Legislative Assembly (28 October 2026, 2:00 pm)

28 October 2026

Legislative Assembly ACT Legislative Assembly

Follow its sittings
00:05 - 00:11
Speaker 13
Mr Speaker. 
00:11 - 00:17
Speaker 12
Thank you, members.  Questions without notice and I call the Leader of the Opposition. 
00:17 - 00:52
Speaker 7
Thank you, Mr Speaker.  My question is to the Minister for Health.  The former Labor Chief Minister Jon Stanhope has declared that the years of policy decisions under the reign of Rachel Stephen-Smith are directly to blame for the deterioration of the ACT's public health system.  Does the minister accept that the state of the system inherited from the previous minister is in significant crisis and in fact is an indictment on the leadership of Minister Stephen-Smith? 
00:52 - 00:54
Speaker 3
Minister. 
00:54 - 01:34
Speaker 11
Thank you for the question.  It's an excellent opportunity to talk about how our health system has been going from strength to strength, particularly under the previous minister's leadership.  We've seen significant improvements in our emergency department wait times over the past few years.  We've seen significant investment in elective surgeries.  And as we've been very much discussing this week, we are beginning a massive reform project through implementing Walsh reform recommendations, which I'll come to the chamber with a government response in the not-too-distant future. 
01:34 - 01:42
Speaker 9
So I feel that the health portfolio is in a very strong position and feel very proud to take the leadership position. 
01:42 - 01:44
Speaker 1
Mr Parton, a supplementary? 
01:44 - 01:58
Speaker 7
Thank you, Mr Speaker.  Given the scale of the problems inherited, has the minister sought additional funding or changes to the government's health policy settings to address the underly the underlying causes of the system's decline? 
01:58 - 02:00
Speaker 5
Minister. 
02:00 - 02:15
Speaker 9
So we are I'm two months into the role, and we have not yet gone through a budget process with me in this position.  So I will absolutely wholeheartedly embrace that process when it begins. 

02:15 - 02:17

Jeremy Hanson

Yes, Mr Cocks?

02:17 - 02:26

Ed Cocks

118AA, the question was specifically about the underlying causes of the systems decline. It wasn't about budget processes.

02:26 - 02:46

Jeremy Hanson

I think it was. Mr Cocks, I think it was specific Minister, there's a point of order. I'd ask you either raise a point of order, let me rule. I the question was about, "Has the minister sought additional funding?" And she did respond to that, she was responsive.

There is no point of order. A supplementary?

02:46 - 02:59

Deborah Morris

Supplementary, thank you. Has Minister Stephen-Smith enabled the most significant decline of public of our public health system since self-government, as per Mr Stanhope's comments?

02:59 - 03:00

Minister.

03:00 - 03:53

Marisa Paterson

Minister Stephen-Smith, when she held the health portfolio, has directed the health system through a major international pandemic. We've seen year-on-year increases in demand for our services, our health services across the board, including our ambulance service. So we have a health system that's under strain, as the chamber would be aware. There's all sorts of workforce pressures as well.

But we despite all those things continue to have a health system that is improving, that has we're seeing emergency department wait times reduce. We are seeing elective massive investment in elective surgery waitlists, and we will continue to invest in our health system to see improvements for the Canberra community.

03:53 - 03:58

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. A new question, Ms Castley.

03:58 - 04:16

Speaker 35

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Chief Minister. Today's ABS data confirms a months-long trend where CPI is increasing more in Canberra than the national average, hitting almost 5% over the past year. Why is the cost of living rising faster in Canberra than the rest of Australia?

04:16 - 04:18

Jeremy Hanson

Chief Minister.

04:18 - 04:38

Speaker 48

I thank Ms Castley for the question. Thank you. Looking at the data, transport costs, recreation and housing were the main drivers of the increase. I think on an annualized rate though, the ACT is within 0.1% of the national rate over the course of the last 12 months.

04:38 - 04:40

Jeremy Hanson

Ms Castley, a supplementary.

04:40 - 04:48

Speaker 35

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Chief Minister, what are the implications for the ACT budget of inflation that is almost double the government's forecasts?

04:48 - 04:49

Chief Minister.

04:49 - 05:10

Speaker 48

Well, that's somewhat speculative as we won't be delivering a budget until June next year. We'll see where inflation is at that point, noting of course that the Reserve Bank are exercising their monetary policy levers with the desire to return inflation to the 2 to 3% underlying rate.

05:10 - 05:13

Jeremy Hanson

No supplementary. A new question, Ms Clay.

05:13 - 05:57

Jo Clay

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Minister for City Services. Construction has begun on the replacement recycling center. Infrastructure Canberra said that soft plastics recycling is a problem for all of Australia and that, quote, "It's a national thing that is being worked on." But it's not a national thing that is being worked on.

A month ago the federal Labor government backflipped on their promise to bring in mandatory federal product stewardship laws nationally. Those laws would have made the big corporations who make and sell plastic packaging responsible for paying to recycle it and for designing it out in the first place. Given this backflip, what was Infrastructure Canberra referring to when they said soft plastics and packaging waste were a national thing that's being worked on?

05:57 - 06:00

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

06:00 - 06:01

Minister Vassarotti, you going to take that?

06:01 - 06:25

Speaker 67

Yes. Mr Speaker, I'm going to take that as the policy for waste, recycling, and circular economy sits with me as Minister for Environment. In reference to ICBR, that would probably report to Minister Cheyne and I'm going to take it on notice and come back to the chamber because my computer has an automatic software update going on and I can't check my notes.

06:25 - 06:27

Jeremy Hanson

Ms Clay, supplementary.

06:27 - 06:37

Speaker 54

Tree. Since federal Labor abandoned their promise to bring in national packaging laws that would make polluters pay, what has the ACT government done to deal with soft plastics in Canberra?

06:37 - 06:39

Jeremy Hanson

Minister Vassarotti.

06:39 - 06:43

Speaker 21

Mr Speaker, that will cut across a few areas so I'll take it on notice and come back with a full answer.

06:43 - 06:45

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, and a supplementary, Mr Braddock.

06:45 - 06:53

Speaker 27

When will Canberrans be able to so- recycle soft plastics in a free and convenient way like other cities like Albury, Ballarat, Adelaide, Tamworth, and Central Coast do?

06:53 - 06:55

Speaker 18

Minister.

06:55 - 06:58

Speaker 31

I'll add it to the list of things I'm taking on notice and come back comprehensive.

06:58 - 07:01

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. A new question, Ms Castley- Ms Kikkert.

07:01 - 07:19

Fiona Carrick

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Minister for Planning regarding the Phillip Pool. The owner of the Phillip Swimming and Ice Skating Centre has erected fences very close to the 50-meter pool. Minister, are the current works, including fencing and decommissioning of the smaller pools, allowable under the current lease?

07:19 - 07:22

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

07:22 - 07:25

Speaker 25

I'll take that on notice, come back to the Assembly with some information.

07:25 - 07:27

Jeremy Hanson

Minister- Ms Kikkert, supplementary.

07:27 - 07:39

Speaker 62

Minister, has there been a safety assessment relating to the clearance around the pool needed to facilitate a rescue operation? If yes, when did this assessment occur and what were the findings and if not, why not?

07:39 - 07:40

Minister.

07:40 - 07:50

Chris Steel

I thank the member for her question. I'll seek some info as to whether I can get some information from the independent territory planning authority about that if they hold that information.

07:50 - 07:52

Jeremy Hanson

A supplementary, Mr Emerson.

07:52 - 07:57

Thomas Emerson

Minister, when was the last inspection for compliance with the Crown lease conditions and what were the findings?

07:57 - 07:59

Speaker 19

Minister.

07:59 - 08:10

Chris Steel

Again, I'll seek some information about that from Access Canberra, who acts as a delegate for the territory planning authority when it comes to enforcing planning regulation.

08:10 - 08:11

A new question, Mr Emerson.

08:11 - 08:43

Thomas Emerson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My question is to the Minister for Children, Youth and Families. Minister, yesterday during question time, you said, quote, "The government is committed to reducing the overrepresentation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children in the out of home care system, and the Our Booris, Our Way recommendations and the committee are foundational in that work." If that's the case, Minister, why hasn't the partnership agreement with the Our Booris, Our Way implementation oversight committee been reviewed as was promised, and why hasn't a new partnership agreement been signed given the exi- given the existing one expired in March?

08:43 - 08:45

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

08:45 - 09:04

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'd like to thank Mr Emerson for the question. There is a disagreement afoot as to whether the review of the partnership agreement has taken place. I understand the views of the committee on this matter. And there was a second part to the question, Mr Emerson?

09:04 - 09:08

Thomas Emerson

Why is there no new agreement, given the existing one expired in March?

09:08 - 09:20

Michael Pettersson

A decision to enter into a partnership agreement has been a decision of the directorate, and I'm not in a position to provide any further information on any decisions of a future agreement.

09:20 - 09:21

Mr Emerson, a supplementary?

09:21 - 09:34

Thomas Emerson

Just point of order on responsiveness. The question was why one has not been signed. It wasn't whether a new partnership agreement would be signed at some point in the future. If the minister's not able to comment today, perhaps he could take that part on notice?

09:34 - 09:41

Jeremy Hanson

On the point of order, do you have anything?

09:41 - 09:55

Speaker 42

Why has one not been signed? Well, I guess one hasn't been signed. I'm not in a position to attribute particular reasons at this point in time why that has happened, and it would be a future decision to do so.

09:55 - 10:06

Jeremy Hanson

Yeah, I'll have a look at the Hansard. I think it's on the It's fine line on that one. I'll have a look at the Hansard and come back with a ruling later on. Mr Emerson, a supplementary?

10:06 - 10:15

Thomas Emerson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Minister, is it true that the Our Booris, Our Way implementation team within the directorate has been unstaffed since October 2025?

10:15 - 10:17

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

10:17 - 10:34

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'd like to thank Mr Emerson for the question. There have been changes in the staff allocation across the directorate that works to these matters. I wouldn't be able to speak precisely to the timelines, so I'll have to take that on notice.

10:34 - 10:36

Jeremy Hanson

Mr A supplementary, Ms Castley?

10:36 - 10:51

Speaker 66

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Minister, is the ACT Government committed to the ongoing oversight through the Our Booris, Our Way Implementation Oversight Committee beyond the 30th of June 2027 when their current funding expires?

10:51 - 10:53

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

10:53 - 11:37

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The government is deeply appreciative of all of the work that the committee undertakes, providing oversight, as well as their original work in providing the recommendations. The role of the committee is important. The role of the committee takes place in the wider context of the oversight of the Children, Youth and Family Services that exist here in the ACT, with a range of independent oversights. The government will need, at sometime in the future, to consider what these appropriate settings are, that should and will be done in conversation and consultation with community.

11:37 - 11:41

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. New question, Mr Cocks.

11:41 - 11:59

Ed Cocks

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Minister for Health.

Minister, on 1 October more than 300 Canberra Hospital cleaners transferred into direct government employment from the private sector. What arrangements has the government made to ensure these workers receive full recognition of their previously accumulated portable long service leave?

11:59 - 12:00

Minister.

12:00 - 12:01

I'll take that on notice. Thank you.

12:01 - 12:04

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you. Mr Cocks, a supplementary?

12:04 - 12:15

Ed Cocks

Thank you. Minister, how many of the in-sourced cleaners had less than five years of accumulated portable service and how many have had that service recognized towards their public sector long service leave entitlements?

12:15 - 12:15

Minister.

12:15 - 12:17

Speaker 44

I'll take it on notice.

12:17 - 12:19

Jeremy Hanson

A supplementary, Mr Pettersson?

12:19 - 12:33

Mark Parton

Yes, Minister, will an in-sourced Canberra Hospital cleaner who returns to private sector cleaning after five years lose both their portable and government long service leave under your scheme's provisions?

12:33 - 12:34

Minister.

12:34 - 12:36

Speaker 53

I'll take it on notice.

12:36 - 12:38

Jeremy Hanson

New questions. Mr Cocks.

12:38 - 13:31

Ed Cocks

Mr Speaker, my question is to the Minister for Business and Industry. Minister, small businesses are dealing with the ban on credit card surcharges, federal Labor's proposed changes to family trust taxation, uncertainty over the future of credit card payments for tax bills following the Albanese government's decision to postpone the ATO's proposed ban. The government has also lowered the payroll tax threshold and intends to impose another employment levy on hospitality and hairdressing businesses from January. This comes on top of yet another interest yet another inflation result that may drive interest rates. Minister, what assessment has the government undertaken of the cumulative impact of these decisions and outcomes on the viability of Canberra small businesses?

13:31 - 13:34

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

13:34 - 14:00

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I can't immediately point to a singular piece of work that would have considered the totality of each of those decisions, many of which were undertaken by entities that are not the ACT Government. The government, in considering any policy decision, is cognizant of the wider settings in which that decision is taken. And we are very confident that the decisions we make are in line with Canberrans' expectations.

14:00 - 14:02

Jeremy Hanson

Mr Cocks, a supplementary?

14:02 - 14:14

Ed Cocks

Minister, how many business small businesses does your government expect will have to increase prices, cut staff hours or delay hiring because of the additional cost of Labor's higher tax, aggressive compliance agenda?

14:14 - 14:16

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

14:16 - 15:08

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I'd like to thank Mr Cocks for the supplementary question. I can't accept the imputations, inferences and claims contained within the question. There are a range of economic circumstances taking place. We make decisions in the best interests of our city. We will continue to do that.

We want Canberra to be a place where business thrives. We are a good place to do business, Mr Speaker. You might have seen, Mr Speaker, that the BCA just recently announced their rankings of the states when it comes to business sentiment and regulations, where the ACT has actually gone up in the rankings, Mr Speaker. Couple that with the fact we've got the third highest growth rate for businesses in the ACT. This government will continue to support the local business community.

We will not speak it down like others.

15:08 - 15:10

Jeremy Hanson

A supplementary, Mr Milligan?

15:10 - 15:24

Speaker 58

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Minister, why is the government imposing another cost to employment from January when the federal Labor government has finally realizes the severity of the cash flow pressures facing small business?

15:24 - 15:28

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

15:28 - 16:25

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'd like to thank Mr Milligan for the question. It is always his strong interest in all matters local business. The ACT Government is expanding portable long service leave to services, hospitality, because we know these are industries that have high rates of business turnover, they have high rates of casualisation and in these industries, it is nigh impossible for working people to access portable long service leave. No, long service leave, which is why we support portable long service leave.

Now, Mr Speaker, there are some people that do not support the premise of portable long service leave. They do not think that working people deserve access to this entitlement, but we on this side of the chamber do. We believe this is an important workplace entitlement that all working people should be able to access, which is why we support portable schemes and we will continue to do so.

16:25 - 16:26

A new question, Mr Cocks.

16:26 - 17:24

Ed Cocks

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Minister for Skills, Training and Industrial Relations. Minister, in May this year, following my announcement of legislation to postpone the expansion of portable long service leave pending an independent assessment of its impact on businesses and workers, the government postponed the expansion by 6 months because of difficult economic conditions and offered substantial introductory levy discounts. Since then, CreditorWatch has reported that 12% of Australia's cafes and restaurants closed over the previous year, while Restaurant & Catering Australia has reported that average restaurant and cafe net profit margins have fallen to just 2.5% before further increases in employment and operating costs. Minister, what independent economic evidence demonstrates that proceeding with the expansion on 1 January 2027 is unlikely to have materially adverse effects on employment or business viability in Canberra?

17:24 - 17:26

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

17:26 - 18:42

Michael Pettersson

Mr Speaker, well, the government does seek advice when considering changes to these schemes. I guess an analysis as described in Mr Cocks's question, I do not believe has taken place. This was a decision taken by the government in response to what we were seeing in the community and representations from business. We make decisions cognisant of the wider circumstances that are taking place, which is why the government has delayed the commencement of this scheme, which is why we have sought to structure the introduction of this expansion of the scheme to provide as much support to these industries which are experiencing challenging economic circumstances. We are living in an inflationary time, Mr Speaker, and many businesses are experiencing that challenge.

We know that portable long service leave is a good thing for working people, and it's a good thing for these industries. Now, when I speak to hospitality businesses, Mr Speaker, commonly, the first thing they talk to me about is their challenges in training and retaining staff. If this as an industry wants to retain more of their staff, then it's important that schemes like portable long service leave are implemented.

18:42 - 18:44

Jeremy Hanson

Minister, a supplementary, Mr Cocks?

18:44 - 18:57

Ed Cocks

Mr Speaker, Minister, has the government commissioned any independent economic assessment of the expansion's expected impact on business viability, staffing levels and working hours, or is all just on the vibes?

18:57 - 18:59

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

18:59 - 20:08

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'd like to thank Mr Cocks for the supplementary question. I reject the premise of the question. This is a decision that was considered and was made informed by what we are having the representations that are made to us and our understanding of the wider economic circumstances.

There are important considerations for government when making these decisions. Mr Cocks, in his previous questions, has gone to some of the record-high hospitality business closures in recent times. These are things that are front and central in our decision-making. But when I cite a statistic like that,

it's important to consider why a scheme like portable long service leave is so important. Because if portable long service leave had been in place before those businesses had gone under, those protections, those entitlements would have been protected. Now, I am cognisant of the challenges that are being experienced by industry, but it's important that this scheme is implemented so that those entitlements for those workers are protected going into the future as soon as possible.

20:08 - 20:11

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. A supplementary, Mr Cocks?

20:11 - 20:25

Peter Cain

What has improved in the hospitality sector since May that makes the government believe businesses can now afford Labor's hospitality tax without cutting staff hours or jobs?

20:25 - 20:27

Jeremy Hanson

Minister.

20:27 - 21:39

Michael Pettersson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Well, this government does pay attention to wider economic circumstances, and I am confident as that we enter into the summer period that there will be more Canberrans spending their money locally, supporting hospitality businesses. We have gone through a challenging time in recent years, Mr Speaker. There has been uncertainty in the local jobs market. There have been challenges in the provision of public spending in this city.

We've gone through election periods, which have seen a reduction in spending locally. I acknowledge that in recent years, off the back of the pandemic, it has been a challenging time for hospitality. But we need to be very clear, Mr Speaker, that there are bright spots in the local economy, and there are lots of ambitious, entrepreneurial Canberrans that see the bright future ahead for hospitality, which is why we're seeing new venues opening up in this city, because Canberrans are optimistic about the future of hospitality, which is why we want to support that workforce and those industries and those employers to make sure that industry continues to thrive.

21:39 - 21:43

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. A new question, Ms Castley?

21:43 - 22:27

Rebecca Vassarotti

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Minister for Health. As we know, the government has sent out a thousand letters to patients who are on outpatient waiting lists, telling them that they've been removed from it without explaining why or providing advice to their GP as to where their patients should go or what they should do instead. Yesterday you told the media that each case was taken off the waiting list, and that was done by a clinician. We understand that clinicians developed the clinical guidelines for the new wait list criteria, but what were the qualifications of the person or people who then applied that criteria and made the decision to remove people from the paediatric allergies wait list?

22:27 - 22:28

Minister.

22:28 - 22:33

Speaker 64

Clinicians, they were specialised doctors who made that decision and assessed each of the cases.

22:33 - 22:36

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. Ms Castley, a supplementary.

22:36 - 22:52

Rebecca Vassarotti

Can the minister advise whether automated decision-making tools, algorithms, scoring systems or other decision support systems were used at any time in determining whether or not a patient continued to meet the clinical criteria?

22:52 - 22:53

Minister.

22:53 - 23:07

Speaker 9

No, I can absolutely confirm that was not the case, and, in fact, members who were at the briefing yesterday morning heard the clinician say that each case was reviewed by a highly specialised medical practitioner.

23:07 - 23:10

Jeremy Hanson

Mr, so supplementary, Ms Clay?

23:10 - 23:22

Jo Clay

What administrative safeguards apply when Canberra Health Services removes a patient from a specialist waiting list, including the information provided about reasons for the decision and any rights to seek review or reconsideration?

23:22 - 23:24

Speaker 63

Can you start the question again, sorry?

23:24 - 23:38

Jo Clay

What administrative safeguards apply when Canberra Health Services removes a patient from a specialist wait list, including what information is provided about reasons for the decision and any rights to seek review or reconsideration?

23:38 - 24:40

Speaker 9

Yeah. So, on the letter that went out to the families, so it had contact details for Canberra Health Services to contact the health services if they did require a review of their situation. And just to also correct the record that GPs all referring GPs also received a letter that outlined the changes to the criteria for referral and also outlined the process of that was being undertaken. So, I think as we have discussed yesterday, there is a process for a review. If an individual still believes that they would like their child to see a specialist, it is recommended that they go back to their GP to again have the discussion with the GP to understand whether a referral is necessary at this time. This was a really rigorous process.

24:40 - 24:42

Speaker 68

The clinical guidelines that are in

24:42 - 24:43

Point of order, Ms Clay.

24:43 - 24:54

Jo Clay

And we may be getting there. We've got an answer about review or reconsideration. We haven't got anything about reasons for the decision in the letter. That was part of the question: reasons for decision.

24:54 - 24:55

Minister.

24:55 - 25:04

Speaker 9

In the letter, it does say in the letter that there has been a clinical review and a revision of the clinical guidelines for access to the service.

25:04 - 25:08

Jeremy Hanson

Time is for a new question. Ms Nuttall.

25:08 - 25:52

Laura Nuttall

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And my question is to the Minister for Community Services. Minister, accessibility issues with our Working With Vulnerable People scheme have been raised in several committee inquiries now, in relation to information sharing barriers within the system and how this is negatively impacting community groups and volunteers who engage with the system and require a Working With Vulnerable People card. The government has said they will look into how to improve information sharing and development of resources regarding the Working With Vulnerable People scheme in partnership with Access Canberra in the ACT Volunteering Strategy Action Plan and said they will conduct a review with key stakeholders. Minister, has this review been conducted and are community sports stakeholders being included in the process?

25:52 - 25:53

Minister.

25:53 - 26:42

Speaker 77

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I thank Ms Nuttall for the question. Working With Vulnerable People checks is a really important part of keeping our community safe and there is work going on not just here in the ACT, but nationally around working with vulnerable people and working with children as they're known in a lot of other jurisdictions. And I, along with the attorney-general, are you know involved in those discussions at a national level. Part of that is we are reviewing how our system works here in the ACT.

And while I can't announce government policy in question time, we are undertaking that work to have a review commence soon. And I have recently met with Volunteering ACT and a few other stakeholders to discuss you know what's not working for them at the moment so we can shape that thinking as things progress into the next steps.

26:42 - 26:45

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. Ms Nuttall, a supplementary?

26:45 - 27:01

Laura Nuttall

Thank you. Minister, if the government is still yet to commence the review, when can volunteers, community organisations and particularly community sports organisations expect to see the actual changes rather than just review or further consultation?

27:01 - 27:02

Minister.

27:02 - 27:31

Speaker 79

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I thank Ms Nuttall for the question. I know community sport organisations, Volunteering ACT and so many of our amazing volunteers in the community you know want to see what happens next. It's just important that we take that those steps both here in the ACT and nationally so that we get it right as we do it and not have to come back multiple times. But, you know, I appreciate there is a lot of, I guess, anticipation in the community on what happens next, but I will keep the Assembly updated as things progress.

27:31 - 27:33

Jeremy Hanson

A supplementary, Ms Castley?

27:33 - 27:42

Speaker 74

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Minister, how is the government considering how other jurisdictions promote efficiency and accessibility in their Working With Vulnerable People systems?

27:42 - 27:44

Speaker 70

Minister.

27:44 - 28:13

Speaker 77

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank Ms Vassarotti for the As part of the work that is being undertaken at national level through the Standing Council of Attorneys-General and meetings of officials, states and territories are in discussions around how different schemes work in different jurisdictions, and so we can share that learnings with each other. I think there's also some informal discussions that happen between officials in different areas on how best, you know, schemes work best and how they can be made more efficient.

28:13 - 28:16

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. A new question, Ms Berry.

28:16 - 28:34

Speaker 78

Mr Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Police, Fire and Emergency Services. Minister, can you please update the Assembly on what the recent Disaster Ready Fund round four announcement means for the ACT and how this investment will help to build a more disaster-resilient territory?

28:34 - 28:35

Minister.

28:35 - 30:14

Marisa Paterson

Thank you. I thank Ms Berry for the question. The ACT has secured a record investment through round four of the Disaster Ready Fund, with seven projects across the territory receiving support and more than $30 million being invested through a partnership between the ACT Government, the Australian Government and project partners. This includes funding for stormwater infrastructure, nature-based flood mitigation initiatives, and camera-based bushfire detection technologies. This investment recognises a simple reality that natural disasters are becoming more frequent and severe, and governments have a responsibility to invest in mitigation and preparedness before emergencies occur.

Examples of the successful DRF projects include the renaturalisation of urban waterways for flood mitigation. This is a $15.8 million project which will renaturalise a section of Yarralumla Creek to demonstrate how nature-based solutions can reduce flood risk. We also have the Hall Village stormwater infrastructure improvements, this is $5.9 million project, and SmokeBench, this is a $4.3 million project which will establish Australia's first national capability for independently evaluating camera-based fire detection technologies, while enhancing smoke intelligence for camera networks. The funded projects will help strengthen the territory's ability to prepare for and withstand the risk of hazards, including bushfires, storms and flooding. They will reduce risk to lives, homes, businesses and critical infrastructure, while helping communities recover more quickly when disasters occur.

30:14 - 30:17

Jeremy Hanson

Minister. A supplementary, Ms Berry.

30:17 - 30:25

Speaker 76

Minister, how will this record investment complement the ACT Government's preparations for the 2026-27 bushfire season?

30:25 - 31:49

Marisa Paterson

Thank the member for the question. It's been a busy season of preparing for this storm and bushfire season in the territory. So, the funding from DRF complements a broad program of work underway for this season. Earlier this month, the ACT Government launched the Chat, Plan, Act campaign, encouraging Canberrans to take simple steps to prepare for emergencies by understanding their risks, making a plan and knowing what actions to take during an emergency. While community preparedness remains at the heart of our approach, the Disaster Ready Fund enables us to strengthen the systems and infrastructure that support that preparedness.

This includes the investment in bushfire technology and other resilience measures to help us improve identifying risks early and responding effectively. These investments sit alongside recent capability upgrades, including the introduction of new heavy tanker fire trucks for that ACT Rural Fire Service ahead of this bushfire season. Together, these initiatives strengthen both prevention and response capabilities, and the message to Canberrans is clear: Chat, Plan, Act.

Emergency preparedness is a shared responsibility. Government is continuing to invest in capability, technology and infrastructure, and I encourage all Canberrans to take steps to ensure they are prepared for the season ahead.

31:49 - 31:52

Speaker 82

A supplementary, Mr... Want to give him a Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.

31:52 - 31:59

Taimus Werner-Gibbings

Minister, why is investing in disaster mis- mitigation and preparedness before an emergency occurs so important for the safety of Canberra?

31:59 - 32:00

Minister.

32:00 - 32:53

Marisa Paterson

Thank the member for the question. The evidence is very clear that every dollar invested in disaster mitigation and preparedness can help reduce the social, environmental and economic costs of future disasters. While we can't necessarily prevent every bushfire, storm or flood, we can reduce the risk they pose and lessen their impact on our community. Investments in mitigation infrastructure, improved planning, early detection technologies and community resilience helps protect lives, reduce damage to property and critical infrastructure, and support faster recovery when disasters do occur. That is precisely why governments at all levels are investing in initiatives such as the Disaster Ready Fund and the projects it supports.

While rather than waiting for disasters to happen, we are taking practical action to identify risks and address them before they become emergencies.

32:53 - 32:56

Jeremy Hanson

Minister, a new question. Milligan.

32:56 - 33:25

Speaker 58

Uh yes, thank you, Mr Speaker, and my question is to the Treasurer. Treasurer, city businesses already pay commercial rates, yet they are charged an additional City Centre Marketing and Improvements Levy for services including cleaning and graffiti removal. Can the Treasurer guarantee that local businesses are not being charged for extra services that should be part of the government's ordinary responsibilities?

33:25 - 33:27

Jeremy Hanson

Uh Chief Minister.

33:27 - 34:28

Speaker 48

The City Centre Marketing and Investment Levy is one that's levied on businesses within the various precincts that the CRA covers. The CRA then works with a representative group of businesses to allocate those funds to a range of activities that includes the staging of events, and it also includes a range of other things that might be described as market failures on private land where no one individual business would have responsibility for the totality of an area, but they would have a shared interest in that area being maintained, but on private land. So, the answer to the question is we can guarantee ruling out the issue that Mr Milligan has raised, and, of course, this levy has been in place for some time and is broadly supported across the precinct.

34:28 - 34:29

Give it to Mr Milligan, a sup- Yes.

34:29 - 34:42

Speaker 58

Thank you, Mr Speaker. What evidence can the Chief Minister provide that the property owners and businesses that are funding this levy, that the levy is delivering measurable improvements and value for money?

34:42 - 34:43

Chief Minister.

34:43 - 34:56

Speaker 48

Yes, it is reported against in the annual report of the agency and information on each specific event, the increase in footfall in the precinct. The economic impact is also reported.

34:56 - 34:58

Jeremy Hanson

A supplementary, Mr Cocks.

34:58 - 35:03

Ed Cocks

Thank you. Chief Minister, why are local business owners paying for Labor's fiscal failures?

35:03 - 35:04

Chief Minister.

35:04 - 35:05

They're not, Mr Speaker.

35:05 - 35:08

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Chief Minister. A new question, Mr Braddock.

35:08 - 35:29

Speaker 27

My question is to the Attorney-General. With the rapid uptake of electric vehicles, an issue repeatedly identified by Canberrans is accessibility for charging for those who live in strata communities under the Unit Titles (Management) Act.

Attorney-General, how does the government plan to help existing strata, owners and residents under that Act to access EV charging at home?

35:29 - 35:31

Speaker 81

Attorney-General.

35:31 - 37:20

Speaker 83

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank Mr Braddock for the question. So, I think it was September 2024 that the Unit Titles (Management) Act was amended to make it easier for residents to install sustainability and utility infrastructure, including EV chargers. Effectively, the way that the legislation works and the ensuing policy is that an owners corporation executive committee or building manager cannot prevent or restrict an installation without good reason. So, that's the legislative framework that we're operating in for our existing buildings. Within Minister Orr's remit, there's also been the residential strata EV-ready pilot study, with some practical guidance to help owners corporations, strata managers and residents assess their buildings, understand the technical options and plan installations safely and equitably.

And importantly, that study has found that most participating buildings wouldn't need an upgrade to their incoming power supply if they used a properly designed load management system. So, I think that's done some great work in terms of addressing some of the anxiety that some of our executive committees or owners corporations have had. And, of course, for new developments, and this might be what I was referring to with September 2024, the territory plan has required that new multi-unit developments include EV-ready infrastructure for every unit's car space, and that complements the National Construction Code.

37:20 - 37:22

Jeremy Hanson

Mr Braddock, a supplementary?

37:22 - 37:28

Speaker 27

Attorney-General, is the ACT government going to implement a right to charge, as the New South Wales government has just done?

37:28 - 37:29

Attorney-General.

37:29 - 39:27

Speaker 83

Thank you, Mr Speaker, I thank Mr Braddock for the supplementary. Well, as I flagged, we already do protect residents against EV charging infrastructure being blocked without good reason. Under our Act, that executive committee or building manager can't prevent or restrict the installation of sustainability or utility infrastructure, and that includes EV chargers, they can't prevent that without good reason. And an owners corporation can also approve infrastructure on common property by ordinary resolution, so the barriers aren't there. So, the recently passed New South Wales provisions, we'll certainly take a look at that, but from my understanding, Mr Speaker, they adopt a similar underlying principle, but the process that residents go through has been explicitly prescribed in the legislation.

So, we've got a broader framework that applies to our infrastructure, while New South Wales has introduced a dedicated individual application process enshrined in legislation with statutory deadlines, approvals and express remedies. So, the principle is the same. We will look at New South Wales' legislation and its implementation, but a right to have a charger shouldn't mean a right to impose an unmanaged or technically unsuitable installation on the rest of the building. So, if we were to go down the path that New South Wales has taken, any consideration would need to preserve the legitimate role of owners corporations in managing the shared in- electrical infrastructure, safety, load management, billing and equitable access. And quite honestly, I think the process that we've designed appears to be working, so I'm not sure that there is a need to go down the path with New South Wales, but we'll certainly keep an eye on how that implementation rolls out.

39:27 - 39:29

Jeremy Hanson

Is there a supplementary, Ms Nuthall?

39:29 - 39:38

Laura Nuttall

Thank you.

Minister, what is the status of the announced plan for interest-free loans for multi-unit buildings to become electric vehicle-ready?

39:39 - 41:31

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'll take this as the Minister for Finance responsible for the sustainable household scheme, and thank Ms Nuttall for the supplementary question. Before I get to the specifics of Ms Nuttall's question, I do want to reiterate as Ms Cheyne has said that the ACT government has already sought to lower the barriers to sustainability measures, like EV charging, being implemented in strata communities. The government has also provided guidance material and made that available for strata and owners corporations on how to approach the installation of EV charging facilities in existing buildings. And owners corporations can already also seek tailored advice through the newly established Sustainable Apartments program, which covers electrification options for their buildings, including EV charging.

And the service provides a comprehensive assessment at nil cost to the owners corporation. And I think that stands them in good stead for the introduction of a program for multi-unit buildings to become EV-ready. So, Mr Speaker, the Sustainable Household Scheme as it is, has supported funding for loans for EV charging infrastructure in 185 homes, and it's also provided loans for the purchase of 813 new electric vehicles and 109 used electric vehicles. The program for multi-unit buildings to become EV-ready is being finalised, with industry consultation currently occurring, so we expect that it will be launched in early 2027. And this will be one of the first programs of its kind in Australia, so careful design and planning has been required, but the programs I mentioned earlier will place strata owners corporations in a good position to understand whether this is something that they may be able to use and would wish to access.

41:31 - 41:36

Jeremy Hanson

Minister, a new question? Mr Cocks.

41:36 - 42:14

Ed Cocks

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Treasurer. Treasurer, later this week, the Assembly will debate the Competition Legislation Amendment Bill 2026, which gives effect to the revised National Competition Policy agreement. That agreement requires governments to assess the competitive impacts of major policy decisions and includes the principle that government and private businesses should compete on a level playing field. Treasurer, what assessment has the government undertaken of whether imposing portable long service leave levies on private cleaning contractors, while excluding the government's own directly employed cleaners, distorts the choice between contracting and insourcing cleaning services?

42:14 - 42:16

Jeremy Hanson

Treasurer.

42:16 - 43:15

Chris Steel

Well, I thank the member for his question. And the answer is that the revised National Competition Policy is only in the process of being implemented at the moment. Of course, that decision was taken prior to the implementation of the new policy, which, of course, our government supports, and we do support that element of undertaking those assessments going forward for major policy decisions. But certainly what we know is that the ACT government offers very competitive conditions for its public service employees, and I don't believe that this would have a very significant impact on competition with private contractors. It's certainly within the government's remit to undertake government work with government employees, and there is that flexibility within the National Competition Policy to make those sorts of decisions.

43:15 - 43:17

Jeremy Hanson

Mr Cocks, a supplementary?

43:17 - 43:30

Ed Cocks

Thank you. Treasurer, when comparing the costs of private cleaning contracts with directly employed government cleaners, does the government ensure that equivalent long service leave costs are included in both cases?

43:30 - 43:32

Jeremy Hanson

Treasurer.

43:32 - 43:56

Chris Steel

I thank the member for his question. And certainly, the government does take into account what the costs would be for the ACT government to be able to insource employees, and we've undertaken work over the last term on developing an insourcing framework that considers those costs in making a decision.

43:56 - 43:57

A supplementary, Mrs. Morris?

43:57 - 44:13

Deborah Morris

Thank you. Can the treasurer identify any published assessment demonstrating that the government's different treatment of private cleaning contractors and its own directly employed cleaners does not unfairly disadvantage private sector providers?

44:13 - 44:14

Treasurer.

44:14 - 44:41

Chris Steel

No. Mr. Speaker, this is government work being undertaken by government employees. This is absolutely within the remit of the ACT government to be able to fund our own employees as government employees to undertake this work, and there's nothing in the national competition policy that would suggest that we can't do otherwise.

44:41 - 44:43

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Treasurer. A new question, Mr. Werner-Gibbings?

44:43 - 45:02

Taimus Werner-Gibbings

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. My question is to the Minister for Education. Minister, can you please update the Assembly on how the ACT Government's Future of Education Equity Fund is helping Canberra families with the cost of schooling and ensuring that every child can fully participate in their education regardless of their circumstances?

45:02 - 45:03

Minister.

45:03 - 46:59

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Thank you. I thank Mr. Werner-Gibbings for the question and for his ongoing passion for public education and for equity for all children and young people. I know it was only last week that Mr. Werner-Gibbings was engaging with a local P&C in his electorate, hearing and learning about the local experience at one of Tuggeranong's public schools. Mr. Speaker, the Barr Labor government is committed to ensuring every child and young person has access to high-quality education and that ACT public schools can be an excellent first choice for every family. One of the ways we are delivering on that commitment is through the Future of Education Equity Fund.

This is a lasting and transformational program that was championed and delivered by Ms. Berry, and I want to acknowledge that. By reducing financial barriers, the fund helps students participate fully in school life, whether it's sporting equipment, uniforms, music lessons or excursions. We know that the costs can add up and sometimes families have to make difficult choices. So, the Education Equity Fund takes a bit of pressure off eligible families, supporting the well-being of their children and young people and ensuring they can access the same opportunities as their peers. So far in 2026, more than 3,200 applications have been approved, delivering around $3.7 million in support for Canberra families.

Eligible families can receive annual payments of $400 for pre-school students, $500 for primary school students, and $750 for high school and college students. Importantly, Mr. Speaker, the fund is available to eligible students attending public and non-government schools, recognising that cost-of-living pressures affect families right across our community. Mr. Speaker, the equity fund is a practical demonstration of ACT Labor's commitment to equity in education because all students should have access to enriching learning opportunities.

46:59 - 47:01

Jeremy Hanson

Mr. Mr. Werner-Gibbings, a supplementary?

47:01 - 47:10

Taimus Werner-Gibbings

Yes, there is. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Minister, how is the equity fund supporting student well-being and participation in school life beyond the classroom?

47:10 - 47:10

Minister.

47:10 - 48:50

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank Mr. Werner-Gibbings for the supplementary. By helping the families with the costs of education, the Labor government is ensuring more students can engage, participate and thrive in school. The government knows that education and school engagement are about more than what happens in the classroom.

Students are more likely to succeed when they feel connected to their school community and can participate fully in the opportunities that school provides. The Future of Education Equity Fund supports this broader vision of education by helping eligible families access activities and experiences that contribute to student wellbeing, engagement and inclusion. As I mentioned, funding can be used for school excursions, it can be used for sporting activities or equipment, it can be used for music lessons, or a myriad of other opportunities that allow students to participate alongside their peers. These experiences help students build confidence, develop social connections, discover new interests, and strengthen their sense of belonging. We know that student wellbeing and educational engagement are closely linked, and that participation in extracurricular and enrichment activities can have lasting, positive impacts.

Mr Speaker, the fund is not simply financial investment assistance; it is an investment in ensuring that students can take part in the full life of their school community. It helps create opportunities that might otherwise be out of reach for some families, and supports our commitment to ensuring every young person can access the benefits of education. By supporting participation, inclusion, and wellbeing, the Equity Fund helps ensure that all students have the opportunity to learn, connect, grow, and thrive throughout their educational journey.

48:50 - 48:52

Jeremy Hanson

Is there a supplementary, Ms Berry?

48:52 - 49:00

Speaker 78

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Minister, who is eligible for the Future of Education Equity Fund, and how can Canberra families access this support?

49:00 - 50:36

Rachel Stephen-Smith

All right, thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank Ms Berry for the supplementary and her absolute commitment to equity for Canberra's children and young people. This program that she delivered is making a real difference for Canberran children and young people. The ACT Government wants to ensure that families who need support can easily access the Future of Education Equity Fund and the educational opportunities it provides. The fund is available to eligible low-income families with children enrolled from preschool through to year 12 in either ACT public or non-government schools. It's also available to eligible independent students and young people undertaking other approved forms of education, including home education and certain equivalent courses through the Canberra Institute of Technology.

To be eligible, applicants must live in the ACT, be financially responsible for the student, and be able to demonstrate low-income status. This is typically done through a means-tested Centrelink Health Care Card or Pensioner Concession Card, but other evidence of financial hardship may also be considered. Applying is straightforward. Families can apply online through the ACT Government's Education Directorate website, and a single application can cover all eligible children in a family, even if those children attend different schools. Applications for the 2026 school year remain open until the end of November 2026, and an announcement will be made about the opening of 2027 applications.

So, I encourage any family who may be eligible to visit the ACT Government website and apply for this important support.

50:36 - 50:39

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Minister. New question, Mr Cocks.

50:39 - 51:19

Ed Cocks

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Treasurer. Treasurer, the government confirmed during estimates that Labor has imposed an average general residential rates increase of 8% across Canberra this year, with some suburbs being hit with up to 19% increases. Average residential rates in each and every Canberra suburb now exceed those of Sydney's Northern Beaches. Is the Treasurer aware that, despite the government's claim of 20,000 households being better off on rates this year, the total number of properties with a calculated general residential rates reduction, so, excluding the expiry of the temporary health levy, is actually seven?

51:19 - 51:20

Treasurer.

51:20 - 53:10

Chris Steel

I thank Mr Cocks for his question, and, of course, he knows, he well knows that he's not taking into account the fact that we abolished the health levy in the budget, and that's why we have seen around 20,000 households better off in terms of their rates.

And when the health levy abolition is included, the average rates increase is no more than 5% across the territory. And of course rates is an important source of revenue to be able to fund the services and infrastructure that Canberrans rely on. But we've certainly recognized that households and businesses are under pressure and that's why we didn't increase rates further. But we are seeing massive rate increases in other jurisdictions around us, including Yass Valley Council, where I believe they're contemplating rate increases in the vicinity of over 70%. We've been measured and balanced in the decisions that we've made in the budget, recognizing the pressure on families.

We have provided cost-of-living support. Minister Stephen-Smith just spoke about the Education Equity Fund, which is one of the measures outlined in the budget that we have made to support cost-of-living in a targeted way. But of course, yes, we are continuing to charge rates and of course, they are apportioned based on partially based on valuation. And it always is extraordinary. They say there's no such thing as a dumb question, but something sometimes it does reveal something about the questioner.

And I did it's worth having a look at the columns from Mr Cain on this subject where he clearly doesn't understand the rate system after two terms.

53:10 - 53:11

I mean very clearly.

53:11 - 53:13

Jeremy Hanson

Members, there's a point of order.

53:13 - 53:18

Speaker 98

Very clearly the Minister is now debating the question.

53:18 - 53:29

Jeremy Hanson

Yeah, I think there was an inference in there as well, Minister, and I'd ask that in answering you not have imputations or inferences as you were leaning towards.

53:29 - 53:33

Ed Cocks

On the point of order, I ask that you request the Minister to withdraw the

53:33 - 53:37

Jeremy Hanson

I will do that, Mr Cocks. I'd ask that you withdraw those comments.

53:37 - 53:42

Speaker 95

I didn't say that he was dumb, but I withdraw if there was an inference.

53:42 - 53:44

Jeremy Hanson

A new question or is it a supplementary?

53:44 - 53:57

Ed Cocks

Supplementary, Mr Speaker. Treasurer, how does the expiry of a temporary levy make a permanent increase in residential general rates of 8% on average any more affordable for households struggling to pay their bills?

53:57 - 54:46

Chris Steel

Well, I thank the member for his question. And as I note again, as I did in the answer to the first question, of course, that figure does not take into account the fact that the health levy has been abolished and so that means that overall rates have not increased by more than 5% on average across the ACT. And we've had to be measured about the decisions that we've made. Measured because we know that there's pressure on households and businesses at the moment with the current macroeconomic climate, the war in the Middle East that is driving up transport costs and driving inflation across the economy. But the government also faces those same pressures, Mr Speaker, in terms of the cost of delivering services to the community, like free public healthcare, for example.

54:46 - 54:48

Speaker 93

And that means we need to be able to fund those.

54:48 - 54:50

Jeremy Hanson

Could you resume your seat, please, Treasurer.

54:50 - 55:14

Ed Cocks

Mr Speaker, a point of order on relevance. The question was actually about the how the expiry of a temporary levy makes a permanent increase in general rates of 8% anymore affordable. It doesn't go to the pressures on the government's budgets, but households' budgets.

55:14 - 55:15

Treasurer.

55:15 - 55:45

Chris Steel

I think I have answered it. And it goes directly to the question that taking off that levy does result in a reduced increase in the overall rates bill of no more than 5% on average across the ACT. And of course, the government receives that revenue to be able to fund services and infrastructure, which is absolutely relevant. And the government is under the same pressure that households and businesses are under in terms of the inflation that we're seeing in the economy. And we do need to fund services like free public healthcare that help to take pressure off people when they're accessing healthcare services, for example, and a range of other services across the community that of course our government prioritize.

56:01 - 56:03

Jeremy Hanson

A supplementary, Ms Bere, or a new question?

56:03 - 56:11

Chiaka Barry

Thank you, a supplementary, Mr Speaker. Treasurer, why are Canberra homeowners paying for Labor's fiscal incompetence?

56:11 - 56:27

Chris Steel

Treasurer, I reject the premise of the question. Mr Speaker, I refer the member to the Business Council of Australia's report today, Regulation Rumble and I have to say these gloves remind me of Alistair Coe in the election campaign, Mr Speaker, and the reason it's relevant—

56:27 - 56:28

Point of order.

56:28 - 56:29

Point of order, if you resume your seat.

56:29 - 56:37

Mark Parton

On relevance. The report that I mean a) it's a prop, but b) it's got nothing to do with the question. There is no relevance whatsoever.

56:37 - 56:54

Jeremy Hanson

Yeah, I think that the question was talking about, you know, making a verging on inference about Labor Party incompetence and so on. You know, a question like that is going to lead to some latitude in the response.

56:54 - 57:09

Ed Cocks

On the point of order, Mr Speaker, in terms of the point of order on relevance, while I acknowledge that the minister is talking more broadly about incompetence, the question was very directly about fiscal incompetence rather than regulations.

57:09 - 57:13

Jeremy Hanson

There's no point of order. Minister, do you have anything further to add?

57:13 - 58:16

Chris Steel

Mr Speaker, they hate this report. They hate this report, and the reason why is it's all about comparing regulations and tax policies across states and territories to inspire a race to the top. And I am inspired, Mr Speaker. I'm inspired because the ACT has not only gone up in our rankings, but we are second in terms of cost and regulation in this report. So, and it goes to the fact that we have abolished insurance duties in this territory.

We have abolished stamp duty for first home buyers. We are doing better than other jurisdictions, and that is taking pressure off businesses and households, Mr Speaker. And we are also improving our regulations across the planning system to prioritise building new homes, as has been recognised in this piece of work as well, providing more affordable options for people to get into a home. This is a report that the Liberals hate, but it shows that the ACT government's concerted effort, through led by Minister Cheyne on the better regulation task force, the work we've been doing on planning system reform and tax reform, is working.

58:16 - 58:19

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you. Minister, resume your seat. New question, Mr Parton.

58:19 - 58:53

Mark Parton

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Chief Minister. Chief Minister, in question time on the 16th September, when asked about the review that you commenced to look into Education Directorate procurement during the period involving the former Director-General and the former Chief of Staff of the then Education Minister, you advised the Assembly that the review is being conducted by the Head of Service. Chief Minister, is this review separate from the desktop review undertaken by the Education Directorate that was tabled earlier this week?

58:53 - 59:16

Speaker 48

Thank you. Look, I understand that there are intersecting pieces of work here. The Head of Service obviously doesn't personally undertake every single element of an audit of that size and will task elements to other parts of the bureaucracy. So, perhaps in the interests of getting a fulsome answer to Mr Parton's question, I'll take it on notice.

59:16 - 59:18

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Chief Minister. Mr Parton, supplementary.

59:18 - 59:40

Mark Parton

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Chief Minister, are you satisfied that the desktop review that has been tabled is capable of identifying any serious procurement issues given the Integrity Commission have found that an earlier desktop review of the Campbell project had significant limitations and would not have, quote, elicited these facts, end quote?

59:40 - 01:00:30

Speaker 48

Chief Minister.

Certainly the desktop review has looked at fundamental question of whether a delegate or a decision-maker varied a decision from that was recommended by the procurement panel. So that is one of the threshold issues clearly that is contained within the Integrity Commission's Kingfisher report. There are, of course, other avenues where issues that might exist from the perspective of tenderers or indeed others involved in the process can be brought to the attention not only of the internal audit committees of each of the directorates, but also the Auditor-General as an independent entity looking over the entire ACT public sector, or, of course, the Integrity Commission itself. Ms Lee, a supplementary?

01:00:30 - 01:00:44

Elizabeth Lee

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Chief Minister, why was the Education Directorate, at least in part, allowed to mark its own homework given the corrupt conduct identified in Kingfisher was carried out by the then head of the Education Directorate?

01:00:44 - 01:00:45

Chief Minister.

01:00:45 - 01:01:10

Speaker 48

Well, yes, I think the answer to the question is partly contained within Ms Lee's question itself. So someone wasn't marking their own homework. A different group of officials were looking at issues at that time. And just because they happened to work in that directorate does not mean, Mr Speaker, that they are incapable of looking at the work that was undertaken 5 years ago. All further questions can be placed on the notice paper.

01:01:10 - 01:01:16

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Chief Minister. Are there any matters arising from question time? Ms Clay.

01:01:16 - 01:03:22

Jo Clay

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I am concerned that the Minister for Health may have inadvertently misled the Assembly, and I've checked the records. I asked the minister what information was provided to people in relation to their rights to seek a review or reconsideration. And the minister has told us that the letters sent out by Canberra Health Services did include that information. The minister specifically said on the letter that went out to families, it had contact details for CHS to contact the Health Services if they did require a review of their situation.

I have checked the letter and I'll just read from the letter. The letter says, "We understand that this can be difficult to hear, and if you have feedback or concerns in relation to this, please contact the CHS feedback team: healthfeedback@act.gov.au; phone: 5124 5932, or visit the website: canberrahealthservices.act.gov.au, and click on the 'Feedback' at the bottom on the home page to access the online feedback form." Nowhere in that does it advise people of their administrative or legal right to a reconsideration or a review. That is simply saying if you've got feedback, here are some ways to lodge the feedback. And the minister has told us that people were advised of that right.

The reason I'm concerned about it, and I don't often raise matters in question time, on the grip program, government did not respect human rights and administrative legal decision-making principles. They did not advise the people who received those letters about that program of their legal and administrative rights to reconsideration, review and appeal. And I'm looking at another letter that looks an awful lot like it also does not advise people of their rights to a reconsideration or review, and the minister has just told us that it has. So I would like to invite the minister to reconsider all of that information and the letter, and then come back to the Assembly and let us know if people were in actual fact advised of their rights to a review or reconsideration.

01:03:23 - 01:04:17

Marisa Paterson

So, exactly as the member read the letter, that is what the letter stated. So, I will correct the record that it did not advise a review specifically, but it advised patients if they had feedback or concerns in relation to this, which was in relation to the re classification the reclassification of their referral that they could contact Canberra Health Services. So, when they do contact Canberra Health Services, they can ask for a review. And in this is I take on Ms Clay's point that it doesn't have other information there, but it as she read out, that is what it states.

01:04:17 - 01:04:22

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, minister. Are there any other matters arising from question time? Mr Pettersson.

01:04:22 - 01:04:48

Michael Pettersson

Speaker, in Mr Emerson's question, he asserted that the partnership agreement between our Boorowa's Our Way Implementation Oversight Committee and HCSD had expired in March and asked why a new agreement had not been signed. I can advise the chamber that the agreement did not expire in March. It is not a time-limited agreement. Any consideration of a different and future agreement would be a matter for consideration at that time if it occurred. That is why no new agreement has been signed.

01:04:48 - 01:04:50

Jeremy Hanson

Mr Emerson.

01:04:50 - 01:05:05

Thomas Emerson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Just very quickly in response to the clarification, it's certainly the Boorowa's Our Way Implementation Oversight Committee's view that the agreement was a one-year agreement. So, given one party of that agreement thinks it's one-year-long, that's an interesting correction, but I just wanted to put that on the record as well.

01:05:05 - 01:05:30

Jeremy Hanson

Was that the question that we had the 118AA on? Anyway, I'll review the Hansard and then see whether that needs to, given your further information, whether that has an impact on that. Are there any other matters arising from question time? No. That being the case, we are moving to private members' business, and I call the clerk.

01:05:30 - 01:05:33

Speaker 104

Private members' business notice number one.

01:05:33 - 01:05:35

Jeremy Hanson

Mr Parton.

01:05:35 - 01:05:47

Mark Parton

Speaker, I present the Suicide Prevention Bill 2026, together with its explanatory statement.

01:05:47 - 01:05:50

Jeremy Hanson

Call the clerk.

01:05:50 - 01:06:10

Speaker 108

A bill for an act to reduce and prevent the incidence of deaths by suicide in the Australian Capital Territory, to establish the Suicide Prevention Council, to provide for the preparation and implementation of suicide prevention plans, to require the training of persons and organisations in suicide prevention and postvention, and for other purposes.

01:06:11 - 01:06:14

Mark Parton

I move that this bill be agreed to in principle.

01:06:14 - 01:06:18

Jeremy Hanson

Question is that this bill be agreed to in principle, Mr Parton?

01:06:18 - 01:11:25

Mark Parton

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Before I begin, I acknowledge that suicide and suicide prevention can be distressing topics for some people, particularly those who've been personally affected by suicide or who are experiencing difficult circumstances themselves. And I encourage anyone who may find this discussion and its subsequent debate distressing to take care of themselves and to seek support if they need it. Every death by suicide represents a profound loss. For families, friends and communities, the consequences are devastating and they're enduring.

For those experiencing suicidal distress, timely support, effective intervention, and a system that responds to their needs can be critical. Now, I think we must therefore ask not simply whether suicide prevention is a government priority, but whether our systems are organised, equipped, and accountable to deliver on that priority.

This bill is designed to strengthen that framework in the ACT. The bill seeks to establish a legislative basis for a territory-wide suicide prevention plan supported by suicide prevention plans across government directorates and agencies, including ACT policing. Now this recognises that suicide prevention cannot be the responsibility of a single minister, directorate or service. It indeed requires a coordinated response across the institutions that interact with people, families and communities at different points in their lives. The bill will establish a suicide prevention council to provide ongoing advice, promote collaboration and strengthen the role of lived experience in shaping policy and practice.

Those with lived and living experience, their families and carers, frontline workers and community organisations must have a meaningful role in informing the decisions that affect them. Hear. Importantly, the bill seeks to move suicide prevention beyond broad commitments by establishing expectations for planning, implementation, evaluation and public reporting. It provides for annual reporting to this Assembly on progress, relevant data and trends, and the government's response to advice and recommendations. And we think that matters, because commitments must be capable of scrutiny.

This Assembly and the community should be able to understand exactly what action is being taken, whether it's making a difference, where gaps remain and what further work is required. Hear. The bill recognises the importance of reliable information and evidence in provisions for a register of confirmed and suspected deaths by suicide, alongside appropriate safeguards for the handling and sharing of information are intended to strengthen our capacity to understand patterns, identify emerging risks, and inform prevention efforts. Effective suicide prevention must also recognise that different people and communities experience different risks and barriers to support. Policy must be informed by evidence.

It must be responsive to priority populations and capable of adapting as circumstances and needs change. And that includes taking seriously the experiences of men and boys who account for the overwhelming majority of suicide deaths in our community, while ensuring that prevention efforts respond to the needs of all people who are at risk. No single piece of legislation can prevent every death by suicide. We can't do that by passing laws. And we shouldn't pretend that establishing plans, councils or reporting requirements is sufficient in itself.

These mechanisms must lead to practical action, stronger coordination, better-informed decisions and a willingness to address shortcomings when they are identified. We now must establish the structures through which that work can be sustained, it can be measured and scrutinised. Suicide prevention cannot be left to good intentions alone. So, this bill seeks to make prevention a more deliberate, coordinated and accountable responsibility across the ACT government with a stronger foundation for collaboration, continuous improvement and transparency. I want to acknowledge the way in which the ACT Greens have engaged with my office in good faith and the minister and government in expressing their willingness to work together on this truly nonpartisan issue.

It gives me great pride and pleasure to commend this bill to the Assembly.

01:11:25 - 01:11:30

Speaker 113

Thank you, Mr. Parton. The question is that the bill be agreed to in principle. Yes, Mr. Dr. Paterson?

01:11:30 - 01:11:32

Speaker 112

I move that debate be adjourned.

01:11:32 - 01:11:58

Speaker 113

Thank you, Dr. Paterson. The question is that the debate be adjourned. Those of that opinion, say "aye". Those to the contrary, say "no". I declare that the ayes have it.

The question now is that the resumption of the debate be made an order of the day for the next sitting. Those of that opinion, say "aye". Those to the contrary, say "no". I declare that the ayes have it. I call the Clerk.

01:11:58 - 01:12:01

Speaker 104

Private members' business notice number two.

01:12:01 - 01:12:03

Speaker 115

Ms. Lee?

01:12:03 - 01:12:09

Elizabeth Lee

Thank you Madam Assistant Speaker. I move the motions standing in my name in relation to school budget cuts.

01:12:09 - 01:12:13

Speaker 116

Thank you, Ms. Lee. The question is that the motion be agreed. Ms. Lee.

01:12:13 - 01:26:28

Elizabeth Lee

Thank you, Madam Assistant Speaker. Back in August this year, principals across the ACT were blindsided when the Education Directorate presented indicative budgets for 2027. These were not just minor adjustments. They were not just small efficiencies. For many schools, these were significant funding cuts, with losses running into the hundreds of thousands of dollars and in some cases, millions.

When concerns were raised publicly, the director-general of Education sought to reassure the community, saying and I quote, "The review said we needed to look at that whole funding formula, and we are commissioning a holistic review of that funding formula. But as a first step for 2027, we've made a small adjustment to the weighting for colleges so that we can get a better distribution of funding across the system." End quote. A small adjustment? Madam Assistant Speaker, there is nothing small about what was foisted on principals.

The Canberra Times obtained figures setting out exactly what these changes would mean for individual schools. Principals were alarmed. Parents were alarmed. Staff were alarmed. The union was alarmed.

The minister later suggested principals should not have been surprised by these changes, and yet they were. We saw reports of shock and disbelief throughout the education community. Even the director-general herself acknowledged the scale of the cuts when she said, and I quote, "The really important thing where there's larger decreases is we do recognize that this is a transition and we need to support schools through." End quote. At the very least, Madam Assistant Speaker, the director-general recognized that some schools were facing substantial reductions.

That is more than what we have heard from the minister. Let's look at the reality of this so-called small adjustment. At least 58 public schools were facing a cut to their budgets in 2027 than the actual funding they received in 2026. Some of the schools facing the largest reductions are schools serving communities with significant needs. Caroline Chisholm School was projected to lose around $1.5 million.

Kingsford Smith School, almost $3.5 million. Latham Primary School, more than $1.6 million. Majura Primary School, approximately $2.2 million. Frosby School, more than a million dollars. Theodore Primary School, an 8% reduction equivalent to around $300,000.

And the list goes on. How can the minister repeatedly claim that these cuts are designed to better support students with the highest need when some of the largest cuts are being felt by schools serving exactly those student communities? Well, perhaps the most shocking example was what was revealed about ACT specialist schools. Malkara, Black Mountain, Woden and Cranleigh were collectively facing reductions of almost $10 million. $10 million.

Let's think about that. The schools that educate and support students with some of the most complex and intensive needs in our education system were presented with budgets showing a cut of almost $10 million between them. It is little wonder school communities reacted with concern. Angela Burroughs from the Australian Education Union warned that schools could be forced to cut entire programs, whether that be performing arts, languages or other opportunities that enrich student learning. She also highlighted the extraordinarily short time frame principals were being given to absorb and implement these changes, and she raised concerns on what these budget cuts would mean, and I quote,

"They know that staffing, staff are being moved on, and principals are in this dreadful position of having to make cuts, and there's just no clarity or transparency," end quote. Madam Assistant Speaker, Ms Burroughs went on to say, and I quote, "We just want honesty and transparency, and the minister to take accountability in explaining to the community what the impact of these cuts will be on school support," end quote. And that gets to the heart of the problem. The government is attempting to make significant changes to school funding without consultation with the very principals that have to implement these cuts, and importantly, before completing the work necessary to justify those changes.

The Director-General herself has said that a holistic review of the student resource allocation model is underway. Yet, before that review is completed, before the evidence has been finalized, and before the sector knows what the future model looks like, schools have already been told to cut their budgets and to find savings. Parents and stakeholders have consistently argued that the review should come first. Veronica Elliott from ACT Parents summed it up when she said, and I quote, "We'd like to see a staged approach to the changes, rather than implementing a budget decision that requires schools to do the work where the system doesn't have the supports available or the guidance already available for them to follow."

She went on to say, and I quote, "I'm concerned that we're asking schools to make changes to how they operate next year without having any formalized guidance on what we're asking them to do," end quote. That concern has been echoed across the education sector. Ms Burroughs put it bluntly, quote, "The resourcing review has not yet delivered a settled operating model for ACT public schools," end quote.

And until it does, principals are effectively being asked to manage an unfinished reform process. Madam Assistant Speaker, the minister repeatedly points to the public school system resourcing review to justify these decisions, but she rarely acknowledges another key recommendation and finding from that review: transparency. The review called for greater transparency in how school budgets are calculated, yet transparency has been sorely lacking throughout this entire process. In successive question times, the minister refused, failed, struggled to explain how specialist schools will be protected from these cuts. Despite numerous questions calling on her to explain where the shortfall of almost $3 million funding cuts to our specialist schools will come from, the minister has dithered and willfully been opaque with her attempt at deflecting from what all principals, teachers, parents, students and the broader community can see: that she cannot pretend there are no cuts and just continuing to deny it and hoping that everyone just swallows it all.

The minister has repeatedly referred to an exceptions pool, whilst simultaneously admitting that the criteria for accessing that pool have not even been finalized. She has then attempted to say that the exceptions pool is not the only source to make up the shortfall, but then refuses to explain if there are other sources to make up the shortfall, and if so, where it's coming from. Principals do not know how this exceptions pool will operate. School communities do not know how it'll operate. Parents do not know how it'll operate.

Confusion remains high. Anxiety remains high. Distress remains high. Madam Assistant Speaker, that is no way to manage major reform. It is no way to treat school leaders,

and it is no way to treat Canberra families. The ACT Public School System Resourcing Review also found that schools often feel decisions are imposed on them by the directorate without sufficient consideration of their impact. But this seems to be exactly what this government has done. We have heard that principals were, quote, "briefed, not consulted", on the budget cuts,

and we have heard that principals felt blindsided by the decision to cut their budgets, exactly what the resourcing review raised as an issue: transparency. And we know the government knew what they were doing was going to cause more stress, more pressure and more anxiety on our principals. It was revealed that the Education Directorate actually planned for this very outcome. It developed a multihazard risk assessment document and created a crisis management team to deal with the fallout from changes to public school budgets in 2027.

Information obtained by The Canberra Times detailed how the risk assessment shows there was a medium risk of occupational violence as a result of the budget cuts. Let me repeat that, Madam Assistant Speaker: the minister's own directorate undertook a risk assessment which revealed a medium risk of occupational violence as a result of the budget cuts. It said principals may suffer stress, anxiety and conflict as they communicate the impact of budget cuts, such as changes to staffing, to their communities. And most worryingly, the directorate's own document states, and I quote:

"Where student supports are changed or decreased, this could lead to escalated student behaviour resulting in increased incidents of occupational violence," end quote. As much as the minister tries to duck, weave and dodge accountability, as much as the minister tries to shift the blame to everyone else, including the opposition, this is purely a miss- mess of her and her directorate's own making.

We are not making up concerns. We are hearing on the ground. They are coming from the very people at the coalface, the very people responsible for delivering public education every day. As Ms Burroughs called on the minister to do,

quote, "Come clean with the public about budget cuts to ACT public schools, to stop the political trickery of arguing that there is no cut to education budgets because the school communities know otherwise," end quote. She said, "School communities know the reality because they are already seeing staff moved on and difficult decisions being made." A staff member from an ACT primary school put it even more starkly,

quote: "We have a lot of high-needs children. I don't think that's been looked at. And it's absolutely disgusting that this has been kept such a secret," end quote.

And the Australian Education Union Vice-President and college principal Simon Vaughan warned, quote, "There is a quantum of savings I will have to find." And he acknowledged the obvious consequence, Madam Assistant Speaker, when he said, and I quote, "If we have to, for example, cut staff, that may cut programs,"

end quote.

Parents are worried, too. ACT Parents has reported that parents and citizens associations are increasingly feeling pressure to fill gaps in funding for core school programs, something fundraising was never intended to do. As ACT Parents asked, and I quote, How can we expect principals to make these decisions when they have to choose from a really difficult list of options, such as reducing what might be considered a core public education offering of music or art, having bigger class sizes or providing less inclusion support? And Madam Assistant Speaker, this is ultimately what this motion is about: not spreadsheets, not formulas, not bureaucratic processes, not some public relations doublespeak or political trickery. It is about whether school communities are being given clarity, transparency, and confidence about the future.

It is about whether our teachers, who are entrusted to deliver a world-class education to our children, including some of our most vulnerable children, are being supported to do. The government may call these changes a small adjustment, but for principals balancing their budgets, for teachers worried about programs, for parents concerned about support services, and for the students who rely on those services every day, there is nothing small about it. The government owes school communities honesty, transparency, and a clear explanation of how these decisions are being made, because right now these communities are being asked to bear the consequence of a reform process that even the government itself has not yet finished designing. They need to do better. They need to learn from this debacle and bring principals to the table, because principals are the people responsible for making these difficult decisions on the ground.

School leaders deserve certainty. They deserve transparency. They deserve to know that major changes to the way their schools are funded will not be sprung upon them without warning and without proper consultation. They deserve confidence about a process of this magnitude, and that it will be undertaken openly, collaboratively, and with the respect of their expertise. So let us learn from what has occurred, Madam Assistant Speaker.

Let us commit to a funding and budget process that is transparent, consultative, and evidence-based. Let us ensure that our principals are partners in reform, not recipients of decisions that have been thrust upon them after. And let us give our school leaders the certainty that they will never again be blindsided by changes of this scale. This is what my motion seeks to achieve, and I call on every member in this chamber to support. I commend my motion to the Assembly.

01:26:28 - 01:26:34

Speaker 117

Thank you, Ms Lee. The question is that the motion be agreed. Yes, Ms Nuttall?

01:26:34 - 01:26:42

Laura Nuttall

Thank you, Madam Assistant Speaker, and I would like to move the amendments circulated in my name.

01:26:42 - 01:26:46

Speaker 119

Yes, sorry, you would like to move the amendments in your name?

01:26:46 - 01:26:50

Laura Nuttall

Yeah, the amendments circulated in my name to Ms Lee's motion.

01:26:50 - 01:26:56

Speaker 118

The question now is that the Ms Nuttall's amendment to the motion be agreed. Thank you. Ms Nuttall.

01:26:56 - 01:39:22

Laura Nuttall

Thank you. I rise to speak in support of Ms Lee's motion and I want to thank her and her team for bringing it before the Assembly today. This motion seeks to clarify the current budget situation which has brought extreme confusion to the community, and honestly, at times, also to many of us in this place. I know we will all be grateful if this debate brings clarity for the community where possible and serves as an opportunity for us to constructively bring the community answers and system improvements that they deserve, so that the government's handling of school budgets does not cause the community further distress, anxiety, and confusion. I especially call for clarity and transparency in the context of the government's new standard lines on school budgets which emerged after the fallout of the cuts: that this process is ongoing and that school budgets are still being finalized.

I'm not suggesting that isn't the case. However, there are real questions as to how much the government is actually going to adjust school budgets in response to the feedback of principals and community, and how much of this is a media-friendly line. It's also not something that helps principals plan for their staffing next year. My doubt around this largely stems from how this budget process has been handled and the ongoing confusion around the collective funding pool which is also referred to as the school budgets exceptions process.

Since announcing changes to school budgets for next year, the government has pointed to the collective funding pool of roughly $8 million as evidence that this process is ongoing and that there is wiggle room for cases where cuts are found to be unviable. But what the government has repeatedly failed to do is actually clarify what constitutes viable cut, what criteria schools are being judged against when seeking to access additional funds to what was in the budget handed down to them. It's not for lack of asking and trying on our part. We've asked the government whether reduced subject offerings or an inability to fully staff a classroom are grounds for a cut to not go ahead.

We did not get a clear answer. We've asked them whether a reduction in language offerings and pathways would prevent a cut. And you guessed it, we got no clear answer. Whether the directorate themselves even has a red line drawn going into this budget process is still unclear.

In saying that, I think it's gotten to the point where their inability to provide a clear answer says something in and of itself. The directorate does not appear to have a clear red line or at least one they were willing to communicate publicly as to what constitutes a viable cut for a school's budget when they started this process. It remains unclear what data informed these budget cuts for so many of our schools. And the data we've seen from The Canberra Times on which schools have been hit the hardest by the cuts makes it pretty clear that the government's new needs-based funding model, I'll use quotation marks there, has not shaped up to its name in practice. When schools hit the hardest include some of the least socio-educationally advantaged when we looked through the ACARA statistics and included schools with roofs leaking, with inadequate cooling and schools considered some of the smallest in their network,

reductions in their funding have not been for lack of need. Last week, we asked the minister to provide an update on the criteria for schools to access the collective funding pool to which she indicated it would be finalised by the end of that week. I do invite the minister if she has the time and the information available to her to please provide an update on this. But in the meantime, I would like to speak to this order of events. I think it says a lot how poorly things have been handled that the exceptions process which the directorate signposted as their contingency plan to assist schools with their budget cuts was: one, only a total funding bucket of $8 million where it looks like there have been approximately $47 million worth of proposed cuts to provisional, individual school budgets; two, there was no established criteria for how access, how to access this funding; and three, despite weeks of concern and repeated questions from across the Assembly, clarity on this criteria has still not to this date been provided.

If this is no longer the case again, I would be glad to hear an update on this from the minister because what we've got to date has not been clarity that our communities deserve. The impacts of these cuts are real and something we must consider in this debate. And again, while I know the government has said that the process is ongoing, we have heard principals announce that there are certain resources which they will have to get rid of, should they not receive access to additional funds. Mt Rogers Primary announced that they will have to cut 27 of their 30 LSAs.

This is horrifying, especially when you consider who these school assistants are in classrooms to help. They support students with complex needs, students with disability, students who the School Resourcing Review clearly found are not being adequately supported by our public schools, let alone after said school has had to operate with nearly $1 million less in its budget, as is the case for Mount Rogers.

Incredibly importantly, LSAs are also people losing their jobs. The review also made clear that schools have become increasingly reliant on LSAs as their primary intervention for supporting these students, yet, rather than addressing the underlying pressures driving that reliance, schools are being asked to absorb funding reductions that may directly reduce LSA numbers. We've heard from parents of schools facing significant cuts. We've heard of instances of violence within schools which required other children having to step in. Now, LSAs are the people qualified to step in, and if you start cutting their jobs, you undermine the safety of both staff and students.

Schools shouldn't need to rely on LSAs, but in our current public school system, they are one of the only ways students can be safe and teachers can properly teach. Our students need a better system, our educators need a better system, and yet the government has decreased individual schools funding instead, directly resulting in the cut of LSAs in schools which rely so heavily on them. It is the ACT Greens' hope that, in establishing clear budget development protocols, in consultation with principals and key stakeholders, that we have a school budget system that considers most centrally what resourcing means for student and staff experience in our schools, not as an afterthought, not as a collective funding pool or exceptions process, but at the start, in the middle, and at the end of all decision making.

Reform of our public school system's resourcing cannot simply mean reducing individual school budgets and expecting schools to apply for additional funding later. Parents from ACT public schools stress deep concern over the cuts their children's schools are facing. As a parent in Latham stated, "I expect that when I send my children to school each day they will be safe, supported, and able to learn in an environment that meets basic safety, educational, and environmental standards. Increasingly, that confidence is being whittled away." When public school community When the public school community has needed clarity most, the government has been unclear,

causing confusion, stress, and anxiety for school leaders, staff, family, and students. Communities should not need to wait for an article in The Canberra Times to tell them if their school's funding is being cut. We, in this room, haven't even had clear communication, as at the briefing paper that we received in August, which stated that 18 schools would have a greater than 5% reduction. That goes against what was reported in The Canberra Times. The government needs to take accountability for this mismanagement and this discrepancy, and acknowledge the distress that they have caused.

Similarly, the government cannot cut public schools' funding to focus on need when government schools aren't facing the same issues. This isn't just about politics. It is about equity. A parent at Theodore Primary sent my office the following question and asked me to put it to the government directly:

"Does the government consider it appropriate to fund infrastructure at non-government schools while a local public school is being asked to reduce its operating budget?" I think it's a good question to ask. The directorate has repeatedly referenced the Resourcing Review to justify these school budget cuts. Yet, although the minister has referred to the recommendations to justify reallocation, the findings explicitly state, "There is not scope to balance within the existing funding envelope."

This brings me to our amendment that we've put forward to Ms Lee's motion, which inserts an additional note to include this fact. It reads quote, "The ACT Public School Resourcing Review final report said, 'Given the significant number of high schools and colleges over budget, there is not scope to rebalance within the existing funding envelope. Instead, this requires medium-term consideration within the national context.'" We want to add this note because we think it's a critical piece of evidence that must be considered when we think about how this process has gone wrong. Review of the current differential base funding model under the school resourcing standard and potentially the student resource allocation between primary and secondary students was a recommendation of the resourcing review and served to reform the school funding model to be increasingly based on need.

It reflected the inequity in our current system, that the inequity in our current system goes right down to the SRA and SRS funding model, and that a shift towards a needs-based funding, more needs-based funding in our system to rebalance funding across schools was not something we could do in the following year's school budgets with a limited bucket of money. It required, and I quote, "medium-term consideration within the national context". Look, I do want to recognise that the government has committed to reviewing the SRA model and that it's set aside funds in this year's budget for the directorate to complete that work. This is positive, albeit dampened by the fact that we are still waiting awaiting an implementation plan for the one-system reforms. I appreciate that Ms Lee's motion today has sought to compel a timeline for the SRA review and transparency for how it's progressing.

I think we need it. I also do want to thank the minister and her team for engaging with me and my office on this motion. I believe that the minister has taken some responsibility in question times and in public communications for how this budget process was not handled well. However, the reason we support Ms Lee's motion in its original form is because fallout remains and there is still a lot of clarity needed for the community. Ultimately, this debate feels like a culmination of collective work since changes to the school budgets were announced about a month ago for 2027, work from the fierce advocacy of parents and carers who have spoken out against the cuts to their local public schools, from the Australian Education Union and from others who have stood in solidarity and know the value of our public education system.

That advocacy has also come from teachers, from LSAs, school staff and of course principals, who have been under extreme stress since budgets were handed down. And I want to directly thank them for their incredible responsibility and strength that they have shown. Supporting their staff, students and community, while trying to balance their books and absorb cuts which, in some cases, are just absolutely inconceivable, I am in awe of their leadership. We've heard from students too, who often get left out of these conversations about the decisions that affect them, and it's them who I ultimately want us to think about today. It's their education, it is their lives that are impacted at the end of the day, and we owe it to them to do it better and work with the people who know and care for them to do so.

To everyone who has written to us, spoken to us at stalls and at Education Union rallies, thank you so much. The community outcry against the how the 20 to 27 school budgets have been handled and at the budgets themselves is loud and clear. The ACT Greens have heard it, and we will continue to stand up and call for system change to create fair processes for school budgets, because things should never have gone this way. Communities deserve answers. Principals deserve clarity.

School staff deserve respect. And students deserve better than a funding process that has created weeks of anxiety and confusion about the future of their schools. We should not have a school-based funding model based on what schools can afford to lose, but based on what students need to succeed.

01:39:22 - 01:39:25

Speaker 124

I commend the motion and the Greens' amendment along with it.

01:39:25 - 01:39:31

Speaker 120

The question is Ms Nuttall's amendment be agreed. Minister Stephen-Smith.

01:39:31 - 01:41:17

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Thank you very much, Mr Assistant Speaker. And I'll start by thanking Ms Lee for bringing this motion to the Assembly today. The government will not be opposing this motion largely because while we would take issue with some of the notes, they are mostly factual, and the calls on asking us to do things that we are already doing and report back in a way that is absolutely possible. But I do want to respond to some of the things that have been said already in the debate today, Mr Assistant Speaker. And I think this will help to maybe clarify why we are in the situation we're in.

The first thing I of course have to say is to repeat what I have been saying almost every day for the last two weeks, and that's that specialist schools not only will not be receiving a reduction in funding, but specialist schools principals, Mr Assistant Speaker, were specifically advised from day one that the Education Directorate understood that the student resource allocation model doesn't reflect the needs of specialist schools, and indeed that was also a finding of the Public School System Resourcing Review and that they would not lose funding and that they would be that the student resource allocation model would not be the model that was used to determine specialist school funding allocation. Despite being told this multiple times, Ms Lee continues to take the funding amounts that were reported in the Canberra Times as some kind of gospel and then continues to spread misinformation and confusion about specialist school funding. I'm pleased that

01:41:17 - 01:41:18

Take a seat, Minister.

01:41:18 - 01:41:20

Speaker 121

Point of order, Mr Lee.

01:41:20 - 01:41:24

Speaker 123

Could you mind stopping the clock, please? Been saying that using

01:41:24 - 01:41:25

Yes, stop the clock, thank you.

01:41:25 - 01:41:35

Elizabeth Lee

Accusing me of spreading misinformation is unparliamentary and I asked you to ask her to withdraw.

01:41:36 - 01:42:10

Ed Cocks

Now Mr Assistant Speaker, the I would reflect that the Speaker earlier in the week reflected that accusations of misinformation uh are not necessarily unparliamentary if it's misinformation in the community, however I believe what Miss what the minister just said was in relation to uh Ms Lee's speech just now in the chamber, which would, in fact, fall within what the Speaker suggested would be unparliamentary.

01:42:10 - 01:42:11

Are we still on the point of order, Minister?

01:42:11 - 01:42:17

Rachel Stephen-Smith

I can assure Mr Cocks that I was talking about Ms Lee's comments in the community.

01:42:17 - 01:42:28

Peter Cain

So I think I'll just have to refer the Hansard to Mr Speaker and get back let him get back to you all. Thank you, Minister, continue, and please start the clock.

01:42:28 - 01:55:35

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Thank you, Mr Speaker. One other comment that Ms Lee has repeatedly made is to quote the words "small adjustment" as if those words were applied by the directorate to every decision made in relation to 2027 school budgets. In fact, my understanding is that particular term was related specifically to the reduction of 0.1 to the stages of school waiting applied to college student resource allocation budgets, and I don't believe that at any time the Education Directorate has used the term "small adjustment" in relation to the 2027 budget more broadly. Ms Nuttall talked about Mount Rogers and said, and I believe that she said Mount Rogers announced, that it would be having to let go 27 out of 30 LSAs.

That did not That is not true. Someone unnamed told the Canberra Times that they had heard this. The Canberra Times published this information as if it was fact, and it has been used in debate ever since. I would like to read an email that the principal of Mount Rogers sent to Mount Rogers family and communities: "Dear Mount Rogers families and community,

I am aware that recent media reporting regarding school budgets and staffing has raised some questions and concerns within our community. I wanted to take the opportunity to acknowledge this directly and provide some clarity about what this means for Mount Rogers. The information that has been reported in the media regarding Mount Rogers is factually incorrect and does not reflect our current staffing arrangements or decisions being considered for 2027. For example, reports of a reduction of 27 learning support assistants at Mt. Rogers is not correct. Like schools across the ACT public education system, Mount Rogers is working through budget and staffing planning for 2027.

This includes considering how our staffing aligns with our available resources, projected enrolments, and most importantly, the needs of our students. This work is still underway. Our staffing model for 2027 has not been finalised, and figures currently being reported publicly should not be interpreted as confirmed staffing decisions or a final picture of what Mount Rogers will look like next year. I also recognise that uncertainty around staffing can understandably create concern, particularly for our staff and families. Any changes that we make will be worked through carefully, with a strong focus on maintaining high quality teaching, learning, and support for our students.

There is a great deal happening at Mount Rogers as we plan for 2027 and beyond, and I remain very positive about the direction of our school. Our focus continues to be on creating a stable, consistent, and high-quality learning environment for every student. As our planning progresses and decisions are confirmed, we will continue to communicate relevant information directly with our staff and community. While it will not always be appropriate or possible to communicate every detail of internal staffing and budget processes, I will aim to communicate openly where decisions or changes are likely to have a direct impact on our students, families, or the operation of our school. In the meantime, I would encourage families not to regard figures or proposed staffing arrangements reported in the media as final decisions for our school."

And the principal goes on to say that they would be happy to meet individually with staff. I would encourage everyone in this place to take the advice of the Mount Rogers principal and not regard figures or proposed staffing arrangements reported in the media as final decisions for any school in the ACT. And I would repeat, as I have many times in this place, that school budgets for 2027 have not been finalised. In saying that, Mr Speaker, I recognise, as I have repeatedly, the distress and anxiety caused by this process, and I recognise, as the Education Directorate has, that this process could have been managed better.

This is the first time that we have done school budgeting in this way, and we understand that lessons will be learned, and indeed the process has changed as we have gone through it, on the basis of the feedback from principals and school communities. I would say in that regard that, as Minister for Education, I have regularly and publicly taken responsibility for the 2027 school budget process.

Indeed, I there was an op-ed of mine published in Region Media on, I believe, the 12th of September that stated that that covered this school funding for 20 budget issue for 2027 and stated: "For others, the fairer funding approach For other schools, that is, the fairer funding approach means their student resource allocation funding will be reduced. Each of these schools has its own story, with different pressures and different opportunities to navigate while adjusting to the new model. Some will find it harder than others.

That's why the Education Directorate has been working with each school on how they can deliver for their students, staff, and community within their new funding allocation. Built into this process is a consideration of whether more support is needed, and transitional funding is required to help them adjust. But I want to be clear. No principal, no business manager, and no school will be left to work this out on their own. We remain committed to ensuring every public school is a great school, where teaching is evidence-based and our students are safe, valued, and respected for who they are.

If we work together as one system, we can grasp the opportunities to deliver high higher-quality teaching and learning, reduce teacher workloads, and deliver excellent student outcomes more efficiently." End quote. Mr Assistant Speaker, I stand by that and it reflects the fact that the 2026-27 ACT budget allocated $1.2 billion to the ACT public school system, representing a 7.3% increase on the 2025-26 budget, with fewer students, recognizing the absolutely important and critical role that public schools play in our community.

Every ACT public school is funded ab- above the national schooling resource standard. The ACT is the only jurisdiction in Australia where this is the case. But we're working to ensure greater equity and fairness in the way we distribute resources across the system to support all students. And I think the debate today has really got to the nub of the matter and, in fact, Ms Nuttall's amendment, which we're not going to oppose, but really highlights the confusion here.

I get the impression that sometimes members in this place think that the bu- the budget-setting process for 2027 was a review reflected a review of the student resource allocation process. And the quote that Ms Nuttall has because the quote that Ms Nuttall has included relates specifically to and is a preamble to recommendation 22 of the student the school resourcing review. "The finding is that there are now significant additional cost pressures associated with the early years of schooling which are not adequately accounted for in the base funding model. These impact early childhood, primary, and combined schools P to 10 for the primary allocation component.

At present, primary students are allocated only seven 79.6% of the base funding of secondary students in 2026." This point, it goes on to say, the commentary: "This point needs this points to the need to reconsider the differential base funding allocations for primary students compared to secondary. However, given the significant number of high schools and colleges over budget, there is not scope to rebalance within the existing funding envelope. This requires medium-term consideration.

The recommendation is, given the increasing costs associated with early childhood and primary schools, consideration must be given to reviewing the current differential base funding model under the student resource standard and potentially the student resource allocation between primary and secondary school students." But this is not what we are doing for the 2027 budget.

So, yes, that finding is absolutely relevant when it comes to reviewing the student resource allocation. But the recommendation we are responding to is recommendation 5: School staffing currently above the student resource allocation should be redeployed to schools based on identified needs and equity principles, or to support system-wide strategic priorities. In the short to medium term, the over-allocation should be corrected so that staffing levels are consistent with funding available for school staff within each school and across the system under the SRA, that is under the existing student resourcing allocation student resource allocation. It goes on to say, Madam Speaker, a senior executive within the human resources area should have responsibility for allocation and redistribution of staff.

We didn't do that. The Education Directorate is working with schools to address recommendation 5, the short-term recommendation that over-allocation and under-allocation under the existing student resourcing allocation needed to be addressed in the short term to provide equity of funding across our schools. It is not fair that schools who've had principals who've been able to secure additional funding, who've overspent their budgets and then never been asked to live within their budgets, benefited at the expense of those schools that have not had that advantage, that schools that those historic imbalances of funding are perpetuated. That is not fair on the schools that have missed out through those differential allocations in the past.

So, Mr Madam Assistant Speaker, in the time I've got left to me, I want to be clear about what's happening this term. In week 1, there was a budget planning tool that was completed received by schools and completed, and provided back to the Education Directorate. Weeks 2 to 5 are the school budget assessment framework implementation. All school profiles are checked against a consistent framework to assess proposed school budgets and workforce profiles. The assessment considers the whole picture, including each school's budget and financial position, workforce, timetabling and use of resources, school operation and curriculum needs, student support needs, including support for students with disability, and work health and safety risks.

Specialist reviewers and subject matter experts from within the education support office have provided advice and assessed risk relevant to each school submission. An assessment and moderation panel is now in the process of reviewing feedback from all schools to determine the impacts of any changes to school budgets. The panel is working through each school individually based on data, risk assessments, and information provided from schools and support teams. As we have worked with schools, we have identified school-specific circumstances as the Education Directorate has worked with schools, it has identified school-specific circumstances that have required more detailed nal analysis and risk mitigations. There has been a work There is a work health and safety staff consultation underway in weeks 3 and 4.

Consultation is taking place now so staff feedback can inform assessment before arrangements are confirmed. And staff feedback and schools' risk assessment will inform the broader assessment for its proposed 2027 arrangements. Final budgets will be determined in week 5. At present, again, Mr Madam Assistant Speaker, no ACT public school has had its budget finalised for 2027, and no final decisions have been made about staffing profiles or individual employee employees.

Final 2027 budgets will be adjusted when actual February 2027 enrolments are known as well. So, thank you to those doing this hard work.

01:55:35 - 01:55:40

Speaker 117

Thank you, Ms Stephen-Smith. The question is that Ms Nuttall's amendment to the motion be agreed. Yes, Mr Emerson?

01:55:40 - 02:02:16

Thomas Emerson

Thank you, Madam Assistant Speaker, and I thank Ms Lee for bringing this motion forward today. And also thank Ms Nuttall for her amendment, and both of which I will be supporting. This is an important matter, of course, and one that's caused real confusion and real anger across our community. I also want to acknowledge that the minister is making difficult decisions when it comes to the resourcing of our public education system. These changes don't come from nowhere, either.

They stem from a review, as she's remarked, that this Assembly requested. And due to that, part of me understands the minister's frustration, it feels as though this place won't get behind difficult decisions like this. I support a public education system that is fair and equitable, and it's abundantly clear that the devolved model of managing our schools has not delivered that, far from it, and now it's a crisis point. Every student in Canberra deserves the same chance at a great education, and change is needed to provide that. My concern is with how we get from here to there.

First, the timing. We're hearing loud and clear that schools and families have not been given the time or the clarity they need to adjust or prepare for what are pretty daunting changes for many schools. The principals, as Ms Lee remarked, have been told about these changes rather than really being brought along on the journey and being part of them, as Ms Nuttall spoke to. Second, the messaging. As Ms Lee points out in the motion, the minister has said that there will be no cuts, at least not to the overall education budget.

And we've heard repeatedly that school budgets haven't been finalised. But these assurances mean little to parents who have heard of, in some cases, millions of dollars potentially being cut from their child's school. These parents are genuinely worried about their children's education and their future. And everyone accepts that hard decisions have to be made, but making them without a plan for how that will land and assuming this information won't be leaked, leading to serious anxiety across our community given what it could mean for some of our schools, I think does show a lack of foresight. Making them in a way that creates such significant uncertainty is deeply damaging for confidence in a public education system which is already seeing declining enrolments.

How the information and messaging around this has been managed or mismanaged, to the motion, has real consequences. I've heard from one parent at a primary school whose proposed budget suggests significant cuts that 10 families they know, this is just among the families they know, have already made the decision to move their children into the private system next year. For them, this is the last straw. They're already seeing split, collapsed classes. They're already frustrated at the poor quality of their school's infrastructure.

They already don't have any language classes at their school. And, for them, they've had enough. For them, it doesn't matter that these are proposed budgets and they're not final. They won't be around to see budgets finalised. Their decision's been made.

Finally, I'm frustrated at the lack of engagement across the Assembly on making difficult decisions before they're made. This is a pattern that keeps emerging. We've seen it with libraries, outpatient wait-lists, and school budgets. You can't expect us to support a decision made without our knowledge when our community is crying out for us to oppose it. It's harder still when we haven't been given an explanation ahead of time of why it had to happen this way.

And I only speak for myself, I don't I don't know the information that's been provided to others, but whether we want to call it mismanagement, bad planning, a comms failure, poor information control, or a lack of foresight, the result is the same and I think the government does need to take responsibility for that today. This for me is not a criticism of the directorate of public servants. Officials are working hard on this and I don't want to devalue that, I acknowledge that. There's just clearly a gap here, a gap between the decision being made and whether or not our community and this Assembly are actually prepared for it. A gap between what families have heard, what they've been told, and what they're actually seeing on the ground at their schools.

That's where trust is lost and the government does need to step up.

Madam Assistant Speaker, I also have concerns about potential downstream consequences of these changes. The student resource allocation works on a per-student basis. Fewer students means less funding. In principle, of course, that makes sense, but, in practice, it does risk creating a vicious cycle.

Parents pull their children out because of under-resourcing, and we've seen this in some of the schools in my electorate, so the school's funding falls. Because of that, other parents see a school with fewer resources, and they enrol their kids into private schools instead. And it repeats again and again until our public schools are stripped bare. That is the risk I think we're running here.

At the end of question time yesterday, the Chief Minister acknowledged the reality of minority government, although in relation to a very different matter. He said that ACT Labor, quote, operates in a parliament where it does not hold a majority in its own right. Therefore, every piece of legislation and every major reform is subject to debate and scrutiny by other parties, by independents, both inside and outside of executive government. This is true. So, please engage with us earlier.

Work with us. If every major reform is going to be scrutinised and debated, and the Chief Minister's right about that, then perhaps it makes sense to bring people in at the start, not leave them to react at the end. Governments need to make their own decisions; I accept that, I'm not asking to be involved in every one of them. But when you are making major changes like cutting library opening hours, changing school funding like this, or taking people off medical waiting lists,

you can't expect us in the Assembly not to react. You know the community's going to react. Most of us support, I think, the principles behind these policies, but we're being asked to defend them while our communities are alarmed. And none of us have been given the information to understand the justification for the changes ahead of time or the longer term vision for how to make them work for Canberrans.

We're here to fight for what's best for our electorate, so please bring us in on this, how these decisions are made and explained so the message our communities hear is more accurate, consistent, reassuring, including when difficult decisions are being made, although I understand that can require trust as well. Mr Speaker, I appreciate the challenging position the minister's in here. We need to move from an inequitable system to an equitable one, which means redistribution, and redistribution at a time when many schools already suffer from under-resourcing.

But I am also hearing every single week from parents who are deeply distressed by what they're hearing about what's happening to school budgets, what they're seeing on the ground. They deserve more clarity and better communication, and our public schools deserve sufficient investment across the board to, per the minister's vision, make every local public school an excellent first choice for every family. The ACT rightly prides itself on our public education system, and we cannot afford for our community to lose faith in it.

02:02:16 - 02:02:21

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you. Ms Castley, on Ms Nuttall's amendment.

02:02:21 - 02:04:50

Fiona Carrick

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The school resource allocation review has made a clear made a clear case for reform if we are to better support students and inform outcomes, improve outcomes across our public education system. This reform, however, cannot come at the expense of transparency, certainty and trust.

I have been hearing from the community about the funding changes. Many school communities have been left confused about what the changes mean for funding, staffing, programs and support services. In some cases, they have struggled to get clear answers. Principals should not be put in the position of having to explain budget impacts to their communities without having the information they need. They should be genuine partners in the process.

That is why it is entirely reasonable to ask the minister to establish clear budget development protocols with defined timelines and meaningful consultation so that school leaders have a real voice in decisions that affect their schools.

This is particularly important at a time when resources are already stretched, teachers are campaigning for better conditions and schools are dealing with increasing student complexity. The uncertainty about the budget adds unnecessary pressure to this already difficult situation. I'm also concerned that some families are losing confidence in the public education system because they cannot get clear information about what these changes will mean for their local school. That is an unacceptable outcome. Strong public schools depend on strong community confidence.

While I accept that not every answer can be provided before decisions are finalized, there is no excuse for failing to communicate clearly, consult meaningfully and prepare school leaders to engage with their communities. The revision of the school resource allocation model is one of the most significant pieces of education reform currently underway. The assembly, school leaders, staff and parents deserve regular updates on its progress, its timeline and the principles that will guide future funding decisions. Changes may well be necessary, but accountability, consultation and transparency are essential. For these reasons, I will be sorting supporting the motion and the Greens' amendment.

Sends a clear message that as the government reforms school funding, it must bring principals, teachers and school communities along with it. Thank you.

02:04:50 - 02:04:55

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms. Castley. The question is that Ms. Nuttall's amendment to Ms. Lee's motion be agreed. Mr. Parton.

02:04:55 - 02:09:12

Mark Parton

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Ms. Stephen-Smith characterized it as scaremongering. We characterize it as standing up for parents and students and standing up for teachers and standing up for school communities. School communities are so happy that Ms. Lee is here because they know that she is a dogged, stubborn, loud fighter for fairness and a better deal for the people in those communities. The minister continues to assert that budgets have not been finalized.

And she'd be right. But I think what's clear is that left to her own devices, the minister would be making the sort of cuts that have been flagged in recent weeks. Ms. Lee, I am so glad you are here to raise these issues in the way that you have, to put the government on notice that these cuts will not be tolerated and that Canberra families will not pay the price for this government's financial mismanagement which is at such a scale that it compromises so much that should be a priority for government. I want to share some of the correspondence that I've had from people down in the southern suburbs regarding these cuts. I'm not going to mention any names.

This person says, "I saw your Facebook posts on school funding cuts. I want to remain anonymous. I'm not sure how much is allowed to be shared. My husband is on the P&C at our primary school and they've been told the funding cut is $800,000. We already don't have a school librarian, regularly have split classes because there aren't enough relief teachers or casuals.

We are horrified at what this will mean for the school going forward. Please keep pushing." Someone from Theodore says How do I know they're in Theodore? 'Cause they start the email with, "I live in Theodore." "I live in Theodore, have three children who attend or will attend Theodore Primary.

I'm writing to express my concern about the reported reduction of approximately $300,000 or around 8% in the school's 2027 budget. Based on recent enrollment figures, this reduction equates to roughly $1,300 per student. But to me, this is about more than numbers on a spreadsheet, it's about the quality of education and opportunities my children receive at their local school. I worry that cuts of this size could affect staffing, learning support and educational programs, reducing the opportunities available to my children and other Theodore students.

What I struggle to understand is how a reduction of this magnitude aligns with the government's commitments to needs-based and equitable funding. The public reporting suggests that some schools in more advantaged communities may receive funding increases over the same period. I would appreciate a clear explanation of how these outcomes fit with the government's own objectives. As a parent, I want my children to attend a well-supported local public school. As a resident of Theodore, I want confidence that decisions affecting local students are being properly scrutinised and that my elected representatives are actively advocating for the children and families that they were elected to serve, which is known by some in the chamber as scaremongering.

That's what this resident of Theodore suggested. Shannon writes: thank you for keeping this travesty in the public conversation. This is the height of mismanagement by the ACT government. Not one public school in the territory should have to face the prospect of budget cuts. No matter how you slice it, vulnerable students are going to be the worst affected, and if they lose their supports, their peers and teachers are directly affected, not to mention the learning opportunities, the specialist classes that are threatened.

These cuts simply have to come from elsewhere in the territory's budget. Leave education alone. I think that there is enough genuine angst, and angst which is extremely warranted in the community to absolutely support this Assembly passing this motion today, and I'm pleased that we're talking about it.

02:09:12 - 02:09:20

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr Parton. The question is that Ms Nuttall's amendment to Ms Lee's motion be agreed to. Mr Warren-Gash.

02:09:20 - 02:18:23

Taimus Werner-Gibbings

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. I did have a much too long speech critiquing this motion's criticism of the government for actively reviewing how resources can be directed more effectively towards ACT public students with the greatest need. Essentially, the members opposite support educational equity for all, in theory, if not in practice, provided nobody's allocation ever changes. But I've cut all of that bit. The minister spoke too well and lucidly.

Instead, I'm going to add some context to this motion's gratuitous, but characteristic, craving to ascribe blame and demand reparation. I'm very disappointed with its description of the ACT government school system in part (2)(j) as being at breaking point. Breaking point. Mr Speaker, I am not an area expert on as many issues as I would like to be. I do a lot of listening to improve my understanding of issues, but really to maintain my own sense of legitimacy if and when I would come out with grandstanding claims about the viability of an institution, a sector, a community, a key element of the social contract, the main seam in the fabric of Australia's fraying vision of itself as an egalitarian society.

And when the aim of those claims is to pour petrol on the institution and watch it burn, I really want to be sure I know what I'm talking about, or at least I want to be able to rely on my lived experience to ballast my rhetoric with some authenticity. And on this topic, even if I don't understand it perfectly, I live it proudly and with more personal investment than anyone else in this chamber. The health, success and prospects of ACT public schools directly affects me. I made a choice. It was an easy choice, and I am proud of it.

I'm the only member of this Assembly with a child in each tier of the ACT public school system. Each of those schools, based on the current modelling, is facing a negative adjustment. None of those schools is happy about that prospect, if it manifests. None of them—primary school, high school, including one Ms Lee helpfully mentioned, and college—is at breaking point.

I had a very interesting conversation with a fabulous P&C committee at one of the schools last week. They are concerned, fair enough. They are doing some thinking, which is great. A couple of members asked about the possibility of a glide slope if the funding reallocation was confirmed. They are looking forward to more information and clarity about how these provisional new funding amounts were determined.

Essentially, they want the government to show its working, how the student resource allocation model crunches numbers on equity and need. Fair enough. And yet, we come back to the term "breaking point". None of them mentioned that the school was at breaking point. And then when I read it in the motion, immediately I thought, "Breaking point compared to what?"

Can't be other Australian jurisdictions. ACT's 26-27 budget, inclusive of new and continuing initiatives, allocates over 1.2 billion in recurrent funding to the public school system. That's an increase of 7.32% on the 25-26 estimated outcome. Every ACT public school is funded above the schooling resourcing standard. The ACT is the only jurisdiction in Australia where every public school is funded above that standard.

Over 98% of Australian public schools are not funded to 100% of the SRS. The 1.3% that are all and only ACT public schools. The Commonwealth government will contribute 22.5% of the SRS in 2026. The ACT government contributes more than its minimum required level of 80%. In 2024, ACT government funding to public schools was 92.2% of the SRS.

For comparison, see Queensland, a schooling system whose commitment to school air conditioners was lauded in the Assembly earlier this year. When you consider the 4% in non-school costs states can claim as part of their SRS share, Queensland contributed 66.5% of the full SRS in 2024. Queensland public schools are underfunded by 13.5%. Under the existing Commonwealth Queensland funding agreement, Queensland public schools will only ever be funded to 91% of the SRS at best. Queensland private schools will be continued to be funded at over 100%.

As the Queensland P&C states, it's impossible to deliver a system which promotes excellence and equity without full funding. So, the ACT public system isn't at breaking point based on its funding. Is it at breaking point based on its outcomes? Completion rates remain high. School retention rates are among the strongest in the country.

The system continues to invest heavily in inclusion, wellbeing, infrastructure, support for students with additional needs. See what the government is doing. The ACT consistently records among the highest NAPLAN results in the country: 74.9% of year 7 students in the strong or exceeding bands in reading and the highest proportion of any jurisdiction in the exceeding category at 25.5%. So, breaking point compared to what? Not funding relative to other Australian jurisdictions. Not outcomes relative to other Australian jurisdictions.

Is the vision of separated secondary public schools at breaking point because its design is more expensive per student and reliant on more separate sites than a comparably cost-efficient system would need? I believe it was this purported inefficiency that saw Saul Eslake focused on in his report on the ACT economy earlier this year. That design in the '70s and '80s was viable under conditions that are no longer present: strong Commonwealth funding, rising enrolments, and a public enrolment share well above today's. The territory is now funding that vision under deficit. And what the vision truly didn't anticipate was how much of Canberra's population would eventually choose not to use it.

Canberra's advantaged and privileged families are disproportionately choosing private schools. And perhaps that is the tacit point of comparison this motion's use of "breaking point" is alluding to. Is the ACT public system at breaking point due to the flight of privileged Canberran children from the public system to the private system, which is creating an increasingly segregated school system as private schools use fees and testing to weed out and exclude the socially disadvantaged and educationally undesirable? I don't have any experience or insight into the need for that expensive choice, but I can guess.

I presume it is partly about preference, partly about cultural signalling, but substantially about the fact that decades of federal education funding policy have actively subsidised that choice with public money. The policies are designed to produce this pattern. Resource advantages help some schools pull privileged in, privileged students in. High fees push children from low-income families away. I cite here a stark example from the excellent work of Will Greenwell, who in a 2020 article noted that the suburb of Pearce, in Woden, was in the top tenth of Australian suburbs.

It hosted, well, still hosts, two high schools, one commercial and Catholic, one public and secular. In 2020, some 58% of the students at the non-government school came from the most privileged quarter of Australian families, 1% from the most disadvantaged quartile. The proportion of most privileged students at the public school was 28%. 16% of its students came from the most disadvantaged quarter of Australian families. The Australian Index of Community Socio-Educational Advantage, or ICSEA, the policy makers measure of how lucky our home circumstances are, gives an average Australian school a score of a thousand.

In Pearce, the government school ICSEA was 1,049 in 2020, the non-government school was 1,132. Tuggeranong schools, Kambah and Wanniassa, are in the second tenth most affluent Australian suburbs, but the social divide between the northern slopes of Mount Taylor and the southern slopes of Mount Taylor is minimal. The educational divide is vast. The 2020 ICSEA scores assigned to the public schools in Kambah and Wanniassa were 980 and 983 respectively. A third or more of their students came from the most disadvantaged quarter of Australian families.

More than 10% of their students were Indigenous. The differences between Kambah, Wanniassa and Pearce is nowhere near enough to explain the differences between the schools, but the educational segregation looks very similar to Australia's increasingly unique education system focusing on separating young Australians into schools characterised by concentrated privilege or concentrated disadvantage, resulting in outcomes increasingly the result of differences in wealth, income, power, or possessions. If only 1% of students at the Pearce Catholic school are from tough backgrounds, then there have to be very high proportions of these kids at other schools in the area. And while successfully recruiting out of area students from well-educated, high-income families, who were or should be leaders and role models at their local public schools, undermines even further the egalitarian, opportunity for all, cultural approach that our public school system is trying to foster. And that's some of the context that this motion needs, Mr Speaker.

02:18:23 - 02:18:51

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr Werner-Gibbings. The question is that Ms Nuttall's amendment to Ms Lee's motion be agreed. All those of that opinion say aye. Ms Lee, this is the amendment. Yep, to the contrary, no.

I declare that the ayes have it. The question then is that Ms Lee's motion as amended be agreed. In closing, Ms Lee. Thank you, Mr Speaker, yes, in closing.

02:18:51 - 02:22:22

Elizabeth Lee

And I thank all members for their contribution to this debate. As Ms Nuttall pointed out, despite the minister's accusations about the opposition, the Greens have also been asking numerous questions about the mismanagement of the budget process which has caused undue confusion and stress and anxiety, and has not been awarded with satisfactory answers. And that is why the Greens have supported my motion today. I also thank Mr Emerson for his contribution. And he's made a good point about, you know, the lack of consultation that doesn't, well, the consultation that doesn't happen before decisions are made, and that seems to be the practice across the board, not just on school budget cuts.

The minister has employed a very strange tactic when it comes to dealing with this issue. Her first approach was to deny, point-blank, the cuts at all. Point-blank deny the cuts at all by willfully talking about the education budget as a whole when clearly she's asked about school budgets. And then,

she pivots to claim that budgets haven't been finalised, that they're only proposed budgets, but then herself admits that final budgets will be pretty close to the proposed budgets. This, of course, totally ignores the reality on the ground that despite what principals are telling her,

that it doesn't matter if the budgets are finalised in April, in January, in November, or September next year, it doesn't matter. The fact is that the principals are making decisions right now about staffing, about programs, and what is going to happen at their schools next year. As we have been told by multiple principals, staff have already been told that they no longer have a job next year. And even in this debate, the minister continues to claim that specialist schools will not lose funding, but refuses, despite numerous opportunities to do so,

refuses to come clean about where the shortfall of funding is coming from. And I note, despite, once again, saying, "No cuts," she does expects all of the principals and teachers to just swallow it without explaining

where the shortfall is coming from. Mr Speaker, it is incredibly disappointing, incredibly disappointing that a minister who has had this much experience,

continues to accuse me repeatedly of spreading misinformation and blaming me personally for the distress, anxiety and stress that principals, teachers and the school communities are feeling. Throwing the blame directly at the opposition and at me personally is the very definition of not taking responsibility, and that is why my motion calls on her to do so.

But as we know, despite the fact Did you have something to add, Minister? Despite the fact that she finally said the words "I take responsibility" only this week, after sustained pressure, we all know that words are meaningless if it's not followed up with action. Let's think talk about Sorry, I don't want to be interrupting you, Minister, what was that again?

02:22:22 - 02:22:25

Jeremy Hanson

Ms Lee, just ignore the interjections, please. Continue.

02:22:25 - 02:25:33

Elizabeth Lee

These are the words of the minister. "I really would encourage Ms Lee to stop scaremongering parents of children and young people in specialist schools." More words from the minister: "I do not know how many times I have to say this before Ms Lee will stop scaremongering parents of children and young people with disabilities." Again, from the minister:

"Any assertions that Ms Lee makes about reductions in funding to any school at this point are not accurate." Again, from the minister: "Ms Lee, as the shadow education minister, I believe, has had a briefing and can have another briefing. She can have as many briefings as she wants until she gets through her head what this model was and that we have another process that we're currently going through with principals." Again, from the minister:

"I really wish Ms Lee would move on from scaremongering about this particular issue." Again, from the minister: "I do want to recognise that this matter has caused distress in school communities, but I would ask Ms Lee to look in the mirror as to who is partially responsible for that. The amount of misinformation that the opposition is putting out is not helpful."

Again from the minister: It would have been less difficult if people were not taking the political opportunity to spread misinformation about it and continuing to raise questions despite firm assurances and indeed guarantees. Again from the minister: Scaremongering, as the opposition is doing, is not helping. Again from the minister:

I do not resolve from my comment last week. She was spreading misinformation and causing distress. Those are the words of the minister who has spent that entire time going "mhm" agreeing. Those are not the words of a minister who is taking responsibility for the mishandling of the budget process. But of course, it's all good for her to say that it's just us doing the scaremongering.

So, let's hear from some of the parents and the emails that we have been receiving. For me, this is not an abstract discussion about budgets and government priorities. It's about the safety of my children and their future. Another one, Mr. Speaker: The proposed cuts are particularly difficult to understand where the school is already struggling with significant infrastructure issues.

Parts of the school have a leaking roof. Some classes lack adequate cooling, making them hot and uncomfortable during Canberra's summer months, resulting in children less likely to engage with proper learning. And another one, Mr. Speaker: Families are concerned about the possible impacts on classroom and relief staffing, learning and disability support, intervention programs, specialist subjects and well-being services. And another, Mr. Speaker:

I'm particular concerned about the impact of funding cuts on students and teachers. Teachers are already working under significant and increasingly unsustainable pressure. Reducing the resources available to the school risks placing even greater demands on teachers while reducing the support available to students. Teachers cannot wait for future reform while being routinely placed in situations where class sizes increase dramatically and additional support disappears. And another, Mr. Speaker:

Students with additional needs cannot simply be expected to cope without the support they require, and teachers cannot continue to absorb increasing levels of responsibility without the staffing and resources necessary to provide safe, inclusive and effective education. And the list goes on, but I think you get the point, Mr. Speaker. And so, for the minister to come into this place

02:25:33 - 02:25:35

Speaker 129

Minister.

02:25:35 - 02:28:28

Elizabeth Lee

And so, for the minister to come into this place and continue to deflect is the very definition of not taking responsibility. And that is why, despite her very many attempts to try and get that ruled out of my motion, that is going ahead as is. Now, in the few minutes I've left, I do want to go to Mr. Werner-Gibbings's contribution cuz I saw that the minister gave him a round of applause, and he deserves it, for the most dramatic sequence that I think he has done to date, and that's saying something. Once again, once again, he talks about and criticizes my motion.

So, I look forward to seeing him vote against it. So, I look forward to seeing him vote against my motion. And let it be let it be said, Mr. Speaker, that Mr. Werner-Gibbings's lived experience, quote "lived experience", trumps the lived experiences of the principals. It trumps the lived experiences of the teachers.

It trumps the lived experiences of the many other parents. It trumps the lived experiences of the learning support assistants. It trumps the lived experiences of the students who have all reached out not just to me, not just to Mr. Parton, Ms. Nuttall,

Mr. Emmerson, Ms. Kikkert. We've all received emails. But no. According to Mr. Werner-Gibbings, his lived experience is the one that trumps them all.

So, he goes on about the words "at breaking point". That would seems to be the thing that he had the most concern with. Those words came directly from the union. Those words are from the organization that represents teachers on the ground. The fact is that this motion was required because, despite the numerous opportunities to do so, the minister—

in fact, she said herself in the debate that Ms. Nuttall in bringing her amendment was confused.

That is the entire point. This whole process has been confusing. The whole process has created anxiety and stress. And she knows because, politically, she doesn't have the numbers. But we know that words speak louder than words, actions speak louder than words, and she needs to make sure that she can learn from this.

But from the attitude and the interjections during my wrap speech, I have no faith that she's going to take on board what I have called for in the motion despite the fact that she's not voting against it purely because they don't have the numbers. But who knows, given Mr Werner-Gibbings's contribution, perhaps he will, because I look forward to seeing him vote against the motion.

02:28:28 - 02:28:44

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms Lee. The question is that Ms Lee's motion, as amended, be agreed. All of those of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. I declare that the ayes have it.

And the clerk will call the clerk.

02:28:44 - 02:28:47

Speaker 130

Private members' business notice number three.

02:28:47 - 02:28:52

Jeremy Hanson

Ms Vassarotti.

02:28:52 - 02:28:59

Rebecca Vassarotti

I move the motion standing in my name on the notice paper relating to clubs' community contribution scheme.

02:28:59 - 02:29:02

Jeremy Hanson

The question is that the motion be agreed to, Ms Vassarotti.

02:29:02 - 02:44:03

Rebecca Vassarotti

Thank you, Mr Speaker. This is a motion that recognises the vital importance of charities, community groups, and community sport to the ACT's social and community fabric. This motion seeks to safeguard the funding and the wellbeing of these groups into the future. It calls on the government to take action now to safeguard community organisations, charities, and community sport. Central to this issue is the fact that over many years the ACT has established a model whereby many club community groups, charities, and community sports organisations have become reliant on funding that comes from poker machines revenue.

ACT legislation requires that clubs operating poker machines return 8% of their net gaming machine revenue, that is their pokies profits, to the community. It is this 8% that my motion focuses on, although I note that the legislation also requires 0.4% of gaming revenue to go to the Chief Minister's Charitable Fund and another 0.4% to go to the Gambling Harm Prevention and Mitigation Fund. What we have set up is a kind of poisonous recycling system. It's a system that takes money from the community through harmful and addictive gambling products and then presents a portion of that same money back to these communities as philanthropy. We should be clear about the fact that it is a legal requirement for poker machine operators to make these community contributions.

Clubs are very active in using the fact that they make these contributions to help generate their social licence to continuing to provide harmful and addictive gambling products to the community. This whole arrangement is a broken system for obvious reasons. Firstly, poker machines cause extensive harm in the community. We are funding community groups from a funding source that is harmful and destroys communities. This harm, of course, is experienced by people who gamble, as well as their families and social networks.

And pokies are the primary source of gambling harm in the ACT. This is borne out by the prevalence survey, and according to a report from Charles Livingston and Fair, the level of harm associated with gambling in the ACT is on a level similar to the to a that of a major mental illness. We can't only look at the contributions that are flowing from pokies revenue and ignore the harm. Gambling harm causes financial harm, relationship harm, physical health harm, legal and criminal harms, psychological and emotional harms,

including links to suicide. I just wanted to make note that I will in this next few minutes speak about some issues related to suicide, and just wanted to give warning of this to people who might be impacted by these comments. I think it is really important that we do talk about the link to suicide. It's not discussed enough, and I know that today just today, the Canberra Liberals have tabled a bill about suicide.

I do not doubt the real concerns the Miss and care that Miss Part- Mr Parton has in relation to suicide regarding this very distressing issues, but you have to engage in the reality of what is driving some of these issues. Research shows that there are strong links between gambling and suicide. Researchers say that documented and understood cases of gambling-related suicide are likely to only be the tip of the iceberg when it comes to gambling-linked suicide, because people suffering often keep it secret, and the real-life stories are harrowing.

Members have probably all read about the tragic case of Mr and Mrs Kazurian. Mr Kazurian tragically died by suicide, and his family have made public commentary about his death and the hundreds of thousands of dollars he and his wife lost in pokies on the pokies at the Woden Hellenic Club over several years. These kinds of stories are not uncommon.

The ABC recently reported on another young man who died by suicide. Jake Bembic was a popular and outgoing 19-year-old. His parents say that suicide was linked to his gambling problem. When he was when he just turned 18, he won the equivalent of his full-time fortnightly wage, but his parents say this was probably his downfall because he saw it such as such a good thing.

Another story from ABC is about gambling harm advocate, Ben Hamilton, who says that his gambling started at the age of 16. He says for a decade he spiralled, and he still dreams about the colours, music, and the flashing lights of the machines conditioned in their users to fall in love with. Ben says that over the years, he attempted suicide on multiple occasion,

and since he's started his organisation, he knows of at least 10 people who have taken their own life. These tragic stories are all too common. According to the Australian Institute of Family Studies, gambling harms are also often under-reported and un- unidentified. I dwell on this because we often hear from clubs that operate poker machines, as well as from members of this Assembly, about the benefits that clubs bring to the community, including through their community contributions. But what we don't hear about is the extent of harm caused by their pokies operations, and how they will address this harm.

We need to acknowledge this harm, and we need to address it. The harm from pokies is a pernicious force that destroys communities. It's not a defense to say that some of them are moneys from pokies trickles back to the community. Even if we were just turned this into a simple economic equation, the report I mentioned earlier from Charles Livingstone and Fair points out the community contributions made by clubs in the ACT do not outweigh the harm caused by gambling harm. These contributions are not offsetting the serious harm caused by this form of gambling.

The second point I want to emphasize is that supporting community groups through poker machine funding is inherently an unstable funding source for everyone. And everyone, I think, agrees that it needs to change. This is not a funding model that we want for the future. It's not good for community groups or for the community at large. Charities, community groups, and community sport, these are fundamentals of to the fabric of our city, and we need to put them on a stable footing.

As my motion points out, the gamblings ga- the government's gambling reform agenda is expected to reduce gambling revenue, which is a good thing, and this will reduce the funds available through the community contribution scheme. The landscape is changing. We need to get ahead and plan for this transition. It is critical that these community groups have access to long-term sustainable funding sources that do not depend on gambling losses. We don't want them to disappear or be disadvantaged from this transition.

These community organizations should not have to bear the cost of the transition. Because of this historical entanglement with pokies money through no fault of their own, groups such as community sports clubs will possibly face uncertainty through the upcoming years of transition. My motion asks government to start addressing these issues now, and to plan ahead to be proactive. One po- important component of this, as my mo- motion asks, is that government considers funding a community peak body to ensure the interests of community sport are represented through this transition. Along with my Greens colleagues, I've enjoyed meeting and hearing the concerns of the Community Sports Alliance ACT, and I'm really supportive of establishing a peak body.

My motion asked the governments to take a close the government to take a close look at the existing community contribution scheme. Needs review, oversight, transparency, and reform. The community contribution scheme does not have a fantastic history. In 2018, there was an Auditor-General's report on communi- on the community contribution scheme, which found a range of problems with how the scheme was functioning. It lacked supporting objectives or guidance about how to interpret the legislation.

The clubs had too much flexibility on allocating contributions. Monitoring and reporting was poor. Some of the concerns raised about the old community contr- contribution scheme included things like apparent community expenditure actually going to things like airp- airline lounge membership fees, massages, and newspapers. The result was that the system was overhauled in 2019. This It brought This brought in new guidelines.

It also devolved responsibilities to clubs individually and independently to manage and report their contributions. It appears, though, that this system is not working particularly well. First of all, I've confirmed in questions on notice that there has been very little auditing or policing of the community contribution scheme.

The auditing that has been done shows that there are problems. The Gaming and Racing Commission has done one partial audit of licensees in 2024-25. It audited 19 club licensees and found that none of them were compliant with their community contributions reporting obligations. And there have not been any other audits of the scheme. This does not bode well for how the scheme is functioning.

What appears to have happened is that the community contribution scheme has become somewhat invisible. It's lacking transparency. For confirmations, we need only to look at the final report of the independent panel inquiring into ClubsACT. The panel attempted to look at community contributions, but it concluded in its final report: The panel was unable to perform any detailed economic analysis of the community contributions made by clubs whether in-kind or direct financial payments.

This was due to lack of high quality, verifiable and complete data related to such contributions. I think we can all agree that this is not a great outcome. When the commissioning expert panel can't even report to the government on the functioning of the community contribution scheme, we know that something needs to change. A related issue that I wanted to touch on is the fact that a good proportion of community purpose contributions are being made via in-kind contributions. That means, for example, that a club can acquit some of its community purpose obligations not by providing direct grants to the community, but say, allowing a community group to use a club a use a room in the club.

Usually, that would be a room that would otherwise be going be sitting empty. These in-kind contributions work to limit the amount of real money that is invested in our community. And I'm not saying that the provision of a room or other in-kind contributions are not helpful. They are. There's a list The list of groups benefiting from these arrangements list into the hundreds.

Affordable to free affordable or free access to venues, sporting fields and meeting spaces is really important for the viability of sporting and special interest groups. I believe that clubs can and should provide many of these community services and supports without being forced to. They can do it because it is so often connected with their core purpose, because they are good community citizens or because they genuinely care,

they generally care and are connected to their community. But they can do this without counting on it as part of their legislated community contributions obligations. I'll conclude by emphasise emphasising the need for action on this issue. The government needs to take action and start addressing the issues I've raised.

This should be based on a vision of us freeing us from gambling harm, while ensuring that we maintain thriving communities where we have community sports, clubs, charities, support services and all those fantastic real-life activities that make up our community. The government needs to review the operation of the community contributions scheme, including in relation to the various issues I've raised in concerning transparency, compliance and appropriateness of including in-kind contributions, and, naturally, in relation to the expected funding changes from the proposed gambling reforms. The motion also calls for a feasibility study for a new, centralised independent fund for community contributions. This is a model that would make the distribution of community contributions independent. Centralising funds would allow the establishment of a corpus that could generate interest and contribute to long-term sustainability of this funding source.

It would allow a level of coordination and streamlining. I've said publicly that I expect such a fund would require the injection of government funding as well. It's a core principle of this transition, as my motion makes clear, that we don't leave our sporting clubs, charities, and community service providers worse off through this transition. They can't be left to bear the burden of this transition. This motion is a modest call to get the work started.

I'm hopeful that there will this is something that the parliament can agree on, and will support this motion. I commend the motion to the Assembly.

02:44:03 - 02:44:06

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms Vassarotti. The question is the motion be agreed to, Mr Parton.

02:44:06 - 02:46:19

Mark Parton

Thank you, Mr Speaker. This motion from Ms Vassarotti is fascinating. It does make a very important acknowledgment. It very clearly states that the government's gambling reforms will reduce the funds available to sporting organisations, charities and community services through clubs. Now that is something that has been made clear on a couple of occasions by the minister, but I think it's really important for us to focus on that.

You know, I don't think that the government's going to go through and amend that out because it's true. The club sector is bracing for the fight of its life. And it's a fight simply for survival. The gambling reforms that have been presented and outlined by the government will send a wrecking ball through the sector, and we've long raised these concerns. The Greens are now recognising that community organisations should not bear the costs of transition, as has been clearly articulated by Ms Vassarotti and one of the things that she and I agree on in this space.

The minister must respond to that concern. And the Greens must follow their own argument through to its logical conclusion. Replacement funding needs to be secured before existing support is put at risk. And it's why I want to move an amendment to the motion. And, members, I'm sorry that it's become a little convoluted.

We've got a version two in front of you at the moment which actually says amend 3(d), but the version that is with the clerk has been amended by pen to say amend 2(d). It is 2(d) that we are looking to amend, and that's to insert how the government intends to replace any reduction in community contributions as a result of government gambling reforms. And we think it's extremely important, and we want to know what's going to happen in this sector. And it hasn't been clearly outlined, so I move the amendment that's been circulated in my name.

02:46:19 - 02:46:23

Jeremy Hanson

The question is that Mr Parton's amendment to the motion be agreed.

02:46:23 - 02:53:44

Mark Parton

The government is about to trash the not-for-profit club sector in pursuit of some ideological prize of getting rid of poker machines, at least here in this little island as the ACT, all while knowing that the genuine problem gamblers will simply go to Queanbeyan to play the pokies. And Queanbeyan will just become Las Vegas. And I want to know how the government will replace the community contributions that will be lost as a consequence, because the community should not miss out because of this fixation that Dr Paterson is clinging to. The government has yet to put before this Assembly a comprehensive, publicly available assessment of the combined impacts of its reforms on community contributions, club sustainability and also on territory revenue, because it is going to It is going to provide quite the hit. How much community funding will be lost?

What will happen to gaming tax receipts and other government revenue?

what additional demands will fall on this already strat stretched budget? We just we've just had a long conversation about school budgets, you know, and about librarians and learning assistants. What how on earth is the government going to step in and say, "Well, that's all right. We'll find 1 million here. We'll find 5 million there," when the organizations that are getting support can no longer rely on club support?

If the minister has this modeling, she should provide it. And if she doesn't, the Assembly is being asked to support substantial changes without knowing the full financial and community consequences. And I know that's not the debate that we're having, but it is linked to this debate.

It's extremely linked. These concerns were also addressed by the independent inquiry the government itself commissioned into the future of the clubs industry. Recommendation G3 placed structural change ahead of material gaming change reductions. Recommendation G18 sought to protect community organizations and infrastructure from adverse transition impacts. Advancing revenue reductions without first establishing those protections amounts in practical terms to repudiating the inquiry's advice on sequencing.

The government cannot credibly claim to be delivering a sustainable transition while leaving the community safeguards, well, just consider them later. We'll get to them a little bit later down the track. Transition support was also a part of Labor's own clubs policy, and Community Clubs Plan, or its Community Clubs Plan, promised an innovation fund providing seed funding for diversification,

a review of existing funding arrangements, and examination of the long-term consequences for community contributions, which are at the core of this debate. I think the minister should explain where that promised funding is, how much is available, when the clubs can access it. The government's inquiry response does not provide a costed transition funding package. The financial support needed to make transition possible has been left behind while measures reducing club revenue move forward. Now, the Greens proposed reporting deadline also deserves a little scrutiny,

and I understand that there's been discussion between the Greens and the government on this, and I understand that there were some good reasons that were put forward as to why the reporting date had to be pushed down the line a little, but the motion would allow this work to run until the final sitting week of 2027. And although government measures are scheduled, well they're scheduled to commence very soon, the EFTPOS withdrawal ban is due in weeks and reduced gaming operating hours on 1 July 2027.

If the Greens accept that community organizations must be protected, they should support bringing this work forward and delaying measures that threaten that funding until the protections are in place. I don't, you know, I don't have an additional amendment, but I just wanted to make the point that a review after support has been lost will not pay a sporting organization's bills or restore a canceled community program. The proposed examination of a centralized fund doesn't resolve the underlying funding question. Changing who distributes the money doesn't replace revenue that's disappeared.

Once the money is gone, it's gone. Any or because once this model has been trashed, it's not resurfacing. It's done. Any alternative must identify the source of replacement funding, its adequacy, the arrangements that will maintain support throughout transition. It must also recognize the practical values of facilities, sporting infrastructure, and affordable meeting spaces.

Transparency and accountability are legitimate expectations, but they cannot substitute for properly funded plan. And when it comes to community clubs, and we are talking about genuine not-for-profit community clubs, let's talk about the Vikings for argument's sake down south, who are doing their best to diversify into another jurisdiction,

because they can see that, you know, things it's all going to go to I can't say that here.

It's all going to come crashing down here. You look at the Vikings, who were set up originally to support rugby union in the Valley. And they have now grown into this wonderful organisation in regards their support for so many community sporting organisations that have adopted that Vikings logo, you know, there's all sorts of Vikings clubs now that get support from the Vikings so that people in Tuggeranong can enjoy that activity. To then go to a role whereby the Vikings are going to get their community contributions, shift them to this central body, and then these Vikings organisations are going to write to that central body and beg for money, which they may not get. All of a sudden, the whole community aspect of that community club has just evaporated.

It's just evaporated. This motion raises an issue the minister must not ignore. The Assembly should require comprehensive costings, accessible transition funding, and secured alternative community funding mechanisms before further progression and implementation of the revenue-reducing reforms. And, you know, I've obviously put that amendment in regards how it is that we're going to guarantee that community funding remains once we've trashed this model. I would respond to Ms Vezzarotti who spoke of our suicide prevention bill, and I would I think she's right to speak of a link between gambling and suicide and it's why we would much rather that people were gambling in a club where there is genuine and active support from club staff, rather than sitting alone in a dark bedroom at midnight and gambling online.

It's why we would support that we think that there's much more there are many more safeguards in place. And I'm also of the belief, well I know, that the protections that are offered here in the ACT are also much stronger than the protections that are offered in New South Wales. And I commend the amendment to the Assembly.

02:53:44 - 02:53:51

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr Parton. Ms Carrick to Mr Parton's amendment to the motion.

02:53:51 - 02:56:07

Fiona Carrick

Thank you, Mr Speaker. This motion raises an important question about the future of funding for community sport in the ACT. Sporting clubs are at the heart of our communities. They bring people together, keep people active and connected, and provide opportunities for young people to develop skills, confidence, and lifelong friendships and mentors. This is particularly important in current times due to the impact of media algorithms that drive division in our community.

For many clubs, funding received through the community contribution scheme helps cover the costs of facilities hire, equipment, participation programs, and volunteer costs. We should acknowledge the significant contribution that licensed clubs have made over many decades to grassroots sport and to many other community organisations. At the same time, it is clear there are questions about transparency, accountability, and compliance within the current scheme. If reporting requirements are not being met, we need a better understanding of how much money is reaching community organisations and how effectively those funds are being distributed. Importantly, as gambling reforms continue and gaming machine revenue declines, we must have an honest conversation about how community sport will be funded into the future.

Sporting clubs should not be left carrying the burden of that transition. Community organisations need certainty and sustainable funding arrangements so they can plan ahead and invest in their club to continue supporting participation.

For those reasons, I support this motion and the amendments. A review of the community contribution scheme is sensible, and I particularly welcome the proposal to establish a peak body for community sport. Community sport deserves a strong voice at the table as these reforms are considered, ensuring that the long-term interests of clubs, volunteers and participants are protected. This debate is not just about gambling policy.

It is about ensuring that community sports remain strong, sustainable and accessible for generations of Canberrans to come, and I am really pleased that we are finally having this conversation. So, thank you.

02:56:07 - 02:56:13

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms Castley. The question is that Mr Pettersson's amendment to the motion be agreed to, Ms Nuttall.

02:56:13 - 03:01:25

Laura Nuttall

I rise today in support of Ms Vassarotti's motion, and thank her for bringing it forward to the Assembly. I'll speak to the part of the motions relating to community contributions from gambling revenue and the future sustainability of sporting and community organisations. Local sporting orgs, volunteer-led orgs and community groups all receive a small portion of funding from gambling revenue. There is of course a challenging moral question for these groups. No one wants to be reliant on revenue associated with gambling harm.

Given the level of funding otherwise available from ACT and federal governments and philanthropic projects, there is also a challenging, practical question for community, sports and rec organisations who might not currently be able to operate at all without contributions from clubs. Importantly, these organisations are doing some of the most important work for our community. They are supporting vulnerable people. They are bringing like-minded people together to foster connection and facilitating local sport across all ages and postcodes. We know that revenue is finite,

and as this Assembly works with clubs to address the moral question of gambling harm reduction, that revenue will dwindle. As clubs move away from gambling related revenue in the ACT, it is absolutely critical that we ensure important community organisations are not left worse off as a result. Now, my colleague Ms Vassarotti has already spoken to the lack of transparency around the clubs community contribution scheme. It's enclosed in the motion, and I am pleased that the government has also indicated their support for reviewing the scheme.

We should be able to clearly see how the community is benefiting from a community contribution scheme. Yet as it stands, there is still little transparency around what money actually reaches the community, and what lot the long-term viability of this funding looks like, when we also seek a critical reduction of gambling harm in our community. Now, I want to make it clear that we understand how valuable and important the contributions to current beneficiaries are. Reviewing this system isn't about taking this away. Rather, it's about rethinking the reliance on an opaque and outdated system, and moving, in partnership with these community organisations, towards a more sustainable and long-term system.

We've heard from community sporting groups that any review of a community contribution scheme must meaningfully consider how any changes could potentially impact them, and that any subsequent reform must heed these considerations and ensure community sport isn't worse off for the changes. I'm really grateful to the groups that have engaged with us on this, and that we've had the chance to discuss how this review could actually be a really exciting opportunity to advance calls from community sports groups, namely, and most centrally, the call for a funded peak body to represent community sport. This is so important in the context of this review, and the government commitment to undertake it, because in order to ensure that the views and interests of community sport are properly represented in this view, community sport needs a proper seat at the table. Now, sport and rec organisations provide incredible value to our community, and that value often isn't properly quantified or accounted for.

These orgs don't just support our physical fitness, they support preventative health, mental health, prosocial behaviours and community connection, at a time when we desperately need it. And as brilliant as community sports and rec organisations are, there is only so far volunteer expertise and elbow grease can get them without long-term sustainable funding.

The closure of the Tuggeranong Zone Bowling and the proposed ice sports facility that never got off the ground are evidence that leaving much-needed sports facilities up to private, for-profit interests is unsustainable and unreliable. You could say the same about Big Splash, about a number of our aquatic facilities, about the wonderful Canberra Indoor Rock Climbing gym, which was the last top rope gym in the ACT. Now, from a Tuggeranong perspective, and speaking to a breadth of community organizations that stand to benefit from a community contribution fund of any kind, it's clear to us that community orgs do a significant amount of heavy lifting. Dedicated volunteers and organizers pour their time and energy into work that supports vulnerable people, all for the love of the game. We have so many great community organizations that have received community contributions, like Helping ACT, Advocacy for Inclusion, Little Lanyon.

Heck, the Tuggeranong Community Council meets monthly at the Canberra Southern Cross Club in Greenway. We want to make sure our community has the best possible investment model and that they are supported and sustained irrespective of clubs gambling revenue. It is incumbent on all of us to reckon with both the practical and, really importantly, the moral questions of our policymaking in this place. I think that this call, this motion, recognizes that tension and strikes a really strong balance. It doesn't rush into reform, calling for a feasibility study with careful considerations around impact and community interests.

And it ensures a long-term lens is used for examining any potential funding model alternatives. All the while, it seeks to push this government on progress that's long overdue for gambling harm reduction. And this, Mr Speaker, is absolutely critical. I commend Ms Vassarotti's motion to the Assembly.

03:01:25 - 03:01:31

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms Nuttall. The question is that the amendment to the motion be agreed. And I call Dr Paterson.

03:01:31 - 03:09:41

Marisa Paterson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I rise today to support this motion and thank Ms Vassarotti for bringing it before the Assembly. The motion raises important questions about what the future of the community contribution scheme may look like and how community funding arrangements can continue to support sporting organizations, charities and community groups into the future. The motion provides an opportunity to consider these issues in the broader context of the ACT's gambling reform agenda and work already underway through the independent inquiry of the future of the ACT clubs industry. These asks of government are very aligned with the work the government intends to progress to understand how community contributions can best operate, with a particular focus on ensuring transparency.

The community contribution scheme reflects a longstanding expectation that clubs benefiting from communi- gambling machine revenue should also contribute to the broader community. In 2019, significant reforms were introduced to strengthen the scheme. These reforms increased minimum contribution requirements, broadened the distribution of community contributions and introduced measures aimed at improving transparency, accountability and reporting. Importantly, these reforms recognize that community expectations have changed over time. The community rightly expects transparency regarding the contributions being made, confidence that those contributions deliver genuine public benefit, and assurance that gambling-related revenue is contributing to positive outcomes for the broader community.

The ACT government remains strongly committed to reducing gambling harm. The evidence is clear that poker machines continue to be associated with significant gambling-related harm and remain a key focus of the government's reform agenda. Over the September and October sitting weeks, I've introduced legislation that delivers ACT Labor's comprehensive gambling reform agenda.

In September, I introduced legislation to reform the territory's self-exclusion scheme. This is intended to make it easier for individuals who experience gambling harm to exclude from gambling while increasing obligations on licensees to recognize signs of harm in their venues. Last week, I introduced significant, nation-leading reform to reduce the harm from poker machines in the ACT. These reforms included introducing mandatory account-based gaming, complete with a range of harm minimization measures,

limiting access to cash in venues by banning EFTPOS and ATM withdrawals in club venues with EGMs, continuing the government's progress on reducing machine authorisations so that there are no more than a thousand machines by 2045. As noted in Ms Vassarotti's motion, the government's reform agenda in this space will potentially impact gambling revenue over time, which will, in turn, affect the amount of money available for distribution via the community contribution scheme. But ultimately, there is very much a recognition by government that this cost of the harm caused by poker machines in our community is significant

and is not outweighed by the benefit of community contributions. The government reforms are guided by the principle that gambling policy should be informed by evidence, focused on harm prevention, and designed to support stronger and healthier communities. Recognizing the need to support clubs through this transition, the government has established the government established the independent inquiry. The inquiry was tasked with developing independent recommendations to support clubs to diversify their revenue streams, reduce their reliance on poker machine revenue, and establish a staged pathway for transition.

The inquiry handed down its findings in June this year, and delivered a set of recommendations directed at both government and the club sector. Importantly, the inquiry recognized that supporting club diversification is important in achieving a sustainable transition away from a reliance on gambling revenue. The government is committed to working with clubs in the ACT to ensure they are supported through this transition. This month, the government will establish the Joint Clubs Transition Governance Group, a key recommendation of the inquiry. The governance group will provide a formal mechanism for government, clubs, and community stakeholders to work together on implementation of the inquiry's recommendations,

and help guide the sector's transition over coming years. The government has also established the Clubs Concierge Service, providing clubs with a dedicated point of contact and support in relation to planning, development, and diversification opportunities. In addition, we have commenced work examining planning and land-use opportunities that may assist clubs to diversify their activities and revenue streams, while a maintaining important community facilities for the benefit of Canberrans. The government recognises that implementation of the inquiry's recommendations will require ongoing collaboration with clubs, community sector, and other stakeholders.

The establishment of this governance group will provide an important forum to support that work and help shape future actions arising from an inquiry. The ACT government also recognizes the important role played by the ACT Gambling and Racing Commission, as the independent statutory authority responsible for monitoring licensees' compliance with the community contribution scheme. The commission plays a critical role in maintaining accountability and public confidence in the scheme's operation. An additional measure introduced in the 2019 reforms was the introduction of the independent audit of licensees' claims.

This provides further assurance that clubs are accurate and legitimate in their claims. Recent work undertaken by the commission throughout its 24-25 and 25-26 community contributions program identified opportunities for strengthening reporting, improving consistency and enhancing public confidence in the scheme. The program found that all club licensees reviewed had aspects of their reporting that did not fully comply with the scheme's reporting requirements. The issues identified related primarily to reporting practices and administrative processes rather than the objectives of the scheme itself. The commission remains committed to engaging with licensees to support compliance with reporting obligations.

Ultimately, maintaining community confidence in the scheme is important as ensuring that the contributions are made to the scheme. The community rightly expects clear reporting, appropriate oversight and confidence that contributions under the scheme are genuine benefits to the ACT community. This motion provides an opportunity to ensure that the community contribution scheme remains transparent, effect and effective in supporting community organizations in the future. Given the last significant reforms to the scheme occurred in 2019, I consider it timely to review the scheme and explore options open to government to ensure long-term funding is available for community purposes. I do have one piece of feedback on this motion and Mr Emerson's amendment, which he will move soon.

But I think it speaks entirely to sporting groups and facilities, and I think what's neglected in this is that not every club is a sports-based club and, obviously, not every community contribution goes to sport. So, many of the ACT clubs are of cultural or specific interest groups, and the government views the government views and response to this motion will hold firmly that in its consideration of what community what the future of the community contributions scheme may be, which will include community groups and much broader than sporting organizations. So, thank you.

03:09:41 - 03:09:56

Jeremy Hanson

The question is that Mr Parton's amendment to the motion be agreed. Thank you, Minister. All those of that opinion say aye. Contray no. I declare that the ayes have it.

So, the question then is that the motion as amended be agreed, Mr Emerson.

03:09:56 - 03:15:37

Thomas Emerson

Uh thank you, Mr Speaker. I'd like to start by thanking Ms Vassarotti for this motion and for her eagerness to tackle gambling harm in our community. It's clearly problematic that the viability of many sports organizations in Canberra, and I do want to focus on the sporting organizations, is so contingent on gambling revenue. And I've heard from some that feel this relationship creates for them an incredibly uncomfortable conflict of values. They desperately need funding to continue to deliver a vital service for our community and ensure Canberrans can enjoy the myriad benefits of participating in sport, but they're also conscious that their sports are funded by the proceeds of gambling harm.

At the same time, they feel unable to speak openly about this because they're so reliant on the funding and are not keen to do anything that may put that at risk. Likewise, this makes it incredibly hard for those sports organizations to participate in political debate about gambling harm reduction measures that may result in reduced income for clubs. And I thank Mr Parton for his amendment to this motion, which rightly outlines the need for a clear p- plan from the government to ensure gambling harm reforms, which I strongly support, do not signal the demise of both community sport and other community activities in Canberras as the minister has reflected on. I think herein lies the exact problem that needs to be solved. These two sectors should not be so inextricably linked that one cannot survive without the other.

On the face of it makes no sense whatsoever that they are. It's ironic in many ways: gambling and alcohol consumption cause significant public health and community harm, but community sports is the antithesis to such harm.

These two should not go together like Tweedledum and Tweedledee, but this is so often the case. It shouldn't be the case that community organisations and sports clubs, which make such a prosocial contribution to the life of our city, are unable to contribute to the public debate about reducing gambling harm in the ACT for fear of a reprisal that may sound their death knell. And it also makes zero sense, if we were coming at this from first principles, that community sport in the ACT is so heavily reliant on the gambling losses of Canberrans. Is this actually the most appropriate way to distribute resources? If we were coming at this with clearer eyes and if it were up to us as a community to determine how community clubs and community sports operate, would we really decide to have a whole bunch of little mini casinos scattered across our suburbs and set up a system where the only way for many people to play community sport was for some people to lose significant sums of money in those mini casinos, causing significant harm to them and their families?

I don't think we would. I mean, I acknowledge that this whole set up has emerged kind of organically over time and been cobbled together along the way. But is this really what we want? The thing is, ultimately, it is up to us as a community to decide how we want this to work. And what I hear from Canberrans is that ensuring community sport is sufficiently funded over the longer term should be the government's job, not the job of pokies venues, that people don't want sport and gambling to be inextricably linked any more.

My sense is that everyone in this place believes that sufficient funding for community organisations, including sports clubs, is absolutely necessary. And I also want to be clear, I'm not anti-club. I acknowledge the many important contributions clubs make to our community. This can't be said without also acknowledging the immense harm caused in our community what is by what is currently the number one revenue source. That's why I'm strongly supportive of the clubs diversifying away from gambling.

I want to see clubs thriving in a prosocial way with no caveats and also contributing to delivering much-needed housing stock for the ACT, which is obviously a potential diversification option. Currently, our planning system just doesn't seem to be facilitating that diversification, certainly not with that with any kind of speed. We need to get these two things working together in parallel: diversification away from something and, at the same speed, towards something else. This will take time, but if we're not diversifying quickly enough towards something else, let's not make the response to avoid tackling gambling harm. Instead, let's speed up the move away alongside the move towards something.

This will take time, nonetheless, and in the absence of immediate divestment away from gambling, it is appropriate to have a look at whether the funding of community organisations through community contributions should be outsourced through a vehicle like an independent independently managed community contributions fund. And I acknowledge the minister's remarks that obviously this isn't just about community sport, given the nature of my amendment, that's what I wanted to focus on in my remarks. An independent fund could be dually beneficial. It would sever these concerning ties between community sports and gambling harm, which is, as we know, a broader connection that's in that in place, not in just in the case of pokies venues, but more broadly, gambling advertising and so on. It would sever those ties, while also ensuring that the community contributions scheme delivers on its aims, with a strong system of independent management and distribution.

So, I welcome Ms Castley's proposal, I welcome her motion and I look forward to seeing the results of the government's feasibility study into such a mechanism. As mentioned, I've circulated an amendment to make clear to community sports that I, and I hope all members, take their viability very seriously and that we will hold the government to their commitment to ensure community sports, and as the minister has remarked, all community organisations that are involved in these schemes, will not be any worse off if any such changes as those implement proposed by the motion are implemented.

And I'm very supportive of Mr Parton's amendment which we've already passed. So, I thank all members for their contributions to this debate and, again, thank Ms Vassarotti for bringing it forward. And I move the amendments circulated in my name.

03:15:37 - 03:15:55

Jeremy Hanson

Mr Emerson, because standing order 142 says an amendment may not be moved to any part of a question after a later part has been amended or after a question has been proposed on an amendment to a later part, I'll require that you seek leave to move your amendment.

03:15:55 - 03:15:57

Thomas Emerson

I seek leave to move the amendments circulated in my name.

03:15:57 - 03:16:01

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you. Is leave granted? Leave is granted.

03:16:01 - 03:16:03

Thomas Emerson

I move the amendments circulated in my name.

03:16:03 - 03:16:21

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr Emerson. The question then is that Mr Emerson's amendment to the motion as amended be agreed. All those of that opinion say aye. To the contrary, no. I declare that the ayes have it.

The question then is that the motion as amended be agreed. In closing, Ms Vassarotti.

03:16:21 - 03:21:01

Rebecca Vassarotti

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker, and I would really like to thank all members for their contributions to the debate. There's been quite a lot of conversation around issues around gambling reform in the chamber over the last few months, and it is really positive that we have found, we have had a conversation and we will be able to move this motion unanimously. And thank both Mr Parton and Mr Emerson for the amendments that you've brought to strengthen the motion. I think it's really positive. I also thank the minister for her comments, and I think that it was, you know, it is really important to recognise that the contributions do go beyond community sport, that it is true that there's a, you know, a significant proportion that is, and certainly for community sports in particular, this remains such a significant part of their opportunities to seek funding, but it is an issue that impacts on other community organisations, and it is really important that we continue to make sure that they are covered as well.

So, that certainly wasn't the intention of the motion. I think people would be well aware of my commitment to the community sector and the amazing work that they do. I am a little bit disappointed in terms of some of the contributions of the Leader of the Opposition, particularly not engaging in the issue in terms of the revenue that is generated through this activity that does cause significant harm. I think it's also really important to, you know, to reflect on the issues around safeguards that are within the clubs, and, you know, I did really want to be very clear on the record and be in the strongest terms that we do really support significant reform to improve safeguards for this these products that need to that do cause significant harm. It's really important.

I also just would like just make a note in terms of one of the contributions that talked about that we needed to ensure that the community contributions being scheme remains transparent. I think one of the things that was really clear that came out of the inquiry report that there is a lack of transparency. We could not even determine really how much money is provided through community contributions, so it is really important and I really welcome the fact that we will do the review of the current of the current scheme. We, there's a real opportunity in terms of looking at what the options are in terms of the future when we recognise the reality that revenues will reduce. And we certainly have a bit of a vision in terms of an independent fee fund, as I noted.

As I noted, we do think that government will need to, will need to provide some support and some funding, but there is actually an opportunity to create a system that is sustainable in the long term. We've put, I've put forward the idea of a feasibility study because there are, you know, real issues that clubs have raised, particularly in terms of their core purpose, that do need to be, need to be looked at. So I'm looking, I'm really looking forward to the fact that the work is getting started, and we'll be actually looking significantly at what we do in terms of future. What we want to see is a future for Canberra where we have a thriving community sector. We have well-resourced charities and sporting clubs, and community clubs are continuing to provide, you know, a really significant contribution to the community.

But we want to see that as functioning free from the shackles of poker machines, which we know cause the community so much damage. We need to actually move away from the language of diversifying community clubs to pivoting away from, to pivoting away from gambling revenues. I think this is really where our future lies. Once again, I want to really thank for the really positive ways in which members across the chamber have engaged with this motion and are supporting the motion. I'm very, I'm really grateful about that, actually.

03:21:01 - 03:21:04

Speaker 138

And thank you very much, everybody.

03:21:04 - 03:22:05

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms Vassarotti. The question is that the motion, as amended, be agreed. All those of that opinion say aye. Contrary, no. I declare that the ayes have it.

Now, before we go to 90-second statements, at question time today, Mr Emerson raised a point of order under standing order 118AA, and I committed to provide a ruling. I've reviewed the video of Mr Emerson's question today asking why the partnership agreement with the Aarres R-Y committee has not been reviewed and why has a new agreement not been signed. The minister responded that there was a dispute as to whether a review was, had taken place or was taking place. That answered the first part, and Mr Pettersson's additional information in matters arising from question time that the government considers the partnership agreement to be ongoing and not time-limited answers the second, so, in my view, the minister has been responsive. And we'll move to 90-second statements, and I'll call the Chief Minister.

03:22:05 - 03:23:13

Speaker 48

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I rise this afternoon to acknowledge the festival of lights, Diwali, which will be celebrated by thousands of Canberrans in the weeks ahead. Diwali is an important part of life for thousands of Canberrans and a wonderful opportunity to celebrate the diversity that makes our city such a welcoming place. As families and communities come together for the festival of lights, we are reminded of the values at the heart of Diwali: hope, kindness and the triumph of light over darkness. Mr Speaker, Canberra is home for people from every corner of the world, and our city is stronger when different cultures, traditions and faiths are shared and celebrated.

Diwali is one of the many occasions that bring people together, strengthen community connections and remind us of the richness of our multicultural city. So, to everyone celebrating across Canberra, I wish you and your families a very happy Diwali and hope that you enjoy this special time with family and friends and that the year ahead, Mr Speaker, brings happiness, good health and every success.

03:23:13 - 03:23:16

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Chief Minister. 90-second statements, Mr Caine.

03:23:16 - 03:24:44

Peter Cain

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Monday around lunchtime, I joined my colleagues from the chamber here, Ms Vassarotti, Ministers Pettersson and Paterson, in a most beautiful setting, on a beautiful day, by the way, for a very somber gathering, the 31st annual remembrance ceremony for those who have lost their lives to illicit drugs.

Very sobering indeed to hear the names read of those over many years who have lost their lives to illicit drugs in the company of affected families and friends. And policy differences aside, I think every member in this place ought to show compassion and seek to make sure those who have been affected by such a loss continue to have support so that they can deal with that loss and move forward with their lives and contribute to how such things can be minimized. So I want to thank the various advocacy groups who are on the remembrance working committee from CAHMA, from Directions Health Services, ATODA, Social Justice Leader at Uniting New South Wales, and especially to Bill Bush and Marion McConnell, formerly for the Families and Friends for Drug Law Reform. Thank you, Mr Speaker.

03:24:44 - 03:25:10

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr Caine. 90-second statements? No. I then, therefore, call the minister. Hold on, I'm not calling the minister.

Well, just hold on a second. I call the Clerk.

03:25:10 - 03:25:28

Speaker 142

Pursuant to standing order 213A and the resolution of the Assembly of 24 September 2026 relating to the Tuggeranong ice sports facility, I table a revised copy of document SEMTD-A-059-CAB-20/421, Outcome of EOI and Next Steps.

03:25:28 - 03:25:31

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Clerk. And now I call the minister.

03:25:31 - 03:25:34

Speaker 136

Thank you, Mr Speaker, I move that the Assembly do now adjourn.

03:25:34 - 03:25:38

Jeremy Hanson

The question is that the Assembly do adjourn, and I call Ms Clay.

03:25:38 - 03:30:45

Jo Clay

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I rise today to pay tribute to Jane Foulds, a much-loved member of our Canberra community whose tragic death has touched so many people across the ACT and surrounding districts, and I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge that her family and friends are here with us in the chamber today. Jane's passing was heartbreaking, not only because of the circumstances in which it occurred, but because it reflected so completely the kind of person that she was. Reports indicate Jane lost her life while attempting to help an injured kangaroo on the Monaro Highway,

in what may have many have described as a final act of compassion and selflessness. At times like this, we're reminded that someone's legacy is not measured by titles or achievements, but by the lives that they touch. By that measure, Jane's legacy is extraordinary. Jane was, above all, a devoted family member. She cherished her family, and she was a loving daughter to her late mother Ruth, her father Ken,

a treasured sister to Anne, a proud aunt and aunt-in-law to Jacqueline and Daniel, Nicholas and Amon and Matthew, and an adoring great-aunt to Violet Ruth. Family meant everything to Jane, and the love, laughter, and countless memories they shared together are a comfort to those mourning her loss today.

Those who knew Jane speak of her warmth, generosity, humor, and unwavering kindness. Friends have described her as someone who lifted others up, welcomed newcomers, and brought joy into every room she entered. She's remembered as everyone's champion, a person whose instinct was always to encourage, support, and care for those around her. Her bright smile and positive outlook and caring spirit made people feel welcome and valued and loved.

Her passion for life shone through her extraordinary involvement in calisthenics. She devoted more than 50 years to that sport, becoming a cherished figure in the ACT calisthenics community. Just a week before her passing, she celebrated the remarkable milestone of five decades in the sport, an achievement of which she was immensely proud. Throughout those years, Jane was a valued member of Joyelle, Karilee and Deanne Calisthenics clubs.

She became a life member of Karilee Calisthenics, and she proudly represented the ACT on many occasions. Beyond performing, she gave generously of her time as an adjudicator's writer, club treasurer, fundraiser and team manager. Her contribution helped shape generations of participants and strengthened the calisthenics community that she loved so dearly. Jane's love of performance naturally extended to the stage. She was deeply involved in community theatre, performing with the Queanbeyan Players in productions including Guys and Dolls, South Pacific and The Sound of Music.

She also appeared in Cats with the Canberra Philharmonic Society, and she performed with Supa Productions in The Witches of Eastwick, Spamalot and Eurobeat. Being on stage brought Jane enormous joy, and she embraced every opportunity to entertain, connect with audiences and share her vibrant spirit with others. Jane was also one of the original Raiderettes, proudly performing as a Canberra Raiders cheerleader in the club's early years. A lifelong supporter of the St. George Dragons, who she followed long before the Raiders existed,

she nonetheless became a committed Raiders member and supporter, considering them to be her second team. She also played women's cricket in Canberra, and she was often seen enjoying Sydney Thunder matches. Whether supporting a team from the sidelines or taking part herself, sport was another way that Jane built friendships and community. Jane will also be remembered for her love of animals.

She was a passionate advocate for animal welfare, who dedicated countless hours to fostering, rescuing and caring for animals in need. Through that work, she gave many animals a second chance, and she demonstrated a compassion that extended far beyond words. Helping animals was not some simply something that Jane did; it was part of who Jane was.

She was a former public servant, a contributor to the cultural life of our region and a deeply engaged member of the wider Canberra community. Her life reminds us that communities are built not by institutions, but by individual people who quietly and consistently give of themselves to others. For many Canberrans, Jane represented the very best of our community: generosity without expectation,

kindness without condition, a willingness to step forward when help was needed. In reflecting on her life, there is a powerful lesson about compassion and civic spirit. Her final act was so consistent with the way that she lived.

The extraordinary outpouring of love and support following her passing is a true reflection of the extraordinary person that she was. To Jane's family, friends and colleagues, teammates and the many communities that she was a part of, we extend our deepest condolences. We acknowledge the profound loss you are experiencing.

We thank you for sharing Jane with our community for so many years, and we trust that her memory will continue to inspire kindness and generosity and care for others.

03:30:45 - 03:30:49

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms Clay. The question is that the Assembly do now adjourn. I call Mr Parton.

03:30:49 - 03:34:24

Mark Parton

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I rise, as Shadow Minister for Men and Men's Health, to recognise today being a Better Fella day and to congratulate young Braedon Fowler,

the exemplary young leader and student behind the Better Fella initiative that was launched today at St Edmund's College here in Canberra. I want to acknowledge the initiative and the leadership that it represents. It is important that we encourage young people to take an active role in shaping the conversations that matter to them and their communities.

Men's health and wellbeing is an issue that deserves greater attention. Too often boys and young men can feel pressure to deal with their problems alone, to hide their struggles or to believe that asking for help is a sign of weakness. We know that changing those attitudes requires more than simply telling men to speak up. It requires creating environments where they feel safe to do so, where looking out for a mate is encouraged and where seeking support is seen as a strength rather than a weakness. And that's why initiatives that are led by young people themselves are so important.

Young men can have a powerful influence on their peers and conversations that begin in a school community can help shape attitudes well beyond the school gates. As the shadow minister for men and men's health, I am particularly interested in supporting efforts that encourage those conversations, that strengthen connections between young men and their communities and help ensure that people know where to turn when they need support. So, I also want to acknowledge St Edmund's College for providing an environment in which students can take the lead on issues rather issues that matter to them. We often talk about the importance of investing in the health and wellbeing of the next generation. We should also recognise and support young people who already are taking action to improve the lives around them.

Braeden actually appeared on ABC Radio this morning and was exceptionally good, moved so many people when he spoke to Ross Solly this morning. But I do want to quote from Braeden's address at St Edmund's College today. These are his words. These are his words. "It is hard to be a boy looking at his mother and realising that the world has not always treated her with the respect she deserves.

It's hard to be a father looking at his daughter and knowing that no matter how much he loves her, he can't always be there to protect her. It's hard to be a brother looking at his sister and wondering whether the world she grows up in will be the one where she is free to live without fear. It's hard to be a young woman learning to navigate the world where her safety is not always something that she can take for granted. It's hard to be a good man knowing that the world we want for the women we love is not yet the world that every woman experiences. That is" How good's that?

How good is that? That is Braeden Fowler, if you don't mind. These are very powerful words, very powerful words from a young man wise beyond his years, and I would call on all members to reflect on them in the context of the responsibility that we as elected members have. I would note that on the radio this morning, I think one of the final questions that Ross asked Braeden is what he wanted to do with his life, and he said that's the hardest question that he got today cause he doesn't know. But I reckon whatever it is, it's going to make a splash.

It's going to make a splash. He's going to do great things. Congratulations, and to Braeden, I look forward to learning more about the initiatives, its ambitions, and how we can work together to support healthier, more connected young men across Canberra. Thank you, Mr Speaker.

03:34:24 - 03:34:28

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr Partington. Question is the Assembly do now adjourn. I call Mr Werner-Gibbings.

03:34:28 - 03:36:36

Taimus Werner-Gibbings

Thank you, Mr Speaker. A couple of months ago, actually in early August, Lucia from Kambah is 16, she might be 17 now, is going to Lake Tuggeranong next year, so shout out to that. And is She did a wonderful week's work experience and left me with this speech for that I read for her to the Assembly. "The issue I raise is the lack of entertainment for youth in the ACT. Although Canberra is Australia's capital, many teenagers and young adults, including myself, feel there are limited activities available for them outside of school, sport or shopping centres.

Compared to larger cities such as Sydney or Melbourne, the ACT still has room for improvement. As a result, many young people often say they become bored and have difficulty finding affordable and enjoyable ways to spend their free time.

This can cause increased screen time and social isolation. For young people who are not interested in sport, the options can be even more limited. Just about two years ago, the best place to go to during summer shut down, Big Splash was one of the few places to go for fun. I have so many happy memories from that place, and when I heard that it wasn't reopening like the owners suggested, I was disappointed, and I know a lot of others were too. The ACT has made efforts to support young people through festivals, parks and recreational spaces.

While these are valuable, Canberra already has many of them. Every year, large amounts of funding is invested in upgrading existing buildings and maintaining infrastructure, such as footpaths. While this work is important and essential services should always come first, some investment could also be directed towards new entertainment venues for young people. Creating attractions, such as a year-round water park, or delivering the ice sports facility announced in 2020, would help make Canberra a more exciting place for youth. Young people are an important part of the community.

By investing in more entertainment and recreational opportunities, the ACT can create a city where youth feel engaged, connected and valued. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

03:36:36 - 03:36:41

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr. Werner-Gibbings. The question is the Assembly do now adjourn. I call Mr Cocks.

03:36:41 - 03:41:36

Peter Cain

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I rise today on behalf of Ms Stacey Xu, a year 10 student at Canberra Girls Grammar School, who joined my office for work experience from 12th to 16th of October, not very long ago. These are her words. "I ask this Assembly to consider an issue that is increasingly affected affecting Australians in their everyday lives. This issue is the spread of fake news and misinformation, particularly through social media and the impact this has on young people.

As a young Australian, I have grown up in a world where information is only a few taps away. Platforms such as TikTok, Instagram and YouTube allow us to stay connected, learn about current events and engage with issues happening across the world. Social media has created valuable opportunities for young people to learn and participate in our community. However, alongside these benefits, it is important to remember not every everything we see online is true. Fake news and misinformation can take many forms.

They may include misleading headlines, edited videos, fake false claims presented as facts or images generated by artificial intelligence. Sometimes this content is deliberately created to manipulate people. At other times, it spreads because people share information without checking whether it is accurate. Regardless of the intention, the consequences can still be significant. Young people are particularly exposed to this issue because social media plays such a central role in how we communicate and understand the world.

Many of us encounter the news through short videos, posts and content recommended by algorithms, rather than through traditional news services. These platforms prioritize content that attracts attention and encourages engagement. This can allow sensational or emotionally charged claims to spread quickly, even when the information is misleading or untrue. Mr Speaker, consider how easily a misleading video or an unverified claim can circulate through a school community. Online, a rumour can be shared between friends, reposted across multiple accounts, and accepted as facts within minutes.

Even after the information is corrected, the damage to someone's reputation or relationships may already have been done. This demonstrates that misinformation is not simply an online problem. It can affect people's real lives, their friendships, their well-being and their trust in others.

The consequences extend beyond young people as well. Misinformation about health can lead Australians to make decisions based on false claims rather than reliable medical advice. Misleading political content can distort public debate and influence how people understand government policies and public issues. False information during emergencies can also create confusion when Australians need accurate instructions to keep themselves and their families safe. Over time the constant exposure to conflicting claims can make it difficult for people to know who to trust.

When Australians lose confidence in reliable information it becomes harder for communities to have informed discussions and make decisions based on evidence. However I do not believe the answer is to simply tell young people to stop using social media. These platforms are an important part of modern life and they can be powerful tools for education and connection. Instead we must equip young Australians with the knowledge and skills to use them properly and responsibly. Firstly media literacy education should be strengthened in our schools.

Students should be should learn how to identify reliable sources, recognise manipulated images and videos, distinguish fact from opinion, and verify claims at school. These skills are just as important as the ability to read and write in today's digital world. Secondly, social media companies should be encouraged to take greater responsibility for the content distributed on their platforms. This includes improving the reporting of misleading information, providing greater transparency about how content is recommended, and taking appropriate action against harmful misinformation. Finally governments, schools, families and community organisations must work together to promote a culture of critical thinking.

Young people should feel empowered to question what they see online, seek out different reliable sources and admit when information they have shared turns out to be incorrect. Developing these habits is important for learning to trust information for the right reasons. And Mr Speaker, I seek leave for another minute and a half or two.

03:41:36 - 03:41:40

Jeremy Hanson

Is leave granted? Leave is granted.

03:41:40 - 03:42:57

Peter Cain

Thank you. Mr Speaker as a year 10 student, I believe young Australians deserve more than unrestricted access to information. We deserve the skills to understand it, question it and use it responsibly. The digital world will continue to evolve and misinformation will remain a challenge, but we should not underestimate the ability of young people to respond to that challenge when they are given the right education, support and tools. Ultimately addressing misinformation is not just about ensuring Australians have access to accurate information.

It is also about protecting public trust and supporting informed decision-making. By investing in media literacy, encouraging responsible technology platforms and empowering young people to think critically, we can build a community that is better equipped to recognise misinformation rather than unknowingly spread it. Mr Speaker, the question is not whether young Australians will encounter misinformation online, it is whether we will give them the tools to recognise it before it causes harm. Thank you. These were the words of Stacey Sue, a year 10 student from Canberra Girls Grammar who joined my office just a few weeks ago for work experience.

Thank you, Mr Speaker.

03:42:57 - 03:43:01

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Mr Caine. The question is the Assembly do now adjourn. Ms Castley.

03:43:01 - 03:44:27

Fiona Carrick

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I am going to read a speech by a young person in my electorate as part of the excellent Raise Our Voice in Parliament campaign. Hi, my name is Hunter and I'm 12 years old. I am from the Bean electorate and today I'm trying to tackle the transport industry.

As a 12-year-old, I'm really passionate about the transport industry, specifically in how it relates to global warming and how we can improve this in the future. I take the bus to school as much as possible. By doing this, I hope to help encourage catching public transport. By taking public transport, you'll be helping the environment. So, if you're passionate about the turtles and pandas, you should really start catching public transport.

Public transport benefits the environment by significantly lowering your personal carbon footprint, decreasing air pollution, and reducing traffic congestion, plus it's quicker. I want the government to take action by putting in more public transport into Canberra, also by adding more bus lanes throughout the city. I would also strongly encourage lowering prices and, if anything, making public transport free. Thank you for listening to my speech. If my speech helps, I imagine Canberra with a public transport-friendly city.

Thank you, Hunter. I agree we need more public transport and bus lanes.

03:44:27 - 03:44:35

Jeremy Hanson

Thank you, Ms Castley. The question is the Assembly do now adjourn. All those of that opinion say aye. The contrary no. The Assembly therefore stands adjourned until tomorrow at 10:00 a.m.