House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittingsDavid Hunt
My Lords, the Office for Budget Responsibility has just concluded that the Employment Rights Act 2025 will have a negative economic effect, something that we on these benches and all employers have been warning about for a very long time. Does the noble Lord the Minister agree with the OBR? And if so, what is he going to do about it?
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, let me say in the nicest possible way to the noble Lord and to noble Lords across that supporting business enterprise means combining a hard head with a soft heart. The Employment Rights Act strengthens provisions and protections and security for working people. But legislation can only set minimum standards. The law establishes the floor. Good businesses should compete to raise the ceiling.
No Act of Parliament can make an employer care about their staff. That comes from leadership, values and culture.
In my experience, looking after your people is fundamental to business success. Now regarding the OBR, we respect the OBR's independent judgment. It expects a negative economic impact, as the noble Lord has said, but find no clear evidence that it exceeds 0.1% of potential output. So has made no explicit forecast adjustments.
Speaker 19
My Lords, while the minister is talking about hard edges to business, it's two years since the then Chancellor made a surprise increase in the National Insurance contribution for UK businesses. So can the minister tell us how many more jobs there would have been if this had not been brought in? How many SMEs have gone to the wall as a result of this tipping them over the edge? And how much investment has been deferred because of this measure?
Sonny Liang
So my Lords, look, firstly, I recognise the pressures on employers. We took the difficult decision to stabilise public finances and fund essential services, whilst increasing the employment allowance to £10,500 to protect smaller businesses. We are also supporting recruitment through the youth jobs grant of up to £3,000 and apprenticeship hiring payment of 2,000. Our aim is to help businesses create opportunities and give young people the skills and experience to build lasting careers.
Margaret Ritchie
My Lords. My Lords. Would my noble friend the minister agree with me that it's important to be positive in relation to these matters and that the Employment Rights Act, along with today's announcement about the potential SPS agreement, will underscore the importance of our food exports and our food industry and the many jobs that are employed in it and the potential for new employment?
Sonny Liang
My Lords, I totally agree with my noble friend there. Look, my Lords, look, the labour market is changing. Provisional ONS figures for the year to September 2026 shows payrolls increased by 66,000 in administrative and support services, 20,000 in education and 19,000 in health and social care. Wholesale and retail lost 71,000, accommodation and food services, 46 and manufacturing, 32,000. We are backing investment, skills and sector jobs plan to help businesses recruit and people move into secure long-term employment.
Speaker 23
My Lords, as my Lords, as the Chair of the International Chamber of Commerce in the UK and a former university chancellor, it saddens me that almost a million young people are not in education, employment or training. What is the government doing to help university graduates get jobs, because they are really struggling to find jobs at the moment and they deserve to get those jobs?
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, look, I fully accept that the labour market is failing too many graduates. Repeated rejection wastes talent and damages confidence. We are investing 7.8 million in universities' AI courses and graduate traineeships, with our 20 million early careers job alliance helps employers maintain routes into work as technology changes. The Digital and Technologies Jobs Plan target 20,000 entry-level jobs annually. So, our responsibility is to turn those commitments into interviews, paid opportunities and lasting careers.
Speaker 10
My Lords. My Lords. opportunity to disassociate himself from the remarks of the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, who said employers are not working people. Thousands of small businesses and employers like myself take great exception to this, because it goes to the mindset and attitude of the government.
Sonny Liang
Firstly, look, let me say this to the noble Lord. I mean, look, at the end of the day, as far as employers and employees and suppliers, is part of ecosystem and we've got to support the employees and the suppliers as well.
Now, our, the way of tackling unemployment is by working with employers and actually looking at a pathway into any growing industries. Let me share with noble Lords, I mean, the professional and business services firms have pledged to create 22,400 apprenticeship or for young people under the age of 25 over the next five years. Construction aims to create 10,000 job opportunities each year, while digital and technology employers are targeting 20,000 entry-level jobs. So these sector jobs blends link investment to skills and recruitment, and our focus is turning those commitments into lasting careers.
Speaker 13
My Lords, isn't there a situ- Isn't there a situation, whereas we just heard earlier, there are a million youngsters not able to get into work? Many university graduates who then face the sort of questions of, "Have you got a degree and have you got two years' experience?" How are they going to get two years' experience if employers won't actually take them on? That's just one example of dysfunctionality in the labour market.
Speaker 15
What is the government doing actively to engage with employers to get a rational labour market, will enable youngsters at all levels of jobs to get into work?
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, let me share with my noble friend here, we are determined to tackle youth unemployment, and look forward to receiving Alan Milburn's recommendations. In addition to that, my Lords, we have committed a further £2.5 billion to the Youth Guarantee and Growth and Skills Levy, helping nearly 1 million young people aged 16 to 24 move into job, education, and training. So, this will create 200,000 jobs through 3,000 youth jobs grants, 2,000 apprenticeship hiring payments, and guaranteed jobs for young people claiming universal credit who have been unemployed long-term.
Mark Harper
I'm surprised the noble Lord the minister couldn't answer my noble friend Lord Leigh's question, because the Chancellor slapped down the Chief Secretary for her ridiculous comments and I'm glad that he did so. But can I just ask him, he gave a good answer to the question from the noble Lord opposite about how to deal with the million young people out of work. How does he think importing up to 80,000 young people from the European Union under the Youth Mobility Scheme is going to help British young people get into work?
Sonny Liang
My Lords, look. We have made settlement based on contributions, not just on time served, as it was under the last government. And we have cut net migration to 82% below its peak under the last government. So, my Lords, we will not leave young British people behind, which is why we are investing an additional £2.5 billion, which I've said in my previous answer, to support almost 1 million young people into education, employment, and training.
Speaker 17
The minister be aware that yesterday there was a report published by UK AI on AI industry guide, which found that there a distinct lack of progress in the promised advanced technology jobs, particularly for women, in many of the inner-city areas. Would noble Lord the Minister consider looking at the report and its finding, and consider meeting the group?
Sonny Liang
Well, I must say, I haven't had a chance to look at the report, but I will definitely have a look at that report itself. But let me share something about AI. My Lords, AI is automating repetitive tasks, and we take the risks to entry job levels seriously.
So, the 20 million early careers job alliance that I mentioned earlier is helping employers redesign roles whilst maintaining routes into work. And through our AI skills boost, we aim to equip 10 million people with practical AI skills by 2030. So, our priority is adoption that supports workers, improves productivity, and opens opportunities. Technology prepares, or rather technology progress, must give young people a better future, not close the door.
Speaker 11
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper.
Speaker 14
The government has made no assessment of the proposals for the permanent return to Greece of the Parthenon sculptures held by the British Museum. We welcome the fact that the British Museum is in discussions with Greek ministers seeking a constructive partnership.
Speaker 11
My Lords, we hear the legal and nationalistic arguments for return, but surely the key argument is the aesthetic one. If, for example, Picasso's Guernica were to be cut into pieces and displayed in different museums, there would be an almighty clamour to get those pieces reunited. Should not the same consideration be given to Phidias's masterwork? Secondly, the government says this is a matter for the British Museum, except that its hands are tied by the British Museum Act. Will the government amend the Act in a limited way so a decision can be made?
Speaker 14
The British Museum and the government recognises the strength of feeling on this, and the British Museum has consistently stated that it would consider a loan request for the sculptures on the condition that the British Museum's ownership is acknowledged and that a binding undertaking is given to return them. In relation to the Charities Act, which is I think what the noble Earl was alluding to, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport has committed to review the implementation of sections 15 and 16 as part of the post-implementation review of the whole of the Charities Act 2022, and this review is due to report in February 2027.
Speaker 21
Museums are stuffed full of artefacts acquired from abroad, frequently in rather doubtful circumstances. Returning the sculptures would be a most unfortunate precedent.
Speaker 14
So, I think we do have a clear view that museums are independent of government. This is one of the principles we adhere to. There are clear examples of museums returning items. As I said, however, the current position is that the British Museum is not planning to permanently return the Parthenon marbles, and that remains their position.
Alfred Dubs
My Lords, many of us have for long argued that the Parthenon sculptures should be returned to Greece, notwithstanding what the minister said just now. I wonder if the minister could clarify something. Does she believe that the present legislation, that's to say the Museums Act of section 5(1)(c) of the British Museum Act, would be sufficient to return the sculptures, or does it require new legislation?
Speaker 14
The British Museum Act 1963 prevents the museum from disposing of items in its collection, with limited exceptions for duplicates and objects not fit for retention, with specific exemptions created in legislation for objects taken during the Nazi era and for human remains under 1,000 years old. We really welcome the fact that the British Museum is in discussion with Greek ministers seeking a constructive partnership.
The director of the museum has alluded to the Bayeux Tapestry loan as a potential model, which is an interesting idea, and clearly, the loan of the tapestry is proving a huge success story.
Dominic Hubbard
Would the government give us some assurance that if there is an agreement reached by the British Museum with Greece that they will allow the time for any legislation that is needed to be passed to happen within this Parliament?
Speaker 14
So at present, there isn't an agreement for us to lean into in that way, but as I mentioned, the British Museum really does recognize the strength of feeling on this and it is working very hard to try and find an arrangement that works within the current legal framework. I can only refer noble Lords to the point I made earlier around the implementation of sections 15 and 16 of the Charities Act, which is part of the review. However, we are open to the museum exploring a loan agreement if that is agreeable with the Greek ministers and population.
Shami Chakrabarti
My Lords, if my Lords If some of the crown jewels have been pinched, I don't think that we would be so glad of a loan agreement. So, given what my noble friend the Minister has said about this being a matter for the British Museum, will, as other noble Lords have said, the British Museum's act be amended to untie the hands of the museum?
Speaker 14
We currently don't have plans to review the British Museum's act. It's not something that's been in the King's Speech. I think that we do, however, recognize the strength of feeling on this, and I can only stress that the British Museum is working extremely hard and discussing possible solutions with Greek ministers.
Speaker 27
My Lords, over six million people every year enjoy viewing the Elgin Marbles, and the British Museum's stance is clear. It is a far greater concern that this government is considering allowing mayors to introduce a holiday tax on both British and international visitors like the ones to the British Museum. It will weaken tourism. It will put jobs at risk. Why is the government intent on yet another tax levy which will hurt the economy?
Speaker 14
I'm slightly surprised that the noble Lord is taking this line of questioning. What the government is trying to do is to empower mayoral strategic authorities and strategic authorities to introduce a potential visitor levy on short-term overnight accommodation in their regions to drive economic growth, including for support for the visitor economy. Personally, and I know this will be the case for many noble Lords across your Lordships' House, I think very little of paying an additional supplementary fee when I pay for hotel accommodation overseas routinely. We're clear that local leaders are going to be setting out plans for how the revenues would be invested by early 2028, and there's plenty of time to discuss how the levy would work and the potential impact. But at the moment, we're clear that this is a positive step to enable mayors to drive their local economies.
Speaker 26
My Lords, referring back to a previous answer by the Minister, could she, for the reassurance of the House and any international partners who may be listening, reassure us that it is the government's intention for the permanent return of the Bayeux Tapestry after its sensational run here, which has now been visited by more than 200,000 visitors, I understand?
Speaker 14
I would like to reassure the noble lord, not least because of his role in ensuring that we were able to bring the Bayeux Tapestry to the UK for the first time in more than 900 years, that there's absolutely no intention, and it would be over my dead body in fact that we'd try to keep the Bayeux Tapestry in this country.
My Lords.
Labour.
Speaker 34
My Lords, before I ask a question, can I wish all the noble lords a happy Diwali, which is at the weekend? My question is, when Britain British Britain annexed Sikh Empire in 1849, the Koh-i-Noor diamond was taken from its young Maharaja, Duleep Singh, he was only 10 years old,
and subsequently presented to Queen Victoria. Many Sikhs have long maintained that the diamond was taken under duress and it was rightful belong to the heritage. Will the Government consider returning the Koh-i-Noor diamond to the Sikh community as an act of historical injustice?
Speaker 14
I thank my noble friend for raising this issue and for his I share his best wishes to everyone celebrating Diwali. I recognise the historical significance for the Sikh community. The diamond does have a contested history. However, it remains the UK's government's longstanding position that the Koh-i-Noor diamond should remain in the UK.
Speaker 32
As a former archaeologist, I've got some sympathy with the Greek government, who argues that the sculptures were actually bought from the Ottoman Empire and not from the Greek Empire. And so, perhaps there is a strong argument for returning them. I've visited the Parthenon, and there are some quite naked bits where the sculptures ought to fit back.
Speaker 14
I can only reiterate that the UK has got a really strong relationship with Greece, built on shared values and history, and we greatly value the friendship that exists between our people today. The government doesn't have any plans to change the law, introduce legislation to permit the Parthenon sculptures to be returned permanently. However, we do recognise, as the British Museum does, the strength of feeling on this and support it in its stating that it would consider a loan request for the sculpture, should that be agreeable.
Meral Ece
The Greek government have been negotiating for decades on this issue and for them
Lib Dem.
Meral Ece
Thank you. The Greek government have been trying to negotiate the return of the Parthenon of the Parthenon Marbles for decades, and I think we need to acknowledge it's a very it's an integral part of their cultural heritage. A purpose-built museum has been built near the site of the Parthenon, where it would be displayed, where it was originally displayed for 2,000 years. So, I think the noble Lord sitting on the Conservative benches put his finger on it.
The British Museum is stuffed full of artefacts from around the world, and in fact I understand that there is as much that's not displayed in the basements, in the vaults, so maybe it'd be an opportunity to bring some of those out if they would return the Parthenon Marbles to Greece.
Speaker 14
I think that I can only reiterate that we've got no plans to legislate to do this at the moment, but we genuinely understand the strength of feeling, as does the British Museum.
Speaker 30
Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, last month, the Government confirmed plans to recruit a national brain tumour lead with details to follow.
As announced by the Prime Minister, the national lead will coordinate action and drive forward work to improve outcomes for brain tumour patients, supported by our rare cancer, clinical and research leads and working with the National Cancer Board.
Speaker 38
My Lords, I congratulate 25-year-old Archie Goodburn, the Commonwealth medallist living with a currently incurable brain tumour for securing this commitment from the Prime Minister for a clinical lead on this devastating disease. Brain tumours are the biggest cancer killer of children and young people under 40, but despite this, there has been no change or progress in treatment in over 40 years. Would the minister agree with me that the only way to change outcomes is to accelerate at pace the number and range of clinical trials taking place, so that there is a chance of a cure for Archie and other patients?
Gillian Merron
Well, I know how much the Prime Minister appreciated his meeting with Archie and indeed, the Prime Minister has acknowledged that enough progress has not been made in this area and committed, as my noble friend said, to a number of actions. I certainly would agree with my noble friend's view on the importance of clinical trials, and I can say to my noble friend that, as we set out in the National Cancer Plan, we are committed to ensuring that the UK supports new clinical trials in respect of brain cancer, but also boosting participation in research. Both of these really need to be pushed forward and we are fast-tracking clinical trial setup times to 150 days to ensure that more patients can access innovative treatments in our country.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, I pay tribute to the swimmer Archie Goodburn for his courage in campaigning for people affected by brain cancer and welcome the government's commitment to commission an expert review, but will the government ensure that the review will set out clear, time-bound recommendations with named bodies responsible for actual delivery in this area and that progress against them is published?
Gillian Merron
Well, we are keen to be open about this and the immediate expert review, which will take just three months, will be led by Professor Anthony Chalmers, and it will examine progress since the 2018 brain tumour research report and I very much look forward to that report within three months, because a national action plan, and I'm sure it will refer to the points the noble lady makes, will then help us move discoveries from the laboratory into treatments and clinical care much more quickly, and that's where we need to be.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, may I ask what powers the appointment will have, given that 74% of patients are diagnosed in A&E because of delays at diagnosis in primary care, resulting in 45% of them being told in A&E that they have a brain tumour? And yet, there is, even when they have a biopsy, there are inadequate freezing facilities for biopsies to be taken and kept, so that personalised medicine can be developed and entered into studies.
Gillian Merron
Well, to the point on brain tissue freezing, NHS England has, as the noble lady may be aware, just completed a freezer capacity gap analysis and is in the process of working with sites to ensure additional capacity. And I would certainly share with the noble lady her view that identification in an emergency setting is not the best place, although that will sometimes be the case, and that is why all of this movement is to reduce that incidence.
Speaker 36
My Lords, I want to pick on two aspects of the very welcome new appointment. The first is the degree to which the patient's voice, so often overlooked in this particular area, will be heard, and will be listening to it be part of the remit?
And the second is about timing. Can the Minister please reassure us on the speediness of the appointment, given that most cancer patients from diagnosis, brain cancer patients have 12 to 18 months to live? They do not have the luxury of time on their side.
Gillian Merron
Well, I think that has been acknowledged by the Prime Minister, for example, in this review being so rapid and within 3 months, and also that the Prime Minister is taking personal oversight of this work, and I think again that's to be welcomed. Indeed, on the patient's voice, one of the outcomes from discussions is that the Secretary of State will be convening researchers, clinicians, charities, for example, to identify the practical ways to increase participation in brain cancer trial. And certainly, the Prime Minister has asked patients, families and charities to work with us to help raise awareness and support participation in clinical trials. So, certainly, for me, the patient's voice is absolutely critical, and I know will be at the heart of this.
Kamlesh Patel
We recognize that outcomes for people with brain tumors, cancers, particularly for children, is no more than 13 months 5-year survival. Whilst it's important to do clinical trials using drugs, the problem we have is the blood-brain barrier protects the brain from being affected by these drugs, so we need to find novel ways of treatment, and there are being researched, like focused ultrasound, for instance, and microRNA treatments, and developing personalized vaccines for each of the tumor, particularly developed for that particular patient. So, we need to support novel ways of finding treatment for brain tumors, which does not apply to other diseases.
Gillian Merron
Well, the noble Lord is right, but that is also, I think, why we have to work so much quicker to move discoveries from research into treatments and clinical care. It has been sadly lacking, and that is why the number of points that the Prime Minister announced, including an accelerated review by the MHRA of the regulatory arrangements for rare disease medicines, known as orphan drugs, and I just mention that as one example, will complete their work in 2 years rather than 3. We do understand the need for speed, and we also understand and acknowledge that, sadly, we're in a position where not enough progress has been made in this area.
Salah Syed Kamall
My Lords, can I also welcome the government's commitment to establishing a dedicated national brain cancer lead? But my question is really one of accountability, going back to the question from the noble Baroness Pidgeon. Will the government publish a set of measurable objectives for the national lead, particularly for access to treatment and patient outcomes, so that this House and others can assess whether the role is achieving the real progress that patients and families want to see?
Gillian Merron
Well, I mentioned a national action plan, which will be informed by the 3-month review, and I can confirm that the government will publish that national action plan, and I would expect to see the markers that both the noble Lady and the noble Lord have called for within that.
Speaker 43
I'm very pleased that Baroness Paul asked this question today as our great friend Baroness McDonagh died of a glioblastoma in 2023. I understand that the NHS is currently running 35 clinical trials related to brain cancer, of which nine are related to glioblastoma, the most aggressive form of brain tumor.
Speaker 41
Could the minister either tell the House today, or write to me, setting out how many patients have actually been recruited to each of those trials?
Gillian Merron
Well, I'm grateful to my noble friend for honouring the memory of the noble lady Baroness McDonagh, as other noble lords have done, and also, of course, the noble lady Baroness Jowell. And I know that many noble lords are affected directly or indirectly by this, and will be feeling the weight of that as we discuss this matter. In respect of my noble friend's question, I can say that the number of glioblastoma patients that have been recruited into specific trials isn't centrally held, but there's a reason for that. And that's because many studies do enrol patients who have more than one type of brain cancer, and the data is managed by study teams and also sponsors. I would also note that some data for commercial trials is considered commercially sensitive, and each trial will have their own inclusion and exclusion criteria that is set out by the study team.
Having said that, if there are particular things with which I can assist my noble friend, of course, I will be pleased to.
Speaker 44
My Lords, I declare my interests in AI and technology as set out in the register, and beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the Order Paper.
David Pitt
I welcome this question. The government is closely monitoring developments following the Binance security breach, and it is engaging with the Financial Conduct Authority and other authorities to assess the implications for the UK. But Binance is not authorised or registered to provide cryptoasset services to the UK. However, it is possible that UK customers may still have been affected, and the government is currently working to understand the associated impacts and risks.
Speaker 47
My Lords, I declare my interests in AI and tech again, as set out in the register. Given that a large number of UK consumers engage with cryptoassets, and that the new regulatory regime will not take full effect until October 2027, will the minister commit today to working with the FCA, the National Cyber Security Centre, the Bank of England, and other relevant authorities to put effective transition arrangements in place now, and to publish a clear, interim cyber security and consumer protection plan with a timetable before the end of this year?
David Pitt
We are looking to learn from the what happened at Binance, but I'm not clear that it makes sense to put in an interim arrangement. By October next year, we will have a comprehensive FCA regime for a cryptoassets, including disclosure, market abuse, and resilience. But to put that in place requires changes by the firms. It then requires authorisation.
there will be an iterative process there and I think it might not be helpful to have an interim regime in the middle of that. It would perhaps slow things down.
Susan Kramer
My Lords, that the hacking of Binance demonstrates that large-scale theft is far more possible in a crypto world. Now at present, UK banks are resisting providing accounts, financial services and credit lines to crypto service providers, but that is expected to change in the next year when the FCA's crypto providers authorisation scheme kicks in. So, what would be the consequence to bank stability of such a heist happening after that authorisation and the relationship created between the banks and the crypto world? Would the banks be covering the losses, and it's certainly unclear who is covering the losses now.
David Pitt
So, I'm not quite sure what a heist the noble Baroness has in mind. I think we can say that right now the Financial Stability Board does not believe that crypto-assets are systemic risk to the financial system, but if she would like to write to me with her thoughts on how this heist might come about to affect one of the large banks, I'd be very interested to read it.
The Lord Ranger of Northwood
I remind the House to my register of interest in AI businesses and digital assets. Digital assets operate across borders and as do cyber security threats as we've seen with the issue with Binance. And given the considerable progress being made internationally on regulatory cooperation, does the Minister agree that there should be an increased amount of discussion about that cooperation on regulatory compliance, and also would the Minister agree that the government should commit to making digital assets a security and regulatory priority as part of our G20 presidency next year?
David Pitt
So, yes, digital assets and cryptocurrencies are two things, related things. As regards a digital assets, this is something that the government is promoting with a industry group with Chris Woolard, which I think is being quite successful in thinking how we do that safely and well to make the UK a centre that can take advantage of crypto, that can take advantage of digital assets and tokenisation.
David Alton
My Lords, will the noble Lord, the Minister, ask his officials to provide for him a copy of the House of Lords Question 4338 from December 2017, which contained warnings about the ability of North Korea to hack cryptocurrency and to commit cyber robbery, 2017 being the year of the attack by North Korea on our National Health Service. Will the noble Lord ask his officials what notice was taken of those warnings, and in the light of the evasion of sanctions, the recycling of revenues into nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles programmes, what progress is being made in tracing the stolen assets and identifying those responsible? And will the noble Lord agree to meet the officers of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on North Korea and the All-Party Party Parliamentary Group on Crypto and Digital Assets?
David Pitt
I'd be very happy to meet, but I wonder whether there's a misunderstanding here. Binance, which is the institution that has been hacked, is not authorised in the UK. It's not registered in the UK. It is a foreign, it is a foreign entity. And so while I'm sure there will be lessons to be learned from the issues that he is talking about, Binance and what happened there was not something that happened under any registration in the UK.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My Lords, this incident shows that society as a whole faces very serious risks from cyber crime and that lessons need to be learned as the Minister has said. Now I know that the noble lord, the Minister, is concerned about financial education. Will he use his influence to ensure that the prevention of fraud in all its aspects, including cyber crime, plays a full part in plans to improve financial education?
David Pitt
I would be more than happy to do that, and I would be more than happy to do that jointly with the noble baroness.
Speaker 55
My Lords, the government is issuing the Digital Gilt Instrument in, I believe, the first trades are expected to happen in Q1 of next year. What lessons are we learning in terms of the security of for DIGIT from this hack?
David Pitt
So, the DIGIT is a digital gilt instrument which we are experimenting with. The hack, of course, was to an exchange, which is rather different, so I'm afraid I don't have an answer to that question. But if you would like, I could write when the evidence is in about what happened on Binance and any relevance it might have for DIGIT.
Speaker 19
My Lords, in order to help the Minister's bewilderment at my noble friend's question, he's right to say that Binance is not registered in the United Kingdom at the moment, but under the conditions of change, as outlined by my noble friend, there is every reason to believe that Binance or an equivalent organization will be registered after the changes of next year. Her question was: in the event of that, how would such a theft be dealt with? Would it be by the banks or would it be by the exchange, and where would the government and the Bank of England sit in that position?
David Pitt
So I don't know the details of what happened at Binance, but my understanding is that the money came from custodial operations at the exchange itself, not from a bank, but perhaps I could get back to the noble lord if I'm wrong on that.
Speaker 54
The question asked by the noble lord Alton, is he aware, he probably will be aware, that yesterday that the US Treasury announced that they had overwhelming evidence that it was rogue North Korean state actors that perpetrated this appalling fraud. Given the number of UK investors in this particular exchange, what can he do, and his department what can they do to work with the US administration to pursue this?
David Pitt
So I'm not sure we know how many UK investors there were, because, as I say, Binance was not authorized or registered to provide crypto-asset services to the UK. But when we discover that, which we're looking to do today, I'm sure we will want to cooperate with all regulatory authorities in making sure that this can't happen again.
Speaker 61
My Lords, North Korea, of course, has form in attacking financial markets in order to fund its foreign currency requirements. It attacked the London reinsurance markets 15 years or so ago, and there were heavy losses for London reinsurers, and also losses for German reinsurers. And this is a pattern of attack by North Korea. Could the noble lord, the Minister, tell us whether we're cooperating internationally, not just with the Americans, but also with the Germans in this instance, in order to try and make sure that we can stamp out this abusive from North Korea?
David Pitt
I think indeed we are and have been taking some powers to trace, seize, and recover, have been getting financial institutions to do more about disclosure and know your customers. Specifically the conversations that we've had with each individual country, I'm not aware of, but if that is a particular interest of the noble Lord, perhaps I can write to him.
Speaker 60
My Lords, that concludes oral questions for today. Could those members who wish to leave the Chamber do so quietly and quickly?
Speaker 52
Order. My Lords, we now come to an instrument previously debated in Grand Committee. There's a minor typographical error on the Order Paper, but the correct title of the instrument is the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 (Specified Purposes Relating to Policing) Regulations 2026, Lord Collins of Highbury.
Speaker 52
The question is that, my Lords, the question is, my Lords, the question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as of that opinion will say content. The contrary, not content. The contents have it. House to be again in committee on the Health Bill, Baroness Merron.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I beg to move that the House do again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill.
Speaker 52
The question is, my Lords, the question is that the House do now again resolve itself into a committee upon the bill. As many as of that opinion will say content. The contrary, not content. The contents have it.
In clause 5, resumed debate on amendment 21.
Speaker 59
My Lords, before we continue to debate amendment 21, I would just like to remind the House that this is an adjourned debate and therefore, unless you were present at the start of the group, you are not able to contribute. The clerk at the table does have a full list of those who were present previously.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, I think it might be helpful, as I moved the first amendment in this group, just recap the nature of the debate that took place last week. First of all, my Lords, the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, moved a number of amendments about carers, when she said 7.4.7 million unpaid carers in England, and that they lack support, and that one of the reasons for it is that we don't have a system of identifying who they are.
This, my Lords, was backed up by Lord Young, who particularly talked about young carers. He spoke of 15,000 school children spending more than 50 hours a week looking after their parents or siblings, 3,000 of whom were aged between five and nine. And, my Lords, they faced many disadvantages in the field of education, as Lord Young identified. They are really identified rarely identified by the relevant authorities until, on average, three years have passed since they first began caring. My Lords, my own amendments are I think that they run in parallel to Baroness Tyler's amendments are about introducing a new legal right to ensure no one is left cut off from relatives and friends in care homes, hospitals and other care settings.
My Lords, this basically would mean that anyone relying on health and care services either in the short or longer term the right to nominate a trusted relative or friend or paid carer to provide essential in-person support and that the parents' access will be protected and their advocacy respected. My Lords, during COVID in particular, but subsequently too, there is a lot of evidence that when a carer, a relative, a friend raises concerns about their loved one in a care residential home, in some cases, my Lords, they have been told that they're not allowed to visit again. There have been some cases too where the resident themselves have been required to be removed from that home. Now, Baroness Hallett recognised the importance of this in her COVID-19 inquiry report recently and she stated in a future pandemic, visits from a central carer should be available to all residents where possible and should be distinct from considerations regarding general visiting, and her report recommend this protection be framed as a right.
Speaker 57
My Lords, it is sometimes frustrating when sitting on the woolsack or at the table during committee stage of a bill, when a debate is taking place, and you wish you could just jump up and say something, a situation I found myself in on Wednesday night. So, I was very glad when the committee adjourned the debate on Amendment 21. In fact, I think I was the person who adjourned the debate, which allows me to say just a few words on this group of important amendments today. I must admit to your Lordships that I haven't spoken in a health bill since I was the opposition health whip to my noble friend Earl Howe, many years ago, when I was also the shadow minister for what was then Children, Schools and Families, and in that capacity, met many young carers. I was humbled by their dedication and the sacrifices that they willingly accepted, and my admiration for them my admiration for them then and now knows no bounds.
So, I wish to add my voice to the powerful speeches already made in this group, particularly in support of respite care, and in doing so, I have just one question for the noble Lord, the Minister. I recognise from the government's unpaid carers action plan that much work is going into the collection of data and identification of uncared pairs by bringing together multiple services. But from my own experience, many young carers are wary of official services for fear that they may think them unable to cope. However, many will turn to the wonderful charities who are active in this space, such as Action for Children.
And can I therefore ask the noble Baroness, the Minister, if the voluntary sector will also be included in this bringing together of services to improve the outcome for young carers and their families, indeed all carers, and will carers also have a voice?
Speaker 56
My Lords, I understand the concerns that have prompted the noble Lady, Baroness Tyler, to table this amendment and I support that fully. I have raised in this very Chamber many times the burden of unpaid caring on one's health and well-being, and also finances. My Lords, the majority of unpaid carers are women who sacrifice their own health and well-being needs to care for others. It is very important that we care for them. We know many
we know many unpaid carers do not identify themselves, as said by many noble Lords last week. But women are less likely to identify themselves as unpaid carers. Identifying carers is important, but it must not simply become another statistics, because behind every carer there is a family. Identification should and must lead to meaningful support for them and their families. As the noble Lady, Baroness Tyler, already pointed out, there is evidence of under-identification of unpaid carers.
The analysis by Nuffield Trust of 13 million GP records found only 1.4% of patients were recorded as unpaid carers in GP systems, compared with the census estimate of approximately 8.8%. That means for every unpaid carer identified by GP practices, roughly four were not identified. In other words, around 1 million unpaid carers were missing from GP records. My Lords, I welcome action 102 in the renewed women's health strategy to support unpaid carers to balance their work and care. The single patient record can be an important enabling tool to identify unpaid carers, and also recording all their caring responsibilities.
Can I therefore ask my noble friend the Minister if the single patient record will be set up in order to systematically identify unpaid carers, and if ICBs will have a clear responsibility to act on that information in order to protect their health and well-being? And also, will the renewed women's health strategy be joined up to this in order to support women who are unpaid carers? We owe it to them.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, this debate started last week has highlighted the extraordinary contribution made by unpaid carers across the country. Every day, millions of people provide care often around the clock, enabling their loved ones to live with dignity and independence. And their contribution is not only invaluable to the individuals that they support, it's fundamental to effectively the sustainability of the health and care system as we know it. As my noble friend, Baroness Tyler, rightly pointed out last week, and the noble Lord Hunt, has pointed out today, the unpaid care provided by an estimated 4.7 million carers in England is worth some 152 billion a year, a figure which is comparable to the NHS budget itself. And without those carers, our health and social care services would be unable to cope.
Throughout this debate, noble Lords have highlighted a stark reality that carers remain too often invisible to the very systems that rely most heavily upon them. And for too many carers who are not identified by health services, it means they miss out on support, advice and interventions that would protect their own health and well-being as well.
Amendments 88 and 89 would help address these issues. Identifying carers, recognizing them as partners in care, involving them properly in hospital discharge planning, and ensuring that their own health and well-being is considered should not be optional extras. And the issue of respite and breaks from caring in my noble friend Baroness Tyler's Amendments 175 and 176 are just really important. A meaningful break is not a luxury. It is often the intervention that enables carers to continue to care year in, year out.
Yet too many carers cannot access the support they need, and too many are facing a postcode lottery in provision. If we're serious about prevention, supporting carers before they reach that crisis point must become a priority. The f- cost of failing to do so is borne not only by the carers, but by the wider health and care system when caring arrangements break down. Now, Lord Hunt's Amendments 21, 173, and 174 look to enshrine in law the right of an individual to have access to in-person support from a health and care partner. A legal right to nominate a health and care partner would ensure people's chosen representatives are welcomed as an essential part of the care team, and this would make it easier for health and care staff to understand who is so important to the person that they are not just a visitor.
And it would rebalance the power in care settings, and provide the comfort of knowing the person you've chosen as your eyes, ears, and voice can be there for you when you need them. I think, my lords, from this debate, there appears to be broad agreement across the House that carers deserve better recognition, better support, and a stronger place within our health system. I look forward to the Minister's response to this important group.
Howe
My Lords, the Committee will undoubtedly be grateful to the noble Lord Hunt, and the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, for bringing forward these important amendments and for highlighting the vital contribution that unpaid carers make to our health and care system. It is an obvious truth, but a truth worth stating, that carers are the people who know the person they care for best. They provide not only practical support, but continuity, reassurance, and an understanding of individual needs that can make a real difference to the quality of care. I very much welcome the recognition of the key role that carers play, and the need to ensure that they are, first of all, identified, as many noble Lords have emphasised, but then listened to and appropriately involved in decisions about the people they support, whilst at the same time respecting the wishes and rights of patients themselves.
Carers are often family, friends, and neighbours, and usually don't foresee the duty happening upon them. They demonstrate the most admirable qualities in fulfilling that duty. The pressures that caring responsibilities can place on individuals and families are frequently very considerable, which is why we must never lose sight of the need to support carers' own health and well-being, including opportunities to take a break from caring, as the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, has just mentioned.
Amendment 21 enshrines the right of carers to be involved in patients decisions and this seems to me eminently sensible and right. Carers with patient consent already have the right to be involved in discussions with clinicians. At the same time, clinicians will always need to make a judgment according to the situation because it's just as important to go back and check the wishes of the patient and to make sure for example the patient has privacy when they want it. Without wishing to downplay the value of these amendments in the very slightest, it would be helpful to have confirmation from the minister that a patient has the right to withhold from a carer any sensitive information in their medical records that they might not want shared. We'll be debating the government's proposals for a National Care Service in a later group, but I wonder whether the minister can give us any sense of how they view the position of unpaid carers in the context of those proposals.
In what way do they think a National Care Service could or should affect the status of family carers? I ask that because with the concerns that noble Lords have raised during the debate, it seems to me doubly important that we don't inadvertently sideline or devalue the extraordinary contribution to society and indeed to the economy that unpaid carers make or to overlook the practical support and respite that carers need. My Lords, unpaid carers are the backbone of so much of our health and social care system. Carers can be of any age, and my noble friend Lord Young of Cookham rightly emphasized the role of young carers. Their contribution is immense as are the burdens that they carry, yet so often those things go unseen.
Caring is a profoundly challenging role that over time will undoubtedly affect a person's mental and physical health. The support for carers that noble Lords have so often called for can come in different forms, and noble Baroness, Lady Watkins referred to the vital importance of respite and the part that care homes play in providing it. My noble friend Lady Morris has just reminded us that there are many great charities operating in this field. I wonder whether the minister could give us a sense of what their vision is for how such support and respite should be delivered, whether they see it as primarily a role for the state or whether there is a broader palette of provision that's right and sensible to avail of. My Lords, whatever the future structure of our care system, we must not lose sight of the people who give so much to care for others.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I'm most grateful to my noble friend Lord Hunt and also to the noble Lady Baroness Tyler for initiating this important debate about carers and indeed health and care partners. The points that have been made in the debate in this group are well made and well heard, and they're very much rooted I know in personal experience as well as professional experience. And I, too, want to pay tribute to the vital work that carers, friends and families, neighbors, all of them do to support their loved ones in often the most challenging of circumstances. And I particularly note the reference to young carers as was said by the noble Lord Young, the noble Lord Earl Howe, my noble friend Lord Hunt.
So, my Lords, if I could turn to first of all the amendments 21, 214, 173 and 174 in the name of my noble friend, Lord Hunt. Integrated care boards do have an existing duty to promote the involvement of patients and their carers and representatives in decisions relating to their care or treatment, and to the point the noble Lord the Earl Howe just raised, carers are the patient. They are the key person, and they have control while, as long as they are able, to make decisions about what is appropriate and what is not appropriate, as is usual. And in addition on this group, these particular amendments, local authorities are required by the Care Act to have regard to the importance of people participating in decisions and being provided with information. And the Health Bill also, I'd just point out to noble Lords, does introduce a duty on integrated care boards to promote opportunities for visiting and for a duty for local authorities to have due regard to the importance of individuals being able to involve other people in decisions about their care and individuals, and them being able to receive visitors.
Regulation 9A already provides local legal protections by placing a duty on the care home, the hospital, the hospice providers to facilitate visits and accompaniment in a way that meets the person's needs. And as I just said, at the central of all of this is the needs of the individual. And just to clarify, a visit does include somebody providing physical support or companionship in person, and it does encompass the support envisaged from a health and care partner. And to my noble friend Lord Hunt and to the noble Baroness Finlay who raised this matter in the earlier part of the discussion, the existing legislation does intentionally avoid establishing a distinct term of health and care partner. And that's simply because a single definition may not appropriately reflect the range of relationships that there may be and those that apply across different health and care sitting settings.
Also, in clause 57, the reference to other people does encompass family, friends, carers, and would already include a health and care partner. So, the proposed amendments, and I know it would be inadvertent, may inadvertently constrain how contact and support are provided and would inadvertently fail to provide for exceptional circumstances where offering support becomes a significant risk to the health, safety or welfare of a person using the service or on the premises. So instead what we are doing is building on existing protections through non-legislative measures including through the development of the NHS Health and Care Partner Policy. So, I hope that will meet the intentions that are in these amendments. And let me turn now to amendments 89, 175, 176 tabled by the noble lady, Baroness Tyler, and they relate to unpaid carers.
The existing legal framework does already require the system to support carers. The Care Act 2014 does place requirements on local authorities to assess and to meet eligible needs, and carers are also explicitly referenced in the NHS Constitution, and local authorities and NHS bodies do have a duty of cooperation. Looking at Amendments 175 and 176, existing legal duties do establish a framework where needs assessments and subsequent care planning focus on the individual and their circumstances, rather than prescribing a particular service or solutions, such as respite care, something the noble Lord Earl Howe referred to. And if I can turn to the noble Lady Baroness Tyler's Amendment 88, and a number of other noble Lords have spoken to this point, including the noble Lady Baroness Pitkeathley, it is important, of course, that carers are properly recorded and identified in the system. However, we don't believe that setting explicit requirements is appropriate for legislation, important though that is.
So, we are making clear commitments in the 10-year health plan and are taking practical steps to improve identification and recording and support. And to my noble friend Baroness Nagant, who asked specifically about the single patient record, I'd perhaps refer back to the bill in that it does contain powers which will enable regulations to make patient information available to people other than patients on the patient's behalf, if that is what is required. And indeed, that can include all carers. And I think the main point here is we do want to ensure that carers who act on behalf of those that they care for can also get full benefit from the single patient record. There is guidance also to support general practice to better identify and record which of their patients are unpaid carers, and there is ongoing work to improve identification by promoting more consistent coding of unpaid carers by GPs.
And to pick up some of the other points that were asked, the noble Lady Baroness Morris, I can confirm that the voluntary sector will be included in terms of the unpaid carers action plan, and carers will be absolutely key, and their voices will be sought and heard as we develop further. And of course, the action plan was published in July. It sets out how to improve how unpaid carers are recognized, how that support is offered and how they can be helped to reach their full potential and live what we would all want, and that's fulfilling lives. So, those voices and that inclusion and involvement will continue. And in terms of the noble Lord Earl Howe's question about a national care service, the unpaid and in respect of the unpaid carers champion, that champion will drive action in the areas that we have discussed, including not just policy, but also delivery, including that of the National Care Service.
So, they will be well involved, and that champion will, back to the noble Baroness Lady Morris's point, speak to carers right across the country to ensure that their experience is reflected.
Ilora Finlay
Just before the noble lady sits down, could she confirm that the partner policy that she referred to that is being developed as guidance and would avoid anything going into statute will include a requirement that the carer providing principle care for someone when they're discharged from a unit will actually be assessed for how much they can and are willing to do in providing care and will be taught procedures that may make the care of the person easier, such as simple things like helping someone get up from a chair, how to manage if someone falls on the floor and even giving injections for breakthrough medication for pain relief if that's indicated, so that they're not left feeling that they don't know what to do when the person goes home?
Gillian Merron
I think that the noble lady makes extremely fair points, but actually, I'd go also to the point that the discharge process does take account of whether somebody can be safely and properly discharged. And of course, the care that is provided, whether that is by a carer who's unpaid or a professional, has to be absolutely right. So, she's absolutely right to make the points, and I'm sympathetic to the points that she makes.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, in seeking leave to withdraw my amendment, can I thank noble Lords who've taken part in this debate both today and last week, and particularly to Baroness Tyler for her amendments? I do think that Baroness Morris, when she spoke about respite care for young carers, made a very important point for us to consider, and Baroness Nargund talking about the identification of women carers, Baroness Pidgeon making the point that intervention before crisis occurs is so important, and Earl Howe about the pressures facing carers more generally. Minister, my noble friend is resistant to legislation because of the existing need assessment framework and the, on recording of people, she think felt the 10-year plan alongside the action plan she mentioned would meet the needs. And I think one must take that as a positive response. I would just say to her though that we have been here before, and we have these huge number of carers who, faced with the bureaucracy of the local system, actually do find it very difficult to get support.
And respite care, in a sense, is a visible indication of the issues that we face, and I'm sure noble Lords will wish to come back to that. On my amendments, I was very grateful to Baroness Finlay for her support last week, and also to Care Rights UK and John's Campaign, who've been really campaigning for a long time now to see some statutory protection for loved ones, partners, call it what you will, who see and have concerns about the way their loved one is being treated in a care home, and actually have faced vindictive action by the people operating those care homes for raising legitimate concerns. I take her point about definitions, and obviously, that is something to reflect upon. I also take the point about the current statutory duties, but, my Lords, I do think that people need some protection against the behaviour of so many care homes when faced with very legitimate questions about their loved ones.
And I do hope, my Lords, because Baroness Hallett has only recently produced her recommendation in relation to this, that the Government will consider legislation in the light of that. Having said that, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 64
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 22, Lord Kamall.
Howe
My Lords, I beg to move Amendment 22 standing in my name and that of my noble friend Lord Kamall, and to speak to Amendments 24 and 68. I'm also grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, for bringing forward Amendments 23 and 67. These amendments concern a principle which we on these Benches have long supported, which and which I believe ought to be central to our thinking about the future of the health service: how we can give patients greater choice over their care and make better use of the full range of healthcare services available to them. Now, those services are what I would describe as a wider health healthcare ecosystem: a complementary system in which the NHS works alongside independent healthcare providers, community organisations, charities and other bodies to deliver services in the way that best meets patients' needs. The principle behind this is straightforward.
There are many services which don't necessarily need to be delivered in a hospital or indeed by an NHS organisation in an area where there are other qualified and appropriately regulated providers capable of delivering them. These might include diagnostic services, physiotherapy, audiology, eye care or other forms of community-based treatment. Where those services can be provided safely and effectively by organisations outside the traditional hospital setting, we should surely be looking at how we can make use of that capacity. There are several potential benefits that flow from this approach. It can allow patients to receive treatment closer to home.
It can allow them to reduce unnecessary journeys to hospital. It can also provide access to services more quickly, and, at the same time, it can relieve some of the pressure on hospitals and specialist services, allowing them to concentrate their resources on patients who need them most. And where services can be delivered more efficiently, they may also provide better value for the taxpayer. I appreciate now that some noble Lords may have concerns about what they might regard as encouraging the privatisation of the health service, but I want to be very clear that's not what we're proposing. We're suggesting that patients We're not suggesting that patients should be required to pay for their treatment, nor that core NHS services should be replaced by private provision.
What we are arguing is that the NHS should have the fullest possible range of resources available to it when it comes to treating patients, and that patients should be able to benefit from those resources regardless of the organisational structure of the provider. The important question is whether a service is safe, clinically appropriate, accessible and provides good value, rather than whether it happens to be delivered by one particular type of organisation. This brings me to the question of patient choice. There's a risk in the present system that patients are not always given the opportunity to make decisions which they're perfectly well placed to make themselves.
For example, a patient may be entirely happy to travel further for a particular service, or they may prefer to receive treatment closer to home. They may be willing to wait for one provider, or they may prefer to be treated more quickly by another. These are reasonable choices. And wherever clinically appropriate, patients should be supported in making them. But the watchword of choice means very little if patients are not told what alternatives are available, or if the way services are commissioned prevents them from accessing those alternatives in the first place.
Amendment 22 therefore seeks to strengthen the provisions in the bill relating to patient choice, specifically in relation to out-of-hospital services. Amendments 23 and 24, meanwhile, raise an important question about what happens when a patient is referred onwards by a hospital or an NHS online service, or another integrated healthcare provider. As more care is delivered through digital services and integrated pathways, we need to be certain that patients don't lose the choices which would otherwise have been available to them, had they been referred directly by their GP. And amendment 68 explores how we might extend meaningful choice into community services, which can provide an alternative to hospital-based care. The amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, mentions optometry services.
Another good example is audiology. Adult hearing loss affects 11.6 million people in the UK. It is the third leading cause of years lived with disability, and it impacts all aspects of people's lives. Unlike most other hospital services, audiology is not consultant-led. And currently, choice over elective care only applies to consultant-led NHS secondary care services.
As a result, NHS community audiology services are being commissioned in fewer than half of ICB areas. And patients therefore often endure long waits, and then attend hospital when the services could often be offered safely and more swiftly in the community. The government's stated ambition is to move more care out of hospitals and into communities, it's a good ambition. But if we are serious about moving care closer to patients, we must also be serious about making use of the organizations, including independent providers, which are capable of providing that care. It would be helpful if the Minister could use this debate to tell us a little more about the government's plans in this area.
What further steps are being taken to empower patients to exercise meaningful choice, particularly in relation to community and out-of-hospital services? And can I press her in particular on primary care audiology provision, which seems to me an especially salient example, given the statistics on hearing loss which I've just mentioned? What is the position? Are integrated care boards being encouraged to make full use of the healthcare capacity available in their local areas, including through independent, charitable, and community providers?
What barriers might stand in the way of this? Much of our debate on this bill thus far has concerned the savings which the Government hopes to achieve through structural reform. But I hope we can agree that the structure of the system should not be such as to dictate or otherwise limit the choices available to patients. There is surely therefore an opportunity, both to make savings and to improve services, by looking more closely at how care is actually delivered. I look forward to the Minister's response and beg to move.
Speaker 64
Amendment proposed: Clause 5, page 4, leave out lines 2 to 4 and insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My Lords, I'd like to start by thanking the Minister for a helpful letter of last week, answering the range of questions I'd raised at second reading. I think that's a symptom of the wide variety of policy issues that this important bill raises. I've added my name to Amendment 22 on choice, so persuasively and sensitively introduced by noble friend, Earl Howe. I believe that private care can complement NHS care, allow treatment nearer to home, and cut waiting times. I particularly support the 'have regards' in paragraph five of the new clause.
I also favour the follow up review, albeit I believe there should be more focus on the value and usefulness of the independent sector in a health system that, frankly, is under so much pressure. I have had very positive experience at Specsavers, who are contracted to do eye and audio tests in a number of NHS trusts. Now, in her letter, the Minister helpfully confirmed that the Government is committed to continuing to continue using independent sector capacity to improve access, reduce backlogs, and build a sustainable healthcare system. However, there is local variation, as she explained, and this does not produce optimal results. Moreover, the Association of Eye Care Providers tell me that because patient choice only applies to consultant-led NHS services, audiology departments, which are not consultant-led, often require patients to attend far away hospital appointments or wait for services which could be provided safely and closer to home by the private sector.
Advances have been made, as we've heard, in audiology and optometry, and the and these can keep private services can keep people away from hospital. So, I've got a good example in eye clinics, which are provided for under the choice legislation, which I'd ask the Minister to investigate. I'm told that they have to operate to an indicative activity plan. They cannot exceed a monthly quota of operations.
They are obliged to operate a minimum waiting time provided by reference to the NHS offering. And if NHS providers slow down, they have to slow down too, even if they have spare capacity. Worse, I understand that the online system used by opticians has changed, and that NHS providers are listed first, making references to private providers down the list less likely.
My Lords, they need to be listed fairly. Let's take another example involving cataract surgery. In southeast London, there is a minimum waiting time written into SpaMedica's contracts as a condition. The company's mean wait has been under four weeks, but the policy requires NHS patients to wait 16 weeks. This seems unfortunate.
I worry, my Lords, that all of this reflects a recent change of culture driven by this Government and the unions. If so, and the Minister may want to comment on that statement, it's self-harm and risks undermining the beneficial advances in audiology and optometry, which have helped to keep so many people working off benefits and in less need of care. So, can the noble the Minister undertake to have a review of local arrangements and look at improvements with a view to better performance, improved efficiency, and cutting wait waiting times? As my noble friend Earl Howe has already said, adult hearing loss alone affects 11.6 million people in the UK. And of course, it's rising in line with the aging of the population, which is a challenge we recently debated comprehensively in this Chamber.
So, I do hope the Minister will give serious consideration to these issues and come back to us before report.
Zahida Manzoor
My Lords, I rise to support the amendments in this group, and particularly support amendment 22, 23, 24 in the names of my noble friends, Lord Kamall and Earl Howe. I would say to the noble lady, the Minister, that in my view, patient choice needs to be strengthened significantly and particularly in three important areas. Currently, there is choice, but we need to make choice much more meaningful rather than simply theoretical, giving patients greater control over access to services and their care pathways, ensuring that choices are built across the whole of the NHS and the health ecosystem, not just elective hospital treatment, as so clearly outlined by my noble friend Earl Howe. My Lords, patients are not always aware that they can choose which hospital or provider they can attend, and in practice, patients may simply accept the hospital suggested by their GP or referral system without being told about alternatives. So, my Lords, how do we improve this?
I do passionately believe that GPs should have a duty to routinely explain patients' rights to choose, and patients should be offered meaningful range of clinically appropriate providers. They should be provided information about waiting times, quality, outcomes, and location should be readily available, as amendment 22 supports. Patients should be supported to make informed decisions rather than being directed towards a single provider. The NHS England guidance recommends currently that refer referrers should shortlist an average of five provider choices, where it's practical, clinically appropriate, and preferred by the patient. Choice is particularly relevant in relation to NHS 111 and A&E attendance.
Patients contacting NHS 111 are often given a recommended pathway, but their ability to access alternative services may be limited. For example, a patient might be advised to: contact their GP, attend an urgent treatment centre, access a community pharmacy, receive a telephone or face-to-face clinical assessment, attend A&E if clinically necessary.
The problem is that a recommendation is not necessarily a genuine choice if the alternative service is unavailable. So, improvement, my Lords, is needed. There needs to be better access to same-day GP appointments, wider choice in the NHS and wider eco-health system, more accessible urgent treatment centres,
greater availability of evening and weekend services, better integration between NHS 111 and local urgent care providers, and much greater transparency about where patients can receive treatment. A key principle should be that patients are given practical alternatives, not simply redirected from one service to another. Amendments 22, 23, 24, and indeed audiology as already been mentioned will enable this.
And I know, my Lords, that this can happen because back in when we had regions, we did have the ability to be able to refer patients to other providers where waiting times could be reduced, and it did work very well. But of course, that is the danger that we don't allow cherry-picking, and we must really, very clearly define what outcomes are to be expected.
Anne Thérèse Coffey
My Lords, I agree with the amendments tabled. I have to say the original duty put in by the government feels a bit lightweight and almost declaratory rather than anything of substance, and that's why I think it's a proving a useful debate to look at this the variety of amendments with more, as I say, substance. I think one of the things that happens in the like the real world of the NHS, in my experience as a patient and previously as an advocate, has been that what's convenient for the NHS is more important.
And we come on to this in a broader sense later in the Bill. But I think it's vital that we try and help patients with the earlier duty that's in the clause that isn't being changed to have more involvement in their health care. And that's why, opening up, as my noble friend Baroness Manzoor has just said, often patients aren't aware of the availability of other services. So, it would be useful to get an understanding of how the Secretary of State, through this clause, intends to make patients more aware. And at the same time, as my noble friend Baroness Neville-Rolfe points out, in effect, what's happening, probably due to budget constraints and rationing has started by not allowing patients to take advantage of provision in the interests of, as I say, rationing and trying to manage budgets.
Now, I'm not saying the NHS is a bottomless pit, it's not. But it does have to come back to, what is the NHS there for? And the constitution is quite clear that parental sorry, patient choice is absolutely a key element of that. And that's reasonable, I think, in order to try and make sure that we have a healthier society. As my noble friend just pointed to, there's quite a lot of illnesses that happen that are stopping people working
or not working to their full potential. That's no good. There's a lot of illness that is not allowing children to reach their full potential and indeed be spending time out of school. So, it's those sorts of factors that I think we need to consider in considering carefully the amendments tabled by both my frontbench and that of the Liberal Democrats into really beefing up what it really means about trying to make sure that other provision can be readily accessed in order to have a healthier society.
I hope that my noble friends will bring this back at report stage if we don't hear any satisfaction during the debate today.
Speaker 69
My Lords, I rise briefly to support the aims of Amendments 22 and 24, and I also welcome the intentions of the Amendments 67 and 68 in this group. I want to concentrate on what these proposals would mean in practice for patients and families. The question is whether choice is meaningful, accessible, and protected throughout their care. For patients, the question's straightforward. Where can I receive appropriate care?
How long will I wait? And how will I get there? Amendment 22 rightly draws attention to the information needed to make that decision, including waiting times, location, quality, and travel costs. Simply presenting someone with a list of providers does not necessarily give them a meaningful choice. A service offering an earlier appointment may be difficult to reach; on the other hand, a nearby service may involve a much longer wait.
Patients need help to understand those options and decide what works for them. Does the noble Baroness, the Minister, accept the case for strengthening patient choice in services outside of hospital? Whether or not she accepts Amendment 22, how will the government ensure that patients receive the information and practical support needed to exercise choice, particularly those who cannot readily use digital services, have communication needs, or require help with transport? Amendments 23 and 24 raise an equally important question about onward referrals. A patient's ability to choose should not depend on which door they entered or which organisations happens to make the next referral.
As services become more integrated and virtual services play a greater role, we must ensure that patients are told about the choices available to them. Integration should make their journey easier while preserving access to suitable providers beyond the organisation arranging their care. Will the Minister explain how patients will be protected against being directed automatically to a closed list of preferred providers without being offered the choice to which they are entitled? Amendments 67 and 68 raise a related issue about choice in community services, including eyecare and audiology, very eloquently already expressed by the noble lady and noble Earl Howe. Moving care closer to home should bring benefits for patients, that's clear.
We should ensure that a change in the setting or organisation of care does not unnecessarily narrow their options. For a family seeking an ADHD or autism assessment, choice can also have very practical consequences. Where choice rights apply, and an eligible provider can offer appropriate care sooner, families need to know that option exists and understand what the service includes. They should also have the confidence that their choice will be respected as referral pathways change. Of course, as the noble Earl has already said, choice must operate within appropriate clinical criteria, with providers meeting the required standards, and with regard to the sustainability of local services.
Must also be available fairly, rather than depending on a patient's confidence or ability to navigate the system. Will the Minister explain how existing choice rights will be protected as services are reorganised, how compliance will be monitored, and what remedy a patient will have if available choice is denied?
The practical test is whether patients can reach appropriate care sooner, with clear information and continuity of treatment. I hope the minister will respond to the concerns behind the these amendments and explain what the government will do to make meaningful patient choice a reality.
Speaker 70
I too support amendment 22 and encouraged by this debate, which definitely needs to happen. Indeed, the GPs I work with in the East End of London would definitely want to open up these very choices to patients from many different backgrounds, because sometimes one can get a sense on the ground in certainly challenging communities, the NHS can be quite condescending, actually, to people and assume that people don't want these kinds of choices. Yet, if you go into East End housing estates in the morning, you'll find lots of different people living there, from lots of different backgrounds, who do want choice. So, personally, I think this is a really important message and needs to be grappled with and taken seriously. But secondly, just on a practical level, when as a country and as an NHS we in a such difficult financial position, I mentioned during my second reading speech that the NHS at the moment is spending £90 million a year on unused rooms and in health buildings, many of them primary care buildings.
Indeed, we have unused rooms sitting there that are costing the NHS all this amount of money. Actually, there's deals to be done here with the independent sector and the social sector and the charitable sector that make financial sense and health sense. So, my question to the minister, and I raised it in the second reading, but got no reply, is what is the minister and the government going to do about that opportunity? How do we grasp that nettle of £90 million and turn empty rooms into opportunities for patients in the NHS?
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, I'm grateful for the support for this group of amendments from noble Lords across the House. If the health service is to be truly patient-centered, then patient choice needs to be a key part of this. Different patients will have different needs and therefore choice is a key part in having ownership of their care and treatment. My amendment 23 in this group is picking up a key issue as we move to greater use of digital health. The NHS app will start to play a greater role.
My amendment picks up the potential loophole that if a patient is seen in person, they may be referred for treatment or diagnostics by their GP or other primary care practitioner and given a choice of where to go for their referral. However, if this is done virtually, via an app or online, patients may not have that same choice as they would have received in person. So, this amendment seeks to ensure that there are no closed lists and patients being referred to one provider only. Amendment 24 in this group is similar in its aims. Amendment 67 in my name and amendments 22 and 68 in the names of the noble Lords, Lord Kamall and Earl Howe and the noble Lady, Baroness Neville-Rolfe, are similar.
My amendment specifically pushes for patient choice for non-consultant-led community services, including optometry-led glaucoma care and community urgent eye care services. This amendment is seeking meaningful choice from providers available in an ICB area for out-of-hospital services. We know that waiting lists have increased for community services, yet these are often preventative services. Now, I've raised in this House before that there are 600,000 people on hospital waiting lists for eye care services, and yet we have optometrists on every high street who could be used to help address this and bring routine treatment nearer to people's homes, thus leaving specialists able to deal with patients who need their services in a more timely manner. And audiology, as we've heard, is another really important area.
As the noble Lord, Earl Howe, has highlighted, NHS community audiology services are only commissioned across the whole of an ICB area in just 42% of ICBs. This means the majority of patients are being denied choice. Patients often require are required to attend hospital-based services and experience long waits for services which could be offered safely and in a more timely manner in the community, nearer to home, or indeed it could be nearer to a family member's home, somebody who helps them get to an appointment and helps them with transport, giving them genuine choice. And if we are serious as we debate this bill, if we're serious about shifting care out of hospitals and into the community, patients must be given the same right to choose their provider for community services as they currently have for consultant-led hospital care. Community waiting lists have now reached record levels with I think around 1.25 million people waiting for treatment.
Patients should be empowered with clear information on waiting times and location, allowing them to choose the provider that best meets their needs. And by placing choice in the hands of patients rather than commissioners, which quite often too often is, we can improve access to timely treatments and actually deliver on the government's ambition of more personalized care closer to home. I look forward to the minister's response.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, with permission, I will address both the wider principles that are underpinning clause 5 with taking amendments 22, 23, 24 and 68 together. With regard to clause 5, and I'm most grateful to noble Lords for their contributions and their considerations of matters that are absolutely key when we talk about patient choice, a concept, I know noble Lords are aware, not new or innovative in terms of this bill, but one that is absolutely at the core of this bill. So, my Lords, clause 5 does introduce new duties to require the Secretary of State to promote the involvement of patients, their carers and their representatives in decisions relating to prevention or diagnosis of illness, care or treatment. And this, I would emphasize, does apply where the Secretary of State is exercising the Secretary of State's health functions. So, as I said, it is absolutely core to the bill, and I do hope that, and I'm sure noble Lords will welcome that.
The bill also requires, and this clause requires, the Secretary of State to act with a view to enabling patients to make choices about the health services provided to them. And I hope that noble Lords will be aware that the government is committed to involving patients and carers in decisions about their care, as we discussed indeed in the last group. And one of the reasons is we know it supports better experiences of care, and in many cases, it does lead to a better outcome.
So it's not just a nice to, it's a necessary to. And to this point, I would say to the noble Lady, Baroness Manzoor, the noble Lady, Baroness Coffey, and the noble Lord, Earl Howe, I would refer them to the new choice charter. And that will strengthen this approach very much by setting out, and I think this is key, what patients can expect in order that they can make informed decisions about their health and care. There is no point in just expressing a wish to have patient choice if we are not equipping patients to make that choice. So that's why we're protecting the patient's right to choice and that duty to involve them in decisions.
And as I said, that will remain central principles of the health system. And I was glad to hear the welcome from noble Lords across the chamber for the move from hospital to community provision. And as the noble Lady, Baroness Pidgeon, set out, many services can indeed be better provided in the community than they can in hospital. So I do welcome that support. So let me now turn to amendments 22, 23, 24, 67 and 68 tabled by the noble Lord Kamall, and the noble Lady, Baroness Pidgeon.
These amendments would go further than clause 5 currently does by expanding patients' rights to choice to a wider range of out-of-hospital services, and to onward referrals by virtual and integrated health services, and prescribing how this must operate in practice. Well, perhaps I can reconfirm our commitment to strengthening patient choice as part of our wider agenda to improve access to care and to reduce waiting times. And I do hope that it will be helpful, and the noble Lord, Earl Howe, might be particularly interested in this, but it might be helpful to remind your Lordships' House that existing choice rights already apply to some consultant-led out-of-hospital services where the regulatory conditions are met. And they do include dermatology, pain management services, gastroenterology, and diabetes services, just by way of some examples. And I would say to the noble Lord Patel of Bradford, who made a number of key points, that it is, of course, the case that community services are by their very nature designed differently to hospital services.
And I can also assure the noble Lord Patel of Bradford, that those who need help to be able to exercise their choice will get that around what their needs are. They will not be simply expected to manage with one size fits all. So whilst the points are fair that are being made, and I do take them on board, I would say that as a point of principle, we don't think that this level of operational detail, important though it is, but it isn't appropriate for primary legislation. So our preference is to use secondary legislation to set out the services that are covered by choice rights and the detailed requirements for offering choice. And the key thing there is that will allow that framework to be updated as services, evidence, and system capability develop because we're not going to be stuck in the one place.
Healthcare is going to be developing as we go along. So, also to the noble Lord Patel of Bradford, we will continue to look at the scope of the choice rights. We will ensure that we're providing the most effective offer to patients. And to the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, and the noble Lord, Earl Howe, we are also taking practical actions which the noble Lord and the noble Baroness were seeking as set out in the elective reform plan. So, yes, empowering people to take control of their health by making the NHS app and the Manage Your Referral website the default route for patients to choose their provider.
And to enable patients to make an informed choice, we are improving the information that is available to them, to my point that I made earlier on, including on waiting times. And the noble Lord Patel, as I just mentioned, was right to say that not everybody can use on online access, we completely understand that. And so, I would emphasize online tools are in addition to traditional channels. What it is that people need in order to make choice, we will ensure that they receive that support, that information in the way that suits them. And that was a point raised by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon.
On the reference to the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, I would say that, and it might be helpful to other noble Lords as well, patients will be able to continue to be able to choose any provider that holds a contract to deliver NHS services, and that, as I did say in my letter to the noble Baroness, does include independent sector providers within of course set circumstances. And it is the responsibility of ICBs to ensure that their processes do comply with the right to choose. That would include any qualifying contract requirements and, indeed, clinical appropriateness or eligibility criteria. There is guidance for the use and implementation of indicative activity plans and activity management plans, and that is detailed in the NHS standard contract technical guidance. And if the noble Baroness would like more information, please let me know, and I'll be very happy to ensure that's there.
The noble Baroness, Lady Manzoor, talked about the need for choice, real choice to be strengthened, and let me say that the government guidance on choice makes it quite clear that GPs, dentists and optometrists have clear duties to ensure that patients are offered a choice of where they go to their first outpatient appointment. The bit that would totally agree with the noble Baroness on, further to that, is of course a right is only as good as the information that you have and the confidence that you have.
And that is why we're taking the steps that we are. The noble lord Mawson asked about unused rooms and talked about this as an opportunity. Whilst not specific to this group, I can confirm that we are ensuring the NHS is making the most of any real surpluses, whether that's space through rooms or through land, in order that the money can be reinvested in local schemes to modernise and upgrade NHS trusts. With respect to audiology, I'll be very pleased to write in further detail to noble lords on that point.
Caroline Pidgeon
Before the noble lady the minister sits down, you mentioned the government has minded to use secondary legislation rather than amendments to the bill. Is the government minded to include the non-consultant community services that we have been discussing in the chamber today in such secondary legislation for genuine patient choice?
Gillian Merron
Well, secondary legislation will ensure patient choice across all NHS services, so that would be included.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
Noble lady sits down, I think her answer showed that this local variation is actually partly a problem because of the standards and contracts that she described, the framework, some of which in future I think will be in secondary legislation, as the noble lady has just said. So, I would like to pursue it a bit further to see if one can sort of tap the you know the capacity that could reduce waiting times in these important community areas of medicine. I'm worried that the existing system is not providing the incentive for that, and would like to get understand a little bit more in detail, perhaps in a meeting, before we get to report.
Paul Scriven
Before the noble lady sits down, I've been listening very carefully. In answer to my noble friend, the noble lady the minister has just said that secondary legislation will be for all NHS services for choice. So, what stops that being put on the face of the bill?
Gillian Merron
It is the point that I've just raised that it is our feeling that secondary legislation is actually the better place to put it because of flexibility and future-proofing it, that it's not appropriate in a static way for primary legislation.
Paul Scriven
That would make sense, I'm sure the noble lady would agree, that would make sense if you were putting the operational services down. If you were making a commitment in clause five that all NHS services in secondary, primary, and community services would be accessible for choice, it then gives discretion within that boundary. So, I don't understand what stops the government from putting those principles on the face of the bill rather than the operation of amendments, which she said were too restrictive.
Gillian Merron
I think we just have a difference of approach and opinion about the role of primary legislation and secondary legislation. So, I do respect what the noble lord is saying, and I will review, of course, as I always do, the points that have been made. However, the position is exactly as I've described.
Howe
My Lords, I'm most grateful to the minister for her response, and indeed to all noble lords who have contributed to this debate. I think this has been a valuable opportunity to explore how we can give patients greater choice, whilst making better use of the resources and expertise available across our wider healthcare system. In particular, services such as optometry and audiology have been highlighted.
I was encouraged by much of the Minister's response, particularly her reference to the need to empower patients, not least to optimise patient outcomes. She is right that there are already several consultant-led NHS services delivered in the community. It would though be helpful if she could reflect on the issues I raised about audiology, which is not consultant-led, and perhaps she could consider what could be done to increase audiology provision in the community. As I said at the outset, our intention is not to undermine the NHS, but to support it, and where independent, charitable and community providers can deliver high quality care closer to home and more efficiently, we should be making full use of that capacity. My noble friend Lady Coffey rightly said that politicians of every colour all too easily make declaratory statements about choice, but that we don't do enough to bring meaningful choice to the attention of patients.
I confess that I worry sometimes that the absence of choice in certain situations may in part not be wholly unintentional. As we heard from my noble friend Lady Rolfe, the Baroness Neville-Rolfe, it sometimes seems to suit NHS commissioners not to bring down waiting times, and the primary reason for that, I suspect, is the way that commissioners channel and direct their commissioning budgets. It's important, though, to keep in mind, and perhaps remind commissioners, that out-of-hospital services can often be less expensive to provide than services delivered in hospital. But having said that, my Lords, I hope the government will take these points away and give further consideration to how patient choice can be strengthened as this bill progresses. For now, I beg leave to withdraw Amendment 22.
Speaker 64
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. The question is that Clause 5 stand part of the bill. As many as of that opinion will say, "Content". The contrary, "Not content".
The contents have it. Amendment 23, Baroness Pidgeon. Not moved. Amendment 24, not moved. Amendment 25, Lord Rennard, not moved.
We come now to Amendment 26, Baroness Finlay of Llandaff.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, I'm most grateful to my noble friend Lord Patel, and to my noble friend Baroness Hollins and the noble lady, Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle, for having added support to my amendments, and I declare my interest as vice president of Marie Curie, an international adviser to the Cicely Saunders Institute, and Professor of Palliative Medicine at Cardiff University. Amendment 26 proposes a transformational fund to improve palliative care by scaling models for which there is strong evidence of proven benefit. Amendments 20- 279B, 242 and 78 state what must be commissioned to rectify current deficits. These amendments all are important. It's a rare finding in health economics to know that if you invest in a health or care service, people's well-being and quality of life will improve, while overall NHS costs are likely to fall.
The evidence for this benefit is strong. We know such care works. There's very clear and robust evidence of good benefit from specialist palliative care for all conditions.
When home-based, it improves symptoms and increases the likelihood of home death when preferred. In hospitals, specialist teams reduce inpatient bed days, reduce deaths in hospital, and reduce health care costs while improving simultaneously quality of life. In 2022, specialist palliative care supported more than 20,000 people in England to die outside hospital, saving 1.5 million hospital bed days and £117 million in health care costs. Currently, one in three people in England and Wales die with unmet palliative care needs. By 2040, this is predicted to rise to increase by over 23% if nothing is done.
This unmet need, in a third of all expected deaths, relates to both general and specialist palliative care provision. Specialist palliative care is essential for those with complex needs and for upskilling generalists. Failures in care lead to poor outcomes, more hospital deaths, and higher health and care costs. Shifting from hospital to community will require upfront investment, hence the call for a transformation fund to deliver longer-term savings and better care by investing in proven interventions of home-based care with specialist support. Of those dying from non-sudden causes, one in five people with cancer and four in five with dementia and heart conditions cannot access the specialist palliative care input they need.
Difficulties getting care, challenges navigating a complex system, and poor coordination lead to a lack of physical and psychological safety. Patients and their carers feel care at the end of life in the community is uncoordinated and unsupported. As a result, over half of people approaching the end of life resort to A&E to get the help they need. Despite the Health and Care Act 2022 stating that palliative care services are core, less than a quarter of integrated care system strategies have this as either a priority, a focus, or an ambition. In 2023, only three ICBs could state that they commissioned core components of the relevant NICE guidelines.
Almost half of ICBs realized they couldn't meet palliative care needs even moderately. Implementation of the NICE recommendations made over a decade ago remains patchy. The 2025 National Audit of Care at the End of Life, NACEL, in hospitals found poor access to palliative care, yet crises and difficulties occur at all hours. For those at home, only one in three UK areas have a designated phone advice line at all hours, despite NICE guidance, and such lines are often charitably funded. Only one in five ICBs commission 24/7 access to advice, and less than one in 10 actually have access to a specialist nurse overnight, although access is a bit better at weekends and bank holidays.
Fewer than two-thirds of hospitals provide face-to-face specialist palliative care seven days a week, hardly surprising as the consultant staffing levels range from one per 154 hospital beds to one per 3,673 beds. And only a third of areas provide direct admission to hospice out of hours. For children, too, only a third of pediatric palliative care teams meet NICE staffing guidance, and some tertiary children's hospitals, such as Manchester and Leeds, and hospitals with pediatric intensive care units, such as King's, still don't have a consultant lead.
For babies, children and young people at home, only 31% of ICBs could evidence commissioning 24/7 end-of-life care to national quality standards. My Lords, currently, this data shows ICBs clearly do not know whether they're meeting their populations palliative care and end-of-life care needs or not. 65% of people across the UK are worried about access to such care, and 41% think too little resource is allocated to it. The evidence strongly supports specialist palliative care being stipulated on the face of the bill as in my two amendments, 279B and 242. COVID revealed how integrated palliative care teams cared better for patients and contributed across health and care.
Those in community and in publicly managed services appeared better able to respond to escalating needs. We must collate person-centred outcomes. Outcomes are not the same as experience. People cared for with kindness and compassion may report a good experience, even if their care fails to manage their pain or other symptoms optimally. Data on unmet holistic palliative care needs and gaps in access are essential to service improvement,
and robust national post-bereavement surveys can capture the voices of recipients and those who represent those who are very sick and dying. Increasingly, electronic systems share information, although sometimes slowly, between NHS and charitable hospices on discussions and decisions people had about their care. Such conversations guide advance care plans, which are the advance statement of wishes in the Mental Capacity Act for which the noble Baroness Barker is to be commended. Sensitive, holistic conversations are part of good care. They must be at the person's own pace, respecting ambivalence and changes, not risk becoming a tick-box exercise.
Care improves through evidence innovations. The impact centre's digestible research summaries foster the adoption and spread of innovation, and inspire researchers whose outputs contribute to our economy. And evidence from the NIHR Policy Research Unit is that specialist palliative care increased quality of life with reduced costs at home of £7,900 per person and reduced hospital costs of around 6.5 thousand per person who dies. My Lords, we know that specialist palliative care works. The evidence is clear and robust.
It reduces hospital bed days, reduces deaths in hospital, reduces healthcare costs while improving quality of life. We have a moral and an economic duty to ensure access to specialist palliative care is now improved, and we have an opportunity. I beg to move.
Speaker 74
clause 16, page four, line 20, at the end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
Anne Thérèse Coffey
My Lords, I'd speak for Amendment 45, which is referring to promoting palliative care equitably. And in particular, I refer to access for all regardless of wealth or geography. Now, I am very fond of the minister. Nobody can get grumpy with the minister. But I'm getting grumpy with the Department of Health and other ministers for the fact that we still don't have the modern service framework for the end of life and palliative healthcare, which has been going on for some time.
I think the latest answer last in September was it would be published in autumn, and to be generous to the government, that normally means right up until Christmas Eve. But I hope that we will see this framework. And it's a long time coming because of the stories that we do hear, and that we've just heard from my noble friend, Baroness Finlay of Llandaff, about accessing such palliative care often does seem a postcode lottery. Now, when I first moved to Suffolk, I became aware of something called the Halesworth Community Nursing Care Fund.
It no longer exists. It's been absorbed into something called the Pear Tree Fund, also still in Halesworth. But there, local people frankly got fed up of waiting for a hospice, and there are still valiant efforts trying to have a building, but I do appreciate that hospice at home is a key element of more the modern hospice service. But nevertheless, it did feel that unless there were people with deep pockets, or those that run the marathons around the country, or indeed other ways of raising funding, that too often that hospice near them would either never open, or indeed for those continuing to support it would collapse. And that's why I do welcome in the neighbourhood health plans the proposals that we have I think by 2029 ongoing targets in regards to this, but we still need the substance.
And I'm also very conscious that living in a rural community not everything is going to be quite on hand. But that doesn't mean that it should be so far away that it more or less becomes irrelevant. And that's where I would like to understand more about how the government is going to consider particularly the provision of such care in rural settings. My Lords, in terms of another amendment in this group, Amendment 230 tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, I wanted to understand this more. And this is about requiring a conversation at the end of life once I think it's terminal illness has been diagnosed.
And I don't think it's written so that it must be offered, not necessarily that a person has to take it up. But I think in a further part of the clause, it suggests that where the person doesn't take it up, or can't take it up, that the family does. Now, I do appreciate that having conversations about the end of life can be very tricky. And bear this in mind of people who are nearing the end of their lives, of what kind of has happened in not too distant a future at too distant in the in history. When I think of the heinous Liverpool Care Pathway, where people effectively were starved and not allowed water, that was horrific.
And I was pleased when she's no longer in her place, but the noble Baroness, Lady Neuberger, came up with her review that the Oh, she's over there behind, apologies. Apologies, I thought it's good to see her here. But made the recommendations which government followed, and that was cast to history. There's also the wide-ranging element of do not resuscitate. And I will use personal anecdote on this.
I do recall going in when my mother had a hip broken a hip, and they constantly kept trying to get her to do a DNR, and then told her that the consultant could do it anyway. It's just like it's just not very encouraging. And when she was finally, sadly, diagnosed in hospital, they didn't actually really know exactly what was wrong with her, but they told her she was going to have less than a month to live.
And that was true. That is what happened. Um, but again, it was very clear in terms of parental, my mother, her patient choice was she was desperate to try and die at home. And to be fair, there was a particular nurse who tried everything and was successful.
But I have to say the bargy-argy of getting it done, for a woman who was dying, I was prepared to just shove her in my car and drive home. But eventually, we did get the agreement for an ambulance to take her home. But even then, all of a sudden, as we were ready to leave, DNR was there. It was just like, I know my mother does not want this. So, they went and found her.
She wasn't speaking very much by then, but she shook her head that she didn't want it. So, it's an element of trust that frankly, I don't know how many people have got confidence, necessarily, on that end-of-life care being provided. She was a woman of faith and if anything, it was a priest from the local Catholic church who happened to be on duty, came in, a Father Joseph Welch. And that conversation more than anything helped a woman of faith who was scared of dying to effectively be reconciled. But it was important in a different way to recognize that this isn't just about NHS saying, "Let's have a chat about the end of your life."
Because, I'm afraid, there is still a nervousness about where that will end up. So, what I wanted to understand, I'm conscious we've spent a lot of time debating another bill in this House where people are scared towards the end of their life and what pressure there may be on taking a particular pathway. And I think we need to be careful and how we get that judgment right is really important. That's why I understand the sentiment behind Amendment 230, but I'd be pretty nervous putting it on the face of the bill, and how that gets delivered being absolutely right for everybody, but also can we get the quality and absolute real understanding that this would actually work to the benefit of the patient, albeit it may be in their final weeks.
Sheila Hollins
I'd like to start by thanking my noble friend, Baroness Finlay, for making the strong economic case for specialist palliative care and also for these very thoughtful amendments, which I've added my name to several of them. Amendment 78. Well, ICBs already have responsibility for commissioning palliative care and that came about following amendments for the 2022 Health Act, which Baroness Finlay introduced. But there's insufficient accountability about whether and how they are meeting the needs of their local populations. The House of Commons Health and Social Care Committee's recent inquiry found no clear standards or reporting requirements for ICBs for the provision of palliative and end-of-life care.
And geographical inequality is striking. In 2023, the proportion of people dying in a hospital varied from 36% to 52% between ICB areas, and the proportion dying at home varied from 26% to 33%. Why? Why are there so many differences between different areas? We cannot improve what we do not properly measure.
Palliative care at the end of life is an essential component of healthcare, not an optional extra. This amendment would require annual performance assessments regarding the standard of palliative care and end-of-life care being provided.
Amendment 26 would require urgent investment in palliative care through a transformational fund. The Health and Social Care Committee considered the specialist palliative care workforce to be in a critical situation. They described 78 consultant vacancies, and around 40% of hospitals not providing a 7-day, face-to-face specialist palliative care service. So, more funding would support the government's intended move towards more care in the community, and help to avoid needless prolonged hospital admissions. Amendment 242 would ensure that NHS and hospice services can work together effectively, with timely information sharing, access to beds, medicines, equipment and appropriately trained staff that patients need and deserve.
At the moment, it is so fragmented. It is so fragmented. It is very hard for people trying to coordinate and manage their own end-of-life care at home, as I know only too well when my husband died last year. The scale of the voluntary sector's contribution is considerable. In 2024-25, hospices across the UK provided palliative and end-of-life care to 310,000 people, alongside direct support to 89,000 family members, friends and carers.
But the financial pressures they are facing are significant, and of course, they rely heavily on charitable donations and fundraising. But voluntary sector providers are not peripheral to our health and care system. They are essential partners. And of course, the Public Accounts Committee in the House of Commons have estimated that 300 hospice inpatient beds have been lost due to a lack of funding. So, it would be very timely to introduce all of these amendments, and I give my wholehearted support to them.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, I rise to commend all of the amendments in this group, as the noble Baroness Finlay, who introduced it so powerfully, said I attach my name to the noble lady's Amendment 26, which provides for a transformational fund for improvements in access, to support service redesign by scaling proven models of care, supporting also the planned shift from hospital care to community care. Now, as the noble Baroness Coffey alluded to, we have to consider this group of amendments in the context of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, generally known as the assisted dying bill. I spoke at the second reading of it in your Lordships' House and my noble friend Baroness Jones covered the committee stage. And it's worth noting that the second time that bill was presented in the other place, Andy Burnham said, in what was a very influential intervention, that before assisted dying is considered in England and Wales, the funding of palliative care should be fixed. That's what this group of amendments in their various ways is seeking to achieve, and surely, we now have the government often says they will do this when legislative time allows, we have the opportunity before us right at this moment.
And I think we've had covered many of the points already, but I just think it is worth noting that on October 20, more than 100,000 people had signed a petition which was delivered to number 10, calling for sustainable hospice funding to be made a national priority. And at that event, the Shakespeare Hospice Chief Executive said, "Our ask is simple: a fair and sustainable long-term funding model that ensures everyone can access high-quality hospice care, regardless of where they live."
But the fact is of course that in many ways hospice care and provision of it is not only a postcode lottery, but it is going backwards in many parts of the country. On average, about 270,000 people each year receive hospice care, but only 40% of the funding for that comes from government sources. So, you've got 60% of the funding coming from very often pensioners standing at train stations, rattling buckets. You have a reliance on charity shops, but charity shops is a funding model that is in very significant difficulty, in part because of fast fashion and other changes. We have of course a cost-of-living crisis that means many people who may have made contributions before simply are not in a position to make those contributions now.
Now, I've spoken in your Lordships' House previously about the very sad closure of the Richard House Hospice in East London, that was in 2025, and I note just as one example the Queenscourt Hospice in Southport, which has been going for 35 years and in the middle of this year, it cut its inpatient provision by 50%, decreasing bed capacity from 10 to 5. It also reduced outpatient services, therapies, and hospice-at-home clinical provision. Associated with that was a loss with a loss of 20 full-time equivalent medical posts. I note also that the Royal College of Nursing supported at its congress in May overwhelmingly, saying that the RCN is going to have to advocate to get decent coverage of hospice care. My Lords, that should not be necessary.
We have before us a bill that has the possibility for the government to put into this a legislative statutory framework to support proper palliative care, which indeed the Prime Minister has said he wants to do.
Kamlesh Patel
My Lords, I've put my name down for Baroness Finlay's amendments 26, 78, 242 and absolutely support everything that's been said by Baroness Finlay, Baroness Hollins and others. And they have highlighted the serious problem of underfunding of palliative care, whether that is like specialist palliative care or community palliative care or hospital palliative care. I to make my points, I need to personalise, which I hope I can do successfully. What impressed me most, when I had to experience provision of palliative care, was the personalised care plan that was written by the team who was going to look after my wife and she died last year. And that was so fundamental for the family and for the patient.
The other important bit was a compassionate. The compassionate that was so shown, and I don't know any branch of medicine where I personally feel compassion is paramount. It's a person who's dying. There could be nothing more final than death, and if we cannot show compassion at that time, then we fail. The next bit was the communication: the communication with patient, the communication with the team who was going to look after and the family, and the inclusion of family in that communication was extremely important.
The team was identified as to who they would really be. It was the GP, it was the district nurses, it was a specialist palliative consultant, who at the end did not need her service to be provided, but nonetheless was available.
The other bit important was the coordination. There was a total coordination of Macmillan nurses, the district nurses, the GP, importantly, to assess the medication that was required on a daily, 24-hours a day, 7-days a week. Because what I learned, if although I'm a doctor of long standing, what I learned was the patients who are dying, medication tends to change hour by hour because their symptoms change. They're not just the symptoms of pain, there are other symptoms that make them uncomfortable, and they need to be relieved of those. Middle of the night, I've services available at 2:00 in the morning by a phone call,
somebody appeared five minutes later to provide that medication and care by the team. The next was continuity of care. It was absolutely the same GP who visited everyday, the same district nurses, including at weekends, day and night, and that continuity of care was provided all of the time. The next bit was comfort. It was it is bit difficult to understand how much comfort is important to these patient when they're dying.
They're uncomfortable because of pain, they're uncomfortable because of the disease that's killing them, they're uncomfortable because they develop symptoms which are difficult like retching and vomiting and other symptoms. And that requires treatment at the time. And if that is not available, the patient who's dying suffers. The choice and the patient autonomy was another factor. That patients do have a say, even though they're dying, as to what would help them.
And that was important. And, furthermore, it was a control that a patient was helped to achieve their goals, and they do have goals even though they're dying. They know what they want in terms of comfort and other issues. Any palliative care proposals, any frameworks developed must address this issue, paramount of which should be the compassion. If we fail to do this, then we fail.
We should not rely on funding from charities, organizing fêtes and coffee mornings. We should fund the service appropriately and we should fund it and demonstrate that we are a compassionate society. Hear.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, I take a rather different view from the noble Lord Patel. I mean we need to look back at the foundation of the hospice movement. It was always founded within the charitable sector and I think it's always been valuable that a lot of the funds to run them have been raised themselves and that has given them a certain degree of independence, which they clearly wouldn't have if they're entirely funded by the state. It also meant that they've brought innovation into services for care, for palliative care, in a way I think that directly funded services would have found it difficult. But I do think, my Lords, that there is a need now for more support from government.
I would acknowledge the resources government has put in the last two years, which is very welcome, and the framework that hopefully my noble friend can say when it's coming. As I understand it, one of the issues about hospice funding is that it is so It's hand to mouth, because I For some reason, ICBs and their predecessors seem to have been incapable of giving longer-term contracts and certainty.
and so it's always short-term contracts. It's always hand to mouth. And my Lords, in a sense, this takes to the heart of this bill, because the reason so many of these amendments are really because we don't trust ICBs to do the job properly. Their main focus is on waiting times and financial performance,
and when you look at the huge variation in funding of palliative care, can we have any confidence that even with the modern framework, we're actually going to get a more comprehensive package of long-term certainty for hospices? And I think that, my Lords, is, in a sense Of course, there's a wider challenge of palliative care within the NHS itself, which Baroness Finlay referred to. But I think, on the hospice issue, some reassurance that actually the framework, when it is published,
would actually mean that ICBs have to sort this out, have to give long-term certainty and actually deal with some of the variation in funding that we see at the moment would be really welcome.
Speaker 83
My Lords, Lord Patel so movingly, other speakers in this group so powerfully, have made the case for palliative and end-of-life care, and I won't seek to repeat that. The whole of Parliament has expressed that view extensively over the last 18 months. I would just very briefly comment on the question as to whether or not provision should be on the face of the bill, or whether or not they should rely on action by the government. And I anticipate that the noble Lady, the Minister, the noble Baroness, the Minister, will make the case that this does not need to be specified in primary legislation, that it can, in fact, be done by administrative act, physical act from the Department of Health and Social Care, and I actually believe that to be the case, but in principle.
Speaker 84
There is no need for new Secretary of State powers, you don't need a new administrative reorganization to actually allocate funding to meet unmet need in palliative and end-of-life care. The question before the committee, however, is the government actually going to do it? And in a sense, I think what we can do is we can give the noble Baroness, the Minister, a bit of leverage inside the department between now and report stage by perhaps sending a signal that if the modern service framework for palliative and end-of-life care has not emerged by then, it's possible that your Lordships' House will take a more stringent view on the need for primary legislation. The noble Baroness, the Minister, told us in writing on the 4th of June that we would see this modern service framework for palliative and end-of-life care in the autumn, as the noble Baroness, Coffey, has pointed out. We are now in November.
Speaker 82
The nights are drawing in. The clocks have gone back. Guy Fawkes Night is this week. Halloween has been and gone. So the question for the noble lady, the Baroness, the Minister, is the promise of an autumn modern service framework trick or treat?
Carys Davina Tanni Grey
I rise just briefly to speak in this group of amendments, because they have an impact on other amendments that have. And I read with interest amendment 45 in the name of the noble lady, Baroness Coffey, ensuring that there was equitable palliative care regardless of wealth or geography. And I'm not entirely sure whether disability would be included in this,
But I'm really keen that disabled people aren't forgotten within this bill. Last week, I spoke to an organisation that works with wheelchair users, and it was very worrying conversation about the impact of general NHS services, and then also into specialist services in terms of change in spinal units and the support they give people if they've had a traumatic accident, but actually the lack of accessibility of a number of services we take for granted, particularly breast cancer screening and smears. And a number of disabled women have been in contact with me to say they've been refused those basic treatments because they're disabled, or because the inaccessibility of the machines. And I've had to have several mammograms over the years, and the machines just aren't designed for somebody who can't stand. So, the last time I had one, I actually had three nurses kind of lifting me up into the machine, which wasn't particularly easy or useful, but they managed to make it work for me.
But I'm worried about the number of people who aren't able to make it work, who might end up in palliative care services far earlier than they need to because of the lack of treatments that they're currently able to access, and you layer on the postcode lottery of it. And I'm really keen that there's a real understanding of the quality of life of disabled people as part of this, to ensure that they get the right support at the right time. And it's really difficult to discuss this bill without my recent experiences of now three stays in hospital since August. The second time I was in, well, the first and second time, I had cellulitis, and it was interesting in the papers that I took home with me when I was released the second time, that it actually had my DNR- DNAR status on the paper. Luckily, it said no.
But it was kind of really interesting that was just, there was no discussion with me, and I wouldn't have expected them to have that discussion with me because of the condition that I had. But a number of disabled people are really worried about when DNAR status is put on their documentation with or without a discussion. And that then leads to amendment 230 in the noble name of the noble Lady Baroness Pidgeon, about the conversations that we have around that and whether it's one conversation or many conversations, it's making sure that the right time is made available to make sure that those are carried out properly. And I think something I'm just very keen on in this group is the specialist aspect of palliative care. So, it's not just generalist education.
It's making sure that we're actually able to raise the bar on specialist palliative care that is available to everyone to make sure that they get the right support at the right time that they need it.
Speaker 86
Like the noble Baroness, Morris of, I spend a lot of time sitting on the woolsack. I didn't take part in the debates on the Assisted Dying Bill, because I couldn't, because I was caring for somebody who, as I said at second reading, died in June. I'm actually very pleased that I didn't, because I don't think that I would have been able to do that with the composure that it would have required. But I did listen to a lot. And the one thing that I would say to your Lordships is that bill did a very substantial amount of damage to this House in very many ways.
Speaker 85
And one of the things that it did was to damage the reputation of this House amongst carers' groups, because there were several speeches made during that bill that were really denigrating carers, not some carers, I would imagine that the people who made those speeches would say, but leaving an impression that many people in this House believe that carers can be unfeeling and mercenary, not with any evidence behind them to substantiate.
Speaker 94
And I think that when we can go on as we must do to look at what happened in that bill, we really need to think very carefully about things like that. And I say that because my experience and the experience of my wife was completely different to that which has been thought. My wife was diagnosed with a condition that she knew would be terminal. And at the point that happened, she made her advanced choice direction and she stuck to it. She didn't want to be resuscitated.
Speaker 93
My experience and hers, because it was quite often, it was always her that was in charge as far as I was concerned, was that every healthcare professional she came across asked her about that. They didn't argue about it, but time and time again they asked her, "Did she really still want?" And she was quite clear. And her statement was as clear as it could be, yes, she would be treated for something which could be treated was treatable and could be reversed; no, she did not want to be revived if she was dying. As it happened, her palliative care took place in an acute hospital.
Speaker 87
And it was extremely good, and it was done in consultation with the rest of the rest of the care team. And that's the thing that I want to, one of the things that I want as to realize is that when we talk about hospices, a lot of the discussion is about locations. Well, that's irrelevant. Palliative care is about a process of care. It's not about a location.
Speaker 92
I am a very proud member and longstanding member of the all-parliamentary group on HIV/AIDS. Mildmay Mission and the Sussex Beacon were set up long time ago to be palliative care systems. Luckily, so luckily, that community and for the purp- the pur- the purpose that they were set up changed because of treatment, but repurposing those buildings to make sure that now that they can be centers of excellent care and treatment for people who are getting old, with, often with comorbidities, is a battle that those organizations are having to have. Why? Because there have been so many NHS reorganisations in the time that there is no institutional memory about provision of care.
Speaker 91
And bear in mind, it was 40 years ago, it was the HIV sector that really did shake up what was then considered to be the classic model of palliative care. The noble Lord Patel, is absolutely right: it's coordination that is needed above all else when a patient and their family is in that state. Now, I think the key part of all of it is to make sure that advanced choice direc- documents are made of, I would personally make them mandatory, I really would. I'd be that strong, but I know you can't. But they are the single transformative thing for patients and their families.
Speaker 90
I'm very lucky, I knew exactly what my wife wanted and did not want. I've talked to other pa-, other carers who've been in the same position that I was, they don't. And that is extremely difficult for them. In my, in our case, it made it so much easier to talk and agree with doctors about what was going to happen and when. So, I would simply say that, in all of this, we really do think, when we talk about palliative care, if you don't include carers in it, you're not really having a proper conversation at all.
Speaker 85
So, I would like us to take some of the principles about the of that are included in these amendments, but stop being hung up on the location of where palliative care takes place.
Speaker 89
My Lords, I hadn't actually intended to intervene in this debate, so I was saving myself for social care and those other issues, but I was very moved by my noble friend Lord Patel's interjection. Hear. And I also disagreed with the noble Lady, Baroness Coffey. I think this is an important suite of amendments, because when we're talking about comprehensive integrated care, it of course has to include end of life, of course it does. And of course, therefore, I know that my noble friend and the minister will be discussing how best to do that, and it may not be to put it on the face of the bill, but it definitely has to be included in this legislation.
I do think that the amendment by the noble Lady, Baroness Pidgeon, is a very good amendment, and I completely agree with it. And I just wanted to say that to the noble Lady.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, first of all, can I thank the noble Lord Patel, and my noble friend Baroness Barker for their very personal and raw contributions as recent carers and their recent losses of loved ones. I'm grateful for the support from Baroness Thornton for my amendment 230 in this group, which is also has the support of Marie Curie and Hospice UK. And at its heart is the principle that people approaching the end of life should be able to have their wishes, preferences, and priorities for care understood, recorded, and respected. Advance care planning helps enable people with terminal illness to express how and where they wish to be cared for. It supports more proactive and personalized care.
And, as we've heard, it has been shown to improve patient and family satisfaction, while reducing the likelihood of crises, avoidable hospital admissions, and the need for emergency care out of hours. And I've seen firsthand in Devon, where the system seems to be set up fairly well to support people in their own homes and to have these actually very difficult conversations by a hospice at home service, and with people who have a real skill in communicating and talking about these very difficult topics at a time when someone may have just learned that they have a terminal illness and lots of things are going round their mind, but being able to get some clarity going forward about what they do wish for and what they don't wish for I think is really important. But, as we've heard, other parts of the country do not work so well. Importantly, the evidence suggests that advance care planning does not increase cost of the health and care system, and may in some cases actually reduce health care expenditure by ensuring care is delivered in accordance with patients' wishes. And we will come on to the single patient record on a later day, but I should flag here that advance care planning can only be effective if the information is available to those providing care when it's needed.
So, you know, the single patient record does offer this really significant opportunity to improve coordination and continuity of care, but its success will depend not simply on sharing data, but ensuring that advance care planning is routinely embedded in clinical practice so that people's wishes can be accessed, understood, and acted upon wherever and whenever care is provided. Now, the other amendments in this group, from Baroness Finlay and Baroness Coffey, highlight the many issues and, as we've been debating, with the current landscape for palliative care and specialist palliative care services, and the difficulty getting access to these services. I look forward to the minister's response, and also her response to the trick or treat challenge.
Salah Syed Kamall
My Lords, this has been an important and timely debate, coming not long after the End of Life for the Terminally Ill Adults Bill, but also the Prime Minister's remarks.
While these amendments address a range of issues, they all point to the same conclusion: palliative and end-of-life care must have a central place in this conversation. If the government is serious about shifting care from hospitals into communities, supporting people to remain closer to home, notwithstanding the comments from the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, and delivering truly patient-safe, -centred care, then palliative care must be part of that vision from the outset. The need for action is clear. Marie Curie estimates that around 170,000 people in England each year die with unmet palliative care needs, equivalent to almost one person every 3 minutes. So, we must ensure that those approaching the end of their lives can access the support they need when and where they need it.
And, my Lords, this is closely linked to my noble friend, Lady Coffey's amendment, who spoke movingly of her mother's experience and the need to ensure that patients have access to high quality palliative care wherever they happen to live and choose to die. My Lords, if the government's proposed National Care Service is to succeed, it cannot simply be a discussion about structures or responsibilities and reorganisations. It must be about the experience of those who rely on care. And no group demonstrates this more clearly than people approaching the end of their life. Palliative care is perhaps one of the clearest examples of where health and social care are inseparable.
While clinical support may be provided by the NHS, the ability of a person to remain at home or close to home, to maintain their dignity and spend time with loved ones often depends just as much on the availability of social care. For many families, it is social care that provides the day-to-day support on which good end-of-life care depends. And evidence shows that when effective support is available in the community, people are more likely to be cared for and pass away in the place they choose rather than in hospital. As the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, and the noble Baroness, Lady Hollins, said, this will also reduce hospital deaths, save the NHS money and make more beds available. My Lords, palliative care does not begin and end with an NHS.
It depends upon social care providers, community services, carers, local authorities, hospices and voluntary organisations working together around the individual and their families. And when these services are joined up, people are more likely to receive care in the setting they choose and with the support they need. When they are not joined up, it can profoundly affect those approaching the end of their lives. And in that context, I welcome the amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, which recognises that good palliative care depends not on any single organisation, but on effective collaboration across the NHS, adult social care and the voluntary sector. Too often, services that support people approaching the end of their life are commissioned, funded and delivered separately, despite the fact that patients and families experience them as all part of one single journey.
And the amendment would help to ensure that integrated care boards take active steps to bring those services together, whether through access to specialist hospice care, shared equipment, medicines, workforce development or closer collaboration between providers. But crucially, it recognises the vital contribution of hospices and charitable organisations to the delivery of palliative and end of life care. These organisations are not peripheral to the system. They are an essential part of it.
And if the government is serious about that national care service and a neighborhood health service that are genuinely joined up around individual patients, then the expertise and the capacity of the voluntary sector must be properly integrated into the way that care is planned and delivered. Indeed, some of the most important services available to people at the end of their life are delivered by the hospices and the charitable organizations. For decades, as the noble Lord Hunt said, the voluntary sector has not merely supplemented statutory services, it has been fundamental to the provision of specialized palliative care. Yet, too often, it is forced to operate at the margins of the system, dependent on local arrangements, local fundraising decisions, local fundraisers, as we've heard, and subject to tax rises, such as employers' national insurance, from which state providers are understandably exempt. The noble Baroness Lady Bennett shared examples of recent hospice closures.
And if the government wishes to build that neighborhood care health service and develop the National Care Service, then integration must mean integration not only within the NHS, but between the NHS, adult social care, and voluntary sector, and ultimately, that the measure of success will not be the structures we create, but whether individual patients receive seamless support at one of the most difficult moments of their lives and for their families. And whether patients have the conversation about the end-of-life care that the noble Baroness Lady Pidgeon's amendment addresses and illustrated by the very moving stories from the noble Lord Patel and the noble Baroness Lady Barker's personal experience and the concerns raised by the noble Baroness Lady Grey-Thompson. So these amendments, I think, seek to move us towards that goal, and I hope that the minister will give careful consideration to the issues that have been raised during this debate.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I can certainly confirm to the noble Lord, I will, of course, give complete consideration to the points raised, and as other noble Lords have acknowledged, I particularly want to speak to the noble lady Baroness Barker and the noble Lord Patel to thank them for bringing their loved ones into the chamber for the benefit of others, but also their willingness to share with us such a painful but realistic time. And I believe many people will identify with what Baroness Barker said and Lord Patel said, and that will mean so much to so many. So, my Lords, let me address Amendments 26, 45, 78, 230, 242, and 279B together. I'd like to give the assurance that under the NHS Act 2006, integrated care boards already have a statutory requirement to provide palliative care and end-of-life care. They have that to such an extent as they consider necessary, and yes, I am quoting, to meet the reasonable requirements of the people for whom they have responsibility.
And additionally, statutory guidance does allow commissioners to determine what the appropriate mix of services is according to the needs of the population and according to the services that are available locally. It also provides that ICBs should ensure integrated and sufficient provision to meet the needs of their local population, whether that's inpatient beds or equipment, and it's also, as I said, taking account of locally available services and best value for money, including voluntary sector provision. And all commissioners are expected to define how their services will meet the needs of the population 24 hours in each day of the week.
And the noble Lord Patel made a very clear, a moving point about the needs of someone who is receiving palliative care, how their needs can vary, including on medication, hour by hour. And I think that sets this form of service apart in this respect. Now my noble friend Lord Hunt reflected that the debate was saying that ICBs, and I hope I'm faithfully quoting my noble friend, are incapable of long-term contracts and certainty, and the fact is, my noble Lord said, that ICBs aren't trusted to do the job properly. So let me say that in June, and that's ahead of course of the publication of the modern service framework, NHS England did set out that it expected all ICBs to complete an integrated needs assessment to gain a detailed understanding of their current and future, importantly, future population, including people of all ages, in respect of palliative care and end of life care needs. And we are asking ICBs to move to a sustainable contracting of palliative care services based on that assessment.
So the point the noble Lord, my noble friend has made has been heard. I do want to assure the noble Lady Baroness Finlay that with respect to her Amendment 279B, these requirements do include specialist palliative care where appropriate. And I know the noble Lady will know this, but crucially, not everybody of course approaching end-of-life requires specialist palliative care, and for many their needs can appropriately be met through high quality generalist palliative care and end-of-life care with specialist services being available for those who have more complex needs. Looking at Amendments 45, 78 and 230, I believe that the current statutory framework and established guidance also already helps deliver the intended objectives of Amendments 45, 78 and 230, and that's a point that the noble Lord Stevens predicted that I would say, and I think he gave his support in advance for me doing that. The noble Lord is saying conditionally, but I would expect, I would expect it always to be conditional.
Thank you for clarifying. To address the concerns of the noble Lady Baroness Coffey, as we've already discussed in this Committee, Section 1C of the NHS Act 2006 does require the Secretary of State, when exercising functions in relation to the health service, to have regard to the need to reduce inequalities between the people of England in the benefits they can obtain from the health service, and this is deliberately an overarching duty that applies across the whole of the health service, so we don't consider it appropriate to create separate versions of that duty for individual services.
We feel that would risk duplication and make the legislative framework overly prescriptive. Now, turning to the much talked about modern service framework for palliative care and end of life care, referred to as a trick-or-treat test by the noble Lord Stevens, I'll leave him to conclude when I've finished, and by my noble friend Lord Hunt and to the noble Lady, Baroness Coffey, who I can assure that no one in this chamber wants her to feel grumpy. And I'm sure nobody in the department wishes her to feel grumpy. The modern service framework will focus on reducing inequalities. It will identify, it will measure and it will reduce inequalities, and reduce unwanted variation in access, experience and outcomes and that absolutely does include, I'd say to the noble Lady, Baroness Grey-Thompson, in respect of disability.
And the modern service framework is anticipated indeed in the autumn which we remain in. I know that we are all keen to ensure that everyone can receive high quality and personalized care in the right place at the end of life. And I look forward to the modern service framework giving us the best way forward on that. If I could turn to Amendment 70A, also in the name of the noble Lady, Baroness Finlay, as per Clause 21 of this Bill, the Secretary of State is already required to undertake an annual performance assessment of each ICB in discharging its statutory functions. And again, that was an area spoken to by my noble friend, Lord Hunt.
And I would say to the noble Lady, and also to the noble Lady, Baroness Hollins, that the latest report, '24-'25 was published on the 17th of December last year. And future assessments will continue to consider how ICBs are discharging their statutory palliative care duties. And I do understand very much the calls from noble Lords across the House and their emphasis on how important on this. And the modern service framework will indeed build on the ambitions that are set out in the neighborhood health framework, which does include increasing the number of those identified as approaching end of life, increasing that identification by 10%, and reducing non-elective admissions and hospital bed days by 10% for those at end of life. So, I do take the point the noble Lady, Baroness Hollins made in particular about measurement and ambition.
With regard to the NICE guidance in this area, in keeping with all NICE guidance, whilst it is not statutory or legally binding, as local healthcare professionals need autonomy to make clinically appropriate decisions in relation to their patients, there is an expectation that commissioners and service providers take it into account when they are making those decisions on how to meet the reasonable needs of their populations.
With regard to Amendment 230 tabled and spoken to by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, alongside the existing statutory framework that I've already outlined, the already published universal principles of advance care planning promote opportunities for individuals, including those with a terminal diagnosis, to discuss their wishes, their preferences and their and the clinical recommendations. And health and care professionals are expected to provide appropriate opportunities for individuals to engage in advance care planning. And this area was spoken to by the noble Lord Patel, and the noble Baroness, Lady Barker. And these principles do explicitly recognise the importance of involving a person's family, carers and those who are important to them. And I think I would emphasise that point that those who are important to us don't always come neatly packaged.
So, but they are to be involved in discussions, including through the nomination of a named spokesperson. And the outputs of these discussions may include one or more of the following: an advance statement and I've heard how helpful that is, along with the importance of an advance decision, where it is to refuse treatment, context-specific treatment recommendations and lasting power of attorney, where it is appropriate, in line with the Mental Capacity Act 2005. Additionally, for those nearing the end of their life, the Government's priority is to provide people with financial support quickly and compassionately. And the noble Lord Patel, and the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, both spoke to the absolute importance of compassion being at the core in all that is done. In a practical sense, the main way this is done is through the Special Rules for End of Life, which applies to five key benefits, including the personal independence payment.
And moving on to the points made on medicines access raised as part of Amendment 242 tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, the Pharmacy Quality Scheme does form part of the Community Pharmacy Contractual Framework. The scheme's palliative and end-of-life care domain aims to ensure sufficient arrangements are in place so that patients, relatives, carers and healthcare professionals can obtain medicines in a timely manner, again, something spoken to very clearly by the noble Lord Patel. And ICBs do commission out-of-hours dispensing arrangements where there is a need for patients to access medicines outside core pharmacy hours. And finally, my Lords, to address Amendment 26 tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, on which we heard a number of contributions, funding for palliative care and end-of-life care is available through existing NHS funding arrangements. And as I've outlined, ICBs do have that statutory responsibility for commissioning.
And indeed, local commissioners are best placed, as we've discussed on a number of occasions, to determine how funding should be allocated according to the population need, according to local service provision and according to the best use of available resources.
So, the ring-fence, ring-fenced fund proposal, which would mean establishing it in primary legislation, would we believe risk being overly prescriptive and would limit the flexibility of local commissioners to determine how resources are best used. And to the point about hospices and funding, I want to very much recognise, as noble lords have done, the absolutely vital part the voluntary sector organisations play, including hospices, when providing support to people at the end of life, but also support to their loved ones. It is also worth noting that the majority of palliative care and end-of-life care is provided by NHS staff and services, to whom we're also most grateful. It is true that the amount of funding for each charitable hospice will vary, but by definition that depends on the demand in local areas, and it also depends on the type of palliative care provision. But my noble friend Lord Hunt did make the point, and it's something that I have found in my discussions in terms of hospices, how they value their operational independence, and they are great innovators.
So I understand the point about funding, as I would do in this whole area. However, I would make the point that when I have looked at this and spoken with hospices, that independence, that ability to operate is one that they really do value. But, finally, the modern service framework will ensure that palliative care and end-of-life care is well within a strategic commissioning model, and, importantly, there will be clear and transparent contractual arrangements, which I hope noble lords will welcome.
Ilora Finlay
I'm extremely grateful to everybody who's spoken in this debate and in particular to the noble lady Baroness Barker and to my noble friend Lord Patel who have shared their recent experiences, but also to my noble friend Baroness Hollins and the noble lady Baroness Coffey who've drawn on their experiences from before. And I believe everybody in this chamber has got experiences of being bereaved. This is a universal experience. It is not restricted to anyone. And we all carry with us the mark of whatever happened.
I'm grateful to the minister for her comprehensive overview. I'm afraid I'm less confident in ICBs going on to commission. And I would like to point out very clearly that specialist palliative care and hospices are not synonymous. The one doesn't mean the other. They are part of a spectrum of care delivered.
And you have NHS specialist teams, and you have those that are funded by the charitable sector. The problem that I've been highlighting is the deficit across the piece in order to provide care universally. And different models are really important because there are different societies and diff- different ways that people live.
The other problem with the hospice construct and the building is they tend to have grown up in areas that are more wealthy. And in very poor areas and in rural areas, access is much less. And so, therefore, the way that teams operate has to be very flexible. It is the specialist teams that upskill the generalists. It was in specialist services that we learnt the basics of morphine prescribing,
of the basics of antiemetic prescribing. That was not happening anywhere in general services. So to think that you can have one without the other, I think, is really deeply misleading. And specialist services will only look after a small number of specialist problems, of special complex problems, and will be there, in a way, on and off, intermittently, as people need support, and as my noble friend Lord Patel pointed out, the consultant was available, but actually, fortunately, not needed.
But that support had been there. It is that framework that I was seeking to get on the face of the bill. Other people have made some really important points, and I wish I had time to answer each and every one of them. In terms of advance care planning, I don't think there's any difference between the wish between what is happening and Baroness Pidgeon's amendment. My concern is that if you put that on the face of the bill, then you don't have the flexibility, and you run the risk of people saying, "Have we had the conversation?"
"Yes, we have, tick." And it being ticked off on the single patient record. Advance care planning has been evolved through specialist palliative care. They have been the leaders nationally in developing it and in running the conferences on it. And knowing what people want and listening and allowing flexibility is absolutely crucial.
So those conversations must happen. Following on from this, I hope that we could have a meeting with the minister, with those who contributed to this important debate and really find a way forward. There is a lot of confidence in the modern service framework coming along, but it's not here at the moment. And what I'm hearing from some people is concern that it won't actually, adequately address the real, some of the really deep problems that are there. There are solutions which may be adopting some of the things that we did in Wales, of having a funding formula for specialist services linking with generalist services, different ways of doing things,
but we haven't got time in this debate to go through those. But I would really value a meeting and, in the meantime, I will beg leave to withdraw, but I would also point out that I think this has gone on for so long and is so urgent that it may well be that I will be tabling something on the face of the bill to try to address it if we really can't come to a good solution. In the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw.
George Young
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is, by leave, withdrawn. The question is that clause 6 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content.
The contents have it. We now come to amendment 27, Lord Kamall.
Salah Syed Kamall
My Lords, I shall speak to amendment 27 in my name, and let me be clear when I start that I recognize that what I am asking for does not need to be on the face of the bill, and does not actually need legislation. But my frustration at the lack of progress, both when I was the relevant minister and a shadow minister, forced me to table this probing amendment. I often meet entrepreneurs and tech companies who claim they have an innovative product or solution that could transform healthcare, and they ask me, "How can I have a conversation with the relevant person within the NHS?" And when I was a minister and I asked my officials about this, they would give me an email address that I could share.
But two things stayed with me. Firstly, why wasn't this email address widely advertised and why didn't more people know about it? And secondly, when I asked the entrepreneur if they had if anyone from DHSC or NHS England replied, the answer was no. So, in opposition, I began thinking, how can I help more innovators into the NHS? And it was suggested that maybe I should meet the Health Innovation Network who told me that they are the front door for innovation.
Once again, many tech entrepreneurs have never heard of them. And when I read the when I read the Health Innovation Network LinkedIn page, I was surprised to read that they have precisely, quote, between 501 and 1,000 employees. How's that how about that for precision? So, speaking to noble Lords and others interested in health innovation, I've heard a range of opinions about Health Innovation Networks from the good to the bad and somewhere in the middle that some regional Health Innovation Networks are good, while others are not so good, and coverage is patchy. So this brings me to my first questions.
What is their remit and what assessment has the government made of their the effectiveness of the Health Innovation Networks? And what plans does the government have for Health Innovation Networks in the reorganisation? My Lords, let me also recognise that there is a fantastic Clinical Entrepreneur Programme led by Tony Young, himself a NHS surgeon and clinical entrepreneur. And he's always been very open and encouraged me to send clinical entrepreneurs that I meet and approach me, I've managed to pass him on pass them onto him to have further conversations. The question for these amendments, or this amendment, is what about entrepreneurs who are not clinicians, but have an innovative solution that could transform health or social care?
Because for them, there is no obvious front door or one-stop shop to the NHS. So what do they do? They spend ages trying to get into the system at primary care, at trust level or the ICB level, sometimes wasting their time, but also wasting clinicians' precious time. So, sadly, what do they do? They give up or go abroad, meaning that the UK loses out on British innovation.
Now, in July, during an oral question, I asked the noble lady, the minister, to ask the DHSC minister for technology and innovation to create such a front door, or a one-stop shop, to triage those who approach them. And a front door could distinguish between firstly, those salespeople who really have no minimum viable product, telling them what they need to come back with in order to be taken seriously. Secondly, what about those who have a solution, but need more support, so they could be signposted to someone who could advise them where they can come up with a more feasible solution. And thirdly, those that have, potentially, a fantastic solution that could transform healthcare and need to be piloted as quickly as possible. And I was also grateful when noble Lords from all benches later told me that they agree that this was a practical idea.
So, could I ask the noble lady, the minister, whether any progress has been made since I asked that question in July, and if not, what are the reasons? Because, time and again, I hear the same concerns from entrepreneurs, researchers and businesses that the system is difficult to navigate. There are numerous organisations involved in supporting innovation, all with different remits, processes and points of entry. Expertise clearly exists throughout the system, but identifying the right door to knock on can be a challenge in itself. And so this amendment seeks to address that problem through a simple, but important, principle: that there should be a single national point of access through which innovators and other organisations can obtain coordinated support.
And its purpose is not to create another bureaucratic layer. Quite the contrary, it is intended to reduce complexity, improve coordination and ensure that innovators spend less time navigating the system and more time developing solutions that could benefit patients. And indeed, the principle behind the amendments mirrors one that the government has itself embraced health where elsewhere in the health service. The concept of a single point of access, or a single front door, is designed to simplify routes into services, triage inquiries effectively and direct people to the most appropriate expertise at the earliest opportunity.
Rather than forcing patients to navigate multiple pathways, the system assumes the responsibility for guiding them to the right destination. My Amendment 27 applies precise that same logic to innovation. Instead of requiring innovators to work their way through a maze of organizations and programs, a single front door would provide a clear route into the system, supported by intelligent triage to the most appropriate person in the Department of Health and Social Care or NHS, it which could be, but not necessarily, one of the 501 to 1,000 people who work for the Health Innovation Network. Having said that, I beg to move the amendment.
George Young
Amendment proposed, after clause 6 insert the following new clause as printed on the marshalled list.
Paul Scriven
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Kamall, for moving this amendment and for the very short debate that's followed. The frustration, I believe, is real. But the committee deserves answers to two questions: what is in place now, and would this new clause make it better? Now, as the Lord noble Lord, Kamall, said, there are 15 health innovation networks, each serving its own region. But there is already a national point of access.
The NHS Innovation Service, as the noble Lord, Kamall, said, has been running since 2022, set up by a very forward-thinking health junior health minister, noble Lord, Kamall, then. And the NHS England describes it as a single entry point. An innovator completes one record, experts from within the network review it within 10 working days, giving tailored advice, and can refer the innovator to one or more local networks. More than 2,000 innovations have now had support through that service. So, subsection (2)(a) and (2)(b) of this amendment largely describe something that already exists.
Does it work? As a front door, it appears to do so in some regions for some people. The problem is that if the noble Lord, Kamall's, amendment was accepted, it would create two front doors for people to come through, which probably wouldn't be a wise thing to do. But I do believe that the front door is not the main problem here. The problem is spread.
Adaptation is one trust taking up a good idea. Spread is that everything gets to the patient, no matter where they live. The Health Innovation Network's own evidence to Parliament says, adoption is slow, uneven, and overtly dependent on local early adopters. It describes what they call a postcode pattern of spread, and warns that proven technologies do not spread through evidence alone. An innovation proven in one place in one place can face the same hurdles all over again in the next.
So, I don't believe, my Lords, that we have got a front door problem. So, I must be honest, as drafted, I think that this new clause would only help at the margins, and it could actually hinder. It could create a second door besides the one that we have, unless it simply puts a statutory label on the existing service. It would write an operational arrangement into primary legislation when the way innovators are supported should be one that and could be one that changes quickly.
It places duties around networks that neither the bill nor the clause defines. And there are two parts that I do welcome. Subsection 3 would require publishing information on performance and we should be told how many innovations spread beyond their first site and how far. And subsection 2(c) on coordinated support across regions goes closer to the real issue. But the networks say spread need systems with the resource to quote "redesign pathways, train staff and evaluate impact".
A referral service does not provide that. But the amendment's most important contribution is the question it raises. NHS England runs the Innovation Service. The network's national commission comes from NHS England with the Office for Life Sciences. But this bill abolishes NHS England.
Clause 6 gives a Secretary of State a duty to promote innovation and a power to award prizes, but it says nothing about the networks. A prize will not help a company stuck between a successful pilot and the second and its second trust. So, I have a few questions for the minister. Firstly, who will run and fund the Innovation Service and commission the networks once NHS England has gone? And can she guarantee that there will be no gap?
Will the government publish performance data which is lacking, including adoption and spread, and whether or not whether or not this amendment is accepted? And who after abolition will be responsible for making sure a proven innovation spreads across the whole of the NHS, not just to the early adopters? A single door is a reasonable aim and we largely have one. What patients need is for it to work in one part of the NHS and then to reach all of it. I look forward to the minister's reply.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Lord Kamall, for bringing this debate before the House today, and I commend his honesty that this is born out of frustration and a wish to improve things, rather than seeking a legislative response, something the noble Lord Scriven, also observed in looking at the amendment. But I do agree with the noble Lord Scriven, that the amendment raises important points to be considered more broadly. So, I want to assure the noble Lord Kamall, of that consideration. Perhaps I can make a few points that may be helpful, that the NHS Innovation Service does already provide a wide national point of access. The way it works is an innovator makes one request, creates one product record, and is referred according to product type, maturity, and location.
And more than 2,200 products have been registered with, and have received support through, the service, including 710 innovations in the '25-'26 financial year. All health innovation networks do participate alongside 11 other organisations, and that means that innovators do have access to a broad range of expertise through a single service. Almost all products reach at least one health innovation network, and are referred to four organisations on average. Innovators may also approach a network directly. Support can span several networks and regions, with onwards referral requiring no new application, and uptake is already reported at a high level whilst, of course, protecting commercial confidentiality.
Funding a second route, or, as the noble Lord Scriven, said, I believe, a second front door, that would confuse us. But funding a second route where, in effect, if national services are already in place, I hope noble Lord Kamall, will understand may not represent exactly what we might call the most effective use of public resource. I would therefore say that the amendment's core aims are already met, and, actually, prescribing an operating model in legislation, something I know the noble Lord understands, could limit its ability to evolve. The noble Lord Kamall, did ask about Health Innovation Networks, and I can confirm they are subject to performance and impact monitoring and they also produce impact reports to show what their local impact there is. Noble Lord Scriven, asked what would happen following the abolition of NHS England and nationally-funded funded Health Innovation Networks' work will continue and will be overseen by the Secretary of State.
And I will look at the other points that have been raised, because I think they're all certainly relevant, and once to be drawn to the attention of my colleague, the relevant minister, Chris McDonald.
Salah Syed Kamall
Well, my Lords, I am grateful for the very many noble Lords who queued up to speak in this debate. Obviously, I raised a very important point. And also, I did I'm also grateful to noble Lord Scriven, for reminding me how innovative I had been when I was the technology and innovation minister. In fact, I set up the very service that I've been I'm now asking for many years later. But it does ask It does beg the question what noble ah my Lords, because, actually, even myself, as the person who set it up, still did not know that this service existed.
And secondly, and secon- and secondly, when I speak to people in NHS England and elsewhere, and I say, "You know what you need? You need a front door for innovators." They say, "You're absolutely right, but we haven't got one." So, even people in NHS England don't know that this exists. So, all that my I suppose my request would be to the noble lady the Minister and I'm and I'm I was up front about this, I knew this wasn't meant to be on the face of the bill.
I just wanted to get discussion. It probably helped to prompt my memory as well. Thanks to noble Lord Scriven. Thank you. But I was I think it is really important that more people do know about the NHS Innovation Service and perhaps the noble lady the Minister could write to me and the many other noble Lords who are interested in this topic to let us know what the Government intends to do to promote the NHS Innovation Service so more people are aware, so I don't ask for the same thing next time we have a health bill.
Salah Syed Kamall
And ha- ha- having said that, I thought it was quite logical, the logical conclusion would be I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
George Young
Is it your pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is, by leave, withdrawn. We come now to clause 7, amendment 28, Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson.
Eleanor Shawcross-Wolfson
My Lords, I'm grateful to Lord Patel, Baroness Harding of Winscombe, and Baroness Cass for their support of this amendment. In moving amendment 28, I want to make a very simple argument. This bill gives ministers direct responsibility for training and educating the NHS workforce. I believe it should also make ministers responsible for setting out what workforce they believe the NHS requires and developing a training and education plan to deliver that workforce.
My Lords, this is not a controversial proposal. Amendments 92, 252 and 253 in this group make a very similar case. Nor is it a new proposal. In 2022, your Lordships' House passed a very similar amendment to the Health and Care Bill not once, but twice, with support from the Labour benches, the Liberal Democrat benches, and the crossbenches. In 2023, the Conservative government published a long-term workforce plan and asked the National Audit Office to scrutinize the modeling behind it.
In 2024, the Labour Party manifesto promised regular, independent workforce planning, and Ministers subsequently committed to producing a new workforce plan with independent scrutiny. So, in theory, my Lords, we all agree. But in practice, my Lords, we are now more than two years after the election, and Ministers have, understandably, set aside the Conservative government's 2023 plan, but have still not published their own. In June, Ministers said it was coming imminently. We are now told that it will arrive in due course.
My Lords, an insufficient NHS workforce is a problem that has been many years in the making. At the end of June, the NHS in England had more than 100,000 vacancies, and vacancies are not the whole story. Since 2015, the number of patients registered with GP practices has risen by more than 10%, but the number of fully qualified, full-time GPs has gone down. Others in this House can describe far better than I what workforce shortages mean on the frontline. So, I will not talk about how hard it is to plan services when you have insufficient staff to deliver them.
I will not talk about the toll on healthcare professionals when we constantly ask them to cover gaps, and I will not talk about the impact on patient care, but I hope others in this debate will do. Instead, I want to talk about how we ended up here, because I really do believe that all governments understand the importance of NHS workforce planning, but experience shows very few are able to develop and deliver a comprehensive plan. And I think that comes down to the very simple fact that training must be paid for today, and the benefits of training are only realized in the future. It takes three years to train a nurse, around 10 years to train a GP, and up to 15 years to train a consultant. So Ministers constantly face the choice between the pressures of today and the prospect of a better NHS in 3, 10 or 15 years' time.
Every pound spent on a GP for 2035 is a pound not spent this winter, or on this year's political priorities. And at any one moment, choosing to prioritize today makes sense. But repeated year after year, that choice leaves us with a workforce that cannot possibly meet the demands it faces. Of course, politicians can take long-term decisions, and sometimes they do. As Chair of the Health and Social Care Committee, Sir Jeremy Hunt championed independent work force workforce forecasts, and as Chancellor, he was in a position to fund an NHS workforce plan, and did so.
That 2023 plan was backed by more than £2.4 billion. It set out ambitions to double medical school places, increase GP training places by half, and almost double adult nursing training places. It was not a perfect forecast, and the NAO kindly pointed that out when they were asked to scrutinize it. But it was a baseline, my Lords, and it showed that when the political will exists, it is possible to plan and invest in the future. However, my Lords, hoping for sufficient political will is not a strategy.
We won't often have a Chancellor who was previously Health Secretary. So this amendment would make long-term workforce planning a duty, and not a matter of personal commitment. It would require independently verified assessments of what staff the NHS needs, and a 10-year plan to train and educate the staff needed. The first assessment and plan would have to be published within one month of Royal Assent to this bill. Both the plan and the assessment will be kept under review and would have to be revised at least every five years.
In 2022, the noble Baroness, the Minister told this House that without mandated forecasts of staff numbers, meaningful workforce planning, something that every other efficient organisation undertakes, cannot take place.
I really agree with her, and I hope that she'll support this principle from the government benches, as she did from the opposition benches, and back this amendment or one along similar lines. While I'm here, I'd also be grateful if the Minister could answer two questions. First, when will the Government publish their own workforce plan? And secondly, who will undertake the independent scrutiny of that plan? My Lords, every government must have the right to set its own spending priorities, but I would also argue that every government should be transparent about the workforce they believe the NHS needs and what the decisions they're making today about education and training will mean for tomorrow's workforce.
George Young
The amendment proposed: clause 7, page 4, line 31, at end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
Sheila Hollins
I'm grateful to the noble Lady Baroness Tyler and to Lord Singh of Solihull for signing up to my amendments in this group. I'm going to start with Amendment 252 as it relates to the points made by the previous speaker, because it would place a duty on the Government to publish a follow-up mental health workforce plan within 12 months of the highly anticipated publication of the next 10-year NHS workforce plan. And it would require some detail on how the mental health workforce will be effectively retained and recruited to meet the scale of the mental health demand. Retention and recruitment measures combined with a clear commitment to the resources required would help to reassure many patients and people across the mental health sector about how the Government's ambitions in this area will be matched with a strategic approach to delivery, and the sector is looking for tangible outcomes for patients, particularly for those who live with a serious mental illness. Mental health and well-being support for NHS mental health staff is integral to the plan, including developing occupational mental health capacity and investing in staff mental health and well-being hubs nationwide.
Staff sickness figures reveal that anxiety, stress, depression and other psychiatric illnesses continue to be the most reported reason for sickness absence amongst the NHS workforce. In the 12 months up to and including May 2026, these conditions accounted for over 8.3 million days of sickness absence, equivalent to 29% of total sickness absence over that period. So, I welcome the commitment in the 10-year health plan to introduce staff treatment hubs for NHS staff. However, I'm keen to understand how these hubs will interact with the existing NHS staff mental health and well-being hubs. A dedicated NHS mental health workforce plan would help to ensure the hubs are as effective as possible.
Amendment 92 would require ICBs to assess and report on mental health workforce sufficiency for their local area every two years and propose measures to address the challenges faced by their workforce in delivering services for the communities that they serve. This takes me back to the discussions during the passage of the Mental Health Act about the need for sufficient community services for people with learning disabilities and autistic people to avoid unnecessary and lengthy admissions to hospital. A localized focus is vital. Organisations across the mental health sector are concerned that the NHS 10-year plan is too vague about how ICBs are expected to both successfully manage system pressures and, at the same time, meet the ever-growing need for an expanded mental health workforce.
Does the noble lady the minister agree that requiring ICB-led assessments would be an effective way to ensure that the government's programs of national reform can be matched with local plans so that the ambitions of the 10-year health plan can be delivered? The Royal College of Psychiatrists advises that investing in the psychiatric workforce will be essential for effective preventative mental healthcare, for staff well-being, and for successful NHS service delivery. Vacancy rates are just one stark reminder. In the most recent Royal College of Psychiatrists' census,
they found that around one in seven consultant psychiatrists posts in England were vacant or unfilled, this was in 2025, but the true vacancy rate, they suggest, was 27%, because over a quarter of consultant psychiatrist posts across England were either vacant or filled by locum and non-substantive consultants. And in the quarter ending June 2026, the medical and nursing vacancy rates in England in English mental health trusts were 10.8% and 8.1% respectively,
much higher than those in acute trusts of 5.1% medical and 4.8% nursing vacancy rates. So, these statistics serve to reveal the extent of the challenges facing the psychiatric component of the NHS mental health workforce and why a workforce sufficiency assessment process by ICBs could be so valuable in identifying needs and planning accordingly, including for preventative mental health care. The thing is that shortages of personnel restricts innovation and takes energy away from prevention. Careful planning is also needed to address bottlenecks in medical education training pathways, as many resident doctors are currently unable to progress in their NHS careers. I beg to move.
Zahida Manzoor
My Lords, I rise to support the thrust of the amendments in this group, and particularly amendment 28 in the name of my noble friend, Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson, who has put her case forcefully and quite clearly, so I won't detain the House for long. My Lords, poor long-term workforce planning creates significant challenges for the NHS staff and patient care. Inadequate forecasting, insufficient investment in training and recruitment, and poor staff retention contribute to persistent vacancy and skills shortages. This increases workforce loads, stress, burnout, and sickness absence, resulting in low morale and higher staff turnover. The NHS becomes increasingly reliant on expensive agency workers and international recruitment, placing additional pressure on budgets.
Consequently, services experience longer waiting times, reduced productivity, compromised continuity of care, and potential risks to patient safety. NHS England estimated an existing workforce shortfall of approximately 150,000 full-time equivalent staff, potentially rising to 260,000 to 360,000 by 2036-37 if there was no intervention. Effective long-term planning is therefore essential to develop a sustainable workforce, improve staff wellbeing, strengthen retention, ensure safe, high-quality patient care, and I strongly urge the minister to support this amendment, and for ministers to be held accountable for the delivery of this workforce plan.
Kamlesh Patel
Sorry. I strongly support the amendment that I've added my name to it of Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson. She spoke so eloquently and made her case so strongly that I've put aside what I had written down because it would have been a repetition of what she had already said.
So I'm going to take a slightly different tack, but make the same point. And she quite rightly linked education, training and workforce planning. You have to know what workforce you might require for the health service you plan to have. And I guess one can say that the government's ten-year health plan and the ten-year cancer care plan outlines the kind of health service that the government wishes to see over the next develop over the next ten years. If that is the case, then you need to address what kind of training and education and what kind of people we will need to deliver that plan.
That plan relies heavily, and I'm guessing now that the reason why the ten-year workforce plan is delayed is because the basis on which that was to be formulated was based on the premise that technology like AI and digital technology will free up a lot of clinical time and hence the headcount needn't be so high. That is a false assumption. It is false because we do first of all we need to train people to use AI and digital technologies. The assessment is that if you use these technologies, you might free up to about 40 minutes a day time for front-line clinicians. With the pressure that the NHS now faces, and the needs of the workforce it now faces, that time will be used to deliver better care to patients.
particularly as the ten-year health plan identifies that technologies such as genomics and personalized medicine will be the way healthcare will go with an ambition to have 50% of patients by 2040 have some issue some idea of how their genomics pans out and the treatment therefore is based on that. If you add all this together, and the Secretary of State now has a responsibility for education, training, and workforce planning, then you ask the question, why is the workforce plan delayed? It's delayed because maybe the penny has dropped that if you don't count the numbers, and don't present a case as to how technologies will reduce clinical front-line clinical time, then you cannot plan a workforce plan. Furthermore, I wonder if the Bailey review, which is based on review of productivity in the NHS, again a premise that a greater productivity will be delivered in NHS because of using technologies like AI and digital technologies.
We don't know that will happen. But we have to wait till the Bailey review comes out and I wonder if that's another reason, and the noble Baroness the minister might comment on that, as to why the workforce plan is delayed. So, it might be political pressures, it might be fiscal pressures, it might be pressures of not knowing how to get the numbers of workforce that we would require to deliver on the ten-year plan and the cancer plan that is holding up workforce planning. But as the noble Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson pointed out, if we don't have a plan, the things will get worse.
Speaker 99
We will introduce technology, which will be not across the board, and that we will then look for workforce that is not trained to deliver it. So I hope the noble Baroness, the minister, will give some answers as to where we're going.
Claire Tyler
My Lords, I was very pleased to add my name to the two amendments and then by the noble lady, Baroness Hollins, amendments 92 and 252 regarding mental health workforce. Look more generally, I'd just like to say I was very taken indeed by the way this really important group of amendments was introduced by the noble lady Baroness Chaworth-Musters, because she's absolutely right. All the things that we've been talking about in this bill so far, all the things I think we all want to see to improve the health of this country and all the things we want the NHS to be able to do, yes, efficiently and yes with increased productivity, but also with great care and compassion, none of them are going to be achieved unless we have a workforce, the right workforce with the right skills and that the education and training is in place. So, that's why I think this is such an important set of amendments. As I said, I was very pleased to add my name to the two amendments by the noble lady Hollins in relation to the mental health workforce.
And the noble lady set out the case very clearly, so I just don't need to do that again. I simply wish to re- reiterate the point that once we have the long-awaited NHS workforce plan, I do think it's absolutely vital, and be grateful if the noble lady, the minister, could make some commitment here about how quickly we will see a follow-up mental health workforce plan. We really do need to see some detail about how the mental health workforce will be recruited, will be retained, and will be able to reach to meet the scale of the mental health demand that we have debated so many times on so many occasions. So, I think that's absolutely critical. And I just and both of those amendments I think of are very important in that respect.
My final sort of thought is that during the passage of the Mental Health Bill, which many noble Lords here were involved in, I think we all thought, and quite rightly, how important it is that as much as many health service for mental health services as possible were actually located in the community. And I think we all agreed with that, and it was the premise, if you like, on which the rest of that legislation was built. But unless we have that workforce, and particularly that workforce, and as important as the consultants and psychiatrists are, of course they are, it's a wide-ranging workforce, it includes mental health nurses and others as well. Unless we have that workforce in the right place in the community, appropriately skilled and educated and trained, we will never be able to deliver those community mental health services, which I think are so very vital. So, I was very pleased to support these amendments.
Hear.
Speaker 101
My Lords, I rise to support the amendment in the name a noble lady Baroness Chaworth-Musters, a very important amendment, which ultimately I think raises two fundamental questions that the noble lady the minister I hope will be able to answer. The first is this, that ultimately in preparing a workforce plan that's going to enjoy broad confidence, there must be external scrutiny of that plan. And it would be most helpful for the noble lady, the minister, to confirm how His Majesty's Government's ultimate healthcare workforce plan is going to be independently scrutinised, and how His Majesty's Government is going to be able to deal and reconcile potentially differences that are generated as part of that independent scrutiny with what they consider to be deliverable at this particular moment in time.
And the second issue is how ultimately a mechanism will be secured, now that the functions independently exercised in NHS England will now become the responsibility of the Secretary of State for Health, in terms of the long-term workforce needs and short-term financial pressures. Because, as we have heard, ultimately, investment in workforce is a long-term investment. Ministers will always be faced with very short-term financial problems and crises, and, historically, in the NHS, the education and training budget has been periodically sacrificed when there have been other demands, service demands, access, and delivery demands on NHS institutions. In providing an opportunity now with this bill, how is the government going to address that fundamental tension and secure a mechanism both for independent scrutiny and to ensure, with all the powers now lying in the hands of the Secretary of State for Health,
Speaker 100
that the education and training budget that secures the long-term development of the workforce cannot be sacrificed for short-term exigencies?
Paul Scriven
I will speak mainly to Amendment 252 in the name of the noble lady, Hollins, and I apologize for not putting mine into it, I wish I had. I wish to speak first on two others. The amendment from the noble lady, Craw- Woolston, is useful, and I thank her for the way that she presented her an amendment. An independently verified assessment and a 10-year plan is exactly what is needed. But I do have a word of caution.
Publication within 1 month of Royal Assent could be a real challenge, even considering the amount of time that we've been waiting. And one that's produced that quickly does possibly risk being inaccurate, and an inaccurate workforce plan is worse than none at all, and the reason for that is because people will be making training and funding decisions on it. Now, the amendment from my noble friend, Lady Pidgeon, offers a better timescale, I believe, of 12 months from the Royal Assent, and an assessment of the staff needed, and a funded plan to close the gap, and an annual report to Parliament. Amendment 252 matters because it names people who are easily forgotten in workforce planning, and that's staff who would care for people with a learning disability.
And let me start with why that matters. The latest LeDeR report found, in fact, the last ever national LeDeR report found that the median age at death for adults with a learning disability was 62.8 years, compared with 81.8 years for the general population. That is a gap of 19 years. And many noble Lords will know that my own wonderful nephew, Miles, who was 31 years old, is part of that terrible tragic statistic. 39% of their deaths were judged to be avoidable against 21% for the general population.
And no workforce plan can fix that alone, but no plan that ignores it is worth having.
Now, look at the people that we rely on for those services. The Royal College of Nursing found that NHS that the NHS in England employed 5,368 learning disability nurses in May 2010, but, by July 2024, it was 3,034, a fall of 43%. In 2024, no university in the South East offered the degree for people wishing to do nursing with learning disabilities as the main speciality. Nearly one in three NHS trusts has no acutely liaison service with a registered learning disability nurse,
and reports last year quoted a senior source saying that England could have no domestic supply of these nurses by 2028. The 2023 plan promised a 46% increase in training places by 28/29, and I tried to follow what is happening. Last November, I asked the Government for the vacancy rate for learning disability nurses in each of the three last three past years, sorry, the past three years. The answer was that the published data is not detailed enough to isolate it.
My Lords, how can you plan for a workforce when you cannot say how many posts are empty? A plan for this workforce has to begin with counting it. That is why the words in Amendment 252 are important. But we also, my Lords, need to think differently about the medical workforce. Too often, a person with a learning disability and complex health needs sees many specialists, and families end up caring sorry, co-ordinating the services themselves.
The Netherlands has taken a different approach. It recognises the physicians for people with learning disabilities as a medical speciality, with three years of dedicated training. Those doctors understand the causes and consequences of the disability, and barriers to diagnosis and treatment. They work in residential care and in outpatient clinics alongside GPs, who remain central. In 2019, there were about 250 of them,
and the Dutch themselves to say does say that the demand exceeds supply. So, it's no easy answer in itself, but the concept deserves serious attention. A doctor whose job is to understand the whole person and bring their care together, supporting the GP along with learning disability nurses, is a good place to start. A co-ordinating physician working with them could strengthen the total team, not replace it.
I also asked the noble and I also support the noble Baroness Hollis's ambition for integrated care boards to assess the mental health workforce, and the review of professional development for nurses and midwives. Protected training to learn is one of the best ways to actually keep staff. So, my questions to the Minister on this group of amendments are, will the Government's long-awaited workforce plan set out a specific number and a funded route for learning disability nurses, together with the datancy the vacancy data I was told does not exist? And will the department look at the Dutch model, and explain why the trial funding these posts have been stopped earlier this year?
And will the Minister commit to looking to reinstating this funding for the trainee posts, and write to me and the House on whether a co-ordinating learning disability physician should and must be in place in England? People with a learning disability died 19 years too early,
and their needs should not be left out of any workforce plan.
Anne Marie Rafferty
Amendment 279G seeks to increase the transparency of continuous professional development in terms of the funding and the protected time allowed, and requests that the Secretary of State reports and reviews both of those variables within 6 months of the passing of this act. Continuous professional development, or CPD, is the mycelium, that's a material that nourishes and sustains professional development and progression for nurses and midwives. It is also an evidence-based intervention for staff retention. And were the noble Baroness Watkins here, she would have added allied health professions to our group,
but will speak to that point at report. But I'm sorry to say that too often CPD is actually paid for by nurses and midwives themselves, or treated as an optional extra, though care, though core, to the training and career development for doctors. Unlike doctors, nurses and midwives lack a predictable career pathway,
underpinned by training support, despite many elegant models for implementation. Funding has been at the heart of this dilemma, with fluctuations reflecting the buoyancy of the health economy, but a lack of transparency means that such funding is often shrouded in mystery, regarding what's available, where, when, and for whom.
Our amendment seeks to place a responsibility on the Secretary of State to report on funding, and, as important, as I mentioned, protected time for training for the first time. This change will open the black box of CPD support, from which helpful benchmarking can ensue, putting what has hitherto been hidden on a more secure footing.
Diana Dido Harding
I, too, rise to support my noble friend Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson and the Amendment 28 to which I have added my name. My first experience of workforce planning in the NHS was when I first applied to be chair of NHS Improvement in 2017. I can remember asking the then Permanent Secretary, who is not in his place at this moment, if there was a plan for the workforce in the NHS. I came from retailing and we spent a lot of time worrying about long-term people planning. And I was absolutely gobsmacked at the time to be told, "Oh no, we don't really do that here."
Fast forward 2 years to 2019 when I was asked by the then Prime Minister to develop a people plan for the NHS. Again, maybe rather naively, I thought, "Good, this is an obviously sensible thing to do." I remember speaking in this chamber in 2022 when that people plan had not yet been published, when it wasn't because the numbers hadn't been run, they had been. It was because the Treasury and the Department of Health and Social Care couldn't agree on whether it would be a good idea to actually publish them.
I don't think it is an accident, my Lords, that there was a workforce plan published in 2023. That was because of the work we all did in this house, my Lords, with the last Health Bill. And I see the noble Lord Stevens nodding his head that the noble lady the minister was instrumental in that pressure that together we put on the then government to actually publish a workforce plan.
So here we are all again, in slightly different positions in this Chamber, but with basically the same problem that my noble friend has set out so beautifully. I think, my Lords, we mustn't settle for what we did in 2022, which is just a commitment to publish a workforce plan. There are huge structural disincentives for any Government to actually publish this, as the noble Baroness the Minister is undoubtedly feeling at this moment, which is why I think we have to put it on the face of the bill. The first rule of solving a problem is naming it. If you don't acknowledge the problem of the escalating demands for a growing workforce in our health and care system, you can't even begin to start to solve it.
And I'm afraid, my Lords, by not acknowledging it, we also lose the faith and trust of that very workforce. Go and speak to any junior doctor, and they know that there's a problem with this. They know that if we don't find better ways of working in health and care, actually we'll all be working in the NHS by the time we die. So we have to name it, but I recognise the very real political problems that naming it presents. So unless we legislate for this, my Lords, nothing will change.
So I think this is a very important group. I am sad once again that the people of our NHS warrant only one group's discussion in this bill. Frankly, I think it should be multiple groups that we really dig deep on how we not just plan for the numbers, but change the culture and the leadership in the NHS. But it is where we are for the moment, and I very much hope that when we come back at report stage, we find a combined amendment between 28, which not, I recognise the noble Lord Scriven's challenge about Amendment 28 being quite speedy, but it does require a regular five-yearly update, which the noble Lord's Amendment 253 doesn't. So maybe some combination of those two amendments we could all align around.
And I would very much welcome a discussion with the noble Baroness the Minister, because I know she's thought deeply about this when she was sitting in another place in this Chamber.
Polak
Amendment 240 is standing in my name, and that of the noble Lord Patel. Now, my amendment is much more narrowly focused than the excellent debate we've had so far. Nevertheless, I'm surprised this issue has not been addressed before, but it's terribly important, and needs to be addressed now. You see, this new clause would require statutory regulators of health and care professions to remove permanently from a professional register any individual found to have committed sexual misconduct. It would also make it would also make clear that erasure from the register is a mandatory sanction, and cannot be replaced by a lesser penalty.
At the heart of this amendment lies a simple proposition: sexual misconduct by a healthcare professional is not merely a disciplinary failing; it is a profound abuse of professional trust. Healthcare professionals occupy positions of exceptional authority, my Lords. Patients are often frightened, vulnerable, in pain, under sedation, partially clothed, and entirely dependent on the judgment and integrity of the clinician before them. Society grants doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals access to situations and circumstances unlike almost any other profession. With that privilege comes an obligation to maintain the highest standards of conduct.
When a healthcare professional exploits that position for sexual purposes, they do more than violate professional rules. They betray the trust on which the entire healthcare system and relationship depends. The current system does not always reflect the gravity of the breaches taking place. Recent analysis by the Royal College of Surgeons has highlighted a disturbing gap between what the medical regulator believes is necessary for public protection, and what tribunals ultimately decide.
An examination of cases involving proven sexual misconduct found that nearly one in four doctors whom the General Medical Council found argued should be struck off were instead given suspensions and allowed the possibility of returning to practice. The cases involve serious misconduct, including sexual assault, harassment, grooming and exploitation of vulnerable individuals. And that raises a fundamental question: What message does it send to patients when a doctor found guilty of serious sexual misconduct is merely suspended rather than permanently removed from practice? What confidence can patients have in a regulatory system if findings of grave sexual wrongdoing do not automatically lead to removal from the profession?
And what reassurance can be offered to those contemplating reporting abuse if they believe that their abuser may eventually be allowed to resume professional practice? My Lords, regulation exists first and foremost to protect the public. Of course regulators must be fair to practitioners. Of course due process must be observed. And, of course, allegations must be thoroughly investigated and misconduct properly proved.
But once serious sexual misconduct has been established, the primary duty of the regulator must be the protection of patients and maintenance of public confidence. Too often arguments were produced that an individual should be allowed another chance because had an otherwise very distinguished career, because they possessed valuable clinical skills which NHS needed or because they express remorse, or because they were mitigating personal circumstances. Now such considerations may have relevance in cases involving competence or judgment or less serious professional feelings. But they should carry very little weight when the issue is sexual misconduct involving abuse of professional trust. The question is not whether the individual remains clinically competent.
The question is whether they remain fit to hold a position that requires vulnerable patients to place complete trust in their integrity and professionalism. Now many professions recognize that certain forms of misconduct are fundamentally incompatible with continued membership of that profession. The deliberate abuse of a position of trust for sexual purposes should be regarded in exactly the same way within the healthcare profession. So the amendment we propose seeks to establish a clear statutory principle: where sexual misconduct is proven, removal from the professional register should follow automatically, not sometimes, not usually, not subject to different interpretations by different panels, not dependent upon which tribunal happens to hear the case, but always.
Some may argue this removes discretion from regulators and tribunals. I would respond, my Lords, by saying that Parliament frequently determines that certain conduct is so serious that a clear and consistent consequence must follow. Consistency is not an enemy of justice. In cases involving abuse of professional trust, consistency can be an essential component of justice. Others may argue that regulators are already reforming their practice procedures.
I welcome these reforms if they are actually happening, and I hope the Minister, in her wind-up tonight, can elucidate on that. Recent proposals seek to strengthen oversight, challenge unduly lenient decisions, and address concerns about the handling of sexual misconduct cases. These developments are positive, and should be acknowledged. But they do not go far enough, my Lords, if that is all that has been proposed. They still leave open the possibility that a healthcare professional found guilty of serious sexual misconduct may avoid permanent removal from practice.
And the amendment the noble Lord Patel, and myself is intended to close that gap. And I would emphasize that this amendment applies across healthcare professionals, all professionals.
The principle should not depend upon which professional regulator happens to have jurisdiction. Patients do not distinguish between different regulatory structures. They simply expect that those who abuse them sexually while occupying positions of professional trust will no longer be fit to practice. And, my Lords, I believe the vast majority of healthcare professionals will strongly support this amendment, and I'm amazed that we have to move it tonight, that this is not currently the existing law. My Lords, the amendment is about patient safety.
It's about maintaining confidence of in professional regulation. It's about supporting victims who have the courage to come forward. And it's about recognizing that sexual misconduct by a healthcare professional is not simply another disciplinary offence, it's a fundamental violation of trust that underpins healthcare itself. When that trust has been abused in such a serious way, the privilege of professional registration should be lost permanently. I look forward to the noble Baroness the minister's response, and I hope she will look favorably on this amendment, or tell me it's not necessary because the Government are already going to do it.
Anne Thérèse Coffey
So, my Lords, I'm just following on from my noble friend, and find it extraordinary that we might have to legislate to get what might seem very sensible work actually just done. But I commend him for raising this really important issue. And I'll still say to my noble friend Baroness Harding, just wait till group 45. We've got another opportunity to develop this in more detail, which I look forward to leading that group in due course. But I am standing to generally support the amendments, particularly that put forward by my noble friend the Baroness, Lady Shawcross-Wolfson.
There's no doubt that trying to come up with a workforce plan for over a million people, in one way or another, either working directly as an employee of the NHS or as a contractor in a variety of ways, is, may seem somewhat overwhelming. But I put it to the committee, it's absolutely necessary in order to deliver what is expected, the promises that are made. And indeed, while I'm conscious that a lot of the mechanisms in the bill are about, effectively, the Secretary of State taking over the functions of NHS England and the like, nevertheless, I actually think it's great. I enjoy this bill, and would like to see even more in the hands of ministers, in trying to make stuff happen. I'm a great believer in the Nike model: just do it.
And, at times, it was JFDI, please don't put that in Hansard. But it's a case of trying to get momentum going, and, even in the short time I was in the Department of Health and Social Care as a minister, we tried to get certain things moving. If I give you an example of what may seem extraordinary, and why it still seems to take an unnecessarily bureaucratic way of getting stuff to happen. So, I was astonished to find out that doctors in, dentists in Scotland couldn't automatically just come and practice in the NHS in England. They couldn't.
So, we had to do some regulations to enable the General Dental Council to do something, and then there's this other local commissioning instead of let's just make the rule that anybody who is qualified to work in the NHS as a dentist in any part of the United Kingdom can also certainly do it in England. And there's no doubt that we want to, should be thinking about how we ensure that qualifications that we recognize from other parts of the world, we need to be careful that they match the standards of the NHS in this country, but I would hope that we can agree it at least amongst the United Kingdom without too much effort and without regulation and without bureaucracy. My noble friend referred to over a hundred thousand vacancies. Well, of course, a lot of those are filled by agency and bank, which we know is very expensive, and I give credit actually to the Government, because I think they put a lot of focus at the beginning of this their administration on trying to work with NHS England to bring that down, because, undoubtedly, that huge cost is should be unnecessary in a well-run organization, particularly where management is, should be highly rated and should be world class.
But unfortunately, what we see in reality is often very different. People will leave the NHS or turn to these other forms of helping patients because of the inflexibility that we see across the system, which is a real tragedy. And indeed, we see it in a different way when we look at the sickness rates of people who work for the NHS, particularly in secondary care. And while, I suppose what continually surprised me is the sickness rates are a lot higher for non-clinical staff than they are for clinical. Now, something isn't right there.
And again, I would hope that the level of detail that future ministers and will have at the fingertips in order to try and get into this understanding, or at least being able to see the analysis and ask the questions, will prompt a really, very thorough workforce plan. My Lords, my noble friend suggested that the NAO is the right body to do this. That could be right. I often find that the NAO is great at looking backwards rather than looking forwards. And in terms of trying to understand some of the operational challenges, it really does vary.
But when 40% of our annual budget for day-to-day spending is consumed by the NHS, and indeed the Barnett formula makes that even higher in other parts of the United Kingdom, it is right that we have a parliamentary body through the NAO involved in doing that scrutiny and be able to give confidence, not only to the scrutiny of this of both Houses, but also an element of independence that isn't so far out of reality that it can be seen as credible also, and not necessarily, I'm trying to think of the right word, wishful thinking by the government, when sometimes think tanks will come up with a lot of wishful thinking on what should happen in terms of there. But I turn to how we get the workforce in, how we keep the workforce, I've already briefly touched on, but also what is happening with the exit. After COVID, there was a huge spike, a surge in people wanting to go to university and train to be nurses. So, I think it was roughly about 22,000 per year for years '22, '23, '24. The sad reality is a lot of those people who are graduating have not found jobs within the NHS as there have been recruitment freezes.
Now, something has gone fundamentally wrong there, and it shouldn't be a surprise to us sadly that the attrition rate for nursing degrees is about 20-24%. Now, on the other hand, we have only quite a modest number of people going through the nursing apprenticeship degrees, about two to two and a half to three and a half thousand per year on average, I think over the last five years. Now, the advantage that people have there is that, of course, they have a guaranteed job, they're already working in the NHS. And that is concerning, such that the government did put out a nursing graduate guarantee scheme, but I don't think there's been any evidence that's had any impact whatsoever. And I may be wrong on that, and I'd be happy to hear from the minister, but I appreciate she has a lot to cover in this, in her 20-minute reply.
But I would be grateful if she would write to me if that information is not available now.
So, there is other issues where, and it was my successor actually who made it a degree requirement to become a paramedic, which have been pushed for by the Royal College of Paramedics and other Chief Executives. And I guess I'm still at the stage of questioning why everything over the last 15, 20 years, there's been a massive push to require degrees for lots of public services, to be a police officer, to be a police constable, you have to have a degree, whereas actually when we've been challenging the private sector, and other professionals, we've been also saying, isn't it outrageous that you have to have a degree if you want to become a solicitor? So, I think we need to get our sort of thinking caps on working with the brightest and the best.
And, by the way, I'll commend Baroness Harding because she gave up a lot in order to run NHS Improvement and to work alongside other people there, particularly during challenging times. But, I think it can be done. And I know that the noble Lord Stevens of Birmingham, was also exemplary in his running of the NHS during his time there. And not everybody has all the skills, but together, I think that we can make it better, and that's why I do support something as serious as this to be on the face of the bill. And it's something I'll, as I've mentioned, I'll explore in a later group.
Now, the missing gap, which I appreciate the noble Baroness Pidgeon, has put in regards to the care service as being part of the workforce plan, understandably with the ongoing work about the creation of national care service, and it was Jeremy Hunt who requested that health and social care be put together, recognizing it was all part of the same outcome or desirable outcome in order to have this working together, that it makes sense to broaden that, but I appreciate that risks a strategy that will be covering probably closer to 3.5 million people, and that's in England alone. So, that I appreciate is challenging. But, nevertheless, I hope that the government, I do appreciate, by the way, when a new Secretary of State comes in, they're in the middle of a bill that perhaps they've never have dreamt of doing.
They've also now looking at the detail of what the actual NHS 10-year workforce plan looks like, that why imminent, which normally means we're waiting for gridlock, goes to in due course, which means it's been completely rewritten from word one almost certainly, that it will take a bit of time. But, the clock is ticking.
We do know that there was a big change made on waiting lists. We do know that we need the staff to get that done. And that's why, for benefit of patients, I support my noble friend's amendment.
Speaker 83
I, too, strongly welcome the leadership that Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson has shown in bringing her amendment and this group of amendments before the Committee. I think, to paraphrase her speech, essentially, the proposition is that Parliament should help government save it from itself. And the dual pathologies, when it comes to these workforce questions, of short-termism multiplied by wishful thinking equals the problem that we have. So, there is a need to do something better. And I would just, in support of other amendments in this group as well, just illustrate why that might be the case briefly in respect of mental health and primary care.
In respect of the amendments on 92 and 232 on mental health, I think we can all recognise that there is actually quite a degree of uncertainty as to what on the demand side the mental health services are going to have to be addressing over the course of the next decade,
Speaker 84
Not just the review that's recently been taking place and has partly concluded on the increase in self-reported mental health problems and the question around unmet need and diagnostic kind of fluidity, but also because, if you look at the NEETs problem and the huge kind of fiscal crunch that the country is facing and the spending review, which is going to be a slaughterhouse next year, solving that problem, which is going to require much greater flexibility in terms of offering targeted services and support rather than simply putting people onto benefits, that is going to require a movement from what our colleagues in the Grand Committee who are doing fortifying the fiscal framework will know as AME spending into DEL spending and translating automatic entitlement into benefits into services. Some of those services are going to have to be mental health services. They're going to require a workforce. Therefore, we do actually need a much more forensic approach to some of the scenarios as to how we're going to respond to this, not just from the point of view of the NHS, but for the point of view of the fiscal sustainability of the United Kingdom. So it's high stakes getting this stuff right.
In terms of primary care, it's less so a demand side question, more of a supply side conundrum. And in my opinion, at least, a lot of what's happening in the gulf between the increased population and the decreased availability of GPs has been misdiagnosed, but a very useful quantitative analysis that's published in the BMJ in September last year, 17th of September, shows that part of what's going on here is that a much higher proportion of GPs who come through training, a higher proportion of GPs than consultants, are choosing to work part-time, and that gap has widened over the course of the past decade. So in 2015, the ratio of FTEs to GP head counts was 0.81. In other words, the typical GP in general practice was working four-fifths of the week in NHS general practice. That had fallen to about 73% by 2024, whereas for NHS consultants, throughout that period they were working over 90% of their week in hospital or in specialist care.
Speaker 83
So we have a higher proportion of GPs choose to work part-time, and that is multiplied by the fact that we have a higher proportion of GPs who are licensed as GPs, but who are choosing not to work in NHS general practice, a proportion that has gone up from 27% in 2015 to 34% by 2024, whereas in the case of NHS consultants, the proportion on the specialist register not working as consultants has fallen from 23% to 18. So put those two things together: more part-time working and lower participation rates in the NHS, what it meant is that, by 2024, you train 1.3 consultants and you get a whole-time equivalent consultant; you have to train 2.1 GMC-licensed GPs to get a whole-time equivalent GP. So there's this huge supply-side conundrum, and I'm not criticising GPs for the choices they're making, the pressures they're under; I'm simply saying that if you're going to have a workforce plan that is going to look at resilient primary care, you're really going to have to get under the skin of this level of detail. And sort of head in the sand, wishful thinking, just kind of get the training numbers up and all will be well, that has not worked, despite the fact that between 2015 and 2019-20, the proportion deliberately of the NHS budget going on primary care, primary medical care, increased. It has fallen back since.
Speaker 84
This wasn't principally a resource input onto the training. This is why we need a holistic view of the workforce, not just the training pipeline in order to answer these sorts of questions. So I think those are again part of the reasons why the amendments 253, which draw attention specifically to primary care points, are so important. So in the round, yes, we do need to actually face up to the different pressures and demands. We cannot just assume that we click and drag on the Excel spreadsheet and all will be well.
The case therefore for an independent assessment to really keep everybody honest is as powerfully needed now as it was on the 5th of April 2022, when Baroness Merron led us into the voting lobbies to ensure that an amendment very similar to Amendment 28 made it through ping pong. And I hope that Baroness Merron of 2026 would agree with Baroness Merron of 2022.
Frances D'Souza
My Lords, I too welcome the amendment by Baroness Shawcross-Fulton, and also speak to Amendment 253, which is in my name. I'd just like to, before I speak, say when I started in general practice in 1991, 80% of the GP workforce were men. We now have a reversal of that, so part of the issue is the feminisation of the GP workforce. We get pregnant, we care for small children, we care for our elders. So, but this is predictable, and when I was a GP leader, I said for every male GP retiring, we needed to replace them by 2.4 GPs, men and women, for various reasons.
But nevertheless, I digress. I'd like to speak to district nurses, and who are our generalist practitioners in patients' homes. Just a little picture. It's a wet Tuesday evening in November, and somewhere in a village, town, or city near any of us, a district nurse is parking outside a terraced house, and inside, an elderly man with a leg ulcer that won't heal, down the road, a woman with diabetes who can't manage her insulin on her own, and a few streets further on, a family sitting with their mother in her final days, frightened and exhausted, and she, the district nurse, is the only one that can put up a syringe driver. This district nurse will visit them all.
She will dress their wounds, check their bloods, ease their pain, and hold their hand. And tomorrow, she'll do it again. They, district nurses, are there every day of the year, in every corner of this country, at almost every hour of the day and night. Now, successive governments have promised to shift care out of hospitals and into the community, and this Government has done the same, and I welcome it. But that shift will be extremely difficult without district nurses.
They are not an optional extra, they're the lynchpin. Neighbourhood health without district nurses is a building without a foundation. And as the Nursing and Midwifery Council has said, district nursing is key to the achievement of the shifts in healthcare that this Government is seeking. So let me just remind you of the, of some of the figures, and I know we've heard a lot of figures today, so I'll cut them back. But according to the analysis by the Nuffield Trust, in 2009, there were about 7,600 full-time equivalent district nurses in the NHS.
By 2024, there were 4,322, a fall of 43%. Put simply, for every seven district nurses we had in 2009, we now have four. Over the same period, the number of adult nurses working in hospitals rose by 43%. The contrast is striking. We've said we want care closer to home, yet our workforce has developed, has continued to develop in favour of the hospital.
Now some will say this is an artefact of how we count the data, because around 2011, some community services moved to voluntary and independent providers, and some district nurses consequently stopped appearing in NHS figures. And that's true, but it doesn't explain a decline that has continued over 15 years. And the picture is even more concerning when we take population growth and ageing into the account.
On that basis, district nursing has fallen by 55%. And the decline is continuing. The Care Quality Commission's latest State of the Care report found the number of qualified nurses qualified district nurses fell by a further 5% between 2024 and '25 and '26. And, my Lords, the problem isn't just about numbers; there's also the question of skills and experience. More than one in four of those recorded as district nurses are employed below band 6, which is the grade at which qualified district nurses would normally start.
So we're losing not just numbers, but the expertise on which this whole community service depends. Now what does this mean for patients? When district nurse teams are stretched, the first things to go are the things that matter most and are seen least. Psychological support, prevention such as looking at trip hazards and adequate lighting, and continence care. That care is now too often delivered less well, not delivered at all, or pushed onto services that are already at breaking point.
Investing in district nursing is not simply an investment in better care, it's an investment in preventing avoidable deterioration, unnecessary hospital attendances, and expensive admissions. And the pressure is set to further increase. The Nuffield Trust estimates that the demand for district nurses could rise by 34% by 2040, based on the projected population numbers. So demand has grown, but the service has contracted, and this isn't a failure of district nurses; they've held the line with extraordinary dedication. It's a failure of planning, as we've heard, priorities and political will.
And that seems exactly why this amendment matters. We cannot keep promising to move care into the community without first asking how many people we need to deliver it. My Lords, district nurses are indispensable. We cannot deliver neighborhood health, we cannot safely shift care out of hospitals, and we cannot provide dignified care at home without a properly trained and adequately staffed district nursing workforce. We know what happens when we plan when with the plan will fail.
We'll see the numbers of patients admitted to hospital. My question to the minister is: will the government commit to assessing the number of district nurses needed to meet current and projected demand, identifying the shortfall, and setting out a funded plan to address it?
Speaker 92
Can I just add to the what the Baroness just said? A very high percentage of our district nurses come from other countries, and therefore I would like to ask her what she's going to do talking to the Home Office about the supply of district nurses that we will undoubtedly need in the future. I want to make just one or two very brief points following on from what the noble Baroness Harding said about planning. If any member of the house has spoken to anybody who is currently employed by an ICB, they will know that, seared in their minds, is the date on which they were told, about 18 months ago, that their jobs were going to go. And for the last 18 months, they have continued to work under that threat.
I don't know any other employer that would expect staff to do that to a workforce and to retain them. I talked to members of staff who work for ICBs, and I had the misfortune to ask to just say that, "How are you?" And 25 minutes later, I knew how they were, and it was not good. I rather suspect that the biggest demand for mental health services at the moment is coming from members of NHS staff, because they have been live- living with this for a- this uncertainty for 18 months. So, I'm not being flippant, but I do want to ask the noble Baroness, if she can't share great detail with us, can she at least tell us the working assumptions that the government is making about the numbers of staff in the future who will be members of ICB staff now, because I suspect that the attrition rate is going to be enormous, particularly given the age profile of some of the particularly members of ICB staff who have built up over many years specialist expertise?
And the second part is, how many members, what are working assumptions are the government making about this numbers of staff, particularly nursing staff, who will move out of acute, the acute sector and into the community?
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, since taking over as our spokesperson, I have lost count of the number of times the noble Lady, the Minister, has talked about the workforce strategy that will at some point emerge from the department. And I'm not sure if we're going to be given a season this evening, but hopefully it will be published soon. Now, my amendment 253, which Lord Stevens of Birmingham and Baroness Gerada have added their names to, would require the Secretary of State within 12 months of royal assent to publish a health and care workforce strategy for England. And I've included care on purpose, because the two are so importantly linked. And it must assess the staff needed to meet current and projected demand, expressly including registered nurses and primary care practitioners, and contain a funded plan to close staffing gaps.
And annual progress reports would be laid before Parliament, and keeping that issue on the agenda for us all. And putting staff in and staff in here is an important marker too. We need to properly plan and invest in our workforce, both health and care, hand-in-hand. Now, the Royal College of Nursing supports this amendment, as do a number of representatives of primary care. Too often, primary care seems to be forgotten, I think, in the debate on workforce, but they are critical: GPs, district nurses, as we've just heard so passionately from Baroness Gerada on the role they play, optometrists, dentists, pharmacists.
And as the government looks to shift services into neighborhoods from hospitals, something I think we all support, it's really important. And the early years workforce is really important as well, and health visitors, and the important role they play. Now, the other amendments in this group, including Baroness Shawcross Wolfson's, all require similar reports, perhaps in different timescales, and some are focused on really important areas such as the mental health workforce, the education and training that's needed alongside a workforce plan, and continuing professional development, so important. And noble Lords have flagged the current vacancy rates in a number of roles and skills shortages, and the need for independent scrutiny of the workforce plan. Now, my noble friend Lord Scriven rightly stressed and using his own personal family experience, the need for people with learning disabilities nurses, and the investment in that workforce, and to understand the whole workforce, looking at models, for example, in the Netherlands.
The noble Lord Stevens and Baroness Gerada really talked about the complexity around primary care, and challenges with part-time workers, with perhaps more women coming into the workforce, and the challenges perhaps with work-life balance. Actually, people do want to work part-time rather than full-time. These are key questions for the government in terms of this issue of workforce. And I really look forward to a comprehensive response from the noble Lady, the Minister, and possibly a date, a season, a hint of when we might at last see that workforce strategy. Hear.
Salah Syed Kamall
My Lords, this has been a crucially important debate, and I am grateful to noble Lords for tabling and speaking to their amendments, which raise fundamental questions about the future of the NHS workforce, the quality of care patients can expect, and the government's ability to deliver on the health service reform.
Now, the amendments from my noble friend Lady Shawcross-Wolfson and noble Baroness Pidgeon actually go to the heart of a very simple, but vital question: how can this government, or indeed any government, credibly plan for the future of the NHS without an independently verified assessment of the workforce that will actually need? Now, as my noble friend said, the previous Conservative government, albeit belatedly, recognised the importance of this challenge when we published the first NHS Long Term Work- Workforce Plan in 2023. And this was really a baseline step in establishing a long-term approach to workforce planning, with clear ambitions to expand domestic training, to improve retention and reduce our reliance on international recruitment. And we recognised then, as we must recognise now, that workforce planning cannot be conducted from one spending review to the next. Training doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals takes years, and the decisions made today will determine the quality and availability of care for patients a decade or decades from now.
Yet, we are still waiting, as other noble said, for the government's new 10-year workforce plan. And the noble Lord Patel offered some possible reasons for this delay. Now, Clause 7 of the Health Bill makes the Secretary of State wholly responsible for workforce planning and training. And as my noble friend asked, will the noble Baroness minister commit to ensuring that the workforce plan is independently verified and published? And is the noble Baroness minister in the position to tell us, as the noble Baroness Pidgeon just asked, by what date it will be published or by what decade even?
And as the noble Baroness Lady Hollins and noble Baroness Lady Tyler asked, what about a workforce plan for mental health services? Remember, during the debates on the mental health bill, and indeed the 2022 Health Bill, we argued for parity between physical and mental health. And so, have we learned the lesson when we're talking about a workforce plan, which seems mostly focused on physical health rather than on mental health, too? And can the noble Baroness minister explain, excuse me, sorry, that's probable what safeguards are in place to ensure that the plan and training evolves as new technology is adopted, and roles change, in line with Baroness noble Baroness Lady Rafferty's remarks about the importance of continued professional development, and the noble Baroness Lady Gerard's contribution on district nurses? Now, my Lords, can I turn briefly to amendment 240, from my noble friend Lord Glen- Lord Glencarthra, concerning sexual misconduct by healthcare professionals?
Patient safety and public confidence must remain paramount. No patient should have to fear exploitation or abuse at the hands of someone that they trust with their care. And, while there are important questions about proportionality and the appropriate role of professional regulators, the underlying concern raised by this amendment is entirely legitimate. So, can the noble lady the minister explain whether the government is satisfied with the current regulatory framework and whether it deals robustly and consistently with proven sexual misconduct? And will the government consider whether further action is indeed needed to ensure that professionals who pose a serious risk to patients cannot simply return to clinical practice, perhaps to repeat the same offenses?
Now, let me return to the issue of workforce planning, and make probably two or three points. We've heard much about the government's ambitions to shift care from hospitals into the community, something that all noble Lords would support. But it's therefore appropriate to highlight that primary care is also suffering under this reorganisation. The Royal College of General Practitioners notes that GPs receive the lowest share of the NHS budget, estimated around 8.3%. But GP workforce sorry, GP workload continues to rise, albeit with some of the demographic challenges we see as we shift from a more feminised workforce, and some of the challenges that they face as they balance work and life challenges.
And we know, as we shift more from hospital to community, primary care will face even more pressure. So does the government intend to implement a commensurate shift of resources? Now, I worry that the government is facing too much emphasis on reorganising the machinery of the NHS and too little on the workforce who need to deliver the necessary care. So can I ask the noble lady, the minister, what assessment the government has made of the impact of this reorganisation on the recruitment and retention of staff? And as the noble lady, Baroness Barker, asked about the retention of ICB staff and their morale.
My Lords, we have more doctors and nurses than ever before, but demand continues to increase, partly as a result of an ageing population and partly as a result of awareness of more conditions. And as the noble Lord Patel alluded to, the former Secretary of State Wes Streeting suggested that the NHS cannot afford to carry on employing ever more people and proposed that AI and technology could be part of the solution. What he implied, but perhaps did not say, is that recruiting ever more doctors and nurses and other clinical staff could lead to the NHS, or even the state, running out of money. Now, if you accept this premise, not only will there need to be a better use of technology, but the NHS will have to be complimented by, or partner with, independent providers, such as mutuals, cooperatives, friendly societies, charities, non-profits, social enterprises and other non-state providers in order to meet that increased demand. So, my Lords, these amendments raise important questions on workforce, on the capacity of our system of healthcare and how it will evolve as new technologies are adopted and demand increases.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I'm grateful for the debate that we've just had, and unsurprisingly, whilst not exclusively, but a lot of it focuses on the promised workforce plan. So let me address that one straight off. There's been a lot of thought about why it is in due course, and that is the situation. And I am glad that the noble lady, Baroness Coffey, appreciated the impact, without blame, of a new Secretary of State. And she's well-placed to speak to that point.
But let me say that, number one, our absolute commitment to the workforce plan for the NHS remains. There is no shift in that. And also to say that, as I mentioned, the reason that we await it and it is in due course is because, and it's absolutely reasonable and right, a new Secretary of State has to be allowed to provide views. And that is the situation. So I hope that clarifies the position.
If I could, my Lords, with permission, address amendments 28, 92, 240, 252, 253 and 279J together. Looking at amendments 28 and 253, which have been tabled by the noble ladies, Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson and Baroness Pidgeon, I absolutely agree that the health and care workforce is fundamental. It's fundamental to everything we are doing and this entire debate, and it is fundamental to the interests of patients, which is why we will publish the 10-year workforce plan.
I would also and as most noble Lords spoke to the plan, I would also just emphasize that the Secretary of State already has duties to ensure effective planning and also delivery of healthcare education and training, as has been called for rightly, and also has duty to report on the system for assessing and meeting NHS workforce needs. To the noble Lord Kakkar, and the noble Lord Stevens, and the noble Lord Patel, I can say that an expert panel of external stakeholders have scrutinized the ten-year workforce plan approach to workforce planning. And to the noble Lady, Baroness Hollins, I can confirm that sickness absence is indeed factored into the workforce planning process. And I did hear the noble Lord Stevens, talking about the way in which the workforce has changed, and that is absolutely right, and again, the plan will reflect on that. To the noble Lord Kakkar and the noble Lord Stevens, who asked who raised the points about short-ter short-termism versus long-termism on workforce planning, and so on, decisions, of course, I'm sure noble Lords will understand, about education and training of healthcare professionals will continue to be driven by data, based in evidence and also intelligence-led, and that'll be through the new restructured system.
And the whole point here is making sure that we've got the right people in the right places with the right skills to care for patients, and when they need it. The noble Lady, Baroness Hollins, asked about a bottleneck in medical training pathways, and I can say to that point that noble Lords will recall the passage of the medical training prioritization act, and we are easing competition for medical training, as noble Lords will recall, by prioritizing UK-trained graduates for foundation specialty training places, alongside some other groups. And the recently agreed 2026 resident doctors deal also significantly expands specialty training places by up to 4,500 over 3 years, including 1,000 next year. The noble Lady, Baroness Gerada, asked about made a very strong and correct point about the role of district nurses, born out by the noble Lady, Baroness Barker, and we are through NHS England actively monitoring future nursing and midwifery student numbers and will continue to assess the 25-26 graduate guarantee as a mechanism. And there are a wide range of measures to support students and educators and universities with a transition into employment, including student hub, and it does offer guidance and resources for students and newly qualified practitioners.
and to the noble Lady, Baroness Barker, yes, I will be pleased to speak to colleagues in the Home Office about the supply of district nurses, if not doing it myself directly, but through the appropriate minister. The noble Lady, Baroness Shawcross-Wolfson, I believe, in her opening comments, made some reference to numbers about GPs. Just to say that we have committed £292 million for GP recruitment this year, which translates to 1,600 GPs, and there are 4,100 more GPs than a year ago. And I do think it's important that whilst we wait for a workforce plan, we have not waited in terms of action.
For example, we have resolved the long-running doctors dispute. We have also published a set of core NHS staff standards. My Lords, for adult social care and I'd say to the noble Lady, Baroness Harding, that was another point that I pushed when we last debated this matter, and when we were in opposition on adult social care, there was a comment about legislating on planning duties. I would say that would pre-empt the vital work to develop a national care service that is going to follow from the recommendations of the noble Lady, Baroness Casey, that we will receive in the summer.
That work will have very important implications for the shape and skills of the future adult social care workforce and I agree with noble Lords it is inextricably linked, it's a point I've made over a number of years, with the NHS workforce. So, in the meantime, we will commit to publishing a workforce plan, and we will set out immediate action to further support and develop the adult social care workforce. My noble friend Baroness Rafferty tabled Amendment 279J. Continued professional development for nurses and midwives, I agree, is critical for patient safety and outcomes.
That's why we are investing in the professional their professional development with £181 million of continued professional development funding allocated for nurses, midwives, nursing associates and allied healthcare professionals in 2026-2027 as part of a three-year cycle, and also to support equitable access to professional development. And I would say to my noble friend Baroness Rafferty in respect of the questions that she raised, that organisations are responsible for the planning and the governance of their CPD to ensure that staff have the fair opportunity to benefit from the funding, and we do expect employers to provide that support, that supervision and guidance, but also to foster a culture of continuous learning, which we would again expect throughout the NHS. If I could turn to Amendments 92 and 252 from the noble Lady, Baroness Hollins. I can assure the noble Lady that action is already underway.
We have recruited thousands more mental health workers,
And our intent, of course, is to continue strengthening services for children and adults. On psychiatrists recruitment and retention that the noble lady raised, that is a responsibility for local organisations in the same way that consultant recruitment, as well as that, retention, is the responsibility of local providers. But there is a programme being run by NHS England which does work with trusts to help them understand why staff have left, and that does focus on better support for line managers, including a staff retention guide, an improved support for new joiners to the NHS, and, for example, enhanced support for staff going through the menopause. The I would say that workforce growth alone won't transform mental health support. But of course, that is why we are working to develop the mental health strategy based on the independent review led by Professor Peter Fonagy.
And to the noble Lord Scriven, we do recognise that there are shortages remaining in respect of learning disability nurses, and we do recognise the difficulty that is causing. So, we are strengthening the future learning disability nursing workforce, and also planning should connect the identified gaps to those organisations that are responsible for recruitment training and workforce development. And I very much acknowledge the point the noble Lord makes about the sad loss of his nephew, Miles, and the impact the staff can have on somebody in their care and the need to support those who are being cared for. I would anticipate, and I say this to a number of Lords who've raised different groups of concern, I anticipate the workforce plan will include all staff groups. And to the noble Lady, Baroness Girada, she's quite right to talk about the shift to neighborhood health in all the shifts. It is going to require a different approach to workforce planning, and that's what this workforce plan will do.
Let me lastly address amendment 240 from the noble Lord Blencathra and ensure him and the noble Lord Kamall, our belief is absolutely that there should be robust address of serious professional misconduct. Protection and safety of patients and the public is absolutely paramount, and we do believe that certain offenses are so serious that conviction is incompatible with registration as a regulated as a regulated healthcare professional, and it should result in automatic removal from the register regardless of the sentence imposed. And that is why also we're taking forward a program of reforms to the legislative frameworks of the healthcare professional regulators, beginning with the GMC, and the legislation for that was consulted upon earlier this year. And we are also, as part of these changes, proposing provisions requiring the registrar to remove a registrant from the register where they've been convicted of a sexual offense listed in the draft order regardless of the sentence imposed. And on some of the points, I will be pleased to pick them up in writing.
And just to say to the noble Lord Patel and the noble Lord Kamall that we do have an NHS Digital Academy in place to support the workforce to develop those digital data and AI skills and the confidence to use them that are absolutely going to be needed for the future NHS.
Eleanor Shawcross-Wolfson
My Lords, I'm grateful to everyone who has taken part in this debate, and in the interests of the time of night, I will try and keep my remarks as short as possible. I'm very grateful to the noble Lady, Baroness Merron, for answering so many questions and setting out so comprehensively what the government is already doing in this space. One specific point she mentioned, external scrutiny of the government's workforce plan, it wasn't totally clear to me whether that means published scrutiny, and I'd be very grateful perhaps if she could pick that up and write and explain what independent scrutiny has been done, will be done, and what is going to be published. But my Lords, standing back, and my apologies, I'm going to take a leaf out of the book of the noble Lord Stevens here, I would like to quote Baroness Merron of 2022 because she puts it better than I could. "This powerful debate has focused on two simple truths.
First, without the full team of people in place at the right time, it will not be possible to provide the health, social care, and public health services we need. The second simple truth is that this will not happen on its own." And I'm afraid everything I've heard this evening suggests to me that it is even more important that we put this amendment on the face of the bill. I'm very glad that this government remains committed to producing a workforce plan in due course. I would like to ensure that all governments are committed to producing workforce plans in a timely manner and with the independent scrutiny that is required.
And therefore, for the moment, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment, but I would like to return to this at report if the government does not produce its own recommendations, which I hope it will do.
Speaker 111
Hear. Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? It is, by leave, withdrawn.
Seb Dance
My Lords, I beg to move that this House be resumed the House be resumed. We will then move to dinner break business. We will therefore not return to the bill before 20:51.
Speaker 112
The question is that the House be resumed. As many of that opinion say, "content". The contrary, "not content". The contents have it.
Speaker 74
Prison (Governor's and Adjudicators' Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026, motion for regret, Lord Farmer.
Michael Stahel Farmer
My Lords, first I would like to thank all noble Lords who have put their names down to speak and have made time to take part this evening. Setting the scene, the Victims and Courts Act 2026 gave judges the power to impose in-prison punishments for non-attendance at sentencing hearing. The MoJ gave these new judicial sanctions a big push in the media last month, when they were laid as the Sentencing Act 2020 (Prison Sanctions) Regulations 2026.
I agree with the MoJ's intent to make, quote, "cowardly killers who dodge sentencing face tough new prison punishments". These punishments include no visits for up to 27 days and restriction of social visits to once every 28 days for up to 84 days. For these prison sanctions to have effect, the sentencing code requires that they correspond to the punishments that may be imposed by a governor under prison rules. So governors who oversee them need parallel powers. Hence, the Prison (Governors' and Adjudicators' Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026.
These are the subject of my regret motion because they give governors new disciplinary powers that do not correspond to judges' very limited sanctions, but far exceed them. Whereas a judge can restrict visits at the very beginning of a sentence, governors are now able to do so at any point to punish any offense. The Prison Prisoner Discipline Procedures Adjudications Policy Framework does set parameters as to offense seriousness. But A, these could change, and B, why are such sanctions generally available? Removing visits for non-attendance at sentence hearings is reasonable and hard to disagree with.
However, the measure has been expanded beyond this initial justification and prison rules changed in a way that was not made clear during passage of the parental act. The Government might claim they are being tough on crime, but it's an ineffective measure to that end at best, a counterproductive measure at worst. Certainly, it's not being soft on crime to oppose it, but the opposite. Social visits can restrain bad behavior because prosocial relationships improve rehabilitation. Lack of such relationships is a criminogenic need.
These are an individual's characteristics, traits, problems, or issues that directly relate to their likelihood of reoffending. Offender assessment system data says 72% of all offenders in custody have a relationships need and 80% of women in prison. Obviously, governors are immediately concerned with reoffending that happens inside their jails. This is the justification for making harsher punishments available. However, I saw during my first review for the Government how family visits can turn around dreadful behavior.
The mother of one young man complained to the deputy governor of a prisoner of a prison I visited about allegations of unfair treatment made by her son. The deputy helped her understand that the shoe was actually on the other foot. On her next visit, this mother put her son right, told him to get a grip, and his behavior changed utterly. This anecdote is backed up by the MoJ's own research on reoffending, which found the protective factor of positive family relationships can moderate risk factors, including having an attitudinal criminogenic need, a way of thinking, belief, or attitude likely to lead to further offenses. That young man would probably be among the 85% of male prisoners in that category.
Those who have family visits are significantly less likely to reoffend than those who do not. The old MoJ figure of 39% dwarfed the effectiveness of other rehabilitation pathways like education, employment, and drug treatment.
It was the reason they asked me to do the reviews, first for the male estate and the second for all female offenders. HMPPS's commitment to implementing all my reviews' recommendations since 2017 has gone far beyond words on a page. They know the greater prize is to shift the culture towards a greater emphasis on improving relationships, whether between officers and prisoners, senior officers mentoring junior officers, or between prisoners themselves. The Transforming Prisons Directorate are reconceiving prisons and designing new builds around the need for relationships. Yet, despite 10 years of progress, social contact is now a disciplinary sanction.
The Prison Reform Trust say this devalues family members, treats them as a instruments of prison discipline, and completely neglects the impact on them, despite them having nothing done have done nothing wrong. Thankfully, those with children will not be so punished. But such prison prisoners already have a far greater incentive to keep out of trouble in prison. A category A prisoners in HMP Frankland told me they walk away from conflict because their families and children will hear of altercations and want to know that they are safe. Indeed, I've heard governors don't want to use this sanction as they see it as counterproductive to running a safe regime.
Lord Woolf's report on our prison riots in 1989 warned that messing with families' ability to visit was one of the most resented acts the prison service could take. To conclude, this is the recurring problem governments of all colors face: how to appear tough on crime, which this isn't, without turning our prisons into overcrowded places where rehabilitation becomes impossible. With attention on capacity pressures and early release, I fear measures are being introduced that make regimes appear tougher on crime, but which are simply tougher on prisoners and more toxic to a rehabilitation culture. If this is in If this increases in prison and community reoffending, our prisons will simply fill up. King and Willmott's honest politicians guide to prison and probation tracks 40 years of tough penal policy and the personalities responding for crafting it.
They found, time and time again, once politicians moved on from the justice portfolio, they acknowledged the futility of bowing down to public opinion instead of doing more to shape it. I am grateful to the noble Baroness the Minister for making herself available to discuss this SI. And I wonder if there might be room for maneuver. The government could rewrite and reissue it, so removal of visits can only be used in relation to the judge-imposed sanction for non-attendance at sentence hearing. This could be achieved by taking it out of rule 55 covering governor punishments for any offense, and following the example of rule 55AB, which specifically requires a prisoner to pay for damage to prison property once found guilty.
This new rule could then be 55AC. I hope this will be considered. And I beg to move.
Speaker 116
My Lords, I normally back wholeheartedly initiatives that improve rehabilitation of prisoners. However, in this instance, I beg to differ from the noble Lord, Farmer, because I believe we must look at these new rules through the lens of fundamental justice, public confidence, and the rights of victims' families.
These new rules can counter a disturbing trend of offenders refusing to leave their cells to face the court at the time of their sentencing. Let us remind ourselves with public and victims' families, they are demanding action. We saw the murderers of nine-year-old Olivia Pratt-Korbel, of Zara Aleena, and of Sabina Nessa refusing to face the families whose lives they had destroyed. This trend is becoming increasingly common,
adopted by serial killers at the Countess of Chester Hospital and the Southport murderer, too. For grieving families, sitting in a courtroom, watching an empty dock because a perpetrator simply chooses to opt out, is an intolerable insult. It makes closure extremely difficult for them, and makes a mockery of our justice system. The traditional internal punishment, such as adding days to a sentence, mean absolutely nothing to a murderer already facing a whole life or half a century behind the bars. If a prisoner deliberately defies the authority of the court, there must be immediate, tangible loss of privileges within the prison estate.
Critics, I know, argue that these rules risk damaging rehabilitation. But true rehabilitation cannot begin without accountability. An offender who refuses to look their victims in the eye is actively rejecting the first step of reform and rehabilitation. The government has approached this issue with care. It has vital safeguards, the rules explicitly exempt an offender's children from these restrictions.
What is being targeted is wider privileges, visits which must be earned through compliance with our justice system. My Lords, we need to back the government in restoring this vital level of authority. However, we must ensure its implementation has checks and balances to avoid abuses. So, a question to my noble friend the Minister, how will the government plan to monitor the implementation of these rules, particularly how the prison governors are using it, and that there are no violations? My Lords,
recognizing that the public confidence in our courts is fragile, these rules protect children, target defiance and ensure court orders are respected. I urge the House to reject this motion.
Speaker 117
the noble Lord Farmer, for bringing this matter before the House and for all he has done over the years in trying to improve rehabilitation in prisons. But I also have great sympathy with the government because they are faced with the action of both political parties in winding up the prison population, which is probably at the root cause of all these problems. But I didn't want to say anything about that tonight. What I do want to raise is the point that shines through the report, the excellent report, of the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, and that is that we don't seem to understand two things.
First, what is the cause of the inexorable rise in the number of disciplinary offences and the sanctions that have had to be increased? And secondly, it normally is useful to try and understand, if you find out what the cause is, what is the most effective way of preventing it.
And it seems to me very clear that what we need is a proper examination of the cause and the best way of trying to deal with the problem. Now, it might be thought that we set up some grand committee or we ask people to look again and take a year or so to resolve this. I don't believe that's at all necessary. We have two expert charities, the Prison Reform Trust and the Howard League, and we have admirable governors, as I'm, as the minister must know, and knows from her own experience, in our prisons.
And there are other experts in penology. It seems to me that what is called for as soon as practicable is: a, an answer to the question of why is prison indiscipline getting worse? B, what is the best way of preventing it? And c, how is what is proposed in this statutory instruments working? Instinctively, I feel that cutting off social relations is bad for prisoners.
I also believe that incentives is probably more effective. But that is a belief. It's not based on evidence. And one thing that experience has taught me is you need to find out the why, the solution and the best way to deal with this problem.
We cannot make, afford to make a mistake, because adding days to prisons, to prisoners is increasing our prison population, and we cannot afford not to seek rehabilitation through visits by families. The two policies seem to me to be wrong, but I don't know. We need to know why.
Speaker 119
My Lords, the prison rules 1999 already provide prison governors with an extensive suite of disciplinary measures. Prisoners who offend against prison discipline may be cautioned. They may be, suffer forfeiture of privileges. They may be excluded from work which they carry out in the prison estate. They may suffer a deduction of loss of earnings.
Speaker 120
They may be confined to their cells. They may have, may be suffer removal from the wing upon which they are located. They may experience payback punishment. Now, my Lords, what do these existing measures have in common? They are all directed against the offender himself: his privileges, his earnings, his freedom of movement on the wing, his opportunity to work.
Speaker 118
Prisoners are serving terms of imprisonment because of things which they have done. We punish people for the crimes which they commit, not the crimes which others commit. My concern, my Lords, is that this amendment to the rules will punish not only the prisoner, but those who would seek to visit the prisoner,
those on the outside who have just as much interest in his rehabilitation as any. Those people, those loved ones, have not offended. They have not breached prison discipline. But just as the prisoner will be punished by being deprived of their society, so they will be punished by being deprived of the society of the prisoner.
Speaker 121
It is undesirable, my Lords, to impose penalties on a person for something which someone else has done. Prison discipline is exercised summarily, necessarily and responsibly by prison governors, but summarily. And it may well be that a prison governor, contemplating the use of this punishment, could easily be expected to overlook the effect on someone outside who would wish to pay a social visit: a parent, a relative, a good friend, a well, a genuine well-wisher.
Speaker 122
My Lords, let prisons help prisoners emend themselves for the better. Let us not punish people on the outside for the disciplinary lapses of those inside prisons whom they love.
Claire Fox
Many thanks to the noble Lord Farmer. My Lords, when we debated the Victims and Courts Bill here, I had qualms about the targeted punishment of withdrawing social visits, even from those prisoners despicably refusing to attend sentencing hearings. I don't like families, even of selfish, cowardly perpetrators, being used as a stick. But then I thought of the families of the victims shown such contempt by such prisoners, and I swallowed my concerns. But if ever there was an example of why we should beware laws passed here being weighed down by secondary legislation powers, it's the dangerous slippery slope on display here.
It shows another type of contempt for democracy. No one in Parliament agreed to this mission creep that has amended the sentencing code to allow restrictions on family visits as a general disciplinary punishment. None of us gave permission for that. Why would we, when it shows politicians' contempt for any of the common-sense advice or on-the-ground expertise of prison officers and criminal justice campaigners about how real discipline works in prisons? One of the most effective restraints in bad behaviour or criminal activity inside or indeed on release from prison is the influence of families and loved ones.
Does the minister understand, if you want a prisoner to have any sense of regret or shame for past crimes or to be inspired to change, it's via their mum, their fiancee, their kids? Not letting them down can be a powerful antidote to getting into further trouble. These social visits can lead to encouragement, even to tellings-off. And while not exactly being able to conquer all the toxicity and brutality of prisons, having to face down your mum can do a hell of a lot. Cutting up cutting off this pro-social influence is inexplicably foolish and performative toughness.
If the government really wants to be tough on the chaos in too many prisons, then do the hard jobs: tackle the thriving drugs industry behind bars, take on the growth of unchecked Islamist gangs, expose how human rights laws are being deployed to limit staff's ability to exert authority and impose rules. Don't take the soft option of weaponising family visits. If only the government used their executive powers to tackle cuts in purposeful activity in prison education, to invest in training and support for inexperienced overworked staff. I've been involved in the prison project Debating Matters Beyond Bars. The most moving moments: those prisoner debaters beaming at their certificates because they can't wait to send them home, and then letters from their wives and their kids saying it helped him see another future, something to be proud of for his family.
Families are the best rehabilitation aid ever. They're cheap and you dispense with them at your peril.
Speaker 125
My Lords, irrefutable evidence from the academic sector, independent reviews, government-led inquiries and the Ministry of Justice itself demonstrates that maintaining family and social relationships is fundamental to prisoners' wellbeing, rehabilitation and successful reintegration. It is, therefore, puzzling, to say the very least, that the government chooses to introduce a punishment that risks undermining the very conditions necessary for safer prisons, improved behaviour and successful rehabilitation. The lack of adequate consultation with prisoners' groups is also of great concern.
Many have expressed doubts on the proposed restrictions, pointing out the possible negative consequences. These include the damaging effect on children who are innocent, for whom keeping in touch with relatives in prison may be an important means of emotional stability and support. Prisoners, especially from the minority sectors, typically tend to convey instances of bullying, unfair treatment and other inequalities to family members during visits, which are then reported on by those family members. My Lords, financial hardship, geographical distance, and other inequalities already significantly restrict family visits. Does the Government really believe that removing a prisoner's source of emotional support is likely to improve behaviour?
Or does it remove one of the strongest incentives for positive change? The new powers, my Lords, I think are disproportionate. They infringe prisoners' fundamental rights to family life and are counterproductive. They directly contradict the Government's wider objectives of improving aspects of prisons and of prisoners' lives. Family contact should be recognised, must be recognised, as an essential component of rehabilitation and not simply as a privilege that can be withdrawn as punishment.
Speaker 32
My Lords, I'd like to thank the noble Lord Farmer, for bringing this. I hate staying up late, but this is worth it because really this is a cruel idea. The Government says that it wants to tackle rising indiscipline and violence in prisons, and of course it does; nobody wants to see prisoners or prison staff living in unsafe conditions. But I am against this decision to take away social visits as a punishment, not least because the Government's own evidence tells us that family contract is one of the things that helps people behave better, supports rehabilitation and reduces reoffending. Plus, we should not pretend that violence and indiscipline in prisons have appeared out of nowhere.
They have to be understood in the context of years of pressure on the prison system, overcrowding, poor conditions, staff shortages, and the staff that are there are often inexperienced. And what's the Government's response? More punishment. The Ministry of Justice produced its research into the impact of social visits on reoffending, self-harm and accommodation after release, and it found that people who receive visits were significantly less likely to have a proven reoffence within a year of release. They committed fewer further offences and took longer to reoffend.
They were also less likely to self-harm and more likely to have accommodation when they left prison. And the more visits people received, the less the lower the reoffending rate. And then in March this year, HM Inspectorate of Prisons published its thematic review and found that regular family contact was associated with better mental health, improved behaviour and greater feelings of safety. People who received regular visits or social video calls were less likely to be at risk of suicide or self-harm. They were also less likely to experience bullying and victimisation and less likely to be restrained or held in segregation.
The inspectorate was clear that family contact should be treated as an essential part of prison safety and rehabilitation. So, I ask the Government: why is it taking away something that its own evidence says that helps make prisons safer? I think that we constantly hear the refrain that prisons have to be a place of punishment, but you can't actually keep on making punishments harsher; it just doesn't work like that.
At some point, you will end up filling up more prison spaces with extra days and days when prisoners should be on license, being supervised. Please rethink this. It's a very nasty move.
Speaker 124
My Lords, the government advance two inconsistent reasons behind this statutory instrument. First, they say that the incidence of violence and rule breaking in prisons is going up and therefore governors and independent adjudicators need harsher or stricter options available to punish the serious and repeat rule breaking. And secondly, they say that because of the Sentencing Act 2026, which reduced the actual amount of time that prisoners will serve of their sentence, governors need to have the ability to keep them in. Now, it strikes me as odd and indeed it strikes me as sad that the central question that which has been asked by my noble by the noble and learned Lord Thomas, but has not been thought about by the government, it seems, is has anybody asked themselves why prisoners commit acts of indiscipline or break the rules in the first place? It's largely because they are incarcerated for 23 out of 24 hours a day in a multi-occupied cell.
They essentially live in a public lavatory. They are largely mentally ill. They are largely illiterate. They are largely innumerate. And what they need is not to be subjected and I think the minister knows this because she used to work in Holloway Prison so she knows that everyone who has spoken this evening apart from the noble lady Gill, is speaking some quite sensible things, saying some quite sensible things.
But it seems to me that if you keep people in those conditions, if you fail to give them a sense of purpose, if you fail to rehabilitate them, well, then you not only let them down, you're not only endanger the lives and working conditions of the governors and the prison staff, but you also waste our money, that's to say the taxpayers' money, and do not provide us with the requisite safety that we require of a rehabilitated prisoner because they come back just as they went in, and so they reoffend. So, please, I ask the government to be a little more intelligent about this, think a little more strategically about this, and not to resort to the usual government rubbish of reacting in a knee-jerk way without having applied their minds to the problem in front of them. It's not surprising that when prison governors and other prison group directors were asked about these measures, they were hesitant, and indeed they were skeptical. And if the minister believes that this is going to be a good idea, when the professionals in the business clearly think it is not, or she needs to have another think. I won't complain about the English of the explanatory notes, but when the government says engagement with internal stakeholders to explore the impact on external policy areas, such as prisoner family and relations, trade unions and third sector stakeholders, has commenced and will continue to occur prior to this instrument coming into force, I ask myself, first, what in the hell does that mean?
Secondly, has it happened and when will we hear about the results? But please, don't allow this House to be fooled into thinking that this is a good idea. It plainly is not.
Patience Wheatcroft
My Lords, the noble Lord Farmer, is quite right to draw the attention of the House to this ill-judged measure. To oppose it is in no way to condone the crime or the criminal, but it is to acknowledge the appalling conditions in many of our prisons, which are giving rise to this discontent and the offences that are being committed there, and as we've just had graphically described by the noble Lord Garnier.
Given that the majority of the prison population consists of people with numerous problems, disadvantages, frustrations, many of whom would have been much better and more successfully dealt with outside the prison system, clashes with authority within are inevitable, and the conditions they now are serving in make that only worse. The potential doubling of penalties under these rule changes risks dramatically damaging the mental health of the recipients, but I'll concentrate my remarks on their potential to add to the chances of prison leavers being homeless.
My Lords, people leaving prison regularly walk out straight into homelessness. In the year to March, the number was averaging 300 a week. Is it any wonder that for some of those reoffending seems the easiest way to find accommodation and a degree of security? These ill-thought-through measures are only likely to add to that problem. My Lords, many prisoners have family relationships which are, at best, fragile.
Visits from relations can at least preserve those flimsy relationships. They might even nurture them. They could be crucial in ensuring that, on release, the prisoner does have a go a home to go to. Damaging those relationships by forbidding visits seems a dangerously short-sighted move. All the evidence is that strong relationships on the outside can be pivotal in allowing a prisoner to rebuild his life after release.
Having friends or family prepared to provide immediate accommodation may be the crucial factor in preventing that individual from reoffending. Governors should never jeopardize that chance. My Lords, as a society, we surely shouldn't tolerate people being relief released from incarceration by the state into a life on the streets. Last month, it was alleged that, on release, some prisoners were being issued with tents. The government response to that was simply, "It is not government policy."
But my Lords, to underline why I believe it's so vital that governors should not endanger any chance of prisoners leaving into proper accommodation, I ask the minister for a simple yes or no, under this government, have prisoners been issued with sleeping bags and tents on their release?
Speaker 126
My Lords, reducing reoffending is widely recognized as a central purpose of our prison system. This was true when I worked in the Ministry of Justice 10 years ago and remains so today. Yet, these rules allowing social visits to be removed or restricted as a punishment potentially undermine one of the very things that can help reduce reoffending. We know that our prisons are full to bursting.
We cannot carry on like we have been. We also know what helps reduce reoffending, education and training, drug and alcohol treatment, preparation for employment, stable accommodation on release and, where needed, mental health support. But provision remains inadequate. HM Inspectorate of Prisons reported last year that 94 of the 104 closed prisons it had inspected were rated poor or not sufficiently good for purposeful activity.
Speaker 129
At a time when public finances are stretched and difficult trade-offs are having to be made about what to prioritize, many of these areas are not being adequately resourced.
Speaker 126
There is one area, though, which the state doesn't need to fund and which will save money over the long term if it leverages it. That is developing strong social networks around offenders. I want to pay tribute to my noble friend Lord Farmer and to Dr Samantha Callan for their important work in this area over many years. The Farmer Review makes a compelling case for maintaining family ties during imprisonment. It cites Ministry of Justice research showing that for a prisoner who receives visits from a family member, the odds of reoffending are 39% lower than those who do not.
Removing visits risks undermining precisely the relationships that can help prevent reoffending after release, a point that's been made many times already. Family relationships should not be treated as a luxury item for those who behave well. Ensuring an ordered and disciplined environment is the foundation for a well-run prison. The irony here is that these rules risk undermining one of the building blocks that can help create the very behavior and stability that prison discipline seeks to achieve. If we are serious about reducing reoffending, we need to be asking how we can strengthen family ties, not treating them as a special treat that can be removed as punishment.
That governors have themselves expressed hesitancy over these changes, and that their likely impacts have not been assessed, mean we should surely proceed with caution. Ultimately, prison discipline should support a prison system that protects the public, and this must mean reducing reoffending. We should not risk undermining that objective without a clear understanding of the consequences.
Don Foster
My Lords, on these Benches, we support the broad thrust of the Government's proposals, but we are concerned, like many others, by the proposal to withdraw family visits as a punishment in the cases covered by the SI. And that's why we do support the regret motion in the name of the noble Lord Farmer. Few have done more than the noble Lord to demonstrate the importance of family relationships in reducing reoffending and helping prisoners rebuild their lives. Now, my Lords, I chair your Lordships' Justice and Home Affairs Select Committee, and in our report on prisons last year, we argued that punishment of prisons is the prisoners is the loss of liberty and that the job of prisons is to reduce reoffending through education, purposeful activity, tackling addiction and mental health problems, and preparing people for release. And that also means maintaining, as so many people have said, family relationships, because as Lord Farmer has rightly described, family ties are the golden thread in reducing reoffending.
Evidence shows that family contact improves prison behavior, supports mental health, reduces self-harm, and importantly, reduces reoffending. So, against that backdrop, I find it extraordinary that the Government should introduce rules allowing family visits to be withdrawn as a disciplinary punishment. Of course, effective sanctions are needed, but why introduce a punishment which undermines the very thing that makes prison and the prisons and the public safer? There are three fundamental objections. First, as the noble Lady, Baroness Fox, has said, it is counterproductive.
Family contact provides hope, emotional stability, and an incentive to behave responsibly.
Removing it risks increasing isolation, frustration and resentment. Secondly, as the noble Lord Stunell said, it punishes innocent people: partners, parents, adult children and other relatives, who've committed no offense, yet lose contact with someone they love. The exemption for children under 18 of course is welcome, but what about everybody else? And thirdly, as the noble Lady, Baroness Wheatcroft has said, it damages relationships essential for successful resettlement. Families often provide accommodation, practical help and emotional support on release.
Why weaken those relationships? Disciplinary sanctions may be necessary, but they should address the prisoner's behavior without damaging relationships that help prevent future crime. We should strengthen relationships that help prisoners turn their lives round, not take them away. The consequences will be felt by prisoners, innocent families, and ultimately the communities to which prisoners return. So, my Lords, if we're serious about fewer victims, safer communities, and less crime, we must stop treating family contact as a privilege that can be withdrawn, and recognize it as an essential to reducing re-offending and protecting the public.
Richard Keen
My Lords, we appreciate and obviously acknowledge the extensive work and the experience of my noble friend Lord Farmer in this area, and we therefore understand what has prompted him to table this regret motion. However, we cannot offer him support on this occasion. This statutory instrument will increase the powers available to governors and independent adjudicators for disciplinary breaches. And given the rising levels of violence and disciplinary issues in prisons, we consider it is important for prison governors to have these additional powers available to them to manage those prisoners who repeatedly break the rules. An obvious concern with the instrument is the failure of the government to provide a considered impact assessment.
And that would include a consideration of the impact on prison capacity with the increased 84-day limit on the number of days that can be added to a sentence. And we would like to hear from the noble lady, the minister, as to what is expected to be the impact of this extension on prison capacity. My Lords, the Ministry of Justice recently released a rapid evidence assessment on safety in prisons, written by Professor James McGuire. And the report looked into violence in prisons and sought to explore the factors that impact the level of violence. And its findings noted that higher staff numbers, a stable staff cohort, and a minimal level of vacancies were associated with low lower levels of violence.
And there's hardly any surprise there. The most recent quarterly data for the Prison and Probation Service for the quarter ending June 2026 showed that the number of prison officers in post had actually reduced over the last 2 years by more than 1 and a half thousand. So, I would ask the noble lady, the minister, what steps are the government going to take to support prison officers in reducing violence by increasing recruitment and retention? My Lords, in conclusion, while conscious of the concerns that have been expressed about the potential impact of these proposals, we are broadly supportive of the need to give prison governors greater powers to deal with indiscipline. And accordingly, we will not seek to oppose.
Speaker 59
My Lords, I begin by thanking the noble Lord Farmer, for securing this important debate, and all the noble Lords who have contributed. I want to recognize the work the noble Lord has done over many years to make sure family relationships are taken seriously within our prison system. He has been a consistent and powerful voice on the importance of those relationships in helping people turn their lives around. And I want to thank the noble Lord for his reviews on prisoner family ties in 2017 and 2019 that many noble Lords have referenced today. The noble Lord's motion focuses particularly on the introduction of new restrictions on social visits, and I understand why he has raised concerns about potential consequences for prisoners, their families and for rehabilitation.
And I will lay out why the government believes these changes are needed, what safeguards have been put in place, and how they strike a reasonable balance. My Lords, I want to make it clear from the outset that I do not see prison order, safety and rehabilitation as competing priorities. Quite the opposite. They all depend on each other. A prison that is not safe cannot properly rehabilitate.
And a prison that does not rehabilitate properly cannot fulfill its duty to protect the prisoners within it and the public. It isn't about unnecessary punitiveness, or the appearance of such. To the noble lady, Baroness Jones' point, the government is absolutely committed to prisoner safety and it is focused on supporting safety and rehabilitation and is working with partners across government and at a local level to improve outcomes for people in custody and on release through better access to treatment and recovery services, prison education, employment, and stable accommodation. On the point raised by several noble Lords, including the noble and learned Lord Garnier and the noble lady Baroness Wheatcroft, about the more general state of our prisons and the contribution of that to prison indiscipline, I would like to take the opportunity to point out that this Labour government in 2024 did inherit a prison system that was on the brink of collapse after 14 years of Conservative mismanagement, with less than 100 spaces left in the prison estate.
Speaker 124
I'm very grateful to the noble lady for giving way. There really is no point in saying we inherited this that every government can come in and say that. I have I said the same things in 20 uh 2010. It makes no difference. We've got to deal with what's going on right now under her watch.
Speaker 59
I will move on to those comments indeed, but I think it's only fair and right that I lay out the territory as you would expect me to do, including referencing the work of his colleague the noble Lord Farmer, in the in my opening comments, when I have 10 minutes to speak. So, as I was saying, the some of the things this Labour government has done is spent over 40 million on physical infrastructure across 34 prison sites. We've introduced specialist staff and equipment to stop the smuggling of contraband into prisons, which can contribute to violence and instability. And as I've said, we're modernizing prison education and creating that joined-up system so that basic literacy and numeracy is in place, supporting people into employment and higher education. There is much discussion also of carrots and sticks and incentives and sanctions in this, so I want to flag that the government has expanded that incent- incentivized substance-free living units where prisoners who agree to regular drug testing can access enhanced opportunities, and this will be up to, sorry, increased by a further 12 prisons by the end of 2027-28.
And as I'm sure all noble Lords who are contributing to this debate know, we've launched the independent review of the prison system led by the right honourable Amber Rudd and supported by a panel of experts. That is to provide that strategic, risk-based assessment of current risks and opportunities facing the system to identify the reforms that will enable us to build that prison system fit for the future, and that is due to report back next month. And I'm sure all noble Lords would welcome that. So the purpose of the instrument here is to strengthen the range of measures available to governors and independent adjudicators, as and as noted by the noble and learned Lord Keen of Elie, this is for when a serious or persistent rule-breaking occurs, to provide a fair, proportionate and a response sensitive to the circumstances of each individual prisoner.
And it's really important, my Lords, to be clear about the why the measure has been introduced in this way. The new social visits sanction forms part of the wider measure in the Victims and Courts Act, which, once in force, will give Crown Court judges the power to impose prison sanctions for an offender aged 18 or over refuses, without reasonable excuse, to attend their sentence hearing where a court has ordered them to do so. Parliament has long considered secondary legislation the most, mostly appropriate for matters concerning the management of prisoners via the prison rules, as it allows flexibility to amend the regulations. To enable Crown Court judges to restrict social visits, the sanction must be contained within the prison rules, making it also available as an option for prison governors or independent adjudicators to use in limited circumstances. It is impossible to include a sanction for non-attendance at a sentence hearing that only judges can impose without an amendment to S 41B of the Sentencing Act 2020.
This is because the act specifies that the power of judges to give sanctions for non-attendance at sentencing hearings is limited to sanctions that correspond to the ones governors can give in the prison rules. And the affirmative statutory instruments specifying sanctions available to Crown Court judges will be debated, and the timing of that will be announced imminently. Therefore, I'm going to try and keep the focus of my response to the subject of the noble Lord Farmer's motion. This Government recognises the importance of family contact, as referenced by the noble and learned Lord Stewart, Baroness Fox of Buckley, Baroness Porter of Fulwood, and Lord Foster of Bath, amongst other noble Lords. Firstly, and really importantly, children are exempt from this sanction, so they can continue to visit their parents.
And I want to reassure Baroness D'Souza of that. That reflects the Government's commitment to protecting that relationship between children and parents in prison, wherever that is safe, appropriate and in the best interests of the child. Secondly, this measure should be used only as a last resort. The prison discipline policy framework said that it should only be used exceptionally and for very serious breaches of the rules, in cases of severe rule-breaking where other interventions and sanctions have not been effective. Adjudicators will have to set out the reasons why they consider the sanction appropriate.
Thirdly, those under the age of 21 when the offense was committed, must not be given forfeiture or restriction of social visits. This is to reflect the separate policy approach for young offenders and for children in custody. Fourthly, individual circumstances will be taken into account. Some prisoners face serious mental health difficulties, are vulnerable and losing social contact would make their situation worse. The Government expect those circumstances to be considered carefully before any restriction is imposed.
This is about giving governors and independent adjudicators an additional option where other measures have failed, a measure of last resort. A number of family circumstances should be taken into consideration by the governor where social visits sanction would cause disproportionate or unintended harm. This includes where a prisoner's family is going through a key transitional period, such as a separation or another period of instability. I understand the noble Lord Farmer's, concerns on the effect of restricting social visits, and I take it really seriously. I mean, having somebody else, as other noble Lords have pointed out, having somebody else on the outside who cares about you, encourages you and can give, and who gives you a reason to keep going, can make an enormous difference.
As your Lordships know, rehabilitation that genuinely cuts crime is central to this Government's approach. The Ministry of Justice is supporting this by updating the strengthening family and family sorry, Strengthening Family and Relationship Ties Policy Framework, and reviewing the current social visits policy to promote child-friendly practice, safeguarding, and consistency across prisons. The Government has not lost sight of the importance of family relationships, and also recognise there will be time when serious or repeated misconduct requires a different response. When a small number of people are violent, threatening, or potentially disruptive, they make life harder for those trying to use their time in prison positively. Those trying to get an education, learn a trade, deal with an addiction, should be able to do so in safety.
My Lords, the noble Lord Farmer, raised a question of whether these new sanctions will improve things for those in prison. And as the noble and learned Lord Thomas, raised, it is crucial to get to the heart of what causes prison indiscipline. And prison order should not depend on sanctions alone, which is why governors can use rehabilitative adjudications alongside or instead of traditional sanctions, helping increase accountability and encourage behaviour change. This includes unpaid rehabilitative or reparative projects. Apologies, my Lords.
In the interest of time, I will have to write to the Baroness Wheatcroft to answer her question. But it is completely unacceptable that people are leaving prisons with tents, and that is not the Government's position. But I will write to outline that more fully. So, in conclusion, and at speed, my Lords, this debate has been valuable, and I'm very grateful to all noble Lords who have contributed for their scrutiny and insight. I hope I have addressed the principle points raised.
I'm aware I need to write to a few people. If the noble Lord Farmer would be happy to meet with myself and perhaps Lord Lemas to discuss further his detailed proposal that he outlined in his opening speech, we can arrange for that to happen. But I do want to reiterate my thanks to the noble Lord for tabling the motion. And I do want to take the opportunity to pay tribute to all those who work to make prisons places of rehabilitation and to keep prisons safe. So, therefore, this instrument should be supported.
The Government does not believe the instrument should be regarded as a matter for regret, so I hope the noble Lord, having heard these assurances the Government has given today, will feel able to withdraw his motion.
Michael Stahel Farmer
Well, my Lords, I'd like to thank all those who have contributed very powerfully to this debate. And I think, apart from Baroness Gill, I think the argument against these sanctions being available to every governor to punish any prisoner for any crime, it's all very well to say that there can be advice and they will take things into account, if the sanctions are there, we have 110 prisons, 110 different prison governors, they will these sanctions will be used differently. I do hear the minister say to me that she'd be happy to talk. However, I've just been aware of the mood of this House. I'm also aware of whippings on the other side, and on my own party's lack of support.
But, frankly, this is a very important matter. And I wish to test the opinion of the House.
Speaker 137
Apologies, my Lords. A division has been called. Sorry. I do apologise. I wasn't sort of expecting that.
Right. My Lords, the question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say "Content". To the contrary, "Not Content". The question will be decided by a division.
Speaker 138
I will advise the House when voting is open. Voting is now open. Clear the bar. Order. The question is this motion be agreed to?
Speaker 135
As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary, not content. The question, sorry, the contents will go to the right by the throne and not contents to the left by the bar.
Speaker 139
I'm sorry, I do apologize. We now the division is over. My Lords, they have voted, Content: 30, Not-Content: 67, so the Not-Contents have it. We'll just have a moment for the House to rearrange and for me to get my script in order. House be again in Committee on the Health Bill, Baroness Merron.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I beg to move that the House do again resolve itself into a Committee upon the bill.
Speaker 137
The question is that the House do again resolve itself into a Committee upon the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say, Content. To the contrary, Not-Content. The Contents have it. And we start with amendment 29.
My Lords, Lord Shinkwin will be taking part remotely in this debate, and I remind the Committee that unless they're leading a group, remote speakers speak first after the mover of the lead amendment in a group and may therefore speak to other amendments in the group ahead of members who tabled them. So, amendment 30 29, I'm sorry, Baroness D'Souza.
Frances D'Souza
Thank you. My Lords, I beg to move amendment 29 and will also speak in my name to amendment 79, 258 and 259.
And I thank the noble Lords Lord Hunt of Kings Heath and Lord Austin of Dudley for adding their names. I also thank the noble Lord Mann for his review of antisemitism and other forms of racism in the NHS, and the government for accepting all 36 of its recommendations. These amendments do not seek to reopen that decision. They aim to ensure its implementation. According to the 2025 NHS staff survey, as reported in Lord Mann's review, 13% of Jewish staff report discrimination from managers or colleagues, compared to 11% from patients or the public.
Jewish staff are the only group for whom discrimination from within the workforce exceeds that from patients. The review heard evidence that staff no longer wish to work in the NHS. This is unacceptable, and must never be accepted as normal. The review also found that some Jewish patients are putting off the care they need. A consultation, my Lords, only works if a patient can tell their doctor about themselves without fear.
When that trust goes, it is not only a question of equality, it is a question of patient safety. For many years, I led the NHS Practitioner Health service, which over 40,000 doctors, dentists and other healthcare staff turned to for help with their mental health problems. My work has taught me that doctors who do not feel they belong become unwell. And doctors who become unwell leave. And we cannot afford to lose them.
These findings concern Jewish staff and patients, but the principle at stake is far broader. A health service that makes any group of patients hesitate to seek care, or any group of staff feel unsafe at work, fails us all. That is why these amendments address antisemitism alongside every other form of racism. Why bring them to this bill? Much of the work required to deliver the review rests on guidance, contracts and programs already owned by NHS England, even as this bill transfers its functions elsewhere.
Commitments that exist only in guidance can be quietly lost when the body that wrote them is wound down. These amendments will place the essentials in statute. Amendment 258 is at the heart of the group. It would require integrated care boards and NHS trusts to have regard to the need to prevent antisemitism and all other forms of racism affecting patients and staff. It would also act to prevent staff conduct that amounts to support for prescribed organisations and respond effectively when racist conduct occurs, including by supporting those affected.
The Secretary of State would report to Parliament every year on progress. I appreciate that the Minister might explain that the public sector equality duty already covers this ground. With respect, it does not. While it requires public bodies to have due regard to eliminating harassment and discrimination, it imposes no specific duty to respond to incidents to support those affected, nor does it require any reporting to Parliament. I recognise that the NHS's existing equality frameworks are important, but they do not adequately address the particular challenges facing Jewish staff and patients.
The workforce race equality standard compares the experiences of white staff with those of minority ethnic minority staff. At most, as most Jewish staff identify their ethnicity as white, antisemitism is largely invisible in this data.
Indeed, the finding I quoted earlier came from the NHS staff survey breakdown by religion, not from the standard. My Lords, the position for patients is even more concerning. The Patient and Carer Race Equality Framework applies only to mental health services, while the equality and health in- inequalities impact assessments carried out by NHS bodies depends on the quality of available data. Yet the NHS does not routinely record patients' religion in any national patient dataset.
Where this information is collected, it is generally done locally and inconsistently, whether on hospital admission for chaplaincy purposes or in certain GP and mental health records. We therefore have no means of identifying discrimination against Jewish staff through the staff survey and electronic, other than through the staff survey and electronic staff record. This creates a significant accountability gap. Jewish patients are therefore largely invisible in ethnicity-based assessments as their religious identity is rarely captured in patient data. If we cannot identify where discrimination is occurring, how can we reasonably expect the NHS bodies to address it?
That is precisely why Amendment 258 would require the annual report to include data broken down by religion as well as ethnicity. It's also why I hope the Government will act on Lord Mann's recommendation to introduce Jewish and Sikh categories, which it says is still considering. These are necessary steps towards ensuring that antisemitism is properly identified, measured and addressed across the health service. Amendment 79 would ensure the Secretary of State's annual assessment of each integrated care board covers how well it's met that duty. Some boards, such as NHS Birmingham and Solihull, have already taken this on voluntarily and been accredited with the Race Equality Code quality mark, and I pay tribute to them.
But accountability for race equality should not depend on which board happens to serve a patient's area. Amendment 29 concerns the education and training duty this Bill transfers from NHS England to the Secretary of State. It would require that training to include recognizing, preventing and responding to antisemitism and other forms of racism, as recommendations 32 to 36 of the review set out. Some of this already sits in the NHS Core Skills Guidance, but that guidance is owned by the body this Bill is winding down.
If the duty moves, the commitment should move with it. I want to say a b- a word about what training should look like. Too much equality training has left antisemitism out altogether or, worse, has played placed Jews outside the protection it claims to offer. A tick-box mo- module completed alone at a screen, in my experience, is unlikely to change behavior.
Again, in my experience caring for doctors, attitudes change with time, and it needs the space and time to reflect with one's peers. That is why Lord Mann called for quality assured content, developed with subject experts, and for its impact to be monitored and reported publicly. The Government's progress update confirmed that a new model module covering antisemitism and anti-Muslim hostility is being finalized.
Amendment 29 secures this duty, and I would welcome the Minister's assurance that the training will meet these standards. Finally, Amendment 259 touches my own part, the part of my own profession directly. Every GP in England, myself included, must be on a performers list to practice. At present, conditions can be placed on a practitioner's inclusion on that list on efficiency grounds,
but not on suitability grounds.
Recommendation 26 asks the government to change that so it can address racist and extremist conduct directly. This is a modest amendment, my Lords. It asks only that the government tell Parliament within six months whether it intends to amend the regulations, and if not, why not. These are probing amendments, and I do not intend to press them to a vote. But I have four questions for the minister.
First, I welcome the government's first progress update published on the 27th of October, but it describes next June's report as the final one. Will the minister commit to continuing to report to Parliament every year after that, as amendment 258 would require? Second, will the government ensure that the NHS staff survey data on discrimination is published by religion as well as by ethnicity? Third, will the minister confirm that the consultation on protected characteristics data planned for early 2027 will include Jewish and Sikh categories, as Lord Mann recommended? And last, when will the government amend the performers list regulations as recommended in recommendations 26?
My Lords, none of these amendments ask the government to do anything that is not already agreed to. They ask it to enshrine that acceptance in law. Jewish patients and staff need to know that the NHS is for them. These amendments would help ensure that it is. Thank you, and I beg to move.
Speaker 140
Amendment proposed: in clause 7, page 4, line 31, at end insert the words as printed in the marshalled list. My Lords, Lord Shinkwin is taking part remotely. I invite the noble Lord to speak.
Kevin Shinkwin
My Lords, I rise to speak to support amendment 29 and other amendments in this group. I would like to say that it is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness Merron, but it is a mixed one. That is not a reflection on the noble Baroness. Rather, it is a reflection of my disbelief that we are even having to raise this issue. But raise it we must.
And so, I thank the noble Baroness, and the noble Lords, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath and Lord Austin of Dudley, for giving your Lordships' House the opportunity to consider it. I say disbelief because I cannot imagine that those noble Lords who helped pass Labour's Race Relations Act could ever have envisaged that 61 years later we should be debating whether it is necessary for the government to take measures to counter the shocking anti-Jewish racism that scars our NHS, a founding principle of which is surely equality. My Lords, as a lifelong patient who owes so much to the NHS, I would say that for such a treasured institution to apply that principle in practice must mean that the provision of health care is made in an environment in which all feel safe and mutually respected, both patients and staff alike.
The reason why I believe this amendment is essential is because sadly some feel neither on account of their Jewish identity. My Lords, I would hope that it's generally recognised that racism is wrong. What I'm less sure about is if anti-Semitism is recognised as racism. Adolf Hitler was very clear. His virulent hatred of Jewish people was racist.
Indeed, he was so passionate about his racism that he made it a central tenet of a Nazi creed, which, as we sadly all know, underpinned and informed the Holocaust. Jews were to be murdered for the crime of being Jewish. It therefore strikes me as bizarre that anyone could either delude themselves, or seek to delude someone else, for example on social media, that anti-Semitism or anti-Zionism is somehow not racist. This is simply factually incorrect. Which is why the recommendations made in Lord Mann's review and the amendments in this group are so important.
My Lords, I wonder if the noble Baroness, the Minister, in her response could assure the House that the third aspect of training mentioned in the amendments, that of responding to anti-Semitism, will include reference to historical facts, such as the fact that the Jewish people have a historical claim to the land of Israel, that Israel has a long, unbroken history, that biblical records about construction of the Temple of Solomon in Jerusalem, for example, which is believed to have existed between the 10th and 6th centuries BC, bear testimony to this, that the Jews were dispersed from their homeland by the Romans almost 2,000 years ago, that perhaps no other race has been subjected to such extreme prejudice and barbaric persecution in the history of humanity, that, given the history of how the Jewish people have been treated, Israel has learnt that there is only one country on which it can rely to defend its interests, most recently in the face of the egregious fabrication that the tragedy of Gaza is a genocide is Israel.
In short, my Lords, can the noble Baroness the Minister assure the House that any training on the need to respond and to how to respond to anti-Semitism and other forms of racism will be informed by, not divorced from, factual, historical context? My Lords, in conclusion, there is another reason what why I support these amendments. I only discovered, excuse me, after he had passed away, that my childhood orthopaedic consultant, who played such a vital part in optimising my life chances, fled for his life on the last Kindertransport to leave Prague before the Nazis closed the borders in June '39. Records show that the family members who he left behind were murdered at Auschwitz only 82 years ago, so within the lifetime of some Members of your Lordships' House. Hanus Weisl lived with that insulting memory for the rest of his life.
I'm not Jewish, but, for me, his memory will always be a blessing. It is a recognition of the debt that I owe to him and, indeed, which I believe many of us owe to members of our wonderful Jewish community, particularly those who have dedicated their skills and their lives to the NHS, that I support this important group of amendments. I hope the Government will give it the careful consideration it deserves.
Polak
Yes, my Lords, I rise to move amendment 279C standing in my name on the order paper. Now, this new clause will require statutory regulators of health and care professions to remove from the professional registers any practitioner found to have engaged in antisemitic behavior or speech as defined in my amendment itself. It would also make clear that removal from the register is a mandatory sanction and cannot be replaced by a lesser penalty. The amendment is founded upon a simple principle: medicine depends upon trust.
Every day, patients place themselves in the hands of doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals. They disclose intimate details of their lives. They place themselves in vulnerable situations. They trust they will be treated fairly, equally, and without prejudice regardless of their race, religion, ethnicity, nationality, or beliefs. That trust is not optional, my Lords;
it is fundamental to the practice of medicine. If patients lose confidence that they will be treated impartially, the doctor-patient relationship is damaged. If an entire community begins to doubt that healthcare professionals regard them as deserving of equal dignity and respect, confidence in the healthcare system itself is undermined. That is why racism has no place in medicine. That is why antisemitism has no place in medicine.
And that is why this amendment is necessary. Now, some may ask why Parliament needs to legislate. Unfortunately, recent events have demonstrated the problem. We have seen healthcare professionals publicly posting material that repeats classic antisemitic tropes, promotes conspiracy theories about Jews, celebrates violence against Israelis, or portrays Jews collectively as evil or uniquely malevolent. My Lords, let me just quote four examples.
Now, these are not hypothetical. I have here the names of the individual doctors who have made these comments. I will not reveal them to the House, I will not enter them in the record, but these are not hypothetical cases; they're real ones. One of these consultants, a paediatrician, was suspended after displaying a placard associating the Star of David with words such as "rape", "kill", and "lie", and after making repeated references to alleged Jewish supremacy.
Regulators concluded that such behavior risked undermining public confidence and causing patients to question whether they could receive fair treatment. Another doctor was suspended while allegations were investigated that included antisemitic conspiracy theories, support for terrorist organizations, and repeated references to Jewish supremacy. The tribunal expressly noted concerns that patients might be discouraged from seeking treatment. A further doctor was suspended after posting comments directed at Jews that were plainly abusive and antisemitic, alongside material invoking conspiracy theories about Jewish influence. And in another case, a doctor who made social media posts joking about the gassing of Jews and expressing sympathy for Holocaust denial material was permitted to continue practicing after regulatory proceedings.
My Lords, I think these are despicable people. I wouldn't want them sticking an elastoplast on me, let alone treating other patients. My Lords, these examples are not cited because the individuals held controversial political opinions. I'm citing them because in a democratic society, people are entitled to support Israel, support Palestine, criticize governments and participate in political debate. This amendment is not about foreign policy.
It's not about whether one supports Israel or Palestine. It's not about criticism of the government of Israel. This amendment concerns something entirely different. It concerns expressions of hatred, prejudice, conspiracy theories, and collective hostility directed against Jews just because they happen to be Jews. It concerns conduct that would rightly be condemned if directed against any other ethnic or religious minority.
Indeed, I should point out that the definition contained in this amendment is not some novel creation of my own. The wording is drawn directly from the definition and examples of anti-Semitism recently adopted and promoted by the Labour government themselves. It's the Labour Party's definition. It reflects long-established understandings of anti-Semitic hatred, including Holocaust denial, anti-Semitic conspiracy theories, demonisation of Jews as a people, and holding Jews collectively responsible for the actions of the state of Israel. Therefore, I say, my Lords, if the government accept that these behaviours I've described and the statements I've mentioned constitute anti-Semitism in public life, it's difficult to argue that healthcare professionals who engage in such conduct should nevertheless continue to hold positions that depend entirely upon trust and confidence.
If the definition is good enough for government policy, it should be good enough for professional regulation. Again, I emphasise that these examples are not about political disagreement. We would not tolerate such conduct if it were directed against black patients, Muslim patients, Hindu patients, Sikh patients, or any other minority group or Scots or hereditary peers or women. We would not tolerate in those circumstances. Therefore, we should not tolerate it when it's directed against Jewish patients.
My Lords, the real test is not whether a particularly Jewish patient can prove that they've received inferior treatment, because by that stage, the damage has already been done. The real question is whether a reasonable Jewish patient who discovers that their doctor has publicly expressed anti-Semitic views could still have confidence that they will receive treatment which is fair, impartial, and free from prejudice. If the answer to that question is no, then continued registration becomes incompatible with fitness to practice as a doctor. So this amendment is not primarily about punishment. It's about patient protection.
It's about maintaining confidence in the profession. It's about ensuring that every patient can enter a hospital, clinic, or GP surgery knowing they'll be treated solely according to clinical need and not through the lens of racial or religious prejudice. The current regulatory framework allows a wide range of sanctions. My contention is that anti-Semitism should be treated like any other serious form of racism in a profession built entirely on trust. Healthcare professionals enjoy the same political freedoms as everyone else, and rightly so.
But professional registration is not an unconditional right, it is a privilege. Society grants that privilege subject to certain standards. Just as we would not tolerate any doctor expressing racial hatred towards black patients or anti-Muslim hatred towards Muslim patients, we should not tolerate anti-Semitic hatred towards Jewish patients. Now, my Lords, let me make it clear that overwhelming majority of doctors, nurses and healthcare professionals serve patients with distinction, compassion, and complete impartiality. And they too have an interest in ensuring that those patients that ensuring that those who promote relation religious hatred or racial hatred do not bring their professions into disrepute.
My Lords, this amendment protects not only Jewish patients, but the reputation of doctors themselves. It establishes a clear and consistent principle. If a health care professional is found to have engaged in antisemitic behaviour or speech as defined in my amendment, and by reference to the Government's own definition, removal from the register should follow. The NHS cannot function without trust; antisemitism destroys that trust. I commend my amendment to the House.
Philip Hunt
My Lords, following the Lord Polak-Crathorne, I certainly hope that the regulators, following Lord Mann's review, and I think the Government, in accepting the recommendations of the review, are expecting the regulators to certainly toughen up their act. And I agree with the sort of thrust of where Lord Polak-Crathorne is coming from. Whether, my Lords, all discretion should be taken away from the regulators I very much doubt, but it'd be interesting to hear what my noble friend has to say on that. In supporting Baroness Deech's amendments, I just wanted to just reflect on two points. One is just to repeat what she said, which I thought was very striking, arising from Lord Mann's report, which is that, drawing on the NHS staff survey, Jewish staff are the only religious group where discrimination from managers and colleagues exceeds discrimination from patients.
This is a very serious indication of the stress and pressure on Jewish staff within the NHS. And I'm afraid so far the response from management I think has been pretty poor. And I think we've seen that in relation to what we might call uniform policy and, as Lord Mann described it, examples of the brandishing of badges, the display of uniforms on political marches or the cobranding of the NHS by staff or others with third parties, has made it unclear what patients can expect from the NHS. And I think patients are entitled to be treated without seeing staff display any political leanings whatsoever, or support for campaigns. And I mean, I find it, if teach- teachers are simply not allowed to do this, one has to ask oneself, what is it with NHS employers that they have failed to actually put across to their staff the behaviour that should be expected of them?
Now, my understanding is that, I mean, Lord Mann clearly called for NHS England to do a review of what you might call their uniform policy. It's not the standardised uniform, but what people wear and how they display it. My understanding is that work is being undertaken, it's subject to consultation, but I just hope that, when it comes out, it's not going to be wiffly-waffly and sort of leaves just too much discretion to local employers. I really think, particularly now the Government is taking this over, because I doubt it will be finished before 1st of April next year, that they actually make it abundantly clear to NHS employers what should and what should not be expected of them. I mean, I know Manchester has been quoted as being a very good example, but, I mean, you know, some trusts do not- as Mann said, some trusts do not permit the wearing of political badges, the wearing of any item of clothing with a political message, or wearing of uniform to political rallies.
And I would have thought we need to see something really firm about this so the employer themselves are implementing what has been required from the centre. And I think, for them, too, it will be much easier than going through the agony of developing local policies subject to consultation, and then leading to a variation.
At the end of the day, patients and staff are entitled to work in an environment where somebody else's views, political views, are actually are not displayed in a way which causes huge upset and concern.
Zahida Manzoor
My Lords, I understand and support the aims and the sentiment behind this group of amendments, and particularly amendment 29 and 258. Any form of discrimination and racism is abhorrent, however one's identify how one identifies oneself shouldn't be a problem. Antisemitism is not acceptable. I thought it may be helpful to reminders of some figures, as sadly racism and discrimination remain embedded challenges within the NHS, affecting both staff and patients, as Baroness Gerada has acknowledged. It's worth noting that 28.6% of NHS staff in 2024 were from ethnic minority backgrounds.
That's over or around 450,000 people, yet only 12.7% of very senior managers came from these backgrounds. And the two 225 NHS staff survey found ethnic minority staff were more likely to experience discrimination from managers and colleagues, that's 13.93% than white staff, which stood at 6.51%. 29.16% of ethnic minority staff experienced harassment, bullying, or abuse from patients and the public compared with 23.54% of white staff. So, it's important to further strengthen legislation as, my Lords, there are gaps. The Equality Act of 2010 prohibits racial discrimination, harassment, and victimisation.
However, significant weaknesses remain. The Public Sector Equality Duty requires organisations to have due regard to equality, but does not guarantee measurable improvements. The NHS equality standards lack sufficient enforcement and meaningful consequences for persistent institutional discrimination. Will the Minister consider how the government can strengthen these further, particularly as reporting, investigating, and addressing racism remains inconsistent with inadequate protections and support for whistleblowers? How will the government address this?
There is no sufficiently robust, uniform accountability framework ensuring perpetrators and senior leaders face consequences, as Baroness Gerada stated. Will the government consider developing such a framework in relation to all forms of discrimination? This would also support Lord Menn's 2026 review, which reinforces the need for stronger investigations, transparency, and organisational accountability.
Speaker 69
I rise very briefly, just to offer maybe two practical issues that I've used in the past. I strongly support the intentions around these amendments. I think the two practical issues are leadership and accountability and the protection of those who speak out. Tackling antisemitism and racism must be a clear responsibility of NHS leadership.
I'd like to see this and I've done this in the past to include these issues in the performance objectives of every chief executive in the NHS. And the boards will be required to monitor those objectives, as well as hold themselves to account as well as the executives. I'm sure the CQC could incorporate this into their well-led review and make sure it does happen. It's not enough to have policies and training programs. We need to know whether they're making a difference and who's responsible when they're not.
Secondly, we must protect those who report racism or antisemitism. Too often, staff are reluctant to speak out because they fear the consequences for their careers or their relationship with colleagues. We need clear reporting arrangements, protection against victimisation and retaliation, and independent routes for raising concerns where senior managers themselves may be involved. I hope the noble Baroness the minister can agree that we should hold boards and NHS chief execs to account and properly protect those who call this out.
Paul Scriven
My Lords, there's just a very quick thing which may be practical to deal with some of the issues that the noble Lord Glencarthur, has raised, and other noble Lords have raised regarding staff neutrality, cuz that's what we're talking about here, staff neutrality. Wouldn't it be wise, rather than to go through a long process with this, is actually it becomes part of the NHS constitution that staff have to be neutral in terms of how they deal with fellow staff and patients who they come into contact with? And I would ask the noble lady, the minister, to consider that seriously when she not just reports back today, but when she reports back at report stage. It's just a practical suggestion.
Ilora Finlay
Could I just very briefly support that suggestion that's come from the noble Lord Scriven? Because as I was listening to the debate, I was thinking about people who've come and told me about feeling discriminated against. And one of the things is that they don't declare their racial or religious or whatever view because they're actually terrified of being further labeled and further discriminated against. And I think the comments that were made by the noble Lord Shinkwin, about the history and the history for the Jewish people, where there were lists of who was Jewish, and particularly in the Netherlands, and that was rapidly exploited in order to round them up with speed and persecute them further. And I think that's a very deep-seated fear in a lot of these people.
And the other fear that there is that actually, if they do disclose that they've been discriminated against, there will be other forms of them being undermined, which actually make their life even harder. And I can think of specific examples again that have brought have been brought to my attention. So, I really would commend that as a solution and a way forwards.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, this group of amendments is incredibly important. I'd like to thank Baroness Deech for tabling them, and her powerful words about both Jewish staff and patients, and the experience they have with the data she also presented. In different ways, all of these amendments are trying to ensure all parts of the NHS stamp out antisemitism and racism, and provide the right training on antisemitism and racism, as recommended by the Lord Mann review. I completely agree with Lord Hunt about the point he was raising about the uniform that staff wear and the neutrality point. And I recall several years ago, the Metropolitan Police had a huge issue with badges that officers started to wear as part even for charities, like Help for Heroes, and actually they were ruled out of order.
They were not allowed to wear them.
And I think it's a similar type thing and there's just been sort of creep in uniforms over the years of what is acceptable or not. And I think actually, you know, that we need to make sure that all staff are seen and behave in a neutral way. I think it's really important assessing the performance of ICBs, the amendment on that, ensuring trusts have a duty to prevent and respond to this. And I think this will ensure it's integral to these organizations, but also the real leadership point that was raised by the noble Lord earlier. We on these Benches fully support the Mann review and the implementation of its recommendations.
And I do think my noble friend's suggestion, Lord Scriven's practical suggestion about the NHS Constitution is certainly a good idea and worthy of consideration by the minister. I hope the government will look at how best to implement these amendments, whether as worded or in a different way. And I look forward to the noble lady the minister's response.
Joanne Cash
My Lords, this looked like a very serious group of amendments on paper, but it did not really emerge until we had the debate quite how grave the gaps are in the current situation in the NHS. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Ghirardoo, for bringing the amendments, and the noble Lords who have spoken to them this evening. And I also pay tribute to the noble Lord Mann, for his review and to the Government for accepting the recommendations, which everyone in, on all Benches in the House appear to accept unreservedly. I sympathise and support the intent of every amendment in the group, and particularly support amendment 79, 258 and 259, given the gaps that they highlight and the urgent need to close those. Even in light of what the Government has accepted, it's quite apparent that shocking levels of antisemitism are continuing, and there needs to be some urgent interventions to stop that.
This, I spoke quite recently in this House on Sir David Bell's review of the levels of antisemitism in schools, and it's really quite sad and a shame for this country that Lord Mann's review shows the same pattern in the NHS. There is clearly a major problem, and it is racism, plain and simple, directed at Jews, and too many institutions are tolerating it in a way they would never tolerate it against any other group. The facts are devastating. Community Security Trust recorded 3,700 antisemitic incidents in 2025, the second-highest total ever recorded. And in the 2025 NHS staff survey, as we've heard, 13% of Jewish staff reported discrimination from their own managers or colleagues.
That's intolerable in your workplace. How can anyone possibly feel safe going about their day-to-day interactions? Jewish staff, we've heard from a number of noble Lords this evening, that they're the only religious group, the only ethnic group for whom discrimination from colleagues is more common than discrimination from patients. Hostility is coming from inside the institution, and it's therefore beholding on us, debating this bill, not to miss the opportunities to address this and close the gaps.
The Commission on Antisemitism found Jewish patients considering whether they should remove their religious symbols before treatment. Imagine feeling so unsafe in a healthcare setting when you're at your most vulnerable that you may have to conceal or consider concealing that about your identity. Patients who feel they have to hide who they are in order to be treated have lost trust in the NHS.
They've lost faith that their doctors will do no harm, the first and basic premise of healthcare, and they've lost confidence that they will be safe. And the regulator hasn't done its job, which is why I support these amendments even though the government has actions in progress, and even though they've accepted the recommendations of Lord Mann's review. Around 70% of completed appeals by the GMC against tribunals have succeeded, and we know that if the regulator is succeeding seven times out of 10, there is something fundamentally wrong in the disciplinary decisions.
I won't repeat what's been said already by noble Lords in support of their amendments, but I will say this: that we should give serious consideration to Lord Scriven's proposal so that we can address the fundamental issue here, which is a loss of neutrality and an open, overt willingness to attack colleagues and patients on the basis of their Jewish identity. And my noble friend, Lord Polak, went even further in his Amendment 279C, and I look forward to hearing the noble Baroness, the Minister's response to that, where he did outline the very serious reasons why he's asked for that, and those reasons and those facts do need to be addressed. On Amendment 29 regarding training,
I do support Lord Mann's recommendation that it's needed, but he was very specific in what he asked for. He called for the mandatory module used by 1 and a half million staff already to be updated with quality-assured content on anti-Semitism and anti-Muslim hostility. He added that subject experts be consulted, and that the training be monitored and reported on publicly to ensure it has the desired impact. I have real reservations about the training that would be possible under Amendment 29, because it doesn't contain any of Lord Mann's safeguards as currently drafted. That doesn't mean we shouldn't consider the training that's needed, or expedite it.
The record of quality, equality training in the public sector gives really good reason for us to take care. In 2020, the government phased out unconscious bias training in the Civil Service after a review found no evidence that it changed behavior, and some NHS anti-racism training has left out anti-Semitism entirely. Moorfields Eye Hospital compulsory anti-racism seminar was reported last year to have made no mention of Jews at all, and training built on theories of privilege has too often placed Jews among the privileged, and so outside the protection it claims to offer.
So, there are lots of types of training which will make the problem a lot worse, and so I would really like to hear from the noble Baroness, the Minister about what types of training, what suppliers, and what accountability and monitoring there will be for anything that's being developed currently. It's also very important to note that Lord Mann recommended mandatory training for the chairs and chief executives of NHS trusts within 6 months of his review, but the government's same statement in response to his review said senior leaders would be invited to complete it by March 2027.
I really hope the noble Baroness the minister will explain for noble lords why a recommendation for mandatory training became an invitation to train and by when that training will be completed by all chairs and CEOs of the NHS trusts, as recommended.
Gillian Merron
My Lords, I'm most grateful to noble Lords across the House for their sensitive consideration of something which is very, insensitive and that is dealing with antisemitism and other forms of racism, but I know the words spoken today, the sentiments and the commitments will resonate across communities in a way that will make a difference, and I personally am most grateful for that. I also am grateful to my noble friend Lord Mann for his review and, indeed, to the former Secretary of State, Wes Streeting, for listening to the voices that made the situation that people live with, day in, day out, quite intolerable and by commissioning that review. And I do believe that's set the tone. As the noble Lady Baroness D'Souza observed from the outset, the recommendation from Lord Mann's review we have accepted in full and we are taking action to deliver. And, as was referred to, we did provide our latest update last month.
But I should say I do believe that this is work that is continuing. So I understand that noble Lords are asking for more to be done. And indeed, there is no let up on it, but I, you know, I just want to sort of counsel that we want to get this right of course. But to turn to the amendments, my Lords, with permission, I would like to address amendments 29, 79, 258, 259 and 279C together. And let me say the what we have all said, but always bears saying, there is no place for discrimination, no place for antisemitism, no place for racism within our NHS.
And, as noble Lords have said, patients and staff and those associated with them have to be free from all forms of racism and religious hatred, and indeed fear of it, as well as the actuality, and that is to the core of these amendments and this debate. I did want to refer the noble Lord Shinkwin to the point that ministers we have asked all NHS bodies to adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism and are receiving a good response and we will continue on that. Turning to amendment 29, I can assure the noble Lady Baroness D'Souza that we are taking forward work to strengthen leadership accountability, but also to improve the reporting and handling of racist incidents.
also to improve data collection and ensure greater consistency across the health system, something I know that is of concern to my noble friend Lord Hunt, along with other noble Lords. But to the Baroness Deech, first of all, improving the data we hold is absolutely key. So, we are developing the Unified Information Standard for Protected Characteristics programme. That will improve the consistency and quality of data on protected characteristics, including ethnicity and religion or belief,
and that will apply to both patients and the workforce. The noble lady asked about the inclusion of Jewish and Sikh categories in data collection. That isn't currently the case, as the noble lady is aware, but the consultation I've just referred to will include reference to the possibility of including Jewish and Sikh categories as the noble lady was referring to. And in terms of training meeting these standards, meeting the right standards,
which the noble lady, Baroness Deech, the noble lady, Baroness Cash, and the noble Lord Shinkwin, referred to, the new NHS training module on equality, diversity, and human rights is being finalized over the coming months. And that does include content on antisemitism and anti-Muslim hostility alongside, and I do think this is important, guidance on challenging prejudice and discrimination, because it should not be down to the affected groups to be the ones who are making that challenge. In respect of the point that my noble friend Lord Hunt referred to about what I might refer to as physical displays of political leanings, for example,
badges, we are looking at how we provide clearer guidance regarding the issues that Lord Mann raised about what he described as staff uniforms, and new national guidance will be published on that. The noble lady, Baroness Manzoor, asked about a framework which reflects transparency in organisational accountability, and the six mandated NHS staff standards which were introduced in July under the 10-year health plan are in are aimed at improving staff experience, and they do require employers to take sustained, meaningful action to not just root out racism, but prevent it.
And I do think we should apply ourself to that, as well. The noble Lord Scriven, also and this was spoken to by the noble ladies, Baroness Finlay, Baroness Pidgeon, and Baroness Cash, about consideration about staff neutrality, and I thank him for that. I mean, we are clear that staff do have to demonstrate the core values of the NHS and demonstrate neutrality in the workplace.
I'd actually go further, I don't know I'd use the word neutrality, it's an issue about just fairness here and without fear or favour, I think, might be the other expression too. And
Paul Scriven
My point was, if it is such an important value neutrality, let me give you an example. You may not be discriminatory, you have somebody who is Jewish, somebody who's Muslim, someone who's Christian and someone of no faith, and you treat them all equally, but you've actually got something on your body which offends two of, well not offends two of them, but actually isn't neutral to two of them, you are therefore possibly going to be treating that person differently from their perspective. Therefore, if it's such an If neutrality and fairness is such an important value for the NHS, all I ask the noble lady, the Minister, is seriously go away and look at putting it as a key component in the NHS Constitution, because it isn't there at the moment.
Gillian Merron
I do take the point, and I certainly accept the spirit in which the noble Lord is suggesting it, and in all the points that have been discussed, I will be taking them away to see if there is any way we can work it rather than extend a debate on what neutrality means, because I do know what the noble Lord is getting at and it's helpful that he has given thought to that. If I might turn to the Amendment 258, NHS bodies are already subject to clear legal duties to prevent and address discrimination and racial harassment, alongside established responsibilities to tackle extremism and to safeguard patients and staff. In a technical fashion, I would certainly caution against adding further legal duties here, reason being it does risk confusion about what to expect ICBs and trusts to do, and I know that isn't something that any of us would wish to do. On Amendment 259, we have accepted Lord Mann's recommendation to consider amending the Performers List Regulations, which would enable conditions to be imposed on suitability grounds, so we intend to amend the regulations subject to consultation, but I would say that the amendment is unnecessary as the Government is already taking forward the substance of the amendment, and it would also impose a six-month statutory deadline before the necessary consultation and consideration have taken place, whereas we do have to allow sufficient time to make sure that any changes are legally robust, proportionate and workable.
Nor would we wish to pre-empt consultation by committing in this moment on how particular forms of conduct should be addressed in the regulations. Turning to Regulation 279C, NHS staff standards, which as I referred to the noble lady, Baroness Manzoor's comments, they were launched on 6th of July, employers must take sustained and meaningful action to prevent and root out racism. NHS organisations will be measured on this through the national oversight framework. In addition, and I say to the noble Lord Blencathra, there are already regulatory processes in place to which all registered healthcare professionals are subject. Regulatory fitness fitness-to-practise processes do allow concerns about misconduct to be investigated, they allow evidence to be considered and the appropriate regulatory action, which could indeed include removal from the register to be determined in each case.
And the Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care acts as an independent body in this regard to make sure that regulators do apply the right sanctions. And where it considers the decision does not provide sufficient public protection, it has the powers to refer the decision to the courts for consideration. And if I could, in drawing this together, say to the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, and the noble Lord Patel of Bradford, I can assure your Lordships' House we are ensuring that ICBs and providers are fulfilling their duties, and the key means to do that is through performance assessments. I would gently caution against adding additional criteria to the current approach, because it is important that assessments have sufficient flexibility to adapt to the evolving role of ICBs as strategic commissioners, which, after all, is at the heart of this bill.
Speaker 91
I'd like to thank the noble Baroness Minister for that very detailed and thorough answer. Can I just can I just check with her that, in the midst of what she said, she did make clear that the NHS, and that's NHS staff and NHS providers, are under a legal obligation to ensure that all the protected characteristics under the Equality Act are treated properly and with respect, yes?
Gillian Merron
They should absolutely have regard to the law in respect of protected characteristics is probably the most full answer I can give at this stage, sorry, at this moment, yes.
Frances D'Souza
My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Lords who have spoken and to the Minister for her assurances. I just want to make a few very brief comments because I'm aware of the time. I'm struck by Lord Shinkwin, and if I heard him correctly, his orthopedic surgeon was on the last kindertransport out from Prague, and our own Lord Dubs was also on the last kindertransport from Prague, as was my father-in-law, as is the coincidences that happen in this life. I just want to make another comment. I am not Jewish, but I have been subject to antisemitism because I suspect that people assume I am Jewish, and I have been left fearful, hurt, angry, all those emotions, and not knowing where to take them.
So, if I experience that, then I can see that my Jewish colleagues experience it in spades. I work in the NHS. I can tell you that antisemitism has become normalized, and whilst the figures that we've shown of 13 and 11% are pretty awful, I suspect they're considerably higher than that because it has become almost a de facto that one can abuse Jewish colleagues, not necessarily Jewish patients, because I think they're subject to greater regulatory forces, but certainly Jewish patients in the last 12 to 18 months have been subjected to quite appalling behavior from colleagues that they work with. So, antisemitism has been normalized and almost accepted. But nevertheless, I thank the Minister.
I hope that the training doesn't become a tick-box exercise, that does include issues that we've heard from, again from Lord Shinkwin. And I beg I may wish to return to this issue at report stage, but at this stage, I beg to leave and withdraw the amendment.
Speaker 140
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is, by leave, withdrawn. The question is that clause 7 stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion will say, "Content".
Content.
Speaker 140
The question is that the House be resumed. As many of that opinion will say, "Content".
Content.
Speaker 147
Let's try that again. Apologies. My Lords, I beg that this House do now adjourn.
That the House do now adjourn.