House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittingsSpeaker 2
My Lords, September brought UN findings, the Prime Minister's G20 AI pledge, international warnings, AI agent breaching Australia's Medicare statistics portal days apart. My balloted options were weeks away. Taking up the committee's invitation to proposals, will the senior deputy speaker help the UK set the global standard for parliamentary scrutiny of AI by proposing at its next meeting a pilot for one sitting term, a protected weekly AI session of up to 30 minutes with cross-government updates and questions on opportunities, risks and delivery on commitments?
Speaker 7
My Lords, I will ensure that this proposal is drawn to the attention of the Procedure and Privileges Committee. As noble Lords will be aware, the committee needs to balance a range of demands on the House's time. Any proposal for dedicated scrutiny arrangements on one policy topic must be considered against other important policy areas. Artificial intelligence is clearly of great importance. Indeed, noble Lords will have an opportunity later today to debate one aspect of this issue, namely the impact of AI on children during the debate in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Patel.
Speaker 18
My Lords, it is incumbent on us all to try and get to understand artificial intelligence as well as using our own intelligence to get our way around that. So will the senior deputy speaker do all he can to draw to the attention of other members of your Lordship's House the availability of digital training as far as AI is concerned and the way in which the House provides those facilities for all to take advantage of?
Speaker 4
Well, I thank the noble Lord for raising that and pointing that out to the House, which he has done extremely effectively. I think many members, if not all members of the House, have dabbled at least, if I can put it that way, in AI. Last week I was in Rome at a Presidents of Parliaments' Council of Europe assembly, if I can put it like that, which spoke about AI. And it's true that parliaments across the world, but also across Europe, are using AI in different ways. We're all finding our way in this and it's something which is an ongoing learning experience, if I can put it like that.
And I thank the noble Lord for drawing that training to the House's attention.
Speaker 19
My Lords, effective scrutiny of future-facing risks and opportunities is not just about time, of course. It's about the full range and diversity of our membership. And while I appreciate this falls outside the scope of the committee that is the subject of the question, does the noble Lord, the senior deputy speaker, agree that the House and those people who make the decisions about membership must do their best to ensure that we are fully equipped to face the future in the expertise we bring to the issues that we debate?
Speaker 4
Yes, I, that's an easy proposition to agree with. In fact, I would say the noble Lord, Lord Nagaraju, brings his own expertise, which he has demonstrated through this question. But of course, this House in a sense justifies itself by its expertise and I'm sure that all the political parties and the crossbenchers are very conscious of that and wanting to maintain the high standards within this House.
Bruce Grocott
Does the senior deputy speaker agree with me that we could have far better consideration of a number of issues including AI if the House started sitting at a more sensible time? Has he seen the, in my view, I'm sorry because they're very senior members, the views of the Procedure Committee that's simply suggested two options: one, do nothing, and the other, do as little as possible? Doesn't he agree with me that we would be far better off if we started most days, not Monday, but the rest of the week at 11 o'clock?
Speaker 7
Well, as the noble lord may know, there is a debate on that very subject at 12 o'clock today in the Moses Room. The proposition before the House is that we should start at 1 o'clock on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. There have been to date 360 responses to that proposition, which is a much better, a much great improvement on the last time this matter was considered about four years ago. So I would encourage all noble lords to respond. The consultation closes at 5 p.m. on the 13th of November and if there is to be change, it will be of course for the House itself to decide whether that change is enacted.
Speaker 14
Noble Lord Agnew's question talked about procedural flexibility and of course the House is using one of those shortly, the PNQ to ask the government about whether it has successfully responded to the PHP security threat. So can I use a bit of procedural flexibility and ask the senior deputy speaker if he can assure noble lords that the House has responded swiftly and that its information technology systems have been patched and that security flaw has been fixed?
Speaker 7
So I've, I think the answer to that question is yes, and I say that because the Clerk of the Parliaments has nodded to me while the noble lord asked his question.
David Alton
My lords, the noble lord will be aware that the Joint Committee on Human Rights in September published a 94-page report on AI and human rights. It was unanimous. It hasn't yet been listed for debate in your lordship's House because it can't be until the government respond. Will he look at first of all that procedure so that the House can be informed at the earliest possible time when select committees publish reports, and will he also please give encouragement to the government to respond so that such a debate can take place?
Speaker 7
So I recognize the point that the noble lord has made and I also recognize the very important nature of that report. It is of course a matter for the usual channels about when issues like this or reports are put down for debate. I might note that some committees actually report or have a debate before the government has responded and that might be something which the noble lord wishes to consider. Nevertheless, I see that the Chief Whip is here and I'm sure his point is well understood.
Speaker 5
My lords, isn't it the case that what is needed is international agreement and regulation, and don't we need to do that as quickly as possible given the pace that this matter is taking?
Speaker 7
Yes, I think the noble lord is absolutely right. As I said, I was at a debate about this in Rome and every single speaker made that point. But it is also true that the rate of change is happening so fast that we need to be cautious and think about the way we need to regulate this matter. A point which was made a number of times last week is that internationally we regulate air travel, we regulate drugs and pharmacy, and this is something of equal importance. So I absolutely take the point that the noble lord makes.
Speaker 13
Picking up on the point that the honorable member has just said, does he agree that we really need to probably look at an overhaul of the procedure of how we legislate in relation to AI? Because AI moves so fast, and even when agreement is reached about what needs to happen, the legislative process is so slow that by the time the legislation has come into force, new problems have arisen. Does he agree that there could be a joint committee of this House and the House of Commons which could have delegated powers to legislate on AI, and that way we would keep up with the speed of AI, which currently is bringing this legislature into disrepute because we always seem to be behind the game.
Speaker 7
So, I think the noble lady makes a very fair point. I have to say it's not limited to AI. There are many other areas in my own previous area of justice, there was a constant frustration that the legislative process was proceeding very slowly. Nevertheless, the noble lady makes a specific recommendation about having a joint committee looking at AI, and I will bring this to the attention of the PPC.
Dianne Hayter
Can the noble lord assure us that our own staff, not just ourselves, are able to use AI where appropriate, particularly in dealing with, for example, response to consultations and select committee inquiries?
Speaker 10
Yes, I can give that assurance. The staff within the House use AI in a number of ways, and there is ongoing training, I understand, and there's also training for members of this House. So, yes, I can give the noble lady that assurance. Second oral question, Lord Spellar. I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Speaker 6
We are changing public procurement to work harder for Britain. In the last six months, this government has issued new guidance on steel transparency requirements and the use of the national security exemption, as well as revising its social value model to support local communities. These reforms will support growth, create more jobs, and strengthen skills while complying with our international agreements, and we will continue to do more.
John Spellar
I thank the honorable minister for that reply. But could I ask her to reflect on the fact that we're still getting replies from ministers that saying that their ability to preference British manufacturers, for example in buses, is constrained by the World Trade Organization and our agreements with the EU. Yet the United States is a member of the WTO and not only has Buy American legislation on the statute, but the federal government mandates in its grants to states and local authorities that they actually have to buy American. And within the EU, founding members Italy, Germany, and France are blatantly preferencing their own suppliers. Can we change the mindset inside government to put British industry and British workers first?
Speaker 6
This government's been working to ensure public procurement plays its full role in delivering our industrial strategy, and my noble friend is right about the value of public procurement. Every year this country spends around 400 billion. We think that the new social value model will encourage contracting authorities, including central government departments, to deliver good quality jobs, skills, and opportunities in communities. We believe we can do this whilst still upholding our international commitments, and guidance will be published in the near future.
Anne McIntosh
Trade Act specifically stipulated that farm produce should meet imports should meet the same high animal welfare and environmental standards as this country. Can the Minister give the House an assurance today that that is happening? And will she investigate for what reason country of origin rules have not been applied so that we can actually the consumer can be aware from which country that produce is coming from?
Speaker 6
I'll look into the noble lady's second point and commit to write to the noble lady. The government's open to considering all lawful means of achieving our ambition that half of all food purchase across the public sector should be locally produced or certified to higher environmental standards. Our commitment to farmers and growers in this respect remains steadfast.
Speaker 21
A crucial element of getting procurement right is transparency both so British suppliers know what they can bid for and so that we can all judge how the public sector is doing in awarding contracts. But the latest research by procurement specialist Chris Smith shows that since the transparency requirements in the Procurement Act came into force three in ten public contracts have not been published despite the legal requirements to do so. So when can we expect the public sector to start fully complying with that requirement of the law?
Speaker 6
I'm not aware of the point the noble lord raises but thank him for drawing it to my attention. I will look into it and revert to the noble lord.
Speaker 20
The WTO is widely held to be in deep trouble. Its dispute resolution mechanism is scarcely used and countries are imposing unilateral tariffs everywhere. The UK has to reconsider its position in the light of this. In order to think that through and that was part of what the noble lord was implying by his question has the government made an assessment of the overall effect of the decline in WTO effectiveness on UK trade?
Speaker 6
The World Trade Organization remains a really effective way for us to enable British businesses to get that reciprocal access to 1.3 trillion in public procurement opportunities overseas annually. We think this is a valuable way of ensuring that our suppliers and our businesses get access to opportunities across the world.
Speaker 5
My lords when the government produces its guidance will they notify local government and regional governments about their decision and expect them to abide by the rules or the suggestions that they're making because quite frankly a lot of procurement is done through those two bodies.
Speaker 6
I agree that a lot of procurement is done through local authorities. Actually some really good examples from local areas on what local government already does. And we will endeavor to make sure that local government is aware of the new regime in the same way as we want central government to adapt how it works.
Speaker 15
Has again committed the government to being buying from local farmers throughout the system. The trouble is there are no facts from the government published regularly so we can see how the government's doing because everyone locally knows perfectly well that it's not working at the moment. So can she assure the house that in future we will have regular updates about what proportion of food is bought locally in schools where the food comes from and how often people look carefully at where it is coming from to do as my noble friend pointed out meet the same standards as we insist upon British farmers meeting.
Speaker 6
So my understanding is that food standards in schools are an issue that the Department for Education has been looking at.
It feels to me like it would be easy for me to commit to that but quite difficult for us to necessarily deliver but I'll look into the noble lord's point and get back to the noble lord.
Speaker 26
The noble lord is right to ask this question and when we discussed the Public Procurement Act in 2023, it was an issue of great interest. Now, there is an opportunity and there is a remit for this, authorities can pursue UK jobs, skills, local supply chains and social value through properly designed award criteria and contract conditions. Is the minister satisfied that the public bodies have that skill, have that knowledge to properly design those contracts so we can make sure that British businesses can get these contracts?
Speaker 6
The noble lord is right that you can do a lot within the rules in relation to ensuring that we really focus on the benefit of British spend for the British population and for British jobs. This is largely why we published the new social value model which has a much sharper focus on good quality jobs, skills and opportunities and we've committed to publishing guidance on that and establishing pilots with mayoral strategic authorities on this before the new approach comes into force on the 1st of January next year.
The Baroness Finn
My lords, the government have committed to prioritize national security in our procurement processes. How will that policy affect the government's flagship gimmick, Great British Energy? Might it mean an end to our reliance on Chinese solar panels?
Speaker 6
I'd like to say there's nothing about gimmicky about our work on Great British Energy. I think it is intended and will deliver for the British population. In terms of the national security guidance, we are clear that the guidance supports the use of the national security exemption in a way that's consistent with our domestic procurement regime and international trade agreements on procurement and will continue to do so.
Speaker 24
My lords, does the minister accept that WTO procurement rules and in Northern Ireland the continued application of EU procurement rules can make it harder to prioritize UK-built buses and what are the government doing to ensure that investment in zero-emission buses supports jobs in Great Britain and indeed in Northern Ireland as well as greener transport?
Speaker 6
The Department for Transport has recently published a 10-year pipeline for zero-emission buses covering procurement through to 2035. This helps and will help give British manufacturers a long-term capacity they need to plan ahead and invest in their workforce and it will benefit producers and manufacturers from across the UK.
Speaker 25
My lords, if this government is serious about growth in every postcode, what specific actions is this government taking to make sure that smaller businesses are able to scale up and grow and compete with companies in the bigger cities across the UK?
Speaker 6
We want SMEs to benefit from the government spend in the same way as larger companies and manufacturers do. And for that reason, on the 23rd of March earlier this year, the government published new targets for the amount we will spend with SMEs by the end of March 2028 and small businesses across the country are set to receive over 7.4 billion pounds of government money a year by 2028. We hope that this will help them grow but in particular this will also help make sure that we get the best opportunities for small businesses at the moment.
Jill Pitkeathley
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Speaker 29
The government wants the action plan to deliver lasting change for unpaid carers and their families. We will publish annual progress updates, meet annually with unpaid carers to hear their experiences, and refresh the plan to maintain momentum and accountability. In addition, the unpaid carers champion will drive progress and work with carers organizations. The cross-government ministerial group, chaired by Minister McGovern, will provide quarterly oversight, supported by regular official-level coordination.
Jill Pitkeathley
I thank the noble lady the minister for that reply, and it's a great pleasure to welcome her to the dispatch box on her first outing. These initiatives for carers are hugely welcome, of course, but I think coordination is going to be of great importance. So could the noble lady say a little more about how the unpaid carers champion, which is a wonderful new initiative, will be involved with overseeing or delivering the carers action plan, and how that in turn will link with the work being done by the noble Baroness Casey and her commission?
Speaker 29
Until May this year, I was the executive member for health and adult social care in Islington Council, and I regularly met with unpaid carers and supported the carers hub there. This gave me first-hand experience of the absolutely incredible people that are unpaid carers first-hand, and I want to use this opportunity to express the gratitude of the government to all those unpaid carers who provide that vital support to family, friends, and neighbors. Now, to return to the noble lady's question, the champion will build on commitments in the government's unpaid carers action plan and enable efforts to improve the identification and support of unpaid carers. Now, work is underway to establish the role, including how it will complement existing activity across government and that crucial wider adult social care reform.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, firstly, can I welcome the noble lady the minister to her place? However, will the government commit to a statutory guarantee so that unpaid carers have access to regular, reliable respite care, rather than support being dependent on reaching a point of crisis or where someone happens to live?
Speaker 29
Thank you. I thank the noble lady for the welcome. Local authorities already have duties under the Care Act to assess carers' needs and meet those eligible needs, while the Better Care Fund can support respite, short breaks, and peer support. However, funding and duties must result in meaningful support on the ground, so we will continue to examine how effectively existing arrangements are working and to consider whether further action is required to enable more support, because we recognize the importance of unpaid carers receiving high-quality support wherever they live in the United Kingdom.
George Young
My Lords, there are 15,000 school children caring for parents and siblings and doing so for over 50 hours a week. And of those, 3,000 are between the ages of five and nine. Those young carers are most at risk for missing school, being suspended, and underachieving, and they're not identified for an average three years. So will the action plan mentioned by Baroness Pitkeathley enable those young carers to be identified much earlier so they get the help and support which they deserve?
Speaker 29
I thank the noble lord for his work in this area and I appreciate the noble lord raising this very important point. The carers action plan indeed has a whole section on children and young carers and the action plan overall is split in three sections, the first of which is recognize. To the noble lord's point, we understand how easy it is particularly for children and young people to go under the radar. And there will be a cross-ministerial group working on this including Minister Ward who's early education years, Minister McGovern as well as colleagues from DWP and BIS, the Department for Business Innovation Science and Technology. Recognition of carers whichever part of the life phase they're in is profoundly important.
And we recognize that young carers make a particular contribution and when consideration of children and as the noble lord raised children particularly aged five to nine incredibly young is a different range of concerns that we wish to respond to there because we recognize for children and young people they should not be expected to undertake excessive or inappropriate caring responsibilities and that can really affect as the noble lord raised that child's educational prospects. So it's important that the whole family can access the right support at the right time.
Ilora Finlay
The Department of Education has identified almost 90,000 of these young carers but actually over half of schools haven't reported any young carers which is particularly worrying. So what powers will the champion have to make sure that local authorities are providing support, are putting identification processes in place first of all for these young people and that that support is both during their period of caring but also extends into a period of bereavement when they're looking after very seriously ill parents or siblings?
Speaker 29
This government is committed to breaking down barriers to opportunity for all young people including young carers and every young carer is entitled to an assessment to ensure they receive the support they need. And local authorities do have that duty of care and we fully support the no wrong door for young carers memorandum of understanding which does promote that stronger joint working between adult and children's care services. The role of the champion and exactly how that will dovetail with existing work and existing departments is still being worked out. The appointment will be announced in due course and at that time they will also announce how that will integrate with ongoing work. But I would also again just draw the noble lady's attention to way this cross-departmental ministerial small ministerial working group will be looking at this issue and I do think the inclusion of Minister Ward as the early education minister is really crucial to ensure that all schools in every local authority are doing all they can to support young carers and children bereaved at an early age.
Speaker 34
My lords, the noble baroness Lady Pitkeathley quite rightly highlighted coordination. And if NHS England is to be abolished in 2027, does that not create an issue for ensuring clear accountability for the delivery of this incredibly important cross-government carers action plan?
Speaker 29
I would have thought in fact the opposite were true. The whole reason the government has agreed to that reform, well the abolition of NHSE is to increase direct ministerial accountability both within Department of Health and Social Care and as previously mentioned in other answers in this case including DWP, DBIS and DFE.
Speaker 32
My Lords, I tried a number of times in the other place to bring forward a bill on the identification of carers because GPs and other health professionals can be inconsistent in identifying carers. And as we've heard from the Noble Lord Young, young carers are the most hidden group of carers. It's good to see the government's first priority in the action plan is to recognize, to improve identification and recognition of unpaid carers. But I would urge my noble friend and health minister to make urgent progress on this priority because I believe it is the vital first step in improving the support we give to unpaid carers.
Speaker 29
The noble lady makes a very important point. And I think it's recognize, refer, reach, the three orders of priority. And recognize is obviously the first piece of the puzzle so that whatever your age and life stage, you can be referred into the appropriate support. And then the reach is about enabling people who are with unpaid, apologies, caring responsibilities to reach their potential, whether they wish to be in work, whether they wish to be in education, whatever is appropriate for that person to do alongside. Because as the noble lady will know, my noble friend will know, when you become a carer, the rest of your life just doesn't stop overnight.
And often these things are incremental. And for many people, what begins as helping somebody out suddenly is hours and hours a week of providing unpaid care for a loved one.
Claire Tyler
My Lords, the action plan contains a welcome commitment to explore modernizing carers allowance, which I very much welcome. And it includes the possibility, it said, of replacing the earnings cliff edge with a taper. But could the noble lady the minister provide any indication of when this work will move beyond initial scoping and we will hear something of in terms of substantive proposals?
Speaker 29
I thank the noble lady for her work in this area and for that question. And as you will know, this government has already increased the amount that people can earn for carers allowance, increased carers allowance and increased the amount of earnings allowance. So this is something we are working on, is a commitment and a priority for the Prime Minister to support unpaid carers. I will have to write to the noble lady with more information about a taper and a timeline.
James Stewart Jackson
My Lords, I welcome the noble lady the minister to her new role and she brings great experience from adult social care experience in the London Borough of Islington. She will know that many carers are struggling with family and friends who are suffering from vascular dementia and Alzheimer's. And that often once a patient receives a diagnosis, there's no real action plan in place to look after those people and give them an action plan going forward. And there are only so many Admiral Nurses, for instance, in the country and the network is limited. So on that basis, will she make sure that dementia and the care for dementia patients over the medium term is taken into account in this carers action plan because it's an increasingly pressing problem locally up and down the country?
Speaker 29
Indeed, the noble lord raises a really important point. And as I'm sure he is aware, we have committed to the announcement of a dementia tsar starting in December. And the joy of the unpaid carers champion role is enabling us to ensure the weaving in of all these important threads because unpaid caring is such a diverse role so that nobody is neglected, nobody is left behind, and that every carer feels seen and able to navigate what can be quite a fragmented system.
Baroness Norgrove
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, most of the 70 HRT products available in the UK remain in good supply. Three are currently affected and alternative products are available.
To mitigate any impact on patients, we have expedited deliveries, issued comprehensive NHS guidance, and introduced serious shortage protocols to allow pharmacists to supply alternative brands without the need to return to prescribers. We continue to work with suppliers, regulators, and importers.
Speaker 33
I thank my noble friend the Minister for her reply. Nearly two million women aged 40 or above are currently prescribed HRT as an essential treatment. So thank you for taking those steps, but can I just ask what steps are the government taking to strengthen the resilience of the HRT supply chain to prevent future shortages, because I know that the news of shortages causes significant anxiety to women who are on HRT, and the shortages cause enormous disruption to their care, particularly when it is an essential treatment.
Gillian Merron
Well, I do recognize that uncertainty can affect somebody's emotional and physical well-being, and that's why I think it's important to use the opportunity, and I'm grateful to my noble friend to give reassurance about the contained scale of this. But to the point about supply resilience, which is indeed what we are working on, we did set out our actions just last year to improve shortage management and strengthen supply chains. We have also taken forward work to strengthen UK medicines manufacturing, as well as improve our understanding of supply chains and, importantly, identify potential risks earlier. And I can assure my noble friend we'll be publishing an update later this year.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, my Lords, HRT, like all medicines, is not a nice-to-have but absolutely critical to so many women. But the Public Services Committee, in its report on medicine security published in February, concluded that medicine security should be treated as a national priority and feature on the risk register. Does the government now agree?
Gillian Merron
Well, it is a priority, for sure. And on HRT, to the point the noble lady raised, there were significant supply pressures in 2022, but that has been contained. I'm glad that we are approaching this, as we do if there are other shortages elsewhere, through, for example, protocols. And as I've explained, there are alternatives. I understand the concerns it might generate, but I think it's important that we do advise women for whom this is crucial, I agree, that there are a whole range of products and formulations available, and pharmacists and their GP are very well able to assist and ensure they do not go without their medication.
Speaker 44
Would the Minister look at the serious issue of vaginal dryness during menopause and the fact that many women cannot always access or afford the over-the-counter products, and to see this as a crucial part of the well-being of not just the person going through the menopause but the wider context of relationships, and see how we can actually make it much more affordable, if not prescribed?
Gillian Merron
Well, I certainly agree about the importance of that and various aspects of menopause and the need to support and, when necessary, prescribe. There is indeed estrogen replacement which is prescribable.
And in terms of cost, what I would say to the noble lady, we have introduced the HRT prescription prepayment certificate, which many women have taken advantage of, I'm very glad to say, which ensures that eligible HRT prescriptions are available for 19 pound 80 a whole for a whole year. But I would also make the point that some 89% of prescriptions generally are in any case free and we have also pegged the costs for a further year to ensure that anyone that is paying is they are still paying at under 10 pounds.
Speaker 48
My Lords, I understand that there is research that shows that there is a low uptake of HRT amongst black and Asian women. Does the government know why that is and what are they doing about it?
Gillian Merron
Well, we have invested into new research just this year to actually build on workplace support for nurses and midwives who are working in health and social care during menopause. And we are also looking at improving the quality of life, particularly where there are disparities in terms of ethnicity in respect of HRT use, particularly in older women who may also be very unaware and excluded from the support that's available. So these ongoing studies I believe will actually assist us to make it more widely available.
Speaker 46
Would the noble minister agree that the issue of HRT secure provision is not a new issue, it's been going on for years, causes women huge fear and anxiety? And would she share my suspicion that if men needed HRT, there would be less disruption to supply?
Gillian Merron
I couldn't possibly comment. But it is important to acknowledge that concern amongst women or any other group is can be very distressing and worrying. And that is why we have taken all of the actions and that I've already described. But I would emphasize that the significant supply pressures on HRT go back to 2022 and there've been considerable improvements. And just to reiterate again, we're talking about three products out of 72 and there are alternatives available.
I would encourage any woman who's concerned to speak to her GP or speak to her pharmacist to get the reassurance and the care she needs.
Meral Ece
Despite the investment in the HRT and the amount of research and guidance, it's still the case that there are variations across the regions and the country on the take up of this and the advice that women are being given by and sometimes a reluctance by their GPs to prescribe them. And I've just last week even heard of a case of a GP that was, you know, a woman I know who was suffering anxiety and symptoms, very, you know, severe symptoms of menopause and she was advised that she had mental health problems and she needed to go and see a mental health specialist and maybe take antidepressant. But she didn't. So I'm just concerned about this sort of variation and the inconsistency across the country and I'd welcome the noble lady the minister assuring me that this is being looked at.
Gillian Merron
The noble lady raises an extremely important point and I can give her that assurance. It is a key part of the women's health strategy which we published earlier this year, the focus on menopause, but to her particular point about clinicians, I'm sure she'll be pleased to know that just last month we introduced a new and updated medical licensing assessment and that does mean that anyone graduating from medical school does require, are required to pass it, which means that they will have a better understanding. And we're also developing a range of tools and interventions to support existing GPs to be more upskilled. And the noble lady, I'm sure, will welcome the fact that we, for the first time ever, are introducing menopause into the NHS health checks.
Speaker 50
My Lords, my Lords, women in less deprived areas are twice as likely to be prescribed HRT compared to those women in more deprived areas. Can my noble friend the minister say what steps will be taken to address equity of access?
Gillian Merron
Well, inequity of access is not acceptable, but I do know it exists in all sorts of ways. And that is why we're improving the evidence base in order that we can address those inequalities. And I'm looking forward to the research on socio-economic and ethnic disparities as I mentioned to the noble lady earlier on. But I also think it's important the action, for example, we've made to, the action we've made to make HRT more affordable and also its availability to those who do not have to pay.
Speaker 43
Private notice question on cyber security, PHP vulnerability, Lord Dixon of Jericho.
Dixon of Jericho
Lords, I beg leave to ask the question for which I've given private notice, to ask His Majesty's government what assessment they've made of the impact on government websites and digital services of the PHP vulnerability set out in the alert issued yesterday by the National Cyber Security Centre.
Feryal Clark
My Lords, the government has made a detailed assessment of the impact of the PHP vulnerability on government websites and digital services and has been working closely with the National Cyber Security Centre and departments across government in response. Prior to public disclosure, departments were alerted to the vulnerability and advised to identify potential affected systems, assess their exposure and prepare to implement mitigations and security updates as they became available. PHP is one of the world's most widely used web technologies and is deployed extensively across both public and private sectors globally. The vulnerability is therefore not unique to government systems and has affected organisations worldwide. The Government Cyber Coordination Centre and the NCSC continue to coordinate the cross-government response, monitoring potential impacts, sharing technical guidance and supporting departments in implementing mitigations and remediation activity.
Our current assessment is that the principal impact on government digital services has arisen from precautionary measures taken to protect systems while security updates are applied. The government continues to monitor the situation closely and work with departments to maintain the security, resilience and availability of public services.
Speaker 47
I thank the noble lady the minister for how, what advance notice we had and that we were able to work in advance. I think when both the Treasury's website and the Office for Budget Responsibility website both go down, we can see how widespread an issue this is. It's crucial that we keep improving how we respond and how we react to this and I think the House will be very aware that we won't get everything right.
Would the noble lady the Minister be able to give us her sense of what went really smoothly over the last 24 hours and what was frankly a bit more difficult in terms of the processes government ran?
Feryal Clark
The government stood up across there was a cross-government incident response structures that you would expect and the government acted proactively ahead of public disclosure. As you would as is often best practice, NCSC were able to coordinate with vendors ahead of disclosure to ensure that when disclosure was made they were prepared with the patches and other mitigations to support their customers when just after the disclosure was made. And I think that is an example of using the identification of vulnerabilities and acting effectively with vendors and with the industry. I think the other thing I would say is that I would encourage industry and others to sign up to the NCSC's early warning scheme. NCSC were able to make 50,000 proactive notifications to the wider economy to advise business and others other organisations on what actions they should take.
And I would really encourage all organisations to sign up to the NCSC early warning system.
Diana Dido Harding
My Lords, would the noble lady the Minister be able to tell us should the the bill that is currently going through this House, the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, should that have been on the statute books, what additional powers or actions could the government have taken had that legislation already been live and does she think that's sufficient?
Feryal Clark
I think the the incident regarding PHP identified vulnerabilities ahead of potential exploitation. And I think that is one of the potential benefits that you can see of frontier AI, although of course we understand that frontier AI and AI in general can also increase the augment potential threats. In respect of the the bill, MSPs will be brought into the bill. And if you look at how SMEs rely on the sort of underlying systems of websites that may be supported by PHP, the fact that MSPs will be brought into the bill will mean that more of the economy will be covered and in particular those companies that don't manage their services directly. In addition, under the security and resilience requirements, there will be further requirements on patching and requirements for critical patching within defined timelines.
So in those ways the bill will support what we're seeing in terms of the new threats and the identification of vulnerabilities.
Sarah Ludford
My Lords, one problem with the bill is that it leaves central government and local authorities outside its statutory duties, relying instead on non-statutory guidance. But the public sector has been particularly hard hit by this incident with several councils taken offline: Edinburgh, Oxford, Bristol, Lambeth and Barnet and probably others. So will the government commit to bringing forward amendments with report on Monday to put the public sector under the enforceable incident reporting and resilience obligations contained in the bill?
Feryal Clark
The as I mentioned, the government has act very has acted very proactively ahead of public disclosure to work with departments and to assess the potential exposure and prepare mitigations.
And the focus has been on protecting public services and supporting rapid remediation and ensuring a coordinated response across government. This is a global security issue that has affected one of the world's most widely used web technologies, so it requires remediation across the public sector, across the private sector, across the globe. In respect of the Government Cyber Security Bill, which indeed we have report on Monday, as I mentioned in committee, the government is looking at future sectors that may be brought within it, and that is a piece of work that is already ongoing.
Speaker 55
My Lords, this outage of numerous government departments will obviously lead to a delay in the provision of key services. And we've already heard about the DVLA, numerous government departments, maybe police departments, etc. What assessment has she made herself of the actual impact of these delays, and can she tell something about the remedies that would be available to members of the public who suffer as a consequence, maybe financially?
Feryal Clark
Currently, the information I have is that 32 government services are unavailable and four are partially unavailable. That's the latest cross-government reporting. And that has largely resulted from precautionary measures taken to protect systems while security updates and mitigations are applied. So we are working very carefully with departments to restore the services safely and securely following that remediation activity. So the advice of NCSC is to mitigate and then restore the services.
Speaker 49
So we are working to restore those services safely and as quickly as possible.
Lindsay Northover
Experts warn that it isn't a matter of if an organisation is going to be attacked, but when it will be attacked, and that's what we're seeing here. And for small businesses, as I think she knows, a cyber incident can be existential. 60% of SMEs who fall victim to a cyber attack go out of business within six months. So does she think that the government is being sufficiently proactive in what she has outlined in terms of protecting the whole of our economy? And given that frontier AI can now find such flaws at such speed, will she be giving the AI Security Institute statutory powers of inspection and mitigation?
Feryal Clark
The noble lady raised a series of very important points. So in respect of this particular vulnerability, whilst we have seen exploitation activity and scanning being reported internationally, we are not currently aware of any confirmed compromise of central government systems resulting from these vulnerabilities. So as we have previously noted, the frontier AI allows for the identification of vulnerabilities. And as the head of the NCSC and others have alerted industry and indeed government, this means we need to be more vigilant and quicker in readying ourselves to apply patches and other mitigations more quickly. And that is something that we all need to prepare for, including SMEs.
In this particular example, as I mentioned, most probably SMEs will be relying on their managed service providers, and I would recommend that they talk to their managed service providers to assure themselves that the services that they are relying on have been updated as advised by the NCSC.
Speaker 45
My Lords, the newspaper article in the Times today suggested that this problem first surfaced on Tuesday and that a patch anyway had been planned to be available on Thursday. And I just wondered how long the government has actually really known about this situation just indicatively so that we understand how much work has been going on behind the scenes and for how long on what is obviously a very serious international problem.
Feryal Clark
The NCSC was briefed by OpenAI last week on this potential specific vulnerability and has been working as I mentioned before to ensure that disclosure happened in a coordinated way with vendors so that there was sufficient preparation to protect customers. It's regarded as best practice to be able to mitigate the impact to prepare in this way and to disclose in a coordinated way.
Speaker 57
My Lords, responsibility for cyber security has now been split between three government departments. We're still waiting for the National Cyber Action Plan and much of our economic activity as we've been hearing from a number of noble Lords remains out of scope of the Cyber Security Bill. Can the noble lady the Minister tell the House who is ultimately accountable for our national cyber resilience and when we will see a coherent plan to deliver that?
Feryal Clark
DCMS via the Government Cyber Unit and the Government Cyber Coordination Centre is responsible for coordinating the cross-government response to cyber incidents affecting government departments and the wider public sector. And that is documented in the Government Cyber Action Plan. As the noble Lord notes, the government intends to publish a National Cyber Action Plan which will set out the whole of government approach to tackling cyber security and resilience.
Speaker 52
My Lords, can I ask my noble friend the Minister what assessment the government has made of the potential for cyber attacks as a result of the disclosure of the PHP programming vulnerabilities specifically on our educational infrastructure including UCAS, university systems, awarding bodies and the risk to intellectual property and research data held by universities? And does the government believe that current protections adequately reflect the importance of education to both our national security and our economic resilience?
Feryal Clark
In terms of the assessment that my noble friend mentioned, we are monitoring the situation closely alongside NCSC. And whilst we have heard reports of exploitation activity and scanning internationally, we are not aware of any compromises in the UK public sector or in the UK as such. I think in respect of cyber resilience more generally across the public sector and the private sector, our message is that with the increased threats that we're seeing from the augmentation from AI, we are recommending that the public sector including education and the private sector, all of industry increases its cyber resilience by taking the measures that we have suggested including board leadership, including signing up to early warning systems, including understanding fully your supply chains and ensuring that they all meet the requisite standards of cyber resilience.
Speaker 53
Would the noble lady the minister agree with me that there are lessons here from the online safety legislation? The effects of regulation, legislation, action plans and so on are no substitute for the tech companies themselves taking full responsibility and being made to take full responsibility for the harm and the dangers that they can cause. What steps does the government think they could take to move us along that path to get the tech companies to take the full responsibility for the risks that they are creating?
Feryal Clark
The noble lord asks about the responsibilities of tech companies but also the impact of technological developments on cyber security. In this particular incident, the effect has been to be able to identify vulnerabilities which can then be mitigated and patched. In respect of the cyber security bill that is coming forward, that will include such sectors such as data centers and managed service providers within the regulatory ambit. The government continues to believe that regulating AI at the point of use is the right approach. The minister for AI set out, I think it was last week, many further efforts that we are taking to harden our defenses and to address both the opportunities and threats that AI is presenting.
Speaker 61
Message from the Commons that they have passed the Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provisions) Bill to which they desire the agreement of your Lordships.
Speaker 59
My Lords, Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provisions) Bill, I beg to move this bill be now read a first time.
Speaker 62
Question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Questions on the statement made in the House of Commons yesterday on the Sir David Bell review into antisemitism in schools and colleges.
Joanne Cash
My Lords, I thank the minister for repeating the statement and thank Sir David Bell and his team and those who gave evidence often at real personal cost. We on these benches welcome the review and the government's acceptance of all 27 recommendations. Every school day, British children are abused for being Jewish in the one place their parents should be able to trust they are safe. We heard the headlines yesterday, nearly three in five Jewish students have experienced antisemitism. Half of Jewish teachers experienced it at work in the past year.
Racism in their classroom, in their workplace, it is intolerant. But there is worse in the report's annex. 16% of this racism is inflicted by teachers. And 38% of the antisemitism students witnessed took place during lessons. Only 18% say an antisemitic incident is actually recorded as such.
Two thirds of Jewish respondents say antisemitism isn't even treated as racism in their school. Yesterday, the Secretary of State told the other place that teachers hear age-old tropes in the classroom and do not tackle them for fear of reprisals. She said, the fears about not being politically impartial is hampering our teachers and school leaders, preventing them from doing what they need to do. What they need to do. What it is their job to do.
What they must do. Because political impartiality is a statutory duty under sections 406 and 407 of the Education Act 1996. It is not discretionary. Helpfully, the annex to the Bell report shows us why there is fear about acting against this evil racism. More than half of teacher respondents couldn't say whether the impartiality guidance helped them.
Over a third named fear of a negative response from pupils or staff. And over a third named fear of community tensions. In the wake of this report, we need absolute clarity about what teachers must and will be supported to do. So will the Minister confirm that in fact challenging antisemitism is challenging racism and is never politically partial? And will she confirm, please, that sections 406 and 407 will be annexed to the letter to be sent by the Secretary of State to every school?
The Secretary of State also told the other place that the unions are keen to put things right. But within hours, she had been let down by the General Secretary of the National Education Union, Daniel Kebede, who had rejected a central recommendation of the review. He called the IHRA definition the wrong approach and warned of a chilling grip on classroom discussion of Gaza. He deployed the Secretary of State's own argument against the review. No wonder 40% of respondents reported negative experiences with education unions.
Days after 7th of October, this union's teachers circulated lesson plans asking pupils whether they would fight back if they lived in Gaza. The very definition of political partiality. In 2022, the last Conservative government suspended all engagement with the National Union of Students over antisemitism. And so I ask the Minister, will the government now suspend the National Education Union from all departmental engagement on this issue? I know they have to be involved in funding discussions.
But on this issue, including communications with the group implementing this review, until it has accepted Sir David's recommendations in full. In answer after answer yesterday, the Secretary of State turned to the curriculum. Citizenship, Holocaust education, Jewish history, media literacy and the curriculum review, the review again. But much of this is already in place. And Holocaust education is already compulsory.
But Parents Against Antisemitism have reported endless incidents, including one child being told to his face, gas the Jews, straight after Holocaust Memorial Day. What is missing is enforcement and consequence. So will the government restore Ofsted's capacity to scrutinise all areas of the curriculum which are subject and vulnerable to politicisation? And will the government, for at least the next three years, have mandatory inspection of the written records of every school's antisemitic incidents and the action taken? My Lords, the importance of this moment is not to be underestimated.
Recommendation eight of the review states clearly that antisemitism in a child can be an indicator of radicalization risk. With only 18% of incidents recorded as antisemitic, the chance to identify this risk is lost at great cost to our national cohesion and national safety. The independent reviewer of terrorism legislation, Sir Jonathan Hall, has called attacks on Jews the biggest national security emergency in almost a decade. So will the minister please commit to publishing national data on antisemitic incidents in schools every term starting this academic year so we can get to grips with this urgently? I look forward to the responses of the noble Baroness the minister.
It is an issue of national security.
Magid Magid
My Lords, the findings of this review are deeply disturbing, with one in five students who responded to the survey reporting that they'd witnessed antisemitism and three in five Jewish students saying they had experienced it. Behind these stats are young people, my Lords, who should be concentrating on their education, building friendships, and planning their futures, but instead, my Lords, they face prejudice, intimidation, and fear because of their religious identity. And I say this as a member of a religious minority. These experiences I know from firsthand in terms of what can happen to young people, whether as a parent or as a youth worker, when actually young people are discriminated against because of who they are, because of events that have no control from them or their parents. And no child, my Lords, should feel compelled to hide their faith to feel safe at school or college, and may I say also in the journey to school and college.
Because I was horrified to see a video of a parent with a young child from a Jewish community who was being harassed on the tube. And ironically, it was a Muslim woman in a hijab that challenged. I don't know how old that video was, but it was quite disturbing that on public transport our young people are also feeling and having that intimidation, and I hope the police do take action. Because educational institutions must be a place where young people, regardless of their religious background, identity, feel valued and protected. And we welcome the government's commitment to implement the recommendations.
However, accepting recommendations is only the beginning, my Lords. What matters really is how effective that implementation is, proper accountability, and the willingness to confront antisemitism wherever it occurs. And I would really urge the minister, when she rises to respond to us, whether they'll consider actually in a year or so's time to come back to us with another review to say we've done a survey and this is what how young people now feel from all backgrounds. Because as we've seen, there are issues of misogyny as well, and young people, like I said, from all backgrounds should be able to go to school without fearing. And teachers and school leaders, my Lords, cannot be expected to tackle these challenges without appropriate training, resources, and guidance.
And we need a clear understanding of the contemporary antisemitism that is around, including the manifestation on online conspiracy theories, Holocaust denial, and the spread of hatred, particularly on social media. We strongly support strengthening opportunities for schools to engage directly with Jewish communities, as this can help challenge stereotypes and build understanding between communities. And as I said, as someone who believes passionately in education as a force for social cohesion, I am particularly concerned that some Jewish students do not believe that reporting antisemitism incidents will lead to action. This is a serious failure of confidence. Schools must have effective reporting systems and pupils must know that complaints will be taken seriously and dealt with fairly.
Speaker 63
At the same time, schools and colleges must remain places, my Lords, where difficult and contentious issues can be discussed openly and constructively. Tackling antisemitism must go hand in hand with protecting balanced debate, challenging all forms of racism and prejudice, and ensuring that teachers feel confident in facilitating sensitive discussions. So I have a number of questions for the Minister. Will the government provide additional funding to ensure schools, colleges and local authorities can implement these recommendations effectively, rather than expecting them to be absorbed into costs that already stretch budgets? And secondly, will the government hold institutions accountable for implementation and ensure that students who report antisemitism see meaningful actions?
Magid Magid
My Lords, tackling antisemitism is not a responsibility of the Jewish community. It is a responsibility for all of us. We must move beyond statements of condemnation towards lasting cultural change, beginning in our classrooms but extending throughout society. Every child, my Lords, deserves to learn without fear, and every community deserves to live without hatred.
Jacqui Smith
Um, my Lords, um, as, uh, both noble Lords have, uh, strongly identified, antisemitism is a scourge that has no place in modern Britain and no place in our schools and colleges. And yet Sir David Bell's independent review makes clear that it is a growing and increasingly normalized form of hatred, with too many Jewish pupils, students and staff experiencing its effects in schools and colleges, and the findings are a stark reminder that we cannot be complacent. That is why the government welcomes Sir David Bell's report, thanks to those who took part, as the noble lady says, in some cases, uh, at considerable risk and detriment to themselves, and accepts all 27 of its recommendations. The review provides a clear and practical blueprint for action. It recognizes, as noble Lords have said, that every school, college and teacher has a responsibility to identify, challenge and prevent antisemitism wherever it occurs, ensuring that all young people can learn in an environment that is safe, respectful and free from discrimination.
And our focus must now be on implementation. Accepting the recommendations is only the beginning. Delivering meaningful and lasting change will require sustained effort across the sector. To support this work, the government has established an implementation group, bringing together key stakeholders to drive progress, share best practice and help ensure the recommendations are delivered effectively. And in light of the, the, the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed, I'm also pleased that Sir David Bell has agreed to undertake a further review in one year's time.
His independent assessment will help ensure momentum is maintained, progress is scrutinized and that we remain firmly focused on turning these recommendations into real improvements for Jewish children, students and staff across our education system. Turning to the other questions, uh, that have been raised, it is of course true that all teachers have responsibility for tackling antisemitism. We are completely clear about that. Uh, teachers' standards, which of course are used, uh, both for, um, uh, training, but also for misconduct, uh, procedures, are clear about their responsibilities to, uh, tackle this issue, uh, but if necessary, when those standards are reviewed, we will strengthen them to make that clearer.
We also understand the need for further training and will develop the resources and training asked for by Sir David Bell in his review. We will review the impartiality guidance to ensure that teachers understand both their requirement to be impartial, but also their responsibility to enable discussion and debate about difficult issues within their schools whilst protecting all those who take part in them, because the noble Lord, Lord Mohammad, is right that schools must facilitate discussion on these difficult issues and too often in recent years they have been put off that by a fear about what this means about their political impartiality. I think the noble lady raised particular points about the National Education Union. Sir David didn't find across the unions that there was opposition to important work to tackle antisemitism, but as a member of an NEU, an active member of an NEU predecessor trade union, I wholly disagree with them on their position on the IHRA and the Secretary of State has been clear in accepting Sir David's recommendation that we believe that that is the definition that should be used across the education system. On the point about Ofsted, Ofsted in the case of the particular incident in the case of the MP for Bristol Northeast that I think particularly raised concern around this, Ofsted could examine aspects of that incident that fell within its inspection remit and it did so.
What it couldn't do, of course, was to act as a general investigator into all the surrounding events, campaign activity or motives of external individuals. Those matters do sit outside Ofsted's statutory inspection powers. But we do think that both Ofsted and the Independent Schools Inspectorate, and we will work with them on this, could do more thematic work examining how schools and colleges identify, prevent and respond to antisemitism with the aim of highlighting effective practice, identifying areas for improvement and strengthening the national evidence base. Every young person within school must feel able not only to report incidents of antisemitic abuse or speech within the school, but they must, as the noble Lord says, be confident that those are both recorded and that action will is taken. That is part of the renewed set of support and guidance that we will provide to schools, but the expectation there is clear that all incidents should be recorded and action should be taken.
And we will consider the points made about the noble lady, the points made by the noble lady with respect to national reporting of those incidents. On the point about funding, this government has already made available seven million pounds to tackle antisemitism in our schools and colleges, which is already responding to some of the issues made both in higher education and across our schools, work to tackle mis- and disinformation and conspiracy theories, work to develop interfaith discussion and to enable young people to understand the need to disagree appropriately and to engage in difficult conversations and controversial issues without resulting to antisemitism or racism, other innovations through the innovation fund that is being supported and through all this support and training and new resources for teachers, which the government will support through its action to put into operation all 27 recommendations of Sir David Bell's very important report.
Speaker 69
Could I welcome this report with some degree of enthusiasm? I think Sir David has produced a very thoughtful report. Does the noble lady agree that vital though it is to adopt the IHRA definition, the working definition, the greater challenge is to ensure that it's properly understood and implemented? In particular, the definition is intended as an educational tool to assist in recognizing and reflecting on antisemitism, rather than as an instrument to which to denounce or to silence others. That's its strength.
It's designed to make people think. And the opponents of the definition are those that prefer slogans to thought. So will she ensure that in this year, the implementation of the definition will be very carefully monitored?
Jacqui Smith
I completely agree with the noble Lord and he's right. And if anywhere should be enabling careful consideration and education, it's our schools and colleges. And that's why we're clear, not only that they should adopt the definition, but in the way in which he's described, that they should use it to support teaching and deeper understanding amongst their pupils.
Lynn Ruth Deech
Crossbench, my Lords, the government's, the report by Sir David Bell has finally brought into national attention the defects in Holocaust education as it exists today. The report says that antisemitism should be at the heart of it. And yet this government shamefully rejected an amendment by Lord Verdirame and myself earlier this year, which would have confined the proposed learning center in Westminster to antisemitism. In other words, the government was seeking to water it down. That should be changed.
We need to review Holocaust education. As the report said, we need teaching about Judaism, contemporary antisemitism, contemporary Jewish life. And the little cramped underground learning center proposed for Victoria Tower Gardens doesn't tackle that at all. It's about some niche interest relating to the British reaction to the Holocaust. We need fresh thinking.
The funds are there. The government must lead the way and make sure that children are taught about today's Jews and not, as the report said, that they think that everything ended at the end of the Second World War.
Jacqui Smith
There's nothing niche about the responsibility for our schools to teach about the Holocaust. That is both within the current national curriculum and will be retained in the future national curriculum. But what we're also clear about is that education about Jewish life and Jewish people should not start and end with the Holocaust. And I think Sir David makes a very important point about how we need to do more to educate our children about Jewish lives, Jewish culture, and Jewish contributions in this country and internationally. And that will be a key part of the work we take forward.
Dianne Hayter
My Lords, my Lords, we quite rightly never accuse Muslims or give them responsibility when an Islamic state hangs gay people from a crane in Iran or denies women their rights in Afghanistan. And yet there seems to be something about a Jewish state doing something that people don't like that enables them to take it out on Jews altogether.
Now, this report will need our teachers to do the work. We are already hearing that some of them are denying this report. So my question to my noble friend is will she ensure that every teacher is given proper antisemitism training? Because otherwise, this will never happen. If they don't understand the pogroms of the 19th century or the things before the Second World War or actually going back even further, how are they going to be able to make sure our children are also taught properly?
Jacqui Smith
I mean, just to be clear, I don't think it's fair to say that the vast majority of teachers are denying this report, nor are in fact the vast majority of trade unions or their members. So I just think that's important to be clear about. But my noble friend is right to say that this will need support to teachers. That's why this government has already, as part of the seven million pounds invested in tackling antisemitism, provided support, sponsorship, champions and resources that will enable teachers to be able to more effectively tackle antisemitism and teach the full range of issues that I touched on in the previous in my previous answer. And it's why the revision of teacher standards and the focus in teacher training is also something that we will take forward as part of the approach to implementing Sir David's recommendations.
Sarah Ludford
My Lords, Judaism is a religion, but Jewishness is a racial identity, as has long been recognized in UK law. And as this report says, antisemitism needs to be treated like any other form of racism. But recently, within the last month, I think, the hate crime statistics were published. And if memory serves, antisemitic abuse was classified only as religious hate. Would the noble lady the minister ask the, I think it's the Home Office responsible, to go back and look at this?
Because to classify it only as religious hate crime is not sufficient. And maybe antisemitism needs to have its own category in the hate crime statistics. But in any case, the racial dimension of antisemitism needs to be recognized alongside any religious dimension.
Jacqui Smith
I think the noble lady's point is right, which is one of the reasons why my right honorable friend the Secretary of State will also be working with the Office of Equality and Opportunity to ensure that the issues identified in this report are taken forward across the government.
Speaker 78
The unintended consequences of removing direct curriculum scrutiny by Ofsted in 2005, and it's under the current government that the partial reinstatement made in 2019 was once again removed. So can the noble lady the minister commit to reversing these decisions which have made it too easy for politicization and failures of impartiality in curriculum and teaching to go undetected, thus creating the environment in which antisemitism can flourish?
Jacqui Smith
Well, I'm not sure I quite agree with the noble lady about the sort of chain of causation that she suggests in that answer. But I have already been clear about the way in which we expect there to be accountability of teachers and representation of the issues in this report in standards. And I've also outlined the work that we will do with Ofsted on this.
Tessa Blackstone
My Lords, I very much welcome Sir David Bell's report and I congratulate him on his recommendations and I'm also delighted that the government has decided to support them all. There are just two points that I would like to raise with the minister. The first is that we must remember that this report is not just about schools, it's about colleges as well. And it's interesting that the noble lady Baroness Cash speaking for the opposition didn't say a single word about colleges. She only talked about schools and teachers.
She didn't mention lecturers either. So I hope my noble friend the minister will ensure that they they don't get forgotten. But the second point I want to make is that Sir David Bell quite rightly said that we should not just be teaching about the Holocaust. We must get a better understanding amongst young people and and indeed children of the enormous contribution that the Jewish population has made not just to the economy but to science, to literature, to the arts, to creative industries. So could I ask her to make sure that the implementation group particularly looks at this issue and thinks out how we're going to get the curriculum to adequately reflect the great contribution the Jewish community has made both historically and today.
Jacqui Smith
Yes, my noble friend is absolutely right. We need to tackle antisemitism not only by confronting hatred when it occurs but also by helping more young people in our schools and she's right in our colleges to encounter and to understand Jewish life, culture and history, building understanding and challenging prejudice before it takes hold so that will be an important part of this work.
The Baroness Finn
So every one of Sir David Bell's 27 recommendations is framed as should and not must. A civil service device I remember well from my own time in government. Schools, like civil servants, treat should as advisory rather than compulsory. Without firm requirements, practice will vary from school to school. So which recommendations will the government place on a statutory footing and will antisemitism training for staff be mandatory?
Jacqui Smith
Well, I mean the noble lady may have tried to get out of her responsibilities in that way when she was in government but this government won't. We've been very clear, we've been very clear about the spirit and the word of accepting the recommendations in this report. That's why we're setting up both the implementation group and we will expect Sir David Bell to report on how well that is being implemented in a year.
Speaker 79
I declare an interest as the former chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission in the past year. It was of course the Equality and Human Rights position that upon which it falls to investigate antisemitism in political parties which is taking root and is reflected in the society and in educational institutions as we've heard. My question to the government is to express my concern that their newly defined Islamophobia definition seems to be treated within government and therefore permeating through to civil society groups as equivalent to the definition of antisemitism which of course as we've heard this morning is defined in statute, is part of race as well as religion and in the hierarchy of a non-statutory policy which they say anti-Muslim hostility is versus antisemitism, there is no comparison of the gravity.
Antisemitism has to be the the antisemitism discrimination has to be the policy which the government takes forward at speed and with alacrity. And will she please speak to her colleagues to say that there is no parity of esteem between a policy adopted by government and the law of the land as it stands today.
Jacqui Smith
Well, I think I hope that the noble lady can see that the seriousness with which the government has taken the issue of antisemitism, the government's response to Sir David's recommendations and the work that will follow will show the priority that this government is giving to tackling antisemitism given its its prevalence and sadly its growth in recent years. We're absolutely clear of the priority that we're giving to this work.
Ros Rosalind Altmann
My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, my Lords, I thank the Secretary of State for stating clearly that targeting British Jews and blaming them for events in the Middle East or for actions of the Israeli government is antisemitism. And could the noble lady the minister then commit to setting out this principle explicitly in the strength and political impartiality guidance. And I welcome the acceptance of Sir David Bell's timely recommendations. But following the question of the noble lady Baroness Finn, what consequences will there be for breaking these guidelines or for continuing antisemitic behavior in schools?
Jacqui Smith
Well, I think, you know, the question about accountability is very fair. That's why I took some time in my first response to spell out the placing of these issues both within teacher standards, within teacher training, and also in terms of Ofsted's work of Ofsted and the Independent Schools Inspectorate on the thematic work that I I identified. And of course, the government will take accountability in asking Sir David Bell to report back after a year on the progress that is made on these recommendations as well.
Speaker 52
My Lords, I welcome this review and its 27 recommendations. It really does shine a spotlight on the horrors facing Jewish students, teachers, and parents across our country in both schools and colleges, a horror that I know all too well as the parent of two primary-aged children attending a Jewish school. If I can focus on modern manifestations of antisemitism, we know that antisemitism remains in some instances under the cloak of anti-Zionist rhetoric. We only have to look at the motion that was passed recently at the Green Party conference to see just one example of such antisemitism. Can I ask my noble friend the minister what plans the government has to ensure that this specific form of antisemitism, and I name it as anti-Zionist rhetoric, what the government is going to do to ensure that it is appropriately captured and understood in all of our classrooms.
Jacqui Smith
Well, I think that may well be an important element to reflect in the new curriculum in terms of thinking about the way in which schools address this this issue. And I mean, I won't comment on the Green Party, although I think my noble friend is right about the very backward step that that motion represents for that party and the sad impact that it will have on those people who most need our protection, not that type of political activity.
Speaker 77
Point raised by my noble friend Baroness Cash in relation to the NEU, and I welcome the comments from the noble lady the minister about her own opinion of their rejection of the IHRA definition. But what does she think Jewish families will feel and Jewish children will feel and Jewish teachers will feel if that union is still allowed to attend meetings specifically on this topic?
Jacqui Smith
Well, I think the Secretary of State and myself have been very clear about our position as ministers and the support we will provide to those families. I think it's for the NEU to answer that question and I've made my views clear.
Speaker 84
My Lords, rather than risk slipping into... Thank you, my Lords. I can't speak for teachers as a whole, but as a teacher, I wonder if the minister would agree with me that I thought the crucial part of the review was a sentence and I quote: "I do not believe that encouraging empathy or asking people to consider how others might feel amounts to a restriction on free speech; rather, it is an important part of living and learning together in a diverse society." Also, Sir David talks a lot about keeping children safe in education, the updating of that. Can I once again implore the DfE to publish that in the summer term so that safeguarding leads can absorb it before the autumn?
Jacqui Smith
I think the noble lord identifies an important part of the report and I agree with his focus on that. And I agree with his, I think his suggested view that the vast majority of teachers would also think that that was important. And I hear him on the key point about keeping children safe in education and of course it was an important point within the report that tackling antisemitism should be seen as a core element of safeguarding and that's why it should be included as a specific issue within the keeping children safe in education guidance.
Speaker 53
Perhaps I might start by registering my disappointment that there are no representatives of the Green Party here to hear this debate. That's a sadness and disappointing. May I say how much I welcome this report which is both chilling and timely, but also more importantly the government's response is overwhelmingly positive and I think we can all applaud them for that. I have one small concern which is that the government does not intend to measure the uptake of IHRA definitions until the 27-28 survey, which leaves well over a year before there's any real scrutiny. Does the government have any plans to monitor this in the meantime until that takes place?
And will there be some in the meantime some training for teachers to help them to deal with real-life incidents in their classrooms while we await the measurement system?
Jacqui Smith
Yes, it is. I mean not only have we already started some of the training that the noble lord asks about with the additional investment that we've put into tackling antisemitism in education, but it is an important element of the recommendations that we produce much clearer guidance and resources for teachers and that we will aim to do as quickly as possible.
Speaker 85
My Lords, does my noble friend agree that rather than risk slipping into a blame game in responses to the report, what our schools and colleges may benefit from most is practical support to help them confidently identify what contemporary antisemitism looks like and the consequences for us all of failing to tackle it?
Jacqui Smith
My noble friend is absolutely right. That's why I have emphasized and my right honorable friend the Secretary of State emphasized yesterday and will and has been very clear in her leadership on this, that not it's not enough to condemn what we see in our schools, which I think quite rightly has happened across the chamber, notwithstanding some absences. But it's also important to provide the practical support for teachers in the classroom, for school leaders at the times when they're faced with difficult issues that they want to be able to respond to confidently. And that is all part of the government's plan to respond to this report.
Speaker 83
My Lords, I'll pause for a short while to allow noble Lords who may wish to do so to leave the chamber. Could I respectfully ask that you do so quickly and quietly. Motion for debate: the effect of artificial intelligence, screen usage and social media on children. Lord Patel.
Narendra Patel
My Lords, it is a pleasure to open this very important debate on the effects of AI, screen use and social media on children. Excuse me using the screen to fulfill my time on the screen. Before I start, I would like to sincerely thank the noble Baroness, Baroness Lloyd of Effra, for making time to take this debate on behalf of the government. I appreciate that. I also like to thank all the noble Lords taking part in this debate and very much look forward to all their speeches.
Particularly welcome the previous speaker, Lord McFall. I think this is the first time since he relinquished office that he's taking part in a debate. Thank you for doing so. Welcome, Lord McFall. I thank the library for their excellent briefing paper and POST, the Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology, who have produced several well-researched evidence-based publications with expert contribution on the subject, in fact several publications.
POST reports don't often get a debate slot despite being well-resourced, high-quality publication. Much of my speech is based on their excellent findings and I thank all who contributed to their work. Anybody who travels on tubes or buses or trains will all see as soon as you get in everybody's looking at their tablets or their phones. So it is not just children who get addicted to looking at it, all of us do. My Lords, the rapid integration of digital technologies into the everyday lives of children and young people has led to the question of its consequences on the health, education and development of children.
Whilst my focus today may sound much to the negative aspects of both AI and tablets and teaching and social media, I do recognize the great benefit it can have if properly used.
Comprehensive reviews by post and international publications in professional journals, government reports have all highlighted that whilst digital technologies offer opportunities in education, creativity and community building, its excessive and harmful content designed to get children and young people addicted to both content and technology is leading to serious harm to children. I will briefly look at the evidence in each of the areas of AI, screen use and social media and its effect, hopefully both good and bad, based on the evidence published. Screen and AI use are increasingly embedded in children's daily lives. Screen exposure begins early in life in United Kingdom. Study shows 98% of children age two use screens on a daily basis.
Use of generative AI, so-called GenAI, is increasing rapidly amongst young people, not just for education but for social interaction. Impact of screen use in children is predominantly based on observational studies reflecting the ethical and methodological challenges in establishing a causal relationship. Whilst screen use and AI can support education, creativity and social connection, it displaces face-to-face interaction and with excessive use leads to poor socio-emotional outcomes. So what is screen use? Screen time, time spent using screen-based devices, remains the key measure of children's screen use, but it is a poor indicator of potential benefits and harm of digital engagement.
Systemic review of over 600 studies look mainly at screen time use and not other factors such as age and development stage of child, type of content, which is becoming more diverse with use of AI, and context, whether it is supervised or not, and the time of day the screen is used by children, all factors that have an effect. What is AI use? AI tools are increasingly embedded into digital devices and online platforms used for information seeking, content creation, communication and learning support. The pandemic, the changes in education, leisure activities with greater availability of devices and technology has led to increase in children's screen use. The 2026 Ofcom data shows screen time at age two is about 127 minutes per day.
It increases to several hours per day with older children. Children who observe parents' frequent use of screen themselves start using screens at an earlier age. Whilst tablet use is common in early childhood, 80% ages 5 to 11, with rising smartphone ownership from 56% of 10-year-old to 83% of 11-year-olds, use of smartphone is now more common than tablets. Use of AI, particularly GenAI, is also increasing. Ofcom data suggests 86% of 8 to 17-year-olds have an awareness of GenAI and 11% use it regularly.
Higher screen use associated with poor socio-emotional development, more common with children with existing emotional difficulties, and with parents using digital devices to manage distress, tantrums or challenging behavior by children, it leads to increase in screen time.
Internet Masters found that 23% of vulnerable children reported using AI chatbot because they did not have anyone else to talk to. Concerns have been raised about AI companies, particularly following high-profile legal cases in United States, which were settled with an $18 billion settlement, alleging that conversational AI system formed emotionally significant relationship with vulnerable young users and responded inappropriately to discussion of self-harm and suicide. Concerns have been raised in particularly about addictive patterns of use, particularly gaming. A 2026 systematic review suggested that GenAI tools may support cognitive processes, but can reduce opportunities for independent thinking, deep learning and skills development. The health impacts of screen use are particularly related to obesity risk, sleep deprivation, particularly when the screens are used, especially if they used at evening and late at night, which in turn leads to emotional well-being and behavioral problems.
There is some evidence of the benefit of use AI-based mental health apps. A 2025 survey suggests that one in four teenagers have turned to GenAI chatbot for mental support with some benefits. UK qualitative data shows that 8 to 17-year-olds are actively spending money online, with persuasive design features influencing spending and contributing to financial harms. Studies also show that adolescents who purchase loot boxes have four to six times higher odds of developing problem gambling behaviors. Children also face high levels of embedded advertising online, often integrated into gameplay or entertainment content, difficult for children to spot.
Children encounter a range of harms through digital platforms, including cyberbullying, grooming, image-based abuse, fraud and scams, exposures to hate speech, exposure to misogynistic content and violence against women and girls, exposure to pornography, exposure to forms of violence, suicide ideation and self-harm content. With the advent of more immersive platform, novel platforms of tech, facilitated abuse can emerge more difficult for children to identify. Turning to the use of social media, children and young adults use social media for a variety of reasons, ranging from entertainment, relaxation, social integration and seeking support. Again, research by Ofcom in 2025 found that 97% of 13 to 17-year-olds had a profile on at least one social media platform. 93% of parents felt concerned about potential harms to their children from social media.
Studies and reviews of harms of social media of children and young people have led countries to develop legislation to deal with it, including United Kingdom, Brazil, European Union, France and Australia. Alongside national policy, social media policy intersects with child and human rights frameworks, such as the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. Range of potential impact of social media use relate to mental health, physical health, safety, financial harms, behavior and social interaction. Elements of social media design on the platform intensify this problem, such as the infinite scroll function, the autoplay, the push notifications that are continuously come on the screen, likes and dislike comment. Adolescents are particularly vulnerable related to stage of their brain development.
Post research also highlight some of the benefits: education and creative thinking, social and community interaction, positive material on physical and mental health. A longitudinal study of adolescents of 31 London schools found that those who use social media, 11 to 12 years, for more than three hours daily, 70% were more likely to experience depression and 60% more likely to experience anxiety. Self-harm related images on social media are associated with harmful effects such as increased self-harming behaviors, anxiety and depression, at the same time possible benefit did include emotional support. While social media platforms have the tools to detect and remove harmful content, such content continues to reach young users online through algorithmic content recommendations, something that the media platforms could easily handle. Research published by Ofcom in 2026 showed that social media was leading online space to which children were exposed to child sexual abuse material.
Children who experience online abuse often end up experiencing poor mental health, self-harm and feeling of disempowerment. Ofcom study also showed that 62% of their sample of 11 to 17 year olds reported seeing bullying content and 51% reported seeing hateful content. My Lords let me now turn briefly but the most important part of the area of concern to most concern to me. We have all seen recent reports in print media and Sky Television investigation into violent and extremist networks that target vulnerable children and young people. FBI, UK Crime Agency and NSPCC have all mapped out how these groups operate to pull minors into illicit networks.
They identify vulnerable children with anxiety, feeling isolation on mainstream gaming consoles, likes of Roblox, Minecraft, TikTok, and after initial contact posing as friendly teenagers, inserting avatars into the game, they switch the child to encrypted apps. Their ideology is nihilistic, self-mutilation and violence. Eventually it leads to self-harm, violence against other, suicide and others and possibly even worse. This my Lord is so serious. In the process of finding this out, I tried to do my own research and interviewed, didn't interview, I spoke to some children age 7 to 13 in front of their parents with the permission of their parents and I was horrified to learn that children as young as seven knew about this and often came across it and the smart ones avoided it.
One particular one whose mother did not allow them to use headphones so that she could listen what they were following, had to turn, ask her to turn the child to turn it off because she was being led, the child was being led to dark internet into asking can you now bring a photograph of yourself. And at that point the mother stopped it. These are dark, dark, nihilistic, serious internet on the dark side of the internet that we must stop. That this is so serious that we need parent education, wide media alerts, law enforcements and legislative action, aggressive prosecutions, international cooperation, gaming industry responsibility, restricting cross-platform migration which they use to migrate children from legitimate gaming consoles onto the dark internet.
And we need much more. So in the context of this, I don't have any other questions except one, which is I ask the noble Baroness the Minister, following statement of the Secretary of State on September the 8th, what further measures, legislative and non-legislative, does the government intend to bring to protect children from online harm, particularly young children from this dark internet? My Lords, I beg to move.
Speaker 77
My Lords, I'd like to open by thanking the noble Lord Lord Patel for securing this extremely important debate and for his very powerful speech. I'd particularly like to associate myself both with his last remarks about the nihilistic behavior that happens with predators approaching our children online and also the ability of the large tech companies to sort many of the problems themselves. We heard during the passage of the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill that we were playing catch-up as a country in relation to protecting our children from the harms, particularly in that case from smartphones and social media. And my Lords, I think we find ourselves in the same position again, but with a much more terrifying prospect of trying to play catch-up in the age of AI. The evidence of harm to children is widespread.
Perhaps most disturbingly in relation to child sexual abuse material, we've seen an explosion in AI-generated child abuse videos. More broadly, we've seen reports of three-year-olds spending hours every day on a screen with visible, forgive the pun, impact on their eyesight, as well as pupils being issued with one-to-one devices at school without evidence of the impact of that. We know, as we heard from the noble Lord Lord Patel and I'm sure we'll hear from other noble Lords, that children are seeing harmful material on social media and meeting potential predators online. And that's not to say there aren't safe and useful things, of course, that can be done online, but the situation currently is the lack of regulation means that the harmful is far outweighing the good. So my first question for the Minister is to clarify whether the government plans to adopt the precautionary principle in future.
We would never let a medicine reach our children without on the promise that harm will be measured later. Will the Minister confirm that products used with children, including educational technology and AI, must show evidence of safety and benefit before they can be marketed, particularly where they are being bought with public funds? We know that the Law Commission is bringing forward a very welcome consultation on changes to product liability legislation, but that is a painfully slow process and not fast enough to safeguard our children.
Most recently, 150 clinicians wrote to the Secretary of State for Education citing their concerns and asking for health checks on classroom technology. They cite research associating each extra hour of daily screen time with a 21% higher odds of short-sightedness. Secondly, can the Minister update the House on whether work is taking place on an early warning system similar to the child mortality database, which would allow us to pick up patterns of harm before full evaluations come forward? And finally, does the government have plans to equip health visitors, GPs, school nurses, optometrists, and pediatricians with the training that they need on digital risks and the impact of screens so they can be part of an effective national response? My Lords, building a system that is agile and resilient is crucial if we're to protect our children from these harms, and I hope the government will consider these suggestions.
Dominic Hubbard
My Lords, when I stand up to talk about technology, I am one of the people who will probably go a little against the tide in the fact that I'm looking for the positives. Here, my Lords, I must remind the House of my declared interests. I am the chairman of Microlink PLC, who deal with assistive technology and packages to support people in the workplace and school, and I'm also president of the British Dyslexia Association. And I am dyslexic. I am also a dyslexic who is dependent to actually write to anybody on voice-to-print image technology.
And also it really helps me when I'm getting the information back, i.e. that is print-to-voice technology helps me on more dense text. I use this as a part of my life, and when it arrived in my 30s, it transformed my experience when dealing with the rest of the world. Now, what this gave me was independence and the ability to interact with the world around me much more easily. We are going to have a huge amount of effort going into special educational needs in the near future, which is overdue but is welcome. Much of the technological world will help various groups interact with the educational process and with the workplace.
Autism, noise-canceling headphones, something that simple can transform the way you actually work, and ADHD as well. Small things that are changed, that are worked into those environments have a positive effect. So please guard against saying all technology bad, and particularly when it comes to children. I don't think that has been said so far, but it is a danger that it is taken as and lumped in together. It can be used as something else.
But what's required to do this? What's required is knowledge and training, particularly within the school department, to make sure that it goes in. At the moment, my Lords, many children do get the benefits of these technologies, but it helps if you're middle class. Helps if your income's there. Helps if you know what you're doing.
Let's make sure when we get through to this new phase of the education system that teachers are trained to use this, to identify earlier. Let's get away from the lawyers. Let's get the teachers being able to identify.
And one of the big advances there is actually screening devices, which are tech. Other tech devices that help you. Please can we move away from having free things that are used online, which are there because of advertising and commercial advantage. Start using licensed products. They're comparatively cheap and you can check round from where they're coming from.
Make sure that these benefits can come into the classroom, but you require training. You require something which doesn't immediately, as the noble Lord Patel said, take you onto another site on the web and going through. You may have to seal them off to get the best out of this. So the internet and the cloud may not always be the answer. Make sure that we can actually get this going through and we will take the benefits with us.
Because somebody who can integrate and act within the education system stands a chance of getting the benefits from it. If you can't, you won't. We've talked about NEET projects, the number of NEETs growing, number of people being disassociated. Allow them to communicate and be part of the system. That, my Lords, will mean that we actually get the benefits of technology and not just the downsides.
It's not easy, but I do hope that the government, the Minister, when she comes to reply, will be able to tell us what steps are being taken in this direction.
Speaker 90
My Lords, it's a privilege to speak on a subject so critical to the flourishing of young people, and I welcome this debate. I too wish to focus primarily on the role that emerging technologies might play in our schools, and how we as the shepherds of those who attend them can ensure that such technologies are integrated safely, usefully, and with humanity in mind. At its heart, a school is a place of preparation, and a good school system must equip young people to confront the challenges of life. But I ask your Lordships to consider whether we've given enough thought not just to preparing young people, but also to preparing and resourcing those we charge with educating them. To give one example, there's a Church of England primary school in Peterborough diocese with just 99 pupils on its roll.
Speaker 89
And it's not uncommon for a Church of England school to be even smaller than this. The governance challenge presented to such schools by the emergence of AI is enormous. How do we ensure its use is safe? How do we integrate it in a way that guarantees the security of children's personal data? These are great philosophical questions as well as governance ones.
Speaker 90
And as a nation, we bear a responsibility to build a consensus that aids our schools with practical advice and support in navigating this new aspect of our world. We owe it to our educators not to expect them to conjure specialist knowledge on AI integration from thin air, but to equip them so that they can prepare our children for lives where they can use these technologies safely. On the philosophical, the question of what it means to be fully human is one that the church has been seeking to guide on for as long as it has existed. In our church schools, we place the concept of human flourishing at the heart of what we do. We have a vision of a school as a place where pupils bloom into the human being they will become for the rest of their lives.
And these technologies have the potential to enhance our human relationships, our human experience, and our human intellect.
But as we've heard, they also have the potential to replace, displace or diminish the humanity in our daily lives. Which of these paths we take is ultimately a very human choice. So whether AI and technology used by or in the service of children enhances or diminishes a human purpose is to us the central and critical question of our time. At the National Society for Education, we are already exploring both the challenges and the opportunities of AI in church schools. First and foremost, this is by working with schools and the dioceses to understand their needs.
Nothing can replace that first-hand experience from those who know their students so well, and I would encourage the government to look at similar consultation as it sets its own policy. We have a solemn responsibility to prepare the next generation for a future where the widespread use of AI is their reality, and as a nation, we must properly equip our educators to do so.
Patience Wheatcroft
My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for his comprehensive introduction to this debate and his observation that screen time is a phrase which encompasses very many different activities. How many of us in preparing for this debate weren't helped, either by design or default, by AI, and as I've no doubt the resulting speeches will demonstrate that it's not artificial, but it's certainly intelligent. The impact of AI is immense, and its potential to improve human lives is so. I don't believe that children should be prevented from complete access to it. But they also need to be taught about the potential harms of AI and to be extremely alert to that, and until they're fully prepared to cope with its downsides, and my goodness, we've already heard about how deep those downsides are, then children's access to AI should ideally be limited.
And the same is true of social media. While many of us may shun most social media, the family WhatsApp group is now a vital part of life for many of us, and it's a vital part of communications for those whose parents may be a long way away or whose grandchildren may be long distance. My young granddaughter got to know her American family courtesy of a screen, and it didn't do her any harm; the absence of that might well have done. But there's no denying the harm that some social media sites are delivering. The big tech companies could do so much more to stop that, and in an ideal world, most people would want to see their children completely protected from such things.
I've supported the concept of tight restrictions on young people's access to social media, but we must be realistic about how effective this can be. Early evidence from Australia is that the ban has had only limited effect. It is, after all, being imposed on a cohort of youngsters who are incredibly tech-savvy and they're finding ways around the ban. Any effectiveness will depend very heavily on the stance taken by parents, and that inevitably will vary. That's not to say we shouldn't do our best to impose restrictions, but we need to be realistic about the impact they will have.
So I want to concentrate my remarks on the area in which government can and should have a real impact, and that is the classroom. The noble lady Baroness Barran explained how schools do not even vet the quality and the damage that can be done by the products they buy.
While it's essential that schools equip our children for this technological age, it means teaching them digital literacy. It means teaching them to be on the alert for the harms that lie in wait for them. But in many schools, what it means is putting them in front of a screen. In some schools, there are now children who learn all their lessons from a tablet. This is not the way that relationships can be built, and most of us will know of a teacher who had a lasting impact on our lives.
Indeed, my speech is going to be followed by one just such teacher, and I'm sure he will be remembered by many of his pupils. Screens should be limited in schools. Indeed, perhaps the example of Winchester may be taken note: the best-achieving school has banned tablets in class.
Speaker 94
My Lords, I feel nervous about the introductions I've had. It's the first time for ten years I've spoken in the House of Lords as a backbencher, and it's a delight. And can I thank Lord Patel for that insightful speech and the interest he's had in this subject for many years. In 2012, along with the late Lord Lawson, the Archbishop of Canterbury and Andrew Turnbull, the then Cabinet Secretary, I represented the House of Lords on the Parliamentary Commission for Banking Standards. That was established by the Prime Minister of the day, David Cameron, in light of the global financial crash.
It was a joint House of Commons, House of Lords committee, not a select committee, but an independent body reporting to the Prime Minister and the Chancellor, with our own staff, outside experts and a very wide remit. It was tasked with providing legislation solutions for banking in the UK, managed by a brilliant House of Commons clerk, Colin Lee. We delivered on its mandate. New legislation was duly implemented, and the House of Lords played a huge part in that. And quite simply, my Lords, I'm calling for that today for AI: such a commission.
One that's established along similar lines to the Parliamentary Commission for Banking, commissioned by the Prime Minister. Why, my Lords? Because the seriousness of the situation confronting our children, society and humanity today is without parallel. We need the authority and the imprimatur of the Prime Minister to foster a national conversation in the first instance, to demonstrate that government, Parliament and industry experts and civil society are facing up to the real-time problems that we have. That's what politics has failed to do to date.
We're always behind the curve. We must rid ourselves of this passive approach. Let me give an example. When Lord Speaker invited the world-renowned Stanford University expert in AI and computing, Stuart Russell, to deliver a lecture on defence and security, his concluding remarks were that he was the bearer of bad news, namely that the industry regulation did not exist. Nothing existed.
And he said we could start a war from one's bedroom. Today, witnessing the lethality of drones in Ukraine, Iran wars and in Gaza, that illustrates his remarks. My Lords, that speech by Stuart Russell took place four years ago last month, October 2022. His warnings went unheeded, and in the intervening period we've witnessed the transfer of sovereignty from our countries to a small number of private tech companies, and we are at their beck and call.
The Musks, the Altmans, the Bezos, the Amodeis, they are the AI masters. We are subservient to them in every respect. But what are some practitioners in the AI industry saying today? For example, Brad Smith, the president of Microsoft, says, "AI is less regulated than milk or washing machines." Bill Gates says, "Left unchecked, the technology could cause a billion deaths."
He added, "No weapon today is more powerful than the combination of AI and malign actors." Sir Ken McCallum, head of MI5 last week, referred to bioweapons and nuclear war threats. So it's clear, my Lords, crystal clear, that a culture of safety does not exist in the AI industry. And I finish by saying if Bill Gates' chilling comments don't incentivize us to all get round the table with parliamentarians in the vanguard, then nothing will. So my challenge is for the parties, for Parliament, for Mr. Speaker and the Lord Speaker, using their authoritative voice, to convince the PM of the need for such a commission.
I finish by saying, my Lords, presently we are drowning in information, but we're starving in wisdom. So let's foster that campaign to ensure that we do acquire wisdom before it's too late.
Speaker 95
I also express my gratitude to Lord Patel for bringing us this debate and also for his outstanding introduction on it. I think the more we debate AI and climate change, I think the more we'd reach the point where we need somebody on the crossbenches to give us a debate on the future of humanity, because these are very fundamental issues we're tackling. We need effective regulation and protection against addiction, exploitation, and damage to children's development, which is arising with AI and related issues. This, of course, could be reduced, as I've argued previously, if, like other countries, we were prepared to develop our own sovereign AI entity. I've pressed this previously.
I've said that I believe many parents would support it. We would control much of what was around us. We would take charge. And we could persuade people, I believe, to invest in this if we were willing to consider creating a whole new public-private partnership to fund its introduction. So I ask my minister friend again, is there any movement on this front?
But we also need to distinguish between the dangers of an unregulated social media and the potential benefits of properly designed artificial intelligence. At Kenward House, a residential recovery center in Kent, we are developing a proposal to trial an AI companion to support people recovering from addiction from alcohol and drug problems and gambling now increasingly. And as ministers know, we're also exploring the possibility that this could, if successful, be equally applied in prisons, and it could be run over a wider front. The essential principle is that AI should support human relationships, not replace them. Could we develop appropriately safeguarded AI companions to help children struggling with obesity, loneliness, poor self-esteem, or difficulties in forming relationships?
Help them not to encourage more screen dependency, but to help them develop healthier lives and stronger relationships with other people. Such applications would, of course, require independent evaluation and appropriate professional support. My Lords, I give another example. This House sent a select committee to Blackpool when it was undertaking a review of obesity and diet and how we could affect changes. In the North West, we found particularly heavy growth of obesity there amongst children.
We've been weighing and measuring children since 2008, yet they get bigger and they get heavier. And we found in Blackpool what the social services people were saying is the reason we do not follow through, we do the measuring and the weighing, but we do not do any follow-through to assist them because we don't have the resources. Isn't this an area where potentially we could explore the use of an AI companion with children to give them guidance about the food, about calories, and so on and so forth? I think these are areas worth looking at. The other area which is developing and I think where we wait with interest to see the report that's coming on employment is how we start to prepare, if possible, about a different style of working that will be needed in the future and the extent to which we can use AI.
AI is going to destroy many jobs that we have known. And what we've called growth may have to be redefined in the future and that we have a shift from the material and more, and I look to our bishops' bench, more towards the caring professions, towards teaching people about the importance of service as opposed to producing goods, and that this is an area where we do things better than any AI, any technology could do, that we look to the strengths in humanity and we start increasingly to try to pass on the message to children and to train them and find all the tools we can, including AI, to make certain that we are affecting this very important shift that will replace many of the traditional approaches to employment.
Speaker 97
My Lords, it's a pleasure to be speaking for the second time in just over a month in a debate secured by my noble friend Lord Patel. If we want to minimize the harmful effects of AI on children through the misuse of AI chatbots, for example, we need to teach them how to use AI properly, and that should happen in schools. Sir Anthony Seldon was characteristically blunt about this issue a month ago when he wrote that Britain was falling behind other countries in its use of AI in education. He went further and said that the DfE should be put in special measures over its handling of AI in schools. Now, I'm not sure how helpful headline-grabbing statements such as these are, but the pace with which the DfE is taking up the challenge of AI in education is far slower than it needs to be.
For example, it is still yet to announce the consultation promised more than six months ago on the approach to certifying the safety of EdTech in schools. Earlier this year, it advertised a new post, Director General for Digital, AI and Infrastructure, with a £200k salary, the highest within the department. Unfortunately, it was only able to make a temporary appointment and the permanent role has now been re-advertised.
There are worthwhile initiatives which have started but as standalone projects. In June, eight companies were awarded contracts to design classroom-ready AI tutoring tools aligning with the national curriculum and covering years 9 to 11 in English, maths, science and foreign languages. As of last month, year 12 students in seven schools are piloting the level 3 qualification in data science and AI which Professor Peyton Jones from Cambridge University and I proposed last year, now designed by the Raspberry Pi Foundation as a preparation for an extended project qualification, an EPQ, in the topic. There are other initiatives such as the AI product safety standards, but there is no overall coherent strategy. So I am in agreement with my noble friend Lord McFall.
The government should set up a commission, but with perhaps a narrower brief. It should have an independent chair and cross-departmental representation and be given a brief to develop an overall strategy for schools, integrating existing DfE initiatives but also identifying gaps where they exist. The commission should work at pace, inject a sense of urgency and create a roadmap for the rollout of AI teaching and digital literacy in schools, with a clear implementation plan which would then be the responsibility of the Director General for Digital, AI and Infrastructure. My Lords, if this country is not to be left behind Estonia, Singapore or China, we cannot afford to wait. Independent schools are not waiting.
Dedicated head of AI education or director of AI posts have been created in elite independent schools such as Brighton College or the Perse School. We need a coherent strategy for AI in education in the state sector, with a timetable for delivery measured in months, not years. Therefore I ask the noble lady the minister whether she will commit to taking such a proposal to her ministerial colleagues in the Department for Education after this debate.
Speaker 98
I start like others in applauding my noble friend Lord Patel for securing this debate. The more I begin to understand this subject, the more appalled I am, as I know many members of this House are, at the exploitation in many cases of our young. Now Lord Patel mentioned their being lured into violence. I'm going to, as you would expect, talk about the national security implications of this. I do so copyright of Sir Ken McCallum, the current head of MI5, who I'm going to quote.
Every year he gives a speech on the threat to the United Kingdom. In 2024 he said that 13% of those being investigated by MI5 for terrorism was under 18. This he said was a threefold increase on the previous year, especially skewed towards extreme right-wing propaganda and violence. In 2025 he talked about a concerning number of minors. One in five of the 232 people arrested for terrorism last year was under 17.
One in five. This year, and Lord McFall mentioned one thing he said in his speech, he talked of a particular case of a 13-year-old who MI5 was investigating and was prevented from causing a major terrorist attack overseas. He went on to say that MI5 did not wish to be having to look at 13-year-olds. So I think that this is another aspect of this which is deeply concerning.
This exploitation and turning towards extreme violence and terrorism of some of our most vulnerable and young people. I'm sure as others have said that key to this is teaching in schools. Lady Barron's remarks I very much associate myself with. But I'm going to end with a little horrible little anecdote which happened to me the other day when I was talking to a friend of mine about the then plan of the American government to stream the execution of a convicted terrorist and saying how appalling I thought this decision was which has now been retracted. They said that they'd been talking about it to one of their grandchildren in their late teens who took a completely different view and said well I've seen plenty of that already on the internet.
And I think that I have seen the odd trauma with my in my life and I have not forgotten what I saw at Lockerbie bodies around scattered around. If our young people are seeing scenes of torture beheading execution extreme pedophilia etc. what levels of PTSD are we inducing for the future? I don't think there's much that's more important than dealing with this very quickly. I don't have quick solutions but some of them have been suggested by colleagues here today.
Speaker 99
My Lords I thank the noble Lord Patel for securing this important debate. I declare my interest as a member of the advisory board for Rare Ventures which invests in AI technologies. Countries across the world are wrestling with the same question: what will it mean for our children's future to grow up in an age of social media and artificial intelligence? I know that noble Lords across this House agree that we must do everything in our power to protect children from harm and to stop those who seek to inflict it. But today I wish to focus my concern that a blanket ban on social media may lead us towards more harm and not less.
As many noble Lords have highlighted the UK is introducing a ban on social media for under-16s. I am not totally opposed to this but I am concerned that this approach is not nuanced enough. Australia banned social media for under-16s in December 2025 and yet research by the Molly Rose Foundation published in April this year found that 61% of 12 to 15-year-olds who held accounts on restricted platforms before the ban still have access to at least one. Of the children who used these platforms before the ban 51% had said it made no difference to their online safety and a further 14% now feel less safe. My Lords these findings are sobering.
I acknowledge that the ban may need more time to bed in but my concern is that a ban in the UK may put the onus solely on parents when we should be using the Online Safety Act to hold platforms accountable and ensure safety by design. The recent Meta settlement in California has shown what can be done when a platform is held to account with a deal struck that limits notifications to children and allows them to choose a feed that is not driven by algorithm. Yet this judgment applies only in participating US states and Meta has not announced whether these essential protections will be extended to the UK.
Any ban that is too porous could take the pressure off social media companies to deliver safety by design. British children could therefore end up with fewer protections than their American counterparts. Children in Cardiff deserve the same protections as children in California. Turning to artificial intelligence, here too our instinct must not be fear alone. AI has extraordinary ability to democratize knowledge, and while we must always scan the horizon for potential harms to children, we must also embrace its benefits and equip our children with the skills needed for an AI future.
Imagine every child in this country having a personalized tutor, one that picks up on the gaps in their learning and can repeat content they struggle to grasp over and over without losing patience. Not as a replacement for a real in-person teacher, but in addition to it. Imagine the potential of this technology for children whose families cannot afford private tuition. Of the potential this could unleash for our STEM industries to have a generation growing up with the curiosity for learning and the confidence and skills to use AI. My Lords, it is vital that we mitigate against the worst impacts of social media and AI on children, but we must take a pragmatic and nuanced approach.
Let us continue to strengthen the Online Safety Act, ensure that tech companies operate with safety by design, and ensure that Ofcom acts swiftly where they fall short. But most of all, let us ensure that the decisions we make today do not limit our children's skills, knowledge, and opportunities for the future.
David Alton
My Lords, I join others in thanking my noble friend Lord Patel for initiating this important cross-bench debate, drawing attention to how AI systems can harvest, scrape, and process personal and biometric data, often without meaningful consent or awareness from young users. These tools also risk making inaccurate assumptions or misidentifying children as adults. AI risks are identified in the last report on my watch as chair of the Joint Committee on Human Rights, Human Rights and the Regulation of AI, which was published last month, including risks to young people and children in whose lives AI is ubiquitous. Over 14 months, I chaired 10 oral sessions. Witnesses included major tech companies, Google, Meta, and Microsoft, regulatory bodies, academics, and the AI minister, Feryal Clark.
That inquiry received over 70 written pieces of evidence, and it led to our unanimous 94-page report and 59 recommendations. We called for a wide-ranging, standalone AI bill, including some outright prohibitions, strengthened GDPR safeguards, and independent oversight. In written evidence, 5Rights Foundation cited their, I quote, Children and AI Design Code. They said government policy on AI has largely overlooked the distinct opportunities and needs for children. May I therefore ask the noble Baroness the Minister what assessment is being made of the nine criteria listed in that code, and of the concerns of the Children's Commissioner, Dame Rachel de Souza, and indeed of our JCHR report?
In the 1990s, in another place, I moved amendments to safeguard children from gratuitously violent video material.
But the same phenomenon has now emerged in new technological clothes. Through my noble friend Lady Kidron, I met the grieving parents of Sewell Setzer, the 14-year-old boy who took his own life because he had been befriended by a chatbot. His mother said it was, I quote, like having a predator in your house. Similarly, a 13-year-old autistic boy was groomed by a chatbot who criticized his parents, encouraged him to run away, and offered him an explicit relationship which could be consummated in the afterlife. Commercial drivers have no compunction in aggressively amplifying high-quality, visually compelling AI-generated material relating to suicide, self-harm, and violence, which is targeted at vulnerable young people.
Platforms leverage persuasive AI-designed features optimized purely for screen time and engagement. Some involve compromising deepfakes. How AI and social media intersect is important because it's in an area where generative AI has already had a colossal and largely unremarked impact. In the influencer arms race, in which an ever-evolving set of tactics are used to maximize the virality of what they write, gaining exposure and ad revenue, generative AI is the equivalent of giving a medieval knight a Kalashnikov. Influencers can now churn out hundreds of posts a day, all hyper-optimized for engagement.
There's money to be made, and so they do. Society is now saturated with mobile social media where nothing can be taken at face value, and the impact on children can be profound. Some material is insanely addictive. It's linked to advertising revenue, and companies have spent a great deal of money making them as addictive as possible. Addictive technology is more analogous to a slot machine than a communication method, with children especially vulnerable to this kind of addictive technology.
Speaker 101
My Lords, government must insist on AI systems that are made developmentally appropriate, safe, fair, transparent, and accountable. And governments, who are the guardians and gatekeepers, have been lagging behind tech giants whose market valuations exceed entire nation states. That must change.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, I join the chorus in thanking the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing this debate and his powerful introduction. I will take a different approach to many of those already made, speeches already made, a broader, systemic, historically informed approach. I begin with a quote. The manufacture of this nation hath been of late years hindered by the misspending so much time as the poorer tradesmen do in going about from one coffee house to another, pouring over seditious, heretical, and treasonable papers. As the language might hint to your Lordships' House, that's from the very early 18th century.
The presence of new technologies and wide access of ordinary people to them has long been of concern to elites and to elders about the young. Technological determinism is a common claim and a handy alibi for those profiting from a society being directed to the benefits of the few at the cost of the many. Technology never determines the direction of a society. It is a human creation, and it can and is directed by humans for good or ill, as is the state of our society. I'll start with screen time.
But what alternatives do young people have? Is there a youth club for them to go to? Almost certainly not. Is there a flourishing healthy green space to attract them? No.
Is their schooling at some giant academy trust involved in employing tech instead of trained teachers? So despite the lack of evidence to any benefits, it relies on edtech. Earlier this week at a meeting of the APPG on woodlands and trees, I heard a nurseryman lamenting the decline of horticultural and agricultural education, the colleges that should be preparing young people for crucial healthy jobs. But how often do we hear ministers or the Prime Minister speaking about this, as compared to waxing enthusiastically about the possibilities of artificial so-called intelligence, promoting it and suggesting that it is an inevitable part of future jobs, so directing young people towards it? And we have extraordinarily well-funded and powerful voices, some of them owning and directing the very technologies we are talking about, promoting AI and social media at every turn.
Lord Patel asks an entirely appropriate question about the health impacts, and yes, my spine can attest to that.
We have them funding so-called think tanks, better called lobbyists, following the models of political influencing developed by the fossil fuel companies and the tobacco merchants of death. This tech can be used and is used for good, as the noble Lords Addington and the Baroness Wheatcroft have said. It can be a democratising force, and yes, I am a fan of BlueSky. It is common these days to complain that there is too much information. Duran Duran sang a song about that in 1993, although when you look at the lyrics of the song, it is actually about advertising, a reminder that a lot of the toxic material our young people are encountering, promotion for ultra-processed food-like substances, for fast fashion, for tech itself, are from giant multinational companies.
Blame them, not the technology. And finally, we come to the question of the environmental footprint of these technologies. Some communities on these islands and around the world are increasingly aware of this issue and campaigning against it. These technologies are not in the cloud, but very much down to earth and causing real damage to the already greatly depleted world our young people will inherit. A question to the Minister: is the government considering how much of all of these technologies our environment and the environments of the world can support?
In conclusion, we have a toxic artificial intelligence and social media environment which harms adults and children. That comes from a toxic society. What to do? Listen to the children. Nothing about us without us.
They are the experts, and as in so many areas of life, allowing more people to put input into decisions rather than the few dictating is the route to a better society.
Speaker 102
As a neuroscientist, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for drawing attention to this timely issue, and I declare an interest as founder and CEO of a biotech company, Neuro-Bio Limited. Most recently, in collaboration with senior psychiatrists, we have been attempting to develop the first ever biomarker for depression, and we've done this in young people. And this experience working with clinicians and disturbed adolescents has confirmed views I flagged in your Lordships' House as far back as 2009, that digital technology was offering an alternative environment for the human condition. Environment is key to individual development. Our species occupies more ecological niches than any other on the planet because of the superlative ability of our brains, compared with those of any other animal, to adapt to our surroundings.
Even if you are a clone, an identical twin with the same genes, your brain becomes personalised through development of unique configurations of connections between neurons that characterise the growth of the human brain after birth, curating a highly individual mind that is in constant dialogue with and updated by your unique life experiences.
Even before AI, it was increasingly apparent that screen usage would bring problems, and it's not just the effects of not sleeping, not escaping the crowd, and not having time to exercise that can facilitate obesity and bullying. The digital lifestyle can, in and of itself, prove deleterious. The more we depend on screen technologies as intermediaries for interpersonal relations whilst young, the less we learn the skills needed for effective communication and empathy in real-world interactions. All too familiar are reports on how video games and social media can be deliberately crafted for commercial purposes to become addictive. The neuronal mechanism of addiction is an enhanced release of the chemical messenger dopamine, which underlies the anticipation of reward, raises arousal, and is indeed the hallmark neurochemically of recreational drugs.
Dopamine inhibits a part of the brain, the so-called prefrontal cortex, that moderates emotional responses and dampens impulsive reactions. This region, just behind your forehead, is not fully operational until late teenage years or even the early twenties, and until then, the characteristic features will include recklessness, short attention span, and most significantly, overdependence on external stimulation. This mindset could well be exaggerated further by the perfect storm of a still immature prefrontal cortex, now coupled with unprecedented surges of inhibitory dopamine driven by a 21st-century screen lifestyle. So we are faced with a set of dilemmas. Society desires young people to master and harness technology for the good of humanity, yet technology simultaneously drives mood deterioration, social exclusion, exploitation, and trauma.
The online world offers connection, AI holds the promise at national and global levels, yet its unregulated integration into young people's lives risks creating an entity increasingly alien to human emotional experience. The education system demands conformity to model answers, yet the modern world increasingly places a premium on creativity, independent thought, and collaboration, skills that current system structures undermine. Young people need community, shared purpose, and belonging, yet the pull of influencer culture and online identity draws them away from real-world participation. My psychiatrist colleagues were keen to suggest solutions, inevitably with more money and more regulation. But perhaps we first need to agree on what the ideal teenage lifestyle would look like in the coming years.
It's easy to list what we don't want, but unless we can decide on what we wish to achieve, it will be hard to attain it. Commonplace activities such as eating together, exercising, reading stories to children, immersing yourself in a novel, may seem simplistic and nostalgic as solutions. Indeed they are, and they are not in themselves the answer. But they can be the bedrock for development of emotions, intuition, empathy, morality, spirituality, and above all, spontaneous curiosity, a quintessential human profile not seen in AI systems. If you like, not a digital lifestyle, but an analog one.
Let's not ask what will happen to us in the AI future, but rather how can we shape a future where AI is neither an anthropomorphized spectre nor savior, but a means towards the valued end of young people realizing their full potential.
Speaker 103
My Lords, I do thank the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for bringing this important debate before the House. There is no doubt that artificial intelligence, social media, and digital technology are changing childhood in ways that would have been unimaginable only a generation ago. Much of our discussion today rightly focuses on the risks.
We are all aware of growing concerns about excessive screen use, harmful online content, cyberbullying, misinformation, and the impact these can have on children's mental health, well-being, and development. We must therefore expect technology companies to take greater responsibility for the products they create and the environments they expose to young people. Children cannot be expected to navigate complex digital spaces without proper safeguards; protection must be built into the systems they use. However, my Lords, I would like to focus on another aspect of this debate which is sometimes overlooked. For many children around the world, technology is not simply a source of entertainment; it can be a gateway to education, opportunity, and hope.
That is where technology has enormous potential. A child living in a remote village should be able to access quality educational material regardless of geography. A child who has fallen behind should be able to receive additional support. A child whose family cannot afford private tuition should still be able to learn, progress, and aspire. Artificial intelligence may help make that possible.
Used responsibly, it can provide personalized learning support, help explain difficult concepts, and offer educational assistance beyond a classroom. My Lords, the challenge before us therefore is therefore not simply how to protect children from technology; it is how to ensure technology serves children. We must protect them from exploitation, harmful content, and unhealthy digital environments. At the same time, we should ensure that children from disadvantaged backgrounds are not excluded from the educational opportunities that new technologies can provide. I hope the government will continue to promote digital literacy, support online safety, and encourage partnerships between technology providers and educators.
My Lords, the true test of artificial intelligence will not be how advanced the technology becomes; it will be whether it helps create a fairer society in which every child, regardless of income, geography, or family circumstances, has the opportunity to learn, to develop their talents, and to fulfill their potential.
Speaker 104
My Lords, I too congratulate Lord Patel. He has given us once again his incredible experience and knowledge on issues like this and has given us the chance to say and to participate in this debate. I must say I am encouraged by the debate because it is much more nuanced than I was expecting. And actually, that is the whole issue, that this debate has to be nuanced; it is not clearly one thing or the other. I have got, I must say, a bit anxious about people thinking the ban on social media is fine, that's it, and putting it on one side.
And we all know that it is such a small part of what we need to do to protect children. And I know that my noble friend on the front bench is really concerned about these issues all around. I agreed with again my noble friend Lord McFall and I'm delighted that he's back now among the rest of us able to contribute. But I want to concentrate only on digital exclusion. I chair the Digital Inclusion Action Committee and everyone today has assumed almost that young people have easy, straightforward access to technology.
And the reality is they don't. This is still an issue where if your parents have got the resource, then yes, you will have the tablet, you will have the computer, your family will have Wi-Fi. But for many families still, the issue is that they don't, that they don't have the resource in order to make sure that their children are getting what now is simply part of being, of growing up in the 21st century. The technology moves far quicker than any of us here in this House. The technology is absolutely changing our understanding, how teaching happens, how everything happens and how public services are going to be delivered.
All of that is changing. And yet we still have a group of people who are not able to access that and that therefore doubles their discrimination. And the noble Lord Lord Addington is right that for particular groups, access to technology is absolutely crucial for them to be able to do normal everyday things. Government's responsibility is to regulate so that we eliminate as much harm as possible. But then we also have to make sure that wherever you are, whoever you are, you have access to good teaching about what the technology can do and how you avoid the harms.
If we simply think a ban is the answer, we will put young people at the stage where they come back to it and they have no idea how to identify a scam, how to identify an untruth, how to identify who is trying to mislead them. They need that information. They need that training. They need that teaching. We have to make sure that we do recognize we are now living in an age where technology is part of our standard of living.
It's part of how we live our lives. And if we actually exclude a group because they can't afford it or they don't have the means to access it because of a disability or any other thing, we are actually increasing disadvantage and discrimination.
We have to protect, but we also have to enable through making sure everyone has a chance.
Usha Prashar
My Lords, I too thank the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing this debate and for his comprehensive, chilling and sobering introduction. As he said, digital technology is now part of children's education, friendships and everyday lives. Research identifies genuine opportunities for learning, creativity and social connections. But research, as he said, also highlights concerns about mental health, emotional well-being, behavioral issues, sleep deprivation, online harm and safety. And issues raised by AI differ from those raised by social media and screen time.
Benefits and potential of AI should not be underestimated, as we've heard, but there are legitimate concerns about AI replacing independent thinking, inhibiting cognitive development, blunting critical thinking and judgment, and encouraging excessive engagement and simulated emotional relationships. Ethical use of AI is also a concern. While the government has taken some welcome actions in supporting the development of AI tutoring tools for disadvantaged pupils, most of the other actions, particularly in response to dangers of social media, have come too late. We are moving towards a predominantly, of course necessary, stronger regulatory environment, but we need to make sure that the regulation is proportionate, that it does not stifle autonomy and learning like self-discipline and self-management and development of children. We need safer technology and hold companies responsible and accountable for making their products safe and Ofcom policing them with rigor.
But above all, as others have said, we need better media and digital education with parental involvement if we are to harness the benefits of those technologies and avoid its downsides. We have not done enough on AI digital literacy or educating children about how best to use AI and social media. We need to empower young people to learn how to self-regulate and establish their own boundaries. Protecting children requires more than just addressing online harm. It requires spaces and initiatives which encourage offline activities, healthy development of children and activities which build resilience and effective personal relationships.
And here I associate myself with the comments made by Baroness Greenfield about making sure that we actually concentrate on self-development of young people. We have not equipped schools with capacity, resources and know-how. Response has been reactive rather than proactive, and as Lord Tarassenko said, there is no coherent strategy. I was, however, pleased that a school in Scotland, probably the first one to do so, has appointed a dedicated principal of AI literacy who's going to be focusing entirely on helping pupils and staff to understand the risks and so on. So this is an encouraging development, but will the government be learning from this initiative?
Furthermore, implications of AI will have profound effect on society and the economy. Are we assessing what skills will children need to navigate this vast changing landscape and job market? Are we doing enough in this area?
Acting on AI is more important than just advocating it or promoting it. It is important that we don't make the same mistakes that we made with social media, where we are behind the curve and just engaged in catch-up. The government cannot afford to repeat the mistakes and delay action with regard to AI. So my question to the minister are: what broader initiatives are the government taking to promote AI and social media literacy and empowering young people to self-regulate in schools? Will the government bring the currently unregulated AI chatbots within the online framework, and if so, when?
And what are the company, are the companies being held accountable for ensuring that their products are safe? My Lords, this is probably the most revolutionary development of our time, and how we respond to these significant challenges will determine the future security and resilience of youngsters and our society.
Speaker 2
My Lords, I too thank the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing this important debate. I declare my interests as a technology consultant, AI advisor, and director of AI and AI policy companies. My concern is children's ability to direct their own attention. Counting hours in front of a screen cannot tell us enough. An hour speaking to family is different from an hour of passive scrolling.
A 2025 study demonstrated how attention fragmentation caused by rapid cuts of short-form content result in diminished focus and mental fatigue in students. Using AI to understand a problem is different from using it to avoid thinking about it. We must distinguish between general time online, the activity undertaken, and the design of the service. Ofcom spoke to 40 children aged 8 to 16 who felt they spent longer online than intended. They described how endless scrolling, autoplay, and personalized recommendations made stopping difficult.
These interviews cannot tell us how widespread that experience is. They do, however, show why design deserves our attention. The Royal College of Psychiatrists recommends that the responsibility for children's online safety should not sit, should sit not only with families, but also with government, regulators, and technology companies, calling on them to promote stronger safety by design by regulating addictive design features such as infinite scroll, autoplay, and engagement-driven recommendation systems. I therefore urge the minister to consider requiring platforms to turn off autoplay by default, to create meaningful stopping points in endless feeds, and to limit notifications that exploit fear of missing out. Conversational AI raises further questions.
It can support learning, but completing homework is not the same as understanding it. Learning sometimes means staying with a difficult task when the answer does not come immediately. And these should never be deliberately designed to create emotional dependence. Chatbots targeted towards children are designed with custom names, avatars, voice-enabled features, and excessive anthropomorphic features aimed at promoting engagement. Safeguards should address simulated attachment, pressure to continue chatting, and interactions that discourage children from seeking human support.
The government has announced restrictions on social media for under-16s, protective defaults for 16 and 17-year-olds, and mandatory chatbot breaks for under-18s. The task now is to ensure that these measures work in practice. I therefore ask the minister three questions. First, how will Ofcom assess whether they reduce prolonged or compulsive use?
Secondly, what enforceable safeguards will prevent conversational AI services from cultivating emotional dependence or steering children away from trusted adults? Thirdly, will the promised independent evaluations measure the prevalence of binge-scrolling behavior in children, children's sleep, attention, learning, and ability to stop, alongside overall time and time spent scrolling, scrolling short-form content online? Will they also examine children's ability to question AI's answers and follow their use of conversational AI over several years? My Lords, our responsibility is to protect children's capacity to learn, form relationships, and make choices of their own. That requires services designed to respect their developing independence and evidence that the safeguards we introduce make a difference.
Speaker 106
My Lords, the noble Lord Patel always likes to give us a challenge when he sets a debate, and this is certainly one of the greatest challenges we've had in terms of its widespread topic. So I'm just going to pick out a few things, so much has been said, it's been a very interesting debate today. The rapid rise of generative AI systems, particularly conversational chatbots such as ChatGPT, has of course sparked new concerns regarding their psychological impact on all users, but especially children. But I want to stress that while there are legitimate concerns, and we've heard a great deal about those, the real problem in my view is that children are missing out on in their lives when they're stuck in front of a highly addictive screen. Friendship, social activities, physical activity, and family time, although of course I do appreciate those amazing ability for children to reach out across to reach relatives in other countries, to talk to friends on screen and so on, but actually in terms of what they get from them from AI generative systems can be very harmful.
When you introduce a young child to book, to reading books, you don't just plonk a book in a child's hand and say, here you are, read that. You read with them, getting to them to know gradually what the words mean, how they connect, and how to grasp the story. The parent supervises the child before letting it loose on any old book. The same surely should be true of AI and the internet in general. And as many people have said, in fact, parents need to know and be educated about it themselves if they are to help their children.
And teachers above all need to know about this stuff in the classroom, and perhaps we are very far behind several other countries in getting to grips with that. So my question for the Minister is what is the government doing to ensure that the Department of Education is preparing its teachers and teachers also preparing parents for activity in this area? While these AI tools offer unprecedented access to educational information, opportunities to learn, learning is not a solitary activity. Being part of a class with a good teacher is worth a hundred hours of unguided self-learning. Interestingly, the Ministry of Education in China mandates AI literacy and tech courses starting from elementary school.
Middle and high school students tackle machine learning, ethics, and model design. So they have, they regulate AI exposure quite fearsomely, and perhaps it's time that we thought about that as well. Right now in the UK, the Scottish government did publish its own, I have to say rather vague policy in March, but left everything open to local flexibility. And in England and Wales, AI usage, where has it skyrocketed, we have not produced in England and Wales a similar policy on how to develop this stuff.
In fact, UK students boast some of the highest generative AI adoption rates globally, using it for nearly half of their academic work. So teachers are permitted and encouraged to use it, but where is the guidance, where is the regulation, where is the education for teachers? But it's the companionship from AI chatbots that pose a real problem, the anthropomorphic nature of them. There is a growing body of evidence that suggests that these objects may induce or exacerbate psychiatric symptoms in vulnerable children and adolescents. False social attachments can lead to some serious harms indeed.
And we've already heard from the noble Lord Alton about the tragic case of Sewell Setzer in the States, who died by suicide following months of intensive interaction with AI chatbots. I've come to the end of what I can say about this, but I do think we need to understand the mental health implications, but also parental and teacher education to get this stuff in their curriculum too.
Speaker 107
My Lords, until a decade ago, the IT revolution seemed a social good. We acclaimed the amazing technology that allows people anywhere in the world to communicate with each other and to access the world's knowledge. But ambivalence set in. We became anxious about the impact of fake news, the amplification of extreme views, and about the shoddy and often obscene content which young children were enticed to scroll through and on which some spent several hours per day. And the pace of advances in the last three years, the release of ChatGPT followed by its increasingly powerful successors, scares us all.
The apocalyptic scenarios, the over-dominance of a few globe-spanning mega-companies, should be high on the political agenda. But today's debate is a chance to address more domestic issues, the extent to which we should allow AI to invade our domestic lives. To take a very simple example, every child could now have a mobile device that can answer all its questions in its mother's voice. Some find this distasteful, rather like delegating childcare to robots. But anyone mindful that some five-year-olds enter reception class not toilet-trained and barely able to speak must agree that such a phone could have eased their deprivation.
It has some pluses. AI can't completely replace a real teacher, except maybe for adult professional education. But it can be a genuine aid for all but the very best teachers. For instance, the Khan Academy website, already fifteen years old, produced a library of simple videos showing a hand writing as though on a blackboard, with an unseen voice offering a clear exposition of, for instance, simple geometry or mechanics. There would still be a teacher monitoring the class, but if each pupil had a tablet or simple laptop, then they needn't all go at the same speed.
And a range of simple programs like this could enhance basic teaching in the developing world, and indeed in this country too.
The Khan Academy allows pupils anywhere in the world to benefit from a small number of outstanding expositors. Likewise, I think those who offer fine lectures at school or university level should spread their impact wider via AI, just as writers of good textbooks do. It's crucial to ensure that students develop their own knowledge and skills, not becoming over-reliant on AI-generated content. There's concern about what's called cognitive offloading, delegating problem-solving to AI rather than nourishing their own intellectual development. We must guard against that.
And AI's role will surely become more crucial at college level if, as one expects, the three-year full-time residential model of education becomes less dominant and is replaced by a more flexible structure.
Speaker 84
I would like to thank the clerks for allowing me to speak in the gap. I would just like to join the chorus of thanks to my noble friend Lord Patel for winning this debate and also for his wise words. And I would also like to congratulate the first speech of my noble friend Lord McFall of Alcluith after his 22-yard walk from woolsack to crossbench. I'd also like to thank my 15-year-old daughter Cecilia for her help in this speech and for being a sounding board. My Lords, I'm a working teacher.
I've said so many times, I've talked about mobile phones. They have no place in either going to or in schools. Children need to learn without them. If mankind has managed for 500,000 years without them, if you need to know where your child is, give them an AirTag. My Lords, we kid ourselves that AI and screens are an issue for the young, but they're an issue that affects us all.
By the time we've finished this debate on AI, it's already out of date. Jimmy Carr says, and I quote, "If you listed me the attributes of God, he's omnipotent, he's all-knowing, he lives in a cloud and he makes miracles happen. These are the attributes of a deity. I think we were made not in God's image, we so wanted there to be a God that we invented one. That's what I think about AI," unquote.
A friend of mine who's the CEO of a data company has a theory that when you ask an AI engine to do a task, it first makes an obvious error and then apologises. And he thinks that's deliberate to make it seem unthreatening so we underestimate the power that is going on behind us. Screens, my Lords. We need to make sure that no one can accidentally or deliberately access harmful content, as my noble friend Lady Manningham-Buller has said so powerfully. And I would like in this stage to commend the work of the charity Tender in educating people how to communicate, and they educate on what is acceptable.
My Lords, fundamentally, if we want to get young people off screens and keep them somehow offline, then we need to make the offline world that much more interesting.
Timothy Clement-Jones
My Lords, can I warmly thank the noble Lord Patel for securing this debate and for the authority with which he opened it. And my Lords, we've heard a series of outstanding speeches today on a very broad range of issues as the noble Baroness Murphy pointed out. And like the noble Lord Hampton, I'm absolutely delighted to hear from the noble Lord McFall, who was a very tech-savvy Lord Speaker, understanding both the opportunities and the risks of tech for this House, my Lords, during his tenure. And I've asked on many occasions whether these technologies will be our servant or master. Today that question has a rather sharper edge: are these technologies serving childhood or are our children being shaped to serve a business model built on attention?
Are we being invaded in our domestic lives as the noble Lord Rees said? Or indeed, as the right reverend prelate, the Bishop of Peterborough said, is it serving their humanity? My Lords, this debate is no longer about whether to act, it's about whether what we do is well-designed, grounded in evidence and able to keep pace with AI. At its heart is one principle: safety by design. The question is not only which children we keep off which platforms, but whether the products themselves are built with children's well-being in mind.
So what does the evidence tell us? The POST briefings were mentioned by the noble Lord Patel. They were published in August and show the scale. By the age of two, 98% of children use screens on a typical day and 97% of 13 to 17-year-olds have a social media or messaging profile. Some harms are found consistently: disrupted sleep, sedentary behavior, obesity mentioned by the noble Lord Brooke, and myopia.
And of course the security risks mentioned by the noble Baroness Manningham-Buller. But POST is equally clear that most studies take a snapshot at a single point in time, so they show a link but not a cause and effect. My Lords, the harm lies not just therefore in the content, but in the functionality of the product: infinite scroll, autoplay, streaks and recommender systems tuned for engagement and recommender systems tuned to maximize engagement rather than well-being, triggering the brain effects mentioned by the noble Baroness Greenfield. These are deliberate design choices and they can be designed differently. A ban asks children to stay away from unsafe products.
Safety by design, as noble Baroness Owen advocated, requires companies to stop building them. But nor should we forget the benefits, and they were mentioned not only by my noble friend Lord Addington, but Baroness Wheatcroft, noble Baroness Owen, Baroness Bennett, the noble Lord Loomba and the noble Lord Rees. The Oxford survey found that one in eight students use social media for mental health support, rising to around a quarter among some of the most vulnerable groups.
An Australia's early evaluation, also mentioned by the noble Baroness Wheatcroft and Baroness Owen, found a fall in accounts on restricted platforms, but that many children had kept access. A blunt instrument can miss its target and hurt the very children it's meant to protect. And we should listen to the children's charities here. The NSPCC has warned us that a complex problem needs more than a blanket solution. The risk is that children are pushed through VPNs into less regulated spaces where they're harder to protect, and then meet the full force of the most addictive features the day they turn 16.
The Secretary of State acknowledged that cliff-edge concern, but the same thinking should apply to younger children too, because many will get round the ban or use services it does not cover, and safer design is what protects them there. And that's why on these Liberal Democrat benches, we've argued for film-style age ratings for social media. Platforms with harmful content or addictive algorithmic feeds would be rated for over 16s and extreme content 18 plus, while educational sites and family messaging stay open. No child should be banned from Wikipedia for their homework or from the family WhatsApp group. We've also called for health warnings on apps and a cap on doomscrolling.
There is a range of views about the right age threshold, but we share the same goal. The government's package reflects some of the thinking behind our approach, and the noble Lord Nagaraju set some of those out, targeting harmful features rather than screens alone, and safer defaults for 16 and 17 year olds. They've chosen a blanket ban where we would preferred ratings, but a ratings approach should still shape how the ban is defined and enforced so that it is the riskiest services that are caught. Now let me turn to artificial intelligence, which has been mentioned by so many noble Lords, which I fear will be the next frontier of this debate long after a social media ban has bedded in. And as the noble Baroness Prashar says, we need to act now.
Ofcom has said plainly that chatbots are not regulated at all where users interact only with the bot, and that extending its powers is a matter for government and Parliament. The Online Safety Act regulates services, not technology, and generative AI exposes that gap. My Lords, the government's fix is welcome, but too narrow. Illegal content duties and an age limit on romantic companion bots leaves untouched the sycophancy, emotional dependency, and manipulative design of general purpose chatbots, which children increasingly treat as friends, tutors, and confidants, as we've heard from noble Lords today. POST also notes potential risks to attention, language development, and independent thinking.
AI should strengthen children's thinking, not substitute for it. These are design choices too. A chatbot that flatters, never ends a conversation, and presents itself as a friend has been built that way. My Lords, will the government look at default design duties rather than relying on illegal content duties alone? So my Lords, I suggest four steps.
First, the adoption of the proposals in the noble Lord Alton's recent report from his joint committee, his Joint Human Rights Committee, my Lords.
And this would involve mandatory children's algorithmic impact assessments before AI products are likely to be used by children. Second, a statutory children and AI design code, building on the age-appropriate design code. And my Lords, many noble Lords have mentioned the opportunities for AI in education. But my Lords, there should be human-in-command standards for AI in schools and EdTech. And my Lords, I commend very strongly the recent book by Daniel Susskind, "What Do We Tell Our Children?"
And of course, all the work that Sir Anthony Seldon and Michael Stevenson are carrying out at Wellington College in terms of human flourishing and education, my Lords. Fourth, there should be age assurance that protects privacy and is built on open standards. And my Lords, I should also mention, as the noble Lord Rees did, the importance of avoiding cognitive offloading in higher education in particular, and the steps that need to be taken to make sure that we use AI tools, but we also educate in a way that forces people not to be able to use AI tools, but keep the critical thinking that is so vital. So my Lords, I have some questions for the Minister. First, will the Section 214A regulations be made by affirmative procedure, with a draft published for consultation, and will the end-of-the-year timetable hold?
Second, which services are in and which are out? YouTube disputes that it is social media, and WhatsApp sits outside the ban. Will there be an independent risk-based rating mechanism rather than a ministerial list? Third, how will privacy be protected in age assurance, and how will VPN circumvention be handled? The government also said they would legislate for age verification at device level if their recommendations were not adopted by September this year.
That deadline has passed. Can the Minister tell the House what has happened and whether legislation is now coming? Fourth, my Lords, will the regulations and Ofcom codes impose positive design duties so that services likely to be used by children are safe by design, as the Online Safety Act's own objectives require? And my Lords, what, as the noble Baroness Armstrong said, what about digital inclusion? And other noble Lords talked about media literacy, my Lords.
The new RSHE guidance, taught from this September, covers online misogyny, AI, and deepfakes. What support will teachers get to deliver it with confidence? And will independent evaluation be built in from day one, my Lords? My Lords, childhood should not be a product optimized for engagement. Our aim is not simply to keep children out of the digital world, but to require that it is built safe for them from the start.
Technology that serves childhood rather than dominates it. And as the noble Lord McFall referred to what Stuart Russell had today when he came to the Lords, my Lords, about the power of tech companies, we should heed him. We need a culture of safety, and we need regulation to back it up.
Speaker 34
My Lords, we are most grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing this important debate. Throughout the passage of the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill, my noble friend Baroness Barran successfully argued that social media, mobile phones, and screens in general were largely detrimental to children, a view which we steadfastly hold.
We drawn evidence from teachers, parents, and experts, which concluded that the use of these devices risked worse social skills, worse mental health, and worse results. The government acknowledged that conclusion, and from the start of this academic year, schools should be mobile phone-free environments by default. Regulations will soon be laid to ban under-16s from the negative effects of social media. In both of these measures, there is an implicit acknowledgement that screens in fact do not benefit children, but actually have the potential to cause active harm. And for that reason, it is a grave concern that worrying elements of educational technology remain in the school system.
The government guidance is clear: no mobile phones in schools, with additional guidance stating anything other than this should be by exception only. My Lords, with the presence of EdTech in classrooms, screens are anything but an exception. 11% of pupils now use an individual device in every lesson, whilst nearly 40% use screens in schools every day. The noble Baroness Lady Wheatcroft was quite right when she said this is not the way that relationships are built. The noble Baroness Lady Armstrong referenced this as a nuanced subject, which is right, and to be clear, we are not conflating mobile phones with educational technology.
There are notable exceptions where EdTech helps, for example with special education needs pupils, but the medically proven distractions considered detrimental by use of mobile phones are too often prevalent in the EdTech that is supposed to facilitate learning. Homework apps may prioritize interaction over learning and treat schooling as a reward-based enterprise versus essential learning for self-improvement. And this would be no issue if using screens produced better learning and better results. But the fact is that these devices have proved the exact opposite. Studies have found that students who spend two-thirds of every hour off-task whilst using a laptop in educational settings is a regular occurrence, and that it can take students up to 20 minutes to refocus on a task following a distraction.
This is a well-known fact. And the noble Baroness Lady Wheatcroft highlighted a school which uses no devices for teaching, and again, my Lords, it is a fact that comprehension increases by up to 60% if students read on print rather than digitally. Benefits to mathematical learning only become pronounced in the upper secondary school years after students have developed sufficient foundational knowledge and cognitive maturity to engage productively with the demands of virtual experimentation. Again, this is a fact. I greatly enjoyed the excellent contribution from the noble Baroness Lady Greenfield with her neuroscience background.
And her fellow neuroscientist and best-selling author Dr. Jared Horvath has demonstrated that England and Wales's independent schools, which relatively use the most educational technology, have been declining in PISA scores by 21% per decade, a phenomenon which is actually offset by improving state schools who have unfortunately less access to some of the EdTech. Now, this outcome should not be a surprise to noble Lords.
Whilst no consensus has been reached regarding EdTech's benefits and only 7% of companies have conducted controlled trials, schools have been left with the responsibility of weighing the costs and benefits of procurement in line with their longer-term strategies. The Right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Peterborough argued that we owe it to our educators, and the noble Baroness Lady Murphy quite rightly challenged the Minister in the very same subject. Schools are being left to navigate an uncontrolled experiment whilst EdTech companies have little oversight of their actions. These are big tech companies that the noble Lord Lord Alton correctly flagged, some of whom have larger market capitalisations than the entire GDP of many national economies. The noble Lord Lord McFall reminded us that AI, bizarrely, is less regulated than milk or washing machines.
As a result, as a minimum, the industry must have some kind of centralised oversight. So we would ask the Minister if she will commit to this kind of regulatory scrutiny in line with the noble Lord Lord Tarasenko's request to be measured in months, not years. My Lords, there is rightfully much interest around the benefits that new technologies can bring to learning and work. We are not suggesting that technology cannot be used to improve schooling or children's lives in general, but simply that it must be rigorously tested before it is rolled out and then overseen when it is. Moving on to artificial intelligence, 90% of children already use it for entertainment, whilst 85% use it for schoolwork.
There are undoubtedly benefits of introducing children to new technologies as they enter into a world built by them. But surely unfettered access and use can be incredibly damaging during a child's core development years. Studies show that early protracted exposure to AI can interfere with long-term memory and learning processes. More generally, there is a risk that AI creates a generation of children dependent on outsourcing their thinking, which has been referenced by many noble Lords. Much like educational technology, AI must be most beneficial when its users have acquired the foundational knowledge and maturity needed to deal with that very technology.
The government are implementing an AI strategy in schools as evidence emerges, but we would suggest to the noble Baroness the Minister we need more. The pace of change in this sector is like nothing we have seen before and there are other countries who are acting. The OECD and the European Commission have co-published the AI literacy framework. Over 35 US states now have official AI guidance. My Lords, the question is, when will this government follow their lead?
If I might end on the concerns of AI becoming EdTech by the back door. There are a number of schools already using AI learning assistants in lessons.
It is so incredibly important, as was referenced by the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, to give children the best start in life, and the government's approach must be evidence-based and balanced. The education sector is facing a torrent of new and untested technologies. Some will be beneficial, but others will not, and it is surely absolutely critical to get this right for everyone involved.
Feryal Clark
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Patel, for securing this important debate, and his introductory speech expertly setting the scene through facts and situating children's experience in the context of the rest of their lives. I would also like to thank those across the House for their valuable contributions. There were so many excellent points made, and I will seek to respond to those. For those I do not manage to get to, I will write afterwards. I can reassure your Lordships' House that the government takes this issue incredibly seriously.
There is nothing more important than keeping our children safe, both offline and online. And the Prime Minister has set a clear ambition that the United Kingdom will have the strongest online child safety laws in the world. It was a privilege to hear the excellent contribution of the noble Lord, Lord McFall today, who asked for the Prime Minister's leadership, which indeed he is setting out. Because artificial intelligence, screen usage and social media all pose unique challenges for children today. We know that 99% of 18 to 17-year-olds are online, and Ofcom's latest data suggests nearly three-quarters of children aged 11 to 17 had encountered harmful content in the previous four weeks.
That is why we are determined to put children's wellbeing first and give them the best possible start in life. As we heard from the contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Addington, these technologies can be personally transformative, and there are genuine opportunities, underlined also by the noble Lord, Lord Loomba. We know they have great potential to support children's learning and development when the conditions are right, as my noble friend Baroness Armstrong so rightly highlighted, the importance of digital inclusion, which the government is working on across the whole of government to ensure that that is embedded as a foundation. And specifically in education, that's why through the AI Tutoring Tools Pioneers programme, the government is working with educators, experts and developers to co-create and trial AI tutoring tools. And the 24 million pound EdTech Testbed programme, delivered in partnership with the Education Endowment Foundation, is building the evidence base on what works in education technology, including AI-enabled tools.
But as many noble Lords stressed today, how we adopt education technology in our schools is absolutely critical. Baroness Barran made this point very eloquently, as did the noble Lord, Lord Tarasenko, Baroness Owen, noble Lord, Lord Rees, and my noble friend Lord Brooke. So our focus should be on the quality of technology use. We need sensible guardrails around children's use of technology while recognising that digital tools can improve outcomes when used effectively. Excellent teaching remains at the heart of education.
Technology should enhance and support great teaching, not replace it. Schools should be empowered to use digital and non-digital approaches according to what works best for their pupils.
To help children and young people benefit from EdTech and AI safely in their education, this autumn we are consulting on introducing new safety certification of technology used in early years settings, schools and colleges. This will help educators and parents have the confidence that tools meet clear, trusted safety standards. And a number of noble Lords, including the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Peterborough, the noble Lord Lord Hampton, have stressed the critical role of teachers. DfE has published practical AI support materials for teachers covering opportunities of risk of AI, which was updated in May 2026, and is developing a new digital and data skills pathway for the education workforce, setting expectations for skills needed to use tech, data and AI safely. And the Department for Education's policy paper, Generative Artificial Intelligence in Education, sets out our approach to the opportunities and risks of generative AI in education and provides advice on using AI safely, effectively and responsibly.
These guardrails are incredibly important for the correct adoption of AI technology in our classrooms. A number of noble Lords, including the noble Baroness Baroness Prashar, highlighted the importance of media literacy, and that is why we published A Safe, Informed Digital Nation, the UK's first cross-government media literacy action plan. It sets out a shared framework for action across government to deliver these aims. However, as many noble Lords have highlighted today, the technology poses risks. That's why the government is delivering on the Online Safety Act, placing tough legal duties on platforms to keep their users safe.
My Lords, the strongest protections in the Act are rightly reserved for children. The child safety duties came into effect in July 2025. They require platforms to prevent children accessing pornography, self-harm material, suicide content and eating disorder content. And the Online Safety Act also requires providers to protect children from harmful content, such as violent content and bullying and abusive content, such as that referred to by the noble Baroness Baroness Manningham-Buller. And when something does go wrong, parents and children have simple, clear ways to report it.
The government has given Ofcom the powers to enforce against the Act, and that is our expectation. But we do know that technology and online harms continue to evolve, and we will therefore keep the legislative framework under review, and we will not hesitate to take further action to ensure children are protected online, a reassurance I hope for the noble Lord Lord Nagaraja. Indeed, we have already done so. Earlier this year, the government ran a national consultation on growing up in the online world. It was one of the largest engagement exercises the government has recently conducted, receiving over 116,000 responses.
This included the views of at least 54,000 parents and 14,000 children. As the noble Baroness Baroness Bennett highlighted, it's important to listen to the voices of young people. The results showed an overwhelming demand for action. 90% of parents who responded to the consultation supported an outright ban on social media for the under-16s, and two-thirds of young people agreed that under-16s should not be allowed to use at least some social media platforms. That's why the government has acted.
Like Australia, we are banning social media companies from offering their services to children under 16. However, we are also going further by banning under-16s from live streaming, stopping unknown adults from communicating with children through online services, including gaming services, and switching off harmful features for 16 and 17-year-olds by default.
This will protect children from platforms and online features that create the most harm. The first regulations on the social media ban will be laid before Parliament by the end of this year and the restrictions will come into effect from spring 2027. A number of noble Lords raised the importance of AI chatbots. My noble friend Lord Brooke highlighted the potential for AI chatbots to help young people learn, explore new ideas and find information. However, as Lord Alton highlighted, there are risks which we are acutely aware of.
They can expose children to harmful content or encourage unhealthy reliance on technology. That is why Britain will become the first country in the world to ban chatbots that offer sexualised content to under-18s. We will restrict this functionality on general purpose chatbots too. And the government has also committed to introducing mandatory breaks in AI chatbot use by under-18s to encourage healthier online habits. We've also taken a delegated power in the Crime and Policing Act to bring currently unregulated AI chatbot services within the scope of the Online Safety Act's illegal content duties.
This is a rapidly developing area, so where new evidence of chatbot harms does emerge, the government will not hesitate to take further action where necessary to protect children. To the question asked by the noble Lord Lord Clement-Jones on the commitment the government has made to be the first country in the world where it's impossible for children to take, share or view nudity online. Last month we announced this government will introduce legislation requiring tech companies to strengthen protections on devices and platforms and the government is working to introduce it as soon as possible. My Lords, we have also heard about the impact of screen use on children. And Baroness Murphy highlighted the importance of parents in this picture.
We know that long periods of time spent on screens can get in the way of activities critical for development such as sleep, physical activity, creative play and interaction with parents. The government recognises the need to balance embracing technology with promoting the health and development of younger children. That's why the government has published advice on screen use for parents of children aged 0 to 5 on the Best Start in Life website. This offers practical, non-judgmental support to help families balance screen use with other activities. It's underpinned by the findings of an expert panel led by Professor Russell Viner and the Children's Commissioner, Dame Rachel de Souza.
Following the guidance for under-5s, DHSC is now working with DfE to develop practical advice for parents and carers of 5 to 18-year-olds. A number of noble Lords highlighted the importance of the offline world and how we cultivate the right atmosphere for children to grow offline, including the noble Lord Lord Hampton, Baroness Greenfield, Baroness Prashar and again Baroness Bennett. What type of society are we building? We are working across government to ensure that children and young people have access to safe online spaces.
Specifically through Youth Matters, your National Youth Strategy, the government is investing more than 500 million pounds to ensure all young people have somewhere to go, something to do and someone to talk to. This includes a 450 million pound Youth Matters Fund to deliver significant long-term change in youth provision in the most underserved areas of England. My Lords, as I said at the outset, there is nothing more important than keeping our children safe. That is why the government is delivering on the Online Safety Act and building on it where necessary to children, to protect children online. In addition, where there is evidence, the government has not and will not hesitate to go further.
We will continue to listen to those making contributions in this House, to reports such as those referenced today, to reports such as that cited by the noble Lord Lord Alton of the JCHR. This is how we will deliver our ambition for the UK to be a world leader, keeping children safe and providing them with the protections and support that they need in an increasingly online world. Thank you.
Narendra Patel
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness the Minister for her response. I think she may not have had the opportunity to pick up some of the points that were made, particularly about developing an AI policy, either through commission or through different other routes, and maybe she can reflect on that again. There were some important points made about how the schools may have an important role, both developing material for the school by the school, and that may be as a point that may benefit particularly vulnerable children or who have greater demands on using, who are better able to participate in educational activities if there were developments made for them to better use of the technology available. So I think there were lots of important points made about how the government can have a bigger role, not just about in regulation, which is important, and we should address that issue, and I'm pleased to hear the Minister refer to the more legislation about controlling the tech industry to have responsibility of some of the issues that were raised that are detrimental to the development of the children, including ability to migrate from a responsible games or gaming platforms to other dark network. They should not be allowed to do that.
So there are issues about regulation that the Minister addressed and I'm glad to hear that more regulation may be required and the government is keeping an eye on it. But there were in the debate, there were opportunities raised to use AI to benefit the children, although much of the discussion today, including mine, focused on the harm that it is creating. So I hope we might return to that and hope the government Minister might reflect on that. Now it's customary, my Lords, to thank all the noble Lords who took part in the debate today. I'm not doing so because it's customary.
I'm doing so because I sincerely mean to thank all the noble Lords who took part today and their contributions were exemplary. It was a well thought out deliberaty. And I'm glad the teacher is back, Lord McFall, who spent a lot of his time teaching, is back and I'm glad, I'm delighted for his contribution. My Lord, I beg to withdraw motion.
Speaker 109
The question is this motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it.
Speaker 113
My Lords, we'll just have a moment before the next item for people to regroup. If noble Lords could leave quickly and quietly, that would be much appreciated, and we will go on to the next business. Okay. Order. If noble Lords could just leave quickly and quietly, or sit down, alternatively.
Speaker 110
Okay. Right, we now come to the next business, which is Question for Short Debate: Age of consent for puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, Baroness Deech.
Lynn Ruth Deech
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper. I declare an interest as a former chair of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, where I witnessed the pain of those whose fertility was impaired. This question is not about transgender identity of adults. Anyone who turns it into a debate about that is distracting from the issue. It's about very young children being deemed capable of assenting to medical interventions whose effects and risks they cannot understand.
Across UK law, the age at which a young person is deemed capable of consenting to significant activities is far from uniform. At 16, one may consent to sexual activity, leave home, work, and join the armed forces with parental permission. Under that age, we just listened to a very solid debate about the harm that could be caused to young children by social media. At 17, one may drive. At 18, one may serve on a jury, vote at the moment, buy alcohol, and enter contracts.
This reflects the law's recognition that maturity develops unevenly, but it also exposes a striking inconsistency. We prohibit young people from making irreversible decisions in almost every other dimension until adulthood, while in the Pathways trial of puberty blockers, we'll be permitting exceptionally young children to assent to powerful drugs whose effects they cannot grasp. How does the government reconcile the exceptionally young ages for this trial? Parliament frequently makes decisions about medical limits: screening, assisted dying, affordability of new drugs, abortion regulation, and so on. So it's no answer to say, leave it to the clinicians.
I suggest that a child does not have the legal competence to give effective consent to life-changing medical interventions. The evidence base shows how great the risks are to an individual child, who should not be used as a test case for future general medical advances. Views on this trial have fluctuated, and it's reported that certain people opposed to it were removed from involvement. Following consultation this year, NHS England confirmed that MAF hormones will no longer be routinely commissioned or prescribed for under-18s. This aligns with the indefinite 2024 ban on puberty blockers, which will be reviewed in 2027.
Even 16 is safer than younger ages because more physical development has occurred. The pathways trial is an outlier. It allows enrolment of children as young as 11 and 12. The central issue is consent. We have something in law called Gillick competence, which means that under-16s may consent if they demonstrate sufficient maturity and understanding.
I urge the government not to reduce age limits.
The Gillick case arose from a case about contraceptive advice, not irreversible medical interventions. So the key question is, can a pre-pubescent child comprehend the long-term effects of puberty blockers or hormones? Does the minister really believe that meaningful understanding is possible at that age? The findings from the Cass Review and others show risks: bone health deficit, fertility, pregnancy and offspring impacts, sexual function impairment, effects on brain maturation, cardiovascular and haematological risks. And the additional safeguards that were added to pathways acknowledge these risks; they don't remove the irreversibility.
We all have the greatest respect for the noble lady, Lady Cass, whose pioneering work raised the dangers of puberty blockers. It will be argued in this debate that there are special reasons for allowing the trial at such a young age, which she has put forward. One is to turn children away from illegally accessing these drugs. But it's very unlikely that this relatively small trial with selected children will lead them to believe that they can access these drugs legally. Possible harm reduction is not an aim of the trial and there'll be no evidence that this is the outcome.
Another argument is the plight of distressed children living in stealth. But unless they stay at home and out of school, a child who presents as a member of the other gender or who has delayed puberty is likely to be highly visible at school one way or the other and still stressed. Moreover, there is no comparator trial save a delay of 12 months. We won't find out if children who are denied or given these drugs are in better shape in say five or 10 years' time. Only retrospective data analysis can tell us that.
A useful comparator would be holistic psychosocial support. Rather than a trial, there should be follow-ups on patients who've already taken these drugs here and abroad, a review of the regulation and the robustness of diagnosis. May we be told how clinicians are going to test the child's understanding of what may happen, and how will they distinguish the parents' understandable wish to relieve the child's distress, which is a different concept from the child's own assent? If this trial goes ahead, and we don't know whether it's started, will the government undertake never to permit another trial on any children under 18 or even 16? Will there be sufficient data collection, including withdrawal and of course any ill effects?
May we be assured that parents will not be punished or pressured into giving their consent? Why can't this trial be replaced by tracking past use of puberty blocking? The Gender Recognition (Disclosure of Information) (England) Order came into force in March. It will allow the disclosure of formerly protected information and facilitate a retrospective observational study tracking health outcomes of roughly 9,000 adults who were referred as children to the former Gender Identity Development Service at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust. Fortunately, the NHS has now moved youth gender services away from medical intervention and towards holistic psychological and psychosocial support in line with the Cass Review.
I hope the Minister will affirm that this is the future model and first resort for all young people presenting with gender dysphoria. There's also concern about overdiagnosis given the sharp rise in recent years and parallels with other mental health diagnostic trends. A study from the University of York showed that diagnoses of gender dysphoria had increased from one in 60,000 teenagers in 2011 to one in 1,200 ten years later, a rise too astonishing to be taken at face value. My final question, bearing in mind the deluge of emails I've had from members of the public, what assessment has the government made of the appropriate age at which a young person can understand and consent to puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones?
Speaker 29
My Lords, before we continue with this question for short debate, I want to remind all noble Lords that the advisory speaking time is five minutes, and I urge noble Lords to keep within that limit so that the debate can conclude within the time allowed without cutting short the Minister's remarks, who I know noble Lords will be very keen to hear from at the debate's conclusion.
Robert Winston
My Lords, it's always a pleasure to speak after noble lady Baroness Deech, even when I disagree with her inevitably, I think that happens all the time unfortunately, much to my embarrassment. And like her, I welcome greatly Baroness Cass to speak on this subject as well, of which she is so expert. I'm afraid unlike her, I'm not prepared to say we don't discuss anything other than gender dysphoria. It's too, in fact, we, it's, it's not just the trials of the drugs. We have to understand also that there's some issues here which are very, very common to in vitro fertilization.
The commonest of course being that with in vitro fertilization, we are increasingly treating patients without any diagnosis of what the cause of the infertility is. And that may be the problem here with a trial like this, and I'm sure that Baroness Cass will, will identify and address that problem because it is a real issue. But I think for me, what I would like to suggest is some of the research we're not doing is really, really worth doing and unfortunately not getting funded. One of the areas which I've already discussed or mentioned to my noble friend the Minister is the issue of epigenetics. Now what's interesting is that there are certain reasons for believing that epigenetics might be very, very relevant in this situation.
I first heard of this, not as called as epigenetics when I was lecturing in Australia in, in Melbourne in, in the late 70s, when I came across a consultant who said he'd see, he'd seen so many patients, it was common by the way, it was common, who were requesting gender change or had some form of dysphoria. And he said what was interesting to him was that when he went through the medical records of the obstetric cases, he found some anomalies such as they had certainly been exposed to unusual stress in some cases or other issues which were might be related to the environment in which the mother was. I've no idea whether that went on, the man is now dead, I would love to have gone to see that, but it was certainly not until about 1999 when Lars Bygren published his first paper on the key issue of what happens to children as they grow up following different exposures to different environments that we suddenly woke up.
These things were often sex-linked by the way, which is quite interesting. And it turns out that some of the issues here are true in transgender as well. It is also a sex-linked issue. And of course many of these children may have some suggestions of autistic autism or certainly some form, I don't want to call it mental ill health, but certainly differences or disorders which we would not accept as being quite usual. On a spectrum is what is often said.
And I think that's a very reasonable way of looking at it. But I need to explain epigenetics to make this understood. I want you to consider the question this: my coat, C-O-A-T, is grey. Let's suppose that's written in the alphabet of the DNA. That could be expressed in two ways: my coat is grey spelled with G-R-A-Y or G-R-E-Y.
It's not important. It works both ways. But a mutation would be if that C was changed into a G: my goat is grey. That's a mutation. Now I'm not suggesting this is a mutation, but there are other things which we now know affect the DNA and how it works.
For example, if you put my coat is grey in let's say quotation marks, "my coat is grey", that changes it. Or for example, something that is not the actual letters of the DNA, but it's the environment in which it's written. Or you put an exclamation mark or a question mark after that question. You end up with a total possibility of the meaning being changed. And I think there's a possibility that is happening increasingly.
We have animal evidence which is very, very, very strong. And we also have evidence both from Canada and in both actually McGill and also in Toronto which shows that this might be in humans and actually could be to some extent heritable. This is not of course gender dysphoria, that is in general troubles of this sort generally. So I would suggest to the House, I don't have an answer to the question which is being asked in this debate, but I do think we need to really consider how we can, if we can, use drugs for different causes which are not in fact a medical condition. And the problem really is how do we define transgender and how we deal with that.
And that's why I really am so pleased that Baroness Cass is here to answer those questions because I think it will be something that we all want to discuss at great length. Because we must have trials if we're going to get anywhere. The problem is how do we do this without damaging children? And I agree completely with Baroness Deech that follow-up is something that we must do with transgender. We've not done it at all.
That has to happen.
Speaker 112
My Lords, government's first duty is to protect its citizens from harm. This government is failing in that duty of care for our children. Two years ago, during a debate regarding the use of puberty blockers, I reminded the House that I had represented Her Majesty's opposition through the passage of the Gender Recognition Bill. That was 23 years ago. That bill had been scrutinized in draft form by the Joint Committee on Human Rights and was steered through your Lordships' House by the then minister Lord Adonis.
I had been reassured repeatedly that gender dysphoria affected a tiny number of people in the UK, 5,000 at the very most. There was no indication, research or medical evidence that this cohort would grow. 23 years on and we're facing the most appalling situation whereby this government thinks it's okay to use young children in random clinical trials, experiments, that may and probably will have a lasting and possibly irreversible and possibly seriously harmful physical and or mental effect upon some or all of those children. My Lords, there is no scientific evidence to back this experiment up.
I have huge respect for the minister, who is in a very difficult position. I have considered with care her and other responses to the noble Baroness Lady Deech's recent oral question in your Lordships' House on this subject dated 25th of June 2026, and I find them shocking and revealing. The minister in her initial response stated with regard to the Pathways trial, and I quote, "Eligibility is tightly controlled, it requires parental explicit consent, a minimum two-year gender incongruence diagnosis, psychosocial support, and NHS multi-disciplinary team approval, as well as participant understanding of the risks and benefits, physical and mental stability, and compliance with state safeguarding requirements." With respect, this is verbal nonsense designed to mask the reality, my Lords. Where and what are the safeguards that should govern any administration of these drugs to children?
Doesn't this make a mockery of safeguarding? Seriously, 11 and 12-year-old participants understanding the risks? How can a pre-pubescent child comprehend the long-term effects of puberty blockers or hormones? And what about legal competence? There is also in the answers to the noble Baroness Lady Deech's question a clear message from the government benches that this is, quote, "not political."
Why is that, my Lords? This indicates to me that the government are keen to ensure that this experimenting with young children's lives is seen as a cross-party exercise. Oh, and includes the bishops. So when it goes wrong, we can all share the blame. Wrong, wrong.
In addition, I was shocked to read the contribution from the noble Lord Lord Cashman that, and I quote, "The only thing that matters in this instance is the right of the child to the best and most appropriate treatment." My Lords, given the possible effects of these drugs, we defer to the right of a child aged 11 or 12? This is madness. The noble Lord Lord Scriven suggested that, quote, "getting an evidence-gathering trial underway would be an effective way to undermine unmonitored and unregulated drugs markets." So, my Lords, just because this country is now almost entirely lawless, with scant enforcement, let's experiment on our children rather than tackle the unregulated, i.e. illegal, drugs market.
The Right Reverend Prelate, the Bishop of Manchester, said in effect that experimenting with our children is a handy way of removing the culture wars. Well-meant, I'm sure, but all this suggests to me that it does help to explain the current state of the Church of England. I put it to the minister, who I repeat, I really do respect, that when in one of her answers she said, "It's important to have a cool head," the noble lady is revealing that she is just as apprehensive as many thousands of others who cannot understand the mindset of those pushing this. Turning briefly to those selected for the so-called trials, will the minister tell us, given the government's obsession with diversity, equality and inclusion, whether participants include children from different ethnic and religious groups, plus maybe one or two who are directly related to members of this government? How does it go?
The evil that men do lives after them. My Lords, I'll end this as I did last time I spoke on the subject, as a mother, a grandmother and a peer. I urge the government to think again and stop this nightmare.
Hilary Cass
My Lords, I declare my interest as being Cass of the Cass Review and an independent advisor to DHSC. As my noble friend has said, the age at which under-16-year-olds can consent to medical intervention is determined by Gillick competence, and specifically in relation to puberty blockers this issue has been tested through the courts through Bell versus Tavistock.
The original judgment was overturned on appeal because the court held that it was wrong to try and establish age-based criteria for competence, which must instead be assessed case by case in accordance with Gillick principles. And as you've already heard, because this is part of an approved research trial, children can't consent anyway, they assent and parents consent. And so with all due respect to the Minister, the only basis on which His Majesty's Government can take a view on the question would be if they wanted to challenge the legal judgment or seek to change the law. As you've also heard, routine commissioning of masculinising and feminising hormones is currently suspended, so that really is probably as far as one can go on the core question itself. But I do understand the strength of feeling in the House, and so I will say a little about the children's and young people's gender services and how they're operating.
The service includes currently five of the UK's specialist children's hospitals and more centres are operating soon. It's staffed by some of the country's most experienced professionals in children's physical and mental health, and the chair of the network is a past president of RCPCH. So to be absolutely clear, this is not a service driven by ideology. About 1600 children and young people have been seen and they've got a very wide range of problems including depression, separation anxiety, social phobia, eating disorders and neurodiversity. And many of them have quite striking physical symptoms including pain, impaired mobility and functional impairment that actually impacts on their ability to attend school, interact with peers and engage in normal physical activities.
For some families, there've been stressors such as domestic violence, parental mental health problems or parental death. A sizeable minority of the patients are open to the safeguarding team, for example because they've suffered physical or sexual abuse, online grooming or exploitation, or because they're taking a range of unregulated medicines and hormones. So the clinical team are providing a very wide range of therapeutic interventions aimed at improving physical and mental health and functional well-being. And sometimes just addressing general health and nutrition, getting young people out of their bedroom and back into school and engaged with peers is all that is needed for their gender distress to largely resolve and for them to re-engage with typical life and development and experience. I should say that we are following up all of those children, or as many as will agree to consent, who do not get any medical pathway, because one of the things I could not find out during my review because they didn't have the data is what happens to the children and young people who did not go on a hormone pathway.
Less than 20 patients at this point out of that 1600 are even in the early stages of being considered for enrolment in the puberty blocker trial. And as I reported previously, they're typically young people who've been socially transitioned since early childhood, and after 18 months of therapy, they still have absolutely no sense or concept of living in their biological gender. Decisions are taken after a really extensive assessment and thorough multi-disciplinary review guided by considerations of the young person's best interests. In other words, the clinicians have to feel that the risks of not enrolling them in the trial well outweigh the risks of enrolling them. I should say in response to my noble friend's remarks that we do not know of any definite irreversible effect of puberty blockers at this time, and that is the whole point of the trial, but these children are going to be extremely tightly monitored.
The commitment is that they will only be allowed to be on them for two years in the first instance, with no automatic assumption that they will progress to masculinising or feminising hormones without further discussion and a further detailed assessment. And the other commitment is that all the time that they are on the puberty blockers, they are locked into two years' further ongoing therapy within the service. And for me, that has to be better than going out and getting some testosterone at the gym instead. So what I would say is that the combined expertise in child health, mental health, safeguarding, clinical ethics, and best interest decision-making within these specialist teams far exceeds that available to either House, and for that reason, I have full confidence in their clinical judgments. I apologize to Lord Winston that I don't have the answers on epigenetics.
David Frost
My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble lady Baroness Cass on any subject, actually, but of course particularly on this one. And I'm grateful to the noble Baroness, Baroness Teach, for securing this very important debate. Now, my Lords, I haven't spoken much about this subject in public, but I have followed it closely and I do feel strongly about it. And I wanted to speak today because I honestly, I simply fail to understand the logic behind what is going on and what we are allowing to proceed. Now, I support what the government has done so far on this general issue: the bans, the indefinite pauses on puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones.
And I think the government deserves credit for this, particularly given the strongly held opposition from a narrow group of their own supporters on this subject. But what I can't quite follow, and I've learned that many other people can't really follow either, is what's happening now. The government has judged these drugs too uncertain to give children in the ordinary way of things, but is now prepared to support giving them to 11- and 12-year-olds as an experiment. We know the MHRA as a regulator had misgivings about this and suggested a minimum age of 14—still too low in my view—but somehow it has been persuaded to change its mind and thinks 11 or 12 is okay. And it's not clear entirely why, and perhaps the Minister could shed some light on that when speaking.
But, my Lords, one must ask why this trial is necessary at all. As far as I can see, the only reason you might want to do it is to learn whether you might one day be able to administer such medicines to children who feel gender dysphoria—for of course we do already use them in other extremely limited circumstances. And if we don't ever wish to do that, then why would we want the trial? I recognize others may not share my view, but personally, because of my own convictions about the nature of reality and sexual difference, I can't imagine circumstances in which we would ever want to do this. And the view that we might rests on the much-disputed premise that a child can have a gender at odds with his or her sex.
And if so, it's the body rather than the belief that should change. And I'm afraid I simply don't accept that. I know others will, but I don't. And by the way, I worry that if the government's conversion practices bill ever made it into law, what I've just said would become quite a risky thing to say in quite a lot of circumstances.
Now, gender dysphoria clearly is a real thing, and children who suffer from it deserve all kinds of psychological and social support, the best we can possibly give. But by crediting the belief that in certain circumstances the body should change to reflect the psychology, we surely make dealing with it harder, not easier, because it appears to offer a way out. So, my Lords, I don't accept the logic behind the trial at all. I just don't understand it. Now, I recognize others, as I've said, may take a different view on the nature of gender and sex differentiation.
We live in a free society, of course. But it's a free society for adults, and we have a duty to protect children. In the debate we've just had, we heard the government saying it was banning chat box, sexualized chat bots for children under 18, presumably because they thought children under 18 can't deal with that sort of content. Surely, therefore, we must protect children from irreversible medical treatment decided at an age at which no reasonable person could think they could reasonably consent, even if it is in a trial. And I don't see how we can in conscience proceed with such a trial on 11-year-olds.
My Lords, I experienced some of the COVID pandemic from the inside of government, more as an observer than a participant. But I'm afraid I learned from that period that sometimes the cleverest scientists and the most highly respected medical authorities could sometimes not see the wood for the trees and ended up supporting things that were, I think, indefensible. And I think you need to stick to principles sometimes. And I think one of my principles on this is that it is wrong to administer irreversible treatments to 11 and 12-year-olds. I find it shocking and disgraceful, to be honest, that we can do it, and it should be opposed in every way possible.
Speaker 106
My Lords, I approach this topic from the view of someone who worked for two years when I was a trainee psychiatrist in a transsexual clinic for adults at University College Hospital. In those days, and I am going back 45 years, men and women came to seek help, usually as confirmed transsexuals, in those days mostly men wishing to be women, slight reverse nowadays in the desire to change. They had received no help of any kind from childhood. So very muscular men with large Adam's apples and deep voices struggled to manage in society or went abroad to seek surgical help to transform themselves into a better facsimile of a woman, with unpredictable consequences and sometimes horrendous outcomes. Now, like many people, and I suspect I was in those days of the Lord Frost school of approach to these problems, I was very young, I thought to myself, well, these people are deluded, why on earth are we colluding with this stuff?
But I gradually came to the conclusion that my task as a psychiatrist was to try to help all individuals to feel more at ease in their own skin, to live the life that helped them to feel more content and at one with society, and for lifelong transsexuals, for whom that help must be given before puberty.
I've usually been feeling this way since they were age three or four, when they could really think back to when their gender identity was formed. How and when should medical interventions be proffered therefore, if it is to be given before puberty? But if you don't, the outcome can be quite horrendous in terms of lifetime achievements for these people. Now the noble Baroness Cass's review of the special problems posed by gender dysphoria, which is now I think two years ago since it was published, has been enormously helpful and influential in ensuring that unregulated prescriptions ceased. Prescription of puberty blockers and other medications only takes part within a carefully regulated research framework with the aim of establishing better guidance.
And I would remind people that we do actually do trials of drugs on children in very many walks of life, often in quite serious, life-threatening disorders and others, when we feel it'll be helpful. And we do it with the children's assent when it's been explained, but with parental consent. And it's under those, under those terms that proposals for research are happening at the moment. And I personally want to pay tribute to Lady Cass's determination to stick to her guns in the face of much upset by the trans activist world on one hand, and those who do not wish to see any interventions before an adolescent can fully understand and make their own decisions. My own view is that she's got the balance right.
These children need a holistic approach to treatment, as we've already pressed, a strong up-to-date medical evidence. But it often has lots of other problems that need to be looked at. And if you do look at those problems in detail, you will end up with a very small group of people who need this kind of intervention. We know that drugs, that children and their parents will get drugs from unregulated sources if we don't make progress in establishing appropriate routes. So I do support the pathways research programme because it has such a broad look at all the aspects of the impact of these drugs, not just the impact on, but also checks on bone density, brain function, fertility and the longer-term outcomes.
We know that very many of these people will turn out eventually to be homosexual as men and women. Very few will remain transsexual all their lives, but it's those that we need to concentrate on. Now, many of these children, as I said, have struggled for a long time to come up to, up to speed with their problems, but really can't do it without more help. And I think to leave them without any sort of support for their gender dysphoria when you know that they are confirmed transsexuals really does suggest that you're turning them away and saying, no, you're deluded, we won't help. I don't think we can do that as a caring society.
We need to recognise and support them in what they wish to do.
Speaker 116
I would like to thank Baroness Deech for tabling this very important debate that concerns children and the age at which those trials should be undertaken. I mean, how can an 11-year-old child understand the consequences of interrupting their own puberty, particularly when adults still lack reliable evidence about the long-term consequences? As we know, the Cass review concluded that the evidence supporting puberty blockers was sorely lacking and recommended their use only within a formal clinical trial. NHS England subsequently ended their routine use.
As the noble lord, Lord Frost mentioned, in February, the pathways trial was paused following serious concern from the MHRA, including its recommendation that eligibility should be restricted to those aged 14 and over. Yet, the revised protocol permits children as young as 11 to receive puberty blockers. Can the minister explain what new evidence justified lowering the minimum age from 14 to 11 and 12? And what independent scrutiny preceded that decision? It is particularly troubling to note that the original committee reportedly met only three times, with just three members attending its final meeting.
My lords, the need for better evidence cannot, in itself, justify exposing children to treatment whose long-term effects are uncertain and may be irreversible. Rather than using children as guinea pigs, should we not first examine existing evidence of those who have regretted their treatment, including Keira Bell and Sinead Watson? 11-year-old girls and 12-year-old boys are barely out of primary school. We recognize that their capacity to assess long-term consequences is still developing. Under-18s cannot purchase alcohol or marry, even with parental consent.
I'm also very concerned about children in care and those with autism or other mental difficulties. Yet children in care are eligible for the trial. Who will independently represent their interest? Children under 16 cannot themselves give legal consent to participate in this medical trial. A parent or legal representative must consent on their behalf.
But parents faced with a desperately unhappy child may feel enormous pressure to act. How will the trial ensure that consent is genuinely informed and each child's understanding is properly assessed? Has recruitment begun? Will every participant receive thorough psychological assessment and continuing support? Above all, how does the government reconcile the participation of children so young with its duty to protect them from harm?
Is there not a danger that the state's pursuit of scientific research is taking precedence over its duty to protect children? Are we really prepared to place 220 children in a trial without being able to answer the most basic question: at what age can a child understand and consent to medical intervention that may shape the rest of their lives? It was mentioned that children do participate in clinical trials, but these are often children who have cancer, something which is one way and maybe the consent is quite different to participating in an experiment.
I therefore ask the Minister directly: why 11 and 12-year-olds? What evidence justifies those ages and how can the government confidently say that these children are being protected rather than exposed to risk they are too young to understand? My Lords, their welfare must come first, not simply during the trial but throughout their childhood and in their adult life.
Speaker 117
This debate takes place in the context of two very well-funded campaigns. There are two groups of people. There's one group of people who do not believe that trans people exist. There is another group of people who believe that trans people might exist, but that all of them, every one of them, pose such a threat and danger to the rest of us that they have to be segregated. The thing on which those two different campaign groups unite is a constant campaigning to make the lives of trans people impossible in a series of different small actions.
We see it every day in our newspapers and on the BBC, different aspects of making life difficult, blaming trans people for things. There is a third group of people to which I belong, which is one that says that believes that trans people are human beings, that they have the same rights as anybody else, that they should be treated and judged just as anybody else is. And that pertains to healthcare as much as anything else. When I was preparing for this debate, I went back to, I looked in my inbox and I found a very helpful email from the noble Baroness, Baroness Cass, following Baroness Deech's last attempt to raise this matter. She circulated a paper to us, which is quite a lengthy, short but very full paper, full of detail, which answers every single one of the questions which has been put in this debate.
Speaker 119
Shame that people haven't bothered to read it. It sets out in much more detail than Baroness Cass did today all of the safeguards which are in this research and why they're there and why they're and why they're needed. I happen to believe, I happen to have listened to what the Baroness Cass has said and I have come round to understanding her point of view. I didn't necessarily to begin with, but I do now. And I do, I do echo the words of those who said that she deserves to be commended for what she is putting in place.
Speaker 117
What she's putting in place is evidence-based scientific research, not prejudice, not ideology, not a set of, as a set of researchers going off on some kind of tangent to experiment on children. It's setting out to answer that question, those questions that we don't know. I don't understand gender dysphoria. I've never experienced it. I know people who do, who have.
Speaker 118
I hear them describe it. I hear them describe the terrible consequences on their lives. And I realize that they have a problem which medicine has tried for a very long time to deal with in kind and ethical ways. Baroness Cass is simply part of that ongoing tradition. I very much agree that it's wrong to turn our backs on people who are in some kind of mental distress, although I very much regret the repeated use of terms such as mental distress to cover all trans people.
I can remember as a young gay person that's what they said about me. They were wrong. And this campaign is so damaging and so regressive. And it falls to people in your lordship's house to stand up for stand up for this visible minority because they're just the first ones to be in the firing line. The rest of us are going to be there soon.
Because what this is fundamentally all about is it's a big attack on human rights by very very well-funded campaigns which are most of which originate in the United States. I would simply wish to ask Baroness Merron one question. Does she agree with Baroness Cass that withholding of treatment is not a neutral act? And withholding of treatment which might solve a medical problem is not something that we would routinely consider for any other group of people in the whole of medicine. And therefore does she agree with me that it is important that having set this process up the government shields this research from the never-ending political attacks ideological attacks on it and that we let the scientists and the medics get on with a very very important very detailed very serious program of work which is going to help some people who some of us in this place clearly don't like but some of us believe need and require our support.
Speaker 112
My lords before the noble lady sits down could I ask her to accept that those of us who've already spoken against these trials for young children we are not against trans people. If I'd had another minute to be able to speak I would have explained that one of my earliest experiences was a deep and longing to understand and understand what was happening with somebody who was called James Morris who became Jan Morris. And when I've spoken in previous debates on this I've spoken of my thorough respect for him. Will the noble lady and him and other like others like him who have been in a sort of medical and physical emotional hell until they've gone through the process to change their sex and I admire people like him and others. So will the noble baroness accept that we're not part of some political campaign.
Speaker 29
I'm going to suggest that noble lords we move to Baroness Cash. I'm afraid Baroness Barkover it's not really proper to be intervening at that moment.
Joanne Cash
My lords I too am very grateful to the noble baroness Lady Deech for securing this debate. Because what her debate focuses on the age of consent there is limited amount on that to be added to what has been said by those who've spoken ahead of me. But your debate her debate does draw attention to an ongoing medical scandal of our times which is the consent to drugs around which we have no evidence of safety. The noble lady Baroness Cass for whom I have the highest of regard and esteem and with whom I've discussed this subject with gratitude on multiple occasions. And I we disagree about the pathways puberty blockers trial.
We agree on almost everything else. And I think the nub of the debate lies there. What I'm hearing in the chamber today is real concern about the age of children who are embarking on life-changing and possibly irreversible changes to their physical bodies to the brain to their bones to their IQ to their fertility.
We just don't know whether the changes caused by use of puberty blockers in young people can be reversed. And I hope I've read the review, the famous Cass Review, correctly. I hope so, because I've read it several times. But when the noble Baroness refers to not withholding treatment, my understanding of that is that she means exploratory treatment, ensuring that the multiple reasons why children present in distress about their gender are fully explored and that they are given opportunity to have the correct therapies and treatments for any of those issues. There are comorbidities: autism, mental health conditions, many children in care, disproportionate numbers presenting with gender distress.
But left alone, as the Cass Review stated, most childhood gender distress resolves. In the largest follow-up study of 139 boys, most desisted and a high proportion grew up to be gay or bisexual. Blockers, puberty blockers, can prevent the child from processing their issues and their reasons. And in the Tavistock's own study, children embarked on puberty blockers went on to cross-sex hormones at a rate of 98%, almost the inverse of the resolution that takes place if puberty blockers aren't taken. So we can't set a safe age because no one has followed up on these young people.
And I appreciate and acknowledge that that is also something that the noble Baroness Lady Cass has highlighted and drawn attention to. We've also seen an independent investigation by Professor Ellis into the Wellbeing Clinic in Brighton, examining 78 children, 51 aged 16 and under given cross-sex hormones, four started at 12, four at 13. More than two-thirds, 53 of 78, had possible neurodevelopmental conditions. Capacity to consent was confirmed in only six cases out of 78. 22 children prescribed without ever being seen face-to-face.
36 received prescriptions at their first appointment. That is not treatment. That is a scandal. 23 different prescribers were involved and one child lived more than 480 miles away. The NHS and the GMC were warned from at least 2020.
They failed to act. Now the investigation is meant to have a second phase to review those children who are now adults, but that phase is on hold. And those young adults matter just as much. That data, the follow-up data, was withheld from the Cass Review when they were trying to follow up on the children who'd been treated at an earlier stage. The law was changed for that linkage, that data linkage study, to be provided and it still has not been.
The law needs to compel it to be disclosed so we truly can establish what happens to these young people after these treatments. The Levy Review proposes moving more adult prescribing into GP-led services. That's the Wellbeing model and it shouldn't happen. And we need to understand the scandal of this Wild West of medical treatment without meaningful consent before any further instances can take place, because there will be a cost to the NHS, as in the United States, where legal claims against the clinicians and the hospitals are now being brought.
And so I use this opportunity to urge the government to commission an independent inquiry into gender-related prescribing in primary care and in adult clinics with a focus on those under 25.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I congratulate the noble lady Baroness Deech for securing this debate today and airing the issues which clearly do need airing. And I do thank all noble Lords for their contributions. There is probably only one thing that unites all the contributions, if I might say, and that is concern for the safety and wellbeing of children and young people. There is, of course, considerable difference amongst contributors. So let me start by making it clear that the government policy on care for children and young people with gender incongruence is underpinned by the absolute need to ensure that they receive safe care based on evidence, and that is what will always drive us.
And that is why we are implementing the Cass Review. And I'm most grateful to the noble lady Baroness Cass, not just for conducting the review, but for her continued work and indeed for her contribution today, which in many ways has saved me something of a job as she's set out the facts, as she did when she previously wrote to all noble Lords. So I won't repeat a number of those points. But we are implementing the Cass Review. We are transforming children and young people's gender services.
And these services, including the four new services that are operating with plans for provision in every region of England by the end of 27-28, they provide a holistic model of care with a focus on psychosocial support, which the noble lady Baroness Deech asked about. And the specification in terms of services for these services is quite clear that medical intervention is not the standard approach to care. And if we look back to March 2024, NHS England issued a clinical policy which set out that puberty-suppressing hormones are not available for routine commissioning within these gender services. And this followed a number of evidence reviews that did not identify good enough evidence about safety risks, benefits, and outcomes. The Cass Review, which was commissioned under the previous government, was published in April 2024.
That also found insufficient evidence. The then Health Secretary Victoria Atkins welcomed the review and committed to implementing its recommendations. There was an introduction of an emergency order restricting the private sale and supply of puberty-suppressing hormones for gender incongruence. And I believe the noble Lord Lord Frost welcomed that action, as indeed I do, not least because this government picked this up and extended the restrictions and made them indefinite from January 2025, a decision I might remind your Lordships' House was upheld in the High Court when it was challenged. The decision in respect of implementing recommendations and also the response on puberty-suppressing hormones was taken with great care.
It was informed by a wide range of evidence, including a report from the Independent Commission on Human Medicines, which indicated that young people with gender incongruence and dysphoria were uniquely being exposed to potential safety risks. And I listened closely to all the contributions. The noble lady Baroness Murphy, I believe, set out why doing nothing is not a neutral option, as referred to by the noble lady Baroness Barker. And if I might put it in my own non-medical language, the issue does not go away by doing nothing. So, with regard to the Pathways study, which a number of noble lords have referred to, the Cass Review did draw that attention to the fact we don't have evidence, we need better evidence.
We need to be able to inform clinical decisions with, and I will reuse my words, I will look at the Baroness, the noble lady Baroness Buscombe, with a cool head. And it will also, I hope, the evidence inform the decisions made by children and their families. So NHS England and DHSC, through the National Institute of Health and Care Research, worked to design and fund a research program. It includes a regularly updated systemic review of available research evidence and, I would say to the noble lady Baroness Deech, a data linkage service study, not an either-or but both, as well as the Pathways study. The trial has been approved by the Health Research Authority and the MHRA.
We are talking, I might add, about a trial involving a small number of children and young people who are already receiving the support of NHS gender services. And to the noble lady Baroness Deech, the Pathways trial entry age, something also raised by the noble lady Baroness Meyer, has been reviewed by the MHRA and the study sponsor. And that has resulted in a minimum age of trial participation of 11 for biological females and indeed 12 for biological males. As I said, it is right that this government, and indeed the previous government, and in fact any government, is guided by expert clinical and scientific advice and takes that approach. On the matter of the Pathways trial, and the noble ladies Baroness Deech and Baroness Meyer asked about this, what it's doing is tightly controlling the eligibility.
It requires both individual assent and parental consent. And I'm glad the noble lady Baroness Deech referred to the Gillick principle. It also requires a minimum two-year gender incongruence diagnosis, ongoing access to psychosocial support, NHS clinician and multidisciplinary team approval, as well as participant understanding of risks and benefits, physical and mental stability, and compliance with safeguarding requirements. I do not read that or consider that to be anything less than a properly considered and evidence-based approach to ensure we can provide the healthcare that we need to.
Questions were raised about parental consent, that is integral. The parent or the legal guardian have to agree not only to their child's involvement, and can I emphasize there is no requirement to be a participant, which has been suggested, this is people who are coming forward and also can meet the very stringent issues that are put to them. It is the case, I believe, and I say this to the noble lady Baroness Cash and to other noble lords, that children who have gender incongruence do deserve to be able to participate in research as they also deserve evidence-based care as we all do, in the same way as children with other clinical diagnosis. And to on the matter, I'll just briefly turn to masculinizing and feminizing hormones, which were also referred to in the debate. Following an independent review of evidence, NHS England have launched a consultation and it has concluded, has proposed that they should no longer be available as a routine commissioning option and the result of the consultation is currently under consideration and we will return to that.
I will conclude by saying that maintaining the safety and well-being of children and young people is our priority, it always will be, and I must emphasize it will always be rooted in evidence.
Speaker 122
My lords, the time for this debate, I regret, is completed. In fact, we're a minute over. I do apologize to noble lords. We will now have a moment for people to regroup for the next debate. Motion for debate, proposals for a written constitution, Lord Anderson of Ipswich.
Anderson
My lords, it is an extraordinary honor to open this debate, and I'm grateful to all the clever people from the Bingham Centre to the Constitution Unit who've helped me prepare for it. But a written constitution is not a subject only for initiates. This debate is on the syllabus of every student of law and of politics at university and at school. It concerns every citizen, including the 12 and 13-year-olds who many of us have met during the course of this parliament through Learn with the Lords and who as things stand will have a vote at the next general election. Those who will speak after me have unrivaled experience in how our constitution actually works in England and in the devolved nations, not only as parliamentarians, but as judges, ministers, party leaders, civil servants, constitutional watchdogs, an intelligence chief and behind the door of number 10.
I suspect we are in for a treat.
The constitutional arrangements of this country are unusual in two respects. Almost uniquely in the world, they are not codified, although many of them are written down, and they are founded on a particularly strong version of parliamentary sovereignty, the principle that, as Chief Justice Holt put it in 1701, an act of parliament can do no wrong, though it may do several things that look pretty odd. People who support a written constitution tend to do so for one or more of three reasons, which I shall describe in ascending order of ambition as clarification, entrenchment, and the driving of change. Starting with clarification, a written constitution would demystify what the journalist Gavin Esler has described as the smoke, mirrors, and glorious verbiage of our constitutional arrangements. It would set out principles, powers, and conventions for all to see.
Arrived at by an inclusive process of public debate, led by a constitutional convention, prefaced by an inspiring statement of values, and eventually endorsed by parliament or by popular vote, it would aspire to foster trust and encourage a sense of involvement, cohesion, and pride in country. Entrenchment would involve taking vital protections that currently exist only in precedent, in convention, or in statute, and placing them beyond the reach of day-to-day politics by including them in a written constitution that could be changed only with a higher than usual degree of political or popular consensus. A desire for greater certainty was expressed in evidence given last month to your Lordships' Constitution Committee on relations between cabinet secretaries and prime ministers. The noble Lord O'Donnell seems to have found such meetings occasionally frustrating, commenting that a precedent is a precedent until someone decides to do something else. And I would love to have been able to say, well, Prime Minister, that is not such a good idea because it is illegal.
Perhaps greater clarity could assist ministers too. Darren Jones MP, until recently Chief Secretary to the Prime Minister, recalled this week in evidence to another committee, I would be told all the time that there were things I could not do because of the constitution. The noble Lord Case, who served as cabinet secretary to four prime ministers, took things a step further in his evidence to the Constitution Committee. He pointed to the waning persuasive force of precedents and conventions against unconstitutional behaviour. A backstop, he said, was needed.
After what he described as a rather long journey, he had eventually concluded that, and I quote, probably the best backstop is a written constitution. Most ambitiously of all, some proponents of a written constitution see it as a vehicle for whatever major change they may favour: removal of the royal prerogative, electoral reform, a new second chamber, the remaking of the United Kingdom on federal lines, or the abolition of the monarchy. Andy Burnham argued last year in his book Head North for a written constitution that would echo the German Basic Law by providing for equivalent living standards between the different nations and regions of the United Kingdom. He has repeated that call since becoming Prime Minister, perhaps uniquely. I look forward to hearing from the noble Baroness the Minister what he meant by that and what government policy is on a written constitution.
On the other side of the debate, it is common to hear reasons why a written constitution could never happen or would be pointless if it did. Some of those reasons are to my mind not wholly convincing. It is sometimes said that a written constitution is against the traditions of this country or the common law. But the Government of Ireland Act functioned as a written constitution for Northern Ireland for over 50 years, and the current devolution statutes operate as written constitutions for the devolved institutions of Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales. Our Westminster model of parliamentary democracy has been codified with multiple variations in nearly all our former colonies.
Indeed, I learned the other day that the drafting of new constitutions for Commonwealth states is still one of our legal exports, although rather a niche one. And we even have state-of-the-art judicial expertise in interpreting constitutions through the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council and through a Supreme Court which performs constitutional review when it deals with challenges to the validity of delegated legislation. Another frequently heard objection to a written constitution is that it would be bound to empower the judges to set aside acts of Parliament, placing our elected representatives at the mercy of the lawyers. Well, courts are the most dispassionate arbiters we have, and it would certainly make sense for them to interpret any constitution. But we would not need to go down the path taken by our American cousins, of whom Alexis de Tocqueville so appositely said almost 200 years ago that there is scarcely any political question that does not sooner or later turn into a judicial one.
So any part of any constitution could be placed expressly off-limits to the courts, a course taken in part nine of the Constitutional Consolidation Act that was drafted for the Public Administration and Constitutional Reform Committee of the House of Commons in 2014. The higher courts, or the Supreme Court only, could be empowered to issue a declaration of unconstitutionality, serving as an invitation to government rather than a binding instruction, a solution not without precedent and fully consistent with parliamentary sovereignty. Or inspiration could be taken from countries such as Sweden and Finland, whose written constitutions are enforced primarily by parliamentary committees rather than the courts. We could even if we wished choose to emulate the Netherlands, whose constitution by its article 120 simply prohibits constitutional review by the courts. Another frequently heard objection to a written constitution, generally accompanied these days by an injunction to look across the Atlantic, is that however fine its words, such a document can do nothing in practice to prevent a slide towards authoritarianism.
That point is overstated. It is true that careful balances of power can fall out of kilter. No written constitution could be a complete defense against leaders who seek persistently to undermine it, or a population which has stopped caring for the values of pluralist democracy. But recent experience in America and in Europe shows that while the tide may attack the foundations of any constitution, that constitution may still educate us to recognize the attack, measure the extent of the damage, and slow its advance while we wait for the tide to turn. So some of the supposed barriers to a written constitution are, I suggest, illusory.
But this does not mean that we will be writing one anytime soon. History shows that new constitutional settlements come only at constitutional moments, times of national convulsion. We've certainly had our moments over the past decade, not least Brexit and the election of nationalist-led governments in each of the devolved nations. But the constitution putters on, with expensive noises coming from the engine, in the phrase of the noble Lord Lisvane, but with only muted calls for fundamental change. For this, something still more dramatic would be required, a civil war or a revolution perhaps, and one would need to be a very keen proponent of a written constitution to welcome that.
There is another point too. We're living through a period of rapid constitutional change. In just a few years, EU membership, fixed-term parliaments, English votes for English laws, and hereditary peers have gone. New mayoral authorities have been created, and the structure for relations between Westminster and the devolved governments has been refreshed. Changes to English devolution and the Westminster voting system may soon be in contemplation.
The information revolution poses urgent questions to ancient institutions and procedures. Looking back, the ease with which it has been possible to change our uncodified constitution has surely been an asset. If we can hold on to that while preserving the values that really matter, we won't have done badly. So this is not, I suggest, the time to divert our energies into the process of attempting a codified written constitution. But the flexible nature of our constitutional framework, its unusual reliance on parliamentary sovereignty, and the relatively limited powers of our courts, place a heavy burden on Parliament to protect and promote constitutional values.
Here are four suggestions for building on what we have. First, we could clarify our current arrangements. The House of Commons Library launched in 2024 and updates monthly a lengthy summary entitled The United Kingdom Constitution: A Mapping Exercise. This could evolve with academic help into an authoritative but non-binding restatement of the constitution. And there could be a miniature version focusing on principles rather than detail, and perhaps endorsed by the constitutional committees of each House for use as a teaching aid in schools and a public point of reference.
We should also build on the government's recent decision to update the Cabinet Manual, the document inspired by the New Zealand equivalent and first published in 2011, that sets out the main laws, rules, and conventions affecting the operation of government. It is excellent news that PACAC in the Commons and our own Constitution Committee are to be consulted on the revisions. The Cabinet Manual should be a document acceptable to Parliament, not just the civil service. Heeding the calls for certainty in the recent evidence of Lords O'Donnell and Case, we might also consider the case for giving statutory force to some of its elements. Thirdly, a clear distinction should be made between common-or-garden quangos, of which there may well be too many, and those of real constitutional significance.
I think of the Judicial Appointments Commission, our guarantor of judicial independence and everything that flows from judicial independence, which it is disturbing to see major political parties proposing to abolish in favour of a more political appointment system. Other watchdogs such as HOLAC, the Independent Commissioner on Public Appointments, and the Independent Adviser on Ministerial Interests might also be candidates for a statutory lock. These are important bulwarks against favouritism and corruption, and a future government should not be able to throw them on the next bonfire without at the very least having to justify that decision to Parliament. Fourthly, the Constitution Committee published last May a codified summary of the legislative standards that it applies in its scrutiny of pending bills. I should declare an interest as a member of the committee at that time.
And better still, if it could be integrated into the guidance applied by Parliamentary Counsel and within government by the Parliamentary Business and Legislation Committee. The quality of legislation is a vital component of the constitutional principle of the rule of law. And these vital standards need to be given both greater weight and more consistency in their application. My Lords, I finish with a word about human rights. Whether these are derived from the ECHR or from a domestic Bill of Rights, any imaginable constitution for the United Kingdom must surely have at its center a catalogue of individual rights against public authorities.
Courts must be able not only to defend the fundamental liberties of the individual against the excesses of official power, but also as a minimum to register their formal concern should those rights be infringed by operation of statute. The genius of the Human Rights Act is that it achieves those outcomes by means of the declaration of incompatibility without in any way affecting the sovereignty of Parliament. If we ever lose the right of recourse to the European Court of Human Rights, we will be still more reliant on the continued power of our own courts to pronounce on violations of our liberties, including when those violations result from the application of statute. A codified constitution may be no more than a pipe dream for now. But let us ensure that the liberties of the individual remain front and center of our constitutional settlement, whatever that settlement may look like.
Murphy
I'm very privileged to follow the noble Lord Anderson. When he started his speech, I thought I was going to disagree with him. When he finished it, I agreed with every word he said. And I think that he mentioned the Constitution Committee as it stands, I'm a member of that. And the committee is now dealing with vulnerabilities and threats to our constitution.
The noble Lord Anderson talked about how students were taught British constitution a long time ago. I was one of the teachers of that in the 1970s and early 80s. And in the first lecture, the students were completely bewildered by the fact that I said there was no constitution to teach them. They of course thought there was. But over the following 18 months, two years, going through everything from the monarch to the judiciary, to Parliament, and to everything else that constitutes a government and Parliament in this country, they began to realize that we did indeed have a constitution.
Some of it was written, some of it was convention, some of it was historical, some of it was good, and some of it was bad. But what it was not was a written constitution. And over the last number of years, as the Constitution Committee undoubtedly will report, there have been threats and vulnerabilities to our constitution. Not least of which, of course, is the rise of populism. Who knows what might happen if a hard-right government took over in terms of what they've already said in the Reform Party, what they would do.
And they're not on their own on that. And would a written constitution stop them? Well, I'm not sure it would. And I think that the constitution as we see it at the moment is strong enough to be able to withstand those threats.
I think it's very important that we try to change the constitution where it needs to be changed in the way that we've done for many years. And there are ways, and Lord Anderson has touched on them, where we can improve the strength of our constitution without going to the extent of writing it all down in a complete written constitution. He mentioned quite rightly the Cabinet Manual. At the moment, it's relatively worthless because it's entirely based on the whim of a Prime Minister. I think the only way that it could be made absolutely perfect would be to codify it in law, in a statute.
And that is something I think the Constitution Committee will probably look at in further detail. Look at the way in which members of our House are appointed. The committee which appoints them is not statutory in the sense that they can do what they want, it's still at the whim of a Prime Minister. And so perhaps that's something that could be codified and put into law as something which is improving our constitution. What I'm particularly interested as a Welsh member of this House and someone who's spent his entire ministerial career in the territorial departments is how devolution has changed the nature of our constitution over the last thirty years.
The landscape's completely changed, the constitutional landscape, the political landscape. All three of the governments and parliaments in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland were first of all set up by statute and then confirmed by referendum. Indeed, I took the 1998 Northern Ireland Bill, as it then was, through the House of Commons, and if you look at what is now the Northern Ireland Act, it is effectively a constitution for the running of Northern Ireland. There have been other acts since which have clarified different things, but that particular act and the similar acts for Wales and for Scotland, where incidentally they said that sovereignty was vested in the people, something quite different from what we've heard in the past, they form the basis of the constitution of those countries. But of course, they are in a sense themselves under threat.
In Edinburgh, in Cardiff and in Belfast, the governments of those countries are now effectively in the hands of nationalists. Perfectly legitimate political parties, of course they are. In Northern Ireland, of course, it's not as simple, it's half and half, but the First Minister is Sinn Féin. In Edinburgh, the First Minister is SNP, and in Cardiff, the First Minister is Plaid Cymru. And all parties are committed to independence.
And so what happens if they do have a referendum in each of those countries? In Northern Ireland, it's the border poll, it's the referendum in Scotland and Wales, and then we will not be talking about a British constitution, we'll be talking about an English constitution. That is a severe threat to the constitution of our country of the United Kingdom, which needs to be taken very much into account. My Lords, Soviet Russia under Joseph Stalin had a constitution. It guaranteed all the rights of freedom of the press and freedom of association and the rest of it.
It was entirely fiction, worthless. Doesn't mean to say if you've got a written constitution that it protects anything if someone's going to overthrow it in his by coup or by some other method. In the United States, the President of the United States, as mercurial as he is, has almost complete control over all the separation of powers which de Tocqueville talked about, a Supreme Court which is compliant, and of course Republican majorities in both houses, and he uses executive orders at a whim.
That's a written constitution which was meant to protect the liberties of the subject. Take care. But of course we might see a change of that in a few months' time. We can only hope.
Howard
My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Murphy of Torfaen, but unfortunately I am no more able to agree with him today than I was during the many years when we served together in the other place. I, my Lords, I have only one point to make. The one certain effect of the adoption of a written constitution would be the transfer of power from elected parliamentarians to unelected judges. This is because under a written constitution, the final word, my Lords, would rest with the judges. Under our present arrangements, the courts interpret the law in a way which Parliament considers undesirable, and Parliament can legislate to put matters right if it so chooses.
Under a written constitution, it would have to amend the constitution, a process which by design would be made very difficult. Now the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, in his opening remarks, sought to circumvent this point by suggesting that you could in some way have a kind of watered-down written constitution, which wouldn't quite have the effect that I have just described. But the whole point of a written constitution is, to a greater or lesser extent, to hamstring the sovereignty of Parliament. And that, my Lords, is what I consider undesirable. Of course democracy isn't perfect.
Of course it doesn't always deliver the verdict that any of us might want. But if those who are elected fail to deliver what they were elected to do, they can be ejected from power and replaced by others. It is, in a real literal sense, power to the people. And if, which I believe would never happen in this country, if an extreme totalitarian government were elected, does anyone think they would be deterred from pursuing their agenda by the niceties of a written constitution, any more than the Russian government, as has just been mentioned, is deterred by the provisions of its written constitution? Of course there are some, and not least some judges themselves, who regard judges as the ultimate personification of all that is noble, wise and good, in contrast to mere politicians who have to pander to the demands of the electorate, or as noble Lord, Lord Anderson put it with the faintest hint of disparagement, day-to-day politics.
That was the phrase he used. My Lords, they may be right, they may well be right in the characterization of judges which I have just described. But judges are not elected, nor of course should they be. And that is why they should not be granted the ultimate power which a written constitution would confer upon them. The transfer of power from elected parliamentarians to unelected judges has of course been happening under our current arrangements.
It has happened as a result of the extension by the judges, not by Parliament, of the scope of judicial review. It has happened most of all by the coming into force of the Human Rights Act, a transfer of power for which Parliament itself most unwisely was responsible. But it would be considerably extended by the adoption of a written constitution. And in due course it would inevitably lead to demands for political oversight of the appointment of judges, so candidates for judicial office could expect to be closely questioned on their political views. And I don't think most people would welcome the importation to our shores of the practice whereby judges of the Supreme Court decide on the date of their retirement by reference to the political makeup of those who would select their successor.
My Lords, what is the mischief which this proposal is designed to remedy? Our current arrangements have by and large served us well. And with a few modest adjustments to return to Parliament the power which has recently been transferred to the judiciary can and I believe will service well in the future. A written constitution is something we do not need, would do us harm and which should not be introduced.
Speaker 130
My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Howard, and I might start by assuring him that I am not one of those judges who would seek to accrete further power to the judiciary. As the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, reminded us, he is a member of the Constitution, as am I, and of course I speak in a personal capacity this afternoon. I've also been asked to convey the regrets of our chairman, the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde, that he is unable to be here this afternoon. My Lords, the merits of a written constitution over an unwritten one such as ours are the stuff of endless discussion. But before any profound change is proposed, there must be a hard-hearted look at what is wrong with the existing system, whether a written constitution would solve the problems identified and whether it's feasible to produce one.
All constitutions are vulnerable to bad actors. Examples abound around the world of governments abusing their constitutions. Many of the most authoritarian countries have constitutions which look beautiful on paper but are worthless, as Lord Murphy reminded us. A written constitution is generally only as good as the ability of a constitutional court independently to interpret it, to declare conduct or legislation unconstitutional and for the government to comply with the court's rulings. Alexander Hamilton, a founding father of the United States and a draftsman of its constitution, observed that the judiciary is the weakest of the three arms of the state because it requires the executive to enforce its orders.
This also explains why so many governments, including some in Europe in recent years, have sought to pack the judiciary with its placement and remove others.
A written constitution in the end provides only limited protection from bad actors. And as Lord Anderson has reminded us, written constitutions usually arise in circumstances of political upheaval and change, sometimes peaceful, such as when new states are created, but often not. The United Kingdom is simply not in that position. Our constitutional settlement followed the Civil War, the restoration of the Stuarts and the Glorious Revolution, and it has constantly evolved since. Aspects of it are contained in legislation, but much of it is not.
It's hedged around with conventions. As has already been noted, at its heart is parliamentary sovereignty. That is a key aspect of our constitutional settlement. And that necessarily includes the proposition that Parliament cannot bind its successor. Any legislation can be repealed or amended, including constitutional legislation.
My Lords, I've not seen any convincing explanation of how Parliament today could pass legislation that is entrenched in the sense that it can only be repealed or amended, for example, with a supermajority in Parliament or by referendum, which are mechanisms adopted in constitutions around the world. Moreover, proposals for a written constitution generally require widespread political support. And I wonder what the prospects are realistically of the House of Commons approving legislation, if a mechanism could be found, which restricted its own freedom of action in the future and very likely transferred final decisions of great political moment to the judiciary. Now, my Lords, as the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, has said, there might be advantage in placing on a statutory footing some of the constitutional guardrails which currently could be swept away at the stroke of a prime ministerial pen. Sir Peter Riddell and Professor Robert Hazell and the UCL Constitution Unit have done invaluable work on that.
Such a move would at least require a government to confront what it was planning to do through legislation. But, my Lords, there is an aspect of our constitution which provides constraints and protections, protections against extravagant executive action of the sort that the proponents of a written constitution fear. That is the existence of conventions, which operate to give the executive freedom of action, but they are not immutable. They include the conventions which operate in this House, itself an important constitutional guardian, and which govern the relationship between the Crown, the executive and Parliament. Conventions work when all who are subject to them respect their boundaries.
But if one player doesn't do so, the others can be expected to modify their responses. It's probably fruitless to hypothesize on the circumstances in which that might happen because they are unpredictable. But, my Lords, it should not be supposed that the current arrangements are toothless. My Lords, I return to where I started. There is little doubt that our unwritten constitution is vulnerable to bad actors, but so too are all constitutions.
But I am unpersuaded that a written constitution is the answer. Ours continues to work well and can adapt. A written constitution would be unlikely to solve whatever problems have been identified, and it is not likely to be feasible.
Speaker 98
My Lords, I rise to speak with some hesitancy given the expertise of many speakers in this debate, and I'm not going to talk for very long. I just want to say a few things. I always believed that our constitution was flexible, adaptable, and preserved the sovereignty of Parliament. And I can remember a conversation with the President of the Supreme Court many years ago about did we need a written constitution, and he said, in 1930, you looked at the constitutions of Europe, you would have said Germany was the best one. We've seen other examples and other speakers have shown the fallacy of relying on a beautiful constitution.
Of course, the events with the prorogation of Parliament and others worried us, I think, certainly worried me, and in particular, I'm going to pick up the Daily Mail story on enemies of the people. Now, my father filled all the major law officers, law roles of the Crown: Solicitor, Attorney General, and Lord Chancellor. And he always told me that he tried to do those jobs in a quasi-judicial way, not a party political way, so that, for example, he objected to Suez on the grounds of its illegality. But he also told me he took an oath to defend the judges if they were attacked. That hasn't recently happened, and the person in the role of Lord Chancellor or the Minister of Justice should defend the judges.
We don't have to agree with all the judgments. We don't have to agree with their decisions. But if we don't resist any imputation of the independence of the judiciary, we're in real trouble. Twice I have, and just a point on that, a recent Attorney General had a spad. This is completely wrong in my view.
I've twice chaired committees to appoint the chair of the Judicial Appointments Commission, which was established by the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005. In each case, I came under some pressure from politicians to reach a certain outcome, which we, the panel, resisted. And I think also in MI5, slightly different, there were occasions under both a Labour and a Conservative government where we were asked why we were not looking at a particular subject. To which the answer was that constitutionally, the government can stop MI5 doing anything, it can sack it, abolish it, sack the leader, refuse to authorize anything, but it cannot tell it what to do, any more than it can tell the police who to arrest or who to investigate. And in each case, both in the appointment for the chair of the JAC and in my MI5 experience, when this was explained, ministers backed off and the constitutional niceties were preserved.
So my feeling is that we just need to be sure, all of us, that we resist inroads into, in particular, and I'm focusing on the independence of the judiciary, but the other aspects of the constitution which we all recognize without necessarily going to a formal document.
Speaker 131
My Lords, this is the first substantive contribution I've made to the work of this House since 2012, when I was disqualified from sitting here by virtue of the Constitutional Reform Act, one of a slew of recent judicial constitutional measures, which I think demonstrate the evolving nature of the constitution.
Reference has already been made to the work of the devolved governments and parliaments, and these are important changes that have been made to the constitutional order through the present arrangements. In principle, my Lords, a written constitution is not necessarily a bad idea. It may have a number of advantages. In practice, however, I think that those who propose such a document rather underestimate the time and energy that would be entailed by such an exercise, to say nothing of the political controversy that would surround it. To take one example, do the nations of the United Kingdom have the power to secede, and if so, on what terms and by what means?
My Lords, in my submission, the issue is not whether we should have a written constitution, but whether we have and maintain the conventions, the norms, and the shared values that support our democracy. The noble Lord, Lord Murphy, has referred to the constitution of the USSR. Article 112 of the 1936 constitution of the Soviet Union states: "Judges shall be independent and subject only to the law." One might think by that, if one looked at that and knew nothing about the Soviet Union, that it had an independent judiciary and was committed indeed to the rule of law. Nothing, of course, could be further from the truth.
What I would submit is that the conventions, norms, and the shared values, the respect for those whose opinions differ from ours, and the respect for human rights and human dignity are of more significance than whether or not we have a written document. If we look across the Atlantic to the United States, a nation whose commitment to a written constitution is in effect forged into its very soul, we can see what happens when these values are challenged. There are too many examples, I suggest, that question its commitment, at least of this administration, to the values that I have just outlined. The most egregious example, of course, was on January the 6th, 2021, when there was an assault on the Capitol building. The President's false allegations of voter fraud and the pressure on the Vice President effectively to overturn the result of the general election challenged the norm that, barring any legal challenge, the result of free and fair elections would be accepted and that thereafter there would be a peaceful transition from one administration to another.
And, my Lords, under this President, we have seen the politicization of federal prosecutions to go after perceived political enemies, the flagrant misuse of presidential powers of pardon, and the threats to journalists and the freedom of the media. And while federal judges would no doubt bristle at the suggestion that they allow political leanings and considerations to color their judgments, it is perhaps remarkable that in order to understand some of the judgments that are made, it is thought relevant to question who was the President who made the appointment.
And this gives rise to the cynicism and undermines the authority of the courts. In April 2026, just 43% of Americans supported the work of the Supreme Court, down by 11 points from a year before. My Lords, these are, I believe, serious matters and, but I am not one of those that believes that America is about to slip into a further authoritarian abyss. But I would suggest that what is happening in the United States is both a warning and a wake-up call. And in this country, we face challenges which I think should be now addressed.
Respect for the opinions of others has declined. Public discourse in this country has become coarser, more divided and more challenging. And the debate over Gaza and Palestine has at times descended into an ugly form of antisemitism. The language that is sometimes used to describe illegal migrants and asylum seekers is often degrading and dehumanizing. Every human is entitled to be treated with dignity.
We see threats to the safety and well-being of politicians and public figures that have increased. These will only serve to push good people out of public life. And social media, of course, has played its part. We've also seen assaults on the independence of the judiciary, as been referred to by the noble Baroness Manningham-Buller. My Lords, these challenges to the unwritten parts of our constitution, more particularly the values which bind us together, will, I fear, only increase.
I have no great views on whether or not we should have a written constitution, but I rather suspect that the energy and time that would be involved in that process would be better expressed by addressing these fundamental issues.
Leslie Griffiths
My Lords, I begin my remarks with two very quick points. Firstly, sharing my noble friend Lord Murphy's point that we came to the fray expecting to hear a very solid advocacy for a written constitution and have prepared the finest speeches against such a proposition imaginable, whereas it hasn't turned out that way at all. Secondly, I had not imagined that I'd be speaking at this point in the debate after all those extraordinarily learned people with huge experience of of law immediately ahead of me. So you must regard my remarks as an entr'acte, a little bit of entertainment between now and when the great heavyweights come on again later. But I did want to make a point about written constitutions, whether of the kind that's in the head of the noble and learned Lord Lord Anderson as he brought the debate before us, or otherwise.
I'll come from a theological angle. I can see your eyes glazing. I come with a consideration, for example, of the 500 years it took the Christian church after the death of Christ to formulate the Nicene Creed. It celebrated its 1700th anniversary just last year. In order to get that form of words that satisfied everybody and attempt to bring an experience out of a Semitic world into a Hellenic world, that itself is is a challenge.
But the Hellenic itself, in Alexandria and Jerusalem and Ephesus and other places, was a variety of ways of speaking Greek that demanded only the best intellects put together in order to take out of all of that something that they could all live with.
It went on year after year, decade after decade, and century after century. And in the end, the great force that brought it into being was a contingent of troops from the Pope in Rome who put a shotgun, or whatever its equivalent was in the fifth century, to the heads of all those gathered for the formulation of the creed. All those elements going into the attempts to make a written constitution which would bind the Roman Empire, or what remained of it, together. 500 years later, I should have said that there were more people excluded from Christendom by the creed than included by it. But let me move on 500 years, because at that particular time in the 11th century, there was a proposal to add one word to the Nicene Creed, one word in Latin, Filioque.
And that itself proved so divisive with this written constitution that it divided the whole of Christendom between East and West, Orthodox and Latin. Written constitutions are for the birds. I do admire the Nicene Creed, its intellectual process that gave us that form of words and satisfied people for a long time, but it is a historic document. I've never used it, I can only say that now because the bishops aren't here. But for all of that, that's my experience of a written constitution there.
Now, I'm a Methodist minister. Every year I get a directory telling me about who's who in my church, together with a second volume that's called the Constitutional Practice and Discipline of the Methodist Church. It's fat. It's the accumulation of all the bits and pieces over 250 years that have allowed us to feel this is our constitutional position, it's fixed. In my early years as a minister, when manses we lived in were furnished, we had a bed, my wife and I, which had one short leg on it.
The Constitutional Practice and Discipline of the Methodist Church fitted perfectly under the fourth leg and we slept happily ever after. Now the trouble about that document is that when it was taken overseas to Methodist churches in Africa, Asia and all over the world, that constitution became a substitute for the gospel. The people coming to meetings would come armed with that. And they'd say, but on page 230 it says X and you're doing Y. Written constitutions lend themselves to nitpicking, oppositionism and uselessness at the end of the day.
Now I've just got half a minute left and I'll do my best, because I preached a sermon at Gray's Inn, and it was the Mulligan sermon, and it was all about the judgment of a man called Richard Atkin who took all those precedents that constitute our common law and made what he called a kind of overarching statement for it. It boiled down in the end to a consideration of the Donoghue and Stevenson case, which all learned lords know about, which at the end of the day allowed him to say a duty of care and doing unto others what you would have them do unto you will undergird all our attempts, legally and constitutionally, to find the right way forward. So there you are, let the lawyers get on with it now, I'll be here to listen.
Speaker 134
My Lords, our uncodified constitution has four legs, short or long, common law, statutes, conventions and practice. Our modern system of administrative law elicited from our well-respected government legal service a measured guide, the judge over your shoulder, now in its sixth edition. Its witty acronym is JOYS, but I take this in the sense that it is a real joy and a huge privilege to live in a country which adheres to the rule of law. An important aspect of the court's role is to determine the legal limits of the powers conferred upon each branch of government. In the two Miller cases, in the first of which I sat, the Supreme Court acted to preserve the position of Parliament, not the executive, as our ultimate democratic institution.
Where our uncodified constitution stands out is in a certain lack of transparency, possibly accompanied with a degree of complacency, in its inability to act as a salient feature of national identity. It mystifies and in its foundational principles of parliamentary sovereignty and privilege, the relationship of which with the other Diceyan principle of rule of law we're discussing this evening. As to transparency, there has been reference to the Cabinet Office manual. In 2008 to 9, when I had the privilege of chairing the House's subcommittee on European law and institutions, on which the noble Lord, Lord Kerr, also served, we were interested to know the bases on which the government chose to consult the House in respect of European legislative initiatives in Brussels. Our information was that in at least one Nordic country, its parliament was not merely consulted, but dictated the executive's line on such initiatives, which are, of course, a form of primary legislation in many cases.
The response to our inquiry was that the Cabinet Office guidelines were confidential. Only on the 5th of May 2009 were we able to thank the then Minister for Europe, Caroline Flint, for a letter putting several of the guidelines for the first time into the public domain. Now, of course, we have the Cabinet Manual, December 2010, but not even updated to reflect our leaving the EU, although about to be apparently reformulated. As to the core constitutional principles of parliamentary supremacy and privilege, they operate well if in exercise with restraint and respect, but can we in modern conditions still feel quite the same complacency as Mr. Podsnap in Our Mutual Friend when he declared that we Englishmen are very proud of our constitution, sir. It was bestowed upon us by Providence, no other country is so favoured as this country.
Mr. Podsnap did not see beyond Hadrian's Wall or foresee devolution. He gloried in English exceptionalism without acknowledging any possible advantages in written constitutions. Today, we do not have to look abroad to see that our uncodified constitution has potential vulnerabilities. The supremacy of Parliament makes primary legislation immune to judicial review. Most written constitutions entrench fundamental individual rights, as the noble and learned Lord, Lord Anderson, has said, a model upon which UK Supreme Court justices regularly adjudicate sitting in the Privy Council.
The UK's nearest equivalent, cleverly constructed to respect parliamentary supremacy, is the unentrenched Human Rights Act. But a government commanding a parliamentary majority can simply repeal that at any time. With one exception, Parliament can do anything. The teasing exception already mentioned is that Parliament cannot bind itself. Nothing can be entrenched, although perhaps a way in the form of some sort of constitutional people's convention or even a referendum would lead courts to recognise entrenchment.
The privileges of parliament combined with Article 9 of the Bill of Rights make the appropriateness of parliamentary procedures forbidden territory for UK courts. This does not, however, mean that nothing needs doing to improve or change them. The problems are well known. The Institute of Government has described the government's iron grip over the Commons timetable as unusual in international terms and needing modification. The insufficiency of parliamentary scrutiny and the prevalence, breadth, and vagueness of delegated legislation have been criticized robustly in and outside parliament by very strongly worded reports, one entitled Dictat: A Call to Return Power to Parliament and Democracy Denied.
Speaker 135
A written constitution would probably address parliament supremacy, although with respect to what the noble lord said about the Netherlands, I believe actually that there is a law going through to give ex post facto jurisdictional power to strike down to the Raad van State on similar lines to the Conseil d'État, sorry, the Conseil Constitutionnel in France. The Prime Minister has, and this has been mentioned, co-authored Head North, looking with favor on the German Basic Law, which features both scrutiny of supremacy and scrutiny of internal procedural privileges of the German parliament. Can I say a word about that? The German constitution and its court were of course part of an essential new start, but both have won continuing acceptance as core elements of Germany's legal and cultural identity. Their court's involvement with parliamentary procedures has been in the interest of democracy.
It has prescribed general principles to prevent the misuse of majoritarian power, to ensure that parliament is given sufficient time to debate proposed legislation, to ensure that minority parties have proper information and a proper say, to ensure the precision of legislation, and to avoid excessive or vague delegation of legislative powers to the executive. At the same time, the German Constitutional Court has remained very sensitive to the greater democratic legitimacy of the German parliament, and Germany is not governed by judges. The elective dictatorship of this country, in my suggestion, clearly needs to improve itself in less dramatic ways than a written constitution. There should be some new self-denying concordat by the executive with government identifying and agreeing to observe certain basic principles governing parliament and its procedures. The German model is an interesting parallel and precedent.
Such changes would revivify parliament as the place where the nation's concerns are debated and true political compromise occurs.
Speaker 137
My lords, it's a privilege to follow so many distinguished speakers. The primary purpose of a constitution is to establish the fundamental legal framework for governing a state. In the United Kingdom, two key facets of this are protecting and strengthening our democracy and providing a framework for effective government in accordance with the rule of law. I would measure the arguments for a written constitution against these two benchmarks. So, would a written constitution be more or less democratic?
Speaker 136
Jonathan Sumption pointed out in his Telegraph article of the 9th of August this year that a written constitution would hand enormous political power to the courts, who would have the power to interpret it and overturn acts of parliament if they did not measure up to the court's interpretations.
That's a point echoed by the noble Lord, Lord Howard of Lympne just now. Extending the role of our unelected judges in this way would distort our finely balanced separation of powers, weakening parliamentary sovereignty and thereby our democracy. Parliamentary sovereignty provides the flexibility to reform and strengthen our democracy. One can point to many of our statutes, such as the European Communities Act, the Human Rights Act, the Constitutional Reform Act and the Fixed-term Parliaments Act, where Parliament has legislated in a constitutional way. The same is true of devolution in the United Kingdom, which the Prime Minister thinks should be extended throughout the country by a written constitution.
Speaker 137
But the beauty of our current system is that parliamentary sovereignty has enabled these constitutional statutes to be enacted and then to be repealed or amended subsequently through a normal legislative process, as has happened in the case of every single one of them. A written constitution could not so easily have achieved this, since the whole point, as has been said, would be to entrench it and give it a higher status than primary legislation, deliberately making it harder to amend or repeal and transferring power from elected politicians to the judiciary in the process. There has, of course, been social and political angst in the debates leading to the enactments and repeals I've mentioned. But take a moment to imagine the discord which the nation would endure in trying to decide what a written constitution should contain. There would certainly be calls for it to go wider than the Cabinet Manual.
One only has to consider the recent heated debates on economic and social issues, such as whether a person is a man or a woman, which migrants should be allowed to stay in the United Kingdom, or the duties of the state to provide welfare and social care. The list goes on, and one could see some people arguing passionately for their inclusion in a written constitution, leading to fresh divisions in society. Far better, in my view, to rely on Parliament to decide such issues as and when necessary in line with manifesto and other policy commitments, and to override unintended judicial interpretations by fresh legislation. Turning to the second purpose of our constitution, that is to provide a framework for effective government, advocates of a written constitution may point to the ineffectiveness of our current system to get anything done. One is spoilt for choice, but just look at the seeming inability to deliver infrastructure projects like the Hammersmith Bridge, which has so far been closed for seven years and won't fully reopen until 2035.
Speaker 136
The Chinese replaced their multi-lane Sanyuan Bridge in 43 hours. Or look at the massive cost overruns and delays of HS2, the broken prison system and the lack of investment and procurement failures in UK defence. Tempting as it is in the face of these failures to seize on anything which might make things better, it's not the fault of our constitution that some governments over the last 15 or 20 years have failed to govern effectively or responsibly. A written constitution would make no difference. Ministerial accountability is already part of our unwritten constitution, for which the Prime Minister holds ultimate responsibility, and it can be enforced by means of the Ministerial Code and parliamentary scrutiny mechanisms such as select committees.
The Public Office Accountability Bill, once implemented, may help to add statutory weight to the principle of ministerial accountability. In addition, there is, of course, political pressure, which at an election punishes ministerial incompetence or irresponsibility, or indeed earlier if our leaders are forced to quit. Seven Prime Ministers in 10 years speaks for itself. This and other political dramas in recent years show how our constitution can weather the fiercest storms. Some would say that a written constitution would be more transparent than our current convoluted statute book.
Speaker 138
They have a point. AI states that there are around 6,000 statutes in force, many totally incomprehensible because of extensive amendments to previous acts. The Representation of the People Bill is a case in point. However, the answer is not a written constitution, but a programme of legislative consolidation, which would vastly improve everyone's understanding of what the law actually is. There's little hope of that.
Speaker 137
In conclusion, let's cherish the jewels in the crown of our unwritten constitution: parliamentary sovereignty, the separation of powers, and ministerial accountability, which have protected our democracy for so long and which are the envy of written constitutions around the world.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord Anderson of Ipswich for securing this debate and so clearly and entertainingly introducing it, even though I profoundly disagree with his conclusions. And it probably won't surprise your Lordships' House to say that I'm going to bring a very different perspective to any thus far heard in this debate. And I thank the noble Lord also for giving me the opportunity to explain a discussion I was forced to truncate back in 2020, when the respected commentator David Allen Green took a letter I had written to the Financial Times in a manner that I hadn't intended. I was in fact agreeing with Mr. Green and an article he had written headlined "The UK's constitution is not working". He responded on the social media site then called Twitter, feeling incorrectly that I had meant to slight him.
The internet rule of not feeding the fire meant I didn't have a chance to fully explain then, but I can now. The newspaper had put the headline on my letter, "It's time the UK had a written constitution", which was an accurate although not complete description of the letter's contents. What I called for was a modern, functional, democratic, and written constitution. I described what we have now as a tangle of historical accident held together by a gloss of tourist-friendly ceremony. The constitution is not democratic.
We have a still massive Labour majority, if with a different leader than than than in that was won in 2024 with the support of 33% of the people who voted, about 25% of eligible voters. Now the noble Lord Lord Anderson referred to our the extreme position we have of parliamentary sovereignty. That's a parliament that does not reflect the views of two-thirds of the British people. The constitution is not functional. There are so many examples I could give, but as an example I'll point to the wide agreement around the House at the abject failure of scrutiny of legislation in the Commons.
Lord Rooker has taken to highlighting this to general House approval. The constitution is not modern. Visit the FCDO Commonwealth offices and they're like a time machine. You return in a flash to the Victorian Empire, as the report "The World in 2040: Renewing the UK's Approach to International Affairs" in 2024 highlighted. But back to 2020.
My focus then and now was not primarily on the written aspect of the constitution, although I think there is an argument going back to the Law of the Twelve Tables in ancient Rome. The plebeians demanded and finally secured written down laws against which the actions of patrician judges and officials could be tested.
If that basic safeguard of being written down is not there, insiders will always have the advantage. What I would have said to Mr. Green is that the existence of a written constitution, of course, does not ensure constitutional behavior, something I'm all too concerned, as a majority of Americans are, we're about to see close up and serious in the US midterms and the next presidential election there. But it would be an important democratic step forward, taken in Rome in about 450 BCE, that the UK has yet to secure. But of course it's not a panacea. No single step will solve all our problems, and anyone who tells you they have a cure-all patent medicine should immediately be discounted as a serious thinker.
What would be really crucial now would be the process of creating a written constitution, to debate, to consider. And here I respectfully disagree entirely with the noble lord Lord Carter. I believe we need to have that debate. We currently have toxically buried a huge amount of disagreement in our society. If we don't have that debate, that disagreement will continue to fester.
In that process, what might we consider? What is the UK? What is its place in the world? Should there still be a UK, something that's now very seriously in question, and I note is challenged by the Green parties of both Scotland and Wales? Should we have such a massive dominance of Westminster over the rest of these islands?
Should we get the big money out of politics, not all of us getting the politics the few pay for? Should we still have the last rotten borough, the City of London? After all, the position of the City of London as a global center of financial corruption is a failure not just of governance, but of government. What does the constitutional monarchy mean? What about the Crown Estate?
Should who anyone's parents are determine their place in our constitution? Should we have an elected upper house? The noble lady Baroness Smith of Llanfaes will give us a chance to talk about that tomorrow, so I'll just leave that there. These and many more are the questions that we need to consider, that I would suggest we should have a people's constitutional convention that would be at the heart of a broad national debate. As Lord Anderson said, the constitution is a matter for every citizen.
I would say it's a matter for every resident of the UK. The status quo benefits the status quo. That is not a sustainable, a stable situation. It cannot continue, and I have to respectfully disagree with the noble and learned lord Lord Burnett of Maldon that written constitutions arrive in a time of political upheaval and change and that that does not apply to the UK. This after we've had seven prime ministers in ten years and we are known internationally now as Westminster on the Tiber.
Speaker 140
My lords, let me too begin by thanking the noble lord Lord Anderson for providing the opportunity for this debate, and indeed for his far-reaching introduction. My lords, this is a huge issue, and we've had various views expressed on the pros and cons of a codified constitution, and I'm not entirely sure that I have much to add to what has already been expressed. But what I would like to do is to touch on the role that Parliament could play in ensuring scrutiny and monitoring constitutional bills to ensure that they receive the attention they deserve and indeed need.
My premise in so doing is that it is the experience, my Lords, of this House over many, many years that incremental reform is more likely to succeed than do sweeping changes. But, my Lords, in the last decade or so, constitutional issues have come into sharper focus. Whether it be the Brexit process and prorogation, the successive rulings by the Supreme Court in 2017 and 2019 on the Gina Miller challenges, or on aspects of devolution. There have too been repeated questions about the integrity and ethics of the government of the day. What emerges, my Lords, is the lack of clarity on exactly where power lies in our uncodified constitution.
Speaker 143
The centuries-old tipping between the monarch, the government, the courts, and Parliament was eventually resolved by the adoption of supreme parliamentary sovereignty as the basis of the English settlement. Parliament, as we have heard, can make or break any law, and in theory at least, this power is constrained by a set of checks and balances. The problem is that these checks and balances have proved weak, resulting in, among many other developments, public distrust in the government of the day and in its political institutions. There are now new elements to contend with, notably the impact of external forces, forces outside government, who by their wealth and their influence are creating a new global power, a new global order. My Lords, I think there is an urgent need for action to reassert the UK's fundamental constitutional principles.
Speaker 141
However, a serious attempt to rewrite our uncodified constitution would be a huge undertaking, lasting several years possibly, with an uncertain outcome. Furthermore, it would require widespread consultation and efforts to educate the public on complex aspects of the law. That said, my Lords, no one denies that there is a case for action. So what kind of action would serve to educate and allay the concerns of the wider public, including the media? One of the main recommendations of the 2023 review of the UK constitution published by the Institute for Government and the Bennett Institute for Public Policy was the establishment of a new and possibly joint parliamentary committee on the constitution.
This committee would have several functions, including scrutinizing constitutional policy and monitoring adherence to norms and conventions. The review points out some of the weaknesses in the present arrangement, such as the tendency for the government to pass devolved legislation often without the consent of respective devolved nations, or the reliance on a simple parliamentary majority for changes such as fixed-term parliaments, only to have them abandoned by a similar simple majority, or again the reversion to referendums on the, for example, the Scottish independence and Brexit by a public that may not take into account the unintended consequences. My Lords, this committee could usefully begin by listing existing constitutional acts and principles and new categories of constitutional acts, thereby formally recognizing the importance of key legislation that underpins our system.
The present constitutional arrangements are relatively unclear. A single, independent and authoritative source of constitutional knowledge would be of great help in clarifying the legitimacy of different party political views, which have no mechanism for resolving disagreements. And in due course, this committee could take on perhaps greater powers, such as the power to delay legislation unless and until the constitutional aspects are formally agreed following pre-legislative scrutiny. The rationale focusing on the constitution is that we can no longer ignore the contradictions of the political instability that is emerging. The public needs reassurance, and the government needs to be prepared to deal with new challenges so as to underpin protections we already have but do not adequately adhere to.
De Souza
The recommendations in the IFG review suggests a way forward that would significantly improve parliamentary oversight and promote public understanding and trust, and also serve to clarify our constitutional laws.
Ajay Kakkar
My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow my noble friend Baroness De Souza, and in so doing, join other noble Lords in thanking my noble friend Lord Anderson of Ipswich for having secured this important debate and introduced it in such a thoughtful manner. I am one who is opposed to the idea of a written constitution because I am deeply attached to the orthodox interpretation of parliamentary sovereignty: the ability for a parliament to make and unmake laws, for an act of parliament to be recognized as the supreme legal authority, and for the clear convention that no parliament can bind its successor. To that I would add the simple principle that ultimately the other place enjoys primacy, and as a result, because the other place is composed of the representatives of the people, not their delegates, we have a situation where the people are ultimately sovereign. However, there are circumstances under which we might need to consider a written constitution in the future, those identified in the preamble of the 1911 Parliament Act, where if parliament decided to compose a second chamber not on a hereditary basis at that time, but one composed on a popular basis, then the interim arrangements of the 1911 Act, which governed effectively the relationship and powers between the two houses, would need to be reconsidered. And in defining the powers of effectively a second elected chamber, there would need to be some kind of constitutional document, and that ultimately would require interpretation, potentially by a different authority from one or two of the chambers of parliament, potentially a constitutional court, and that's why in principle I have been opposed to an elected second chamber.
But my Lords, I've had the privilege of serving in two positions that have been mentioned by other noble Lords, or two bodies that have been mentioned by other noble Lords. I chaired for some years the House of Lords Appointments Commission and thereafter the Judicial Appointments Commission. And they are two very different bodies. The House of Lords Appointments Commission, composed as a result of a written ministerial statement by the then Prime Minister in April of 2000, laying out the basis for appointment of the first commission and indicating that in addition to making nominations for appointment to the crossbenches, it would adopt the responsibilities of the then Political Honours Scrutiny Committee.
The Judicial Appointments Commission, on the other hand, was established as a result of the 2005 Constitutional Reform Act, came into being in April of 2006, and many of the regulations under which it makes appointments were brought into force in 2013. It's interesting that both bodies are subjected to parliamentary scrutiny, the chairman of the House of Lords Appointments Committee appearing before the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee of the other place, and the chairman of the Judicial Appointments Committee before the Justice Committee in the other place. Both bodies appear before your Lordships' Constitutional Committee, so there is an important degree of parliamentary scrutiny. It's suggested that the House of Lords Appointments Commission should be put onto a statutory basis. It's merely advisory at the moment, and there may well indeed be some arguments for that.
I was always quite anxious about that proposition because in putting the body on a statutory basis, one would then establish criteria for appointment in statute, and I always wondered whether therefore appointments could be challenged or subjected to judicial review, and that would put your Lordships' House, indeed this Parliament, in a difficult place where the judiciary might ultimately object to the appointment of somebody who had already taken their seat in your Lordships' House, creating something of a crisis. On the other hand, in the Judicial Appointments Commission, there are very clear statutory objectives, duties of the commission. There are only two: to appoint on merit and to appoint individuals of good character. And the work of the JAC was often challenged because it failed to achieve quickly enough substantial and sufficient diversity of the different jurisdictions and benches. When those challenges were made, the statutory position was very clear, and a Lord Chancellor of the day was able to resist those calls and ensure that the JAC continued to be supported to make appointment on the basis of merit only.
The reason I make these observations is because so many of the settlements that we enjoy and that have been broadly discussed in this very interesting debate by other noble Lords are dependent upon those who have the responsibility and privilege to act within our constitution to understand that envelope of responsibility and to act within it. If we are to consider a change, a move away from these current constitutional arrangements, we'll need to consider both positive and unintended consequences. And I believe for those reasons, the flexible, pragmatic approach that we've enjoyed to date is the appropriate approach to continue. However, the point has been made that for certain bodies that play a role in our constitution, such as the House of Lords Appointments Commission and the Judicial Appointments Commission, there may be further thought to strengthening the way that Parliament itself can protect their work against excessive interference or indeed becoming subjective to particular mood not properly enjoyed by broad democratic consent, and that is something that I believe should be considered. But ultimately, I think we have to continue to believe that our constitutional settlement as currently constructed provides protection, and certainly the experience I had with regard to those two bodies confirms that the arrangements are appropriate as long as we continue to understand that it is Parliament that has the ultimate responsibility for scrutiny, and therefore both the other place and your Lordships' House must be able to effect their responsibilities with efficiency and determination and absolute confidence.
Speaker 144
Up to a point, Lord Kakkar, as Evelyn Waugh might very nearly say. I I I agree with the general thesis, but I do think HOLAC needs to be on a statutory basis and with a wider remit. I myself once tried to write a constitution for the European Union. It was a constitutional treaty and mine was merely the pen. The ideas came from representatives of 28 legislatures and 28 governments, including four active members of this House, active present members of this House.
My treaty was a total failure. It was accepted by 18 countries, but it was vetoed by two, and it would have been vetoed in this country, I think, if it had come that far. Are there any lessons that I can bring to the House from my sad experience of having failed to write a constitution, or having written a constitution that failed? Well, I'm prepared to try if you insist. I think we failed principally because Lord Anderson wasn't involved.
He could have warned us not to be so ambitious, as he warned three years ago in his famous lecture, and he's warned again tonight. In his lecture, he distinguished three kinds of constitution writing. He warned against a revolutionary approach, starting from scratch, a Grundgesetz. He recommended for this country an authoritative restatement of current constitutional arrangements, making them easier to grasp, and as again today, he spoke of a program of modest renewal, dealing with problems that have thrown up by recent history. I think the HOLAC case is a case in point.
Excessive use of framework laws worries me greatly, and I think the Independent Adviser on Ministerial Interests and the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments, which seems to me to be a revolving door committee, could both be be looked at. All these defects, I think, are ones which most of us in this House would hope Mr. Burnham would address. The Anderson prescription is evolution, not revolution, and I I concur with my learned friend. I am uneasy about the suggestion, I don't know how valid it is, that Mr. Burnham is still attracted to something like the German Basic Law. The EU constitutional treaty that failed was actually not far from the Anderson prescription.
It was mainly restatement. But the provisions in it which attracted most opposition were in fact provisions that it was restating. They were already operative when they attracted enormous opprobrium in France and a certain amount in this country, and they remained operative after the treaty was rejected.
The elements that were new, the new powers of the European Parliament, the European Council's enhanced status and presidency, and the bulwarks against competence creep, were not in themselves revolutionary, and 95% of them were subsequently adopted in and are operative now. It was putting them all together in a single new compendium text that killed them in 2005. It looked an intimidatingly big package, and a vanishingly small proportion of those who rejected it in France, in the Netherlands, and I suspect in this country, had actually read it. My apologies. I draw two conclusions from that sad history.
First, restatement and renewal should, as Lord Anderson prescribed, be entirely separate exercises. Second, renewal should be tackled seriatim, in a rolling programme over time. Every innovation will have an opponent, and the opposition to a compendium will amount to more than the sum of individual criticisms. So no German Basic Law, please. It would need countrywide acceptance, presumably by referendum.
It could easily suffer the same fate as my EU masterpiece, and a failure would do lasting damage because it would be very hard to distinguish and disentangle the acceptable from the unacceptable. So, one final point. We shouldn't, in my view, just think about the relationship between executive and legislature. I think we also need to think about the relationship between this legislature and those in Belfast, Cardiff, and Edinburgh, and the relationship between central and devolved governments, as Lord Murphy did. I hope that Mr. Burnham, when he preaches devolution, looks beyond England.
As a Scottish unionist, I strongly resented the way recent union governments patronised and insulted Edinburgh. I was and remain uneasy that consultative intergovernmental mechanisms were so little used, and interparliamentary consultation so vestigial. Lord Burnett commended conventions, but our elastic interpretation of the Sewel convention seems to me to be dangerous and dishonourable. The convention written into the Scotland Act 2016 says we won't normally legislate in devolved matters without the consent of the Scottish Parliament. But, my Lords, we never should, and the inclusion of the promise that we won't normally cheat is an open invitation to cheat, which has all too often been exercised.
Devolved means devolved, and we should mind ourselves never to claw back competences when it suits us. We Scots are great at grievances. Let's not create real grievances. Let's honour the constitutional settlement we've got and go in for some cautious reform and renewal along Anderson prescription.
Stephen Benn
My Lords, I'm very pleased to make a contribution to this debate, not least because I welcome any opportunity to debate the constitution, and being so low down in the list at least gives me the opportunity to say what a wonderful debate it's been so far, and I commend the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, for securing the debate and for his speech.
I myself find myself rather missing my noble friend Lord Hennessy of Nympsfield, who if he were here would be making a contribution. Now, may I say I've been very grateful to the library for the briefing it's given, setting out the arguments for and against a written constitution. And as we have heard the noble lady Baroness Manningham-Buller pay a tribute to the distinguished career of her father, may I be allowed to thank the library for including in their briefing a reference to the Commonwealth of Britain Bill 1991, introduced by the then right honourable member for Chesterfield. Now, we know that we don't have a single document that contains our constitution, and we have a variety of laws and judicial decisions, customs, conventions and precedents. But we don't just have written documents, we also have pictorial documents.
Earlier this year I went to the British Museum to see the Bayeux Tapestry, and I recommend all members should do the same. And in a way that tapestry is a foundational document of our constitution, because the events that followed the Battle of Hastings have laid the foundation for the system of government that we have today. Now, the Prime Minister's set out his case for greater devolution, Number 10 North is a symbol of his commitment, and in due course it may well be that this will lead to new developments in our constitutional arrangements. But they will be evolutionary. It's not quite the same thing as saying that it will inevitably lead to a brand new written constitution for this country in a single document.
Apart from anything else, my Lords, it would in my view be remarkably difficult to create and agree a written constitutional document, setting out all the relationship between the various branches of government and the individual rights of people and the sovereignty of the people and so on. And that's not to mention the need for the way in which it might be ratified. Now, there may be members of this House, and people present now, who as I have, have studied the founding of the United States. And the Federalist Papers and the debates in Philadelphia culminating in the document written in 1787 represented a great achievement at that time. And it does still remain one of the most robust and successful in modern political history, though I am bound to say that it is currently under strain to say the least.
And we have yet to see how stretched that constitution can be by current events. Ask me some more after November the 3rd. But that's a debate for another day. Now, I don't think it is feasible or practicable for us to create a single written constitutional document today. Frankly, my Lords, we've had too much history to make that possible.
Nor do I think it would be right or desirable, if I may gently say so to the noble and learned Lords here present, to create a constitution that would inevitably confer on the judiciary a major responsibility for its interpretation. Call me old-fashioned, but I'm a believer in parliamentary sovereignty, and I may as well add that I was brought up to be so. And for those who argue that a written constitution is a vital bulwark against the abuse of power, I would argue that written constitutions are not immune to bad actors, a point made by many people so far. And of course there are weaknesses in unwritten constitutions. I can think of a recent example, the attempt to prorogue Parliament for such a long time in 2019, though that did not eventually succeed.
Some have raised other weaknesses. Recently I saw the evidence given by the noble Lord, Lord Case, to the Constitution Committee of your Lordships' House, and he gave us an argument for a written constitution that it was remarkable for a G7 country and a P5 member of the United Nations and a nuclear power not to have a clear line of succession. A not unreasonable question.
Well, my Lords, what would happen if our Prime Minister was run over by a bus today? The only thing I know for certain is that the passengers on that bus would have not paid more than two pounds each for that journey. But seriously, my Lords, what would the line of succession be? I don't claim to know. We don't at the moment have a designated Deputy Prime Minister, though we've had at various times in the recent past.
So some might claim that this is a fatal weakness. But I think the situation would be resolved. I'm sure we'd probably have an interim leader, an election of the Labour Party, and events would then unfold in a familiar way. But the underlying point I'm trying to make is that our unwritten constitution would in effect cope with such a situation, as it has with others, because ultimately it rests on the consent and the confidence of the people. And this concept of confidence is a central part of our unwritten constitution.
After all, we have a system in which the very definition of a Prime Minister is that she or he has the confidence of the House, and the political system has the confidence of the people. And after all, this year has seen a pretty classic example of what happens when a Prime Minister loses that confidence. And where there have been attempts made to import a rigidity into our constitution, the Fixed-term Parliaments Act of 2011, well, it failed because it didn't work and it was realized that we need to retain that flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances, even if it means, as the country knows well enough, that this adaptation has meant six Prime Ministers in seven years. Now, there's one thing I do want to raise. Others have mentioned it before me, but that's the disadvantage of being down the list, and that's the issue of the Cabinet Manual.
If there is one point on which I hope my noble friend the Minister will reply is to update the House with progress on the next edition. The origins of the manual go back to what were called Questions of Procedures for Ministers in the 1970s, and then it was updated by the noble Lord, Lord O'Donnell, who I'm glad to see is in his place, and Lord Hennessy of Nympsfield, with the direct support and encouragement of the then Prime Minister, whose interest in architectural, the architecture of British politics is well known and to be respected. Now, I'm one of those who have long campaigned for a new edition of the manual. My time is up, so I just urge my noble friend to tell us how progress is going, what the process for approval might be, what consultations there will be in both Houses, and when will it be published. And following that, my Lord, I very much hope that this House will have a debate upon it, because it would make a fitting sequel to the debate that we are having today.
Usha Prashar
My Lords, I thank the noble and learned Lord, Lord Anderson, for securing this debate and his masterly introduction, but with light touch. My Lords, Andrew Blick and Peter Hennessy, recently mentioned, in their book, The Bonfire of Decencies: Repairing and Restoring the British Constitution, written following the Boris premiership, highlighted how the experience of the Johnson premiership demonstrated the fragility of our uncodified constitution. They argued that muddling through is no longer feasible. Although the system self-corrected itself, they say, these excesses are a warning. And more recently, as we've heard, the Prime Minister Burnham has said the greater devolution of powers within the UK strengthens the case for a written constitution and made reference to the German model.
And in the recent years, UK constitution has been under pressure for reasons such as Brexit and COVID, among others. And calls for a written constitution are not new, and arguments for and against are well-rehearsed. But however, in my view, what is clear is that our uncodified constitution needs attention. But my view is that a fully-blown written constitution, where we move from parliamentary supremacy to judicial supremacy, is not the answer to the concerns expressed.
We need evolution, not revolution. And I think the flexibility and the merits of our current arrangements were very well articulated by Lord Carter of Haslemere and I agree with what he said so I will not repeat them. But the current constitutional arrangements need enhancement in areas such as violation of conventions, unlawful activities of a challenging nature, violation of criminal law by ministers, breaking treaty obligations and international law, or compromising public institutions and values associated with it and eroding any mechanism that exists to police or limit overriding rules, conventions and limitations, for example parliament, courts and oversight bodies, particularly those of constitutional nature. Our current arrangements depend on these structures and their robustness and respect for them. The underlying changes faced in the recent years necessitate a look at the problem as a whole and not in my view piecemeal tinkering.
There have been a number of inquiries with recommendations and suggestions which need to be brought together and considered as a whole. We've had a number of inquiries, select committee recommendations and indeed I was involved in one two years ago, two years ago on the Governance Commission which was chaired by Dominic Grieve. But what we need I think is a cross-party commission which considers the recommendations already made, examine where the weaknesses are in our current arrangements, what needs to be strengthened and where we need harder enforcement. Such an exercise in my view would address the problems as a whole and their combined effect. This process could be used to encourage public awareness and show why respect for rules and conventions matters.
And I think the hidden wiring of our constitution as described by Lord Hennessy needs to be made more explicit in a document which is accessible and then that can be underpinned by the recommendations made by the Institute of Government to which Baroness Souza referred. I think those arrangements would work well. While I think such an exercise is necessary, it's not sufficient because the environment within which this operates also need attention. No constitution can function satisfactorily without a strong political realm. Addressing lack of trust and confidence in government and democratic institutions, tackling decline of lack of participation in political processes and initiatives to restore confidence in democracy which have given rise to populism, authoritarianism and consequent social divisions are equally if not more important.
And I think this is where, so what we do need is to strengthen and enhance our current constitutional arrangements and foster values which bolster democratic behaviors and encourages engagement of citizens. There is, this is where I think devolution can help because properly implemented it can bring decisions closer to communities, strengthen local leadership and enable greater public voice. It can through deliberative engagement foster social cohesion. True participation rests on the capacity to come together, build trust and have shared spaces for dialogue and collective problem solving. It is these which need to be woven into a devolution and not just a constitutional change.
Because devolution is not an administrative task or a rearrangement of the constitution, but it is also a genuine community building task. And if we neglect this, we risk the devolution that will be technical but socially brittle.
Ultimately, constitutional success depends on human beings rather than just written documents. Our uncodified constitution needs a refresh and a reform, and not the tearing down and replacement. So the question really is, is the government going to take a comprehensive look and not just continue to muddle on?
Alexander David Hugh Hannay
My Lords, we are bit formulaic in this House about congratulating colleagues for obtaining a slot in for a topical debate. Now I won't miss out today, but my noble friend deserves more than that because subjecting to scrutiny Britain's lack of a written constitution is an essential exercise, not just something to be taken for granted and for it simply to be assumed that because it's British and it's survived for centuries, it must be the best approach when most other countries, many but not all of them impeccable democracies, do have written constitutions. Indeed, it is a trifle odd that despite not having a written constitution ourselves, we had no compunction about writing constitutions for parts of our colonial possessions as they achieved independence. Now one reason for us to have a written constitution is that many of our fellow citizens believe we don't have a constitution at all, when in fact we have a collection of conventions and statutes which serve that purpose. Such a fundamental misunderstanding cannot be entirely satisfactory.
And then our present unclear situation does leave a very large amount of scope for disagreement and recourse to the courts, including the Supreme Court, for interpretation. That too is not entirely satisfactory, even rise quite recently to debate which detracts from our respect for the rule of law, which is fundamental to our freedoms. But such course cannot be entirely avoided, as we've heard this evening, it would arise very much so if we did have a written constitution. And the absence of a written constitution does make the teaching of our constitutional practice in schools and universities far more complex and difficult than it would otherwise be, and harder to absorb. So quite a list of arguments for switching to a written constitution, and there are plenty more than those I've mentioned, even leaving aside sloppy and self-serving ones drawn from the history of countries, including our nearest neighbors in the United States, who have and treasure their written constitutions.
But there are plenty of compelling arguments against switching in that direction. First, negotiating a written constitution would certainly be contentious, often opening up old wounds long since healed by time and patience. You only have to look at the official opposition's policy of withdrawing from the UK withdrawing the UK from the European Convention on Human Rights and its application by our courts to see how that might play out. And writing a written constitution for the UK would be likely to throw up many difficult, perhaps insoluble questions over devolution and the definition of devolved powers, not to speak, and this is really important, of the basic unity of the UK. It really is a little bit hard to see an SNP government in Edinburgh, a dual government in Belfast, and a Plaid Cymru government in Cardiff easily agreeing to a text on what the United Kingdom consists of.
So, having seen the absence of clarity from the situation emerging from our recent efforts at devolution, it's not easy to sustain the argument that dealing with those issues in a written constitution would be easy or straightforward.
It's also perhaps relevant that we don't seem to be terribly good at writing constitutions. Not only are there quite a few ex-colonies which we endowed with written constitutions that didn't stand the test of time, but look at the mess we made of the EU's constitutional treaty about which the noble Lord Lord Kerr spoke, where we happily allowed the European Community's founding treaty, the Treaty of Rome, which made no provision for a member state to leave, to have such a provision inserted and be retained in the Lisbon Treaty. Surely a case of painting a target on your own back for a decision which is now rather widely considered to have been an egregious error of judgment. Would we not have been better off without that? But perhaps the most compelling argument against switching to a written constitution would be the massive amount of legislative time that would be required to reach a conclusion.
This is time that would be at the expense of more mundane legislative tasks which would risk those latter being neglected, rushed or fudged. We already promulgate too many imperfect laws without programming a lot more of them. Now I've left out of this list of arguments against switching the likelihood that the means of choosing the members of your Lordships' House and even more so of defining its powers relative to those of the House of Commons could in itself prove just a trifle contentious and extremely hard to resolve. Now I don't habitually come down to arguing against reform, but in this case I do so, more for reasons of practicality than of principle. If it ain't broke, don't fix it, is quite a useful adage bequeathed to us by our transatlantic cousins.
Speaker 21
My Lords, I too wish to follow in that convention, but a very honorable and venerable convention of thanking the noble Lord Lord Anderson for securing this important debate, particularly at a time when democracy in different countries is being so tested both by economic and social strains, but also by authoritarians and extremists. And that makes this a good time to consider how we might be able to strengthen or improve our democracy through the use of a written constitution. Now that's an argument my party has long made and having listened carefully to several noble Lords express, I'm not sure if it was happiness or disappointment that the case for written constitutions had not been made more in this debate, let me summon up my courage and join the noble Lady Baroness Bennett in setting out some of those points. And I think it's worth starting with particularly an emphasis that written constitutions can take many forms. They take many forms in the degree to which they are embedded and they take many forms in the degree to which they give power to judges.
The USA's example scores very highly on both of those criteria, but it is by no means the only model available. And the German Basic Law has been mentioned a couple of times by noble Lords. It's worth emphasizing the German Basic Law has been amended over 60 times, including perhaps most notably recently to allow a policy decision by the German government to significantly increase defense spending. And I think that illustrates that it is possible to have a written constitution that brings benefits but is sufficiently flexible that it does not require a religious schism or a civil war to be amended. And one other thing that is of course common with written constitutions is just how widespread they are.
Other than New Zealand and Israel, I think I'm correct in saying that essentially every other modern democracy has a written constitution. And there is a risk, obviously not in this House, but sometimes in wider discussions on this topic, therefore, of a certain myopic insularity of talking about problems in theory with written constitutions that are in fact problems that many other countries have found solutions to and practically implemented written constitutions to address. And across those different models, though, there is that common essential quality of the idea that a written constitution provides some grit in the system, some limitation on the ability to do whatever, whenever, however, to whoever by the government. And I should say that perhaps that is in many ways something that we are a little bit more familiar with than we sometimes remember in these debates, because one example I would suggest of embedding such grit in the system are the Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949. They are to some extent embedded.
They are to some extent, as indeed the plurality of the phrase Parliament Acts illustrates, open to amendment. And they have shown how a degree of embedding can be an extremely useful part of our constitution. And there are particular reasons why such grit is useful and indeed may become more useful in the near future, because while we have, for the moment at least, the first-past-the-post electoral system for the House of Commons, and we have a five, six, or indeed in Scotland and Wales perhaps one might more accurately at times say seven-party system around the country, what that means is in practice it is absolutely possible for a party to win a clear majority in the House of Commons on less than 30% of the vote. We could have a government elected where two-thirds of those voting have voted against it and, as our current setup would give it, very extensive power, very extensive power indeed, that would flow from its majority in the House of Commons. Now, obviously when making this point, I believe it is one of our constitutional conventions that somebody has to make reference to Lord Hailsham and elective dictatorship, but I think it is worth bearing in mind that just how much the electoral system has changed even since when his, sorry, the electoral system has in practice changed since even when he made those comments, given how much lower the winning post now is for governments.
And that grit in the system can be extremely helpful as a protection for the unfashionable, the unpopular, the minority, but also as an aid, in fact, to better decision-making, because in many ways what a written constitution could provide for our country is what the House of Lords provides for Parliament. We do not take away the democratic sovereignty of the House of Commons, but by adding a little more process, a little more grit, be able to occasionally enforce a little more reflection, one might even say, on the House of Commons, we enable those democratic decisions to be better. There is also a benefit, as has been touched on by several noble Lords, of the sort of consolidation aspect, as one might call it, of a written constitution, that ability to pull together different documents in a way that makes the way our rules operate clearer and more transparent. Noble Lords, I fear, are already slightly bored of hearing me talk about this in the context of election law, the many benefits that it brings from having the clarity that comes from a robust, consolidated set of rules, but those benefits are by no means constrained simply to elections. They are benefits that can be taken much more broadly.
Now, the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, quoted rather, expressing it rather more poetically than I have, Gavin Esler making this point, and I think it is an important, valuable one. I've in the past made the comparison with how sometimes our attitude towards the statute book and other laws and rules that we have is a little bit like that of a teenager with a messy bedroom, that you know at one point sometime in the future it's going to be worth tidying it up, but you always find an excuse to put it off.
Which is why my hopes have been raised by the fact that we have a Prime Minister who is now, we now have a Prime Minister who has previously made such positive comments about the benefits of a written constitution. So I very much look forward to hearing from the noble lady the Minister in due course what the government plans are to actually bring to life those previous comments by the Prime Minister. Plans, I'm sure we could all agree, whatever we might otherwise think about the merits of them, but plans that I'm sure we can all agree we hope the government is planning a route that requires neither civil war nor religious schism to bring about what the Prime Minister has previously praised so much.
The Baroness Finn
My Lords, I too thank the noble Lord Lord Anderson of Ipswich for bringing this debate to the House today. In his Lord Radcliffe lecture on a written constitution in 2023, the noble Lord said, "Our constitution is sick, though the illness is chronic rather than acute." That diagnosis, combined with the Prime Minister's own interest in a written constitution, makes today's debate timely, and we have heard a range of thought-provoking contributions from across the House. The noble Lord Lord Anderson of Ipswich's constructive introduction to this debate was especially helpful given the complexity of the issues and level of disagreement on the right way forward. The noble Lord briefly argued for a stronger Cabinet Manual and putting HOLAC and the Independent Adviser, among others, on a statutory basis.
That is separate from our debate today, but I would gently point out that our constitution relies more on balances than checks. As such, the proposals would undermine the flexibility of our constitution to its detriment. My Lords, the constitution of the United Kingdom can be summarized in eight words: whatever the Crown in Parliament enacts is law. Ministers are drawn from and accountable to Parliament, and the judiciary ensures the government acts within the law as set by Parliament. In recent years, the Prime Minister has shown an interest in a written constitution for the United Kingdom.
He argued in his book Head North that devolution will not work, and I quote, "unless we build the new Britain on the strong foundation of a written constitution." More recently, in June this year, he spoke of giving Number 10 North a mission to strive for equivalent living conditions in all parts of Britain, borrowing from the German Basic Law, as many noble Lords have referenced today. The German Basic Law being the 1949 written constitution of the German state. Although the Prime Minister was not specific about which part of the German Basic Law he was referring to, I think it is reasonable to assume that he was reflecting on the 2006 amendment to the German Basic Law creating Article 104b, which established a mechanism through which the German Federation is able to provide financial assistance to the federal states, or Länder, of Germany with a purpose to: one, avert a disturbance of the overall economic equilibrium; two, equalize differing economic capacities within the federal territory; or three, promote economic growth. Successive governments have indeed adopted measures to tackle inequality of opportunity across the United Kingdom, and it is not clear to me why a basic law or written constitution is a necessary prerequisite for effective progress towards that objective.
Perhaps the noble Baroness the Minister would take the opportunity in her response to this debate today to confirm whether the Prime Minister was indeed referring to Article 104b of the German Basic Law and set out further details of the Prime Minister's plans for a written constitution. If she cannot provide that clarity today, perhaps she would commit to writing with that detail.
My Lords, whatever the Prime Minister's plans in respect of a UK version of Article 104b, he should consider carefully whether it might not be simpler and no doubt much quicker to place that provision on the statute book in the normal way, with the full inviolable authority of Parliament, rather than allowing his proposal to be bogged down in a more fundamental and extremely contentious debate about codified constitutions. As Lord Sumption argued in a recent UCL Constitution Unit blog, there is nothing that a written constitution could achieve that could not be achieved with equal efficacy by ordinary parliamentary legislation. And whatever the Prime Minister's view of written constitutions, the motion before us invites a much broader consideration of the benefits and disadvantages of a written constitution. The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, has expressed his support for a codified constitution that is reflective of existing arrangements rather than a vehicle for reform. Others have expressed their own views in this debate.
Whatever benefits may be gained from having a written constitution, whether that be a public understanding or clarity for lawmakers, we know constitutional flexibility would be a victim of a written constitution, whatever form it may take. The noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, has himself previously quoted the late US Supreme Court Justice Scalia on this point, who argued: "The very objective of a basic law is to place certain matters beyond risk of change, except through the extraordinary democratic majorities that constitutional amendment requires. The whole purpose of a constitution, old or new, is to impede change, or pejoratively put, obstruct modernity." My Lords, we have never fallen victim to that sea-anchor approach to constitutional rules, instead adopting a consensual style and system of conventions and practices that allow effective government to be carried on, even in circumstances unforeseen by the drafters of a written constitution. We have also generally been spared the frustrations of legal deadlock between Parliament and the courts.
That simple constitutional principle, the sovereignty of Parliament, underpins so many of the processes and practices allowing the King's government to be carried on without the intrusion of overmighty justices as seen in the United States of America and elsewhere. In his 2025 lecture on the unwritten constitution, Lord Sales argued of our existing settlement, and I quote: "In the historical record, its flexibility has on balance been an advantage," and I fully agree with him. The noble Lord, Lord Anderson's position is that a written constitution need not be a revolutionary document, nor need it be a vehicle for radical reform. But is it not the case that in all our examples bar the Kingdom of the Netherlands, codification of the constitution has opened the door to judgments in the courts striking down new legislation that is in conflict with the text of the codified constitution? Is that not a revolutionary change in our constitutional settlement in itself?
Another major concern with any proposal for a codified constitution is the de facto obligation for judges to take political decisions. Under the Human Rights Act 1998, judges must, so far as possible, interpret legislation compatibly with convention rights. Where that is not possible, the higher courts may issue declarations of incompatibility. Such declarations do not invalidate acts of Parliament, but in order to make them, judges must undertake evaluative exercises that necessarily require them to balance competing public interests that should more properly be undertaken by Parliament, an argument so eloquently advanced by my noble friend Lord Howe of Aberavon.
Under the former European Communities Act 1972, courts were required to disapply domestic legislation which conflicted with directly effective European law. These arrangements forced judges to intrude into the political arena in a way that has been helpful neither to the judges themselves nor to our mode of democratic accountability. A codified constitution with the status of a higher law would take this further by inviting courts to set aside acts of Parliament which they judged inconsistent with it. That would be a fundamental change in the way our constitution functions, and it is certainly not a step to be taken lightly. There is no way of creating a higher form of law that does not fly dilute the principle of parliamentary accountability.
If Parliament could amend or appeal it by ordinary legislation, it would have no higher status. If it could not, future Parliaments would be bound by rules they could not change through the normal democratic process. What mandate then would be sufficient for the approval and amendment of a written constitution? If clarity is all that is sought, then perhaps a supermajority in both Houses of Parliament would suffice. Or if this is something that only those with a democratic mandate should decide, perhaps it ought to be approved by a supermajority in the House of Commons alone.
If the latter is the case, is there a risk this new document is then used by the House of Commons to weaken the ancient rights, duties, liberties and duties of your Lordships' House, or indeed other parts of the constitution, without recourse the normal legislative process. Perhaps a mandate from outside Parliament through referendums would be more appropriate. Both have their drawbacks. In the case of a parliamentary supermajority, this may be difficult to achieve, and it would likely never be achieved without the governing party voting for a constitution or any amendment to it. In effect, it would remain in the gift of the executive to create and amend constitutional rights.
If referendums were to be the chosen mechanism, we might face costly national exercises in democracy even more frequently than we do now. I think we would need to see evidence that the electorate genuinely wanted to see more regular referendums if we were to consider that mechanism. My Lords, in its basic shape and function, the Crown in Parliament has guided this nation through the industrial revolution. The creation, expansion and dismantlement of an empire. The successful prosecution of war against Napoleon and of two world wars.
The creation of a welfare state after the Second World War and the market turn in the philosophy of government brought about by the late noble Baroness Lady Thatcher. It has proved remarkably flexible and durable, adapting to both pandemic and war, to changing needs and times, to evolving public spiritual and moral values. We must each of us ask ourselves, is there truly another country to which we can look and say we wish we were governed as they are? For my own part, I think not. With all its advantages and compromises, we have inherited from those who sat here before us the most stable constitutional settlement in the democratic world of which we can and should be justly proud.
Speaker 6
My Lords, I'm going to add my thanks to the noble Lord Lord Anderson of Ipswich for securing this fascinating debate on the proposals for a written constitution and for his very thought-provoking introduction. This is a vast and complex subject that has been long debated, including in your Lordships' House. We've heard many interesting contributions from across the House, without picking out any particular favorites, I am going to, I'd like to say that I particularly enjoyed the contribution by my noble friend Lord Griffiths of Burry Port, which was both entertaining and fascinating, but almost also demonstrated some of the challenges we face in this area of debate.
The government warmly welcomes the opportunity to debate these issues in Parliament. As the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, made clear, this is of interest well beyond this chamber, including amongst students, not least those taught by my amazing and noble friend, Lord Murphy of Torfaen. And I think it was the noble Lord, Lord Hannay of Chiswick, who said that a written constitution would make teaching students easier, which is one argument in favour of a written constitution, perhaps, though not necessarily a defining one. I thought it was helpful to hear alternative views put forward to noble Lords by the noble lady, Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle, although I didn't necessarily agree with everything she said. It was also interesting to hear the noble Lord, Lord Kerr of Kinlochard's account of a failed attempt at writing a constitution for the EU.
I welcome the alternative view of the noble Lord, Lord Pack, which significantly balanced out the debate in his support for a written constitution. As noble Lords are clearly aware, our constitutional system is somewhat unusual. Noble Lords, including the noble and learned Lord Mance, noted that it is uncodified, and as my noble friend Viscount Stansgate said, it isn't in one document. It is indeed dispersed across many documents and sources. As the noble and learned Lord Burnett of Maldon said, it has evolved over time and is made up of conventions, statutes, judicial decisions, principles and practices.
And as the noble lady, Baroness Finn, said in her remarks, it relies more on balances and checks, and like every constitution, my Lords, it is imperfect. However, it is also flexible and adaptable. This is a core feature of our constitution, and it has served us well, as many noble Lords, including the noble Lord, Lord Howard of Lympne, made clear. It is not written down in a single place, yet it exists. And I would agree with my noble friend Lord Murphy that it is strong.
I would also agree that a written constitution does not in itself necessarily confer protection. As the noble Lord, Lord Howard, made clear, totalitarian regimes would not be deterred by a written constitution per se. And as the noble Lord, Lord Burnett, said, all written constitutions are vulnerable to bad actors. The example given by the noble lady, Baroness Manningham-Buller, of 1930s Germany demonstrates this powerfully, and the many other examples given today and that exist. My Lords, it is the very features of the UK's constitution that mean that it is not frozen in aspic, nor indeed should they be if we want a political system that delivers for everyone.
The noble lady, Baroness Prashar, mentioned the need for trust and for us to rebuild trust, and this is key. The government's priority, my Lords, is a politics that works for all people in all places, not just some people in some places. We are beginning the work of shifting power and resources away from Whitehall, as set out in the Rewiring the State cabinet statement of 31st of July. We've already launched the biggest transfer of power from Westminster in a generation. That includes the largest package of financial powers ever offered to English mayors, with a retained share of income tax revenues for the first time.
We will replace the current model of consultation by default with new and modern forms of public participation. The noble Lord, Lord Pack, mentioned electoral reform, and as the Prime Minister has announced, the government intends to establish a new national commission on electoral reform, and has invited all political parties to be part of this work. We want everyone's vote to count and everyone's voice to be heard. The government is not afraid of going further, and where there is a case for doing so, codifying elements of our constitutional arrangements. The noble lady, Baroness D'Souza, referred to the IFG recommendation of a new joint committee on the constitution.
The establishment of a joint committee is clearly a matter for Parliament rather than government. I also note that the Lords Constitution Committee is already undertaking an important inquiry into the UK constitutional safeguards as mentioned by a number of noble lords, and I look forward to reading the findings of this inquiry in due course. As the noble lord Lord Anderson and the noble and learned lord Lord Mance highlighted, and as referred to by my noble friend Viscount Stansgate, the government is currently drafting an update to the Cabinet Manual. The Cabinet Manual, as noble lords will be aware, serves as an authoritative guide to the UK's constitutional arrangement. It's the executive's view on the processes and rules around the operation of government, including the formation of a government following an election.
The Cabinet Manual is not intended to be a written constitution, but acts as a practical document to help ministers, officials and the public understand how government works and its interaction with other parts of the constitution. It was first published in 2011 and it has become significantly out of date, most notably, as has been noted during the course of today's debate, in its descriptions of the UK's relationship with the EU, of general elections and of the devolution settlement. An update will therefore restore the manual's status as an authoritative guide. The government will seek feedback from parliamentary select committees on proposed revisions. This is intended to be a meaningful opportunity for MPs and peers to support the updating process so that the manual continues to be a non-party political document that provides a record of fact.
My noble friend Viscount Stansgate asked about progress and when this will likely to work was likely to come to a conclusion. I'm pleased to be able to confirm to noble lords that the update to the manual is well underway and we intend to publish the updated manual early next year. The noble lord Lord Anderson asked for the government's view on a written constitution. The government welcomes feedback, continued discussion and debate like the one we are having today on the next steps on constitutional form. That is different to converting the UK's uncodified constitutional arrangements into a single written document for its own sake.
The noble lord Lord Boyd, the noble and learned lord Lord Boyd wisely cautioned us to consider the time and effort it would take to create a codified constitution, and the noble lord Lord Anderson's own work on this subject shows constitutional reform is not a straightforward subject and there are steps well short of a written constitution that we can consider. As time goes on and as society changes, as new issues emerge, constitutional arrangements need to adapt accordingly. Indeed, one of the main issues with written constitutions is that they can become out of date very quickly, as the procedures and rules for amending them may often become cumbersome and difficult to satisfy. Before I conclude, there are another couple of points I did wish to cover, not least a number of noble lords, including Lord Anderson, Lord Burnett, the noble and learned lord Lord Boyd and the noble and learned lord Lord Carter of Haslemere referred to the role of the judiciary. We do believe and are very clear that it is important that we have an independent judiciary, and during the debate the risk of creating an over-powerful judiciary under a written constitution was also noted, not least by the noble lord Lord Howard.
An independent judiciary is, however, a cornerstone of our constitutional arrangements. The noble lord Lord Kakkar and the noble lady Baroness Finn also referred to parliamentary sovereignty, as did others, and I agree with the noble lord Lord Kakkar on the importance of parliamentary sovereignty as a central tenet of our constitutional arrangements.
In conclusion, my Lords, I'd like to once more thank the noble Lord Anderson for leading a very thought-provoking discussion on our constitutional arrangements. As the noble Lord Pack said, it was timely given what a testing time we live in. This government's priority is to establish a politics that works for all people in all places, not some people in some places. We're serious about constitutional reform and we will take bold steps where there is a case to do so.
Anderson
I thank the noble Baroness the Minister for her response, and I thank all noble Lords who have participated in this scintillating debate. I was reminded as it went on of Oliver Cromwell's speech to the first protectorate parliament of 1654, in which he famously said, "In every government there must be somewhat fundamental, somewhat like a Magna Carta that should be standing and unalterable." That caused me to reflect on two things: that we've been debating a written constitution in Westminster for almost 400 years without reaching a conclusion, but also that this might be one of those issues where the journey in terms of the scrutiny that it provokes is more important than the destination. A formally binding codified constitution was not generally thought to be on the horizon, notwithstanding the Prime Minister's recent words, and appeared to many to be a practical impossibility, not least given the current politics of devolution. But the predominant view that a written constitution is neither necessary nor feasible was vigorously challenged by the noble lady Baroness Bennett and by the noble Lord Pack, who described the advantages of grit in the system.
Their views, I suspect, will have resonance outside this chamber. As to the Prime Minister's views, it was impressive to see them analyzed in forensic detail from the opposition front bench. The Minister was perhaps a little more circumspect, but if she writes the letter tentatively requested by Baroness Finn, and I wouldn't put a lot of my money on that, I shall be fascinated to see it. The noble and learned Lord Mance warned us against the complacency of Mr. Podsnap and suggested, as did the noble Lord Hannay, that we might have something to learn from what has been done in other places. I feel sure, for my part, that Lord Mance's praise for the German constitution is more securely founded than was the favorable opinion referred to by the noble lady Baroness Manningham-Buller of its 1930 predecessor.
I could not agree more with the noble Lord Howard's deprecation of politically appointed judges and would urge all who feel the same way to resist calls to abolish the Judicial Appointments Commission, which might not be a perfect institution but is, I think, when one looks at the alternatives, a very necessary one. We had some constructive suggestions for constitution renewal related to the Sewel convention, concordats, HOLAC, a stronger cabinet manual, and so on, not all of them uncontroversial, but like much else we've heard this evening, they deserve further thought. I beg to move.
Speaker 150
The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion shall say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
The House do now adjourn.