afternoon - Competitiveness Council
No chapters available yet
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Council of the European Union
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 2
There is also the review of market access regulation, which should take place next year and strengthen the cooperation between competitors and authorities. And it should ensure that we have sanctions and the power to investigate at the European level for serious and manifest infringements. So, of course, this does not undermine the competencies of national authorities but adds to coordination because it is unacceptable that all our consumers are not protected at the same level. And we have a collective responsibility to protect our borders at the European level. We also want to overcome the gaps when it comes to enforcing legislation for online sales.
The commission is also assessing which measures would improve cooperation for protecting consumers through controls, as this is something that needs to be done simultaneously. And finally, as I said at the start of my statement, we need to implement SA. I know that this debate was already held at the Telecom Council last week, and this needs to be done both nationally and at the European level so that we can join forces and ensure that the platforms do not exploit the gaps that we have. That is why we need to ensure better cooperation and greater effectiveness of our regulation. Thank you.
Speaker 1
Thank you so much, Stefan. We have a long list now, two minutes each. We start with shares from France, and after that, Belgium.
REPRESENTATIVE:
Serge Papin
Colleagues, Chair, Executive Vice President,
Thank you. I am a European who believes in the European Union that protects its commerce, its SMEs, and also respects our environmental ambitions. There are some e-commerce platforms that we see do not respect our rules and engage in dumping. And when these infringements are recurrent or serious, it shows that these platforms can pose systematic risks. We need to act fast and open up investigations.
China must mitigate these risks that Shane and other platforms do not respect. We have a case underway against Temu and AliExpress already. European action is also vital in this. France calls for a global approach to ensure coherence between the DSA, customs rules, and consumer protection regulations, with the implementation of a Europe-wide surveillance authority. We need strength and coordination between European networks, strict enforcement of existing law, including for platforms that are created outside the EU.
European institutions must also guarantee that the notion of systemic risk is explicitly included in the definition of non-compliant, dangerous products or unfair competition. So, I propose that we engage in a common reflection on a direct intervention by the commission on these three major platforms. France proposes setting up a tax for small packages in its 2026 budget. We need to spread that throughout the Union. The future European Products Act will be a major step to galvanize the protection of the internal market and support European competitiveness.
This is something that France will do with conviction to support our economies, particularly our local economies and consumers. Thank you.
Merci.
Speaker 4
Thank you. E-commerce offers opportunities for growth and innovation, but it comes with major challenges regarding consumer safety, compliance, and fair competition. In Belgium, more than 1,000,000,000 packages arrive each year, and up to 90% of these packages are not entirely compliant with European regulations. This is a serious risk for consumers and also weakens the companies that respect the rules. Belgium believes that the single market must remain a space of trust and equity.
We welcome the Commission's communication on a toolbox for safe and sustainable e-commerce. So, we also welcome the lifting of the exemption for customs on packages of less than €150. This is an important measure, but it will not be enough to resolve the problem. We still have major challenges. And that is why Belgium, from 2026, will include a new tax of €2 per package. European enterprises are losing ground.
This is not just a question of consumer safety. This is a question of competitiveness, employment, and the integrity of this single market. We have also written a non-paper on this topic because we need to have coordinated measures to ensure fair trade, protect consumers, and ensure the effectiveness of the single market without imposing administrative burdens on our companies. We also need to avoid fragmentation. Customs authorities cannot do this job alone. We need to have a risk assessment, and we need to use AI that can easily identify the high risks so that we can also ensure the interoperability of authorities.
At the European level, we must focus on promoting cooperation and European support, as well as using existing EU tools to ensure that legislation is respected, including initiatives such as the European Product Act, which are the right way forward and ensure facilitation and harmonization.
Speaker 6
Thank you very much, dear colleagues. I thank the Presidency for bringing this topic into discussion, and the Commission for all its efforts. In Finland, we fully recognize the challenging situation and take it seriously. We have taken action to respond to the challenges. I recently appointed a working group to assess solutions to problems of e-commerce.
We emphasize that the effective implementation of existing legislation is of utmost importance. The commission has a strong role here, not least because of its powers under the DSA, as we saw last Friday. It is important to emphasize that economic operators are responsible for product compliance. We should facilitate compliance. Focusing only on market surveillance might send the wrong message about who is responsible and who needs to do better.
Because the challenges posed by e-commerce are EU-wide and global, I highlight that efficient solutions are needed at the EU level. Here, we support the Commission's work on the European Product Act and see that it might be justified to assess the need for even stronger measures. We look forward to continuing the exchange on this topic. Thank you very much.
Speaker 8
Thank you, Martin, and thank you to the presidency for facilitating this very important discussion today and a similar one at last week's Telecommunications Council. Both the Commission's e-commerce communication published last February and today's discussion note highlight the growing regulatory challenge posed by third-country imports, particularly via e-commerce. There is no question Europe needs to do more to ensure a level playing field between market participants operating in the single market and to close any enforcement gaps. Ireland has established a national e-commerce task force to create a unified national response, but national initiatives alone, like establishing a task force, are insufficient given the scale of the challenge. Ireland supports further proportionate EU-level legislative action, including the forthcoming EU Product Act, the possible establishment of an EU market surveillance authority, and the possible establishment of a tiered European enforcement approach.
On the Digital Services Act, we welcome the recent evaluation, which shows the complementarity of the regulation with other Union law. Our competent authorities are available to assist the Commission in expediting ongoing or future investigations, and we welcome the recent news of a formal request for information issued to Shine. It is now time to fully enforce the DSA, the General Product Safety Regulation, and the recently agreed toy safety regulation, once operational, which will all establish clear obligations for online marketplaces to ensure accountability and traceability. These regulations and market surveillance efforts must be complemented by fully aligned customs code reforms, which do not create legal and regulatory uncertainty. Furthermore, both these lines of defense must be resourced accordingly in the next multi-annual financial framework through the Single Market and Customs Program.
Lastly, the 2,000 e-commerce directive prohibits general monitoring and only provides provisions enshrined in the case law of the European Court of Justice. We will continue to support this framework until it is shown to be no longer fit for purpose. Lastly, we look forward to further cooperation in this space and to the Commission's evaluation of their e-commerce communication, which we believe is due for publication in early 2026. Thank you. Great.
Thank you.
Speaker 1
Thank you very much, Peter. Then we go to Spain, Fernando. And after that, Eva from Sweden.
Speaker 9
And before continuing in Spanish, let me thank you for the excellent presentation that you made on this point, and also the Executive Vice President's introduction. Thank you.
Thank you to the Commission for that significant input on the importance of building a safe e-commerce market. We think that with this aim, we should continue to galvanize e-commerce in Europe, focusing both on European companies, particularly SMEs who have the greatest difficulties operating in the digital environment, but also on our citizens. Both need us to build a real level playing field with equal opportunities and conditions to compete in this market. The real value of Europe should continue to be the openness of our markets, while we also strengthen the internal electronic market, which is a matter of removing internal barriers for the improvement of our companies and citizens. So, I welcome the creation of a new surveillance authority for Europe, which should have real executive capacity to be operative and efficient in its mission.
It should have capacities for two main areas: to stop products that aren't compliant with EU legislation, and secondly, the capacity to establish infringements and impose sanctions on non-compliant companies. We'll be closer to achieving this aim if we unite and add to each other's efforts in market surveillance. Also, Spain supports the proposal for the modernization and digitalization of products. There should be digitalized information for products because information is powerful for consumers, and our consumers are already electronic consumers. It's also key to remove the threshold of the €150 exemption.
We should agree on that because the figures, as the commission has highlighted, for small package sending have doubled compared to 2023 and tripled compared to the year before. The customs rights should ensure that we have only high-quality products coming into the market, and it should be a joint accountability among operators, platforms, and e-commerce systems. However, there must also be obligations as well as opportunities. Thank you.
And.
Speaker 10
While the recent reports of illegal products are absolutely unacceptable. Such products have no place in our market. France said it well earlier, and it should be made very clear to providers of online marketplaces and their sellers that we expect them to comply with the EU obligations. To try to respond to the broader questions posed by the presidency here today, I want to start by saying that Sweden is working intensively on multiple fronts to strengthen cooperation and coordination nationally, seeking to amplify impacts and regulatory oversight. It remains essential to intensify cooperation and coordination also at the EU level.
We appreciate the efforts from the commission here to help us break the silos. As regards regulation, we must start with ensuring full implementation and strong enforcement of our existing tools such as the DSA and GPSR. In addition, Sweden welcomes the agreement to remove the EUR 150 duty exemption. Hopefully, we will soon have the new Union Customs Code in place, including a Union handling fee and increased responsibility for platforms. Regarding the forthcoming European Product Act, as well as other future proposals, Sweden encourages the Commission to ensure a thorough impact assessment, including an analysis of links to other relevant legislation.
In this context, Sweden believes that a streamlined use of the digital project passport could be a game changer for the single market if done with business, particularly SMEs' perspectives, and administrative burdens in mind. Thank you.
Speaker 1
Great, Eva. Thank you so much. On to Bulgaria. And after that, we will go to Slovenia. Bulgaria?
Speaker 11
Thank you. Bulgaria expresses its strong concern about the unprecedented growth of e-commerce imports from third countries, which not only present serious challenges for customs and market surveillance authorities, but also have a significant negative impact on the competitiveness of European enterprises and thus become a threat to the functioning of the single market. Given the cross-border nature of the problem, the joint efforts for enhanced surveillance at the EU level should be focused primarily on mobilizing and utilizing the available resources for feasible, well-coordinated, and efficient measures within the existing EU legislation toolbox. This includes the launched actions to enhance customs controls, the information campaigns by national competent authorities in the member states, directing consumers to identify risks of non-compliant products, as well as sectorial initiatives for sharing best practices. We should take into account the growing need to enhance the capacity of the national competent authorities.
Addressing the challenges posed by e-commerce requires the adoption of new legislative measures, including the envisaged European Product Act. Such measures should aim at establishing a clear and coherent regulatory framework, defining precise and enforceable obligations for economic operators, and respecting the better regulation principles. With regard to online platforms, we consider as potentially effective the introduction of so-called ex post control that allows the removal of content from the platform where a risk of noncompliance of a product has been identified, instead of monitoring all uploaded content. Thank you.
Missus Triniamo.
Speaker 14
We agree with most of what has been said so far, but we all know that our task is to protect the European consumer in all member states. But we believe that the single market is something that must be promoted and built up, and this will save Europe from going down. And e-commerce is one of the very important fields here. And we should set the priorities together, and we wouldn't then need a directive to regulate this, but rather a regulation. A second thing that I find important is that the relevant directorates of the commission work together.
Some commissioners keep saying that we must sign new agreements, but some have already been signed. But all of this must be connected to what we are talking about today, right here. Thank you.
Speaker 15
Thank you, Chair. Romania considers that strengthening customer protection and ensuring fair competition in e-commerce must be prioritized at the EU level. First, digital platforms need higher transparency, including clear information on recommendation algorithms and a ban on manipulative practices. We also support stronger but smarter control of products sold online, especially those imported from outside the EU. Second, online subscriptions require stricter rules, a simple cancellation mechanism, and the elimination of abusive automatic renewals.
Fair competition also depends on harmonizing tax rules, including consistent VAT application and action against evasion by non-EU traders. Third, customer education is essential. An EU-wide campaign to identify fake reviews, misleading offers, and check product authenticity can significantly reduce the risks. Marketplaces, both EU and non-EU, must also be held accountable when they fail to meet their legal obligations. Finally, we need stronger cooperation between member states, faster information exchange, coordinated controls, and harmonized sanctions.
Only through a unified approach can we prevent the removal of unsafe products in one member state from remaining available in others.
Speaker 1
Thank you. Thank you so much, Vuel. And then we go to Eleftherios from Greece. And after that, Greater Ivan. Thank you, President.
I will speak in Greek. We
Speaker 16
I would like to thank the presidency for adding this challenging issue of e-commerce to the agenda. And I will not forget, mister, you talked about one out of 2,000,000 products being unsafe, and most of them are important products. Therefore, we have to take measures in this field. We need more effective market supervision. We need to guarantee imported goods through supervision mechanisms, such as lifting the duty-free threshold for low-value goods.
We also have to eliminate any problems that are created through the platforms. We need more accountability for online platforms with regard to illegal registrations and obligatory validation of identity. And finally, we also need to boost the competitiveness of European businesses. With regard to the second question put by the presidency, we need enhanced cooperation between competent authorities. We need systematic monitoring and updating of the regulatory framework.
We need to use AI and also inform and make businesses aware of the voluntary compliance. Thank you.
Speaker 17
Thank you, Chair. We thank the presidency for putting this important topic on today's agenda. Croatia fully shares the deep concerns regarding the operation of e-commerce platforms from third countries. This is no longer just a competition issue, but a direct threat to the security of our citizens and the functioning of the single market. Therefore, we support the effective implementation of the Digital Services Act.
On the first question, for customs controls, we should strengthen the systematic data exchange on shipments from third countries at both EU and national levels. We should implement comparison with third countries on customs data to ensure equal treatment of products regardless of origin and to prevent abuses in cross-border online sales. For customs reform, we support a new governance model that establishes the EU Customs Authority and the EU Customs Data Hub to enable unified risk management and more coordinated controls. On the second question, for stronger and more operational coordination among all surveillance authorities, we should standardize data exchange formats, deadlines, and procedures to ensure uniform rule application and enforcement across member states. In addition, the upcoming European Product Act should address online platforms, greater responsibility, and contractual issues between EU consumers and non-EU traders.
In conclusion, a modernized regulatory framework alone falls short. We must establish stronger cooperation among enforcement authorities in the EU and in third countries. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much. We go on to Listerena, Ebinas, and after that, Marco from Italy.
Speaker 18
Thank you, Chair. Dear colleagues, we share the president's concerns regarding e-commerce. At the same time, we believe that any measure should remain within the principles established by the European Court of Justice and preserve the existing product safety responsibility regime. In our view, two elements are essential. First, we must strengthen customs and market surveillance authorities and increase their cooperation, including dedicated support for our national authorities under the Single Market and Customs Program.
We also remain open to the idea of establishing a new EU-level market surveillance authority to oversee e-commerce, especially very large platforms. Second, we must ensure the full and effective enforcement of the Digital Services Act. The DCA provides a powerful set of tools, including the crisis response mechanism, the powers of digital services coordinators to restrict access to services, and the Commission's ability to impose sanctions on very large platforms. These tools must be used prominently. To conclude, we underlined that adding a new layer of requirements is unlikely to deter these harnessed companies but will increase the burden on compliant new companies.
Our focus instead must be on enforcement, strengthening institutions, raising consumer awareness about the quality of products, and incentivizing the purchase of new products. Thank you. Thank you so much, Marco, Italy.
Speaker 20
You, Chair. To protect consumers, ensure fair competition, and improve European businesses' competitiveness, what we need are further measures at the national and EU levels. These measures should include stricter enforcement of existing rules, rolling out new targeted laws when necessary, and coordinated actions at the European level, as well as customs measures such as duties and tariffs. At a national level, we could take on administrative and legal initiatives to tackle unfair competition from platforms selling unsafe or non-compliant products. To improve coordination and strengthen enforcement in the current regulatory framework, we need closer cooperation between national authorities, advanced information-sharing mechanisms, and the development of innovative tools for customs controls and consumer protection.
We need new legislative measures to increase the liability of online platforms for the products they sell, in light of the constant concerns regarding unsafe or non-compliant goods. I would also like to recall the letter sent to the Commission by France. We joined France, together with 13 other members, in subscribing to this letter to ensure greater protection for our consumers. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much, Marco. We go on to Germany and then to the Czech Republic. Helen?
Speaker 21
Thank you very much. Online trade, especially when it comes to imports from third countries in 2024. In the European Union, 600,000,000 low-value packages. E, under 150s reached the union, doubled in 2023 and quadrupled in 2022. These third-country products do not respect European standards, which exist today, and therefore, they hamper the competitiveness of those companies that sell products in compliance with our rules. They also hamper the rights of consumers.
It also represents a challenge to the entire internal market. That is why we need measures. When it comes to market surveillance for online trade, we have to increase it. And therefore, we believe that having an EU MSA is necessary, and it should have specific competencies when it comes to sanctions, among others. We also need a new authority when it comes to e-commerce platforms, especially when the national legislation is not enough.
Furthermore, we need cooperation when it comes to MSAs and customs authorities, and MSAs should also be strengthened to ensure that, when it comes to infringements, they can act. That is why we have to define solutions that allow us to implement sanctions. When it comes to e-commerce enforcement, we have to do so in a timely manner because that will send a strong message regarding the removal of the 150 threshold and ensure that it can be implemented by 2026. We'd also ask the Commission to implement the DSA before thinking of new legal measures. That is why we do call for an EU transparency database.
And Germany appeals to the Commission and all of the member states to continue working together against those traders and platforms that are not compliant with the existing rules, to ensure that we can promote fair competitiveness. Thank you.
Speaker 1
So much, Helen. We go on to Stefan from the Czech Republic, and after that, Malta.
Speaker 22
Thank you for the floor. We acknowledge the grave challenges presented by third-country online marketplaces, particularly given their increasing dominance, significant growth of cross-border imports directly to consumers, and the associated compliance risks with EU rules and standards. In this regard, we welcome the initiation of the discussion, which is timely given the gravity of the issues mentioned by many of you. It is clear we cannot go on like this. It is clear that we cannot go on like this. We need to employ every tool provided by the current legislative framework while working on new frameworks at the European level where needed, as their potential is not yet fully exhausted to provide for a fair, transparent, and secure digital single market.
This is also necessary to substantially strengthen product-market surveillance in the online environment. Given the cross-border nature of e-commerce, solutions are best developed using a harmonized EU-level approach, such as by organizing joint control activities. We already see examples of effective cooperation, such as the coordinated investigation of Tenwen Chain, which we welcome as a positive demonstration of interinstitutional collaboration at the European level. We should launch more awareness campaigns for consumers and warn them about the possible risks of buying products on online marketplaces from far outside the EU. Explosive growth in the volume of dangerous and non-compliant products leads to serious risks for the health and safety of consumers.
This situation also has a significant negative impact on both the environment as well as the competitiveness of EU producers who comply with the EU rules. In addition, we support the EU customs reform, which will help tackle the challenges once it is adopted. But it seems evident we cannot wait until 2028, and we support work on a QuickPick realistic solution as soon as possible in 2026. Thank you very much.
Speaker 1
Great. Thank you very much. We go on to Chris from Malta, and then Manuela from Portugal.
Speaker 23
Chris? Thank you. Chair Malta acknowledges the need to address the realities our enforcement authorities face due to the exponential growth of e-commerce imports. These trends present significant challenges and negatively impact the competitiveness of our SMEs. We need to take action to protect consumers against unsafe products.
We must also avoid limiting their choices, and at the same time, ensure a level playing field for European businesses at the national and EU levels. Structured cooperation frameworks between authorities responsible for consumer protection, customs, market surveillance, and online enforcement are essential. While Mota continues to strengthen its national measures and invest in resources, the scale and cross-border nature of e-commerce demand a coordinated approach at the EU level. In this regard, we call for the proper implementation of the General Product Safety Regulation and the Digital Services Act. Malta supports advancing EU-level initiatives and actions, including targeted support to enhance border controls and market checks, which are vital to ensure regulatory standards are met, thereby protecting both consumers and local businesses.
While national authorities must intensify inspections and testing, the scale of the challenge also demands sustained public awareness efforts. We call for the exchange of best practices, enhanced market intelligence, and continuous training. To achieve timely and effective enforcement, additional funding for joint EU actions and access to well-equipped laboratories and other customs and market surveillance instruments are indispensable. Robust national measures, coupled with a strong and unified EU framework, are essential to safeguard the single market from the risks posed by non-compliant products. We remain committed to upholding a fair, competitive, and secure environment for our businesses and consumers across Europe.
Thank you.
Speaker 1
Great. Thank you so much, Chris Maroela from Portugal, and then Fabienne from Luxembourg.
Speaker 24
Thank you, Minister. Portugal shares the concerns about the impact of e-commerce on product compliance and safety, consumer protection, and unfair competition. We need a strict reinforcement of existing rules, such as those set out in the Digital Services Act, the Market Surveillance Regulation, and the General Product Safety Regulation. This would already help reduce the presence of dangerous or non-compliant goods. Increasing coordination through mechanisms such as the European Market Surveillance Network and the Safety Gate, RAPEX, can promote uniformity in the application of rules and facilitate joint surveillance.
More generally, cooperation among national authorities within and beyond member states could be strengthened through shared information systems, common operational protocols, and joint teams specialized in e-commerce. Investing in digital control technologies, such as traceability systems and automated risk analysis tools, can help us filter the massive volume of low-value consignments. AI and big data can also help identify risk patterns in real time and guide inspections. We have also been looking into eco fees and extended producer responsibility for packaging, which we consider could have a significant impact on this type of e-commerce. Awareness campaigns targeting both businesses and consumers, especially the most vulnerable, are also key.
As regards market surveillance, customs control, laboratories, and awareness raising, the Single Market and Customs Program must continue supporting national authorities. Furthermore, we expect that the removal of the customs exemption of up to €150, as foreseen in the customs reform, will help reduce the massive entry of non-compliant products from third countries. Looking beyond, a revision of the market surveillance framework seems necessary to hold platforms accountable and to commit marketplaces to prior checking, alert procedures, and swift removal of illegal products from third countries. This way, when imports from third-country sellers are at stake, they will act as an integral part of the compliance chain. We therefore support the creation of a European Product Act, and we also look forward to the Digital Fairness Act proposal and to the revision of the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation.
Developing laboratory resources and testing capacity at the university level will be needed to complement the action of national authorities with more limited technical infrastructures. The creation of EU bodies, such as the EU Customs Authority, is very welcome in this regard. And finally, international cooperation must not be overlooked. It is key to negotiate agreements with third countries that harmonize standards and facilitate joint monitoring. Thank you.
Speaker 1
Thank you so much, Rosa. I'm sorry. Good. On to Fabian from Luxembourg, and then Estonia.
Thank you, Chair.
Speaker 25
We'd like to thank the Danish Presidency and the French delegation for taking the initiative to put this on the agenda. The Competitiveness Council is the most appropriate setting to have this debate, which touches on anarchy, and which we also adopted here at Compet very recently for some instruments. Three points. Firstly, practice shows that this problem is linked to non-compliance with European rules, not necessarily the absence or insufficiency of these rules. We also wish to state that Europe has equipped itself with more ambitious instruments, particularly vis-à-vis platforms.
Also, the current situation shows that we must step up border control and market surveillance efforts, which should be coordinated more at the European level. We have the DSA, and that should be fully and rigorously implemented throughout the entire internal market. We fully support the commission in its open investigation to ensure the protection of miners and efforts to step up cooperation between market surveillance and the customs authorities concerned. We also welcome the measures adopted by the commission in the last few days to target damaging products for consumers on certain online platforms. We hope that in the short term, the commission will adopt deterrence for certain stakeholders that repeatedly failed to comply.
We must also adjust our regulations, as we are doing with the customs code at the moment. But to give a structured, rapid, holistic solution to the illegal offer, we must scale up our efforts in prevention, detection, and rectification at the European and national levels. Thank you, Chair.
Speaker 12
Great. Thank you very much, Fabienne. We go on to Estonia, Catherine, and after that, to funds from Austria.
Speaker 26
Thank you. Estonia completely agrees that we need decisive and coordinated action to counter the influx of non-compliant and unsafe products from third countries. This is harming consumers and law-abiding European businesses. However, new regulations cannot deliver results if the current rules are not effectively enforced. We must significantly step up the enforcement of the Digital Services Act, especially when it comes to large online platforms.
Current e-commerce challenges impact the entire EU and therefore require a unified response. Coordinated action through EU joint inspection projects and adopting digital solutions, such as the digital product passport, will increase surveillance efficiency. We are also open to considering the idea of creating an EU market surveillance authority to supervise large platforms in the EU markets. Finally, we believe that the EU customs reform should be delivered to help better protect the EU borders. Beyond EU commerce, we are also deeply worried by the threats posed to our democratic societies by third-country platforms such as Telegram.
The platform allows unchecked circulation of violent and abusive content, as well as being a breeding ground for Russian disinformation. Also, it has been used to manipulate elections in European countries. Despite public data indicating that it meets the user threshold, Telegram has yet to be designated as a very large online platform. This lack of oversight compromises the safety of our society. Large platforms like Telegram must also take a higher level of responsibility.
Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much, Catherine. And then on to Austria, France, and after that, Hungary, Catherine. Thank you.
Speaker 27
You. What's particularly important is that the customs amounts are being revised. And Limember States again need to have a say here. As soon as possible next year, we will have to ensure the transposition of the instrument. Now, the existing regulations should be tested to see whether they really provide the level playing field we want.
Or are they, in fact, at a disadvantage compared to EU companies? I'm thinking particularly of direct imports because if that's not under the direct scope of the regulation, there will be a massive burden. Now, it's also important to have cooperation between all the various authorities. We already have good cooperation in Austria. For example, the market surveillance authority and customs authorities are well coordinated at the HIP.
That's not the case all over the EU. The commission already has very robust powers to use against platforms. However, the Digital Services Act has come into force at a time when the market is increasingly dominated by some players. So, we'll be following the French proposal with great interest. Business models like the ones described by the French did damage the European standards, and the Digital Fairness Act should be used to look at, for example, the possibility of sanctions being imposed. Ultrafast fashion should also be tackled.
A key point here is raising consumer awareness. Many people are buying from platforms from third countries, and they are not aware that these products don't meet EU standards and that they could cause damages. Thank you.
Speaker 28
Thank you, Chair. E-commerce is growing at a fast pace. None of us can ignore it. And with that growth comes a great responsibility to ensure that product safety and compliance teams work just as effectively online as offline. We have seen that Focus National Action delivers results.
In Hungary, our seven-point plan to reinforce controls on low-value parcels from third countries is already improving customs alerts, data flows, and risk profiles. This helps us intercept unsafe products before they reach customers and protect businesses that comply with the rules. But fragmented coordination still limits our collective effectiveness. We therefore need stronger high-level coordination, better data analysis, and more efficient information exchange. Digital solutions would also reduce the labor intensity of enforcement.
The upcoming EU product is a crucial opportunity to modernize our framework. We are open to strengthening EU-level coordination and analytical capacity while maintaining the established division of enforcement responsibilities. As we approach the review of the Consumer Protection Corporation regulation, we support improving coordination and data flows, but we do not see evidence to justify granting the commission direct enforcement power, similarly to the DSA model. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much, Katherine and Lynn. We go on to the Netherlands, Karola, and after that, Poland.
Speaker 29
Thank you, Chair. Out of the €12,000,000 daily packages, the Netherlands receives €3,000,000 as the first point of entry to the EU. So, we really feel the level playing field challenges, the dangers to competitiveness, and the challenges to consumer protection they bring. Therefore, we welcome the communication on e-commerce from earlier this year, and we also support the Commission's plan to eliminate the €150 customs duty relief on e-commerce as quickly as possible. But it has, of course, to be compliant with international trade obligations, such as those under the WTO.
As to your question, Mr. Chair, on what additional measures are needed, we call on the Commission to present initiatives that could help ensure that authorized representatives can actually be held accountable for product safety. Enforcement of legislation such as the DSA and the GPSR will also help in tackling e-commerce challenges. The proposed instruments by the commissions, such as customs reform, AI detection tools, the digital product passport, and the revision of consumer protection cooperation regulation, are also important steps forward in this slide. One note as a final remark.
Many legislative initiatives and instruments, like the DSA and the GPSR, are relatively new and have yet to take full effect. It's therefore too early, in our view, to comprehensively assess their impact. The same goes for the Customs Reform, as it has not yet entered into effect. It is important to await its impact before proposing new legislative acts, also in light of our shared ambition to reduce regulatory burdens. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Great. Thank you very much, Gaola. On to Poland. And then, after Poland, we will go to Libya.
Speaker 30
Thank you very much, sir. This is indeed a critical issue for Europe, both for the security of our consumers and for our businesses. Our companies are struggling with an uneven global level playing field. As the commissioner has said, we are flooded with a high number of parcels from third countries. In principle, we agree with the direction and measures outlined by the Commission and its communication on e-commerce.
However, the timeline of proposed actions is relatively distant, considering the dynamics of the challenge we are facing. Therefore, short-term actions are needed. We should focus primarily on implementing and enforcing the existing regulations. The proceedings conducted by the commission with respect to e-commerce platforms from third countries should be dealt with more swiftly. At the same time, it is essential to introduce the handling fee on low-value parcels at the EU level as soon as possible.
Different levels of enforcement capacity and digital tools in national administrations, as well as fragmented practices, are also major challenges. Efficient controls, supported by digital tools and better data exchange, along with more robust funding, will therefore help alleviate those problems. Thank you.
Speaker 31
Thank you, Chair. Latvia recognizes the rapid growth of e-commerce and that e-commerce introduces new risks and supervisory challenges, particularly in monitoring individual shipments, which can be resource-intensive and inefficient. We believe that solutions must be effective, risk-based, and leverage digital tools, including automated checks, enhanced laboratory capacities, and rapid testing methods. To ensure the safe and informed use of e-commerce, we need targeted measures to strengthen staff expertise, enhance digital skills, and educate consumers. Latvia considers that the current EU regulatory framework, including the DSA, the Market Surveillance Regulation, and the General Product Safety Regulation, is sufficient if fully applied.
Any new legislation should only be developed after a thorough impact assessment to avoid overregulation and to maintain the EU's competitiveness in a global market. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Great. Thank you. Then Nicodemas from Cyprus, and after that, the Chair of the High-Level Group.
Speaker 33
Sorry. Give me a second because we didn't ask for intervention, but let's do it. But if you want, no. But I will do it because you want me to.
Speaker 33
Thank you very much, and it's good to have a break from this monotonous dialogue. So, thank you, Chair. The rapid increase in small parcels arriving from third-party countries, particularly via e-commerce platforms, significantly strains customs and market surveillance resources. Cypress supports strengthened EU-level coordination, including the possible establishment of a European market surveillance authority, as smaller member states, in particular, would greatly benefit from shared expertise in digital tools and risk analysis systems. We also support introducing clearer and stronger obligations for online marketplace providers, including responsibility for verifying seller identity, ensuring that products have an EU-based responsible person, and swiftly removing dangerous products flagged through Safety Gate.
The removal of the 150 customs duty exemption is an important step towards closing loopholes that currently facilitate the massive inflow of noncompliant products from third countries. Finally, we emphasize the need for targeted EU funding and technical assistance to reinforce digitalization, AI-based risk assessment, and operational capacity in customs and market surveillance authorities, enabling all member states to reinforce compliance effectively and safeguard consumer protection and competitiveness. Thank you, Chair.
I thought so, actually.
Speaker 1
We have to keep you on your toes. Great. You're ready. Okay. Then, we go to the Chair of the High-Level Group on Competitiveness.
Patek, the floor is yours.
Speaker 35
Thank you, President, dear Executive Vice President, dear Ministers. I would like to share with you the conclusions from the meeting on November 18. At then, the group actually discussed the issue related to e-commerce as the key context of the challenges for market surveillance of products from third countries. And this discussion directly corresponded to the heat map exercise, which was the subject of the previous debate. Actually, preliminary results of the heat map show that difficulty controlling products imported from third countries and unequal levels of market surveillance across member states stand out as one of the most complex and cross-cutting barriers.
Exponential search of imports through e-commerce creates an uneven playing field between EO companies and those from third countries that do not comply with EO rules. HLG members highlighted that national measures alone are not sufficient to address this challenge. One problem that was particularly noted was the lack of resources at the national level, both from a skills and infrastructure perspective, especially testing facilities. In the short term, HLD members welcomed initiatives such as the priority control areas and encouraged the Commission to pursue follow-up actions, including skill development programs for national authorities and awareness campaigns for consumers. They emphasized the need for further sharing expertise and potentially launching cross-border initiatives, particularly on testing centers.
Digitization, including the digital product passport, was suggested as a potential game changer, with an emphasis on ensuring interoperable IT systems across national administrations and at a cross-border level. Delegations expressed mixed views on long-term measures. Some advocated for a revised, harmonized, and modernized legal framework, as the current one has proven ineffective against big players. Others preferred allowing the Digital Services Act to take full effect before introducing additional rules, thus potentially adding additional burdens. Thank you very much.
Yes. Thank you.
Speaker 2
Very quickly, I've taken from this exchange that we are all in favor of urgent, ambitious actions to summarize the situation and tie in with the discussion we had this morning. Europe cannot become a destination for industrial overcapacity and Chinese products. I think we have this scissor effect where probably e-commerce companies have margins. But in terms of capacity for innovation and in macroeconomic terms, whether it be their trade balance or economic growth, we are facing major difficulties. When it comes to responsibilities, we need to assure our businesses that abide by all European regulations the right level playing field, and we must protect our consumers.
The first test will probably be the trilogue, then on customs reform and the eco fee. And I invite all member states and national political leaders to really be rapid in the decisions that they make in that dialogue with the European Parliament. Thank you very much.
Speaker 1
Thank you so much, Stephane, and thank you to all the delegations for participating in what I guess is fair to say was a very good and, of course, very useful discussion. So, thank you all again for that. There's no doubt that this is a huge challenge, and we need to take action to try to fix the problems that we are facing. So, thank you very much. This will then close our exchange of views on e-commerce.
Then, colleagues, I would like now to give you an update on the legislative proposals we have been working on. I'm very proud that we have accomplished what we set out to during our presidency term. Let me take you through our main achievements. First of all, the Danish President made a deal with the parliament on two important pieces of legislation: the package travel directive and the measuring instrument directive. The agreement on the provision of the package travel directive creates better consumer rights. It reduces burdens for operators and clarifies the obligations on package organizers regarding issues such as refunds, insolvency protection, and the use of vouchers.
We have agreed on an amendment that will update the rules for measuring instruments. As I said, this will cover new devices that are important for the green and digital transition, such as electric cars, chargers, compressed gas dispensers, and terminal energy meters. The revised rules also prioritize digitalization and smart metering. They support the use of emerging gases, like hydrogen, to help decarbonize industrial processes. We have achieved this agreement just one year after the Commission tabled the proposal, showing our commitment to the twin transition.
This morning, we discussed the importance of simplifying rooms as a way to boost our competitiveness. In that sense, I'm happy with the important progress the Danish presidency has made on several Omnibus simplification packages. We have made an agreement with the Parliament on the Stop the Clock text regarding battery due diligence obligations. Also, that's, as you know, a part of the Omnibus IV package. We also agreed to delay some of the new labeling and packaging rules in the CLP regulation until 01/01/2028.
That's the Omnibus 6. We have a council position on the simplification proposals. We aim to extend certain mitigating measures for SMBs to small mid-caps, as well as on digitalization and common specifications. We have also reached the Council position on the proposal to simplify provisions in three major pieces of EU chemical legislation: the CLP regulation, the cosmetic regulation, and the biocidal products regulation, all while maintaining a high level of protection for human health and the environment. It will be up to our Cyprus colleagues to take the work forward with the European Parliament.
Last but not least, I really hope we will reach a deal tonight with the European Parliament on the Omnibus One package, amending the Corporate Sustainability Reporting (CSRD) and due diligence (CSDD) directives. This will be the cherry on top of the Danish presidency's work on simplification. So let's cross our fingers for that. We were also hoping to reach a deal on the regulation of the E-declaration. And we had very intensive negotiations with the Parliament, and we have found a solution to most issues.
However, finding the right landing zone on the latest political issues will take more time. We'll therefore hand over the file to our Cypress colleagues, and I trust that they will resume building compromises to move the file forward. I would like now to turn to the supplementary protection certificate file. The package has been under intensive negotiation in the council for more than 2 years now. Making progress on these proposals is complex, as we face tricky legal questions. Following the path paved by the Ukrainian, sorry, the Hungarian and the Polish presidencies, we have tried to advance the negotiations in the Council as much as possible.
We have managed to get broad support on important topics like the involvement of a network of the National Patent Office in the examination procedures and a clear majority for removing the pre-grant opposition procedures. However, there is still quite some work left for the incoming Cypriot Presidency. We hope that the work done during our presidency will help find solutions to the remaining issues in this difficult file. Finally, I want to mention the Single Market and Customs Program, part of the next budget, the MFF. We have made good progress on this file, and we seem close to an agreement within the council.
Before giving the floor, I would like, of course, to warmly thank the commission for all the support you have provided and continue to provide for us during these negotiations. So please, Stéphane, the floor is yours. Thank you.
Speaker 2
Thank you very much. And I would also welcome the efforts made by the Danish Presidency to move this legislative proposal forward. They are very important at this geopolitical and economic time. And congratulations on your various successes here. Very briefly, one of the files that hasn't been concluded is the declaration. The commission thanks the Danish presidency and regrets that the trialogue didn't come off.
We talked about the importance of the internal market and removing barriers today. And so, that was an occasion that was lost. I know Morton and the presidency. You did everything you could to align the points of view there. It was not possible.
And hopefully, the Cypriot presidency will be able to do that. With the full support of the commission, this is a file that we will have to bring back to the table, but it's a symbolic aspect, if you like, and it shows the difficulties that you have when you get down to the nitty-gritty on the internal market. Often, there are declarations from political leaders at summits, at European summits. They're very ambitious on this, and we really need to uphold that ambition while also defending all vested interests. But finding a landing zone is essential, particularly at the current juncture.
I'll leave it there, then. Congratulations on all your many successes on these important files. And the very best of luck to the Cypriot presidency for those remaining issues.
Speaker 1
Well, thank you very much, Stefan, again. And dear colleagues, your support has also been key in making progress in these very important files. So now we will hand over the floor to you, and we'll start with France. And after France, we'll go to Romania. France?
Thank you.
Speaker 36
You, Chair, and thank you for the work that you've done on the SPC. Since its launch in June 2023, the single patent system has been a success. The European Patent Office has recognized a high number of requests. The single patent should also be extended to medicine and pharmaceutical products. That's key for the competitiveness of the internal market.
It's now time to have an institutional provision on this that can work on the European patent, the European Patent Office, and the jurisdiction we have for patents. This will allow us to reduce costs and ensure a high level of quality expertise, in addition to coherence with the European patent system. And we invite the current and upcoming presidency to exchange on how we can develop new competencies for supplementary protection certificates in full respect of European legislation. In the coming months, French authorities will, with the presidency, the member states, and the commission, work constructively to come to the best framework for Unitary SPCs in Europe. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much. We go on to Biorel from Romania, and then Caola from the Netherlands.
Speaker 15
Thank you, Chair. Romania supports the initiative to introduce the unitary supplementary protection certificate as the natural next step following the unitary patent system. A coherent architecture built on the existing European Patent Office and the Unified Patent Court is the most efficient and predictable solution. This approach avoids one second. This approach avoids creating new administrative layers, keeps costs under control, and ensures high-quality examination.
It also strengthened European competitiveness in key sectors such as pharmaceuticals and plant protection. For Romania, it is important that national experts remain involved in the examination process and that the system remains accessible for SMEs with a balanced framework that supports innovation while keeping the market dynamic once protection expires. We support a rapid consultation with the EPO on the technical and legal aspects. And we are ready to work with the Presidency, the Commission, and the Members' Day to move this file forward. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much. And on to Kawala from the Netherlands, and after that, Alek from Poland.
Speaker 29
Thank you, Chair. And also, many thanks to your presidency for your important work on these files. I also wanted to speak to the SBCs. We see a strong need to make SBC procedures simpler and more harmonized. Our innovative companies depend on this.
Yet, we also see that the negotiations on a new SPC system remain stuck, and it actually slows down Europe's innovation and competitiveness. The unitary patent is working well and is valued by businesses. Therefore, a unitary SPC can complete the system, but only, of course, if it is simple, predictable, and aligned with the Unified Patent Court. To achieve this, we need to seriously explore a role for the European Patent Office. Therefore, we call on the presidency, the incoming presidency, and the commission to promptly consider inviting the IPO to discuss how it could take on a role in the SPC process.
Thank you.
Speaker 37
Yes. Thank you so much. On to Poland, and after that, Hungary. First of all, many thanks to the Danish Presidency for...
Speaker 30
All the progress you have achieved on all the legislative proposals. Let me focus on two on which the work will continue. First, on SPCs, this was also raised by my colleagues. We support the Commission's original proposal designating the EU IPO as the managing and issuing authority. The EU IPO, as an EU agency, meets key criteria of accountability, legal certainty, compliance with EU law, and full alignment with the EU institutional framework.
Assigning supervisory or decision-making functions to an external organization creates a real risk of insufficient judicial control by the Court of Justice and inconsistencies in the application of EU law. The European Patent Organization is an international organization operating under the Patent Convention, and it is not part of the EU's legal and institutional framework. In those uncertain times, we should not delegate our competencies to non-EU bodies. And lastly, on the declaration, as of today, we spent all day talking about simplifying, reducing barriers, and increasing our competitiveness. Let's use this enthusiasm to continue working on the e-declaration.
We keep our fingers crossed for the Cyprod presidency. Good luck.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much, Eric. On to Katherine from Hungary, and then France and Austria.
Speaker 28
Thank you, Chair. And let me start by thanking you for the information provided and your dedicated work during this semester on the different legislative files. I would like to mention a few words about the supplementary protection certificate. I share your assessment that it has been a very difficult case. And also, a very important one: the SPC reform is important for our pharmaceutical companies, and we support the business-friendly, simple system of granting SPCs, but with a very solid legal foundation.
We believe that a number of legal and institutional questions are still open. One of the most important things is that the Managing Office should be the EU IPO, in our view, and not the European Patent Office. The integration of the airport into the EU's legal order raises a number of legal and policy questions. And as you mentioned, there is still some work to be done on this. So, this question needs to be further considered.
Thanks.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much, Kathleen Fanz from Austria, and then Heilen from Germany afterwards. Yes, feeling done.
Speaker 27
Thanks very much. Once again, on this matter of the SPCs, like those who spoke before me, I think that we need manageable legal solutions within EU law. We have our doubts that the options currently under consideration would meet the criteria of legal certainty. And we support the most harmonized solution possible with, say, 27 of us, as has already been said, tackling jointly the still open questions. This needs to be an effective discussion.
Thank you.
Speaker 12
Thank you so much, Franz Helens, Germany, and after that, Spain. Thank you.
Speaker 21
You, including the work you've done. Surely, the aim should be to keep data processing within the EU and to get rid of unnecessary red tape. But of course, I have to plead for the retention of social standards and controllability. However, this is an important step towards a European single market for digital services. It does require enough flexibility.
This is something the Danish presidency has been working hard to achieve. Only with support from member states can we achieve this and ensure that the e-declaration will have low bureaucracy in the future, avoiding the return of bureaucracy so that we can finish the file. Now, on SPCs: yes, protection of IP is important for medicines and plant products. And we think that the robustness of a patient needs to be defended in this way. It must be something that's doable for the industry as well as having legal certainty.
We have our doubts about the EPO being the managing body here because the matters they are considering are not related to union law and do not always involve legal acts of the union. So the managing office cannot be the IPO because when they're testing the effective ingredients, this may require patents to be tested by the EPO. And that's exactly, I think, what the Danish presidency has suggested, which is to be welcomed: that we need to find out who the proper managing office will be. Thank you.
Thank you.
Speaker 38
Thank you very much, Chair, for your information and the work done. Vis-à-vis the SPC work, I just wished to echo what Poland, Hungary, Austria, and Germany have already said. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Great. Sorry. Thank you. Then Marco from Italy, and next, Orsa from Sweden. Thank you.
Speaker 20
You, Chair. Congratulations to the Danish presidency for all the work done up until now regarding the different legislative proposals. Two items. Minister Urso said that it is very important that we keep carrying out simplification. Indeed, Italy believes that simplification is key for the omnibus packages.
To echo other colleagues, we want to talk about the SPCs, as Italy supports what has been expressed by France and confirms everything that has been included in the joint declaration. In other words, it should be the EPO, the one to certify and publish the SPCs by involving the national offices as well as the United Patent Court when it comes to counterfeit and counter proposals. This is an important task when it comes to strengthening the internal market by 2028, and this is a political objective shared by the Council and the Commission after two and a half years of negotiations. And during this time, the European landscape has expressed its clear wishes regarding the harmonization of SPCs, plant products, and medical products. That's why we're open to dialogue with the current presidency, the future presidency, and all stakeholders when it comes to improving the SPCs.
Speaker 39
The insurance system is more transparent, accessible, certain, and even easier to forecast within the legal framework. Thank you.
Speaker 12
Marco, then we go to Sweden, Osa. And last but not least, Malta, Chris.
Speaker 40
Thank you, Chair, and thank you for keeping a high pace in many negotiations here, as you mentioned in your introduction, including on the SBC. Sweden is a strong supporter of a new system for unitary SBCs, but it is also important that we tailor it to the needs of the industry and keep regulatory burdens and costs to a minimum. We believe that the best way to attain this is to build upon what we already have and use the existing structures of the unitary patent system. We encourage the presidency and the incoming presidency to explore a setup based on the current actors in the European patent landscape. Thank you very much to the Danish Presidency for all your hard work on this file.
We also look forward to cooperating with the incoming Presidency, which kindly left some work here on this file. We are committed to supporting the incoming presidency on this important file to meet the needs and expectations of the industry. Thank you.
Speaker 23
Thank you, Chair, for the update on the state of play regarding the legislative files. Specifically, on the SPC, we do have reservations about the current direction that the file has taken. And I want to echo the concerns mentioned by Poland, Hungary, Germany, Austria, and Spain for the reasons mentioned there. And in addition, we also have concerns about a model that does not employ pre-grant opposition possibilities. And in this regard, we consider that the EU IPO should be the appropriate body for the management and granting function of SBCs.
Thank you.
Speaker 1
Thank you so much, Chris. Thank you all for the kind words and support for our presidency, and good luck wishes for the upcoming presidency. I can conclude that the council took note of the information provided by the presidency on these proposals here. The next item on the agenda will be discussed in nonpublic sessions, so we need to make sure that cameras are off.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.