Social Housing Bill [Lords]

3 November 2026

Social Housing Bill [Lords] House of Commons

00:00 - 00:32
Speaker 7
Before we begin, I have a few preliminary reminders.  Please switch electronic devices to silent.  No food or drinks are permitted during the sittings, other than the water provided.  Hansard colleagues would be grateful if Members could email their notes to hansardnotes@parliament.uk, or pass them to the Hansard colleague in the room.  We begin today's proceedings with group 44 and new clause 36, with which it will be convenient to consider new clauses 54 and 59. 
00:32 - 00:36
Speaker 1
I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 36. 
00:36 - 02:23
Speaker 5
Good morning, Mr Vickers.  It is nice to resume today's hearing under your convenership.  I rise to move new clause 36, which stands in my name.  This bill will change how social housing is funded, how receipts are used, and who can afford to buy their home.  This creates understandable and unhelpful uncertainty for local authorities and social housing providers and, by extension, tenants. 

Local authorities are right to be anxious, because clause 10 hands the Secretary of State sweeping powers over capital receipts, and councils cannot plan if they do not know what they will lose or gain.  New clause 36 simply asks that, within six months of royal assent, the Secretary of State must publish and lay before Parliament a fiscal impact assessment.  It must examine the effects on local authority finances, whether social housing offers value for money for the taxpayer, and how the bill changes tenants' financial ability to use right to buy.  If the Government is confident in its figures, it has nothing to fear from publishing them.  With regards to new clause 54, this bill represents an assault on the aspiration of social housing tenants to own their own homes. 

It is an ideological attack on that, on a policy that for over 40 years has given millions of people the opportunity to get onto the housing ladder who otherwise may never have been able to do so.  By extending the qualifying period and slashing discounts, the Government is seeking to effectively abolish right to buy your own home, and force residents into renting for longer and longer.  That is why I have tabled new clause 54, which would require a review of the impact of the provisions of the bill on the rates of home ownership among social housing tenants.  The bill's impact assessment shows a dramatic, projected decline in right-to-buy sales within the first two years of it coming into force, with sales nearly halving.  With little effort to support people onto the housing ladder and cuts to measures such as first-time buyer stamp duty relief, the Government is tearing up not only one of the most effective routes to home ownership for social housing tenants, but one of the only routes, full stop. 
02:23 - 02:36
Speaker 6
That is why it is critical that we understand the bill's full impact and demonstrate the disaster that awaits social housing tenants, aspiring not just to live in their own home, but to own it too. 
02:36 - 02:46
Speaker 4
Fiscal impact assessments.  The question is that new clause 36 be read a second time.  Lee Dillon. 
02:46 - 03:13
Speaker 8
Yeah, thank you, Mr Vickers.  Pleasure to serve under your chairship.  I rise to speak to new clause 59, which, in a similar spirit to the official Opposition's new clause 36 and 54, asks for the Secretary of State to carry out a review.  The amendment table in my name asks for that review to take place 12 months after the Act.  But we come at it with a different aspiration. 
03:13 - 03:54
Speaker 9
I feel that the Opposition's amendments are tabled to try to catch the Government out, whereas we support the objectives of this bill. 

support the objectives of this bill, but we feel that it is right that while we are making changes to right to buy, that we support, and tightening stock disposals, it's only right that the House, via a review by the Secretary of State, is tabled 12 months after this bill, so that we can see if those objectives were indeed met, or if we need to legislate further to make sure that we continue to protect social housing stock, which we are in full agreement with the Government on. 

03:54 - 05:55

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers, it's a pleasure to continue our proceedings with you in the chair. I'll speak to new clauses 36, 54 and 59 together. Members of the committee will have heard my opinion of the merits of opposition amendments that seek further statutory reviews in general, so they can guess where I'm heading with some of these, but while we share the aim of ensuring that the impact of these reforms is properly understood, the Government does not believe that further statutory review requirements are necessary or proportionate. We've already published an economic impact assessment. We have arrangements in place to monitor the effects of the Act.

The impact on businesses is expected to be de minimis, with estimated direct costs well below £1 million. Now, Mr. Vickers, new clause 59 would specifically require a review within 12 months covering the supply and retention of social housing, tenants' rights, the right to buy, and the right to acquire. Many of the measures in the bill will take time to bed in, so a statutory review within that time frame, we believe, risks providing only a partial picture of their impact. But more broadly, the Government already publishes comprehensive data on social housing sales and demolitions, right to buy sales and replacements, local authority housing stock levels, and new affordable housing supply, including detailed local authority-level data. We will, of course, continue to monitor the impact of the reforms through these existing datasets and established statistical releases, but for that reason, we don't think new clause 59 is warranted.

On the specific issue of home ownership raised by new clause 54, a core aim of the right to buy measures in the bill is to ensure that social homes are not sold off without being replaced. I therefore agree with honorable members on the importance, again, of monitoring these reforms and their impact; however, imposing additional statutory review requirements would risk duplicating the existing analysis without providing a more meaningful assessment of the Act's effects. The Government's priority, Mr. Vickers, is to implement these important reforms and monitor their impact effectively through the arrangements already in place, and for those reasons, I'm afraid we will not be able to accept new clauses 36, 54, or 59.

05:55 - 05:57

Speaker 16

Gareth Bacon.

05:57 - 06:12

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I have listened carefully to what the Minister has to say, Mr. Vickers. On new clause 36, in light of what the Minister has said, we will withdraw that new clause. However, when the time comes, we will press new clause 54 to a division.

06:12 - 06:28

Martin Vickers

Is everyone content on the new clause 36 being withdrawn? New clause 36, by leave, withdrawn. We now come to new clause 37, which was debated in group 41 with new clause 32. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

06:28 - 06:33

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I move formally, Chair.

06:33 - 06:37

Speaker 10

Provision of social housing: foreign public office holders and associated persons.

06:37 - 06:59

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 37 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division. Lock the doors.

06:59 - 07:00

Gideon Amos?

07:00 - 07:02

Speaker 15

No.

07:02 - 07:04

Speaker 17

Aye.

07:02 - 07:02

Edward Argar?

07:04 - 07:05

Gareth Bacon?

07:06 - 07:07

Danny Beales?

07:08 - 07:08

Rachel Blake?

07:08 - 07:10

Speaker 12

No.

07:10 - 07:11

Semina Bajwa?

07:12 - 07:13

Nesil Caliskan?

07:14 - 07:15

Lewis Cocking?

07:15 - 07:18

Speaker 11

Aye.

07:18 - 07:19

Lee Dillon?

07:20 - 07:21

Mary Kelly Foy?

07:22 - 07:23

Matthew Pennycook?

07:24 - 07:25

John Slinger?

07:26 - 07:28

Speaker 20

Patrick Spencer?

07:29 - 07:30

Laurence Turner?

07:30 - 07:31

Steve Yemm?

07:31 - 07:41

Speaker 18

No.

07:41 - 07:56

Martin Vickers

The ayes were 4 and the noes were 11, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 45 and new clause 38. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 38.

07:56 - 08:45

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Mr Vickers. I rise to move new clause 38, which stands in my name. Every home that is illegally sublet is a home taken from a family who needs it. With waiting lists as long as they are, that is nothing short of theft from the public. It is also unfair to the many tenants who play by the rules.

We know that the problem exists, yet we have little idea how well it is being tackled, how many prosecutions are brought, how many properties are actually recovered. What stops landlords and councils from acting? This new clause answers those questions. Within 12 months of royal assent, the Secretary of State must publish and lay before Parliament a review of enforcement activity. It would set out the number of prosecutions, the number of properties recovered, and the barriers to enforcement.

This bill claims to be about making better use of social housing stock. Freeing up homes that are being misused is the obvious place to start.

08:45 - 08:48

Speaker 19

Illegal subletting of social housing: enforcement review.

08:48 - 08:54

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 38 be read a second time. Minister.

08:54 - 11:23

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr Vickers. I thank the shadow minister for tabling and speaking to this amendment. The government does want to ensure that social housing is used effectively and efficiently to meet housing need. Tackling illegal subletting is an important element of that, and we are clear that landlords should be taking action to clamp down on such unacceptable practices. And I very much agree with his comments about how unacceptable they are.

They are a misuse of social housing. New clause 38, as he said, would require the Secretary of State within 12 months of royal assent to publish and lay before Parliament a review of the effectiveness of enforcement activity relating to illegal subletting of social housing. The review would have to include information on numbers of prosecutions, numbers of properties recovered and any barriers to enforcement. Mr Vickers, as I've already set out to the committee, the government is undertaking a review of social housing stock management which specifically considers unlawful subletting and tenancy fraud in it. It would be premature, in our view, to legislate for a separate enforcement review before that work has concluded.

The findings of the stock management review will help inform any future action, I can give the shadow minister that assurance. In addition, much of the information the amendment seeks to collect is already collected through other sources, including local authority housing statistics. New statutory reporting requirements would add limited value, while placing additional burdens on local authorities and registered providers. As a man who wants to deregulate and remove burdens, I'm again surprised that he's urging the government to add new burdens and requirements on local authorities. But, in our view, in this instance they aren't warranted.

We think that would risk diverting resources away from frontline housing management and service delivery. Mr Vickers, where unlawful occupation of social housing properties occurs, the government, as I said, expects landlords to take active steps to tackle fraud and ensure social housing is used fairly, and this may include taking legal action. And the government is already taking targeted action to detect tenancy fraud and recover social homes. Through the Cabinet Office's National Fraud Initiative, tenancy records from local councils and participating housing associations are routinely cross-matched against wider public sector data to identify unlawfully occupied properties, saving the public purse an estimated £78,300 for every home recovered. On the 8th of July, the government also announced a new innovative data-sharing partnership between the Public Sector Fraud Authority and Airbnb.

This first-of-its-kind agreement, led by the Public Sector Fraud Authority within the Cabinet Office, will ensure social housing properties remain there for families who need them and not in the hands of criminals. This is a clear example of the government taking action on fraud. For these reasons, I'd ask the shadow minister to respectfully withdraw the new clause.

11:23 - 11:26

Speaker 21

Gareth Bacon.

11:26 - 11:34

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Okay.

On balance, Mr. Vickers, I will accede to the minister's request and will withdraw this clause.

11:34 - 11:58

Martin Vickers

Is everyone content for new clause 38 to be withdrawn? New clause 38, by leave, withdrawn. We now come to group 46 and new clause 39, with which it will be convenient to consider new clauses 47, 48, 49, 50, and 51, in the name of the official opposition, and new clause 61 in the name of Lee Dillon. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 39.

11:58 - 16:37

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I rise to move new clause 39, which stands in my name. Every member will have heard from constituents living with damp, mould, faulty wiring, or repairs that never arrived. The death of Awaab Ishak shamed this country, and we all promised that it would never happen again. Since then, the Government has introduced new hazard regulations.

The regulations alone do not help a landlord who is unsure what compliance looks like or a tenant who does not know what to expect. This new clause attempts to fill that gap. Within 12 months of royal assent, the Secretary of State must publish guidance including detailed instructions for full compliance with the 2025 regulations. It would also cover damp, mould, electrical safety, response times for repairs, and complaints procedures. Registered providers would have to have regard to it.

Clear standards protect tenants and give landlords certainty, good landlords certainty. With regards to new clause 47, social homes are safe havens for some of the most vulnerable in our society. Whether facing destitution, abuse, or persecution, some of those with the greatest need in our society find their safety and peace in social housing. Yet, for too many residents, estates are poorly managed, antisocial behaviour is rife, and tenants are unsupported. Residents must not bear the burden of poor management practices, and that's why I've tabled new clause 47, which would require the Secretary of State, within six months of royal assent, to publish guidance on the social responsibilities of providers.

Of course, up and down the country, many providers already exercise good practice, due diligence, and uphold their respons- social responsibilities. There is- exists, however, a small fraction within the system who do not fulfil their responsibilities as required, and new clause 47 would strengthen the Government's hand in ensuring and enforcing good practices and give tenants greater protections against unscrupulous behaviours. With regard to new clause 48, social housing is not an issue that ends up, that ends with the housing of vulnerable people, but begins with it. Once homes are found for those in need, it is vital that registered providers are properly managed, run, and governed. At present, I believe that not enough is being done to ensure that this is the case, and that is why I've tabled new clause 48, which is a probing clause, which would require a review of governance arrangements within registered providers of social housing.

It should not be the case that just because someone is vulnerable, they have little say in how their estate is run, who runs it, or what agreements are being made, and that is why new clause 48 has a specific focus on key points such as accountability to local communities. We want to see a fair and accountable social housing sector, and I call on the minister to assure the committee of that future here today. With regards to new clause 49, registered providers are responsible for nearly 3 million homes, around 63% of all homes that make up the national housing social housing stock. In some parts of the country, housing association stock outweighs that of local authorities by huge margins, such as in the north-west, where 86% of stock is owned by private registered providers. These tenants deserve nothing less than the openness and clarity about how the est- estates are run, and new clause 49 asks the Secretary of State to publish, within 12 months of royal assent, guidance on minimum governance standards.

It would cover financial transparency, tenant representation, and the publication of performance criteria. Again, this is a probing clause, and it aims for clearer standards, not red tape. It is a simple and straightforward ask, and I hope the minister will give assurances on that point. With regards to new clause 50, social housing residents deserve accountability.

Where life has dealt a weak hand, the unexpected has created hardship or vulnerabilities have led to inhibitions, social housing should be fair, open and accountable backstop. And that is why new clause 50 will seek to enable local authorities to require senior housing association representatives to attend scrutiny committee meetings. For the most vulnerable in society, protections are essential, and that is why it is necessary to scrutinize the performance of registered providers. As I said before, the vast majority of providers are fair, efficient and honest, but it is unfair on tenants to assume this without checking. And that is why new clause 50 has been added, or has been tabled to this bill.

Finally, Mr. Vickers, new clause 51. Across the public and private sectors, it is good practice to evaluate and publicize the performance of any department, business, or team. This same practice should be applied to registered housing providers. That's why I've tabled new clause 51, which would require housing associations to publish quarterly performance information. This includes vital works, such as repairs left incomplete after 6 months, complaints, anti-social behaviours, levels of tenant satisfaction, and void properties.

These are critical issues that cannot be left unsolved in an efficient and trustworthy social housing system. And that is why I've tabled new clause 51.

16:37 - 16:38

Lee Dillon.

16:38 - 16:39

Oh, sorry.

16:39 - 16:43

Speaker 22

Standards relating to the maintenance of social housing. Lee Dillon.

16:43 - 18:08

Lee Dillon

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I rise to speak in support of new clause 61 tabled in my name, which is a probing amendment. A home and place standard, as the clause outlines, is about being able to have a design and place-making framework for an organization, and to be able to measure housing quality, guide strategic conveyance investment, and shape resident well-being. The core pillars of a standard should focus on customers, it should focus on home, it should focus on the place, and make sure as well that social housing providers are part of the sustainable future. And whilst it may not be appropriate in this legislation to mandate a standard onto PRPs, I would be keen to hear from the minister in how his department is shaping the future standards for the sector, but really encouraging those PRPs to go further, to think just beyond their bricks and mortar, but to think about where their homes are situated, their role that they play on an estate, their role that they can play in a town, encouraging sustainable transport into new developments, and really having that holistic approach to what makes social housing so important, and how we can make it even more successful.

18:08 - 23:54

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I'll speak to this group of seven amendments together, beginning with new clause 39. In doing so, I must welcome the shadow minister's comments in relation to standards and decency. It is reassuring to know that his deregulatory zeal does not extend to Awaab's law, to the Decent Homes Standard, to minimum energy efficiency standards. Mr. Vickers, as well as delivering the biggest increase in social and affordable house building in a generation, we're determined to drive a transformational and lasting change in the safety and quality of social housing, and maintenance is a critical part of this.

We've set out the standards required for social housing through the Decent Homes Standard. We will be providing more detailed guidance on how landlords can meet this in the coming months. We've also published electrical safety guidance setting out rights and responsibilities for landlords, local authorities and tenants. On complaints, social landlords are already subject to the housing ombudsman statutory complaint handling code. We're working closely with the ombudsman to ensure it has the resources and capacity to meet increased demand and support better complaint handling by landlords.

We've also, as the hon. members of the committee know, introduced Awaab's law, with clear time-bound requirements on social landlords to investigate hazards and take action.

Ahead of phase two coming into force on the 30th of November, we've published updated guidance to support landlords to comply with those requirements. Awaab's law promotes a person-centered approach, putting the need to make individuals safe at the heart of legislation. I again commend the opposition because it was an opposition Act of Parliament that provided the powers to introduce Awaab's law into the social rented sector. In our view, it wouldn't be appropriate for government to tell landlords how to put individuals at the heart of legislation as the solutions will vary depending on individual circumstances and, for that reason, we don't believe this additional guidance as called for in this new clause is necessary. Turning to new clauses 47 and 61, 47 in the name of the shadow minister, 61 in the name of the honourable member for Newbury,

the first would require the Secretary of State to publish guidance on the social responsibilities of registered providers of social housing; the second would require the regulator to publish a home and place standard, alongside a methodology for assessing providers against the standard. Mr. Vickers, all registered providers of social housing must deliver the outcomes set out in the regulatory standards set by the independent regulator. These standards specify a range of outcomes, including those relating to the safety and quality of homes, where providers must have a good understanding of the condition of their homes and meet the Decent Homes Standard. They require providers to treat their tenants with fairness and respect and take action to deliver fair and equitable outcomes for them. The standards also set outcomes relating to the role that social housing providers must play to support social, environmental, and economic well-being within the areas in which they operate, and require registered providers to work in partnership with the local authority, the police, and other relevant organisations to deter and tackle anti-social behaviour.

The regulator seeks assurance from registered providers that the outcomes set out in these standards are being met, including through routine inspections of large registered providers, as a range of enforcement powers at its disposal where required. Taking all of that into account, I'm of the view that neither an additional quality standard nor further guidance on the social responsibilities of registered providers are necessary. Turning now to clauses new clauses 48 and 49, new clause 48 would require the Secretary of State to undertake a review of the governance arrangements of registered providers of social housing, while new clause 49 would require the Secretary of State to publish guidance establishing minimum governance standards for registered providers. I agree that strong governance, transparency and accountability are fundamental to a well-functioning social housing sector.

However, it's my view that strong governance mechanisms are already in place. Private registered providers are already subject to the governance and financial viability standards set by the regulator. The standard requires providers to have effective governance arrangements which deliver their aims and intended outcomes for tenants in an effective, transparent, and accountable manner. It also requires them to be accountable to tenants, the regulator, and relevant stakeholders. All registered providers must also meet the transparency, influence and accountability standard, which requires providers to give tenants meaningful opportunities to influence and scrutinise their strategies, policies and services.

Providers are required to publish information about their performance through the tenant satisfaction measures. The regulator is currently considering how its approach to economic regulation should evolve through its More and better social homes discussion document, including how regulation of governance can be strengthened. In that light, I don't think that either a separate statutory review or further guidance from the Secretary of State is necessary. Moving to new clause 50, also tabled by the shadow minister, this would require senior officers of registered providers to attend local authority overview and scrutiny committees in certain circumstances.

The government recognises the importance of strong relationships between PRPs and local authorities, and we're committed to giving local leaders more influence over housing in their local areas. Social housing providers have an important role to play in their communities. We expect them to work constructively with local authorities and respond openly and transparently where concerns arise. In this context, I should hope that senior officers of registered providers would be willing to engage with their local authority in whatever forum was most suitable to the specific circumstance. Whilst oversight of registered providers is important, it's my view that it would be disproportionate to require a senior officer of a registered provider to attend a local authority's overview and scrutiny committee meeting in particular.

This is because we are bringing forward an enhanced scrutiny regime through schedules 4 and 5 of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, which makes provisions for local scrutiny committees for mayorship strategic authorities.

These will have the power to require a key person to attend meetings or provide information where required. A key person can mean the mayor, deputy mayor, mayoral commissioners, officers of the authority, and members of the authority with policy responsibilities, as well as others that will be specified in regulations.

23:54 - 23:55

Will the minister briefly give way?

23:55 - 23:56

I will give way.

23:56 - 23:57

Edward Argar.

23:57 - 24:08

Edward John Argar

I'm grateful to the minister for being typically generous in giving way. What provision is he putting in place to replicate that where there is no mayoral authority?

24:08 - 26:00

Matthew Pennycook

He makes a well-made point that the set of arrangements I've just specified apply to mayoral strategic authorities. It is worth making clear, though, that where there are concerns that a registered provider may not be meeting the outcomes in the regulatory standards, these can be referred to the independent regulator of social housing. This is not the only route. Just talking about in terms of local authority scrutiny, there are new measures coming forward through the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill in that regard. It tempts me to debate a much wider issue than the scope of these new clauses.

Turning, finally, to new clause 51, Mr. Vickers, seeks to require all registered providers to publish specified information on their performance every three months. The government is committed to really ensuring that tenants have clear and meaningful information about their landlord's performance and are able to hold them to account. I also recognize the importance of continuing to improve the quality of data available and ensuring that it's used effectively to identify emerging risks and drive better outcomes for tenants. However, there is already an extensive framework in place to achieve this. All registered providers are required to publish tenant satisfaction measures annually.

These cover many of the areas identified in the new clause, including repairs, complaints, anti-social behavior, and tenant's overall satisfaction with their landlords. Those measures also sit alongside a much wider range of regulatory, financial, and statistical information collected by the regulator, including information on providers' stocks and rents. The regulator's transparency, influence, and accountability standard also requires all registered providers to collect and provide information that supports effective scrutiny by tenants of their landlord's performance. I'm mindful of the need to keep reporting requirements on registered providers proportionate and to minimize administrative burdens, and it's my view that the current framework strikes the right balance. For those reasons, I don't believe that prescribing a further, quarterly reporting regime in primary legislation is necessary or proportionate.

For the reasons I've given, Mr. Vickers, I hope the honorable members opposite will withdraw their respective new clauses.

26:00 - 26:02

Speaker 30

Gareth Bacon.

26:02 - 26:11

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I thank the minister for his excuse me, lengthy answer and I will accede to his wishes and withdraw all of those clauses.

26:11 - 26:27

Martin Vickers

Is everyone content for new clause 39 to be withdrawn? New clause 39, by leave, withdrawn. We now come to new clause 40, which was debated in group 18 with clause 17 stand part. Gareth Bacon, to move formally.

26:27 - 26:30

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Formally, Chairman.

26:30 - 26:33

Speaker 38

Fixed-term tenancies for social housing.

26:33 - 26:37

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 40 be read a second time. As many as that opinion say aye.

26:37 - 26:38

To the contrary, no.

26:38 - 26:40

Speaker 35

No.

26:40 - 26:42

Martin Vickers

Division. Lock the doors.

26:42 - 26:52

Speaker 43

15:11

26:52 - 26:54

Speaker 31

Gideon Amos?

26:55 - 26:56

Edward Argar?

26:57 - 26:58

Gareth Bacon?

26:59 - 27:02

Speaker 40

Danny Beales? Rachel Blake?

27:02 - 27:04

Speaker 33

No.

27:04 - 27:05

Sureena Brackenridge?

27:06 - 27:07

Nesil Caliskan?

27:08 - 27:09

Lewis Cocking?

27:09 - 27:12

Speaker 29

Aye.

27:12 - 27:13

Lee Dillon?

27:14 - 27:15

Mary Kelly Foy?

27:16 - 27:17

Matthew Pennycook?

27:18 - 27:18

John Slinger?

27:18 - 27:20

Speaker 36

No.

27:20 - 27:21

Patrick Spencer?

27:22 - 27:22

Laurence Turner?

27:23 - 27:24

Steve Yemm?

27:24 - 27:34

Speaker 18

No.

27:34 - 27:46

Martin Vickers

The ayes were 4 and the noes were 11, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to new clause 41, which was debated with clause 13 stand part in group 14.

27:46 - 27:47

Gareth Bacon to move formally?

27:47 - 27:50

Speaker 59

I move, formally, Chairman.

27:50 - 27:51

Shared ownership strategy.

27:51 - 28:01

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 41 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division. Lock the doors.

28:01 - 28:06

Speaker 47

Division in room 11.

28:06 - 28:07

Gideon Amos?

28:08 - 28:09

Edward Argar?

28:10 - 28:11

Gareth Bacon?

28:12 - 28:13

Danny Beales?

28:14 - 28:15

Rachel Blake?

28:16 - 28:17

Sureena Brackenridge?

28:18 - 28:19

Nesil Caliskan?

28:19 - 28:21

Nesil Caliskan

No.

28:21 - 28:22

Lewis Cocking?

28:23 - 28:24

Lee Dillon?

28:25 - 28:26

Mary Kelly Foy?

28:27 - 28:28

Matthew Pennycook?

28:29 - 28:30

John Slinger?

28:31 - 28:32

Patrick Spencer?

28:33 - 28:33

Lawrence Turner?

28:34 - 28:35

Steve Yemm?

28:35 - 28:44

Speaker 18

No.

28:44 - 29:02

Martin Vickers

The Ayes were 6 and the Noes were 9, so the Noes have it. The Noes have it. We now come to new clause Unlock. We now come to new clause 42, which was debated with clause 18 stand part in group 19.

Gareth Bacon to move formally?

29:02 - 29:04

Speaker 44

I formally move, Chairman.

29:04 - 29:07

Speaker 46

Review of income eligibility for social housing.

29:07 - 29:20

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 42 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division. Lock the doors.

29:20 - 29:22

Speaker 58

Gideon Amos?

29:22 - 29:23

Edward Argar?

29:24 - 29:25

Gareth Bacon?

29:25 - 29:27

Speaker 53

Aye.

29:27 - 29:28

Danny Beales?

29:28 - 29:29

Rachel Blake?

29:29 - 29:31

Speaker 52

No.

29:31 - 29:32

Sureena Brackenridge?

29:33 - 29:34

Nesil Caliskan?

29:35 - 29:36

Lewis Cocking?

29:37 - 29:38

Lee Dillon?

29:39 - 29:40

Mary Kelly Foy?

29:40 - 29:42

Speaker 60

No.

29:42 - 29:43

Matthew Pennycook?

29:43 - 29:44

John Slinger?

29:45 - 29:46

Patrick Spencer?

29:47 - 29:47

Lawrence Turner?

29:48 - 29:49

Steve Yemm?

29:49 - 29:57

Speaker 18

No.

29:57 - 30:09

Martin Vickers

The Ayes were 4 and the Noes were 9, so the Noes have it. The Noes have it. We now come to new clause 43, which has been debated in group 41. Gareth Bacon to move formally?

30:09 - 30:11

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I formally move, Chairman.

30:11 - 30:22

Speaker 50

Review of income eligibility for social housing. Pardon me, sorry, 43. Assessment of social housing demand arising from inward migration.

30:22 - 30:35

Martin Vickers

We're all taking absolute notes for this. The question is that new clause 43 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division.

30:35 - 30:40

Speaker 56

Division in room 11.

30:40 - 30:41

Gideon Amos?

30:42 - 30:42

Edward Argar?

30:43 - 30:44

Gareth Bacon?

30:45 - 30:46

Danny Beales?

30:47 - 30:48

Rachel Blake?

30:49 - 30:50

Sureena Brackenridge?

30:51 - 30:52

Nesil Caliskan?

30:53 - 30:54

Lewis Cocking?

30:55 - 30:56

Lee Dillon?

30:57 - 30:58

Mary Kelly Foy?

30:59 - 31:00

Matthew Pennycook?

31:01 - 31:01

John Slinger?

31:02 - 31:03

Patrick Spencer?

31:04 - 31:05

Lawrence Turner?

31:05 - 31:08

Speaker 55

No.

31:08 - 31:16

Speaker 18

No.

31:08 - 31:08

Steve Yemm?

31:16 - 31:30

Martin Vickers

The Ayes were 4, the Noes were 11, so the Noes have it. The Noes have it. We now come to new clause 44, which was debated in group 39 with new clause 28.

Gareth Bacon to move formally.

31:30 - 31:35

Speaker 57

Clause is withdrawn, chairman.

31:35 - 31:42

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 45 which was debated in group 14 with clause 13 stand part. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

31:42 - 31:44

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Withdrawn, chairman.

31:44 - 31:51

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 46 which was debated in group 39 with new clause 28. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

31:51 - 31:53

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Withdrawn, chairman.

31:53 - 32:00

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 47 which was debated in group 46 with new clause 39. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

32:00 - 32:03

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Again withdrawn, chairman.

32:03 - 32:11

Martin Vickers

We now come to news clause 48 which was debated in group 46 with new clause 39. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

32:11 - 32:13

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Withdrawn.

32:13 - 32:18

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 49 which was debated in group 46. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

32:18 - 32:20

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Withdrawn, chairman.

32:20 - 32:26

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 50 which was debated in group 46 with new clause 39. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

32:26 - 32:28

Speaker 67

Withdrawn.

32:28 - 32:34

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 51 which was debated in group 46 with new clause 39. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

32:34 - 32:38

Speaker 69

Withdrawn, chairman.

32:38 - 32:45

Martin Vickers

We now come to group 47 and new clause 59. I call Gareth Bacon to move new clause 52.

32:45 - 33:44

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Chairman. I rise to move new clause 52 which stands in my name. The most recent data available to us shows that the waiting list for social housing stands at a shocking and shameful 1.34 million people. This data, however, is now well out of date, coming from an MHCLG publication from March 2025. To understand one of the fundamental issues we are here to rectify, that is, how to get people off the streets, out of temporary accommodation and into social housing, we must have the full scale of the issue before us.

And that is why I've tabled new clause 52, which would require housing register applications to be reviewed at least every 3 years to ensure that the waiting lists remain accurate and up-to-date. Without this, it is impossible for resources to be properly distributed, stock to be efficiently allocated and decisions to be made promptly. Efficiency means more than people finding themselves with a roof over their heads and a place to call home. That is why I believe the proposals in new clause 52 make essential and much-needed changes to the system.

33:44 - 33:47

Speaker 66

Periodic review of applications for social housing.

33:47 - 33:52

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 52 be read a second time. Minister.

33:52 - 35:25

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr Vickers. I thank the shadow minister for tabling and speaking to this amendment. I'm enjoying the irony, Mr Vickers, of a minister who bemoans this government's, in his words, zealous over-centralisation, our penchant for regulation. And here we are, that the shadow minister with an amendment that would impose a statutory requirement for local authorities to review a housing register at least once every 3 years, i.e., a new duty that would create additional administrative burdens without any evidence it would improve allocation decisions. Mr Vickers, local authorities take different approaches to managing their housing registers.

It's right that they have the flexibility to do what works best for their own local area. In addition, councils already reassess housing need both before a household joins the waiting list and again before allocating a social home, ensuring that social homes are going to those most in need. In August, we launched a call for evidence, as I've mentioned a number of times in the proceedings in the committee, call for evidence for our review of the statutory guidance on social housing and allocations. This review is providing an opportunity for us to consider whether clearer expectations would help local authorities maintain accurate registers, including how they review applications and respond to changes in circumstances. But our clear starting point, Mr Vickers, is that this is a process that local authorities are best placed to manage themselves, and we will intend to address expectations through statutory guidance, if necessary.

For those reasons, I hope the shadow minister might consider withdrawing the new clause.

35:25 - 35:38

Andrew Gareth Bacon

On this occasion, I will respectfully decline the Minister's invitation. I stand by my remarks, Mr Vickers. If we do not understand the scale of the problem, we cannot possibly tailor our solutions correctly, so we will be seeking to divide on this new clause.

35:38 - 35:50

Martin Vickers

New clause 52 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division.

Lock the doors.

35:50 - 35:55

Speaker 75

Division in room 11.

35:55 - 35:56

Gideon Amos?

35:57 - 35:58

Edward Argar?

35:59 - 36:00

Gareth Bacon?

36:01 - 36:03

Speaker 83

No.

36:01 - 36:01

Danny Beales?

36:03 - 36:04

Rachel Blake?

36:05 - 36:05

Sureena Brackenridge?

36:06 - 36:07

Nesil Caliskan?

36:07 - 36:09

Speaker 73

No.

36:09 - 36:10

Lewis Cocking?

36:11 - 36:13

Speaker 86

Lee Dillon?

36:14 - 36:16

Speaker 84

No.

36:14 - 36:14

Mary Kelly Foy?

36:16 - 36:17

Matthew Pennycook?

36:18 - 36:19

John Slinger?

36:19 - 36:20

Patrick Spencer?

36:20 - 36:22

Speaker 96

Aye.

36:22 - 36:23

Laurence Turner?

36:24 - 36:25

Steve Yemm?

36:25 - 36:33

Speaker 18

No.

36:33 - 36:47

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four, and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to new clause 53, which was debated in group 25 with new clause 3. Gareth Bacon to move formally?

36:47 - 36:50

Andrew Gareth Bacon

That clause is withdrawn, Mr Chairman.

36:50 - 36:57

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 54, which was debated in group 44 with new clause 36. Gareth Bacon to move formally?

36:57 - 36:58

Formally, Chairman.

36:58 - 37:01

Martin Vickers

The question- sorry.

37:01 - 37:04

Speaker 98

Review of the impact of this act on home ownership.

37:04 - 37:17

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 54 be read a second time. As many as of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division. Lock the doors.

37:17 - 37:18

Gideon Amos?

37:18 - 37:19

Edward Argar?

37:20 - 37:21

Gareth Bacon?

37:22 - 37:23

Danny Beales?

37:24 - 37:26

Speaker 90

No.

37:24 - 37:24

Rachel Blake?

37:26 - 37:27

Sureena Brackenridge?

37:28 - 37:29

Nesil Caliskan?

37:30 - 37:31

Lewis Cocking?

37:32 - 37:33

Lee Dillon?

37:33 - 37:36

Speaker 91

No.

37:36 - 37:37

Mary Kelly Foy?

37:38 - 37:39

Matthew Pennycook?

37:40 - 37:41

John Slinger?

37:42 - 37:43

Patrick Spencer?

37:44 - 37:45

Laurence Turner?

37:46 - 37:47

Steve Yemm?

37:47 - 38:01

Speaker 18

No.

38:01 - 38:13

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four, and the noes were 10, so the noes have it, the noes have it. We now come to new clause 55, which was debated with clause 1 stand part in group 1. Gareth Bacon to move formally?

38:13 - 38:15

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Formally, Chairman.

38:15 - 38:18

Speaker 110

Strategy relating to right to buy 16 to 25 year olds.

38:18 - 38:30

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 55 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division. Room 11.

38:30 - 38:31

Gideon Amos?

38:32 - 38:32

Edward Argar?

38:33 - 38:34

Gareth Bacon?

38:34 - 38:36

Speaker 103

Aye.

38:36 - 38:38

Speaker 78

No.

38:36 - 38:36

Danny Beales?

38:38 - 38:38

Rachel Blake?

38:39 - 38:40

Sureena Brackenridge?

38:40 - 38:42

Speaker 85

No.

38:42 - 38:43

Nesil Caliskan?

38:44 - 38:45

Lewis Cocking?

38:46 - 38:47

Lee Dillon?

38:47 - 38:49

Speaker 87

Abstain.

38:49 - 38:49

Mary Kelly Foy?

38:49 - 38:51

Speaker 79

No.

38:51 - 38:52

Matthew Pennycook?

38:53 - 38:55

Speaker 74

No.

38:53 - 38:53

John Slinger?

38:55 - 38:55

Patrick Spencer?

38:55 - 38:57

Speaker 77

Aye.

38:57 - 38:57

Laurence Turner?

38:57 - 38:59

Speaker 76

No.

38:59 - 39:07

Speaker 18

No.

38:59 - 38:59

Steve Yemm?

39:07 - 39:18

Martin Vickers

The ayes were four, and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. We now come to new clause 56, which was debated in group 39 with new clause 38. Gareth Bacon to move formally?

39:18 - 39:21

Speaker 82

No, that clause is withdrawn, Chairman.

39:21 - 39:27

Martin Vickers

We now come to new clause 57, which was debated with clause 1 stand part in group 1. Gareth Bacon to move formally?

39:27 - 39:29

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Formally, Chairman.

39:29 - 39:33

Speaker 102

Transitional arrangements relating to qualifying period for right to buy.

39:33 - 39:38

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 57 be read a second time. As many of that opinion, say "aye".

39:38 - 39:39

To the contrary, "no".

39:40 - 39:45

Speaker 105

Division, lock the doors.

39:45 - 39:46

Gideon Amos.

39:47 - 39:48

Edward Argar.

39:49 - 39:50

Gareth Bacon.

39:50 - 39:51

Danny Beales.

39:52 - 39:52

Rachel Blake.

39:53 - 39:54

Sureena Brackenridge.

39:55 - 39:56

Nesil Caliskan.

39:57 - 39:57

Lewis Cocking.

39:58 - 39:59

Lee Dillon.

40:00 - 40:01

Mary Kelly Foy.

40:02 - 40:03

Matthew Pennycook.

40:03 - 40:04

John Slinger.

40:05 - 40:06

Patrick Spencer.

40:07 - 40:08

Laurence Turner.

40:09 - 40:09

Steve Yemm.

40:09 - 40:18

Speaker 18

No.

40:18 - 40:30

Martin Vickers

The Ayes were 4 and the Noes were 11, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. We now come to new clause 58, which was debated in group 18 with clause 17 stand part. Gareth Bacon to move formally.

40:30 - 40:32

Speaker 106

Move formally, Chairman.

40:32 - 40:34

Speaker 99

Review of lifetime secure tenancies.

40:34 - 40:39

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 58 be read a second time. As many of that opinion, say "aye".

40:39 - 40:40

To the contrary, "no".

40:41 - 40:42

Division.

40:42 - 40:47

Speaker 101

Division in 11.

40:47 - 40:48

Gideon Amos.

40:48 - 40:49

Edward Argar.

40:50 - 40:51

Gareth Bacon.

40:52 - 40:52

Danny Beales.

40:52 - 40:54

Speaker 97

No.

40:54 - 40:54

Rachel Blake.

40:55 - 40:56

Sureena Brackenridge.

40:57 - 40:58

Nesil Caliskan.

40:59 - 40:59

Lewis Cocking.

41:00 - 41:01

Lee Dillon.

41:01 - 41:03

Speaker 92

Abstain.

41:03 - 41:03

Mary Kelly Foy.

41:03 - 41:05

Speaker 95

No.

41:05 - 41:05

Matthew Pennycook.

41:06 - 41:06

John Slinger.

41:07 - 41:08

Patrick Spencer.

41:09 - 41:10

Laurence Turner.

41:10 - 41:11

Steve Yemm.

41:11 - 41:18

Speaker 18

No.

41:18 - 41:29

Martin Vickers

The Ayes were 4 and the Noes were 9, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. We now come to new clause 59, which was debated in group 44 with new clause 36. Lee Dillon to move formally.

41:29 - 41:31

Speaker 107

Withdraw.

41:31 - 41:40

Martin Vickers

The question is, sorry, we now come to group 48 and new clause 60. I call Lee Dillon to move clause 60.

41:40 - 43:53

Lee Dillon

Thank you, Mr Davies. So, I stand to move new clause 60 in my name, which is access to dwellings for registered providers. As members of the Committee will know, I worked in social housing for 14 years before entering this place. And one of the more challenging aspects of the role that we undertook was ensuring the safety of our residents, particularly when that came to annual gas safety checks, whereby we would have to make three attempts before then going to court and seeking an injunction in order to access the property. This not only costs the social provider legal costs, it also extends the amount of potential time where a tenant is residing in a property without a boiler having its approved checks done.

This also can expand to 5-year electrical safety checks, and only yesterday, Mr Chairman, I hosted a round table with the British Pest Control Association, where we spoke about the delays of access in those incidences really causing further damage by pest infestation. If you think, for example, with bedbugs, they will often move within a block of flats, so quick access into all dwellings in that particular incident is key to be able to stop the spread and the impact that has. So, this bill is, or this amendment, new clause has come from experience of working in the sector.

I've never known a judge to not grant an injunction when a social landlord has been able to prove that they made those three attempts. And whilst article 8 and the right to a private life may come up, that is of course a qualified right, so, as long as it was in accordance with the law, if it was necessary and proportionate, or if it was pursuing a legitimate aim, article 8 considerations can be laid aside. Thank you.

43:53 - 43:55

Speaker 93

Access to dwellings for registered providers.

43:55 - 44:00

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 60 be read a second time. Minister.

44:00 - 45:44

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Can I thank the honourable gentleman, the Member for Newbury, for tabling and speaking to this new clause? It does raise an important issue. We recognise it's been an area of growing concern. There were some particularly considered and constructive debates in the other place on it, and I should express our thanks to the noble Lord Best for his engagement on this issue.

What those debates have reinforced is that this issue is incredibly complex. It involves the interaction of fundamental rights of tenants, the legal duties placed on landlords, and the safety of both residents and their neighbours. To reassure the honourable gentleman, since those debates in the other place, the government has been undertaking an intensive process of engagement, of policy development examining the issue. We're grateful, in that respect, to the input, expertise that we have received from a range of residents groups, landlords, representative bodies and charities. Mr. Vickers, that engagement has put beyond doubt that there is an issue here that must be resolved.

However, it also made clear that we can't act in haste and risk creating new systemic problems, and there are a range of challenges that arise from various options in this area. For that reason, the government can't support this amendment, but we will shortly be bringing forward a consultation that will examine the issue in the round, to try and get at some of those challenges, what potential solutions might be. And it will also look at the design and necessary safeguards for any new law in this space. To support the sector with practical advice, we'll also bring forward plans to develop best practice guidance on access procedures. So, I absolutely understand and recognise his expertise in the area, it is a valid point he raises, but for the reasons I've given, I hope he will accept to withdraw his new clause.

45:44 - 45:45

Lee Dillon.

45:45 - 46:18

Lee Dillon

Can I thank the minister for that reply and for the department understanding the wider impact it has, and welcome the consultation being launched, and I agree that it does need a lot of thought and balance between a landlord's rights and a tenant's rights. And even from, since drafting my new clause 60, I hadn't included pests as a hazard in there, which I appreciate that should be included as well. So, I would happily withdraw the new clause and look forward to seeing progress made by the government.

46:18 - 46:32

Martin Vickers

Is everyone content for new clause 60 to be withdrawn? New clause 60, by leave, withdrawn. We now come to new clause 61, which was debated in group 46, with the new clause 39. Lee Dillon to move formally.

46:32 - 46:35

Speaker 112

Withdrawn.

46:35 - 46:46

Martin Vickers

We now come to group 49 and new clause 62, with which it will be convenient to consider new clause 63. I call Lee Dillon to move new clause 62.

46:46 - 47:16

Lee Dillon

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I stand to move new clause 62 and new clause 63 tabled in my name. These are both simple new clauses that we would hope to see support from all sides on. In effect, Mr. Chairman, new clause 62 is looking at the opportunity for social tenants to be able to have an electric charging point on existing stock, and new clause 63 is seeking the same, but for new builds. Thank you.

47:16 - 47:19

Speaker 111

Ability of tenants to request an electric vehicle charging point.

47:19 - 47:25

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 62 be read a second time. Minister.

47:25 - 49:30

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Can I assure the honorable gentleman the government is committed to improving access to convenient home charging for tenants, and this includes in social housing. However, we don't believe new clause 62 is the right way to achieve that objective for the reasons I'll set out. Tenants can face hurdles getting landlord or freeholder approval, sometimes without a clear reason. That's not in dispute.

The Department for Transport is already consulting on an ability to charge for tenants and leaseholders. This consultation, published on the 21st of October, considers both legislation and non-statutory guidance to give residents clearer routes to request permission for a charge point. The consultation also seeks views on setting clearer expectations for landlords and freeholders when responding to those requests, and that includes in social housing. This new clause would therefore pre-empt that consultation by introducing requirements before the government has considered any evidence or fully assessed the impacts. This risks, Mr. Vickers, in our view, introducing grounds for refusal which could be inappropriate and have the unintended consequence of deeming certain scenarios unreasonable when they are not, serving to limit access to home charging for tenants rather than making it more accessible.

We want to ensure that any intervention is workable for tenants, while also taking proper account of the legitimate responsibilities and constraints faced by landlords and freeholders. New clause 62 risks creating an inconsistent approach between different property types, which could cause confusion for housing providers and leave other tenants without the same protections. Support is already available, Mr. Vickers, help with the installation costs with existing government grants, providing up to £500 towards the cost of installing an eligible charge point. Turn to new clause 63, which seeks to require new social housing developments to include electrical vehicle charging points. I entirely agree with the honorable gentleman on the importance of ensuring that new homes are equipped for the transition to electric vehicles.

The existing building regulations, part S, introduced in 2021, already require charging infrastructure in new residential buildings and those undergoing major renovations in England. This includes social housing developments. Therefore, in our view, this amendment isn't required. The government is also currently considering whether these requirements should be strengthened via the consultation I just mentioned, that DfT consultation. And for the reasons I've given, therefore, I'm winding up, I'm afraid.

49:30 - 49:31

Gordon Henderson.

49:31 - 49:51

Gordon Henderson

Thank you, minister, for giving way. Just expanding on new clause 63, does he not agree that firstly, before we worry about people electric car charging points, the new developments must have enough parking spaces, because I suspect we all have our postbags full with new developments coming forward without enough parking spaces as it is, without having electric four-wheel car charging points there as well?

49:51 - 49:52

Minister.

49:52 - 50:14

Matthew Pennycook

He tempts me He tempts me to opine on a completely different issue. If he's more than welcome He's more than Car park car parking spaces The honorable gentleman may correct me if not in the scope of this particular amendment. If he wants to write to me with specific concerns on local authority action in that area, he's more than welcome to do so. For those reasons, I hope the honorable gentleman will withdraw his two new clauses.

50:14 - 50:15

Lee Dillon.

50:15 - 50:21

Lee Dillon

I happily accept the minister's considered view about the consultation and withdraw the clauses.

50:21 - 51:26

Martin Vickers

Is it the will of the committee that new clause 62 be withdrawn? Agreed. New clause 62, by leave, withdrawn. We now head to new clause 63, which has been debated in group 49. Lee Dillon, to formally withdraw.

We now come to new clause 64, which has already been debated in group 13 with amendment 4. Does anyone wish to move that clause? No. We now come to new clause 65, which has already been debated in group 13 with amendment 4. Anyone wish to move that formally?

No. We now come to new We now come to group 50 and new clause 66, by which it will be convenient to consider new clause 67. New clause 66 was tabled by Liz Jarvis, who is not a member of the committee. Does anyone wish to move it? Gideon Amos.

51:26 - 54:42

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. It's a pleasure to rise and speak on again. No day would be complete without meeting in this committee rooms on the housing. So, thank you for that, Mr. Vickers. I rise to move the new clause 66 in the name of my honorable friend, the member for Eastleigh, who states in her proposition of this amendment, there are hundreds of thousands of empty homes across England and Wales while many families wait years for social homes or remain in temporary accommodation.

My amendment would require the government to carry out a review of how empty homes could be used as social housing. It would assess how many properties could be brought into use, potential benefits of a dedicated scheme and the barriers that would need to be addressed. Bringing empty homes back into use can be a faster and more cost-effective way of achieving social housing increased supply, whilst also helping to regenerate local communities. This review would give the government the evidence it needs to act, and I hope it will receive support from across the House. My honorable friend is absolutely right.

And in particular, I draw attention to the regeneration benefits of bringing empty homes back into use, which are significant. And we all know our town centres, that many of whom have many of which have too many empty buildings and there is a real bottleneck in terms of the procedure for getting them back into use. The late minister Liberal Democrat housing minister, Andrew Stunell started the last significant empty homes program that any government has put forwards. In that program, the empty homes program began in 2010, 120,000 empty homes were brought back into use. If we compare that with the that's 10 times the number of social homes built created last year alone and a very significant contribution to the need for housing.

When the Conservatives took over in 2015, that program was abandoned, the funding was ended. We now have empty homes on the increase again having fallen to a record low as a result of that program of from 316,000 to 203,000. It's now gone up again under subsequent governments. In October, it has risen to 303,000, almost back to the 2010 levels, up 14% on 2024, and 25% higher, sorry, 50% higher than it was in 2015 when the program ended. The units were brought into use for affordable rent, low-cost home ownership and social rent.

And therefore made a significant contribution not just to housing, but to social housing. The grant was around £22,000 per dwelling, which made them significantly less than the average subsidy used for creating new social housing and was therefore a very important factor. As my honorable friend for Eastleigh has pointed out, there are hundreds of thousands of empty dwellings in the country. We need a program to bring them back into use. It's the missing link in the government's housing policy at the moment.

And a Liberal Democrat government will bring in an empty homes program forthwith, and we commend this amendment to the Committee. Thank you, Mr. Vickers.

54:42 - 54:45

Speaker 117

Review of the use of empty homes in social housing.

54:45 - 54:50

Martin Vickers

The question is that new clause 66 be read a second time. Minister.

54:50 - 56:07

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Can I thank the honorable gentleman, the member for Taunton and Wellington, for speaking to this new clause tabled in the name of his colleague, the member for Eastleigh? Mr. Vickers, he rightly pointed out that there are currently over 300,000 homes that have been empty for six months or more. The government absolutely wants to see more empty homes brought back into use across the country. However, we don't believe a national review or a national empty homes strategy, supported by a new ring-fenced fund, is the right approach.

The scale and causes of empty homes vary considerably between places, as do local housing pressures and the interventions that will be most effective. As such, we believe that local authorities and mayoral strategic authorities are best placed to understand those circumstances and determine the right approach for their area.

Local authorities can already access funding to bring homes back into use, including through the Affordable Homes Programme, the Local Authority Housing Fund and the Long Term Rough Sleeping Programme. Loan funding is also available to the Public Works Loan Board to support the acquisition of empty homes. And as he will know, we're also strengthening local authority powers to bring empty homes back into use by reforming Empty Dwelling Management Orders, removing evidential requirements and reducing the period of property must be empty before it is eligible for an EDMO from two years to six months. I will give way.

56:07 - 56:35

Lee Dillon

I am grateful for the minister for giving way. The minister outlines a number of funding packages and processes that are already set up to tackle empty homes. Can the minister say how well they are working? And therefore, does the government actually need to go further, and having a national strategy, but by having regional breakdown or local levers within that national strategy, actually could help tackle the problem?

56:35 - 56:36

The Minister.

56:36 - 57:19

Matthew Pennycook

Well, he's asked me a very specific question, and what I will commit to going away to do is to try and give him in writing a sense of both the local and regional breakdown of the use of EDMOs and these powers. The funding is available, but I suppose the point I'm making, Mr. Vickers, is that funding can be a barrier, but is only one part of the solution. Local authorities have a range of powers and incentives available to them to tackle empty homes, and we want to continue empowering them to use those, but we think it's right that local authorities retain the flexibility to respond to particular local priorities. And so while the government agrees with the sentiment behind these amendments, Mr. Vickers, we don't believe that this bill is the best route forward. And on that basis, I hope the members opposite might consider withdrawing.

57:19 - 57:21

Speaker 114

Gideon Amos.

57:21 - 59:26

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Perhaps I can give the example of, from my own experience, where I put on record my interest as a social landlord. Under the programme I've described, I, in a former life, I brought into use four empty dwellings as social housing. And the challenge is that whilst the grant level is generally less, and the cost can be less than building a new home, the schemes themselves are much more complicated, complex, because the ownership, existing buildings, consents, many are listed. So, it's with some trepidation that I think owners and developers will go into this field.

So, without the benefit of the previous scheme was that was a ring-fenced scheme which was dedicated for empty homes, rather than relying on existing processes and programs that don't normally, don't, for example, the affordable, a social housing program won't generally be geared up towards some what can be long-winded and complex schemes in the empty homes field. Having that ring fence fund that is named and available gives I think owners and developers the confidence to know that the empty home scheme will compete well among amongst the applications being submitted in the Social and Affordable Housing programme. So, and I just reiterate, finally, Mr. Vickers, that it was the most successful programme that I can find ever recorded in empty homes. It brought the level of empty homes down to its lowest level ever, brought 300, 320,000 down to 200,000. So, it was proven, this is proven technology, Mr. Vickers, so we should proceed with it, and unless and until the government have their own empty homes program, which I haven't heard, you know, said, I think we should continue to push for this, and I will be pushing it to a vote, Mr. Vickers.

59:26 - 59:40

Martin Vickers

New Clause 66 proposed as on the amendment paper. The question is that the Clause be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. Division.

Lock the doors.

59:40 - 59:41

Gideon Amos?

59:42 - 59:43

Ed Argar?

59:44 - 59:45

Gareth Bacon?

59:46 - 59:49

Speaker 115

Danny Beales? Rachel Blake?

59:50 - 59:53

Speaker 118

Sureena Brackenridge? Nesil Caliskan?

59:53 - 59:55

Speaker 122

No.

59:55 - 59:56

Lewis Cocking?

59:57 - 59:58

Lee Dillon?

59:58 - 01:00:00

Speaker 119

Aye.

01:00:00 - 01:00:00

Mary Kelly Foy?

01:00:00 - 01:00:02

Speaker 124

No.

01:00:02 - 01:00:03

Matthew Pennycook?

01:00:04 - 01:00:05

John Slinger?

01:00:06 - 01:00:06

Patrick Spencer?

01:00:06 - 01:00:08

Speaker 116

Abstain.

01:00:08 - 01:00:09

Laurence Turner?

01:00:11 - 01:00:18

Speaker 123

No.

01:00:18 - 01:01:24

Martin Vickers

The ayes were two, and the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to New Clause 67, which has already been debated in group 50. Anyone to move? No.

We now come to New Clause 68, which was debated in group 32 with New Clause 15. Not moved. Government New Schedule 1 was debated in group 21 with New Clause 21. We will, therefore, proceed straight to the question. The Government New Schedule 1 be read a second time.

As many of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 51 and amendment 80, with which it will be convenient to consider amendment 81, clause 20 stand part, government amendment 78, clause 21 stand part, clause 22 stand part, and clause 23 stand part. I call Gareth Bacon to move amendment 80.

01:01:24 - 01:03:17

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I rise to move amendment 80 and 81, which stand in my name. Both, Mr. Vickers, are about transparency and accountability. We believe this bill is unsuited for its own stated purpose: to make provision for social housing. Already at second reading and here at committee, we've seen an unwillingness from the Government towards reshaping this bill into something not only fit for purpose, but that actually delivers provisions to benefit social housing tenants.

If the Government cannot be trusted to deliver fit for tenants over the whole process of parliamentary scrutiny, it would be unwise to let further changes to the system be made by the Secretary of State alone and without the same level of oversight. Let us be clear what clause 20, page 16, line 10, subsection (2) is. It is a Henry VIII clause that allows for this bill, after all the debate, analysis, and scrutiny here and in the other place, to be selectively amended at the whim of the Secretary of State of the day. We believe it's been clear to date that the Government are misguided in their approach to reforming the social housing sector, so it would be unwise to let that further forms go unchecked in the future. That is why I have tabled amendment 80, which would ensure that Ministers cannot just use regulations to amend or repeal existing Acts.

With regards to amendment 81, Mr. Vickers, the Government have done their best to centralise power and avoid scrutiny throughout the last two years. The Planning and Infrastructure Act's demolition of local democracy, the cancellation of elections, and now Henry VIII powers in this bill are just a few examples of this department alone. It is critical that such power grabs don't go unchecked, and that's why I've tabled amendment 81, which would require an affirmative parliamentary procedure for regulations made under clause 20. I recognise that it sometimes is necessary to tackle less consequential points or issues in need of immediate response through secondary legislation, but this does not mean, however, that Ministers have an excuse to avoid the watchful eye of parliamentary scrutiny. So, I hope that all honourable members will support amendments 80 and 81.

01:03:17 - 01:03:19

Speaker 121

Minister.

01:03:19 - 01:07:13

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. Amendments 80 and 81, tabled by the shadow Minister, both concern, as he's made clear, the power in clause 20 to make consequential provision, and the level of parliamentary scrutiny that should apply. I recognise that these amendments seek to ensure robust parliamentary scrutiny, however, as we've already discussed during our proceedings, we believe the bill strikes the right balance. Amendment 80 would prevent consequential regulations from amending or repealing primary legislation. This could mean that any further consequential changes identified following royal assent would require additional primary legislation, which would be an inefficient use of parliamentary time and could delay implementation.

The power, Mr. Vickers, is expressly limited to provisions that are consequential to the act. It cannot be used to pursue new policy objectives whether related or not to the legislation approved by Parliament in this bill. Any regulations made beyond what is consequential on the bill's provisions would be open to legal challenges as well as parliamentary scrutiny. And importantly, clause 20 already provides additional scrutiny where this power is used to amend or repeal primary legislation, which with such regulations requiring the approval of both Houses. Amendment 81 would go further by requiring all consequential regulations to be approved by both Houses.

We don't consider that proportionate. Where regulations do not amend or repeal primary legislation, the negative procedure provides an appropriate level of scrutiny for more technical, supplementary, incidental, transitional or saving provisions. The power itself is limited to making provision that is consequential on the act and is intended to ensure its effective implementation and the maintenance of a coherent legislative framework. I therefore consider that clause 20 provides the appropriate level of parliamentary scrutiny while avoiding unnecessary demands on parliamentary time. And I hope on that basis I've reassured the shadow minister sufficiently that he might withdraw new clauses 80 and 81.

Mr. Vickers, I must speak to clauses 20, 21, 22 and 23 themselves as the general provisions of the bill. Clause 20, as I've just set out, gives the Secretary of State the power to make consequential regulations arising from the bill. The purpose of this power is to ensure that once the act is enacted, any consequential changes to the statute book can be made to ensure that provisions of the act operate effectively and coherently alongside existing legislation. The parliamentary procedure for this power is affirmative where the regulations amend or repeal provision made by an act of Parliament, negative in all other cases. As I've said, we believe this strikes the right balance between parliamentary scrutiny and a proportionate use of Parliament's time.

Clause 21 provides that the bill's extent is to England and Wales only, although the bill's application is to England only. Clause 22 deals with when the different parts of the bill will take effect. Some of the right to buy and right to acquire provisions will come into force straight away on Royal Assent. This is to mitigate any spike in sales which would undermine our central objective to protect existing social homes. However, we will be taking steps to notify tenants via gov.uk and via their landlords of the forthcoming changes to the schemes in the coming weeks and ahead of implementation.

Other provisions in the bill, Mr. Vickers, will come into force two months later where a short period is needed before the changes take effect. Any remaining provisions will be brought into force at a later date by regulations made by the Secretary of State. The clause also allows the Secretary of State to make transitional or saving provision where that is needed as the new arrangements are introduced. Clause 23, they're the general provisions, and that provides the short title of the act, which would be the Social Housing Act 2026. I commend these clauses to the committee.

May I also just briefly beg to move government amendment 78 which makes a consequential change to the bill's extent provisions. This is necessary as a result of new schedule 1 which makes amendments to the Co-operative and Community Benefit Societies Act 2014 and the Companies Act 2006. Amendment 78 ensures the bill's extent provisions properly reflect those amendments. It's therefore a technical and consequential amendment, and I commend it and those other clauses to the committee. Hear.

01:07:13 - 01:07:15

Speaker 127

Gareth Bacon.

01:07:15 - 01:07:22

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I sorry, would like to formally move amendments 80 and 81, Mr. Vickers.

01:07:22 - 01:07:30

Martin Vickers

Amendment 80 to clause 20, as on the amendment paper, the question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye.

01:07:30 - 01:07:32

Speaker 132

No.

01:07:30 - 01:07:30

To the contrary, no.

01:07:32 - 01:07:38

Speaker 138

Division, lock the doors.

01:07:40 - 01:07:41

Edward Argar?

01:07:42 - 01:07:43

Gareth Bacon?

01:07:44 - 01:07:45

Danny Beales?

01:07:46 - 01:07:47

Rachel Blake?

01:07:48 - 01:07:49

Sureena Brackenridge?

01:07:50 - 01:07:51

Nesil Caliskan?

01:07:52 - 01:07:53

Lewis Cocking?

01:07:55 - 01:07:57

Speaker 126

Abstain.

01:07:57 - 01:07:58

Mary Kelly Foy?

01:07:59 - 01:08:00

Matthew Pennycook?

01:08:01 - 01:08:02

John Slinger?

01:08:03 - 01:08:04

Patrick Spencer?

01:08:05 - 01:08:06

Laurence Turner?

01:08:07 - 01:08:15

Speaker 18

No.

01:08:15 - 01:08:29

Martin Vickers

The ayes were 4 and the noes were 9, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Amendment 81 proposed to clause 20 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:08:30 - 01:08:30

To the contrary, no.

01:08:31 - 01:08:36

Speaker 139

Division.

01:08:36 - 01:08:38

Speaker 129

Gideon Amos?

01:08:39 - 01:08:40

Edward Argar?

01:08:41 - 01:08:42

Gareth Bacon?

01:08:43 - 01:08:44

Danny Beales?

01:08:45 - 01:08:46

Rachel Blake?

01:08:47 - 01:08:48

Sureena Brackenridge?

01:08:49 - 01:08:50

Nesil Caliskan?

01:08:51 - 01:08:52

Lewis Cocking?

01:08:55 - 01:08:56

Mary Kelly Foy?

01:08:57 - 01:08:58

Matthew Pennycook?

01:08:58 - 01:09:00

Speaker 130

No.

01:09:00 - 01:09:01

John Slinger?

01:09:02 - 01:09:03

Patrick Spencer?

01:09:04 - 01:09:05

Laurence Turner?

01:09:06 - 01:09:14

Speaker 18

No.

01:09:14 - 01:09:32

Martin Vickers

The ayes were 4 and the noes were 9, so the noes have it. Unlock. Clause 20 was debated in group 51 with amendment 80. The question is that clause 20 as amended stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:09:33 - 01:09:42

Martin Vickers

To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Government amendment 78 to clause 21 was just debated. I call the minister to move the amendment formally.

01:09:42 - 01:09:43

Moved formally.

01:09:43 - 01:09:48

Martin Vickers

The question is that government amendment 78 be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:09:49 - 01:10:02

Martin Vickers

To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Clause 21 as amended has just been debated. The question is that clause 21 as amended stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:10:03 - 01:10:17

Martin Vickers

To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Amendment 84 proposed to clause 22 is on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:10:17 - 01:10:20

Speaker 135

Aye.

01:10:20 - 01:10:22

Speaker 136

Yes, aye. Aye.

01:10:22 - 01:10:23

To the contrary, no.

01:10:23 - 01:10:25

Speaker 134

No.

01:10:25 - 01:10:48

Martin Vickers

I think the noes have it, the noes have it. Government amendments 17, 79, and 18 to clause 22 have been debated. With the leave of the committee, I put a single question on those amendments. The question is that the government amendments 17, 79, and 18 to clause 22 be made. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:10:49 - 01:11:07

Martin Vickers

To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Clauses 22 and 23 have just been debated. With the leave of the committee, I put a single question on these clauses. The question is that clauses 22 as amended and 23 stand part of the bill.

As many of that opinion say aye.

01:11:08 - 01:11:22

Martin Vickers

To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. The final question I must put is that I do report the bill as amended to the House. The question —

01:11:22 - 01:11:23

Point of order, Mr. Vickers.

01:11:23 - 01:11:24

Point of order.

01:11:24 - 01:12:05

Matthew Pennycook

Just briefly Mr. Vickers, can I take the opportunity to put on record my thanks to you and the other chairs of the committee? I also would like to thank our exemplary clerks, the Hansard reporters, and the doorkeepers for overseeing our proceedings. I also thank my officials and my private office who, for all the support they've provided in bringing forward this piece of legislation. Finally, Mr. Vickers, I want to thank honourable friends on this side of the committee for the valuable insights they have provided. When it comes to the shadow minister and the Liberal Democrat spokesman, we've had a spirited and constructive dialogue.

I accept fully there are principal points of disagreement, but I have valued the challenges and contributions that have been made, and I very much look forward to further engagement with all honourable members as the bill progresses through its remaining stages.

01:12:05 - 01:12:06

Gareth Bacon.

01:12:06 - 01:12:37

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Mr. Vickers. I would like to echo the minister's sentiments. Obviously, on a subject like this, there are going to be disagreements across the House. I think they've been largely respectful, and I think also at times really quite good humoured. And so I would like to add my thanks both to the minister, to his officials, to members of my own side, my honourable friends, also to the Liberal Democrats, and to all honourable members across the chamber.

I look forward to seeing you all at report stage.

01:12:37 - 01:12:39

Speaker 131

No one else is catching my eye, so

01:12:39 - 01:12:57

Gideon Amos

Can I simply repeat the thanks that the minister and the opposition have made both to the officials and to my honourable friends who supported me, and thanks to the minister for taking so many amendments on board, at least in spirit if not in reality?

01:12:57 - 01:13:02

Martin Vickers

The question is that I do report the bill as amended to the House. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:13:03 - 01:13:05

Martin Vickers

To the contrary, no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it. Order.