House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittingsGeorge Young
Grateful to the noble lady for that reply, but only ministers believe that 1.5 million is achievable. Even the National Audit Office has said the chances are slim. My Lords, the Prime Minister has recently decided to channel public money for housing away from housing associations and through local authorities. Does the noble lady agree that this means we will get fewer social homes because housing associations can top up public money with private borrowing and the local authorities can't? So will she urge him to change direction?
And secondly, does she agree that many of those renting could afford a mortgage if they had some help with a deposit? And has she read today's Financial Times, which indicates that her previous Secretary of State, before he was sacked, was urging the government to introduce a successor to Help to Buy? Will she urge the Prime Minister to continue with that, as this will give the market the confidence it so badly needs?
Jane Sharon Taylor
On the noble lord's first question, the Prime Minister was talking about support between local authorities and housing associations. And it's really important that we have that good collaboration between the two partners in delivering social housing. So I look forward to a very productive relationship between local government and our registered providers, and no, I don't think that will lower the number of houses that are able to be delivered, particularly as we now have a National Housing Bank which this government's brought in. On his second question, I think I'll write to him as an answer for that one.
Richard Stuart Best
We're not going to make the 1.5 million new homes, I'm afraid. But we can pull out all the stops and get as near as possible to it. And can I ask the noble baroness the minister whether she can prevail upon her ministerial colleagues to spend rather more, to commit rather more of the 39 billion that's been set aside for social housing, because we can get on with that at a time when the market, the private market, is in the doldrums and there are lots of opportunities to help the construction industry and get on with the social housing programme, which is just so important.
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, we committed to delivering a stretch target of 1.5 million homes, and I think we know it's a stretch target, but it's better to aim high, I think, in this respect. In terms of the 39 billion for social housing, we've already announced the first tranche of that funding, which will be, which has been announced in August, and we will be moving forward with later tranches as quickly as possible.
Speaker 21
My Lords, I very much welcome what the minister said, because housing associations built the highest number of social rented homes over the last decade, and the National Housing Federation suggests figures suggest it's going to further increase this year. I wonder though whether she could add to what she's said and confirm whether her department is making representations to the Treasury to match the ambition of the housing association sector and council sector and increase investment in the social and affordable homes programme in the autumn budget.
Jane Sharon Taylor
I'm sure my noble friend wouldn't expect me to comment on the autumn budget in advance of the Chancellor's announcements. But I think it's important that we remember that this 39 billion pound investment is the highest level of investment in social and affordable homes for generations. As I said, we've already begun implementing that programme. Further funding is available through future allocations. And for the first time, three councils have been awarded strategic partnership status outside London, demonstrating how our councils are stepping up to meet these ambitions.
We're also removing the barriers that we've had to council house building: a 10-year rent settlement, rent convergence, Public Works Loan Board borrowing rates, Right to Buy reform, and a further 46 million pound investment through Capacity to Build to strengthen councils' skills, expertise, and capacity.
Speaker 15
Given the dire state of the housing market, surely the response should be the 'Yes Minister' response of a very brave minister retaining the target. Can the minister reassure the House that to get construction moving, it will give priority to encourage private sector investment in social housing rather than relying on help-to-buy schemes, which normally end up in higher prices.
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I'm keen to encourage as much investment into the delivery of social and affordable homes as we can. And there was a great appetite when I did a workshop on this in the city for the kind of patient capital investment into social housing. So I hope we will be able to encourage that. In terms of help-to-buy, we've done a review of the help-to-buy system, as the noble lord indicated. We are working through whether that's the right way to go.
There were some issues with the previous help-to-buy scheme. We continue to explore ways to deliver more housing, but certainly I would encourage investment into it.
Speaker 10
My lords, many villages are increasingly unable to retain young families, agricultural workers, and other key members of the rural workforce because of a shortage of affordable homes. As the government pursue their house building target, how will they ensure that rural communities remain sustainable local economies rather than becoming places from which local people are priced out?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Yes, well, I think there are a number of issues we need to address. One is the issue which we have thought about, which is the rural homes exception. So making it possible, first of all, local authorities need to make sure they've got enough rural housing in their local plans, making sure we've got rural homes exception policies so that local people can determine what housing is built and where. And then, of course, the issue of making sure the services are there to support rural housing as well. All of these issues are important, and we must bring those together as we make sure there is sufficient housing in rural areas.
Gerard James Jamieson
The minister frequently trumpets the government's 39 billion social homes program as a means of accelerating housing delivery. Can the minister tell the House how many social homes will be completed and occupied by July 2029 from this grant? And would she categorize that figure as a firm commitment or a slim chance target, as the Secretary of State describes the commitment to 1.5 million new homes by 2029 July?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I'd say it's a great investment because it actually is an enormous investment in social and affordable housing. And significantly, it was something that the previous government left us in a housing crisis. So I'm not going to take any criticism from the other side about investing in that social housing. The funding that Homes England is committing now will deliver 73,500 homes via strategic partnerships. And the GLA also intends to offer allocations of at least 8 billion pounds and will set out the number of homes it expects to achieve through that initial allocation shortly.
We consider whether a national central government target or ambition is appropriate in this regard.
Speaker 9
I warmly welcome the approach that the government is taking but would like to ask the noble lady the minister whether funds could be made available for housing associations to purchase properties immediately for social rent with so many on the market, some of which are shared owned anyway by housing associations.
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I appreciate all the issues around shared ownership and we've debated those extensively in your lordships' house. Housing associations manage their own finances, they're independent organisations and many of them do indeed purchase houses that become available on the open market and we would encourage them to continue to do so.
Speaker 20
I welcome the government commitment, an absolute commitment to building 1.5 million houses. How does the government square its decision to build a data center in the heart of the East End of London, Beckley Lane, which is occupied by communities, hundreds and hundreds of families, which would take away scarce land for housing to which the government is committed?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, it would be totally inappropriate for me to comment on individual planning applications from the dispatch box. We always have to get the balance right between meeting the needs of our economy and data centers of course are a very critical factor in terms of driving our economy forward and of course making sure there's enough land for housing. That situation is the responsibility of our local authorities when they go through their planning process unless of course the data centers are referred as part of our national infrastructure system but I am not going to comment on an individual application here and now.
Jane Sharon Taylor
Our tax system is very supportive of economic growth. Our tax to GDP ratio is in the middle of the pack of the G7 and we have the lowest deadline rate of corporation tax in the G7. UK economy saw the fastest growth in the first half of this year and the IMF expects the UK to remain the fastest growing European G7 economy in 2026-2027. And according to the IMF, this year for the first time since 2004, we are forecast to be borrowing less than the rest of the G7 on average. Despite the headwinds from the war in the Middle East, there is a lot to be optimistic about.
Speaker 18
Well, my lords, the tax burden is forecast to reach its highest ever level. The last two disastrous budgets raised taxes by 40 billion and 26 billion respectively and the results can be seen in today's very disappointing unemployment figures. So the manifesto has ruled out any major tax increases but there's still great uncertainty in the UK economy which is damaging the economy. What evidence can the government offer that such a historically high tax burden is consistent with promoting economic growth which is so badly needed in this country?
Speaker 12
Can I just say to the noble lord that we did have quite a big mess to tidy up when we got into government two years ago and I don't think the opposition should be allowed to get away with that. I mean only on Friday the ONS estimated the GDP growth increased in July by 0.4%, well above expectations. In fact the UK GDP growth is the fastest in the G7 nations. For example the effective tax rate for a single individual with no children on average earnings is one of the lowest in the OECD. And I'm not pretending everything's rosy in the garden but there is a lot of rose, there is a lot, there is a war in the Middle East and we've think also that we need to consider the unemployment figures that came out today.
I don't know whether the noble lord is aware but there is only two peacetime years out of the past 150 years when the average annual employment rate has been higher than it was in 2025.
And let's just listen to what business have been saying. A representative of the KPMG said, businesses are starting to press ahead with investment. We are starting to see data moving in the right direction. Like I said, there's a lot to be optimistic about.
Susan Kramer
My lords, my lords, my lords, there's a very strong argument that the businesses hardest hit by today's tax rises, notably employers' NICs, are small businesses with more than seven employees and medium-sized businesses. Now, has the government done work to look at the impact of growth on that specific sector, because it is absolutely crucial in very disadvantaged communities and the impact is masked by always quoting the high-level numbers.
Speaker 12
I don't obviously want to preempt anything that might be coming out in the, in the budget, but I think it's fair to say the government has protected the smallest businesses from these changes, from the NICs changes, by more than doubling the employment allowance, which allows eligible employers to reduce their employees' NICs bill by up to ten and a half thousand pound. This means that around 900,000 employers, or about 40%, will have no employer NIC liability at all. We are thinking about small companies. We know they are the ones that grow the economy and we're going to continue what's best for the British economy.
Speaker 11
My lords, my lords, does, returning to the original question asked by the noble lord, does the minister agree that what really matters is the growth in GDP per capita, where we sit near the bottom of the G7, given our population growth over the last five years, and that this has happened at a time when the tax burden has risen at the fastest rate in the G7? That's not a coincidence, is it?
Speaker 12
I think it's, it's fair to say as far as the GDP by capita is concerned, I think the other thing that is, other figure that is not really looked at but is, is prevalent to all of this, is payroll employee-based productivity growth has grown by 2.2%, which is the fastest calendar year rate outside of the pandemic for more than a decade. And productivity growth is the main way to sustainable increase in long-term economic growth. Like I said, we're not out of the woods yet, but there's a lot going on that is positive and optimistic and I think that's the line that we need to toe.
Speaker 23
My lords, my lords, our new Prime Minister has talked about growth in every postcode and he's right surely to have set that objective so that communities are not left behind. So how, may I ask my noble friend the minister, how will the government ensure that the revenues raised through taxation actually help deliver growth in every part of our country?
Speaker 12
My noble friend asks a very important question and I think it's central to this government's plan for growth and devolution. Closing regional productivity gaps is a major economic opportunity, with productivity in northern cities around 20% lower than similar-sized cities in the OECD. If we were able to do that, we could actually boost UK GVA by 82 billion pound. We are devolving more power to local leaders and investing in transport, housing, infrastructure. The aim is not simply to redistribute existing growth, but to increase the productive potential of major cities around the country.
And we also going to rely also on the regional mayors, for example, to ensure that they have a say in how that growth is going to take place.
Speaker 19
The basics of the argument, can the noble lord the minister explain why the government believes that raising taxes and increasing regulation promotes growth?
Speaker 12
Like I said, we've got one of the most productive and tax regimes in the world, and we can see that by the amount of money that's being raised, by the amount of money that's, the number of people who are actually in employment. It's the highest figure, only two years in the last 150 years that have seen that. So I think we've got ourselves into a position where we have to raise taxes to help solve the problems that we were left with two years ago, and we will continue to press on to make sure that the economy is as productive as it possibly can be.
Speaker 24
My lords, the noble lord is now an independent, I believe, so he'll take the question and then we'll be followed by the crossbenchers.
Speaker 26
Very kind, thank you indeed. My lords, under Tony Blair, the noble lord the minister's predecessor in Sedgefield in another place, the state was taking 34% of GDP, spending about one pound in three. Now since the pandemic, it's closer to one in two, and that has coincided with an extraordinary flattening of our growth rate. So will the noble lord the minister urge his colleagues in government to look at which taxes are the most deleterious to growth while bringing in the lowest revenues? I'm thinking specifically on taxes on savings, investment, and inheritance.
Speaker 12
That is a very important point, I think, and all I would say to that is that we always have these taxes under review, and no doubt when we have the budget at the back end of October, there will be some statements made by the chancellor that will reflect what we need to do to ensure that the economy does grow into the future, and we will continue to do what is in the best interest of the British people.
Speaker 27
My lords, does the minister agree that a bigger obstacle to growth than the tax burden is the level of public debt across the world, reflected in higher interest rates across the OECD countries? And therefore, can he please recommit the government's commitment to the fiscal rules and to fiscal consolidation in general?
Speaker 12
I think we, the new chancellor said that we're going to stand by the fiscal rules that were laid out at the start of this parliament. And he's absolutely right about the debt servicing costs that we have to make. But one of the upsides, not of the debt, but what is happening is the borrowing has been stuck at about 5% of GDP for the last four years, but borrowing fell by 1% to its lowest level for six years at 4.2% in '25-'26. And according to the IMF, this year for the first time since 2004, we are forecast to be borrowing less than the rest of the G7 on average. And we all know about the conflict in the Middle East and the impact that's having on debt, not just in this country but around the world.
But we are setting a plan to ensure that we can lower that debt burden.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My lords, wealth creators and entrepreneurs are more internationally mobile than ever.
What steps are the government taking to ensure that their cumulative tax rises don't drive away young people or established wealth creators like Chris Rokos, who until recently contributed so much to the UK's prosperity in tax and philanthropy?
Speaker 12
The noble baroness mentioned young people and the importance of them staying in the UK and working here. And we all know the problems that we have with NEETs. And I think what we need to consider is what some of the businesses around the country and internationally are saying about doing business in this country. And we've got, for example, businesses are starting to press ahead with investment. We're starting to see the data moving in the right direction.
Despite geopolitical tensions, cost of living pressures and fiscal uncertainty, the fundamentals for UK businesses are strong. So all this is business that's speaking about the future of the British economy. And like I said, we need to be optimistic. And the point she mentioned about the tax burden is it driving people out the country? There'll be some figures released next year which we think will prove that it's been marginal on the number of people who are leaving because of that.
Speaker 29
Third oral question, Baroness Thorp. I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper and draw the house's attention to my register of interest.
Gillian Merron
My lords, this government supports the integration of neighbourhood health and social care. Our approach to neighbourhood health brings services together so that people experience more joined-up and person-centred care, including from integrated neighbourhood teams. In March, we published the neighbourhood health framework promoting joined-up partnership arrangements between ICBs and local authorities and asking health and wellbeing boards to develop neighbourhood health plans for implementation from 2027-28 at the latest.
Speaker 29
I thank my noble friend for that answer. And I felt moved to put this question, my lords, because there seems to be more hope today than for many years that local integration of social care, health and primary care might happen. So my question to my noble friend the minister is that with so many moving parts in the reform agenda, the Casey review, the 10-year plan and so on, there may be a danger for reform to steam ahead without the voices and views of patients, carers and those with lived experience not properly baked into the design process. So I'm seeking reassurance from my noble friend that those voices will indeed be heard and heeded.
Gillian Merron
I certainly can give that reassurance to my noble friend, not least because as we move towards neighbourhood health, and I'm glad my noble friend recognises this isn't just a shift on paper, this is a real turnaround of how we see people and how we see services, that indeed co-production is required on neighbourhood health plans and they would be all the poorer if we did not include the voices to which he refers.
Speaker 30
My lords, integration is harder than co-location. And so, for instance, housing and social isolation are key detriments to health, but yet they sit outside the NHS. So therefore, a social worker sitting next to a GP may be helpful, but the reality is that this social worker will not get extra money, extra access to health beds in the community, and nor will she get extra staff. So what are the government going to do to erase these difficulties, particularly when the health needs of the population are growing and the workforce has not kept pace with the needs of the complex needs of the ageing population?
Gillian Merron
The noble lady is quite right to talk about people having more complex needs and indeed we're also living longer. But the fact is the current health system is organized around institutions and services that are complex, they are disjointed and they're difficult to navigate as the noble lady said. But to the point, for example, on housing, I know that through the health and wellbeing boards, and they are the key to all this, they are, they can design themselves to bring in services and I can think of a number who have already done that, including people from housing in the way she describes. So absolutely it's encouraged and health and wellbeing boards across the country are already doing that.
Caroline Pidgeon
A recent workforce assessment by Skills for Care found that adult social care in England still had around 96,000 vacancies and projects a further 410,000 posts will be needed by 2040 to meet demand. So what is the government doing to address these shortages to deliver genuine integrated patient services?
Gillian Merron
We do recognize the challenge that we inherited in terms of the workforce and that does still continue. But that is why we're investing in the adult social care workforce. The first ever fair pay agreement will come in in 2028, it'll be backed by 500 million pounds funding, it will improve pay and conditions for the workforce, which is crucial. But we're also implementing the first ever universal career structure for the adult social care workforce, as well as investing up to 10 million this year to the learning and development support scheme. This along with all the other changes will make a massive difference to the workforce in terms of retention, recruitment and development.
Speaker 34
My lords, my noble friend has already mentioned health and wellbeing boards of which of course local government are key participants and players. So I wonder whether having said that and with the government's commitment to devolution in mind, can she tell us more about the role that local government will play in improvements to health and social care going forward? And in doing so, I'm delighted to declare my interest as a vice president of the Local Government Association.
Gillian Merron
Well, my noble friend is right to identify that if we are going to deliver neighborhood healthcare and if we are to make improvements in social care, we have to join up and we have to join up between NHS and local government. That is actually key to our whole approach to neighborhood health. But that is why health and wellbeing boards, who are responsible for drawing up the local plans in respect of what the locality needs, will bring together and have on their local authority representation and voice along with the NHS and others. Because it is only by doing that that we will do, because in order to reduce health inequalities, in order to deliver locally, there's no way that it just sits with one and I'm grateful to local government in what they are doing.
Speaker 9
Can the Minister explain how health and social care will be planned to ensure intergenerational input, in particular young carers and young people who often have very good innovative ideas about how to provide such services?
Gillian Merron
It's a very good point and young carers are sometimes left out to the detriment, as I said earlier, I think, to services and also to policy. And so when, and I bring us back to the requirement through the neighborhood health framework, which we published in just March of this year, and I would add to that our introduction of neighborhood health center schemes all across the country, the voices of local people and particularly those in the higher priority cohorts, which of course can include young carers, will be heard and will be part of the co-production of how we provide neighborhood health and social care.
Speaker 37
My Lords, the noble lady has said that the health and wellbeing boards will be responsible for making sure that there are sufficient social care services at the neighborhood level. Following Lord John's question, can I ask the noble lady to whom will they be accountable if they don't deliver sufficient social care at the neighborhood level?
Gillian Merron
Well, the framework does, which I mentioned, the neighborhood health framework published in March, does require local systems to develop neighborhood health plans. And I think that will give, not I think, it will give a very clear basis for measuring impact that we haven't got at the moment because it's not the quality of the plan, it's the quality of delivery. And on that, I would certainly agree with the noble Lord and that is why the framework also empowers local leaders in five minimum national goals, and that does include, for example, as we've discussed many times, improving access to general practice as well as the join up with social care.
Speaker 36
My Lords, I declare an interest as the former vice chair and trustee of the British Red Cross. I have seen firsthand how the British Red Cross delivers health and social care across communities in our country by helping people to transition from hospital to home, giving them independence at home and avoiding readmissions. Does my noble friend the Minister agree that bringing together the voluntary sector alongside local authorities and the NHS will help to deliver more connected, effective and compassionate social care in every postcode?
Gillian Merron
I agree with my noble friend on that point and that is why achieving neighborhood health will rely very critically on that strong partnership and it will include civil society as my noble friend says.
Speaker 32
The noble Baroness didn't answer my noble friend the front bench spokesman in terms of the question of who will be accountable if this doesn't work out properly.
Gillian Merron
Well, all of the local systems have their line of accountability, which I know noble Lords are familiar with currently, ICBs, for example, report to NHS England. That will now, subject to the passing of the health bill, come within the department and there will be an accountability mechanism and I can also say to noble Lords transparency will be a very key part of that. If noble Lords have any particular individual concerns, I'm always happy to hear them.
Diana Dido Harding
I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Fiona Twycross
My Lords, AI is advancing at an extraordinary pace, creating opportunities and risks that do not stop at national borders. All new emerging technologies have had an impact on society and it is government's role to help mitigate potential risks. The UK is leading global efforts to test and understand AI with one of the best resourced AI Security Institutes in the world. That will help us develop the standards and safeguards necessary to keep people safe.
Speaker 60
In recent days, we've heard urgent warnings from industry leaders and even a Nobel Prize winner about the arms race to superintelligence and the potential for grave harm to humanity. Whether you focus on apocalyptic risks or human rights abuses from AI happening now, experts are crying out for international collaboration, transparency, and regulation to ensure AI is used for human flourishing and not harm. Will the government use all its influence, including as host to the G20 next year, to work for international agreement to mitigate risks and lead the way here by bringing forward an AI bill to give statutory teeth to the AI Security Institute, something my noble friend Lord Clement-Jones has long been arguing for?
Fiona Twycross
The noble lady makes a really important range of points, and I just wanted to reassure your Lordships' House that the government treats AI risk with extreme seriousness. And like others, we're pleased that some of the sector is actually talking about the risk, because only by talking about them are we able to work through solutions. As a responsible leader in AI security, we monitor a full range of risks that could be posed by frontier AI. I note the noble lady made a number of different points and questions. I'm very happy to meet the noble lady to talk through where we think we might go with this policy area.
David Alton
My Lords, in the light of the existential threats which have been referred to by the noble baroness, Lady Turber, and having chaired the inquiry launched by the Joint Committee on Human Rights into AI and human rights with ten oral sessions, including important evidence from Minister Kanishka Narayan, may I ask the noble baroness the minister if she'll urgently read this 94-page report published yesterday and now available in the printed paper office? And having particular regard to its 59 recommendations and conclusions on the inadequacy of existing law and regulation, ensure, my Lords, a swift response and that we will have the opportunity to debate this report fully in your Lordships' House.
Fiona Twycross
I commend the Joint Committee of Human Rights for its report. I actually read it on the way into London yesterday. And I think it's a really interesting read and very clearly written. So for somebody who wouldn't purport to be as much of an AI expert as our AI minister, I felt that it explained how AI works in very clear terms. So from that point alone, I'd commend it to noble lords to read.
In terms of the regulation, the government is taking an agile and context-based approach to AI regulation. We're trying to balance the opportunities for growth with safety. We believe this approach allows risks to be addressed in the context in which they arise while also supporting growth and innovation. We'll obviously respond fully to the Joint Committee's report in due course.
The Lord Ranger of Northwood
My Lords, yesterday, if you watched the news, you'd have seen an AI actor being interviewed by a certain Ed Balls and Susanna Reid. And by the evening 10 o'clock news, we'd have heard about AI extinction from the big AI tech bros. So in the middle of that, we had an APPG AI session on what leadership looks like for AI. The questions were about international leadership, business leadership in the UK, and also how to reassure the public. Could I ask the noble baroness the minister, what is the government doing about reassuring the public when it hears all these messages about AI?
Fiona Twycross
I think the main, the main thing we need to do is not downplay people's concerns because clearly when you've got world experts and people who've been working in this field raising concerns about it, the worst thing we could do as a government is to say nothing to see here because we're so keen to be part of the huge positive way forward for AI. So I think that's the first step we can do. One of the reasons and one of the things I think we should do more about is to talk about our successes through the AI Security Institute, or AISI. I've been really impressed by what I've heard about it, and I do think that the public would be reassured by some of the big successes of AISI over recent months and years.
Speaker 57
Does the Minister agree with me, does the Minister agree with me that this is an international issue and that the only way we can deal with it is internationally, but the most important part will be to make sure that the regulator has the ability to actually police what is going on in China and America and the rest of the world?
Fiona Twycross
So my noble friend raises a number of interesting points. I think it is true that we need to address this internationally. AI clearly crosses national borders, it's not like other previous forms of new technology. We need to find the way forward in terms of getting the balance right, but actually we've been using our opportunity to lead internationally in terms of having those conversations across borders as one of the leaders in AI safety.
Timothy Clement-Jones
My Lords, I'm very interested in consulting to DLA Piper on AI regulation and policy. My Lords, just two weeks ago, the government resisted a proposal from members right across this House to introduce an AI kill switch into cyber legislation on the grounds that the government is, and I quote, "technology agnostic". My Lords, how agnostic does the Minister feel today?
Fiona Twycross
So I presume that the noble Lord is referring to the amendments put in the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill. One of the things that we've done is to introduce the bill and the guidance to work through that. I know that my colleague Liz Lloyd would be very happy to talk further with the noble Lord about this. In terms of a kill switch, one of the issues is that it's impossible for Britain to simply turn AI off. So one of the issues is the extent to which and people's concerns about whether or not a kill switch could or would work, but I know my colleague Lady Lloyd would be delighted to speak to the noble Lord further.
Speaker 55
My Lords, I very much agree with the earlier questioner. When it comes to managing the existential end of AI risks, unilateral regulation is of very limited value because the risk is of course global. But given this, what is the government's assessment of existing efforts to drive multilateral regulation, many of which, including the G20 that was mentioned earlier, have been trundling on for many years without a great deal of result? What more can the government be doing, and in the absence of DSIT, which ministry is in charge?
Fiona Twycross
In the absence of DSIT, as the noble Lord says, we've actually embedded AI across government by having the very first AI minister sitting at cabinet table. The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade has responsibility for AI policy, including growth, innovation and infrastructure. The newly expanded Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport has responsibility for tech sector oversight, cybersecurity and online safety, and Minister Neri sits across different departments.
We can't have our policy on AI sitting separate from all other policy areas. It's vital that we get this driven across across all areas of government.
Speaker 39
How may I ask the noble lady the minister is the government thinking of talking to China?
Speaker 52
The the government is clear that all parties involved in the development of AI need to be in agreement about way forward.
Diana Dido Harding
Thank you my lords. The tech companies particularly the social media companies have argued for a decade that their technology is global and therefore local regulation isn't the way to do it. And yet Australia and I believe now this house my lords has realized that local regulation is the only way you get global regulation in the end. Why do we think AI is any different?
Fiona Twycross
So apologies if I gave the impression that we didn't think you should have any regulation relating to AI. What I what I believe I was trying to get across that we're taking agile and context based approach to AI regulation which seeks to get a balance. And there's a number of pieces of legislation the government has put through that do have AI related elements. And I'm very happy to write to noble lady to outline what these are. Thank you.
Speaker 40
My lords I beg leave to ask a question of which I've given private notice namely to ask her majesty's government what assessment they have made of the government of China's financial influence over UK water companies.
Sue Hayman
My lords the noble lord does raise a very important issue because of course it's absolutely critical that those who own and invest in our water companies are good custodians of these nationally important businesses. The reforms that we're putting in place will transform our water system to ensure it delivers for customers and the environment but also that it attracts investors who are committed to securing the long term performance of our water companies.
David John Maclean
I thank the noble lady the baroness for that reply but that's for the future. The Times reveals that emails and financial records obtained from the London office of the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China the world's largest bank show that the Chinese bank issued nearly 1.26 billion in loans and borrowing options to UK water and energy companies up to July 24. Furthermore there were examples of cases where concerns in the London office about internal due diligence were overruled by bank staff in Beijing as well as concern about money laundering when the bank moved 960 million for Huawei back from the UK into China following the arrest of one of their top officials. So as a result of their investment in our strategic industries there are deep concerns that this poses a financial security risk especially since the ICBC has continued to accept business from Russian and Belarusian clients.
Speaker 44
So my Lords, what will the government do about this potential security threat we have at the present moment?
Sue Hayman
Well, the government takes all security threats extremely seriously. And I'm sure the noble Lord will be pleased to hear that the water industry will be included in the National Security and Investment Act mandatory notification scheme. And that will require water companies and certain infrastructure delivery providers to notify government of certain proposed acquisitions. And these notifications and companies will ensure that government can undertake a robust assessment of any national security risks. And it will also operate alongside powers that allow government to call in certain acquisitions.
If necessary, we can then intervene with various remedies, and that could include legally binding conditions or, in rare cases, actually blocking or unwinding a transaction.
Chris Fox
My Lords, the National Security and Investment Act of 2021 allows the government to scrutinize and intervene on certain acquisitions made by companies, including businesses and investors who could harm our national security. The Act covers 17 sensitive areas in the economy, but although there was much discussion when the bill was before your Lordships' House about including critical infrastructure, it was not included in those 17 areas. So with what we know today, and I thank the noble Lord for bringing this issue up, what we know today, is it not time to add services like water to the list so that the Act can be used in full to scrutinize who controls our critical water supply?
Sue Hayman
Well, of course, as I just mentioned, the water sector is in the National Security Investment Act. That's mainly because of the essential services that it provides for public health and the economy. And there are 17 existing sectors included in that mandatory notification scheme, which includes things like civil nuclear, energy, and transport. And we are taking an assessment regarding whether proposed acquisitions pose a national security risk, as I just mentioned. However, the noble Lord does make a very important point, I think.
So I'm happy that we do consider the water industry when we redo the terms of that Act.
Speaker 50
My Lords, UK water companies. My noble friend will be aware that Scottish Water is publicly owned, and so the Chinese can have no such influence. Is that not the way forward?
Sue Hayman
Well, I'm sure my noble friend will be aware that we published the water white paper earlier this year. One of the things we are looking at in that white paper and in the legislation that we will be bringing forward is what does public, what does ownership look like? What is the best way to secure our water industry for the future? And clearly who owns our water industry and who has influence over it is a key part of that decision-making.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, once upon a time we owned the water industry because local authorities used to run water services very well up to 1974. My Lords, alongside the security issues and the white paper work that's being undertaken, will my noble friend be looking at how these bodies can be made more publicly accountable locally?
Sue Hayman
I think my noble friend makes a really important point. We have to ensure that not just water companies, actually, but any kind of industry that is critical to our national infrastructure and our national security is fully accountable. Absolutely, we must look at that.
Speaker 45
My Lords, the question of ownership is not the only security question that we should consider. There are reports that Iranians did a cyber attack on I think dozens of water plants within the United States at the same time as they did an attack on an electricity generator in this country. What assurance does the my noble friend the minister have, and I refer to my interests as chair of the National Preparedness Commission, that the security of the physical arrangements is sufficient to deal with those sorts of cyber attacks of which incidentally the Chinese are also very capable, it's not just the Iranians.
Sue Hayman
Well I think one of the issues that we have to face as a government is the increasing threats from cyber attacks. The previous question was around AI. We have to really understand what the potential for such attacks is. And also for drone attacks, we're seeing drones being used much much more if we look at the kind of attacks Russia is making on Ukraine through drones. And I think one of the really important things we have to do as a country and we've been having meetings in Cobra about national security is to look at how we get together proper resilient plans that include cyber attacks for example.
Anne McIntosh
My Lords, carefully at the ownership of other water companies, Thames Water company is obviously very much in the spotlight. But is she mindful of the fact of the contribution over a number of years that privatised water companies have made to the UK pension funds and that were these to be nationalised, what would the impact be on pension funds at that time?
Sue Hayman
Well pension funds are incredibly important part of how our investment works and we have to ensure, I mean the thing one of the questions that the noble Lord raises with me is what do we consider to be good investment in this country? And actually good investment is from businesses and investors who are committed to the industry they're investing in and that includes the pension funds.
Sarah Ludford
My Lords, could the noble lady the minister just clarify what she said earlier about whether the National Security Investment Act covered the water sector? I've just, I wasn't an expert on it I have to admit, but looking at it online, 17 types of notifiable acquisitions, water doesn't seem to be there, though there does seem to be some indication the government is considering adding it. Could she just clarify for the benefit of the House exactly what the status is of the water industry under the National Security and Investment Act notifiable acquisitions?
Sue Hayman
Well my understanding is that the National Security Investment Act which was brought in I think in 2021, one of the recent announcements that we've made is that the water industry will be subject to that act.
Prem Sikka
My Lords, 90% of England's water industry is foreign owned including the Chinese state. The result has been low investment, high bills, raw sewage in rivers, over 1200 criminal convictions, harms to nature, health and national security. Everyone knows that public control of the water industry has failed to deliver and the only way forward is public ownership. Why is the government in denial?
Sue Hayman
Well, I don't think the government is in denial. The government, through the white paper and the act which we'll be bringing forward, will be looking at the best form of ownership for water companies going forward. But it's also really important that we get the right kind of investment. The water industry requires over 200 billion pounds in new investment before 2050. And we have to remember that capital markets are global.
If we artificially restrict the kind of investment that we want to see, we will reduce competition, we'll increase costs for customers. So it's incredibly important we get this right, while at the same time closing doors to investment that compromises our national security.
John Redwood
My Lords, given the very big capital requirements the minister's rightly identified, and given the need to pay compensation to existing shareholders if the government wanted to buy it out, isn't it the case that the country cannot afford nationalisation of the water industry?
Sue Hayman
Well, I think I've expressed concerns to your Lordship's House previously about the costs of nationalisation, which is why we're looking at the best way forward when we bring forward the new water legislation. And I really look forward to hearing what noble Lords in this House have got to say about how we move forward in this space.
Speaker 61
My Lords, being unaware of the specific confidential financial arrangements of the UK water companies with the Bank of China, but given the high level of public anxiety over water companies' performance and competence, can my noble friend the minister give the full assurance that progress on water provision, waste management, and adherence to environmental health will nevertheless be upheld as the most critical of the UK's national infrastructure?
Sue Hayman
Yes, I can give my noble friend that assurance. But of course, to deliver all this, we do need to make sure that we encourage the right kind of investment into the infrastructure. And that is one of the reasons why the water industry is going to be included in the National Security and Investment Act mandatory notification scheme in order to ensure that we have that assurance and that we do have information about delivery providers and that we do have the options to intervene when necessary if we're not happy with transactions that are going forward.
Speaker 63
I know that the noble lady the minister agrees with me that one of the reasons that the water industry got in such a mess was because it was so poorly regulated. A lot of these issues that we talk about now about overlaying debt, for example, are simply a result of the regulator not being up to the job. The new regulator, which we are promised, a called a super-regulator apparently, really, can I just underline again, needs financially acute people who understand this sort of financial engineering. This needn't have happened. We could have had a privatised water sector that was properly regulated.
We didn't, it was badly regulated and it got away with murder.
Sue Hayman
I mean, I think the noble Lord hits the nail on the head around regulation because we know that it isn't who owns the water company, whether it's nationalised or whether it's private, as to how effective it is, how efficient it is, how well it works. It's actually how it's run. And the financial nous, if you like, that underpins that and doesn't allow it to get into the kind of debt and use leverage systems in a way that is just not sustainable is what's caused so many problems. And I completely agree with the noble Lord.
Speaker 34
My Lords, it's been notable since he took office how clear the Prime Minister has been in his commitment to reforming the water sector, which he describes as a leaking monument to a system that prioritises private companies over public interest. Can I ask my noble friend though about timing and when we might expect to see real change come forward to make this sector work for people and places again?
Sue Hayman
Well, of course, we made some changes very quickly as soon as we came into government with the Water Special Measures Bill, which I know this House welcomed. The white paper, as I mentioned earlier, has been published. We are currently working on the bill that we will be bringing forward, and we will want to make the changes as quickly as possible. As my noble friend points out, this is a ministerial and government priority.
Speaker 32
But considering foreign ownership of a country like China and their long-term strategic endeavor to undermine our economy, owning critical national infrastructure like water, but also our economy, our manufacturing industry and other things that's been evidenced in the motor manufacturing industry. What about utilizing pension funds, whether they're homegrown pension funds or indeed international pension funds, to invest specifically in the water industry?
Sue Hayman
Well, I think because of the huge challenge that the water industry faces, the huge amount of investment that we need, I would suggest that the government would be open to looking at any suggestions on how we can actually plug that gap, because there is so much work to do.
Speaker 69
There are no more questions on the PNQ. May I suggest that any noble lords who wish to leave the chamber do so now before I call next business. Message from the Commons that they have passed the Sovereign Grant Bill, to which they desire the agreement of your lordships.
The Baroness Antrobus MBE
My lords, Sovereign Grant Bill, I beg to move that this bill be now read a first time.
Speaker 67
Question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. My lords, we now come to some instruments previously debated in Grand Committee.
Armed Forces Service Complaints Miscellaneous Provisions Amendment Regulations 2026 and one other motion, Baroness Antrobus.
Speaker 66
My lords, I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper en bloc.
Speaker 67
Question is that the two motions in the name of Baroness Antrobus be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Withdrawal Agreement, Windsor Framework and Governance Amendment Regulations 2026, Baroness Twycross.
Fiona Twycross
My lords, I beg leave to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.
Speaker 67
Question is that the motion in the name of Baroness Twycross be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Voter Identification Amendment of List of Specified Documents Northern Ireland Regulations 2026 and two other motions, Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent.
Baroness Anderson
My lords, I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper en bloc.
Speaker 67
Question is that the three motions in the name of Baroness Anderson be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Questions on a statement made in the House of Commons yesterday on Speciality Steel UK.
Andrew Sharpe
My Lords, I thank the Minister for repeating the statement. And I should say at the outset, above all our thoughts are with the more than 1,300 employees of Speciality Steel UK and their families who once again face considerable uncertainty about their future. However, I am afraid that this announcement appears to be a sign of things to come under this government. When Parliament was recalled last year to pass the Steel Industry Special Measures Act, we were told that these extraordinary powers were required to deal with the immediate crisis at British Steel. And when the government returned with their nationalisation legislation earlier this year, ministers again presented it as a targeted last-resort response to the situation at British Steel.
British Steel has since been nationalised, yet the government has still failed to secure the private investment needed for its long-term future. Now, only two months later, we have another steel company moving towards public ownership after the proposed sale to Blasta fell through. Now, can I start by asking the noble Lord the Minister why that deal fell through, given that yesterday the Guardian was quoting a Blasta spokesman as saying, and I quote, "We have a fully funded proposal at no cost to the British taxpayer that is ready to complete within 12 weeks," end quote. My Lords, surely the bigger question is why does the private sector increasingly find it so difficult to invest in British steel companies? Surely part of the answer is that successive decisions by this government have made Britain, and particularly energy-intensive industries such as steel, simply too expensive in which to operate.
Our industrial electricity prices remain among the highest in the developed world, and they are around four times those faced by manufacturers in the United States. Then there are the additional employment costs. The government's own latest assessment puts the direct annual cost to business of the Employment Rights Act at around a billion pounds. During the passage of that legislation, businesses repeatedly warned ministers about its cumulative impact on investment and recruitment. During the passage of the Steel Industry Nationalisation Bill, we on these benches gave ministers opportunities to address some of these underlying problems.
We sought greater discipline over regulation and reporting, proper scrutiny of taxpayer liabilities, and action on the cumulative burden of carbon and energy policy. Instead, my Lords, from the 1st of January next year, the government will introduce the UK Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism. The government's own figures forecast that the CBAM will raise 140 million pounds in 2027-28, 180 million pounds the following year, and 175 million in 2029-30. Those costs ultimately fall on imported steel, aluminium, cement, and other materials used throughout British manufacturing supply chains. Now, at the same time, domestic steelmakers remain exposed to the UK Emissions Trading Scheme, and the government are now negotiating to link that scheme more closely with the EU's ETS.
We also understand that the government wish to participate in the EU internal electricity market. The negotiating framework envisages dynamic alignment with relevant EU electricity rules and an indicative UK renewable energy target comparable to that of the European Union. That, my Lords, will only add more costs. The new Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero has spoken of the need for greater realism in our progress to net zero. So can the Minister therefore tell the House whether that realism will translate into a material change in energy policy for energy-intensive industries?
What specific action will the government now take to bring industrial energy prices materially closer to those faced by our major international competitors? The Business Secretary told the other place yesterday that public acquisition could require approximately 350 million pounds, including the acquisition itself and working capital over a period of one to three years. My Lords, the taxpayer is already supporting Speciality Steel UK to the tune of a reported three and a half million pounds a month in salaries while production remains largely dormant. So can the Minister therefore tell the House what is the government's current estimate of the total taxpayer exposure? How much has already been spent?
How much working capital does the government expect to provide? Will ministers publish a clear timetable setting out the expected costs over the next three financial years? And what, my Lords, is the exit strategy?
The business secretary said yesterday that his ideal remains for the company to be run in the private sector and that he is keen to see it return to private ownership. If that is the objective, will the government commit to publishing measurable conditions for doing so, regular assessments of opportunities for private investment, and a clear process for returning Speciality Steel UK to private ownership? My lords, private ownership does not in itself give workers long-term certainty. A competitive business, sustained investment, and customers who want to buy steel domestically give workers long-term certainty. And my lords, that matters particularly when the government tell other sectors that there is no money available.
Only yesterday, the government were defending their refusal to reduce VAT for our struggling hospitality sector on the grounds of the cost to the exchequer. Yet when another nationalisation is proposed, hundreds of millions of pounds of taxpayer exposure apparently becomes possible. We cannot return to a model in which government continually absorbs the losses of industries that its own policies have helped to make uncompetitiveness. The minister will know this history as well as anyone in this house. Britain tried widespread state ownership of major industries before.
By the 1970s, taxpayers were repeatedly required to support loss-making nationalised industries while investment, productivity, and competitiveness suffered. My lords, that experiment ended at the IMF, and looking at gilt yields today, that is where the markets think we are headed again. We do not want to see that history repeated. So my lords, will the government now recognise that nationalisation is not an industrial strategy? Will they instead set out a serious plan to slash industrial electricity prices, reduce unnecessary regulation, the costs of unnecessary regulation, make Britain internationally competitive again, and create the conditions in which private investors actually want to invest in British steel?
Chris Fox
My lords, I congratulate the minister on his new role, which is fast becoming that of a steel baron. As I said from these benches during the nationalisation bill, which, as the noble lord sharp pointed out, focused on British steel, Liberal Democrats recognise that national security, energy security, and food security are all intertwined, and steel is critical to our renewable sector, our defence, and our national infrastructure. Now in one sense yesterday's announcements add yet another complication to the government's attempts to ensure that the UK has a viable and strategic steel industry. In the other, it was perhaps inevitable, and perhaps it also gives the government a chance to consider two sides of the steel industry at the same time. So my first focus really is that on the timeline and how this fits, the speciality steel part fits with other activities.
Now in answer to my friend Daisy Cooper MP's question in the commons, the secretary of state said that he expects the process for speciality steel to take between four and six months. So can the minister update your lordship's house as to the timeline for British steel and the valuation process that is underway there? And can he tell us whether there is any crossover between the two, or are they discrete processes? The secretary of state set out a different scale of task to rejuvenate British steel, and in fact he implied that any involvement of the private sector was going to be some time in the future. So perhaps the minister can confirm what the government's thinking is around private sector involvement in British steel, and how does that affect the attempts to get private sector involvement into speciality steel?
And can he also confirm the scale of investment that actually speciality steel itself will need in order to make it an attractive investment for the private sector?
Additionally, how does all this affect Tata Steel in Wales? The Secretary of State said that he hopes British Steel will follow Tata and install electric arc technology. Well, how does Tata, which despite government support is investing a great deal of its own money in electric arc, compete with a government-funded competitor, competing for raw material at the very least, but also markets? Money-wise, in the Commons, the Secretary of State said that the cost of nationalising Specialty Steel would be met from existing budgets. He went on to remind the House of the huge sums involved, but it's quite clear that this pot is emptying fast.
So can the Minister undertake to bring detailed costings to this House, covering both valuations of this asset and the British Steel asset, as soon as they are available? Daisy Cooper MP in the Commons also raised the issue of Europe. The steel sector generally, and tariffs and carbon border taxes specifically, all hinge on our relationship with the European Union. So can the Minister agree that by having a much closer relationship with the EU, it could make many of these issues much easier to deal with and indeed iron out? And can he tell us when the government will be making substantive moves to achieve this closer relationship?
As the statement observes, the noble Lord Sharpe's government created the legacy that this government inherited. Central to this legacy has been the structurally sky-high costs faced by this and other manufacturing industries. Now, I know the Minister is new to his role, but I'm sure that energy was one of the first things he was asked about when he took over. The government has made some efforts to help some high-energy users, but these bypass most manufacturers, and for those they do affect, reductions are being cancelled out by other measures in the opposite direction happening at the same time. So can the Minister confirm and agree with me that without new measures which substantially cut energy costs so that they're much closer to our global competitors, it really doesn't matter who owns the steel industry?
With costs like this, the sector will always struggle to flourish. And I'll just close by recognising the people working in the industry and their importance. They are vital, and the UK needs their skills, and indeed the skills of many who've left the industry to come back. But these people need to know they have a future. They need to know that their industry has a future.
Now, the government has made first steps in this, but there is a great deal to do, and we on these benches will support the government where we can to help pick up momentum and get this industry back on its feet.
Speaker 73
My noble Lords, I'm grateful for the contributions and the serious consideration that the House has given to the future of Specialty Steel UK, and I will come on to address some of the specific questions that both my noble Lords have rightfully asked. But can I first of all start by echoing and thanking both noble Lords for mentioning the workforce? For them, it's a time of particular anxiety, and I think it's important that they know that regardless of party politics or party, that both this House and the other place stand fully behind the fantastic workforce. Before I get into some of the detailed answers, I think it's important just to clarify some of the facts on where we are and what the Secretary of State outlined yesterday.
Speaker 72
This is an important matter for the employees of the business, the communities surrounding its sites and the United Kingdom's wider industrial capability. I therefore welcome the opportunity to clarify the government's position, explain the decision we have taken and set out the next steps. So Speciality Steel UK entered liquidation in August 2025 and since then the independent court-appointed official receiver has been responsible for managing the liquidation process. A question was asked about how much that has cost to date. We have supported the official receiver with around 148 million pounds to date, both in terms of supporting staff but also the safety at the individual sites.
That funding has allowed the receiver to carry out his statutory duties. It's included maintenance of the site as I said and conducting a sale process for the business and its assets. And for more than 12 months the government has worked to facilitate a private sector solution and my noble lord is right to say that a private sector solution remains the first preference. As part of that process the official receiver engaged with a number of parties interested in acquiring the business and its assets. And the party granted preferential bidder status by the official receiver subsequently sought government support in connection with its proposed acquisition of Speciality Steel and we engaged extensively with the bidder and its advisors and considered the request in detail.
To clarify they were requesting upfront financial commitment from the government. And following the work that we did we concluded that we could not provide the support on the terms proposed. And this decision was not taken lightly. The government carefully examined the proposal and explored whether an arrangement could be reached that would provide a sustainable basis for the future of the business while offering appropriate protection for public money. And despite that extensive engagement material concerns remained regarding the evidence supporting the proposed support package and the protections available for taxpayers.
Now I want to be really, really clear because I think this is important that we're talking specifically about the financial support that was requested. That should not be interpreted as a wider judgment on the bidder itself or its other business activities either here or elsewhere. So our responsibility was to assess the proposal before us, include whether it provided a suitably robust basis for intervention and the appropriate safeguards and having considered those matters we could not support the proposal on the terms put forward. However that conclusion does not diminish the significance of Speciality Steel UK. The business occupies a unique place in the United Kingdom's steel ecosystem.
Specialist capabilities have potential applications in advanced manufacturing, aerospace and defence. Therefore it is of strategic importance and that's why the government remains committed to the sites, to the workforces, to the local communities and the local economies that are impacted. So we believe therefore the viable future options should be assessed properly before the range of possibilities is permanently narrowed. And for that reason the government will engage with the official receiver's sale process and develop a proposal for the public acquisition of Speciality Steel UK. And any engagement will respect the independence of the official receiver and his statutory responsibilities.
Developing a proposal does not remove the need for proper processes to be followed nor does it prejudge the outcome of the work underway. So the purpose of developing an acquisition proposal is to preserve control of the sites and maintain every option available while decisions are taken about their longer term future.
And let me stress, public acquisition is not the end point. And it's also not the first preference. It would not in itself determine the permanent future of the business, its operations or its sites. Rather, it would create the space required for detailed assessment of the available options. And these include a sustainable future for Speciality Steel UK as a speciality steelmaker supporting advanced manufacturing sectors, the regeneration of the sites, or the combination of the two.
And this government will remain focused on engaging closely with the employees, with the trade unions, with the local communities, with elected representatives, with the mayor, industry experts and other interested parties. And again, I open that offer to my noble lords on all sides of the house too. I recognise that noble lords will want and expect proper safeguards for public money. They have that firm commitment from me and from the Secretary of State. All options carry significant costs.
There's no point pretending otherwise. The risks exist and significant costs exist. That includes the risk of immediate closure. And we will develop our estimates as the work progresses. And again, I'm happy to share those assessments as much as possible with noble lords on all sides of the house.
I also recognise the desire for certainty, particularly amongst employees and their families. So it would not be responsible to preempt the detailed assessment or suggest that decisions have already been taken where they have not. But equally, I think it's important that potentially viable options are not lost by default. And I think the approach that the government has set out yesterday and today strikes that right balance of giving reassurance to the workforce, of keeping every option on the table and making sure we've got the backup of a public acquisition option. I think that is the right and responsible course to take.
Some specific questions that I've not addressed. I've already said around the private sector preference being the first one. Secondly, we should accept that there is a global challenge around steel, not just a UK challenge. Third, I recognise the challenge set out by both noble lords that we have to drive down the cost of living and also the cost of doing business as relates to energy. And that is something that is of course of huge, huge significance and importance for us if we are going to make sure we're protecting our steel industry, but also industries that are very energy intensive.
And these are all considerations of course that are being made in advance of the budget. I noted from my noble lord's questions there were many questions that I think relate to that budget process. And I imagine those are questions we'll come back to as we get closer to and at that budget point. I also noted that my noble lord spoke about history and not repeating the mistakes of the past. All I would say, he is very selective in which part of history he chose and which bits we do not want to repeat.
I think there are other parts of our history that we don't want to repeat and we need to learn lessons from. And my noble lord from the Liberal Democrats asked questions around finding longer-term private sector solutions. We're only going to find those longer-term private sector solutions if we make the steel industry a sustainable industry in the country, if we get the energy crisis right, if we address the challenges around the broader cost of production, if we deliver the orders that are required for there to be manageable order books and to be a functioning business, and also back it up with the appropriate skills. The steel strategy is ambitious, but it's also deliverable. And we've all got work to do to make sure that happens.
But let me just repeat again that I commit to work with noble lords on all sides to make sure they're fully abbreviated of the situation as this develops. There was one last final point, sorry, which is around the relationship with the European Union. I think if there's one lesson, of course some of that will come from the UK-EU summit that we continue to work towards. But I think there's also a wider lesson in terms of defensive and protection measures that we're all grappling with, that the UK is grappling with when it comes to its steel industry, but also the EU is grappling with when it comes with its steel industry. And I think the more that the relevant ministers and governments across Europe, the continent, work together in lockstep on many of those same issues we're confronting together, the better I think it'll be for our industry here in the UK, but also for steel industries across Europe.
Magid Magid
Can I welcome the noble lord to his position?
I look forward to quizzing him as someone from Sheffield from a steelmaking heritage. I will miss his noble friend Lord Leong's interactions. I really enjoyed them and I wish him well. But can I just make two points? One is about that frictionless relationship with the EU, so whatever barriers, whatever bureaucracy you can take away in that reset with the European Union would be welcomed from these benches in particular.
Can I just pick up on the point that my noble friend Lord Fox raised about the people? Because due to the unstable nature of the industry for the last couple of years, it has lost some skilled, experienced workers, both through redundancy but also those who have sought stability elsewhere. So therefore I do want to press the minister around how do we, as my noble friend said, how do we bring back that skills base and also how do we grow the next generation in terms of apprenticeships? So I would welcome the noble Lord's responses to both that people question that he rightly commented on at the beginning, but I would like to press him further.
Speaker 72
I thank the noble Lord for the question and let me reassure him that my noble friend will continue to fact-check me on a regular basis in the absence of him answering the questions directly. Look, I think the workforce is fundamental to this. And of course we will make decisions based upon what it means for production, what it means for GDP, what it means for growth, what it means for broader calculations, but in actual fact for these communities, either those that work directly in these sites or the ones who rely upon these sites in terms of employment, for them it's their everyday life. And I think if you look at where many of these sites are, particularly for Speciality Steel UK, they're amongst some of the most deprived communities in the country. And therefore it's really important that the government works right across government, so that's Department for Education, the DWP, as well as BIS colleagues, as well as the local authority, as well as the broader mayor and the regional authority, to make sure where we can we're protecting these jobs, where we can we're providing reskilling opportunities, but also to the noble Lord's point, how are we making sure that the next generation also feel as if this is a sector they want to train and then also work in as well, because that too is very much part of having a sustainable steel future for the UK.
Speaker 50
My Lords, can I congratulate my noble friend on his patience in dealing with some of the questions from opposition spokesmen? I mean, it really is quite astonishing. I am old enough to go back to the Thatcher years, and in 1980 when she appointed Sir Ian MacGregor to run the British Steel Corporation and closed down Redcar, Port Talbot, Consett, Corby, Shotton, Ebbw Vale, and in Scotland, Ravenscraig. Let's make sure that the Tories are never allowed to forget that. Would my noble friend consider arranging a little seminar so that they can learn from history?
Speaker 72
I thank my noble friend for the usually robust contribution he's made. I would gently tell my noble friend that whilst he was here to witness what happened in 1980 and therefore tell us the lessons that must be learned, I was born in 1983.
Speaker 75
My Lords, if there are no further questions, questions on the statement made in the House of Commons on Thursday the 10th of September, update on Ukraine and threats from Russia.
Speaker 74
My Lords, I thank the noble lord the minister for giving us the opportunity to ask questions on this statement. May I first pay tribute to the British service member who tragically died in a road traffic accident in Ukraine on Saturday. It is a truly saddening affair when we lose a member of our armed forces, and my thoughts and those of the entire House are with his family. My Lords, it is welcome that the new Secretary of State has reaffirmed so convincingly the government's commitment to support Ukraine in its battle for the survival of its homeland. It was also welcome to see our new Prime Minister, as one of his very first acts in office, visit Ukraine and meet with President Zelenskyy and hand the president something of real value to his nation.
May I also put on record my deep concern at the Russian strikes on the railway in Western Ukraine over the weekend. Fortunately, the train carrying the former Prime Minister Boris Johnson and the current National Security Adviser, amongst other key diplomats, wasn't hit, but for Russia to potentially attempt to target serving and former senior British government officials, if indeed this was their intention, is extremely concerning. My party stands resolutely behind the government in its continued support for Ukraine. My Lords, in many ways this statement somehow manages to simultaneously tell us quite a lot while also telling us very little at all. It tells us a lot because we now know the new Defence Secretary wishes to approach the job much like the last two.
That is to say, he likes to talk about the nature of the threats we face as a nation, but fails to realize the scale of the investment that will be required and, crucially, the pace at which that investment needs to be delivered. Indeed, the Secretary of State in his statement said, the threats we face are not only evolving, they are getting closer to home. Every day, the UK and our allies encounter espionage, cyberattacks and military posturing by hostile states. My Lords, I completely agree. Threats to the United Kingdom are getting closer to home.
But what concerns me, my Lord, is that even after accurately recognizing those threats, the Defence Secretary went on to simply repeat the government's line, emphasizing how much was already being spent. That is where the statement tells us very little. I will happily concede that the government has increased defence spending, but the scale of that increase pales in comparison to what is truly needed now and, as of yet, we are no closer to eliciting the vital detail on defence spending and the timing of that expenditure that we have sought for the last two years. The government tells us that spending will reach 2.7% next year, up from 2.3% when they entered office, but they conveniently neglect to mention that they've changed the definition of defence expenditure to include the single intelligence account. The defence investment plan was essentially unfunded, and we now know that the Chancellor is unlikely to establish the path to 3% by 2030 until the next spending review in 2027, rather than at the upcoming autumn budget.
And now we have a Prime Minister who has stated openly that national security cannot come at the expense of social security. This is a worryingly short-sighted statement to make at such a critical juncture. As my noble friend Lady Goldie said last week, these benches are united in our view that national security comes above all other priorities. Can the noble lord the minister confirm whether the government's position has indeed changed, or whether they do still regard national security and defence as the paramount duty of government, over and above welfare.
More importantly, my Lords, it is not necessarily how much is spent, although that really does matter, but what we are getting for that money. We have heard that the army is being required to cut virtually all meaningful training exercises and, in a bid to save money, the reserves are also suffering. We currently have no attack submarines available to go to sea, and it took us weeks to prepare HMS Dragon for operations to protect British bases in Cyprus. The decision on the number of the AUKUS submarines to be procured has reportedly been delayed until 2028, and, my Lords, when will the government announce the locations and start building the six new energetics factories we were promised in the SDR? The Defence Secretary said in his statement, "I have seen the capabilities that this country has and they are considerable."
Indeed, my Lords, the Secretary of State is correct, but these capabilities are not considerable enough for the growing challenge, and, I might add, they are diminishing in real terms. As an example, the renewed challenge from Argentina to British sovereignty over the Falkland Islands could, heaven forbid, mutate into an overt threat. We must ensure that we have the capabilities to respond appropriately should that situation occur. My Lords, to bring this back to Ukraine, what happens if we end up with a ceasefire, which we all hope and pray for, and British troops are committed to Ukraine? Will they be sufficiently resourced to ensure they can fight to the best of their abilities?
I know there is deep concern about the answer to that question. And finally, my Lords, the new Secretary of State said that there is an enormous amount of consensus and national unity when it comes to defence. Might I gently say to the noble Lord the Minister that this is not entirely correct. There is indeed an absolute consensus between us on the issue of our continuing support for Ukraine, but there is not that consensus on whether or not this government is doing all that it should to prepare us for any major conflict in the near future. My Lords, this statement has bravado abound, but bravado is meaningless if it's not backed by hard power.
We do not say this to embarrass the government or to score political points. We say this because we are worried about our lack of defence readiness. I urge the government, do not place social security above national security, as the Prime Minister suggested last week, for when the bombs are falling and the drones are striking, as warned by the Chancellor only a few weeks ago, there may be very little social security left to speak of.
Julie Smith
My Lords, from these benches, I would like thoroughly to endorse everything the Earl of Minto has just said. We often say that on matters of defence, the official opposition and these benches are at one with His Majesty's government, but there are a range of issues that need to be dealt with, scrutinised, and reassessed. And while, as the Earl of Minto pointed out, it is excellent that the new Secretary of State for Defence has pledged his commitment and the country's ongoing commitment to Ukraine, and that the new Secretary of State and the new Prime Minister have been to Ukraine, that is a fundamental sign of the commitment of this United Kingdom to Ukraine and very much to be welcomed. But in the statement made in the other place, there are still a range of questions that need to be reviewed and looked at in more detail. Before I go further, I would also like to associate myself with the words of the noble Lord the Earl of Minto and pass on our condolences to the family of the service person lost in Ukraine last week in the road traffic accident.
That loss and the loss of any personnel is a sign of just what every member of His Majesty's Armed Forces puts on the line in the service of our country day in and day out, and we all acknowledge that. My Lords, we seem to have a sense in which from the front benches on defense, we are really clear that as the Secretary of State for Defense said in his statement last week, if the first duty of government is to keep our country safe, then that is greater and more a greater and more urgent responsibility than it has been for generations. That is clearly true. And yet we don't seem to have a sense of urgency from the Chancellor of the Exchequer in his current incarnation or the Prime Minister. That to suggest that national security can't come at the expense of social security, as the noble Lord, the Earl of Minto has already pointed out, raises some serious questions.
What is His Majesty's government doing in terms of ensuring that by the time we get to the spending review next year? So we understand that we're not going to get the clarity we might want at the budget in the autumn. But by next spring, what will the Chancellor be doing to ensure that we are on track for the 3.5% that the Secretary of State for Defense has recommitted to? Because at the moment we don't have clarity on that. In the wee small hours of the night last week, as we got to the end of committee stage of the Armed Forces Bill, I wrapped up group 13 with all expediency possible, which meant we didn't discuss my amendment in great detail on the implications of the delays in the defense investment plan for small and medium-sized enterprises.
It's an issue that we do need to think about because we need to be absolutely clear that the government is investing and ensuring that we have the drones and the interceptors and everything else that we're making pledges to Ukraine about, that we also have for our own security and defense. Because Ukraine might be at the front line of our security, but His Majesty's government owes it to our country as well as to Ukraine and our NATO allies to make sure that we're investing here and now.
Vernon Coaker
My Lords, can I start by thanking Earl Minto and Baroness Smith for overall their constructive remarks and rightful challenge to the government. So can I thank them for that. Can I start with a few introductory remarks? And as both the Earl Minto and Baroness Smith started, noble Lords will be aware that a member of the UK Armed Forces died in a road traffic incident in Ukraine this Saturday, the 12th of September. I'm sure the whole House will join with me in extending our deepest condolences to the individual's family and loved ones, as well as to their colleagues in the Armed Forces at this difficult and tragic time.
Further details are expected to be released in due course. However, I must reiterate that this incident was not the result of hostile action. Over the weekend and into this week, noble Lords would have seen reports of the continued Russian long-range attacks, including on gas and rail infrastructure near the Ukraine-Poland border as mentioned by the Earl Minto.
Indeed, we saw yet another Russian drone incursion overnight, this time into Lithuania, prompting a swift response from allies, particularly obviously the Italians. These reckless and dangerous strikes against civilian infrastructure underline the wider security threat that Russia poses to Europe. The UK continues to stand firmly with Ukraine, and I'm proud that support for Ukraine continues to unite this House. And can I thank, genuinely thank the Earl Minto and Baroness Smith for their comments about that. And also Earl Minto's points about the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State for Defence.
Can I also say to him in that spirit, we also remember that the last government stood steadfast as well in its commitment to Ukraine and to defend Ukraine against the illegal invasion by Russia. And I think that political unity is of such immense importance in the way that Russia sees our response. And that's true of both the last government, this government, and indeed the support right across this House. And I think it's something that we should never, ever tire of saying because it is repeated time and time again with our adversaries. So that is why the latest Ukraine Defence Contact Group earlier this month, we announced we will contribute a further 100 million towards PERLS, which will support the delivery of Patriot missiles and other air defence equipment.
We also reaffirmed our commitment to provide more than 120,000 drones to Ukraine over the course of the year. In total, the United Kingdom has committed 25 billion for Ukraine, and that includes nearly 20 million rounds of small arms ammunition, more than 1 million artillery shells, more than 100,000 drones, and thousands of air defence missiles and armoured vehicles. And we must remind ourselves, if there is anything Putin has achieved through this war, it has been to strengthen NATO, to strengthen the West, and to weaken Russia. And I point, I just said to Earl Minto that I would start with a few introductory remarks before I answer the specific questions because I think it's important to lay some of that on the table and to repeat that in your Lordships' House. Specifically, I'll deal with defence spending towards the end.
Specifically on small and medium-sized enterprises, they do form a major part of the government's attempts to ensure that we have the defence industrial base that we need, both for now and in the future. The noble Baroness as Earl Minto will know, as indeed many others will know, that there are small and medium-sized businesses provide that agility that sometimes the larger companies can't. There is an issue around regulations, which they have no doubt continually raised, and we will see what we can do with that to ensure those small and medium-sized enterprises can develop as quickly as they could. The Earl Minto asked me about the munitions factories. Feasibility studies for future energetics facilities are due to report later this month, while construction of new UK energetics facilities is planned to commence later this year.
So I hope that answers the specific point about the munitions factories. On the Falkland Islands, we remain, as I think was in a very well-attended and thoughtful, again, united discussion and debate in your Lordships' House I think last week, the government, with all of your Lordships' House and indeed the other place, reiterated our strong commitment to the protection of the Falkland Islands and a reminder to everyone that the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands is a matter for the Falkland Islanders themselves, and we will support them in that. As the Earl Minto, I don't know whether he's had the opportunity of, but I'm sure some members of the House have had the opportunity of going there to see the defence base that is there, the Typhoon jets that are there, the air defence system, the troops that are there with other defence equipment in order to protect the Falkland Islands, but purely from a defensive posture, just to highlight that.
So that remains the government's position as it's remained the position for decades for our country. On the issue of the Russian threat, in order to try and make the Earl Minto's point for him, but also to I think just highlight for all of us some of the just to make it real, just to give some of the statistics. NATO has scrambled aircraft over 700 times in the past two years to intercept Russian aircraft approaching allies' airspace, and the current rate of Russian long-range aviation in the High North is the highest in six years. If the noble lord, I think it's helpful just to give some of these statistics. Russian aircraft and drones have violated airspaces across multiple NATO countries, and UK aircraft have experienced GPS jamming.
There's been a 30% increase in Russian vessels threatening UK waters in the past two years. And just picking out again, Navy, the Navy has escorted Russian vessels for 21 days in July, and activations to monitor Russian support is up 25% in the first eight months of 2026 compared to 2025. And just one last point on a whole range of statistics, just to give your lordships' house a flavor of the threat from Russia, over 90,000 attempted cyberattacks in a year on UK defense networks, a large proportion coming from Russian-speaking actors. So I hope that's helpful to the house because it's just to make the point, not hiding behind that, there is a very real threat, which obviously then takes us to the whole discussion about defense spending. And just I would say, I don't think we should just dismiss the fact that the government has increased defense spending.
There is an argument about the pace and the amount, but the government has significantly increased defense spending. And I would point out that the 15 billion that was announced in-year is a significant thing for a government, as some of you who've had more experience of being in government than I have will know, that to actually change a budget in the middle of the budgetary year is quite a difficult thing to do. And taking 15 billion or finding 15 billion from other government departments to increase the Ministry of Defence budget was quite a significant change, and I've made that point to your lordships before. And the final piece of that jigsaw, the 4.7 billion, will be provided in the autumn budget that's coming up. And I don't know whether anybody has had, certainly a number of the people in the other house have had experience of where changes have been made to budgets in local areas which to fund defense, which have caused some controversy, which shows that we need to win that debate about increased defense spending.
The noble lord knows that the spending review next spring will be the time in which we get to a point where actually the government lays out its trajectory to 3.5% by 2035, and clearly within that, at some point, clearly obviously 3% will be passed, but when that actually is will be laid out by the Chancellor in the budget next year. In terms of national security and social security, let me just say this where I come from for it. Of course you want to see a reduced social security bill because it means more people will be back to work, more people will be active, all of those sorts of things. So I think if the government's back-to-work campaign and the various measures there, hopefully what one will see was a reduction in that budget. And of course national security remains the prime duty of government.
But we have to win as well as winning the debate in here, we have to win the debate out there with people that any changes to budget, any reductions that may or may not be able to be made in the social security is not done at the expense of those people who depend on those things, but also we actually have that money available to spend on defense in the way that we would want and in a way which is supported by the population of this country. And I would suggest that that debate, that still has to be won with some sectors of our population and we shouldn't take that for granted.
Speaker 66
My Lords, we have now to have 20 minutes for questions from the backbench. Can I remind my noble Lords to keep remarks brief and to ask a question so that we can get as many contributions in as possible.
Speaker 75
My Lords, Lord Campbell-Savours is taking part remotely. I invite Lord Campbell-Savours to speak.
Dale Campbell-Savours
My Lords, why don't we put aside our immediate reservations about Trump with all his idiosyncrasies, certainly following his disastrous miscalculations on intervention in the Middle East, and then join his people in any talks that might take place seeking a settlement in the Ukraine conflict? And if we want to be more adventurous as a compromise, promote the idea of protectorate status, protectorate status in Eastern Ukraine to include Donetsk and Luhansk, underpinned by guarantees from the major powers to include the United States, Europe and Russia. There are precedents. We need to think out of the box and stem the escalation referred to by my noble friend the Minister in his statement. Thank you.
Vernon Coaker
Well can I thank my noble friend for for his question. Of course we have to prevent de-escalation and be careful in the language that we use, which I think by and large this House does because it's aware that a word misplaced can actually have very serious consequences. Let me let me just say to my noble friend though, we all want to see a ceasefire in in Ukraine. As far as the government is concerned, the obstacle to that is Russia and that it's it's they're the problem with it. And let me also say the fundamental principle for all of us is that any ceasefire should be done with the acceptance and support of Ukraine itself.
And that is a really important and fundamental principle for that. In terms of what comes after, we that's why the UK with France has been leading the coalition of the willing, the the possibility of the multinational force to so that any agreement that is rate reached has the backing of that support rather of that multinational force so it can make sure that it's not just written on paper but it's secure in any arrangements that it comes to.
Speaker 79
My Lords, my Lords, the Minister's completely correct to reject the appeasement put forward in the previous question. We have to do everything we can to ensure Ukraine defeat Russia. That's the only way this conflict is going to be resolved. And with that in mind, what can the Minister tell me what more we can do to disrupt the flow of Russian oil which is underpinning Putin's economy? Russia experts tell me this will be the best way to put pressure on Putin.
So what thought has the government given to taking sanctions and measures against the refineries in places like India and Turkey which are which are refining the oil for Putin?
Vernon Coaker
Well can I first of all can I thank the noble Lord for his his comments about standing up against Russia.
The UK government has done has taken made significant effort to disrupt the Russian economy through sanctions and through various measures that it's that it's taken. And I I just think it's really important to also recognize that the the impact on Russia. And it gives me the so we significant billions of pounds has been sanctioned, many ships have been disrupted, etc, etc. But let me just again share because this isn't often done. Let me just share with my noble friend the noble friend the economic impact on Russia so far.
Because the the idea is that no nothing has worked. Russia's GDP growth has slowed from over 4% in 23-24 to around 1% in 2025, with Russia's Ministry of Economic Development forecasting only 0.4% growth in 2026. That's a significant achievement, I would say. That we need to actually say more about the impact that it's has. Inflation expectations rose in July to their highest level, 14.7% in years.
The deteriorating economic picture is directly hitting average Russians with projected growth in Russians' real incomes to slow to 1.6 in 2026, down from 7.7% last year. And we've seen the queues that there have been for fuel as well. So all I all I'm saying is that there's a lot more to be done. I I absolutely accept that. But let's also give credit to the impact that what we are doing is having an impact on Russia as well.
And at that time let's remind that our our dispute with Russia is with the leadership, not with the Russian people.
Speaker 81
I agree with everything that the Earl of Minto said. And I want to come back to home. And as the Minister said, the threats are real. But one has the impression that the government is not doing enough to protect the British citizens. And it reminds me a little bit of my father, who is French, who said that just before World War II, the French were so much in disbelief that Germany could invade them as they had suffered so much during World War I, that there was a little bit of a the expression head in the sand.
And I have the feeling that we are actually not taking the threats to this country seriously enough.
Vernon Coaker
Well, I think it's difficult to to to argue that completely. Because why would we be doing what we're doing in Ukraine? You know, under the under the last government and under this government, if we didn't believe that the freedom of Ukraine was ultimately and intrinsically linked with our own freedom and the freedom of all of Europe. Why would we be supporting NATO in all of the ways in which we have with respect to infringements of airspace, what we do with Poland? Why have we got troops in Estonia?
Why are we talking about all of the various things about the possibility of tactical nuclear weapons on F-35As? And ultimately, why is it that we spend a quarter of the defense budget on the nuclear deterrent, which is the ultimate guarantor of our freedom, the freedom of Europe and the freedom of the world? And let's remind ourselves that we guarantee although the Prime Minister retains the ultimate decider in its use on us, that guarantee, that nuclear guarantee, that nuclear umbrella is explicitly given towards the defense of Europe. So I think there are challenges, but we can I don't think it's fair to say, I don't think it's fair to say that this government is weak when it comes to Russia.
Speaker 83
My Lords, the Minister's been clear and other statements have made clear the the risk from Russia is rising.
The common usage is often the word hybrid, but we also now see that associated with sabotage attacks across Europe. So we need to take that threat seriously. And I think in the spirit of this debate, this discussion, we need a stronger narrative on defence. And we need to embrace all elements of our society in that narrative. We need to build on the points around the readiness in defence, both for regulars and importantly for our reserve forces.
And it's a declare my interest as President Reserves for the UK, our reserve forces have never been more important. Through that, we can build stronger resilience. And it's resilience that's going to see us through. And it's that resilience that has seen us through before. And so in building resilience, Minister, do you agree that it's time to have a bigger conversation and strengthen the whole narrative around defence and security?
Vernon Coaker
I I do absolutely agree with that. And certainly the government are looking at accelerating the progress or not that it is making with respect to a national conversation. The noble and gallant Lord is absolutely right when he talks about resilience and the need to have a whole of society approach. I couldn't agree more, and the government is certainly working to deliver that. I I think the the important thing is to actually, which is why I mentioned the 90,000 cyber attacks, because I think that that people that we need to get through to people, it may not be Russian paratroopers landing in the middle of Nottingham, but it that the cyber attack is happening now.
We've seen some of the activity in Salisbury and elsewhere on on our own soil. We've seen some of the way in which global conflict impacts on the domestic fuel price and the impact that has. So we need to to explain that much more fully. On the reserves, I couldn't agree more. And and the the importance of the reserves is central, which is why I was so proud and pleased to go to Grantham, which the noble and gallant Lord will know very well.
I was pleased to go to the Prince William Barracks on Saturday morning to celebrate the passing out of approximately 800 reserves, and their importance and the pride that they had and their families had was immense, and we need to build on that.
Speaker 91
The the situation in we face in Ukraine is nothing new. In the Crimea in 2014, Russia annexed it when the party opposite were slashing the defence budget by 16%. Likewise, the problem we have now with our nuclear deterrent was down to the Liberal Democrats who were couldn't make their mind up about whether to replace the nuclear deterrent. But having visited Lithuania earlier this year, they're under constant attack, not just as Lord Peter just said about sabotage, but by drone incursions. Is it not about time now that NATO take the fight to Russia on Ukrainian territory to take down these drones?
Vernon Coaker
I I think we I think we do need to be careful about talking about taking Russian drones down in Ukrainian airspace. However, my my noble friend is absolutely right when he talks about the need for a robust response to the incursions that we've seen. And he talked about Lithuania. He will know that the NATO response was strong and powerful, and a drone was shot down there following detection shortly after midnight. And I think that is a really important indicator.
I'm not sure whether everybody is aware, but additionally this morning at approximately 11 o'clock, an unidentified object was spotted on the radars close to Vilnius Airport, leading to its closure.
Fighter jets from the NATO Baltic Air Policing were scrambled to respond to that. So, in answer to my noble friend, she's absolutely right that Russia needs to know that incursions into NATO airspace will be dealt with robustly and strongly in the way that it has been.
Speaker 86
My Lords, we need to acknowledge, I think, the immense efforts that the Ukrainians themselves have made in their defense. That they have been innovative, that they have been collaborative, and that they have been very successful in their fight against the Russian invasion. But I think we also, and we also have to acknowledge that the support that NATO has given them significantly. And but what I do think we need to do is think about what comes next. We need to help the Ukrainians build their industry, build their defense industries, and help them to grow beyond the innovative stage to be so that they don't risk them being taken over by the United States, by the big Western companies, and that they can build their defense industry for themselves, for their because the threat from Russia is not going to go away readily.
Vernon Coaker
I think the bravery and courage of the Ukrainian people cannot be overstated. It's simply immense. And when you when you think about, and I think this is a point I've made again, but I'm going to make it again, Russia did not attack Ukraine when it did in the belief that years later it would still be fighting. It believed, as I'm sure our former ambassador would say, that three days or so after the attack, they were going to be in Kyiv and they were going to install a government there which would be pro-Russian. They did not attack in the belief that they would be where they are now with a million and a half casualties, God knows how much money cost, etcetera, etcetera.
And it is the it is to the immense credit of the Ukrainian people that that has remained possible, not only in the face of the initial invasion, but the continued way in which they've stood firm as they have done. And I agree with my noble friend, we not only need to support them in terms of their war effort, but to continue to discuss with them and work with them about what will happen in the future. But the immediate priority is to secure the sovereignty of their country.
Speaker 89
My Lords, I would like us just for a moment to concentrate on the incredible loss of human life in this conflict. The noble Lord mentioned the economic cost to Russia, and indeed he mentioned the human cost just now. But it's worth remembering that Russia has suffered one and a half million casualties, and that compares to about 125, 150,000 on the Ukrainian side. Of course, all to be lamented. But it is worth noting, I think, that the cost to Russia has been absolutely astonishing.
And one has to think a little bit, on whichever side these people are, the awful cost into families and people, the tragedy of all of these lives that have been lost.
Vernon Coaker
Well, I think all of us would deplore the loss of life and are we're all human and we reflect on the casualties, the killed and the wounded, the impact psychologically on many people. We don't talk about the numbers in Ukraine in terms of casualties, but clearly the suffering that there's been in Ukraine and all of that is important for us to remember. But the only thing I would say, there's one person who was responsible for invading Ukraine, and as far as I can see, that person is responsible for the consequences.
But we all hope that as soon as possible, we get a ceasefire that is acceptable to Ukraine and the slaughter and killing stops.
Charles John Fuller
My Lords, last week, 18 maritime nations responsible for about a fifth of the global ship tonnage warned that global shipping rules are collapsing. We're an island nation. We depend on shipborne trade. But the dark fleet threatens a structural risk to trade under IMO rules. And of course, the IMO is based here in London.
How are our armed forces ensuring that ships can maintain free passage in pursuance of the free trade that generates wealth and supports our economy?
Vernon Coaker
Well, I think in my remarks to in response to Lord Minto, we talked about the numbers for 21 days, I think from I can't find it in the note, but I think I said 21 days in July, ships were escorted by the Royal Navy. We see our ships deployed not only in the channel but elsewhere. We had the carrier in the North Atlantic supported there to ensure that shipping was protected. We have relationships and alliances and agreements with countries across the whole of Europe and beyond. And in that way, we can ensure that we protect as much as we can the merchant shipping upon which we all depend and do something about sanctioning the Russian fleet.
If the noble Lord's question is about building more ships, we are.
Speaker 87
My Lords, I welcome the statement which says, and I quote, "Russia is constantly probing and testing us." And in terms of the narrative of what is happening, is it time to use perhaps less of the euphemistic language of malign actors, especially in regard to the very large number of cyberattacks to which my noble friend has already referred? Because when you take the recent case of an aborted drone attack on a German airfield, which thank heavens didn't work, the German government, as I understand it, has reached the view that it has now got the evidence to openly blame the state of Russia for that attack. Is that an approach that we should take as and when the government has evidence to that effect?
Vernon Coaker
Well, I think if you have evidence that something has happened, then it is quite right to actually talk about drone attacks such as the one that my noble friend refers to in Germany at Leipzig Airport. I think one thing that is incumbent upon us, and I just say sometimes when I'm asked questions, I actually would want to go further than I do. I would actually want to use language that to be stronger, more powerful about it. But I also recognize that when you're a government minister, particularly at a sensitive time, particularly in a difficult situation like this and in the other place, and it was true it would be true under whatever government you had, you have to be extraordinarily careful about what language you use in case you generate unintended consequences. And I feel a real responsibility sometimes for that because I'm not the person flying the jet.
I'm not the person in the ship. I'm not the person undertaking various activities. So I do think my noble friend is absolutely right that where we have the evidence, we do have to say what has happened, explain the threat to the British people, whilst at the same time being extraordinarily careful with the language that we use in case, as I say, we generate unintended consequences.
Speaker 88
My Lords, the Minister agreed, he's referred to cyberattacks, he's referred to drone probing and other members of the House. But that's just part of the picture. There's also threats to factories doing things for Ukrainians, sabotage at them, murder in the London streets.
Speaker 90
There were firebombs on DHL aircraft. The shadow fleet, what they're doing at sea, equally worrying. And of course, the threat to our undersea cables. If we lose those, we're in disaster. So I want just to suggest, I want to ask the Minister, very grateful for what he's said so far, the scale and range of what the Russians are doing to us is broader than has been so far said in this House.
And that's beyond as well conventional espionage and all the other things they do.
Vernon Coaker
Well, can I thank the noble Baroness for that? I think she's absolutely right. And it's the sin of omission not to mention underwater cables and some of the other points that she mentioned in the remarks that she made. And she's absolutely right to mention that. And being able to explain that to the British people is, I think, really important.
And of course, part of the problem as well, I think, is that, and she will know this better than me from the responsibility that she had, is the work of the services as well to protect the country. And some of the work they do with others is unreported in many respects, but deals with many of the particular issues to which the noble Baroness points out. I'm proud of the work that the services do, the bravery and courage that they show. We often talk quite right, talk quite rightly about our armed forces, but also the fact that day in, day out, MI5, MI6 and other of the intelligence services protect us from harm and protect the public from harm, both at home and abroad. And we should celebrate what they do as well.
Speaker 76
My Lords, we now come to the third reading of the Financial Services and Markets Bill, Lord Pitt-Watson.
David Pitt
My Lords, I will begin by making a short statement on the position regarding legislative consent on the bill. Legislative consent from the Northern Ireland Assembly and the Scottish Parliament is required for clauses 49 and 51, which concern cryptoassets and their seizure and recovery by UK law enforcement. These relate in part to matters that are devolved matters in respect of Scotland and transferred matters in respect of Northern Ireland. The government have written to the Northern Ireland Executive and the Scottish Government on this matter, and my expectation is that these issues will be fully addressed during the bill's passage in the other place. We remain committed to sustained engagement with the devolved governments for the remainder of the bill's passage.
Speaker 82
The question is that the bill be now read a third time. As many of that opinion say content, the contrary not content, the contents have it. In clause 16, amendment 1, Lord Pitt-Watson.
David Pitt
My Lords, I beg to move this bill be read a third time. Let me begin with amendment 1, to which I will also speak to the other government amendments tabled in my name. At report and in committee, we discussed the fact that climate-related risks and nature-related risks can have significant implications for the economy, for financial markets, for long-term prosperity and for the ability of the finance industry to do its job properly. We heard a number of calls to ensure that the financial services regulators continue to prioritize this agenda at a day-to-day level.
However, it is important that this is done in a way that is aligned with the government's wider regulatory strategy and does not result in a new a new set of have-regards which would further complicate the regulatory framework rather than make it simpler and more effective as the bill is intended to do. The amendments tabled in my name deliver on the commitment I made last week to require the FCA and PRA to continue to have regard to their existing climate change and environmental targets regulatory principle at a day-to-day level and to maintain appropriate notification and reporting requirements as part of that. So amendments 1 and 3 amend clause 16, formerly clause 17, so that the FCA and PRA must have regard to the climate and environmental targets principle when discharging their general functions. And amendments 5 to 8 ensure that the regulators must report appropriately on their consideration of the principle, including in annual reports and consultations. Amendments 2, 4 and 9 then ensure that certain references and definitions are correct and account for these changes.
Put together, these amendments will ensure that the FCA and PRA continue to have an appropriate focus on this vital issue. I beg to move.
Speaker 82
Amendment proposed, clause 16, page 21, line 17, after principle insert and the climate environment regulatory principle.
Helene Hayman
My Lords, I'm extremely grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for the clarity with which he has introduced these amendments. I'm even more grateful to him for the very great care and attention that he and his team of officials gave to the concerns that were raised across the House about the not just the perception but the reality of what clause 17 as previously drafted would have done to the ability of regulators and the duty and responsibility of regulators to take in their day-to-day functions proper cognizance of the risks to financial markets and to industry and to our economy of changes in the climate and changes in the natural environment. What we have managed to do, I think, is find a way forward that keeps within the bounds of what was the government's intention in terms of regulation but doesn't sacrifice a focus that if nothing else this summer gave us some real experience of the effects that can happen through these issues, I think particularly of the insurance industry and of the housing market and the effects that are already being felt in these. It's been quite a struggle to get here and I think we've gone down some byways, but I think in the end we have reached absolutely the right conclusion and I'm extremely grateful to the Minister and absolutely support these amendments.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, it's a pleasure to very briefly follow the noble Lady Baroness Hayman and applaud the noble Lady's and her allies' work that has got us to this place, as she said, after a great deal of struggle. One day we will just simply have these arriving in the bills without the need for struggle, we can but hope. But I just have one simple question to put to the noble Lord the Minister, and this was inspired by attending the Gravesend people's emergency briefing on climate and nature on Saturday night, one of some 3,500 already held after the initial event in Westminster all around the country. Now, we've yet to hear from the Conservative front bench, but house rumour suggests that they are going to oppose this amendment. If that is indeed the case, would the noble Lord the Minister agree with me that they would benefit from seeing this briefing?
And therefore, can I ask the Minister, as this is the first time I've asked with the new Prime Minister, if the government will organize a live national televised emergency briefing on climate and nature as all of these local events are asking?
Susan Kramer
My Lords, my colleague spoke eloquently on these issues at report, Baroness Northover and Baroness Sheehan, that if these amendments are moved by the government, we will support them.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My Lords, as this is third reading, I just wanted to start by extending my warm thanks to the noble Lord the Minister and his team for their work on the bill. I welcome the movement that the government have shown on several of the issues we've raised during the passage of this 137-page bill that in general we support. Chief among them is proportionality, which will continue to apply to the regulators in the exercise of their day-to-day functions. And that change reflects concerns on all sides of the House, and my hope is that it will help to reduce the burden on SMEs, so I thank the Minister for this. I also welcome the movement that we've seen on the important issue of financial education.
I look forward to engaging on that. It's becoming ever more important whether you are a pupil, a student applying for a loan, or an adult managing your finances or thinking about retirement. However, there remain important issues which the government has not yet addressed sufficiently. Among them are the Henry VIII powers in clause 3 and clause 50, and the first use of the extensive new powers in the bill. Now, I understand the government intend to reintroduce clause 3 at a later stage in the bill's passage with further detail, and that is welcome.
But it does not detract from the fundamental point at issue. One of Parliament's principal functions is to scrutinize government legislation, and we simply can't do so properly when bills confer broad powers without setting out clearly how they are to be used. A digital assets strategy to support faster action to stop further loss of digital entrepreneurs and less aggressive use of section 166 are two further areas where we believe the government should go further because we've heard consistent concerns from industry. My Lords, turning to the amendments, I deeply regret the fact that the government is introducing amendments today on climate change. This represents a serious U-turn by the government.
Their original proposal was to move these considerations into five-year strategies. The existing requirements they dispense with are largely superfluous and burdensome, and there is little evidence that today's amendments to restore them make any meaningful contribution either to reducing climate change or to protecting the environment. At a time when businesses are already facing considerable pressure and when our wider economic circumstances demand an unrelenting focus on growth, competitiveness, and investment, imposing further needless regulatory burdens is the wrong direction of travel.
I would also suggest that for an economy as dependent as ours on international investment, these amendments send entirely the wrong signal. We should be demonstrating to investors overseas that the UK is a predictable and attractive market. Instead, they reinforce the perception that doing business here means ever more regulation, additional cost and greater complexity for no clear practical benefit. At second reading, the then minister Lord Stockford, I'm glad to see in his place, said that the purpose of this bill was to modernize how the sector is regulated and enable it to grow. My Lords, these amendments seem to me to run directly contrary to that objective.
I'm deeply disappointed that the government have abandoned that principle so quickly and with so little resistance. We on these benches have been consistent in our opposition to this duty, which we have made clear in the house and in discussions with the minister. And I shall seek to divide the house when the amendments are called.
David Pitt
My noble Lords, I think there is a wide agreement that finance is absolutely essential for the running of our economy and that we want the British finance industry to be as successful as possible. I think that there would be few of us that would think that climate finance was not one of the most important areas to which the industry needs to contribute. And I think all of us would feel pretty proud that our country, particularly London, is rated as the number one center of green finance in the world. The noble Baroness Neville-Rolfe, I understand her wanting to minimize regulation and that this might be something superfluous, but I would just note climate is everywhere in the financial world. Why?
Because you're managing other people's money. A fund manager, possibly with millions of people who are saving, how do you think about appropriate investment? If you're responsible for the stewardship of the company, what is the sensible line that they should be taking in making sure that they're as profitable as they can be, but they're not risking the sustainability of the world? If you're an investment banker and somebody's issuing a bond, should it be a green bond? Is that fair for it to be a green bond?
Or you're thinking about the reporting on the stock exchange, should you have taken into account that the carbon assets that you have will need to be written off and you will need to have a fund and tell your investors about that? If you're interested in impact investment in REDD, I know we were talking a lot about deforestation, how is it that we manage to get private money into deforestation? Baroness, the noble Baroness Hayman talked about insurance, even your operations. Look at the sort of thing that Bloomberg has done, where now all its electricity is zero carbon. So there's lots of stuff and the UK is a leader and it's a growing area as well.
We should be absolutely proud of that. And does regulation make a difference to this? I think that is a good question. But look, if you were to look at the UK and our regulation on this and compare it with the United States, London versus New York, you would be in no doubt which was the better for promoting green finance.
Nor frankly do I know of many financiers who would say that the United States now has more predictable regulation than we have in the United Kingdom. You could say the regulator is already doing enough. And whilst I can't respond to Baroness Bennett by having a national conversation, I did organize the FCA to do a drop-in to talk to noble Lords about what it was that they were doing in this area. Every single one of you that I've talked to after that thought that it would be a mistake to withdraw the have regard and that therefore this amendment that we're putting was the right thing to do. So look my noble Lords, whether you are someone who believes in the importance of climate and environmental issues, or whether you want to be sure that Britain maintains its USP in this critical area of finance, I would urge you to vote for these amendments.
Thank you.
Speaker 82
The question is that amendment 1 be agreed to. As many of that opinion say content. The contrary not content. The question will be decided by a division. I would advise the House when voting is open.
Voting is now open. Clear the bar.
Order. Order. The question is that amendment 1 be agreed to. As many of that opinion say content. The contrary not content.
The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents the left by the bar.
Speaker 96
Order. The question is that amendment 1 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion say content.
Speaker 82
The have voted content 258, not content 109. The not contents have it. Sorry, the contents have it, the contents have it. I'm so sorry. The question is that amendments 2 to 9 en bloc be agreed to.
As many of that opinion say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. The question is that this bill do now pass. My Lords, this bill delivers important reforms to ensure that the UK's financial services sector remains open, innovative and internationally competitive while maintaining high regulatory standards and protecting consumers.
It strengthens the legislative framework for financial services, supports growth and investment and ensures that our regulators have the appropriate powers and responsibilities to respond to a rapidly changing market. The bill has benefited considerably from the detailed scrutiny and expertise of noble Lords throughout its passage. And I hope you feel that the government have listened carefully to the arguments advanced in committee and at report and that we have brought forward amendments which were appropriate in response.
David Pitt
The Bill of course is broad. It touches on lots of areas, but it's united by one common theme. I think it's a theme shared by the House that we want to create a clear set of rules which allows the financial industry to serve its customers better and to prosper by doing so. And so I would like to thank all noble Lords who contributed to our debates. Perhaps in particular my noble friend Lord Stockwood who led the early stages of the Bill.
I would also like to thank my officials who supported the Bill throughout its passage. It was no mean task. I'm particularly grateful too to the opposition and Liberal Democrat front benches. To Baroness Noakes and other members of the Financial Services Regulation Committee. To members of Peers for the Planet.
To noble Lords across the House including crossbenchers for their constructive engagement. And if I had a special thank you, it would be to my whip, my friend Lord Wilson, without which I would have found this process quite impossible. I think the Bill leaves this House strengthened by the scrutiny that we have given it, and I beg to move.
Susan Kramer
My Lords, I'm going to be brief, which has been my practice I think as people may have noticed throughout much of this Bill. But first I want to open by saying a thank you to the Minister and to the box. They've been very willing to share their time with us, to brief us and to listen to issues that we raised. We didn't always get the response that we wanted, but I think it was a positive engagement that gives us some hope for really making progress in the future. I think the Minister came to this Bill having been told it was a minor technical Bill and that probably couldn't have been more wrong.
I'm glad we achieved what we did working across the opposition benches, and I give credit to Conservative peers Baroness Noakes, Baroness Neville-Rolfe and others, as well as on my own side to Baroness Bowles and Lord Sharkey, but in trying to deal with the issues around proportionality. But there is a great deal left in accountability that is going to be have to have to be tackled in future Bills. And as we see the speed up with AI and crypto and the other rapid changes that are coming, we are going to have to find a new way I think as Parliament to engage. And I also want to thank Baroness Neville-Rolfe for putting in an amendment that did begin to deal with the digital issue, and I really think not covering that within this Bill was a miss out and the government will have to step up to the plate again very shortly. I am very grateful also for the fact that we got support on the Child Trust Fund issue again from the Tory benches.
It's something I feel very personally as people can probably guess, and benefits 80,000 disabled youngsters who've been unable to access money that is theirs, that's sitting in trust fund accounts. My Lords, I want also thank Lord Sharkey particularly for fighting the battle for the FOS. That battle I think is not over either. And Baronesses Northover and Sheehan, we would have gone further I think on the climate change, environment, deforestation issues, but we do feel an important step was taken by government in the amendments that were moved today. So this I think has been a very constructive Bill, but it frankly was not the maximum use that could have been made of a Financial Services Bill.
And I hope we will see another one come along shortly because there are problems to be tackled, not least the mortgage prisoners issues, the issues of community development financial institutions, as well as that utterly significant constitutional issue of accountability and how the regulators need to be effectively accountable to Parliament.
So I do thank the whole House for working on a very complex set of issues, particularly when it entered this phase with the understanding that it was only going to be minor technicalities.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My Lords, I want to close by acknowledging the considerable degree of cross-party support and engagement that has underpinned most of our discussions on the bill. And I want to thank the noble Lord the Minister, Lord Pitt-Watson and his officials for their work, and also the noble Lord Lord Stockwood for guiding through the bill through second reading and report, and indeed I'd like to thank Lord Wilson for his support. I agree with the Minister that the bill has benefited from its passage through the House in major ways. I'm particularly grateful to the noble Baronesses Lady Kramer and Lady Bowles, and the noble Lord Lord Sharkey, and the noble Lord Lord Vaux for the constructive way in which they've worked with us on a number of shared priorities. Across the House, we've identified targeted and largely non-partisan areas in which this bill could be improved.
Serious concerns have been raised and serious well-intentioned proposals have been brought forward in response, and I hope they will be progressed by the government. My Lords, I also want to thank my noble friend Lady Noakes and my noble friend Lord Bridges of Headley for the deeply constructive approach they've taken to the important question of accountability and oversight. I strongly urge the government to continue working with my noble friends on this issue. As I'm sure the Minister recognizes, they have approached it throughout in the interest of good governance and effective parliamentary scrutiny with the support of the excellent Financial Services Regulation Committee. My noble friends Lord Ashcroft, Lord Ranger of Northwood, Lord Holmes of Richmond, Lord Massey of Hampstead, Lord Howard of Rising, Lord McKinley, Lord Hunt of Wirral and Baroness Lawlor have all made important and valuable contributions to our discussions, and I'm grateful for their work in raising important matters with the Minister.
My Lords, this is in many respects a model of how your Lordships' House can work at its best, identifying genuine concerns, drawing on expertise across the House and working constructively to make legislation more effective and more accountable and better. I hope the government will take the amendments passed and suggestions made forward as the bill progresses. But most of all, I'd like to thank my noble friend Lord Altringham and my noble friend Lord Ray and our team of officials for their support on this complex bill. Their experience and expertise in this area have been invaluable.
Speaker 82
The question is this bill do now pass. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. I'll leave a small pause before we start the next business.
Bill, Lord Lyon.
Speaker 82
Question is this report be now received, as many of that opinion will say content, the contrary not content, the contents have it. In clause one, amendment one, Lord Holmes of Richmond.
Andrew Sharpe
My Lords, I move this group on behalf of my noble friend Lord Holmes of Richmond, who sends his apologies to the House for his absence today. But my Lords, before I begin, can I start by noting my gratitude to the noble Lord the Minister, who has been incredibly receptive in listening to and addressing our concerns with this bill. I believe we've broadly ended up in agreement on the final form this bill should take, and so I commend him and his officials for the cross-party work they've facilitated. My Lords, my noble friend's two amendments from the committee stage seek to address three technical matters. Amendment one aims to provide the supplier with guidance as to how to submit a notice.
Amendment five seeks to clarify that a payment is only defined as such when the supplier has clear and unequivocal use of funds, and amendment ten would prevent the import-export exemption from being extended past the implementation of the Electronic Trade Documents Act. As at committee, we remain broadly supportive of all three amendments. Amendment one reflects the fact that good payment practices can only be ensured if both parties are aware of maximum payment terms and the supplier has submitted a notice in good time. Amendment ten reflects a much-raised concern that imports and exports are exempt from the bill currently. The Electronic Trade Documents Act means that this will not have to be the case, and so I hope that the Minister can assure us that there are plans for import and export incorporation into the payment regime upon the full enactment of that Act.
And lastly, my Lords, it is a shame to see that the aim behind amendment five has not been accepted by the government. This bill aims to improve payment practices between firms, largely because currently too many exchanges are delayed at the expense of the supplier. So if, my Lords, a payment is made through an intermediary and remains there for an indefinite period of time, perhaps beyond the 60-day payment term, and does not fall under the provisions of this bill, then this bill is of little use to the supplier awaiting payment. Amendment five would ensure that payments are considered as paid only when they reach their final recipient. And that principle was the reason for the Minister accepting, or sorry, rejecting, not accepting, my amendments two and four at committee stage, that regardless of delays, payments should only count when received by the supplier.
So I hope the noble Lord the Minister can today confirm that this definition will be made explicit in all cases. My Lords, moving on to my amendments, alongside my noble friend Lord Hunt of Wirral, I have retabled several probing amendments arising out of the concerns for the effects of the maximum payment terms. Amendments two, four and 19 are concerned with payments that are delayed by either bank holidays or bank processing times. Amendment nine probes the economic and opportunity costs of the exemption of upwards payments from payment term restrictions. Amendments three and six add a definition of nationalised bodies to the bill, reflecting the fact that whilst they will be treated as regular commercial bodies, their business models are self-evidently different and as such there is a risk that their payment practices reflect this.
My Lords, these are all questions that we would benefit from seeing answered. However, that doesn't detract from the fact that we support the general aim of part one of this bill. And it is also true that the best way of judging the effectiveness of a policy is through analysing its effects in practice. Therefore, my Lords, I welcome the compromise that the government has made with the noble Lord Lord Fox, giving the Secretary of State the powers to shorten payment terms alongside mandating a consultation about that decision. The new clause under amendment 15 does not commit the government to any specific action, but simply requires a review of the effects of the maximum payment terms and allows for adjustment if necessary.
I think that is a sound, self-correcting approach, and I therefore thank the noble Lord the Minister for agreeing to this measure.
My lords, I beg to move.
Speaker 82
Amendment proposed, clause 1, page 2, line 5, at the end insert the words printed on the marshalled list.
Chris Fox
My lords, I feel a great wave of consensus flowing over me. I rise to speak to amendment 8 in this group, which is in my name, and as we discussed before the recess, much of the consultation process proposed a 45-day limit, yet this bill as it stands offered no easy route from the 60 days it proposes to a shorter timeframe. My amendment requires the Secretary of State within five years either to lay draft legislation reducing the maximum payment for private purchasers from 60 to 45 days or explain to Parliament why not. And I would say that the minister's reaction and response to this particular issue has been typical of the very strong consensus that we've been able to build, and I echo the words of the noble Lord Sharp. I think both the minister and his team have been extremely helpful in this, and that's why I'm delighted to note government amendment 15 and the various consequentials, which essentially lock in very much what I was looking for.
And as the noble Lord Sharp, the need for consultation over five years with a view to shortening the payment period, and this amendment is an excellent response to my amendment 8, which makes my amendment unneeded.
Sonny Liang
My lords, prior to introducing these government amendments, I would like firstly to express my personal thanks to the positive engagement across the house, and in particular the front benches from the opposite benches, Lord Hunt and Lord Sharp, and also Lord Foster from the Liberal Democrats for their very thoughtful scrutiny of this bill. This bill builds upon the important reforms that were enacted by the previous Conservative government. The provisions in the bill have been drafted following extensive consultation with businesses, with over 850 responses to our consultation undertaken between 31st of July and 23rd of October 2025. We have brought forward this bill reflecting that consultation. Our decision to impose stricter maximum payment terms of 60 days received support from 66% of consultation respondents.
This is a significant strengthening of current law. No longer will large businesses be able to impose payment terms of over 60 days upon their suppliers. The question remains whether 60 days should be the end of that journey. We have heard loud and clear from smaller businesses that government should consider reducing maximum payment terms to 45 days or even 30 days. I've listened carefully to all noble lords across the house encouraging us to go further on this.
I'm very pleased to say the government has tabled amendments to provide a power that may be used in future to reduce the maximum payment terms. These amendments allow the government to consult on whether payment periods should be reduced, ensuring any future decision is informed by evidence and experience of how the new measures are operating in practice. Furthermore, the government will not use this power to reduce maximum payment terms for at least five years.
I hope noble lords will agree that this is a sensible change and a balanced approach, maintaining the payment periods consulted on and included in the bill, providing stability and certainty while businesses adapt to the new reality of 60-day maximum payment terms and ensuring there is a clear route to further in future if the evidence supports it. Turning to the amendments tabled by other noble lords, in response to amendment two, increasing the maximum payment term for public authorities beyond 30 days would undermine the Procurement Act 2023 and delay payment to suppliers. In response to amendment four, increasing the maximum period for a non-public authority purchases beyond 60 days would delay payment to suppliers and move away from the position consulted upon with strong levels of support. Regarding amendments three and six, national ownership does not by itself determine the applicable payment regime. Under the bill, a nationalised body that meets the definition of a public authority will be subject to a 30-day maximum payment period.
A nationalised body that does not meet that definition will be subject to the 60-day maximum payment period that applies to other purchases. My lords, I recognise Lord Fox's intention and ambition in amendment eight to reduce maximum payment terms. Turning to amendment 19, the bill takes important steps by introducing clarity and consistency around payment terms, building on the reforms introduced by the previous Conservative administration. We are not aware of public holidays being raised as a concern by any business or stakeholder during last year's extensive public consultation. Turning to amendment one, this is already covered by the bill.
We are setting out clearly the trigger points that can be agreed to start the clock on payment and the implied term if payment is not explicitly made. Regarding amendment five, the government believes that the bill is clear. For the purposes of whether a payment has been made on time and when interest on late payment will start, payment will be considered made at the point that funds have been received by the supplier. On both amendments one and five, the Small Business Commissioner will provide advice and information on compliance with legal obligations on these points. On amendment 10, I outlined at committee how removal of this exemption would place UK businesses at a competitive disadvantage.
I recognise the groundwork laid by the noble and learned lord Lord Thomas and noble lord Lord Holmes in relation to the Electronic Trade Documentation Act and intend for government to take this into consideration when consulting and developing regulations regarding payments and imports or exports. I can assure all noble lords that government is actively supporting businesses to utilise digital trade documents, including an SME capability programme, a dedicated gov.uk webpage and business awareness campaign. I just want to bring attention to Lord Sharpe's question about why is the government not defining when a payment is considered made in the commercial in this bill itself. The bill is clear on the payment terms that commercial contracts can contain and the consequences for not making a payment within those terms. So where a payment has not been active, has not been received by a supplier under the terms of a contract, that payment will be a late payment and interest will accrue.
My lords, with those assurances, I hope noble lord, the noble lord will feel able to withdraw amendment one and support the amendments in my name. I beg to move.
Andrew Sharpe
Well, my lords, as ever, I'm very grateful to the noble lord the minister for his response, and in particular about the last piece that he mentioned, which is very welcome news, and I appreciate the clarification. But as I outlined in my opening speech, my lords, a number of questions do remain regarding the implementation and operation of maximum payment terms. I accept what the noble lord said about consultation. I'm generally dubious of the government's enthusiasm for consultations, but in this case it was a good one. But we do, we very much agree with the principle, my lords.
We need to see how these measures will actually work in practice still. That's why I am very optimistic about amendment 15.
The government will have an opportunity to revisit these measures. And I hope in doing so that they consult stakeholders and those affected by all the potential issues that this group has raised. Keep up the good consultation work on this case. My Lords, I look forward to scrutinising the regulations when they appear. But in the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 82
Is it your Lordship's pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn. Amendments 2 to 4 taken together, Lord Hunt of Wirral. Not moved. And amendment 5, Lord Holmes of Richmond.
Not moved. Amendment 6, Lord Hunt of Wirral. Amendment 7, Lord Fox.
Chris Fox
My Lords, I rise to move amendment 7, which is in my name. As we all know, economic activity is switching from familiar structures and supply chains to one where businesses market their goods or their services via third party online marketplaces or virtual intermediaries. This amendment brings such marketplaces and intermediaries into the context of this bill. It closes a loophole by providing that payment is not treated as made to a supplier until the supplier actually receives the money, which seems reasonable. And by requiring any intermediary that collects payment on a supplier's behalf to pay it within seven days, regardless of how the intermediary is legally characterised.
The noble Lord the Minister is Minister for Small Businesses. And I'm sure that very many of the businesses that are now under his purview would agree that their cash flow can be majorly impacted by how quickly these online marketplaces settle. Now we've debated the role of online intermediaries in a number of bills and in a number of contexts. For example, we've talked about their role when considering product safety. And in every case, the government, I think both governments, if we can put it that way, have found arguments to eliminate these important businesses, this important sector, from whatever legislation we've been putting forward.
So it's quite clear that we have to move on from where we are now. We can't keep exempting what is becoming a major part of our economy from the legislation that we're putting forward. So an ever-increasing proportion of the UK economy is shifting in this direction and we need to grasp the nettle. So at the very least, I'm looking for some assurance from the Minister that the Small Business Commissioner, the government and across departments can actually take a look at the role of these businesses in all walks of the economy and find a way of bringing them on board and making sure that they are not a loophole to the laws that the government is very properly putting forward. So with that, I beg leave to move amendment 7.
Speaker 82
Amendment 7, page 3, line 37, at the end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
David Hunt
My Lords, this amendment touches on very much the same point as my noble friend Lord Holmes of Richmond's amendment 6 in the first group. Indeed, the principle that payment should be considered as such only when received by the supplier underpins several of the amendments that we've brought back from committee on this side of the House.
So as such, my Lords, His Majesty's loyal opposition support this amendment as we did at committee stage. I do not think simply because a payment is made online and happens to travel through an intermediary that it should fall under a different regime to direct payments. Similarly, my Lords, ensuring the prompt forwarding of payment by intermediaries is an integral part of promoting good payment practices. This amendment aims to do so, and I warmly commend the speech of the noble Lord, Lord Fox. So I join with him in hoping that the noble Lord the Minister can confirm that these issues have been considered and addressed.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, I am indeed grateful and thank the noble Lord, Lord Fox, for amendment seven. I recognize that this amendment is tabled in a constructive spirit, and I would like to thank the noble Lord, Lord Fox, again for the engagement that we've had on this matter both in person and also by correspondence. The government shares the noble Lord's aims of ensuring that suppliers are paid promptly, payment processes are clear, and purchasers cannot use contractual mechanisms to unjustly delay payment. I entirely agree that when a small business sells through a platform or marketplace, the money due to that business should not be held unnecessarily. I want to be absolutely clear that the use of intermediaries does not affect a supplier's right to be paid within 60 days.
Chapter one, part one of the bill ensures that for business-to-business contracts for the supply of goods or services, the maximum payment is 60 days. If payment is more than 60 days overdue, the purchaser is in breach of contract and liable to pay interest. The use of an intermediary does not alter this position. I would also like to reassure all noble Lords that persistent attempts to circumvent the maximum payment terms through intermediaries constitute poor payment practice. Under clause 19, this constitutes grounds for the Small Business Commissioner to investigate and potentially to levy a financial penalty on larger businesses that persistently engage in that practice.
Under clause 18, the Commissioner will also be able to adjudicate payment disputes where a larger business owes money to a small business, including where the debt arises from the use of an intermediary. This bill addresses late business-to-business payments. It is not intended to regulate broader business relationships, such as those between retailers using agents to sell goods to consumers or between a platform or marketplace and others when the platform or marketplace is holding, processing, or transmitting funds between them, which are subject to separate regulation. The contracts through which the majority of small businesses trade on online marketplaces are either business-to-consumer or consumer-to-consumer contracts and are subject to consumer legislation. These contracts were outside the scope of our impact assessment and our public consultation.
The amendment as tabled would therefore not address the issue that the noble Lord has raised. Tackling the issue of late payments outside a business-to-business context would move the bill into a completely different area of regulation and would require the establishment of a new statutory regime for online marketplaces and payment intermediaries.
This would cut across existing legislation rather than maintaining the bill's core focus on commercial payment practices between suppliers and purchasers. This amendment would also interfere with existing commercial models that operate in the interest of the relevant parties and serve legitimate purposes. For example, where most intermediaries operate a system in which payments are pooled in a small business account and drawn down by the small business on a regular basis. This amendment would mean that cash for each individual sale, however small, would have to be remitted directly to the small business, significantly increasing transaction numbers and costs and reducing the flexibility of the operating model. Another example is payment providers holding funds for more than seven days to allow for fraud checks or other compliance requirements.
This amendment would increase small businesses' exposure to fraud and undermine the regulatory and legal framework governing payment providers. However, I do understand and share the noble lord's concerns about withholding funds from small businesses. I am therefore happy to ask the Small Business Commissioner to review this issue with a view to developing guidance to small businesses understand how this bill applies to trading activity on online marketplaces. This can build on the guidance the commissioner produced last year to help small businesses understand why their accounts may be frozen or funds withheld and how they can take action to avoid this. This includes this included a 10-point pledge for online marketplaces and payment providers signed and promoted by several major companies.
As Small Business Minister, I will also commit to examining how government can further support small businesses in addressing this issue faced by those who use online platforms, including engaging other departments, other government departments and regulators where they have responsibility. For those reasons and given the commitments I've made, I respectfully ask the noble lord, Lord Fox, to withdraw amendment seven.
Chris Fox
Well, first of all, I thank the noble Lord Hunt for his support on on on this amendment. I one one point of sort of consternation rather otherwise is I would suggest that the supplier-marketplace relationship is a B2B relationship, it isn't a B2C relationship. So I'm not sure where the argument that somehow I'm pushing this to a different a different sort of relationship came from, but I will set that to one side and and mull on it later. But I do thank the the minister for the latter part of of of his speech and and undertakings to to focus the SBC on this issue and also for his department to look at ways of making sure that small businesses understand their rights. And I think that's the point really.
I think the the way in which the first part of the minister's speech was was set out made it clear that there are all sorts of rights for small businesses within within this, but I'm not sure the small businesses necessarily are aware of that and how they go about exercising those rights and making sure that the exercise of those rights is not a time-consuming and overwhelming process. So I think it'd be useful to hear from the minister going forward and perhaps from the Small Business Commissioner in as time goes by how small businesses are going to be engaged to make sure that they are are actually fighting on an even footing with the marketplaces who, let's face it, many of them are absolutely huge and very, very difficult organisations to take on and actually very difficult organisations to even find the right person to speak to to start with. So with those, I thank the minister for for the work he's going to do in future and I beg leave to withdraw amendment seven.
Speaker 67
Is it your pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn.
Amendment eight, Lord Fox, not moved. Not moved. Amendment nine, Lord Hunt, not moved. And amendment ten, Lord Holmes, not moved. Amendment eleven, Lord Hunt of Wirral.
I should perhaps alert the House to the fact that if this amendment were to be agreed to, I would not be able to call amendment thirteen by reason of preemption.
Andrew Sharpe
My Lords, this group of amendments revisits the issue of definitions of different sized businesses, and I note the new amendment in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Fox, which highlights the same concerns that we raised at committee stage. Those concerns remain, my Lords. There has been a proliferation of definitions for different sized businesses to suit a multitude of aims of the government of the day. There are currently a minimum of six statutory frameworks using materially different sized criteria, as well as other definitions existing in sector-specific regulations and guidelines. I know that the noble Lord the Minister will agree with me when I reiterate that this is currently too complex a system.
My Lords, the government should aim to place as few obstacles as possible in the path of business, and that means cutting the bureaucratic paperwork and jargon that firms complete to meet their legal obligations. And the proliferation of business size definitions is a case in point. They may not be entirely contradictory, but they are certainly not complementary, and I believe that everyone would benefit from a more streamlined approach. Now, I entirely accept the Minister's point at committee that such a wide reform cannot take place in a bill with as narrow a scope as this one. But I think that the Minister should at least commit to restricting the definitions within this act to those that already exist, and to the best of his ability.
And such a step clearly has the support from all sides of the House. And similarly, my Lords, given the fact that the noble Lord the Minister has indicated his support for some reform of definitions, I would appreciate it if he could commit to revisiting this issue with me at a future point. And I hope that he can agree to this, and I look forward to his response. And I beg to move.
Speaker 67
I was expecting somebody else to speak, and it was me. I beg the House's pardon. Amendment proposed, clause three, page eight, leave out lines seventeen to twenty-four and insert the words printed on the marshalled list.
Chris Fox
My Lords, the noble Lords Hunt and Shark were right to raise the issue of definitions in committee. And rather than simply echo them, I decided to add something to the debate through amendment thirty-five, which sets out something of the Babel, the Tower of Babel that exists around definitions. Subsection two of amendment thirty-five gives examples of the many phrases and words which are used in a variety of different contexts. Subsection three identifies seven acts, not the six that Lord Shark came up with, so we managed to find another one, where these phrases are prevalent but not necessarily synonymous. And subsection four really sets out what we're looking for the Minister to do.
And it's really to work out to what extent the definitions differ within subsection, the definitions set out in subsection two differ in subsection three. There's a compliance cost to these differing definitions. How is that different, those different definitions actually costing business because they have to make different decisions for different legislative frameworks? The extent to which this arises, gives rise to uncertainty and actually undermines the law, and the effect that it will have on the functions of the Small Business Commissioner themselves.
Those are just some of the things that we think should be taken on board by the government in order to bring a state of order to what has been an organic process of legislation following legislation, definition following definition. Now, in order to help the minister's new constituency of particularly small businesses, is the time to bring these things under control and bring definitions into order.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, let me thank noble Lords for their amendments 11, 12, 13, 14, 35 and 46. My Lords, I recognize the concerns raised by the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe and Lord Fox at committee regarding the number of existing definitions of company sizes on the statute book and the desire for clear and consistent definitions to avoid confusion for businesses. I would like to reassure noble Lords that our intention is to use the company size thresholds set out in the Companies Act 2006 and the Enterprise Act 2016 as the basis for defining company size in the bill. However, it is important that we consult with businesses and industry experts to ensure that these definitions are appropriate for the purposes of this bill. That consultation may indicate that for the purposes of the bill, company size definitions should be revised or simplified.
Any modifications to existing definitions will be made only when necessary. For example, we may choose to simplify definitions to make it easier for businesses to use exemptions whilst still using existing definitions as the basis. We may find through consultation that different parts of the legislation require different definitions to ensure precision and effectiveness. For example, we might be required to simplify the size definitions for the purposes of the Small Business Commissioner's powers so that they are based solely on headcount for simplicity. We should not constrain ourselves by introducing rigid definitions now, as this would make or could make the powers and protection afforded by this bill more difficult for businesses to understand and administer than is necessary.
I also do not consider it necessary to delay the bill's commencement pending a further statutory review of definitions used across a range of legislation. The government is already committed to consulting on any regulations made under these powers and to taking into account relevant existing definitions when developing them. The delegated power in section 2E will be subject to consultation and to parliamentary approval under the affirmative procedure, giving your Lordships' House the opportunity to vote on the regulations before they are introduced. In conclusion, my Lords, the definition of business sizes will be set out in secondary legislation. These regulations will be informed by consultation to ensure that they are appropriate.
The government intends to use the existing definitions as the basis for this bill and we will keep definitions as simple and effective as possible. I can also commit that before making any regulations in this area, the government will have regard to the definitions in the Companies Act 2006 and the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015 and the Enterprise Act 2016, and I can also commit to meet up with the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, to look into these definitions going forward.
Andrew Sharpe
Could I suggest to the noble Lord the Minister that during this consultation they also include perhaps a question about how the nature of small business has evolved in the last 10 years? Obviously there is the spectacular explosion in e-commerce and other things, which I think will have a material impact on the types of definition we're talking about. My Lords, as I outlined in my opening speech, the current landscape of definitions is unnecessarily and expensively, as the noble Lord Lord Fox pointed out, convoluted. But I also recognize that this bill is not necessarily the best vehicle for driving through that reform. So I do appreciate the Minister's response to this issue.
I will absolutely take him up on his offer of further talks about how we might improve what is a bit of a messy situation, messy picture. And I think I also heard him, and I might be making this up, that he's quite keen to find another perhaps legislative vehicle where we can address this in the future. And if I am making it up, I'm sure he'll correct me, correct the record. I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 67
Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 12, Lord Hunt, not moved, and 13 and 14 not moved. Amendments 15, 16, 17 and 18 already debated, moved formally, Lord Lyon. The question is that these amendments be agreed to en bloc.
As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment 19, Lord Hunt, not moved. After clause 10, amendment 20, Lord Hunt.
David Hunt
My Lords, amendments 20, 21 and 33 in my name and that of my noble friends Lord Sharpe of Epsom and Lord Leigh of Hurley have been brought back from committee in order to address the concerns that we have with special administration regimes and payment practices. My Lords, may I begin by acknowledging that the Minister did reassure us that the terms of this bill will apply to companies required to continue supplying SARs following their being placed into administration, as amendment 20 probes. Similarly, my Lords, I acknowledge that the report on the interaction between insolvency moratoria and payment practices that amendment 33 mandates may be unnecessary given this fact. We have, however, retabled these amendments as they lend themselves to my argument surrounding amendment 21. My Lords, when this amendment was raised at committee stage, the noble Lord the Minister stated, and I quote, that it would cut across the established insolvency framework, that providing preferential treatment to one group of suppliers would disadvantage other creditors and undermine the purpose of the existing insolvency regime.
My Lords, we don't agree with this argument. The very acceptance of amendment 20, that suppliers to SARs will fall under this bill, implies a recognition that there is something unique about this set of businesses.
Indeed, the entire reason we are having this debate is that in section 233 of the Insolvency Act of 1986 makes it illegal to withhold supplies to an SAR on the condition of the payment of arrears. It would not be preferential treatment to offer to them what this bill offers to every other business: the ability to recoup funds owed but not paid. Indeed, my Lords, that would place those firms on an equal footing with other creditors, given that they currently have less ability to ensure payment of arrears. My Lords, amendment 21 is proportional in that a cap can be set by the Secretary of State and the payment cannot be of sums subject to genuine disputes. This bill is designed to ensure fair and timely payment practices.
This amendment seeks to ensure just that for a set of firms who currently have no means of recouping owed sums. Of course, I look forward to the noble Lord the Minister's response and in the meantime I beg to move.
Speaker 67
Amendment proposed after clause 10, insert the new clause printed on the marshalled list.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly let me thank the noble Lord Lord Hanworth and Lord Sharp of Epsom and Lord Leigh of Hurley's done in his place today for amendments 20, 21 and 23. I'm really grateful to both noble Lords for our recent meeting covering these points and I hope that the follow-up information which my officials provided has been helpful. I'm also grateful to the Insolvency Service for its expertise in supporting our position. The bill does not seek to alter the existing statutory framework regarding insolvency. Regarding amendment 20, I would firstly like to clarify the position of suppliers providing goods or services after a company enters a special administration regime.
Clause 1 inserts a new section 28 2B into the Commercial Payments and Interest on Late Payments Act 1998, applying maximum payment terms to relevant payments under contracts within the scope of the legislation. The bill does not exclude suppliers made to companies in special administration. There is an important distinction between pre-appointment and post-appointment debts. Post-appointment suppliers remain subject to the bill where they are otherwise within scope. Payment obligations and statutory interest may continue to apply or accrue.
Recovery and enforcement remains subject to any relevant insolvency moratorium and the wider insolvency rules. By contrast, debts relating to suppliers made before the appointment are in a different position. They remain pre-insolvency claims and are dealt with under the established insolvency framework. The bill is not intended retrospectively to alter their status or priority. The government does not consider that entry into a special administration regime should of itself result in a purchaser being treated as a public authority for payment term purposes.
Companies in special administration remain commercial entities operating within statutory rules. Special administrators are independently or independent court-appointed office holders with statutory duties to manage the businesses within those rules. Applying public authority payment requirements solely because a company has entered special administration could have operational repercussions, for example, by exacerbating cash flow pressures. Nor do we consider that this bill should determine whether liabilities are to be treated as expenses of a special administration.
Amendment 20 would make qualifying post-appointment sums, including statutory interest, expenses of the special administration. Amendment 21 would similarly elevate certified pre-appointment sums. These would be substantive changes to the treatment and priority of liabilities, potentially affecting other creditors. Such questions are matters for the insolvency framework. Regarding amendment 21, I recognize the concern raised by the noble lords.
Suppliers may be carrying unpaid debts when a company enters special administration. That can be difficult, particularly for smaller businesses supporting essential service. I appreciate the particular concern where insolvency legislation restricts a supplier's ability to terminate a contract or make continued supply conditional on payment of pre-appointment debts. However, the relevant insolvency provisions contain their own protections and mechanisms, including provisions relating to payment for post-insolvency supplies and safeguards where continued supply would cause hardship. So we do not consider that those carefully calibrated arrangements could be recast through this bill.
Giving one group of creditors preferential treatment could disadvantage others, including employees and HMRC, and would cut across established statutory priority rules. The bill is focused on tackling late payment through clear statutory payment periods and related measures, not on amending insolvency law, creditor priorities, or special administration regimes. Regarding amendment 33, the government does not consider the proposed statutory review necessary. The amendment specifically asks about the interaction between an insolvency moratorium and the small business commissioner adjudication scheme. That scheme does not displace an insolvency moratorium or determine the status or priority of claims.
Its operations must remain subject to applicable insolvency restrictions, including restrictions on recovery and enforcement. So my lords, we therefore do not consider a separate statutory review of this is required. The interaction between the bill and the insolvency framework is already governed by established legal principles. A report within six months of Royal Assent would be unlikely to provide meaningful evidence about provisions that may not yet have commenced or had sufficient time to take effect. The government will nevertheless monitor implementation of the new payment framework, including its operation where a purchaser enters an insolvency procedure, and will engage with the insolvency service and relevant sector departments should evidence of practical problems arise.
My lords, for those reasons, I would ask the noble lord to withdraw the amendment.
David Hunt
My lords, we will carefully consider what the noble lord the minister has said, but I think he will acknowledge that there is some doubt, some worry, some concern still in existence. I appreciate his reiteration that amendment 20 will be covered within the bill already and accept that the information for a review is not currently available.
On amendment 21, my Lords, whilst I accept that it does not fall into the scope of this bill, I would gently ask the minister whether the government are currently looking at insolvency moratoria and special administration regimes. There has been plenty of talk in recent months about placing certain industries into public hands, not least Thames Water. I think if businesses of this scale are in question, firms supplying them deserve some clarity. My Lords, these firms are worried about their futures. The very need for this bill demonstrates that poor payment practices and withheld arrears are a threat to their existence.
I hope to see some solution reached in the near future, but acknowledge that the minister has gone a distance to try and address these concerns and that he has committed to continue to monitor the situation carefully. And therefore, in the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 67
Is it your pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 21, Lord Hunt, not moved. Not moved. In clause 11, amendment 22, Lord Hunt.
Andrew Sharpe
My Lords, firstly I'll begin by reiterating my support for the government's position on retention payments. We do support the right to the free exchange of goods and services and the right of firms to enter into mutually agreed upon contracts. But it is also clear that retention payments have become misused and are therefore untenable. My Lords, 65% of retention payments are paid back late, whilst almost 25% are never paid back at all. They have become a tool for big firms to retain cash flows to prop up other ventures whilst the supplier, often a smaller firm, suffers as a result.
However, we must not lose sight of their original purpose. My Lords, retention payments as a concept are wholly justified, in that they offer an insurance against defective or untimely work and incentivize the remedying of that. I, as I'm sure many noble Lords would agree, would hesitate to commission construction work on a private property if I did not have a way to ensure it was done to an acceptable standard, and we should not expect firms to be any different. Therefore, my Lords, some middle ground must be reached. As at committee stage, I've tabled along with my noble friend Lord Hunt of Wirral two amendments that propose alternatives to retention payments, namely escrow and staged payments.
Now, I'm aware that the noble Lord the minister has outlined that these would be permissible following the enactment of this bill, but as far as I'm aware, they are currently a small part of the market share of construction insurance. So the primary goal of these amendments is to seek clarity from the noble Lord the minister on what steps the government is taking to promote these and indeed other alternatives. They're consulting with industry. What conclusions have they reached from those discussions? Which other forms of insurance does the government deem effective and how are they acting to promote them?
So I hope the minister is able to give some clarity from the dispatch box on all of those questions. My Lords, amendment 24 would exempt resident-run or resident-owned blocks of flats from falling under the retention ban. The minister has made it clear that this ban is intended to target commercial contracts rather than those of private citizens. Resident-run properties fall into an odd medium in that they are technically commercial properties, but they are run as if they are private. There is clearly a category issue here.
So does the minister accept that these are not run as commercial properties? And if so, does he have the data in front of him as to the scale of this issue and whether the incoming ban will pose a risk to the resident-run property market? Finally, my Lords, I'll touch on amendments 25 and 26 in my name and the names of my noble friends Lord Hunt of Wirral and Lord Leigh of Hurley.
My Lords, much of this bill seeks to support small business by placing them on an equal footing. It recognizes there is often an asymmetrical relationship between the buyer and the seller when either is larger. Our amendments simply seek to extend that recognition to these two well-known practices. So I hope the noble Lord the Minister will agree with me and I beg to move.
Speaker 67
Amendment proposed, clause 11, page 15, line 34, to insert the words printed on the marshalled list.
Chris Fox
There are no amendments in my name in this group, but I would like to speak very briefly on the noble Lord's amendment 24, which as we heard seeks to remove the ban on retention with the very worthy aim of helping ensure resident-owned or resident-run blocks of homes can police work done on the grounds of safety. And on the face of it, that sounds like a very worthy idea. I am concerned that it opens a can of worms and that is my instinct is there has to be a better way of ensuring that the work is done properly. Perhaps it's the noble Lord's idea of escrow, which I believe could if mutually agreed would be would be possible. There is a danger in watering down the retention ban if we were to accept the noble Lord's ideas and also the definition of safety remedial work could be broad or it could be very narrow.
So I'm I'm and I've had briefings from a number of different organizations which have all been contradictory to each other. So I'm I'm passing the buck to the Minister to explain how he is going to to solve the very worthy issue that the noble Lord Sharp has identified, which is resident-run properties or resident-owned properties, whilst at the same time not prising open the lid to the can of worms.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly let me thank noble Lords Lord Sharp and Lord Hunt for the amendments in this group. Let me take amendment 22 first. Firstly, let me reassure the noble Lords Sharp and Hunt that this bill, this bill does not prevent parties in any sector, including construction firms, from making use of payment arrangements through a bank or an escrow provider to facilitate the transfer of funds. The important distinction is between a third party facilitating that payment of money that is due and a third party holding back of that money as security for the supplier's performance. The former remains permitted, the latter could amount to a retention and would therefore fall within the prohibition.
Therefore amendment 22 is unnecessary. The government's view shared by many in the industry is that construction should move away from cash retentions and towards a modern, more secure and equitable forms of surety. We know that there are alternative forms of surety, including performance and retention bonds already available in the UK, which can mitigate risk for clients and firms. There are also alternatives used in other countries, such as warranty bonds, which are very common in Europe and available in the UK. We will be working with surety providers to ensure that a range of alternatives are available when the ban comes into force.
In relation to amendment 23, I would like to reassure noble lords that the bill does not prescribe when stages or milestones must occur or prevent parties from agreeing interim valuations and payments. It regulates the period within which an amount must be paid once that payment becomes due. Genuine stage and interim payment arrangements will therefore remain entirely permissible. However, describing a withholding of money for work already completed and where payment is due as a stage payment would not prevent it from falling within the prohibition on retentions if, in substance, the money was being retained as security for the performance of contractual obligations. The right for firms to be paid in stage payments on projects lasting more than 45 days is already enshrined in section 107 part 2 of the Housing Grants Construction and Regeneration Act 1996.
This bill does not amend, qualify or undermine that right. Therefore, this amendment is unnecessary. In implementing the provisions of this bill, the government will engage directly and closely with construction industry clients, specialist providers and representatives of smaller firms to provide guidance that legitimate payment arrangements can continue while preventing contractual devices from being used to recreate cash retentions under another name. To turn to amendment 24, we recognize the understandable intention that there are means of ensuring that the resident-led and resident-owned companies want assurance that building work is completed properly and of high quality and that defects are remedied without additional cost falling on leaseholders. We do not believe retentions ensure this.
To agree to this amendment would create a broad exemption for construction contracts entered into by resident management and right to manage companies. That would leave firms working on those buildings exposed to the risks associated with cash retentions. It could also create uncertainty where different ownership and management structures exist within the same building or development. In addition, the process required by the Building Safety Act 2022 for delivering work on high-risk buildings places an emphasis on safety and quality. It includes numerous gateways, information requirements and independent reviews of the building.
If clients and firms in their supply chain are meeting the requirements of the act, then there should be no need to deduct retentions. As Dame Judith Hackitt has noted, retentions are ineffective and undermine the effectiveness of the supply chain, which is why alternatives are required. For this legislation to be effective, it must incentivize the industry and its clients to end the practice of cash retentions and to adopt alternative forms of surety together with improved quality management. Finally, I wish to address the request made by a number of noble lords at committee stage for further information about the work to develop alternatives to retentions. The Construction Leadership Council has now appointed a new industry lead for this area and we will be increasing our engagement with stakeholders across the industry in relation to alternative forms of surety and quality improvement from September.
This will give us plenty of time to address those issues in advance of the introduction of the proposed ban. Turning to amendment 25, I acknowledge concerns around the risk of small businesses being pressured into accepting payment methods they have not agreed, including cryptocurrency. However, this amendment is not necessary. The terms governing payment between parties are a matter for contractual arrangements and a purchaser or supplier should not be able to impose new payment terms unilaterally.
In adjudicating disputes, the Small Business Commissioner will determine whether larger businesses owe smaller businesses money under a contract. A breach may include a failure to pay, paying late, or partial payment because of a larger business attempting to unilaterally change existing contractual terms. Regarding amendment 27, I agree that payments under the bill should not be withheld where there has been no breach of contract by the supplier. This amendment is therefore not necessary to achieve this. And the same principle, my Lords, I outlined in response to amendment 25 applies and includes ESG.
The Commissioner can determine what is owed under the contract through adjudication and has the power to investigate persistent poor payment practices. For those reasons, my Lords, I respectfully ask the noble Lord to withdraw amendment 22 and not move amendments 23 to 26.
Andrew Sharpe
My Lords, I'm again grateful to the Minister for his response and indeed to Lord Fox for his comments. First on the ESG impositions and the general risk of coercion of smaller businesses by larger ones. I accept that these are already prohibited by law, but I would however gently raise that the risk of coming forwards with complaints of this kind often outweighs the benefits of redress. Essentially small businesses are being coerced into ESG practices. That is still a problem and it's one that I hope a government will address in the future.
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord the Minister for his outline of the government's approach to the retentions issues, and I am genuinely optimistic listening to him because he has talked about a variety of different products that are available, and we've had some briefings on those: performance bonds, retention bonds, and as the noble Lord mentioned, the warranty bond. My Lords, these tend to be common practice, more common practice in Europe than is current, and I think warranty bonds are only offered by a single firm in the United Kingdom at the moment. I do and would hope that the market will provide solutions to this problem because we do think there is some form of insurance is effect would be effective and necessary in these circumstances. But it can't really be accepted as a retention payment alternative if it's currently so scarce. So we do need to make sure that it is well understood publicly and perhaps mount a campaign with industry to make sure this is very well understood.
I also accept the noble Lord's arguments about the difficulty of creating an exemption for residents-run properties. I'll have a think about that further when I have a chance to read Hansard, but I do think he made some good points. So I do hope the government will be able to update the House in due course on their progress in promoting these various different types of instrument, but in the meantime I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 67
Is it your Lordship's pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 23, Lord Hunt, not moved. And 24, not moved. And 25, not moved.
And indeed 26, not moved. In clause 18, amendment 27, Lord Fox.
Chris Fox
My Lords, I rise to move amendment 27 and also to speak to amendment 34, which are both in my name. So first I'll speak to amendment 27. This amendment requires payment disputes referred to the adjudication scheme to be resolved within 60 days unless the Small Business Commissioner considers a longer period reasonable. This bill creates a 60-day limit by which large private organisations must pay back small businesses.
However, although in the case of a dispute there is a time limit for the dispute to be raised, there is no such limit on when the case should be resolved. This means that large companies could, in effect, contest a dispute and delay resolution, putting pressure on the SMEs to settle. As can be seen from the amendment, this calls for the adjudicator to reach a decision determining a relevant payment dispute before the end of the period of 60 days beginning from the day on which the dispute is referred to the adjudicator under the scheme. The 60 days suggested in this amendment is itself more generous than the 28-day time limit that is currently covered for the construction sector, but should at the very least be seen as a backstop. And I look forward to hearing from the Minister what limits it sees to the adjudication figure should be and how they would be applied in practice as the act currently stands.
Turning to amendment 34, this simply looks to lock in sufficient funding and government support for the Small Business Commission to reflect its vastly wider remit. Now, I'm persuaded that there are some moves that have already been made and some that are in the offing that will boost the capacity for the Commission. But as we have seen with Companies House, transforming an organization into an investigative body is a huge undertaking and it's a cultural change. It requires both resources and great resolve from the leadership team in that organization. And I think both Houses need to be reassured that sufficient resources and sufficient government support is being made available, because if the Small Business Commission fails, it undermines the whole pretext of this bill.
So I beg to move amendment 27.
Speaker 67
Amendment proposed, clause 18, page 22, line 35, at end insert the words printed on the marshalled list.
David Hunt
My Lords, we're all very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Fox, for moving this group of amendments. And ahead of this group, I would once again like to thank the noble Lord, the Minister, for his engagement. We entered this part of the bill with some apprehensions, not least regarding the funding of the Small Business Commissioner's office. It would perhaps be too soon to say all of those concerns have been quelled, but I appreciate the time that the Minister, the Small Business Commissioner herself, and her team have taken to try and address the questions that we have all put forward. My Lords, I will begin by addressing the amendments to which I've added my name and the name of my noble friend Lord Sharpe of Epsom, namely those in the name of my noble friend Lord Leigh of Hurley.
Amendments 28 and 29 aim to bring some transparency to the office of the Small Business Commissioner through requiring written reasons for declining to adjudicate a dispute and through requiring the definition of a sufficient number of occasions to trigger an investigation into payment practices. My Lords, on the latter point, I accept the government's reasoning that a numerical definition does not sufficiently account for the scale of different poor payment practices.
I hope therefore that the noble lord the minister can confirm that there will however be some framework upon which these decisions to investigate will be based. On the former point, written reasons for declining to adjudicate a dispute, I do hope the noble lord the minister will be able to outline the government's position. I understand that discretion and disclosure are considerations, and so perhaps a middle ground that requires the informing of decisions to decline without necessarily including the reasons for doing so would be acceptable. My lords, my concerns remain with putting a time limit on resolving disputes as amendment 27 would do. Whilst disputes should of course be addressed in a timely manner, the fact is that different disputes will require different resources and be of vastly different scales.
An arbitrary time period risks rushing the commissioner's office or forcing them to prioritize or perhaps even to accept trade-offs. We don't believe that the benefits of a 60-day limit offset those risks. Finally, my lords, I'm grateful to the noble lord the minister for providing us with a briefing beforehand on some of the previous funding of the small business commissioner's office and their plans for the future. We are satisfied that these have been modeled on the best predictions possible, and I'm sure your lordships' house would be grateful if the noble lord the minister could outline some of that data when he comes to reply to this debate, certainly at the dispatch box at some stage. I would like to finish by asking whether there is a way to scrutinize the commissioner's funding in the future.
As I have said, we are satisfied with the predictions, but they are still only predictions. I'm sure there will be an internal review process into the effectiveness of these, these reforms, but this house does deserve the opportunity to have some input into that process, so I look forward to hearing the noble lord the minister's response.
Sonny Liang
My lords, once again, let me thank the noble lord Lord Fox for amendment 27 and 34, and the noble lord Lord Lee, who's not in his place, Lord Hunt and Lord Sharp for amendments 28 and 29. Firstly, let me recognize the constructive spirit in which these amendments have been tabled and the shared objective of ensuring the small business commissioner's new functions are timely, transparent and effective. I agree that payment disputes should be resolved as quickly and efficiently as possible. In line with the construction adjudication scheme, we are considering whether a 28-day time limit for the adjudicator to reach a decision, extendable where necessary, would be appropriate. I believe that noble lords would agree that this time is sensible and reasonable.
We will consult on this to ensure the final approach is informed by evidence and by stakeholder views. Time limits will be set out in regulations subject to parliament's approval. This approach will give businesses confidence that payment disputes will be resolved quickly and efficiently while maintaining flexibility to refine time limits in light of feedback and operational experience. The government recognizes the importance of transparency and I appreciate the sentiment behind amendment 28.
As a matter of principle, a small business should understand why the adjudicator has declined to adjudicate a dispute and why the commissioner has declined to adjudicate. However, there may be occasions when disclosing the details of a referral to a larger business could harm commercial relationships or be otherwise inappropriate. As such, we believe such obligation should be subject to further consultation and addressed through regulations. Regarding amendment 29, I understand the desire for clarity on how the commissioner will assess repeated poor payment practice. But this is precisely the kind of judgment that should be informed by real experience and evidence and guided by statutory criteria which the commissioner must consider on a case-by-case basis.
If we try to prescribe an arbitrary number for vastly different practices, we risk creating an inflexible model that fails in practice and undermines the commissioner's ability to act. On resourcing, I do hear the concerns raised by noble lords. I wholeheartedly agree that the provisions in this bill will only be effective if properly enforced and that the resources available to the small business commissioner are crucial to this aim. I want to reassure all noble lords that the office of small business commissioner is already being resourced to implement and that I am the minister responsible for the small business commissioner and I will ensure that they have the proper resources. And I've recently also facilitated a meeting between the commissioner and noble lords to discuss preparation for the legislation coming into force.
I can confirm that the commissioner's budget has already received an initial 30% boost this financial year with recruitment underway for six new members of staff bringing the existing team to 20. This has already allowed the office to begin building its capability ahead of the new enforcement powers from the bill. In addition, we will under we have undertaken a rigorous assessment and benchmarking exercise to assess future demand for adjudication, enforcement and investigation and I can assure the noble lord Hunt that I will ensure that he gets the data regarding the assessments that we have done. The department will provide further resources doubling the commissioner's resource base in 2025-26 to ensure that the office delivery capability is ready on day one. They are also considering options for appointing third-party adjudicators to provide further flexibility and capability.
This will provide the commissioner with a strong operating base and together with the ability to recover the cost of adjudications and investigations ensure we have a funding model that is sustainable and flexible enough to manage demand. I'm also happy to go further to provide noble lords assurance on this. I'm willing to commit that before the new adjudication and investigation functions commence, the government will provide parliament with a clear statement on implementation readiness including staffing, systems, operational capability and arrangements for keeping resources under review. Resources will not be treated as a one-off issue. We will keep the commissioner's capacity under review as the regime settles, caseloads become clearer and evidence emerges on the use of adjudication, investigations and enforcement powers.
The Commissioner's annual report will continue to provide transparency on activities, performance, staffing, funding and audited accounts. In addition, the government is prepared to provide further assurance to Parliament on implementation before the relevant new functions are brought into force. These are concrete evidence, sorry, these are concrete commitments that show the government is already taking the necessary steps, so there is no need to include a separate budget publication requirement in the bill. I'll be happy to provide further updates ahead of commencement. For these reasons, I respectfully ask the noble Lord to withdraw amendment 27 and not move the other amendments in the group.
Chris Fox
My Lords, I would like to thank the Minister wholeheartedly for his response to both my amendments. The response to amendment 27 was probably more ambitious than I was proposing, so I'm very happy with that. And I think his response to amendment 34 on resources has been more than fulsome. On that basis, I'm pleased to withdraw, beg leave to withdraw amendment 27.
Speaker 67
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 28, Lord Leigh of Hurley, Lord Hunt, not moved, and amendment 29, not moved. In clause 24, amendment 30, Lord Fox.
Chris Fox
Lords, I rise to move amendment 30 and speak to amendments 31, 32, 43, 44 and 45, which sounds daunting, but they're all the same amendment. And these amendments are in my name, and I'm happy to say that they've been countersigned by the noble Lord the Minister as well. And in effect, of these changes is to remove the requirement for the Small Business Commissioner to use UK turnover alone when making an adjudication. And I thank very much the Minister for his contribution to this. There may well be cases where indeed it's appropriate for only UK activity to be the basis for any fine.
In fact, most cases, that will be the case. But there may be others where a broader turnover is actually appropriate. For example, where a company's accounting practices effectively shrink the UK turnover in order to shrink a penalty. In these cases, we need to give the Small Business Commissioner the power to prevent the avoidance through profit shifting and turnover shifting. Now, in committee, I used the example of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which makes the same point and puts in place a similar, a different but otherwise solution.
Now, by removing the UK from the description of how the Small Business Commissioner calculates any sanctions, or giving that option to the Small Business Commissioner, gives flexibility for the Commissioner to pitch the right sanction to an errant business. And for that reason, I beg leave to move amendment 30.
Speaker 67
Amendment proposed, clause 24, page 37, line 42, leave out 'in the United Kingdom'.
Andrew Sharpe
Well, my Lords, as we come to the end of this report stage, I once again like to place on record my thanks to noble Lords on all sides of the House for their engagement with the passage of this bill. Now, up until this point, we've had a very chummy time and a lot of cozy consensus. So you'll be very pleased to know I intend to introduce a note of disagreement on this particular amendment. My Lords, I'll begin by stating that I don't disagree with the premise of amendment 30 in the name of the noble Lord Lord Fox and the noble Lord the Minister. Companies should ensure that they have good payment practices and that these are reported, and these should be incentivized where necessary.
My Lords, I equally understand the reasoning behind giving the Small Business Commissioner the powers to both oversee and enforce the reporting of payment practices and performances. The office will have a closer knowledge of small business payment practices than regular departmental officials, and so it makes sense that they are given this responsibility. So the issue, my Lords, is therefore not one of principle, but one of proportion. Two other arms of the government have the power to fine businesses based on global turnover rather than domestic turnover. They are the Competition and Markets Authority and the Information Commissioner's Office.
My Lords, these bodies deal with some of the most important wide-reaching areas of our economy. The former with the upkeep of fair and competitive markets, and the latter with the protection of the public's private information. My Lords, those issues are of far greater in scope and gravity than what clause 24 and the new section 3A will give the SBC, the Small Business Commissioner, powers over. These powers are not even dealing with payment practices, but the reporting of payment practices. And yet the office will be able to fine companies 1% without even the discretion to fine less than 1% of global turnover.
This, my Lords, to His Majesty's loyal opposition seems disproportionate to say the very least. We do not believe this is the right vehicle to address the subject of the profit shifting that the noble Lord, Lord Fox, mentioned. One of the key concerns that we've heard from stakeholders during the passage of this bill is that while they support maximum payment terms, there will be a transition period to implement the technology and payment systems. And this is particularly the case with large multinational corporations. These companies have incredibly complex systems that organize payments across borders, time zones, and legal frameworks.
And it is not outside the realm of possibility that a business such as, for example, Amazon has some teething problems and fails to accurately report payment practices and performance within the UK. The result would be that the Commissioner, based on a failure to report practices within the United Kingdom, would have the power to fine Amazon based on their global turnover. That would equate to more than 700 million pounds for a potential technological error or delay. I don't think that power reflects the duty that we are dealing with. Lastly, my Lords, there is the question of incentives.
The Small Business Commissioner, and justifiably, prides itself on saving more money for the small businesses than it costs the taxpayer. But if value for money is the justification for the office's existence, then its incentive is to use its powers to raise money in order to continue its operation. My Lords, I'm not accusing the SBC of this, I'm simply reflecting upon the perverse incentives that occur when an arm of government relies on action to justify its continued existence. Now, I don't think that given these natural incentives exist, that we should give any arm of the state the power to tax multinational businesses based on their global turnover for actions within the United Kingdom. We should especially reflect on this when we are not even discussing payment practices, but the reporting of payment practices.
My Lords, we won't oppose this amendment given that it is the support of the majority of the House, but I would like to place on record my and indeed our, the His Majesty's loyal opposition's concern about this measure. It would go some way to allaying my worries if the Minister could outline how many times a fine has been given under the existing section 3, but I'm still concerned that this is a disproportionate step that places far too much power in the hands of an ultimately unaccountable body, and I look forward to the noble Lord the Minister's response.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, let me thank noble Lord Fox for his amendment regarding turnover and financial penalties. These amendments raise an important question about how turnover should be calculated for financial penalties under the payment reporting regime following an investigation by the SBC. And I'd like to thank noble Lord Fox for the constructive discussions we've had on this issue.
The government agrees that this is an issue that merits proper debate. We want penalties to be meaningful and capable of driving compliance whilst ensuring the approach is proportionate, relevant and workable for businesses in scope. The government supports the aim of this amendment at this stage to open up the debate on the appropriate basis for calculating turnover. However, I want to be clear that the government has not reached a final view on the most appropriate approach. The government will want to engage with businesses, business representatives and other interested parties before determining how turnover should be calculated for these purposes, including whether it should be limited to UK turnover given that the bill addresses UK payment practices or extended more widely.
Further detail on how turnover is calculated will be provided in secondary legislation. That secondary legislation will be informed by a process of consultation to determine how turnover should be calculated. Additionally, that secondary legislation, which will be debated in Parliament, will allow the final position to be properly tested. This approach will ensure the regime retains the flexibility required to operate effectively and proportionately. On that basis and once again my thanks to the noble lord Lord Fox for raising this important issue and for engaging with the government in a positive manner.
The government supports amendments 30 to 32 and 43 to 44 to which I have added my name. My lords, before I sit down, I just want to thank again all noble lords, especially from the opposition benches, noble lord Sharpe of Epsom and noble lord Hunt from Wirral and noble lord Fox for their very thoughtful and constructive engagement throughout the passage of this bill. And it just shows that we can get things done if we work collaboratively. I beg to move.
Speaker 67
I take it that amendment 30 is to be agreed. Can I have confirmation of that from Lord Fox, that the noble lord wishes to move that amendment? The question is that amendment 30 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content.
The contents have it. Amendments 31 and 32 moved formally, Lord Fox. The question is that amendments 31 and 32 be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary, not content.
The contents have it. Amendment 33, Lord Hunt, not moved. Not moved. Amendment 34, Lord Fox, not moved. And 35, Lord Fox, not moved.
Amendment 36, Lord Leong, moved formally. And sorry, I should also add amendments 37, 38, 39, 40, 41 and 42 moved formally en bloc. The question is that these amendments be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content.
The contents have it. Amendment 43, Lord Fox, moved formally. The question is that this amendment be agreed to together with amendments 44 and 45. The question is that these amendments be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content.
To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. In schedule 4, amendment 46, Lord Hunt, not moved. Not moved. My lords, I think it would be appropriate to take a short pause before next business in order for noble lords who wish to leave the chamber to do so.
My lords, we'll now move to next business.
Ilora Finlay
Batteries placing on the market Northern Ireland regulations 2026, Baroness Hayman of Ullock.
Sue Hayman
My Lords, I beg to move that the House approves the batteries placing on the market Northern Ireland regulations 2026, which was laid before this House on the 4th of June. In 2023, the European Union replaced their 2006 batteries directive with a new batteries regulation. This updated placing on the market requirements, covering design specifications for batteries and requirements relating to information and labelling. These requirements, designed to support environmental and safety performance of batteries, relate to carbon footprint, performance and durability, recycled content, and removability and replaceability of batteries from devices. The new EU regulation has also introduced specific safety requirements for stationary battery energy storage systems and updates the information requirements to include state of health and expected lifetime.
Finally, the EU regulation also introduces the digital battery passport and supply chain due diligence policies for larger organisations. Previous requirements relating to the restriction of certain substances in batteries are carried forward. The EU batteries regulation also introduced conformity assessment where the CE mark is required to demonstrate compliance with the requirements that I've just listed. These requirements apply directly in Northern Ireland as in European member states. They apply in Northern Ireland under the Windsor Framework.
As a regulation, the obligations within it apply directly without need for transposition. They phase in, meaning that some requirements are already in force and others are due to come into force on future dates. These changes have been introduced in light of the rapid growth in sectors such as electric vehicles, e-bikes, portable electronics and energy storage, alongside the increasing volume and complexity of batteries that are now in circulation. The new EU regulation also makes changes to waste and extended producer responsibility requirements. Those matters are not covered by this instrument and I will come back to next steps there.
The instrument laid before the House, which is in a reserved policy area, is the domestic legislation required to enable effective enforcement of these obligations. Implementing these measures helps Northern Ireland to maintain its dual market access. It does this by establishing a proportionate enforcement offences and penalties regime in Northern Ireland for the placing on the market requirements of the EU batteries regulation. The Office for Product Safety and Standards enforces the existing placing on the market requirement across the UK and will act as the market surveillance and enforcement authority for this instrument in Northern Ireland. The SI also includes supplementary measures arising from the requirements related to conformity assessment.
It amends the batteries and accumulators placing on the market regulations 2008 by revoking them in respect of Northern Ireland. To be clear, it does not introduce new policy objectives or regulatory standards beyond those arising from the EU batteries regulation. I will also set out timing regarding UK-wide batteries regime to which this SI is linked. The EU batteries regulation required the penalty regime established by this SI to be in place by the 18th of August last year. As I've already indicated, there were further parts of the EU batteries regulation that remain to be implemented in Northern Ireland.
And I want to be clear that we will take any steps necessary to continue to meet the government's commitment to protecting the UK's internal market. I do recognize the concerns raised by the Noble Lord McCrea in respect of the application of EU legislation in Northern Ireland under the Windsor Framework. Indeed, I was in this place recently addressing another regret motion in relation to plant health regulations. The measures before us reflect necessary updates in a rapidly evolving sector that supports higher standards of battery safety, environmental performance and supply chain transparency. We believe these measures will deliver practical benefits across the whole United Kingdom.
And that's why we will consult this autumn on an aligned regime in Great Britain that's consistent with the EU's 2023 batteries regulation. This consultation will be UK-wide and conducted with the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs in Northern Ireland and other devolved governments as a four-nation approach. This approach will avoid duplicative administrative burdens by providing a unified framework across the UK and EU for batteries and will also deliver against our environmental objectives. Battery manufacturing is a highly sophisticated global sector and major manufacturers are already adjusting to the new standards set by the EU. And a unified approach is therefore what business is asking for.
The autumn consultation will seek views on both applying the placing on the market obligations in Great Britain, but also the waste and producer responsibility provisions, which in doing so will complete the implementation of the EU batteries regulation in Northern Ireland. It's our firm view that pursuing this approach provides the best outcome for the EU. I do welcome the collaborative approach taken in the development of this instrument, which has drawn constructively on expertise from industry and government departments. The enforcement provisions set out in this SI meaningfully strengthen the application of the EU batteries regulation in Northern Ireland where it has been law since its publication in 2023. By improving compliance in key areas such as battery safety, hazardous substances and environmental performance, it is reasonable to expect positive environmental outcomes through reduced risk of unsafe or environmentally harmful batteries being placed on the market.
I'm also reassured by the de minimis assessment undertaken in respect of this instrument, given that the associated costs are minimal and that the instrument introduces no contentious or disproportionate impacts, this approach seems to be both reasonable and appropriate. Of course, it is right that this House scrutinizes delegated legislation carefully. I am satisfied this instrument falls within the scope of the parent act and represents an appropriate use of powers. It is for these reasons that I beg to move.
Hear, hear.
Ilora Finlay
The question is that this motion be agreed to. Amendment, Lord McCrea of Magherafelt and Cookstown.
Robert William McCrea
My Lords, I rise to speak to the regret motion in my name and will make four main points. First of all, these regulations provide a graphic demonstration of the humiliating nature of the Windsor Framework because the substantive legislation which they enforce is EU regulation EU 2023/1542. Now, this legislation took effect in Northern Ireland automatically on the 17th of August 2023 by means of dynamic aligning the UK with respect to Northern Ireland with the EU, effectively treating part of the United Kingdom as an EU colony. Now, Northern Ireland legislators were not even briefed on this matter. The first we learned of it was three years later reading the explanatory notes to the regulations before us today, whose purpose it is to serve the EU and their legislation by providing a means for its enforcement.
Secondly, the enforcement that these regulations provide is deeply problematic.
Speaking when these regulations were debated in another place on the 8th of July, the Minister of State stated, and I quote, "Offences are put in one of three penalty groups: summary-only offences, such as those subject to a fine, which can be unlimited; either-way offences, or imprisonment for up to 12 months and/or an unlimited fine; for the most serious indictable-only offences." Offences include failure to keep appropriate due diligence documentation, failure of a supplier of battery cells and modules to provide documentation to manufacturers, failure by an importer to comply with certain battery safety regulated obligations. Those fall into three penalty groups, one, two, and three respectively. My Lords, let's just take a step back for a moment. If the norm of the 18th century was such that there could be no taxation without representation, then plainly we cannot contemplate fines and imprisonment in the 21st century further to contravention of laws unless the citizens in question were represented in the making of those laws that they have broken.
Now, the EU is expecting the United Kingdom government to not only subject part of itself to EU law, but it expects the United Kingdom to introduce a legislative mechanism whereby their law can be imposed with sanctions, depriving UK citizens of money in the form of fines or potentially their liberty through imprisonment. This is constitutionally completely absurd and absolutely unacceptable. Thirdly, we need to confront how these regulations are implicated in destroying the United Kingdom internal market for goods. By providing enforcement, the regulation before us today bring EU regulation 2023/1542 into full effect, creating a new legal market for batteries as a matter of practice, subject to different rules from the rest of the United Kingdom. Now, the regulations are called the Placing on the Market Regulations, where the market in question is the EU internal market, not a United Kingdom internal market, which necessarily becomes, by default, a GB internal market for goods for these purposes.
Now, in this, the principal economic challenges for Northern Ireland are this: if we manufacture our own batteries, we will not do so on a level playing field with the rest of the United Kingdom because we will be subject to EU regulations that do not apply to Great Britain. If, as a small and until recently completely integrated part of the United Kingdom economy, we get most of our batteries from GB, we will not be able to do so going forward unless GB companies, A, provide batteries to the requirements of EU law, and B, also pay to get additional Northern Ireland marking. Will they do this for a tiny market? This necessarily represents or presents a very real supply chain concern. Fourthly, the explanatory memorandum attending these regulations is unlike the memoranda accompanying many other regulations forced and forged in deference to the Windsor Framework.
Often they state that the government is planning to prevent divergence between Great Britain and Northern Ireland by bringing GB into line with Northern Ireland and thus with the EU. However, the explanatory memoranda accompanying these regulations do no such thing. This prompted real concern that on this matter London was ready to cut Northern Ireland off, which resulted in concerns being expressed to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee of your Lordships' House.
In the other place, the Minister said, and I quote, "Let me be clear that we will take any steps necessary to continue to meet the government's commitment to protect UK internal market. That is why we will consult in the autumn on an aligned regime in Great Britain that is consistent with the EU 2023 batteries regulation." Thus, my Lords, along with the tumble dryers regulation, the machinery regulation, the batteries regulations now become an early expression of the government's reset policy with the EU. In closing, my Lords, I want to anticipate and respond to the counter-argument deployed by the Minister in another place when proposing this legislation in July. She said, "Implementing the measures helped Northern Ireland to maintain its dual market access."
The sense was that all the problems that I've outlined are worthwhile because of the great prize of dual market access. But let me be quite clear: dual market access is a myth. If Northern Ireland enjoyed dual market access, there would be no Irish Sea customs border or UK-Republic of Ireland customs border. Northern Ireland would enjoy unfettered input access, unfettered sales access to the rest of the United Kingdom and unfettered input and unfettered sales access to the Republic. What has actually taken place is that Northern Ireland has been forced to exchange unfettered access to its home economy of nearly 70 million for unfettered access to another approximate economy of about 5 million.
My Lords, rather than becoming less problematic over time, the Irish Sea border is becoming more problematic with every new piece of legislation that is published to try and accommodate it. This position is completely unsustainable. The Irish Sea customs and international SPS border must go. I beg to move.
Ilora Finlay
The original question was that the regulations laid before the House on the 20th of January be approved, since when an amendment has been moved by Lord McCrea of Magherafelt and Cookstown to leave out all the words after "that" and insert the words set out on the order paper. The question I therefore have to put is that this amendment be agreed to.
John Redwood
My Lords, I thank Lord McCrea for putting this amendment so that we can again debate this crucial constitutional matter, and I have every sympathy with the points he made. Because what we face again this evening here is legislation by sleight of hand. We are in fact approving very comprehensive regulations for the battery sector, but we are told that's none of our business as a United Kingdom Parliament because that is something which was determined in Brussels without any of our representatives present and formed into a directive which is directly acting in Northern Ireland and an important part of our country. And so we are asked to debate today the much lesser issue of the impact of the enforcement mechanism, which we are allowed to discuss and approve, and not the wider impact of this battery regulation on a growing and complex sector with many businesses at stake. And so the Minister is able to tell us, reasonably accurately perhaps, that the impact assessment says this is not going to cost very much because the impact assessment only assesses the administrative cost connected with creating these new offences and doesn't go into the detail of what might happen if people actually had to pay the fines, of course.
And it leaves out the question of the huge compliance costs with the underlying directive. And the case is made that, well, of course, that already applies and so businesses have already had to impose that. It is rather odd that the government hasn't got round to putting the enforcement mechanism until now, because we've been told that it's much delayed compared with the EU requirement upon us. But nonetheless, they get there in the end. And I think Lord McCrea made very powerful points that in a democracy, if you're imposing potential large fines or imprisonment on people, that is surely something which your country and your elected parliament should control and not something which we are told we have to do because of an EU imposition on part of our country.
But my second great worry about this is it illustrates that not only are laws imposed on Northern Ireland without proper debate and democratic consideration or economic assessment, but we end up with them in Great Britain as well. And we are now told by the government that the only way they think they can guarantee the very important integrity of our internal market, a far bigger economic impact on both sides of the Irish Sea than the issues the EU is imposing with far less trade at risk. We are told that that all has to be taken for granted and we have to adopt the measures that the EU is imposing on Northern Ireland, otherwise our internal market will, of course, be disrupted. So not only now does the Windsor Framework mean that Northern Ireland has to accept undemocratic law on itself, but we probably end up with it in GB as well. Now, these are mighty issues arising out of what look like rather technical and small directives and statutory instruments to handle the directives.
And I would urge again the minister to take back to the wider government the point that you cannot go on like this. You cannot go on pretending we live in a sovereign democracy if by the back door these laws can be imposed on part of our country and then perhaps on the whole country without proper consideration. This must be the number one issue in reset and the government should not take no for an answer. There are easy solutions in reset. Please get on with them, government.
Nigel Dodds
My Lords, I rise to support the amendment in the name of my noble friend Lord McCrea. The government presents the regulation as a technical measure concerned with the placing of batteries on the market. However, like so many regulations flowing from the post-Brexit arrangements for Northern Ireland, they raise issues that extend far beyond their immediate subject matter. They concern the principle of equal treatment within our United Kingdom, the burden placed upon Northern Ireland businesses and the continuing erosion of democratic accountability. At the practical level, these regulations impose obligations on traders, manufacturers and distributors operating in Northern Ireland that are not faced by many of their counterparts elsewhere in the United Kingdom.
Businesses will have to familiarize themselves with new requirements, maintain compliance procedures, keep appropriate documents and ensure that products satisfy the latest relevant regulatory standards. The government may regard these obligations as modest, but for many small businesses and medium businesses enterprises, they are anything but modest.
Speaker 106
A family-run wholesaler or retailer in Northern Ireland does not have a dedicated compliance department or a team of lawyers on hand to interpret evolving rules. Every new requirement means additional paper, additional administrative time, additional record-keeping, and of course, additional cost. Businesses supplying both GB and Northern Ireland may find themselves having to operate under distinct regulatory arrangements. That can mean separate packaging, separate documentation, separate compliance checks and reporting requirements. These costs are very real for small traders working on very tight margins.
My Lords, we must also consider the enforcement regime that accompanies these obligations. Businesses are not merely being asked to comply with another set of rules, they're being asked to do so under the threat of investigation, enforcement and sanctions if they fail. A trader who inadvertently breaches these technical requirements may face compliance notices, restrictions on the sale of products or further legal proceedings. The real concern is not simply the penalty itself, but the risk that accompanies it. My Lords, this debate is therefore far more about more than batteries.
It is about democracy, accountability and equal citizenship. The issue before us is not simply an environmental policy, it is a question of equal treatment under the law. Businesses in Northern Ireland deserve legal certainty. They deserve democratic accountability and they do deserve the same regulatory framework as their counterparts in the rest of the United Kingdom, unless there is a compelling justification otherwise. Increasingly, however, we see Northern Ireland subject to distinct requirements which create barriers within the internal market of our own nation.
Lord McCrea's amendment rightly highlights these concerns. It recognizes that every new layer of regulatory divergence carries practical consequences for traders and constitutional consequences for Northern Ireland's place within the United Kingdom. I support Lord McCrea's amendment.
Jenny Chapman
My Lords, I'd like to just speak against Lord McCrea's amendment, although I do understand the tenacity with which this point is being put on a very regular basis and the sincerity with which he feels about these issues. I also understand that having listened on repeated occasions to these points being raised, that this is not a case of persuading my good friends and colleagues in this House that this is just about batteries and that there is a pragmatic need to just get on with this and these are probably good regulations anyway, so what's the harm? Those arguments get nowhere in this debate and I recognize that. So what I'm going to seek to try to do is just I think put this in a little bit of context around how we've got to where we are. The Windsor Framework, unfortunately, and it is better than that which it replaced in the Northern Ireland Protocol, but it is still the case that it is imperfect, it does create friction in the Irish Sea, it does create additional burdens on businesses and I think it's probably wise to just be honest and open and upfront about this and to not pretend otherwise.
It was necessary. It came about and I heard Lord McCrea say that he was not aware that these regulations would be coming into place and I can see why he says that but surely it must have been anticipated when the vote to leave the European Union took place that there would need to be some kind of arrangement for Northern Ireland and that it was going to entail a huge amount of compromise and ideally flexibility and understanding on both sides and a real determination to find a solution. I don't remember that atmosphere around those discussions at the time and so we are left with this unsatisfactory way of working but it is the operational reality in which we find ourselves and while it is there it is one that we must make to work. I've heard it said that the dual market access is imaginary, it's not a thing and I understand that there are problems with GBNI trade, that is true but it is not fair and not correct to say that there is no such thing as dual market access. There is and it is a position that businesses in Northern Ireland themselves, small enterprises, big exporters, manufacturers talk about wishing to take advantage of and they you can see the growth that is being achieved in Northern Ireland as a consequence of that dual market access and that unique economic position of Northern Ireland.
These regulations I think see that Northern Ireland is succeeding perhaps you could argue in spite of some of these challenges and when was that not the case that business and enterprise were not able to overcome such things. My experience of talking to businesses in Northern Ireland is actually they want the clarity, they want the certainty and they can deal with it and that is their intention. It is right if it's what you to believe to criticize the complexities of the current arrangements but equally please do not ignore the concrete advantages that see Northern Ireland consistently expanding manufacturing sales into the EU in advanced manufacturing, life sciences, aerospace and with local pioneers openly pointing to the Windsor Framework as a net positive giving them access to a six trillion pound market. I think that what we would be well to try and do when we can is to have a calm level-headed approach to all of this. The foundational agreements of the peace process they stand, what is needed is flexibility, pragmatism and a real focus on making sure that we never lose the stability, prosperity and achieving that good governance that Northern Ireland will always need.
Tom Elliott
My Lords I welcome the opportunity to speak in this debate and it's very welcome to follow Baroness Chapman who made some very interesting points, some of which I don't agree with to be fair but that's politics. But it is quite clear that in this particular piece of legislation that there is a UK conformity assessment and you know it's not going to be as simple as some people try to make it out, that is the difficulty that we have. And I agree with Baroness Chapman in that some people may see the Windsor Framework as being positive in the business sense, many others do not and that is the difficulty particularly if you're running a small or medium-sized business the extra burden and administration and bureaucracy that is put onto you leaves it sometimes hugely difficult to find your way around it.
The second issue that has been mentioned by a number of speakers here is actually the control that there will be on those who basically break the law because there will be penalties, very severe penalties that has been highlighted that the UK will have no control whatsoever over. I note that it didn't require a full consultation and that the de minimis amount has been put on it as regarding costs. I'm just not sure what all that covers. Maybe the minister can help us out in that sense as to what the estimates and the best estimates are. I do see the estimates in the legislation, but I'm not sure if that is the full amount.
The final thing that I did want to say and it goes back to I suppose the management of the entire Windsor Framework process. And Lord Murphy, who is in the chamber, had a report out last year. And one of his comments in the report was stated that the UK government should work to make the Windsor Framework related guidance accessible in a single all-in-one service and do more to signpost businesses, especially small and medium-sized businesses. I'm not actually sure that that has taken place yet. I'm not so sure that there has been any progress on it.
And I would like to hear from the minister because it's not going to resolve the issue around divergence between the UK and Northern Ireland, but what it would do at least in the meantime is help those small and medium-sized businesses in Northern Ireland, signpost them and get them the proper help and security that they may need. So I'd like to hear if there's some progress on that. Thank you.
James Stewart Jackson
My Lords, I'm pleased to have the opportunity of supporting the noble Lord McCrea of Magherafelt and Cookstown. And I find myself surprisingly in agreement with the noble lady Baroness Chapman of Darlington, who made a number of very fair points. And incidentally, I would say it would be good to see her back on the front bench and she's much missed on the front bench eventually. But I think she has slightly rose-tinted spectacles in respect of the negotiations of which I was part, a small part in the early part of the Northern Ireland Protocol, because it was never a binary choice as between a hard border and nothing else. There were always the options which were ignored by the May government and the Sunak government and the Johnson government of technical solutions which Lars Karlsson amongst others had pioneered in the Middle East, in Norway and Sweden.
And I perhaps preempt the comments, the perennial comments of the noble Lord Davies of Brixton about how terrible Brexit is. In respect of Northern Ireland, there were always choices which were not pursued. However, we are where we are. The Windsor Framework we know relegates Northern Ireland citizens as second class in applying EU law and violates territorial integrity and erodes UK sovereignty. Now, notwithstanding the fact that this is a technical enforcement instrument brought about because of the need to avoid legal jeopardy and litigation risk, I believe that we are failing in our duty because actually we're not even fulfilling the traditional parliamentary role of scrutiny and oversight.
We're not even fulfilling it. Incidentally and ironically, nor are the European Parliament or the Northern Ireland Assembly because of course this is generated from the European Commission. The European Parliament is not a parliament that we would necessarily recognize in the traditional sense.
It is in fact a body which is subject to huge amounts of lobbying by business in the interests of the countries of the European Union. What we are is an appointment body effectively for the market surveillance authority, which is the Office of Public Safety and Standards. That's our role in this sovereign parliament, and it's quite shameful in my opinion. We're not even looking at the efficacy of the policy, the technical details on carbon footprint, standards, recycling, labelling, the battery passport and CE marking. We are of course diverging from the 2008 regulations affecting Great Britain.
And I do believe, and it was a point made in the committee in the other place, that we are, we may have warm words, but as they say, warm words butter no parsnips. That section 46 of the Internal Market Act 2020 has not been offended, but it has. We're clearly not abiding by that, the territorial integrity and the importance of the UK-wide United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland single market. And this goes to the point made earlier, I think by one of the noble lords from the DUP, that we're talking about criminal liabilities here. We're not talking about an overdue library book.
We're talking about people potentially being the subject of criminal sanction and going to prison. That is not being debated in our sovereign parliament, or indeed in the devolved assembly in Northern Ireland. And I think that is a serious issue which should concern everyone, irrespective of their party. So my lords, that is something that ministers I think, and I challenge the minister to perhaps talk about that issue, because this is, these regulations are rules set by a body that no one voted for and cannot be removed. So can I ask three quick questions of the minister before I sit down?
Will she give us more details on the GB-wide consultation? What are the likely producer responsibility requirements that will arise following that? And will she perhaps undertake to review the operation of the regulations as between Great Britain and Northern Ireland in respect of competitive advantage? My final point is, if the noble lord chooses to test the opinion of the house, he will have my very strong support.
Maurice Morrow
My lords, I do welcome the amendment of the noble lord Lord McCrea to the house. And my lords, while a casual observer might think we are simply debating technical standards for consumer electronics or even industrial machinery, anyone with an eye for the integrity of our United Kingdom knows that we are doing something far more insidious, but also I have to say very dangerous. We are watching the further decoupling of Northern Ireland from the rest of the United Kingdom. And let us be completely clear about what this statutory instrument does. First of all, it does not create laws designed by British lawmakers to serve British citizens.
Instead, it seeks to establish an enforcement and criminal penalties regime within our borders to police an EU batteries regulation that applies directly under the Windsor Framework. My lords, it's an absolute travesty of our democracy that laws are being imposed on a part of the United Kingdom without a single vote being cast or a single shred of scrutiny being offered to any parliamentarian elected by the people of Northern Ireland.
We are instructing our own domestic courts and enforcement bodies to punish British citizens for failing to comply with rules manufactured in Brussels. How can we honestly stand in this chamber and claim that the union is secure when a consumer or a business owner in Belfast is legally barred from placing a product on the market that is perfectly lawful in the rest of this United Kingdom? This regulation divides our internal market, creates a regulatory border down the Irish Sea for everyday goods. We were promised that the Windsor Framework would protect the internal market. Yet here we are in 2026 rubber-stamping an instrument that proves the exact opposite.
My Lords, this is a classic and deeply troubling case of a democratic default. Not a single member of this House or any elected representative in Northern Ireland had the opportunity to scrutinize, debate, or vote on the underlying EU regulations. My Lords, we must not simply roll over and accept the rubber-stamping of foreign laws wrapped in criminal penalties while the economic foundations of the union are being eroded away, and I would urge members to oppose this regulation.
Bryn Davies
Before the recess, we had tumble dryers, last week we had seed potatoes, and this week we've got batteries. I support the process. I think it's right that every member of this House should have the right to seek a proper debate on all the statutory instruments that come before us, whether they affect Northern Ireland or more generally. It's important and to an extent we're making up for the problems faced in the Commons in giving adequate consideration to all the matters that come before them. So I support the process and I welcome the opportunity to debate these issues.
As the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough, apologies, said, there's always choices. I think the point we need to emphasize is that in the UK, we have made a choice. Some people don't like the choice we've made and you've got every right to protest about it, but it is the choice that has been made. And I think there's a certain irony that it's those who are most vociferous in calling for Northern Ireland's place within the United Kingdom who are objecting to a decision made by the United Kingdom. I think you have to take the obligations that come with your objectives and this is what we've got.
Now, I would just remind people of the points I made last week, which was that when the people of Northern Ireland voted, they voted against Brexit.
So I think people when they come forward to complain about the outcome, it's those who promoted Brexit who should accept the responsibility about where we've ended up. Given the land border, there were bound to be problems. And clearly whoever negotiated the arrangements did not do a good job. That's why yesterday in Grand Committee, the framework was being discussed. And my noble friend Baroness Ritchie of Downpatrick actually said, it's important, quote, "it's important that the challenges and impediments presented by the Windsor Framework are ironed out."
So it's an acceptance by even those she declared her support for the Windsor Framework, but she went on to say that it should be sorted out. And indeed that is following up the work of my noble friend Lord Murphy of Torfaen. So turning to batteries just in my last few seconds. Batteries are made in China. Some are made in Belgium.
And the idea that we as a country can determine the nature of batteries that are used in this country is an illustration of the falsity of the claim of taking back control. We are part of an international system and the reason why we don't have control over the form of batteries sold in this country is because we left the European Union. The decisions are being made. We have no power over what batteries are made in this country because they're not made in this country. They are made elsewhere.
And the wish to ignore the reality of an interconnected world is at heart the cause of the problems here.
David Frost
My Lords, I rise to support Lord McCrea's regret motion this evening. My Lords, one must acknowledge there's a slight Groundhog Day feel to the debate again this evening, third time in three weeks. And the points we've made this evening have already been made many times on the previous two occasions. But I think they're justified and I think they're no less important for their repetition. And indeed, I think the tone of these debates has changed a little week on week as we've reflected on the situation that we're facing.
And I think it is right that we keep at the forefront of our minds these great matters of principle. They do bear repetition. And indeed, as that great lady, Lady Thatcher, said when she was accused of saying the same old thing, she said, "Of course I am, the truth always is the same old thing." And it's true of this tonight as well. Now, the noble lady the Minister in some ways made it easier for us tonight.
And I don't know whether she got weary on the previous two occasions of trying to say there's nothing to see here and we shouldn't worry about it. Because tonight she's been quite upfront about it in her opening statement, that she was quite open about the fact that there's no discretion about this. That the regulation has already been in force for two years. We're talking about supplementary enforcement arrangements for a regulation that's already being enforced. There is no choice about the legal requirement to impose these new laws.
They're already in place. There's a legal requirement, as has already been noted, to enforce laws, criminal laws, criminal offenses, new offenses that have been made elsewhere and in which nobody in this country has had any say. And as I said last week, I think there's an element of performative lawmaking, performative discussion in this when there's no discretion.
And if that's not a lack of autonomy, I don't know what it is. Now, I use that word because the noble lady the minister may remember that last week I said, I quoted her as saying on our first debate, "we retain", and I quote, "we retain complete autonomy to make our own regulatory decisions". She was referring to Northern Ireland. And I questioned whether in the light of the regulations we were discussing, whether that could really be stood up as a statement. And I don't think she responded to it last week.
Perhaps she could take the time to explain how she justifies that statement tonight when we are discussing a regulation over which we've had no choice. The noble lady the minister was also honest about her intention to replicate in Great Britain this legislation that's already in place in Northern Ireland. And I think it would be better to be honest if at some point the government admitted that it is its policy to do this, to replicate where it can laws that are already in place in Northern Ireland in Great Britain as part of a bridge, no doubt, eventually to the single market for goods. My Lords, in my final few seconds, I just wanted to thank the noble lady Baroness Chapman for her comments. I thought they were, if not entirely fair, and I wouldn't agree with everything, I think that the tone was good and I think that we should be able to have pragmatic and calm discussions of this while not forgetting the important points of principle involved of democracy, of discussion, of proper lawmaking.
I do just want to pick up this point of dual market access in the final few seconds if I may. I don't think it's a good term. Northern Ireland is a member of another market for goods. That's the situation. A market in which it has no say.
It has attenuated access to GB, but the real problem is that Great Britain has a very limited access to Northern Ireland. And that is what the real underlying problem of the Windsor Framework is. And until we deal with that problem, we are going to be coming back discussing this for years to come.
David John Maclean
My Lords, I thank the noble lady the Baroness the Minister for bringing forward these regulations and being present to hear the concerns of noble Lords. And I look forward to a response. Once again, I found the arguments of the noble Lords from Northern Ireland, my noble friends, on the constitutional difficulties of these regulations to be very compelling. So I begin by addressing the motion in the name of Lord McCrea Magherafelt and Cookstown. And I repeat the sentiments of what I said last week.
The Windsor Framework was an improvement on the Northern Ireland Protocol, but that is not to say it has no flaws or that my party are not willing to improve it further. And indeed, we all must. He's absolutely right, and other noble Lords and my noble friends are right. We cannot let the integrity of the Union and Northern Ireland's place in it be quietly undermined through secondary legislation. Secondary legislation which seems quite straightforward, seems quite innocuous, is quite trivial, doesn't change much, but collectively begins to lever Northern Ireland out of the United Kingdom.
Labour person from that side, I have heard say that the the um the Windsor Framework needs a bit of tweaking. And I think it was quite a bit of tweaking she was suggesting. I think I and my noble friends would like probably a lot more tweaking of it than she does, but it's a very good it's a very good stance she's taken and I agree it can be done quietly and softly and and speaking quite softly. Now, these regulations of course fully implement the the um the battery regulations and they replace the previous 2006 batteries directive to improve battery safety and environmental performance. We understand the government received a limited number of responses to its engagement and so concluded that stakeholders are content with these regulations.
And I welcome the wise words of Baroness, the noble lady Baroness Chapman of Darlington. And I too miss her from the front bench.
Well, that may be the case, but I'd like to ask the noble baroness the minister what assessment they've made of the impact on the UK's internal market more widely, as well as on the competitiveness of Northern Ireland businesses, specifically within our internal market. The minister in the other place had said the government will and the noble lady also said the government will consult on an aligned regime across the whole UK that is consistent and will provide a unified regulatory framework across the UK and the EU. So does that form part of the government's wider aims for dynamic alignment and what is the basis for alignment in this specific regulatory area? And I think I I agree with my noble friend Lord Frost that when they do this consultation, I think we all know what the outcome will be. The outcome will be yes, the UK must adopt the similar legislation in Northern Ireland and adopt the UK regulation.
In that case, let's cut out the comedy of doing a long consultation and get on with it. So if we are going to align UK battery policy with Northern Ireland battery policy and EU battery policy, then let's do it quickly so we don't have any lacuna and industry can crack on with it. And I say that not because I want to be aligned with EU policy, but if the government's going to do it, then whatever thou doest, doest quickly. So my lords my noble lords have raised important points um from all the noble lords from Northern Ireland and my noble friends and the noble baroness Chapman, I look forward to the minister's response.
Sue Hayman
My lords, can I thank noble lords for the contributions to this debate. I think it's important just to clarify what the instrument does and what it doesn't do. It doesn't introduce new policy, nor does it impose any significant new regulatory burdens on businesses. What it does is ensure the obligations that are already in force in Northern Ireland can be properly enforced. And without these regulations, we'd have rules on the statute book but no effective means to uphold them.
And that isn't a position that the government considers to be acceptable. So I'll just try and answer as many questions as I can. I don't have very long, unfortunately. The noble lord Lord McCrea talked about internal UK divergence as a result of the placing on the on the of this SI. As I said, different requirements do now apply for batteries placed on the Northern Ireland market compared to those placed on the GB market as a result of the direct application of the EU batteries regulation in Northern Ireland.
However, the majority of batteries will be manufactured to meet the Northern Ireland and EU requirements whether they are physically placed on the market in mainland Europe, Northern Ireland or in Great Britain. So the idea about this SI is to provide clarity, certainty and enforceability and to equip enforcement authorities with the powers they need to ensure that the batteries placed on the Northern Ireland market do meet the required standards. There have been a number of questions around divergence, impacts to business and on enforcement. And on divergence, I want to reassure the house that in practice the impact will be minimal because the reality is most manufacturers already design their products to meet EU standards as I said wherever they are wherever they are sold. The noble lord Lord Elliott asked about enforcement and costs in the de minimis assessment covering the enforcement regime.
These were extremely low with an equivalent annual direct cost to business of under eight thousand pounds. And that's across all Northern Ireland businesses that are affected, not each. So that eight thousand is is right across the piece.
The noble lord Lord Elliott and the noble lord Lord Redwood also asked about impact assessments and costs. The related calculated costs in the SI are minimal. A small one-off familiarisation cost, that's about two hours per business, total in 35,017 pounds across all the affected businesses is estimated as they become aware of the SI and its enforcement provisions. 776 businesses that place batteries onto the Northern Ireland market are estimated to be in scope. There will also be some small additional costs for monitoring and enforcement activities for compliant businesses that are placing batteries on the Northern Ireland market to enable regulator activity such as audits or inquiries.
And they've been calculated to total 33,822 pounds over the 10-year appraisal period. There's also ongoing costs of approximately 330,000 pounds per annum expected to be incurred by Defra to fund market surveillance and enforcement activity undertaken by the OPSS. This is inspections, investigations, audit and do not fall on businesses as costs and are not included in the equivalent annual net direct cost to businesses. There is no direct impact on households so the equivalent annual net direct cost to households is therefore assessed as zero pounds. The noble lord Lord Redwood also asked about some on offences.
Just to say that 182 batteries industry and other stakeholders were sent the proposed offences and penalties and invited to provide feedback in January of this year. Out of the 182 stakeholders only one responded, which came from a trade body operating in Northern Ireland. They agreed with the rationale behind the penalty group, didn't comment on other aspects of the SI. So the very low response rate to this communications indicated stakeholders are content with the approach taken and concerns related to this SI are low. On enforcement, the Office for Product Safety and Standards, which enforced the previous placing on the market regulations, will be appointed by the Secretary of State to enforce the new placing on the market requirements of the EU's 2023 batteries regulation in Northern Ireland.
And to facilitate it, this SI amends the market surveillance Northern Ireland regulations of 2021 to provide for the powers of enforcement under those regulations to apply to the enforcement of these regulations and to the EU batteries regulation requirements. The noble lord Lord Blencathra asked some specific questions about competitiveness of Northern Ireland businesses and impact on the internal market and also about whether the proposed alignment in the consultation formed part of the government's wider aims for dynamic alignment. I thank the noble lord for those questions. We think the practical effect will be limited. As I've already mentioned, the majority of batteries will be manufactured to meet the Northern Ireland EU requirements whether they're physically placed on the market in Europe, Northern Ireland or in Great Britain.
And batteries meeting the Northern Ireland EU requirements can also be placed on the market in Great Britain. As I noted earlier, it doesn't introduce any new requirements or amend any existing ones, it's just to ensure placing on the market requirements are already in force or due to come into force and are enforceable in Northern Ireland. And we're satisfied the SI goes no further than is necessary to implement those provisions reflecting that position. On the question on alignment, we do intend to consult as I said later this autumn on the aligned regime across the whole of UK that's consistent with the EU batteries regulation. We think that's the right thing to do as I mentioned earlier, it has to be for the whole of the UK and to protect the whole of the UK's internal market.
We've engaged extensively with businesses and others over a long period on the approach to batteries. And for placing on the market matters, industry's been clear that they do want to see this common set of standards. For waste and producer responsibility matters, as I... the pace of battery technology development and change means that market and waste burden is very different now to when the current UK regulations were made. And there are a number of acknowledged difficulties with the operation of the existing approach. And we're hoping that the consultation with that UK-wide approach should go a long way to address those issues.
But it's important the consultation should not be seen as a general approach to regulatory alignment. Rather, it's reflecting the specific circumstances of the battery sector. The noble Lord Woodward asked about the penalties regime and why it's taken over three years since the batteries regulation was published in July 2023. It does... the EU batteries regulation does introduce significant new and evolving requirements. And it's important that any regime respects Northern Ireland's dual market position.
And within this mind, we do feel that we have moved as quickly as we were able to bring forward this instrument on the placing of the market elements. And as I've previously set out, the consultation that we're going to be doing this autumn on waste and producer responsibility provisions. And that UK-wide consultation is, as I said, going to propose consistency, which we know is what business wants. On conformity, I can't remember who asked me this, terribly sorry. The UK NI marking is a common requirement for regulatory regimes included in the Windsor Framework that require conformity assessment.
If assessment is conducted by a UK assessment body, if a product has been conformity assessed by a UK conformity assessment body as opposed to an EU conformity assessment body, then it must be accompanied with the CE plus UK NI marking and can only be placed on the Northern Ireland market. I'm going to wrap up so I want to give Lord McCrea some time to respond. It is important to note all of this has been done with close engagement across government and industry. And we have not had concerns raised by stakeholders. So this is practical, proportionate, and necessary.
Can I thank noble Lords again? Anything I haven't covered, I will pick up from Hansard.
Robert William McCrea
My Lords, I want to express my thanks to everyone who's taken part in this debate. I'd like to thank Lord Redwood and Elliott, Jackson, Frost, Cathcart, and also my colleagues Lord Browne and Hay for their support. There have, however, been two dissenting voices from that of your Lordships' House. I'd have to say to Baroness Chapman, I deeply appreciate where she's coming from. But she did acknowledge that there are additional burdens on industry through this.
And my answer to her by question is, how much and how many more additional burdens can industry in Northern Ireland take and be told that they must accept? Because all the concessions as regards whenever Europe asks for something, all the concessions is a one-way traffic. And the government surrenders to the demands of Europe. And as regards the dual market access, I have to remind her there are many disadvantages on that so-called dual market. For example, business importing steel into Northern Ireland are now paying up to 25% tariff on categories 4 and category 7 steel because the EU tariff quotas have already been exhausted.
So there are problems there. To Lord Davies of Brixton, I can say that I'd remind him also gently that the decision was not concerning the leaving of the European Union, what part was going to leave. It was a question for the United Kingdom as a whole. And therefore, when we were asked, should the United Kingdom leave, not should Northern Ireland, should Scotland. Because in actual fact, whilst there's different treatment for Northern Ireland, it's interesting there's no different treatment for Scotland, whilst they're demanding special treatment for them.
But there's no such thing as that coming their way.
I've listened very carefully to what noble Baroness, the Minister, has said and I thank her for the gracious manner she has dealt with this regret motion. But I have to say to her and to the government that that response will not do. On one level, introducing the same laws that the EU has imposed on one part of the United Kingdom on the other removes the problem of divergence, but it allows the EU to shame the whole United Kingdom through its strategy of divide and rule.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, the time allotted for this debate has now elapsed and the noble Lord must either press his amendment or seek leave to withdraw it. Does the noble Lord wish to move his amendment?
Ilora Finlay
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. The question is that the original motion be agreed to. As many as that opinion will say content. The contrary not content.
The contents have it.
That the house do now adjourn.