Third Delegated Legislation Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Third Delegated Legislation Committee House of Commons
Follow its sittings
Stephen Doughty
We also lastly, Mr. Chair, the designate the amended regime adds the power to designate by description. And this allows the UK to designate where a specific name is not available and capture all members of a specific group or organisation allowing greater flexibility and reach under the regime. So this is a provision that allows again us to target a greater range of actors who may be responsible for these violations and be able to take action against them.
Speaker 6
I'm grateful to the Minister for giving way. He talked about the purpose of sanctions to be deter, disrupt and demonstrate. Would he like to give the House the two best examples that he's come across of who the parties were and what they were deterred from doing and who the parties were and what they were disrupted from doing?
Stephen Doughty
I can give him a very specific example which was able to be done actually under the existing powers, but for the sake of the argument, Mr. Chair, and it's one that perhaps will be less familiar with colleagues, but I think is a very important one where we've had a very significant impact was the actions in relation to Southeast Asian scam centers. This is an issue where there's a direct impact on the streets of this country, people being defrauded, you know, money being taken off them, also people being held effectively in servitude in these centers in Southeast Asia. And not only did we disrupt these networks by our by that action and the designation, but we actually deterred further action and we actually also encouraged other countries and countries involved to take action domestically in terms of their own legal processes. So that's a very clear example of those two purposes that he he asked about. But Mr. Chair, to conclude, this instrument provides the government with vital new powers with which to stand up for British values and respond to serious human rights abuses and serious violations of international humanitarian law around the globe.
Of course, at this stage, we are not making the specific designations. Those will come in in due course. As you know, I don't comment on those future designations or when they may come about. But clearly we take powers for a purpose. We take powers in order to be able to use them.
This gives us a new set of tools, a new set of levers in our armoury to respond to some of the worst atrocities and violations of the principles that we stand for in this country in a range of contexts, Mr. Chair. And I think that's important to emphasize and I commend the regulations to the committee.
Graham Stringer
The question is that the committee has considered the Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law Sanctions Regulations 2026. David Reed to speak for the opposition.
David Reed
Thank you, Mr. Stringer, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today. And from the outset, I'd like the Minister to know that His Majesty's loyal opposition will not be opposing these regulations today. It's right the government should have the power to sanction individuals, groups and companies responsible for serious human rights abuses and serious violations of international humanitarian law, and these regulations provide it. But asset freezes, director disqualifications and travel bans are serious measures, and these regulations considerably widen the conduct for which they can be imposed. Powers of this kind must be used fairly, consistently and on the basis of sound evidence.
And I therefore request an area four areas of clarification from the Minister, and I thank him for his in-depth opening remarks. First is on the scope. The regulations add three new grounds for designation: serious violations of the right to liberty and security of person, serious violations of international humanitarian law, and obstructions of humanitarian assistance. How does the government intend to apply them and what process will govern their use and review? In particular, how will these powers interact with the separate assessment regime the government announced in September?
Second are safeguards. In areas of humanitarian crisis, legitimate commercial and humanitarian activity can sit close to conduct that might trigger designation. Under regulation eight, anyone who provides financial or goods finance or goods to a person responsible for these abuses can be treated as involved, and that limb contains no requirement of knowledge. So I ask what protections will there be for British people and businesses acting legitimately and in good faith?
Third is impact. Now I understand that no specific consultation or full impact assessment was carried out. Given that British nationals and companies are bound wherever they operate, what assessment has the government made of the consequences for British businesses and what guidance will it provide. Fourthly is consistency, Mr Stringer. Designation requires only reasonable grounds to suspect.
What evidence will the government require in practice, particularly for designations by description, where a whole class of people can be designated at once. And how will the minister ensure that these standards are applied consistently across different conflicts and countries. As stated, Mr Stringer, His Majesty's loyal opposition does not oppose these regulations. We only ask that ministers put on record how these powers will be used, where their limits lie, and what safeguards will protect legitimate activity and ensure consistency. Thank you.
Kim Johnson.
Kim Marie Johnson
Thank you, Chair. It's a pleasure serving under your chairmanship today. I welcome the expanded sanctions framework and in particular the introduction of the new sanctions ground relating to the deprivation of liberty. It is right that serious arbitrary detention, unlawful imprisonment, and the denial of basic legal protections can now form the basis of sanctions and designations. So can the minister therefore set out how this new ground will be applied in practice to evidence concerning the detention of Palestinian children.
Human rights organisations and international bodies have for many years raised concerns about the arbitrary or unlawful detention of Palestinian children, including prolonged detention without charge or trial, military detention, and the systemic denial of due processes and legal protections. And as we know, Israel is the only country in the world that systematically and automatically tries children through military court, with a conviction rate of 99% for Palestinian defendants. And of course we're all alarmed by the introduction of the death penalty, which has been criticised by human rights groups and the UN as applying de facto exclusively to Palestinians. The separation of legal systems based on the race and nationality of defendants have led leading human rights organisations, including B'Tselem and Human Rights Watch, to declare Israel an apartheid regime. If the government receives evidence that such practices meet the threshold established under these regulations, will ministers actively consider designations under the new liberty ground.
Furthermore, when assessing responsibility, will the government look not only at those directly responsible for detention, but also those who enable and sustain these practices, including officials, ministers, and private actors who provide services that facilitate places of detention where serious violations are alleged to occur. Finally, how does the minister intend to keep Parliament informed of the use of this new sanctions power. Given the significance of the liberty ground, it is important that members understand how evidence is being assessed and whether potential cases, including the detention of children, are being actively considered. The creation of this new sanctions ground is welcome. The test will now be whether it is applied consistently and robustly wherever credible evidence of arbitrary or unlawful deprivation of liberty exists.
Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams
Thank you, Mr Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship.
I also welcome the new statutory instruments in relation to the Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law Sanctions. We know that sanctions are a vital tool for the government to use to promote our British values, in particular in relation to the rule of law, democracy, and human rights. By designating individuals or entities responsible for human rights violations, for example, we send a clear message that the UK stands firm against despots like Vladimir Putin. Sanctioned persons face penalties including direct disqualification in this country, asset freezes, and being prevented from traveling to Britain. These are significant penalties, and those who are designated to face them are only designated on reasonable grounds.
While the 2018 Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act was certainly an important piece of legislation, recent events have shown the incompleteness of its implementation. The Global Human Rights Sanctions Regulations from 2020, which the regulations we're debating replace, was of course correct to punish those who perpetrate violations of human rights. However, it was clearly an oversight to punish these acts while not taking equivalent action for serious breaches of international humanitarian law. So what does this new expanded set of regulations mean? As the name sets out, the new Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law Sanctions Regulations 2026, I'll just call them the new regulations, expand the former regulations so serious breaches of international humanitarian law around the world now constitute designatable activity.
Previously, this was not a consistent policy of the British government. Such breaches could be designated in countries which face their own UK geographic sanctions regimes, such as Sudan, Syria, Myanmar, and the Democratic Republic of Congo. And this change is common sense. Some examples of serious breaches include armed actors targeting defenseless civilians, performing public executions, and a state deporting or transferring parts of its civilian population into the territory it occupies. One of the chief catalysts for this action was the Israeli government under Benjamin Netanyahu making a clear statement that it is intended to bury the prospect of a Palestinian state and with it the two-state solution through illegal settlement expansion, particularly in the case of the E1 project.
This breaches the rights of Palestinians for self-determination. Israel always had a right to defend itself in a proportionate manner after the heinous terror attacks of the 7th of October 2023. However, what we have seen in both Gaza and the West Bank has gone far beyond this. This government has thankfully accepted the July 2024 advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice that Israel's occupation of Palestinian territory is unlawful, and my right honorable friend the Foreign Secretary was exactly right to say in his statement of the 8th of September, if the occupation is illegal, do we want to maintain at the level of principle normal economic relationships? We say no.
Nevertheless, without a new statutory instrument, normal economic relationships with illegal settlements would have been effectively maintained. The previous regulations did not afford the government the power to systematically oppose their creation through financing and construction originating in the UK. The previous regulations, while a good step, were inadequate for the government to deliver on its obligations under international humanitarian law. While I wholeheartedly support the replacement of the previous regulations with the new ones, two questions remain which I would like to put to the minister.
How will the government monitor those who commit acts which may make them liable to designation, and how swiftly will we act upon reliable reports of such acts? I'm sure that in the particular case of the government's ambition with its allies to stop E1 being built and protect the two-state solution, the Foreign Secretary's statement to the House on the 8th of September and the joint statement from this and other governments on how we will take action against settlement expansion was a meaningful factor in the Israeli Attorney General's delaying the opening of construction and financing tenders to mid-November, a long sentence in one breath. To support the government's action, the APPG on Britain-Palestine, which I co-chair with my honourable friend the member for Middlesbrough and Thornby East, has written to over 150 financial and business entities, trade associations and regulators to inform them of the obligations these regulations place on them, their members and those under their regulatory purview. Currently, we've had a response of 27 from some of those entities. It is evident that the government's initial announcement on the 8th of September was a good warning for them to avoid involvement in E1.
Nevertheless, that response rate suggests that people haven't quite got the message. We cannot afford to march to the edge of action only to falter when we've finally shown the collective action of the UK and our allies to be a powerful threat against breaches of international humanitarian law. I therefore ask the Minister what work does his department is his department undertaking to ensure that this unity of purpose, particularly between those who were co-signatories of the joint Foreign Minister's statement on the two-state solution on the 8th of September, translates into unity in action? Does he it also does he also view these measures as sufficient to combat activities to maintain existing settlements? If not, what action will he take to ensure that this is the case?
Only yesterday, it was I was approached by a journalist with evidence of jobs in medical clinics in illegal settlements being advertised in this country at an event in London last weekend. I know the government was outraged by the advertisement of illegal settlement properties at the Great Israeli Real Estate event which took place a few months ago in London. So what action can the government take to ensure that these activities cannot happen again? As I've said, I fully support these new regulations, however, I would be interested to know whether creating a set of activity-based regulations applying to all existing settlements, not just the new ones, would would be a better approach. I'm grateful for your time, Mr. Streeter, and thank also the members of the committee.
Monica Harding
Thank you, Chair, it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today. This is an encouraging and very welcome step forward. The Liberal Democrats have long pushed for a greater use of the UK's sanctions regime to target those whose actions are actively undermining human rights, targeting the most vulnerable and perpetrating war crimes. It is important and right that the legislation more fully provides for responding to egregious violations of international humanitarian law. This is particularly so at a time when millions around the world are facing humanitarian crises, yet while brave humanitarians are doing their best to provide life-saving assistance, other actors are actively undermining, obstructing or preventing those efforts.
The Liberal Democrats support this legislation and will back it. But in setting out our support for this, it is also vital to note that this is, whilst an important step forward, not the final step. This legislation furnishes the government with the framework needed to stand up for human rights and international humanitarian law around the world. It is a tool, and a powerful one, which allows the UK to take targeted measures to stand up for the most vulnerable people around the world.
So what matters now is the government's willingness to use this tool given to it to it by the House to stand up for the values it has articulated and take on with our support those powerful forces who believe that they can act with impunity. The government must have the courage of its convictions and in light of the provisions set out in this legislation it must evaluate without fear or favour the actions of all those friend or foe whose actions are both fuelling and carrying out violence, displacement, famine and human rights abuses around the world. The legislation opens the door to further sanctions and greater accountability. The government must grasp this opportunity and members across the House must demand it.
Speaker 20
Thank you Mr Speaker. I think often in these delegated legislation committees we think we're just going to be talking about technical issues and maybe not covering matters that are of groundbreaking importance. But I have to say I feel a bit of the weight of history on my shoulders today. I think I'm the only member who was also in the bill committee for the original sanctions and anti-money laundering bill, the SAML bill as was. And referred to previously so obviously that was being worked on at the end of 2017 into 2018.
Back then the opposition was trying to persuade the government at the time to take on Magnitsky sanctions as they were known then. Now we didn't get very far for a long time but very pleased that Baron Benyon came to our rescue who had been put on the bill committee possibly by mistake actually but anyway he helped us and he managed to get us there and I'm very very pleased that the government then in opposition the Conservative party did then take that on. And I must pay tribute to them because I think they did try and make a success of that regime. But I'm really proud that it's now being expanded. It's so important that it is.
And very very proud that that's happening under a Labour government. And I do think that we should now take a moment to remember the people who pushed for those Magnitsky sanctions in the first place not least Bill Browder in memory of Sergei Magnitsky and his truly disgusting treatment by the Russian regime. But we do need to be seeing change here. So I'm very pleased with what the minister said. I was pleased to see the round of sanctions that he mentioned earlier this week on the one year anniversary of the fall of El Fasher particularly focused on conflict-related sexual violence which I think is not not often common in sanctions regimes but absolutely right the UK is taking a stance on this.
And in relation to that question about the direct consequences of sanctions obviously the minister provided a great example but we saw with the previous round of Sudan-focused sanctions how one of the worst perpetrators of truly horrific violence in the Sudan conflict who was sanctioned by the UK named and shamed then appeared to be removed from the command structure of one of the warring parties. There is a direct impact from these measures. And I'm really pleased their scope is going to be expanded because again we see in so many contexts as others have talked about the manipulation of life-saving aid as a weapon of war over and over again and sadly that's only become more common so it's right that we're taking this action now. And I really hope the government will keep this under review in relation to Sudan. I hope they will also be focused on the fact that we see many external actors involved in Sudan.
We've seen that through the UN's fact-finding mission report particularly in relation to the UAE but other countries as well. I was pleased that the government reaffirmed its commitment to that report in the House yesterday and I hope they will bear that in mind in everything they do sanctions but also their actions at the UN too.
I should mention also in this regard that some representatives from South Sudan were in the House this week, and they said that they thought it was important our sanctions regime should notice the connections between what's happening in Sudan and South Sudan, particularly also given that the US, for example, has used visa bans on South Sudanese individuals who've been responsible for violations of human rights. And I would associate myself with the remarks made by my friend for Old Abingdon and Saddleworth as well when it comes to the West Bank and Gaza and IHL. And I'd just end by saying I really think this legislation represents our values as a country. You know, the UK supports international humanitarian law, we have done since the end of the Second World War, and I think we should be really proud about our principles, not just in rhetoric, but obviously with hard action hitting those perpetrators of violations where it hurts. So very, very pleased to see this today.
Kit Malthouse
Oh, thank you, Chairman. I too support these sanctions, seems sensible to me, and I would imagine any patriot would support something that seeks to make us more powerful in the world in pursuit of not only our national interest but our national values, as the honorable lady said. I do though have, I know she said we often talk about technical questions, I do though have just three short technical questions if I may for the Minister. First of all, within the bill, it seeks to differentiate between citizens of the rest of the world and those of the United States, European Union, Australia, and Canada. Could he explain why those territories or countries get special treatment compared to anybody else?
The second issue I had was about transparency of consideration. He will know that one of the frustrations that the House has expressed on many occasions over the last three or four years has the unwillingness of the government to share its legal advice in consideration of its position under lots of international treaties and agreements. And if, say for example, a Member of Parliament or anybody else, frankly, was to bring a particularly egregious case for consideration under these designation sanctions, how would that person understand how the government has reached the conclusion that it has, either for or against? Obviously, a huge amount of discretion in here with regards to the Secretary of State's powers, but I think the credibility of these sanctions and their deployment stands very much in the contemplation of how those decisions are reached. And, you know, it may be that the government has to fess up to the fact that it's making decisions on basic politics, right?
That there's somebody who under any other guise we'd love to designate, but actually there's something else we're getting round the back from them that we need to be cognizant of. But I just think the government loses credibility if it starts to take inconsistent decisions that are being illustrated. And then my final question was really when do we expect the first wave of sanctions, assuming this goes through today?
İmran Hussein
Thank you, Mr. Slinger, and of course it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I of course welcome, like other colleagues, these very important regulations today. And it's clearly the commitment to strengthen our firm commitment to international humanitarian law and make clear that there will be consequences for those who breach these laws. I also want to welcome the wider change in direction announced by the Foreign Secretary recently. But as has been made clear, Mr. Slinger, these are only, these regulations are only enabling powers.
They do not in themselves sanction a single individual or company.
So the real test is how ministers will, how effectively ministers will use these regulations. And as we've seen in the case of the predecessor regulations to these, they were used very effectively and continue to be with regards to the widespread sanctions against Russia. What we must see is these regulations with the widened scope now used for widespread sanctions against Israel with its war crimes and breach of international humanitarian law. And again, I welcome the government has acknowledged the unlawful occupation, the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians in the West Bank by settler terrorists and increasing evidence of war crimes in Gaza. We must now act to prevent the war crimes, and it is clear we cannot continue to allow people, companies, and institutions sustaining them to retain access to British finance and markets without consequences.
And to be clear, what we cannot stop with a handful of sanctions against violent settlers or apply only to future expansions. The existing settlement system is unlawful and sustained by a wider machinery: ministers and state bodies, banks, construction and property companies, and technology companies providing surveillance used daily against Palestinians. So I have a number of questions for the minister. Will the minister make clear that these powers target those maintaining existing settlements as well as those expanding them? The E1 bids can be opened from 19th November, yet no E1-related designations had been announced as of yesterday.
So will the minister confirm that designation cases are being prepared by the government and the government will act before the tender advances any further? Will he also confirm that banks, contractors, technology companies, and others involved in supporting the E1 project and the wider settlement enterprise will be included? Will he confirm that these new powers will be used against those responsible and involved in obstructing humanitarian aid into Gaza? Will he also confirm, as stated by my honourable friend for Liverpool, that the new powers would be used against those who are involved in the serious and arbitrary arrest and unlawful detention of Palestinian children? And can he set out the timetable for all of the above?
Richard Burgon
Thank you very much, Mr. Stringer, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. These regulations are important. These regulations are important in their potential and, of course, in their application. I very much welcome the government's recognition that Israel's occupation of Palestinian territory is unlawful, in line with the International Court of Justice's historic 2024 opinion. I also welcome the associated sanctions package, including these regulations before us today, as an important first step towards meeting our obligations under that ICJ ruling.
These regulations add grounds for sanctions, including for serious violations of international humanitarian law, for serious breaches of liberty and security, and for aid obstruction. Used effectively and quickly, these powers can help prevent further crimes and can help ensure accountability for those crimes already committed. So I've got four key points for the minister and I'd welcome a response. Firstly, what counts as a serious violation of international humanitarian law?
Will the Minister confirm that as a minimum, the definition will follow that of the International Committee of the Red Cross? The International Committee of the Red Cross's role under the Geneva Conventions makes it an authoritative voice on the rules of war. The ICRC states that serious violations of international humanitarian law are war crimes. The two are interchangeable. So will these regulations apply when an occupying power transfers its civilians into occupied territory, forcibly transfers an occupied population, or deliberately attacks civilians or civilian infrastructure, war crimes Israel has repeatedly carried out?
And will these powers cover international humanitarian law violations across all Israeli settlements, not just new ones, and also be applicable to those financing such violations? Secondly, on aid. Here, as with E1, urgent designations against those meeting the legal tests can make a real difference. Regulation 4(4) creates new grounds regarding aid obstruction. With winter approaching, aid is again being blocked when it comes to Gaza.
Last week, Israeli political figures joined a blockade of aid trucks bound for Gaza. Without naming individuals here, will the Minister confirm that the government is preparing sanctions against those obstructing or supporting the delivery of aid to Gaza this winter? And will the Minister confirm that these regulations can apply to officials, politicians, and private entities, including UK charities, responsible not only for physical blockades, but administrative obstruction of aid, including decisions on permits and crossings, and to those financing aid obstruction? Thirdly, these powers must apply to those funding and supporting violations. Regulation 8 makes it clear that an involved person includes those supporting IHL violations as well as direct perpetrators.
Back in March 2022, the government targeted six banks in a package aimed at key industries supporting Russia's illegal invasion. We need the same determination to stop money flowing from or through the UK to sustain illegal Israeli settlements or the wider unlawful occupation. So will the Minister today make clear that banks, charities, financiers, contractors, insurers, and technology companies supporting these international humanitarian law violations risk sanctions? And finally, these regulations will need to be accompanied by additional FCDO resources to tackle Israeli war crimes. Will the government provide the staff, the legal expertise, and the resources on a scale matching its work on sanctions against Russia?
Andy McDonald
Thank you, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I draw members' attention to my role as co-chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Britain and Palestine. But I very much welcome these regulations and I congratulate the Minister for bringing them forward. These powers, of course, apply globally and colleagues have rightly cited the heinous crimes in Sudan and in Ukraine.
But I want to focus on their potential application to Israel's conduct in the occupied state of Palestine, where recent events demonstrate the urgency of translating these new powers into action.
Earlier this month, more than 100 humanitarian human rights organisations, including Save the Children and the Norwegian Refugee Council, warned that Israeli restrictions on aid, essential equipment and reconstruction materials continue to prevent Gaza's recovery. Meanwhile, the UN reports at least 160 settler attacks associated with the West Bank olive harvest in the first fortnight of October alone, sometimes involving Israeli forces. The World Health Organisation reports median approval delays of 74 days for medical supplies, with 40% of laboratory and diagnostic equipment awaiting approval. The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs has similarly documented continuing obstacles affecting the delivery of essential humanitarian supplies and equipment. So against that background, I too have a number of questions for the Minister.
First, is the Government currently assessing whether these documented actions in Gaza and the West Bank meet the new grounds for designation, including the responsibility of ministers, military commanders, senior officials and those involved in the arbitrary detention of Palestinian children? Second, will the humanitarian assistance provisions be applied to those responsible for decisions or omissions obstructing food, medicines, essential equipment and the operation of humanitarian organisations wherever the statutory criteria are met? And third, how will the Government assess financiers, companies and commercial interests supporting or facilitating qualifying violations, including those associated with the maintenance and expansion of illegal settlements? And as my honourable friend, the Member for Aldridge-Brownhills, had referred to the Great Israeli Real Estate Event earlier this year, I've also been made aware that at Sunday's Medex UK event in London, an organisation was distributing leaflets advertising medical vacancies in illegal Israeli settlements, while another exhibitor was reportedly offering to help British people relocate to what it described as awesome settlements. What is the Government's response to that?
Will the Government issue new guidance to the Charity Commission, banks and other financial institutions and relevant businesses, making clear their obligations and the risks of financing or facilitating qualifying violations associated with illegal settlements? And fourth, the E1 settlement tender concerns 1,234 homes, with bids not due to be opened before the 19th of November. So will the Government seek to make its first evidence-based designations before the 19th of November, while there is still an opportunity to deter further commitments to the E1 development? And will the Minister provide Parliament with a timetable for implementation of these powers and the wider promised action on settlement goods and services? Mr Stringer, I very much welcome these regulations, but their effectiveness will be judged by whether they deliver timely and meaningful accountability, not simply by the powers they place on the statute book.
I'd welcome some comment by the Minister and hopefully some reassurance on these matters. Thank you.
Ian Robert Byrne
Thank you, Mr Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. First, I'd like to pay tribute to Father Bashir, who was here earlier, a Palestinian priest who spoke so movingly this afternoon about his experiences of settler violence in his town, Taybeh, in the West Bank.
It was extremely moving what he had to say and what they were actually living through. I very warmly welcome the government's new regulations to extend sanctions frameworks to serious violations of international humanitarian law. The Foreign Secretary rightly warned businesses on the 19th of October not to accept tenders related to the expansion of illegal settlements in the E1 area of the West Bank. Yet, as I understand it, Minister, the UK sanctions list shows no new designations connected to this warning since the regulations came into force. These warnings will only be as strong as the action that follows.
The regulations we are discussing today give the Foreign Secretary the power to enforce his calls. And I raise this in the context of charities. It's been reported that a UK charity gave around 5.7 million between 2017 and 2021 to a school in an illegal settlement in the occupied West Bank. Further reporting has identified UK charitable funds reaching organizations that pursue settlement expansion. The British public give to charity in good faith.
They do not expect their generosity to finance the occupation of the West Bank that the British government itself recognizes as unlawful. So, can I ask the Minister for three clear commitments? If the government will issue guidance working with the Charity Commission to ensure that trustees know what due diligence is expected to avoid funding organizations or people directly or indirectly involved or that enforce the illegal occupation of the West Bank. Second, confirm that UK individuals, businesses, and charities financing or supporting settlement activity can be considered for designation where the legal criteria are met. And thirdly, set out how the government will investigate evidence of charitable funding supporting serious violations and act on that evidence and report this back to Parliament.
Every designation must meet the legal test, but under the standard procedure, that test is reasonable grounds to suspect that a person is involved. A criminal conviction is not required. So, Chair, we cannot condemn illegal settlements while failing to confront the money that sustains them. The government has rightly strengthened its powers. What Parliament, charities, businesses, and above all the Palestinian people now need to know is when these powers will be used.
I thank you.
Stephen Doughty
I certainly would, Mr. Stringer, and can I start by thanking members for their support for these regulations, but also the powerful and passionate speeches they've set out a wide range of concerns and issues, both in relation to how the sanctions regimes can be used effectively, but also a number of circumstances in which we may choose to use those regimes, Mr. Chair. And obviously, as I never tire of saying, I don't comment on future designations. We don't comment on future designations. But what I can assure you of is that I've heard very, very clearly a number of the examples, both the themes that members have raised, but also the specific examples they've raised. And what I would say is that they should always feel free, as indeed should other organizations, to make representations and to provide evidence, to provide information.
I cannot always be able to say that how we will use that, but it is gratefully received and is hugely impactful in the government in deciding on both which designations to make, but also which will have the biggest impact, because ultimately that's what we're trying to do here. I'll try and respond on, I think we've got a reasonable bit of time, I'll try and respond to as many of the comments made as I can. But firstly, thank the opposition shadow minister for his comments and welcome that the opposition won't oppose these regulations.
And he asked a number of questions about the the way in which we reach designations and the the process, how do we ensure it's fair, proportional, due process and and so on. I can assure him that it's an incredibly rigorous process. And it has to be, because of course these designations and regulations have to stand the test of challenge, both within this place but also fundamentally in the courts, Mr. Chair. And it's very reassuring to me that our sanction regimes, which are wide and broad and have many many thousands of designations, have survived the rightful challenge that they're able to be put under through due process in the courts. And I think that is a reflection of the the effort that is put into ensuring the lawfulness, the proportionality, the accuracy of the evidence.
And there are a number of processes he asked about review and how we ensure that things are done rightly. We have a ministerial review process, we have reviews by officials and those can go to ministers. And we do occasionally revoke or vary designations if we've found to have made a mistake or where there is, for example, an evidence of a significant change of behavior and therefore the regulation is not is not needed. It's also very important, Mr. Stringer, that we look at the issues around compliance and enforcement. This is an issue I took on quite substantially when I became the minister in 2024 and worked closely with colleagues across government.
Colleagues will understand this is a responsibility of multiple departments to ensure that we have good compliance and enforcement. And part of that, of course, is working with businesses, with the legal sector, with those who might be impacted by sanctions. Ultimately, they are responsible for complying with the law, but we want to ensure they have the right information. We've tried to... I I certainly will, I'll give way.
David Reed
Thank the minister for giving way. Just in terms of consistency then, so this what's been put forward now expands the scope quite significantly. Will the FCDO be using existing frameworks to ensure that consistency or are you going to expand it to reflect the expanded powers?
Stephen Doughty
So I guess there are two two things, Mr. Stringer. One is that firstly we already have in place actions that we've improved the way we do enforcement and work across government departments that came in as a result of the review that we did. Those are now being taken forward, they're making a significantly successful impact in both the information we give externally, how people can report breaches, the information we provide to businesses, to legal advisors and others to ensure compliance. But he did ask more broadly that point about consistency as well across topics and I guess across geographies as well. And in the existing regime, it had already been used for Southeast Asia, Sri Lanka, the West Bank, the designation of Ben-Gvir and Smotrich, Georgia.
There are many many examples. And of course this is one part of our overall sanctions legislation. I'm conscious that my right honorable friend previously served on the actual SAMLA legislation. Of course there are many different regimes under that legislation, geographic regimes, thematic regimes. They are all tools in that armoury and we are using them in a wide range of geographic and thematic contexts.
But I'm also very very happy at any point, should he or any other colleagues want to have more detailed briefings with officials about how the process is work. I've greatly valued actually the cross-party input that there's been on these issues and we've had a number of sessions with our our detailed technical teams. I think he asked a specific question as well about the new power about designation by description and how that's used effectively. And as I said, it provides additional flexibility in circumstances where we can't possibly identify every relevant person individually by name. And similar powers exist actually elsewhere in the sanctions architecture.
But of course, Mr Stringer, any use of the power would have to meet the requirements in the legislation. It doesn't remove the need for designations to satisfy statutory tests and that's absolutely right and that's how we maintain the legitimacy and the functioning of the overall sanctions regime. There were many, many helpful points by colleagues. Can I thank my friend from Liverpool Riverside? She raised a very, very important issue about the detention of children and many, many harrowing cases that she has rightfully spoken out on but also that I am aware of.
We're horrified by the reports of mistreatment or abuse of children in detention, many reportedly without charge for months and children must always be protected. I'm sure we would all absolutely agree and we have called repeatedly on the Israeli authorities to investigate urgently. I cannot comment on future designations but she can be absolutely assured that this is an issue we take incredibly, incredibly seriously and I'm very happy to discuss that further with her and a number of other colleagues raised that as well. She asked about how we use evidence. She'll appreciate that I can't always go into that process and she'll understand why not but what I can assure her of is that it is considered absolutely rigorously.
We have to satisfy through our own tests because ultimately that is evidence that has to satisfy courts if necessary if designations are challenged and otherwise so it's an incredibly rigorous process. And I'd be quite honest, Mr Stringer, I know there is sometimes frustration about speed in these processes but it is that question of sometimes balancing speed against the solidity of our designations and our regimes and ensuring that they stand the test of time and the test of the courts. We will keep Parliament obviously informed and we regularly do in terms of specific designations that we may choose to make under these new expanded powers. We'll of course be keeping colleagues informed on that. My honourable friend from Oldham East and Saddleworth, she was asking a range of questions making very passionate points about the situation in Palestine but I think she was also touching on this issue of well why didn't we necessarily have some of these powers originally given actually the much wider range of abuses that we're aware of.
And obviously it was a previous government under which the original regime was introduced but my understanding was that particularly as we were developing our new sanctions regime after Brexit and having to develop a system from scratch, we hadn't yet been tested by the courts. We wanted to make sure that what we did was effective, was going to stand up and that's why actually some of the original powers were perhaps more narrower than we would all want to see. But I'm really pleased at the welcome that there has been that we are now expanding, that we are taking more powers, that we are encompassing a wider range of issues, Mr Stringer, because I think that's very important. I'll happily give way.
Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams
Thank you so much and I'm grateful to the Minister. It was actually to think why our regulations wouldn't incorporate existing settlements as well as...?
Stephen Doughty
This was a point that was made actually by a number of members. I can assure our position on settlements is very, very clear. They are all unlawful. They are all illegal. The occupation is unlawful.
That will be what guides our approach. I'm not going to get into the specifics but she can be assured that our view is about all settlements. But obviously there is a particular challenge that we'll accept and a number of members raised about the particularly the E1 project and the expansion of particular actions that are going on at the moment. And again thank her for her work on the APPG. A number of members actually in that regard asked why we haven't yet announced any designations to prevent the development of E1.
You know we've obviously tried to move as fast as we can in terms of these new powers. Members will note that we have of course set out on the 8th of December we'll be introducing a specific settlement trade-related regime as well. That will take longer.
This was important to get these powers in place now. We now, hopefully with the permission of this committee and the other place, will have the powers secure and in place. I won't comment on when we might choose to use them, how we will use them, but I'm very conscious of the very specific things that are going on. We are building designations. I do want to assure colleagues in relation to that, and we will ensure that they're effective as a part of a wider strategy, which is aimed at isolating, restricting, changing the behavior of those targeted, sending a clear message about our position on this.
I can also, you know, assure colleagues that even the fact that we have announced these measures is already impacting on behavior. And I hope it's focusing the minds, and I say this very sincerely, Mr. Stringer, I hope it's focusing the minds of those who might consider being involved in the expansion of these illegal settlements, and particularly the E1 project. We've sent a very clear message. I've sent a clear message. The Foreign Secretary's sent a clear message.
The Prime Minister's sent a clear message. Businesses and others, including those in the provision of services, should hear that message. They should heed that message because we will not be hesitating to act. And I also want to assure colleagues that although the Foreign Secretary was very clear that it could take up to six to nine months for the wider settlement regime, we will be seeking every opportunity to accelerate that whilst ensuring it's properly viable and has the very, very strong legal basis. The Liberal Democrat spokesperson, I want to thank her again for her contribution and indeed the welcome for the legislation, the passion she set out, and also the challenge, and we welcome that scrutiny and it's good to be able to work cross-party on these.
My right honorable friend from Oxford East, I'm already commended for her work originally on the SAMLA bill, and she rightly pointed out others who have stood up actually on a range of regimes, and she mentioned Bill Browder and indeed Baroness Bonyan and others, and there have been many, many strong advocates across the house for powers to act in a wide range of circumstances. I'm very, very glad that we are taking more powers. I thank her for her welcome about the measures we announced in relation to Al-Fashir, and you know, my honorable friend the Minister for Africa spoke very passionately yesterday about some of the testimony that she'd heard about the absolute horrors that were seen in Al-Fashir. We are all, I can assure her, resolutely focused on preventing a further deterioration of the situation in Sudan, and indeed she rightly mentioned South Sudan as well. We will be looking at every single way in which we can do that, including of course through sanctions and designation regimes, and she quite rightly pointed out a way in which our regime has already had an impact on a particular individual.
The honorable member from Northwest Hampshire asked a very particular question about citizens and incumbents. I will make sure we write to him about that and get him a technical answer on that. He asked about when. I'm afraid I can't reveal that today in the committee, Mr. Stringer, but I can assure him we don't take powers without intending to use them. There'll be a range of measures that are laid before this house in due course, and I hope members will be reassured when they see those, but also that they will apply to a wide range of contexts.
We heard a number of those mentioned today. I appreciate, you know, there is a desire from those who perhaps provide information or raise concerns, they want an explanation about why things are decided or not decided and consistency and so on. He'll understand we don't normally put forward obviously legal advice or the individual circumstances and why we decide or not. What I can tell him is we're always looking at, with the constraints of resource, of legal capacity, there is a huge amount invested in this in the department and we've ensured that that is protected and further invested in. We also want to have the biggest impact.
There are many, many thousands of people that I would like to take sanctions action on every single day, but I want to have the impact that is the biggest impact and that is disrupting, deterring, changing the behavior of those actors that we're seeking to influence. The honorable friend from Bradford East, I thank him for his welcome for this and also for his reference to the government's wider policies in relation to settlements and terrorism on the West Bank. And I can assure him that it won't just be sanctions, you know, we are taking every action we can, including of course raising the concerns directly with the Israeli government. I've made very, very clear, illegal settlements, they are unlawful, so is the occupation.
We've been absolutely clear about that. We absolutely made it very clear that we will be taking action on services as well and on those obstructing aid. And of course that can apply in a wide range of of contexts. And indeed I referred already to the detention issues that I think so horrify members on on this committee. I thank my honorable friend from Leeds East as well.
He asked specifically what counts as a serious violation of international humanitarian law. Mr. Stringer, international humanitarian law seeks to limit the effects of armed conflict to protect people who are not or are no longer participating in hostilities. Colleagues will know this and limits the methods and means of warfare. And the principles of distinction, proportionality, and military necessity are central to IHL. Those familiar with the Geneva Conventions and other parts of international humanitarian law will know that well.
And so the expanded regime allows us to take action where we have reasonable grounds to suspect serious violations of international humanitarian law have taken place. And a designation can be made where there are reasonable reasonable grounds to suspect. That's the key the key point here. Obviously this is a lower standard than would be applied in a civil or or a criminal court. And I think that allows us the the necessary latitude to be able to to act and to act robustly where we have very clear evidence as taken place.
I hope that that helps him. I've answered the question I think about settlements and and obstruction. He asked also about resources. And I do want to praise the fantastic teams, Mr. Stringer, in the FCDO who work on these issues. They're an incredible team.
They work night and day to make sure not only that we're able to respond to developing situations and challenges, but also as I said to ensure that those designations that we make are evidence-based, they're proportional, they're lawful, and they stand the test of of scrutiny. And that requires an immense amount of very, very detailed technical work. Colleagues will appreciate. And I thank them every day for the work that they the work that they do and the impact that it has. And genuinely it has had a very, very substantial impact.
My honorable friend from Middlesbrough, I was just thinking it can scarcely be I think it's 14 years since we first came into this place almost to the to the week, couple of weeks' time anniversary. And he's been an assiduous champion on these issues throughout his time in this house. And thank him for his work on the APPG as well. You know, he shared and reflected powerful testimony from NGOs and humanitarian organizations. He also spoke of issues relating to delays in medical supplies, diagnostics, and so on.
And I can absolutely assure him that all of that sort of evidence is the sort of thing that informs who we will choose to act on. And again he raised the issue about services which we've made clear we will take action on. And I hope very much as I said the fact we've announced this, Mr. Stringer, is already having a deterrent effect. Very confident of that. But people should be in no doubt that we will seek to act against specific individuals and organizations.
And my honorable friend from Liverpool West Derby also spoke with great passion. He raised specific issues around charities. He'll know that obviously regulation of charity for the Charity Commission, but we do look at these matters very seriously. He'll be aware of a number of ongoing investigations and processes. But I in conclusion, Mr. Stringer, I do want to thank all colleagues for the very comprehensive contributions they've made.
It's incredibly helpful for the government to have heard them, to have this genuine scrutiny and challenge. Helps us develop and and expand these regimes and do so effectively. We are acting, we're acting on the basis of our values. We're acting because we want to see impact. And I can assure colleagues that further measures will be laid in due course before the house.
And again thank all members of the committee and commend the regulations to the committee.
Graham Stringer
The question is that the committee has considered the Global Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law Sanctions Regulations 2026. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye." Of the contrary, "No." I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.