Legislative Council (19 November 2026, part 4)

19 noviembre 2026

Legislative Council Parliament of Tasmania

Seguir sus sesiones
00:00 - 03:22
Interviniente 1
if pastoral care or professional discussions may be unintentionally captured.  The bar to allege harm is low, and the net to capture offense is wide, and neither are well-defined.  And I think there is a real question over the consequences of the bill and its potential to have a chilling effect on the support available to our most vulnerable kids and young people as they struggle through the challenges of gender distress.  Family members, medical practitioners, trusted support networks may feel less free to engage on the issues, to answer the questions, and to have those honest, difficult conversations.  And I know there are chop-outs in the bill for certain cohorts, but I do think the spectre of potentially having these conversations misconstrued does present a risk, particularly in the provision of professional services, and particularly in the circumstances of family breakdown. 

Almost universally, parents want the best for their kids.  They navigate difficult conversations everyday on any topic you can think of, but they do not want to be placed in a situation where they feel unable to discuss issues relating to relationships, sexual, faith, identity, or personal well-being.  Likewise, many Tasmanians draw enormous support and guidance from their faith communities.  Though I am not one of them, I do not believe that holding religious beliefs should be treated as unlawful, nor do I believe that respectfully expressing a religious view should be treated as unlawful.  The bill does confer new powers, a new architecture of investigation, reporting, compliance, and enforcement. 

It is, without question, an extension of state oversight into deeply personal areas of family and religious life.  Again, it is the issue of balance.  I note that the bill goes to considerable lengths to specify conduct that does not of itself constitute a conversion practice.  It expressly protects guardians discussing and providing guidance, support, or advice to children, participating in a public debate.  It expressly protects health practitioners who provide information in good faith, and those provisions are not minor details, and I do take some comfort they provide some of the necessary protections the bill absolutely requires. 

It expressly states that religious beliefs may be expressed in sermons, religious education, pastoral care, and prayer, and I would also point to amendments that have been made in the other place as significantly having improved the bill and will follow the in with interest the course of event, amendments that are proposed in this house.  Mr President, I recognise some members of our community and members of my electorate will remain concerned.  I also recognise that there are Tasmanians who have waited a long time for parliament to acknowledge the harm conversion practices have caused in their lives.  So for me, I have attempted to distil this very complex issue and the imperfect remedy before us down to a simple proposition. 

El resto de la transcripción está reservado a clientes Pro

Desbloquee la transcripción completa, el chat y todas las funciones de análisis con Polyfact Pro.

El vídeo, en cambio, sigue siendo gratuito y completo, sin necesidad de cuenta.

Empezar una prueba gratuita