House of Commons

12 March 2026

No chapters available yet

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:18 - 00:23
Speaker 1
The order.  Question is secretary of state for business trade, Laura Perksma. 
00:23 - 00:26
Speaker 2
Thank you, mister speaker.  Question one, please. 
00:26 - 00:27
Speaker 1
Minister.  Thank 
00:27 - 00:59
Speaker 3
you, mister speaker, and good morning.  With your permission, I'll answer questions one, nine, and 22 together.  This government is committed to strengthening rights for parents.  This April, we are introducing bereaved pair partners paternity leave and making unpaid parental leave and paternity leave day one rights, bringing over a million parents into scope.  Next year, we'll further improve protections for pregnant women and those returning from maternity leave, and the parental leave and pay review will conclude giving us recommendations and informing our next steps. 
01:00 - 01:00
Speaker 4
Okay. 
01:01 - 01:32
Speaker 2
You.  And the government is making really great strides in improving parental rights at work, But for kinship carers, it's still tough.  In Aylesbury, I met a wonderful lady who has become the kinship carer for her baby grandson, but she was only given ten days of paid leave from work and now has to take unpaid leave to care from him with for him, which is causing serious financial strain.  So will the minister join me in paying tribute to all of our kinship carers for their remarkable work?  And will she outline what discussions she's having across government to ensure that kinship carers get the support they deserve. 
01:32 - 02:15
Speaker 3
I thank my honourable friend for her really important question and absolutely recognise the enormous contribution that kinship carers make to children's lives and of those of her constituents.  This government is committed to helping more children grow up in safe, stable and loving homes within their family network whenever it is in their children's best interest.  And I want to acknowledge that incredible commitment and the generosity of kinship carers.  By opening their hearts and homes to our most vulnerable children, they are absolutely transforming young lives.  And we shouldn't underestimate the life changing difference that kinship carers make every single day. 

Are parental leave and pay reviews considering the needs of all working families who do not qualify for existing leave and pay entitlements, including kinship payors. 
02:15 - 02:15
Speaker 4
Thank 
02:16 - 02:40
Speaker 5
you, mister speaker.  Since 2004, the limit on relief for small employers at which they can reclaim statutory maternity pay has been set at £45,000.  SMEs, of course, want to support working parents, but they need our help to do so.  Could the minister re confirm whether as part of the parental leave review this will be looked at? 

02:40 - 02:41

Speaker 1

CHAIRMAN I

02:42 - 03:16

Speaker 3

thank my honourable friend for her question and for her advocacy on this issue. The government acknowledges that the class one national insurance contributions threshold used to determine eligibility for small employers' relief on parental pay has remained unchanged for several years. Part of this relief includes an additional compensation payment known as small employers' compensation, and last April, the government increased the SEC rates from 3% to 8.5% and will increase it to nine per cent from 06/2026. The Government keeps all eligibility criteria under review whilst balancing the needs of business and the Exchequer.

03:16 - 03:17

Speaker 1

Josh Dudley.

03:17 - 03:20

Speaker 6

Many of us on this side of the House have long been arguing for

03:20 - 03:21

Speaker 1

a boost to paternity leave, one

03:21 - 03:47

Speaker 6

of the proudest of the last Labour government. But one group that are being badly let down is self employed dads. Just one in six are taking leave after their children are born. And that's unpaid, meaning they face a drop in income of over £1,000 just for taking a couple of weeks off. Introducing paid pat leave for self employed dads would cost £38,000,000 at most, possibly as low as 13,000,000, but it'd be a huge win for dads, mums, and their babies.

So would the minister consider this as part of the ongoing parental leave review? Minister.

03:47 - 04:24

Speaker 3

I thank my honorable friend for his question and for his campaigning on this issue. As I've mentioned, the government's parental leave and pay review is underway and will conclude in early twenty twenty seven. We know the parental leave system needs to be improved and recognize that the current system doesn't do enough to support the many dads and partners who want to be hands on and actively involved in caring for their children. That's why this review is so important and will consider all current and upcoming parental leave and pay entitlements, looking at options to improve the support available to British working families and whether the support available meets the needs of working families who do not qualify these entitlements that he outlines and raises today in the house, such as self employed parents.

04:24 - 04:49

Speaker 7

I refer members to my register of interest as the chair of the All Party Parliamentary Group for Infant Feeding. One of the key barriers to women returning to the workplace is if they continue to breastfeed their children. Lot A of workplaces are not providing facilities for expressing and then storing that breast milk. Can the minister update the house on what the department is doing to support women back into the workplace when they are still breastfeeding their children?

04:50 - 04:52

Speaker 8

I thank the

04:52 - 05:20

Speaker 3

honourable member for her really important question and for raising this at the House today. We are absolutely committed to ensuring that every parent feels secure at work, particularly mums when they are breastfeeding and returning to the workplace. With the Employment Rights Act, she will know the different bits of legislation we are introducing to help women back into work, whether it's making it more unlawful to dismiss pregnant women, mothers on maternity leave, making it easier for people to take flexible working as well, and providing those provisions in the workplace. I'd be really keen to hear more about the work that she's doing in APPG and members across this House.

05:20 - 05:21

Speaker 1

Thank you. James Sheldon.

05:21 - 05:53

Speaker 9

Mister speaker, again, I thank the minister very much for that very positive answer. Minister, there's nobody in this house or further afield doesn't welcome the improvement of parental rights at work. I had a chance to speak to the minister beforehand, so should know where my question's coming from. And that's on behalf of the small and medium businesses who may find it difficult to cover those who get the parental leave when it comes off work. Has anything been done to ensure that the businesses, especially the small ones, might find time or find it difficult to find the time to put someone in place to overlook their job when they're off.

05:54 - 05:55

Speaker 8

Thank you so much.

05:55 - 06:26

Speaker 3

I thank the honourable member for his question and agree family friendly workplaces strengthen our workforce and our economy and are absolutely important for reducing the turnover of staff and retaining their high quality staff as well. And that's why it's really important that we're working with businesses small and large. It's wider our wider parental pay and leave review. In every area of my work, really conscious to work really closely with our businesses at the different areas, but recognize that, you know, we're in the same place of keeping people into work and especially supporting parents and making sure that workplaces are much more family friendly.

06:26 - 06:27

Speaker 1

Speaker All the above.

06:27 - 06:30

Speaker 8

Next question to you, mister Speaker. Minister.

06:30 - 06:56

Speaker 10

Speaker Thank you, mister Speaker. We're supporting private sector investment in Buckingham and Bletchley by working with partners across the Oxford Cambridge growth corridor to find new opportunities for business. And I'd like to acknowledge the work of my honorable friend in launching the Bletchley Investment Task Force, which is bringing together private capital and local partners using infrastructure such as East West Rail to improve connectivity and working with OxCam partners so local businesses benefit from innovation skills and inward investment.

06:56 - 06:57

Speaker 1

Colm Anderson.

06:57 - 07:10

Speaker 11

Thank you, mister speaker, and I thank the minister for his response. As he says, I launched the Bletchley investment task force last year to attract the businesses, investments, jobs, and apprenticeships that local people need, and we're

07:23 - 07:36

Speaker 10

speaker. I I'd like to congratulate him for his work with the Bletchley Investment Task Force, and I know that businesses in his constituencies such as Mvisics, Carnage, and and Pulsar have benefited from the work that he's done, and I'd be very happy to ensure that he gets the meeting with the relevant minister.

07:36 - 08:06

Speaker 8

Frank Randolph. Question number three, sir. Minister. Mister speaker, promoting Scottish industry overseas is one of our prime objectives. Whether it's opening up new markets like India for Scotch whisky and or say key securing new beef opportunities in The United States Of America, securing contracts for Scottish steel in new bridges in Ukraine, or financial services around the world, we are on the case.

I've even seen Tunnock's Caramels in Lulu, in Doha.

08:08 - 08:09

Speaker 1

Frank McNally.

08:09 - 08:49

Speaker 12

Thank you very much, mister speaker, and I'm grateful to my honorable friend for that answer. With up to £8,200,000,000 of private investment, the Lanarkshire AI Growth Zone delivered by this Labour government represents one of the largest industrial investments in the history of Scotland. At its heart is a partnership between Lanarkshire's own data vita and American cloud computing company, Coreweave. Such partnerships are critical to supporting the industries of the future. So what further steps can my right honourable friend take to promote Scottish companies overseas to secure such high quality jobs and deliver even stronger growth?

08:49 - 09:15

Speaker 8

Minister. Well, I pay tribute to my honorable friend on the work that he has done to make sure that the UK government has delivered in his constituency, and and I'm I'm glad that he raises the Lanarkshire AI growth zone because it's a really important part of trying to make sure that the industries of the future are absolutely at the heart of the jobs of the future in Scotland. And I look forward to the SNP welcoming it welcoming this in the next moments.

09:15 - 09:16

Speaker 1

Here's the chance. Krishnan.

09:16 - 09:58

Speaker 13

Thank you, mister speaker. And, of course, I'll always welcome that Scotland punches above its weight, whether it be industries abroad or whether it be investment in Scotland. And, indeed, under the SNP, the last ten years have shown that foreign direct investment in Scotland has been higher outside London for the last ten years than anywhere else in The UK, something I would expect the UK government to be also celebrating. However, mister speaker, this week we learned through a leaked memo that the prime minister told senior ministers of this government to go against the wishes of the Scottish Government when taking decisions. So I wanted to ask from the secretary of state, does he agree with the prime minister, and does he not agree that Scotland makes the best decisions when it's the people of Scotland that makes these decisions, and that will only happen when it becomes independent.

09:58 - 10:01

Speaker 14

It's

10:01 - 10:35

Speaker 8

like an open goal, isn't it, mister speaker? Sorry. You haven't got a view. Look. I believe that we achieve far more by our common endeavor than we do by going it alone.

And that's why I'm a passionate supporter of the union. And, of course, there are specific things about the Scottish economy that we want to drive forward. For instance, 54% of Scottish exports go into the European Union. If we manage to secure the SPS deal that we're trying to negotiate at the moment with the EU, that will pay enormous dividends to the e to Scotland, which it would never secure if it was entirely on its own. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

10:36 - 10:37

Speaker 1

Dave Robertson.

10:39 - 10:39

Speaker 15

Thank you, mister speaker.

10:39 - 10:42

Speaker 1

Question number four, please. Minister.

10:42 - 10:43

Speaker 10

Thank you, mister speaker.

10:43 - 10:43

Speaker 16

And I

10:43 - 11:12

Speaker 10

thank my honorable friend who's who's such a an advocate champion of businesses in the Litchfield constituency. And as I'm sure he's aware, we're making sure that The UK is the best place in the world to invest by backing priority sectors through our industrial strategy. The advanced manufacturing sector plan will strengthen our UK supply chains in sectors such as automotive, aerospace, and clean energy industries, ensuring that businesses in Litchfield, such as manufacturing and logistics, get the skills, technology and new commercial opportunities that they need. Robert.

11:12 - 11:49

Speaker 15

Thank you, mister speaker. The quantum technology sector is a hugely important one for The UK. We have world leading researchers and businesses innovating in healthcare, defence and many more industries. But quantum firms tell me that as they grow they find it harder and harder and harder to secure the investment that they need to commercialise those exceptional ideas. The risks that we face is that they take their businesses out of The UK in order to seek that investment.

That's why I've recently established an all party parliamentary group for Quantum Technologies to help members in both houses understand this rapidly evolving sector. What can the government do, though, to ensure that our quantum businesses get the investment they need to grow here in The UK?

11:49 - 12:35

Speaker 10

Minister. Thank you, mister speaker. And I'd like to thank my honorable friend, for his work, in establishing the all party parliamentary group on quantum technologies. It's quite right to identify these technologies as, as very important for the future and also to put his finger on this particular problem we have in The UK of involving brilliant at innovating and investing in research, but historically struggling at scale up. And that is not something that this government is prepared to accept.

And so just as we're investing in, in critical minerals and in automotive, connected and mobility technologies, we're also investing in this area as well. The British business bank is doubling its annual investments ensure that we can, support scale up and bring at least 10 new to market growth, stage funds so that we can leverage those pension investments and help British businesses to stay and grow in The UK.

12:35 - 12:35

Speaker 1

I'll try

12:35 - 12:35

Speaker 12

and do

12:35 - 12:35

Speaker 8

the most.

12:35 - 12:36

Speaker 17

Thank you,

12:36 - 12:52

Speaker 18

mister speaker. Increasing private sector investment is now being seriously held back by the failure of this government to publish its defense industrial plan. Has the minister any idea when this much awaited document will hit the streets?

12:53 - 12:54

Speaker 19

Mister.

12:54 - 13:17

Speaker 10

Thank you, mister speaker. And and, of course, the government recognizes the importance of the defense industrial plan, and that that will be, brought to the house, as as soon as it possibly can be. But on this point of, private sector investment, we, we saw £10,000,000,000 of investment come in from the regional summits, £79,000,000,000 of investment identified in the last quarterly report from the industrial strategy. Investors are voting with their money, they are investing in The UK.

13:17 - 13:19

Speaker 1

Shadow minister, Dan Haribald.

13:21 - 13:41

Speaker 20

Thank you very much, mister speaker. There was a new private sector investor into Royal Mail last year. And as we heard yesterday in the house, the regulator has let universal service obligation slip. So could the minister update the house on how his colleagues meeting with the regulator went yesterday?

13:42 - 13:53

Speaker 10

Minister. Thank you, mister speaker. And the the post office, and, minister for Royal Mail is sat beside me, and, of course, he he spent ninety minutes in the house, just yesterday. Ex That's a

13:53 - 13:53

Speaker 21

good question.

13:53 - 14:18

Speaker 10

Yeah. Ninety minutes in the house yesterday answering questions from, members who have problems on their service, around the whole of the country, and I've seen them in my constituency as well. The government is is clearly not happy by, the level of, service, from Royal Mail, and and, the, the shadow minister will hear in a fulsome response in question 15, when the appropriate minister will be at the dispatch box and be able to tell her everything she needs to know about that particular meeting.

14:18 - 14:19

Speaker 4

There is an assumption we'll

14:19 - 14:21

Speaker 1

get there. Lieutenant Pinto Chodzinski.

14:22 - 14:25

Speaker 22

Thank you very much, mister speaker. Number five, please.

14:25 - 14:27

Speaker 1

Okay. Joe Stoeck.

14:27 - 14:52

Speaker 23

Thank you very much, mister speaker. Mister speaker, the operation, I'll answer question five and eleven together. The industrial strategy focuses on business investment and creating high quality jobs. We back our strengths in unblocking barriers, including £1,200,000,000 worth of skills investment by years 2028, '29. This is the Labour government investing in skills, investing in jobs, investing in creating wealth and opportunity across The United Kingdom.

14:52 - 14:54

Speaker 1

Yeah. You're a pent up, mister chief.

14:54 - 15:14

Speaker 22

Thank you so much, mister speaker, and I thank the secretary of state for his answer. Communities like mine in Hendon were let down by fourteen years of economic ins instability and a lack of a strategic approach towards driving growth under the party opposite. Can the secretary of state set out how our modern industrial strategy will help accelerate growth in places like Hendon? Yeah.

15:15 - 15:52

Speaker 23

So I can absolutely. And firstly, Hendon has a champion in you, in him, mister speaker, and that did that counts for a lot, and in you, mister speaker, in making sure we get through these questions so swiftly and efficiently. I can actually assure the house that the industrial strategy has delivered over £7,900 higher in average wages in those sectors that we are supporting with the industrial strategy. Over 50,000 jobs supported through investment commitments made in the industrial strategy eight sectors simply in the last quarter. This is a government attracting investment, spending it wisely, and making sure all communities, including Henley, benefit from it.

15:52 - 15:53

Speaker 1

Thank

15:53 - 16:26

Speaker 24

you, mister speaker. It is no secret that clean energy is creating the next generation of well paid jobs, and it's essential that South Dorset gets its fair share of these jobs. The development of offshore wind at Portland, including the exciting Moorwind and Portwind projects, would certainly help to create much needed maritime, engineering, and construction jobs for local people. So with all that in mind, will the minister work with me and the Department of Energy, Security, and Net Zero, and the Crown Estate to support the development of offshore wind off the coast of Portland?

16:27 - 16:28

Speaker 25

So, sir.

16:28 - 17:11

Speaker 23

I thank you for his question. Of course, it would be a pleasure to work with him to unlock more investment in offshore wind, in South Dorset. Dorset Council and the Crown Estate have already committed up to a million pounds to support a feasibility study for a £500,000,000 clean energy, port facility adjacent to Portland Port by energy developer Moorwind. Also, the clean energy industries are expected to support, around The United Kingdom, 860,000 jobs across The UK by 2030, including up to 100,000 direct and indirect jobs in offshore wind. Now thanks to the work that he is putting in, I am sure that South Dorset will benefit from this incredible growing British industry.

17:12 - 17:13

Speaker 1

Should mister Dan Harriet Paul?

17:13 - 17:14

Speaker 16

Here. Here.

17:14 - 17:40

Speaker 20

Thank you very much, mister speaker. Now, of course, there are lots of well paid jobs in the steel sector. In fact, the taxpayer is now subsidizing every job at British Steel to the tune of a 110,000. So can the secretary of state update the house on how his negotiations are going with Jingyi and when he will finally publish his long awaited steel strategy?

17:41 - 17:41

Speaker 1

So, sir.

17:42 - 18:05

Speaker 23

I'm very grateful for her question. Of course, after fourteen years of running the economy in a steel industry, we have landed in the place that we have that this government is having to sort out. I can reassure her that negotiations with Jinye are well underway, and I will be updating the house shortly, on those on progress there and, of course, on the strategy that I've been working very hard on with colleagues on behalf of the steel industry.

18:05 - 18:09

Speaker 1

Sarah Oldley, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

18:09 - 19:01

Speaker 26

Very much, mister speaker. Research from the entrepreneurs network shows that 54% of Britain's 100 fastest growing companies have a foreign born founder or cofounder. International entrepreneurs play a vital role in driving innovation, investment and job creation across The UK, and yet this government is recklessly introducing unworkable visa regulations for these very people. Since the budget in October 2024, a 110,000 jobs have been lost in the hospitality sector, 74,000 in retail, and 700,000 graduates are currently unemployed. Youth unemployment has just hit 16%.

So what impact assessment has the government undertaken of the impact on job creation due to their proposed changes to indefinite leave to remain, and what conversations has the minister had with the home secretary regarding this damaging disincentive to those looking to build their businesses and create jobs here in The UK?

19:02 - 19:03

Speaker 1

So stay.

19:03 - 19:49

Speaker 23

I'm afraid, mister speaker, that she describes the world as it is in the doom laden, lib dem world in which she must inhabit, but not the real world that's inhabited by entrepreneurs and businesses right around the country. The reality is, in the real world, that 381,000 more people are in work because of this labor government since the start of 2025. She may have missed that my department, under my leadership and this team, have set up the global talent task force in the department of business and trade accompanied by a global talent visa. We are out there around the world hunting down the best talent, attracting them to The UK, aligning it with investment, making this the best place to invest, to scale, to grow, to scale a business anywhere in the world?

19:49 - 19:50

Speaker 16

Here again.

19:50 - 19:53

Speaker 27

Thank you, mister speaker. Question number six, please.

19:53 - 20:11

Speaker 8

Minister. Thank you, mister speaker. We want to build new opportunities for startups and scale ups, to export around the world. That's why we are providing tailored market advice, free training through our business academy, export finance, and on the ground support in international markets.

20:11 - 20:41

Speaker 27

Thank you, mister speaker. British fashion is recognized globally its creativity. At London Fashion Week just gone, designers such as Erdem, Tohlu Kocher, Simone Brocher showcased the very best of British talent. And with international designers international buyers up by 17%, we that we not only have the raw talent here, but the business minds to commercialise it internationally. What steps is the department taking to help emerging British fashion brands translate that creativity into export growth and scale internationally?

Internationally?

20:42 - 21:32

Speaker 8

She makes a really good point both by standing here on London Fashion Week by raising the points. She's quite right that there are lots of businesses in Northamptonshire working in this field as well. One of the key things that we do is through NewGen. We provide support for, in fact, many of the people that she just met mentioned, including Edem and Simone Rocher, to be able to start out finding new export markets overseas. We send people to London to Paris Fashion Week and to PitiWomo, our creative industries are a really important part of how we intend to build on that in the future.

And to use a term from another cons business in her constituency, I think she has Weetabix. What we really want is everybody to have three Weetabix, for breakfast so that we can really export around the world. Rishi Sun.

21:32 - 22:03

Speaker 28

Thank you, mister speaker. At the recent, India AI summit, I was delighted to participate in an event with the deputy prime minister highlighting the opportunities for British and Indian growing technology companies to do more in each other's markets, and I'm looking forward to another such event in London in the coming weeks. Will the minister join me in commending both of our high commissioners, their excellencies, Lindy Cameron and Vikram Doriswami, for their steadfast commitment to strengthening the links between our two fantastic technology sectors?

22:04 - 22:59

Speaker 8

He makes a really good point, and and I noticed that he was commending the government on securing the free trade agreement with India, which previous governments weren't able to secure, which he did so generously. And I'm really pleased that we mister speaker, I might have misled the house previously because I might have suggested that the India free trade agreement, would be entering into force, this summer, but I'm very hopeful that it will actually be entering into force this spring. The key thing is not just to have a free trade agreement, but to be able to deploy it and make sure that businesses take an opportunity to do so. Our two high commissioners, both, in India and here, are absolutely essential to making that happen. And I look forward to working with the right honorable gentleman to do that not only in India, but also, as I know, in, Ukraine.

He's now been appointed to help the, Zelenskyy's government in reconstruction in Ukraine, and I'm the minister for Ukraine

23:12 - 23:37

Speaker 29

And I welcome the minister's previous comments, and enthusiasm, actually, for our most innovative companies. But he will know that the chancellor's decision to cut VCT rate relief will be very damaging. How does the minister explain the disconnect, therefore, between his department's words and what the chancellor is actually doing?

23:38 - 24:21

Speaker 8

Well, actually, what we're trying to do is we're trying to very much focus on those key sectors where we know we can really deliver. And that's precisely what, the we're trying to bring together the trade strategy, the small business strategy, and the industrial strategy is designed to do. I was delighted yesterday to be at the security and policing trade event down in Farnborough, and it was fascinating seeing small companies. A lot of that sector is SME companies, who have really been supported either by by very different departments at the home office, DBT, treasury, and others as well, to be able to scale up and and take their their product to market. I was able to persuade, I think, the Malaysian government, to secure quite a few contracts

24:21 - 24:24

Speaker 1

with British businesses as well. Perfect.

24:24 - 24:54

Speaker 29

Well, I'm very grateful, to him for that answer. I was asking specifically about VCT rate relief, and the reason I ask is the last time that the rate relief was cut was under the last Labour government, and fundraising was cut by two thirds. And it took a decade for that to recover for the sector. So specifically on VCT rate relief, which has been cut from 30 to 20%, will he commit to meeting with the VCTA, the industry body, and will he take their concerns to the chancellor and ask her to reverse course?

24:55 - 25:19

Speaker 8

Minister. Of course, I'm happy to meet, with the body, and I'm and I'm happy to listen to their concerns as we do all the time. But I just want to make this point that, what we're seeing at the moment is a a concentration in DBT on trying to make sure that what we do well in this country, we really have an opportunity to do even better at. And that focus, is a key part of what what the, what the the our

25:36 - 26:08

Speaker 3

The Government recognises the central role that the hospitality sector plays in supporting jobs, sustaining high streets and strengthening community life. That's why we've significantly increased the hospitality support fund, providing £10,000,000 over three years to help hospitality businesses become more resilient, allowing them to thrive. We've permanently reduced business rates for eligible RHL properties, benefiting 750,000 properties. We're also beginning cross government work on our high streets strategy developed with business and representatives to be published later this year.

26:09 - 26:09

Speaker 1

Edmund. Thank

26:09 - 26:38

Speaker 30

you, mister speaker. Energy costs are obviously a huge issue for hospitality businesses in a large rural constituency like Dumfries and but they're also an issue for hospitality business customers because generally people travel to these businesses using their cars. So will the minister and her colleagues in the department lobby the prime minister and the chancellor to ensure that the proposed rise in fuel duty does not go ahead in September?

26:38 - 26:39

Speaker 1

I

26:41 - 27:22

Speaker 3

thank him for his question and do recognise that energy costs remain one of the biggest pressures facing hospitality businesses. I meet with them regularly just this week and really to ensure that I'm aware of the concerns and their experiences on the grounds. The real risk to to businesses is dependence on volatile international gas markets, which we, of course, seen and have been left as exposed to in terms of our global energy shocks. More of our own power here in Britain is absolutely what this government is prioritising and focused on, to tackle the root cause of unstable energy markets. We're working really closely with businesses and across the sector to understand the pressures, and we'll continue to do so in a responsible way.

27:22 - 28:04

Speaker 31

Mr. Governing Williamson. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I myself minister is deeply concerned about the rising rate of youth unemployment which is currently standing at 15%.

And one of the key employers of young people is for hospitality sector as well as for retail sector. But when I speak to businesses in my constituency of Stonebrake, Worley and Penkridge, so many of them reference the fact that they've been hit by business rates and the impact of national insurance. This is discouraging investment and reducing job opportunities for young people. What action is the minister taking to reverse this trend? I

28:06 - 29:10

Speaker 3

thank him for his question and agree that hospitality does provide those first jobs and career pathways for young people and is really, really important as an opportunity. As I've said many times in the House, it was my experience into employment, and I'm sure for many other colleagues. And young people absolutely deserve that opportunity, is why our focus is on skills, on training and getting young people into work. We'll continue to back employers who take on apprenticeships and provide those opportunities, whether it is providing those full training costs for young apprentices aged 16 to 21, to employers not required to pay national insurance contributions for all apprentices under the age of 25. I would say that under their watch, under the previous government, the number of youth apprentices cut by 40%.

And the previous government presided over a massive increase in young people, not in education, employment and training. So whilst I recognise what we are working with, we do want to provide those opportunities for young people. We will not leave a giant entire generation of young people behind. And that's looking at a £120,000,000 youth guarantee and so much more to provide that employment support and give them a guaranteed job and recognize the sector as vital.

29:10 - 29:25

Speaker 11

Mister speaker, six hospitality venues are closing every single day under this government. And if the government actually asks the sector why that is, they'll tell you. They'll tell the government. It's because the jobs killing national insurance tax rises.

29:25 - 29:26

Speaker 32

That is literally a tax

29:26 - 29:30

Speaker 11

on jobs, as well as the red tape and additional costs of the employment

29:57 - 30:25

Speaker 3

because hospitality, in particular, as a vital sector for our high streets and for people, thrives when the economy grows, when wages rise, and when people have more money to spend. We will always support our hospitality businesses, but do so responsibly and sustainably. They are the heart of our high streets and community, and that's why we are backing them, reforming our our the broken system that they left and did nothing about when it looks to business rates and building that better support system for them so they can thrive and support all employment and particularly for our young people.

30:25 - 30:26

Speaker 4

Sir Cubs.

30:26 - 30:34

Speaker 33

Thank you, mister speaker. Drivers looking for refreshment on the motorway have regular signs to point them to hospitality available. But for drivers of EVs, it's less easy to

30:34 - 30:34

Speaker 34

tell where they can

30:34 - 30:44

Speaker 33

get a coffee and a charge because of arcane rules that are preventing EV signage on motorways. This is also a problem on a roads, and one charge company told me they were quoted a £150,000

30:44 - 30:46

Speaker 35

to put up two signs on an a road. Given

30:47 - 30:56

Speaker 33

that many hospitality businesses have partnerships with EV charge providers, will the minister work with the DFT to change these mad signage rules and support hospitality and EV charging? Minister.

30:57 - 31:34

Speaker 3

I thank my honorable friend for her question and for raising up this issue and bringing it to the house today. We are working closely with industry to promote consumer confidence in electric vehicles and their charging infrastructure. At the February 2026, the government and industry have supported the installation of over a 118,000 public chargers. And in a move to help EV drivers plug into the rapidly expanding charging network, government is modernizing EV charging signage on major air roads. Changes will allow larger EV charging hubs to be signposted from major air roads too, and we're working with local authorities to make it easier to provide that signage to charging facilities on local roads.

31:34 - 32:03

Speaker 36

Speaker, for almost a year, constituents of my right honorable friend and neighbor, the member for Dumfriesa, Clydesdale and Tweeddale, have enjoyed, the benefits of the guest beer agreement. Given the society of independent brewers believe that a the right to buy a guest beer drives customers into pubs. Can the minister please update the house on when she expects to announce the results of the beer market review and the merits of introducing a guest beer agreement in England?

32:04 - 32:04

Speaker 8

Minister.

32:05 - 32:29

Speaker 3

I thank my honourable friend for her question. I know we've discussed this at length, she champions her pubs in her constituencies, and I absolutely thank her for it. We do recognise the importance of independent breweries and pubs and remain committed to ensuring that the beer and pub sector remains diverse, competitive and rooted in local communities. We have reviewed the beer market to assess any barriers facing small breweries, and we'll announce the outcome in due course.

32:29 - 32:31

Speaker 1

Sir, Alden Liberal, Dubbercross Post.

32:32 - 33:15

Speaker 26

In the q four quarterly economic survey of 2025, 52% of businesses reported utility costs as a pressure that's driving them to raise prices with a particular impact in the hospitality sector. Recent research by the British Chamber of Commerce shows that over a quarter of businesses will struggle to pay their energy bills over the next twelve months, and this survey was conducted before the recent escalation in The Middle East. Last week's OBR forecast did not take into account any potential impact from the jump in oil prices triggered by the strikes on Iran. The fuel duty hike in September is already expected to hit families and small businesses hard. So will the, secretary of state speak to the chancellor now about scrapping this damaging policy?

33:15 - 33:16

Speaker 37

I

33:18 - 34:05

Speaker 3

thank the the honorable member for her question. She will have heard my earlier remarks that I do absolutely recognise and meet with hospitality businesses regularly to hear their concerns and pressures and, of course, energy costs, has come up as many as one of the the biggest pressures facing hospitality businesses. And I do recognise the concerns they will have looking at the global conflict and the impact it will have. You 'll have heard my earlier answer about the real risk to to businesses is that dependence on the volatile international gas markets that have left us exposed. And she will know the work that we're doing across government and different departments in recognizing this and and tackling that root cause to provide better support for businesses when we look at those instable energy markets that have left it exposed so we have more power here in Britain.

And we'll work with the sector really closely and across government.

34:05 - 34:07

Speaker 8

Tom Brutland. Question number eight, please.

34:10 - 34:43

Speaker 23

Thank you, mister speaker. With your permission, I will answer questions eight and fourteen together. The UK EU collaboration is vital for growth and for security. 46% of The UK's total trade is, after all, with the EU. We have had, in recent weeks, I've gone to Brussels and signed a new competition and cooperation agreement furthering the partnership between our two territories in the interests of businesses.

And I had very constructive meetings with commissioners Ribeira, Minsatu, and Wirkanen.

34:44 - 35:10

Speaker 38

Thank you, mister speaker. After years of the conservatives and reform trying their best to ruin our relationship with our nearest neighbors, damaging business exports, this labor government has been working hard to ensure my constituents feel the benefit of our renewed relationship with the European Union. Could my right honorable friend update the house on the work he's doing to ensure businesses like Worthing's very own musical instrument business, Hobgoblin, can benefit from the resetting relations that we've had with our European neighbors.

35:11 - 35:45

Speaker 23

I'm very grateful for my honorary friend and neighbor down in sunny Sussex. The reset relationship with the EU, has been fundamental, and and it it is is delivered delivered for businesses right across Britain, including Hobgoblin there on the sunny South Coast Of England in in Worthing. We are tackling the barriers to trade. And, of course, the dialogues that we have with the EU on business mobility and recognition of professional services will unlock future opportunities into the future. Where working with the EU delivers for Britain, we will do so enthusiastically.

35:45 - 35:46

Speaker 1

Yeah. Lintas.

35:47 - 36:22

Speaker 39

Thank you, mister speaker. I put on record my role as chair of the APPG for Bulgaria. And the APPG recently visited Sofia where we met with businesses who are particularly keen to build their trade relationships with this country, particularly in the energy and tech sector, and also the work being done by the embassy in partnership with the UK Bulgarian Chamber of Commerce. Does the Secretary of State agree with me when we're looking at trade with Europe, we need to be looking at many of those newer markets in Eastern Europe where they're keen to create trade, particularly where we have an active business community from that country in The UK keen to build a partnership which will benefit our country and our partner in Europe.

36:22 - 36:23

Speaker 1

So stay.

36:23 - 37:13

Speaker 23

My old friend is absolutely right, and his work on in this area is, of course, vitally important. Our trade with every one of the newer EU member states has increased over the last twelve months to September 2025. And to give examples of the kind of work that we're they've engaged in supporting Rolls Royce, which is planning to build up to six small modular reactor units in The Czech Republic. One of the EU's fastest growing economies in Europe is, in fact, Poland, where we won Polish air where Polish Airways will order the first 40 Airbus aircrafts benefiting the British economy. And we've agreed to start trade policy dialogue with Norway, negotiations on a trade agreement with Switzerland to boost trade services as well.

Non EU countries, of course, play a vital role in that tapestry as well. Vicky Slade.

37:13 - 37:57

Speaker 40

Thank you, mister speaker. A sector needing urgent attention here is road haulage, moving goods but also people across Europe in tourism, education, but importantly, film, TV, sport, and music. My constituent Cameron works mainly in the music sector supporting European tours and festivals. He tells me that the ninety and one hundred eighty rule is leading to cancelled events and job losses, with some firms only employing dual nationals or using European firms rather than British ones, or flying drivers home to swap out on these longer journeys, avoiding breaching the rules. So although the rules have existed since 2021, as the minister told me, they have not been fully enforced.

So as part of The UK EU reset, will he look at finding a way to help professional drivers keep the show on the road?

37:57 - 38:11

Speaker 23

Yeah. I'm very grateful. She does point to one of the areas where the Brexit deal negotiated by the other the the Conservative Party let down Britain. It is part of the negotiations. We are aware of these issues, and we will see what we can do for these sectors into the future.

38:11 - 38:12

Speaker 1

Thanks, James.

38:13 - 38:40

Speaker 41

Thank you very much, mister speaker. I've heard from so many businesses in Wokingham who have suffered post Brexit with masses of red tape limiting their exports. Losing key trade relationships in Europe has meant many local businesses have seen their profits evaporate. So what is the government doing to develop and strengthen the trade with Europe so businesses in working and can start to grow again? Agreeing a bespoke customs union would be a really good start.

38:40 - 38:41

Speaker 16

Here. Here.

38:42 - 39:22

Speaker 23

So I'm very grateful he will know that where we have the most agency is regulation in this country, when we are pledging to reduce the burden on business by 25%. The issue of regulation, than the barriers to trade was something that I mentioned in my visit and meetings with three EU commissioners just in the last fortnight. It is something we're very aware of. And, of course, part of the reset is to lower the burdens. It is good to see, mister speaker, that, members from, many parties in this house have a real interest, in talking and questioning and engaging in debate about the EU and healing the relationships and creating new opportunities with our biggest trading partner, with the exception of one who are all sitting silent.

I want Speaker.

39:23 - 39:24

Speaker 1

Daniel France.

39:24 - 39:27

Speaker 42

Question number 10, mister speaker. Melissa.

39:29 - 40:05

Speaker 3

Thank you, mister speaker. Pubs and micro pubs like the ones in the honorable members constituency at the heart of all our communities. From April, every pub will receive a 15% reduction on its business rates bill when bills are then frozen in real terms for a further two years. Three quarters of pubs will see their bills stay the same or fall, saving the average pub around £1,650 next year. We're also launching a review of how pubs are valued for business rates and investing £10,000,000 through the hospitality support fund to help pubs diversify and improve productivity across the sector.

40:05 - 40:06

Speaker 4

Francis.

40:06 - 40:36

Speaker 43

Yeah. I thank the minister for her comments. I recently visited the Birds and the Barrel Micro pub in Barnhurst. They also operate and the Brewery in Slay Green in my constituency. They informed me that due to the number of Thai tenants in the constituency, they've accessed less than 8% of the market in local pubs across Bexley from Crayford.

And like my own little friend from Carlisle, they are pressing me and I'll be pressing to see the update to the pub's code to support micro pubs and breweries. So come our honorable friend, give some more detail on when we may see some progress on that matter.

40:36 - 41:12

Speaker 3

I thank my honorable friend for his question and what a champion he is for micro pubs and his constituency from Ankabee to Bakewell, Tart, Stout, Bexley Brewery showcases an excellent range of beers and small brewers and micro pubs such as the Bird and Barrel play a vital role in supporting local communities and economies. Alongside the beer market review, the government is carrying out a statue review of the pubs code and pubs codes adjudicator, as well as a post implementation review to assess the code's impact since 2016. The government's report covering this work will be published as soon as practicable.

41:12 - 41:15

Speaker 23

Thank you, mister speaker. Question number 12, please.

41:17 - 41:17

Speaker 1

Minister.

41:18 - 41:53

Speaker 3

Thank you, mister speaker. The government closely monitors business confidence across the hospitality sector and recognises that businesses face real and sustained pressures. That is why we have announced targeted support measures to help the sector remain resilient, including permanently lower businesses rates for eligible retail hospitality and leisure properties. A significant increase to the hospitality support fund, action to reduce regulatory burdens, pressing ahead with licensing reform for a new national licensing policy framework, and greater flexibility for pubs and hospitality venues, allowing them to thrive.

41:54 - 42:07

Speaker 23

Hospitality businesses in the Scottish borders are being squeezed by rising energy costs, wage and supply bills as well. Does the minister think that this Labour Government's jobs tax has helped or hindered the hospitality sector? I

42:09 - 42:46

Speaker 3

thank the honourable member for his question. Business confidence depends on economic stability, and that is exactly what this government is delivering. A stable government where businesses can't invest in growth, and he will have heard my commitment to the hospitality sector, my personal investment in it, but my absolute determination to work closely with them so we can build those stronger local economies that mean stronger rights and thriving stronger high streets and thriving businesses. And especially when working people have more money to spend in businesses, they will see that stronger demand, and that's what we are absolutely focused on, building that stability for our local communities and businesses to benefit too.

42:46 - 42:49

Speaker 44

Thank you, mister speaker. Number 15.

42:49 - 42:50

Speaker 1

We've murdered it.

42:52 - 43:25

Speaker 21

Worth Worth waiting for. We are clear that Royal Mail's service performance has not been good enough. Ofcom is the independent regulator for the sector, I met with them yesterday to stress the widespread concerns of honourable members about standards of service. My honourable friend has deep experience in this area, and I welcome his engagement with the main delivery office in Corby, where Royal Mail tell me that they are currently recruiting nine new postal workers to support the timeliness and quality of their postal services.

43:26 - 43:26

Speaker 1

Good morning.

43:27 - 44:03

Speaker 44

Mister speaker, quality of service in the Royal Mail has been at shocking levels over recent years. Considering that Royal Mail is legally obliged to deliver a universal service obligation and to keep our communities connected, would the minister join me in calling on the owners of Royal Mail to honor their agreement to end the two tier workforce to bring new entrants terms and conditions up to the same standard as those of substantive Royal Mail employees which is leading to 50 per cent of new entrants leaving the service within one year, is leading to a decimation in the quality of service?

44:04 - 44:49

Speaker 21

He is absolutely correct to highlight that the quality of service issues are linked directly with issues around the terms and conditions of the workers. It is precisely because we take that connection so seriously that my right honourable friend, the Secretary of State, convened the meeting between the unions and the management of Royal Mail, the owners of Royal Mail. When I met Ofcom yesterday, they made it clear that they expect the plan for improvements within quality of service to be in place within days of an agreement being reached with the unions, and we'll certainly hold them to that.

44:49 - 45:07

Speaker 25

Ehru. Thank you, mister speaker. Does the minister agree with me that by being asked to focus on parcels over letters and having overtime hours for deliveries restricted, many hardworking postal workers will feel they're undermining public trust in the Royal Mail?

45:07 - 45:08

Speaker 45

Yes. So

45:08 - 45:31

Speaker 21

I discussed the issue of the prioritization of parcels with Ofcom yesterday. They had previously investigated this matter. Think it is fair to say that they have heard that widespread concern about the issue he raises around the House, And if they if they are continue to be concerned about that, they won't hesitate to investigate that again.

45:31 - 45:34

Speaker 1

We now go to topicals. Jane Carcombe.

45:34 - 45:36

Speaker 46

Thank you, mister speaker. Question number one.

45:38 - 45:39

Speaker 1

Mister speaker.

45:39 - 46:48

Speaker 23

Thank you, mister speaker. Mister speaker, in the face of global uncertainty, this government is acting with boldness, creativity, and urgency to back British business. Soon, we'll publish our steel strategy to secure internationally competitive, investable, and sustainable future for British made steel. We are making highly significant interventions on energy. The supercharger discount will will increase next month, cutting costs further for around 500 of the most energy intensive businesses.

Our BICS will see electricity bills for 7,000 businesses slashed by up to 25% from 2027, and we're helping businesses scale and to grow with the British Business Bank making the largest ever equity investments and UKEF working with banks to generate £11,000,000,000 worth of support for small businesses to export. And we're opening new markets with the India free trade arrangement now through both houses of this parliament. Just last week, I was in Brussels to sign a new competition cooperation agreement. And, mister speaker, I expect my department to match the dynamism of the best of British entrepreneurs, and I am proud to report that with this Labour government, is.

46:48 - 46:49

Speaker 1

Ed Kirkland.

46:49 - 47:19

Speaker 46

Thank you, mister speaker. Sole Fire, in my constituency, is an example of a cooperative business that benefits its community. They deliver organic sustainable food. I also have Segar Varg Stagg in Ponce Nuth who are trying to take over and run their local pub and the ship in at Portlow which has already done it. Setting up or transitioning to a co op model can be difficult.

Can the minister update me on what support the government are providing to help new co ops, start up, and existing businesses transition to employee ownership?

47:19 - 47:21

Speaker 47

Secretary. I'm

47:21 - 47:40

Speaker 23

very grateful for her. Really important question. She will know that our manifesto committed to double the size of coops in the mutual sector, and we are well on the way to doing so. She will know also that a consultation just on this, issue closed, very recently. We are analyzing the results, and we will be making further statements very, very soon.

47:40 - 47:43

Speaker 1

Andrew Griffith, Shadow Secretary of State.

47:43 - 48:24

Speaker 42

Thank you, mister speaker. Government doesn't create jobs. Business does. Yet with unemployment rising, this is the last chance, to ask the secretary of state, a question ahead of the April when a tsunami of business rate rises will hit. Shops and restaurants will see on average a 50% increase, and the business rates of hotels will double.

He and I both represent wonderful Sussex constituencies, full of hospitality, high street, and tourism businesses. But young people need those jobs. So for their sake and for others, will he finally postpone his business rate rise?

48:24 - 48:26

Speaker 1

So so.

48:26 - 49:13

Speaker 23

I'm grateful for his question. I enjoy these exchanges with the shadow secretary of state. I noticed that the reform, self styled, shadow secretary of state, who was I called a shadowy secretary of state, isn't in his place despite being just next door in the tea room a few minutes ago. I think that speaks volumes. Mister speaker, the, honorable dental knows that this government under this government and with this government, the economy, the private sector has created three three hundred and eighty thousand jobs.

We will continue to grow the economy and grow people in work and make sure that people are benefiting from all of the rights that we're delivering them, which are pro business, are pro worker. He spent fourteen years letting down Britain. Now he spent eighteen months talking it down.

49:13 - 49:57

Speaker 42

Andrew. Well, mister speaker, the honorable gentleman forgets I've not even been here for fourteen years. Sometime some days it feels like that, but I can assure him that is not the case. No answer to that question. Let me try another, mister speaker.

Does the secretary of state agree there's something pretty badly wrong with employment law in this country when Peter Mandelson, the friend of a convicted pedophile and leaker of classified government documents, walks away with a £75,000 payoff? The permanent secretary thinks that's good value for money. Will he now review Labour's policy of uncapping employment tribunal payouts for the highest earners? So stay.

49:57 - 50:52

Speaker 23

As is often the case when we have these exchanges, he spends a lot of his time slagging off his own record in office. They had fourteen years to reform tribunal rights. They didn't even touch it. They had fourteen years to update the workers' rights, and employment status in this country. They didn't do it.

The economy moved forward. They failed to move forward. Now I will now turn to the issue of Peter Mandelson, and I will do so by starting by recognizing that at the heart of this debate, at the heart of the issues surrounding, this situation, there are victims. Those victims are in my mind today, and they have been all the way through, and they are in my mind, as I answer this question. We will be we will make sure that those victims get the justice that they deserve.

And when it comes to the issue surrounding Peter Mandelson, there are multiple inquiries underway. Thames Valley Police is leading on a criminal inquiry, and I will leave it at that.

50:53 - 50:54

Speaker 1

Chancellor Gilbert.

50:55 - 50:55

Speaker 48

Thank you,

50:55 - 50:56

Speaker 2

mister speaker. There are further

50:56 - 51:19

Speaker 49

members to declarations of interest as a former employee of Osdaw. The new rights of change union access and employment rights act could be game changing, but proposals to cap fines for breaking new rules at £75,000 is loose change for union busting employees like Amazon. Will my hon. Frank consider setting fines at a percentage of global turnover, like in cases of GDP breaches, for ticket touting websites?

51:21 - 51:22

Speaker 13

I

51:22 - 51:49

Speaker 3

thank my honourable friend for her question and for championing her work in this area. The Government believes that trade unions are absolutely essential for tackling insecurity, inequality, discrimination, enforcement, and low pay. And we're providing a legal framework for businesses and unions to negotiate access to the workplace. We must recognize that for this framework to effectively facilitate access, it's got to be supported and and why we are consulting on this and officials are reviewing those responses, and we'll publish a response in due course.

51:49 - 51:50

Speaker 1

Mister Ashley Fox.

51:50 - 52:19

Speaker 41

Mister speaker, small businesses in Bridgewater were hit last year with the chancellor's jobs tax. This year, they face the additional burdens of his unemployment bill and higher business rates. So the last thing they want with petrol and diesel pricing, prices rising is a fuel duty increase. Will he speak to the chancellor and ask her to cancel her fuel duty rise in September? Minister.

52:20 - 52:35

Speaker 21

Well, you know, fuel duty is currently frozen at the moment. But the key thing we can do to make sure that we deal with this instability in energy prices is make sure that we de escalate in the region. I'd remind him that his party has been calling for us to join the war.

52:35 - 52:36

Speaker 1

Exactly. Thanks, Thank

52:37 - 53:02

Speaker 50

you, mister I'm a proud Labour and Co operative MP, and Co operatives, of course, play a really important role in our economy, building a fairer and more resilient economy that gives workers and communities a stake in the businesses they rely on. Now this Labour government has a world leading commitment to double the size of the cooperative sector, but can the minister update me on the progress towards achieving that ambition, and what further measures are being brought forward to help cooperatives grow?

53:02 - 53:19

Speaker 21

Well, she's absolutely right. I think cooperatives create a really important sense of connection at a time when people feel disconnected. But co ops and mutuals are also more resilient and more productive, that's why we have the commitment we've made. Our call to evidence has closed,

53:19 - 53:19

Speaker 15

and we're

53:19 - 53:34

Speaker 21

working on the proposals that will flow out of that. It's perhaps a good day to also say that I really welcome the news this morning that the John Lewis bonus is returning and congratulate them on their results today.

53:35 - 53:36

Speaker 1

In room.

53:37 - 53:57

Speaker 25

Thank you, mister speaker. Many small businesses in my constituency of North Devon will now be gearing up for a busy tourist season that is just around the corner. What steps is the government taking to support small businesses in the Southwest to help them make the most of their biggest window of opportunity over the summer? Our

53:59 - 54:26

Speaker 21

small business strategy sets out the range of support we're taking to support small businesses. That includes an increase of £4,000,000,000 backing the finance that is available to businesses so that they can invest to take advantage of those opportunities. We will also be bringing forward the strongest proposals on late payments to improve cash flow to small businesses, as well as cutting red tape so that they can take advantage of the opportunities he describes.

54:26 - 55:00

Speaker 51

Madam Nayal. Mister speaker, can I first wish my constituents a happy great Grimsby Day to commemorate the signing of our charter in 12:01? UK titanium dioxide production like that at Tronox is under threat from aggressive Chinese practices funneling cheap product through companies that they buy, run down, and hollow out circumventing protective levies. Can the minister tell me what he's doing to ensure a level playing field so we don't see industry skills and jobs draining out of The UK?

55:01 - 55:32

Speaker 8

Finish. I thank my member for standing up for the business in her own constituency. She's absolutely right. The trade remedies authority is investigating, and she knows I would urge industry to participate in that, though I can't comment on the precise details of that investigation because it might eventually come on my onto my table. But the important thing is that we need to make sure, that dumping is not acceptable for British businesses because it makes it impossible for us to prosper.

We will do everything in our power to make sure that we use the remedies that we have available to us to protect British businesses.

55:33 - 55:34

Speaker 14

Tom Toohey.

55:34 - 56:02

Speaker 52

Thank you, mister speaker. May I ask, the secretary of state, if you'd care, to join me for a pint of Larkins in Kent, where we can discuss the effect of his business rate relief on small businesses. Because the high streets in Tunbridge, Edinbridge and Borough Green are doing as well as they possibly can, but they are struggling. And one of the reasons they're struggling is because of the hit on hospitality industries. It's already cost the man of Kent in East Peckham, but perhaps we can meet at another pub, and he can hear from the public and themselves as to what the impact is.

56:02 - 56:04

Speaker 1

So stay.

56:04 - 56:42

Speaker 23

I'm I'm always grateful for invitations to drinks with the right and older gentleman. I I might well ask him to come to Hove, though. I've been to his his constituency a a number of times over the years. It's about time he visited mine. And and in that time when he's there, he will see a thriving hospitality sector, but a sec hospitality sector that, yes, it does need support in order to meet to meet its full potential.

We accept that, which is why we've introduced so many support packages that we have since coming into office. But what the hospitality sector needs is what every other sector in the economy needs, a stable or industrial strategy. State. You've got a

56:42 - 56:46

Speaker 1

lot about venture who are desperate to get in, and they want to hear from you. Douglas McGallister.

56:46 - 56:46

Speaker 4

I'd

56:46 - 57:13

Speaker 53

to be Thank you, mister speaker. Scotch whisky has faced sky high import tariffs with India for years, as high as 150 per cent. The Scottish Whisky Association has described the tariff cuts as transformational, and the Scottish whisky industry supports thousands of jobs in my Western Partnership constituency. Does the minister agree that the increased bilateral trade with India is set to grow the Scottish economy by a £119,000,000 a year, and it's a massive win for the whiskey industry Western Bartonshire in Scotland?

57:13 - 57:44

Speaker 8

He's absolutely right, and I commend him for supporting his constituents. But but equally importantly, there there are many Scottish products that we need to make sure that British businesses are able to take opportunities such as the India FTA affords and and build on those so that we can build British businesses that are strong. We've also got, for Scotch Whisky, geographical identification in in Argentina. We need to build these gains across the world. Liz Jarvis.

Thank

57:44 - 58:05

Speaker 54

you, mister speaker. Recently, I had the pleasure of visiting Ironoptic, a fantastic local employer in Charmers Ford. They tell me that UK SMEs are being impacted by export license turnaround times, which are currently taking up to six months for non controlled goods. Can the minister confirm when we will see a significant improvement in these turnaround times?

58:05 - 58:25

Speaker 8

So, militia, I'm very happy to meet with her. If she wants to take me take me through some of the specific issues in her constituency, I've done that for several honorable members, and we've we've had a roundtable last week to try and get these debt time timelines down. Sometimes it's difficult. The the median time that we sort these out is in fourteen days, but if she's got problems, I'm very happy to tackle them with her.

58:26 - 58:27

Speaker 1

Sergei Ebs.

58:27 - 58:50

Speaker 55

Thank you, mister speaker. From Kingswood accountants to automated analytics and our young traders market, Doncaster is home to many businesses run by ambitious entrepreneurs. So can the, minister update the house on how government's, support such as the start up loan scheme and the growth guarantee scheme are helping young entrepreneurs and start ups and what more we can do in this area?

58:50 - 58:51

Speaker 25

I'll give them a call.

58:51 - 59:14

Speaker 23

I'm very grateful for her advocacy on this. Britain is the start up capital of Europe. We are doubling down to make sure that once they start it up, that they can scale up, stay here, and build their innovation here, which is why we're also the unicorn, capital of Europe. And we're gonna make sure we double down and make sure that all of that innovation, the job creation, and the wealth creation remains here benefiting Britain, including her constituency.

59:14 - 59:15

Speaker 1

Thank you, mister

59:15 - 59:34

Speaker 19

speaker. Anchor Sound and Security, based in Kingsland, explained to me how they're disincentivized to hire more employees due to rising compliance costs and regulatory uncertainty. What is the minister doing to stop these regulations stifling small business growth and destroying the strong relationships between employer and employees?

59:36 - 01:00:03

Speaker 23

I'm going for this question. This government has a commitment to reduce the regulatory burden on business by 25%. My department is led by almost a billion pounds worth of regulatory reform for company reporting just in the first weeks of taking into this office. The small business plan, and strategy will deliver for, small businesses on top of it. The industrial strategy, of course, getting our economy facing the future and into solid growth from now and into the future as well.

Laura Leppard.

01:00:03 - 01:00:31

Speaker 55

Mister speaker, may I add my voice to the call from my honorable friends for the government to publish the market access review into small breweries as soon as possible. I was delighted that Moot Brewery in Hauling in my constituency had the opportunity before Christmas to be the guest sale in the strangers bar here in the House of Commons. But will the secretary of state please support a national guest beer agreement policy so that when I visit more of my local pubs, I can see fantastic local brewers like Moot represented there too.

01:00:33 - 01:00:53

Speaker 3

thank my honorable friend for her question. She's a real champion of her local brewers, especially the Moot brewery in Hauling, which I know she visited regularly and produces excellent beer. We do recognize the importance of independent brewers and pubs and, of course, are committed to ensuring that the sector remains diverse, competitive, and rooted in local communities. We've reviewed the beer market to assess any barriers, of course, I'll keep it updated.

01:00:53 - 01:01:33

Speaker 47

Duncan Smith. Mister speaker, the small volume business manufacturers in the automotive sector are having a terrible time at the moment. They're reliant on exports, and the exports to The US were very critical, whilst I welcome the agreement that the government struck, still the cost of four times what they were before, president Trump put his tariffs in, and they're being squeezed by business rates and by national insurance at home. Would he please now represent to the chancellor? This is a very delicate market.

It there's something has to be done reducing the cost on them, and I I would urge second state, please make representations now to get the cost down on this sector. Yeah. State.

01:01:33 - 01:02:09

Speaker 23

He he raises an issue which is very close to my heart. This government and myself care deeply about the future of the automotive sector. Exports are incredibly important to it, but so are also security of supply chains. Not only is this raised by me with our US counterparts and our other export markets, but also the EU to protect the supply chains. I can assure you that that my my colleague, the minister, chaired the automotive sector council just yesterday listening, gauging, and we are acting on their behalf.

Automotive production fell by 50%, I'm afraid, when they they were running the country. We are trying to get it back up to where it deserves

01:02:09 - 01:02:12

Speaker 1

to be. Chair of the Select Committee, Liam.

01:02:12 - 01:02:43

Speaker 56

You. The Select Committee recently flagged that small business in our country is now facing pandemic level pressures. But in April, standing charges for energy are set rise by 60%. There is no price cap protection, now soaring oil and gas prices threaten to be the final straw for thousands of SMEs. So will the secretary of state bring forward an urgent assessment of the risk of soaring energy prices together with a clear account of how we're going to keep in business the SMEs that keep this country running?

01:02:43 - 01:02:44

Speaker 1

The only Minister.

01:02:44 - 01:03:03

Speaker 21

Well, he's absolutely right, and, we've obviously taken action with the British industrial competitiveness scheme as a down payment on exactly the sort of support that he describes. We are constantly working on ways to cut those costs for small businesses, and I am sure we will work with the select committee on

01:03:06 - 01:03:39

Speaker 57

Last time we were here for business questions, asked one about the export of paraquat to other countries, even though it's forbidden for use in this country. I live in hope that I'm going to get an answer to that but I might update the ministerial team that actually Syngenta, the company that makes Parapat, put out a press release on March 3 saying it was going to stop doing that during the course of this year. Could I therefore expand my previous question to make sure that the response includes the export of pesticides and other products banned in The UK but used we we send them to other places in the world.

01:03:39 - 01:04:08

Speaker 58

Minister. Yes. Paribou. Mraz Haumetendal, mister speaker, The UK economy needs more and more critical minerals, and in Cornwall, we've got loads of them. Private capital has flowed into the duchy on the back of the Labour government's investments of about a £100,000,000 through the National Wealth Fund of the Kernow Industrial Growth Fund.

But can the minister update the house on government plans to unlock more private investment into our critical mineral sector to unleash the Cornish Celtic Tiger?

01:04:08 - 01:04:10

Speaker 59

Yeah. Minister.

01:04:10 - 01:04:36

Speaker 10

Thank you very much, mister speaker. My honorable friend is right. Cornwall has loads of critical minerals that will be beneficial not only to drive The UK economy, but great businesses and export opportunities as well. As I said before, we want these companies to scale and grow in The UK to be headquartered and listed in The UK and provide great jobs in The UK, and that's why I'm working with him and his, Labour MP colleagues in Cornwall with the industry and with the capital markets in The UK to try and crowd that capital into Cornish critical minerals.

01:04:36 - 01:04:37

Speaker 1

Martin Bickers.

01:04:37 - 01:05:04

Speaker 60

Thank you, mister speaker. Since part of Grimsby falls in my constituency, I joined my member of parliament in celebrating great Grimsby day. And I was free, recently, attended a meeting with the member of Scumthorpe with a group of potential investors in the steel industry who I know have made approaches to the secretary of state, could he give an assurance that, all potential private sector investments in the industry will be given serious consideration?

01:05:05 - 01:05:08

Speaker 23

So so. I congratulate him on scumvault day, and I can give him that assurance.

01:05:09 - 01:05:10

Speaker 1

I said, Trevor.

01:05:10 - 01:05:50

Speaker 61

Thank you, mister speaker. Can I thank the minister for previously speaking to me about the poor postal service in Dargaville Village in Bisherton? I know the minister is working hard to resolve my answer matters and answer to questions yesterday, and I had meetings yesterday. Can I thank him for that? However, this matter, as he will appreciate, is of particular importance in Scotland due to the elections on the May 7, Postal votes will be issued soon.

In Scotland, we have an NHS with significant waiting lists, and we cannot possibly have people missing medical appointments. On behalf of residents of Bishopton in particular, can I stress the urgency of this matter?

01:05:51 - 01:06:27

Speaker 21

My office manager lives in Dargaville Village, so I have a personal incentive to make sure that the service improves where she represents. We spoke about yesterday, we have called in Royal Mail. We brought together unions and management, and we had the meeting yesterday with Ofcom to stress that things have to improve. With regards to postal votes Scotland, there are specific meetings taking place around that, And we have sought assurances that postal votes will be not impacted by the problems with quality of service.

01:06:27 - 01:06:28

Speaker 1

Ronald Pinkerton.

01:06:28 - 01:06:58

Speaker 32

Thank you, mister speaker. I met with the British Chambers of Commerce yesterday who relayed the profound concerns of The UK automotive industry that they may be excluded from the European Union's proposed Industrial Accelerator Act. Nissan and Honda have already broken cover to say that their future may be uncertain unless they are included within the made in Europe rules. So can I ask the secretary of state what he's doing with his front bench team and across government to ensure that The UK automotive sector isn't placed at a competitive disadvantage as a consequence of those measures?

01:06:59 - 01:07:38

Speaker 23

I'm very grateful for his question. It's an incredibly important one. He will know that I've been very active, and my ministerial team have been very active, on this very issue. And just a couple of weeks ago, when I was in, Brussels raising it directly with the commissioners, he will also know that in the published act, which has not been introduced yet, that there are potential challenges for automotive sector. It is very clear and the voice is being heard loud and clear from the business community themselves as well as us working with our EU colleagues to make sure their voice is heard and that the automotive sector, for which 86% of components that are assembled in this country come from, EU countries, are respected, valued, and secure into the future.

01:07:38 - 01:07:40

Speaker 1

Brian Leishman.

01:07:40 - 01:08:07

Speaker 62

Thank you very much, mister speaker. The sudden shift in steel import policy has created uncertainty for firms that have invested heavily in expanding their operations based on previously stable trading conditions. Will the Secretary of State commit to working with effective businesses in Scotland, including central rebar in Alawah, to provide clarity, to prevent further disruption, and to ensure that companies vital to the Scottish industrial base are not placed at a competitive disadvantage.

01:08:07 - 01:08:08

Speaker 8

Minister.

01:08:08 - 01:08:26

Speaker 10

Thank you very much, mister speaker. The government is incredibly concerned about the gradual erosion, over a period of time of UK, steel production, domestic production versus import. Can I ask my honorable friend to to wait the very short period of time until the steel strategy has been published? And then perhaps, he might like to have a further discussion with me after that.

01:08:27 - 01:08:28

Speaker 1

Max Wilkins.

01:08:28 - 01:09:01

Speaker 37

Thank you, mister speaker. High streets are a key concern for all of us in this House. And in Cheltenham, on the promenade, we have Cavendish House, which was the cherished center for retail for two hundred years. The minister remembers it. And and indeed, now it is empty.

Mike Ashley, sports direct left there, and now we have a big empty building owned by Canada Life. Now would the ministers, whoever's gonna answer, agree with me that these big pension investment companies need to pay more respect to our high streets and bring forward planning applications to redevelop and regenerate as soon as they possibly can. We shouldn't be left waiting for as long

01:09:01 - 01:09:02

Speaker 56

as we have been.

01:09:02 - 01:09:23

Speaker 21

Minister. Well, as my honorable friend mentioned a moment ago, we're working on a new high street strategy, which will seek to to deal with some of the issues he mentions. I think we do want to see investors to step up, but we also have responsibility through planning reform to make sure that it's easier to regenerate the types of situations he describes.

01:09:24 - 01:09:55

Speaker 23

Good stand, Mike. Considering the global energy crisis, manufacturers reliant on gas would struggle with recent spikes in energy costs. Can the minister confirm if his department are considering a transitional dual fuel discount alongside BICS for industries that will continue to use gas for the foreseeable future. Very good. I'm very grateful to him.

He'll know that the impact that BICS is having is essential, and it will be fundamental in making sure we can get, growth into the economy and sustainable business into the future. Of course, we're looking very carefully about how that, the learning from that can be applied in other areas.

01:09:55 - 01:09:57

Speaker 1

Well, let the front benches change over.

01:10:23 - 01:10:26

Speaker 63

Order, before we become to the

01:10:26 - 01:11:59

Speaker 1

business questions, I would like to say something about yesterday's evening's proceedings. The final division of the day on the third reading of the finance number two bill was subject to intolerable delays in the voting lobbies. This parliament is meant to be respected around the world and should set an example of good behavior. The behavior in the lobby last night involving a group of about half a government half a dozen government members, including the chief and deputy chief Wick, was totally unacceptable. I expect better from honorable members than right honorable members.

If members are asked to move swiftly through the lobbies, they must do. The fact it took twenty two minutes to get a vote through is beyond the pale. I cannot believe the behavior. It is absolutely not going to be accepted. The sergeant lost his authority because MP said, I am not moving.

Pretending to be ill, by 07:00, they were suddenly well again. If we think that this gives us good standing in the world, it doesn't. It is appalling. We should be ashamed, and I hope that I will be getting letters from the people who were involved in that protest. If the government can't manage the business, nay, maybe they ought to go on a training exercise rather than disrupting the rules of the house.

01:11:59 - 01:12:02

Speaker 42

Yeah. So I say,

01:12:02 - 01:12:35

Speaker 1

I expect better from honorable right on members. If members are asked to move swiftly, they must move and respect the sergeant. There are other ways in which the government whips can manage timings of business in the chamber. It is disrespectful to this house. To the occupant of the chair, the deputy was put in impossible position, and to the office of the sergeant at arms to behave in the way that they did.

Members, as I say, involved should be ashamed. I will now call the shadow leader for business questions Jesse Norman.

01:12:37 - 01:12:43

Speaker 64

Thank you, mister speaker. Will the leader of the house give us the forthcoming business? Leader.

01:12:43 - 01:13:47

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. The business for the week commencing the March 16 will include Monday, March 16, consideration of an allocation of time motion followed by all stages of the Grenfell Tower memorial expenditure bill. Tuesday, March 17, consideration of an allocation of time motion followed by all stages of the ministerial salaries amendment bill. Wednesday, March 18, opposition day, debate on a motion in the name of the official opposition subject to be announced. Thursday, March 19, a general debate on progress in tackling climate change, followed by a debate on a motion on online harms.

The subject for these debates were determined by the Backbench Business Committee, Friday March 20, the house will not be sitting, and the provisional business for the week commencing the March 23 includes Monday, March 23, consideration of Lord's amendments to the tobacco and vapes bill followed by consideration of Lord's amendments to the National Insurance Contributions Employer Pensions Contributions bill. Jesse Long.

01:13:48 - 01:14:15

Speaker 64

Thank you very much, mister speaker. Let me start by associating myself with your remarks just now from the chair. It is plain to all members of this house that the government chiefs whip, and deputy chief whip have badly misstepped here, and indeed there has been scant respect for this house more generally from the government whip's office. I cannot believe such a thing would have happened when the leader of the house was himself the chief whip.

01:14:15 - 01:14:16

Speaker 16

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

01:14:16 - 01:14:44

Speaker 64

Let me join, if I may, the prime minister yesterday, and I'm sure the whole house today, in remembering the dreadful events of thirty years ago in Dunblane and paying tribute to the victims and their families. On a happier note, last Monday saw the two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of Adam Smith's immortal masterpiece, the wealth of nations.

01:14:44 - 01:14:46

Speaker 65

Yeah. Yeah. Great or interest. I

01:14:49 - 01:19:17

Speaker 64

members may wish, if they like, to consult, works by the shadow leader on this topic. I doubt I doubt if any other book or any single body of thought has had more effect in improving the lives and livelihoods of people across the world in the intervening two hundred and fifty years. Mister speaker, we celebrate the service of our armed forces, and we rightly treat defense matters wherever possible as bound by a united focus on the national interest. But it is precisely that focus on the national interest which requires us now to acknowledge that the past two weeks have been a disaster for this country. Our allies in The UAE, Bahrain, across The Gulf have criticized this country for its, quote, slow and, quote, weak response to date.

The Cypriot high commissioner and the president of Cyprus have publicly expressed their disappointment and dissatisfaction. Why? Because we have exposed their people, our people, to drone attacks as targets, placed weapon systems on their territories, made solemn undertakings over many years to them, and now failed to come to their defense in time. It did not have to be this way, mister speaker. So we must ask how can this possibly have happened.

Let us review the history. It was being publicly reported by January 15 that America was starting to build a carrier strike force around the USS Abraham Lincoln targeted at Iran. On the January 28, I'm sorry, the January 26, The Washington Post reported that this force had arrived in The Middle East. On the January 31, our own prime minister himself told the BBC, and I quote, the aim is that Iran shouldn't be able to deliver nuclear weapons. And I quote again, we support the goal, and we are talking to allies about how we get to that goal.

Those remarks come close to an explicit endorsement of The United States on this operation as they were doubtless intended to. But the key point is this, all this happened four full weeks before the start of the attack. Last week, at this dispatch box, I highlighted the gaps and inconsistencies in the government's position between supposedly settled legal review and the last ditch political decision reportedly taken in cabinet on the Friday before hostilities began, and secondly, between the cabinets and the prime minister whose original instinct was to support The USA but who was overruled. It is now clear that there has also been a disastrous failure of political leadership. The prime minister and the cabinet knew or should have known for a full month that The USA was mustering a vast body of forces to attack Iran, that these could not remain on high readiness indefinitely, and so an attack must surely follow.

The prime minister himself said last week that the government had predeployed some weapons to the region, yet he failed to give instructions in time to the navy to prepare US Dragon HMS Dragon. He failed to notify the Cypriots, and he failed to warn our allies and other friends across the region. Now that they are engaged, our armed forces are discharging their duties with distinction. But the result of this political incompetence has been a fiasco, which brought shame and dishonor on this country. We have the disgraceful sight now of the government anonymously trashing the chief of the defense staff in a desperate attempt to deflect responsibility for its own inadequacies, not just via an anonymous leak in the spectator repeated in the telegraph, but by a quoted but, of course, unnamed official to the Financial Times.

I cannot recall that a political hatchet job of this kind has ever been performed on a commanding officer in the course of a military operation. It is deeply dishonorable and itself a further sign of failure in number 10. So I ask the leader these things, whether he would support an inquiry into these leaks and briefings, and whether he would support an investigation in due course as to how this embarrassing fiasco can have been allowed to happen and what can be done to prevent it from ever happening again.

01:19:18 - 01:19:20

Speaker 4

Here. Here. Leader.

01:19:20 - 01:21:58

Speaker 14

Mister, speaker. And can I, first of all, respond to your words, mister speaker, previously about the events of last evening and endorse everything that you have said about the need to respect staff? That is absolutely correct that you should say that, and I absolutely endorse your remarks. And can I assure you, mister speaker, and the house that not only has the government heard your words, but they will be acted upon? May I also associate myself with the remarks that the honorable gentleman made made about Dunblane?

We do remember that tragedy. And I have to say on a personal level, it is one of the proudest moments in my career when I voted for a handgun ban, because that has had that has made a difference, to our communities and the safety of our communities. Mister speaker, the events that are unfolding, in Iran are deeply concerning, and I will, turn to the specific remarks of the honorable gentleman in a moment. But the events are deeply concerning, and our thoughts are with British citizens and our brave servicemen and women in the region. The security and safety of British citizens across the region is the government's top priority.

The first government charter flight landed on Tuesday morning, with the second landing on Wednesday. We will continue to explore all options for helping our citizens return home as swiftly and safely as possible. Drop ins are being, held for MPs with concerns. And as I said last week, mister speaker, should members face issues and are not able to get the support, that they need for their constituents, I invite them to speak to my office and my officials, and we will help in any way that we can. This week, we've launched the social cohesion action plan, which sets out the steps the government is taking to improve social cohesion and protect what matters.

We will invest in initiatives to which create opportunities for connection across backgrounds, and we will expand the Pride in Place program, which puts more communities at the heart of decision making in their own neighborhoods. And we will develop new tools and powers to safeguard organizations that spread extremism, hate, and threaten public safety. It's also, mister speaker, I think, correct to reflect on that last Sunday was COVID nineteen day of reflection, an opportunity to come together to remember those that lost their lives and to honor the tireless work and acts of kindness shown by many during the pandemic. The government remains committed to learning the lessons needed from the COVID inquiry

01:25:34 - 01:25:48

Speaker 18

dropped. The Prime Minister himself said that big tech companies need to be held financially accountable for their role in fraud, but when the strategy was dropped, instead of enforcing that we have an industry working group

01:29:27 - 01:30:27

Speaker 60

outcomes for patients with Elus Danlos syndrome and craniocervical instability, hope I've got that right, and possibly for the potential merits of mandatory body armor for prison officers, but that one is provisional. We have, as the leader knows, a great deal of outstanding debates, the the weekly plea for more time is coming your way. Turning to my own issue, mister speaker, I have many park home owners in my constituency, and the leader, I'm sure, will be aware that the government published some research only this week about park homeowners. The Backbench Committee has a pending debate on this, but perhaps if the Leader could be particularly generous with Government time, we could bring that forward and satisfy the many park homeowners, throughout the country.

01:30:28 - 01:31:35

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. And I thank the honorable gentleman for, his, work, with the, backbench, business committee, and indeed thank the the whole of the committee. And I note, with particular pleasure, the debate on accessibility to banking services, which is an issue which has been raised in business questions many times. I'm pleased that that has been scheduled. In terms of more time, I can't promise him more time at this at this moment, but I I do, also recognize that it's important to get confirmation of time, as early as possible, and I will endeavor, to do that.

On the matter that he raises on, Park Holmes, we do, recognize, mister speaker, the long standing concerns, among Park Holmes residents about, things like commission fees, and we have, launched a call for evidence. And I would encourage his constituents, indeed everyone's constituents, to contribute to this call for evidence. If needed, miss mister speaker, I I should remind the house that Parkham residents are entitled to free independent legal advice about their rights through the government funded leasehold advisory service.

01:31:35 - 01:31:36

Speaker 1

Big picture.

01:31:36 - 01:31:36

Speaker 30

Thank you,

01:31:36 - 01:32:05

Speaker 66

mister speaker. My honorable friend in Doncaster Central and I have often come here to speak about the appalling service of audiology at Doncaster Royal Infirmary. Now they have put an action plan in place and first time appointments are improved, but second and third appointments are just not happening and people are waiting for hearing aid refits and repairs. Well, leader of the house asked ministers to set how they will support trusts to expand capacity to follow-up audiology care, including how they could use high street provision where that can be provided under the NHS.

01:32:06 - 01:32:39

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. We know that people aren't waiting too long for community health services, and we are committed to cutting waiting lists, including for audiology. We're providing capital investment to upgrade audiology facilities in NHS Trust and expand audiology testing capacity through community diagnostic centers. And as he hopefully, I raised his previous concerns with health ministers, who I believe have since written to him on this matter, earlier, this week, but I will ensure that the department hears his latest question.

01:32:39 - 01:32:40

Speaker 1

So Julian Insman.

01:32:40 - 01:33:02

Speaker 59

Mister speaker, manufacturers and distributors of bullets in The UK are extremely concerned about the decision by DEFRA to ban lead in 2029. The EU was about to make this decision but pulled back from it. Can we have a debate about the impact of this decision on UK sovereign capability as urgently as possible?

01:33:03 - 01:33:15

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. I can offer the right honorable gentleman a meeting with ministers if that is what he seeks, but I certainly draw to their attention the point that he raises.

01:33:16 - 01:33:16

Speaker 63

Alright, Kirk.

01:33:16 - 01:33:40

Speaker 2

Thank you, mister speaker. I know lots of us in Aylesbury and the villages have watched the channel four drama dirty business. One resident described it to me as harrowing, powerful, and emotive, and they are right. The government has made some good progress in tackling the crime of sewage in our waterways through the water special measures act, but will the leader ensure that further parliamentary time is allocated to debate and advance our long overdue reforms to the water sector?

01:33:40 - 01:34:22

Speaker 14

Yeah. Thank you, mister speaker. My honorable friend raises a very important, matter, and the program to which she refers has, quite rightly caused, concern amongst people and and a dialogue on these matters, which is important that we have that. The reality is that the previous government should never have allowed the water sector to get into this state because the public deserves better. She says our water special measures that will introduce tough enforcement measures, the most powerful in a decade.

The Water White Paper goes further, setting out clear powers for the new water regulator, and a new water reform bill will create the laws that we need to fundamentally change the system. And, when that bill is introduced, there'll be plenty of time, to debate this matter.

01:34:22 - 01:34:24

Speaker 4

Griffiths. Thank

01:34:24 - 01:35:11

Speaker 67

you. Mister speaker, the situation at Zachary Merton Hospital in my constituency of Vognor Regis and Littlehampton is causing deep concern locally. Services there were closed on what residents were told was a temporary basis, yet that closure has now been made permanent. The evidence behind that decision has not been clearly set out. Communities rightly expect candor when decisions are taken about the future of local health care provision.

So does the Leader of the House therefore agree that there is a wider issue here about transparency and accountability in NHS service decisions? And will he consider granting time for a debate, in government time, on the future of community health care provision? Yeah.

01:35:11 - 01:35:27

Speaker 14

Yeah. You, speaker. I I do agree on the need for, candor and for openness, for residents who are obviously concerned over the matters, not least the one that she, refers to. Should she wish to, make her case to the relevant minister, then I will make sure that she has that opportunity.

01:35:27 - 01:35:28

Speaker 1

Anton Dibblin.

01:35:28 - 01:36:16

Speaker 35

Thank you, mister speaker. Comedy has always been a part of the fabric of British society, so I am delighted to be a patron of the newly launched craft set up to work to give the comedy comedy industry the formal recognition it deserves to ensure fair funding and government and industry support. From national treasures and emerging talent to homegrown natural funny people in our own communities, like Steve Cook in my constituency of South Derbyshire, who runs I Love Swad on Facebook with Pete J. Madame Brass. Stephen never fails to make me laugh.

I'm nearly there. Bear with me. He turned a council decision to turn around an interesting feature roundabout and call it SWADHENGE. Google it. You'll find it.

It's also on TripAdvisor now too. So does the leader of the house agree with me that comedy is an art form, not just a genre? And will he join me in thanking Lou Jackson, founder of Craft, and Steve Cook, and all those who support comedy in

01:36:16 - 01:36:17

Speaker 68

The UK? Yeah.

01:36:17 - 01:36:17

Speaker 69

Good one.

01:36:17 - 01:36:40

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. Mister speaker, much like myself, comedy brings light and laughter to our lives. And is it a talent and an art to which I'm proud to join my honorable friend, in recognizing. Of course, I want to thank everyone who supports the incredible UK comedy scene, including, Lou Jackson from Craft and Steve Cook from her

01:36:40 - 01:36:41

Speaker 1

constituency. Thank

01:36:42 - 01:36:42

Speaker 16

you very

01:36:42 - 01:37:20

Speaker 70

much, mister speaker. It was good that the government did host a session in relation to heating oil. Rural constituencies, like my own of North East Fife, have almost 15% to rely on heating oil, so it's really important that the Government is debating that. But as my right honourable friend, the chair of the EFI Select Committee, raised, red diesel is also an issue, and rural impacts of the conflict in Iran are greater than heating oil. Fertiliser is another challenge reports a 40 per cent increase in the costs.

When food security is becoming even more vital, can the leader of the House ensure that we have a statement from the secretary of state for DFRA on the rural impacts of the conflict?

01:37:20 - 01:38:09

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. I don't think we've been shy in bringing forward statements on on matters that have arisen from the crisis in Iran, and we we will continue to do though do so. The honorable lady is absolutely right to raise concerns about heating oil and about other matters too. And as she knows, the energy minister has asked the CMA to make sure that consumers are treated fairly, with the with the option of investigation into unfair practices if that becomes, necessary. But the government is very cognizant of of that, of of energy prices in general, but also of heating oil, and indeed of, fuel.

And we'll keep that, under close, watch, and, when appropriate, bring forward and update the house on what we intend to do about it.

01:38:09 - 01:38:10

Speaker 4

Deb Zaffler.

01:38:10 - 01:38:48

Speaker 39

Thank you, mister speaker. This weekend marks the fiftieth anniversary of the West Ham station attack where an IRA bomb exploded on a tube train injuring nine people. Post office engineer Peter Chalk was shot and seriously injured, and the tube driver Joseph Julius Stephen was shot and killed as they attempted to stop the attacker escaping. These significant anniversaries, particularly where it involves public sector workers who have stepped up beyond above and beyond

01:38:48 - 01:38:49

Speaker 15

the call of

01:38:49 - 01:38:52

Speaker 39

duty and sacrificed or risked their own lives to protect the public?

01:38:52 - 01:39:23

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister Speaker. I absolutely, thank my, John, my honorable friend, in wishing, sending our best wishes to the, friends and family, of the people who were, killed. And I thank him for raising this important anniversary. It's an import it is important, that we remember events such as these, because not least it it underlines the importance of community. And I join him in recognizing all public servants who have acted in the face of danger to protect us as we go go about our daily lives.

01:39:24 - 01:40:15

Speaker 22

Blobbermore. Thank you, mister speaker. Last week, I met with Toby Hammond, the lead volunteer for West Yorkshire scouts. Astonishingly, the scouts have now learned that they could be hit by Labour's proposed new tourist tax being introduced by the mayor of West Yorkshire, Tracy Braben, because this tax is on overnight stays. It could now apply to youth camps, outdoor experiences, and sleepovers run by volunteers at scout groups across Keathley and Ilkley who are giving up their own time, their own evenings for the benefits of our young people.

It will hit thousands of young children and young people, that will be negatively impacted. So will the leader of the house grant a debate on this very issue and join me in urging the mayor of West Yorkshire to scrap this tax once and for all that is impacting many of our scout groups that continue to provide and deliver vital work for our young people?

01:40:16 - 01:40:57

Speaker 14

You, mister speaker, I I sincerely hope that the impact not as the honorable gentleman has led us to believe. If if he wants confirmation from that, then I will arrange for a minister to explain what the situation is. Absolutely right, though, mister speaker, that mayors are given the opportunity, the choice rather, as to whether or not they introduce tourist tax. It it will be controversial in many ways. We understand that.

But let's not forget that there are benefits, in in terms of the income and and what can, what can be used with that money. But I join with him in in his worry that that if that impacts negatively on scouts, and that's something that should be should be borne in mind because they do a fantastic job, mister speaker.

01:40:57 - 01:41:29

Speaker 71

Mister speaker, bank closures have affected many communities. In Blighnae, Grant and Remney, we'll have banking hubs in Abbotley and shortly in Ebervale, so residents have access to bank services on their high streets. These are very popular. It's great that the government is committed to delivering 350 banking hubs. Maybe have a statement to find out how that's going, to hear about lessons learned, and if access to hubs could be widened in the future.

01:41:29 - 01:42:18

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. Banking is changing with many customers benefiting from the convenience of managing their finances remotely. And what the government also understands, the importance for many people of face to face banking and is committed to supporting sufficient access for customers, which is why the financial services industry, with government support, is committed to rolling out 350 banking hubs. That's 350 now, mister speaker, but it doesn't that's not an upper limit on how many there will be. This is 350 by the end of parliament, but there's no reason why the process can't, continue.

The government is working closely with industry on this commitment, including through red, regular ministerial engagement as we assess the rollout of those bunking hoops. I'm sure ministers will want to bear in mind the need to update the house when appropriate.

01:42:18 - 01:42:20

Speaker 4

Christine Jalti. Thank you very

01:42:20 - 01:42:29

Speaker 72

much, mister speaker. And can I associate myself with the remarks of the Leader and Shadow Leader about the anniversary of Dumplaine? Many

01:42:29 - 01:42:29

Speaker 2

of us

01:42:29 - 01:43:09

Speaker 72

in this place have pensioner constituents abroad, particularly 90 per cent of them in the Commonwealth who have frozen pensions from the point at which they left. This is an issue of great concern not just to them but increasingly to the governments of Canada and Australia in particular, where it places a heavy burden on them. The regulations were passed recently through this House, the annual regulations without scrutiny because of the way in which they are passed. So would there be some way that we could arrange a meeting with ministers or a debate in this House so that we can examine this policy and see if there is a way of amending it to make it fairer both to those pensioners and to everyone else affected by it?

01:43:10 - 01:43:17

Speaker 14

Missus Bikrat, I don't know the answer to the honourable lady's question except to say that if she seeks a a meeting with the minister, I will help her to facilitate one.

01:43:18 - 01:44:02

Speaker 70

Thank you, mister speaker. The March 16 marks the start of sign language week. Derby has the largest deaf community of any local authority in the country, thanks in large part to the Royal School for the Deaf founded in 1898 and the strong and supportive community that has arisen ever since. But even in Derby, too many people find public services inaccessible. Would the leader of the house agree that across our public services, everyone should be able to access information and communicate in a way that works for them?

And will he join me in wishing everyone that uses British Sign Language in Derby and across the country a very happy sign language week.

01:44:02 - 01:44:31

Speaker 14

Yeah. Thank you, mister speaker. And I thank my honorable friend for bringing this matter to the house, and I absolutely endorse remarks about, more people, being able to, use and understand, sign language because it's a vital means of communication, for, many people. And I hope that this week raises some well needed awareness, of the importance of British, sign language. So I do take this opportunity, along with the whole house, to wish everyone a happy sign language week.

01:44:31 - 01:44:32

Speaker 4

Mike Wood.

01:44:32 - 01:45:03

Speaker 65

Thank you, mister speaker. Farmers in King Swinford and South Staffordshire have contacted me in recent, days about the steep rise in key inputs like fertilizers and straw. Now current affairs and current events are likely to make these pressures even more acute with serious implications for farm viability and for domestic food production. So could we have a debate in government time on the rising cost facing British farmers and the long term resilience of UK food production?

01:45:03 - 01:45:03

Speaker 16

Hear hear.

01:45:03 - 01:45:27

Speaker 14

Hear. Thank you, mister, speaker. It seems like longer, but we're eleven days into this particular, crisis, and the government has not, as I said before, not been shy, on bringing forward statements when necessary on particular aspects of it. I will raise his concerns, with Defra ministers who I'm sure are watching the situation, very carefully. And, should the opportunity arise to update the house, or the need arise to update the house, I'm sure that's what they'll do.

01:45:27 - 01:45:28

Speaker 1

Jim Mattmall.

01:45:29 - 01:45:55

Speaker 41

Speaker, there are around 430 farmer owned cooperatives in The UK and around a 150 farmer members turn over £10,000,000,000 a year, delivering high quality food produced to the highest welfare and environmental standards. With food security being national security and the government committed to doubling the size of the corporate sector, will the leader of the house grant time for a debate on expanding the agricultural corporate sector so they can play a role in strengthening

01:46:09 - 01:46:18

Speaker 14

And should my honorable friend seek a a debate on these matters, I'm sure there are many across the house who would want to join in to discuss what is a very, very important subject.

01:46:18 - 01:46:19

Speaker 5

Sir Lewis.

01:46:20 - 01:46:57

Speaker 18

May we have an update from a health minister on progress in the review of prostate cancer policy and whether it will focus as it should on such issues as targeting particularly vulnerable age groups or ethnic groups such as black males, one quarter of whom will be affected by this disease at some stage in their lives, and speeding up NICE approval of relevant drug treatments in England and Wales which are already actually being prescribed in Northern Ireland and Scotland?

01:46:57 - 01:47:26

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speakers. The right honorable gentleman will know that the the government has produced England's first ever male men's health strategy, And we're investing we're not just reforming the way that things are done. We're we're putting the investment in as well. On the specific issue which he raises, which I agree with him, is an extraordinarily important matter, I will seek an update from a health minister for him. And should he seek after that a minister for, for further detail, then I'll help him to arrange that too.

01:47:27 - 01:47:58

Speaker 73

Law Law. Thank you, mister speaker. I was delighted to, see the Eden Project's recent report, which shone a light on the nearly £7,000,000,000 worth of positive impact it's drawn into the Cornish economy and our community over the last twenty five years. Yeah. So will the leader of the house work with me and across departments to ensure that our high street strategy and that our local visitor economy strategy works for Cornish businesses, for local wealth creation, for skills development, and for our wider communities just as

01:47:58 - 01:48:00

Speaker 19

the Eden Project has done. Thank

01:48:01 - 01:48:35

Speaker 14

you. Mister speaker, my honorable friend is a strong advocate, not just for his constituency, but for, Cornwall, and I commend him, for that. The Eden Project, as he said, has been an amazing initiative to and, contributed to the local community and economy, attracting visitors, creating jobs, and generating £6,800,000,000 boost to the area since it opened. My door is always open to the honorable gentleman to discuss what further action can be taken to champion this cause. And if he seeks one, I will also get a meeting with the relevant minister.

01:48:35 - 01:48:36

Speaker 1

Anderson Bean.

01:48:36 - 01:49:13

Speaker 50

Mister speaker, for decades, local people in Froome have used packed saddle fields as a valued space for walking, recreation, and nature. Plans to build housing on the site were refused twice last year because of the harm it would cause to the community's use of the land. Despite this and the fact they have no life planning application, Live West is now taking legal action relating to access to the fields and has forced Somerset to to fence off the area, which simply denies local people the many benefits of being able to enjoy the outdoors. But the leader of the house urged the minister for the ministry for housing local housing communities and local government to look at whether it's reasonable that land can be fenced off in this way, and help me organize a meeting with the relevant minister to discuss this?

01:49:13 - 01:49:44

Speaker 14

Mister speaker, I will raise the matter with the relevant minister and ensure that the honorable lady gets an update on the important point that she raises. But I would gently point out, as I do, when housing matters are it's much better if these things are decided locally and communities can go along with it because we do need more houses. We need more houses for people to live in and to make sure that communities are resilient. But I will ensure that she gets a response to the specific point from the relevant minister.

01:49:44 - 01:50:32

Speaker 63

Thank you, mister speaker. Silicosis is a particularly nasty, debilitating respiratory disease, and it's alarmingly on the increase here in The UK, predominantly for young people between the age of 20 and 30. It's really something we need to be be looking at. It's a preventable disease. The reason why it's escalating is because the increase in engineered stone, dry cotton.

Can we have a debate in government time to see how the government can intervene to prevent this debilitating disease, silicosis, from becoming the next asbestos national tragedy?

01:50:33 - 01:51:05

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. My honorable friend, as ever, raises an important, issue. The government is committed to increasing the capacity of respiratory services, and the NHS has specialist centres for diagnosing and managing lung diseases that cause scarring such as, silicosis. I'll make sure that the relevant minister hears, his concerns. If he wants a meeting, with that minister, then I will, help to facilitate that because we should use, the experience of my, people like my honorable friend, on these matters because he he is he does bring a loud and strong voice to him.

01:51:05 - 01:51:07

Speaker 74

John Blow. Thank you, mister speaker.

01:51:07 - 01:51:57

Speaker 75

My constituent, Kate Simankovic's daughter, Ruth, tragically died in a mental health inpatient unit, and she's been told by the government that the law as it stands already provides adequate protections to ensure that family contact and visits can happen. But plainly that didn't happen and with tragic consequences in that case. Please could the leader of the house facilitate a debate or a statement or a meeting with the minister because when a tragedy like this happens it's not enough to say the law is satisfactory as it is because plainly the tragic death of their daughter is something that they will not rest until it's properly met by government action.

01:51:58 - 01:52:20

Speaker 14

Mister speaker, and the right honorable general is absolutely right to raise these matters, and I commend him for the way in which he has raised them here today. And it's an awful tragedy when these things happen, and I understand the family's reluctance to accept that the law is strong enough. Should he seek a minister with a meeting with the relevant minister, then I'll help him facilitate it.

01:52:20 - 01:53:18

Speaker 11

Thank you, mister speaker. March is prostate cancer awareness month, and as we know, this Labour government has created a men's health strategy for which the men and boys summit will be a central pillar later this year. Today, the prostate cancer APPG heard powerful testimonies from Movember, Maggie's, the British Association for Urological Nurses, and Alfonso Archer, a survivor, who spoke powerfully about, the inequities in, prostate cancer provision and the place for music therapy in the recovery process. Whilst welcome the very powerful, response to the, right honorable member for New Forest East, would the leader of the house ensure that a round table on prostate cancer is among those included, in the lead up to this very welcome summit later this year? Indeed,

01:53:18 - 01:53:37

Speaker 14

mister speaker. It is as my honorable friend pointed out the second term that this has been, raised today, and that underlines the importance of these, matters. Should he seek a debate, I'm sure that, others will, join him in raising these important matters. But in terms of the roundtable before the summit, then I'll certainly look into that.

01:53:38 - 01:53:40

Speaker 1

Andrew Rosnall. Thank

01:53:40 - 01:53:41

Speaker 15

you, mister speaker.

01:53:41 - 01:54:37

Speaker 76

Every year for Saint George's Day, my local scouts in Romford have a Saint George's Day parade and a service at a local church in Horn Church as well, so two parades in Havering. But this year, the police have withdrawn support. They're not prepared to marshal the very short parade on the basis of cost. Now, mister speaker, we pay in huge sums of money for the Metropolitan Police. And when there is any kind of event, I expect the police to be there to look after the safety of those young people that are celebrating the patron saint of scouting.

So will the leader of the house allow for a debate about firstly the importance of celebrating Saint George's Day as part of our great English cultural heritage, but also the failure of the Metropolitan Police to ensure that the London borough of Havering is given the police cover that we deserve and that we pay for?

01:54:39 - 01:55:00

Speaker 14

Mister speaker, I'm sure this was not an easy decision for the police, but I can understand the distress that it might cause. And I I do even now hope that a local solution can be found. But he raises the matter of whether or not there would be a debate to commend commemorate Saint George's Day. Let me see what we can do in that regard, and that will give him and others the opportunity perhaps to raise issues like this.

01:55:00 - 01:55:01

Speaker 1

Jim Dixon.

01:55:01 - 01:55:38

Speaker 63

Thank you, mister speaker. It's been a really big step forward to see the statutory levy on gambling operators up and running since April with money raised ring fenced for much needed gambling related harms research, prevention and treatment. However, I am very concerned that with only three weeks until the new financial year, funding allocations haven't yet been announced, leaving vital organisations like Gamcare, Gordon Moody, and many others uncertain of their future. Would the leader of the house pass on my concerns to the relevant health minister and ask that they update the house as soon as possible?

01:55:39 - 01:56:05

Speaker 14

Mister speaker, I thank my honourable friend for his question. We are committed to strengthening protections for those at risk and reducing harmful gambling, and levy commissioners are best placed to make decisions on the future of their work. I will ensure, however, the relevant minister has heard his concerns and that he gets an update, but, mister speaker, it will be from a DCMS minister because they are responsible for the implementation and oversight of the gambling levy. Levin Mundell.

01:56:05 - 01:56:06

Speaker 70

Thank you, caller.

01:56:06 - 01:57:10

Speaker 30

Speaker, can I associate myself with the remarks earlier about, the Dundlein tragedy? Could, the the leader of the house, arrange for there to be a statement, on the government support for egg production in The UK, a vital part of, the food chain. I have some of The UK's largest egg producers in my constituency such as Glenrath Farm and they are very concerned about a consultation on phasing out of enriched colony cages. They point out that current UK trade policy allows tariff free imports of eggs and egg products from lower welfare systems including conventional cages still legal in many non EU countries. A unilateral UK ban on cage production without equivalent import restrictions would accelerate imports of shell eggs and egg products from systems that would be illegal domestically and would undermine UK producers and processors who have invested heavily in enriched cages.

01:57:11 - 01:57:44

Speaker 14

Mister speaker, and I thank the honorable gentleman right honorable gentleman for bringing this to the house because I agree with him. It's absolutely vital that we support the British egg industry. He will be aware that DEFRA have recently held a public consultation on this matter, the which a call for views closed last week, so we will await the outcome of that. But I will make sure that the relevant minister has heard the right honorable gentleman's remarks here this morning. And when once the consultation has been considered, the outcome of the consultation, then should a a statement or a debate be necessary, then we'll help to arrange that.

01:57:46 - 01:57:48

Speaker 70

For constituents in 8th Parrott

01:57:48 - 01:58:23

Speaker 77

and Cunnock affected by the loan charge, the McCann review has had a long anticipated step towards bringing a year of uncertainty to an end. However, a number of individuals still feel that cases dating back decades remain unsolved, and the focus of enforcement has not been applied evenly between scheme promoters and those who use the arrangements. Can I ask the leader of the house what analysis has been carried out and how the recommendations of the McCann review will affect individuals and businesses that are currently engaged with HMRC on loan charge matters?

01:58:24 - 01:58:47

Speaker 14

I thank my honourable friend for raising the matter. The Government does understand the strength of feeling about this issue, which is why we accepted all but one of the independent review's recommendations and why, mister speaker, at the budget, we made the decision to write off £5,000 from the liabilities of everyone who's been affected by the loan charge. But I will ensure that ministers have heard my honourable friend's concerns today.

01:58:47 - 01:58:48

Speaker 1

Thank you,

01:58:48 - 01:59:11

Speaker 78

mister speaker. In my constituency of Guildford and right across the country, the continued spike in oil prices is having a huge financial impact on families reliant on heating oil. Will the leader of the house please allow a debate in government time on its plans to help with this issue? And also, will he ask his colleagues in the treasury to look at a mechanism for heating the, heating oil price cap?

01:59:12 - 01:59:41

Speaker 14

Mister speaker, as I I said previously, the energy minister has asked the CMA to make make sure that consumers are being treated fairly, with the option of investigation into unfair practices should they occur. We're not going to tolerate, mister speaker, companies profiteering from, this, conflict. And, should it be necessary, then I'm sure my, right honorable friend, the energy secretary, will come to this house to set out what further action, the government intends to take.

01:59:41 - 02:00:07

Speaker 15

Joe Morris. Mister speaker. Across last summer, did a tour of my constituency holding 80 surgeries in four weeks. The number one issue that came up in West Northumberland was potholes on rural roads, where we are unfortunately lumbered with conservative around Northumberland County Council, whom are actually both incompetent and, slightly neglecting the west of the county to an almost historic degree. I wonder if you if you're in the house might join me in a visit to one the potholes in my constituency.

02:00:08 - 02:00:43

Speaker 14

Thank you. Thank you very much indeed. And I thank my honorable friend for raising this matter in the house. He's a very strong advocate, not just for his constituency, but for the west of the very beautiful county of Northumberland. The government is investing £24,000,000,000 in maintaining and improving motorways and local roads across the the country.

And I would join him in urging councils such as Northumberland County Council to act so that our constituents can reap the benefits of this funding in terms of the very tempting invitation that he sends me. I will certainly look at my

02:00:43 - 02:00:45

Speaker 4

diary. Rexman.

02:00:46 - 02:01:32

Speaker 79

Thank you, mister speaker. The Liberal Democrat chaired Buckinghamshire and Milton Keane's fire authority have just consulted on closing Stoken Church Fire Station, Great Missingdon Fire Station, and removing nearly a quarter of the fire engines from the Buckinghamshire and Milton Keynes fire authority area. It is no surprise that the consultation responses are in, and the public do not want to see these dangerous cuts taking place. But the papers for next week's fire authority meeting seem to show that the fire authority are gonna ignore that consultation and carry on regardless. So can we have a debate in government time about the duties on public bodies to actually listen to consultations?

Otherwise, the public will just look at these things for token exercises rather than real meaningful engagement.

02:01:33 - 02:01:55

Speaker 14

Mister speaker, and and I do understand public concern when issues such as these arise and wherever possible. Of course, the authorities need to listen to residents. Should the honorable gentleman seek a Westminster Hall debate, I'm sure others will seek to join him in that because there there are common concerns in other areas of the country.

02:01:55 - 02:01:56

Speaker 4

Brenda Jones.

02:01:56 - 02:01:56

Speaker 16

Thank

02:01:56 - 02:02:45

Speaker 80

you, mister speaker. A constituent contacted my office to say that their daughter and her partner are caught in a student loans trap where, although they are both working and paying back their loans, they are hardly making any headway in reducing their debts. Apparently of those with student loans 76% feel trapped by a student loan balance that keeps growing despite making repayments. 87% do not think that the 6.2% interest rate on plan two loans is fair and 81% say that they're they were not fully informed about the terms of the loan when they took it out. I'm aware of the inquiry that has now been launched by the Treasury Committee, but would the leader of the house please agree to a debate in government time in due course about how we can make student loans fairer so that our young graduates do not face the life of never ending overwhelming debt.

02:02:45 - 02:03:16

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. We inherited a system of student loans, which effectively, was broken for many people. We have, we are trying to make changes to improve the, student loan system to make it, fairer, and we will continue to look at ways to do so. Yet my honorable friend refers to the, treasury select committee, which is looking into this matter. Once they've been given time to consider it, hopefully, that would be brought to the floor of the house and lead to the debate which he seeks.

02:03:16 - 02:03:16

Speaker 1

And then.

02:03:17 - 02:04:08

Speaker 81

Shock of our miss mister Sefarib, I've been inundated, as many in the house, from constituents facing impossible heating oil costs, with one telling me their 500 litre order has sold from £302 to over £900. At yesterday's meeting arranged by the minister and the treasury, the government said that people should apply to their local council for emergency support via the crisis and resilient fund. However, councils we know are on their knees financially and simply don't have this money. And additionally, this fund is an England only fund. So can we have a debate in this house on the need for the UK government to take responsibility by providing new crisis support funding for off grid house households in Wales and in the other devolved nations.

02:04:09 - 02:04:30

Speaker 14

This is, an issue which has been raised a number of times, this morning and demonstrates the strength of feeling. So I would, either, encourage the honorable lady to seek a debate on these matters to hear from the, minister. Or if she, wants a meeting, with the minister to to explain her concern, I will help her to facilitate that.

02:04:30 - 02:04:55

Speaker 41

Paul Wall. Thank mister speaker. Rochdale's Bassah Football Club recently returned from their tour of Bangladesh, where they met street children, blind children, and autistic children who were helped by the amazing £20,000 that the club had raised for charity. So will the leader join me in congratulating Dolliesmir, Sajmir, all the lads at Basa, as well as their sponsors, the restaurants, Pavilion, Pandora, Panchi, and Amore? Thanks.

02:04:55 - 02:05:12

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. I'm delighted to hear about the fundraising success of Rochdale's Bangladeshi Arts and Sports Association football club. And John, my honorable friend, in congratulating the whole team and everyone associated, with the, team, including their sponsors, who made this possible.

02:05:13 - 02:05:14

Speaker 1

Doctor Andrew Morrison.

02:05:14 - 02:05:53

Speaker 18

In the late nineteen thirties, this country's defense industrial base grew very fast indeed to deal with the mounting, threat. The failure to publish the defense industrial plan is not in that tradition. From Spitfire in Trowbridge, mister speaker, to the Royal Ordnance Factory in Chorley, you'll know that, very well. Can we have a debate in government time to establish when we are going to see the defense industrial plan whose delay is holding our defense industrial base back published? Yeah.

Mister

02:05:53 - 02:06:33

Speaker 14

Speaker, the government is committed to publishing the plan, and we'll do so at the first opportunity. But we are facing a similar situation to the one that he describes at the end of the nineteen thirties in that defenses were run down, and the decision had to be made in order to start to rebuild them. And that's why the work that he talks about at the end of the nineteen thirties had to had to happen. Of course, we hope that the what happened later is is not something that happens now. It's clearly evident, but we are trying to rebuild our defenses.

We are working on the plan, and we will publish it as soon as we can.

02:06:33 - 02:06:36

Speaker 4

And we still got the storage facility in Chorley as well. Amanda Barton.

02:06:36 - 02:07:19

Speaker 82

Thank you, mister speaker. And I'd like to firstly associate my words with the leader of the house in support for armed forces, particularly HMS Dragon that left Ports Of Shores. Residents in Caution, Poresgrove Hillsey and Drayton Farlington have faced years of dangerous anti social behaviour along Portsdownhill. Following what seems to be delays from the Hampshire PCC's office and potentially the council, the average speed cameras promised to the community are still only at tender stage and they won't be installed until after the summer. Understandably, mister speaker, my constituents do not want to face another summer of disruptions and unsafe driving.

Could leader house advise what further steps I can take to expedite action and ensure these communities finally see enforcement measures that they were promised?

02:07:19 - 02:07:51

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. We published our road safety strategy in January, which marks a turning point in the government's approach to this, and we are taking decisive action to make our roads safer for everyone. But I will ensure that the relevant minister has heard her contribution today, but it's also an opportunity, mister speaker, to thank everyone involved in getting HMS Dragon ready so that it can embark, and I want to pay tribute to everyone there. But can I also congratulate the city of Portsmouth, who I understand celebrates its centenary this year?

02:07:52 - 02:07:53

Speaker 1

All Cup.

02:07:53 - 02:08:38

Speaker 83

Thank you, mister speaker. Criterion Capital has recently embarked on a series of mass no fault evictions in my borough of Merton, including Emerald House and my Wimbledon constituency. It's a shameless attempt to do so before the practice becomes illegal under the Renters Rights Act. The section 21 notices have been accompanied by ostensibly fraudulent electrical safety reports issued by a company dissolved at the date of issue after supposed visits that do not appear to have taken place. The owner of Platinum Capital is mister Asif Assis, who has given tens of thousands of pounds to the Labour Party and to the Conservatives.

Will the leader of the house assist me in securing a debate government time on this rogue landlord? Does he agree with me that both the Labour and Conservative parties should immediately return his donations?

02:08:38 - 02:08:39

Speaker 4

What are you doing?

02:08:39 - 02:09:12

Speaker 14

She was raised earlier this week by, my, right honorable friend, on, this side of the house because I understand the concern. And it is important that the government is changing, the law, in this regard. And it's right that the honorable gentleman calls out people who are acting unfairly, in the, run up to that change in the law. It's much more important, that we protect the, the, the the people involved in this, rather than seek to play party politics.

02:09:12 - 02:09:13

Speaker 1

Thomas. Thank

02:09:13 - 02:09:48

Speaker 84

you, mister speaker. In Erewash, we are very lucky indeed to have a fantastic community radio station in Erewash Sound. Thanks to the incredible Jeff Martin, Paul Stacy, Emma Duthy, and dozens and dozens of other volunteers. We have a proper local radio station that focuses on hyper local matters, promotes our community, and has created a media training pipeline through the Erosh Sound Academy that creates real excellence. Will the leader of the house then make time for debate on community radio so everyone can hear some more about the magic that my community, many other communities around the country enjoys.

02:09:49 - 02:10:17

Speaker 14

I want to join my honourable friend in sending my thanks to all those involved in community radio, including Geoff, Paul and Emma at Airwash Sound. I know that my honourable friend was a keen musician in his youth, mister speaker, and that community radio stations such as those in his community are vital for local and grassroots music. I also, would encourage him, to apply for Westminster Hall debate, on this topic because I'm sure there are others who would wish to join in and, celebrate what's happening in their own areas.

02:10:17 - 02:10:18

Speaker 1

Yeah. Well, good job.

02:10:18 - 02:10:52

Speaker 59

Thank you, mister speaker. On Monday, my wife asked me what we were doing at work this week, and I said I was trying to support the British pub industry, and she looked at me and said trust me, you're doing your bit already. The reasons why the the pub industry are suffering a bit, we probably couldn't agree on, but would the leader of the house agree with me that we can all show some leadership in our communities if all 650 honorable members committed to going to their local pub and buying a drink this weekend?

02:10:52 - 02:10:53

Speaker 16

Yeah. Yeah.

02:10:53 - 02:10:55

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister, speaker.

02:10:55 - 02:11:12

Speaker 14

certainly encourage honorable members to visit their local pub because they're an important part of local communities, but to be moderate in their actions because we might save the poor, not we might not save our marriage.

02:11:12 - 02:11:13

Speaker 37

Never ever.

02:11:17 - 02:11:55

Speaker 15

Residents president of Mitchfield have got serious concerns about the property management company that's running their estate, Remus. Some residents have submitted formal complaints and have no reply from the company and a promised residence meeting between the company and those concerned residents has never materialised. I wrote to Remus in October to ask them to meet me, no reply. I wrote again in November, no reply. In February, I escalated to their CEO.

He did actually get back to me and he told me that the regional manager would be in touch. A month later, I've heard nothing. Will the leader of house join me in calling on Remus to stop dodging residents' complaints to meet with me as a matter of urgency?

02:11:55 - 02:12:11

Speaker 14

Speaker. Yes. Here. Here. Because it's important that members of parliament raise matters such as these on behalf of their constituents, And Remus and other companies should accept that responsibility, they should respond in an appropriate way.

02:12:11 - 02:12:12

Speaker 1

Judge Brockwell. Thank

02:12:12 - 02:12:46

Speaker 7

you, mister Speaker. Developers building in my constituency of Chichester, in Bosom, Erneley, and Bracklesham, were given planning conditions where they weren't allowed to move residents onto those new developments until the wastewater treatment work capacity had been completed. Well surprise surprise there is no extra capacity at the wastewater treatment work and yet those developers are now going back to the council to ask for that commitment to be removed from the planning conditions that got them the planning in the first place. Will the Secretary of State please arrange for me to meet with the Secretary of State for housing communities and local government so I can talk to them about an infrastructure first approach to development.

02:12:46 - 02:12:50

Speaker 1

Can I can I just suggest to members? We're gonna finish at twelve. We're gonna help each other.

02:12:50 - 02:12:57

Speaker 4

We're gonna have to really speed up. Leader. Yes. I will, mister speaker. Right.

Daniel Francis.

02:12:57 - 02:13:28

Speaker 43

Thank you, mister speaker. Last year, the Conservative Control Council in London by Bexley demolished the much loved Parkside Community Centre in Barnhurst. They've now said they will allow it to be rebuilt if a charity funds the rebuilding themselves. I've conducted a survey of local residents that says that 89% believes that the council should rebuild that rather than the charity. We believe the house therefore confirmed whether time could be made available for a debate on the importance of community buildings and the level of support available to voluntary groups who run them.

02:13:28 - 02:13:47

Speaker 14

Raider, thank you, mister speaker. I'm sorry to hear about the loss of the much loved Parkside, community centres because they provide valuable services and are, as I've said before, the golden thread that ties communities together. My honorable friend may wish to attend the Westminster Hall debate week on social enterprises and community ownership to hear more from the minister directly.

02:13:48 - 02:14:15

Speaker 29

Thank you, mister speaker. The government's own strategic defense review highlighted the important role of reservists across the country quite rightly. I'm very proud that Grantham's Prince William of Gloucester Barracks actually trains around 70% of all army reservists in the country. So can we have a debate on the government's decision to close down Grantham's Barracks and debate not just the impact on the town of Grantham, but the wider national security issues that it will cause?

02:14:15 - 02:14:26

Speaker 14

Thank you, speaker. And I understand the concerns locally that this, decision, might cause. Should the honorable gentleman, seek an adjournment debate, he can put those questions to the minister directly. Thank

02:14:29 - 02:14:56

Speaker 49

you, mister speaker. I'm proud to support the government's ambition to cut violence against women and girls, and a cross government approach is essential to delivering this. I'm increasingly concerned that the Department of Work and Pensions is not recognised in OnlyFans' content creation as commercial sexual exploitation, potentially exposing more women to harm. Will the leader of the House face this with the relevant ministers and bring forward regulations to amend section two a of the Employment and Training Act 1973 to address this problem?

02:14:56 - 02:15:16

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. The government is committed to cutting violence against women and girls, and we committed to do this in our Vogue strategy, which we published last year. We recognize that a cross government approach is essential, and we're embedding this mission into every corner of public life. But I will raise my honorable friend's concerns with the relevant minister.

02:15:16 - 02:15:17

Speaker 1

Doctor Charles Pink.

02:15:17 - 02:15:53

Speaker 32

Thank you, mister speaker. Friendly Park Hospital in my constituency is due to be rebuilt as part of the government's new hospital program, but it's recently transpired that the costs of upgrading vital local transport infrastructure have neither been costed nor budgeted for as part of that scheme. The NEO share my concerns about escalating costs, and and also about the slipping delivery times. I was told that those costs would have to come from a contingency fund for this scheme. Given that this scheme needs to be credible and command public support, can I ask for an urgent debate on this issue so that those errors are not hard coded into this process?

02:15:53 - 02:16:13

Speaker 14

You mister speaker, the honorable gentleman, raises quite rightly the investment which the, department of health intends to put into his local community, but he's right to say that it's more than just the department of health because there are issues around, transport. So I will, arrange for a meeting with him, with the relevant minister, should he seek one to see if we can resolve this.

02:16:13 - 02:16:58

Speaker 44

Lee Barrow. Thank you, mister speaker. Reform led North Northamptonshire Council has just announced that it's increasing school transport from £795 a year to £965 a year. That's a £170 increase. That's an increase of over 20% and that's an unaffordable increase for families.

That comes from a council that promised lower costs for families, comes from a council that's failed to have its books signed up, and it's from a council that's received a groundbreaking real terms increase in their settlement from this government. So does the leader of the house agree with me that North Northampton Chair Council should reverse this unacceptable, uninformed, and unaffordable decision?

02:16:58 - 02:17:31

Speaker 14

Thank you. And, mister Well, you've I I do agree with my honorable friend, and I would just contrast the record of reform led North Northamptonshire Council, with what the government is doing, to support families, in a in a whole range of, actions. The actions of reform led councils are consistently brought to my attention every week, mister speaker, in these sessions, and it's never in a positive it's never in a positive, light. So I do hope that the council has heard my honorable friend's, contribution today. It's further evidence that reform over offers and under delivers.

02:17:31 - 02:17:32

Speaker 1

John Tuglander. Thank

02:17:32 - 02:18:09

Speaker 52

you, mister speaker. Would, would the honorable sorry. Would the leader have grant some time and government time, please, to debate the state of our telephone networks? It can't be only in Tunbridge that we've noticed that actually the connectivity has gone down. And while you may see that you have full bars on four g, in fact, have no ability to get any data.

This has been a problem that's been going on for a number of years, and Jess in my office has been absolutely brilliant at trying to get the different organizations together, has sadly torn her own hair out and probably most of mine in the frustration at dealing with all of these different people who simply fail to connect Tunbridge to the rest

02:18:09 - 02:18:09

Speaker 1

of the world.

02:18:09 - 02:18:25

Speaker 14

Thank you. Over the supergition, the right honorable gentleman seek an update on what the government can do to assist this situation? I do understand his and his residents' concerns. Then I will seek that update for him. If he wants to explain that to minister directly, I'll seek a meeting for him.

02:18:25 - 02:18:48

Speaker 74

Loud mayor. Speaker, in Hemmington, in my constituency, the ward councilors Nikki Walker and Tom Moen have been trying to push the social housing provider thirteen to deal with the set of empty properties around Ellis Gardens and Fontaine Court, which have been sitting abandoned for months, perhaps even years. Does the leader agree with me that 13 need to pull their finger out and stop leaving properties to rot and support people to get into these properties?

02:18:48 - 02:19:07

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. My honorable friend, race is an important matter, and I hope that thirteen have heard his words today. The government expects social housing landlords to manage their stock efficiently, ensuring that vacant properties are made available wherever possible. These are obviously concerning matters. I'll make sure that the relevant minister is made aware of them.

02:19:08 - 02:19:09

Speaker 1

Vicky Slay.

02:19:09 - 02:19:42

Speaker 40

Thank you, mister speaker. Despite relying on public money, financial accountability and value for money of a multi academy trust is seemingly unchallenged with many leaders earning more than the prime minister. Aspirations with the school in Paul spent money on Teslas for their central staff and are now cutting the curriculum to balance the books. In this year, it's cutting teaching assistants as send increase increases, blaming reducing pupil numbers while boosting their exec team. With the current consultation on the white paper, now seems a good time for the government to make time government time, for a debate on transparency and accountability of academies so we can drive out access and get back

02:19:42 - 02:19:43

Speaker 85

to doing what they were supposed to.

02:19:43 - 02:19:49

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. When the consultation has ended, I'm sure there'll be an ample opportunity to raise the points that the honorable radius raised.

02:19:49 - 02:19:50

Speaker 8

Ron Rufflin.

02:19:50 - 02:20:15

Speaker 38

Thank you, mister speaker. This labor government has given conservative run West Sussex County Council 27,000,000 to get our roads in shape. But across my constituency, there are dangerous potholes they refuse to fill and roads in desperate need of resurfacing, including in Mansfield Road and Fessager Road in East Worthing that I saw at the weekend. Will the leader of the house join me in calling on the county council to properly fix roads across Ada and Worthing and make time for debate on renewing our road?

02:20:15 - 02:20:29

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. The performance of Conservative run West Sussex County Council on potholes, was raised with me only, last week, mister speaker, and I'm sure that, today, they will have heard my honorable friend's contribution, and I hope that it spurs them into action.

02:20:29 - 02:20:30

Speaker 1

Flag, Jones.

02:20:30 - 02:21:05

Speaker 41

Thank you very much, mister speaker. Duncan Lynch Precision Engineering is a successful specialist manufacturing company established over sixty years ago. They would like to take on a number of new apprenticeships, good, well paid jobs for local young people. The company is struggling to find apprenticeships, and appropriate courses, a clear concern for the business and for young people seeking a good career. Can we have a debate in government time to discuss how to boost the uptake of apprenticeships and improving the courses available to manufacturing and engineering business?

02:21:05 - 02:21:37

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. The tragic record of the last government pause that apprenticeships went down. This government is committed to reversing that, which is why we have a £725,000,000 growth in skills levy, and our reforms will help to deliver 50,000 new apprenticeships. And in our first year, we've helped over 350,000 people into apprenticeships. So should the minister should the minister should the honorable gentleman seek a minister a meeting with the minister to explore what further can be done, then I will arrange that.

02:21:37 - 02:21:38

Speaker 1

Sorry, Coombs.

02:21:38 - 02:21:39

Speaker 86

Thank you, mister

02:21:39 - 02:22:19

Speaker 33

speaker. This week, there was a mass release of balloons in Birmingham in memory of my friend, councilor Waseem Zafar, who passed away suddenly and tragically at the age of 44. There was no proud of Brummie than Waseem. He loved the city, he loved the villa, and he loved representing the people of L'Hazeles. As cabinet member for transport, he was the driving force behind the city's clean air zone, and he fought every day against the health inequalities that mean so many Brummies die too young.

I will miss Waseem more than I can say. He leaves a hole in the city that would be very difficult to fill. Will the leader join me in sending his deepest condolences to Waseem's wife Aisha, his four sons, his wider family, and can we have a debate on the health inequalities that Waseem cared so passionately about?

02:22:22 - 02:22:48

Speaker 14

absolutely join my honorable friend paying tribute to Waseem Zafar and his work as a local councillor, particularly on the clean air zone in Birmingham. I know that he will be greatly missed, and I extend my heartfelt condolences to his loved ones at this time. Should my honorable friend, seek a Westminster, hall debate, then she will not only be able to pay further tribute, but to explore, what further action needs to be taken, on these very important environmental matters.

02:22:48 - 02:22:48

Speaker 1

Well,

02:22:49 - 02:23:20

Speaker 57

thank you, mister speaker. I'm seriously concerned about the lack of progress for the public office accountability bill. I sat on the committee in November, and it was urgent then. Can the leader of the house write write to me to explain why the government's not adopted the common sense and victim centred amendment 23. And it's ironic really that bearing this in mind this is about openness and transparency.

Ministers seem to be completely unable to explain their objections to it. And can he investigate what is blocking progress, please?

02:23:20 - 02:23:21

Speaker 1

The minister Absolutely,

02:23:21 - 02:23:37

Speaker 14

don't worry. Ministers are working very hard, mister speaker, on what is a a sensitive bill, actually, in many ways, and we are working hard. We will bring forward the bill, in, in due course. But if she seeks an an update, from the relevant minister, then I I will get her one.

02:23:37 - 02:23:38

Speaker 1

Laura Lubbock.

02:23:38 - 02:23:39

Speaker 55

Thank you, mister speaker. Yeah.

02:23:39 - 02:23:40

Speaker 3

Yeah. May I

02:23:40 - 02:24:10

Speaker 55

ask the leader of the house for a debate on recent valuation office agency changes to business rate class classifications for flexible and co working spaces. The agencies say they are just following case law, the change could have significant implications for these businesses, some of whom will face big back dated bills. Flexible working spaces are an important factor in regenerating a lot of our town centres, like Chatham in my constituency, because they drive footfall into our town centres and people spend money in local shops. We desperately need a political solution to this problem.

02:24:10 - 02:24:30

Speaker 14

Leader. Thank you, mister speaker. I absolutely agree with my honorable friend that flexible coworking spaces play a vital role in high street regeneration, and that's a priority for this government. I'll be happy to help her to arrange a meeting with the relevant minister to discuss this should she wish, or should she seek a Westminster Hall debate on these matters. I'm sure the debate would be popular.

02:24:30 - 02:24:53

Speaker 37

Max Wilkins. Thank you, mister speaker. Under regional devolution plans, Gloucestershire is being told by MHC LG to go to the North with Herefordshire and Worcestershire, maybe Warwickshire as well. Our ICB is being merged with Bristol, North Somerset, and South Gloucestershire. Meanwhile, our police boundaries are being merged with Wiltshire.

Does the leader agree with me that this makes a mockery of the devolution agenda? And if he does, can he arrange for me to meet with the appropriate minister so we can sort it out?

02:24:53 - 02:24:53

Speaker 1

Well, I

02:24:53 - 02:25:10

Speaker 14

I don't agree with him, mister speaker. It makes a mockery of this. It's about getting local decisions made best on behalf of local people. But it is important that we we recognize regional and local identity. And should he seek a meeting with the minister, then I'll help him to arrange one.

02:25:10 - 02:25:41

Speaker 58

Pardon? Whereas, mister speaker, Joffe Mitchell, who's from my neighboring constituency, was diagnosed with motor neuron disease last October, and since then Joffe has raised over £50,000 for MND research through activities including plunging into frozen Austrian, lakes and warm Sri Lankan seas, I should declare an interest Joffe is my oldest and dearest friend. Given the importance of both sustaining research funding into MND and addressing significant patient delays or experience in in accessing genetic testing, could the leader assist me in getting a meeting with relevant ministers?

02:25:41 - 02:25:42

Speaker 1

Minister. Thank

02:25:42 - 02:25:59

Speaker 14

you, mister Speaker. And I send my best wishes to John and congratulate him on the money that he's raised so far. We are investing in MND research across all areas, causes, prevention, diagnosis, treatment, and care, mister speaker. But I will assist my honorable friend in getting the meeting that he seeks with the minister.

02:26:00 - 02:26:01

Speaker 1

That brings me to Jim Sheffield.

02:26:02 - 02:26:40

Speaker 9

Thank you, mister speaker. I want to bring to attention of the, leader of the house. Nigeria's president, Tanubu, had a recent visit to to, The UK. There were concerns regarding the ongoing harassment, persecution, killing Christians in Nigeria. Thousands of Christians were killed, abducted, or unlawfully detained in Nigeria last year alone.

Islamic militants operate with impunity in 12 states in force Sharia law, leaving Christians as second class citizens and punishing those who convert from Islam. Leah Sharbou is one of those in her eighth year of captivity. Could I ask the the Labour to raise the decision of the FCDO and ensure that Leah Sharbou can be freed?

02:26:40 - 02:26:41

Speaker 1

Thank you. I believe

02:26:41 - 02:27:05

Speaker 14

that, mister speaker. The honorable gentleman is absolutely committed to defending freedom of religion and belief for all, and so is this, government. It is our firm belief that every Nigerian should be able to practice their faith or belief in safety, free from fear and persecution. And I commend the dedication by the hon. Gentleman for consistently raising these matters in this chamber, and I will share his concern with the foreign office after today's session.

02:27:05 - 02:27:28

Speaker 16

In October, sent a number of FOI requests to the Nursing and Midwifery Council on sexual harassment and misconduct cases. However I've still not received a reply. For these bodies to be trusted they have to be accountable. Will the house please advise me what more I can do to make sure we get proper accountability under the Freedom of Information Act?

02:27:28 - 02:27:46

Speaker 14

Thank you. Thank Mister speaker, my honorable friend, will will know, mister speaker, that the FOI Act sets out in legislation the requirements for public bodies to release that information. So I'm disappointed, that he needs to bring this to the matter, to the floor, today, and I will make sure that his concerns are raised with the relevant body.

02:27:46 - 02:27:47

Speaker 1

Chris Watt.

02:27:47 - 02:28:17

Speaker 87

Thank you, mister speaker. 5,000 people walked through the door of the Blackpool Winter Gardens the other week for my second annual jobs fair, which I was delighted to open with the secretary of state for the department of work and pensions. Over a thousand roles were secured on the spot, 853 have already started their new jobs with thousand more's handing out CVs and interviews on the way. So will the leader of the house join me in thanking my constituency team, job center staff, Blackpool Tourism Limited, and every employer and resident who attended making it such a huge success?

02:28:17 - 02:28:52

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. I certainly join my honorable friend in thanking everyone associated with the Blackpool, jobs fair and making it a success, not least, my honorable friend, who is a fantastic fighter, on behalf of his constituents. It is incredible, mister speaker, to hear that over a thousand rules were secured on the spot, and it's the jobs fair, which was the first ever jobs fair, for the youth, guarantee. It's good to see so many local employers choosing to back our youth guarantee, and we'll keep going further to make sure, like my friend, our honorable friend, that every young person has the chance to earn or learn.

02:28:52 - 02:28:52

Speaker 4

Josh Stupid.

02:28:52 - 02:28:53

Speaker 15

Thank you,

02:28:53 - 02:29:16

Speaker 6

mister speaker. Having heard that MHCLG will soon decide on the next round of Pride in Place funding, I'd like to make a plug for my iconic Chase constituency. It's my honor to represent proud communities, but many like Chadsmore and Rugenley Springfield Estate were hit hard by austerity that tore away support for deprived areas. Would the leader agree with me that Cannock Chase would make an excellent candidate for Pride in Place, and could we have a debate on the benefits of local growth funding for communities up and down the country?

02:29:16 - 02:29:40

Speaker 14

Thank you, mister speaker. My honorable friend is a fantastic champion for his constituency, and I commend him for that. We are giving the government are giving constituents the investment in powers that they need so that they can deliver the change that they want to see in their, communities. So I wish my honorable friend constituency good luck, but also wish other members of the house good luck in their campaign to get pride in place and to make sure that it's a success.

02:29:40 - 02:30:11

Speaker 53

Mister speaker, tomorrow marks the eighty fifth anniversary of the Claybank blitz when across the nights of the March 1941, my hometown of Clebank suffered horrendous losses. Five hundred and twenty eight people were killed, and of the 12,000 homes, only eight remained undamaged. And I'll be attending the service of remembrance at Cabowy St Andrew's church in Clebank tomorrow. Will the leader of the house join me in commemorating this occasion and agree that all wars, result in the loss of innocent civilian lives?

02:30:11 - 02:30:35

Speaker 14

I thank my honourable friend for marking this important anniversary, mister speaker, and particularly at this time, we must remember all those who serve and have served in our armed forces and who are victims, on the, of the devastating impact of war. Anniversaries such as the Clydebank Blitz remind us of those who have served, those who were wounded, and those who were killed, and I thank my honourable friend for raising it this morning.

02:30:35 - 02:30:37

Speaker 1

It's fair to say to the member for Clydebank, I did go to

02:30:37 - 02:30:40

Speaker 4

the memorial a few years ago. Very moving.

02:30:41 - 02:32:52

Speaker 1

Right. Let the front benches change over. Before we come to the statement on defending democracy task force, I would like to make a related statement. Members will recall that in October 2024, I established a speakers' conference to examine the security of members, candidates and elections. That cross party group published two reports, the first in June and the second in October 2025.

Together, those reports set out more than 60 recommendations to tackle the series and the wholly unacceptable levels of abuse intimidation that was faced by politicians. The scale of the challenge is clear, and no single body can dress it alone. The conference, therefore, called for action across government law enforcement, political parties, traditional and social media, and several other relevant stakeholders. It also recognized members' collective responsibility to lead by example in the way that we treat each other. Responses on both reports have now been published, and I notified that all members and member staff of the earlier in the week, and so therefore they should have seen it.

I am encouraged by the clear sense of shared purpose and determination to tackle the issues shown by all partners, and I'd like to thank them for their constructive engagement and positive response to the conference's work. Although the conference has concluded its formal work, I remain committed to monitoring progress closely and will continue to press for delivery of its recommendations where necessary. With that, I'm pleased to be calling the security minister today who will update the house on the work of defending democracy task force, which includes action the government is taking in support of the speakers' conference recommendations. Minister Dunjavas. Hear.

Hear.

02:32:52 - 02:36:07

Speaker 4

Paul, thank you, mister speaker, for your statement. And with permission, I will make a statement on the work the government is leading to defend our democracy and those who serve within it, particularly as we approach the local and devolved elections taking place in May. Now, mister speaker, twice in the last decade, devoted and beloved members of this house have been lost to abhorrent acts of violence. Each time I enter this chamber, my eyes are drawn to the shields dedicated to Joe Cox and to sir David Amis. They are not simply memorials.

They are a daily reminder of the duty we owe to one another and to our democracy to ensure that no one is deterred from public service by fear, intimidation, or violence. It is in that spirit that I come to the house today to set out the challenges we face, what this government is doing, and to make clear what we will not tolerate. Now, mister speaker, the work of elected representatives at every level level matters. It shapes millions of lives and our country's future. That is why those entrusted to serve must be able to do so without fear or favor.

Free debate and honest disagreement are the lifeblood of democracy. But let me be clear. Harassment, intimidation, abuse, and violence are not political expression. And today, the volume, breadth, and tempo of threats against elected representatives is unprecedented. Across this house, colleagues will recognize the grim reality, assaults, vandalism, stalking, blockading, a blizzard of online abuse.

This is not theoretical. It affects honorable members, counselors, and candidates. It affects our families and our staff. Women and ethnic minority representatives report the highest volumes of abuse, including overtly sexualized and racially charged threats, which has a chilling effect on who feels able to stand for public office. When fear warps debate, when candidates step back, and when fewer people from diverse backgrounds feel able to stand, the damage is deep and lasting.

That is why this government treats harassment and intimidation not as an inevitable occupational hazard, but as a serious threat to our democracy itself. Now I know that you share that stance, mister speaker, and I pay tribute to your leadership, especially through the work of the speakers' conference. And our response is rooted in the defending democracy task force which I chair, working across government, law enforcement, parliament, the electoral commission, and the intelligence community. The mandate of the task force renewed by this prime minister is clear, to tackle the full spectrum of threats to

02:36:07 - 02:36:07

Speaker 14

our

02:36:07 - 02:45:07

Speaker 4

democracy. That means preventing and deterring harassment, ensuring real consequences when it does occur, and providing proportionate effective security for everyone who participates in our democratic process. This is a year round task, but the upcoming local elections demand that we intensify our focus and where necessary, go further. Now yesterday, I chaired a meeting of the defending democracy task force with ministers from the devolved nations. It was a constructive discussion on strengthening our collective security posture ahead of May.

We reaffirmed our readiness to support colleagues in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. The police are at the forefront of defending democracy efforts, and I thank officers and staff across the country for their dedication and diligence. Ahead of the May elections, we are working with the College of Policing, the National Police Chiefs Council to strengthen guidance for frontline officers responding to incidents involving elected representatives. It is essential that the consistency of police response is improved across all force areas, and I welcome the police's decision to act on the recommendations of your conference, mister speaker. Now I'm pleased to be able to inform the house today that the deputy chief constable Chris Balmer from Cambridgeshire Police has been appointed to the role as the national police chief's council lead for defending democracy.

And I've written to the chair of the National Police Chiefs Council and to DCC, Barmer, to stress the importance of their work to democracy itself. I emphasize the importance of keeping pace with the evolving threat abuse poses to democracy, and I will be meeting with them both shortly. Every police force now has a dedicated superintendent coordinator for Operation Bridger, which handles the protection of members beyond the parliamentary estate. Through operation Ford, elected official advisers at working level exist to support both members of parliament and locally elected representatives. I've extended the operation Ford offer to cover all elected representatives across England, Scotland, and Wales, supported by a full time network of 66 home office funded force elected official advisers.

I'm also pleased to announce the creation of a new threat assessment center. This will support operation Ford by centralizing and coordinating intelligence nationally for incidents which target locally elected representatives. This function will be live ahead of the local elections. Now, mister speaker, where the law fails to provide adequate protection, we will strengthen it. We've seen protests deliberately targeted at private homes, timed to intimidate families and children, and designed to exert pressure through fear.

That is why the crime and policing bill introduces a new offense to restrict protests outside the homes of public office holders. Peaceful protest is a cherished right, but the doorstep of a private home is not an appropriate setting for it. In addition, the representation of the people bill will introduce a new aggravating factor empowering courts to hand down longer sentences to reflect the seriousness of crimes committed against those who serve our democracy, whether elected representatives, candidates, their staff, campaigners, and electoral officials. Now, mister speaker, many members across this house and beyond have faced sustained online abuse and intimidation. Some have questioned whether to stand again.

This is simply unacceptable. Through the Online Safety Act, The UK has established one of the strongest online safety frameworks in the world. Services now have clear legal duties to identify, remove, and prevent illegal content, including threats, incitement, and nonconceptual consensual intimate images such as explicit deepfakes. And as we approach the May elections, government will be engaging directly with major social media platforms to support and inform their election preparedness. Now, mister speaker, countering threats to our democracy is a priority for this government, but I have always believed that this should be a shared endeavor.

Therefore, today, I am directly appealing to every member of this house and to colleagues across local government and the devolved governments to play their part. Where we see harassment or intimidation, we must act. Where we experience it, we must report it. I know it can be time consuming, but reporting really does matter. The parliamentary security department works closely with the home office and the police to assess threats and put protections in place, but they can only do so with accurate information.

Every report, even if the incident is judged to be below the criminal threshold, helps the authorities to build a clearer picture of the threat. So I urge on rule members, if there is an immediate danger, of course, call 999, reference operation Bridger, and use your SOS fob. For nonemergency incidents, report them via 101 or online, but, again, reference op Bridger and inform your Bridger single point of contact. The metro mayors, local councilors, and police and crime commissioners reference operation Ford, and this will be picked up by the local force elected official adviser. Let me be equally clear about our message to those who threaten, intimidate, or harass those participating in our democracy, and this applies to individuals and groups alike.

Anonymity is not safety. No one is beyond reach. And whether the offense occurs online or offline, those responsible should expect to be investigated and prosecuted. Now, mister speaker, we must challenge at every turn the notion that abuse, threats, and intimidation are now an inevitability for those working in politics and in public life. Across our society, we must never become desensitized to rhetoric about harming those who serve in public life.

When we hear it or see it in our communities, it should be challenged, not shrugged off as some new normal. And all of us in this house must also lead by example. Those entrusted with public office set the tone for our national conversation. If we allow abuse to creep into our exchanges, whether here or on the campaign trail, we risk normalizing behavior that undermines democratic debate. By leading with civility, even in moments of sharp disagreement, we demonstrate to the country that principled argument can coexist with mutual respect.

Mister speaker, I can inform the house that an extensive program of work is well underway to ensure the security of the local and the devolved nation elections taking place in May. This includes support for returning officers to keep polling stations and count cent count centers secure alongside expert guidance on personal and cybersecurity for candidates. Mister speaker, history shows us that our democracy is precious. So today, together, we should draw a line declaring with one voice that we will not be deterred from serving the public. We will never tolerate abuse, threats, and intimidation.

And together, we will confront unacceptable behavior, hold perpetrators to account, and defend our democratic way of life. And in doing so, we honor the words of Joe Cox who taught us that we have far more in common than that which divides us. I commend the statement to the house.

02:45:07 - 02:45:08

Speaker 21

Can I thank

02:45:08 - 02:45:24

Speaker 1

the minister for the statement and thank him for taking on the recommendations of the conference as well? And I'd like to put on record my thanks for those who served on the conference and for all the effort that was put in. I think this is when the House has at its best. Katie Lamb, Shadow Minister.

02:45:24 - 02:49:27

Speaker 88

Thank you, mister speaker. There is much to welcome in the security minister's statement today. I thank him for advanced sight of it and more broadly for his update on the work of the defending democracy task force. And I join him in remembering our colleagues who lost their lives in service of the public. As he rightly notes, all of us in this place have a sacred duty to protect and uphold the democracy which has made this country so great for so long.

I know few understand this as well as those in the Speaker's office, mister speaker, and all of our madam deputy speakers. So let me take this opportunity to thank you on behalf of all members here for everything you do in public and in private to keep us all safe. Targeted and serious intimidation of democratically elected politicians, particularly where their intimidation escalates into credible physical threats, is a serious impediment to the functioning of our democracy. It is, of course, right that criminal behavior is prosecuted and punished. At the same time, we have a duty to ensure that policing of genuinely criminal behavior does not stray into policing of free speech or free expression.

In individual cases, this can be a challenging balance to strike. I trust the minister will approach these cases with the appropriate caution and sensitivity. While many aspects of the minister's statement are encouraging, I am concerned that other members of this government have failed to approach this issue with the necessary caution or the necessary candor. We must be honest about the fact that while violence against elected politicians can come from a wide variety of groups, the single biggest extremist threat to our country remains the threat of extremist Islamist violence. That threat is intimate intimately tied up with a growing tendency towards sectarian politics in some parts of our country.

As my right honorable friend, the leader of the opposition said recently, separatism is on the rise in our country because for too long, Britain has been complacent about our culture and too tolerant of those weaponizing identity politics for their own gain. Yet, in its cohesion strategy published earlier this week, this government seemed unwilling to deal with this threat head on. The strategy openly acknowledged the existence of communities in The UK living segregated or parallel lives. But rather than dealing with that problem directly, the government proposes a package which may only make this problem worse. More DEI in the public sector, an attempt to smuggle in so called social engineering under the guidance of social cohesion, under the guise of social cohesion, advisory boards designed to manage tensions when it was exactly this focus on managing community tensions which allowed rape and grooming gangs to operate unchecked for so long in towns and cities across our country, and a new rebranded Islamophobia definition to be issued as guidance to public servants which will have a chilling effect on their behaviour.

This will make it harder to have open public discussions about subjects like female genital mutilation, grooming and rape gangs, and extremism, including any threats it may pose to our democracy. We have already seen that creating conditions in which people fear being branded as racist for keeping the public safe can create horrific outcomes. We must never again allow guidance like this to create a culture of fear which breeds inaction, cover up, or denial. The cohesion strategy is a recipe for further suppression of discussion of the threats that face us today and their root causes. We will not make the truth disappear by discouraging people from talking about it.

That has never worked, and it will not work now. So, again, I thank the minister for his statement today and his work on tackling criminality towards elected officials. Can he assure us that his colleagues in government are as committed to dealing with this problem at its root as he himself seems to be?

02:49:28 - 02:49:30

Speaker 89

Minister Jarvis. Absolutely disgusting.

02:49:30 - 02:54:11

Speaker 4

Madam deputy speaker, let let me firstly join with the shadow minister in expressing our, I'm sure, collective thanks to mister speaker, to all the deputy speakers, all the staff in this house for the important work that they do. It's hugely appreciated, and I know that we are very grateful to it. Let me, try and find a a point of consensus, difficult though that may be to do given what we've heard. I'd very much wanted to take the opportunity today to do this on a very much across party basis. And in fact, I'd intended and will continue to take the opportunity to thank the work that was done by the previous government.

In particular, I want to take the opportunity to pay tribute to my predecessor, the right honorable member for Tonbridge, who set up the defending democracy task force. It didn't exist before he was the security minister. He set it up. It is a very strong legacy for him because he invested a lot in it, and I hope that he will see how seriously we take that work. He passed the baton on to me, and I hope that he will see that having taken the baton gratefully from him, we have sprinted forward with it.

I was particularly pleased this week to chair a meeting of the defending democracy task force that brought the whole of the system together. That was always his intention that it would provide that fulcrum point to bring together the different constituent parts of government and law enforcement and the electoral commission to provide, if you like, a single version of the truth and make sure that we are properly resourcing all of those who work to keep us safe. I think and I hope that he'd be proud of the work that the task force is doing. He understands it's not just about periods of electoral activity. This is activity that takes place the whole year round.

He knows how seriously I take it, and I was really grateful, the other day to be reminded of the work that he'd done in terms of getting us, to where we are now. And I hope that he will be pleased to acknowledge the progress that we've made in recent times, which I, referenced in my, introductory remarks. Not least, the government has introduced new legislation. It's important to bring forward legislation where it's required, which will restrict the protest outside the homes of public office holders. I don't think anyone really thinks that it is appropriate that MPs and their families should be targeted at home, and we are, taking legislative action to prevent that from happening.

The relationship, as the right honorable gentleman will know, with the police is a very important one, and we work very closely with them to ensure that they've got the appropriate guidance that they need, particularly for police officers on the front line when responding to incidents involving elected representatives. And I'm particularly pleased to be joined on the front bench by the minister for democracy. She has other responsibilities, but that's a very important part of her remit. I'm really grateful to her for the important work that she has been done been doing in terms of the representation of the people bill, which will introduce new measures to create a very powerful deterrent for those who would seek to intimidate those who serve in our democracy. Now the the shadow minister opposite, she did raise a point about policing priorities, and I understand why she would seek to raise that particular point.

She will understand, not least from her time previously working in the home office, that the police are operationally independent, but it is important that we work closely with the police. That's why I particularly took the opportunity this morning to welcome the appointment of a new national lead for defending democracy. This is someone that I intend to work very closely with and I think will provide an important focus for policing activity around the country. Now, madam deputy speaker, I am very sorry that the, honorable lady opposite then chose to segue into matters that were not within the scope of this statement. I I'm genuinely so sorry that she decided to do so because not least, I've given, the the front bench opposite ample, warning of my intention to come forward and bring a statement to this house today.

I did so on the clear understanding that this is something around which we can unite as a house. That on this, of all occasions, as we stand and sit in the shadow of the shields, if we can't cooperate on this, then what can we cooperate? So I hope the honorable lady will reflect on her comments.

02:54:11 - 02:54:13

Speaker 90

Dear. Dawn Butler.

02:54:13 - 02:55:31

Speaker 91

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Madam deputy speaker, I hope the shadow minister will get to her feet and correct the record because there's a far greater threat from the far right than there is from Islam. You know in this holy month of Ramadan I'm sure Muslims all over the country will be praying for her soul whether she deserves it or not. Madam deputy speaker I sit on the speaker's commission on AI, which is chaired quite expertly by yourself and every month I put a block of the month on my social media. The threats to our safety is getting worse.

A small number of tech firms are deciding what a large number of people see here on their social media platforms with very little oversight or accountability. Eight people basically deciding what 8,000,000,000 people see. It is time and I hope the minister would agree with me. It's time we can't put guardrails around the AI industry. It's moving too quickly.

So we need to put guardrails around the human beings. We need to make sure that our rights are protected. Our voice, our image, and what we do is protected. So we need to focus on guardrails around the human. And I do hope that the minister will consider my human rights bill that I'm proposing very shortly.

02:55:31 - 02:55:32

Speaker 89

Minister Jarvis.

02:55:32 - 02:56:28

Speaker 4

Madam deputy speaker, I'm very grateful to my honorable friend, not least for the work that she does on the speaker's commission, and she's right to raise the concerns in the way that she has. I know that she will understand that there's a very important role for DCIP in terms of these matters. These are things that we discuss in the forum of the defending democracy task force on a very regular basis, but she's right to raise her concerns. And I know that they will be widely shared around this house. But perhaps I might just say one other thing to my honorable friend because I am in awe of the courage that she and other honorable members brings to their public service in the face of extremely unpleasant abuse that she and other honorable members have to tolerate on a very regular basis, that she continues to step forward to represent her constituents and her country in a way that she does is greatly to her credit.

02:56:29 - 02:56:31

Speaker 89

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Max Wilkinson.

02:56:31 - 02:59:31

Speaker 37

Thank you, madam deputy speaker, and thank you to the speaker's, office for all that the speaker and the madam deputy speakers are doing on this issue. I must say I was somewhat taken aback by the shadow minister's approach to this, and I'll try to be, constructive. But where I do veer away, I hope the minister will, take the points. The minister is right to highlight the importance of protecting politicians at every level of our democracy. We must ensure that the horror of what happened to Joe Cox and sir David Amos never happens again, and the representatives at every level feel secure when they're discharging their democratic duties.

Many members have received death threats and harassment and fear for their families, particularly women and those from minority backgrounds. Having experienced threats myself, not from radical Islamists, but from right wing extremists, I know how important these protections are. I also remember, as the Cheltenham MP, the bravery of Andrew Pennington, who died defending my late friend Nigel Jones in an attack on the Cheltenham Liberal Democrat office. I welcome the steps that the minister is taking to ensure that the elections in May are free and fair. Our democracy is precious, and it must be carefully protected by those in power.

To that end, we welcome the existence of the task force and the work that it is doing. We do worry, however, that the task force is perhaps not working fast enough to address the threat of foreign interference in our democracy. Hostile states are increasingly using social and traditional media to spread disinformation to undermine democracy and our elections. So what steps are ministers taking to tackle that threat? As the member of parliament for Cheltenham, home to GCHQ, I know the vital work our intelligence agencies do to counter those threats, but that must be matched by political leadership from this house as well.

We will all remember, madam deputy speaker, with disgust, the case of Nathan Gill, the reform politician convicted of working for the Russian government, which received remarkably little attention, yet it shows the very real threat to our democracy from within. We're all scarred also by the revelations that there were agents of the Chinese Communist Party working in this house for honorable members, and we were outraged, rightly, that Peter Mandelson shared market sensitive information with Epstein among elements of many elements of disgraceful conduct that poses a threat to our democracy. So it is not now time so is it not now time for a dedicated crime and corruption unit in Whitehall? And would the minister agree with me that it is time for legislation to ensure all electoral candidates declare any donations or gifts from Russia? Does he also agree with me that it's time that rules are introduced around donations made to political parties via cryptocurrencies.

This method obscures the source of donations, and this loophole must be closed before it is exploited more widely to the detriment of our democracy. We will all have noted the recent endorsement of crypto by the leader of the reform party, the member for Clapton, who does so, madam deputy speaker, while maintaining, and I quote, that he does not do computers. There is much work to be done to protect our democracy, and the minister and the government has our support to speed that up because there is nothing more important than we can do in this house than protect those values.

02:59:31 - 02:59:32

Speaker 89

Minister Jarvis.

02:59:32 - 03:00:54

Speaker 4

Madam deputy speaker, I'm very grateful to him for the constructive nature of his tone, this morning. I'm also very concerned to hear about the threats that he has, faced, and he knows that I'd be very keen to work closely with him if there's any further support that he thinks that is required. And I also join with him in remembering his lost colleague. He's right to raise the important work that his constituents do in his constituency of Jeltenham, and he knows that I'm a huge supporter and a fairly regular visitor, to meet with them. And he's right to raise concerns about foreign interference.

He will know, and I'm pretty certain that his party have provided a a submission to the Rycroft review, that the government commissioned Philip Rycroft to do an independent piece of work, to look at the nature of, interference in our democracy. I know that, mister Rycroft is finishing his work and will report, to ministers in the near future and will do so in a way that will allow MHCLG to incorporate any of the recommendations that we think is appropriate into forthcoming legislation. He cited a number of particularly egregious examples of interference in our democracy, and he made a number of what I think are entirely reasonable and helpful suggestions. I hope he knows that my door, and I'm sure the door, my fellow minister is always open to him should he wish to discuss these matters further.

03:00:54 - 03:00:56

Speaker 89

Rachel Hopkins. I

03:00:57 - 03:01:43

Speaker 78

should mention that I'm a member of the Speaker's Committee on the Electoral Commission, where we work very collegiately, cross party, in support of that important work. I thank the minister for his statement today and like the women who encouraged me, I aim to support any young women, particularly those from black and Asian minority backgrounds in my constituency, to put themselves forward to represent their communities in local government. Unfortunately, the increased harassment, abuse and intimidation of councillors and candidates we've seen, particularly in recent years, has been a huge deterrent. Does the minister agree with me that it's vital that we increase the support and protection to all those putting themselves forward, but particularly women, to encourage women from all backgrounds to step forward and represent their communities?

03:01:43 - 03:01:44

Speaker 23

I'm very

03:01:44 - 03:03:14

Speaker 4

grateful, madam deputy speaker, to my own royal friend, for the important work that she does on the electoral commission panel and for the points that she has raised. She's absolutely right about the threat that women elected representatives and candidates face around the country. I hope that she sees the determination of the government to work with her and colleagues across this house to make sure that we're putting the protections and the support in place that are required. That was specifically why I referenced the creation of the new threat assessment, which will provide a greater granularity around operation in intelligence that that we think will deliver real benefits at a local level. She's absolutely right to highlight the concern about the threats, intimidation, and harassment both online and in person of those participating in public life, and there are some particularly egregious examples of that in recent times.

We've got to do everything that we possibly can to support those women who want to step forward, And I'm particularly concerned of the chilling effect that some of these threats and intimidation have on extremely talented women who might want to step forward in public life, but will look at the circumstances that they might have to deal with and think, well, why would I want to expose myself to that? We should all collectively be very concerned about that, and collectively, we should redouble our efforts to stand against it. And that is precisely why I made the point, hopefully, clearly as as I did, that wherever we encounter this kind of activity, we must report it.

03:03:15 - 03:03:16

Speaker 89

My neighbor, Tom Tighornhut.

03:03:16 - 03:05:34

Speaker 52

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. May I start by thanking my, honorable friend for his kind words at the beginning, and may I also extend, praise to lord Case, who is cabinet secretary who was so important in setting this up. He's absolutely right to, of course, have mentioned Joe Cox and sir David Amis, both of whom, at various different points were in my mind when this was set up, and I am indeed extremely, impressed with what he's done in taking forward the defending democracy task force. May I perhaps unfairly challenge him, however, to go a little further and to answer some of the questions that I didn't answer when I was in his place, but I hope that he may be able to answer now that things have progressed a bit. And that's really to do with foreign influence.

When we're looking today at what China has done in our democracy, and I don't just mean in this house, but I mean online, when we're seeing the threats that organizations like TikTok bring in terms of disinformation and the way in which they actively promote or demote stories that promote division, We can see that the nature of the threat has changed, and this is really a question about influence. Now yesterday, I had the good fortune of meeting the director general of Taiwan's Ministry of Justice Intelligence Bureau, who is he knows I was the first cabinet minister to meet a cabinet minister from Taiwan in a non trade capacity. They have a lot to teach us about the way in which China plays in our democracy and tries to influence it. Has he looked or has he considered any of that yet? And the second area I would be interested in his thoughts, again, an area that I didn't get to, I would have liked to have got to, but I didn't get to when I was in his position, which is on the protection of journalists.

Because while it is, of course, important to protect the freedom of elected members at whatever organization, whether council or national, that in which they speak. It is also important to protect journalists in their freedom to speak. Now I was made aware only recently of a very unpleasant threat against Constantine Kissin relating the attack on Charlie Kirk who was murdered only a few months ago. Now this happened to come from a left wing extremist, but as we know, there were extremists of various different color and creed in our community, various different political opinion. So has he looked at how protecting journalists may be able to be brought into the defending democracy task force?

03:05:34 - 03:05:35

Speaker 86

Mister Jones.

03:05:36 - 03:07:13

Speaker 4

Well, madam deputy speaker, let me extend my thanks to him again for the work that he did, and he's right to raise the important contribution that was made by the then cabinet secretary, now Lord Case, in terms of setting the defending democracy task force up in the first place. And I genuinely welcome the points that he has made. He's been very good about providing helpful bits of information and intelligence over the past eighteen months or so, and I always really appreciate that because it's it's well meant and well received. I understand why he raises the particular, concerns about China, which have been very well debated across this house. I believe that he does understand how seriously I take those threats.

There is a huge amount of activity taking place across government for reasons that he will know very well. We don't often get into the detail of all of that, but I hope that he will understand that that activity is underway. And a crucial part of that is, as he described, working with our allies, and we do that on a very, very regular basis. He's right to raise the important role that journalists play. He will remember from his time in the home office and working with colleagues across government that a lot of resource and a lot of time is invested in our protective security regime.

We don't tend to say much about it, but I give him an assurance of the seriousness with which we take these issues. And I agree with him about the importance of free speech and the role that that journalists have to play. It's completely unacceptable that anyone in this country should be intimidated by any foreign power, and this government will always stand against that activity.

03:07:13 - 03:07:46

Speaker 92

Lorna McAvoy. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And I'd like to put on record my personal thanks to the minister for the support that he's given many members of this house, including myself, as newly elected members. And welcome a newly elected female member to the house today. Would the minister elaborate a little bit on the defending democracy task force and any focus that the or any time that was spent looking into the algorithms that reward rage baiting and extremist opinions?

Because I feel that it is degrading our public debate outside this place and inside it.

03:07:46 - 03:07:48

Speaker 86

Thank much, doctor. Minister.

03:07:48 - 03:09:02

Speaker 4

I'm very grateful to her. She's she's a great constituency MP, and it's profoundly concerning to me, and I'm sure to other members who've been in this place for a number of years now, to hear about some of the threats, the harassment, the intimidation that newer members have had to face in recent time. It's completely unacceptable, and I pay tribute to their resilience in terms of standing against it. But we want to work very closely with them to make sure that they feel properly supported in that. She's right to raise concerns about algorithms.

I can give her an assurance that that is a subject that has been, discussed on a number of occasions within the defending democracy task force. I know that she will understand that DCIP are the lead department for that activity, But I heard someone make the comparison the other day that in days gone by, people would go into a library, and they would choose the book that they want to read. Now online, often people's content is being directed by forces way beyond their control. I think we should all be very concerned about that. Certainly, I am, and it's a matter that I work very closely with colleagues.

Do you sit on?

03:09:02 - 03:09:03

Speaker 89

Greg Smith.

03:09:03 - 03:10:08

Speaker 79

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I welcome, the minister's statement this afternoon and in kindly concur with the domestic elements of protecting our democracy he announced. If I can return to the issue of foreign influence, of course, those countries that seek our democracy harm do not recognize the value of democracy themselves. My right humble friend has mentioned China. We have debated at length in this house.

Russia and the minister was in his place yesterday when I questioned the home secretary on the influence of Iran in this country with a lot of fears and reporting of shell companies being used, proxies being used to operate, within our own shores, including the IRGC themselves. Given the heightened tensions in The Middle East at the moment focused around that Iranian regime, can I ask the minister to ensure that all loopholes are being closed down to stop the influence of that Iranian regime where no matter what different views are on the war, I think the whole house can condemn the Iranian regime itself to ensure they are not able to influence our democracy?

03:10:08 - 03:10:09

Speaker 89

Miss Jarvis?

03:10:10 - 03:11:11

Speaker 4

Madam deputy speaker, I think the royal member makes some really good and important points. And it also provides me with an opportunity to pay tribute to the extraordinary work conducted by our intelligence services and by counterterrorism police. By very nature of the work that they do, it's almost always in the shadows. And often, they don't get the praise that I think that they deserve. There are some extraordinary people quite literally working around the clock to keep our country safe, and we owe them a debt of gratitude.

He's right to raise concerns about the current situation in The Middle East, and he's right to ask questions about what the government's response is to it. I know that there is often a temptation to reach for the prescription tool, and sometimes that is the right response. We talk a lot in government about toolkits. There is quite a lot in our tool kit, and I give him and the house an assurance that I will use everything that is in the toolkit to stand against the threats that we face.

03:11:11 - 03:11:12

Speaker 89

Luke Meyer.

03:11:12 - 03:11:56

Speaker 74

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. We've heard today, from members across the house about two twin evils that are driving online abuse. One being the algorithms of social media giants which are promoting content which makes people feel angry and makes people feel afraid. And the other is the influence of hostile states who deliberately sow disinformation designed to undermine our democracies. I've heard the minister say that this is Desit's role primarily to deal with, but please will he ensure that ministers keep all of us updated on the work that is going on to address this?

Because unless we all work together across parties and across departments, then this issue will continue to proliferate, and there will not be a democracy for us to defend.

03:11:56 - 03:11:57

Speaker 89

Mister Jarvis.

03:11:57 - 03:12:22

Speaker 4

Well, madam deputy speaker, my honorable friend is absolutely right to raise the point in the way that he does. And whilst, of course, there is an important role for DSIT, I can give him an assurance that lots of other government departments are actively involved in that work as well, including the foreign office, the home office, the cabinet office, and other government departments. He's right to raise concerns, but I give him an assurance that we're doing everything that we possibly can to stand against those particular threats.

03:12:22 - 03:12:24

Speaker 89

Ben Maguire.

03:12:24 - 03:12:56

Speaker 93

Thank you. I'm the deputy speaker. Can I just thank the minister for his statement? And it stood in very stark contrast to the statement from the opposition, was chilling. I thank the minister for the statement.

Many members have already referenced the horrific online abuse which we see on a daily basis and that online abuse often originates as has been said already from foreign states. What steps is the minister and the task force taking to protect our democracy from foreign interference, is often subversive, especially following the recent arrests on allegations of spying for China?

03:12:56 - 03:12:57

Speaker 89

Mister Jarvis?

03:12:57 - 03:13:46

Speaker 4

Well, I'm grateful to him for the approach that he's taken. I can give him an assurance that through the defending democracy task force and working with the intelligence services and with counterterrorism police and law enforcement more generally, we're doing everything that we possibly can to stand against the nature of the threats that we, that he described. The world is a dangerous, challenging place at the moment, and there are a range of different state actors who will take every opportunity to sow mis and disinformation and undermine the basis of our democracy. That is a very important role for government to stand against all of that. But I also think there's a really important role for this house, and that is why I've approached this statement in the way that I have.

I want to work with members right across the political divide, and I'm grateful to him for the support of that approach.

03:13:46 - 03:13:47

Speaker 89

Chris Webb.

03:13:47 - 03:14:33

Speaker 87

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Can I first just put on the record my sincere thanks to the minister for reaching out after the incident that occurred in Blackpool, with me a few weeks ago? Unfortunately, since becoming a member of this house, I've received a barrage of constant threats and death threats from the far right in my constituency, and that seems to be growing, which is a real concern. So I know from my discussions with the minister how seriously he takes the security of members of this house and also those councillors that serve in our town halls. So can you outline to the house how we can support him in defending our democracy in the right way, which unfortunately is in stark contrast to what we heard from the party opposite in their statement today.

03:14:33 - 03:14:34

Speaker 89

Mister Jarvis.

03:14:34 - 03:15:26

Speaker 4

Madam deputy speaker, I'm very grateful to him. He knows I was very concerned to hear about the incident, that happened recently. I can say to him and to the house that under those very difficult circumstances, he did exactly the right thing, But he was dealing with a situation that he should not have had to deal with, and that's why it's incredibly important that we make sure that our response is as organized and resourced as it needs to be. He specifically asked the question about what we can collectively do. What more can we do together as parliamentarians.

My response to that is to echo the remarks that I made earlier, which is to report it. I know that we're all busy people. Our staff are busy, but we mustn't let anything slide. We must take every opportunity, even if it falls below a legal threshold, to report matters to the police.

03:15:26 - 03:15:29

Speaker 25

So they can do you have an expense like the money?

03:15:29 - 03:15:29

Speaker 4

We can use.

03:15:29 - 03:16:10

Speaker 46

Constable. It's an honor to serve on the speaker's conference, and I've tried to, in all of the work that I've done around security, be a voice for the smaller parties and particularly for people that are further away from Parliament as well. One of the biggest strengths of the speakers' conference was the amount of listening it did to members and members' experiences. Appreciate the huge amount of work that's been done to improve the data gathering and the fact that we're much better at pulling together understanding on threats. But would the minister give us a reassurance that members' experiences will be listened to in addition to just looking at the data so that we can build on those strengths that we had during the speakers' conference?

Let

03:16:11 - 03:16:27

Speaker 4

me just quickly say that had a very constructive meeting with colleagues from the Scottish Government yesterday, and I appreciate their attendance at the meeting. She's absolutely right to raise concerns about experiences, and that is why I will always make myself available to speak to any member of this house about what's happened to them.

03:16:27 - 03:16:27

Speaker 86

Speaker Speaker

03:16:29 - 03:17:02

Speaker 82

of the intimidation candidates now face doesn't come on the doorstep but from anonymous or fake online accounts. Having experienced that myself, I welcome the work of this Government, the police, the Defending Democracy Task Force and the office of Mr and Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to ask the minister what action is being taken to stop online anonymity being used as a shield for harassment and intimidation in our democracy, and how will candidates in Portsmouth's May election receive receive advice, support, protection, and the enforcement they need to stand safety safely for public office. Right

03:17:02 - 03:17:25

Speaker 4

to raise the concerns in the way that she has. Hopefully, she will have heard my earlier remarks, which specifically respond to the point that she's made. We're working very closely with law enforcement, and there is work underway to work more closely with the the tech companies as well to make sure that we've got all of the right protections in place for the elections. But if there's more she thinks that we should be doing, be very grateful to discuss it with her.

03:17:25 - 03:18:05

Speaker 81

Madam Dirbhut Shevarev, and I welcome the statement from the minister and everybody's commitment in the house to keep us all as safe as possible. The secretary of state just a few months ago called the case of foreign of Russian interference within reform party a stain on our democracy. And since then, of course, we've had members linked to Welsh Labour Party are being investigated for their connections with the Chinese state. With the same outcome reelection just a mere two months away, what assurances can the minister give me that this task force will help defend our elections in Wales from foreign influence and interference? Well done.

03:18:05 - 03:18:19

Speaker 4

And give her the assurance that she seeks, and I'm grateful to Welsh colleagues for their attendance at the defending democracy task force yesterday. She's right to raise the the threats and the challenges that we face. We are making sure that our response to them is proportionate.

03:18:19 - 03:18:20

Speaker 7

Richard Bay.

03:18:20 - 03:18:47

Speaker 30

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I'm pleased to hear about the minister's positive dialogue with Scottish ministers ahead of the vital elections in May. On the issue of the collective responsibility of political parties to fair and to safe debate, well, do you agree there should be no repeat of the racist advert published by reform last year attacking a Nash sawa for the heritage of his family, which was widely published and seen hundreds of thousands of times on social media. Yeah.

03:18:48 - 03:18:58

Speaker 4

Well, I I do agree with him, and I can tell him that myself or the director general of m I five and myself met with the chief executives of political parties just recently to just discuss these matters.

03:18:59 - 03:19:00

Speaker 86

Our speaker 10.

03:19:00 - 03:19:58

Speaker 32

Madam deputy speaker madam deputy speaker, in 2019, I was physically attacked or at least an attempt was made to physically attack me during, the twenty nineteen general election when a beer glass was thrown at my head. I recognize how intimidating that was, but that was nothing to the the experience of those who are commemorated on the walls of this house or indeed many of the women who sit in this chamber. Less than twelve hours ago, I'm very sorry to say the Conservative Party put out social media posts that place the prime minister's face on the body of a slug Shame. Or a worm Shame. Or a snake on a five pound note.

And several months ago, the Conservative Party in my area sorry. He put out a tweet about me that suggested that I somehow supported rape gangs because I couldn't support their reasoned amendment to the Children Well-being and Schools bill. Does the security minister consider those social media acts to be elevating our politics and conforming to the values that we're speaking about today?

03:19:58 - 03:20:12

Speaker 4

Well, I'm grateful to him, but concerned to hear about what happened to him back in 2019. I think he makes an important and reasonable case. I think the majority of members in this house will agree with him, and it's something that we need to keep a very close eye on.

03:20:12 - 03:20:46

Speaker 35

Samantha Niplett. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I welcome this statement and I'm particularly delighted to read where the law fails to provide adequate protection, we will strengthen it. As someone who wrote a case thrown out by the c p s of being an MP, should just have thicker skin. That is welcome news.

I have thick skin. But does he share my concerns that we have members of this House who are benefiting from engagement with platforms such as X and taking a significant income and then benefiting from angry engagement? It's going directly to their pockets.

03:20:48 - 03:21:06

Speaker 4

Madam deputy speaker, I'm very sorry to hear about what happened to the honorable lady. She's right to reference the work that we're doing. We are changing the law to strengthen it in order to provide additional protections for members and for elected representatives. I think she makes a good point and a good challenge, and I know it will have been heard and agreed with around the house.

03:21:07 - 03:21:08

Speaker 89

Final question. Jim Shannon.

03:21:08 - 03:21:59

Speaker 9

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Can I thank the minister very much for his statement and thank the speaker's conference as well for for bringing this forward? It's really important we do so. The minister, the operation forward, that he referred that you referred to on page two, says that it will be England, Scotland, Wales. Can I just ask clarification why Northern Ireland?

Or maybe there's something else in in place, but just to check. Can I also make a comment? Often members and, indeed, their staff and teams are required during election campaigns. They undertake extensive public facing activities including constituency events, door to door counselling and campaigning, which can expose them to additional harassment or intimidation. What assessment has been made on the adequacy of security arrangements and guidance to members and their staff during election periods, and what role the task force is playing in coordinating measures to mitigate these risks?

Thanks so much.

03:21:59 - 03:22:25

Speaker 4

Thanks, Carl. Madam deputy speaker, I'm grateful to him as I always am and also grateful to the first minister and the deputy first minister, from the Northern Ireland Assembly for their attendance at the task force yesterday. The devolved arrangements are slightly different in Northern Ireland with regard to operation Ford, But I gave an assurance to the meeting yesterday that where there are areas where we can provide additional support to Northern Ireland, then, of course, we'd be happy to do so.

03:22:25 - 03:22:27

Speaker 16

Yes, the general government.

03:22:27 - 03:22:55

Speaker 89

That is the end of the statement on defending democracy task force. I'll give the front benches a moment or two to shuffle as we start the business of the day. Are ready. We now come to the general debate on International Women's Day, and I call the minister to move, minister Sima Kennedy.

03:22:58 - 03:25:15

Speaker 94

Madam deputy speaker, I beg to move that this house has considered the matter of International Women's Day twenty twenty six. It is an honour to open this International Women's Day debate held for the first time since 2020 in government time. International Women's Day was forged in the Labour strikes of the early twentieth century as women came together to call for better pay, shorter working hours, and voting rights. It has become an important milestone which celebrates the achievements of women, promotes gender equality, and acts as a call to action. In this debate, I've no doubt we will hear about pioneering pathfinders, including women who smashed the glass ceiling in parliament too and paved the way for us today.

Constance Markovich, the first woman elected. Nancy Astor, the first to take her seat Margaret Bonfield, the first woman cabinet minister and I recommend the new biography by Nan Sloane, a driving force behind the Labour Women's Network. Honourable members will mention the first woman prime minister in 1979. Labour has seen the first female chief whip, the first female chancellor, first black woman MP, the inspirational right honourable member for Hackney North and Stoke Newington. We have also seen Barbara Castle, Ellen Wilkinson, Jenny Lee and Baroness Harmon in the other place.

Not to forget yourself, the first non white deputy speaker and the first female Muslim minister. I also have many greats and firsts sitting behind me, including honourable member for Brent East, the first female black minister and the first black woman to speak from this despatch box. I am also proud that many are also Fabian women, and proud that this year we mark twenty one years of the Fabian Women's Network. I will give way.

03:25:16 - 03:25:55

Speaker 9

Talking of strong women, my mum, my wife, my three daughters in law, and my three grandchildren, three big girls at a very young age, but I tell you what, they have the potential to be leaders as well. And they're fierce women, they're strong, and I'm very, very pleased to see that. But does the minister please ever mindful on that they were celebrating Women's Day across Northern Ireland and the minister will know this. Another lady was killed last week, and that shows the highest number of women have been murdered in Northern Ireland and whole of The United Kingdom. Does she share my concern whether we celebrate women, we also have to protect women, and our society must do that?

Thank you so much. I

03:25:57 - 03:28:07

Speaker 94

thank the honourable gentleman for his comments, and indeed I wish all the women in his family a very happy International Women's Day. And every girl is a leader. Let that message ring out from this house. And he is absolutely right that we almost also must look at where women come under threats through whether that's online or through violence, and we must make sure we do everything to protect women and girls across The UK and across the world. Madam deputy speaker, we speak today about the agenda of women's progress, but we must remind ourselves that whilst we have made progress, men and women are still not equal, not equal at home and not equal abroad.

And indeed, that we face a new challenge, a misogynistic insurgency that is determined to roll back women's rights. And when we look at the level of online abuse, sexual harassment and intimidation, it is horrifying to see us in a situation with products that appear designed to make money out of the sexual harassment of women. So today, I want to make three main arguments that women are still not equal, that we must be uncompromising in resisting the backlash on women's rights, and that in these fragmented times women must work with women around the world. In a world where inequality persists in society, in the economy and in power, I am proud that Labour, led by a cabinet that is 46% women, is putting progress at the of women at the heart of its missions. That isn't a coincidence.

Women's representation in politics drives new conversation and puts wider issues on the agenda. Of the 695 women ever elected to the House of Commons, 405 or 58% were first elected as Labour MPs, and a 182 or 26% as Conservative MPs. I

03:28:07 - 03:28:45

Speaker 81

I thank the honourable member for giving way. I'm proud to have joined this parliament in 2024 as part of a record number of women elected for Plaid Cymru and of the record 40% of women being elected in that same year. We're clearly on our way for gender equal parliament. So with this historic milestone within sight, would the minister commit a government to a centenary actions call to enact section one zero six of the equality act, which would require political parties to publish diversity data on candidates to increase transparency?

03:28:47 - 03:31:21

Speaker 94

I thank the honourable lady for her question, and indeed that I think comments about our 40% of women in the House of Commons today is an important milestone, but we know we're not yet at 50%. And I'm proud that the Labour Party has got close to that, and in fact, pretty much reached that level. And it is important that we continue to look to the centenary as she describes, and look at a range of measures that we can see to make sure that we push forward the progress of women's representation the role of political parties in that, but also that we look forward to the progress of women in every part of society and every part of our economy. I do want to also recognise, madam deputy speaker, about the choices we make because Labour's manifesto committed to action to tackle gender inequality, from strengthening rights for women in work and reducing the gender pay gap to halving violence against women and girls. Our groundbreaking violence against women and girls strategy begins a decade long whole of government, whole of society effort to halve violence against women and girls and is backed by over £1,000,000,000 worth of funding.

That is a goal I know that every member of this house will be wanting to get behind. I also want to acknowledge the incredible efforts of my friend and colleague, the minister for safeguarding, who I am proud to stand alongside in today's debate. We are not just acting at home. We have made tackling violence against women and girls a priority in our foreign policy too. Recently, the foreign secretary launched All In, a new international coalition to scale up action to end violence against women and girls.

It brings together global leaders, experts and campaigners, and focuses on preventing violence before it happens. Labor is working to prioritise women's health, with a refreshed women's health strategy to be published soon. Our plans to make work pay are putting in stronger protections for pregnant women and new mothers at work, and tackling maternity inequality. We're reviewing parental leave and making flexible working more easily available. With two consecutive years of minimum wage rises, more money in the pockets of working women.

03:31:21 - 03:31:23

Speaker 2

Will the honorable lady give way on that point?

03:31:23 - 03:31:24

Speaker 94

I will give way very briefly.

03:31:24 - 03:31:42

Speaker 92

I thank the honorable lady for giving way, she's giving a brilliant speech that lots of us will be feeling very emotional about. Would the honorable lady agree with me and members across the house that whilst increasing the minimum wage is really important, disproportionately does affect female workers, we need to restructure how we value women's work as well and the workforce that

03:31:42 - 03:31:44

Speaker 3

is predominantly made up for women. I

03:31:45 - 03:33:50

Speaker 94

thank my honorable friend for her comments, and indeed that is a debate that continues to be ongoing and indeed will be relevant issues to that that I will touch on in my remarks. Madam deputy speaker, last week, I I was also proud to launch our voluntary action plans alongside the Secretary of State for Women and Equalities. Employers with 250 over 250 employees will be asked to submit action plans as part of the Employment Rights Act, showing how they will reduce their gender pay gaps and support employees going through the menopause. We are working with business leaders, civil society, and trade unions because we cannot reach workplace equality without the support and the commitment of all. And removing the two child limit will also lift 450,000 children out of relative poverty in the final year of this parliament.

A poverty we know impacts women, who the women's budgets group describe as the shock absorbers of poverty. On business, madam deputy speaker, the chancellor has backed the Invest in Women's task force, launching a funding pool of over £600,000,000 to be invested in women led businesses, including a 130,000,000 from the British Business Bank. That is the largest fund of its kind globally, addressing the enormous access to finance barriers that exist for women. And alongside, this government is supporting more women in The UK's tech sector. Every year, the economy loses an estimated 2 to 3 and a half billion pounds because women leave the tech sector or change sector due to barriers that should not exist.

Men outnumber women four to one in computer science degrees, a subject I also studied, madam deputy speaker. Women are likely less likely to enter tech, stay in the sector, or rise to leadership. I wonder

03:33:53 - 03:34:10

Speaker 46

if she would be able to talk about not just the tech sector, but in my constituency there are a huge number of engineering jobs. There is such a glass ceiling when it comes to engineering that women rarely manage to make it above. It's a similar issue with race equality when it comes to the higher tiers of engineering.

03:34:15 - 03:36:22

Speaker 94

Never a truer word was spoken. What I will will say, madam deputy speaker, is that building on, the honorable lady's comment, it is worth the house knowing that at the current pace, it will take 283 for women to achieve equal representation in tech. That is why I am proud that the Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology has launched the Women in Tech Task Force Yeah. To champion diversity in The UK tech sector, with a pipeline strengthened by stronger engagement with tech in the classroom. There are spaces in which our economy is going to grow, and we need a plan for women to be part of it.

Because through history, madam deputy speaker, women have consistently been the backbone of our communities, giving their power, their time, their ideas, and more. And they have done this in our classrooms, our offices, our hospitals, our military, and in the home. History has taught us that despite giving so much, women don't always gain equally to men. Every day, women and girls across The UK challenge the stereotypes so often thrown upon them. But they are our scientists, our teachers, our business leaders, our astronauts, our athletes, and so much more.

There is nowhere that women and girls should not be able to reach. But while this government has women's equality firmly on the agenda, the battle is not yet won. Increasingly loud voices attempt to dismiss the necessary protections for an inclusive culture at work. Some argue that our existing equality framework has gone too far, that it hinders progress. Let us be clear, madam deputy speaker, these protections embody British values Yeah.

Yeah. That women should be treated equally with men or that you should be treated equally regardless of your race. That is a core British value.

03:36:22 - 03:36:23

Speaker 95

Yeah. Yeah.

03:36:23 - 03:41:32

Speaker 94

It was faultful. The Equality Act last September was described by a now reform MP as fueling a corrosive culture of grievance in a Westminster Hall debate, who then called for it to be abolished. But it is not a grievance to recognise that a woman made redundant for being pregnant or who leaves work because her employer doesn't make reasonable adjustments for the menopause leaves us poorer as individuals, as an economy, and as society. And this battle, these voices, they are taking up space online too. When we look at the level of online abuse and intimidation, we must tackle this misogynistic insurgency that threatens to roll back women's rights and is having a huge impact on the well-being and aspiration of women and girls across our country too.

Online abuse of women athletes is set to be discussed at the next women's sports task force meeting. And I'm proud that the offence of creating intimate images without consent was signed into force last month, and that our female secretary of state announced it will be made a priority offence under the online safety act, delivering the strongest protect protections for users from such content. But this only happens against a backdrop of changing, but this happens against a backdrop of changing social attitudes, which we are only just beginning to address. New research from Ipsos Murray and the Global Institute for Women's Leadership at King's Business School shows that thirty one percent of Gen Z men born between 1997 and 2012 agree that a wife should always obey her husband, and one third, 33%, say that a husband should have the final word on important decisions. According to a new global study of 23,000 people in 29 countries.

We are in a renewed battle of ideas and new conversations about progress and rights, with pressures and influence we also see through online social influences. It demands that we engage, and it is through conversation, legislation, education, and campaigning that this government is determined to keep us moving forward. But with the challenge to women's equality now being international, so must our response be. In the year 2000, we led the first UN Security Council resolution on women, peace and security. It was a simple but transformative idea that peace is more durable when women help shape it.

UN Women's Statistics show that when women meaningfully participate in peace processes, the resulting agreement is 64% less likely to fail and 35 per cent more likely to last at least fifteen years. Women and girls are disproportionately affected by conflict and are likely more likely to see their rights curtailed. Sixty percent of preventable maternity maternal deaths and fifty three percent of under fives deaths take place in settings of conflict and displacement. We continue to use our voice at the United Nations to push for women to be embedded in peace processes, resolutions and humanitarian responses. Indeed, this week, Baroness Smith of Malvern and The UK Special Envoy for Women and Girls, Harriet Harman, are leading our delegation at the Commission of the Status on the Status of Women in New York because this government stands in solidarity with women and girls, not just in The UK, but around the world.

To conclude, Pepty speaker, International Women's Day marks the beginning, not only of a month long celebration of women's history, but also, I hope, a year of progress and action. The theme for this year's International Women's Day is give to gain, the aim of which is to emphasise power of reciprocity and support, whether through advocacy, education, mentoring or time, to help create a more supportive and interconnected world. Building new networks in our communities to bring hope, leadership, and change, renewing our determination, connecting with our sisters at home and abroad will give us a renewed frontline to resist the rollback of our rights and push forward for the progress of women and girls for generations to come. But this month is more than about reflection. It is about maintaining momentum.

As Ruth Bader Ginsburg said, women belong in all places where decisions are being made. That isn't an observation. It's a directive. It is for us, madam deputy speaker, to hold the light up to highlight progress and to keep fighting for a better world for women and girls everywhere.

03:41:32 - 03:41:39

Speaker 89

The question is that this house is considered International Women's Day, I call the Shadow Minister Joy Morrissey.

03:41:41 - 03:42:37

Speaker 34

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. It is a privilege to be represented to be representing today, the International Women's Day debate and to follow the honorable lady. And it is wonderful to hear the honorable lady talk about her passion for fighting for inequality and for the rights, and to fight the gender pay gap as well. And I hope very soon to see you in shadow cabinet, to see the member in shadow cabinet. Yes.

Yeah. I mean, real cabinet. Yeah. Not not us. Yeah.

That would be terrible for you. You wouldn't like that. And I and that that topic is what unites us today in this chamber, that we may have differences of opinion on every topic and come at every ideological point of view, but we are united in our ability to exercise that right to debate and to stand up for women.

03:42:37 - 03:42:38

Speaker 8

Yep.

03:42:38 - 03:43:30

Speaker 34

And I am so grateful to be part of this country and to be able to have those rights that so many women no longer have across the world. And I'd like to pay tribute to madam deputy speaker for not only her career her amazing work here in the chamber of keeping us all under control, but but which is a full time job for anyone. But it is more I just wanted to highlight the incredible work that madam deputy speaker has done to champion Uighur women and girls. When everyone was turning their back on Uighur women and girls, you madam deputy speaker, you led the campaign. You tirelessly campaigned across the world to make sure Yep.

That their story was heard and that their voice was heard, and you worked cross party for that. So thank you from everyone across this house for your incredible work. Yeah. Can I just

03:43:30 - 03:43:43

Speaker 89

Plea please? I'm incredibly grateful, is why I was then sanctioned by the Chinese Communist Party. But there's a lot of very powerful women in this room that won't be deterred by any sanctions regardless. So please continue. Go, Morrison.

03:43:43 - 03:46:03

Speaker 34

I feel that if one has received sanctions, it is a badge of honor. And, firstly, to honor in the international scope of this debate, I would like to take this moment to think about the women of Afghanistan who have suffered under the Taliban. The life of all human beings is intrinsically valuable and should always be remembered. And Afghan women whose rights have been systematically dismantled, 100 decrees to restrict their freedom of movement, education, work, expression, visiting a doctor, financial freedom, and there is no protection against violence, beatings, and forced child marriage. May we remember them today and how quickly the rights we take for granted can disappear.

Both across this house and throughout our great country, women have shaped our community, strengthened our institutions throughout The United Kingdom and the Commonwealth, and led with courage, determination, and resilience. Women are leaders in business, in education, in science, in armed forces, in charities, and volunteer organizations, and, of course, here in parliament. Yeah. Yeah. We must also recognize the women who contributed who are often not recognized, the carers who support their families every day with no thanks and no recognition, the volunteers who hold our communities together, the mothers, the daughters, the sisters, the friends who provide strength and stability in the time we need it most.

I've often spoken in this house about the importance of service, service to our communities and service to our country. That spirit of sacrifice and service is embodied by countless women across The United Kingdom who quietly make an extraordinary difference in the lives of others. May we recognize their contributions today.

03:46:03 - 03:46:06

Speaker 89

Yeah. Yeah. Goodbye, honourable friend, to give way.

03:46:06 - 03:46:08

Speaker 34

I will. I I thank

03:46:08 - 03:46:32

Speaker 67

my honourable friend for giving way, and I just wondered if she would join me in thanking and celebrating the fantastic women in Bourgne Regis and Littlehampton who do exactly what she has just described in businesses, in our local democracy, in our third sector, and in shaping the futures of our girls in community groups and schools.

03:46:32 - 03:46:33

Speaker 89

Joy Mawlsey.

03:46:33 - 03:49:20

Speaker 34

Thank you. I wholeheartedly agree with the comments to praise the unpraised volunteers, the community organizers, those that make our our our towns and villages what they are today, and it is so important that we highlight their contributions today. And we in my constituency of Beckinsfield, Marlowe, and the South Bucks villages, I see inspiring and dedicated women every single day. Carers fighting for their disabled children, like Hazel, fighting for the Burnham Day Center to remain open, health care professionals at Wexham Park Hospital, entrepreneurs like Allie and Lizzie McIntosh, who are now global presenters for f one and leading the way in lifestyle influencing, and I wish I had their social media talents, and volunteers dedicating their time to strengthening our communities. Their contribution should should remind us that leadership is not confined to these corridors of power but exists in every town, village, and neighborhood across the nation.

Mhmm. And may I pay tribute to the Taaplo Burnham Hitcham Women's Institute for their tireless service to our community and their wonderful one hundred year celebration to their branch and the opening of their building one hundred years ago by Lady Asta. We owe a great debt to the woman who went before us and none more so than Nancy Asta. Nancy Asta was a pioneer for women in parliament, and with her early pioneering, it brought early exposure to the American accent in this place, and it has taken this place one hundred years to recover from that. And, madam deputy speaker, it will probably take another hundred years to recover from this.

Yes. Yes. But we live in hope. And she was a pioneer in other ways, madam deputy speaker, fighting for children and, more importantly, the vulnerable. She supported initiatives to protect children, including raising the age of consent, fought to tackle children living in appalling conditions, helping countless women and girls.

What we saw in Nancy Asta was a female leader prepared to confront the uncomfortable and endure the hostility many and many opposed her campaigns, but she carried on, even Churchill, but she carried on. She carried on, and it is wonderful to follow in her footsteps today. That leadership and determination to fight for the voiceless lives on in many outstanding women today.

03:49:20 - 03:49:22

Speaker 7

Will the woman lady give way?

03:49:22 - 03:49:22

Speaker 33

I will give way.

03:49:22 - 03:50:08

Speaker 7

On the point of raising Nancy Astor, there is a statue of Nancy Astor in Plymouth. In my constituency of Chichester, we have 11 statues that are available for people to view and none of them are of women. Does she think that it's so important that when we think about how we represent women through history they need to be represented not physically but also in statue form. Would she join my campaign to get a statue of an amazing suffragist, in Chichester, outside Chichester Cathedral, Margaret Ethel Turner, affectionately known as Madge Turner, who was our own suffragette in Chichester. This campaign has been launched by the Chichester Women's History Group.

Does she agree with me that it's a campaign we should all get behind?

03:50:09 - 03:50:19

Speaker 34

I absolutely do agree, and I support the member in pursuing this wonderful statue for MAG, and you have and I lend you my full support in

03:50:19 - 03:50:19

Speaker 62

that

03:50:19 - 03:53:02

Speaker 34

campaign. And it is fitting that on International Women's Day, the UN's theme is rights, justice, and action for all women and girls. Three important words that matter to women and girls, rights, justice, action. It is fitting because there are many areas where those rights and that justice and the call to action have been pursued by inspirational women in the face of hostility, not dissimilar to what Nancy Asda faced in her time, and many members across this house have faced similar challenges. And no matter what party we are from, I must respect, madam deputy speaker, the courage that many who have gone before me have have blazed the trail, for coming to this chamber, fighting for our rights, fighting for the right to be heard, and on their contributions and sacrifice we are allowed to to debate today.

And I'd like to start by mentioning a member in this house that has battled for safe spaces for women and sex based rights, and that is the foundation for which true protection for women and girls needs to start. And none have fought that battle with more energy, resilience, and determination than the honorable member for Canterbury, fighting tirelessly to protect children and women and girls. She deserves our thanks and our respect for all she has done. In the other place, my noble friend, Baroness Jenkins of Kennington and Baroness Davis of Davenport, led the way in protecting women and girls, again, facing much hostility, but never once deterred from doing what they believed to be right. A champion of women only spaces and defense of biological sex is and, of course, outside of this house is JK Rowling, a woman who has been nothing short of inspirational, facing down personal threats to her safety, determined to ensure the rights of women are heard, and the leader of the opposition who firmly took a stance to protect women and girls for years when very few joined her to stand up for those safe spaces.

It is for that reason that we must also be clear that we, as a society, have failed many young girls for far too long. I will.

03:53:03 - 03:53:21

Speaker 45

Thank the honorable lady for giving way, but I'd also like to make the point that there are many people with different views across this house, and many of which I agree with, and she makes a very good point in naming some of the individuals, but there are many, many other women that stand up for sex rights, and I'd like to say that on the floor of the house, and I thank her

03:53:21 - 03:53:23

Speaker 57

for her her words. Thank

03:53:24 - 03:53:32

Speaker 34

you for that. And there are many women from all different ideological perspectives who have contributed to this debate, and I want to thank them.

03:53:32 - 03:53:33

Speaker 57

Of course.

03:53:33 - 03:53:57

Speaker 91

Thank madam chair speaker. I thank the honorable member for giving way. And in her speech, we should also recognize that some people have also been transphobic. We must be very mindful that there are a lot of people who are trans, who feel very vulnerable at this time, and some have committed suicide. So in this debate, can we also hold them in our thoughts?

03:53:57 - 03:57:19

Speaker 34

And may I thank the member for that very nuanced response and and contribution, and may I thank her for being the first female of color at the dispatch box leading the way and also a chairman of a select committee and someone who all members of this house from every party respect and admire, and thank you for everything that you do. And as we try to protect young women and girls, no clearer or more scandalous a failure than the rape gangs scandal that we are now confronting. Here, I want to pay tribute to the honorable member for Rotherham and the honorable member for Keefley and Inkley, who have both raised this in parliament, along with Alex Stafford, is no longer in this place, and the honorable member for Ashfield, a cross party effort of raising this issue time and time again while very few other members of this house did so. May I commend them for being brave enough to do so. And and, yes, may I thank there are so many that I'm not able to thank today, but I want to recognize them as best that I can.

And Baroness Casey said, too many shield away from the issue of ethnicity in the rape gang scandal. These honorable members did not. That is real leadership from cross party members for protecting women and girls. This International Women's Day let us unite in clear determination that where Nancy Asta led in confronting injustice for the voiceless, parliamentarians of today will follow Yes. Speaking up for the rights of women to women only spaces, making sure that no matter the community or ethnicity or religion, we will never again let a scandal like the rape gangs go unchallenged.

And, madam deputy speaker, as someone who has fought for women and girls and abuse sexual abuse and child sexual exploitation, I think that this is something that we can every every member of this house can support and look at how we can protect women and girls no matter who they are, no matter where they are from, moving forward. And I I believe that that is something we can all agree on. And for International Women's Day to matter, it must be more than symbolic. It must combine celebration with action. It must be a further catalyst for rights, justice, and action for women and girls.

It must harden our resolve to ensure safety for all women and girls. It must set in clear focus our collective determination that this will be a country where women and girls from every race, religion, and creed are able to contribute their talents to our country with the certainty that we will keep them safe for rights, justice, and action. Our women and girls deserve nothing less. Thank you. Thank

03:57:20 - 04:04:16

Speaker 48

you, mister speaker, and and thank you to all the inspirational speeches we've heard so much. This year, International Women's Day feels particularly poignant to me for two reasons. The first is watching the women in Iran. And the reason why this has particularly affected me is because many of you, including you, madam deputy speaker, will remember the fight for six years to bring back my like she was nothing in all honesty and the worthlessness that was attached to her identity. And now watching women who are fighting just for education, just for the right to dress the way that they want, just for the right to live.

Bombing primary schools full of little girls is something that's really hard to fathom. And every morning, no matter what happens, we wake up feeling very lucky because we know we can walk to work, get on the tube, and we will be safe. And our thoughts today are with the people who are in Iran, especially the women who are fighting for justice. The second reason that International Women's Day this year particularly feels poignant to me is because of the case that I'm dealing with in Bright Horizons Nursery in my constituency, which some people in the chamber would have heard me speak about. Vincent Chand operated for seven years undetected, preying on little girls and babies and toddlers, inflicting pain on them, and conducting sexual abuse, something that he had already done in his previous workplace and was undetected, given a job in the place where parents entrusted people to look after their children when they went to work, and came back and found out.

And they only found out because he had been reported by a brave whistleblower for acts of cruelty towards children, for bullying, not for sexual abuse. And it's only when police decided to seize his devices, including nursery iPads. So he had filmed himself acting sexual acts of violence against little girls in the nursery itself, used it to airdrop the images to his own devices, and that's how he was found out. It makes you think about how much work we have to do to combat violence against girls and women and that the fight is not over. And I'm pleased to be here today surrounded by women who have been fighting that, and I hope people like Vincent Chant do get the absolute justice that they should get and do end up behind closed doors and behind bars as well.

And I just want to pay tribute to all the mothers two person rule per child in every room in nurseries. They are the ones who are now fighting for a flare system so that whistleblowing can be done properly and without fear, and that it's not nurseries marking their own homework. But every time I speak about this case, I also want to say that for all the cases that have happened of sexual abuse in nurseries and early years practitioners, there are a thousand and million other babysitters, staff members, and staff workers who look after our children day in day out and make sure they're loved and protected. So let's make sure we don't tar everyone with the same brush, but we do need to take it seriously and something does need to be done. But today I want to talk about my brave constituents, Shunja Paul, who is in the gallery today.

The focus of the UN this International Women's Day, as the opposition spokesperson said, is rights, justice, and action. And because across the world, and girls just have 64% of the rights of men. And that's why I want to concentrate on Shunju's case today. Some of you in the chamber would have heard me mention her before because after six years of fighting a legal battle against her former employer, a management consultancy firm, she won a landmark case against unfair dismissal at the Employment Appeal Tribunal in London. Her case sets legal precedent for endometriosis to be considered a disability under the Equality Act 2010.

Madam deputy speaker, I hope you'll indulge me a bit while I talk about Jean Dupol's case because I feel like everyone in the chamber, including everyone in the world, should be listening to what she had to go through. In 2018, Shondra was diagnosed with severe endometriosis where she had large fluid filled sits on both of her ovaries. This required an immediate operation. She returned to work a month later in severe pain, she told me. She was bleeding.

She could hardly walk because she had been pushing herself too much for promotion to senior manager. She told HR, she told them in explicit detail how much pain that she was in. After three months after her phased return to work ended, without any warning, Sunjoo was sacked. She was told to leave the building immediately. Do not contact all the colleagues that you had been working for for ten years now.

Just get out of the building, be quiet, and leave. She had worked there for ten years and she told me categorically that life, her entire life, was based around her work and making sure that she looked after people that she was serving at Accenture. She was sacked for not being ready for promotion within a required time frame. This is known as the up or out policy used by many corporates, where employees can be dismissed if their manager believes they cannot be promoted. The termination letter, which, by the way, she received minutes after the meeting that she had, did not state any actual reason for her dismissal.

It also didn't inform her about the right to appeal or refer to the policy that was being followed. Now if you'll excuse me for saying, as a Camden girl through and through who went to Camden School for Girls, she decided not to take this lying down. She took it to internal tribunal where the high court later found out that the panel had completely disregarded what she had written in her impact statement. When she took it to tribunal, it ruled that Shanju had not proved that her illness had an ongoing substantial effect on her daily life and stated that many women with endometriosis had mild or no symptoms at all. The tribunal rejected her claim for disability discrimination and lacked any understanding of the physical impact of her health condition on her own body.

She appealed this decision, and high court eventually ruled that she was unfairly dismissed

04:04:16 - 04:04:17

Speaker 70

from

04:04:17 - 04:06:37

Speaker 48

her job without her employer falling a fair capability procedure or providing any reasonable adjustments after she was disabled because of her health condition. I am so proud of Shonju for her tireless campaigning since her unfair dismissal in 2019, and employers now must follow this judgment on considering endometriosis as a disability and providing reasonable adjustments. More needs to be done to ensure that this does not happen to other women who are physically left disabled by this condition and other gynecological conditions. And I know my friend, the MP for Erithyn Thamesmeade has done some brilliant work in this area for years now, but we need a collective voice. We need everyone in the chamber to stand up and speak about this because it has been taboo for too long now.

And it is shocking if the minister is listening that not a single gynecological condition is introduced in the disability guidance of the Equality Act. This basic change could have saved Shonju her job. So much time, money, and anxiety that she spent six years fighting for this unfair dismissal, It could have made a huge difference for countless other women that we haven't heard about who are facing the same discrimination in the workplace across the country. One in ten women are suffering from endometriosis. Yeah.

Sixty nine percent sufferers say that they face discrimination at work. Cases like this are far too common, and it's left us with one in six women with endometriosis unemployed because of their condition. Women should not be forced to go to tribunal just to get the rights that they deserve, and that's why I believe women with endometriosis should be given specific workplace adjustments and the right to reasonable adjustments to their condition. And alongside that, endometriosis should be listed under reoccurring and fluctuating impairments in the guidance for the Equality Act so that employers actually understand their legal duty to provide reasonable adjustments to women who are suffering for this condition. And finally oh, yes.

I

04:06:37 - 04:06:44

Speaker 91

thank my honourable friend for giving away. You may be coming to this, but it is an incredible I'm sorry, madam deputy.

04:06:44 - 04:06:46

Speaker 46

I don't want to wish to correct any one

04:06:46 - 04:06:51

Speaker 89

of our fantastic female parliamentarians, but you means me. You means me. One more time. Go butler.

04:06:51 - 04:07:11

Speaker 91

Thank you. And you are amazing, madam deputy speaker. My honorable friend may be coming to this, but my friend Elaine Banton was the lawyer in this case, and I just wanted to also put that on record to your excellent remarks for your constituent.

04:07:11 - 04:07:13

Speaker 16

Well done, Tom. Thank you

04:07:13 - 04:08:38

Speaker 48

to my honorable friend, and Elaine Banton definitely deserves a mention in the workplace as well. There's a lot more I'd like to say about this case I think it's so important, but I'm very conscious that I want don't want to take up too much time because there's so many women who want to speak today in the debate. But I just want to mention that growing up, and I did grow up in a Muslim Asian household, but even then, I didn't hear anything about endometriosis. I never heard the word menopause growing up. If I was ever on my period, I was told to quickly move away and listen and change and make sure my brother didn't hear anything.

There is a point at which we need to change that. My mother was very forward in other ways, growing up in a Muslim household. On Friday nights, we always had dinner with our Jewish neighbors. She was very clear about the fact that in our house, could celebrate Christmas, Eid, Hanukkah, you could do whatever you wanted because we were citizens of the world. But if you ever mentioned your period, menopause, endometriosis, that was simply not allowed.

So for the sake of Shonju's case, but also for all the South Asian mothers who are listening out there, this is the time when we need to break the taboo. We need to stalk about conditions that affect women, particularly when it affects young girls as well, so they don't feel ashamed, and they don't feel like they have to hide it if they're affected by the conditions in the workplace.

04:08:38 - 04:09:18

Speaker 11

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. She's making an incredibly powerful point. But if we are going to really change things, we actually need fathers to speak to their daughters and I recall making a very deliberate point when my daughter started menstruating and standing in the supermarket trying to assess and understand what I was faced with with the wall of of things and people coming up to me and saying, do you want some help? And saying, no. I need to work my way through this.

And we need men to advocate and understand these things as well.

04:09:20 - 04:09:50

Speaker 48

Absolutely. Thank you very much for that point. I wholeheartedly agree with my honorable friend, who is a staunch feminist, and which is one of the reasons why he's in this debate speaking today. But I'll finish now by saying that the justice that was served to Shonju is not just a victory for herself. It's for the countless women across the country who fought so hard to get reasonable adjustments in the workplace.

And I hope the minister will consider this case and will legislational follow from the Labour government to ensure that women never have to face discrimination in the workplace again.

04:09:50 - 04:10:02

Speaker 89

Hear. Hear. Fantastic speeches to stop me interrupting them. You and your unless you're referring to the chair, should not be not be said at all. Now I'll come to the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Alex Brewer.

04:10:02 - 04:10:03

Speaker 17

Here. Here. Here.

04:10:03 - 04:17:34

Speaker 54

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. This year's theme, as we have heard, is give to gain, and that prompted me to think about feminism on a global scale and how interconnected we truly all are. Our globalized world is far from isolated borders bounded by iron isolated countries bounded by iron borders. We exist in physical space and online. Our geopolitical landscape is shifting constantly, and feminism must move with it.

The experiences of women are shaped by overlapping factors of race, class, disability, migration status, sexuality, faith, and geography. Feminism policy cannot be effective if it only reflects the lives of the most privileged. Some of the gravest injustices faced by women globally include physical violence, forced marriage, and economic exclusion, and these fall hardest on those at multiple intersections of disadvantage. Progress for women is never a zero sum game. When we lift up the most marginalized, we all rise, which is why give to gain is such an important theme and has made me reflect on how we as a country and as a society must give through overseas aid if we are to help build a more progressive, fair, and stable world.

So today, madam deputy speaker, I want to raise one of the most difficult and taboo subjects in the area of violence against women and girls, but it is one we must confront, that of female genital mutilation commonly known as FGM or cutting. This is a sensitive and distressing topic, but to break taboos, we must start to articulate the problem. Female genital mutilation comprises all procedures that involve partial or total removal of the external female genitalia or injury to the female genital organs for any nonmedical reasons. Reasons. It is steeped in misguided ideas of a woman's virtue, ideas which are pervasive and which manifest in all cultures in different ways, of which FGM is, I believe, one of the most insidious and violent.

In January, I traveled to The Gambia as part of a delegation with the parliamentary commonwealth association. FGM was made illegal in The Gambia in 2015, yet the practice continues. In fact, in order to avoid detection, cutting is now carried out on younger and younger girls and sometimes even on babies with devastating, sometimes fatal consequences. The practice has no health benefits and causes lifelong problems, including severe bleeding, incontinence, infections, long term pain, menstrual problems, complications in childbirth, and an increased risk of newborn deaths. Beyond this clear physical trauma, many women live with depression, flashbacks, and lifelong psychological scars.

It is a form of torture. FGM is a serious violation of human rights and bodily autonomy, not a cultural inevitability, and more than four million girls are at risk every single year. Yet in The Gambia, I also saw hope. I saw the profound impact of not for profit and grassroots organizations working creatively and sensitively within communities to remove economic and cultural barriers to change. Data gathering is difficult in a country with such severe levels of poverty, but initial estimates suggest the prevalence of FGM has fallen from around seventy six percent to around fifty one percent of girls.

NGOs and grassroots women's organizations are uniquely effective because they are trusted by families and embedded in communities. These organizations are part funded by British Overseas Aid, which this government is now reducing. Their funding runs out this year just as the message is starting to get through. Reduction to aid like this tears holes in the safety net for the world's most vulnerable communities and leaves young girls more exposed. The government's decision to reduce The United Kingdom's official development assistance from naught point 5% to naught point 3% of gross national income will have real world consequences.

It represents the lowest United Kingdom aid contribution as a share of gross national income since 1999 and diminishes our long standing reputation as a global leader in humanitarian assistance. On the women and equalities committee in our report on f g m, we were clear. The government must protect funding for programs that prevent f g m and set out its plans for future investment in this vital work. Instead, in its response, the government confirms that its flagship program to end FGM will finish in October 2026 and that there are no plans at all for what comes next. This is not just disappointing.

It is deeply irresponsible. When Britain invests in the freedom and well-being of girls globally, we gain a safer, fairer, and more stable world, which is why when the Liberal Democrats were in government, we secured a commitment of naught point 7% of gross national income for overseas aid. FGM is, of course, illegal here too, but in today's global society, British girls are being taken abroad to undergo cutting in areas with fewer protections. In the last decade, more than forty one thousand women and girls had FGM identified at an NHS appointment in this country. And yet in the five year period between 2019 and 2024, there was just one conviction under the Female Genital Mutilation Act.

Protection must not stop at the border. Intervention must happen before a child boards a plane and after she lands. Frontline NGOs in source countries are often best placed to prevent FGM before happens. The practice of FGM is rooted in gender inequality, control of girls' bodies, and forced silence. True solidarity means recognizing that their struggle is our struggle.

By supporting global efforts to end FGM through aid and diplomacy, The UK helps meet its international commitments and reduces the chance of FGM happening to people who live here. This government must not be complicit in removing the progress that is preventing such violence against girls no matter where they are born. Madam deputy speaker, understanding intersectionality is vital to feminism today, and I am calling on the government to recognize that in our interconnected world, solving violence crime against women and girls everywhere is everyone's responsibility.

04:17:34 - 04:17:37

Speaker 89

Here. Abinat Opongosara.

04:17:38 - 04:28:57

Speaker 85

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. It's a privilege to speak in international women's debate. We reflect the women who have created International Women's Day and the women who have marked every day since. Women across the world of politics, trade unionism, business, science and arts making strides forward in the face of ignorance and misogyny. Women taking a sledge hammer to the glass ceiling, smashing through the barriers and making space for those who have followed.

I reflect on the women who have lift the pathway to my own place in parliament. The right honorable member for Hackney North and Stoke Newan, the mother of the house, is an inspiration to so many of us. I'm also thinking of Baroness Harmon and Baroness Amos in the other place. And of course, you, madam deputy speaker. And of course, on the front bench, my honourable friends the Equalities Minister and the Minister for Safeguarding and Violence Against Women and Girls you have such a long title.

And all the women I've met through my years leading the Labour Women's Network. These are the giants on the shoulders we stand. They lift us up and in turn we must lift others in Parliament and in our communities. Globally too we have heard in this debate about the status of women globally. Across the globe women are denied basic rights to school, have a job, be paid equally, enjoy equal legal rights and exercise basic freedoms.

For example, Afghanistan 2,200,000 girls are banned from secondary school by the Taliban. Only a quarter have jobs. In particular, cruelty of Afghan women are barred from entering the medical professions but the Taliban ban women being treated by men so women are denied the basic right of basic medical care. In Iran in Iran women hold only 64% of legal rights enjoyed by men. In Iran, women are required permissions from husbands to get a passport or travel abroad.

Girls as young as 13 can be married if a male judge decrees it. There are no criminal offences of rape within marriage or violence in the home. It is women who are leading the resistance to the Ayatollahs in Iran risking everything from justice and liberation and we should take inspiration for women standing up for their rights around the world and here at home. So I'm proud that we've passed the Employment Rights Act because it's women who will benefit the most especially low paid women, women of colour and working class women. Workers will have a right to guaranteed hours for the first time which means clarity on how much you will be earning and the stability to plan childcare and family expenditure.

This will be life changing for millions of families. None of these steps forwards come from a clear blue sky. They come from decades of struggle and argument, reversals and defeats and step forwards and progress. They come because of the suffragettes campaigning for political rights and the likes of Barbara Castle campaigning for economic rights. So yes we've seen the progress in social, political and economic fronts but equality is still a distant dream.

As the minister said take pay according to the office for national statistics median weekly earnings for female employees working full time was £710 at April 2025 compared with £815 for male full time employees. Equal pay remains some way off. And then also take healthcare, the harsh truth is that women continue to get a raw deal in the health care system. We do not enjoy true equality within the NHS. We have a system shaped and largely run by men with women's health as secondary concern.

There is still a male by default culture within the healthcare and I've been campaigning for faster treatment for endometriosis and fibroids where one in ten women suffer from these painful and incurable conditions. Yet on average the length of time women are waiting for diagnosis has gone up to nearly ten years. It has gone from an average of eight years to nine years and four months and if you're a woman of colour that is literally a double whammy of racism and sexism where it's gone up by eleven years. So women are waiting in pain for years. Their concerns are dismissed and their pains are ignored.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, if one in ten men suffered a painful incurable disease no offence there will be faster treatments and research into cures, times off work and systematic and sympathetic hearing from society. So as it is, women face ignorance, discrimination and stigma when they present crippling, blinding pain and heavy bleeding. So on International Women's Day and this debate I want to pay tribute to George E Wilman for creating her brilliant film This is Endometriosis. I was delighted to see it win best short film at the Bath urst this year. It is a truly well deserved recognition.

I would also like to commend the work of the Chair of the Women and Equalities Committee and the Chair of the APPG for Angiometriosis and of course my honourable friend for Hamp Stead and Highgate who has been supporting her constituent who was dismissed for working in her organisation for after ten years because of her condition with endometriosis. Sandra or Paul, you are inspiration to us all here and thank you for the work you have done with your MP in making sure this hits us nationally. I have argued that the solutions must include enhanced training for GPs to speed up diagnosis and improving the education of young people and women on menstrual cycle. I am looking forward to the new women's health strategy and I hope it places women front and centre in the strive for equality for women within the NHS. I already welcome the shift to use greater use of technology towards local diagnosis hubs and to greater awareness about women's health conditions.

But of course we have far further too much. I take enormous inspiration from women and girls I meet in my constituency who are fearless and driven and dedicated women who want to live out their potentials. I want to take an opportunity to name a few. Chimaymaker Meeninki, apologies if I pronounced it wrong, she is a dedicated wife, mother and community champion in Thamesmead who supports others through healthy cooking workshops. Jatung Dah Rai who is the CEO of BEXI Voluntary Service Council who supports charities and communities and local people in my constituency and beyond.

Chantelle Morris, who I met in one of my constituency surgeries, who shared her experience of homelessness and spoke about her aim to provide support to local people and families facing eviction living in temporary accommodation. So I was delighted to see her organisation hit the ground and I was delighted to attend her launch of the Morris Mission in Erith last October, where she now provides training to support local people. Jo Dunkley at the Off Ropes who has done incredible work bringing the brilliant charity to life through her passion of boxing shared by so many. They support local adults facing mental health challenges to build confidence, resilience and lasting connections through sport. So I was delighted to cut the ribbon at their new gym in Abbey Woods last November and since then it has gone from strength to strength and a huge credit to Joe for making this happen.

I also like to pay tribute to the staff at the community hospice where I'm patron. In particular Anita Saunders who's stepping into the CEO role from the Director of Income Generation and Doctor Lesley Ball the Medical Director who is also helping to steady the team through their leadership transition. And finally, although I've mentioned her in previous speeches on International Women's Day, I wanted to mention once again the brilliant Kate Heaps. Kate has been the Chief Executive of Community Hospice after nearly two decades with her team. She has grown the hospice work and fought hard to improve hospice care locally and nationally and I want to pay tribute to her and wish her the best steps, best luck in her next steps.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this is International Women's Day debate and I want to highlight that I'm proud of what this Government has achieved so far towards a fairer, more equal society and economy. I'm lifted up by my sisters in Parliament and the amazing women that I meet here on a day to day basis in politics and around this place. So even in the darkest times and amidst times of uncertainty we support each other and we uphold our convictions and our passion and uplift each other in representing our constituents and beyond and fighting on campaigning issues which are important to our constituents.

04:28:57 - 04:29:00

Speaker 95

Wendy Chamberlain.

04:29:01 - 04:35:59

Speaker 70

Madam Deputy Speaker. On this International Women's Day I rise to say a few words about the women and girls of Afghanistan, as I am the chair of the APPG for Afghan Women and Girls. I reflect some of the comments that honorable member for Erith and Thamesmeads just made in relation to their experiences. I saw comments in the telegraph at the weekend that stated the fact that International Women's Day is marked in Afghanistan shows that the day is meaningless, and I would beg to differ with that assessment, particularly given the number of us that are here on a Thursday afternoon. But, factually, it's not listed as a holiday in Afghanistan, and we're not seeing celebrations or protests, debates, or marketing based on the day itself there, simply because that is not possible for women and girls in Afghanistan.

Afghanistan remains a member of the UN, which marks the day, but you don't need to formally indict banning something to effectively do so, not when women cannot gather and they cannot speak, not even in their own homes if they can be heard outside of them. But nonetheless, there is a value to International Women's Day, madam deputy speaker, and I believe even in the darkest of circumstances, is still value in this day to the women of Afghanistan. As we are hearing in this debate, International Women's Day is about so many struggles, but also about celebrations. The women of Afghanistan's struggles and the celebration of their resilience has equal value today. When they cannot speak for themselves, those of us with voices internationally can do so, and, indeed, elevating the voices of Afghan women is what the APPG is set up to do.

But there is no sugar coating it, madam deputy speaker. It is bleak in Afghanistan. A new penal code was introduced in January that has effectively legalized domestic violence, including sexual assault within marriages there. Husbands are explicitly authorized to discipline their wives for non specified transgressions. And the only crime in the books is for a husband who beats his wife with a stick in such a way that it causes severe injury, such as a broken bone.

The burden of proof for this offence lies on the woman, and the punishment, if proven, is just fifteen days in prison. Injuring animals in Afghanistan carries a greater penalty. I doubt if we will ever see a prosecution under this law, given that gathering the proof required would involve the husband who has committed the assault chaperoning his wife to hospital to get the evidential x-ray required. On the other hand, if a woman tries to leave a marriage by visiting her father or relative, and does so without her husband's consent or refuses to return, you can imagine circumstances where somebody would look to do that in order to escape domestic violence in their house, then that woman can go to prison for three months. If a woman is found to have abandoned Islamand I believe here we are talking about the Taliban's interpretation of the faith, which many disagree withthen she can be jailed indefinitely with ten lashes daily until she chooses to return to the religion.

There are severe restrictions on working, which the Honourable member for Erith And Tenthmeet referred to. Some organisations in some areas have negotiated the right for women to keep their jobs. Women still can provide health care, though increasingly women are being denied the right to be trained in health care, which means that you can very easily see what that means for the future of maternal and female care in Afghanistan. But we are certainly a long way away from there being a freedom to work, and financial autonomy is simply not a reality. And the future for the next generation is even bleaker.

For girls now growing up without completing their education, and without women being able to have medical training, there will be a point where there are no women left to provide that health care. And the reality is that in a country at war, at the forefront of the climate crisis, where seventeen million people face acute hunger this winter, and with millions of displaced people returning its neighbours, including Iran, it is women who are bearing the brunt of the desolation. And I'm aware that in setting out this reality, I'm not elevating the experiences or feelings or voices of any one woman. There are 25,000,000 women in Afghanistan, and each and every one of them should have the right to speak, to live freely, and indeed to live at all. And prior to 2021, they were able to do so.

So on this International Women's Day, would like to see commitments from the government to the women and girls of Afghanistan. I put on the record that I do not agree with the government's decision to close the door on safe and legal routes to refuge or to study or work. I was told on Monday here in the chamber by the minister responding to the statement on the government's response to immigration that it was about ensuring that universities were not making the decisions in relation to who got to stay here. If there are no other ways for people to come and seek safe refuge, it is not surprising that people take that opportunity. If they no longer have that opportunity, it will not be surprising if they revert to circumstances such as irregular routes, and by that I mean the small boats that we all say we want to prevent.

But having made those decisions, I call on the government to do more in Afghanistan, much more. The minister at the outset in her remarks talked about the work this government does overseas, but I do beg to differ in that assessment. Afghanistan is not one of the ring fenced countries that the Government has featured as it looks to cut order spending, but Afghanistan is apparently a priority. I'd really like to understand what that means and what that looks like. I think it's important that we also recognise the strength of Afghan women.

The APPG has had the privilege of hearing from several Afghan women in the last year, as well as NGOs and academics who have spent time on the ground. We've heard a lot, unsurprisingly, about the loss of hope. We've also heard about resilience, the unbelievable resilience. Afghan women live in unthinkable circumstances for any of us here, but they keep on. Whilst this is a speech setting out terrible things, I'm not asking you to pity the women and girls in Afghanistan.

In talking about them, I'm asking you to take action. And I know Madam Deputy Speaker, you were previously a member of the APPG in the last Parliament and how supportive you were and continue to be. But to end, I want to share the remarks that the APPG heard last year from a female medical practitioner on the ground who told us that she was speaking to us as parliamentarians as a witness to the quiet suffering and untold strength of Afghan women. These stories are not just tragic, they are powerful, and they must inform policy decisions and humanitarian priorities moving forward. I urge the government to heed those words.

04:36:02 - 04:42:53

Speaker 35

You. Madam deputy speaker, it's my absolute pleasure to rise to speak in this year's debate to mark International Women's Day. The important day that it is does give us an opportunity not only to reflect on half how far women have come, but disappointingly how far we have yet to go. But it also, allows us to recognise the women who continue to shape and strengthen our communities every single day. And I want to use my time today to celebrate some of the remarkable women across South Derbyshire who are making a real difference.

It's my absolute favourite thing to do to make sure people feel seen in this place. Firstly, Kaleela's story. Kaleela is my right hand woman in the constituency. She runs my office and I honestly do not know what I would do without her. I'm sure many of us across this house will probably share the experience with with some incredible women in their teams.

Also, I'd like to give a shout out to Lib Orm, and correct a mistake I made in business questions this morning when I didn't give recognition to her as being the founder of I Love Swad, which is a Facebook page which has got almost 46 and a half thousand members. Incredible achievements. And also, Lesley Asby. Now I hope Lesley Asby feels seen by me for the woman she is, both in the constituency as her MP and in this place. She will know why I've mentioned her name.

In Melbourne, Sharon Brown is the driving force behind the wonderfully vibrant Melbourne Festival of Arts and Architecture, which last year celebrated its twentieth year. She also manages the Creative Melbourne Gallery. Through her work, she has brought art, culture, and creativity to the heart of her community, creating opportunities for artists and inspiring residents and visitors alike. Also using creativity as a force for good is Julie Batten. She's the director of People Express.

Julie has led the organization since 1992, and under her leadership, it has used the arts as a powerful tool for engagement, working with a diverse range of people across our community and a and enabling them to become the writers, filmmakers, and artists of their own stories. Her work help ensures the creativity is truly accessible to everyone. Supporting local enterprise is Keely Briggs, a marketing expert who provides networking opportunities for businesses across South Derbyshire, particularly in Swaddling Coat. She is a passionate champion of small businesses and organizes the annual Small Business Showcase, giving local entrepreneurs a platform to grow and succeed. Entrepreneurship is also embodied by Elaine Pennon, the founder of Lemon and Lime Interiors, whose business has grown into a highly successful company supporting homeowners and property professionals alike.

Supporting that growth with her is Katie Lavis, who started her own business and now works with Lemon and Lime as it continues to expand. Another fantastic local entrepreneur is Tracy Payne, whose work and dedication exemplify the determination and creativity of women running small businesses in our community. Public service is another area where women across South Derbyshire make an enormous contribution. And Angela Archer, chair of South Derbyshire District Council, is a passionate advocate for children with special educational needs and disabilities. As a parent of Sen Children herself, she co founded the charity SHOUT to support families navigating the challenges that SEND can bring.

There are also people like Keddie Bailey, who quietly supports families of SEND children, demonstrating the compassion and commitment that empowers families at times of significant challenge. In the voluntary sector, I want to recognise the work of Holly Benton, Chief Executive of South Derbyshire CVS, and Petra Parker, who manages their food hub. Together, they support local people to access food parcels, befriending services, help to return home after a hospital stay, and a wide range of support, ensuring that no one in our community feels alone when they need help the most. Ingrid Bandavide, editor of the local publication Swad Style, keeps residents informed about what is happening across Swaddlingcote and the surrounding area. She also leads the wonderful Swaddlingcote Festival of Words, taking play at place later this month, which celebrates literature, storytelling, and creativity for all ages.

Our cultural heritage is also being preserved, thanks to Becca King, the museum manager at Sharps Pottery Museum, who works tirelessly to ensure that our local history is accessible, engaging, and celebrated. I would also like to recognize Peggy Moore, whose dedication to remembrance in our community is truly extraordinary. Peggy has spent countless hours knitting poppies, creating a life size knitted Tommy Soldier and collecting donations for the Royal British Legion Poppy Appeal. Her dedication ensures that the sacrifices of those who served are never forgotten. I also want to recognize Maria Hanson, MBE, founder of charity Me and Dee.

Since founding the charity in 2006, Maria has dedicated herself to supporting families facing life changing and life limiting conditions. Her vision, compassion and determination have helped thousands of families across The UK, and this remarkable work has been recognised with the charity being awarded the King's Award for Voluntary Service. In my constituency, there are also women whose leadership continues to inspire long after they've left public office. One such person is Edwina Currie, the first female MP for South Derbyshire. To this day, residents still speak fondly of her to me as a dedicated constituency MP who worked tirelessly on their behalf.

I'd also like to give a special mention to Margaret Garner, an absolute gem in our community, Repton in particular. Margaret, now in her eighties, is an incredibly loyal and supportive friend, a volunteer for many activities in Repton, and swears like a trooper. She is the kind of person who lifts those around her, brings humor and honesty wherever she goes, and reminds us all of the strength and spirit that runs through so many women in our community. And of course, none of us would be here today without the women who came before us and fought to open the doors of democracy. One such woman from my constituency is Hannah Mitchell, a suffragette who lived in New Orleans in the early nineteen hundreds.

An activist, a rebel, and one of the many women who challenged inequality and fought for women's rights to take part in public life. Madam deputy speaker, the women I've mentioned today come from many different walks of life. From business, the arts, public service, charity work and community leadership. What unites them is their determination to make the places they live better for others. There are, of course, so many incredible women across South Derbyshire.

Giving a few shout outs today inevitably means I have missed someone, but I hope this speech goes some way towards recognising the extraordinary contribution of, that women make across our communities every single day. Thank you.

04:42:54 - 04:43:03

Speaker 1

Right. We know I've made the speech. Can I first of all say and remind everyone there is no interruptions during this maiden speech?

04:43:04 - 04:43:04

Speaker 10

Am I speaking

04:43:04 - 04:43:06

Speaker 16

to sir? Here.

04:43:07 - 04:43:08

Speaker 70

Thank you, mister

04:43:08 - 04:49:47

Speaker 96

speaker. Four weeks ago today, I was in college, a plumber learning how to plaster and today I'm in Parliament as an MP. Being here is the honour of my life, but I don't want this to be unusual or exceptional. I truly believe anyone doing a job like mine should get a seat on these benches. Where I'm from, we're taught to look after each other, to look out for each other, to stick up for each other and to stick together, to see each other as human.

I'm so proud of that humanity and that people in Gorton and Denton and Burnage and Levenshoom and Longsigh and Abbey Hay feel that way too. It's in our blood and in our bones We see each other as human. Where I'm from, we give a nod to the statue of Emmeline Pankhurst. We remember the farm worker and seamstress Hannah Mitchell, the trade unionist Mary Quail and the mill worker Annie Kelly and of course Elsie Plant, who's from just down the road from me and who I named one of my beautiful greyhounds after. I think of these brilliant women a lot and especially today as we debate International Women's Day.

I think of many others too, from pits, slums and factories. The women who changed the system so that I could be here. The women of colour whose names we will never know because history didn't bother to recognise or remember them, but we do today because without their struggle and their fight and their determination to stick together, none of this could be possible. And it's bittersweet to recognise these brilliant people but to be reminded that we still need to try and be them. The constituency that elected me is the fifteenth most deprived constituency in the country.

It has suffered decades of neglect and broken promises, And we see this every day right in front of us, the litter, the fly tipping, the state of housing, the struggle for a job that you can build a life on, the filthy, polluted air and the reduced life chances, the sheer unfairness of it all. My constituency has been hit hard by the ongoing cost of living crisis and now none of this is fair, none of this is right and none of it happens by accident. So I very much share my predecessor's strong commitment to tackling health inequalities and putting local people and all of our communities at the heart of decision making. That's how we begin to turn things around, to give people agency a genuine chance of a better today and a better tomorrow. And to the girls who I saw photos of, sorry, who went to school on International Women's Day dressed as Hannah the Plumber in their overalls, spanners and trademark hair.

To the 10 year old boy at Hideout who rock climbed an incredibly high wall with me and who saw me suddenly become very terrified of how far up I was and who said to me, don't ever give up and if it's scary looking down, then just look at what's in front of you. To the women in my life who've had my back, who fought for equality alongside me, and to the men that I work with, especially the lads on my plastering course who dealt with my newfound spotlight in the middle of our training very well. But those men who will suffer the effects of this unequal society through their mental health, To the veterans I know who were willing to risk everything and come home and find that society was turning its back on them. To the white working classes who are always lumped into one group and never appreciate it. To everyone who will have nowhere to sleep tonight or will barely exist in a cold, damp and insecure home.

To my trans siblings who get blamed for everything. To the Muslims everywhere who are constantly and often violently scapegoated. To the disabled people who can't access the world because of structural inequality that is completely fixable. To the people of colour who have to work harder at everything. I don't always get it, I won't say I always understand it, but what I do know is what it feels like to be looked down on, to be let down and left behind, to be less worthy because of something about me.

Our struggles may be different, but our humanity is the same. We always stick together, we always fight for each other, and that is what I want us to take forward from International Women's Day and to do that every day. The cleaners, the bus drivers, the nursery workers, the foster carers, the home carers, the unpaid carers, the teaching assistants, the bin collectors, the warehouse workers, the delivery drivers, the school dinner staff, the lollipop wardens, the supermarket workers, the posters, the library staff, the kitchen porters, the farm workers, the mechanics, the ground workers, the scaffolders, the electricians, the plasterers and the plumbers. We deserve to be here, every single one of us. I will make space for you to come and join me to get to have your say.

From the bustle of Longsight Market to the many Irish pubs in Levee, Sue's Chippy and Tony at California Wines and Gorton, the amazing young people at Hideout, the best hash brown butter at Cafe Plus in Denton and the women led social enterprise at Dalia Cafe on Burnage Lane. You are the best of our brilliant communities. I want to put Gorton and Denton on the map by championing the positives about our community. The spirit, the warmth, the grit and the way that we help each other out every single day. Whether that's our neighbours where we live or our siblings in places like Gaza, Sudan, Iran, wherever we are, we deserve to live freely as the human beings that we all are.

We do things differently in Manchester, and it makes me proud every single day. And now I want to make Abi Hay, Levenshoom, Bernard, Longsight, Gorton and Denton proud of me. Thank you so much for putting your faith in this plumber and newly qualified plasterer. Together we can make hope normal again and we will look after each other, whoever we are, because where I'm from, that is just what we do. Thank you.

Amen.

04:49:48 - 04:49:55

Speaker 1

Can can I just say that at least you can cross the football political divide by being a Bolton Wanderers supporter? Melanie Ward.

04:49:57 - 04:52:37

Speaker 70

Thank you, mister speaker, and let me start by congratulating the honorable member for Gorton and Denton on her first speech in this place. I welcome her to her place, and I don't know if she's noticed that the Palace Of Westminster is in need of some maintenance, so it is entirely possible that both her plastering and her plumbing skills will come in useful in the very near future. I rise to speak in my first international women's debate. I have followed this debate since before I was elected, so it is a true privilege to take part today. Forgive me, if the composition of this chamber, by which I mean the number of men and women relative to each other, was like this more often, I feel like we might have some different kinds of debates in this chamber.

Today, we celebrate women in our communities and across our country and our world. We celebrate extraordinary women who achieve incredible things for the good of humanity. In that context, it is a great but sad honour to sit opposite the coat of arms of my dear friend Jo Cox, with whom I served on the board of the Labour Women's Network, and think of her every time I come to this place and see her coat of arms. We miss her and her contributions dearly. I have previously mentioned Jenny Lee and my contributions, a proud Pfeiffer who grew up in Cowdenbeath in my constituency and served as a Labour MP for two different spells.

As well as having been the first ever UK minister for the arts and the creator of the open university, it is less known that Jenny served in the ministry of aircraft Production during World War II, keeping aircraft factories running during the Blitz. She was called to do so because of her no nonsense attitude and her ability to get things done. That is something that I take inspiration from. I am proud to follow Jenny as the five hundred and ninety fifth women, amongst many thousands of men, elected to this Parliament, together with an unprecedented number of women MPs. Our Labour Government has important plans to advance women's equality, from halving violence against women and girls to transforming women's experiences of maternity care, a subject about which I met the Baroness A Moss just this week, As well as the women who are recognised for extraordinary achievements, we must be clear that the unseen work that women across the world do every day does not receive the recognition that it deserves.

According to the UN, women and girls do sixteen billion hours of unpaid care work every single day. Their

04:52:37 - 04:52:37

Speaker 46

work is

04:52:37 - 05:00:28

Speaker 70

the very glue of families, communities and economies. Countries could not function without it, yet this work remains largely invisible, undervalued and unequally distributed. Today I want to sound a warning. We know that violent struggles are being fought for global power, but around the world and increasingly at home, the struggle for power is being expressed as a struggle for control over women and our bodies. My honourable friend, the member for Aylesbury, and I have written about this together this week.

There are many shocking examples of the battle to control women's bodies. In Iran, as my friend, the member for Erithyn Thamesmead, mentioned, the oppressive regime has been desperate to prevent women from dressing the way that they want to, despite the incredibly brave protestations of amazing women there in the wake of Massa Amini's death. In Afghanistan, as the honourable member for North East Fife spoke about so eloquently, the Taliban have tested the limits of whether the world would stop them from enforcing gender apartheid, forcing women out of schools and workplaces and into the home. They looked for and found the answer that they wantedthat indeed the world does not care enough to stop them. In Sudan, the world's worst humanitarian crisis, rape and sexual violence is routinely used as a weapon of war.

At the Munich Security Conference, which I attended recently, my honourable friend, the member for Pontefract, Castleford and Nottingley, spoke powerfully about her visit to Sudanese refugee camps and the horrific accounts she heard there, including the systematic rape of girls as young as eight. I am proud to be a former chair of the Circle, the global feminist organisation founded by Annie Lennox. Only this morning they shared data with me, that shows that sexual violence in conflicts worldwide has increased by 25 per cent in the last year. In conversations about a shifting global order, there is an increasing subtext of the need to control women's bodies. We see this in some of the attacks on the legitimacy and funding of the United Nations.

I have worked with the UN in my previous work, and make no mistake there were many reforms that it would benefit from. However, starving its institutions of funding to do work that no one else will do, for people that no one else will help, is a grave error. Work like providing contraception to women in war zones and refugee camps so that they have some basic control over their bodies in situations where they have control over almost nothing else. In the context of domestic cuts to our own aid budget, which is a source of concern to many of us, we must do everything possible to preserve support for women and girls. I know that the Foreign Secretary is doing important work on this.

But we mustn't content ourselves by believing that this misogyny only exists abroad. Matt Goodwin, the reform candidate in the Gorton And Denton By Election, said that women who don't have children should be taxed more and that young women need an education in fertility, as if the Handmaid's Tale was something that we should aspire to. He seems to believe that women who choose not to have children, or cannot, are somehow failing in their duties. Reform have said that, were they in government, the Equality Act, basis for much of the progress we have made on women's rights in The UK, would be repealed. Shame on them.

Online, British women are stripped of the agency we have over our own bodies, exemplified by Grock weaponising women's bodies through notification apps, which our Labour Government is right to crack down on. My honourable friend, the member for Lowestoft, had the truly awful experience of someone using this technology to make a fake video of her being chloroformed and prepared for rape. This makes the Opposition front bench comments in the previous statement all the more unacceptable. The intended humiliation of women online is not simply cruel or misogynistic, although it is certainly both. It is intended to instil fear and to signal that some violent men believe they are entitled to dominate women.

It is to try to normalise this abhorrent behaviour. Last week, ahead of International Women's Day, I met with the FIFE Violence Against Women Partnership. We discussed the more than 5,000 incidents of domestic abuse and over 1,100 crimes of indecency reported to the police in Fife last year, and we know that there will be many more unreported. They also shared with me their concerns about social media and the misogyny spread online by so called male influencers. I heard shocking reports about some of the things that local schoolboys have said to female teachers, comments that they have learned online.

These included female teachers being told by boys that they teach: You are so ugly, I wouldn't even rape you. Male influencers online also seek to spread the idea that the role of the trad wife is what girls and young women should aspire to in life. This is the idea that women belong only in the home and that we should all take our fulfilment simply from cooking meals for our husbands and rearing children. This online misogyny is spread by the likes of Andrew Tate and the late Charlie Kirk, and far too many others, and it is aided by harmful algorithms. Perhaps it should not surprise us that a new global survey has found that younger men increasingly believe that a wife should obey her husband and that men are expected to do too much to support equality.

This is not an accident. There is transnational organisation to make it happen. The European Parliamentary Forum for Sexual and Reproductive Rights found that $1,180,000,000 was pumped into European movements dedicated to rolling back women's rights between 2019 and 2023. This funding came from two seventy five different actors, including church run NGOs and far right populist parties. Russia was the biggest source of donations, and The United States the second biggest.

It came especially from American Christian nationalists. This American funding is now accompanied by financial help from the US Government, which has set aside $200,000,000 to support MAGA friendly think tanks in Europe. Let us be clear that this is designed to spread their ideology, including here in The UK. So when we, the decent majority, both in this House and outside of this House, confront the grassroots arms of the far right, local groups in our communities. Let us be clear that they are not just isolated local groupings of people they are the grassroots arm of a well organised international effort to reverse women's rights.

Our Government is doing a huge amount to drive forward women's equality on closing the pay gap, on childcare, on tackling violence against women and girls and so much more. I am proud of that work, but we face a dark threat to the fabric of our society from this organised misogyny that I have described. We must defeat it and we have much to do.

05:00:31 - 05:00:32

Speaker 74

Thank you

05:00:32 - 05:07:34

Speaker 59

madam deputy speaker. Can I start by paying huge tribute to the member for Gordon and Denton for her maiden speech? She spoke with grace, poise and purpose, I think that her constituents are very lucky to have them her representing them here, whether they voted for her or not. Members on these benches will know that I am not overly competitive. I just have to win everything.

And so I was rather devastated that the the new member made a far, far better maiden speech than my own meager offering after the general election in 2024. She said she wanted to put Gauntlett Denson on the map, and she certainly put it on my radar because I was wondering when she was listing the number of distinguished people from her constituency whether she would get around to mentioning Ethel Sunny Lowry, who was the first British woman. She was born in in in Gorton, and she was the first British woman to swim the English Channel in 1933. I know what honorable members are thinking. Surely, I have got some neat segue to other women with water based heroics from my own spelt on constituency.

And I wouldn't like to disappoint honorable members, because in 1903, at 111 White Hart Lane in Barnes, young Amy Gentry was born to a Cockney father who had worked his way up and become a publisher. And they bought a plot on an island called Hamhore Island. Now Hamhore Island is the southernmost point of the River Thames, and it is also the southernmost point of my Spelthorn constituency. You can get camping plots there. And she went there from the age of one, and her dad got a boat, and they used to love messing around in boats.

Before she was 10 years old, the people on Hamhore Island used to have these Jim Carnas. She was entered into a dinghy racing contest, which I think she won, so she clearly got a taste for competition. The war then intervened in her growing up, and obviously honorable members will be only too aware that in 1918 we passed in this place the representation of people, the People Act. The tide was turning in terms of votes for women, women's individuality, women expressing themselves. In 1920, Weybridge Rowing Club decided that they would form a women's section.

This was considerably revolutionary at the time. They formed a women's rowing section. They got a group of young ladies together, trained them in how to row properly, and had the whole women's rowing movement began. In 1925, young Amy Gentry went over to the charity regatta in in Belgium, oh, in The Netherlands, where she competed against France, Belgium, and Holland. And in 1927, the sport had developed that much further that the they had an eight competition on the Oxford and Cambridge course between Putney and Mortlake.

She wrote at the time that she felt like she was rowing backwards at times. I mean, not I mean, obviously, literally, she was rowing backwards, but she didn't really feel like she was going anywhere. So dreadful were the conditions. In 1932, her father went to a boat builder and said, if you build my daughter a boat, will, she win? And the boat builder said, she will.

And indeed she did. And she carried all before her from 1932 to 1934. She became the the secretary of the Weybridge Rowing Club, and by 1939 was its chair. She was the driving force on in women's rowing in the country. One of the clubs which had been useful and had adopted this with some enthusiasm was the Vesta Rowing Club, and they set up the first women's regatta.

And a gentleman from the Vesta Rowing Club said at the time, while I do not approve of rowing for women, as they will do it anyway, the best thing I can do would be to help them do it properly. So you can see the sort of attitudes of Rat at the time. Nevertheless, she was fantastic at it, and she retired from the highest level of the sport in the late thirties. Obviously, the second world war came around, and in 1939, she became the secretary to Barnes Wallace. And for those members who are not familiar with the dam busters, I have to remind honorable members that Barnes Wallace was instrumental in developing the bouncing bomb.

And the way in which he did it was that he and his secretary, Amy Gentry, would go to Silvermere Lake, and he would fire various projectiles from a catapult across the lake, and then he and Amy would row out to collect them in order to see how they fared. Sort of a very high grade stone skimming competition. And at one stage, Barnes Wallace was a pretty serious guy. And Amy had to point out to him, as they were rowing out to one of the projectiles. She said, Wallace, you may be in charge, but I am in charge in this boat.

Sit down. So after the war, rowing went from strength to strength. We were represented in the European Championships in 1952, and in 1954, carrying all before us at the national and international level. As a slight aside, in the nineteen fifty four European games, which Amy Gentry went over to, she handed out some prizes to one of the crews, to a young lady called Betty Shugbrook. And Betty Shugbrook was a member of the London Rowing Club, and she had met her soon to be husband at the London Rowing Club on Regatta on Boxing Day.

His name was Graham Hill. She went on to be Betty Hill, and she became the only person to be married to and be the mother of a Formula one world racing champion.

05:07:38 - 05:08:52

Speaker 59

Amy was awarded the sorry. She was instrumental in bringing the Euros here, the European Championships here, in 1960, and she was awarded the OBE in 1969. She died in June 1976, in Stanwell, in my constituency, And the significance of that date is a sad irony because she didn't quite live to see the moment one month later when women were allowed to compete in rowing in the Olympic Games in Montreal. And so if, when honorable members in a month's time, if they happen to be watching the Oxford and Cambridge boat race, when the, crew the the women's crew goes under Barnsbridge in the latter stages of the race, they will pass a huge pub on the South Bank of the River Thames, and it is called the White Hart. And that is at the end of White Hart Lane where Amy Gentry was born.

And so when honorable members, see that moment, perhaps they would join me in raising a glance to the remarkable woman, Amy Gentry.

05:08:54 - 05:18:45

Speaker 91

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'd like to thank the government for having this debate in government time. I had put in for a backbench business debate as I normally do as backup. I think that now that we have a Labour government I could probably stop doing that now. Madam Speaker to speak I need to apologise for my voice.

I was going to blame it on a cold but actually I was at the transmission concert yesterday at Wembley Arena and I was shouting that trans rights are the human rights quite loudly. And also singing along to Beverly Knight's Everything's Going to Be Alright. And it reminded me of a saying that everything will be alright in the end and if it's not alright it's not the end. And Madam Deputy Speaker right now things are not alright for women. As the minister stated in her excellent opening speech, women are currently at our most vulnerable globally.

It feels worse than it has felt in a very long time. With the influencers and the brain rot of social media and the increasing lack of legislation around bodily autonomy and men influencing boys as we've heard many times from MPs today on what a perfect woman should be with detailed instructions of how to abuse women and girls, we are in serious danger as women and we need protection. So today is the day on International Women's Day Madame Deputy Speaker to tell some truths because for many of us progress has not been made by us being welcomed in the room. Progress has been made by us taking up room. Progress has been made by us taking up space.

And I want to thank all the women in my constituency in Brent who have taken up space. Even when as women we're told you don't belong here or we're told they're letting anyone in nowadays which was said to me by an MP once on the terrace. And that is not the only thing that's been said to me as an MP. I've been told Madam Deputy Speaker that I'm too serious and then I've also been told that I'm not serious enough. I've been told I need to dress up then been told I need to dress down.

I should smile more or I smile too much. I'm too confident or I'm not confident enough. I talk about black issues too much and then I don't talk about black issues enough or I talk about women's issues all time but I don't talk about men's issues. And the reality is madam deputy speaker I've been here for all of the international men's day debate when there's been nobody on the backbenches from the other side. So nobody can accuse me of not being an equal opportunity debater.

But the truth is this, that you can't win and you will never win if you're trying to fit into anyone else's expectations. Some people try to make you feel so small that they try and strip away who you are so that you no longer recognize yourself. And some people and and the hallmark of those people are the people who are unhappy in their own lives. They often have small appendix and they will try to put others down and the worst thing we can do to yourself is to allow that to happen. Because in life as women we need all the strength that we can get just to survive.

I recall Madame Deputy Speaker after my cancer diagnosis and whilst writing my book A Purposeful Life deciding that I wanted to be Mayor of London. There were many positive responses to that for which I am eternally grateful and I'll be tapping them up for the campaign. But of course that was mixed with oh there's never been a black mare and oh there's never been a female mare and what makes you think you can do it? What have you done? What have you delivered?

As that somebody else was saying that to me. It's a man's job isn't it? And I should stay in my lane. Madam Deputy Seeker, the truth is my lane is wherever I say it is and I will slay in my lane and I will achieve my ambitions because I have learned something important on my political journey. That when you give your voice, when you give our voice, when we give our time, when we give our courage, we don't lose, we learn and we gain.

And I have gained so much. I have gained friends, I have gained knowledge and I've gained the power to change things for the better. And I have made it my mission to pave the way for others. I don't always succeed and sometimes people let you down but that's just life, but sometimes I do succeed Madame Deputy Speaker. And there were two female MPs in this place who I gave their first jobs to in Parliament.

My dear friend, the MP for Stratford and Vogue and the MP for West Bromwich. Two women who are now doing a phenomenal job for their constituents. That is what can happen when you give. When you give, you and others gain. I know what it feels like Madam Deputy Speaker not to be taken seriously, to have my experiences dismissed, my views belittle and for people not recognizing the struggle or your greatness.

So this International Women's Day debate is time to tell the truth. I have been in many rooms where I've not fitted in so I've come to accept that and I have come to embrace standing out. I will wear my bright clothes Madam Deputy Speaker, this one is from Deborah. I will smile when I am happy and I will act confident even when at times I may not feel it. The truth of the matter is when women rise the system gets better.

Women are failed by the system and by some men and women time and time again. Whether it is the court system or whether it is in Iran, Gaza, Afghanistan, Sudan, UK or America. Women and girls lives are in danger all over the globe. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I find it strange that we have misogynistic men who are part of the biggest wealthiest pedophile gang we have ever seen and yet no one is in prison. Even though the evidence is there in the Epstein files, hardly anyone has been arrested and where they have been arrested it is not for raping little girls and teenagers and we should ask ourselves why is that?

How is it that people can protest outside hotels but they're not protesting outside the Sandringham Estate. No matter the color of your skin or how much money you have in the bank, if you abuse and rape little girls and teenagers and young women, if you're part of a grooming gang large or small, you should be punished and you should be imprisoned. And I believe it is our duty in this place to speak up and to ensure that paedophiles are punished without fear or favour. I don't care who they are. I don't care who they're friends with, I don't care if they're royalty, I don't care if they're influential people.

It's time to tell the truth and not to pretend that you care about women and girls when you're being selective. A woman is killed every three days in The UK and every ten minutes globally. A woman is raped every eight minutes in The UK and just seconds globally. I want women and girls to be safe not just in The UK but globally around the world. This International Women's Day I would love for people to give comfort to women who are struggling everywhere whether it is at war or in the workplace.

There is no hierarchy of women. None of us are free until we are all free. None of us are safe until we are all safe. Madam deputy speaker the truth is you don't know how strong you are until that is the only thing you have left. But you shouldn't need to be strong.

You should just be safe. It is also true that women of colour are expected to be strong all of the time and we are tired. Tired of not being supported, tired of being overlooked and tired of our pain not being recognized whether it's in The UK or globally. And as we pour unprecedented amounts of money into AI systems that makes women's lives less safe let's refocus our efforts on protecting women and girls. And if we do that, if we protect the most vulnerable women, if that is our starting point Madam Deputy Speaker, then the outcomes will be better, stronger, fairer, more equitable and safer for all.

05:18:47 - 05:25:55

Speaker 46

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. It's always difficult to follow the member from Brent East to speeches I am generally in awe of and that was yet another one. A speech that I was also in awe of was the one from the member for Gorton and Denton. Like the member over here I wish I had delivered a maiden speech that was anywhere close to as good as that. That level of passion for her constituents was very clear and that understanding of constituents as well.

There are so many MPs in here who were first elected who do not understand their constituents or their constituencies and it's very clear that the new member for Gorton and Denton is one of her people in her constituency and really understands how her patch feels. I think they are very lucky to have such a representative. Madam Deputy Speaker, I thought about how best to do this speech today, whether I would go on a kind of political thing raging about all of the injustices, whether I talk about all of the unseen women that there are, that are doing all of the heavy lifting that we don't talk about and we don't notice. I thought about how best to put this across but honestly, native speaker, I've had about the busiest week in Parliament that I've ever had and I am going to try and give a speech in which I don't cry and that's my bar today. So if we get to that point I'll have one.

One of my team is called Alma and is one of the most wonderful humans I have ever met. And she was born in Denmark, has spent a lot of time in Denmark, was telling me that in Denmark International Women's Day is called Kfundernest Kampdag, which I've probably pronounced wrong, but it means women's struggle day or women's fight day. It's about recognising the fight and the struggle that women face, but it's also about fighting and struggling for those women. I thought that that was such a good thing to think of for all of us in here about the fact that that fight and that struggle is ongoing. It is not one.

As the member from Brent East said, things are not in a good way right now. Things are less safe than they have been in a very long time. I think we need to continue to support, recognise and fight for those unseen women. Sometimes. We talk about the fact that there are women doing jobs that nobody notices.

I'm telling you you would notice if they weren't doing them. You would notice very quickly if they weren't doing them because things would not work. One of the reasons that we're all standing here today and the reason that we are able to have this debate today is because there's a member of House staff who makes sure that we have these debates, that make sure that debates happen. It's her birthday today and I'm not going to say her name because she'd probably kill me, but I want to recognise that she's one of the many unseen women in this place who ensures that we can do what we do, who ensures that we have got that time and space to be able to stand up and make those speeches, who has made the time on this Thursday for us to be able to speak about the issues that are affecting our constituents, issues that are affecting women around the world. A number of people have spoken about oppressive states and what is happening in so many countries around the world, with the situation systemically, run by the state becoming worse for women.

Some of that is because of religious expectations from various different religions requiring a very strong interpretation, an extreme interpretation, of some of the religious texts and requiring women to act and behave in a certain way. Some of it's not. Some of it's just because we continue to have patriarchal societies throughout the world, and men are historically bigger and stronger than us and able to keep that in place. We've got huge amounts of gendered expectations on young women growing up. It is made worse by the fact that they are on the internet, fact that the gendered expectations are not just happening in the school classrooms, not just happening in television shows that they see, they're happening in games that they play online, they're happening in online spaces that they inhabit, they're happening everywhere, that women are expected to be subservient to men.

A number of us have spoken before about how women have got to be better than men in order to get to the same position. I've spoken before previously a lot about the phrase hard working families, and sometimes when people say the phrase hard working families, they mean middle class families. They mean people that are earning 40 or $50 a year. They don't mean people who are working as carers. They don't mean people who are trying to get four kids out of the door in the morning with the right shoes on, on the right feet.

They don't mean that. They don't mean the people who are doing those everyday jobs that we desperately need. They don't mean the bus drivers. They don't mean the people working to ensure that all of our lives run smoothly. I think the member from Darlington mentioned earlier on the way that we look at society and the value that we give to roles.

And I've been thinking for a long time about the fact that we should really tip this on its head. We should think about which jobs actually do we need? Which jobs do we need people to be doing? We need people to be carers. We need people to look after children in nurseries.

We need people to be teachers. We need people to be nurses and doctors. We need people to do all of those public sector roles that we desperately need. But we don't value them. We don't pay them more than the living wage in a lot of cases.

Actually, those are the people whose jobs we desperately need or society would fall apart. Yet, for some reason, we continue to think that that's okay, that they continue to be bottom of the pile. These jobs are overwhelmingly jobs that women are in. Overwhelmingly. And I think that we need to think about that gendered expectation that women will continue to do all of the hard work and we'll pay them very little for doing that job.

Imagine they didn't. Imagine the women went on strike. Imagine every woman that we know that's working and every job that we know went on strike. How quickly society would fall apart if the women stopped doing all of that work that we don't see, which is why we need to fight for them. We need to fight for all of those unseen women doing those unseen jobs.

We need to fight so that we can ensure that it's not just women who are filling those roles. We need equal opportunities at the top of the

05:25:55 - 05:25:57

Speaker 48

pile and at the bottom of the pile.

05:25:57 - 05:31:51

Speaker 46

We need to be able to lift women out of some of those roles, we need to be able to ensure that men can take up some of those roles and then perhaps we'll get more pay for carers, if there are more men being carers. There are some, absolutely, but I think that would tip things in a good way. A couple more things in relation to Parliament. I thought it was really interesting having the Defending Democracy Task Force just before this debate. I struggle more than I ever have telling young women to come to Parliament, telling them to become an elected representative.

It is harder than it has ever been. Part of that is because of social media. Part of that is because of the toxic climate that there can be particularly out there, particularly out in the world where you know there's so much polarization and ideological position taking that results in the abuse that women face, the abuse that members from ethnic minority backgrounds face. Standing up in front a class of young women, a class of people from a variety of different ethnic backgrounds, it's very hard to say to them this is a great job. You should do it.

What I find myself saying to them is look this is a really hard job. This is a job where you will face abuse. It is worth it to make a difference. It is worth it to do that. And I think, cross party, we are genuinely all working together to try to ensure that democracy is defended, that younger people thinking about going into politics, or older people thinking about going into politics, can truly consider that and take that on without fear that they will be abused.

Again, the member for Benny's talked about those expectations on women. I remember watching a Queen's speech and I was doing BBC TV when I was I think it was a Queen's speech and I was sitting there and the journalist turned to me when Theresa May got out the car and said What do you think of Theresa May's outfit? And I was like, she looks very resolute, you know? He said, Okay, you're right. I shouldn't have asked you that.

I'll ask the man on the panel instead, What do you think of Theresa May's outfit? That's not the point. It's not about what Theresa May is wearing. It's about what she's doing. It's about the importance of this moment.

Whether I agree or disagree with the Conservative Prime Minister, she was stepping out of the car as Prime Minister. It was really important. Talking about what she was wearing was not the right thing to do in that moment. As I said, the member for Brent used to talk about those expectations was talking about being too smiley or not smiley enough, talking about the fact that we just simply cannot win. No matter what abuse is thrown at me, I guarantee you I have said worse to myself.

I am my own greatest critic, as many of the women that I meet and that I know across Parliament. As the only woman in the SNP right now, because of being wiped out by you guys frankly, it's not that we didn't stand lots of women, we stood lots of women, it's just bad electoral luck on our part in relation to that, and losing lots of seats. As the only woman in the SNP, that fellowship across the house is really difficult right now, finding that fellowship and support. So I'd be happy to support and to work with people who are organizing the women's caucus, trying to get that off the ground. For people like me, and women in other parties, particularly small parties, who don't have those relationships naturally within our parties, who can't find those people unless we're having to bump into each other in the tea room.

We don't get that in group meetings. I think it's really important that we push forward with the women's caucus, in order that women can have that place where we get support. I commend all of the members that have worked really hard on trying to bring forward the women's caucus. The last thing I wanted to touch on was menopause. Because members are right, it's not talked about enough.

It's not something that I ever would have heard discussed in my home when I was a child. It's not something that I knew existed. Mean I'm sure I knew that something happened at the end, but I didn't know. I'm sure I knew that periods stopped at some point, but I didn't really know much beyond that. The more I've got groups of women that I speak to that are growing older, getting past their kind of thirties, the more I've learned about menopause.

And I just want to say how unfair is it that itchy ears are a symptom of menopause? I mean, you know, you've got everything else to deal with. You're dealing with so much rubbish. I'm just telling you all, if you don't know, itchy ears are a symptom of menopause. I think that's my public service announcement for the day.

If you hear women in your life talking about having itchy ears, just be kind to them, give them a bit of support. Madam Deputy Speaker, I think it's really important that we hold each other up, that we support one another, that we work on a cross party basis to further the rights of women, to ensure that those unseen women are supported and to ensure that people working in traditional women's roles that are historically belonging to, mostly held by women, that we pay them an awful lot more money in order to recognise the contribution that they deliver.

05:31:53 - 05:38:05

Speaker 17

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. It gives me great pleasure and pride to contribute to this debate today. Is probably okay, I've only been here eighteen months but this is one of my favourite debates in the chamber. It gives A T S that privilege of being able to listen to the experiences from across the house, to recognise the women who make a difference in everybody's local communities, the difference globally, and it is always inspiring. It also gives me great pleasure to follow on from the member from Aberdeen North, because of the conversation that we had earlier on in this week.

I think I uttered the phrase that in this place we cross paths more often than we cross swords. The proverbial verbal swords, not the physical ones always out for the master of arms. Whilst we are here as women, and this is the most diverse ever that there has ever been, we are not homogenous. We all bring different things to this place. We all bring different perspectives.

And this parliament is stronger for it. That is why I also feel really privileged to be able to hear the maiden speech of the member for Garton and Denton and welcome what she brings to this place. This year's theme for International Women's Day is give to gain, but also the UN's theme of recognising rights, justice and action for all women. It reminds us that we must never accept that the work is done. We must never forget that what advances we have made can still be lost.

There are still far too many women and girls across the world who do not have rights, who cannot access justice and who are denied education, health care and financial independence. In the short time available to me today, I want to highlight some of the women of my constituency, Cumbernault, Kirkintillith, who embody that theme. The women who work every day for the rights, well-being and opportunities of others. Women like Linda, Lorna and Christine and all the women at Tony's Safe Space, an organisation which was founded four years ago today, to provide support those affected by suicide, beweavement and mental health. A group of women turning personal tragedy into compassion and practical help for others is an extraordinary act of strength in itself.

Women like Anne Miller of Quillsides Senior Citizens and the old library management group are a real force of nature in the community, working tirelessly to ensure that older people remain active and connected. I have been known to chase me down when I have been doing my surgeries and who is somebody I always love to see. Women like Isabelle Hughes and the welcome group at St Patrick's in Kulcythe, who provide support, respite and friendship for people living with memory loss and for their families. Whilst Grace is a woman's name in itself, it also stands for the Group Recovery Aftercare Community Enterprise in Eastern Bartonshire, where Linni and Yvette support adults who are in recovery from life trauma. It is an organisation rooted in lived experience, providing therapy, recovery support and aftercare.

Is a fundamental belief that the need for aftercare never stops, as standing as a powerful force for good in those who are building their lives. Those women, and so many others across Cumber, Nauld and Kirk and Tillich, give their time, energy and compassion to support others. That work, as the member from Aberdeen North said earlier, happens quietly without recognition and its impact is profound. They strengthen communities, they lift people up, they remind us all of the power of kindness and solidarity. And that is why International Women's Day matters.

It allows us to celebrate those contributions whilst remembering that progress has never been inevitable. Every right a woman today enjoys been hard won by those who came before us. As we celebrate those achievements, we must also recognise that the work is still to be done tackling violence against women and girls, closing the gender pay gap and ensuring every girl has the right and opportunity to lead, learn and thrive. Today, I place my sincere thanks to the women across Cumberland, Oldenkirk and Tullock, who give so much of themselves in service to others. Their work reminds us that progress is not just delivered by government it is built every day in our communities, the people who choose to care, support and stand up for others.

If we truly want a world where women and girls gain equality, justice and opportunity, then we must continue to match their commitment with our action.

05:38:07 - 05:38:08

Speaker 68

Clive Jones.

05:38:08 - 05:42:30

Speaker 41

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I congratulate the Honourable Member for Gorton and Denton on her maiden speech? It was an eloquent speech that actually made us think that you've been here for several years. I really enjoyed your description of your constituency and the people and organizations that you are now representing. And I hope that the honorable member doesn't get involved in fixing the plumbing and the plastering in this place.

Her place is in this chamber, and I'm sure in being here, she'll make a name for herself and be a really good champion for her constituents. This debate is an opportunity to mark the progress we have made to improve gender equality and empower women in all areas of life. It is important that we also monitor the progress and assess where there is much work to do. The gender equality index is a helpful tool which looks at gender equality across all authorities in The UK. Wokingham scores in the top 10% of local authorities for women's outcome, meaning women in Wokingham generally have better equality in pay, life expectancy, job progression and skills compared to women nationally.

However, specifically in Wokingham, there is still a significant gap in pay between women and men, in job progression and in participation in our civil society. This needs to change. It is of course very welcome that women are doing well in Wokingham, but that counts for little if their outcomes are still far behind the outcomes of men. That is why there is still so much work that needs to be done to ensure that the gender equality is improved and then strengthened for this generation and for many generations to come. A very serious issue is where gender equality plays out in shocking and violent ways.

Through casework I have seen many women in working on are victims of abuse and violence, often linked to an imbalance in financial and physical power. It is a great shame that many women who are victims of domestic abuse feel unsupported and neglected by the police, the courts and other services, and are often left relying on charities. That is why the government needs to ensure survivors of violence against women and girls are properly supported in the criminal justice system with mandatory training for police and prosecutors on the impact of trauma. The government must also ensure that there is sustainable funding for services that support domestic abuse survivors. On this, I must highlight the vital work done by Vicki Robertson and her charity, Kaleidoscopic UK, who are based in Wokingham and help women who have experienced domestic abuse across the Thames Valley.

I've also seen through casework that so much of homelessness stems from domestic abuse. This is because of a financial imbalance as women often have to care for their children and the accommodation offered is unsuitable for a family. The government must take action to ensure that victims are not forced to return to perpetrators due to inadequate temporary accommodation. It is clear that while some progress has been made to close the gender gap, there is still so much more to do to make our communities safer for women and to level the playing field. You.

05:42:31 - 05:42:33

Speaker 68

Tanya Antonietzi.

05:42:33 - 05:50:19

Speaker 45

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. It is a real privilege to be here to speak today to mark International Women's Day and also I'd like to pay tribute to the Honourable Member for Gortmund Denton on her maiden speech. I remember when I made my maiden speech here nearly nine years ago time flies nearly nine years ago I remember just above me here were my mum, my brother, my younger brother and my son aged just 13 at the time. I don't know who she has with her today, however I'd like to pay tribute to family members, my mother who we lost last September. I just wanted to say if it wasn't for other women, supporting women and their brothers and sisters and children, we wouldn't be able to stand here today to do our job, so I wish her all the very best in her career.

There have been many advances in the fight for women's equality in recent decades, and indeed much welcome and needed action on male violence against women and girls since their Labour government came into office. There has however been a frustrating stasis on some issues meaning that they have worsened. Sexual exploitation has been showing a clear and sustained rise in The United Kingdom with increasing numbers of women identified as victims. We're seeing more UK national victims of sexual exploitation and at a younger age. Yet women and girls exploited in the sex trade remain to be amongst the most neglected in our policy discussions and reforms and so it is of them I want to talk about today.

Because these women matter, madam deputy speaker, and the harms they experience are extreme. Technological change has reshaped our world but it has also created new opportunities for sexual exploitation to proliferate on a scale we have never seen before because our legislation has not kept pace and is not capable of keeping pace. Despite it being illegal to place a prostitution advert in a phone box, that same advert can legally be published for profit on a website. Into this gap, traffickers have moved quickly, pimping websites which act as a vast online brothel, drive demand and supercharge the sex trafficking trade by making it easier and quicker for pimps to advertise their victims. They make it as easy to order a woman to a booze as it is to order a takeaway, and they operate freely and openly because our legislation allows this.

A report published just weeks ago by the independent anti slavery commissioner shows how adult service websites don't just horse exploited and trafficked women, they provide the infrastructure to initiate, scale and normalise their abuse. Nearly 63,000 listings for women were recorded across 12 of these sites at one point in time, which attracted almost 41,700,000 visitors in a month. And this Madam Deputy Speaker is just a fraction of an even larger marketplace because additional sites are available to users. Nearly 60% of the adverts analysed displayed three or more indicators of trafficking or exploitation which for example include multiple ads linked to the same phone number and new to area language. Behind these numbers are real and severe harms endured by women exploited on these sites.

Survivors interviewed for this report talked about how they were groomed, controlled and advertised online without their knowledge or consent. A survivor who was exploited alongside other women said, none of us had access to the emails from buyers. They came directly through him. He answered us if he was us and then he would send me a message saying, oh, this person you know, this is where you're going to meet them and this is what you have agreed to do.' This use and abuse of women is directly enabled and amplified by these sites' very design which, for example, enable third party facilitation. Survivors spoke of how traffickers and abusive partners created profiles, arranged bookings and made profits while women themselves were controlled and intimidated.

Despite third party facilitation being a known red flag for trafficking, Ofcom guidance ignores this and portrays it as a safety measure. Profiles on these sites also give the illusion of independence to mask deeper exploitation. Another survivor said she was being raped on a webcam essentially and of course the people watching aren't aware of that. The profile is written so it sounds as if I'm independent and enjoying it. How do you go behind a webcam to make sure that that woman isn't being coerced?

Meanwhile, buyers on some forums openly discuss which women are controlled and the benefits this has for them. As another survivor explained, you will see men sharing about. These girls are trafficked. You can get away with doing this to her. It's just right there on the page.

This is the selling and abuse of women in plain sight on an industrial scale, madam deputy speaker, enabled by our legislative framework. This is totally unacceptable. These women deserve so much better. The Independent Anti Slavery Commissioner is absolutely right in saying that these websites are ready made tools for abuse and that the toughest action must be taken against them. The All Party group on commercial exploitation, which I chair, has been sounding the alarm on pimping websites and their harms for quite some time.

And the truth is that current legislation and regulatory guidance are not acting or preventing this harm, and it is traffickers, pimps and punters operating with near total impunity who benefit. Women are abused as if they are objects and suffer acutely. We, madam deputy speaker, are failing them. So I urge the government to pay close attention to the report's findings and to act urgently on its recommendations for a robust review into them, one that includes survivors, and this needs to be a prompt one. There's a lot of evidence already out there and the longer we wait the more women and girls are suffering as a result.

And what's more, the scale and ease access of this online market is not just facilitating exploitation, it is also more widely fuelling the dangerous rise in misogyny by normalising the idea that women exist to be bought, used and discarded. In an age where prostitution is glamorised, boys and men are repeatedly exposed to platforms that present women as sexual commodities and it inevitably shapes their attitudes. The scale of demand for pimping websites should give us serious pause for thought in that respect as well. Shutting these sites down has a fundamental role to play, not just in preventing horrific exploitation but also in shifting the attitudes of men and boys to promote healthy and respectful relationships. If we are, madam deputy speaker, to tackle male violence against women and girls, these websites have to be shut down.

05:50:19 - 05:58:49

Speaker 16

John Grady. I'm obliged Madam Deputy Speaker. May I start by paying tribute to the member for Gawson and Denton for what was a profound speech. Remember used the phrase, Our humanity is the same, and in that there is a profound truth. And we must recognize in this house that there are people who disagree with that and want to tear us apart.

As someone who has a diverse constituency covering many different races, faiths and differences of views, I treasure that diversity because I do believe our humanity is the same. And we in this house must be very careful to fight against those who want to shatter that and who want to tear us apart and take us significantly back in time. Our humanity is the same as those women and girls that my friend, the member for North East Fife, spoke of and as a fellow office bearer on the APPG for Afghan women and girls, we must do much more to support women and girls in Afghanistan, and we must look afresh at things like international law to criminalize the mistreatment of women and girls to such evil degrees. The minister rightly mentioned the fight by trade unionists for equal pay. The first socialist in my party was my great auntie Nelly who led equal pay strikes in the thirties in Pontefract and malicarist factories.

She became friends with Barbara Castle who of course is responsible for the Equal Pay Act. We should all be very angry but the fact of the matter is that women now are paid less than men. There is still considerable structural inequality of pay. But now our fight for equality, which I believe is shared by all of us and we must all share, faces new and much more dangerous threats. We must redouble our efforts and we shouldn't just be angry about it.

We are legislators. We must legislate and then see that legislation on because otherwise the future for women and girls, my daughter and the other children in my constituency and across the world, will become bleaker when we want to see progress. I want to speak about domestic abuse today. One in four women in The UK will experience domestic abuse in their lifetime. In Glasgow East, I work with survivors and I see how, in particular, housing instability is a barrier to my constituents fleeing abuse.

I'm very dismayed of the lack of support provided by the housing sector in Scotland to survivors. Survivors do not receive trauma informed care and are not supported into safe, settled homes. Instead, I've met women who have suffered from terrifying sexual violence, who have been forced into social housing in an awful condition and then faced months of unknown male workmen coming to their new home. And that social animals have been aware that the women in question have suffered and that women shouldn't have to ask for female work people to come to work in their homes should be a matter of course. Women in my seat waiting months for house transfers meaning that their abusers know exactly where they live.

A particular legal problem is when women are not included of a tenancy for their rented home. This means that they do not have legal rights to stay in their home and when the relationship comes to an end the women face eviction and homelessness. This is why the Scottish Parliament passed part two of the Domestic Abuse Protection Scotland Act 2021 almost five years ago. Gives social landlords powers to transfer tenancies from abusers to survivors. But almost five years after it was passed we are still waiting for this to be made legally enforceable by the Scottish Government.

I've been pressing the Scottish Government on this and in January I wrote to the press about this disgraceful delay. On the next day the Scottish Government announced they would finally bring these provisions into force. Despite this five year delay, social landlords have had no formal guidance from the Scottish government about how the provisions will operate in practice. They do not know how the courts or the police will approach this and this is essential for social landlords. A poorly thought out implementation will put survivors at further risk.

I have raised these concerns with the SNP Scottish Government and I am still awaiting a response. Now madam deputy speaker, there are organizations who do fantastic work to ensure survivors' housing stability. The Domestic Abuse Housing Alliance provides the infrastructure training and monitoring necessary for social landlords to recognise and tackle domestic abuse. This works very well in England. Just north of here Islington Council have very successfully worked with Dahar and significantly improved the outcomes for survivors of domestic abuse.

In Glasgow social landlords need help and support to make the improvements that they must make and the social landlords I recognise do recognise the importance of this. I am determined to see survivors of domestic abuse get much better help and support. So I've asked social landlords to meet with Daha and I am pleased that two housing associations in my seat, Wheatley and Govan Hill, as well as the Scottish housing regulator, have expressed an interest in learning more and are willing to meet with Dahan. In agreeing to do so, they are demonstrating their commitment to supporting survivors of domestic abuse. I will encourage others to do the same.

Madam Deputy Speaker, we must do much much better in Scotland for the survivors of domestic abuse and I'm determined to continue to work hard on this. I wish to speak about one other topic on my seat. I am very proud of the work of one of my local charities Scottish Sports Futures. They do great work with young people in my seat. In particular they encourage young women to speak up about their experience of violence against women and girls.

This means that the young men programmes learn about what they have to do to treat women as their equals and to treat them with respect. I cannot praise Scottish Sports Futures enough for working on this and giving those young women a voice. Several of those young women in their programmes spoke with bravery about this at their annual awards event last week. At the event a young woman from Barrowfield just round in my seat spoke courageously about violence against women and girls and the issue of youth violence more generally which has a profound impact on girls in my constituency. In particular following the killing of a young boy in my seat two years ago called Corrie McCrimmon.

His family faced their grief by the way with profound dignity and courage. I'm proud of all my young constituents, madam deputy speaker, and politics is a matter of morals and it's a moral issue. My moral obligations, their member of parliament, is to do everything within my power to tackle violence against women and girls.

05:58:49 - 05:58:52

Speaker 68

Doctor Marie Tibbon.

05:58:52 - 06:08:16

Speaker 88

Thank you madam deputy speaker and to all the women in this chamber who really have slayed in their lane in the debate today. When they amputated my leg, they amputated a part of me. I see my body and I feel disgust, repulsion. I fear that my amputation took away my femininity, my ability to be yearned for, my womanhood pauperized, trapped in a body that does not reflect my mind or myself. Anorexia, unplanned, like an addiction crept upon me.

I ate less and became thinner. My wish that nobody would notice my disability and I would simply disappear, a physical escapism. For the first time in my life, the eating disorder gave me control over my body, the way it looked, the way it felt, my frustration about my physical form turned into obsession. The obsession fed me where food did not. It gave me power.

Success became feeling bones left behind under taut skin, knowing my pelvis protruded below a small waist. Cheekbones were prominent on a smile less face. Anorexia was about the relationship between a despised body and a disciplined mind. Eventually, that mind was consumed too. A warped wasteland where fear and anger roamed.

There was no escape from or for myself. Weight, four stone, ten pounds. My body was breaking down. I was losing my hair, and my period stopped. My menstruation ending ultimately saved me and my life.

Somewhere at the back of my head, I knew I wanted to have children. Eventually, I took the pill. My period started again. I ate more. My desire to be a mother gave me a reason to get better, signaled a future, and made me no choice once again.

I wrote these passages twenty years ago in my early twenties while recovering from my last major surgery to my legs. I was anorexic for four years from being age 14, And whilst I was physically better by the time I went to university, it took me until my mid twenties to have a healthy relationship with food. And I'm not alone. Over the years, I've spoken to other disabled women about their experiences of eating disorders linked to their own body image and identity. Devastatingly, twenty years later, two decades after I wrote those passages, social attitudes towards sex, relationships, and disability remain an enormous taboo, which means disabled women are still going through this anguish, damaging their mental health, causing them to self harm, and eroding their self esteem.

Actor and disability activist Melissa Johns, who has an upper body limb difference, shared her story, how she has a strong history of loathing her body. But that never came from her. It came from society telling her that her body was wrong. Too often, madam deputy speaker, disabled women's bodies do not count. Mum, social media influencer, and wheelchair user Sophie Bradbury Cox showed me just some comments made on her social media about the fact that she is a disabled mother, including there's some thing horribly unethical about having children when you're not able to care for yourself.

These damaging attitudes and the lack of awareness of these issues are leading disabled women to face barriers in public services, including accessing sexual and reproductive and maternity care. In the last year, I've met two incredible disabled women, Carly, a Paralympian, and Sarah, an occupational therapist. Both have cerebral palsy and neither found out they were pregnant until their second and third trimesters respectively because none of their clinicians considered that they might be pregnant. Carly Tate, who competed in the twenty sixteen Paralympic Games in Rio De Janeiro, soon discovered she was pregnant after retiring from professional sport. This was immediately followed by a lot of questions about whether she was capable of giving birth, a line of conversation she faced throughout her pregnancy.

Some people seemed to ignore her pregnancy altogether. On the last day before her maternity leave, a colleague approached her saying, oh my gosh, you're pregnant, showing an ableist view that someone like Carly couldn't possibly be pregnant. But disabled women are making babies, having babies, and being brilliant mothers. Against the odds. Odds that mean we face a forty four percent higher likelihood of stillbirth.

That's why I called on the Secretary of State for Health to put inclusive maternity care for disabled women at the heart of our women's health strategy so that our womanhood no longer remains invisible. But we need to go further and finally embed the social model of disability into women's health care and implement the recommendations for the UK government made by the United Nations Committee on People with Disabilities in 2017. That committee found that the rights of disabled women and girls have not been systematically mainstreamed into either the gender equality or disability agendas, with disabled women facing multiple barriers to accessing sexual and reproductive health services and professionals. I've lost count of the number of disabled people I've ended up mentoring who self harmed and attempted suicide because of these issues of sex, relationships, and disability not being discussed and the lack of services and absence of professional expertise to support them. I'm proud that our government's reforms will engender a high quality and inclusive curriculum for all, but this must include the representation of disabled people in PSHE lessons in school.

We must turn the tide of public attitudes towards disabled people, particularly empowering young disabled people to have more positive perceptions of self. But there are reasons to be hopeful. Green shoots of representation are appearing on our screens. EastEnders is currently covering a storyline about a pregnant woman who is a wheelchair user. This season's Bridgerton featured a subplot with Hazel, a maid played by Gracie McGonagall, and her love interest with dashing footman, John, without the series ever even mentioning Hazel's limb difference.

Instagram has become a burgeoning social media platform for brilliant disabled women supercharging representation of disability and desire of being proud and empowered about the intrinsic beauty of our bodies and ourselves. They are boldly forging the conversation about us being loved and in love. Powering the narrative around disability and dating, elucidating new language about being in interabled couples, navigating difficult conversations and acceptance. Disability no longer cast as absence but complete, full bodied presence. To be loved is to be seen.

It is high time our society sees disabled women's whole selves, for only then will we create society which treats disabled women with the dignity and respect we deserve. Dear. Dave Robertson.

06:08:16 - 06:11:51

Speaker 15

Thank you madam deputy speaker. Earlier on, the member for Aberdeen North, as part of her speech, mentioned that it can be difficult at times to advise people to come into the roles that we all do. I actually think she would be well served by just playing people what we've heard in the House today. This debate has been of the highest quality and I thank everybody for their contributions It's so been a genuine pleasure to be here and listening and part of it. We've had the whole gamut of everything we've had.

People just taking the opportunity to pick up their own constituencies. The member for South Derbyshire, member of Spelthorn, thought think did excellently. And I'm not gonna get everybody, by the way, because I can't remember everybody's constituency, I'm gonna do my best. But we we we we took we had people just taking the opportunity just to celebrate wonderful things in the country and those wonderful people who saw a glass ceiling and jumped higher and it was wonderful to be part of that. But we've also had a debate where people didn't shy away from the really difficult things that we must do.

I'd like to thank the Liberal Democrat spokesperson for her intervention, as well as my honourable friend for Glasgow West. East! It's not gone well already. Two members who took the opportunity to go to actually talk about some really difficult things as well. Obviously I am absolutely going to thank the honourable member for Penison and Stockbridge for her powerful personal testimony.

She is always, always somebody who I enjoy listening to in the chamber. I thank her very much for her contributions today. The debate today serves many of those purposes. It gives us the opportunity to celebrate what is great but it also gives us the opportunity to talk about where our society and our systems have failed women for far too long. Unfortunately that's my role today because I do want to come and raise the issue of what the system has let down far too many people for far too long and that is in the crimes of Mohammed Fayed.

I'm very specifically talking about the crimes of Mohammed Fayed because I do not want to talk about him. Today is about the proud survivors who have done all they can to bring his crimes to light. Feyed is the former owner of He was a sexual predator. He trafficked and sexually abused hundreds of women over decades with near complete impunity. Well over 400 survivors have already come forwards and every day more women take the brave decision to do so.

Yesterday the Honourable Member for North East 5 powerfully described Fired as Britain's Epstein. It's a characterisation that I and she have heard many times from survivors particularly as we now co chair the all party parliamentary group for the survivors of Fired and Harrods. It's also very good to see another of our officers, and though I don't know your constituency, so I'm just going to welcome you to your place. Apologies to the honorable member. The scale of the crimes committed by this predator, and I will not call him a man because real men respect women.

The scale of the crimes by this predator is staggering but it is a mistake to think that it is the work of one bad human. Fired was supported by a network of enablers. He died having escaped justice but there are scores of people who can and must be held to account. They include employees who identified groomed and trafficked women for the abuse. Security staff who harassed and intimidated survivors into silence.

Lawyers who churned out non disclosure agreement after non disclosure agreement after non disclosure agreement and nobody thought to do anything. Doctors who performed invasive medical exams and reported Order.

06:11:53 - 06:12:08

Speaker 68

Apologies for interrupting the honourable gentleman. As there is one live civil case can I just encourage the honourable gentleman to exercise caution in what he says? Is it perfectly okay to say anything Mr. Fyrd who is dead?

06:12:10 - 06:14:19

Speaker 15

I thank the chair for her guidance there and it is really important and I thank her for that because there are some cases still ongoing. I will be talking about the Metropolitan Police in a minute but it is clear that we must do better. For far too long survivors have been ignored and that cannot continue and it must not continue and I'm really grateful to the Minister for Safeguarding who is set to meet with survivors very soon. I welcomed the Prime Minister's commitment yesterday to meet survivors as well. It's taken far too long to get to this stage but I'm very glad to see that things are finally starting to move.

I've had the privilege of meeting dozens of women who have taken that very brave step and come out and been able to put themselves in a place where they can disclose to parliamentarians and people they've never met before because it is their tenacity and their strength that has been fundamental to driving this agenda forwards and to seeing the advances that we've made recently. I know I'm very grateful to all survivors as I'm sure everybody in the APPG is also but we must never take the trust that they have given us for granted. So far the APPG has run a consultation with survivors and we're really pleased that we've seen dozens and dozens and dozens of responses to that because we are very clear that there is a huge network of people who have been wronged in so many ways by so many systems and it is astonishing how almost every time we have a meeting there is something else. Because the scale of the failings here cuts right across civil society, across enormous parts of the state and there is a huge amount that needs to be done to give recompense to some people who have been so poorly served for so long.

I must also place on record my thanks to Survivors Trust who have been working with us and have provided invaluable support to ensure that we are working in a safe way bearing in mind the trauma that survivors have suffered. I'm very eager to in the coming months work with people from right across this house, right across the other place and actually anybody who wants to be involved to make sure that we keep up a drumbeat of evidence about the scales of these crimes.

06:14:19 - 06:14:20

Speaker 17

Will the Earl remember give way?

06:14:20 - 06:14:21

Speaker 62

Absolutely, I'll give way.

06:14:21 - 06:14:22

Speaker 4

A very

06:14:22 - 06:14:49

Speaker 70

grateful to Earl remember for giving way. He is rightly and powerfully talking about the testimony of survivors and giving thanks to Survivors Trust who have given us such invaluable support as we navigate how we manage a very difficult APPG. Can I also talk about just two amazing women, our researchers Catherine and Jessie who keep us right, keep us grounded and have done a huge power of work while we work out how we will the EPPG forward and take the Secretariat forward?

06:14:50 - 06:15:07

Speaker 15

I am so thankful to the Honourable Member for raising both Jesse and Catherine who are acting as the Secretariat in a very difficult space in and around other very busy jobs and I think it's very, very, very clear, certainly to me and I know to the Honourable Member that without their hard work we would not have been able to they

06:15:09 - 06:15:10

Speaker 63

are far too good.

06:15:13 - 06:17:26

Speaker 15

I've completely lost my place now. Give me a second. As we move forwards we are regularly reminded by survivors that for far too long parts of their stories were ignored. For far too long actually often their entire story was ignored. They're very clear that things do need to change and things need to move fastly.

One of the things that comes up most regularly is the police investigation. I'm really glad that the Met along with forces in Scotland and in France are investigating. The Met has now confirmed that it is interviewing suspects on suspicion of trafficking and that is vitally important because survivors really regularly bring up that that was not being taken seriously enough. I'm very, very, very glad that it now is. That focus is vitally important to maintaining the trust of survivors or what trust is left between survivors and the MET.

They do still need reassurance though that the force is truly grasping the scale of that issue. That they are truly working on this as fast as they can and there is often times a frustration raised with us that the updates from the MET appear to be we'll give you another update in three months and that update is there'll be another update in three months. Three months is not a short amount of time and when it's the third or fourth or fifth time that happening, it undermines people's trust that this will ever come to a head and allow justice to happen. Just before I close, I would like to thank all members who have spoken about fired crimes in this chamber and there's been a number of people in various different formats. All those people who have joined the APPG.

All those people who have spoken to me about this. It's been a real learning curve for me over the last year or so. It's been really challenging and that's not to say it's not more challenging for other people but it's been really challenging for me but it's also been a place where I think I've really appreciated people coming to that and showing that trust and hopefully I want to able to repay that as time goes by and move things forward in this space for them. Earlier on though, the few members mentioned that the theme for International Women's Day has been rights, justice and action. And I think that we can really show here that this predator took rights away from far too many people.

They deserve that justice and it really is time to see that action to get that justice delivered. Thank you.

06:17:29 - 06:17:48

Speaker 68

I'm expecting the front bench to be called round about half past four, maybe a little later and I have one, two, three, four. It's either six or seven members waiting to speak so perhaps members who are still waiting could find their remarks six or seven minutes so that everyone can get in. Doctor Lauren Sullivan.

06:17:48 - 06:18:23

Speaker 90

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's my privilege to speak in this debate today and I want to pay tribute to the women here, the men here, particularly to the member of Penney Stone and Stockbridge for her powerful and moving account and sharing her experiences. You're a voice to so many and there will be action because we love it. So, International Women's Day. From Graveshym in my community I've met with many amazing women.

I just want to mention a couple before I move on to the substantive part of what I want to

06:18:23 - 06:18:23

Speaker 17

speak

06:18:23 - 06:20:21

Speaker 90

about. Nagina Hussain is a absolutely phenomenal woman and last week I recently met with over a 100 women and had a very beautiful, wonderful evening together where we shared in food, the breaking of the fast and it was just phenomenal. I just want to pay tribute to here, as well as our business leaders. So Susan Hassan from Nels Caff who I nominated for the MP Heroes, which is Savanta's programme in partnership with NatWest. She's an institution, a business leader, as well as Sylvia Mead who brought wonderful Gravesham businesses up to visit me in Parliament this week.

Again, it's about women coming together, bringing communities together. Now there are many, many more and women in Gravesham do great things. Just one I'm going to tell you a little bit about. Catherine Green grew up in Gravesend, went to Gravesend Grammar School for girls, went on to university completing natural sciences, she earned her PhD and completed many fellowships, was part of the team at the Jenner Institute who developed the AstraZeneca Covid vaccine. She worked with Sarah Gilbert and we thank them for using their talents, their expertise when the world needed them they were there.

I'd like to thank and recognise them for that. Not all women science have been recognised and in celebrating women and science I just want to pay tribute to some women that haven't been recognised. Ada Loves who is the mother and inventor founder of computers. She was only recognised a hundred years after.

06:20:23 - 06:20:23

Speaker 61

Roslyn

06:20:23 - 06:20:59

Speaker 90

Franklin who was the chemist, an x-ray crystallographer not credited or valued for her research but it was her x-ray image that showed that DNA is a double helix. Alice Ball who was an African American scientist, chemist who found a leprosy treatment but that was stolen and written up as the Dean method. Later retracted but still. And Marie Tharpe who is the mother of plate tectonics. So literally these women are absolutely credible but their names and contributions need to

06:20:59 - 06:25:54

Speaker 90

recognised. The UN research shows that global scientific community only a third of women make up that science community and only one in 10 of those researchers are women in leadership roles. Why? Why is that? Women face a set of different challenges.

One of those challenges is the motherhood penalty and that's from pregnancy and beyond. There are structural issues. In science PhD students receive a stipend and they are not employed so they don't get those access to maternity rights or government childcare currently. Postdocs maternity time is not really factored in. They're two year contracts so if you need to step out for six months a year what do do?

Put your research on pause? Somebody else comes in and finishes it? What that means is that there is less papers, less impact, less likely to see progress. It is possible and there are many women that have suffered through it, waited and delayed having families until they have tenure in that permanent position. But it doesn't need to be this hard.

When children grow up half of responders in The UK report for carers in STEM report that they had to cancel their travel plans because of caring responsibilities. I've had it myself an experiment you spent months planning, nursery ring up, come and collect your child with the aerial. Researchers in the field say that they don't travel to those international conferences where they network, where you bring the ideas together because of caring responsibilities. It's fine, we do it, we look after our families but all that means is we are there one step behind. Others, like me, took a career break.

Just want to declare an interest here, I was currently was a recipient of Daphne Jackson fellowship. And why are they amazing? They are phenomenal because they help women and men return to science. It was named after Daphne Jackson, an English nuclear physicist, the first female physics professor in The UK, University of Surrey, the age of 34. Phenomenal.

Thought that qualified women who are unemployed following a career break for family commitments represent an appalling waste of talent and investment in their initial education. Many such women are eager to return to their original careers or to field activity for which their initial education is relevant. Daphne Jackson Fellowships provide that retraining so that they can return on a part time basis. Here I just want to pay tribute and thank the Daphne Jackson Fellowship and the Francis Crick Institute for supporting many women back into research. After a meeting with the Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology about my career and the choices of leaving science to raise a family then return and just wiggle everything through and try and make it work, she launched yesterday a new charter to support women in research.

This is a call for funding bodies, all funding bodies, to step up to include fifty two weeks maternity leave for PhD funders that the UKRI are also supporting. It's about raising the bar, a rising tide lifted all boats to improve maternity leave as well. She also announced an increase of £4,000,000 now to Daphne Jackson's that's over a 100% extra. How many returners to science will that need? It's incredible.

This chart is direction of travel. It's a marker. We're not done. This is a call for women researchers in The UK to tell us what else can we do? How can we work together to make those changes to keep science and scientists improve science for everyone?

In my concluding remarks I just want to speak to all those young women and girls who are curious about science, who want to help people, save the world. Do not doubt yourself. The country needs you. Finally, the men who us, who let us embrace our talents, thank you. Good men never finish last but they help us all improve everybody's quality of life.

I believe the profession of science has the ability to improve lives beyond measure. Thank you to the scientists who are making a difference. We see you and we thank you.

06:25:57 - 06:29:53

Speaker 82

I want to thank all of those who have contributed in this and other debates this week including my honourable friend from Penistone and Stockbridge and my honourable friend from Warrington North who this week have shown true bravery and should be an inspiration to us all. I also want to welcome the honorable member from Gorton Denton to her place and for her passionate speech. Madam deputy speaker, I want to start by thanking and celebrating the amazing women who have played and still play a part in my life, including friends, family and my fabulous staff. They are truly inspirational in the love, support and grounding that they give to me, and I hope that they know that I would not be here and could not do this job without them. Madam Deputy Speaker, this International Women's Day, I want to celebrate the women of Portsmouth, my city, and a city celebrating a truly special milestone of one hundred years as a city this year.

One hundred years of community resilience and remarkable women getting on with the job and making our city the place it is. Portsmouth has traditionally been a city that celebrated its people's achievements, but documented by its naval dockyard, its history has often been a masculine one. But the women have always been there, and as my honourable friend from Aberdeen North said, we'd certainly notice if they weren't. Teachers, doctors, nurses, city councilors, factory and shop workers, small business owners, faith leaders and volunteers all pioneering equal rights at work and all quietly cracking on and holding their families and their communities together. They just didn't and often still don't get the recognition that they should deserve.

Some of you may notice that I often wear a necklace and it says Madame Deputy Speaker Pompey Bell. When I was teaching a group of girlfriends in the NUT and I began wearing them together partly in tribute to the women who during the first and second world war kept my city's heart beating whilst the men served abroad but also as a quiet reminder they were never facing things alone and that together we can achieve so much more. Now whenever I put on this necklace I feel like I'm carrying the support of those women with me. Women who are kind, intelligent, determined and women who get things done. These necklaces are also made by Hip Pip Hooray, a brilliant woman owned local business.

That's local creativity celebrating our women. To mark our city century, I'm proud to be joining forces with others, including my honorable friend from Horts of South, to launch the 100, a campaign to truly recognise the unsung amazing heroines of our city. 100 Pompey Bells who are the women who show up every single day, the women who don't seek the spotlight, but the women whom without Portsmouth simply would not function. These women, madam deputy speaker, are in all parts of my city and of all ages and of all backgrounds. I'm privileged to meet so many of them in this role as the Ports of North Member of Parliament.

I'm so often very humbled, many times reduced to tears, at all of the very proudness, the strength, the openness, the trust and the resilience that they demonstrate day after day, night after night, week after week. With this year's theme of Give to Gain, I want to give recognition to the absolute queens in my city because my city really does gain from them. Nominations will be open soon and I'd love to see as many local women as possible get involved. I'd love to see their friends, their families, their colleagues, their neighbours put their names forward because we know too often they will not do it themselves. So that we can celebrate them and all that they do.

From baking barriers and science to running food banks, teaching and coaching our children, caring for our most vulnerable, running our small and large businesses, and simply holding our communities together. Madam Deputy Speaker, Portsmouth women have always been extraordinary, and they've always been proud. So I'd like to place on record to every Pompey Bell in this house and beyond. Thank you for being you, for all you do for others and for our city.

06:29:53 - 06:36:20

Speaker 36

Amen. Madam deputy speaker, it's been an absolutely excellent debate with so many brilliant contributions, but there are three in particular I would just like to single out. The first is the honorable member for Gortland Denton on an absolutely brilliant maiden speech. I am sure she will continue to make many colourful and inspiring contributions in the years ahead in this place and it's always a joy to welcome another northern woman to this chamber. Also to my honourable friend, the member for Brent East, pick whatever lane she would like.

I will gladly follow. The more important thing is she keeps driving ahead. And the third one is to the member for Aberdeen North who reminds us that whatever our difference is, we always have more in common than that which divides us. Though, madam, deputy speaker, you were not here for, the member's remarks, she talked of strike action by women. I would just like to caution, please, the three deputy speakers not to go on strike because I really dread to think what would happen to this place, with the greatest respect to mister mister speaker.

I'd also like to put on record my thanks to Megan Red who is my senior caseworker, who, week in week out, strives to deliver great results and improve the lives of the people of Carlisle and who, in the last couple of weeks, has achieved the most remarkable outcome for one woman in Carlisle in particular. It's my privilege today on, in this International Women's Day debate to speak about another remarkable woman, an overlooked figure from the Victorian era, Angela Burdett Coutts, a woman whose compassion, generosity, and determination helped shape modern philanthropy, a woman who embodied give to gain. She was born on the 04/21/1814 in Piccadilly, the youngest daughter of sir Francis Burdett and Sophia Coutts. She inherited not only her family's name, but in 1837, she inherited her grandfather Thomas Coutts' immense banking fortune, making her one of the wealthiest women in England. Deeply influenced by leading social reformers including Charles Dickens with whom she collaborated for many years, Burdette Coutts dedicated her fortune to tackling poverty, education, and social injustice, earning her the name queen of the poor.

Her philanthropy was extraordinary in its breadth. She helped fund ragged schools, built model housing in the East End, developed Columbia Market to bring wholesome but affordable food to the poor. She co founded innovative projects such as the Urania Cottage, a home for vulnerable and homeless women seeking a new start in life. In 1884, she co founded the London Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children which later became the NSPCC. She championed the protection of animals becoming president of the Ladies Committee of the RSPCA and commissioned the commemorative statue and fountain to Greyfriars Bobby.

Her humanitarianism reached far beyond Britain endowing bishoprics in Cape Town, Adelaide and British Columbia. Back home, she funded drinking fountains and animal troughs right across London. She financed Charles Babbage's early computing efforts and she contributed significantly to hospitals and churches. I first came across her when I discovered she had funded the building of St Stephen's Church in Carlisle in 1864. Having learnt that the new Saint Stephen's Church in Westminster, just a stone's throw from this place, had been financed by Miss Bodette Coutts, the then Bishop of Carlisle wrote to her to inquire whether she would fund the building of a new church in one of Carlisle's poorest areas, Wapping.

Not only did she agree and personally select the stained glass for the church, she also gifted appeal of eight bells that were, on the church's demolition in the nineteen sixties, installed in the new Saint Elizabeth Church at Harrowby and where they remain to this day. In 1871, Queen Victoria recognized her immense contributions by granting her a peerage, making Baroness Burdette Coutts one of the few women of her era to receive such an honor in her own right. Like all female pioneers, she was unafraid to challenge convention. Possessing considerable wealth, she was beset by suitors. Many men proposed marriage to Miss Coots and she declined all of them.

She did however propose marriage to her friend and adviser, the Duke of Wellington when he was 79 and she was 33. He gently declined her but that was nothing to the scandal her eventual marriage caused. When she was 66 she married 29 year old American William Lehman Ashmead Bartlett. In doing so she not only caused an outrage in Victoria society but she triggered a clause in the will of her grandfather's second wife which stipulated that she must marry an Englishman and in doing so she lost much of her multi million pound fortune. Madam Deputy Speaker, since discovering Angela Coutts I have mused not just on how her stories like Angela's deserve to be more widely known but how we should celebrate the female philanthropists and change makers that did so much for people and wider society.

So in closing, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to invite you, the minister and indeed all colleagues from across the house to support not simply a statue or a plaque to female change makers, but to an audible celebration featuring the Coots bells from St Stephen's Church in Carlisle in a new national monument to the social change that women like Angela Badeck Coots and so many that we've heard about today have made possible.

06:36:21 - 06:36:22

Speaker 97

Josh Newbury.

06:36:22 - 06:36:22

Speaker 3

Thank you

06:36:22 - 06:38:53

Speaker 6

Madam Deputy Speaker. It is a pleasure to speak in today's phenomenal debate marking International Women's Day alongside so many remarkable women across this house including the Honourable Member for Gortmund Denton who I thought gave an inspiring main speech. Although she's no longer in her place, I particularly want to thank her for her words of solidarity for our trans community, including trans women who should never be forgotten in this discussion. I think it's appalling that the Honourable Lady has already experienced intimidation just for standing shoulder to shoulder with our trans siblings, but I hope she knows that many of us on all sides of the house will have her back on that. Now as a man I approach this debate with a little hesitance because I am acutely aware that the experiences being discussed today are not my own.

But I also remember how many women across this house contributed so thoughtfully to the day on International Men's Day. And it reminded me that progress on equality has never come from working across purposes to one another, but from working together. The women who shaped my life, particularly my mum and my sister, raised me not only to respect women but to champion them. To raise women up, to challenge barriers whenever we see them, and to take that responsibility seriously in the work that we do in this place. Since becoming a father to my daughter, these issues have taken an even deeper meaning for me.

When you look at the world through the eyes of your child, start to notice things that you might have taken for granted. My daughter's only six years old and yet I've already heard her say things like, I can't do that, it's a boy's job, and describe certain roles as ones that require you to be brave, an attribute that she associates with men. Now I can assure the house that my husband and I made sure that she knows exactly what she can do, which is any job she wants to, and that she is exceptionally brave herself. Hearing that from a six year old reminded me that despite the progress we celebrate on International Women's Day, the messages that children absorb about what women or girls can or can't do can still shape their ambitions from a very young age. As a parent and as a member of this house, that is something that I feel a responsibility to challenge.

Every girl in this country and beyond should grow up believing that her ambition is limited only by her talents and her determination. One issue that I want to touch on and it has been touched on by other honourable members is the perception of masculinity and how that shapes the experiences of both men and women. For a long time I've spoken about the challenges facing young men and boys but doing that should never be seen as being in opposition to championing women and girls. In fact, the two go hand in hand. If we want a healthier society, we have to address both sides of the equation.

06:38:53 - 06:38:54

Speaker 93

So I'll

06:38:54 - 06:38:54

Speaker 16

never give

06:38:54 - 06:38:55

Speaker 6

way? Absolutely.

06:38:56 - 06:39:23

Speaker 70

Member for giving way. He's made me remember something very important. When Sarah Everard was murdered and a number of us were lighting candles, I remember having a conversation with my son and daughter, where my daughter, who was 15, told her brother about all the times that she had been called and harassed on the street as a 15 year old. I absolutely agree that it is important that this isn't just about educating girls or boys it is about educating the human beings that we are raising. Does he agree?

06:39:24 - 06:41:24

Speaker 6

I completely agree with the honourable lady. I think that allyship across many different characteristics is essential. To me, I've always felt that anything that men can do to echo, raise up, as I said, the voices of women is incredibly powerful. It's something that we should very much take seriously and not shy away from in debates like this where we perhaps feel that our voice isn't as important. It absolutely can be.

Because too many men and boys today feel disillusioned with politics, with opportunity, and what positive masculinity can look like in modern Britain. That's a real issue and it deserves serious attention. But the answer to that challenge is not to exploit those frustrations by turning men against women. The answer is not to seek votes by weakening women's rights. Yet that is exactly the direction that some would take us.

For example, as we've heard, the reform candidate for the Gorton indented by election suggested that people without children should be taxed for it, placing pressure on women to have children. That misogynistic view of women's role in society should be rejected in the strongest terms. I am proud of everything this Labour government is championing for women, including on closing the gender pay gap. British women still earn 13% less than men. But the pay gap isn't just about numbers on a spreadsheet.

Large employers are required to publish gender pay gap data, but this alone won't close it. This isn't just fiscal, this is cultural. Thanks to the Employment Rights Act, employers will now have to publish clear action plans showing how they will close the gap and support women to progress. But before they even go into work, as my daughter has shown me, girls can already feel that there are things that aren't for them, certain ambitions that are out of reach. When we look at the history of opportunity in this country, we're reminded how much can change when assumptions and prejudices are challenged.

One of the most powerful examples of that is the work of Jenny Lee, who as well as being a true Pfeiffer, as noted by my humble friend, the member for Cardamith and Cocotte, was also one of my predecessors and an adopted sister of Canna. As minister for the arts in the nineteen sixties, Jenny championed the creation of the Open University,

06:41:24 - 06:41:25

Speaker 15

built on

06:41:25 - 06:42:58

Speaker 6

the belief that talent should not be limited by background, age or sex. The idea that someone could study for a university degree from their own home was dismissed by many as unrealistic, but Jenny believed that education should be open to anyone with the determination to learn. The result has been extraordinary. The Open University has educated millions of people across this country and beyond. Many of whom might otherwise have never had the opportunity to access higher education.

That legacy reminds us that expanding opportunity is not simply about access to education. It's also about expanding the horizons of what people believe is possible for themselves. The equality also depends on recognising the barriers that women still face in other areas of life. Women's health has been far too overlooked, with conditions like endometriosis taking years to diagnose and many women leaving the workforce because of untreated menopause symptoms. I'm proud this government is taking steps to tackle medical misogyny, from strengthening rights at work to improving support for conditions largely affecting women and expanding opportunity through education and childcare.

I will close by saying that according to a report published by the UN, women in 2022 could take close to three centuries before we can achieve full gender equality. That statistic should give us pause, but it should also strengthen our determination because progress does not happen by itself. It happens when we smash outdated assumptions and refuse to accept that inequality is inevitable. And if my daughter and millions of girls growing up across this country are to inherit a fairer society, that work is going to need all of us in this house to continue that effort.

06:42:59 - 06:43:16

Speaker 97

I know that the previous occupant of the chair did remind members that we need to be starting front bench speeches around half past four, so if I could ask the remaining members to keep their comments to around five minutes that would be very helpful. Apsarna Begum.

06:43:16 - 06:48:07

Speaker 86

You, madam. Thank I will do my very best to do so. I congratulate members for their contributions in the debate so far, and in particular, of course, the honorable member, Folk Gorton and Denton, for a very impassioned first speech about the rich traditions in her constituency of standing in unity and for humanity against attempts to divide. Madam deputy speaker, it's now also six years since I delivered my first speech in parliament during a similar debate on International Women's Day in which I pay tribute to our local history of women's struggles for social justice, which continue to be daily sources of inspiration. Today's debate comes as the cost of living crisis continues to foster a sense of injustice, uncertainty, anxiety across The UK, set against a brutal backdrop of more than a decade of conservative austerity and chronic underinvestment in public services, services which were left hollowed out and in many instances privatized by the last government.

The cost of living crisis has meant that women are more likely than men to lose their jobs or reduce reduce their paid work given that they are more frequently employed in sectors that have been directly disrupted by austerity measures and impacted by cuts and underinvestment in public services. Women, particularly black, Asian, and minority ethnic women continue to account for around two thirds of low earners and are more likely to be working on zero hour contracts or part time contracts as well. Ahead of the UN International Day to combat Islamophobia this weekend, I'm all too aware of how Muslim women are among the most economically disadvantaged faith group in The UK impacted by the prevalence of negative stereotypes, harassment, and hate crimes. Increased overlap of working and caring responsibilities has added to ongoing reality that caring continues to be a major factor in women's ability to participate on equal terms. Put simply, women still face structural economic inequality through their lives, and this intersects with other structures of inequality including race and disability.

We also know that violence against women, including trans women, continues to blight our society. I know personally that the impact impact of domestic abuse on physical on the physical and mental health of survivors can be devastating. Four years ago, I faced a reselection process in which numerous complaints were made about rule breaking and misogynistic intimidation, a process marred by the involvement of my ex husband and his associates. As many members of this house will be aware, I subsequently signed off sick from work. While activists and organizations in the domestic abuse sector expressed alarm at my treatment and my independent domestic violence advocate made representations on my behalf, the matter remains unresolved.

The post separation harassment, the institutional gaslighting and silence goes on silencing goes on and on. What I am reminded about my lived experience is that domestic abuse can impact people from all walks of life and in all forms of employment, including those of us in public life. To this day, I still have women reaching out from across the country in support. I'm continuing to work with members from across this house to call on all political parties to ensure that political representatives who are survivors of domestic abuse are not exposed to further harassment in their roles. I also continue to call and campaign for better protections in the workplace more widely from paid leave for domestic abuse to mandatory policies on domestic abuse in every workplace to eliminate domestic abuse in our society because domestic abuse requires a whole society approach.

And I'm entreated by today's announcements about a new unit to look into intimidation experienced during elections, given that my ex husband stood against me at the last general election with a stated aim of trying to set the record straight after everything that I had already endured. And I will look at ways in which I can contribute constructively in the government's work in this regard. Because this isn't just about me. No survivor of domestic abuse should be prevented from standing for office or staying in public life Here. Having flood abuse because they be or because they experience post separation harassment and because there is a need to ensure that this place sends the right message in our country.

In light of the Amandersen scandal, we need an independent statutory inquiry into all of Jeffrey Epstein's links to British institutions and figures, which I, along with over 70 members of this house, continue to call for. It's also why I believe we need an independent investigation into the activities of labor together. Madam deputy speaker, as chair of the all party parliamentary group on domestic abuse and violence, I'm delighted to be working with Biminzig to ensure that no survivor is left behind. As we approach the fifth anniversary of the landmark domestic abuse act 2021 next month, this could be this could not

06:48:07 - 06:48:07

Speaker 46

be more

06:48:07 - 06:49:38

Speaker 86

important because we know in the vogue sector that the weaponization of violence against women and girls by far right groups, and political parties such as reform harms survivors and ultimately impedes the real work of tackling the root causes of society wide violence to the detriment of women and girls. It's resulted in women fleeing persecution abroad facing even more danger here, including the targeting of them at hotels over the past year. The government has an ambition ambitious commitment to halve violence against women and girls in a decade, and our APPG welcomes measures in the VOG strategy to try and achieve it, including the overarching cross departmental approach and focus on prevention. The minister for safeguarding has positively engaged with us in this regard and is also delivering on other commitments. However, I am concerned about the government's wider program of austerity, real terms cuts to benefits, including the retention of the overall benefit cap, the freezing of the local housing alliance, and the continued injustice of the Waspie Williams lack of compensation and ongoing, assaults on civil liberties targeting those most of the well, those who are most at risk, minoritized and migrant women, including those from GRT communities.

I hope going forward that the government can address these areas in which migrant and minoritized women need our support. Thank you.

06:49:39 - 06:49:40

Speaker 97

Gavin Bonavier.

06:49:40 - 06:49:43

Speaker 30

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker that all of

06:49:43 - 06:52:54

Speaker 69

us in this house, women and men, would have been inspired by individual women both in and out of our own lives and I've certainly been inspired by many of the contributions made by women members today and I've been proud to be part minority that are listening and also contributing. And I'm proud to say that I've become who I am today because of many women in my own life and just three I just want to single out and pay tribute to. My own mum who brought me up despite many personal challenges in our family. Sister Bernadette in St. Joseph's Conference School in Malta who gave me the self discipline I hope I still have today and Patricia Hennessy who was an inspiring primary school teacher who helped me and so many others believe in ourselves and that is why I'm sure I am here today.

But I'm also proud to represent the Constitution that's produced so many great women that have not just inspired those around them but have made the weather, that have brought greater quality for women across the country. Every year I visit the grave of Lady Constance Lytton in Nebworth Park. She was a suffragette, came from a privileged background but took another name so that her privilege would not give her advantages. She was imprisoned, she was force fed, she carved V with a hairpin on her chest. V for votes for women.

Women got those votes but she soon lost her life and every year we pay tribute to her and all the women who gave up so much to get where we are today and we have so much more to go. But beyond that we have other women in Stephenedge who are still with us today. Barbara Follop, one of my predecessors. Very proud of our Barbara who helped found Labour Women's Network and I stand next to the Honourable member of Aarysen Tensmith who's been a stalwart there herself because Barbara helped lead the way and much of the composition of this house is down to her hard work. And she's not just that, she's improved the appearance of many of us in this house and I myself have been followed by Barbara.

So so I pay I give her a special thanks for that. And Baroness Sharon Taylor in in the other place, leader of Stephenwich County for sixteen years and now doing great things as a minister for this government, improving housing for so many people and housing is what gives women much better quality in their own lives. So these are trailblazers. But in my town as well we also have other women. We have our deputy leader Jeanette Thomas who again is leading the housing revolution in Stevenage.

We have our current mayor of Asian background councillor Nazmin Chaudhry who with grace and understanding exemplifies the best of women in Stephenidge. And finally I want to mention our youth mayor Charlotte Gregory who has been shadowing me this week in this place and she has also helped put these notes together for this speech. Not all of which I can use unfortunately.

06:52:55 - 06:52:55

Speaker 12

And I want to thank

06:52:55 - 06:53:44

Speaker 69

Charlotte for being an exemplar of the future of women in our town and our country. May there be many more like her to come. I won't talk about what this government is doing. It's doing great things. I'll let the minister set some of that out.

But I fully support our mission to halve violence against women and girls in the coming years. It's a lot of hard work. We gotta keep pushing it and I will support that all the way. I just want to end on one quick thing and that is this is not a zero sum game when we try to get equality for women. It's good for all of us.

Just it's good for men too. We all benefit from equality for women. So I will stop on that note so that so we can get to the end this debate. But so I'm proud to take partners in this debate I will fight for equality with every breath that I've got inside and outside this place. Point

06:53:45 - 06:53:48

Speaker 97

Doctor of Laurence Sullivan.

06:53:48 - 06:54:01

Speaker 90

I just want to make clear on the record that in my register of interest I am a visiting research scientist at Francis Crick, which is an unpaid position, but just to make it clear I forgot to mention it in my speech. Thank you.

06:54:02 - 06:54:09

Speaker 97

I thank the honourable member for her point of order. Her interests are now on the record. And a very quick speech from Calvin Bailey.

06:54:09 - 06:54:13

Speaker 11

Very quick speech. Said and Calvin Bailey said no one ever.

06:54:15 - 06:54:17

Speaker 37

In thank you. Thank you, madam.

06:54:19 - 06:57:45

Speaker 11

And that shows the influence that someone such as yourself would have over someone like me. In 2021, the Defence Select Committee published a landmark report on women in the armed forces, and one of the most consistent things that comes out about women that serve is their failure to is their feeling that they failed to be recognized in the public. Our veterans do not feel that society acknowledges them, and so the committee recommended that we on days like today, use things like International Women's Day to make sure that those voices and experiences are heard. Throughout my career, I've had the privilege to serve alongside some exceptional women. When I led humanitarian aid operations in The Philippines, I did so alongside master sergeant air crew Samantha Green.

When I delivered aid to the Yucidi women stranded on Mount Sinjar, it was flight lieutenant Abby Anderson that generated our beloved c one thirty j aircraft, and it was my very close friend Jen Bracewell, managing both me, as you have done so, madam deputy speaker, and the missions. And when I commanded a frontline squadron, I did so learning from the venerable wing commander Cas Viles, who's commander of the Royal Squadron, and I did so under the exceptional leadership of air marshal Soraya Marshall, who is without doubt one of the most outstanding military leaders of her generation. Despite the landmark case, in, landmark 1975 sex discrimination act, women continued to be excluded from frontline combat roles in the British Armed Forces until 2016. It was in fact, it was only when I entered the MOD in 2018 that all those restrictions were finally removed. We would have all seen over the last couple of days how, regardless of why they were there, a female F fifteen pilot was shot down over q eight, and we should all reflect that whilst, women are putting themselves, in the line of fire, there are people that are discharging them that are questioning whether their gender makes them suitable to do that job.

And that reflects the other five minutes of discussion that I would have gone on to discuss how these things are being challenged right at this very moment and that I call us all to make sure that those things are that we challenge them when we get given the opportunity to speak. It's important that although the services are recovering and the number of women in the service are improving, that we point to the disparities in treatment persist. Because while there are good stories, there remains challenge and inequities. I urge anyone that sees my very truncated speech to go and listen to the other wonderful speeches that we've heard today, including the maiden speech, which will all be very ably summarized in a moment. But the last thing I want to say is that I started by saying that this landmark piece of work was done by the Defence and Collegue Committee.

It's important therefore that I recognize Lucy, Eleanor, Innes, Tony and Corina who sit in the background, who tolerate the lights of myself and help us produce this incredible work. So thank you for them, thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I look forward to hearing the summation.

06:57:46 - 06:57:49

Speaker 17

So Joy Morrissey. With leave

06:57:49 - 07:01:00

Speaker 34

of the house, madam deputy speaker, it has been an excellent debate with some outstanding contributions. And congratulations to the member of Gordon and Denton on her maiden speech, which was significantly better than mine, madam deputy speaker. Her empathy, honesty, and generosity of spirit will serve her well in this place, and her genuine pride in Manchester could put even Andy Burnham to shame. And I want to thank the member for Northeast Hampshire for her excellent speech on FGM and raising this important issue. Also, we have South Derbyshire who raised miss, madam deputy speaker the excellent, idea of praising her staff, and I shall shamelessly copy that by also praising my, office manager, Alexandra Turner, and my senior caseworker, Mary Shaw.

Without these women, I would truly be lost. So thank you for bringing that, and thank you to all the women who serve as parliamentary staffers across the house. We would honestly be lost without them. I will go quickly. I've made I shall keep my comments to a very small minimum as I know that the minister would like to speak.

So I just want to say thank you so much for these for these incredible debates and and the incredible time and honesty that all members put in today. And I want to also thank the, Brent East MP who, her campaign for London mayor will, I'm sure, be a smashing success. I was the first female to make it to the final three for the London mayoralty for the Conservatives, and I would absolutely be terrified to stand against you. So I have no doubt that you will take up the space of London and do a fantastic job. And Aberdeen North, thank you for your contribution for standing up for young women and girls in online harms.

This is something that this member has continued to champion, not just in this debate, but throughout her time in parliament. And I want to talk about everyone and the member for Gower and child child sexual exploitation and really championing that issue was so important. I feel as if I'm doing all of you an injustice by cutting down my comments of which I have a plethora of short. But please know it was an incredible debate to watch all of you, and we do have more in common than we think. And with that, as we bring the debate to a close, you'll be happy to hear, it seems fitting to return to Nancy Astom.

And so I want to close with one of her greatest quotes. She once said, women are young at politics, but they are old at suffering. Soon, they will learn that through politics, they can prevent some kinds of suffering. We in this house have that chance for our women and girls. Let us take it.

Thank you. Minister

07:01:02 - 07:01:03

Speaker 97

Jess Phillips. Hear.

07:01:04 - 07:05:12

Speaker 95

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I'm gonna start my comments by first saying that, thank you to the minister, for equalities, for securing this debate in, government time. I think in the time that I've been in the house, this is only the second time that has, ever, happened. I'm incredibly proud to stand alongside her. I also want to say thank you to the opposition spokeswoman for the the tone in that was set throughout this debate and to everybody else who has followed that tone.

I have to say that I have felt tearful at lots of points. I don't know what's wrong with me. It's almost certainly something that the member for Hampstead and Highgate's mother would not be pleased for me to say. It is either both hope or anger or just that I have my period that makes me feel both tired and hopeful and angry in equal measure to the member from Aberdeen. If I get through this without crying, it will be a miracle.

So I just really want to say a massive thank you. Also, as others have done, I had assumed, actually, because sometimes I don't pay much attention, that this debate had actually been called by the member for Brent East who does that service, so, well, every year through the backbench, business committee, but it it it, in fact, was the government's doing. And, I thank her for her comments and agree that she would be I hope that she is a challenge to whoever she stands opposite. Of course, to the member for Gorton and Denton who made her maiden speech. When I made my maiden speech, I commented on what a sexist thing it was for it to be called a maiden speech, that I wasn't a maiden because my children were in the gallery.

So true to form, talking about my period and my lack of virginity, I shall continue. It was an absolute pleasure to listen to her. I shall put aside my Birmingham versus Manchester rivalry and say that she is very welcome here. And across this house, as I am definitely not going to repeat what I said to her when I first introduced myself to her, but it was a long you can paraphrase it without it being sweary. There there are lots of lovely people here regardless of which political parties people come from, and that when we work together, we are always strongest.

I wish that I could go through everybody's statements, but I do just want to highlight the member for Peniston and Stockbridge, a woman who I worked very, very closely with and gave me campaigns that we had worked on together gave me cause to cry earlier in the week. The only thing that I would say is that she ruined Bridgerton for me because I've only seen the first episode, and so for that I am irritated. However, she always speaks with such passion that who doesn't deserve love? I mean, that that is she rang out from the chamber. I would like to, pay tribute to the towering figures of the past that everybody has mentioned who have advanced the causes, of women's rights, but we have also all paid tribute to the women who, without fanfare and acclaim, support families and contribute to their communities every single day.

I personally could not cope without the women in my life propping me up and making me laugh and just noticing the stuff that needs noticing,

07:05:13 - 07:05:13

Speaker 46

and

07:05:13 - 07:16:59

Speaker 95

then people not noticing that how important that little act of love actually is. And so we have spoken of progress and of celebration, but we know that we have far to come. To the women of specifically, and there are many countries in the world I could highlight, but many members have highlighted the women of Afghanistan. And Iranian women have featured very heavily in this debate. I am the sister-in-law of a beautiful and now departed Iranian, woman who died of breast cancer but made her home in our country because her country was not safe for her, that the the bravery of the women who stand up to be counted in Afghanistan, and Iran currently should move every single one of us.

We don't want to come here on a Monday morning. Imagine the privilege, to be able to stand, and speak out in this place. But and now the the the reason I stand well, the reason I stood to be elected to parliament in the first place is that while we are gathered here in the heart of our democracy to discuss the these issues in comfort and in safety, beyond these walls in every part of our country, women and girls are suffering. They are being attacked, abused, harassed, and stalked at home, in public places, and online. The scale of violence against women and girls shames our society.

And today's debate is not a moment for detailed policy talk, so I won't do that. But I will say that I am proud to be part of a government that is tackling this as if it is the national emergency that it is, and, has been underscored by many people who have spoken about our commitment to halve violence against women and girls in a decade. But we know that words are not enough. Plenty has been promised and pledged in the past without results, and that is why our violence against women and girls strategy published in December had to be different. It has to deploy the full power of the state to deliver the change that is desperately needed.

And I wanted to take this up and, actually, it is just a piece of paper. It is just a document. And I have always said that when, it needs to be stretched, ambition needs to be stretched, then that is absolutely what it should be. And so I, with some pleasure for the brilliant women and campaigners, and credit to the domestic abuse commissioner, who have campaigned for, what I am about to say, which was not in the violence against women and girls strategy. And, before I take on the grim task of reading out the names of all the women who have been killed in the last year, I want to take this opportunity to commit the Home Office to funding and delivering the oversight mechanism for recommendations made in domestic homicide reviews.

We will put in place a system that strengthens accountability and ensures learning is consistently embedded across both local and national agencies. This is about turning lessons into action, not just letting those documents sit on a shelf in some local authority. And by doing so, we will drive meaningful change that is so desperately needed because those women's names aren't even they used to just be numbers, now they are names. Have to make a change to enable us to prevent any future horrific deaths. It has been a long and arduous struggle, I do believe that with drive and leadership, change will come.

Tragically, though, it will be too late for the victims whose lives have been ended by this scourge, I can never say that, scourge and their shattered families. And that brings me on to the task at hand. I will now read the names collated arduously every year for over a decade by the femicide census of the women who have allegedly been killed by men in the past year. They are Angela Chetty, Joanne Penny Michelle Egg Bailey Meletta Roseveer Carmenza Valencia Trudillo Rachel Dixon Claire Anderson Parmajit Kaur Claire Burns Sarah Reynolds Hain Ti Vu Rebecca Campbell Pariah Vesey Tracy Davies Pamela Munro Amy Pike Elizabeth Tamilor O'Dunzi Nenena Chima Katherine Perkins Margaret McGowan Ellen Cook Rachel Vaughan, Marjama Osman, Yajaria Castro Mendez, Miriam MacDonald, Mary Greene, Mandy Riley, Samantha Murphy, Isabella Knight, Christina Alexander, Annabelle Rook, Rianne Coulson, Nilani Nimalaraja, Irene Mabuga, Neela Patel, Sarah Montgomery Angela Botham Fortune Gomo Phyllis Daly Gwyneth Carter Stephanie Blundell Brenda Breed Vanessa White and her children James and Sarah Courtney Angus Nikiru Chima Kimberly Thompson Sharra Miller Paris Kendall Sophia Caton, Zawah Saleh Mukhtar, Nuwahulaj Dona, Nuroda Kalapani Niuuhuila Cheryl Wilkins Halina Hoisan Tia Langdon Nidata Bob Lina Sang June Bunyan, Michelle Thompson, Anne Green, Shelley Davis, Anjani Sundir, Catalina Burley Charisse Bailey Sonia Axelby Agnes Droskines Michelle Kennedy Angela Sheelis Stephanie Irons Dickazy Nurse Natalie Egan Colleen Westerman Katie Fox Laney Williams Lily Stirinova Zeeqing K Julie Wilson Maria Sakinu Lisa Smith, Janet Bowen, Samantha Lee, Lisa Marie Hopkins, Jilly Lively, Tanya Williams, Gloria De Lazari Victoria Hart Lisa Denton Vanessa Poulton Chander Helen Rundle Annam Ruffay Rita Rowley, Amal Roy Tan, Carla Maria Drozhewski, Helen Bird, Angela Clayton, Naomi MacGyver, Carolynne Baracluff, Jennifer Simmons, Ellie Flanagan.

Two women in their forties whose names have not yet been confirmed. And the final name on this year's list was a name, and this always happens every single year, is there is always a name that has to be written on because it comes in as I'm walking in to give you an idea of the regularity of this happening, and that is Carly Sohn. The following women whose names have not been read out in previous years are Lat Parks, Delia McInerney, Lucy Harrison, Leila Zaju Negana, Judith Law, Jane Riddle, Dawn Kerr, Victoria Adams, Simone Smith and Brigitte Rizuli. I am grateful to the women of the femicide census for making sure that the previously incomplete lists, because the information was not known, that those women can be remembered. I also want to take a moment to remember those who have died by suicide or in unexplained circumstances as a result of their abuses.

We commit to do more so that their names are also not forgotten and they outstrip the women on this list by some margin. We refuse to forget these women who all deserved so much more. I want to once again thank the femicide census for the tireless work that goes into collating these names every year. We find it difficult to listen to them, and they look through every single story. I express my profound gratitude for their work and the work that they do to raise awareness of women and girls who have been so tragically killed by men.

There is so much more that I could say in conclusion, but the list continues to speak for itself. I will finish by saying only this, may these women get the justice that they deserved, and may we honour them by preventing others from suffering the same fate. Thank you. The

07:17:02 - 07:17:14

Speaker 97

question is that this House has considered International Women's Day. As many as are of that say aye. Aye. To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.

The ayes have it.

07:17:15 - 07:17:18

Speaker 90

I beg to move that this house do now adjourn.

07:17:18 - 07:17:50

Speaker 97

The question is that this house do now adjourn, and I'll give the front benches a a few moments. Question is that this house do now adjourn. Brian Matthew.

07:17:51 - 07:18:04

Speaker 98

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I'm grateful, to open this debate on fire station closures and would like to begin by paying tribute to the bravery of firefighters across the country.

07:18:07 - 07:18:07

Speaker 1

I'll give

07:18:07 - 07:19:11

Speaker 16

away. It's I'm obliged. I I thank the honorable men for for giving way and securing this debate and paying tribute to the bravery of firefighters. As the member of parliament for Glasgow East, I wish to pay tribute to the brave firefighters in Glasgow who risked their lives to battle the fire on Union Street this past week, preventing casualties and saving Glasgow Central Station. This fire is absolutely devastating for the people who made their livelihoods and feed their families through working in that building which has now collapsed.

I wonder if the honourable gentleman shares my concern that in Scotland under the SMP, 1,250 firefighter posts have been cut since 2013 and high raise appliances critical for tackling fires like the one in Glasgow on Sunday, have been slashed from 26 to 16. And two were in Glasgow, and both were unavailable, it is understood on Sunday. I'm obliged.

07:19:13 - 07:25:31

Speaker 98

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And I take the points on well, and I think we should all think of of what happened in in Glasgow. So thank you for for raising that. I know that family family members of firefighters from Wiltshire, are here in the gallery today, and I thank them for coming. I know also firefighters from Dorset and Wiltshire who would also like to have been here, but as on call professionals, they are in their communities today ensuring coverage is in place, to mobilize if the call comes.

We owe them all a debt of gratitude. I've met with firefighters at a number of fire stations in Wiltshire. They're dedicated local people demonstrating real pride in place protecting their area. They have genuine concern about what these proposals mean for fire safety in rural communities. Madam deputy speaker, there is a consultation taking place on the closure of eight fire stations across Dorset and Wiltshire.

To put this in perspective, this is eight engines supported by nearly a 100 firefighting staff who keep communities like Bradford On Avon safe. The towers the town's fire station has served for generations, and the consequences of its closure would be profound. This is echoed across all eight stations listed for closure. These crow crews attended over 500 incidents per year ranging from house fires to flood response, road traffic collisions to river rescues, and these are the emergencies that make the headlines. But the everyday callouts are no less important to those in trouble.

They include freeing trapped livestock, assisting vulnerable residents stuck in their homes, and ensuring partner agencies know about any safeguarding risks. These stations act as natural points of emergency response coordination for events we hope will never happen, but for which they must always be prepared. Beyond the communities these stations serve, the closures will have an impact on the whole Dorset and Wiltshire service. More than 60% of incidents that crews from the eight stations attend are outside the station catchment area. My neighboring liberal democrat friend and colleague, the member for Chippenham, has written to me to say that she shares the concerns of the fire service and the many residents across Wiltshire who are worried about the impact of these closures on our community.

Last summer, firefighters from Bradford and Avon traveled 50 miles to tackle a large wildfire fire on Holt Heath in Dorset. The incident was a stark reminder of how our changing climate is adding to the burden on fire and rescue services. Wildflowers, flooding, and extreme weather are no longer once in a generation events. They're becoming part of the operational norm. In spite of massive flooding during storm Burt in my constituency and indeed in this year in Devon, Cornwall, and the East Midlands, fire services across the country received no specific funding for flood responses.

How can we therefore be contemplating such sweeping cuts to emergency response capacity and civil resilience when, in fact, more is required? Since my election, I've been in regular contact with Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Service leadership, and they've told me about the increasingly challenging funding environment. Since the merger in 2016, the service has had to find savings of over £15,000,000, which has led to a 15% reduction in firefighter posts and the withdrawal of second engines from five stations. While no one disputes the need to focus on value for money, the service is already recognized as outstanding for efficiency by the independent in inspectorate. The service's current operations are lean.

Ongoing modernization is keeping capabilities up to standard, but the obvious question looms of how any further cost pressures can be absorbed. The government's three year settlement has been welcomed to aid longer term planning. Indeed, the minister will be quick to point out that the government's 4.1% annual uplift over this period by allowing the fire authority to raise, council tax preset by £5 to offset the 19.5 percent decline in central government funding between '26, 2026 and 2029. However, at the core of this settlement is the treasury's assumption that the area's council take tax base, which is driven by new housing development, will increase by 1.57 annually. This forecast contrasts sharply with the past three years of actual growth, which have averaged at just 1%.

For the coming twenty twenty six to twenty twenty seven financial year, the figure is now confirmed at 0.9%, far below the treasury's projection, and it will remain as such for the following two years. And the result is a 1,270,000 annual disparity. The government's been clear the multiyear settlement is intended to provide greater certainty for local authorities to take sustainable long term decisions. The treasury's 4.1% uplift for Dorset and Wiltshire is welcome. The service is not asking for special treatment.

The request is that the means are available to achieve this funding uplift on the ground, not just in an optimistic treasury model. Please.

07:25:31 - 07:25:49

Speaker 18

I'm very grateful to my neighbor for allowing me to intervene briefly. He will know that our right honourable friend, the member for Salisbury, who's concerned about Wilton, has written to the minister to request a meeting and I did the same at prime minister's questions yesterday. I very much look forward to that meeting.

07:25:51 - 07:25:52

Speaker 95

Order.

07:25:53 - 07:25:56

Speaker 90

I beg to move that this House do now adjourn.

07:25:56 - 07:26:00

Speaker 97

The question is that this House do now adjourn. Does

07:26:02 - 07:26:34

Speaker 18

he agree with me that the issue here is easy to resolve? Because the conundrum that we're in is based upon an assessment by the Treasury which he has described which was over optimistic through nobody's particular fault but we can remedy this simply by allowance and flexibility in the precept and that would deal with the issue that has faced our wonderful fire and rescue service. I certainly join him in paying tribute to those wonderful people, particularly the volunteers who give freely their time to keep our constituents safe.

07:26:36 - 07:29:39

Speaker 98

I thank the right honorable member for for his comments and in fact, I'm going to go into some details on that now. Members across the house will recognize that rural fire services face different cost pressures compared to urban ones, and I do not believe rurality is adequately addressed in the current or previous funding formulae. That is a debate we must continue. But in the face of closures this summer, an urgent solution is required to safeguard our community fire service. If the government is not prepared to review its central funding, the only option on the table when the treasury's assumption are proven incorrect are station closures or additional precept for, flexibility for 2728 financial year to address short term funding pressures through local rather than additional central government funding.

Dorset and Wiltshire's current precept is below the national average for stand alone services, and a one off correction would bridge the funding gap while keeping the precept in line with that of neighboring services. In the consultation on closures, residents have been asked if they're willing to pay a little more for their fire and rescue service, and I would urge the minister to study these responses and to act on them. I can find no recent precedent for such a large number of fire stations being closed in one year, and with them, the loss of so many frontline jobs. Once a station is closed and its site sold, there is very little chance that it will be reinstated. The hit to emergency response times and community resilience is essentially irreversible.

For the average household, the fire precept amounts to less than £100 or £1.85 per week. For this, we receive what is arguably the most important insurance policy any of us can have, a well funded, well staffed, and well trained fire and rescue service ready to respond when the worst happens. All eight stations are staffed by on call firefighters, individuals who put their communities first, ready to pause their job and family life at a moment's notice, putting themselves at risk to help keep us safe. To my mind, the question is simple. The minister can do nothing, and the stations that have served our towns and villages for decades will close, or by allowing some adjustments and giving the authority the opportunity to raise the funding the the government says our Dorset and Wiltshire fire service should get via the precept.

These stations would thus remain open providing the emergency response, civil resilience, and capacity our communities will need in the years to come. Thank you.

07:29:40 - 07:29:41

Speaker 5

Edward Morella.

07:29:41 - 07:34:25

Speaker 19

Thank you very much, madam deputy speaker, and I'd like to congratulate my honorable friend, the member for Melcham And Divisors, for securing this important debate and also to thank both him and the minister for permission to speak in this debate. I am at danger of repeating many of the points that my colleague has already made, but they are important points, and this is an important issue. The proposals from Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Service would see the closure of eight on call state fire stations across Dorset and Wiltshire, including the stations of Chalmouth and Maiden Newton in my constituency of West Dorset. I recognize that the decision of outstation closures ultimately sits with the fire authority and not the minister. But when the pressure driving those decisions stems from central government funding settlements, it is only right that the government is held to account.

If approved in the coming weeks, these closures would remove 16% of the service's fire stations and lead to a loss of 72 firefighters. For many villages and towns these stations serve, they are the closest responders, and their loss would change the resilience of emergency coverage across our rural communities. The proposed closures have understandably caused deep concern amongst my constituents. I have met with the fire chief officer and the senior management, representative of the two firefighter unions and the station commanders of both Chalmouth and Maiden Newton. I've also received a huge number of emails and letters from residents who are rightfully worried about what these changes will mean for their safety and for the safety of the many visitors that come to West Dorset each year.

The firefighters who serve our communities do extraordinary work. The stations at Chalmouth and Maiden Newton, as well as the eight other stations, are staffed by on call firefighters, people who live and work locally, but are ready to leave their jobs and their families at a drop of a hat to respond to emergencies. They do so knowing they may be putting themselves in harm's way, and they do so to protect their neighbors. In West Dorset, they are often the first responders to road traffic collisions, particularly on dangerous rural roads like the A 35. They respond to wildfires and Heathfires during the summer months, which are becoming more and more frequent with temperature rises.

They assist during flooding incidents, something that our communities have experienced repeatedly in recent years, most recently during Storm Chandra. Since the merger that created Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Service in 2026, the service has had to find more than £15,000,000 in savings savings and is under real financial pressure. It has already resulted in a 15% reduction in firefighter posts and the removal of second fire engines from five stations. Under the so called long term funding settlement offered by this government, the authority has a revenue budget deficit of 1,200,000.0 in year one, 1,500,000.0 in year two, 1,700,000.0 in year three. Frankly, madam deputy speaker, I do not think funding settlement is the correct phrase.

The minister will mention the government's decision to allow fire authorities to raise council tax precept by £5 per year, which is said to produce an average of 4.1% annual increase. But, as has already been outlined, that does not tell the full story. Central government revenue support grant for Dorset and Wiltshire is projected to fall from 12,800,000 in 2026 to 10,300,000.0 by twenty eight-twenty nine, a reduction of nearly 20% in three years. The fair funding model has to date removed about 1,800,000.0 a year from the services budget. To put simply, madam deputy speaker, the government expects fire services to make up the shortfall the government has created through council tax increases.

In theory, 73% of the fire service funding is made up by council tax, business rates make up 11% and revenue support grants from central government only 16%. But the underlying assumptions do not work for our rural areas. Council tax revenue depends heavily on local population growth and housing development. In many rural areas including Dorset, the tax base is growing far more slowly than Treasury assumptions Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Service has already confirmed that its tax base growth is below the levels assumed in the funding settlement. At the same time, the services are facing rising costs that it cannot control.

Increases in employer natural insurance contributions, higher fuel costs, especially true with the current conflict in The Middle East, higher energy bills and rising contract costs, further compounded by the fact that the funding model does not account for rurality. All of this leaves the service in an increasingly vulnerable financial position.

07:34:27 - 07:34:27

Speaker 59

will of course.

07:34:28 - 07:34:57

Speaker 18

Frank Groveson, I agree with absolutely everything he has to say. However, will he agree with me that the only practical way of getting Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Service the funds they need to prevent the closure of these eight stations including Miriam, my constituency, is to allow for flexibility around the precept. Otherwise, sadly, they're going to close. The structural issues that he has cited of course need to be addressed They won't help in respect of the emergency that is now upon us.

07:34:58 - 07:37:34

Speaker 19

I thank the right hon. Gentleman for his intervention and I fully accept that an increase in the precept would be one option available to the government. But I would also like to challenge the government on the underlying assumptions in Treasury funding models, not least with the population forecast population growth, but also with the lack of rurality included in many of the funding models across the board, which, you know, we're talking about fire services today, but I could talk to rurality and funding for Dorset Police or Dorset NHS or any number of areas. The fact is is that rural Britain is repeatedly underserved when it comes to the Treasury funding model. The result is that stations like Chalmouth are now being considered for closure with neighboring stations such as Lyme Regis expected to cover larger areas without any additional resources.

If local stations close, travel distances will inevitably increase, which means longer response times for fires, road traffic collisions, flooding incidents, and other emergencies. 60% of incidents that cruise from the eight at risk stations attended are outside of the station catchment area. In critical, life threatening situations, small delays will have consequences. This is particularly concerning in West Dorset where the population increases by 42% during the summer months due to tourism. Our narrow country roads, the wider effect of rurality, seasonal visiting numbers, coastal geography all create travel difficulties not accounted for in the formula.

Time and again, it is rural communities that end up paying the price. There is currently consultation underway on the proposed closures and I, like many, urge all of my residents to make sure their voices are heard. But the reality is that the service is being pushed towards these decisions by the financial framework it has to operate within. Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Service has already lost one fifth of its workforce since 2010. Removing another 16% of stations would push the service even further.

I therefore asked the government to look carefully at whether the current funding settlement for fire and rescue services properly reflects the needs of rural and coastal areas, and whether the current funding is undoing years of underfunding or in reality compounding it. Madame deputy speaker, it is not hyperbole to say without proper funding we are putting people's lives at risk. I beg the minister and the treasury to meet with Dorset and Fire Service to review the underlying assumptions and reconsider this funding settlement.

07:37:35 - 07:37:36

Speaker 97

There.

07:37:37 - 07:41:23

Speaker 5

Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I'd like to thank the honorable member for Melksham and Devizes for raising this important issue and for setting out his concerns so clearly. I'd also like to acknowledge the firefighters who have attended today and welcome them to the chamber. I'm mindful that this is an issue significant concern to many, including those who've traveled here today and who feel passionate about this subject. The honorable member has quite understandably focused on proposals affecting his constituency, and I'll address the point points he's raised while noting there are, of course, as he acknowledges, limits to central government's involvement in local decisions.

First, let me be clear. Public safety is and always will be the main priority for this government. I want to place on record the government's deep appreciation for the dedication, professionalism, and courage shown every day by firefighters and the support staff who stand behind them. As the honorable member for Glasgow East has pointed out this afternoon, their work saves lives and provides reassurance to communities across the country as demonstrated in the fire near Glasgow Central Station on Sunday, which shows how much we depend on the bravery and rapid response of firefighters to safeguard lives and provide reassurance in moments of real danger. Members will appreciate that decisions on how fire and rescue services are organized including the numbers and locations of fire stations, appliance availability and crewing numbers are not decisions for the government.

I'm pleased that the honorable members recognize this and that they are rightly the responsibility of the local fire and rescue authority and its chief fire officer who are best placed to assess local needs and demands. All FRAs have a statutory duty to produce a community risk management plan in which they set out the key challenges and risks facing their communities and how they intend to mitigate them. Decisions on fire and rescue resources including how staff are best deployed and the location of fire stations matters for each FRA based on risks identified within local community risk management plans. Turning to fundings, after a decade of short term settlements, twenty twenty six-twenty seven marks a significant change as honourable members have recognised. It delivers the first multi year funding agreement for local government providing councils and FRAs with the stability and certainty required to plan ahead and invest for the long term.

Under this settlement, almost 1,950,000,000 in core spending power will be made available to standalone FRAs in England excluding North Yorkshire and Greater Manchester. That represents an average increase of 4.71% on twenty twenty five-twenty six levels rising to a total increase of 12.75 by the end of the multi year settlement period. In addition, since the provisional settlement, an extra £15,000,000 has been secured for fire and rescue services over the multi year settlement. This ensures a minimum uplift of 3.8% in core spending power in twenty twenty six-twenty seven for all standalone fire and rescue services with some benefiting from increases of more than 7%. Take yes, I will.

07:41:23 - 07:42:11

Speaker 18

To the minister, I welcome the multi year settlement and so does the Fire and Rescue Service. However, will she accept one of the problems with it is the assumptions on which government support is based, that is to say the growth of council tax, has no opportunity to be tweaked up or down because we're looking at a longer settlement period than was previously the case and that is precisely the problem that we face at the moment and the solution that is being offered is the preset flexibility that will allow that to be resolved and therefore keep our fire and rescue our fire stations open. So in a sense what we're talking about is an artifact, an unintended one, of the multi year settlement that needs to be resolved.

07:42:12 - 07:46:52

Speaker 5

Thank you to the right honourable gentleman for his points. I look forward to discussing them with him further as I'm no doubt going to be representing the prime minister in our meeting. What I would say that is that in in line with usual practice and in recognition of the views raised, the government will continue to keep its methodology under review when it's calculating the core spending power of local government for future years. So I will look forward to discussing it with him further. And I note the comments of members here today.

The Honourable Member raises the issue of funding pressures and as he's pointed out, Dorset and Wiltshire FRA will have access to 79 and a half million pounds in core spending power in 2627 as recognized a 4.1% increase compared to 2526. This does strengthen the FRA's ability to plan, invest and deliver for the communities it it serves. While the government sets the funding framework, decisions on how best to deploy these resources to meet core responsibilities does remain the responsibility of the FRA, ensuring a locally led response to local risk. I also want to pay particular tribute to our on call firefighters, individuals who base balance everyday lives, jobs, families, responsibilities with exceptional commitment of responding to emergencies. Whether attending a fire in a rural village or a major incident in a city center, their readiness and bravery command the respect of the whole house.

In many rural areas, on call firefighters are not just important, they're indispensable. These communities rely heavily on their presence, and I recognize their local knowledge and ability to respond rapidly. I firmly believe that the on call model is invaluable to the communities that it serves. While the government recognizes the challenges for services for whom on call is integral to their operating model, With innovative and strategic thinking, it can work and offer real resilience within fire services. With sustained collaboration between government, fire and rescue services, and fire and rescue authorities, there's a real opportunity to strengthen and revitalize the on work far workforce as part of a wider workforce strategy that sees on call treated and respected as the professionals that they truly are.

To support that work, the National Fire Chiefs Council has published detailed research into the sustainability of the retained duty system. This work's been shared with FRAs to inform future planning, improvement activity and local workforce strategies. The government continues to engage closely with the sector on this really important issue. More broadly, the government remains committed to a reform agenda, one that supports the sector to evolve, professionalize and thrive. I'm encouraged by the work of the ministerial advisory group for fire and rescue reform, which has brought together a wide range of voices to identify good practice and remove barriers to progress.

I do, however, recognize that the funding formula, as it stands, is out of date. We are working on reforming this for the next spending review period. In conclusion, madam deputy speaker, operational decisions must rightly remain with local FRAs. I note that the Dorset and Wiltshire Fire Authority, on which the honorable members party holds the majority, are cons are consulting on these proposals. The consultation runs until the May 15, so I would encourage all residents affected, firefighters and stakeholders to participate.

Meanwhile, this government will continue to support the sector with stable funding, a clear frame framework for reform both in terms of the role of the firefighter, the role of FRAs, and also in funding, as well as an unwavering commitment to public safety. We will stand with firefighters as they continue to protect our communities with professionalism and courage. I thank the honorable member once again for raising these important issues and look forward to working with members across the house to ensure our fire and rescue services remain resilient, responsive and equipped for the challenges ahead. Thank you, madam

07:46:52 - 07:47:03

Speaker 97

deputy speaker. The question is that this house do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion, aye. Aye. The ayes have it.

Order, order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.