Westminster Hall
28 April 2026
No chapters available yet
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Westminster Hall House of Commons
Follow its sittings00:12 - 00:14
Speaker 1
Order. Order. Rachel Gilmore to move the motion.
00:15 - 05:24
Speaker 2
I beg to move that this house considers the subject of international parental child abduction and it's a privilege to make my remarks under your very capable stewardship, doctor Murison. I understand that these issues are very sensitive and of huge human significance. And so I feel privileged to be able to bring the eyes and ears of the house to them. And I salute the left behind parents, some of whom join us in the gallery this afternoon, for their indefatigrility and for their courage. And I know that it will take they will take little comfort in such words, but I must say it anyway, Chair.
I think it's important to emphasise the need not to prejudice ongoing legal proceedings, but as representatives of our constituents we feel to proper advocate for them. According to Reunite International, over 500 children are abducted from The UK by a parent every year. Among the families who attended the most recent roundtable on this subject here in parliament, there were upwards of half a century half a century of lost years. That is to say lost contact with their children. The testimonies I have heard, though individually unique, paint a troubling consistent picture, deliberate misleading, ill fated recovery attempts and financial costs running into the millions.
Many have travelled time after time after time to foreign jurisdictions in the hope of recovering their children. The human toll is staggering on both sides. The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction provides the principal international framework governing these cases. Crucially, it mandates expeditious handling of abduction proceedings, yet from testimonies I've received months often elapse before the first substantive hearing in a clear breach of the convention. Such delays risk the factual entrenchment of the abducted child in the new jurisdiction, entirely undermining the notional remedy of return.
The convention exists precisely to prevent this outcome. Far too often it does not. There are several structural concerns that recur across the cases brought to me. First, the undermining of established jurisdictional findings. In one instance I learnt of the Cairo Court here had already determined the child's habitual residence to be in England, and the Polish first instance court was aligned ordering return.
However, the appellate outcome reversed this position despite no dispute as to the original wrongful removal and no clear finding that the Article 13 threshold had clearly been met at first instance. This raises concern about consistency in applying Hague principles at an appellate level and the degree to which appellate courts revisit or expand factual assessments beyond convention limits. The second concern is the creeping expansion of Article 13 welfare arguments as a basis for refusing return. These provisions were always intended to be narrow exceptions, not an open door for wide ranging allegations. Where such arguments are routinely entertained without proper substantiation there is a considerable possibility that summary return proceedings are converted into de facto welfare determinations which is not what the convention intended.
Thirdly is the insufficient use of protective measures. In this case The UK had jurisdiction and capacity to implement protective measures upon return with an active high court framework available. These mechanisms should be taken seriously and fully operationalised. Failure to do so risks turning theoretical concerns to harden into grounds of non return. The post decision consequences of such outcomes are stark.
The child remains outside the jurisdiction of the habitual residence. There is no effective restoration of the pre removal status quo and contact arrangements remain limited and unresolved. This illustrates how delay combined with appellate intervention can effectively neutralise the convention remedy entirely. I am of course conscious that not every parent who crosses a border with a child is a wrongful abductor in the conventional sense. There are genuine cases and we must be clear eyed about this where a parent flees with a child from real, documented domestic abuse and the law must be sensitive to that reality.
05:25 - 06:29
Speaker 7
Article 13 exists precisely for such circumstances and where the threshold is generally met it should of course be engaged. The concern is not with the protection itself but with its expansion and at times its misapplication. The difficulty is that the very features which make these cases so emotionally charged also render them susceptible to the weaponization of abuse allegations as a litigation strategy. It is therefore incumbent upon courts and authorities to apply rigorous scrutiny to such claims, neither dismissing them reflexively nor accepting them uncritically so that the protection is reserved for those who genuinely need it rather than becoming the means by which the Convention's core remedy is routinely frustrated. The Child Abduction Act 1984 does not provide for the occurrence of a criminal offence when a parent has consent to take a child down to the country but then fails to return them.
06:30 - 07:09
Speaker 2
This legal impole became known as the Nicolau Problem following a 2012 judicial review process. The law commission's 2014 report identified this legal blind spot and recommended a change in the law. And I'm pleased to say, minister, that the Crime and Policing Bill, which completed its passage through Parliament late last night, will finally close that loophole. All abductions to The UK will now be criminal. Based purely on the volume of human stories, Poland appears to be at the sharp end of these affairs and I must set out the record plainly as it stands.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.