House of Commons

3 September 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:25 - 01:19
Speaker 3
Order, order.  Before we start the questions, I would like to take this opportunity to pay tribute to the legendary Sir Billy Boston.  He was a pioneer in the rugby world, switching codes from Union to League, a record try scorer for Wigan, the second all-time scorer of tries, a World Cup winner for his country, and the first ever Rugby League player to receive a knighthood.  And he was also known for the BBC documentary, The Codebreakers, where because he was black, he couldn't play for Wales, he couldn't play for Cardiff, and he was an exile that had to come north.  May that never happen again. 

And we wish Billy peace in his death.  Right, let us start with the questions.  Can I start with Joe Powell for Secretary of State for Digital, Media and Sport? 
01:19 - 01:21
Speaker 1
Number one please, Mr. Speaker. 
01:21 - 02:00
Speaker 2
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I associate myself with your kind words about the legend that is Sir Billy Boston.  It was also a real pleasure to hear you say the words Wigan without choking in the context of Rugby League.  This government is committed to implementing the regulation of short-term lets.  We believe in our communities and we believe in their right to shape their own areas.  This regulation is about putting power back into people's hands so that they can shape the right balance between the benefits that tourism brings and the needs of people locally to decent housing. 
02:00 - 02:37
Speaker 6
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  Over the summer, the abuse of short-term lets in my community has continued, including breaches of lease, anti-social behavior, subletting of private rented properties and social housing, and even short-term lets hosting brothels.  We still don't have a way of identifying where these lets are, so enforcement action can be taken, or of implementing London's 90-day cap on lets.  So can I ask the Secretary of State to please do all she can to make it a priority to tackle these serious harms, let us know when the register will be going live, and work with those of us affected and local councils so we can find solutions for our communities. 
02:37 - 03:11
Speaker 2
Can I assure him that we certainly will, and the problem that he points to is a problem across the country.  I recognize it in my own constituency of Wigan, where the council has taken decisive action to clamp down on HMOs, and instead what we've seen are short-term lets springing up to get round the ban, which is causing havoc in local communities.  Can I reassure him that the Prime Minister in his first week in the job asked me to accelerate this work, and that work is now continuing at pace.  In any case, the register will be up and running in full by March. 
03:11 - 03:31
Speaker 4
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  In rural areas like Glastonbury and Somerton, the growing number of short-term lets is displacing local families and workers from the rented sector, hollowing out our rural communities. 

So what steps is the Minister taking to make sure any new regulation protects rural rented stock from being removed from the market? 
03:31 - 04:05
Speaker 2
It's precisely why we're bringing forward these measures to introduce a register of short-term lets.  We believe that local leaders need to have the ability to understand what is happening in their own local areas and to be able to shape and to drive that in order to make sure that they can have the benefits of tourism.  And in some areas, there may be places that would want to have more short-term lets available to support the tourism industry.  But there are other areas, including in her constituency, where there is a real need for local housing for local people, and local leaders should have the power to be able to provide that. 
04:05 - 04:08
Speaker 5
Question two, Mr. Speaker. 

04:08 - 04:28

Stephanie Peacock

Thank you. Well, everyone, regardless of background, should have access to quality sporting opportunities. Sport England targets investment towards deprived communities and places with the greatest need. So, for example, 50% of the awards from their 160 million pounds Movement Fund have gone to areas ranked in the top 25% of greatest need.

04:28 - 04:57

Paul William Forster

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Four of my constituents, Ethan, Harrison, Jude, and Lucas, who train at the Marshall X Academy in Woking, have been selected to represent their country in next month's Martial Arts World Championships. As well as wishing them well, I hope the Minister will take steps to ensure that the cost that they're having to pay, which is over a thousand pounds each to compete, is reduced for young athletes that represent their country in the future.

04:57 - 05:38

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I would of course like to congratulate Ethan, Harrison, Jude, and Lucas on their selection to represent England at the Martial Arts World Championships, and I'm sure the whole House will want to wish them good luck next month. This government is committed to ensuring whatever people's postcode, they can access quality facilities and enjoy the sports they love. Specifically on international representation, the government directly supports Olympic and Paralympic pathways. For other international opportunities, parents should contact the relevant governing bodies or SportsAid for support and advice. Via Sport England, we provide over 60 million pounds of funding to SportsAid, whose Backing the Best program helps talented young athletes overcome financial barriers.

05:38 - 06:23

Becky Gittins

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer, Denby Town Football Club did themselves absolutely proud as hosts of four UEFA Under-19 Championship games, including a Spain v Germany match which saw record attendance of almost 2,000 spectators. Thanks to significant investment into Central Park, including a 300,000 pound Cymru Football Foundation grant funded by this government, not only is the club now match-fit to host international games, but it also has top-class facilities all year round for the whole community. Does the Minister agree with me that the inspiration and opportunities this brings to children from all walks of life is immeasurable? And how is the government ensuring that facilities like this are across the country?

06:23 - 06:44

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the honorable lady who talks about the investment from the government and the Football Foundation into Central Park. She's absolutely right, and we know that the thing that gets young people most likely to get active in sport is to watch live sport. And so that is why we are so committed to investing in our community facilities. But as our new Prime Minister has said, we absolutely want to go further and do more where sport is concerned.

06:44 - 07:23

Caroline Dinenage

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I know that the Minister does care very deeply about increasing sporting participation, so she must be as disappointed as I am that the government's rhetoric just does not match the facts. School sports funding has been cut. Business rates rises means that clubs and facilities are raising their participation fees, some by as much as 85%, making them less accessible for the poorest. Local authorities are shutting their facilities, and the UK ranks near the bottom of EU expenditure on sport and physical activity.

The government says this is important, but how can we believe them when existing facilities are shutting faster than they can invest in new ones?

07:23 - 07:54

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the chair of the select committee and indeed for all the work that her committee does and indeed the report she did and her committee did in the last year on this very issue. On school sport, a billion pounds will be going in over the next few years. Of course, there has been a change. It is revenue and it is capital and it is primary and secondary. But we have to acknowledge under the current system, not enough young people are getting active.

And of course, we're investing 400 million pounds into community facilities. But as our new Prime Minister has said, we absolutely want to go further and do more where sport is concerned.

07:54 - 07:55

John Whitby.

07:55 - 08:08

Speaker 16

Does the Minister recognize the disproportionate impact that the removal of the school sports premium will have on children in small rural schools? And is this a conversation that she's having with the Department for Education?

08:08 - 08:25

Stephanie Peacock

Well, as the honorable gentleman will have just heard in my answer to the chair of the select committee, we make no apologies for changing the system. Not enough young people are getting active. I know how important that is as a former secondary school teacher, and I'd be very happy to speak to the honorable gentleman, and of course, I do regularly speak to the schools minister on this issue.

08:25 - 08:27

Speaker 13

The honorable Minister Louie French.

08:27 - 09:00

Andrew Gareth Bacon

And I refer members to my register of interest. Making sports more accessible should be the ultimate goal of DCMS, and that is why we continue to urge the government to stop raising taxes on sports clubs and to ensure that all sports champion fairness and safety, especially for female sport. The Conservative Party are clear: all UK sports and their governing bodies must follow the law when it comes to biological sex and ensure a level playing field for female athletes to compete. So I ask the government today, will they match the Conservative Party commitment to women's sports and remove public funding from sports bodies who refuse to follow the law?

09:00 - 09:13

Stephanie Peacock

We've always been very clear that sporting national governing bodies will set their own policies for who can participate. It's incredibly important we prioritize fairness, safety, and competition whilst balancing the need for inclusion and ensuring everyone can participate.

09:13 - 09:15

Speaker 12

Amanda Martin.

09:15 - 09:17

Amanda Martin

Question number three, Mr. Speaker.

09:17 - 09:44

Chris Bryant

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. With your permission, I'll answer questions three and six together. Everyone should be able to participate in and enjoy culture wherever they live, anywhere in the country. Through our Arts Everywhere program, we're investing 1.5 billion pounds into arts, culture, and heritage across England. In addition, our UK City and Town of Culture competitions are empowering cities and towns to celebrate their local culture, and we're focusing investment and engagement in our cultural priority places to ensure the benefits of culture can be felt everywhere.

09:44 - 10:18

Amanda Martin

Statistically, Mr. Speaker, Portsmouth closer represents places like Hull, Gateshead, and the Wirral than its neighbors on the south coast. Our region is often overlooked as affluent, but my city has suffered loss of industry, faces serious deprivation and child poverty. But bringing in the good vibes, Mr. Speaker, Portsmouth has so much to offer, from our historic dockyards to seafront creative creativities and festivals. And Portsmouth is bursting with talent. This August, we officially submitted our bid to become UK City of Culture.

Does the Minister agree with me, it's time for the first City of Culture in the south of England, and Portsmouth deserves this investment?

10:18 - 10:53

Chris Bryant

Thank you for that question. Nobody brings good vibes to this chamber more than my honorable friend, Mr. Speaker. Portsmouth, of course, holds an important place in our national story with its strong maritime history, thriving cultural sector, and iconic sites like the historic dockyard. UK City of Culture gives all bidders, win or lose, opportunities to deliver on their ambitions to use culture as a catalyst to make transformative change for the people and place. An independent panel of judges chaired by the wonderful Sir Phil Redmond chairs the competition.

I wish Portsmouth and all bidding places the very best of luck, and I thank my honorable friend who does so much for her constituent for her lobbying.

10:53 - 10:54

Lee Anderson.

10:54 - 11:23

Lee Anderson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You know as well as I do that Stafford has brilliant cultural amenities such as the Gatehouse Theatre, which recently hosted a first-of-its-kind technical summer school, providing a unique opportunity for young people to experience technical theater skills. But this can be much more challenging for those that live in more rural areas, those that live in rural areas of my constituency, who don't necessarily get the same opportunities due to rural transport issues and lack of cultural amenities. So will the Minister please tell me what they are doing to support cultural activities, particularly for young people in our rural areas?

11:23 - 11:57

Chris Bryant

Thank you for the question. Can I commend the Gatehouse Theatre in Stafford for all they do for young people? It's a fantastic initiative. DCMS understands that people in rural areas face additional challenges accessing culture. We know transport challenges make accessing touring productions and after-school activities more difficult.

It was something that we discussed during Staffordshire Day indeed in this place. Arts Council England is committed to responding to those specific needs of rural areas, such as working with artists, improving access for rural audiences, and building partnerships for growth. Access to culture should not be a postcode lottery, either due to transport restrictions or availability, and that's what our Arts Everywhere programme is all about.

11:57 - 12:27

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I thank the Minister very much for that answer? The local National Trust site at Castle Ward in my constituency puts on a host of culture and creative activities throughout the year to allow locals to engage with the arts. Many, many of those things, bus services are needed to ensure that urban and rural can both access the National Trust activity. Will the Minister work in partnership with the National Trust right across this great United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland to ensure that what they're doing, government can work alongside them?

Thank you.

12:27 - 12:53

Chris Bryant

Absolutely, Mr Speaker. Can I commend the honourable gentleman for the work that's done in his constituency and indeed at Castle Ward? Encourage everyone to go and visit, it would be the best thing for me to do as Minister. This came up also at the Select Committee that I attended this week on the connectivity in terms of transport attending cultural events, attending music events, attending historic and heritage places. So we're working very hard to make sure we can resolve those issues.

12:53 - 13:46

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr Speaker. We're fortunate to be served by the fantastic Rex Cinema, which is Dorset's oldest cinema and one of the oldest in the country, and is volunteer-led. It shows two films a day every day and has been refurbished to maintain its Art Deco interior. But its roof is now over 135 years old and will cost £400,000 to repair. The volunteers have funded a new projector, but they just can't raise that sort of money.

Will the Minister consider extending cultural capital grants to community cinemas?

Mr Speaker, I'm very happy to meet with the honourable lady in the interest of time to discuss that in more detail.

13:46 - 14:25

Rebecca Paul

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Celebrating culture as a community can be an incredibly unifying experience, and many people will have enjoyed Notting Hill Carnival this weekend. But 636 people were arrested for crimes, including sexual offences and possession of weapons. Last year, the carnival cost around 16 million just to police, and this year a further 4.6 million of taxpayers' money was provided for additional safety measures. Given those figures, is the Minister and the Secretary of State satisfied that this particular cultural event represents good value for taxpayers?

And what discussions is she having with colleagues about whether the present approach is sustainable?

14:25 - 15:27

Chris Bryant

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I congratulate and welcome the honourable lady to her place? And I look forward to us having many discussions as a ministerial team with her ministerial team in her new place. I'm sure she's going to do a significantly marvellous job. Mr Speaker, it was the 60th anniversary of Notting Hill Carnival, and everyone's concerned about the 636 arrests.

It's a carnival that's been enjoyed by many millions, tens of millions of people over the last 60 years. It's the responsibility of the Mayor of London in terms of the policing of it, and we'll be working very closely with the Mayor of London in terms of what happens in the 60 years, the next 60 years of the Notting Hill Carnival. It's something that we should celebrate and enjoy, but has to be done safely, without discrimination for anyone, and without fear or favour for anyone as well. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I point the honourable gentleman to the recent report in December from the AI Safety Institute, which showed that AI's role in social interaction, online harms, cybersecurity, and the workplace is increasing?

We are taking the risks of AI as seriously as we take the opportunities, working closely with colleagues in the Business Department and the Cabinet Office.

15:27 - 15:32

Lisa Nandy

And we are clear as a government that companies cannot be allowed to mark their own homework.

15:32 - 16:12

Shockat Patel

Mr Speaker, I welcome the response from the Minister. OpenAI, the company OpenAI has just created a program called Astra, which in their own words is the most dangerous program they have ever created because it can hack other programs autonomously. Following other AI programs who have hacked and unleashed themselves from their own security system and hacked other programs simply because they can, because they speak a language only they seem to understand. AI is inevitably our future, but with the government handing over NHS contracts and our public service records to big American AI companies, what is the Minister doing to ensure that we are kept safe in this dangerous world?

16:12 - 16:35

Lisa Nandy

He's right to point to the fact that as frontier AI develops, it poses new challenges and new risks, not just in the area of hacking, but also in creating confusion about legal liability, about safeguarding, and who is responsible. There is a clear role for government in this and we are working hard to make sure that we meet those expectations.

16:35 - 17:03

Chinyelu Susan Onwurah

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My committee's report, Science Diplomacy, Sovereignty Strategy and the Global Race, highlighted the risk of the UK being cut off from frontier AI models at the whim of other countries, and one country in particular comes to mind. What assessment has she made of the impact on the UK's society and economy if we were unable to access these models?

17:03 - 17:37

Lisa Nandy

Well, she's right to point to the UK's need for sovereign capability in AI, and I want to pay tribute to the work of my honourable friend the Member for Leicester West, whose work I've inherited in this area. Can I thank her also for the contribution of her committee to this over a long period of time. We are taking the need to deal with that exposure of the UK very seriously, and I'd be very happy to meet with her to discuss that further.

17:37 - 18:11

Layla Moran

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. Frontier AI is supercharging misinformation online, but we still can't get to grips with harms much closer to home. We have campaigners in the gallery today, including Talisa Contostavlos, target of a fabricated story from an undercover tabloid sting and proof of the damage an unregulated press can do. Examples like this are why the Lib Dems want the full implementation of Leveson 1 and the commissioning of Leveson 2. Will the Secretary of State meet with me and Talisa to discuss finally getting proper regulation of the press?

18:11 - 19:02

Lisa Nandy

I would be delighted to offer her that meeting, and can I also take the opportunity to pay tribute to Talisa, who I've admired for many years for the way in which she's taken such a dreadful experience and used it to help others. Could I also, Mr Speaker, just take this moment to acknowledge the absolutely tragic death of Professor Jason Arday that has happened since this House last met. There is an inquest ongoing at the moment and an ongoing investigation by Cambridge University, and while this government will not wish to undermine in any sense those ongoing inquiries, I do want to reassure the House and the many families who've been affected by the sort of practices that she references over many years that we are not neutral as a government when it comes to protecting our citizens.

19:02 - 19:17

Stephanie Peacock

Thank you. I've had discussions across government with ministerial colleagues, I've spoken to mayors and a range of tourism representatives. This government is committed to giving powers to local areas to enact an overnight levy, and we will work closely with MHCLG and HM Treasury on developing this policy.

19:17 - 19:43

Andrew Gwynne

Mr Speaker, rural and coastal communities are particularly reliant on seasonal tourism. If you look at my register of interests, you'll see that I used to run one of those businesses.

Does the government not understand that it's tough enough already out there without the government thinking up a new tax on holidays? So instead of ploughing on regardless, will the government commit to publishing an independent assessment on the impact on businesses before any new tax is introduced?

19:43 - 20:07

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful for the honourable gentleman. I was actually in Blackpool myself last week discussing this issue with representatives. I visited his own constituency a few years ago, so I know how important tourism is to coastal communities up and down the country. Introducing a levy will be up to local areas, and of course it will make sense for those areas to invest funds generated in improving local tourism offer, as many have already committed to doing so.

20:07 - 20:25

Jade Jessica Toale

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Hotels in my Bournemouth West constituency are largely in favour of an overnight visitors levy, but on the proviso that the money is ring-fenced for tourism purposes, not lost to the black hole of local authority or strategic authority finances. So what reassurances can the minister give hotels in my constituency?

20:25 - 20:45

Stephanie Peacock

So as I just outlined, it will of course make sense for those funds to be reinvested into local tourism, but that will be a decision for local areas. That is why we're working closely with the Treasury and MHCLG so that local areas can be empowered to make the decisions that are right for their areas.

20:45 - 21:29

Nigel Huddleston

Mr. Speaker, may I welcome the Shadow Secretary and new Shadow Minister to their place? And can I take the opportunity to thank the Secretary of State and her team for their constructive engagement with me over the last year? However, there's always a however with me. On Tuesday, the new Prime Minister committed the government to bringing in a new holiday tax. On Wednesday, he told the House that he was helping businesses by cutting taxes, yet we all know business rates and national insurance are increasing, destroying over a hundred thousand jobs in tourism and hospitality alone.

In what crazy Labour universe is it possible to claim that you are cutting taxes when you're actually increasing them and bringing in entirely new taxes?

21:29 - 22:00

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman, and can I take this opportunity to pay tribute to him for all of his work as the Shadow Secretary of State and indeed before that as the minister. It's been a pleasure to work with him and I look forward to continuing to do so. Of course, there is more than one tax. We are cutting taxes, but we are also introducing an overnight levy. And as I have outlined, we're working across government and with tourist sector and with mayors to make sure we get that right for local areas.

And it of course makes sense for that money to be reinvested into the tourism sector, but that will be up to local areas to decide.

22:00 - 22:22

Jeff Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And Mr. Speaker, I can, I think rural and coastal communities can be encouraged by the success of the city visitor charge in Manchester, where we've raised ten million pounds to invest in advertising tourism and cleaning the city. And can the minister join me in rejecting the scaremongering about this and just remind people this is a purely permissive measure, that it's up to local areas to do if they want?

22:22 - 22:44

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman, who is an excellent champion for his city of Manchester. I think he shares a really important example, and it is right to caution against scaremongering. It's absolutely right that local authorities and local areas rather have the powers in which to make their decisions themselves.

22:44 - 23:38

Lisa Nandy

I'll get up. Can I thank the honourable member for his long-standing work on this? He will know... Let me start again. Can I thank the honourable member for his intense work on this issue?

And can I say to him that the Minister for Sport will be delighted to meet him? However, he will know that lidos are a personal passion for me, and reversing the neglect of these much-loved community assets is something that this government intends to make a priority. We will be in a position to say more about this shortly, but in the meantime, can I pay tribute to him, to the member for Peterborough and to the member for Bournemouth West for the work that they've done to campaign to make sure that lidos have their proper place in British public life.

23:38 - 24:11

Joseph Simon Opher

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And in Stroud, I celebrated the reopening of our lido by making a splash, jumping in fully clothed next to a woman dressed as a lobster. And I just thank the Save Our Lido and the Friends of Stroud Lido and the whole community for working to reopen the lido. But as she knows, most of our lidos were built in the 1930s, they're in financial difficulties. So I'd be really looking forward to meeting the minister and maybe establishing a lido fund to support nationally our lidos.

24:11 - 24:29

Lisa Nandy

Well, I think he makes a very compelling case. And while I don't wish to preempt any future imminent announcement, I will just say to him that we really recognize as a government the need to support communities with the funding pressures that lidos face, including energy costs. And we will have more to say about this shortly.

24:29 - 24:31

Speaker 24

Dr. Danny Chambers.

24:31 - 25:02

Danny Chambers

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There's a very passionate group of people in Winchester who've long campaigned for a lido to be built in the leisure center that has been, well, the old leisure center, as a new one has been built. And they're very excited that one of the proposals for the old leisure center is a lido. Would the minister mind explaining what support is available for facilities like this that get people outside exercising and being part of the community, which is good for physical and mental health?

25:02 - 25:44

Lisa Nandy

Well, he'll have heard the Minister for Sport talk about the 400 million pounds that we're putting into grassroots sports facilities. And he'll also have heard my answer to my honorable friend about a forthcoming announcement that we're planning to make specifically around lidos. But can I just congratulate his community on defending and supporting and championing not just leisure facilities, but lidos in particular. Most of the lidos that exist in this country exist because of people like his constituents who care for them and have supported them to stay open for many years. And I would be very happy to come and visit and to meet them at some point, only on the condition, though, that there is a woman dressed as a lobster as part of the event.

25:44 - 25:45

Joe Robertson.

25:45 - 25:47

Joe Robertson

Number eight, Mr. Speaker.

25:47 - 26:11

Stephanie Peacock

Tourism drives economic growth and jobs across the country, including in the Isle of Wight. Over the summer months, the Great British Summer Savings schemes provided a temporary VAT cut for eligible businesses to encourage visits to tourism attractions during the school holidays. And at the same time, Visit Britain's Starring Great Britain campaign is promoting film and TV locations to inspire global audiences to explore a wide range of regions across Great Britain.

26:11 - 26:41

Joe Robertson

Mr. Speaker, growth in tourism requires an increase in visitor numbers so that more money is spent on the high street, not a new tax. Oxford Economics says the cost of the overnight visitor levy will be around 1.8 billion in reduced spending and a decrease in tax receipts, not an increase. Now, can the minister confirm that the visitor economy growth strategy will consider the harm caused by the new tourism tax, and when will it be published?

26:41 - 27:07

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman. I know he's a huge champion for his constituency and indeed on this subject. He will have, we are committed to increasing visitor numbers, and he'll have heard my answer to the previous question on the overnight levy, where there's a strong case for that any money raised to be reinvested into tourism. As I say, I was in Blackpool last week speaking to tourism industry leaders and businesses, and far from the doom and gloom my honorable friend alludes to, what I witnessed last week was a great deal of hope, hard work, and dynamism.

27:07 - 27:38

Rachel Blake

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We've had a good debate about the overnight stay levy and short lets. On Warwick Way in my constituency, I've seen real harm to communities because of unregulated short lets. Does the minister agree with me that for the tourism industry to be a real success, we cannot allow hotels to be undermined by short lets? And getting the registration scheme in place and getting the Treasury to investigate where there might be breaches of HMRC rules is an important step forward in making sure that short lets aren't undermining hotels.

27:36 - 27:56

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the honorable lady. She has been a really strong champion on this issue. It was a delight to visit her constituency to talk and to see this issue and see the problem that it creates firsthand earlier this year. As the Secretary of State has outlined, this government is absolutely committed to that register, and we know the difference it will make to communities like hers, but also communities up and down the country.

27:56 - 28:01

Speaker 23

James Wild, shadow minister.

28:01 - 28:32

James Wild

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The visitor economy is worth 147 billion pounds, supporting millions of jobs, but this government has hammered the sector with higher taxes and now plans a holiday tax. Perhaps there is some hope, though, as the Prime Minister told the House on Monday he wants to go further than business rate relief for pubs and music venues. So will the minister urge him to take up Conservative policy and scrap business rates for them and restaurants, cafes, hotels, and leisure attractions, and actually support this vital sector?

28:32 - 29:03

Stephanie Peacock

Well, can I welcome the honorable gentleman to his place, and I look forward to working with him in the coming months. He will have heard that the review of business rates for pubs and hotels announced just a few weeks ago by the Chancellor has, of course, been welcomed by a number of people, including from the CEO of UK Hospitality, which has said it is a positive move. And, of course, under this government, we have seen the biggest investment into the tourism sector with the Universal Studios Bedford investment of 6.3 billion pounds. It was a pleasure to be there a few weeks ago.

29:03 - 29:06

Adam Jogee

Question nine, Mr. Speaker.

29:06 - 29:39

Feryal Clark

Minister, and welcome. Thank you. As set out in the government's digital inclusion plan, everyone in every community should be able to benefit from technology. And that's why we launched the 11.9 million digital inclusion innovation fund, backing local projects across the country to help people get online. And I'm glad that Citizens Advice Staffordshire was one of the funded projects, supporting people with digital skills and resilience, including online banking and job searching.

29:39 - 30:01

Adam Jogee

Mr. Speaker, and I welcome the minister to her new position. Residents across Newcastle-under-Lyme, particularly in Betley, Balterley, and Wrinehill, have been digitally left behind with poor broadband connectivity for far too long. I've raised this before, but can I ask the new minister to do what she can to ensure that my constituents working and living in rural communities can get online, and will she come along to hear their experiences herself?

30:01 - 30:07

Speaker 31

Yes, absolutely. I would love to come along.

30:07 - 30:09

Speaker 28

And we now go to topicals, Adam Thompson.

30:09 - 30:13

Adam Thompson

Number one, Mr. Speaker.

30:13 - 31:46

Lisa Nandy

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to start by recognizing the extraordinary British sportsmen and women who lit up the world this summer. And I'd also like to put on record what an honor it is to return to this place in with a newly created Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport. I'd like to pay tribute to my right honorable friend, the member for Leicester West, for the extraordinary work she did in a very short period of time, opening up opportunities to young people to benefit from the technology developments of the future and taking decisive action on social media. I'd also like to thank the honorable member for Droitwich and Evesham for the very constructive way that he has both challenged and supported us as a front bench since the general election, always acting in the interests of the sectors that we both care passionately about.

And can I welcome the honorable member to Reigate to her place. I'm very much looking forward to working with her. Finally, Mr. Speaker, I wish to pay tribute to the Rugby League legend that is Sir Billy Boston and to his incredible wife, Lady Joan, who sadly passed away a few weeks before Sir Billy. Billy was a sporting giant. His talent, his determination, and his legacy will inspire generations for years to come.

And it was a privilege, Mr. Speaker, to work with you following your campaign over many years to right a historic wrong and to ensure that he became the first ever knight of Rugby League. Rest in peace, Sir Billy Boston.

31:45 - 32:11

Adam Thompson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Take-Two Interactive CEO Strauss Zelnick recently said that their business is now well over 90% digitally distributed. And Take-Two have confirmed that Grand Theft Auto VI's physical box won't contain a physical disc, but will instead contain a download code. Killing physical media prevents consumers trading in or sharing their games and it erodes the concept of true ownership of the product. What's the Secretary of State doing then to support physical ownership of video games as well as music and film?

32:11 - 32:47

Lisa Nandy

So, the Minister has just reminded me that he and I are so old that we started out loading cassette tapes when we were playing video games as kids. I am aware that people feel very strongly about this issue. He will know that decisions around media formats are ultimately for companies, but we believe as a government that companies should always be clear with customers about what they're paying for. And that is why we've commissioned the Chartered Trading Standards Institute to develop guidance that will clarify people's ownership rights when they purchase digital games, music and films.

32:47 - 32:49

Speaker 46

Shadow Secretary of State, Rebecca Long-Bailey.

32:49 - 33:45

Rebecca Paul

Thank you, Mr Speaker. May I start by thanking the Secretary of State for her warm words and I'm looking forward to working constructively with her and her team going forwards. May I begin by paying tribute to PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough, who were killed in a horrific head-on collision on the A66 last month. The car that collided with them was travelling in the wrong direction. My thoughts are with their family and friends at this terrible, terrible time.

Their deaths have renewed concern about videos on TikTok and other platforms which glorify dangerous driving and police chases. The behaviour these videos encourage can have fatal consequences. We know the government has recently raised this with social media companies, yet the content remains up. What more will the Minister and Secretary of State do to ensure TikTok and other platforms crack down on this before more lives are lost?

33:45 - 34:33

Lisa Nandy

She's absolutely right, first of all, to pay tribute to those incredible police officers who lost their lives and can I associate myself with her remarks and put on record my sadness and love and sympathy to their families and loved ones. Can I also say to her that I agree with her that there is more that must be done to tackle what is becoming an epidemic in young people in particular using social media to encourage dangerous behaviour. I have a meeting with TikTok set up in the coming days. We've obviously been in close discussion with them and with other social media companies since this tragic, appalling incident. But there is more that we intend to do as a government and I'd be very happy to meet with her to discuss that further.

34:33 - 34:34

Callum Anderson.

34:34 - 35:03

Callum Anderson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. 60 years ago, or nearly 60 years ago, a Labour government designated Milton Keynes a new town and today we're one of the fastest growing cities of the United Kingdom and millions are also drawn to attractions such as Bletchley Park, the Milton Keynes Gallery and our international festival. I can't think of a better candidate to be the UK City of Culture. Does the Minister agree with me that culture and economic growth go hand in hand and might she meet me and my Milton Keynes colleagues to discuss the merits of our bid?

35:03 - 35:18

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman. He's a great champion for his city. It was a pleasure to do a sporting visit to his constituency earlier this year. We've got a really strong shortlist for the City of Culture and indeed the Town of Culture and I look forward to visiting the final shortlist in the near future.

35:18 - 35:19

Olly Glover.

35:19 - 35:44

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Mr Speaker. In my Oxfordshire constituency, Challow and Childrey Cricket Club's partnership with local state school King Alfred's Academy is providing cricket opportunities to students who may not otherwise have access.

However, affordability and perceptions of cricket mean that a participation gap remains between state-funded schools playing and independent schools. So what further steps can the government take to improve opportunities to participate in sports?

35:44 - 36:02

Stephanie Peacock

Well, I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman. Cricket is incredibly popular, I know in my own constituency how important it is. I did a visit to Worksop to see the ECB's schools program in action. I think programs like that are incredibly important for getting people, and in particular young people, involved and active in sport.

36:02 - 36:37

Danny Beales

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer, 1.5 million people attended London Pride, a celebration of love, freedom, and diversity. Yet at the same time, discussions on GB News compared Pride and LGBT people to bestiality and even pedophilia. There's now been 12,000 complaints to Ofcom about this. Does the minister agree with me these sorts of comments have no place on an apparent news channel, and will she assure me and those who have complained that Ofcom will be effective in challenging hate speech on television?

36:37 - 37:12

Chris Bryant

Mr. Speaker, can I thank my honorable friend for bringing this incredibly serious question to DCMS questions this morning. There is no place for homophobia or prejudice in our society. The media has a duty to uphold the highest standards, not polarize or divide. I understand Ofcom is investigating whether the program has breached broadcasting code standards, and I expect it to do so without fear or favor. Through our media green paper, we are considering how to ensure Ofcom has the right powers to protect audiences and regulate TV services in the future.

We have a proud free media and free press in this country, but that doesn't come without responsibilities, and GB News should be thoroughly ashamed of themselves.

37:12 - 37:29

Paul William Forster

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As we saw in the World Cup, football is fundamental to our national identity. Football fans are having to pay almost 700 pounds to follow their club in this season's Premier League. So does the Secretary of State agree with me that we need to have more, not less, free-to-air sport?

37:29 - 38:09

Lisa Nandy

Can I thank him for that? And he'll know from previous discussions that we've had in this place that there is a balance to be struck between making sure that we get the right level of investment into sport and making sure that those sports are opened up to the widest possible audience. And that's a conversation that we continue to have. Can I also say to him that there is another element to this, which is about the cost of tickets and the action that this government is taking on secondary ticket touts, which I know that his party strongly supports. Later today, we'll have the pleasure to introduce the Major Sporting Events Bill to this place.

And part of the measures that we're taking on that is to take action to make sure that ticket prices remain affordable and those practices are stamped out when it comes to sporting events.

38:09 - 38:38

Clive Efford

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Football is not the private property of Gianni Infantino or a handful of rich and powerful men. So it belongs to the billions of people who watch it, who play it, and enjoy it. Given that UEFA are proposing to make a criminal complaint about the conduct of FIFA's leadership, will the minister join me and others in calling for a genuinely independent investigation into FIFA's decision to try and sell off the World Cup?

38:38 - 39:06

Lisa Nandy

And well, can I thank him for that? I absolutely 100% agree with him that football belongs to its fans. And for far too long, fans have been treated as at best an afterthought and at worst a nuisance when it comes to the future of their own clubs, their own tournaments, and their own game. We are as a government appalled by what happened recently around the World Cup, and the Prime Minister has been absolutely crystal clear that it's time for a change of leadership at FIFA.

39:06 - 39:39

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. An ever-growing list of charities have faced serious allegations of peddling extremism and even funding terrorism. Most of these continue to operate despite lengthy Charity Commission investigations, such as the Iranian regime-linked Islamic Centre of England, which is reportedly sponsoring visas for people to enter the UK. Now, it's painfully clear that the Charity Commission lacks sufficient powers to shut down these offending charities, and yet the government has wasted six months since first acknowledging this clear and immediate threat. So will the Secretary of State confirm when these powers will be granted?

39:39 - 40:06

Feryal Clark

The Charity Commission takes very seriously concerns about the alleged misuse of charities in the UK to promote the interests of foreign states. The government's Social Cohesion Action Plan published in March set out our plans to strengthen the Charity Commission's powers to tackle extremist abuse of charities. We are working with the Charity Commission to develop the necessary legislation and we take this very, very seriously.

40:06 - 41:06

Speaker 79

That completes questions. Just news for the House, when we return after the conference recess, this will be an hour. Let the front bench change over.

41:06 - 41:10

Speaker 52

Right. Who's answering this one? Marsha de Cordova.

41:10 - 41:42

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Good morning and thank you. So the Church condemns the persecution we have seen and stands in solidarity with Palestinian Christian communities across the Holy Land as they continue to face profound hardship. And the Church of England remains committed to supporting our Anglican partners and advocating for human rights and calling for the upholding of international humanitarian law and a just and lasting peace for the Palestinians.

41:42 - 42:15

Speaker 76

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Taybeh, an ancient Palestinian Christian village in the West Bank, is facing record levels of escalating Israeli settler attacks. Father Bashar Fawadleh has warned that residents feel vulnerable and insufficiently protected. Will my honourable friend tell the House what engagement the Church has had with church leaders in Taybeh and what further steps can the Church take to support this community and help ensure its continued presence and security in the Holy Land?

42:15 - 43:16

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And look, can I firstly start by thanking my honourable friend for her continued and steadfast support for the Palestinians. Since the start of this year, the UN has reported that 76 Palestinians have been killed by settler violence and among them 18 children. And as she has rightly mentioned, the village of Taybeh continues to experience near daily raids on their homes by settlers and the village has almost entirely been circulated by roadblocks and fences. Now during her recent visit to the Diocese of Jerusalem, the Archbishop of Canterbury met with Christian leaders where she heard firsthand of the suffering being experienced by Palestinian Christians, including the persistent violence, the destruction of property, the seizure of land and restrictions on movement.

Mr. Speaker, it is time that this settler terrorism that we are witnessing must come to an end.

43:16 - 43:38

Tessa Munt

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I encourage the Church Commissioners to support the Church in facilitating community events? Wells Cathedral and Wells Bishop's Palace are at the centre of an amazing programme of year-round festivals, fairs and markets. But the Church Commissioners have suddenly served a stop notice on the Phelps family at Palace Farm in Wells, which for decades have offered...

43:38 - 43:52

Lindsay Hoyle

Sorry, can I just say to the honourable member, but you're going to have to sit down, sorry. But this is about Palestine.

It's not relevant to the question. Yeah, don't worry. Let's move on, Jen Craft.

43:52 - 43:54

Jennifer Craft

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, number two, please.

43:54 - 43:55

Nick Smith.

43:55 - 44:30

Nick Smith

Mr. Speaker, the House of Commons administration provides a variety of training for members and their staff to help them respond to domestic and sexual abuse casework, which includes a day-long training course on dealing with cases of domestic abuse, HR sessions on domestic abuse awareness, and a safeguarding e-learning module. The training courses equip participants with the knowledge and confidence to recognize signs, respond accordingly, and also provide access to support resources.

44:30 - 45:17

Jennifer Craft

Jen Craft.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As members of Parliament, we regularly support vulnerable women and girls who have experienced sexual abuse, violence, rape, stalking, coercive behavior, and other forms of violence. These can be some of the most complex and sensitive cases, requiring knowledge of legal frameworks, safeguarding, and trauma to safely support individuals in traumatized circumstances. I'm extremely grateful to be able to lean on the expert guidance of SERICC, our fantastic local rape and sexual abuse service in Essex, but not all offices are as fortunate. I would therefore like to understand what guidance the House of Commons provides to honorable members specifically on responding to rape and sexual abuse casework and whether there is scope to provide more specialist and trauma-informed training.

45:17 - 45:18

Nick Smith.

45:18 - 45:44

Nick Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the honorable member for this important question? It's great that she's got good local services on this important topic. I've already outlined the training and guidance we have on offer at this current time. The Commission though is keen to ensure members are well supported in this area and is open to suggestions to develop the training offer.

I will ask officials to get in touch with my honorable friend.

45:44 - 45:47

Josh Newbury

Josh Newbury, number three, please, Mr. Speaker.

45:47 - 45:48

Marsha de Cordova.

45:48 - 46:12

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. No parish is required to make payments to the national church institutions. Parish share or the common fund is a financial contribution that a parish makes to the diocese that helps fund clergy stipends, pensions, housing, including mutual support for ministries that are in less affluent areas.

46:12 - 46:46

Josh Newbury

Mr. Speaker, whether it's holding coffee mornings to bring people together, stepping in to provide activity for young people where council services have disappeared, or providing affordable spaces for community groups, our churches are part of the fabric of Cannock Chase. But what they do carries a cost. One parish in my constituency saw its parish share reduced from thirty-five thousand to fifteen thousand, yet even that lower figure required it to draw on reserves which are now exhausted. What assessment have the Church Commissioners made of how many parishes are in a similar situation and what support might be available to those churches once their reserves have run out?

46:46 - 47:25

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend is absolutely right to point out the importance of churches in providing community support and care, which are essential in many local areas. On his specific case in his parish he has raised, I would be happy to put him in touch with the Diocese of Lichfield so that he can actually discuss these concerns more broadly with them. On a more broadly note, Mr. Speaker, the Church Commissioners are supporting parishes in the lowest income communities with over one hundred and thirty-three million pounds of investment, representing a forty-six percent increase on the previous funding window.

47:25 - 47:26

Andrew Pakes.

47:26 - 47:36

Lindsay Hoyle

Number four, Mr. Speaker. Can I just remind members they're meant to stand up, we just do it, you know, we're back from school, you know, this is first day of term, let's get some memory power.

47:36 - 47:40

Speaker 60

Marsha de Cordova.

47:40 - 48:18

Marsha Cordova

I have to stand up, Mr. Speaker. Right, the Church remains deeply concerned about the ongoing persecution on the ground... on the ground... sorry, on the grounds of belief, faith and belief worldwide, including recent cases in Sudan, Afghanistan, Palestine, India and many, many others. And all these countries have featured high on the most recent Open Doors World Watch List. And alongside the UN Secretary General, the Church believes that whenever one minority group is persecuted, no one is safe.

48:18 - 48:19

Andrew Selous.

48:19 - 49:04

Andrew Elliot Pakes

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I stand rightly chastised. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One of the most important aspects of being a Christian to me is being part of a global fellowship. And the Church of England stands as a light on the hill for our global community.

I have been contacted on numerous occasions by churches and fellow Christians in my community who are deeply worried about the persecution of fellow Christians in Nigeria, on top of the persecution we are seeing increasingly around the world of Christians in different countries. Could my honourable friend outline to me what more the Church of England can do with its special role in our global fellowship in terms of speaking out and providing solidarity to Christians in Nigeria and other parts of the world?

49:04 - 50:05

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for his question. As he mentions, in parts of Nigeria, the Christian communities continue to face considerable persecution. And this has been happening for many decades, particularly from the Fulani militia and Boko Haram. Now, senior members of the Church have frequently visited and written to the Nigerian government ahead of elections, urging them not to exploit ethnic or religious divisions, financial violence or pursue electoral success at the nation's expense. And the wider Anglican Communion and its agencies do continue to offer support, financial aid and education in that space.

And I should say also that the bishops in the other place raise cases and the experience of Nigerian Christians with the UK government. And I would also invite my honourable friend to also raise these cases with the government as well.

50:05 - 50:06

Greg Smith.

50:06 - 50:07

Question five, please, sir.

50:07 - 50:29

Marsha Cordova

Marsha de Cordova. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now, across the country, churches provide holiday clubs, activities and safe spaces for children and families, often in partnership with organisations such as Lighthouse. Now, these groups help young people develop skills and confidence to become responsible, active participants in their local communities.

50:29 - 51:13

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Over the summer, I was delighted to visit Princes Risborough Lighthouse for both their opening and closing ceremonies. They welcomed 450 local children over the course of a week for fun activities, a lot of chaos. I may have been gunged in the closing ceremony, but all underpinned by Christian teaching. Similar schemes ran in Great Missenden and Haddenham too.

So will the honourable lady join me in thanking Elena Kibble and her massive team of volunteers, trustees and church leaders for putting on such an incredible programme? But more fundamentally, ask what the Church centrally is doing to underpin and support community-led, church-led programmes like this?

51:13 - 52:03

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This sounds like it was a wonderful visit, despite the honourable member being gunged, I have to say.

But I would much like to join him in thanking Lighthouse in Princes Risborough and in Great Missenden and Haddenham in his constituency for their incredible work. And huge thanks to Elena Kibble and the team of volunteers, whom we know without volunteers none of these schemes are actually going to be possible to be delivered. So huge, huge thank you to them. I'll also point out that since 2019 the Diocese of Oxford has given over 300 financial grants totaling 5.9 million pounds to its parishes to host youth groups and Lighthouse holiday clubs. And I know the church is committed to and will continue to support community projects such as these in areas across the country.

52:03 - 52:04

Jim Shannon.

52:04 - 52:13

Jim Shannon

Always standing, Mr. Speaker. Question number six.

52:13 - 52:46

Marsha Cordova

Shall I stay standing, Mr. Speaker? No, in all seriousness, family hubs are a crucial one-stop shop for families to access vital support in one place. And the Church of England supports this with other denominations through the Church Works Commission, which has produced helpful guidance and resources for churches and local authorities. Now this includes a toolkit that sets out how churches can be involved through signposting, referrals, use of buildings, and by running specific services.

52:46 - 53:24

Jim Shannon

Jim Shannon. Thank you very much. Can I thank the Church Commissioner very much for her answer? St. Mark's Church, Newtownards, in Strangford, held a brilliant summer scheme this year, offering games, songs, and crafts for children from the local community. The church has the facilities and capacity to provide more activities and support for families throughout the year.

However, with additional funding it could do much more. So given the need for central government funding, what steps can the Church Commissioner and government take to ensure that community organizations such as St. Mark's have access to the funding they want and need to support local families and communities all the year round? Thank you so much.

53:24 - 54:27

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I just say how delighted I was to see my honorable friend on the order paper this time, Mr. Speaker? He didn't have to bob. But I'd also like to join him in congratulating the valuable role churches play in supporting young people and thank him for raising the excellent work of churches in Newtownards. Now following the exchange with the honorable member for Runcorn, I wrote to the local government minister and the children's minister to discuss how faith-based organizations can work more closely with local authorities to expand youth provision.

Supporting young people is part of the Church of England's growing younger priority, backed by a 1 billion pounds investment over the next nine years. And I would be happy to put my honorable friend in touch with the team and officials at Church House for further information on this. And I also just would want to encourage all local authorities to see the great work that partnering with the churches can deliver in supporting and providing opportunities for young people.

54:27 - 54:28

Dr. Marie Tidball.

54:28 - 55:31

Speaker 82

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and it's good to see you after recess. Over the summer I attended a packed meeting about saving St. John's Church in Dodworth in my constituency, a grade two listed building that's been at the heart of my community for over 180 years and wants to serve that community going forward in providing more services to children and young people and older adults too to prevent loneliness. However, it is currently temporarily closed and under threat of permanent closure due to urgent structural building work needed. Our community wants to save it and I'm working with them to reopen it, secure its long-term future to serve our community and our community groups, including fundraising 250,000 pounds and finding ways to meet the building's ongoing costs. Can my honorable friend advise me on how we can access funding and support from the Church of England and any other relevant funding pots for St. John's in my constituency to ensure this vital community space has a bright future?

55:31 - 56:38

Marsha Cordova

Thank you Mr Speaker, and can I just thank my honorable friend for her question and also congratulate her on being a steadfast voice for her constituents and also for St John's Church, which clearly provides great support services for children and young people as well as adults in her constituency. Churches, Mr Speaker, are the cornerstones of our communities, and I'd be very happy to write to my honorable friend with more details about funding opportunities and ways that they can seek to raise some funds locally to help save the church potentially. Is that okay? Wonderful. Thank you, Mr Speaker, question number seven.

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The unacceptable use of Christianity to exclude or intimidate others is deeply offensive and frankly deeply concerning. The Church has established a working group to support parishes with theological, practical and pastoral resources along with best practice advice. Recent work includes guidance on Fly the Flags and webinars on theology, on the theology of patriotism.

56:38 - 57:07

Speaker 90

Thank you Mr Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for that answer. Does she share my concern though at the promotion of Christian nationalist ideology in supporting the activities of the far right in this country and their poisonous propaganda of hate and division? Will she urge the Church of England to do all the Church can to counter Christian nationalism and show that the true message of Christianity is love, compassion and respect for all?

57:07 - 58:03

Marsha Cordova

Thank you Mr Speaker, and my honorable friend is spot on and he really does raise important issues, issues, and I completely share his concerns over the misuse of Christian ideology. Now the Church are discussing their shared experiences of Christian nationalism with partners and churches in nations of the UK, and this also includes the Church in Scotland. We all know Mr Speaker, throughout the Bible we are called to learn to do right, seek justice, defend the oppressed, take up the cause of the fatherless and plead the case of the, of the widow. But also Mr Speaker, when we, when we think of the Bible and we reflect, the greatest commandment of them all is to love the Lord our God with all our hearts, but also to love our neighbor as ourself. These people are neither patriots nor Christians, they display little to no understanding of faith and that they profess to support.

58:03 - 58:06

Speaker 66

Number eight please.

58:06 - 58:35

Jeremy Paul Wright

Thank you Mr Speaker. The Electoral Commission has made no formal assessment of this. It would be a matter for Parliament to introduce such legal protections. It is prescribed in law that poll cards and ballot papers must be provided in English or Welsh, but there are no other prescribed language requirements relating to election materials. The Commission translates voter materials including voter registration forms into a range of languages informed by census data and community insights on voter needs.

58:35 - 59:06

Perran Moon

Mr Speaker, since January this year, Kernewek, the Cornish language, has enjoyed Part III protection under the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages alongside Welsh and Scottish Gaelic. In light of that recognition, can I ask the right honorable gentleman what steps the Electoral Commission could take to review its policies and guidance to ensure that Cornish speakers are not treated less favorably in elections than speakers of other protected minority languages?

59:06 - 59:22

Jeremy Paul Wright

I'm afraid to the honorable gentleman I apologize to him I can't respond to him in Cornish, but I will say to him that as he may, I won't try, but as, as he may know, the Electoral Commission is in discussion with his local authority at the moment and I know it would welcome any further representation.

59:22 - 59:37

Lindsay Hoyle

Order. Mr. Perkins, you've just walked right in front of the vision between the member who's asking the question. Apologies. Yeah, but there's something going wrong with the house. Can we please get back to remembering the courtesies of other members when they're asking questions?

Sir Jeremy.

59:37 - 59:52

Jeremy Paul Wright

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And so I know the commission will welcome any further representations he wants to make. And as I say, the commission keeps the languages it chooses to translate materials into under review.

59:52 - 59:54

Preet Gill

Question nine, Mr. Speaker.

59:54 - 59:55

Marsha de Cordova.

59:55 - 01:00:42

Lindsay Hoyle

Mr. Speaker, the church has a long history of working across faiths to ensure community cohesion. Most dioceses has an interfaith advisor who advises clergy... Order. I think I've been instructed on who sits where. That was directly in the sight of Preet Gill because you came past the door.

It blocks my vision when you walk in front. I don't like being challenged on something when I'm absolutely am correct. Marsha de Cordova. I'll take it from the top then, Mr. Speaker. The church has a long history of working across faiths to ensure community cohesion.

Most dioceses have an interfaith advisor who advise clergy and congregations in their interfaith engagement, promoting community cohesion. And this work is also supported through the national presence and engagement program.

01:00:42 - 01:01:13

Sonia Kumar

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One of the church's greatest strengths is the ability to bring communities together. And at the time of heightened community tensions, opportunities to bring all faith leaders together is ever more important. Over the summer, I've worked closely with local faith leaders in my constituency to build resilience and how we manage an attack on one is an attack on all. Will my honorable friend set out how the church can strengthen dialogue, support cohesion, and help communities resist division?

01:01:13 - 01:01:57

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I first just congratulate my honorable friend for the work she's doing in her own constituency and bringing our communities together. She rightly points out that the church is has a key role in in in drawing our communities together. And that is a case of wanting to protect those, but also for peace and social justice. And the church supports the work of the Church Urban Fund and Near Neighbors, whose central aim is to promote interfaith understanding and stronger community cohesion.

As I mentioned in my previous answer, the church has established a working group that's with the bishops to promote community cohesion in response to some of the deep political polarization. And I hope to provide an update on that work in due course.

01:01:57 - 01:02:00

Speaker 75

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question number ten, please, Mr. Speaker.

01:02:00 - 01:02:01

Marsha de Cordova.

01:02:01 - 01:02:12

Marsha Cordova

Yes, Mr. Speaker. The Church Commissioners intend to proceed with Project Spire as we continue to regard the historic links to African chattel slavery with profound regret.

01:02:12 - 01:02:40

Blake Stephenson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the member for that response? Around the country, particularly in Mid Bedfordshire, parish churches, sorry, are struggling to find the funds to save their historic buildings. Do the Church Commissioners not believe that the time, money, and energy spent examining and absolving the church's historic transgressions could have been better spent bringing hope and belonging to future generations and saving our historic churches?

01:02:40 - 01:03:45

Marsha Cordova

Mr. Speaker, I want to take this opportunity to make clear that Project Spire is being funded out of the commissioners' own income. None of the money given in parish collections goes towards funding this project. It is also worth pointing out that over the next three years, the commissioners are distributing one point six billion pounds to provide record levels of support for church ministry and mission across England. It is my sincere hope that Project Spire delivers exactly what the member for Mid Bedfordshire points to, a sense of belonging for future generations in the church. And finally, Mr. Speaker, I also want to highlight the words shared by the Archbishop of Canterbury in her historic visit to the Cape Coast Castle in Ghana, which I too have also visited myself.

And she says, Mr. Speaker, I pray not only in lament for the church's involvement in the slave trade, but also for hope, hope that the God of healing can bring justice and reconciliation to all who are still impacted by its legacy.

01:03:46 - 01:03:51

Liz Twist

Question 11, Mr. Speaker.

01:03:51 - 01:04:13

Marsha Cordova

Mr. Speaker, church officials are in regular contact with Historic England and the Department for Culture, Media and Sport regarding the Places of Worship Renewal Fund and are monitoring parish experiences of using the scheme closely. Following feedback, Historic England has also published a funding directory to help identify alternative sources of support.

01:04:13 - 01:04:15

Speaker 77

Miss Twist.

01:04:15 - 01:04:45

Liz Twist

I thank my honorable friend for that answer. In communities like Blaydon and Consett, historic parish churches such as St Ives in Leadgate, known locally as the miners' cathedral, are irreplaceable heritage assets but carry huge repair burdens. What discussions has she had with the department to ensure that round two funding is targeted towards former industrial communities with larger conservation needs?

01:04:45 - 01:05:31

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend is right to point to the importance of historic buildings such as St Ives, the miners' cathedral, to the local communities and the pressure with which they all face. Historic England, as I say, are managing applications and have indicated they are measuring need and also using an at-risk register as well as a local deprivation index to identify best places to prioritize on this. It will be easier, I think, to assess the effectiveness of the new scheme and the new fund once it has had a little more time to bed in. And I will ensure my honorable friend receives details of the funding directory, which I hope will help parishes in her constituency identify suitable sources of funding that they may be eligible for.

01:05:31 - 01:05:48

Speaker 80

Right, that completes questions. Let's front bench change over. We now come to the urgent question. Shadow Secretary of State, Andrew Bowie.

01:05:48 - 01:06:01

Andrew Bowie

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, to ask the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero if she will make a statement on the future of the Jackdaw and Rosebank oil fields following the closure of the public consultation.

01:06:02 - 01:08:34

Sarah Jones

Good morning, Mr. Speaker. Can I first welcome and congratulate the honorable gentleman to his new position as the Shadow Secretary of State for the Department of Energy Security and Net Zero. The Scottish Court of Session quashed the original consents for these projects in January 2025. We published supplementary guidance in June 2025 to implement the Finch judgment, under which end-use combustion emissions must be taken into account in environmental impact assessments for oil and gas production projects. At this time, the government reopened the window for applications, and the Jackdaw and Rosebank fields are each subject to a live regulatory process.

The public notice periods, which as the gentleman knows closed on the 10th and the 17th of August respectively, were part of that regulatory process. The Secretary of State will consider the representations received and will make separate decisions on each project in due course. I do appreciate the strength of interest in this decision, but it would not be appropriate for me to comment any further on either project. I have to say, Mr. Speaker, it is a little bit rich hearing the Conservatives suddenly talk about protecting jobs and caring about Aberdeen. Let's look at the facts.

By the end of 2016, under the Conservatives, more than 120,000 UK oil and gas jobs had gone. More than a third of them in Scotland and the vast majority in the North East. And those aren't my words, Mr. Speaker. They're the words of the Conservative MSP, Liam Kerr.

And what happened to Aberdeen on their watch? The independent think tank Centre for Cities call it Aberdeen's lost decade. It found that between 2010 and 2022, the city lost around 9,000 jobs under the Conservatives. Real household incomes per head fell 6.7% and nearly 15,000 people left the city. In fact, Mr Speaker, Aberdeen was one of just two of Britain's 62 largest cities and towns to have fewer jobs than it had in 2010.

I gently say to the member for West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine, this is an abysmal record from his party in government. He may have a little bit of selective memory about the Conservatives' record in the North East, but I don't think his constituents do.

01:08:34 - 01:10:21

Andrew Bowie

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I don't think the Conservative Party will take any lectures from Labour on record in the North East of Scotland given the result in Aberdeen South only a few months ago. But I'd like to thank her for her warm welcome to my new position. The public consultation on Rosebank and Jackdaw has now closed. The department can no longer hide behind process, delay or consultation exercises.

They have dithered, prevaricated and delayed for far too long. Industry and workers in and around Aberdeen and indeed across the United Kingdom need an answer now. We have a new Prime Minister, a new Secretary of State, so how about a new direction? That is what our oil and gas industry needs. That is what the thousands of workers in it that do not know what lies ahead of them need.

So can I ask her a simple question? Will they finally approve Rosebank and Jackdaw, something we already did in government, or will they continue the previous Secretary of State's campaign against Britain's North Sea oil and gas industry? It was the previous Secretary of State that refused to appeal the ruling against the decision over two years ago. It was the previous Secretary of State that refused to fast-track the consultation process. It was the previous Secretary of State that refused to act in the national interest because this goes beyond Jackdaw and Rosebank alone.

It is about whether Great Britain chooses to produce its own energy or become ever more dependent on imports from overseas, dirtier and more expensive foreign imports. So where does the Minister want that energy that we will need to come if they don't get on and approve Rosebank and Jackdaw? Mr Speaker, the question today is a simple one, but the answer could be transformative for the North Sea industry, for the North East of Scotland and for the United Kingdom's economic and energy security. When will they approve Jackdaw and Rosebank?

01:10:21 - 01:10:53

Sarah Jones

Thank you, Mr Speaker. As I say, I appreciate there is a huge amount of interest in this process. I think what we could all agree, though, is that we want this process, this very robust process, to take its course. And the worst thing that could happen is that anything is prejudiced or interferes with that process and we end up having to re-run it. So we will be doing that in due process.

As I said in my statement, the process ended in August and the Secretary of State will be taking those decisions in due course.

01:10:53 - 01:12:03

Speaker 93

Thank you, Mr Speaker. As the Prime Minister said on Tuesday, our energy supply and our energy security is not a question of either oil and gas or renewables, it is a question of both. And it is a great pity, of course, that a proper process wasn't followed in 2022 or 2023. Otherwise, well, the Shadow Secretary of State says it was, but if that's true, why was it able to be challenged in the courts?

And this of course is why it's really important that the government gets it right this time around. But Mr. Speaker, it is really important that the we recognize the importance of the supply chain, the workers, their companies, their communities in oil and gas in the North Sea, because they are the same people we need to make the energy transition that is so critical to our future. So does the Minister agree that it is vital we support the companies, the workers and the communities in oil and gas while we gear up in renewables so they are available to contribute and make that transition happen as fast and as effectively as possible?

01:12:04 - 01:12:38

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable gentleman for his considered question and thoughtful question. He is absolutely right that we have taken a we've already we're already drilling in the North Sea and we're clear that oil and gas have an important role and this Prime Minister we have a pragmatic approach. But it's important we think about the workers and in terms of he's absolutely right to think about the supply chain, both in terms of the industries of today and of the clean industries of the future.

01:12:38 - 01:12:41

Speaker 92

Pippa Heylings, Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

01:12:41 - 01:13:31

Pippa Heylings

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This summer I saw firsthand the devastation that wildfires fueled by climate change caused to Dunwich Heath and the communities around them. And my thoughts are with those impacted by wildfires nationwide this summer. And that's why it's so shocking to see some parties across this House trading conservation of our environment for a scorched earth policy. We on these benches do not and will not accept assertions from the Conservatives and Reform that these licenses would magically create billions to bring people's bills down now.

We do need to bring people's bills down by investing in homegrown renewable power whilst recognizing that we need some oil and gas for decades to come. However, no part of the country must be left behind in this pursuit. So will the Minister guarantee a genuinely just transition with good quality clean energy jobs, protect workers, supply chains and communities?

01:13:32 - 01:13:59

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable lady who brings to this debate her usual passion and commitment and talks about the wildfires over the summer of which the Prime Minister announced yesterday we would have a wildfire summit. On the topic today, we will be continuing with this robust process. And as I say, I appreciate the strength of interest both in this place and outside, but given the quasi-judicial nature, we cannot get involved further in terms of the process.

01:13:59 - 01:14:02

Speaker 94

Toby Perkins, Shadow Environment Minister.

01:14:02 - 01:14:51

Toby Perkins

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The government is right to take its time and make sure it gets this right. We've seen what happens when the previous government didn't do the work that's needed. This is a delicately balanced decision. The world already has all the oil it's going to need until 2050, so further exploration increases the amount of oil that there is and drives down the prices and slows down the transition to renewables.

But there are also strong arguments to say that we will be importing oil and gas and this will slightly reduce the amount that we that we import. So can I say to my honorable friend, she's absolutely right to take time to make sure we get this right. She should listen carefully to all of the arguments that have been made on both sides. Those jobs are important, but so is the transition that the government is rightly committed to.

01:14:52 - 01:15:24

Sarah Jones

Thank you. And I thank my honorable friend who has a long and standing interest in this area. He is absolutely right that we need to take into account make sure we're thinking taking our time through the process, respecting the robustness of that process and thinking about the implications. And I know the Secretary of State will be doing that and is considering all of the evidence that will be supplied to her.

01:15:24 - 01:15:25

Douglas Lumsden.

01:15:25 - 01:16:08

Douglas Lumsden

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I must admit I'm angry and disappointed how I hear members on other benches seem to cast aside jobs in my constituency. Because on the 18th of June, the people of Aberdeen South sent a huge message to both this Labour government and the SNP government in Holyrood that they will not stand back and watch their jobs being destroyed. Now, every month, a thousand jobs are being lost in the UK oil and gas industry. Every month this government dithers and delays, it means more jobs lost.

So does the Minister not accept that these workers deserve clarity and not having this decision kicked down further down the road, and they need some assurance that their jobs are going to be saved.

01:16:08 - 01:16:54

Sarah Jones

I thank the honourable gentleman for raising this and raising it so passionately on behalf of his constituent. I absolutely agree with him that jobs are key, and that is why we expanded the training support and new jobs service for around the North Sea. I absolutely agree with him that we want clarity on this decision, and that is why regretfully we cannot say a huge amount on the process today because we want that process to be respected. It has to be a robust process, and because it is quasi-judicial, I am very concerned that I am respectful of that. And I want to make sure for his constituents and also for the rest of the country, we have a clear decision that is made respecting that robust process.

01:16:54 - 01:17:35

Speaker 98

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I can assure the member for Aberdeen South that there is not just jobs in his constituency, but in mine in Hill and Year and across the whole of the UK as well. One of the first things I did was present the new Prime Minister with a map of the UK showing the postcode payslips that affect almost every constituency. And can I echo the Prime Minister's words when he was addressing the member for Boston Skegness the other day, when he said we need to be pragmatic. We still need oil and gas for some time to come, and we are mistaken to say that it's got to be one or the other when we need both.

And can I remind the ministers making this decision that when it comes to Rosebank and Jackdaw, we do need both.

01:17:35 - 01:19:30

Sarah Jones

I thank my honourable friend and I think we've all heard as I say, there is a significant amount of interest, thoughts and opinions in this place and outside of that place. The Prime Minister has said we will take a pragmatic approach. Oil and gas will remain part of our energy mix, and we the environmental impact assessment that is taken place will take account of scope three emissions. It's absolutely right to mention as others that this the North Sea is also has opportunities both in clean energy and in fossil fuel energy, and we need to think about that in a more in a holistic sense.

01:19:30 - 01:19:58

Kerry McCarthy

Thank you Mr Speaker. Personally I cannot see that Rosebank is compatible with meeting our climate objectives but I do recognise that the process should be followed. Green Alliance has reported that the gas being wasted in the North Sea is enough to heat 570,000 homes. It's been over a year since the government issued a methane action plan I think the minister took it over from me. Methane's over 80 times more powerful than CO2 in the short term.

So what are we doing to reduce venting and flaring in the North Sea?

01:19:58 - 01:20:44

Sarah Jones

Minister. I thank the honourable member and I thank her for all the work she has done in this in the previous role but also before she came to this place and and throughout her time here. And I'm grateful for her awareness of the process in terms of that we are unable. She raises a really important point in terms of our methane. It is a very potent greenhouse gas.

It also would be cost and efficiency savings for these companies. We should be using our energy efficiently. I am meeting with international colleagues in the forthcoming weeks to discuss this but also we are working domestically as well in terms of that. But I appreciate her raising the point we will continue to work on it.

01:20:44 - 01:20:45

Stephen Flynn.

01:20:45 - 01:21:05

David Mundell

Thank you Mr Speaker. The BBC and others have reported that importing liquefied natural gas is 10 times more polluting than pipeline gas. Does the minister agree with that assessment? And further has any assessment been made as to what the impact of Jackdaw on that in reducing pollution would be?

01:21:05 - 01:21:32

Sarah Jones

Minister. I thank the honourable member for his very specific questions. I have not seen the BBC report. I'd be very happy for him to to send it to me. As I said to the honourable member before scope 3 emissions will be part of the environmental impact assessment which will be given to the Secretary of State and which will make a part of it will feed into her decision-making process.

01:21:32 - 01:21:33

Richard Baker.

01:21:33 - 01:21:49

Speaker 90

Thank you Mr Speaker. If Jackdaw and Rosebank proceed they will create and sustain thousands of skilled jobs and apprenticeships which in the future will be crucial to developing our renewable sector further. Does the minister agree that this should be a crucial factor in this decision?

01:21:49 - 01:22:21

Sarah Jones

Minister. I thank the honourable member for raising the issue of jobs. As I said we have since we came into government have expanded the North Sea job service to support workers. He's absolutely right there is a huge crossover between renewables and oil and gas workers. And I'm struck that every wind farm we visit there is usually a Scottish accent there.

So I appreciate and as I say the Secretary of State will be aware of this fact. Thank you.

01:22:21 - 01:22:22

Kirsty Blackman.

01:22:22 - 01:23:18

Ann Kirsty Blackman

Thank you Mr Speaker. Mr Speaker there's more starkly than I've ever seen in this place before a geographical divide on this. Every member representing a Scottish constituency on a cross-party basis has stressed jobs has stressed how important this is to the North East of Scotland. If this doesn't make clear that Scotland needs to be in control of energy policy I don't know what does. The minister has mentioned two things in terms of the consultation.

She's said a decision will be taken in due course. Does in due course mean before the budget? Does it mean 2026? Does it mean 2027? Does it mean 2029?

Could she pin it down slightly further than that? And then on scope 3 emissions will she be very clear in ensuring that what is published is what the honourable member asked for a comparison on how much the import of LNG would affect the environment compared to how much approving Jackdaw would affect the environment?

01:23:18 - 01:24:12

Sarah Jones

Minister. I thank the honourable lady for her question and I admire her trying to lure me into conversations on independence and devolution. I'm afraid I'm afraid that is not part of the scope of the discussion today so I will not. In terms of again look in terms of the timeline as I said in due course. We are fully aware of the need for clarity but the most important thing for me is around the robustness of the process.

Because the worst thing would be if we end up inadvertently undermining the process today by me making a comment today. Undermining the process would be the worst outcome for everybody. What I agree is in terms of making sure that we have a just transition and make sure we support our Scottish workers for the jobs and industries of the future.

01:24:12 - 01:24:53

Speaker 103

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I think we do need a pragmatic approach for oil and gas and one that is focused on people, prioritizing British businesses and communities. So I do want to see a positive decision on both Rosebank and Jackdaw. But does the Minister agree with me that the reason we're in the position we are now with less clarity and less security about what's going to happen is the abject failure of the party opposite to reduce our reliance on fossil fuels, their failure to run a properly managed decision process on Jackdaw and Rosebank in the first place, while overseeing an absolute failure of an effective transition to a low-carbon economy, while overseeing the loss of over 120,000 jobs in the industry?

01:24:53 - 01:25:30

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable member for his excellent analysis of why we have ended up here. So I think it's absolutely right and I think it is on all of us to respect that process because I think the feeling of the House is we want clarity and in order to do that, it's around the robustness of that process. And so it is hugely important that today we respect that. But I understand the level of interest, but as I said in my opening remarks, I find it a little audacious that this is something that we have had an about-turn and it's not the only thing that this shadow Secretary of State has had an about-turn on.

01:25:30 - 01:26:05

Bob Blackman

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The fact is, of course, that the gas and oil coming from the North Sea is declining year by year. The sad reality, of course, is that without a decision on these two fields, Jackdaw and Rosebank, we will be totally dependent on expensive imports. So I understand the Minister not wanting to interfere in the quasi-judicial process, but will she accept the principle that it's far better for us to supply our own oil and gas rather than import expensive oil and gas from abroad?

01:26:05 - 01:26:35

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable member and I appreciate his respect for the process and the need for clarity and robustness. He does also make the important point that it is a declining basin and therefore we also need to make sure that we have other sources of energy. And that's why this government has secured record investment from the government and from the private sector in terms of clean energy to make sure that we have as much energy there.

01:26:35 - 01:27:01

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The party opposite failed to invest in clean power and now they're suggesting they'd fail to invest altogether. Can the Minister tell the House what action this government is taking to ensure that wars overseas don't increase the bills of my constituents in Paisley and Renfrewshire South, making the cost of living unaffordable?

01:27:01 - 01:27:34

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable lady who is passionate obviously about her constituency but also about this area. And she makes absolutely right that we are at the behest of the fossil fuel rollercoaster and we have all seen the impacts of that over the last few years. And in the last four years we've had two international energy crises and we are at the moment a price taker on the international fossil fuel markets which has an impact on our constituents.

And that's why our Secretary of State is focusing on energy affordability as her priority.

01:27:34 - 01:27:35

Dr. Ella Chart.

01:27:35 - 01:28:27

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We cannot discuss this issue without recognizing that climate breakdown is costing us hugely already. Hottest summer ever, worst arable harvest ever. Met Office says it's 130 times more likely that we face this crisis this year. Just today, the WMO has said that climate breakdown is supercharging natural phenomena like El Niño.

Now, the Shadow Secretary of State says that North Sea communities need a new direction. Yes, a new direction, a just transition to clean energy for the future, not the dirty energy of the old. So will the Minister recognize that the climate damage created by Rosebank and Jackdaw will hugely outweigh any potential economic benefit and therefore rule them out? Fossil fuels have to stay in the ground if we're to have a livable future.

01:28:27 - 01:28:29

Speaker 104

Minister.

01:28:29 - 01:29:00

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable lady for her question and for her passion on this topic. The environmental impact assessment that has been part of the process will take account of scope 3 emissions. I can say no more in terms of the Rosebank and Jackdaw decisions today. What I will say is this government takes climate change incredibly seriously. I hope on Tuesday she heard the new Prime Minister talking about it and obviously his commitment and is going to Turkey for the COP this year.

01:29:00 - 01:29:46

Elizabeth Rachel Collinge

Miss Col... Lizzie Col.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As a member of the Energy Security and Net Zero Select Committee, I've taken evidence on the complexity of the North Sea oil and gas discussion and the long-term decline of this mature basin. I have to say, as a Member of Parliament for two nuclear power stations, I will not take lectures on energy jobs and their importance, particularly given the lack of progress on nuclear under the Conservatives. But I think the complexity of the discussion is lost, Mr. Speaker, on the opposition. And some of their assertions, particularly the impact on prices of new drilling, is simply not based on any evidence.

So this is a complex discussion, but does the Minister agree with me that what is really clear and really simple is that climate change is an existential threat and that a clean and fair energy transition is absolutely vital to tackling climate change?

01:29:46 - 01:29:48

Speaker 106

Minister.

01:29:48 - 01:30:34

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable lady for her question. I have been subject to her tough questioning at the Select Committee, so it's a joy to be having it in the House as well. As I say, look, on this specific process, I cannot say any more today because, as we have, I think, collectively agreed, the robustness of the process is absolutely key. And I am very cautious of saying anything that would jeopardize that because we want that clarity of decision. At the same time, as I've just said to my honorable lady on the other benches, climate change, we know, is a key issue.

We've seen the wildfires this summer. And we've seen this week only the Prime Minister talking in his first intervention and committing him to the COP and having a wildfire summer.

01:30:35 - 01:31:10

John Glen

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I listened very carefully to what the Minister said about the process, and I respect that. But most people who take a pretty, sort of, level-headed, pragmatic view of the need for a transition over time still can't get their head round the reality in the short term, where we have so much turmoil in the Middle East. Why would we extend the time that we are not reliant on our own available resources? And as a member of the Treasury Select Committee, where one to two billion of VAT receipts alone, as well as the impact on the economy of the northeast of Scotland, is so severely impacted, can't this decision be made more quickly based on principled guidance from this government?

01:31:43 - 01:32:09

Sarah Jones

There is a lot of interest in this place and outside, and our Secretary of State wants to consider that properly to make sure that we do expedite the decision as soon as we can, but that has to be done properly or we will all end up back here again. So let's make sure we respect that process and we will do that. But as I say, I have heard the thoughts of the member, but there is interest in here and outside.

01:32:09 - 01:32:49

Jonathan Brash

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One of my great frustrations in the debate around energy security is the way that populism and ideology pollutes the debate. Hartlepool is one of the largest clean energy economies in England through new nuclear, which some oppose, through renewables, which others oppose, but which both of which I support. And I also support drilling in the North Sea. It's good for jobs, it's good for the economy.

So will the Minister take back this message to her department? We must approve Jackdaw and Rosebank and we must go further to expand drilling in the North Sea.

01:32:49 - 01:33:06

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable member for his comments and for his interest in this and other energy decisions. As I cannot make any further comments in terms of these particular projects because of the robust regulatory process that is underway.

01:33:06 - 01:33:49

Speaker 111

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Both Labour and the Conservatives are guilty of failing oil and gas workers by driving uncertainty in this debate. Conservatives by their U-turn in climate change policy, something which both the oil and gas sector and the renewable sector are deeply unhappy with. And the Labour government by their complete lack of pace and decision-making on regulatory issues like TNUoS charges, the 18 months to decide on what was happening at Ardersier, and on now on Jackdaw and Rosebank. The whole energy sector needs pace and clarity of decision-making.

Scotland would make this a priority with the full powers of independence. Will the government put the same pace and effort into it?

01:33:49 - 01:34:40

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable member for his question. I agree with him that there has been a certain amount of U-turns on the benches opposite, you know, and they keep coming, so we will continue to see what the position is. And also their lack of clarity in terms of strategic planning for our energy systems, they're not listening. You know, has had consequences, regretful consequences. I'm sure where I would disagree is the honorable member, we have had the evidence, the deadline finished in August.

I don't think anybody would expect that we wouldn't want to make sure we were listening to that evidence and making sure we're taking account of all of the input. So I think, and in terms of us not moving at pace, I think that nobody would say this government has not moved at pace on energy and in terms of our clean energy mission.

01:34:40 - 01:35:17

Speaker 112

Mr. Speaker, between 2014 and 2019, the Select Committee heard that production rose by a fifth, there was a much more favorable taxation regime, and jobs continued to fall in the sector. The evidence is clear: approving Rosebank and Jackdaw will not protect jobs. The sector is unfortunately in decline. But we can do, Mr. Speaker, does the Secretary of State, the Minister agree with me, that if we can fix transition costs that are stopping renewables, the ridiculous delays from NISO on connections, the SNP's blocking of nuclear, and of course ramping up support and training for workers, will actually help the sector to revive and be sustainable long-term.

01:35:17 - 01:35:45

Sarah Jones

I also welcome my honorable friend for his interest in this and for his interest in the wider debate. I appreciate the strength of feeling, I can hear the strength of feelings on all sides within this place. Where I, and I cannot say any more about the specific process and the decisions that are underway, but in terms of making sure our energy system is working efficiently and moving at pace, we are doing everything we can and I look forward to continuing to engaging with him on that.

01:35:45 - 01:36:18

Rose Savage

Mr. Speaker, we've heard a lot from this government about energy security, but if Rosebank were to go ahead, we won't own this oil, we won't set its price, and most of it won't be refined here. Thousands of homes in my constituency are off the gas grid and heat with oil bought by the tankful at whatever the international price happens to be that week. Would the minister please explain what security a barrel sold on the international market at the international price buys for the households of the South Cotswolds?

01:36:18 - 01:36:52

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable lady for her question and for her interest in this area. I think getting into any defenses of specific areas may lead me into areas where it would potentially be saying things I shouldn't be saying in terms of this is for a Secretary of State decision. She will be taking into account the environmental impacts assessment and we are working through the large number of evidence that has come into the department.

01:36:52 - 01:37:34

Speaker 117

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to say from the outset, I agree with my honorable friend from Bristol East. I'm afraid I do not agree with drilling for oil in Rosebank. It will not take a penny off bills and it would absolutely smash out of the water our carbon emissions targets. But the party opposite are living in another world. They haven't lived through the summer that we've all lived through: drought, wildfires all across South Wales.

We need to go hard on the green transition. So will the secretary, sorry, will the minister agree with me that we should absolutely keep to our targets in the Climate Change Act and not agree with the party opposite to repeal it?

01:37:34 - 01:38:10

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable lady for her question and I note her opinion as I say there is a strength of feeling across this house on different sides. We are noting those, I will make no comment. In terms of her separate question on the Climate Change Act, I was absolutely baffled at the position of the party opposite. It wasn't a position that when he was in power he took, but I think many of his party will be ashamed and I noted the article in the FT from the former environment secretary who referred to it, I believe, as tin-eared.

01:38:10 - 01:39:03

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, can I thank the minister very much for her answers. That our long-term goal must be, of course, energy independence so that we are never again at the mercy of volatile foreign regimes for our basic power needs. National Energy Action NI have highlighted that roughly 39% of households in Northern Ireland are currently living in fuel poverty, compounded by the fact that 60% of homes in Northern Ireland still rely on heating oil subject to unregulated markets. So given that the public consultation has now concluded, will the minister assure the house that the final decision will strike a balance between our environmental responsibilities and the urgent need to protect domestic energy security, shield hard-pressed working families from soaring utility bills, and safeguard the thousands of vital jobs supported by our domestic energy sector? Thank you.

01:39:03 - 01:39:36

Sarah Jones

I thank the honorable gentleman for his question and for the important points that he raised. This Secretary of State has put energy affordability at the heart of our agenda. We will continue to do that. Fuel poverty is something that she has worked on for many, many years and is hugely passionate about. When the straight from Muse crisis and the Middle East crisis began, heating oil is something we obviously took action on and this government is investing a record amount in the warm homes.

We need to do that at pace to make sure that this is felt in constituencies and postcodes across our island.

01:39:36 - 01:40:02

Luke Myer

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I echo the comments made by the chair of the select committee earlier on? And at risk of inviting criticism from the left and the right, can I just plead for some nuance in this debate? These are two materially different prospects. And of course, one of them is able to feed directly into our domestic markets.

So can I just urge ministers to make sure that the decision is made based on evidence rather than just ideology?

01:40:02 - 01:40:11

Speaker 116

I thank the honorable member for his question. And I can assure him that we are very much in favor of evidence-based policymaking.

01:40:11 - 01:40:38

Speaker 120

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Given the climate emergency we're already living through, this is obviously a hugely significant decision for the Secretary of State. And while I respect the minister can't comment today on the merits of each of the proposals, surely she can comment on how this House will be able to scrutinize any final decision. So can she confirm today from the dispatch box that when a final decision is taken, there will be a chance to debate and vote on it in this House?

01:40:38 - 01:41:05

Sarah Jones

I thank my honorable friend for his suggestion. I don't want to presuppose a suggestion. Look, in terms of today, he's absolutely right that the robustness of this process is absolutely key. And we need to ensure that we respect that process for clarity on the decision, ensuring that we have respected the process which will lead to that is the most important thing for us.

01:41:05 - 01:41:52

Speaker 119

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown has recently argued that the future of the North Sea is not about a choice between oil and gas and renewables, but about protecting jobs as workers transition into the industries of the future. I wonder if the minister will agree that projects like Jackdaw and Rosebank matter and are so important because they provide jobs, investment, skills, and let's say further tax revenues today, and that a just transition has to protect those workers and communities rather than leaving them behind.

01:41:52 - 01:42:21

Sarah Jones

I thank my honorable friend for his question. And I respect our former leaders who have at many times engaged in the energy conversation. In terms of he highlights many different areas that this impacts. The North Sea does impact each of these areas. And the Secretary of State will be making a decision in due course, taking account of the new evidence that she has received.

01:42:21 - 01:42:46

Speaker 123

Right, well let the front bench change over. Right, we've come to the next statement. Robbie Moore.

01:42:46 - 01:42:54

Robbie Moore

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs if she will make a statement on Bluetongue virus in livestock.

01:42:54 - 01:43:20

Speaker 122

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to begin by recognizing that this is an incredibly difficult time for livestock keepers, veterinary professionals, and those that are working directly on the impact of the Bluetongue outbreak. Responding to outbreaks is core to Defra's work, and we will continue to use tried and tested methods to address this challenge. Bluetongue affects cattle, sheep, goats, deer, and camelids.

01:43:20 - 01:45:11

Daniel Zeichner

It's spread by biting midges and can cause significant animal health impacts, although it poses no risk to human health or food safety. The first confirmed case of bluetongue serotype 3 in the UK this year was on the 10th of July in Staffordshire. As of yesterday, there have been 795 confirmed cases of bluetongue in Great Britain. We are supporting enhanced testing capacity. We've worked closely with the devolved governments and industry throughout the outbreak, listening to farmers and jointly developing policies to ensure farmers receive timely information and practical guidance.

This has included regular disease alerts, social media updates, weekly communications to livestock keepers, and a programme of industry webinars. Vaccination remains the most effective and viable short and long-term control measure against bluetongue, both for this season and in the future. Defra and the Veterinary Medicines Directorate, VMD, are working closely with manufacturers to monitor availability and are taking proactive steps to ensure that additional vaccine stocks are made available as quickly as possible. I encourage all livestock keepers to remain vigilant, monitor and vaccinate their animals, and report any suspicions of disease immediately. Finally, I know that this has been a trying period for farmers, animal keepers, and private vets.

Support is available through government guidance, the Rural Services Helpline, and Farming Help. We will continue to work closely with industry representatives to ensure concerns are heard, information is shared promptly, and support reaches those that need it. Through vigilance, vaccination, and partnership, we will continue to meet this challenge and protect the health of our livestock sector. Thank you.

01:45:11 - 01:45:13

Speaker 118

Shadow Minister Robbie Moore.

01:45:13 - 01:47:23

Robbie Moore

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Bluetongue is spreading across Britain at an unprecedented rate, devastating livestock businesses and putting farming families under immense financial and emotional pressure. And I thank our vets and those at the front line of addressing the spread of the virus. As of yesterday, 795 cases have been confirmed this season, but there are more than 2,500 potential cases still under investigation. Yet farmers and vets are being forced to wait up to three weeks for blood test results, leaving the livestock sector without a real-time picture of the outbreak.

So why was testing capacity not significantly increased over the summer period, and when will ministers clear this backlog? In hotspot areas, will a proportionate risk-based approach be adopted? Those delays are more concerning given that Defra's expenditure on bluetongue testing was significantly reduced under this Labour government by 74% in this financial year. Why did the government allow this spending to fall so dramatically just as the outbreak was accelerating? Ministers rightly advise farmers to vaccinate livestock, but supplies can take up to three to four weeks to arrive.

So why has the government not acted to secure adequate vaccine supplies, working more closely with vaccine manufacturers, veterinary bodies, and industry? Farmers also face mounting fallen stock disposal costs, yet repeated calls to ministers for financial assistance has gone unanswered. Can the government today confirm financial assistance will be put in place, and will the government review the environmental permit constraints to ease carcass disposal? Finally, Mr. Speaker, bluetongue presents similar symptoms to those of foot and mouth disease, which is already present in continental Europe. With testing for bluetongue taking weeks to turn around, there is a real concern that a positive foot and mouth case could be hidden within the backlog.

So what assurances can the minister give that he is alert to this issue and is taking action? It seems, Mr. Speaker, that despite concerns being consistently raised throughout summer, ministers have been asleep at the wheel.

01:47:24 - 01:48:46

Daniel Zeichner

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I must stress that vaccination remains the only effective long-term option for disease control, and we will continue to work with keepers of susceptible animals to discuss vaccine options with their vets to protect animals and reduce the impact of disease. I thank the shadow minister for his questions. We absolutely recognize that this is a difficult time for livestock keepers and for veterinary professionals supporting them. Defra is working really closely with livestock keepers and industry to facilitate access to vaccinations and ensure timely information. This has included webinars, engagement events attended by a thousand farmers, disease alerts, regular updates on gov.uk, on APHA channels, and welfare support.

I must stress that the government has acted quickly to secure increased vaccine supply. Vaccination does remain the only effective long-term option for disease control, and we will continue to engage all keepers of susceptible animals to discuss vaccine options with them. With regards to testing capacity at Pirbright and Alpha, we have stepped up capacity for testing and worked closely with industry on these, and we will continue to work with our keepers to ensure that the sector is supported, and I continue to engage with the National Sheep Association, the NFU, and others on the issues at hand.

01:48:46 - 01:48:48

Speaker 124

Terry Jermy.

01:48:48 - 01:49:16

James Terry Jermy

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the minister for his response and for his engagement with the farming community over the summer, which I know has been appreciated. Bluetongue is a huge concern for farmers in Norfolk at the moment, and resilience is so low, any one issue risks being the straw that broke the camel's back. So now we have the farming profitability review, we have the farming roadmap. Can the minister talk more about work the government is doing to improve resilience in the farming community?

01:49:17 - 01:49:46

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my honorable friend for his question. He's a real champion for the farming community in his constituency. I know he's now recently met over a hundred farmers across his patch and look forward to working with him this autumn on the challenges and issues that the farming community in his constituency continue to face. He's absolutely right. Our roadmap sets out a 25-year plan to support the farming communities to build resilience, to build confidence, and to build a productive sector for the future, and I know that he will do everything he can to make sure that becomes a reality in his own constituency.

01:49:46 - 01:49:49

Speaker 126

Sarah Dyke, Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

01:49:49 - 01:50:44

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As climate change extends the range of disease-carrying midges, confirmed bluetongue cases have surged in nearly 800 nationally, with thousands more suspected. Somerset and Devon are among the worst affected areas. Vets in Glastonbury and Somerton tell me their vaccine waiting lists are now as long as their arm, while farmers face mounting costs during dealing with transporting fallen stock, paying for vaccine, all the while they deal with the devastation of their livestock being put at risk. Farmers cannot be expected to shoulder an ever-growing share of the cost of controlling a disease that threatens our national food security.

The government must recognize the serious financial pressure this outbreak is placing on farms already struggling after years of neglect. So what steps is the minister taking to accelerate the vaccination rollout, to support affected farmers with financial assistance, and to remove barriers to surveillance?

01:50:45 - 01:51:28

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honorable member for her questions, and it was a real pleasure to be in the southwest to hear directly from farmers in August, some of the challenges that they're facing, including farmers in the southwest affected by the bluetongue virus. And I absolutely recognize the real challenges it's brought them this summer on top of a whole set of other challenges. I must stress the importance of vaccination, and that's why we've worked really closely with industry to increase the vaccine supply coming into the country, but also working closely with Pirbright Institute in Weybridge to ensure that there's extra capacity going in there around the testing. We recognize the significant impact that bluetongue is having on farmers, and this does include reviewing our processes to help expedite the confirmation of disease, and we are considering what further support may be available to farmers in the future.

01:51:28 - 01:51:29

Ben Goldsborough.

01:51:29 - 01:51:53

Ben Goldsborough

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The 27th of August 2024 will stick with me for a very long time because that was the first case of bluetongue in South Norfolk. So what I would like to ask the Minister specifically is what action is being taken to increase APHA capacity, but also to improve mapping accounting for both confirmed and suspected cases within the disease.

01:51:54 - 01:52:13

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my honorable friend for his question, and as I mentioned earlier, we have increased capacity at Pirbright Institute, working closely with APHA on capacity issues. Very happy to write to him about the specifics of that, and I know that he is a real champion on these issues and will continue to hold my feet to the fire on any action that government can take.

01:52:13 - 01:52:16

Lindsay Hoyle

Alistair Carmichael, Chair of the Select Committee.

01:52:16 - 01:53:16

Alexander Carmichael

Mr. Speaker, I remind the House of my own entry in the register of members' interests, and that my wife is actually a practicing veterinary surgeon as well. What's happening, Mr. Speaker, was predictable because it was predicted. The government was warned by the National Audit Office in June of last year that they were unprepared for outbreaks of this sort. So can the Minister tell us what actions were taken by the department following that? The priority for the moment has got to be getting better vaccines supply and faster testing turnarounds, but then there are questions that need to be asked about the lack of proper campaign of awareness earlier in the mid-season because we're going to be coming back to this.

And why is there not better information available for vets and farmers? I vaccinated my stock last year. I couldn't even find out this year whether that was going to be sufficient or whether the vaccination would need to be done again. The Minister's right about the protection that we get from vaccination. The second most important thing is reliable information.

01:53:17 - 01:54:01

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the Chair of the Select Committee for his contribution. He's absolutely right that this is a serious issue that needs serious consideration. I mentioned that Defra has tried and tested approaches to dealing with outbreaks. There are always lessons that we can learn, and I will certainly look very closely at what the report tells us and will hear very closely what the Select Committee may say on these issues in due course. In terms of communications, I think there's always more we can do.

We've had popular webinars. We've been putting information on the gov.uk website. There's been information from APHA as well, and I want to also praise the contribution that the NFU has made in terms of making sure that farmers are engaged in these issues and getting the right support at the right time.

01:54:01 - 01:54:02

Josh Newbury.

01:54:02 - 01:54:35

Josh Newbury

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Bluetongue is causing misery in my county of Staffordshire, which has seen the biggest growth in cases of our region. The more vociferous spread and longer season due to the heat this summer underlines the urgent need for disease outbreak preparedness to be a key plank of Britain's adaptation to climate change. Is the Minister confident that the increased uptake that we will hopefully see can be fulfilled, and would he be willing to meet with livestock farmers in my constituency to discuss the many challenges that they have faced this summer?

01:54:36 - 01:54:59

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my honorable friend for his question, and again, he is a real champion on farming issues and really look forward to visiting his constituency in due course to understand some of the challenges and opportunities that farmers in his constituency are facing. I'm regularly engaging with the livestock sector, having visited the National Sheep Association event in July, and very happy to hear his views and concerns and to meet the sector to understand any opportunities and challenges that continue to exist.

01:55:00 - 01:55:34

John Lamont

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Bluetongue is now causing considerable concern amongst livestock farmers in Scotland and the Scottish Borders, with cases increasing and restrictions affecting livestock movements at a particularly critical time of year. Indeed, the important Kelso Ram Sales are due to take place next week in my constituency. Given the substantial movement of sheep and cattle across the Scotland-England border, what discussions is the Minister having with the Scottish Government to ensure that vaccination, testing, and movement rules are properly coordinated across Great Britain and do not create unnecessary barriers for farmers?

01:55:35 - 01:55:52

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honorable member for his question.

I can assure him that officials are working closely with the devolved nations and indeed I am in regular contact with my equivalents in the other nations to make sure that we keep a close eye on the outbreak and do everything we can cross-border to support any challenges and concerns.

01:55:52 - 01:56:24

Perran Moon

I thank the Minister for visiting Cornwall last month to talk to some of our farmers about their concerns. As of Tuesday, there were 117 cases in Cornwall and as has been mentioned there's a further 2,500 nationally under investigation. My farmers have raised their concerns about the length of time that it's taking to get test results back. Can the Minister reassure my farmers that their test results will be delivered in a timely manner?

01:56:24 - 01:56:55

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my hon. Friend for his question and know that this is an issue that really matters to him based on the feedback and concerns that he's received from his farmers and it was a real pleasure to be with the Prime Minister last month to announce further measures to support our farming community down in the South West. More broadly on the points he raised around capacity issues at Pirbright and testing, I will certainly take away the specific questions that he raises but I can assure him today from the dispatch box that there is increased capacity to assist with those issues.

01:56:55 - 01:57:32

John Cooper

The midges which spread bluetongue are no respecters of the border and the fact that devolution is sent to Holyrood for consideration in Scotland as we've heard, there are difficulties with cross-border movement. It's a huge issue and I've also been told that the Animal Plant and Health Agency reacted in Scotland initially with all the alacrity of a tranquilised sloth in the initial stages of this outbreak. The Minister has warm words about talking with his equivalent in Scotland but we need action on the ground. There are real difficulties now particularly with these sales coming along.

01:57:32 - 01:57:52

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the hon. Member for his question. I know that there was a very helpful briefing for parliamentarians in August led by my colleague Baroness Hayman. We're very happy to replicate that so that we fully understand the cross-border issues but I can assure him from the dispatch box that we continue to work across governments to ensure that our farmers are protected wherever they live in the United Kingdom.

01:57:52 - 01:58:28

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the new Minister to his role and thank our Defra PPSs for their typically diligent work in briefing us ahead of today. While taking part in the NFU's excellent food and farming fellowship, I've seen how precarious profit margins are for our livestock farmers both in Calder Valley and beyond. So can I please ask the Minister what steps we are going to take to support farmers managing the costs of bluetongue including vet bills, vaccinations and fallen stock disposal?

01:58:28 - 01:58:53

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my hon. Friend for his question and Defra is considering a whole range of measures to support the farming community. This includes supporting vaccination availability and expanding testing capacity as I mentioned earlier. We will continue to evaluate measures including the possibility of further financial support and this I believe is an incredibly important issue that the department is considering and certainly will respond to him in due course on further detail.

01:58:53 - 01:59:49

Danny Chambers

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We're in the middle of this outbreak and there's been a lot of vets and farmers about a couple of technical suggestions that could help us deal with this. Obviously rolling out vaccination as quickly as possible and secondly testing as quickly as possible. So firstly, bluetongue is classified under the special animal pathogens order in such a way that very few labs can continue testing at the moment. This means that not only is it slowing down the diagnosis of bluetongue but we can't test for other causes of abortion that farmers regularly need to test for.

And secondly, for those practices and wholesalers who have managed to secure vaccines from abroad, a lot of these labels will be in Spanish, Polish, German. Can we ensure that should English labeled product become available, they will not have to discard this perfectly good product because that'd be a huge financial loss.

01:59:49 - 02:00:14

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honorable member for his question, who brings real expertise on these issues with his background in veterinary science, and I want to pay tribute to all vets across the country that are supporting farmers at this difficult time. He's been corresponding with the department on various issues on blue tongue for quite some time, and I'm very grateful for the expertise that he's been feeding into Defra policy. I will take away the specific points that he raises and look into those matters and get back to him.

02:00:14 - 02:00:58

Julie Minns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I add to what my neighbor across the border has already said about the friction that we already experience with cross-border trade? Over the summer, I visited the country's largest sheep auction in my constituency, the largest for the whole country, and that trades right across the border. With the introduction of the zone in the southwest of Scotland, the restrictions that still exist on trade and what the auction house has to go through to be able to trade cattle and sheep from Scotland are frankly somewhat meaningless now. Can I please urge the government to work at pace with the Scottish government to get frictionless trade across the Scottish border?

02:00:58 - 02:01:17

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my honorable friend for her question. It was a real pleasure to visit Scotland over recess to talk to Scottish farmers about some of the issues and challenges that they face, and indeed some of those cross-border issues. So very alive to the issues that she describes, and very happy to work with her on the issues that she describes so we can find solutions as appropriate.

02:01:17 - 02:02:00

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the minister to his position? Farmers in Somerset and Devon are gravely concerned by this outbreak, as they're amongst the worst affected areas in the country. And I'm afraid that the government and his department have been asleep. He talks about increasing testing capacity, and yet this government has cut the money available for testing by 74% over the last 12 months.

And there are now reports that it's taking weeks for vaccines to reach farmers and vets who need them. So can the minister outline what the government is doing to ensure that those supplies reach those who so desperately need them?

02:02:00 - 02:02:34

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honorable member for his question. He would have been listening really carefully earlier to what I said in terms of the increased capacity at APHA, and indeed what we've been doing to work with industry to increase vaccine supply. I must stress the importance of vaccination and ensuring that farmers are kept informed of progress the government is making. The best way that they can do that is by looking at the regular updates on gov.uk, on social media, and at the disease alert services. There are weekly email updates to livestock keepers, and I'd encourage him to ensure that his constituents are receiving those emails.

02:02:34 - 02:03:49

Andrew Elliot Pakes

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I welcome the minister's actions over the summer, and firstly put on record my empathy and thanks to farmers and vets around the country who are dealing with this desperate situation on top of an already horrible year with harvest, the weather, and other challenges facing the farming community. I spoke to a farmer before this urgent question this morning in my constituency in Cambridgeshire, and we're looking across the border to Norfolk and other challenges that are happening there. There is a question around the speed, access to vaccines, and the speed of testing, and I'd urge the minister to speed that up. But to be honest, there's a bigger issue here. It's not a question of the immediate response, though that is important, but for far too long, Defra has been unprepared for the resilience we need to face biosecurity threats in this country.

We have had a decade of cuts which frankly isn't about what's happened this year, it's what we inherited and what Defra's budgets were treated by lots of previous governments in the past about its priority. Can he reassure me that as we face a changing climate and more likely of these instances, that the machinery of government in Defra will be up to the job for preparing these challenges so that farmers are supported in years to come when we face these risks?

02:03:49 - 02:04:22

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my honorable friend for his question and may I also pay tribute for his efforts and enthusiasm during his time as a Defra PPS, one of the best jobs in government is my view. He makes a number of really valid points from expertise working closely in the department and I will certainly take away the messages that I've heard from him today. My message to farmers in his community is simple: remain vigilant, monitor your animals closely and take up the vaccine and I will certainly take away the concerns that he's raised to make sure government's doing everything it possibly can.

02:04:22 - 02:05:06

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Livestock farmers in North Shropshire as everywhere else across the country have had a torrid, torrid year with drought impacting their ability to feed their livestock, dairy farmers selling milk at well less than the cost of production and now they have the added concern of bluetongue to bring a horrendous end to a horrendous year. They've been caught unawares and the department has clearly been unprepared for something that could have easily been predicted. So what support is he putting in place for those farmers now and more perhaps importantly, what steps will be taken for this time next year so that we don't find ourselves trying to get on top of a of an epidemic that could have been prevented in the first place?

02:05:06 - 02:05:33

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honorable member for her question. As I mentioned, Defra has long-standing arrangements in place to support outbreaks. There's always lessons we can learn from outbreaks but we are working really closely with industry, with farmers and with the NFU and others. We absolutely recognize the impact that bluetongue is having on farmers after what's been a very difficult summer and we are looking at everything we possibly can do to support them with the outbreak going forward.

02:05:33 - 02:06:11

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the minister to his place and I'm pleased to hear him promote vaccine uptake. Can he say a little more about the discussions he's having with the Scottish government to ensure that farmers, livestock keepers in Scotland are getting the vaccines they need? And given the pressure on the veterinary sector, can he assure the House that the reform of the Veterinary Surgeons Act is getting the attention that it deserves because that will not only support our veterinary surgeons and all those who work in the sector but also consumers?

02:06:11 - 02:06:31

Daniel Zeichner

I thank my honorable friend for her question. She will know that my colleague Baroness Hayman in the other place leads on a number of the areas that she describes but certainly I would take those messages back to her and very keen as I mentioned earlier to work with the devolved nations on the issues that we face in the farming community and very look forward to working with her on any issues and concerns that she has going forward.

02:06:31 - 02:07:03

David Reed

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Livestock farmers in Devon are facing this bluetongue outbreak in an already difficult time. They are meeting unexpected vaccination and fallen stock costs following a summer of drought while changes to APR and BPR are adding to concerns about farm finances and succession. Does the minister recognize that the financial impact of bluetongue cannot be considered in isolation and what assessment has he made of the cumulative pressures on farm cash flows this year?

02:07:03 - 02:07:33

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honorable member for his question and I mentioned earlier it was good to be in the South West to talk to farmers directly around their asks of government. We've put in place a number of actions following their asks, continue to work closely with the NFU and others to understand what might they further need. I do absolutely recognize the pressures that livestock keepers are under including financial pressures and indeed well-being pressures so there is support available for the sector but I will certainly take away his views and concerns back to the department.

02:07:33 - 02:08:21

Seamus Logan

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Perhaps in contrast to some other members, I want to commend the minister for the interest that he has shown in the issues affecting Scottish farmers, not least in my own constituency and the North East in general. And I also want to commend the excellent collaborative work that he's engaging in with the Scottish government. But I'm encouraged to hear in response to various members across the house that he said that he is looking at potential additional financial support, and there will be extra costs for farmers next year. I had the pleasure of a excellent coolcation in Kinlochbervie in the Highlands, and I can assure him it was a bumper season for midges this year, next year will be even more so.

So I would ask him to consider, if he is looking at additional financial support, please consider the Barnett consequentials for Scotland as well.

02:08:21 - 02:08:43

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. It was a real pleasure to visit his constituency during recess and thank him for those opportunities. I will take away the issues that he describes. You know, midges don't respect boundaries, so it's really important that we do work across boundaries on these issues and make sure that where possible we can have a coordinated approach.

02:08:43 - 02:09:53

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Mr Speaker. As my honourable friend from East Exeter and Exmouth has already alluded to, Devon has a huge issue with bluetongue cases, and in fact of the 795 cases, 334 of those, by far the highest number across the country, are in Devon, and one of those is new just this week. The minister will remember, I'm sure, that at one of his earlier visits to Westminster Hall around finance in farming, I invited him to come to visit Dartmoor. Now that was ostensibly about livestock numbers around the hill ponies and the future of farming on Dartmoor, but given this bluetongue outbreak, that invitation seems even more important now because Dartmoor is a key farming part of Devon itself. Now I invited him, I've invited him three times and not yet had a response, so I would just like to extend that invitation again, and you know, my farmers in South West Devon, that particular part of Dartmoor, would very much welcome a visit, and I would be grateful if he could respond to the letters that I've sent him over the last few months.

02:09:53 - 02:10:47

Charles Edward Robin Morello

I thank the honourable member for her question. She knows from my conversations with her face-to-face that very keen to visit Dartmoor and I'm sure we can make that possible as soon as the diary allows.

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Last week I was at the Melplash Agricultural Show and I extend an invitation to the minister to join me at next year's show. Farmers there raised all of the issues that have been mentioned already: testing time, vaccination availability and disposal costs. But one thing that they also raised is frustration with the fact that the government map of bluetongue is woefully out of date, possibly as much as a three-month lag. We know bluetongue is in Dorset, the map shows one confirmed case, but one farmer told me they know of at least five in the immediate area.

The map does not show suspected cases, it doesn't show where testing is undergoing, and the problem is that's causing other farmers to delay doing anything because they think it's not in their area yet. So please will the minister do something to speed up the updating of the map and show suspected cases and where testing is underway.

02:10:47 - 02:11:03

Daniel Zeichner

I thank the honourable member for his question. I mentioned at the outset the importance of communication with the livestock sector, that has included webinars, engagement events, disease alerts and information on gov.uk. I will take away the specific point with regards to the map and thank him for flagging that with me today so we can look into those issues.

02:11:03 - 02:11:46

David Mundell

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I once again restate the cross-border issue. Longtown in the honourable lady for Carlisle's constituency is one of the most important markets for livestock in the south of Scotland. So can he confirm specifically that he's addressing the issues that the National Farmers Union for Scotland have raised in relation to cross-border issues, and that includes the requirement relating to vaccination, testing and the return of animals to Scotland, the compatibility and recognition of vaccination records across the border, and the arrangements for animals that cannot meet vaccination requirements within the prescribed timescales.

02:11:46 - 02:11:48

Daniel Zeichner

I met with the NFU Scotland on my visit to Aberdeenshire in August. I will write to him on the specifics in terms of the actions that he's described and make sure we've got you a response, make sure the member's got a robust response.

I thank the honourable member for his question.

02:12:02 - 02:12:44

Ben Maguire

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My North Cornwall farmers have had the summer from hell. Bluetongue virus has decimated their herds and that's on top of a crushing drought. One North Cornwall farmer told me he's lost 40 of his sheep to bluetongue with no vaccine available when he needed it most. Seeing their animals suffer is hard enough, Mr. Speaker, without the huge associated costs of disposing of fallen livestock compounded by the financial loss of the animal itself.

So will the Minister back my call in my letter to him back on the 3rd of August and supported by the NFU of urgent financial assistance for farmers facing these extraordinary disposal costs?

02:12:44 - 02:13:08

Daniel Zeichner

I thank him for his question. As I mentioned earlier, Defra is considering a whole range of options to support the farming community. This includes support, vaccination availability and expanding testing capacity. We will continue to evaluate measures including the possibility of financial support and we do recognize this incredibly challenging time for the livestock community and we will do what we can to support them.

02:13:08 - 02:14:04

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the Minister very much for his positive answers and I think we should be encouraged by that. Although Northern Ireland have thankfully no reported cases of bluetongue, the Ulster Farmers' Union, and I declare an interest as a member of that, has issued an urgent warning that vaccine supplies are under severe pressure in GB with some major manufacturers completely out of stock. Given that DAERA at the Northern Ireland Assembly has rightly moved to a general license to allow our farmers to vaccinate, they cannot actually protect their herds if they cannot access the physical vaccine vials. So will the Minister assure this House that the government is working directly with pharmaceutical manufacturers to guarantee supply security and will the Minister commit to working closely with the Northern Ireland Assembly to ensure that our family farms are not left at the back of the queue for those vital BTV-3 vaccine supplies as the midges active season continues and gets even more short?

Thank you.

02:14:04 - 02:14:23

Speaker 123

Yes and yes.

02:14:23 - 02:14:34

Lindsay Hoyle

We now come to business questions, but can I say the reshuffle has left the old guard, the old team, so let us start off with Shadow Leader of the House, Jesse Norman.

02:14:34 - 02:14:38

Alexander Jesse Norman

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the Leader give the House the forthcoming business?

02:14:38 - 02:15:46

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Mr. Speaker. The business for the week commencing the 7th of September will include Monday the 7th of September, remaining stages of the Health Bill day one, Tuesday the 8th of September, conclusion of remaining stages of the Health Bill, Wednesday the 9th of September, second reading of the Civil Aviation Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform Bill, Thursday the 10th of September, second reading of the Social Housing Bill, Friday the 11th of September, private members' bills. The provisional business for the week commencing the 14th of September will include Monday the 14th of September, all stages of the Sovereign Grant Bill followed by a general debate subject to be announced, Tuesday the 15th of September, general debate on the potential merits of a full ban on fracking followed by a general debate on World Sepsis Awareness Month, the subject for these debates determined by the Backbench Business Committee. The House will rise for the conference recess at the conclusion of business on Tuesday the 15th of September and return on Monday the 12th of October.

02:15:46 - 02:19:54

Alexander Jesse Norman

Mr. Speaker, the past few weeks have brought news of the deaths of Dolly Parton, Tim Curry, and Wendell Berry. I'm sure many colleagues will share my sense of shock and sadness at the loss of these extraordinary figures, but also great thanks. Truly we live in a world of change. Rather unexpectedly, a new government, a new Prime Minister, and a reshuffle on the Treasury bench and among the opposition. But amid all this risk and uncertainty, I am delighted to say that there has been one beacon of stability, Mr. Speaker, one oasis of calm, one single unmoving axle at the still center of our politics.

I refer of course to the Leader of the House and myself. Each of us has emerged phoenix-like, blinking but resolute, from the ashes of political reconstruction. I rather fear that given our longevity and the level of banter on the other side of the dispatch box, Mr. Speaker, we will be seen over time as the Morecambe and Wise or perhaps the Two Ronnies of British politics. I won't invite the House to say which of us is which, but I will simply say to you, Mr. Speaker, and to all members returning from recess, it's hello from me and it's hello from him. Now to more serious matters.

I invite the Leader to clarify where the government stands on defense spending, given the different briefings and public challenges that the government and the Prime Minister have received over the last two weeks. But I also have two specific questions. The first is on restoration and renewal. The government's had since February to table a motion on this topic. In view of the new Prime Minister's spending priorities, it now seems highly unlikely that the ruinously expensive current plans will be put to this House before the end of this year.

Seven months have already passed with no action. Will the government now recognize the delay and use it to give the R and R team time to develop a sane and far less costly alternative? My second question is about an issue at the very heart of the new government: the status and functions of Number 10 North. As this House knows well, in our system of government, a Prime Minister may have political power, but Number 10 is not a spending department and it does not possess independent fiscal authority. Yet this new Prime Minister has insisted again and again that Number 10 North will not just be a paper exercise.

You see the difficulty, Mr. Speaker. Will Number 10 North have real spending powers of its own? If the answer is yes, then this will be a new kind of cross-departmental ministry, perhaps a territorial ministry like a regional government, but with no defined scope or mandate. We will need to see the legal instruments delegating Treasury authority and functions to it. After all, in this scenario, the Chancellor of the Exchequer will not be fully in charge of the public finances.

We will have to have new forms of accountability to this House, with a Number 10 North Select Committee and questions, so that members can press the First Secretary of State or perhaps the Prime Minister, as the ultimately responsible minister, should the spending decisions Number 10 North take turn out as they plan or indeed as they do not plan. But if the answer is no, and Number 10 North will not have spending power of its own, then ultimately the Treasury and the Chancellor will continue to sign off on its public spending and indeed on any taxing matters. Decentralization is really important, but Number 10 North will not be a means of decentralization in this scenario; it will be just another layer of government. It doesn't feel like the government has thought this issue through at all. So I'd be very grateful for answers to these questions, both now from the Leader of the House and in writing from the First Secretary of State.

02:19:54 - 02:26:51

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And let me begin by saying that I'm sure the thoughts of the whole House are with the people of Nepal and all those affected by the recent devastating flash floods, including the loved ones of 36 missing British nationals. As the Prime Minister said to the House on Tuesday, we will do everything we can to support British nationals impacted in the region and are working closely with the Nepalese authorities. Mr. Speaker, this summer has seen a significant number of wildfires which have affected many people. And I want to pay tribute to the emergency services who have been on the frontline of helping to tackle the blazes.

But also, Mr. Speaker, pay tribute and thank the farmers who have been very brave in their work to protect their livelihoods but indeed their whole communities. And I want to put on record our thanks to them. I also want to pay tribute, Mr. Speaker, to the two police officers who lost their lives in Cleveland, PC Blades and PC Cluff. They devoted their lives to the noblest form of public service, protecting their fellow citizens. Policing, Mr. Speaker, is not just a profession, it's a calling answered only by those who are willing to place themselves in harm's way to protect us all.

And I think also of their colleagues in uniform, not just, Mr. Speaker, in Cleveland, but across policing, who have lost friends, colleagues, and fellow members of the policing family. And as the Shadow Leader has said, we lost a great number of great people from across the world, not least in sport and entertainment. Billy Boston, Mr. Speaker, who I know you were a great admirer of, one of the greatest and most popular rugby league players of all time. Kevin Keegan, a football legend who played for Liverpool, Newcastle, and England and went on to manage the national side. But also, as the Shadow Leader has said, pay tribute to Dolly Parton.

Beyond her legacy as the Queen of Country Music, she will also be remembered through the work of her Imagination Library, which has provided seven million books to children here in the UK and helped children across the world discover a love of reading. Mr. Speaker, earlier this week the House heard from the new Prime Minister. His administration will oversee the rewiring of the British state, and I'll get on to what the specific that the right honourable gentleman raised in a moment, but also rebuilding the resilience of our communities and tackling the reindustrialisation of our regions. And later this year, our 10-year plan for Britain will set out plans for stronger public control over these essentials, making them work for people and places once again. I'm pleased, Mr. Speaker, as you are, that the Shadow Leader has survived the reshuffle, and I welcome him back to his place.

He was very generous in his offer to run my campaign to continue in my role, which was a very successful campaign on his part. I have to say I was very ready to reciprocate, but that proved unnecessary. But I'm genuinely pleased that he's, I'm not sure I'm genuinely pleased with the way that we were described, but I'm genuinely pleased that he's remained in his post because we do have our political differences, which is an obvious thing to say, but we do have a shared deep respect for this place, and I look forward to working with him going forward. I'm not sure that his suggestion that we're either Morecambe and Wise or the Two Ronnies, I think he flatters himself of a sense of humour in that case.

But we shall see, Mr Speaker, as we go on. He talks about defence spending. There is no confusion, as he seems to suggest, about defence spending. The Prime Minister set out clearly what our position is, and of course we'll have a budget in not too distant future which will set out clearly what those proposals are. The Prime Minister faced this House on Tuesday for three hours and 20 minutes and then came back to do Prime Minister's Questions yesterday, so there was no shortage of an opportunity for the opposition to find out exactly what this government is going to do.

In terms of R and R, he knows because we've talked about this before, of course there was a set of proposals put forward and we have thought deeply about when is the best time to bring forward those proposals. I don't think he should assume, Mr Speaker, that he will have to wait that much longer for this House to be given the opportunity to make a decision. I agree with him on one thing, which is that this decision has been delayed for too long and as a result there are costs to that delay which we're paying whether or not the House decides to do something in the long term about it or not. But I don't agree with him that the answer is another delay, that we go back and have another look at this again. We've been round that track so many times that it explains why we've actually got to this particular place.

And while I'm on that subject, Mr Speaker, it's very odd where a member of the shadow cabinet leaves in order to run for office and begin his support for London and criticise this side of the House when that side of the House, as far as I understand, are actually whipped against the restoration of this place, which is an iconic building, the iconic building actually in London. It's part of UNESCO World Heritage Site. It's work which is long overdue. It will create not only jobs and opportunities in London but throughout the regions of our country. So the opposition can't have it both ways.

In terms of Number 10 North, it's really important, Mr Speaker, that as the Prime Minister has said, that we pursue, in fact go further on the devolution agenda. And setting up Number 10 North is the biggest, will be the biggest transfer of power and decision making out of Whitehall in a generation. But I can assure you that the Chancellor of the Exchequer will be in charge of the nation's finances and he will set out, as I've said, his proposals on that. But having said that, it's important that we get decisions made closer to where those affect, those affected will feel that. But what I would say is I have some agreement with him on the point that he makes about scrutiny by this House, because I think there is an issue around, for example, how mayors are scrutinised actually.

But I think as power is transferred away and as decision making is transferred, it does raise the issue of how this House will continue to be able to scrutinise that. And I'll take that away and think about it more.

02:26:52 - 02:27:28

Valerie Vaz

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I ask the Leader of the House if we could have a debate in public time on the use, on the best use of public money? 50 million has been allocated for a free school which is against government policy and against the evidence. 38 million pounds has been drawn down by the Oak Academy Trust, which was set up under the COVID, so it's not clear why it's needed now and distorts the publishing market. And the contentious transaction of Walsall College to close Walsall Leather Museum.

None of this benefits my constituents who don't want any of this.

Could we have that debate on the best use of public money?

02:27:28 - 02:28:02

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, my honorable friend is a great champion of her local community and we've talked about before the issue of schools in her area. And this government is committed to empowering local leaders to take action and spend money where the community requires it. And they are the best judge of how that money should be spent. I will ensure that the relevant minister has heard her contribution. She may wish to seek a Westminster Hall debate to raise this, which I know the issue's been going on for quite some time, or if she wants to meet a minister, I'll help to arrange that.

02:28:02 - 02:29:52

Bobby Dean

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I also warmly welcome the Leader of the House back to his place? I believe that that makes him the longest continuous serving member of the Labour front bench of 20 years, and that's a remarkable achievement. I won't go into what I was doing 20 years ago because I'm sure he's got no interest in what I studied for my GCSEs. One of the stories that caught my eye over the summer was the sale of British success story EasyJet to a US private equity-backed investor.

That's going to create worry about jobs, fares, routes across Europe, but it also creates a worry for the British economy. We're going to see profits now move overseas. Now, acquisitions in and of themselves are not a bad thing. Sometimes they're a sign of positivity for British business. But what is worrying is the trend.

We're starting to see British businesses bought out by overseas investors again and again, and we're seeing people leave the London Stock Exchange at an alarming rate. And I think this is starting to become a problem for the resilience of the UK economy. Tate & Lyle, the famous sugar manufacturer, they were also sold to an overseas investor this summer, and three London-listed companies decided to leave the London Stock Exchange just this week. And so if the government shares my concern about this, they do have many levers available to address the issue. They could look at stock market regulation, they could look at competition regulation, they could look at taxation.

And I believe the time has come for us to have a proper debate in this House about this matter so that we can properly look into the details of those levers, which ones are the correct ones, and get a ministerial response on this matter. So could the Leader of the House organize for a debate about the future of UK businesses and the alarming trend of them being sold to overseas investors?

02:29:52 - 02:30:51

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, the government doesn't comment on individual firms' commercial decisions, but I do understand that some of the decisions that he's mentioned will cause concern to employees, but also in the case of EasyJet to travelers as well. We are working to reform UK capital markets to make it easier for companies to raise capital, to go public, and to grow. And we do have some of the most innovative businesses in the world and the most talented leaders and entrepreneurs of any nation. We do continue to work closely with business groups and industry leaders to understand the pressures facing industry and develop measures to support them, including the ones that he listed there. There will be an opportunity to debate these matters, I'm sure, up to but also particularly around the budget.

But it is also possible that the Liberal Democrats can ask for one of their opposition days in which they might want to choose this as a topic. It's entirely up to them.

02:30:51 - 02:31:51

Josh Newbury

Thank you, thank you very much, Ma'am. And can I welcome my right honorable friend to his place once again? Now, recent comments by an elected, recently elected Reform councillor in my area caused great offense when he attacked in quite a horrible way women who have abortions. Now, it's not acceptable that people should use their platforms in that way. Of course there are different points of view about abortion.

But can he encourage the Leader to reaffirm the consensus in our country, either it's perfectly legal, reasonable, and responsible for women to pursue that particular course of action? And does he think that there's an opportunity in the future where we can continue to reaffirm the views of all of us?

And finally, will he say that it's not appropriate for people to use elected position to make people feel deeply uncomfortable because of personal choices, often painful, which they've made?

02:31:51 - 02:32:32

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm happy to reaffirm, as my honorable friend has said, what the government's view is on these matters. In terms of comments by a particular councillor, and they often, Madam Speaker, become clearer and more noticeable and even more abhorrent once they are elected. And we often see the true nature of some of the people, and I have to say, not least amongst Reform councillors. They do not represent the view of right-minded people, and councillors are there to represent the whole community, not to represent just those who may share their abhorrent views.

02:32:32 - 02:32:35

Lindsay Hoyle

Backbench Business Committee Chairperson, Bob Blackman.

02:32:35 - 02:36:26

Bob Blackman

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the leader for announcing the backbench business debates for Tuesday the 15th. The business in Westminster Hall that the Backbench Business Committee has agreed will include on Tuesday the 8th of September a debate on the safety of the Jewish community. On Thursday the 10th of September, debates on reform in the vascular sector, followed by a debate on contribution of fathers and positive male role models to families and society. And on Tuesday the 15th, there'll be a debate on building safety remediation of residential buildings. And indeed, when we come back, Madam Deputy Speaker, after the conference recess, we are planning ahead, that on Tuesday the 13th of October, there'll be a debate on the future of the UK coach industry.

And on Thursday the 15th, debates on support for unpaid carers and also a debate on progress towards a smoke-free UK. Now, I would just gently ask the leader to consider what time will be made available in the chamber for the Backbench Business Committee for the week we come back, and hopefully he'll be able to announce that next week. That week is Baby Loss Awareness Week. Now, he will recall that the last debate we had on this had protected time, but was held on a Monday when we came back and started very late in the day, and individuals were bravely giving their stories late into the night, which I think we all agree is unacceptable. We would like to programme that debate for the Thursday we come back, if it's possible, but obviously we understand constraints on government accordingly.

Can I also advise the leader to use his good offices? The Backbench Business Committee consists of eight members. We are holding a Labour vacancy following the member for Harlow's promotion, but that has not been replaced. I'm also aware that two of our members are potentially going off onto other parliamentary duties, and indeed our Liberal Democrat member has not been able to attend because of accidental damage to his leg, which has caused him grave difficulty. We have a quorum of four.

So this is giving me real concern about us, our ability to meet and make decisions. So can I gently ask that we do the appropriate things? Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, young people go back to school in the not too distant future, and it is welcome that those on low incomes will be receiving free school meals. But there is a problem. During the term time, that's not an issue.

The leader of Harrow Council has written to me and to the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions regarding what happens during school holidays. Previously, under arrangements for Harrow Council, I suspect many other local authorities across the country, that has meant that the continuation of those free school meals has continued. However, we understand that the rules and regulations around this have changed under the Crisis and Resilience Fund that allegedly local authorities will now have to individually decide who gets support and who doesn't. That to me, and I suspect most members of the House, doesn't seem acceptable. This should be done on a basis so that children who potentially could go hungry over Christmas should not be in that position.

So could the leader arrange for a statement to be made on the floor of the House next week on the position of this so they can make sure that those children of parents that are low paid are able to secure their necessary food.

02:36:26 - 02:38:18

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed. First of all, may I thank the honorable gentleman for his work and the work of his committee and I'll take away what he says about vacancies on that committee and make sure that we fill them as quickly as possible so that he can depend upon there being at least a quorum at his meetings. Thank him for updating the House on what the topics are going to be going forward. He will know with regard to business loss, baby loss, that I do refer to that quite a lot because I do recall that very well and he will know that I was extremely concerned about that and have tried since to do everything that we can to ensure that that doesn't happen again or indeed other similar topics are given a proper time and a proper place to do that. And I will take that away and I will see if we can make sure that that happens.

In terms of the issue that he raises about children in his patch, he will know that they do return to school, but they also return to school with help from this government. Their parents were helped with the cost of uniforms. We do have free school meals have been extended and there has been help for travel costs as well. The government is always looking to help families where there is a cost of living issue. And I will take away his concerns because I've heard them from my constituency as well about what happens during term time is great, but what happens for some families outside of those times.

Let me take them away and refer it to colleagues to see what further help we can provide.

02:38:18 - 02:39:01

Josh Newbury

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The British Medical Journal has reported that 406 million pounds allocated by universities to NHS trusts in England between 2020 and 2023 for medical student training remains unaccounted for and some trusts admit they don't know how that money was spent at all. This is a huge failure on the part of the party opposite, which also presided over sluggish growth in medical school places and a service-wide workforce crisis. Given the seriousness of these findings, will the leader grant a debate on transparency and accountability in NHS training so we can be confident that all of the money set aside to train the world-leading doctors of tomorrow will be spent properly.

02:39:01 - 02:40:04

David Mundell

We are, the government is fixing the problem. We did introduce the Medical Training Prioritisation Act, which has had an impact. Competition ratios have halved, prioritised doctors have filled 98 percent of roles and in some specialties like general practice all posts have been filled by prioritised doctors. But he is right to continue to raise these matters and to campaign on them and I'd urge him to apply for a Westminster Hall debate so that he can hear directly from ministers.

...ing of the Prime Minister on his appointment. Can we have a debate, Madam Deputy Speaker, in government time on the operation of the DVSA? My constituent Fiona Reid advises me that her daughter has sought to get a practical driving test in Dumfries and Galloway and has not been able to secure one before the end of January. She's also tried to get an appointment in Carlisle and has not been able to do so. Driving for young people in rural areas like mine is not a luxury.

It is an important part of being able to get a job and social interaction. So could we have that debate and get an improvement in their service?

02:40:04 - 02:40:34

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, as ever the right honourable gentleman raises an important issue for his rural constituents. We have taken measures to improve the situation, stamping out the resale of tests, limiting changes to bookings and location to stop bots, and doubling the number of permanent examiner trainers, but there is still in some areas a great deal of work to be done. I will make sure that the Transport Secretary has heard his specific concerns and urge the Minister to write to him.

02:40:34 - 02:41:14

Clive Efford

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I say to my right honourable friend in welcoming him back to his post that not all the rewiring of the new government is welcome? I understand that the Cabinet Office intends to move responsibility for the Infected Blood Compensation Authority to a Minister in the Lords. Now, we all have constituents that are raising serious concerns about that process, and we want to be able to come to this House and hold to account the Minister responsible for that agency. So can I urge my right honourable friend to take this matter up with the Cabinet Office, but if they are intended to do this, can we have a statement?

02:41:14 - 02:41:38

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I would just try to reassure my honourable friend that even though ministerial responsibility might change, there will still be departmental ministerial responsibility for really important matters like this in this place, and we will continue to have an opportunity indeed to question, but also to request statements from Ministers who are accountable to this House.

02:41:38 - 02:42:28

Tessa Munt

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like others, one of my constituents has inherited responsibility for a retirement property on the death of the resident. It's been on the market since 2022, incurring annual costs of about £14,000: a falling sale value, ground rent, service charges, council tax, and an exit fee. Whilst the landlord forbids subletting, even though it's renting out its own properties on the same site, there's also an over-55 residency restriction, so neither the beneficiaries nor their adult children, who are struggling to get onto the property ladder, can live in the property. Would the Leader of the House ask his ministerial colleagues to look at the protections for families trapped by retirement housing leases, including the cost elements I referred to earlier, including the huge service charges on empty properties, empty home council tax, and age restrictions for occupants?

02:42:28 - 02:42:36

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll draw to the attention of the relevant Minister the points that the honourable lady makes and make sure that they get back to her on those important matters.

02:42:36 - 02:43:07

Julie Minns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Inspired by the experience of club member Liam Burns, Carlisle Golf Club members have raised a whopping £54,000 for Prostate Cancer UK in their Big Golf Race. Liam himself stands atop the individual leaderboard and the club is £20,000 more, has raised £20,000 more than the second-placed club. Will the Leader of the House please join me in congratulating Liam Burns and all the members of Carlisle Golf Club on a truly amazing round?

02:43:07 - 02:43:18

Lucy Maria Powell

I will indeed join my honourable friend in congratulating Liam Burns and everyone associated with the Big Golf Race. I thank them for raising so much money for such a worthy cause.

02:43:18 - 02:43:56

John Glen

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

It's 55 days till the budget, and given the market's reaction to the Prime Minister's statement on Tuesday and the gilt rates that are higher than our peers in the G7, could we have a debate on the implications of higher taxes for growth? Because I think the country's very concerned that given the Prime Minister says he's going to stick to the previous Prime Minister's borrowing rules, we're in grave risk of higher taxes which are going to damage the problem that he's trying to fix.

02:43:56 - 02:44:46

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The right honourable gentleman will have to wait for the budget for some of the reassurances that he seeks. But I would gently point out to him, and he should know given the experiences of the job that he did in government, that there are international pressures on inflation, concerns about inflation, for example. There's also competition for money to invest in things like AI around the world. So there are international pressures, but the difference between this government and some others in comparable situations is that the rates that he's talking about are the direct result of the Liz Truss budget.

And we're still, we are still living with that, businesses are still living with that, and households are still living with that with higher than necessary mortgages.

02:44:46 - 02:45:31

Nick Smith

Madam Deputy Speaker, this summer wildfires raged across South Wales and other parts of the UK. On Monday, our emergency services received a thousand telephone calls. Our South Wales Fire and Rescue Service worked tirelessly alongside firefighters from across the UK. The Royal Logistics Corps, councils, and Welsh Water staff, farmers and residents all gave a helping hand in Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney. Ahead of the National Wildfire Summit, will the government please provide a statement on support for areas such as the South Wales Valleys and the steps being taken to improve preparedness and reduce the risk of fires in the future?

02:45:31 - 02:46:03

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, and I join my honourable friend in thanking everyone involved in tackling the fires, the emergency services, the farmers, and indeed local residents. The government is spending around 100 million pounds to strengthen the country's response to wildlife, to wildfires and extreme weather. And as he points out, we will be chairing the Wildfire Summit in the autumn to consider how national response capabilities can be strengthened across the UK. And I'm sure that ministers will want to continue to update the House on any further developments.

02:46:03 - 02:46:45

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Far too many communities across the country are blighted by travellers and gypsies who seek to circumvent the planning system and build without seeking permission first. I've got two instances in my patch in Dodford and Hagley. Does the Leader of the House agree with me that there should not be a two-tier approach in the planning system? And will he allow for a debate in government time on strengthening the planning system so that councils get the power that they need to resolve this?

And will he stress to his colleague, the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, that she should not have removed the powers that local councils have to prevent such development on environmental damage grounds?

02:46:45 - 02:47:00

Lucy Maria Powell

Residents won't expect a two-tier system, Madam Deputy Speaker, and as the honourable gentleman is right to point out, there is a statement following on housing. I don't know whether the points that he raises will be in the scope of that, but he might want to raise it directly with the minister.

02:47:00 - 02:47:06

Tessa Munt

Valerie Vaz. Forgive me, I'm losing myself. Callum Anderson.

02:47:06 - 02:47:40

Callum Anderson

Madam Deputy Speaker, over the summer recess I had the pleasure of visiting the Florence Nightingale hospice charity shop in Winslow, which celebrated 25 years in the town. In that time, hardworking volunteers and local people have helped raise over 1.5 million pounds for the hospice.

So will the leader join me in congratulating and thanking local people on this achievement? And might he consider making government time for a general debate on how we can deliver a secure future for our hospice sector, especially as they provide such compassionate care at the most difficult of times?

02:47:40 - 02:48:10

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I certainly join my honorable friend in congratulating the Florence Nightingale charity shop on its 25th anniversary and to thank all the volunteers for their dedicated service. We are committed to supporting the hospice sector and have provided 125 million pounds of capital funding as a boost to them. I would encourage my honorable friend to apply for Westminster Hall on these matters because I know there is agreement across the house on the importance of hospices and what further can be done to support them.

02:48:10 - 02:49:03

Danny Chambers

Danny Chambers. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I spent the summer visiting all the villages outside of Winchester in the rural areas. And the one thing that was very, the common theme that came up was the speed limits and the speed of traffic that goes through small villages at 60 miles an hour. All these villages, including Littleton, Crawley, Hambledon, and Droxford, all of them want to be able to decide whether they have a 30 mile an hour speed limit in their village, yet Hampshire County Council won't even consider it, including ones that have self-funded traffic calming measures, they don't have permission to instigate them.

Would the minister consider granting a debate on how with all these local government reforms and devolution, how we can empower local communities to set their own speed limits in their own villages?

02:49:03 - 02:49:34

Lucy Maria Powell

We're very much in favor of local communities having more power over the decisions that affect them most. The government did introduce a road safety strategy last year, but of course it comes down to local authorities. I hope that his local authority has heard, Madam Deputy Speaker, what he has said today and responds positively to residents in that area. If they don't, then he might want to come back with a Westminster Hall debate to raise it still further and see what more government could do to help him.

02:49:34 - 02:50:12

Lee Anderson

Lee Ingram. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know the Leader of the House agrees with me that pubs are such an important part of British culture, especially in towns and rural villages, often acting as crucial community hubs. And the Oxleathers pub in my constituency of Stafford, Eccleshall and the villages is the only pub from the West Midlands to be shortlisted in the PubAid Pub Hero Awards. I welcome the government's recent announcement of business rates cuts to pubs for hospitality venues.

So would the leader agree to a debate, please, on the importance of government support for pubs, especially in rural towns and villages?

02:50:12 - 02:50:41

Lucy Maria Powell

My honorable friend is a real champion for her local area and I pay tribute to her for that. I want to absolutely join her in congratulating the Oxleathers pub for being shortlisted for the PubAid Community Pub Hero Award. Pubs do bring our communities together. I would encourage her to seek a Westminster Hall debate because I know pubs are of importance to members across the house because they're such an important part of our local communities.

02:50:41 - 02:51:10

Liam Kerr

Liam Thompson. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. During recess, I had the pleasure of visiting the Counseling House charity in my constituency, who are doing excellent work providing mental health counseling to young people and families free at the point of use against a backdrop of savage cuts from the SNP-run Aberdeen City Council. So could the government bring forward a debate in government time to discuss the important issue of young people's mental health and how we can move it onto a more sustainable future going forward?

02:51:10 - 02:51:32

Lucy Maria Powell

The honorable gentleman will know this is a really important matter for the government and we are making progress in all sorts of ways, but I accept that there is further progress to be made. He may wish to either go to the backbench business or indeed through a Westminster Hall debate to raise these matters himself, though the government does update the house when necessary on these matters.

I repeat, as I've done before, they've had the best settlement ever. It's just not appropriate that they don't fund the services which are of such critical importance to his constituents.

02:51:32 - 02:52:24

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have several constituents who are retired civil servants and they are still waiting to receive their pension statements and indeed their actual pensions. Now, this is causing a lot of worry, distress and in some cases financial hardship. What is deeply concerning for me, though, is that when this is raised with Capita, they are pretty laid back about it and frankly showing little empathy or any urgency in trying to resolve these matters. So can I press the Leader of the House that we can get a government statement that will set out concrete steps that it will take, and in my view to relieve Capita of these responsibilities, but more importantly to ensure that my constituents can begin to receive their pensions that many have given tens of years of service to this country.

They deserve to be paid and treated with respect.

02:52:24 - 02:53:06

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, my honourable friend will know from the support across the House really on these matters that the service levels following the move to Capita have just been completely unacceptable. And the government's priority has been to stabilise service and give former civil servants who rightly need to be treated better the service that they deserve. But I understand the strong feelings. He might want to raise that again at Cabinet Office questions next week, Madam Deputy Speaker, but the government and the department has not been shy in coming forward on statements to the House about what remains a very difficult issue.

02:53:06 - 02:53:42

Robbie Moore

Madam Deputy Speaker, within the Worth Valley, we are on the cusp of getting our household waste and recycling centre reopened at Sugden End, which has been causing huge levels of concern, fly-tipping increases and long waits at Royd Ings Avenue in Keighley. But we are yet to hear anything about the household waste and recycling centre that was also closed under Labour-run Bradford Council in 2024 and yet for a solution in Ilkley. So could we have a debate in this House about the importance of household waste and recycling centres and taxpayers getting a decent level of service from their local authority?

02:53:42 - 02:54:02

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, recycling and fly-tipping, these are important matters for local residents and the honourable gentleman is right to raise concerns on behalf of his constituents. He might want to seek a Westminster Hall debate to hear from the relevant minister what the government's approach is because we're doing stuff on fly-tipping, but there is more to be done.

02:54:02 - 02:54:36

Adam Jogee

Madam Deputy Speaker, last weekend people from across Newcastle-under-Lyme and further afield came together for the Newcastle-under-Lyme Jazz Festival 2026. My wife and I enjoyed several acts. It was a brilliant date night spread over three days for Mr. Jogee and me and it was especially good to see, despite the liquid sunshine, all our town has to offer. So will the Leader join me in paying tribute to Newcastle BID, to all the businesses involved, the artists who performed and all those local people who turned up? And will he come and see us next year?

I'll get the first round in at one of our brilliant pubs.

02:54:36 - 02:54:53

Lucy Maria Powell

I'm happy to congratulate everybody involved in the Newcastle-under-Lyme Jazz Festival, all the organisers, the businesses and everyone else. I think it's a great boost for towns and cities when festivals such as this are held. I look forward to being a success in the future and I'll think about his invite very carefully.

02:54:53 - 02:55:33

Ben Maguire

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Since my election, I've been campaigning for a new GP surgery building in the fast-growing town of Bodmin, which is set to receive more than 3,000 new homes by 2030. The current building is already running at around 160% capacity, yet the clear and urgent need is not being met by our local ICB, who are dragging their heels in the extra costs required to get shovels in the ground. As we know with restoration in this place, further delays mean build costs go up.

Will the leader of the house assist me in securing an urgent meeting with the health minister to help bridge this funding gap and finally deliver the new GP building.

02:55:33 - 02:56:01

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I understand the point that the honorable gentleman has made about where necessary house building takes place. It's really important that we get the infrastructure in place and the government is very aware of that. We did announce quite recently more diagnostic centers for local areas and they are very welcome. But there is a statement after this one, Madam Deputy Speaker, which the housing minister will be there. He may wish to raise these matters directly with him.

02:56:01 - 02:56:25

Nick Symonds

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Danielle lost her husband Chris in a road traffic collision in 2024. She was left studying to become a nurse and with three children to care for and found the bereavement support payment system to be wholly inadequate to give her the support that she needed. So will the leader of the house ask the relevant DWP minister to write to me about this matter and can we have a debate on it please.

02:56:25 - 02:56:39

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, let me pay tribute to the work of my right honorable friend and the diligent way in which he stands up for his constituents. These are concerning matters that he raises. I will get the relevant minister to write to him as he asks.

02:56:39 - 02:57:14

David Reed

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We all know the Prime Minister is a strong supporter of devolution and we understand that big changes are now underway in Devon. But before Devon embarks on one of the biggest changes to local government in a generation, local people deserve to know what their new mayor would do, what their mandate would be, how much it would all cost and how they'd work with the new unitary authority. Now, when we've asked the government for questions we've received very little information back. So will the leader of the house please ask the responsible minister to meet with Devon MPs to discuss this in detail.

02:57:14 - 02:57:32

Lucy Maria Powell

Yes, I will indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker, do that because it's important. We recognize that not all of the country is covered by devolution in the way that the Prime Minister has set out. It's important that no area is left behind and I will seek to arrange the meeting which he requests.

02:57:32 - 02:58:10

Kate Samantha Dixon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm beyond pleased that Chester North and Neston will be hosting this year's World Town Crier Tournament at the end of this month. I'm sure that with the talent, showmanship and sheer vocal power of this year's contestants who hail from 15 UK towns and eight nations, audiences will be able to hear their cries of Oyez from our city's Roman walls and beyond. Will the leader of the house join with me in raising his voice to wish all 25 contestants the best of luck.

02:58:10 - 02:58:57

Lucy Maria Powell

Much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker, and let me also pay tribute to my honorable friend who did a fantastic job as a minister and is a great champion for her fine city. I will join her in her excitement in welcoming the World Town Crier Tournament. Its question is exceptionally timely given that one of the earliest surviving records of town criers in the UK is in fact part of the Bayeux Tapestry brought home yesterday to such fanfare. So I wish all of the contestants, all of the contestants in her competition all the very best of luck.

02:58:57 - 02:59:42

Alice Macdonald

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I share a love of poetry with my dad, which is why I was delighted to host an event yesterday to spread the word about a free initiative he's involved in and I'm very grateful to you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for dropping in. Poetry Together brings children and older people together to perform and share poetry. At a time when loneliness and social isolation affects people across generations, simple initiatives like this can give people of different ages a reason to meet, talk and form connections that might otherwise never happen. With World Poetry Day just a few weeks away, can I ask the leader if we can have a debate on the role of intergenerational projects in tackling loneliness and encourage him and members across the house to get schools and older people groups across their constituencies involved in this initiative.

02:59:42 - 03:00:14

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, it seems like a timely opportunity for her to seek a debate on these matters given what is coming up. But let me pay tribute to her and to indeed her father for this initiative and the work that they are doing. It is so important that we have ways of tackling inclusion and tackling loneliness and I wish them all the very best in that. But let her remind her, let me remind her very gently that the new Prime Minister has confessed to being a poetry addict as well.

03:00:14 - 03:00:47

Richard Burgon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Further to the request from my honourable friend the member for Battersea earlier, can I really push the government for a debate on the progress of the government's measures to tackle the ongoing failure of Capita to effectively administer civil service pensions. But can I also urge the government to publish the advice of Grant Thornton on a secondary recovery plan now that Capita's own internal deadline for sorting it out has also been passed. It's been raised by my constituents, it's been raised by people across the country and by the PCS union and it'd be great to see some progress on that.

03:00:47 - 03:01:09

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, as I said to our honourable friend before, the government takes this very seriously. There are Cabinet Office questions next Thursday, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend might want to raise that matter there. But I sense the feeling across the House. The government has updated the House on developments, but let me go away and see if another update is required.

03:01:09 - 03:01:48

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When the power fails, the electricity supplier provides generators. When the water fails, they provide water. But when the data switches off, silence. My community of Bloxwich had over a week before Openreach even bothered to reach out.

They couldn't access their GPs, they couldn't access important business calls, personal calls. And data is now critical infrastructure like power and water. And in the event of conflict, we know that interference with the data is likely, more likely than boots on the ground. So can we have a ministerial statement or a debate in the House on the resilience of our critical information infrastructure.

03:01:48 - 03:02:09

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I hope that Openreach have heard what the honourable lady has said and I agree absolutely on the importance of data in our modern lives. The government takes this matter very seriously as it takes the matter of resilience very seriously and indeed is doing some in-depth work on how we can improve that situation going forward and at the appropriate time I'm sure they'll want to bring forward any further proposals to the House.

03:02:09 - 03:02:12

Eleanor Laing

Dr Peter Princely, you're not in your normal seat.

03:02:12 - 03:02:38

Peter Richard Prinsley

I apologise, Madam Deputy Speaker. So I have this morning met with Julie, the mother of Heather, whose tragic death was featured in the Channel 4 Dirty Business program. She is an incredible campaigner. Now in all of the debates and discussions about the terrible state of the water companies, does the Leader agree with Julie and with me that public health must be our top priority in this House.

03:02:38 - 03:03:02

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, yes I do. And in terms of clean water, I'm not going to rehearse all the arguments about how we've actually got to this situation which has been a national disgrace, Madam Deputy Speaker. But I can reassure my honourable friend that for both the Defra Secretary but also the Prime Minister, water is one of our top priorities.

03:03:02 - 03:03:39

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Transplant World Cup is taking place between the 13th and the 18th of September in Frankfurt. Now all the players have had a transplant, whether that be organ, stem cell or bone marrow. Now my constituent Philip Taylor is the goalkeeper coach for the England team. And the England team are really hoping for a triple victory because they've won the Transplant Football Euros and the Transplant Football Four Nations.

So I would just ask the Leader of the House if he will wish them luck in their endeavour and reiterate how important it is about donations and transplants to saving lives and living a fruitful one thereafter.

03:03:39 - 03:04:09

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I congratulate the honourable lady on her new role in the shadow administration. I do reiterate how important it is transplants are, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I hope that people listening to this have heard what she has said.

I wish the England team all the very best. I congratulate them on their success so far. I wish them luck in the games that are coming up, and should they win that, maybe there are some lessons for the England national team to learn from that.

03:04:09 - 03:04:52

Navendu Mishra

Madam Deputy Speaker, in my constituency of Stockport, particularly in Portwood and Edgeley, residents are increasingly concerned by the impact of over-concentration of houses in multiple occupation. Too many communities have been left feeling powerless as family homes are lost and local services come under strain with increased traffic congestion and parking pressures. Local authorities need stronger planning and licensing powers alongside adequate funding to manage the concentration of HMOs and protect the character of residential neighbourhoods. As such, will the Leader of the House allow time for a debate on further powers and resources to help councils regulate HMOs effectively and mitigate their impact on local communities?

03:04:52 - 03:05:32

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed. As my honourable friend points out, local authorities do have planning powers to limit the proliferation of HMOs, and I would suggest that my honourable friend might want to raise this matter in a statement which is about to take place. But local authorities do have powers, but I would encourage them to use those powers, Madam Deputy Speaker. We keep regulations under review, but it's not always a case of more power being needed, but the power that exists actually being used better by local authorities, including his local authority. This is a matter that concerns members across the House.

A Westminster Hall debate, it seems to me, would be an appropriate opportunity to discuss these matters further.

03:05:32 - 03:06:14

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was pleased to support Georgie Newbery from Common Farm Flowers in Charlton Musgrove, also representing Flowers from the Farm, to secure a dedicated SIC code for flower farming, which was launched at the Chelsea Flower Show earlier this year. It recognises the contribution of flower farms in creating jobs, driving rural growth, and enhancing biodiversity, but full implementation won't happen until 2031. So can the Leader of the House help me secure a meeting with the relevant minister to discuss how SIC codes are reviewed and how we can accelerate the rollout for flower farming and other horticultural sectors?

03:06:14 - 03:06:18

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I agree with the honourable lady about the importance of flower farmers and the importance of horticulture, not least because of the opportunities for jobs, Madam Deputy Speaker, so I will help to arrange the meeting that she requests.

03:06:18 - 03:06:51

Jonathan Pearce

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This Saturday marks International Day of Charity. In High Peak, we are incredibly lucky to have so many charities and volunteers supporting our communities, from Connex Community Support in Buxton, New Mills Volunteer Centre, and Little Cherubs in Chapel. On Friday, I'll be hosting an event to say thank you to all of those amazing charities. Will the Leader of the House make time in government time for a debate on how we value volunteering and charities and how we can better support them?

03:06:51 - 03:07:17

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I certainly join my honourable friend in celebrating the important work of local charities? As I've often said on these occasions, charities and community organisations are the golden thread that run through our communities. I'd encourage him to seek a Westminster Hall debate so that not just he but other members and indeed ministers can say thank you to local volunteers and charities because they do such important work.

03:07:17 - 03:07:47

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My residents feel badly let down by Royal Mail. Across the summer, many residents have not had a delivery for three or more weeks.

Some constituents have been to the sorting office to collect time-sensitive post, to be told that there are still sacks of mail waiting to be sorted and there's nothing for them to collect. So can we have a debate in government time on how this government is going to hold Royal Mail to account for the license it holds?

03:07:47 - 03:08:19

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, we have been very clear that the Royal Mail service is unacceptable. As the honorable gentleman points out, a well-run postal service is one of the things that constituents expect. The Business and Trade Committee have called in Royal Mail to talk about their performance. I hope, because I know that Royal Mail do listen to these sessions, I hope that they've heard what he's said, and the government stands ready in future to make sure that we get the service from Royal Mail that the honorable gentleman is asking for.

03:08:19 - 03:09:02

Mohammad Yasin

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Thousands of my constituents in Bedford and Kempston have signed petitions following the loss of the 7, 10, 53, and 53A bus routes and cuts to the 3, 4, 5, and 8. For many older and vulnerable residents, these services are lifelines, and many now feel isolated and abandoned. Will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on how government can support councils and communities to use the powers and funding this government has provided them to develop locally-led solutions, such as a community interest model, to restore these vital services?

03:09:02 - 03:09:36

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There's been a three billion pound boost to bus services for millions of people across the country. The government has capped bus fares to two pounds from 2027, and the Buses Act will let local leaders take back control of those services. I hope that local leaders will take advantage of that because, as my honorable friend knows, the Prime Minister is particularly interested in good bus services because he realizes that interconnectivity is so important for people, particularly about getting to work.

03:09:36 - 03:10:08

Jim Shannon

Madam Deputy Speaker, each week I usually bring an individual religious persecution issue, but this week I wish to bring forward a collective request. Will the Leader of the House ask the Foreign Secretary to make a statement on the disturbing findings of the Pew Research Center's latest report on the worsening state of global freedom of religion or belief across all of the world, and what steps the government of this United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland are taking to uphold freedom of religion or belief as an intrinsic and non-negotiable human right in their foreign policy? Thank you.

03:10:08 - 03:10:47

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's good to see the honorable gentleman back in his place and good to see him in these sessions, of which he is a consistent attendee, and I thank him for that. Madam Deputy Speaker, as ever, he raises a very serious issue. Last year, we launched our freedom of religion and belief strategy, focusing our efforts to drive positive change. We continue to raise our concerns directly with countries where violations occur and work with international partners to defend this fundamental human right. I'll make sure that FCDO hear his concerns and see if he can get the update which he seeks.

03:10:47 - 03:11:17

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've been supporting the excellent North Staffordshire Pensioners Convention in their campaign for an older person's commissioner who would champion later life issues. This is also a recommendation by the Work and Pensions Select Committee in their report for pensioner poverty and the APPG for ageing and older people's report on older people's rights. So would the Leader of the House make time in government time for a debate on the need for an older person's commissioner in England?

03:11:17 - 03:11:46

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, given the Speaker's introduction at the beginning of this session, I think that I may well be a candidate either to be a commissioner for an older person or indeed the beneficiary from having a commissioner for an older person. It is an interesting idea, Madam Deputy Speaker. There is a campaign for a commissioner for older people of an ageing in England, and it's an important campaign. I would encourage her to seek a Westminster Hall debate to further develop her arguments and to hear directly from ministers.

03:11:44 - 03:12:21

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can we have a statement on the closure of post offices? When York's Crown Post Office was closed after 138 years and moved into WHSmith, we were given assurances that that was a long-term solution. And now that we have Modella Capital private equity buying out WHSmith, we have seen the closure of WHSmith on our high street and 150 across the country, meaning that we're going to lose our post office once again. So can we have a statement to make sure we secure the jobs, but also the services to my residents and businesses?

03:12:21 - 03:12:51

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend will have heard from the murmurs behind that this is not just a matter for her constituency. It's a matter for others too. It's an important point and she's right to raise them. The government's priority is to maintain the current size of the post office network and ensure that communities continue to have access to post office services.

And I will make sure that the relevant minister hears what she has said today and writes to her with an update on what further steps can be taken.

03:12:51 - 03:13:22

Chris Bloore

Madam Deputy Speaker, with Redditch suffering the worst mental health illness rates in Worcestershire and with child referrals doubling over the last five years, I'm sure the Leader of the House will join me in welcoming the government's intention to spend 343 million pounds on opening 100 community walk-in mental health centres and 59 emergency mental health centres in our hospitals. Would the Leader of the House add his weight to my campaign to ensure that our local ICB makes sure the money goes where it's needed most, which means a centre in Redditch?

03:13:22 - 03:13:47

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for raising such an important matter. The government has recruited almost 8,700 mental health workers and we're dedicated to ensuring that communities are able to access mental health support when they need it. In terms of the application for his particular constituency, all I can say that I will raise the points that he has raised today and highlight his campaign with the relevant health minister.

03:13:47 - 03:14:31

Warinder Juss

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I had the opportunity to visit the Women and Families Resource Centre in my constituency of Wolverhampton West, who last year delivered well over 6,000 essential items to support over 1,000 vulnerable children and women facing poverty, trauma and social isolation. So will the Leader of the House please join me in commending the centre for the vital support that it provides to disadvantaged and deprived communities in Wolverhampton? And can he also reassure the charities in my constituency that this government will continue to invest in early intervention and preventative grassroots support services so families can have the stability that they need to build secure independent futures?

03:14:31 - 03:15:01

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I certainly join my honourable friend in commending the outstanding work of the Women and Families Resource Centre in Wolverhampton West. Delivering essential items to support more than a thousand vulnerable women and children is a testament to the extraordinary dedication of its staff and volunteers. He is entirely right about the critical importance of early intervention and preventative support, and I'll be happy to raise these matters with ministers on his behalf to remind them, although they don't need any reminding, of the importance of this issue.

03:15:01 - 03:15:46

Jonathan Brash

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. At the start of the summer, two heroic men tragically lost their lives trying to save children in the sea at Seaton Carew beach in Hartlepool. Wayne Taylor and Ian Pasco were recovered from the water by the RNLI, but despite urgent medical treatment at the scene, tragically both men died. They were heroes, their courage, selflessness and instinct to protect children in danger represent the very best of our communities. So will the Leader of the House join me in paying tribute to Wayne and Ian, extend the deepest condolences of this House to their families and loved ones, and recognise the bravery of the RNLI and all those who put themselves in harm's way to save others?

And will he urge his ministerial colleagues to ensure coastal communities like mine have the resources and life-saving equipment needed to keep people safe?

03:15:46 - 03:16:13

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I absolutely join my honorable friend in paying tribute to Wayne and Ian and offer the heartfelt condolences of this House to their families and their loved ones. RNLI volunteers tirelessly provide a critical service in coastal towns and villages across the United Kingdom, including in my own constituency. I will ask that ministers write to him regarding resources for life-saving services going forward.

03:16:13 - 03:17:11

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On Saturday evening, for the fifth year running, the Art Department in my constituency launched the Big Art Show. This is one of the largest visual art exhibitions in the United Kingdom, with over a thousand works on display in a variety of mediums. It's a testament to our cultural heritage in my constituency and the work of the Art Department in encouraging creative participation of people of all ages and abilities, that over 50% of the works come from Paisley, Renfrewshire, and the Greater Glasgow area. So will the Leader of the House join me in congratulating Stephen Thompson, the creative director of the Art Department, and his whole team for putting the show together?

And if he or you, Madam Deputy Speaker, happen to be in the West of Scotland during the show, which lasts for the next couple of months, you'd be very welcome to see it.

03:17:11 - 03:17:36

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, and I'm happy to join my honorable friend in congratulating the Art Department team and their creative director, Stephen Thompson, for what is clearly an extremely successful project. Should I find myself in Scotland, or indeed we find ourselves in Scotland, Madam Deputy Speaker, I don't know why we wouldn't, but there we are. It would be my pleasure to see at first hand the incredible work.

03:17:36 - 03:18:10

Liz Twist

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So here we are back from recess, where I had a great time meeting people and businesses across Blaydon and Consett, from celebrating the centenary of Thomas Swan and Company in Consett, to independent local breweries like the Thirsty Moose in Ryton, and volunteers at the Just Love project in Leadgate. Will the Leader of the House join me in celebrating their hard work, and can we have a debate in government time on supporting regional manufacturing, high streets, and community champions?

03:18:10 - 03:19:00

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, and recess truly is an opportunity for all members to engage even further with constituents and see the fantastic work that they do in local communities. This government is committed to supporting local business and high streets, and later this year we'll bring forward the High Streets Strategy, and our Pride in Place program is gearing up to 5.8 billion pounds over 10 years to support 284 towns. I also join my honorable friend in congratulating businesses in her own community, the names of which and the places I recognize very well since it was the land of my birth, and encourage her to apply for what I'm sure would be a very popular Westminster Hall debate so that others can also praise the fantastic work of similar businesses and organizations in their constituencies.

03:19:00 - 03:19:32

Perran Moon

Moras, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Cornwall, the percentage of adults seen by a dentist within the last two years has fallen to just 29%. Cornwall is one of the worst dentistry deserts in the UK, and this lack of access to dentists is now having a profound effect on the health and well-being of the Cornish people. Can the Leader arrange for me to meet the relevant Health and Social Care Minister to discuss an urgent plan to deliver the dental care that the Duchy deserves?

03:19:32 - 03:19:53

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the government is committed to reforming the dental contract so that we can recruit more dentists and make sure that they work in the NHS for our communities. But I will reach out to the relevant minister to help to meeting with my honorable friend on this important matter, particularly because there is a plan to see how better these matters can be taken forward.

03:19:53 - 03:20:23

Elsie Blundell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Functional neurological disorder or FND can be debilitating for those affected, with symptoms including limb weakness, tremors, and chronic pain. Because of historical commissioning arrangements in my constituency, physiotherapy for FND is not available easily for my constituents. Can the leader speak to how the Department for Health seeks to improve access for FND patients and bring an end to what has become a postcode lottery when it comes to conditions like this?

03:20:23 - 03:21:02

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Functional neurological disorder can have a significant impact on the lives of those affected, as my honorable friend has said. And the government recognizes that access to appropriate support can vary between areas. Integrated care boards are responsible for commissioning services that meet the needs of their local populations and for ensuring the providers deliver services. But I will raise specifically with health ministers the concerns that my honorable friend has going forward, and perhaps she can meet with the relevant minister to see what further can be done.

03:21:02 - 03:21:31

Euan Stainbank

Following years of closures of community spaces, places of worship have become increasingly precious to communities across my constituency, especially across the Braes villages. The SNP learned 20 months ago that they were now responsible for support grants for places of worship and have only now delivered a paltry scheme with seemingly half as much resource committed proportionate to the scheme down here, top-sliced from the already significantly reduced Historic Environment Scotland budget. Will the leader support a debate on the importance of places of worship to our communities?

03:21:31 - 03:22:06

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As my honorable friend points out, in England we've launched the new Places of Worship Renewal Fund. And I similarly am pleased that the SNP have finally listened and opened up their own scheme. However, as my honorable friend has said, it's a rather disappointing scheme. As I've already said today, but I've said previously, the Scottish government have the biggest funding settlement since devolution, and it should be using it for what matters most to the people of Scotland.

Scotland's heritage is of such importance to the nation, and I hope that they have heard what he's said today.

03:22:06 - 03:22:46

David Williams

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last month, a devastating wildfire ripped through Sandford and Goldenhill in my constituency of Stoke-on-Trent North and Kidsgrove. Four homes were completely lost and 13 properties and gardens were badly damaged. Six of our heroic firefighters ended up in hospital, and they were battling exceptionally difficult conditions. So will the leader of the house please join me in paying tribute to our Staffordshire Fire and Rescue Service, and also to Goldenhill Community Centre, the Goldenhill Working Men's Club, the local residents association, local businesses, and volunteers who all rallied around to help their fellow residents?

03:22:46 - 03:23:11

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm sure the whole house will join me in sending our most heartfelt thanks and best wishes to the brave six firefighters that my honorable friend talks about. And I indeed join him in paying tribute to Staffordshire Fire and Rescue Service, and indeed all the community organizations who've come together to look out for one another. It really is the best of community under very challenging times.

03:23:11 - 03:23:34

Jade Jessica Toale

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I recently met my constituent Jan, whose daughter Amy died aged 29 of sudden cardiac arrest. I'll be joining Amy's friend Kayleigh this weekend on a sponsored walk from Hengesbury Head to Bournemouth to help raise awareness. So will the leader of the house please ensure that health ministers give due consideration to the need to raise awareness about sudden cardiac arrest in young people so that we can better understand the warning signs and save more lives?

03:23:34 - 03:24:17

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend raises a very serious matter. The UK National Screening Committee has just run a public consultation on evidence relating to screening for cardiac conditions associated with sudden cardiac death in young people. It is important that we increase the number of people in the country with life-saving, valuable life-saving knowledge of CPR, and we are extending this to all NHS staff. But I will make sure that the relevant health minister is aware of my honourable friend's concerns, and I wish her very well in these fundraising efforts, not just to raise money, but also to raise awareness.

03:24:17 - 03:24:56

Douglas Alexander

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Walk for Jock is a local banner charity founded in 2012 in loving memory of John Patterson, who died from cancer at 47. Tomorrow, 15 hikers will set off on the 96-mile West Highland Way as part of community fundraising that has raised over £250,000 since it started. Will the Leader of the House join me in congratulating John's brother Davie, the volunteers, the walkers, and committee members on their remarkable fundraising effort and wish them safe journey as they undertake their five-day hike.

03:24:56 - 03:25:20

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I certainly join my honourable friend in wishing all those taking part in Walk for Jock a safe journey in what must be a remarkably beautiful part of the country. Davie's efforts to keep the memory of his brother John alive is truly admirable, and I want to congratulate everyone involved for their incredible fundraising work and wish them well.

03:25:20 - 03:25:44

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Too often, single mothers come to me for help because they're being failed by the Child Maintenance Service. I therefore welcome the government's commitment in the tackling child poverty strategy to bring forward legislation to overhaul the Child Maintenance Service. Can the Leader of the House advise what progress is being made on this legislation, and can I urge him to ensure it is brought forward as quickly as possible.

03:25:44 - 03:26:12

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is an important matter. My honourable friend is right to raise it, and it will, I know, resonate across the House. We recognise that some parents' experience of the Child Maintenance Service do not meet the standards that they and we expect, which is why we're committed to reforming the system. Legislation, as she said, will be brought forward when parliamentary time allows, but in the meantime, we're continuing to take forward work on wider reform and improving outcomes for separated families.

03:26:12 - 03:26:42

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over recess, two serious incidents happened in Truro in my constituency. One led to a death and one involving a very large knife. Neighbourhood policing in my constituency has been decimated, and more recently due to sickness and officers being continually seconded to other duties. Would the Leader take my concerns on A, allocation of neighbourhood policing in Truro and Falmouth, and B, the regulations on size of knives in food establishments, to colleagues in the Home Office.

03:26:42 - 03:27:25

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. We are committed to delivering 13,000 additional neighbourhood policing personnel by the end of the parliament, and with that, more than 3,000 neighbourhood police officers now on frontline position. And Devon and Cornwall Police have been allocated over £8 million for 2026-27. But I recognise my honourable friend's concerns and that many forces still face very challenging conditions. I am happy to take forward what she has said, both about funding powers and also knives, but should she wish a meeting with the police minister herself to make that point, I'll help her to arrange one.

03:27:25 - 03:28:12

David Pinto-Duschinsky

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. On Christmas Day last year, residents of Beaufort Park in Colindale in my Hendon constituency received an unwanted gift. Their freeholders, the Berkeley Group, doubled their ground rent to £800, clearly trying to squeeze leaseholders for every penny before the government rightly introduces the ground rent cap.

It's simply unacceptable. I have written to the executive chair of the Berkeley Group asking to meet so that we can discuss this rise, but have either been fobbed off or my letters have gone unanswered. This clearly shows why the government's reforms and change to leasehold is so important. Will the leader join with me in calling on Berkeley Homes to meet with me, and will he allow for a debate in government time so that we can discuss how to hold unresponsive freeholders to account?

03:28:12 - 03:28:49

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend has been a relentless campaigner on this matter of ground rents, and I pay tribute to him for that. As the Prime Minister confirmed earlier this week, it is the intention of the government to bring forward legislation to reform this unfair system. And it's right, Madam Deputy Speaker, that honourable members are not ignored by organisations when they raise matters of interest to their constituents. It's a discourtesy to them, but it's also a discourtesy to this House.

So I hope that the Berkeley Homes have heard what he's said, and I hope that they up their game.

03:28:50 - 03:29:27

Chris Kane

The City of Stirling Football Hall of Fame was launched last week, with local legends Billy Bremner, Alex Smith, Duncan Ferguson, Jimmy Ryan, and Jimmy Bone its first inductees. Their names will now be etched on the new Wall of Fame at Forthbank Stadium. Will the leader join me in recognising our inaugural inductees, congratulate the Scottish Football Supporters Association for this initiative, and make time for a debate on the remarkable contribution Scotland has made to the beautiful game, not just through our footballers, but through the Tartan Army, whose exploits at this summer's World Cup once again showed the very best of Scotland to the world?

03:29:27 - 03:30:07

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. And some of the names, I don't recognise all the names, Madam Deputy Speaker, that will be going onto the Hall of Fame, but I recognise some of them and they were remarkable individuals and fantastic and pretty tough footballers. Their names are to be etched on a Wall of Fame as my honourable friend has said, and rightly so. I pay tribute to all of them, but also to Scottish football, both the organisers, the clubs, but also the supporters, who are very much part of the success of football north of the border. And I pay tribute to them, and I wish them well going forward in the future.

03:30:07 - 03:31:03

Jim Dickson

Jim Dickson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Southfleet is a beautiful village in the southeast corner of my constituency. It's set in quiet Kent country lanes, it's got a 700-year-old church, and it's got a history of over a thousand years. But it's also the entirely inappropriate site for a proposed new data centre, which will take up 90 acres of a 145-acre site next to the village. Now, I recognise as much as anyone the role of data centres in supporting our online activities, which we need to continue our day-to-day lives, but we must make sure that data centres are placed in the right part of this country.

Would the Leader of the House find time for a debate on the placement of nationally important infrastructures, including data centres, so that we might discuss the siting of those data centres in this place?

03:31:03 - 03:31:25

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend is right to highlight the importance of data centres, and it's important that they are in the right locations. I will raise his concerns with ministers, but it seems to me that it would be appropriate for him to raise these matters directly, either through an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall debate with ministers, so that he can speak up for his constituents.

03:31:25 - 03:32:17

Amanda Martin

Amanda Martin.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

This week I was devastated to learn that Alan Knight, a true Pompey goalkeeping legend, died aged 65 following a battle with prostate cancer. I had the privilege of meeting Alan many times over the years through my work as an MP, a member of the Portsmouth Supporters Trust board, a lifelong Pompey fan, and at my own Nan's funeral. He gave 801 appearances in blue and a lifetime giving back to Portsmouth long after he hung up his gloves. He was a strong union man and was awarded an MBE for his services to football as a learning rep for the PFA. Following his diagnosis, he helped raise awareness and thousands of pounds for prostate cancer charities, helping many people in Portsmouth and beyond.

So will my right honourable friend join me in sharing mine and Portsmouth's condolences with Alan's family and friends at this incredibly sad time and honour this Portsmouth giant?

03:32:17 - 03:34:22

Lucy Maria Powell

Hear, hear, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm honoured to do as my honourable friend says. I'm sure the House will join me in sending our condolences to the family and friends of Alan Knight. He will be fondly remembered not just for his exceptional charity work, but also of course for his football career. But let me just stray slightly more widely than that, Madam Deputy Speaker. The football community can be rightly proud of the way in which they have highlighted issues around prostate cancer, and I want to pay tribute not just to Alan but to the wider football community.

Final question, Fleur Anderson. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The impact of flights going over my constituency of Putney is enormous. They go over every 90 seconds. And so lots of Putney residents got involved in the consultation, the government consultation on the Heathrow expansion National Policy Statement during the summer, which closed on Monday.

But being held in the summer was concerning. It did limit public participation in that consultation. So would the Leader of the House provide some time in government time for a debate on the Heathrow expansion proposals before decisions are made to raise concerns from constituents and to inform ministers' decisions? Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is important that the concerns of both my honourable friend and local residents are heard, which is why the consultation took place.

The 10-week consultation has now closed. We are looking at the responses, and I'm sure there will be an opportunity once those responses have been looked at and digested, that there'll be an opportunity for the government to bring forward this matter for scrutiny and indeed debate in the House. But if my honourable friend wishes to preempt that in any way, then I'm sure through an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall, she'd find others who would want to take part in that. That is the end of the business questions if the front bench wish to shuffle over.

03:34:22 - 03:35:25

Eleanor Laing

We now come to the statements on building homes and renewing communities. Secretary of State, Angela Rayner. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister has set out this week our plan to bring back hope after a decade of decline. Today I want to update the House on the first steps my department is taking to rise to these new challenges.

We know that the sense of decline people feel runs deep. The causes aren't straightforward and it didn't happen overnight. But the most visible sign of this is a constant reminder of political and economic failure is the state of our high streets. Shuttered up shops reminding us of what was once, and organised crime too often out there visible in the open. Decades of deregulation and austerity for local government and the recent cost of living crisis all share the blame.

03:35:25 - 03:43:59

Angela Rayner

Every part of government, Madam Deputy Speaker, has a role to play in getting our high streets booming again. So in response, we are rebuilding the local state, giving councils new powers over their high streets, putting them back in control of their town and city centres. Local leaders know their high streets best and are best placed to bring them back to life. So in the months ahead, we will support councils to block new bookies, vape shops and so-called casinos, and we will double the length of closure orders from six to 12 months so that police have longer to investigate dodgy shops. And we will improve high street shopfronts by setting clear expectations for their design and appearance.

This is alongside, Madam Deputy Speaker, our Pride in Place programme, which is giving local communities six billion pounds to improve their areas. Everyone who has walked down their high streets will have spotted another glaring signal of state failure: people sleeping rough. In 2026, the world's fifth richest economy, everyone, Madam Deputy Speaker, should have a roof over their head. That is who we are as a country. This is a kind, caring nation that takes pride in looking out for each other, and that is why we will end rough sleeping in this country.

Madam Deputy Speaker, when I visited Changing Lives in Newcastle over the summer, I met the incredible Sabrina Cohen-Hatton. Today, Sabrina is the Chief Fire Officer for Hampshire and the Isle of Wight. But as a teenager, she experienced homelessness. Sabrina is an absolute inspiration and shows that if people are given the right support that they need, they can really transform their lives. And by Christmas this year, Madam Deputy Speaker, everyone sleeping rough will be offered a route off the streets.

We have set aside 442 million pounds for a new rough sleeping programme to meet this milestone, while investing in accommodation and support to end it for good. That takes our total investment in homelessness and rough sleeping services to more than four billion pounds over the next three years. We know that the reasons people sleep rough are complex. For example, eight out of ten have a mental health vulnerability. Our plans are more than just accommodation; it's a whole system approach which will also include access to health, substance and employment support.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, women who are homeless aren't always visibly rough sleeping. So we are specifically asking services to meet women where they are to ensure that they get the support that they need. But rough sleeping is just the worst symptom of an underlying crisis that we're determined to tackle. For too long, Britain has not built the homes that we need. We're getting Britain building, with council housing at the centre of our plans.

Madam Deputy Speaker, the failure to build council homes to replace those that were sold off is one of the major causes of the housing crisis we inherited at the last election. And last month, I met with families in Kidbrooke who told me that when they moved into their new social homes, it took so much stress away.

And that finding out that they were moving into a new home was like winning the lottery. And last week, I announced the first wave of our allocations for the social and affordable homes program. That's over 70,000 homes, nearly two-thirds of which will be for social rent. We also announced new support for councils to rebuild their capacity, including a further 46 million pounds over three years and an expansion of the pathways to planning program. And this follows our new national planning policy framework, which will unlock thousands of homes around train stations, and our announcement of new housing and planning powers for mayors who can now call in planning applications for strategic sites and grant upfront permission to build for the benefit of local people.

We are also giving them greater say over how national housing funding is spent in their areas, with Homes England investment now focused on their priorities. And solving the housing crisis isn't just a moral cause, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's an economic necessity. Every shovel in the ground means new investment, new jobs, growth in every postcode. But we must put power in every postcode too. The legacies of political choices in the 1980s and the decades since, the centralization of power, privatization of economic wealth, and deindustrialization all contributed to the loss of control that many people feel today.

The future of our country relies on us building new economic and political settlement that serves those that we represent. And that starts with the largest ever transfer of power and funding out to every region of England. For the first time, mayors will receive a share of income tax revenues, meaning that they can invest in what matters most locally. They will also be given new powers to bring rail and bus services under local control, run 16 to 19 funding and employment support, and back local industries and businesses to create new jobs. Where power is devolved, resources will be devolved too.

And this, Madam Deputy Speaker, ends the begging bowl culture of the past and it paves the way for a new era of devolution. In the months ahead, we will make sure that every area benefits by supporting areas without a mayor to establish new strategic authorities. And finally, I want to take this moment to thank all those involved in the response to the wildfires this summer, including the firefighters who showed immense bravery battling the flames. Madam Deputy Speaker, I saw the horrendous damage in Stourbridge firsthand and the level of emotional turmoil was just devastating. I'll never forget meeting a woman on Quarry Bank Road whose neighbor was widowed less than a year ago and she'd lost her home and all her possessions too.

During the fires, we made emergency funding available and this autumn, the Prime Minister will chair a wildfire summit to discuss what more that we can do to improve our resilience. The wildfires and extreme heat show the threat that we face from the climate crisis and we must treat this as an emergency in itself. Madam Deputy Speaker, these steps we're taking are only the start.

In the months ahead, we will take through the Representation of the People's Bill, giving 16 to 17-year-olds a vote and protecting our elections from foreign interference. We will speed up building safety remediation and end the feudal leasehold system. And we will work with local leaders as we fix the foundations of local government. The Prime Minister has promised a new political and economic model, and together, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are shaping it.

03:43:59 - 03:44:02

Eleanor Laing

I call the Shadow Secretary of State, Katie Lamb.

03:44:02 - 03:47:27

Katie Lam

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you to the Secretary of State for advance sight of her statement. It is a pleasure to see the right honourable lady again so soon. I would like to thank by joining her in thanking those involved in the response to this summer's wildfires and applauding their remarkable courage. The Secretary of State is right to note that for far too many people across the country, the sense of decline runs deep. In far too many places, organised criminals have taken over the high street.

In far too many cases, a place to sleep is something that people cannot take for granted. The stories that I have been told by constituents who have experienced rough sleeping or unsafe housing remain some of the most challenging and profound that I have heard since coming to this place. But while she talks about a new political and economic model, I'm afraid what we have heard today, Madam Deputy Speaker, is a recipe for more of the same. While her focus on the scourge of organised crime on the high street is welcome, I'm concerned that she addresses a symptom of the problem but not the underlying cause. While many bookies, vape shops and high street casinos are clearly legitimate, their cash intensivity and lower overhead costs make them particularly attractive as fronts for money laundering.

However, if these businesses are closed, criminals will simply find other types of high street businesses through which to launder money. So can she set out what conversations she is having with her Home Office colleagues on dealing with organised crime itself? And though she talks about the devolution of power and resources to local people, what she really means is more politicians given the power to increase the size of the state and raise taxes, but never to let people keep more of their own money or to interfere less with their lives. So can she confirm today whether any tax-raising powers devolved to mayors will be accompanied by the powers to reduce tax, and if not, why not? Similarly, while she is right to recognise the vital importance of addressing the housing affordability crisis, the answer cannot be spending ever more of taxpayers' money.

Instead, the state must stop making it so difficult and so expensive to get new houses built in the places where people want to live. A greater supply of homes in those places will mean lower costs for everybody, particularly those who are renting and those who are looking to get on the housing ladder. In London, where our housing crisis is most acute, Labour have been in power for over a decade. Under Sadiq Khan, housing starts fell to their lowest level ever in 2024 to 25; construction began on just 4,000 homes across our capital. Can the Secretary of State explain why Labour's London Mayor has failed to get to grips with this problem, and will the changes that she proposes actually solve the housing crisis in the capital?

Because if not, it is a little difficult to understand why she is introducing them. Finally, on homelessness and rough sleeping, while we share the government's ambition to end rough sleeping, it is impossible to ignore the fact that the new Prime Minister promised to do exactly this in his 2017 manifesto for the Greater Manchester Mayoralty. His pledge was to end rough sleeping within three years. In fact, rough sleeping in Greater Manchester has increased every year since 2021, including in 2024 and 25 when the Labour Party were also in power nationally. Can the Secretary of State therefore explain why the Prime Minister failed to solve rough sleeping in Greater Manchester, bearing in mind that it increased when both the local authority and the national government were run by the Labour Party, and can she explain why anybody should believe that he will be able to do so nationally?

03:47:27 - 03:52:08

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the honourable member to her place, and I look forward to facing her across the dispatch box in the months to come.

And she comes with a job of a good strong track record. I believe her grandparents met whilst they were delivering leaflets for the Labour Party, so that's a good start. And, Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome her tone and in particular the agreement on supporting those that helped us over the summer with the wildfires, and I look forward to working with her constructively, especially as we move towards that summit in the autumn, which I will keep her informed of. And some of the challenges we face have been long-standing, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I think it would be remiss of me not to gently remind the party opposite that the austerity measures that they hollowed out our local services and the decline in our high street started under their watch. But she's absolutely right to highlight the challenges that our high streets face, and that's why we have a strategy for it.

That's why the announcements that we made around making sure we tackle organized crime, giving police more powers, giving them more funding so that they could tackle it with a 13 million pound boost to police and trading standards activity, strengthening the closure orders and a new high streets organized crime unit. So we're tackling the issues that the party opposite failed to tackle. In terms of local powers, look, the Prime Minister's been really clear about making sure that we work with local leaders and that they're able to do the things that will help them in their local community so that they can really start to tackle some of those issues. And in terms of tax-raising powers and the reduction of tax, again, that is an ongoing dialogue, and the honorable member opposite, the honorable lady, would have seen the statement from the whole of cabinet and the work that we're doing through the National Economic Council to work with mayors and local leaders so that we can take those issues forward. I find it, I found it bemused that the honorable lady said that the state has made it hard to build.

The party opposite missed every single housing target that they set. And they scrapped targets completely after pressure from their own backbenchers. We've brought in new powers, Madam Deputy Speaker. We've updated the national planning policy framework. We're giving more powers to mayors.

We've brought in mandatory housing targets again and a mandatory housing plan, and we're working with local areas to deliver the housing that we need. We've been very upfront about that, but we've also been really clear that infrastructure and wildlife and nature have to be taken into account. But I won't take lectures from the party opposite, Madam Deputy Speaker, when they created a housing crisis where millions of families were locked out of home ownership. In terms of specifically around London, London built significant amounts of council housing, Madam Deputy Speaker, but she's absolutely right to raise the challenges that London face. When you look at the number of children in temporary accommodation, London has an acute need, and that's why we recognize that with the support we give them through the announcement of the money that we've put forward through the social and affordable housing program with their allocation of that money.

And we recognize the success that the Mayor of London has had in terms of ramping up housing supply where it's needed. And then finally, on the question of what happened in Greater Manchester with the mayor, our new Prime Minister, we saw, Madam Deputy Speaker, in Greater Manchester, and as a Greater Manchester MP, I saw this, that numbers actually fell originally.

But what happened is because there wasn't a national program, the numbers went up because more people came to Greater Manchester. And that's why we want to roll out a program working with local leaders and with mayors so that we can offer that support. And I hope that the honorable member will work with us because I remember that this used to be a target. They wanted to end rough sleeping, but then they scrapped that target. But I hope they can work with us now with this renewed effort in the spirit of how the Prime Minister wants to work to ensure that we can roll out a program nationally where everyone who is rough sleeping has an option of safety and has an option to come in.

03:52:08 - 03:52:11

Eleanor Laing

Melanie On.

03:52:11 - 03:53:09

Melanie Onn

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to thank the Secretary of State for her statement today, which is very timely and very welcome. To point out a good development that is happening in Grimsby, there is a really good example of town center house building that is working with local housing associations. The partnership is between Keepmoat and Ongo Northern Lincolnshire Housing Association, which is going to provide a mix of private accommodation as well as social housing. But she will find in her mailbox a letter from the leader of the Labour group, Emma Clough, who's written to her to raise the issue of town center houses and particularly empty homes in town centers to ask whether or not the government will be looking to put in place additional measures to support local authorities in tackling the scourge of empty homes, which number nearly 2,000 across Grimsby.

03:53:09 - 03:53:42

Angela Rayner

I thank my honorable friend for that question, and she's been a great champion for Grimsby for a very long time. I remember, I think we originally came in together in 2015 and congratulate her for her work. She's absolutely right also to praise the housing associations that are coming together to build those homes that people desperately need. And I will look at that letter, and she's absolutely right to highlight, and I will bring forward proposals on how we're working with councils to make sure that we deal with the empty homes situation that we have as well. Thank you.

03:53:42 - 03:53:45

Eleanor Laing

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Gideon Amos.

03:53:45 - 03:55:27

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I first congratulate the right honorable lady on her appointment? I look forward to exchanges and working with her and her team. In our country, there are millions fewer council houses than there used to be. Yet the need for social housing has only increased, not least the scourge of poor quality temporary accommodation for too many children.

The Shared Health Foundation have found that in the last six years, 104 children have died with temporary accommodation noted by the coroner as a contributory factor. But in Taunton and Wellington and elsewhere, all people are seeing are unprecedented plans for private housing. Many will not be able to afford that housing. Councils instructed by Whitehall to consent homes for 180,000 people in Somerset in the next 15 years, a 25% pace of growth never seen in the county's history. What we need instead is a truly ambitious program of council and social housing.

Not the government's re-announcement that 60% of its 300,000 program will be social housing. Not this 18,000 per year, but the Lib Dem policy of 150,000 social homes a year. I recognize this statement confirms around 46,000 social homes over 10 years with further tranches to come. But will the Housing Secretary and the new Prime Minister, who's said a lot about social housing, raise the target from 18,000 a year or not? And will the government raise its 3.9 billion funding to our proposed 6 billion?

Or if it won't do that, will it write off some of the council's housing revenue account debt so councils like Somerset can build the 600 council houses they would if they could?

03:55:27 - 03:56:57

Angela Rayner

I thank the honorable gentleman for his comments, and he's absolutely right actually to raise this issue. And it's something that the Prime Minister feels incredibly passionate about. The Prime Minister's committed to delivering the biggest council house building program since the postwar boom ended in the early 1980s.

And I recognize the challenges, but I want to also celebrate last year, Madam Deputy Speaker, that councils built the most council houses since the early 1990s, 1991 when records began. But we really want to see that ramp up with, as I outlined earlier, Madam Deputy Speaker, the money that we're investing to help councils. We've already taken measures. You'll see through the legislation going through at the moment and it's been in the other place around tightening up right to buy and making sure that councils keep full receipts. We're supporting that program, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I think to recognize the significance of the 10 billion pounds of investment which was announced earlier this last month, which was about making sure that we get that money out the door so we can build those homes.

And the planning reforms we've made as well is about making sure that people have a say about the homes, Madam Deputy Speaker, but we are having clarity so that those homes are built and the infrastructure around them is absolutely right to raise the numbers of children in temporary accommodation. I still think it's absolutely awful that those children are in those circumstances and that's why we want to tackle social housing in particular.

03:56:57 - 03:56:59

Eleanor Laing

Jonathan Brash.

03:56:59 - 03:57:32

Jonathan Brash

Madam Deputy Speaker, our councils are the front door to our democracy and after years of damage, too many people have lost faith in what lies behind it. Does the Secretary of State agree that rebuilding strong, trusted local government must be central to rebuilding trust in politics itself? And on high streets, will she meet with me to discuss how existing tools like high street rental auctions can be made simpler and easier to use by councils so communities like Hartlepool can bring empty shops back into use?

03:57:32 - 03:58:48

Angela Rayner

Well, he's absolutely right, Madam Deputy Speaker, to highlight the role of local government. I am a bit biased, Madam Deputy Speaker, I came from a local government background and then I represented local government workers across the board as a Unison rep for many years. So I am slightly biased about what local government do and if you think back to what's happened to local government, the pressures that are on our local councils at the moment and there have been on our local councils since 2010 and how they've had to evolve with those pressures and the challenges, I absolutely commend local councils and their representatives across the board in the work that they're doing. And that's why this government has given more funding to councils. We've freed up some of the pots because they were all itty-bitty to try and make it easier for councils to do the work that they want to do.

And in terms of auctions, absolutely right to mention that we've also been making sure that we can support councils and support the plan we want to put in place for our high streets so that there are more powers in place and that we can safeguard community assets and the high street rental auction powers will also bring closed down pubs and properties back into use.

03:58:48 - 03:58:51

Eleanor Laing

Gagan Mohindra.

03:58:51 - 03:59:35

Gagan Mohindra

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I firstly welcome the Secretary of State back to the front bench and we look forward as a select committee to scrutinize her in due course. As the Secretary of State will be aware, Southwest Hertfordshire has a beautiful green belt land and we would have seen at the last bank holiday weekend press reports about unauthorized clearance of sites. While some of these may be legal and lawful, I think the concerns that my residents consistently have is the lack of information and the worry that bulldozers and tree clearing equipment turns up on a Saturday morning and council officers are not available until the following Tuesday after the bank holiday weekend. What more can she and her department do to make sure that my residents don't have that fear?

03:59:35 - 04:00:27

Angela Rayner

Well, I thank the honorable member for raising this issue and actually it was an issue that my ministers and myself was discussing only yesterday and I'll make sure he gets an update on that. It's deeply concerning that some try over the bank holiday weekend to do things that they know is absolutely not okay and completely unacceptable. We are cracking down on illegal traveler sites and it's completely important that we do so. Our new planning rules explicitly tackle any potential environmental damage and transport impacts that make it harder for people to get retrospective permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I will have contact with the member specifically about that case because I know it's caused great concern to people in his local area.

04:00:27 - 04:00:46

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I strongly welcome the investment in social housing and ask the Secretary of State what more the department can do to make sure the social infrastructure comes with those new homes, the school places, the doctors, the dentists, which we struggle to secure in my constituency to support new homes and which we need around the country.

04:00:46 - 04:01:34

Angela Rayner

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, he's absolutely right to highlight this and it's one of the issues that I was acutely aware of because I don't like it when this debate becomes about people who are opposed to new homes and people who aren't because actually I think most of the time, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's about people are concerned about the infrastructure that comes with the new homes. And that's why the reforms that we've made through the National Planning Policy and the Planning Act is to make sure that those provisions are in place so that we can make sure that when those homes are built, there is local input into the planning process, but also that the infrastructure is there critically so that local people can see that it enhances their area and it alleviates some of those genuine concerns that people raise.

04:01:34 - 04:02:42

Julian Lewis

Does the Secretary of State accept that there's an intimate link between local government reform and the successful carrying out of major house building programs? One of the reasons I warmly welcome her return to office is the failure of her predecessor on 16th of July either to confirm or deny the report in the Times on the 18th of June that senior civil servants and lawyers in three separate departments had been overruled when they advised him not to make local government reorganization decisions merely at the behest of Labour-led councils. Will she undertake to look at this again, particularly in light of the number of boundary changes involved when her own colleague from Oldham West, now mercifully back in action, had originally promised that boundary changes would only be rare exceptions with particularly strong reasons having to be put forward in justification.

04:02:42 - 04:03:24

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Without straying too much into that area, can I just say to the honorable member that my principle around local government reform is about the best services for the people in their local area. And I think that is the only way that really we get the buy-in from the people to deliver that, whether it's through our local representatives, local councillors who are doing a fantastic job as I said before and many of them are and the challenges that local government face. But actually local government reform to me is about making sure that areas can deliver on things like transport, on education, on health and they can deliver it in a way that is best for those people. And I will look into those issues.

04:03:24 - 04:03:58

Rachel Blake

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's really great to hear from the Secretary of State today. Members across this chamber will know about the harm that damp and mould does to children and their families. And it's absolutely right that we have brought in Awaab's Law, and where there was real cross-party support for that. But what are we doing to monitor the impact of Awaab's Law, and how should housing associations and social landlords be regulated to make sure that they're enacting Awaab's Law and being on top of the timelines that Awaab's Law requires?

04:03:58 - 04:04:55

Angela Rayner

Well, can I thank my honourable friend for that, and thank her for the visit that we did together, where we met that wonderful young mother who had gone through, well, it's hell and back really, what was a dream of home ownership turned into hell. And I think that her experience is one that many have experienced up and down the country, and that visit is still very much at the heart of my mind when we take things forward. And Awaab, of course, and Awaab's Law, which was Awaab and his family was from Greater Manchester, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the tragic case of a young person losing their life because of the conditions that they live in. We're absolutely clear that we have to take this forward, and we've done a process of test and learn as part of that, and that the phase two is now being implemented to make sure that we're continually robustly proving that those laws are in place and that they will deliver what we expect them to.

04:04:55 - 04:04:57

Nusrat Ghani

Ian Roome.

04:04:57 - 04:05:38

Ian Roome

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State for saying that the closure orders will be extended to combat dodgy shops on our high streets? In my constituency of North Devon, the police have fought a running battle against shops with secret compartments selling counterfeit cigarettes. However, after talking to my local Trading Standards in Devon, Trading Standards do not have nearly enough personnel to investigate suspicious businesses. So will her department also look at the funding given to local councils to do this is ring-fenced to recruit more Trading Standard officers?

Thank you.

04:05:38 - 04:06:17

Angela Rayner

Well, I can thank the honourable member for raising this really important issue, and I can appreciate that in North Devon this has been an acute issue, but I think it's coming up across the whole of England. And that's why we are strengthening the orders, which I thank him for his acknowledgement of that. We have, as I mentioned, invested thirty million pounds to boost police and Trading Standards activity, with thousands of businesses expected to face raids, closures, and cash seizures. So hopefully he'll be able to work and be in touch with his local police and local Trading Standards to see how they're implementing that in his North Devon constituency.

04:06:17 - 04:06:19

Nusrat Ghani

Abena Oppong-Asare.

04:06:19 - 04:06:54

Abena Asare

Thank you. I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for her statement, particularly in relation to the vape bars, what the government is doing in relation to that. As minister, I oversaw the emergency alerts and the creation of the risk vulnerability tool. I would be grateful if the minister could set out what work the government is doing to strengthen the resilience plan so that we can be better prepared for the future, and also to share with us lessons learnt from the emergency alert that was issued on the fourteenth of August.

04:06:54 - 04:07:30

Angela Rayner

Well, I thank my honourable friend for that, and to congratulate her on the work that she's been doing. We're making almost one point nine five billion pounds available to standalone fire and rescue authorities in England through the local government finance settlement. This can be used for training and preparation and prevention based on local risks. We're making wildfire advice more visible, including through social media during high-risk periods, the Fire Kills campaign, and the National Fire Chiefs Council-led education platform.

And of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, as I mentioned, we have the wildfire summit which will consider how we can go further.

04:07:30 - 04:07:31

Wendy Morton.

04:07:31 - 04:07:59

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There's an estimated 1.4 million consented homes in England that remain unbuilt. So I'd like to ask the Secretary of State why she will not concentrate on getting those homes built before demanding that councils surrender more green belt and greenfield land, which allows developers to just cherry-pick the most profitable sites instead of building the homes for which they've already been given permission.

04:07:59 - 04:08:27

Angela Rayner

Well, my simple answer to that question is we are. And that's why we've strengthened the National Planning Policy Framework. We're putting this, as I've said before, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's not just one lever, there is a number of factors that need to be considered. And we have been doing that, including mandatory house, mandatory housing targets and plans for local areas. We are strengthening, we are pushing, and we're making sure we fix the mess that the previous government left us with.

04:08:27 - 04:08:28

Clive Efford.

04:08:28 - 04:09:11

Clive Efford

Madam Deputy Speaker, it was a pleasure to join my right honourable friend at Greenwich Council's development in my constituency of 435 council properties to launch the social and affordable housing programme. 70,000 homes are planned. It's very welcome and very overdue. But as we push for more land, in a constituency like mine that has a lot of sports grounds, the temptation is for owners of those sports grounds to lock the gates in the hope that they're going to make get a windfall from having those sites developed. So can I just ask my right honourable friend to reassure my constituents that that won't be allowed as part of the programme to build the housing that we need.

04:09:11 - 04:10:18

Angela Rayner

I thank my honourable friend and it was a great pleasure to visit the site with him and to see, and as I in my opening statement, it really touched me and that's why I outlined it that way, is that the way in which people spoke about getting a home, the conditions before and then the way in which it changed their life, they literally said it was like winning the lottery, it was just life-changing. And I think, as I outlined to the Shadow Secretary of State earlier in my in my response, I do think about those children, especially because of the acute housing crisis that London faced. And I congratulate the Mayor of London and London councils that are working to to deal with that. And that's why we announced the funding grant that we did to to help London with their acute particular problem that they've had. I do think you're absolutely right also to raise the issue around protecting spaces.

And that's what we've done through strengthening the National Planning Policy Framework. And the Housing Minister would be happy to chat more with you about that, which I'm sure you do as you're neighbours. But I think it's important that we continue to do that as well.

04:10:18 - 04:10:20

Speaker 201

Mark Francois.

04:10:20 - 04:11:17

Mark Francois

Thank you, Ma'am. The Secretary of State mentioned mandatory housing targets. And under Labour's targets, in South Essex, from Grays across to Shoeburyness, we would be expected to accommodate over 100,000 houses. That's 7% of the government's entire 1.5 million target in one half of one county alone, despite the fact that our medical infrastructure, our sewage capacity, and particularly our roads, the A13 and the A127, are maxed out as it is. Simply cannot cope even now.

So why are Labour so determined in South Essex, you can chunter all you want, why are Labour so determined to cover South Essex in concrete and gridlock our roads purely for ideological reasons?

04:11:17 - 04:11:57

Angela Rayner

Madam Deputy Speaker, we can look at it another way and say I'm really confident in the honourable member and the local members there to work with us to recognise the acute housing need within his local area and to make sure that we're working in partnership to deliver, as we have said, through well-connected local transport, deliver the homes that are so desperately because his government, his government failed to deliver that. And I'm sure his inbox is full of people, Madam Deputy Speaker, who needs those homes. And we're going to work with his local leaders to deliver the homes and the infrastructure that people in his constituency desperately need.

04:11:57 - 04:11:58

Mohammad Yasin.

04:11:58 - 04:12:39

Mohammad Yasin

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Will the Secretary of State meet with me to discuss the St Andrews estate in Bedford where local residents and children walking to Great Ouse Primary Academy are being put at risk by dangerous driving and parking on the estate roads that require traffic safety measures but have remained unadopted for around eight years? And what action will she take to address the wider problems of developers and local authorities passing the responsibilities between themselves, leaving residents waiting for years for estate roads to be completed and adopted?

04:12:39 - 04:13:08

Angela Rayner

Well, I thank my honorable friend for raising this issue, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm sure the residents of St Andrews estate is very frustrated but commend the work of the honorable member in highlighting this issue. It is not acceptable for years for roads to be left unadopted and for people to be left in those circumstances. And I'm happy to arrange a meeting with the relevant minister for him to look at ways of how he can support the honorable member in his endeavor to deal with this particular matter.

04:13:08 - 04:13:10

Nusrat Ghani

Vicky Slade.

04:13:10 - 04:14:11

Vikki Slade

Madam Deputy Speaker, communities like Wimborne Minster and Bearwood have doubled in size in the last few years. No extra roads, it's not funny, the people there have no extra roads, no water treatment plants, no new GPs and the remaining areas of green belt specifically designated to separate them have disappeared. Their communities are being forced to build thousands more, 7,000 a year in Dorset, similar to Essex, but Madam Deputy Speaker, they're not selling. These houses are lying empty, which means that the community infrastructure isn't being built and we have empty homes everywhere. The local population can't afford them, the social housing providers don't want them because they're built under old standards and we run the risk of them being filled with holidaymakers.

We really do need a review of this huge housing target so it's based on the need in the local community and also the requirement for the infrastructure to come first. Can she please help?

04:14:11 - 04:15:07

Angela Rayner

Well, well, I can, I can honestly feel the frustration that the honorable member is raising in regard to that. And I suppose one of the issues that I picked up when I first became Secretary of State is as I said outlined earlier, is it's not opposition to new housing, it's the infrastructure's not there, the frustration of what the houses are and local people can't afford them. So I have complete sympathy with what the honorable member is saying. And that's why we've been putting changes within the National Planning Policy Framework and changes within the way in which we do the building consent so that we can get these houses built where local people do have access to them and that they are contributing to the wider local community including services. And I'm happy to speak to the honorable member about the specifics because I appreciate, Madam Deputy Speaker, if there are empty houses that local people can't get and the infrastructure's not there, I can fully appreciate why people would be frustrated with that.

04:15:07 - 04:15:08

Deirdre Costigan.

04:15:08 - 04:15:37

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State is right to say that the reasons people sleep rough are complex. And Ealing Southall is almost unique in that many of our rough sleepers don't have the right to stay or work in the country, so the council can't legally help them off the streets.

Will she meet with me to find ways of making it easier for this group of rough sleepers to reconnect with family abroad and return home with dignity?

04:15:37 - 04:16:03

Angela Rayner

I thank the honorable member for raising this issue, and she's absolutely right, we have to do more in terms of making sure that people who are not here, who have exercised all of their appeals or others who want to return home, we need to make sure. And I will work with my colleagues in the Home Office to look at how we can tackle that issue alongside the package that we're putting in place over the winter.

04:16:03 - 04:17:08

Robbie Moore

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Silsden in my constituency, we are absolutely being inundated by a huge number of housing developments. We've in the last few years, we've had seven different housing developers all building houses with no focus whatsoever on improving infrastructure or services. It is getting to a stage that Silsden can't cope. And it gets worse than that, Madam Deputy Speaker, because the Section 106 money that is collected and negotiated with the housing developer with Bradford Council under the last Labour administration is not being respent in mitigating the negative implications of these housing developments.

And there is no local plan in place by Bradford Council. We're seeing a lot of speculative development coming down the line. It is simply not good enough. And I have to say to the Secretary of State, it was all overseen by the last Labour administration at Bradford Council. So what in today's announcement is the Secretary of State going to deliver that is positive for my constituents that addresses the key issue of focusing on infrastructure and service improvement when house building does happen?

04:17:08 - 04:18:04

Angela Rayner

Again, I thank the honorable member for raising this issue, and we have strengthened the infrastructure within the National Planning Policy Framework. The announcement we made is about making sure that local areas can deliver on local plans, and that is very clear, and I've been very clear as the Secretary of State on that. I can hear his frustration around the Section 106, and some of the, there are some legitimate reasons why sometimes they are delayed, but it's an area that I've focused on since returning to this post. I've focused on that with the Housing Minister, and I've been in touch or I'm due to be in touch with local authorities again around that issue to make sure that that money is going out the door, and that also the right to buy receipts, which again is money that we have strengthened for councils, is going out the door and that that's creating the homes and the infrastructure that local areas desperately need.

04:18:04 - 04:18:44

Nusrat Ghani

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State knows my constituency well, and she knows that I've been campaigning to regenerate Wythenshawe Civic Centre for a number of years now. Thanks to this government, we're about to cut the turf on building 2,000 new homes within the decade. Phase one of this starts with building 800 social homes in the next few weeks. So my question to the Secretary of State, Madam Deputy Speaker, is would she be prepared to don her best Doc Martens, pop out of Number 10 North, and cut the ceremonial piece of turf?

04:18:44 - 04:19:25

Angela Rayner

It's a tough question, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honorable friend knows full well that my family from my mum's side of the family are from Wythenshawe, so I know Wythenshawe Civic Centre very well, and I used to spend many a weekend at Woodhouse Park Social Club, which unfortunately is no longer there. But you can see the civic pride across the whole of Wythenshawe. I am not the most famous person whose family are from Wythenshawe. We all know a famous footballer who's done incredible work in that area, but never mind.

But I do congratulate the work that my honorable friend is doing there. The 2,000 homes are desperately needed in that local area. I've got fond memories of growing up around that area, and I would be absolutely honored to come back.

04:19:24 - 04:20:02

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State failed to mention or to recommit to the one and a half million new homes pledge of Labour's manifesto. She also failed to mention the almost five billion pounds that were provided to the Mayor of London by the previous Conservative government, and also the fact that this Labour government has been forced to cut the Mayor's housing target given his poor record of delivery here in London. But one way that the Secretary of State can help improve London's family housing crisis is to give local councils more powers to stop bad HMOs in their community. It is destroying family housing in communities across the capital, particularly in outer London.

Will she commit to that today?

04:20:02 - 04:20:51

Angela Rayner

I'm going to slightly disagree with the honorable member in terms of what's happening in London. We've seen that half of all council homes built in 2024-25 were coming forward in London, showing what can be achieved through devolution through the London Mayor Sadiq Khan, who has been doing a fantastic job. And that's why I have confidence through the social and affordable housing program in giving more investment to London so that they can deal with the acute situation that they face at that time. And in terms of HMOs, again, I take no lectures from the party opposite. They left us in a very difficult situation with this, but it's under review and we're working with local authorities and with mayors to make sure that the planning circumstances are not creating situations which are causing tensions through HMOs.

04:20:51 - 04:20:52

Jessica Toale.

04:20:52 - 04:21:36

Jade Jessica Toale

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I very warmly welcome the Secretary of State to her place. In my constituency, the local GPs serve 20% more patients than the national average, and it is particularly bad at Barking Riverside where there is new development. Unlike members opposite, I strongly support new homes being built because my constituents feel the pain of having a housing crisis. But not having GPs, not having schools, and other crucial infrastructure means that they are let down. Can I press the Secretary of State to give us further assurances that as this government delivers the homes that we need in this country and in my constituency, the GPs are also delivered?

04:21:36 - 04:22:41

Angela Rayner

Again, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you for that question. I think there's a theme developing here and I think it comes from years of not having the infrastructure and people are rightly concerned about that. I mentioned it earlier that I think a lot of the opposition that comes to some of the planning reforms, some of the mandatory housing targets that we've set forward as a government. And I hear it loud and clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want her constituents and my constituents, every constituent to know that I am acutely aware that with the housing needs to come the infrastructure that people desperately need. I don't think they're NIMBYs, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think they raise genuine concerns and I've heard them loud and clear.

That's why we've strengthened the National Planning Policy Framework, in particular around GPs. I'm sure my colleagues in health have heard her, but I'll make sure that there is a nod for what's happening in her particular area. But I want to reassure the House that I am acutely aware if we're going to ramp up house building, which we absolutely have to do and our constituents expect us to do, it has to be done in a way that local people are involved in the process and that infrastructure is there too.

04:22:41 - 04:22:42

Manuela Perteghella.

04:22:42 - 04:23:33

Manuela Perteghella

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The South Warwickshire Local Plan requires more than 27,000 new homes to be allocated to Stratford-on-Avon District under the standard method, and my constituents support the delivery of truly affordable homes and social rent. However, these homes are not going to be affordable for local people, and housing growth continues to outpace investment in transport, in schools, in GPs, and in drainage and sewage infrastructure. So will the Secretary of State review these mandatory targets to ensure that it's local housing need rather than a centralized formula which determines housing allocations in rural areas? And can she guarantee that infrastructure will keep pace with development instead of lagging years behind it, if it's delivered at all?

04:23:33 - 04:24:25

Angela Rayner

Well again Madam Deputy Speaker the house the the target that is set the local target is based on housing stock and affordability. And I appreciate the comments she made in terms of affordable housing and I think I would put her back to what the Prime Minister has said around actually we need more social housing and I'm sure that's a particular issue that she appreciates as well. So we will be making sure that we're leaning towards that so that we build the houses that people need so that local people can can get access to the homes that are built in their area. And the infrastructure is an important part that she mentions water drainage and water supply. We haven't built a reservoir for decades and this government is now taking the action to make sure that we build reservoirs that we build the critical infrastructure that we need to to deliver for the housing that we need and the infrastructure.

04:24:25 - 04:25:09

Anna Dixon

Anna Dixon. Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I'm delighted to see my honorable right honorable friend back in her role. And I'm really pleased that the government have committed to fast track developments close to transport hubs. It's a fantastic opportunity to build housing around Shipley station which is close to the recently refurbished Shipley market. High quality and affordable housing would help increase footfall and bring regeneration to the high street.

So would the Secretary of State join me and West Yorkshire Mayor Tracy Brabin for a visit to Shipley to see the opportunity for herself and help accelerate house building in Shipley?

04:25:09 - 04:25:37

Angela Rayner

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I often visit the West Yorkshire Mayor and and geographical area and Shipley is a great place and Madam Deputy Speaker from my house in Manchester over there it's a really really good drive as well so I recommend it to anyone. So often I always jump at the chance to go to the area and I congratulate the West Yorkshire Mayor and her local leaders and herself in the work that they're doing to deliver the homes that people there desperately need.

04:25:37 - 04:26:22

Greg Gregory Smith

Greg Smith. Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. How does the Secretary of State square what she said in the statement about wanting to put power into every postcode with the reality of what her government is doing to Buckinghamshire? A 43% increase in the housing target whilst letting London off some of theirs something that if we had power locally we would categorically not choose to build and and telling Buckinghamshire Council that if they turn down too many planning applications and actually support the residents of Buckinghamshire they'll have their planning powers taken off them. That's not putting power into every postcode that's central dictat isn't it?

04:26:22 - 04:27:01

Angela Rayner

Well I I disagree Madam Deputy Speaker in the way in which the honorable member has framed that. Again the the housing targets are based on housing stock and affordability and there are local plans which are mandatory which the honorable member's party opposite removed. So what we're actually doing is strengthening and we're also making it more strategic and clear about where houses go and and the infrastructure that people need and and I would urge the honorable member to engage in that process look at the key changes to the national planning policy framework and use them to the benefit of his constituents.

04:27:01 - 04:27:46

Jade Jessica Toale

Jessica Toale. Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Over the conference recess my team and I are taking over a shop in Bournemouth town centre and filling it with a range of community and cultural uses which showcase the amazing local organisations we have. Now meanwhile spaces have a range of benefits for our high streets they give small businesses and charities a chance they can fill persistently empty shops and create better collaboration between councils landlords and tenants. But they often require councils to use the powers at their disposal particularly around rates relief and a bit of capital investment for persistently neglected units.

So I really welcome the measures announced over the summer to improve high streets but can the Secretary of State tell me how meanwhile spaces fit in the government's high street strategy?

04:27:46 - 04:28:33

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think this is really important and I congratulate the honorable member and the work that Bournemouth are doing and it sounds absolutely fantastic because these are exactly the sort of projects that we want to see as opposed to vapes and betting shops and other elements is what do we do with that space? And I think the measures that we've been outlining around the community right to buy, around the high street rental auctions, around giving local places practical powers and cutting business rates which we announced over summer is about making sure that local areas can use that space. And we have a high street strategy that's coming forward and I hope the honorable member will be engaging with my department to make sure that she could contribute that because she's clearly been able to demonstrate that in her local area.

04:28:33 - 04:29:29

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the Secretary of State will be aware, we're still awaiting a local government reorganization decision in Cambridgeshire and Peterborough. And to that extent, as I laid out in my Westminster Hall debate on Monday, I very much back a Huntingdonshire unitary authority because of the opportunities for growth that it will afford the region, including the delivery of the Ministry of Defence's Project Fairfax, which I had the opportunity to discuss with her colleague the Housing Minister earlier this year. So before she makes her final decision, could I invite her to speak to Huntingdonshire District Council to clarify any of the decisions that her predecessor required more clarity on before he could make his decision? And could I also ask her to assure my constituents that any decision will be a decision that is coterminous with the current district authority boundaries so that we don't lose any more time in disaggregating those functions because we've already lost two months ahead of the elections next May already?

04:29:29 - 04:29:46

Angela Rayner

I thank the honorable member for raising this important issue for his area and I know that my colleague the Minister responded to him as he outlined earlier this week and I know that he said that there would be an outcome by the end of October and he's done his job well in representing his constituents by raising that issue with me as the Secretary of State here today and I have noted it.

04:29:46 - 04:30:33

Perran Moon

Moraes, Madam Deputy Speaker, I really welcome the Prime Minister's commitment this week to work on Cornish devolution. But the Housing Minister has told me that, and he didn't make up the rules, that the population of Cornwall is too small to be granted a strategic place partnership, despite the fact that our population is greater than Iceland, Malta and Barbados and our lack of social housing is one of the greatest blockers to regeneration in Cornwall. So we're very, very keen to actually take up a strategic place partnership. Is there a chance that I could get a meeting with the Housing Minister or somebody from MHCLG to discuss our desire to have a strategic place partnership?

04:30:33 - 04:31:04

Angela Rayner

Madam Deputy Speaker, they might be small but they definitely mighty, that's what my observation is in regards to the honorable member and his colleagues around Cornwall. And absolutely, I will get the Minister to meet with him to see what more we could do. I know the honorable member and his colleagues have raised concerns around the devolution agenda and how we can make sure that devolution is there for Cornwall and fits with them as well, but I will make sure he gets a meeting with the relevant Minister.

04:31:04 - 04:31:28

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government appears to be very inconsistent in its approach to local government reorganization. Worcestershire is being split into two, Gloucestershire is being kept whole and the boundary of Leicester City Council is expanding outwards into surrounding areas. Can the Secretary of State rule out further expansion of Birmingham City Council into surrounding areas, including Worcestershire?

04:31:28 - 04:31:59

Angela Rayner

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think in response to a question earlier on local government reorganization, my principles around this is that it should benefit the people and the services of their local area. I have, I don't want to comment on specific local areas at the moment. I need to look at that. But what I would say is the principle should be around making sure it's not done to people, that local leaders are part of that process, and that this is about making sure that services deliver for the people in their local area.

04:31:59 - 04:32:05

Nusrat Ghani

Just to be clear, after the next speaker, I'll be coming to Steve Darling. Lee Anderson.

04:32:05 - 04:32:52

Lee Anderson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the Minister back to her place. I also agree with her comment, the situation we're facing on high streets isn't something that we've just created recently. It's something that's been inherited over years of austerity. And particularly in Stafford High Street, we welcome many of the initiatives taking place, particularly around vape shops, and also to a bit of a throwback one, the high street rental auctions, which are great. But could I ask the Minister if she could have a meeting with me, because my local authority are really keen to pursue this, but with LGR going through and some quite stretched personnel situations with LGR and austerity previously, they're finding it a little bit overwhelming in terms of the administration to do this.

It would be great if we could get that in Stafford, but maybe a little bit more support for councils like that.

04:32:52 - 04:33:17

Angela Rayner

I thank my honorable friend for that question, and can I commend her for her work she's doing in Stafford in representing them and appreciate that there's a lot going on at the moment. I really want her to be involved in the high streets strategy that we're coming forward with, and I will make sure that my department's in contact with her to make sure that she's fully engaged and that her local area can play a full role in making sure they shape the future of that and are heavily involved in that process.

04:33:17 - 04:33:18

Steve Darling.

04:33:18 - 04:34:03

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the Secretary of State is quite right to highlight the link between mental health illness and people who are street homeless. Sadly, over the 30 years that I've served the people of Torbay, I've seen that quadruple. And it feels to me that street homeless people are just the tip of the iceberg of levels of homelessness that we see in our communities. Will the Secretary of State give me some assurance that in a community like mine, where we only have 7% social rented housing compared to the national average of 18%, that areas like Torbay will be targeted with additional support for additional affordable and social rented housing?

04:34:03 - 04:35:11

Angela Rayner

Can I thank the honorable gentleman for raising this issue and the champion that he is in knowing and also recognizing the challenges that his local area faces. In terms of the announcement we made for the 442 million pound support with tackling rough sleeping this winter, again, that goes off a formula which recognizes the local area's challenges that they face. So I would, I will get my department to be in contact with him so he can understand how that will affect and he can shape what comes forward into his area. And he's absolutely right as well to recognize that the program has to have settled accommodation as well as an intensive wrap-around support to help people leave rough sleeping behind. And we have to learn the lessons of what happened in Greater Manchester and how they were able to achieve great outcomes for people.

And as I mentioned in my statement at the beginning, Madam Deputy Speaker, when I've met people whose lives have been transformed by it, I can understand why the Prime Minister has said nationally we want to make sure this happens.

04:35:11 - 04:35:12

Andrew Pakes.

04:35:12 - 04:35:56

Andrew Elliot Pakes

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. One of the most inspiring housing projects I've ever seen is Coin Street, a housing and worker cooperative, a few moments' walk away from this House on the banks of the thriving Thames in London.

They don't just build houses, they build homes and communities and give pride back to working people in the heart of London. That same spirit of pride goes through the pride in place funding that Peterborough has received and the ambitions of this government with devolution. Can my right honourable friend put on record her support for cooperative and mutual ideals as part of our devolution agenda and as part of our mission to rebuild communities in our country?

04:35:56 - 04:37:05

Angela Rayner

I thank my honourable friend for that and for him recognising some of the fantastic work that the cooperative movement have done. I think is our Prime Minister the first ever cooperative and Labour Prime Minister? I think he might be, Madam Deputy Speaker, without misleading the House. I think that's exactly, he's definitely one, I think he's the first. But Coin Street is what can happen when actually you have the homes and communities and you build that sense within that.

And the work we're doing with pride of place as well, which is about rejuvenating our local areas. And Madam Deputy Speaker, in my own local area in Tameside, I've seen people who have through the difficult times, and there has been some difficult times for our nation and our country recently, whether it's the COVID pandemic, the austerity years or what's been happening locally. They've come together and with pride of place there's been a recognition of not just looking at how we can stop the flow of some of the challenges, but how we can tackle and we can work together as a community to face them together. And I'm incredibly proud of the work that they do.

04:37:05 - 04:37:47

Alison Louise Hume

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome the government's decisive action over the summer to tackle wildfires, particularly placing a temporary ban on disposable barbecues? Last year a huge wildfire caused massive damage to the North York Moors near Whitby and the farming community played a vital role in supporting firefighters. But they're still out of pocket over a year later having suffered significant losses. Will my right honourable friend look at introducing grant schemes to help those affected by wildfires, similar to the ones available for major flooding events?

04:37:47 - 04:38:27

Angela Rayner

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm really sorry to hear about the situation especially in the North York Moors and the circumstances around the funding package. We're working closely with fire and rescue services to ensure the support is targeted at those facing the greatest operational pressures and we'll set out further details in due course, Madam Deputy Speaker. The current focus at the moment was about making sure that the support reaches the areas that need it most urgently, but I'll certainly take back what she said. And as I said, the Prime Minister is looking at the summit, wildfire summit that comes up this autumn, so hopefully we can make progress.

04:38:27 - 04:39:14

Nusrat Ghani

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And isn't it great to see our right honourable friend back in her place? It was also great to see the first allocations of the social and affordable housing programme last month. And we desperately need our share in Tipton, Wednesbury and Coseley, including at the Friar Park development of 650 new homes in my constituency. So I'd like to ask my right honourable friend, will she support the campaign that I've been running with our West Midlands Mayor to get Sandwell Council and Homes England to help local people stuck on waiting lists for years and raise the proportion of social housing on the Friar Park development to 50%?

04:39:14 - 04:39:54

Angela Rayner

Well, I wouldn't be on the, Madam Deputy Speaker, I wouldn't want to be on the wrong side of a campaigner with the formidable honourable member. And she is a formidable campaigner, so I reckon she has got all power to her elbow. And having the West Midlands Mayor on side as well is, I am confident that their campaign will come through. But she's absolutely right to raise not only the social and affordable housing programme and the work that we did in announcing the 10 billion pound of funding, Madam Deputy Speaker, but the work we're doing on mayoral planning and housing devolution. I think will put more power to their elbow as well and I'm fairly confident that they will win through.

04:39:55 - 04:40:38

Peter Swallow

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the 39 billion pound investment into the social and affordable homes programme that this government is making but my right honourable friend will know that for every social home we build when a social housing provider disposes of another not only are we losing valuable homes that could support residents in Bracknell Forest and across the country but we also need to replace that home. And that's why I'm calling on the government to go further than is currently envisaged in the social housing bill to clamp down on disposals. Will she continue to look at this with the housing minister so we can do everything we can to protect the social homes we already have as well as building more.

04:40:38 - 04:41:17

Angela Rayner

I thank my honourable friend for that and can I just put on record my thanks to ministers Madam Deputy Speaker including the housing minister in my time of absence who have seen the social housing bill going through this place and the other place which have strengthened significantly which will see actually council housing for the first time will start to see that there is more council housing being built that is being lost. That is welcome. That's not happened for a very long time and I'm sure the housing minister's heard everything that the honourable gentleman has raised today but I know that certainly his intention and it's definitely mine.

04:41:17 - 04:41:47

Nusrat Ghani

Can I thank the Secretary of State for her statement this afternoon. I will allow a couple of moments for the front benches to swap over before we move to the main business. The clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.

04:41:47 - 04:41:54

Antonia Romeo

Sporting Events Bill Lords second reading. Now.

04:41:54 - 04:41:58

Nusrat Ghani

Minister to move second reading Secretary of State Lisa Nandy.

04:41:58 - 04:44:46

Lisa Nandy

Madam Deputy Speaker I beg to move that this bill now be read a second time. Just over 14 years ago we lifted the curtain on the opening ceremony of the London 2012 Olympic Games. It did not disappoint. 29 gold medals Super Saturday Usain Bolt winning medal after medal sporting moments that will remain with us for the rest of our lives. But London 2012 did more than that.

It told our national story on the world stage and it sent a clear message to future British athletes that there should be no ceiling to their ambition. 14 years on from London 2012 I still meet athletes who talk about that moment as the moment that changed their lives forever where they were inspired where they saw something and where they thought I can do that. This is why major events matter. They bring world leading athletes and competitors to our shores. They show children across the country where ambition and talent can lead them.

And perhaps not all of those children will go on to be the Mo Farahs and Jess Ennises of their generation. But they will because of the power of sport go on to live richer larger lives. If done right these events leave lasting legacies they help to fund grassroots projects and they break down the barriers to opportunity. And we shouldn't be shy Madam Deputy Speaker about saying that here in the UK we are really really good at delivering them. From the Women's Rugby World Cup to the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow to the European Athletics Championships in Birmingham time and time again we have welcomed the best of the best and put on an incredible show.

And our government is not going to stop there. Over the next few years we'll host the 2028 Euros and the Tour de France Grand Depart.

But I want us to go further. I want us to be bolder and I want us to be bigger. I want us to harness the power of major events to build social cohesion, bring people together, to spread opportunity and to deliver long-lasting change to communities whose contribution has not been seen or valued for far too long. So alongside our bid for the FIFA 2035 Women's World Cup, I'm delighted that we've submitted a bid to host the World Athletics Championships in 2029. We're also clear that this government would love to see the Ryder Cup return to the UK, and we are continuing to explore at pace a bid for an Olympic and Paralympic Games in the north of England for the first time.

04:44:46 - 04:45:18

James William Naish

I thank her very much for giving way. I'm MP for Rushcliffe where we have Nottingham Forest City Ground, we have Trent Bridge, world-renowned cricket venue. But we also have the National Water Sports Centre, which is one of three locations in England with a two-kilometre rowing lake, but it has lacked investment over many years. But for us to be able to bid for a northern Olympics, we are likely to need that type of venue to be within our collective offer. So I wonder whether she'd be happy to meet with me and the Mayor of the East Midlands, Claire Ward, to look at the investment that needs to go into that site via UK Sport.

04:45:18 - 04:47:37

Lisa Nandy

I'd be very happy to offer him a meeting with the relevant minister and officials to discuss the specific site that he talks about. But he's absolutely right to say too that this is precisely the reason why this government believes in major events, because of the lasting legacy they have for our country and for our communities as well. And as we go on to explore the Olympic bid in the north of England, we are really clear that with that has to come the world-class infrastructure that we deserve, which doesn't just include sporting infrastructure but includes the transport infrastructure as well. And Madam Deputy Speaker, if we were successful to host these events, you have my commitment here today that every single one of those events we will use to their full potential, not just to drive growth but to deliver change and to enrich people's lives. We will learn from exceptional mayors like Steve Rotheram, who has not only launched a major event strategy to showcase Liverpool, but is deliberately anchoring major events and urban regeneration in some of the most historically deprived neighbourhoods in his city region.

I want major events to not only inspire and light up the world, but be a powerful lever for change in areas that have been neglected for far too long. But in order to do this, we need to make sure that we're in the best possible position to tap into the opportunities that exist. And that is what this bill is for and what this bill will achieve. It will deliver a framework for delivering major events, sending a clear message to event organisers across the world that the UK is serious about being a world leader in major sporting events. As well as providing important commercial protections, the bill will tackle ticket touting for qualifying events, complementing the government's broader legislation on secondary ticketing.

For too long, fans have been locked out, priced out and ripped off. Under the provisions set out in this bill, event organisers will maintain control of ticket distribution, helping more people to access tickets at face value and protect against price gouging which has harmed sporting events for too long.

04:47:37 - 04:48:17

Jim Dickson

Can I thank the Secretary of State for giving way and for the points she's making about ticket touting. I have the good fortune this Saturday to be travelling with the Crystal Palace faithful to Craven Cottage in search of our first three points of this season.

I've paid thirty pounds for my ticket as a Crystal Palace season ticket holder. Even a cursory glance on the internet shows me the same ticket, same equivalent ticket is on sale for a hundred and thirty, a hundred and forty, a hundred and fifty pounds at Craven Cottage. Isn't it totally wrong that this practice should continue and isn't it right that the government is really seeking to tackle this issue and clamp down on it?

04:48:17 - 04:49:07

Lisa Nandy

Can I thank him for that and can I also say that I think this is a matter that commands support across the whole House. I think we all believe actually that whether it's football or live music events, that these things belong to the fans and it is completely unacceptable that this has been allowed to happen in plain sight for too long. And may I also, Madam Deputy Speaker, just take this moment to reassure the House on this point because they will know that members will know that we introduced draft legislation in this session. We did so in order to ensure that that legislation was watertight, robust and would work and was subject to the full scrutiny of both Houses, but we do not intend to delay this legislation. The Prime Minister feels particularly passionate about this and we will treat this legislation with the priority that it deserves.

I give way.

04:49:07 - 04:49:28

Peter Wishart

Grateful to the Secretary of State for giving way and it's great that sport's going to be protected from the ticket touts, but as she said, all that music and live entertainment is getting is a draft bill, which seems very much like a delaying tactic in the long grass. Facing South Asia, will she give a guarantee and an assurance that we will see this bill and this will be introduced in the next session of Parliament?

04:49:28 - 04:49:56

Lisa Nandy

It is my intention that we introduce it as soon as possible and I think we may be in a position to do better than that, but I will update the House shortly. I have heard the strength of feeling on all sides of this House about this and I share it and we intend to treat this piece of legislation as a priority as a government in order to ensure that we get this onto the statute book without delay. Yes, of course.

04:49:56 - 04:50:52

Peter Swallow

I thank her for giving way, she's being incredibly generous. I think she's right to pay tribute to the spirit of the 2012 Olympic Games. I know that, I'm afraid to say as a teenager at the time, it changed my life and my ability to go to some of those events was very much transformative, not turning me into a world-class athlete, it has to be said, but nevertheless giving me a sense of pride in my country. And I share her ambition for us to bid for future events, future World Cups, hopefully future football World Cups as well as future Olympics. However, she will also know that many were very concerned at some of the scenes we saw at the World Cup this summer, not on the pitch, but in terms of the ticket sales and the high price.

Can she assure this House that if this government is bidding for events, we will always prioritize trying to make them as accessible as possible as part of our bid?

04:50:52 - 04:53:17

Lisa Nandy

Yeah, can I thank him for that and I hope I can reassure him on that. Just to give him an example, we have the immense privilege of hosting the Euros in 2028 and I've been really pleased to be working alongside the various sporting bodies who have given an assurance that they won't be using dynamic ticket pricing as part of that event. We will always do everything that we can to make sure that football remains for its fans. He will know that we introduced the Football Governance Act, one of the first things that the Minister for Sport and I did in order to protect football clubs from owners who prey on those clubs. We will not hesitate to pull every single lever we can to put fans first and can I thank him too for his advocacy on behalf of his own fans in his constituency, who I know will really appreciate it.

Alongside these measures, Madam Deputy Speaker, the bill will introduce provision to manage transport and traffic in relation to a sporting event in England, as well as bespoke funding powers for events in either England, Scotland or Northern Ireland. This will remove the current piecemeal reliance on powers from across multiple other acts and enable us to fund related activities beyond the sporting event itself. And finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I wanted to touch on the issue of including domestic events in these bill provisions, which we know was a regular concern raised in the other place. I want to take this opportunity to reassure this House that we have heard these concerns loud and clear. We recognise that there is a real opportunity here for some of our incredible domestic events.

We will therefore seek to address this issue through the passage of the bill, and I look forward to working with members across the House in order to achieve that. Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is a clear signal that this government is serious about major events and serious about harnessing the power of sport and culture to change our country and the lives of people in it for the better. Driven by a new enhanced Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, Britain will rebuild our sense of self-confidence and we will go out to deliver extraordinary major sporting events that light up not just our towns, villages and cities, but light up the world as well. This bill is about making sure that we are ready for those global moments and that when the world comes calling, this country will stand ready. For that reason, I commend this bill to the House.

04:53:17 - 04:53:25

Nusrat Ghani

The question is that the bill be now read a second time. Shadow Secretary of State, Rebecca Powell.

04:53:25 - 04:56:19

Rebecca Paul

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Sport occupies a very special place for us in this country. We all know the power it has to bring communities together, inspire millions of people to take part and provide some of those increasingly rare occasions when the whole country seems to stop and watch the whole thing, the same thing. Britain can also take enormous pride in its place in the sporting world. There is no doubt that we excel across the board and the patriotism such events can generate is truly wonderful.

We are home to Wimbledon, the Open, the British Grand Prix and the London Marathon. We have successfully hosted Olympic and Paralympic Games, Commonwealth Games, World Cups and European Championships, and we do it exceptionally well. These events are part of our national culture. They create memories which last for generations, inspire children to pick up a racket, a football or a pair of running shoes and showcase the very best of Britain to audiences around the world. Take by way of example the London Olympics and Paralympics, which I know the Secretary of State has just mentioned and we obviously share some similar memories here.

I think it's fair to say before it started there was a bit of grumbling about the disruption, the cost and impact in even the logo, some of you may remember. But once it started, the overwhelming pride we all felt in our home nation, our capital and our sportsmen and women was something I'm sure that none of us will forget. It was a truly momentous once-in-a-lifetime event that made me so proud to be British. And those of us, including me, who worked in London at that time certainly enjoyed the instruction to try and work at home during that busy period. But these big sporting events are not only sources of pride and joy for millions.

Taken as a whole, sport is also a roaring economic engine. The government's latest estimate suggests that the wider sport sector directly contributed 63.2 billion to the UK economy in 2024 and accounted for 1.3 million jobs. Major sporting events alone can generate very considerable returns for our country. In 2023, 10.8 million of UK sport and government investment supported 16 major sporting events which generated an estimated 373 million for our economy.

The Birmingham Commonwealth Games are a particularly striking example. Research found that the games contributed almost 1.2 billion to the overall UK economy as well as nearly 80 million in social value. Those are very substantial numbers. They represent money being spent in hotels, restaurants and pubs, business for suppliers, employment in event management, broadcasting and security, and visitors coming to parts of the country they might otherwise never have visited. I will of course give way.

04:56:19 - 04:56:55

Joanne Sarah Dyke

I thank the shadow Secretary of State and welcome her to her place. Just on that point on the economic benefit, obviously I refer to my register of interests, but as a Member of Parliament for Silverstone, the Grand Prix has had a huge boost to the local economy in our area and it's a vital part. But the only reason that it is on the annual calendar as it is is because of the hard work actually of the team to keep it there. There's no guarantee that we will have it every year. So I very much welcome the Secretary of State looking at the widening the definition of major events to capture, you know, Silverstone because I think it's absolutely vital and so valuable to our sporting calendar.

04:56:55 - 04:59:43

Rebecca Paul

I thank my honourable friend for making that point. I know she is passionate about Silverstone and she's absolutely right in all the points that she makes. We must never be complacent about it and we must strengthen and build upon all of the great sporting events that we have in this country. Sport also strengthens Britain's reputation overseas. Few countries combine our extraordinary sporting heritage, our wonderful venues, our broadcasting expertise, our enthusiastic crowds and our experience of putting on major events the whole world wants to see.

It is therefore very much in our national interest to ensure that the United Kingdom remains one of the best places in the world to host these big events. So that is the context in which the opposition approaches this bill. We support its underlying objective and we will support its second reading. It absolutely makes sense and is in this country's interest to create a standing legislative framework of this kind. When the United Kingdom bids to host a major international sporting event, the governing body will commonly require guarantees from the host country covering matters such as ticketing, commercial rights, advertising and transport.

Historically, Parliament has often had to legislate specifically for individual events. There is an obvious inefficiency in recreating substantially similar provisions every time Britain secures another major tournament. If we know that certain protections are repeatedly required, it is reasonable to place a common framework on the statute book which can then be tailored to the needs of individual events. That should make Britain a more competitive prospective host and give international sporting organisations greater confidence that the protections they require will be available. And that confidence is vital as international competition to host major sport is fierce.

Countries across the world understand the prestige these events bring, the visitors they attract and the economic activity they generate. We cannot simply assume that Britain will continue to win the rights to host them if we become less accommodating than our competitors. We need to make the strongest possible case for the UK and part of that is demonstrating that when we make commitments as a host nation, we have the legal framework to deliver them quickly and effectively. With that objective in mind, there is much within the detail of the bill's proposed framework that we support. It is right that organisers should have effective tools to prevent professional ticket touts exploiting supporters.

It is right that genuine sport sponsors who may invest very significant sums in making the event possible should receive reasonable protection against businesses falsely passing themselves off as official partners. And it is plainly sensible to have the capacity to make temporary transport and traffic arrangements when hundreds of thousands of additional spectators may be moving around a city or region.

I will of course give way.

04:59:43 - 05:00:19

James William Naish

Thanks very much for giving way. And the Secretary of State moved on very quickly earlier because I just wanted to specifically talk about transport arrangements because for constituencies like mine where you've got three international venues in very close proximity, actually for the residents that live in that area, it can be extremely difficult. And I just wondered whether the Shadow Secretary of State would agree with me that enforcement powers for local councils to make sure that the plans that are put in place around transport are extremely important to make sure that the residents who are hosting these major sporting events can live alongside them.

05:00:19 - 05:07:21

Rebecca Paul

Um, I thank the honorable member for making that point. And I think it is really important that we explore this in a lot more detail as we go through the committee stage. And obviously it requires a bit of balance. We need to consider both sides of it in order to get to the right place with all of this. But this is a great starting position and hopefully we will have a lot more detailed discussions as the bill moves through the House, assuming it goes through at second reading, which it looks likely to, I would, I feel at this point.

So, we are not concerned about the concept of the bill. Indeed, colleagues in the other place approached it in exactly that spirit, supporting the principle while working constructively to improve the legislation. And on that point, I particularly want to acknowledge the important work undertaken in the other place to ensure that the framework can benefit not only major one-off international tournaments, but the great recurring sporting events which are already woven into British national life, which the Culture Secretary has already raised in her opening speech. As originally drafted, the bill risked producing the rather peculiar result that an international tournament visiting Britain for the first time might qualify for these protections, while Wimbledon, the Open, the London Marathon, or the British Grand Prix could not. That was a significant gap, and opposition peers, including Baroness Evans and Lord Parkinson, worked closely with colleagues across the House and with the sporting sector to address it.

The All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club, the ECB, the FA, the London Marathon, Silverstone, the R&A, the Rugby Football League, the Rugby Football Union, the Sport and Recreation Alliance, and UK Athletics were among those supporting a widening of the framework to include repeat events. These great recurring events are not simply fixtures in our sporting calendar. They are strategic national assets. They attract international audiences, support thousands of jobs, generate significant economic value, and serve to showcase Britain around the world. We should therefore always seek to maximize the opportunities and returns they bring.

As originally drafted, the bill was principally aimed at major one-off or infrequent international events. The amendments made in the Lords widened that framework so that our great recurring UK sporting events of national or international importance, such as Wimbledon, the Open, the London Marathon, or the British Grand Prix, can also ask to benefit from its protections. That does not now mean that every protection in the bill will automatically apply to every one of those events every year. Rather, it means that where a major recurring event can demonstrate a genuine need for one or more parts of the framework, it can ask the government to apply them. Ministers must then agree, and any use of the framework remains subject to parliamentary approval.

Baroness Evans put the principle neatly when she described the Lords' approach as providing opportunity, not obligation. That is the sensible and proportionate approach.

There are inevitably some further areas which we will want to examine as the bill enters committee. That is not because we oppose the powers themselves but because a permanent legislative framework needs to strike the right balance between giving organizers the protections they require and avoiding unnecessary burdens on those affected. The first is the impact on existing businesses. One of the central reasons we want major sporting events in Britain is the economic activity that they generate. We want visitors filling hotels, restaurants and pubs.

We want local businesses benefiting from increased footfall. We want traders to share in the opportunities created when tens or hundreds of thousands of people arrive in an area. There will plainly be occasions where crowd safety, security or legitimate commercial arrangements mean that some restrictions are necessary but the government's own impact assessment assumes that a substantial proportion of street traders in affected areas may be unable to trade while restrictions operate. Colleagues in the other place pressed ministers on that point and secured a useful change requiring existing trading licenses to be taken into account. The government also committed to work with organizers and local authorities to consider alternative arrangements where an existing trader cannot remain in their usual location.

At committee stage we will want to make sure that the practical arrangements around notice, authorizations and treatment of existing businesses are fair and proportionate. Same principle applies to advertising. We support action against genuine ambush marketing. Official sponsors make substantial investments in major sport and are entitled to protection. At the same time the framework should operate sensibly for existing advertisers and should distinguish between falsely claiming an official association with an event and legitimate commercial activity, for example a company truthfully promoting an athlete whom it genuinely sponsors.

Lord Parkinson raised concerns from the Advertising Association in the Lords and the government undertook further engagement with the industry which we welcome. It would be useful to have an update from the culture secretary on how those discussions have progressed. Again this strikes me as exactly the kind of detailed matter that can be worked through constructively in committee. Finally clause 25 gives government a broad standing power to provide financial assistance in connection with sporting events. There is a certain lack of clarity here around what the criteria and eligibility for such payments would be and I would ask again that this is considered further at committee stage.

In closing. We all want Britain to remain one of the finest places in the world to host major sport. We all want to attract new World Cups, European Championships and other global events. This is good for the sporting sector, our economy, the country and our people. We are fortunate that Britain starts from a position of considerable strength already with its world-class venues, experienced organizers, passionate spectators, internationally recognized events and a sporting heritage which few countries can match.

But now we must capitalize and further build upon those strengths to fully unleash the potential of the sector and this bill can meaningfully contribute to this. But our task now is to preserve the improvements made to the bill in the other place and ensure they deliver the intention of ensuring that our great recurring events are properly covered too. We support the principle of the bill. We support the ambition behind it and we will support its second reading today while working constructively with the government to improve and clarify it further as it proceeds through the house. Thank you.

05:07:21 - 05:12:33

Jim Dickson

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Major sporting events are something that we do very well as a country. I think everybody in this House is agreed on that and making it more straightforward for us to host them is vital. So I really welcome this bill. I need to declare at the outset that I'm a member of the England Football Supporters Club, or the England Football Supporters Travel Club as it now is, and a season ticket holder at the home of quality football in South London, that is Crystal Palace.

And I, and I know very many of my constituents, a lot of them Dartford Football Club supporters, but supporters of many other clubs as well, are united in hugely looking forward to Euro 2028 being hosted across England, Scotland, Wales, and the Republic of Ireland. And hopefully home advantage will enable England to go one further than they were able to in 2024. Hosting major sporting events like the Euros and the recent Women's Rugby World Cup and Cricket World Cup has the potential to inspire the next generation of young athletes. Anything we can do to increase the level of physical activity across society and most of all in young people is important and supports our efforts of the 10-year plan to create a healthier society. And I'm really pleased that sporting legacy and our young people and inclusion of our young people in sporting activity is a core part of the government's objectives in attracting major sporting events.

And I also know that the nation's most vivid memories are often sporting ones. I was privileged to be in the stadium when Jess Ennis won her 2012 heptathlon gold and was there, with apologies to Scottish colleagues, to witness that goal by Paul Gascoigne against the old enemy in Euro 96. But it's not just the memories. These events help to illustrate why the UK remains such a well-placed country to host international sporting events. We have a range of excellent, large, atmospheric stadiums, a vibrant hospitality sector and brilliant fans, while also being a transport hub that much of the world can easily travel to.

The British public embrace major sporting events. Take the excellent and record-breaking crowds for last year's Women's Rugby World Cup as an example. Birmingham's European Athletics Championship as mentioned by the Secretary of State last month saw mostly, mostly full stadium. And can I just give a big shout-out to Dartford Harriers' Emily Newnham for winning a brilliant silver medal in the 400 meters hurdles. The British public want us to bid for international events.

It's wonderful to hear that the Olympics is a target for this government in the next decade. I also believe we should be targeting another men's football World Cup in the late 2030s or in the 2040s, alongside our bid to host the Women's World Football Cup. And of course I hugely welcome London's bid to bring the World Athletics Championship back to the UK in 2029. I want to pay tribute to the efforts of the England team at the recent World Cup tournament in Mexico, the USA and Canada, who took us close to repeating the 1966 triumph, as close as we've got in my lifetime. But it was a great World Cup.

However, there is no doubt that many ordinary fans were priced out of attending. As a member of the aforementioned England Supporters Club, I could see the comments on our Facebook page over the summer. Many loyal fans simply couldn't afford to go. And so speaking of extortionate ticket prices, ticket touts selling football tickets at inflated prices outside grounds or online remains far too prevalent. And despite the efforts of football clubs, and I can attest to what Crystal Palace as an example have been doing, ensuring that you have to be a club member to buy any spare tickets.

But even where these efforts are in place, it's still the case that just about any Premier League match can be found in terms of tickets at an inflated price via StubHub and Viagogo and some of the other platforms, let alone via illegal touts. And it's something that we have to address and I'm pleased the government is doing that. And it was noticeable that in July it was reported that more than 1.2 million pounds in assets were seized and 432 lifetime bans issued as part of joint work between Liverpool FC and Merseyside Police investigating ticket touting. But a change in the law is still needed. That's why the measures in this bill are so welcome.

It's long overdue that we create a criminal offense for the unauthorized resale of tickets for a sporting event. And I hope that we will see more joint working between the police and sports clubs building on these new powers to make more tickets come within the reach of fans. So I look forward to more major events being held in this country and more opportunities for us as a country and as these sporting events to inspire a new generation.

05:12:33 - 05:12:36

Anna Sabin

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Anna Sabin.

05:12:36 - 05:16:18

Layla Moran

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Trying to speak in Parliament after developing vocal cord paralysis feels like a major sporting event, so let's see how I get on. In the last 15 years, we've seen over four separate acts of Parliament passed to deliver four separate events. Each one of these bills essentially repeated the same core provisions from scratch through bespoke legislation. So this bill is a welcome change that will make it easier for the government to deliver major events.

But for the Lib Dems, there's a few areas where we think the bill could be taken further. Firstly, the scope of the bill. I'm glad to see the government has accepted a Liberal Democrat amendment in the other place so that this legislation now applies to world-famous domestic events that happen every year in the UK.

Big events should never hollow out local businesses or grassroots sports and culture. The Lib Dems therefore seek clarification from the government that commercial deals under the frameworks of this bill treat SMEs fairly and ensure that grassroots organisations see a tangible benefit from large sporting events in the UK. For the Lib Dems this bill is not simply about making international events easier to host. It's an opportunity to make them more accessible, more affordable, and more enjoyable for the very people who make British sporting and other culture what it is. And that's what I'll be pushing for as this bill passes through this House.

05:16:18 - 05:16:19

Imogen Walker.

05:16:19 - 05:19:53

Imogen Walker

Thank you. We are a nation of sports fans, Madam Deputy Speaker, and for good reason. Because from a kickabout in the local park to the great tournaments, getting together to watch sport or play sport brings joy to millions. And when Scotland went to the World Cup this summer, football even united the Scottish MPs on this side of the chamber with honourable members opposite, and that, Madam Deputy Speaker, is quite the achievement. And at home, we were so proud that Lewis Ferguson from the town of Quarter and a former Hamilton Accies player was part of the squad.

He took our hopes and dreams with him to the States, and he did us proud. Evie Mackie from Lanark represented Scotland in the Commonwealth Games, another local talent to make it to the international stage on the back of her hard work, determination, and the support of the brilliant Lanark Amateur Swimming Club. So these incredible athletes have not only done Lanark, Hamilton, and Scotland proud, but they've shown the way for the next generation of athletes who deserve the chance to compete at every level. And so the provision in this bill for the Scottish government to fund sporting events really matters. Our pride in our nations, our teams, and our sportspeople cuts across political boundaries and is a power that sport has, which is rarely seen elsewhere.

And when the Hamilton Accies ran into difficulties that threatened their very future, the fans made it clear what the club meant to them. One young fan, just 18 years old, wrote to me to say: I was introduced to the club by my father, and I have been forever indebted to him for making me an Accies man. It gave me a platform to develop relationships with others, take in live sport, and to help me understand the true meaning of joy when those victories occurred or goals hit the back of the net. I believe the club has a massively positive impact on the mental health of many people, man and woman, every week.

Win, lose or draw, the club gives people a place to go and get away from the stresses of employment, unemployment, addiction, financial stresses, grief, and general loneliness. Which puts it very well, I think, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it was fans like this who came together to show their love for the club, overcame all the odds, and after several months at another ground, brought the Accies home this season to Douglas Park. Sport is universal and it cuts across divides. Lewis and Evie show that you don't need to be from a big city to reach the top and that the talent we have in Hamilton and Clyde Valley is world-class.

But let's be clear. Young people don't train day in, day out to make a profit for ticket touts. They've dedicated their lives to pursue a dream. A dream that gives people hope and inspiration and something to believe in, not to buy some crook another Merc. So this bill's important.

Cracking down on ticket touts and building on the UK's track record of hosting major events, bringing people together and supporting local economies.

This is how we will inspire and support the next generation and make sure that their hard work leaves a legacy and keeps dreams alive.

05:19:53 - 05:25:02

Nigel Huddleston

Nigel Huddleston.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I refer honorable members to my register of members' interest. I've particularly enjoyed the reminiscing about London 2012 going on today. I actually remember Super Saturday very well because I was at the beach volleyball watching it just up the road, of course, at Horse Guards Parade. I think it was the third time I went to the beach volleyball for some reason that attracted me quite a lot. A lot of good events going on, but unlike the honorable gentleman who spoke earlier on, I was very much not a teenager at the time.

And could I take the opportunity as well to just reiterate and repeat something I said this morning, Madam Deputy Speaker, and welcome the Shadow Secretary of State to her role. It is an incredibly, incredibly broad, fascinating, but also daunting brief, and I think anybody who's been involved in DCMS recognizes that, but she will both enjoy it and I wish her the very best of luck and any way I can support her, she will always have my support. I'd also like to thank my former team as well, including the honorable member for Old Bexley and Sidcup, who is sitting there, of course, as well, the honorable member for the Isle of Wight East and Lord Parkinson and the broader team who did such a good job at supporting me personally, but most important the sectors. And I would also like to pay tribute again, and I think already we can see there will be a good working relationship between opposition and government in those areas where party politics is not relevant. And that is often the case in DCMS matters.

That relationship between government and opposition is important. It's not always seen in the chamber, it's often at events where you're together or along the corridors, but it is important that dynamic happens. I'm not going to lay it on too thick. I'm not going to say I'm going to ever vote for the honorable ladies, but I think the most important thing to recognize is that you can be opponents but also be civil to each other and decent and quite frankly nice people, and sometimes people don't always see that in this place. Politics is politics, there will always be areas of disagreement, but a constructive relationship where a constructive relationship is required is vital for British democracy and long may that continue.

Now, I do also empathize with the minister, by the way, I've been there, the constant disagreements, challenges when it comes to asking the Treasury for money as well. But let's stick to this key theme here and about this cooperation. This is a bill that I support, that obviously there's a tone today of general cooperation for the very reasons so many colleagues have already articulated, that the UK rightfully has a world-renowned global reputation for doing these kind of international sporting events not only well, but superbly well. And when we're committed, and indeed we're all committed to delivering international sporting events, and we need to seek even more opportunities to do so because they do create these genuine lasting legacies and inspire that next generation of talent. And sport interest, engagement and participation can have a really positive impact as well, of course, on the nation's well-being in terms of inspiring a more active and healthy nation.

It can also lead the way on inclusivity, and think of the amazing achievements in the integrated Commonwealth Games where able-bodied and para-athlete events are held alongside each other. And Britain has a proud reputation for not only investing in para-sport, sponsoring para-athletes, but also broadcasting it on key channels at peak times, and that is something I'll come on to again shortly. And of course, hosting major international sporting events makes huge economic sense for UK PLC, as several members have mentioned today. When done well, they can be profitable, and the multiplier impact on spend on travel and hospitality in pubs, bars, restaurants, hotels, of course, from both domestic and international visitors can be absolutely huge.

And we must remember that inbound visitor spend is export revenue. And every year, for example, over a million people come to the UK primarily to watch a Premier League game, generating over a billion pounds for the UK economy and again, that is export revenue. So this bill is not a trivial one. And of course with government support, we already have major events secured including the Euros in 2028 as well as the FIFA Women's World Cup in 2035. And when I say government support, it's also important to recognise that we mean multiple governments because the nature of the bidding process, the extraordinarily long timelines for some of these, often requires not only the government to commit to them but the opposition as well.

And those who are having the events or holding the events and we're bidding into them often want to see that cross-party support because of course there could be a different government by the time of the next event. And I'm certainly hoping and planning, planning that will be the case. Yes. So perhaps we can turn the tables and we on this side could benefit from your hard work rather than the other way around. I will give way.

05:25:02 - 05:25:42

James William Naish

I must say I think that was actually the case with the 2012 games if I'm not mistaken in that it was won under a Labour government but delivered under his government. But the point I wanted to make was around the kind of development of long-term vision because certainly in Nottingham and Nottinghamshire, we're doing a lot of work at the moment on something called the Trent Sports District which is taking our excellent venues and painting out a long-term vision for what they can do for our city and for our area. And that's exactly what he's saying about individual events. So would he agree with me that actually using sport as a regeneration tool and a visioning tool is an excellent way of bringing everybody together cross-party for long-term benefits for an area?

05:25:42 - 05:31:12

Nigel Huddleston

I do indeed agree with the honourable gentleman. And I think the other point he's making as well is sometimes when we do these events it's often one individual city or one particular location that gets a lot of the focus. What I quite like at the moment, there does seem to be a trend even with hosting major international sporting events and we even saw it this year with the World Cup of multiple venues, often multiple countries and of course we've often bid and continue to bid on a four nations approach as well. That can also be beneficial. Goes back to that point, the economic benefit can be so considerable that it's great if we can spread that quite frankly outside of the M25 as well and it's important we do do that.

And I don't want to be negative about London, we've got amazing sports venues in London but we always need to think about London plus if London is the anchor. Now as the former sports minister overseeing the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games, I'm very familiar with and therefore welcome many of the framework provisions that go deep into the weeds of event organisation on matters such as ticket sales, unauthorised advertising, brand protection, transport logistics and so on that previously had to be considered in discrete bills for each and every event which clearly doesn't make sense and therefore the basic logic for this bill is very sensible. And whilst I'm broadly supportive of the bill, very much along the lines of what my honourable friend the Shadow Secretary of State said earlier on, there are some changes we would like to see and in particular the concerns expressed by many in the Lords that the definition of events in the bill initially seemed to cover a way too narrow group. But therefore I really appreciate the Secretary of State's comments and I remember us having a conversation about this at Silverstone that actually there is some logic to include many of those important domestic events.

And as the Shadow Secretary of State pointed out, that doesn't necessarily mean everything all the time, but we can pick and choose elements of the bill. That always causes complexities in bills like this because it can cause some challenges and therefore we probably need to build in some flexibility that I'm sure as we go later on in the bill's stages we'll be able to work out. But I think there's a very clear, strong feeling on behalf of those major domestic sport events that were mentioned, Wimbledon, Grand Prix and so on, that we do right by them as well. And again, quite frankly, make it easier for government as well in dealing with these things. So again, let's just use a hefty dose of common sense in these things.

And there are a couple of other sports-related matters that should be considered in the wider context of this bill that I'd like to raise, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I would genuinely appreciate the Minister's views on these in her closing comments. Now, first, the Minister will be aware of speculation about allowing alcohol sales at football games. And the Conservatives, of course, did introduce, I say the Conservatives, the honourable member sitting in front of me, introduced an amendment to the Football Governance Bill last year for a consultation on lifting the alcohol ban on top-tier football. Now, unfortunately, that amendment, despite quite a lot of agreement cross-party, that amendment was shot down then by the then Labour government.

So will the Minister now reconsider this and is this bill an appropriate vehicle or opportunity to consider that? For example, would alcohol sales therefore be restricted at some of the events that we are talking about in this bill? Now, similarly, is the government reconsidering as well the 3:00 PM blackout rule? Nothing to do with this bill, I just wanted to take the opportunity to put the Minister on the spot. And finally, I'd also like to touch on something that has been mentioned before on the listed events regime and ask the Minister if this is being reviewed, because particularly in the context of the events being considered in this bill.

Because if there is government support for hosting an event and taxpayers' money being put into it, there is a reasonable expectation that attendance and viewing of that event should therefore be maximised in country. And indeed, to maximise the overall benefit and the inspiration these things can have. And therefore, is this a good time to reconsider the listed events regime, particularly for events supported with taxpayers' money held in the home nations? Now, BBC Sport's fantastic coverage of the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games achieved record-breaking audiences on TV, streaming and online. And I was fortunate, and I know as the Ministers were, to attend the Glasgow Commonwealth Games this year.

And the city and the organisers put on an absolutely fantastic show, particularly given the circumstances of how they came about, which I think most people are familiar with. So it was a deliberately smaller-scale event than obviously the Birmingham games and so on. And while the coverage on TNT Sports and Channel 5 was good, it did not get the breadth of coverage and therefore achieve the level of awareness in country that we would have had, for example, had the BBC or another major broadcaster secured those rights. Which does raise the question about what the BBC is bidding for and how much it is bidding, but that is definitely a debate for another day, Madam Deputy Speaker, though an important one. And I will end there, Madam Deputy Speaker, by confirming that I broadly support this bill.

And I certainly look forward to engaging constructively with the Ministers as it goes through its remaining stages. And I hope we will see some amendments supported by all parties. Thank you.

05:31:12 - 05:39:28

Caroline Dinenage

Dame Caroline Dinenage.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I just first of all say what a pleasure it is to follow my honourable friend from Droitwich and Evesham in welcoming my other honourable friend as Shadow Secretary of State to her role. I know she will be excellent.

I also want to pay tribute to him as her predecessor. He has, he was an exceptional minister. He was an exceptional Shadow Secretary of State. He's always been an exceptional champion for the sectors that the DCMS represent, and I know he will be a formidable and quite terrifying backbencher as well. So, it's a pleasure to hear him.

At the risk of universal agreement breaking out in all corners of this room, can I also say that I widely support this bill as well. Sport is one of our country's greatest strengths, one of our most successful worldwide exports. Major sporting occasions represent such a huge source of national pride, as the Secretary of State said, inspiration, massive driver of tourism, investment, jobs, and when they are done correctly, their legacy can just have tentacles that go on forever. And we are just world-class at delivering them. We know that on the world stage, British athletes and sportsmen are out there representing us with just the most phenomenal success.

Now, I was exceptionally proud of the UK deaf athletes who claimed 12 medals, including five gold at the Tokyo 2025 Deaflympics, despite the fact, Madam Deputy Speaker, that they receive no public funding. They are elite athletes who should make our country very proud. I say this as a gentle reminder, given that sport's in the theme today, as a gentle reminder to the Minister to look again at their eligibility for UK Sport funding. Our strength, Madam Deputy Speaker, is reflected not only in our participation and our elite performance, but also in our ability to host and showcase some of the world's most significant sporting events. This small island gave the world some of our best-loved sports, from football to cricket, lawn tennis to boxing, rugby to snooker.

We may not always lead the world like we did in those halcyon days of the 1700s, Madam Deputy Speaker, when the small village of Hambledon in Hampshire, known as the cradle of cricket, took on the rest of the world and won. But iconic British fixtures from the Premier League to Wimbledon, the British Grand Prix to the Grand National are globally synonymous with their sport. They bring people to our shores, they generate economic growth, they inspire participation, and they project the United Kingdom's reputation around the world. And Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a reputation which is under pressure. The gap in soft power between the UK and our competitor nations is closing.

Brand Finance have said that the UK has recorded a sharper than average drop in soft power, and the British Council said that the lead Western nations, including the UK, hold over our competitors is narrowing. And that's why, can I gently say to the front bench, it is very disappointment that the government's action, very disappointing that the government's action on soft power has failed to keep pace with its rhetoric. I really welcomed the creation of the Soft Power Council, but it cannot even claim to be a talking shop when it has only met four times in the last 18 months and the Culture Secretary, who I admire enormously and chairs it, has only attended twice. It needs to put together a coherent strategy, and if it did, then major events would play a significant role. Our committee, the DCMS Select Committee, Madam Deputy Speaker, will shortly be reporting back on a recent inquiry we did into major events.

The UK's event sector is an engine for so much growth, but has so far received limited attention from the government until now. And they could be doing so much more to unleash its potential and ease some of its constraints. So this bill is a really good place to start to address that balance, particularly when, when done well, the ratio of investment to return on these kind of things is so high. It makes sense for the government to do all it can to attract opportunities to hold all kinds of major events, particularly sport. The Sport and Recreation Alliance told us in our Select Committee inquiry that dedicated major events legislation would strengthen the UK's global position as a key destination for major sporting events.

So I really support the principle of this bill. Bespoke legislation for individual events creates an opportunity to remove any uncertainty, anything that is unwieldy and unpractical when we're doing these individual pieces of legislation every time. This framework introduced by these new legislation is welcomed by everybody, by organisers, rights holders, sponsors, hosts.

And I do think that our noble colleagues in the other place made such important improvements by widening the legislation to include other substantial annual events. It's actually, if I can be honest, something that our committee would have introduced had it not already been done. I suppose we shouldn't be at all surprised that amendments that were proposed by the Paralympic medalist Baroness Tanni Grey-Thompson would have won this race. As she said, legislation in this area does not come along often and we must take advantage of this opportunity. So when Parliament has the chance to establish this framework, we should ensure that it is robust enough not only to support the next tournament but the ecosystem that exists all year.

And in its amended form, the benefits of the provisions in this bill, creating offenses on ticket touting, ambush marketing, unauthorized trading and association, will not just be felt by these one-off totemic events but by the stalwarts as well. And that's why I'm so grateful to the Secretary of State for her signal today that the government does not intend to remove these amendments made in the House of Lords. Throughout our own inquiry, Madam Deputy Speaker, the evidence we received underline a few wider concerns. The major events sector does not always feel recognized as a strategic national asset. Particularly organizers outside of the world of sport, they often feel excluded from national planning and policy makers.

The flower shows, cultural festivals, music festivals, military tattoos, they attract tourists, create jobs, bring people together, and yet many witnesses told us that they don't feel recognized in the same way as their sporting counterparts. And across the board, the event sector are asking for better coordination, the removal of barriers that prevent them from reaching their economic potential. And witness after witness called for better cross-government working, clearer points of contact, streamlined approvals, and a more coherent long-term strategy. So I appreciate that this bill aims to make the United Kingdom more competitive in winning bids to host international sporting events, but it doesn't do much to alleviate the concerns that we've heard from other event organizers across the country about the things like the weight of bureaucracy, the costs of policing, the integration of events with transport plans, to name just a few. I was also grateful during the passage of this bill in the other place to hear that the government had promised a major events strategy, which we really welcome.

And we hope that the government will lean heavily on the conclusions that we draw in our select committee report and the recommendations that we make when it comes out. I also want to say one final thing, Madam Deputy Speaker, about the contribution of business events. They really shouldn't be forgotten. Conferences, exhibitions, trade fairs, they generate huge economic value for the UK and bring in massive inward investment. Over a million conferences and business meetings take place in the UK every year.

It generates 33.6 billion pounds for the UK economy. Given its firepower, it's almost laughable that there isn't an industrial strategy for this alone. Excuse me, Madam Deputy Speaker. Given its firepower, it's almost laughable there isn't an industrial strategy for this sector alone. The business events sector means business and we'll shortly be releasing a standalone report on this, which I hope the government is minded to take note of.

In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is a very welcome step. It has the potential to strengthen the UK's ability to compete for and host major sporting events. It provides a more consistent framework and reflects the importance of sport to our economies, to our communities, and to our international standing. But it needs to be the starting point of a conversation. And for those reasons, I support the bill's objective, welcome the improvements made in the other place, and encourage the government to see this as the beginning of a wider and more ambitious vision for the future.

05:39:27 - 05:39:28

Pete Wishart.

05:39:28 - 05:40:46

Peter Wishart

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And not wanting to make this some sort of grand Kumbaya, let's all hold hands moment, I also very much support this bill. And I'm pretty certain that the right honourable lady will secure the necessary legislative consent motion from the Scottish Parliament, given the devolved nature of so much of what's been included in this. And there's very few opportunities the Secretary of State's going to get to have such buy-in from everybody here. So I hope she enjoys that moment.

And I think I can say with some great deal of confidence that it won't last all that long. But it surely is in everybody's interest to create a legislative approach that can better equip the UK to attract and deliver the biggest international sporting events. And we're very fortunate in the UK, of course, because we've got a great global reputation for being able to produce these events and put on some stunning sporting events right throughout the decades. And I think that's something that we'll be able to build on with this piece of legislation. What this bill will hopefully do is just bolster that reputation and ensure that we will be near the top when it comes to being able to be one of the contenders for major international sporting events in the future.

Well, the honourable gentleman just came into the chamber, but given that we've got probably the necessary time, I will give way to the honourable gentleman.

05:40:46 - 05:41:05

Speaker 230

I'm glad the honourable gentleman is so positive about the UK, and I wanted to underscore that. But also say, as a former diplomat, it was great to see the role that these events play in our soft power. And I wonder if you might comment on how important these events are for Scotland and for the whole UK in promoting who we are in the world. Hear, hear.

05:41:05 - 05:48:27

Peter Wishart

I appreciate the efforts that are getting made to make all parts of the United Kingdom are promoted adequately. And I'm sure, like me, he will be watching very carefully that Scotland gets promoted in the events that come forward in the future. But I think it's fair to say, and others have mentioned this, that nothing enthuses and unites the whole of the UK, if I could use that term again, than sporting success and people who are representing our nations as prize athletes and winning medals. And it was great to see in the course of the last few months that happening in both the European Championship and the Commonwealth Games. And we even got to a World Cup this year for the first time in 28 years, and where the Tartan Army did its usual job of, like, charming the olive Boston and Miami in its usual antics, which I think thrilled and excited and impressed so many of our American colleagues.

Unfortunately, it wasn't translated onto activities on the football field, and so we'll probably just maybe leave that at that. But it was a huge unifying force, and I think the honourable lady's quite right that it unites all of us, from whatever political persuasion and whatever side of constitutional debate you're on, in support behind our national side. But this year in Scotland also, as the right honourable lady referenced, Scotland also stepped in at the last moment to host the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow. And I won't go over the reasons why we got there, but I just think we should all just be grateful that Glasgow did what Glasgow does, and which is to step in at the last moment. And I think we could safely say that Glasgow rescued the Commonwealth Games.

And I think the model that's been adopted for a what's been described as a more scaled-down version of the games will be the blueprint as we go forward now. And I've certainly heard other nations that are interested in bidding in the future saying they'll look very closely at the model that was adopted in Glasgow. The games were an overwhelming success and perfectly showcased Glasgow, while allowing Scots and those from the rest of the UK to see first-hand a range of sports that caught the imagination and sports that we might not normally watch, which is only available with the Commonwealth Games. And where Glasgow stepped up to host these games, the BBC most definitely did not. This was the first Commonwealth Games in 72 years that the BBC didn't fully cover.

And that was because they offered what could only be described as a derisory, if I could say it properly, bid for the rights, which they lost to the subscription service TNT. Now, what that meant was, because it was a subscription service and people were having to pay for watching the games, many sporting fans lost the opportunity to follow the games. And I just think that was just so bad.

And compare and contrast that of course with the European Athletics only a few weeks later in Birmingham where the BBC appropriately bid, secured the rights and even went as far as to change their scheduling in the mid of the week so that people could see the games. And I think in Scotland we just feel we just lost out a little bit there and I would hope the Secretary of State would maybe raise that with the BBC and see why that was allowed to happen and make sure that this never happens again wherever it's going to be held within the United Kingdom. The BBC should be covering something as significant and popular as the Commonwealth Games and where there is no provision about broadcasting rights. And I do support some of the things that have been said about free-to-air and you know like what we call the crown jewels of events. We in Scotland for years lost free-to-air football to follow the national men's football team.

I think for something like six years we went without any opportunity to see it for free like everybody else across the United Kingdom. That meant that a lot of fans couldn't follow our national team. That's now been put right and of course we're able to see Scotland games, the qualifiers, on the BBC. But I think we have to ensure that everybody has the right to see certainly their national men's football team qualifying and appearing in major major championships. But I want to just say a few minutes Madam Deputy Speaker to focus on the clauses relating to ticket touting.

And I think that for so many of us who care passionately about live music and the whole music fan experience, this bill just feels just a little bit of a disappointment. This I think is a lost opportunity to ensure that the scourge of ticket touting is tackled right across the sporting and entertainment environment. And we're grateful that the government is tackling ticket touting at sports events, but music fans have been let down by what they see as a lack of action on this issue. Where the government is prepared to act on behalf of the sports sector, music fans will again have to wait before having its issues properly resolved. And clauses five and six are good clauses of this bill and what it does is set regulations in relation to ticket touting for sporting events.

And it's fast-tracked heavy-duty legislation. It goes further than what the live music sector is asking for because what it does is make all unauthorised ticket resale a criminal offence for major sporting events full stop. The government has rightly recognised the urgency, found the parliamentary time, found the necessary legislation and acted decisively to shield sports fans and official sports rights holders and quite right too. But surely music fans deserve the same attention. Now the millions of people who form the backbone of our world-leading eight billion music industry are to remain exposed to the touts, to the spivs and the profiteers.

And for music the government has offered a promise, a draft ticket tout ban bill, a draft bill. But let's be clear, a draft bill until we actually see it and work starts on it is pretty much just an aspiration. And what it exposes it to is a whole host of pre-legislative scrutiny, consultations, delays and a long and winding road through this House. Now I listened very carefully to the right honourable lady's response when I intervened on her and I heard her, I think I heard her say that action is going to be imminent and we're going to see something very quickly when it relates to music and I really hope that's the case because music fans are having to pay through the nose in order to see their favourite bands. And this is costing something like 145 million pounds a year according to the sector.

And what music's asking for is not a total ban on resale. What the UK music are asking for is a resale price cap which prohibits someone from reselling a ticket for more than the original cost, service fee limits to ensure the price cap cannot be undermined by inflated fees or hidden charges placed on consumers, and to volume limits to make it unlawful to buy more tickets for an event than the one individual is permitted to buy on the primary market. And again, and I've heard the Secretary of State say this before, that the government roughly supports all of these endeavors and issues. But I think what we need to see now is just to get it done, please, because what we've got is great for sports and I think everybody's welcomed that. I'm sure it'll go a long way to ensure that sports fans are protected.

But we need to see the same type of action, the same type of legislation for music fans. But I'm encouraged with what the Secretary of State said. I don't want to end on a sour note, but like I think she'd expect me to come forward and say these things to her. But I think as we go forward now, let's all work together and get this fixed for music too.

05:48:27 - 05:48:33

Louie Thomas French

Which brings us to the front bench contribution, Shadow Minister Louie French.

05:48:33 - 05:58:49

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I start by referring members to my register of interests. I'd also like to put on record, as the Secretary of State hasn't, my delight that my old club the London Broncos won silverware at the weekend. London beat the North at their own sport, it was a fantastic sight to watch. And can I start now, but seriously, because she's really enjoying that. Can I start by saying this bill is a welcome step in the right direction for major sporting events across the UK as we've heard already today.

And can I thank all honorable members from across both houses for their contribution so far, and particularly to my friend from Droitwich and Evesham for his fantastic championing of DCMS over many years. He's going to, I know he's going to continue to do so, and for also putting up with me for the last 12 months. So thank you very much. As we all know, major sporting events make a substantial contribution both social and economic to our country, and more often than not, the journey from bidding stage to delivery spans across governments. So it is vitally important that we get this right and seek to work constructively wherever possible.

And it is notable, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the turquoise goalhangers have not even turned up for this major debate despite making references in the press about hosting events in the future. Not the first time that has happened either, Madam Deputy Speaker. But in an increasingly competitive international bidding environment, this bill should help the UK to attract more events and allow those we already stage to be more successful. I'm therefore pleased that the government has accepted, as we've heard already, some of the amendments made in the other place, particularly in expanding the scope of the bill to a wider range of major sporting events, including those taking place on a regular basis. The objective of this bill should be to streamline the bidding and delivery aspects of hosting major sporting events.

That is a principle that we can support because as Conservatives we believe fundamentally that Britain succeeds when the government gets out of the way. And there are many sporting examples I could provide today to highlight this point, but I will highlight just three in the interests of time. Firstly, football. Yes, not without its issues as we've discussed on many occasions. But our domestic football competitions such as the Premier League and the EFL continue to lead the world in attracting investment and fans from across the world.

We should never apologize for this success, nor forget why British football continues to deliver billions of inward investment and champions our soft power across the world. The success of football across the UK, but particularly in England, also means that we are well placed for future bids given our stadiums and supporting infrastructure such as training bases. With the recent example of the Barcelona men's team training at St George's Park highlighting again what a fantastic facility this is, which will continue to support new coaches and existing coaches and further success I hope on the pitch for England's national teams. I would also like to put on record my thanks to our football associations for their ongoing leadership work, both at home and overseas, in very challenging circumstances as we have sadly seen again this summer with the ongoing FIFA saga. Such diplomatic skills will continue to be vital for any future bids to host competition and I thank officials for their ongoing work.

Secondly I will briefly mention Formula One and the commercial vision and leadership which like the Premier League continues to put the UK at the top of the international podium. Formula One's success embodies the very best of international competition and sports science creating fantastic jobs and investment across Britain which stretches far beyond the Grand Prix weekend as I saw again on a recent visit to the Formula One media center in Biggin Hill. And the third example that I would provide is the National Lottery, one of the greatest Conservative legacies that has allowed UK sport with the support of lottery players to transform our athletic success across multiple sports. Gone are the days when a more state controlled approach to sport saw us languish in the medal tables and this is another area where we will seek to continue working constructively with the government to ensure funding for sport is maximized. From the Premier League to Formula One, the Open to the London Marathon, Wimbledon and beyond, our nation's sporting heritage is rich and continues to lead the world.

In fact Madam Deputy Speaker I cannot see why events like the British Grand Prix at Silverstone, the Open or the London Marathon were excluded from the remit of this bill in the first place. These events provide incredible return on investment for this country with independent assessments already anticipating that Euro 2028 will generate over 3.2 billion pounds of social economic benefits for the United Kingdom and Ireland between 2028 and 2031. This is equivalent of approximately 5 pounds 74 of benefit for every 1 pound invested. It is therefore welcome that the government has accepted these amendments in the other place and to allow the benefits of the bill and subsequent framework to be extended to events which already benefit this country. However as my honorable friend the Shadow Secretary of State has already set it out and many noble lords made clear throughout the passage of the bill in the other place there are some serious questions still that need addressing in the government's approach to major events.

Firstly why has the government tabled a bill to support hosting major sporting events when its own major event strategy which has been promised is still unpublished? Does the Minister not see that this bill should be part of that strategy and that they are at risk of putting the cart before the horse? Second the bill fails to address major fiscal and regulatory concerns outlined by organizers of major events. These include proposals by the Home Office to charge for policing services, the implementation of Martyn's Law, increasing employment costs, higher business rates and the Care Quality Commission's new regulation. Madam Deputy Speaker on CQC regulation I know the sporting event sector has had discussions with the Department for Health already and with the CQC on an exemption for those who provide medical services for athletes, performers and officials.

But as we have seen for the past two years Minister failed to grasp the nettle and provide urgent clarity to the sector. So will the Secretary of State or Minister please now make sure that either her directly or her ministerial colleagues provide confirmation and clarity on the introduction of the exemption as soon as possible so that major sporting events are not negatively delayed or impacted by unintended consequences. Madam Deputy Speaker we have also heard from our constituents about the increased cost of businesses under successive now successive Labour governments and that is no different to those who host major sporting events. And while the Prime Minister might be able to afford his new Everton season ticket or returning Everton season ticket there are many out there who will no longer be able to afford to watch their beloved teams thanks to the increased cost being piled onto clubs across the country. We've heard already about the impact of changes to events that are televised on national TV for free and this is an ongoing challenges that sports are facing it's having direct consequences for fans across the country whether they seek to watch sport in person or at home.

Because not only has the government saddled organizers with more costs in the form of minimum wage increases, national insurance increases, business rates increases and energy costs but now the Home Office is threatening to increase the cost of policing these kind of events.

A joined up government approach would see a guarantee that our major sporting events will benefit from policing services in the same way as every other sector of the economy, and not be forced to pay again for public services that have already paid through high levels of taxation as part of their contribution. So will the Secretary of State commit to making sure that no extra police charges will be imposed on sporting events and that an impact assessment on the ability of these events to swallow such costs is published as soon as possible if the government are to proceed in this way. More broadly, Madam Deputy Speaker, this government's words on sports are not being matched by its actions as we've already seen and heard today and I do hope that new Prime Minister does change direction on this. Because we all know that having a good strategy is one thing and this bill will make it easier to deliver such events. But the country will miss out if we do not address some of the sporting cuts that have happened particularly at the grassroots in the past two years.

Because it is future generations that will miss out on being inspired by hosting such events. Since entering the government two years ago, this Labour government has cut 57 million pounds from the opening sports facilities funds. 127 million pounds a year less for primary school PE and sports premium. 35 million pounds from investment in grassroots cricket. 11 million pounds from multi-sports grassroots facilities program.

25 millions in real term cuts in grassroots sports investment compared to the previous Conservative government. This is not a good record, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it is our sports and our grassroots facilities that are paying the price. While in government the Conservative Party invested more than one and a half billion pounds in grassroots, schools, and elite sports from an unprecedented 400 million investment to grassroots sports and 300 millions of pounds of emergency funding to support community to support community sports clubs and grassroots organizations. Perhaps the program we Conservatives should be most proud of, Madam Deputy Speaker, is the PE and sport premium, introduced to help inspire a generation after the London Olympics. This was worth 600 million between 2023 and 2025 alone and totaled almost three and a half billion directly to schools since we introduced it in 2013.

This summer of sport was built on the legacy of the 2012 Olympics and Paralympics, the 2014 Glasgow Commonwealth Games, the 2015 World Cup, the 2019 Cricket World Cup, the 2020 Men's Euro Final, and the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games to name just a few of the incredible events that have taken place. But if the government continues down this path of not funding sports properly, I'm afraid there will be less money for future generations and future stars that we so need. And I sincerely like I said, I sincerely hope the government does help this department change direction of what we've seen over the past two years. So to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is a welcome move for elite sport and major international events and we will work constructively to try and improve it as it passes through the Commons. But this Labour government must change direction, it must reduce costs for all levels of sports, otherwise we will lose our seat at the top table of international sport and the next generation will not benefit from hosting such major incredible events.

Thank you.

05:58:49 - 05:58:51

Speaker 232

Minister.

05:58:51 - 06:03:41

Stephanie Peacock

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm grateful to all honorable members across the House who have contributed to today's debate, which has shown cross-party recognition of the importance of major sporting events and their ability to showcase the very best of our country. I'm going to speak about the bill, its importance and provisions and I will address some of the wider points raised in the debate throughout my contribution. The UK is an undisputed world leader when it comes to hosting major sporting events and the benefits of these occasions are felt right across the country.

We all fondly remember the London 2012 Olympics, as the Secretary of State and many others have outlined during this debate. Events like these bring huge benefits and opportunities. The London Olympics and Paralympics brought 14 billion pounds of trade and investment benefit to the UK. This was alongside the regeneration of 500 acres of East London and 400,000 Londoners participating in grassroots sports in the three years following the games. In my own area of South Yorkshire, the Olympic Legacy Park in Sheffield is another testament to the transformative power these international events can have and stands as the only Olympic Legacy Park in a city that has not hosted the games.

More recently, the 2022 Birmingham Commonwealth Games contributed over a billion pounds to the UK economy and events like the 2025 Women's Rugby World Cup, the 2026 Women's Cricket World Cup and the recent outdoor European Athletics Championships, the first time the UK has hosted the championships, have and will bring their own legacy benefits. And we of course note the huge success of the Glasgow Commonwealth Games and the fact that Glasgow really stepped up and hosted those games at the last minute. And looking ahead, the Grand Depart for the Tour de France and the Tour de France Femmes in 2027 and a potential World Athletics Championships in 2029 will inspire the next generation and bring live sport to communities across the country. Indeed, we expect the Tour de France races, the most accessible major sporting event Great Britain has ever hosted, to bring 150 million pounds in economic benefits across the country. This government is committed to not only hosting major sporting events, but also making sure the benefits are felt far beyond the field of play.

As I have said in this House before, inactivity is the story of inequality. And that is why this government is investing at least 400 million pounds in community sports facilities across the country over the next four years and why we are determined that major events should support greater grassroots participation. And I note the points raised about the power of sport to inspire in every postcode and that was made very powerfully by the member for Hamilton and Clyde Valley and of course from Dartford. Now, turning to the bill, as it currently stands, this legislation will strengthen our ability to bid successfully for major sporting events and will ensure that we are ready to create more moments like London 2012 or Birmingham 2022. France and Australia already have similar legislative frameworks and France's recent success in hosting both the Olympic and Paralympic Games and the Rugby World Cup demonstrate the value of having these protections in place.

I will run through briefly the provisions in the bill and how they will be enforced. But before I do, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's worth noting that this legislation is only one component of our broader national ambition. As I recently announced to the Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee, we are currently developing a major events strategy to be published in the near future. For the first time, a comprehensive strategy will unite sport, culture, arts and business events under a single strategic framework designed to simplify and drive growth. Now, I absolutely recognise the points that the chair of the Select Committee has raised and indeed the work her committee has done and in particular I've heard her calls very clearly on business events.

And after I appeared in front of her Select Committee, I've convened more than one cross-government meeting and I'm absolutely committed to making government do better in this area. Now, the shadow minister did ask why we were, in his words, putting the cart before the horse and not publishing this bill before the strategy.

06:03:42 - 06:03:58

Clive Efford

But I wonder if she'd agree with me that when we have these major sporting events, it's also important for the communities around the stadium that the right legislation is in place, that the government works with the council and the police to make sure there's no anti-social behaviour, littering and other things that cause disruption to the people who live around the stadium.

06:03:58 - 06:07:53

Stephanie Peacock

The honourable gentleman's absolutely right, and that goes to the heart of this bill. It absolutely should be collaborative and it should work for local people. And actually, that speaks to the point I was going to come on to say, which event-specific regulation setting out which provisions will be applied to the event and including information such as the time period, which provisions apply and how they do to a local area will be subject to parliamentary debate and scrutiny through the SI process. Now moving on to some of the specifics on the bill, the ticketing provisions in this bill are designed to ensure that tickets can only be resold with the authorisation from the event owner or organiser. This measure will clamp down on ticket touts who seek to exploit sports fans and profiteer from major sporting moments.

We saw this legislation work effectively at London 2012, and this bill will make it the baseline for major sporting events. Where needed, local trading standards authorities and the Competition and Markets Authority will be able to enforce this. While the bill does not prohibit official reselling above face value, we will be bringing further legislation on this. And of course, the Secretary of State was very clear in her remarks about the draft legislation being there so we can get it right, but she was also clear that it should be a priority, an incredible priority in this session. Moving on, the bill will introduce time-limited restricted zones around competition venues, fan zones and transport hubs to prevent aggressive ambush marketing and unauthorised street trading.

Without these protections, the Women's Euros in 2022 faced persistent street trading and unauthorised advertising blimps. In contrast, the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games used these powers to swiftly resolve over 50 advertising and trading infringements, protecting official sponsors and keeping spectator routes safe. The bill will empower local authorities to undertake enforcement at future events. When determining an application to trade in a restricted zone, the bill ensures that the interests of those with an existing trading licence are taken into account. But I'd like to say we are absolutely determined to make sure this bill is as strong as possible in this regard in terms of protecting small businesses, and we absolutely will work across the house to make sure it delivers on that.

The bill will prohibit unauthorised association, which will prevent businesses from falsely suggesting to the public that they have an official connection with an event in order to gain exposure. Weak controls around unauthorised association make sponsoring an event less appealing and allow businesses to benefit without giving financial support. The bill sets out controls to prevent this happening, giving powers to designated enforcers, likely to be event owners or organisers, to enforce the provisions. Protections will have been built in to ensure proportionality and to help ensure once again small businesses can benefit from major events on the doorstep. It is our intention to make sure small businesses benefit from major events, and I'm very keen to work across the house to deliver this, yes.

I thank the minister for giving way on this exact point, and we are willing to work constructively on this. Can we also ensure there's significant flexibility that for events such as Wimbledon, just to name one, obviously a lot of residents nearby who suffer the parking stress that we heard earlier from colleagues for those events normally hire out driveways and it actually helps with parking capacity for the events themselves. So will there be enough flexibility in the legislation that that kind of thing can carry on?

I think the honourable gentleman makes a really important and valid point, and I look forward to continuing the conversation with him in bill committee and we can pick up on that specific point.

A good example is the Games Route Network used in Birmingham 2022, which ensured spectators could move safely and efficiently while minimising disruption to local residents and to businesses.

06:07:53 - 06:07:54

I will give way, yes.

06:07:54 - 06:08:36

Speaker 236

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. She will know that Peel Land are hoping to support a bid for the Ryder Cup to come to the Hulton Park site in my Bolton West constituency. Many of my constituents have grave concerns, and I have serious reservations around infrastructure at that site, which will be predominantly road traffic in particular around Westhoughton, Chequerbent roundabout is chock-a-block with traffic all times of the day. Will she meet with me to hear those concerns to make sure that any putative bid at a future date does address some of these infrastructure concerns that I raised with the Prime Minister earlier in the year in his previous role as the Mayor of Greater Manchester?

06:08:36 - 06:12:37

Stephanie Peacock

I thank the honourable gentleman. He raises an important point on behalf of the people he represents, and I'd be absolutely delighted to meet him to discuss it further. Now, as the Secretary of State mentioned, we are well aware of the concerns around recurrent domestic events, and we recognise the opportunities available here. We will seek to address this issue through the passage of the Bill, and I welcome the comments from the front bench opposite. The Member for South Northamptonshire made an important point regarding Silverstone, and I can assure her that both the Secretary of State and I are passionate about it too, having attended indeed with the Member for Droitwich, and the Shadow Secretary of State, sorry, the Shadow Minister made an important point on this issue too.

And I do welcome the Shadow Secretary of State's comments about working on this point on recurring events with us, and I look forward to doing that in committee. Now, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, and again, I welcome her support broadly for the Bill. She raised the point around music events, and I do appreciate and hear the point she made. She asked sort of why they weren't included. The Bill originally was designed for biddable events.

So while I've heard those points, that is why they weren't included, and indeed that is why some of the recurrent events weren't initially included. But we've heard the points made in this House and indeed in the other place, and we will work with people to get it right. Now, the whole of the UK stands to benefit from major sporting events, and we are committed to seeing the reward shared across the four nations. From the inception of the Bill, we have worked closely with devolved partners to ensure this Bill serves the whole Union, and we will continue to work with each devolved government to ensure that, where appropriate, legislative consent motions are secured. Now, I'd like to cover just some of the broader points mainly put to me by the Member for Droitwich, and again, I pay tribute to him.

So like he said, I don't want to overstate it, but I do pay tribute to him in all the work he's done on both the shadow front bench and as a minister before that. And he put various questions to me. So I'll just touch briefly on some of them. So he raised the point around the 3:00 PM blackout. Of course, it does exist to protect ticket sales for lower leagues in the football pyramid, and as a former Minister for Sport, he will know it's an issue for the FA, but we do support the current situation as we recognise the importance for the lower leagues.

He raised the point around alcohol. He's absolutely right, we debated it during the Football Governance Bill debate. There are, of course, different views on it. It was originally introduced to protect fans. I recognise the debate that takes place.

It is, of course, an issue for the Home Office, but I will reflect the points he makes to the relevant minister. Now, both the honourable gentleman and indeed, I think, the Member for Perth raised the point around the Commonwealth Games coverage. Now, ultimately, again, he will know as a former minister that this was a decision for Commonwealth Sport as the rights holder, and it is, of course, a balance between accessibility and commercial considerations.

And I know he was in attendance at the Commonwealth Games, and I think that TNT did a very good job of making it accessible. Of course, there was work on radio with S4C and the BBC and the free-to-air highlights on Channel 5. But I do absolutely acknowledge the point, the fact the BBC didn't cover it means there wasn't as much awareness more widely. But he will appreciate it is an issue that is independent of government. And the Chair of Select Committee raised the point around Deaf athletes and the Deaf Olympics.

UK Sport have met with them, as have I as the Minister. I'd like to assure both the Committee and the House and anyone watching our proceedings today that we absolutely haven't forgotten the issue. I know I wrote to the Select Committee earlier this year. It's something that myself and the Secretary of State care very much about, and I will update both the House and the Committee on that issue. Now, major sporting events can change lives, transform communities, and inspire people to get involved in sport.

This Bill will make sure we are ready to secure more of these incredibly important global events and bring their power to communities across the UK. We will champion fans, protect commercial rights, and give organisers the reassurance they need to come to our country and cement the UK as a world leader in this space. And so I commend this Bill to the House.

06:12:37 - 06:12:48

Speaker 239

The question is that the Bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Program motion to be moved formally.

06:12:48 - 06:12:49

I beg to move.

06:12:49 - 06:12:59

Speaker 238

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Money motion to be moved formally.

06:12:59 - 06:13:01

Speaker 233

I beg to move.

06:13:01 - 06:13:35

Speaker 238

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We now move on to the petition, but I'll give the front benches a few moments to vacate.

Petition, Chris Bloore.

06:13:35 - 06:14:45

Chris Bloore

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Today I am presenting a petition concerning the West Mercia Police and Crime Commissioner's decision to spend 20 million pounds of taxpayers' money on a new police and fire station which, despite that significant investment, has neither a front counter service nor holding cells. I would like to thank the thousands of residents who have signed this petition, both in paper and online. Their support demonstrates the strength of feeling within our community and sends a clear message that a town the size of Redditch deserves a fit-for-purpose police station. The petition states: "The petition of residents of the constituency of Redditch declares that the lack of a permanent publicly accessible front desk at Redditch Police and Fire Station prevents members of the community from accessing a vital public service."

"The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the Government to review the provision of a publicly accessible front desk at Redditch Police and Fire Station to ensure adequate and accessible policing is available to the people of Redditch." And the petitioners remain, etc.

06:14:45 - 06:14:55

Speaker 237

Petition, Redditch Police and Fire Station.

06:14:55 - 06:14:58

Speaker 235

I beg to move that this House do now adjourn.

06:14:58 - 06:15:03

Speaker 234

The question is that this House do now adjourn. I call Dr. Allison Gardner.

06:15:03 - 06:24:14

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm grateful for the opportunity to lead this debate in the role of masterplans in large-scale developments. This debate will be of particular importance to many of my constituents in Lightwood and surrounding areas where some 3,000 homes have been allocated through Stoke-on-Trent's emerging local plan under site BL1. I want to begin by making my position clear. I oppose development of this scale in Lightwood.

It is the largest single housing allocation in the entire local plan and would, in practice, create a substantial new community on the edge of the city. Like many constituents who have contacted me, I do not believe that the existing infrastructure, public services, and transport network can accommodate development of this scale.

I have consistently raised objections to the scale of this proposal. However, I also recognize the reality that development is likely to proceed, particularly given that elements of the site are under council ownership. I also believe the centrally determined housing target for Stoke-on-Trent of 948 homes a year is a little too high given the city's tight administrative boundaries and limited land availability. It is therefore concerning that we have reached the Regulation 19 stage of the local plan process without residents having any meaningful detail about how this strategic allocation of 3,000 homes would be delivered. There remains no comprehensive framework setting out infrastructure requirements, no clear understanding of how cumulative impacts will be mitigated and no shared vision for how a development of this scale will integrate with both the existing community and the wider area.

What makes this particularly difficult to understand is that residents elsewhere in Stoke-on-Trent have been afforded precisely that opportunity. The council prepared a masterplan for the strategic site at Patmore, despite it being around a third of the size of the proposed Lightwood allocation. That process provided a clear vision for the site and enabled residents to engage with the overall shape of development before individual planning applications came forward. By contrast, residents in Lightwood are being asked to comment on a strategic allocation of 3,000 homes without the benefit of a comparable masterplan and without the same level of consultation on how the site will ultimately be delivered. It is a clear example of inconsistency in the planning process.

Residents should not receive different levels of engagement, transparency and certainty about the future of their communities simply because they happen to live in different postcodes. When a development is large enough to create an entirely new neighborhood, it should not be allowed to emerge through a series of disconnected planning applications. It should be planned from the outset through a comprehensive masterplan that establishes a clear vision for the area and provides a framework for future development. In the case of Lightwood, I believe the local planning authority should be taking a proactive role in preparing and coordinating such a masterplan. And masterplans are not simply about determining where houses will go.

They are about creating successful places and sustainable, accessible communities, both new and existing. They provide the strategic framework that brings together housing, transport, education provision, healthcare capacity, utilities, mains water from the main water companies, environmental enhancement and design principles into a coherent vision for long-term growth. Most importantly, they ensure that supporting infrastructure is planned alongside development, rather than treated as an afterthought once planning applications have already been submitted. In that regard, masterplans are entirely consistent with the ambitions of the National Planning Policy Framework, which seeks to promote sustainable development, effective placemaking and infrastructure-led growth. While national policy recognizes the value of masterplans and design codes, their use remains largely discretionary.

The experience of Lightwood and Patmore demonstrates the inconsistency that can result. That is why I believe there is a strong case for a clearer national requirement that developments above an appropriate scale should be supported by a comprehensive masterplan.

I am not suggesting that every housing development requires one. A scheme involving a few dozen homes is clearly different from a strategic allocation comprising thousands of properties. However, where development may be delivered over many years, involving multiple landowners or developers, and have substantial implications for infrastructure and existing communities, the case for masterplanning becomes clear. In such circumstances, a comprehensive masterplan should be established before individual planning applications are determined. Without a clear overarching framework, there is a real risk of piecemeal development.

Individual planning applications may appear acceptable in isolation, but collectively they can create unintended consequences for transport networks, public services, drainage systems, and environmental assets. Opportunities for integrated transport links, coordinated infrastructure, and high-quality placemaking can easily be lost when development comes forward parcel by parcel. A masterplan does provide the framework that ensures every proposal contributes to an agreed vision for the site. It should establish how movement through the site will work, where community facilities will be located, how public transport will be integrated, where drainage infrastructure will be provided, and how development will connect with surrounding neighborhoods. It should also identify how environmental assets will be protected, enhanced, and connected across the site as a whole, and that brings me to a particularly important issue: green infrastructure.

Green space is often treated as a residual element of development, fitted into whatever land remains after housing numbers have been maximized. A proper masterplan takes the opposite approach. It recognizes that accessible green spaces, recreation areas, tree planting, biodiversity corridors are fundamental components of healthy communities. They contribute to physical and mental well-being. They create opportunities for recreation and social interaction.

They improve climate resilience and flood mitigation and help maintain a connection between communities and the natural environment. Green infrastructure cannot be viewed as an optional extra; it is essential and ensures that growth enhances rather than diminishes the places people call home. And of course, infrastructure planning is equally important. Questions about road capacity, public transport provision, walking and cycling routes, school places, healthcare services, utilities, and drainage cannot sensibly be addressed on an application-by-application basis. They must be considered collectively in the context of both future residents and the communities that already exist around development.

This is particularly important in relation to mains and water infrastructure. I remain concerned that the mains water with the water companies do not upgrade their systems to match the new developments. And in my village of Upper Tean, they have frequently had this problem. The developers meet their requirements in terms of mains water and sewage and flood mitigations, but when that hits the main systems, this is when we get manhole covers blowing out and flooding happening all over. People's homes get flooded, people's businesses get flooded, play areas get flooded, and of course that has ensuing problems environmentally.

A masterplan should also ensure, if we are serious about creating inclusive communities, the development of accessible homes and communities, including bungalows, so that they meet the needs of those who are aging, have disabilities and frailty. The English Home Study found that 91% of homes do not meet necessary requirements for wheelchair users to visit, let alone live in them. Data by Habinteg, who provides thousands of accessible social homes across the country, shows that wheelchair users could wait up to 47 years for a suitable accessible property to become available. Masterplans therefore can be a valuable way of ensuring that future housing development meets existing local housing needs, including the estimated 20,000 wheelchair users nationally on local authority housing waiting lists. And currently fewer than 2% of new-build homes are bungalows, meaning they are not fully accessible.

Sites such as Land Lightwood are not a blank canvas.

People already live there. They rely on local roads, footpaths, public transport, schools, healthcare services and community facilities. As we work to deliver the homes that this country needs, we must make full use of the planning tools available to ensure those homes become successful communities accessible by all. So I ask the Minister to consider strengthening national planning policy so that large-scale developments above an appropriate threshold that can be discussed are required to have a comprehensive masterplan in place before individual planning applications are brought forward.

06:24:14 - 06:34:31

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a pleasure to respond to this debate with you in the chair. I congratulate my honourable friend the Member for Stoke-on-Trent South on securing this important debate, and I commend her for the compelling argument she has just made about the importance of planning effectively for large-scale residential developments to ensure that they're well-connected, well-designed, sustainable and attractive places where people want to live, with all the infrastructure, amenities and services needed to sustain thriving communities. While I've noted the comments she's made today and indeed on previous occasions in respect of the BL1 green belt site in Lightwood that's identified in the draft local plan, I know she is cognisant of the fact that I can't comment on specific local plans, specific sites or indeed specific planning applications due to the quasi-judicial nature of the planning process, but I will make some general points that I hope will be of use to her. I'd like to start, Madam Deputy Speaker, with plan-making. The plan-led approach is and must remain the cornerstone of our planning system.

The benefits of an up-to-date local plan are significant. I think they're well-known across the chamber. Local plans are the best way for communities to shape decisions about how to deliver the housing and wider development their areas need. They enable local areas to set the strategy for future growth and their approach to protecting and enhancing the environment, and they provide the certainty and confidence required to bring development forward across the country. In the absence of an up-to-date local plan, there is a high likelihood that development will come forward on a piecemeal and speculative basis, as she mentioned, with reduced public engagement and fewer guarantees that it will make the most of an area's potential.

That's why the government remains determined to drive local plans to adoption as quickly as possible in order to achieve our ambition of universal plan coverage and to ensure that plans contribute positively to increasing rates of housebuilding and infrastructure delivery. She will know that the emerging Stoke-on-Trent City Council local plan is undergoing the Regulation 19 consultation. I'd encourage my honourable friend and her constituents to engage meaningfully with that process if they've not already done so to ensure that any specific concerns are understood by the authority even at this advanced stage. Anyone, Madam Deputy Speaker, who submitted a representation during the consultation on the draft plan may make a request to be heard by the inspector during the examination. Once submitted for examination, it will be for the independent inspector to examine the plan and the proposed site allocations to ensure they're legally compliant and sound.

And of course, it is for the inspector to ensure that the plan is in conformity with national policy, which has always been clear that local plans should identify the infrastructure necessary to support the delivery of the local plan, providing certainty and better outcomes for communities, businesses and developers. I just want to briefly mention the interaction between design codes, codes and masterplans and local plans. My honourable friend is absolutely right that local planning authorities can identify and prioritise where design guides, codes and masterplans are produced. They can make provision for their adoption as supplementary plans. There's no requirement for them to be adopted as part of the development plan, but where they are incorporated into development plans, they are afforded more weight on that basis.

So it is important that for those key sites where a local authority wants to see a masterplan in place that they are incorporated into plans.

And they can also be produced as part of the development management process to support the delivery of larger site allocations. In the new NPPF that we published on the 17th of August, we included new policy, policy L1 for those who are interested, which encourages the use of master plans where appropriate to optimize the use of site allocations. We did so in response to consultation feedback. My honorable friend has, in the context of her concerns about the BL1 site, made a number of specific points about large-scale residential development and the importance of master planning to ensure the best outcomes for communities. I very much agree with her as to the benefits of those.

Delivering at scale does provide opportunities for comprehensive development where homes, infrastructure, green space, and community facilities can be planned together from the outset. As I've said, national planning policy has long required local plans to take this joined-up approach, including by setting out the infrastructure needed to support growth and clear expectations for the quality of places to be created. This includes using design tools such as master plans and design codes where they are needed. However, that new NPPF that we published on the 17th of August, in response to the specific points she raised, has strengthened national planning policy in this area for future plans and sites, including by introducing a definition of what is called a strategic site, a site of at least 1,500 dwellings, most often to be delivered in multiple phases, significant infrastructure requirements. And through the NPPF, we've set clear expectations that such development should come forward in suitable locations, be supported by necessary infrastructure and facilities, address strategic environmental opportunities, and, I quote from the glossary, require a master plan.

So for any strategic site over 1,500 units going forward, we require a master plan to be taken forward. The new NPPF also strengthens expectations for a mix of homes to her point on accessibility and tenures on strategic sites. Now, while it will principally shape future plan-making and future site allocations, it does, I hope, demonstrate the direction of travel that this government has taken, ensuring that large-scale development is planned comprehensively, supported by timely infrastructure, and capable of being well-designed, sustainable places, even where a standalone master plan is not in place. But I understand her concerns in the context of her draft local plan being assessed under the old, not the new framework. I just want to briefly touch on design and infrastructure.

I absolutely agree with my honorable friend about the importance of providing a long-term vision to guide the delivery of well-designed, large-scale development. National planning policy, again, Madam Deputy Speaker, is clear that local authorities should identify in their development plans where master plans are necessary to achieve positive design outcomes and that they should use master plans where appropriate to optimize the use of both allocated sites and smaller windfall sites. It also requires that master plans reflect a clear understanding of local character and the wider context of an area and should be informed by effective community engagement. Now, we're not complacent. We want to build on what is already in place, and our draft planning practice guidance on design and placemaking, which we consulted on between January and March of this year, will go even further to support local authorities to prepare effective master plans in collaboration with communities and key stakeholders.

A chief concern my honorable friend raised was infrastructure, the provision of which, as she made clear, communities across the country rightly expect to be delivered alongside development rather than being an afterthought. We've been clear that while we need to build many more homes, they need to be supported by the right infrastructure to ensure that we're creating functioning places where people want to live and work. The new NPPF has strengthened existing national policy to ensure developers and local plans deliver much-needed affordable homes and the infrastructure required to support new development, like schools and GP surgeries. And through the new NPPF, we've placed a greater emphasis on upfront clarity on expected developer contributions, reducing the risk of lengthy negotiations and again providing greater certainty for communities. More widely, Madam Deputy Speaker, our new NPPF supports the provision of new community facilities and public service infrastructure, particularly where new development would have a significant impact on the number of people needing to use those services.

And the NPPF is also clear that in planning for new community facilities and public service infrastructure, authorities should engage proactively with local communities and the relevant service providers, taking into account relevant strategies to improve health, address inequalities, and foster social and cultural wellbeing for all sections of the community.

I finish by just saying at the same time the government is backing delivery centrally with the launch of a new National Housing Delivery Fund. This includes around 5 billion pounds of capital grant funding to address viability challenges across the country, including through remediation of brownfield sites and the provision of unlocking infrastructure. The fund is designed to deliver a range of interventions, including large strategic schemes as well as faster smaller sites and viability gap projects. Its aim is to accelerate housing delivery, increase supply, and support our ambition to build one and a half million new homes in this Parliament. And it sits alongside, Madam Deputy Speaker, the 16 billion pounds of financial capacity that we have available to us through our National Housing Bank.

Just briefly on landscapes and green places, again it is important for me to say to my honorable friend, the NPPF highlights the importance of conserving and enhancing landscape character, the natural beauty of the countryside, and higher quality agricultural land. Local plans may designate land as local green space where this would safeguard green areas of particular value to the local community. And we've introduced a new requirement for plans to set standards for green infrastructure, defined as a multifunctional network of green and blue spaces. The government is obviously also committed to the ongoing protection of England's green belts, which have served England's towns and cities well over many decades. We've not shied away, however, from the fact that we do need to take forward a more strategic targeted approach to green belt land designation and release where that is necessary.

But we expect local authorities to prioritize, in when they have to release green belt under exceptional circumstances, previously developed and lower quality grey belt land within the green belt. To conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm extremely grateful to my honorable friend for securing this debate, for bringing this very important issue to the House's attention. I'm very passionate about well-designed masterplans. They can really reduce opposition to development, convincing people that the delivery, the development to come forward is infrastructure-led, it's well-designed, it's sustainable. The government is committed to delivering the right homes that people need while ensuring that development is supported by the appropriate infrastructure and working in tandem with local areas.

We have, as I've set out today, taken bold steps to reform the planning system and to drive wider changes across the housing market to improve supply, quality, and fairness. I look forward to working closely with colleagues to build a housing system that's both fair and sustainable and to drive up the quality and indeed the coverage of masterplans, particularly on strategic sites across the country.

06:34:31 - 06:34:37

Speaker 238

The question is that this House now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.