Women and Equalities Committee
No chapters available yet
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Women and Equalities Committee House of Commons
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 3
It's a bit of a perfect storm, I think, in in other in in in other words. So where organizations have made public statements on politically sensitive issues without a clear connection to their internal practice, this can contribute to perceptions that EDI is more about signaling than substance, which can further weaken confidence, as I say, particularly if employees aren't feeling the link between the external messaging and everyday experience at work.
Speaker 2
Does anybody have a different view? Please go ahead Ian. Ian, if you can also consider as well, when we look at how we measure EDI, are The UK and US comparable?
Speaker 6
That's a good very point. And I think I actually agree with with a lot of what Zoe said, but I would more add just a couple of other factors. So I think that whilst rooted in the best of intentions to root out discrimination to provide an inclusive workforce, I would say some of the backlash has come from specific programs and policies which were seen as going too far. I might refer to when a senior executive of Aviva said in parliament that she would have to personally sign off any nondiverse hire. Ethnic minority, only internship schemes, for example, are another example of this.
There's also been more being there is a greater realization by companies that the public and their staff don't necessarily want the more heavy handed programs, which have come under the, under the banner of EDI. They do want nondiscrimination. A strong support for that. They do want people to be treated fairly. But, for example, we did polling at Policy Exchange in 2024, and we asked people to pick between two statements, which were employer should appoint or promote the person most qualified for the job without taking into account factors such as race and gender, or employers should appoint or promote people in a way that creates a diverse team which reflects the makeup of The UK.
And 75% of people went for the first, 15% for the second. Similarly, 50% of people agreed that businesses have been too concerned with taking political positions on contested issues, which I think matches with some of what Zoe said, with only 18% disagreeing. I say with The US, and I think it's a very, good question, I I think The UK has generally been in a better position in The US, both in terms of, I guess, overreach and backlash. So we never had we never had positive discrimination here. We do positive action and there are debates to be had about that, but we haven't had the full on affirmative action which you saw in The US, which I think is a good thing.
We've also had less of a backlash in terms of some of the very heavy handed by some states, for example, The US. I'm not saying I think everything is perfect here. I think from our report, you know, we think there are things that can be changed. But I would hope that just as we often do in Britain that we can navigate a better way between the two poles of overreach and backlash than some of what's happening in The US.
Speaker 7
Louise wants Can I just add a quick point on that? Think again there's consensus between us in many areas. I do think the questions that were asked there sort of are in danger of presenting diversity and inclusion as anti meritocratic, as the opposite to meritocratic. And I would just signal that's not necessarily the case. That just because we have diversity and anti discrimination measures in place, that is not saying that we are making non meritocratic hires.
We are compensating for historical disadvantage that anti discrimination law does not do on its own. So I think it's quite problematic to position diversity necessarily as anti meritocratic and to ask a question that in some senses frames that as an either or. I think it's slightly misleading. And just one final point just more generally on this. I think one of the things going back to Zoe's point is that when we look at EDI measures or or equality, we always move through fads and fashions.
We always do with all management practices. And we can think of that in relation to EDI in a sense that EDI has been in fashion for a variety of reasons. It's it's moving a little bit less or a little out of fashion partly, and I would I think we might talk about this when we come on to the business case. I think what we have to remember that there's never been a consensus around DEI EDI. There was a surface consensus to some extent.
And I think one of the currents that's affecting us from The States is that we So I would argue much of EDI is driven by reputational pressures, not necessarily the business case. I think those political currents from the states are reducing those reputational pressures and as a result of that, organizations are starting to feel less constrained and there's a sort of apparent collapse of consensus. But it's more the fact that we're just seeing that support was always quite contingent, always quite instrumental anyway.
Speaker 2
Thank you, Louise. If I can come to Peter briefly, I will come to you in a moment, Alan. If if please reflect on anything you've spoken about already, but I'm interested to what extent has political and public support of EDI been affected by movements such as Black Lives Matter and the debate about balancing trans inclusion with women's sex based rights.
Speaker 5
I mean, we've touched on some of these points already. I mean, I always say that business is part of society. It has to we have to understand and recognize some of the societal trends and what's being discussed and debated. And that can create some challenges as well. So it can overcome yeah.
Sometimes, as we've already explored, and I agree with much of the commentary, can overcompensate for some of these things. And when you're in environments where these discussions, as Louise has already said, difficult to find consensus on, can get overly politicized, then the reaction from organizations can, of course, be very variable as a result of that. I think what's essential now is that we are focusing on, as has been said, the outcomes, acknowledging that whilst there has been some progress, there is still more to be done. I don't think anybody would deny that we need to do more in building inclusive cultures, in particular, and which are supportive and respective of people and difference in recognizing the value that that brings to an enterprise. But we will always be confronted, I think, in business with political trends.
And the important thing is to make sure that we are grounding what we do in business on evidence. We have to listen to the voice of our employees. And our employees, certainly in the recent generations, are more vocal on these issues, they expect to hear their voice heard in organizations much more. But I do think we're also at a little bit of a point of saying, alright. How do we get the balance between just saying everything's up for debate in organizations and every political trend or every conflict around the world?
Or whatever it might be is open for discussion in our workplaces. I think we have to find a balance. And and what has been described in the past is the social contract of work, which is where I have my employment contract, but I also have a recognition that when I come to work, there may be certain things I have to leave outside the door because it's not helpful to, you know, inclusive cultures if I'm debating absolutely everything. And I think there's some of that conversation going on, which goes back to my point about the extent to which organizations take a are mindful of societal and political shifts, but at the same time, don't just immediately fall into saying, right. I gotta deal with all these things, and I've gotta have all these campaigns going on internally because we we can't deal with it.
And I think we have to be very wary of the trends that that might drive.
Speaker 2
Thank you. I'll bring Alex in just to finish off on this section, but Alex, if you can also maybe consider how the sector can perhaps reset itself to gain, a broader political and public level of support, for the work that's being done.
Speaker 8
This would be to focus on the evidence that some of my fellow panelists have highlighted. So this goes back to the the opening question that you had. Why has there been a change in the views? And in addition to the political changes and the institutional changes is developments in the evidence. There used to be a strong consensus that demographic diversity, which was measured mainly by gender and ethnicity, that was strongly linked to financial performance.
But now evidence suggests that a lot of those studies were weak and flawed and there are a lot of issues with this. But we need not go to the other extreme and say this means that DEI is always damaging because that's not the case. Actually, there's new evidence suggesting that if we broaden diversity from just demographic diversity to cognitive diversity, that could be socioeconomic diversity, that could be diversity of background in education, then we do have a link with financial performance. That was a report I did for the diversity project last year, which we launched in the House of Lords in June. And also, if you look at equity and inclusion, psychological safety, places where people can express different view points and challenge each other, that is also linked to financial performance.
And I think the early movements of of DEI, people didn't think, oh, demographic diversity is all that matters and we ignore cognitive and and inclusion. People thought maybe that's just a good enough proxy. So maybe it's not perfect, but it's a reasonable correlation. But
Speaker 8
the new evidence suggests is you're actually missing out a lot of that other stuff. It's not sort of good enough. It might actually be quite misleading. Some organizations can tick the box on certain visible demographic diversity metrics whereas they're not moving the needle on what truly drives performance, cognitive diversity and inclusion of corporate culture.
Speaker 7
Really quick. I just want to make a point on the business case which is I think really important to bear in mind. The business case has been the primary motivation for equality in social justice and organisations for about ten, twenty years, the same time that EDI was imported from The States into The UK. Critical scholars have been arguing from the very inception of that agenda that we have to be extraordinarily careful about using a business case as our primary driver for fairness or for equality because the business case will always be contingent. It will always be difficult to prove.
It's very difficult to decide which aspect of diversity we attach it to. So the argument would always be that although we can have the business case there in the background, personally, think that serves as a fig leaf. As I said, I think most organizations act according to reputational pressures as opposed to a pure business case. But really, we fundamentally need to focus on our principles, what our values are. Because those principles and those values remain consistent, whereas the business case is really difficult to prove and it's really difficult to prove in any sort of consistent sense.
So there has to be a principled argument as well.
Speaker 1
David. Thank you, David. Iain, I just wanted to ask a little bit question around that polling information that you gave us. So it was a sample size of around 1,900 people. That's right.
Yeah. And of those 1,900 people, seventeen forty six of them identified as white. Only 83 black and 116 Asian. Is that was that how did you choose your sample?
Speaker 6
I mean, was a British polling company member. It was a standard way in which they construct their sample to be representative of The UK population.
Speaker 1
Okay. Would there be any effort at all to make a more representative sample when it comes to those that are affected by EDI policies?
Speaker 6
I think all employees are affected by EDI employee policies. When a company runs an ethnic only internship scheme that means all the employees who are not ethnic minorities or potential employees are not able to get get in there.
Speaker 6
That report. And that report and this just to be clear, this is a different report to the one we published recently. But both of those reports form part of our core work program.
Speaker 1
Yeah. Who funds your core work work program? Because I think it was really interesting what Zoe had said earlier about that kind of creep from The US over and we just want to I mean, you talked about one of them politicizing business and I just wonder where the politicization is on on this front coming from because I think it's really important that we're transparent about this and I just want I just wanted to know where the basis was from from this and particularly I think given the conversation that we've had in Parliament today around funding I think it's really important that we know who is funding the research that is being quoted.
Speaker 6
Yeah, so Policy Exchange is a registered charity. We are fully compliant with our charity commission obligations and you can see our returns including our accounts on the charity commission's website. We are funded by a wide range of foundations, trusts, corporations, individuals. Where it's appropriate and where they ask for it, we're proud of all of our donors, but we respect their privacy. Our offices have been vandalized by extremists three times in the last three years, and it is understandable why some of those who donate to us wish to maintain their privacy as they are entitled to by law.
Speaker 1
for what I really hope all of your staff are okay because I think all of us sat here can understand that when you put yourself forward in a public facing role that, unfortunately, those the public but also to the staff as well. I'm going to pass on now to Nia.
Speaker 9
Thank you very much and excuse my voice being a bit croaky. I'm going to turn to the issue of how we actually define diversity inclusion, which you have actually touched on already. So perhaps if I can start with Zoe and Alex, and asking you about what some of the difficulties are in defining, promoting and analysing diverse and inclusive cultures in the workplace. Shall I begin? Was that first?
Well, I don't mind. Yes.
Speaker 3
Diversity is is about who? So the makeup of an organization's workforce. And hence, the the focus, you can you can count that, you can attach to protected characteristics by by account. Inclusion is is the mechanism by which which diversity brings value for the individual and for the organization, and inclusion is in precisely defined and is very difficult to measure. There is not a universal agreement around how to measure inclusion.
It's often measured by by organizations in surveys, in people surveys, and it's measured by mood. So I feel included, I feel my voice is heard. It's rarely measured by functioning. So how does the organization actually work to ensure that the diversity and the contribution is leveraged and is working for the organisation and creating value. So there are imperfect measures.
There's the lack of clarity around EDI interventions and the specific problem they are to solve, as well as the lack of measurement around the impact that they might make. So it's very hard to compare interventions because they operate at different levels. So you might have awareness training or process change or a policy change or system redesign, and these interventions are not equivalent. And the evidence suggests that progress and impact, say, on progressing women into leadership roles, will come from a combination of interventions. So it's hard to say whether development programmes for women work, because the outcome the measurable outcomes from that might be a participant's report in improved confidence and intention to put their hand up for promotion.
But whether that promotion is is achieved depends on changes to the decision making in promotional pathway and other system adaptations as well. So it's very, very difficult to measure, but what would help enormously is some focus work on on supporting how to define inclusive culture, inclusion as skills and behaviors that we that can be can be measured. Right.
Speaker 9
bring in Alex tomorrow, I'll come back to Louise with some additional additional challenges.
Speaker 8
Thanks for the question. So I'll start with cognitive diversity, and then I'll move to inclusion. So in the report that we did, we defined cognitive diversity as the range of expertise, experiences, information, perspectives, preferences, and ways of thinking within a team. It can arise from differences in educational background, professional background, life background, cognitive style, personality, and demographics. So let me just expand on that.
So one point is this is something which is purely it's fully consistent with meritocracy as was highlighted earlier. This is to make effective organizations where the whole is more than the sum of its parts, where we have a range of different opinions and perspectives to to lead to a a better outcome. Indeed, demographics is one source of this. So men and women think differently. So there's psychological evidence looking at different risk appetite and caution and emotional intelligence.
Also, ethnicities will have different experiences and cultures. But it's more than that because sometimes approaches may give the impression that a white man doesn't bring any diversity to an organization when his expertise might be in humanities and everybody else's in sciences. He might be the first in his family to ever go to university. And so those things are important. It's not that cognitive that demographics take up 80% of it.
In fact, all of these other factors do matter a lot. Personality cell matters a lot. Are you more risk seeking or or risk averse? Then when we move to inclusion, this is a corporate culture that allows people to to be themselves, to express their viewpoints, to challenge each other, to challenge seniors, to propose bold ideas without the fear of failure or chastisement if you go against a senior. But it's important to to not, overextend this because sometimes inclusion suggests that we should be a space that everybody can say anything even if it's demiscriminatory and and offensive.
So that is not part of inclusion. Also, shouldn't necessarily be that everybody's viewpoint should always be included in every meeting, that every viewpoint gets equal air time because there will be some people with more expertise on a topic, and we can't have every decision being taken with the town hall. So then what does inclusion mean is we're going to include all viewpoints that are relevant to the issue at hand. So certainly discriminatory behavior, that is not going to be beneficial to the decision being taken, but also something which is not coming from from expertise or maybe a less informed viewpoint that doesn't necessarily all need to be included. But we want to look at the merit of a viewpoint and if the viewpoint comes from somebody of a particular minority demographic group, that should be taken as seriously as it as if it came from majority group.
Speaker 9
There you've touched on a a, you know, quite a wide range of different characteristics So do you think there's been too much focus on the protected characteristics and not enough focus on that wider range of diversity that you've just mentioned.
Speaker 8
Yes. There is. And I I think this is not not from a a malicious view viewpoint or negative viewpoint. It's just we want to start with what's easy to to measure. Right.
And those are easier to measure. And we thought, maybe that would be 60% or 80% of it perfect should not be the enemy of the good, but what the evidence increasingly suggests is that is capturing a a small part of the picture. And in particular, to the extent to which these measures become much more reported, there will be organizations which want to look good on those metrics, and that could be at the expense of what really matters. So just like with company reporting, if we focus on quarterly earnings, then companies will focus on short term profit at the expense of research and development and building corporate culture, And this could be also one of the the unintended consequences of focusing only on the visible measures of demographic diversity.
Speaker 7
I'm gonna I'm gonna disagree slightly, I'm afraid. Just a couple of points. One, Alexi mentioned that men and women think differently. I'm careful about that sort of essentialist judgment. Think that men and women have different experiences for sure but I don't think fundamentally they think very differently and those kinds of binary distinctions usually work less well for one group and that's typically women I would say.
So I think we have to be careful with that. And I do think that when we think about cognitive diversity, yes, yes to some extent, but let's not forget that representation matters and it continues to matter. And if we think for example, let's think of the city of London where many of our most elite and high status and highly remunerated jobs are, even today 60% of senior leaders in those organisations are white male and from upper middle class backgrounds. So I think, yes, let's think about cognitive diversity. I would question it to some extent partly because one of the difficult things organisations is their incredible pressures towards assimilation.
And often the way that you get ahead is to be like the people who are already there and that doesn't really change that moment that much. So we can start with our level of cognitive diversity. Whether that gets us to the top of organisations at all is a little doubtful. I just am a little bit cautious about it. And on the matter of discrimination, I think a really important point is that in it's sort of embedded within the business case the idea that discrimination is economically irrational because it means you're not recruiting and promoting on job relevant factors.
And that's the sort of classical economic argument behind non discrimination. And in a way it makes sense, but in a way it doesn't at all because it assumes that we are economic economically rational actors and that we always make economically rational decisions. And the thing about human nature is we don't. So often it can be entirely rational to discriminate for non economic reasons depending on your interests and therefore we just have to be a bit careful about again using this business case which actually isn't very powerful in driving change.
Speaker 1
I'm just going to gonna bring in Peter, and then gonna have to update you about where we are with votes in a minute, I'm afraid. Sorry.
Speaker 5
I'm just getting more constrained. Yeah. A couple of quick thoughts. On the business case, we've always argued it also from the perspective of being able to attract and retain the greatest diversity of talent and skills that you can, which sort of builds a little bit on Alex's point. I understand your points on that, Louise, well.
And the fact that our demographics as a society have been changing. So that that's point one. Point two is that you have organizations that reflect the customers that they are serving and the communities which of which they are part. And I've had many conversations with business leaders that get those arguments without necessarily needing the absolute quantitative proof, which think we all acknowledge is not easy to find. So I tend to express the business cases from those perspectives as well.
And then I think in terms of the measurement, you've got quantitative and qualitative. I think, of course, we can look at representation, but I also encourage organizations to say, well, if you'll if you have different demographics which you're measuring, then also look at things like retention and progression, because those are also good indicators of what's going on. You can then look at qualitative metrics around surveys and begin to break those by demographic groups as well, and find, you know, if you're asking questions about, do I feel safe? Can I speak up? Am I respected?
Do I feel included? You can break those down also by demographic groups. And that can give you a lot of insight. And I think that's where a lot of this debate is now beginning to move to.
Speaker 5
on that front as well. Done a lot on those sorts of things as well. And those are difficult things to measure it. And you get all this complexity of intersectionality and all this debate. And, ultimately, I think it's very and we're all individuals.
And and trying to categorize too much, I think, has been part of the problem of the past. Let's put people in categories based on their ethnicity or whatever it might be, then train managers about what particular ethnicity or gender thinks. And that, of itself, is not creating inclusion. And I think we've learned a lot over the last, whatever it's been, fifteen years or so, to move away some of those ideas and talk much more about collective inclusion, respect for the individual, and this combination of both qualitative and quantitative measures.
Speaker 1
Thank you. Thank you. Nia, are you done? Yeah. Thank you.
Thank you, Nia. So we are probably gonna get two votes a lot quicker than we thought we would, and they will take an hour. So when we do suspend the session for that, we'll discuss whether we come back after an hour or whether we find another date. But I am really sorry because is such a fascinating session but we do also have to vote as well at the same time.
Speaker 1
pretty sure all of you would have a say about how we could actually modernize and make that a much more efficient way of doing it. Kim?
Speaker 4
Fabulous. Thank you, Chair. Thank you everybody. This is really, really interesting. So I'm going ask you a few questions about what success looks like.
So for which types of equality, diversity and inclusion initiatives is there the strongest correlation between the intervention and then intended positive outcomes? So what what does good look like in this space? I'm going to ask Louise first of all if that's okay.
Speaker 7
Yeah. It's a good question. I'm going to go back to well, two things picking up on points that Zoe said. One of the problems with measuring success is there's too many confounding variables and we cannot ever almost use a control group. So because most of the intervention is not big enough to allow that to happen.
And there's often a kind of sense, and this isn't necessarily criticism in diversity, that you try a lot of things, one of them will work but you're not always quite sure which one it is or not, basically. So we have to be very careful about this. We also have to be very careful because DNI, I keep using different terms, DEI is, as I mentioned just now, extremely vulnerable to fashion and to imitation. We call it institutional isomorphism in my world, which is that organizations often like to adopt similar practices because that's legitimate as opposed to being effective. And DEI is one of those policies that's very open to that form of imitation.
And the policy that I'd probably pick out as particularly representative of that is something like unconscious bias training, which is very widely introduced without any evidence at all that had any effect and it probably doesn't have much of an effect. But it almost became problematic not to give unconscious bias training because it looked like you might not care about unconscious bias. So we see these kind of these things, these movements and snowballs happening that are just completely non evidence based. So having said which, it is difficult to get really very clear evidence for the reasons that both I and Zoe have said. I think generally though, and I'll I'll hand over to the fellow panelists, what we like to see is kind of structural interventions.
Things that actually change structures of organizations as opposed to purely cultures although the two things can work together. So maybe I'll cede the floor because I'm talking a lot to others. I'm sure you've got
Speaker 3
I think there's been some success with a focus on practices, not programs. Yeah. So capability building, so supporting managers to manage performance in a humane way. And if I might offer a case study example, actually, in the care sector, an organization that I've been working with, where the diversity is already there. It's a fact.
The question is, whether that organization is equipped to make it work, and and this is a mid sized group of residential care homes, 600 staff, highly regulated in environment, and like much of the sector, a very diverse workforce. Ethnic diversity, a high proportion of internationally trained, nursing staff, on training visas as well, and predominantly female workforce. It's a business that wants to grow, but the reality is that their, HR infrastructure is two and a half people for organization of of 600 or so. The management director, and this is why it works, was very clear that their ability to deliver high quality care, to manage risk, and to grow depends entirely on how well their people work together to deliver that care. So when we looked at what the challenges were to that, and this is another point, things are interventions are most successful when they're based on a clear diagnosis of what to focus on.
The challenge was not about intent, it wasn't about policy, it was about everyday interactions, communication across cultures, confidence to speak up when a mistake was made, and how teams handled mistakes in real time. So the focus wasn't on adding an EDI programme, It was on building capability, particularly of the manager, to set the tone, to set clear expectations about how people work together, and to enable people to challenge and support each other. And and the results and this is doing that in the flow of work. So it's not taking people off-site for a training program or things like that. This is in the flow of work, integrating inclusive practices and skills into that environment.
And the results were very changeable. So vacancy rates are the lowest they've ever been. Staff turnover is also low and much better than the sector average for that size group. And for me, this is a a great example of effective inclusion work and what that looks like in practice. It's not separate from the business.
It's how the business works.
Speaker 4
I think now that that's really interesting because that you know, again, without sort of giving my own opinions on on this matter, there is something sort of not always very helpful about saying we're gonna do equality diversity inclusion training today. Exactly. As opposed to saying this is the organization we are and this is how we operate, and that is embedded within that. Yeah. Peter, did you want to add something?
Speaker 5
Absolutely, Kim. And I wanted to reinforce the point. There's so much evidence now that what works is when you've really focused on the culture. You can put all these initiatives in, but the culture is not inclusive and supportive. They're not going to work.
And I think, as we've all recognized, a lot of historical stuff, let's do something. And Louise's point of I think tonight so often have talked about it's not about best practice, but about best fit. You gotta understand the context, and you absolutely gotta understand the cultural dynamics that can be working against some of these initiatives. So to get there, it is, you know, it is training our managers, making them better people managers. And if there's been a failing in business for many, many years, as we tend to promote people and their job competence, but we are not doing enough to train and hold them to account for being effective people managers, of which this is a very core component.
And then you look at the diversity inclusion initiatives, and you integrate them into practices. So you think about it all the way from recruitment, resourcing, progression, promotion, and so forth. And you just see it as integral to what you're doing in your HR practice. It's not some separate thing over there that we've all got to, you know, pay some different attention to. So it's about integrating to culture, integrating to practice Mhmm.
And shifting that mindset, I think, well.
Speaker 4
Okay. That that's really interesting. So we've talked a little bit there about what does work, and feel free to add to that, and I'll work along. But is there anything that, obviously, you in your experience hasn't worked? I'll start with Ian.
Speaker 6
I wanted just to add to that by talking at how our laws and the courts can warp businesses' measures of success and not always in a very helpful way. So if you are taken to court for, you facial discrimination, sex discrimination, and so forth, one of the ways you can defend yourself as a company is to show that you had policies in place and processes and training. So introducing unconscious bias training, and I love the word, the itomorphism word that you use here, it may be completely useless in terms of improving your culture. But actually, if it means you win the court case and said that you weren't at fault, then perhaps if you're the CFO, then, well, well, that's a win. And so you may do the stuff which doesn't help, and that's how because that's how the courts work.
It can encourage a fix. Again, we've had discussion on was there too much focus on identity characteristics, protective characteristics. Well, again, if you are if you're a financial services firm, the FCA says that you have to have 40% of your board must be female, and one of your board must be an ethnic minority. So perhaps success means that, for you, that you don't have to write an explanation to the FCA or regulator on why you failed to meet those targets. I think one of the things which I think came out very strongly in when we did our recent work is that this is not a case of businesses running away and, you know, deciding to be woke or whatever or implementing EDI schemes for the sake of it.
A lot of businesses and, indeed, public sector want to do their best for employees. Yes. They're buffeted by fashions. Yes. They sometimes catch on with things.
But, actually, when we look at the drivers of this, we need to look at the laws. We need to look at the courts. We need to look at how the courts interpret those laws because they are often driving the focus, It's whether that's on sort of tick box, counting protective characteristics, whether that's about introducing training and policies just to show that you have a training and policy in place. That's gonna be that can be a very major factor. And, actually, what we should be looking at, we should be looking at the culture.
We should be looking at cultures which deliver fantastic service. In the NHS, for example, productivity has not increased despite the huge focus on on diversity. Now that may be for other reasons, but we need to look at what happened in the financial services. I mean, do we care most about them hitting certain numbers on board? We might care a little bit about that, but we probably care more about not having the cognitive blind spots that led to the financial crisis in two thousand and eight.
Success needs to be considered broadly. Companies should do it broadly. And this is not saying that should there should be no regulation from government, but we do need to consider how that regulation, as it is written and as it's interpreted through the courts, distorts the success metrics of companies who will be responding to it.
Speaker 4
Okay. And that's really helpful. And I suppose there's different phases to this. There's the recruitment phase Mhmm. How you get your people Yep.
Mhmm. And then there's the culture around how those people operate. So maybe it's worth thinking about it like that that a little bit as well. Alex, did you want to come in?
Speaker 8
Thanks, Kim. You you asked two questions, what works and what may not work. So in terms of what works, there is modest evidence that cognitive diversity is linked to financial performance. But I have to stress the evidence was modest. So before I wrote the study for the diversity project, I hoped that I'd find really strong evidence that if we expanded diversity beyond demographics and looked at cognitive diversity, you get a really strong link.
But I found that even cognitive diversity was not enough because it needs to be accompanied by inclusion, by a culture psychological safety. So often organizations might have what I call an add diversity and stir approach. Let's just assemble a cognitively diverse team and wait for them to do their magic, but we need intentional management in order to harness the benefits while attenuating some of the costs. In terms of what what doesn't work, there has been evidence looking at the effect of quotas on performance. For example, in Norway, they had this requirement to have 40% of boards be women.
They had treatment and control groups, so they had the companies which were more in compliance than ones that were less in compliance. And the ones that were more affected, they suffered worse long term performance. But again, we we should not over interpret this, and to say, well, gender diversity is always negative. This was just a force measure of diversity. If you required 40% of boards to be professors, you'd probably have worse performance because there's just not enough of a supply.
And indeed, gender diversity is something which could be a source of demographic diversity. So I was a bit surprised by the early comment that men and women don't think differently. There is a lot of psychological evidence. They provide useful differences. So there's evidence on overconfidence.
So men typically attribute success to themselves. Women credit other people. When failures happen, men blame other circumstances. Circumstances. Women Women take responsibility themselves.
And this manifests in their own decisions. Men trade more speculatively than women, and women trade more more cautiously.
Speaker 1
Of kind of regurgitating I would say some some things. Could you just point to or could you send us some of the evidence that you have on that front? Would be Absolutely. Really
Speaker 4
Okay. No. That's that's really helpful. Thank you. And and how easy is it if you know, an EDI related initiative isn't going well and isn't having a positive effect?
How easy is it for employers to to stop that, Zoe, from from your perspective?
Speaker 3
Depends whether the intended focus and target for change was understood in the I first think it's it is quite easy, but for reasons that Louise has has said, there is a sort of peer pressure with fashionable initiatives, I think, that does rather grip. And so, just to echo the point the diagnosis of what to do in the first place that's best for that particular organisation doesn't always take place, and there isn't necessarily a clear line of sight to an outcome. There certainly is a lack of sharing of evidence of impact between organisations as well. That's actually kept very private. So many Some of the good stuff we don't get to hear about, but equally we don't get to hear about some of the things that haven't worked from inside organisations.
It's just if it was part of an academic study or a controlled Yeah,
Speaker 7
with Zoe. Just one thing, I do a lot of my work in social mobility and one of the interesting things about that area is numerous sort of groups being put up and put together in different sectors or industries. So for example in accountancy there's a group called Access Accountancy, in finance one called Progress Together, There's more. And they they look at kind of social mobility within these organizations. And what's really useful about those sorts of organizations is that sharing failure can confronting.
It'd be quite difficult to do that. But these act as sort of semi closed groups in which those experiences can be shared more openly. And that kind of model can be really useful to talk about what does work and what doesn't in a relatively supportive environment. Yeah. That's great.
Speaker 1
Thank you very much, Kim. And that brings us to close to that section anyway nicely. I will be suspending this
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.