Representation of the People Bill
No chapters available yet
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Representation of the People Bill House of Commons
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 3
Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin? Aye. Lloyd Tassins?
No. Sejan Joseph? No. Laura Kirk Smith? No.
Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray? You're on. Sam Rushworth?
No. Davidson? Pupstein. Steve Yen.
Speaker 1
The ayes were two and the nos were 10. So the nos have it, the nos have it. We now come to new clause 17, which has already been debated. Do you wish to move new clause 17 formally? I do, sir.
Speaker 1
My question is that new clause 17 be read a second time as many as are of that opinion. Say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. No.
Speaker 3
Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray? No. Sam Rushworth?
No. David Simmons? Abstent. Steve Yem? No.
Speaker 1
The eyes were two and the nose were 10, the nose have it. Does anyone wish to move new clause 18? And does anyone wish to move new clause 19? The question is that new clause 19 be added to the bill be read a second time. As many as are that opinion, say aye.
Aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Alex Baker? No. Eddie Chowns? Aye. David Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin?
Speaker 3
Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray? No. Sam Rushworth?
No. David Simmons? No. Steve M? No.
Speaker 1
The eyes were two and the nose were 12, so the nose habit, the nose habit. We now come to new clause 20, which I understand was debated previously with new clause four. Would you like to move new clause four? We come to group 46, new clauses twenty two and twenty three. We now come to group 46, new clauses 22 with which it will be convenient to consider amendment 23.
New clause 22 was tabled by Emily Darlington, who is not on the committee. Does anyone wish to move it?
Speaker 6
pleasure to turn around your chairship. I'll just briefly move this because I do think it's an important amendment, and it has clearly garnered support from a large number of government MPs. If you don't know, the second signatory is the chair of the member for Newcastle, Newcastle of the time, West And Central, I think, and the chair of the Select Committee on Science, Innovation, and Technology. And so this this is quite a reasonable amendment, it seems to me. Just simply requires the electoral commission to publish a report setting out their assessment of the risk of electoral online harms.
And as we have already discussed during the course of this committee, there is clear evidence of, electoral online harms. And so I do think it would be useful, to, you know, request the electoral commission to produce such a report to set this all out clearly and indeed to set out the measures that they intend to take to address it. I am I'm not gonna push it to a vote. I'm open as to whether, you know, this necessarily needs to be in statute or simply in guidance from the government, but I do think it's it's an important element of improving the safeguards against online online harms in relation to our electoral system. Look forward to card.
Missus response. Thank you, sir. And
Speaker 8
I would just wish want to thank my honorable friend for her comments, and I just really want to add to it to say that this is an area where we've seen over the last couple of elections, nineteen twenty twenty four, and we're going to see it again in the local and national elections, that our regulatory framework is not keeping pace. And there's no electoral framework as far as I'm aware, and I'd I'd love to hear from the minister on this For the for anyone to really map systematically map the risks that are posed by by deepfake and associated online issues, voters deserve to make free informed choices not tainted by some of the things that are seen online, and I hope that the government will take this forward.
Speaker 5
Minister. Thank you, sir Devlin. It's a pleasure to serve on being chairmanship. The government does not believe this amendment is the right or effective way to address these concerns, while we do acknowledge the seriousness of the issue our honorable friend is raising. The amendment would risk blurring regulatory boundaries between two rightly independent regulators, the Electoral Commission and Ofcom, have distinctly separate roles, statutory roles, with Ofcom responsible for regulation and enforcement of online safety duties on services.
Requiring the Electoral Commission to make proposals for amending the Online Safety Act would cut across that and risk duplication in an area where clarity is essential. Secondly, the Electoral Commission already has the power under Section six of Propera to produce and publish reports on matters relating to elections where it considers this appropriate. We therefore do not consider it necessary or proportionate to mandate a further statutory report. I'd also note the risk of duplication with the recent speakers' conference report which examined these issues and included evidence from the electoral commission. The Government welcomed the conference's findings and our response was published on the March 5.
Under the Act, Ofcom is the independent regulator responsible for overseeing a risk based framework, including publishing codes of practice and requiring the largest services to provide transparency reports about their systems and processes for addressing online harms. That framework provides an appropriate basis for regulatory oversight and platform accountability. The Online Safety Act also places clear duty on services that host user generated content to tackle illegal content online, including illegal abuse, threats and incitement to violence. Ofcom is now implementing and enforcing that framework and the government will work closely with Ofcom, the electoral commission and law enforcement through existing arrangements for these reasons. I ask my friend, honorable friend, to withdraw their amendment.
Speaker 6
I stated, probing amendment withdrawn. Moving it probingly. Yes. Speaking to it probingly.
Speaker 1
Repository of digital Repository of digital political advertising. The question is that new clause 24 be read a second time as many of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray? No. Sam Rushworth?
No. David Simmons? Aye. Steve Yen? No.
Speaker 1
The ayes were four and the rows were 10, so the noes have it. The noes have it. Does anyone wish to move new clause 25? Not. We now come to new clause twenty seven and twenty new clause 26.
Now come. Groups 47, new clause 26, a new which was debate, which is tabled by Emily Darlington. Does anyone wish to move it? Dean.
Speaker 6
Thank you, sir Desmond. Thank you. This new clause would require the government to establish and publish a transparent protocol for responding to election information incidents and place that protocol on a statutory footing. And I do think this is important because there's currently no clear, you know, publicly accountable mechanism for in in The UK for informing voters about serious information incidents during election periods, such as, for example, coordinated disinformation campaigns or foreign interference. And while there may be internal processes, you know, under the radar within government, they're not transparent.
They lack clear triggers for action, and they're not subject to democratic oversight. And so I think their absence creates uncertainty about how and when the public would be notified if there were to be such an attack or a threat to the integrity of an election. And this potentially undermines trust and leaves voters without without information and and potentially exposed to unchallenged misinformation at critical moments during an election. And I I think we can all recognize this is a growing growing threat. So this amendment would address that gap.
It would establish a kind of, you know, a a clear publicly accessible protocol that would set out how and why and when election information and few incidents would be identified, would be assessed and communicated to the general public. And, you know, we have seen with the rise of disinformation, coordinated online campaigns, the use of bot campaigns and so forth, it can spread very rapidly during election periods. It can influence public perception before corrective action is taken. And without naming particular electoral processes. I think we can all call to mind examples.
And it is a problem that we do currently lack as transparent framework for dealing with public notification when such incidents occur. And other democracies have taken steps on this. For example, most notably Canada has already introduced a formal mechanism to respond to these risks, and this does highlight the gap in The UK. So I do think we should be looking at international best practice. In relation to this, I do think that we should be trying to, you know, stay ahead of or at least catch up with the threats that that our democracy is facing, you know, as fast as possible.
And it does seem to be very clearly directly related to this this bill. So I would really welcome hearing from the minister and her response to this. I will clarify for the sake of the house at this point. I'm not intending to move this to a vote, but I'm raising it because I do think having been tabled by I should have mentioned the honorable member for Milton Keynes. It does raise an important issue that's crucial to the safety of our elections.
Thank you.
Speaker 5
mister Desmond. These are important issues, and I acknowledge the honorable member for raising them. I described earlier today in committee the work of the joint election security and preparedness unit, GEF, which is exists as an enduring function to protect our elections and our democracy. This also includes monitoring for miss and disinformation. The JESP election cell brings together Whitehall department departments, law enforcement and intelligence agencies, as well as key stakeholders to agree monitoring thresholds and response options where necessary.
Speaker 3
DSID is a core member of JESP's election cell, as is the electoral commission. At this stage, the government has no plans to introduce critical incident protocol for the purpose of responding to incidents that represent a significant threat to the integrity and security of and public confidence in elections. Any gains in public confidence and informed debate achieved through greater transparency on how the government responds to information incidents must be balanced with national security concerns. Broad knowledge about internal protocols, escalation thresholds, command structures or the bodies involved in responding to threats to the integrity of our electoral processes, through information threats, could expose or enable insights into The UK's security posture, capabilities, and response mechanisms. This could assist hostile actors in identifying vulnerabilities or understanding how the government would react in specific scenarios, thereby creating a real possibility of undermining national security and muting the effectiveness of our response, which I'm absolutely certain is not the intention of the Honourable Member for Milton Keynes.
Speaker 5
Where we judge that the public should be informed, will take clear action to do so. The work of Jess and the wider government response, law enforcement and intelligence agencies, as well as the Electoral Commission make sure and will continue to make sure that elections in this country remain free, fair, and secure.
Speaker 1
Is it the only committee that new clause 26 be withdrawn? By leave withdrawn. We now come to new clauses twenty seven and twenty eight, which have already been debated with clause 63 stand apart. Clauses 27 new clauses twenty seven and twenty eight were tabled by Emily Darlington, who is not a member of this committee. Does anyone wish to table them on her behalf to move them on her behalf?
No. We now come to new clause 29, which has been which has not been debated and was tabled by Manuela Patella, who is not a member on the of the committee. Does anyone wish to move it? New group 48. New clause we now come to group 48.
New clause 30, which will it will be convenient to consider new clause 54, new clause 58, new clause 65. New clause 30 was tabled by Manuela Pagela, who is not on the committee. Does anyone wish to move that?
Speaker 8
I do, sir Desmond. Thank you, sir Desmond. Thank you. Thank Desmond. You, This new clause in the name of my honorable friend, the member for Stratford Upon Avon, goes to the heart of a very basic question, who does our democracy serve, voters or those with the deepest pockets?
And the new clause would introduce a cap on political donations from any one individual or entity each year with that cap set following independent review and approved by parliament. And it would also ensure that the level is kept under regular review so it remains appropriate over time. At present, there is no upper limit on political donations in The UK, and that is a striking gap in our system. It allows vast sums to be given by a single donor, creating the risk of dis disproportionate influence by an individual. Already too many people across The UK look at our politics and see a system that appears to be tilted towards those with wealth and access.
They question whether decisions are made in the public interest or in the interests of those who can afford to make the largest contributions. That is unsustainable, and it undermines our democracy. And my honorable friend wishes to be clear. This is not about stopping people from supporting political parties. It is about drawing a reasonable line to ensure no individual organization can dominate political funding simply because of the scale of their resources.
There is also a clear issue of integrity and security. While there are rules on permissible donors, there remain loopholes, that allow money to be routed through UK registered companies in complex structures and that creates a real risk of foreign or opaque influence on our politics. A cap wouldn't resolve that problem alone but it would significantly limit the scale of it. This clause seeks to take a careful, balanced approach to the issue. It does not impose an arbitrary figure, requires independent evidence based review to recommend the level of the cap considering economic considerations, democratic participation and political competition.
It places that decision firmly within a transparent and accountable process. Ultimately, elections should be decided by voters persuaded by the strength of arguments, the quality of ideas, and the credibility of leadership. I don't think anyone on this committee would disagree with that. It shouldn't be about the scale of financial backing. If we allow money to operate without meaningful limits, we undermine the fundamental democratic principle that every voice should carry equal weight.
So, I will not be, pushing this one to a vote, sir Desmond, but I would like to, hear the minister's thoughts on that amendment. And with your permission, sir Desmond, I would like to speak to my honorable friend, the member for Hazel Grove's amendment. New clause 54. Thank you. We've established here in this committee that, unfortunately, public trust in political funding and in democracy itself sometimes is at a very low point.
Donations of millions to a handful of wealthy individuals, spending wars between parties, loopholes that undermine the spirit of the rules. There is a public perception that politics can be bought and elections can be won through the donations of a few. And I think all of us would agree that is not a place where we want to be. This amendment, calls for a royal commission to look at the evidence properly and make recommendation. This allows for level independence and cross party process.
The current system allows single donors to give millions to a party, which raises legitimate questions about whose interests are being served. There are limited financial provisions on long campaigns. Significant money is spent well before the official period begins, the limits don't catch it. We, as liberal democrats, have long called for greater transparency in political spending, real time disclosure with donations, and a cap on political donations. And annual expenditure limits sit squarely within that agenda.
Thank you, sir
Speaker 1
Capital political donations. The question is that new clause 30 be read a second time, doctor Ellie Chance.
Speaker 6
Thank you very much, sir Desmond. And with your permission, I'll, speak in response to new clause 30 tabled by the member for Strathfield and Avon. New clause 54 table by the member for Hazel Grove, both of which deal with the very important topic of the cap and donations. And we'll then go on to speak to my amendment in relation to limits on campaign expenditure, and that that's been tabled in the name of the member for Oxford East also in relation to campaign limits on campaign expenditure because these two topics are indeed closely related. And first of all, to take the the topic of the case for limits on a cap on political donations, and as the honorable member has just set out, this case is, I think, very strong and to some extent has been recognized by the government in the measures that they to take forward in relation to right profit in return in relation to instituting a cap on donations from British citizens living abroad.
And specifically though about the broad the the the the the question of donations from all British any any British voter. You know, overall, this this issue of the the total amount of donations and the number of very large donations has really significantly increased over time. And the extent to which parties political parties, some in particular, are reliant on funds contributed by a small handful of very wealthy donors is widely recognized by the public and a cause of concern to a large majority, of the public too. Rightly so because as the public understand, this carries the risk that, individuals with very deep pockets can potentially have a disproportionate influence, on our politics. Now back in 2011, the committee, on standards in public life produced a report addressing precisely, this risk, the problem of increased reliance on significant donations, and they recommended a donations cap.
This was fifteen years ago. The problem has only become more and more significant since then as we have seen with just in the last less than a year, seven donations in in the many millions of pounds to one to to to one political party. And so this is this is this is clearly, I think, a problem and a risk to our politics. And it's a it's a risk that has been recognized worldwide. As I understand it, about half of global countries and, well over two thirds of European countries, impose some sort of limits on donations.
And and indeed, The UK, was one of, I think, 22 signatories to a UN resolution in December 2025, that identified the, risk of corruption in politics from large donations and called for countries to consider instituting a cap on donations. It would only be, consistent with our signatory our signature to that UN resolution for us to actually take action on this ourselves. Now Philip Wythoff, if you'll allow me to quote directly from his report on page 29, identified this problem too. He talked about his worries that the the the the the lack of spending the lack of year round spending limits on campaign expenditure plus the lack of limit limit limits on donations can lead to an arms race between parties and political actors to out raise and outspend their competitors. And although he felt that this issue fell beyond his remit, he did, point out that, this is something that could, in his word, be usefully debated during the passage of the representation of the people bill.
So I'm very glad that a number of colleagues have tabled amendments in relation to this to allow us to discuss it and to hear from the government. And this is widely supported by a large number of individuals and organizations who submitted evidence to the committee, the electoral reform society, Transparency International, light on Corruption, Open Britain, a whole range of others, and indeed a number of academics who specialize in this in this area. Sam Power, who gave evidence to us, Alan Renick, and and and a number of others. And as Transparency International points out, other comparable democracies have sought to curb the corrosive influence of big money in politics by setting donation caps. Canada caps donations to political parties at 1,750 annually.
France caps donations to political parties at €7,500 annually and 4,500 for presidential campaigns. Italy's cap is a €100,000. Australia has introduced 50,000 Australian dollar caps per donor per year due to apply from July year. This has been recommended by, as I've said, the Committee on Standards and Public Life. The Hayden Phillips review is supported by a majority of voters.
And YouGov polling published in December 2025 showed that 67% of UK vote voters say there should be a cap of £50,000 or less or indeed no private donations at all. Some people feel the system should be dealt with like that. Now I I I I will briefly preempt a point that I suspect the minister is going to raise in, in her response about, the fact that some other countries have, greater have greater degrees of state funding, of politics. But I think that, it's, you know, arguably, a balance has to be struck. My case is not that there should be no no ability for voters to contribute to politics.
Arguably, that's an important part of the democratic process. But the problem is that in a in a democracy in which, by definition, one person has one vote, the problem is that money can buy huge amounts of influence that outweigh and indeed hugely influence many of those votes. And if a party has received many millions of pounds just in the last six months, it is not surprising that they will have a capacity to spend that in the nonregulated period in a way that is highly likely to influence voting. So I think that there's a very, very strong case for introducing some sort of annual donation cap. Now Transparency International advocates for that being £50,000 a year.
The CSPL, I believe, advocated for £10,000 a year. That was back sixteen years ago. If you multiply that by inflation, that's about £15,000 a year now. Others have talked about a £100,000 a year. That would, of course, bring it in line with the system that the government has already committed to putting in place in relation to donations from British British voters overseas.
There is clearly a problem of the distortion of our political system caused by the influence of big money, big donations in politics, and I think we have an a crucially important opportunity through the passage of this bill to take action to address it. Many of the other issues that we've that we've talked about here, company donations, influence of foreign money, and crypto donations, I I I have repeatedly drawn the connection with the need for a cap on all political donations because these things cannot be completely divorced, and we will not be able to address the the issues that concern us in relation to distortion, the distorting effect of money on on our politics if we do not implement a cap on political donations. So I very much look forward to hearing from the minister on that. And in relation to the the question turning now to the question of setting expenditure limits. First of all, my amendment, would require the electoral commission to conduct a review within six months of the passage of the bill into making campaign spending limit applied annually rather than just in, the weeks and months before an election.
And for this to be done in consultation with the speakers' commission, and the ethics and integrity, commission, the the amendment asked the electoral commission to consider fairness of elections, the risk of foreign interference, and how to make any measures proportionate. I think this is a very, you know, a very gently drafted amendment. It's not committing the government to doing something really harsh now, but it it's recognizing that this problem of the complete absence of spending limits year round ignores effectively the fact that election campaigning happens year round. Political campaigning happens year round. The influence of voters happens year round.
Now I've I've I've seen specific examples of political parties gaming the system of the restrictions on campaign spending during the regulated period by spending shed loads of money just in the week beforehand, But this isn't the only problem that we face. We also face, and this is why it's important to talk about it in relation to the cap on donations, a situation where you can have an individual gives £9,000,000, another individual gives 4 and a half million pounds. That money can be spent and will be spent to influence voters with no restrictions whatsoever on the spending, on on, campaign spending and will inevitably have a huge impact on the voting choices of electors. So I think having recognized that spending influences voter decision making, that is why we have spending limits during the regulated period. I think we do need to recognize it's time to catch up with the reality that politic political campaigning happens year round.
And a number a number of experts have commented on this. So the Joint Commission Committee on National Security Strategy, which has been cited a number of times already in this committee, reported just last month that the risks of foreign financial influence apply to nonelection periods just as much as regulated election periods, perhaps even more so given the lower levels of transparency requirements and public scrutiny. That is their word. It is clear that they agree that this needs to be considered. The Electoral Commission in January told parliament that outside election periods influencing party and government policy is likely to be another attractive target for foreign influence.
And and committee on standards on public life, I've already cited, and the Hayden Phillips review, this is going back some time now, but it just highlights that actually this is not a completely new issue. Campaigning is continuous, it would be logical for the limits on campaign spending to apply on a continuous basis as well. And I think in the last in in the last nineteen years, we have seen a a huge change, particularly through the spread of social media and online campaigning, which makes this particularly particularly vital to deal to deal with. And as I've mentioned, people like Sam Power in in in in evidence to this committee specifically specifically highlighted this. So so I'd like to ask the minister to to consider to to to to recognize that this bill provides a really crucially important opportunity to bring forward limits to campaign expenditure that apply year round, not just in the regulated period.
And then finally, to move on to the amendment that has been tabled by the honorable member for Oxford East, which essentially talks about national limits on campaign expenditure. And and this is essentially proposing to reduce the campaign expenditure limits, were, of course, increased under the elections act 2022. I think as as Philip is here's Philip Rycroft mentioned, this this problem of the arms race between parties spending ever more. Initially, the I the whole idea of setting campaign expenditure limits during the regulated period was to try to to, you know, to encourage parties not to spend too much. But if the limits are high, parties are inevitably going to end up spending if they have the financial capacity right up to right up to the limit.
So I think these together, these proposals for a cap on donations and a limit on expenditure lower limits on expenditure and for limits to apply year round. We're at the very least for the electoral commission to do a review on this as per my my new clause, would be really critical safeguards for our democracy and go some way to recognizing the reality that big money has a huge and damaging, distorting, and antidemocratic effect on our politics economy. Thank
Speaker 5
you, sir Desmond. When n c thirty seeks to place a cap on the amount a person can donate to registered political parties in a calendar year. The government aims to strike the right balance in terms of political donations to protect against foreign interference and improve transparency while also ensuring legitimate donors can continue to fund electoral campaigning. This amendment goes a step too far in restricting legitimate donations and could significantly limit party's ability to raise sufficient funds to communicate their views to the electorate, an essential part of a healthy democracy and effective election process.
Speaker 5
I I would like to press on if you don't mind, if if that's okay. You will be able to sum up later, I assume. To better protect against those who seek to covertly undermine UK elections, we are instead strengthening rules, closing loopholes at all stages in the political donations process, I've described the measures in some detail earlier today: Know Your Donor, the three steps for foreign companies and also the consideration that we're giving to the Right Profit Review. A cap is not being placed across all donations because currently the majority of funding for political parties in The UK comes from private, corporate or other organisational sources. State funding accounts for around 10% of the total income of UK political parties.
There is no public or political appetite to increase the level of state funding. I'd urge the honourable members of this committee to reject this amendment. Amendment NC 54 proposes that the Secretary of State shares plans for establishing a Royal Commission, which would consider the effectiveness and merits of political expenditure and, in particular, a cap on political donations. A public inquiry is an extremely costly and lengthy process. Instead, we've already sought to ensure our democracy is strengthened by considering recommendations by authorities and expert bodies in this area, including the Electoral Commission, the Committee on Standards in Public Life and the National Prime Agency.
These risks and recommended solutions were taken forward and set out in our Strategy for Modern and Secure Elections published on the July 17. Those commitments are now set out in full in this bill, and to ensure no stone was left unturned, the Secretary of State commissioned the independent Rycroft review to see where we could strengthen our laws and to see what could be recommended to protect against covert funding and foreign interference. I therefore hope that the Honourable Member will withdraw her amendment. I now turn to NC 58. The purpose of this amendment is to require the Electoral Commission to conduct a review on the feasibility of a cap on annual expenditure by political parties, candidates, or third parties, and then for the government to issue a response which must contain proposals informed by that review.
The government agrees transparency and fairness are vital principles to be upheld in elections. Further, it's of the utmost importance to limit risk of foreign interference. We're committed to ensuring we have robust systems to protect The UK from foreign interference, and this bill reinforces electoral legislation against foreign interference. The honourable member's commitment to ensuring fairness and transparency in elections has been clear throughout the parliamentary process, and I share this commitment. The government will note notes the recommendations of the Rycroft review and will respond in due course to those measures.
Amendment NC65 would substantially cut national spending limits for political parties and would, for the first time, bring most campaign staff costs within scope. National spending limits were intended to strike a careful balance, allowing parties to communicate effectively with voters across the country while preventing money from dominating elections. In practice, parties generally campaign within the cap, which operates as a ceiling rather than a target. These limits were set by Parliament in 2000 and have been upgraded over time to maintain their real world value. Periodic uprating helps avoid eroding parties' ability to communicate effectively with the electorate, which would otherwise cut across the original policy intent Parliament improved.
The proposal to include campaign staff costs would represent a significant change to the regulatory framework, introducing additional complexity in how parties define roles and apportion costs. There's not clear evidence of a problem with this arrangement currently. The Government notes the issues raised about the level of spending limits, including those highlighted by the independent Rycroft review, and as members know, we're considering those very carefully and will respond in due course. On that basis, and to allow that work to be completed first, I invite my hon. Fem to withdraw her amendment.
Thank you, Mr. Desmond.
Speaker 6
I do. Thank you very much, sir sir Desmond. And, the the minister just just three quick points. You know, the minister implied that any limit on donations is unacceptable to her. And to me, that seems to be a very extreme position for the government to take.
I'd like to check, is that really the government's position in responding to n c 30 from the the member from Stratford On Avon? She she seemed to be taking that position, and yet that new clause does not specify a a particular level. It specifies that a cap should be set after a review, which is regular in itself regularly reviewed. That seems to me a very reasonable approach to take. So does she not recognize at all the the even the theoretical possibility that large donations can skew our politics?
I would find that quite an extraordinary position for for the government to take, to be honest. The second point is that this seems to be completely inconsistent, I'm afraid, with the fact that last year The UK and at least 59 other countries co sponsored a resolution passed at the conference of states parties to the UN convention against corruption that calls on states parties to, and I quote, consider limitations on donations with a view to combating corruption. The government has already recognized that large donations into the political system carry a risk of corruption. And so in order to be consistent, would the government, please come I don't expect her to put a number on the table today. But would the would the minister, please take this away for consideration alongside the other issues that have come out of Rycroft.
I think it is clear through this committee process that we need amendments to come forward that are not just driven by Rycroft, but also driven by some of the issues that Rycroft himself has highlighted as relevant yet out with the specific terms of reference of his report. Certainly, caps on political donations, expansion of the regulated period, and I would also say reform of political advertising is in that subset as well. And then thirdly, just to respond to the point that the governor I did try to preempt, but the minister did come back with it as well, the point around, the fact that politics in The UK is largely funded through private, company and trade union donations. Absolutely. And I'm not I have not, at any point, arguing argued for more state funding of politics.
That could be a separate debate, but I am not arguing that. By discussing the arguments in favor of a cap on donations together with the arguments for stronger limits on expenditure, I'm arguing for a politics in which money skews politics less overall. Now we can surely recognize that if one person can contribute, say, for the sake of argument, £9,000,000 to an organization, a political actor, then that will inevitably have a hugely skewing impact on our politics. Does the government really not recognize that? Will the government really not take any steps to limit political donations and that skewing and pollution of our politics?
Speaker 2
When Zoe Franklin moved new clause 30, she indicated she did not wish to press it to a division. My understanding from listening to the other speeches is that is not a universal view. Is it the will of the committee that new clause 30 be withdrawn? I leave withdrawn. We now come to group 49, a new clause 31, with which it would be convenient to consider new clause 34, new clause 35.
Speaker 8
Thank you, sir Bessemer. My new clause 31 requires the secretary of state to use regulations to ensure the electoral commission establishes a fund to help disabled candidates meet additional disability related campaign costs in England. Historically, in England, the access to elected office fund and the enable fund provided funding for practical support and reasonable adjustments to remove barriers for disabled candidates who are standing for election. That could include help with communication, transport, or personal assistance, not general campaign costs. The interim Enable fund of 250,000 was launched in 2018, involved a two stage application process approval process with an independent panel of experts on disability as well as the political groups of the local government association.
In total, 41 candidates were awarded funding, and of those who received funding, 45% were elected. In the Scottish twenty twenty twenty two local elections, 46 people got support from a similar fund that's available in Scotland. Of those, 22 were elected. I would suggest based on these numbers that the funds put these types of funds providing support make a tangible difference. However, the English fund was discontinued in 2020.
And as yet, although I understand that the government has indicated that it it would wish to do something on this issue, it has not yet been reinstated or an alternative option put forward. As a result, this leaves a distinct inequality between the different nations of England because Wales and Scotland both have funded schemes. England does not. Representation in politics is crucial, whether it is here in parliament or in our council chambers across the country. The House of Commons Library estimates that twenty five percent of The UK population is disabled, with twenty four percent of working adults stating that they are disabled.
A truly representative parliamentary house would have a 156 MPs indicating that they have a disability, yet only twelve declare themselves having a disability. That's less than two percent of parliament. According to the local government association, in their census in 2022, approximately fifteen percent of local authority councillors in England declared a disability or a long term condition. So essentially what we have is consistently we are not returning a set of councillors or MPs that is truly representative of the people that we seek to serve. This is, in my view, a wrong that needs to be corrected, and establishing a new fund in England to provide the support is absolutely crucial.
It is also a change that is supported by elect Her, Centennial Action, the Joe Cox Foundation, Unlock Democracy, the Faucet Society, Disability Policy Center, and others. And I believe that this bill is the opportunity to right this wrong. And I would welcome to hear welcome hearing from the minister whether she agrees with this amendment, and I do hope that she will. But if she does not, will she outline how the government is planning to support candidates with disabilities and address this glaring disparity between the nations? Because we really must do better when it comes to representation of people with disabilities in our politics.
Thank you, sir Desmond. Oh, forgive me, Desmond. I have forgotten my other amendments, and I appreciate why our colleagues may wish to move on. I think they are very important amendments, and they continue on the theme of actually ensuring that our democracy is truly representative of the people we serve. So turning to new clause 34, this would require the secretary of state to, within three months of real assent, bring new bring section one zero six of the Equality Act 2010 into force.
A new clause 35 would then place a duty in preparer, the political parties, elections, and referendum act 20 2,000,
Speaker 8
the main law governing political parties, finance donations, etcetera, and require the electoral commission to publish the information in accessible form. It would also give ministers the power to require, registered political parties to publish anonymized information about the diversity of people coming forward as candidates. For example, information about protected characteristics among applicants, selected candidates and elected candidates. This duty applies only so far as it is possible to publish characteristics, of course, while retaining the privacy of the people it is referencing. For a long time, we have as a nation talked about ensuring that this information was made available.
In March 2026, the parliamentary's undersecretary for equality stated the government is committed to in commencing the Equality Act twenty ten's revision requiring registered political parties to publish anonymized data relating to diversity of their candidate selections. We are currently exploring when and how to commence the provision under section 106. We'll provide an update in due course. It was then repeated again in the House of Lords. That statement took place a while ago, and as yet, we have not seen any movement.
And I personally again feel that this bill is the opportunity to enact this section of the Equalities Act. So I would like to hear from the minister whether she supports the amendment and whether or if she does not, when will the government bring into force section one zero six of the Equalities Act? Thank you, sir Desmond.
Speaker 6
Thank you, sir Desmond. I'd speak very briefly in support of the three amendments tabled by the member for Guildford. I think they highlight really important issues. It does seem extraordinary, really, that we have such inequality between England and Wales and Scotland in relation to support for disabled candidates. And clearly, with such huge levels of underrepresentation of disabled people in our politics, it's imperative that there is support put in place to try to rectify that.
So I I fully support the call for reinstatement of the Access to Office Fund.
Speaker 7
Oh, yeah. Thank you. So, Edith, my I'm grateful be on member for giving giving away. Appreciate the main focus of these amendments has been around disability. I know I was proud of the work that my party did in government to try and improve the diversity of candidates that were standing, in particular in local elections.
I'd ask the Honourable whether she's given consideration to the broader concept of diversity in terms of candidates because we know disability can present some quite specific challenges, but one of the issues for political parties is engaging those much wider communities from whom sometimes very few people feel willing to put themselves forward as candidates. Do you have a a view about that that she'd like to share with the committee?
Speaker 6
I thank the honorable member. I absolutely do. And indeed, that is what the next two amendments are specifically in relation to. I think this is clearly the next step that we should be taking. I mean, it was put in place in the Equality Act.
It's just about commencing a provision that is already there under section one zero six, which would apply to reporting on diversity with a range of protected characteristics, not just in relation to disability. And I I completely agree. Our politics should be representative of our population as a whole. We should all be challenging ourselves constantly, as individuals, as parties, to ensure that we're doing everything possible to to address underrepresentation of certain groups. I mean, it's you know, the the lack of representation of women is a is is particularly kind of brought into focus by the fact that it's nearly a hundred years now until, you know, the franchise was fully extended.
And yet and yet we are still women are still underrepresented, seriously underrepresented in this house still and even more underrepresented in local politics nationally. But there are many other dimensions of dimensions of underrepresentation. So I do think that, whereas, the First Amendment relates specifically to support for disabled candidates, the second two amendments, relate to that much wider spectrum, and that is crucially important. Thank you.
Speaker 5
you, sir Desmond. New clause 31 would require the electoral commission to establish a fund to provide financial assistance to disabled candidates standing for election in England. It is the Government's ambition to see more disabled people in public office, and we know that some disabled people still face additional financial barriers when contesting elected office. To address this, we're currently developing a new fund to support disabled election candidates with the disability related extra costs they can experience to enable participation on an equal basis. We've put the lived experience of disabled people and lessons learned from previous funds at the heart of our work to develop the new fund.
We've engaged with a wide range of stakeholders, including MPs and disabled local councillors. We've heard how ensuring ongoing support is important to provide the reassurance people need to plan for the long term as it can take a number of attempts to get elected. The government's able to provide this type of support without this amendment as it has done in the past with the access to elected office fund from 2012 to 2015 and the Enable Fund from 2018 to 2020. As part of our work to develop the new fund, we're considering how design elements might better support longevity, retaining the flexibility needed to ensure the fund provided is fit for purpose. Given the ongoing work the Government is already doing in this area to establish a Fund, I would gently ask if the Member could withdraw the amendment.
I'll now turn to new Clause 34. The Government's committed to improving better representation in politics. We encourage increased diversity in government and political candidates and have taken action to address this. Section 106 of the Equality Act 2010 is an uncommenced provision which would require registered political parties to publish unanonymised data relating to the diversity of their candidate selections in accordance with regulations. The Government is committed to commencing Section 106 of the Equality Act 2010.
However, careful consideration needs to be given to how this might be implemented, the supporting regulations, and whether any phasing might be needed in implementation. Officials will consult the stakeholders, including political parties, in due course.
Speaker 7
for way. Clearly, one of the issues that this creates is that if we're seeking to establish the accessibility of politics to candidates from a diverse range of backgrounds. We need to know not just who are those candidates who make it through to be selected and then nominated as the candidates, but also the broader range of the public from whom those candidates may be drawn. It's fairly standard in terms of the quality's impact to understand from that data who it is that's not making it through that process. Has she given any consideration to how that particular concern might be addressed beyond simply gathering the data, which may not tell us who has felt that they simply were not able to make it through that process because of its nature to get to the point of being nominated as a candidate in the elections which are covered specifically by section 106.
Speaker 5
I think the Honourable Gentleman has highlighted exactly why further consultation is needed. This is a complex issue that needs to be discussed with all of the major and minor political parties to explore how candidates are coming forward, how they are encouraged to come forward and the ways in which we can support political parties to become more diverse. I hope he'll accept that as a response. Turning to new clause 35, the Government really is committed to better representation, and we've taken action to address this through a variety of different ways. As I've mentioned, Section 106 is uncommenced, and we're committed to commencing it with careful consideration and at the appropriate time.
I therefore ask that the Committee reject the discussed amendments as they are already in progress.
Speaker 6
If I may,
sir Desmond, I just very briefly want to come back to the minister on I hear what you're saying, and I am really pleased that this something that the government is undertaking. What concerns me is that we are going through we are going through sets of elections again and again and again without that consistency across the nations where some in our nation are supported stand to ensure we have a more representative democracy, and others here in England do not have that. So, I am willing to withdraw my amendment. However, I would appreciate it if, the minister would commit to sharing, firstly, a timeline, but also more I think more importantly, committing to make information more available to publicly and certainly to organizations working within this space and MPs about what is being what is happening in relation to a fund to support candidates with disabilities. And the same applies to the my my amendments in relation to s one zero six of the Equalities Act.
Speaker 8
Because I really do think at the moment, one of the reasons this this amendment had to be submitted is because, actually, while the government has said things on the public record, they have then not shared what is happening, going foot what is happening behind the scenes, and it is a matter of public interest. I will not press any of those, of my amendments to a vote, but I would appreciate if the minister would come back on those queries.
Speaker 5
write to the honourable member and provide, as much information as I can at this time.
Speaker 1
lead withdrawn. We now come to new clause forty thirty two which it which was already debated with clause 60. It was tabled by Duncan Jordan. We now come to group 50 and new clause 33. I call Lisa Smart to move clause 33.
Jury frank Zooey Frank, you need.
Speaker 8
Thank you, sir Desmond. I'm grateful to allow you allow me to to table this, to speak on this amendment by my colleague, the honorable member for Hazel Grove. So as has come up repeatedly in this committee, trust in elections is in a very difficult place at the moment. And we really need to consider as MPs how we can address that luck lack of confidence the public have in our political system. Also, frankly, the voting system is used that is used and where the results feel representative.
While we continue to face a flood of foreign money and powerful actors working to undermine our social fabric and interfere in public life, we must make sure we're actually improving the public's confidence in face of those threats. The requirement to consult the devolved government is essential as this law would apply across all four nations, and trust deficits are not uniform. Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland must have a voice in assessing the impact within devolved elections. This bill is already taking very welcome steps to modernize elections, and we could have the opportunity to do further reform. One of the most powerful causes of disillusionment within politics is the sense that people's votes just don't count.
You can turn up on polling today, and your voice simply disappears into a system, that does not reflect it. We believe that any serious review of representatives has to grapple with that, and any bill that is looking to a formal election should be considering how to both change its reception and change the voting system to best reflect what stroke who people are actually voting for. This bill presents an opportunity for the government, but it I we believe that it government is only grasping it in part. We need to recognize that the threat is real. It is urgent.
The misinformation, power concentrated in the hands of too few, all of this is undermining public trust, and my honorable members amendment new clause seeks to address that. I look forward to hearing the minister's comments.
Speaker 10
Thank you, mister Desmond. And I'd like to rise today to speak against new clause 33. And we will contend that this is a overly restrictive amendment tabled in this committee. While the honorable member for Hazelgrove and Guildford for moving the the the amendment, frames the measures as a shield for democracy, they are in reality, I would argue, a recipe for bureaucratic paralysis and a dangerous encroachment on the natural administration of our elections. And, sir Desmond, firstly, may I refer to, the reporting mandate mechanism in proposed new clause 33.
It demands that the secretary of state publish a report and on, and I quote, trust in elections just within 12 months. And this is this is a purely subjective academic, exercise masquerading as policy. Trust is not a metric that we can legislate into existence. It is a subjective measure, and by forcing the government to constantly review public confidence, we are effectively inviting the secretary of state or ministers to visit politicize the very foundations foundations of of our our voting system. Now that may be the intention of the honorable, lady, but I would contend that this is just another mechanism for parties who currently disagree with our voting system to carpenter about it every year.
And I would just say to the Liberal Democrats and to other parties, that have who want might want this to go ahead, we have tested public opinion on new voting mechanisms, and it should be, as I've said in other bills, it should be for the government of the day to be able to put forward changes to the voting system and changes to, electoral law in this country. Secondly, Secondly, it mandates consultation with ministers across all devolved nations and the electoral commission before a report can even be published. And while I respect our devolved partners, I I do, we have to accept that in at least two jurisdictions, there is it is that it is that government's policy to have different voting systems. In fact, we have different voting systems within those devout administrations. So it seems to me like this is a veto by committee structure that the honorable lady is trying to propose.
And, actually, if we look at trying to measure that trust in politics, many other first ministers or governments that will be putting forward will each be putting different, you know, forward different views as to whether, trust has been measured. Well, how do you measure trust? You can poll. You can poll local election, outcomes. You can poll national action.
I'll give way to the minister.
Speaker 5
Thank you to him very much. Would you not agree that voting is an act of trust?
Speaker 10
Well, the minister is absolutely right. I am a democrat. I believe that everyone that is sitting in this room who has the backing of their constituents, okay, not by a margin that the Liberal Democrats or Greens or any other party might favor because they want to change the voting system. Each and every member of this committee won more votes than all of their competitors. That is an act of trust.
It is an act of trust where our constituents elected us under the system that was provided to them. That is the greatest measure of trust, sir Desmond, that can be portrayed in a result by securing the number of votes that you get in winning that election under the guidelines. And I just think that we are entering a slight Pandora's box and actually may I just say, cloud cuckoo land. If we get to a stage where the the this parliament is mandating to measure public trust. There are organizations that do that.
We have polling companies. We have too many polling, companies in my view and too many opinion polls at the moment, and that's not just because we're not in front at the moment. But I do think that in order to have on the statute book an impact of the act in trust on elections is something that I I really find difficult to to to support. And I will give way. Yes.
Speaker 5
Is my I beg my old friend for giving way. Does he note as I do that the international gold standard for the conduct of elections is set by the Venice Commission which is a group of academics, people with political experience from countries across the democratic world that meet with a view to considering measures including voter identification, the conduct of polls, transparency of electoral material, all those different different matters. And that when I asked the Secretary of State about the input that they'd acquired from the various commission or whether they considered its latest reports, what was clear is the Secretary of State hadn't even heard of the various commission, that that is an example of something which would, to a degree, undermine trust and confidence in elections. But also, as he's setting out in any poll of this nature, it depends very much on who asked the question, how they asked the question, and of whom they asked the question. And Given that this simply cannot set that out in statute, it does not add value to the contents of this bill.
Speaker 10
I agree with my honourable friend in terms of adding value I honestly believe that this amendment forgive me, doesn't had add any value because actually, I think it does the reverse, which is when a report within twelve months of Parsonage Act is published, I actually think it could be a greater tool to reduce trust in politics because trust is subjective. We all have different opinions. And when, the secretary of state, after twelve months reports on on on trust in elections after a democratic mandate, or maybe a general election, or maybe a local election, but let's say, twelve months, let's say this, act passes and this new clause was put in and there was a next election to which this was supposed to be, reporting on, there are so many different opinions that the fact that the government and the secretary of state is even reporting on these, on these criteria that have been outlined, there are gonna be many people that disagree with the report of the secretary of state, thus undermining trust in a democratic process depending on what side of the coin proportional representation, on first past the post, on the electoral commission, on the way in which parties were funded, on the way in which parties campaigned.
That is the result of a general election that is the ultimate arbiter of whether trusting politics is a good or bad thing. And I just think this is one of the more strange new clauses that we have seen. And I don't say that personally to the honorable lady for, Hazel Grove or Guilford. But we should be rolling back legislation all the way through this bill. The liberal democrats and myself have been calling on, calling on the electoral commission to do more, but we've also called on the electoral commission to have the right, resourcing to be able to under undertake the the mechanisms to which the government and we were calling in in different respects.
This will add more bureaucracy. It will add more reporting, and it will undermine the trust, I would argue, of the electoral system, which is already in a very delicate stage. It I I absolutely accept that it's a very delicate stage, but the minister is absolutely correct. The elections as undertaken, the results of the elections as undertaken by the democratic will of the people of this country are the are the arbiter oh, sorry. Are the results of trust.
There are many organizations that can measure it. I don't think it's up to the government to measure trust. It's up to governments to lose elections if they're not trusted and win them if they are trusted in opposition, and I think that's the way that it should stay. Thank you very
Speaker 5
much, sir Desmond. This bill is about building trust and confidence in our electoral system, and many of the reforms in the bill within a year of re royal assent, which is the timescale, the mover has suggested the report should come, will either not have come into force, may not have had sufficient time to bed in and achieve their aims. Any assessment of impact at that stage could therefore be premature, risk drawing misleading conclusions, and as the Honourable Member for Hamble Valley has so eloquently put it, reduce trust. For these reasons, we do not believe there would be sufficient benefit in drafting and publishing this report. I would, however, like to reassure members that Government is committed to robust monitoring and evaluation of the Bill, and we will anticipate that this will show whether the policies introduced have achieved their aims, including, where relevant, relating to trust.
We earn trust, Sir Desmond, and I reiterate my point that voting is an act of trust, but nonetheless the Government is working hard to bring confidence more confidence to our already trusted electoral system with this bill.
Speaker 1
question is, that new clause 33 be read a I know, but but but but there was a there was a a persistent cry
Speaker 1
The eyes were two and the nose were 12. So the nose have it. The nose have it. We now come to new clauses thirty four and thirty five, which were already debated with new clause 31. Does Zoe Franklin wish to move new clauses thirty four and thirty five?
Speaker 1
You don't? Right. We now come to group 51 and new clause 36, where which it will be convenient to consider amendment 25. I call Paul Holmes to move new clause 36.
Speaker 10
Yes. So, Desmond, thank you very much. And I rise to move new clause 36, namely the act for which the implementation would be, to require the electoral commission to prepare and parliament to approve statutory guidance to returning officers on the enforcement of the ballot secrecy act 2023. And as, I'm sure members of the committee will know, that amendment 25 is consequential, on this new clause. I believe that, the representation of the people bill, as I've said before, is a huge opportunity, in when when when legislation on changing elections comes around so rarely to tighten up the systems that we have.
Engaging we I believe that we should be engaging people in looking at what could be significant bill, and the machinery of elections in a generation. The government has admitted that themselves because they're extending, reducing the age of the franchise, changing how people can register, and they're updating the rules on political finance. And therefore, I think it's absolutely right that when we have a patchwork quilt of interpretation of election, of of of elections being undertaken at polling stations, I believe that it is right that the, government should look to, issue statutory guidance to returning officers on the enforcement of the ballot secrecy act, particularly when it comes to a number of reports of by the family voting in the recent by election, Gauss and Indentum by election, which, of course, there was a police investigation, but still, independent volunteers at polling stations did report concerns over family voting. But also the different interpretations of returning officers and election staff across the country, about some of the things that we see at every general election or every local election. Every party interprets the regulations of which we are governed by differently, at various areas across the thousands of polling stations, in this country.
Election officials often interpret, what is right and what is wrong in different ways. And I will give you an example. Quite often during local elections in my constituency of Hamble Valley, easily liberal democrats are often found setting up a table with a liberal democrat, at tablecloth inside the polling station saying hello to people. At some occasions, I've raised that with someone who's in charge of a polling station, and they get them out quite rightly in my view of the interpretation of the law, and some don't. Now I report that, but that is, I would argue, a breach of the ballot secrecy act.
I think family voting, and we know it exists regardless of whether some people say that it doesn't, that that is a breach of the ballot secrecy act. And I do not think that it is unreasonable to expect an occasion when we get legislation like this that the government has a look at again at whether our ballots polling stations and whether our ballot process ballatory process is working. For example, should we have the case where our ballot where our polling stations now have tables at quarters where people can look over at other people voting? Have we got to the stage where actually we might need to look at an American system where we disguise tables so that people are convinced and are reassured that their votes are cast in secret as they should be under the legislation of this country? Because
Speaker 7
So that's my honorable friend who's making an excellent speech. A consistent theme that emerges from what he's saying and which has emerged from the evidence and the debate in this committee is that we can have all
Speaker 7
but there's a major challenge around the enforcement. Yeah. And in particular, the point which he highlights is around inconsistency. Because there is an element of vagueness in the law, it is left to an individual, clerk to a particular polling station, sometimes with or without good advice from a returning officer or electoral officer, to try and determine what the appropriate course of action is. Hence, in some places, people breaching the rules would be kicked out.
In others, they wouldn't. But does he agree it is essential that we get the detail correct on the face of this legislation in order to bring a greater degree of consistency and therefore trust and confidence to the practice of these elections across the country?
Speaker 10
Well, my honorable friend is absolutely right because at the moment, as I said, and he's acknowledged, is that most of the, running of a polling day at different polling stations and I am specifically using polling stations as the example because that is the most user interaction or, you know, voter interaction that we, have when they cast their ballot and should pleased to do so, that at every polling station, it is interpreted very differently. I gave an example about my constituency. Counts are treated very differently. Polling stations are, are interpreted, very differently. When we look at when it's acceptable, at what distance you should be able to display a poster.
Now I have myself been in situations where we're down one road, they're allowed right up to the door, including in it in some cases by some parties, and in other areas, they're not allowed in the power park at all. That's all on interpretation, and therefore, what we are seeking to do through this new clause is have that uniform guidance, that uniform electoral guidance produced by the electoral commission as the minister has outlined a very independent organization who are being asked to take on more, responsibilities to assess, to approve, and give out statutory guidance to returning officers. Now if we go through the journey of voting at most polling stations, people drive their park there. You know, there are candidates that often wait outside. There are people that are telling, and I believe in telling because it does give interaction with political parties before they cast their votes.
Can any really can any member say in the last election to which they were participating in that there was a uniform code as to whether they saw the same thing at each polling station? I would contest no because those election staff do not have that central guidance to say this is what should happen. This is what not should happen. And quite often, when a lot of candidates report inconsistencies, because there are inconsistencies, evidence and the burden of proof on trying to say that a breach has happened is much harder and much more difficult to prove. Sir Desmond, I honestly believe that with the discussions that we've had this afternoon where each and every political party has wanted to ensure that our democratic process is tightened up, whether that be from foreign interference, whether that be from cryptocurrency donations, whether that is from donations in this country, whether we want new people to be able to vote, whether we want those people to be able to give ID to vote.
All of this is contained within this legislation. Therefore, I rarely do press.
Speaker 7
to appoint effect, anyway, because I think just to bring him back to where he was starting in the collection that's so striking with what he's was just saying. That moment when the voter goes to the polling station is the key interaction that most people have with our democracy. And the debates that we as politicians are terribly interested in about the sources of electoral finance, the eligibility of different people to come and vote or not. Those things, whilst they are important to politicians, are not as salient as what is going on in the mind of the voter at that point that they go to cast their ballot. And their ability to do that with complete integrity and faith in that process is absolutely critical.
So does he agree that it makes it even more absurd to make that point that this review is necessary, this update is necessary because for the voter it represents the front door, the window on politics which is influenced by all the other issues that members across the chamber have been raising throughout the passage of this bill.
Speaker 8
I agree with my honorable friend. And actually, to to to kind of ironically yet seriously related to the previous new clause that we discussed, I would I would argue that having a uniform code of guidance and where voters are being given, assurance that everything is being run run-in the same way, it would rebuild trust in our democracy and would rebuild trust in the government and rebuild trust in the process that we go through. It my honorable friend is absolutely right that the difference between us sad political operatives who look at electoral law and look at whether they are everything is being run okay versus the average voter on the street, a term that I hate, but we know that people out there when we're currently knocking on doors either haven't thought about the fact there's local elections or don't think about the machinery of how a ballot is run. That when they approach a ballot a a polling station, and they have difficulty, the trust that they have in the integrity of this of the system is damaged. And having that reassurance that the government, regardless of political color, are looking to give an independent body reviewing powers perhaps after every general election, I think adds to that trust and that feeling that there is competence, in the electoral, in the voting system.
Speaker 10
System. And and when we were going through the journey of the voter and we see that somebody goes into the polling station, I know for a fact that we've heard the odd conspiracy theory about pencil versus pen. Some places you can vote by pen, some places you can vote by pencil, some people said that your vote could be rubbed out if you vote by pencil. I happen to not ascribe to that theory. I think our election staff are people of integrity.
Integrity. But even that's not clarified under central returning officer guidance, and therefore allows people to have the confidence if it would be. People are often looking at how people vote on in polling stations. I know I hate to break the news to you, sir Desmond, but they do. Because when we stand at a polling station and the person's voting there for the for the benefit of hand stuff, which I apologize, I'm just standing slightly to the right to signify that there is a desk right next door, we can see how people are voting.
That is breaching that is breaching the trust that we really do need. So I say to the minister, who I know is gonna throw out this new clause because, so far the government hasn't conceded on very much, That if we are all democrats the government hasn't conceded on very much, I'm afraid to say. If we are all democrats, then we really should not be afraid afraid of assessing whether our elections work. We have a groundbreaking piece of legislation. And I say to the minister, because I'm sure when we get to report stage in the chamber, the minister is going to quote back in inverted commas, the shadow minister said this is groundbreaking legislation, and I agree.
I agree. It's got I think it's got its bad points, but it also has its very good points. But it could be even more groundbreaking and actually be the key piece of legislation that builds the integrity in our election system, which is extremely delicate at the moment as the honorable lady for Guilford outlined. I'll give way again.
Speaker 7
It to them. I'm once again grateful to my honorable Benford for giving way. But this is probably one of the most important, parts of the debate that's taking place on this particular bill. And I'm sure most of us as politicians will have had that experience of a voter telling us on the doorstep that they would be willing to vote for our party, but they lack confidence in the secrecy of the ballot because they know the ballot paper issued has a serial number on it and that in theory it could be tracked down later on and established as to how they voted. Does he agree with me that when we look at electoral behavior, the turnout in, for example, local elections has been consistent for a hundred years.
The debates around trust have not been as material to people's willingness to vote as a trusted politics agenda as their confidence in the parties and their sense of what is at stake in those elections really matters. And that's really a question of politics rather than as early amendments suggested a question of trust. Does So it agree that the significance of this that this is about ensuring the integrity of the process by which democracy happens as opposed to a wider debate that reflects our political views about that process?
Speaker 10
No. I I absolutely agree with my honorable friend. This is not about a this is not about whether one political party or one party in government is more trustworthy than the other. We leave that to the voters. This is about trust in the integrity of the process, and he is absolutely right that greatest, the greatest influence that any citizen of this country and the first right of every citizen in this country should be able to participate in democratic process and pick their government and their elected representatives who stand up for them, but they need to have that integrity.
And he is absolutely writing, outlining, that it shouldn't be seen in a party political way. Absolutely should be seen in a, in a in a process way. And I say that the, the the new clause, I think, adds to that by giving the power to the independent electoral commission, which the minister reminded us in the previous session of this committee is governed by parliament, not by the government. And I think that that, is a step that the minister could take seeing as they are very keen to give the Electoral Commission increased power. So, sir Desmond, this is a, I would argue, a a crucial nonpartisan new clause
Speaker 10
That would allow us to have a tangible effect on the of the trust and the integrity of our system. Nobody is bigger or better than the system that we have, but it can be improved. And we shouldn't be shying away, sir Desmond, from allowing ourselves to improve that system no matter who is in government, to make sure that every time someone walks to that polling station, they know their vote has been cast in the most secret and the most, and the best way possible. I hope the minister looks on this very kindly. I'm sure she's probably not going to, but I look forward to her remarks in response to this new clause.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 36 be read a second time. Doctor Ellie Chams.
Speaker 6
Thank you, sir Desmond. And just briefly, ballot secrecy is clearly extremely important. I know the opposition spokesperson has talked about family voting. I'm frankly deeply disappointed and concerned by the implicitly discriminatory accusations made by some parties in relation to family voting in recent weeks. And I wish we thought saw as much passion about the, in my view, far greater threat to our democracy posed by the skewing effect of huge donations.
I note that the Conservative Party spokespeople made no contribution in the discussion on caps on donations or limits on expenditure earlier this afternoon, but have devoted considerable airtime to this particular topic. And I would ask all of us to consider what is the greatest threat really to the integrity of our political system. And so while balancing give way or not. That's that's it.
Speaker 7
for giving way. I I think the the crucial distinction which perhaps I'd be interested in is it
Speaker 1
would be helpful. I I'm sure it's the honourable gentleman's greatest pleasure to address the chair, particularly so when I'm in it.
Speaker 7
My apologies. Mister Desmond. Chairman. What I was seeking to to garner from the honorable member for North Perilfordshire is her views on the distinction between what happens at the point of casting a vote, which is where all of us exercise our equal democratic freedom. We have a vote each, and we cast it in the same way in a process which needs to have integrity.
There is no guarantee that any amount of expenditure will influence a voter to vote in a particular way if they feel that that is one, and each of us as voters exercises that judgment equally and freely under the law. Whereas the amendments which we've been so keen to spend some time on are ones that are about the integrity and the confidence in the process under which every single voter is equal in the power that they exercise in their democracy. Doctor H. Chan.
Speaker 6
I thank the honorable member. I mean, I think I've made my point. Let's consider what's the greatest threat to the integrity of our democracy. And because of my concerns about the ways in which concerns such as those articulated in this group have been, weaponized by some political actors, if this is taken to a vote, I will abstain.
Speaker 5
Thank you, sir Desmond. New clause 36 and amendment 25 would place a new legal duty on the electoral commission to produce guidance for returning officers on how to enforce defenses introduced by the Ballot Secrecy Act 2023. I would stress at the outset how seriously the government takes all forms of electoral fraud or coercion, including family voting. It's illegal. It's unacceptable, and polling staff should feel confident to challenge and report any incidents.
However, I have serious concerns about this amendment. It is firstly essential to point out that the commission can already issue guidance, and it already provides extensive guidance for returning officers. Putting this requirement into legislation would set a new precedent, allowing parliament to direct how the commission produces its guidance in the future. The commission's independence, as we discussed earlier on today, is central to public confidence in how elections are run. Because these amendments require ministers and parliament to approve or even change the guidance, there's a real risk that people would see this as political interference and involvement in something that should remain an operational matter for the commission.
The extra approval steps could also delay clear guidance for returning officers. If Parliament rejected the draft guidance, the Commission would have to start again, creating uncertainty for those responsible for enforcing ballot secrecy. For those reasons, about independence, ministerial involvement, added complexity, and the precedent this this sets, the government can't support these amendments.
Speaker 10
Thank you, sir Desmond. If I may, because there were some comments which I think, questioned my integrity in making my speech from the honorable lady from North Herefordshire. No. From the lady of the ladies from North Herefordshire. It's very interesting, sir Desmond, how politicians on this okay.
My judgment. The only way he says judgment. But it's very interesting that, being accused of being weaponizing, an issue on one certain aspect of what I think is a imbalance or or a interpretation of different ways of it of, enacting voting at polling stations. Firstly, it's a subjective term, but it's also the honorable lady no. I'm not giving away at the moment.
I will. Would ask to do a point of order to do that, so I don't I'm not giving away.
Speaker 6
Point of order. Point of order. The house will know that I didn't accuse anybody in particular of weaponizing. I, observed that the issue had been weaponized.
Speaker 10
No. The honorable lady here has made that point, but she said that members were weaponizing. Seeing as I was the only member that was actually speaking to an amendment table by the official opposition and in my name. I think we can take that as read. But it is interesting that when you look at one area that, is a possible infringement of an equal right to vote, the landlady focused on family voting.
I mentioned I I focused on many other things, whether we should look, through this review, through this mechanism, asking for an independent review on whether the secrecy of the ballot is being kept by an organization. I mentioned family voting once. I mentioned the activities of political parties at polling stations. I mentioned whether the desks should be looked at differently.
Speaker 10
I don't think that that's been, I don't think that that's necessarily been unique to myself on this committee, but I will draw my remarks to a close, which is that when you are challenged over the intentions as to why you're bringing an amendment, which actually is well intentioned and has been picked up, that it's just because of one thing and weaponizing, which it isn't
Speaker 7
So desperate. You're much I'm really worried that seeking to avoid any agree again? He that
Speaker 7
key strength which he's advocating for here is that it is the integrity of the ballot that is the guardian against all of these issues. If we have a secret ballot that we can trust, all of these issues of corruption, undue influence, family voting, wherever they be may be, are managed appropriately. If we fail to ensure the integrity is balanced, then those things become irresponsible.
Speaker 10
I thank my thank my own friend which I, we I will I thank my own little friend for his intervention, which I, of course, endorse. But, the the the the remarks before me, sir Desmond, intimated, that we hadn't commented on other aspects of the bill. All I would say is that I welcome the honorable lady's comments from North Harri Fisher on cryptocurrency. I welcomed and, in fact, said to the Liberal Democrat spokesman spokesperson that I would look to support them on some of the aspects around capping of finances and election electoral finance. So I think we need to just be very careful when we speak, on this section.
But, sir Desmond, I will be pushing this new clause to a vote because I think anybody in on this on this, committee who was scared of an independent review as to whether our system works really shouldn't be hiding away from the people that vote for them. And therefore, I think that we should be moved this to a vote for Desmond, and we will be voting in favor.
Speaker 1
Yeah. The question is that new clause 36 be read a second time. Those of the are of that opinion say aye. Aye.
Speaker 1
Aye. Aye. The ayes have it. Division. The noes have it even.
Division. Lock the doors.
Speaker 9
Alex Baker? No. Ellie Charms? No. Deirdre Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? Zoe Franklin?
Speaker 9
Lloyd Hutton? No. Paul Holmes? Aye. Zoe John Joseph?
No. Laura Kirk Smith? No. Andrew Lewin?
Speaker 1
The eyes were two and the nose were 10, so the nose have it, the nose have it. We now come to group 52 and new clause 37. I call Paul Holmes to move. New clause 37.
Speaker 10
Thank you, Desmond. And I think this is a vitally important new clause. And, of course, I would say that because we've tabled it, but I do think that this is a new clause which aims to repair some of the imbalance of some of the tactics that we have seen in recent elections, and to give every voter a level playing field of participating in voting in an equal way. So Desmond, new clause 37, is bears relation to language of campaign materials and advocates that during a relevant period, campaign material must not be promoted or published in a foreign language. And by that, I mean the short regulated campaign period.
And so Desmond, if a person is found guilty of an offense and causes campaign material to be promoted or published falls within subsection one, I e, within a foreign language, the person will be guilty of an offense under, one, a conviction sorry, a summary conviction in England and Wales to a fine or a summary conviction in Scotland or Northern Ireland to a fine not exceeding level five on the standard scale. And I want to be very clear why we bring we're bringing forward this amendment. We are all politicians who campaign in our constituencies, but we all know that politics is becoming more divisive in the messages that certain parties are putting out there in the country. In the Gorts and Denton by election, we saw an election leaflet written in Urdu that said, give the Muslims a voice, punish labor for their views on Gaza, vote green. That is not not withstanding the fact that that is a divisive statement to make.
I would argue that that was actively and purposely done by the Green Party to prey on the vulnerabilities of a community that are as not as involved in British society as they should be, and in order to to exploit their vulnerabilities, in order to vote Green on a one issue, which is the foreign policy and the actions of the labor government on their decisions on Gaza. Now every government's first duty in this country is to keep its citizens safe, and regardless of what we think on Gaza or any one issue, the government's number one duty is to undertake its responsibilities. And on foreign policy, the prime minister and the foreign secretary have done that. They do that every day. That is what the prime minister and the foreign secretary are supposed to do.
So when we see campaign materials published in a foreign language to exploit communities that should be much more involved in British society than they are. I think that is exploitation. I think that's exploitation for personal and political for political, not personal gain, and that is something that I think skewed result to have the result of that by election in Gorton and Denton. Oh, thank you. Now I I would in a second.
Now let me be clear. I am not contesting the result of that election. My party was never going to win that election. So if anybody wants to intervene on me and say it's because you got a measly 6%, that is entirely true. But let's face it.
Not everybody in that constituency were able to see what the Green Party was saying to those communities about Gaza because that constituency is a very diverse constituency. Big white working class community and then a big ethnic minority community. I say it again, sir Desmond, and I believe that that was exploitation of one community on one issue and that the Green Party were guilty of doing that,
Speaker 7
I give way. So I'm grateful to Ronald Frederick for giving way. He's spoken very eloquently about the the shocking behavior of the Green Party in Gortmund Den by election. But does he recall as I do the evidence that we heard on our first day in committee from Tower Hamlets, which really gave, I think, all of us cause to reflect that this is not simply something that has been about a recent shocking issue of the Green Party, but has been a long standing concern in our politics. And in a country where we want to ensure everybody has equality of access to our democracy, that we need to make sure that we get this right.
And using the established languages of our nation is a key part of that.
Speaker 10
I agree with my own president. And look, that's one example, but we know that there have been examples in the electoral integrity in Tower Hamlets. We know that the government, the previous government, and the government stepped in to the case in Tower Hamlets because there were breaches alongside, some of the election materials that were going out. My contention in bringing this forward is that every voter, no matter where they come from, should be able to have the same access to campaign materials. And that, I don't think, is unreasonable that we have election materials in the short campaign only, digital and physical, at any other time in the period, people can do that.
But in the short campaign where emotions can be high, where polls can be tight, and where parties are campaigning very hard, I believe that should be done on an equal footing. I also think that the government are moving towards trying to encourage translation anyway. So in the house, the secretary of state released a social cohesion strategy. A social cohesion strategy that is supposed to make every citizen in this country feel British or identify as British, but feel safe and feel at one in this country. The only way we can do that is by increasing funding for translation services and encouraging people and sometimes forcing people to learn the languages of this country, and that's English, Scottish, Welsh, or the other registered languages in the British Isles.
I don't think that that is unreasonable, and the government clearly don't think that that's unreasonable as well because in the social occasion strategy, they actively promote that. So all I'm trying to do is make it official that people should be reading their election materials in one language or or in a choice of official British language. Of course. Of course.
Speaker 1
Grandmother would not have a native native English because she was first language Gaelic, Scottish Gaelic. Under the 2022 census, in North Lanarkshire, four eighty three people speak Gaelic in the home. Over 2,000 people speak Urdu in the home. Is what the honourable gentleman is suggesting is being equal for all, making it more equal for one rather than the other?
Speaker 10
No. I and that's the simple reason I say that, mister Bladie, who I who I have a lot of respect for because we we get we get on, and I believe that we're both in it for the same reasons. And my explanatory note is very, very clear that it it protects and does not have impact. It would not ban campaigning in native languages of the British Isles such as English, Welsh, Cornish, Ulster Scots, Irish, Etowl, nor would it prevent campaigning by the likes of BSL or Braille. So no.
Because they are officially known as a minority language within The United Kingdom or within the British Isles. So we've been very careful that people in well people in Wales and Northern Ireland or in Scotland, people who read braille, people who rely on sign language will be not excluded by this new clause, but communities that are not learning english should be able to read that english through translation services being encouraged by the social cohesion strategy. But also we have to think on the other side of many people who live in a community which may be multi ethnic, who get leaflets in a foreign language and can't read what's being said by a party either. And that is not a level playing field in the voting system, and I think that that is wrong. I think we've seen examples of where that's been used as an an exploitative way in recent months, and no doubt I think that we will see it used in an exploitative way in future.
It's happened in London. It's happened in Tower Hamlets. It's happened in Gorton, and it will happen again. Therefore, I say to the minister, if she's not going to support this new clause, is she or her government looking at how we do streamline the voting system in this country in terms of having at least guidance in terms of languages, at least guidance in terms of and she may say it already exists, but toughening the regulations to, prescript or to describe how parties should be acting when it comes to British languages versus foreign languages. And I look forward to the minister's response on this new clause, mister Desmond.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause thirty second 37 be read a second time. Ellie Chowns. Doctor Ellie Chowns.
Speaker 6
Thank you, sir Desmond. I'm going to rise above, the petty politicking aspects of some of the comments of the spokesperson to the official opposition. But I do want to engage with his claim, absolutely extraordinary claim, that communicating with people in their mother tongue is, in some way, exploitation. He expresses concern for inclusion of diverse communities in our country. He talks about social cohesion, but what he's proposing is essentially a nativist policy as has been highlighted by the question from, the government member, just now, Gaelic speakers are accepted or at least speakers are not.
I fundamentally disagree. Of course, as a country, we should provide support to assist people to learn English, not force, as the member argued. But if they are not yet fluent, it seems to me to be perfectly reasonable. In fact, clearly helpful for inclusion and participation to provide election materials in the language in which they can best be understood. And indeed, this is what returning officers do.
Election officers provide information in multiple languages. Mhmm. So why shouldn't parties and candidates also be free to do so? Mhmm. Let me quote from the electoral commission's website the guidance that they provide to returning officers.
They say, some voters may need assistance in another language because of their limited English or English or Welsh language skills. You should consider what support you are able to provide to those voters in your area, such as providing translations of the polling station notices. Indeed, in Gorton and Denton, polling stations provided information in multiple other languages. The effect of the amendment that is before us today would be exclusionary and discriminatory, and I strongly oppose it.
Speaker 5
Thank you, mister Desmond. Amendment n c 37 seeks to ban the use of foreign languages in campaign material during the regulating period, it would make it a criminal offense. A primary purpose of this bill is to encourage more people across society to engage and participate in our democracy. This amendment does not serve that purpose. It is not for the government to prescribe the languages campaigners are permitted to use to engage voters who come from a wide range of diverse backgrounds across the constituencies we represent, it is certainly not for the government to criminalize the use of certain languages.
There are various electoral and non electoral offenses which protect against malicious forms of campaign material, which is in essence what the honorable member was talking about. For example, it's an offense to publish or distribute threatening, abusive, or insulting material that is intended or likely to stir up racial hatred. It's also an offense to improperly influence someone to vote in a particular way or refrain from voting. This includes, for example, a leaflet which threatens to make use of force or place undue spiritual pressure on a person in order to induce a voter to vote in a particular way or refrain from voting. These offences apply regardless of the language used in the campaign material.
To answer the honorable gentleman, the government has no plans to regulate the use of foreign languages in campaign material. We are seeking to minimize barriers to participation while safeguarding the integrity and security of elections. The measures in this bill are intended to restore faith in our politics and ensure that The UK continues to be a thriving and diverse democracy. This amendment is entirely incompatible with those intentions. I therefore ask the honorable member to withdraw this amendment.
Speaker 10
Port Holmes. Mister Desmond, thank you. And I, wholly, accept the comments from the minister. I didn't expect that she would be looking into this, and I I acknowledge the comments made by the honorable lady for North Harwicher as well. I do would say to her that when she used the example of returning officers, those returning officers are filling in and conducting a political protest a process.
They are not using foreign languages to exploit a section of our society against a policy that they happen to disagree with against a party in this country. That is the clear and distinct difference, and that is the example that I was using in my oration to move this new clause. So her example is about a process. My example is about using political language in a foreign sorry. Foreign language in a political way to exploit a message that they wanted to use in an advent advantageous way.
That is why I've brought forward this new clause, and I want to push it to a base, isn't it?
Speaker 1
I've now concluded. But she's entitled to speak again if she wish if she wishes. The question is if you call
Speaker 6
member the member seems to, seems to say that, the making of any political argument that he disagrees with is exploitation. It's ridiculous.
Speaker 1
The question is, in the new clause 37, we read a second time. As many of that opinion, aye. Aye. To the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Samantha Dixon? No. Sari Franklin? No. Lloyd Hatton?
David Simmons? Aye. Lisa
Speaker 1
The ayes were two, and the nos were 13. So the nos habit, the nos habit. We now come to new clauses thirty eight and thirty nine, which were debated with new clause number two. Pawthones, do you wish to move or does anyone else wish to move new clauses 38, thirty eight and thirty nine?
Speaker 1
We now come to new clause 40, which has already been debated with clause 48. Do you wish to move mister Holmes, do you wish to move new clause 40, or does anyone else wish to do so?
Speaker 1
We now come to new clause 41, which was debated with new clause 65. Do you wish to move it, or does anyone wish to do so?
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 41 be read a second time as many as of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Zoe Franklin? Pastor. Lloyd Hatton? No. Holmes?
Aye. Sajad Joseph? No. Laura Kirk Smith? No.
Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray? No. Sam Rushworth?
No. David Simmons? Aye. Lisa Smart?
Speaker 1
The eyes were two and the nose were 10, so the nose have it. The nose have it. We now come to new clause forty two and forty three, which I think were debated with new clause six. Can I look into the clock? Yes.
Yes. Very good. Right. I've already been debating new clause six. Do you wish to move new clause forty two and forty three?
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 42 be read a second time as many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Zoe Franklin? Aye. Lloyd Hatton? No. Paul Holmes?
Aye. Sojan Joseph? No. Laura Kirk Smith?
Speaker 1
The ayes were four and the noes were 11, so the noes have it. Noes have it. New clause 43, electoral register British nationals abroad. The question is that new clause 43 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion, say aye.
Aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Alex Baker? No. Bradley Chowns? Aye. Deirdre Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin? Aye.
Lloyd Hatton?
Speaker 3
Paul Holmes? Aye. Sojourn Joseph? No. Laura Kirk Smith?
No. Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray? No.
Sam Rushworth? No. David Simmons? Aye. Lisa Smart?
Aye. Steve Yen?
Speaker 1
The eyes were five and the nose were 10, so the nose have it. The nose have it. We now come to new clause 44, which was already debated with clause 15. Does zoe Franklin wish to move move to clause 44? I wish
Speaker 3
Report on proposals to support the extension of franchise to 16 and 17 year olds.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 44 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion, say aye.
Speaker 3
Alex Baker? No. Ellie Chowns? Aye. Deirdre Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin? Aye.
Lloyd Hatton? Paul Holmes? Aye. No. So, John, Jason?
No. Laura Coatsmith? Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray?
No. Sam Rushworth? No. David Simmons? No.
Lisa Smart? Aye. Steve Yem? No.
Speaker 1
The eyes were three and the nose were 12. So the nose have it, the nose have it. We now come to new clauses 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, fifty, and fifty one, which were all debated with clause 56. The new clauses have been tabled by Matt Weston. Does anyone wish to move them?
Speaker 3
No. I mean, you can you can take the first question only and then can't take the rest
Speaker 1
Right. Okay. I can do that then. I can I can take the first one and then say that's enough? So Well, that's the that's the advice.
Speaker 3
New clause 45, permissible electors to include overseas electors with previous tax residents, etcetera.
Speaker 1
As men the question is that new clause 45 be read a second time. As many areas of that opinion say aye.
Speaker 3
Lloyd Hatton? No. Paul Holmes? Obstare. Sodian Joseph?
No. Laura Kirk Smith?
Speaker 1
The ayes were three and the noes were 10, so the noes have it and noes have it. New clause 47. 46. 46 even.
Speaker 3
Alex Baker? No. Eddie Chowns? Aye. Dieter Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin? Aye.
Lloyd Hatham? Paul Holmes? No. Sergeant Joseph? No.
Laura Kirk Smith? No. Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray?
Speaker 1
The ayes were three and the noes were 12. So the noes have it, noes have it. Number 47.
Speaker 3
New clause 47, commencement of section nine two of the political parties elections act 2009.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 47 be read a second time. As many as of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. No.
I think the noes have it. The noes have it. Division? No.
Speaker 3
Ellie Chounds? Aye. Theodore Costigan? No. Samantha Dixon?
No. Zoe Franklin? Aye. Lloyd Hatton? No.
Paul Holmes?
Speaker 1
That's three and a 10. The ayes were three and the noes are 10. So the noes have it, the noes have it. New clause 48.
Speaker 3
New clause 48, offenses relating to election expense returns, reduction in threshold.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 48 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion, say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Alex Baker? No. Eddie Chowns? Aye. Theodore Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin? No.
Lloyd Hatton? No. Paul Holmes? No. Sojourn Joseph?
Speaker 1
The eyes were three. The nose are 12. So the nose have it. The nose have it. New clause 49.
Speaker 3
New clause 49. Declaration as the source of donation reduction in amount.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 49 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Speaker 1
The question is that you clause 50 be read a second time as many as are of that opinion, say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. No. The notes have it.
Speaker 3
Alex Baker? No. Ellie Chowns? Aye. Theodore Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin?
Speaker 7
Lloyd Hatton? No. Paul Holmes? Steve Yen? Ayes are three, the noes are 12.
Speaker 3
New Clause 51. New clause 51, annual report regarding foreign interference in political funding.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 51 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion, say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. No.
I think the notice have it. No. No.
Speaker 3
So Joseph? No. Laura Coat Smith? No. Andrew Lewin?
No. Katrina Murray? No. The
Speaker 1
ayes were three and the noes were 10, so the noes have it. The noes have it. We now come to new clause 52, which has already been debated with clause 60 stand apart. New clause 52 was tabled by Richard Burgeon. Does anyone want to move it?
No. No. We now come to new clause 53, which was debated with clause 65 stand apart. Does Zoe Franklin wish to move new clause 53 foreman?
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 53 be read a second time as many as are of that opinion say aye.
Speaker 3
Alex Baker. No. Ellie Chown. Aye. Deirdre Costigan?
No. Samantha Dixon? No. Zoe Franklin?
Speaker 3
Lloyd Hatton? No. Paul Holmes? No. Sajid and Joseph?
Laura Kirk Smith? No. Andrew Lewin? No. Katrina Murray?
No. Sam Rushworth?
Speaker 1
Eyes were three. The nose are 12. So the nose have it, the nose have it. We now come to new clause 54, which was debated with new clause 30. Does mister Smart wish to move it?
Speaker 3
Very good. Proposals for a royal commission on political donations and campaign expenditure.
Speaker 1
The question is that new clause 54 be read a second time. As many as are that opinion, aye.
Speaker 3
Lloyd Hatton. No. Paul Holmes. No. Sergeant Joseph?
No. Laura Kirk Smith? No. Andrew Lewin? No.
Katrina Murray? No. Sam Rushworth?
Speaker 1
The ayes were three and the nos were 12. So the nos have it, the nos have it. We now to come to new clause fifty five and fifty six, which were already we have already debated. Zoe Franklin, do you wish to move? I trust.
No. Right. We now come to new clauses fifty seven and fifty eight, which were already debated. Does Ellie Charles wish to move them?
Speaker 1
up. We now come to crew fifty three. You close 50 nine. You close 61, new close 62, new close 63, and new close 60 four, with which it will be convenient so it's group 53. New clause is 59 with which it will be convenient to consider new clause 61, 62, new clause 63, and clause 60 and new clause 64, and new clause 59 was tabled by Luke Myers, who's not on the committee.
Does anyone wish to move it? Yes. Doctor Ellie Charles.
Speaker 6
Thank you, sir Desmond. I rise to move the amendment tabled by the member for Middlesbrough South And East Cleveland regarding creating a new offensive misleading the public by candidates in a parliamentary election campaign, and I will also be moving the amendments tabled by the member for Ellison Ellsmore Port and Bromborough. And first of all, regarding the one around the creating a new offense of misleading the public by candidates, we're we're witnessing a spread, a proliferation of disinformation, and also a concurrent rise in distrust among the public. Recent survey by Ipsos Mori said that just 11% of UK public trust politicians to tell the truth. This is clearly problematic.
And unlike in advertising, finance, or med medicine, there is no legally enforceable standard of requiring truthfulness from those who hold or seek public office. Now ministers are not allowed to lie, but under the current situation, candidates can. So this lack of accountability does unfortunately create create an incentive to decease because deceive because as the old saying goes, you know, a lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still putting on its shoes. So this legal vacuum has unfortunately enabled far right figures to weaponize disinformation. It's enabled enabled foreign powers to covertly manipulate elections and policy.
And we know that the manipulation of voters through false factual claims has changed the landscape of a nation. There are already examples of this, including Brexit and campaign tactics in previous elections. So the amendment, table here aims to protect voters from political deception by holding parliamentary candidates accountable for intentional acts designed to mislead the public or manipulate voting in their favor. Actually, a similar measure is already provided for in the public the government's public accountability bill, which creates a new offensive misleading the public, which will cover public officials. But so these parallel measures will will ensure that that candidates are are included in a similar provision and cannot use deliberate deception to win public office.
Now as it happens, the Welsh government has recently introduced similar equivalent legislation which provides for the Wales equivalent to the representation of people built to be amended to create an offensive deliberate deception by candidates. So Westminster won't be acting alone. This would provide consistency across the country. Now this isn't an order to punish genuine mistakes, you know, misspeaking and so forth, or to restrict legitimate political rhetoric. It's not covering the manifestos as a manifesto as a statement of intent, and it's not creating a new area of law.
It's merely extending it to plug a gaping loophole political defence deception by applying existing legal principles. And the amendment includes safeguards to ensure fairness, such as a high legal threshold for wrongdoing and a defense for those acting with reasonable excuse. And so the phrasing of the amendment, ensures that that threshold for wrongdoing is high. It applies only to conduct that is seriously improper. So this targets deliberate misinformation campaigns, major false claims that could influence voters, and manipulative or dishonest campaign tactics that are falsely used to steer voters towards a particular decision.
There is actually overwhelming public support for this measure. A petition on this issue has over 200,000 signatures, and polling by opinion shows that 72% of voters support it. Further research by survey found that a majority of voters in every single party is in favor of it. So I do think that this measure would go some way to helping to repair trust in our politics, and I look forward to hearing the minister's response on that issue. Moving on to new clauses 61, 62, 63, and 64 tabled in the name of tabled by the member for Ellsworth Port and Bromborough briefly to cover these.
So first of all, on n c 61, introduce to introduce the code of conduct for political campaign. This is an amendment that we're putting on a statutory footing. There's already widespread widespread agreement that we need a code of conduct, for political campaigning. This was, of course, a recommendation of, the speakers conference last year, and the government indeed, has committed to establish a code of conduct for campaigns following that recommendation. And the electoral commission has, has absolutely, welcomed this.
And I would just, draw colleagues' attention to one of the evidence sessions to the speakers' conference last year in which Labour's executive director of governance and legal highlighted this question of whether the code of conduct would be statutory. Said it said a code of a code might be helpful in setting a public benchmark of acceptable behavior. Ultimately, you would probably want it to be enforceable in some way. And then the question is question would be, is it appropriate to put that on a statutory footing? Is there a a possibility of agreeing something?
So I asked the minister to consider we have an excellent opportunity here to put it on a statutory footing within this bill to ensure that that code of conduct, which is so widely recognized as being absolutely necessary as per the recommendations of the speakers' conference, to ensure that that has the the the force of primary legislation behind it. Moving on to n c 62, electoral advertising code of practice. Practice. We have already discussed issues relating to electoral advertising. I have shared with the committee my huge concerns about the regulation, in particular, of online political advertising and the urgent need for a real time political adverts library.
And but this is more more general. And it's frankly unclear why ads for commercial products are actually held to greater account than ads that move votes and affect election outcome. You know, that that seems weird, fundamentally. That seems unequal and and deeply problematic. And reform political advertising is an organization that's been campaigning very effectively and long and hard in this area.
For example, in the twenty twenty four London mayoral election, they trialed a factual accuracy code, and seven London mayoral candidates signed up, including Sadiq Khan plus Green and Liberal Democrat candidates, other people who have supported it. And international precedent exists. Regulation of factual claims in electoral advertisement has been in place in New Zealand for several decades with cross party support. I will be aware.
Speaker 7
We should be able to perhaps just briefly set out for the benefit of the committee, who, whether it's a body or an individual, she feels would be the appropriate judge for factual accuracy. I think for all of us as political parties, we've been on the receiving end, for example, the famous lived in bar chart which contains tiny letters underneath survey of 10 people we asked in the pub last night. Now you could argue therefore, mister Lester, that it was factually accurate based on that very dubious source. So how are we going to ensure that where there is some dispute about what the facts actually are, there is a sufficient degree of independence to arbitrate that question?
Speaker 4
I I thank the member for his intervention, and I refer him to the very next new clause on the agenda which engages with precisely this question. And, I had almost finished my notes on the previous one, so I will just observe that in addition to New Zealand, there are similar rules about regulation of political advertising in Australia as well. And so to the to the point of who will adjudicate on this, there is currently no independent body with powers to adjudicate on the truthfulness of the or accuracy of nonbroadcast political advertising. This is an issue, and the the provision has been made within these new clauses specifically to separate the point about the establishment of a code of practice by the electoral commission and the oversight of the decision making, the adjudication to a different body. And so it is recommended as per the recommendation, actually, of a 2020 report by the Lord's Committee on Democracy and Digital Technologies, their report on digital technology and the Reserves Direction of Trust, they called for a regulatory committee on political advertising that would involve relevant expert in the ASA, the Advertising Standards Authority, the Electoral Commission, Ofcom, and the UK Statistics Authority calling on them to cooperate through a regulatory committee on political advertising.
Speaker 6
And political parties should work with those regulators to develop the the code of practice along with appropriate sanctions that restricts fundamentally inaccurate advertising during a parliamentary or mayoral election or referendum. And this regulatory committee should adjudicate breaches of this code. That is what, that laws committee recommends, and that is effectively, what, n c 63, would put into place. I hear you ask, what then would happen about sanctions? Well, that takes us on to n c 64, the last clause here, which, again, separates out this this point and would establish an enforcement framework and enable the electoral commission to impose civil sanctions for breaches of the advertising codes, basically, on a kind of a laddered a a ladder of increasing seriousness.
So I I I warmly recommend all of these new clauses to the government and to the committee. It's despite the rapidity of my speech given the shortness of time, this is a crucial issue. This this this issue with the way that advertising can can distort our politics. And so I very much hope that the government will give warm consideration to these issues alongside all of the other ones that they are hopefully going to come back to us with at a later stage. Thank you.
Speaker 5
Thank you. New clause 59 would create a new offense of misleading the public in a parliamentary election campaign, could be committed by candidates in election campaigns. Unfortunately, this approach would risk making the courts, turning the courts into political fact checkers, risk undermining public confidence in the judiciary and create significant freedom of expression concerns. In line with the recommendation from the speakers conference, we'll work with the conference, the electoral commission and political parties to develop a campaigning code of conduct that's fit for
Speaker 5
people people of practice to make or publish a false statement of fact in relation to the personal character or conduct of a candidate, with an effect to impact the election results. I will speak to new clauses 61, 62, sixty three and sixty four together. These amendments would amount to a significant expansion of the regulatory framework governing political campaigning and electoral advertising. These amendments would introduce a statutory code of conduct for political campaigning, a statutory electoral advertising code, and a new electoral advertising code committee to oversee, adjudicate, and enforce compliance with the advertising code funded through a levy on political parties. We welcome the speakers' conference recommendation to develop a code of conduct for campaigning.
We're working with the speaker, the electoral commission, political parties on an approach that's fit for purpose and works across the broad range of candidates and campaigners. That work's already underway. Ahead of the May twenty twenty six elections, the Electoral Commission has published the first set of advisory principles for campaigning respectfully and safely. Government to government The elections, it will assess how they operated in practice and use that to inform development of a fuller code of conduct. A non statutory approach gives the best opportunity for the code to be developed collaboratively with strong cross party engagement and sufficient flexibility to ensure it remains meaningful and can be refined in light of experience and development in campaigning practice over time.
It would be better to allow that work to continue and be evaluated in practice rather than prescribing the content and process for an evolving set of codes on the face of the bill. Turning to amendments NC62, NC63 and NC64. These amendments would place regulators in the position of adjudicating factual claims made in the course of political campaigning, an area that's inherently contested and closely connected to political opinion. While safeguards are included, there remains a real risk of regulatory creep, drawing independent regulators into disputes around policy or political arguments, which can be rebutted by rival campaigners and scrutinized by the press as part of the normal course political debate. Any reforms in this space must be considered carefully and developed in consultation to ensure changes to the regulation of political advertising are proportionate, protect freedom of expression, and maintain public confidence in the independence and impartiality of regulatory bodies.
I therefore respectfully ask the honorable member to withdraw these amendments.
Speaker 1
Right. We now come to new clause 66, which was in group 54. I call Ellie Chowns to doctor Ellie Chowns to move new clause 66.
Speaker 7
Point of order. Point of order, I may. May I seek your guidance, mister chairman? I know you remember what they actually didn't say anyone, but Could you just confirm to the committee that we do have two further full days of consideration which are in everybody's diaries? I know the government workers declined my suggestion and adjournment early on.
However, members should not feel constrained in fully setting out the concerns that they have or the issues that they wish to raise to this bill. Given as I understand it, we still do have a further two full days of consideration available to us.
Speaker 1
I can only confirm that there are four more sessions over two days, Tuesday and Thursday next week. We now come to new clause fifth the new clause 66. I call a chance to move loose clause 66.
Speaker 6
Thank you very much, sir Desmond. So we this this clause would remove the prohibition on the electoral commission from instituting criminal proceedings, in England and Wales and Northern Ireland, a capacity that they previously had and which was removed and maintained by the Elections Act in 2022. So we currently have this bizarre situation whereby any individual organization other than the electoral commission can bring forward a private prosecution against breaches of political finance law, but the electoral commission itself can't. And I think this gives rise to a criminal enforcement gap, and it's not helped by a lack of kind of, you know, in investigatory and prosecutorial kind of lead capacity, especially for UK wide offenses. Other similar regulators in The UK can bring criminal proceedings in, you know, in the area of their auspices.
So there is a real question, why not the electoral commission? Now I I note that Philip Reichwaff, in his report, has dealt with this and has recommended an alternative approach. So, essentially, you know, this I I I have tabled this as a probing amendment to ask the government to really provide a little more clarification because we are if we're not going to give these powers to the electoral commission, then who should take the lead? The status quo is clearly not working. There's an alarming lack of prosecution in this space going back quite a number of years.
And so the the net effect is essentially that people can escape from prosecution. If it's not going to be the electoral commission, then we I would argue that we need, much more investment in the the capacities and the powers of the police. As I understand it, we have a situation now where arguably the police may not feel it is necessarily in their interest because the the fines that could be charged are perhaps not proportionate to the huge amount of time that might be required to investigate these issues. So I would really like to hear from the government how they are going to address this, clear gap in the capacity of the system overall to, to, initiate criminal proceedings in relation to breaches of electoral law. I think it would be an obvious solution to put it through the electoral commission.
I recognize that Philip Lycroft has a somewhat different view. Can the government please explain what their view is? Thanks.
Speaker 3
Electoral commission power to institute criminal proceedings in England and Wales on Northern Ireland.
Speaker 5
Thank you, sir Desmond. New clause 66 would remain remove the prohibition on the Electoral Commission, bringing criminal proceedings in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland, which was introduced in the elections act 2022. To be clear, the electoral commission has has never brought criminal prosecutions, even brought to the changes introduced by the act. It has a wide range of investigatory powers and is able to impose a variety of civil sanctions for certain offenses. This bill is already extending and strengthening those powers to promote more robust and proportionate enforcement.
Where criminal investigation and prosecution is required or thought appropriate for certain offences, the Commission refers those cases to the police and the relevant prosecuting authority who are experts in this domain. The Government recognizes the importance of ensuring electoral laws are enforced effectively, and there's public confidence in a system of regulation governing political finance. That's why we commissioned the Rycroft Review. The review looks specifically, as the honorable member for North Harrowfisher has pointed out, that criminal enforcement arranges and concluded it's entirely appropriate that criminal investigations are handled by the police, the Crown Prosecution Service and the Public Prosecution Service for Northern Ireland. The review noted that the Electoral Commission having prosecutorial role would be unnecessary and potentially counterproductive, requiring significant investment in specialist expertise that might only be deployed sporadically.
Furthermore, while the Electoral Commission must enforce electoral law without fear or favor, it must also engage constructively with campaigners to help them comply with the rules. Rycroft noticed it would be difficult to maintain that constructive regulatory role with political parties if it were also pursuing criminal prosecutions. Given the review's findings on this issue, we do not think any changes are needed to the Electoral Commission's role. We will respond fully to the Rycroft review in due course and consider whether any other legislative changes are necessary in last week's findings. I therefore request that the member withdraw this amendment.
As already stated, withdrawn.
Speaker 1
76 to 81 stand part and government 21 amendment 21. The question is that clause 75 start stand part of the bill. Minister.
Speaker 5
Sir Desmond, I will now turn to the final clauses in the bill which make general provisions and our standard taxes for ability. Given the hour, I I do not intend to go through each Board of Directors Government Amendment twenty twenty one. So I would urge members to to accept all of these general provisions as well as the consequential amendment amendment 21.
Speaker 1
Does anyone else wish to contribute? Right. So the question is that clauses 76 to 79 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion, say aye. Aye.
Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Now have
Speaker 1
question is that clauses 75 to 79 stand part of the bill. As many of that have opinion say aye. Aye. On the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.
The ayes have it. We now have
Speaker 1
Which was debated with clause one. So can we have it moved formally by Paul Holmes?
Speaker 1
The question is that clause 33 be made as many as of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no.
Speaker 3
Lloyd Hatton? No. Paul Holmes? Aye. Zoe Joseph?
No. Laura Kate Smith? No. Andrew Lewin? No.
Trina Murray? No. Sam Rushworth? No. David Simmons?
Aye.
Speaker 1
The eyes of two at the nose at 12, so the nose have it, the nose have it. We now come to clauses 80 to 81. With the leave of the committee, I'll put it as one question. The question is that clauses 80 to 81 stand part of the bill. As many of that has said, opinion say aye.
Aye. To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. You've got government amendment 21 to the title of the bill, which was debated with clause 75 stand part.
The question is that the amendment be made as that of as many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
The ayes have it. We now come to the final process question of these proceedings that I report the bill to the house. As many are of that opinion, say aye. Aye. To the contrary, no.
I think the ayes have it. The let's do a problem. The question is that I do report the bill as amended to the house. As many as are of that opinion, say aye. Aye.
And to the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. The community fit has finished its work order order.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.