Transport Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Transport Committee House of Commons
Follow its sittingsDave Calfe
Yeah, very similar to what Eddie said. That's we're waiting for the RMT to conclude their discussions with the employer, and then we'll get involved as ASLEF.
Jodie.
Jodie Lofthouse
I really share the frustration that residents along the route have and share their ambition to get this services open as soon as possible. The Department continues to work really closely with Chiltern to get passenger services up and running, and we've made significant progress in completing the remaining tasks that have been alluded to for mobilization of services, including training of drivers, including the completion of modifications to the trains, and on completing works at Winslow, which is in the process of being handed over. The remaining works include the agreement of the operating model for the railway, and we need to have that completed before we can look at the dates for getting passenger services in play.
Tony.
Tony Baxter
Okay, yeah, I mean I agree with a lot of what the panel said there. I think in terms of a lot of progress has been made in terms of the three areas of operational readiness, which Chiltern are involved with.
from a trains point of view, we have taken trains from WMT, the 196 trains. Modifications have been completed now, and we've made good progress in terms of the acquisition and make and testing. From a stations point of view, we operate Winslow station. The fit-out is now largely complete. The legal transfer to Chiltern is in flight, and we've completed all our staff recruitment there, so good progress on stations.
In terms of the running of train services itself, we've recruited and trained 44 drivers, which is a big task for a relatively small train operating company. And they're well advanced in their training both from acquisition of the original driver train licences through to specialist knowledge we need for the route and the types of trains that they'll be driving as well. The outstanding there's still some outstanding tasks before we can move into operations of services, and one of those is to reach agreement, which we haven't been able to do yet, with the RMT. I think ASLEF's position, as Dave has said, has been quite consistent, really, that from sequencing point of view, we need to have a resolution with the RMT and between the RMT and Chiltern to allow us to finalize those conversations with the ASLEF. Then there's and perhaps set it out later, there's then some other tasks that need to be done once agreement is reached from
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
So, you indicated that the discussions with the RMT is not the only issue. Are there some other issues that are responsible that are you know, a factor towards the 744 days?
Tony Baxter
Right. So, in terms of the other issues, which are now largely complete, so the station is ready, from a point of view of that. From a train's point of view, we have completed modifications, which did drive some of the delay, which is regrettable. That is now completed.
Speaker 8
Right, so that's complete. That's complete. Is there anything else not complete?
Tony Baxter
as well. Yeah. So, what needs to happen now, if I can set out maybe the sort of the key steps, and we can write and offer a bit more detail if this is helpful to the committee. Our priority is to agree method of operation with the RMT. That will then allow us to finalize discussions and reach agreement with ASLEF.
Once we've done that and achieved those two points, there is then some further work required in terms of updating things like training materials, which will reflect the agreed method of operation. And then, there is some final training to be done and things like final safety validations with the Office of Rail and Road, which is our safety regulator. So, the key sequence of events with those, to reach agreement with the trade unions, which is very much an alive discussion.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
And for the unions, particularly the RMT, is the dispute primarily around passenger safety or job security or just the fact that you feel they didn't talk to you early enough?
Eddie Dempsey
It's about passenger safety. We've maintained a position around maintaining the safeties a second safety-critical person on trains. We're going to come on to the detail of that.
Eddie Dempsey
Yeah. And we initially reached out to talk to people in 2024, and have had a series of conversations with people in industry and government since, but we haven't started formal consultation around staffing matters until July of this year. So, that's one of the reasons why we're disappointed this could have been dealt with sooner, we think.
Speaker 18
So, what would a what would a satisfactory settlement look like so far as you're concerned?
Eddie Dempsey
It's very simple. We're talking about very few staff. We're talking about less than 40 staff. We're talking about a salary difference of about five grand for a second safety-critical person with a role in the dispatch process.
Speaker 15
Sorry, is that five grand between having the dispatch role and not having a dispatch role, or yeah?
Eddie Dempsey
Presently, what's being proposed is 31 customer service staff would work on the trains in a customer service role, and we're saying to give those staff the full suite of safety responsibilities for train evacuation, protection of the line and all of the other duties we've seen guards undertake in derailments recently, the difference in salary is about five grand, so this could be resolved.
Eddie Dempsey
So, it's not an argument about who presses a button to open a door, it's about who has got a role in managing the platform train interface process. So, this could be We're talking about less than 40 staff, we're talking about somewhere between 150, 200 grand annually, we're talking about probably 0.3% of the payroll bill to resolve this.
We're in negotiations and we're hoping we can get a resolution.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Okay. All right. Well, we'll move on, and may pick that up, the details of that, in subsequent questions. Alex.
Speaker 22
Thank you, Chair. Starting with Tony, please. Why did Chiltern Railways take the decision to propose driver-only operation on the line, and did you anticipate any opposition from the unions?
Tony Baxter
Yeah, so if I can answer that in terms of this a little bit of the history. So, the original specification for the East West Rail was as driver-only operated, which means there is one person with full safety accountability, including operating of the doors and dispatch, and that formed part of the specification for East West Rail when Chiltern became the operator acting under that specification in March 2025. Chiltern supported that, though, so it wasn't it wasn't imposed on Chiltern. Chiltern operates around 73% of its services at the moment within driver-only op- operations,
and I think we were selected following a selection criteria and process which the department did as well. Does that fully answer the question, or-
Speaker 23
Yes, basically, I think so. So, Eddie, at the moment, the trains between Oxford and Bicester Village, how many members of staff do they have on them?
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Can I j- Before we go any further on the details of this, can we just be quite clear that there's the driver-only operation, DOO, refers to just one person on the train who is the driver, and DCO is the driver-controlled operation, but that the assumption on when we talk about DCO is there's a second person on the train, and the discussion is about what they're doing, not whether or not there is a second person on the train, because that has been resolved?
Yes.
Speaker 23
Thank you. So, we understand the RMT's position that a second, safety-critical member of staff is essential. Is there anything different between the part of the line between Oxford and Bicester Village and the new bit of the line that makes a second, safety-critical member of staff more important?
Eddie Dempsey
Not particularly, but if you're going to staff a train, we think it makes better sense to have that person fully trained with the ability to operate the full suite of safety responsibilities. It seems to us not to make sense to staff the trains, but then not have that person with the ability to carry out the full suite of safety responsibilities that a fully trained guard would have. That doesn't seem to make sense to us.
Speaker 23
And can you explain So, you were saying before that second, safety critical member of staff would have responsibilities for evacuation, for example, which I think we could all understand. Thank you. Could you explain particularly the issue of dispatch? Because clearly, across quite a lot of the railway, we've just had some stats, drivers are managing to operate the doors.
Eddie Dempsey
So just to explain, the platform train interface is very important because it's where we find an over over-representation of incidents where people are hurt on the part of the network that is driver-only operation. So out of the train operating companies run by the DfT, there is only one which is fully driver-only operation. The majority of services are still run with a safety critical guard on board. There are plenty There are some companies where there's a mix of driver-only and guarded operation. But what we see is about 70% of incidents related to the platform train interface happen on the DOO services.
So traps and drags, people falling down between the train and the platform, and so on. Where you've got somebody responsible for the dispatch process, it allows the driver to be responsible for the movement of the train, driving the train. And it allows that person to deal with issues around accessibility, people with additional needs getting on and off, and incidents that happen in that area. And we've seen plenty of occasions where in fact it's been indispensable to have someone with those safety responsibilities on board, most recently the derailment near Bedford, and of course the tragic events that happened on the East Coast last year. So we think those things are important, and for the sake of in this instance, maybe 150, 200 grand plus on the wage bill a year to have those safety responsibilities and competencies, we think that's probably best value for the public, and a better settlement overall, rather than staffing the trains, but staffing them with people unable to carry out those safety roles and responsibilities.
Speaker 23
And in terms of a person sort of hopping on and off the train to dispatch it, I would say sometimes as a passenger, I felt they spend a lot of time getting on and off, and then perhaps aren't walking up and down the carriages as much, particularly on busier services. So might not be spotting other issues on board the train, perhaps antisocial behaviour or something like that. Is that an issue that you recognise that if somebody is literally having to get off the train at each station, press a button, et cetera, that they might not be, you know, manning the full length of the train as much as somebody whose job was literally to walk up and down it rather than have a role at each individual station?
Eddie Dempsey
We think all of those things are important, but please bear in mind on a lot of our network, accessibility is important. A lot of incidents, antisocial behaviour or otherwise don't just happen in the carriages of a train. Having a person with a role in the dispatch process is important as well as the other duties that are carried out. So I don't see that there's a conflict between the two, if I'm honest with you.
Speaker 23
Okay, thank you. And then back to Tony again. Did you undertake a route-specific risk assessment in terms of driver-only operation being safe on that bit of East West Rail?
Tony Baxter
Yes, so in terms of the safety validation, we've done a lot of work around that. We can't finalise safety validation until we have method of operation agreed, but we are very confident there's nothing unique or particular to that line of route, which is different to the rest of our route, that will present any risks. I think in terms of the safety element and the discussion there, just to sort of maybe just to remind the committee, obviously the original proposal was for driver-only operation. We then, on reflecting and taking feedback around the role the second person on board can play for providing customer service, visibility, assurance, et cetera, in July we compromised and set a new position in terms of we made a proposal to RMT to place the customer services inspectors, which is a current role we already have on train.
They do have some elements of safety roles and responsibilities, but obviously not the dispatch of the train, but some of the things which I know the public are very interested in terms of assurance for people maybe travelling at night, extra visibility, etc. They can provide that, and also antisocial behaviour as well. In terms of the safety validation, that will be finalised once we have agreed method of operation. I think previous evidence submitted to this Committee from the Office of Rail and Road has set out sort the safety points around this, and very much providing the right infrastructure and training is in place. It is deemed a safe method of operation by our safety regulator.
Speaker 28
Thank you. Eddie, you just to take a step back from this issue of the low six-figure difference between roles, which, you know, as a just-in-case thing sounds like a very small amount of money, but it's much bigger amount of money to put these customer service inspectors on when previously it was a driver only operated proposal. You rejected that on the grounds of customer safety in August this year. We've just heard from Tony when they see that as having sort of reached a compromise offer. Have you had any further discussions with them on this particular issue since then?
Eddie Dempsey
Yes, it's worth saying we first began speaking to Chiltern about this issue in the summer of 2024. We've had series of meetings with Chiltern and with DfT right the way through. We didn't begin formal consultation on staffing arrangements until the summer of this year, but we are in discussions now and we're in good discussions, we hope, and we're trying to find a resolution. So, we are working through that, and have been in conversation right the way through. It's worth pointing out we have been very clear from the start where the union stands on this question.
I think it's fair to say until arrangements were put in place following the general election, it made things a bit diff- more difficult to progress, but we have had good conversations and continue to have those, and we're in negotiations now. Outside of this issue, this is a place where we've got remarkably good industrial relations. Our local officials and reps and the management side in Chiltern Railways get through industrial relations very well, and have done for some time. This is one area where sadly that's not landed, but we are in negotiations as we speak, and we're hopeful we can make progress.
Speaker 28
I'm sure other colleagues will want to ask about the DfT's role in this, and if this really is an anomaly to an otherwise successful relationship, I'm sure they'll probe that. Is there any room for negotiation? We've got a scenario of DOO, we've got a scenario of DCO, and now we're talking about the difference between a customer service inspector and a guard. Do you feel that there's room for negotiation? What would Chiltern have to do?
Eddie Dempsey
There's always room for negotiation, but we'll try not to play that out in this room because that will make it more difficult if we start painting ourselves into corners here. We are genuinely working to try and find a resolution, and I think it's fair to say management side is as well. I don't get the impression that they're, you know, not trying to get to a position. So, think with a bit of luck and time, we'll find ourselves coming to a resolution sooner rather than later.
Speaker 28
If I could just ask both of you, I mean, it's noble of you to consider customer safety, it's very timely obviously in the aftermath of tragic events in Europe, but we've heard that the ORR, the regulator, sees DOO as a safe way of operating a train service. It's being used, I don't know what the stats are for the particular stretch of line in which it's already being used.
Why do you disagree? And not to re-litigate the arguments you've already made, but why should it be that the unions know more about safety than the regulator?
Eddie Dempsey
So, look, I've been a I've been a driver of driver-only operated services. Okay. I worked on the railway in a number of different roles. And for me, this goes right to the heart of what sort of railway do we want to have. Do we want to have a de-staffed, dystopian network where passengers-
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Hang on, sorry. We're not talking about less staff, we're talking about the role of the second person on the train. Because I certainly echo what Alex said as a passenger, there is a reassurance of having a second person on the train who has, you know, who has my interests in heart at heart as a passenger, particularly if I'm vulnerable, particularly at night, you know, particularly if I was disabled, but I don't think at this point we're talking about literally driver only. We're talking about, as far as I can understand, on this rail line, what the second person does, not whether or not there is a loss of staff because there's no second person.
And, you know, I'm not making any comments about existing literal DOO services, but just the different roles that we'd, my understanding is in discussion of the second person on the train.
Speaker 31
I mean, I was trying to ask the question, but I'll be more specific. What we're talking about here is cost.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Yeah, you used a You used a term that implied a cutting away of staff and I don't think we're- Yeah, it's cost. Yeah, I understand that.
Eddie Dempsey
That's what's at the heart of this. Are we prepared to invest in having the best possible railway we can have for passengers, or are we going to talk about cost? Under the privatised model, the reason we ended up with driver-only operation was in order to reduce staffing costs to allow greater profits for the private companies. The profit motive isn't with us now. Now we're looking at improving service and trying to reduce public subsidy.
This government has said so far that it recognises staff as an asset rather than just a cost to be cut, which is a positive thing. So, what we're talking about right now is cost. We've already reached a point where it's agreed that this train should be staffed, and it's just to what extent those staff are going to be able to serve the public. And it seems to me, for what is quite a small cost, we should probably make sure that those staff can do more than just look after people from a customer service point of view, but also should be they're ready to deal with the safety of the line in an emergency and to keep passengers safe, for what's a relatively small cost.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
So, can I just probe your statement a little bit that driver-only operation is to do with private company profits and privatisation, as my understanding, the vast majority of driver-only operation was introduced by British Rail, which was notoriously not a private company and not a profit-driven one?
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Yes, but the first bit of DOO was introduced in the early 1980s on the Bedford-St Pancras route and there was definitely no talk of privatisation at that stage.
Eddie Dempsey
Inverclyde line. Okay. Under If we go back, we had more than 10 years of disputes around the role of the guard. That was driven by reports here aimed at cutting staffing costs because, at the time, the current thinking was, or the way it was being described as how you get cheaper fares in Britain is by cutting all of the staff out of the network without considering the massive profit leakage.
So, that's what sparked the most recent round of disputes on driver-only operation. And so here we are today. I think we're in a better place, but, as again, this is really a question about cost. The argument isn't about running an entirely destaffed network. It's about what we do with the staff we've got.
Uh no, that's completely
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Oh, thank you, Chair. In terms of resolving this dispute, what role, if any, has the Department for Transport played in this? And I suppose it's best to start with you, Jodie, on that.
Jodie Lofthouse
So, the department is supporting Chiltern as part of the appointment of Chiltern as the operator for this line. Chiltern is leading the negotiations with the unions.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
And what more do you think the government can do to help end this dispute, because I mean it's been very long-running now?
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Jodie, just for the audio, could you speak a bit louder and or closer to the mic, because you've got that we've been told you've got quite a quiet voice.
Jodie Lofthouse
No problem. I was just saying this is for ministers to take a judgment call for what actions that they might want to take. As a civil servants, my role is to give them impartial advice, which is taken from across our industry partners, and for them to make a judgment call on any further action they might want to take. So, essentially that's what the process would follow.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Fair enough. I mean I think probably, I hope the Chair would agree, we have asked ministers about this in the past, and perhaps not always necessarily received entirely clear or convincing answers. Given that the Department for Transport decided to appoint Chiltern as the operator for Oxford to Milton Keynes, to what extent was the risk of there being an argument about who opened the doors and DOO DCO taken into account when deciding that? Because you've got what sorry it's not London Midland now, sorry, London Northwestern Railway just down the road out of Bletchley who do driver and guard.
Jodie Lofthouse
So, there are a multitude of risks that come have the potential to come into play on any major rail project. This is one of the ones that was obviously known to us and the governance we set up around the project gave a clear escalation route when those risks materialize and subsequently, you know, that's what happened back in November last year when the announcement that the services weren't going to be in play that year. But again, the decisions that were taken by ministers were based on advice provided to them about the operate you know, the mode of operation on this services is one that's established on the network. It's one that Chiltern runs in a majority of its services and it's been proven to be safely operated over the last 30 years in terms of some of the facts that would've fed into that.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Yeah, sorry, perhaps my question wasn't clear. I don't necessarily need convincing. I've managed drivers both in a DOO and in a non-DOO environment. But it's more my question was more what risk assessment was made of the potential of a industrial relations conflagration on this? Was How high up was that on risk registers that it could happen if Chiltern was chosen?
Jodie Lofthouse
So, that was always one of the core risks at the top of the risk register. It's one of the ones that we monitored very closely and when Chiltern were brought on board, one of the ones that we reviewed with them as well as our other industry partners. So, again, it's always been at the top of the list of things that could happen. It was making sure that we had the governance that enabled us to act quickly, you know, should that materialize.
Speaker 30
I mean I'd suggest that governance has not yet necessarily succeeded given how long it's been going on.
Jodie Lofthouse
In mitigating the risk, I recognize what you're saying.
I think the governance in handling the risk has worked. I think some of these elements are outside of some of our control.
Speaker 34
Thank you, Chair. So, to Tony, as we're hearing about driver only operation, crimes committed on the network, including assault and harassment, have risen substantially in the past year. Personal safety on board trains is a top concern for rail passengers wherever they're traveling. How do you square those facts with the decision to propose driver only operation on the East West rail line?
Tony Baxter
Well, I think you're absolutely right. We share that concern as well around the whole aspects of anti-social behaviour, crime on the railway, and violence against women and girls, which is a key priority for the Department. In terms of our proposal now, which is driver-controlled operations with a second person on board, there is very much a focus in that second role, the CSA role, around supporting some of those concerns, so visibility and reassurance for customers, and that's part of their job description, very much so, includes that. As an operator, we take other measures as well to try and reduce crime on the railway. We work very closely with the British Transport Police and regularly share intelligence, and work with them very closely.
We also have our own security teams who are on both fixed and mobile as well, to provide extra reassurance and support on that as well, and including that includes mobile officers, where we can deploy based on where we see risk to crime, but also based on feedback from either customers or colleagues as well. So, if we have known hot spot routes, we can deploy those as well to good effect. I think there's a huge challenge around anti-social behaviour and crime on the railways. We actively engage with other government schemes such as safeguarding schemes, and we've invested in equipment and training for our colleagues as well, including body-worn video is available to all front-line colleagues, in terms of train managers and station colleagues. So, yeah, there's a whole suite.
There's no, I don't think, silver bullet for this, but certainly, our proposal gives the reassurance, that visibility for colleague for customers who'll be using the new East West Rail services between Oxford and Milton Keynes.
Oli.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Chair. Jodie, again, what is the Department's policy on driver only operation, or its position?
Jodie Lofthouse
That is a ministerial judgment, I don't think that has been sort of publicly stated.
Jodie Lofthouse
Well, generally, I actually don't have that information, so I can bring that back to you, but I think, as was mentioned before, East West Rail specifically in its infrastructure was specified against being able to be operated under driver only operation, and that's what it's ready for in this service.
Daniel Francis
Thanks, Chair. I'll start with Tony. So, Chiltern Railways transferred into public ownership in September '26. So, do you believe that improves the prospects for the resolution of the dispute?
Tony Baxter
I'm not sure it materially changes the challenge that we have at the moment. As Eddie says, industrial relations is very good with ASLEF and RMT and Chiltern, so this is quite unusual and the difficult position we find ourselves in. Even before we came into public ownership, we would liaise regularly with the Department for Transport. Clearly, any final settlement we come to and an agreement has to go through appropriate approvals as well. So, because we were operating on the national rail contract before, there's not a huge difference.
Our relationships with the department are very good and are very supportive of the approach we take as well. So, I think it's very supportive, but it was supportive before the 20th as well.
Jodie Lofthouse
No, I would just re-emphasize really working closely together and fully aligned, wanting to get on with it.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Dave, you've not spoken a lot.
I just wondered if you had any distinct perspective on these issues.
Dave Calfe
I think certainly from ASLEF's point of view, if you were to design and implement a new railway, you wouldn't do it like this. I mean the use of East West Rail I don't think has been beneficial to setting up this railway. We've opened a new line between Newcastle and Ashington in the same time period that's up and fully running, conventionally crewed trains and serving the people in the North East, Northumberland. This has been bordering on dysfunctional, I think, for trying to run a railway. Discussions between individual parties, when our reps have tried to get engaged with it in aside from the train operation, it's been a slightly confused situation, I think, at best.
So I hope we don't use this as a template going forward certainly for new railway lines. Aside of as well other issues as we see is design issues with the line not being electrified as a new railway in 2026, how that was never considered and should have been part of the design process for a new build is beyond us to be honest when we're looking towards a green agenda. So, but we are in a situation as a trade union that we are in the laps of others around us, because we're not in that position yet to go forward and have the further discussions. But we do want to see the railway up and running, but we want to see it up and running in the right way. As a there's a lot of investment gone into East West Rail.
And again, we similar to a lot of things that happen on the railway in this country from infrastructure point of view, we don't seem to do it on the same cost basis as we do elsewhere in Europe. You know, so there's a whole host of things I think around East West Rail, and hopefully that gives a bit of a flavor where ASLEF is, I think, with
Most definitely.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Yeah, okay. And just while you have the floor, as it were, on the dispute or you've not come out in support, sorry, you have come out in support of the RMT's stance on DOO, but you've not launched a formal dispute with Chiltern. Why is that?
Dave Calfe
'Cause we allow the discussions within the company and the other grade groups to come to an end and reach agreement before we have our discussions as as as as as as as train drivers, as ASLEF. It's a protocol that we adopt in all the companies in which we negotiate.
Not on that, chair, I think we're all right.
Daniel Francis
I can come on to the second part, yeah. I'll carry on with Dave whilst he's got the floor. So the government said that handing operations into public ownership and creating GBR will lead to a more joined-up railway. So what lessons do you think should be learned by GBR from this dispute when introducing new services and negotiating workforce arrangements?
Dave Calfe
Yeah, don't use a third party to do it directly through a train operator. I mean one of the things that hasn't been mentioned so far today is initially the driver's depot was at Banbury. It was then closed at Banbury, well Banbury depot is still there, but the drivers allotted to this work were moved then or the those driver positions were moved, as as as as as has been said, to Bletchley. And you would have thought that from an operational point of view, if the work was going to be at Bletchley, you'd put it in the existing depot at Bletchley that gives you that cross-cover and probably gives you efficiencies to the industry, rather than setting things up in different silos. So I hope GBR going forward will see a bigger picture, that will have a more broad look across not just small elements of new rail services, but actually look at it in the whole and use the existing depots, the existing regimes they've got, rather than try and set up new separate niche areas.
Eddie Dempsey
Yeah, we're hopeful under GBR, having that strategic overview that's been lacking in the industry for quite a long time, moving towards a single employer and having an integrated collective bargaining framework, should allow us to deal with issues of strategic importance like this sooner, quicker, before they become problems. I think those are the lessons for us for GBR.
Jodie Lofthouse
Yeah, so I acknowledge that we should have had our operator on board earlier in this program. And there's at least three core lessons that we've taken forward, learnt from this first phase, as the first phase of the wider program, so there'll be a number of further phases in delivering East West Rail as a major rail project. Those three core lessons: one is about carrying out that full systems thinking right at the early on with all of your delivery partners around the table, and that's been embedded, and we'll probably hear a bit more about this in the second panel, this has been embedded in the way that East West Rail company are designing and taking forward the railway; needing to bring the operator on board earlier,
and so we started working with Chiltern in '23, and they were appointed in 2025, but, you know, that means that you don't have to revisit decisions that you've made earlier on or change any have any late changes in the design; and then the need for a really strong delivery integration function, making sure all of the parts come together in the plans and the schedule, and, again, that's been addressed by East West Rail company in the way that they've set up, and of and in the role that they are taking forward as the single purpose delivery vehicle and integrator of the project.
Tony, anything you want to add?
Tony Baxter
No, I think I'd echo what colleagues to my right said, really, obviously, early operator involvement is really helpful. We've talked a lot today about method of operation, but also sometimes things that more mundane things as well, certain things like station fit-outs and things like that, which aren't big sort of things in their own right, but where by coming late to the party, just builds a little bit more sluggishness and delay into it. So, I think, you know, across the piece, early involvement from operators is really good learning point.
Thank you.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Okay, thank you. Right. Last couple of questions in this panel. Alex.
Speaker 23
Thank you, Chair. Tony, you've already mentioned some of this already, but beyond this dispute, do you foresee any further obstacles in getting passenger services up and running on this section of the route sooner rather than later?
Tony Baxter
So, I think we know the what needs to happen. Obviously, resolution of the dispute then that allows us to have the conversation with ASLEF. We've finalised training agreements and things once we know what exactly what that final bit looks like. So, we foresee, you know, a fairly positive outlook in terms of the things in front of us now aren't huge obstacles. It's completion of training, it's some recruitment, still needs just to finish off things like CSR recruitment,
and then there's some final validations and ORR approval. So, there's nothing insurmountable. There's a lot of quite still quite a few moving parts with other partners to do as well, but we, you know, we are really positive once we've got that agreement. Obviously, not a position yet to announce when that date may be, but I'm sure the minister will want to do that, but I think we're all aligned in what needs to be done.
Speaker 23
Do you have a sense of how long it would take roughly after an agreement was made?
Tony Baxter
It's really hard to commit on that today because not all of it is within Chiltern's control. I think everyone collectively, and I say this for, you know, everyone you'll see today is really keen to get these up and running. You know, we recognize the impact this is having on communities and the expectation people have of passenger services took on. So, I think everyone's focused on that, and when there's a date we can all align to, you know, I'm sure the minister will announce it.
Speaker 23
And is there any work that can be done while we await that to deal with any of the- I appreciate that you need to have an answer on exactly how the train is going to be staffed.
However, there can't be that many different permutations of it. So, are you working so you can speed through it once we've got an answer?
Tony Baxter
Yes, we have been very sort of focused around delivering every bit of driver training in particular, which is often for any new piece of railway transformation, the ability to staff with drivers and have the right skills. So, we are well advanced in the driver training elements we can do before agreeing method of operation. So, the new drivers who we recruited are all now qualified drivers, which takes about 18 months. They are learning the routes, as they have to learn the sort of the specific geography. They're doing that,
and they're learning how to drive the 196 trains we've acquired as well, because that wasn't the trains they're actually trained on originally. So, we're not waiting for all those training pieces. What we're waiting for is once we've got agreement, we then do the final piece of training once we've got everything in place. So, we're not we're not waiting for to start work on driver training once we've got an agreement. We're well down that road.
Jodie Lofthouse
No, I'm really confident that Chiltern have been progressing everything they possibly can to make sure they minimise the amount of time and the number of activities required following the agreement.
Dave?
Speaker 44
Outside of an agreed method of operation, probably not, no, as far as we're aware.
Eddie?
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Right, and Olly, you've got the last question or questions, however many.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Yeah, so I just wanted to just ask you just something about the previous one very briefly. So, only you mentioned it, Mr Dempsey, but in some of the ministerial statements about this, Winslow station was cited as a factor for not opening the line. What's the status of that as an issue? Don't know who'd like to answer that.
Tony Baxter
I can respond to that. So, I think there were some minor things that were done at Winslow which are that are now being resolved. So, there were some fit-outs which Chiltern requested as well, but fairly minor stuff in terms of staff toilets and things like that. There was a more technical lease issue, which my colleague this afternoon can expand on if need be from Network Rail, or later this morning, rather. That has now been resolved.
So, the interim leases are now sitting for final signatures, I think, touch wood, this week. So, we're pretty much there on Winslow.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Would you agree it's a bit of a strange reason to cite for the line not opening? I mean, Dave Calfe, you mentioned the Northumberland line, where that opened with some of the stations opened, but the others still construction sites. And that their stations that weren't yet finished weren't cited as a reason for not starting passenger services, particularly on a line that is being used for both freight and charters. Do you think that was a bit strange to cite that reason? Maybe it's more a question for Jodie.
Jodie Lofthouse
Yeah, I think the reasons that were cited were the things that needed to be completed to make sure that we could give the passengers the experience and the performance that we intend to. And not having Winslow station fully finished was part of that reason.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I mean, trains could have just run through it whilst that was being done is the point I was perhaps making, but maybe we've done that. Right, last question, then. So, I'd just like to just go in sequence for all of you and say and ask you what actions that you'll be taking, including engagement with other parties that are here, to bring this dispute to an end and open passenger services on the line? And can you give your prediction for when that will happen? Because we've just had a night of predictions in the US midterms, and they were very inaccurate, and maybe yours can be better.
Who'd like to start first? Thank you.
Dave Calfe
I'll go. Look, as far as we're concerned, as soon as the discussions are concluded between Chiltern and our RMT colleagues, we'll be sitting down to have that similar discussions on behalf of the drivers. What the time frame is around that, I don't know, because I've not been involved in the other discussions. But we've always participate fully and engage. Come to the table, we negotiate, and we'll do the same do the same with Chiltern.
Tony Baxter
I think for us, I think it's the energy into the negotiation and discussion. I think we're having positive discussions.
I think everyone wants a resolution. This is not a dispute where, you know, people don't want a quick resolution, so I think it's to make sure we've got the management focus, we'll keep liaising with the department as well to remain in lockstep there so we can speed through any sort of final sort of ratifications, etcetera, which as ever are needed at the end, but we'll have full focus and energy to get a resolution.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Any thoughts on time scales, even if it just weeks, months, or years?
Tony Baxter
Tough to put, certainly won't be years, I hope, but I think, you know, we are committed. It's we talked last week, we will have more conversations over the coming days and weeks, so, you know, we're keen to do it as soon as we can.
Jodie Lofthouse
The department will continue working with Chiltern really closely to support them in the negotiations with the objective of getting these services up and running as quickly as possible, and, in my role, I will continue to advise the minister based on their proposals.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
The department often likes giving timescales by seasons, so do you have a season, perhaps?
Jodie Lofthouse
It's not for me to give a given entry into service date. The minister you're seeing, I think, in December, actually, you can probably ask that question again.
Eddie, your thoughts?
Eddie Dempsey
Well, we're hopeful. We've got ongoing discussions. We're prepared to engage with those and try to find a resolution as quickly as we can. Our view is if common sense prevails, we could get this wrapped up in weeks.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
All right, thank you. That brings our first panel to an end. It was quite illuminating. I'd like to thank you all for your evidence and the time you spent preparing for today, and if there's anything you feel you'd like to elaborate on, please do email us, and I'd like to suspend the meeting for a few minutes while our next witnesses take place. The sitting is suspended.
Order. Welcome to our second panel which is covering the wider issues of accountability, delivery, and governance on East West Rail. So, welcome to our second panel. Could I ask you each to introduce yourselves, starting off with Ben?
Ben Rule
Hello, I'm Ben Rule. I am the railway operations director in East West Railway Company.
Jodie Lofthouse
Jodie Lofthouse, programme director East West Rail in DfT and SRO for the first phase of delivery.
Rosemary Hopkins
Rosemary Hopkins, interim director of East West Rail at DfT and senior responsible owner for phases two to five of the scheme.
Speaker 47
Good morning. Christian Irwin, I am the capital delivery director for Network Rail.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Welcome. So in the previous panel, we heard about the ongoing dispute which has resulted in no passenger services running on the first stage of East West Rail for since the line opened 744 days ago. So, what impact has the dispute had on the delivery timetable, the costs, and the planning assumptions for subsequent phases of East West Rail of the East West Rail project? And I'm just realising you probably don't all need to answer all of the questions, given you're from similar organisations. So who wants to kick off on that?
David Hughes
I think that's probably one for me, Chair. The material impact of the delay in passenger services on the first phase actually is probably limited in terms of our planning of future phases. I don't underestimate the reputational damage that the delay has had for East West Rail as a programme. But in terms of actual material consequences on cost and schedule for future phases, there isn't any, really. The key thing for us is learning lessons from all of those discussions you've just been having in the first stage of this panel.
Speaker 53
What How do we do things differently to ensure that we're not in this situation again when we get to opening up the future phases of the railway?
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Right, and also did it impact has it is it impacting on expected revenues?
David Hughes
Well, clearly now, yes. Clearly, there is. Yeah, that's a matter for Chiltern and the department in terms of the loss of the revenue today, in terms of the the the the the the overall delivery cost of the programme, it doesn't have an impact. The big impact for us as East West Rail, East West Rail Ltd, responsible for delivering the programme is the reputational damage it has, which is significant. And also, I think very important not to lose sight of the real-life impact that this has on communities along the line of route. I have a lot of people in my team.
you know, we've recruited a lot of people in recent years. A lot of them have, you know, moved into the area, bought houses in places like Winslow expecting to be able to travel to work by train and they can't. So.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Sorry, I realize Chiltern's not here, but do you have a figure for the revenue lost? Yeah, ob- obviously.
No, it's not Chiltern, no.
Jodie Lofthouse
So potentially I can come back on and send to you something in writing around the revenue loss. I think what I would like to just say is that we've been very cost sorry, cost-conscious on this development of this railway and the delivery of the railway. I think when our Secretary of State came to Select Committee back in June of this year, she talked about bearing down on the costs and recognizing that we weren't, you know, it wasn't driving revenue at the moment. What I would like to say is, you know, being cost-conscious, we have delivered the infrastructure for this part of the railway both on time and under budget. And the overarching fund envelope that first phase, which is 1.2 billion, I'm continuing to drive that delivery, you know, within that funding estimate.
So this isn't a case of creating significant additional costs for the taxpayer. In actual fact, we are looking at continuing to minimize those and bring this part of the railway in under budget where possible.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Okay. All right, so and those have not answered the first question. Has this dispute had impact on either the delivery timetable, the infrastructure costs and the planning assumptions for the subsequent phases of the project?
Jodie Lofthouse
I think just coming in on this, going back to the lessons learned, I actually think I would say it has had a positive impact on the planning that we're making and the lessons that we've learned and actually how we're setting the project up for success. So the whole point about, you know, learning from this first phase is that you can enhance the delivery of the future phases and that's one of the reasons why you split up these major projects so that you can, you know, roll over that learning and make sure that you're addressing it in the future phases. So I would expect all of the things that we've experienced on this first phase to be addressed in how we're setting the company and the program up for those future phases.
Christian Irwin
So as Jodie made reference to, we delivered the infrastructure on time and ahead of budget, which we're really proud of. Obviously we are equally disappointed that we haven't got passenger services on the railway. We do have a well-established maintenance and operations team that are looking after the railway, keeping it in good condition and we have got regular freight services on the line. We do have charter services on the line and as we speak, we have got a very intense driver training program, which is almost simulating an hourly service on the line. So we are comfortable that we are ready to go and our infrastructure is there and being utilized for the start of service.
Scott Arthur
Oh, quick word here. So thanks for that, Jodie. Hopefully the Secretary of State is bearing down on this dispute as much as she's bearing down on costs. But I guess it's quite disheartening, I don't know how you feel sitting there, the people the other side here saying, "Well, you've done a bit of the job, it's not our fault." Whereas really I think the taxpayer wants all five of you here to be working together to resolve this.
So David, come along. I'm not being critical, David, saying, "Well, I the lost revenues lost. Revenue, that's not my problem, that's someone else's." It's just people, I guess taxpayers want this to be a team effort. Can I ask the lost revenue and the costs of the dispute, and I know you can't say, you can't put a number on it just now, but in terms of the scale, how does it compare to the cost of actually just settling the dispute and giving the trade unions exactly what they want?
Speaker 66
I think they said it would cost £150,000 a year.
Surely the lost revenue must far exceed that. And David's also talked about the impact on communities. That's an That's a wellbeing impact and all the rest of it, but it's also an economic impact. So what's the quantum of that, the impact of the dispute in terms of the impact on communities and also the loss in terms of revenue?
How does that compare, how do those numbers compare?
Jodie Lofthouse
Yeah. And I think this isn't a simple it's a it's a system we're talking about here. There's a wider network, and it's about delivering this part of a wider network. And, you know, consideration of the cost is something that ministers consider, you know, regularly. Um, but it's
Jodie Lofthouse
So I don't have the I don't have numbers in front of me. But, you know, this isn't just about, you know, a cost over here. This is about the operating model that we've based the infrastructure and the plans on. So when you make those changes, it has consequences which would require further consideration and judgment by our ministers, you know. So it's not as simple as just make this happen, and it will work tomorrow.
As a system, it's more complex than that. I can look into what I can give you and provide you with some following information by writing, if that will give you a bit more and help in understanding that.
Scott Arthur
Interesting. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. On the consultation on the project going forward or sorry you the project's moved from a connection stage to a being delivered in phases.
So what does this mean? Connection model sorry, a connection model to be delivered in phases, what's the difference there? And as a somebody who may be wanting to use a network, what differences is that going to make to me?
David Hughes
It's partly a change in terminology, but actually, there's it there's more than that, and it's probably one that's best for Ben to answer.
Ben Rule
Yeah, so, as David said, to some extent, it's just terminology. But what has happened in moving from the connection stages to key outputs is we've done two things. Firstly, we had to react to the fact that the Universal attraction that's going to be built at Stewartby had was proposed. And so we needed to have a plan that dealt with the arrival of that theme park, and we had to adjust what we were doing so that we could provide services in line as far as we can with the arrival of the theme park. So that was the first thing.
Speaker 63
What drove you to do that then, was that you were told you had to do that or you just felt this would be a good thing to do, or you've seen that as an opportunity to raise revenue?
It's a big
Ben Rule
It's a big investment in the country, it's a big investment. The East West Rail route runs right alongside it. It's absolutely the right thing that we do to provide a transport link to that, along with also transport link on Midland Main Line as well. So we had to we had to react to that. The key output approach is partly to do that.
The other thing that the key outputs have done is it's allowed us to make sure that we are delivering benefits to customers as early as possible. So the series of key outputs
Right from the start?
Ben Rule
that is a It's a good question. But what we are doing now is we are making sure that the schedule that we are now working to is delivering as many benefits as early as possible. And so the key output stages that we have deliver four trains an hour to Stewartby station earlier than you would have had under the connection stage approach. It's about bringing forward as many benefits as we can.
David Hughes
It's not it Look, the intent and the original approach of opening this in three phases, we've not it's not revolution what we've done.
We've now, we've just broken it down into slightly more phases. In part, that's learning lessons from previous projects that says, actually, the more that you can break down the delivery of the project and introduce services gradually, the more that de-risks the project. So, there's just a sort of good practice: try and break it down into bite-sized chunks. There was also a very clear steer, clear ask, from government in early 25, when it was clear that Universal was going to go ahead, was: how can you adapt that opening schedule to get a service to the park, as much service into the park as quickly as possible? And alongside that, what else can you do, as part of the overall economic growth agenda, how can you bring forward benefits in Cambridge, in Bedford?
How can you sequence delivery of the railway to ensure that we get as much of the benefit as we can as soon as possible? So, all of those elements came together to drive, not a it's not a massive change to the pri- It was always intended to open it in phases. We've just broken it down into slightly more phases with the intent of bringing forward benefits, and, in particular, as Ben says, of trying to get a service, as much of a service to the park as soon as we can. Because it's huge, right? The park is going to be the UK's biggest tourist attraction, and it's literally 100 meters from one of our stations, so we were going to have to adapt the design of the station to the designer of the railway to cater for that.
Speaker 64
Yeah, I don't want to reopen the debate, but it's interesting that there's a focus on delivering that economic benefit as early as possible. Be interesting to see how changes in your plans, what the benefit of that is compared to the impact of the dispute. You know? So, but let's not reopen that, yeah, OK.
David Hughes
If I may, Dr. Dr. Arthur, the for us, just to sort of close out that, we talked a bit in this session already about learning lessons from the position that we're in on phase one, and no one is happy with the position that we're in on phase one. The key thing for us, for Rosemary, Jodie, myself, Ben, is: how do we make sure, when we get to these future phases, that we're not in the same position? And the two key lessons, I think, that we've taken away are, firstly, about clarity of accountability. You heard some of the witnesses in the previous session referring to the fact that was not as clear as it should have been. So, for the first phase of the railway, Oxford to Bletchley, where we haven't got services running, the accountabilities were split between, and there's a lot of history around that, between what the department was responsible for, what East West Rail was responsible for.
So, for the first phase, East West Rail had a responsibility for the infrastructure, but not the introduction of the services. Going forward, it is absolutely clear now that East West Rail Limited holds accountability for the whole system. So, for the future phases, it's my job, it's Ben's job, to make We don't control everything, we don't have direct control everything, but we are the conductor of the orchestra. Our job is to make sure that, when we get to these future phases, we haven't just delivered the infrastructure, important though that is, we have all those other elements that are necessary to bring passenger services into operation, that they are all in place as well. So, that's the first lesson: clarity of accountability.
The second, and again, there was reference to this in the previous session, is getting ahead of the issues early. So, that's why one of the first things I did when I came in as chief exec just over two years ago was bring Ben in, someone with a huge amount of rail operations experience, so that the sort of issues that have delayed us now on the first phase, we're starting to tackle them now, several years in advance. You heard the union reps saying, you know, we didn't get into consultation on these issues until relatively late in the day. You need to be One of the big lessons from big rail projects is it's there's a risk of focusing on the infrastructure in the early days. You need to focus on the whole system from the get-go, and that's what we're trying to do to ensure that there is no repeat of where we are now when we come to open up future phases of the railway.
Speaker 65
Good.
So last question for now. In this place, I have to keep reminding myself that the world doesn't end at Oxford and Cambridge. Is there scope for the line to go beyond Oxford and Cambridge at some point?
Speaker 60
Is there scope for that? Is that a possibility? Is there a business case there?
David Hughes
I can't answer the question on business cases certainly, and Ben might want to comment. There's nothing to preclude running services beyond Oxford and Cambridge.
This is This will be part of the integrated rail network. By the time it's delivered, GBR will be fully up and running. GBR will be that single controlling mind. It's not a self-contained railway that can only run from Oxford to Cambridge.
You could run from Penzance to Ipswich if you chose, but that's an operational choice that would be made by GBR as it plans the overall network. So, there's nothing we're doing that precludes running services beyond, but, Ben, did you want to come in?
Ben Rule
No, absolutely, it's part of the network, it's connected in many places with the wider network. In terms of freight, for example, freight will use East West Rail to connect ports and depots across the network, so that's already happening. We are speaking with the operators that operate at either end of the line as well. We have good conversations with Greater Anglia, with GWR, about the opportunities that there might be to run longer-distance services. It's entirely possible with the network.
Scott Arthur
In your consultation in 2026, you said there will be up to one freight train per hour between Oxford and Bletchley. Up to one train, what is that, up to one train? Is that a guarantee that one train could run, or does it mean possibly one train could run?
Ben Rule
So, the network's designed with sufficient capacity to be able to run the passenger trains that we are instructed to provide for, and there is some additional capacity built into it to allow for freight traffic as well.
Scott Arthur
If my wife says to me we're going to have to up to one holiday this year, I would read that might be no holidays, so. So.
Ben Rule
So, there is capacity on the network to be able to run an hourly freight service.
So that is there, yeah, okay.
Ben Rule
That is there. It doesn't always mean that you will have a freight train in every hour, because it depends partly on demand. The other thing to say,
Speaker 73
All right, so that those one that average of one per hour is over a day, so those trains just could be overnight.
Ben Rule
The Well, we will provide the capacity, actually for freight companies, they can then choose whether they would like to use that, depending on the demand that they're trying to meet, the contracts that they have, et cetera. So, but the capacity is there. It's also worth saying that whilst we're providing capacity for one freight train an hour along the line of route, there are other investments that would be required elsewhere on the network really to make that something that the freight companies would definitely want to take up.
Ely-Holy.
For example, yes, good example.
Scott Arthur
So, it's one per hour between Oxford and Bletchley, one every two hours between Bletchley and Bedford, and around two freight trains each direction east of Bedford. Is this a strategy, or is this just really—
Speaker 68
I mean, is there a strategy here for freight? Does this all make sense, those numbers?
That's Yeah.
Ben Rule
So, there is a strategy. I think the reason why perhaps the wording is as you've described it is because the railway that we will upgrade and build has capacity for an hourly service along the line of route. Whether that is taken up or not does depend on some of these other investments, and I think some of the wording that you've read out there reflects the expected demand without that further investment, but we are providing capacity for a freight train every hour along the line of route.
David Hughes
So if I may, chair, just to build on the strategy is driven partly by constraints on existing network, but largely by what are the demand flows. So, providing capacity for a train an hour on that section between Oxford and Bletchley, we can do that. We have done that already, but it also reflects the demand flow, which is if you think about the geography of the country, it's actually Southampton coming through up to Oxford using that line from Oxford to Bletchley to join the West Coast Main Line and then head north to the West Midlands into Trafford. That's the flow. The logical flow freight flow from the other side of the country would be from the east coast ports, Felixstowe in particular, coming through Cambridge, joining our infrastructure and then, if you like, turning right onto the West Coast Main Line at Milton Keynes. The two problems there, these are the constraints that Ben talks about, is there are bottlenecks before you get to Cambridge that would have to be the industry would have to invest significant amounts of money to invest in the bottlenecks there.
And then, there is, if you like, there is no right turn from our infrastructure onto the West Coast Main Line to head north at Bletchley. That would also be a very significant piece of infrastructure work. So, I completely take that if you look at the numbers cold, it doesn't make a lot of sense, but it reflects both the demand flows and the underlying capacity that there is in the network.
Speaker 75
So you don't you don't want to be a constraint in the future, basically.
David Hughes
No, so if those constraints were unlocked in future, you would be relatively easy to make sure that the East West Rail infrastructure could accommodate that increase in freight.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
While we've got a freight target increase, the Secretary of State confirmed to me in Orals last week that there is not going to be a specific freight strategy. It's going to be incorporated into the rail investment strategy. So, do we have any timescale for that?
Rosemary Hopkins
Yeah, on the freight strategy, I'm not sure, actually, so it's probably one we need to take away and check out and come back to you on. Well, no, as you say, there isn't going to be a specific
freight strategy, and
is what she confirmed to me last week.
Rosemary Hopkins
and it will be rolled into the wider strategy for rail investment. I this is work we're undertaking along alongside preparing for the stand up of GBR. And in readiness for the stand up of GBR, we need to have that vision and prioritization in place.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
I mean, am I right in saying that's about investment in hardware, whereas that last set of questions focused on things like train paths in among passengers and so on, infrastructure off logistics infrastructure just beside the line and that sort of thing, which is why a freight strategy, would I be right in saying a freight strategy is somewhat different to in rail investment strategy? Maybe I'm missing something.
Rosemary Hopkins
I think as a whole, you know, one of the great advantages of standing up GBR is actually to be able to think about the system, to be able to think about the policy intent, the ambition that we have for delivering outcomes for passengers and for freight, and the infrastructure, the services, the operations, and, you know, the depots and the rolling stock that we need to be able to support those outcomes. You know, we're building the bits of the jigsaw together, and I feel really confident that we'll get there, but the team that's here today are particularly the team that are leading on a piece of the infrastructure within that wider system.
Speaker 76
And as you say, it's much easier in the context of the GBR, so thank you. Ollie.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Chair. East West Rail's been a bit of a journey in terms of the delivery timescales it's been working to. So in 2019, the aspiration was to do Oxford to Milton Keynes by 2024, which we've discussed in some detail; some limited service using the existing infrastructure, Oxford to Bedford 2025; and the whole thing to Cambridge in 2028. I think now East West Rail is saying mid to late 2030s for the Cambridge bit.
I must admit, I'm not quite clear what the current Bedford Bletchley thing is, maybe you can tell me. How confident are you that the current key time scales that you're working to are now deliverable on schedule and won't slip further?
David Hughes
I'd say that at this those original timescales, yeah, they whether they were ever plausible, I question. The reality we're in at the moment is if everything goes to plan,
the earliest that we would get the powers, that we would get our development consent order, is late 2028, early 2029. So, for the bulk of the work that we have to deliver, we can't actually get started until late 2029. So whatever the history before, the reality we're in and that takes you into a whole debate about how long it takes to get planning consent for big infrastructure, which is a probably a different committee to look at that. So the reality we're in at the moment is the earliest that we're going to start our main works, get really get going on the bulk of the project, will be sometime in 2029, 2030. At this stage, we are still at a relatively high level of design as we head into the DCO.
One of the things that we have to do between over the course of the next 12 months, to inform government's decisions about the project, about whether government wants to commit to the funding of this project, one of the things me and my team need to do over the next year is develop our a very clearer understanding of what the likely cost envelope and delivery schedule is. So, at the moment, our best estimate is that we will complete the project in mid to late 2030s. That's where we are at the moment. But I would say, as with cost envelope and schedule, we I don't want to overstate It would be wrong of me to say, "Yes, I'm absolutely confident," because we're just too early in the process for that.
That's our best understanding of where we are, that's the timescales we're trying to meet. But what I'm not going to do, as we work through the detail of what the cost and schedule will look like and present that to government when we get to OBC next year, my job is to give the most accurate view of what we think that will be. I mean, that is clearly one of the key lessons from HS2 and other projects. At this stage, don't succumb to optimism bias.
Don't try and meet artificial deadlines or artificial cost envelopes. We will spend the time between now and DCO submission, which we plan to do this time next year, really bottoming out what we think the cost envelope and schedule ranges are for this project. At the moment, our best estimate is it's mid to late 2030s.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Yeah, I mean I understand your point about looking to the future and not dwelling in the past, but those time scales I mentioned that is something that East West Rail did a very extensive non-statutory consultation about in 2019 and 2020. So I think that's partly why I'm asking and lots of other people are asking, is to what's going to be different this time? But you've given your view on that. Okay, and I was also going to ask you if you could say which stage each section of the project has reached. So, you've mentioned DCO submission this time next year.
Is business case approval ready to move to that phase in terms of FBC or OBC?
David Hughes
So we present our OBC to the department I'll use a season, summer, actually, we're thinking around June, July. So the plan
David Hughes
Right. Hard on the season. We're aiming to be Round about June or July of next year, we will be presenting to Government our OBC, our outline business case, and our draft DCO submission. And that's really a key decision point for the Government. We've We use the jargon, it's a review point 2.
We went through a review point 12 months ago. Review point 2 in round about June, July next year, two big decisions for Government is the OBC that we'll present, and we're going to be in front of Government saying, "We think we're good to go with our DCO submission, and we're planning our plan is to be able to submit that round about this time next year."
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Okay, and forgive my ignorance, and what at what point does FBC happen? Is that—
David Hughes
That would happen after the DCO award, and so we're planning that would be in sort of late 2028.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
And just a final question for you, Mr Hughes, I read a book over the summer where you were quoted. Sir Jonathan Simcock's The Delivery Gap. And you said to him, in relation to your time as chair of the Crossrail sponsor board, quote, "I put my hand up to the failure of the assurance. I need to say that upfront, I'm on the list of the guilty." So, you've said a little bit about what you think can be learned from previous projects.
What else would you say you'd take from that time, and maybe HS2, as to how East West Rail is going to be different, and how we can learn positively from those projects?
David Hughes
Oh, God, I mean I could talk for hours about that. I would be So, I think relevant to where we are as a project now, I think the key lesson that my team hear me banging on about all the time is getting making the right judgement about that cost envelope and schedule. And it's something that I talk with Mark Wild, chief exec at HS2, a lot, and he and I worked on Crossrail together. We want to We want to set an ambitious cost envelope and an ambitious schedule. We want to drive the project hard so we get the most efficient delivery and we can realise benefits as quickly as possible, but at the same time, we have to guard against over-optimism, which so many projects have fallen prey to.
What I do not want to be guilty of is coming to Government next year with too rosy a picture on cost and schedule to secure the funding. You know, what we need to do, and this is a lesson from HS2, is flush out now our best possible view of that cost and schedule to inform the Government's decision about whether it wants to commit to this scheme. Flush that out now, not after the event, not after you've let your main works contracts. Flush out now your best possible judgement of that cost and schedule range.
Speaker 82
Thank you, Chair. We've had consultations in 2019, 2021, 2024, and 2026. Is that it?
David Hughes
We will not We're not planning on any further route-wide consultations. That is it. What I would like to say is the fact that we're not having any further route-wide consultations does not mean it's the end of engagement with communities and stakeholders along the line of route.
Speaker 23
So, you So, and for anyone who wants to answer because Christian was nodding away, so, the next time that the public will be participating is examining that application for the DCO?
David Hughes
In a route-wide sense, yes. I mean, we're in Buckinghamshire this morning, we were in Bedfordshire last night, we're in Lidlington tomorrow. So, actually, one of the I think one of the is quite an important point for us, actually. So, the Chancellor made the point, I think, in a speech about, you know, the fact that we had four consultations. I think, look, if we'd the Planning and Infrastructure Act has changed that process.
If the Planning and Infrastructure Act had been on the statute book several years ago, our whole approach to this would have been different. By the time the Planning and Infrastructure Act came onto the statute book last December, and it does make some significant changes to the pre-application process for the DCO, we'd already done three route-wide consultations, and we were just gearing up to go out with our fourth. So, the Planning and Infrastructure Act will change how this is done in the future. I would two points: I think the consultations that we've done have been hugely valuable in refining our design.
You know, the feedback we get from the public has made has resulted in some quite significant changes to our design. That would be the first point. And the second, I do think it's really important that, because I think there's a danger that people think the Planning and Infrastructure Act changes mean we're not going to consult anymore, or when I answer your question saying we've not got any more planned consultations, is that we're not talking to the public. Where actually I actually think what the Planning and Infrastructure Act enables is for us to have much better and much more iterative engagement, like we're having this week, with communities on the issues that matter to them. The thing about the route-wide consultations is they are big set-piece events, and they put, before you even get out of the door, they put six months on the programme.
Doing a three-month route-wide consultation puts six to nine months into your programme. So, I think the big win from the Planning and Infrastructure Act going forward is it enables you to engage in a much more iterative way with communities on the things that matter to them. So, for example, Bicester, you know, it's not true to say the only thing they want to talk about in Bicester, but the main thing they want to talk about in Bicester is what we're doing with our level crossing. They're not really interested in what we're doing in Cambridge East, they don't, you know.
Speaker 87
So, moving away from these route-wide consultations opens up the opportunity for us to engage, I think in a much better way, and at the same time speed up the process. So, there are still some decisions to be made. For example, you mentioned Cambridge East then. Is there any possibility that you will feel the need to consult again, specifically, for example, in Cambridge East, ahead of the DCO?
David Hughes
We're not we're not we don't have plans to do so at the moment. I think it's I think it's not I think I'm right in saying it's not unusual in a DCO process to have targeted consultations if there are changes emerge. We've got another year to go before we submit the DCO application. We're not anticipating significant changes to the scope of the scheme at this stage. We're certainly not anticipating running any route-wide consultations.
It is possible that we need to do some targeted engagement if there were to be any significant changes at a local level in the route design. But we're that's not that might happen, but that's not part of our plan.
Speaker 23
And then, you mentioned that, had the legislation been on in place earlier, it would have changed the way you did potentially those first four consultations. Are there any changes that you're making going forward because that legislation now is in place?
David Hughes
The Planning and Infrastructure Act, the biggest impact of it is on that pre-application process. So, it has enabled us to move more, believe it or not, it has actually enabled us it will enable us to get to the point of DCO submission this time next year more quickly than would otherwise have been the case. It has limited impact on what happens then when you get into the examination stage. And I know that's something that government more broadly is now looking at, because I think it comes back to Mr Glover's point really, about, you know, if you step back from it, East West Rail was initiated in 2017,
and the earliest we're going to have spades in the ground is 2029-2030.
That's 12-13 years. And there's all sorts of reasons for that, but it's not untypical. Lower Thames Crossing sort of similar time scale. So it's part of that much bigger debate, I think, isn't it, about how long it takes to get major infrastructure spades in the ground. So we're part of that debate.
The Planning and Infrastructure Act has definitely helped. The benefit from it we've mainly captured already in the pre-application phase. It doesn't actually change the bar very much in terms of what we have to demonstrate in the examination itself.
Jodie Lofthouse
The only thing I would just add to that is, on this project, we've been engaged on the planning infrastructure app and the opportunities that are afforded very early on. And we've worked really closely and set up some governance across Whitehall to make sure that we're taking on board the, you know, utilizing those opportunities wherever possible, and David's talked about a number of those. There's always more to do and more to consider, and bringing, you know, utilizing those opportunities for East West Rail also gives us the opportunity to identify and demonstrate other opportunities we can draw out of that, and leave more of a legacy from this project to support the other major projects that are coming up behind us.
Speaker 83
Thank you, Chair. Mr. Irwin, how has the East West Rail project affected the delivery of Network Rail projects across the region?
Christian Irwin
Well, the East West Rail project was set up by ourselves in 2015, under an alliance with some brilliant delivery partners. So we've had a standalone alliance team in existence for nearly 11 years, and they have worked in full collaboration with East West Rail Company, with our operators, with the Department for Transport, but also on discharging the Transport and Works Act Order and engaging with communities through the delivery of the programme. Given we've had a standalone alliance to deliver this, we have had a very lean team to manage this alliance. We have equivalent of 10 full-time equivalent staff managing the alliance right now, so it's a very cost effective way for us to deliver our infrastructure projects. Th- this project itself, whilst we are, you know, with all our colleagues, very disappointed we haven't got passenger services running like right now, if you look at how this was delivered using a modern form of NEC contract, using the government construction playbook, and the way that we collaborate, build target costs, we have, during the life of the alliance, been able to, through the design stage, reduce the costs by nearly £300 million.
We have, through the delivery stage, excuse me, save saved £60 million, and we've handed that back to the Department for reinvestment back in future stages of of of of of East West Rail. And we've also been able to offset during the construction period, which was, you know, very challenging through COVID-19, we started our construction phase as at the back end of, you know, 2019 into 2020, we managed to offset nearly £300 million worth of headwinds that kind of impact the project. So, from a delivery front, we are really proud about what we've been able to learn through the life of this project. And if you look at our future investment projects that were delivering across certainly our big programmes like the Midlands Rail Hub, the West Coast Mainline modernisation, TransPennine route upgrade, there are phenomenal amount of good lessons that we are I'd undertaking, but also bringing into the future delivery. The one big lesson for us, collectively as an industry is, and you made the point earlier, is that we need to act and operate as an industry.
It can't be that one part of the industry delivers its bit, and the other parts of the industry don't. We are a railway, and we need to deliver outcomes. And the journey the rail investments been on over the course of the last 10 year, has been that shift from being infrastructure focused to being very much outcome focused.
The reality is delivering the East West Rail Line will deliver phenomenal transportation outcomes. Let's not forget the outcomes go far beyond transportation: connectivity, access to jobs, employment, education, gross domestic product growth. That is what we need to focus on, and that's why it's so important that the lessons that we're taking forward, a fully integrated team under David's stewardship, with Network Rail, operators, and East West Rail Company, the DfT all aligned on the outcome. That is the lesson we're taking going forward.
Scott Arthur
So, Christian, of course, the 10 FTE lean team would sound a lot better if the project was running better, wouldn't it? Yeah. So, but you talked about how you've learned valuable lessons from the project. So do you think the problems the project has been beset with were inevitable then, or do you think if Network Rail had been delivering it, perhaps some of these things, at least some of these things wouldn't have happened?
Christian Irwin
Well, let's let I'll just replay the point I just said: we as an industry are accountable. Yeah, we work in partnership with now the partners over in East West Rail Company. We are a an arm's-length body of the Department for Transport. The reality, the lesson for this is that whilst we were brilliant at specifying the infrastructure, great, we could crack on and build that, we know how to do that, what we got wrong at the start of this programme was we didn't specify the operation, the end outcome, how the rail system was going to come together. The railway system is very complicated.
It's not just about kind of the hard infrastructure, you know the soft infrastructure about how operations maintenance, but you heard it this morning, you know how we operate the trains, how we dispatch, how we make sure the passengers get where they need to go.
Speaker 65
You are saying that these problems would have happened if Network Rail had delivered the project?
Christian Irwin
I think, as I said, the journey that the industry has been on over the last five, 10 years has been flipping our investment approach from infrastructure very much into outcomes. And you know we've learned those lessons on Network Rail self-delivered projects, as well as projects delivered by other people. I think the reality is it's a it's a learning approach. We're very much focused on the end user, the end outcome, the passenger. Our investment projects were very much focused on the infrastructure side previously, and that's a huge lesson we're taking going forward across all our rail investment schemes.
David Hughes
If I Well, I just I think it comes back to that key lesson from the first phase is And it's absolutely the heart of the thinking behind GBR, and it's at the heart of the thinking about how we set up for future delivery of future delivery of future phases of East West Rail is don't think about the railway in a fragmented way, infrastructure, trains, rolling stock, people. It's a whole system. You have to manage it as a whole system. And it doesn't really matter who was in charge in previous phases, the structure was fragmented. GBR, the whole thinking behind GBR is to try and put that right, and I think it will.
And in the meantime, in terms of how we're planning for future phases of East West Rail, we're putting it right by making sure the accountability was is with us. I know Ben
Speaker 84
You're so You're so on message, David, I like this. You're so on message.
David Hughes
Well, it's because I believe it. I mean, honestly, I it's not being on message. I Just look, my background is rail delivery in London Underground, which is a vertically integrated rail system, and I've always looked at the nation For me, GBR is blindingly obvious. How can you run the railway in any other way than as a whole system? So, I don't, Ben, if you want
Ben Rule
Yeah. So, I agree what with what's been said. A lot of projects that have failed to deliver their benefits in the future in at the end of the project are because they have not had alignment between a number of things that need to be perfectly aligned at the end of the programme. You need to have infrastructure that matches the rolling stock, that matches the competence and the training of the staff that you've recruited, that match the authorisation you get from the regulator and a number of other things.
When any of those things are out of line with the others, you end up failing to deliver your benefits. Now, I think one of the mistakes that we have repeatedly made is that some of those things which are about operating the railway rather than building the infrastructure are seen as things that you can consider towards the end of the process. And they are not. You have to be thinking about them earlier. Now, I think what has made that worse is that we have during the period that the railway has been privatised, we've tended to equate the word operations with the appointment of a train operator through its franchise.
And actually operating a railway is not just about appointment of a train operator through a franchise. It's about speaking to operators that know how this railway's going to be built and making sure that their voice is heard early enough in the process that people can take it into account. Now, my job, since I arrived about 15 months or so ago, is to make absolutely certain that collective voice of operators is being heard in the program early enough that the issues can be identified and people can make choices about how to avoid problems as we go forward. So, I have got together the various train operators that are involved in this. There are a number of them because it's not just Chiltern, it's Great Western, it's West Midlands, it's Greater Anglia, it's GTR.
We're speaking to them already. We get them together. We talk to their rail operating people as well, so that we have a common plan and we can flag to the project where there are things that need to be considered early. That, I think, is what will make it more likely that the key outputs that you were talking about earlier on are delivered successfully in the end.
Ben Rule
So, we are talking to the train operators, talking to Network Rail. They obviously have the relationship with the trade unions because they are the people that employ the people that work there. But absolutely, we want to make sure we're taking all issues into account.
Daniel.
Daniel Francis
Thank you, Chair. Jodie, in 2023, the National Audit Office addressed, assessed rather, the East West Rail project is offering poor value for money. So, what's your current assessment of the project's value for money?
Rosemary Hopkins
I think that's probably one for me to pick up. So, it's a piece of work that we are taking forward with East West Rail Co in preparation for the outline business case, which as David says will be available early next year as part of the decision-making ahead of DCO submission. I think it's fair to recognise that actually East West Rail is the backbone of a, the government's growth strategy for the Oxford to Cambridge corridor. It's the enabler for, you know, potentially as many as a 100,000 houses, 10, sorry, 10,000 houses. No, a 100,000.
Houses. You know, it's going to be feeder for potentially two new towns that are in MHCLG's new towns strategy. It's feeding the biggest visitor attraction in Europe. And we estimate that it could deliver as much as pb6.7 billion of GVA to the local economy by 2050. We need to recognise those strategic benefits and the impact that East West Rail can have on growth, on connecting people to jobs and opportunities and housing in the area through the business case.
And that is part of what we are collectively working together to ensure that both we quantify where we can in transport terms and growth terms, but that we also recognise the wider strategic opportunity and value that the scheme adds, that we capture that in the business case. But also that we work across, you know, as SRO for the subsequent parts of the schemes, that we set up both the governance arrangements and the partnering arrangements across Whitehall to ensure that the benefits that are possible from the enabler that the East West Rail is are fully utilised through delivery and the incremental investment that will be needed, you know, around as I say new towns and other enabling infrastructure to be able to maximise that economic case.
David Hughes
Just to build really on, I agree with all that Rosemary said. I'm often asked, you know, are you confident in the business case for East West Rail? And I am wholly confident. I'm on message on this as well, because I believe it. I'm wholly confident in the business case for East West Rail.
And, but the business case comprises a number of elements. And the key element of the business case for East West Rail is the strategic case, which has been backed by successive governments, including this one. You know, the railway makes a reality of the Oxford-Cambridge Arc. And growth in the Oxford-Cambridge Arc is critical to the future prosperity of the UK. That's the strategic case.
It's about housing development at large scale, hundreds of thousands of houses, connectivity, connecting houses to high-productivity productivity jobs in the kinds of industries that are going to be critical to the UK's future prosperity. So, it's a really strong strategic case. People confuse business case with benefit-cost ratios and the intricacies of the transport appraisal guidance. A personal view, I think that the business case methodology that drives the BCR is really poor at capturing the benefits of schemes like East West Rail that are not a typical It's not a It's not a railway transport project, it's an economic growth project. I sometimes say it's a housing project with a railway attached.
The methodology is really poor at capturing that. That's not unusual for this sort of project. So, if you look at the Borders Railway, I don't think there's no one would say that is anything other than an outstanding success. It had a really poor BCR when it was committed to by government. So, when I'm asked about the business case, we've got a really strong business case.
I'm completely It's compelling. It's about making a reality of that Oxford-Cambridge Arc. BCR, I don't expect would be very good. So, the report of the NAO, before my time, doesn't surprise me. Don't think, on the standard methodology, we'll score well on BCR.
That's not the basis on which we're making the case for investment in this railway.
Daniel Francis
So, if the National Audit Office, you know, compiled a report today, based on that, you think it would say the same based on the BCR analysis?
Rosemary Hopkins
Well, I think there are two elements for me about this. There's absolutely making sure that we can quantify all of the benefits we can as part of the benefit-cost ratio for the scheme, and then it's important that we recognise the wider strategic case and opportunity that the project represents beyond what is quantifiable in a BCR when providing advice to ministers on which they can take a decision on whether this is the best use of public funds for delivering, you know, delivering infrastructure that can enable growth. And for me, as SRO working with David, it's really important that we do set out both that narrow transport case well and well quantified in economic terms, but also that we take a place-based approach to this and are able to exploit the opportunity we have to demonstrate the value that this project provides to the growth corridor and to the wider economy, which isn't typically captured well in a transport economic appraisal on, but the decision will be taken in the round on the basis of all of the cases, strategic and economic.
but the decision will be taken in the round on the basis of all of the cases, strategic and economic case for the scheme.
Daniel Francis
So back in 2023, they said that the DfT was expecting to spend between 5.7 and 6.6 billion on the project. So, what's your current assessment of how much they're projected to spend?
Speaker 92
I'm going to pass that onto David in the first case, because you're doing the numbers for my business case.
David Hughes
It comes back, actually, in part to the answer I gave to Mr Glover earlier, the current estimate is a 2023-24 estimate of 6 to 7 billion, and that's in 2021 prices, so that is the current estimate that we have in the public domain. As I explained in my response to Mr Glover earlier, what we are doing now over the next 6 to 9 months, as we head to that OBC submission to government in the summer of next year, is working out our revised view of the schedule and the cost envelope that's going to be required to deliver the scope of the railway that we now have.
And the scope has changed significantly since 2024 to a large extent driven by Universal, so we're delivering more benefits, longer trains, more frequent services, to make sure we can accommodate the additional demand from Universal, which is a good thing, revenue, etcetera. Having the UK's biggest tourist attraction on your doorstep is a good thing, but we have had to make changes. So, what we're doing at the moment, we've now essentially, as I said to Alex earlier, you know, we've pretty much locked down the scope now, we think, to take into the DCO.
We need to cost that design, and this is, as I said earlier, this you know, about making the best possible judgement about what our cost envelope is going to be to deliver the scope that we've now agreed with the department. That's going to take us through until that review point to moment in June, July next year. That's when we'll be setting out a revised cost envelope. But it you know, the design has changed,
and, of course, the previous estimate is in 2021 prices, so everyone can do the maths around that.
Daniel Francis
Can you tell us how much it's been spent to date and break that down?
David Hughes
I'm not I can't, and I wouldn't want to because I think to sort of do a running commentary on what I might be thinking at any one point in time isn't the right way to do this. We've committed to government, I've committed to government, that we will set out our best view, all the reasons I said earlier, do that now before the point of commitment, get the judgement right about being, you know, ambitious about efficiency, but don't lose a grip on reality, don't succumb to optimism bias.
These are really difficult judgements that I need to make made with my leadership team and with the East West Rail board, and we will present the outcome of that at review point two as part of our OBC submission to government.
Daniel Francis
I heard what you said earlier, obviously, on experience from elsewhere, but is there anything else you want to add, really, on how you're going to ensure that costs don't exceed estimates along the way?
David Hughes
Well, I think again, it's sort of repeating the same point, there's lots of reasons why rail projects go over their initial estimate. One of them is you get the initial estimate wrong. And to refer to the book that Mr Glover mentioned earlier, the book by Jonathan Simcock, well worth a read, not just because I'm quoted, it's well worth a read, about, you know, some of the dangers around government sponsored projects in particular is there is a lot of the temptation to sort of low-ball your estimate at this point in the process,
not in a sort of Machiavellian way, but the way the system works, there's a risk, and we see it time and again, that the initial estimate is wrong. And you get the funding commitment, and then you're fighting a battle after that, because your costs exceed the estimate. What the you know, the challenge ahead of me and my team and my board over the next six to nine months is to try and get that cost envelope, our best possible view of what we think it's what the government is going to have to invest to deliver the scope that we've now arrived at.
Rosemary Hopkins
And I wonder whether I could just come in on the department's role in this as well. That you know, as SRO, my responsibility is very much about setting the strategic direction of the project, which we've talked about, is the backbone for growth in the Oxford to Cambridge corridor, to set up the sponsor requirements for what we want for an operational railway, ensure that we've got the governance to oversee that effectively and hold the programme to account for delivery. So, where we are at the moment is very much around, as David says, working up that cost envelope and schedule. And for me, it's about building confidence in that cost envelope and schedule, getting the right balance between, you know, what is a minimum viable product, what is the best value for the taxpayer in terms of what we can deliver, but also balancing that with confidence that it is deliverable.
You know, we've talked a little bit already about the lessons learned from HS2 and other major projects, and where large infrastructure schemes sponsored by government have gone wrong previously. And they have, as David said, tended you know, some of the common themes are around, you know, under under-specifying or underestimating the cost, and then watching the cost creep up over time. What I've been really keen to do with David is agree, you know, to take the time to work thoroughly through both the schedule and what is achievable and the cost envelope that's required to deliver that, being as lean and responsible as we can be with public funds, and then to put in place a governance that ensures that both David has the objectives and incentives to deliver that, but also that he has the resources to be able to do the project well. I'm, you know, looking forward to working up the business case so that we can then take that decision as that ministerial decision as government around whether this is the right investment choice, and keen to ensure that we also ensure that we got, you know, the scope locked down at that point, and DCO submitted, and that we make the funding available to take this project forward.
Because it's that it's that changing the specification and hitting affordability problems and taking projects to market when they're insufficiently mature that drives the uncertainty and delay and cost growth that we've seen on other projects. And that is where we're taking the learn learning on board here about taking the time to get it right and scope it well and cost it properly at the outset.
Jodie Lofthouse
Well, the overarching envelope is 1.2 billion. The overarching funding envelope for phase one is the 1.2 billion, which we expect to come in within or under that budget.
David Hughes
And then we've spent, I'd have to write to the committee to confirm, so there's the phase one delivery of the phase one infrastructure.
East West Rail Limited has been in existence for nine years. So, we've had for most of that time it's the annual spend has been relatively small. We're ramping up now. So we put our accounts in Parliament on was it last week, on Monday? So last year we spent 190 million.
This year, and this is in design development now. So we spent 190 million in the last financial year. Our budget for the current financial year is around 275. So we're ramping up. The bulk of that spend now is on design development.
So again, key lesson from HS2: get your design to the level of maturity that you need to make informed judgments about cost envelope. So lion's share of our spend at the moment is on design development, and we have also got a very extensive survey programme. So if you're out in the area, particularly between Bedford and Cambridge, you will see a lot of folk in orange jacket doing ground investigations, environmental surveys, etc. Again, key lessons from previous projects: you invest in your design maturity, you get you spend actually as much as you can on understanding the ground conditions in which you're going to be delivering the project. Yeah.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
I think we get that from HS2, etc. Okay, thank you, that's helpful. Oli?
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Chair. East West Rail is proposing discontinuous electrification with battery electric trains for the next phase of the project. The Campaign to Electrify Britain's Railways has argued that the case for discontinuous electrification on a railway such as East West Rail has not been adequately demonstrated. How would you respond to that criticism?
Ben Rule
Thanks for that. So I think you need to start by remembering the purpose that East West Rail has, which is to provide connectivity along the Ox-Cam corridor to drive economic growth. That is what we are tasked with doing. To do that you need some trains. So there will need to be a procurement of trains to run the service from Oxford to Cambridge.
DfT are the procuring authority for that. We're working with DfT to make sure that those trains are available. What DfT have done recently, of course, is publish the Rolling Stock and Infrastructure Strategy that sets out how DfT intend to deliver new trains for the country. That has made it very clear that moving away from diesel rolling stock is the policy. That means that you will end up with fleets of electrically powered trains.
That's the direction of travel. The question then becomes to what extent is that full driven by full electrification or discontinuous electrification? Discontinuous electrification is a way in which we can reduce the capital cost of delivering the infrastructure. The rolling stock strategy sets out that is the preferred direction of travel for discontinuous electrification, battery EMUs. And we are clear direction from the department that we are expected to deliver our benefits by the best possible capital costs this project.
We're incentivised to try and do that as efficiently as possible. Battery EMUs with discontinuous electrification allows us to do that. It's worth just giving an example of why discontinuous electrification can save us significant amount of money. In the country, quite a lot of the National Grid power lines run north-south, actually. Our railway runs east-west.
It means that there are a number of points at which our railway crosses those grid lines. For us to put overhead line on the railway in some of those locations would require those National Grid lines to either be lifted or buried. That is a significant cost, and if you can avoid that, it keeps the cost down.
It also incidentally will reduce schedule risk because National Grid and other power companies are under quite a lot of pressure with the amount of work they've got to do. Avoiding those is good from a schedule risk point of view as well. So, our proposal is for discontinuous electrification battery EMUs because we believe that will deliver the benefits at the best capital cost for the program.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Okay, thank you. Yes, it's so there's quite a bit to pick out there. Let's start with what you said about the right overall rolling stock approach. So, you've cited the rolling stock strategy, but my recollection of reading that document, it does very clearly say in there that for railways that are intended to have freight as well, then full electrification might be justified. And you have cited earlier in your evidence today that there is a case for using freight on East West Rail.
So, would discontinuous electrification and battery trains help electric freight to, enable electric freight, in your view?
Ben Rule
So, we talked earlier on about the fact that we are providing the capacity to allow freight trains to operate. We're, talked about freight train per hour. Doing discontinuous electrification does not prevent freight trains from operating along the line of route. We are tasked with providing that connectivity between Oxford and Cambridge, driving that economic growth. We believe that by doing discontinuous electrification, we can deliver those benefits we're tasked with delivering, for the best capital cost for the program.
David Hughes
If I'm If I may, Mr. I just want, sort of, not Ben's much closer to the detail, a reflection for me, when I came into this role in June 24, the assumption that the project was working to was that the end state rolling stock would be diesel. So, the assumption was that this would be a diesel traction railway. Two things became very clear to me very quickly. First was that was never going to be acceptable to stakeholders on the line of route, who could not get their heads round why you were building a new railway with the intention of it being diesel operated in the 2030s. That was very made very clear to me very quickly.
The other thing that was very clear to me very quickly is that we would never get the money for full electrification of this railway from the department and from and particularly from the Treasury. Uh,
Why is that?
David Hughes
I think so, I won't speak for the, but I'll give I'll give you a view. I'll tell you this is a view, not really so much from my position as chief exec of East West Rail, but my experience generally. The Treasury looks at the amount it needs to spend on decarbonization, not by sector, it looks at it, you know, ac- across the UK as a whole, and I think it looks at rail as a form of transport that actually is it you know, relative to other forms of transport, rela- you know, rel- relatively carbon friendly. So, I think from a Treasury perspective, and the I'm sure Rosemary will have a view, Christian as well, I think one of the difficulties that the rail industry has had in arguing for, you know, more investment in electrification is again, personal view, the Treasury thinks actually, in terms of bang for buck in meeting the UK decarbonization targets, rail is not where it wants to put its buck. It wants to spend it in other areas.
I think so I just think that's a general context that we have. And the way that felt to me coming in is I came in, said, you know, we have to try and find, you know, delivering a brand new railway on the basis of diesel traction is not going to be acceptable in the mid, you know, mid to late-2030s. And I can see why, you know, it was a real bone of contention for stakeholders and communities along the line of route.
And it was very clear from the discussions we had earlier the pressure and the upfront capital cost difference is in hundreds of millions, right? So the discontinuous route allowed us to decarbonize the traction solution. That was hugely well received along the line of route, and it did so at a cost that was going to be acceptable to government. In a world where, you know, money was no object, that might not be the solution you arrive at, but, you know, that's not the world in which we live. And so I think, you know, we have ended up a solution that allows us to have a decarbonized railway at a cost that is acceptable to government, and using a technology that is becoming, is now going to become increasingly the norm in line with the national strategies, not just actually in this country, but in Europe as well.
The route to decarbonizing the railway is not going to be putting wires up across the whole of the network.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
And yet all across Europe, they continue to do so. Countries in Europe have a vastly higher percentage of electrified lines than we do, on average. Are you aware of any other 100 mph high-frequency railways that are being proposed for discontinuous electrification, not full?
Ben Rule
So, we are not aware that there is an identical railway that's set up in that way. There are a number of railways around Europe that are being set up as discontinuous electrification. I don't think there's an exact match.
Speaker 99
New one, new ones, which don't come with the same burden of structure clearance?
Ben Rule
I'm not, I'm not aware of one that matches that in Europe, but that doesn't mean to say that we cannot use discontinuous electrification on our railway to provide a decarbonized railway that delivers the benefits that we're tasked with delivering.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Too much, Chair, I don't want to hog it for too much longer.
No, go on, because it's quite important, Mr.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Okay, thank you for your forbearance, Chair, and indeed everybody else. There's still a bit more I want to probe about that. So, you mentioned that the cost difference, the cost saving is in the hundreds of millions. What's the cost per standard track kilometre you're assuming for electrifying your railway?
I'll have to write to you on, I don't have that to hand.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Yeah, please do. Please, that would be great, because I think that cost, given that it's a relatively small distance you're not proposing to electrify, is very surprising, given that Scotland, as a result of their rolling program, has got the cost per standard track kilometre down to about £2 million. Now, rough maths, forgive me, I don't know the, so I think there's about 30 km, 20 mi you're not planning to electrify. So, 60 km times by 2 million track, right, so it doesn't necessarily get to hundreds of millions that quickly, and of course that's a new railway without structures to clear, which is some of the cost. But I maybe, that's from my very rough maths.
Ben Rule
So, we will write to you on that. It is worth going back to the point I made earlier on that it isn't just about the pure cost per kilometre. There are those other specific costs around things like utility diversions that you do have to take into account to get the total cost.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Yes, I want to come back to that because there's been another east to west railway that's been electrified in recent times, admittedly with problems. That's the Great Western Main Line electrification. Now, reading the National Audit Office report, there's no mention there that the costs resulting from National Grid power line diversions as a factor. And from having looked into the Midland Main Line business case, that the information I've been given from conversations I've had is that accounted for about 0.2% of the cost. So what's different here?
And have you looked at the costs of that particular element in previous electrifications?
Ben Rule
So, I was the operations director for Great Western Railway at the time when the thinking was being done on electrifying Great Western Main Line. I can recall that there was great concern in the program at the time about the fact that the diversions that needed to be done, at least one of which is in your constituency, I think, were potentially going to put the program at risk because of the length of time it would take. So, there was a lot of concern at the time about it. Now, the electrification of Great Western Main Line obviously took longer than expected and was more expensive than expected. But I'm pretty clear that there was concern in the program about the scale of work required to do that.
I don't know the exact cost numbers, but I can recall there being quite significant concern about the scale of that.
Speaker 100
Well, hopefully, you do because you're citing it as a big reason for your decision.
Ben Rule
Well, we definitely have the numbers for the cost of the diversions that we would require to do on our railway. Whether we can have we have the numbers for the diversions specifically on Great Western is a different matter, yeah.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
And have you and just two more Chair, and then I will stop, I promise.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
And then, oh yeah, sorry, right. And then, just so just on that. So, have you had your assumptions about electrification costs and rolling stock capability and cost peer reviewed?
Ben Rule
We have had a we have a number of expert panels inside East West Rail that give us advice, independent advice from experts on a number of different topics. We've had electrification expert advice, they've looked at our proposals, they've made some observations on our proposal. So, yes, we have had external advice on what we're proposing to do.
Okay, all right?
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
And just sort of one more Chair, sort of I do apologize. And just on In terms of the assumption that it's cheaper, I mean, Mr. Hughes, you keep referring to optimism bias and I think that's a very important thing to think about. Does the fact that the cost of 29 five-car trains for TransPennine Express with batteries cost £1 billion, £6.9 million per vehicle, which I'm pretty sure is one of the most expensive rolling stock orders ever, does that support the assertion that indeed it is necessarily cheaper to do discontinuous and batteries?
Ben Rule
So, our assessment of the business case for discontinuous electrification has assumed a range of lease costs for rolling stock. The way in which we've done it is by assessing the lease cost of the rolling stock. We've taken a range and that assessment has included a range for the lease cost of battery EMUs, which is higher than the lease cost for a plain EMU. So, our assessment has included a higher lease cost for battery EMUs already. That's the way in which the business case work has reflected the risk of battery EMUs being a more expensive train.
Sorry, thank you Chair.
Christian Irwin
I mean the conversation has moved on a little bit, but I guess just on the point about kind of benchmark in electrification costs. We know there's been a phenomenal amount of lessons that have been learned since the Great Western electrification, and you know, we held internally to the industry a challenge panel on reducing the cost of electrification only 3 weeks ago with our chief executive. And the amount of innovations that have come through in terms of how long we can put between stanchions, voltage control clearances, and we have been able to really drive down some of the costs of electrification. And particularly Scotland have done a wonderful job in terms of that and you've quoted their benchmark rate of sub-2 billion £2 million per kilometer. Where the challenge on electrification comes is in highly congested urban areas.
We are still really struggling to find a way to drive the costs down below £5 million, £4 million for in those highly congested areas, complex utilities, bridges, structures. Wigan to Bolton, no, we delivered about £4.5 million per STK. And I recently spent some time with Transport for Wales colleagues on their Core Valley Lines, which is recently just delivered its partial electrification saving themselves nearly £300 million.
Their narrative was very clear around where it is complex and disproportionate to deliver the electrification. The efficiency about being able to have that battery on board enables that to the railway to be very successful, and, you know, their batteries never dip below 90%. So, there is innovation to drive the STK right down; that is really important. But there are certain parts of the industry where of the infrastructure where it is so disproportionately expensive, the cost of putting what we now have an automatic pantograph changeover, a balise on the ground allows the pantograph to drop as to run into an alternative mode and then speak out,
that efficiency in terms of pure infrastructure is significant. And we're talking hundreds of millions of pounds. And certainly, the conclusion we drew from our industry challenge panel electrification cost is that where it is appropriate to do so, that has to be a fundamental part of our strategy going forward. Yes, we need to prove that the technology is suitable and robust. Yes, you need to demonstrate the rolling stock is affordable to buy that, but we're starting to see through what are procuring on TransPennine, what we're doing in Liverpool, what we're doing in the Core Valley Lines,
and we're going to be going out with colleagues in Italy, France, and Germany looking at some of their partially decarbonised fleets. So-
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Yeah, but I would just come back to the point about 100 mph operation, which is definitely not what happens on the valley lines in South Wales. So, the there are some differences that I hope are going to be looked at.
Rosemary Hopkins
Well, and I wonder whether it's just, in conclusion, worth coming back to the government policy on this, which you know, we already talked about the wider rolling stock and infrastructure strategy, which is supporting the increasing use of standardised battery electric fleets. You know, in making that policy recommendation, the department's got confidence that it will deliver a net zero passenger railway at significantly less infrastructure and lower up-front costs than full electrification. That's certainly what you know, what the numbers are suggesting on East West Rail.
We have considered full electrification, but the analysis suggests that the infrastructure costs, you know, are higher whilst delivering a similar passenger outcome. But I think the important thing to note here is that, you know, the both the final traction and the fleet solution still remain subject to that business case approval, and that will be part of the, you know, decisions taken at the OBC stage.
Speaker 83
Thank you, Chair. Can we have an update on the work of the East West Rail Economic Growth Board, what work it's been carrying out, and any conclusions and recommendations that it's that it's made?
David Hughes
I, and it was reword The Economic Growth Board was reworked after the 24 election, and is now the Oxford to Cambridge Growth Corridor Unit in Treasury. I think that was set up in Treasury under the leadership of Lord Patrick Vallance. So, that is the That replaced the Economic Growth Board.
And continues, I think, and Rosemary and Jodie will probably want to come in, to play a really important role in convening business, academia, local authorities, other stakeholders along the line of route to drive the agenda for economic growth in the corridor. And we were really pleased as East West Rail Limited to see Lord Vallance confirmed, continuing in that role as chair of the growth corridor
following the recent change in prime minister, to see Lord Vallance continuing in that role was really welcome news because he is a very powerful advocate for the importance of the corridor, and the importance of East West Rail in making a reality of the corridor.
Speaker 106
There was some criticism in 2024 that the board was quite isolated in terms of local perspectives. So, is that what was res the response to it?
Rosemary Hopkins
So, you know, certainly my my experience, it doesn't align with that. My attendance at the ministerial delivery group has included take, you know, sessions with England's Economic Heartland, so actually providing that joined-up approach across the corridor to look at the opportunity as a whole. The delivery board has been just hugely helpful in terms of convening all of the parts of government who have a opportunity to influence the success of this project together, both to you know, unlock barriers to successful delivery and, you know, really bring some momentum and focus to what needs to happen to make this work well.
I think what that's also enabled You know, so that so there's a cross-Whitehall piece there driven by ministers to set the ambition and to unlock the impediments to success. I think what we've been able to do, learning on the learning the lessons from HS2 and other major projects, is refresh our own governance and oversight of the project to ensure that we are also replicating that cross-Whitehall influence and focus in our own governance. So, we, on the back of the James Stewart review and the recommendations on for HS2, have looked at our own sponsorship and governance arrangements and are about to step up a new programme board for the programme as a whole, which will include the cross-Whitehall attendance from MHCLG, Treasury and other colleagues across Whitehall to both really to set that expectation for whole-of-Whitehall collaborative endeavour to maximize the benefit that the enabling infrastructure can have in terms of growth.
Speaker 34
Thank you, Chair. So, we're familiar with the reporting from Rail Magazine in late 2025 that there was strong reporting, and a consideration and support for taking East West Rail in-house to Network Rail. Just want to, first of all, David, is that still being considered?
David Hughes
Yeah, so it's really important, I think, to start from an understanding that we're not two completely separate beings, East West Rail Ltd and Network Rail. We're both arm's-length bodies of the Department for Transport. My East West Rail Ltd, we sit in Network Rail offices. My leadership team comprises a number of NR secondees, my whole team.
So we're working hand in glove with Network Rail. That's really important. And, actually, around half of the spend on the programme will be delivered by Network Rail on its infrastructure. About half of it is the new build stuff between Bedford and Cambridge, and half of it is upgrading existing rail infrastructure. So, the success of this project is critically dependent on East West Rail Ltd and Network Rail working hand in glove.
One of the questions that I raised, I haven't got a sort of selfish agenda in maintaining an independent East West Rail Ltd, when I came into the role, I started a discussion with government and with Andrew Haines, the then Chief Exec of Network Rail, about whether it still made sense for East West Rail Ltd to be a separate arm's-length body set up for the delivery and design of the railway, because there's a lot of history here. When East West Rail was first set up back in 2017, there was a very different vision about what its role would be and what the future operation of the railway would look like.
We're very clear now that our role is as systems integrator, as we've touched on already, our job is to coordinate inputs from across the industry to make sure we bring together all of those elements that are required for successful delivery of railway services. That's the outcome that we need. Now, we raised specifically whether keeping East West Rail as a separate arm's length body was the right thing to do, and we raised that in the context of the James Stewart review into HS2 governance. Off the back of the James Stewart review, the Department and East West Rail, we jointly commissioned a follow-on review on East West Rail governance.
That included James himself actually as part of the review team. And one of the questions that we posed to that review was would it make sense to move East West Rail Limited into NR, or in fact G GBR from day one? The conclusion that was reached by that review, which was endorsed by ministers, was, actually, for the time being at least, there is merit in retaining East West Rail Limited as a separate arm's length body. Why is that? I think partly just where we are in the program, having a single-purpose vehicle focused on securing the DCO, developing the design, getting the project to the point of main works delivery, it makes sense to keep East West Rail Limited as a separate body and, in the meantime, allow GBR stand up to take place.
I think it's fair to say, although it's probably not written down anywhere, there is an expectation that in a few years' time, maybe 2029-30, by which time, all being well, we will have secured our DCO, we'll have secured full funding for the railway, we will be at the point of starting main works delivery, and in parallel, GBR will have been stood up in a bit more steady state. I think there is an expectation that whoever is in government at that time would probably want to revisit whether at that stage
we should revisit the question of whether East West Rail should remain as a separate entity. But that question was looked at very carefully in light of the James Stewart review into HS2. There were pros and cons around it, but the decision reached was actually, for the time being, to try and incorporate East West Rail in into GBR at the point of stand up would probably import a bit of a risk in terms of distraction on all the other changes going on. So it's as we are for the time being. I think that makes sense.
The point I'd stress is that we're not two separate organizations in the way that perhaps we were when East West Rail was first established back in 2017. That was very much the original vision for East West Rail when it was set up by the then Secretary of State, Chris Grayling, was that it will be very distinct from Network Rail. That's not where we are in today's world. As I say, we work hand-in-glove with Network Rail, and that's the trajectory that we're on.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Do keep the answers quite short, because we are short of time now.
Ben Rule
If I may, if I could just add a little to that. So, David has talked about the question as to whether East West Rail should become part of Network Rail, Great British Railways. I think it's also worth thinking, though, that Network Rail is a series of routes. I talked about north-south power lines earlier on, but actually a lot of Network Rail's routes run north-south as well. Those routes will become business units in GBR.
East West Rail's route actually cuts across seven of those routes, seven of GBR's business units. Regardless of whether East West Rail is inside Network Rail or GBR or not, it is important to have a group of people who are focused on bringing the East West Rail project to a successful conclusion.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Yeah. And, I mean, so it's quite important that the relationship between East West Rail and Network Rail is effective.
Do you think it's working to date?
Christian Irwin
As Ben just described, this is about how we integrate and how our relationships work to deliver this together. I think whether in Network Rail, outside Network Rail, in GBR, it's about how we structure ourselves both in terms of the governance, in terms of the assurance, but in terms of how we set the system up for success. We've recently made some significant changes in how we integrate together. David has appointed one of our major program directors to sit on his leadership board and Katy, who fulfills that role, represents the broader Network Rail, the six, seven routes that it crosses. We interface with five main lines, time tables.
That integration is absolutely fundamental. But having a clear guiding mind focused on the outcome is really important and David's team can provide that. What we can provide in terms of that integration is making sure that whilst we're building the new, we keep the existing railway operational during construction and post-construction. And I think that interface, playing the best athletes in their roles is really important. We've really established that clear governance.
David Hughes
So, yeah, we still got a way to go in terms of how we move into the next delivery phase, but we are, we're pleased with the direction of travel and the integration we have together. If I may, Chair, a very brief, one build on Christian's point, and we've mentioned the review we've done of governance, so to really give effect to the lesson learned and the need for integration, we now have Network Rail and DFTO embedded at every level of our program governance, up to and including the East West Rail board. So, we now have, for example, Ellie Burrows, the Regional Managing Director of Eastern Region attends the East West Rail board. So, complete integration from my team right the way up to the East West Rail board to make sure we are looking at this as one system.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Yeah. Okay, Scott, has your question more or less been answered?
Scott Arthur
I think so. I don't think I think we've covered HS2 and lessons learned. I don't think any of the others have anything to add on that.
Rosemary Hopkins
I think the only thing I would pick up from what we've just been saying about the collaborative working with Network Rail and East West Rail Co picks up one of the lessons from HS2 lessons learned as well, which is the clarity of accountability and, you know, not In addition to the governance arrangements, we've also been very clear about the accountability that David and East West Rail Co have for integration of the whole, so bringing together the relationship with Network Rail and DFTO to take responsibility for delivering an end-to-end railway into operation. I think I mean, just on the HS2 lessons learned, very briefly, so I mentioned Mark Wild already. I meet regularly with Mark. I would say the biggest lesson already actually embedded in the project, and the biggest advantage East West Rail has in some ways over HS2, is we have absolute clarity of what we're trying to do, why we are here, what our purpose is. We're here to enable sustainable economic growth along the Oxford-Cambridge corridor.
David Hughes
And I think HS2 has suffered from the get-go about not being absolutely clear what problem it's trying to solve.
You've even got a completion date, which is a start.
Scott Arthur
So, in terms of the lessons what about lessons learned from East West Rail itself for other projects? Now, I think David, Ben and Christian already touched on this. Rosemary and Jodie, have you got anything to add in terms of future projects, what we can learn from East West?
Rosemary Hopkins
I think there's been a lot of learning from HS2 that we've taken into East West Rail in the department's governance and oversight arrangements, some of the things that have changed in our sponsor team around recognizing the need for a dedicated SRO and appointing rather than as part of putting East West Rail as part of a portfolio, working on our sponsor capability and our role to be to specify and set the policy intent, the objectives, and the outcomes, but then very much be eyes on, but hands off and give the accountability to David and East West Rail Co.
What I think we've been really good at building on the experience of HS2 is bringing together both ensuring that we've got really well experienced SROs across the department leading the major projects with the capacity and the capability to do those well, but also bringing them together as a you know, as a cohort, so peer support and sharing experience and lessons.
So I meet with my SRO colleagues of the other big infrastructure projects in the department, you know, on a fortnightly basis to share you know, lessons, experiences, and troubleshoot sort of challenges we have on our projects both technical and policy together.
Jodie Lofthouse
To add really quickly, obviously, one of the latest projects that will also learn from us is NPR, and we work really closely with the NPR teams across DFT at DfT and are actively sharing the lessons that we learn with them so that they're embedding them even earlier on in
David Hughes
I think there's two there's two specific areas I would highlight. It's definitely about sharing with NPR. One is the way we've built that strategic case, because NPR has a lot of similarities, you know, in terms of the economic case, agglomeration, building an economic so sharing our thinking about how we've developed this compelling strategic case for the railway. I think the other clear area where we are learning lessons which we can share with future projects, not just in rail, is we are a pilot project under the Planning and Infrastructure Act. So we're the first big project going through the new processes and we are learning some lessons, and we will share those with other projects, so.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Great. Okay, thank you. Olly, you had a quick question, then
I think you've I think you've largely
You get it covered?
covered this.
Daniel Francis
Thanks, Chair. So some local stakeholders, including councils and campaign groups, have argued the 2026 consultation process lacked openness and freshness, and the insufficient information was provided to enable meaningful engagement. So how'd you respond to those criticisms?
David Hughes
So I think that I think that quote might come from a an organization called BFAR, which is a cam a campaign group that has existed for a number of years and has campaigned for a different route choice through Bedford. That route choice was made in 2023. Actually, I think we've been I think we've been run really most of the feedback we get is that the consultation processes we run have been really effective. We get really high response rates and we've been able to demonstrate that actually we have made significant changes to our design as a result of the consultation. So for example, in last year's consultation, as a consequence of the feedback, we changed our tunnelling proposals in around Bourn Airfield.
We moved the location of Cambourne Station, and there are a number of other examples I could point to, so
David Hughes
We've covered it, we've made a lot of we've made a you know, I think we've run a really good consultation process. I think as we are the first project big project through the Planning and Infrastructure Act, so the process we're going through at the moment with local authorities we had a meeting, we've set up an East West Rail forum which brings together all the local authorities at the political leadership level. It's chaired by a former chair of this committee, Huw Merriman, chairs that forum for us. Lord Hendy dialed into that first meeting we had a few weeks ago, and explained to the local authorities, and I think the leadership of the local authorities get this, that it will feel different. We are the first project going through up to the DCO submission under the processes established under the new Act.
It will feel different, and at times because it's different it will feel a bit bumpy and a bit uncomfortable. We think, as I said earlier, actually it doesn't mean less consultation, it means doing it differently in a more iterative way.
I, but I think the criticism that you cite, I don't accept. I think actually, what I found and I do a lot of public events and the nature of it is that those who turn up at the public events, you know, are often there because that they've got concerns about the project, I can't tell you how often I've had people say to me, "Well, you know, I don't, I'm not a big fan of the railway, but this was a really good event." So, I think we do it really well.
Speaker 115
So how'd you reach those hard to reach groups though, the people that never turn out?
David Hughes
Well, we do quite a bit of work actually. It's the silent majority, isn't it, because actually we do a little bit of polling and
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Well, sorry, that's not the silent majority. I think actually Daniel was referring to kind of people who are impacted, but don't generally pick up on public consultations.
David Hughes
We do extensive we mail shot within a boundary around the railway. I've already mentioned, you know, we're out every week, Bedford tonight, Little Bedford last night, Lidlington tomorrow. We get a good response to our consultation. I think opponents
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
And you assess them for things you know, like protected characteristics, and homeowners, not homeowners, all of that?
David Hughes
Yes, yeah, and we can provide a huge amount of detail on all of that. We work really hard to engage with everyone along the line of route. I think, look, the criticism that you quote, I think, is driven by a frustration from some who are opposed to the scheme that when we came out to consult earlier this year, we were very clear, we're not consulting at this stage in the process on route choice, whether we're turning left or right, whether we're going north into Cambridge, south into Cambridge. Those decisions were made some years ago. We were very clear that the purpose of the consultation in the spring was about refining the detail of the design along the chosen route.
Now, for those who fundamentally oppose that route choice, that's not a message they wanted to hear. So, I think that drives you know, some of the criticism that you may have heard, or you quote around the nature of the consultation is because people wanted to re-litigate decisions that actually government took in 2023, and were confirmed by the new government in 2024. My instructions from government were very clear was to develop a design based on the route choices that had been made at that time. That's partly a lesson learned from HS2 as well.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Okay. You've done? Yeah. Okay, thank you. I just want to go, pick up on this one item that was mentioned at the first session.
Dave Calfe from ASLEF talked about the frustration and the wisdom from his perspective of moving a maintenance depot on the route. Does, you know, did you did any of you want to pick up, was it a Was it a maintenance depot or?
It was the driver depot.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Driver depot, I do apologise. Driver depot. Did you want to pick up on that?
Jodie Lofthouse
Yes, I think I can start off, and then Ben might want to add to it. So, in the first phase, the, you know, as part of the working out the design, there was always an intention to have a depot in Bletchley. And that was part of the kind of proposal for East West Rail specifically. And when we brought the operator on board, obviously we looked at that from a wider operation operational perspective, and, you know, we had advice and proposals from our operator, and from the rest of the industry at that point to ensure we got the right solution. We confirmed that Bletchley was the right solution, as, well, ministers confirmed.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
On the specific site at Bletchley, because he talked about one that's already there.
Jodie Lofthouse
There's an existing Bletchley site, and that was always within the scope of the options that we had, so whilst I think that was being set up, so some of the drivers that were being recruited and brought in would have gone to Chiltern's home depot, they would, you know, It was always then agreed that eventually all of the staff for the line would be in Bletchley.
Speaker 122
So, yeah, it sort of it evolved, but Bletchley was always part of the scope.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
And, just in case, was there anything that was said in the first session that any of you wanted to pick up on?
Ben Rule
I would simply add that I think Dave's point is a valid one, that it is important that you consider those things early. Jodie's talked about the fact that there was a consideration. I made the point earlier on that I think it is critically important that people who know how to operate the railway have a sufficiently strong voice sufficiently early in the programme. And if you do that, I think you go a long way to minimising the risk that those issues become the blocker later. Hard to say they go away completely, but the earlier you think about them, the more likely you are to be able to avoid them.
David Hughes
The only point, so any point to pick up from the first set, David Calfe from ASLEF, you know, was very critical about the set-up of East West Rail, and I just want to stress that's the change we've made in terms of our accountability. What he I think what he has been critical of is what was in place that has led us to where we are today. We have made changes specifically, as I've said, to ensure we're not here again in the future.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Okay, thank you. And what steps are you going to make, each of you, each organisation, over the coming weeks to ensure passenger services are up and running on the first phase as soon as possible?
David Hughes
Well, that's an easy one for us because we're not we're not actually involved in those discussions, so.
Jodie Lofthouse
I think, for me, it's just reiterating what I said in the last panel, and it's probably what Rosemary will say as well, is about continuing to work with Chiltern, who is leading the negotiation, and support them to get the agreement we need to get those final few things done and get a confident enter-into-service date for people.
Rosemary Hopkins
Yeah. Sorry, going on the line. Sorry, Christian, I was just yeah, you know, I think we share the frustration of the panel and the public around not running services on CS1. It's certainly the department's ambition and intention to unlock that as with Chiltern and the union as soon as we can. But also, you know, we've talked a lot here about learning from the experience we have there to ensure that the process works more smoothly on subsequent phases.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Our colleagues in this place whose constituents live along the route are equally frustrated. Christian.
Christian Irwin
Just to there's a few key steps for us to take over the next few weeks. So, Tony made reference to the fact that the station lease was about to be signed for Winslow, so that is being sorted this week. We're working with West Midlands Trains to just issue the contracts for seven new staff that will staff the platforms seven and eight at Bletchley, so they will go out later on this week as well. The final stage really for us is to submit our final evidence to our internal systems review panel to allow both stations to come into full in full into full use. And we can set the whatever the date we set as the go-live date for passenger services, we've obviously got to publish the timetable and start enabling tickets to be available for sale at that point in time.
So, once we get over the this morning's discussion and we get a way forward, set a date, we've got a very clear path in terms of what we need to deliver.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Okay, and that's the go-live date. What about the completion date? Can we be any more specific than mid to late 2030s?
No, not at this stage.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
No, not at this stage, okay. Thank you very much for your evidence and the time you spent preparing for today. Again, if there's anything you didn't have a chance to cover or want to add more detail, please do feel free to write to us, and that concludes today's meeting. The evidence we've received today, being a one-off session, it will inform future deliberations, particularly when we discuss these issues further with the rail minister when he next appears before us in December. So, thank you very much.
Order.