Justice and Home Affairs Committee

3 November 2026

Justice and Home Affairs Committee House of Lords

Follow its sittings
00:01 - 00:29
Speaker 7
Okay. Order.  The meeting is now being recorded and public proceedings are beginning.  5, 4  Welcome everybody and to this meeting of the Justice and Home Affairs Select Committee, following up our work on prisons.  We're absolutely delighted we've got Dame Anne Owers with us today. 

Dame Anne, if you'd be kind enough to just introduce yourself and your background. 
00:29 - 00:51
Speaker 4
Thank you, Lord Chairman.  I'm Anne Owers, and I was for nine years Chief Inspector of Prisons, and after that I ran the Independent Police Complaints Commission as it then was, and have also been National Chair of the Independent Monitoring Boards in prisons, and currently I chair the Howard League. 
00:51 - 00:53
Speaker 1
Thank you very much.  Lord Trefgarne. 
00:53 - 00:59
Speaker 2
Thank you, Chair.  We told just now we may call you Anne.  I hope that is all right. 
00:59 - 01:00
You may.  Thank you. 
01:00 - 01:36
Speaker 3
I noticed the Chair didn't, that's why I thought I would check.  Didn't obey our own rule.  Let's move on.  A nice simple question to start with, how do we get out of the prison capacity crisis?  And while you think about the simple answer to that question, you made a number of recommendations, I think a while back, five recommendations. 

I see that the then minister accepted the major in principle the majority of them.  Can you tell us which ones were not accepted and how you're getting on with the ones that are accepted? 
01:36 - 02:23
Speaker 4
Okay, if I could deal those with those questions in turn, my Lord.  I think one of the things in my report, two preliminary comments: my report is pointing not just to one capacity crisis, but to what I called a perma-crisis and those crises have not stopped since I produced the report.  Prisons are good at crisis management, they have to be, but if you're operating always under crisis, you're not operating at optimal capacity.  And capacity, as I said in my report, isn't just about space, it's about whether you've got the capacity to actually deal with the issues that have brought people to prison in the first place and will bring them back if you don't do something about it.  And also, before I get on to my own recommendations, I think there are two rather large elephants in the room. 
02:23 - 03:20
Speaker 6
One of which is the rise in prison sentences, which everyone is aware of: at least 40% rise recently, 80% in some serious cases, so that what is building up is that people are not getting out of prison as quickly, or whatever you do at the front end.  And the second, which I also mentioned in my report, is the importance of investing in what I called not prison, investing in not just the probation service, but those other services in the community which people need if they are not to get there in the first place or not to come back.  And if you look at what's happened in the youth justice system, where when I was inspecting there were 3,000 children in prison and they're are now in the 300s, because of the engagement of other services in the community and there's been a reduction in youth offending.  So, those are the sort of preliminary comments. 

03:20 - 06:26

Anne Owers

How we get out of the crisis is, as I say, by in those in my view, those are some of the key areas. The response to my report, well, I think this Committee will be aware of the fact that when you produce reports, people accept things in principle, and then you look at the practice, and you wonder what precisely has changed. And that, I think, is the case with for many of the things that I recommended. There is and I know this Committee is aware of this that Amber Rudd is doing a review of the prison service,

which I think is needed, to look independently, and indeed, I would like the Chief Inspector of Prisons to be able to look more at the prison service itself instead of individual prisons. I think that would be helpful. So that is useful. I also made quite a lot of recommendations about probation, the about the need to do the same with the probation service, because we know what's happened to the probation service, that the pressures, the capacity pressures that there are, invisible, but very real.

And also, the need to involve the third sector more in planning, not just in delivery, but in planning for delivery, and I haven't seen any change in that. The thing that both David Gauke's review and my own recommended was that there should be some independent advisory body to provide advice and validation of capacity strategies and challenges in both prisons and probation, and in particular, any proposed changes in the criminal justice system. It's always tempting to tinker with the system and to tinker with sentencing, as we have found quite recently. There is no independent validation of what might happen as a result.

When I started Just to conclude, when I started my own review, I was presented with what the permanent secretary in the Ministry of Justice had done before, which was to set up something she called Operation Rearview, which to collect evidence that would show the impending result of what was happening in prisons and prison capacity, which everyone was aware of. That was very helpful to me. I would like there to be an independent body that carries out operation forward-look, because if you're driving a car and you only ever look in the rear-view mirror, you know what will happen,

and it keeps on happening. So I don't see as yet any movement, and this is also something David Gauke recommended, I don't yet see any movement on that. I think having some independent body which is looking at the impact on capacity in both prisons and probation of any interesting, new development, thought, plan would be incredibly helpful, because it's known internally, but it's not always known externally.

06:26 - 06:29

Don Foster

Thank you. Very briefly, Baroness Berridge.

06:29 - 06:42

Elizabeth Berridge

You mentioned that the Amber review Amber Rudd review is necessary. How would you distinguish that review from we've got a list of quite a number of reviews that has happened in the last 5, 10 years, how do you distinguish that review?

06:42 - 07:34

Anne Owers

Well, I think it is looking independently of what's happening in the prison service as a whole. As I say, the Chief Inspector can look at individual prisons. There isn't, at the moment, and I think there should be a regular capacity for looking at what's happening in prison so what's happening to staffing, what's happening to buildings, what's You know, all of those things that are very important. So, I think that's helpful, but I think your point is a wider one, isn't it, that it is very easy, and governments are very good at commissioning independent reviews,

and indeed independent inspections, and independent all kinds of things.

But the advantage of independence, of course, is that you can say what should be happening rather than what can happen right now. But the proof of the pudding is actually whether anything changes.

07:34 - 07:36

Don Foster

Baroness Bertin.

07:36 - 08:15

Speaker 16

Yes, good morning. If we could just sort of carry on a little bit from your question, the first question about how effective actually are the systems in place for prisoners leaving prisons, for example, tagging, housing, and health. I realise they're three quite big meaty subjects which I realise you can't answer totally in full, but particularly if we could begin on tagging, because as you would be very aware, the victims of domestic abuse are terrified by the early release scheme, and the fact that tagging does not seem to be, as far as we can tell, being put in place in a manner that is entirely proper.

08:15 - 09:31

Anne Owers

No, tagging is, I mean, I'm not an expert on tagging, so I'm not I'm not going to venture too many opinions, except to say that I know the Institute of Government has done a look at it, hasn't it? And there are some serious issues about compliance, and so on, and about fitting tags and unfitting tags, and so on and so forth. And of course, it will it also adds to the pressure on the police service, and so on. That's evident. I think the other problem with tagging though is it is enforcement, it's not support.

And if you rely solely on enforcement, I mean, what people leaving prison very often need is the services that are very stretched outside: housing, mental health services, drug and alcohol services, employment, all of those things. I mean, that's the crucial thing. If we just invest in prisons or indeed just in any sort of enforcement, it's I used to say it's a bit like just investing in the accident and emergency services in the health service. What you're doing is picking up what's going wrong elsewhere. You're not actually engaged in prevention, support, and making people healthier, and making people less likely to commit crimes.

09:31 - 09:50

Speaker 16

If I could just have a follow-up on that, particularly around housing and health. I mean, how far away do you think we are really in getting to a place that can actually those issues help people from going back into prison as you put forward? I mean, you know, how could you put a sort of estimate on how far away we are from getting to a better place on that?

09:50 - 10:37

Anne Owers

Quite a long way away. I mean, if you look at the fact that 2/3 of those who are homeless will end up back in prison. I mean, that's just one statistic. I mean, I could bore you with statistics for a long while on this. But what you know, what you know is that the people who are in prison are, you know, more of them more of them will have used drugs, and more of them have mental health issues.

So, and we know that community services are very stretched. It's evident. The criminal justice system acts as a sort of as a sort of emergency mental health service, both in terms of policing and in terms of prisons. So, it's, so, you know, without that, without investment in not prison, I think we're going to be back in the same circle.

10:37 - 10:39

Speaker 9

Yeah, thank you.

10:39 - 10:40

Lord Hogan-Howe.

10:40 - 10:51

Speaker 11

Just quickly on tagging, because there are two, I agree with entirely with everything you've said up till now. But one of the things about tagging is that there's now sobriety tagging, which helps to reduce the some of the cause of some offending for some people.

10:52 - 11:07

Speaker 11

And there's also geofencing, which helps to reassure people like domestic violence victims that people will not be enter an area in which they live, for example. So, I just wonder what more, because it's not just the present system which is inefficient, it's the future that's not, it seems to me, not been mapped out.

11:07 - 11:29

Anne Owers

Yes, yeah. I I I I I take your point, Lord Hogan-Howe, absolutely, that I mean, I'm not saying that tagging is ineffective, and certainly can provide some assurance to people. But unless you deal with the underlying causes, it's the same as prison.

You're not, in the end, going to make the community safer.

11:29 - 11:35

Don Foster

Thank you. Baroness Buscombe.

11:35 - 12:15

Peta Buscombe

Thank you. I have to say, Dame Anne, really pleased that you've come here today, because some of us have been debating this for over 20 years and no change, just a different approach. And the latest one, of course, is to try and sort the cost, and time, and delay through the Courts and Tribunals Bill. So that's supposed to have a positive effect on prison capacity and the prison estate. I'd love to have your, we'd love to have your thoughts on that, but also what changes you'd like to see made to the bill.

12:15 - 13:49

Anne Owers

I have to confess that I haven't looked at the bill in detail, because it's not something that you're right that there will be an effect, certainly an immediate effect on both prisons and probation. The impact assessment for the bill indicates that there will be that there will be a quick consequence, pressure consequence, for both prisons and probation in the Courts and Tribunals Bill. It's not really and it will increase probation costs. I think that the premise of the bill of faster justice is a good thing in itself. I mean, it's a good thing for victims, it's a good thing, actually, for offenders, to and what I saw in prisons a lot is prisoners serving almost the whole of their sentence on remand, which is not good for anybody, because it means that they can't, obviously they can't be put into offending behavior programs, because they haven't offended.

They're not obliged to go to work or education, and prisons often can't make the space for them to do that. So that and people sometimes, I found in my report, released directly from court without even any probation supervision, because they'd served every part of their sentence already before they'd even been sentenced. So, faster justice will is, in principle, a good thing, but I go back to the point that it requires the support, it requires support for prisons then to be able to do what they're supposed to do.

13:49 - 13:57

Speaker 17

Yeah. And do you have confidence that will happen, because the probation system we know is in crisis and has been for years?

13:57 - 14:28

Anne Owers

Absolutely. Absolutely. And no, I don't. I wish I had more confidence, but, as I said earlier, probation there has been a capacity crisis in probation for a very long time, not helped by extensive reorganisations and re-reorganisations, and difficult difficulties with staffing, difficulties in all areas. So, I think that, you know, the system is not working as it should.

14:28 - 14:31

Speaker 23

Also, I mean, I Yeah. Okay.

14:31 - 14:33

Don Foster

Can we if you don't mind, Lord Bach.

14:33 - 15:08

Lord Bach

Thank you. This is a hugely wide question, and I'm going to try and ask you about one aspect of it. The question is what are the many major challenges that you see in our prison system moving forward? I'm almost slightly embarrassed asking you that question, and, but what I would like to just direct your mind towards a bit, with your experience, is the issue around prison officers. We've debated this and reported on it quite a lot recently, and there does seem to be a real problem still in terms of prison officers.

15:08 - 15:11

Speaker 21

I wonder if you have any solutions.

15:11 - 17:12

Anne Owers

Solutions! I agree with you, and, yes, I If you were to ask me about the major challenges, I think we would probably be here at till at least lunch time, and I don't propose to subject you to that.

If you're thinking about staffing, yes, there is a real problem. There is a problem both in prisons and probation about the numbers and about the levels of experience of staff who are dealing with some very difficult and problematic people and some very some people have a lot some in prisons, a lot of experience of prisons. I mean if you look at the fact that 31% of the main prison officer grade have been there less than three years, and only 25% more than 10 years. And if you look back to 2010 when I stopped inspecting prisons, there were only 13% of prison officers under three years, and there were 56% who had more than 10 years. Now just being there for a long time doesn't necessarily make you a great prison officer, but it does mean that you've got experience.

It does mean that when you're very young and on the landings and you're the thing that struck me when I went round prisons was the inexperience, but also the youth. I mean these are sometimes 18, 19-year-old people who are not, you know, there aren't enough experienced prison officers around to get to warn them about not about being strong in the right places, and not homing in on the wrong things at the wrong times. So that the inexperience, inconsistent practice, limited capacity, and I also have always thought that we do not invest enough in training our prison staff or our prison governors. They're doing an incredibly difficult job and it there is insufficient investment in continue in both early and continuous training.

17:12 - 17:54

Lord Bach

Can I just have one quick supplementary? I think we, if I remember rightly, it looks like our allies, other countries, when we look internationally, kind of professionalize, make it a sort of more worthy profession in terms of eyes of the public than prison officers perhaps sometimes here. Is there something in that? Should, is part of it an attempt to really make it sound and be a better job and people able to be more proud of it than they are perhaps sometimes, because people aren't particularly appreciative of them? Is there anything in that at all?

17:54 - 18:46

Anne Owers

I think there's something in it. But, I mean, I think perhaps going down the Norway route of two years' academic training before you become a prison officer is probably not. I think we need definitely more training and also, but it is also about, I think the second bit of your question is important. It's about the respect for the job and people don't know what goes on in prison. So, people see police officers and the job that they're doing, the very difficult job that they're doing.

People don't see prison officers. They don't see what happens behind those walls. So, I think more investment in staff generally and in-service training and all those, I mean, there are projects starting, but in my experience, projects start and then sometimes they sort of just fade away. Yeah, thanks.

18:46 - 18:47

Baroness Hughes.

18:47 - 19:34

Beverley Hughes

Thank you, Chair. Good morning, Dame Anne. This committee has called for a greater focus on meaningful, purposeful activity in prisons, and indeed, the Chief Inspector has lamented the lack of meaningful, purposeful activity now over many decades. Why do you think that is? And what, in your view, is the best way to achieve it?

Is it a matter of resource, political priority? Is it just in the too difficult box? What how do you see that, because it has been a sustained picture, hasn't it, the failure to realize the potential of prison to help people when they get out to avoid offending through activity?

19:34 - 21:33

Anne Owers

That's absolutely true. It's partly a function of what we were talking about earlier, which is the sheer number of people in prison. That limits budget. I mean you've only got to look at the fact the education budget, for example. Now what the prison service will say is the education budget hasn't been cut.

Well, no, it hasn't, but the number of prisoners has risen and teachers' salaries have also risen, so there's an effective 30 to 40% cut in prison education. And that is crucial because you're often dealing with people who have avoided or been avoided by education for most of their young lives. And you've got an opportunity there to do something. I think the other thing about prison education that I'd say is that one of the things that's taken a real deep dive a real dive is vocational training, because if you've got people who have, as I say, been avoiding classrooms for most of their lives, sitting them down in a classroom is not necessarily the best way of learning. And we're looking in education generally at vocational training, at actually linking in training to what people might want to do.

I can remember when I visited Aylesbury prison a long time ago and Nissan had invested in a car workshop, a beautifully constructed car workshop, so that kids who outside prison had been taking cars, were now learning, and were fascinated by cars, were learning how to fix them and were really enthused by that. So that kind of that kind of thing. So I focused a bit on education, but generally purposeful activity. I mean if you look at the surveys from the prison inspectorate, 34% of people locked up for 22 hours a day. I mean, what's going to happen is they're going to be locked up, waiting for the next drone drop or and watching television.

It's You know, we've got there's an opportunity, you have literally a captive audience and you ought to be doing something with them. Mm.

21:33 - 22:02

Beverley Hughes

And do you think the resource constraints are a major factor? Or has that grown in the prison service amongst the staff? Are they inured now, you know, more to locking people up all day than they used to be? Because it used to be, when I visited prisons, when I knew you, that was something that people really officers really wanted to avoid, and yet it's very commonplace now.

22:02 - 23:14

Anne Owers

I think the combined impact of inexperienced staff, COVID, the COVID lockdowns, and some and let's be honest, some difficult to reach prisoners. The combination of all of those things, I think has made a different feel in prisons than it used to be. In when I used to inspect prisons, in a bad prison, there was a saying of officers, happiness is door-shaped. In other words, everything was all right as long as the prisoners were behind their doors. That was unusual and rare and frowned upon.

It's now become, you know, with prisoners locked up for 22 hours a day, it's now become normalized in some places. And I think so, I agree with you. I think prisons are much less purposeful and much less active places than they used to be when even when I was inspecting. They weren't by any means perfect. But if you look at the assessments of the Chief Inspector of Prisons and purposeful activity, I think from memory, there's only one closed prison which he said was good.

23:14 - 23:31

Don Foster

Could I just interrupt that? Can you tell us, may not know, whether the rate of reoffending was lower at the time when you were doing your inspections than it currently is? I.e. when there was more purposeful activity?

23:31 - 23:37

Anne Owers

I can't answer that question, I'm afraid. I could go and have a look. I don't know.

23:37 - 23:46

Don Foster

It would be very helpful obviously if we did know that, because it would make the help make the case that we're trying to make for more purposeful activity.

23:46 - 23:51

Anne Owers

I would say to some extent, the rate of reoffending does depend on the number of short sentence prisoners you've got,

23:51 - 23:52

Of course.

23:52 - 24:11

Anne Owers

because there are now fewer prisoners serving short sentences, and those are your revolving door prisoners. So, they will revolve until a certain point at which a light goes on and they become too old or they stop doing it. So, it does depend a bit on the composition of the prison population, as well as what's happening in prisons.

24:11 - 24:14

Don Foster

Yeah, that's a very good point. Lord Dubs.

24:14 - 24:36

Alfred Dubs

Yes, good morning, Anne. In our report, we talked a lot about the power of governors and how much autonomy they have. And indeed, we felt, and I quote my own report, "Governors are hindered by an overcomplicated and confusing management structure, too much bureaucracy, etcetera." What do you think?

24:36 - 26:13

Anne Owers

I agree in principle, and so, of course, does the Prison Governors Association, unsurprisingly. I do think that governors often feel that their hands are tied in terms of things that they can see that they want to do, even sort even things that they want to get for the prison. Even everything is very centralized. So, I think that, and I know that in probation, it's looking they're looking at devolution to local areas, and that would fit in with also governors getting more involved in what's going to happen outside. But it does require training.

If you are going to give more autonomy, more decision-making to governors, then you, like prison staff, you need to invest in, because it is a very difficult job to do. I mean you're running something which has to provide everything that a small town would. You know, a very complex environment with some very complex people. So, I think more devolution to governors would be helpful, combined with more training, and also, hopefully, less movement of governors.

I noticed in the Prison Inspectorate report that there was one, or was it the IMB's, one prison had three governors in a year. Well, the staff know that the they just need to sit around and wait for the next one. I mean it's not, you know, you're not going to be able to You've got to stay long enough to be able to manage the consequences of the changes that you want to that you want to put in place.

26:13 - 26:35

Don Foster

Thank you. Just before we move on to Lord Anderson, in terms of the increased autonomy for governors, making your noting your point about training and support, and so on, do you think that should include greater involvement in the appointment of prison staff?

26:35 - 27:11

Anne Owers

It's certainly something that prison governors have said that they would like to be more involved in. And I can see the point that in other institutions, you do get to choose the people who work for you, in a school and so on. So, I think more I think also more a differ- more a different kind of interviewing for prison staff, because there's an awful lot of drop out very early on in prison staff because people genuinely don't realize what they're getting into. And an experienced governor would be able, probably, to ask the right questions.

27:11 - 27:22

Don Foster

Thank you. Our next question is quite lengthy, but I'm going to lead leave Lord Anderson to take us through it.

27:22 - 28:09

Speaker 25

Well, thank you.

The question is about oversight. This committee found last year that the recommendations of the chief inspector are often disregarded, even if, as I think you were hinting, they may have been accepted in theory. And it also found that the capacity for the Independent Monitoring Boards to deliver robust and consistent oversight had diminished. And I wondered if you had any thoughts on those conclusions, whether you agree with them, what you think perhaps ought to be done to remedy them if you do agree?

And then, if that wasn't enough, can I add a final curveball, something this committee has been thinking about in a slightly different context: Do you think there is still any place for Crown immunity in our Prison Service?

28:09 - 31:15

Anne Owers

Well. Oversight mechanisms. I think there's always been a tension, I think, in oversight between effectiveness and independence. If you're going to be independent, you can't you won't be recommending things that the service can immediately do or can or and sometimes is doesn't want to do.

I mean that you wouldn't be independent if all you were doing was saying how things should be, how things are. So for that reason, Chief Inspectors of Prisons have always been independent, always come from outside the Prison Service and have always been genuinely independent. So you're not tied to what the system can currently do, which does create a tension because you are sometimes recommending things that can't immediately happen. However, I do think that there ought to be a rather more effective mechanism of testing what actually has been done in relation to inspection reports, review. We talked about the number of reviews and so on. It's I think some sort of formal reporting to this House or to the other place,

some formal look at what has actually happened would be incredibly would be incredibly helpful. And that's one of the reasons why, in my review, I was talking about some sort of body that was looking forward at what was happening. Because what inspectorates all inspectorates can do, if they do it well, is to tell you what's happening now and what the consequences of your actions have been. They can't they can't predict.

They can't they can't tell you what's happening at the time. They tell you what's happening at the time, not what might happen. In terms of Independent Monitoring Boards, it is I think it is there are some there are some genuine difficulties. Recruitment is always going to be a difficult to a voluntary, unpaid role. The advantage of Independent Monitoring Boards is that they are there all the time.

And really, they ought to be a very effective complement to the inspectorate because they're your they're your permanent They can tell you know, what the trajectory of a prison is, as opposed to a deep dive at one particular moment. So it feeds in very well to occasional inspecting, having people there on the ground. And I think the most recent annual report of the IMBs is a really good description of what is happening just now in the prison system. So I think, working together, those two bits of inspection can do all that inspection can do, which is to tell you what's actually happening.

31:15 - 31:17

Speaker 24

And Crown immunity?

31:17 - 33:02

Anne Owers

And Crown immunity, yeah. I I I I I am surprised by a couple of things, looking at Crown immunity. I'm surprised, for example, that the police and the NHS don't have Crown immunity.

And I'm also surprised that private sector prisons don't. And it does seem to me rather strange to the point of being really difficult to defend, is that if you are lucky enough to be in a private prison, it then it will have to it will have to comply with what with the Crown Premises Fire Safety Inspectorate. If you are in a public sector prison, well, they can say, well, we might do something about it, but we haven't done anything about it right yet. I noticed there were nine step away notices recently, including two in a young offender institution, which is and I know this committee has taken a lot of interest in fire safety, which is one of the one of the huge risks. But there are others, such as Legionella, such as radon, such you know, there are the these are very these are potentially very risky places, and you know, fire safety smoke alarms.

So, I struggle to see why there shouldn't be why there should still be crown immunity. With other public sector bodies, there are sort of reduced fines, so you don't you don't reduce the capacity of the body to be able to act by but by enforcing, but you do it concentrates the mind wonderfully. Thank you.

33:02 - 34:14

Don Foster

Thank you very much. It was already referred to the large number of reviews that have taken place about prisons in one aspect or another of them in recent times. And we've also had annual Chief Inspector of Prisons reports and of course, the probation reports. All of this happening, but I think you rather implied not a lot has changed. I can also tell you that sadly, our committee advisor has just looked up the figures to show that, in fact, there has been no change in the return rate of prisoners over the last sort of 30-odd years.

So, apart from a slight blip during COVID, it's remained remarkably consistent. So, my question is, what is your view about all these reports, and yet everything remaining much the same? What can we do to give chief inspector reports of committees like this and others, a bit more teeth to get some changes made?

34:14 - 36:00

Anne Owers

I wish I had a re- really very concise answer to this, and I'm not sure I do. Reviews usually I mean reviews all almost always follow a disaster, don't they, rather than preventing it. So, I think the I think the trick is to try to make sure that those preventive mechanisms which exist have I as I said in answer to the previous question, I don't think you can have an enforcement role, because otherwise you couldn't point to what's good and what's necessary rather than what's possible. But certainly a greater accountability of to the prison service for responding to and not sort of saying, in principle, we accept this, when, in practice, as I said, nothing has happened. And there are lots of organisations, also in the voluntary sector, that are good, that point to things that do go wrong.

And I am very tired of hearing, you know, "Lessons have been learned."

Well, if they had, I'm afraid I wish they had because I don't think you'd pass the GCSE if that was if that was the way they you'd learned lessons because they tend not to. So, to I think a more active role for the chief inspector in terms of the Prison Service, as I've said, a reporting to Parliament on recommendations and what's actually happened. But sometimes these things do take time. But it isn't it isn't enough simply to say

36:00 - 36:22

Don Foster

Can I just take you back to the question Lord Anderson raised earlier about Crown immunity? Do you believe, and I think this is what you were implying in your answer to him, that if we removed Crown immunity from the public prisons, that would help to increase the accountability?

36:22 - 37:00

Anne Owers

I think, inevitably, it would. As I say, I think it concentrates the mind wonderfully. If it didn't, we wouldn't have a criminal justice system. It's it unless if there is no penalty whatsoever for things which are unsafe and potentially catastrophic, and of course, you know, as and when a catastrophe happens, as we've found in other areas of public life, everyone wrings their hands and says, you know, "Why didn't we know?" "Why didn't we do something about it beforehand?"

Well, this is a way of doing something about it beforehand.

37:00 - 37:09

Don Foster

Thank you very much. Now, we've a few minutes left, and I know one or two colleagues want to come in. So, Baroness Berridge.

37:09 - 37:36

Elizabeth Berridge

Thank you. You mentioned earlier about planning and the third sector being involved in planning. Could you give us, I used to, years ago, be involved in a charity called Kainos, that merged with Langley House Trust because we couldn't manage the big procurement that MoJ needed, so just as background. What's happening to the third sector who are involved in rehabilitation over sort of the last in terms of their capacity and involvement in our prison estate?

37:36 - 38:58

Anne Owers

It's not been easy, and I one of the things that I found a bit disappointing in the questions that Amber Rudd's review was asking was that there was no mention at all of the third sector. On the other, but I understand that she has reached out to third sector organizations and is doing something with them. They it tends to be the sort of, "Oh, yes, and." Whereas, actually, the third sector can be really influential because they have got those links outside that prison staff don't have, and that sometimes probation staff don't have. They provide that really essential link.

And, very often, I used to be very depressed when I went into prisons, and I would commend a particularly good and effective model that was being done, usually with third sector involvement, and you go back next time and it had gone because there wasn't there weren't the resources or they couldn't get the staff for it. I think we've got to think the third sector as more than an add-on, of, "Oh, you know, we you can do this for us." But actually learn from what the third sector knows and can do well, and can tell you. They so they got to be a genuine partner. Partnerships are talked about a lot, but they very often mean, you know, we we we we we talk, you do.

38:58 - 39:05

Don Foster

Thank you. Lord Eames, and then Baroness Buscombe, and then, I'm afraid, we'll have to bring it to a close.

39:05 - 40:14

Reg Empey

Good morning. At the very beginning of your answers, you referred to our lengths of sentencing. And that is, of course, a political decision, basically. And it would be nice to know of the evidence between long and short, and so on. But the point is, if you have longer sentences and we have a high rate of reoffending, if you then shorten the sentences, if the high rate of reoffending isn't curbed, then, in fact, you're not actually solving anything.

So, what is your assessment then of what we do about the sentencing? We seem to be a bit of an outlier in western countries, and I'm just wondering is it simply a reaction to political old throw the lock the key and throw it away and all this sort of thing. What assessment have you made of that, and whether bringing shorter sentences if it would make any difference, would it, in fact, make any difference to the number of people in prison?

40:14 - 43:00

Anne Owers

Perhaps I can answer that in two different ways. One is that actually very short sentences really don't work, but in order for them to in order to not to do that, you have to invest in what I call not prison. It's no good just saying, oh you know, the idea is that there won't be short sentences, that they will be dealt with by the probation service, you're going to have to do a heck of a lot of investment, because those are the people with the problems that we just talked about that need dealing with. So, in terms of in terms of sentencing, I one of the things that I am intrigued by is the notion of early release, which is the way that we have dealt with increasing sentence lengths and prison capacity. I could wish that we wouldn't talk about early release and that we could talk about conditional release, because it has always been the case that most people will not serve in prison the sentence of the court that they were given.

Way back in the 19th century, we had ticket of leave. We used to have remission for good behaviour after immediately after the Second World War. And I was very intrigued to look at, in 1967, Quintin Hogg, Lord Hailsham as he then wasn't, and Roy Jenkins joined together in the 1967 Criminal Justice bill which said that prisoners should serve a third of their sentence in prison, a third of their sentence on parole, having just created the parole board, and a third of the sentence remitted. Does that sound awfully familiar? It sounds exactly like David Gauke nearly 70 years later.

So, you know, we this is as I say, I wish we could then talk about a structured sentence, and the structure that critically depending on doing something effective in prison, doing something effective in the community, and instead of moving all the and we you know, we vary between people spend a half of their sentence in prison, they spend 40% in prison, they spend a third in prison. And for the public, it just looks completely it looks as if it's completely random. And if it is, and if it is as it is being driven by capacity, and not by effectively dealing with people. If we had a system up front that said, this is the effective way of dealing with people, and some of it will be in prison, and some of it will be in the community, instead of this constant moving around, I don't think it does anything for public confidence.

43:00 - 43:01

Baroness Buscombe.

43:01 - 44:08

Peta Buscombe

Yeah, very quickly, so you talked about the enormous advantage of trying to focus on prevention, and some of the future feels a bit bleak and possibly catastrophic in terms of where we are. We in our report, we did have quite a lot of evidence which showed that there is a huge increase in violence within prisons, and also so that being a reason why people are banged up for 22 hours at a time because it's just too tough on the staff, violence against staff, the drones of drugs coming in.

Should, do we need to be a bit more brutal in explaining to the Government just what it is that is happening in our prisons as well as those who are due to be deported on release, being released because the Home Office hasn't got around to organizing their papers, for example? The public in other words, need to hear and need a response from Government on some of these tough areas.

44:08 - 45:46

Anne Owers

I think you're right about safe, I mean, prisons are less safe than they used to be. That is certainly the case. I think that takes two that has two aspects. One is violence in prison and assaults, which have been increasing although they seem to have plateaued recently, and the other is suicide and self-harm. Self-harm rates have rocketed in recent years.

They've always been high in women's prisons and higher than they should be. So, I think safety takes both of those aspects, the safety of prisoners and staff from each other, and but also safety from yourself. And again, I think the more that you the more that you're overcrowded, and you're just dealing with the day with today, the less people, there was a very interesting I think the MOJ has done a study which shows that prisons that have more purposeful activity, violence goes down. Who knew? Who has ever dealt with you know, adolescent or teenager, adolescents and so on, and young men or young women.

So, I think it all hangs together. And of course, you know, if there are drugs in the prison also, I mean, that's going to that is going to result in debts, and debts lead to violence.

45:46 - 46:19

Don Foster

Thank you very much indeed, although that's a rather depressing note to leave it end on. Although I did note that was suggesting that we'd be brutal with the Government, having talked about violence in prisons, so I'm not quite sure. It's been an enormously helpful session based on your very many years of experience in the field, for which many thanks for all you've done. On behalf of the entire committee, thank you very much indeed. Order, the public evidence session is now concluded.