Standing Committee on Environment and Planning: Standing Committee on Environment and Planning - Inquiry into DPA-11- Belconnen Section 65 Block 42 (5 November 2026)
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Standing Committee on Environment and Planning ACT Legislative Assembly
Follow its sittings



Peter Quiggin
Yep. So, I've lived in Belconnen for around 55 years. I should say I don't have any links to the Belconnen Community Council, but I support the comments they've made in their submissions. My awareness of community-zoned land started with the Arcadia House relocation attempt, where the government was basically saying that only one site in Cook was the only suitable site zoned as community use in the whole of North Canberra for that facility. They did suggest two sites in Cook, but one was actually urban open space.
The two distinct things that I wanted to put forward: the first is that the land should be used for community facilities, not for housing,
And the second is that the University of Canberra should not be able to profit from changing the permissible use of the land. The main points in relation to the use of the land for community facilities are there's a need for more land zoned as community facilities in the Belconnen area, and I strongly agree with the Belconnen Community Council's submission that the land occupied by the University of Canberra, the hospital or the housing project should not be counted as available for community purposes. My main points in relation to UC not profiting from the change in the permissible use of the land are according to the UC submission, UC has controlled the block for over a decade and does not appear to have done anything with it. According to UC submission, they received the land in 2011 as part of the National Rental Affordability Scheme,
but seems to have stopped being used for affordable house student housing within a few years, probably 2014, and it's therefore questionable how the site contributed to rental affordability in Belconnen. If UC does not wish to use the site for the purposes of the lease, they should hand it back to the ACT government. If any compensation is paid, it should not exceed the amount that UC paid when they obtained the lease.
While the UC submission that says it is as a market value lease, and not a concessional lease, they did not disclose what the market value was paid, although it's fairly clear that it was gifted even though it was valued at $9 million. In 2015, the University of Canberra agreed with the ACT Auditor-General's recommendation that, quote, "if it is not to be used for student accommodation or educational purposes as planned and changes to the use require a change in the lease whereby the property value exceeds that provided by it in support of NRAS," $9 million, "it would be equitable for an appropriate adjustment to be made to the ACT government." End quote.
And as I note, the University of Canberra agreed with that recommendation. As this appears to be the case, University of Canberra should honour that agreement and make an appropriate adjustment, which I would suggest is the current market value of the land. I think a proper evaluation of the best future use of the land should be undertaken, and I think as part of that consideration should be given to locating Arcadia House on the site. That's all I want to say as an opening statement.
Speaker 6
Peter, that was excellent. And colleagues, we're going to have up to 10 minutes each, and we'll go down the line. Thank you very much for that. I am also interested in the transfer of benefits that's operating in this proposal. We did see that site in the Auditor-General's report was valued at $9 million and UC then reported it as a part of their surplus that year.
Jo Clay
Can you see what financial benefit would flow from the territory if this site were if this proposal were up for a another developer, for Geocon or someone else? Do you think there's you can actually see what public benefit and what territory benefit is coming from this proposal?
Peter Quiggin
Not from this proposal. It appears to me from the information that I've seen, I should say I've only been able to see publicly available information, the proposal appears to basically be to build a block of flats with some sort of use of the ground floor. And well, obviously, there's some benefit in having additional housing, but I don't think that's a particular one. The other thing I'd note is in the high the site,
I don't think is a natural part of the University of Canberra site. I think the they've described that it could be a gateway to it. I assume I don't know if the committee's been there, but Arscott House is
Peter Quiggin
I'm in Macquarie now. I grew up in Belconnen. I know the area and it's right Yeah. Yeah, it's on the edge near
Yeah, so it's so it's separated from UC by a four-lane road, which is busy enough that when it was built, it had an underpass, but obviously at some point that wasn't sufficient. So put in a traffic light pedestrian crossing, as well. I drove it this morning. So the natural boundary of UC is the far side of the road. It's been unused by UC for a decade.
I think the to suggest that it's the gateway to UC is risible basically. But I can't I don't see any benefit in to the ACT government if it's merely sold to a somebody who then develops it other than that very general thing of as a benefit in more housing.
Speaker 13
Yep, and perhaps, in this instance, not even sold. We'll get further details from the minister on the exact transaction at the time, but, yes, it sounds like there was a $9 million benefit that was transferred at zero cost.
Peter Quiggin
Yes, so, well, from the Auditor-General's report, it appears clear that it was given it was given to UC so that UC could then use it as, effectively, security for other money or other loans that they would then be able to somewhere build the NRAS the National Rental Affordability Scheme properties. I note that when they took it over, UC never actually ran Arscott House. It was run, I think, by some sort of students association. When UC took over, it had around 90% occupancy, and this is in the Auditor-General's report. Within four years of University of Canberra being the landlord, it was unprofitable to the extent that it had to be a students association abandoned it to UC, who then said they'd try and find another provider, and that was their evidence of the Auditor-General.
So at the time of the Auditor-General report, the UC uh what the UC was saying was they were looking for someone to run it, and they didn't at that point indicate they were not going to continue Arscott House as it was.
Jo Clay
Yeah. And University of Canberra is trying to make a case that changing the zoning is got social benefits. Do you think that social impact assessment justifies the loss of community facility land or do you think that's just an argument made in support of rezoning?
Peter Quiggin
I haven't read I haven't read that, but I think changing it from community purposes to residential, I don't think has a community benefit.
Jo Clay
And tell me, as a as one of our community members, how are you concerned about the long-term implications? We're hearing quite a lot about what will happen with the next development on this site, but a zoning decision is actually something that you make for the next 50, 100, in perpetuity sort of
Peter Quiggin
Well, certainly I think the Belconnen Community Council made the comment that once these changes are made or once things go out of community usage, they basically never come back, and certainly if an apartment block, for example, was built there, it's almost impossible to see how that would ever come back into community use.
Jo Clay
Some of the community zoned land in Belconnen in the Belconnen Town Centre that's being cited as, "There's lots of community land there." There's land there like at Radford College, there's UC and hospital, UC Hospital. There's quite a lot of sites that are quite heavily used. Do you imagine that the community considers that's part of their community land? Would Do you think it's open to government to ask Radford or the UC to say, "Hey, we need a community facility on your site because you're on community zoned land," or does that mean that we actually have less community zoned land there and we need to protect the empty sites that we have?
Peter Quiggin
I should declare a conflict of interest in that my children went to Radford, my grandchildren go there, and I was in fact on the board for many years at Radford. So I just make that comment.
I also went to the school there.
Peter Quiggin
Yeah, so I'll just make that comment so people are aware. I don't think it affects the answer I give. I was quite surprised that particularly University of Canberra was seen as community land available for Belconnen residents. University of Canberra obviously draw in students from all over Canberra, but also, I'm actually an ex-student of, and a graduate from there. They also bring in students from all over New South Wales and obviously overseas students as well, and I think that to see that as something that is for the Belconnen community is, again, a fair stretch.
So, I was quite surprised at the number of the places listed that they were seen as community facilities.
Yeah.
Peter Quiggin
I think most, well, I would have expected community facilities to be things probably the library and some of those, things like Arcadia House is probably one that, if it was there, would be a community facility. But, yeah, I was quite surprised to see, well, particularly the University of Canberra and North Canberra Hospital were seen as community facilities,
Yep.
Jo Clay
It's interesting that you mention Arcadia House. We've had a number of people suggest that government is in actual fact running out of community-facilities-zoned land, and two of the things that have come up in this inquiry are we need somewhere to put Arcadia House, and the recent process for government did not even identify this site as one that would be suitable,
Yeah.
Jo Clay
and that we will need a primary and high school, possibly a vertical high school, at some point in a town centre of 16,000 people in the next 40 years. Do you think it's a bit of a lost opportunity if this site is not considered for some of those other?
Peter Quiggin
I think definitely, I think it's, I was involved in the consultation on the suggestion to move Arcadia House to Cook, and, in fact, at that time, I looked into what possible land there was, and had some communications with some of the members, the government members in our electorate, that were in that electorate about what land was available, and I should say they were very responsive to those, but, in fact, it was raised about whether there was land at the University of Canberra that was available, because you know there's vast tracks of paddocks there at the moment,
Peter Quiggin
but we were told that there was no available land at the University of Canberra for this. So, I don't think at that point, and then again go back to my point, everybody would have seen that block of land as being part of the University of Canberra, so it probably wasn't raised in the consultation in that
Yeah.
Peter Quiggin
context, but they did produce a list, the government produced a list of all of the land in Canberra available for community facilities, and it was a very small, there were almost no large blocks. In fact, the fact that the Cook block was seen as, it was sort of the largest one, is rather telling, I think.
Fiona Carrick
Thanks, Chair. I think it that option of UC giving the land back to the ACT government should be explored. I mean, to me, community facility land is very precious. The government, however, has a densification agenda with infill of 70%, and putting people close to where the amenity are.
That site has been had homes on it, whether student accommodation, over the years. So, given the government's agenda of 70% in-fill and putting people close to where the amenities are, where people want to be, why wouldn't this site, given the amount of land around there, be used as this 70% in-fill policy?
Peter Quiggin
I think that's a matter for you. My view is that there is a lot of land available in Belconnen, the Belconnen Town Centre for high rise development and there's a lot of it going on and has been going on. So, I think where there's what there isn't is available land for community purposes. I mean that seems to be there must be much more of a shortage of that than uh land that could otherwise be used for housing.
Fiona Carrick
What sort of community facilities do you think Belconnen short on compared to any other part of Canberra?
Peter Quiggin
I'm not sure there's specific ones at the moment. I think what the Arcadia House consultation made clear was that was a like a fairly essential service for the whole of the ACT. I don't think it was a Belconnen-specific facility. Um, but the government appears to have been unable to find anywhere to move that after it was basically removed from the North Canberra site by the, I don't know whether it's the Capital Health service that controls who goes on that site, but the fact that a service like that cannot find a place to go. There was also, I read in the various submissions, that there was a childcare centre in that part of Belconnen that had to move, I'm not sure why, and they were unable to find any suitable sites.
So I think the problem is there are very limited of these sites, and, as Ms Clay mentioned, once this is built on, it is gone forever. So it's not something where you could say, "Well, we'll build a block of flats, but in 10 years' time we'll come back and say, 'Well, actually we need this particular thing.'" So I think, I suppose, part of my submission was that there should be a complete review to, in fact, find what you're asking, which is what is the optimum use for this land that is now vacant? So it's I think an opportunity that has come up, probably unexpectedly, I don't know, but we well, they're not making more land, and so unless land suddenly becomes available through some other thing, which seems doubtful, this is sort of pretty much the only block of a large block of community or land that could be used for community purposes in Canberra, certainly in Belconnen, but from the list we were provided by the government, it appears possibly in the whole of Canberra. And there's, like where I live in Cook, I look out across Whitlam and Denman Prospect, there's still vast amounts of land out there that could be used for housing development.
Speaker 14
Yeah, that's right. They don't have a lot of community stuff there. Have a long way.
Peter Quiggin
No, and No, and I saw in one of the other newer suburbs was, in fact, a proposal to rezone some of that community land in to some other purpose, and I didn't see the full details of it, but it was basically something on one of the maps that I saw. So, I guess it seems that it's almost a blind spot for the government, using the term to cover the bureaucracy as well, of making sure there is sufficient community land available.
Fiona Carrick
It's true, I agree. It is a blind spot and we do definitely need our community land, so how we balance it with the 70% infill policy and the provision of community facilities is always a struggle.
Peter Quiggin
Yeah. I should say that I necessarily agree with the 70% infill policy, I'm not sure. Well, that's a whether if the basic policy is we should have 70% infill so we'll put houses on everything that we can find, which is sort of what's being described, that doesn't seem like a very well-thought through policy. I can see the I can see we need to have more dense suburbs and dual occupancies and those sort of things, but yeah, whether you say to put more and more people in a by removing open land or community service, community land doesn't seem all that sensible to me.
Speaker 28
Okay, well, thank you. So, if you were doing our job this afternoon with the minister and his officials, what would you ask them?
What would you like
Peter Quiggin
Well, as I said, there's it's basically two themes I've put forward. One is that the land should be used for community services or community purposes, and I suppose my question to the ministers would be what land do they have available for community purposes and what is their long-term planning in relation to community facilities, because they're the two things that I think are missing. The second one is the view about UC profiting from the land. The land was basically given to UC, and not only given to them, I think it was basically given to them to prop them up financially rather than to make use of the land, because the Basketball ACT was already there and already operating, so it was basically a transfer to give them $9 million that they could then put into their books. On what basis do they feel that University of Canberra has a moral entitlement to profit from land where they were given an operating facility that was 90% full, within four years closed it down, and I've done nothing with the site since then, apart from land banking?
Speaker 19
So, the $9 million you've mentioned, that's the valuation at the time, that's in your understanding?
Peter Quiggin
That's my understanding from the Auditor-General's report, and that the University of Canberra, when they were given the property, then showed that as income in that year, which enabled them to have a surplus of $10 million.
Peter Cain
Sound like it was a gift then, if they just credited it. So, you've also, as has been touched on, you've said that it would be an appropriate site for Acacia House. Is that your preferred use for the site, or you're just
Peter Quiggin
Look, I'm just putting that out there. We were we, the community Cook community, were told there is nowhere in the whole of Canberra except Cook Oval for this, and this appears to be a site. I don't have a particular preference about that one.
Peter Cain
Just on the Acacia House, did you present this view during the actual submissions on the site? I know there was public forums and things.
Peter Quiggin
Well, nobody knew about this site. That's Yep, yeah. I can't say that. When we, the community, asked, or when I asked government representatives what sites were available, this site was not ever listed.
Peter Cain
And you've touched on the absence of a strategic, I mean, there's we've obviously got a very dated Belconnen Town Centre Master Plan. And also, there's the issue of the needs, growing needs maybe of a school, real late children to have a local school. The SDN Bluebell was the child care centre, a not-for-profit as well. That was I mean, their lease was just ending and there was no appetite for extending it. And that's why they relocated out to Gungahlin.
So, what do you think is lacking in the government's vision, let's just say pick or picked a Belconnen Town Centre? What's lacking that these things are happening, that we're seeing e.g. SDN moved out, fortunately found a place, no apparent plan for a primary school and a growing population, where I know children are living in these apartments and family apartments as well. So, what's lacking in the government's vision, do you think?
Peter Quiggin
Oh, look, I think that's probably beyond my knowledge. I've looked into fairly specific things about Aranda House, rather than I think someone like Belconnen Community Council would be better to answer that.
Yvette Berry
I also know the site quite well, being a Belconnen resident and living in West Belconnen. I think perhaps the issue with the site is that it wasn't a government-owned site, taking into account, putting aside the gifting and everything of it, when they were suggesting a site for Arcadia, it was government community not this one. And that's why it wasn't considered at the time.
That doesn't mean it couldn't be, but it's just that when they were thinking about Arcadia, they were referring to government-owned community facilities zoned land. The question on what the site could be used for if it was community facilities zoned, whether it's owned by UC or the ACT Government, is that's not an issue for you.
It's just that it could should be used for, so it could be used for community housing and public housing?
Yvette Berry
Which it is. Yeah. Yes, it has a it's a catch-all phrase for, you know, things that benefit the community. And in your
conversations with Cook other Cook people and people in Belconnen, this is a concern that they've raised about the site, is that it shouldn't be used for student accommodation or it could be?
Peter Quiggin
No, I haven't had any discussions with anyone about the this site. My discussions with the Cook community, or as part of the Cook community, was in relation to Cook primary, so I don't in anyway represent the Cook community.
Yvette Berry
Okay. All right. So, the site though, you're you wouldn't be If it was student accommodation, that would be acceptable?
Peter Quiggin
Well, I think that's what it was has been, and I think that would be acceptable. I think if they just rebuilt an Arscott House sort of thing, that that would seem to be a useful
Yvette Berry
Yeah. No, so I think that's important to understand, that people are okay It's not a green space issue. It's a using it for the use that it was intended.
Peter Quiggin
No, at Yeah. No, I This is and again, this is my view,
it's not a very useful green space, it's it's right next to John Knight Park which has plenty of green space so, certainly, I I would look just for it to be used in a sort of positive community or a building of some sort.
Fiona Carrick
I thought that was good advice, you know to ask about what land they have available for community services and what plan does the government have for community facility land. When if the government were to do proper planning, they would then look at what land we need for community facilities and social infrastructure, and what land for housing, and for all the different parts of life that people that you know land use is used for. Don't you see that land use can ever be changed to
Do you think that the zoning can be changed? If there was a plan that set out all our needs, that zoning could be changed to a current plan?
Peter Quiggin
Well, I think certainly if assuming you have a plan and you may have an area that's set aside for something, and it's while it's still vacant or if it becomes available it'll be worth reviewing that.
So, I'm not quite sure what the question is.
Fiona Carrick
Well the loan the land is zoned currently like all land in Canberra, and we're constantly getting major plan amendments to the Territory Plan to change the zoning all the time for all across Canberra. And so do you think it's appropriate that we change the zoning where appropriate?
Peter Quiggin
Yes, I think that there just needs to be a close investigation of for each one, what is its current zoning, what are the benefits of that compared to what is the new zoning. And
I suppose my caveat on that would be I have two caveats, one is I would be very cautious wherever the zoning is to change open land or public use land, etc., to housing to particularly sort of high rise
housing. And I suppose my second one which sort of I've already said ANU sorry, UC shouldn't profit from this, I think the other difficulty is other organisations
also getting open land or land that is used for community purposes under some sort of concessional basis and then large profits being made out of those being turned into housing.
Fiona Carrick
Often the government will tell us that commercial zoned land can be used for community purposes, so when we scream blue murder that we want some community zoned land, they'll say, "You can put community facilities in commercial zoned land." So, why don't we just put community facilities in you know given that commercial zoned land can have community facilities as well, what's the problem with turning it into community commercial zoned land and being having still the opportunity to put community facilities there?
Peter Quiggin
Well, you'd need to buy it, and the government appears to be unwilling to buy land at, if it's available for commercial purposes, its value would be what it could be sold as for commercial purposes, which would be a lot more than what it could be sold for community purposes. So, there's a direct cost to the ACT taxpayers if they're trying to obtain
commercial land for community purposes.
Fiona Carrick
Yeah.
I mean it's it doesn't really work because commercial an owner of commercial land will try and get highest and best use out of it. So community uses doesn't tend to give highest and best use, so it's a bit of an anomaly saying
Peter Quiggin
Well, if there was vacant community sorry vacant commercial land that the ACT owns and they then put a facility on it, I don't have an issue with that. But I think the idea that you could say, "Well, that could be used for those purposes, so therefore we'll rezone it as that and then sell it as that." Once it's sold the value is obviously substantially more than it was for community purposes.
Peter Cain
Yeah, I mean just a comment I guess, but happy for your thoughts. I mean obviously once the if the rezoning happens or the variation is approved, what's to stop UC selling it for development?
Peter Quiggin
Well, I assume that's the purpose, unless I mean unless they're moving into real estate development, although I noticed it was the housing thing which I've never really understood project they're doing, but I would have thought they would sort of they would either do that or have some sort of joint venture with a developer.
Speaker 33
Well they're doing a lot, obviously, at the site, campus site. I don't have any further questions.
Jo Clay
Peter, thank you so much for coming in. Your submission was excellent and your has been very helpful. Is there anything we didn't ask you that you wanted to tell us?
Peter Quiggin
No, I don't think so. So, I'd just like to thank the committee for the opportunity to both make a presentation, or to make the submission, and to be here today.
Jo Clay
Thank you. And we will now break until 9:45. Thank you for coming in. Thanks gang, we might just break till 9:45.
Welcome for our next witnesses from Belconnen Alliance of Highrise Apartments. For the Hansard record and starting with you, Chris, can you state your full name and the capacity in which you're appearing today?
Chris Brack
Okay, I'm Associate Professor Chris Brack. I'm appearing on behalf of the Belconnen Alliance of Highrise Apartments, and I'm also on the executive committee for the Dusk and Republic precinct in that area.
It's great.
Trevor Drover
I'm Trevor Drover. I'm appearing for BAHA as well, and I'm the chair of Altitude Apartments in Belconnen.
Jo Clay
That's great. As witnesses, you're protected by parliamentary privilege, and you're bound by its obligations. You must tell the truth. Giving false or misleading evidence will be treated as a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. And feel free to stop and ask for guidance at any point.
We're really happy to provide it. We're not taking opening statements. We've got a really short session, and we'll probably just run down the line with 5 minutes each. We have a lot of people in Belconnen Town Centre,
and we're heading towards 16,000 over the next few decades. Have we got enough community facilities and community land there available for our current residents and for our future residents?
Chris Brack
I think the short answer is no. Yeah. So, we think that the original town plan underestimated how fast we were growing, and possibly the land was reserved on those bases, and we've got we don't think enough to have where Belconnen is going,
and we certainly don't want to lose any of that potential end.
Jo Clay
And what sorts of needs do you see now and into the future for community facilities in that area? What do you think we need that we're not we don't yet have?
Trevor Drover
Well, primary you need a primary school in there. That's the only free block of community land left in Belconnen Town Centre. And so the population was estimated in the 2016 Belconnen Town Centre master plan to be what, 8,000, 8.5 thousand by 2031. We reckon it's going to be at least 16,000, possibly more. And so there's no there's no primary school in the area.
Jo Clay
Yep, that's right. And we've and we've had government commitments for a feasibility study which is underway, but we haven't yet seen it. We've also heard from other witnesses that we do need community facility land, but some of the other needs could be a primary school, a high school, Arcadia House, noting the government recently wasn't able to find a suitable community facility-zoned area, and then just community and recreational facilities. Do you think there's an opportunity cost then if this land is rezoned away from being community facility land?
Def- definitely.
Definitely, yeah.
Jo Clay
Yeah. You've talked about suspending the sale of land in the Belconnen Town Centre until holistic plans are prepared. I suspect the government would say that 2016 Belconnen Town Centre Master Plan is a holistic plan. So, what would you say to that?
Chris Brack
It's a terrible underestimate of the needs for the area. And that's it's obvious already just a total population is much greater than anticipated in that plan. We also think the demographics of the place has changed quite dramatically since that plan. We're looking forward to the census results. We think the number of younger families with school-age children has increased dramatically since that 2016 and since the expectation in that 2016.
Yep.
Jo Clay
And I think you'll be right. Certainly, our information has been that area was seen for single adults and built for it, and it is in actual fact home to many families with children, which is partly why we needed more facilities for kids in that area, so it's-.
Chris Brack
Just my expectation walking around my precinct, you see a lot more there now than you might have expected. Certainly in 2016, but well we didn't exist then, the precinct, yeah.
Speaker 40
And this rezoning would reduce our community use land in the town centre by 8%. Do you think that's a significant sort of concern?
Chris Brack
Yes, is the, yeah, we're we don't have enough to start with, so a loss of another 8%. And it's pretty much the only vacant land left. It's not just 8%, it's 100% of the free land. The free land, yeah.
Jo Clay
We've also heard a lot of concerns that University of Canberra got the land for free and it was valued at $9 million by the auditor-general. It appeared in UC's surplus statement that year as a $9 million asset and that UC would now potentially be rezoning it for commercial purposes. Is there a concern about public benefits from this decision? And where those public benefits should go? Where those public benefits should go to the territory, or whether they go elsewhere?
Chris Brack
I think there was some Disgruntlement over the University of Canberra appearing to make a huge profit out of that. Uh yes, I think there is some concern about that.
Yeah. I might hand over to Fiona.
Fiona Carrick
Thank you, Chair. What is your definition of community facilities? Oh. Does it include like cuz I think like, when I talk about community facilities, there's a level of, I have a different view of it to the government, because I think they will talk about aged care, child care, you know, Arcadia House, that sort of stuff.
I talk about art centres, indoor sports stadiums, aquatic centres. So, I think there's a little bit of confusion about what actually is a community facility in the first place. Because when I look at Belconnen, there is, in commercial lands like there'll be statistics about the amount of community-facility-zoned land, but there are community facilities on commercially-zoned land, for example, the Belconnen basketball stadium, the arts centre. So, I'm just not 100% sure that using the that metric of Belconnen's needs more community You know, when we look at community facility-zoned land and not include community facilities that are on commercially-zoned land, if that makes sense, because the arts centre is not going anywhere and nor is the basketball stadium, because that's Basketball ACT, that's their whole purpose. Like they're not going to sell it.
So, can you that metric that Belconnen Community Council uses about we've got less community-zoned land than anybody else per capita, how does that gel with commercially-zoned land that is actually got community facilities on it?
Chris Brack
I don't know how the council worked out the percentage, but I assume you have to use horses for courses and make everyone do the same thing. So, how much in the other suburbs do they have commercial land that's also used for community? So, yeah, I don't know how that did that balancing act. I think you're right. So, things like the arts centre is a community resource.
So, I think I personally would have counted that as a community place. Community places are where the community can get together. That's right, or it's not just the private commercial stuff. When we lost the Bluebells childcare centre that got hunted out of the area because they needed more room to build more residences, I would have counted that as a loss of community asset. Don't know if it was zoned as commercial, I don't know that, but I certainly would have counted that as a loss of community asset.
Chris Brack
Yeah. So, I don't know what definition was used in that the that 8%, but I just do know that the block we're looking at is something that has potential to do a whole range of things, and it's one of the few things that's left where we have that expansion potential.
Fiona Carrick
So, with the 70% land infill policy and the government wanting people to live close to where they want to be and, you know, where there's amenity the densification agenda, given that there are community facilities around that aren't on community-facility-zoned land, how do you see that densification agenda going for Bel- for Belconnen? And why wouldn't this land be used for housing, given that had always been housing, like whether it be student accommodation or whatever? Primarily, in the past, it has had homes. Why wouldn't it be used for the infill policy?
Trevor Drover
Well, the I think that the infill policy was more aimed at the residential side of things, residential single singles houses and building additional accommodation on those lands. There's currently I reckon about 4,000 apartments that have been scheduled, either being built or scheduled to be built in the next four years in the town centre anyway.
Speaker 54
Anyway, sorry. You can, it's higher. We're going to be 19,000 people by 2065, but anyway, and a smaller area. In a very small area. With less facilities.
Yeah, there's no there's no playing fields, no, we've got Margaret Timpson Park, which is a miniscule thing.
Chris Brack
And the infill in Belconnen has primarily been done, or in recently in the near future, on surface level car parks. So, basically every surface level car park has turned into a high-rise building. Um, so, yeah, that's just another thing to
Speaker 53
But that's across Canberra, every surface car park is on its way out. But we're putting towers up on ours, yeah, so that's the big difference, so.
Peter Cain
Peter? Yeah, no, thanks, Chair. I know the census is coming out and we'll have some numbers, but have you got an estimate of, I guess, the numbers or percentage of pre- school-aged children or primary school-aged children? Is there, have you got any idea at all or we're just going to see the numbers, obviously?
Trevor Drover
Well, in the last census, there were the problem with Belconnen is we got a high population, but the, um, in the last census was 8.7% were children 0 to 14, compared to 18.7 for the rest of Canberra. Now, I believe that could be the case of we've got a smaller family population there because there's people don't have a school to go to. Yeah. And as Chris has noted, we are, because of the cost of housing, we are getting more and more families moving into apartments.
Speaker 51
And have you been engaged on the proposal for establishment of a primary school in the in somewhere in the centre?
Peter Cain
Have you been engaged by the government as, in terms of, no, okay. And look, I think you, your point's well made about, um, we got a very dated master town centre plan. And, uh, again, we don't have an update to that, in fact, we don't even have, in my opinion, an evaluation of that 10-year-old plan. Um, so, I guess what's on your wish list for, as members of a growing, densifying residential town centre? You've mentioned the miniscule Margaret Timpson Park.
Sorry?
Peter Cain
Would that be something you feel as an example deserves to be expanded over the hole that's been there for nearly quite a while?
Does that sound like a good idea to you?
Yes, it sounds a great idea.
Chris Brack
Okay. That's been a point the BAHA have been pushing for a number of years, yeah.
Chris Brack
So, that's the, that increase in that little bit of green space in the town centre and the absence of schools are the two big community things.
Peter Cain
So there we push for. So the BAHA's view, and you're here for BAHA almost, yes. Um so, what would be your top five priorities for what happens in the town centre within the next 10 and ongoing years?
Speaker 48
So, just sorry, just repeat and clarify, if you don't mind, the two top are?
Chris Brack
Schools, a school within Okay. walkable distance. Yes. Um and the expansion of the Margaret Timpson, the green space. Mm-mm.
Speaker 52
Okay. Anything else, thank you, anything else come to mind that Well Or is they just stand out?
Okay.
Trevor Drover
Yeah. It's unfortunately it's in private hands so there's not much the government can really do about that.
Peter Cain
And so, just as a final what a point of observation, I invite your comments. So, obviously we're starting to see Emu Bank that the area there opposite the town centre, we've got the Sly Fox Markets.
Yes, they've done it twice now.
Peter Cain
So, are we seeing that the residential community in the town centre are starting to say, here are the sorts of things we like seeing and hence we'd rather they didn't disappear on us?
Chris Brack
Yeah, I mean Sly Fox Markets is I think it's going really well and I know the residents really appreciate it. It is very popular. So it's we are building up is part of this. The residents are doing getting involved and coming out again, not just being isolated in little towers.
Peter Cain
So, to me, it's certainly one way that the community is letting its expectations be known by such actions which is not a protest, but it's like an indication of, wow, let's what we can make of the space available. So, certainly that's I think any of us would encourage the community to let their views be known through such things.
Thank you, Chair.
Speaker 69
Yvette. Thank you. The 8,000 residents, is that 8,000 people or 8,000 unit homes? In your submission.
Trevor Drover
Let's say from memory there's Belconnen Town Centre has got I think about 8,000
Yvette Berry
We can I mean we can I mean we'll know soon enough through the census, but I was just curious because I'd heard that, you know, vacancy rates are still pretty high across um residential in the ACT.
Yeah, down south, but not in Belconnen.
Not in Belconnen.
Not in Belconnen Town Centre.
The ACT is the highest in Australia
Yeah.
Yvette Berry
Okay. Oh well, we'll find out when the census comes out anyway. And on the site beside Lake Ginninderra College,
Sorry, Yvette's got a question.
Yvette Berry
Sorry. On the on this site beside Lake G College, is that a It's currently zoned community facilities, so it's not a green space issue for you, it's what facility could be built there? The development application change would make it into something different, but if was for community or public housing or some other use, that would be fine by your association?
Speaker 56
Because it takes away the opportunity to put a school in there. There's nowhere else there's nowhere
Speaker 63
So, from your perspective, it's just a primary school, that's it, no question?
Trevor Drover
Well, it's the only place you really could you yeah, you could put one in the town centre, unless you want to No, there's no there's nowhere there is nowhere else conceivable you could do it.
Chris Brack
And the town centre I mean, the new buildings do have substantial areas of accessible housing, social housing. The new tower going up near the markets is 75% social and affordable housing. So, we think you can do that rather than just have a dedicated social housing block where we think there's other priorities for that particular area. We prefer it to go for a school or something like that, rather than just more residences, even if it is 15-30% affordable housing in that new residential block.
Chris Brack
Yeah, and they call it different things. We have what's called a summer housing in one of the three or four floors where they have disabled people living in them, so all the blocks have
Speaker 81
I was just wondering, sorry, is there an underpass under Coulter Drive?
Speaker 78
There is, yes. Yes, there's a pedestrian crossing and there's another pass as well, yeah.
You mean Florey Primary School.
Yeah, like
Chris Brack
It's quite a wander. There's an underpass that goes from, you know, just up from the block of land we're just talking about under into UC. So, there is an underpass there. Is that the underpass
Speaker 74
On the other side, it will actually There is another pass over that side as well, yeah.
Any more questions?
Peter Cain
I'll certainly encourage you to keep submitting, keep speaking, because you're a representing a significantly growing part of the Belconnen's population, and thank you for your submission.
Thank you.
Speaker 82
Was there anything we didn't get to, but you wanted Is there anything that we didn't ask you about, that you really wanted to make sure that we got to?
Speaker 72
Not for this inquiry. We have a whole bunch of things on the D-casification what have you, but that's a different inquiry, yeah.
Speaker 85
Thank you so much for coming in. That's been really helpful. We haven't had any questions on notice, and we will now break until 10:25. Thank you.
Thank you.
Thanks.
Thank you.
Jo Clay
Excellent. And welcome our next witnesses from Belconnen Community Council. For the record, we might start with you, Kieran. Can you, I'm so sorry. Can you state your full name and the organisation you're here to represent?
Speaker 87
I'm Kieran Stroh. I'm Secretary of Belconnen Community Council Incorporated.
And Lachlan?
Jo Clay
Excellent. As witnesses, you're protected by parliamentary privilege and you're bound by its obligations. You must tell the truth. Giving false or misleading evidence is a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. And, please, feel free to stop and ask for guidance at any point.
We weren't going to do opening statements. We've got quite short hearings, and you've given us two actually excellent submissions, so we might jump straight into questions and just move down the line. And I will kick things off. You've got some concerns about the metrics and evidence that have been presented in the social impact assessment. And all of the community facilities in Belconnen Town Centre, they're used by town centre residents and people from other parts of Belconnen.
Speaker 90
Do you think the well-being of the whole Belconnen area is going to be diminished if the particular site, we're looking at Arscott House, is rezoned from community to commercial?
Lachlan Butler
I think there's definitely that is a real risk, considering the problems identified by the government earlier this year with the Arcadia House consultation, talking about the lack of community, or the limited community-zoned land available in the district. So, I think when we're looking at rezoning one of the biggest spots of community-zoned land in the town centre of the biggest district that's going to have the greatest increase in population over the next 40 years, I think that is a, yeah, a real concern that we really need to think about what we're going to do with, yeah, how what those community needs are and how they're actually going to be met.
Speaker 94
So, I think I might just quickly add to that. The proponent's consultants, in response to our concerns on SIA, kind of flagged commercial type sites which had uses for community. Looking at that list of sites, skate parks, CISAC, those aren't things exclusively used by town centre residents. I think it would be fair to assume that community use would be diminished, potentially depending on plans for the whole of Belconnen.
Jo Clay
Some of those sites aren't necessarily fixed long-term sites either, are they?
The CISAC site for instance, right now is a great recreational facility, but there's no guarantees that it will remain a great recreational facility in 20 or 30 years.
Lachlan Butler
And I think that's an excellent example, because that's one that's zoned commercially. And so if they did want to change and put apartments there, you know, once a cashier had made a bunch of cash by putting apartments there, they don't have to go through this rezoning process. And so, and there's no call in powers for DAs anymore, so really that one is at risk and there's not much members here and in the Assembly can do to stop that from happening.
Speaker 95
We've heard in the submissions and from witnesses already today concern that there's not a lot of vacant community facility land in the town centre or in Belconnen in general. Does Belconnen Community Council see that concern as well?
Lachlan Butler
I think you know, the examples that we're seeing in the last 12 months alone prove that. Whether it's the Arscott House consultation, whether it's the Bluebell childcare centre that relocated out of Belconnen, because they couldn't find a spot to relocate to in the town centre. City and Environment Directorate did a assessment on what community recreational and social needs the district needs, and there's a few that are there's a gap now and there's a gap in the future.
Jo Clay
We've had a few witnesses talk about the difficulty in finding a site for Arscott House, the need that Belconnen town centre will have for probably a primary and a high school, might be vertical ones, and just community facility land in general. Do you think there's an opportunity cost in this site?
Lachlan Butler
There's definitely an opportunity cost. I think in our submission to this inquiry we sort of put a list of all the community zoned land in the town centre and what's been used on each site. This is the only vacant one. It's the third-largest site in the town centre, and so we think there is a massive opportunity cost if it's rezoned before actually knowing how we're going to deliver all these community needs. I think it's interesting, the Territory Planning Authority kind of sort of goes, "Oh, it's fine, we're doing studies to figure out what we need."
Speaker 93
It's like, well, we probably should do the studies first and then rezone, not rezone and just hope for the best after the fact.
Jo Clay
We've also had concern about the transfer of a public benefit and where that goes. So, Arscott House was gifted unstemmed to University of Canberra at a value of $9 million. It appeared in their books as a $9 million line item. It was part of their surplus that year and UC is now seeking to rezone that for what looks to be commercial purposes. Do you see a concern in transferring a territory benefit in that manner?
Would you want to touch on this one?
Speaker 94
I think a bit shaky here, but my understanding was around the time of that transfer University of Canberra agreed that should future use of that site change, it would make in kind or a relative or respective payment back to the Territory. Could be the lease, who knows? But I think broadly, the territorians gave an institution of the territory that site, which is now being used to profit. Well, potentially could be used to profit, generate profits for the institution, but doesn't benefit the people of the territory.
Fiona Carrick
Thanks, Chair. The current district strategies that replaced our master plans, because I don't think the master plans have got much currency anymore since we've moved to the new territory plan and the guiding documents and what have you. So do you think that the current district strategies provide a good town plan for your needs in Belconnen?
Lachlan Butler
No.
I think we've been coming out since the district strategies came out that these district strategies, the current ones we've got, they're not, they're not fit for purpose. They're very vague. They talk, it's mainly just a long list of studies and things to look into, things to consider. I don't think you can look at that and go, "Oh yeah, in 20 years time, that's what Belconnen's going to look like."
Fiona Carrick
Yeah, so they don't, what's your view about how they identify the land use because we talked about integrated transport and land use planning. So do they identify, do they do an assessment of the needs for your district in Belconnen Town Centre because it services you know, Belconnen, your needs, and then identifies the land to match those needs?
Lachlan Butler
No. I think it's mainly just a list of things to look into in the future rather than, yeah, actually doing that assessment.
Fiona Carrick
Yes, so your, would you advocate for bringing back the master plans?
Lachlan Butler
I mean I think all things should be considered. It'll be interesting to see what the next lot of district strategies look like. This was the first run. They seemed a bit thrown together at the last end amongst a big reform, so like you know, I could see the next run of district strategies being a lot higher quality. But I think that's yet to be seen.
Fiona Carrick
Every f— okay, so we expect better planning in five. Well, that'll be about 2028, I guess. 2023 was the sort of planning reform, so, all right. And you know, when you got a lot of kids in a area, you need schools. So, how far do you reckon kids should be walking to get to school?
Speaker 94
I don't know, I walked a kilometre to school at Fraser Primary School as a child. I didn't have to navigate an a maze and network of vehicles in a town centre. Certainly if I lived in a town centre, I wouldn't expect that my children would be walking to Florey Primary School for example. It's a, yeah I probably can't put a number on it for you.
Speaker 94
Um that's, yeah. It's certainly a point well made on we've encouraged density in the town centre, and families should be taking advantage of that, and young couples, or people who will have children. Those children who go somewhere, so if they need somewhere to go to school, we should have a school in the town centre, and Belconnen Community Council has advocated that for a number of years.
Fiona Carrick
Yeah. And that comes back to the planning, I guess, that there's no planning for where school should go to make the population growth that's happening in the town centres.
Lachlan Butler
I think from my understanding, they're, that sort of planning work does occur, like within the Education Directorate. It's probably a question better served for them, but I think in this case, specifically, the territory planning authority goes, "Ah, don't, you know, we don't consider that. The Education Directorate considers where schools go, so that's a non-issue for us." And that's, like there's so many things in there in their sort of comments that are pretty much just like, "Ah, that's a different part. We don't have to, we don't have to consider this aspect, or you know, we're doing a study on this so, like, we can rezone it."
And I think education is an interesting one because they do pretty much just say, "Well, Education Directorate does this research, it's fine, rezone."
Fiona Carrick
Yeah, it's like I guess how the directorates and the planning directorate work together to ensure the planning makes the needs of the directorates because I guess the directorates have to inform the planning directorate about what the needs are.
Peter Cain
Yeah, now, thank you, Chair.
I'm probably a bit surprised, I mean, Ms Carrick touched on the need for an updated master town plan. We've got a ten-year-old one that hasn't really been evaluated properly. So even though we may have a an enhanced district strategy, you still think there's a need for a dedicated Belconnen town centre master plan?
Lachlan Butler
I think it depends on what the next district strategy looks like, because it's very vague. Like there's it's not very prescriptive in what a district strategy looks like. So it could be a lot more detailed. Well, the next round of district strategies could be a lot more detailed and sort of touch on a lot of the things that the master plan did. If it stays at this very high-level, just sort of, yeah, recommending studies that should be done in vague timelines, then, you know, we probably should consider, yeah, the planning for the town centre.
I think it's challenging Fiona touched on earlier, which was master plans don't really exist in the planning system anymore. But the SLA still talks and creates master plans. So, there is a lot of community confusion about how they hear, "Oh, town centres don't get master plans anymore. The planning system doesn't do it." And then the SLA come out and say, "Here's our master plan."
Peter Cain
So, do you think there should be a concession that, oh, we won't worry about master plans now for the planning of our city? Do you think there's still a role for dedicated town centre master plans and subject to what the district strategies have? But I'm not sure even the most ambitious district strategy could actually encompass the uniqueness of a town centre with significant retail. And now, as we're seeing both in Woden and here, in Belconnen, significant densification.
Lachlan Butler
Yeah, I think it's yeah sort of, I think it's the district strategy could be better than a town centre a damn town centre master plan in the way that looking at the district holistically, it can sort of tie in connections between other yeah, the rest of Belconnen and the town centre, really sort of cater for that, if you're being really optimistic and assume it's going to be really good. However, if it is just a repeat of what we're saying now, I think people are going to want another master plan. Kieran, do you have any?
Peter Cain
Yeah. So, there may well be something the committee's reflexed upon. So, in terms of obviously, you mentioned this particular site, the third-largest CFZ, and thank you for pointing out some government cleverness and maybe categorisation things that happen to elevate percentages in terms of the usage, effectively the usage. So, what do you think is the best use for that site? And I'm just thinking about the town centre now, because it's very much a part of the town centre in most views.
What else do you think could be enhanced or developed in the town centre? And I'm I am exploring your views on the expansion or not of Margaret Timpson Park.
Lachlan Butler
I think I wouldn't want to be too prescriptive in what sort of we think should be on that site. There hasn't really been sort of a conversation for what should be on this site, so sort of just been told what's happening. I think it's interesting that yeah, Purdon and UC sort of put together some funny numbers on community the availability of community-zoned land in the ACT, including a 1,600 dwelling development across the road that UC sold land for to occur. But I think it really does come down to if we know what needs the Belconnen town centre has, we can actually start planning the land use and start allocating spots for it. At the moment, it's a well, we'll rezone it and then figure out where everything's going to fit out fit later.
Lachlan Butler
Look, it'll be interesting to see what comes out with the community housing provider. I think for us, it's if no community housings provider is interested, then we can't just have this perpetual hole in the ground in the town centre. So, we want to see this move pretty quickly with the they eventually called it Belconnen Precinct on Emu Bank. You know, that site took like four or five years to sell that. We don't want to see that happen in this case.
And if the if they're going to not expand Margaret Timpson Park, then we do need sites to put green space, community facilities, places, third places for all these people that live in apartments to go out and, you know, actually spend time.
Yvette Berry
So, there's a couple of reports I guess that everybody's waiting for, which is the feasibility on the primary school work and the census so we know what's happening and who's living in Belconnen. But are there's like it's pretty It's pretty constrained as a sort of place now, because it's pretty kind of set up now of what's going to happen and there's only that site left. There's the side of the Eastern Valley Oval, which I know nobody wants to touch for anything other than the but the floodway or whatever it is. There are some other commercial sites in the in this town centre. Is that I mean, are those being looked at for, because we know community facilities, as you talked about with pool sides, that can be built on commercial sides.
Lachlan Butler
I think it's and I think you rightly point out, you know, you can build community use stuff on commercial zones facilities. I think for us, it's in the last 12 months, we've seen, you know, Bilby, uh the Bluebell Day Care move, we've seen the Kaleen Indoor Sports Centre close, we've seen all the stuff happening with Big Splash. And so, I think it's just very much at the moment particularly, people are quite frustrated to just see stuff go at one way and not the other.
Yvette Berry
It's very difficult when they're privately owned and the private owner for whatever makes a decision to do something else, which is, you know, their prerogative, but not a prerogative that everybody agrees with. And but that it all seems to be condensed into a couple of years is really frustrating for everybody in the ACT, I get that. Do you think that, so then, the waiting So, I know it's frustrating for people also as well to wait for reports when they have strong views about things. But under But understanding the data really compels the government to make a decision about what they do with things, as long as it doesn't take too long. I mean
Lachlan Butler
Yeah, I think people can appreciate that private owners can do what they want, you know, with, well, within obviously the rules of they want to do with their sites. I think, for this one, they see well, the rules are set and UC is asking for them to be changed. You know, when it's They call it mixed use, but it is pretty much just housing with a very token sort of community use aspect and undefined ground floor usage. And I think people can appreciate what you're saying about the privately owned stuff, but when the Assembly, when the minister, when the government has, you know, the chance to actually, you know, have a say, they want to see, yeah, the say be on the community side, not the developer's side.
Yvette Berry
Yeah. And the community facility zoning we've been talking about, that's pretty broad description for a range of different purposes.
So, as long as that land was used for community facilities, that wouldn't be of some sort, that would be something that the community council would be fairly relaxed around?
Lachlan Butler
Yeah, I think it's even with like Big Splash, a lot of the stuff, there's obviously a couple of people that really want the slides to be protected, there's a couple that want the pools to be protected, but there's a lot of people that are just like, "We want a recreational facility of some sort." It might not be a pool and might not be water slides, but they want to see, yeah, it could be a massive tennis courts or, yeah, some sort of recreational sporting facility. So, it's not the specific use case that people get quite fired up about, it's just losing that entire category. You don't really get back.
Yeah.
Speaker 111
Awesome. Is there anything we didn't get to that you wanted to tell us?
Lachlan Butler
I think the key point is on the technical specifications. So, with this one, I won't rehash too much of what's in our submission, but the defense is there's a technical specification that says 3,000 square meters of community space will be built. But technical specifications are guidance. They're not required. They can be changed by the chief planner without public consultation, without the involvement of this assembly.
So, we could approve this, well, this committee could recommend that it be approved, and the minister approves it, and then you see next year guys, "Oh, actually, it's kind of hard. Can we change that?" And the chief planner can change that with no public consultation.
And I think Purdon's submission, Purdon and UC's submission is quite interesting, because they talk about, you know, the technical specifications will save the day. But if you look at the master plan that they put out for Big Splash last year, also by Purdon, also done by Cox, I'm looking at sort of like a six-story hotel, what appears to be a six-story hotel with a 25-meter pool in the on the ground floor on a site that says the hotel should be secondary in use on that site. So, it's kind of hard to see the technical if the technical specifications aren't really being followed for Big Splash, the Big Splash master plan put out last year, it's sort of hard for people to have faith that, oh, this time will be different.
Speaker 94
Only very general one on a higher policy of densification across Canberra. We've had some really great work done, missing middle reforms, Penrhyn books exciting. We've got Ginninderra East. We're told this week by the SLA they'd land release in 2030.
We have people coming. The Ginninderra development is still building. It would be an awful shame to basically forever lose the loss of a really good site in the town centre to some more apartments with something on the ground floor where there are a range of options with an ageing population, social or aged care type facilities through to
primary schools. We're getting the apartments and we're getting townhouses elsewhere. I think the Belconnen community would be disheartened to learn that a territory-owned or territory institution is adding to that rather than creating community good.
Yeah.
Jo Clay
Thank you so much for your time. Thank you for your evidence today and we will now hear from University of Canberra. Thank you. our witnesses from the University of Canberra for the Hansard record, starting with you, Hugh, can you state your full name, your role and the organisation you are here to represent?
Speaker 115
Yes. Hugh Howarth, director of campus estate effectively, representing the University of Canberra.
Speaker 114
And Michelle Moore, chief operating officer for the University of Canberra.
Jo Clay
Great. As witnesses you're protected by parliamentary privilege and you are bound by its obligations. Witnesses must tell the truth. Giving false or misleading evidence will be considered a serious matter and may be treated as contempt of the Assembly. And please feel free to stop and ask for guidance if you'd like to. We haven't been doing opening statements.
We have got your submission and we're happy to table any further material that you've brought. We might jump straight into questions if that's okay. According to the 2021 UC Master Plan, under campus housing, it says consider the former Arscott House site for purpose-built short-term accommodation enabling students and families, conference attendees, and partners to more deeply engage in the campus experience. So the direction for the land in 2021 seems to be different from what you're proposing in the major plan you've put up at the moment. Is what you've shown in the major plan amendment right now what you see as the future for that site?
Speaker 117
I think what we're asking for is a rezoning so that we can understand what might be the best use going forward, Ms Clay, because I think there's We need to understand what the options are before we put a plan on the table.
Speaker 118
Okay. So, if what If UC got If UC was successful in getting this land rezoned, what would UC use this land for?
Speaker 117
We'd have to work through the scenarios based on what the zoning would allow. And what the needs are in comparison to the whole of our campus.
Speaker 90
That's a challenging position for the community I think, and potentially for the authority at ACT Government, to say we're going to rezone a site that is currently community facility zoned land, we're going to rezone it into something else and we have no idea or guarantee about what will go there. What would you say to people who are concerned about that decision-making process?
Speaker 119
Well, it's educational facility zoned as I understand it now, including
Speaker 116
Yes, with the overlay from the Crown lease for educational purposes, and which includes student accommodation, so yeah. I think to answer your question, the intent is to continue to use the site for an educational purpose. What that actually looks like, we're not completely sure of. So the broader master plan talked about a partnership development on that site. It talked about activating ground floor, a component of retail.
It talked about a component of accommodation. In addition, the actual campus master plan more broadly allocates uses on our campus and what we're trying to avoid is duplicating uses across those two sites. So, something like a student accommodation, for example, we're trying to avoid a fragmented approach to student accommodation. So that's the planning we would need to work through once we knew the zoning conditions. In addition, we weren't really completely sure about the 3,000 m² and that was something that was introduced in consultation with the territory planning authority.
So, all of this will have an impact in on what's probably feasible and achievable on that site.
Jo Clay
And the 3,000 m², which is the community facility portion that you would imagine would be in there, as opposed to the entire site currently being community facility, what where did that number come from, and what guarantee would there be that the community would get something that they considered to be a community facility out of that?
Speaker 116
A basic analysis of the site and yielding what the site they thought the architects of what would fit on the site, and it was a percentage of that yield. In terms of use, I mean, things were discussed around childcare facilities, other educational establishments, a broad base of community facilities, or it could be elements of affordable housing, social housing and other pieces like that.
Speaker 124
So, it was based on the development needs for the site, not based on the community needs for community facility, community space? It was It wasn't based on any kind of assessment of what Belconnen town, yeah, the Yeah.
Speaker 116
Well, I think there was a level of assessment there. It was based on a percentage of the use of the site, trying to balance the site with different uses, 3,000 being a fairly large number.
Jo Clay
Yeah. How, given the given that there's no clear plans about what, if UC got this rezoning, you don't have fixed plans yet on what you'd do with it, why do you need to rezone it? Why can't you just come up with your plans and maybe your plans for development there might fit into the current zoning? Like why do you need to get a rezoning decision now, when you're not even certain what you want to do with the land?
Speaker 116
This was seen as a gateway step. There was multiple steps and then the first step was to test the appetite. So, we approached the Territory Government with a view about what we would like to do with the site and had these discussions and then we understood the process would be to then look at potentially a rezoning, which probably is the most straightforward approach. This has actually been looked at for probably over 10 years in terms of what to do with the Arscott House site. We were following the process that we understood, which would include community consultation, so we did a prior community consultation,
then we were interested to see what came back from that. We modified our plans a little bit and then Territory planning did their or the Territory planning team did their consultation, so we were interested to see what the result of that would be.
Jo Clay
So, I'm interested, if this has been under consideration by UC for 10 years, that's, you know, 2015-2016, the site was given for free to United to University of Canberra in 2011, have I got this right? It was valued at the time as $9 million, and that valuation appeared on UC's books as a positive revenue stream part of your surplus for that year. And then, within 4 years, University of Canberra decided that they didn't actually want to use the land for student accommodation, they wanted to redevelop it. Is that the sort of decision-making process?
Speaker 117
Well, I think the student accommodation part became part of consolidating our student accommodation onto campus, and that's from a safety perspective, it's also from an amenity perspective. So, between 2011 and 2018, we added to about 1,200-1,300 beds on campus in excess of the Arscott House site, so we actually met that increase in beds in a way that our campus master plan actually
Jo Clay
So, I think it's great that you built enough student accommodation to meet your needs elsewhere, that's excellent. Did University of Canberra consider giving the site back to Government because University of Canberra got it for free from Government and then didn't need it for the purpose for which it was granted anymore?
Jo Clay
Yeah. We've certainly had a number of witnesses that suggest that. We've had a number of witnesses that suggest that University of Canberra agreed with the Auditor-General's findings about a decade ago, I'd have to look, I think it was the 2015 2015, that the Auditor-General suggested if the site was not going to be used for that purpose that it should be handed back to the Territory free of charge, and I understand that University of Canberra, at the time, said that sounded reasonable and that they agreed with that.
Speaker 130
Have I got any of that information wrong? By all means please correct me if I have.
Speaker 117
My reading of the Auditor-General's report was also that if the land was going to be used for another purpose, that the university would recompense or use would remit any funding that is required legally back to the ACT government as part of that. That's what that's what the Auditor-General's report said.
Jo Clay
Thank you so much. So, will the University of Canberra if this zoning decision goes ahead and is approved, will the University of Canberra remit the value back to the territory and what have what's the assessment of that value that you would send back to the territory?
Speaker 117
So, my understanding is that there'd be a number of stage gates post this, so there's a lease variation, the underlying lease would need to be varied and then the development application would have to go through. So, all along that way I think in terms of an uplift related to an underlying lease change that would trigger potentially trigger obligations on behalf of the university.
Jo Clay
Are you talking about remitting the full value of the site back to the territory, or are you talking about paying the ordinary LVC charge that any commercial developer would have to pay?
Speaker 116
We've always modeled around the LVC, but to your point around the Auditor-General's report, it referred to profit. We're yet to crystallise what that profit would be and whether the value of the site my interpretation was profit above the value of the site at the time of acquisition which was put at $9 million, I believe. Whereas, current LVC will probably have a different methodology for calculation, but I imagine will still capture the full value.
Jo Clay
Current LVC is typically 75% of the uplift value and that is applied to all developers. I think what I'm interested in and what came out in that Auditor-General's report and what a number of witnesses have said is, well, that's what happens when developers who bought the land uplift the value. What about the $9 million you started with and what of that $9 million, what the site is worth at today's terms? I don't know what it is. Are there discussions going on, will UC remit the value of the land as it is today back to the ACT government?
It's not a conversation that we've had.
Speaker 90
So there's no contractual obligations, no conversations about that with the territory, this decision would be made ahead of any agreement of that nature?
Fiona Carrick
Thanks, Chair. You said that this land's got an educational overlay, and you're an educational institution with lots of different aspects to your business, aged care and hospitals and all sorts of things. So, given that the community is growing in the town centre with the towers, and they talk about having a primary school, why couldn't this land be used for that purpose and work with the ACT government to put a primary school on that land? And associated with it the policy of not-for-profit childcare, due to Bluebell being having nowhere to go.
Speaker 116
Certainly a very good question and one I would encourage the committee address to the Education Department as well. The university earmarked a large parcel of land on our campus for a primary school and other educational partners which was bigger than the Ascot House site, and more aligned with what we understand to be the siting policies around schools. So, we have been working with government on that land, and would encourage the committee reach out to Education about the findings of that feasibility.
Fiona Carrick
Coz interestingly, I mean that's great to know have a primary school on the University of Canberra site, but given all the population density will be in the towers in the town centre and the Ascot site is closer to the town centre so that the kids have it's closer to walk, if that site is appropriate for a primary school, why wouldn't that be used as opposed to a site on University of Canberra where it's a longer walk for the children to get to?
Speaker 129
I think the comment there, if appropriate, my understanding of the siting guidelines for primary schools within that
We will suspend the hearing.
Excellent.
I have one more.
Okay, can I start?
Yeah.
Fiona Carrick
Okay, so I just wanted to ask about you know, it was brought up this morning that once land is zoned to commercial zone, becomes more expensive because you can highest and best use in commercial zones, you can make a lot of money out of it. So how the given the community is so concerned about the community facilities how would you propose to ensure that there's community facilities if it commercial if you zone it commercially?
Speaker 116
My view at this stage is that we still have to go through a crown lease variation or modification and those conditions could be instilled in the crown lease in terms of the obligation around community facilities.
Fiona Carrick
But that doesn't always happen. You know, like things go through without the crown lease being definitive and often things are just pushed down the track. And so they might say in the crown lease, oh, community facilities to be determined later and they won't be specific so specific in the crown lease. So, you know, given that the it's a risk, I'm just saying that to for the community it is a risk if you zone it commercial land.
Speaker 116
I think, you know, as a side piece, I mean, it was also discussed that there is nothing happening with the land at the moment and part of this arrangement is to try and get traction on a balanced development on that site and effectively find a bankable or a fundable or viable development that works on the site. So I think that's the other part of the DA the future DA and a future crown lease is to make sure whatever is delivered is actually viable and can be delivered for the community as opposed to the land remaining vacant.
Fiona Carrick
I guess, you know, like if UC doesn't need it, the land, it's been sitting vacant for something that's brought up and Ms Clay brought it up in her question.
If the UC doesn't need it's not part of their master plan, why isn't it given back to the ACT government to use for the town centre for their needs?
Speaker 117
It be I mean we're always talking to the government about the use of our land. This was the approach that we the plan that we went through was let's see what this land could be used for. We've undertaken this piece of work with the territory planners to make sure that we are being really clear about what this land could be, so I don't think we've shut the door on any- Did they suggest that you give it back to them?
or childcare? Not for-profit?
They as in
Our planners, Purdon?
Speaker 150
No, the ACT Government planners. Did they ever suggest to you that perhaps you get that back given
Speaker 116
Not the territory plan- Not the territory planning team. I No, that wasn't raised during this. I understood from their consultation report that the question was asked around education, whether education had an interest to purchase it, and I believe from that report it said education didn't have an interest to purchase it, if I understand that correctly.
Peter Cain
Okay. Now, thank you, Chair. So, what's your plan A for the site if the rezoning happens? And do you mind if you don't have a specific answer to provide, I'll move on to some other questions.
Speaker 151
Well, I think I mean I think Ms Clay asked a similar question, Mr Cain, and fo- for me it's about wha- what is the best use of that site right now and we'd have to work through the scenarios. So, we don't have a specific plan.
Peter Cain
So you don't have a specific plan? So, you've engaged Purdon for, um, to provide submission and, you know, there's a fair bit of work here, so you don't have a plan for the site if it's rezoned?
Speaker 116
We have a broad master plan ambition for that site, and we engaged Purdon's to start a process which involved consultation to inform what we do next, yes.
Peter Cain
No. So, when you say that the site will be used for educational purposes, I think that's the phrase you use, yes, what educational purpose? It's not going to be student accommodation. It's not going to be a school because you've got that in the master plan on the site.
What would the education purpose be? What is the top five possible educational purposes the site would be used for?
Speaker 160
I think that there are things like educate- It depends how you define educational purposes, a bit like the conversation you had earlier around community facilities, so, for me, educational purposes can be things like
Speaker 117
wo- work integrated um learning, um placements, those things are also educational purposes. So, that's part of the aged care precinct and the healthcare facilities on the rest of our campus have an educational purpose because they allow us to undertake work-integrated learning and placements with those partners.
Peter Cain
So, there's been some ideas thrown about that the land should be returned to the ACT Government. Have you done an analysis of the cost, the book value cost to the UC if that occurred?
Speaker 117
I can tell you that it sits on our books now at $1.85 million this piece of land.
Mm-hmm.
Speaker 149
Because that would that $9 million would have been with the building. Yeah.
Speaker 142
Is that equivalent to its UV for rates purposes? Is that the same number?
I'd have to take that on notice, Mr. Cain.
Peter Cain
I'd appreciate that. Thank you. You don't need more student accommodation and I guess part of your possibility, range of possibilities is not to return the land? That's not within the possibilities that you're contemplating, it wouldn't be, would it, because you got
I'm assuming that's a no.
Peter Cain
Have you done a range of scenario analysis that would show what are the capital gain the UC would make or ongoing revenue gain the UC would make with various development proposals?
Speaker 116
Nothing definitive. High-level indication numbers over the years about different uses as people have approached us, but nothing
Speaker 116
I think all of the scenarios have been difficult because the sites have been so constrained, no one's really been able to identify the actual massing or what could be delivered, so what they're typically just reduced to what people believe the underlying land value might be for a party, but it hasn't yielded very attractive returns, in terms of nothing to date has been fantastic in terms of financial outcomes.
Peter Cain
Are you able to comment at all on, I guess, UC's financial situation and, I guess, the broader plans of managing its financial its revenue versus expenses, and its capital investments?
Speaker 117
So, I can talk about where we're sitting this year. So, we're aiming to deliver a pretty much a balanced result this year. I think that's from a series of losses.
The university has implemented strong financial
Speaker 117
Yes, a balanced result, which I think is a significant improvement from where the university was. Across the forward projections, I know in our I don't manage the finances of the university, but what I can say is the work that we are doing is around what does the asset replacement look like, what does the capital program look like across the forward years. And we do that on a risk-based approach.
Peter Cain
Thank you. Just a final one. Thanks, J. So, you said you intend to use the land for educational purpose and it's really already got that in its current zoning.
So, why support a rezoning?
Speaker 116
You know, I guess it doesn't have the flexibility under its current zoning.
Speaker 116
Well, we have looked at affordable housing, we have looked at key worker housing and other types of housing that would complement the campus and also contribute to our educational outcomes.
Peter Cain
How would I'm just trying to see how would education how would housing, means even if it's affordable housing, how is that going to contribute to an educational outcome?
Speaker 116
Most of this is enabling, or a lot of it can be enabling. There's also elements of these things that we've looked at around research within to different typologies of affordable housing and bits and pieces, and how-
Speaker 116
Enabling the activation of our campus, making it easier for people to find the university more accessible, so-
Speaker 116
No. Well, probably a different type of student accommodation in the sense that student accommodation isn't typically targeting broad base, it's normally a traditional student. There is a gap there in non-traditional student-
Peter Cain
So, just to finish, so, earlier you said that you don't need more student accommodation, but now it seems you're contemplating that you would, perhaps, have a student accommodation?
Peter Cain
And what would that look like? What would non-typical student accommodation look like?
Speaker 116
It's more of a residential setting designed for families who are looking for something-
Yvette?
Yvette Berry
Thank you. Look, the submissions that we've been hearing so far are pretty opposed to that. You've been here, you've heard them. So, is there, I mean, obviously, the government will make a decision around this and the committee will make recommendations based on these hearings, but does the UC then go back to the drawing board, or is there, do you have other plans in place for the potential for this site? Obviously, there's the feasibility work the education's doing around a potential primary school site adjacent to this site's a little bit small, I think.
I don't know, primary school, high school, but there are other sites on the UC campus, so if there was another, I guess you probably can't talk about this is hypothetical, what you could do if you have to go back to the drawing board on what would be possible on that site, people have really talked about Arcadia House.
Speaker 177
I think it's about how we term what does educational facilities, including student accommodation, what does that mean? So, yes, we would go back and look at scenarios, the same as you know, we are we do across all our campus, and in line with the campus master plan.
Speaker 170
I don't really have any more questions, I think that the submissions, I think there's a bit of we've got to find out from other people.
Speaker 176
I just wondered, has have you identified a site on the UC campus, the main campus, for a primary school?
Yes, we have.
Speaker 116
It's close to the core of the campus, so close to the centre of our campus, but it's aligned with the rapid transport network and others that make it attractive in terms of getting to and from the site.
Jo Clay
Thank you. Government's said that we need a primary school, and they're doing that feasibility which was going to be out in 25/26, and we're waiting for it, so it's great to hear that plans on the table. Have you got any Have you had any conversations with government about a high school down there, knowing that children age with the passage of time, and the kids who go to a primary school will also need to go to a high school?
I haven't, neither.
Not that I Not with me, anyway.
Not with me directly, no.
Speaker 166
Can you put it closer to the town centre so it's closer for um the children to walk?
Speaker 116
Well, I guess the broader question is can the university look at revising the master plan? Yes, we will refresh our master plan, and this is where the consultation will come into it. We'll have a look at what the community wants, what the university needs, and if we need to amend things, we amend things. At this stage, that it is located, as I said, in the centre. It does have some synergies being in the centre.
We can link it with the library, we can link it with retail services, it's close to security, central parking, and ovals, which is largely how it arrived at the location that it's proposed now. Um, yeah, but you know, these things are subject to time and change, so.
Speaker 116
Again, we already have two childcare facilities on our campus. Part of the planning is to look at long term what that looks like and whether there are options to integrate that with other educational partners, such as primary schools, high schools, and things like that. The intent I think is that we are focused on a vertical, like that was discussed as well, a compact, vertical model of education, and education partners is probably where we're massing these locations. So, integrating early learning would be a good thing for the university and the community, we think.
Jo Clay
Is there anything that we didn't ask that you wanted to make sure that we knew that's not in your submission?
Speaker 177
I mean, I think, Ms Clay, I'd just want to reiterate that we really do consider the community in our planning, and I think when you look across the facilities that are on UC, um, we are trying to make sure that our campus is a community asset. We are inviting more and more people onto campus. We had close to 8,000 people at open day, which was three times as many as we'd had a couple of years before. We had wood chopping, we had great community vibe. And, for us, that's really important, because we do see our role in Belconnen to be um, that as a steward of, you know, how do we actually bring people on, how do we use our ovals.
Speaker 117
I mean, our ovals are there for the use of the community, our health hub, our the hospital. We do want this to be considered by the community as its asset as well in terms of being able to come off campus. I think the vice-chancellor's been really clear about wanting people on our campus, so, um, you know, we're really happy to come here today and make sure that was really clear, that, as a university, we do consider the community that we are in, and we, um, appreciate the vibrancy of the community, and the growth that's in Belconnen, actually, um, and how can we support that growth. I think there's been some great conversations about what actually constitutes a community facility. I thought that was a great conversation, and certainly gave me food for thought about how we consider what's a community facility as well.
And I thought it was important that other contributors think about what does a community facility look like, because UC is really there as a community facility, and that's absolutely what the vice-chancellor and the rest of the executive are making sure that we're considering. So.
Dig out the splash.
Thank you.
Jo Clay
Yep, and our secretariat will help you out with that so that we can get that answered. And we would appreciate that answered within 5 days of you getting the uncorrected proof. And we will now break until 11:30, no, we are, yes, we'll now suspend
12:30.
Jo Clay
the proceedings until 12:30. We will now suspend until 12:30. Thank you.
Great. Welcome, Mr Chris Steel MLA, Minister for Planning and Sustainable Development, and officials from the City and Environment Directorate. For the Hansard record, we might start with you, Alix. If you can state your full name, your role and the agency you're here to represent.
Speaker 188
James Bennett, Executive Branch Manager, Building, Design and Development Branch.
Jo Clay
Thank you. As witnesses, you are protected by parliamentary privilege, and you are bound by its obligations. Witnesses must tell the truth; giving false or misleading evidence is a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. And we're not doing opening statements, so we'll proceed straight to questions. Minister, we had a good session with UC immediately prior to this, and we were discussing the terms on which UC acquired the lease in the first place.
Can you tell me the date and the type of lease that UC has for this site? Is it a market value lease?
Speaker 189
Yes, it's a market value lease, and it was granted on the 21st of December 2011 to UC.
Speaker 191
To UC, great. And as a market value lease, government would have had a value for the lease at the time?
Speaker 189
It went through a direct sale process, and it had was a nil value that was allocated through the direct sale process.
Jo Clay
So UC paid nil for it, but as a market value lease, isn't there usually a market value that attach? Did government conduct any kind of assessment to determine the value of the site before issuing that zero-dollar lease?
Jo Clay
Can you take that on notice? Thank you. We would like to know what process government went through to determine the value of that zero-dollar lease and also what the value of the site was put at. So if government went through a costing, a valuation for what the site was worth and came to something other than zero, we would also like to know what that value of the site was. The site appeared on UC books as worth $9 million, and it was reported in their annual report as $9 million worth of asset,
and they have told us now that at the moment they have it listed as worth $1.85 million. Have you got any You're obviously the territory authority is considering a matter to rezone that site. Does the territory authority or does government have any information about what that site is worth at the moment?
Jo Clay
Is that information that the territory authority or government would have in order to make a decision about rezoning the site? Would the decision-makers, I'm assuming it's the authority, but would the decision-makers wish to know the value of the site before deciding to rezone it?
Speaker 189
It's not standard to find out the value of the site. It's looking at more the uses that have been proposed, what benefits that they will have, the changes to the territory plan. So, it would be uncommon to find out that information about the site.
Speaker 195
Not the usual process. Excellent. If you can take on notice if you do have that information, provide it, and if you don't have that information, then obviously you don't need to provide it.
Speaker 196
And that's The value of the site is not a consideration under the statutory major plan amendment process, so it's not something that we consider in making strategic planning land use decisions.
Jo Clay
Sure. We have had a number of concerned community members. They're concerned about a number of aspects of this rezoning, but amongst their concerns are the fact that UC received the land for free for a certain purpose, which was for student housing. UC is now seeking to rezone it for other purposes, and I'll come to that in a second. And people are concerned that UC is now profiting from a free gift from the territory.
Speaker 194
If this site were rezoned for UC, and then UC redeveloped it, how would the territory get a return from that transfer of the gift? Where would the money go?
Speaker 197
So, that would come through the lease variation process that if they, while the territory plan may change to allow different uses on the site, the lease will also need to be varied. The lease at the moment is limited to educational establishment with some other words following that, but to In order to take up the opportunities of a zoning change, the lease will need to be varied, and lease variation charge may apply to the uplift through that lease variation.
Speaker 90
And that LVC process is a standard one that applies to all developers, and it's often applied at 75% of the uplift value. In this particular case, would UC be charged 75% of the uplift value? And would the uplift value be taken from $0, which is what UC paid for it? Or would the uplift value be taken from today's market value?
Speaker 197
The that lease variation charge is calculated by the statutory formula in the Planning Act, and that has a formula for how you calculate before value and after value. And so, it'll be calculated in accordance with the statutory process. There's no there's no special process for different sites, so that would be a before-value, after-value calculation.
And then, the way that lease variation charge is applied is that the charge is 75% of the uplift value.
Jo Clay
And the before value just cuz I you're more familiar with this instrument than I am, is the before value going to be today's market value of the site, or is the before value going to be $0 that UC paid for it?
Speaker 197
It's no, it's the before value at the time that you're seeking the lease variation. So, what someone paid for something in the past is a relevant consideration in that, but it is not the determining factor of what the before value is.
Jo Clay
So, the actual effect, if all of that happened, and obviously those things haven't happened yet, but the actual effect would be that UC would have received a site free of charge, and then, they would get to redevelop it, and they would only pay 75% of the value of the site plus the uplift, and they would have all of that first bit of value that they were given for free, they would still have that for free? Is that the actual impact of how that natural reading would flow?
Speaker 197
Potentially, that's how that would play out. So, the before value is not calculated by some historical number. It's calculated at the time that the lease variation is sought. So, if that before value is higher than a historical amount, it would be the current before value.
Jo Clay
And what's the public interest justification for an arrangement like that where UC, as a property developer, has received a free gift for a certain purpose and is then redeveloping the land for a different purpose? What's the public interest justification for that?
Speaker 189
I can So, I suppose in answer to the question for original question about the UC getting the site for $0, it was because it was related to the contribution for the ACT government to the National Rental Affordability Scheme that was happening at the time. So, by delivering the housing that was on the site, that was calculated, and this is I suppose the net value is deemed to be zero.
Jo Clay
And when the auditor-general looked at this, did the auditor-general decide that UC had actually made that full contribution into the NRAS scheme, into the National Housing Accord scheme at the time?
Was it NRAS?
Jo Clay
There was an audit into this matter in 2015 from the auditor-general. I wonder if you'd like to take on notice whether the auditor-general determined that UC had fully met its obligations or not.
We can, yeah.
Jo Clay
Thank you, that'd be great. We've also had a lot of community concern about the loss of community facilities zoned land in Belconnen, and we've had a number of people put up pretty good cases, frankly, that government is struggling to find community zoned land. Government found it difficult to find a site for Araluen house. That needs community zoned land. We have heard from UC that there may be plans for a primary school.
It doesn't UC tells us that they've never had any conversations with the ACT government about a high school, so it's great to hear that this pans coming on for the primary school, but it doesn't seem to be any consideration for a high school.
And there's a lot of community usage requirements for an area this big that is growing so rapidly. What is, how are you confident to give away the largest remaining community-zoned site in the heart of Belconnen, given all of those concerns?
Speaker 197
So, the provision of appropriate community facility land has been a key consideration of the territory planning authority in this application. We have looked at the historical use of this site. I think when the building was first built as a hostel, it was originally built and used as a hostel, and then when it came into ownership by the UC, that it was used as residential student accommodation. So, we've looked at the history of the site and how that particular block has contributed. We've also looked at the forward plans that the UC has put forward in their master plan for this site.
A very key consideration of the authority has been the desire to secure an appropriate community facility provision from this site, and that's reflected in a territory plan assessment outcome that's included, and there's a supporting technical specification that is included there as well. The authority considers that, with the historical use of this site and the proposed use, that the provision that requires community facilities to be provided and a minimum technical specification, that would improve, overall, the provision of community facilities on this site as part of the Belconnen district.
Jo Clay
And has the authority made an assessment of all of the community-zoned land in Belconnen CBD, or is the authority simply looking at this block?
Speaker 197
We are looking at the Belconnen town centre more broadly, through a separate piece of work where we're looking at the provision of social and community facility sites across the Belconnen town centre. This particular site doesn't sit within the strict boundary of the Belconnen town centre; it sits just outside of that, and we have looked at, as you're aware, the social and community facilities audit that we've done as well, and that's played a key part of the considerations about what suitable contribution this site can make to the broader community facility provision across the district.
Speaker 90
And have you seen how many community witnesses have interpreted, they consider this as 8% of the town centre's community land, where the authority seems to be considering this as 0.24% of the entire community land in the whole greater district? Do you understand how the community considers this as kind of part of our town centre, and so it's quite a big proportion of it?
Speaker 197
We appreciate that it's very close to the town centre, and, in terms of that strict boundary, it's adjacent to the town centre; it's not within the town centre boundary. But, yes, and the authority agrees that this is a key site and needs to provide a suitable community facility contribution to the district and to the town centre users as well, and that's why we've had a territory plan assessment outcome that's included, and that's supported by a technical specification as well.
Jo Clay
Some of the sites that are considered by the authority, I think, as community sites are sites like Radford College. Do you imagine that Radford College would be happy to locate Arcadia House or a community recreation facility on their grounds, or do you see-?
Chris Steel
Sorry, I just- Yep. Want to remind everyone this is a proponent-initiated amendment- Yep. And the territory planning authority explicitly addressed the issue around the percentage of community facilities land in the consultation report attached to the MPA.
Yep. So, that's on page 9 of the consultation report, and the authority has acknowledged concerns regarding methodology used by the proponent- Yep. Who is putting forward this major plan amendment, so- Thanks. So, maybe I'll restate the question.
So it's not the TPA that's saying 0.24%. That's what I'm saying. It's the proponent.
Speaker 90
Cool. Thank you, just be clear about that. Does the authority consider that this is a significant proportion of the community zoned land for Belconnen town centre? So, this site's not in the town centre. So,
the authority is only considering this site as part of the Belconnen greater district and is not considering the impact of losing community zoned land as a town centre issue, it is only considering it as a Belconnen greater district issue?
Speaker 197
Just in terms of the methodology, I just wanted to be clear that it's not in the boundary. We have absolutely considered the appropriate provision of community facilities for the people of Belconnen, and that's why we have put in and including those who live in the town centre, and those in the broader district, because it is technically outside that boundary. And that is why we have included a requirement that this makes an appropriate contribution to the provision of community facilities, and we set a minimum technical specification just for that site. We agree that this site needs to provide ongoing community facility provision for the Belconnen community.
Speaker 197
That's that is, and as I said, back to the historical use of the site, that is a significant increase from what has previously operated there, which in its most recent history was a as a private student accommodation facility.
Speaker 90
And I'll hand over to my colleagues, I have one more question. We asked UC what they wanted they are seeking a rezoning, and we asked them why they needed the rezoning, what they wanted to do with the land, and they weren't really able to answer that question. They said they hadn't decided yet, not to verbal them, but just see there's lots of different ideas and they haven't actually decided. Why do does the authority typically rezone land when there's actually no need to rezone the land, because the person who holds it in current zoning
may not need a rezoning? It seems unusual to me to need to seek a rezoning if you don't actually even know that what you want to do would require a rezoning.
Speaker 197
I can't answer that on behalf of the UC, but the Territory Planning Authority has received a proponent initiated major plan amendment, and that major plan amendment is supported by a supporting report, and an indicative master plan for the site, and that is what the authority has assessed this application on the basis of. The information provided by the proponent through the proponent initiated pathway, we have assessed that information that they have given to us, and the indicative site master plan that they've put forward, and the range of uses that are proposed in that, this change would facilitate the proposed master plan that they've put forward for this site to the authority under the proponent initiated process.
Speaker 90
Thank you. I might get you to take this on notice and I'll hand over. Can you provide on notice what you consider the boundary of the Belconnen Town Centre? Because I've just been reminded that the 2016 Belconnen Town Centre Master Plan has this site as part of the town centre. So, I think there's obviously a bit of
disagreement across different government planning processes as whether as to whether this is or isn't in the town centre. If you can provide on notice
Speaker 197
I can tell you now, it's in the commercial zones policy in the territory plan, and the and in the description of the town centre boundaries in the act.
Speaker 197
I don't know the explicit boundary there. The master plan for Belconnen may have had a different boundary, but in terms of the statutory boundaries that we're talking about, those are those which are set out in the act, and also the commercial zones policy in the territory plan.
Okay.
Fiona Carrick
Thank you, Chair. So, it appears that the land is surplus to needs to UC,
And it is very close, whether it's with or with in or out of the boundaries for the town centre, it's very close. So did the government ever consider asking UC to hand the land back so that it could be used for the purposes of the town centre, as opposed to the purposes of UC?
Speaker 197
This is a privately leased block and the lessee of that block has the right to use it as they wish. I'm not aware that the government has asked the UC to sell that land back to the government.
Fiona Carrick
Well, given it's only back on their books at $1.85 million, it'd be a bit of a steal, like a bargain, to pay them the book value that they have. So it is an opportunity to ask for the land back. Well, I mean, no harm in asking because they don't actually, you know, they didn't, couldn't identify what they really wanted it for. I mean, I didn't ask the question directly, but I assume they want to develop the site as a revenue stream. So as a revenue stream to UC.
But for the value of the book value of the land, it there are opportunities for the government to provide something for the Belconnen Town Centre. So is it, you know, like I guess it comes back to the planning. Is there, do you intend to do a town plan, because the last batch of master plans are like 10 years old now, so do you intend to do a new batch of master plans or have a bit more detail in the district strategies, which actually sets out the land use and so that block of land could be identified for a community need for the town centre, as opposed to a revenue stream for UC?
Speaker 197
I think in the context of the Belconnen Town Centre, the directorate's undertaking detailed planning and technical studies that support the future planning for the Belconnen Town Centre, and that's looking at implementing the Belconnen district strategy. That work will consider the provision of community and social facilities across the town centre, and I think the plan for that is to release that work mid-2027 for community consultation, but that detailed planning work to implement the district strategy is being undertaken at the moment.
Chris Steel
The supporting documentation from the authority has talked about the outcomes from the community needs assessment infrastructure audit of December 2025 for the Belconnen district and what the specific needs are that have been identified in that piece of work that are being considered as part of the future planning for the Belconnen Town Centre.
Fiona Carrick
And given that community land is pretty precious to hang onto, because if you have facilities that are on commercial land as opposed to community facility land, they're at risk of development. So, CISAC, for example, is on commercial land and, you know, people get worried that it's at risk. So, have you ever considered rezoning places like CISAC and the Belconnen Arts Centre and the basketball stadium to be community facility land so that they are protected by the zoning of community facility land?
Speaker 197
I don't believe that's been actively considered. The facilities on those sites are have been developed within those zones. I don't think there's any active work to look at rezoning those particular
Fiona Carrick
Okay. And just one last thing from me for the minute. With the school, the UC says that they're planning a primary school and the community is very keen for a primary school for the town centre, primarily children, because it's, you know, like developing the population is growing. So what conversations have you had with UC about an appropriate site for a primary school?
Speaker 197
So the planning authority explicitly, I don't believe that we've had any explicit conversations with UC about the site for a primary school.
That would be led by the Education Directorate. The Education Directorate are doing a lot of work to understand future school needs across the Belconnen district, including in the Belconnen town centre and potential future demand in the Belconnen town centre, and there's a range of budget initiative-funded projects to do early planning work around that. There's the potential for new development in the Ginninderra East, former CSIRO site, that could provide the need for future school facilities as well,
but that work is being led by the Education Directorate to plan for those future needs.
Fiona Carrick
So, you don't want children to have to walk too far. Like, Florey is 2.6 k's, for little kids, that's a long walk each way. So, how do you how does the Education Directorate dial into the planning directorate? Because there's a whole heap of needs, not only schools, there's a lot of needs.
So how do you work it out if you've got each directorate doing their own thing?
Speaker 197
Well we work very closely with the Education Directorate about the future need for school sites and the availability of land for those school sites. I believe that the Education Directorate answered in a response to an assembly resolution last year that they're undertaking assessments for the future need of a new school in the Belconnen town centre. Currently, there's enrolment capacity at primary and early childhood sites in suburbs adjacent to the Belconnen town centre, but that is something that they're actively looking at and planning for. And when the Education Directorate sort of identify the need for a new school site, they will work closely with the planning authority to identify and potentially rezone, if required, appropriate parcels of land for that purpose.
Peter Cain
Thank you. Are you aware when this feasibility study into the primary school will be completed?
We can take that on notice.
Chris Steel
But they I think just important to note page eight of the consultation report, which explicitly deals with the Education Directorate's response to the consultation on the draft plan amendment, where the Education Directorate advised the TPO that they are not seeking to acquire the site for the purposes of developing a primary school.
Speaker 215
So, how much engagement is the directorate having with this study into whether a primary school is feasible or not? City Services is running this?
Speaker 197
That work will be led by the Education Directorate to identify whether there is demand for a future primary school site in the Belconnen town centre, or whether that demand is appropriately met through schools in other suburbs in the Belconnen district, and potentially new Scott school sites, or upgrades to the capacity of existing school sites. So that work would will be led by the Education Directorate. At the point in time where they identify particular land-use needs, they will engage with the territory planning authority in that process.
Speaker 212
So there's no ongoing conversation now with the planning authority about that, except to be notified of developments? What kind of engagement are you having?
Speaker 197
We engage regularly with them on that. I'm not aware of any explicit conversation about that for now. I think as the Minister mentioned, the response and the feedback from the Education Directorate is summarized in the consultation report, and that's the current status of those conversations.
Peter Cain
So, we heard a figure from BAHA, the Belconnen Alliance of Highrise Apartments, that the last census identified that 8.7% of children, 8.7 of the people who live in the centre were under 14, 0 to 14. The census, recent census, will highlight any change in that. So with the planning, though, particularly for a site that's zoned educational,
Speaker 212
does that factor in your calculations of whether this zoning, the zoning change should be approved or not?
Speaker 197
It's, I think it's a question for Education about their school planning, and the available sites that they might need. There's no proposal for a school on this particular site, and the Education Directorate have not advised that they would be looking at this particular site for a future school.
Peter Cain
Now we heard earlier that the educational purpose of the land will be preserved. Is that something that from a planning point of view that you want to see, to absolutely ensure that it's kept for an educational purpose?
Speaker 197
The proponent has sought to amend the zoning of the site from a community facility zone land, with a lease that is currently has a purpose clause that is limited to educational establishment. If they were to seek if they were to be successful of having the land rezone, it opens up a range of other uses that they could prepare, and they will need to undertake a lease variation. The authority has been keen to lock in the provision of community facilities on that site, and so that's where we have focused our work, and the assessment requirements under the proposed DPA require future provision of community facilities on that site. Under the current zoning, there's a range of there's a range of uses that they could put that site to. There's one described in the lease, but there are a range of other uses that they could put that site to, and there's the ability to apply through the territory plan to vary that lease to access the available uses within the zone.
Speaker 217
So, the update to the district strategies, when's that due to be completed and published?
Speaker 211
If sorry, are you referring to what I said before about implementing the district strategies?
Speaker 197
So the directorate is doing work on detailed planning and technical studies for the Belconnen Town Centre, and we expect that work to be released around mid next year for a community consultation.
Peter Cain
Mid next year for consultation. So is it anticipated that the level of detail would be the equivalent of effectively a master plan for the town centre, or much broader than that?
Speaker 197
I think it will look at how the current district strategy and the current district strategy reflecting the previous Belconnen master plan, how that has been delivered, and whether sort of the delivery of that, and the uptake of the opportunities that were previously put forward in the previous version of the territory plan, whether they have been realized, in what way they've been realized, and what future planning needs to deliver for the town centre.
So that would be looking at the range of issues, especially around the provision of social and community facilities across the Town Centre and there'll be particular work that's undertaken and put forward around that.
Peter Cain
So, what have you, what can you draw attention to in the original master plan from over 10 years ago now that are obviously needs significant revision? Or are we just going to see a slightly amended version of that?
Speaker 197
I think the work that's being undertaken is looking around is looking at some of the change areas that are identified in the district strategies and what opportunities relate to those sites which are identified in the district strategy.
Speaker 197
We I might need to take on notice exactly what the timeline for that work is and what will be put out, but we expect that work to be completed for a conversation next year and in the exact form of that I'll need to check with the
Peter Cain
And feel free to provide a fairly detailed timeline of all stages of, I guess, the review of the district strategies and things that you've pulled out of the previous master plan and obviously the very different nature of the town centre.
Chris Steel
Well, the government hasn't taken a review of district strategies which would which has to occur, well, may undertake to review the district strategies every 5 years under the which will occur, obviously they have only been in place for a relatively short period of time, but that would likely occur after the planning and the strategy is developed and consulted on with the community. The government hasn't determined to actually go out and consult on changes to the Belconnen to the territory plan in Belconnen. We're undertaking some work looking at the implementation of the district strategies, but we actually haven't determined that we would go out for consultation with the community on any particular proposal at this time.
Yvette Berry
Good. Thanks. So, I just wanted to confirm the current site that the University of Canberra have applied for direct territory plan variation, is that right? That site they leased the site from the government for the student housing. I should have asked that of UC when they were here, 'cause it was initially student housing, right?
Speaker 197
They have a market value lease over that site, which has a lease purpose clause of educational establishment and the ability to use that for student accommodation. Right.
Chris Steel
And it was used in various different ways for student accommodation. At one point it was licensed to the UC Students Association, which operated Arscott House for a period of a few years and then it was before it was then handed back to UC. I think that was in 2014. I think the proponent's supporting report has a timeline in it with some of that information. So, it was used for that purpose previously.
I understand the proponent's putting forward in their at least what's put forward in their landscape plan, master plan for the site, that they want to use the site for a residential purpose as well as having that community.
Speaker 216
So, it would be some form of residential component, which is what the site, being an office, which is what it was used for before for the students, but obviously this it would be a broader residential use would be a potential use.
Yvette Berry
I think that's the thing that people are worried about, not so much the student, while some have differing views, but it's, but its use is for community benefit for the Belconnen Town Centre and the ACT. For the authority to not rezone, have you got some examples of reasons on other sites where the authority has said, "No, that master plan is not within the best interests," or whatever, and we won't we don't agree to rezone?
Speaker 197
So, when a proponent, under the statutory process, when a proponent comes along with a proponent-initiated amendment, there's a two-step process to that. They make an application to the Territory Planning Authority, and we that we undertake an initial assessment about whether that application is broadly consistent with the planning strategy, the district strategies, and any sort of detailed directions that the government has for this area. And then we decide whether or not to accept that application. Accepting the application doesn't mean that the government necessarily endorses all parts of it, but thinks that it's worthy to then take through the process to be assessed and considered.
And then we put that out to entities for feedback and comment, and we put it out for public consultation. And then, when all of that information comes back, the authority then considers that application and decides whether to then progress it to revise it or not revise it, and then progress it to the minister, who then has to refer it to the committee for an inquiry. There are times where people make applications to us for change, and also in the sort of pre-lodgement conversations that we have with people about particular change ideas, where we give them an indication about whether that application could be considered under the process. And generally, that needs to align with the broader strategic planning framework for the city, set out in the planning strategy and the district strategy.
Speaker 213
They'll need to demonstrate consistency or not being inconsistent with those.
Yvette Berry
Do you So, is that other individuals or organizations that put applications in?
Speaker 197
Yes, and any private lessee has the ability to seek a major plan amendment, and so that application process provides that scrutiny about whether we can say no right up front if this is beyond the realms of what we would consider for that site, or this can be considered in some form, and we can put it through the statutory assessment process.
Yvette Berry
And then, can the authority then require an overlay, like this site has a current overlay of educational purposes or whatever?
Speaker 197
Yep. So the proponent is entitled to make the application. The authority is not obliged to progress that in exactly the form that the proponent puts that forward. So, while the proponent makes the application and provides the initial supporting report for that application, it's then the authority who can add or detract some requirements or obligations from that plan amendment. So, there's some changes that are outlined in here about what the proponent put forward, and where the Territory Planning Authority has made some variations from that supporting report. And this is where we can look at things that might limit the overall negative impacts from a proposed change that a proponent might put forward, so that we can manage and mitigate those impacts, and the authority can then put that forward into the assessment process for consideration.
Yvette Berry
One of the, I think, things that we've heard from witnesses that they're worried about is that it will be sold on to someone else for re- for development once it gets this, re- if it's successful in getting this territory plan zone changed. Can the government do anything to stop that from happening?
Speaker 197
No, but what we can do is make sure that the site is appropriately zoned with the appropriate territory plan provisions that would control how any future development application is assessed. And in this particular example, the change from community facility zone to CZ2 opens up a range of opportunities, but we have also included mandatory requirements that they need to provide an appropriate community facility provision on this site. So, that obligation will transfer with any future lessee if they were to sell it, and that would every future developer development application on the site would be assessed against that requirement, which would be put into the territory plan.
Speaker 197
Yes, and we have picked up through the draft plan amendment process a requirement that they have to provide an appropriate community facility. And then in our technical specification guidance, we've put a 3,000 square meter requirement in there for them to, which reflects the master plan, the indicative master plan provision that they put forward.
Yvette Berry
Is there a is there a formula for how much of community facilities on a site like that would be required? Like, is or is it just, oh, we think about this much is right?
Speaker 197
What we have done here is assessed a range of factors there. We've also looked at the master plan proposal that they've put forward, which identifies a particular building of a particular size, and that's the sort of indicative facility that we've put forward in the technical specification. But then in the territory plan requirement, there's an assessment outcome that says you must provide an appropriate facility for the for is contributing to the supply of community facilities to the district. So, that assessment outcome has to be met. There might be some slight variance of what that size might be, but 3,000 is put in there as a reasonable estimate of that number and that reflects the balanced master plan proposal that they've put forward.
Yvette Berry
And you could the planning authority tighten that community facilities part even more like and put a requirement for a particular community facility, because it's such a broad reference?
Speaker 197
Yeah, we could do that, and there's a range of options that could be considered there about being more explicit about the types of uses or more explicit about the size of the facility that needs to be.
Yvette Berry
Would there be other reasons besides the ones that have you've described that they meet the territory's, you know, broader strategy going forward? Would there be reasons outside of that the authority could go, actually, this isn't this doesn't actually tick all the boxes that we needed to?
Speaker 197
As the Territory Planning Authority, we need to assess these applications under the process that's set out in the planning legislation. So, our obligation is to follow statutory provisions.
Jo Clay
I might pick up on that 3,000 square meters. Is that would be a requirement in the technical specifications, from which So, the technical specifications aren't actually mandatory though, are they? So, we could easily see a situation where if there's a requirement under tech specs for 3,000 square meters and the site's been sold on, that the new leaseholder would not actually provide 3,000 square meters of community facility?
Speaker 197
That's correct that technical specifications are not mandatory, but what is the mandatory requirement here is a an assessment outcome that's put into the Belconnen district policy that says that this site needs to make a suitable contribution to the long-term provision of community and social facilities in the broader Belconnen area. So, that is the assessment outcome. So, it's hard to see a way that a future development application could include no community facilities because it would be making no contribution to long-term provision.
We have put in a reference point into the Tech Specs based on the master plan proposal that they put forward that describes an appropriate size facility, that would be a reference point for the assessment of that provision, but any future application could deliver more and that would be needing to meet this definition of suitable contribution and that they will need to provide evidence in a development application as to why that would be a suitable provision as part of the district, and that's why we've worked through that methodology about space and available space per square meter per capita.
Speaker 90
In the consultation report you say the authority considers broader strategic planning advice, including population growth, distribution of facilities and accessibility of services across Belconnen District. What was the broader consultation advice that you considered in this case, like what was the evidence that you took into account?
Speaker 197
Oh, so that sort of set out in the Consultation with Government entities is set out in the report. We've also reviewed the application against the Planning Strategy and the District Strategies, and have engaged closely with those other parts of government who have potentially an interest in community facilities, education facilities to understand their view on this application.
Speaker 225
And in reducing from 10,000 square meters of community space to 3,000 square meters, what population figures were you taking into account?
Speaker 197
So we have looked at the previous use of this site as largely being a site that has provided a different type of residential accommodation over its recent history, and while that's been in various forms, this has largely been student residential accommodation. And so we have sought to ensure that any future development of the site includes an improved provision of community, social and community facilities that are actually available to the community. So we think that compared to what is what has been there and what will be there in the future, this will be an improvement of social and community facilities on the site.
Jo Clay
Sure, and if you fill in a hole in the ground you've got something better than a hole in the ground, that's great. Were you considering the future projected population though and did you do this, is there a written document in which you made this consideration?
Speaker 197
So the page 9 of the Consultation Report sets out the sort of authorities consideration of that and references the Community Facility Needs Assessment and the Social Infrastructure Audit, and talks that's is in the context of future population growth and potential gaps in provision of community and social infrastructure facilities in the Belconnen District.
Speaker 218
And just humor me, what was the population figure that was being used there?
Speaker 197
I don't have that in front of me, but that would be set out in the audit report.
Jo Clay
Is And where would I find that order? What I'm trying to find out is are you using the population now or are you using the population that you've already projected will be there?
Speaker 201
Our assessment of potential needs is a forward looking assessment out to 2051, and has and considers population growth out to.
Speaker 197
The sort of needs for the Belconnen District as they evolve over time, that's what's outlined in the Infrastructure Audit. So it's got a range of things that are outlined.
Speaker 90
In reducing 7,000 square meters, what population figure have you based that determination on? Is that a Is that a question that can be answered? I'm trying to make it as simple as possible. You've determined we can do with 7,000 less square meters. How many people are you looking at when you say we can get rid of 7,000 square meters?
Speaker 197
And I think our answer to that is that we've been actually keen to promote this as we're getting 3,000 more square meters of dedicated social and community facility space because that's current.
Because there's nothing there now.
Speaker 197
Well, there's nothing there now, but there wasn't anything like that provided in the previous use of the site, which was largely used for student residential accommodation. So, people have lived on this site for its sort of its history, and while it had a particular zoning, we've sought to make sure that the future use of the site has dedicated community facilities on it.
Chris Steel
So, there's various the community needs, the community and recreational needs, and the infrastructure audit report looks at projected population by district from in 2026, 2031, 2036, 2041, 2046, 2051, and the changes in between.
Jo Clay
Thank you, Minister. Auditor-General Maxine Cooper in 2016 said if Arscott House was no longer to be used for student accommodation and the university made a profit from it should make an appropriate adjustment to the ACT government. And when she said that, the site was valued at $9 million. Did government respond to that recommendation from the Auditor-General back in 2016?
Speaker 235
Excellent. And if government you that's great that you've taken that on notice, and can you tell me what government's position is as of today to that recommendation from the Auditor-General?
Excellent.
Speaker 234
Sorry, can I just-- I think that the 9 million was because it had infrastructure on the site. I think that's what UC said.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Once you go ahead, and then Peter.
Fiona Carrick
We have the outcomes-based framework, planning framework now, so how did you assess the outcomes, and how did you access assess the outcomes for the community and the public interest?
Of what?
Fiona Carrick
Well, it's an outcomes-based plan, you know, we're getting supposed to be getting assessing things against We're supposed to be getting good outcomes, it's an outcomes-based framework. So, how did you ensure that we got the good outcomes for the community, and it's all in the public interest?
Chris Steel
So, I think firstly, I haven't made a decision on the application yet, so I haven't considered the Planning Act provisions in relation to this, and I just refer you to those specific provisions of the Planning Act, which are relevant in this case. So, introducing terms which aren't necessarily reflected in the Planning Act, like public interest, is not necessarily helpful in the discussion around the assessment of these applications, because they're made against the requirements of the Planning Act. Public interest has been used in the previous Planning Act on certain decisions, but there's a very specific set of provisions in the Planning Act.
Speaker 229
Shouldn't beyond the outcomes be in the planning, in the public interest?
Speaker 226
Well, let me find the section, I'll run through, but I don't know whether you want to comment more broadly on the--
Speaker 197
I think in the broader context, the public interest is reflected in that the act is there, and the objects of the Planning Act talk about providing for the future planning needs of the city. It's reflected in the planning strategy, and it's reflected in the district strategies about how the planning system needs to provide those range of options for housing, for community facilities, for recreation, planning for the environment.
And so, all of those sort of broader factors are reflected in the act and the strategic planning framework, and we assess applications to change the territory plan against that planning framework, legislative process and the statutory planning documents being that planning strategy and the district strategy. We have been very keen through this MPA process to lock in the appropriate provision of social and community facilities on this site in the future. And so, we have a an outcome, an assessment outcome that's included in the territory plan. And so that means that the proponent of a future development application that would be assessed against this provision will need to demonstrate that any new development proposal provides an adequate provision of community and social facilities for the broader Belconnen area. That outcome will need to be met in any DA, and that is supported by a technical specification that says a reference point of about 3,000 square meters.
So, that has been locked in, that any future development application will need to be assessed against that requirement and need to deliver that requirement in order for it to be approved. There's been a particular proposal put forward to support the territory plan change, but there'll be a subsequent, detailed development application that will need to be supported and demonstrate how it meets that provision.
Chris Steel
So, section, sorry, apologies, just jump in, so section 75 is the relevant section, and, which goes to consideration of documents given to the minister under section 67, any, which is, which includes the draft of my plan amendment itself and the supporting documentation, any recommendation made by the Assembly committee, the planning strategy, the district strategy, and then the minister may only approve draft plan of major plan amendment, the draft amendment is not inconsistent with the planning strategy or the relevant district strategy.
Peter Cain
So, have you or any part of government that you are aware of done a business case as to the revenue collected if this DPA is approved? And what would revenue be from rates, land tax, and other charges for various development scenarios?
Speaker 197
No, we haven't, and that's not a consideration under the planning act major plan amendment process.
Peter Cain
And have you decided if this DPA is approved, as part of your consideration of the DPA, what would be your preferred development?
Speaker 197
We have assessed this application on the basis of the indicative master plan proposal that was put forward by the proponent, but this enables a range of uses, and they'll need to consider what the appropriate mix of uses is for a future development.
Speaker 231
Apart from This is the UC master plan you're think Is that what you're referring to?
Speaker 197
The documentation which was attached to the proponent initiated amendment which they have put forward and the master plan indicative master plan proposal that they have included, that has formed the basis of the assessment of this application that's been put forward.
Peter Cain
So, what else has formed the basis of your assessment? What, for example, I mean, we have a dated master plan for Belconnen, we have district strategies. What are you weighing, what are you considering from, I guess, the government's own strategies and announcements and priorities? What else are you considering as to whether this should be approved?
Speaker 197
We're not considering anything else. What the assessment against the statutory requirements is outlined in the DPA document and the supporting report.
Peter Cain
You're not You're not in a tunnel here of the UC proposal, and that's all you look at. What else are you considering, and what weight would you give those things in deciding this DPA?
Speaker 197
So, we consider the planning strategy, the relevant Belconnen district strategy, any
Speaker 197
No. No, there's an existing Belconnen district strategy. It identifies a range of things, and for the town centre it also identifies a range of change areas, and what we were talking about before was planning and technical studies to understand what options there might be for those change areas identified in the district strategy. There's no proposals that are arising from those necessarily, there is work being undertaken to explore opportunities for those change areas, and that's what we were talking about being put out, the outcomes of that work being put out mid-next year.
But the what we have to consider when a proponent makes a proponent-initiated amendment is very clear in the Planning Act. We can only consider those things. We can't consider things outside the statutory process.
Speaker 239
You can't? So, what about other you can engage other directorates, as to you've obviously got an educational interest in this?
Speaker 197
So, that referral to relevant entities is part of the statutory process that's outlined in the Act.
Peter Cain
So, what's the feedback from Treasury as to obviously the bottom-line figure for them as to how much revenue they would like to see from this land?
Speaker 197
We don't consult with Treasury as part of a major plan amendment process, and the value of land is not a consideration in the Planning Act about strategic land use for strategic land use change.
Speaker 197
That's not a consideration about how land should be zoned as part of the strategic planning process.
Chris Steel
Community needs are relevant, because they're referenced quite a bit in the district strategies, and so the just to draw your attention to page 10 of the consultation report, just around the specific things that the ACT Community Sport and Recreation Facilities Needs Assessment and Social Infrastructure Audit Final Report mentioned for that district of Belconnen, specifically the gaps in the provision of community and social infrastructure relating to community-accessible meeting rooms based in libraries and/or community centres, community centres youth and senior citizens centres, best practice is to provide multi-use, multi-purpose centres, expansion of library spaces and community arts centres, formal and informal sports spaces, including courts and BMX/skate parks. Sure.
So, those are needs that obviously that the territory planning authority would take into account in assessing what's being proposed, and I guess it's a question of, well, is what they're proposing consistent with some of those needs, and that might be taken into account.
Peter Cain
And so, if, as you consider approving this DPA or otherwise, do you turn your mind to what the land will be used for as a possible use under the varied plan and what's your preferred use for the land?
Speaker 197
Yes, and I'd say, in this particular instance, that's what has been put forward by the proponent as part of their indicative master plan.
Speaker 232
What's the thing that they've put forward that you're referring to now?
Speaker 197
That's the master plan document that's attached to their to the background papers which we've published on the planning website with the DPA documents. I think the other point to make is that the list of needs that the Minister has just read out about social and community infrastructure needs in the Belconnen area, I think it's important to make the point that community-accessible meeting rooms and community centres, those are two identified needs, and the particular master plan proposal that's put forward and the community centre that's provided in that has the ability to meet that need should those organisations wish to pursue those conversations with the lessee.
Fiona Carrick
Can I ask my question? I just want to ask about, you know, you say that the needs are community centres and meeting rooms and what have you, but is this an appropriate site for that? Because it's not in the town centre, you know. If you want to have meeting rooms and community centres and that where you know, you want to you want to consider where you place your community centres and that they're appropriately sited, not just because, you know, a developer-led proposal comes forward and says, "We'll put one here." Like, is that Is there any consideration of you know, whether that's the best site for the community to have a community centre?
Speaker 197
This site has the ability to provide that provision, should it be should it be taken up, but we wouldn't specify that particular organisations need to set up their services in that building. And there's a range of other sites in the town centre and work going on to look at where other sites may need to be provided as well.
Fiona Carrick
And I just want to ask, when we I think there's a bit of confusion between, you know, you mentioned community facilities and social infrastructure. What is a community facility compared to social facility You know, like, we use a whole heap of different language for this. And so if this is community facilities, does that mean does that mean it could be social infrastructure? And what is the difference? Like, what are we going to get there?
Speaker 197
I mean, there's a there's a range of definitions which are provided in different parts of the planning system. But we're talking here about facilities that are available to community groups to use in various forms.
Speaker 197
Under the community facility zone and the definition, there are a range of things that could be delivered there.
Chris Steel
And under the current zoning, without the zoning change, they could deliver an aged-care facility through a development application tomorrow if they wished, on this site, which if it wasn't approved, they may consider, I'm not sure.
Jo Clay
All right, team, thank you for your time today. Thank you for your evidence. We thank our witnesses. We thank broadcasting and Hansard. Thank you, as always.
Anyone who wants to lodge a question on notice, please lodge it within, as soon as possible, no later than 5 business days. And we are now adjourned. Thank you.