Westminster Hall

28 April 2026

No chapters available yet

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:12 - 00:14
Speaker 1
Order.  Order.  Rachel Gilmore to move the motion. 
00:15 - 05:24
Speaker 2
I beg to move that this house considers the subject of international parental child abduction and it's a privilege to make my remarks under your very capable stewardship, doctor Murison.  I understand that these issues are very sensitive and of huge human significance.  And so I feel privileged to be able to bring the eyes and ears of the house to them.  And I salute the left behind parents, some of whom join us in the gallery this afternoon, for their indefatigrility and for their courage.  And I know that it will take they will take little comfort in such words, but I must say it anyway, Chair. 

I think it's important to emphasise the need not to prejudice ongoing legal proceedings, but as representatives of our constituents we feel to proper advocate for them.  According to Reunite International, over 500 children are abducted from The UK by a parent every year.  Among the families who attended the most recent roundtable on this subject here in parliament, there were upwards of half a century half a century of lost years.  That is to say lost contact with their children.  The testimonies I have heard, though individually unique, paint a troubling consistent picture, deliberate misleading, ill fated recovery attempts and financial costs running into the millions. 

Many have travelled time after time after time to foreign jurisdictions in the hope of recovering their children.  The human toll is staggering on both sides.  The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction provides the principal international framework governing these cases.  Crucially, it mandates expeditious handling of abduction proceedings, yet from testimonies I've received months often elapse before the first substantive hearing in a clear breach of the convention.  Such delays risk the factual entrenchment of the abducted child in the new jurisdiction, entirely undermining the notional remedy of return. 

The convention exists precisely to prevent this outcome.  Far too often it does not.  There are several structural concerns that recur across the cases brought to me.  First, the undermining of established jurisdictional findings.  In one instance I learnt of the Cairo Court here had already determined the child's habitual residence to be in England, and the Polish first instance court was aligned ordering return. 

However, the appellate outcome reversed this position despite no dispute as to the original wrongful removal and no clear finding that the Article 13 threshold had clearly been met at first instance.  This raises concern about consistency in applying Hague principles at an appellate level and the degree to which appellate courts revisit or expand factual assessments beyond convention limits.  The second concern is the creeping expansion of Article 13 welfare arguments as a basis for refusing return.  These provisions were always intended to be narrow exceptions, not an open door for wide ranging allegations.  Where such arguments are routinely entertained without proper substantiation there is a considerable possibility that summary return proceedings are converted into de facto welfare determinations which is not what the convention intended. 

Thirdly is the insufficient use of protective measures.  In this case The UK had jurisdiction and capacity to implement protective measures upon return with an active high court framework available.  These mechanisms should be taken seriously and fully operationalised.  Failure to do so risks turning theoretical concerns to harden into grounds of non return.  The post decision consequences of such outcomes are stark. 

The child remains outside the jurisdiction of the habitual residence.  There is no effective restoration of the pre removal status quo and contact arrangements remain limited and unresolved.  This illustrates how delay combined with appellate intervention can effectively neutralise the convention remedy entirely.  I am of course conscious that not every parent who crosses a border with a child is a wrongful abductor in the conventional sense.  There are genuine cases and we must be clear eyed about this where a parent flees with a child from real, documented domestic abuse and the law must be sensitive to that reality. 
05:25 - 06:29
Speaker 7
Article 13 exists precisely for such circumstances and where the threshold is generally met it should of course be engaged.  The concern is not with the protection itself but with its expansion and at times its misapplication.  The difficulty is that the very features which make these cases so emotionally charged also render them susceptible to the weaponization of abuse allegations as a litigation strategy.  It is therefore incumbent upon courts and authorities to apply rigorous scrutiny to such claims, neither dismissing them reflexively nor accepting them uncritically so that the protection is reserved for those who genuinely need it rather than becoming the means by which the Convention's core remedy is routinely frustrated.  The Child Abduction Act 1984 does not provide for the occurrence of a criminal offence when a parent has consent to take a child down to the country but then fails to return them. 
06:30 - 07:09
Speaker 2
This legal impole became known as the Nicolau Problem following a 2012 judicial review process.  The law commission's 2014 report identified this legal blind spot and recommended a change in the law.  And I'm pleased to say, minister, that the Crime and Policing Bill, which completed its passage through Parliament late last night, will finally close that loophole.  All abductions to The UK will now be criminal.  Based purely on the volume of human stories, Poland appears to be at the sharp end of these affairs and I must set out the record plainly as it stands. 

07:10 - 14:23

Speaker 2

The European Commission launched infringement proceedings against Warsaw and the European Court of Justice concluded that steps taken by the polls to disrupt and ignore UK convention orders were in contravention of EU law. A financial penalty was imposed for such intransigence. I would very much welcome the minister's reflection on the status of the British government's support for the European Commission's proceedings in relation to Poland's infringements in this area. The European Court of Human Routes found that while initial steps were timely, subsequent enforcement actions were marred by delays, ineffective procedures and a lack of coordination. Moreover, the court determined that authorities repeatedly relied on flawed or misleading information and failed to adjust their strategy when previous steps failed.

The failures were primarily attributable to the authorities and not solely the abductor's actions. It therefore held that there had been a violation of Article eight of the convention. The bottom line is this, abductions to Poland often endure because of the incompetence deliberate or otherwise of the authorities. At the very least the conduct of the Polish authorities has been marked by wilful negligence if not a sinister concerted effort to frustrate enforcement orders. This speaks to practices that seemingly have been institutionalized And Chair, listening to some of these stories it is hard to shake the distinct impression of conspiracy that the abducting parent is in coordination with the authorities, aided and abetted to evade enforcement.

Britain and Poland have a close bond. I think of the brave Polish pilots who fought with British wings with distinction in our country's finest hour. In recent decades, many of Poland's sons and daughters have made their home on these shores. They say that friends should be able to talk candidly, openly, and earnestly with each other even when it comes to uncomfortable discussions. In fact, especially when it comes to tricky home truths.

The government line is that these issues are raised at every opportunity with Polish counterparts. I appreciate that this is a delicate diplomatic dance but Poland's famous intransigence on this issue has hardly been subtle and so beyond the diplomatic niceties I would like to know what the response is when the question is put pointedly to Polish officials officials because it should not be the case that when sincere representations are made at the highest level they are met with prevarication. I'll now turn my attention to REMO, otherwise known as Reciprocal Enforcement of Maintenance Orders. Because there is much angst that the current default position is to enforce them without any scrutiny at all. In practice, this can result in maintenance being enforced against a left behind parent even in cases where there has been an abduction and an existing HAE return order.

Remo cases are typically held abroad without the involvement of the other parent and with no opportunity for defence. Amounts are often arbitrarily assigned with no consideration of a formability. To the best of my knowledge, Remo enforcement has been successfully challenged on only one occasion, and even then, only on a technicality. For left behind parents it adds insult to profound injury expected to help fund the illegal abduction of their own children and often forced to spend thousands of pounds pursuing appeals in UK courts against Remo enforcement. This mechanism is problematic for clear reasons.

Hague convention return orders are effectively disregarded in financial enforcement proceedings. Left behind parents may be required to pay backdated and ongoing maintenance. Worse still, this system risks inadvertently incentivizing abduction because it can perversely result in delivering financial reward to the abducting parent. Surely, case where there is a Hague Convention return order should not qualify for maintenance payments of this kind, and that is something that should be enshrined in law here. I ask the minister to help us understand what measures the government can take to ensure adequate protection of abduction victims from being penalized in this way when foreign courts reward abductors with high maintenance orders in unreasonable circumstances.

There's also an understandable concern that Britain's position outside the European Union may be influencing how such cases are handled in EU jurisdictions. There is a prevailing sense that The UK has been left out in the cold, perhaps even punished, and that other states have used the Brexit verago as a smokescreen to turn a blind eye. While the precise impact is unclear, it is a mood worth acknowledging as part of the broader context, and I wonder whether the minister may reflect on this point. I am told that the European Commission has a team actively working on these cases. Would there be an argument for a dedicated task force within the Foreign Office?

I absolutely understand the pressures our Foreign Service finds itself under in these times of geopolitical turmoil, but I would welcome minister's view. Much has been said of the fragility of international law recently. It is for countries with shared values who believe in the primacy of the rule of law and international treaties to make this case by practicing it. I would remind Warsaw, for instance, that Poland was a signatory to The Hague Convention too. In concluding, as I bring my remarks to an end, I would ask the minister to outline what support children and families can access have been the victims of abductions.

Can the minister furnish us with the statistics on repatriation, specifically from Poland? And if the minister does not have these figures to hand, will he commit to providing such information in writing to me? I also ask, perhaps naively, whether in these often highly fraught cases sufficient consideration is given to the child's perspective. The child's voice is a good place to start and to return to throughout. Our role here is not to litigate constituent cases from the chamber, but to push the government to ensure that our counterparts honor the decision of our courts, to call on them to fulfill their obligations under international law and oversee the safe and timely return of abducted children back to the country from whence they were taken.

I implore the government to bring all the diplomatic power we have to bear on this matter because British children, wherever they are sent to or taken to, deserve nothing less. Thank you.

14:25 - 14:32

Speaker 1

The question is that this house is considered the matter of international parental child abduction. Jim Shannon.

14:32 - 20:50

Speaker 3

Okay, mister chairman. Can I first of all, say what it is a pleasure to serve on your chair? It's always a pleasure to to have you in the chair, and and thank you for that. And can I thank, first of all, the honorable lady for Tiverton and Minehead for bringing this very difficult matter to the floor, a matter that is as heartbreaking as it is complex? And the honorable lady, I think, understood that very, well in her introduction.

The wrongful removal of a child from their home, and their family, and the international parental child abduction is not always merely a legal dispute. It is a profound violation of a child's security and a parent's rights. Can I say how pleased I am to see the nurse in this place? I wish him well. He he always seems to be able to encapsulate the the thoughts of us and and and whether it be in debates in this house or whether it be in questions in the chamber.

And and we thank him for his answer today. We look for some direction in releasing that. And and always a a pleasure to see the the the shadow minister in her place as well and from the Conservative Party and also from the Lib Dems. Over the years, mister Shepherd, I I've had occasions. There there wasn't many of them, but there was occasions where I've evolved with some families or relation when I was in MLA at the Northern Ireland Assembly and as an MP now in my sixteenth year here.

For my party, the Democratic Unionist Party, the protection of the family unit, the safety of our children has always always been paramount and always will be. I think that's reinforced, think, chairman. First of all, when you see your own children growing up, but it's probably reinforced even more when it comes to the to the grandchildren stage. And and I'm very much at that stage now with with with six grandchildren. We believe in a society where the rule of law is respected and where those who seek to circumvent our courts whether by crossing the REC or an international border, are held to account.

I'm not interested chairman, I'm sure you everyone will know that that filament TV, the equalizer, Denzel Washington. If you haven't seen it, it's worth watching. I I repeatedly watch it when it comes on TV. But he starts off one of those films where lady in in The United States Of America, in New York, I think it is, and her and her daughter has went missing. Went on holiday with the dad.

The the dad decided he wasn't sending her back. But then Dental Washington of course is a is a phenomenon. It's not real life. But it does illustrate that he by his very nature was able to go on a train convinced that man, the father to send his daughter back and whether whether he had four burning bodyguards to try and take on Denzel Washington. Denzel Washington was a credit card which is pretty sharp.

Was able to dispatch all four of them. So now that's that's a film. It's not real life. But sometimes we all wish we had a Denzel Washington in our corner. The man who can make things happen.

Sometimes I I I maybe I shouldn't say this. Sometimes you need to be maybe stepped slightly aside of the rules to ensure that that a son or a daughter can return home. And he did that. We welcome the progress of the crime and policing bill twenty four twenty five which is currently moving through this place. I I think the minister, not this minister who was responsible for it, but the minister was responsible for it, for all the hard work and effort that's been done to make that happen.

And and I think maybe all the the amendments from the House of Lords would come back. Really feared to say anymore about that. But I think last night none came back, so that's probably it now, laid to bed in relation to him. While it is a crime to take a child, out of the country without consent, there is a gap in our law. It has always been a very clear criminal offense to retain them abroad after a permitted holiday or or indeed a visit.

This bill corrects that injustice and ensures that the wrongful of detention is treated with the same seriousness as abduction. And I think the honorable lady again very clearly, illustrated that in her contribution to set the scene. It is a common sense change that we wholeheartedly support. Families torn apart. A mother whose son was taken on holiday with her dad.

I give you one example without naming any names. Mister Chubby And and this lady from Northern Ireland was married to a man from Lebanon. And the the child was able to go and hold a young man young boy to to Lebanon. And of course, we all know the the the Lebanon, a a country in crisis for many years trying to find out where the where the father lived and where the child was was almost impossible. And a society that closes ranks and and yet, you know, you have a a woman, a mother back home in Northern Ireland whose heart heart is breaking and and and again a difficult one to do.

Now the council were able to give some assistance in helping that, but, it it was a tragedy and difficult case. However, legislation is alone is not enough. We must ensure that the nineteen eighty hate convention is not just a piece of paper, but a working reality. When a child from Northern Ireland is taken to a foreign jurisdiction, they should be returned properly so that our local courts can decide what is in their best interest. We cannot have a situation where foreign jurisdictions become a safe haven for those who defy Northern Ireland's judicial orders.

So while I today in this debate, mister chairman, would call on the Northern Ireland executive and the Department of Justice to ensure that our central central authority for Northern Ireland is fully resourced. The issue is a UK wide one and follows quite clearly on the shoulders of the minister who's here today. And, I believe we must see a UK wide protection. Families in these crisis do not have weeks or months to wait. Every day a child is separated from their habitual home is a day of trauma.

20:51 - 21:43

Speaker 8

And and for those who who we we all love our children and love our grandchildren, but to have a child away somewhere where you feel powerless, unable to to to do something, it it must weigh heavily on the shoulders, both physically and also emotionally. So we do need a very swift decisive action, a seamless cooperation between the PSNI in Northern Ireland, the home office here, and international partners like Interpol. And I believe, mister chairman, we must continue to press for a justice system that is responsive, A border that is secure against such activity and a law a law that puts the best interest of the child at the very heart of everything we do. I look forward very much to other contributions from the two shadow ministers, but also from the minister in particular. And and I conclude with this, missus Sharon.

21:43 - 22:08

Speaker 3

Let us stand together to ensure the disunited kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is a place where every child is protected and where no parent ever has to face the agony of an empty bed because of a blatant disregard for our laws. Our laws have to be permanent. Our laws have to work for the people. And the duty of us today in this house is to ensure that our government can do that for them. Thank you so much.

22:09 - 22:11

Speaker 1

Mrs. Smart for the Lib Demerson.

22:11 - 28:53

Speaker 4

Thank you, Doctor Morrison. It really is a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. And I warmly congratulate my honourable friend, the member for Tiverton and Minehead, for securing this important debate. I'm very grateful for the opportunity to speak on such an important issue for many families across the country and beyond. Since being elected to this House, I've been approached by constituents whose situations have made it impossible for me to look away.

I have met parents who have written to me asking for support so that our legal system would protect them and their children. Some of these parents have had their children moved by the other parent, and others have fled violence, including two of my Hazelgrove constituents who I will not name because they're going through active legal cases. One of these parents fled Australia and the other Poland with their children due to domestic abuse and coercive control from their partners. In one case, the abuse was proven in court and it was so substantial that the other parents' parents, so the grandparents of the children, intervened and felt that the children should be removed from that country for the safety of them and the parent. Yet, these families have found themselves caught in a legal framework that has not accounted for what they were living through and fleeing.

The 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction was built on a sound that a child who had been wrongfully removed from their country of habitual residence should be returned promptly. In the vast majority of cases, that is absolutely the right outcome and the Convention has served many thousands of families well over the decades. The convention was drafted in 1980 and in the intervening forty six years our understanding of domestic abuse and many circumstances that had not been considered by the international, by the initial drafting of the legislation has changed enormously. I'm very grateful for the work of The Hague mothers who have helped me to understand some of the issues around these cases. They are campaigning to end injustices caused by the nineteen eighty Hague Convention on International Child Abduction, particularly for mothers fleeing domestic abuse.

And I'm very grateful to my constituents who have been to see me, both at the abductor and the other parent whose children have been abducted. The convention was originally aimed primarily at abducting fathers and was designed to ensure the quick and safe return of the child. And there's been now though a shift. And around seventy five percent of the the parents who were brought before the court are mothers, with at least seventy five percent of cases involving allegations of domestic abuse. Now, no two families are the same and no two cases can be identical, but it cannot be beyond the wit of humanity to find a way through with the interests of the children at its heart.

The Convention provides three defenses against returning a child, one of which is that doing so would expose the child to a grave risk of physical or psychological harm or otherwise place them in an intolerable situation. On paper that sounds like an adequate safeguard. In practice it has not always proven sufficient. If the abuse has not been targeted at the children but at the other parent, that's where the legal wrangling can come. It's long been argued, and the evidence bears this out, that one of the Convention's most significant shortcomings is that it failed to anticipate that some so called abductors could be domestic abuse victims fleeing their abuses.

A parent, often but not always the mother, who escapes to this country to protect themselves and their children from violence should not find themselves faced with a legal mechanism that treats them as a wrongdoer. Yet that's precisely the situation too many have found themselves in. The challenges don't end there. When a child is taken to a non convention country that has not signed up to the HAYED framework, the remedies available are even more limited. In those cases, it may be necessary to pursue legal proceedings in the country to which the child has been taken and for any parent that prospect is daunting.

Under Section one of the Child Abduction Act 1984, it's a criminal offence for a connected person to take a child out of The UK without the appropriate consent, but there is no equivalent offence where someone takes a child abroad with consent and then refuses to return them. This was identified by the Law Commission in 2014 and as my honourable friend mentioned, it's taken until the Crime and Policing Bill to begin to address it. And I welcome the legislation before Parliament that would close this loophole. But the delay is worth noting because it has caused real harm to real families. And I also want to raise the situation in Scotland because the law there operates differently and creates significant disparities in the support available.

Due to differences in criminal law, many parents whose children are wrongfully removed from Scotland cannot access the same assistance from the police as those in England and Wales. Police Scotland's powers to prevent abduction are more limited, and there are some individual cases that demonstrate with painful clarity the human cost of this inconsistency. I want to turn briefly to the Family Court, because any discussion of international child abduction must acknowledge the domestic legal backdrop against which these cases are heard. A report published last year by the Public Accounts Committee made it claim that Family Court Services were not operating as they should. Regional disparities are wide.

Waiting times are excessive, and too many children are enduring prolonged uncertainty when what they need is resolution. The Liberal Democrats have long been calling for meaningful reform. We are heartened by the results of the child focused courts pilot, which saw significantly faster resolution of cases, with the backlog in pilot areas more than halved. The child centric approach of these courts, focused on the best interests of the child rather than on adversarial process is exactly what the Family Court should embody. We welcome the decision to expand these courts across England and Wales, and we'll continue to hold the Government to account to ensure that rollout is effective and that the benefits of the pilot are reproduced nationally.

International abduction cases do not remain neatly within domestic borders. They require international cooperation, diplomatic engagement and where The Hague Convention does not apply, a willingness to pursue legal routes in foreign jurisdictions. The government should ensure that the resources, legal aid and consular support are in place to help families navigate these processes. Currently, too many parents are left to do so without adequate assistance. The Liberal Democrats are therefore calling for the Crime and Policing Bills provisions to close the Consent to Retain loophole to be passed into law without delay.

28:54 - 29:39

Speaker 16

We want to see a serious review of the disparities between Scotland and the rest of The UK so that all children receive the same standard of protection. We want to see the expansion of child focused courts delivered with the rigor and resources needed to realign their potential. We want to see the Government ensure that parents facing international abduction, particularly those fleeing domestic abuse, have access to proper legal support and are not left to navigate complex cross border legal systems alone. The law exists to protect children, and when a child is taken from a parent or when a parent is forced to flee violence with a child in tow, our legal framework should be capable of reaching the right outcome. That means being honest about the limits of international conventions, updating domestic law where it has fallen behind, and ensuring that the family courts are fit for purpose.

29:41 - 29:42

Speaker 2

You. The chair

29:42 - 29:43

Speaker 5

of the minister.

29:44 - 36:31

Speaker 6

Thank you, doctor Morrison, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today. I'd like to start by congratulating the honorable member for Tiverton and Minehead on securing this really important debate today and for shining a light on the topic of international parental child abduction. And in addition to that, providing an opportunity to highlight the devastating impact that this issue has on families. I'd like to thank the honourable member for Strangford, as ever, for his very thoughtful contributions. As we have heard today, and as many of us in this place know, cases of international parental child abduction are truly horrific and they are deeply, deeply distressing.

The breakdown of relationships is often traumatic for all involved, especially for children. But when a parent has their child abducted and taken abroad, the consequences are profound. It's not only emotionally devastating, but it's also financially draining for parents forced to fight, often for years, simply to secure contact with their child, let alone their safe return. Navigating courts, legal systems and bureaucratic processes across multiple jurisdictions is complex, it's costly, and far too often, as we've heard, it's unsuccessful. During the course of this debate, the Honourable Lady has set out how deeply concerning and troubling cases can be, and she's illustrated the scale and severity of this issue.

I also would like to pay tribute to those in the public gallery today in Parliament, but I also acknowledge that there are many, many more outside of this place who will also be affected by this issue, and many colleagues as well who are not in Westminster Hall, who've probably had items of casework in their constituency inboxes as well. And actually, I am reminded of a case in my own constituency. I'd not long come to this place, and someone from my constituency came to see me. Her child had been abducted, and together with her family and the Foreign Office, particularly the ambassador in the country concerned, they worked tirelessly over many, many months. And I have to say, in that case, they were successful, and that child was safely returned to The UK.

But I acknowledge that that is not the case for everyone. I also recognise that ministers across successive governments, alongside diplomats and officials, have worked, and do work, to raise these cases with the governments concerned. I also remember some of this from my time as a minister in the FCDO, often some of the most troubling cases that we could ever try and imagine. But progress in securing outcomes and in reuniting children with their families in The UK is too often unacceptably slow. Parents continue to fight tirelessly for their rights, yet their efforts are frequently obstructed, sometimes by the very authorities who should be upholding international law.

My right honorable friend, the shadow foreign secretary, the member of parliament for Witham, has a constituency case, which is known to the minister and the FCDO, and she has asked me to to raise this today. And this highlights these challenges very starkly. That's the case of mister Tom Tulin. Mister Tulin's daughter, Rianne, was taken to Poland in 2018 by his former partner, despite a court order explicitly prohibiting her removal from The UK. Over the past eight years, he has been unable to secure her return.

Rhianne is now 12 years old. During this time, mister Tooland has endured the anguish of missing his daughter grow up, he's missed birthdays, Christmases and countless irreplaceable moments. I'm sure we would all agree, doctor Morrison, this is truly heartbreaking. At every stage, he has faced frustration and delay despite the provisions of the Hague Convention on the civil aspects of international child abduction, despite sustained diplomatic engagement and even the issuing of a return order by the courts involved. Yet Rianne has still not been returned home, and mister Tulin's ordeal continues.

He has said, and I will quote, the Hay Convention was designed to ensure that children unlawfully abducted would be returned within six weeks, but we all know that this does not work, particularly when appeals and procedural delays are used to prevent the return of an abducted child. Having incurred legal costs exceeding £160,000, mister Tulin and others in similar situations deserve and want answers. So I'd like to use today to ask the minister a number of questions. Firstly, what further steps are being taken to support efforts to bring Rhianna home? But then I would also like to ask some more broad questions.

Can the minister outline the latest discussions he has had with international counterparts on improving the operation and effectiveness of The Hague Convention. What assurances has he received and what concrete actions will follow? Will the government establish stronger mechanisms to support the return of British children abducted overseas. Because we know this issue is not isolated. The number of international parental child abduction cases has risen significantly in recent decades.

Official figures show an increase from two seventy two cases in 2000 and three-four to five eighty in twenty twelve-thirteen, and the true figure, sadly, today may well exceed 1,000 annually. I think the truth is we do not necessarily know the full picture. So can the Minister provide an updated figure for the number of cases currently known to the Government, and how many are being directly supported by the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office? Previous governments undertook awareness campaigns to deter parents from taking children abroad unlawfully. So what further preventative measures are now being considered?

36:31 - 37:24

Speaker 10

In addition, what steps are being taken to strengthen the enforcement of court orders designed to prevent abduction, particularly through the use of border controls and travel restrictions? Finally, can the minister set out the government's approach to holding countries accountable where they fail to comply with the Hague Convention? In particular, how is the government working with both signatory and non signatory states to ensure that international obligations respected, while strengthening cooperation and preventing delays in the return process. This, Doctor Morrison, is an issue that demands urgency, it demands resolve, and it demands sustained international cooperation. For the families affected, time lost is time that can never be recovered.

37:26 - 37:27

Speaker 1

Minister.

37:29 - 38:26

Speaker 5

Thank you, doctor Morrison. It's an honor to serve under your chairmanship. I'm grateful to the honourable member for Tifton and Minehead for securing this debate. I'm also grateful for the contributions of other honourable members, particularly those who've represented their constituents' perspectives. As the Shadow Minister rightly said, this is a deeply distressing topic, I am conscious I address it in front of two colleagues who have also been Foreign Office Ministers, and I'm sure share with me our thoughts for all families affected by international parental child abduction, particularly the children who are going through such upheaval and uncertainty.

I'll respond to the points raised today while being careful not to comment on individual cases or disclose personal details. I hope the shadow for a nonsexual understand why I won't wish to comment in detail on the case she raises.

38:26 - 38:35

Speaker 6

If I may, perhaps if it's in order, the minister may be able to provide a written update to my right honorable friend, the lady for for Witham. Thank you.

38:37 - 45:58

Speaker 5

I would, of course, be happy to, and honorable members are, of course, welcome to contact me directly to discuss specific cases further. And for the aid, particularly, of the public gallery and those watching at home, I'm the minister for Consular Affairs, though for the reasons that the Shadow Minister set out, it will often be dealt with by the geographic minister, so the Minister for Europe in the case of Poland and the Minister for Indo Pacific in the case of Australia. But on these vital, wider issues of international parental child abduction, this government does take international parental child abduction extremely seriously. We are proud to be a party to the nineteen eighty eight convention. We work with more than 80 countries to support the prompt return of children to their country of habitual residence.

That is an important principle which, as I can see, has been supported across the House this afternoon. Where parents raise persistent problems with how the convention is applied, we raise those concerns directly with foreign governments and will continue to do so whenever appropriate. At the same time decisions on return ultimately rest with courts, often courts in the country where the child is located. Those courts must consider where the child is habitually resident, the child's best interest and the child's own views. Decisions about a child's long term future should be taken by the court that determines the child's habitual residence.

We have put in place clear measures to try to prevent international parental child abduction and we've published guidance on the practical steps a parent can take when they think there is a risk. I will focus, if I may, on what happens in England and Wales because, as members have pointed out, the arrangements in Scotland and Northern Ireland operate under a different law. For the purposes of clarity and time, I think it's probably best to focus on England and Wales for these purposes. But that is not to say that any member, including of course the member for Strangford or his colleagues who would like to write to me on Northern Ireland, to get Scotland and Wales questions. I'm very happy to take them up.

But in England and Wales concerned parents can get a specific issue or prohibited steps order to prevent a child from being taken out of the country. Our courts can order the passport office to temporarily withhold a British passport from a child at risk of abduction. The police can also issue a port alert if a parent is concerned their child is likely to be taken aboard without their consent within the next forty eight hours. We continue to support our charity partner, Reunite International, which also provide online prevention guides for not just England and Wales but Scotland and Northern Ireland too to help parents understand and navigate the options of support available to them. When a child is abducted and taken aboard, our Consular staff provide compassionate support to the family.

That can include practical guidance on travel, local systems and procedures, and help making contact with the local authorities. At the request of either parent, the foreign office can also formally express an interest in the case with the courts or authorities involved. We can also help families access specialist support, including through Reunite International, who should be able to provide expert advice. In relation to the nineteen eighty Hate Convention, The UK works closely with authorities seeking a return for parents. Our central authorities stay engaged throughout the process until the courts have reached a final decision.

It is, of course, important to be clear on roles. Decisions on enforcement rest with the authorities and courts of the country where the child is located. Our consular responsibilities mean that we cannot interfere in foreign legal systems just as we would not accept foreign powers interfering in ours. We cannot compel enforcement or influence court outcomes or take part in any illegal efforts to return a child. I haven't seen the film that the member for Strangford describes, but I'm not sure I can use a credit card in the way that he outlined to secure returns, however frustrating that is.

And I do recognize the deep frustration many parents experience, especially when cases face long delays or return orders are not enforced. In those circumstances, the government raises concerns with foreign partners at senior levels and presses them to meet their obligations under the convention. Let me turn to Poland as it's a country raised by a number of honorable members. It is, of course, a close European partner and the member spoke the honorable member spoke movingly about the shared history between our two countries, a history we have in my constituency of Lincoln too, where so many of those pilots set up permanent residence. But it is also, as she says, one of the countries where we have the highest number of outstanding Hague return orders affecting British parents.

We recognize the serious impact this has, that Poland has not enforced a number of return orders, and that concern is reflected in rulings by the European Court of Human Rights and actioned by the European Commission. That's why we raise international parental child with the Polish authorities consistently and at senior levels. I can confirm that the deputy prime minister has raised it with Poland's deputy prime minister, Sikorsky, in January. The foreign secretary raised it with Polish counterparts in October. And earlier this month, the British ambassador in Warsaw wrote to the Polish minister of justice alongside eight other diplomatic missions to seek a meeting and press for progress on these cases.

So I would reassure the honorable member that The UK continues to play a forward role. Some of those other eight countries are members of the EU and others are not. Our officials also continue to engage regularly with Polish authorities on enforcement. In April 2025, the UK Ministry of Justice hosted a joint workshop alongside my department for Polish and The UK authorities. We shared UK best practice on enforcement and discussed closer cooperation.

We'll continue to work with Poland and with other partners to improve enforcement and outcomes for children and families. I recognize the sensitivity and delicacy of some of the issues raised in relation to violence against women and girls, the very sensitive questions around domestic abuse, and we recognise that there are concerns raised in some contexts about how the nineteen eighty Hague Convention operates in cases involving domestic abuse. That's why we've sought to take a leading international role, serving on the steering committee of two K Conference Forums examining how the conventions operate where domestic abuse is present. And I think both of those forums have been in the last two years. This is an active and ongoing effort on our part.

46:00 - 46:58

Speaker 2

At home, we are working closely with victims' organizations, the devolved governments and the senior family judiciary in England and Wales, and I'm grateful for the honorable member's kind recognition of the progress made recently in tightening the law in this area. We are also commissioning research into how the convention operates in domestic abuse cases so future policy is grounded in evidence and focused on improving outcomes for children and survivors. For countries that have not yet joined the nineteen eighty convention, we actively encourage accession through both bilateral and multilateral engagement while also seeking solutions to existing cases in exactly the way the Shadow Minister describes. Some of those efforts include the Malta process, which aims to improve cross cooperation in cross border family law disputes involving children. We also work with Reunite International to support mediation as an alternative to court proceedings.

46:59 - 48:37

Speaker 5

Last month in Lagos, our deputy high commissioner hosted a workshop with Nigerian partners focused on international parental child abduction and family mediation. Members were asking me for figures recently. If the Honourable Member will permit me, I might ask the Minister of Europe to write to her specifically on Poland cases. But in terms of the cases which the Foreign Office are aware of, in 2024 it was one hundred and seventy seven. In 2025 it was one hundred and sixty seven.

We recognize the profound distress caused by international parental child abduction, and we do take these cases extremely seriously. We work with partners through the nineteen eighty Hague Convention. We raise concerns about enforcement and noncompliance at the highest level, and we press for improvement where systems fall short. We recognize that decisions on return ultimately rest with the courts and the authorities in the country where the child is located, so we must work with our partners abroad to try and build up their capacity where we are concerned about it. On a personal note, supporting British Nationals overseas remains a core public service performed by my department, and it is a key priority for me personally.

We remain committed to prevention, stronger international cooperation, and supported supporting affected children and families throughout what I know is often a long and painful process. And I join with the honorable member in paying tribute to the family members in the galleries.

48:39 - 48:41

Speaker 1

Rachel Gilmore to wind up.

48:41 - 50:10

Speaker 2

Thank you, doctor Morrison. Could I start by thanking the minister for his very inclusive and thorough response to some of the concerns raised today, and I will be certainly be writing to him on behalf of my constituent who is sitting behind me. I'd also like to thank the obviously very doting father and grandpa and omnipresent member for Strangford for his contribution today and really quite an imaginative one, it was it was too. And as ever, my honorable colleague, the member for Hazelgrove, who has put the right and honorable and proper Liberal Democrat policy at the heart of her contribution. And it was a real privilege for me today to listen to the shadow minister, the right honorable member for Aldridge of Brown Hills, who brings a great deal of experience and knowledge to the debate.

And it's something that as a new member of parliament, I have learned a lot from, and I thank her very very much for her contribution. Some of you might have heard a little noise going on behind me. The little noise is called Kit and he's three months old. And Kit is beautiful, articulate and vocal but Kit too is a victim of child abduction because Kit will never meet his half brothers and sisters. So what we have talked about today can affect the oldest and the very youngest and that is why it is so important.

50:12 - 50:29

Speaker 1

This house is considered a matter of international parental child abduction. The question is that this house is considered the matter of international parental child abduction. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. To the contrary, no.

50:29 - 01:30:12

Speaker 15

I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Order, order. This sitting is adjourned until 4PM. Order, order.

01:30:12 - 01:30:32

Speaker 1

I'm going to call Matt Vickers to move the motion and I'll then call the Minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission from the member in charge of the debate and the minister. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up as is the convention for thirty minute debates. Order. Order.

Matt Figgars to move the motion.

01:30:32 - 01:31:28

Speaker 7

Thank you, doctor Morrison. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Our firefighters are heroes. They're the people who put their lives on the line to protect us all. Whilst others run from danger, they run towards it.

It's only right that we support them with colleagues, the equipment, and the funding they need to do their job properly. Use today's debate to highlight the ongoing and serious challenges facing fire and rescue services, including Cleveland Fire Brigade, which serves my community in Stockton, as well as Hartlepool, Middlesbrough, and Redker in Cleveland. I also want to take this opportunity to pay tribute to all the firefighters and support staff in fire brigades across the country, particularly those who work for the Cleveland and Durham fire brigades. I've met many of them on many shadow shifts and got to see firsthand their incredible skill, determination, commitment and bravery.

01:31:33 - 01:32:01

Speaker 11

Employees at Devon and Somerset Fire and Rescue Services tell me funding cuts have seen shift systems worsen, rope water and animal rescue services scaled back and watches usually running with around six firefighters instead of nine. Does the Honourable member agree that this has put an unaccepted pressure on stretched fire, rural fire and rescue teams and will cause a damaging workforce and equipment crisis, all of which may ultimately put people's lives at risk?

01:32:01 - 01:32:42

Speaker 7

I think a lot of fire service across the country are facing huge challenges. I think the debate today will probably draw out some of challenges that are unique to rural communities, to coastal communities, and other such communities. We want to see these firefighters back for their safety, for the safety of the communities we serve, and and wider safety piece across the whole. Our firefighters worked tirelessly day in and day out to protect our community, and we all owe them our thanks. We should be incredibly proud of their work in challenging circumstances.

Of course, it's right that efforts are made to ensure our public services are as efficient as possible, optimizing outcomes and spending public money wisely.

01:32:46 - 01:33:15

Speaker 2

To the right honourable member for giving way. He agree with me that it's very important that any reorganisation of services involves the engagement of firefighters, because they know the service best and they know the needs best? Would he share my relief with the fact that Oxfordshire County Council is backed away from what would have been a botched reorganization, reducing support from my constituents in Oxford City and indeed across the county by not listening enough to what firefighters said was needed? Thank you.

01:33:15 - 01:33:45

Speaker 7

I think it's hugely important that the firefighters are involved in those discussions. I think it's hugely important that communities, are also involved in those discussions so that we can get the best structure that works best for the communities involved. Over recent years, Cleveland Fire Brigade has achieved this and made difficult decisions, streamlining operations, managing workforce numbers, and finding efficiencies wherever possible. But there comes a point where continued pressure risks undermining resilience. The latest go on.

Yeah.

01:33:45 - 01:34:17

Speaker 3

I thank the honorable member for giving way, but also for securing this very important debate. And I'd like to declare an interest as the chair of the FBU parliamentary group. They are calling FBU are calling for increased investment, and they say without it, kill. But will my honorable member agree with me and recognize that 14 of austerity has led to more than 12,000 firefighter jobs being cut.

01:34:17 - 01:34:42

Speaker 7

So I'm sure we should also recognize that the situation is getting worse, not better. Across the country, despite the fact we're paying record levels of tax, our fire services are under pressure. We might wanna talk about the history of it. I wanna talk about what's gonna happen in my community in the coming months as they may they they make hay with this horrendous settlement that could see the number of firefighters in my community reduced, and that's why I'm here. I will give way.

01:34:42 - 01:35:19

Speaker 3

James, can I come in? First of just three weeks ago, we had a massive fire in in at at Currie's Farm. Currie's Farm outside Newton Ords, and while the fire service personnel were absolutely excellent in in how they responded, the issue was about the access to water pressure. In rural communities, access to rural pressure is always less. And one of the solutions is to have a water tanker in each district.

Now that means capital expenditure. But those gentlemen feel sometimes when it comes to responding to fires in rural areas, for example, there needs to be a new look at how they respond and what they do.

01:35:19 - 01:36:40

Speaker 7

I think you're entirely right. I think that ensuring that we've got the right capabilities and the right resources to be able to respond to issues in rural communities often requires technology, often requires capital investment. I think it's important that that's put into the mix as we look at what this funding settlement will look like. We're trying make a little bit of progress. The government's latest settlement takes things a step too far, with huge concerns raised about the impact on frontline services, the safety of the public, and of our brave firefighters.

Through the dedication of our firefighters and sound leadership, Cleveland Fire Brigade has one of the fastest response times in the country for fires in the home, as well as one of the highest rates of home fire safety visits. They serve almost 580,000 people from urban town centers to rural and coastal communities, as well as Teaside's significant industrial assets. Cleveland faces a series of unique challenges. It's a small force, less able to spread or absorb costs through economies of scale. It serves a disproportionately large and complex industrial landscape covering petrochemical sites, heavy manufacturing and complex infrastructure.

It serves an area with significant pockets of deprivation linked to higher incident rates. I will.

01:36:40 - 01:37:09

Speaker 17

Thank you, Doctor. Nourishan. The Honourable Gentleman is making an excellent point in advocating for his area. Does he agree with me that sometimes cuts can inadvertently have a very damaging effect on neighbouring areas? In my own county of Berkshire, there's an excellent fire service, cuts that were proposed in neighboring Oxfordshire would have meant that appliances from Reading would have had to travel 25 up to 25 miles outside of Reading to serve and cover for their colleagues, leaving Reading itself exposed.

01:37:09 - 01:37:13

Speaker 10

Does he agree with me that this is not a great way to address these problems?

01:37:13 - 01:38:05

Speaker 18

I think cross border support, mutual aid is vitally important. It's important for us to understand the profile of those areas and where those demands take us when we invest as we should in our fire services. I think as well as the deprivation links to higher incident rates, greater vulnerabilities, and increased need for community safety interventions, Cleveland has long been associated with levels, higher levels of deliberate fires, at times earning the label of The UK's arson capital, placing a disproportionate demand on prevention work as well as frontline response. It's amongst the busiest nonmetropolitan fire brigades in the entire country, and it's getting busier. This unique mix means the financial settlement is uniquely harmful to the safety of firefighters and the public in my community.

01:38:05 - 01:38:36

Speaker 7

It stretches them to breaking point. Steve Wright, general secretary of the fire brigades union, has said that our fire services face a real terms cut that puts lives at risk. When someone calls 999, they are in an emergency. Panic. It could be a fire in their home or community, a traffic incident, someone drowning.

They deserve nothing less than a quick, fully staffed, and fully equipped response. This settlement puts that at risk.

01:38:36 - 01:39:04

Speaker 11

I will. I'm grateful to my old friend for giving way, and he's making a superb speech. In Buckinghamshire, the Lib Dem led fire authority have consulted on removing a third of Buckinghamshire and Milton Keane's fire engines and closing two fire stations, Stoke And Church and Great Missingdon, in my constituency. At this time where risk is increasing, we're seeing more fires, not least from things like battery storage, now is not the time to be reducing frontline firefighting capability.

01:39:04 - 01:39:35

Speaker 7

I couldn't agree more. Even as the Fiber Guides Union puts it, these cuts are putting lives at risk. The inability to respond to the increasing number of fires and hazards has real consequences for real people out there in our communities. Cleveland Fire Brigade is currently facing a significant deficit even if council taxpayers are hit with the highest possible increase in precept. Cleveland's medium term financial strategy shows a three year deficit of £1,200,000

01:39:35 - 01:40:04

Speaker 5

I'm really grateful to Don Brown for giving away. Dorset and Wiltshire Fire Service has a similar deficit of £1,500,000 and I don't think this is about party politics because the fire authority actually can only work with what it's got. Would the honourable member agree with me that we need to work cross party to encourage the government to properly fund all of our fire services so that we can protect all of our residents regardless of who runs their fire authority?

01:40:04 - 01:41:19

Speaker 7

I think, a, we've got to see that funding from central government put in place to make sure that we can run safe, meaningful fire services. And b, within that envelope, we've also got to make sure that local fire authorities do spend wisely with that money. I think in recent years, many of them have looked at those efficiencies. We're now getting to a point where we need to go further than that, and government needs to step up. Like other businesses and organizations, our fire brigades have been hit with the national insurance increase with spiraling energy costs and the need to ensure our firefighters receive a fair pay settlement.

If the fire precept is not increased in the coming years, the funding gap in Cleveland could rise to nearly £4,000,000. But the answer, mister Morrison, is not to simply increase council tax even further. In my part of the world, Stockholm's Labour Council has already increased council tax by 54 since 2016. It's for this Labour government to fund our fire services properly and to fix the fund fair funding formula, the apparently fair funding formula, which is damaging Cleveland and Durham fire brigades. I'm sure the minister will say that Cleveland's cost spending power has increased, but as the chief fire officer has told me himself, it's nowhere near enough to meet the increasing cost pressures.

01:41:19 - 01:41:21

Speaker 9

Will the honors will never give away?

01:41:21 - 01:41:22

Speaker 7

I will. Our

01:41:23 - 01:41:59

Speaker 13

area of Dorset and Wiltshire are told that we will have to face the closure of potentially of eight fire stations across our area. At a time when we do not know what is happening quite apart from anything else on the international scene, when people are talking of dark days ahead, does the honourable member not agree with me that at this time, to be cutting these essential services seems total and utter madness?

01:41:59 - 01:44:25

Speaker 7

I couldn't agree more. I think more than ever actually, see fire services that are lean, are efficient, have undergone all sorts of savings. We've now got to the point where you haven't got the fat. You're hitting the bone, and we can't go on like this without real consequences for public safety. I'm sure the minister will say, in fact, I've done that.

These funding decisions have real consequences for Cleveland, including a likely reduction in frontline firefighters and cuts to the number of fire appliances. Demand on our firefighters is rising. It's not acceptable to ask them to do even more with even less. Of course, it's not just our fire brigades that are under pressure. I've also heard from Cleveland Mountain Rescue, a hugely valued voluntary mountain rescue team providing vital cover at fell races and mountain bikes event.

Is the government thanking them for their incredible service and commitment? No. It's hitting them with CQC registration and inspection regimes, more bureaucracy, more intake, and more costs. If the mountain rescue team are forced to reduce their services as a result of this, this will create yet more pressure on our local fire brigades. Has the minister looked at the consequences of these changes and the impact this could have on fire services?

There is a broader point. Whether it's Cleavan Fire Brigade facing funding pressures or Cleavan Mountain Rescue facing new bureaucracy, the government must support the people who protect the public, not make the job harder. Cleveland Fire Brigade is one of the busiest nonmetropolitan fire services in the country in terms of incidents per head of population. They attend six times the national average number of deliberate fires. Last year alone, the service saw 25% increase in arson and deliberate fire incidents, and these are incidents which cause huge concern within our communities.

The government's fair funding approach is neither fair nor reflective of this need. It systematically disadvantages areas such as Stockton On Tees in the wider Cleveland area. It creates unacceptable risks for emergency response and public safety because it fails to recognize local need. Factors such as individual risk, levels of deprivation and geographic complexity must be given proper weighting. Will.

01:44:25 - 01:45:12

Speaker 14

Thank you, honourable member, for giving way and for securing this debate. I'd like to firstly just thank Dorset and Wilshire Fire Service for their response to the Newell House Fire in Sherbourne. The other night. I am in awe of their their bravery. They were on the scene within eight minutes.

But he talks about the particular issues facing his fire service. Dorset faces a near 50% increase in its population during the summer months, as well as the issues of rurality and being a coastal community. But fundamentally the issue in the funding model is that the government's assumptions on our population increase in terms of increases in council tax revenue are just wrong. The fire service has proven that they're wrong. If we don't have a fair funding formula, then how on earth are we ever going to provide the services to the local communities that they deserve?

01:45:12 - 01:47:04

Speaker 7

He has the pleasure of representing a beautiful part of the world. Sherburn is a very beautiful perhaps that needs proper fire protection. I think he's right. I think the consideration that we talked about today through deprivation, through industrial sites and the challenges that they pose, but moreover, about actually knowing how many people live in an area and how many homes have to be protected by the fire service are pretty fundamental, and we need to be getting that right. This unfair funding settlement could mean fire engines arriving at emergencies without enough crew to respond effectively and save lives.

Or worse still, engines not leaving the station at all because there are not enough firefighters to staff them. Last month, Stockbridge Council passed a motion highlighting that the government's approach to public service funding has failed to deliver genuinely fair or needs based funding for fire and rescue services, as well as policing and local government. A letter's been sent by the council outlining these concerns and setting out the stark reality of the situation. However, we've yet to receive a response. Will the minister confirm whether she's in discussions with the treasury about the challenges facing our fire services, and what action will be taken to properly fund Cleveland and Durham fire brigades?

If this issue is not addressed, it will force difficult decisions on staffing, equipment, and service delivery, and ultimately shift the burden of national funding failures onto local residents. This government has increased taxes to record levels. The chancellor's first two budgets have raised taxes by £36,000,000,000 and £26,000,000,000 respectively, pushing the overall tax burden to a historic high. Yet we've seen cuts to the number of police on our streets and now potentially cuts to our fire services. I hope the minister will be able to provide answers.

I will give you.

01:47:04 - 01:47:30

Speaker 3

Just one very quick one. Should have said it earlier on, but I don't think it's been mentioned. Back home in North Nam, we've had an issue with gorse fires on the on the peak and the mountains. We've had two massive fires just there last weekend. Does he share my concern as the summer comes in and hot weather comes, hopefully, that along with that comes the threat of of gorse fires and the loss of peatland and farmland.

Is that not something that should be motivating the minister and this government to respond positively?

01:47:31 - 01:48:58

Speaker 7

I I think certainly the pressures of the summer and the consequences that we know for rural communities, but also the fact that fire authorities across the country are now having to make incredibly tough decisions about what they're sourcing, about the people that they can employ. And it's a pressure point that is moving at a hell of a pace. So, yeah, we need a quick response to this challenge. We've seen cuts to the numbers off, please. Oh, oh goodness.

I hope the minister will be able to provide answers and reassurance on some of the points that people have raised today. What is the government planning to do to properly support Cleveland and Durham Fire Brigade and their significant financial shortfalls? How will the minister and the government fix the fair funding formula to ensure that communities like mine in Stockton and across Teeside are treated fairly? If we fail to fund our fire services properly, we put lives at risk. Firefighters in our communities have raised the alarm repeatedly.

Their concerns cannot be ignored. The service responsible for protecting us is being asked to do too much with too little. I urge the minister to carefully consider the points that have been raised to work with colleagues to deliver a financial settlement that's fair, forward looking, and reflective of the unique challenges faced by Cleveland and Durham fire brigades. Listen to firefighters. Listen to fire chiefs.

Listen to local residents and communities who are deeply concerned. Invest in our fire services and keep us all safe.

01:49:00 - 01:49:04

Speaker 1

Considered funding for fire and rescue services. Minister.

01:49:04 - 01:51:36

Speaker 15

Thank you, doctor Morrison, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, particularly given your specific interest in this particular matter. And I'd like to thank the honorable member for Stockton West for securing this important debate and the consistent way in which he raises it in the house and in his role as shadow minister for crime policing and fire. I welcome the opportunity to set out the government's position. We all know and members have contributed today to the role that fire and rescue services play in keeping people safe every day. Firefighters and fire service staff protect lives, prevent harm and provide reassurance to communities.

Alongside responding to fires they attend road traffic collisions, floods, wildfires and other emergencies. They deliver vital prevention and protection activity and increasingly support wider resilience efforts as other members have mentioned at local and national level. To carry out this work effectively, fire and rescue services rely on a mix of funding from central government, council tax precept, retained business rates and specific rate grants. Getting that framework right is essential, particularly at a time when services face changing risks, increasing complexity and growing demands beyond traditional fire incidents. I think the Honourable Member for Liverpool Riverside got it particularly correct.

Fourteen years of conservative austerity have absolutely battered our fire and rescue services. Fourteen years of conservative cuts to local authority and fire service budgets has left many areas operating on a shoestring with 20% of firefighter capacity lost across the country in that period. And throughout this period, the FBU, the Fire Brigades Union and its membership have worked tirelessly to protect the public and do more with less. We're working hard to remedy this, and that's why the twenty twenty six-twenty seven local government finance settlement marks a significant change. After decade of short term settlements, it delivers the first multi year funding settlement for local government in ten years, which gives fire and rescue authorities the stability and the certainty they need to plan ahead, invest in their workforce and estates, and make sound long term decisions in the industrial bubbles.

Point.

01:51:36 - 01:51:37

Speaker 2

Miss Gimmer.

01:51:37 - 01:51:41

Speaker 15

I will give way to the minister from Liverpool Riverside.

01:51:41 - 01:52:07

Speaker 9

Thank the minister for giving way. This morning, I met with Anne Davies, whose husband, Jeff, became the first UK firefighter to have his death from cancer officially recorded as caused by the job. So does my honorable friends agree with me that this investment into the fire and rescue service will provide the necessary equipment so that no more firefighters die as a result of industrial injuries.

01:52:07 - 01:52:54

Speaker 15

I'd just like to point out to my honorable friend the speech made by the secretary of state for health at the recent FBU conference announcing welfare checks for fire and rescue service, members, and I think that's a significant move forward and will protect the workforce, for the future. And I think that's really important and something that is welcomed across the sector. Importantly, since the provisional settlement, the government's also secured an additional £15,000,000 for fire and rescue services. This makes sure a minimum uplift of 3.8% in core spending power in 2026 for all standalone FRAs, with some services receiving increases of over 7%.

01:52:55 - 01:52:57

Speaker 1

Yes. A slave.

01:52:57 - 01:53:28

Speaker 12

A buggie of the minister of a given way on that point. Dorset And Wiltshire's fire and rescue service core spending power is only going up over the three years because of the increase to local taxpayers. The actual amount being provided is going down, not just in real terms, but in in in actual cash terms. We simply do not have enough money to keep our fire stations open. Will the minister commit to meet with us again to look at reforming our funding formula for Dorset and Wiltshire?

01:53:28 - 01:53:28

Speaker 5

Yeah. Yeah.

01:53:29 - 01:54:56

Speaker 15

Thank the member for Mid Dorset and North Pole for her comments. I will come on to how the government is addressing the entire reform of the funding settlement for the fire and rescue services shortly because I think it's an important point that all members who've attended this afternoon need to understand for the context of our future fire and rescue services. Turning specifically to the honorable members constituency of Cleveland Fire and Rescue Authority, which serves Stockton West. They will have access to £37,800,000 in core spending power in twenty sixtwenty seven, which is an increase of 3.8% and provides the authority with greater certainty as to how it plans to best serve the communities of Stockton On Tees and the wider Cleveland areas. While government sets the national funding framework however, decisions about how resources are deployed locally must rightly remain with fire and rescue authorities and chief fire officers.

I think they are best placed to understand local risk and demand through their community risk management plans and to make operational decisions in consultation with the workforce and communities. And I think speaks to the wider point members have made about local decisions and reflecting local needs. I'm grateful

01:54:56 - 01:55:24

Speaker 11

to the minister for giving way. But in Buckinghamshire and Milton Keynes, there was a consultation. The public overwhelmingly said no to the cuts that that fire authority was pushing, and firefighters very clearly said no. This is crazy. Don't do it.

So how can the government actually ensure that fire authorities that are making local decisions must reflect those very, very important views, not just of the public, but of firefighters themselves?

01:55:25 - 01:55:55

Speaker 15

Fire authorities by and large, to speak to the honorable member's point, are locally elected representatives. They are accountable to their communities. They should serve their local communities. They need to respond to what they're hearing from consultations, and I think that's an important point for members from Dorset and Wiltshire. They need to actually respond to what their local communities are doing in the way that the Oxfordshire Fire and Rescue Service have also done to done in recent days.

01:55:55 - 01:57:03

Speaker 13

I'm going to make some progress if if that's okay. The government is command is is committed to not only providing stable funding, but also contributing, to continue to work with the fire sector to make sure the funding system remains fair and responsive. Funding allocations for fire and rescue authorities are determined through a national funding formula which assesses relative need using factors such as population and other cost and demand drivers. The current fire funding formula was designed over a decade ago and as part of the fair funding review and following consultation, the government updated the relative needs formula for fire and rescue using the most up to date data available and changes in individual authorities allocations so that they reflect updated data within the formula. Now looking ahead, and this is the really important point to speak to the member from Mid Dorset and North Poole, We've committed to working with the fire sector on a comprehensive review of the formula ahead of the next spending review.

01:57:03 - 01:57:28

Speaker 15

As part of this engagement, every fire and rescue service in England has been invited to participate in sector engagement workshops, the first of which is taking place today in Manchester. It includes chief fire officers, heads of finances, and relevant officers. It's a really important opportunity to reform funding for the future.

01:57:28 - 01:57:30

Speaker 4

Won't she give me on that front?

01:57:30 - 01:57:31

Speaker 15

Yes. I will.

01:57:31 - 01:57:46

Speaker 16

I'm very grateful. I'm also a member of the EU parliamentary group. I understand the consultations that actually going on, and we welcome them with regard to the formula. Could I ask her to ensure that the trade union representatives are built in to those regional consultations that are taking place?

01:57:47 - 01:59:09

Speaker 15

I'd like to thank the honorable member for his his point because it brings me to the work of the ministerial advisory group, a group that was established following our manifesto commitment to work with the entire sector. The Ministerial Advisory Group involves the National Fire Chiefs Council, the Inspectorate, the Fire Standards Board, the National Joint Council, the Local Government Association and the Fire Brigades Union. They sit at the table, they're looking at reform of the role of the firefighter, reform of the funding for the fire sector and also the wider sector reform in terms of governance and arrangements like that. I have asked that group to be bold in their decision making because after the past fourteen years, this sector cannot continue in the way that it is. We need to support them as fully as we can.

I think local fire authorities need to listen to their communities, work with their communities and also work with government to try and support their communities as we go forward. I think that funding is only one part of the of the picture. There is exciting work ahead of us. There is a generational opportunity, and this government is determined to seize it. Thank you.

01:59:09 - 02:00:15

Speaker 1

The question is that this house has considered funding for fire and rescue services. Has any SRF that opinion say aye? With the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

Order. Order. Order, order. Sir Andrew Mitchell to move the motion.

02:00:17 - 02:03:18

Speaker 17

Doctor Morrison, I beg to move that this House has considered a national strategy on accident prevention across The United Kingdom. I want to draw the House's attention today to what can only be described as a silent and spiralling crisis in our country, the devastating human cost of preventable accidents. This is not a new issue but it is one that is getting worse and crucially it is one that is still not given the level of sustained national attention that its scale demands. Too often people think of accidents as tragic misfortune, but they are often ordinary moments, a fall at home, a collision on the road, an accident at work, a lapse in safety in a familiar environment. Every member of the House here will recognise the pattern.

We hear it in our advice surgeries, we receive the letters, we take the calls, we meet parents who have lost children, spouses who have lost partners, children who have lost a parent in circumstances that are sudden, awful and preventable. Towards the end of last year, following two road fatalities in our community in the Royal Town Of Sutton Coalfield, over the course of a week and the recent drowning of a teenager in Sutton Park, I had the most valuable experience of meeting a long standing resident of Royal Sutton Coalfield, Becky Hickman, is the Chief Executive Officer of ROSPA, the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents, who has championed accident prevention at the national level for over twenty years. Indeed, she is in the gallery today. One of these horrific accidents took place on Friday August 22 when tragically 21 year old Natasha Thorpe was struck by a car in Brassington Avenue in my constituency and died shortly afterwards. I've had the privilege of getting to know this family a little and joining Natasha's father and members of her family for the installation of a memorial bench that has recently been installed in Sutton Park overlooking the Blackroot Pool.

It is hard, Doctor Morrison, to describe the life changing trauma they have suffered. But they are not alone. I should be clear that Ross Per and I welcome the DFT's new road safety strategy. But it is a small part of a much bigger issue and strategy. Road traffic accidents are sadly not isolated events and nor do accidental deaths and injuries only happen on the roads.

Tragedies can occur at home, at work, and indeed when out in open spaces. I will give way. Yes.

02:03:18 - 02:03:19

Speaker 1

I thank

02:03:19 - 02:03:57

Speaker 14

the honourable gentleman for giving way. One of the gaps that we consistently see is in water safety, and it's the interventions that are often reactive rather than preventative. Through my work on Sam's Law, following the tragic death of a young boy in a local reservoir to me in Yorkshire, I've been working with organizations such as Rossifer and the Royal Life Saving Society and the Fire and Rescue Services to develop a clear risk based approach for water safety, including guidance on when and how life saving equipment should be provided. Does the honorable member agree that a national accident prevented prevention strategy must bring together those kinds of organizations who have that experience and that knowledge to make sure that those sorts of incidents never happen again.

02:03:58 - 02:07:00

Speaker 17

Yes, I'm extremely grateful to the Honourable Gentleman for making that intervention. As you will see as I develop my speech, I very much agree with him. In Birmingham, have the seventh highest number of accidental deaths in England. Each year more than five hundred and fifty families in our city lose a loved one due to a preventable accident. That is more than one death every single day.

Across the West Midlands, over two thousand people die annually due to accidents, the equivalent of wiping out a small village year after year. Nationally we have seen an eight percent rise in accidental death rates and a three percent increase in hospital admissions in just one year. Over the past decade accidental death rates have risen by over forty percent. That is not a blip, not a statistical anomaly and not a short term fluctuation. It is a serious problem that has been brushed under the carpet for too long.

There is also a wider national cost to this issue. Accidents place a significant and growing burden on the National Health Service. Every preventable injury that results in an emergency admission adds pressure to already stretched A and E departments, ambulance services and hospital wards. We are talking, Doctor Morrison, about millions of bed days every year linked to accident related admissions. Accidents now are believed to cost us at least £6,000,000,000 annually in NHS medical care.

The impact on NHS staff is also profound. Doctors, nurses, paramedics and support staff are dealing daily with injuries and emergencies that, in many cases could have been prevented. That is not only a clinical challenge but also a human one placing additional strain on a workforce that is already under great pressure. And the burden extends across the economy. When people are injured, they are often unable to work, sometimes temporarily, sometimes permanently.

Families lose income, employers lose skilled workers, productivity falls. The country loses millions of working days each year due to accident related absence. The combined cost to UK business is now estimated at about £6,000,000,000 every year. Taken together, this represents a hidden but substantial cost to the country, to our health service, to our economy and to our public finances. The truth is, Doctor Morrison, that we can do better.

And indeed, we have done better before. We know what works: safer homes, stronger product standards, effective public awareness campaigns, improved design of public spaces, better data collection and coordinated action across government and local agencies.

02:07:00 - 02:07:23

Speaker 14

I will. Thank you, honorable member for giving right. Honorable member for giving away. He mentions data there. 28 year old Benedict Solly was killed on the A-thirty 7 near Surin Abbas at a notorious accident hotspot, and there were plenty of interventions that local residents have been calling on to make that junction safe.

02:07:24 - 02:07:46

Speaker 20

But part of the problem is the decision on whether or not to make an intervention at that junction is based on historical data, which is only recording actual collisions, not near misses, not near accidents avoided, all of those other things. Does he agree with me that actually we need a wider data set in order to inform the interventions that we make to avoid the fatal accidents occurring?

02:07:47 - 02:08:33

Speaker 17

Well, the Honourable Gentleman makes an a good point and he adds that particular tragedy to the tragedies which I have already mentioned. Of course, he is right that with modern technology racing ahead in so many ways, our data should be better and more effective at informing the decisions that are made. He made that point with great eloquence. Yet what Doctor Morrison is currently lacking is a clear, coherent and sustained national strategy to bring these efforts together. At present responsibility for accident prevention is fragmented across multiple departments health, transport, housing, education and others.

02:08:33 - 02:09:42

Speaker 12

The result is a system where responsibility is dispersed, coordination is inconsistent and prevention too often falls between institutional gaps. And that is why I believe there is now a compelling case for a national accident prevention strategy. Such a strategy would have benefits across the whole of government be it safer roads for the Department of Transport, reduced pressure on the National Health Service for Department of Health and Social Care, less spending on benefits for people unable to work due to accidents for the Department for Work and Pensions and higher productivity for the Treasury. As such a national accident prevention strategy must be led by the Cabinet Office which has the oversight necessary to set cross government priorities and coordinate and align the activities of different departments to achieve them. Becky Hickman and Rothbauer should be asked to produce a report for the government on what such a strategy might look like.

02:09:42 - 02:10:06

Speaker 17

It should in my view be based on a few clear principles. First, ministerial leadership at the center of government ensuring accountability and direction. Second, a clear focus on prevention rather than simply reacting after harm has occurred. The very point that the honourable gentleman was making just a moment ago. Of course.

02:10:06 - 02:10:35

Speaker 8

I thank the right honourable gentleman for giving way. Rural communities face unique challenges when it comes to prevention and addressing accidents. We are more isolated, have terrible signal, roads more likely to lead to crashes, and agriculture is Britain's most dangerous industry. Does the honorable member agree that any national accident prevention strategies must focus on reality and must and be matched by proper investment in public health funding, areas like Somerset have always lost out on?

02:10:35 - 02:13:40

Speaker 17

I think I do agree with what the hon. Gentleman has said, except I wouldn't wish to make a particular case for the countryside. I think this affects all parts of our country. As he will know, the Royal Town Of Sutton Caulfield is an ancient royal town, not therefore part of the countryside as such. Although we do have in the Royal Town Of Sutton Coalfield the biggest municipal park in Europe.

So we at least doff our caps to the issue of rurality. I was listing the number of clear principles, Doctor Morrison, that I thought should inform a report of the type I have described. I mentioned two, the third is indeed the better use of data so that we understand where risks are emerging, where interventions are needed and whether policies are working. So I suspect I will carry the two honourable gentlemen who have intervened on me on that point. Fourth, a serious focus on those most at risk of accidental harm.

And fifth and finally a sustained approach to public education and awareness so that safety is embedded across the life course from childhood through to older age. I want to return, doctor Morrison, briefly to the human reality behind all of this. A child walking to school, a friend cooking a meal at home, a parent swimming in the sea on holiday, ordinary stories with tragic endings. We all, as members of parliament, know of searingly heartbreaking, awful occurrences like poor Natasha's death. We have the evidence, we have the tools, we have the example of other countries such as Australia and Finland where coordinated government accident prevention strategies are already in place.

What is missing in The UK is the sustained national leadership to bring them together. We should not accept a situation in which tens of thousands of lives are lost each year to preventable accidents. We should not accept a system that is fragmented when lives depend on coordination. And we should not accept avoidable suffering when the knowledge, tools and capacity to prevent it already exist. Because ultimately this is not just about policy.

It is about whether we are prepared to act on what we already know, that far too many lives are being lost unnecessarily and that this does not have to be the case. Above all, doctor Morrison, all these are non party political points. There is no party politics in this. I am appealing to the good sense and experience of all members of this house in hope that together we can support the government in driving this agenda forward with vigor. The

02:13:41 - 02:13:48

Speaker 1

question is that this House is considered the potential merits of a national accident prevention strategy. I call Jim Shannon.

02:13:50 - 02:19:56

Speaker 3

To serve on your chairship and thank you for your chairship this afternoon and to the honorable gentleman. Right right honorable gentleman for Royal Sutton Caulfield for allowing us to the opportunity to speak on this topic. I congratulate him on a truly excellent speech. And I want to give a perspective of a can. I'm chair of the APPG in Healthy Homes and Buildings, and this is something of great interest to me.

And it's the actions, in the home, it's the actions on the roads, it's the actions on the farm, it's the actions on water. It's all those things together. As the honorable member has highlighted, fatal accidents in The United Kingdom have risen by a rate of eight percent in one year, and accidents now kill over twenty three thousand people annually. That's more than the capacity of the London 02 Arena. And of these, nearly eight hundred people die annually in accidental deaths in Northern Ireland.

So I'm gonna get that Northern Ireland perspective to this debate if I can, please. Indeed, accidental fatalities in Northern Ireland are rising with the region experiencing a rate of thirty nine deaths per 100,000, significantly higher than UK average of thirty four per 100,000. So we in Northern Ireland have are in in the in the back foot in this one where we're already behind on the on the targets, and and we need to do better. But to add our support and our contribution to this debate, almost 900,000 people, the equivalent of the entire population of Devon, are admitted to hospital duty actions every year. People living in the most deprived areas are nearly twice as likely to be killed in an accident than those in the least deprived.

And I want to highlight if I can very quickly, mister chairman, the issue of actions on the farm, whether they will to do with falling off the roof whenever we we as and I live in a farm, mister chairman, we tend to do the work ourselves. It's the nature of life and and to be truthful, some of the health and safety aspects may be and I I say honestly that maybe I haven't adhered to them either. So actions in the farm are regular things. Will it be machinery accidents? Will it be slurry?

And and I've had a number of over the last few years, a number of families who have unfortunately succumbed to the to the fumes of of of the the slurry tank. My neighbor, who takes my land, I remember him telling me last year, he says to me, he says, Jimmy, he says, I was, like, clearing the slurry tank, and he says, it's the funniest thing. I was there, and all of a sudden, I was away. And and and there was a guy in the tractor about 10 feet away that pulled pulled him away from it. So it it it the things that perhaps maybe we who live in the rural hunterland and whoever live in the country and are affected each day with with farm issues, maybe just don't stand over those.

So I look to the minister perhaps when it comes to highlighting those. I know that back home, the DERA department, they they advertise on the TV regularly about the the the dangers of of of the farm. Will it be overhead lines, for instance? You can have a your your Caterpillar JCB, and you could be doing work and all of a sudden you you can you can head over a headline and and and find a tragic action as well working with animals. Another example, always be wary of the of the cow that has a has their own calf, of the bull that's in amongst the the cows as well, and these things can happen.

So there's a real danger. I've been in contact with Rosborough who welcome recent steps by the government to improve regulation standards in the housing sector. I wanna speak to that as if I can, particularly the commitment to implement the recommendations of the Grenfell inquiry in full. I know government, has been proactive in responding to the Grenfell inquiry, and they've come up with a lot of, good positive ways forward. Ross has also worked with leading housing providers to reduce safety by design a framework to reduce serious accidental injury in new build homes, which sets out a practical measures to reduce shocking current rate.

Six thousand, mister chairman, six thousand accidental fatalities occurring in UK homes each and every year. However, accidents are not just an issue in the home. They affect people across all areas of the for their work on on the roads, at work, during leisure time. Actions are now leading the leading cause of preventable death in people 40 with eight hundred and forty thousand hospital admissions and seven million seven million a and e attendance being accident related in 2223 costing the NHS as a right honorable gentleman referred to £6,000,000,000 and 5,200,000 bed days annually. Economic costs as a right honorable member has referred to are exceptional.

It's estimated at another £6,000,000,000 is due to lost working days and output. So if we can improve the accidents rate, we can improve the economy, we improve people's health, and it's a a win win in every way. I conclude with this petition. That's why I joined the calls that the right honorable gentleman has put forward for a national action and prevention strategy. I look to the minister as and the minister has been has been very active in Westminster Hall this last week or ten days or even two weeks, and it's good to see her in her place again.

We look forward to to her answers to our request. But if we can model our national action perfection strategy on those who have been implemented as a right number member referred to in Australia and Finland, then we can, I believe, we collectively, government minister ways, can tackle this crisis? And I would ask members and the government to initiate and to support these steps for each of our constituent's safety. I believe if we can address this issue in a collective collegiate way, at government level, then we can address some of the concerns that we have, whether it be in the home, whether it be on the roads, whether it be in water, whether it be in the farm, wherever it is, we need a national, accident prevention strategy. And I'm I'm mister chairman, we need it now.

Thank you.

02:19:58 - 02:19:59

Speaker 14

Sir Ollie for the liftgate.

02:19:59 - 02:25:22

Speaker 6

Thank you very much, doctor Morrison. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Can I congratulate the member for Sutton Colfield for bringing this extremely important debate? I four weeks ago today, actually, I was at the funeral of a young man who was killed in a road traffic collision in Sussex just after Christmas. His mother, is one of my constituents and seeing how how broken hearted she was and and the young man's friends who were there at his funeral really brings, home to me how important it is that we must take all steps to mitigate these kinds of accidents wherever we can to avoid future suffering by the families and friends of those who die in accidents.

And I'm grateful to the member for Doncaster East and the Isle Of Axon for highlighting the importance of water safety in my constituency, is has as its boundary one of the the country's major rivers, the River Thames, water safety is a constant issue for for the young people that I represent. And it's a good opportunity, if I may, to take to highlight the particular risks around locks in the summer months. Teddington Lock in my constituency attracts a great number of young people who find it appealing to jump off the lock into the river. It's incredibly dangerous. And there was a fatality in the river not far away from my constituency in Sunbury a couple of years ago.

And so I'd like to take this opportunity to highlight to the young people, in particular my constituency, the enormous danger of playing around the locks on our rivers. But I would also like to take this opportunity to pay tribute to the British Standards Institute and all they've done in their one hundred and twenty fifth anniversary year and the seventy fifth year of the BSI's Consumer and Public Interest Network and the Consumer Forum, ensuring that consumer voices are heard in the developer's standards, so they reflect real world experience and mitigate accident risk. The Liberal Democrats believe investing in prevention through public health initiatives is the most effective way to enhance well-being, reduce the burden on NHS services. We support the introduction of a national accident prevention strategy, as advocated for by the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents. Accidents are a leading cause of preventable death and injury in The UK.

The Health and Safety Executive, the NHS and local authorities all have a role to play in accident prevention, but there is no single overarching national strategy coordinating activity across settings roads, workplaces, homes and public spaces. The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents have also long advocated for a joined up national approach to home safety, particularly for children and older people. Despite this, no government has been forthcoming with legislation which would bring together all of these strategies into an effective framework. The Liberal Democrats understand the benefit of a national strategy. Road safety strategies have previously driven significant reductions in deaths and serious injuries.

The UK has historically been amongst the safer countries for road casualties. The Government has yet to introduce a successor strategy of equivalent ambition, and as such, progress has stalled. The Liberal Democrats have consistently pressed the Government to adopt a road safety strategy. We welcome the Government's action on this, but are disappointed that much of strategy is simply commitments to undertake consultation, kicking meaningful activity down the road. We're calling for action to be taken much more quickly, as well as investment in road safety infrastructure, better enforcement on speeding and law breaking, education programs, and improved safety technology across the motor industry.

The Liberal Democrats are also campaigning to roll up active aging programs and falls assessments for anyone over the age of 75 to prevent falls, to avoid unnecessary hospital admissions, and to promote healthy aging. A key cause of workforce shortages is ill health, in part caused by accidents. To tackle the problem, government should be investing in our NHS and social care so that people can get the health care they need and rejoin the workforce more quickly. We've called on the government to fix NHS backlogs, cut ambulance waiting times, and raise the minimum wage for care workers by £2 an hour to help boost our social care system and get people out of hospital quicker. Social care is an essential part of enabling people to live safely and independently at home, but the Government is kicking the issue into the long grass, with its Commission not set to complete for another two years.

We would complete the Commission within a year and deliver the answers and investment needed to tackle the social care crisis. Beyond the obvious physical and mental impact of accidents, there's a broader economic impact. Each year, accidents cost UK businesses £6,000,000,000 due to lost working days and lost output. We want to see the National Prevention Strategy setting out clearer expectations for enforcement and employer compliance. The Health and Safety Executive oversees workplace safety regulation, but budget cuts have reduced its inspection capacity.

While the NHS continues to be under huge stress, introducing a strategy to reduce preventable accidents is even more pressing. Accidents cost the NHS 5,200,000 bed days amounting to almost £6,000,000,000. Therefore, I wish to ask the minister, will they accelerate their plans to conclude the Social Care Commission before 2028? What action are they taking now in advance of the conclusion to support people through recovery and back into work? And what steps are they taking to ensure their road safety strategy works effectively and cohesively alongside other government strategies to reduce the number of preventable accidents and injuries across the country.

Thank you, doctor Morrison.

02:25:22 - 02:25:54

Speaker 11

Shadow minister. Thank you, doctor Morrison. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I congratulate my rightable friend for Sutton Colfield for not only securing this debate, but for the thoughtful way he presented his opening remarks highlighting the need for a national strategy to prevent accidents, not least through the lens of the horrific tragedies in the royal town that he outlined. Now doctor Morrison, I'm always pleased to see the minister in her place.

02:25:55 - 02:27:03

Speaker 19

But this debate was tabled to discuss a national accident prevention strategy. A strategy that would need to extend well beyond the portfolio of the minister, well beyond the department for transport, for roads, and other transport methods only represent a portion of the challenges that are raised in this debate today. And for a government whose principal ideology appears to be predicated on a misguided notion of due process, it seems there has been an accident in today's assignment. The issue at hand requires a minister whose responsibility is to think about the broader impact and prevention of accidents, which I would argue would look to the Cabinet Office or perhaps the Department for Work and Pensions which holds significant responsibility in this area as the sponsoring department for the health and safety executive. I say none of this in criticism of the minister who I have very high regard and respect for.

02:27:03 - 02:31:43

Speaker 11

I do say it though as a criticism of the government because I cannot understand why the government have chosen to field the department for transport on this debate rather than a department that cuts across the whole of government. This is an incredibly important issue. There is a risk of accident from the moment we all wake up in the morning, travel to work or to whatever leisure activity and go about our daily business. Risk in our journeys but also with every product we use and place we visit. The government has a regulatory responsibility for mitigating these risks as much as possible to prevent avoidable accidents, saving lives, and shielding the taxpayer in the process.

The concept of a national accident prevention strategy should not be about burden and over regulation, but about safety and confidence that people and businesses can live, operate and thrive in an environment with lower risk. The cost of accidents to the NHS is estimated to be around £6,000,000,000 per year And it is suggested by the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents that accidents are the leading cause of death in the under forties. We have a duty to do what we can to really get to grips with the significant causes of accidents, especially as they change with new developments in our way of life. It is interesting to dive into the figures of what accidents are prevalent over time. Transport related accidents are horrific and of course the government should want to do more to reduce these further.

Though over the last two decades they have already fallen by some seventeen percent. Whilst the number of falls, many of which will be from all of our elderly constituents, is up considerably by ninety percent and makes up forty six percent of all accidents. I will be interested to know how the minister is planning to address some of these major emerging causes of accidents, particularly working across different departments. The report published in November 2024 by the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents makes several recommendations that the clear theme across it points to the need for a more holistic joined up approach to accident prevention. The health and safety executive does a very robust job of upholding safety standards in the workplace but there is absolutely a need to make sure that the safety standard is consistent at work, at home and in the public realm.

And future proofing our safety standards will also play a key role in mitigating risk for the long term. And I would like to hear from the minister what considerations the government has made to accommodate for the growing use of AI and robotics in industry and by business, both to mitigate accident risk and to utilize new technologies to reduce risks elsewhere. And I give an example that will be relevant to the minister's department that we have seen in our newspapers this week of a self driving car driving straight through the police cordon around a crime scene here in London. That is an emerging technology that clearly is not foolproof, clearly has shown on the streets of our capital city this week that it is potentially dangerous and how the government will rise to the regulatory challenge around that. Now this topic, as my writable friend for Sutton Colfield so eloquently set out, is broad.

And it is clear from delving into the issue of accidents just how necessary it is that the government take the issue seriously. With real strain and cost placed on our NHS and public services and some truly horrible accidents happening around us each and every day, I would like to hear from the minister that they are taking this issue seriously, that they are working across government and not just within the Department for Transport, and that they are acting when it comes to actually delivering a broader strategy of accident prevention, that the government won't just have a narrow approach, but to listen to the recommendations made by the Royal Society for Prevention of Accidents and take the cross departmental approach that is quite clearly necessary.

02:31:48 - 02:45:16

Speaker 19

Well, thank you very much, doctor Murison. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this afternoon. I'd like to begin by thanking the right honorable member for Sutton Colfield for securing this debate, and I'm very pleased to be able to respond, on behalf of the government. Perhaps I'd like to, begin by offering my condolences to all those affected by the incidents he mentioned in his own constituency, Natasha's family, and friends. And I pay tribute to him for raising awareness of this important issue.

As he rightly suggests, it's not an unreasonable expectation that we should be able to go about our everyday lives without the fear or risk of accidents. The impact on individuals, families, and friends can be devastating, and I share his view that we should collectively act to address these risks. As the minister responsible for road safety, I'm aware of the right honorable member's interest in the lead up to the publication of the road safety strategy earlier this year. He has a track record of making the case for effective safety measures in his constituency and beyond, which is of course to his great credit. And I'm particularly struck that we're here on International Workers Memorial Day.

Too many people are killed or injured as a result of their work, and it's apt that we're discussing this issue on a day when we remember those killed in workplace incidents and we recommit to fight for a safer future for the living. As the right honorable member noted, the issue of accident prevention cuts across several areas and the responsibilities of many departments. Within my own ambit, it means road traffic collision prevention. More widely, accident prevention impacts home safety, safety in the workplace, product safety, building safety, safety in childcare, health prevention, and much more. Now the right honorable member spoke movingly of the incident we will all have heard about as constituency members.

This government clearly recognizes the importance of prevention, of protecting lives, promoting good health, and ensuring that public services are not called upon when they do not need to be. A number of members talked about the impact on our economy and on the National Health Service as a result, of accidents. It is the first job of government to keep the British people safe, and I know that colleagues in all departments are taking measures to ensure our approach to accident prevention is as strong as it can be. With that in mind, I hope that honorable and right honorable members will allow the opportunity to speak first about the work of my own department. This country has some of the safest roads in the world, but years of complacency have allowed our road safety record to slip.

Around four people die on our roads every single day, lives taken too soon, lives altered beyond recognition, and lives grieved by families left behind. Now language and terminology matter to victims of road traffic collisions. Since 2022, other than when required by specific legislation, the Department for Transport has referred has used the term collision in relation to road traffic, crashes because the term accident can imply events are unavoidable or without fault. We know that the vast majority of incidents on our roads are preventable. Earlier this year, my department has already been said, published the new road safety strategy because we believe that road traffic collisions are preventable, and our strategy sets out how we intend to deal with the root causes of collisions.

We've set out our vision for safer roads for all, including ambitious targets to reduce the number of people killed or seriously injured by sixty five percent and seventy percent for children by 2035. Rooted in innovation and underpinned by the safe systems approach, our strategy recognizes that while driver error is inevitable, deaths and serious injuries on our roads are not. It outlines concrete steps to better support road users, including consultations. Five consultations were published alongside the road safety strategy on minimum learning periods, on lower drink drive limits, on mandatory eyesight testing. And I make no apology for consulting because I think you know when we're publishing the first road safety strategy in a generation, it's right that we take the time to get this right.

It's right that we have set out those consultations what we intend to do, but listen very carefully how best to make those changes happen. So whilst I do want to see progress, and I'm going to be chairing a national road safety board to ensure the implementation of this strategy. And of course, I want to see those numbers going down, and we have set those ambitious targets for what we intend to achieve over the next decade. I don't think it was wrong, to consult on them. Now the staff strategy commits to harnessing technology, data, and innovation to improve the safety of vehicles and infrastructure, and it sets out a strengthened approach to enforcement, putting penalties under review, and considering new powers to suspend licenses.

Now the honorable man member from Mid Buckinghamshire rightly raised the potential of some of those new technologies, including AI. But he also highlighted the important need to get it right when it comes to that technology and that of course includes automated vehicles which have a huge potential when we know that driver error is such an important contributory factor in many road traffic collisions. The ability to take out, know, the the the potential for driver error with an automated vehicle is there. But of course, we need to make sure that technology is as reliable as a careful and competent driver, and that's why we have got some of those the piloting of automated vehicles, but with a safety driver in place at the moment. Now what applies to road safety as much as any other area of accident prevention is the importance of collective effort.

We rely on partnerships with local authorities, with industry, with emergency services, charities, stakeholders, and communities. In transport, we recognize the importance of a just culture, which recognizes that humans do make mistakes, systems can fail, and safety improves when people are honest, and learning means more than blame. In aviation, in rail, and maritime, we have the accident investigation branches. They are not there to apportion blame or liability. Their focus is investigating serious incidents to ensure we can learn from them and prevent reoccurrence.

Accident prevention must be a call to action, not just a new policy or set of regulations. Honorable and right honorable members will be aware of Think, the government's flagship road safety campaign that aims to reduce the number of people killed and seriously injured on the roads in England and Wales. It seeks to change attitudes and behaviors amongst those at risk and is a good example, I think, of the importance of public awareness campaigning. I want to pay tribute to all those individuals, organizations, campaigners, response teams who make such a difference to lives across the country, both by raising awareness of those most at risk of harm and by standing ready and responding night and day to help people in danger. And I'm thinking of our, you know, our lifeboat responders, our mountain rescue teams, and many others.

In housing safety, and I think the honorable member for Strangford mentioned this, the government is taking various actions to improve safety and accident prevention. The decent home standard is one of several new updated measures aimed at improving quality in the private rented sector. This includes AWABs law, which requires landlords to address issues of damp and mold within stricter time frames, not accidents, but ill health caused by living, in unsafe conditions. And of course, new fines for landlords whose properties contain serious hazards. Action is being taken forward on all 58 recommendations from the Grenfell inquiry report, and this is intended to build a more robust and trusted regulatory system in the wake of that tragedy.

We'll never forget those taken too soon or the impact that will still be felt every day by their loved ones. In December, the government published the single construction regulator prospectus and consultation document, laying out our plans for regulatory reform to integrate the regulation of buildings, products, professions. This followed the appointment of an expert panel to help guide the building safety regulator led review of the building regulations guidance. Now the honorable member for Doncaster and the Isle Of Axo and the honorable member for Richmond Park both mentioned the dangers that can be seen around rivers, canals, lakes, and the sea. It takes a real collective effort by emergency services and volunteers to deliver search and rescue services.

And the government's made tangible progress in recent years to support voluntary organizations. In the recent budget, for example, a vehicle excise duty exemption was announced for mountain rescue, lowland rescue, cave rescue, independent lifeboats, and the RNLI. This reflects a clear recognition of the public value of search and rescue volunteers and the practical costs they bear in carrying out their work. And of course they also do really important work in making people aware of those dangers as part of that prevention agenda. Now I was saddened to read in the annual review of ROSPA, which I'll refer to in a moment, that alcohol related deaths have increased by five percent following a period of relative stability.

These include accidents caused by exposure or poisoning, and all such deaths are a tragedy. The government has committed to help people make healthier choices about alcohol, and we're working towards legal requirements for alcohol labels to display health warnings and consistent nutritional information. To better support support better outcomes people experiencing harmful drinking and alcohol dependence, we published the first ever UK clinical guidelines on alcohol treatment to drive improvements in treatment provision. Our extensive program of implementation support and the guidelines have been positively received by commissioners and providers, and we continue to work across government to consider further measures to reduce the negative impact alcohol has on health inequalities, crime, and the economy. The same could be said about some drug use, which also is a major cause of accidents and poisoning.

Now when it comes to health, it's worth speaking about falls. Falls accounted for almost half of all fatal accidents in The UK in 2023 and fifty nine percent of all accident related hospital admissions in 2023, '24, making them by far the largest single category of accidental harm. And that's against a long term backdrop of false fatalities increasing by eighty one percent between 2013 and 2022. But there is hope, and again, it it comes to technology. So emerging evidence from the government funded independent evaluations indicates that falls technologies can reduce falls in care homes by between thirty seven percent and forty nine percent, as well as reducing hospital admissions and freeing up staff time.

And in the next year, the government will set new national standards for care technologies and produce trusted guidance so people can confidently buy and use technology which supports them or the people they care for. Now the honorable member for Richmond Park asked some important questions about social care and I will assure that she receives a written response to those questions. Moving on to workplace safety. The government's employment rights bill is a significant Act, pardon me, doctor Morrison, is an important towards delivering the biggest upgrade to workers' rights in a generation. Ensuring statutory sick pay from day one will reduce the risk of presenteeism, a key risk in operational environments when people are at work but unwell.

Limits on nondisclosure agreements will enable learning from incidents instead of silencing them. Reducing zero hours working will ensure greater predictability in work patterns, reducing fatigue, working alone or or rushed work. The creation of the Fair Work Agency will provide better protection for whistleblowers, reinforcing a strong safety culture in our workplaces. And making it easier for trade unions to organize ensures that more workplaces benefit from health and safety representatives and the vital work they do. And I pay tribute to trade unions across the country who are health and safety representatives.

I know firsthand from the incredible work they do to keep workplaces safe.

02:45:17 - 02:45:18

Speaker 15

I will

02:45:18 - 02:45:18

Speaker 19

give away.

02:45:21 - 02:45:51

Speaker 18

mentioned earlier it's International Workers Memorial Day. The trade unions today have been here really making sure that we raise awareness of that. And this year's theme is psychosocial interventions that are required to support workers and mental health. I wanted to just take the opportunity to remember those that we've lost at work, but also to really promote employers implementing really strong mental health interventions at work and raise that awareness to prevent lives lost?

02:45:51 - 02:47:05

Speaker 19

I thank him for that intervention and he's absolutely right. We think of all those who've lost their lives at work and I think the figure is stuck to around about one hundred and twenty people each year who are killed in the course of their work, but there's a much bigger problem of people who suffer ill health, particularly related to work related stress, mental health, and of course, you know, the best employees do work really hard on those issues, often in consultation with their trade union health and safety reps. The Health and Safety Executive is, of course, Britain's national regulator for workplace health and safety. It delivers a combination of proportionate enforcement, targeted regulatory work, engagement, and development of standards and guidance. And that includes public awareness activity to promote the safe use of ladders and power tools through guidance surveillance work and campaigns.

And I know the honorable member for Strangford who is no longer in his place, he rightly spoke about the risks in agriculture. HSE do work extensively with farm safety partnership to ensure industry is aware of risk, we think about similar in relation to construction and other high risk environments. Of

02:47:06 - 02:47:06

Speaker 3

course. With

02:47:06 - 02:47:42

Speaker 1

a due sense of trepidation, he wasn't here for the openings or at least until the very end of them but nevertheless.

I apologize for my sardiness. But I just wanted to pick up on the point of agriculture and just emphasize that as we're talking about national accident prevention, it's important to recognise that accidents in rural areas require a different level of engagement, different level of promotion and different level of public engagement. And would you join me therefore in recognising and urging everyone involved in accident prevention to recognise the unique challenges that rural areas face and to take appropriate steps where possible, whether that's in road safety or in workplace safety?

02:47:42 - 02:48:30

Speaker 19

I think he makes a very important point and in addressing all of these things we need to think about who is most at risk and what's the appropriate way in which we can intervene. And I think a point was made earlier in the debate about whether rural areas are particularly at risk. We know that those who are from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, the people in the poorest neighborhoods are most at risk of being involved in serious incidents, and that's true for road safety as it is for other things. Although he's right to raise the issue of rurality because, of course, rural roads are are amongst the most dangerous. To address accidents in educational settings, the Department for Education have worked with the Food Standards Agency, for example, to develop a food safety advice webpage including a section on choking prevention.

02:48:30 - 02:49:31

Speaker 6

The department already also works with the Department for Business and Trade to ensure safety alerts for products related to early years and childcare were communicated to the sector, including the five step safety message for parents and carers to minimize the risk of serious injury from toys. Finally, the Office for Product Safety and Standards, which sits within Department for Business and Trade, in addition to local authorities trading standards, have powers to tackle the supply of unsafe or non compliant consumer products and remove them from the market. And the Product Regulation and Metrology Act introduced various measures to reduce the risk of fires. These include the risk of e bike and e scooter battery fires, and secondary legislation will regulate battery design compatibility and safety information for consumers. The office also works with a variety of stakeholders to gather information about incidents, which may be linked to product safety issues, and that includes fire and rescue services, other regulators, consumer bodies, and safety charities.

02:49:31 - 02:51:29

Speaker 19

And I want to pay tribute to all those charities within the sector who do such vital work and the volunteers without whom, they would not function. Chair, I know that many campaigners across the country do valuable work to raise awareness of accident prevention and to shine a light on areas where improvement is needed. I do note the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents as the right honorable member has for their work campaigning for a reduction in accidents at home, on the road, at work, and at leisure. And I particularly note their recently published annual review, which followed their 2024 report calling for a national accident prevention strategy. They powerfully highlighted the human and economic costs of accidents to individuals and to society.

We, of course, recognize that coherent action is an important factor in tackling issues which may have many dimensions and owners. I regret that I'm not in a position today to commit the government to a national strategy, but I do hope that honorable and right honorable members can be reassured of two things. First, that individual departments take their responsibilities for safety, security and accident prevention seriously, and I hope the House can recognize my own passion for road safety as just one example. And second, that we will continue to work across government to ensure that our approach to accident prevention is the right one. That includes a focus on prevention, such as rolling out a range of measures to tackle health inequalities and stop health problems at source.

And it includes better use of data such as the establishment of a data led road safety investigation branch covering the whole of Great Britain, which will draw on data to carry out thematic investigations and make recommendations. I once again thank the right honorable member for Sutton Colfield for securing this debate. I'm grateful to you, chair, for overseeing us this afternoon, and I thank all those honorable and right honorable members who've spoken in the proceedings. Thank you.

02:51:30 - 02:51:31

Speaker 1

Andrew McChaw to wind up.

02:51:32 - 02:52:49

Speaker 17

Thank you very much Doctor Morrison. I'd like to thank the Minister and the Shadow Minister for their speeches which I thought answered the comments that I tried to make in opening this debate very fully and to also thank colleagues from across the house for their contribution on what I think is a very important subject. I was very pleased to hear the minister say that she will be chairing the National Road Safety Board. I very much hope that she will use that opportunity to help drive the more comprehensive approach to this matter which I set out in my opening remarks and in particular try and make sure that it doesn't suffer from departmental turf exchanges. I think there is a real win here to be gathered by helping drive this through the whole of Whitehall and produce what is a genuinely comprehensive strategy.

And I also hope that she will use ROSPA that she spoke about warmly and I strongly concur with her remarks. This is a great organization which can give the necessary perspective that we require quite apart from it being an example of the good sense and wisdom of the Royal town of Sutton Coalfield where it is based.

02:52:50 - 02:53:02

Speaker 1

The question is that this House consider the potential merits of a national accident prevention strategies. Many as of that opinion say aye. As a country, no. I think the ayes have it. Order.

Order. The sitting stands adjourned.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.