Westminster Hall

13 October 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:20 - 00:28
Speaker 1
Order, order, and my apologies for my tardiness.  I now call Luke Akehurst to move the motion. 
00:28 - 01:28
Speaker 4
I beg to move that this House has considered police funding in the North East, and it's an honour to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Wishart.  I'm grateful to colleagues from across our region for coming here today so that we can speak with one voice about the need for greater resources to keep streets safe in our constituencies.  I first want to pay tribute to the police officers that serve our constituents in the North East of England and across the country.  Whatever political disagreements we will set out throughout this debate, I hope we can all agree that the men and women who put their own safety on the line to uphold law and order represent the very best of our country.  In bringing forward this debate, I want this place to focus on how we can best support those working day in, day out to protect us and to ensure they can do the best possible job for our communities. 

I know I won't be the only member in this room who's deeply disturbed to see the scenes emerging out of Cleveland earlier this year.  I pay tribute to PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough.  I give way. 
01:28 - 02:10
Speaker 3
I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for giving way.  I too would like to add my thoughts to the families of PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough.  Matthew was a coach at my son's football club and his loss and the loss of Tom have been felt very deeply across our region.  But their tragic deaths did not come out of the blue.  They were as a result of systematic underfunding. 

So does my right honourable friend agree with me that the funding formula has now become so perverse, so warped, so broken, that it now is inverse to the levels of crime we are seeing in our communities and the North East and Cleveland are losing out as a result? 
02:10 - 03:55
Speaker 4
I thank my honourable friend for his intervention and indeed his anticipated what the general frost of the remarks I'm going to make is going to be.  And I join him in paying tribute to PCs Matthew Blades and Tom Clough who lost their lives trying to protect the public.  Whilst the Labour government was right to provide an additional two million pounds for Cleveland Police in response, it struck me that the challenges facing Cleveland are not unique within the North East region.  They are challenges faced across the region, across the Durham, Cleveland and Northumbria police force areas.  Police numbers were cut in the years after 2010, public safety has therefore deteriorated and our constituents are paying the price. 

It terrifies me to think that communities like those I represent could ever face such a breakdown in law and order as occurred temporarily in Cleveland.  It drew me to ask the question, why was our region left so under-resourced that it became vulnerable to such pressures?  Sadly, I can only conclude the answer lies in an ideological choice by the Conservative Party during the 14 years in which it was in government, that places like North Durham were not deserving of the necessary police resources despite the severe social and economic challenges our community have faced, communities have faced following decades of deindustrialisation. 

Frankly, that decision should be regarded as nothing short of a national scandal, as I hope to demonstrate today, it has reduced safety, security and opportunity for the people of our region.  The numbers paint a damning picture of how badly the last Conservative government failed the North East of England.  Our three police forces all sit in the top four across England and Wales in terms of percentage reduction in police numbers between 2010 and 2024.  I will give way. 
03:55 - 04:47
Speaker 2
I thank the honourable gentleman for bringing this forward and I want to come along to support him in his claims and his demands along with his colleagues from the North East as well.  And unfortunately, I'm sorry to say that police underfunding is not just something that happens in the North East, it happens to us in Northern Ireland as well where our police numbers are down, where our funding is scarce.  But at the same time, in the last few months, in the last year, sorry, I should say, the PSNI have been able to detain and seize some half a million pounds worth of drugs.  But it does, I feel, and I think the honourable gentleman will probably agree with me, community policing, which I've a great believer in, I know the honourable gentleman has the same belief in it as well, will it suffer?  Because that's the front line of the police when it comes to the community and the face of the police. 

And does he feel when it comes to the minister's response that there must be a real emphasis and prioritise for community policing? 

04:47 - 16:06

Luke Akehurst

I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention and obviously I don't share his knowledge and expertise of the unique policing challenges in Northern Ireland, but I appreciate his support for us in the North East of England around this debate and appreciate the points that he's made about community policing. I don't believe it's a coincidence that over the same period of time that I just described, Durham, Cleveland and Northumbria recorded the three largest increases in crime, excluding fraud, of any police force areas in England and Wales. Today, County Durham still has 120 fewer police officers than it had in 2010, equating to 102 full-time roles. That's a decrease of 6.7%. Across the whole North East, 578 officers have been lost in the period since 2010, a fall of 7.8%.

In stark contrast, the areas that saw the greatest increase in police numbers were as follows: Surrey, Cambridgeshire, Bedfordshire, Hertfordshire, Norfolk, Thames Valley, all, if one was being cynical, all areas which during the period that the Conservative Party was in government, on the whole, had Conservative MPs and generally greater prosperity and lower levels of policing demand than many of the communities represented in this room. While across the country, officer numbers sit 1.5% higher than they were in 2010, the regional disparity regarding which communities benefited from increased police numbers is clear and has grown. This begs the question, why did successive Tory governments deem these places to be most deserving of frontline police presence? Why did politicians here in Westminster during that period decide that working-class families in North Durham were less deserving of police protection than people living in more prosperous areas with lower crime levels where police officer numbers were increased? To compare the demand different police forces face, we can look at the measure of police-recorded crime per officer.

In County Durham, in the year 2025-26, there were 42 recorded crimes per officer, much higher than the national average of 36. If our county received the same funding per recorded crime as the national average, we would be £29 million a year better funded. Not only are policing numbers on the ground lower than 2010, our area also faces more incidents requiring police time. During July 2026, Durham Constabulary received over 10,000 emergency 999 calls, an increase of 11% compared to the same month in the previous year. Demand remained high throughout the summer with crime-related incidents more than 14% above normal levels in August.

Anti-social behaviour related to off-road bikes and e-bikes and scooters poses another particular challenge in policing in County Durham.

I commend my honorable friend, the member for Darlington, who isn't able to be here today, but who has been campaigning on this issue over the last year, as have many other honorable members and right honorable members in the room, for all her work highlighting the support police officers in our area need to tackle this issue blighting our communities. Just last week, she was involved in or observed 70 illegal bikes and scooters being crushed that had been confiscated by Durham Constabulary. Police chiefs in our area tell me there were over a thousand more incidents each month over the summer than for the same period in 2025, representing two full days of additional demand each month. In particular, high levels of deprivation in our county translate to higher police demand related to mental health crises, drug or alcohol abuse, and cases of missing children. In the Durham and Northumbria police force areas, our officers face the especially challenging combination of some areas of the force area that have high levels of deprivation and others that are extremely rural.

It takes more money to police rural areas due to additional travel costs and the need to maintain smaller, less efficient police buildings. I hope the minister will set out what particular consideration has been given to the additional needs of police forces in rural areas which also have high levels of deprivation, and how the government is supporting them with the unique challenges this combination poses. Whilst our force in Durham has managed to maintain performance in responding to public requests for help despite these severe challenges, in other areas demand is affecting performance. According to our latest inspection, Durham had the highest rate of repeat domestic abuse incidents per thousand population of anywhere in England and Wales. Of 188 priority domestic abuse incidents, 119 did not meet the attendance target.

To me, that's shocking evidence of the scale of demand facing our police force and why it needs the resources to do more to protect vulnerable people and prevent abuse. Would the minister please set out what assessment the government has made of this particular problem and how it will ensure those experiencing domestic abuse in my constituency and across the region receive the same level of support as anywhere else in the country? My message to my North Durham constituents is this: I will not allow our area to be denied the support it needs and deserves from the state. A Labour government will always stand up for our area, and I look forward to hearing the minister set out how we are doing that just later on in this debate. Having told you what the numbers show, let me tell you what the impact of this is on typical constituents in North Durham.

For a family in Stanley, it means worrying about your children being the victims of anti-social behavior on their walk home from school. For a small business in Chester-le-Street Front Street, it means accepting that shoplifting is an inevitable cost of doing business. For a farmer near Lanchester, it means having no support in fending off perpetrators of agricultural crime, damaging or stealing your expensive machinery. For residents in Craghead, it means worrying that stretched police resources may prevent the prompt response and support they deserve when a crime occurs. The consequences of stretched policing resources were hammered home to me when I hosted a group of women and girls from the Just for Women centre in Stanley and St Bede's school in Lanchester in Parliament just last month.

In our discussion, the group highlighted their public safety concerns, recalling that they no longer feel safe walking home at night. The group was clear that rather than simply catching perpetrators when awful crimes happen, our priority should be preventing harm in the first place. I firmly believe that visible neighborhood policing has an important part to play in preventing violence against women and girls and helping women feel safe in their communities. I would appreciate if the minister could specifically reflect on the safety of women and girls in the North East of England in her remarks later, updating this House on efforts in our region to tackle the scourge of VAWG and any assessment that the government has made of the gendered impact of the previous policing cuts in our area.

Of course, policing isn't just about officers patrolling the streets in our neighborhood. When the worst happens, it's also important to have enough officers in a response team to deal with the fallout. But too often, police shortages have meant that when major incidents occur, officers are pulled off of neighborhood policing to respond, leaving our communities with a reduced police presence. Such support from neighborhood policing to response teams in County Durham was provided on 129 occasions just in August and 233 occasions in September of this year. So will the Minister set out the government's thinking on the balance between neighborhood policing and response teams, and particularly how she will ensure that when incidents do occur, the towns and villages in my constituency and across our region aren't stripped of their neighborhood policing?

I will now come to the rallying cry of this debate. As MPs from across the North East of England, we are here to call for more resources from central government to deal with the challenges our communities face. What we need is recognition that because of decisions by the last Tory governments, we are starting from a lower baseline of officer numbers than we should be. That's why I'm calling for ministers to deliver additional police numbers to the North East on top of what is already promised through the neighborhood policing guarantee, to reverse the cuts to policing in our area which have compromised our safety since 2010. I welcome the Labour government allowing Durham exceptional flexibility over our policing precept in order to avoid further avoidable cuts to our policing presence.

I commend our Police and Crime Commissioner Joy Allen for her consistent advocacy for policing across County Durham and Darlington and for taking the difficult decision to propose a modest precept increase to ensure residents were protected from crime and ASB. However, she's rightly pointed out that because our area has a low council tax base, the amount of money we can raise locally to invest in policing is very limited. About 70% of County Durham properties are in council tax bands A and B, and I note that I'm stood next to a proponent of reform of council tax for those reasons, whilst a 1% council tax increase generates 1.9 million pounds in Surrey, the same change in County Durham would only raise half a million pounds. The safety of my constituents shouldn't depend on the value of property in their postcode. In fact, it is areas like ours that need investment most desperately.

I know the Police Federation of England and Wales, which represents 145,000 serving officers, have highlighted the risk that reliance on council tax precepts risks a postcode lottery of funding. They've called for a long-term funding settlement which takes this into account. I therefore want to ask the Minister whether she thinks it is fair that local areas are expected to raise money for policing themselves when areas which have the least ability to raise the money are the same places that because of the levels of deprivation need the police presence most. In making this case, I'm optimistic that our Labour government has already shown that it cares about these issues and wants to deliver a fair settlement for the North East. Nationally, the Labour government has been robust in making the case for visible police presence on our streets to improve public safety, backed by a neighborhood policing guarantee to deliver a named police officer for every community.

Police funding is increasing, and after the unrest in Middlesbrough, the government acted swiftly and firmly to deliver more funding for Cleveland's police force. The Home Secretary has also committed to a wider review of the police funding formula to ensure fairness. Can the Minister confirm when this review will happen, if it will include consideration of incidents of crime and ASB, and whether we will see a real cash increase in funding for our North East police force areas within this Parliament? As the Minister responds, I urge her not to lose sight of the fact that the North East is still dealing with the consequences of years of disproportionate policing cuts. I hope she will be able to outline what role this context plays in the government's thinking on the fairness of the current formulas and how she is ensuring that this review properly takes into account the policing demand and lack of funding that our region so clearly presents.

Our constituents aren't asking for special treatment. What they demand is they are afforded the same level of protection that people elsewhere in the country are granted. The safety of a family in Stanley, in Chester-le-Street, in Annfield Plain, Sacriston, Pelton, South Moor or Craghead should matter to politicians just as much as anywhere else in the country. That is why the government must ensure a fair funding settlement which accounts for the challenges facing our communities to ensure policing that the public can have confidence in. Today we're sending a clear message.

The government must do more to ensure that policing in the North East of England is adequately funded to deliver for our constituents.

16:06 - 16:13

Peter Wishart

The question is that this House has considered police funding in the North East. Sharon Hodgson.

16:13 - 21:58

Sharon Hodgson

Thank you very much, Mr. Wishart. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today. And can I start by thanking my honourable friend the member for North Durham for securing this very important debate and setting out so clearly as he did the issues that have brought so many North East colleagues here to this debate today. And can I also start by thanking all who serve in our North East police forces for all they do to keep us all safe every day. Everyone, Mr. Wishart, has a right to feel safe and secure in their communities, especially in local areas such as our high streets, parks and town centres as well as in their homes.

However, time and time again constituents will tell me how anti-social behaviour such as theft and off-road bikes have caused chaos in our local communities, leaving my constituents feeling intimidated and unsafe. And I know the issue of illegal off-road and e-bikes is of particular concern to the member for North Durham. And I attended, I was very glad to have attended just last month a round table that he organised in his constituency held in the beautiful Beamish Museum with partners from policing, local government, the community, where we discussed these very issues. Now, the previous government considered many acts of criminality as low-level behaviour and failed to act. However, I know now how even small acts of anti-social behaviour can compound to severely damage how a community views itself.

Many feel as if the respect for law and order has simply disappeared, with bobbies on the beat becoming a rarer sight. Therefore, I support and do support this Labour government's Crime and Policing Act 2026, which is about taking back our streets, restoring respect for law and order and giving police the powers that they need to tackle crime and policing, providing support for victims of anti-social behaviour. And it takes stronger action against anti-social behaviour through the new respect orders, longer dispersal powers and tougher penalties for breaches of public spaces protection orders. And the government has also promised to rebuild neighbourhood policing through additional investment in officers and PCSOs, ensuring that every community has named contactable officers focused on tackling local crime and anti-social behaviour. And that's all good.

And I also pay tribute to Northumbria Police and Crime Commissioner Susan Dungworth and her predecessor, the now Mayor of the North East, Kim McGuinness, who have been excellent at tackling crime as well as identifying the root causes of crime, notwithstanding, as I said, the legacy left by the previous government. So despite our region including communities with some of the highest levels of deprivation and demand in England and Wales, the North East, as we've heard from my honourable friend in his opening speech, the North East police numbers have fallen by a shocking 8% since 2010 when the Conservatives and Lib Dems embarked upon their damaging programme of austerity. This translates to 578 fewer police officers in the North East, including a loss of 255 in Northumbria Police which serves my constituency.

Now, forces in wealthier areas can raise substantially more, as we've heard, through the police precept. North East forces cannot, however, due to lower property values and a far weaker tax base, therefore creating a greater reliance on central government. Northumbria Police in particular has the lowest police precept in England and Wales, meaning residents already contribute less through local taxation than any other area, with government grants making up 79% of the budget. Even where police and crime commissioners increase the precept by the maximum permitted amount, this financial yield generated is significantly lower than in forces with larger and more affluent tax bases. This contributes to Northumbria Police force having a budget that spends below average per head in England and Wales.

Northumbria spent in 2016-2017 £50 less per head than Merseyside Police and £147 less per head than London Metropolitan Police. Whilst I do not want to oversimplify the matter and I understand both of those other areas I mentioned face their own unique challenges, but how will our region ever gain parity economically without parity of security? And this is fundamentally an issue of fairness in my opinion. Communities should not receive less effective policing simply because they live in areas with lower property values. Future funding reforms should explicitly recognize deprivation, demand, and limited local revenue-raising capacity so as not to risk penalizing the very areas with the greatest policing needs.

So like many colleagues in this debate, I campaigned heavily at the last election on issues of anti-social behavior and I genuinely believe this government has shown that it is willing to act and I commend it for that. However, we must make sure that no one region of the country is left behind and I sincerely hope the Minister will consider these funding issues raised today. Thank you.

21:58 - 22:08

Peter Wishart

Order. If we all try to take about six minutes, everybody will get in sufficiently. I won't put a time limit on just now, but we'll see how we get on. I call Ian Lavery.

22:08 - 29:27

Ian Lavery

Thank you, Mr. Wishart. As ever, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I want to thank my honorable friend the member for North Durham for bringing this really, really important issue to the House. I think I would like to first of all pay tribute to PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough and also Jess Turnbull, three police officers who lost their life in the line of duty. Jess Turnbull, who was killed only two or three miles from where I live, lost her life. She was 18 years of age.

She had her life ahead of her. She joined the police force because she wanted to change the world and help people. And she died at the age, as I mentioned, the age of 18 on June the 8th. We should always remember the dangers the individual police officers and the members of the police force put themselves in in the normal course of their duty.

But Mr. Wishart, the previous speakers have set out in detail the scale of the the cuts faced by police forces across the North East. So I wouldn't want to intend to repeat the facts and the figures which have been precise and and excellent really. But I think it's fair to say that the years of Conservative austerity has had a devastating impact on policing in our region. Absolutely devastating. It shouldn't be forgotten that it went far beyond cuts to police budgets as well.

Austerity reached into every corner of public life. The CPS, the prisons, the probation service, mental health services, education and countless other services were cut to the very bone. As those services weakened, we had an issue whereby police officers were increasingly left to pick up the pieces, facing growing demand with ever-dwindling resources. And at the same time, crime itself has involved evolved. The digital revolution has brought enormous opportunities.

But you know what? The criminals have adapted just as well too. Police forces have been expected to tackle sophisticated online crime, combat the spread of misinformation and manage an ever-growing burden of statutory checks and administrative tasks, all without the resources required to meet those challenges. It's all about resources. It's all about financing.

Again, I want to place on record my sincere thanks to the police officers serving my Blyth and Ashington constituency. Just for the record, Mr. Wishart, Northumberland, my constituency, for those that are not aware, is cradled between the the Scottish border and North Tyneside. It's the political no-man's-land. I think ministers generally forget where we are and haven't really adapted in terms of the financing or the required police services that we desperately, desperately need. I feel sorry for some of these police officers who go to work day in, day out, facing the problems they've got in Ashington and Blyth and Bedlington and Newbiggin and Choppington, and basically because of the lack of financial resource and resources in general, face an uphill battle.

And I want to just mention Inspector Dawn Sykes and Inspector Wayne Daniels, who serve our communities with great professionalism and dedication under the the most unbelievable circumstances. I want to thank Northumbria's Police and Crime Commissioner Susan Dungworth, who has worked tirelessly to ensure that the priorities of local people remain at the heart of policing. But I want to focus the rest of my remarks on what budget constraints have meant for the communities I represent. South East Northumberland contains three of the county's four largest towns. Yet two of the largest towns now have no police station at all that members of the public can simply walk into and speak to an officer.

That's a direct consequence of funding pressures. So we've got two of the largest towns in Northumberland with no police stations, manned police stations at all. They're still there, police station, nobody in there. Nobody in there at all. And then the the situation gets worse.

The impact of the change in terms of the police stations is absolutely immense for the people in South East Northumberland. Can I give just a simple example? A constituent noticed that his neighbor's porch light had been on continuously for several days. Concerned for their welfare, he phoned 101 to request a welfare check. After waiting almost an hour for his call to be answered, he gave up and he went to Ashington police station in the center of the town in person.

When he arrived, he found a sign stating that the station was closed to the public with an arrow directing him to a telephone on the wall so he could ring 101 again. I mean, this is unreal. And it's something which is happening right throughout the country, by the way, the closure of major police stations in major towns right across the UK. You know, we rightly pride ourselves on a system of policing by consent, but we also rely on the goodwill and public spirit of people like my constituent. And after an experience like that, I suspect he might think again about taking similar action.

Earlier this year, the custody suite in Bedlington closed with the police citing funding constraints. That was another blow to local policing. Officers who make arrests in my patch must now transport detainees to Newcastle for processing, taking valuable police time and resources off the streets at critical times. We see that in my patch all too often. An already stretched police force is routinely called upon to respond to threats of the likes of...

29:27 - 29:32

Peter Wishart

Order. I'm hoping the honorable gentleman will be concluding his remarks so his regional colleagues get a chance to say a few words.

29:32 - 30:00

Ian Lavery

Thank you very much, Mr. Wishart. We see lots of things occurring due to lack of resourcing in my patch. We've got the mass motorbike riders, we've got the shoplifting, we've got the anti-social behavior, we've got county line drug dealing. It goes on and on and on. The police need the resources required to tackle not just those types of crimes, but basic crimes as well.

Thank you.

30:00 - 30:02

Peter Wishart

Luke Myer.

30:02 - 35:44

Luke Myer

Thank you, Mr. Wishart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I congratulate my honorable friend for securing this debate on such a critical issue for our region. And can I join him and colleagues in paying tribute to our two brave police officers in Cleveland, Tom Clough and Matthew Blaydes, who tragically lost their lives recently, and also to pay tribute to all of their colleagues and friends in our force, particularly Chief Constable Victoria Fuller, who's conducted herself with incredible professionalism in this difficult time, and all of the officers who deal with my office every day to report and tackle crime, including Inspector Neil Deluce and Inspector Ian Mitchell, who are the pinnacle of professionalism despite these challenging circumstances. Can I also take a moment to thank everyone who has supported our police force in recent weeks given what they've been going through, including the community. And the Chief Constable said to me recently that every single police station has been filled with gifts and cakes and cards for our officers.

There's been a huge outpouring of support from the public. And also, as she cannot speak in these kinds of debates, can I take a moment to recognize my constituency neighbor, the honorable member for Redcar, given this incident took place in her constituency and she has been engaged in all the same conversations and discussions I've been having, even if she isn't able to speak in this format.

Cleveland has a relatively small police force, but it suffers from some of the greatest demands in the country. We have some of the highest recorded crime rates in England and Wales, alongside severe deprivation, serious violence, organised crime, and immense pressure on public services. And yet our funding has failed to keep pace for well over a decade. I heard from my honourable friend earlier how the percentage change in FTE police officer numbers since 2010 shows the serious issues not only in Cleveland but across the North East. We're not able to use props in these kinds of debates, Mr Wishart, but if I get out the graph, it shows right at the bottom, in the bottom four, Cleveland and Durham and Northumbria suffering the worst cuts in the country.

The Chief Constable has said that they estimate that around 500 additional officers would be required in Cleveland to bring workloads closer to the national average. And that's just to catch up to the average, not to deal with the additional demands that we have in our region. Those pressures are being felt by frontline officers every single day, and Cleveland Police Federation has warned about unmanageable workloads with officers responding to traumatic incidents involving domestic abuse, serious violence, and vulnerable people. In my constituency, that means officers dealing with anti-social behaviour in places like Hemlington and Park End, illegal off-road bikes, as has been mentioned, in places like Eastside, and the very different challenges of policing our rural villages in East Cleveland as well. In Guisborough, our town has suffered from shoplifting on the high street, and I want to recognise the work that Councillor Bill Suthers has done to convene residents and police and the council to discuss what more can be done and to get results from that discussion.

At the same time, though, Cleveland has made real progress, and the force has come out of special measures and has been recognised for its improvements. Our officers are delivering results despite the pressures that they face, and this is nothing short of a miracle. So too are our councils delivering programs to support their work and tackle anti-social behaviour and crime, and I welcome the decision taken just this week by Mayor Chris Cooke to introduce new public space protection orders in places like Hemlington Lake to help address some of these issues. But the reality is stark, and the Chief Constable and the PCC have called for at least 20 million a year in additional funding to keep pace with demand. It is a clear and practical request backed by leaders across Cleveland and across party.

When the government takes forward its police funding reform, it must ensure that deprivation and crime rates and demand are properly recognised so that Cleveland finally receives the funding that reflects the challenges our officers face every single day. And so too can I mention the situation facing our fire brigade too, which faces very similar challenges, and the fire service funding formula also needs to change too. They have also lost a third of their full-time firefighter posts since 2010 and now face a 1.2 million funding gap ahead. So that funding formula also needs addressing. This is the legacy of austerity writ large in a region that desperately needs it.

So we need an urgent injection of funding now for our police and our fire brigade. We need particular focus on our region as police reforms progress, and special consideration made to accelerating those reforms in the North East region, perhaps a pilot program given the challenges that have been set out across the whole region. And we also need clarity on what will happen with PCC funding beyond 2028. My honourable friend mentioned the issues around domestic abuse. In our region, we have some fantastic organisations on Teesside, from Arch Teesside, My Sister's Place, Eva Women's Aid, Halo, and many others.

Many of them get their funding from police and crime commissioners, and they do not have clarity on what will happen after they are abolished. I would welcome some clarity on that from the Minister. But the message here today from me and from colleagues is that residents need to see safer streets again. They need proper neighbourhood community policing again, and that means our government backing our police force with the resources that it desperately needs.

35:44 - 35:51

Peter Wishart

We've got four speakers left and we've got 20 minutes, so strict five minutes please, and we'll make sure everybody gets in. Andy McDonald.

35:51 - 41:40

Andy McDonald

Thank you, Mr Wishart, and thanks to my friend from North Durham for securing this debate.

Let me start with a simple proposition. Cleveland Police can't be expected to tackle the highest levels of recorded crime in the country with the lowest levels of police resource. It's not fair on our officers, it's not fair on our communities, and it's not good enough. The figures are stark. Cleveland has around 123 recorded crimes per 1,000 people, the highest rate of any police force in England and Wales.

And Middlesbrough's got the highest recorded crime of any local authority area. And what's happened to police numbers? Since 2010, we've suffered the worst percentage reduction in full-time equivalent officers of any force, down 15% from 1,652 to just 1,405. That's 247 fewer officers at a time of such extraordinary demand. That's a disgraceful legacy of the party opposite.

Yet against that backdrop, Cleveland Police is still one of the most improved forces in the land, and I commend Chief Constable Victoria Fuller for that achievement. But it's now dealing with significant increases in recourse to prison. They've rocketed in recent times. Our officers are being asked to do more with less, confronting serious crime, anti-social behavior, and major incidents with a depleted workforce. The appalling A66 collision in August brought these pressures into sharp focus.

Seven lives lost, including two magnificent and brave Cleveland Police officers, PC Matthew Blaze and Tom Clough. I pay tribute to them, of course, and their families and colleagues who've continued to serve our communities in the most difficult of circumstances. And the incident also exposed the demands placed on a small force requiring mutual aid from other constabularies, and one that continues to be ravaged by the ongoing evil of organized crime. But the A66 has rightly brought Cleveland's resources and funding under renewed scrutiny. We must learn the lessons, but we must not pretend that this terrible incident created these problems.

The underlying pressures have been building for years. And I welcome the government's 2 million pounds in additional support. It's right that Cleveland receives help with exceptional demands. But let's be honest. A one-off 2 million pound payment isn't a permanent solution to a structural funding deficit.

The scale of the challenge is substantial. And in any event, when the mutual aid bill is already way north of 4 million pounds, as Matt Storey, our wonderful Police and Crime Commissioner said, 2 million pounds won't touch the sides. But with that mutual aid, Cleveland's delivered 100% of 999 calls answered within the prescribed period and has made massive inroads into clearing arrest warrants. But that mutual aid will end soon. Realistic and conservative estimates put the additional annual funding, as my honorable friend said, north of 24 million pounds per annum and recurring.

And I do welcome the government's commitment to review the police funding formula. But the published timetable concerns the review of police structures, and we have no firm date for a new funding formula to be implemented. Myself and my colleagues, including my honorable friend the member for Redcar, have said repeatedly, Cleveland can't be told to wait while Whitehall works through another lengthy process. The government itself has acknowledged that interim measures can be considered to better align funding with policing priorities, so I ask the minister directly, why not start with Cleveland?

I urge the Government to consider piloting a revised needs-based allocation for Cleveland in 2027-28, taking proper account of its exceptional crime rate, deprivation and depleted officer numbers, followed by a decision on additional recurring support. That's not going to preempt national reform. It would demonstrate that the Government understands the difference between a long-term plan and an immediate responsibility to keep people safe. We can't rebuild policing on the cheap, and we can't ask our communities to wait indefinitely for change. And that funding must deliver something people can see and feel in their daily lives: effective neighbourhood policing and the eradication of OCGs.

They want to feel safe walking home and raising their children. And I beg the Minister to hear the pleas of the bereaved families, who've let it be known that they want the legacy of PCs Tom Clough and Matthew Blage to be fairer funding and an equitable policing settlement for Cleveland. Minister, don't let their deaths be in vain. Their tragic loss has further galvanised and unified our community. And that's why restoring police capacity matters.

It's not simply about figures in a spreadsheet or allocations made in Whitehall. It's about having enough officers to prevent crime, respond when things go wrong, and build lasting relationships with the communities they serve. This Labour Government was elected to change things in Cleveland. In Cleveland, that means correcting an indefensible funding imbalance, rebuilding police capacity and putting officers back into our communities. The test is not what we announce in Westminster, it's what people see in the streets.

So, Mr. Wishart, I ask the Minister to come to Cleveland with a clear commitment, an urgent assessment of its needs, serious consideration of additional recurring funding and a needs-based pilot in 2027-28. The people of Cleveland have waited long enough. This Government must deliver visible change on the ground for our communities in Cleveland and across the North East. Thank you, Mr. Wishart.

41:40 - 41:41

Mary Kelly Foy.

41:41 - 47:16

Mary Foy

Thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Wishart, and I congratulate my neighbour, the honourable member for North Durham, for securing this debate. The consequences of what we see today, that we've heard already about our areas in the North East, come as no surprise. Generational deindustrialisation causing regional economic disparity, combined with austerity, deep cuts to public services, growing pressure on councils and community services have all taken their toll. And we are now seeing those consequences: higher levels of social need, anti-social behaviour, neighbourhood insecurity and addiction.

But our officers can often be left dealing with the symptoms of the challenges that begin long before criminality occurs. And the reality is that Durham Constabulary has had to manage a rising and increasingly complex demand while still operating with over a hundred fewer police officers than it had in 2010, despite officer numbers increasing nationally overall. And it's had a real impact on our communities. Only last week, I received an anonymous letter from a serving police officer outlining their concerns about neighbourhood policing. They told me that despite on paper neighbourhood teams seem adequately staffed, the reality on the ground is that these officers are routinely assigned to cover other duties, leaving PCSOs to cover the majority of neighbourhood work.

And alongside this, the nature of policing has changed dramatically. Officers today are not only dealing with traditional crime, they're responding to incidents involving online offending, child exploitation, safeguarding concerns, domestic abuse and mental health crisis.

Those issues require significant time and resources, but they're now a routine part of modern policing. And the result is that officers are dealing with huge workloads. In Durham, recorded crime per officer remains above the national average. And this has implications not only for the service provided to the public, but also for the wellbeing of officers and staff who continue to serve our communities with professionalism and dedication. Durham Police Federation has highlighted the pressures experienced by frontline officers.

They've spoken of officers working hard to meet demand, often at the expense of their own wellbeing and family life, while dealing with uncertainty created by short-term funding settlements. Now, we've already heard about the unfairness of forces with lower council tax bases, so I'll not repeat those facts. However, as discussions continue about the future structure and funding of policing, it's important that the experiences of North East police forces are fully understood. Any assessment of need must reflect not only population, but also deprivation, rurality, and vulnerability. County Durham contains both urban and rural communities, each with their own challenges, and those realities should be reflected in future considerations.

And we must listen to the views of our constituents, whose concerns at present often go unanswered for lengthy periods because there aren't enough officers to respond to the incidents. I met with Belmont Guides recently and heard how deeply anti-social behaviour and low-level crime impacts their local community. Whether that's balaclava-clad youths riding e-bikes, vandals damaging park equipment and green spaces, acts of animal cruelty, or intimidating behaviour as the evenings draw in, these are the issues that many of our communities are increasingly having to contend with. These young girls deserve to feel safe in their communities, but they see a distinct lack of police officers on the streets, and they want to know why that is. So I'd ask the Minister, how do I reassure these young people in Durham that our county will receive the additional police officers we so desperately need and deserve, so children feel safe enough to enjoy being out in the fresh air with their friends instead of being attached to electronic devices?

And it's not just young people. I regularly hear from elderly residents who are afraid to go out alone after dark, from women who have escaped abusive relationships only to find themselves being pursued again, from public transport users dealing with anti-social behaviour and violence at bus stations, and from shop workers and market traders who suffered repeatedly thefts while seeing little police presence on our streets. This is a real picture that I'm painting, and it is one that we ignore at our peril. And I think, as it's been said, the recent tragic events in the wider North East region has served as a reminder of the risks officers face in protecting the public, and our thoughts remain with those families. My constituents in Durham rightly expect an effective, visible, and responsive police service.

And as future decisions are made about police structure and funding, I sincerely hope that the experiences of forces and residents across the North East will be at the forefront of these discussions, because it's time a government listened to them, and I hope that it will be this Labour government.

47:16 - 47:17

Alan Strickland.

47:17 - 51:53

Alan David Strickland

Thank you, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Wishart. And can I thank my honourable friend the Member for North Durham for securing this crucial debate. And building on the really powerful speeches by other honourable members, there's really sort of three reasons I want to set out as a County Durham MP why this review of police funding is so important. The first is to recognise, as other colleagues have said, the additional costs of policing areas that are both semi-rural and post-industrial, like my constituency.

And that's because, chair, communities like the ones I'm proud to represent have a strong industrial heritage of coal mining and other industry, and it's often forgotten across the public sector that they are at the same time largely rural. 43% of the population of County Durham lives in rural areas, and my constituency is entirely villages and small towns. But these often aren't farming communities, they're former pit villages that still experience the serious scarring effects of major losses in employment and social infrastructure in the 70s and 80s, but at the same time significant geographical isolation. So given these issues have caused a growth in county lines, in organized crime, and other very serious issues, Durham Constabulary are dealing with complex problems across a sprawling county, which creates obvious policing challenges. So can I ask the minister to consider how police funding can better take into account this particular challenge of increasingly serious criminal issues you might expect in an urban area, but in rural settings which are much more expensive to police and where effective neighborhood policing, which can be important in preventing crime, is obviously more difficult.

The second reason, as colleagues have mentioned, are the real challenges, ongoing challenges of deprivation in County Durham without enough wider public sector support. And this is again something I think we need to see better reflected in funding. Durham Constabulary works in communities with families affected by higher levels of complex need, intergenerational unemployment, and poverty. For example, parts of Ferryhill in my constituency are in the top 1% of the most deprived communities in the country, half of children are on free school meals, and of course that brings significant challenges, social challenges, lack of opportunity, and with that, as we know, comes greater crime, criminal justice issues, and other problems. So as the member for North Durham rightly pointed out, this creates a dual challenge for the police in my area: more difficult issues to tackle while at the same time a higher number of households in the lowest council tax bands, reducing the funding available to pay for this.

And of course the complexity of some of the families Durham officers are working with can mean that officers are not just dealing with criminal justice matters, but have increasingly had to step in to fill gaps left by cuts to social services, mental health support, addiction services, homelessness services caused by the deep austerity cuts of the last Conservative government. So our police officers in Durham are to be congratulated for the myriad ways they step up every day to support residents. But the message should be clear, chair, that the police can't be expected to do everything. So it'd be great if the minister could set out how the Home Office can work with other departments across government to support more investment in family intervention projects, schemes to reduce youth reoffending, and other measures outside of policing which could reduce and prevent crime. My final point, chair, is about the growth in poorly regulated private landlords who too often are allowing crime and anti-social behavior by their tenants to go unchecked, and this again is creating more complex policing problems.

Can I in particular urge ministers across government to put more pressure on authorities like reform-led Durham County Council who are simply failing to act in many cases where irresponsible landlords are allowing their properties to become magnets for crime and disorder, often in previously quiet streets that had very low levels of crime. This is coming up again and again in my constituency. We know that council enforcement teams have got powers to tackle landlords who are refusing to take ASB seriously, but too often this simply isn't happening. Now I'm pleased to report to the minister, chair, that residents facing these serious incidents I've met recently have been incredibly complimentary about the police force who are responding quickly, but it's clear that the force is bearing significant costs which the wider public sector could be helping with more effectively.

So to finish Chair, I'd like to support the calls for the review of funding. I'd like to echo the thanks given by colleagues to all serving police officers. But let's see what we can do more to make sure that our brave men and women in uniform have the proper resources they need.

51:53 - 51:54

Lewis Atkinson.

51:54 - 58:16

Lewis Atkinson

Thank you Mr. Richard. It's a pleasure to serve in your chairmanship and I congratulate my honourable friend the member for North Durham on securing this really important debate. We've heard from colleagues representing constituencies covered by Northumbria, Durham and Cleveland forces about what a huge issue this is for the North East. And that's because our forces collectively and individually have been asked to do more with less for longer than anywhere else in the country. There is a clear case for the North East to be prioritised in the same way that for example Mission North East has for schools in the North East in responding to this challenge.

In my own force Northumbria between 2010 and 2019 central government funding fell by more than 31% in real terms. No force was hit harder. It lost a quarter of its officers. And we know that when budgets are cut it's the neighbourhood teams unfortunately that often go first. Today Northumbria has 255 fewer officers than in 2010.

As my honourable friend from North Durham said that was a political choice by the previous government that skewed funding formulas and completely ignored the need for deprivation and places like the North East to be policed appropriately. We know that demand is higher than elsewhere. On the ONS figures the North East records 98 crimes per thousand against 85 nationally, the highest of any region. In Sunderland we saw 27,000 recorded crimes last year which is down 3% but still above the national rate. But of course recorded crime only tells us a small amount of recorded crime isn't all crime.

It only shows what's reported. The ONS's own survey suggests that about a third of crimes people experience are reported to the police. The gap between what people live with and what they report itself tells us about the confidence in policing. And of course police deal with much more than crime. Mental health incidents in Northumbria have risen by 152% since 2017.

Demand that never shows up in any crime figures. As colleagues have I want to put my thanks to our officers because what the range of what we ask them to do is extraordinary. You know it was I think three weeks into being elected that officers placed themselves in harm's way in Sunderland city centre as thugs threw bricks and stones at them and they stood protecting our community and places of worship on that. Just two weeks ago we had a terrible tragedy on the River Wear in Sunderland and again it was police officers along with other emergency services responding not just doing the search and rescue and the investigation of the incident but liaising in the most difficult circumstances with the bereaved families. And every day officers are on our streets with people in crisis, tackling crime.

Now our constituents tell us that police visibility is crucially important. It's what constituents raise with me probably more than anything else. And when I've been out on walkabouts with officers in Hendon, in Pallion, in the city centre I see the response of the public to visible policing. You can see, you can sense that residents and shop workers feel safer, that people with potential troublemakers are potentially thinking twice, that people stop to talk and share intelligence with the police about what's going on. But of course too often residents don't see the police.

And when they don't see an officer, when they wait too long for a response to a call or an online report they stop reporting and they their trust and sense of security reduces.

So we need to boost visibility as a way of boosting confidence and reporting. Nowhere is that clearer than anti-social behavior. It's absolutely not low-level. It's drunken intoxicated behavior, whether it's e-bikes and off-road bikes around estates or parks, it's yobbish behavior. It wears our communities down night after night and it's not good enough.

So visible policing matters and that's why I welcome the government's decision to replace the previous head count target with a neighborhood policing target because a force Northumbria could hit the previous government's head count target and still not have on the ground policing in full in my constituency. Northumbria is adding 54 neighborhood posts by next March, which is a good first step. But those posts must be protected. We must have more and they must reach the estates and our villages, not just the city centers. Now in terms of reorganization, the government has talked about structural reform of the police and that going alongside funding formula reform.

I and I won't speak for colleagues, I'm open to reorganization, regional reorganization. We already of course have a Northeast serious organized crime unit that does effective work across our forces in that. You know where there are capabilities like firearms, potentially drones, we've seen a significant amount of mutual aid particularly in recent months following events in Cleveland and there is a reasonable case that going moving to a Northeast wide regional force if that's what the Hogan-Howe review recommends would strengthen resilience and potentially produce some efficiencies in those areas. But I think people will only accept a bigger force with two guarantees. The first is to ensure that local policing areas are strong and protected and that officers local officers still know Sunderland and they have a local commander that we can hold to account.

And secondly, crucially, funding reform. Merging three underfunded forces gives you one large underfunded force. We have to move the two together. So I finish by asking the minister a couple of questions. As she considers police force reorganization, would she consider if a Northeast force is proposed, if we can move faster than others in terms of the funding formula as others have?

That could be transformation funding as part of a move to a regional force if that is helpful to the Home Office and considered necessary. There is clearly a case for the Northeast to be treated differently on this.

58:16 - 58:22

Peter Wishart

Order, order, we have to move to the front bench spokespersons. Lib Dem spokesperson Max Wilkinson.

58:22 - 01:04:03

Max Wilkinson

Thank you Mr. Wishart, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I commend the member for North Durham for securing this debate today. I want to begin by putting on the record my party's thanks and admiration for our police service all up and down the country and the vital role that officers play in keeping our communities safe. The tragic A66 collision that claimed the lives of two police officers Matthew Blades and Tom Clough horrified us all. The disorder that followed in the days after this tragedy disturbed people far beyond the Northeast and we must hope it has brought renewed focus on the area's safety and I commend all of the MPs from the region who have spoken so powerfully with one voice in this debate today.

That disorder this summer underlines the importance of having a police service that is properly resourced, that is visible and is trusted by the communities that it serves. We have long called for a return to genuine community policing focused on preventing crime through policing that builds relationships with local communities. Just a few days ago I was in the Northeast in Peterlee to appear on a televised political panel debate and it was clear that crime was a real concern for residents in that area. Indeed it was one of the questions raised by the audience member who was asked to ask the first question. The audience spoke about the impact on their communities and the underlying causes including the fact that many of the communities have been hollowed out in terms of their economy over the last few decades.

What came across was a deep frustration and also, very sadly, a sense of helplessness from those in the room. Now, police presence must be part of the focus to address the concerns of residents across the North East. Under the Conservatives, Cleveland Police lost hundreds of officers, I think around 400. 200 officers after the disorder this summer needed to be drafted in to deal with the disorder that unfolded. This is not an acceptable state of affairs.

Now, we Liberal Democrats welcome the government's pledge to recruit 13,000 additional police officers, but police numbers sadly have not matched the government's ambition. If the government is serious about restoring neighborhood policing, it must get more officers back onto our streets and it will need to recruit many more. We cannot expect overstretched officers to do more with less, as others have mentioned. Too many crimes go unsolved, and these are the issues that we hear about regularly in relation to the North East, but also elsewhere, and they're the same issues that are common to so many places across the country. The government will tell us it has increased national police funding, but with reference to the North East, Cleveland's funding apparently is the lowest in the country, sorry, the funding increase is the lowest in the country, worth 1.65 million a year less than if it had received the 4.5% average.

On top of this, Cleveland Police are being asked to find 3.88 million of savings to balance their budget. Now, regardless of the regional issue, it is clear that policing must focus, must refocus on finding more resources and making the best of the resources that they do have. There is a real issue that a huge amount of police time is taken up by online crime, principally fraud, but others including child sexual exploitation and online violence against women and girls. And huge amounts of police time are now taken with, taken up by that, those issues. Unfortunately, it's the companies who facilitate this behavior who have not acted strongly to prevent this from happening, which is why the Liberal Democrats are calling for a new police agency to tackle serious online crime, funded by a levy on big tech and AI companies.

So will the minister today commit to taking steps to ensure that those companies that facilitate online crime are called to account and asked to pay for some of the problems that they create on a polluter pays basis? This indeed would help to redirect police resourcing to the front line and to build and maintain a physical policing presence that our communities can rightly expect. It would help restore a police counter in every community, giving people accessible, convenient places to share information and engage with the police within their communities. Now, the government talks about its neighborhood policing guarantee, but we now need to see change in our communities, and our proposals, we believe, can help. One other concern lies in police force reorganization.

If merging forces means officers become more distant from the communities they serve, or less able to respond to local crime, or indeed if three underfunded forces become one massive underfunded force, then the reforms will have failed. So will the minister ensure that police reform will not lead to resources being directed away from smaller communities, often in rural areas, to larger urban centers? This is particularly important for those rural communities that we've heard about today in this debate, where crime has become increasingly organized, increasingly serious, and increasingly persistent. Now, we are calling for a countryside copper guarantee with properly resourced, dedicated rural crime teams or specialists in every police force. So will the minister commit to ensuring that forces serving rural areas have the resources that they need?

And finally, Mr. Wishart, transferring police and crime commissioners' powers to mayors without sufficient democratic scrutiny risks replacing one flawed model with another. Local crime and police boards made up of local residents and representatives of the community can provide meaningful local accountability and oversight of policing. So is that being considered by ministers in their police reforms? This is vital because only by empowering communities to work with local police will we reduce crime across the country, including in the North East.

01:04:03 - 01:04:06

Peter Wishart

Shadow spokesperson Matt Vickers.

01:04:06 - 01:06:12

Matt Vickers

Thank you. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Wishart. I congratulate the member for North Durham for bringing this important debate today. I'd first like to reiterate my condolences to the family and friends of PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough. Their deaths have been a tragedy for the local force and their loss serves as a constant reminder of the risks our police officers face every day.

Alongside other members, I was privileged to attend their funerals and it was clear from everyone there how deeply they were loved by their families, respected by their colleagues, and valued by the communities that they served. The incidents that occurred after these deaths were a sad reflection of the problems that we face in the North East. Funding for our police forces is not an issue that should be taken lightly, as it clearly has a huge impact on their ability to operate effectively. As an MP from this region, representing an area served by a local force facing acute funding challenges, I share the concerns raised passionately by so many members today. As the minister will be aware, following the incident in Middlesbrough, I raised the issue of police funding in the North East, particularly my own area of Cleveland.

It's an issue I've raised on many, many occasions under this government and the last. While I appreciate the targeted funding announced in September, it is nowhere near enough to make a difference or solve the underlying problem. The member for Middlesbrough rightly points out this has been more than consumed by the costs following the incident. To give one example from the North East, Cleveland serves some of the most deprived communities in the country and faces exceptional levels of demand. In the year ending March 25, Cleveland had the highest recorded crime rate per head of population of any police force in England and Wales, 122.1 crimes per 1,000 people, compared with the national average of 87.2.

While anecdotes can only tell part of the story, we unfortunately see brazen criminal activity from off-road bikes to knife crime taking place without effective intervention.

01:06:12 - 01:06:35

Andy McDonald

Will the gentleman give way? I'm listening very attentively to what he's got to say. Does that picture that he paints cause him to reflect on the savage cuts to Cleveland Police under his party's stewardship that saw 500 officers lost to Cleveland Police during that period of time? Does he want to apologize for that error?

01:06:35 - 01:11:30

Matt Vickers

I always think that these things are better done, as has been done actually, with one voice fighting for more resource for our areas. But actually, I was elected in 2019. In the last workforce, Home Office workforce data shared in September 2019, there were 1,226 police officers in Cleveland. In March 24, there were 1,514. That's an increase of 288.

In the year to March this year, 2026, the Cleveland full-time equivalent police officers in Cleveland fell by 17. I'm going to carry on. Stockton's going to have its say as well as Middlesbrough. This week, police have had to impose Section 60 dispersal orders in Thornaby, in my constituency and the honorable member's, after a series of targeted incidents in which vehicles were driven into houses and two men were seriously assaulted with a knife.

Yet the funding formula does not adequately recognize those pressures. I want to be clear that although I speak as a shadow minister, this is not simply a party political point. The Labour Police and Crime Commissioner Matt Storey has warned of a 2.4 million pound funding shortfall, the equivalent of around 40 police officers. His argument, which the minister has heard many times, is that a system based too heavily on population fails to take sufficient account of deprivation, crime, and demand. The situation has been made worse by this government's decision to inflict the cost of national insurance increases on police forces while providing a woefully inadequate funding settlement.

The consequences of that decision are clear. While I recognize that areas such as Northumbria have seen an increase in officer numbers, the number of full-time equivalent officers in Cleveland fell by 17 between March 25 and March 26. The latest Home Office data shows that there are now fewer officers in place than there were in March 2024 under the previous government. Ministers will point to the neighborhood policing guarantee, and of course, we all want more visible local policing. But if overall officer numbers are falling while more are badged as neighborhood officers, they're being moved from somewhere else, often from response teams.

That means fewer officers available when someone dials 999, longer waits for victims, and less capacity to deal with exactly the kind of serious incidents we've seen in Thornaby this week. Given the scale of the challenges the force faces, which have been so clearly demonstrated, it seems preposterous that it is losing officers rather than gaining them. I appreciate that the funding formula is not easily resolved. Hardworking MPs from across the House representing areas disadvantaged under the existing rules have long pushed for change, including under the previous government. However, I hope the minister will accept that this issue requires action now.

The most recent arrests under Operation Artemis, including individuals connected to the events preceding the tragic incident on the A66, demonstrate the deep-rooted challenges facing the area. So what could we do immediately? I know the minister will reject this proposal, but the Conservative Party's costed 800 million pound plan to recruit 10,000 additional officers across the country would at least go some way to tackling this issue. Although recruiting more officers is not a complete solution, our proposal would help Cleveland Police by providing nearly 100 additional officers. The need is clear.

Despite all of this, the message from people living in our area is that they want to see this as a turning point. Their resilience shows that change is possible, but only if we give our communities the support they need alongside robust enforcement. That means increasing police numbers, as I've said, but also ensuring that repeat offenders face consequences for their crimes, including prison where appropriate. The early release scheme, which is proven to be an unmitigated failure, is undermining that. Offenses that should see people behind bars are simply not following through.

Yet because of the pressures on the criminal justice system, these offenders are not spending the time in prison that they should. Although this may not fall directly within the minister's portfolio, I hope she is pressing her colleagues every day for an end to the early release and for more police capacity. Without effective enforcement, the funding allocated to police forces will not be used as effectively as it should. Members present for today's debate know how easily the North East problems can be overlooked. As we approach the forthcoming police funding announcements, I hope the government will reflect on the events of a few months ago, on the words of North East MPs, and the need for meaningful improvement to police forces in our region.

Our brave frontline police officers deserve the resources they need to do their job, and our law-abiding residents deserve safe streets to go about their lives without fear.

01:11:30 - 01:11:33

Peter Wishart

Minister Sarah Jones.

01:11:33 - 01:17:15

Sarah Jones

Thank you, Mr. Rishat. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And can I congratulate my honorable friend, the member for North Durham, for securing this debate. Can I start where he started in paying tribute to our police officers and our police staff who work tirelessly in what can be incredibly difficult circumstances and who sometimes have to pay the ultimate price. Many, I think probably all of the members today paid tribute to PC Blades and PC Clough and PC Turnbull, all of whom have died this year and all of whom have been an incredible loss to their families, but also the policing community and their wider communities.

My honorable friend from Blyth talked about Jess and how young she was. I have met her father now a couple of times and he is also a police officer who had just retired when she became a police officer. And really that whole community has been devastated. What I would say is that what I saw at all three of those funerals was an entire community coming out to support policing, which was an incredibly powerful thing to see. And I know that there has been a struggle in terms of people's confidence in policing.

There are challenges that we are dealing with. But what I saw in those communities is a community supporting their police officers and giving them the respect that they deserve. What I would say secondly is that I have, I think, probably the best job in government. Working with policing is unbelievably a privilege and a joy to do. But standing here today and listening to honorable friends talk about the struggles that they are facing in their communities is very humbling and very difficult.

And I hear very loud and clear the message that you are all telling me. I have met since the A66 crash and the awful incidents that followed, I have met either with the Police and Crime Commissioner or the Chief Constable, I think five or six times since that point. And I have met with honorable members as well. And have heard, not least from my colleague in the Home Office who was mentioned already, the member for Redcar, have heard loud and clear the challenges that are being faced in your communities. And I want you to know that I hear those challenges.

And that is important to say. I just want to touch on a couple of sort of topics. I think the first one is the funding formula, because that's what everybody is leaning into a lot in this debate. The funding formula used to be determined according to lots of the measures that people have mentioned here today: deprivation rates, obviously levels of crime, rurality, ethnicity. There was a whole raft of indicators that went into a previous calculation of the police funding formula.

When the Conservatives began austerity, they took a decision to cut forces all by the same proportion.

So that was the point at which the relationship with all of the different factors that go into devising the funding formula was sort of cut. So it was still sort of there in that the proportions were increased or decreased in that case equally. But over time, obviously what was originally the funding formula has lost its meaning. And it has lost its connection to, in a real way, the factors that need to go into how you determine funding. We are reviewing that.

That is a process that I am spending a lot of time thinking about. It is complicated. We have to get it right. There are lots of different parts to it. So if people could imagine a graph where you have a crime type here, say violence against women and girls, and an indicator there, and you map all the parts of the country and you see what the line tells you.

So for example, violent crime, there is a link between violent crime and educational attainment. It is a clear, when you look at the graph, there's a clear link. So that has to be an indicator that is part of how you're working out your funding formula. So there is a lot of work that has to go into that. There is a lot of work that goes not just into crime types, but the things that police do.

So police spend more than 50% of their time not dealing with crime. They're dealing with missing people, people with mental health problems. They are they are doing things that aren't what you would perceive as being a crime type. We have to think about those. And then we have to think about, an honourable member's mentioned this, the relationship with council tax and and the precept and and what's fair and what's not.

01:17:15 - 01:17:32

Speaker 43

And we've seen our colleagues in MHCLG go through that process to the advantage of some and the disadvantages of others. There is always winners and losers in a funding formula review. But this is a complicated process. And... Yes.

01:17:32 - 01:18:33

Andy McDonald

I appreciate it's a complicated process. But the graph that she's seen, I'm sure, showing the changes in full-time equivalents between 2010 and 2025 are stark. And there's a political bias built into that. It's and the urgency that underpins what we are saying from these benches is that that needs to be corrected. It's an inequitable, unfair formula that visits badly on the constituencies in the North East of England.

And it's that that needs attention. And really, we cannot wait for months and months of recalibrating the formula to come up with a better answer. The need is now. And the one point I'll agree with the shadow minister opposite, if we carry on as we are, we're going to be losing more officers in Cleveland. So the need is urgent.

It isn't a matter for months. It's it's days we've got to do this. And if she needs any further information from Victoria Fuller, the Chief Constable of Cleveland, I'm sure it can be provided. But we need that progress immediately.

01:18:33 - 01:19:47

Sarah Jones

Can I thank him for his intervention? We've obviously had several conversations on this in recent times. And of course I've talked to Victoria and I'm well aware of all the statistics and I understand what he's saying. What I'm saying is we are reviewing the funding formula. We will do that and it will be fair.

When it comes to the funding for this year as we're as we're coming, that is not going to be under the new funding formula. That is going to be allocated. We are at the moment going through a process which the Chief Constable is party to and Matt Storey is party to and all of the chiefs and all of the PCCs across England and Wales, where they can come to us while we allocate what the funding will be for next year and they will say, here is our exceptional financial situation, here are the exceptional circumstances that we are in. And of course we are having those conversations with colleagues across the North East. Of course we are, as everybody here would expect.

So whilst the funding formula will come with the reforms, we are looking right now at the exceptional funding requests that people are making across the country and what we will do about those things. So that was the second thing that I wanted to say is that there is a process. We are looking at the funding for the next financial year, for the next funding year, as well as reforming the funding formula, which will come later. Yeah.

01:19:47 - 01:20:27

Luke Myer

I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. I do welcome the commitment to changing the funding formula. That is genuinely a seismic change. The point that my honorable friend is making is that we cannot really wait. We've already had this government in for two years.

There's another what, two years until PCCs are abolished. We're encountering these incidents every single day. Last year, Norfolk had 20,000 fewer crimes than Cleveland but received 50 million pounds more in funding. That cannot be justified. It's unfair and it's un-Labour.

And so I would urge the minister to look at what can be done in-year and also look at the proposal to accelerate reforms when it comes to the North East in particular.

01:20:27 - 01:23:56

Sarah Jones

Can I thank him for that question. My point about looking at the funding for this coming year is exactly that. We are doing that. We are looking at what is the exceptional circumstances of police forces across the country right now and what do we need to do about that. I wanted to touch on police reform.

Some people have mentioned it. I'll do it very briefly. The point of police reform is to do two things. One is to make sure our police are equipped to tackle the epidemic of everyday crime we see in our communities. And the second is to make sure we are equipped to tackle the changing nature of crime.

Most crimes have a digital footprint. Serious organized crime doesn't pay any attention to boundaries and is much more complex than it used to be. People have mentioned online sexual abuse, for example, the complex crimes that we need to be able to tackle. That is the point of police reform. We don't have the time now for me to set out how we are going to achieve the changes that we're going to achieve, but the police reform program, we are going to legislate on that in this session and we will introduce changes which will change the structures of police forces, which will mean that the way that the funding formula works has to fit with those structural changes as well.

We are also putting more police in our neighborhoods and this is very important. And I just want to make one final point, which is hard to make in a short space of time, but we have had lots of conversations, which I understand and appreciate and don't disagree with, on police numbers. But you cannot just judge a police force on police numbers. It doesn't work. When the Tories were in, they cut police funding by, cut police numbers by 20,000.

They then rushed to recruit another 20,000 and actually the arrest rates went down because we have 12,000 officers who are sat behind desks. They are not out in our communities fighting crime. We've had no investment over the Tory years in technology, which means that you, I'm sure honorable members will find this the same whenever they go out with the police, everybody has to spend hours and hours and hours filling in forms, doing the bureaucracy. If you can cut that, people have more time to be more productive. If you can get police out from behind desks into our communities, you can be more productive.

I am not denying the point that honorable members make about police numbers, but that is not the only, if we measure just police numbers, that doesn't actually reflect what the police do and how they do it. I won't give way because I only have a couple of moments left. So we are tilting our resources into neighborhood policing. We have got just shy of 4,000 extra police into our communities. I just want to end by paying tribute to the honorable member.

He asked me a series of questions, which I have here a list of answers in terms of how we are particularly supporting VORG. He asked about in the North East and other honorable members asked questions about antisocial behavior.

They asked questions about online, about the early release scheme. I am very happy to meet and talk to other members again because we don't have the time here. But can I assure honorable members I hear, and the government hears, what your case is on the North East. We are with you in our desire to reform policing, to make sure we've got the people that we need to fight the crime so that your communities can feel safe, which is the very least that a Labour government ought to be able to deliver for them.

01:23:56 - 01:24:01

Peter Wishart

The honorable member's got about a minute to wind up if he wants to use that time.

01:24:01 - 01:24:50

Luke Akehurst

Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm grateful to the Minister for her remarks and for getting to the crux of this matter, which is that the funding formula was kind of ripped up under the previous government. I'm grateful to the shadow ministers for at least understanding what the problem is in terms of low levels of funding in the North East. But I kind of regret that they weren't able to bring themselves to explain that it was conservative governments and a coalition government, including the Lib Dems, that actually did that ripping up of the funding formula. And I'm very grateful to all my honorable friends on this side of the house for the eloquent way in which they've expressed the extreme pressures that policing is under in the communities that they represent, and some of the indeed tragic events that have happened partly due to that pressure.

01:24:50 - 01:24:56

Speaker 36

And with that, I'm conscious of the need that I need to sit down before the turn of the hour.

01:24:56 - 01:26:13

Peter Wishart

The question is that this house has considered police funding in the North East. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order.

And if honorable members can leave the chamber efficiently and quickly. Order. I will call Bradley Thomas to move the motion and I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission from the member in charge of the debate and the Minister. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up as this is convention for 30-minute debates.

Order, order. Bradley Thomas to move the motion.

01:26:13 - 01:29:34

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Mr. Whissart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. So, BREP, the Bromsgrove Route Enhancement Programme. This is quite a niche topic for Westminster Hall. And there's a reason why I'm here.

It's because Bromsgrove is suffering under the chaos that is the BREP scheme and the mismanagement and chaos around how it's being delivered. A bit of background. Bromsgrove is a busy town. It's a commuter town in the West Midlands with two motorways running through it. We've got the M42 and the M5.

And this is crucial for context because particularly when the M5 is congested, snarled up, the A38 running through Bromsgrove, the route that the BREP program is concerned with, becomes a pressure relief valve for the M5 and as a result Bromsgrove suffers additional congestion once all of that traffic is displaced from the motorway and running around the town. Now, I would argue that that means that the A38 running through Bromsgrove is a part of our key national infrastructure given the role that it plays in alleviating pressure on the M5. So Bromsgrove is currently seeing investment to the tune of tens of millions of pounds on this BREP project. But the reality is it's delivering really acute disruption to the local economy, to local businesses, schools, and residents. Now, any road project that is being delivered will inevitably bring some degree of disruption.

The folk of Bromsgrove are reasonable. They expect that when investment takes place, there will be disruption, but I'm afraid the scale of disruption that we've seen is beyond anything envisaged by those living and working in the town. But I think more crucially, it's beyond anything that Worcestershire County Council appear to be acknowledging, either in their engagement with me or with local residents. Now, accepting that work has to take place doesn't mean accepting endless delays, lack of accountability, poor communication, and date slipping, because these are the characteristics that we've seen associated with the BREP works. Now, the impact is profound.

We've got safety concerns. Losses for businesses are particularly profound. I routinely meet and speak with businesses that are quoting BREP and the compounded effect of roadworks in Bromsgrove as the reason, one of the reasons why their businesses are suffering. And I note that whenever the BBC or ITV or media outlets have been out and about speaking to local businesses, the congestion, whether that's from BREP and the compounded effect of other roadworks, are routinely quoted as reasons behind this. And as a result of this, well, I think the reality is there is a severe reputational impact to Bromsgrove at the moment as a town that should have a vibrant economy given its location, given the relative affluence of the hinterland, and given the connectivity that the town had previously benefited from and enjoyed.

01:29:34 - 01:29:36

Speaker 37

So I will give way.

01:29:36 - 01:30:13

Jim Shannon

Can I commend my honorable friend? He's absolutely right to bring this forward. When millions of pounds of public money are committed to corridor schemes like the Bromsgrove Route Enhancement, we need stricter oversight to prevent administrative paralysis. We have the very same thing happened to us in Northern Ireland, Mr. Chairman. The Court of Appeal had to step in to greenlight the 1.7 billion pound A5 upgrade, a vital project trapped for 20 years in a web of legal and bureaucratic challenges.

Is it not time that government ensured that when infrastructure funding is approved, red tape does not stand in the way of safety, of economic growth, and local commuters?

01:30:13 - 01:31:28

Anthony Bradley Thomas

I thank the honorable member for his contribution, and I feel that his presence vindicates my, vindicates my debate, not because of the worthiness of the point, but because the honorable member himself has come into a debate about something in Bromsgrove. But he's correct, and I will touch upon this point shortly in my remarks. So the impact of the BREP works in Bromsgrove, they are profound. There are safety concerns. There are the losses for business that I've spoken about, endless delays for routine trips, and the reputational impact and damage to the town that I've mentioned.

So think about it. Who do we have going about their lives in any town? You've got parents wanting to take their children to school. You've got workers driving to work. We've got businesses reliant upon deliveries, upon trades.

You've got carers. You've got people going about their life needing to get to appointments, GPs, hospitals. And I read a statistic that the average UK driver spends 62 hours per year stuck in traffic. Well, I can tell anyone who wants to listen that I can guarantee it will be a hell of a lot more in Bromsgrove because of the BREP roadworks. I will give way.

01:31:28 - 01:32:00

Speaker 38

Can I thank my honorable friend and next-door neighbor for raising this incredibly important point? When he talks about the problems in Bromsgrove, he's speaking to a wider problem in the whole of Worcestershire and indeed the West Midlands. And he'll be well aware that in Stourport, in the neighboring constituency of Wyre Forest, we have huge problems with the Stourport and people trying to get through the town or actually wanting to be in the town.

And that actually the government needs to step up with some major road improvements, including a Stourport relief road and a new bridge over the River Severn.

01:32:00 - 01:45:39

Anthony Bradley Thomas

I thank my honourable friend for his contribution and constituency neighbour. He's absolutely right. All of our constituencies deserve investment, but the crux of the story here that I hope will become apparent as I go through my remarks is that when infrastructure is delivered, it has to be delivered in a way that's consultative with local people, local businesses, and we can't allow the fragmentation of the state to paralyze the delivery of infrastructure projects that are so essential to our prosperity. Coming back to my remarks, Chairman, we've got businesses in Bromsgrove that are struggling. They're struggling under the current economic climate regardless of BREP and the compounded effects of the roadworks, but this is particularly acute in Bromsgrove.

And I know from speaking to so many residents and businesses that there is a general sentiment that those responsible for the scheme, and it's important to note that Worcestershire County Council is the body responsible for delivering the scheme even though this is backed by tens of millions of pounds of central government funding, there is this perception that those delivering the scheme do not care or are not listening to the voices of those who are affected. And I fear that it will take a large amount of time to be elapsed before the reputation of Bromsgrove recovers once these works are eventually completed. 83% of businesses nationally claim that congestion is a problem. I can guarantee in Bromsgrove it will be 100% of businesses. And 41% of businesses nationally claim that their profitability is affected by Bromsgrove.

Again, I can guarantee practically every business in the town will be citing BREP and the compounded effect of roadworks as one of the reasons why they are struggling in an already difficult economic climate. Now, it should not be an abstract for any of us to believe that it's the responsibility of the state in all of its forms, central government, local authorities, government agencies, to do everything possible to ease the burden of the effect of roadworks in our communities. And I'm afraid with Worcestershire County Council, I'm kind of bewildered really. I've had a reasonable amount of engagement with the County Council over this project, but it feels incredibly tokenistic. I've had meetings with them to discuss different schemes, different, sorry, different portions of the project, different phases of the project that are being delivered.

At times in the past, I've had meetings with them with residents to discuss specific concerns about particular parts of the project, but I'm afraid the responses are only ever tokenistic. We're getting responses such as, you know, we have consulted, we've engaged. And I'm afraid part of my conclusion can only be that some of those responsible for delivering the scheme, whether that's contractors, whether that's officers of the council, I suspect their lives aren't as affected by the scheme, perhaps because they don't live in Bromsgrove, they may not travel through the town.

I fear that those taking decisions, whether it's on this or on other aspects of investment, are far too often removed from the consequences of what they're delivering. And that means that there is a real loss of the voice of the community that's affected in this process. And to the point that my honorable friend from Northern Ireland mentioned about the fragmentation of the state, whether we're talking BREP, whether we're talking delivery of all manner of different public goods, I think we're far too often seeing delivery of projects with far too many stakeholders involved and as a consequence there appears to be a significant lack of accountability in the process. So here we've got a scheme that is funded largely by central government. Bromsgrove would be incredibly grateful for those funds if there was a genuine sentiment that this was being delivered for the betterment of the town.

But I'm afraid that the patience and the goodwill of the public has probably worn thin. I there's probably not much patience left to squeeze out of the, you know, the very patient and dutiful residents of Bromsgrove. And so there's this lack of accountability. There's this perception that things fall through the cracks. That if it's the responsibility of one body, well they'll tokenistically engage, but, you know, they'll get on with their lives, not have to necessarily live with the consequences, whilst I'm afraid the residents of Bromsgrove do in this case.

And it's advertised that BREP is an enhancement, but the reality is it's made things worse. Now we'll wait and see at the end of the delivery of the scheme what things actually look like. But this forty million pound investment is due to improve a typical journey along the A38 by two minutes. Two minutes. This is without taking into effect the eighty-five percent increase in the housing target being imposed on my constituency by the government.

So that is based on an infrastructure, a society that is arguably already out of date. The compounded effect of growth in the future will see this BREP scheme effectively become a white elephant, a complete waste of money. That's the fear of many of my constituents. I'm afraid it's the fear and suspicion that I've now concluded. And I think it's a bizarre contradiction that we've got this multi-million pound investment.

I mean forty million pounds is not a small sum of money. It's something that if it were spent on something that I believed was truly for the betterment of the town, I'd be rejoicing at this. Forty million pounds can buy a lot. It can tangibly improve a community in so many different ways. But the question everyone is asking is, well for two minutes, and will those two minutes even materialize?

I'm afraid from start to finish this entire project has been a catalogue of mismanagement, it's been a catalogue of communication failure, and most of all it's been a severe failing of all involved to really consult with those who will be affected the most. And so my constituents, as you've probably understood by now, are fed up. I've appealed to Worcestershire County Council to halt all unnecessary roadworks that are over and above the BREP scheme. I believe that BREP should have been delivered in phases rather than one large scheme from start to finish. We're seeing the hauliers, the traffic on the M5 all displaced through the town.

So we've got this additional heavy, unsafe, large loads of traffic. And this is in an already relatively crowded area of population. I have parents get in touch with me because they're worried about the journeys that their children take, particularly if they're crossing the A38. There's been frankly a complete mess and confusing mix of signage and road blockages. And had one constituent get in touch yesterday to say that because of an unmarked curb he'd split his tire and showed me a photograph of that.

So this is having a really profound effect. I want to stress, I do not bring a debate of this kind to Westminster Hall or the House of Commons lightly. It's because my constituents and I really are sort of at the end of our tethers with this. But I would like to take a moment to pay tribute to an 83-year-old cyclist who tragically lost his life a few weeks ago on New Road in Bromsgrove. I would like to stress I am not linking the two events, but it is unquestionable that traffic and congestion in Bromsgrove has got worse.

And I'd like to pay tribute to him. Thoughts are very much with his family and I support the investigation of the authorities as they ascertain the facts behind what happened. So since the general election when I was elected two years ago, I've been pretty relentless in holding Worcestershire County Council to account over BREP. There needs to be a much more coordinated approach both to reduce emissions, congestion, and disruption, and minimize this community impact. Instead, there has been this nonsensical approach.

I'll quote one example in particular that's affected many residents. We have a housing development known locally as The Oakalls, and Regents Park Road, the entrance to this, used by thousands of cars every single day. A large stretch of this road has been narrowed. I've been there multiple times and seen cars flooring it, to be frank, putting their foot down to get through the narrow junction before another vehicle appears. And this has undoubtedly increased the safety concerns on that junction.

Worcestershire County Council, well, I've invited the cabinet member to come down and meet with me and residents. I'm afraid I haven't had a response to the affirmative. I can only conclude that on that front, Worcestershire County Council is not interested in engaging in a junction that they've changed and is unquestionably more dangerous than it was before. Now, my constituents are sensible people. They are prepared to put up with reasonable disruption and they expect unknown hurdles to present challenges.

But their sensibility and their patience does depend on mutual respect. And that's a respect that has been lacking seemingly throughout this process. I quoted The Oakalls' lack of collaboration there. We've got recent ministerial communications, which I am grateful for, saying that the program is now scheduled to end in early 2027. But it's important to put on the record that this BREP scheme, if it is completed in early 2027, will have been delayed effectively twice from its original scheduled completion date.

Now, there are some things that need to be done. I recently sent a letter on the 11th of August to the Secretary of State pleading, really, on behalf of my constituents that serious consideration is given to asking National Highways to intervene in this scheme, given the role of the A38 as a key part of our national strategic infrastructure, that pressure release valve that I've described. I believe it's pretty apparent that Worcestershire County Council lack the expertise. For whatever reason it may be, this could be a project that is just far too big for them to handle.

They may have bitten off more than they can chew. There may be council officers there or contractors who aren't as invested in delivering a successful scheme for the town because their lives are based in other places. I suspect that that is a factor, even though that's a bold statement to make. But I reiterate my plea to the Minister, and I'm grateful to him for coming here today to consider engaging with National Highways on this. Whether it's, I would like to see the Minister engage them to take this under their control, to get this scheme completed using their skills and expertise.

But if the Minister won't do that, I sincerely hope that the Minister will support me in gaining answers to a litany, 34 in fact, 34 questions that I recently sent to the Secretary of State on a range of topics around how this is being delivered. This is about who shoulders the burden of additional cost. My constituents want to know that compared to the original tender that was awarded, how far behind schedule this project is. I think it's quite right that my constituents, who are also taxpayers, and the businesses, not just in Bromsgrove but across the country that are funding this project, aren't shouldering burdens that have been brought about because of poor contractual timekeeping. There are so many unanswered questions.

I don't want to go through them all now because I'm conscious of time and I do want to allow the Minister to come back in what I hope will be a positive spirit. And I will emphasize to him now that I don't come here lightly. I come here because my constituents deserve answers. I am prepared to meet with him in seeking answers. And I'm even prepared to meet with him to engage with National Highways if it will seek a swift, successful and efficient conclusion to the taxpayer to get this scheme delivered once and for all.

01:45:39 - 01:45:46

Peter Wishart

The question is that this House has considered the Bromsgrove Route Enhancement Programme. Minister Justin Madders.

01:45:46 - 01:50:55

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you, Mr. Wishart. It's a pleasure to see you in the chair this afternoon. And can I start by saying I'm grateful to the honorable member for securing the debate and indeed for the determined way that he has represented the interests of his constituents. Can I just start by joining the honorable member in saying how very sad it was to hear about the recent tragic road collision on the A38 which led to the death of a cyclist, and my thoughts and sympathies go out to his family and friends. So, Mr. Wishart, I welcome the opportunity to respond to the concerns the honorable member has raised regarding the A38 Bromsgrove Route Enhancement Programme and its impact on residents, businesses and road users.

And the honorable member was right to acknowledge that schemes of this nature will inevitably lead to some disruption, but it is clear from what he has said today that both he and his constituents have run out of patience in that regard. As he said, the A38 acts as a key strategic link providing access to the strategic road network as well as serving regional and local traffic. And I recognize and sympathize with the comments he made about the road being a key pressure valve when there is disruption on the M5. My own constituency is close to the motorway network and we see the impacts when there are delays and disruptions on there as well. But as the honorable member quite rightly pointed out, the programme has been developed and is being delivered by Worcestershire County Council.

It is the biggest upgrade to Bromsgrove's local road networks in a generation. Its aims are to reduce congestion and increase journey reliability, support the delivery of housing and employment growth, and improve connectivity for pedestrians and cyclists. It is a critical investment in the town's infrastructure and has been assessed as providing high value for money for taxpayers. And indeed, the honorable member did describe the scheme as excellent when it was first announced back in 2023, although I take it from his comments he is a little less supportive of the scheme now, whether that's entirely down to the delays or whether the benefits of it are not as clear to him as they were at the time.

We will no doubt explore that in due course. But as he's rightly pointed out, since the scheme was approved, it has experienced a number of delays and of course I understand the frustrations that his constituents have experienced. The principal cause of delay on the program has been the discovery of numerous previously unchartered utility assets along the A38 corridor, including complex gas infrastructure. The scale and complexity of these assets has required significant additional investigations and changes to designs and construction plans. Because much of this work has involved third-party utility providers, it has not wholly been within the control of the County Council or their contractor.

And as is often the case with major urban highway projects, other factors have also led to delays. Bad weather and the challenges associated with delivering work safely within a live highway environment have also constrained progress. Worcestershire County Council has kept the department regularly updated and as the honorable member has confirmed, most elements of the project are expected to be completed in early 2027. Oak Hill's roundabout will be the final section to complete construction and the contractor's latest plans indicate that the work there will finish in June of 2027. However, the council is exploring opportunities to accelerate delivery and it's hopeful that completion of the roundabout could be brought forward to the spring.

The honorable member has raised, as he said, a number of detailed concerns through correspondence, in meetings and now through this debate, and of course I understand why he's pursued those questions on behalf of his constituents. But it is important to be clear that the responsibility for delivering the A38 program rests with Worcestershire County Council as the local highway authority. The council is therefore accountable for project governance, procurement, contractor management and delivery. And the vast majority of issues raised by the honorable member concern the day-to-day management by Worcestershire County Council of the relationship with its contractor. Detailed decisions on the construction program and the management of delays are matters for the council as the client authority and for the contractor delivering the works.

The Department for Transport has provided funding and maintains appropriate oversight to ensure value for the taxpayer and that public money is spent properly. However, I need to be clear with the honorable member that oversight is not the same thing as management. The department scrutinizes business cases, monitors information and assurance arrangements, but it does not manage contractors, it does not direct operational decisions on site or act as the project manager for locally delivered schemes. I know that he has argued that the department or National Highways should intervene directly and assume responsibility for the project, but let me be clear, neither option is appropriate or indeed possible. National Highways is responsible for England's strategic road network.

The program is a local authority scheme on the local road network and therefore falls outside its remit. And equally there is no mechanism through which the Department for Transport could take over delivery of the project from Worcestershire County Council. The County Council...

01:50:55 - 01:50:56

I certainly will.

01:50:56 - 01:51:42

Anthony Bradley Thomas

I thank the minister for giving way. I appreciate him coming here and responding to my points. Does the minister accept that this is an example of that fragmentation of the state once again? The one thing that the public, including my constituents, are absolutely sick and tired of is this idea that it's not us, it's them. I understand and accept that Worcestershire County Council are responsible for delivering this scheme, that it's funded by central government.

But to say that nothing to do with National Highways because it's simply a local road, when I've demonstrated that a key piece of national infrastructure, the M5, is affected by what's going on on this road, isn't that another example of just passing the buck? It's that fragmentation of the state. We've got to do better.

01:51:42 - 01:54:16

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, it's not about fragmentation of the state. It's about actually letting local areas determine their own priorities and manage their own schemes. That's how local roads have always been run. And I have listened to what he's said about the interactions he's had with the local authority. It seems to me that there needs to be some discussions with his elected councillors about where the accountability lies, because from where we are standing, that is clearly where the question should be directed.

But I think it's also fair to say that we have looked at some of the criticisms and concerns that he's raised. And we do know that there was an independent review of the programme undertaken in 2021, which concluded that appropriate industry-standard de-risking activities had been undertaken before construction commenced. It found that many of the delays encountered were, and I quote, "unavoidable and could not have been fully predicted in advance." Most importantly, it concluded that the programme remains deliverable. The review also recognised that public confidence has been affected by the length of disruption and recommended improvements to communications.

I understand the council has taken on board those recommendations. And the honourable member mentioned the impact on local business, and I have raised this issue with them directly. And they mentioned some recent examples of work regarding the opening of a new Sainsbury's, working with Avoncroft Museum to ensure adequate signage and diversion routes are in place. So it does seem to me that there is some progress in that direction. And we know that the council will continue to work with contractors and utility providers to address the remaining challenges.

Now, I want to conclude by saying that although this is not the department's day-to-day responsibility, I do understand the frustrations experienced by the honourable member, by his residents, by his businesses and road users. The government clearly expects Worcestershire County Council, as a delivery authority, to maintain its focus on completing the remaining works, minimising disruption where possible and keeping local communities informed. And the department will continue to monitor whether the council delivers on that. I would say that it is important that we don't lose sight of the long-term benefits this investment will deliver: reduced congestion, more reliable journey times and improved connections for pedestrians and cyclists. And I am happy to work with the honourable member and the local authority to see that those benefits are delivered as soon as possible, with the minimum level of disruption to his constituents.

01:54:16 - 01:54:25

Speaker 44

That is not the same, and we have to be clear, that is not the same as the department taking day-to-day management of the project. And I hope the honourable member will understand from what I have said why that cannot be the case.

01:54:25 - 01:54:35

Peter Wishart

The question is that this House has considered the Bromsgrove Route Enhancement Programme. As many of that opinion say, "Aye." Of the contrary, "No." I think the Ayes have it. The Ayes have it.

01:54:35 - 01:55:08

Speaker 52

Order, order. And can I ask everybody to take a seat, please? There's plenty of seats available so we can start this promptly. Liz Twist to move the motion.

01:55:08 - 01:56:22

Liz Twist

Thank you, Mr Wishart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chair for this debate. And I beg to move that this House has considered government support for youth suicide prevention charities and mental health support for young people. I'm grateful to have secured this debate on a subject that touches every single constituency in this House.

Now last month I had a debate for World Suicide Prevention Day and indeed many of the same people were here. There was a strong focus in that debate about recognizing that we all need to do more. Sadly in the same week Papyrus Prevention of Young Suicide, a charity which supported young people and their families for nearly 30 years, went into administration. We're just over one month from that date and following the news of this debate so many charities and third sector organizations have been in touch with me to ask if they can contribute to this debate in some way, not because they want recognition but because they all feel the strain of funding and fear for what will happen if no one listens to their pleas.

01:56:23 - 01:56:57

Speaker 47

I thank the honorable friend for giving way. On Saturday I attended a service of hope and remembrance for World Mental Health Day at St Peter's Collegiate Church in my constituency of Wolverhampton West and it brought together a range of organizations dealing with suicide bereavement, debt advice, drug and alcohol support, mental health services and wider community assistance all working together to prevent suicide. So does my honorable friend agree that this kind of joined up community-based approach is vital to get that early intervention and to prevent deaths through suicide?

01:56:57 - 01:57:13

Liz Twist

I thank the honorable friend for his intervention and I most certainly do agree that it's people coming together and working together that can really make a difference. So well done to his community for doing that.

01:57:13 - 01:57:45

Alex Easton

I thank the honorable member for giving way and for securing this debate. Would the honorable member agree with me that the 290 suicides reported by the Northern Ireland coroner's office in Northern Ireland in 2024, eight in ten of them being male and with 28% being from the most deprived communities which underline the urgent need to reach people across our UK? Would the member agree with me that we need sustained government funding targeted for community outreach, prompt counseling and specialist care? Thank you.

01:57:45 - 01:58:46

Liz Twist

I thank the honorable member for that intervention and I most certainly agree that we need to do all that we can to support young people, in fact all people facing ideas of suicidality. And I will touch on the issue of funding. So as I was saying we're just over a month on from that date and so many organizations have been in touch wanting to contribute and I apologize to those who I can't mention and can't refer to the specific points that they make but I do know that they provide a lifeline to so many people and I'll try to do my best to do them justice. Papyrus had a national focus and offered hope to thousands of young people across the UK. They offered specialist support for young people and I'm sure the minister will know this was a vital support given the biggest killer of young people is suicide.

01:58:46 - 01:58:47

I will give way.

01:58:47 - 01:59:18

Jessica Morden

I thank very much my honorable friend for giving way and the excellent work she does in this area. I met Papyrus through my constituent who my honorable friend knows, Emma Webb, who campaigns on suicide awareness amongst young people after sadly losing her daughter. The fact that rising demand is cited as one of the main reasons for its closure should tell us absolutely everything that we need to know. So can I join my honorable friend in calling on the minister to do everything we can to fill the gap left by Hopeline?

01:59:18 - 01:59:28

Peter Wishart

Before the member replies to the intervention could I just remind everybody we have only an hour and there's going to be a strict time limit so interventions will have to be limited and people will have to be patient. Liz Twist.

01:59:30 - 02:01:48

Liz Twist

And I thank my honorable friend for her intervention and I do most certainly agree with the points that she makes and thank her constituent for the work that she does in raising awareness. So, with its sudden closure, we lost one of the most vital services that Papyrus provided, HOPELINE247, our nation's only round-the-clock helpline staffed by advisers trained to support young people experiencing suicidal thoughts. Over the years that this service existed, it helped save the lives of so many young people and the staff provided an important service that was unlike any other. And I want to take a moment now to thank all of those staff, 120 of them, who worked for Papyrus on the helpline and in its other suicide prevention services. Now, for three decades, Papyrus saved lives.

When a young person called HOPELINE247, they spoke with advisers who understood the pressures facing under-35s. Schools, colleges, universities, and GPs relied upon their work. Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services, CAMHS as we usually call it, and emergency departments routinely signposted young people in distress to Papyrus, knowing they would receive safe, compassionate care. My own office and many places of work across the country have displayed posters signposting people to the service with its contact details clearly listed, so that any young person or parent struggling with the subject knew exactly where to find immediate help. On Papyrus going into administration, callers were redirected to Samaritans or to the Shout text helpline, both excellent services but not a dedicated helpline for young people.

We all know that just because the HOPELINE247 service no longer exists, the need for support for young people does not disappear. There are many young people worried that there's nowhere to turn as the option to talk to someone who understands them has gone. The young...

02:01:48 - 02:02:13

Baggy Bhagat Shanker

Thank my friend for giving way. Would my friend agree with me that the Children's Commissioner reported that there's over an active one million referrals made to mental health services, which means that help and support not only to young people and children need to be made, but also to parents, voluntary organizations, and charities that do the good work in this area to prevent suicide?

02:02:13 - 02:04:28

Liz Twist

I thank my honorable friend for that intervention. I most certainly agree with the Children's Commissioner and with him on those issues that he's raised. So, the young people who would have reached out to HOPELINE247 are still struggling with severe emotional distress. Without that helpline, the pressure falls directly onto overstretched emergency services, onto NHS 111 handlers, onto GP surgeries, and onto partner charities like Samaritans and Shout and Chasing the Stigma, which are already running at full capacity. Now, I've recently met with the administrators who are overseeing Papyrus's administration.

They tell me that there is real hope that another charity or service could recreate the helpline dedicated to young people so that they could still access this specialist support. They are keen to speak with government officials about what help can be given to ensure that the helpline and maybe some other parts of the work which Papyrus did can continue. So, right at this stage of the debate, Mr. Wishart, I will ask the Minister whether she will ask her officials to make that contact and help be part of a working solution for young people, because it's a service, as we've heard, that is still vitally needed. Now, the 3 Dads Walking, Andy, Mike, and Tim, have spoken forcefully about the loss of HOPELINE247.

Each having suffered the unbearable loss of a daughter to suicide, Sophie, Beth and Emily, they walked hundreds of miles across the country and raised over 1.5 million pounds for Papyrus. And they have told me that they will get behind whatever organisation is able to pick up the work that Papyrus carried out. Following the closure, the Three Dads asked why a national service relied upon by NHS trusts and CAMHS was left financially dependent on voluntary donations and charity walks. That's a fair question that we in Parliament must answer.

02:04:28 - 02:04:49

Speaker 65

I thank the honourable member for giving way, and she's making a powerful and important speech on something that I know she's campaigned very hard on. I wonder if she'd agree with me that we ought to learn from countries like the Netherlands, where they have a much more integrated system to help young people with their mental health, physical health and with their employment opportunities, all of which contribute to the overall mental health picture.

02:04:49 - 02:05:42

Liz Twist

I thank my honourable friend for that intervention, and certainly we need to learn from best practice wherever it occurs to make sure that we can look after our young people and keep them safe. So, most of all and urgently, we need to take steps to close that gap in support for our young people. There are organisations who are willing to work to provide a helpline and have the skills and the ability to support younger people and young adults. The administrators are working with these organisations, but are keen, as I said, to speak to government about what help might be available to make these plans a reality. This is an opportunity for the government to come to the table, create a dependable support for people under 35 and to set a precedent of care for the lives that need a vital service such as this.

02:05:42 - 02:06:18

John Milne

I thank the honourable member for giving way. On 27th of September, it was five years since my constituent Jess's son Mason died by suicide. His death was one of several examined in a local safeguarding review, but it took her three years of chasing and pressure from my office just to see its recommendations. She's still not seen the full report. Does the honourable member agree that we should install a national oversight mechanism so families can see whether lessons are acted on without feeling that they have to fight the very system that's supposed to be supporting them?

02:06:18 - 02:08:28

Liz Twist

The honourable member makes a very important point there, and it's certainly one I think we could develop further in another debate. So the closure of Papyrus has highlighted the wider financial pressures across the voluntary sector among suicide prevention and mental health charities. This isn't new, but Papyrus is an example that has hit hard. Across the country, non-profit organisations are supporting statutory health services without the predictable long-term funding required to keep their doors open. Now, over recent years, major government grant programmes for suicide prevention have reached the end of their funding periods.

The 10 million pound VCSE suicide prevention grant fund, which supported 79 charities across England, ended in March 25, it was in fact a one-off fund. The official evaluation of that scheme showed that while short-term grants funded helpful community projects, the lack of ongoing funding left charities facing sudden financial cliff edges once the grants ended. In addition, the 57 million pounds allocated to local areas through NHS England for suicide prevention came to an end in April 24. A London-based charity, Body & Soul, surveyed their young service users.

They told me that the short funding cycles threaten the specialist staffing and the stable referral routes they have on offer and the continuity needed to build trust. Short-term funding incentives, short projects and countable contacts over creating sustained capacity needed by young people whose difficulties do not resolve to a grant timetable. And North East-based charity If U Care Share, which members will have heard me speak about before, has raised with me the precarious nature that short-term funding puts charities trying to create long-term programs for their communities in. And I've certainly helped them to try and achieve funding in the past.

02:08:28 - 02:08:57

Charles Edward Robin Morello

I thank the honorable lady for giving way. She's making a powerful speech. On the point of the impact of short-term funding, there is a very human cost. And more often than not, it's the young people involved who pay the price. In some cases, as I've had casework about, people who are losing probably their only outlet for therapists, their only point of contact, someone that they have built up a relationship with, only to see the funding go and that contact go and throwing them back into crisis.

Does she agree with me that short-term funding has real-world impacts on young people?

02:08:57 - 02:11:01

Liz Twist

Well, I thank the honorable member and I do agree with him because we hear that from charities time and again, particularly in this area of work. So, I was talking about two charities in particular and this story is repeated right across the country. It's vital that we tackle the funding issues that face charities who are providing preventative work across the country. Now, to prevent suicides among young people, we must address the pressures they face. Suicide remains the leading cause of death for individuals under 35 in the UK and the Samaritans report around 200 school-aged children take their own lives every year.

There are so many statistics we could quote about why young people consider suicide, but we already know them too well. Statutory services such as the mental health in schools team, CAMHS and other NHS statutory services play an important part in supporting the most vulnerable in our system. And the government must be congratulated for focusing on these areas. However, we can't forget that it's the third sector organizations who are able to be adaptable and present in their everyday lives. They can be a safe external space where young people can go to feel supported and open the doors that young people need to build the foundations of a better life.

Now, the government has taken positive steps including the announcement of 343 million pounds in capital funding for new community mental health hubs and emergency centers. That capital investment is welcome, but without people, both NHS staff and crucially today, the voluntary sector, they will not be effective. For example, Hope Haven in Whitehaven, where the NHS and the voluntary sector work together to maximize the quality of care and support for their community, is a good example of where that is happening. And it's essential that our various strategies work together.

02:11:01 - 02:11:19

James Mark Sewards

Very briefly. She's making such a powerful speech. The Education Select Committee, Health and Social Care Select Committee worked together on this very subject. And they found that the NHS and local commissioners are not taking advantage of the expertise in those third sector organizations. Does she agree the government should take note of that report and act on its recommendations?

02:11:19 - 02:11:30

Peter Wishart

Order. Before the honorable lady responds, we've got about 20 members with something like 10 to 15 minutes of time available and I'm just wondering if the honorable lady is about to conclude her remarks.

02:11:30 - 02:13:57

Liz Twist

Yes, I am going to skip some things, important though they are, because I know other members want to come in. I thank him for that comment. And yes, I most certainly agree with that, that we need to take note of that. So, as I was saying, we have a number of different strategies. And as we develop the mental health strategy, we must take account of young people's needs and make sure they don't fall between the gaps of the men's health strategy and other strategies that we have.

So I'm going to go straight to my asks to the government. Right now, Minister, there's a growing demand due to the closure of Papyrus's HOPELINE247, one that can be remedied at pace with other charities seeking to fill the gap. They need support from the Minister to be able to do this. So will the Minister work with the administrators to make sure that this can happen as quickly as possible to prevent the gap in this vital service? And will the Minister ask her officials to contact the administrators of Papyrus and their specialist advisor to discuss what financial and other support can be offered to make sure that a properly skilled and specialist young person's helpline can be retrieved from the collapse of Papyrus?

And in the longer term, will she consider the funding needed for our third sector organizations in suicide prevention and mental health to continue to provide that open access support that must be the bedrock of our work in mental health? And finally, will she confirm that youth suicide prevention and children's mental health will explicitly form part of the forthcoming mental health strategy? Mr. Wishart, every statistic we discuss in this chamber represents a young person whose life was cut short, leaving behind a family and a community reshaped by grief. The closure of Papyrus must not be seen as a single charity going under. All our third sector partners are struggling.

It's impossible to build a strong mental health system of which third sector organizations play a crucial part if we allow the charities keeping our young people alive to close due to financial strain. Suicide is preventable. By supporting our voluntary sector, by funding frontline services, and by acting early when a young person reaches out, we can save lives and give every person in distress a reason to stay. I beg to move.

02:13:57 - 02:14:17

Peter Wishart

Order. As we can see, there's quite exceptional demand for this particular short debate. We're going to have to confine ourselves to a one-minute time limit because the frontbench speeches will have to start at 5:08. And we'll start with Tim Farron, but he's just left. We'll start with Dr. Neil Hudson.

02:14:17 - 02:15:58

Neil Hudson

Thank you. It's a great privilege to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Wishart. Can I start by congratulating my honorable friend, the member for Blaydon and Consett, for securing this debate and thanking her for all the hard work she does in highlighting this crucial area, something I've been privileged to work with her on the APPG for suicide and self-harm prevention. I could not make this speech without paying tribute to Andy Airey, Mike Palmer, and Tim Owen, better known to all of us as the 3 Dads Walking. It's been a humbling privilege to work alongside Andy, Mike, and Tim, who tragically lost their precious daughters, Sophie, Beth, and Emily to suicide.

United by shared grief, they did something so simple and yet so powerful. They walked, they talked, and together they changed the national conversation on suicide prevention, all while raising over one and a half million pounds for Papyrus. It was therefore devastating that on the very week of World Suicide Prevention Day, we heard that Papyrus had gone into administration. This provided a vital lifeline to people, to young people. There are three excellent charities that provide support in this area: Samaritans, Shout with their crisis text service, and Chasing the Stigma, who provide a Hub of Hope mental health support directory.

But with the loss of Papyrus, we have a huge gap, Minister. The 3 Dads showed us that prevention and signposting is a critical layer that helps us to address mental health and suicide. So I urge the Minister, there's so much work to do across society, and prevention and signposting has to be at the forefront alongside treatment and intervention for when crisis occurs.

This will help save lives. I urge the government to act.

02:15:58 - 02:16:11

Peter Wishart

Given that everybody didn't bob who was down to speak, we're back to two minutes. So you, and can I just remind Dr. Hudson, you did get your two minutes there. Thank you. Laura Farris.

02:16:11 - 02:18:07

Laura Kyrke-Smith

Thank you, Mr. Servant, your chairmanship. And I commend my honorable friend, the member for Blaydon and Consett, for securing this debate. She is right to highlight the vital work of youth suicide charities and the need for sustainable funding. And I would like to pay tribute to Hector's House, a brilliant charity in my constituency which supports young people at risk of suicide in Hector's memory. In Aylesbury, I run a program for young people about politics and government and leadership called Your Voice, Your Future.

The young people share their campaign ideas with me and they often focus on mental health. One group made it their focused project: Be You, Not Blue was their campaign. And their point was that while awareness of mental health matters and is improving, awareness is not the same as understanding, and understanding does not yet translate into the support that they need nationally or in their communities. And so what I think it's so important that we get support for people in crisis right, and the mental health strategy presents a real opportunity to do that. I'd like to reflect the points that these young people make to me, which is that we shouldn't be waiting to offer support until people are at crisis point.

It's so vital that support kicks in early and that mental health is woven through everything that schools do, that the other brilliant youth mental health charities like Youth Action and Action for Youth in my constituency are known by people, are accessible to people, and that the government's youth services also have that mental health support mainstreamed through them. So I think today's debate presents a real opportunity to get youth mental health support right more broadly. And I know it's something that the Minister is working hard on, making sure that we get that support in early as well as for those who do get to that crisis point.

02:18:07 - 02:20:06

Sarah Olney

Thank you very much, Mr. Servant, your chairmanship. Can I congratulate the member for Blaydon and Consett for securing this debate and for all of her excellent work in this field. The closure of Papyrus last month was a devastating loss. Its HOPELINE helped countless people at the toughest point of their lives for nearly 30 years. And I would like to pay tribute to their staff who will have experienced incredibly tough times while handling very delicate but vitally important calls.

And while HOPELINE has been disbanded, the demand for help has not gone away, and it will simply move to other already stressed helpline services. Papyrus helped to alleviate this demand from other charities and health services, and the NHS even signposted to Papyrus to people looking for support. I'd like to add my words to what the honorable member for Blaydon has already said about Three Dads Walking and the incredible work that they've done to raise money for Papyrus. And it obviously is a great sadness to all of us that the service has come to an end. And as the demand for suicide prevention hotlines is growing, I'd be really grateful if the Minister would consider working with Papyrus's administrators to restore HOPELINE.

The independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD, and autism found that mental distress has increased significantly, especially for young people. Investment in services has not kept pace with this demand, meaning that people wait longer for support, which often exacerbates existing mental health conditions.

One of the many recommendations is to close the treatment gap and strengthen specialist services for people with the most complex needs. My constituency is home to Castle Hospital, a tier four therapeutic community for adults with complex multiple diagnosis presentations. Patients tell me that their treatment there is life-saving, life-changing, and while the hospital has proven that their work saves the NHS millions of pounds by reducing hospitalizations and the need for emergency services. Tier four services are under a review by NHS England. Withdrawing funding to a hospital which serves people suffering with the most complex mental health conditions would be a travesty, and I would be grateful if the minister could arrange time to speak with me regarding this matter.

02:20:06 - 02:20:08

Speaker 58

Thank you.

02:20:08 - 02:21:54

Adebayo Alaba

Bill Alaba.

Thank you, Mr. Whis-hart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I also want to thank my honorable friend, the member for Blaydon and Consett, for securing this sad and very necessary debate. In the UK, we are fortunate to have a number of charities dedicated to the prevention of suicide among our young people, and I am deeply proud of this government's work to tackle this issue head-on. But regardless of this work, the unacceptable reality is that suicide remains the leading cause of death for people under 35.

Last month's announcement that the Papyrus Prevention of Young Suicide would cease its operations was such a devastating one. I was also motivated to speak in today's debate, not only because of the recent closure of Papyrus, but by the story of Leslie Harris, a constituent who lost her 13-year-old granddaughter Ella to suicide in 2023. Despite presenting at A&E with suicidal thoughts, Ella was ultimately discharged after speaking to healthcare professionals. She did not receive a full suicide risk assessment and subsequently took her own life. Since the devastating loss, Ella's friends and family have launched a petition calling for a suicide risk assessment to be made legally mandatory whenever a young person in hospital expresses an intention to harm themselves.

Thanks to their hard work, I am pleased to see that the petition has now achieved 20,000 signatories and will receive a government response. I fundamentally support their efforts and have written to both the Prime Minister and the Department for Health and Social Care to that effect. I look forward to receiving their responses. Thank you.

02:21:54 - 02:21:56

Annest Meddy

Annest Meddy.

02:21:56 - 02:23:52

Speaker 66

Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and can I commend the honorable member for Blaydon and Consett for securing this important debate. And firstly, I would like to start by expressing my deepest sympathies to all the families, friends, and the communities affected by suicide. Today, I'm going to focus on two charities that serve my constituents and beyond. The DPJ Foundation was set up in July 2016 following the death of Daniel Picton-Jones. His widow Emma established the foundation to support mental health for those in the farming sector.

Ten years on, the foundation continues to provide invaluable support for the farming communities across the whole of Wales through specialist support tailored specifically for agriculture, and this means our young farmers are also receiving that support in our rural communities. And as already mentioned, Papyrus, the Three Dads Walking, and I'm privileged that Mike is one of my constituents and I was able to join them last June in their walk around Ynys Môn, my constituency. And on that walk, I was able to have those conversations with family, with friends that have been deeply affected by suicide, and the importance of prevention, the importance of having that support network, and also the importance of that 24-hour support. And that's why the Three Dads Walking raised so much money for Hopeline 247. The charity's closure in September comes despite it having the two busiest months in nearly 30 years over the summer, showing that the service is needed more than ever, and this decision will mean the loss of lives.

So I urge on the government to do all it can to support the valuable work of charities like Papyrus and DPJ so that young people continue to have access to essential support wherever they live in our communities.

02:23:52 - 02:25:47

Amanda Martin

Amanda Martin.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Any death by suicide is devastating, but a death by suicide of a child is often unimaginable. And whilst rates of suicide are highest in the middle-aged group, there has been a concerning increase among children and young people over recent years. And one worrying trend linked to the health problems and suicide in Portsmouth has been the troubling rise in the use of ketamine. In February 2024, Sarah lost her daughter Honor to suicide following a battle with ketamine addiction.

Honor was bright, loved, and let down by a system that didn't recognize the dangers until it was too late. She was 23. Ketamine addiction among young people is a growing crisis hiding in plain sight. Unlike alcohol or vaping, most parents don't see the signs, most schools don't teach it, and most GPs don't even screen for it. Search engines and information online doesn't highlight the dangers that this addiction and the damage it does to a person's body and their mind.

And drugs like ketamine are frequently marketed on mainstream social media. The widespread availability and low cost of this substance also makes it particularly accessible to teenagers, and the class B it carries doesn't deter people from selling or buying it. That's why Sarah set up H23 Foundation to fight ketamine addiction and prevent more lives like Honor's being lost. The foundation aims to reach as many students and young people as possible, provide support for families, and create a lasting legacy with systematic change. Efforts by our government since 2024 to address ketamine addiction have been a welcome start.

However, there is more to do, and I'll be grateful if the minister could address any other efforts that government is taking to address the specific challenges the rise in ketamine use and wider drug addiction have on young people's mental health and risk of suicide, and how we can ensure that the truth about the damage this drug does to people can be available, because stories like Honor show just how devastating the consequences can be if left unlooked.

02:25:47 - 02:27:28

Jim Shannon

Jim Shannon.

Mr. Chairman, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. A big thank you to the honorable lady for Bridgend and Pontypridd for setting the scene so incredibly well. This is an issue that is a profound and heartbreaking crisis touching almost every community, every school, and every street across the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. When we talk about the mental health of our young people, we are talking about our future. The world our young people inherit is one of intense and inescapable pressure.

Social media follows them everywhere, there's no place to hide from cyberbullying, and the continuous distortion of self-worth is pulling our youth into dark, isolated corners. One in ten have in Northern Ireland, one in ten have engaged in self-harm. Across Northern Ireland, we have lost 280 suicide deaths in a single year, and every single one of those numbers represents, Mr. Chairman, an empty chair at a family table, a shattered home, and a life of potential cut tragically short. Regional figures for Strangford and Ards and North Down Council indicate that the number of local suicides in Ards and North Down increased by a shocking 40% in a four-year period, rising in the last four years. Our local youth services and schools are overwhelmed.

Grassroots groups are doing an angelic job, but they are fighting an uphill battle against rising demand and unstable funding. Our young people in Ards, Comber, Newtownards, and right down the Ards Peninsula where I represent and where I live, deserve better than a system where they have to wait months on end just to speak to a mental health professional.

That's not satisfactory. Early intervention is not a luxury. It is a life-saving necessity. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.

02:27:28 - 02:27:32

Peter Wishart

Just a minute and a half to try and get everybody in. Jack Abbott.

02:27:32 - 02:29:15

Jack Abbott

Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today, and I thank my honorable friend for bringing this debate today. And seeing how many colleagues have attended is a real reminder that there's not one constituency or community that is safe from the devastating impact of suicide or the very particular kind of grief that comes with the death of a young person. In Suffolk, we lost 65 people to suicide in 2024, 10 of whom lived in Ipswich. And to each of their families, I want to say sorry.

Sorry the help they needed wasn't there. Sorry the signs weren't spotted sooner, and sorry they were so badly let down. But I just wanted to highlight and thank the local charities that do an incredible work protecting our young people. Suffolk Mind, for example, offers a wide range of courses for children and young people to empower them with the tools they need to look after their own mental health and to help them become more resilient, emotionally aware, and resourceful adults. And I'm really pleased that the government's Pride in Place funding is going towards helping them open a new center in Ipswich town center.

We're also very lucky to have a local Samaritans branch, I'm sure many of colleagues in here will also attest to this, who have supported our community for over half a century. And in a typical year, their team locally, supported of 100 volunteers, listens to 20,000 phone calls and spends 4,000 hours on the phone to people who need that as well. But I also want to be really clear that charities cannot and should not be expected to carry this burden alone. And at the moment, someone experiencing mental health crisis locally may have to go through a busy A&E department and then wait for specialist support to become available. So I'm really pleased the Woodlands unit at Ipswich Hospital is getting dedicated emergency mental health provision as part of a national rollout backed by over 350 million pounds, as we owe it to every young person in Ipswich, Suffolk, and across the country to give them the support they need when they need it.

02:29:15 - 02:30:49

Juliet Campbell

Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today. I thank the member for Blaydon and Consett for securing this important debate. Mental health for children and young people is one of the defining health challenges of our time, because one in five young people has a confirmed or suspected mental health condition. In Broxtowe, I see both the scale and the need for and the value of community-based support.

The Middle Street Resource Centre in Beeston provides mental health support services to young people and adults in my community, and I'm enormously grateful to the staff and volunteers for everything they do. However, new referrals to their services have doubled in the last year, yet their staff numbers do not reflect this. Even more so now that some of the larger funders have temporarily withdrawn funding opportunities, which means the demand for small numbers for small numbers of funders is significantly oversubscribed. Core costs, including staff costs, are hardest to fund. And without significant or sufficient funding, these types of specialist organizations will struggle to engage, will struggle because those young people who struggle to engage with more formal or centralized services means that they will not continue their work.

Young people need services to help them to recover, build resilience, and even more importantly, not no longer need ongoing care when they are adults. I ask the government to give additional funding through a... Order. Thank you. Frank McNally.

02:30:49 - 02:31:20

Francis Joseph McNally

Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I congratulate my honorable friend. In my own local authority of North Lanarkshire, we have suicide rates above the Scottish national average, and we know that young people face particular challenges. During 2024, 735 young people registered with the online mental health charity Kooth in North Lanarkshire alone, with 68% of logins outside normal working hours, which demonstrates the importance of ensuring support is available when young people actually need it.

02:31:20 - 02:32:23

Speaker 76

I do want to briefly just commend the tremendous work undertaken in North Lanarkshire to confront this challenge. The community partners there have made suicide prevention a priority and are working to ensure early intervention. And just last week, 150 young people at Ravenscraig Regional Sports Centre took part in a netball and football tournament to raise awareness of suicide prevention. These types of community partnerships can genuinely save lives. But local authorities, voluntary organisations cannot tackle this challenge alone and often face difficult financial settlements.

So I do encourage the government and of course the Scottish government to provide additional support to local authorities and to those third sector organisations to ensure that long-term certainty can be provided and that they can deliver the support that's needed as early as possible, long before young people reach that desperate stage.

02:32:23 - 02:33:32

Perran Moon

We could get two more speakers in if they take a minute each. Perrin Moon.

Merci, Mr Wishart, and I thank the member for Blaydon and Consett for securing this important debate. Improving mental health services for our young people is deeply personal for me and one of the reasons I became an MP. Too often, the first support someone receives comes only once they have reached crisis point, either at a busy A&E department or on a charity hotline. So I was extremely concerned to hear that Papyrus had gone into administration. One constituent, Anne, lost her son Toby to suicide in 2011.

She told me how Papyrus had given her hope for the future and for others. She raised thousands to keep the Hopeline going, including trekking 50 kilometres across the Sahara in Toby's memory. And she speaks for many when she asks how such a vital service could be allowed to disappear. I welcome the government's investment in new community mental health centres and crisis centres, including in my Camborne, Redruth and Hayle constituency. They are the right investments.

02:33:32 - 02:34:29

Sureena Brackenridge

Thank you, Mr Wishart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I also want to put on record my heartfelt thoughts and wishes with all those affected by suicide. For constraints of time, I will focus my remarks on the number of children who are presenting at A&E, often in a mental health crisis and a complexity of mental health issues. So I'm going to take this opportunity to ask the minister two questions.

First, what action is the government taking to reduce the number of children reaching crisis point and presenting at A&E, including by improving access to community-based support and CAMHS? And secondly, will the government consider a children's health investment standard to ensure children's mental health receives a fair share of NHS funding and ensure every school can access appropriately trained mental health professionals?

02:34:29 - 02:34:37

Peter Wishart

Order. And apologies to those colleagues we couldn't get in this debate. We go over to the Lib Dem spokesperson, Danny Chambers.

02:34:37 - 02:36:50

Danny Chambers

Thank you, Mr Wishart. It's an honour to serve under your chairmanship. And I pay tribute to the member for Blaydon and Consett for giving such an eloquent speech at the beginning of this very difficult debate. When I became an MP two years ago, there were half a million children on waiting lists for mental health services. About two months ago, that had raised to a million children.

That's a million children needing help and a million families who are probably stressed beyond belief worrying about the impacts of being on a long-term waiting list. And the Darzi report showed that NHS caseload is 20% mental health and yet it received was receiving at the time in 2024 10% of the funding. I'm very disappointed that the government removed the mental health investment standard, which ensured that the proportion of money spent on mental health increased in line with physical health. And as a result of that standard being broken, the NHS mental health services now receive 8% of the funding.

So the proportion is dropping while we have record waiting lists. And the cuts to mental health services are not just limited to NHS services. Last year, the government cut the VSC grant, which is a vital fund that contributed to many charities and organisations like Samaritans, at Men's Sheds, the Young Farmers, youth groups. And one of them was Papyrus, which everyone has been talking about today, offering support for children and young people experiencing suicidal thoughts. And this is a devastating loss, because organisations like Papyrus and the amazing Winchester Youth Counselling in my constituency, they're vital because they give support to children before they need clinical NHS services.

This is early support. It's targeted support. It's often self-referral. It's counselling, it's talking therapies. And not only does this help children maintain their mental health, but it also saves the NHS money as they're less likely to end up in extreme cases in A&E, which is probably the worst place.

I'll give way very briefly.

02:36:50 - 02:37:17

Catherine Eccles

I thank him for giving way and I will be very brief. It was just on the point about the sad demise of Papyrus recently. It isn't just the hopeline that they did amazing work with. They pioneered the work of the suicide safety planning for young people and the support they gave to parents. Does he agree with me that the government urgently needs to replace those services somewhere within the mental health ecosystem?

02:37:17 - 02:39:06

Danny Chambers

I totally agree with that intervention. And I just want to finish this speech, Mr Chair, by focusing on why these organisations are so important. Some politicians from some parties have been using mental health and children's mental health as a bit of a political football, calling young people struggling with mental health snowflakes. This is absolutely shameful. And for families who have lost children, for children who have lost brothers and sisters, when there's one less child in the school football team, when there's one empty chair at the dining table, when there's one fewer set, one less pair of shoes at the front door, these affect those families, these losses affect those families forever and for the rest of their lives.

And I want to pay tribute to one of my constituents, Martin Pond in Alresford, who lost his son Archie at only 19 years old. And he has got a bench put in, made by an amazing organisation called Legends on the Bench. And it's a solar-powered bench, and it has a light on at nighttime, and there's a QR code where you can read a memorial to Archie, but there's also support and signposting to organisations like Samaritans, so anyone who comes across this bench in a time of crisis, feeling alone, can get that kind of support. And I think it is an amazing tribute to an amazing young man. I would finish, Mr Chair, by urging the government to restore the mental health investment standard.

I think politicians overuse the word crisis, but it's really hard to think of another word to describe the state of children's mental health and mental health services at the moment.

02:39:06 - 02:43:47

Gregory James Stafford

Thank you very much, Mr Wishart, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I want to thank the honourable member for Blaydon and Consett for securing this debate and for the courage and dignity in which she has spoken, and indeed the way all honourable members have spoken in this debate. We know that there are record numbers of young people in England who are asking for help, and too many of them are waiting months, if not years, to receive it. In March, nearly a million under-18s had an active referral, and we need to do better. I pay tribute, like so many honourable members did, to the families who have turned their grief into action.

And my honourable friend for Epping Forest mentioned Three Dads Walking and their 1.5 million pounds that they raised after losing their daughters. I also think, of course, of organisations like Samaritans and YoungMinds and so many more national and local charities.

And I pay tribute to the bereaved families in my constituency some of whom I have worked very closely with. And that brings me to Papyrus. Last month it entered into administration and its helpline 24/7 went silent and 120 jobs were lost. And a young person in crisis tonight cannot call the line that was essentially built for them. The administrators cited rising demand, higher costs and falling reliable funding.

And the Samaritans and Shout have warned of further pressure on charities working in and I quote an extremely challenging financial environment. The suicide prevention grant fund launched under the last government gave 10 million pounds to 79 organisations between 2023 and 2025. Papyrus was shortlisted for 625,000 pounds from it. And in the previous round it received over 150,000 pounds for the helpline. And the government chose not to renew that fund and said it had no plans for another and I know of no other of comparable scope.

Now I know and I suspect the minister may point to money for suicide prevention pathfinders in the mental health strategy but that is much less than the fund provided and it is not a helpline. And then there are the costs. Since April 2025 charities have faced additional burdens including increases through national insurance employer national insurance contributions. The government can't withdraw funds, raise the costs and then express surprise when charities struggle. Now colleagues across the house have previously asked whether the government would consider if its own evaluation of the fund found that it had worked.

So I do ask the minister was that evaluation taken did that take place and what the outcome of that evaluation was. I think the last Conservative government had a record that is to be proud of. The first suicide prevention minister, the first cross-government plan in 2019, the five-year strategy and the national suicide surveillance system in 2023 and the Online Safety Act which requires companies to remove illegal content which encourages suicide and made encouraging self-harm a criminal offence. Now on the 8th of September ministers reaffirmed the government's commitment to a strategy. The call for evidence on the wider mental health strategy closed in July but we're waiting for an outcome from the government.

Now given the timing I will close closer to home. Following the death of a man in Farnham in 2022 my constituent Mr Clark Senior who served in Bosnia, Northern Ireland and the Gulf and Kosovo and lives with disabilities sustained in the line of duty got involved with the veterans' charity Legend on the Bench. In December I will be attending the unveiling of three suicide prevention benches across Farnham sponsored by the University of the Creative Arts, Waverley and Farnham Town Council with more to follow in Bordon and Haslemere. But I ask the minister and I say to the minister the goodwill of the community and a bench cannot replace a trained and manned helpline. So I have four questions for the minister.

First of all will the government restore a dedicated 24-hour youth suicide helpline? Will it review its decision to close the suicide prevention grant fund, publish its evaluation and move from 12-month to multi-year funding? What assessment has been made of the impact of higher national insurance contributions on the sustainability of youth suicide prevention charities? And what progress has it made on the suicide prevention charity will it renew it when it expires in 2028 and will the minister give firm dates for the mental health strategy?

I know a lot of people watching this debate will be affected by this. If anyone needs more help, the Samaritans are still available on 116 123. A young person in crisis tonight needs a line to call and that is what Papyrus gave them. We on this side of the House will continue to support any efforts to improve support and to challenge these policies where they fall short.

02:43:47 - 02:44:51

Alison McGovern

Minister Alice McGovern.

Thank you Mr. Wishart, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship as ever. And I would like to thank members across this House who've participated in such an important debate and especially my friend the member for Blaydon and Consett for bringing this debate. She does a very, very important job in chairing the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Suicide and Self-Harm Prevention and she will have heard just how much her colleagues right across the House of Commons support her in that work today. I, officials have very kindly drafted me quite a long speech. I'm going to try to answer people's questions but also given Mr. Wishart how you very diligently tried to get so many people in, members might have things that they missed.

So if anybody wants to intervene on me during that speech, it may mean that I miss paragraphs that officials have diligently written, but I think it's better if people make their interventions on me as I speak if that's acceptable to you Mr. Chair. Okay.

02:44:51 - 02:45:18

Sarah Hall

I shall be very quick, thank you to the minister. Papyrus was actually based in my constituency of Warrington South and last month alongside almost 60 cross-party MPs and peers I wrote a letter to the Secretary of State calling for urgent action to protect these vital services. Now I've also spoken to the administrators and they are incredibly keen to find a solution. So will the minister set out what action's being taken in relation to the concerns raised in the letter and will she agree to meet me to discuss the issues raised?

02:45:19 - 02:48:09

Alison McGovern

Thank you Mr. Chair and I thank my honorable friend for that intervention and through her I thank Papyrus and all of those in her constituency for all the hard work that they have done. I will update colleagues in just a moment on the steps that we are going to take from this point. But just by way of context, people have mentioned the suicide prevention strategy for England which shows that while suicide rates among children and young people are relatively low compared to older age groups, it's the longer-term trend that is really concerning. And I think right across this House we share that worry about the increase that we've seen in suicide amongst the young. The strategy requires tailored and targeting support and early intervention and collaboration right across the public sector which we all want to see.

And before I turn to Papyrus and to respond to the questions that my friends and others have put to me, I just want to draw members' attention also to the publication last week of the Fonagy review which gave the wider context of rising mental distress, particularly for young people and particularly for young women especially. And if members haven't read that report I would strongly recommend it to them because that is the context against which we will move forward before Christmas to publish the mental health strategy which will pick up many of the issues that members have mentioned. To turn to Papyrus, I will in just one moment, just let me put this on the record. I hope that all of those who've worked for Papyrus and who've been involved in it and who've raised funds, including Three Dads Walking and so many others, I hope they will have heard the support for Papyrus and the work that they've done today and I want to add the government's gratitude. Officials are in touch with administrators to try to work with them in the way that colleagues have suggested.

My recommendation would be that members who are interested meet with department officials as soon as possible to be updated on that work if that is acceptable to colleagues. Youth suicide prevention and mental health will be a part of the mental health strategy going forward. So immediately we need to take steps to make sure that the process through the administration happens.

Colleagues will understand that I cannot give more details at the dispatch box just now, but as I've said, I suggest we have a meeting for colleagues very soon with officials so that they can understand the detail of that. And then we'll need to make sure that that mental health strategy to come, which the Prime Minister has committed to before Christmas, takes into account all of the issues that colleagues have raised today. Give way.

02:48:09 - 02:48:32

Perran Moon

I thank the Minister for giving way. Just on that point, does she agree that as an absolute base principle of success, that no young person should have to wait until the point of criticality at an A&E department or a charity helpline before they get the support that they deserve?

02:48:32 - 02:49:55

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Chair. And I wholeheartedly agree with that point. We need to move to a system where children and young people are able to get support quickly, in an open way that's non-stigmatising, so that we don't see them reach crisis point. I do wholeheartedly agree with that, and that is the direction of travel that the Fonagy review suggested last week, that we will take forward through the mental health strategy. Now, I'm conscious that the Shadow Minister asked me some direct questions as well, including about funding.

And I want to respond to his point along with the point made by my friend for Leeds, who I can't just see at this moment in time. There is, has been a real problem about short-term funding. And again, I think we need to think about what principles we should put in place to try to resolve that, because we know that the best care and support from a mental health point of view often comes from the community and voluntary sector, and members have described quite accurately what the funding environment has been like, too short-term. So I would ask colleagues to work with me as we try to get to a better, more long-term arrangement.

02:49:55 - 02:49:56

Will the Minister give way?

02:49:56 - 02:49:57

I will, of course, yes.

02:49:57 - 02:50:24

Baggy Bhagat Shanker

Thank you very much, Minister, for giving way. Earlier this month, Linking Hope hosted an upstream suicide prevention training event in Derby South. They do some fantastic work, working with voluntary groups, charities, and members of the public. Does my honourable friend agree that the more stronger these links are, all of us are better equipped to help young people in this area?

02:50:24 - 02:55:01

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I do agree that that connectivity between organisations is really important. One of the things that the suicide prevention strategy has said is that preventing suicide is everybody's business. We all need to have that in our minds and then to work together across organisations to support people. So I do, I do agree with him.

One of my friends asked me a question about ketamine use. And again, the suicide prevention strategy did identify substance misuse as an issue for suicide prevention. And she'll understand I'll be working with colleagues across government very closely to try to support their work on substance misuse. The Shadow Minister also asked me about evaluation, and I will write to him with the details of that. He's quite right to point out that it's extremely important that we understand the efficacy of what's been done before so that we can bring that into the mental health strategy to come.

And the spokesperson for the Liberal Democrats asked me about the mental health investment standard. And I again, I will write to him with the details of how we are taking that forward. Spending forecasts show that we should reach 16.1 billion pounds on mental health in 26-27, which is a good thing. I have concerns about outcomes because whilst spending increases, it's very, very important that recovery also increases. So we want to make sure that that those spending increases happen in a way that where we're also seeing continuous improvement in terms of outcomes for particularly for some of the conditions that are most stigmatized, schizophrenia, bipolar and other things where we just haven't seen the better outcomes that we have in conditions that people are finding easier to talk about.

A number of members asked me if I would meet with them to discuss this or matters in their constituency or organizations that they've supported, including the member for Richmond. I would just say that my time for meeting MPs is Wednesday after Prime Minister's Questions and if a member of Parliament asks me to meet, I will meet. So please do get in touch via the department and I'd be happy to meet all members who would wish to. Members have also mentioned the Samaritans and their number 116 123, which is there to support those who need it. And of course, I would also say the NHS 111 service with the mental health option can be used where people need that support.

And I would wholeheartedly encourage all of us to keep helping people know where they can reach that support if they need it. Of course, we don't want children and young people to get to that crisis point. And what I hear from schools and teachers again and again is how they need support to make sure that they are addressing challenges where they come up for young people. And that's why I'm pleased with the progress being made through our mental health support teams in schools and colleges, with latest data showing that nearly 6 million pupils and learners are now covered by a mental health support team, which is about 60% of pupils and learners in England. We've obviously got more to do because we we want that coverage to be complete by 2029.

So we have more to do, but we are making progress. We're also investing in early support hubs, which a number of people have mentioned will provide which will provide that community-based, de-stigmatizing support. And again, we have more progress to make on that. I just want to finish, Mr. Chair, by saying that it has been good and important to hear about members' experience with their constituents on this issue. We all want to work together to make sure that we can find any possible solution to what's happened with Papyrus.

I suggest we meet again shortly to discuss that. But my final message is really for any young person out there: you are not by yourself. You are not alone. Reach out for help and you will be able to move forward, so please do reach out.

02:55:01 - 02:55:18

Peter Wishart

The question is that this House has considered government support for youth suicide prevention charities and mental health support for young people. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order.

The sitting stands adjourned.