House of Commons
No chapters available yet
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
House of Commons
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. We're providing £3,600,000,000 worth of funding over the next three years to tackle homelessness and rough sleeping, including 11,000,000 for Newcastle through the homelessness, rough sleeping, and domestic abuse grant. And councils can use this funding flexibly to to meet the needs of women in their area, which is vital given that 40% of homeless households were recently single women or women with children.
Speaker 5
Thank you, and I thank the minister for that response, and I welcome the increased investment in tackling homelessness in Newcastle, is really transforming lives. Now homeless women are both more vulnerable and less visible. Recently, the Women's Homeless Alliance Northeast showed just how serious a problem this is. Through a proactive and concentrated survey, it identified a 144 women sleeping were far more than councils were aware of at the time. Without accurate data, it's hard to plan effective support, leaving women at greater risk.
So, could the minister tell me what the government is doing specifically to ensure women's homelessness is better measured, monitored, and dealt with?
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker, and and I thank the honorable lady for her question. She makes the case for women's homelessness and rough sleeping to be better understood to improve evidence, and we added an indicator on gender as part of the monthly rough sleeping survey, which we published in February 2026. But I would encourage all local authorities to listen to the question that she just asked to consider taking part in the women's rough sleeping census, and to understand that domestic abuse is the third biggest reason for homelessness. So we need to act on this issue.
Speaker 10
I'll take questions four seventeen and twenty two together. Alongside our commitment to delivering the biggest increase in social and affordable house building in a generation, the government is determined to drive a transformational and lasting change in the safety and quality of social housing. To that end, we've begun the implementation of AWABS law, introduced a new modernized decent home standard, updated minimum energy efficiency standards, and directed the regulator of social housing to set new standards ranging to the competence and conduct of social housing staff.
Speaker 8
Thank you, mister speaker. In October 2022, a constituent of mine moved into a housing property and immediately faced issues with extreme cold and damp. And these rash issues went unresolved for so long that he referred his complaints to the housing of ombudsman in April 2025, but it took until February for investigations to begin. And like everyone, my constituent simply wants a dignified life in a safe, comfortable home they could be proud to call home. So can the minister explain what the government is doing to ensure that housing associations are meeting their requirements under our ABS law and that they have the resources to do so.
I'm very sorry
Speaker 10
to learn, mister speaker, the experience of my honorable friend's constituent. All housing association homes must be free from dangerous damp and mold. I know that my honorable friend's case, arose before, we brought the first phase of our law into force on the October 27. Having done so, mister speaker, all social landlords are required to repair emergency hazards within twenty four hours and fix dangerous damp and mould within fixed time scales.
Speaker 62
Thank you, mister speaker. In my constituency of Ronkonen Helmsby, Riverside Housing Association are flat three sixty five homes demolishing them to rebuild them four new homes. But residents have been left with no communication, no support, no number to ring. Residents like John and Barbara Weldon, now in their eighties, who've lived the same property for over fifty years and are facing the trauma of that move without knowing where they are going. Will the minister agree with me that housing associations have a duty of care to residents and where they fail that duty of care, they should be held to account.
Speaker 10
I thank the honourable lady for her question. Social landlords are held to regulatory standards that are overseen by the regulator. I'm sorry to hear about the experience of John, Barbara and others. If she likes to write with me with details about the case, I will happily look into it.
Speaker 12
Prime Thank you, mister speaker. More social housing is essential, but as members across the house will know, increasingly distant housing associations are often far too quick to put up fees and far too slow to tackle damp, mould and disrepair. So what more will the minister do to ensure that future public funding comes with clear strings attached to require better standards for our constituents?
Speaker 10
I thank my honorable friend for his question. Resident providers of social housing, mister speaker, whoever they are, address non decency wherever it exists and do so in a timely and professional manner. Where there are concerns that an RP is not delivering against the required regulatory standards I just mentioned, referrals can be made to the regulator, and the regulator has robust enforcement powers that allow it to take effective action when serious failings are identified.
Speaker 14
in my inbox as an MP for Woking, including in damp and mould. And one of the key issues I get is following the Conservatives unlawfully removing over £4,000,000 of money from the housing revenue account. It has resulted in a huge backlog of issues. What steps is this government and this minister taking to ensure that that doesn't happen again to add other woes to our social housing stock?
Speaker 10
Well, we are taking a number of steps to assist local authorities whose HRAs are under pressure, including the rent convergence, introduction that I know the honorable gentleman is aware of, and all of the other regulatory certainty and stability that allows local authorities as well as, housing associations to plan for the future and invest in their existing stock, as well as building new social and affordable homes. Red Hawkins.
Speaker 4
Sarah Stake. Mister speaker, well, I was delighted to confirm up to £20,000,000 for Central Luton as part of the expanded Pride in Place program. This funding will give the community the resources and the power they need to drive transformational local change, and that will bring people together and restore a sense of pride in the area.
Speaker 15
moment to congratulate Luton Town on winning the EFL trophy yesterday at Wembley. But and I very much welcome, the £20,000,000 pride in place funding for Central Luton, which will help restore pride in our local neighbourhoods after being left behind for so many years under the previous Conservative Government. Does the sector of state agree with me that decisions on how to use investment to regenerate Central Luton will be made by the community, for the community, and to connect the community?
Speaker 4
of Well, I I do agree with her that one of the most exciting things about pride in place is that it is the community themselves that take decisions about how the money should be spent. Of course, that's the right thing to do because it's communities themselves that know best what needs to change to put pride back at the heart of their communities.
Speaker 18
Thank you, mister speaker. Any form of coercion at the polling booth is unacceptable and undermines confidence in our democratic process. The Ballot Secrecy Act 2023 makes this clear. The government will continue to work closely with the electoral commission and administrators to ensure polling staff station staff are confident in challenging these offenses.
Speaker 19
GREGORY STAFFERY. Thank you, mister speaker. Whilst Greater Manchester Police has stated that there was no evidence of family voting in a recent by election, democracy volunteers reported witnessing concerningly high levels of such activity on polling day. So how does the minister reconcile these conflicting accounts, and can they confirm, and can she clarify, how Greater Manchester Police conducted that assessment, particularly where the witness statements from the observers were taken into account?
Speaker 18
Thank you, mister speaker. The Greater Manchester Police have completed their investigation and found no evidence of family voting. I'd like to thank the police for their careful and diligent work investigating this matter, as well as the electoral commission and the local returning officer for the support that they have provided. As I said before, coercion in the polling station and other types of electoral offenses are unacceptable and undermine confidence in our democratic system.
Speaker 25
Thank you very much, mister speaker, and happy Easter. Family voting is just one example of unfair voting practices that seek to skew elections and exploit those isolated from wider British society. Another example of these divisive tactics was a disgraceful green leaflet in the Gorton and Denton by election written in Urdu saying, and I quote, Labour must be punished for Gaza. Give the Muslims a voice. Vote green.
Speaker 20
If the minister agrees that this is divisive language, will she back our amendment to allow only election literature in the short campaign printed only in an official British language? Minister.
Speaker 18
Thank you, mister speaker. We will continue to work through the representation of the People's Bill in committee line by line through scrutiny. I look forward to continuing that work with him, and we will discuss that then.
Speaker 10
Thank you, mister speaker. On the March 19, we published a full impact assessment for the draft common hold and leasehold reform bill. You'll be aware that we are also currently consulting on precisely how we introduce a ban on the use of leasehold for new flats, including in respect of issues such as scope and transition arrangements and exemptions.
Speaker 21
Thank you, mister speaker. Wixom's retirement village in Mid Bedfordshire is a wonderful integrated retirement community, but I understand from the sector and the industry that the business model is under threat from the government's leasehold reforms. Given the important role these communities can play in reducing social care costs for our local authorities and the fantastic option they represent for older constituents, will the Minister commit to look again at the specific impacts on leasehold reform on the integrated retirement sector, particularly to give stability and predictability to investors so they can invest in future schemes?
Speaker 10
Prime I thank the honorable gentleman for for his well judged question. Let me reassure him that the government understand their distinct operational and financial models which underpin specialist retirement housing, and we recognize the important role that integrated retirement community operators play in providing high quality housing for older people. As he's hopefully aware, the question of how the retirement housing sector functions in a world in which common hold is the default tenure and whether some kind of exemption is required is one of the many questions we're seeking feedback to through our moving to common hold leasehold flat band consultation, and I encourage him and any operators within his constituency to engage with it.
Speaker 78
you, mister speaker, and I thank the minister for his work on this issue. I'm working to make sure that managing agent Freshwater will meet with me in order to talk about their service charge levels. What does the minister agree with me that it's important that managing agents do meet with representatives in order to tackle some of these high levels and so that they're prepared for some of the reforms that this government's bringing in, but also a real concern that I have about the impact of high service charges on the long term sustainability of the leasehold model for people who are choosing to retire into leasehold properties.
Speaker 10
I absolutely agree with my honorable friend. High and rising service charges are putting unprecedented financial pressure on leaseholders. They are also causing issues. More and more, we're seeing this, mister speaker, with mortgages, and remortgaging, processes. So absolutely agree with her.
And on the point of managing agents, absolutely, yes. Managing agents should meet with residents where they have concerns either collectively or individually.
Speaker 10
Thank you, mister speaker. The government appreciates fully the long standing concerns among park home residents about the requirement to pay site owners a commission upon sale of a park home. On the March 5, we published a call for evidence in relation to the said commission payments so that we have the information necessary to act and provide the clarity and certainty that park home residents and site owners have rightly been demanding.
Speaker 14
mister speaker. Park home residents in Brecon and Radnor and indeed across the entire country described the 10% sales commission as a deeply unfair hit on their life savings often amounting to tens of thousands of pounds. And with the government's call for evidence now underway, what assessment has the secretary of state made of whether this charge is fair and whether residents are receiving value for money? Minister.
Speaker 10
Well, can I say, mister speaker, I fully understand the honorable gentleman's desire to secure change in relation to this matter, I assure him that I share his eagerness to proceed quickly? Unfortunately, the research undertaken by the previous government was not conclusive as to either the purpose of the commission or the impact of its removal or reduction. The final report recommended further work, to clarify the rationale of the commission so the government can make informed policy choices, Hence, the call for evidence, which I hope he and park homeowners in his constituency are engaging with.
Speaker 48
Thank you, mister speaker, and I welcome the government's new call for evidence. Perhaps unsurprisingly, park homeowners across South Dorset continue to be deeply frustrated with the unfair 10% sales commission that slapped on all park homes. The current system feels unfair as if is punishing one group disproportionately compared to others. So with all this in mind, will the minister look to ensure that park homeowners are not forgotten and look to unf finally end this unfair 10% sales commission charge and ensure these reforms sit alongside wider reforms to leasehold?
Speaker 10
I thank my honorable friend for that question, and I again emphasize that I appreciate the frustration amongst park homeowners. Unfortunately, we don't have the evidential basis that we need to act. We need to make a decision on the basis of evidence that is gathered through this current call for evidence taking place, and then take into account the impact on parts of all sizes to ensure fairness and transparency transparency. But I can reassure my honorable friend that we will act, once we have that information and evidence that we are seeking. Luke Charters.
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. Because of the inconsistent and disproportionate practices observed, the government has consulted on modernising and improving the administration of council tax, including its collection, and we'll publish our response shortly.
Speaker 10
Mister speaker, working with the charity Step Change, we have seen that some councils are too often moving too quickly towards bailiff enforcement action. So would the minister consider issuing best practice across councils to ensure that vulnerable households are supported instead of too often being pushed into further financial misery by overly aggressive enforcement action.
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. And I'd like to thank the honorable gentleman for raising this issue on the floor of the house and through him, thanks StepChange for their work. As I mentioned, we'll have more to say in this area shortly, but as he will know, the Ministry of Justice is also involved, in the issues that he mentioned, so I'll work with ministers in that department too.
Speaker 96
Thank you, mister speaker. Council tax is widely acknowledged to be a deeply regressive and unfair tax based on property values that are decades out of date, and the poorest households pay a much larger proportion of their income in council tax than the wealthiest. So rather than consulting on just better ways to collect it, will the minister instead commit to review and replace this outdated and unfair tax with a system of taxation that is fairer and based on property values?
Speaker 6
Thank you, Mr Speaker, I thank the honourable lady for raising this issue. As I've said, we'll have more to say on this shortly, but when it comes to fairness, she'll know that the chancellor introduced a new charge for those properties that are of the highest value, showing that this Labour government is prepared to act when it comes to fairness. David
Speaker 122
mister speaker. Maximizing the rises in council tax underpin this government's entire approach to council finance. The minister has admitted the minister has admitted that no assessment has been done of the impact that this has on the cost of living for British households. So as the government sends in the bailiffs to support force its council tax maximization strategy, will she assure the house that the prime minister has considered the impact of these huge council tax rises on working households? Yeah.
Speaker 6
Yeah. Thank you, mister speaker. I mean, I think that is a little bit rich given what we have all lived through over the past fourteen years. I would say to the honorable gentleman, on average, Tory councils cost you more. And I know that the most the best way that we will make sure that council finances recover from the period of Tory austerity is to improve services, stop paying the cost of failure, and help deal with the cost of living crisis too.
Speaker 4
was to join her on a visit to the new Pride In Place area at Enfield Wash during the Easter recess? Now many places in phase one of the program who have already announced their intention to spend what they're gonna spend their money on have selected community spaces as what they want to spend it on. And no wonder because community spaces are where communities can come together, take action together, and give their community the voice that they need to articulate their aspirations for the future.
Speaker 31
Thank you, mister speaker. Mister speaker, can I thank my right honourable friend for visiting Enfield Wash in my constituency last week? Mister speaker, after fourteen years of Conservative cuts, Enfield has lost around 60% of its funding, hitting vital service like adult social care, youth services, and the high street. Despite the cuts, Enfield Labour Council has worked tirelessly to protect residents and support the most vulnerable. So does my right honourable friend agree with me and our brilliant Labour council leader, Ergen Eberle?
Speaker 1
Order order. Please. I know I know we're into an election period, but we're gonna have to short the questions to get all the members in. I'm sure the secretary of state will agree.
Speaker 4
Always agree with you, mister speaker. Fair funding, of course, is going to provide a significant increase for Enfield Council in line with levels of deprivation, and the additional funding for two pride in place areas will give two of the most held back areas additional funding to take control of their own futures.
Speaker 69
Thank you, mister speaker. In Staffordshire County Council area, we've got some amazing community spaces, but some community spaces that would benefit from additional investment, and Pride in Place would have been a great way to do that. But sadly, none of the local authorities in the Staffordshire County Council area are eligible to Pride in Place. And it does feel a little bit like gerrymandering, in terms of a result, but I'm sure that is not the case. Would the secretary of state commit to actually looking at this afresh and see if there's any opportunity for Staffordshire not to be forgotten by this government.
Speaker 4
what Labor is doing with fair funding is ensuring that funding goes where deprivation is highest after the previous prime minister stood up in a leafy garden in Tunbridge Wells and boasted about how the conservatives were taking money away from deprived areas to use it for what I can only assume was gerrymandering. Thank
Speaker 16
you, mister speaker. In Dudley, the pride in place is being divided between two constituencies, risking dilution of its impact. Given the high levels of deprivation of many of my residents that they face in Dudley, what steps will my right honourable friend take to ensure communities in Dudley fully feel the transformational benefits of this investment and see tangible improvements locally? And will he weep with me to see how we can crowd in funding?
Speaker 4
Joe Stadt. Thank you for your question. Of course, the most exciting thing about Pride in Place is its communities themselves, not politicians who take the decisions about how the money, will be spent. They will come together from across, the area that is benefiting from the funding, and they will decide what they want to do to put Pride back into a community that had Pride ripped out of the heart of it by the party opposite. John Mill.
Thank you,
Speaker 32
mister speaker. There are real concerns that pride in place is just another example of this government's blind spot when it comes to rural areas. Groups like the Rural Services Network and Plunkett Foundation warn that villages are being left behind. Key rural assets are disappearing fast, and Plunkett are calling for a targeted 10,000,000 rural community ownership fund to help. So what is the government doing to make sure that rural communities don't get left out again?
Speaker 4
course, the funding was distributed according to data provided by the indices of multiple deprivation. So it's going to the areas that are most deprived wherever in the country they may lie, in urban areas or in rural areas. But, of course, with a fair funding review, that also ensured that funding was targeting those areas that needed it the most and have been most deprived of it by the previous government, including a measure on rurality, to ensure that rural areas get their fair share.
Speaker 10
Minister. Mister speaker, responsibility for developing a registration scheme for short term lets in England lies with the department for culture, media, sport. It is building a simple and easy to use registration scheme for short term lets informed by ongoing stakeholder feedback and consultation. The scheme entered user testing in October ahead of its planned launch this year.
Speaker 36
Thank you, mister speaker. The scale of short term holiday lets in York continues to heighten our significant housing challenges, impacts our public services and the economy, whilst residents are having to put up with antisocial behaviour on their doorsteps. So while a registration scheme will be helpful and it would be good to know exactly when it will be introduced, Will the minister also commit to working with MPs who face significant challenges of Airbnb's in rural coastal and urban communities and embark on a consultation for licensing in the next parliamentary session? Minister.
Speaker 10
I thank my honorable friend for her question, and I understand the, acute pressure she faces in her constituency as a result of an excessive concentration of short term. Let she and I only recently met to discuss this matter, but I'll happily continue to engage with any honorable member across the house in relation to it. As she knows, the government appreciates that excessive concentrations of short term lets can impact the availability and affordability of homes both to rent and to buy, and we continue to consider what additional powers we might give local authorities to enable them to respond to the pressures created by such concentrations.
Speaker 19
mister speaker. In rural and coastal communities, hospitality is already under massive pressure, thanks to the tax rises, regulatory impacts, and other negative impositions by this government. So can I urge ministers to make sure if we bring in a registration scheme, gather the data, and don't move in too heavy handed for the risk would be that we will, damage further damage a hospitality sector, which doesn't need it until we can establish the data and find out whether further action is required? Well,
Speaker 10
I can assure the honorable gentleman that DCMS is working closely with digital delivery experts to ensure that the registration service is robust, secure, and simple to use, minimizing the impact on businesses for precisely the reasons that he gave. Kirkham.
Speaker 37
Thank you, mister speaker. You will be aware that the has the second highest number of short term lets in the country after London. We understand that DCMS has responsibility for the scheme. But would the minister consider discussing with his, opposite number in DCMS, the possibility of uploading registering things like fire and safety certificates and checks rather than just a simple light touch registration scheme in the future, if not during this round?
Speaker 10
Well, as I said, I think, mister speaker, we know that excessive concentrations of short term lets affect urban and rural constituencies, but coastal, communities in particular, are feeling the acute pressures that result from them. I'm more than happy to engage, as I do already, my counterpart in DCMS, and to raise these specific points that she makes.
Speaker 65
will the minister look at closing the loophole that allows second homeowners, people who are well off enough to afford more than one home, to dodge paying any council tax whatsoever by putting their property on as a short term net for up to seventy two days seventy two days a year, therefore pay no council tax. But because they're a small business, they pay no business rates either. Thousands of my constituents are working their socks off to pay the council tax to subsidize people like that. That's wrong, isn't it? And will he also bring in a separate category of planning use to make short term lets more easy to control?
Speaker 10
Minister. Well, the honorable gentleman is well aware of what we've already done on the furnished lettings exemption. We look at taxation in this regard and keep it under constant review as ever. And we've had a long discussion on this particular issue over many years, mister speaker. But I'm more than happy to continue the conversation with him.
John Tricky
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. In December, DCMS published the National Youth Strategy, our ten year plan to ensure young people can access services and opportunities they need to thrive, and I speak regularly to local leaders about this work. The local government finance settlement makes available £78,000,000,000 for English councils this year, most of which is on ring fenced, giving councils flexibility to meet local needs, including for youth services.
Speaker 39
and thank the minister for her, response. But the truth is that in the austerity years, over over £1,000,000,000 was taken out of youth services by the previous government. That was shameful, and it was damaging to the social fabric. The legacy left behind, the minister's already indicated we're beginning to tackle, but in the mining communities, with villages remote and no bus services really available in the evening, young people being left behind, is there more that we can do to help those mining villages? And would she also reflect on the the availability of a of a youth center which has been left closed now since the tories were in office in Upton in my constituency, which might well be used as a youth hub.
Speaker 6
And thank you, mister speaker, and I thank the, honorable gentleman for his contribution, which reminds us of the damage that was done, particularly to those least able to bear it. I'm pleased to say that for Wakefield, spending power has increased by just shy of 27% since Labour came to office. So when it comes to the youth centre in Upton, I hope that there's more options available for Wakefield than there once was, but I'm happy to work with him on it.
Speaker 9
Chocker Adam. Thank you, mister speaker. There is a direct link between youth services and housing communities. In fact, it's been shown that once we invest in our youth services, there's reduced homelessness and fewer young people in temporary accommodation. However, the cut in real terms close to a billion pounds means the whole sector has been decimated.
And so will the minister agree with me that when we lose our youth service in our centers, our whole community suffers? And how is this government going to make youth working a viable career going forward? Minister.
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. And I thank the honorable gentleman for his contribution. Sadly, we all know only too well the cost that young people, had to bear of the years of austerity. Through the homelessness strategy, we have been trying to support young people at an earlier stage, and I'd discuss that with him. We need to make sure that young people really do get a decent chance in life.
Speaker 23
Thank you, mister speaker. May I take the opportunity to wish you a happy Easter. Over the during the time of the previous government, youth funding was reduced by approximately 70%. In particular, it was universal provision that was impacted the most. While we on these benches welcomed the youth strategy, I'm very concerned that local government reorganisation will actually result in continued reduction in youth provision within our communities.
Speaker 42
We need to remember that it's actually the voluntary sector that pick up the pieces soft, and I see this in my own constituency. They do a brilliant job, but it shouldn't be down to just them on their own. Can the minister advise what assessment has been made of the impact of local government reorganization on youth provision in areas beyond their promised 50 young future hubs? Sorry.
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. And I I think we're on different sides of the house at risk of breaking out into violent agreement about the importance of youth services and, what the Conservative Party did to them previously.
Speaker 1
Mister Stewart, we don't need any extra help. Right. Let us move on, Carol Langhorne.
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker, and for that assistance. I have regular conversations with ministerial colleague colleagues across government, and my department works very closely with the Department for Work and Pensions and the interactions between social security policy and homelessness.
Speaker 43
you, mister speaker. Years of freezes to local housing allowance by successive governments has meant that it goes nowhere near covering the cost of social housing, let alone renting privately. In my constituency, the average rent for a three bedroom home can be well over but a family of four will only receive a month. Poor and temporary housing is a key driver of child poverty, so it's really important we resolve this. Will the minister commit to working with the Department for Work and Pensions to unfreeze local housing allowance, so that we can lift children out of deep poverty?
Speaker 6
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the hon. Lady for her important question. And in my previous role and in my current role, I've worked very closely across, MHCLG and DWP to, as I said before, to see the interactions between poverty and homelessness. We spend £34,000,000,000 annually on housing support through social security, including 12,000,000,000 on the private rented sector.
As part of the child poverty strategy, we have lifted the two child limit, will help families stay in homes, particularly larger families. We're helping parents with childcare costs. We have brought in the fair repayment rate so that people don't need to get into unnecessary debt, and we've increased the standard allowance of universal credit above inflation for the first time as far as anyone can remember. Those are big steps to help family income and we should all be proud. Jordan.
Thank you Mr Speaker.
Speaker 85
The gap between average rents and wages in pool is among the widest in the country. Freezing the local housing allowance has clearly made that position worse. So can the minister outline when this freeze will end and when we will see the allowance increase to reflect the actual housing costs that people face?
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker, and I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. We obviously keep the local housing allowance under review along with DWP. I would just say to him, if you want to prevent homelessness, you need to build homes and make sure that people can afford them. That's why the chancellor's investment of £39,000,000,000 to build the social housing we need is a crucial part of making sure that families can get housed properly in this country in future.
Speaker 10
Mister speaker, the government is committed to preserving green belts, which have served England's towns and cities well over many decades. We have not changed the five purposes of the green belt set out at paragraph a 143 of the national planning policy framework, and that framework still contains strong protections for Green Belt, making clear that inappropriate development in it should not be approved unless justified by very special circumstances.
Speaker 46
Thank you, mister speaker. The bench's opposite approach to Green Belt is the clearest example yet of them saying one thing and doing another. The secretary of state campaigns against building on green spaces in his own constituency, but is more than happy to see green space in my constituency concreted over by developers. So I'd like to ask the minister if he can tell me why constituents' green space in in my area is apparently less important than the green space in the Secretary of State?
Speaker 10
As the right honorable lady well understands, we've had this exchange many times. It is for individual local planning authorities to determine if Greenbelt should be released and if that exceptional circumstances test, has been met. But I have to say, mister speaker, all the clever questions she comes up with, and I admire her ingenuity for doing so, Disguise her true position, which is she doesn't want any houses built on any Green Belt land in any part of her constituency or anywhere near, even if that means preventing families from buying or even longer waits for people on housing waiting registers.
Speaker 3
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mister speaker, is the minister confident that the government's invention of the term grey belt is providing protection to the green belt?
Speaker 120
I am confident. I am confident, mister speaker. But is it now, perhaps the honorable gentleman could confirm to me, the policy of her majesty's opposition that if all reasonable options, mister speaker, for meeting identified housing need have been exhausted, including grey belt land, that no green belt land can ever be released even under those very special circumstances. If that is the position, the opposition are consciously and deliberately consigning people in this country to longer misery as a result of the acute housing crisis that got worse on their watch and is still causing misery, and we are undoing.
Speaker 94
Mister speaker, the government have previously claimed that so called grey belt land is comprised of old petrol stations and disused car parks. But by December 2025, if the 13 developments of 10 or more homes have been approved by government planning inspectors on so called grey belt land, 88% were due to be built on what had previously been undeveloped countryside. Mister speaker, the evidence is unequivocal. The fact is that the green belt is under attack from this government. Why wouldn't the minister just admit the term grey belt is in fact a dishonest concoction designed to mislead the general public?
Speaker 10
It's anything but a dishonest concoction, mister speaker. Grey belt, as I've said, is determined by local planning authorities where they doesn't meet the purposes of the green belt as set out. But what is the honorable gentleman saying? I come back to mister speaker. Is he saying that our strategic and targeted approach to the Green Belt should be replaced by the chaotic and haphazard approach that the previous government took, in which we saw sways of Green Belt released across the country often in the wrong areas.
Grey Belt is ensuring that the right kind of low quality Green Belt land is released where all other options have been exhausted and where housing needs needs to be met through that avenue. Serious May.
Speaker 4
The Pride in Place programme supports community community cohesion by backing locally led, change determined by local people who live in the area who come together, whatever their background, to determine their own priorities to putting pride back at the heart of their communities.
Speaker 16
I've also established a Get Heimbern Working Group, is bringing together local organisations, schools, the EWP, bond sector organisations, the college and our training providers to tackle economic inactivity and look at the high levels of young people that we have who are out of work, training and education. Does the minister agree with me that pride in place funding could play a key role in supporting these place based collective approaches to tackling issues like these?
Speaker 4
of all, can I congratulate her on bringing that working group together? I think that is an excellent way to use her role as a member of parliament to support her community, to have a bigger say, and to enable them to share their ideas, their creativity about how they tackle local priorities, in the circumstances he's talking about, the important matter of getting people into work and guaranteeing them a better future.
Speaker 10
Mister speaker, the government recognized that a far smaller proportion of social rented homes are let as furnished or partly furnished compared with the private rented sector. In our response to last year's consultation on a new decent home standard, we made clear that we're exploring what more can be done to support tenants who are most in need to access floor coverings and other essential furniture. Tenants currently living without essential furniture can, of course, look to local authorities for support through the Crisis and Resilience Fund.
Speaker 20
you, mister speaker. Carbon Homes, which is the dominant social landlord within North Durham, provides furnished tenancies to ensure that vulnerable low income tenants can access essential furniture and white goods. What steps will his department undertake to ensure that other social landlords across The UK adopt this approach to greatly improve the quality of life for the least well off people?
Speaker 10
I thank my honorable friend for his question, and I commend carbon homes, mister speaker, for their commitment to furnished tenancies. While such tenancies are not mandatory, we know that many social landlords want to know more about the opportunities that furnished tenancy schemes can provide, as well as the funding and budgeting implications and operational requirements. We intend to publish comprehensive best practice guidance alongside our updated decent home standard and will engage with providers and other stakeholders in its development.
Speaker 48
Thank you, mister speaker. In my constituency, I have families moving into social housing with no beds for their children to sleep in, no table to eat family meals, and no white goods to cook healthy meals. So will the minister recognize the importance of ensuring that tenants moving into social housing have access to basic furniture? And will he commit to working with social housing providers to make sure no one is left without the essentials? Here.
Speaker 10
Minister? I thank the honorable lady for her question. I do recognize the importance of ensuring that tenants can access essential furniture where required. As I said, furnished tenancies are not mandatory in making the decision on the decent home standard. We had to balance the costs involved with ensuring that that's a requirement across all providers.
But we are, as I say, not least through the best practice guidance that I just made clear that we intend to bring forward, seeking to encourage the really good practice that's out there and that so that more social landlords can take, advantage of the opportunities that furnished tenancy schemes provide.
Speaker 10
Thank you, mister speaker. The government continues to steadily implement those reforms to the leasehold system that are already in statute and to progress the wider set of reforms necessary to end the leasehold system for good in this parliament, not least through the provisions in our draft common hold and leasehold reform bill that was published on the January 27.
Speaker 49
My constituent Yvonne has lived in a house that she's owned in Helserwyn for twenty years. She purchased it under a leasehold arrangement that allowed her property management company, Principal Estate Management, to quadruple her service charge from £400 to $15.50 pounds without conducting any maintenance. Clearly Yvonne feels like she's being ripped off and her other members of the housing estate that they live on are now having difficulty selling their homes. So can the minister outline what action is being taken to tackle property management firms like principal estate management, so people like Yvonne aren't continually being ripped off?
Speaker 10
I thank my honorable friend for that important I'm determined, mister speaker, to switch on the improved leaseholder consumer rights provided for by the 2024 act, including service charge standardization and transparency measures, at the earliest possible opportunity so that people like Yvonne and many hundreds of thousands more across the country who I know as I do in my own constituency are dealing with exorbitant service charge increases to get the protection they need. When it comes to managing agents, as my honorable friend knows, we're committed to strengthening regulation, but I'll happily write to him to provide him with the full position and details of what measures we are considering to take forward.
Speaker 50
Mister speaker, I thank the minister very much for his answer and to the honorable gentleman for Hillsborough for bringing forward some of the issues that he referred to. We have we have similar problems in my constituency, and I know the minister is very keen to to ensure that all parts of The United Kingdom can take advantage of the legislative change that the government has proposed here. So can I ask the minister this question? Can't he discuss with the relevant minister in Northern Ireland to assure that the proposals put forward by government here to address the issues of the Norman German can be done for my constituents in Northern Ireland as Thank you.
Speaker 10
I thank the honorable gentleman for his question. As he knows, we engage regularly with, counterparts, from Northern Ireland. I'm more than happy in the case of leasehold reform, which covers just England and Wales, to provide him with the insights of the proposals we've been working up and what more we are considering to take forward in future months and years.
Speaker 10
Thank you, mister speaker. The government does not support the introduction of rent controls, which we believe could make life more difficult for renters. There is sufficient international evidence from countries such as Sweden and Germany and from individual cities such as San Francisco and as well as the recent Scottish experience to attest to the potential detrimental impacts of rent controls on tenants?
Speaker 37
Thank you, mister speaker. There is an injection of housing investment in some parts of my constituency, but sadly, it is by landlords who are taking advantage of low house prices to turn family homes, whole terraces into HMOs, charging sky high rents for people to live in single bedrooms, undermining the local community. Could I ask the minister, because he's told me a few times that the government is opposed to rent controls, to really look again at the evidence and start to consult? Because it's clear we need to see rents come down in this country, especially in the most deprived areas.
Speaker 10
I can assure my humble friend that I've looked at a wealth of evidence, in particularly international evidence, of what the impact of first and second generation rent controls are, or even subtler forms of rent control, can have differential impacts on different groups typically benefiting benefiting settled and better off tenants more than those looking for a home or needing to move. So while I appreciate there's a broad spectrum of regulation that falls under the title, miss Figa, there's enough international evidence in the government's view to attest to the potential detrimental impacts of rent control, and it remains the government position that we will not introduce them.
Speaker 4
Sterling. Mister speaker, the renters rights Act meets Labour's manifesto commitment to transform the experience of private renting in England. We will introduce our reforms in three phases, and the first phase begins on the May 1 year. On this date, section 21 no fault evictions will be abolished. Rent increases will be limited to just once a year.
We will end rental bidding wars and limit requests for rent in advance to a maximum of one month, and it will be illegal to discriminate against prospective renters who have children or who receive benefits. These are the biggest reforms in the rental sector in a generation. And while the Tories and reform voted against them and the Greens want to abolish renting, this Labour government stands firmly on the side of renters. Sheriff Dye.
Speaker 37
Mister speaker, the availability of affordable housing in Somerset has plummeted. Demand has surged, and rents have gone up six times as much as income. These challenges are highlighted in rural market towns like Glastonbury, where hundreds of people live in vans and caravans lining the curbsides. Many are there because they can't afford to rent a bricks and mortar home. So what steps is the minister taking to ensure everyone has a decent and safe place where they can afford to live?
Here.
Speaker 4
Cheers. Of course, ensuring that there is a decent and a safe place for people to live all across the country is a primary objective of this of this government. She will be aware that the social and affordable homes program opened to bids in February. It closes in the first phase, later on in April. That provides up to £39,000,000,000 for the biggest increase in social and affordable, including council housing, right across this country.
That will make a massive difference to people in rural areas as well as other parts of the country.
Speaker 49
Thank you, mister speaker. One of the biggest housing challenges we have in many of my villages of Suffolk coastal, and market towns like Alford, Oldborough, and even larger towns like Felixstowe, is social housing providers selling off housing stock and not replacing it locally. Looking at how we tackle this issue is critical, and expanding the rural exemption sites must be part of that solution as set out in the recent LRG report. Will the minister set out what steps he has taken to expand rural sites to deliver affordable housing?
Speaker 10
Minister. I thank my honorable friend for her question. Our recent consultation on a revised MPPF included proposals to strengthen support for rural exemption sites and to make it easier for authorities to require affordable housing on smaller sites in rural areas. She will also be aware that designated rural areas are already exempt from the right to buy, but I'd be more than happy to meet with her and the rest of the members of the research group to discuss protecting existing stock and other matters covered in the recent report she referenced.
Speaker 47
in Bromsgrove, a rural constituency facing an 85% increase in its housing target whilst neighboring Labour run Birmingham with significant brownfield capacity has seen its target cut by more than 30%, a target increasing by 37% in Essex, but decreasing by 11% in London. House building has collapsed under this labor government. So why is he letting his labor run urban friends off the hook whilst dumping the housing targets in rural Britain?
Speaker 4
was the conservative government that abolished housing targets everywhere and led to the housing crisis that we're facing where the number of people sleeping rough on the streets and in shop doorways doubled. They're smiling while I'm explaining what they did. They're smiling that the number of people sleeping on the streets doubled. And the number of families in temporary accommodation, that doubled as well. And they did nothing when the housing market collapsed in 2223 because of Liz Truss's budget, which the opposition shadow secretary of state supported.
Sir James.
Speaker 47
He can't answer. He doesn't have an answer, mister speaker. Perhaps he could answer this because he failed to do so in response to a written question. He has once again refused to publish either the prospectus or the selection criteria for his election pilots. And this is part of a wider pattern.
Speaker 31
Canceling elections they don't think they're gonna win, changing local government boundaries instead of giving that task to the independent boundary commission, changing voter ID without consultation. When I saw this kind of behavior overseas, I called it out for what it was, dirty, self interested, partisan politics. So will he scrap this Auburn style politics and start doing it properly?
Speaker 4
Well, I mean, as he's aware, elections are going ahead all over the country right now. I suspect he, like me, has been campaigning and knocking on doors, to talk to people about how they're gonna vote. We'll find out in a few weeks what their judgments on all of us will be.
Speaker 22
Speaker, I welcome action the government is taking to improve reporting and transparency of political donations from unincorporated associations in the representation of the people bill. 97% of donations from these bodies since 10 came from unknown sources under existing rules. But will ministers consider going further and require information to be published on who runs unincorporated associations that make political donations and what their purpose is to ensure that we have maximum transparency.
Speaker 18
Thank you, mister speaker. Through the representation of the people bill, we're significantly lowering the threshold for when unincorporated associations register with the electoral commission, and will be requiring them to publicly identify a responsible person who is legally accountable for compliance with electoral law.
Speaker 42
a development of 500 plus homes in my constituency predicated on building a brand new Howard of Effingham School was withdrawn after a decade of commitment to the plan. The developer is expected to proceed with a new application without a school. The community and school are understandably angry and up set. What powers does the minister have to ensure developers can be held to such long term commitments? And will he meet with me to discuss the issue and its implications in my constituency and more widely?
Speaker 10
Mister speaker, the honorable lady will, I know, appreciate that we can't comment as ministers on individual planning applications or individual local, plans, but I'm more than happy to meet with her and discuss the general issues arising from the case she mentions.
Speaker 54
much, mister speaker. I previously raised the case of the Ada Bellfield Care Centre in Bellport with my honorable friend, the minister of state from Birkenhead. At the moment, that has an uncertain future. Reformed Derbyshire County Council may sell the home. Can I ask her to take an interest in this case to make sure that we've got adequate so so adult social care provision in Derbyshire?
Perhaps might raise that with the council's leadership.
Speaker 6
Okay. Minister? Thank you, mister speaker. And I thank my friend for raising it. It's important for local authorities to work very closely with NHS colleagues, as I'm doing in government, to make sure that we've got sufficient adult social care, because otherwise we won't be able to get people out of hospital and into good homes.
So I would ask them to pay attention to that, and I'll happily work with him on it.
Speaker 15
mister speaker. Mid general in Stockport is the MJ's council of the year. It spends 3 in every four pounds on adults and children, and it includes the most deprived part of Greater Manchester. Yet the Government's funding settlement leaves the borough receiving £52,000,000 less than the average each year compared to equivalent authorities, made significantly worse this year. What advice would the minister give to my constituents when they see the council having to make cuts to vital local services?
Thank
Speaker 6
you, mister speaker. I'd like to thank the honorable lady for raising this point. We want to see all councils progress towards financial sustainability. And what I would say to her constituents is that the decisions taken under the past fourteen years have left councils paying for failure. We get that right.
We'll be able to spend on the things that people really prioritize locally.
Speaker 55
Thank you, mister speaker. Can the minister outline how the new national homelessness strategy will provide additional funds to Sunderland City Council to tackle rough sleeping and support the vital work that organizations like Oasis, the Salvation Army, and Sunderland Community Soup Kitchen do in our city?
Speaker 6
Minister? Thank you, mister speaker. And I'd like to thank my friend for raising this issue. And through him, if I may, mister speaker, I'd like to thank the organizations that he mentions. Our homelessness plan provides millions of pounds for Sunderland to do that work to help prevent people becoming homeless, and as a with all members, I'll work with him on that.
Speaker 49
Thank you, mister speaker. The government's connectivity tool classifies land proposed for development at Bighorn Hill and Hayes Farm as equally well connected as the Greenwich Peninsula. This is utterly nonsensical. Does the minister recognize that the government's housing targets for the London borough of Bromley are both unfair and unachievable?
Speaker 10
I I do find it quite galling, mister speaker, that we've got the shadow secretary of state saying that we've lowered London's housing targets too far, and the honorable gentleman saying they're too high. They're just in the right place from my point of view.
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. And I thank the secretary of state for outlining the new reforms that will come through with the Rentals Rights Act. Eighteen days, and residents will see no fall evictions banned. The minister also knows that with that, we need local authorities to have the resources, and the minister outlined that there will be additional resources for local authorities, including the launch of the PRS database and the launch of the PRS housing ombudsman. Can the minister give us an update on when that will be live?
Speaker 10
Yeah. Thank you, our honorable friend, for that question. She won't have to wait long at all to find out details of the new burdens funding that's coming through for local authorities. And as she knows, in terms of implementation of the wider bill, both the database and the ombudsman and other things are coming through in further waves than the wave that commences on the May 1.
Speaker 37
Thank you, mister speaker. Rural areas are facing a wave of unauthorized developments on land owned by travelers with little or no action being Yeah. Taken against them.
Speaker 37
My right honorable friend, the member for East Surrey, and 30 of my colleagues have been pressing for national support to give new powers to the police and local authorities to deal with this. Here. Will the minister meet with us to discuss this issue, is causing havoc in our precious British countryside?
Speaker 10
Mister speaker, local planning authorities have a range of planning enforcement powers to tackle unauthorized development with strong penalties for noncompliance. In our recent consultation on a revised planning policy framework, we included proposals to strengthen national policy in respect of unauthorized development. We're more than happy to meet her and other honorable members about the issue.
Speaker 57
Thank you, missus Victor. In constituency of Blackpool South pay more in council tax for their housing than mansions in Mayfair. This is because under the conservatives, Blackpool Council had to put their council tax up to the max
Speaker 6
I already mentioned the increased charge that the chancellor introduced because this Labour Party believes in fairness when it comes to council tax. And I'll work with councils right across the country to get their costs down so that people are not paying sky high bills in future.
Speaker 44
The presumption in favor of development in transport nodes and also the so called grey belt means that in my constituency of Isher and Walton, which is half green belt, disproportionately high number of stations with everybody lives within fifteen minutes of a station means that you could develop everywhere under the government proposal.
Speaker 10
You should say to them that they live nearby highly sustainable areas for development, and we wanna see more homes come forward in those areas. Sarah Coombs.
Speaker 37
Thank you, mister speaker. Last week, the Sikh community in Sanwell was rocked by a second appalling attack at Guru Nanak Gudwara. For the second time, the Gudwara faced a racist attack where someone dropped a bag of meat on the doorstep. Given the strictly banned inside the Gurdwara, this was deeply offensive. Given it's a repeat attack, will the minister meet with me
Speaker 6
Thank you, mister speaker. And I'd like to thank the my honorable friend for, telling the house about this appalling incident, which we will all agree is absolutely terrible. Racial and religious hate is completely unacceptable, and I'm sure her constituents will be glad to know that the prime minister is here to hear what's happened too. The government supports organizations, and I'll make sure that the minister for community cohesion meets with her.
Speaker 49
At the behest of Labour dominated Southampton City Council, two thirds of my constituents are to be torn away from the New Forest and placed under the control of an urban dominated unitary authority. Does the minister accept that my constituents are overwhelmingly against
Speaker 6
Mister speaker, I thank the royal mother gentleman for raising this point on behalf of his constituents. We take everybody's views into account. I know this will be difficult, but we will be working with all colleagues as we make this process work.
Speaker 50
Thank you, mister speaker. The week before Easter, Derby suffered a terrible incident when a car was driven into crowds of people on Frygate, and several people were seriously injured. Will the minister join me in thanking the emergency services for their response and men's the public who delivered first aid? And will the minister meet with me to discuss how we strengthen local preparedness and design out risks, not just in Derby, but across the country to help keep people safe in future.
Speaker 18
Thank you, mister speaker. I'm so sorry to hear about this terrible incident. I will, of course, meet with my honorable friends. The local resilience forum in Derbyshire Derbyshire has worked really hard to respond to this event, and I will, work with her across the and across the country for resilience and recovery.
Speaker 34
Council has a vendetta against local businesses, most recently placing an enormous storage crate outside the Dickens Tea Cottage, which is gonna affect local businesses. Will the minister urge them to remove that so that we can make sure we protect custom at that local business.
Speaker 6
speaker, I would advise all councils not to have a vendetta against local businesses.
Speaker 4
Thank you, mister speaker. In just one week prior to Easter, Hillingdon Council discharged their homelessness duty by issuing 22 secondtion two zero eight notices by placing 77 individuals, including 35 children, into Hartlepool with many of them concentrated in just one postcode. Does the minister accept this unfair practice places a far too greater burden on towns like mine? Yeah.
Speaker 6
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You, mister speaker. And I thank my friend for bringing this issue to the house.
He knows how important this is. Hillingdon Council will have heard what he has to say. And mister speaker, I won't try your patience with rehearsing all that we're doing on this, but it's not acceptable. Yes.
Speaker 1
It's not my patience. It's it's the house. Right. We'll let the front bench change over. Welcome to the statement.
Prime minister.
Speaker 63
Thank you, mister speaker. With permission, I'd like to update the house on my visit to The Gulf, the evolving situation in The Middle East, and the implications for Britain's security. But before I do that, I want to put on record in this house my total determination to make the changes across the entire state that are so clearly necessary to honor the victims, the injured, and the families of Southport. Hear. Today's report, mister speaker, is harrowing.
It is difficult to read, and I cannot begin to imagine the pain upon pain that will cause the families that it affects. And our thoughts are with them today. And the home secretary will respond to the report in full, mister speaker, after this statement. Mister speaker, last week, I visited The Gulf, and I was able to thank in person some of the brave men and women who from day one of The US Iran conflict have resolutely defended the interests of this country, its people, and its partners. I thank them again, mister speaker, in this house for their courage and their service, and I'm sure the whole house will join me in those thanks.
Mister speaker, whilst in The Gulf, I met leaders and senior military representatives across the region, including the crown prince of Saudi Arabia, the president of The UAE, the king and crown prince of Bahrain, the emir and prime minister of Qatar, and in recent days, I've also spoken to the sultan of Oman and the emir of Kuwait. Across all of these conversations, I agreed to deepen our engagement on both defense and economic resilience Because, mister speaker, they all made it abundantly clear that the solidarity and strength of our partnership with them has been a comfort in these challenging times. And we should not forget that the nature of Iran's response, the indiscriminate attack upon countries who never sought this conflict, the huge damage done across The Gulf to civilian infrastructure with civilian casualties is abhorrent. It has clearly shocked the region and all of us, and we must bear that in mind now as we lift our sights to the future. Because whilst the ceasefire between The US, Israel, and Iran is undeniably welcome, it is also highly fragile.
The region remains on edge, and a lot of work is required to reopen the Strait Of Hormuz to deescalate the situation leading to a sustainable ceasefire. In pursuit of that goal, we call for Lebanon to be included urgently in the ceasefire. Diplomacy is the right path, and I welcome the talks taking place this week. Hezbollah must disarm, but I'm equally clear Israel strikes are wrong. They are having devastating humanitarian consequences and pushing Lebanon into a crisis.
The bombing should stop now. Mister speaker, we also put on record our thanks to Pakistan and other partners for playing such an important role in diplomatic efforts. We hope the process will continue without further escalation, and that applies to the running sore that is the Strait Of Hormuz, shamefully exploited by Iran. All of the leaders that I met were crystal clear that freedom of navigation is vital and must be restored. No conditions, no tolls, and no tolerance of Iran holding the world's economy to ransom.
Because, mister speaker, the impact of Iran's behavior in the strait is causing untold economic damage. It's visible on every petrol ball court in the country. My guide from the start of this conflict has always been our national interest. That's why we stayed out of the war and why we continue to stay out of the war. And that is why we are work working now to restore freedom of navigation in The Middle East because that is squarely in our national interest.
Now, mister speaker, quite clearly, this is not a straightforward task. It will take time. I met UK businesses in energy shipping, insurance, finance, And they are clear that vessels will not be put through the strait until they are confident that it's safe to do so. And that's why we're working around the clock on a credible plan to reopen the Strait. And, mister speaker, I can confirm today that together with president Macron, I will convene a summit of leaders this week to drive forward the international effort we have built in recent weeks, bringing together dozens of countries to ensure freedom of navigation in the Strait Of Hormuz.
The summit will be focused on two things. First, diplomatic efforts to bring pressure to bear for a negotiated end to the conflict and for the strait to be opened. Second, military planning to provide assurance to shipping as soon as a stable environment can be established. And let me be very clear, this is about safeguarding shipping and supporting freedom of navigation once the conflict ends. Our shared aim here is a coordinated independent multinational plan.
This is the moment, mister speaker, for clear and calm leadership. And notwithstanding the difficulties, Britain stands ready to play our part. Mister speaker, let me now return to the impact of this conflict on our economy. We all know that the consequences will be significant, but they they will last longer than the conflict itself. Now we continue to monitor the effects, and I remind the house that energy bills went down on the April 1.
And whatever happens in The Middle East, those bills will stay down until July. We're investing over £50,000,000 to support heating oil customers, and fuel duty is frozen until September, all because of the decisions that this government took at the budget. But, mister speaker, there's a wider point because we can't stand here in this house and pretend that a global shock threatening to hit the living standards of British people is somehow a novel experience. Britain has been buffeted by crisis for decades now, from the two thousand eight financial crash through austerity, Brexit, COVID, the war that still rages in Ukraine, and the disastrous premiership of Litrust. The response each time the response each time has been to try to return to the status quo.
A status quo, mister speaker, that manifestly failed working people who saw their living standards flatlined and their public services decimated. So this time, Britain's response must and will be different to reflect the changing world that we live in. That starts with our economic security, where during this conflict alone, we've capped energy bills, raised the living wage, strengthened workers' rights, and ended the two child limit that will lift nearly half a million children out of poverty. But, mister speaker, looking forward, it also means a closer economic relationship with our European allies Yeah. Because Brexit did deep damage to the economy Yeah.
And the opportunities we now have to strengthen our security Yeah. And cut the cost of living are simply too big to ignore.
Speaker 63
It continues, mister speaker, with our energy security, where I say once again, oil and gas will be part of our energy mix for decades to come. But, mister speaker, we do not set the global price for oil and gas. And households across the country are fed up with international events beyond their control pushing up their energy bills, and I stand with them on that. So we will go further and faster on our mission to make Britain energy independent because that is the only way we get off the fossil fuel roller coaster and take control of our energy bills. Finally, mister speaker, we must strengthen our defense security.
That means boosting our armed forces as we have with the biggest sustained investment since the Cold War. It means doubling down on the most successful military alliance the world has ever seen, the NATO alliance, of which this party in government was a founding member. But it also means strengthening the European element of that alliance, taking control of our continent's defense more robustly, deepening our partnerships. Have we done with our deals to build Norwegian frigates on the Clyde, Turkish typhoons in Lancashire? Not only, mister speaker, creating thousands of secure jobs and opportunities for our defense industry right across the country, but also enhancing the way our armed forces can collaborate with our allies.
Because, mister speaker, as the Middle East conflict shows once more, The world in which we live has utterly changed. It is more volatile and insecure than at any period in my lifetime, and we must rise to meet it calmly but with strength. That is exactly what we're doing at home and abroad. We are strengthening our security, taking control of our future, and building a Britain that is fair for all. And I commend the statement to the house.
Speaker 64
Thank you, mister speaker. And can I thank the prime minister for advanced sight of his statement? I would also like to pay tribute to our brave servicemen and women serving in The Middle East right now. Mister speaker, the prime minister is right that Britain did not start this war, but whether we like it or not, we are impacted by it, and this is likely to get worse. The cost of borrowing has jumped, petrol prices are climbing, inflation is rising, and living standards falling.
It is time to take decisive action in our national interest. Britain must focus on what is in our power to protect British citizens today. First, we must rapidly solve the energy crisis this war has caused in our country. And second, we must make sure that Britain is ready to defend herself in this new age. A nuclear armed Iran is an existential threat to The UK.
Speaker 64
should be in no doubt whose side we're on in this war, our allies in The Middle East and The United States. So I welcome the prime minister meeting some of those allies, and I also welcome his support for diplomatic efforts and military planning to restore freedom of navigation in the region. But we will need to go further than just talking. He says Britain stands ready to play our part. We can all see that we were not ready for this situation.
Here's what we need to do now. First, we must take rapid action to increase our energy security and keep bills down, not just until July, but longer than that, permanently. Britain is particularly vulnerable to energy price shocks because we are killing domestic oil and gas production in the North Sea. Labor's policy of more expensive energy and deindustrialization at this time of crisis is dangerous and irresponsible. It is also harming the defence industry.
We must start drilling our own oil and gas in the North Sea, grant licenses for drilling in the Jackdaw and Rosebank fields, and restore British production before it is too late. The prime minister says this won't impact international prices. This is more than international prices. This is about the domestic supply, especially of gas, all of which is used in this country. Supply matters.
And finally, the government must cancel the proposed rise in fuel duties. Hiking taxes on motorists for the first time in fifteen years, while prices are surging is a disgraceful decision. If Britain is to be a stronger country, it needs a stronger economy, not one being hammered by the highest energy prices in the developed world. So will the prime minister grant the oil and gas licenses and scrap the rise in fuel duty? I know he'll say that it's the energy secretary's job.
The energy secretary is not the prime minister. He is. He can instruct him to grant those licenses. But, mister speaker, secondly, to be ready, Britain must be able to defend herself, and that means we must be ready for these situations before they happen. France and Greece, they are not I don't know why they're laughing.
I didn't. I'm I'm I'm surprised they're laughing because last time I checked, France and Greece sent ships to protect our bases in Cyprus while our destroyer was stuck in Portsmouth. It was a national embarrassment on their shoulders, and it should never happen again. We need no further evidence that we are living in a more dangerous world than a decade ago. I'm sure Labour MPs will try and think of a way to make this my fault.
Let me remind them. Yes. I know. And it's it is preposterous, but let me remind them the historical illiteracy that is on those benches. Governments of all colours, including those guys there, spent the peace dividend from 1989 when the Berlin Wall fell until the Ukraine war.
Speaker 8
And when that war came, the conservative government responded rapidly and unequivocally. We didn't have anything stuck in Portsmouth when Ukraine was invaded. We trained tens of thousands of Ukrainian soldiers and equipped them with our missiles. We increased defense spending every year since the war started, but the world has since become even more dangerous. Every serious person, mister speaker, every serious person, especially in the military, agrees that Britain must now find a way to spend 3% of GDP on defence by the end of this parliament.
Speaker 64
After the election, many of the plans for spending were paused for Labour's strategic defence review. Nine months after publishing it, there is still no defence investment plan that explains how we will fund this. The defence readiness bill is also nowhere to be seen. The question is not whether we need to increase defence spending. The question is what tough choices we must make to do so.
That is what is missing from the government's plan. The government has a plan for welfare spending until 2031, but no plans for defence spending. So I say to the prime minister, let's put party interest aside. Yes. I'm glad that I'm glad that they're laughing because I want the public to hear Labour MPs laughing when we say let's put party interest aside.
So please keep laughing. Go on. Please keep laughing. I say to the prime minister, let's find the money to rearm. Let's identify the spending cuts.
And if we reach agreement on a joint plan, we can all support those measures in parliament. Conservatives have already found savings to fund more than £20,000,000,000 extra for defense spending. I am willing to work with him to go further. And in his response, mister speaker, I'm sure the prime minister will be tempted to misrepresent my position and pretend that I demanded he join in the initial strikes. Yeah.
Yes. I know they can't even resist the temptation. He and I both know that is not true, but let us get serious. Let's get serious. It is time for us to act decisively in our national interest.
Let's show our allies what we bring to the table. Let's show our enemies that we are able and ready to defend ourselves. That requires a defense investment plan. So I asked the prime minister in conclusion, when exactly will the defense investment plan be published, and what action is he taking to find the money to pay for
Speaker 63
mister speaker, I noticed that her opening sentence has changed. She used to say, we didn't start the war, but like it or not, we're in it. Yep. And we should be in it. Yep.
That was her position. Now she says, well, they can't make their mind up. They supported the war without thinking through the consequences, and now they're pretending they didn't support the war and they're against it all along. She challenged my position, and she did the mother of all U turns on the most important decision the leader of the opposition ever has to take. Can I thank her for her support, for the planning that we're doing with other countries?
It is important. It has a number of components, the political and diplomatic component, the logistics as well in terms of getting the vessels through where we're working with the sector, and, of course, the military component. We've working on that for two or three weeks now and now bringing together with president Macron, the summit later this week in that, regard. In relation to, energy bills, mister speaker, yes, we all want to get energy bills, down, and oil and gas will be part of the mix for many years. But it is because we're on the international market that our bills have gone up, And that is the problem, that straight up for moves is a choke point for energy getting oil and gas getting to the international market.
That's pushed the price up. That's being reflected in every household. And that's why, mister speaker, the only way to take control of our energy bills is to go faster on energy independence. Now, mister speaker, the leader of the opposition used to make that argument. In 2022, she said this, it is investment in nuclear and renewables that will reduce our dependence on fossil fuels and keep costs down.
She keeps she changes her mind on everything. That is that was her argument. And now she put just like she pretends she wasn't in favor of getting involved in the war, now she pretends she wasn't in favor of keeping costs down. And, mister speaker, she says that we must be ready. That's coming from a party that hollowed out our armed services.
Mister speaker, on their watch, frigates and destroyers were reduced by 25%. Mine hunting ships reduced by 50% on their watch. And she lectures us about being ready, having hollowed out our armed forces and hollowed out our capabilities. We're investing 300,000,000 more in shipbuilding, and we got 13 ships on order. That, mister speaker, is the difference between the two parties.
Mister speaker, I hope that she and they will forgive me. After fourteen years of breaking everything under their watch, I'm really I'm going to resist I'm going to resist the offer of joint planning from the government, from the party that crashed the economy, hollowed out our armed forces, crashed our public services. Thanks, but no thanks.
Speaker 68
But when people heard the Israeli defense minister say that his war aims in Lebanon would follow the model in Gaza, our blood ran cold.
Speaker 68
the house what role The United Kingdom can do to ensure a ceasefire in Lebanon and that Lebanon that Israel is stopped from taking over Lebanon south of the Litani River? Yeah.
Speaker 63
Raise the important question of Lebanon. I want to be really clear in relation to that. That should be included in the ceasefire, and we're using every opportunity we can to make that argument. And, please, there's some diplomacy at the moment, but those attacks should stop, and it's really important we're very, very clear about that.
Speaker 69
Mister speaker, can I thank the prime minister for advanced sight of his statement? And can I join him in what he said about the horrific attack horrific attack in Southport? Our thoughts with the families of BB, LC, and Alice, and with all those affected. Mister speaker, a whole civilization will die tonight. Words I never thought I would hear from an American president.
And though Donald Trump thankfully didn't follow through this time, these words are a stark reminder of how reckless, immoral, and completely outside the bounds of international law this president is. Regrettably, he is no friend of The United Kingdom. He's no leader of the free world. He is a dangerous and corrupt gangster, and that is how we must treat him. So will the prime minister advise the king to call off his state visits to Washington before it's too late?
Because I really fear for what Trump might say or do while our king is forced to stand by his side. We cannot put his majesty in that position. And when it comes to Trump's latest cunning plan to blockade the Strait Of Hormuz, that will only escalate this crisis and jeopardize the precarious ceasefire. So it's right that The UK is not joining Trump, and I welcome the prime minister convening a summit to offer an alternative to Trump's. We must work with our reliable allies in Europe and the Commonwealth and our partners in The Gulf to bring this conflict to an end and keep open the Strait Of Houmas.
Speaker 71
That is critical for tackling the cost of living crisis that's getting worse and worse for people in The UK. With petrol prices now up by more than 25 p a litre and diesel up 49 p since Trump started this war, cheered on, let's not forget, by the leader of the Conservative Party and reform, does the prime minister recognize that families and businesses can't wait months for the government to step in and help? So will he use the windfalls the treasury is getting from higher fuel prices to cut the cost of living and keep the economy moving with action to slash bus fares and rail fares and cutting fuel duty by ten p today, bringing down the price of at the pumps by twelve p a liter?
Speaker 63
for his question? And and in relation to the language about destroying a civilization, could I really be clear with this house? That was wrong. Yeah. A threat to Iranian civilians in that way is wrong.
These are civilians, let's remember, who've suffered immeasurable harm by the regime in Iran for many, many long years. And that's why they're words and phrases that I would never use on behalf of this government, is guided by our principles and our values throughout all of this. Mister speaker, in relation to the king, the relationship the king's visit, the relationship between between our two countries is very important on a number of levels, and often what the monarchy is able to do, through the bonds that they build is reach through the decades in a situation like this. And the purpose of the visit is to mark the two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the relationship between our country and The United States, and that's why the visit is going ahead. In relation to the blockade, let me be clear as I've been already, in the last day or so, that, we are focusing our efforts on opening in full the Strait Of Hormuz because of the damage it's doing to economies around the world, including our own economy.
That is why we've been working with other countries, at various levels, and we'll bring them together, in a summit later this week. And we, The UK, will be not be joining the blockade that the president announced. In relation to the help that is needed to families and households, obviously, we put in place help for energy bills already and oil heating that is in place. But, mister speaker, we're keeping this under constant review as the situation evolves. The single most important and effective thing we can do is to deescalate the situation and work with others to get the Strait Of Hormuz open, and that is why we're focusing so much of our efforts in that regard.
Speaker 66
Thank thank you very much, mister speaker. I thank the prime minister for confirming that despite the significant unwelcome trolling and pressure from president Trump and Israeli PM Netanyahu that The UK is not being dragged into this war, and it is not in our national interest. Given that The US has now initiated the blockade of Iranian ports, can the prime minister confirm what steps are being taken to help deescalate the situation, whether it's to reopen the Strait Of Hormuz so that goods can transit freely and that we can ease the cost of living pressures for our constituents, and also what is being done to help deescalate the situation in Lebanon? And can you also confirm that any future UN UK involvement in the region will be strictly limited to defensive purposes only?
Speaker 63
Well, can I thank him and reiterate that we will not be dragged into the war? In relation to the steps we're taking, they're across a number of levels. It was central to discussions I had in The Gulf States last week in terms of what we can do together to deescalate. Mister speaker, they they are shocked and angry, frankly, that they have been attacked in the way that they have been attacked. They were not involved in the conflict, and it's clear to them that they were targeted within hours of the beginning of this conflict starting, and civilian infrastructure and civilians were targeted as well.
And they've absolutely clear that that targeting was put in place before the conflict started. So we're working with them. We're working across the coalition of dozens of countries now to deescalate and to get the Strait Of Hormuz open just as soon as it's viable and credible to do so.
Speaker 17
Hear. Hear. The prime minister may recall that on day one of this war, I supported his defensive attitude to it and said we couldn't change the regime from the air, and he's been he agreed. He's been proved right. But with apologies to Leon Trotsky, we may we may not be interested in war, but war is interested in us.
Speaker 72
So we all agree we have to rapidly rearm. The trouble is that with the ever increasing proportion of our, entire economy taken by the state pension and by benefits, perhaps we can't afford to do it. So will he work with the leader of the opposition to take the necessary, perhaps unpopular decisions to return defense spending to what we spent in 1989, the end of the Cold War?
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, we he's right to raise this, and we do we've already raised, defense spending, as he knows, in the most significant way since the Cold War. I've been clear in the Munich Security Conference that I gave a few weeks ago that we need to go further and faster, and we will. I think in addition in addition to, the funding itself, I think it's really important that we take this opportunity to collaborate and cooperate with our partners, particularly in Europe. Because if all European countries simply increase their spending without regard to the capability that they're using that spending on, we won't make the best of what we've got. And therefore, I'm making a a dual argument, one in relation to the actual money we spent, but secondly, the way we need to collaborate and the way we haven't done frankly for decades in relation to this with our allies, particularly in Europe.
Speaker 2
Shneura Ali. Thank you, mister speaker. I welcome the prime minister's call for Lebanon to be included in the ceasefire. 1,700 people have already been killed by Israeli attacks, and over 1,000,000 one and a 1,100,000 people have been displaced at a time when aid budgets have been cut, including by our own government. Will the prime minister commit to playing that international leadership role as he is doing in relation to getting a ceasefire, working with our European partners and others to support the humanitarian effort and increase support to those who are being displaced in the region, but also think about how we support countries in the global south that are now going to be hit very hard because of this crisis, because the the impact of that will affect all of us if we don't take action at the international level.
Speaker 63
Can I thank you for raising this really important issue? And be clear, Lebanon must be included in the ceasefire, and it's very important that we are clear about the principle behind that. I also, accept that there must be more support on the humanitarian front. We've just put more, money into the humanitarian support, but it's clearly a cause of concern, in Lebanon, actually, and in wider areas as she rightly points out.
Speaker 74
Andrew Mitchell. Thank you, mister speaker. I think the prime minister should acknowledge, I'm sure that he does, that over the last thirty years, our armed forces have been hollowed out by governments of all parties as they have ceased sought to take a peace dividend. But I'm afraid the chickens have come home to roost on his watch. So will he now commit to a huge and immediate uplift in defense spending, not just by vaporizing British soft power expenditure.
We are talking of moving towards a 5% increase so that the government can play a full part in European defense and deliver on its first duty to its own citizens?
Speaker 63
Well, I agree that our armed forces now capable of this hollowed out over over many years, in particular, under the last government, I'm afraid to say. Ben Wallace, the defense secretary then defense secretary, was very clear about that. But he's right to say now now is the point at which we've got probably more conflict going on in the world now than most of us have seen in our, lifetime. So that's why we have to increase increase defense spending. That's why we took the decision to increase to two and a half percent sooner than people thought we would, and that's already taking place.
I made commitments at the NATO summit last year in relation to the further spending that we need, to put in place. I stand by those commitments. We must go further, and we must go faster.
Speaker 1
Abdul Khan. Thank you, mister speaker.
Firstly, let me say that thank you to the prime minister for your statesmanship. This weekend saw the Pakistani government step up and take global leadership by expertly hosting and mediating negotiation between Iran and America. The whole world is indebted to the noble efforts of prime minister Shebaaz Sharif, foreign minister Ishaq Dhar, and general sayyid Osimandir to achieve a ceasefire. Given Pakistan is a long term ally of Britain, will the prime minister outline what support he's giving the Pakistani government facilitate an agreement for long lasting peace and stability in The Middle East?
Speaker 63
I reiterate my thanks to Pakistan for the role they're playing. And I can tell the house that I spoke to the prime minister of Pakistan on Friday as we're going into the talks this weekend about the talks, what support we could put in place, and the foreign secretary spoke to her counterpart this afternoon. It's very important that we support this process and try to move it forward and not to let it escalate.
Speaker 18
prime minister is absolutely right to condemn the abhorrent response of the terrorists in the IRGC, but I noticed from his statement that there's no explicit condemnation of the illegality of Donald Trump's actions. There's no explicit condemnation of the illegality of Netanyahu's actions. And despite having the entire Easter break to think about it, there is explicitly no new financial support for households on these aisles whatsoever. Despite the fact that in Ireland, they've put down €750,000,000,000 worth of support for motorists and farmers, the best he can muster is to continue to monitor the effects. Now I appreciate that he might not be in office for very much longer, but whilst he is, the public expect him to provide support.
Speaker 63
Well, mister speaker, I'll remind him that we put in support and protection for our citizens in the region by taking defensive action. He opposed that.
Speaker 63
Yeah. For Scottish citizens in The Gulf, and they oppose taking any action whatsoever. It is only because we've stabilized the economy we're able to reduce energy bills. What did they do? They voted against the budget in which we put forward the money, for this.
So we will carefully do the work that we need to do, carefully do the work that we need to do to reopen the Strait Of Hormuz, which is the single most effective thing we can do in relation to household costs Yes. Yes. And to work for de escalation. I would have thought I would have thought that he would have supported that, but unfortunately, again, he's on the opportunistic road rather than the up the road to support what we really need to do.
Speaker 53
Yeah. Escalating the conflict in The Middle East, and also to agree with him in terms of not getting drawn into this conflict. But could I ask him about Palestine, in particular, at the West Bank? Does my right honorable friend agree with more than 30 former UK ambassadors that any bidder for contracts to design, build, or finance the e one settlement expansions should endanger their business interests in and with The UK?
Speaker 63
Well, Clyde, thank you for raising this. And it's very important that we don't lose focus on what's happening in the West Bank. It is deeply concerning and deeply worrying. And in relation to the e one settlements, I made the position clear, I think, the week before last, and that remains the position.
Speaker 4
Thank you, mister speaker. In a crisis, governments have permission to do things that are not possible in normal times. But I'm worried that what the prime minister is gonna bring forward will not meet the measure of the moment. Can he commit to the house that when it comes to energy policy, he will dramatically change it so that it focuses as much on cheap energy as clean energy? And when it comes to the desperate need to increase defense spending, will he look at serious welfare reform Yes.
That stops someone who is earning the national living wage working full time, sometimes only getting half as much as someone on
Speaker 63
Can I thank him for his question? In relation to the cost of energy, yes, of course, we have to focus on the cost of energy. And there's simply no denying the fact that it's because we're on the international market that our energy prices are going up and down. And fam families across the country are are really fed up with the fact that international events happen, which they can't control Yeah. And their energy bills go up and down causing a cost of living crisis.
That is because we're on the international fossil fuel market. There's no denying that. And that will be the case so long as we're on that market because that controls the price. Putin and Iran control the price of the international market. And the longer we're on it, the more our families will be subjected to that.
We have to take control of energy bills. The only way to do that is through energy independence. It's the only way to do it, and that's why I think we need to double down on going faster, and further in relation to that. Yes. Of course, oil and gas will be part of the mix for many years to come.
I've been very clear about that, but equally clear that that won't have an effect on the price and the cost of energy bills. The only thing that will have a price an effect on the price and cost of bills is coming off the international market that we're stuck with. That's why the Strait Of Hormuz is so poor. We don't get as much that much energy in oil and gas coming out of or coming through the street, but it's because we're on the international market that we're impacted by the fact that others do. That is the source of the problem.
That's why we're working so hard to resolve it.
Speaker 39
Sir, can I echo the comments about the president's statement on Easter Sunday that in an evening, he could destroy a two and a half thousand year old civilization? But on the question of the Straits Of Hormuz, isn't it clear that the Straits were open before the president foolishly launched his illegal war? And can I ask the prime minister to say quite clearly that no British military assets or brave personnel would be putting risk at risk in a foolish idea to blockade the straits even further, which came from the from the president yesterday? Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 63
Kim, for that. It it, of course, Iran that's putting in the chokehold on the strait. That is wrong, and the strength of feeling across the Gulf last week was very, very clear to me. I can assure him that we are not getting involved in the proposal to blockade the strait. On the contrary, we're working with other countries to try and get the Strait open and fully open for free navigation, something this country has championed for years and years and years.
Speaker 103
you, mister speaker. Today, The US president impersonated Jesus Christ. Last week, he pledged to wipe out an entire sin civilization. His warmongering in The Middle East is piling on the pressure for my constituents in Eastern Waterton from prices at the pump to mortgage increases in the midst of a constant living crisis. So given the disturbing assurances from the, occupant of the White House and the squeeze in our living standards, surely the future is across the channel towards Europe.
Speaker 44
And I know that the prime minister gave a line presumably for the local elections about alignment with Europe. But could he give more detail on what this means for defense and security and for prosperity?
Speaker 63
Well, a a close relationship for the with the EU and Europe was in our manifesto in 2024, which is a very successful manifesto. And we've been working to that end ever since, which is why we had the first UK, EU summit last year with agreed 10 strands. It's why I've been clear that we want to go further this year, not just, in seeing where we've got to and what we've already agreed, but going further than that because, it is in our interest, whether it's defense, security, energy, or the economy, to be closer to Europe, and that's what we're endeavoring to do.
Speaker 19
Omer Kommerer. Mister speaker, can I thank the prime minister for his statement and welcome his, welcome his convening of a summit of leaders alongside president Macron? Mister speaker, the situation in Lebanon is devastating. Israeli escalation has led to a grave humanitarian situation. The images of civilians being carpet bombed are horrifying.
Speaker 78
I want to reiterate what the Foreign Affairs Committee heard today. We met with ambassadors from The Gulf. They expressed their genuine appreciation for the prime minister's presence and Britain's continuing support. Can I ask the prime minister to continue to represent the voices of our constituents and to resist escalation, include Lebanon in the ceasefire, and to press for peace? Can
Speaker 63
I assure her we'll make the case for Lebanon to be included in the ceasefire, and we will continue our work to deescalate and not get drawn into this war?
Speaker 45
we all hear the prime minister's words about Lebanon, but surely the lesson of the last two and a half years is that his words and the words of anybody in this house have no impact on an Israeli government seemingly led by supremacist maniacs. Now before Easter, I asked the foreign secretary, how many Lebanese was an acceptable number to see killed over the coming weeks, and we've learned over the Easter break that there's seemingly no upper limit before we're willing to act. So I wanted to ask the prime minister a a simple question. Given that he proudly, quite rightly, proudly pointed to the part Britain is playing in defending other nations in the region. Why have we not stepped forward to defend, Lebanese civilians in the same way that we have others?
And secondly, a simple question if you can't answer that one, does Lebanon have a right to exist?
Speaker 63
Speaker, I'm grateful to him for raising this really serious issue. And I think the immediate focus has to be ensuring that Lebanon is in the ceasefire and being absolutely clear in our condemnation of the action that Israel is taking. We are working on that on a number of levels, but I always believe and continue to believe that we are stronger when we work with other countries, and that's what we're endeavoring to do.
Speaker 73
mister speaker. I'm grateful to my honorable friend for his statement, and I note the import the emphasis he has on the no return to the status quo, particularly in relation to the importance of energy independence. Will he acknowledge that we are now entering a new energy era? And perhaps he agrees with president von der Leyen, who today has said, here is one thing that all these events are making clear. We are paying a very high price for our overdependency on fossil fuels.
Speaker 73
Hey. And the grim reality for our continent is fossil fuel energy will remain the most expensive option in the years to come.
Speaker 63
Oh, mister speaker, that's the argument that, I've been making, and I believe to be right. It's the argument the leader of the opposition used to make, but she's U-turned on that as well.
Speaker 105
Thank you, mister speaker. All our constituents are worried about the price of energy, the price of gas. But is the prime minister aware that the price of gas in The US has fallen 20% since the start of this war, while the price of gas in The UK has increased by 50%, proving, prime minister, that if we produce and consume our gas domestically, we can have much lower bills, proving why we must allow the consents for Jack Dor, for Rosebank, and all of the oil fields across the North Sea and onshore as well.
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, I I remind myself that, his party's position was to fully support the war, go in with both feet, whatever the consequences. Now he says there are these consequences. Well, they should have thought about that before they adopted the policy of going straight in. But, mister speaker, on the question of, energy and gas, yes, the price is subject to the international market because because we're on the international market, that is why the sooner we have energy independence, the better.
Speaker 79
you, mister speaker. Trump's illegal war on Iran and his genocidal threats to kill a whole civilization are part and parcel of a dangerous new US security plan. The Trump doctrine is based upon yet more war and tearing up international law, making the whole world less safe. Prime minister, given that, isn't it time for Britain to stop being a junior partner to The US and pursue a truly independent foreign policy? And shouldn't the very first step be to end all US access access to British military bases for Trump's war on Iran?
Speaker 63
have British civilians in the Gulf Region, about 300,000, And they are at risk because of Iran's actions, and it's my duty to ensure that we protect them. That is why we've taken action in our own rights, particularly with our pilots. It is also why I've allowed the bases to be used for defensive purposes to prevent those attacks on our civilians as much as anything else who are in the region. And I'm never going to abandon them to their fate, when there's incoming missiles and drones into the areas where they are living and where they are working. It's my duty to protect them, and I'll continue to do so.
Speaker 81
Thank you, mister speaker. Could the prime minister just remind some of his colleagues that United States is a democracy and an ally, and Iran is an odious regime that could have ended the war this weekend had they agreed to give up their ambitions for nuclear weapons and to cease supporting their proxy terrorist organizations around the Middle East. And wouldn't it be helpful if the prime minister said a bit more of criticism of the Iranian regime rather than supporting his colleagues and criticizing The United States?
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, in fairness, I've been very clear about the Iranian regime. It is odious as he rightly points out. It is really important that they do not have the nuclear, capability and that we deal with those their proxies. And that has been the consistent position of this government and previous governments, to be fair. It's been the way in which I put it from the dispatch box on many, many occasions.
Speaker 114
Thank you very much, mister speaker. I commend the prime minister for his efforts to keep The UK out of Donald Trump's latest dangerous attempt to end a blockade by creating another. I also commend Pakistan's attempt to broker peace and the UK government's work with now over 30 countries to pursuit of a diplomatic solution. But if the strait remains closed, what plans does the government have to protect UK households and businesses from impact on energy supplies, trade, rising costs?
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, we're we're planning for all contingencies, but I emphasize once again that our absolute focus has to be on getting the strait open. Having spoken to shipping, finance, insurance, etcetera, they're very clear with me that they're not gonna be putting vessels through whilst there is a conflict, and therefore, we must de escalate and come up with that credible plan. We will do that in conjunction with other countries, and that's why president Macron and I are convening the summit later this year, building relating this week, building on the work we've been doing over the last few weeks.
Speaker 108
in his statement, the prime minister said that he wants to double down on NATO. But president Trump has attempted to use the NATO alliance or threat to withdraw from it to blackmail other NATO countries into joining his illegal endeavor in Iran. He's also threatened to annex the sovereign territory of another NATO member. He has said that NATO members weren't there for The US in Iraq. It is clear that NATO The US is an unreliable partner in NATO.
Speaker 84
So will the prime minister announce when he is going to release the defense investment plan? And will he explain how we can forge closer ties with our European allies who are more reliable?
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, let let me thank you for his question. And first thing I'd say is it's very important that we defend NATO. It's the single most effective military alliance the world has ever known, and we should do nothing to weaken it. I do think that there should be a stronger European element on defense and security. It's an argument I've been making for some time.
It's particularly important now that Europe steps up with stronger European element, and we're working with our, allies to do that.
Speaker 116
Thank you, Warren. Thank the prime minister for his statement and his positive efforts on the issue of the Straits Of Hormuz. Last week, I met with farmers in Whitby who are deeply concerned about the skyrocketing price of red diesel. In January, the fuel cost was 64p per litre, and it has since doubled. With the busiest period of the farming calendar approaching, can the prime minister outline what measures the government is considering to support farmers impacted by these rising costs?
Speaker 63
I assure her that we have been looking at that in the various meetings we've been having, particularly the red diesel question, looking at contingencies? But in addition to planning for those conditions, it is really important that we double down on our work to deescalate and to open up these straight up Hormuz.
Speaker 7
May I quote the prime minister who told us just a few moments ago that the bills for energy are gonna stay down until July? But he also correctly said that we do not set the global price for oil and gas. Is the prime minister making an enormous gamble on the energy price, and how much money has he set aside in order to ensure that bills stay down even if prices rise? I'm not sure if he's aware, but the last tanker to leave the Strait Of Hormuz and bring fuel to The UK docked only a few days ago. The last tanker to arrive in The US waters will be arriving in a day or two.
Speaker 86
And after that, we're on our own. Is he taking that bet, and who's gonna pay for it?
Speaker 63
Can I thank him for reminding the house that we are reducing energy bills? We have done that already by an average £100 per household, and that will stay, that will remain the case, until the June, until July. It's very important that people hear that message because they are concerned, and they're concerned to know that that will be the case whatever happens in the conflict, and it is. That decision was taken as a result of what we did at the budget last year, where we were able to stabilize the economy and provide the money for it because we're bearing down on the cost of living.
Speaker 30
All war. Speaker, can I thank the prime minister for refusing to allow The UK to be dragged into America's war in Iran, a war that's he's in my constituents directly in the pocket and at the petrol pumps? But he rightly mentioned the the people of Palestine earlier, and can I remind him that last week, the former heads of Shin Bet and Mossad Security Services and former IDF chiefs of staff described the ongoing settler violence in against Palestinians in the West Bank as I quote, government sponsored Jewish terrorism, which is not only a moral disgrace, but a fatal strategic blow to Israel's own national security? So can I urge the PM to condemn the settler violence, condemn Israel's refusal to tackle it, condemn Israel's expansion of illegal settlements, and also to back the pope who said that peace should be the priority?
Speaker 63
thank him for raising the question of settler violence? Because it is disturbing, it is wrong, and it's escalated as he knows better than most. And that's been our clear position to call it out and to do everything we can in relation to that settler violence, which is getting worse by the day, not better by the day.
Speaker 61
Thank you, madam speaker. The crisis has laid bare the palace state of the British military, Madam Deputy Speaker, the three main parties of government should put aside the blame game and accept that we all have played our part in getting the British military into the state that it's in now. For over a year, the Liberal Democrats have been asking for cross party talks on how to get to 3%. I'm glad the Conservatives have now joined us. We've spoken about defence bonds.
I'm sure the Conservatives have got ideas. I'm sure the government has ideas. Can we please, madam deputy speaker, if this could be the prime minister's legacy, can we please get together in the national interest and talk about how to increase defense spending?
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, we do need to increase defense spending. I've been clear about that. But can I just make the case that, our military have been hard at work throughout this conflict from within about two hours of the conflict starting? That means hours and hours of the pilots taking incoming missiles to to safeguard our citizens, our interests, and those in The Gulf. But when I was there last week, all of the leaders I met were at pains to thank us for what our military is doing.
And we're too quick sometimes to run them down. They've done a lot of brave work, particularly in the last six to seven weeks, and I thank them for that work.
Speaker 43
deputy speaker. Can I thank the prime minister for all his efforts, not recently not not not least, of course, in the last few days? I'm a little concerned that, because many of us have a difference with the way president Trump talks and the actions he's taken in terms of Iran, and, obviously, something you don't agree with That's on this side of the house, I am a lot concerned that we we shouldn't get mixed up in the fact between what president Trump trains in his view and what the congress and senate think in in The United States Of America. Because when you talk to them, there is significant and overwhelming support for NATO and for Europe.
Speaker 87
think it's important we actually remember that because our relationship with America is very, very important Yeah. Not least in terms of NATO. And I hope that the prime minister will comment on that.
Speaker 63
Can I thank him for that? He's right to draw attention to the broad support there is for NATO in The United States and always has been. And whilst it is true we should do more for a stronger European element in NATO, we should never pull away from NATO, which I say has been the single most effective military alliance the world has ever known.
Speaker 117
Afro Brandra. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. The war in The Middle East is having a real effect on my constituents in Chester South and Edisbury from fuel to fertilizer. Prices are increasing, and action needs to be taken to alleviate the consequences. While there are immediate steps that the prime minister and the chancellor should be taking, not least reversing the planned increase in fuel duty.
Speaker 88
The bigger picture involves reopening the Strait Of Hormuz. What thought has been given to the role The UK can play in clearing the Strait of mines? And in particular, did the prime minister raise the potential deployment of our autonomous minesweeping capabilities, which are already in the region during his discussions?
Speaker 63
I thank her for her question. She's absolutely right in relation to opening the strait and playing our part. There is the political and diplomatic element, but there is also the military capability. What we're doing with the countries that we've brought together in a loose coalition and we'll meet in person later this week is to look across those capabilities and draw them together. We do have capabilities when it comes to minesweep.
I won't go into operational details, but she knows what they are. And, obviously, as we look across the board with with President Macron and others, Part of that exercise will be and the military planners have been looking at this to look at how we can pull together the capabilities of all the countries that are prepared to work with this on this. We've got at least a couple of dozen that we've working with for the last two weeks, and we'll be doing that further this week.
Speaker 69
in supporting our regional partners and our national interest, in particular, that of free navigation. But this lies out with our most immediate security problem, which is depending Europe from Russian attack in all of its forms. Does the prime minister agree with me that we should recognize Russian Iranian cooperation and that we must not let this distract from our urgent need to collectively rearm and defend our country and the continent of Europe. Prime minister.
Speaker 63
Well, can I thank you for drawing attention to this really important issue, which is the relationship between Russia and Iran and the assistance that Russia has given to Iran in relation to the intelligence that's being used during the conflict? And we must never lose sight of the fact that we're facing a war on two fronts, and Russia is a huge threat to our continent and to our country.
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, we're working to finalize the defense investment plan. It's really important that we don't make the mistakes the last government made. We we inherited plans which were unfunded and not deliverable. And it's really important, therefore, that we that our plan is robust, that we're finalizing it, but it will be a robust plan that serves for the future defense and protection of this country.
Speaker 66
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. We now know that an agreement was about to be reached on the uranium enrichment by Iran. However, Israel decides to bomb Iran as did The USA, joining and doing an illegal, immoral, dangerous war of choice. And even during the ceasefire, which included Lebanon, Israel continues to bomb South Lebanon and Beirut, displacing millions of people. This is typical of Israel.
Just before an agreement is reached, it kills negotiators and bombs the country. Now these are not far away conflicts. My constituents of Bolton South and Warwickton are paying the price for it by higher fuel costs, raising mortgages, and household bills. So can I ask the prime minister what additional steps is he taking to help the constituents of my area, but also the country and the world to bring peace, unlike, of course, members of Opposite who seems to be finding it very amusing?
Speaker 63
Madam deputy speaker, that is precisely why we're working with other countries to deescalate the situation and get the straight forward moves open. As I said in my statement, that is not gonna be easy, but notwithstanding that challenge, we'll continue to do so.
Speaker 29
Deputy speaker, in the prime minister's 17 page statement, there was not one word of condemnation of the actions of The US Yeah. Despite the fact that they started this legal war, and then last week, Trump threatened to wipe out an entire civilization. Now the prime minister did rightly condemn the horrific Israeli attacks on Lebanon, but we all know that the war criminal Netanyahu just ignores what we say because there are no consequences. So will the prime minister take action? Sanctions on Netanyahu withdraw all permission for The US to use UK bases and UK airspaces to make clear that we will not be an accomplice to the rogue actions of Donald Trump, which endanger us all.
The
Speaker 63
US are using the basis to attack the Iranian capability to fire missiles into the region, including at our citizens and our nationals. Include you'll have seen the images going into hotels, going at to the bases the bases where our military are based. Is she seriously suggesting Yeah. That we should reduce the protection Yeah. For our people in the region and expose them to attacks they wouldn't otherwise be exposed to?
That, to me, is a dereliction of duty, and I will never do that.
Speaker 65
Donald McDonald. I think the I actually think the house is at one with the prime minister with regard to the inclusion of Lebanon in the ceasefire. Yeah. The problem that we face is that today there's been more airstrikes against the Lebanese, and the Israeli artillery are now shelling Lebanese cities and towns. Great.
Speaker 84
And for many of us, we feel it is because Netanyahu actually is out of control Yeah. And Donald Trump is not willing to exert that control or influence to bring him into line. Yeah. So can I suggest to the prime minister, in his next discussions with the European leaders that he's successfully convening, can he place on the agenda now a comprehensive European sanctions strategy so that we can exert some influence on preventing Netanyahu, as I say, running out of control and actually creating problems for the the globe, not just the Middle East?
Speaker 63
And I thank him for his question, and and clearly Lebanon should be included in the ceasefire. And let's be clear, these attacks must stop, and we need to be really clear about that. And we will work with our allies on both those issues.
Speaker 89
Okay. We know that the defense investment plan was originally due to be published last year. As it's a ten year plan, will it be a ten year plan from publication in this financial year, twenty twenty six, twenty seven? And does that change the cost envelope? Is it a ten year plan now or a nine year plan in terms of the way it's being financed?
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, madam deputy speaker, I'm so sorry. It's a ten year plan, and it, mirrors our strategic, review. But, of course, obviously, it sits alongside the defense spending commitments that we have made and we're implementing with the two and a half percent and the commitments that I made at the NATO summit, last year.
Speaker 33
repeatedly been told the government has permitted The US to use British military bases for defensive purposes only, but amidst the widespread US targeting of civilian infrastructure in Iran, including schools, hospitals, and bridges, we have not been told how these restrictions work in practice. Could the prime minister confirm whether The US military aircraft have taken off from RAF Fairford or Lakenheath carrying heavy munition payloads? If so, whether there is any US operational policy for action from our bases in place approved by this government? And if not, is it the case that the working def definition of defensive action here is simply don't ask, don't tell?
Speaker 63
Well, let me assure her in the house that isn't the position. It's for defensive action only. I'm particularly concerned to make sure we take every measure available to protect our nationals in the region and very many of them. Not only is it defensive action, but it's monitored and has been monitored since the bases began being used.
Speaker 91
Madam, deputy speaker, the prime minister is absolutely right to suggest that tremors provoked by this conflict will reverberate long after the kinetic fighting has finished. And there's perhaps no greater example, of that than in Cyprus where government officials all the way up to the level of the prime minister have questioned Britain's continuing sovereignty over our sovereign base areas in Cyprus. So can I ask the prime minister what he has done to reassure the Cypriots, to reassure the Cypriot government that Britain is a trusted and reliable neighbor and partner, and that our continuing sovereignty is immutable? Can
Speaker 63
I thank him for raising this and assure him? I've spoken to the president, a number of times in this regard, about the basis about security in particular, which is, of course, a concern to him, and his public, and those discussions are ongoing.
Speaker 61
You, madam deputy speaker, this war, which we are rightly playing no part in, has my constituents fearing for the future, not least in terms of rising energy and fuel costs. And this underlines the crucial importance of bringing down the cost of energy and securing energy independence. But will the Prime Minister reassure my constituents in Crewe and Nantwich that while this government is rightly taking the necessary steps to provide us with long term energy security through renewable energy and new nuclear, that the government will go further in the short term to tackle some of the profiteering that is happening and to directly support hard pressed families and small businesses in my constituency with the cost?
Speaker 63
Yes. We will, bear down on any, profiteering at the same time as pushing forward at speed for energy independence.
Speaker 118
I'd ask the prime minister about one particular consequence of this war in the Mid Middle East, and that's the rising cost of heating oil, diesel and, petrol. Now, everyone is struggling. I've spoken to many businesses and people who are really struggling to pay their bills, but the UK government and the Scottish government support is only for people claiming benefits. So when will the government reconsider this approach and ensure that everybody, working people and businesses, are also getting sufficient support as well? Well,
Speaker 63
madam deputy speaker, we'll we'll we'll set out the plans as they develop. Some of the ways in which we protect and support has to be universal, and in fact, the cut in energy bills that's through to the June is universal. But we're looking at the most appropriate support on a wider basis.
Speaker 21
Fresh from a weekend knocking on doors, I can confirm to the prime minister that on the streets of Newcastle Central And West, there is no appetite for further involvement in this war. Now there are some, including apparently the leader of the opposition, who say that while they might not have chosen to start the war, now that the bombs are flying, we have no choice but to support our allies. So can the prime minister confirm that president Trump's America is not a reliable ally, that the prime minister that prime minister Netanyahu's Israel is not a reliable ally, and that we have to work with our reliable allies in Europe to end this conflict and ensure that working people in this country do not pick up the bill.
Speaker 63
Madam deputy speaker, we we we work with Americans on a daily basis on defense, security, and intelligence. It's really important that I reiterate that position to, the house. And, of course, we're working with them in relation to the use of the our bases to take the action that's necessary to protect our, civilians and our nationals. At the same time, we need to work more closely, with our European allies on defense security, on energy, and on the economy.
Speaker 23
Yeah. The prime minister was right to mention the untold economic damage that this crisis has already wrought on households and businesses across the country due to increased fuel cost. But does he also share my concerns and those of the agricultural sector that a prolonged closure of the strait may also feed through to higher food inflation? Yeah. And can I ask him what measures the government is considering to help mitigate the potential consequences of a prolonged closure of the Strait of
Speaker 63
Well, I thank him for drawing attention to that because there will be consequential impacts beyond the immediate impact on energy, and that's why we're monitoring, keeping under review the steps that we can take? But I go back to my opening point, really, which is the absolute focus has to be on getting the strait reopened as quickly as possible because all the time that is closed to free navigation, the damage that's being done is being compounded. And that's why it's really important that we work with our allies to that end.
Speaker 19
Madam deputy speaker, last week, president Trump was making the most outrageous and dire threats in order to try and reopen the Strait Of Hormuz. This week, he wants to keep it shut. So I wonder if the prime minister can shed any light on what The United States strategic objective is, behind this latest move. What can be done to reopen the straightforward moves and what this government can do more to protect our people from the economic consequences of this mess? Yeah.
Yeah.
Speaker 63
Let me be clear. I want the straight open, not shut, and that is what we've been working on for the last few weeks and will continue to work on. And that's why when I spoke to president Macron yesterday, we proposed pulling together a a leaders level summit later this year to continue the work we're already doing. But to be very clear with him and the house, that is to keep the strait or to get the strait fully open because that is the single most effective way to limit the damage that is being done to all of our economies.
Speaker 95
Dame Harriet, Baldwin. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. When the prime minister was in, The Middle East, did the subject of The UK's dependence on helium come up? Because it is an element which we don't produce in The UK and is vital for things like MRI scans in the NHS.
Speaker 63
Well, we did discuss a range of issues. I won't go into all of the details, but we did agree that where we're working together already, we should double down and do even more in relation to resilience in particular, which goes to her question both, economically and defensively, and we'll take forward that work.
Speaker 62
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And I welcome the prime minister's continued clarity on the need for Lebanon to be included in the ceasefire. But Israel's tactics in Lebanon forced displacement, evacuation orders, a 165 children killed, and eighty seven medical workers killed are straight out of their Gaza playbook. Does the Prime Minister agree that in Lebanon, as in Palestine, there must be proper accountability for these war crimes, because this age of impunity puts us all in greater danger.
Speaker 63
I'm grateful for her question. It absolutely shows why we must keep pushing for Lebanon to be included in the ceasefire. It's vitally important that we do so. And, of course, there must be accountability for all the actions that are taken in any respect in this conflict.
Speaker 98
Christine Jarden. Thank you very much. Madam deputy speaker, I've been overwhelmed at the number of my constituents in Edinburgh West who've written to me over the past two weeks about the situation in The Gulf. They are of course concerned about their energy bills and the cost of living. Overwhelmingly they are outraged at the actions of all the actors in this Iran, Israel and The United States.
Speaker 96
And what they want from their government is more and stronger leadership on the international stage to open the Straits Of Hormuz. So will the Prime Minister consider going to the United Nations with an emergency motion to the Security Council to get that done and to condemn the actions
Speaker 63
as she probably knows, we have been supporting measures in the UN, over the last two weeks, particularly some of those that were put forward by our Gulf allies, and I had the opportunity to discuss those last week in The Gulf. We will continue to work with them and others on building the necessary coalition to do all that we can to get the straight open.
Speaker 67
Stella Creasy. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. May I welcome the tough stance of the prime minister in response to the demands of president Trump to get involved in this conflict and his commitment that Lebanon must be part of the ceasefire, our constituents need us to give them hope that they will not have to continue to live in a world which is driven by the uncertainty of when the White House takes to truth social. We can do things to deescalate conflict, and one of those things is to support the two state solution in Israel and Palestine, which he knows is at the heart of much uncertainty in The Middle East. Given that the conduct of the settlers on the West Bank directly undermines the possibility of peace and the possibility of a Palestinian state, will he commit to including their conduct in his conversations about the ceasefire and how we can give hope to people in the Middle East and peace to people around the world?
Speaker 63
Can I reiterate to her in the house how support for the two state solution is the only way for a viable long term peace in the region? And, of course, the settler violence is a threat to that. It's wrong in principle. In addition to that, we'll continue to bear down on that.
Speaker 97
Deputy speaker, for years, well before this conflict took place, members from all sides of this house have called on the government of the day to prescribe the IRGC. Whether it's been the prime minister answering or other ministers, there has always been a pivot to economic sanctions against the IRGC. We know that the Iranian regime have found ways through cryptocurrency and fake corporate structures to evade those sanctions. So what assessment has the prime minister made of the effectiveness of UK sanctions against Tehran? And on the presumption that those sanctions are failing, what precise action is he gonna take to strengthen them?
Speaker 63
Well, can I thank him for his questions? The IRGC has been sanctioned in its entirety. In relation to what more we can do, obviously, we've been looking at state based threats, which will almost certainly require legislation. He will be familiar with the review in that regard. So I think there are further things that we can do, and hopefully, we can work across the House on some of those issues.
Speaker 36
speaker. It's clear now there was no plan behind this reckless war, and the resulting energy crisis is going to have huge impacts both here in The UK and around the world. Can I thank the prime minister for his cool headed approach in the face of pressure from the leaders of reform and the conservatives to follow The US blindly into this war? And does the prime minister also agree with me that it demonstrates how important it is that we finally get off the fossil fuel roller coaster and continue our record investment in green energy? Thank
Speaker 63
you, ma'am. On both fronts, it was very important from the start that we made clear that we wouldn't be playing any part in this war, not least because of the consequences. And, what the war has flushed out is the need to get off the international market and have independence of energy bills in this country.
Speaker 100
deputy speaker. Madam deputy speaker, British drones flew over Lebanon hours before and after the Israeli massacre, which killed at least 18 people in Beqar Valley City, among 300 people across the region that day. Madam deputy speaker, we know no UK drones and surveillance flights have been used to feed operational information to the IDF during the genocide in Gaza, and it is deeply concerning that this may now be the case in Lebanon. Will the prime minister confirm if these flights were coordinated with the Lebanese army? Was intelligence shared with Israel or with The United States?
What is our armed forces role in this land grab and ethnic cleansing? And have any weapons supplied by The UK to Israel been used
Speaker 63
throughout this conflict and throughout the time this government has been in power.
Speaker 29
deputy speaker. And can I commend the prime minister and also the leadership from the foreign secretary and also the NSA, I'm sure, in the work that's being being done? I welcome the news about trying to resolve the issues in the Strait Of Hall moves, but I share concerns that have been voiced around the chamber here about the situation in Lebanon and also the West Bank. But but closer to home, the Resolution Foundation has have quoted that medium working age households will be hit by £480 additional cost this year. What they're describing in my commute constituency is the cost of Trump.
Speaker 101
So will the prime minister go explains more about what can be done to assist households here in The UK?
Speaker 63
Well, the single most important thing is to deescalate and get the straight of all moves open, and that's why we're working so hard with other countries in order to do so. Because the impact that it's having on our economy, and undoubtedly is, is affected by how long the straight remains closed for, and that's why we have to focus on that.
Speaker 53
Deputy speaker, the price of energy is obviously important, but as important is the security of supply. Exactly. And whether the government like it or not, over 70% of our energy comes from oil and gas. And the events of the last month must be a wake up call to them that we must secure our supply. Luckily, we do have a secure supply under the North Sea.
But and although his government ministers might say otherwise, his government's policies are meaning that we cannot produce it. When is he gonna get serious about our energy security and ban the end the ban on new licenses, end the EPL, permit Rosebank and Jackdaw, and finally get The UK drilling again.
Speaker 63
Mister speaker, oil and gas will be part of the mix for many years, to come up. I've very clear, about that. Oil and gas is being produced twenty four seven, every day, in relation to, our energy supply, and it's really important that it does. That will be part of the mix. But equally equally, if we're to get to energy independence, which we need to, we need to go further and faster on renewables.
Speaker 35
Sonia Kumar. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And I welcome the prime minister's statement and commend his leadership in steering The UK clear from the Iran conflict and blockade. During this war, health care centers, and ambulances have been attacked and the Iranians now face acute shortages of care and medicines. What action is the prime minister taking to press all parties to comply with international meritarian law and end the attack on health care infrastructure?
Speaker 63
Madam deputy speaker, let me be really clear. Any attack on health care infrastructure is completely unacceptable, and that is why we've been very clear in relation to our own actions and the actions of anybody else. They must have a lawful basis, and that's the starting point for all of the work that we're doing.
Speaker 38
Madam deputy speaker, the prime minister rightly in his statement referred to defence security and energy security, but he made no reference to food security, which feels like a glaring omission given the impact of the doubling of red diesel on the farmers who produce our food. I wonder if he's even aware that outrageously England is now the only country in The UK and in the whole of Europe that does not use its farm payment scheme to actively support its farmers to produce food. In these troubled times, does he agree with me now that's a glaring omission also? Will he turn around and change it?
Speaker 63
Thank you for raising this. Food security is really important. I mean, it it actually comes under energy security in a sense because it's the energy costs that are pushing or or or could have the effect of pushing in relation to food security. And that's why it's very important that we do focus where we are focusing on, which is deescalating the situation and reopening the Strait Of The Moose.
Speaker 36
Rachel Maskell. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Resulting to violence doesn't achieve anything that has left two thousand Lebanese dead and 1,200,000 displaced. As the Prime Minister is demonstrating, bilateral and multilateral dialogue is the way forward to get progressive change. Instead of just looking at increasing the defence budget, would he also look at increasing investment in diplomacy and development, which is really crucial in this ever increasing destabilized world?
Speaker 63
Can I thank her, I I think that the work we're doing with other countries has to start with the political and the diplomatic? Of course, we're looking at military planning, but you can't have military planning without the diplomacy because it's absolutely clear to me that the Strait Of Hormuz will not allow for safe passage until there's a ceasefire in place. And all of the sectors involved in vessels going through the Strait are clear that they won't be putting their vessels through until that is the situation. So she's absolutely right about diplomacy.
Speaker 39
Thank you very much, madam deputy speaker. The prime minister is absolutely correct to praise the service of our armed forces personnel, and I join him in doing so. But they are being let down by the failure to deliver the defense investment plan. That failure can only be the result of either inertia or incompetence within government. Which one is
Speaker 63
I I remind they hollowed out the armed forces. They reduced our they they hollowed out the armed forces. They didn't increase defense spending. The last time we were at two and a half percent was under the last Labour government. Yeah.
Yeah. Now we're under it under this Labour government. So I appreciate, all the advice, but after fourteen years of failure, I don't really need that advice. Thank
Speaker 97
you, madam deputy speaker. From Iran to Russia, this major security threats we face are pan European, challenges, and the prime minister's referenced the need and our intention to work more closely with our European allies within NATO. Can you
Speaker 97
do to be ambitious with those allies on the continent to strengthen our defense and security partnerships, especially in the run up to the EU UK summit in the summer? Well,
Speaker 63
I'm grateful. I do think there's more we can do on defense and security, particularly collaborating, cooperating about the particular capability, in in addition to the amount of money we're spending, and that's what we're focusing on, with our allies, in the EU.
Speaker 102
I'm deputy speaker. Britain's military cooperation with The USA and Israel has enabled Israel to commit acts of genocide against the people of Gaza, the Palestinian people, and has enabled The United States to undertake this massive illegal bombardment of Iran. Could he assure the house that from now on, the military cooperation and the supply of weapons and parts to both Israel and The United States will be suspended whilst this appalling war goes on in Iran, which is a danger, not just the peace of the whole region, but clearly a danger to the peace of the whole world.
Speaker 63
Can I assure him and the house that the permission to use our bases is strictly for defensive purposes, and, in particular, to protect our nation our nationals who are in the region? We've got two or 300,000 of our nationals in the region. Iranian strikes were coming into the region, into the Gulf States that I visited last week, hitting infrastructure deliberately aimed at our service personnel. And it's my duty to protect them, I will continue to do so.
Speaker 2
to join the prime minister in thanking our armed forces who are protecting, British citizens in The Middle East, and thank him on behalf of my constituents for his cool headed leadership and firm decision not to join Trump's illegal war. Could he reassure my constituents worried about the of energy that he's doing everything within his power to secure peace, to reopen the Straits Of Hormuz, and to ensure consumers are protected against rocketing energy prices?
Speaker 63
I give her that assurance. That's what we've doing particularly intensely in the last two or three weeks, and we'll continue to do it later this week when president Macron and I host the summit together.
Speaker 19
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Going further and faster on renewables is entirely compatible with new licenses in the North Sea. And my constituents, Canada, they can see that the prime minister has very little power to reopen the Straits Of Hormuz and total power to order Jack Dor, Rosebank, and new licenses in the North Sea. How can he stand there and say that energy independence is the goal while he desperately tries to get oil and gas from elsewhere, which he could do little about, and refuses to overrule his insane secretary of state for energy and make sure that we produce I withdraw that, madam deputy speaker. His the crazy policies of the secretary of state for energy who insists on not producing it here.
It makes no sense. Prime minister, get a learning, get a teaching, but make sure it's not with him.
Speaker 63
I'd say oil and gas is part of the mix for many years to come. Susan's on Jack Dell on Rosebank, according to the legislative procedure. That's the right way to do it. But we could legislate. It'd probably take longer.
Mister speaker, mister speaker, mister speaker, they'll be part of the mix, but the long term the only way to get energy independence is to go further and faster on renewables, and that's what we're doing.
Speaker 100
Japan, Turkey, China, and India have already been in negotiation with Iran to try and secure safe passage for their vessels through the Straits Of Hormuz. The prime minister was absolutely right to visit the Gulf States and their leaders, but he knows the importance of The Straits to those economies. Did he receive any assurance from them that they would not try and negotiate with Iran to salvage their own economies because any tacit acceptance by them of the right of Iran to control the straits would set a terrible precedent and empower Iran's leverage towards its nuclear ambitions.
Speaker 63
Can I assure him on that front? Because this came up in all the conversations I had. There was absolute clarity, amongst all the leaders that I spoke with that there mustn't be any conditions, mustn't be any tolls, or anything that increases the chokehold in relation to the Strait Of Hormuz. In relation to that Strait, in particular, very important to the Gulf, but also, we fought for the principle of freedom of navigation for many, many years and for good reason.
Speaker 27
Manuela Pertigala. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. At the beginning of Trump's illegal war in Iran, we witnessed the bombing of the school, which killed at least 168 people, including 110 children. So can the prime minister tell the house whether the UK government has agreed a no strike list of civilian infrastructure that must not be hit by US planes launching missions missions from UK military bases?
Speaker 63
Let me be really clear about that because there must be a lawful basis for anything we do, and that includes what happens from our bases, which is why I've been very clear about the use of the bases and why we're monitoring the use of the bases, on the terms that we set out.
Speaker 115
Since we last met in this place, the president of The United States has had at least three positions in relation to the Strait Of Hormuz. First of all, he said that it was not in his interest because The US didn't need it and didn't use it. Then he speculated that actually it might be a good idea to have tolls on ships passing through the Strait with Iran in a joint venture, and now today he is overseeing a blockade. Given those incredibly erratic comments, can I commend the prime minister for his consistent and calm leadership, which stands in such clear contrast? And can I I ask the prime minister if he agrees with me that ultimately this conflict will be concluded not by post on social media, but by patient and persistent diplomacy?
Speaker 63
can I agree with him? And I think, that is precisely why we're pursuing that patient diplomacy, which is an essential first step to getting the strait open, and we'll continue to do so.
Speaker 90
deputy speaker. Madam deputy speaker, I'd like to ask the prime minister about food security. In response to an earlier question, he suggested that the answer to, food security was to have further and faster on on renewable energy. But does he recognise that carpeting some of the country's best some of, indeed, some of the world's best farmland in Lincolnshire in solar panels is counterproductive to that aim?
Speaker 63
I don't think it's counterproductive, but just just to be really clear, the most important thing on food security is getting the de escalation in the Strait Of Hormuz open, and that's why we're convening a number of countries, have been for the last two and a half weeks, we'll do again later this week, to operate at all levels to try and get that done as quickly as possible. I understand the impact on the farmers in her constituency and across The United Kingdom, and that is why we have to have that absolute focus in the work that we're doing.
Speaker 67
Ruth Jones. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And I thank the prime minister for the statement today. He will know that, Yom Hashoah, a Jewish Jewish commemoration of 6,000,000 Jews murdered during the Holocaust, begins tonight. We must never forget.
Speaker 107
But as this powerful memorial begins, Benjamin Netanyahu continues fled international laws by bombing innocent civilians in Lebanon and intimidating Palestinians in the West Bank under the cover of The US Iran situation. So what can The UK do to support the victims of Netanyahu and stop his ongoing destructive act actions in all areas? Here, here. Will?
Speaker 63
I thank her for her question. It's that that's why it's so important that we stay anchored in our principles and our values, foremost of which is that any action that we take or support must have a lawful basis.
Speaker 15
Brendan O'Hara. Madam deputy speaker, following his ill conceived illegal war in Iran, president Trump has now sent the US Navy to block the Straits Of Hormuz. Already this year, Trump has unlawfully invaded Venezuela and has threatened to annex Greenland, invade Cuba and quit NATO. He even accused UK troops and those of our allies of cowardice before launching an unprecedented attack on the integrity of Pope Leo. Clearly, there is nothing sacred or off limits to this man, yet there was not a single mention of Donald Trump in the prime minister's statement.
Speaker 108
Given the catalogue of illegality and bullying, does the prime minister still believe that president Trump is a stable, reliable, and trustworthy ally?
Speaker 63
Can I remind him that, every day we work with The US on defense, security, and, intelligence sharing? The intelligence when I say the US administration, The US, I mean president Trump. He's the president. Yes. We share intelligence on a daily basis.
That intelligence, that safeguards many people in all countries across The United Kingdom. And it would be foolhardy, in my view, to give up that co work that we do, which is vitally important, and safeguards the lives and interests of so many so many people in this country on a daily basis.
Speaker 57
deputy speaker and I thank the PM for his statement today. The disruption in the Strait Of Remus is having a real and growing impact on ordinary working people across the world and in my constituency of Blackpool South, many are already struggling to make ends meet, something the Prime Minister and I discussed a few weeks ago when we met. So can the Prime Minister update the House and my constituents in Blackpool South, what steps he is taking to resolve this issue as quickly as possible. Yes.
Speaker 63
And I know this will be of interest to his constituents. Many of whom are worried by what they're seeing on their screens, also the knowledge that it may impact them on the cost of living. And I can assure them that that is the reason that we are working with allies, to seek de escalation, to get the Strait Of Hormuz open. That isn't, a remote issue. It's an issue which affects them, their cost of living, and the bills in their households, and that is uppermost in my mind as I take these actions.
Speaker 103
The Lebanese health ministry earlier today confirmed 2,055 civilians have been killed since the start of this latest crisis, including a hundred and sixty seven since Friday alone. So I joined the prime minister in calling for that urgent ceasefire to include Lebanon. But also, since this crisis has started, the treasury have received over £200,000,000 in additional VAT from fuel. So will the prime minister commit to using those funds here in The UK to mitigate the cost of living crisis Yeah.
Speaker 63
Hear hear. On Lebanon, his question underlines again why it's so important that Lebanon is included in the ceasefire. And, of course, we're looking across the board at all contingencies in relation to the support that we can put in.
Speaker 60
Busy Collins. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. My constituents are absolutely horrified by the civilian toll of US, Israeli, Iranian military attacks, including threats to basic civilian infrastructure. They're also very concerned about the long term domestic impact of the closure of the Strait Of Hormuz, for example, on food prices. So firstly, can the prime minister reassure my that UK bases will never be used to target civilians or civilian infrastructure?
Secondly, can you reassure them that the Government is planning for all possible domestic impacts? Let
Speaker 63
me give that assurance on both fronts. Both very important points. Give that assurance.
Speaker 111
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Oxfam has warned that the Gaza playbook is being repeated. The Israeli military is demolishing villages in South Of Lebanon, displacing over 1,300,000 people, killing over 2,000 and injuring over 6,400 people. Prime minister, journalists are being killed by the Israelis. NGOs are being killed by the Israelis.
Speaker 9
The United Nation peacekeepers are being targeted by the IDF. So it's all good and well for the prime minister to say it's wrong. Can I ask what he's going to actually tangibly do to stop Israel's war machine in its tracks this time and do what he failed to do during the genocide in Gaza and say no to Israel and say no to Benjamin Netanyahu? Well,
Speaker 63
it's right. The, attacks are wrong, and it's important that we are clear on that. Lebanon should be included in the ceasefire, and we're clear on that. We need to work with our allies to follow through on both of those propositions.
Speaker 12
Jane Kirkham. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I want to send my thanks and thoughts to our personnel, particularly the Cornish Merlin that's supporting our jets to defend British citizens since the Saturday after the conflict started. The Straits Of Hormuz issue has underlined the massive importance of energy independence in this country. Can the Prime Minister outline how we're seeking to solve that crisis in the short, medium and the long term, particularly considering the wealth of natural resources we have in critical minerals and energy in Cornwall?
Speaker 63
Can I just underscore the point she makes about the wealth in terms of that capability in Cornwall? And we do, in relation to renewables, need to go further and faster to make sure that we get the energy independence, and that is important for her constituents and constituents across the country.
Speaker 4
Thank you, Bennett. Deputy speaker. The manufacturing businesses I visited my constituency recently are clear about the importance of both the availability and affordability of energy. The longer business waits for a plan, the worse the damage will be as investment plans are postponed and other costs are cut. So when will the government act to support businesses particularly in energy intensive sectors like manufacturing, hospitality and
Speaker 63
we have taken action in relation to particularly energy intensive businesses. I recognize that those that fall without that, outside that protection are extremely concerned. The most important thing we can do for them is to reduce the cause of the energy prices going up, and that is to deescalate the situation and get the Strait Of Hormuz open because that's the cause of the energy prices going up.
Speaker 54
Deputy speaker, the brutal Iranian regime is utterly appalling, but that is not a statement which is necessarily true of its ordinary citizens. So can I thank the prime minister, for calling out president president Trump's words about obliterating a generation? Now, the conflict has brought, a civilization. The conflict has brought, our energy security into sharp focus, is why today's announcement, the £600,000,000 deal with Rolls Royce for small modular reactors is so important. It's good for the country and it's good for jobs for my constituent constituents in Derby.
So can I ask the prime minister to work further and go farther, to, ensure that the small modular reactor, program is expanded and that it's brought to support our grid at pace?
Speaker 63
Can I thank you for raising that? The Rolls Royce project is hugely important. I'm very glad that we're able to announce it today because that is the first of the SMR projects, and it's really important that we take full advantage of projects like that.
Speaker 110
Thank you madam deputy speaker. Given the threat that the Iranian regime and its terrorist proxies in Lebanon present to world peace in in The Middle East, and beyond. Does the minister prime minister not accept that action against that regime was inevitable to cut back their military ability and also their ability to blackmail the rest of the world through illegally stopping an important waterway. It has economic consequences for our own country, but would you accept that given the the additional tax revenue which the government has brought from the increased fuel prices, that there is room to give extra support and the longer run, of course, extract their own oil and resources, get the tax from that, and, have a secure supply which can't be interrupted?
Speaker 63
Can I thank him? And, look, the nuclear capability, and the development thereof and the proxies is a threat, of course, that has to be dealt with. And the question is how that is dealt with. I've made my decisions based on the twin questions of whether any action that we take is got a lawful basis and a viable thought through plan, and those are the principles that have guided me. But it doesn't take away from the fact that those threats are there, we have to deal with them in the most effective way possible.
And, of course, we need to look at the support that we can, put in for both businesses and individuals who are impacted by, this conflict.
Speaker 70
I'm deputy speaker. Can I commend our ongoing, refusal to be drawn in this conflict? And can I ask the prime minister what steps we're taking to ensure that UK bases aren't used for offensive operations and furthermore won't be used for any ill advised US blockade which will be economically rudest of the straight of home moves?
Speaker 63
Can I thank you for that question? The bases are strictly for defensive purposes, and we monitor that in order to make sure that that remain that that is and remains the case.
Speaker 44
Madam deputy speaker, I thank the prime minister for his comments on Lebanon. We're seeing an Israeli military playbook from the from Gaza collective punishment, forced displacement, and attacks on health being used in Lebanon without meaningful action from the UK government. Will the prime minister please outline the specific steps his government will take to ensure an end to Israel's chronic immunity and impunity? Thank you.
Speaker 63
Well, in relation to Lebanon, I think the immediate focus has to be on ensuring the ceasefire does extend to Lebanon. That is crucially important. Obviously, there's some diplomacy going on at the moment, but we need to keep that firmly, in mind and work with others, not only on the question of Lebanon, but on accountability, which goes with the principle that any action should have a lawful basis.
Speaker 34
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And can I thank the prime minister for his leadership on this? Unlike certain other world leaders, it's clear that he recognizes the consequences that international crises have on the cost of living at home. My constituents are feeling that every time they go and fill up the car. And that's further made made galling by the fact that, in Bracknell between, fuel is between two and ten p more expensive than in neighboring towns.
What conversations has the government had with the competition markets authority and the sector at large to clamp down on this obvious unfairness?
Speaker 63
Well, I thank you for his question. And I'm absolutely conscious of the impact this is having on fuel and therefore people in his constituency and across the country. We are working on a number of fronts. One, to make sure there's absolutely no profiteering from this in relation to the price discrepancies, but also, to ensure that we deescalate the situation, get the Strait Of Hormuz open, which will, be the most effective way to get those prices down again, which will impact on everybody filling up their cars.
Speaker 93
The prime minister knows that his government's coffers have been swollen by hundreds of millions by the extra, particularly VAT tax take on rising fuel prices. Would it therefore be unreasonable to expect a socialist government to practice some redistribution of wealth from government to hard pressed vehicle users, farmers, businesses who are being crippled by the price hack price hack in fuel. And today, surely, he can give some light to consumers by saying that instead of anticipating a restoration, an increase in fuel duty, he will announce a decrease in fuel duty.
Speaker 63
Well, we are looking at all contingencies. It's important that we do so, and we will continue to do so mindful of the impact that he points out in his question. But there's no getting away from the fact that it is de escalation and getting the Strait Of Hormuz open that is the single most important thing we need to focus on at the moment.
Speaker 32
Madam deputy speaker, and can I thank the prime minister for the positive steps that The UK is taking to promote a negotiated settlement to the war and reassurance to shipping post settlement through the Straits Of Hormuz? But it is clear that the war, even thus far, will have a significant impact on British consumers. The prime minister has talked about very welcome measures to support residents with energy bills, and they will be welcomed by my constituents in Dartford. But would he consider additional measures to support those who are most vulnerable, those on the lowest incomes, with the cost of living going forward as a result of the impact of this war?
Speaker 63
Yes. We are considering what further support that we can put in place and bearing in mind that de escalation is the single most effective thing we can do.
Speaker 47
You, madam president speaker. The impact of this conflict is horrific for those in the line of fire. It's also having a significant creating some significant financial distress for residents and businesses right across these aisles. The Prime Minister stated that energy bills have gone down from the April 1. For tens of thousands of my constituents who rely on kerosene and LPG, that is not true.
Speaker 113
For tens of thousands of my constituents that use petrol and diesel to access essential services many miles from their home, that is not true. Will he correct the record on that, and will he also tell us when he is actually going to do something to help those households that are in distress?
Speaker 63
And he'll know that we, in addition to bringing household energy bills down by a 100 pounds from April until the June, we also announced the support we're putting in for oil, those that use oil to heat their homes. We need to look more closely across the board.
Speaker 6
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. President Trump told the world that this was about liberating the Iranian people, but you don't liberate people by murdering a 165 Iranian children in this illegal attack. And what we are witnessing now is an absolute madness where Donald Trump seeks to implement collective punishment, not just on Iranians by closing the street over Mawls, but the wider global community, including British families that are seeking a price rise in fuel, food, and utilities. So will when will this prime minister build the courage and strength to state that the attack and the continued action is illegal under international law? And if he seeks to provaricate, doesn't it just show how weak and embarrassing this government's become?
Speaker 63
Hear. Hear. We're one of the countries that are pulling together a coalition to deal with the impact of this by de escalating the situation and seeking to get the, Strait Of Hormuz open. That is the most important thing for his constituents, for my constituents, and people across the country.
Speaker 115
I'm deputy speaker. First of all, I'd like to associate myself with the remarks of the honorable member for Trone, far north of the guards of the Cornish Merlin, helicopters from RNS, Cul Droves in in my constituency. The the prime minister knows he has the full support of all the house when he he says that he wants Lebanon included in in the ceasefire, but surely he must accept that that he can do a great deal more by first of all ensuring that no UK arms components ends up in the hands of the genocidal Netanyahu government and secondly by by ensuring that there is absolutely no trade with the illegal settlements in in in the occupied Palestinian territories.
Speaker 63
I thank him for that. And as he knows, we've taken measures on both of those fronts in relation to the framework of law that we have in place.
Speaker 50
Jim Shannon. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. First of all, think it's important that we do recognize the prime minister's efforts in The Middle East to try and find a a way forward that's incredibly difficult and should be recognized. There have been fuel protests in The Republic Of Ireland just in the last week. Some of, protests are planned for Northern Ireland in this week coming in.
Last Friday, I spoke to the Ulster Farmers Union and some of the farmers expressing concern about the rise in the price of red diesel and also fertilizer. On the Saudi and Portovuki, the fishing sector told me they were concerned about the the rise in diesel in their, boats as well. And the HTV spoke to me last Friday and Saturday to express the same thing. Republic Of Ireland have given some €4,000,000 €5,000,000, 4,000,000 sterling every day for now for the next thirteen weeks to help those sectors. If they can do it, prime minister, please do the same for us in Northern Ireland and did across us across the board
Speaker 63
at what support can be put in place and looking at all the contingencies, but there's no escaping the fact that if we don't do the international work to deescalate and get the strait open, then we're fighting an uphill battle, which is why we have to convene those countries and try to resolve what's a very challenging situation.
Speaker 55
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. If I may join the prime minister in recognizing and commending Pakistan's efforts efforts to facilitate dialogue in the pursuit of peace. It is, however, regrettable that a resolution has not yet been secured. I therefore asked the prime minister what assessment has he made of the breakdown in US and Iran talks, of Israel's role in the in the collapse of those talks and of the ongoing strikes in Lebanon? And will he condemn this continued hostility which is creating a fresh human humanitarian crisis in a region already torn apart apart by Israel's genocide of the Palestinians?
And finally, does the prime minister acknowledge that it is long overdue that Israel's aggression in that region be forced to stop through sanctions and cutting up diplomatic ties.
Speaker 63
In relation to the talks, as I mentioned earlier, I spoke to the prime minister of Pakistan on Friday ahead of the talks. We've been in touch again since the talks broke down about the very issue he raises, which is the prospect of still trying to find a way forward. And we will work with the prime minister of Pakistan and others to try and ensure that we get that diplomacy, as far as we can deescalate the situation in that way.
Speaker 68
I thank the prime minister for his statement this afternoon. I'll allow a couple of moments for
Speaker 68
Brings us to statement from the home secretary on the Southport inquiry. Home secretary.
Speaker 41
With permission, I would like to make a statement on the Southport inquiry. I must thank all who participated in the inquiry and the chair, Sir Adrian Falford, and his team. Today, sir Adrian published the report of the inquiry's first phase. This summer, the government will provide a full response. This will also cover Lord Anderson's prevent review.
Today, I will provide the government's initial reaction to an inquiry that exposes a series of tragic failures from which we must learn. We do so in the shadow of the events of the 07/29/2024. I will not name the perpetrator nor dwell on the details of the crimes that saw three beautiful young girls murdered, the attempted murder of eight other children and two adults, and lasting physical and psychological harm to many more. I know I speak on behalf of the whole house when I say my thoughts today are with all those affected. In honour of them and the memory of three murdered girls, Elsie Dotsgancombe, BB King, and Alice de Silva Aguirre, we must now act to prevent similar attacks.
It was for that reason that my predecessor appointed sir Adrian Falford to lead a full statutory inquiry. The inquiry's work has two parts. The first, which reported today, considered the decisions made by the agencies and services that interacted with the perpetrator. This included a range of institutions within the criminal justice system, as well as education, health care, and local government. It also considered the actions of the perpetrator's parents.
The findings of the inquiry are unsparing. Sir Adrian has uncovered systematic failures across multiple organisations. The recording and sharing of information was poor. None of the agencies involved had a full understanding of the risk that the perpetrator posed, and many did not take steps to assess the risk that he posed to others. There was a failure by the agencies involved to take responsibility, and nobody was clear as to who was in charge.
So the failure, because it belonged to everyone, belonged to no one. Where individuals missed opportunities to intervene, lessons must be learnt. But they did so within organisations that repeatedly passed the risk to others and where systemic failings existed. The perpetrator came into contact with the state on countless occasions. Lancashire police responded to five calls to his home address.
The police were called when he was in possession of a knife in a public place. He was referred on several occasions to the multi agency safeguarding hub. He came into contact with children's social care, the early help service, and children's mental health services. He was referred to prevent on three occasions. He was convicted of a violent assault and referred to a youth offending team.
All failed to identify the risk that the perpetrator posed, and so he fell between the gaps. The warning signs were missed, a growing history of violence, and a clear and continuing intent to commit harm. In the Home Office, the focus falls on prevent and policing. Sir Adrian is clear that police should have progressed the perpetrator to the multi agency Channel programme, and Channel could have actively assessed and managed his risk. Instead, he was not deemed suitable because he had no fixed ideology.
This ran counter to the guidance at the time, but the thresholds were unclear and the guidance was applied inconsistently. The perpetrator's multiple referrals were also considered individually, when they should have been seen as a cumulative and compounding risk. The perpetrator did not receive the correct interventions, and his autism diagnosis meant that professionals focused far too much on his vulnerability and far too little on the threat that he might pose to others. The horrific attack was itself evidence of the ease with which it could be concluded. There was no restrictions to stop the perpetrator from watching the violent content that inspired him, nor downloading instructions to make poison, nor viewing in terrorist materials online.
He was also able to bypass the safeguards that should have stopped him from buying and receiving dangerous weapons. These findings are devastating, but they are not surprising. Findings like these have been heard in inquests and inquiries before. This time, however, they must be a spur for change. The inquiry makes 67 recommendations.
The government is reviewing these and will respond to those which relate to national government this summer, and I expect local agencies to do the same. Since this awful crime, the government has already acted, and that begins with prevent. Since the Southport attack, the Home Office and counterterrorism policing have reviewed historical cases to ensure that similar instances were handled correctly, with cases reassessed for any change in risk and managed accordingly. This government has reviewed the prevent thresholds and published updated guidance. We've introduced a new prevent assessment framework with mandatory training for counter terrorism case officers.
Oversight of repeat prevent referrals has been strengthened, ensuring that cumulative risk is not missed and that senior sign off is required before a case is closed. And to prevent independent oversight of the whole system, we created an independent prevent commissioner. I would like to thank Lord Anderson for so ably taking on that position on an interim basis. His term ends today, and I am pleased to say that I've appointed Tim Jakes as the new prevent commissioner who begins his role tomorrow. This government has also begun to place greater controls on a dangerously unregulated online world.
The Online Safety Act requires companies to remove illegal content from their platforms. The act is intended to limit children from encountering content that is legal but poses a risk of significant harm. But this is just the beginning of what can and must be done. The Internet remains a dangerous place for children, and we are clear that tech companies have a moral responsibility to keep their users safe. But have no doubt that when they fail to do so, this government will intervene, which is why the government is consulting on whether to remove children's access to social media entirely.
I can also announce today that we will legislate to prevent the spread of extreme violent content online. We've also made it harder for people to purchase weapons. The crime and police bill places new controls on the online sale and delivery of knives. We have banned the manufacture, purchase, and possession of ninja swords and zombie style machetes. And earlier this year, we published new guidance mandating that any child caught with a knife must be referred to a youth offending team.
In the aftermath of the attack, the government commissioned Jonathan Hall Casey, the independent reviewer of terrorism legislation, to consider the legislative gaps exposed by this attack. This identified an inconsistency that clearly needed addressing. Unlike terrorist attacks, if you are planning an attack without an underlying ideology, there is no crime on the statute book. Jonathan Hall therefore recommended the creation of a new offence, and this legislation will also be brought forward as soon as parliamentary time allows. But the inquiry also identifies a wider issue.
There are rising numbers of young men who are fascinated by extreme violence, boys whose minds are warped by time spent in isolation online, and this is a risk to us all. Where someone is vulnerable to terrorism, they can and should be managed through the prevent programme. However, where they are not, there is no clear approach to that risk. Today, we published the terms of reference for the second part of the Southport inquiry, and it will face directly into this challenge. Sir Adrian will provide recommendations on the adequacy of existing arrangements across all arms of the State for identifying and managing the risk posed by violence fixated individuals.
He will explore what specific interventions are required to reduce the risk to the public. He will also review the influence of the internet and social media, and the ease with which weapons can be procured. Sir Radron begins this work immediately and will present his final recommendations next spring. Madam deputy speaker, in the 2024, an act of unspeakable evil took place in Southport. Nothing will ever heal the pain of those who survive, including the families who suffered unimaginable loss.
Responsibility rests with the perpetrator. There was also responsibility within the family. The perpetrator's parents knew the risk he posed, but did not cooperate with the authorities. And there is also responsibility on the state and on all of us here to learn the lessons from failures wherever they occurred. And the lesson is that the failures happened everywhere.
We must ensure we do not find ourselves here again, grieving deaths which should never have happened had the state and those who worked within it acted differently. Madam deputy speaker, that is our task, and I commend the statement to the house.
Speaker 74
Thank you, madam deputy speaker, and I thank the home secretary for advanced sight of her statement. Let us remember the three victims of this savage attack, BB King, aged just six, Elsie Dot Scantcombe, aged seven, and Alastair Silva Aguirre, aged nine, and eight more children and two adults who were seriously injured. I also want to thank Merseyside Emergency Services who responded to this event. As the home secretary quite rightly said, this report identifies very serious repeated failings by public bodies. Sir Adrian said, and I quote, a merry-go-round of referrals, assessments, case closures, and handoffs meant no agency took the lead or properly addressed the danger Radhakubana posed.
Multiple opportunities were missed to prevent this tragedy. Sir Adrian also found Radhubakarna's parents created, quotes, significant obstructions to constructive engagement. Sir Adrian makes important recommendations. I'm glad the home secretary will respond by the summer, and we, on this side of the house, will support necessary actions. During the inquiry, we heard evidence given by Radhakabana's former head teacher, Joanne Hodgson.
She told the inquiry she was pressured by mental health services to water down the EHCP to minimize the danger posed by Radha Cabana because of his ethnicity. Miss Hodson told the inquiry this, and I quote verbatim, my efforts to include this information in the EHCP were met with hostility by the father and also by mental health services. Miss Steed, who was from CAMS, even went as far as to accuse me of racially stereotyping AR as a black boy with a knife. Nothing could be further from the truth. But in the end, the wording of the EHCP was rewritten in many places.
That's the end of her verbatim quote. Madam deputy speaker, this contributed to the clear risks being missed. The Nottingham inquiry into the three tragic murders there identified exactly the same issue. Mental health professionals in Nottingham decided not to section Valdo Calicone because they were concerned about, and again, I quote verbatim, an overrepresentation of young black males in detention. And the government's own notes accompanying the king's speech on the mental health bill even refer to this issue as well.
Madam deputy speaker, the fixation with ethnic disproportionality is deeply damaging. Ethnicity should never be a consideration when an agency is taking steps to protect the public. Everybody should simply be treated exactly the same. We cannot allow dangerous individuals to avoid detention for public safety simply because of their ethnicity. Everybody should be treated the same.
I think it would be helpful if the home secretary makes clear from the dispatch box that she agrees with that approach and sets out how the government will change their approach in the future. Today's report also makes clear that Raduka Barna's autism was wrongly allowed to inhibit the way he was dealt with. Yet the government's king's speech notes the mental health bill again expressly says people with autism should be sectioned less often. Given the findings of today's report, will the government reconsider that? I also want to raise the aftermath of this tragedy which saw serious rioting.
Speaker 52
It is, of course, important to avoid prejudicing criminal trials. However, as Jonathan Hall, the independent reviewer of terrorism legislation said, and I quote, the government has to be aware that if there is an information gap, other voices, particularly on social media, will try to fill it. He went on, quite often, there's a fair amount that can be put into the public domain. And indeed, in October, two or three months after the attack, but well before the trial, information concerning the Al Qaeda terror manual and Rising was put in the public domain without prejudicing the trial. So I think the failure to provide information did create an information vacuum in those early days of August 2024, and that vacuum was filled by untrue speculation online, some of it originating outside The UK, which fueled the riots.
Speaker 74
So, to having regard to that, will the home secretary commit to making sure such information is routinely released in cases of public interest in the future. Madam deputy speaker, as the mother of Elsie said at the inquiry, this tragedy must be a line in the sand. We owe it to the victims, to the survivors, and to their families to learn the lessons from this tragedy and to make sure it never happens again.
Speaker 41
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Let me say I welcome the, shadow home secretary's, comments about, potentially working together on the changes that need to be, made, as a result of the initial findings of the inquiry. The government will respond by the summer, and I look forward to discussions with him and with others in this house to make sure that the house is united as one in the action that needs to be taken. As he says, that is the very least that we owe the victims' families and all those who've been affected by this horrific, horrific tragedy. Let me just say on the issue of missus Hodson, the head teacher, whose specific testimony he referred to Shiffforce gave evidence, and I I believe that the position that she took was vindicated very strongly by the chair in the findings of the inquiry.
And let me be absolutely clear, the only factors that should be taken into account are the potential risk posed by an individual and how best to manage that risk. No other factors are relevant. And it is clear, not just in relation to the experience that missus Hodgson had, but actually the failures that existed across a multiplicity of public agency. That was the failure to appropriately assess the risk that the perpetrator posed to others, which was at the heart of the problem. And that is how he managed to slip through the cracks because no one agency took responsibility for the assessment of that risk and, ultimately, for the managing of the risk that the perpetrator posed to others.
Those are the only factors that should ever be taken into account, and I will be working closely with government ministers from other departments as we formulate our full response to the findings by the inquiry in setting out what our expectations are of professionals, not just in health, but in other public services as well. Let me also say on the diagnosis of autism, sir Adrian, in his report, did make it clear that it would be wrong to make a general association between autism and increased risk of violence to others. But he also found that in the perpetrator's case, the way his autism manifested did increase the risk of harm that he posed to others. And it does show the absolute importance of taking a case by case approach and making sure that all factors are adequately taken, into account, and that agencies take responsibility for how that risk, is going, to be managed. And, again, there are good lessons to learn, from, from this for health practitioners and for others in our local services when it comes to both assessment of risk, but also, ultimately, for how it is best managed.
Let me say to him on the issues relating to the communications post the attack taking place, especially at a point where there was a lot of misinformation that was being spread, particularly online. He will know that there has already been a change in practice, learning the lessons of what happened then. There was, of course, a well meaning desire to make sure that nothing was done that might prejudice a future trial, but exactly how the rules are applied, I think, can be a matter of interpret interpretation and degree. The College of Policing has already created new professional practice in its guidance for police officers. There is already now a new CPS, that is to say, the Crown Prosecution Service and media protocol, and we are developing a new charter between criminal justice agencies and the media to make sure that whatever information can readily and easily be made available is done so at the earliest opportunity.
It will always be incredibly important that nothing is done that might prejudice a future trial. But I know he will acknowledge that since this horrific attack, there's already been a change in approach to comms, the government and other agencies have already, in other instances and in other cases, been making much more availability much more information available to the media and, ultimately, therefore, to the public. Let me just say, in conclusion, madam deputy speaker, do I I know that the findings of the inquiry and also in phase two report will be of, great interest to members across the whole house, and I do look forward to working, not just with the official opposition, but with all parties, to make sure that the house is as won in, the response to this horrific tragedy. That is what we owe all of the victims, of this case.
Speaker 57
deputy speaker. I welcome the Home Secretary's statement, this afternoon. My constituents expect PREVENT to keep them safe. So can she reiterate what changes she will make in this Home Secretary and this Government to prevent, to help stop an attack like this again in the future?
Speaker 41
Thank you. My Honourable Friend makes an incredibly important point on the reliance that all of us place upon the prevent program, that we should rightly be able to place on that program to make sure it is as strong as it is possible to be in preventing tragedies and diverting people away from potentially committing a terrorist act and driving them away from extremism more broadly. We have already been delivering a number of improvements to the prevent program. There is new statutory guidance. There's improved training, new case management systems, much stronger interventions for people who are already on the programme, and a strengthened approach to managing repeat referrals.
So, where you've got a number of referrals which individually might have not led to a an onward referral to the channel stream, the cumulative impact is now already being taken into account. There is also now a much more robust risk assessment tool, and I think the totality of the changes that we've already made have put the program in a much stronger position. But, of course, learning, the findings from this inquiry, we will take more action as necessary.
Speaker 17
Thank you, madam deputy speaker, and I thank the home secretary for advanced sight of her statement. To know that there were so many missed opportunities to stop the Southport attack is truly heartbreaking, and my thoughts today are with the bereaved families whose young daughters were so cruelly taken from them and the many other victims who suffered unimaginable trauma that day. We owe it to them to make every attempt to prevent a senseless attack like this from ever happening again. And the report today lays bare that agency after agency failed to step up and take ownership of the risks that the perpetrator posed. There are monumental failures across a number of authorities, the police, PREVENT, NHS mental health services, children's social care, youth offending services and the perpetrator's parents.
This is simply not acceptable. So, can the Home Secretary please confirm how soon she plans to report back on whether the government will be accepting all 67 of the recommendations, and will she commit to providing Parliament with an update on progress every six months? Today's report exposes serious oversights also by online giants that allow the perpetrator to collect an arsenal of weapons without effective age verification checks. Will the Home Secretary confirm whether the recently published knife crime strategy will address the ease with which knives are available for purchase online and crack down on those big tech companies like Amazon who are putting profit above protocol when it comes to the sale of dangerous items. And finally, the Liberal Democrats have long argued that prevent is not fit for purpose and it is deeply shocking that the perpetrator was referred three times and yet no further action was taken.
We understand that was because he didn't possess a specific ideology. Should be no clearer sign of a system unable to address modern threats. So will the Home Secretary commit to a full overhaul of prevent within this Parliament so that warning future signs aren't missed? Will she commit to bringing forward the legislation recommended by Jonathan Hall KC in the next King's speech?
Speaker 41
You, madam deputy speaker. Let me thank the Liberal Democrat spokeswoman for her comments. She's absolutely right. The sheer number of missed opportunities in this case is truly horrifying, and it's why we must do everything we can to reform all of these systems within our public services to make sure no such incident can happen again. Let let me say to her, there will be a comprehensive response from the government on all of the recommendations made from phase one of the inquiry.
I intend to do so before the summer, so the House will have an opportunity to debate that. And, of course, as we move to delivery of the government's response to the recommendations, I will, of course, keep the House updated on our progress, including on where potential future legislation might also be needed. Let me say to her, in terms of the sale of knives in the crime and policing bill, which is still continuing its passage through parliament, we have introduced new age verification checks, both at the point of sale and also at point of delivery of knives as a way of directly responding to some of the issues that we've seen in this case, where the perpetrator was able to slip through the system that should not be possible in the future once the bill becomes an act of parliament and is implemented. Let me also say to her on the threat posed by those who are fixated by violence, but who don't necessarily have an ideology or who have a mixed ideology or who flit into having an ideology and then not having one. There is a developing complex picture of the sorts of threats that we are facing.
We've made it very clear that those who have no fixed ideology but are vulnerable to terrorism are still and should be referred to the prevent program. That remains the lead program for dealing with the risk posed by those individuals. The inquiry recognizes that there is a gap from those who do not have a fixed ideology, who are not vulnerable, to terrorism, who might slip, through. The the phase two of the inquiry will consider how best to respond, to, those sorts of cases. We'll make recommendations on who should take the lead on dealing with those individuals.
But I want to assure the honorable lady and all members in the house, the government is not simply waiting for phase two to report. We're already trialing with a number of local authorities a new approach for those who are below the threshold for prevent, but who have a risk that we are concerned about and where we believe that they might pose a risk of harm to others, to think about different ways in which agencies might handle that risk to make sure that those individuals don't slip through the net. As we learn lessons from those pilots, we will seek to start implementing them whilst we wait, of course, for Sir Adrian Fulford and the inquiry team to come forward with fuller recommendations on this later in the future.
Speaker 76
madam deputy speaker, and can I thank the home secretary for her statement? I'd like to place on record my sympathies to the families of Alice, Elsie and Bebe who are living with the most unimaginable loss. The Southport attack has been ruled a disaster waiting to happen after the perpetrator was referred to prevent on three separate occasions and other multi agency failings have been highlighted by sir Adrian Fulford. On the 06/20/2020, my constituents, Gary and Jan Fairlong lost their son James, who was murdered during the Forbury Gardens terrorist attack. I'm also thinking of them today, madam deputy speaker.
Speaker 116
Like the South like Southpaw, the perpetrator of the Forbury Gardens attack had been referred to prevent four separate times and multi agency failures were also highlighted by sir Adrian Fulford. And like the deaths of Alice, Elsie and Beebe, the deaths of James Fairlong, doctor David Wales and Joseph Ritchie Benis were ruled as probably avoidable. I acknowledge that it will take some time to go through the 67 recommendations that has been made in respect of Southport, but can the home secretary advise, despite the improvement she has outlined today in respect to prevent, does she actually believe that prevent is fit for purpose? To quote the Home Secretary, Madam Deputy Speaker, from her statement, She said we must ensure we do not find ourselves here again grieving deaths which should never have happened had the state and those work within it acted differently. But the fact is that we are here again Madam Deputy Speaker and we are here time and time again after multi agency failures.
So can she immediately take respect in respect of joint or partnership working and outline to us what those steps will be to ensure that no family has to endure such loss. Madam Secretary.
Speaker 41
Well, can I thank my honourable friend for what she has just said and also associate myself with her remarks about the victims and the families of those who died in the Forbury Gardens attack? She is absolutely right. We have been here far far too many times. This must be a moment of change. I'm very hopeful that with such a thorough report from sir Adrian Forford, with such clear practical recommendations for action to prevent such a tragedy occurring in the future, that we can and will make progress.
And I do ask her and and I know she will accept that we this is what we owe families, and this is the very least that we owe all of the families. And I do look forward to working with colleagues across the House to implement recommendations as we move forward. All have to do more, and government agencies all have to do more as well. Let me assure her that I'm standing up a a task force to bring together all government ministers with relevant responsibilities to make sure that we are beginning work immediately on improving the systems and the processes that that are in place at the moment, and that we're not still simply waiting for the final phase of the inquiry to report. So there will be more progress.
We have taken steps on reforming prevent. I know that the PREVENT strategy, the work that it does, has been of interest in this house for many years and has been scrutinized very, very thoroughly. Let me say to her, an intervention program of this kind is always going to have to move very quickly to deal with changing threat patterns. So even if we just look at Islamist extremism, for example, the way that that might have presented in the era of Daesh and ISIL in Syria, sort of becoming prominent is different to how it presents now, And practitioners have to be able to adapt as quickly as the presentation of extremist ideologies is developing as well. So it will always be a work in progress.
I think that that is something that we should acknowledge just because the nature of the threat is changing so quickly and so regularly. But but we can and we will have strong mechanisms in place to make sure that it does the job that we all know it needs to do.
Speaker 90
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Madam deputy speaker, as a consultant paediatrician, I have to undertake preventive training at regular intervals and in each one of those occasions I've raised with ministers my concerns about either the quality or the emphasis or both of this training. But I wonder if the Home Secretary could say whether she feels in this particular situation the problem was mostly that the perpetrator didn't conform to the usual patterns that people were being trained to spot, that people were being badly trained, that people were not using their training diligently, or that the actions once the case had been reported were not followed through. Which was the major factor, does she think? Let
Speaker 41
me say to the honourable lady, I'd be happy to hear her personal experiences of the quality of that training. I think this is the first time she and I have had an interaction on this matter. I'd be very happy to pick those issues up off offline. Well, let me say on on the substance of her point, we we must follow the findings of the inquiry chair who said that there were five major failures here, that no single agency took ownership of the risk that the perpetrator posed, that there was poor information recording in management, but also that sometimes the behavior was excused on the basis of his perceived or diagnosed autism disorder. So there are a range of factors in place.
I think we should follow the evidence and the findings of the inquiry chair, and we will respond based on the failures that have been found.
Speaker 93
Deputy speaker, all of our thoughts are today with the families of Alice, Bebe, and Elsie. They have already suffered the most horrific loss. To have confirmation today from sir Adrian Fulford that their loss was preventable is utterly unbearable. Sir Adrian's report highlights the failure of the multi agency safeguarding hub, exactly the place where joint responsibility between different agencies should have been held. And he also said that children's services were not well equipped to manage a risk presented by a young person as distinct from risks to a young person.
Can I, therefore, ask the home secretary what plans she has to work with the Department for Education and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government to ensure that as a matter of urgency, every professional working with high risk young people knows exactly what to do when they are fearful that a young person is a risk to others and is accountable for taking that action?
Speaker 41
Secretary. Well, my honorable friend notes one of the absolute key failures, which is on, who the risk is to. And in this case, too much of the, internal assessments were on the risk to the perpetrator himself and not on the risk that he posed to others, and that must change. There were practical recommendations from Sir Adrian Fulford for the individual agencies, but I think there it speaks to a need for a a cultural shift, I think, in the way that these cases are looked at and managed. That will be a cultural shift for colleagues in the health department, in education, as well as in housing communities and local government.
Where a prevent referral is made because there is a vulnerability to terrorism, there are already systems in place that would enable those risk assessments to be made on the basis of risk posed to others. Of course, here it should have been made but was not made the onward referral to channel as should have happened. But we have to make sure that even where the onward referral to channel doesn't take place and somebody doesn't quite fit the threshold for prevent, that they are still picked up and that that cultural shift for management of risk, assessment of risk, dealing with it is take is taking into account all of the findings that sir Adrian Forford has made.
Speaker 81
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Can I thank the Home Secretary for her statement and for the way she is promoting learning rather than blaming, because that is the best way to get the change we need? And for her very robust response to my right and dear friend, the shadow home secretary, about the point he raised and for the point she now makes about the requirement of a cultural shift. Can she take a close interest in this because not many leaders in many organizations understand that that means changing the attitudes and behaviors of individuals in their organizations. It's not just about setting a policy and that requires a very concerted act of leadership and diligence and consistency and making sure that those who don't want to make the change are eased out of their positions and there are no promotions for those people who don't respect and demonstrate the changed attitudes and behaviours that are required.
This is a big ask and doesn't often happen in the public service.
Speaker 41
Home Secretary. I thank the honourable gentlemen. Let me say to him it is a big ask and I am very clear. This must be a moment of change. I don't want to be standing here with a future tragedy saying the same things that have been said in response to what happened in Southport.
We owe the families a true moment of change for the way that public services are delivered. And he is absolutely right. The cultural shift is absolutely critical to the ability to make onward progress here, whether that is agencies that don't normally consider risk posed to others because they're primarily concerned about the risk of harm a person poses to themselves and their clinical need that is different to a wider societal need to protect others from harm. And and I do think that that is now something that we are going to have to look at very closely as a government and to bring forward real change within our health service, within education, and within local government as well. Let me assure him and the house, I will take a close personal interest because at the end of the day, preventing harm and keeping our people safe is is my responsibility where people meet the threshold for being dealt with through the prevent strategy and onward referral to channel.
I will make sure we do everything we can to have those mechanisms as robust as possible, but where they are below that threshold, as a society we still need an answer and of course I will take a very close interest in that myself.
Speaker 55
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I know that the whole House's thoughts are with the family and of course my families and of course mine are too. One of the many aspects of what has gone wrong here relates to children's mental health services. Could the Home Secretary please outline what we are doing about the workforce for children's mental health services, because there is a real shortage of people who are skilled in this area? My
Speaker 41
honourable friend makes an absolutely important point. The Government's obviously already taken steps to shore up the provision of mental health services within the National Health Services. I'm joined by colleagues from the health department today who I know are listening very closely and will be absorbing the findings that sir Adrian Fulford has made in phase one of his inquiry. I will be working with all ministers across government before we formulate our fuller response to all of the 67 recommendations. But let me assure her the provision of mental health services will be absolutely critical to the work the government does as a result of this inquiry.
Speaker 45
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. The home secretary's statement confirms the core failure that when everyone was responsible, no one was accountable. And we have seen this pattern before, the same passing of the book in safeguarding, the same passing of the book in grooming young cases and in mental health. We have we have heard today about reviews, frameworks, and guidance but not enforcement. So I'd be grateful if the home secretary could tell us tell this house plainly, if recommendations are not followed to the letter, what consequences will follow?
Speaker 41
the honorable gentleman is right that, of course, it's one thing to to bring about changes and to change professional practice, but, of course, these these things should be enforced properly when the government responds in full before the summer. In in terms of our response to all 67 of the recommendations, I will lay out what our expectations are going forward. I think it's important to recognize the rate in Forford doesn't make individual findings a fact, in terms of individuals and those failings because there was such widespread system failure. So I do think it is right that in the first instance, the government looks at the wider systems that we have in place, but of course within those systems ultimately if there are failures and there are individual failures there should be accountability. Thank
Speaker 98
you madam deputy chief and I thank the home secretary for her statement today and her continued leadership on this issue. And can I join the whole house in sending my sympathies not only to the victims, to their families? This is absolutely a dreadful crime, and I'm sure any parent in the room I am one is is rightly appalled by it. Having worked both in education and also in the charity sector, I saw an awful amount of butt passing when it came to mental health support and also safeguarding issues. My view was always, if in doubt, report it.
And clearly in this case, things have been reported, but haven't been taken forward, which is hugely concerning. What can the Home Secretary do to ensure me that this buck passing, as mentioned by the member opposite, will stop and there will be accountability and people will be responsible for these issues?
Speaker 41
My honourable friend raises a really important point. He's absolutely right. The failure of any one organisation or group of individuals to take responsibility for the perpetrator is one of the key failures that has occurred in this case. What what phase two of the inquiry will consider is what is the best mechanism for managing people who pose these sorts of risks going forward, and and recommendations will be made about the proper structure that should be brought forward. Think where somebody meets the prevent threshold, prevent will remain the lead the lead institution for referrals.
And, of course, that referral and onward progression to the channel stream should have happened here. And if that had happened, then we would be in a different position today. But for those who don't fall within that threshold, we will need to have a wider system response. As I've said earlier, I am trialing in different local authorities pilots to look at different approaches for what you might do with those individuals who are below threshold. But in the end, think Sir Adrian Forford's work will give us the new framework and some guidance as to the best agency that should take the lead in different cases.
Because I think when an agency takes the lead, there is an obvious sort of accountability, or even if they're convening all of the other agencies, which is how multiagency safeguarding hubs should work and sometimes do not. Those are, I think, the key areas that lessons need to be learnt on. Bradley Thomas.
Speaker 117
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I thank the home secretary for her statement. Does she plan to provide any additional resource or funding to the prevent programme? And if so, does she have any initial idea as to where that may be targeted?
Speaker 41
Let me say to the honourable gentleman, he raises an important point. When the government responds in full to the recommendations, I will set out any resource implications that there are, not just for the work of the home office, but for other agencies as well.
Speaker 5
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And can I join the home secretary in commending the bravery of victims in coming forward to give evidence to this inquiry? We owe it to them to make this a turning point, to make certain that the systemic failures and culture that made this attack possible are fixed and can never be repeated. Many of us in this house will recognize from the report the difficulties in accessing CAMS, the ambiguities in responsibility and massive under resourcing of this vital service. Does my right honourable friend agree with me that this moment calls for nothing less than a revolution in how children's mental health services are commissioned and resourced?
Speaker 41
honorable friend makes an incredibly important point. There are, of course, recommendations for different government departments, including health, to take forward, and I will be working very closely with ministers from across government as we design our response to sir Adrian's recommendation. But let me tell him, on the issue of violence fixation, the dissent into nihilism, and that fascination with extreme violence, that does demand a new public policy response from all of government, particularly for those children who wouldn't necessarily meet a test for clinical need, but who absolutely do pose a risk of very serious harm to other people.
Speaker 110
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. When I heard the news this morning and it was read out the catalogue of failures, missed opportunities, and the focus of attention there was in this murder, and yet he was allowed to get off with it, my heart went out to the families of these three wee girls who could have avoided, and that their murder could have been avoided, and yet it was missed. And time and time again in this house, over the time I've been here, I've heard individual child abuse cases, rape gangs, mass murder, and all on each occasion, there was failure by public bodies and individuals in in public bodies to prevent what could have happened. And unfortunately, and as it had been highlighted here again today, there seems to be this attitude that, look, if there's color or ethnicity involved in it, that's an an additional factor and fear of racism. I welcome the assurances that the secretary of state has given today, but what I would ask is what steps, given how deeply this attitude is embedded in the public sector now, what steps does she intend to take to make sure that this does not happen again and that those who are responsible for these decisions are held to account?
Speaker 41
The honourable gentleman is right. Reading the report of the inquiry, it's horrifying. It makes for incredibly difficult reading, and the recommendations are incredibly important. The government will respond in full by the summer, and we'll take forward practical work to make sure that we strengthen all of our systems to make sure this can't occur again. Just let me repeat, the only thing that matters, the only relevant factor when we have a person who is violence fixated, has a fascination with extreme violence violence, is the risk they pose, the assessment of that risk, and then the steps to take to mitigate that risk.
No other factor should be taken into account by any agencies. The most important thing is we keep people safe and that we do not allow other irrelevant considerations to play any part. The inquiry made findings in relation to missus Hodson, the head teacher, and I endorse, of course, and agree with the findings that sir Adrian Forford has made. Garrison.
Speaker 104
Thank you very much, madam deputy speaker. The Home Secretary will be aware that there are 28 prevent priority areas across the country. There used to be 40 Stoke On Trent was one of them until 2023 when the last government changed the criteria. She'll know that to be a prevent priority area you normally have to demonstrate either right wing extremism as a hotspot or is the minister active as a hotspot or in the checkered past of my own city both. If Jonathan Hall's legislative suggestions come into force and we are now having a new offense of non ideological based fixation with violence, How does the Home Secretary see that playing into those prevent priority areas given that the locality of that is going to be much more difficult to consider?
And post the events in August 2022 when there were riots in Stoke On Trent, has the Home Secretary given any thought yet to whether or not any recommendations for where new funding should go to help deal with some of these issues? Should look at where there was rioting in August 2022, particularly in places like Stoke On Trent that don't currently qualify for prevent priority funding?
Speaker 41
My my honorable friend raises a a a really important point. Let let me say to him that, once phase two of the inquiry has concluded, especially on, the proper mechanism, by which we, deal with some of these violence fixated individuals, they will, of course, I think, be knock on consequences for the wider countering extremism system. It wouldn't be right for me now to get ahead of that, but let me assure him I'm very aware that that both the current work of the inquiry but also the future work of the inquiry will require further clarity, I think, on exactly where responsibilities sit. Prevent as a program will still, I believe, continue to play an incredibly important role. It will remain our main tool for countering extremism.
I'm sure there will be more we can do to strengthen its ability to counter extremism, but there will be knock on consequences in other parts of the system, including for funding as well. Will be able to set out more of, the government's response on that when we respond in full, to the inquiry's recommendations. But as phase two gets underway, I think that's where some of the real meat, of the new policy responses that are needed for violence fixated children, that's where that will come out.
Speaker 9
A young person who is at risk to harming others will often become known to a teacher, a social worker, a health worker before any other agency knows that this person is going to pose a risk. There are statutory requirements that make it very difficult to report on a young person if they are below a certain age. Will the home secretary clarify if she will work with multi agency, multi departmental changes to a statutory requirement that teachers, health workers, all of these, and councils are required to bring forth even a young person who is underage if they are going to pose a risk, if they are of risk and that that will take the statutory requirement above anything else because right now many agencies are afraid to come forward because they feel that there is a statutory requirement to protect the child rather than come forward if there is a harm that they could be potentially giving to someone else.
Speaker 41
The honorable lady, has raised an important point. Phase two of the inquiry will absolutely consider how we, deal with and what the correct public policy response is to children who are violence fixated. One of the horrifying developments of the last couple of year last few years or so is that the number of children, ever younger children, who are fascinated with extreme violence have this sort of nihilistic approach to violence. It's shocking. I've seen cases of, you know, very young children.
And, course, we've got to have an adequate public policy response that is able to, counter that descent, into violence fixation and to do so effectively. Phase two of the inquiry, that is the the the meat of the work that will be done in phase two of the inquiry, and we will obviously follow closely all of the recommendations that they make.
Speaker 114
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Can I also share, along with this house, my, thoughts and prayers to the victims of this horrific attack in Southport? I also welcome the, steps this government has taken to address what can only be described as a very challenging environment. Only two weeks ago, attended the Islamic Jamia institution in King's Landing along with my honorable member for King's Landing because we share the boundary line where this institution is located. That building had been attacked a few weeks during the month of Ramadan and then attacked again with vile vandalism and graffiti.
Clearly, attendees of that institution were very, very anxious. But it wasn't just the attendees, the local community came out to support, the local Muslims. So will, the home secretary join me in not just commending the actions of Westmoreland's police, which acted very swiftly, but also the various faith groups that came together that don't just come together in solidarity when an incident like this occurs, but are also the very backbone in terms of identifying any form of extremism within our communities? The
Speaker 41
Honourable Gentleman is right that solidarity between people from different communities, it's something that we don't often talk about in this house or only do so when a horrifying incident has taken place, but it is the absolute backbone of how we function as a society. And I pay tribute to all of those who spend their time working with people from different backgrounds to themselves, whether that's race or faith, in order to hold our communities and ultimately our nation together. Let me say to him, he's right that there is a very challenging environment when we look at at the overall threat picture. The the issues that we're dealing with today relate to somebody with no fixed ideology who's clearly vulnerable to terrorism, but had no fixed ideology, but had this fixation with extreme violence. We have that running alongside the sort of more traditional and well known and understood elements of extremism, like Islamist extremism or extreme right wing terrorism.
But even within those better understood forms of extremism, the the the pattern is changing, and it's always evolving and developing. And that does pose a challenge to all practitioners to try to keep up with how extremism is presenting itself in our communities, but that is absolutely work that the government is in is absolutely committed to making sure it's as robust as possible, and we take every step we can to make sure that we are countering extremism in all of its forms.
Speaker 50
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Home Sick Day for a very positive statement and associate myself with the events of a year ago when this nation mourned for the three children? I think everyone has recognized the horror of what took place and our prayers and our thoughts are very much with the families even today, especially with the parents. I think that's how we all feel home secretary. The report is full and I commend the author for his determination to ensure that political correctness does not influence the document.
It is clear that a sea of change is required in departments to be less concerned about offending innocent people and should be more concerned about protecting our innocence. What lessons can be learned to inform new procedures that must be accountability within the intelligence and the security services in particular?
Speaker 41
Well, the honourable gentleman is right. It is cultural change that is needed, and and that is what sir Adrian Forford's initial recommendations from phase one of the inquiry are designed to bring about practical measures as well to change the way in which risk is both assessed, and then ultimately, mitigated. The government will ensure, that we respond in full to those recommendations, but that we, bring together every part of government, every part of the state to, make sure we're people are doing everything they should be doing in order to assess risk. The only factors that matter are the risk that is posed by an individual to other people of significant harm of the type that we have seen in this case, and that is what the government will make sure happens in the future.
Speaker 24
Can I thank the home secretary for her statement this afternoon? I'll allow a few moments for the large front benches to swap over. Which brings us to a statement on Diego Garcia, base, and the British Indian Ocean overseas territory bill. Minister Doughty.
Speaker 120
Well, thank you, madam deputy speaker. And there has been much speculation in recent weeks about the state of the Diego Garcia treaty and the associated bill. And so I'd like to take this opportunity with your permission to update the house. Madam deputy speaker, we have debated at length, the critical importance of the military base on Diego Garcia for UK national security and that of our allies. The base allows us project the full array of military capabilities in one of the most important regions for international stability and global trade.
The base is vital for countering terrorism and threats from state adversaries. It protects Britons at home and overseas. And honorable and right honorable members know that the operation of the base has been under threat for decades. This government inherited a situation in which there was no legal certainty for future operations, and the threat of The UK, losing our ability to operate effectively for us or our allies was and remains real as the opposition benches know full well. The status quo is untenable.
Ignoring that situation would have been reckless and irresponsible. The previous government knew this, which is why it was they who opened negotiations with Mauritius, why they put sovereignty on the table, and why they had 11 rounds of talks and agreed the vast majority of the treaty. But, mister speaker, I know they don't want to hear this, but I do think it would be better if we had, some quiet inability for me to make this statement. And I am proud that this government completed that process in May. The Diego Garcia treaty puts the base on a secure legal footing for the first time in decades.
It gives us complete operational freedom and puts in place important safeguards to protect it from outside threats. In short, the treaty assures the continued contribution of the base to UK national security and the security of our allies for generations. The Diego Garcia Military Base was founded as a jointly operated base by The UK and The United States. It is one of the foundation stones on which our close defense and security partnership was built. And, of course, madam deputy speaker, the previous government knew this, which is why, as I said, they took the action to start the negotiations when they did.
For this reason, madam deputy speaker, the treaty to protect the base was negotiated in close coordination with The United States under both this and the previous United States administrations. The treaty was tested thoroughly at all levels of The United States system under two administrations and found to be robust. Throughout this process, we have also been clear that we could not let the treaty enter into force without US support, and we have that support when it was signed and consistently since. President Trump called it very strong and powerful. Secretary Rubio welcomed it as a historic agreement that secures the long term stable and effective operation of the joint US UK military facility at Diego Garcia.
Speaker 73
Madam deputy speaker, nothing in the treaty has changed since then, and United States support has been consistent in viewing the agreement as the best means of protecting operations on this vital military asset. However, in recent weeks, the position of The United States president appears to have changed, and this means that in practical terms, it has become impossible to agree at political level an update to the 1966 UK US agreement concerning the availability of defense purposes of the British Indian Ocean territory known as the exchange of notes, which is also necessary in order to ratify the treaty. Honorable and right honorable members will know that updates to the exchange of notes are nothing unusual. In fact, they have been updated periodically to ensure the governance arrangements of the base remain fit for purpose in a changing world. They were updated previously in 1972, in 1976, in 1987, 1999, and were rolled over in 2016.
Speaker 120
They now need a further update in light of the Diego Garcia treaty. We have debated this previously in this house, and I know my counterpart, Baroness Chapman, has similarly discussed it in the other place. Madam deputy speaker, officials from the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office and from the Ministry of Defense have been working with United States counterparts over many months and made excellent progress in updating this agreement. I can confirm that a finalized text was agreed at official level and is ready for political clearance and signature. But due to those new comments that I referred to, this process will obviously not now proceed on the previously agreed time frame.
And due to the delays in agreeing the exchange of notes, the Diego Garcia bill can therefore not complete its passage this parliamentary session and cannot be carried over due to its advanced progression through parliament. The government nevertheless remains confident that the Diego Garcia treaty is the best means of protecting the full operation of the military base for future generations for us and our allies. We will continue to work with The United States on the agreement and the way forward. We will continue to engage closely too with Mauritius. Madam deputy speaker, in parallel to these geostrategic developments, there is also, of course, the human story.
And I refer, of course, to the Chagossians rightly raised by many honorable and rightable members who were removed from the archipelago in the nineteen sixties and seventies. And the government, as I have said on many occasions, deeply regrets the manner of their removal, and we remain committed to building a relationship with Chagossian communities that is built on respect and acknowledgment of the wrongs of the past. The delay to the treaty will be sad news to many Chagossians, although I accept not all, who rightly see it as the only viable means to a sustainable program of resettlement, which Mauritius would be able to implement under its terms. And we also want, as I've said on many occasions, madam deputy speaker, to see the recommencement of the program of heritage visits, which we understand are so important to Chagossians, particularly for older generations. Madam deputy speaker, these are times of great uncertainty and acute risk to British interests.
Our security and prosperity are under threat at home and overseas, And this is a moment for calm and considered reflection, not cheap political point scoring by opposition parties. Well, they're just they're they're just proving this very point, madam deputy speaker. They are absolutely proving this very point, madam deputy speaker. They would put that security at risk and play reckless games. The threats facing the future operation of Diego Garcia base are real, as the opposition well know.
And the Diego Garcia treaty remains the best means of securing the vital military base on the island. And we will continue, madam deputy speaker, to work with partners, including The United States and Mauritius, to protect our national security and that of our allies. I commend this statement to the house.
Speaker 102
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And let me just start my remarks by saying that the minister today has done the right thing by coming to the house to give this statement and to absolutely not be dragged here through an urgent question, but state the factual and accurate position now that this treaty is not going to go forward. But, of course, madam deputy speaker, he has been once again left carrying the can for the prime minister's epic failure of statecraft. Yep. Labour's Chagos surrender has been wrong from the start.
Yeah. And instead of making excuses, the right thing to do would have been to tear up this dreadful treaty and commit to keeping Chagos British. The news that the ratification of this treaty is now done and dusted is a humiliation for the prime minister and this government. And let's be clear,
Speaker 102
labor surrender treaty is labor's mess. And as the house knows, within days of coming to office, the prime minister's top foreign policy priority was to exceed the wishes of his left wing lawyer friends and surrender the Chekos Island at an enormous cost to British taxpayers. He met the Mauritian prime minister, appointed Jonathan Powell to conclude negotiations, and rushed and blundered to into this treaty. They inexplicably announced it to the world just before Mauritius went to an election. Then when the Mauritian government that they agreed to deal with got kicked out, the new Mauritian government, guess what, demanded more concessions from Britain, and Labour rolled over and got eaten for breakfast.
They put one of our most important defence and security assets at risk. They compromised the special relationship with The United States. They ignored and betrayed the wishes of the Tregossian community, and they were prepared to hand over £35,000,000,000 of taxpayers' money to lease back a land that we own. And then they went ahead with the deal before receiving the critical exchange of notes from The United States. And having been to The United States myself recently, I'm not in the least surprised that the administration has stopped to stop this deal.
They can see what we have been saying for a long while, and it's the Conservatives who have opposed this Labour deal at every turn. Yeah. And while Labour has spectacularly failed to defend British sovereignty, and reform have gone from suggesting that we sell the islands to The US to suggesting that we give it to The Maldives. The Conservative Party has been effectively scrutinizing and opposing this surrender every step of the way to make sure that we keep Chagos British, and we protect our sovereignty and our taxpayers. It's conservatives who've exposed the full £35,000,000,000 cost of this deal.
Speaker 68
It's conservatives who've dismantled Labour's outrageous and offensive narrative that those who opposed the Chagos surrender are siding with British adversaries and instead brought forward the four the major security concerns about this deal and expose the fact that Mauritius is deepening partnership with Russia, China, and Iran. It's conservatives that have been pressing the government for months on its totally inadequate answers about why the anti nuclear Pendalaba treaty would apply to Diego Garcia, and its conservatives have been supporting the Chagossians every step of the way and giving them a voice and speaking up for them. Our questions and debates in this house and in the other place have laid led Labour to account and forced them now into this position today. But while this surrender and this whole process now has been ripped up, I do want to ask the minister some fundamental questions. The Mauritian government has announced that The UK delegation is going to Mauritius later this month.
Speaker 102
Will the will the minister tell us who is going and now what is the purpose? What will they be negotiating? Is there a new timetable? What is actually going to happen? We also know that Mauritius has budgeted to receive the surrender payments from the British government.
So can the minister confirm that no payments will be made to Mauritius as a result of what he has announced today? And will the Labour government commit to spending the money they were planning to ship to Mauritius on boosting defence spending at this critical time, which is exactly what the British taxpayer wants, the purpose for which should now be clearly allocated to this fundamental resource? Can he confirm in no uncertain terms that for as long as The US opposes this deal, Labour will not seek in any way to reinstate this? And on the Chagossians, if the island stay British, is it the government's intention to look at resettlement options, and will he rule out new any new legislation coming forward next session, even if it isn't in the king's speech, so that the surrender treaty cannot become operable? The only bill that the government should be taking forward now in the session is my original bill to make sure that Chagos remains British.
Speaker 120
Madam deputy speaker, I will start with a thanks, to the honorable lady. She She has rightly scrutinized many different aspects of this over many, many months. And I have come dutifully to answer many of these questions. I've met with her privately, and this has been scrutinized by many committees. And it was the right thing to do to update the house today on this on this development.
I'm I'm glad that she acknowledges that point. Of course, it's not for government to simply choose easy paths. It's to choose the right path. It's to choose the path that's in the interests of Britain and our national security and that of our allies. And fundamentally, at the heart of this, madam deputy speaker, is a is a question.
The opposition know that there is a huge challenge here. They knew that there was a problem, and that's why they started this process. And throughout this, through all the exchanges we've had, they have never been able to answer that simple question. Exactly. And I cannot recall a time, madam deputy speaker, when we have seen so much misinformation and, quite frankly, negligent disregard for the national interest and security of the British people.
And it's regrettable that the official opposition, indeed, the party opposite the Tinny, see one of their members has turned up, today, have been at the heart of this. And they will say, of course, oh, this is just politics, and we and the government should be thick skinned. But quite frankly, the British public deserve better. Indeed, the national interest is what drives this government and our national security as they well knew, which is why they started the process. So we've seen, frankly, ludicrous disinformation about the operations of the base, about the genuine threats it faced, about the security provisions of the treaty, which, of course, we strengthened, about the costs.
No matter how often they give these, false figures about the costs, it doesn't make them any more accurate. And, of course, about the views of Chagossians, which I accept are wide and varied, but they conveniently always ignore the views of significant numbers of Chelossing communities and groups who feel very differently about this treaty and who have supported it since the start, and indeed about the protection of the environment. And the fact is, madam deputy speaker, the opposition know the reality. They operate in a state of convenient amnesia. They knew the jeopardy facing the base.
They knew that they presided over 11 rounds of, negotiations. They published it in ministerial statements, in records of meetings with the Mauritian prime minister, and they know too that the treaty signed by this government was born of their policy choices and their negotiation mandates. So as ever, madam deputy speaker, the opposition cannot run fast enough away from their record in government when it suits tiresome political politicking. And the British people are not fooled. They can see their hypocrisy, and they deserve better.
Speaker 40
Thank you. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Thank you. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. So so I do want to thank the minister for the work he's done over many months working with our allies on this issue to reach agreement in in our in our national interest and theirs.
He's remained consistent throughout on this issue, and he's gave us many updates many updates on this issue. I wish you could say the same about the opposition. Their short memory, their flip flopping, and their complete disregard for national security is very similar to the position they've got themselves into with Iran. Very, very similar. They're laughing they're laughing in the face of real threats to our national security.
Speaker 112
But can the minister can the minister explain? I'm I'm actually quite concerned because it seems to me that the status quo is in our national interest. And without a treaty, what does that what does that mean for the long term access to this base for ourselves and also for our allies?
Speaker 120
Well, madam deputy speaker, my honorable friend sets out, the fundamental issue here, which of course is the risks to the operation of the base, which the opposition knew all along. That's why they started this process and which we have responded to with this treaty, that protects, our security and that of our allies. I'm not going to speculate about, the coming of those risks, but we know that we need to put this on a secure footing. We know that the treaty is the best way to do that. We know that this was agreed under two administrations across The United States in an interagency process.
We continue to believe that it is the right way forward, and we will announce our business in the usual way.
Speaker 91
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And can I genuinely thank the minister for this statement today, for the advance side of this statement, and for his long engagement with me on these, issues? The process for negotiating this treaty has been, I'm sorry to say, utterly shambolic, from its beginning under the previous government to its demise under this one. But when we finish As the government shells a gentleman a gallant gentleman from the sedentary position says, why did we finish it? I'm sorry to tell him they didn't.
There is no evidence at all.
Speaker 91
no evidence at all that this statement was finished by the previous government. But as this government shelves this legislation, it must now reckon with the litany of failures that have plagued this process. Yeah. Specifically, its inability to secure financial legal guarantees, fundamental legal guarantees in The US through the necessary exchange of letters. Its reluctance to adopt measures which would enable genuine parliamentary scrutiny over the planned vast sums of money Yeah.
That would be sent to the government of Mauritius, and its willful reluctance to work with or to secure the rights of Chagossians, including, but not limited to, the right of return to the Chagos Islands. Aside from the government's apparent ignorance of the legal prerequisites for the passage of this treaty, the most objectionable aspect of this process has been the woeful engagement with the Chagossian community. The British state has long denied Chagossians a meaningful say in their own future, and the provisions of this treaty shamefully failed again to affirm those rights. So if this treaty ever does return to this house, the government would do well to observe and understand the amendments submitted by the Liberal Democrats in the other place, securing genuine rights for Chagossians and helping to buck the historic trend of that community being left out of the decisions about its own future. But I only have one very simple question for the minister.
Given that the government has now abandoned its proposed deal with Mauritius over the Chagas Islands, can the foreign secretary set out what this means in practice for the long promised right of return for Chagossians? Will the government now commit to supporting resettlement under continued UK sovereignty? And if so, does he assess the implications of that return for the evidential and legal basis underpinning the 2019 ICJ advisory opinion? In conclusion, madam deputy speaker, British citizens physically located on the islands would constitute a resident population who would be very dogmatic. Order order.
Minister.
Speaker 120
Well, thank you, madam deputy speaker, and, I thank him for his, his comments and his continued engagement and good faith throughout this process. And I can assure him that in due course, we will obviously return to the issues that he and I and his honorable and right broader colleagues were discussing with us and the concerns they expressed in amendments in this place and indeed in the other house. And I can absolutely assure him of that. But I have to, of course, I have to, of course, reject his assumption that this is, somehow met with demise. It's not been abandoned.
And we have always been clear about the need, to have the agreement on The US UK exchange of notes. Indeed, I refer him to the comments of my honorable our honorable friend in the other place on the November 18, where Baroness Chapman said very clearly, and I quote, before The UK can ratify the treaty, we will need to do the following, pass both primary and secondary legislation, update The UK US exchange of notes, and put in place agreements on the environment, maritime security, and migration. We have been always clear about the processes that needed to be followed in parallel here. It's regrettable to us that, obviously, there has been a delay that we've run out of time in this parliamentary session, but the facts have not changed in the need for this treaty or indeed the need for the different, processes and legal provisions, to be brought in place. He rightly raises the concerns about the Chagossians, and he and I have discussed these on a number of occasions.
Of course, we have engaged extensively with Chagossian communities. There are a range of views in the community. There will be many Chagossians who will be deeply disappointed by this delay in the treaty, not least for the very reason that he refers to, which is that, we believe that this is the best route, under Mauritius' guidance to lead to resettlement. And, of course, I want to reemphasize our commitment to restarting at an appropriate time, those heritage visits that are so important. He'll understand why the current situation does not allow that to take place, we will obviously seek to do that at the earliest opportunity.
We know how important it is, particularly for those heritage reasons to do so.
Speaker 92
Morning speaker. I think it was the test of a of a bad bit of legislation is when you see carte blanche Henry the eighth powers inside a very thin and flimsy piece of legislation and granting therefore the government the right to do anything it liked with the bill even after it had passed. So that made it a dog of a bill. But now the government's come to either pause it or whatever they call it, return it or u-turn it. Can I just take the government back, the right honorable gentleman, back to the statement he made about the Chagossians?
Speaker 121
Because right at the heart of this lies their rights over this. And I will say that he talked about them wanting to come to some conclusion about their ability to return to the islands. So could you perhaps answer me within all of that, why then, when the Bayatu Supreme Court's ruling that section nine of the 2,004 order in council that barred the right of abode to Jugosians was illegal, why have they then mounted an appeal against that to ensure that they are illegal if they go to their islands? Does he think the Zhigoshians have no right to go to the islands or they do have a right? Which is it, if he could answer?
Speaker 120
Well, he's clearly familiar with the the history on this. He'll know the judgments in the courts of England and Wales on this matter on the right of abode. I'm not going to comment on ongoing legal proceedings. It's safe to say that we were disappointed by the position that was taken, and our understanding is that BAYADA are appealing that judgment, and we have taken an interest in that matter.
Speaker 89
The minister talks about convenient amnesia, but he didn't go back to discuss what the previous Labour government did. So all the way back in 2008, Gordon Brown met with Navanchando Ramgulam when he was minister of Mauritius for the first time and agreed to establish a dialogue about the British Indian Ocean territories. And the first official meetings took place in January 2009, Wednesday the fourteenth to be precise, where the topic of sovereignty was discussed. So could the minister outline and I appreciate you might not have those details to hand, he's welcome to write to me. Could he outline exactly what discussions took place with the previous government all the way up to the end of their, time at 2010 that set the conditions for the subsequent ICJ appeal that Mauritius put in following that discussion.
Speaker 120
will happily write to him on this matter, but what I am absolutely clear about, madam deputy speaker, is that it was his government when they were in government who started the process of negotiations under the former foreign secretary, the member for Braintree, who conceded the principle of sovereignty, conceded a financial element, and, of course, actually didn't put in place some of the key the key, security provisions which we were able to secure in these negotiations. And I will happily write to him.
Speaker 24
Madam deputy speaker, the US Navy began a blockade of Iran at 2PM this afternoon. Has The US been granted permission by the British government for the use of the deepwater port at Diego Garcia as a staging post for the imposition of that blockade?
Speaker 120
Madam deputy speaker, you understand that I am not going to comment on operational details from the dispatch box, but the prime minister has been absolutely clear about what requests from The United States have been exceeded to and which ones have not. He's answered an extensive statement on this this this after this afternoon, and I hope that that suffices.
Speaker 95
Dear Harriet Baldwin. Thank you, madam deputy speaker, and thank the minister for confirming that this parliament has not ratified this
Speaker 60
And I think the more that parliament heard about the deal and the more that the British public heard about the deal, one of the things that they found the most inexplicable was that the deal involved us paying a substantial amount of money, not yet confirmed to par parliament how much it is to the Mauritian government. So could the minister minister confirm confirm from from the the despatch box today that because parliament has not ratified this deal, he will not be paying any money to the Mauritian government?
Speaker 120
Benister. She asks an important question and to be fair, the Shadow Foreign Secretary asked this question as well. Absolutely, can confirm that in relation to the costs associated with this treaty, they cannot be paid without the treaty being passed, with the relevant legislation being passed. So she's absolutely right on that point. But what I will say is that there has been willful misinformation from a number of quarters, on the costs associated with this deal.
We published the forecast costs at the time that we presented the treaty and the methodology used. We've answered questions on it many, many times. And the fact is that the costs associated are simply not as being by the opposition front bench or indeed other parties in this place. And they represent, you know, compared to, for example, what France pays for its base in Djibouti, this is 15 times larger, immeasurably more capability. And we are not going to scrimp when it comes to the national security of this country.
Speaker 108
day in this parliament, another chaotic u-turn. Can I thank the minister for being the latest to make the long walk from number 10 over here to announce said U-turn? And also thank the one solitary Labour MP who could be encouraged to stand up for the government. Now whereas I accept the Tories made a mess of this, I have to say that the excuse given by the minister that Donald Trump's unpredictability was something that could not be foreseen is something that people will find very difficult to believe. On that lack of foresight, this is a serious issue, and I know the minister treats it seriously.
So will he tell us how much money has been wasted on this so far? What are the implications in terms of national security? And what are the implications in terms of the international rules based system and the rights of the Chagossians who have been caught in the middle of this sad, sorry mess?
Speaker 120
Well, he raises many, many issues there. I mean, the situation is is clear for all to see. I've set out, why it's not able to make the progress that we'd hoped it would make in this parliamentary session, but the merits of the deal, the need to secure the base, for us and our allies stay unchanged. As I said, we're not gonna scrimp on national security. When it comes to these capabilities, we will do what is right and in the interest of the British people.
Speaker 81
deputy speaker. Can I congratulate the minister for so valiantly trying to explain the inexplicable and to reconcile the irreconcilable? And I don't want to detain the house by quoting the whole Monty Python parrot sketch, but this is now an ex treaty. It is no more. It has shuffled off its mortal coil.
Speaker 38
But coming back to the can you why can't they just honor what the court has decided about the right of return? And why are they now trying to frustrate the survival and safety of the Churgossians who have returned, taken there by my good friend, former Conservative MP, Adam Holloway, who has organized who has organized this expedition, despite despite despite the the government. And the government why is the government now mounting operations and sending police officers and customs operators to try and frustrate safety equipment going to the expedition on the Chagossian for the to support the Chagossians? Why is why are they blocked to a water purifier? Even medical supplies.
Speaker 81
They've blocked a fast boat that would provide emergency evacuation so that these people are more at risk as a result of the government. Is that the government's policy after all the wrongs that have been done to the Zhigashians?
Speaker 120
of respect for the right hon. Gentleman but he is simply wrong on this point about the Chagarsians. The reality is that there are a range of views within the Chagarsian communities. I have taken those incredibly seriously including those who do not agree with this treaty, but there are many who do agree with it. I'm afraid the incident he refers to in terms of the illegal arrivals on Peros Banos, they they are illegal and they are not appropriate.
It is a dangerous environment. It is not appropriate for them to be on there. We are disappointed by the judgment that was made. Bayata are appealing that judgment and their interest. If he wants me to provide him with the list of items that were sought to be provided on that island, I think he would be quite shocked.
And he would, I'm sure, agree with me that it was not appropriate to be having a drone flying on those islands or indeed other items that are not necessary. This is a dangerous and unsafe environment. And I'm quite quite frankly astounded not only, the opposition, but indeed the other party, we've got one representative here, are attempting to support people arriving illegally by boats on an island which is not safe for them. That is quite frankly extraordinary.
Speaker 12
Deputy speaker, I very much welcome this statement and commend the minister, for the way that he has framed it. He has been absolutely spectacular, if I may say so, over the months in trying to defend the indefensible, as indeed he has done today this u-turn on steroids. Can I press him on the matter of money? Because he has been, I think, Delphic in his response to my two right honorable friends in relation to demands that Mauritius perfectly reasonably will be making of this government given this utter mess and the fact that they were making spending plans already on the back of the largesse that the minister had been talking about. Will he confirm that not a penny piece will be passed to Mauritius now that this, treaty has gone the way of the apocryphal Norwegian, Blue, in either payments or indeed in compensation, and what legal notes have been passed between the two governments, given that plainly, this thing is now not going to be happening, in relation to moneys in compensation that Mauritius perfectly reasonably will now be demanding of The UK?
Minister.
Speaker 120
I answered the question very clearly a moment ago to his right honorable friend.
Speaker 119
Joy Morrison. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Will the FCVO be consulted, and will the British Chagossians be brought into that discussion prior to their mission to on the April 22? And will they accept a British Chagossian on the actual delegation so that they'll be represent represented when you go on the April 22? And also, is there will the government be speaking to the Trogashians who have just come on the boat and seem to be the only small boat that the government are interested in stopping.
So will they actually be helping rather than hindering? Minister.
Speaker 120
I mean, on the on the last point, I'm sure she can see the absurdity of of what she and others appear to be supporting. This is a dangerous political stunt. It's putting lives at risk. It is not safe. It is not proper to be on those islands.
And we're very, very clear about that, and we've communicated that very, very clearly. And, obviously, the biota administration will take whatever steps they deem necessary under their laws and administration to ensure the adherence to their laws, but also the safety and security of individuals. It's simply I'm genuinely astounded that people would support this. It's putting lives at risk and deeply irresponsible. In terms of the the the the wider questions that she asked about Chagossians, I've been very clear throughout.
There are a range of views within the communities. There are a range of views within the British Chagossian communities. I've heard them. I've met with them. I've heard very difficult views.
People who don't agree with us on this issue, I'm not afraid to do that, neither is the government. It wouldn't be practical just to take simply one person representing a whole whole community, but what we have done throughout this process is to seek to ensure the voices of Chagossians are heard, for example, in the proposed trust fund, securing places on that. I've set that on a number of occasions. We will continue to engage with all Chagossian communities.
Speaker 77
Can I remind members that if they were not in at the beginning of the statement, they will not be called? Mike Martin.
Speaker 61
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. This process is amongst other things about protecting British access to the communications spectrum and that's why
Speaker 61
previous government started it and that's why the current government is carrying it on. So if we're not able to pass the treaty and we're not able to ensure that access, what's plan
Speaker 120
think, Madam Deputy Speaker, I have set out on a number of occasions very clearly, the risk to the operation of the base. They were well understood, by the opposition, in particular those who served as ministers in the last government. It has consistently staggered me that they attempt to sort of gloss over all of that and the risks that it puts to our operations and our capabilities that keep us and our allies safe. And I think they will look on some of the political point scoring that they have been doing with regrets in future years.
Speaker 110
I doubt if many people across the nation are sitting watching Parliament Channel at the moment to see their statement. However, anyone who was would be surprised that the ministry started off saying this space is critical to our national security. It allows us to project the full array of military capabilities in one of the most important regions for international stability and global trade. It's vital for countering terror terrorism and threats threats from state adversaries and protects Britons at home and abroad. We'll be asking, why the devil then, if we owned it, did we give it back to the Mauritian government then to lease it for £35,000,000,000 from a government which is more interested in some of the states which are hostile to our interests in the area?
Does the minister not agree that the nation, if they're listening to this, will be totally confused or else think that this government must be the one of the most incompetent governments in in Bain? Beneister.
Speaker 120
I I simply must thoroughly disagree with what he has set out. Our national security and that of our allies has been paramount in putting this treaty forward and this deal to secure the Diego Garcia base, not only for us, but for our allies, for Five Eyes partners. That's why they all welcomed it. That's why it's gone through extensive processes in this country, in The United States, with other partners. I will not apologize for that.
The duty of this government is to protect the people of this country and our partners and our allies. That is exactly why we have proceeded on this basis and why this treaty is needed.
Speaker 49
Speaker, two questions to the minister if I may. Can I welcome the retreat from this bill and this deal? It ill served the taxpayer and our national interest. My first question is, is the government now officially withdrawing the bill rather than merely pausing its passage? And the second is he was very clear to in earlier questions that no payment would be made under the treaty to Mauritius.
Can he confirm that there will be no goodwill payment, ex gratia payment, or any payment made to Mauritius outside of the treaty effectively as a way of saying sorry? Because frankly, we have nothing to say sorry for. Any sir?
Speaker 120
Madam Deputy Speaker, the honourable gentleman who I have affection for, he understands the procedures of this place. He understands that the bill has has is going to time out because of the upcoming prorogation. It can't be carried over because of the progress that it's made during this session. We understand the procedures around that. It's disappointing that we saw so much game playing, particularly at the other end of this building around it, that is the position.
I've set out the position on the costs.
Speaker 80
very much welcome the, government's withdrawal of this bill. I have two questions about the future commitment of this country to the Chagosian people and to the Chagos Islands. The first is with respect to any future constitutional change. Will the government commit that if there is to be any constitutional change to the status of the islands that the Chagossian community here in The UK has given the chance to express its view in a referendum of that community? And secondly, with respect to the heroic landing by my new friend, reform member, Adam Holloway, who made a brave journey to reform, and and it also went to the Tagus Islands with a group of islanders.
Speaker 27
Can I remind the honorable the the the minister that those people were forcibly removed from their homes by a labor government in the nineteen seventies? The infrastructure that that they left behind is now descending into jungle. Why will not the government recognize that they do have a right of abode there? And why is the government frustrating the very legitimate efforts of philanthropists to support them to reestablish their community? Here here.
Speaker 120
Again, I am I am genuinely shocked, madam deputy speaker, that the honorable gentleman will be supporting a reckless political stunt of this nature, indeed his party as a whole, promoting a rival on an island that is not suitable for human habitation, where lives are at risk. And they would support and encourage people to be put in position, think, is quite frankly shameful. And quite frankly, you know, again, absurd in terms of their commentary on many other issues in in in this in this in this matter in relation to irregular migration. I just find it absolutely astounding. So I'm really not gonna take any lessons from him.
Speaker 13
Thank you, madam deputy speaking. Can I thank the minister for his statement today? There have been many discussions over the amount of money that was gonna be paid, and discussions over the methodology and how it was come to. And I'm prepared to park those on the basis that provision has indeed been made in the government's budget lines to pay for this treaty, which is now in abeyance. And so for the period of time that it is in abeyance, would the minister be able to tell us that 100% of that amount that would have been paid to Mauritius will now go into the defense budget and pay for hard power?
Speaker 120
Madam speaker speaker, you well know that I am not a part of the treasury team. It's not it's not for to me to respond these points. Obviously, in the interim, we remain responsible for the administration of of BIOTS, and BIOTS administration does. And, of course, the long standing arrangements between us and The United States in regards to the operations, the crucial operations on the base. And he knows, as I've set out on many occasions, madam deputy speaker, the priceless value of the capabilities there.
That is why we set out this treaty and this deal as the best way to secure those capabilities.
Speaker 112
The minister was asked a very precise question by the honorable member for North Dossert, and it was this, quite apart from any military obligations under the treaty, outside of those obligations will a single penny be paid to Mauritius going forward? That's a very simple question. It's nothing to do with the treaty. The treaty's gone in that sense. But outside of any obligations that were under the treaty, will there be a single penny paid to Mauritius?
Surely the minister can answer that rather than continue to dodge it.
Speaker 120
We have relationships with many different, countries around the world, including through our ODDO programs, through, different multilateral programs, through our investments, through all sorts of things that are in the British national interest. But what I assure him is that the costs associated with this treaty, cannot be paid without the treaty. I've been very clear about that from the beginning. And he can impugn all he all he likes, but that is the fact.
Speaker 50
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I thank the minister very much for his statement, and he has outlined the reality of where we are today, and I think it's important that we do understand what that means. The minister has also made clear the the feelings of where we are, but can I ask them, missus? How those No. Checosians who asked us to retain the island control due to the human rights, consideration and other issues?
And whilst the future of the treaty is uncertain, what will government and the minister do to engage with those who are disenfranchised and uncertain due to the treaty failure?
Speaker 120
Well, thank, Marable Frank for his question. Of course, we will continue to engage with Chagossian communities. I'm absolutely committed to that, as I have been, throughout, including those who disagree. But there will, as I said, be many Chagossians who will be deeply disappointed by this delay, and I think it's important that their views, are understood and respected, as well as those who oppose this treaty.
Speaker 77
And that concludes the statement. I'll just give the front benches a few moments to swap over for the next statement.
Speaker 23
With permission, madam deputy speaker, I wish to make a statement on North Atlantic activity. Let me begin by thanking the many members of our armed forces currently deployed in over 30 operations across the globe. Their efforts are often unseen by the British people, but they are always appreciated. They defend the very freedoms we enjoy. I agree.
Last week, my right honorable friend, the defense sector, revealed details of one such operation. While the focus of many has been drawn to The Middle East, UK armed forces, in partnership with our allies, have been deployed to deter increased Russian activity that we have seen and witnessed in the Atlantic. The specific operation involved a Russian Akula class submarine and a concurrent deployment of two specialist submarines from Gugi, Russia's main directorate for deep sea research. Last November, the defense secretary outlined to the house how Gugi vessels, including the spy ship Yantar, are directed by president Putin to engage in hybrid warfare activities against The UK and its allies, specifically around critical undersea infrastructure. Their mission is to survey pipelines and cables during peacetime and then potentially, if required, sabotage in conflict.
In response to the Russian subsurface activity, the defense sector deployed a Royal Navy warship and a Royal Air Force p eight aircraft alongside allies and partners to ensure the Russian vessel was monitored during every phase of their operation. The Akula subsequently retreated home, having been closely tracked throughout, and we continue to monitor the two Googie submarines when they were in around UK waters and, of course, beyond. Our armed forces left them with no doubt that they were being monitored, that their movements were not covert as planned, and that their attempted secret operation had been exposed. The two Googie submarines have also now left UK waters and headed back north, and this operation, which lasted more than a month, has now concluded. Madam deputy speaker, in often treacherous conditions, our pilots racked up over 450 flying hours.
Our frigate sailed several thousand nautical miles. 500 British personnel were involved in the response, and I know the whole house will join me in paying tribute to every single person involved. Mister speaker madam deputy speaker, we exposed this military operation undertaken by Russia for three key reasons. Firstly, to send a message to Putin that he failed to remain covert and that any attempt to damage critical national undersea infrastructure will not be tolerated and cannot be denied. Second, to demonstrate that even with significant capabilities and personnel deployed in The Middle East, we will always, always do what is necessary to protect our homeland.
And third, to highlight a significant operation carried out by our armed forces who once again met this challenge with a characteristic determination and professionalism we all know too well. Madam deputy speaker, this operation reminds us why the seabed matters, especially for the island nation of Britain. It connects us to everything, and that connection is sustained beneath our waters without interruption through a vast network of cables and pipelines on which much of our way of life relies. Much of the gas that heats our homes, 99% of international telecoms and data traffic, trillions of pounds of global trade each day. And because the seabed matters to us, it's also a prime target for our adversaries.
Speaker 90
The UK's undersea network is highly resilient, but the threats are increasing. And so we're stepping up our action to defend it, including providing an extra 100,000,000 for our vital p eight submarine hunting aircraft, launched our Atlantic Bastion program to combine the latest autonomous technologies with the best warship and aircraft to create a British built hybrid naval force, and making the biggest sustained increase in defense spending since the Cold War, after years of hollowing out and underfunding from various governments. Madam deputy speaker, the threat is clear, and our resolve to confront it is absolute. And that's why this year, we're deploying our carrier group where it is most needed, the North Atlantic and the High North, and why we're supporting NATO's new mission, Arctic Sentry. I also want to put on record our thanks to our allies with whom we have cooperated closely throughout this operation, including Norway.
Speaker 23
Our shared commitment to confront Russian aggression in the North Atlantic is at the heart of our Lunar House Agreement, and together, we are now building a combined fleet of new submarine hunting frigates and new uncrewed systems. And let me say a few words on Ukraine from where I've just returned last week. Today, two wars on two continents are being fought at the very same time, and Putin wants us distracted while he steps up strikes on Ukraine relentlessly and indeed at enormous scale with around 7,000 attacks a day on the front line and 55,000 drone and missile strikes last year alone. We must always remember our duty to Ukraine and recognize Russian aggression is growing across Europe once more. Madam deputy speaker, let me finish where I began, with praise for our people.
We have the very finest armed forces a nation can hope for, second to none. As I speak, we have personnel deployed across every domain, every moment of the day, in every part of the world, And they're in constant confrontation with our adversaries from the depths of the seabed to the reaches of space. When a crisis erupts, as it has done in The Middle East, I understand people questioning why all UK military assets and personnel haven't been sent to deal with it. Well, as demands on defense rise, we must deploy our resources to best effect across multiple priorities. Because of an increase in defense investment, we'll be able to call on more and more resource in the coming years.
As we defend our interests and partners in The Middle East, we will tackle increasing threats in the High North. We will stand with Ukraine. We will meet our NATO obligations. Above all, we will always fulfill the first duty of government, to protect our homeland and keep the British people safe, and I commend this statement to the house.
Speaker 25
Thank you, madam deputy speaker, and I thank the minister for advanced sites of his statement. Now with all eyes on the Middle East, let us not forget that Russia remains the most acute, persistent, and active threat to The United Kingdom. Putin's goal of conquering Ukraine is unchanged, and the fact continues to place our entire European continent in jeopardy. His ongoing nefarious activity, most notably in our own territorial waters, should be a stark wake up call. We must start acting on the threats that are visible and right in front of us.
Now we may be critical of the government's tortoise like approach to giving defense what it needs. And, madam deputy speaker, slow and steady does not win this race, and it certainly does not keep us safe. But what does unite us is the full throated support for the men and women of the Royal Navy, the Army, and the Royal Air Force who keep the wolf at bay in these dangerous times. And I pay pay a particular tribute to all those who serve in The Middle East at the moment, in recent Atlantic operations, and especially those who crew our continuous at sea deterrent patrols twenty four seven, three hundred and sixty five days a year every year. When the secretary of state came to this house last year, madam deputy speaker, to highlight the actions of the Russian spy vessel, Yantar, he told Putin, we see you.
We know what you're doing, and we will not shy away from robust action. Now that was the right message. But at some point, simply saying we see you is not enough.
Speaker 25
Words must be backed by action. This is not just a question of traditional defense. There is a growing and underappreciated threat to our national resilience, to our way of life. Just 65 undersea cables carry 99% of global communications, and a far smaller number of pipelines and interconnectors link our gas and electricity suppliers to others. So that can the minister guarantee there are no hostile devices, kinetic or otherwise, on, near, or underneath any of those cables, pipelines, or interconnectors?
The reality is he cannot. The secretary of state, secretary of state spoke of confidence that there was no sabotage on this occasion. But what of the many other incidents in UK waters? In the Baltic, in the cables running to North America, West of the British Charles, where monitoring capacity is limited at best. The truth is we don't fully know how to secure our critical under underwater infrastructure is.
That is why we are dismayed that the much touted defense readiness bill has been delayed by a full year. We're still at a time of demanding cross party unity. It was deeply disappointing to hear the prime minister flatly reject the leader of the opposition's offer of greater engagement earlier today. That was the wrong call. On Russia's shallow fleet, madam deputy speaker, when the prime minister announced on March 25 that British forces would be permitted to board sanctioned vessels transiting UK waters, we rightly supported that decision.
And the chief of defense staff, when asked at the recent London defense conference, said plainly, we are ready. And yet no action has been taken. We set a red line, and we have watched Russia repeatedly cross it.
Speaker 75
Worse, Russian military vessels are now accompanying shadow fleet ships, deliberately escalating the situation. Madam deputy speaker, this is deterrence in reverse. The minister and I know better than anyone else in this chamber the very real challenges of boarding vessels at sea and the serious legal questions surrounding what happens to a ship and its crews once the decision is, made to seize them. These are the same challenges that I faced personally while serving in the Royal Marines boarding pirate vessels off the coast of Somalia. Back then, those legal and logistical hurdles were just as real, but it was clear that the global economy was being directly impacted by piracy, that we had to act, and we found a lawful way to do so.
Speaker 25
So why can't we now when the situation is far more grave? Now it's been reported that the attorney general has denied the legal basis for interdiction. If that's the case, I asked the minister directly, what is the current position of the government, and can he tell this house how many sanctioned vessels have transited UK waters unchecked? Russia is brazenly moving military supplies to our own waters. That must be met with robust action, not statements.
To conclude, madam deputy speaker, today's statement is a start, but only a start, and it's clear the government is not moving fast enough to deter our adversaries. Deterrence requires capability, and capability requires funding. Now I know the minister has not had sight of the defense investment plan, but I can at least can at least tell the country when it will be published. Yeah. Seven months delayed.
This is simply simply becoming a farce. Yeah. Does he agree with us and the Defence Select Committee that this government must commit to 3% of GDP on defense within this parliament? Majority. Not the next.
Now the Conservatives have already identified saving, delivering over 20,000,000,000 in additional defense spending. We want to go further, and we renew our offer to work across the aisle to find them.
Speaker 25
Because the choice is simple. If we are serious about deterring Russia and other hostile states from the High North or our overseas bases, then we must reach 3% on defense now, not later, and give our armed forces the resources they need to keep us safe.
Speaker 23
Madam deputy speaker, we can, agree that no sabotage has taken place this time, from the Russian subsurface activity that took took, place off the coast of The UK. Words back by action when it comes to deserting Russia, 4,500,000,000 UK military support to Ukraine, total of 21,800,000,000.0. The UDCG just raised an astonishing 45,000,000,000 to buy weapons and munitions and capability for the Ukrainians. The MOD stands ready to board any vessels that meet the criteria. There's a lot of misinformation out there.
What I would also say is, very expensive frigates escorting every vessel at such range is putting significant demands on the Russian fleet and is also degrading their capabilities. And what I would also say is that we're gonna see we've seen 5,000,000,000 extra spent this year alone, on the defense budget. By 2829, we'll spend circa 73,000,000,000 on the defense budget.
Speaker 71
Thank you very much, madam deputy speaker. And to increase public awareness about the growing threats that our nation faces, I thank the minister for his statement and indeed the defense secretary's public statement. And on behalf of the defense committee, I want to pay tribute to all our armed forces personnel involved in disrupting the Russian activity, around our critical undersea infrastructure. Madam deputy speaker, this incident also underscores the growing threats that Russia poses and also the need to increase defense investment now and the need to finally publish the defense investment plan. But turning to the incident itself, I take on board the ministers were just now, but it has been widely reported, including publicly at the London defense con conference, that Putin had explosives planted on our undersea cables.
So for the record, can the minister confirm, were Russians involved in either sabotage or precursors to sabotage on or around our undersea cables? Minister.
Speaker 23
I'd like to thank the honorable friend for his, questions. The the reality is Russia failed on this occasion, and they failed because we exposed their activity, meaning that there was no way, shape, or form they could deny their activity in the first place. Though I was at the London defense conference, I heard the, certain discussions around undersea cables. I can confirm that no sabotage took, place this time. What I can say is that the Russians put a lot of effort into mapping and understanding our undersea critical national infrastructure, and we'll do everything to map, track, and expose it, should it take place.
Speaker 56
Thank you, madam deputy speaker, and can I thank the minister for advanced sight of his statement? Can I also associate my party with his thanks and appreciation for the dedicated service of our armed forces personnel around the world? Madam deputy speaker, while the world's attention was on Trump and Netanyahu's catastrophic war in Iran, Vladimir Putin was collecting vital information about our critical infrastructure. In response, the defense secretary told Putin for the second time, we see you. But we need much greater confidence that this government has the plan and resolve not just to observe Russia's activities, but to meet and resist them should that be required.
Speaker 122
As Putin plans for future conflict, our government appears frozen. Delay and inaction is sapping industry's confidence as well as our allies whilst enabling Putin's war machine in Ukraine. Madam deputy speaker, the government must remedy these feelings as a matter of urgency. Our national security and the sovereignty of our Ukrainian allies demand it. So I'd like to ask the minister, will he commit to publishing defense investment plan before the house prorogues?
And will he publish a plan to raise £20,000,000,000 in defense bonds to be spent on urgent projects, including rebuilding our naval capabilities, which are critical for protecting our undersea infrastructure? Madame deputy speaker, the minister rightly highlighted Russia's continued assault on Ukraine. Peter Magyar's spectacular victory in yesterday's Hungarian elections should unlock European financial support to Ukraine. At just the same time, Donald Trump authorized a suspension of sanctions on Russian energy assets. Assets.
The government cannot allow this opportunity to slip. So will the minister work with EU partners so The UK's £30,000,000,000 share of the frozen Russian assets in Europe can be sent to Ukraine's defense alongside the promised €90,000,000,000 from the EU? And will he work with colleagues across government finally to put an end to the scandal of UK companies providing maritime services for the export of Russian oil, gas, and coal?
Speaker 23
Minister. Madam deputy speaker, I'm glad this government, took a defensive stance on Iran. It didn't, we were clear we didn't have a legal mandate. There wasn't a plan, and there was no clear end state. And I think if you're gonna put people in harm's way, you need those three things before you can do so.
Whilst the defense investment plan is not has not arrived yet, five classes of ship or submarine are in order or on build just now. 13 frigates in order, eight type 26, five types 31, which is a collaborative effort to ensure our maritime capability is fit for purpose as we move forward and as those threats diversify and, indeed, increase, in particular here in the High North. Learning the lessons from Ukraine, ensuring we have the best autonomous capability, and our Atlantic bastion platform is moving in the right direction. We have worked exceptionally hard, and the foreign office are pushing as well to sanction thousands of individuals within Russia, companies, and, of course, vessels as well to reduce their legal flow of resource coming back into Russia, which is funding that illegal and brutal war waged by Putin on Ukraine.
Speaker 101
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Thanks to my right honorable friend and gallant friend for the statement. GUKI's been work really since the nineteen sixties as as I understand it. Been doing extensive mapping for quite some time. In our report, the Joint Committee on National Security Strategy, we came up with a great many recommendations that he'll be more than familiar with.
When it comes to the defense investment plan, can I just bring focus his focus perhaps to one particular element of the recommendations, was about a sovereign capability for repair ships? So would he just promise either to look at that or agree to meet with me to discuss?
Speaker 23
I'd like to thank my honorable friend for what is already a focused question. We've been watching the underwater research program for years now. We understand exactly what they're up to and why they're up to it. They understand some of the I wouldn't say weaknesses, but vulnerabilities that sit in the West, and they are trying to identify it, and indeed threaten it at a point in time of their choosing. I also recognize the report that was written around sovereign capabilities to fix cables.
We're working with industry and partners, And, of course, we have a multitude of capabilities within defense that can support those types of operations that may need to take place should anything happen to our undersea cables.
Speaker 110
very much, madam deputy speaker. I am delighted that the minister has made the statement he has this evening because I have raised this issue a number of times in this place. My constituency looks directly at the High North and it's off the coast of my constituency that this Russian activity has taken place. Let's make no mistake about it. And my constituents find this deeply, deeply worrying.
Speaker 123
The point I want to make my mandatory speaker to speak to the minister is this, is as he is himself admitting, we only have so many surface ships. They are based mostly in Devonport and Portsmouth. The saving time from the South Of England to Orkney, Shetland, or my constituency is a matter of days. And we have to move very, very fast in the in in this situation with Russia. And let's remember history.
Before the first world war, Winston Churchill and others took the decision to relocate part of the fleet to Invergordon and to Scarpa Flow and the Orkneys. I want to press the minister, are we quite certain that we are basing those surface ships that we have at present, and we hope we'll have more, in the correct position where they need to be to keep a close eye on the High North and to protect our vital strategic interests.
Speaker 23
I'd like to thank the honorable member for what is already a focused question. Part of this problem set is around looking at early warning to when systems appear either in our waters or close to our waters or indeed close to any critical national infrastructure. That's a multi domain operation ranging from space all the way down to other intelligence assets that give us very early warning of what is happening, where, when, and why, and allows us to preposition capabilities to meet them or, indeed, ensure we can understand exactly what they're up to and therefore put in a operation to deter it if required.
Speaker 87
Thank you very much, speaker. I was in Latvia weekend, and they very, very, very much know what the threat is from Putin and the Russians. And can I thank the minister for his statements? What's clear and what's been helpful in the way this has been described in public, but what's clear is we need to do a lot more to explain to the British public what the threat is and how it's getting worse from the Russians, Not least if we are to increase the defense expense, I've been advocating here for some time, and some tough decisions were made to be made. So we need to have a better program of education and information to just demonstrate how serious a threat Putin and the Russians are to the security of this country.
Speaker 23
Madam deputy speaker, I completely agree. A more effective and well understood communication education plan as to what those threats really mean to the population is essential. If I was to turn around the population, say there was a cyber attack on Jaguar Land Rover, that would affect, and people would take notice in and around Jaguar Land Rover. If I was to say that half of the the attack on Jaguar Land Rover cost half of the two child benefit cap, it then resonates far greater across the nation. If I was to say there were over 10,000,000,000 of cyber attacks just last year alone and that the MOD has seen a 50% increase in hostile state attacks, that starts to resonate.
We need to ensure that narrative is continued to be communicated in the easiest way, but also that it resonates with every section of society, and I couldn't agree more.
Speaker 12
Madam deputy speaker, the backbone of our ability to detect Russian submarines over decades has been provided by our towed array patrol ships from Leander right the way through to our increasingly decrepit type 23. But does the minister agree that the logic of what he has said, given that the threat has increased significantly over the past several months, couple of years, is that we should be looking again at the orders for eight type 26 with twenty eighty seven towed array on the back of them and upgrade that in order to deal with the threat that we now face. Because where we are now is not where we were a few short years ago when that order book of for eight type 20 sixes was constructed.
Speaker 23
So I recognize the right honorable member's experience in this space. I would say that eight type twenty two two towed array frigates is the right level. What I would like to see is our ability to cover the ocean for expanded through the use of autonomy and some of the lessons that we've learned from Ukraine. And that's why I talk about the Atlantic Bastion. Major capability platforms matched with mass uncrewed systems will provide us a far more effective way to find, deter, and indeed neutralize threats subsurface in the future.
Speaker 106
deputy speaker. I join the minister in thanking our armed forces personnel that identified this threat and allowed us, to take the action which he has described. I note that real terms defense spending fell by 22%, in the eight years or so prior to 2017. It's this government that's turning that around with, fresh investment, and more cooperation with with the sector. But we know our undersea, infrastructure is vulnerable to to a great many threats and as we face threats on a number of different fronts, we mustn't lose sight of that.
Speaker 54
We do have a job however to explain to the British public why we need this investment. Can I encourage him to when these if if we face a similar threat in the future, to make sure that the public understand this because it's a choice that might mean we don't have the opportunity to spend in other areas of public life?
Speaker 23
I I think we we have a job to ensure that we communicate and educate the population all of the variety of threats, whether it be the threat posed by Russia and Ukraine, that threat emanating from the High North that comes into the Atlantic. A lot of people talk about us not having a frontline with the Russians. The reality is we do. It sits in the North Atlantic, but that's not the only threats. There's also threats in influence space and, of course, in cyberspace, which we must must compete with, but then also respond to contin contingency operations the Middle East, madam deputy speaker, which you've seen us do over the last seven weeks.
Speaker 13
Lincoln Jop. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. The prime minister said, I think, about three weeks ago that the Royal Navy would go after sanctioned Russian tankers. And yet, if the press reports are to be believed, those very same sanctioned Russian tankers have sailed with impunity through the English Channel. My question is, why haven't we done anything?
Is there some legal bar or a practical bar when it comes to Royal Navy resources to mount interdiction operations in the English Channel?
Speaker 23
So, madam deputy speaker, I have a lot of experience, as does the individual opposite, on boarding ships. The MOD is absolutely ready to go, but we must ensure those ships meet the certain criteria. And as soon as they do, they will be boarded, and deterred.
Speaker 74
madam deputy speaker. Does my honorable friend agree with me that whilst the government continues to rightly defend our people, interests, and allies in The Middle East, we must never lose sight of the war in Europe and our determination to always stand with Ukraine during this conflict. Yeah.
Speaker 23
Madam deputy speaker, I completely agree, and a key piece there is never lose sight. Over a million casualties, Russia has taken more casualties than America has took in the entire second World War, 55,000 drones and missiles fired in the last year, thousands of tanks destroyed, and cities plunged into poverty, into the cold with no lights, no no, hospital services across an entire nation. Why? All to support an individual's ambition to rewrite history and indeed rewrite the rules for international borders through the use of brutal force unacceptable.
Speaker 107
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Back in February, former Royal Mari Navy officers and other expert witnesses warned the the Defence Select Committee that although tapping an undersea cable is very difficult, they are vulnerable to sabotage, and more than three quarters of The UK's natural gas is imported by via undersea pipelines from Norway. Does the minister agree, given Russia's attacks on Ukrainian energy infrastructure, doesn't The UK need to press ahead faster with the Atlantic Bastion initiative? And in light of recent defense budget pressures, can the minister confirm whether funding levels are adequate to maintain long term submarine detection and tracking capabilities? Minister.
Speaker 23
I respect the honorable member's, insight into this, especially with his constituency. What I would say is Atlantic Bastion is moving forward fast. We're using some of the requirements and the needs also in The Middle East to see what we can test and trial, and we're pushing forward as fast as we can, Taking those lessons from Ukraine and ensuring they're inculcated into the slightly rougher and bigger seas in the North Atlantic is an exceptional challenge, but we're moving forward as fast as we can to do it. And when combined with our type 26 fleet, between us, Norway, and hopefully others, we will have one of the most effective counter submarine fleets in the world.
Speaker 86
It was a privilege recently to spend a week at Camp Viking with our Royal Marines, seeing firsthand the work they're doing to defend the High North. Would the minister agree with me that it's clear strategically that the security of the High North and of the North Atlantic are intrinsically linked because of the sea lanes, data cables and also the presence of the Russian northern fleet around the Kodo Peninsula? Can he set out, as well as their carrier group, what else we'll be doing as a nation to protect the Arctic and our interests and allied interests in order to diminish and constrain Putin's war machine but also to protect access to the North Atlantic?
Speaker 23
So as my old girlfriend, will know, we have the carrier group deploying up there, which will be a nor a NATO exercise with a multitude of different assets attached, which will be running through all sorts of mission rehearsals, but also deterrent operations. On top of that, we've had international engagement with our GEF partners, and that will increase over time. And, of course, we have 1,500 exceptionally effective marines deployed in the High North protecting our NATO flank and, of course, our allies and partners.
Speaker 81
Thank you, madam. Mister speaker, can we be absolutely clear from his statement, which I very much commend for its candor and bluntness, that these two guggy submarines have left have now left UK waters. They were carrying out hostile acts in UK waters. And I cannot believe that the MOD or many people in the MOD are happy with the limp wristed response of the rest of the government to this episode. Has the ambassador been summoned for a public dressing down?
Have we expelled any Russian diplomats in retaliation? Retaliation? Are we making it clear to our Russian adversaries that if they mess in our territorial waters, we will demand their immediate surrender and that they should surface and be escorted to a British port, or we open fire or at least fire a warning shot. Because just saying we see you is not going to be enough. That's not going to bother president Putin one jot, and he'll carry on doing exactly what he's doing until we're prepared to escalate ourselves and show we are prepared to deter what he is doing to our
Speaker 23
I can confirm the the submarines were not within the 12 nautical miles of UK territorial waters, and the right honorable member will know the rules of the sea have all sorts of rules and regulations around the use of force. What I would say is we have been watching and observing, those vessels, and actually by calling it out and telling the world about exactly what they're up to reduces their ability to do something and then deny it and blame it on someone else, which in itself is probably the most effective deterrence that we've done.
Speaker 28
Deputy speaker, while the member for Clapton talks down our Royal Navy, I think the House today is united in praising the Royal Navy for their work to deter Russian activity at deep sea. Through Atlantic Bastion and with emerging defense SMEs, does my right honourable and garrent garrent friend agree with me that defence companies should get the finance they need to be able to thrive and protect our deep sea assets? Minister.
Speaker 23
So I know my honorable friend is exceptionally passionate about this, as am I. I fully support our Royal Navy activity in the High North, but I also expect, as we move forward with big capability procurements, that SMEs get a fair showing to ensure that we can capitalize on some of the entrepreneurial spirit that is driving what is a technological revolution in Ukraine. We've done thousands of contracts. There will be thousands more, but we also have a really difficult challenge on our hands. New technology in Ukraine is driving change faster than ever before.
Capabilities that were ordered perhaps previously may have to have their roles changed or adapted, and indeed some of the capability we have now is outdated and needs replaced. That complexity is why the defense and investment plan is taking time, but it will come. And when it does, it will be fantastic.
Speaker 34
I hope to give the minister a focused question. He's rightly laid out the importance of the data cables to The UK as an island and also highlighting Russia's continued activity over many decades. The frigates that we have in the Royal Navy are really the centerpiece of the anti submarine war. So my short focused question is, how many frigates could we put to sea tomorrow?
Speaker 23
Depending on the situation, we could put frigates to sea at any point in time. That comes down to the balance of risk around health and safety and operational readiness depending on the threat.
Speaker 70
Thank you. Speaker. Russia is in our seas undermining our North Sea cables. They are, they are on social media spreading myths and disinformation, and Russia is even in our politics as we remember that the former former leader in Wales is currently serving time in prison for accepting Russian bribes. Members across this house recognize the ever present threat that Russia poses to this country.
Speaker 34
I'm not sure that the public are always quite as aware of just the scale and presence of Russia affecting our society at every level. So can I thank the minister for coming to the house today and updating us on what's been going on? It's really important we do expose Russia and what they're up to. And can I urge him to work with colleagues across government to ensure that we continue to expose Russia wherever they are attacking us?
Speaker 23
I'd like to thank the honorable friend for raising this issue. Yes. There is a physical threat from Russian submarines, Russian surface ships, bombers, the war in Ukraine, but there's actually a more subversive threat, one that is based on influence on the hearts and minds of our nation, on the political divide of our nation, and that's why we've seen some members of some parties, actually do over ten years in prison because of the connections to the Russian regime. And I think, actually, in some of those areas, myself and my other ministerial colleagues are working exceptionally hard now to quantify what that threat looks like from a cyber and influence perspective, and then putting measures in place to neutralize it so democracy can thrive.
Speaker 72
I join the honorable and government minister in paying tribute to our armed forces. After the defense secretary gave a press conference calling out this operation, Russia said it poses no threat to undersea infrastructure. I asked this question when the minister responded to an urgent question back in November after lasers were fired at RAF pilots by Russia. Why has the Russian ambassador not been summoned by the foreign office given this clear threat to our national security?
Speaker 23
We regularly make clear to our, Russian counterparts, what they're up to, what's happening, and ensure that the, the severity of their activity is explained to them. The the this question about whether Russia poses no threat to a CNI, I think, is fundamentally wrong. The reason they are mapping it, the reason they're trying to understand it, is to find a gap, develop capabilities, at a time of their choosing, perhaps use it. We acknowledge that. We are watching.
We have very clear indicators and warnings, and I have complete assurance in our armed forces' ability to deter it.
Speaker 4
you. You've been speaking The minister may be aware that the RAF's investment into the p eight sub submarine hunting program was taken back in 2015, a time when Russian activity in the North Atlantic was much less, the threat to The UK much lower. Now I welcome the £100,000,000 announced, just now, but that is less than one third of the cost of one of those aircraft. So can I ask him what assessment he's made of the p eight, submarine hunting capability in light of the increased Russian activity? And will he assure the house that he will go further if the RAF needs him to?
Speaker 23
So I'd like to it's a fantastic question and point. The Nimrod capability was taken out of service many, many years ago. The p eight program is a is a huge success. Many other allies and partners use those same aircraft. When you combine that with some of the best frigates and the best, navy personnel and with our subsurface capability, that multi domain spectrum of finding, submarines and tracking them is second to none.
There's a 100,000,000 investment going into the p eight program, and, of course, we will ensure that our money is spent wisely on maintenance and other, gaps if required, and we will spend more indeed if there are issues with the p eight program in the future. It is the front line of our deterrence and indicator network.
Speaker 74
Madam deputy speaker, this incident highlights the need to move at pace to scale up our hybrid naval capabilities. And so will the minister commits to do so, drawing on the strength of Northeast, industry? Minister.
Speaker 23
Madam deputy speaker, a navy without a navy has destroyed or rendered irrelevant, one of the biggest black fleets in the world, which is the Black Sea Fleet. The lessons that we can learn from the hybrid activity in Ukraine are some of the most important for our island nation, and We're going to ensure they are inculcated and integrated into our major capability platforms to ensure, in future, we have a high low mix of hardware with very sophisticated software combined into some of those very fantastic high end systems, such as the type 26 frigate.
Speaker 113
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. First of all, can I pay tribute to the dedication and bravery of our armed forces, and in particular, this instance, to the many members of armed forces in this operation who are based at RAF Lossymouth in the Poseidon fleet, and also those in the typhoons who provide quick reactional air from Lossymouth? They are on the front line in defensive operations and protecting the integrity of our defense against Russia. The point that was made by the honorable member for Keith and Sonsutherland about the threat of Russian vessels in the North Atlantic growing is really important. And the there is an advantage to basing more vessels in the North Of the Isles of these isles, and there are plenty ports around Scotland that could accommodate that.
Will the minister give that serious consideration?
Speaker 23
We have a multitude of indicators and warnings that highlight when threats come into our areas of interest. When they do, we make sure we mobilize capability to meet and deter that threat. What I would like to say is I think it is realizing on all parties the absolute centrality of Scotland within our defensive network, its geographical position, but also the access and insight it gives us to the High North, which is critical to our defense.
Speaker 32
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And can I thank my gallant friend for his today? Building on the remarks of my, honourable friend, the member for witness, can I commend the minister on his statement, but encourage him to do all he can to continue to raise awareness of the subversive actions of Russia, whether that's in the grey zone or hybrid activities? And does he agree with me that the success of our armed forces in the North Atlantic recently rebuffs recent remarks that the leader of the opposition has continued to fail to apologise for when she said that our armed forces were simply hanging around. In fact, what we have seen is whether it's at sea, in the air,
Speaker 56
forces are working day in, day out to keep their homeland safe, and we should be proud of all that they do.
Speaker 23
So we have seen we have seen billions in pounds of cyber attacks in The UK. We've seen a 30% increase in Russian surface and subsurface capability in the High North. We've seen tactics and training cross pollinated between Russia and Ukraine, and now Iran across 10 different countries with low and slow flying drones and high end ballistic missiles mixed into a very effective strike program. And then we have seen on the other side the capabilities from Ukraine now deploying into the Middle East to defend against those very same tactics. And I think it is clear to everyone to see that there are countries working together to undermine the West, not just in the physical domain, in the cyber domain, in the influence domain.
The quicker we push against this, the very better.
Speaker 94
Hi, madam deputy speaker. It's clear that under the current leadership, The US is no longer a reliable ally, threatening European colleagues, Commonwealth nations, and undermining the very purpose of NATO. As we face increasing threats from Russia, we are reliant on them for our nuclear deterrent, our kit and technology. Will the minister share his plans to increase the priority for British and European partners' equipment so that we can have some independence from them and also boost our domestic market? We
Speaker 23
have a multitude of allies and partners. The US been a partner for the last twenty years and will continue to be so for some time to come. We share a whole plethora of different capabilities and have done for the last twenty years. We also do the same with our European allies. And as you will know, the Lunar House Agreement with Norway has resulted in the frigate deal, our Trinity House deal with the Germans, and, of course, our capability cooperation with Poland has resulted in millions of pounds of investment, but also thousands of skilled jobs from Scotland to Cornwall to Ireland to Wales.
Speaker 101
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And I thank my honorable gallant friend for his statement, today. Can I personally pay tribute to our incredibly brave naval personnel for the important work that they're doing, often under very difficult weather conditions to keep us all safe? It strikes me that Harlow is quite away from the Arctic Circle and that the Arctic Circle is considerably colder than a Harlow, particularly this time of year. I wondered if my honorable Gallant Friend would touch upon the unique challenges that our naval fleet face in those conditions.
Speaker 98
Although it's hugely important we support NATO with their mission Arctic Century, would he reflect on the challenges and reassure me and my constituents that our naval fleet are prepared for those challenges? Minister.
Speaker 23
So I'm, in no way doubt, absolutely clear we have the best one one of the best navies in the world. I've served in the Royal Navy for twenty four years as a member of his majesty's Royal Marines. Operating in the High North is exceptionally difficult. I've only done a little bit of it in my time on the carrier strike group as the chief of staff, but when you're in Sea State 9 on a pointy frigate, yes, you need to have some metal to, continue, doing your job, when it happens day in, day out, for weeks on end. What I can say is the Royal Navy persevere.
They do a fantastic job, and when you combine that with our p h in the sky, and, of course, the silent service underneath the waves, I have no doubt that our nation is very well protected.
Speaker 89
Madam Speaker, the minister may recall that back in November when we discussed the Yantar, I asked him about the circumstances under which the fleet contingency group would be given the green light to conduct a maritime interdiction operation, and he responded and said that it would be it would need to meet the international law. I was very pleased on the March 25 when the Prime Minister put out his statement saying that, the the Royal Marines and Special Forces would be given the opportunity to interdict Russian Shadow Fleet vessels, but subsequently we haven't seen any of that take place. The minister mentioned that criteria need to be met. Now there are 544 sanctioned Russian Shadow Fleet vessels. Can you confirm whether all of the by virtue of just being sanctioned meets the criteria for being interdicted or are there vessels within that list of 544 that are in scope and simply they haven't transferred yet through our waters?
Speaker 23
you will as you will be absolutely clear, the maritime interdiction of a Russian flagged vessel such as the Yantar is very different to one that either doesn't have a flag or changes its flag regularly. The criteria must be met to enable those boardings. The MOD is absolutely ready to go, but, unfortunately, I'm not going to go through the detail, here because it may allow some of those vessels to put in place the mitigations that will reduce our ability to board them.
Speaker 12
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. With the Russian Navy now escorting shadow fleet vessels down through the English Channel, could a mitigation or a blocker for actually interdicting on one of these vessels be a naval vessel with them? And was it an error of judgment by the government to put them on notice that we were now about to start these interdictions?
Speaker 23
Minister. So we'd already supported The US boarding of a sanctioned vessel and, of course, multiple other allies as well. Russian naval escorts do escort some of these vessels. When they do, that's also putting a considerable strain on the Russian fleet, which is relatively limited when you combine it with its subsurface capability, which is having an effect. What I can say is the MOD is absolutely ready to board any ship that meets the parameters and will do so if it happens.
Speaker 27
It was Danny Kruger, I believe. Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I wanted to pay tribute to the Royal Navy and and echo the point made by the minister in respect of our brave personnel. And I agree with him that we have the best navy in the world. I just wish it were larger.
Can I question the the the minister? I'm unclear from what he's been saying whether we've had more than a narrative of what happened over the last month and of our capabilities in respect of these events. What has actually changed in terms of the government's planning with respect to defending our undersea infrastructure from Russia in terms of either disposition of our forces or or procurement perhaps? And secondly, can I ask him he he mentions the resilience of our undersea infrastructure? Can you tell the house a little about what what plans we have to cope with an attack on undersea cables and how quickly we could recover from them?
Speaker 23
First of all, it's a delight to see your party sat here in a defense in defense a defense subject, which is a first. And I'd also just like to remind him of the capability that we've seen as this Russian operations take place. The UK has deployed assets to map and track it, and then expose it, which is, in fact, is one of the best deterrents because no longer could Russia or indeed Putin claim that an operation or sabotage that took place was not them, which was the whole purpose of that operation, which has, been fantastically conducted by the best, Royal Navy in the world. And remember, it's not just the ship or indeed the aircraft. There's a whole plethora of individual.
In fact, 500 people sat behind this operation conducting it, it was successfully prosecuted. Claire Young.
Speaker 109
I'm deputy speaker. I'd like to return to the issue of UK Maritime Services facilitating the export of Russian energy, which I raised in this chamber three months ago. Does the minister not see the irony that a time when we're all grappling with how we fund our own defence that the government is still letting UK plc bankroll Putin's war machine a war machine that is mapping our infrastructure and what action does the government plan to take to stop it? So
Speaker 23
we have taken some of the most extensive action on sanctions in any other country, sanctioning thousands of individuals and indeed enterprises, and we'll continue to do so as long as that money is fueled into an illegal war, and a barbaric war, in Ukraine.
Speaker 110
Speaker. A recent policy exchange document entitled closing the back door highlighted that as a result of the Irish government freeloading on UK and NATO, that it was increasingly reliant on UK for security, particularly regarding to air defense and maritime security, resulting in an ability to, an an an inability to protect its own airspace and territorial waters, including crucial transatlantic cables, which created a backdoor vulnerability for The UK and NATO. What discussions has he had with the Irish government to up its game and to provide for some security measures? Does he have these any concerns that a future Irish government, which included Sinn Fein, could lead to any cooperation breaking down?
Speaker 23
need to accept that, Ireland in itself is exceptionally close to the mainland, and therefore we have shared security interests. The PM has had very constructive conversations with his Irish counterparts to ensure, where applicable, we share those resources, and ensure that we protect both Ireland, and, of course, Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
Speaker 24
Madam deputy speaker, the minister talked about ways in which the government is investing in deterring adversaries in the North Atlantic. He talked about the Atlantic Bastion program. He talked about extra money for p eight aircraft. He talked about additional surface vessels that are on order. But I don't, unless I missed it, think I heard anything said about plans for the AUKUS class submarines, but the plans for in development, with The United States.
Can the minister comment on the future of the AUKUS programme?
Speaker 23
The AUKUS programme is not in question. It continues at full strength and is a fantastic trilateral partnership between us, Australians, and the Americans.
Speaker 112
Thank you. Given Northern Ireland's geographical position, it increasingly occupies a geosecurity location of some significance, particularly in regard to the Transatlantic undersea cables. I'm therefore disappointed that there are still only five Royal Navy personnel based in Northern Ireland. Could I ask the minister? Last month, there was a memo memorandum of understanding between The United Kingdom and The Republic Of Ireland to provide sea and naval cover for the entire British Isles, particularly important to the republic given their cyber economy reliant upon those cables.
It is reported in some press that that has been provided free of charge to the Republic Of Ireland. Is that correct? Surely not.
Speaker 23
Minister. It's not lost on me the essential role of Northern Ireland in our both our transatlantic relationship, but also in the security of our Great Isle. The and the essential role it played, indeed, in World War two. I wrote back to you with the detail of numbers within Northern Ireland, if I can, if it's within the operational parameter. What I would say is that any discussions taking place with another country on a diplomatic space usually have bilateral benefits.
Speaker 91
Madam deputy speaker, can I thank the honorable and gone minister for his statement today? No one in this house or outside of this house doubts the commitment of the honorable gentleman. The select committee had come about, I think, maybe about six weeks ago to the house and I'd asked him a question to the chair of the select committee, the very issue that my honorable member and friend for East Tottenham referred to. The ministers were that the Royal Navy and the Royal Air Force protect not only The United Kingdom Of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, also The Republic. And that pipelines and undersea cables go from United Kingdom to The Republic Of Ireland to Atlantic Ocean.
Speaker 50
So can the minister confirm, that the activities of Russian submarines have not been active in the soft underbelly of The Republic Of Ireland and the backdoor to The United Kingdom Of Great Britain and Northern Ireland? Thank
Speaker 23
Madam deputy speaker, I'm not going to go into the specific detailed geographical movement of submarines. What I can say is that there are interdependencies between us and, of course, Northern Ireland, Ireland, and a multitude of other European nations of where cables go under the sea. We are working with our allies and partners, we'll continue to do so to ensure they're absolutely protected. And indeed, if any threat appears, that it is mapped, tracked, and deterred.
Speaker 54
I've been waiting over four months for a reply to written parliamentary questions nine six three five seven, nine six four seven five, and nine six four seven seven on SEND reform, as well as a Freedom of Information Act request, which is also now several weeks overdue as well. And I see your guidance if you could encourage the Department for Education to reply to their correspondence in a timely fashion.
Speaker 77
I thank the honourable member for giving notice of his point of order. Freedom of information requests are not a matter for the chair, but it is important that members receive timely answers to their parliamentary questions. The honorable member's point will no doubt be drawn to the attention of the leader of the house who will be able to pursue this matter. Motion number one on business of the house today. Minister to move.
Speaker 77
Motion not moved. I'll give the front benches a few moments to swap over. Now come to the backbench motion on send provision and reform. I call Gregory Stafford who will speak for up to fifteen minutes.
Speaker 19
deputy speaker. I beg to move that this house calls for review of send provision and reform, and I thank the backbench business committee for allowing this debate. Every debate on special educational needs and disabilities is dominated by statistics. Funding, school places, workforce numbers. These are, of course, important, but at the heart of this is the issue of the children, the families, and their carers who rely on the system.
So therefore, I want to thank the hundreds of families who've contacted me since this debate was scheduled both in my own constituency and across the country. Now this debate was applied for before the white paper came out, so colleagues will forgive me if I decide to focus pretty much my whole comments on the white paper, but I'm sure other colleagues across this house may speak more widely on the issues. In in my opinion, any credible reform of SEND, including the government's white paper, must meet three tests. It must strengthen legal protections, it must improve delivery on the ground, and it must address the underlying pressures in the system. And if it does all of these three, it can and it will save money in the long run.
But I'm afraid that on all three, the government's proposals fall short. Before turning to the substance of the proposals, want to address the process by which they've been brought forward. The consultation itself has raised serious concerns. Parents and representative organizations have expressed overwhelming opposition to key elements of the reforms, particularly around the potential weakening of legal protections. National charities have warned that proposals risk eroding rights, while others have questioned whether the most consequential changes have been fully and transparently put to the consultation at all.
At the same time, many parents and forums report feeling that engagement has been superficial. The workshops and consultation exercises have not meaningfully reflected their views. And this matters because reform of this scale depends on trust.
Speaker 50
done is right to to underline the issues, that's why everyone here in the house is quite full. But one of the things that has never been done, and I think it should be done, is the issue of I'm I'm 71 years old. I remember when I was young as a child, there wasn't many children that had autism and had, learning difficulties. But today, the numbers are exceptional. Does the honorable gentleman agree it's time to source out the reason why there are so many children with special needs, necessities and qualities that they don't have and they didn't have back in the 60s and the 70s when I was a boy?
Speaker 19
The Honourable Gentleman raises a very good point, very interesting point, and I think if you're going to try to solve, if that's the right word, the issue around special education needs, and more importantly put in place the systems, to, support children with special education needs, you do need to have an understanding of the reasons for it. But instead I have to say to your honorable men gentleman, I think in the government's proposals, there is a feeling for families who are already exhausted by the system becoming disengaged from the very process that it's supposed to improve it. Now across Farnham Borden, Hazelmere, Lippock, and the surrounding villages, SEND is the most single most important and most prominent issue in my casework inbox. Parents, schools, and carers feel consistently let down by a system that is too slow, too complex, and too on too is too often unresponsive. Now as vice chairman of the APPG on SEND and through my work on the health and social care, select committee, I see these challenges not just locally, but reflected across the country.
Speaker 114
I I give way. Yes. I I think the honorable member Giveng Giming Wang. He's obviously making very persuasive arguments and points. In my constituency of Birmingham, View, unlike many other constituencies, the issue of SEND and support for SEND is an ever increasing problem.
It's not just the support, but the quality of support. And what we are now seeing, parents having to lose their jobs because travel for send children to and from school is being prevent prevented. Does the honorable member agree that this consultation should focus on the need as opposed to the financial aspect?
Speaker 19
As I said in my opening remarks, my view is that if you get this system right and I don't assuage any unfair or untoward motive for the government. I do think they come from this from a point of trying to trying to improve the system. But if you improve it properly, then I think it will save money. And I think the danger with the way the government has approached this is they're looking to save money, and they're thinking about how they can solve the system. And I think that I think that is the danger.
I think that is the danger. So moving on to those three tests that I talked about at the start. The first test is whether the government's proposal strengthened legal protections. Now education health and care plans introduced in 2014, I accept are not perfect, but they provide something essential. Clarity, structure, and crucially, enforceability.
Can I make a little bit more progress? The central question is whether individual support plans will carry those same enforceable rights. At present, the government has not provided that assurance, and I look to the minister to do so. In fact, external assessment suggests that these changes will significantly weaken legal protections. Now that creates a clear risk, replacing a system that is legally enforceable, albeit slow, with one that may be simpler in theory, but weaker in law.
And we know that enforceability matters. Across the country, over nine in ten tribunal appeals are upheld in a minute against, against the local authority. And while, let's be frank, that covers no local authority in any kind of glory, it is evidence that the legal framework works when families are able to challenge decisions. Remove that safeguard, and families lose their ultimate protection.
Speaker 98
him way, and I thank him for being this really important debate to the chamber, and I recognize his passion for supporting young people of SEND. I do disagree with him on his views, when it comes to the government white paper. I'm not saying it because I'm sitting on this side of the bench. I'm saying it as a former teacher who worked with a system that did work that was very similar to the system that's being put forward. I've just put to him the point about legal enforcement and EACPs.
I would question that because actually what you found is that even when children did get the EACPs, the schools just weren't able to provide what the EHP defined. So whether it was a legal requirement or not, those schools just weren't able to provide. I would just ask you to reflect on that.
Speaker 19
madam deputy speaker. Given the amount of time, I'm probably not gonna take too many more interventions. On the on on the honorable gentleman's point, I think it's a strange argument to have that because a child has been legally given an EHCP which requires the school to provide a certain level of support that because for whatever reason whether through the school, through the local authority or whatever reason that cannot be supported, we should therefore water down its legal rights. So when the current system works, and it does work in places, it is transformational. One parent in my constituency wrote, and I quote, we are incredibly relieved.
I have received the final copy of my EHCP, and the school is now implementing it. It has been a long road, end quote. That relief exists that relief no. I won't. That risk exists because there is a system that ultimately guarantees report report.
Replacing that certainty is and with ambiguity is not reform, it's regression. Now the second test is whether the proposals improve delivery on the ground. The model set out in the white paper relies heavily on early intervention through the NHS and through local schools, but that depends on capacity that currently simply does not exist. For example, in Hampshire and Isle of Wight ICB, CAMS waiting time stands at around about twenty eight and a half weeks for an assessment, rising to fifty two weeks for treatment, far beyond the NHS standard of eighteen weeks. Without clinical capacity, the central delivery mechanism of these reforms cannot function as intended.
Schools are already being asked to fill that gap. In discussions with head teachers and senators across my constituency, including at South Farnham School, Highfield South Farnham, St. Polycarps, Mary's, Bagshot the influence infants, and others, a consistent picture emerges. Rising demand, limited special support, and growing pressure on staff to manage needs that should sit elsewhere in the system. One school put it plainly, and I quote, CAMS sometimes ask us to manage pupils ourselves because they do not have the capacity, end quote.
So that is not joined up delivery, it's displacement of responsibility. And the consequences of this gap between the policy and the reality are severe. In my constituency, a 12 year old whose needs were identified in year two is still waiting an assessment. Without diagnosis, her school has been unable to put the right support in place. And her mother wrote, and I quote, we are at the end of our wits.
The delays are not just administrative, they are shaping the course of our daughter's life, end quote. And that's not an isolated quote. I've also worked with a family who despite clear professional evidence were initially refused an EHCP and forced into a lengthy tribunal process only for the decision to be overturned. There is further consequence of these proposals that need to be addressed. By moving away from a clean defined legally enforceable EHCP framework towards individual support plans, much of the responsibility for decision making and inevitably dispute resolution risks being pushed onto schools in one in in one in one moment.
That would place teachers and school leaders in an increasingly difficult position, expected to determine provision, manage expectations, and resolve disagreements with families without the protection of clear statutory framework or the capacity to meet those needs. At a time when schools are under significant pressure, this risks shifting both legal and emotional burden onto institutions that are simply not equipped to carry it.
Speaker 115
To my fellow member of the Health Select Committee for for giving away. Is he not making two contradictory points though? Because he says on the one hand that it should be legally enforceable, a point on which I entirely agree, particularly as when one looks at partially and wholly upheld as nearly 99% of tribunals are supported. But he also recognizes that ECHPs are not coming through at the level within the twenty weeks that they should and certainly at about the 10% level. Therefore having the legal backing and framework isn't actually delivering the outcome.
Speaker 19
Well, I I don't think those two points are contradictory. I think one one is a one is an issue of the legislation, which is what I'm talking about and what the government is potentially looking to change, and one is the how the system itself is being implemented by local authorities and others. And I and I think I would be very clear in my speech that whilst I absolutely believe, like I think he does, that, the legal requirements should remain, I'm not in any way shooter sugar covering the the difficulties that local authorities are having in meeting those legal requirements. Madam deputy speaker, the third test which I mentioned are whether the reforms address the underlying pressures in the system. Now demand is rising rapidly.
Over one point seven million children in England are now identified as having special educational needs with numbers increasing year on year. Yet the government's proposals place additional expectations on schools and local authorities without resolving those fundamental constraints, namely workforce, funding certainty, and system capacity. The white paper promises more educational psychologists, more therapists, more specialists, but training an educational psychologist can take up to eight years. So the question is simple, how are those gaps going to be filled in the meantime? And at the same time, the department's own figures showed that there are now 400 fewer teachers in than when we left office.
So schools are being asked to do more with less. Now local authorities are at the sharp end of the system, and they are being placed in an increasingly impossible position. And I know, colleagues will know that in Surrey, around a £100,000,000 has been invested locally to expand Semra Vision alongside further investment in staffing, yet demand continues to outstrip capacity. And in Hampshire, SEND overspend now stands at around a £140,000,000, placing extraordinary pressure on finances. But this isn't unique to my areas in Surrey or Hampshire.
Across the country, councils are being asked to meet rising demand, fulfill substantial statutory obligations, and absorb increasing costs without that long term funding certainty certainty. And the result is a system where families face delays, councils face financial instability, and schools face mounting pressure. Madam deputy speaker, I think taken together this is not simply a failure of local authorities. It is a failure of the system to meet demand. And into that system, the government proposes a decade long transition.
Councils are already preparing for a surge in EHC applications as families seek to secure existing protections before reforms take effect. And that's certainly not going to ease pressure. It is in fact going to intensify it. Now through my work on the Health and Social Care Select Committee, I consistently see that cannot be addressed in isolation. The number of children with SEND is rising by about five percent each year, and meeting that need requires genuine coordination between education and health.
And yet SEND was almost entirely absent from the NHS ten year plan. And when I submitted written questions on conditions such as autism, ADHD and dyslexia, the responses revealed that data is not collected individually but grouped into very broad categories, which is really not joined up government. It's fragmentation. That needs to change. I want to touch briefly on the independent sector capacity because independent schools also play an important role in relieving pressure on the system, particularly for children with complex needs.
They act as a pressure valve. And I'm aware that some characterize all independent provision as little more than private equity extracting profit. But I can tell you that the independent sector in my constituency provides excellent and comprehensive coverage and capacity. I'm fortunate enough in my constituency to have excellent specialist provision including schools such as Holywater, Undershore, Morehouse, Pathways, the Abbey School, and the Ridgeway School. They support children with complex needs every day and they should be supported.
Madam deputy speaker, in conclusion, when families what families need is not another wholesale structural overhaul nor a decade of transition. They need assistance that delivers on time with clarity and with enforceable rights. So I have a few questions for the minister. First, will she set out the full cost of replacing the HCPs with individual support plans including the transition implementation? Can she guarantee that ISPs will carry the same legal enforceable rights including access to a tribunal?
Third, when will additional SEND staff be trained and imposed? Fourth, what action will be taken against local authorities that consistently fail to meet ute timelines? And finally, will the government publish detailed data on specific conditions and systems performance so that outcomes can be properly measured? I would say this to honorable and right honorable members across the house. This is not about defending a white paper.
It is about defending the families that we represent. Families are not asking for perfection. They are just simply asking for a system that works. The question of the government is simple. Will it strengthen what exists, or would it replace it with something weaker, slower and less certain?
Because on the current trajectory, that is the risk, and it is one I believe this house should not accept.
Speaker 77
The question is as on the order paper, and I will start with an immediate five minute time limit. Chair of the select committee, Helen Hayes.
Speaker 93
Madam deputy speaker, can I congratulate the honorable member for Farnam and Borden on securing this important debate and thank the bank backbench business committee for allocating the time for it? The support for children with special education needs and disabilities is an area in which my committee has taken an intense interest. It is the single biggest challenge in our education system with far reaching consequences. The current system is failing children, families, and the professionals who work with them right across our country. It is causing deep distress, sometimes even trauma, for children and their families.
Speaker 109
The implications of the failing system for local authority finances are profound, and many professionals are put in the invidious position of being unable to deliver the education and support that children and young people require because of impossible constraints on resources and ever increasing need. The outcomes for children with SEND are unacceptably poor, and I'm afraid, madam deputy speaker, I simply don't recognise the description of the honorable gentleman for, Farnam and Borden that this is a system that is broadly working, a system that relies on parents having to battle every step of the way Yeah. And having to go to tribunal to seek redress is an exclusionary and inequitable system. And we need to be absolutely clear that it is failing and that the reform that is necessary to get it to work is comprehensive and far reaching. It is vital that the failures in the current system are addressed.
Speaker 93
Vital on its own terms because no child should feel that there is no place for them in our education system, that their needs are not understood, or even worse, as we heard from some of our witnesses, that they are the problem. No parent should have to battle at every single stage of their child's education to get the support they need. But this is also vital if we want to improve outcomes in our education system, and if we want to unleash the talent and creativity of every single young person for the benefit of our society and our economy. I
Speaker 22
thank my honourable friend for giving way. What I hear about is a real concern from parents about exclusions, as she's mentioned. They're really concerned to understand how accountability will work in a future system, particularly around that risk that exclusions can have for a future where children are concerned about trauma as a result of their exclusions. Grateful for her thoughts on that.
Speaker 93
I thank my honourable friend for her intervention. Accountability is one of the areas that we highlighted in our committee report last year, which I'll come on to speak about in a moment. We published our inquiry report last year, solving the send crisis. Our report was based on 900 pieces of written evidence, seven oral evidence sessions, and visits to Ontario and Canada, and to schools and colleges implementing innovative good practice in England. In 95 detailed recommendations, our report called for comprehensive change to the SEND system, with a focus on early identification of need, making mainstream schools inclusive for the children with SEND who are already in them, increasing the accountability of the SEND system, as my honourable friend rightly suggests, for schools, local authorities, and importantly for the NHS, and involving parents and carers in every decision about the support their children receive.
We have, to date, received only an interim response from the government to our recommendations. We look forward to receiving the full response in due course, but we are encouraged that the Government's send reform proposals reflect several of my committee's recommendations. It is very welcome that the Government has committed additional resources to send support, We'll effectively be running two parallel systems for a number of years to avoid sharp cliff edges between the old system and the new one. That is the right way to deliver significant reform. The decision to write off 90% of local authorities' debt, I know, comes as a huge relief.
It is the right approach to prioritise early identification of need, to be seeking to make mainstream schools fully inclusive for the children who are already in them, and to be expanding the availability of provision in the state sector for children who need a place at a specialist school.
Speaker 28
for giving way. One of my constituents, Olivia, is battling for her son to stay in mainstream education alongside her son's twin, who is an anchor to them. And so would my honourable friend agree with me that we must ensure that ISP is there quickly to avoid some of that distress in the process when parents battle to keep their children in mainstream settings?
Speaker 93
my honourable friend for that intervention. He speaks very well on behalf of his constituent, whose situation is replicated right across the country, and it gives urgency to the need to reform our SEM system. It is the right approach to be increasing the expertise of teaching staff and to be making specialist expertise available to schools whenever they need it. The long waiting times for diagnosis and specialist support, such as speech and language therapy, is one of the most appalling aspects of the current system. Childhood is so short, and children shouldn't be seeing years of their education pass them by without the support they need to get most out of it.
My committee is undertaking our own scrutiny of the Government's proposals tomorrow, when we will hear directly in an oral evidence session from witnesses with a wide range of different perspectives and expertise. We will write formally to the Government in due course without reflections following this evidence session. As I speak with parents and the organisations that represent them, there are some areas of anxiety about the Government proposals that I hope the minister will speak to today. The proposals involve, over time, a scaling back of EHCP assessments and EHCP's, replacing some EHCP's with individual support plans. Parents and carers who I've spoken to are understandably concerned about replacing a statutory plan with an ISP which won't be on a statutory footing.
The concern is about how accountability will be guaranteed if there are problems with the ISP, if their child's needs are not correctly identified, if the ISP is not fit for purpose, or if it is not being implemented properly. I'm afraid I won't give way because the time. Parents and carers of children with SNP have often been let down so much by so many different parts of the system that they simply don't trust that anything will work as it should. Their children have rights on paper which are so often not upheld in practice. In such a context, accountability matters.
Rebuilding the broken trust and confidence of parents and carers in the SEND system will be absolutely critical to the success of the government's reforms, and it's why my committee recommended no changes to current rights and entitlements so that a new system can be built while parents still have the same access to redress to fall back on. I hope the minister can speak to the ways in which her reforms are designed to ensure that trust and confidence is rebuilt, and especially that parents and carers know exactly what will happen if things go wrong. There are also concerns about the proposed reassessment of EHCPs in year six. The transition from primary to secondary is one of the most high risk times in a child's education. We hear time and again from parents who say that starting at secondary school was when their child's education started to unravel.
If only they had been able to transport what they had at primary into secondary, things might have gone better. I am grateful to the minister for the considered and thoughtful approach she has taken to send reform, and for the extensive listening she's undertaken with parents, carers and professionals. The current consultation on draft proposals is also an important part of the process, and I hope that if it is necessary to make adjustments to proposals in light of the feedback from the consultation, the government will be willing to do so. It is so important that these reforms are absolutely right.
Speaker 119
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I've been contacted by a huge number of constituents raising concerns about delays to EHCPs, lack of specialist placements, and the struggle to secure the support their children need. Like so many in this House, SEND issues dominate my surgeries and casework, And it is heartbreaking to see the delays and the pain and anguish brought to those children and families as they wait for what they deserve, an education that works for them and their specific needs. And what troubles me even more is not just those cases that have been brought to me, but how many more there must be who have not come forward. One of the most troubling aspects of this SEND crisis is that too many children simply do not have a suitable place at all.
Speaker 97
Children left in settings that cannot meet their needs or in some cases out of education altogether. But this issue does not begin with placements. It begins much earlier in the system. In Buckinghamshire, Buckinghamshire Council have advised that there is a shortage of occupational therapists to carry out assessments and delays of up to fifty six weeks just to issue an EHCP. That is over a year, a year where a child may be stuck in the wrong setting, a year of lost progress, and a year of growing pressure on families.
Speaker 100
for giving way. Would he agree with me that as well as the harm to the children who do not receive timely support for their special needs, if they're in the wrong setting, there's also harm to the teachers who are not qualified to support those children in their setting, their normal mainstream setting. So the quicker we can do the assessments and get the right support will not only help the children but also the educationalists that are providing the education.
Speaker 97
the whole system that suffers in the circumstance that he describes. The teaching staff who do their absolute very best. And also every other child that is in those classes. He makes a very fair point. So before we even get to the question of school places, the system is already falling behind.
But in Buckinghamshire, nearby SEN schools are already oversubscribed. And mainstream schools, despite the best efforts of those heroic teaching staff, cannot always meet complex needs. And this is where we in Buckinghamshire have been most let down by this government. Back in twenty twenty four, May twenty four, the Department for Education wrote to Buckinghamshire Council committing to a brand new 152 place SENSE school for Buckinghamshire. That wasn't a political pledge or a general election campaign promise.
It was officially announced by the Department for Education. This Labour government have formally scrapped it. What was a £20,000,000 spend downgraded to 8,000,000 over three years for Buckinghamshire. That is not good enough. Yeah.
That school would not have solved all of our problems, but it would have gone a very long way. And I urge the government, even at this late hour, to think again and deliver this school for my constituents, children and families in Buckinghamshire who would benefit so much from it. Now turning to the government's proposed SEND reforms. Many parents have contacted me on this. And I'm concerned, as my honorable friend Farnham and Borden has outlined, that the governments are not even close to getting this right.
One constituent wrote to me, and I quote, I am concerned that the direction of SEND reform risks children and young people having to fit into whatever provision is available or else missing out on education entirely. I am really worried that these new proposals will leave parents having to battle directly with schools to get help for their child. And that is an important point. We need a system that works for the needs of each and every child, not a system that works for a faceless bureaucracy. My constituent continues, and again I quote, my two children both have an autism diagnosis but are significantly different in their support needs.
A one size fits all type provision will not be suitable for even these two siblings. I would love them to be able to manage as a mainstream school, but the solution is not for schools to become more SEN friendly. The solution is a complete overhaul and reform of the schooling system. It is antiquated and not fit for purpose. And I would urge the minister, I was lucky enough to go to an event in Port Cullis House with parents and teachers of SEND families this afternoon chaired by Rory Bremner.
The evidence given by those parents and those teachers was quite frightening. Many who fear that under this white paper brought to be, their children will be excluded altogether. I urge her to get a readout from that meeting. Now this leads on to wider concerns about the loss of individualized, and as my honorable friend put it in his own excellent speech, legally enforceable support. Not just the risk of children being forced into inappropriate provision, but the potential loss of legal protections and tribunal rights, and the potential loss of EOTAS packages, education other than at school, for children who cannot attend any school setting.
That cannot be right.
Speaker 20
I'm I'm very grateful to my honorable friend. And previously when I, spoke in the select committee debate on this in this chamber, I highlighted that too many parents feel the system is done to them rather than working with them. Does my honourable friend share the concern of parents in my constituents in my concern that for that trust to be rebuilt, there has to be some sort of individually legally enforceable backstop for those families?
Speaker 97
My right honorable friend, friend, he hits the nail precisely on the head. And it is in the interest of those families that motivated me to speak in this debate this afternoon. I entirely endorse the point he makes. In the last few moments I've got, I'd like to briefly raise another specific case that I would be grateful for the minister's reflections upon in her summing up. And that is a case that brought to me by a constituent who adopted two children in 2020.
Both children experienced significantly early trauma and later received diagnoses indicating multiple and complex needs. Not least, fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, which can involve more than 400 co occurring difficulties affecting physical health, cognition, executive functioning, and behavior. And delays in intervention have had real and significant consequences. As adoptive parents, my constituents are aware of research estimating that adoption generates significant long term and social economic value. I doubt anyone would disagree with that.
Yet paradoxically, adopting their children, they appear to have lost priority access to some state funded support that would have been available had those children remained in foster care. This unintended consequence is deeply concerning. And more broadly, adopted children with SEND often fall between services. Responsibility frequently passed from one agency to another without the care and attention they need. And I would welcome the minister's reflections on that.
But to conclude, too many families are being let down. One size fits all does not work and never will. Let's focus on the child, the needs of each child,
Speaker 58
Children in West Lancashire have felt previously let down by the SENSE system. People lost faith in the very system that is meant to be supporting the children in our communities who need it most. And that's the inheritance that this government took over from the last. I know how important getting this right is to the secretary of state, and the work this government has done in the past few years has not gone unnoticed by my constituents. But it is so important that we get these changes right, madam deputy speaker, because the people who write to my inbox or visit my surgeries are simply desperate for a system which treats send pupils with dignity and truly recognises them as individuals filled with all sorts of potential.
There's much good in the Government's plans. The vast increase in specialist places and the training and upskilling that will give our teachers more tools to help SEND students will make a real difference to the lives of children, but also to their families. Senparents are no different to any other parent, madam deputy speaker. Every day they fight to give their children the best start in life they possibly can, and it's so important that this government supports them to do this without them having to endlessly fight layers of bureaucracy and constantly pushing back against a computer says no culture, which requires individuals to fit cookie cutter templates to get bespoke assistance. We must ensure that with these changes, we are giving parents respite and not just inadvertently moving the fight from one place to another.
Speaker 115
The honorable member for giving way and and must congratulate her having been a great health minister. I'm sorry that she stood aside. But I, in relation to the point that she's making, she is aware that, of course, there is a party which isn't, of course, present this evening where the policy is and a lot of it in the media are suggesting that they will make the next government, but their policy in this area is that this is a crisis of over diagnosis. I mean, does she not share my concern that there is an issue where where where this debate is simply not being properly held by the people who actually want to damage the system most?
Speaker 58
for his intervention, and his kind words. I would agree that we can't simply say there's an over diagnosis. It's been referred to previously that there weren't as many people with ZEND before. The reality is we don't know that because for many many many years, diagnoses of SEND simply went unnoticed. People weren't diagnosed and they were simply written off as naughty or backward.
And it is so important that we recognise how important these children are and how much support they need. Dozens of parents in West Lancashire have contacted me to request that I come here today to protect the rights that they have under current legislation to enforceable provision based on a child's particular needs. We all know the deficiencies that exist with the current EHCP system, but we must make sure that we listen to parents. I know that this Government is committed to ensuring that these changes make life easier for SEND children and their families, not harder. I've met twice with a constituent of mine who has a son with severe and complex special needs.
He's non verbal and has sensory challenges. Even when her son was offered a place at a special school, the local authority did not accept the place, despite it being cheaper than the local authority provision. They ignored recommendations and assessments, and my constituent's son was out of education for seven months. My constituent had to use the rights that exist in current legislation to fight for the most basic right for her son to have an education. The issue was only resolved because of his legal right to legal enforceability and the tribunal power to name a school.
Had this not been the case, her son may still not be in education. My constituent agrees with the government that the system we inherited isn't working and she's not asking us here today to scrap these reforms, but we must make sure that the changes we are making to an unfair system are supporting SEN children and their families as much as we possibly can. Last year reform took control of Lancashire County Council, the authority that makes decisions about send provision for my constituency. And despite claiming they would tackle the issue, it's plainly obvious that they demonstrated no interest in it. Their national party doesn't as has already been pointed out.
Not a single one of them is present for this debate this evening.
Speaker 58
Reform led Lancashire County Council has failed to provide tailored support for children in my constituency, failed to support families in my constituency who are fighting tooth and nail for the same opportunities for their children that the rest of us rightly expect as standard. And it would be an abdication of my duty in representing my constituents if I didn't seek to give parents every tool in the box to defend the rights of their children to a decent education in the face of a local authority whose leadership turns its gaze and plugs its ears. I'm proud that this government is tackling this issue in a constructive way. Parents have waited for these changes for far too long and as part of my right honourable friend's commitment to giving every child the best start in life possible, I would be grateful if the minister could give a clear reassurance today that the legal right to an EHCP or similar for those who need it will remain and that the ability of families to enforce provision will not be weakened under reforms.
Speaker 94
The speaking limit is now three minutes. It's highly unlikely that most people will get in. Andrew George.
Speaker 46
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. In fact, I had made a number of interventions in in place of my of my of my speech. So I wanted to respond to the the honorable member for for West Lancashire because she was making a very strong case in relation to the the the need to make sure that these reforms are are forced through. The the the the issues which were raised by by the honorable member bringing this debate today, the the three the three tests which which which he he introduced to to this to this debate, think, sort of set the template on which I really hope that the the minister responds in in in due in due course. The issues which I I know that in in in my constituency and across Cornwall, and it's good to see members from from Cornwall here this evening, are causing the greatest concern over in relation to the to the large number of of tribunals which are raised in order for parents to ensure that their children get the decent education that they desperately deserve.
Speaker 113
Thank you for giving away. Let me tell him that in London too there is the same concern as my colleague from West Lancashire put out, that we have to change the system, but too often it has been parents having to go to tribunal in order to be able to being heard. So any reform must support parents to continue to be heard as part of the educational system of supporting
Speaker 115
I absolutely agree. Indeed, what worries I think all of us most is the fact that parents have to be sharp elbowed enough to actually take on the tribunal system, is no mean feat in in itself. And and what worries me in indeed is is how many other parents don't have the confidence to go forward to use the tribunal system and to challenge the system and to actually make a complaint even to the ombudsman or using even local authority facilities to actually pursue those issues. So so there are there are major issues which I think need need to be reflected upon and certainly certainly you know, it shouldn't just be those, you know, down to those parents who have the self confidence to be able to navigate their way through the system that they that their children benefit and so many others are actually falling by the wayside. And that that does cause a great deal of concern to me indeed.
And indeed the other issue which the honorable member in his opening remarks identified is that of the very low numbers that are meeting the twenty week ECHP, you know, basis which which obviously does result in in many pupils just simply not getting on and getting the services which they need within the education service which they which they do desperately need. So, I mean, on that basis and the fact that I have, in any case, made a couple of interventions already,
Speaker 88
I congratulate the member from Farnam and Barden for bringing forward this debate. This government has set forward an ambitious plan to reform the SEND system in this SEND white paper. I am proud of the commitment this government has made to ensure children with SEND are supported to thrive and achieve bringing about change bringing about the changes parents and educators deserve and need. If you ask any parent about their experience of navigating the current SENSE system they will tell you stories of being pushed from pillow to post and not being listened to because the SENSE system that we inherited from the previous government has completely undermined the trust and confidence of parents and carers in our SENSE system. Last Friday in my constituency of Broxdo I met with parents and educators who spoke of their own heartbreaking experiences.
Speaker 127
They told me of their families being traumatised and their children often excluded from education altogether. They welcome the white paper and express their support for all that it seeks to do. However they do have concerns and those concerns around the accountability of the legal status of parents who seek to get support for their families. They are in particular happy and want to support the Government in the fact that the Government wants to do early interventions, provide support closer to home and they are particularly happy that there is going to be additional occupational therapists, speech and language therapists and educational psychologists and that there'll be upskilling for staff in every school. All parents and educators are also seeking further detail in how we can also reform the current teacher training curriculum so that newly qualified teachers and educators are trained with the skills and expertise that they need in every classroom which includes dyslexic pupils and the neurodiverse.
We know dyslexia is one of the most common forms of learning difficulties and learning differences yet under the current system support is inconsistent or non existent or simply depends on an overstretched classroom teacher that may not have received specialist training. It is my hope that this white paper will be a vehicle for the development of a national dyslexia strategy and I have confidence that this government will take this into consideration alongside all their other excellent work that they are doing to improve the education outcomes and the life chances of those with SEND.
Speaker 4
Madam deputy speaker, now I'm sure the minister is probably sick of me banging on about the local picture up in the East Riding Of Yorkshire and the fact that we are the lowest funded local authority for SEND, roughly around £1,000 per pupil per year versus Camden at the other end of the league table. The prime minister's constituency, £3,800 per pupil. That discrepancy, that inequality, it's it's simply I mean, it's it's insane, frankly. It's a historic problem. It's a funding formula.
It doesn't work for local rural authorities for larger rural authorities. It is something that members across the house have campaigned on for many years. I know that it is one of those almost too difficult to do problems that ministers have perhaps shied away from on on on on both both our side and indeed on the labor side as well. And I do ask her this opportunity, this unique opportunity to grasp it, that we are now consulting on this, and I do welcome the opportunity to meet with her next week alongside my right of all friends, the members for Beverly and Holderness and, Goole and Pocklington. And hopefully, we can find a way forward.
Because I think some of the highlights the the issue's already been highlighted,
Speaker 4
thank my honorable friend member Farrand Borden for this opportunity to debate this today. I just want to take in the limited time I've got just to highlight a few of these particular problems that the system is throwing up. Firstly with EHCP drafting, if you can of course get an EHCP in a timely manner in the first place. Often what we're seeing is vague recognition of need, which means that actually delivery on that need and the action plan is therefore very unenforceable in a legal perspective. It's something that needs to be addressed going forward.
The routine breaches of timelines are simply outrageous. People waiting four years for an autism diagnosis. As a parent of a child with SEND, was extremely lucky that nursery that my son was at recognised his developmental issues at age two and were very supportive in the process that we then went on. However, I then became aware of how adversarial the process can become when you start to engage in that local authority provision situation. I found out on a Friday at 03:30 by an email that my son would not be able to receive the school placing that perhaps at that point was most suitable for him.
It did say that I was able to appeal that decision, but it gave me no reasons as to why the decision had been made. Of course, 03:30 was when they were finished for the weekend on a Friday. No option to go back. Obviously it's that kind of thing. Simple things within the system that we can address and should be addressing to ensure the journey for parents is less challenging and more easy.
Because the more we get the children into the right settings, the better that will be for them. Fewer will lose time in education, and actually the long term problems that lead to further issues in adulthood can be avoided. We do not find a child heading into a journey of never ending care.
Speaker 19
I entirely support the point he's making, and I think the idea that anyone on this side is wholly endorsing the current system, let's be frank, would be false in doing so. But the concerns that I have, and I think he's expressing, is that the current proposals under the white paper means that if, unfortunately, he has to go through through to a tribunal system, currently, that tribunal can allocate a specific provision, that that that the parents and child can can go. Under the current proposals, they wouldn't that tribunal wouldn't be able to allocate a specific provision, which essentially renders the whole thing null and void. Yep. So does he agree with me that what we're not what we're asking for the government is to rip out what they're doing, but to listen to the concerns that parents are making about their changes and tweet them so that they can be responsive to the problems that he's raising?
Speaker 4
And it's about that journey because one of the problems, of course, for the children involved is that their journey is uncertain. And the system becomes inflexible. The reviews are not done in a timely fashion, which means a child gets stuck in a placement that may not be right, and that exacerbates the problem going forward. So we end up with these much bigger, more costly issues, not just costly in terms of local authority or central government spending, but costly, of course, for the parents and for those children. And that is one of the most challenging things I think as a parent, is not knowing where that journey is going to go.
Not knowing what my son's outlook is likely to be in two years, in five years, in ten years, but if I had the confidence the system would be there to support and provide the necessary safeguard around that schooling provision, maybe that provision into adulthood required, then I think we could start to break down some of these challenges and the barriers we've got at the moment. I appreciate that a lot of this comes with costs and local authorities do need more provision in certain areas, and I would plead once again to ensure that inequality in the funding gap is addressed. But I hope that this provides us with an opportunity to find a better way forward with SEND provision.
Speaker 128
Deputy speaker, and I stand as someone's received, as I think many of my colleagues have, many, many emails and messages and had many conversations with parents of disabled children. And I know that everywhere across the country these parents are fighting battles to get children basic support that the law says they should already have. And this is the profoundly damaged system that this government is determined to change and I welcome that hugely. In my view, the school's white paper represents the most important attempt to improve life for disabled children, young people and their families since the introduction of EHTPs in 2014, and before that since the last Labour government's Aiming High for Disabled Children program in 2007. And I shall perhaps declare an interest here.
I campaigned with Contact a Family and Main Cap and the Council of Disabled Children to build the political case for disabled children in the mid two thousands that led to aiming high and secured nearly £1,000,000,000 in new funding plus new rights for disabled children and people and their families.
Speaker 56
Briefly, will you join me in welcoming the £4,800,000 of extra investment that this government has put in to support SEND adaptations in Bolton, but also the recognition that came from parents at my SEND roundtable last week that it can't just be about extra investment into the system, but this reform is now long overdue.
Speaker 128
Thank you. I guess my honorable friend makes an excellent point, I'm very glad his local area has received that investment. Indeed, in the two boroughs of my constituency, Chelsea and Fulham, they're going to be getting a 10% increase in SEND funding for next year to support new dedicated SEND spaces in every secondary school. And this sort of thing is happening across the country, and it's absolutely right that it should. These are real commitments seriously made.
The 4,800,000.0 from four nearly £4,000,000,000 for school improvements and new therapists and specialists and better teacher training. The new individual support plans for every child with SEND, the ECP and tribunal rights being retained for those with the complex needs, all seriously made commitments, I welcome them. But I have to say questions do nonetheless remain. Some have been raised, and I have therefore three questions, just three questions for the minister. The first relates to enforceability.
And if a school fails to deliver what's written in a child's individual support plan, I do think parents need a clear legal route to resolution.
Speaker 34
I'm very in giving way. I recently hosted an open meeting with parents on these reforms. And whilst there was widespread, welcoming of of meant much of what was in the white paper, certainly an absolute urging that real sustained change happened. One concern was around the enforceability and the accountability for those ISPs and what would happen if a school was not delivering what was, needed to support a child and where that accountability would fall?
Speaker 128
My my understanding is very good points, I think that there's been talk about a beefed up school complaints process doing the work there. I don't think that's going to be sufficient, and I'd ask the minister to consider extending the remit of the local government and social care ombudsman in this respect to provide a binding route, statutory backstop, to resolution when schools and other settings fall short. The second question I have is around health and social care coordination. This is where the white paper is perhaps most silent and also where the current system is most visibly broken. As we mentioned, the health and social care committee of which I'm a member recently examined how the health aspects of EHGPs are being delivered and the result was depressing.
One of the biggest problems is that ICBs and local authorities simply don't jointly commission children's therapy services. Of course, back in 2014, a truly joined up education health care plan was exactly the ambition that was being strived towards, but health never fully showed up and the then government allowed them for years to get away with that. So what we have to do now is we have to tackle that. And witnesses to our committee urged that local authorities be mandated to have represent that the government mandate local authorities have representation on ICB decision making boards. Will the minister be prepared to give this serious consideration?
Speaker 13
Finally, madam deputy speaker, children will send spend most of their lives outside the classroom, of course, cared for by parents who in turn receive remarkably little support. So will the minister commit to a clear published expectation that health and social care will provide these families with the information, guidance, and practical support that they need? Madam deputy speaker, this white paper shows a government that understands the system is broken and is prepared to invest. And success is going to depend on many things, and including as I've raised today whether health finally shows up, whether ISPs are properly enforced, and whether families get the support, the own support that they need. I have every confidence this government is gonna carry on doing the right thing, and I look forward to improving the lives of disabled children, young people, and their families.
Speaker 91
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And can I thank the honorable member for parliament warden for calling this important debate? Like him, my inbox has overflowed since being elected last year with concerned parents writing to me about the state of special educational needs provision. Recognize that the system is broken, but they also recognize that the system that they experience in Surrey is perhaps more broken than almost anywhere else. To start off with one bit of good news and some acknowledgement of the department, I would like to thank the department for confirming funding for the new Frimley Oak Academy that's going to be opening in my constituency in the near future that will cater to a 170 people.
So it it it represents a really important step forward in addressing some vital local need in education, for children with special educational needs. But the sad reality is that for too long, so many parents and children in my constituency have been failed, and I'm sorry to say, by Surrey County Council. Surrey has the highest recorded number of send tribunal appeals anywhere in the country for the last three consecutive years. That is a a statistic that's a symptom of systemic dysfunction and failure. And behind every one of those appeals, there are human stories.
One constituent of mine recently wrote to me, and her opening words were simply, our life is crumbling right now. Others described their children being stripped of their childhood, families being physically and mentally broken, and their finances being pushed to the brink. At one recent constituency surgery that I held, a parent came to me and described the process of navigating the SENSE system like walking the yellow brick road with every trial and tribulation thrown in your way, and then finally getting to the Emerald City of something that might represent something a little bit better, only to pull back the curtain and find that there's nothing there, An EHCP with the wrong name describing the wrong child offering the an inappropriate package of support. And sitting at the top of all of this in Surrey, senior leaders who say there's no problem with special educational needs in Surrey at all. There's just parents who are too articulate Outrageous.
Claiming outrageously that there's not a problem. There are just parents who have too inflated an idea of their children's wants. It's absolutely atrocious.
Speaker 81
thank my friend for Surrey Heath, for giving away. Him and I and other colleagues in Surrey have campaigned hard to change Surrey County Council's appalling approach to children's special education means. Does he agree with me that local government reorganization is a huge opportunity for us to change that culture and what he urged the minister to ensure that all new local authorities that established put children first.
Speaker 30
grateful to my honorable, friends, Intervention, and I agree there is an opportunity here with local government reorganization to try and get some of these processes right, but I also recognize there are enormous risks, again, in Surrey, where this new this new unitary authority is likely to start its life with £4,000,000,000 worth of debt and a £150,000,000 per year annual shortfall in terms of its operational budget. This could be a council that is in special economic measures, section one one four, from the moment of its creation. And given the level of need that I see represented in my inbox, and I think other honorable and right honorable members will will will feel the same thing across Surrey, I'm incredibly concerned that more parents, and more generations of children are going to be let down. So whilst I the minister and the government for what I think is the correct intention of travel with their plans, I'm also incredibly concerned that perhaps there aren't the necessary financial foundations in place to ensure that children are properly looked after. Because ultimately, debate comes down to one simple question, and that is will these send reforms that the government is proposing deliver meaningful change or simply repackage a system that continues to fail families?
Speaker 91
Judging by the state of my inbox, we cannot allow any more families to be failed.
Speaker 16
I would like to thank the member for Farnam and Borden for securing this debate. As the motion states, it is vital that parliament continues to hold a spotlight on the Sen system as the government works to bring about the necessary reforms. And necessary is the right word as the system the Labour Government inherited is not working for families, children, local authorities, health service or teaching professionals. The last Government left the system close to breaking point, and it is this Labour Government who are rebuilding a system that works. In Lancashire, the Government has increased the high needs block allocation to £223,000,000 in twenty sixtwenty seven, which will be a 56% increase compared to the allocation they had in twenty eighteennineteen.
Speaker 51
They've also committed an extra £19,000,000 toward capital investment last year, with £23,000,000 coming in this year, an uplift of an extra £4,000,000 to support the capital costs. Like councils across the country, they are benefitting from 90 per cent of their send deficit being written off. However, my constituents in Heimbourn are still facing a lengthy wait for an EHC to be finalised. Lancashire County Council have only issued 17.3 per cent of their plans within the twenty week requirement, I'm interested in the minister's plans to improve the accountability for local authorities. I am losing count of the number of families I've had in tears in my surgeries, due to the failures of our county council, currently led by reform, in making sure that we meet the needs of our children when they need it, and provide the certainty for parents of how they get the education that they all deserve.
Speaker 16
Whilst parents and carers are desperate for a system that works with them and not against them, as we've heard in a number of members' contributions this evening, how we do the reform is as important as the reform itself. That is why I called for the Government to ensure that they put the voices and views of parents, carers and young people at the heart of their reforms. It is undoubtedly evident that they strengthened the plans and helped shape the Government's approach positively, through the time that the Government took to try and get this right. Many of my constituents found this engagement refreshing and helpful. I was delighted specifically to welcome the Schools Minister to Hasnington Academy, where we had a great morning with young people and the head teacher there.
I'm delighted that the Government's ambitious roadmap for change recognises that the reforms can't be piecemeal. It addresses the system as a whole. We don't have time to outline the many facets and focuses that the white paper outlines, I believe that this white paper starts to provide a roadmap for how we can deliver the change for every child, wherever they live, in order to end the postcode lottery that currently exist in. A more consistent, earlier, clearer and fairer system is within reach. We need to be ambitious for our children, delivering expert cent provision in every mainstream school, where no child is left behind.
Speaker 12
When addressing this subject I think of the sixteen years of surgeries I've had where parents have come in to explain their profound dissatisfaction with the way that the evaluation of their child's needs has been conducted. One of the most powerful examples was a constituent who came to me and said that their son has complex SEND needs including autism, ADHD, sensory processing disorder, demand avoidance, SEMH and severe anxiety and school trauma. They went on to tell me that for the last eight years there had been a series of failings in terms of dealing with their situation inadequate and inaccurate EHCPs school placements and support failures and then went on to tell me the enormous impact it had on their family. Now I honestly believe everyone in this place wants to get to the right improvements to this broken system. The system?
I'm very happy to
Speaker 4
much for giving way. Two of my constituents, Tom and Emily, they're brother and sister, they got their EHCP's after tribunal fairly early because their parents were so robust. They then only got the suitable schools after tribunal because their parents were so robust against the will of the local authority. Does he agree with me that any reforms to this process must be enforceable?
Speaker 12
but I want to address the key point that I think we've all got to acknowledge. Between 2014 and 2023 there was a 140% expansion in the number of EHCPs to well over half a million. And in generating that volume of demand we have to be honest on all sides of this house about whether given the budgets we have or whoever's in government can actually provide solutions that meet the needs of every individual child. And we're all trying to make the case that whether it's EHCPs give us the legal backstop or whether we move to an ISP and a school based solution that it will achieve that. What I want us to recognize is that in defining needs so much more broadly, we have created such a demand and expectation of the state, we have got to be real about what we can and what we can't provide.
And this is very delicate territory because we're always concerned that we're gonna be accused of denying the needs exist. But what concerns me is that we're going to set expectations that the school is gonna set up an individual definition of of provision, and it will not be met in exactly the same way that we've seen the challenges of the last decade. There is a central tension in this white paper that as we move from a rights based system of statutory entitlements to a resource led system that it will automatically improve. It seems to me the concern that I see exists amongst the representatives of those with unmet send provision and the charities is that there will be an enforceability gap having set expectations in our country that EHCPs are legally enforceable. So with these new proposals of ISPs, while parents might have the right to a plan they will not have the legal right to the provision it contains.
And if we standardize things over individual needs and we move to a situation where we have nationally determined fixed packages of support we risk just getting into exactly the situation that we've got to in recent years. So I I will give way.
Speaker 4
Thank him once more for giving way. He's treading this, compassionate tightrope very, very delicately. I have an organization in my constituency called Children Lead the Way, and they take children who are struggling in the traditional setting outdoors, and there have been examples where some of those children have later been able to go back into the school system. So rather than sort of under diagnosing, which I think might be the end result here if we're not careful, would you be willing to accept that it's possible that some children who are taken out of settings may later be reintroduced if we reconsider the settings?
Speaker 12
Of course I do. This is where the problem is, that if we have a move towards a standardised provision that's driven by central government or a latest orthodoxy we risk missing flexibility that should exist and needs to exist on an individual basis. But the core point that I'm still uncomfortable about is that in a situation where in twenty four-twenty five parents won ninety five-ninety nine percent of tribunal cases it appears that the system has defined needs that exist that we cannot provide. So we need to level with the country and with parents and say well what can we provide and what are we actually really not able to provide? Rather than I won't have any more time so I won't So let's not peddle a dishonesty in saying that we are going to deliver a perfect system because frankly, you know, I think we've got to the point where we need to look at the definitional parameters and get to a more honest conversation about how we're gonna actually deal with this problem.
Speaker 19
Madam deputy speaker, and I declare my normal interest that my wife's a special needs coordinator in our local authority in Londonburgh, Bexley, and one of her children is in receipt of an EHCP. Now I've known this journey. I know those like some other members in this chamber of being a parent in that position that you find yourself in. And I know as the parent of twins, and I've said this before, that I've had a battle for every single aspect of one of my children's education and none of my other child's education. Now what we've heard today is lots of criticism about what may be coming and lots of criticism about the current system, but let's be frank, the current system is totally enough to be broken.
Yeah. And and what I the reasons why I do support the proposals is there are issues there which we can put right. Experts at hand, the health aspects, and I hear what my honorable friend from Chelsea says, there are things we still need to get right there, but with experts at hand, the health aspects currently, in my local authority, when you end up as we did three years ago with an officer judgment of systemic failings in our SEND system, there was no way of holding our local NHS provision to account on those matters. And we've got to get that right and those experts at hand in that early intervention, there are things there you can do. On the individual support plans, why on earth are we making young people wait a year or two until their eHCP is updated, particularly for some young people who don't have the complexity that my daughter has, where you could get that early intervention much quicker and that support provided at a much earlier stage?
And on this issue about standardised provision, what I would say is of course, you know I'll mention my good friend, my roommate of a parent, your daughter's needs are very different to my daughter's needs. But what I would say within that is we do need to look at where some people need to be there in mainstream, some people need to be there in special school. But why do we wonder why one in eight young people are NEETs and and why we have had the debate we've had over welfare when we isolate so many young people and then and then question why they're not available and ready to work. So the minister knows I have three issues which I think we can get right, but where I still have concerns about transition, about getting those health aspects right, and about some support for professionals.
Speaker 42
Thank you. Thank you for giving away. Residents in Dartford who I had a roundtable wheel on the white paper last week, whilst welcoming the greater focus of schools to provide quicker and more flexible support, are nervous about the level of resourcing that are gonna be available to schools. They're also worried about the accountability of schools to parents through a new complaints procedure, and they're worried about the perceived loss of rights for families compared to the current system. Does the the honorable member agree those are things that we do need reassurance from the government about?
Speaker 19
I absolutely agree with my honorable friend, who literally is my neighbor in my neighboring seat in Dartford, about those issues. But we can get that right. I do genuinely believe that. I do genuinely thank the minister for the engagement she's had with the sector, with with backbenchers like myself through this process, that we can get that right through both the consultation and the legislative changes. But we need to accept, as I've said, we are dealing with a system which is totally broken.
I, like my friend, held my own consultation. I won't go into detail with it, but I heard long and hard from those parents. But when you've been through what my borough's been through, that offset judgment, that safety valve, which was a ticking time bomb on so many of our families and their provision. And what I've seen, both as a councillor, was a councillor twenty years in my patch in unibarbexy, so I saw the system change fundamentally. If a family like mine, where I was leading the opposition from the council, and my wife was actually employed by the authorities of Senco, couldn't get through the system, how on earth can any parent get through the system?
And that is why I do support these changes, Getting the early intervention right. We wonder why the loss of Sure Star and those changes that happened in those long fourteen years have inherited the system we have today Yeah. For children with disability and special educational needs. So I thank the minister. I will continue to challenge her, but I do support these changes.
Speaker 94
Yeah. Interventions just don't allow other colleagues to speak. Chris Coughlin.
Speaker 24
Just quickly on the honorable member of Saul's rehab. Enormous respect for, but your underlying argument is flawed because of the same number of senchildren now as there were in 2010 as in 1978. The question is why did they fall so much to 2016 and rise? Which I would suggest the answer probably has something to do with scrapping of Sure Start by my party and his, but that's for another day. Madam deputy speaker, one month ago, a SEN dad messaged me on Facebook about his autistic son, who'd been out of school for seven years.
His tribunal delayed three times. He said that his son will now be out of education and employment for the rest of his life, and he said, and I quote, that he had been left to rot, his son had been left to rot by his local authority and the NHS. I wrote to him to say how sorry I was, suggested how he could get help and put him in touch with his MP, but then two weeks ago, he wrote to me. My son is very unwell, and I can no longer carry on. I'm mentally and physically exhausted, and I'm electing to end my life.
I intend to find peace. I simply can't continue, and I refuse to see my son deteriorate further. There'll be no one to care for him, so now the NHS will have to care for my son. We called 999 immediately, and emergency services sent an ambulance. We've seen too many families like this.
Speaker 35
I presented to the government and published in the Times evidence that hundreds of SEND children are avoidably killing themselves due to public authority negligence. ITV has published evidence of misconduct and law breaking on SEND by a 117 local authorities. I believe the government is serious about SEND reform, and I am grateful to the minister of coming to Dawkins tomorrow to meet Surrey SEND families. The family after family has testified to me that the legal rights the government is seeking to reduce can be the difference between life and death. When a council officer determines that a child does not need an EHCP, when they know that that child does in fact need an EHCP, that is serious misconduct.
Speaker 24
Misconduct. We know this is happening at a massive scale because families win the resulting tribunals 98% of the time. The councils are betting that the families that they can save money because the families are too exhausted to take them to tribunal. Children are killing themselves as a result. Under resourcing is no excuse.
When a council officer denies sorry. An under resourced council officer
Speaker 83
He talks about under resourcing, and I would like to highlight a situation at West Sussex County Council, where the department just put an answer phone message on their system saying we are overwhelmed, we cannot take any calls today. Does he agree with me that the parents that are navigating that system, that often describe it as a fight, do not have the opportunity to put their phone on answer phone or not show up for their kids that day because they are overwhelmed. Does he agree with me that we need to do far more for those parents?
Speaker 24
I entirely agree with my Honourable Friend because an unresourced officer can still determine the need, can still issue an EHCP and be transparent about what cannot yet be delivered. That, at least, is honest. Now, I know that many council officers do the right thing. When an outs council officer commits misconduct that results in an avoidable death, why are they not criminally prosecuted? So here we are.
Pervasive local authority law breaking, hundreds of children avoidably killing themselves, a government that plans to cut the rights that can save their lives. The public will be asking members of parliament about this scandal. What did they know?
Speaker 12
Moving and powerful speech but isn't the reality that if every single EHCP was properly diagnosed and the need was expressed it would impose an honest but unachievable burden on the state. Will he acknowledge that and address how we come to terms with that?
Speaker 24
I thank the Honourable Member for his intervention and I completely disagree. Obviously. You think about the autistic boy that I was talking about at the start of my speech. So he's been out of school for seven years. His father has quit his job to look after him.
That's even before he costs it. Father's quit his job to look after him. And you've lost a lifetime's earnings from that person. You've got the cost of social services. By the time you add that rule into account, compared to if you have an effective system based on effective early intervention, rigorous accountability on local authorities, legally enforceable rights, I'm convinced it will actually no longer be far cheaper than what we have today.
And the public will be asking members of this house what do they know about this scandal of hundreds of children avoidably killing themselves while there's myths about overdiagnosis and everything else going out there. What do they know? When do they know? And what do they do about it?
Speaker 83
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. Central vision is a fraught and highly emotional issue as we've heard because of the stakes at play, education, inclusion, and above all, dignity. I'm pleased to see so many colleagues here today from across the house with only a couple of exceptions from some parties. Like others, I want to share the experiences of my constituents. A few months ago, I met with the senior leadership team at KELT, the organization that runs the majority of the primary and secondary schools in my constituency.
And to their credit, they acknowledged they've not always got things right, particularly in the wake of the pandemic. But they were candid about why, and that's without an EHCP, they simply do not have the funding to support many of the children who need it the most. And demand for EHCP's is incredibly high. Cornwall Council receives over a 100 requests every single month. Yet in 2024, Cornwall was also ranked as the second worst local authority in the entire country for issuing EHCPs within the twenty week required time frame.
The causes are clear. A shortage of educational psychologists, the complexity of multi agency coordination, and a system overwhelmed by this demand. The consequences for children in my constituency have been devastating, and I want to name some of them. One of my constituents has an adopted daughter with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder. Her school submitted a referral for an EHCP in March 2024.
The council rejected it. Her father fought back through appeals, through a tribunal, and the council eventually conceded an all too common farce, as we've heard. And they still failed at the end of this to produce a completed plan until 2026. That is two years of a daughter's education lost. Another constituent has been waiting since August 2025 for the outcome of his daughter's educational psychologist assessment.
They are still waiting. His daughter remains without suitable provision. A third constituent's son hasn't had appropriate education for a significant period of time. His school cannot meet his needs. He is not attending.
Speaker 64
His family are waiting for an EHCP. Three families, three children, all failed by a system that was supposed to protect them. The government's white paper promises a £1,800,000,000 investment in specialist support, including educational psychologists and commits to training over 200 more psychologists per year from 2026, putting mental health support in every school, reducing the post code lottery, and the attainment gap. I welcome that ambition, but I say to ministers, the consultation closes on the May 18. Families cannot wait until 2029 for legislative change.
Speaker 89
of the things that shocked me most when I got elected was how much we are failing children with special needs. We all get the emails in our inbox that are absolutely heartrending, and when you meet those parents you can see the stress and the strain etched in their faces, and you can only imagine what it's like for the child to be in a school where they feel they're not understood and they're not supported. It is really shocking how we are treating these people at the moment. So I really welcome that the government is trying to do something to change this and make it better. I worry though that we need to make sure there are the resources there to deliver what these families deserve.
Speaker 6
Obviously that's money, but it's also the educational psychologists, other expertise that we need, having all the staff at the school properly trained so they know how to deal with the various needs of the children in their school at that time. And I also worry that parents cannot, cannot, must not lose the ability to take action to fight for their children's rights.
Speaker 48
thank my honourable friend for giving way and does she agree that strengthening inclusion in mainstream schools and maintaining legally enforceable protections for children and young people should not be competing games?
Speaker 6
I agree, we mustn't set things up in competition. So I would like to ask the minister three particular questions. One, what are you going to do to make sure that every area really has the specialist resources? Sorry, what what is the minister going to do to make sure that every every school in the area has the resources they need to deliver for for their children? How are you going to help make sure that rural areas like mine in Ely and East Cambridgeshire have access to these resources for all the schools and all the children?
Because it does take longer, it therefore does cost more to get those across the area. And what are you going to put in place to make sure that parents really retain the rights to fight and enforce for their children's rights?
Speaker 94
that the the member's gonna speak very briefly. Interventions aren't helping other members in the chamber. Alex McIntyre.
Speaker 95
Madam deputy speaker, for too long parents and carers in Gloucester have had to fight a broken system that was not delivering the best chance in life for their children. This government inherited a SEND system that did not include parents and carers in the conversation, that did not value their children, and led to a complete breakdown of trust between families and the system that was meant to support them. And I'm pleased that this government has made fixing this system a top priority. As Glossus MP, I've always believed that every child in my city deserves the best start in life, and I hope that these reforms will restore trust in the system and ensure that every child of gets the support they deserve. Madam deputy speaker, when I talk to constituents about SEND, they often make the same reflection.
Speaker 129
The previous government never listened to them. They didn't include them in those discussions, and they didn't take them seriously. And I know that ministers have been really clear these reforms had to be done with parents and carers and families, and I'm really pleased to see they've made good on that promise and continue to do so. And I hope they continue that approach through the latest consultation. And in my city of Gloucester, I have been listening to parents and carers too.
I've met with dozens of parents in my surgeries. I ran a community consultation for families to say what they wanted to see in the white paper, and I hosted a brilliant parent and carers roundtable in the city center. And from this, I was pleased to produce my Send in Gloucester report, which I presented to the minister earlier this year. In that report, residents made several recommendations. A really important one was about more support early on.
Parents and carers felt that they often spotted the signs of additional need early, but it took years for any formal support to be introduced. And often the support would only come at a crisis point when early intervention could have prevented the crisis in the first place. I also visited Dignity's Promise Early Years Centre in Coney Hill, which shows the benefits of early intervention and the importance of targeted support at an early years level. And I was pleased to see the government listened to the recommendations of Gloucester residents on early intervention by putting more money into early years as part of these reforms. Madam Speaker, another key takeaway from the report was a lack of funding and capacity for school Sencos.
Parents and carers repeatedly highlighted that many Sencos are working tirelessly, but are fighting that broken system. They felt that making Sencos full time, providing high levels of specialist training, and giving them a more senior role in schools can have a big impact. If there's one ask I can make for the ministers today, it'd be whether they can consider extending this government's commitment to providing the best possible school experience for children with Sen by providing for a full time fully qualified Senko in every Gloucester school. Finally, spoke with many residents since these reforms have been announced. While the reaction has been mostly positive, I know that the concerns remain in communities across my city, particularly those families whose children are receiving an EOTUS package.
I understand that, and I'll continue to raise their voices with ministers, and I hope she may be able to give some reassurance today. But I want to again underline the importance of this moment. We must give our schools and our teachers the resources they need to deliver our children. We must rebuild trust with families who've been so badly let down in the past, and we must get these reforms right so that every child with SEND can have the best chance in life.
Speaker 13
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I congratulate the member for the Farm and Board on securing this debate? We've heard in terms of demand, we've heard a number of varying views. Some people saying that demand hasn't gone up at all, and others saying it has. I have relied on the House of Commons Library to tell me that since 2015 demand for EHCP has ballooned by 140% and that in 2025, 13 there were 13 times more people waiting for an autism assessment than there were in 2019.
Speaker 41
Honorable members across the house have described very effectively, so I won't replay the tape, this extraordinary diagnosis of a system that has not been able to meet demand. And the ninety eight percent tribunal success rate is symptomatic of that. And it is pretty shocking. It shows a system which is having to be fought against systemically, and it's deeply worrying. Honorable members from across the House have been replaying their own case studies and inboxes and I haven't got time to go into child Y and child L and child F and child D and so many others, all of whom have finally come to their Member of Parliament because they have seen no way through and the computer has said no.
Speaker 13
And it has taken that and that shouldn't be the case. I do just want in the time remaining to take a strategic approach and look upstream Because in March, the Secretary of State for Health said that he was sold on the idea that over diagnosis was the root cause of mental health illness. On the June 1 I asked the Secretary of State for Education whether there was any work being done between her department and the health department on what was causing increased demand for special educational needs children. And she gave me she said she was very concerned about it. Very concerned indeed.
I then waited until the December 1 and said, so what did you and the health secretary do in the intervening seven months? And I think it was the minister who kindly said that she was very concerned about it. And five days later, the health secretary announced that there was going to be a six month study into the causes of the increase in demand for special educational needs, and that will report in the summer. So I don't think anyone is covering themselves in glory here. And but I do think that we do need, as a nation, to get increase our understanding of this phenomenon that we are experiencing in order
Speaker 130
deputy speaker. I'd like to declare an interest as a member of the SEND APPG and also a parent of a child with an EHCP and to congratulate the member for Farnam and Bordham for securing this debate today. This is a deeply important and one I am like many members across this house. My inbox is full of SDND parents who struggle under the current system and let's be clear it is absolutely broken. And there's been quite a lot of discussion today about whether or not this current system or indeed our society as a whole has the ability to meet all presenting needs.
And I'd just like to clarify something. Unmet need does not magically disappear. It doesn't just go away. What it does is it festers and it grows, which is what we see under this current system. We see children's needs not met at the earliest opportunity.
We only see them being met when they reach an absolute crisis point. By and large that is what happens. And what we end up with is a system that ultimately lets down children. And I want to say the need for SCND reform and the work that the minister has undertaken on the white paper speaks to the heart, I think, of who we are on these benches as a party. Equitable and equal education for everyone goes to the heart of socialist progressive politics, and that is who we are.
And it's absolutely crucial that just because a child is disabled or has an additional needs, that they are not excluded from education on the same basis as their able-bodied peers. It's completely unacceptable if they continue to be so. The system we have at the moment is antagonistic, it is adversarial, it puts fight and struggle at the heart of what should be just the norm for every parent which is attaining a decent education for their children. But I would like to speak to some of the concerns. I noticed I have a very short amount of time left around the white paper because some do remain.
There needs to be accountability in the system. If it is going to work, parents, schools and councils have to trust that the system will work. Accountability, understanding if my child's school hypothetically and realistically do not do what they are supposed to do, how do I make them do it? What is the recourse that I have to make sure they do so? Other huge
Speaker 12
Extremely grateful. She deal with the challenge of if we are now in a more sophisticated understanding of an individual's need and the provision of meeting that need has reached a cost and a breadth across society such that the actual needs meet are so significant, how do we provide for that given the finite budgets that exist?
Speaker 130
How you provide for it is by meeting need at the earliest opportunity, is addressing it reaching crisis point, is addressing it getting to the situation we are in now. You wouldn't do this in any other situation. You wouldn't say, hey, there's too many people out there with cancer. We should stop diagnosing cancer. It wouldn't work like that.
Speaker 26
You don't turn around and say, hey, there's too many people that are presenting the need. You meet it. And if we look at this as we do with all just for a second imagine that a typical parent we address the education system as a whole as we address SEND education as a problem to be solved and not an opportunity that exists to create young people that are willing, equipped and able to go out into the world and to shape our future society and indeed our place on a global scale as well. So why do we not look at that for SEND children as we do for the wider school population? I do.
Speaker 17
Honourable Lady for giving way. Does she agree with me that there's also so much untapped potential in the parents that are currently trapped at home trying to support their children that are not being supported into schools? When I hosted a recent roundtable with parents in my constituency I had ex teachers, teaching assistants, an educational psychologist and none of them are at work because they're not being supported.
Speaker 130
I agree with that 100%. Know if you can do a lifetime cost of a parent being out of work to care for their child who should be in education or who should be in a suitable school. Even a parent having to you know draw back from working a certain amount of hours or reaching where they could be able to go in their career because of the stress that it puts on them. And that does lead to some of the concerns that I have in the white paper. This has to work.
I think we I want to start from that basis. This white paper has to work for families like mine, for people that are struggling, that see the current system is failing for them, it has to work. And it is in danger of not working on a few points. Number one is trust, which I mentioned. The second one is workforce.
Now this cannot be solved by the Department for Education on its own. A real crucial part of that workforce comes from the Department for Health and Social Care. The Secretary of State for Health must publish a statement as to how he is going to deliver the SEND workforce, particularly the paediatric paediatric allied health care workforce. Otherwise this plan, I'm really sorry to say, really will struggle to get off the ground. Finally, if there is something in this plan that can be brought to change the current system for how it works and the stress and strain it puts on parents is to support parents.
Quite often parents feel like they're under attack. If your child receives a diagnosis of SEND and you know you feel like your parenting method, who you are and the benefits that you bring to your family is constantly questioned and you don't know where to go for support. If we can support parents to care for their to implement the same intervention measures at home as well as giving them the ite that they need, support to know that they're not alone and to actually be able to properly support their child through education then this white paper can truly deliver on the promise that it holds.
Speaker 100
You madam speaker. I'm grateful for the opportunity to speak in this profoundly important debate which I thank the honourable member for Farnam and Borden for securing. As with all members across this house this is one of the most common and most urgent issues raised by struggling families in overstretched schools within Dewsbury and Backley, this cannot be allowed to continue. We all agree that the system is broken and needs to be improved, And I welcome the fact that the government has recognized the scale of the crisis and is attempting to bring forward wide ranging reform. But good intentions must be matched by good policy.
Consequently there are a number of concerns that I believe must be addressed with urgency if these reforms are to succeed. Firstly on consultation we've been told by the government that its new framework is being shaped in partnership with families schools and other stakeholders but serious questions remain about the adequacy and scope of that consultation. Recent reports show that members have been effectively guided by the Department of Education on how they should respond to the consultation risk fatally undermining confidence in the process. Consultation must be genuine and transparent. Secondly on implementation it is concerning that local authorities are already being instructed to begin reforming their systems by developing local plans and reshaping provision before the consultation has even concluded.
Speaker 124
That risks creating confusion inconsistency and instability in a system that is already under immense strain and it risks the perception of treating public consultation and the consent for vital policy proposals as an afterthought rather than being central to policy making process itself. Thirdly on capacity ambitious reforms require the workforce to deliver them. We need clarity on how many trained professionals will be required how initiatives such as the proposed experts at hand service will be staffed and how training for teachers will be delivered. Without that detail we run the risk that expectations will outstrip reality. And finally on accountability, any changes to tribunal arrangements must not weaken the ability of families to challenge decisions not least because they have been so successful in appealing these decisions and we've heard about the 99% figure.
Speaker 100
For many parents the tribunal system is not an optional preference but a safeguard of last resort that must be preserved. So my ask to the minister are these: Will the government ensure that the ongoing consultation genuinely reflects the voices of families, schools, and experts? Will it provide clarity on work force training and funding? Will it protect the rights of families to challenge decisions and will it ensure that reforms are implemented in a way that is transparent evidence led properly resourced with built in accountability? Because if we get this transform the lives for better.
But if we get it wrong, it is the children and their futures who will bear the cost for years to come.
Speaker 36
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. We know the stories. We know the concerns. We have heard the trauma and we know of the battles and the fights, of course the embedded inequality within the system, where parents with little agency have little voice. What's so important is that we recognise the 2014 Children's Families Act ultimately never came with the funding, the staffing, the resourcing that was needed as well as a culture change.
There are three things that I really want to focus on today. One is culture, second is resourcing and funding and third is governance. With regards to culture, whilst we've heard about the rising of attainment for so many children, we know that other children just never get that opportunity. Their right to an education is denied. We've got to change the pedagogy within the education system to make it an inclusive environment, but also to ensure that the high stakes behaviourist approach is ended, because that for children who are neuroatypical means that they are being denied an education.
Speaker 3
We must address this clash which is still being driven by a results based system and look at a child more holistically and about their long term future. I would encourage the minister to look at the work of Sir Ken Robinson in understanding that the system needs to be built around a child as opposed to a child fitting into the system. Also developing a nurturing environment, and in York we talk about belonging, going beyond nurturing. Need to look at how we address that security a child needs in order to thrive in any environment and to ensure that framing is put around a child, that we are integrating that with a trauma informed approach as well. We have heard about adoption today and the trauma that those children experience, but we know so many children experience adverse childhood experiences, violence and neglect in the home, and have had challenging pasts intersected with their SEND needs.
Speaker 36
We need to ensure that is put in place briefly on funding. If we can move resources in this place to fund our national security, we can move funding to secure the child's security as well. Therefore, we do need to resolve the system and to resource it not only financially, because without it this will never succeed, but also to ensure and many have made this point about having a workforce plan and integrating that with the NHS workforce plan, knowing the timing in which resources will come on stream. Thirdly, this brings me very briefly to governance. The governance of where risk responsibility sits in the system is in the wrong place.
That's why we really need to have a look at the impact of the academisation programme on where those lines of accountability are. When holding schools to account, it is virtually impossible in the system we've got. I certainly want to extend those discussions with the minister when I get the opportunity.
Speaker 94
Order, we've run out of time for backbench contributions. I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson Caroline Bowden.
Speaker 43
I thank the honourable member for Farnam And Borden for bringing this debate. It's really clear from the passionate contributions so widespread the problems are with a SEN system that is completely broken. And we've heard the all heard the anguish of parents, and we have read the dreadful stories of desperate children who have lost their lives because of failures in this system. So in that context, I want to welcome the Government's recent white paper as an important step in the right direction. We have to address the growing need, and as the member for Thorough said so passionately, we cannot limit provision because there is too much need.
The earlier we identify need and start addressing it, the better the outcomes will be for children, for parents, for families, and for society as a whole. We have had to wait for this white paper, but putting the delays to one side, we're here now, and the central focus on inclusion through improving support in mainstream settings is an approach that the Liberal Democrats welcome. If children with SEND can attend a local school, they can stay connected with their friends, be part of their local community, and their family can engage better with their school. Inclusion bases, like the one being opened King Edward the sixth Community College in my constituency, are welcome, with a focus on bringing children back into school after they dropped out following a difficult transition into year seven, and helping them become part of the school community again. And this model has a good potential to succeed if it's properly resourced.
However, many questions remain about funding children's rights and staffing. On funding, the £4,000,000,000 pledge to accompany the upcoming reforms, plus capital spending, and the council debt write off are welcome. But we are worried that the Government is holding councils to ransom, by tying this debt relief to restrictions on special school expansion. The Government must also provide clarity on where the new funding, including the Council deficit write off, is coming from. The Liberal Democrats are very concerned that other areas of the wider schools budget may be cut, even though there is nothing left to give.
And the government has introduced some good policies, has failed to fully fund them, like breakfast clubs, the expansion of free school meals, even teacher pay rises, and today, the healthy school standards. Will that be fully funded for schools? Because it will be more expensive. I won't give way because I don't have enough time. I'm sorry.
Schools and local authorities are already at breaking point and are now being asked to deliver even more, including running two SEN systems in parallel during the transition period. On parental rights, parents have expressed deep concern about changes to the tribunal system. Removing power from SEN tribunals to direct a local authority to name a specific setting will give parents even less opportunity to choose a setting that suits their child. Given that currently 99% of tribunal cases are won by families against the authority, how can we trust that local authorities will suddenly start getting it right under the new system? The Liberal Democrats are clear that stripping back parents' ability to challenge the system is unacceptable, and their anxiety is understandable.
Speaker 104
Many parents are worried their child will lose existing support or not receive the support they need under the new system. So will the minister guarantee that legal rights will not be stripped away, that settled placements won't be disrupted, and that accountability, including meaningful routes of appeal, will remain strong and effective? It is absolutely vital that children and families remain at the heart of these reforms and retain the few rights they have. On staffing, we welcome the experts at Hand Service to embed specialists like speech and language therapists and educational psychologists into mainstream schools, but we need to see a credible workforce plan to see how the government is going to recruit and train all the staff needed and encourage trained specialists back into the profession. I'm concerned though about the need for more learning support staff, staff, the people who are absolutely crucial to delivering these reforms and ensuring mainstream inclusion works effectively.
Speaker 43
Schools are being forced to cut learning support staff due to the financial pressures they are facing. And a SEND system focused on inclusion simply cannot be done without them. So I'd like to hear further detail from the minister on how the government believes schools can deliver an inclusive approach for all children without funding more support staff. Away from budgets and staffing, there are of course other changes we can make in the way we run our schools that would make them accessible for all children. Curriculum reform is vital to inclusion.
Learning how to express and process emotion through music, drama, creative arts, sport and outdoor play is vital, not just for children's mental health, but their emotional development. It simply must be given more space. So we believe the current direction of travel is the right one, but all these reforms must be fully funded, fully staffed and fully consulted with those who will be impacted most by the changes, the parents and the children with SEND who are so often not heard.
Speaker 117
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. And can I start by thanking members from across the house for what was a wide ranging and passionate debate about an issue that affects each and every one of us and many of our constituents? And I wanna start by thanking my honorable friend for Farnam and Borden for securing this important debate. He's been a passionate and determined champion for parents of children with special educational needs. I thank him for all his hard work in this area.
He was pragmatic, constructive, and he reflected what I've also heard back from many, many parents, teachers, and council leaders. I also wanna say thank you to all the people who contributed, but specifically those parents who reached out to have their voices heard today. Madam deputy speaker, this is an issue that affects each and every one of us. And while I will focus on the much delayed white paper, let me be clear to the minister. His majesty's opposition will work constructively with the government where we see meaningful progress can be made.
And I acknowledge I acknowledge the system is creaking under its own weight. Almost weekly, since I was first elected in 2019, I've met parents who are tired of fighting a system that was designed to help them, one that enshrines their rights in law, but has instead become a barrier to supporting their children. I've campaigned for for, those parents, so I want these reforms to work. But I say to the minister, we on this side of the house won't shy away from asking questions that are difficult for the government to answer, and we won't allow the government to spin their way out of this because too much is at stake. And I hope she can, work constructively with me in that spirit.
And there are a number of questions.
Speaker 77
for giving way, and of course across Quayfi and the wider Bradford District, I'm inundated with correspondence from constituents challenging the quality of EHCPs and the diagnosis procedure. One of the big concerns that I have is with the white paper reforms and it will lead to a standardized approach associated with many of those rollouts of the IPSs. And I was wondering if the shadow minister agrees me in the direction that these reforms are going in under this Labour government.
Speaker 117
Honourable friend for making that point. It's a point that's been made to me by many parents about the one size fits all approach of these reforms. And I look, I wanna give the minister an opportunity to try and reassure some of those, parents, because parents do want answers, and the children, and families that are affected do, deserve them. Now, I've spoken to many, many parents and representative groups, and there's a huge amount of anxiety about these reforms. And it's a view shared by many parent carer forums, It and wasn't helped by the delays to the white paper, nor the drip drip briefing suggesting e h c SCPs would simply be scrapped.
And let me be very clear, the conservative position is very clear. Any reforms that come forward must enshrine parental rights in law. They must not water them down. I will No.
Speaker 117
I I take your lead, madam deputy speaker. But I will say, look, I I there is very little detail around the deliverability in this white paper. It's a concern that's been raised by me, to me, whereby a number of council leaders, head teachers, and parents alike. And even the OBR, the government's own independent watchdog, explicitly says that the impact of reform on underlying cost remains uncertain. It is for the minister to provide that certainty.
They're not convinced that the reforms will close the funding gaps. And look, the government, when it was in opposition, had fourteen years to think about what they wanted to do, so I hope the minister can provide some of those answers today. The issue of timelines, was raised, today, and I agree with that. We all agree that this is urgent, but full implementation is not expected until 2829 at the earliest. Changes to EHCPs will not begin until around September 2030.
So for a family with a six year old today, that child will be 10 or 11 before they feel any difference from any reforms. For a family with a teenager, reform will never arrive in time. It was a point made by the honorable member for Saint Austell and Newquay. So can the minister tell the house, according to her analysis, how many children will have left school entirely before a single EHCP reform, takes effect? I
Speaker 121
Brandon, this is Will. One of the key issues that parents of my constituency who've been within the SENSE system are really fearful of now is that there'll be the white paper, more chain proposed, but the key element to that is in delivery is local councils. And the problem is it is so patchy. Some councils are absolutely appalling on mining, an area which had an excoriating report. Other ones manage.
Nobody's brilliant, but they try and get by. They try and do the ECHPs. So I would simply say, how are we going to tackle that patchy delivery which at the end of the day these reforms will still have to rely on?
Speaker 117
I I thank my right, hon. I think he makes a really valid point. Now I will come on to councils, and their funding, shortly, but I think he makes a really valid point. And I hope the minister heard that and will be able to answer. I've had a number of parents write to me asking to put their questions directly to the minister.
Natasha and Lindy wanted to know why there's been a dilution of parental rights proposed. Why is the government removing the legal right to appeal, especially when 98% of cases are currently won by parents and carers? And I say to the minister, the my right honorable friend for Salisbury made this point very eloquently. If the logic is to reduce the cost of provision by removing some of those rights, then the minister should say so plainly. We knew I think they need those parents need that clarity and that, level of honesty.
Look, there are some points we we welcome. We welcome the principles of support in schools, and evidence led packages, and the idea of more speech and language therapists. There there is broad consensus that earlier intervention is essential, and the statement of intent on this is most welcome. But I do want to just focus on speech and language therapists, very quickly, because I'd campaigned on this as a backbench MP with Mike Sitcher and Mike Yacchis, Chris Kamara, the famous footballer, and we met with the relevant health minister more than a year ago, and there was an explicit promise for a speech and language therapy action plan. There still hasn't been one.
And I in March 24 and and Mikey said, in March 24, I met with the minister for care, the member for Aberfan and Meister, who promised an action plan for speech and language therapy. And one year on, we still have not seen anything. So has the minister and this point's been raised about liaising with the health department. Has she spoken to health minister? And has there been any progress on that?
The Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists have been very clear. Delivering the experts at hand service will require SLT, an SLT workforce to be incorporated into the ten year workforce plan with funding ring fence. And I did ask the minister a very written question, a written question in March about how many speech and language therapists will be required to deliver experts and then she gave a great answer, I will say, but she avoided to give me the answer I needed around numbers. I hope she can answer that. So how many specialists will be needed, and where will they come from?
The question from the British Dyslexia Association was also posed to me, because one in three children in our classrooms need support for dyslexia. Can the minister confirm whether the experts at hand service will include support for children with dyslexia, and whether specialist dyslexia teachers will form part of that workforce? I wanna just turn to inclusion in mainstream, because at a meeting recent meeting with Sollyhole School leaders last month, I had serious concerns about the capacity pressures the government's approach could place on mainstream schools. There was consensus around the principles, but there was, there was also consensus that far more detail is needed on what inclusion actually means in policy terms, and how how gaps in staff training and funding will be, filled. Very briefly.
Speaker 103
honorable friend and constituency neighbour for giving way. I was in the same meeting, One of the big concerns was the loss of the special school that was planned for Tamworth Lane. Does he agree with me that not only does that detract from parents and pupils who would benefit, but it puts additional pressures on mainstream schools?
Speaker 126
I couldn't have said it better myself, and of course that's one in my borough, but the truth is there are special schools across the country that where the funding has been taken away, and it is is going to be essential because you cannot have a one size fits all. Can the minister also explain for those teachers how how mainstream schools will be supported in terms of capacity, funding, and training as these reforms are are rolled out. I want to just get to, very quickly, madam speaker, to ISPs, because, of course, as the founder of North Solihull additional needs supports group asked whether there will be a legal backing for those ISPs. It's a point that's been made by a number of, members, but of course around enforceability. And I wanna get straight to, the funding point, and that's where I'm gonna end, my remarks.
Speaker 117
The OBR at the budget, identified a £6,000,000,000 fund funding black hole. When the minister was asked about this before, she used the word scaremongering, but these were not our figures. They were figures based, from the OBR based on, what the government had provided. Can the minister now confirm how large the shortfall now is? I think having looked at numbers it's shortened, maybe she'll be able to give, a bit more clarity.
But if it that money is not provided, if the gap will funded this according to the OBR, by way, the gap will funded entirely from within the DFE's £69,000,000,000 budget, it would imply a 4.9% real fall in mainstream schools spending per pupil. And there is no spending review till 2829, so maybe, she can do, give me some clarity on that. Let me repeat. There's no new funding till 2829. Can she give clarity?
Which departments may be giving up their money, for the USEN, reforms? I hope she can provide some of the answers. Those are questions that I wasn't able to ask.
Speaker 132
Madam deputy speaker, I'm grateful for the huge interest showed across this chamber in this critically important issue. I think tonight we heard the voices of children and families, from so many different MPs, and I I really thank the efforts of of members of parliament to to listen to to children and families, to bring their voices to me personally and into the chamber. And I appreciate the member for Farnham and Borden for bringing this important debate and their long standing support for children with special educational needs and disabilities. I think we all heard the depth and strength of concern and the agreement of the system at the moment is broken and not working for so many families. I don't have much time, I'm not going to take interventions, I want to be able to answer the points that have been put to me.
Too many children left without provision, parents trying to explain to their children what it feels like to why they're not at school alongside their friends. Too many parents having to battle, and we've heard the the phrase fight time and time again in this conversation. And I say to the honorable member opposite and to to everyone in the chamber that I am really committed to working constructively and cross party on this issue. It is too important to not take all views and to to work together. I really welcome opportunities to come and to talk to individuals about issues that have been raised in this debate.
But I won't apologise for taking longer to develop these reforms, because that time was spent talking to thousands of parents, young people, teachers around the country, and to make sure that their voices were embedded in what we put out for consultation. And I also make no apology for taking time to transition into these reforms. As we heard from so many around this chamber, trust is low and it is really important we build this new system with children and families. But that doesn't mean that we are not acting now. The investment that we have been talking about is going into our communities straight away, whether that's the £3,700,000,000 that we're already starting to invest in specialist places around the country, whether
Speaker 132
the £4,000,000,000 that we're investing into the services we've talked about today experts at hand, the educational psychologists, the speech and language therapists that now be available to local schools, or whether it's the Inclusion Mainstream Fund that will be going directly into schools. These are huge investments that this government is making. And to answer directly the point about the OBR, the OBR made those projections before they'd seen our reform plans, before they'd seen these huge investments we're making, including new investment going in in 'twenty eight, 'twenty nine, as I know the honourable member will have seen. And I agree wholeheartedly with everyone who's raised the importance of early intervention, making sure that we're putting as much support in as quickly as possible. So many families have told me if support had been available much quicker, their needs would not have escalated, they wouldn't be out of education, they wouldn't have needed to leave their local schools.
And also the importance of inclusion, and I've so powerfully heard from the member from FARROC who talked about why it's so critical that children with special educational needs and disabilities are at the heart of our education system. They have so much to offer, and every school should be an inclusive school. But that doesn't mean that we don't also need special schools and that £3,700,000,000 I've talked about will be investing in new specialist places. So to take the points from the Honourable Member for Farnam And Borden, which I think the first and most important is our intention in these reforms is to improve outcomes for children. That is our guiding principle, that is our number one outcome.
The honourable member mentioned the long waiting list that so many families are exposed to. And that is the point of these reforms, putting in place educational psychologists, speech and language therapists and so many others that schools can draw down on and give children access to without a lengthy wait, a battle for an EHCP, a diagnosis, that support will be available as part of the mainstream system under our reform plans. And really critically, education health care plans will remain. And they will be available for children who need them. But we know that too many children are forced to apply to get an EHCP because their needs are not being met in mainstream schools.
And the vast majority, or the majority of children with special educational needs and disabilities in our school system don't have any HCP. They're on the SEND register, and those are the children who are often being badly let down. And our reforms will extend rights for those children, including new statutory duties on schools to develop inclusion plans, to develop individual support plans, new layers of support targeted and targeted plus new national standards, and new duties on teacher training. Honourable member Thurboxtow talked powerfully about the importance of teacher training. Every single teacher trained to support children with special educational needs and disabilities, so every class is accessible.
Speaker 99
The Honourable Member for Dulledge and West Norwood talked as ever expertly about this issue, and we are really grateful for the work of the committee and the huge amount of time they put into their report. And I wanted to address the points that she raised about transition and accountability within the transition. So, some safeguards that I think can reassure parents is that every child who is in a special school will remain in a special school, that we will build the new system before anyone transitions into that new system, and that somebody with an existing EHCP would either move on to an EHCP or to an individual support plan, and that would be backed by the tribunal. There are lots of questions about individual support plans accountability. So, Ofsted will be looking at individual support plans, will be developing a new complaints process with an independent role, and really importantly, if a family doesn't feel their needs are being met by the mainstream system, they will still be able to request a needs assessment and that will be backed by the tribunal.
Speaker 132
So there will still be that access to the tribunal and the tribunal will remain an important part of the system. But we don't want families to have to go to a tribunal. We want to deliver a system that really works, where their voices are put at the heart of decision making, and where accountability doesn't sit on the shoulders of families, but it sits on us as the DFE, as the Department for Health, as government, to hold local authorities to account. And there was a question about why are we going ahead with local send reform plans and asking councils to develop those plans? Because we are absolutely clear that councils need to deliver for children with special educational needs and disabilities today.
As we heard from this chamber, there is too much failure and we are determined to hold councils to account. We are absolutely committed to a full consultation, we welcome comments on every aspect of these proposals and I would really ask everyone in this chamber to make sure that you're holding events, talking to your constituents, pointing them towards consultation, because this is a generational opportunity to change this system. Families have been failed for too long and it's only by listening to them we will get this right.
Speaker 94
Far too many you and yours throughout speeches today. People need to check how they language they use. Gregory Stafford to wind up.
Speaker 19
Thank you very much, madam deputy speaker. And I'm sure you would agree with me that, the speeches that we've heard today have been wide ranging and, passionate. And I want to thank all those who've spoken, all those who unfortunately didn't manage to speak, but also the many members who supported this debate. I'm leading it, but plenty of members across the house supported this debate, and thanks to the backbench business committee for doing so. I think the one thing that united every speaker in this house was a clear desire to improve a system that currently is not working for young people in our constituencies.
And we may disagree about the exact process to get there, but I think, what I would say to the minister is that there was nobody in this house who was expressing anything other than what they had heard from their own constituents, and that may be, in some cases where they supported the government's proposals. But I think we have to be honest that many many of our constituents are raising the concerns that they have. And I say to the minister, do not squander the opportunity that this government has to bring all of those people who raise the concerns, and I know there are antibodies from other members of Opposite whenever I open my mouth about anything, but I am passionate. I'm passionate about this issue, and I think together we, on all sides of the house, can improve what the government is doing and ensure that the legal protections remain whilst improving the system. So I do hope that the minister is able to, one, answer a number of the many of the questions that honorable members raise across the house on this issue that she wasn't able to answer at the smashbox in writing, but two, that she comes to, assess the responses to the white paper with an open mind looking to make sure that every child has a legal right to the education that he or she deserves.
Speaker 94
Yeah. The question is, as on the order paper, as many of that opinion say aye. Aye. And many of the opinion say aye. Aye.
Speaker 87
Other country, no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it. If the front benches want to quickly shuffle over, they should do so now. Colleagues could keep their private conversations outside the chamber.
Speaker 94
We now come to motion number three Aye. Relating to business and trade committee, Jessica Morden.
Speaker 94
The question is as on the older papers, may in their opinion say aye. Aye. As the country know, the ayes have it. The ayes have it. I now come to motion number four, We're linking to foreign affairs committee, Jessica Morden.
Speaker 94
The question is as on the order paper, as made in that opinion say aye. Aye. I beg to know, the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
Speaker 94
this house do now adjourn, and I come to Steve Yem on experiences and outcomes for young people with cancer. Steve Yem.
Speaker 133
Thank you, madam deputy speaker. I'm very grateful for the opportunity to secure this important debate on the experiences and outcomes for young people with cancer. This is a subject that matters deeply to me in my role as parliamentary champion for the Teenage Cancer Trust and as an officer of the APPG for cancer in children and young people and as an issue that matters profoundly to my constituents. In Mansfield, I'm regularly contacted by young people, by parents and by families whose lives have been turned upside down by a cancer diagnosis. They write to me not just about treatment, but about their wider experience, the fear, the uncertainty, the disruption to education and work and relationships.
And they write because they want to be heard. And today, I hope that this house and indeed the government will listen. Every few hours in The UK, a young person hears the words, you have cancer, mostly with blood cancer, which includes leukaemia, lymphoma and myeloma being the most common cancers amongst children, teenagers and young adults in The UK. And the reality is stark. More young people are getting cancer.
Rates have risen by a quarter since the early nineteen nineties and they're projected to continue increasing. Cancer remains the leading cause of disease related death amongst teenagers and young adults in The UK. But even for those who survive, the impact can be lifelong physically, emotionally, and socially, especially when the right support is not there. And this is happening at a time when life is already tough for young people. Many are facing economic uncertainty, struggling with mental health issues, worrying about their futures.
A cancer diagnosis compounds all of that often at the most formative stage in life. This month marks teenage and young adult cancer awareness month, and it's right that we use this moment to shine a light on a group that is too often overlooked. Young people who fall between children's and adult services and whose needs are too often not fully recognized. I'd be delighted to take an intubation from the honorable gentleman.
Speaker 50
Madam Douglas here, first of all, can I commend the honorable gentleman from Mansfield to bring this forward? It's a very important issue for himself, and he he's illustrated that by his commitment to all these debates that he he gets involved in. So I want to congratulate him. In Northern Ireland, approximately sixty children 16, 80 teenagers and young adults, sixteen to twenty four, are diagnosed with cancer each year. While these cases are rare, accounting for only one percent of all diagnosis, they require a highly specialized family centred approach.
Around eighty seven percent of young people survive for at least one year, seventy eight percent survive for five years or more. So those at the don't agree that improvements can be made to ensure that our children have the best of the best possible treatment regardless of where they live. There should be no box for them. They should get it wherever they are near the kingdom.
Speaker 133
I thank the honorable member for his intervention. Madam deputy speaker, before 1990, young people with cancer were treated either on a children's ward or alongside much older adults with very little recognition of their distinct needs. The Teenage Cancer Trust changed that. They pioneered specialist care for 13 to 24 year olds creating dedicated units within the NHS staffed by expert nurses and youth workers and designed to support not just treatment but the whole person. And today there are 28 units across The UK helping young people receive that care alongside others of their own age in environments that protect their independence, their dignity and their mental health.
Because cancer at that age is not just a medical condition. It disrupts their education, relationships, identity, and plans for the future. And as we know that when young people receive this kind of age appropriate care their experiences and outcomes improve significantly. But only around half of young people currently benefit from this type of specialist support and one of the most critical issues facing young people with cancer is the speed of diagnosis. Unlike many adult cancers those affecting young people are often rare, they cannot be prevented and blood cancers as mentioned earlier is the most common cancer for young people.
It doesn't have the same focus or understanding as other types of cancers. That means that early diagnosis is absolutely crucial, yet too many young people face delays. Awareness of cancer symptoms among young people also remains worryingly low. Fewer than half of 18 to 24 year olds can identify key warning signs things like unexplained lumps, pain, tiredness or significant weight changes. And in Mansfield, I've heard directly from families about the consequences of that lack of awareness.
Multiple GP visits, uncertainty, delays before being referred for diagnosis. Indeed, nearly half of young people with cancer report attending three or more GP appointments before being referred. This experience was echoed by the family of eleven year old Joel from Mansfield, who in 2024 sadly passed away after a nine month battle with acute myeloid leukemia. In his case, he made four initial GP visits presenting a range of symptoms which were dismissed as simply bruising from football, or a laundry detergent algae. After the symptoms worsened, it took a second opinion from another GP and an emergency A and E visit before being diagnosed correctly.
It's important also to recognize that these delays are not just clinical. They're often psychological. Evidence shows that waiting two months or more for a diagnosis significantly increases the likelihood of anxiety and depression. So I want to ask the minister how will the government ensure that teenagers and young adults are not simply followed through pediatric diagnostic pathways but are recognized as a distinct group with distinct needs and what steps will be taken to raise awareness both amongst young people themselves and across primary care of the signs and symptoms of cancer in this particular age group. The second issue I want to address is psychological support.
A cancer diagnosis at any age is devastating but for a young person it's often overwhelming. They face fears about survival, about treatment, about their futures, their education is interrupted, their friendships are disrupted, their sense of identity can be shaken. It's deeply concerning and studies including research from young lives versus cancer who provide specialist social care support show that ninety percent of young people undergoing cancer treatment experience anxiety, eighty three percent report loneliness, seventy percent experience depression and nearly half experience panic attacks. I'm going to continue if you don't mind in view of the time. They're not marginal figures.
It's an overwhelming majority and yet despite clear NHS commitments that every young person should have access to mental health support, provision remains inconsistent. It's in effect a postcode lottery. Five years ago, the Teenage Cancer Trust warned of this in their not okay report, but today progress remains limited. And in Mansfield, families have raised with me the difficulties of accessing timely mental health support during and after treatment. The family of Ailey, a 23 year old from Mansfield, who was diagnosed with a rare lung cancer at the age of 20, after initially being reassured that nothing was wrong, made this point to me.
She underwent the removal of an entire lung, but what followed was a lack of clear aftercare and support. No structured rehabilitation and limited guidance on recovery and ongoing difficulty navigating care. Her experience highlights not just the physical impact of cancer treatment but the confusion, anxiety and gaps in support that too many young people face once treatment ends. And so I'd also like to ask the minister what funding and timelines are in place to ensure that every young person with cancer can access specialist psychological support not just drawing treatment but for at least two years afterwards. The third issue is access to clinical trials.
Clinical trials are essential to improving outcomes and developing new treatments but teenagers and young adults are significantly less likely to take part compared to other age groups. This is not because they do not wish to, it's because the system doesn't work for them. They're often excluded due to age restrictions, too old for pediatric trials and too young for adult ones. They're more likely to have rare cancers, meaning fewer trials are available. And referring again to Joel from Mansfield, the family asked his doctors about opportunities to participate in a clinical trial but were told that they weren't any.
And even when trials do exist, information can be difficult to find both for clinicians and for parents. The ambition has been clear, 50% participation by 2025, but, again, progress has been slow. No young person should miss out on a potentially lifesaving opportunity just because of their age. So I'd also like to ask the minister, how will the government measure and report progress on improving access to clinical trials for young people, and what accountability mechanisms are in place to ensure delivery. And finally, want to address the issue of data.
Too often, young people with cancer are effectively invisible in the system. Data is not consistently collected, not consistently reported, and not always broken down in a way that allows us to understand their experiences. Without good data, it's hard to identify inequalities. Without it, we cannot target improvements, and without it, we cannot ensure accountability. So I'd also like to ask what steps the minister might take to improve the collection and publication of age specific data on cancer outcomes for teenagers and young adults.
Madam deputy speaker, as I begin to conclude, the issues I've spoken about today mattered deeply to my constituents in Matsfield. They matter to the young people facing cancer today across the country. They matter also to the families supporting them, and they matter to all of us who believe that no young person should face this disease without the care and support that they deserve. The evidence is clear when young people receive timely diagnosis, age appropriate care, access to psychological support and opportunities to participate in clinical trials their outcomes improve. Teenage Cancer Trust has shown what's possible but they cannot do it alone.
If we're serious about improving outcomes, then the commitments in the National Cancer Plan must be delivered with urgency, with funding, with accountability. And we need to improve awareness. We need to remove barriers, and we must ensure that young people are no longer overlooked or underserved. So I'll close with a simple request to the minister. Would she commit alongside the secretary of state who promised me personally he'd do so to visit a teenage cancer trust unit to hear directly from young people to understand their experiences and to see firsthand the difference that specialist age appropriate care can make.
Because I think if we truly listen to these young people, we'll know exactly what needs to change.
Speaker 18
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to start by thanking my honourable friend, the member for Mansfield, for securing this very important debate. As we heard, this is during the awareness month for teenage and young adults with cancer. And I want to thank him for his very important work on the All Party Group on cancer in children and young people, as well as his role as the parliamentary champion for Teenage Cancer Trust. And I'm also grateful for my honorable friend for his invitation he's just made for me to visit a Teenage Cancer Trust unit, which I would be very pleased to accept.
I also want to pay tribute to some of the fantastic charities that he and I have both worked with. Teenage Cancer Trust as he's mentioned but also Young Lives versus Cancer and Children with Cancer UK to name just a few. They supported us to write the National Cancer Plan and now the plan is published they will play a vital role in its delivery. Madam Deputy Speaker, cancer remains a leading cause of death by young people under the age of 14 and I cannot begin to imagine what it must be like for those children and young people who have their whole life ahead of them to hear the words you have cancer. And not to mention those moms and dads who go through the nightmare of seeing their child suffer.
It is true that seventy eight percent of children with cancer between eight and 15 said they were very well looked after by the NHS but I won't be satisfied until that number reaches one hundred percent. There are so many areas we must do better, particularly when it comes to patient experience. And the honourable member laid out quite clearly, I feel, in his opening remarks, what some of those areas were, so I will go through them one at a time. So thanks to my predecessor, my excellent predecessor, my honorable friend, the member for West Lancashire, we now have a plan that includes a dedicated chapter on children and young people, setting out how the government will address their unique needs. And we will begin to shift the dial on detecting, diagnosing and treating cancers in young people and we will continue to listen to young people and their families through our patient experience panel ensuring lived experience sits at the heart of everything that we do.
I will.
Speaker 14
giving way and I congratulate the member for Mansfield for securing this important debate. He's been a champion on this issue since he came to this place. The minister mentioned patient experience and one of the things that has been brought to me in my surgeries is after the often intensive clinical process of a young person going through cancer diagnosis, getting treatment and getting through the other side, that period of the all clear is an intense period of social isolation and significant mental health support is required to get them back into integrating into school or college or work. Would she be prepared to meet with me and those young people that have been through that experience as to how we can improve the system so that they can integrate into normal life as quickly as possible.
Speaker 18
I want to thank the hon. Member Redditch for that very important intervention. I will also commit to meeting with him and the young people he mentions. Perhaps we could do it in coordination when I meet with the Teenage Cancer Trust and do a visit to the Teenage Cancer Trust. I hope that there would be plenty opportunity to meet with young people during that visit.
Yes to both of those requests. So one of the things that we heard from the Children and Young People's Cancer Tax Course was about how many parents have been forced to cut back on food and other expenses to pay for their travel to treatment. But when a child is diagnosed with cancer, their family's only focus should be on helping them recover and getting them well, not on whether they can afford the petrol or the bus fare to get to their next appointment. And that is why, through the plan, we are investing up to £10,000,000 a year to support families with travel costs and this fund will make the world of difference to parents. Because it doesn't matter what you earn, your child needs treatment, we will help you to get them there.
We are also transforming the experience of care in hospital, making sure that every child and young person with cancer has access to high quality, age appropriate psychological support. The Honourable Member for Mansfield and Redditch have both asked questions on that. So that support should be from diagnosis through treatment and beyond. And I'll take on board my honourable friend from Mansfield for his request for that to be for up to two years post treatment as well. So this includes early referrals.
He spoke about how important it is to have those early referrals to teenage and young adult multidisciplinary teams with youth support coordinators on hand to help young people navigate this huge journey that they're going to have to go on the emotional impact of cancer alongside challenges around education, perhaps fertility and their long term well-being. Madam Deputy Speaker, this government is committed to diagnosing cancer in children and young people faster to ensure that they get the treatment and care that they need as soon as possible. As my honorable friend set out in his speech, this speed is of the utmost importance, so we will remove the barriers that stand in the way of timely diagnosis by making sure young people's needs are embedded into the design of neighbourhood health services. Just before recess, my honourable friend, the Minister for State for Care, announced the first 27 of two fifty one stop health shops that will be up and running next year with 120 planned by the end of this Parliament. These offer a new model of care as set out in our ten year plan for health with better access to specialist support and the safe rollout of AI.
Many colleagues, not least my honorable friend Mitcham and Morden, have been pushing the government for a long time to go further on research. That is why we are making research into improving outcomes for children, especially into kinder and more gentle treatments, a national research priority. So the department will take a more joined up approach to research priorities using data as my honorable friend urged us to do. So efforts are focused where they can make the greatest difference. And we will break down the barriers that prevent young people from accessing clinical trials, particularly those who do not often qualify for pediatric or adult trials by requiring clinical justifications for age limits.
And while we strengthen data collection across the cancer pathway also. Madam Deputy Speaker, in the next few months the department will establish a reformed National Cancer Board once a co chair has been appointed to oversee and monitor the implementation of our cancer plan. And the board will include a dedicated lead for children and young people's cancer, ensuring that this work is driven forward with clear accountability and focus. They will make sure we are staying on track, and I know my honorable friend, the member for Mansfield, will play his part in that too. Because we on these benches believe all children and young people, no matter their circumstances, deserve support to achieve the very best outcomes in life, but most importantly to live fulfilling and happy lives.
So alongside our work on cancer, this government is combating the drivers of ill health in children's lives such as poor diets, damp homes, dirty air and a lack of opportunity. We've abolished the two child benefit cap, taken half a million children out of destitution, shame and hunger. We've brought in free breakfast clubs and extended free school meals, so kids start school with hungry minds not hungry bellies. Also, soft drink industry levy, a warm home discount that reaches millions more, generational ban on smoking, AWAB's law, cutting pollution and cleaning up the air that our children breathe, and this year I am determined to do everything I can for children and young people with cancer. So, madam deputy speaker, I have my foot on the accelerator, and I look forward to working closely with my honourable friend in the months ahead on this work.
Thank you.
Speaker 94
is, is house to now adjourn? Is the mayor of the opinion say aye? Aye. The ayes have it. The ayes have it.
Order. Order.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.