Human Rights (Joint Committee)

28 October 2026

Human Rights (Joint Committee) Actual start House of Lords

Follow its sittings
15:53 - 16:54
Speaker 1
Joint Committee on Human Rights, public evidence session on safety, security and protest. 

The Joint Committee on Human Rights is a committee of both houses made up of 12 members from a broad range of political backgrounds.  Today we will be looking into safety, security and protest and we will be hearing from three witnesses: Liz Webster, founder of Save British Farming, Peter Leary, deputy director of Palestine Solidarity Campaign, and Rahila Gupta, trustee of the Southall Black Sisters.  As members will be aware, the sub judice resolutions of both houses mean that live legal cases should not be discussed in parliamentary proceedings.  Please remember as witnesses to avoid referring to any live legal cases in our discussions today.  And also remind the gallery that you are here to observe and not take part in the meeting in any way. 

I will start the questions.  So, first question is: you've all been involved in organizing protests in the past few years.  Have you noticed any change in the attitude of police towards your events in that time? 

Maybe we'll start with you, Mr. Leary. 
16:54 - 20:01
Speaker 2
Well, what I would say is that over the past three years in particular, we've been involved in a large number of, organizing a large number of protests in response to Israel's, what we regard and others widely regard as Israel's genocide against the Palestinian people in Gaza.  And what we have experienced is a level of policing and a type of policing that isn't familiar to us from the past and hasn't been, isn't familiar to those of our members and coalition partners who have, in some cases, a very long track record of organizing protests and demonstrations going back decades. 

I mean, what that includes is the routine use of the public order legislation to impose restrictions on our marches, restricting the time, the duration, the routes, the end time of marches, in some cases of preventing us from protesting at places where we would wish to protest, the BBC for example, or the Israeli embassy or other sites that we would regard as sites of legitimate protest that we would want to be protesting.  And I think that is a very sort of, as I say, a new experience, these use of conditions. 

I mean, if I can sort of perhaps explain what I mean by that, we would speak to the police ahead of the demonstration and we would discuss the route of the march and the time we planned to set off and we would reach agreement on that.  And then usually the day before or a couple of days before, the police would impose conditions to say, if we say we're assembling at 12:00 with a view to set off about quarter to 1:00, the police will impose conditions to say you must have set off by quarter to 1:00.  So, you know, theoretically, if we're still there at 10 to 1:00, we could be charged for violating the order.  Similarly, people taking part in the march must follow this particular route.  So again, theoretically, someone who leaves the march to go to the toilet even could be potentially in breach and violation of those orders imposed by the police. 

We would say, you know, we hope to be finished by 4:30.  We would then have a condition imposed to say you must be finished by 4:30. 

So again, you know, putting extreme pressure.  We often have speakers at the end of the demonstrations, members of parliament, trade unionists, Palestinians who have lost family.  The Palestinian ambassador often speaks.  Sometimes people don't always stick to time.  But because of the way in which these orders are used, that could potentially be an arrestable offence if people are still speaking at 20 to 5 when we said we were aiming to finish at half past 4. 

So that's a very new experience and it has developed over the past few years. 

20:01 - 20:15

Alex Sobel

I'm going to ask a follow-up question before I move on to Liz Webster. So you've said that technically they could make arrests if you run over time.

Have they made arrests?

20:15 - 21:24

Peter Leary

We haven't been arrested, nobody's been arrested for running over time. But we've been very fearful of that and have, you know, we have had situations where, you know, the final speaker would be up speaking and we're getting agitated and the police are approaching the stage and we're sort of pushing that. We have had situations where conditions have been imposed, on one occasion for example the conditions were imposed governing where people could be in various parts of Whitehall at various points during the day and there were people who were arrested literally for finding themselves on the wrong side of the road at the wrong time. And so a lot of that, you know, there can be confusion, uncertainty.

I think the other thing, as I say, is it creates a sort of chilling effect. We've also had occasions where speakers have not spoken because we were running out of time and we were running up to the allotted time. So that's in terms of people's expression and their ability to address the rally. While not being arrested, it has obviously had that suppressing effect.

21:24 - 21:27

Alex Sobel

Liz, what's your perspectives on this issue?

21:27 - 23:18

Liz Webster

Well, when we did the first demonstration in London, it was actually during 2020 and the COVID years. So I would say that our experience is probably a little bit the opposite in that it was much tougher when we first started. It was the first time tractors had ever really been brought to London in any number. And so the police were quite concerned about what we were going to do.

And so they were helpful but they were sort of don't do this and don't do that. And so there was a lot of mistrust to begin with. And we did another bigger one in 2024 and they were going around checking our machinery, making sure it was in, you know, it was legal. I mean it's a slightly different protest because it's a moving, it was a moving vehicle protest. And so when we came to do the much bigger protest in 2025, 2024, the end of 2024 and 2025, by then we'd sort of built a better relationship with the police.

They knew who we were and we spoke to them and had meetings with them ahead of the protests so that we knew what the parameters were and we just decided to work with them as much as we possibly could. So I would say it improved. It was much, much tougher in 2020 because probably of the COVID, you know, restrictions as well. So all in all it sort of got better for us. And also I was clear with them that we never wanted to see anyone participating in the tractor protest to go on the wrong side of the law.

We were adamant that we didn't want to see any farmers arrested. That would not have helped us or them.

23:18 - 23:33

Alex Sobel

Just, just to follow up, have you had any similar issues that Peter's had, so time restrictions, threats of arrest, people maybe straying off a tractor route and being arrested?

Have you had any of those issues?

23:33 - 24:53

Liz Webster

Yeah, I mean legally there is a slight different difference between a moving vehicle protest and a physical protest of people. But they at times were, you know, we want you to finish at this time and you can't always guarantee that you're going to get rid of people. Some tractors decide to hang around and park in Whitehall afterwards and go for a drink. You know, but we we did everything that we could to make sure that we did what the police asked us because we felt it was more important for the protest to go well and positively and we didn't want to have a negative relationship with them. So we when they came through to us and said we want you to clear Whitehall now, that's exactly what what we did.

We did our best to do what the police asked us to do. But we had to consider that it's a vehicle protest and we didn't want to get in the way of hospitals or we didn't want anything that was going to cause significant problems for London or for the people in London. So we tried to do everything that we could to work with them as positively as possible. And that has helped us. You know, that we've built a good relationship with the Met and and so I would say that that that has made it more positive.

So an opposite experience.

24:53 - 24:55

Alex Sobel

Rahila, can we hear your perspective on this?

24:55 - 30:08

Rahila Gupta

Okay, um first of all, thank you very much for inviting Southall Black Sisters to talk on this important subject.

I want to make my comments a little bit broader than those of my colleagues here and just to say, start with a really simple point that, you know, we wouldn't be here today if we hadn't been out there on the streets and continued to be to make our voices heard. Um, so that's really the, the importance of protest is, is very, very important to us. And it's also, it's the right to belong, which I think is very important for racialized minorities. And as we know, with the Article 15 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the right to belong is enshrined there. And of course, Hannah Arendt has talked about the right to have rights.

So I just want to start with that introduction.

In terms, so I do have some provisos and it goes back to the fact that we cannot separate the policing of protests from our history or from our experience of policing generally. And so we come from a history of, you know, the Mangrove Nine, the Bradford 12, Newham 8, and in fact I could say that most recently the King's Cross 3, when our director who's sitting right behind me was bitten in a racist incident on the tube and it was the police who arrested her for common assault. Now we fought the charges, the charges were dropped, but I'm giving you this incident to explain how our experience of policing comes from a particular bias if you like, but a bias that we feel is justified by our history. And again this might feel a little bit too far back, but it's relevant to the point I want to make about the two-tier policing.

I'm sorry to use that term because I think it's been usurped by the likes of Nigel Farage, but I come at it from a totally different point of view. And just to say that Southall Black Sisters was, you know, came up in 1979 when we had the National Front wanting provocatively to hold a meeting in Southall, a predominantly Black Asian area. They brought in the Special Patrol Group on horses, you know, criminalizing, arresting Black Asian men.

So, it's it's we are still living with that double-edged or light-touch policing, if you like, of the far right, who whose right to protest seems to be better protected than ours. So going back 50 years, sort of nearly 50 years, forward fast-forward to last year when we organized a demonstration outside the Home Office to protest against the earned settlement route in the new immigration proposals, these are still proposals. And we were actually really anxious that the far right would turn up and do a counter-protest. So we didn't even advertise this demonstration on social media, which you might say is a bit of an own goal because it's self-defeating if you can't actually bring the numbers together.

And that was our anxiety that these men who have appeared outside asylum centers and immigration hostels, they are, they are dominated by men who have criminal convictions for racial and sexual violence. They've been known to photograph women leaving these centers and then putting that on social media. So with these sorts of dangers, we were worried about how do we mobilize, how do we bring our women into what could be a potentially dangerous situation? And our entire work is about restoring confidence to women, reclaiming the streets, you know, restoring their autonomy. So it's this two-tiered policing that is problematic.

The second proviso is that unlike my colleagues here, we have organized, as I've just mentioned the demo, we've organized a few demos and mostly marches through Southall, but we're not, that's not our primary tool of protest.

So I will be talking from our experience of participating in marches, many of them organized by Palestine Solidarity Campaign. And just to say that from that experience, I would argue that the law has now caught up with policing. And what I mean by that is that what were heavy-handed measures in the past are now, have legislative backing.

And I would argue that it probably goes even further, that if you talk about things like the excessive noise clause, or you talk about, you know, the facial covering, etc.

30:08 - 30:09

Alex Sobel

We'll come on to those issues later.

30:09 - 30:32

Rahila Gupta

Yeah, I'm not going to talk in detail. I'm just going to say that those were proposals that the police may only have dreamt about in the past. So if the law gives tools that are not proportionate to the police, then any reassurances that the police will use those proportionately do not reassure us.

30:32 - 30:34

Alex Sobel

Right, I'm going to bring in Afzal Khan.

30:34 - 30:53

Afzal Khan

Thank you, Chair. To what extent do you see the police as facilitators of protest and to what extent an obstacle?

And have you changed your protest approach in response to the changing restrictions?

30:53 - 33:54

Peter Leary

Well, I mean, as I sort of indicated in my previous answer, I mean, we obviously always make sure that we do inform the police. We discuss with the police ahead of our protests. We understand that they have a responsibility to facilitate protest, but also we want to because we're bringing large numbers of people. These are often very, very large events. They contain a wide range of people: disabled people, elderly people, people with children and young families who come on these marches.

And we want to make sure that they can do so safely and participate effectively in the aims of the protest, as well as, you know, the practical things. We want to make sure that the roads are closed so that we're not walking headlong into traffic. And for all of those reasons, it's, you know, we always seek to engage with the police.

I think that I would characterize the sort of approach of the police... I wouldn't characterize it as one in which they are seeking to facilitate us to exercise our rights. I would think they are seeking to use what powers are at their disposal to limit and curtail our rights to do that. That includes, you know, as I say, for example, preventing us for several years now from protesting from either marching to or from the BBC, somewhere we have wanted to be a part of one of our national demonstrations. From protesting at the Israeli embassy.

Sometimes imposing restrictions that make it very difficult to protest in a sort of normal or standard way at all.

I mean, one ironic example was the day that the Crime and Policing Bill, which contained a number of what we would regard as restrictive anti-protest clauses, was debated in Parliament, and we organized a protest outside, um, outside Parliament on the day. We discussed with the police, we discussed with them the location of the protest and where it should be sited, and with an hour to go, they, they imposed a restriction banning us from using megaphones, which megaphones have been a feature of protests and demonstrations, I'm sure since before I was born.

And, you know, what that makes it means it's very difficult to communicate with the people who have gathered. I mean, we did hold our rally, we had to shout, it gave us all a sore throat, but, but, but, you know, that sort of normal feature that you would expect that would enable you to communicate with people who have come together to, to, you know, both in order to get the message of your protest across, but also to, you know, for safety reasons, to tell people if you want them to move and that kind of thing, we were sort of banned from doing that at very short notice. So, certainly our feeling is isn't that the police have been seeking to facilitate us to make our protest, sort of the contrary, in fact, at many times we've felt that their approach has been like we're not really people going about our lawful business at all, we're people engaged in a sort of quasi-criminal activity by taking part in the protest and that protesters perhaps exist over here and the public exists over there and their role is to protect the public.

34:39 - 38:53

Liz Webster

Um, we in the beginning of the after the farm tax was brought in, there was efforts by other people in the farming community that wanted to go and block depots, supermarket depots.

And you know, going back 20 years ago, that would not have been illegal. And so I just used, I had the view that from our perspective, we wanted to run a PR campaign and we wanted to get positive, it was about getting positive press and to get people on our side. So I did everything that I could to stop that from happening, despite the fact that that probably would have got more attention because food would have been interrupted and people would have understood the impact of what the farm tax means to them personally. So were we able to do what we wanted to do? No.

But what we decided to do was to keep within the parameters of the law because in my view, the more that we try to push the law and put the police in the position where they're going to start being heavy-handed with us, that it would actually probably give more freedoms for the lawmakers to inflict more laws on protesters. So there were two things in my mind: A, getting through the message, which is about everyone's food, not just the farmers, but also about trying to show that, you know, protesting in this day and age isn't the same as it was when Emily Pankhurst strapped herself to the railings because we've got social media, we've got television, you know, 24/7. And I was very keen to try and get a positive campaign out to make sure that people heard the message and to do it as orderly as possible. Controlling people that are protesting with you is like herding cats, and that is difficult.

And I also respected the job that the police are trying to do. It's not their fault that the laws are coming through. I mean, maybe some of them agree with the laws, maybe some of them don't. We're all humans at the end of the day. And I did feel that we needed to try and get to a point where we're sort of saying, look, these things are happening to British farming, which means it's going to impact your food, which in fact impacts all of our human rights as well, access to food.

And to try and do that as positively as we can. But so that is how we decided to approach this situation with protesting.

And it's been more successful, I think, from from that point of view because we found a narrow way through it. And it is easier because it's we've we've used it was COVID that got us into the vehicles because we wouldn't have been allowed to do a physical protest in 2020, but we were allowed to, it was outside of the remits of the COVID laws, to do a moving vehicular protest. And then in doing so, it sort of gave us the opportunity to we've got big machines, that's fortunate, so we're we're able to be seen, which gives us it makes it look as if we're being treated differently, but we're not really. We're trying to do the same thing. We're trying to communicate, I suppose that's what protesting is, we're trying to communicate to the people to know what's going on in their country and what it means to them.

But there is an element of people wanting to express their frustration with whatever they're protesting about. And as organizers, I think that responsibility is enormous because you can't control everybody. And the law is quite frightening because I mean, I don't want to go to jail and I didn't want anyone else to go to jail and end up with a criminal record either. So it is, it is a big thing to do a big protest. It's a huge amount of responsibility.

38:53 - 39:03

Rahila Gupta

And just to add to what I said earlier, we're not primarily organizers of marches, we are participants. So I don't really have anything to communicate.

39:03 - 39:10

Alex Sobel

We'll now move to questions from Baroness Lane-Fox on police engagement and then understanding of protest law.

39:10 - 39:54

Martha Lane-Fox

Thank you. I mean, you've talked a bit about this already, so I don't want you to have to repeat answers. And I think we've all appreciated you have slightly different levels of direct engagement with liaison groups as part of the police and with the police directly in your case.

So I'm interested more in more solutions that you think to some of this stuff. You know, the starting point, I'm assuming for many of you, is a pretty low level of trust in some of the police liaison groups that you meet and how they're working with you. Maybe I'm wrong. Please correct me. I'm interested, firstly, if that's the case, and secondly, how you meet with them beforehand.

You've talked a little bit about that. What barriers there might be in overcoming that trust and what you might propose as a solution.

39:54 - 43:23

Peter Leary

Well, I would say we have a mixed experience of different police officers that we deal with. I would say that there is a sort of a lack of, you know, I mean, maybe this is the wrong way of viewing it, but for example, our marches have been a major issue of national controversy over the last number of years following various comments that have been made. The Chief Inspector of the Metropolitan Police has made numerous public comments about our marches, some of which we have, you know, rejected and objected to and so on, but has repeatedly refused to meet with the organisers of the marches. So I think from the top down there's a sort of, you know, there's that unwillingness to engage with political conversation about our marches, but not a willingness to engage with those responsible for organising the marches.

And I think that's often reflected in some of the operational police that we also deal with are often not willing to, you know, or, you know, sort of place conditions in terms of engagement. So, for example, we had a situation in May where we were, the police refused our route for our annual Nakba Day commemoration march. They proposed an alternative route. We had some concerns about it. There was a major right-wing, far-right we would say, demonstration taking place in London on the day in a context where some of those groups have previously tried to violently attack our march, most famously on the in November 2023.

We had concerns about the route.

We wanted to meet with them and the police took the position that they would only meet with us once we had agreed to the route that that they were proposing. So so they were sort of using refusing to engage in in dialogue with us unless we met certain conditions. We've had had similar experiences where right up to the week of a demonstration, the police have been threatening to or saying that they will impose conditions on our march, including the the formation point, which is obviously the most important thing that we have to be able to advertise in advance where people need to come in order to arrive, but but refusing to tell us what those conditions might be and instead sort of saying, "Well, can you, you know, come up with a, you know, an alternative?" and and so on.

So so there, you know, there there has been an approach that, um, my experience is that I think that what the law, um, has given to the police is are are a lot of powers, um, to to impose conditions, often at very short notice, so they're not subject and can't be subject to any legal scrutiny or we would have no, um, opportunity to to seek any legal redress given the the timescales involved. Um, and and that creates a disincentive for the police to engage in any kind of good faith in in discussion with protest organizers because they know that they can ultimately just impose conditions and, um, there's very little that we can do about it.

43:23 - 43:28

Martha Lane-Fox

So would more con- I'm assuming therefore that more communication is what you would suggest would be the most important?

43:28 - 43:40

Peter Leary

Yes, but I think it comes back to the the issue that that you know greater pressure on the police to recognize their responsibility to facilitate demonstration which I don't think they quite appreciate at this moment in time.

43:40 - 44:27

Alex Sobel

Thank you. The march you raised on that day march, I was going to ask later on but I'll I'll ask now. I remember very well the difficulties because the Tommy Robinson march on the same day and the pressures that put on your organization. Um and you mentioned that your route was in part determined by the fact that that Tommy Robinson had decided to have his um whatever you want to call it event the same day. Um there was contention within the Jewish community about the route of the march because of its proximity to Westminster synagogue.

Was that route decision due to the Tommy Robinson event, and would you normally choose not to march close to a synagogue or place of worship?

44:27 - 46:26

Peter Leary

Well, it's certainly absolutely no intention of ours to march close to or past or target any place of worship in any way, so that's not sort of part of our intention. Now, it is challenging. There are very, I mean, sometimes what the Metropolitan Police determine as near to or in the vicinity of is quite expansive. So I've also mentioned, for example, the BBC, we've been prevented from marching there owing to a synagogue several streets away.

The occasion I was just referring to when we were, when the police refused to tell us what conditions they were going to impose with just days to go, relates to Hyde Park, a long-standing historic site of protest and assembly and so on. That relates to, related to, we didn't know at the time, but it turned out related to a synagogue I think about 12 minutes' walk away. So the challenge is that there are very few places in any town or city, and certainly not in central London, that aren't within those kinds of distances of a place of worship of one kind or another. So I think, you know, these are quite large distances that far beyond, for example, the exclusion areas that in my view quite rightly are imposed around abortion clinics, for example, to protect those using those services, or far beyond the sort of protection that's given to accommodation for asylum seekers, to give another example, where there are very threatening protests often happening right outside.

So, certainly, the, you know, it is difficult. The issue there, the route, as I say, was imposed on us, so it wasn't, you know, it wasn't particularly a route of our choosing. But there are challenges in terms of organizing protests in that sense.

46:26 - 46:44

Alex Sobel

I don't want to belabor this too much, but would it be helpful if an exclusion zone was closely codified in law, so it was clear what the police could ask and what you would have to adhere to in your planning?

46:43 - 48:35

Peter Leary

Well, as I say, I certainly, you know, we would obviously reject any suggestion that our marches in any way represent a threat to people who are wishing to use their place of worship, including people who are wishing to visit synagogues. And would point to the fact that the very clear messaging from our marches in terms of opposition to anti-Semitism alongside all other forms of racism, Islamophobia, anti-Palestinian racism, and the fact that large numbers of Jewish people participate in the marches, both as many of them are marching as part of an organized Jewish bloc, as platform speakers in all of the marches, including often Holocaust survivors speaking at the demonstrations. But I certainly think that that lack of clarity and the discretion that is given to the police leads both amongst march organizers, but I think also amongst the public, to a false impression often.

So, for example, Mark Rowley has said that when we march, we try to march near a synagogue. But he means twelve minutes' walk away, whereas I think when that often gets interpreted, it means past the very door or on the doorstep, and that undoubtedly will create a false perception and may indeed create fear in certain communities about what our intentions and the intentions of the marches are.

So I think, yes, I mean, some sort of some clarity on that would enable people to understand what is and isn't happening in relation to these marches, for one thing, but also to would help us as march organizers to facilitate that.

48:35 - 48:46

Martha Lane-Fox

And same question to you in terms of your engagement with the police liaison and your experiences of that and how you might suggest there could be issues made better.

48:46 - 51:12

Liz Webster

Yeah, I mean, I'd never arranged a protest until, you know, 2019 was the first time when we brought sheep to London and People's Vote organized all of that. So it was quite a big step to first do it. I kind of it was quite, you know, daunting, I suppose. And it, you know, you're not quite sure what's expected of you in London. But once you've actually once I breached that barrier and made connections with certain people in the Met, it got a lot easier.

So the communication channels opened, I got to know them, they got to know me, and we were able to have a dialogue and sort of say, can we do a protest next week? And they'd say, actually that's a bad day Liz because so-and-so, you know, is coming over and we've got this going on. And so that was, you know, that was, that was fine. You know, okay, it was inconvenient perhaps one day we would have wanted to do something, but I understood that their resources are really stretched. And so I took the, I took the view that, and I still take the view, that I want the protest to be positive, not negative.

And so I recognize that we have to work with them. So I suppose if there's more communication around that, that when you're arranging a, I think, I mean what I would say to somebody who's organizing a protest in London is, and ask them, what do you want to achieve?

Are you doing it because you just want to go and feel and, you know, and let off steam? Or are you doing it because you're communicating and trying to further that so that Parliament acts, you know, about the issue that you're upset about? And that was the view that I took. But I am, as a citizen, I am concerned about the creeping laws which are restricting us to do these things.

Because I honestly can say I never want to be arrested and have a criminal record and I wouldn't want to be responsible for anyone else doing that either. And I'm I am acutely aware of the fact that those laws have become more illiberal and I'm also aware that what happened in Hong Kong and how that slippery route continues. So I didn't want to also be responsible for provoking that and shutting down protest even further, which is a fundamental human right.

51:12 - 51:24

Martha Lane-Fox

Thank you. Rahila, I know you said you don't directly liaise with the police around protests, but do you have any reflections taking part in so many of them and any particular suggestions about how trust issues could be overcome?

51:24 - 55:31

Rahila Gupta

Okay. So the first thing I would say is that I take your point completely about the dangers of getting a criminal record as a citizen, but what if your right to protest and anything that you do on that protest actually takes away your ability to continue to live in this country, which is actually the people that we deal with because every single not every single, but a lot of the women, both workers and the women that we deal with, their right to remain in this country is affected by the immigration rules.

And I think that is, it puts us in a completely different situation from the ordinary citizen who rightly fears the policing of protests and fears arrest. And I just, because the immigration rules are quite complex, I just want to refer to my notes so I don't get it wrong. So I think one of the big issues is this proposal of the earned settlement route.

And I think that that is within your, these are still proposals, and this is within your remit as lawmakers to actually reverse them, because there is a good character test which has direct impact on this issue about participation in protest. And so this earned settlement route, which Andy Burnham has put his, has seems to be supporting, it's through economic contribution, high earnings, and good character. And that's the, one of the big issues in relation to this. So your, previously you were, had an automatic right to permanent residence after a period of five years. Now the length of time can increase for anywhere between 10 to 20 years.

So this intersection of the good character test and these expanding protest laws, they carry significant human rights implications for non-citizens in the UK.

So I think these policies alter how fundamental rights are exercised. And any of the serious disruption offenses that are being, are in the law at the moment, locking on, blocking the highway, they can all carry prison sentences of up to 12 months. There is a persistent offender clause which can catch anyone who is engaged repeatedly in acts of civil disobedience. And those can receive cautions or there are minor convictions. And if there are three occasions or you accept a conditional caution to avoid court, it could affect your ability to remain in this country.

So that is a really big problem for us. The other issue, and this was in section 22 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, it gave the police and the CPS the power to issue conditional cautions to foreign nationals.

They were known as undocumented migrants at that point. The new law in 2026 has expanded that to all foreign nationals who hold limited or valid, they're valid visas, but limited, in order to enter and remain in the UK. And some of the categories that affect us, and they affect us because we have workers drawn from these categories, are skilled workers on employment visas. There are individuals on family visas, there are international students, and then of course there are recognized refugees or victims of human trafficking. So many of our workers and women fall into one of these categories.

So what, and we're not talking about a small number of people, these numbers are sizeable. People who are subject to the no recourse to public funds are number somewhere around four million people. And this, these are only going to grow with the EU settlement and then also with the refugees. All of this actually has a huge impact on our ability to participate in protest.

55:31 - 56:04

Martha Lane-Fox

Thank you. And I think we've got the sense of what you might answer for the next question, but it's just to kind of double down a bit more on the how you see the changes that have been made to the law on public order and protest in recent years. Overall, do you think these changes have made it more or less clear when protest becomes unlawful and when police interference is justified? So it's a broad question, Peter, I know you've answered some of that, but is there anything you'd like to add about the expansion of the law?

56:04 - 58:10

Peter Leary

Yeah, I mean, I think that, you know, as I've probably indicated, it's become much more difficult for us. I think that the police have a lot more powers to prevent protest, effectively prevent protest by imposing conditions on it that make it difficult, if not impossible, to organize a protest. We've had experiences where, for example, we wanted to protest at the Israeli embassy in response to the passing of a death penalty law that applies only and exclusively to Palestinians, whether in the occupied Palestinian territory or Palestinians with Israeli citizenship.

We wanted clearly the target of that of such a protest is the Israeli embassy that the the government is responsible. The police at about an hour's notice imposed conditions on us to move us to Downing Street. Which, you know, not only I mean we did go ahead with it, but it but it but effectively we're not protesting against the the body that we wish to be, you know, we're not able because they've they've got those powers to to sort of uh you know, to move us. I mentioned the occasion which was I did feel extremely ironic when we were had a protest in response to the crime and policing bill and the anti-protest clauses in that and we were banned from using megaphones and we had to shout.

We were banned on the day that the famine was officially declared in Gaza from banging pots and pans at a protest. We were banned from using megaphones or amplified noise on the day when the President of Israel visited Britain and we wished to protest in response to that. So I think that this makes protests, it silences them, makes them much less effectual, much harder to organise protests, to even communicate with people where the location of a protest is going to be.

58:10 - 58:23

Martha Lane-Fox

Can I just ask you a supplementary and ask all of you in advance, what would you propose to change? What would be your biggest ask of a change in legislation?

58:24 - 59:51

Peter Leary

Where to begin? You know, I mean, you know, I think there are many, many things and it's very hard to prioritize them. I mean, I think that the proscription of Palestine Action has created a hugely chilling climate for anyone wishing to engage in protest or express themselves at all in this country. I think it is absolutely shocking the consequences that we have seen from that in terms of huge numbers of people, often elderly people, disabled people being arrested simply for holding signs. And I don't think that the implications of that simply stop at those protests.

I think they send out a clear message about what the attitude of the police and the government in this country is to freedom of speech and to freedom of expression.

So even though that's not a protest that I'm involved in myself or that we're involved in, I think that would be one thing. But I think there is so much that we would like to, you know, I mean, you know, in terms of the, you know, the charges that are being pursued against people for taking part in protests of a variety of kinds, but also the, you know, there has been just a wave of, you know, anti-protest laws. I mean, perhaps I'd go chronologically and start with the Crime and Policing Bill and go back to the Police, Crime and Courts Bill and work backwards that way, but I just think there's been so much that needs to be looked at and addressed.

59:51 - 01:00:11

Martha Lane-Fox

Right, thank you. And can I ask reflections on the, whether you think clarity has been provided by the recent legislative changes? And then the same question again, what would you suggest as changes in a, realize in a complex landscape?

01:00:11 - 01:02:03

Liz Webster

Um, I think the sort of knee-jerk reaction to keep legislating in response to protest, which is happening because of economic changes and, you know, which are also linked to immigration and changes over the last, particularly over the last 10 to 15 years, are just, it's just the wrong thing. And I think it also makes the police's job probably a lot harder because they have to tick boxes as well in all of this. So I think, you know, I think that the, I'm scared of it becoming an illiberal police state. That is not a country I want to live in, and it does feel that we're getting closer, edging closer to that.

And it does mean that you're less likely to want to even get involved in protest or certainly managing it because the responsibility sits with you. And that's telling you that that's fundamentally wrong if you believe in human rights. So I don't think that more legislation is the answer. I think that probably a pulling back from that, but also that involves properly funding our police who are, I know, overstretched to manage these different demonstrations. And so you've got the austerity which has made everything worse as well.

So politically, you've asked me a very difficult question and yeah, there's a lot that needs to be looked at. So it's, we're not in a good situation that we have got this going on.

And certainly with Palestine Action, that the police's resources are having to arrest people for holding a sign is ludicrous. Thank you.

01:02:04 - 01:04:03

Rahila Gupta

Well, I have to echo everything that has been said before me. And I really do think that we should be looking at repealing a number of these laws. Certainly the serious disruption prevention orders, I think should be repealed. I think the whole thing around megaphones and excessive noise, that's the joy of protest. We go, we sing, we chant, we dance, we have, we play drums.

You know, this is part of the reason that people come out on the streets.

And to legislate against that, to criminalize that, I think, you know, really puts Britain in some category like India, actually, because India is, you know, really coming down very hard on public demonstrations. So I would repeat all of those things. We need to go back to a, I don't even know when I would date it, but certainly there have been four new laws in the last five years. And I think that a lot of them have some of these draconian elements to it. And I was listening to the police give evidence here, and I think the issue was not so much of clarity, but plethora of laws.

They didn't know which law to use to do what. And I'm not sure that actually the police are not happy with the situation. My understanding is that they have got what they have asked for and what they have wanted and they've been lobbying for.

So I think we're in a situation where the police have got too many powers and there's too much legislative backing. And to make the point about living in a democracy, I mean, this is your mailbag come to life. You know, this is your mailbag personified, that there are people who are going out on the streets to tell you what's going wrong with their lives, you know, that the status quo has become unbearable for them. And so why do we fear it? Why do we not welcome and facilitate it rather than see it as a problem to be policed?

01:04:03 - 01:04:07

Speaker 16

So that would be my view on that.

01:04:07 - 01:04:09

Speaker 15

Baroness Chakrabarti.

01:04:09 - 01:06:59

Shami Chakrabarti

Thank you, Chair.

Um, it's always a privilege to sit on this committee, but I have to say that listening to these witnesses is, um, and their gentle, reasoned engagement has been really, really wonderful in recent minutes. Um, our three witnesses are very much steeped in the law and the organizing around protest, but there'll be many others in your communities, in your campaigns, who are not so much, and who will listen to today's evidence and be concerned about the potential cost of participating in protest. So, and by the way, I declare an interest, Chair, as I'm teaching an undergraduate law course at the LSE this term that includes the law of protest, so I'm declaring that interest.

Put that on the record. With all the frenetic activity, we had the Public Order Act 1986 and there wasn't that much frenetic activity after that, and then in recent years, lots of frenetic legislative activity. My question is now, you have a friend, you have a supporter, sort of putting their toe into the water of your campaign. We have three different campaigns. And they say, I really care about this cause and I really want to, I really want to be heard, but I'm really nervous.

I'm really nervous about consequences.

Now, I think we've heard from Southall Black Sisters about the particular consequences for non-citizens. But so maybe firstly to the other two, what do you actually say in friendship and solidarity to them about whether it's a good idea to be in Parliament Square, be outside an embassy when they're particularly nervous? And they could be nervous for any number of reasons. And Liz was very honest, I think, and articulate about not wanting to be arrested, not wanting to be prosecuted. People have families, people have livelihoods.

They want to be heard. What would you honestly say to them now in Britain 2024 about how comfortable, you know, as a good friend actually, as a good friend, what would you say to them about whether that's a good idea or not and what they might face?

01:06:59 - 01:09:51

Peter Leary

I think it's difficult. And I think that there are, you know, it is something we hear all the time. People, I mean, including people who are, you know, perhaps they're on a student visa or they're, you know, they've concerns around immigration. People who've got concerns about their job. A colleague was telling me about someone saying I'd really like to go on the marches but I'm a teaching assistant and I'm worried about my job.

So these are concerns.

And the truth is that we can't guarantee, if you go on a protest, you can't guarantee that people won't face arrest, potentially through no fault of their own. And I think earlier I made the point about people being arrested for finding themselves on the wrong side of the road in Whitehall when the conditions said they had to be on one side and they were on the other side. Now, in that case, I think there was no further action taken, but it's nevertheless a distressing sort of experience for people and there'd be people who don't want to take that risk. At the same time, I obviously encourage people to come on the protests. It's my job to do so.

I think it is important both in terms of the issue that we're protesting about. And you know, we've all seen the horrors in Gaza over the past three years and the need to, why we have felt it's so important to protest, to keep protesting, to maintain, you know, continue to come out into the streets.

We've now seen obviously some shift in government policy as a consequence of of maintaining that persistent campaigning and those persistent protests. Nowhere near as far as we would like it to go but but nevertheless we've had that real the you know the real impact. I also think it is important to to uphold our our democratic rights. I don't think they they you know the freedoms we have have come about through people exercising through people taking to the streets in protest by people campaigning for the right to vote but also for you know rights to strike and to take all all these kinds of actions and exercising those rights as well. I think that that that's how how they are preserved.

So I think we we do have that responsibility almost to to to continue to defend, to exercise, to deploy our our democratic rights or or we will lose them. But I can understand on an individual level why some people don't wish to do that, and particularly those people who for various reasons are more likely than others to be arrested or will face more severe consequences than others if if they should find themselves in that situation. I think it's it's a very challenging situation.

01:09:52 - 01:11:16

Liz Webster

If somebody, well, I mean look, when we, when the farm tax first came in and we did the first big demonstration, a gentleman rang me from Tetbury who is in his 80s. And he was so upset by that, but he drove his tractor all the way from Tetbury to here because he didn't have time to do any tax planning and it was, you know, the responsibility or the emotional reality of needing to say to Westminster and to MPs what on earth you're doing to us is immense when that reaction is needed. So I would say when something happens which is a shock or whatever and you have a feeling that you want to go and do something and exercise your right, that you should be able to do that fairly freely. To organize it, as I've said, is an enormous responsibility in London. I mean, it's actually because we've done demonstrations across the country in other towns, which is really very different.

London, busy place, it's very different. So if someone said, "I want to organize a protest, Liz, what do you think?" I would sort of say, it's hugely complicated. It's a lot of responsibility, liability, and all the rest of it. And so it's not for the faint-hearted.

01:10:56 - 01:10:56

Speaker 19

It's very easy.

01:11:16 - 01:12:59

Liz Webster

It's a huge thing to run a protest. And it shouldn't be, the responsibility shouldn't be so great on so few to actually have the, because you don't get heard. I mean, we're lucky in the farming community to be able, a few people are seen because we've got big machines. And so we're able to make a big message and get seen. And I recognize the disparity with this protest and other protests, that when you're only, and I mean, I attended a lot of the pro-EU marches, millions of people are not seen as much as thousands of tractors.

And so we were able to get our message out more more clearly. And we were less as vehicles were actually the law doesn't bite on us as much as it does on physical protests, which is another thing to think about. But it's an expression and it's a communication. And maybe if Parliament had more access to petitions that had more bite. In the European Union, they do have citizenship petitions that when they reach a certain level, they can actually bring in legislation rather than just saying, oh, you go to a back committee, you express yourself and then it's closed.

Because that's another thing that leads to more protests. So if you want to reduce the protests, actually you need to open these bigger groups more access to the parliamentarians who perhaps can find a better way of easing pressure on society. I mean, that would be another thing that I would say, because I do feel sorry for the police because I know their resources are very limited.

01:12:59 - 01:14:38

Shami Chakrabarti

Just on that one, one final supplementary if I may, Chair. You've all spoken, you represent organized protest groups in a way, which isn't the whole story about protest, because a protest could be about an individual who gets upset with what's happening in their community and they don't necessarily have the access to the negotiations that you've described.

There is a theory, and there's academic scholarship on this, there's a theory that parliamentarians inherently believe that the only legitimate sort of political democratic expression is through this place. Now I say this at risk of upsetting, and I've already got a look from someone who I won't name, a colleague, but there is an, there is a, there is a theory that parliamentarians historically think that, you know, democracy is about, you know, you have your election every four or five years and then, and then parliamentarians carry the torch of democracy and they have the rigorous debates and everyone should just sort of quieten down and wait for the, wait for the next election.

So you've all spoken about your engagement with the police, but what about your engagement with parliamentarians? How sensitive do you think parliamentarians are to your feelings about street protest in between elections?

01:14:38 - 01:16:00

Rahila Gupta

I just want to reiterate the point I made earlier that the street protest is your mailbag on the streets that you can and I believe that parliamentarians are very dedicated to their mailbags because every point that they raise in Parliament is supposedly arising from the strength of feeling of their constituents.

So here you have the strength of feeling of your constituents on the street, especially at a time when we tend to be rather dismissive of people who, you know, sign petitions at the click of a mouse and we talk about, you know, keyboard warriors. So if people then come out on the street, it's actually a strength of feeling that in all weathers you are dragging your sorry body out of your home, you know, in order to make a point. And the fear, in fact, that parliamentarians won't hear it, because in the past we used to feel that there was, I mean, that's a question that needs to be debated. We still hope that, you know, our voices are heard, that the amount of disruption we create sends a message to Parliament: here are a large number of people who are very upset by this, that or the other and you need to act on it.

So I would have hoped that actually this would not fall on deaf ears.

01:16:00 - 01:19:15

Peter Leary

Thanks. I mean, I have heard that sentiment, ironically sometimes from members of the House of Lords who aren't elected, but say that, you know, well, there are avenues for people to express themselves democratically. And of course the irony of that is that the only reason why most of us have the right to vote for at least some of the people who sit in here is because people went out into the street and protested at a time, protested in fact in successive waves of protests to expand the vote, first amongst men and then to women and so on. So I think that the democratic system, however imperfect that exists, is in many ways a result, a product of protest, rather than that, you know, protest is something that is indulged by or within a democratic system.

And of course we all know that the, yes we do have a vote, but the electoral system is imperfect. We vote for political parties, we vote for MPs who stand on a wide range of manifestos, but that doesn't mean that we don't have an issue or an issue doesn't arise where that hasn't been reflected in when we went to the polls or isn't reflected necessarily in the manifesto. Or I might support the Labour Party but disagree with it about Palestine. How do I then vote? Do I vote for some other party or what do I do in those sort of situations?

So I think that our involvement in those democratic processes is vitally important.

And and I think that what we have seen over the past few years is a good example of it. But you know, we have brought about through protest significant, I would say partial, but significant shift in government policy from where we were when we started the recent cycle of protests where, you know, the major parties were instructing their MPs to vote against the motion simply calling for a ceasefire to one where we are now seeing the imposition of sanctions against illegal Israeli settlements in the illegally occupied Palestinian territory. So so that I think is a consequence of protest.

And I think one of the worrying things, particularly worrying things for us is the laws around cumulative disruption, the cumulative disruption, because it's actually been the persistence of those protests that has brought about that really significant, I think, albeit limited, political shift. If I could just very quickly, if it's just something I should have said before on your previous question about what I would say to people who are afraid to protest, because I do think it's important that we don't contribute to the chilling effect. Because actually, one of the things is, difficult as it can be as an organizer to organize a protest, on our protests certainly, arrest rates are very low. They're lower than the arrest rates at football matches or music festivals, other large engagements. What it often is, is that chilling effect, it's the fear of it, the conditions that are being imposed creates this sense of menace that for many people means that they're afraid to take part in that protest rather than they would really be arrested.

01:19:15 - 01:19:54

Liz Webster

Specifically for MPs, interestingly, the journey was that in the early days when I said we first started, we actually had Labour MPs and Lib Dem MPs supporting our protests.

And then we had a change of government. And so now the, before the Conservative MPs weren't, when they were in government, they didn't want to stand with the farming protests. And now the inverse has happened. The Conservatives are wanting to stand with the farmers and some Labour MPs are supportive or they feel awkward about it. So it is political, yes.

01:19:54 - 01:20:00

Alex Sobel

Interesting. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, let's move on to Lord Rooke.

01:20:00 - 01:21:00

Rooke

Thank you. Thank you very much. Um, Rahila, I'm very glad you're here.

I was doing an event with a colleague from the Commons last week and she told the most amazing story about how your organisation had helped her to right injustices in her own life and in the life of her family. And so it's a real privilege to be asking questions on this important issue of all of you today, but I'm really glad you're here. So I'm going to address this firstly to you. Obviously in 2011, powers were amended to impose conditions to provide more detail on what was provided, am I right, on kind of serious protest. And that was to include this idea of excessive noise.

So I'm interested from all three, we've heard a bit from Peter around the sort of loud hailers and the amplifiers and kind of things, the megaphones, which, you know, are there examples by which your activities have been changed by that imposition of rules around excessive noise?

01:21:00 - 01:21:02

Speaker 23

And I'll start with you, Rahila.

01:21:02 - 01:21:45

Rahila Gupta

The very short answer to that is actually no, because we continue to bring our megaphones along and our drums and we sing and we continue to do all of that. But it's it's this chilling effect that we've all been talking about. At which point will the police intervene? At which point will they stop us? And that's the fear.

And and I think we're going to be talking about face coverings later on, so that's part of that, I would like to talk about that in particular. But yes, I think, you know, I think megaphones is really quite a ridiculous issue that they should be thinking of criminalising.

01:21:45 - 01:21:48

Speaker 22

Liz, for you, how how's this affected?

01:21:48 - 01:21:51

Speaker 24

Um, yeah, I mean, look, probably we probably had the noisiest protest.

01:21:51 - 01:23:08

Liz Webster

I'm sure you all remember it. We did try again, the police asked us not to blow the horns particularly around Parliament Square. We can't control everyone. But it's it's their expression. And so yes, it's inconvenient for you, I know, and I certainly even know the Sky News studio found it a bit annoying as well, but it's funny.

And it's it should be it's something that we're proud of as a culture, that we can go and express ourselves. And there is definitely with protest, there is an element of theater to it. And that is wrapped up in the whole thing, which is so fundamental. That perhaps the police forget about because it's their day in, day out, we've got to do this and as I've said, I've I've been into their control rooms, I've seen how overstretched they are.

So, you know, it's a delicate balance. And so, you know, I think it's really important to try and maintain our culture, which is around noise and expression and theatre and, yeah, and being extrovert, because we are quite extrovert. And why would we want to stop that?

01:23:08 - 01:23:29

Rooke

Intrigued on that one, because we've all been in our offices either humming along with the horns of the tractors or maybe shouting at them. What have there, I mean, clearly as you say, it's difficult for you to control people doing or not doing that.

What has been the nature of your interactions with the police when that has happened even though you've been trying to make sure it didn't happen?

01:23:29 - 01:25:12

Liz Webster

So when we did the first one in 2020, as I said it was the COVID restrictions and they were really heavy-handed with us and they did say we would arrest you if you blow the horns. And and they got better with us because as we got bigger, it was it was probably they realized that it was a an ask too far and and that it sort of became and the media were more the media were more focused on us because we were bigger as well so it was we were we were only sort of 25 tractors the first time. So it was different and it was a different time with the COVID restrictions.

I mean it was ridiculous really because it was really very empty outside because of the COVID restrictions. But it was a new, I think it was a new experience for them and they were unsure. And again there'd been terrorism in Parliament and they were worried about trailers with what would be in it. And so I, as I said, I tried my best to work with the police to make them understand that it was an expression that we needed to do to try and get Parliament to act, which looks like a niche issue because it's just farmers, but it isn't, it is everybody's food. And that is, that's what we were trying to communicate rather than completely just being about I'm personally upset about this.

I was always as in, I mean I've got a marketing background which probably changes it a little bit, as in I want all of you out here in Britain to know that there's massive changes on your food and that's going to impact all of us. So that's where I, you know, where we took it from.

01:25:12 - 01:25:18

Rooke

And to your knowledge there's not been an arrest as a result of someone playing the theme tune from the Dukes of Hazzard on their tractor?

No.

01:25:18 - 01:25:22

Speaker 25

Okay. Peter, I mean you shared some of this earlier, is there anything else you need to add just on this?

01:25:22 - 01:26:29

Peter Leary

I mean I think I've probably said most of it. I mean I'd repeat the example of the day that famine was officially declared in Gaza, I think it was the 22nd of August 2025, and we were, it was a Friday evening, it was the start of a bank holiday weekend, we were proposing to protest banging pots and pans for an hour, 6 o'clock in the evening. Now that would have made noise and people would have heard it, but within what I would regard as a reasonable amount of noise and time of the day and all the rest of it for an appropriate protest. And the police used the powers to ban us from doing that.

Similarly, when the President of Israel visited and we were banned from using megaphones. I mean, I think, you know, it just sort of made it very difficult again, an evening protest that was sort of dark, we wanted to be able to communicate with people who are in the crowd and and it was um it was impossible for us to do so. So that's, you know, what is excessive, I suppose.

01:26:29 - 01:26:48

Alex Sobel

Thank you. We now move on to questions from Ewan Steinbank on new powers in legislation, over to you Ewan.

01:26:48 - 01:27:36

Speaker 26

Um, yes, protests can be intimidating.

They obviously can have a significant effect on people who live or work or worship nearby. In 2026, this year, the Crime and Policing Act was passed, which imposed, provided powers to the police to impose conditions in relation to access in relation to places of worship and required the police to consider and to take into account the cumulative disruption of protests. To what extent have these changes impacted on your protests and what effect might they have in the future? It's obviously a fairly new piece of legislation. I think Mr. Leary, you probably have the most direct experience of this.

01:27:36 - 01:29:57

Peter Leary

Well, I think, I mean, I have commented a little bit on in relation to the places of worship in response to the previous question and I can come back to that if you'd like.

But just on the cumulative impact, I think that is one that we find deeply concerning. It allows the police to impose restrictions based on the impact of past or future protests in a particular area. The area is sort of ill-defined. It could be, for example, the whole of central London, could be an entire town or city. There's no sort of clarity in relation to that in the law.

And in fact, some of the conversations we've had with the police suggest that they do think about it in that way. Oh, you had a previous protest in another route in London and you've now got a protest on this route in London. There's a cumulative impact of all of these.

It's obvious that certain sites are are the frequent location of protests: Trafalgar Square, Parliament Square, city centers. Most most town centers have a place where where protest happens in in the center of the town. It also doesn't matter whether the protests are the for the same purpose or involve the same people. So, for example, the police could impose a restriction on one of our marches on the grounds that a farmers' protest took place in the same location the the the previous week or, you know, on a previous occasion.

They could ban and restrict a Pride parade on the grounds that a far-right protest took place the previous week or is planned for for for the next week in in the same location. So I think this is deeply concerning in terms of its, you know, its potential impact, how it could be used by this or any future government to effectively make make protests extremely difficult to organize, mass protests in any sort of city center, town or city. And I think what would be lost as a result of that, I mean, even if you even if we're only thinking about protests that are organized by the same people or for the same cause. I mean, we were talking about the campaigns for democracy, the the the suffrage protests went over more than a decade it took for them to achieve their goals. The protests against apartheid South Africa took decades of repeated protests.

01:29:57 - 01:30:08

Speaker 26

And sir, can I bring you back to the 2026 Act, though? In your experience, have the police used the powers in that very latest piece of legislation in relation to cumulative disruption in relation to your protests?

01:30:08 - 01:30:29

Peter Leary

Well, the police were already referring to cumulative disruption prior to the passage of the Act on the grounds that they said nothing in law forbade them from taking into account cumulative disruption. The change in law was that it would require them to do so. So they've already been using that as a requirement prior to the passage of the Act.

01:30:29 - 01:30:34

Speaker 27

And have you changed many behaviors as a result of these observations?

01:30:34 - 01:30:46

Peter Leary

Well, they have imposed conditions on us on the basis of what they regard as the cumulative impact, which has changed our behavior insofar as it has prevented us from marching where we wanted to march.

01:30:46 - 01:30:51

Speaker 26

What does the effect of that been on your protests?

01:30:51 - 01:31:39

Peter Leary

Well, for example, I mean, cumulative disruption has been used to justify banning our marches going to the BBC, for example.

So we haven't made, you know, that's something that we would very much wanted to do. There's a very strong feeling amongst a lot of people that the BBC's coverage of Gaza has been inadequate and one-sided. And many people wanted to make a, who are our supporters and amongst our wider sort of coalition and the constituencies we represent, wanted to protest there. We haven't been able to do that, have one of our marches either assemble there or end there now for I think over two years as a consequence of the police using cumulative disruption as a grounds for imposing conditions to prevent us from doing so.

01:31:40 - 01:31:47

Speaker 26

When you're planning your protests, do you ever consider the impact on people who live or work or worship nearby the route?

01:31:47 - 01:33:04

Peter Leary

Well yeah, I mean that, you know, one of that's one of the things that we would want, one of the reasons why we would want to, particularly at the at the very height of the bombing of Gaza when we were having quite a lot of protests, that you know, that this was a we were being confronted every day with the sort of horrors that I'm sure you've all witnessed, we were we were maybe marching once a month and so on. We wanted to make sure that we were varying our routes through through, you know, through different different parts of London, for example. And so, you know, we we tried to take different routes. One of the things that the police did was was to impose restrictions which had the effect of limiting us to fewer and fewer routes.

And it sort of feels like this awful catch-22, if you like, where the police are using conditions to limit us to fewer and fewer routes for our marches, and then that builds the case, I guess, that you could argue that we're having a cumulative impact in marching in those areas. So that sort of feels to us like a kind of a vicious circle and a trap that makes it very difficult, increasingly difficult for us to organize in that way.

01:33:04 - 01:33:12

Speaker 28

Thank you. Ms. Webster, do you have any thoughts on this topic? Have you had any issues with the police mentioning cumulative disruption in relation to your demonstrations?

01:33:13 - 01:33:52

Rahila Gupta

I just want to make a small observation, and that is that I don't think the farmers' march would be rerouted because it went too close to a place of worship, but the Palestinian march would be.

And I think that that assumption, because I have been on those marches and there's never been any sense of antisemitism or anything that others would fear, would necessarily fear, unless you politicize the issue. So it's interesting that, you know, which marches would be routed where in itself reflects a certain degree of prejudice and assumptions from the police.

01:33:52 - 01:34:01

Speaker 29

I know that the question of antisemitism arising at those marches is coming up later in the questions. Okay. Thank you. I'll next move to you on the last supplementary on this and the next question.

01:34:01 - 01:35:26

Speaker 30

Just a very short supplementary, and it is on the point of the principle of cumulative disruption, but also the use of exclusion zones.

I'm not sure this will be for you, Liz, because to the best of my knowledge there hasn't been any counter-protesters to Save British Farming during your protest in London especially. I've had, and you referred to this really early on, asylum protests in my patch, and something that I've noted in terms of opinions on how we should regulate protest in the country is that it is becoming, coming in my mailbag in a greater proportion from those actually participating in the protest by using examples of the conduct of the counter-protesters or the protesters, essentially just talking about the conduct of the other side and saying we need to do something about that. So when we talk about the boundaries of how cumulative disruption has been applied and the impact and some of the vagaries that I do sort of share your concern about in law, is there a concept of cumulative disruption that should be kept in law to address, I think, the impact it can have on distinct communities, or should we be addressing this more through the use of exclusion zones?

Because we don't have cumulative disruption, I think, in Scotland. I do think the First Minister is certainly lying in wait to see how it pans out before deciding how he goes in this direction. But we do use exclusion zones and have legislated for things like abortion clinics in the past. Do you see that as the better way to address, I think, the legitimate concern the public do have about the conduct of protests in the same area over and over again?

01:35:26 - 01:37:28

Peter Leary

I mean, I think that there are certainly, I mean, you know, I think that it's in my view perfectly justified that there are exclusion zones that allow people to access the services in abortion clinics, for example, and that they aren't disrupted from doing so. I'm not sure whether that's a cumulative issue or not, because if you're somebody who needs those services and you may need them only once and you go in and there's someone who's preventing you or a protest that's preventing you from doing so, you should be able to access those services.

So I don't know whether cumulative disruption is the, is the means by which to do that. But I think it's sort of, it's interesting the question around the counter-protests and that you raise, because I think one of the contradictions that we have found is that while we have been prevented from protesting at sites where we would wish to protest, I mentioned the Israeli embassy, the BBC, for example, the police then are also always telling us that the counter-protests have a right to be within sight and sound of our protests. And, you know, yes, we also are some of those people who complain about the behavior of the counter-protests because they have subjected people to racist and sexist abuse, rape threats, death threats, and so on in terms of the counter-protests. And of course, the far-right counter-protests have on occasions violently attempted to violently attack the marches.

So that, you know, that is a concern. The police seem to take a different view to that than they do to the protests in terms of where we have a right to be or to protest against. But they certainly don't. So yes, so that's, but whether cumulative, I don't, it doesn't seem to me that cumulative disruption, and certainly not as it's framed in the existing legislation, offers anything positive. I think it really is an alarming encroachment on the right to protest.

01:37:28 - 01:37:39

Rahila Gupta

Well, just a broader sort of political point really, and that is that cumulative protests would not be necessary if it were not for the failure of Parliament to listen to the demands that people are making.

01:37:39 - 01:37:45

Speaker 31

So we're looking at the symptom rather than the cause.

01:37:45 - 01:38:03

Speaker 30

So I'm just going to move on to the eighth question, which is in relation to the new offences, the 2022 Act. Since 2022, a number of new offences have been created, such as locking on and interfering with key national infrastructure. Have these new offences affected your protests? Perhaps start with Peter.

01:38:03 - 01:38:56

Peter Leary

No. I mean, what I would say though, I suppose, you know, the type of protest that we organise aren't direct action type protests, so it's not something that has impacted on or affected us directly.

But I do think that it is part of a wider climate that, in terms of the message it sends out, which I've already alluded to, the proscription of Palestine Action as terrorists, for example, that certain types of protest might be branded in that extreme way. And then you have other types of protest being subjected to further legal restrictions. I think that it creates an atmosphere around protest that it's, you know, that it is something that's very dangerous, that it's something that people should steer clear of or should be concerned about engaging with.

01:38:56 - 01:39:11

Speaker 30

Liz, you obviously talked about the direct action suggestions of members of your group that you tried to steer people away from. Is that, sort of, these particular offences being examples of things that you've tried to steer people away from doing so that they don't end up with a criminal record?

01:39:11 - 01:41:46

Liz Webster

Yeah, I mean, farmers wanted to, some of them wanted to do really naughty things and I'm a good girl.

And so, um, I tried my best to explain to them that from a public relations point of view, we don't win hearts and minds by doing what the French do. And I think that's, that's, you know, they sort of see the French and, you know, Belgium and they destroy stuff. But I don't think that the British public as a whole buy into that, which is why actually the, the bans on the, you know, on horns and stuff is so bad because that is an expression which is harmless, um, that, that actually helps release some of the pressure. Um, and, and it is really, you know, it is understanding from Parliament's point of view why people, nobody bothers to get out of their house and put a huge amount of effort and time and money into doing a protest, um, because, just for the hell of it.

I mean, maybe some of them that are crowdfunding, you know, with standing outside the Daily Mail do. But you know, as a whole, when you've got large members of the public interacting and feeling that they've got no other recourse but to do this, is, you know, I don't know what else would happen that you would be totally suppressed and you would just have to accept whatever Parliament puts on you. So I wish that if there'd been another way of us being able to do it, then, because farmers are pretty conservative people as and they're quite, you know, they're not used to, they're not even used to coming to London, most of them.

And so it was an enormous change for them to come here and that reaction. And you know, it so it's just if it's not released by if the pressure and the ask is not released by Parliament, then it does lead to lawbreaking and it will do. And that you know, there is still a risk that certain members in the farming community that will go and do that. And we're at risk of that today, it's budget day and there's not been any changes. And so there's still risk of that happening.

I think that's a bad thing for our campaign because I think you'll lose support from the public. But ultimately, that's what it that's what it leads to because you're not being heard by Westminster.

01:41:46 - 01:41:54

Speaker 30

It sounds like even if locking on and targeting key national infrastructure weren't criminal offences though, your campaign would try and deter those types of tactics being used.

01:41:54 - 01:43:05

Liz Webster

Look, I'm not, I don't believe in destruction. I'm not, I don't think it's, for me, it doesn't win my heart if somebody breaks something. When I see the French farmers destroy something, I think it's, I think it's awful. But it, it does get a reaction in their country and it works, so they keep doing it. Um, I, so I don't think it, I've always seen it from a sort of marketing, overall PR thing, getting people to sort of go, this campaign is, is moving and it's, it's gathering pace.

That's how I see it as a campaign organiser rather than I'm upset about this, so I'm going to go and, you know, go crazy. Um, you know, it's one of those, one of those things. I took the responsibility of leading my campaign very, very seriously.

I wasn't in it to have a crowdfunding thing to grift for my poor children who might not survive or anything else. I'm not in it for those means. I'm in it to say, 'this is really concerning and it impacts everybody across the board'. And that's what we continue to try and communicate to people.

01:43:05 - 01:43:08

Speaker 32

Thanks so much. Any thoughts from you on the offense?

01:43:08 - 01:43:56

Rahila Gupta

I just have an anecdote to offer, and that is that my partner was arrested for holding up a placard saying 'I support Palestine Action'. We both support the direct action taken by that organization to, you know, attack the factories that provide armaments to Israel.

But I could not take part because of my connection with Southall Black Sisters and I could not take the risk that it might bring to their funding and their stature and their authority. So I had to actually step back from what I would have liked to have protested about. But because my partner's semi-retired, of course I think it did affect some of his patients who come to him for acupuncture. But, you know, yeah, that's my kind of contribution to this.

01:43:56 - 01:44:01

Speaker 33

Thank you. Thank you. We're now, we'll now go back to Lord Murray.

01:44:00 - 01:44:01

Speaker 26

On a very discrete point, in the 2023 Public Order Act, a new power was given to the police to stop and search people at a protest in a specific location if to see whether or not they had on them an item which might be used in a protest, for example, glue for locking on. My question is this: to what extent has this increased power for stop and search, suspicionless stop and search, had any impact on the protests that you have organized? I think Mr. Leary, I might ask you first.

Yes, a very discrete point.

01:44:35 - 01:46:42

Peter Leary

Yeah, I mean, it's not something that I'm particularly aware of. We don't make use of much glue on our... When you started saying something that might be used in a protest, I thought you were going to say a placard or perhaps a megaphone, if you're allowed.

It's an article to be used that could be used in an offense described in the Public Order... Yeah, I mean, it's not something that I've been particularly aware of.

I do think though that that a lot of the the these powers where certain things that either wouldn't be allowed in terms of police behavior or certain behaviors that would be allowed in terms of what people might be doing on a protest, I don't necessarily mean this example, that it's sort of treated differently. I think it sort of fuels this sort of sense about what a protest is and where it stands in relation to the law, which seems to me is the opposite of what it should be. I mean, people who go on a protest are people who are going about their lawful business. They're not merely going about their lawful business in the way that you would be if you're going to the the the shops, for example, but they're actually exercising rights that are afforded enhanced protection in terms of their their human rights.

And yet, I think a lot of the legal framework that has come in in recent years seems to imply the opposite, that you're sort of because you're on a protest, you are you have fewer rights than you would be in another situation, so that you can be stopped and searched in a way that you might not be in another situation. Or you can be arrested for, you know, if I want to go to the shops with a mask on, there's no law that says I can't do that. If I do that at a protest, I could be finding myself prosecuted. So it adds to this environment that in my view is the opposite of what it should be, that participating in protest, rather than being one, lawful, two, protected, and three, this is my view, something that should be celebrated as part of a democratic society, instead that it's something that is verging on the criminal or quasi-criminal just by being there and that you're subjected to a different set of laws than other citizens would be.

01:46:42 - 01:46:45

Speaker 34

So I can sum up what you say, basically you think it might put people off?

01:46:45 - 01:46:57

Peter Leary

I think it would put people off, but I'm not aware of any, of anyone being searched for glue, so I couldn't, anecdotally, I couldn't sort of comment directly on it, but my, I think it's part of a culture that I think does put people off.

01:46:57 - 01:47:03

Speaker 36

Thank you. And Ms. Webster or Ms. Gupta, any comments on this particular aspect? I realize it's rather niche.

01:47:03 - 01:47:12

Liz Webster

No, I mean, I don't know anybody, I mean, if they'd wanted to search any of the tractors, we wouldn't have, I wouldn't have had an issue with that.

01:47:12 - 01:47:18

Speaker 35

Thank you. So next we'll go on to the point, that point about concealing identity in more depth to Lord Rook.

01:47:18 - 01:47:39

Rooke

The Crime and Policing Act has introduced new powers to make it a criminal offense to use an item to conceal identity at a protest.

I think first, my question is, do you think this was needed? And the second one is, how has the change in the law again impacted your ability to protest and and religious groups?

01:47:39 - 01:50:53

Rahila Gupta

So yeah, this has a particular impact on us because many of the women that we serve have been escaping domestic violence, they're afraid of violent spouses and disapproving families. So, in fact, on I have an incident to talk about on the 10th of October when the Palestine march took place and the women we had quite a big block organized for Southall Black Sisters. And two of our women were wearing COVID masks. They were wearing this because of fear of being photographed, filmed, seen, etc. And as far as I know, the police are not allowed to legitimately ask for a medical mask to be removed because they don't know whether somebody is actually suffering from something or the other or not.

Now, we also had a woman in our group who was wearing a niqab, the Muslim face veil. She was not approached by the police because the police are required to ignore religious face coverings. Now, as a secular women's organization, we are not in any way ever going to tell our women to wear a niqab in order to hide from police scrutiny. So these women were asked to take their masks off and they did. One of them put it back on and the police came in very aggressively and said, "I will arrest you if you continue to do that."

So that is—and she—it was her first march that she'd ever attended. I in fact have a quote from her if I could read it out, I would like to do that. Is that okay?

So I have in fact a quote from a woman who has no status in this country and who, and where has it gone? Sorry. Yeah, so this is the woman who doesn't have status in this country. She said, "This is the first time ever I've been on a march and when I was asked to take off my mask, I did, but I felt unsafe because of the cameras and videos." "I went into the background and hid myself."

"I will have to think about whether I come again." And then the second woman who has recently got her right to remain, she said, "I finally got a chance to be there without fear and feel that I am on the right side of history." "I stood by my words and principles." So you know, those were the two kind of very different reactions, but the chilling effect is felt throughout the group.

So for us, it's really problematic. Yeah, so we would definitely not. And also, again, the thread that's been running through everything I've said is the two-tier policing. We noted that there were men hooded, masked in black, all in black, in Dover and in Portsmouth, and they were not challenged, and they were simmering with aggression. Huge world of difference from two women wearing COVID masks.

So there is no nuance in which policing is carried out. How do you police for that? You know.

01:50:53 - 01:50:55

Speaker 37

Thank you. Liz.

01:50:55 - 01:51:37

Liz Webster

Um, yeah, I mean, it has, it is having an impact on us because actually we'd like to dress up as animals, chickens, pigs, cows, and we can't now. And so, you know, okay, we can do it without, but we'd have to have our face out, but it changes the whole thing. And in fact, if you look back, MPs did a protest wearing chicken outfits, the Labour Party did. And so again, it's one of those examples of a law coming in as a reaction which then sort of ends up having an impact on everything else.

01:51:38 - 01:53:54

Peter Leary

Yeah, I mean, I echo what has been said.

I mean, I think there are multiple elements to this in terms of, I mean, firstly, I should say most people, because I wouldn't want to create a false impression, most people who come, I don't know if any of you have been on the marches, but most people don't cover their faces or wear masks, unlike some other protests that do happen, which are largely people who are concealing their identity. I think the people who do wear masks do so for complex reasons. Some do so for medical reasons, some do so for religious reasons, some wish to conceal their identity because they don't wish someone to know that they're on a demonstration or where they can be found or identified. We're operating in a context where cameras are everywhere.

I mean, I don't mean police cameras or CCTV, but there are, you know, there are now if you go on a march you'll encounter far-right activists videoing people on the march, posting people on social media, commenting on, you know, on that. I think for a lot of young people who are, you know, very, very exposed in their lives on social media, they may wish to conceal their identity. And of course, those sorts of theatrical elements where people, there was a, I think a Grim Reaper was arrested recently, ironically, I think, protesting the death of democracy in response to one of the prosecution cases relating to right to protest. So, you know, it sort of undermines some of those kinds of aspects.

But again, I come back to the point, if I if I if I go out on Saturday night for Halloween with a mask on to go trick or treating, that's perfectly lawful. But if I go on a protest with the same mask on, it ceases to be or potentially ceases to be lawful, which implies that by going on a protest, I'm not just going about my lawful business as I would be if I went trick or treating. And certainly I'm not engaging in an activity, the expression of freedom of expression, exercise my rights to freedom of expression and assembly, which are actually protected activities and should be more enhanced rather than not less than than trick or treat.

01:53:54 - 01:54:02

Alex Sobel

Now we'll go to a series of questions from Peter Swallow on intimidation and harassment, followed by the final question about Afzal Khan. Peter.

01:54:02 - 01:54:45

Peter Swallow

Fantastic, thank you so much. This sounds like a very philosophical question at this stage of the session, but we, all of us, are very familiar with the debate around freedom of speech and where freedom of speech should end, what limit there should be on it in terms of what should be allowed to be upsetting or offensive and what shouldn't be allowed because it's threatening or abusive. Could each of you please set out what your view is on that as organizers of protests and also just perhaps if you think that's different from the perspective of the police? Rahila, can we start with you?

01:54:45 - 01:56:03

Rahila Gupta

Yeah, I think this issue has been so politicized that actually we are confronting a number of absurdities really, I think.

So, for example, I know that two people were arrested because they used the slogan "globalize the intifada", which to me is a political slogan which is not aimed at any individual group or not. And then, I think it was probably on the same day when the people arrested in the Unite the Kingdom rally, in which black police officers were called the N-word and they were told to effing go home. Now, you know, those both of those people in both of those marches were arrested. I don't know in which world they are comparable. So I think we have got to a situation, it's at the best of times freedom of speech is really hard to define the boundaries in practice.

It's quite easy, I think, not easy, but it's easier maybe to define it in theory, anything that doesn't cause harm or incitement to hatred or etcetera, etcetera.

But in practice when it becomes so politicised I think you can get to situations which are quite absurd.

01:56:03 - 01:56:24

Peter Swallow

I think in the interest of attempting some balance I will say that there are many, many people who would say that the phrase globalise the intifada is highly offensive, but you know I do recognise that views on that differ. Liz.

01:56:24 - 01:58:40

Liz Webster

Look, on a personal level, my son was attacked in 2007 by a gang and it was a racial attack. My son is white but it was a result of racial tension.

And so I'm acutely aware of how language can be dangerous and how it actually impacts everybody. It isn't a one-sided thing. You know, if my son happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time and racial tension had been allowed to run free in a school and racial slurs were given, you know, were prosecuted on one side and not on the other. And the tension, and so it's not a question of saying you're right, you're wrong, or you know. The point is that from a legislative point of view, you have to look at it cohesively in terms of safety.

And so if you're suddenly going around and you're criminalizing somebody for saying something, then you can then end up in a situation where you've got this sort of imbalance, I suppose.

But I think once you understand that it's not just a word, it is a building of things. And in recent times, because of the rise of the far right, that it's become more like it was as I remember when I was younger, that we are having, there's more permissiveness around extreme racial language day in, day out, whether it's on social media or anything. And so I would say that they are the most concerning things, that people are getting used to hearing politicians from the Reform Party, the Restore Party in particular, say things that are racially inflammatory. And so for me, that is the worst thing because it causes tribalism, and that is dangerous. It ends in violence because one side feels that they are better than the other.

And we should all be thinking that we're all human, we all have skin, we all have organs, we can all die if somebody puts an implement into our body.

01:58:40 - 01:59:44

Peter Swallow

Feel free not to answer this, because I appreciate it's outside the remit of Save British Farming, potentially. But we were just having that conversation just now with Rahila's point about two uses of language, which I think it's fair to say different people would, I hope everyone would accept that using the N-word against black police officers is utterly unacceptable. Saying that, I know that not everyone, but the vast majority of decent British people would be appalled at that.

I think the other, the other phrase used is more contested, shall we say. There is a challenge there, isn't, isn't there, where, where when we're trying to seek this balance, if we each of us have different perspectives, each of us have our own politics, our own views, it can be challenging to reach that consensus about what is unacceptable, what should be unacceptable in a democratic society and what shouldn't. I mean, what I'm trying to say is it is complicated, isn't it, basically?

01:59:44 - 02:01:19

Liz Webster

It's completely complicated, but you should be coming at it from, you should be coming at it cohesively as a whole to make society safer and to make society more tolerant. And that is not happening because of the politics and because some politicians are able to get all of the media's attention. And we've had it this week with Nigel Farage saying things about the Conservative leader, which is totally unacceptable.

So you ask me what I personally find unacceptable, it's that, it's racism. And it's dangerous and it puts us all at risk and you know even you guys in Westminster. It doesn't matter what your ethnicity is, all of those things make society more dangerous. So if we focus on a tick box as in, you know, am I offended because I mean I come from a Gypsy Traveller background, I mean I you know so someone could wouldn't know that. I come from a mixed ethnicity background, I don't look like it.

Would I be offended if somebody said something rude to me? Yes.

Yes, but you know, if you if you're asking me about my personal feelings of what I get upset about, that's a different thing to saying what do I think for the country as a whole. I want to see my country return to being more tolerant, kinder, and more patient and thinking more about a cohesive society and welcoming people who want to come here and work here and help us run an aging society. And those communication issues are far more important than a tick box say this one's allowed and that one's not.

02:01:19 - 02:01:27

Peter Swallow

Yeah, I guess my reflection would be that unfortunately the reality of the law is that sometimes the law has to work with tick boxes because that's the nature of it.

02:01:27 - 02:01:29

Speaker 39

That's the problem with over-legislating.

02:01:29 - 02:01:31

Speaker 40

Peter.

02:01:31 - 02:03:20

Peter Leary

Yeah, I mean, it is complicated and it does call for nuance. I mean, freedom of speech is precious and people also have rights not to be threatened and intimidated and abused.

And I think it's right that we seek to draw the distinction between language that incites violence or hatred and statements of political statements that people may strongly disagree with, may even find offensive. I think we've, you know, in terms of our work, I think we've strayed over very much into the policing of political statements, the most obvious being expressions of support for Palestine Action, which I don't think anyone could plausibly describe as inciting hatred or violence, but nevertheless, the large numbers of people have been arrested and criminalised under the most extreme legislation available for doing just that.

I mean, if I can just pick up on the, the, the example that was given in terms of the word intifada, which is, which is an interesting one in the sense of London and Manchester have made statements around that. I don't think the same policy's been adopted by other police forces. So you can say it in Liverpool, but not in Manchester, or maybe you can't say it in Liverpool because maybe Greater Manchester covers that, but, but you get the point I'm making. The, the, you know, there's a sort of a lack of consistency there. One of the biggest inconsistencies for me is that, that I'm, you know, intifada is an Arabic word, it means uprising.

It's been used in a wide variety of contexts. It is used in a wide variety of contexts. The Easter Rising in Dublin in 1916 is described as an intifada in Arabic sources. The, it's been, it's been used to describe many of the uprisings that we collectively know as the Arab Spring.

02:03:20 - 02:03:35

Peter Swallow

I guess the point is, given that it is well documented that there are people in society who find it personally very offensive and threatening, would it not just be a good idea not to say it on any of your marches?

02:03:35 - 02:04:04

Peter Leary

What I find extraordinary is that if I go out and call for an uprising, that's grand, but if an Arabic speaker says exactly the same thing in their language, they're potentially going to be arrested and criminalized for that. And I think that sends out a very dangerous message. It's hard not to see that itself as an example of racist and offensive policing for someone using the same word but in their own language to be treated as a criminal offense.

02:04:04 - 02:04:08

Speaker 41

I think we've got a supplementary from Ewan before we move on to your second question.

02:04:08 - 02:04:42

Speaker 30

Just very briefly, it's building off what Peter's talking about.

Obviously the police's job in the context of this question is to legally distinguish, not politically distinguish, between lawful language and threatening language. So do you recognize that there is potentially a unique challenge, and I'm coming back to the point I made earlier about a higher volume of complaints about the conduct of protests coming from those who are the counterparts, in the police being able to legally distinguish between points that are being made, whether it's lawful or unlawful expression?

02:04:42 - 02:05:51

Peter Leary

I mean, I can I can understand that that is is difficult. I think that that they, you know, they they need to, you know, I guess there should be great all I can say is I think there should be greater clarity on that.

I think it should be applied consistently and equally. There are lots of statements made that, you know, I mean, I read things in the newspapers every day that I find offensive, that I don't like, that I might even consider to be racist. But the police, um, you know, aren't knocking down the doors of Fleet Street or wherever the newspapers are based these days to, you know, to arrest the sort of editors. But I think that, you know, there is this approach to protest that it's sort of being put into this category that it should be held to a different standard, treated as something that is automatically illegitimate and therefore should be viewed with a certain degree of suspicion. When people chant things, for example, the worst possible interpretation should be placed on what they say rather than, you know, taking them at their word that they mean what they say when they say what they mean.

02:05:51 - 02:06:23

Speaker 30

I potentially acknowledge the point that you made potentially about a British or white speaker, especially at Palestine rallies, compared to an Arabic speaker.

Do you think that that type of selective reporting is creating an incentive system for protesters to essentially police the conduct and report the conduct of counter-protesters? So somebody who, for example, would have very different views to you would use a particularly more politically evocative person to blame and castigate, and potentially vice versa. Are you concerned about that incentive system?

02:06:23 - 02:07:42

Peter Leary

Well, I mean, I think, yes, it is a, sorry, it is a feature of demonstrations now that we have counter-protesters who are filming the demonstration, who are looking for things that are said or things that happen on the demonstration that can possibly be then interpreted in the worst possible light, often in my view in ways that are unjustified on the face of it, that can either then feed, you know, media stories or that can be, you know, reported to the police.

I think one of the worrying things that we've seen is the police often responding, I think they spend too much time on Twitter if I dare say, that they respond to demands that go out on social media of this has happened, that has happened, and that is sort of driving policing, you know, rather than actually this was, this isn't, you know, this isn't someone who is an asylum seeker who's just living in their accommodation and protesters have come and shouted offensive things at them. This is someone who's gone to a demonstration with a camera to look for something that they can possibly interpret in a way that they can claim that is offensive to then report it to the police, and the police priorities seem to be sometimes being driven and shaped by that.

02:07:42 - 02:07:51

Speaker 30

We need a bit of clarity on legal distinction, not necessarily... I think there is a challenge if we consistently present it as political distinction, but that's not really a question, so I'll go back to the chair.

02:07:51 - 02:08:49

Peter Swallow

If I can just ask my sort of follow-up point there, which is I think if we can agree not necessarily... I mean, not just me, I'm trying to keep my personal views out of it. I mean collectively, if as a country we can't always necessarily agree readily where the line is, I hope we can all agree, as Liz was alluding to, that there is a line.

And therefore, you know, if a protester crosses that line, whatever that line may be, who is responsible or who shares responsibility about responding to that? Do you as an organizer of protest see it as part of your job in organizing the protest when someone, if someone does cross the line, to step in and address that? Is that purely a matter for the individual? Is it a matter for the police? Where does the responsibility for that fall?

02:08:49 - 02:08:53

Speaker 42

Or where should it fall, I should say?

02:08:53 - 02:10:32

Peter Leary

Well, certainly we have an extensive stewarding operation at our demonstrations. We, you know, I mean the police themselves have remarked at how well organized and stewarded the demonstrations are. And I think that in terms of any kind of, if you're continuing this sort of line in relation to hateful speech and so on, the our positions and the message that goes out to our stewarding operation and from our platforms and in our communications is absolutely clear that we reject all forms of racism and discrimination of every kind.

So people are are very much aware of that. And and I think, you know, where they become aware of instances, I think, you know, if people people were to see hear something or see something sort of that was problematic, then our stewards would within reason feel confident to challenge that. I mean, obviously they don't have police powers. They're not designated constables. There are limits to what what they could possibly do and in fact could find themselves on the wrong side of the law if they were to to sort of overstep that.

But but, you know, so and and I think again it comes back to this point. People don't sort of step outside of the the public, if you like, once they go on a demonstration. They're still entitled to protection and of you know, from the law and so on.

So I think that, you know, we're very clear in our political messaging that, you know, and that that is passed on to, um, to our, to our stewarding operation and to all those involved in, in our, um, events.

02:10:32 - 02:10:35

Speaker 43

Thank you. Um, Liz.

02:10:35 - 02:11:43

Liz Webster

I, I think it's really hard for organisers to be in control of what people that are coming to your protest. I mean, we, we actually had the far, what I would describe as the far right turn up to our protest uninvited and tried to sort of claim it was their protest, you know. Um, and so some people thought that they were there and that we'd invited them and, and we hadn't.

So I think it's really hard to really get a view of, or have control exactly what they do. And as I said, I think that you can sometimes over-legislate for quite small things. I mean, you might have somebody at your protest who's got Tourette's, who comes out and says something. I think so if you're controlling people for what they say, it's just too much control and, and too much. But if you've got collectively a large gang of far-right thugs telling people to go home because they're, they don't identify with their ethnicity, then that is a significant problem that needs to be addressed, not one person in a protest saying something which is offensive.

02:11:43 - 02:11:45

Speaker 44

That's what I would say.

02:11:45 - 02:11:50

Speaker 45

Yes, so, you know, it's proportionate, right? So you're not...

02:11:50 - 02:13:17

Liz Webster

So if you've got, if you look at a Tommy Robinson, I mean, which I find particularly worrying and threatening, when you see, and I don't know how someone who, I mean, someone who, I was born in this country and, you know, I don't, I'm not, it's not obvious from the color of my coloring that I come from a mixed heritage. So I can only imagine how scary it must be for people to see those protests unfold. I find it makes, as I said, my son was hurt, he survived a severe attack with a hammer to his head.

So I have felt that violence perpetrated on my son and I felt the racial backlash of what happened and the fear of of one community wanting to go and take it out on another community. And I that's really what brings me actually to into this activism is fear of that unfolding and lots of you know of violence where people are are unsafe. And so that's how I take my views. I think if you're too focused in on one word or one person who doesn't know how to behave you're losing the plot in terms of trying to get communities safer and feeling as if we're working and functioning better.

02:13:17 - 02:13:19

Speaker 46

Yeah. Thank you. Rahila.

02:13:19 - 02:14:06

Rahila Gupta

I don't really have much to add to what has already been said except to caution against the rolling of you know causing offense into incitement to hatred. I think this is the problem.

I think we have, as a society, become very sensitive to what is offensive and what isn't. We've lost some of the robustness that I remember from my early days of political organizing, where we said things to people, you know, and people took it in the right spirit, I mean, you know, in debate. Now it's really, you have to be very careful how you speak, and we've moved into this era where offense can be very easily given and taken. And I think that that should not be part of any legislative consideration.

02:14:06 - 02:14:12

Speaker 48

Okay, thank you so much. Okay, thank you. So we've got the final question now to Afzal Khan.

02:14:12 - 02:14:14

Speaker 47

Finally we're there, the last question.

02:14:14 - 02:14:38

Afzal Khan

And the question is actually to you, Peter. At the end of April, the Independent Reviewer of Terrorism and State Threats Legislation called for a moratorium on pro-Palestinian marches due to concerns over them incubating anti-Semitism. What is your response to that proposal?

02:14:38 - 02:19:20

Peter Leary

Well, I think for me there are two dangerous conflations there. And I'd also, I think there's also something to be said about the particular context of that moment, but, or of that march that we're talking about there. The, I think the two dangerous conflations is on the one hand conflating protest with totally unrelated acts of violence.

This came in the wake of the the the attack at Golders Green that were not linked to any form of protest in any way. And there's no reason to believe as far as I know that that any individual associated had any links to any form of protest or or of of any kind. So there's that conflation which obviously builds on the previous the other conflations of protest with terrorism that we've seen around the prescription of Palestine Action but but but but I think it's particularly dangerous in this context where we start conflating political dissent with terrorism. The other conflation obviously I think is with Israel and the state of Israel and the actions of the state of Israel with Jewish people and Jewish communities in this country.

We are, as I say, absolutely and consistently clear: Jewish people are not responsible for the crimes of the state of Israel. And that is our very, very consistent and clear message. In fact, there are many, many Jewish people involved in the marches, involved in the very marches that this moratorium, this call was asking for a moratorium of. Many of them marching, often hundreds if not thousands of Jewish people marching as part of an organized Jewish block, Jewish speakers on the platform. There are Jewish people who are among the key organizers of the marches.

On several occasions, the marches have been addressed by Holocaust survivors, perhaps some of the largest audiences ever addressed by Holocaust survivors in this country.

And that's to send out a very clear message about any, we're ensuring that that's the message that we're coming out, we're sending out from the protests. So I think for that reason, I mean, the idea that, you know, the marches could be incubators of antisemitism seems absurd. I think if someone was an antisemite, they would find our demonstrations a very, very uncomfortable place to be because of the messages, because of the makeup of those marches and protests. In fact, anyone who believed in any form of bigotry, I think would feel that way because these are protests that bring together people from all backgrounds and every walk of life. The particular, that particular statement was made in the context, in the run-up to our Nakba Day demonstration, which is an annual event when we commemorate the displacement of Palestinians from their homeland since 1948.

It's a very solemn occasion in many ways.

It's very important to the Palestinian community in particular. And I don't know whether the Independent Reviewer of Anti-Terror Legislation consulted with or took the feelings or sentiments of the Palestinian community into consideration, because it's also a kind of a national day for Palestinians as well, when they celebrate and mark their Palestinian identity. So this was a very important march. Every year it's led by Palestinian children along with what are by now very elderly Nakba survivors who go at the front of the march. And I think it was very important that we continue to commemorate that in that way.

And also, of course, it came on the day that Tommy Robinson had called on his far-right supporters to come out into the street. He has called on his supporters to attack our marches before. I believe that he likely called on his supporters to come into the street on the day of the annual Nakba march in order to try and drive the Palestine solidarity movement off the street because he hates to see Muslims and immigrants and alongside Jewish people and LGBT people and all others that represent everything that he stands against taking part in a protest. So I think had there been such a moratorium imposed, it would have been a victory for Tommy Robinson and the far-right as well. So our response was to continue with our protest and I think that was the right thing to do.

02:19:20 - 02:19:26

Alex Sobel

Thank you. I'd like to thank all of the panel. And with that, order, order, I close the session. Thank you.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.