Standing Committee on Public Accounts and Administration: Standing Committee on Public Accounts and Administration - Inquiry into the secure local jobs Code (2 November 2026, 8:31 am)

1 November 2026

00:03 - 01:01
Member of the Legislative Assembly (ACT) | Yerrabi
Member | Legislative Assembly for the Australian Capital Territory
James Milligan
Are we broadcasting?  Excellent, thank you.  Well, good morning and welcome to the public hearings of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts and Administration for its inquiry into the Secure Local Jobs Code.  The committee will today hear from representatives from a range of unions, community organisations and industry representatives.  The committee will also hear from the Minister for Finance. 

Now, the committee wishes to acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land which we are meeting on, the Ngunnawal people.  We wish to acknowledge and respect their continuing culture and the contribution they make to the life of this city and this region.  We would also like to acknowledge and welcome other Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who may be attending today's event.  We'll just run through some housekeeping matters for today.  All mobile phones and laptops would be switched off or switched to silent mode, which I will do also. 
01:01 - 01:03
Speaker 1
Mine was on for once. 
01:03 - 03:07
Member of the Legislative Assembly (ACT) | Yerrabi
Member | Legislative Assembly for the Australian Capital Territory
James Milligan
And witnesses are to speak one at a time and will need to speak directly into the microphone or your computer for Hansard to be able to hear and transcribe them accurately.  Now, this hearing is a legal proceeding of the Assembly and has the same standing and proceedings of the Assembly itself.  Therefore, today's evidence attracts parliamentary privilege.  The giving of false or misleading evidence is a serious matter and may be regarded as contempt of the Assembly.  Now, the hearing is being recorded and transcribed by Hansard, and will be published. 

The proceeding is also being broadcast and webstreamed live.  Now, when taking a question on notice, it will be useful if witnesses use the words "I will take that question on notice".  This will help the committee and witnesses to confirm questions taken on notice from the transcript.  Now, we welcome Stacey Scharkie—is that correct, Scharkie?—from the Australian Services Union, New South Wales and ACT Services Branch via video link.  Now, please note, as a witness, you are protected by parliamentary privilege and bound by its obligations. 

You must tell the truth; giving false or misleading evidence will be treated as a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly.  As we've only got 20 20 minutes, is that correct, for this session, we might just go straight into questions if that's all right with you, Stacey.  And what I'll do is I'll allow each member to have five minutes each and they can ask a series of questions in whichever field they would like to ask questions in.  So, I might just start off if I can.  My question is what demonstrated cases of workplace harm in code-certified ACT community service providers were detected or prevented specifically by the code rather than by fair work or existing funding audits? 
03:07 - 03:45
Stacey Sharkey
Assistant Secretary, Australian Services Union NSW and ACT (Services) Branch
Yeah, sure, thank you so much for having me here with you today.  Look, I don't have any exact examples with me today to solidify that question.  However, I will just give the example that it is a lever and a tool within a tool kit, and given that the community services sector is almost wholly reliant on government funding, the code gives additional accountability and an additional lever for us to utilise to make sure that our members and the workers across the community sector, their workplace rights are being upheld. 
03:45 - 03:58
Member of the Legislative Assembly (ACT) | Yerrabi
Member | Legislative Assembly for the Australian Capital Territory
James Milligan
In your submission, you acknowledge that the number of certificates issued and audits undertaken doesn't establish whether employment has actually become more secure. 
03:58 - 04:01
Speaker 5
Can you sort of elaborate on that? 
04:01 - 04:39
Stacey Sharkey
Assistant Secretary, Australian Services Union NSW and ACT (Services) Branch
Yeah, sure.  Look, I think what I will say is that a secure job is also secure within its employment and also within its safety standards within the workplace.  So, the code gives us an additional consultation obligations of the organisations themselves.  We also do recognise that there's been submissions put in around the administrative burden or around funding cycles, and we can confirm that we do agree with the sector on that.  And we just don't agree that there should be less accountability just because it's a not-for-profit sector. 

04:39 - 04:50

James Milligan

Are you able to point the committee to any measurable improvements in employment security that can be directly attributed to the code since its introduction?

04:50 - 05:25

Stacey Sharkey

Yes, like I said, we can utilise the code as a an additional lever when we're organising around workplace health and safety, especially within the community sector psychosocial safety. Our members work in domestic violence services, they work with people living with disability, they work with really vulnerable community in Canberra, and this allows us to have additional internal dispute mechanisms to utilise to alleviate any of those concerns within the workplace rather than having to escalate externally outside of the workplace.

05:25 - 05:27

James Milligan

Alright, thank you. Ms Carrick.

05:27 - 06:02

Fiona Carrick

I'll have a stab on that community line. When we talk about secure jobs, often what we hear from our community sector is that the fact that we have a very late budget, it creates uncertainty about funding. And due to that uncertainty, community organisations lose staff to go and get something that's a bit more secure. So, when we talk about secure jobs, could the ACT government actually help with creating a bit more certainty around the jobs in the community sector in Canberra?

06:02 - 06:53

Stacey Sharkey

Yeah, absolutely, but retention and recruitment is an issue within the community services in Canberra. Our members experience, as we've said, psychosocial risks at work. It's a really hard job, and there is a lot of burnout. And there's no surge workforce just waiting to come into rape crisis centres or domestic violence crisis centres. Some of the mechanisms that could be utilised by government is longer-term funding cycles, which I know others in the sector have alluded to in their submissions as well.

And New South Wales government has just implemented it in more recent tender processes, which we're seeing having a more secure workforce because there is more secure funding. So, that's one mechanism that we could recommend.

06:53 - 07:34

Fiona Carrick

And another thing with the community sector, they say when it comes to putting in for contracts, that requirements, not only the secure local jobs code, but I don't know, I think that's potentially a range of things, that it makes it easier for the bigger end of town and the national community organisations to put in a bid. They can put in a more polished professional bid than our local small community organisations, and some of our like the small ones feel like they're missing out to the more polished submissions to a procurement.

07:34 - 07:37

Speaker 7

Do you have a view on that?

07:37 - 08:22

Stacey Sharkey

Yeah, so I think we do. I had it in my opening statement, which I'm happy to send through after this as well, that the administrative costs or the time that it takes to, you know, uphold the Secure Local Jobs Code and also throughout tender processes, should be funded from government for government funded services. We absolutely agree with the sector that, you know, there should be longer term and more stable funding, which should include things like that you've just spoken about and the administrative burden around and costs around the Secure Local Jobs Code. What we disagree with the sector on is less accountability through either removing community services from the Secure Local Jobs Code or not strengthening the code through this process.

08:22 - 08:40

Speaker 42

So, in the submissions, they will say from the community sector that they are already regulated. How are they already Why is it they that they think they're already regulated, but you would think that they still need the Secure Job? Where is the disconnect there?

08:40 - 09:26

Stacey Sharkey

Look, I can't specify what they're stipulating in their submissions, but what I can say is obviously we do have Fair Work mechanisms and Safe Work and work health and safety requirements. The difference, I guess, with the Secure Local Jobs Code is that it is about accountability to public funding and to government funding, and the community services sector in the ACT is wholly reliant on government funding and, I think, through CSD, it's 250 million dollars a year or something along those lines. And so, it's not a small amount of money. And so, the Secure Local Jobs Code's benefit is that there's additional mechanisms and requirements for government funding. But, yeah, I can't really speak to the specifics of those submissions.

09:26 - 09:29

Speaker 6

I do have one more question, but in the order of time, I'll- No worries.

09:29 - 09:30

Good on you.

09:30 - 09:31

-pass to the other.

09:31 - 10:02

Jo Clay

Stacey, thanks for coming in. The Greens engaged in budget negotiations with the government this year, and we got a significant uplift in community sector funding, but I would say it's a common theme across all the submissions for community sector that the best way to have a stable workforce and good conditions for workers is increased funding. So, do you think that's probably one of the most important things government could do to improve conditions for workers in the community sector?

10:02 - 10:42

Stacey Sharkey

Yes, absolutely. And we've put that in our submission, and also would agree with YWCA and ACTCOSS, and other submissions from leaders across the sector as well. And absolutely funding within the community sector needs to be uplifted and to be adequate. And potentially through this process, there could be mechanisms within the Secure Local Jobs Code to It's a bit of background noise. To, you know, rectify that situation, as well as those longer term funding cycles that I spoke through earlier, which we have seen the New South Wales government recently implement and it is making a difference within the sector in the retention and recruitment of staff.

10:42 - 11:19

Jo Clay

That's right. And indexation has always been a point of contention where if the funding is inadequate or adequate, the indexation the community sector has often said the indexation is massively inadequate. It doesn't keep pace with wage price inflation, which is the primary cost of the sector. And also noting that everybody has submitted that they actually need government funding in order to respond to the secure local jobs administration. Do you think an index that is pinned to wage prices, and also accounts for the administration of getting government funding would help?

11:19 - 11:45

Stacey Sharkey

Yes, absolutely.

Yes, absolutely, and, look, the ACT Government have an indexation formula for the community sector, which is fantastic, but it hasn't been keeping up with the fair work increases and the superannuation increases, so adequate uplift in the indexation, absolutely, which could include indexation for the cost of the Secure Local Jobs Code and other mechanisms that the sector has to uphold.

11:45 - 12:40

Jo Clay

Yeah. Well, I think the indexation is less than what the horse racing industry gets on their funding, so that certainly doesn't look like it's the right amount to me. We have had a number of community sector submissions, and also other smaller organisations say that they should be exempt from the Secure Local Jobs Code. A lot of the same submitters have also said, "If we can't be exempt, can we please have a simpler pathway that is more appropriate?" I would imagine that is probably something that would apply to the smaller community sector organisations rather than the larger ones, like a really large organisation might need to comply with the full thing.

Do you have any views on whether there might be a simpler administrative pathway or different types of ways that you can get a Secure Local Jobs Code certificate or comply with the Code if you are an organisation of four versus if you are an organisation of 500?

12:40 - 13:42

Stacey Sharkey

Yeah, absolutely. And look that is there's such a discrepancy within the community sector for the smaller orgs and the larger orgs around the funding that they receive. We agree and it was in within our submission that there should be less of an admin burden for smaller, local community services. We agree with the sector that a simpler pathway is it could be a way through this. What we don't agree with, and we work with the sector very well.

We come from the sector. But in this instance, we don't agree with community services being removed from the Local Jobs Code, but we can agree with a simpler pathway and also the admin costs being covered through some form of indexation. Like I've mentioned earlier, the community services sector is wholly reliant on government funding, and it gets a lot of public money as it should. And so, it should also then be, you know, held to the same standards as other sectors that also get public money.

13:42 - 13:50

Speaker 18

And do you have any ideas of what a simpler the features of a simpler pathway might be for smaller players?

13:50 - 13:54

Speaker 11

I don't have anything here with me today, but I am happy to take the question on notice.

13:54 - 14:02

Speaker 10

I won't If you think of thoughts later and have time, Stacy, send them in, but if you don't, please you don't need to.

14:02 - 14:04

Speaker 9

Okay. Thank you.

14:04 - 14:06

Speaker 30

Thank you, Chair.

14:06 - 14:08

James Milligan

Yes, Ms Berry.

14:08 - 14:17

Speaker 16

Thanks, Stacy. Could you just briefly describe the services that you um represent here in the ACT, like the workforces?

14:17 - 15:06

Stacey Sharkey

Yeah, absolutely. Look, our members do such important and vital work across the community services, and we know that's quite a blanket umbrella term. And so, the services that our members work within is alcohol and other drugs, mental health support services, rape crisis centres, domestic violence services, child protection services, financial counselling. It's such a broad sector. It's such important work.

And that's also another reason which we've stipulated in our submission that there should absolutely be accountability for the money that goes to these services. It's, you know, secure local healthy jobs within these services support everyone in Canberra's community: our members doing the work, and also those vulnerable Canberra community members that utilise the services themselves.

15:06 - 15:09

Speaker 21

And you cover disability support workers as well?

15:09 - 15:23

Stacey Sharkey

We do indeed. Due to the fact that it's a lot of NDIS funding, not that many are secure are on the Secure Local Jobs Code, but yes, we absolutely do support disability support workers as well.

15:23 - 15:37

Yvette Berry

And often there's a perception, I guess, in the community that organisations not-for-profits organisations aren't, you know, underpaying people or stealing wages, but those sorts of circumstances do occur within those jobs.

15:37 - 15:40

Speaker 14

Is that your experience?

15:40 - 15:49

Stacey Sharkey

Yes, it can. It's certainly not exempt from wage theft, just like any other sector.

15:49 - 16:14

Yvette Berry

And do you think that should have wages and conditions, if an employer has a history of underpaying, or there are records that show that an organisation might be underpaying their workforce, or doing something that is in breach of the Fair Work Act, that should be held in high regard with regards to the secure local jobs code for community services as well?

16:14 - 16:24

Stacey Sharkey

Yes, absolutely. And that was in our submission as well. There should be consequences for non-compliance. And absolutely, that should extend to wage theft.

16:24 - 16:28

Speaker 24

And I guess work health and safety issues as well? Yeah.

16:28 - 16:57

Stacey Sharkey

And like I mentioned earlier, Yes. having the Secure Local Jobs Code registrar as an additional tool and as an additional lever has been useful to resolve work health and safety disputes within the workplace, which is always the best way to go about that, especially within the community services sector, where reputation is so important for community members to feel, you know, comfortable accessing the services. And so, yes, absolutely.

16:57 - 16:59

Speaker 53

Thanks, Stacey.

16:59 - 17:00

Thank you.

17:00 - 17:02

Speaker 19

Ms Castley?

17:02 - 17:18

Speaker 37

I was just going to ask, do you think that the registrar has enough powers to do the job, or have you found in your sector that it would be the registrar should have more powers?

17:18 - 17:32

Stacey Sharkey

Yeah, we did mention this in our submission as well. It definitely should be looked at through this process. And we've recommended that there's more robust powers for the registrar on the other side of this.

17:32 - 17:38

Speaker 27

And have you had any issues with that aspect of the registrar?

17:38 - 17:40

Speaker 55

No, we haven't.

17:40 - 17:44

Speaker 34

Okay. Thank you.

17:44 - 17:46

Speaker 12

Anybody? I can ask another one. But anybody else is welcome.

17:46 - 17:49

Speaker 25

You go. Yeah.

17:49 - 17:51

Speaker 44

I reckon I'm good.

17:51 - 17:58

Speaker 31

You're done? Yeah. I don't know. The only thing I'd ask is, Stacey, is there anything we haven't covered that you wanted to tell us?

17:58 - 18:01

Speaker 17

Good question.

18:01 - 18:11

Stacey Sharkey

I think the questions have covered most of what I was going to say in my opening statement. I'm also happy to send it through, though, just for everyone to have after this meeting.

18:11 - 18:13

Speaker 15

Thank you. Thanks. James?

18:13 - 18:17

Speaker 41

I'm happy to do you want Stacey to table her opening statement?

18:17 - 18:21

Speaker 22

Yeah, that would be that would be useful for the committee. That would be great, thank you.

18:21 - 18:21

Wonderful.

18:21 - 18:25

Speaker 26

Yeah. Excellent. Any other questions? Ms Castley?

18:25 - 18:44

Fiona Carrick

Do you think, Stacey, that there is confusion just about what the objective of the code is, whether it be local jobs or secure jobs? I find that people don't really, they think it's local jobs, but it's not really. Is there confusion about the objective of it?

18:44 - 19:21

Stacey Sharkey

I guess I would say that there could be more education done, especially with workers around what the secure local jobs code entails. But also, a secure and local job can mean the same thing, but are two separate things. It can Having secure jobs within the community services sector is so important, as we've discussed, around keeping those respected and maintained relationships within the services, also having local Canberra workers within those workplaces. I see it as probably two different things, but within the same meaning of what the code should represent.

19:21 - 19:47

James Milligan

Excellent. Well, thank you, Ms Sharkey, for attending today's hearing. On behalf of the committee, thank you. I have noticed that you haven't taken a question on notice, so if you're able to provide your answers to the committee secretary within five business days from receiving the uncorrected proof, that would be useful.

And if you're able to table your opening statement, that will be most beneficial as well.

19:47 - 19:49

Speaker 54

Great, thank you so much.

19:49 - 22:20

Speaker 63

No worries, thank you. from the United Workers Union. We'll just run through a couple of things before we get started. Please note that as a witness, you are protected by parliamentary privilege and bound by its obligations, you must tell the truth, giving false or misleading evidence will be treated as a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. We've only got 20 minutes, so if you do have an opening statement, it would be great if you're able to table it.

22:20 - 22:22

Speaker 20

Instead, do you have an opening statement?

22:22 - 22:23

No, we don't.

22:23 - 22:57

James Milligan

No? Okay, well, we don't need to worry about that. We'll just go straight into questions. We'll have 5 minutes each and each member will ask questions, you know, in whichever field that they would like in relation to your submission. I'll start. Are you able to identify, post-2019, cases in which the code independently detected and remedied worker exploitation that existing workplace regulations or a strengthened government contract could not address it?

22:57 - 23:03

Speaker 32

I might have to take that one on notice and we'll give that to you as soon as possible.

23:03 - 23:23

James Milligan

Okay. In your submission, claims that tendering has remained as robust as it was before the code commenced and that certification requirements have not been a barrier to participation. What evidence do you have to make those claims?

23:23 - 23:27

Erryn Cresshull

Well, it's just that the contract system continues to churn.

23:27 - 23:37

Speaker 38

It hasn't changed at all since the code came in. Certificates get issued, and contracts get issued. It's, no real difference there.

23:37 - 23:52

James Milligan

Have you examined how many businesses or, if any businesses have stopped tendering for government work or elected not to seek certificate, uh, certification because of the code?

23:52 - 23:54

Speaker 33

No.

23:54 - 24:00

James Milligan

And have you concluded it hasn't been a barrier to participation with the code?

24:00 - 24:09

Speaker 39

We have concluded it hasn't been a barrier because contracts still continue to get issued for ACT Government work in our areas.

24:09 - 24:14

James Milligan

Okay. Well, I'll come back shortly. Miss Carrick?

24:14 - 24:41

Fiona Carrick

So, can you tell me whether in your view that the secure local jobs code is achieving its intended objectives? And what are your views about the objectives and people are confused about local workers as opposed to secure jobs? Because I noticed your first recommendation mentions the impact on local workers.

24:41 - 26:35

Erryn Cresshull

We think the job the code is doing a good job. Before the code came in, we saw many cases of exploitation within the industries we represent, particularly with the Secure Local Jobs Code with cleaning and security. They are service-heavy jobs. The contract churn is high, and the first thing that gets cut is wages and conditions. The people that work in our industries tend to be immigrant workers with possibly less understanding of what their rights are, which makes them open for exploitation by unscrupulous contractors.

And unfortunately, there are many of them. Prior to the code coming in, we saw really terrible exploitation of our members. And we I think Jim and Mojo can absolutely attest to that working for a company, Philips Cleaning, that was one of the names of the company that was contracted in ACT schools. Since the code has come in, we haven't had to have those outrageous battles with those companies who clearly sought to deliberately undercut our members' rights. So, from our perspective, it is achieving its objectives.

It is working. The second point, and I'll If you'd like to hear from our members, they would very be very happy to talk to you about the industries they work in and their experiences. And noting we've only got 20 minutes, so we want to get the main points out. Yeah. With the local component, I do understand that there's there has been some confusion that's been documented about what secure and what local means for us.

26:35 - 26:51

Speaker 57

Workers in Canberra, we need to make sure that they're treated properly and that they have secure employment, that is good employment, and they're not being exploited. So for us it's, it is about our members in Canberra and the work that they do.

26:51 - 27:09

Fiona Carrick

Has there Have you heard any issues with bigger firms, national firms, winning the contracts as opposed to smaller local firms because they just have the resources to put in better bids?

27:09 - 27:23

Erryn Cresshull

Not that I Not that we know of. I suppose there's a thing where some bigger firms have better capacity with the HR or better IR procedures in place already.

27:23 - 27:33

Speaker 58

So, it may be easier for those firms to apply for contracts, but that certainly doesn't cut out any other firm.

27:33 - 27:41

Speaker 60

And do you think the registrar's powers and responsibilities are sufficiently understood in your sector?

27:41 - 27:43

Speaker 46

Probably.

27:43 - 27:46

Speaker 52

Yeah, okay, that's good.

27:46 - 27:55

Speaker 56

Moe Joe, Mehul and Jim, I would love to hear from each of you which industry you work in. Moe Joe, can you tell me are you, can you tell me what industry you work in?

27:57 - 28:11

Speaker 59

I used to work with a Philip Cleaning Service. On that time, like during the school holiday, we don't have any job, and we couldn't get any money to pay rents and all.

28:11 - 28:14

Speaker 50

Oof. That's tough. Mehul?

28:14 - 28:19

Speaker 51

Yeah, I'm working as a security officer.

28:20 - 28:21

Now Canberra Centre.

28:21 - 28:23

Speaker 49

And Jim?

28:23 - 29:03

Jim Maneesirawong

I once worked with actually with Moe Joe in Phillip Cleaning before, and yeah, they have a lot of, you could see that we were they doing a take took advantage on a worker like us, especially from a migrant background. And we've been threatening by you doing what I've asked, or you just leave and no work. And so, many of us who have a language barrier have not been able to ask, or raise our voice, or our concerns because too scared to lose our job, and we think that job is hard for us to find as language barrier, yeah.

29:03 - 29:34

Jo Clay

Yeah. No, fair, and this was the example one of the examples there were three examples in your submission. This was one of them, the cleaning company. Yeah. And do you think there's been, and it's okay if you don't know the answer to this, there have Since the secure local jobs code came in, there have also been improvements to the Fair Work legislation.

Do you think that some of those improvements to the legislation have also helped with rights? I don't know if that's one for you, Erryn.

29:34 - 30:32

Erryn Cresshull

It's a really tricky question because Sorry. Because the industries our members work in are so exploitative. It's, and we constantly pick up problems. And if an employer's a bad employer, they will find ways to ignore anything. The thing about the secure local jobs code is that it is here in Canberra, and we do expect that our taxpayers' money is not given to dodgy operators.

The Fair Work Act sits there, but every, we recover millions of dollars for our members across Australia every year because of shonky employers. But we don't want to see us trying to recover that money out of workers in Canberra who have taxpayers' money through government contracts. So possibly yes and no, but I think in our industry, it's more no.

30:32 - 31:24

Jo Clay

Yeah. So, there's a huge benefit in having that direct, accessible ACT Secure Local Jobs Code. Yeah. No, thank you. That's covered it well.

I also wanted to ask we have had a number of submissions from community and non-profit organisations, and also from small businesses who say, look, for an organisation for a company an organisation of two, or three, or four people, it's really hard to apply for the secure local jobs certificate, and we should have a simpler administrative pathway than for an organisation of a 100 or a 1,000 people. Do you think keeping the secure local jobs code, but having a simpler administrative pathway for organisations of a certain size, or in a certain sector, do you think if that's done well, that's a good idea?

31:24 - 31:34

Speaker 39

It would really depend what it looked like.

We wouldn't want to see any corners cut, because some of the smallest operators are some of the worst employers.

31:34 - 31:47

Speaker 61

Yep. Yeah. And this might be hard to think in the abstract, but are there any features that are really important in that administration pathway to make like that protections? What would the protections make to be?

31:47 - 31:49

Speaker 47

We'd really have to consider that, I think.

31:49 - 32:06

Jo Clay

So, perhaps it's probably more a process question. If government were looking at that, do you think if government developed that, would they need to do public consultation, consult with the unions, and consult with the sectors affected? Would that be the right way to make sure it is well-designed?

32:06 - 32:14

Speaker 39

Well, absolutely. We'd want our members' voices front and center, because they're the ones that are the workers, and the ones that would suffer should things go awry.

32:14 - 32:35

Jo Clay

Yeah, excellent. I also I was pretty struck, it's an excellent submission, this is a really good submission, and the $300,000 wage theft issue was quite key. That took quite a long time. That was successful, wasn't it, but the impact of that was still quite negative on the people affected.

32:35 - 32:45

Erryn Cresshull

Well, Moe Joe and Jim here were affected by that, and it was a very difficult path, particularly for a refugee a mainly refugee community.

32:45 - 32:55

Speaker 71

Yeah, right. Yeah. And then not everybody got their money, and it took a long time to get the recovery of the wages.

32:55 - 33:44

Erryn Cresshull

It was through the federal courts, and that takes a very long time. And I think, if I can say, I think the thing about the Secure Local Jobs Code, it catches things before they happen. We don't want this to happen to our members again. If we can put in, you know, we have a process where bad operators, hopefully, can't get through. Otherwise, we're in a situation that we were with the Federal Court case that we ran and our members, and it was a terrible time.

It was very difficult to recover those wages. Also, just confidence in working in Australia, you know, it was a it was a terrible thing. And they are not alone. Our industries are bad industries. We know this.

But catching it first saves that pain.

33:44 - 33:49

Speaker 69

And did you have to find lawyers? Did you have to find and pay for lawyers? Is that something that the union did?

33:49 - 33:51

Speaker 65

That was through the yeah, through the union, yes.

33:51 - 33:54

Speaker 68

So, the union then had to fund that?

33:54 - 33:55

Yes, through our member funds.

33:55 - 33:59

Speaker 64

At the outset in order to recover the wages.

33:59 - 34:00

Absolutely.

34:00 - 34:02

Speaker 66

Yeah, okay. Thank you.

34:02 - 34:04

Speaker 67

Ms Berry.

34:04 - 34:33

Yvette Berry

Thank you, Chair. Thanks, everyone, for coming in. And I should disclose that I am a member of United Workers Union, and I know Erryn quite well, but have not discussed this hearing with anybody before today's date. Obviously, I'm aware of the Phillips Cleaning Services issue, and the challenges within the cleaning industry. I wondered with the Secure Local Jobs Code, having it catch bad players before they're engaged with the government is one thing.

34:33 - 34:46

Speaker 70

What is the What would be an ideal kind of check-in through the Secure Local Jobs Code if an employer does find their way around their requirements or their obligations under the code?

34:46 - 35:01

Erryn Cresshull

I think it needs to have constant reporting throughout the contract period, and rigorous reporting, that's not just the company saying, "This is what we're doing, and we're ticking all the boxes." It has to be real.

35:01 - 35:15

Yvette Berry

And how does that message get out to cleaning contractors that is now a requirement, that they understand that they can't, or that there are better ways now to improve their work?

35:15 - 35:51

Erryn Cresshull

Well, I think it's through the government has to say to those contractors, and through the local jobs code registrar when they go through the process at the beginning.

I mean, small businesses and companies running these types of outfits have many things that they have to do to make sure their company is financially viable and in line with all the other legislative requirements they have. I don't we don't tend to buy that this is red tape that's so excessive that they can't do it.

35:51 - 36:18

Yvette Berry

And I acknowledge, as Ms Clay has, the courage, I guess, that for your members to come in and tell your stories and your experiences and still having that fear that you may be targeted by unscrupulous contractors here in the ACT. How do you make sure through how do we make sure through the secure local jobs work that people can tell their stories and their experiences, and that they can be protected with their union and by the government?

36:18 - 36:26

Speaker 76

Well, it's a matter of engaging with workers through the unions, I think. And that doesn't always happen.

36:26 - 36:45

James Milligan

Okay, thank you, Ms Berry. Just going back to the school cleaners case, now, they were able to pursue their entitlements through the Federal Court and through those laws. What additional protections does the code actually provide that couldn't be achieved through that normal process?

36:45 - 37:22

Erryn Cresshull

Well, the main thing is that there's checks at the beginning, so we probably won't even we don't necessarily have to go through the process. It's thousands and thousands of dollars of our members' money and taxpayers' money in through the court system. If we stop it at the beginning, and have contractors at the beginning that are doing the right thing, then we don't have to do that at all. And we haven't to date, like this has been it's been working for our members in industries where it doesn't work in a lot of other places.

37:22 - 37:30

Speaker 74

So, how does the code pick up these incidences before any action through the Federal Court or any other current laws?

37:30 - 38:34

Erryn Cresshull

Well, it's the fact Sorry, I interrupted you. It's the fact that they have to get a certificate to start with, and those companies are interrogated at the beginning before they are issued with a government contract. We're happy to strengthen the code to make sure that there's more checks and balances along the way, you know, to check in to make sure that a company hasn't slipped through the net or changed how they operate, because these companies are slippery, and they and it's a hard industry, because it's relying on wages. So, anything that any anything that goes, it's always wages that get cut first. So, we see an absolute value in how the code's operating, but any strengthening of the code will of course strengthen build our members' confidence, I suppose, in the in whether or not they are getting paid, and the conditions are being appropriately issued to them.

38:34 - 38:47

James Milligan

The light rail has what been allegedly reported as underpaying its workers through that construction. If the code is working, why did it come to that?

38:47 - 39:14

Erryn Cresshull

I can't offer any insight into the light rail. Our members work in security and cleaning, and it's a really services-based industry. And the first thing that will get cut in this industry are wages, and that these companies will undercut each other. That's really the only thing they can undercut on is wages, so it's a different it's a different kettle of fish, I suppose, than what our members do.

39:14 - 39:20

James Milligan

In security and cleaning, there is a standard wage that is applied,

39:21 - 39:22

minimum wage, I'd take it?

39:22 - 39:24

Speaker 72

award rates, yes.

39:24 - 39:27

Speaker 75

Are businesses not meeting that minimum wage? Where are they failing?

39:27 - 39:30

Speaker 73

Often.

39:30 - 39:36

Speaker 83

Do you have evidence in terms of that here in the ACT of recent?

39:36 - 39:49

Erryn Cresshull

Yes. I'd have to provide that later, but absolutely. We've got many cases where we've picked up underpayment of wages, or conditions, or any terms of employment in the ACT.

39:49 - 40:06

Fiona Carrick

And if that slips through, as you said before things slip through, does the registrar have the investigation powers and the enforcement powers needed to resolve those situations?

40:06 - 40:13

Speaker 82

We would we'd love to see it strengthened. So, some, yes, but we'd like to see that strengthened.

40:13 - 40:17

Speaker 78

And when you say strengthened, what how, like what would that mean?

40:17 - 40:21

Speaker 81

The check-in, the you know the check-in and the auditing to make sure

40:21 - 40:22

More regular?

40:22 - 40:24

Speaker 79

Yeah, that's right.

40:24 - 40:26

Speaker 80

Okay.

40:26 - 40:52

James Milligan

Any other questions before we close this session? All good? Well, on behalf of the committee, I would like to thank you for your attendance today. There has been a few questions taken on notice, so if you're able to provide your answers to the committee secretary within five business days of receiving the uncorrected proof, that'd be very useful for us. Other than that, we are finished and have a good morning.

40:52 - 40:53

Thank you very much.

40:53 - 40:54

Thank you.

40:54 - 40:54

Thank you.

59:43 - 01:00:13

James Milligan

Good morning. We have Michael Hiscox here from CFMEU. Welcome.

Please note that as a witness, you are protected by parliamentary privilege and bound by its obligations. You must tell the truth and false or misleading evidence will be treated as a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. As we've only got 20 minutes for this session, we might go straight into questions if we can. Did you have an opening statement at all?

01:00:13 - 01:00:14

No, I'm happy to go straight to questions.

01:00:14 - 01:00:26

James Milligan

Excellent, all right. We'll go straight into it. Just for clarification, is the CFMMEU under administration right now, ACT, due to federal Labor?

01:00:26 - 01:00:32

Speaker 85

Yeah, the entirety of the construction division of the CFMMEU is in administration, including the ACT branch.

01:00:32 - 01:00:37

James Milligan

And how's that affect things here? Does it still operate, or not, or?

01:00:37 - 01:00:53

Michael Hiscox

Yeah, the union still operates. Effectively, it just means that the powers of the union that would normally be with officials of the union or committee of managements or things like that, all of those powers sit with the administrator.

01:00:53 - 01:00:58

James Milligan

Okay. No worries. I'll come back to myself, I might go to Ms Carrick first, or Ms Clay.

01:00:58 - 01:00:59

Oh, okay. Go on.

01:00:59 - 01:01:00

Are you ready, Ms Clay?

01:01:01 - 01:01:07

James Milligan

All right. We'll do five minutes at a time with each person.

01:01:07 - 01:01:34

Jo Clay

You put a number of excellent suggestions in your submission, including gender on the tender, and you talked about sham contracting on the Woden Hospital. Which of the bits in your submission do you think are directly relevant to Secure Local Jobs Code? We're not Secure Local Jobs Code doesn't do gender on the tender. It's a great suggestion, but it's not really Secure Local Jobs Code. Sham contracting, would that be part of the Secure Local Jobs Code?

01:01:34 - 01:01:55

Michael Hiscox

So, with gender on the tender, that's something that we've suggested could form part of the Secure Local Jobs Code, either through the or worthy system that sort of sits alongside of and that's part of it. But it probably wouldn't necessarily be something that's a requirement to have the code certificate. It would be sort of like

01:01:56 - 01:02:44

Michael Hiscox

a target or something that's a requirement for certain projects of a certain scale or a certain size. With the sham contracting, part of what we were sort of addressing there was our experiences on the Canberra Hospital project and how we thought the Secure Local Jobs overall system helped address issues of sham contracting there, and that when issues sort of came up or when people came to site that were clearly in these sham arrangements, the overall framework meant that it was dealt with in a much faster, quicker way than we've seen in situations previously, either prior to the Secure Local Jobs Code on ACT government projects, or situations that we see on projects now that aren't on part of Secure Local Jobs that aren't an ACT government project.

01:02:44 - 01:03:01

Speaker 88

And if there were no Secure Local Jobs Code, that particular issue, which would have been covered with the Fair Work legislation, tell me what the difference would have been in terms of how quickly it would have been addressed and what the impact on the workers in ACT would have been.

01:03:01 - 01:03:46

Michael Hiscox

Yeah, sure. So, under let's say the Fair Work Act, for example, the obligation to ensure sham contracting isn't occurring only applies directly to their employer. And obviously, in construction, there is a lot of subcontracting that goes on, legitimate subcontracting as well, and part of that is to help shield the risk of those sorts of things.

Under the Secure Local Jobs Code, it's an obligation not just on the employer, but also the principal contractor who arguably has the most power over what's going on. So, the builder or contractor, I guess, in the case of civil construction, they can't sort of shield themselves from any blame of what's going on. They have to be involved in part of the process, and they can be held accountable if those practices are happening on their sites.

01:03:46 - 01:04:18

Jo Clay

Part of what we heard in our last session is it's also the accessibility of the rights. So the difficulty in accessing rights under Fair Work legislation is it's federal and you may need to go to the federal court. There's likely to be a big time lag. There's you need a lawyer and legal advice to access those rights and you may end up getting a settlement or getting a post-fact award of damages, but it doesn't actually prevent the behavior in the first place. Is that one of the key differences that you can see?

01:04:18 - 01:05:02

Michael Hiscox

I think that's part of it. I think it also just generally promotes good behavior. I mean some of these things that can occur, as I think it sounds like you heard previously, it can take years and years for that to resolve. And then when it does, you can sort of just continue go back to working like normal. Sometimes there's often not findings in these things.

Like, they come to a settlement with individual workers involved and no one would know what sort of exactly happened there. I think part of the benefit of the framework we have here is that part of the consequences isn't just any legal consequence that happens directly from that individual worker. It affects your ability to continue to tender for work or win work in the Territory.

01:05:02 - 01:05:32

Jo Clay

We've heard from a number of witnesses that they have suggested the administrative pathway to getting a certificate, which is equally difficult for an organization of one or two or four people and an organization of a thousand people. There's been two responses to that situation. Some people say we should exempt small businesses, small organizations. And the other suggestion is we should provide more support to small organizations and a simpler administrative pathway.

01:05:32 - 01:05:40

Speaker 61

Have you got any views on that, noting that I would imagine, in construction, we probably don't have any tiny organizations?

01:05:40 - 01:06:50

Michael Hiscox

There are a lot of small organizations in construction. I'm not, I don't want to sort of I can't really speak for other sectors because I'm not as familiar with their circumstances there. Specifically within construction, I would be concerned about exempting small businesses specifically, because, like the example I said before, construction companies have a good way of organising their business to avoid accountability and liability. So, I'm sort of concerned that if you just provided a blanket exemption,

businesses would respond by saying, "Well, rather than having one business of 50 employees, I now have five of 10," or whatever. That being said, I mean the intention certainly isn't to become the intention isn't to try to be overly burdensome to small businesses. I think especially where some of the submissions I've read through employer groups, certainly when that information is already being asked for from the government in other places, it makes perfect sense to avoid asking for it again and just creating additional work for no reason. But ultimately, everyone has the same obligations, whether you're a small or large business, to pay your people properly and follow those. And I don't think there should be an exemption for smaller ones.

So-

01:06:50 - 01:07:06

Jo Clay

What if it the simpler administrative pathway isn't about giving different standards to smaller businesses, it's about having a simpler administrative pathway to obtaining a certificate for smaller businesses and more support for those smaller businesses? Is that something that bothers you or that you have strong views on?

01:07:06 - 01:07:28

Michael Hiscox

I don't have strong views on providing more support for businesses, big or small, to get them. And in terms of exemptions, I would have a problem with it just an exemption saying you don't need them. If there was a different pathway, not necessarily that wouldn't necessarily be a huge problem, but

the key thing I guess is that big or small, the enforcement is happening in the right way. I think that's most important.

01:07:28 - 01:08:11

Jo Clay

I'll finish on one more. So, part of the Secure Local Jobs Code and the role of the registrar, clearly there is confusion about what that is. The CFMEU, obviously engaged with the registrar in ways that came up in Operation Kingfisher. We I would say there's a lot of confusion around. Do you think there's a role for government for better education for industry and the public about what that is?

And do you think there's a role to make that registrar more independent and more robust from approaches, from interference, have more public transparency on if people want to engage, how do they do so?

01:08:11 - 01:09:10

Michael Hiscox

I think more public transparency with the overall system of procurement and tendering and awarding of contracts would be a good thing and I think, yeah, that would be welcomed. I think that should sort of extend across a whole range of things, like, so for one example, the labouring plans, I'll forget the full name for them, but it's sort of been referred to as part of SLJC, we've often called for those things that they should just be made public because they are requirements that companies have to comply with them as part of their contract. I think they maybe briefly were made public for a period and in those cases we identified a number of cases where companies weren't even they weren't even pretending that they were complying with those obligations. And I think in all those instances there's just no reason why that information shouldn't be publicly available. Like, it's all sort of public money.

It's all things that we should be getting delivered. There's no reason why anyone shouldn't be able to look that up on an ACT Government website and see what's happening there.

01:09:10 - 01:09:12

Speaker 89

Mrs Kikkert.

01:09:12 - 01:09:24

Fiona Carrick

Okay, thank you. Does the registrar have the powers that he needs for compliance?

01:09:24 - 01:10:18

Michael Hiscox

I think Look, I think most likely he has the powers. One of the suggestions we make in there is I'm just trying to remember if what we raised as the issue is with the powers or how they're used and I think it's more so how they're used. One of the things I guess that's frustrated us sometimes is the registrar's reluctance to make findings on things unless there is a court decision or unless there is a similar sort of decision. We've essentially sort of put forward a view that they could undertake more investigative work. Obviously, they're not a court, they can't make a finding, but there's certain things that would be so obvious or so black and white you could make a finding under the Secure Local Jobs Code and move ahead like that.

I don't believe there's anything currently that prohibits them from doing that. That they might have a different view and say that is a barrier, but it is something that they currently don't do, or if they do it's very rare that would happen.

01:10:18 - 01:10:24

Speaker 90

Could that be resources that limits that investigative

01:10:24 - 01:10:35

Michael Hiscox

Potentially, yeah. I think it's partly resources. I think it's partly they prob- I think they just don't necessarily see it as their role. I think more over they see their role is they take action once a finding's been made elsewhere.

01:10:35 - 01:10:46

Fiona Carrick

A previous witness said that the companies should do more reporting to the registrar. Would you support that?

01:10:46 - 01:11:24

Michael Hiscox

Don't necessarily have any problem with it. I think there is a there certainly is a need for ongoing compliance. And that's, I think we include some of those comments in there, that's the main frustration that we hear from employers that are part of the system is that they've got their certificate and then they know, you know, across what through the grapevine other employers aren't doing the right thing, and it doesn't seem to be any consequences for that up until they have to maybe go get their certificate again and that's a point in time audit. So, if you if everything's fine by that point then there's no consequence for it.

So, I think ongoing compliance would be, is important, yeah.

01:11:24 - 01:11:39

Fiona Carrick

If, um, if something's going on at a workplace, how do you know whether it's the Registrar or the Fair Work that comes in and has a look at these things? Who's, like who's ultimately responsible?

01:11:39 - 01:11:58

Michael Hiscox

Both have got different obligations. So, Fair Work, the Fair Work Ombudsman would, um, maybe not have an obligation, but have the ability to investigate underpayments. The Registrar has the ability to do so simply as far as it relates to their obligations under the code.

But I'd say in,

01:11:58 - 01:11:59

Is there overlap?

01:11:59 - 01:12:25

Michael Hiscox

There might be some overlap, but in practice, probably neither are doing that. Like Fair Work Ombudsman really don't. Much more rarely now would pursue individual one-off cases of underpayments, like they tend to take a much more, I think they use the term strategic litigation. So, unless there is real, substantial, they probably won't bother it.

They would prefer it. But rarely would both be showing up to site. It probably would be neither in most cases.

01:12:25 - 01:12:34

Speaker 92

Right. So, um, the Fair Work is more reactive if they get a complaint or something, as opposed to being out there, um, undertaking compliance?

01:12:34 - 01:13:06

Michael Hiscox

Um, yeah, the they, they probably are more so reactive, but even in those cases, like they've obviously got limited resources as well, so they don't they don't get a complaint and say, "Okay, we're going to go do an inspection now." They'll want to get a sense of the scale of the problem, and if they didn't think it was significant enough, they would not pursue it.

Um, but similarly, yeah similarly with the Registrar, I don't think they would pursue, if they had a report of that, I don't think they would pursue it either. I think they would just refer it to the FWO and go from there.

01:13:06 - 01:13:16

Fiona Carrick

Okay, thank you. Um, what evidence exists that the two-gate model produces better procurement outcomes?

01:13:16 - 01:14:21

Michael Hiscox

Um, it's the model itself probably hasn't been around long enough that it's probably hard to evaluate in ACT specifically. I think we quote some of the academics that site the two-gate model as what they consider to be one of the best models for procurement in Australia. I think I guess the principle of it, which is one we obviously support, is the previous sort of system where you would evaluate, say, 10% for safety or 10% for industrial relations or things like that could lead to quite perverse circumstances where, at least in theory, say, someone with 0% on safety could get there if they were good enough on some of these other criteria. And I think most people would agree

well, if your safety is so poor, you don't deserve to be successful on any of those projects. The overall, I guess, intention is that there are certain thresholds that if you don't meet those, you really shouldn't be in the mix for it at all. Um, but similarly, once you've met those, then whoever is able to put forward the best tender should get it.

01:14:21 - 01:14:23

Speaker 91

Okay, thank you.

01:14:24 - 01:15:08

Yvette Berry

Thank you, and I should say that I know Michael through his work through the CFMEU, but I have not discussed this committee hearing with him at all. I did just, I was curious, Michael, about work health and safety records of employers in the construction industry that it is, you know, has, you know, can be quite unsafe. It's hard work. If there is an employer that has a record of bad work health and safety continuously, but it's not ever gone to litigation, is that something that you think should be used as evidence in securing a secure local jobs code or throughout the code's application?

01:15:08 - 01:16:06

Michael Hiscox

Yeah, oh, look, I definitely think it should be. I mean, as you say, I think construction is the I think second most dangerous industry in terms of fatalities, in terms of serious workplace injuries, it's the most dangerous.

This year just passed now, we've actually sort of increased the number of deaths in construction, which is obviously heavily concerning. Similar I guess to the conversation around FWO, WorkSafe have limited resources and they have to be strategic in how they pursue their litigations, which certainly means a lot of breaches don't get pursued, even when they should. But I think it's definitely worthwhile looking at sort of other records or other information that could be brought in, that companies that have poor safety records,

they suffer a consequence for that, cuz most of the time, these companies are doing it to save money. It's not, that's the only reason, so why should they get an unfair advantage over another company because they've got a poor safety record?

01:16:06 - 01:16:12

Speaker 93

What are the kinds of corners that they would be cutting to save money in work health and safety particularly?

01:16:12 - 01:16:56

Michael Hiscox

The most, there's a number of different things, but the most clear-cut one normally we'd see is, and especially sort of see this is, in residential, is the way they provide access and egress to a site. So, most of the times, the safe way to do it would be to erect scaffold or do something similar. And then we'll see sort of situations where people are just working off ladders or things like that. So, fall from heights is obviously one of the most serious risks. And then I guess it just comes down to just general planning and coordination, which often comes down to there aren't sufficient resources to ensure that it's one person's role to say, ensure that, okay, what are going to be the access ways on-site when we have these deliveries?

How are we planning for vehicle movements, those sorts of things.

01:16:56 - 01:17:14

Yvette Berry

Do you have examples on some of the bigger contracts where there might be subcontracting, which is perfectly legal and legitimate, where there might be a record of, you know, work health and safety issues that may not have been taken into account, or are still not being taken into account?

01:17:14 - 01:17:32

Michael Hiscox

Look, not off the top of my head, that's probably something we'd have to provide later. I mean, look, all the major builders will subcontract in a legitimate way as well. But, yeah, in terms I guess safety issues that probably haven't been adequately addressed, yeah, that's probably something we'd need to take on notice.

01:17:32 - 01:18:46

James Milligan

Thank you, Ms Berry. Earlier, or last year, September 2025, the CFMEU joined employers and the Albanese government in endorsing the National Construction Industry Forum blueprint for the future. Now, that document specifically calls for reviewing procurement red tape, aligning existing pre-qualification schemes, and examining barriers for small business to participation.

Now, the CFMEU's own administration subsequently cited the blueprint as part of its reform, but as I understand, the CFMEU is advocating for an expansion of the secure local jobs code with additional certification and compliance. You mentioned compliance just earlier, and you say that they do have the powers, but they're not doing enough in that space. How did the CFMEU come to that position with the secure local jobs adding additional burden and compliance in comparison to the blueprint for the future, where that's meant to be looking at reducing red tape,

removing barriers, and helping people in the industry?

01:18:46 - 01:19:06

Michael Hiscox

I guess the point you sort of said our position there, so the position was to review the procurement legislation, and obviously, it's being reviewed here, and we support it being reviewed. In terms of, I guess, adding burdens or adding red tape, what would you say the things that we're proposing that would add burdens or add red tape?

01:19:06 - 01:19:17

James Milligan

Extra compliance, calling in the council to do more inspections and so forth. Are you suggesting they're not doing enough, or

01:19:17 - 01:19:30

Michael Hiscox

So, that's not a burden to the employer, though. That's obviously additional work for the registrar to undertake. But the only way that puts in an additional cost on the employer is if we find if the registrar finds non-compliance.

01:19:30 - 01:19:39

James Milligan

Did you agree that there should be extra reporting with the businesses on the Secure Local Jobs and how they've been compliant?

01:19:39 - 01:20:21

Michael Hiscox

Not I think that was asked before. Look, I don't really have a strong view about whether they should sort of renew a certificate more frequently or less frequently. I guess what's most important is the ongoing compliance. So, there's different methods about how you can make sure that businesses are complying properly.

I don't know if it is the best thing to say send us something every month saying you're compliant or not, because if they're sort of if they're getting around them if they're getting around it currently, then asking for more reports every month will just be more reports that aren't correct. So, I don't know if it's necessarily worthwhile just getting additional information from them.

01:20:21 - 01:20:35

James Milligan

Okay. Well, we have come to the end of this session, and obviously on behalf of the committee, we'd like to thank you for attending today. I wasn't sure if there was any questions taken on notice today.

01:20:35 - 01:20:36

Just the one around safety.

01:20:36 - 01:20:46

James Milligan

Around safety? Okay. Well, if that's the case, are you able to provide answers to that question within five business days from receiving the uncorrected proof?

01:20:47 - 01:20:51

James Milligan

That would be most helpful for the committee. Otherwise, good morning and have a great day.

01:20:51 - 01:20:52

No worries, thanks.

01:20:52 - 01:21:15

Speaker 99

Thank you. How are you?

01:21:15 - 01:21:16

Good, thank you.

01:21:16 - 01:21:46

James Milligan

You're here from the Canberra Business Chamber, and we'll just run through the parliamentary privilege areas. So, please note that as a witness, you're protected by the obligations of the Assembly and parliamentary privilege. You're bound by those. You must tell the truth; giving false or misleading evidence will be treated as a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. We haven't been taking opening statements, but if you have one, are you have able to table?

01:21:46 - 01:21:49

Speaker 96

I didn't really have an opening statement, so happy to just go to questions.

01:21:49 - 01:22:12

James Milligan

Excellent. Well, that's really good, then. We'll just go straight into questions, then, and I'll give each member, you know, seven or eight minutes. We've got 30 minutes, so you're one of the lucky ones to have more time here. I'll start it off.

Your submission recommends repealing the Secure Local Jobs Code in its entirety. Could you talk us through what led to the chamber having that position?

01:22:12 - 01:23:36

Greg Harford

Yeah, absolutely. Thank you for the question. Look, essentially we fully support the idea that employers should be complying with the law. We fully support the idea that workers should be kept safe when they go to do their jobs, but I think the point is that there's already provisions to deal with these issues through a multitude of Commonwealth and territory rules and regulations. So, it sort of seems to us that having a separate process in place around so-called Secure Local Jobs Code really drives cost, it drives complexity, it contributes to reduced value for money for taxpayers at the end of the day, and ultimately, it reduces competition in the market.

Our view is that yes, these things are all very important, they should be set out when the territory is seeking to procure work, they should be a condition of the contract of that work, but you don't need to have a separate process up-front where businesses effectively have to jump through multiple hoops to get a certificate before they're allowed to bid, because that is a deterrent to entering the market, and we know that there are firms that do not do business in the ACT, or seek not to do business in the ACT, because they do not believe that the cost of compliance is worthwhile.

01:23:36 - 01:23:49

James Milligan

So obviously the cost of compliance is time, but also financial for the entities, but that's no guarantee that they'll be able to get any procurement through ACT government contracts or jobs, right?

01:23:49 - 01:24:07

Greg Harford

No, that's absolutely right. And the cost is not just the cost of getting the certificate, it is the cost of maintaining records. It is the cost of time spent complying with the rules and regulations. It adds up, is a big a lot of impact.

01:24:07 - 01:24:22

James Milligan

And you've obviously heard that from your members. I'm not asking you to disclose any members or specifically what they've said, but you're gathering your evidence directly from people in the industry's trying to look at procurement for government, right?

01:24:22 - 01:24:23

Yeah, absolutely.

01:24:23 - 01:24:37

James Milligan

You've raised concerns about the administrative burden of complying with the code, and particularly the duplication of requirements. Can you explain what that looks like in practice for a Canberra business trying to undertake government work?

01:24:37 - 01:25:18

Greg Harford

Well, I mean in essence that a Canberra business is required to comply with the law. Additionally, they're required to comply with a Secure Local Jobs Code process that requires them to prove before they bid for a contract upfront that they are complying with the law and have complied with the law. That evidential basis, you know, that is where the cost comes in. That is where the complexity comes in. And as I say, it is one of the things that deters people from seeking to bid for territory work because there's an upfront compliance cost with no guarantee that they're going to get the work.

01:25:18 - 01:25:37

James Milligan

You mentioned that there's, you know, duplication of things in the code and ACT legislation, but also federal legislation. Is there any parts of the code that's not part of any ACT legislation or federal government legislation that we should still consider?

01:25:37 - 01:26:21

Greg Harford

I, my It's all pretty much covered. So the way this works is, as I say, it's a it's a process that you've got to go through upfront. That process is all about compliance with the law, essentially. If you're complying with the law, you are complying with the law.

We don't think you need to go through those sorts of processes to need to prove that. And if you're if you're a bad actor, and I think the reality is there's very few bad actors in the world, but, you know, if you were a bad actor, you if you, and I sort of caught the tail end of some of that conversation, if you're if you're falsifying documents, you're going to falsify documents anyway. This is not This is not going to stop bad guys.

01:26:21 - 01:26:47

James Milligan

Yeah, of course. What record should the government be compelled to publish about ACT versus interstate contracts, and that have been awarded subcontractor payments and external tender representations to establish whether the procurement is competitive and properly independent? How could the government report that this code is delivering for the ACT?

01:26:47 - 01:27:35

Greg Harford

Well, I think the question you've got to ask is ultimately looking at the cost of ACT government procurement, which typically is higher than it might be in other states and territories, as I understand it. There is a premium cost to doing business here. Secure Local Jobs Code is part of that. We know that there are, for example, exemptions that are sometimes issued to the code because there aren't people in the ACT willing to go through the process in order to bid for government work. That says to me that it is a barrier to entry.

And if you removed that upfront barrier, and you incorporated contractual requirements into your tender contracts, that would be a better way of delivering good outcomes and you would hopefully see a better value for money as a result of that.

01:27:35 - 01:28:02

James Milligan

So obviously it's a bit of a lengthy process to go through a procurement process for any entity applying for a tender with an ACT government job, and as I understand, they've got to go through that process every single time.

Does the secure local jobs help in that in any way? Does it help that process a lot smoother or more streamlined or is it just purely another administrative burden on applying for any procurement jobs?

01:28:02 - 01:28:32

Greg Harford

Look, I think honestly it is an administrative burden. You have to In some cases you have to provide a local industry participation plan, that's not necessarily part of the code directly. The LORT processes again are slightly different from the code processes themselves. But, overall, I think we will see this very much as a compliance requirement which drives cost, deters competition and prevents entry into the market.

01:28:32 - 01:29:01

James Milligan

If the Secure Local Jobs Code I know it's all a bit of hypothetical, but maybe based on evidence that you've heard from your members, if the code was removed, do you think based on feedback from your members, that you'll get more businesses back involved in the construction industry here in the ACT, that you might see an increase in people putting in for tenders and maybe actually make it more competitive because you've got a broader range of applicants?

01:29:01 - 01:29:23

Greg Harford

I believe that to be the case. As I say, we believe the Secure Local Jobs Code deters entry into the market and therefore if you if this were abolished and if the provisions to protect workers were made part of a contractual requirement, you would see more businesses tendering upfront which, hopefully, would deliver a more competitive outcome for the taxpayer.

01:29:23 - 01:29:31

James Milligan

And so that would just be added into the contractual contract in itself, right?

01:29:31 - 01:30:01

Greg Harford

That's right. So, the actual requirements to pay workers properly, keep them safe and all that stuff, does not change. It's just the process for delivering that, and if you If government would to be including that as a condition of the contract, that could then become a question of ongoing contract management, and you would then presumably see different levels of management depending on the scale and size of the contract. It would just be one process for an application, and that's it.

01:30:01 - 01:30:03

James Milligan

Okay. Ms Carrick.

01:30:03 - 01:30:29

Fiona Carrick

Thank you, Chair. The proof of compliance at the beginning, we have heard from previous members that helps weed out bad actors and like they've used the example of the cleaning industry and so they're very supportive of that step to try and weed them out before contracts are awarded. Do you see any value in that at all?

01:30:29 - 01:31:23

Greg Harford

To be honest with you, like there are minimum terms and conditions for employing people. There are There's a whole thousands of pages of law about what you need to do to employ people. Every business in Australia is required to comply with the law. Those are federal requirements. They are set federally.

I don't believe having a separate ACT process on top of that to prove compliance with something that everyone is required to comply with is going to resolve issues. I also, frankly, don't buy the fact that there are you know, bad actors who are willingly trying to go out and do the wrong thing. In my experience, certainly, members of the Canberra Business Chamber are fully aware of their legal requirements. They work very hard to make sure that they're doing the right thing by their people.

01:31:23 - 01:31:32

Speaker 100

Um, but Canberra Business Chamber wouldn't have members of like every industry, like I mean, would every cleaning contractor be a member of your

01:31:32 - 01:31:38

Speaker 102

Ah, no. I wouldn't say every cleaning contractor is a member of the chamber, well, we certainly have cleaning contractors who are members of the chamber.

01:31:38 - 01:32:15

Fiona Carrick

Okay, thanks. Um, when you talk about the barriers to competition um, from having the code and having the, um, requirements to protect workers in contractual requirements, does that not fragment the skills in, um, undertaking compliance? So if you have the registrar, you have that the skills there within one entity, as opposed to being scattered across the ACT government?

Does that not, um, provide some economies of scale by having that compliance function in one area?

01:32:15 - 01:32:16

Well, my understanding

01:32:16 - 01:32:16

And save costs there?

01:32:16 - 01:32:51

Greg Harford

Yeah. I mean, my understanding is that Procurement ACT, uh, runs procurement processes on behalf of the ACT government. Um, I think you could certainly, um, centralise your contract management, uh, but that is actually a different point from whether, um, uh, whether you should be putting upfront processes that add cost and reduce, uh, competitiveness, um, into a process or whether you should, um, so certainly that's one option. Um, the other option is that you make sure that your contract managers are trained to do, uh, the jobs that they're employed to do and that they're managed.

01:32:51 - 01:33:49

Fiona Carrick

And, um, compliance seems to be a diff- a difficult thing because, um, um, you know, workers' rights do slip through the cracks. We've heard some examples of it. Um, and one, um, witness said maybe more reporting, another said well that wouldn't really work. Um, how do you, um, ensure proof of compliance like should there be stronger whistleblower laws, so that where there is, um, a breach of workers' rights that like how do you bring it forward because,

uh, one witness said that the Fair Work isn't proactive, they don't get out on every site, they might hear a complaint, but they won't investigate everything, they don't have the resources. So, ha- who is actually responsible for getting out there and investigating if, um, you know, because that would turn every contract manager in the ACT into a workplace investigator.

01:33:49 - 01:35:28

Greg Harford

I think I'd question the fundamental premise of that question, which is that workers' rights slip through the cracks. Workers' rights in this country do not slip through the cracks. If you've got someone who is deliberately flouting the law, I think it's a reasonable assumption that they will be prosecuted with the full weight of the law, whether that is a workplace health and safety issue or whether that is a Fair Work issue. Um, employers, let me tell you, live in fear of doing the wrong thing. They are not out there trying to, uh, reduce worker rights.

They are not out there trying to do the wrong thing. Um, they are typically working, um, very hard to ensure compliance. Now, there are sometimes situations where people get things wrong, and those there are honest mistakes sometimes that happen. I think they are generally resolved through conversation between, uh, workers and employers. Um, there are a very small number of, uh, people who might, uh, willingly engage in criminal, uh, behaviour, uh, but I think the numbers of those firms, um, are very small.

Uh, there is a whole, uh, framework to deal with them, um, and, uh, and, you know, putting extra compliance requirements across the whole of the industry, um, is really not a solution, um, that makes sense when you're deal- dealing with actually a very small number of people. Um, it is kind of like saying, "Well, there are some criminals in the community, uh, therefore, we need to treat everyone like a criminal." Um, and that's not the case in the business community. It's not the case in the community at large.

01:35:28 - 01:36:11

Jo Clay

Okay, thank you. Greg, you've talked about the Secure Local Jobs Code being duplicative. We've had some evidence from other witnesses describing the difference in being able to access ACT rights and making sure at the outset that a government procurement spend is upholding really good standards versus having to take someone to the Federal Court, incur all the legal advice and legal fees of that and possibly after a period of some years maybe get a retrospective award of damages to cover the issue. So, the standards might be the same, but the pathway to enforcing your rights are quite different if it's ACT or federal. Does that change your view at all?

01:36:11 - 01:36:47

Greg Harford

Look, the reality is these are Commonwealth rules that we're trying to enforce here if we're talking about workplace terms and conditions, if we're talking about health and safety it's an ACT issue. You know, the territory, the states around the country have referred their industrial relations powers to the Commonwealth. That's the appropriate place to deal with these. Again, just because somebody may have a problem with a process, that doesn't mean you need to treat everyone in business like a criminal and put these processes in place. It doesn't, it doesn't make sense when there's rules there.

01:36:47 - 01:36:58

Jo Clay

Sure. You'd said that procurement in the ACT is more expensive than in other jurisdictions. I would love to know the data. Have you got any evidence or data on that?

01:36:58 - 01:37:28

Greg Harford

Sorry, what I was really trying to say was that it is more expensive to do business here in the ACT. There are extra costs that businesses face here in the ACT because they're in the ACT, because the ACT government makes it harder and more expensive to do business, principally whether that's through rates, charges, extra processes such as the Secure Local Jobs Code. There's a whole range of things which, definitely the feedback I get from members, is that it's much more expensive to do business.

01:37:28 - 01:37:33

Speaker 105

Have you got, have you got any sort of evidence or comparison, like have you got any data?

01:37:33 - 01:37:52

Greg Harford

I don't I don't have, I don't have a magic number that I can sort of show you to say it's here, but certainly things again, workers compensation, I've got members telling me that it costs them four times as much per employee here in the ACT than it does in Queensland. We've got commercial rates.

01:37:52 - 01:37:57

Speaker 107

Unless your members happen to be in the horse racing industry, in which case the ACT government has taken care of that expense for them.

01:37:57 - 01:38:20

Greg Harford

Yep. Not qualified to talk about the horse racing industry, but there is that, commercial rates here have gone up 8% this year. I don't have perfect numbers from across the border, but on average they're less than 4% in New South Wales. There's a whole range of things where we're just not competitive, and many of those things are within the ability of the ACT government to look at.

01:38:20 - 01:38:27

Speaker 106

Yeah. And do you know any, has the ACT government or have you, or has any organisation put together like a comparison on those?

01:38:27 - 01:38:36

Greg Harford

Look, we've got comparisons of some things, but probably one of the things I'm really keen to do is to kind of pull that together more generally, but I don't have that.

01:38:36 - 01:39:37

Jo Clay

Yeah, I think it'd be useful. I won't ask you to take it on notice. I think if you did that piece of work, it would probably be a useful piece of work. You mentioned the difficulties of local jobs, and we've had this in discussion in the public domain quite a lot, that the Secure Local Jobs Code does not in actual fact do anything for local jobs. I, the figures that we've got from various questions on notice asked in parliament, are that ACT government procurement local procurement spend dropped from 54%, which is already quite low frankly, to 34% over the past six years.

So, our local spend has dropped and that wealth has left the community. Of course, some of those people will live temporarily in the ACT and deliver the work, but the actual wealth of that procurement spend has not been local, it's dropped to about a third and is heading downwards. Have you got any view, do you think the ACT government should have some positive levers to try to encourage local benefits for procurement in addition to secure work?

01:39:37 - 01:40:28

Greg Harford

Yeah, look, I mean, I think we would certainly be supportive of making sure that ACT firms get the benefit of ACT government procurement. But we need to be very careful that we're not destroying value for money through that process. We don't want to put up trade barriers that make it more expensive, even more expensive to do business here. I think, you know, what we're seeing New South Wales recently has changed or is changing its procurement rules so that they are weighting their procurement decisions in favour of New South Wales businesses. We could do something similar through our procurement policies.

Um, but again, we do actually just need to be careful that we're not creating adverse outcomes through that process.

01:40:28 - 01:40:36

Jo Clay

So, there's not probably hard laws that you would want to see come in, but there's definitely some changes to the way we do procurement to encourage it?

01:40:36 - 01:41:02

Greg Harford

Absolutely. But we do have to be careful there, too, because we need to make sure that there are opportunities for ACT businesses in other jurisdictions as well, and the reality is other jurisdictions are bigger than us. And if we effectively try and put barriers up to stop New South Wales firms crossing the border and doing business here, you know, some sort of tit for tat arrangement would not be a good outcome for ACT.

01:41:02 - 01:41:07

Speaker 108

Well, imagine, so if the New South Wales government has made a change, we could safely make the same change?

01:41:08 - 01:41:57

Jo Clay

Yeah. We've also had We've had various calls, there's a lot of different opinions on the Secure Local Jobs Code. We've had calls to strengthen, expand, extend. We've had calls to remove it altogether. We've also had, I guess, a middle ground call that the administrative pathway for smaller organisations should be more supported by government and should be simpler.

And the theory behind that is, you know, an organisation of one or two or three people complying with exactly the same requirements as an organisation as a major corporate of a thousand people, that's quite inequitable and maybe not the best system. Do you think there is room to come up with a simpler administrative pathway for certain small organisations, community sector, or more government support for certain types of organisations?

01:41:57 - 01:42:55

Greg Harford

Look, I think the best way to deal with that issue is, first, to assume that everyone is actually complying with the law and doing the right thing, and, secondly, to include it as conditions of the contracts that are being awarded, and to make sure that those contracts are being managed appropriately. Now, if you're a small business of two or three people, and you've got I'm making this up, but if you've got a $300,000 contract to do something, the management of that contract would presumably be a lot lighter than, say, a $500 million contract to build a stadium, or whatever. You that is how you deal with that issue. I don't think keeping a flawed framework, and somehow then creating Band-Aid solutions to help smaller businesses navigate that process is the answer. The answer is to deal with the flawed process in itself.

01:42:55 - 01:43:40

Jo Clay

I'd Oh. Yeah, go on then. One to two, and you've mentioned a number of times we should assume people are complying with the law, and I absolutely agree we should always assume good will and good faith where we can. We've had a number of submissions and witnesses come in and tell us specific examples of wage theft, the impact on workers, the impact on migrant workers, the impact on refugees, the difficulty in claiming that, and it has come up in construction, in cleaning, in hospitality, in quite a range of high-risk industries. So I d- Does that If Have you had a look at any of that evidence, or heard any of that evidence of if we assume everybody is complying with the law, but we have many examples where people here in the ACT are not, maybe we need a greater protection?

01:43:40 - 01:44:35

Greg Harford

Well, I think if there is an issue with wage theft, which is now federally a criminal offense, then there are already processes for dealing with that issue. If those processes are not suitable, then I'd suggest it needs to be dealt with at a Commonwealth level. If the Fair Work Act is not delivering, that's something that needs to be dealt with by the federal government. The ACT government shouldn't be trying to develop a solution for people here in the ACT, because the end result of that is undermining of the federal industrial relations framework and potentially a patchwork of eight separate rules around the country sets of rules around the country, if everyone's doing that. We've got to We've got to accept that this is a federal issue and that it needs to be dealt with federally.

01:44:35 - 01:44:38

James Milligan

Excellent, thank you. Ms Berry?

01:44:38 - 01:45:13

Yvette Berry

Thank you. My questions go a bit to where Jo Clay was heading around work health and safety and industrial relations. If work health and safety, and making sure that workers are paid appropriately, is the minimum requirement, and the secure local jobs code is just asking for that minimum requirement, proof of that being applied, and it weeds out bad actors, how can that be a bad thing for the businesses in this town?

01:45:13 - 01:46:24

Greg Harford

So there's two reasons that creates problems. First, it's an additional layer of compliance. So, businesses work very hard typically to do the right thing, pay their employees properly, that's core business for any firm. What's not core business is then having to justify that, prove that, apply for a secure local jobs code certificate, be audited, incur all the time, and cost, and energy of that, which is, you know, particularly for small businesses really problematic. And also, the point I'd make is that this whole process, we know, does deter entry into the market.

So, there are businesses that don't bid for ACT government work, not because they're bad actors who try not to pay their employees properly, but because they don't think the value they will receive from ACT government work, if they're lucky enough to win ACT government work, makes it worthwhile to go through those compliance hoops in the first place. And that means that there is less competition in the market for ACT government work, and competition tends to lead to better prices.

01:46:24 - 01:46:54

Yvette Berry

Wouldn't the community though have a, and they will, have a very high expectation that the funding that they provide through their revenue, through rate payments, that funding is being spent appropriately? And I agree, not everybody in business is a criminal, and I don't think any of us are saying that. What we're saying is we want to weed out the criminals or the bad actors. And the community should have an expectation that would be the case. And that should be publicly seen somewhere.

01:46:54 - 01:47:46

Greg Harford

Yeah, look, I think it's absolutely right. The public should be expecting that ACT government money is being spent prudently, wisely, and cost-effectively. And I would suggest that the best way you can do that is to have as many people as possible bidding for work, so that you can get the best value for money. And you need to You can then ensure that the whatever the requirements are being met through a condition of your contract. That is the That is the thing.

Contracts are legally binding. You know, if you sign a contract um and you breach that contract, uh there are remedies in that contract. You can be taken to court. You can have damages awarded against you. Those are things that businesses take seriously, um and people work very hard to make sure they deliver um what they're required to do.

01:47:46 - 01:48:43

Yvette Berry

We've heard, as uh Ms Clay suggested, that a number of witnesses this morning, and you will know about these, from unions, and it's no surprise that you would have a different perspective uh from your um the Business Chamber and the unions, as far as the Secure Local Jobs Code. However, you know, we've heard of these um very real experiences, uh and I've seen that on the um work uh Work Health and Safety website that um there were 173 falls from heights in '23-'24 and '24-'25 that were that workers' compensation was agreed for. So, obviously, there's been some significant uh work health and safety issues and injuries caused on worksites. It might not be the case that somebody is doing that on purpose. You know, of course, we would never think that somebody would want to harm somebody on purpose on a website, on a worksite.

01:48:43 - 01:48:47

Speaker 110

However, there's clearly something wrong there when people are being injured.

01:48:47 - 01:49:21

Greg Harford

Absolutely, and workers should be able to go home safe everyday. I absolutely endorse that. Um but the numbers that you're citing, I don't know if they relate to ACT government uh procurement work or not, um but they are there while we have um uh a Secure Local Jobs Code in place. So, the Secure Local Jobs Code does not stop an accident happening in the workplace. What stops an accident happening in the workplace is good attention to health and safety and making sure that people are staying safe.

01:49:21 - 01:49:44

Yvette Berry

When the um government brought in silica training to keep in keep uh workers safe, particularly in the construction industry, um some construction industry businesses said that would be a further burden on the industry. Do you agree that having that kind of work health safety requirements, silica training, asbestos training, working from heights training, is a burden?

01:49:44 - 01:50:45

Greg Harford

Uh not when it is when the right people are being trained. If you've got someone who is uh potentially exposed to silica, asbestos, or who is going to be working at heights, um obviously, they need to be trained to make sure that they uh know how to manage the risks of that. Uh where we have had concerns about uh some of those rules are blanket rules, um which don't necessarily make sense. So, uh for example, someone uh responsible for cleaning this building, um is re- required to hold a silica card, um even though um they're not likely to be exposed to all of the silica any more than you are, who work here. Uh In this building, there's probably likely asbestos.

Absolutely. Yeah. So, my question, though, is like if you're working in an office, um and you are exposed essentially to the same risks that um, say, a cleaner is, uh whether that's around silica or asbestos, um why would you not roll those requirements out to uh members of the Legislative Assembly, for example?

01:50:45 - 01:51:24

Yvette Berry

Uh The Secure Local Jobs Code is designed to ensure that those work health and safety requirements are being met by construction companies and other businesses in the ACT, um putting aside the number the people who might not require that training. Um If the case is that we're just wanting to ensure that businesses are keeping their workers safe, yes, I understand that there are regulations around a number of these things, but they're not being met by everyone. Isn't Doesn't that lead to better competition if all of the good people are com- competing for the same thing and they've we've managed to eradicate the ones that aren't doing the right thing?

01:51:24 - 01:52:22

Greg Harford

No, because you're not eradicating the people who are not doing the right thing. You are eradicating people who do not um who do not see the value in the compliance requirements around it.

So there are plenty of good businesses out there who fully meet all their health and safety obligations, who choose not to participate in ACT Government procurement work because they do not they do not wish to undertake the compliance requirements of the Secure Local Jobs Code. And I would just say, again, I make the point that if there are workplace health and safety rules, there is a whole statutory framework around dealing with workplace health and safety that is in place now. The Secure Local Jobs Code does not make someone, make a business more safe, it does not make a worker more safe. What is making that worker safe is compliance by the employer with health and safety regulations and enforcement action being taken by WorkSafe where appropriate.

01:52:22 - 01:52:25

Speaker 111

But accidents are still happening.

01:52:25 - 01:52:51

Greg Harford

Accidents do happen, that is correct. And I think employers who have an accident, something's obviously not gone right and no one is no one is out there not training their staff and not complying with health and safety requirements typically. And where you find that there are businesses who that have not complied with health and safety rules, then they tend to be the subject of enforcement action.

01:52:51 - 01:53:05

Yvette Berry

I guess what I'm trying finding hard to understand is why an employer wouldn't want to show that they're doing all the right things by getting a Secure Local Jobs Code, like I don't understand why that would be.

01:53:05 - 01:53:56

Greg Harford

Because the process is bureaucratic, because the process is cumbersome and expensive, and there may be other ways that they can show that. So, for example, a business might well have perfect health and safety record, let's imagine, as part of their response to a tender, I would expect them to be saying to ACT Government, "We have a perfect health and safety record, we've had no accidents, we've had no near misses, we've had no prosecutions." That is absolutely something that they should be celebrating, it's a good thing, and I would expect that would come through a tender process. What you don't need is a separate government process at the front end to try and force people to prove that, when actually they can prove that anyway through their process. It's a compliance and cost issue.

01:53:56 - 01:54:10

James Milligan

Yeah. Thank you, Mr Harford, and on behalf of the committee, we'd like to thank you for taking the time to come along today. Was there any questions taken on notice, do you recall? No? Oh, you're off the hook on that one.

01:54:10 - 01:55:10

Speaker 112

Well, you have a good morning. Thank you. Thank you. We will kick it off five minutes earlier, and that can make you kick off five minutes earlier as well if you want to.

01:55:23 - 01:56:06

James Milligan

I'm sure the committee would be happy to have you here, but we welcome Mr Scott Harris and Anna Neelagama from Master Builders Association. When you speak for the first time, if you could just take your name and your position that you're appearing here on when you first speak. Please note as a witness, you are protected by parliamentary privilege and bound by its obligations. You must tell the truth, giving false or misleading evidence will be treated as a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. Now, because we've got short times, we weren't going to do opening statements.

We're just going to go into questions. You've got one. Are you happy to table it, or do you want to, like, it looks pretty long?

01:56:06 - 01:56:10

Speaker 114

Ah, it's less than three minutes, but it's your call, Chair. I can table it.

01:56:10 - 01:56:13

James Milligan

Well, because we are have started early, go for it.

01:56:13 - 01:56:17

Speaker 115

Anna Neelagama, CEO, Master Builders ACT.

01:56:17 - 01:56:23

Speaker 116

Scott Harris, Director of workplace relations and policy too.

01:56:23 - 01:56:50

Speaker 117

I'll rip through this, I promise. Thank you, Chair and committee members for the opportunity to appear today. We ask our written submission be taken as read. The Productivity Commission has estimated that the annual regulatory burden on the Australia's housing and construction sector is between $18 billion and $47.5 billion. That is a staggering cost for our industry already struggling with declining productivity, tight margins and persistent inflation.

01:56:50 - 01:57:20

Speaker 121

At a time when governments are resource constrained, we should be removing unnecessary regulation, not perpetuating it. We are here today because the case for retaining the secure local jobs code simply has not been made. Our position rests on four key points. Firstly, there is no evidence to justify its continuation. The government has failed to demonstrate through credible monitoring, evaluation, or performance measures that the code delivers meaningful outcomes for workers, businesses, or the community.

01:57:20 - 01:57:46

Speaker 118

In previous inquiries, ministers and officials have been unable to substantiate its effectiveness beyond anecdotal claims. Secondly, the code duplicates existing laws. Workplace health and safety and workplace relations have advanced significantly since its introduction. These obligations are already regulated and should be enforced by existing Commonwealth and territory authorities. More regulation does not mean better outcomes.

01:57:46 - 01:58:19

Speaker 121

Thirdly, the compliance burden is excessive. Our industry is overwhelmingly made up of small- and middle-sized family businesses. The cost of complying with the code simply to compete for government work creates an unnecessary barrier to participation, reduces competition and ultimately increases costs for taxpayers. Fourth, the government itself acknowledges confusion about the code's purpose. If a regulatory framework remains poorly understood after years of operation, that raises fundamental questions about its design, effectiveness and necessity.

01:58:19 - 01:58:49

Speaker 120

The government's own submission repeatedly emphasizes what the code is not, including local industry participation, procurement outcomes, and awarding contracts. This only reinforces the question of what unique outcome the code is achieving. There is also an opportunity cost. In an already resource-constrained government, skilled people are employed to administer this additional layer of regulation. These resources could be redirected elsewhere to areas delivering greater value for the Canberra community.

01:58:49 - 01:59:36

Speaker 119

I want to be very clear. This is not an argument against safe workplaces, fair employment conditions, or responsible procurement. These are non-negotiable. It's an argument for evidence-based regulation, efficient government and taking accountability for the burden on small- and middle-sized businesses. The central question for the inquiry is straightforward.

What does the secure local jobs code achieve that existing workplace laws and regulators do not? Supporters point to individual examples and good intentions, but after years of operation, there remains no evidence demonstrating the code delivers unique outcomes beyond those mechanisms already available.

Until that question can be answered with evidence, the case for retaining the code remains unproven. We thank the committee for its consideration.

01:59:36 - 02:00:06

James Milligan

Excellent, thank you very much. What we'll do is we'll just run through the table here. We'll give each person seven or eight minutes to ask a series of questions. Could be on any topic, but I think that's a more efficient way for us to all be to ask questions if we need to. In your submission, you mention that you would recommend that the code be repealed.

Can you explain what that would change for local businesses? What that would mean if it was repealed?

02:00:06 - 02:00:17

Speaker 119

It would be a reduction in red tape and an increase in productivity, but that productivity would be two-sided because government would no longer have to administer the code. Scott, do you want to supplement that?

02:00:17 - 02:01:10

Scott Harris

Go with Chair at the same time, it's more part as we said in the opening statements on the part is we're not against safe workplaces, best work practice and to go with from there, which is already there from Commonwealth law and Territory law to go with from there. They've got to abide by those rules already, and they've got to put them into place to go with it. It means decreasing a level of regulation and obligations on the small, medium-sized businesses who don't understand what they've got to do, other than make safe workplace and pay their people correctly to go with it. That's what they're concentrating on. So, it's removing one burden from one group of people and from the government too at the same time, which can be reallocated and deliver other services for the community.

That's the main question behind it. We're not against what the code's concept is. It's just how that the code is managed and put into place.

02:01:10 - 02:01:31

James Milligan

So, there seems like there's a duplication of what this code is aiming to achieve under other legislation, whether it be ACT legislation and/or federal government legislation. Are you still confident that if we did remove the code that workers would still be protected under existing legislation?

02:01:31 - 02:01:56

Scott Harris

Yes, Chair, that's a very straightforward, down-the-line yes, because the regulator's obligations and responsibilities is to make those places safe, and ensure that they're being paid correctly and working with the right conditions to go with it, which is not a part of the code's responsibility. It's actually given it off to the regulator to do anyway. It's just a tick-box exercise to say that I've done this. I don't have any problems. So-

02:01:56 - 02:02:34

James Milligan

And, so, obviously, the code applies for, you know, procurement and jobs that the ACT government goes out there with, and using the ACT taxpayers' money for that. There's no difference between any other builder doing a residential job using a client's money to do the job, they're still obliged to provide, you know, the right wages, the right conditions. And there is no difference, and the same legislation that's under ACT and federal applies to them also. So, in other words, there's extra compliance on ACT-procured jobs than what there is for the private sector, but they do the same thing?

02:02:34 - 02:02:40

Speaker 122

That is correct. The same compliance applies for non-government work.

02:02:40 - 02:03:10

James Milligan

For your members, you've got members in the ACT, but also members in New South Wales as part of the MBA. In terms of competitiveness between New South Wales and ACT, how does the ACT compare, particularly on administration and compliance and red tape compared with New South Wales? Are we competitive, or do your clients prefer to work in New South Wales?

02:03:10 - 02:03:47

Speaker 119

I mean the majority of our membership are committed to Canberrans, and they like to build Canberra, and that's what they're here to do, but obviously we have many builders who are licensed dual builders. There's not a Secure Local Jobs Code in New South Wales, I believe. However, but the cost of business is considerably higher in the ACT, simply when you look at insurance costs and payroll costs alone. So, to answer your question, Chair, which is not, I guess, central to the inquiry's purpose, it is more expensive to do business in the ACT.

02:03:47 - 02:04:15

Speaker 121

And I know that the government's submission goes to great pains to point out the code is not here to deliver local procurement outcomes. When you evaluate a local procurement outcome, one of the basic facts is that an ACT business has a lot higher cost to participate in, just simply because of those payroll tax and insurance costs, than others do.

02:04:15 - 02:04:26

James Milligan

You describe builders having to provide similar information through several different processes. Can you give us a practical example of that duplication?

02:04:26 - 02:05:26

Speaker 119

So, when you are competing for government work, you have to go through a pre-qualification process. On certain process project sites, you have to comply with culture and construction. You need to get a secure local jobs code. In certain instances, you're required to have an OFSC accreditation. And for every job, even if you're on a panel, you have to resubmit these documentations every time.

There's no central portal where you can just find that every time. And in every instance, you have to do a Liberty and a local industry participation plan. So, there's, yes, the one-off cost of achieving the various certifications, but then it's the, I guess, the constant reapplication and replication that businesses have to go through. And generally speaking, the procurement process has become a lot more lengthy and less concise over time.

02:05:26 - 02:05:27

Okay, Miss Carrick.

02:05:27 - 02:06:16

Fiona Carrick

Thank you, Chair. With the, it seems to me that there's two bits to all this. There's the certificate, certification process, and then the compliance side of it. So, with respect to the certification, are there any aspects of it that you would keep? Because the weeding out of bad actors in the first place, like we have had evidence of the cleaning industry, for example, where there are, you know, it's a, you know, a lot of migrants in their industry working, and there's about power imbalance, you know, like between the employer and the employee perhaps, and there have been some poor practices.

02:06:16 - 02:06:18

Speaker 124

So, the question is

02:06:18 - 02:06:42

Speaker 121

Again, I would point towards those employers are required to treat people well and pay people legally under existing laws. The world has changed a lot since the original Secure Local Jobs Code was introduced. There is high scrutiny, rightly, on employers to do the right thing by their workers. This is simply a duplication of existing laws and existing regulatory processes.

02:06:42 - 02:07:13

Fiona Carrick

So, on the compliance side then, say there are poor practices in paying people or work health and safety, who goes in, who is responsible? Is it the Commonwealth, or the Registrar, because the Registrar has investigative and compliance and enforcement powers too. So, who goes in the ACT, like who actually does the investigations in that enforcement and the compliance?

02:07:13 - 02:08:09

Scott Harris

Through Miss Carrick, on the side here, first of all, any worksites in these ones here, it's either the FWO's responsibility, or it's WorkSafe's responsibility to be on the site. The union has got their own responsibility to ensure their people who are members are being looked after to go forward from it, same as us as an employer association, it's our own soft application to inform our members that they've got to do the right rules, and follow up from there.

Now, I can't say, and I've not ever heard, of the regulator who's looking after this code ever being on a worksite. I can't even say a person who's got one of these qualifications have brought to my attention they've ever seen the regulator there. But they can tell me when the FWO's been on site. They can tell me when WorkSafe's been on site. They can tell me when the union's been on site, but not this regulator for this piece of paper or this certification has ever turned up there.

02:08:09 - 02:08:37

Speaker 119

And it's a it's a registrar not a regulator, and they have, I think, a fairly limited scope that's limited to the renewal of certificates. So, when we saw the reported underpayment of workers on the Altus traffic, it was only because that certificate is expired. The union was able to discover underpayment of workers. So, in that instance, the Secure Local Jobs Code did nothing for workers.

02:08:37 - 02:08:45

Speaker 126

It stopped work. Which I assume cost some money, a few days stop work.

02:08:45 - 02:08:51

Speaker 125

Okay. So, between WorkSafe, which is an ACT Government body,

02:08:52 - 02:09:01

Speaker 37

and Work Health and Safety, which is a federal one, where does the difference lie there about who actually manages compliance?

02:09:01 - 02:09:33

Scott Harris

Sorry, let's go on that one. There'll be two parts of that one there. One will be whether it's a Commonwealth-funded project too, so that's the OFSC will be a part of those ones for the auditing on those ones. If it's an ACT one, it will be WorkSafe itself to do with work health and safety. But the FWO will have responsibility and obligations across regardless as long as they've met Commonwealth or, sorry, their statutory company obligation, sole trader, partnership, or whatever, the FWO can do the full investigation into it and hold them accountable.

02:09:33 - 02:10:07

Speaker 119

Sorry, can I just supplement that, do you mind? I think generally speaking, and maybe this is a good question for Procurement ACT, with projects, generally speaking, I believe you're also meant to um submit a WHS management plan. So, when they're selecting the best person for the job at the best price, they should be looking through that WHS management plan, which is tailored and targeted to the project and obviously, I guess the best statement of how the employer is going to manage risk for workers on that project.

02:10:07 - 02:10:36

Fiona Carrick

And when it comes to reporting a unsafe workplace or, you know, like a lack of pay, how does that get You know, do WorkSafe and the Commonwealth triage what they can investigate, or do they You know, do some people just slip through the cracks because they're nobody actually investigates them?

02:10:36 - 02:12:35

Scott Harris

Look, I'll go I'll guess from my history and everything else, especially with those organisations, to go with it from there, is I've had it both ways where those organisations will ring us as an employer association, and say, "We've just received a complaint against one of your members," or a potential member to go with it there, "We're about to go on-site and do the investigation to go with it from there. We would like you to come along." So, this is all the relationship. Ninety per cent of the time is, the first time you hear about it is when one of your members will ring up and say, "I've got a regulator on-site at the moment, it could be Work Health and Safety, or the FWO, or the unions are what have I got to do? What's my obligations?

What's my responsibility?" And we walk them through what is their obligations, responsibilities, and provide the information, not deny not denying entry to the workplace, to go with it from there, and walk them through to show them that they're actually following the best practice. Secondly, if there's a If there's an accident on-site, that site where the accident occurs is shut down.

That is the rules to go with it. You've got to report it within 24 hours, even quicker to WorkSafe. And you've got an investigator standing on your doorstep saying, "What went on? Where's my paperwork to go with it? What's happening from there?"

Between 15 minutes to an hour, I'll have a work health and safety inspector on one of my sites. If I've appraised a complaint about them not doing the right thing, then if the union raises a complaint about them not being safe, the site will have a work health and safety inspector there to look through what's going on: paperwork, who's been trained, who's not been trained, are the right people doing the job? It is highly regulated to go on that part of the industry. This document we're talking about here is just a supplementary to all that, and it's just taking more time and moving resources.

People doing this one here could actually go back and do work health and safety. They could be working on pay rates and everything else to go with it from there, making the government's money be go better on that side.

02:12:35 - 02:12:37

Speaker 127

Thank you.

02:12:37 - 02:13:24

Jo Clay

Thanks, Chair. The CFMEU, in their submission, put in some data, and you may or may not have had a look at it, but they are saying that the costs of construction haven't increased since the secure local jobs code came in. And what they specifically said is non-residential building costs in the ACT went up by 8.8% from 2020 to now, but around Australia it went up by 37%, and residential went up by 7% here in the ACT, but around Australia it went up by 34%. Do you that's that doesn't match what you've said about our costs going up here. Do you know what's going on with, you know, two different sets of data there?

02:13:24 - 02:13:58

Speaker 119

I couldn't speak to that data, but I think the data that this committee needs to look at is any government project that's been delivered and see whether costs have increased there. I would note the CFMEU submission also points out that there is little public information on how the code is operating, and there's no publicly available data on how code-covered work is structured for employees. So, the CFMEU themselves acknowledge some serious shortcomings and lack of evidence when it comes to the code.

02:13:58 - 02:14:11

Jo Clay

Yep. Yeah, this was one of the other aspects of your submission. You wanted to have a lot more public evidence and public data on the secure local jobs code. Can you tell me specifically what you reckon government should be making public?

02:14:11 - 02:14:57

Speaker 119

So, if you look at the government submission, they go to great lengths to detail the number of visits, audits and investigations. What they cannot do is justify better outcomes in safety, in workplace relations and things like payroll compliance, enhanced outcomes in procurement, and better outcomes for workers, whether they're construction workers or any other workers covered in code activities. So, I really think we need to be looking at the outcome, not just the amount of activity generated from the registrar's office. And you know, many third-party organizations were really only able to produce anecdotal evidence of, you know, the good, the bad, the ugly when it came to the code.

02:14:57 - 02:15:23

Speaker 61

Yep, no, fair point. You also said that if uh you would like the code to be abolished, but you said if it's not abolished, government should implement Operation Kingfisher recommendation that compliance is solely determined by the registrar. Can you talk me through you think the registrar needs more independence and the ability to not have anybody tell them what to do?

02:15:23 - 02:15:45

Speaker 119

That's correct. Operation Kingfisher was very focused on the independence of the registrar, but frankly, case has not been made for the code to be retained. It is not doing anything for workers, and it's not doing anything for local businesses, and it's consuming government resources.

02:15:45 - 02:16:40

Jo Clay

Yeah. In terms of local procurement, this is a really interesting point. So, the answers from government, the answers from government under on questions on notice show that six years ago, 54% of ACT government procurement was being spent locally. And frankly, 54% doesn't sound like that much for ACT government spend. That's now dropped to 34%.

So, it's it has that actually has decreased. Government knows that's decreased. They've got the data on that, too. So, do you think government, do you think there are benefits in government money being spent in a way that is sending more of that to local businesses and local residents, and keeping more of that wealth circulating within our community rather than the trajectory we're on at the moment where more of our local more of our ACT government spend is going to non-local businesses?

02:16:40 - 02:17:56

Speaker 119

Absolutely, everybody wins in that instance, including the government's payroll receipts. Every time an interstate or multinational wins, the territory actually loses from its coffers. But the government submission was really interesting, because it said that the code there's confusion about the code and it's not here to deliver this local economic outcomes, but the code actually specifically states that there's a relationship with the Local Industry Participation Plan. In order for the Local Industry Participation Plan, which must be submitted with every tender, that needs to be tied to the procurement contract, which is not currently required to do, and for the head contractor to be held accountable to the Local Industry Participation targets. And that's on every project.

That's from major projects downwards. But, I mean, it just makes perfect sense to be offering local work to local businesses, who, you know, as we've as we've seen in some recent inquiries, are can do the job. They submit the best tender, and they submit the best tender with the best value for money.

02:17:56 - 02:18:46

Jo Clay

Yes. And then sometimes they don't win that tender. And we heard from the Canberra Business Chamber that, and we haven't verified this yet, but that New South Wales government may have changed their procurement weightings to give more weight to local tenderers. And we discussed this and the view was that if the ACT made changes to our procurement system to benefit locals, that matched changes the New South Wales government has made, they'd be unlikely to be any negative consequences of that. They would you know, we wouldn't we wouldn't have New South Wales government not want to send work our way.

We wouldn't we wouldn't have any cross-border issues. Does it sound like we should be looking at some of the tools New South Wales and Victoria are using to encourage local procurement spend and perhaps seeing if we can match those in the ACT?

02:18:47 - 02:19:49

Scott Harris

Just going to sit back and explain on that one is, New South Wales councils have had this in place for years. It's a part of the tendering process where they actually give the local community, it's a 15% or 20% weighting on their assessment when they look at RFTs to go with from it, and it's been in the councils for years. It does work, but it always keeps coming back to the one question, it's no problems giving it to a local person, but has the local person got the right capacity, capability, skills and everything else to do with it? I'm very strong to give it and retain the money locally, but there's still got to be value for money for the government, too, in doing that service.

So, it might be better to go external instead of internal on that type of arrangements. But it's always been there, is where the local people have always had a heavier weighting, at least I know in New South Wales because I was part of local councils over there, that if you were a local person, you're weighted a little bit heavier than anybody else coming in.

02:19:49 - 02:19:52

Speaker 129

And do we have that weighting in our procurement system, do you know?

02:19:52 - 02:19:54

Speaker 131

My understanding, and this is only my understanding,

02:19:54 - 02:20:05

Scott Harris

there is a small weighting that is put to locals in there.

Procurement people will be able to give you a more damn finish, but there is supposed to be a weighting in that process.

02:20:05 - 02:21:04

Jo Clay

Yep, I'll ask them. The other really useful piece of feedback we've had from witnesses and evidence in submissions is that, yes, we have a federal system of IR laws, and, yes, that system has changed and improved since 2020. But actually accessing rights under that system is quite difficult. And the specific examples we were given was of refugee and migrant cleaners, and for them to enforce their rights in the federal court, it took several years. There was a $300,000 award of damages.

It came years later. One of their members had died before receiving the award, and they of course needed to get union advice, legal advice, and representation in order to access those rights. So, is there a benefit in having something that is ACT at the outset of the procurement that is, you know, intended to avoid those sorts of breaches from coming up in the first place?

02:21:04 - 02:21:27

Speaker 119

There is nothing stopping government as the client requesting things like payroll records throughout the course of the delivery of project to check that workers have not been underpaid. We do not need a whole separate compliance framework on top of that, which really only looks at compliance around renewals, not through the life of the project which is being delivered for the territory.

02:21:28 - 02:21:40

Speaker 119

So, a sort of system of random audits, good employment employers do not mind participating in that to avoid outcomes that you're describing.

02:21:40 - 02:22:09

Jo Clay

Yep. And do you think we'd benefit from some more proactive ACT government publication of the results? You've talked about the publication of the outcomes of secure local jobs. We could have publication of tracking the proportion of work that's going to local industry, so we don't have to sort of, you know, ask parliamentary questions to try and tease out the data. Are there aspects where you think a proactive government report each year or some proactive tracking and publication of the results would help?

02:22:09 - 02:22:46

Speaker 119

Look, I think there's great merit in a quarterly report to the parliament on how local businesses and local workforce are being supported. And I think that's part of what's missed with the code in particular. Anyone can win government work provided they have a certificate, which means crews can be imported from Newcastle, Melbourne, Perth. And that procurement process is not actually looking, "Are we building the workforce of the future locally?" These people come, they deliver the project, they get paid living-away-from-home allowances, and then they leave.

02:22:46 - 02:22:47

And they leave.

02:22:47 - 02:23:17

Speaker 119

And the current procurement system and the grading in the awarding of tenders does not take into account how local employers are developing their workforce and indeed the benefit local workers might get on working of certain projects of distinction in the local economy. So, that's something that's really a lost opportunity not only in the Secure Local Jobs Code, but elsewhere in the procurement framework.

02:23:17 - 02:23:19

James Milligan

Thank you. Ms Berry.

02:23:19 - 02:24:16

Yvette Berry

Thank you.

I just had a question. You just talked about people coming into town and then leaving, and that there's a measure that suggests that in the ACT there's a lot of people that come and go from jobs in the ACT.

But a lot of those would also be like single-people businesses, right? Like architects, or some other person that's at the top of the workforce chain, I guess, not so much the worker bees down the bottom. 'Cause that's measured as well, right?

So, if there's like at the start of a project 15 individual businesses, but it's only one or two-person businesses, that sort of inflates the number of people moving in and out of town. I'm just trying to get to the bottom of that number. Like, are you saying that like people a whole bunch of people leave, but

it might be just those businesses at the top at the start of the project?

02:24:16 - 02:24:27

Speaker 119

Look, I couldn't provide any evidence to sort of say they're the smaller, local contractors. Generally speaking, I would say they're more crews.

02:24:27 - 02:24:51

Yvette Berry

Yeah, I'm not talking about the crews. I'm talking about like the, I don't know, the people at the top that are doing their architectural work or a particular piece of consulting for a business on a job, you know, that they might be very small organizations. They might not be local, but they'd still be counted in the movement,

which might inflate the numbers of movement on jobs in the ACT?

02:24:51 - 02:26:11

Scott Harris

Look, again, Ms Berry, on that one, it is a hard question to answer because you've hit on a part is where you're actually looking for specialist skill sets and capability, which may not be local. You have to bring them in for external to go with it, but because that particular skill's not there, yes, and you will have inflated because people coming in and out to go with it from there, but they're specialisations to go with it from there. I'd prefer, from an experienced point of view, is to grow our people locally. So, if you got an RTO local, you'd use the local people to do with it from there, and they grow their workforce by putting more people on from that side of it.

I'm not against somebody having to bring in a specialist to do something to go with it from there, and we all need them at times. But why not use that specialist to grow our internal skill sets and make it so they retain them here? So therefore, the government doesn't have to go looking somewhere else, they can actually do it locally, too, at the same time. Then it probably would remove that potential thing of in and out at the senior levels. But I do know, from personal experience,

your lawyers, your architects, your senior-type people do float in and out because that's what they need for a set project only, for a very small part of the time. There's no use trying to keep them on staff for the whole project because it's not adding value. Yeah.

02:26:11 - 02:26:23

Yvette Berry

Sorry, I know that was a bit of a random question. I just remembered seeing that data somewhere and just going, well, hang on a minute, it's not just workers. I mean, everyone, the worker, but, you know, it's not just the, you know, on the ground, construction.

02:26:23 - 02:26:46

Scott Harris

I agree with Ms Berry that at the same time that's the one we hear from our members a lot, is about not at the senior levels, that the bottom levels, where full crews are coming in to do work and then those full crews are leaving again, which yeah you may need to, because you might not have the workforce on the ground to do it. And you've got to breed from somewhere else to help you with, from this.

02:26:46 - 02:27:19

Yvette Berry

Do your members tell talk to you about people that or organizations that are not complying with the various regulations that are required? 'Cause remember, you went into a bit of detail about it before. I just wondered like, is there a bit of, you know, word on the town about particular organizations?

I'll be honest, I'm not asking you to make No. That I'll go very clear, Ms Berry, on that side is, if I find a member who's not doing the right things and won't fix the problems that we've discussed with them to fix it,

02:27:19 - 02:28:04

Scott Harris

I'll throw them under the bus, which a lot of other people, too, will do the same type of thing is, because it's reputational, it's providing the right services, it's getting the right people in the roles, and that and recognising employees work hard.

Most of them do, I'll go with that, most do, but you need to reward them by paying them correctly, giving them the right entitlements from there. That's what my job is to educate the employer to make sure that's happened, and they're doing it.

If they don't want to follow that rule and don't want to do it, I will have a discussion with the regulator about having an inspection to go in there on the spot. And both, I'll use them both, as WorkSafe safety and FWO like it when we help them with them to do their jobs, too.

02:28:04 - 02:28:30

Yvette Berry

And the Secure Local Jobs Code, I guess, goes to that where a employer or business can have that as, you know, when a member of the MBA stickers, or whatever, on the back of their cars, they can have their, you know, Secure Local Jobs sticker saying that they're compliant with all the regulations across the board, and that's been proven for ACT government projects. I mean, that could be a good thing for them, as well.

02:28:30 - 02:29:38

Speaker 119

Again, I think it comes back to the evidence. I think the Secure Local Jobs Code has had various instances where we've seen that it's quite easy for an out-of-town company or a multinational to obtain a certificate and do work, even if they're unable to perform work on government sites elsewhere. That to me is not a sign of a system that's supporting the best and the most local and the most ethical employers. That shows me that the system is failing. Second thing is duplication: we're all busy, government's busy, government's under-resourced,

this takes up resources on both sides of the procurement equation, and we can't demonstrate that we're actually getting anything for that. And the third is just the regulatory burden on small- and middle-sized businesses, mostly family businesses, but then also I note the various submissions from the community sector and, indeed, volunteer school committees that have to be code-compliant. So, I think we've just got to look at this in a very evidence-based way.

02:29:38 - 02:30:09

Yvette Berry

And I don't think I mean, I don't think any of us have a problem with, you know, understanding the code and making it, or from my perspective, anyway, making sure that it's meeting our community's needs. And I think your suggestions that you've made today are worthy. I just, you know, note that, you know, regulations and laws are being broken all the time by lots of different organizations, and the Secure Local Jobs Code goes to try and bring all of those together into one place. And I'm sorry, I'm probably arguing with you now, and I don't shouldn't do that, but—

02:30:09 - 02:31:07

Speaker 119

The code in itself does not make a business more ethical. It just means that they comply at a point in time of certification, and then it's a set and forget until renewal. The registrar, as Scott pointed out, does not go out on site and provide any quality assurance back to the government on WHS practices or workplace relations practices. All it does is certify compliance at a point in time.

That means anyone applying for government work, those large multinationals, those big businesses that have compliance officers, are automatically at an unfair advantage, because they can live and breathe this. The small- and middle-sized businesses are putting an excessive amount of time and cost and lost productivity that they could reinvest into better workplace relations and better safety practices. So, the code in itself does not make businesses more ethical.

02:31:07 - 02:31:17

Yvette Berry

And it's a good point because that's what witnesses have been telling us: that there needs to be checks and balances along the way, not just a tick and flick at the start.

02:31:17 - 02:31:23

James Milligan

Thank you, Ms Berry. Thank you, Ms Neelagama and Mr Harris for coming in.

02:31:23 - 02:31:26

Speaker 135

Was there any questions taken on notice?

02:31:26 - 02:31:26

Not aware of, Chair.

02:31:27 - 02:31:33

James Milligan

Happy to answer more though. All right, I won't have to go through that section then, but you guys have a very good afternoon. Thank you very much.

02:31:34 - 02:31:34

Thanks, Chair.

02:31:35 - 02:33:21

Speaker 112

Thank you.

02:33:21 - 02:34:01

James Milligan

protected by parliamentary privilege and bound by its obligations, you must tell the truth, giving false or misleading evidence will be treated as a serious matter and may be considered contempt of the Assembly. Did you have an opening statement? No, excellent, so we can get straight into it. What I'll what I'll do is I'll give each member 10 to 15 minutes at a time and they can ask a whole series of questions on any substantive matter.

I think it's more efficient to do it that way. I'll start off. What is the present legal and operational status of Union's ACT procurement MOU?

02:34:01 - 02:34:04

Rachel Stephen-Smith

The MOU has been terminated by agreement of both parties.

02:34:04 - 02:34:37

James Milligan

It has been terminated. Okay. Just get into my next question. Minister, a central concern raised by industry is that compliance requirements increase the cost of doing government projects. Has the government undertaken any comparison of procurement costs before and after the introduction of the code?

02:34:37 - 02:34:49

Robert Wright

Robert Wright, Deputy Director-General, Office of Industrial Relations and Workplace Strategy, and I'm also the Registrar of the Secure Local Jobs Code. I'm unaware of a comparison being undertaken.

02:34:49 - 02:35:15

James Milligan

Okay. Your own discussion paper acknowledges concern about duplication requirements between the Secure Local Jobs Code, ethical treatment of workers evaluation, and other government procurement processes. Has the government undertaken a detailed assessment of which requirements are duplicated with existing workplace laws and or procurement obligations?

02:35:15 - 02:36:21

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Well, I think the purpose of the review that the discussion paper was the first stage of was to have a look at those things.

The Statement of Procurement Values came in after the Secure Local Jobs Code, and the ethical, as did the Ethical Treatment of Workers process in the way that it is currently implemented. Of course, the ACT Government has already, always had a commitment to ensuring that workers are treated appropriately and their rights are upheld. And I think that goes to your pardon me, other point, Chair, is that, in terms of duplication with existing laws, the point of the Secure Local Jobs Code is to get an upfront pardon me, certification that tenderers, organisations that are intending to tender for ACT Government work, are compliant with their legal obligations.

02:36:21 - 02:36:29

James Milligan

You're making me cough. You can take a breath if you want. If you've got someone else that wants to step in, feel free to.

02:36:29 - 02:36:54

Robert Wright

Yes, so I should, apologies Chair, that I have read and acknowledged the privilege statement. So, in terms of looking at this, we are, the government is committed to taking independent review of the code, and will now be progressed following the current committee inquiry.

02:36:54 - 02:37:33

James Milligan

You're making me cough. I apologize, it's allergies, it's pollen. Unless someone brought something in here just to throw us off too, I'm not sure. Figures provided to the Assembly on notice show that 83.5% of the value of 13 major project contracts awarded in 2024-25 and 25-26 went to head contractors with registered addresses outside of the Canberra region. What proportion of the ACT Government construction procurement went to local head contractors before the code was introduced compared to today?

02:37:33 - 02:39:13

Rachel Stephen-Smith

I'm not sure if anybody has those figures, but I would say I'm not sure that in any case it would be an apples to apples comparison, given the number of significant major projects that have been undertaken in the ACT since the introduction of the Secure Local Jobs Code. So, obviously, we've always built schools and health facilities, but the Canberra Hospital expansion, the light rail project, the theatre project, the light rail stage 2A project and the New Northside Hospital project and the CIT project are all major projects of much larger scale than most previous ACT Government construction procurements. And tier one contractors do tend not to be headquartered in the ACT. So, I it is really important to recognise that isn't necessarily the apples to apples comparison that you would draw. Part of the question is what are the local participation requirements of those tier one contractors?

So, the Local Industry Participation Policy, which is separate to Secure Local Jobs Code, specifically requires contractors, major contractors to engage local companies as subcontractors. That wouldn't necessarily be captured in the procurement data that you're talking about. Having said that, I'll hand over to Mr Wright or Mrs Lukins.

02:39:13 - 02:40:06

Robert Wright

Yeah, so I'll start off, and then I might throw to you, just around some of the data, Mrs Lukins. So, I think it's important to note the code is not designed to directly support the awarding of ACT contracts to local businesses.

Rather, it seeks to create a level playing field for businesses applying for territory-funded work, and to encourage fairer, better, and more secure local jobs for workers. So, the specific procurement policies and processes that the minister referred to, such as the Canberra Region Local Industry Participation Policy, or LIPP, are managed separately from the code, and support the awarding of businesses, sorry, contracts to local businesses. The LIPP applies to all approaches to market by territory entities, and was implemented from 1 January 2017.

02:40:06 - 02:40:45

Ellen Lukins

Ellen Lukins, Executive Branch Manager, Policy in Work Safety Group. Acknowledge I have read the privacy statement. In terms of the code and what we know about code certified entities and local, so there's around 2,400 code certified entities, I think as at 30 June 2026, there were 2,396. If we look at those code certified entities, around 57% were ACT-based entities. So that is just over half of those entities.

02:40:45 - 02:41:02

Speaker 140

Around 36% were New South Wales-based. And in terms of the size of those, around 70% of those are entities with less than 20 employees, so small to medium.

02:41:02 - 02:41:21

James Milligan

This morning we heard calls from union representatives calling for the government to fund the cost of compliance with the secure local jobs code for small community organisations. Is this something the government is considering, or thought about, or looking into?

02:41:21 - 02:41:23

Speaker 139

Sorry, Mr Milligan, I just missed that. Would you mind repeating that?

02:41:23 - 02:41:38

James Milligan

From union representatives today, they suggested that the government fund the cost of compliance for the secure local jobs code for small community organisations. Is that something that you've considered?

02:41:38 - 02:45:03

Rachel Stephen-Smith

It's not something that has explicitly been considered. It would be part of doing business with the ACT Government. A lot of community organisations in the contracts that they enter into, they would be primarily contracts for labour, and in some cases, they would also be considered to have a relatively vulnerable workforce. Of course, ACT Government would does expect, as and this was part of the Counting the Cost report, that our non-government organisation partners are tendering or entering into commissioning processes reflecting the full cost of delivering services, and that includes the regulatory costs. And I think it is important to understand depending on what sector you're talking about, if you're talking about human services sector, for example, non-government organisation, the cost of Secure Local Jobs Code certification would be not substantial compared to the cost of some of the other regulatory requirements that those organisations have.

And so part of the ongoing conversation with our community sector is, how do we ensure that they are able to reflect the cool full cost of delivering quality services when they are engaged with ACT Government commissioning or procurement processes? And so, in that way, when we then pay the full cost of delivery of service, if we can get to that point, we would in we in effect be funding the cost of becoming secure local jobs certified. The other point that I would make is that one of the questions that we've asked in the discussion paper, I think, and one of the things that we've discussed is whether the threshold for procurements is the correct threshold, given the threshold, which I think is $200,000, is was set when the code was established in 2018.

And so, whether that threshold for all procurements should be reviewed. And then the third thing I would say in relation to that is there is some flexibility in relation to grant program, so if it's a relatively small amount of money and it's a, and it's been delivered through a grant, some organisations wouldn't be required to have secure local jobs certification. Sometimes directorates are using that as an assurance to be assured that the providers are in fact meeting their workplace relations and industrial relations obligations, their fair work obligations. It is really important to us that our non-government partners also meet those obligations to their workers. And so, and I also am aware that at least one other non-government organisation has required secure local jobs certification for its own construction project, despite not being required to by law, because they wanted to be assured that company, that the company they were engaging was meeting their ethical obligations.

02:45:03 - 02:46:16

Robert Wright

Mr Milligan, one of the pieces there that were particularly interested in as part of the review is where we have multi-year projects, where the 200,000, yeah, particularly for community sector organisations, over so a five-year contract, you know, becomes a lot you know, like, less in terms of the value over that prolonged period. So, that is one of the things we'll be looking at as part of that independent review. I'd also note that the indicative costs for those micro businesses are lower than what is applied to larger businesses, for the audit of these. So, we're looking between $565 and $1,000 for micro businesses, $970 to $1,750 for small businesses, 5 to 20 employees, whereas for the large businesses you know like that can go, you know like on average up to $3,500.

So, there are different rates supplied for smaller organisations, but as I said, that you know period of which the procurement runs over is something that we will definitely be looking at.

02:46:16 - 02:46:17

Okay. Ms Carrick.

02:46:17 - 02:46:56

Fiona Carrick

Thank you. It seems to me that there's different aspects of the secure local jobs code. There's the certificate at the beginning and the, you know, the different views about the, on the one hand, the cost of compliance, and the time, and the energy, and that it's not worthwhile, and then on the other hand, that it weeds out bad actors right at the beginning, so they don't tender for the jobs. How many people that apply for secure local jobs code certificate are rejected?

02:46:56 - 02:47:32

Jordan James

Jordan James, Senior Director, Workplace Legislation and Policy, and I've read and understood the privilege statement. That's not something that we have great visibility over because of the way the auditing is done. In order to get a certificate, you're required to receive an audit that says you've met the requirements of the code, and so those auditors manage that before it even gets to us for a decision. They can submit a form to us saying that this business hasn't met the requirement, but we don't always get it.

So it's a hard piece of data to be able to give a confident number on at the moment.

02:47:32 - 02:47:46

Speaker 142

Interesting. Okay. So Yeah, like I mean, well they're saying that they can't get the data because the auditor weeds them out before they even get to the Registrar.

02:47:46 - 02:47:58

Jordan James

The auditors are external to the ACT Government. They're private businesses and they manage that on behalf of the Registrar doing that function. And then, it's not necessarily reported to us when a business doesn't make the requirements.

02:47:58 - 02:48:00

Speaker 148

So

02:48:00 - 02:48:45

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Well, can I just say, I mean, there's I'm just interested if there's an There's an opportunity for businesses also to, they're obviously not going to make the requirements if they've been repeatedly found to be in breach by going to Fair Work Commission. But if the audit finds that they are in fact in breach and they rectify that is an opportunity for businesses to improve the way that they are doing things. And one of the things we certainly heard anecdotally early on was that the audit process itself was valuable for some SME businesses and non-government organisations, because it provided them with an assurance that they were doing the right thing in what can be quite a complex environment.

02:48:45 - 02:49:15

Fiona Carrick

So could is it possible to take it on notice the Registrar's understanding of how many businesses may not be successful in getting the certificate? Because, you know, the we have people complaining that this is burdensome and what is the outcome of it all? What is the benefit of it all? And if we don't know, if everybody just gets it, the certificate, or if we don't know how many people don't get it just doesn't provide very good evidence for why we have it.

02:49:15 - 02:49:17

Speaker 146

We can take it on notice, Ms Carrick.

02:49:17 - 02:50:03

Fiona Carrick

Okay, thank you. So onto the compliance side of it, the Registrar has got investigative powers and enforcement powers. But the this is another, you know, like polarization in people's thoughts about the whole thing. Some people think, like presumably that's good, other people think that is, there's already it's a duplicate and there's already other legislation that manages that compliance side of it.

So how often does the Registrar use his compliance powers and what outcomes have there been on investigations and enforcement?

02:50:03 - 02:51:31

Robert Wright

So I might start off, Ms Carrick. So primarily with the code matters, we are looking to leverage from decisions of administrative bodies, such as Fair Work Ombudsman, where there've been decisions, a breach of industrial law, which are publicly available. We're also interested in breaches of WHS law by WorkSafe ACT and other similar entities. And they're the decisions that we're basing the majority of determinations around businesses from. So in terms of investigations, just bring those numbers up.

So I always find in these hearings that my moving from glasses to glasses is All right. So in the 25-26 financial year, there were 33 Registrar-initiated investigations and

02:51:31 - 02:51:34

Speaker 147

in terms of

02:51:34 - 02:51:37

Speaker 145

Is that's public somewhere? Is that in a

02:51:37 - 02:51:42

Speaker 144

It is attached to this, the ACT government submission, so,

02:51:42 - 02:51:44

Speaker 154

Yeah. Sorry to interrupt.

02:51:44 - 02:51:51

Speaker 153

Keep going.

02:51:51 - 02:52:06

Fiona Carrick

And so 33 registrar-initiated investigations, and why weren't they then forwarded on to WorkSafe or other, um, regulators?

02:52:06 - 02:52:36

Robert Wright

So, we do, you know, like, forward on where there've been, uh, we believe there may be breaches of the code to those organisations. So, but they're a lot of reasons for, you know, like, a registrar-initiated investigation, and not all, you know, like, of those might be things that pertain to, you know, like, Fair Work Ombudsman or the WorkSafe ACT.

02:52:36 - 02:53:03

Fiona Carrick

So, can you tell which ones where there's a gap in the Commonwealth law or the WorkSafe ACT, you know, other laws apart from the registrar, where there's a gap where that registrar will need to step in and do the compliance work? Because other jurisdictions don't have a Secure Local Jobs Code. So, where is the gap in the ACT that the registrar has to step in?

02:53:03 - 02:53:50

Ellen Lukins

I'm happy to start. So, if we look at the dashboard information that is attached to the submission, it, you can look to see where the sections of the code being breached, are alleged to be breached, are being investigated. So, that's what the split between the different sections and obligations under the code. That might be where there are requirements to have subcontractors certified. The relevant one to the question that you're asking about, um, compliance with industrial legis laws or prescribed legislation, uh, is the section 11, um, compliance.

And that is highlighted, you can see the purple bits in that dashboard on the top right, um, and it indicates, uh, where you're seeing specific noncompliance with, um, industrial laws.

02:53:51 - 02:53:53

Speaker 150

In the code.

02:53:53 - 02:54:24

Fiona Carrick

I'm still not clear why, if it's industrial laws, the registrar would investigate. Like, I can understand if the registrar would investigate compliance with the certificate, so a subcontractor doesn't have a certificate, so that would be the registrar's role to investigate that noncompliance. But if it's actually an industrial law, um, why wouldn't the registrar pass that on to the regulator of the industrial law?

02:54:24 - 02:54:39

Ellen Lukins

So that's where they would be referred to relevant authorities where those matters are coming back, coming up, and, um, it, through complaints that the, uh, registrar receives, um, where it is noncompliance with an industrial law, that's where those matters are referred to the relevant regulatory authority.

02:54:39 - 02:54:45

Fiona Carrick

So, fundamentally the registrar's compliance role is around the certificate.

02:54:45 - 02:54:48

Speaker 152

The code and its requirements, yes.

02:54:48 - 02:55:34

Rachel Stephen-Smith

And on the, there are ongoing requirements, so it's not only about the initial certification. There are ongoing requirements to stay compliant with the requirements, so, correct me if I'm wrong, but as an example, if there is an allegation that, um, a provider is not compliant with the law, the investigation that the registrar might undertake is, well, is that true? What evidence is there before the Fair Work Commission that the contractor has been breaching the law?

And then if there is evidence that they have been breaching the law, that's an investigation that's been done by that regulator, but there would be consequences in terms of sanctions under the Code.

02:55:34 - 02:55:56

Fiona Carrick

So the register the regulators, Fair Work, WorkSafe, do they have registers, public registers of who has breached their regulations or the law, breached the law? Like, can you see who has breached the law from the regulators that regulate this all this stuff?

02:55:56 - 02:56:00

Speaker 151

Yes, we can, Ms Carrick. Those decisions are usually public.

02:56:00 - 02:56:11

Fiona Carrick

So why, when you're doing a procurement, wouldn't you just look up the regulators and see who's in breach?

02:56:11 - 02:57:11

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Well, I mean, to start with, that would require every entity that's undertaking a procurement to separately go and look up all of the Fair Work Commission, for example, rulings in relation to all of the companies that have tendered. So that potentially ends up being quite duplicative. So part of the reason to do a certification process is that it's do it once and then have a central point of contact to ensure that compliance with the Code is maintained. But also, there may be actions that are currently in train, commencing before the Fair Work Commission, where there isn't necessarily a finding and it wouldn't necessarily be public, but the auditor may be able to identify that there are risks associated with that. Or the auditor may be able to identify something that hasn't, that legal action hasn't yet been taken on.

02:57:11 - 02:57:50

Fiona Carrick

Because one of the complaints is it's a bit of a set and forget, you get your certificate and then nothing much happens after that until you have to renew it again, and that there is no ongoing, you know, proactive compliance, like that there's no reporting back by the companies that they are still compliant. So how do you ensure that they don't get their certificate, become non-compliant, and then nobody looks up? You know, they might become non-compliant by Fair Work or WorkSafe, they might be on some register, but nobody even sees that because they've got their certificate.

02:57:50 - 02:58:29

Jordan James

So there are a range of mechanisms that we and the Registrar proactively monitor. The way the Code is structured, a lot of responsibility is put on the head contractor, who's in contract with the territory. So a lot of our engagement is often with the head contractor, looking at the subcontractors that are engaged. We engage with the contract managers in the background to look at that and monitor. We have a complaints mechanism which allows for anyone to submit a complaint where there may be concerns about an entity that's been non-compliant, and we'll then take relevant action.

So there's a range of proactive mechanisms that the Registrar and the compliance team undertake to monitor that.

02:58:29 - 02:58:43

Fiona Carrick

All right. Well, perhaps you could take that on notice and tell us what they are, because we have heard from other witnesses that there is no reporting back from the companies to the Registrar about compliance or about anything.

02:58:43 - 02:58:55

Jordan James

It will vary, depending on whether they are a subcontractor or whether they're a head contractor, how often they're engaged in territory-funded work. But, yes, we can take on notice to provide more information on that.

02:58:55 - 02:59:08

Fiona Carrick

I've just got one more. How much does the Secure Local Jobs, that team, how many are in that team and how much does it cost?

02:59:08 - 02:59:30

Ellen Lukins

Happy to start with that. So, in the SLJC team, there's around 10 10 to 12 FTE, that's a head count, including myself, as well as Shane and Registrar. So, it is quite a small team. It's It has a senior director that leads the team and then is structured into compliance officers that sit under the senior leader.

02:59:30 - 02:59:42

Fiona Carrick

So, how does how many compliance, out of the 10 to 12, what are sort of administrative or certificate-based and compliance?

02:59:42 - 02:59:44

Speaker 155

I'll hand over to Jordan.

02:59:44 - 03:00:17

Jordan James

Yeah. So, it's a multiskilled team, so the compliance officers perform, essentially perform all of the functions, reviewing certificates, undertaking investigations and assessments. So, there is currently four ASO6 positions that are those compliance officers with the senior officers sitting above that. They are required to hold a certificate for in government investigations as our baseline qualification to support the functions that we do from a compliance and investigations perspective.

03:00:17 - 03:00:20

Speaker 156

Thank you. Thank you.

03:00:20 - 03:00:33

Speaker 160

Operation Kingfisher covered the issue of the independence of the Registrar. Have you got any views on whether you think the Registrar needs to be independent, whether you think that's functioning well?

03:00:33 - 03:00:39

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Registrar is legislatively independent and cannot be directed by the Director-General or a minister.

03:00:39 - 03:00:48

Speaker 158

Yep. And did you engage with recommendations of Operation Kingfisher, do you think in practice they are operating in a truly independent manner, or would they

03:00:48 - 03:00:54

Speaker 159

There was nothing in Operation Kingfisher that indicated that the Registrar was not operating in an independent manner.

03:00:54 - 03:01:05

Jo Clay

Okay. Okay, thank you. So, the government is not looking at whether in practical terms that registrar needs to be a statutory independent role?

03:01:05 - 03:01:29

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Well, not to my no, not to my knowledge, but and there's a I mean, I guess that's something that the committee can give some consideration to, and it would obviously be something that would potentially come up in the review as well. I mean, noting that we are doing, you know, we are about to undertake a review, we wouldn't be preempting that by making structural changes without some evidence to support that.

03:01:29 - 03:01:42

Jo Clay

Yep, great. And can I just check, Mr Wright, what capacity are you appearing here today? You're listed on our sheet as appearing as the Deputy Director-General. Are you appearing as the Deputy Director-General or as Registrar or as both?

03:01:42 - 03:01:57

Robert Wright

Look, I obviously, I hold both those roles, Ms Clay, so, you know, I am here primarily in my function as the Registrar of Secure Local Jobs, but I am also the Deputy Director-General of Office of Industrial Relations and Workforce Strategy.

03:01:57 - 03:02:45

Jo Clay

Thank you. We heard quite a lot of evidence from people in the community sector and also some people in smaller organizations that compliance with the secure local jobs code is more onerous for smaller organizations than it is for large organizations, just that an organization of two or three or four people that has to obtain a certificate has a different compliance burden than an organization of a thousand. We've had two responses to that. Some organizations are calling for more exemptions for the community sector or for certain organizations, and others are calling for a simpler administrative pathway for certain organizations in sectors and of a size and for more help from government. Have you had any feedback on that?

03:02:45 - 03:02:48

Speaker 157

Have you got any thoughts on that issue?

03:02:48 - 03:04:09

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Yes, I will obviously, the we talked earlier about the threshold for the value of procurements or commissioning processes that the code applies to. It is important to recognize that secure local job code certification is only required for procurements that relate primarily to the delivery of labour. So, very small organizations with only a few employees would be unlikely to be require to be participating in tender processes that are primarily for the provision of labour unless those tenders were quite small. So, that is one of the considerations, is recognizing that there probably are a number of very small organizations that have potentially been captured by that 200,000 threshold, given that it is for a single contract rather than per annum.

So, that's really, I think, where one of the things that we would be looking at, rather than exempting businesses or organisations of a certain size. But it's certainly, again, a piece of feedback that we would look at through the review if they're outside of those cleaning, traffic management and construction sectors.

03:04:09 - 03:04:20

Jo Clay

I think it has primarily been raised by community sector and environmental groups who are triggering that $200,000 tender. So, is government already looking at that issue?

03:04:20 - 03:04:26

Speaker 162

Yeah, so that's something we raised in the discussion paper was are those thresholds appropriate, just yeah.

03:04:26 - 03:04:52

Jo Clay

The community sector has also suggested that their indexation is not really meeting their costs. They've been saying this for a number of years. Their indexation is not based primarily on Wage Price Index, and they have also suggested that it is not their funding from government is not indexed appropriately to cover things like their genuine compliance burden from Secure Local Jobs Code. What's the response of government to that?

03:04:52 - 03:05:41

Rachel Stephen-Smith

And that's one of the things that we, as I mentioned earlier, have been working through in the context of the Counting the Cost report, but also our immediate response to the Counting the Cost report was to change the community sector indexation arrangements. So, community sector indexation is 80% wage-related and 20% CPI. For the wage-related part, we changed it from being a WPI indexation to being the higher of WPI and award and I think it was CPI, but I can't there were three elements to it and it was going to be the higher of those. So, we have been indexing the wage element of community sector indexation to award wage increases, which have generally been higher than WPI over the last few years.

03:05:41 - 03:06:11

Jo Clay

Oh that's excellent. So, that's covering the cost of wages, but it's not covering the cost of the compliance impact. And we heard figures before of what the auditor fees were. I've written those down separately. We've got $565 to $3,500, but that's just the cost of the external auditor.

That doesn't count for the cost of the labour, the hours from the organisation. Is the cost of the labour compliance direct on the organisation, is that something that government is looking at assisting with?

03:06:11 - 03:07:32

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Well, as I mentioned earlier, Ms Clay, this the requirement to be a code certified entity applies to a new procurement and we would expect that in a new procurement, or commissioning process, or even a grants process if it's relevant, that organisations would be putting in a proposal that reflects the full cost of delivering that service. That is one of the conversations we've been having with the non-government sector is part of the competitive process in procuring, whether it's human services, environment, in the non-government sector is there has been a behavioural response to that competitive tension over time where non-government organisations have been lowballing it with the proposals that they put into government, and then coming back and seeking increases in funding over time. What we are saying is we want a genuine understanding of what it costs to deliver that service, all of the costs associated with delivering that service. And if you are getting a Secure Local Jobs Code certification, it is probably because you're participating in a new tender or commissioning process, and therefore you have an opportunity to put in a tender or a proposal through a commissioning process that reflects the full cost of doing business, and we would expect that you would do that.

03:07:32 - 03:07:44

Speaker 161

So, to the extent that people aren't doing that's problematic. We recognize that. That's part of the convers ongoing conversation we're having with the tent with the sector in relation to procurement and grant processes.

03:07:44 - 03:08:29

Jo Clay

Minister, that does sound sensible and much better for budgeting purposes both for those tendering and for ACT government. But that is not what happened on recent tenders in which in the environment sector, there were two recent tenders when the minister said there was a review done. The review the government's review said the funding window needs to increase. The government went out to tender and said the funding window will not increase. So, the organizations tendering were told by ACT government, "We are not increasing the funding window."

In that environment, do you think it is realistic for those tenderers to have increased their tender price to match their costs when they have already been told by ACT government, "We know the funding is too small, but we're not increasing it"?

03:08:29 - 03:10:22

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Well, I mean, probably getting outside of the scope of this hearing, but that is part of the challenge of the ongoing conversation in relation to managing budgets. I would expect organizations would come back and say, "Okay, well, if that is your if that is your funding envelope, this is what we can deliver and it's not going to be everything you want, because that's not realistic within the size of the funding envelope. If you want us to do everything, this is what it's going to cost." Now, those that does require mature conversations, I understand that, between ACT government officials who are undertaking the commissioning or procurement process and the organizations involved. And that can be challenging, and I think this is an iterative process.

But we certainly recognize that for organizations that are particularly where they are entirely reliant on ACT government funding, they have an obligation to meet their legal obligations to their workers. So, they should be doing this anyway, the actual cost of meeting the requirements of paying your workers fairly and ensuring that you're participating in portable long service leave, if that's a requirement for you, etc., etc., doing your work health and safety assessments, do make meeting all your regulatory requirements, you should already be accounting for those costs. And that, in itself, requires a labor component to it inside the organizations. The I mean, I think the aim when we were setting up the auditing process at the time was that if you had all your ducks in a row in terms of already meeting all of your obligations to your employees, that it shouldn't be significantly burdensome on a business to have an auditor come in.

03:10:22 - 03:10:34

Speaker 163

Ms Clay, you referenced writing down those figures that are in the ACT government submission, as well. Yes, thank you. I wrote them down from the ACT government submission, thank you. I wasn't sure if you'd read the submissions.

03:10:34 - 03:11:25

Jo Clay

We have we saw a lot of content in the public domain and in your submission, explaining that the Secure Local Jobs Code is not primarily there to ensure that procurement is kept local. Ah that's certainly what's showing up in the figures, the ACT government's local procurement spend dropped from 54% to 34% over the past six years. And actually, frankly, both of those numbers look low to me, only a third in the ACT looks very low. Even a bit over a half looks quite low. We have heard today that New South Wales councils, for instance, have much higher weightings for local participation than ACT government has.

What do you think there is a benefit in having more of that wealth circulating within the ACT, and if that is not in the Secure Local Jobs Code, where should that sit?

03:11:25 - 03:12:55

Rachel Stephen-Smith

So, we yes, we do have a 10% weighting is the standard weighting for local industry participation plans. I would say that for, I mean we've been, I mentioned earlier that we have had some very large construction projects with tier one tenderers that you wouldn't expect to be headquartered in the ACT. We've also undertaken some quite large procurements in the human services space, so we procured all of the care and protection services and again, the sort of the contractor, both for residential care and a couple of at least a couple of the contractors for foster and kinship care are organizations that are not headquartered in the ACT, but they are not-for-profit organizations who would obviously be employing people locally to undertake to deliver those services. So, to the extent that the wealth is largely tied up in wages, that wealth would be being circulating in the ACT because the people actually work here and for all of these sectors, actually the whole point of the Secure Local Jobs Code is it's targeted at sectors that are primarily, where the tender is primarily for the cost of labour, other than probably construction, which most of the cost of construction is in labour, but there are a lot of other costs as well. So, the actual people who are being paid are here, living here.

03:12:55 - 03:13:34

Jo Clay

We have heard evidence that doesn't agree with that. We heard evidence in the construction industry in particular, but we didn't get a lot of specialists in which they said crews were imported and then went home again. So, that is not really That's neither keeping the wealth local, nor is it, in actual fact, building our skills pipeline in an area where we really need our construction skills pipeline to be reinforced. Can you provide the committee with any data If you say the tenders maybe going interstate, but the labour is in actual fact local and is remaining local, can government provide any data on that over the last six years to contradict the figures I've put up?

03:13:34 - 03:13:50

Rachel Stephen-Smith

So, I think that's probably a matter for Infrastructure Canberra to look at what the compliance with local industry participation plan has been in terms of those major tenders or construction tenders.

03:13:50 - 03:14:20

Robert Wright

So We could take that on notice, Ms Clay. It's not you know, information you know, pertaining directly to the Secure Local Jobs Code. It's the local industry participation policy. So, the code requirements apply to territory-funded works you know, covering labour above 200,000, constructions construction except for excluded works, traffic control management, building or industrial cleaning, and security services.

03:14:20 - 03:14:30

Jo Clay

Well, can you tell me the interrelationship between the local industry participation code and the Secure Local Jobs Code, because they are interlocked, aren't they? The one picks up the other.

03:14:31 - 03:15:15

Rachel Stephen-Smith

No, they're two separate parallel policies and that's part of the part of the consideration in terms of our review and again waiting to see what comes out of this process is are there overlapping requirements between the two different sets of policies and then are there overlapping requirements between Secure Local Jobs Code and the ethical treatment of workers? So, we recognise that there are a number of streams of requirements in the procurement process and to what extent are we asking for the same information or, you know, and can we streamline that and make that easier for businesses? I do sometimes use businesses' shorthand, I realised, but businesses or organisations that are

03:15:15 - 03:15:48

Jo Clay

Organisations, yeah, sure. And I'd just I'll The chair will cut me off in a second, but we've had a number of small useful suggestions on how the code could be improved.

One was why do you get a 30-month certificate, why not 36-months? That looked like a fairly minor and useful change if it helped people. How Are you looking at small changes like that, and how did you come up with which industries are excluded? I can't see a published list of criteria by which government has said these industries are covered, these industries are excluded.

03:15:48 - 03:17:14

Rachel Stephen-Smith

The that work was done at the time of the legislation. We're very interested in people's views about what could be improved. That's why we're That's why we're doing a review in the first place. So yes. The industries that are primarily excluded are primarily excluded because they are professional sectors where workers either you would expect those workers would have significant market power and be reasonably well paid.

So the point of the Secure Local Jobs Code is to support and protect workers who are more vulnerable to exploitation, which is why cleaning, security, traffic management and construction are the named sectors. The media and telecommunications, real estate services, financial insurance services, professional, scientific and technical services and medical and other health services tend to be services that are higher paid, higher qualified workers with more market power in themselves. In addition, things like hospital services have already quite a significant regulatory environment wrapped around them that supports those workers. So that and tends to be sort of public service provision that upholds that.

03:17:14 - 03:17:27

Jo Clay

It's already there. Community and environment sectors weren't in that list, but they are covered. So maybe you can take it on notice, is there like a statement of criteria about why community and environment services are included?

03:17:27 - 03:17:34

Rachel Stephen-Smith

They would be included in the context of primarily for labour with an estimated value of $200,000 or more.

03:17:34 - 03:17:39

James Milligan

Thank you very much. Ms Carrick, do you have a quick, succinct question?

03:17:39 - 03:17:58

Fiona Carrick

Oh, I did. Well, I was just going to say on what Ms Clay was saying earlier about the $200,000 and the environment groups, they trigger that 200,000 because they use volunteer labour. So there'll be one or two staff, paid staff, but there'll be hundreds of volunteers, and so therefore they can do bigger contracts and they trigger it. That was all.

03:17:58 - 03:17:59

Okay, Ms Berry.

03:17:59 - 03:18:16

Yvette Berry

Am I able to ask questions about the review? I mean, I know you won't have I know we're kind of doubling up doing a review here and government review. You've been describing it as an independent review. Who's conducting the review?

03:18:16 - 03:18:30

Robert Wright

So we are waiting for the end of this particular process, Ms Berry, but then we will go out and find like an eminent person like who independently can conduct that review on behalf of government.

03:18:30 - 03:18:36

Yvette Berry

So you're going to consider the committee's recommendations before implementing the review?

03:18:36 - 03:18:37

We will indeed, Ms Berry.

03:18:38 - 03:18:49

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Just to be clear, we will sort of try and do the two processes in parallel so we'll be able to commence the review quickly rather than waiting for the government response to this process before we start.

03:18:50 - 03:20:01

Yvette Berry

Okay, because some of the we've talked to some of the witness recommendations or thoughts around the Secure Local Jobs Code, one of the points that was made was around procurement transparency, that there wasn't enough transparency around procurement, and that businesses should have All the information should be available for everyone to see even during the procurement process.

It's a question, not everyone might agree with that. The other thing that was interesting that came from some of our witnesses, particularly the business chamber and the Master Builders Association, was, of course, they want to get rid of the code completely. But when we drilled them on things that could improve in the code, they were suggesting that there was no evidence to prove that the code was working. Is the review considering that kind of activity? Like, or is there evidence that the government has now to show that the code is doing its job?

03:20:01 - 03:20:23

Robert Wright

So, in terms of the code doing its job, you know, we've got data that suggests that we have better compliance as a result of the introduction of the code. But we will consider, you know, all the things which are taken from this committee hearing, and in the independent review.

03:20:23 - 03:20:29

Yvette Berry

Is that compliance, is that compliance data, is that public?

03:20:29 - 03:20:50

Robert Wright

So, the compliance some of that compliance data is, you know, like, in the government's submission, so which was the information, you know, like, that Ms Clay was referring to. And you can see over the years that there is, you know, like, you know, better compliance, you know, like, by participants.

03:20:50 - 03:21:07

Yvette Berry

Well, is that like is that somewhere where businesses can see it, or because you know, we've had some witnesses say, "We believe it is doing the job," but we've had other witnesses say, "There's no data to back up the evidence that you're suggesting"?

03:21:07 - 03:21:49

Ellen Lukins

So, that dashboard that was included and it was based on a financial year within the government submission, the Advisory Council does receive at meetings a quarterly update around that data. So, that is going there. As part of those discussions with council, we have been discussing the how we might, or what we might publish in terms of that data. So, we have been working closely with the council to consider what from that dashboard is useful to be publishing on the website.

I think we have held that to see where we land with reviews before finalizing what we do publish from that dashboard.

03:21:49 - 03:21:55

Speaker 167

Can you remind who's on the Advisory Council? Sorry. Is it was probably in your submission, is it?

03:21:55 - 03:22:01

Speaker 168

It's the Master Build-- Perhaps not, but we do publish the names of members on our website.

03:22:01 - 03:22:06

Speaker 165

Or they might have in short, though, to say is it Master Builders and Chamber of Commerce represented?

03:22:06 - 03:22:28

Ellen Lukins

So, the individuals that are appointed, so, it's, on the employee representatives, it's Casey Tomkins, Michael Hiscox and Stacey Scharkie. In terms of the employer representatives, so, we have Josh Reinkhardt, Anna Neelagama and Greg Harford. And we have the ex officio member of the registrar.

03:22:28 - 03:22:37

Speaker 169

Okay. All right. So, those discussions have been taking place on the Advisory Council about that evidence?

03:22:37 - 03:22:42

Speaker 166

About the dashboard information and what we might be able to publish.

03:22:42 - 03:23:34

Yvette Berry

And when you talked about random sorry, random audits, because we've been talking a bit about the auditing, and we've been hearing from people about this potential of duplicating different audits by various organizations, in the review work, are you going to that question of whether or not the audits that the government registrar is doing, or the compliance officers are doing, is enough? Or are you taking evidence from other regulators when they're doing audit audits? So, like, if Fair Work does an audit of someone, finds they've got a certificate, do they report to you, "We've done this audit, and this person's underpaying their staff" or something?

03:23:34 - 03:24:11

Robert Wright

So, those decisions would be Ms Berry, they would be public. And so breaches of industrial legislation would be public and, as part of, you know, the certification audit, you know, like, they would be picked up as part of that.

If they happened to a code certified business during the life of the certificate, you know, like we would be looking into that as well. And as stated a little bit earlier, we also get complaints for which there's an official complaints process, and we take those into account as well.

03:24:11 - 03:24:27

Ellen Lukins

Can I just add to that? There is a requirement on code certified entities where there has been an adverse finding, ruling or order made to be notifying the registrar when that occurs. So there are several mechanisms by which we're able to identify that.

03:24:27 - 03:25:02

Yvette Berry

What if there is a circumstance and I and this is this will be sort of I think considered as part of the review work, what if there is a situation where an employer has a record of non-compliance with the Fair Work Act or work health and safety, but it doesn't go to litigation? That it's a continuous record of, you know, bad behavior? Is that considered as evidence, or is that not enough? Does it have to go to litigation, or does a continuous bad record count?

03:25:02 - 03:25:07

Speaker 173

Sorry, is this a- Yeah, and I think it's just digesting the question to a certain extent.

03:25:07 - 03:25:42

Jordan James

There is a case-by-case sort of issue that we work through, and it depend whether it's been publicly prosecuted or private litigation as to whether we're aware of it. But broadly speaking, we're looking at the pattern of behavior, mitigations that have been put in place, and the code is trying to raise the standard of businesses that are doing work. So, we would consider it in some form, but it would depend on what the level of penalty is that's applied by the registrar, if any.

03:25:42 - 03:25:43

I don't really have any other questions at all.

03:25:43 - 03:25:45

Fiona Carrick

I do have questions.

03:25:45 - 03:25:46

Yes, Ms Carrick.

03:25:46 - 03:25:59

Fiona Carrick

Thank you. So, which functions of the Secure Local Jobs Code cannot be effectively performed through existing workplace safety and procurement legislation?

03:25:59 - 03:26:03

Speaker 174

Well, it's Well, I guess it's the pre-certification process.

03:26:03 - 03:26:06

Speaker 171

Yeah, aside from that. Okay, so the

03:26:06 - 03:26:08

Speaker 172

That kind of is the point of that.

03:26:08 - 03:26:30

Fiona Carrick

All right, so why do we have all the compliance stuff in the registrar's role if there is no if there's no difference, because this is one of the major things that they keep talking about, the duplication of the WorkSafe and so on?

03:26:30 - 03:27:12

Robert Wright

So, as registrar, you know, my compliance powers are limited to code requirements, you know, for example, that subcontractors performing territory-funded work are code certified. I do not have powers to investigate alleged breaches of non-compliance with other legislation, such as work health and safety laws, or fair work laws, and therefore I am reliant, you know, upon those bodies to do that. Where we do get those things come up, you know, I refer those matters to the relevant regulatory authority responsible for administering that legislation, so that might be the Fair Work Ombudsman, that might be WorkSafe ACT, and we do that.

03:27:12 - 03:27:22

Fiona Carrick

Okay, what evidence demonstrates that certified businesses perform better than non-certified businesses in relation to workplace compliance?

03:27:23 - 03:29:23

Rachel Stephen-Smith

If I can just say in relation to the previous question and maybe it goes to this one a little bit, I recognize the point that people are making about potential duplication, but one of the challenges we face is this is part of our procurement system, and what we really want to do is ensure that the businesses and organisations that we procure services and construction from are meeting their legal obligations. And this provides a process for us to have one central point of contact, one single certification system, and one single compliance system. Within the individual contracts, SLJC certified organisations would be required within their contract with the ACT government to maintain their SLJC certification, and you would hope to provide the directorate with which they are contracting information if they are in breach of their code requirements, or if their code certification is suspended, anything like that.

That means with one central point of contact in the ACT government maintaining an oversight over compliance with work health and safety and, particularly, Fair Work obligations, rather than every procuring entity, so every single directorate, having to maintain that watching brief on all of the organisations with which they are contracted. So, yes, it requires resources to oversee the implementation of the Secure Local Jobs Code, but it also means we have a an assurance process that doesn't require every single directorate to be duplicating that work, particularly if they may be contracting with the same or similar organisations.

03:29:23 - 03:29:50

Fiona Carrick

So, that's interesting that watching that you use that language, "watching brief", because, I mean, you could centralise the watching brief of looking at who's breached regulation, and have a list of people that have breached, and that centralised area could have a look at, you know, these are these companies that have been found to breach regulation. That is different to having a whole certificate process.

03:29:50 - 03:30:43

Rachel Stephen-Smith

So, the difference is that having the certification process then means that you can put that into your contract to say, "You must retain your code certification, and there will be consequences if you don't do that." It is much more complicated to say, "You must comply with all of your Fair Work requirements, and this is the threshold at which we will say we're going to cancel your contract or we're going to issue a penalty if you don't." So, this process creates an opportunity to have breaches, or sanctions, or penalties issued that would be very difficult to achieve without an actual certification process if it were just left to each individual directorate to try to implement some kind of sanction within their contracts for the delivery of service.

03:30:43 - 03:31:04

Fiona Carrick

And so, does your dashboard, because, for some reason, I don't I don't have it there, does the dashboard tell us how many breaches have been how many companies have you issued a breach to from the point of view of the Secure Local Jobs Code?

03:31:04 - 03:31:15

Ellen Lukins

So, in the dashboard, there is a in the same sections of the code breach, that top right-hand corner, it does have the number of the investigations resulting in sanctions, so it does list that.

03:31:15 - 03:31:53

Fiona Carrick

Okay. May I have one last question? When it comes to security of jobs, what is the ACT government doing to make sure that community organisations have funding in place so that they don't lose staff because of the uncertainty of funding arrangements? So, we've, you know, ever since I've been in the assembly for two years, community organisations have said the budget is so late in June, we're not sure about our funding, and because of the uncertainty, we find it really hard to hang onto staff.

And so, isn't that a classic contributor to insecure jobs?

03:31:53 - 03:31:55

Speaker 177

Yeah, absolutely. More insecure jobs?

03:31:55 - 03:33:33

Rachel Stephen-Smith

Yeah. Look, I agree with you, Ms Carrick. This has been a challenge. It's been a challenge for the entire time that I've been in the Assembly as well. That's why part of the commissioning process has been seeking to move towards longer contracts with our non-government providers, particularly our community sector partners, and then also trying to change those timelines so that we can ensure that certainty is provided earlier.

We have certainly improved that even in the last couple of years, and have made commitments in relation to upcoming budgets. One of the things that we have been looking at in that context is are there ways that we can bring things forward through the mid-year budget review process that look at funding beyond the 30th of June, so we're not necessarily using that process for funding in this financial year, but we're actually using a process, either early in the budget process or through mid-year review, to provide that certainty. It is sometimes simply the case that it's actually a delay in the procurement or commissioning process, rather than a delay in funding certainty, that also results in uncertainty of ongoing contracts. So, that's the other side of it that we have been trying to address. But certainly where there are funding cliffs, we're very conscious of seeking to address that.

And I think, in the last couple of budgets, we have addressed a lot of the potential funding cliffs.

03:33:34 - 03:33:37

James Milligan

Minister, officials, ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much.

03:33:37 - 03:34:11

Jordan James

Could I just quickly, in relation to the question on notice, put some data there? So, in relation to the code certificates that were rejected, last financial year, there were four code certificates that were rejected after we received an audit report saying they'd met the requirements, and for the same timeframe, we were notified twice by an auditor that they'd rejected an application. And in terms of those applications or audits, they don't just look at the breaches, it's about the business determining or showing evidence that they've met the requirements of the code. So, there's a range of information that they have to provide.

03:34:11 - 03:34:20

Fiona Carrick

So, can you tell us, for those four and two was it, for what reason they were they didn't get their certificate?

03:34:20 - 03:34:22

Speaker 178

I would have take that on notice to get the detail.

03:34:22 - 03:34:24

Speaker 176

Yeah, that'd be great to know why they didn't get their certificate.

03:34:24 - 03:34:43

James Milligan

Excellent. Well, thank you very much. And as you all know, questions taken on notice, please get them to our committee secretary within five business days from receiving the uncorrected proof. Other than that, have a great afternoon. We're going to break for an hour and come back at 1:00 pm.

Thank you very much.