House of Commons

10 September 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:15 - 00:57
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
Before we start proceedings today, the House will know that tomorrow marks the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks on the United States.  The Speaker's Chaplain will deliver a special prayer before the start of business in the chamber tomorrow.  Members will also have an opportunity to mark this anniversary during tomorrow's adjournment debate.  I know that colleagues across the House will join with me in remembering the victims of the horrific 9/11, the families of all those who died and the men and women involved in rescuing people.  Right, we now come to questions to the Minister for the Cabinet Office, Joe Powell. 
00:57 - 00:59
Speaker 3
Number one please, Mr. Speaker. 
00:59 - 01:03
Speaker 1
Minister. 
01:03 - 01:22
Georgia Gould
Lab Member of Parliament | Queen's Park and Maida Vale
Member of Parliament | Queen's Park and Maida Vale
Georgia Gould
I'm grateful to the Commission for its thorough work which we are considering carefully.  We know that more can be done on transparency around lobbying and we'll present our response to Parliament in due course.  There is a great deal of interest in this, understandably so, and we are determined to get this right. 
01:22 - 02:00
Lab Member of Parliament | Kensington and Bayswater
Member of Parliament | Kensington and Bayswater
Edward Joseph Powell
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  I strongly welcome the government's efforts to rewire the state and create more accountability for decisions made by government.  And as part of that effort, cleaning up our politics is so important, as we've seen from the summer of scandals on the funding of the Reform Party.  The Ethics and Integrity Commission have laid out how lobbying can be reformed to make it more open, rational and accountable.  So can the Minister outline what immediate steps might be taken and can he assure us he will keep an open mind to their central recommendation, which is legislation for a unified digital open lobbying register? 
02:00 - 02:20
Georgia Gould
Lab Member of Parliament | Queen's Park and Maida Vale
Member of Parliament | Queen's Park and Maida Vale
Georgia Gould
We certainly recognize that the current system of transparency around lobbying does not have widespread support.  It isn't good enough.  That's why the Ethics and Integrity Commission was asked to report on this matter.  We are considering the case for legislative reform very carefully and will report back on the EIC as soon as we can. 
02:20 - 02:56
DUP Member of Parliament | Strangford
Member of Parliament | Strangford
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  I thank the Minister very much for that answer.  Minister, when it comes to lobbying, Northern Ireland has a peculiar and particular circumstance where one party can be involved in politics in Northern Ireland and at the same time be involved in politics in the Republic of Ireland.  When it comes to looking at the accountability the honorable gentleman and the Minister is putting forward, can he assure us in this House and us in Northern Ireland that the rules that apply here will apply equally in Northern Ireland and apply to the political parties who transverse the border both north and south? 
02:56 - 03:09
Georgia Gould
Lab Member of Parliament | Queen's Park and Maida Vale
Member of Parliament | Queen's Park and Maida Vale
Georgia Gould
It wouldn't be a first outing at the dispatch box without a contribution from the honorable member for Strangford, so I welcome that.  We'll of course consider all of that in the response to the EIC.  Thank you. 
03:09 - 03:58
Lisa Smart
LD Member of Parliament | Hazel Grove
Member of Parliament | Hazel Grove
Lisa Smart
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.  The Ethics and Integrity Commission's report rightly argues that our transparency rules are stuck in the past.  Influence is being exerted in ways that just didn't exist a few years ago.  We've got members of this House earning more than their salary as an MP for posts on X, a platform that actively incentivizes divisive content.  Indeed, the register of interest for the member for Great Yarmouth has declared earnings of over 108,000 pounds since his election to this place. 

Does the Minister agree that our current laws around what constitutes lobbying are just too narrow and that when an MP is financially rewarded by an algorithm for their political output, it crosses the line into financial influence?  Will he update lobbying and ethics rules to tackle this loophole? 

03:58 - 04:21

Georgia Gould

I thank her for that question. We will of course consider that as part of the response to the EIC. I take very seriously, as I'm sure members across this House do, the issues of outside earnings by members and particularly potential undue influence. With regard to X, I share her concerns personally, I don't use it.

04:21 - 04:26

Speaker 12

I presume you've let the member know. That's great, thank you. Right, let's move on to Martin Rhodes.

04:26 - 04:30

Martin Rhodes

Question number two, Mr. Speaker.

04:30 - 05:05

Daniel Owen Jarvis

With permission, Mr. Speaker, I will answer questions two, five and ten together. This government is strengthening our national resilience so we are better prepared for threats like extreme weather, cyber attacks or another pandemic. We are implementing the resilience action plan. We have published a new pandemic preparedness strategy. We are updating what we call the war books with a home defense exercise planned next year and we will run a public awareness campaign later this year on how households can prepare for emergencies like severe weather.

05:05 - 05:33

Martin Rhodes

In order for us to have national resilience, we must have a network of local services that have local knowledge, local experience and are based in local communities. This should include well-funded local fire and rescue services who can keep response times low and communities safe. Therefore, would the minister agree with me and the Scottish FBU that the Scottish government should reverse its cuts to fire and rescue services, stopping the planned closure of Yorkhill fire station in my constituency to avoid undermining the resilience of local communities and our preparedness for emerging risks?

05:33 - 06:01

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Mr. Speaker, I'm grateful to him for the important points that he raises and I understand the concern that the closure of any fire and rescue station brings to people. We've seen in recent weeks with widespread wildfires just how crucial fire and rescue services have been to saving lives and keeping the public safe. Decisions on fire services in Scotland are a matter for the Scottish government, but we have given the Scottish government a record level of funding with the biggest block grant in the history of devolution.

06:01 - 06:34

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the minister for his answer and can I also take the opportunity to welcome my honorable friend from Gateshead Central and Whickham to his rightful place on the front bench. As you may be aware, Mr. Speaker, in late July there was a severe wildfire off Second Avenue in Harlow and I thank the fire services and fire officers who attended and dealt with the issue so well. But can I ask him what he's doing to increase awareness of starting fires, particularly in this dry weather which is likely to continue next year as well?

06:34 - 07:03

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, Mr. Speaker, let me take the opportunity to pay tribute to the tireless efforts of fire and rescue services across the country, including of course in the honorable member's Harlow's constituency over this summer. As the House will know, the government issued an emergency alert to advise people of the steps they should take to avoid inadvertently contributing to already widespread fires and MHCLG is exploring ways to expand its Fire Kills campaign to deliver targeted messages and resources to the public.

07:03 - 07:23

Speaker 25

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. As the minister says, the UK is facing a growing range of threats for which people and businesses are not fully prepared, including climate change, cyber attacks by hostile states and organized misinformation. Recent incidents in Germany, including attacks on energy infrastructure and the attempted airport bombing in Leipzig, which has been linked to the Russian state, highlight the seriousness of these risks.

07:23 - 07:41

Speaker 29

Given the breadth of these challenges, a whole-of-government approach is required to inform and prepare the public. Can I ask the Minister what steps he's taking to coordinate this work and provide clear public guidance, and can I ask if he's engaged with countries such as Sweden, Denmark, Estonia, and Taiwan on how they have built their public resilience through increased and honest information?

07:41 - 08:13

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, Mr. Speaker, the honourable gentleman is entirely right. I can tell him that I recently visited Estonia to sign a landmark defence roadmap designed to deepen military cooperation and modernize allied forces, and likewise, we regularly engage with our partners to learn about not only what they've done, but crucially, what has actually worked to build public resilience. We are using that insight to develop a campaign tailored to the needs and strengths of the United Kingdom, bringing us closer in line with our international partners, most of whom do this regularly.

08:13 - 08:43

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Mr. Speaker, over the summer I met with two experts in my constituency on fire resilience. They've got experience of fires in California. They told me that simple measures taken locally can have a significant impact, things like clearing vegetation around a house and making sure there are no log piles next to a home. This can all be done through parish councils and local resilience planning. So what steps will he take to support parish councils as they develop local resilience?

08:43 - 09:11

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, Mr. Speaker, I think the honourable gentleman is right to raise the point in the way that he does. I can say to him that the resilience action plan details how we will better integrate the voluntary, community, and faith sector into planning. I would include parish councils within that. It will also enable us to test new structures for leadership, accountability, and assurance through the stronger local resilience forum trailblazers programme. Absolute acknowledge and agree with the point that he made, very happy to discuss it with him further.

09:11 - 09:47

Speaker 57

Mr. Speaker, resilience is obviously the crucial question for the country and the government is right to be focusing on the need to strengthen the centre of government to achieve that. My concern is that the legislation which has been trailed, according to a leak in the Times this week or a briefing presumably from the Cabinet Office, is that the Cabinet Secretary is proposing to take new powers to direct permanent secretaries of government departments. Can the Minister confirm whether legislation is in fact planned to change the statutory basis of the civil service and most importantly, does he agree whether the Cabinet Secretary should or shouldn't have the power to direct permanent secretaries?

09:47 - 10:09

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, I would gently advise the honourable member, as I'm sure he's aware, not to believe everything that he reads in the newspapers. But I hope he would have his approval and the approval of the House that this government and new Prime Minister, new First Secretary of State, will want to look very carefully at the structures of the civil service and ensure that they are delivering for the priorities of this government.

10:09 - 10:47

Alison Bennett

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After a winter of torrential rain and a summer without any rain, residents in Mid Sussex are incredibly concerned about the impacts of drought and of flooding, and amongst those residents are our farmers. Yesterday was Back British Farming Day and I spoke to Caroline, a West Sussex farmer, who was really concerned about their capacity to grow the food that we all need to eat. So, will the government make better use of water storage capacity available on British farms, including by removing planning and funding barriers to on-farm reservoirs as part of its approach to building national resilience?

10:47 - 11:21

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, Mr. Speaker, I think the honourable lady is right to raise this important point. Food security is national security and this government will always back our farmers. I think she raises some important points. I can say to her that this government and government departments stand ready to respond to natural hazard risks such as drought and flooding, severe storms, and extreme temperatures, and the COBRA directorate in the Cabinet Office works in partnership with departmental policy teams and public entities to ensure that our response is proportionate to the nature of the climate threat that we face.

11:21 - 11:51

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Question number three, please.

Minister.

This government is committed to deepening our ties with the European Union, Mr. Speaker. It is right at the center of everything we are trying to do on cost of living and energy as well as the security of our continent. I will continue to lead discussions with my counterpart, Commissioner Šefčovič, who I met most recently on Monday, on how we can continue to strengthen the UK-EU partnership.

11:51 - 12:39

Caroline Jane Voaden

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. British farmers and fishers and my shellfish exporters continue to face unnecessary trade barriers with our largest export market. A 2024 report from the Centre for Inclusive Trade Policy found that exports of British food to the EU had dropped by nearly three billion pounds since Brexit. Our farmers and fishers desperately need an SPS agreement, and fast, to reduce costs and bureaucracy and to allow them to export their produce to the EU. Yet the second UK-EU summit was postponed following the former Prime Minister's resignation, and we've had no update on when it will take place.

Now, I hear the Minister say that he met Mr. Šefčovič yesterday, so can he now tell us and commit to the summit taking place this year, and can he give our British farmers and fishers a date for when that is going to happen?

12:39 - 12:55

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Mr. Speaker, I'm determined to get the SPS agreement done. It is the subject of intense discussions. I can't provide the House with a date just yet. That will need to be agreed, of course, between the UK and the EU, but I hope to be able to provide a further update soon.

12:55 - 13:38

Chinyelu Susan Onwurah

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There's an extraordinary debate going on right now inside and outside AI companies as to whether or not the possibility of AI destroying humanity is more or less than 10%. Now, the European Union is moving ahead with a comprehensive AI regulatory framework, but the UK continues to rely on existing regulation. So could the Minister tell me what discussions he is having with the European Union about aligning AI regulation, especially given that Anthropic has refused to submit its model to the AI Safety Security Institute? How is he assuring that we can keep European and UK citizens safe?

13:38 - 14:08

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

My honorable friend is right to highlight the shared challenges that we face with the European Union, including obviously the very rapid developments in artificial intelligence. I am proud to sit next to the first AI Minister to attend Cabinet here and indeed anywhere, and I know that he has some questions that he'll be answering during this session as well. Clearly, this is a matter of real interest and concern, as my honorable friend says, and we're working at pace to address it.

14:08 - 14:42

Alex Burghart

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to begin by welcoming the Minister to his post. Now, I very much look forward to him updating the House on his negotiating mandate and on his conversations with the European Trade Commissioner. Earlier this summer, the Prime Minister said that it would be wrong to rerun divisive arguments about rejoining the EU, but soon after, the Minister for EU Relations refused to rule out rejoin being an option in the next Labour manifesto. So will the Minister tell the House, will Labour rule out rejoin featuring in the next manifesto?

14:42 - 15:05

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

I can hear from the outrage behind me that there is... I have many responsibilities, but writing the next Labour Party manifesto is not one of them. We are committed to the red lines. We were all elected under that manifesto. We want to go further and faster. We have inherited a poor deal with the European Union.

It is my job now to improve it.

15:05 - 15:35

Alex Burghart

Well, it's perfectly reasonable to rule things out, Mr. Speaker, and he's had plenty of time to talk to Number 10 since his interview on Sky. Yeah, I'm sure the Labour Party would rule many things out at this stage. I'm sure they would rule out leaving the European Convention on Human Rights. I'm sure they'd rule out getting rid of net zero targets. I'm sure they would rule out bringing back the death penalty.

So why is it so hard for the Minister and the Government to rule out rejoining the EU?

15:35 - 16:16

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

I want to be really clear with the House, Mr. Speaker, as the Prime Minister has been repeatedly, we are not, despite the anxious desire on the other benches, rerunning the arguments of 2016 once again. My constituents, indeed I know the constituents from right across the House, are concerned with the day-to-day impacts of the deal that we have inherited. It is my job to improve it, that is what I'm focused on, our manifesto red lines remain in place. I will of course update the House on the proceeds of the negotiation. We've been clear in the King's Speech that should that negotiation result in a need for legislation in this House, it will of course face scrutiny here.

16:16 - 16:18

Speaker 17

Sarah Hall.

16:18 - 16:21

Sarah Hall

Number four, Mr. Speaker.

16:21 - 16:23

Speaker 20

Secretary of State.

16:23 - 16:48

Pat McFadden

The Office of the Prime Minister and Cabinet and Number 10 North are working closely with regional leaders, the Treasury, and departments across government to align national policy with the long-term economic priorities of different places and remove barriers to growth. This includes fiscally devolving a share of income tax and business rates to mayors, giving local leaders greater power to attract private investment, create good jobs, and deliver growth in every postcode.

16:48 - 17:16

Sarah Hall

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Britain's future growth depends on having the infrastructure, energy, skills, and industrial capacity to support it, but too often investment is held back because the problems sit across different departments. Whether that is grid capacity, water, transport, or skills, how will the department make sure this government deals with those problems together so we can reindustrialize Britain and bring growth to every postcode?

17:16 - 17:40

Pat McFadden

My honorable friend is absolutely right to highlight this, and too long local leaders have had to navigate Whitehall departments who have played each other off against each other to unlock growth for their areas. Number 10 North brings their priorities into the heart of government, gets the right people around the table, and drives joined-up action, ensuring the center works as one to unlock good growth in every part of the United Kingdom.

17:40 - 18:17

Max Wilkinson

Mr. Speaker, our long-term economic success is only going to be strengthened by our cybersecurity, and right next to GCHQ in Cheltenham, which ministers are aware of, is the Golden Valley development, which is going to support our cybersecurity capacity. It's a vital development for the nation as well as my local area. Now, will the government go a little bit further on the matter of the designated area so the proceeds from that development can be held locally, which I think is in line with the new agenda that's being set by the Cabinet Office, and also will they restart the discussions around the places for growth scheme, which seem to have stalled with the local authorities and the developer?

18:17 - 18:32

Speaker 39

I'm very grateful to the honorable gentleman's question, and that's exactly the kind of project that Number 10 North will gladly look at to consider whether that should be a designated zone for further retention powers. I'll ask Number 10 North to write to him to consider the proposal.

18:32 - 18:37

Speaker 19

Peter Bedford.

18:37 - 18:58

Georgia Gould

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government has reviewed all 306 active arm's length bodies, and we have commitments to reform over one-third of them, but we will go further. Devolution by default means we will transfer arm's length bodies' functions to local leaders or return them to departments, because all critical decisions should be taken by ministers who are directly accountable to Parliament and the public.

18:58 - 19:24

Peter Bedford

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There are actually over 400 quangos in existence that spend over 390 billion pounds a year. That's one in three pounds of every pound spent by the government. Last year, ministers promised a full review of these. As an accountant, we would call that a zero-based budgeting.

So will the minister tell the House how many of those bodies have been scrapped and how much has been saved?

19:24 - 19:45

Georgia Gould

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm afraid the honorable member appears not to have fully heard my initial response, which I actually believe probably tackles all of his issues.

His question was about arm's length bodies. Of course I answered on arm's length bodies. There are 306 of them. We are reviewing over a third. I would have hoped that you would have welcomed that, because devolution by default means restoring powers to where it should be: democratic accountability.

19:45 - 19:46

Darren Paffey.

19:46 - 19:54

Darren James Paffey

Question seven, please, Madam Deputy Speaker.

19:54 - 20:23

Abena Asare

With your permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, I am going to answer question seven and 15 together. Current service levels are completely unacceptable, and we are holding Capita accountable by withholding payments in the short term and assessing the long-term viability of bringing the scheme in house. We will continue to use the most stringent commercial levers that we have under this contract, which was signed by the last government, to ensure that we have full accountability.

20:23 - 20:58

Darren James Paffey

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome my honourable friend to her place and thank her for her answer. In Southampton Itchen, I've got constituents who have been deprived their pension for many months. One waited over a year even for an accurate quotation. Another, after 40 years of service, is yet to receive a penny.

And one with stage four cancer took three months to get any money, and only then after I'd nagged a minister to intervene. When I was a Southampton City Councillor, we ended Capita's contract and took those services back in house. Isn't it time for the government to consider doing the same?

20:58 - 21:35

Abena Asare

I thank my honourable friend for raising his constituents' cases, and I've had many similar in Doncaster as well. I want to ensure him and his constituents that I am using all levers at my disposal to ensure that Capita delivers a better performance at the earliest possible time. We have set out our intention to advance the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation, and we are now actively shaping a long-term strategy to look at what that would look like if we brought the pension scheme back in house. He will of course be aware of our manifesto commitment to have the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation, and I am committed to fulfilling that.

21:35 - 21:36

Alex Barros-Curtis.

21:36 - 22:04

Alex Barros

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I share my friend's warm welcomes to my honourable friend in her new position. I too, in surgery after surgery, have examples of Capita failing to do its job. And the latest example of this was a surgery just the other week, a constituent of mine called Craig, who since July has received no pension payment or calculation. Will the minister please look into Craig's case and also do everything she can to give Capita the boot?

22:04 - 22:31

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Look, the performance of Capita has been totally abysmal, and I have raised this a number of times in this House myself as well. And I can assure him that we will be holding Capita to account, including withholding nearly 10 million pounds of contractual payments, because we will not pay for services that have not been delivered. If the honourable friend will write to me, I will ensure that his case is investigated and get back to him at the soonest possible opportunity.

22:31 - 22:32

Gagan Mohindra.

22:32 - 22:58

Gagan Mohindra

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Despite dedicating their lives to public service through long careers in the civil service, many of my constituents have faced severe delays with their pension payments, causing them anxiety and financial hardship. So how will the minister ensure that her department gives my constituents the support they need to ensure this crisis gets resolved, but also, just as importantly, doesn't happen again?

22:58 - 23:39

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So the department, there's an independent Capita-funded remedial advisor that has been appointed to identify service delivery issues to allow us to continue to hold Capita fully accountable. There is also around 147 surge staff that have been deployed in this crisis. The government remains committed to maintaining resource levels. No team members will be withdrawn from that surge team until service levels are permanently fixed.

And as I said in my previous answers, we are using all commercial levers that we have at our disposal, including withholding those payments so that Capita are held accountable, and we are exploring very closely options of bringing the pension scheme in house.

23:39 - 23:41

Speaker 26

Dr. Ellie Chowns.

23:41 - 24:25

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Numerous constituents in North Herefordshire have had the same problems with the Civil Service Pension Scheme run by Capita. One example is my constituent Ruth. Her husband worked for the Ministry of Defence. He died in service nearly a year ago.

She's been waiting 11 months for a death in service payment and pension. Capita promised to get this resolved, all bereavement cases done by the end of August. They broke that promise this week, she is still waiting. This is absolutely unacceptable. I welcome the fact the Minister says there will be penalties for Capita, but does she not recognise this is such a clear example that outsourcing does not work?

And will she ensure that Capita doesn't get contracts like this ever again?

24:25 - 25:14

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the honourable member for raising the experience for constituent. And I'm sorry to hear about that, and I've heard many similar examples in my own constituency, I know members across the House have as well. I will be providing a hopefully a more substantive update in October. But as I've said previously in my answers, their performance is totally unacceptable. I am not going to defend that, and I will continue to hold them to account every single day that I am in office until the service levels are brought back up to an acceptable standard and all of our constituents get their pension that they should have had, in your case 11 months ago.

And I will continue to do that. We are looking at bringing the pension scheme in-house and looking at the different options that are viable to do that. It's in our manifesto to commit to the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation, and we are all committed to do that.

25:14 - 25:18

Rosie Wrighting

Rosie Wrighting. Question number eight please, Madam Deputy Speaker.

25:18 - 25:38

Feryal Clark

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am working with colleagues right across government to deliver good AI jobs in every part of this country. That means a focus on capabilities, AI skills boosts for individuals, BridgeAI for firms. It means a focus on compute, with AI growth zone program, AI research resource for British startups. It means a focus on capital, through the British Business Bank and Sovereign AI.

25:18 - 25:18

Minister.

25:38 - 25:42

Feryal Clark

And at the heart of it, it means a focus on culture so that we're building AI for good in every part of the country.

25:42 - 25:48

Speaker 32

Minister may wish to check his notes, that question is grouped with number 18. Rosie Wrighting.

25:48 - 26:19

Speaker 58

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to welcome my honourable friend to his place. I'm particularly so pleased to see him as the first Minister for AI around the Cabinet table. In order for AI productivity gains to be felt in every postcode and in areas like Kettering, we need to reduce the barriers of entry for small and medium-sized businesses. So what is his department doing to make sure it's as easy as possible for SMEs to upskill their workers and access this new technology so its impact isn't contained to a few large companies?

26:19 - 26:55

Feryal Clark

Well, could I firstly thank my honourable friend? She's been a champion both in this place and as someone with great experience of technology from her prior career as well, which is a source of insight for all of us. On the particular question of AI support for small businesses, we have a skills boost program with a particular focus on upskilling two million individuals in SMEs, the biggest targeted training program since Harold Wilson's Open University program as well. Alongside that, my focus is on making sure that procurement programs in AI are supporting small businesses in every part of this country, including through an AI R&D scheme that is supporting those businesses.

26:55 - 26:57

Speaker 30

Paulette Hamilton.

26:57 - 27:33

Paulette Hamilton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I also welcome my honourable friend to his place. Birmingham has an enormous potential to benefit from the growth of AI, but communities like mine in Erdington must not be left behind. What steps is the Minister taking with colleagues across government to ensure that young people in constituencies like mine in Birmingham Erdington have access to the skills, apprenticeships, and training they need to secure the new well-paid jobs being created by AI?

27:35 - 27:37

Speaker 37

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

27:37 - 28:16

Feryal Clark

Well, can I firstly thank my honourable friend for her shared commitment to the fact that unlike the last wave of technology, in this wave of AI, everyone across this country must feel the opportunity that it offers. And for that reason, we are focused on both the AI skills boost I mentioned as well as upskilling challenge funds so that local areas across the country can benefit from those resources. I'm also looking very closely at AI bootcamp pilots to support in particular young people not in employment, education and training to learn the lessons of it and working closely with trade unions on the earlier careers jobs alliance, thinking about where the future of jobs will go so that Britain is best prepared for the every community to make the most of it.

28:16 - 28:22

Ian Robert Byrne

Question number nine, Madam Deputy Speaker.

28:22 - 28:33

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Madam Deputy Speaker, there's a well-established process for the revocation of honours. Any instance where a recipient may be deemed to have brought the honour system into disrepute can be considered by the independent forfeiture committee.

28:33 - 29:17

Ian Robert Byrne

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In December last year, the Independent Office for Police Conduct found that Sir Norman Bettison, a chief inspector for South Yorkshire Police at the time of Hillsborough, would have had a case to answer for gross misconduct had he still been serving an officer a serving officer today. This related to his role in the Hillsborough cover-up through deliberate dishonesty in the aftermath of the disaster and for lying about his involvement during his application for the post of chief constable of Merseyside in 1998. Yesterday, I wrote to the Prime Minister asking the Honours and Forfeiture Committee have taken December's finding into account. Will my honourable friend confirm these findings are being considered by the committee and if not, make representations that it should be.

29:17 - 29:55

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Madam Deputy Speaker, let me start by paying tribute to the work of my honourable friend on this. This government is absolutely clear, the Hillsborough disaster must never happen again. That is why the Public Office Accountability Bill will establish a new duty of candour and assistance at inquiries and investigations backed by criminal sanctions. This will also extend to police misconduct investigation. My honourable friend will understand why I'm not in a position to comment on an individual case from the floor of the House, but I'd like to reassure him that I've seen his correspondence with my predecessor on this question and I'm looking at it very carefully.

29:55 - 29:59

Margaret Olivia Hillier

Question number 11, Madam Deputy Speaker.

29:59 - 30:31

Pat McFadden

The Infected Blood Compensation Authority has asked 6,321 people to start their claim. I'm sorry to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the horrible nature of this awful scandal means there is inherent uncertainty about the number of eligible people, but we are deeply committed to ensuring everyone eligible receives the compensation they are due. IBCA has a registration service which supports its understanding of who intends to claim. As of the 25th of August, IBCA has received 20,487 registrations.

30:31 - 31:04

Margaret Olivia Hillier

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and in my right honourable friend's and I welcome her to her place at response. It demonstrates really the complications of these schemes. I'd asked the National Audit Office to look into this and yesterday the Public Accounts Committee published its report into compensation schemes suggesting that there was a central body to be established. I know that she and her department will respond in due course formally to that, but could she give the House a hint about whether she thinks that there is room for improvement as government sets up different compensation schemes on different systems that can be very complicated and we don't seem to be learning from the better practice.

31:04 - 31:40

Pat McFadden

Well, my right honourable friend with her considerable experience in this area is absolutely right. The fact of the matter is that no amount of money will make up for the impact that this terrible tragedy had on countless victims and their families, but we're determined to deliver justice as swiftly as possible. We're very grateful to the work of the committee in their time assessing the progress made on compensation schemes. We're also considering as part of the government's response to the Williams Inquiry report in which we indicated that the government would give further thought to how redress should be delivered in future and will respond to the Public Accounts Committee in due course.

31:40 - 32:17

Joe Robertson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I recently met with one of my constituents, Stan, whose father died through contaminated blood. Like many families, he is facing an endless delay through poor administration of the scheme. It feels like it is a scandal within a scandal unfolding as mistakes are made and further stress is caused to families. What steps is the Secretary of State taking to ensure that the scheme is administered properly, mistakes are cut out, and would she consider meeting with me to explore the issues raised by my constituent's case?

32:17 - 32:52

Pat McFadden

Well, I'm incredibly sorry to hear about the experience of Stan and the death of his family member. Unfortunately, it is an experience that has been shared by too many people and the government and my predecessor, the former Minister for the Cabinet Office, has worked considerably to improve the scheme, setting out a number of reforms and new statutory instruments. I will ask my honourable friend, the Minister in the other place, to meet with him and his constituent in order to consider his experience and how we can improve the system going forward.

32:52 - 32:53

John Lamont.

32:53 - 32:56

John Lamont

Thank you very much. Question number 12, please.

32:56 - 32:57

Minister.

32:57 - 33:18

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

With your permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to take question number 12 and question number 17 together. Number 10 North will drive growth in every postcode of the country, working alongside mayors, council leaders, and businesses from across Britain. The costs for setting up and running Number 10 North are covered by existing Cabinet Office budgets.

33:18 - 33:19

John Lamont.

33:19 - 33:51

John Lamont

I thank the Minister for that answer, but of course for my constituents, it's not Number 10 North, it's Number 10 Midlands. According to a freedom of information request, tens of thousands of pounds have already been spent setting up Number 10 North, including 10,500 pounds on branding, 1,700 pounds on crockery, and nearly 1,000 pounds moving a replica Downing Street door. Now, does the Minister think this represents good value for money and can the Minister commit to publish annually the full cost of running Number 10 North, including staffing, travel, and security?

33:51 - 33:52

Minister.

33:52 - 34:15

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

I thank the honourable member for his question. For me, as a Member of Parliament in North London, it is very much north to go and visit Manchester, but it's fantastic to go up there, Madam Deputy Speaker, and meet with local businesses when I do. On his specific question, of course, the expenditure on Number 10 North will be published in the usual way along with the Cabinet Office accounts.

34:15 - 34:16

Greg Smith.

34:16 - 34:37

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can the Minister be really specific? How many civil servants and how many special advisers are due to be permanently staffed at Number 10 North, and once they are all in place and working there, will the government publish their attendance statistics at the office?

34:37 - 34:38

Minister.

34:38 - 35:12

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Of course, as permanent teams are formed, and they will be formed, we will make sure that those who live nearby and are in commutable distance are encouraged to apply, and we hope that they will do so. There are already some 80,000 civil servants working in the North West of England, and I think it is a fantastic change that this government has introduced to mean that more civil servants from more parts of the country, more people can contribute at the heart of government to building the change that this government wants to see.

35:12 - 35:13

Feryal Clark.

35:13 - 35:39

Feryal Clark

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. After 14 years of austerity and Westminster knows best from the previous Conservative government, my constituents in Ealing Southall feel just as left behind and ignored as those in Manchester and Wakefield. So does he agree with me that if Number 10 North finally makes this country work for constituents like mine, then it will be worth every single penny?

35:39 - 36:12

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

I thank my honourable friend for her question. She is totally right that the objective of Number 10 North is to drive good growth in every postcode across the whole of the country.

Too many places and too many communities have been left behind for too long because power and decision making was hoarded in Westminster. Members on our side of the House know that the roots to growth everywhere is getting it out across the country. Members on the other side of the House, it seems want to keep hoarding power and decision making here in Westminster.

36:12 - 37:00

Mike Wood

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And we've heard again just what we've had in response to a number of written questions. The Minister either doesn't know or won't tell us how so, either doesn't know or won't tell us how much Number 10 North will cost, how many people work there, or how many of them actually turn up to work. I mean it's almost as though this hasn't, it's almost as though this hasn't been properly thought through. So can the, can the Minister understand why with so little information and so little transparency, so many people feel that this is a gimmick rather than a strategy.

37:00 - 38:06

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When it comes to efficient use of taxpayer money, I would like to point out to the House that the honourable member, of course he's welcome to submit as many questions as he likes, but he's sent 371 at a cost to the taxpayer of potentially around 80,000 pounds. Of course, of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are willing to have debates in this place and on the floor of the House. And my honourable friends in the Cabinet Office will of course continue to answer questions. But in the end, we need to make sure that this Government is driving good growth and opportunity and devolution across the whole country.

It's the right thing to do. The previous Government passed onto us a country that was the most geographically unequal advanced economy in the whole world. We are setting to turn that around for the people of this country. And of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, the details on employment and the costs of Number 10 North will be published in the usual way along with the accounts for the Cabinet Office.

38:06 - 38:50

Mike Wood

Madam Deputy Speaker, of course we wouldn't have to table so many written questions if they actually answered the first question we tabled instead of expecting us to come up with precisely the right form of words to leave them with no way of getting out. So surely it cannot be right that it requires a freedom of information request to discover how much it cost for a replica door at Number 10 North, but the Minister refuses to answer legitimate parliamentary scrutiny. So Madam Deputy Speaker, will the Minister at least commit, if he does have this information, which the Department surely does, will he finally commit to publishing the total budget for Number 10 North, the number of staff and special advisers who are going to work there, and to publishing attendance statistics.

38:50 - 39:29

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Madam Deputy Speaker, I think it would be best for honourable members rather than getting in a flap about Number 10 North, to back what we are trying to do to drive good growth and opportunity and devolution across the whole country. It's the right thing to do. The previous Government passed onto us a country that was the most geographically unequal advanced economy in the whole world. We are setting to turn that around for the people of this country. And of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, the details on employment and the costs of Number 10 North will be published in the usual way along with the accounts for the Cabinet Office.

39:29 - 40:02

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Madam Deputy Speaker, climate change brings an increased risk of severe weather. We are learning from the summer droughts and planning for what will likely be a challenging winter. As I saw when I visited the honorable member's St Ives constituency back in January, extreme weather can cause disruption to the essential services that we all rely on. We are working to make public infrastructure like telecoms more resilient and will also launch a public awareness campaign this year so people know the small but important steps they can take to be ready for emergencies like severe weather.

40:02 - 40:54

Andrew George

I'm grateful to the Minister for that response. And indeed, as the Minister said, he kindly visited the constituency shortly after the significant devastation that was caused to West Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly following the storm, Storm Grette, in early January this year. In his letter to me shortly thereafter, he committed to a comprehensive review of response to Storm Grette, ensure lessons are learned and that preparedness and response plans are improved. So my question is, in what way have those plans improved? And given that communities are now preparing themselves to improve their own resilience and we're bringing them together this autumn, would he be prepared to come and visit West Cornwall again and to meet my communities?

40:54 - 41:45

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm very grateful to the honorable gentleman who has consistently and constructively raised the points that he has done again so today. Having been to visit his constituency and seen firsthand the devastation caused, I'm personally extremely keen to make sure that we do learn the lessons that have been drawn out from what happened under Storm Grette. As he will know, COBRA officials have worked closely with Cornwall Council on resilience planning. We are going to be launching a public awareness campaign which will support people in Cornwall and beyond with future emergencies. I'm also pleased to say that the honorable member's constituency is receiving over two million pounds this financial year to tackle flooding.

He very kindly invites me to visit his constituency again. What I would say to him is time spent in Cornwall is time well spent.

41:45 - 41:46

Julia Buckley.

41:46 - 42:22

Julia Buckley

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Water privatization and climate change has left us with the twin resilience challenges of both water scarcity and flooding. So to reduce demand on our drinking water supply, is the Cabinet Office looking at the landmark report that came forward this March from the Drinking Water Inspectorate, which sets out a governance framework for reusing rainwater harvesting? Could we look at installing rainwater for toilet flush in our publicly owned buildings? We could cut our costs, increase our resilience, and make steps towards sustainability.

42:22 - 42:32

Speaker 70

I think the honorable lady raises a very important point and I give her an undertaking that I will look closely at the report that she has referenced and also make sure that we're discussing it with colleagues in DEFRA.

42:32 - 43:04

Andrew Snowden

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Flooding during severe weather incidents is often predictable because they're the same areas that often suffer from low-level regular flooding throughout the rest of the year. These issues affect multi-council areas up and down stream and cover multiple government agencies. Bodies such as flooding boards that cover those areas are a really great way of coordinating agencies and councils, but they're not across the whole of the UK. So would the Minister consider looking out at support for rolling out flood boards for every part of the UK?

43:04 - 43:23

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think the honorable gentleman raises a very important point. I'm proud to say that I think I was the first metro mayor to launch a flood catchment plan. So I absolutely recognize the importance of the points that he has made. I want to give it due consideration. Let me consult with ministerial colleagues in DEFRA and I'll come back to him.

43:20 - 43:49

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I'd like to return to Cornwall for a minute. The Minister did mention the possibility that Cornwall could be a pilot area for storm resilience measures, so it would be good to hear a bit more about that. And particularly regarding to raising awareness, that's very welcome because people in Cornwall, how they acted on an individual level, on a local emergency plan council level and on a unitary level, guidelines for that would be really useful going forward and I wondered if he could say a bit more about that.

43:49 - 44:12

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, I'm grateful to her also for the championing she's done not only of her own constituency but of wider issues relating to infrastructure and resilience in Cornwall. I know that the Prime Minister has given a commitment to meet with Cornish MPs. Let me consider carefully the points that she's made along with the points that the honourable member has made. And I get a sense Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm probably going to be heading back to Cornwall.

44:12 - 44:13

Alex McIntyre.

44:13 - 44:15

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Question number 14 please Madam Deputy Speaker.

44:15 - 44:16

Minister.

44:16 - 44:36

Pat McFadden

Last month I announced reforms to public procurement that will cut red tape and focus social value on delivering good jobs and skills development. In the autumn I will publish new guidance to ensure central government procurement consistently supports jobs, skills and people in every postcode.

44:36 - 45:06

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank my right honourable friend for her answer. Procurement matters because done well it supports local jobs in Gloucester and communities like mine. Together Gloucestershire are a local organisation who are an excellent example of how procurement can be done differently. They work with local businesses and the public sector to showcase the talent and skill that we have in our own county and provide a procurement portal for organisations to access it. Will my right honourable friend meet with me and Together Gloucestershire to discuss how this model could be better supported and developed further?

45:06 - 45:27

Pat McFadden

I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for bringing the important work of Together Gloucestershire to the House. It's an excellent example of where social value can ensure that British taxpayers' money is directed towards delivering British jobs and skills in our constituencies. I will of course ask the Minister and our officials to meet with the honourable gentleman and businesses in his constituency.

45:27 - 45:28

Gordon McKee.

45:28 - 45:30

Gordon McKee

Question number 16 Madam Deputy Speaker.

45:30 - 45:31

Minister.

45:31 - 45:55

Feryal Clark

Can I first and foremost Madam Deputy Speaker enthusiastically ask your permission to group questions 16 and 20. Technology in my core belief should not be the reserve of a privileged few but instead should be a great leveller supporting dignity in our public services and opportunity for British businesses. That's why I'm focused on redesigning the way government uses AI and technology to support our brilliant public service professionals achieve those ends.

45:55 - 46:14

Speaker 76

I thank the Minister for his answer. The pace of innovation has never been faster, which means that the value lost by slow procurement processes has never been higher. We need the government departments to be able to buy in the most advanced software, the most advanced technologies without lengthy delay. So can the Minister tell me and the House what work he is doing to enable departments to do that?

46:14 - 46:45

Feryal Clark

Well can I firstly pay tribute to my honourable friend. There's only one thing that's faster than the pace of technology and that's the pace at which my honourable friend keeps up with the technology and in particular online engagement as well. Can I flag two things that are particularly the focus of my efforts on this question. First, to make sure we're creating swift examples of procurement support for British businesses, not least through the Sovereign AI R&D procurement scheme, and then a more systematic focus on bringing the best package of AI tools to support procurement professionals move faster.

46:45 - 46:53

Speaker 78

Emily Darlington. Not here. Helen Morgan.

46:53 - 46:55

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Number 19 please Madam Deputy Speaker.

46:55 - 47:25

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Madam Deputy Speaker, the first duty of any government is to keep people safe. Our recent decision to issue an alert was made in direct cooperation with the National Fire Chiefs Council at a time when emergency services were facing unprecedented pressure with 43 active fires and four major incidents. Evidence from the 72 hours following the alert indicates that this intervention was effective with a measurable reduction in new wildfire incidents.

47:25 - 48:05

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker.

In North Shropshire, we are on the border with Wales and we have poor to non-existent mobile phone signal. This meant that many of my constituents received the emergency alert in Welsh first and maybe didn't receive it in English at all, or received it in English many hours later. And because there was no pre-briefing, they were really concerned about the emergency alert that they'd received that they couldn't understand. Would the Minister consider in future pre-briefing when an alert is going to happen, so that when we get the alert in a different language, or people who are trying to keep their phones secret because they're vulnerable, they have time to be ready for that and aren't unduly alarmed? Thank you.

48:05 - 48:38

Daniel Owen Jarvis

I think the honourable lady makes an entirely reasonable point. I hope that she would acknowledge that we look very carefully when an alert has been issued and seek to learn lessons from it. I can tell her that all emergency alerts are sent in conjunction with local partners, and in Wales the alert was sent first in Welsh followed by English in order to fulfill our legal responsibilities under the Welsh Language Act of 1993. But I'll look very carefully at what she has said, and I give her an assurance that we'll seek to learn lessons from the way in which this alert was issued.

48:38 - 48:40

Speaker 77

Josh Fenton-Glynn.

48:40 - 48:42

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Number 23.

48:42 - 48:46

Speaker 73

Minister.

48:46 - 49:10

Georgia Gould

Wonderful. All government departments have set ambitious SME spends. We have strengthened late payment policy and now make it easier for SMEs to bid by raising the threshold for when social value should be taken into account. This government is determined to use public procurement to back small and medium-sized enterprises, and I was pleased that the Federation of Small Businesses welcomed our social value changes over the summer.

49:10 - 49:11

Josh Fenton-Glynn.

49:11 - 49:40

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's commitment to helping SMEs access public contracts. In Calder Valley, or Val-Valley as we often call it, small manufacturing firms contribute to nationally significant projects, but through supply chains, and they're often left out of the conversation about national procurement. So can I please ask the Minister how we can ensure that these smaller manufacturers have the opportunities created by government to create a new generation of skilled manufacturing jobs?

49:40 - 50:04

Georgia Gould

I thank my honourable friend for his question, and he is a fantastic campaigner on behalf of businesses in his local community. And in his local community like mine, those small and medium-sized industries play an absolutely critical role, not just in our industrial past but also in our industrial future. I'd be more than happy to meet with him to talk about as we develop this agenda, how we can make this work for communities like ours.

50:04 - 50:06

Speaker 66

Topical questions, Tom Gordon.

50:06 - 51:12

Pat McFadden

Question one, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, for far too long the state has found itself reaching for the comfort blanket of consultation, review, and process. To deliver change at the pace and scale the public expects, my department is stripping out needless bureaucracy. Between 2019 and 2023, the government asked the public three times for their views on introducing legislation to microchip cats. You couldn't make it up.

If we can't microchip cats without tying them up in red tape, it's little wonder the public has lost faith that government can deliver change. So I am telling ministerial colleagues consultations are not required, and we will introduce reforms to minimize the risk of judicial review. Once the necessary legislation is passed, transport, water, and other major infrastructure projects will benefit from parliamentary authorization. Governments are elected to lead, not hide behind process. This government will lead and put public control at the heart of our decision-making.

51:12 - 51:13

Tom Gordon.

51:13 - 51:34

Thomas Gordon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. No sum of money can truly replace the loss of a loved one. On my summer supermarket surgery tour, I spoke to one constituent who lost his father as a result of contaminated blood products. He wanted me to ask the First Secretary of State, with payments scheduled into the future, will she look at considering index-linking compensation to inflation so that delay doesn't shrink what families have been awarded?

51:34 - 51:54

Pat McFadden

I'm very sorry to hear about the honourable gentleman's appalling experience for his constituent.

As we've discussed earlier in questions, we have made considerable efforts to improve the scheme and ensure that constituents receive their compensation as quickly as possible. Reports are being laid in the House today and we will consider his request as we go forward.

51:54 - 52:19

Josh Dean

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. One of my constituents contacted me about her mother, who'd worked for the Department for Work and Pensions since the age of 18, but sadly died before Capita released the pension she'd earned through a lifetime of public service. So given the distress caused to families like this one by such delays, what steps is the Minister taking to ensure that civil servants receive their pension payments promptly upon retirement?

52:19 - 52:54

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for raising this appalling case of his constituent. Current service levels are completely unacceptable. We continue to use the most stringent commercial levers that we have under this contract, including withholding contractual payments. We have 147 surge staff deployed in this crisis. We won't be moving any of those team members until service levels are permanently fixed.

If the honourable member would like to write to me, I'd be happy to make sure that any of his future cases are looked at with urgency.

52:54 - 53:13

Alex Burghart

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over the summer, the Prime Minister announced that mayors will keep a proportion of income tax receipts. So why won't mayors like Conservative Mayor Ben Houchen be allowed to use that money to cut taxes or offer rebates to local residents and businesses?

53:13 - 53:24

Speaker 74

The Mayor of Tees Valley Ben Houchen already has the ability to provide grants to businesses and communities. He's very welcome to do so with the considerable funding he already receives.

53:24 - 53:57

Alex Burghart

Thank you, thank the honourable lady for her question, but she didn't for her answer, but she didn't answer my question. My question was about the income tax receipts that Ben Houchen will be allowed to retain. Over the summer, she said that he would not be allowed to use that to give rebates to local individuals and businesses. At the moment, councils already have the power to levy council tax discounts and business rate discounts. Why can't mayors do the same with income tax receipts?

53:57 - 54:24

Pat McFadden

I'll explain to the Shadow Secretary, there is a difference between rebates and grants. The mayor doesn't have the ability to provide rebates now and is unlikely to in the future because it would involve getting HMRC data and the ability to set income tax thresholds, which of course we will not be devolving to a mayoral level. If the Mayor of Tees Valley wishes to support businesses and communities, he is as welcome to now as he will be in the future.

54:24 - 54:50

Margaret Rachel Taylor

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I regularly hear from young people in my North Warwickshire and Bedworth constituency about the challenges they face getting their foot on the career ladder. Will the Minister set out the specific steps the Cabinet Office is taking to ensure the Government's new procurement rules translate into more jobs, more apprenticeships, and more opportunities for young people in rural communities like mine?

54:50 - 55:16

Pat McFadden

Giving young people opportunities to reach their potential is a key priority for this Government, and that is why we have asked Alan Milburn to push forward this agenda looking at young people not in employment, education, or training. We are using specific local social value schemes that suppliers can support through public procurement, which will provide much-needed education, employment, and training so young people can progress.

55:16 - 55:52

Lisa Smart

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last week, Channel 4 showed senior figures from Reform UK discussing how money from an American donor could reach the party through his UK-based son.

Does the Government agree that covert overseas finance represents a clear and present threat to our national security? But do they also accept that measures in the Representation of the People Bill don't go quite far enough when it comes to stopping foreign money being funnelled into our democracy? And that the best way to reduce the options for those who seek to exert undue influence through big money is to put a cap on all political donations.

55:52 - 56:34

Daniel Owen Jarvis

I'm grateful to her for the important points that she's raised and the constructive conversations we've had about these matters previously. She will note the work of the Rycroft review and I know that she understands the important work that we do through the Defending Democracy Taskforce. And as the chair of that, I've always believed that this is a shared endeavour across the House. I can say to her that we will assemble a new cross-government task and finish team to identify next steps for tackling the issue of mega-donors in UK politics and putting politics under public control. Many honourable members will have seen the programme that she references and share the concerns.

She will also understand that there is now a live police investigation and therefore there's nothing more I can say about it.

56:34 - 57:05

Joseph Ronald Morris

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the announcement from the Secretary of State and Prime Minister over the summer that they're going to reform procurement to benefit British businesses. On my summer tour of my constituency, I met with large groups of local farmers who've seen previous procurement reforms not quite benefit farmers in the way that they would like. So I'd like to know if the Minister would join me visiting a farm in Northumbria. They can mutter, but I do visit my farms, unlike my predecessor.

Would she like to join me on a visit to a local farm to discuss how procurement can benefit British farmers?

57:05 - 57:38

Georgia Gould

I'd like to commend my honourable member for his remarkable stamina over the summer with more than 80 visits across his constituency, the largest in England. He is certainly a passionate campaigner for farmers. And he will know that our recently announced reforms to social value mean that businesses bidding for Government contracts, a market worth 90 billion, will be rightly judged on creating high-quality jobs, skills, and apprenticeships in local communities. That includes food procurement, where we are aiming for at least half of all public sector food to be locally produced. And I would gladly join him with one of his local farmers to talk further about this.

57:38 - 58:05

Liz Jarvis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Simon gave 31 years' service at the Maritime and Coastguard Agency supporting the Royal Navy. He contacted Capita in March ahead of his April retirement and was assured that his pension would be sorted, but the same promise was repeated in June, then again in July. It remains awaiting triage. Can the Minister say when this backlog will be cleared and Simon can expect his pension?

58:05 - 58:43

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the honourable member for raising this case. As I've said previously today, Capita's performance is absolutely diabolical. There are no excuses for it and I'm not going to make an excuse for it at this dispatch box. But we are holding them to account every single day. As I've said before, we've brought 147 surge staff deployed to help in this crisis.

They won't be removed until service levels are brought up to scratch. We're withholding contractual payments and we have an independent Capita-funded remedial advisor who's been appointed to identify further issues. If she wants to write to me about that case, I will make sure it's escalated.

58:43 - 59:23

Ian Lavery

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's nearly two years since the contaminated blood inquiry report was published. People think it's finished, but it isn't. There are still 18,000 affected and infected individuals still haven't begun their claim. Will my right honourable friend reaffirm to this House the commitment to the contaminated blood community and will she meet with the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Haemophilia and Contaminated Blood so we can discuss the best way forward to press these cases home expediently?

59:23 - 59:55

Pat McFadden

Well, can I congratulate and thank my honourable friend for his many years of campaigning on this terrible issue.

He will know the Prime Minister's personal involvement and commitment on this issue and experience campaigning alongside the victims, so he will know how importantly he considers this, as does the department. The Infected Blood Compensation Authority has now paid out over 2.2 billion pounds in final compensation payments, but we are very aware that there is much more to do. And I'm I'm happy to say that the the minister in the other place will be happy to meet with his APPG.

59:55 - 59:56

Wendy Morton.

59:56 - 01:00:34

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. One of my constituents served HMRC for 43 years, yet more than five months after taking partial retirement, she is still waiting for her pension and lump sum. My office has attended two casework surgeries with Capita and the Cabinet Office, neither of which has secured a resolution. This this individual is now paying additional mortgage interest because of these delays. So will the minister urgently meet with me to resolve this case, secure a payment date, and ensure my constituent is compensated for the financial losses incurred?

01:00:34 - 01:00:58

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm I'm sorry to hear the experience the honorable member's constituent has had with Capita. As I've said previously, their performance has been absolutely abysmal, and we are holding them to account every single day until service levels are brought back to a good service. And I'd be happy to meet with the honorable member to look at her case and personally ensure that it's that it's escalated.

01:00:58 - 01:00:59

Euan Stainbank.

01:00:59 - 01:01:23

Euan Stainbank

The Prime Minister was right to say that too many buses are being built from abroad last week. The 10% social value commitment from combined mayoral authorities following the bus manufacturing expert panel earlier this year will not be enough to protect British bus building as China continues to scale up their automotive dumping. Will the First Secretary of State work with the devolved mayors, DfT, and DBEST to bring social value requirements in line with the 20% she has rightly set for major government contracts?

01:01:23 - 01:01:38

Georgia Gould

I thank my honorable friend for his work, his work through the APPG. He's a passionate campaigner, I know, Madam Deputy Speaker, on behalf of British buses, particularly with regard to the impact on his local constituents. I would of course be happy to meet with him to discuss this further.

01:01:38 - 01:01:39

Andrew Snowden.

01:01:39 - 01:02:02

Andrew Snowden

Upon her appointment as the First Secretary of State, it was widely reported in the press that she had had responsibility for fraud in the Cabinet Office removed from her. I wonder if the First Secretary of State could outline why those and speculation was made, and if she's struggling, she can perhaps use the phone a friend option.

01:02:02 - 01:02:16

Pat McFadden

A number of responsibilities were removed from the Cabinet Office in order to create the new Office of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, a central new body at the heart of government committed to delivering the Prime Minister's and the British people's priorities.

01:02:17 - 01:02:56

Richard Quigley

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And may I say how happy I am to welcome my right honorable friend the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster to her place. And I know she will continue to be a fantastic champion for the Isle of Wight. Per capita, not the pension people, but head of population, the island tops the league for tech and advanced manufacturing. But despite our brilliant pedigree, under the previous government, we have been continually overlooked for funding and investment.

Will my right honorable friend assure me that she will use her office to secure sustained growth in our postcodes so the island can finally receive the recognition, investment, and job opportunities that its contribution to our economy deserves?

01:02:56 - 01:03:19

Pat McFadden

Well, I'm extremely grateful to my honorable friend's and his kind words and his continual championing for the Isle of Wight. And I will ensure that his ferry in particular is top of my to-do list for 2050. The the proposal that he outlines is exactly the kind of work that Number 10 North has been designed to champion, to drive good growth in every postcode, north and south.

01:03:19 - 01:03:23

Speaker 82

Alex Brewer.

01:03:23 - 01:03:40

Alexandra Katherine Brewer

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Most fire responders in North East Hampshire are volunteers. After an unprecedented summer of wildfires, including in my constituency, will the Minister meet with me and fire volunteers to hear first-hand the pressures on the fire service?

01:03:40 - 01:03:42

Daniel Owen Jarvis

I'd be delighted to do so.

01:03:43 - 01:04:07

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I very much welcome the procurement changes that this government has brought in. In the summer, the docks in my constituency lost a UKRI contract on the Sir David Attenborough to a Danish dockyard. Can the Minister assure me that these new rules will refer to government agencies across the government, rather than just simply within the government?

01:04:07 - 01:04:26

Georgia Gould

I thank my right honorable friend, promoted you there, my honorable friend, for her campaigning on behalf of Cornwall and for her constituency. I want to assure her of how seriously we take that issue and broader issues around procurement, and of course we'll be happy to meet with her to discuss this further.

01:04:26 - 01:04:27

Robert Jenrick.

01:04:27 - 01:04:54

Edward Robert Jenrick

The Minister said that governments are elected to lead, by which most people would assume that means ministers are elected to lead, accountable to Parliament and to the people. Why then is the government giving away powers to the Cabinet Secretary to direct permanent secretaries, which should be the role of Secretaries of State? Don't ministers want these powers to actually do their jobs?

01:04:54 - 01:05:10

Georgia Gould

I thank the right honorable member for his question. We are committed, and the Cabinet Secretary is committed, to conducting a full review of the civil service. This is at a relatively early stage, but I look forward to hearing what decisions are taken, and of course it will be a matter for the Prime Minister what powers are determined.

01:05:11 - 01:05:49

Christine Jardine

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I hate to take the Minister back to Capita, but unfortunately I have a number of constituents who have been through the many stages already explained by the Minister. Capita is not working, and the government, I accept that you're doing all these things, but it is making not a blind bit of difference. I have people who can't pay their mortgages, who've been waiting for more than a year for a settlement sum. Something more needs to be done, and it's very depressing for these people when they read in the papers that Capita are getting more government contracts. So what more can the government do?

01:05:49 - 01:05:54

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Minister's response, that's the first you of the day, hopefully the last you of the day, Minister.

01:05:54 - 01:06:31

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I hope to be able to update the House shortly after recess with further steps that the government are taking. As I've said, we have a Capita-funded remedial advisor in place who's identifying the delivery issues, and we've also deployed auditors to Capita to get a full understanding of the exact state of the service. We'll continue to look at withholding contractual payments, and as I've said, this government is committed to the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation. So whilst we inherited this contract from the previous government, we are going to ensure that going forward, looking at in-house schemes is a priority.

01:06:32 - 01:06:53

Clive Jones

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Brexit has created a web of red tape preventing businesses in Wokingham from developing relationships with European partners. Will the government start negotiations for a growth and defense partnership with the EU to boost trade and growth?

01:06:53 - 01:07:06

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

We are engaged in discussions with the European Union on exactly the questions that the honorable member refers to. We've made good progress in the first two years. I wish to go further, as I set out in my answer to the question before.

01:07:06 - 01:07:08

Speaker 87

Tuckman.

01:07:08 - 01:07:27

Tessa Munt

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Returning to the emergency alert, I wonder what assessment the Secretary of State had made of issuing alerts on a regional or county basis for important but more local emergencies, such as bluetongue outbreaks in cattle and sheep in rural areas.

01:07:27 - 01:07:51

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Well, I hope she heard my earlier response about how seriously we take the issuing of the alert and how we take considerable effort to look carefully at how it has worked and whether it can be improved in future. I can say to her that every emergency alert is carefully coordinated with the responding public bodies and agencies, and each request is evaluated on a case-by-case basis to ensure that it is necessary for public safety.

01:07:51 - 01:07:53

Speaker 93

Vicky Slade.

01:07:53 - 01:08:33

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I'm so sorry to return to Capita, but I may have a solution. My constituent John is retiring partly due to ill health and his salary is now at half level, he's really struggling. But he explained to me the current system means that a retirement date has to be selected four months in advance and if the delay goes one day past that, rather than an amendment on the figures, the system has to start all over again. So my suggestion is that we change that slight tweak so that we save Capita a lot of work and our residents a lot of heartache. I wonder if she could comment on that and pick up my constituent's case.

01:08:33 - 01:08:44

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the honourable member for bringing that idea to this House. I'll be happy to put that to Capita when I next meet them and if she wants to write to me with her case, I'll happily make sure it's escalated.

01:08:44 - 01:08:46

Speaker 106

Final question, Dr Ellie Chowns.

01:08:46 - 01:09:16

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The next National Adaptation Plan, NAP4, is not due until 2028, but the wildfires and droughts we saw this summer, the impending extreme El Niño, show that we can't wait that long. Will the Minister commit to taking urgent action to tackle resilience before then and give our farmers, our communities, our householders the support they need to face the challenges of drought, wildfire and flood risk.

01:09:16 - 01:09:40

Daniel Owen Jarvis

Madam Deputy Speaker, I completely recognise the importance of the point that the honourable lady has made. She's made it previously. I can say to her that the government has established and tested response protocols in place for all severe weather events. The impact of each is often very different based on different factors, but I give her an assurance with the seriousness with which we take these issues, we're working across government to make sure that our response is proportionate to the nature of the threat that we face from climate change.

01:09:40 - 01:10:39

Eleanor Laing

That is the end of Cabinet Office questions, if the front bench wish to shuffle over. Colleagues are taking their time this morning. Before we come to the urgent question, I must say how disappointing it is that the government was not forthcoming with a proactive ministerial statement on this matter. The disruption to aviation and the impact on many constituents has been considerable. I hope the Minister and the Treasury front bench will pass that message on to the Secretary of State.

We come on to the urgent question on air traffic control.

01:10:39 - 01:10:53

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if she will make a statement on the failure of the United Kingdom's air traffic control system and the resulting disruption to flights and passengers.

01:10:53 - 01:13:28

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Thank you, and good morning, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I will ensure that the comments you have made are relayed. May I begin again by apologising to passengers across the United Kingdom who faced significant disruption as a result of the issues which impacted NATS's operation on the 8th of September, resulting in delays and cancellations for hundreds of thousands of passengers, as well as the disruption that it has caused for industry. Let me be clear that disruption of this kind is absolutely unacceptable. Now to provide some context to the House. At around lunchtime on the 8th of September, NATS experienced an issue with its flight processing system at its Swanwick centre affecting the data which was available to controllers.

The disruption had a significant impact across the UK aviation network, resulting in widespread delays, cancellations and diversions. NATS worked hard to fix this issue, but this took time as the systems needed to be tested to ensure that they had fully recovered and that operations could safely return to normal. My officials were in regular contact with NATS, airlines and airports during the incident to understand the issues impacting them and to offer government support, such as granting night flight alleviations to support recovery at regulated airports including Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted. NATS have confirmed it was a technical issue and do not believe it to be cyber-related. The Secretary of State and I met with Martin Rolfe yesterday and we've agreed that he will send a report to us by Wednesday the 16th of September, setting out the cause of the incident and the actions that are being taken to ensure that this cannot happen again.

The Secretary of State has also asked the CAA to conduct an independent review to establish cause and to ensure that our air traffic control systems can get passengers to where they need to be, with an update provided to me within six months. We will work closely with both organisations, airlines and airports to ensure that lessons are learned and that any necessary improvements are implemented. This morning I met with representatives from Unite the Union to hear directly about the impact of the incident on airport and airline staff and to discuss broader issues with them relating to the abuse of frontline transport workers. I would like to express mine and the Secretary of State's gratitude to all those staff at our airports and airlines who provided support to passengers whose journeys were disrupted over the past few days. And our sympathies remain with all of those passengers who have experienced delays or cancellations to their travel plans.

01:13:28 - 01:15:35

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over 2,000 flights cancelled, more than 150,000 passengers affected, delays, disruption, pain, embarrassment for Britain. What an absolute mess. And as you said, Madam Deputy Speaker, no offer of a statement from the government, hence this urgent question from these Conservative benches. Nothing sums the situation facing real people this week up better than Martin Brundle's scathing post on Tuesday, I quote: "9 hours and counting, sitting on a plane which has travelled nowhere, at a remote parking bay, no food throughout, and mothers and babies and a person with a medical condition desperate to get off, as everyone else is, toilets no longer available as blocked, no sign of steps or buses, and that's before the wait for luggage, pathetic and dangerous lack of corporate contingency and responsibility."

Is the minister not embarrassed? A report by the 16th of September, into recess, six months to then fully diagnose the problem, that's not good enough. A third failure deserves immediate action, not delaying tactics. The government has a considerable say in how NATS operates. Ministers cannot suddenly discover the virtues of arms-length government when something goes wrong in an organisation in which the taxpayer owns 49%.

Passengers have heard before that lessons will be learned, reviews commissioned and improvements made. They do not want another sorry story of apologies and assurances while everyone waits for the next failure. A cyberattack has been ruled out, so exactly what did happen? Was it a software failure? Were sufficient engineers available on site?

Were previous recommendations actually implemented, and if they were, why on earth are we back here again? And why are airlines and airports lacking suitable contingency plans when NATS fails, when government fails, but there is no government support on the ground? The Secretary of State needs to take responsibility, get a grip of this mess and make sure that this time, lessons are not simply learned, but acted upon.

01:15:35 - 01:17:53

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, I thank the shadow minister for his questions. He asks me for more detail about what exactly happened. Now that a cyberattack has been ruled out, the disruption was caused by a technical issue within NATS' Swanwick flight processing system. It affected the processing of flight plans used by data controllers. NATS have advised that the problem was affecting the flight processing system and the data that was being fed into controller radar displays.

A fix was implemented later in the day, but recovery took time as NATS needed to test that that system was safe. But he is right to raise the experience of Martin and so many other hundreds of thousands of passengers across the United Kingdom who were adversely affected. It raises really serious questions about contingency planning and resilience planning at our airports, conversations that I'm determined to take forward with the CAA, NATS, and with airlines and airports in the coming days. He criticizes the fact that it's going to take around a week to get this report back to us. It's incredibly important that we take the time to figure out exactly what's happened because ultimately this is about aviation safety.

This is about making sure that the UK can retain its reputation for passengers getting to where they need to go whilst protecting their safety. Also, the question was raised about it going into recess. I am happy to return after recess to answer any questions that you may have about that, honorable members may have about this issue. There is a broader question as well about the CAA being asked to conduct an urgent review into this and to report back within six months. I would remind them that after the largest recent outage in 2023, it took two and a half years for the CAA to fully assess the implications and all of the technical improvements and requirements that would be needed as a result of that incident.

They provided 34 recommendations and all of which have been implemented. A six-month timeframe to get to the bottom of what is a highly technical matter and an incident of disruption is proportionate, but it is also timely and it will allow us to react quickly with stringent ministerial oversight. So when the shadow minister asks ministers to take control of this situation, to exercise effective oversight on behalf of passengers, that is exactly what we are doing.

01:17:53 - 01:18:00

Eleanor Laing

Well, I've noted the minister's proactive commitment to a ministerial statement there. John McDonnell.

01:18:00 - 01:18:29

John Martin McDonnell

Can I thank the minister for his statement? NATS used to be in my constituency and then moved out to Swanwick. And of course with Heathrow in my constituency, as I mentioned yesterday, I'll receive a large number of correspondence from a whole range of constituents for other MPs who think I'm responsible for Heathrow Airport. But can I say that in the, I'm grateful. Can you control these, Mr. Speaker?

01:18:29 - 01:18:36

Speaker 111

Order. Mr. Gammel, I'll need you right. Well, that was very well done there. John McDonnell.

01:18:36 - 01:19:30

John Martin McDonnell

Okay, it's not a laughing matter. I'm sorry for interrupting the flow of the discussion that's taking place on that basis. But can I just say this, it would be useful in the review to look at the long-term investment plans of NATS, particularly since its partial privatization in 2001, which I opposed. But also, can I also thank him for meeting Unite this morning and thanking the workers who worked so hard? But can I also say, I understand from my experience of NATS when things have gone wrong, the PCS members in NATS itself, the technical members themselves, will have been scrambling, working incredibly hard to put this right.

And I hope we can thank them as well. And I say to the opposition spokesperson, he never made any reference today with regard to the workers themselves. They've worked incredibly hard. As the minister has said, some of them have experienced horrendous abuse and we should congratulate them and support them in their work.

01:19:30 - 01:19:32

Eleanor Laing

Minister.

01:19:32 - 01:20:27

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

May I thank the right honorable member for his constructive question?

I do think he is right to raise the question of NATS' resourcing, whether it is exactly where it needs to be to ensure that we have the capacity and the right people in the right places to deal with these issues when they arise. I am confident that the fantastic teams of people working at NATS responded with all possible haste and diligence to the disruption that was experienced, and I thank them for doing so. But he raises broader questions about NATS' resilience. Part of that is implementing the large-scale technological transformation programs that are required to ensure that our air traffic control systems are fit for purpose. And while more often than not the UK has a formidable reputation for aviation safety, that does not mean that when disruption like this occurs we must take a very cold hard look at NATS' processes and see where we can do better.

01:20:27 - 01:21:18

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I start by thanking the Speaker's office for granting this urgent question. And I join the Minister and the right honourable member for Hayes and Harlington for thanking airport, airline, and indeed air traffic control staff for handling this incident and helping passengers who experienced such very significant disruption. This is the third major incident in recent years to do with our air traffic control systems. So I'd like to ask the Minister whether the government should commit to fixing our air traffic control systems, given such poor passenger experiences and the poor management of the disruption and the customer service resulting from the disruption.

Should the government commit to doing that before it commits so enthusiastically to massive aviation expansion, which our current systems and processes may not be able to accommodate?

01:21:18 - 01:22:37

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

I thank the Lib Dem spokesperson for his questions. One factor that I would like to point out, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that more often than not our air traffic control systems and the individuals who work within them provide a safe and effective service for UK air passengers. In a typical year, NATS handles over two and a half million flights and around 300 million passengers travel over the UK and across the North Atlantic. We are responsible for a large proportion of European air traffic, and NATS does a good job to be able to make sure that UK passengers get to places safely. Incidents like this, though, and the fact that they have occurred three times within four years, do bring home the fact that when disruption does occur it is incredibly difficult for passengers and for our airlines and airports to adapt to.

So he is absolutely right to say that lessons must be learned. There are technical lessons that must be learned, and that is what we will get to the bottom of through the report from NATS and then from the six-month report from the CAA. But he is right to raise broader questions. And if we are to facilitate what this government wants to achieve, which is a program of ambitious expansion in our airport capacity, particularly in the southeast of England, we will do so with passenger safety at its heart, and oversight of NATS, effective oversight, must run to the core of that.

01:22:37 - 01:23:40

Speaker 132

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Minister for his answers today, and I'm sure he'll join with me in thanking the management and the staff of Manchester Airport who've worked overtime to minimize the disruption to passengers over the last couple of days. He will be as aware as I am that we could be in danger of playing regulatory whack-a-mole here. Three years on, less than three years on from the last disruption and the 34 recommendations, we have to begin to ask questions about why did those recommendations not cover the technical issue that we face today. And maybe that we begin to see that we need wider reform of both CAA, which I'm pleased to say is under new management since 2023, and NATS.

Because are we making the progress in vertical takeoff and landing, in drone technology at pace? We've seen progress this year in Scottish airspace in the upper echelons, but we have seen Manchester airspace and the northern airspace stuck in neutral since. These organizations need to get on and show the vision that we remain a world-class aviation sector in the world.

01:23:40 - 01:24:38

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, let me thank my honourable friend and my predecessor in this role for all of his work in holding the CAA and NATS to account and managing some of those difficult conversations that came out of other disruptions that we have seen. He raises a valid point that those recommendations were passed through by the CAA to be implemented and have been so in full, and yet we have seen this disruption. Part of that is us working with the CAA to encourage NATS to work with NATS to go further, faster in some of the technological innovations and transformations which he describes. But he is right to say that this should be a useful opportunity, despite the negativity of the situation, to ask ourselves questions about where we can encourage NATS to go further, push the boundaries in terms of regulatory innovation in some of the issues he spoke about in terms of eVTOL and drones, but also to learn the lessons from this incident and think about how they can build greater depth of resilience across our UK aviation sector.

01:24:38 - 01:25:41

Paul Holmes

Madam Deputy Speaker, NATS falls within my constituency in Swanwick. Could I place on record my thanks and dedication to the staff of NATS, who I've seen work day in, day out to make our our skies safer, and also the work of 78 Squadron Royal Air Force on the same site. I must just ask the Minister to have a look seriously at that six-month timescale for the CAA review and just ask him to commit to the full transparency to make sure that those lessons learned are not only held within the DfT but also to this wider Parliament. But also in the topsy-turvy world in which we live, Madam Deputy Speaker, I find myself in agreement with the right honourable gentleman for Hayes and Harlington in asking the Minister to seriously look at, with the management of NATS, those long-term investment plans to make sure that after the third time of this happening in as many years, that those investment plans are there to make sure that this doesn't happen again and that the management of NATS cannot blame lack of investment for the system's failure.

01:25:41 - 01:26:37

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Let me thank the honourable member for his work both representing the staff at NATS, which he does so admirably, but also for his constructive questions on this issue. I do believe that six months is the right timeframe to report back because it allows us to effectively learn the lessons and get to the bottom of what is ultimately a highly technical matter. But he is right to say that Parliament must be involved in engaging with what the lessons learned are. It's also important that we think about the connection between this incident and legislation currently moving through the House. The Civil Aviation Bill will give us new powers both to give the CAA the ability to set aviation safety rules, but also for air passenger rights to be enhanced and for consumer rights to be enforced directly by the CAA.

Parliament must have its say in thinking about how lessons we can learn from this incident can inform how we can use the bill to practically improve the travelling experience of passengers up and down the country.

01:26:37 - 01:26:57

Speaker 120

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Minister for his statement and his leadership of this incident. NATS have apologised rightly unreservedly for this Swanwick incident which affected infuriatingly hundreds of thousands of travellers. Might the Minister join me in thanking the staff of NATS in Prestwick in my constituency for their support for the management of this incident.

01:26:57 - 01:27:31

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

I thank my honourable friend for giving me the opportunity to thank the NATS staff at Prestwick but across the United Kingdom for the incredible work that they do. NATS will come under a lot of scrutiny in coming days and weeks, and rightly so, because we expect them to maintain a system of air traffic control that keeps the British public safe. But I am resolute in my belief that all the staff at NATS responded with all of the haste and diligence that we would expect to protect passengers and to ensure that they could restart aviation in a way that was safe, and ultimately that is what we expect of them.

01:27:31 - 01:28:07

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is clearly a very unfortunate incident, and full transparency is essential. Does the Minister have a view on what the overall cost of this was to the UK economy? If the Government doesn't have that at the moment, would he update the House separately? And what plans does the Government have to work with industry to compensate passengers who were affected?

Because there will have been all manner of costs borne by those who were unable to fly, and I'm sure that these probably run collectively into the millions of pounds.

01:28:07 - 01:29:00

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

I thank him for his question, and while I am not in a position currently to give him a pounds and pence figure about what the economic impact is, I am under no illusion that it is incredibly significant. And therefore we need to learn the lessons from what has happened to ensure that we can minimize the chance of disruption of this kind ever happening again. He asks me a broader question about compensation or refunds for passengers. Passengers whose flights have been cancelled are entitled to assistance from their airlines, including either a refund within seven days or a rerouting to their destination, including on another airline where that is appropriate. Passengers may also be entitled to care and assistance while waiting for a delayed or rerouted flight, but there are of course lots of instances we have seen of airport capacity not being able to deal with the number of passengers who are disrupted, and I think that is a key lesson that we have to learn from this incident.

01:29:00 - 01:29:01

Daniel Francis.

01:29:01 - 01:29:27

Daniel Francis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Minister for his statement and echo those thanks to those staff who've been working to overcome the incident. Yesterday the Civil Aviation Bill passed its second reading, but will the Minister commit as part of the review and as part of that bill to look at how our most vulnerable passengers, particularly wheelchair users, blind and partially sighted passengers caught up in incidents like this can be supported when these incidents occur?

01:29:27 - 01:30:07

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, let me thank my honorable friend for his determined advocacy for passengers with disabilities both within our aviation sector and the wider UK transport system. He is right that through the Civil Aviation Bill we include the ability for the Secretary of State to conduct a review in how to enhance air passenger rights, particularly for those who can face the most acute forms of disruption while traveling, including people with disabilities but also those with other protected characteristics. I think we need to have a cold, hard look at how some of the most vulnerable people in society are affected by disruption of this nature and think about how we can strengthen our air passenger rights regime to respond effectively.

01:30:07 - 01:30:09

Eleanor Laing

Do you need medical assistance, Alex Shelbrooke?

01:30:09 - 01:30:48

Alec Edward Shelbrooke

I'm okay, Madam Deputy Speaker, I will struggle on. Thank you very much. The Minister has outlined that there is an investment program for technology and upgrades, but one of the concerns that always exists, especially in software upgrades, is that the premise of the programs keep getting changed. That can bring in delay, that can bring bugs to a system. So can I ask, does the Minister have an oversight to make sure that the plans which were put in place to say this is what needed to be done don't keep getting sidetracked by people deciding that this is a bit more shiny, we should do that, delaying the whole thing and being left with, quite frankly, what is looking to be more and more an antiquated system?

01:30:48 - 01:31:32

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, let me reassure my honorable friend and neighbor that we do have a system of prioritizing what we feel as a department is most important through the CAA and down to NATS. The Secretary of State puts together a priorities letter which sets out very clearly what her expectations are when it comes to our air traffic control system, and chief among them when this was last done so was around technological transformation to ensure that our systems are resilient. That recommendation is more pressing than ever given what we have seen, and the Secretary of State and I will both reaffirm that in our subsequent meetings to come with NATS and the CAA because this incident teaches us that that technological change should be completed with all possible haste.

01:31:32 - 01:31:33

Chris Bloore.

01:31:33 - 01:31:55

Speaker 128

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and can I thank the Minister for his statement and all the work he's doing to get this situation resolved. Unfortunately some of my Redditch residents were impacted yesterday due to the cancellations. And would the Minister assure me that he is reminding airlines that particularly those customers that have been stranded far from home that they have a continued duty of care to get those people home as quickly as possible.

01:31:55 - 01:32:26

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Minister. Let me thank my honourable friend and of course we are in close dialogue with both airlines and airports reminding them about what needs to be carried out in regard to protecting the welfare of their passengers. But might I also say that I think actually both airline and airport staff and the companies themselves across the country are endeavouring to do the right thing by their passengers who are facing this disruption. The Department needs to make sure that it is doing its bit as well and we will of course never be shy in fighting for passengers and their rights.

01:32:26 - 01:32:28

Eleanor Laing

Christine Jardine.

01:32:28 - 01:33:23

Christine Jardine

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker and apologies for the earlier slip. Can I echo the comments made about the fantastic job done in safeguarding the British public by the staff at NATS. Just recently I visited the air traffic control in our control tower at Edinburgh Airport and saw first hand the amount of work that goes into keeping the public safe. But I am also acutely aware through the airport that there is a dissatisfaction with the delays in the new airspace management program. We haven't made progress in Scotland.

In fact we fear that it's going to be put aside for yet another year. And this all feeds into a lack of confidence in the British public and air passengers in our transport system. So can the Minister assure me please that steps are going to be taken to speed up the management and ensure that our air passengers get the improved system that they deserve.

01:33:23 - 01:34:01

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Minister. Well let me thank the honourable lady for her challenge. She is right to say that both Glasgow and Edinburgh airports have got ambitious programs of airspace redesign underway and I would like to reassure her that the Department is committed to working productively with them to ensure that they can realise those airspace change proposals as quickly as is possible. Doing so will help us make our flights more efficient. It will reduce carbon burn.

It will stop planes idling when they don't need to be and hopefully minimise noise. Scotland is well ahead of other areas in that space and we need to give them all possible tools to be able to deliver that important work.

01:34:01 - 01:34:03

Eleanor Laing

Bambos Charalambous.

01:34:03 - 01:34:19

Charalambos Charalambous

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Many passengers and indeed their families across the country will still be wondering whether the disruptions caused by the incident have been fully cleared. Would the Minister confirm what's the current situation and when he expects airports to return back to the excellent service they generally provide.

01:34:19 - 01:35:06

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Minister. Well the honourable member is right to point out the fact that the issue that caused this initial disruption was fixed as quickly as possible by NATS. But a number of hours subsequently went by because they needed to ensure that the system was stable when it was rebooted and that flights could return to the air safely. And that is the most important consideration that NATS has to make when facing disruption of this kind. I can confirm to him that the congestion that we've seen despite the fact that lots of planes were out of place and needed to be rerouted has largely passed through.

It's now to the Department for Transport, NATS and the CAA to work practically together to make sure that any following congestion is minimised and that the British public can carry on flying to where they need to go.

01:35:06 - 01:35:08

Eleanor Laing

Simon Hoare.

01:35:08 - 01:35:45

Simon Hoare

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Against the backdrop of reality that things go wrong no matter how much money is invested and how up to date things just go wrong. It does seem slightly ludicrous does it not that NATS have put all of their eggs into one particular basket and there is no shadow or backup or secondary scheme that can be used. It may not be as good as the main one but which would minimise or certainly attenuate against the scale of disruption that we have seen. Is that in the Minister's thinking just to have more eggs in more baskets rather than just reliance on one particular bit of software.

01:35:45 - 01:36:22

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, let me thank him for his question. The Secretary of State said from the dispatch box yesterday that she is of the view that while this disruption was not foreseen, it was not avoidable and that there are lessons to learn about how we can minimize the chances of it recurring in the future. And he is right to point to the fact that resilience is clearly not where it needs to be. We need our technological systems to be more adaptive and more reactive. That is exactly why the Secretary of State has said that technological change needs to be at the forefront of the CAA and NATS's priorities.

Minister.

And as part of that, agility and resilience within the system needs to be one of their top considerations.

01:36:22 - 01:36:55

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As you'll be aware, this issue has had a huge impact on my constituency of Harlow. Not only do many passengers use Stansted Airport, there are over a thousand staff members at Stansted Airport who live in my Harlow constituency. I have full faith in the minister and his ability to lead on this issue, but can he reassure them that he is doing everything he can to hold the leadership of NATS to account to ensure this doesn't happen again? And as the previous speaker said, even if something like this does happen again, there are contingency plans in place.

01:36:55 - 01:37:23

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Let me thank him for his question. The Transport Secretary and I met Martin Rolfe on Wednesday. We expressed our concern at the scale of disruption on behalf of passengers and industry. The Transport Secretary's asked for the cause of the issue to be identified and addressed as quickly as possible. That scrutiny, both of the leadership of NATS but also those technological programs and processes, is critically important and something the department will keep at the forefront of our minds in the days and weeks to come.

01:37:23 - 01:37:54

Christopher Chope

Does the minister agree that that incident and the other ones that preceded it are a threat to national security? Because as my honorable friend from Hamble Valley said, there are more than a hundred RAF personnel actually staged at Swanwick and they are involved in protecting our national interest and our defense. The honorable member, the minister, has not yet addressed the security threat to our country posed by this incompetence.

01:37:54 - 01:38:34

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, allow me to reassure the honorable member that the civil aviation air traffic control systems and those used by the military and the Ministry of Defence are separate. But he is right to say that our air traffic control for civil aviation is a foundation of both the resilience of our aviation sector but also the enormous amount of economic growth that is dependent upon our aviation sector functioning effectively, whether that be through air freight, the movement of business travelers to where they need to go, or facilitating the UK tourism industry. That's why it's so important that lessons are learned from this incident to think about how we can minimize impacts on our national resilience in the future.

01:38:34 - 01:39:05

Liz Jarvis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. NATS is a significant local employer for my constituents in Eastleigh and I want to put on record my thanks to the engineers and controllers who worked hard to restore the system and keep passengers safe. But this is the third such collapse in three years and all employees who work for NATS and the airports, airlines, and passengers who rely on it deserve better. So what steps is the minister taking to ensure a genuinely effective backup system is in place so we are not back here again in another two years?

01:39:05 - 01:39:51

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, let me thank the honorable lady for her work to represent her constituents who are employees of NATS and let me use this opportunity again to thank them for the hard work that they do. But she is right to say that resilience in those systems is not currently where we need it to be. We never want disruption of this kind to occur, but when it does, we need to use it as a productive lesson to learn about how we can strengthen those systems to ensure that when things do go wrong, they are restored as quickly as possible. I am confident that NATS in responding to this incident did so in the shortest possible timeframe in which they could still ensure that safety was paramount in aircraft both arriving and departing. But there are lessons to be learned about what contingency plans need to be put in place in the future and we will endeavor to learn them.

01:39:51 - 01:40:11

Desmond Swayne

Just how confident is he that it wasn't a cyberattack? How confident is he of the resilience of the system in the event of such an attack? How confident is he in the willingness and ability of the government to retaliate in the event of such an attack as the best form of deterrence?

01:40:11 - 01:40:46

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Questions of retaliation to cyberattacks, as he will know, are not appropriate matters to be discussing across the dispatch box. But he also raises a critically important point about our overall resilience and ability to defend against cyberattacks when they do occur. While NATS have confirmed that this was a technical issue, they do not believe it to be cyber-related. I can reassure him that both the CAA, NATS, and DfT and transport providers work very closely together to defend against cybersecurity attacks from our adversaries or any other threats as they may emerge.

01:40:46 - 01:41:06

Robin Swann

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Any disruption to the aviation has an adverse impact on travellers coming from Northern Ireland. Can I ask the Minister just to give that reassurance when he speaks of contingency and resilience, that he does include the Northern Ireland airports, Aldergrove Airport in my own constituency and Belfast City Airport as well?

01:41:06 - 01:41:29

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Aviation connectivity is perhaps nowhere more important than from Northern Ireland to the rest of the United Kingdom. It's both an economic and a social lifeline, and I'm very cognizant of that. I can reassure him that retaining that resilience is of the utmost importance to me from Northern Ireland to the UK mainland, and I would be glad to speak with him about this issue further to think about how we can strengthen those aviation links in the future.

01:41:29 - 01:42:11

Bob Blackman

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many of my constituents actually work at Heathrow Airport. They've had to work extra hours, as the honourable member for Hayes and Harlington mentioned, and they've suffered abuse as well. So I put on record my appreciation for all that they've done. Even more of my constituents, of course, use Heathrow for business travel and social travel.

And some will have insurance, others will not. And I wonder what advice the department is giving to those people that have been affected on claiming compensation and potentially alternative opportunities for them to travel. Has he set up a hotline, for example, whereby people can phone in and get advice immediately?

01:42:11 - 01:42:54

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, let me just say to him quickly that if he has constituents who are experiencing particularly thorny issues in regard to engaging with airlines to get the support that they need, he is welcome to raise them with me. Passengers whose flights have been cancelled are entitled to assistance from their airlines, including either a refund within seven days or rerouting to their destination. The CAA has published guidance on its website stating that delays and cancellations caused by the NATS technical incident are likely to be considered extraordinary circumstances because they are beyond airlines' control. That being said, we will think about how we can work with a range of actors, including the airports and airlines themselves, to get the right information to passengers to ensure that they can access the support that they need.

01:42:54 - 01:42:56

Speaker 124

Joshua Reynolds.

01:42:56 - 01:43:18

Joshua Peter Reynolds

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. A constituent of mine has contacted me to say that their shift at an airport was cancelled yesterday due to the problems with the air traffic control system. They were told to not come into work, but they were also told to not expect pay for that day's shift that they missed. Will the Minister confirm to me that he expects all workers who were due to work at airports yesterday to get paid for that shift regardless?

01:43:18 - 01:43:33

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, let me use this as an opportunity to restate my thanks to workers across UK airports who've responded to this disruption. I'm concerned to hear about the case that the honourable member raises, and if he would write to me with more detail, I can assure that the appropriate action is taken.

01:43:33 - 01:43:35

Eleanor Laing

Final question, Jim Shannon.

01:43:35 - 01:44:21

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank the Minister for those answers. Three times in three years. Normally the third strike you're out, and the chief executive of course gets an £871,000 bonus instead. For people in Northern Ireland, a flight to Great Britain is a basic utility. When the NATS system crashed, my constituents are entirely cut off.

So what specific resilience measures is the Minister's department implementing to guarantee that Northern Ireland air bridges are prioritized during system recoveries? And hardworking families in my constituency this week who suffered are told they won't get a penny of compensation because NATS' failure counts as an extraordinary circumstance. If the system is avoidable, then why on earth are passengers carrying the financial burden while NATS avoid accountability?

01:44:21 - 01:45:22

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Well, that is a very fair challenge from the honorable member, and I would say that our response to ensure that his constituents get the protections that they need are threefold. Firstly, we need to learn the lessons of what has happened, the nature of the technical fault, and to fix it to minimize the chance of it ever happening again. Secondly, there is a broader resilience question around air connectivity from Northern Ireland, and I would like to work with him and other honorable members to think about how that can be strengthened further, but I would reassure him that resilience work on that matter is widespread across the Department for Transport and is at the forefront of our minds. And thirdly, there is the question of residents of Northern Ireland being able to benefit from the measures included within the Civil Aviation Bill, specifically designed to strengthen consumer protections, to enhance air passenger rights, and to make more streamlined the system of aviation safety that we have in this country. I would look forward to working with him and other honorable members on those important issues.

01:45:22 - 01:45:34

Eleanor Laing

The end of the urgent question, air traffic control disruption. If the front bench wish to shuffle over very quickly. We now come to business questions and Deputy Shadow Leader, John Lamont.

01:45:34 - 01:45:38

John Lamont

Thank you very much. Will the Leader of the House give us the forthcoming business of the House?

01:45:38 - 01:48:47

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The business for the week commencing the 14th of September will include Monday the 14th of September, consideration of an allocation of time motion followed by all stages of the Sovereign Grant Bill, followed by motions to approve recommendations by the Modernization Committee and Committee of Privileges and changes to standing orders following machinery of government changes, followed by a general debate on Israel and Palestine. Tuesday the 15th of September, a general debate on the potential merits of a full ban on fracking, followed by a general debate on World Sepsis Awareness Month, the subjects for these debates determined by the Backbench Business Committee. The House will then rise for the conference recess at the conclusion of business on Tuesday the 15th of September and return on Monday the 12th of October. The business for the week commencing the 12th of October will include Monday the 12th of October, a general debate on Baby Loss Awareness Week, the subject for this debate determined by the Backbench Business Committee.

Tuesday the 13th of October, remaining stages of the Courts and Tribunals Bill, followed by consideration of a carryover motion relating to the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill. Wednesday the 14th of October, opposition day, an official opposition day, subject yet to be announced. Thursday the 15th of October, second reading of the Highways Financing Bill, followed and Friday the 16th of October, private members' bills. And the provisional business for the week commencing the 19th of October includes Monday the 19th of October, Committee of the whole House of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill day one. On Tuesday the 20th of October, conclusion of Committee and remaining stages of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill.

Members may also wish to know, Madam Deputy Speaker, that subject to the progress of business, the House will rise for the November recess at the close of business on Wednesday the 4th of November and return on Tuesday the 10th of November. The House will rise for the Christmas recess at the close of business on Thursday the 17th of December and will now return on Tuesday the 5th of January 2027. The House will rise for the February recess at the close of business on Thursday the 11th of February 2027 and return on Monday the 22nd of February. The House will rise for the Easter recess at the close of business on Thursday the 25th of March and return on Monday the 12th of April. The House will rise for the May bank holiday recess at the close of business on Thursday the 29th of April and return on Tuesday the 4th of May.

The House will rise for the Whitsun recess at the close of business on Thursday the 27th of May and return on Monday the 7th of June. And the House will rise for the summer recess at the close of business on Thursday the 22nd of July.

01:48:47 - 01:48:48

Deputy Shadow Leader.

01:48:48 - 01:52:57

John Lamont

Thank you very much, I'm grateful to the Leader for outlining the business and of course the recess dates, it's always good to look forward to the next recess. Tomorrow marks the 25th anniversary of the appalling terrorist attacks on the United States. We remember the thousands of innocent people who went to work that morning, boarded aircraft, or reported for duty in the emergency services and never returned home. We remember their families and all those whose lives were changed forever. Earlier this year, I had the privilege of visiting the 9/11 Memorial in New York.

Standing where the Twin Towers once stood is an incredibly moving experience and a powerful reminder of both the terrible events of that day and the courage and resilience that followed them. A quarter of a century on, we should never forget the victims, nor should we ever waver in our determination to confront terrorism and defend the freedoms and values that those responsible sought to attack. Madam Deputy Speaker, perhaps I can now turn to matters closer to home. The Leader has announced that the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill will be rushed through the House over a couple of days in October with no separate report stage. This is very little time to consider such a complex bill, particularly as the Government is reported to be preparing to table over a hundred amendments.

I therefore ask the Leader of the House if he will ensure that the Government amendments are tabled before the House rises on Tuesday and will he explain why the Government is not providing a separate report stage. There seems to be growing chatter on the Government benches about an early general election, with some apparently wondering whether the new Prime Minister might even go to the country before Christmas. Well, the Leader of the House is of course a man right at the heart of the Government decision-making and will know better than most what is being discussed in Downing Street. So for the benefit of an increasingly nervous Labour backbench today, can he give the House a simple assurance: will this Parliament run its full course, or will the new Prime Minister already be running away from difficult decisions? Madam Deputy Speaker, turning to Scotland, last week the SNP Government published its latest programme for government.

After nearly two decades in power, Scotland was promised renewal. Instead, as Russell Findlay put it, we got more meddling and gimmicks, more centralisation, more bureaucracy, and yet more attempts to distract from the SNP's dire record in office.

This was in full display when the PISA school results were published recently showing Scotland's once world-class education system is now considered to be just average. Of particular concern to my constituents is the extraordinary proposal by the SNP government to abolish Scotland's 14 territorial health boards and replace them with just two. This means the abolition of NHS Borders as we know it. People in my constituency in the Scottish Borders have already experienced the consequences of SNP centralisation with Police Scotland and the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service. They do not want vital healthcare decisions taken away, taken further away from the communities those services exist to serve.

So will the Leader of the House join me in paying tribute to the hardworking staff in NHS Borders and call on an increasingly centralising SNP government not to forget rural and remote communities in Scotland? Finally, farming is the backbone of communities across Borders, across the border and across rural Britain. Despite the enormous concern expressed by farmers and farming businesses, Labour's family farm tax is now in force. So ahead of the budget next month, will the Leader of the House convey a very simple message to the Chancellor: listen to our farmers, recognise the damage that this tax is doing to confidence and succession planning, and finally do the right thing, scrap the family farm tax.

01:52:57 - 01:58:36

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank the Shadow Deputy Leader for his remarks. Before I turn to his specific questions, can I remind the House that today is World Suicide Prevention Day. And when someone takes their own life, the impact on family and friends is devastating and widespread. And today is an opportunity for all of us to unite behind one clear, unambiguous message: that suicides are preventable.

And I want to place on record my sincere thanks to the many community groups and charities across the country who offer compassionate, life-saving support to those affected. And I'm very grateful to my honourable friend the Member for Blaydon and Consett for her thoughtful contribution in leading the Westminster Hall debate on this matter on Tuesday. This government is firmly committed to tackling suicide, and new mental health hubs and emergency centres announced over the summer represent a crucial step forward in delivering early community-based support. Madam Deputy Speaker, as the Shadow Deputy Leader said, tomorrow marks the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 terrorist attacks. And I too have seen the site of the attacks, and it is a harrowing reminder.

We remember the 2,977 innocent lives lost, including 67 British citizens, and the countless families whose lives were forever changed. We pay tribute to the extraordinary bravery of the first responders, the firefighters, the police officers, and the medical personnel who risked and sacrificed their lives running towards the danger in order to save others. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's been an important week for government announcements. On Tuesday, the Foreign Secretary set out our response to illegal settlements in the Palestinian territories. The government has announced targeted sanctions, introduced an important ban on goods originating from illegal settlements, and taking action against companies and individuals providing services, infrastructure, or finance for settlement expansion.

And as we have made clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, these settlements are illegal and the occupation of Palestinian territories is unlawful. The Chancellor also set out this week how the government will make Great Britain Growth Britain again, which will, we will drive devolution, provide more public leadership and control, more investment, more innovation, and more jobs.

And there will be growth, Madam Deputy Speaker, in every postcode. Let me now turn to the remarks of the shadow deputy leader on the Northern Ireland Bill, which I've just announced we will be taking shortly after the conference recess. I haven't announced two days on the floor of the House for the committee stage and also remaining stages. It is often the case when matters are dealt with on the floor of the House that the report stage is either unnecessary or there isn't a great deal of time which is necessary. But I take away what he says, and I also take away what he says about making sure that the amendments are timely.

Because, Madam Deputy Speaker, we want to go further at the committee stage with a substantial package of amendments safeguarding our Operation Banner veterans. None of these protections were included in previous legislation, which instead left our veterans in legal limbo. So I do take into account what he said, but we're not going to take any lessons from the party opposite. He talks about chatter about an early general election. If there is any, it's on the other side.

And I would just say to the, I would just say, I would just say to the other side of the House, be careful what you wish for. As the Prime Minister has made clear, he has no intention to call an early general election because there is an important job to do. He is determined to get on with that job. I think he's made a fantastic start, and he intends to continue to do everything that we can to make our country a better place to live and work in again. He talks about the situation in north of the border and mentioned Scottish education.

I remember when Scottish education was the model for education not just in the United Kingdom but often around the world as well. And all I would say on this matter is that the lack of ambition which appears to be north of the border from the current government is in stark contrast to the ambition that we have for every young person this side of the border. And I am happy, I am happy to pay tribute to NHS staff in his area, as I would do NHS staff everywhere else. But I think, and I would agree with him, I think this Prime Minister and this new administration is very clear that we believe that devolution is the way forward, decisions made locally where they affect people is the way forward rather than centralization. And therefore I do agree with what the shadow deputy leader has said.

And as far as farming is concerned, I'm not going to comment obviously on anything that might be or might not be in the budget, but I would simply point out that we are supporting farming, not least with the sixty-five million pounds extra that we provided.

01:58:37 - 01:59:30

Liz Twist

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank the Leader of the House for his comment about World Suicide Prevention Day. But I would like to ask another question. In the UK, someone takes their own life every ninety minutes, the length of a football match. Now, as you said, today marks World Suicide Prevention Day, and partnerships like the Premier League and Samaritans Together Against Suicide initiative show how sport can break stigma and save lives.

Will the Leader of the House join me in welcoming this campaign and set out how the government is supporting community-led suicide prevention across the country?

And will he allow a debate in government time on suicide prevention?

01:59:30 - 02:00:40

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, and as I said in my opening remarks, I'm very grateful to my honourable friend as ever, not just for her question, but for her continued contribution on these matters. And it's really important that she continues to raise them. I do want to place on record my sincere thanks to the many community groups and charities across the country who offer compassionate life-saving support to those affected. And I agree with her absolutely that organisations like the Premier League in playing a role do draw attention, very welcome attention, to what needs to be done. And I thank them very much for that.

The government remains committed to tackling suicide, which is why, as I said, we announced new mental health hubs and emergency centres, because it's important that we try to prevent as many unnecessary deaths as possible. I would suggest to her that should she seek, either through the Backbench Business Committee or a Westminster Hall debate, a further debate on these matters, then she will have heard from the murmurs across the chamber that there are a lot of people who share her concern.

02:00:40 - 02:03:09

Wendy Chamberlain

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I echo the comments made in relation to the September 11th attacks anniversary. Nearly 25 years ago, my husband and I visited the site of the Twin Towers in the April after the attacks. We were both police officers at that time and realising that we and our colleagues would have gone to face the same dangers as others had done so really did bring home the scale of the sacrifice made. And having attended a debate on confidence in policing yesterday, I know how important trust in policing is.

But Madam Deputy Speaker, Reform UK's disdain for British electoral law was broadcast to the nation last week in undercover footage involving the honourable member for Clacton, who I have emailed, and some of his closest advisers. The Metropolitan Police was of course already investigating Reform UK and it has now confirmed it is broadening its inquiry to include foreign donations involving polling. And I find it ironic that a party that stakes so much of its reputation on claims of patriotism spends far more time trying to get around British law than it does in strengthening it. So I wonder if Reform MPs will share with the country whether they and their campaigns have ever benefited from any foreign money. And I would also reiterate the calls I made over recess for Reform's Home Affairs spokesperson to provide evidence for the damaging claims he made online against a business in my North East Fife constituency.

Several weeks on, we and I are still waiting. We're living in an unstable world, Madam Deputy Speaker, where dodgy donations are routine and corruption is common. Bad actors like Elon Musk, Vladimir Putin, and Reform pin-up boy Donald Trump are dedicated to destroying our democracy. The government and all parliamentarians should be standing up against these threats. And again, for a party so keen to ensure relationships with our nearest neighbours, they seem happy to jeopardise our sovereignty by encouraging foreign interference.

But Madam Deputy Speaker, the Representation of the People Bill that passed through the Commons last week did not include a donation cap and therefore failed to protect our political system from the corrupting influence of foreign money. Given the bill was debated before MPs were aware of these concerning allegations, will the government provide time to legislate to protect British democracy?

02:03:09 - 02:04:04

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, let me join the honourable lady in her remarks about the bravery of New York police officers 25 years ago in running towards danger. And I want to be absolutely clear, I think that in a terrible situation where something similar happened in this country, that is what our police officers would do as well.

Fantastic servants of our community and indeed our nation. She talks about donations and we'll have to see how the current crisis for reform plays out. She's right that we have had representation of the People's Bill in this place, but of course there will be an opportunity to look at some of these matters again in another place. But as we look at making the long-term changes that are necessary as well to clean up our politics, then there will be future opportunities for legislation as this government continues to get on with the job.

If you're content with your seat now, Lee Pitcher.

02:04:04 - 02:04:32

Lee Pitcher

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and apologies for moving around the chamber. May I first congratulate Merv Johnson, who has been shortlisted for an award in recognition of the countless hours he gives to Outcasts Cricket Club, keeping its ground in fantastic condition throughout the season. Volunteers like Merv are the backbone of grassroots sport, but their dedication depends on clubs having somewhere to play. Will the Leader set out how he will support clubs going forwards?

02:04:32 - 02:05:00

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Absolutely join my honourable friend in congratulating Merv Johnson for his hard work at the Outcasts Cricket Club. This government is committed to ensuring that everyone benefits from quality sport and physical activity opportunities in their local area. We're investing at least 400 million pounds over the next four years to provide communities with the sports facilities that they need, and that includes 3 million pounds through the England and Wales Cricket Board this financial year.

02:05:00 - 02:08:12

Bob Blackman

Chair of the Backbench Business Committee, Bob Blackman.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Leader for announcing the business. Since the changes, we've been inundated with requests from the select committees to have statements in the House, which I welcome. So Tuesday, there'll be select committee statements on the Treasury Committee report and the Public Accounts Committee reports before the two debates that we've scheduled. I know that the Leader will share my concern about the first day back being the debate on baby loss awareness week, following what happened last year when, because of government statements, the debate took place late at night and it was very difficult, I think, for many members to contribute. We thought long and hard before we allocated this.

We approached the sponsors of the debate and they were insistent that they wanted the debate on the first day back. So I hope that the Leader will once again provide protected time and that he will prevail on his colleagues not to have too many statements from the government so we can have a reasonable debate on the subject. There are, in addition, Madam Deputy Speaker, another five potential select committee statements that are going to come forward in the next few weeks, which I once again, as I welcome. Indeed, if we are offered the 22nd of October, we have potential debates as well ready to go. On, in Westminster Hall, on Tuesday, there'll be a debate on building safety remediation of residential buildings.

And on the 13th of October, Tuesday the 13th, a debate on future of the UK coach industry. On the 22nd of October, there'll be a select committee statement from the Joint Committee on Human Rights, followed by a debate on support for unpaid carers, followed by a debate on the progress towards a smoke-free UK. On Tuesday the 20th of October, there'll be a debate on manufacturing skills, and on Thursday the 22nd, a debate on compensation for Equitable Life policyholders. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm sure that the whole House will recognise the importance of hospital radio across the country. The hospital radio gives great comfort to patients, both the music, the discussions, the news, particularly when people are suffering in hospital.

I'm pleased to say that next month, before we come back, Radio Brockley, which operates in my constituency at the Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital, will be celebrating its 60th anniversary. It is the longest running hospital radio station in London. And indeed, we have volunteers who've served for more than 40 years giving their service to that hospital. So I'm sure the Leader will join me in congratulating Radio Brockley on this wonderful anniversary. And possibly we could have a statement in government time on the importance of hospital radio on the health service and the benefits it brings to patients and staff.

02:08:12 - 02:09:57

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I thank the honourable gentleman for what he's told the House today, but also for his ongoing work as chair of the Backbench Business Committee. He is right that the baby loss debate is scheduled for the first day back. He will know that the way in which this happened last time concerned me greatly, and which is why we did wonder whether or not it could be perhaps taken another time, but that's not turned out to be the case, so it will be on the first Monday that we get back. And he talks about two things. The first is protected time, and I will certainly, I've already thought about that, and I will certainly give that some further thought, and I hope that we can get to that place.

But I have to say to him that that might be a bit of a mixed blessing unless we have real discipline on that day, and some of that discipline, I'm careful how I say this, is not entirely in my hands. But what is to some extent in our hands, in the government hands, is the number of statements that we have. We're coming back from conference, I would expect there to be announcements over the recess, and therefore I would expect statements. But I'll do everything that I can to make sure that there is not just time for that debate, but an appropriate time for that debate, because there are so many parents and families who come down for that, that they deserve the best that we can provide. I join with him in thanking everyone involved in hospital radio across the country, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I agree with him about the importance, and particularly congratulate Radio Brockley on their 60th anniversary. That's a remarkable achievement, so well done to them, and thank you to all the volunteers, not just now, but all of those who've volunteered in the past.

02:09:57 - 02:10:06

Speaker 143

Right, we've got many, many colleagues to get through. I can see people's bits of paper with far too many sentences on. Cross them out, one sentence. Sharon Hodgson.

02:10:06 - 02:10:32

Sharon Hodgson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'll be very brief. Next Thursday is World Patient Safety Day. As the landmark Cumberlege Review confirmed, patients, and particularly women, have had their concerns dismissed and denied for far too long. As the co-chair of the All-Party Group on First Do No Harm, can I ask the Leader of the House if he will grant a debate in government time on when the government will respond to the excellent Hughes report?

02:10:32 - 02:10:59

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We recognise the profound life-changing impact that these harms have on individuals and on their families. As she will know, we are carefully considering the Hughes report. She talks about an opportunity to debate this, but first of all, I will seek an update from ministers for her to see whether or not we can need to make further progress on this really important matter.

02:10:59 - 02:11:37

Nigel Huddleston

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, as you know, I love to do everything I can to support our pubs and hospitality industry, and I do mean everything. And of course, I'm very pleased to represent an area of the country with many fantastic pubs, many of whom are participating in my current Pub of the Year competition, and voting is open now. Can we have a debate in government time about the important role of our hospitality industry in our local communities?

And can I invite the leader of the house, you Madam Deputy Speaker, in fact everybody to the winner of my pub of the year competition, whoever it may be. I didn't promise to pay for every pint, but we'll see how we go.

02:11:37 - 02:12:21

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed. Should the, should the honourable gentleman seek a debate on this, this matter, perhaps in a Westminster Hall debate, I'm sure others will, will join him to talk about the importance of pubs in their area and it will allow the ministers to talk about the cut to business rates for pubs that this, this Prime Minister has already insisted on. I will certainly give careful thought. This is the second time that we've been invited out together. Well, couple is not necessarily the word I would use at this point, but it is, it's interesting that people are reading into this perhaps more than is the case.

But I'll certainly bear that in mind, but I wish all the pubs all the very best and it's fantastic that the honourable gentleman is having that competition.

02:12:21 - 02:12:47

Euan Stainbank

I don't think I've been publicly invited and dismissed from a date in one sitting. Euan Stainbank.

HGV drivers such as my constituent Peter Cunningham are vital to Falkirk's local economy. DVLA have directly risked Peter's livelihood by requesting duplicate medical information a month after he already submitted it in full. Will the leader arrange for a statement from the relevant minister on how DVLA and DVSA delays are being addressed and will he support my representations to help Peter get his licence back?

02:12:47 - 02:13:01

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. As my honourable friend has highlighted, these delays have, are having real impact on the livelihood of constituents. I'm not across the detail of the case that he raises, but if he shares the detail with my office, I'll ensure that it's taken up with the relevant minister.

02:13:01 - 02:14:03

John Hayes

Sir John Hayes.

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Cruel experiments on children are the stuff of dystopian fiction or the fact of past tyrannies. Yet as the shadow minister, the honourable lady for Beaconsfield reminded us, such experiments are taking place here and now to establish the damage that beta blockers do. Now, when challenged on this in the house, the former Secretary of State for Health, the member for Ealing North, said in agonised fashion that he'd be requesting monthly updates on the progress of those experiments. We have heard nothing since.

And I'm confident Mr Speaker and you, Madam Deputy Speaker, would want this house to know first how these experiments are going. So will the leader of the house demand from ministers a statement on these matters as was promised, or was that promise merely a rhetorical device to assuage the genuine fears of members across the chamber?

02:14:03 - 02:14:19

Lucy Maria Powell

No, knowing the then Health Secretary, it wasn't the latter that the right honourable gentleman mentions, but it was a commitment that we will seek to uphold. So I will take that away and talk to current ministers in the department and see if we can get what the right honourable gentleman seeks.

02:14:19 - 02:14:21

Speaker 145

Catherine Atkinson.

02:14:21 - 02:14:58

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Last month I visited HMP Foston Hall women's prison to see the work they were doing in giving catering and hospitality experience to women there. But when so many in our prisons are on remand waiting for trial or temporarily back on recall, it's much harder to do the work that can break cycles of reoffending. Last year I was able to secure a debate on work in prison, but will the leader of the house find time for a debate on the broader issue of education, training and work in prisons to prevent future offending and keep our communities safer?

02:14:58 - 02:15:29

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend raises a really important matter today. The government recognises that high quality education, vocational training are central to rehabilitation and reducing offending. We're expanding vocational opportunities to help prisoners develop the skills needed to secure sustainable employment on their release. My honourable friend talks about a previous debate that she had on related matters.

I'd encourage her to seek a Westminster Hall debate to pursue this particular aspect.

02:15:29 - 02:15:31

Speaker 142

Brian Matthews.

02:15:31 - 02:15:44

Speaker 155

Madam Deputy Speaker, I feel it right at this point to make the point that the debate on the health bill this week was poorly organised and not enough time was allowed.

02:15:44 - 02:16:23

Speaker 156

Many backbenchers from my own party and no doubt others across the House were not called to speak despite hours of bobbing. In my case, I wanted to raise the issue of new clause 72, the provision of minor injuries units in rural areas. When these efforts, which can add validity to the bill being debated, are not given the time they deserve, it results in frustration on the part of MPs who are trying to represent their electorate and a lessening of the effectiveness of our democracy. Please can greater thought be given to giving us as backbench MPs a more valued say in these debates.

02:16:23 - 02:17:23

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and to some extent I share the honorable gentleman's concern actually because there have been a series of statements since we came back after the summer recess. That isn't unusual, but I think what is unusual of course at the beginning of that recess is that we got a new administration and a new Prime Minister. So it's right that the time which was allowed for health, there was a significant amount of time, but I take I take I bear in mind, I bear in mind what he said because it's an opportunity for members to get in and talk about their constituency matters. I'll also bear that in mind because the Modernization Committee is looking at use of time in this place. And I think what is becoming clear is that one of the issues, whatever we look at in terms of time for government, opposition and all the other things, that we need to think about statements and urgent questions and how the day starts so that where there is great demand for discussion of legislation, which isn't always the case, but in this case there would have been, then that time is available.

02:17:23 - 02:17:52

Kim Marie Johnson

Kim Johnson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I really welcome the government's expansion of free school meals for those children and households eligible for Universal Credit. However, 500,000 children will be taken out of poverty. However, what we're experiencing at the moment is two-tier poverty because those children will not be eligible for HAF funding. So can the leader grant time to have a debate to look at how we can reverse that situation.

02:17:52 - 02:18:18

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm pleased that my honorable friend has recognized the important steps that the government has taken. I understand the point she makes about HAF funding because it's been raised by others too. Perhaps she would want to seek a Westminster Hall debate to not only expand the points that she makes but allow others to take part in that and then hear from the minister about what other things the government can do.

02:18:18 - 02:18:19

Dr. Neil Shastri-Hurst.

02:18:19 - 02:18:46

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last weekend I visited Cornerways in my constituency, which provides supported caring living for those vulnerable adults. The Friends of Cornerways have spent the last year clearing the gardens so it's now a workable space for residents. Will the Leader of the House join me in thanking them and other community groups that do so much for our local areas and perhaps giving some government time so we can debate the importance of community projects for societal good.

02:18:46 - 02:19:11

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I've said on numerous occasions that community volunteers are the golden thread that runs through our communities and in fact make our communities what they are. So I absolutely join him on the constituency case that he raises and should he seek a Westminster Hall on debate on communities and volunteers, then I'm sure it would allow others across the House to share their other similar positive experiences.

02:19:11 - 02:19:47

Sureena Brackenridge

Davina Brackenridge.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I recently met with the Royal Society of Chemistry and as a former teacher spent far too much time reminiscing about my time in the classroom, but we quickly turned on to the contribution that chemistry makes to our economy.

In 2023, chemistry contributed 60.5 billion pounds in GVA, including over 64 million pounds in Wolverhampton. So given the pressures on the skills pipeline, will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on how we can ensure young people have the skills needed to support growth and innovation in this vital sector?

02:19:47 - 02:20:19

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honourable friend is right to point out that chemistry makes a considerable contribution to our economy. As the House will know, the UK is a world leader in science, and that is in no small part due to the quality of our teachers. On skills, we're committed to ensuring that young people are equipped for the future, including through new technical education pathways for science. And should my honourable friend wish to look at this more broadly, then perhaps she should look towards an adjournment debate.

02:20:19 - 02:21:10

Speaker 161

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Industrial hemp is at the forefront of innovation in agriculture, and my constituent Martin Cessford is a farmer who's at the forefront of that in Scotland. It has great promise for industrial, health, climate, and building applications. But he has been thwarted at every turn by the Home Office and its absurd application of the 1971 Misuse of Drugs Act as it relates to hemp products. He's made some progress with my help on that, but now his shipment, which is going to Germany for quality control testing, is stuck in the Netherlands.

I've asked the FCDO for help over a month ago, I've not heard anything from them. So can we have a debate on government time about the tension between the government's need for growth and innovation and their departments standing in the way of that? And would he possibly use his good office to give the FCDO a shake?

02:21:10 - 02:21:27

Lucy Maria Powell

Indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. As a former drugs minister, I understand the complexity of some of these matters and often the frustration too. But I will raise the matter with both the Home Office, who have responsibility obviously on these matters, and the FCDO to see if we can get some clarity in the situation going forward.

02:21:27 - 02:22:02

Speaker 162

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Residents in Gadsbys Way in my constituency of Wycombe are stuck. They are subject to a 1924 act and a rent charge that makes it incredibly difficult for them to sell their homes because if they miss a payment, it can be repossessed. Now, most owners of those rent charges do allow a simple change in the deed. I've every faith this one will as well, and we're planning legislation in this area.

So can I ask the Leader firstly to encourage the owner to allow a simple change in the deeds, as well as confirm that we still have legislation planned to change this horrible practice?

02:22:02 - 02:22:32

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I hope that the owner has heard my honourable friend's comments here today. As a government, we're committed to banning the use of draconian and outdated remedies for non-payment of rent charge through the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, which we published in draft in January and will be bringing forward. I will ensure that my honourable friend has a meeting with the Minister for Housing and Planning so that he can hear more about the progress that we intend to make.

02:22:32 - 02:23:02

Jess Brown-Fuller

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was shocked and appalled at the vitriol and hate that's been shown towards the RNLI volunteers across the entire south coast, but also to the RNLI Selsey in my constituency, because they go out day in, day out, and they show us what an actual patriot looks like when they're saving lives at sea. So will the Leader of the House please join me in paying tribute to our brave RNLI volunteers and make time for us to debate how we can better support them?

02:23:02 - 02:23:39

Lucy Maria Powell

Indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I absolutely join the honourable lady in sending our support and appreciation to the RNLI, not least because I have RNLI presence in my own coastal constituency. It is wholly unacceptable that RNLI volunteers face social abuse on abuse on social media or indeed abuse of any sort, and let me put that very clearly on the record. They need to feel safe, they have to feel safe in the roles that they play for the contribution, the life-saving contribution that they make.

So she's right to raise this matter and I absolutely endorse what she says.

02:23:39 - 02:24:28

Elizabeth Helen Hayes

Yesterday we received the fantastic news that a community campaign, Buy Back Brixton, have been named as the preferred buyer for Brixton's iconic markets, Brixton Village and Market Row in my constituency. This means that the markets can be purchased by the community for the community, safeguarding their character and heritage and securing the long-term future for the incredible traders who make their living there. Will the Leader of the House join me in recognizing and celebrating this milestone reached by Buy Back Brixton and encouraging everyone to support their drive to raise the remaining funds they need to complete the sale? And can we have a debate in government time on what more can be done to safeguard community assets and independent businesses on our high streets and in our town centers and to expand community ownership?

02:24:28 - 02:25:05

Lucy Maria Powell

And I offer my congratulations, I'm sure the congratulations of the whole House to the traders and campaigners in the Buy Back Brixton campaign and I'm delighted to hear of their success. We've implemented new high street rental auction regulations and the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act introduces a new community right to buy. Later this year we will be bringing forward a high street strategy and at that point I'm sure my honorable friend will have an opportunity to raise local matters in that debate.

02:25:05 - 02:25:28

Wendy Morton

With an estimated 1.4 million approved homes unbuilt, brownfield capacity for 1.41 million homes and over 750,000 empty homes in England, will the Leader of the House allow a debate in government time on unlocking this housing to meet the government's 1.5 million target before any more green belt is released?

02:25:28 - 02:25:57

Lucy Maria Powell

Indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker, the right honorable lady has raised housing matters and she's right to do so on behalf of her residents. But there is that tension between the feelings often of local residents and their concern where there's green belt, but also the need for additional housing. I will take into consideration what she said about a potential for a debate and see what we can do.

02:25:57 - 02:26:45

Charles David Robertson

Since 2011, 15 years ago, my constituent John has been forced to use a bucket in his garden in lieu of a toilet because his own toilet pumps raw sewage back into his house. I've raised this on the floor of the House before and after my intervention Severn Trent finally provided a portaloo and a promise of a permanent solution. Unfortunately this week they informed John that that permanent solution won't work and there is no timeline for a delivery of a solution to this absolutely shocking failure on their behalf. It is a matter of dignity for John and his neighbors in Hill Ridware. Will the Leader of the House arrange for me to meet the minister to discuss this shocking case because it simply cannot go on any longer?

02:26:45 - 02:26:58

Luke Morgan Evans

Madam Deputy Speaker, the situation my honorable friend describes is simply unacceptable. I hope that Severn Trent have heard his powerful representation here today and I'll certainly ask ministers to meet with him.

02:26:58 - 02:27:28

Speaker 167

This House will know that I continue to push for the issues to be addressed for men and boys and we were making progress. The last Prime Minister committed to a men and boys summit. Sadly there's been a reshuffle, we've had a change and that summit hasn't yet happened. So I've written to the Justice Department and Cabinet Office but haven't heard anything back. Would he use his good office to raise with Number 10 whether or not this summit will indeed go ahead and if not push forward so it does go ahead so we can discuss the issues facing men and boys in this country?

02:27:28 - 02:27:45

Lucy Maria Powell

The honorable gentleman is an assiduous campaigner on the issue of men and boys and I pay real tribute to him for that. I would encourage him and others to contribute to the Westminster Hall debate later today on men and boys. But I will take away his concerns about the offer of taking this forward with government and indeed a summit to find out what the new administration's plan is because I'm sure they'll want to honor that.

02:27:45 - 02:28:32

İmran Hussein

Today marks three months since the lockdown in Azad Kashmir. Over a hundred peaceful protesters have been killed, over a thousand injured, and many more remain in arbitrary arrests. Over a million British Kashmiris quite rightly remain concerned at this escalation. The All-Party Parliamentary Group, along with 80 parliamentarians across this chamber, raised serious concerns at the human rights violations. Will the Leader of the House allow government time to allow for a full and substantial debate so that we can put on record that the human rights violations of Kashmiris are in breach of international law and we must resume peaceful table talk immediately?

02:28:32 - 02:29:03

Lucy Maria Powell

Deputy Speaker, my honorable friend has been an assiduous campaigner on these matters and I pay tribute to him for that. He is right in saying that human rights apply and should be respected wherever they are. And in terms of a debate, should he seek an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall debate on these matters, he will both hear from the relevant minister on the government's position on Kashmir, but also any other concerns of other colleagues across the House.

02:29:03 - 02:29:41

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Dr. Rosena Allin-Khan.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister's stated intention to tackle the social care crisis and to work cross-party to this end. But I was disappointed that the talks convened in July did not involve all of the parties that had previously been involved in the existing cross-party social care talks. So can the Leader of the House update the House as to the timetable for the next steps in those cross-party talks? And can he assure the House that they will be genuinely cross-party because we on these benches are very keen to work with the government to tackle this essential issue.

02:29:41 - 02:30:29

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's more than a shared intention of the Prime Minister, it's one of the things that drives him. When he was previously a member of this House, that was the case, and he has returned with that drive too. She's right that not all of the parties took up the offer in the way that the Prime Minister asked for. However, the Liberal Democrats did, and I pay tribute to her for that.

I will take away her comments about other parties that might want to be invited in the future. We can't guarantee that they will turn up, but other parties being invited in the future and see what the government intends to do, what the government intends to do to move this situation forward because it's an area which we have to do, where we have to move forward and it will be done much better on a cross-party basis.

02:30:29 - 02:30:34

Speaker 168

David Simmonds.

02:30:34 - 02:31:20

Speaker 176

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Fly-tipping and littering are a blight on our communities. That's why I'm proud of the work of amazing organizations like the Friends of Welsh Harp, Friends of Hayborn Park, the Burnt Oak Nepalese community, the litter pickers at St. Mary's, and many more for the work they do to keep Hendon looking its best. I'm working with them to hold my next big Hendon litter pick on the 25th of October. Over a hundred people attended the last one and this one promises to be even bigger.

Will my right honorable friend join me in thanking all the selfless volunteers and brilliant organizations that keep Hendon tidy and in encouraging people to come along on the 25th? There's a high-vis and a bin bag with his name on it if he's free that day.

02:31:20 - 02:32:03

Lucy Maria Powell

It is very tempting, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I notice it was only I that was invited and not the Deputy Speaker, but there we are. I want to pay tribute to all of his constituents who have selflessly volunteered to keep Hendon tidy. Community action like this is absolutely vital, and I would encourage his constituents to join him in this litter pick next month. The government is playing its part. We're taking robust action against fly-tipping, increasing the maximum penalty to £5,000 and giving council powers to crush vehicles of suspected fly-tippers.

But it is a whole effort of government and communities that is going to bear down on this intolerable problem.

02:32:04 - 02:32:38

Paul William Forster

I was very concerned to read at the weekend RNLI lifeboats were turned away from two ports, Portsmouth and Southampton. As a result, the brave RNLI volunteers had to face angry anti-migrant demonstrators. Somehow those protesters knew where those lifeboats were going to land. So please can the Leader of the House ensure that the government makes a statement on this incident, including why harbourmasters were allowed to turn away lifeboats who are there to save lives?

02:32:38 - 02:33:10

Lucy Maria Powell

Deputy Speaker, as I said previously, we pay tribute to the RNLI across the country. It is wholly unacceptable that volunteers anywhere should face abuse and certainly should not be turned away. The government takes these matters very seriously and will be looking at what has happened in terms of the importance of the RNLI going forward. Because this has been raised by more than just him, he may want to seek a debate and pin the minister down on what further action might be taken.

02:33:10 - 02:33:48

Speaker 177

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. By the time I was 18, I had already had five years' work experience, stacking shelves in the local supermarket and making Big Macs in McDonald's. Sadly, too many young people today just don't have access to work experience. On the 25th of September, I'm holding the fourth of my hugely successful jobs fair, and I'm encouraging all the exhibitors to offer work experience to local young people so that we can break down this barrier. Will the Leader of the House arrange a debate in government time on the importance of work experience for our young people and for our economy?

02:33:48 - 02:34:32

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, we are committed to supporting young people into work, and work experience, as my honourable friend says, is an important part of providing insight into future potential career paths. As he will know, the Milburn review is looking at how we can tackle some of these issues. We want to make sure that every young person between 16 and 24 has the opportunity to earn and learn, and part-time jobs and work experience are an important part of that. I'd encourage young people to go along to his jobs fair, and I pay tribute to him. On I note that next Monday is education questions, he might want to raise this matter directly with ministers.

02:34:32 - 02:34:33

Sir Julian Lewis.

02:34:33 - 02:35:23

Julian Lewis

On Monday, just as campaigners from the New Forest and Waterside were handing into Downing Street a 32,000-signature petition against the appalling and unfair outcome of local government reorganisation affecting our area, the welcome announcement was made by the government that the local government reform proposals for Hampshire and three other counties were being withdrawn and all the rest were being paused. May I invite the Leader of the House to secure a statement either from the Prime Minister or from the Secretary of State as soon as possible, confirming that that withdrawal and those pauses will be made permanent?

02:35:23 - 02:35:52

Lucy Maria Powell

Deputy Speaker, the Secretary of State at the earliest opportunity came to the House, and I think that was the right thing to do to make that statement.

The department is obviously going away to, the government is going away to have a look at these matters because we are keen that we get the best local government that we can in this country. And when it is, there are further things to say in these matters, I'm sure that the Secretary of State will want to come back and report to the House.

02:35:52 - 02:36:42

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Offences under the Domestic Abuse Scotland Act have skyrocketed by 81% since July 22, a stark sign that violence against women and girls in Scotland has reached crisis point. A fact that was rammed home to me last week as I listened to a woman in my constituency advice surgery describe the abuse that she has been experiencing at the hands of her partner. This Labour government is working hard to halve violence against women and girls, but to deliver that for the whole of the United Kingdom, we must tackle the root causes and demand urgent action from Holyrood. So can the Leader of the House outline what he thinks the Scottish government might learn from the work of this Labour government?

02:36:42 - 02:37:28

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's clear that violence against women and girls is reaching a crisis point, and I'm disturbed to hear her assessment of what is happening north of the border. This is in contrast to the action that we're taking in Westminster. We've published our violence against women and girls strategy, detailing how we will tackle this national emergency and halving violence against women and girls in the next decade. If the SNP government doesn't share that ambition, then I would encourage them to get on and do more about it and indeed align themselves with that ambition.

This government is very much about not just cross-party working in this place, but also between governments as well. So if they wish to engage in that, I'm sure it'll be worthwhile.

02:37:28 - 02:38:11

Edward Robert Jenrick

Robert Steel was a beautiful four-year-old boy who died three weeks ago in Newark when he was thrown from an off-road bike that was being driven by a 24-year-old man. This is the culmination of a number of incidents in my town and many others across the country involving off-road bikes, e-bikes, and e-scooters. Would the government consider a debate on the policing of these bikes, what further action we can take to prevent terrible tragedies like this one, and indeed the posture of police forces across the country when appropriately they can intercept them and protect members of the public?

02:38:11 - 02:38:57

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm sad to hear of what happened in the right honourable gentleman's constituency, and our thoughts are with the family. He's right to point to the scourge of off-road bikes and e-scooters because there are simply too many incidents of the sort that he is talking about. I think if he called for a Westminster Hall debate on these matters, then he could hear from the minister about what we intend to do because we do intend to crack down on them. And I absolutely agree with him on this point, that where police forces have the powers, then they need to use them.

It's probably easier for me to say than it is for them to do. However, they need to use the powers because together we need to tackle this scourge.

02:38:57 - 02:39:21

Elizabeth Helen Hayes

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Awaab's Law has support from across this chamber. I'd be grateful if the Leader could share with us whether he agrees that we need to move now to an assessment of the impact of Awaab's Law and what parliamentary time can be allocated to this so that we can all be certain that the scourge of damp and mould will be tackled by this government in our lifetimes.

02:39:21 - 02:40:04

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Everyone deserves to live in a home that's safe and decent, which is why we brought in Awaab's Law into force, protecting millions of tenants and forcing landlords to urgently fix dangerous homes within 24 hours of reporting. And the Renters' Rights Act also tackles the blight of poor quality privately rented homes, including applying the Decent Homes Standard to the private rented sector for the first time. Should my honourable friend, who is a fantastic campaigner on these matters, should she seek perhaps a Westminster Hall or adjournment debate, then I'm sure her and others will be able to find out from the minister what further steps can be taken to make sure that housing improves for the many.

02:40:04 - 02:40:05

Bradley Thomas.

02:40:05 - 02:40:52

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Bromsgrove continues to grind to a halt because of Worcestershire County Council's disastrous delivery of BREP, a local transport scheme. Now, this scheme is being backed by tens of millions of pounds of central government funding. I recently wrote to the Transport Secretary with 34 questions that my constituents want answers to, and I received a reply that, frankly, didn't answer a single one. I've resubmitted a letter to the Transport Secretary, imploring them to answer questions.

I'm sure I am often an irritant to the government, Madam Deputy Speaker, whether it's my campaign to protect Bromsgrove's green belt or this, but I make a plea to the Leader of the House: will he please press upon his colleague, the Transport Secretary, to support me in seeking answers that are in the interests of my constituents?

02:40:52 - 02:41:12

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's no bad thing when MPs are irritants to government, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I commend the honourable gentleman for the work that he does for his constituents on this important matter. I'm disappointed that he didn't get a proper reply to the questions that he asked. Let me take that away and take it up with the minister and see if we can get him a better reply.

02:41:13 - 02:41:36

Margaret Pamela Cox

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to pay tribute to victims to Colchester's much-respected Centre for Action on Rape and Abuse, or CARA. And following the confirmation of additional 9 million pounds for victim support services in Essex, will the Leader of the House make time for a debate on the progress the government's making on its work on prevention, enforcement, and survivor support?

02:41:36 - 02:42:14

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I join my honourable friend in welcoming this government's action and support on violence against women and girls. As the minister said yesterday, we are committed to tackling all forms of violence against women and girls whenever it occurs and by whomever. This has been a bit of a theme today, Madam Deputy Speaker, so I would encourage my honourable friend, she's right to say that it is time for the House to be able to discuss these matters, so perhaps if she applied for a Westminster Hall debate, others can bring in their concerns and suggestions for going forward and hear directly from the minister.

02:42:15 - 02:42:47

Clive Jones

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. This week I chaired a round table on delivering early diagnosis with cancer charities and leading clinicians. Everyone had concerns about NHS workforce shortfalls blocking the progress of a national cancer plan. Will the leader allow time for a debate in government to assess what investment is needed in the NHS workforce to be able to deliver the ambitions of earlier diagnosis in the national cancer plan?

02:42:47 - 02:43:27

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the honourable gentleman is right: this government's plan for tackling cancer is ambitious, and we have set out not just in terms of the investment that is needed but also our plans for the workforce. Of course, some of the shortfalls in workforce are being addressed, but as he points out, there is more that can be done. We have brought in our national cancer plan, 2.3 billion pounds invested to deliver 9.5 million additional tests by 2029, so we are making progress, but I'll ensure that the Health Secretary hears his specific concerns.

02:43:27 - 02:43:28

Alex Barros-Curtis.

02:43:28 - 02:44:04

Alex Barros

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Recent blasting at Taff's, Taff's Well Quarry in my constituency caused water to be displaced, resulting in extensive flooding and damage to my constituents and causing them significant distress. And not just to them, but across Wales for anyone who lives near a similar site. So may we have a debate on the assessment and monitoring of quarries near former mine workings in Wales? And will this government encourage the Welsh government to consider extending the transparent risk rating approach that we have for coal tips to similar quarries in Wales so that constituents can know the risks that are posed near them?

02:44:04 - 02:44:32

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And my honourable friend is right for raising this very serious issue, and I commend him for that. I understand the concerns of his constituents, and I hope that the Welsh government has heard his words today and that they will take action to address his concerns because he doesn't just bring to this House a concern about what has and hasn't happened, but some good ideas about how this can be addressed. And I hope that the Welsh government is listening.

02:44:32 - 02:44:33

Andrew Snowden.

02:44:33 - 02:45:42

Andrew Snowden

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. On the 17th of June 2025, my constituent's four-month-old puppy, Teddy, sustained a serious leg injury during an introductory puppy grooming appointment. Upon complaining to the staff, the staff dismissed it as just a bruise, but later veterinary imaging confirmed blunt force trauma resulting in three fractures to the dog's leg. Instead of addressing the complaint transparently, they ultimately offered partial compensation, but only if my constituent signed a broad confidentiality clause. I raised this with the Defra minister and I received a response on the 27th of November 2025, but the response missed the kind of the nub of the issue that my constituent was raising and I requested a meeting.

I have since emailed and written to them on the 12th of January, the 14th of March, the 16th of April and the 26th of August, not to receive even a response from the Defra minister. So could the Leader of the House use his good offices to seek a response?

02:45:42 - 02:46:13

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. And our best wishes go to Teddy and the whole family. I will take up the matter with the Defra minister. I will do everything that I can to get a meeting for the honourable gentleman. He will know that this government is concerned about the cost of animal welfare in terms of grooming, but also vets' bills as well.

So raising his concern directly with a minister, I think is the right way forward, and I'll see what we can do to get him a meeting.

02:46:14 - 02:47:19

Ian Lavery

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Dr. Anna Bron Bhattacharya is a resident of mine in my constituency. He's lived there for 60 years. He travelled to Kolkata only a couple of weeks ago, and it appears that he's been caught up in the horrendous flooding in Nepal. There's been numerous attempts to contact him, but they've been unsuccessful.

The FCDO have been less than helpful, basically pointing the family to the Indian consulate, who again are less than helpful. He's lived in this country for 60 years. He's missing. Can we have a debate in government time about how the FCDO can be more helpful to people who've lived in this country all of their lives, and because of these national tragedies, because he hasn't got a British passport, we cannot help him?

02:47:19 - 02:48:03

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We are working with the authorities on the ground to support their efforts in this terrible situation, supporting the survivors of all nationalities and trying to get information for families about missing loved ones.

And as my honourable friend has said, we're also in contact with the Indian authorities about the relief effort. I'm disappointed, however, that that hasn't led to the success that my or the outcome that my honourable friend seeks. I will see if the relevant FCDO minister will meet with him, not just to discuss this case, but the wider issue about what governments can do in what are often terrible circumstances.

02:48:03 - 02:48:42

Thomas Gordon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Brierley Homes, a company owned by Conservative-run North Yorkshire Council, is forecast to lose five million pounds this year on top of seven million pounds it lost last year, and that's on top of an original 25 million pound loan from the council and repeated bailouts. Multiple people have raised with me serious concerns about how this business is run, including allegations of bullying, corruption, fraud, and potentially even money laundering. They appointed an independent auditor earlier this year to the council, but it turned out that too was owned by the local authority. Can the Leader of the House provide time for a debate on transparency and accountability of council-owned companies?

02:48:42 - 02:49:02

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honourable gentleman raises some very concerning situation, a very concerning situation. I don't off the top of my head know what the answer is, except to say that I will take up, if he gives me the details after this, I will take it up with the relevant department and see what powers and influence they have to get a better outcome.

02:49:02 - 02:49:35

Gerald Jones

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Both towns in my constituency have lost a number of banks and building societies, leaving access to cash really difficult. In the other villages and communities across the constituency, we've lost a number of Post Office branches for a variety of reasons, and in some cases the Post Office have been reluctant to reopen. Can we please have a debate on what more government can do to ensure that communities, particularly geographically isolated communities, can maintain access to cash, which a large number of constituents rely on?

02:49:35 - 02:50:12

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Access to cash is an issue, most acutely felt often by those in rural areas of the country that rely on cash. And we are accelerating the rollout of banking hubs, with over 240 already opened. But we've also launched an independent review on access to banking services, and the Financial Services and Markets Bill will allow us to take further action in future to protect access to banking services if needed. This has been a common theme over the weeks and months in these sessions, Madam Deputy Speaker.

If my honourable friend seeks an adjournment debate or Westminster Hall debate, then I'm sure it'll be well attended.

02:50:12 - 02:50:36

Joshua Peter Reynolds

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Leaseholders in Maidenhead and across the country are being stuck with sky-high service charges. Many constituents have raised their service charge bills with me. I have seen many of these bills and some of the costs that are in there are absolutely astronomical. Can I ask the Leader of the House for a debate in government time to discuss service charges and how these massive service charges are quite often stopping leaseholders from being able to sell their properties?

02:50:36 - 02:51:06

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I do understand the concern sometimes of the situations that the honourable gentleman suggests. We are committed to making changes, as he knows, and implementing the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act of 2024. We published in draft form the Leasehold and Commonhold Reform Bill. The Prime Minister's absolutely determined that we get on with this, and when that happens, I'm sure the honourable gentleman will be able to raise these specific constituency concerns then.

02:51:06 - 02:51:25

Speaker 182

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Professor Jason Arday, aged 41 and the youngest black professor in Cambridge's history, was found dead at his house in my constituency on the 13th of August, days after resigning his chair and after a sustained press and intrusion and harassment.

02:51:25 - 02:52:35

Speaker 180

An inquest has opened, but there are serious questions for government on press regulation and widespread calls for a public inquiry. Tens of thousands attended a vigil in Trafalgar Square, vigils have been held from Bradford to Bristol, constituents have sent emails, the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State have both commented, but there has been no statement in this House. The government cannot comment on their own terms where members cannot scrutinize and then resist a debate the whole House can join. Is the leader aware that this House regularly debates policy arising from deaths whilst proceedings are live, leaving those proceedings alone? Press regulation in July 2011 after the hacking of Milly Dowler's phone, fire safety after Grenfell, policing and the safety of women in March 2021 after the death of Sarah Everard, also my constituent, or during court proceedings, the death of Molly Russell during the passage of the Online Safety Act, the deaths of Lucy Meadows and Caroline Flack, both connected to press conduct.

But the press pursue a black man to the end of his life and this House says nothing about their conduct. I do not have to tell the Leader of the House why this is wrong, so all I will ask him is when the government will rectify it.

02:52:35 - 02:53:17

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and Jason Arday's death is an utter tragedy and I pay tribute to my honorable friend's tireless work on behalf of Professor Arday and his family and friends. As she is aware, there is currently a coroner's inquest. I hear what she says about what may have happened in instances in the past, but there is a coroner's inquest into Professor Arday's death, which the government is particularly careful not to want to not cut across, but there will be an opportunity in the future to respond to that, and I know that the Culture Secretary is very keen to work with her on this matter.

02:53:17 - 02:53:56

Vikki Slade

Madam Deputy Speaker, every time I raise child maintenance failures in this House, my inbox and social media feeds are flooded with parents sharing harrowing cases of domestic abuse being perpetuated, income being undeclared, and where children are being used as weapons in their parents' relationship breakdown. And a report from the other place made sweeping recommendations for change, but its long delays and poor processes are really harming children who should be at the heart of the decisions. We have already had several debates, as the leader will know, on this, and there have been commitments in those debates for change. So will he please ask for the minister to bring an update to this House so we can see what the government are actually going to do?

02:53:56 - 02:54:19

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I understand the the way in which the honorable lady raises this point because there's incredible frustration and more often across constituencies about the workings of the Child Maintenance Service. Let me take that away and look ask the relevant department if they will consider an update to the House when it's appropriate.

02:54:19 - 02:54:43

Speaker 178

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Wigan today, a funeral service is taking place for Sibilly Boston, who was rugby league's first knight, a trailblazer on and off the pitch, a leader, an inspiration to millions, and a gentleman above all else. On what will be a sad day for his family, will the Leader of the House please join me in paying tribute to Sibilly one last time and sending condolences to his loved ones?

02:54:43 - 02:55:05

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and as I did last week, I I pay tribute to Sibilly Boston, and I know the thoughts of the whole House will be with his loved ones at this time. He was one of the greatest and most popular rugby league players of all time, and his legacy will no doubt continue to inspire future generations of rugby league players.

02:55:05 - 02:55:35

Robin Swann

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Joint Committee on Human Rights has completed a report on the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill and has produced a number of significant recommendations. Can the Leader of the House give us an assurance that the government will respond to those recommendations before the next stage of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, and can he give us an update as to where the current remedial order, which passed through this House and then went to the other place, currently is, because it hasn't completed its full passage?

02:55:35 - 02:55:55

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, the honorable gentleman raises in a very reasonable way some of the and highlights some of the complexities in this and the determination of the government to get this right. So if he'll allow me, I will take away both of those requests to the department and get him the update that he seeks, the assurance on the first question and then an update on the second one.

02:55:56 - 02:56:26

Speaker 188

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I recently visited the RNLI lifeboat station at Girvan. It was great to see the fantastic volunteers who work all year round in all weathers to keep us people safe along the coast. The RNLI received community benefit from SPEN Energy to support high-quality training for volunteers who carry out these life-saving duties. Would the leader agree that this is money well spent and would he find time for a debate on the role of community benefit funds within local communities?

02:56:26 - 02:57:00

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank my honorable friend for this question and join her in thanking all the volunteers for exceptional and life-saving work. I do agree with her that money spent on the RNLI service is indeed money well spent, with volunteers providing life-saving services to coastal communities like mine and indeed hers across the country. And this has been a theme again of today. So if we had a debate on the RNLI, both the unfortunate things that have been happening but also the really positive things that they do day in, day out, I'm sure it would be a well-attended debate.

02:57:00 - 02:57:02

Alison Bennet

Alison Bennett.

02:57:02 - 02:57:17

Alison Bennett

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Regarding the honors system, when are the next triennial report and quinquennial review due, and will the public be able to contribute their views as part of this?

02:57:17 - 02:57:33

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And again in short, I haven't been part of the honors process. I don't know the answer to the honorable lady. So if she doesn't mind, I will take that away and I will get the answers to the questions that she asked.

02:57:33 - 02:58:16

John Martin McDonnell

John McDonnell.

On a number of occasions, I've raised the case of Lee Cheuk-yan, who many members on this side of the House will remember was the general secretary of the Federation of Trade Unions in Hong Kong, was also the founder of the Labour Party in Hong Kong. He was detained as part of the democracy movement five years ago. We've just heard over the last 48 hours that he's before the courts again on Friday, having served a five-year sentence, he's now being tried for subversion with the threat of a 30-year sentence. Could I ask the Leader of the House to liaise with the Foreign Secretary to see whether we can get a statement urging clemency on behalf of on behalf of Lee and hopefully securing his release?

02:58:16 - 02:58:34

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm sorry that my right honorable friend has had to give the House such a distressing update. But I will, as he asks, take this away and raise it with the FCDO and see I'm sure it won't wait for a statement for them to make their representations known to the Chinese authorities.

02:58:34 - 02:58:36

Speaker 184

Tessa Munt.

02:58:36 - 02:59:25

Tessa Munt

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the leader knows, it's World Suicide Prevention Day today. And suicides are the leading cause of death under the amongst the under-35s. After nearly 30 years, Papyrus, the national youth suicide prevention charity, went into administration two days ago. Its HOPELINE247 crisis service ceased with immediate effect.

One of my constituents is absolutely terrified about their young adult returning to university without Papyrus's support on which they were entirely reliant. Would the Leader of the House agree with me that this charity's collapse is catastrophic for younger people? And can he speak to his colleagues about crisis support for young people and young adults immediately?

02:59:25 - 02:59:46

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm obviously concerned about the collapse of Papyrus. And I will raise with colleagues the honorable lady's concerns. I have outlined in previous responses our strategy on this and what we intend to do going forward. But I understand the urgency of what she's saying, so I will take it up with colleagues.

02:59:46 - 03:00:24

Steve Yemm

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many of us on all sides of the House remain incredibly frustrated by Capita's performance and ongoing failures related to their administration of the Civil Service Pension Scheme. My office, and I'm sure many other members, are dealing with many cases on behalf of constituents in Mansfield who are struggling to access their pensions in a timely manner, and the delays are simply beyond acceptable now. Can the Leader of the House ask ministerial colleagues to provide the House with an urgent update?

03:00:24 - 03:01:18

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the service levels following the move to Capita have been completely unacceptable. Our immediate priority was to stabilize the service and give current and former civil servants the service that they deserve. I would urge my honorable friend, and indeed all honorable members concerned about the issue of Capita, to contribute to the Westminster Hall debate on this very topic next Tuesday so they can hear directly from ministers. But before that, I'd point them towards the written ministerial statement which has very recently been published, which actually gives a, not only sets out what the government is doing about it, but actually gives a commitment from the minister to provide the House with a substantive update in October following the conclusion of the technical audit and report from the remedial advisor.

So the update that my honorable friend is seeking is on its way.

03:01:18 - 03:01:19

Freddie van Mierlo.

03:01:19 - 03:01:51

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When I met with constituents who are family members of people living with dementia in Thame, the overwhelming response and emotion was anger. Anger at the lack of support for them, and in particular concern around what would happen to their family members if they themselves became ill. So will the Leader of the House outline what the government is doing to support carers of people living with dementia and support a debate on government time?

03:01:51 - 03:02:35

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government is doing a great deal in what we recognize is often a very distressing situation. He will know that the Casey review came up with a series of recommendations on dementia and other things like motor neurone disease, for example. We've also launched the Big Conversation on Care to ensure that people can feedback their views, and appointing a dementia tsar to help drive forward much-needed improvements will be important. But we're also investing more as well in services, but of course I recognize that there is a great deal more to be done.

I will get a further update for the honorable gentleman from the relevant minister.

03:02:35 - 03:02:39

Speaker 189

Sarah Hall, after which I'll call Steve Darling. Sarah Hall.

03:02:39 - 03:03:27

Sarah Hall

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As we've already heard, today is World Suicide Prevention Day, and this week Papyrus, which is based in my constituency in Warrington South, went into administration after almost 30 years. Its HOPELINE247 service meant young people experiencing suicidal thoughts and anyone worried about them could speak to trained advisors day and night. I've actually written to all MPs and peers asking them to sign a cross-party letter to the Health Secretary calling for emergency funding to protect Papyrus's services. Will the Leader of the House make time for an oral statement from a health minister on the closure of Papyrus and the steps the government is taking to restore HOPELINE247 and support the young people who relied on it?

03:03:27 - 03:03:58

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As was raised earlier, and my response, that the news regarding Papyrus is deeply concerning. We are entirely committed to suicide prevention and making sure that high-level quality mental health support is there, particularly for young people. I will reach out to the relevant minister, as I've offered, and include my honorable friend in that, and maybe ministers might want to give an update to all members because this is of such importance.

03:03:51 - 03:04:20

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Families across Torbay are struggling to receive adequate SEND provision. I know that other MPs are able to engage meaningfully with their local authority to support these families. Sadly, the leader of Conservative Torbay Council has written to me saying that they will not deal with me on a case-by-case basis around these families in need. The ombudsman have refused to engage.

03:03:58 - 03:03:59

Steve Darling.

03:04:20 - 03:04:29

Matthew Stephen Darling

Will the leader ask the appropriate minister to give me some guidance of how I can best support these families in need in Torbay?

03:04:29 - 03:04:58

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. I will indeed do as the honorable gentleman said, but I find it quite outrageous, actually, that leaders of councils refuse to engage with members of Parliament who are doing the raising legitimate matters on behalf in a reasonable way, as I know the honorable gentleman will be, on behalf of their constituents. And therefore, I hope that the leader of the council has heard that, but I will get him the information that he seeks from the relevant minister.

03:04:58 - 03:05:00

Speaker 192

Chris Bloore.

03:05:00 - 03:05:34

Chris Bloore

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Residents in Redditch and Wythall, despite being asked to pay more by Severn Trent, are continuously facing water outages as crumbling infrastructure takes days to repair. Many vulnerable residents, including new mums, have been left, even despite being on the priority list, without bottled water. Privatization, or the benefits thereof, seemingly are non-existent to my residents in Redditch and Wythall. Would the leader of the House share their frustrations and their sympathies towards a change in ownership model?

03:05:34 - 03:06:11

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the fact is that the water industry has not been working for people for far too long, and the incident that my honorable friend raises only demonstrates that, which is why the government is looking at ways in which we can give the public more control as well as keep bills as low as possible. It is a priority for the new DEFRA secretary, but I have to say it's also a matter of priority for the new Prime Minister too. On Monday, Madam Deputy Speaker, there will be a petition debate on a referendum on public ownership of the water sector, which my honorable friend and others may wish to attend.

03:06:11 - 03:06:13

Speaker 191

Liz Jarvis.

03:06:13 - 03:06:47

Liz Jarvis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On Tuesday, Salt of the Earth, a family-run business in my constituency of Eastleigh, was formally awarded the 2026 King's Award for Enterprise and Sustainable Development. From kitchen chemists to natural deodorant pioneers, this fabulous little business is now manufacturing from a 16,000 square foot facility. Does the leader of the House agree with me that SMEs like Salt of the Earth are crucial to growth across the country and their success should be celebrated and supported?

03:06:47 - 03:07:08

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yes, I do, but more importantly, yes, the government does too, because small and medium-sized enterprises are so important to our economy. And I just want to praise Salt of the Earth for the work that they are doing. It is no mean achievement to get a King's Award, I can assure you, and so they and the wider community should be very proud of themselves.

03:07:08 - 03:07:10

Speaker 193

Alison Hume.

03:07:10 - 03:07:44

Alison Louise Hume

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Boulby Underground Laboratory near Whitby is leading the race to host a massive international experiment to search for dark matter.

However, STFC's proposed 40% cuts to the lab's operating budget has created uncertainty about the government's continued support for the project. Will the Leader of the House facilitate a meeting with the responsible minister to discuss these drastic cuts and help secure Boulby's future as a world-leading centre for physics research?

03:07:44 - 03:08:18

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, my honourable friend is absolutely right to raise this important matter on behalf of her constituents and indeed the sector more widely. The government is investing 86 billion pounds to drive scientific breakthroughs through the across the UK. We have a proud record of science in this country and we intend to keep that lead. There will be science questions next week, but I would be happy to facilitate a meeting with the relevant minister to allow her to discuss these concerns in greater detail.

03:08:18 - 03:08:19

Callum Miller.

03:08:19 - 03:09:02

Callum Miller

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituents and I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment in this House on Tuesday the 1st of September to familiarize himself with all the detail of the proposed asylum centre at MOD Bicester. The Prime Minister further committed that he would, and I quote, happily report back on this to the House from the dispatch box. On the 4th of September, the government announced the short deadline for my constituents to respond to this application is Thursday the 17th of September. So will the Leader of the House make government time available for a statement from the Prime Minister before the consultation deadline so my constituents can hear his conclusions from the dispatch box, or if not, could the Leader of the House advise how the Prime Minister can fulfill his commitment?

03:09:02 - 03:09:27

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's important that the honourable gentleman's constituents do get an opportunity to give their views, which is why the consultation is important and it's important that those views are given time to be considered so that the government can act upon them. The Prime Minister is a man of his word, so I am sure that he will he will want to respond to this issue, perhaps once the consultation's closed.

03:09:27 - 03:09:28

Apsana Begum.

03:09:28 - 03:10:00

Apsana Begum

Madam Deputy Speaker, the government's new restrictions on fire and rehire are due to come into effect from January next year, yet some organizations are rushing to make use of this unfair and abhorrent practice in the time that remains. This includes EastendHomes in my constituency, deploying it against its long-standing housing workers who are members of Unison to force through the acceptance of diminished pension terms. Does the Leader of the House agree with me that this is unacceptable and that fire and rehire practices should have no place in our society?

03:10:00 - 03:10:09

Lucy Maria Powell

Yes, I do. And I hope that the firms concerned have heard the honourable lady and that they think again.

03:10:09 - 03:10:10

Richard Foord.

03:10:10 - 03:10:35

John Richard Foord

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Trains are running at half the normal frequency on the West of England line because of dry embankments. This is happening for months at a time and for the second year in a row. New Civil Engineer magazine has written that, quote, the London-Devon rail route needs investment. Can we have a debate please on adapting our rail infrastructure to the effects of climate change?

Thank you.

03:10:35 - 03:11:02

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The very the government is very keen to learn the lessons of what is happening as an as an effect of climate change because this is going to be at least as grave a problem going forward, maybe even worse. I suggest that the honourable gentleman seeks an adjournment debate on these matters to hear from the relevant minister about what the government plans to do to address what I know will be of serious concerns to his constituents.

03:11:02 - 03:11:03

Morwenna Moore.

03:11:03 - 03:11:44

Perran Moon

Moras, Madam Deputy Speaker. Rick Rescorla, a son of Hayle in my constituency, was head of security at Morgan Stanley in the South Tower on 9/11. He was widely credited with helping to evacuate more than 2,500 people while singing Cornish songs as he did so. He sacrificed his own life attempting to save the last few employees. Having served in both the Parachute Regiment and the US Air Cavalry, Rick is truly a national hero.

Does the Leader agree with me that Rick's life, as well as the thousands who died that fateful day, should never be forgotten?

03:11:44 - 03:12:09

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I do indeed agree with my honorable friend that Rick's life should be recognized and remembered. It's important that we continue to remember the innocent lives lost and the extraordinary bravery of service personnel like Rick. My honorable friend may wish to attend tomorrow's adjournment debate on the anniversary of 9/11 so that he can tell Rick's story in full, because it's a story which deserves to be told.

03:12:09 - 03:12:11

Speaker 202

Jim Shannon.

03:12:11 - 03:12:44

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank the Leader of the House always for his answers to our questions. And will the Leader of the House ask the Foreign Secretary to make a statement on forced marriage and freedom of religion or belief in India, following reports of women being subjected to violence for refusing marriages chosen for them, and continuing concerns over pressure and interference in interfaith marriages, and on whether the government will raise the protection of women's freedom to choose both their spouse and their religion with the Indian authorities? Thank you.

03:12:44 - 03:13:17

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As ever, the honorable gentleman raises a serious issue, and the reports that he raises are concerning. The UK government condemns any instances of discrimination because of religion or belief, regardless of the country or the faith involved. The British High Commission in New Delhi and our Deputy High Commissions across India regularly meet with religious representatives from different faith communities. I will ensure I will raise the honorable gentleman's concerns directly with ministers, and I'll make sure that he gets a response.

03:13:17 - 03:13:18

Douglas McAllister.

03:13:18 - 03:13:54

Douglas McAllister

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The mental health charity Stepping Stones in my West Dunbartonshire constituency celebrates its 35th anniversary tomorrow. A member-led organization founded in 1991 by local people, it provides mental health services and supports around a thousand referrals each year. And they do so at a time when uncertainty looms over future funding. So will the House have an opportunity to debate a mental health strategy for all parts of our nation, and will the Leader of the House join me in thanking and congratulating Stepping Stones for their invaluable work across West Dunbartonshire?

03:13:54 - 03:14:28

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And first, let me join my honorable friend in thanking and celebrating Stepping Stones' 35th anniversary and thanking them for the vital services that they provide. As he suggests, we are developing a new mental health strategy for England. We've announced up to 159 new NHS mental health centers backed by 343 million pounds over the next four years. I'll ensure that he gets a response from the Health Secretary so that he can hear more exactly more what we intend to do.

03:14:28 - 03:14:29

Sir John Hayes.

03:14:29 - 03:15:07

Sojan Joseph

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like every other member, I'm proud of the high streets in my constituency of Ashford, and I want to see them continue to flourish. We should be doing everything we can to encourage more people to travel to their high street to support local businesses. It is therefore important that shoppers and other visitors do not have additional costs, such as unnecessary car parking charges, especially due to unregulated private parking companies and their ticket machines that often doesn't work. Will the Leader of the House find time for a debate on the importance of high streets and the steps that can be taken to keep them vibrant?

03:15:07 - 03:15:33

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed. Small businesses are at the heart of our economy. We are committed to supporting them. We will bring forward our high street strategy later this year, which will build on our work to regenerate high streets across the country. And I hear and share his concerns about car parking charges and indeed rogue companies.

If he was to apply for a Westminster Hall debate, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm sure it would be well attended from by members across the house.

03:15:33 - 03:15:35

Speaker 201

Laura Kyrke-Smith.

03:15:35 - 03:16:12

Laura Kyrke-Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I'm working with a group of cross-party colleagues on a proposal for a parliamentary committee of the future. The committee would focus on medium and long-term challenges, from the impacts of climate change to the future of work, to ensure that strategic foresight is better integrated into policymaking and legislation, and to ensure that young people and future generations are better represented in this place. From Finland to Kenya and South Korea, we're seeing this approach being taken up and starting to work. Does the leader agree that a committee of this nature could strengthen the work of this house, and can he give me any guidance on how to move this forward?

03:16:12 - 03:16:45

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed. As my honorable friend will recall, I have indeed met with her and indeed other honorable and right honorable members to discuss this idea. It is an interesting proposal, and I would encourage her perhaps to put this to the modernization committee as part of our pitch your ideas session, because as the shadow deputy leader of the house can confirm, our first pitch your ideas session, which we had earlier this week, was a resounding success. And so I would encourage my honorable friend to consider this as a way forward.

03:16:45 - 03:16:47

Speaker 200

Katrina Murray.

03:16:47 - 03:17:32

Katrina Murray

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. 16th of September marks the 89th anniversary of the Eastside Bothy fire in Kirkintilloch, where ten young men from Achill in County Mayo lost their lives in what is widely considered to be a deliberate fire in their accommodation. Those young men came to Kirkintilloch like many thousands of Irish migrants before them to work as tattie howkers on the potato harvest. Will the leader join me in paying tribute to the committed local volunteers who have done so much to ensure that these young men are not forgotten, whether it's in Kirkintilloch or in Achill, and are doing what they can to have a permanent memorial in place in time for the 90th anniversary next year?

03:17:32 - 03:17:54

Lucy Maria Powell

Madam Deputy Speaker, I absolutely join my honorable friend in paying tribute to the volunteers in her constituency who ensure that we remember the Eastside Bothy fire. It's important that we continue to do so. I'm pleased to hear that funding has been raised for a permanent memorial. I hope that work with East Dunbartonshire Council can progress swiftly to have it built in time for the 90th anniversary.

03:17:54 - 03:17:55

Varinder Jas.

03:17:55 - 03:18:42

Varinder Jass

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Concerns raised by the Francis inquiry into Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust led to section 92 of the Care Act 2014, which makes it a criminal offense for health and social care providers such as NHS bodies to supply, publish, or make available false or misleading information where they are under a legal duty to provide that information. However, despite multiple reports in recent years of NHS trusts failing to disclose relevant information that may be damaging to their reputation, the Solicitor General on 10th of June confirmed that there had been no finalized prosecutions under this provision. Could the leader of the house please arrange for me to meet the now Solicitor General to help me understand why that is the case?

03:18:42 - 03:19:12

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for this question, which goes to the heart of the transparency and patient safety lessons that we have learned from the events at Mid Staffordshire. This government takes matters like this extremely seriously, which is why we're progressing the Public Office Accountability Bill to place a legally binding duty of candor on all public servants. But of course, I'll reach out to the Solicitor General and facilitate a meeting for my honorable friend.

03:19:12 - 03:19:13

Tracy Gilbert.

03:19:13 - 03:19:56

Tracy Gilbert

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. A year ago, my constituent John McNabb was stabbed in Leith in the early hours of the 2nd of September 2025 and tragically pronounced dead near the scene shortly afterwards.

John's mum Lisa has gone to heroic efforts to see bleed kits rolled out across key places and campaigned tirelessly, including bringing the Knife Angel, a 27-foot structure made of 100,000 knives and blades seized by police officers across the UK, to Leith as part of raising that awareness. Will the Leader of the House join me in paying tribute to the bravery and campaigning efforts of Lisa, and can he bring forward a debate in Government time on the work across the UK to reduce knife crime?

03:19:56 - 03:20:46

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know the whole House will join me in offering our condolences to Lisa and all of John McNab's loved ones. And also I want to recognize Lisa for taking such a tragic event and seeking to turn it into a force for good. In June 2024, we set out our ambition to halve knife crime. Since the election, overall knife crime has fallen by 11% and we have taken 63,000 knives off our streets.

But I recognize how important this work is and how much more needs to be done. I would encourage my honorable friend to apply for a Westminster Hall debate to hear from ministers what further action they intend to take. Unfortunately, this problem continues and that's why we need to stay focused on it.

03:20:46 - 03:20:47

Frank McNally.

03:20:47 - 03:21:36

Francis Joseph McNally

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Mrs. McNeilly moved from England to Glenboig in my constituency in January. However, a lack of compatibility between the medical record systems of Scotland and England means that all of her records have to be compiled and transferred by courier. As a result, nine months on, Mrs. McNeilly's records are still not with the NHS in Scotland or with her GP practice. Does my right honorable friend agree with me that the NHS in both England and Scotland, where there have been a lack of digital records, presents a major problem and we must work constructively to ensure these types of issues are avoided in the future?

03:21:36 - 03:22:00

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I do absolutely agree with my honorable friend that waiting eight months for records to be moved across the border is simply unacceptable. Healthcare on the border has been raised with me on a number of occasions, not least by the Deputy Shadow Leader. And my honorable friend is absolutely right that we've got to work constructively on these matters. And I'll ensure that the Health Secretary hears his representations today.

03:22:01 - 03:22:38

Tom Collins

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Worcestershire Royal Hospital has pioneered a project to ensure that every patient they treat is addressed by the name by which they're known. Surprisingly, one in four patients are known by a different name from the one on their hospital record. It's a simple step, it's proved its accessibility, treatment, safety, and dignity. And rolling this out across the NHS requires no change to the law, but it does demand leadership from Government.

So will the Leader of the House provide Government time for a debate on how we can modernize the NHS culture and practice to better put patients as people at the heart of their processes?

03:22:38 - 03:23:00

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I think everyone in the House will join me in praising Worcestershire Royal Hospital and its staff for this initiative. Simple gestures like this help build trust and bring comfort to patients. And I'd strongly encourage my honorable friend to apply for a Westminster Hall or adjournment debate to see how we can modernize the NHS further and improve care.

03:23:00 - 03:23:01

Baggy Shanker.

03:23:01 - 03:23:27

Charalambos Charalambous

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Earlier this summer, I met brilliant scouts and volunteers at the 1st Shelton Lock Scout Group across Derby South. Five of our young scouts are currently fundraising to represent Derby at the World Scout Jamboree next summer in Poland. Will the Leader of the House join me in congratulating them on their fantastic achievement in being selected for this opportunity and wish them the best with their fundraising efforts?

03:23:27 - 03:23:42

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I certainly congratulate them on their efforts and indeed scouts and volunteers across our country. They do a fantastic job. I wish them well in everything that they do in the future in what is a remarkable opportunity for young people.

03:23:43 - 03:24:25

Chris Kane

This weekend, Stirling will welcome thousands of music fans for Radio 2 in the Park, and it seems a fitting moment to celebrate radio more widely, particularly my constituency with such a strong radio tradition, from Central FM, where I spent many happy years behind the microphone, to Stirling Community Radio, Air 3, Trossachs Radio, and Radio Royal. Will the Leader of the House join me in welcoming Radio 2 to Stirling and make time for a debate celebrating BBC, commercial, community, and hospital radio and that rather special relationship we all have with them? And if you'll indulge me, it's 12:57 on your smart speaker and on your radio, this is the House of Commons, the voice of democracy, and it's now time to hear from the Leader of the House.

03:24:25 - 03:24:53

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you very much indeed. Once a radio expert, always a radio expert, Madam Deputy Speaker. I certainly join my honorable friend in welcoming Radio 2 in the Park to Stirling. Radio continues to be a highly valued medium across our country, and it contributes significant public value through its trusted news and diverse entertainment, and I thank them for that. Should my honorable friend seek a Westminster Hall debate, I'm sure that colleagues across the House will want to spend some time praising the efforts of local radio in their own particular area.

03:24:53 - 03:24:54

Jane Kirkham.

03:24:54 - 03:25:17

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Home Office revocation of health and social care visas linked to single employers has disproportionately increased recently. That's concerning because that leaves 40,000 social care workers displaced, and only a small number are getting alternative employment. I'm worried that people are slipping into the grey market. Can the Leader ascertain with Home Office colleagues what steps the Home Office takes to track outcomes for these workers?

03:25:17 - 03:25:43

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is an important matter. We want to give people who come here in good faith every opportunity to contribute to our country. Therefore, the Home Office has paused routine visa cancellations for care workers where sponsor revocation is the sole ground for cancellation to give displaced care workers longer to find alternative employment. But I understand my honorable friend's concerns.

I'll make sure that she gets from the relevant minister an update of where we are.

03:25:43 - 03:25:44

John Slinger.

03:25:44 - 03:26:24

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Sixty of my constituents from all across my constituency of Rugby have written to me and contacted me to complain about what is often a totally unsatisfactory service from Royal Mail, either no, slow, or bulk deliveries. This has real human impact. And if I may, I would like to draw attention to Rugby Talking Newspaper, whose customers are not receiving this vital service that they rely on. And I believe that Royal Mail may be in breach of its obligation, statutory obligation, to deliver articles to blind people free of charge.

Will the Leader consider time in government time so that we can debate how to exert more public control over this vital public service?

03:26:24 - 03:26:53

John Slinger

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We've been very clear as a government that Royal Mail service is unacceptable, and the example that the honorable gentleman gives simply underlines the unacceptability of Royal Mail's performance in these regards. The public expects a well-run postal service. I know, Madam Deputy Speaker, that Royal Mail listens closely to these sessions. I hope that they have heard my honorable friend's concerns because I know that it has been the subject of not just inquiry by the relevant select committee, but it is a priority for the relevant department.

03:26:53 - 03:26:54

Martin Rhodes.

03:26:54 - 03:27:10

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Next week, on the 18th of September, it will be National Playlist Day, which celebrates the positive impact that personally meaningful music can have in reconnecting people living with dementia with their memories. This initiative was established by Playlists for Life, a charity based in my constituency. Would the Leader of the House agree with me that personalized music could benefit how the NHS approaches caring for those with dementia, and I ask that time

03:27:47 - 03:28:06

Martin Rhodes

This initiative was established by Playlist for Life, a charity based in my constituency. Would the Leader of the House agree with me that personalized music could benefit how the NHS approaches caring for those with dementia, and I ask that time may be made available to look at the issues raised by National Playlist Day?

03:28:06 - 03:28:41

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honorable friend is absolutely right to praise the good work of Playlist for Life, and I want to pay tribute to everyone involved in making their work possible. We are looking at how we can better support those with dementia, including through appointing a dementia tsar to help drive the drive towards much-needed improvements. But to his point on personalized music, the idea is a very interesting one, and I'll make sure that the Health Secretary is made aware of it and gets back to my honorable friend.

03:28:41 - 03:28:42

Josh Newbury.

03:28:42 - 03:29:19

Josh Newbury

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Wildfire after wildfire throughout this incredibly dry summer have been devastating for Cannock Chase and elsewhere in Staffordshire. Crops were destroyed, animals perished, heathland rarer than rainforest was scorched, and six firefighters were taken to hospital. I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to hold a wildfire summit, but will the Leader grant a debate in government time on wildfire resilience and preparedness so that members from affected parts of the country can discuss prevention, equipment, staffing, and funding to ensure we're in a much stronger position for next summer?

03:29:19 - 03:30:11

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is not the first time that wildfires have been raised with me in these sessions, and my honorable friend is absolutely right to do so. We have announced 97 million pounds to upgrade the national resilience assets, including specialized firefighters and equipment, and as he says, there will be a wildfire summit in the autumn to see how we can further strengthen our national response capabilities. I want to just place on record again our thanks to all the emergency services, including obviously firefighters, but I also want to thank farmers for the fantastic job that they did as well in combating this problem over the extraordinarily dry summer that we have just had. I'll make sure that the House is updated on the government's work going forward because we're very keen to learn lessons and to make sure that we have the resilience going forward.

03:30:11 - 03:30:57

Danny Beales

And the last question, Danny Beales.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Hopefully the best saved to last, but you can judge that. My predecessor, when he was in this place, campaigned famously for a new fish and chip shop in Uxbridge, but now he's the leader of the Conservative council, he seems to be closing the fish and chip shop that does exist in Hillingdon, along with the florist, the pharmacy, the hairdresser, and the local convenience store. Local shops whose landlord is the council are facing a 100 percent rent increase backdated for several years, all whilst repairs have not been done, sometimes for up to nine years. Does the Leader of the House agree with me that local businesses are the lifeblood of our communities, they should be supported by councils, and can we have a time for debate in this place on the importance of local high streets?

03:30:57 - 03:31:21

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My honorable friend is absolutely right, small businesses are at the heart of our local economy, and our small business plan provides wide-ranging support for SMEs, including action on late payments, access to finance, business support, and skills. But it's very disappointing, but not altogether surprising, to hear that Conservative-led Hillingdon Council is letting businesses down in this way. I hope that they have heard his words today.

03:31:21 - 03:31:42

Speaker 215

That concludes business questions. I'll just give a few moments for the front benches to swap over. We'll now begin the statement, Statement, Defense Secretary.

03:31:42 - 03:41:31

Speaker 214

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, with your permission, I will make my first statement to the House as Secretary of State for Defense on Ukraine, the ongoing threat from Russia, and the government's approach.

It is not yet clear whether freedom or tyranny will define the 21st century. What is clear is that the United Kingdom will not be bystanders in that struggle. The front line is Ukraine. And in Kyiv, on my first overseas trip, I saw for myself what modern tyranny looks like. President Putin's illegal and unprovoked invasion is a challenge to the collective security of all of us in Europe.

History teaches us, especially the history of our continent, that when imperialist ambitions go unchallenged, leaders like President Putin come back for more. That is why Ukraine's security is our security, and why we will not waver for one second in our support for Ukraine. This week, I co-chaired my first meeting of the Ukraine Defence Contact Group with my German counterpart, Boris Pistorius, alongside Ukraine's new Defence Minister, Evgeniy Khamara, and NATO Secretary General, Mark Rutte. We know that President Putin, facing the reality that Russian casualties surpassed one and a half million this week, is preparing to intensify his barbaric attacks against civilian and energy targets over the coming months. And when I met President Zelenskyy, I heard loud and clear the vital importance of supporting Ukraine through this winter, as did the Prime Minister.

We promised to mobilise allies and provide more support wherever we can. And we are delivering on that commitment, strengthening Ukraine's defences and, alongside over 50 nations, converting commitment into capability. That's why this week, I announced that the UK is pledging 100 million pounds to support the rapid delivery of air defence interceptors in response to a direct request from Ukraine. We also reaffirmed our commitment to provide more than 120,000 drones to Ukraine through the course of this year. In total, Madam Deputy Speaker, the United Kingdom has committed 25 billion pounds for Ukraine.

That includes nearly 20 million rounds of small arms ammunition, more than 1 million artillery shells, over 100,000 drones, and thousands of air defence missiles and armoured vehicles. Winter in Ukraine is no longer a season, it's a weapon. In Kyiv, the Prime Minister and I saw first-hand the destructive consequences of this war. But we also experienced the spirit and strength of the Ukrainian people. The message we delivered on behalf of this Government and on behalf of the British people was unequivocal.

We will be with Ukraine for as long as it takes. That commitment is built on the rock-solid foundations laid by our Labour and Conservative predecessors, who stood shoulder to shoulder with Ukraine since day one. Boris Johnson pledged anti-armour missiles before Russia's invasion. And in one of his first acts in office, my right honourable friend the Prime Minister handed over blueprints for British-made missile components so that Ukraine can produce long-range weapons on its own assembly lines.

Madam Deputy Speaker, it has been a striking feature during an especially divisive period in British politics that support for Ukraine unites this House. And one of the things I feel most strongly about in this role is showing our allies, but particularly our adversaries, that there is an enormous amount of consensus and national unity when it comes to defence. That unity is itself a projection of strength and deterrence. So I say to colleagues across this House, it is your job and the job of Parliament to hold us to account, and it is right that you do. But let's not manufacture difference where it doesn't exist.

On this issue, more than any other, there is far more that unites us than divides us. And we have a collective responsibility to level with the British people. If the first duty of government is to keep our country safe, then it is a greater, a more urgent responsibility than it has been for generations. The threats we face are not only evolving, they are getting closer to home. Every day, the UK and our allies encounter espionage, cyberattacks, and military posturing by hostile states.

Just yesterday, a 31-year-old British man was charged under the National Security Act over alleged contact with Russia's military intelligence agency. Alongside these threats comes the bellicose rhetoric we hear from the Kremlin. Russia is constantly probing us and testing us. And the tragic irony of where we find ourselves is that Russia envisages the UK and NATO as a threat which in reality simply does not exist. The UK is not at war with Russia, nor do we seek confrontation with Russia, nor do we have any quarrel with the Russian people.

All we seek to do is to defend freedom, democracy, our interests, our allies, and our values. And contrary to the propaganda, NATO has always been a defensive alliance. And if there is one thing that President Putin has achieved through the war in Ukraine, it has been to strengthen NATO and our commitment to our collective defence and security. So Moscow should be in no doubt, we are ready to defend every inch of NATO should Russia attack. But Madam Deputy Speaker, knowing the gravity of the threats our country faces, this government has overseen the biggest sustained increase in defence spending since the Cold War.

We are already investing 15 billion pounds more in defence than we were even at the last spending review. And over the next four years, we will be investing 298 billion pounds. As a percentage of GDP, we have gone from 2.3% when Labour came to office just two years ago to next year reaching 2.7%. And we know that this Prime Minister and this Chancellor are both fully committed to funding our nation's defence, including meeting our NATO commitment of 3.5% by 2035 and setting out an earlier 3% commitment at the next spending review.

No one disputes that there is more to do to get there, but it's important to emphasize just how much new money is already going into defense. That money is what allows us to do those things we need to do, to strengthen our deterrents so that our adversaries think twice about attacking us, and to strengthen our capabilities so that we have the resources to fight and win if deterrents fail. That means making sure every penny is spent wisely, both new money and existing budgets, so that our military has the equipment, the training, and the kit they need to keep us safe. It means making sure that we are constantly pushing the frontier of defense innovation so that we have an advantage over our enemies. And it means making sure that we are creating more skilled jobs, more training, and more opportunities for people and businesses in our own country, unashamedly backing British to reindustrialize the places where defense runs in the blood.

That is how we will keep our country safe in today's more dangerous and volatile world. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, as I take on this role, I feel the considerable weight of responsibility on my shoulders to proudly and robustly defend our country, our people, our values, and our allies. I am lucky that in this endeavor, I'm supported by our exceptional armed forces, some of the smartest brains on the planet, and the extraordinary service of those working around the clock and around the globe to protect us. I have seen the capabilities this country has. They are considerable.

We should have enormous pride in what our country does, let alone what we can do in the future. So this government will build a Britain worth fighting for and a Britain capable of fighting for it. That is our mission, and that is what we will do. I commend this statement to the House.

03:41:31 - 03:41:33

Speaker 217

Shadow Minister Mark Tami.

03:41:33 - 03:46:50

Mark Francois

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On behalf of the Shadow Defense team, I'd like to take this opportunity to welcome the new Defense Secretary, Labour's third in three months, to his place and to thank him for advanced sight of this important statement. On a personal note, we have a mutual friend in Labour Councillor Gareth Barrett. And I know he'd be very proud to see his long-time friend standing at the dispatch box representing the Ministry of Defence today. It's over four years now since Russia's brutal and illegal full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

But as the Ukrainians reminded me when I visited Kyiv in February, the Russo-Ukrainian war has actually been raging for 12 years, when Putin's Russia illegally annexed Crimea and parts of the Donbas, which is longer than both the First and Second World Wars combined. I'm sure I speak for the whole House today in paying tribute to the Ukrainians for their fierce and determined resistance, fighting for values of freedom and democracy which this House has represented for centuries. So when we say Slava Ukraini, we mean it. In particular, on that trip, the Speaker of the Rada said something I'll never forget. When you go back to London, tell them we know the Russians better than anybody.

And if we fall, you're next. My hon. Friend for South Shropshire, who's now joining our Shadow Defense team, has just returned from Kyiv overnight. And he reports how the Russians cynically suspended missile strikes on the capital whilst the American delegation were present, but resumed them almost immediately after their departure, and tragically a number of innocent civilians were murdered in Kyiv last night.

On supporting Ukraine and brave President Zelenskyy, there has been absolute solidarity between ourselves and the Labour Party. When I served in the Ministry of Defence following the 2014 invasion, we began training troops on Salisbury Plain via what was then known as Operation Orbital. That continues today via Operation Interflex, which between them have trained over 50,000 Ukrainian troops on British soil. The House would no doubt recall that very powerful footage from February 2022 of columns of Russian tanks being destroyed in 60 seconds in highly coordinated anti-tank ambushes north of Kyiv, carried out by Ukrainian troops, but with UK-manufactured NLAW anti-tank weapons. Had it not been for that kit and that training that accompanied it, the Russians would likely be having lunch in Kyiv today.

We all want to see a ceasefire in Ukraine, but as the Ukrainians themselves would tell us, not at any price. However, the government's policy is then to participate in a coalition of the willing in order to help maintain a ceasefire. I hope the Secretary of State can confirm that again. However, were we to deploy the British Army into Ukraine, it's very important they be adequately trained and equipped. The Defence Secretary invited the House just a few moments ago to hold him to account.

So taking him exactly at his word, I must press him on some extremely worrying reports first published in the Times on the 3rd of September last week and amplified in the journal Defence Eye just on Tuesday, that British Army training is being seriously curtailed in order to provide in-year efficiency savings, that's cuts in plain English, at Treasury behest. In the financial year 26-7, the MOD's been given a ridiculous efficiency savings target of over 3 billion pounds, much of it from operational spending such as training and exercise, and the Army's share of that is reportedly 1.2 billion. So given the seriousness of this situation, I wish to ask the Defence Secretary three very important questions. Firstly, is it true that training in both the regular and reserves is being materially constricted in order to save this money at Treasury behest? Secondly, what action is he as Defence Secretary, no doubt in consultation with the Chief of the General Staff, taking to push back against these pernicious in-year funding cuts as imposed by the Treasury?

What discussions has he had, ironically, with the new Chancellor, who resigned in June as Defence Secretary because Labour wouldn't commit to spend 3% of GDP on defence by 2030? The government cannot keep kicking this can down the road. And thirdly, in which year specifically will Labour now commit to spend 3% of GDP on defence as the Conservatives have now pledged to do by 2030 at the latest? We will not deter the likes of Vladimir Putin by capping bus fares. So in summary, Madam Deputy Speaker, we're four-square with the Ukrainians, we support the government in supporting them, but they must support our troops.

So what are they doing to training?

03:46:50 - 03:51:48

Speaker 214

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Look, can I firstly thank the right honourable gentleman for the constructive spirit with which he responded to my statement, and I very much hope that we can maintain that across both sides of the House, and I've certainly enjoyed early conversations I've had with the Shadow Secretary of State too. So we will continue to work in that spirit and maximize and project globally unity wherever we possibly can. He references I am the third Defence Secretary in recent months for reasons that are evident, and I give him an undertaking to add this to the retention priorities for the workforce, a point I made very firmly to the Prime Minister. I'm very much in favour of retention in this post.

I will just in that note, though, however, say and place on record my enormous respect and thanks to both of my Labour predecessors, the Chancellor and the Security Minister. I particularly want to pay tribute to my right honorable friend, the member for Barnsley North, who did an outstanding job during his time in this office to do some considerable heavy lifting to get the defense investment plan over the line. And not only do I thank him for it, I think the country will thank him for it in the longer term too, and I'm enjoying working with him in his post. He mentioned support for Ukraine and particularly the support we've given over a number of years on training. I should also reflect back to the House from my visit to Kyiv, what's fascinating about the evolution of this terrible war is that whereas we've spent a considerable amount of time training the Ukrainians, increasingly find it's the other way around.

We are seeing the rapid evolution of modern warfare and the Ukrainians are at the forefront of defense innovation. And we are actively learning from our Ukrainian friends, their ingenuity, their expertise. Yes, we've got to provide them with the resources they need to fight and to win, but it's also important we recognize the extraordinary capability they have under the most unimaginably difficult circumstances. He asks about the multinational force for Ukraine and, you know, we hope for the best, we plan for the worst in terms of the continuation of this war, but we are also actively working to prepare for conditions in which a ceasefire has been agreed by Ukraine and with Ukraine and from our perspective for Ukraine. I'm proud of the work we're doing, particularly with our French allies on the multinational force for Ukraine.

I enjoyed visiting MNFU in Paris during a visit to meet my French counterpart, Madame Batroun, earlier this summer, and I'm looking forward to hosting MNFU here in the UK later this year. The objective of MNFU is in the event that a ceasefire is achieved to increase Ukraine's deterrence against war breaking out again, and that is the focus of the mission there. He refers to reports in the media about training, and I just want to unpack a few points there. Firstly, we are investing more in training and it is certainly not true to say that training has ceased. There has absolutely been, and to be fair to the right honorable gentleman, he didn't make that claim, but I have seen people draw that conclusion from some of the reports.

Of course training continues. There has been some reprioritization to make sure we're prioritizing those activities that will provide most impact at this point in time. I do acknowledge, though, that one of our responsibilities as a department is to live within our means. And one of the disciplines that I have to bring to the Ministry of Defence, drawing on my experience at the Department of Health and Social Care and the NHS, is to make sure that there is not a culture of routine overspending, to make sure we are improving productivity, to make sure we deliver value for money, and that we recognize that the money we're investing in defense comes at choices and trade-offs that apply across government and also rest ultimately with the taxpayer. And yes, we've got to make the case for more defense investment and spending, and we will, and we see that across the House.

But what we shouldn't enable in the process is a distraction from making sure we live within our means, that we deliver capability and effect and impact, and we treat every penny of taxpayer's money wisely. And I hear from the opposition benches that they agree with that point. Finally, he tempts me to announce the date at which we will hit 3% spending. He will know that getting ahead of a Chancellor and a spending review is a breach of the ministerial code, and having resigned from government once already, I have no intention of doing so again today.

03:51:49 - 03:52:45

Alex Baker

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It was great to welcome my honourable friend to Farnborough Airshow and great to have him at the dispatch box this morning. Our adversaries in China and Russia are mobilizing their financial markets to sustain military aggression. We've seen the industrial ramp-up that has been needed in Ukraine to fight. The PM confirmed to me last week that the government is looking at the Multilateral Defence Security and Resilience Bank, which had been brought together by our allies to mobilize the finance to rearm.

The Secretary of State and I have talked about this a lot previously, but does he agree with me that we need to build the financial resilience to deter and that we should take this opportunity to join the Defence Security and Resilience Bank to send a powerful signal to our adversaries that we have the financial firepower to outbuild and outlast them.

03:52:45 - 03:53:26

Speaker 214

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I find myself having rapidly gone from asking questions about the DSRB to now answering questions about the DSRB, so she will know that I've been tracking developments on this Canadian-led initiative very closely and I can certainly see the enormous benefits of DSRB and the objectives that Prime Minister Carney has. We're tracking that progress, we're talking to our Canadian allies and we're also considering how that could work alongside the MDM initiative that was led by our former Chancellor, the Right Honourable Member for Leeds West. As those discussions continue, I will keep the House informed.

03:53:26 - 03:53:29

Speaker 221

Liberal Democrat spokesperson James MacCleary.

03:53:29 - 03:55:47

James MacCleary

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I also welcome the new Secretary of State to his new role and thank him for advance sight of his statement. And I say to the new Secretary of State, the Liberal Democrats continue to stand ready to work constructively with the government in the interests of our national security and indeed Ukraine is a great example of where we have that common ground. The Secretary of State is quite right, of course, that Ukraine's security is our security. And as another winter approaches, Russia will once again seek to weaponize the freezing cold weather to attack Ukraine's energy infrastructure and harm the civilian population. So the additional £100 million for air defence interceptors is therefore a really welcome move.

I'd like to ask the Secretary of State what discussions he is holding with NATO allies to secure more air defence systems and interceptors for Ukraine before the winter sets in. And is the UK prepared to provide further assistance should the request be made. We also welcome the government's recognition of the need to increase defence investment. However, the defence investment plan is still not fully funded and given the threats we face, progress on the government's commitment to raise defence spending to 3% of GDP remains slow. In response to the UK supplying technology for deep strike capability, Russia has stated that UK military installations and equipment both inside Ukraine and beyond its borders are now considered legitimate targets.

That only adds to the urgent need for investment in our national defence. That is why the Liberal Democrats are proposing issuing defence bonds. A plan to raise £20 billion over two years meeting the urgency of the situation head-on. So will the Secretary of State urge the Chancellor to consider defence bonds and perhaps he could share his own view with the House on this idea. Finally, we must do more to cut off the funding that fuels Putin's war machine.

Supported by Western-linked shipping, insurance and financial services, Russian fossil fuels continue to flow into global markets. Will the Secretary of State push within the government for tougher action to crack down on activities facilitating Russian fossil fuel exports and work with allies to impose a comprehensive ban on supporting Russian oil, gas and coal. Ukraine is fighting for its survival and for the security of our entire continent. The UK must continue to stand with it.

03:55:37 - 03:58:32

Speaker 214

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Liberal Democrat spokesperson for his constructive support and scrutiny. Through our work with my German counterpart Boris Pistorius and our coalition we are regularly mobilizing more support for Ukraine both through direct contributions but also through active defense diplomacy. And I'm particularly grateful to my right honorable friend the Foreign Secretary for the support of his department in those efforts too. Every country involved in supporting Ukraine faces the same choices and trade-offs that we're debating here at home.

And in that spirit we approach those conversations but we also ask people to think about the consequences were Putin to prevail and take from that the incentive to further threaten Russia's neighbors and our NATO allies. And that is why I make the case that supporting Ukraine is the right thing to do morally but it is also the right thing to do in our national interest and the interest of the collective security of our continent. He refers to the defense investment plan and raises the issue of defense spending. And I just want to be clear about two things. One is we are already delivering the largest sustained increase in defense spending since the Cold War.

That is a significant improvement on the previous position. And we are also ahead of the you know he mentions the DIP not being fully funded. It is absolutely true to say that where the negotiations around the DIP reached was a position where there is a shortfall just shy of five billion pounds which we need to deal with in the immediate term. And the House should take reassurance from the fact about the instincts of this Chancellor and the government that without any need for persuasion from me or my department whatsoever this Chancellor has already confirmed he will close that gap at this budget. So I'm reassured by that and that gives me even greater confidence as the Chancellor looks ahead to the spending review.

But that doesn't mean we should be complacent about as a as a department and as a team in defense making the strongest possible case recognizing the trade-offs across government. So we will continue to approach the spending review process in that spirit. And finally he also raises defense financing. It is true to say that defense bonds are borrowing. And nonetheless we continue to work closely with our colleagues at Treasury and with our industry partners to do to look at what more we can do to leverage finance for defense and to do so in a way that creates jobs skills opportunities and re-industrialization here in Britain.

03:58:32 - 03:58:47

Speaker 224

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Could the Secretary of State please outline what assessment the government has made about recent statements from Moscow regarding the United Kingdom. Thank you.

03:58:47 - 03:59:57

Speaker 214

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. There's a distinction to be drawn between what the Kremlin says and what it does. And some of the performative displays we've seen from Russia in recent months and I think particularly about some of their actions in the channel and then the actual threats that we deal with and deter and repel on a daily basis. The British people should be in no doubt about the threat and intent of Russia but they should also draw confidence in our capability.

What we've been debating actively in this House, and we ought to debate more widely as a country, is how we maintain our ability to deter and how we build our capability to respond to evolving threats given the way in which modern warfare is changing as we're seeing in Europe. So, you know, the overall posture of the country ought to be to be alert to the Russian threat, but certainly not alarmed, and proud of the capability that we have even as we seek to fund and build more.

03:59:57 - 03:59:59

Speaker 222

Dr. Andrew Murrison.

03:59:59 - 04:00:39

Andrew Murrison

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's good to hear that the government plans to replenish the dwindling stocks of Patriot missiles in Ukraine, which I suspect they're going to need this winter. However, Patriot is low volume and high cost, and what the Ukrainians need is high volume and low cost. So what assessment has he made of the First Point Consortium's Fraia missile system that stands every chance of providing the solution to this conundrum, not just for Ukraine, but also for the UK and its allies in NATO as we try to face down this threat from Russia?

04:00:39 - 04:01:18

Speaker 214

Can I thank the right honourable gentleman for his question and also put on record my respect for the expertise and experience he brings to debates on defence in this House. He's absolutely right about what the objective needs to be: lower cost, higher impact. We are actively working to drive innovation in this space, particularly through initiatives like Breakstop, and we are tracking our allies who are also actively seeking to push the frontier of defence innovation in this space. I'll of course keep the House updated as those initiatives progress.

04:01:18 - 04:01:20

Speaker 223

Joanna Baxter.

04:01:20 - 04:02:07

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome my right honourable friend to his place, and I'm very pleased that he has now seen for himself, as I have, the reality of Russia's illegal war on the ground in Ukraine. So I know he will share my concerns about the deeply troubling report contained in yesterday's Telegraph that SAS veterans are training Russians to fight Ukraine. They actually state an assessment compiled for Five Eyes intelligence agencies found with strong confidence that Western military veterans had been recruited to train Russian citizens as well as active duty personnel. Will he investigate as a matter of urgency those reports and report back to the House?

04:02:07 - 04:04:12

Speaker 214

I'm grateful to my honourable friend for raising this very serious and important issue, and she will understand that as a matter of policy I will not comment on intelligence, but I will address the reports that she has raised. One of the great privileges of being in this post in the last seven weeks has been meeting the people and seeing the capability that our special forces have. It is truly remarkable, and my only regret is that we are not able to show, for obvious reasons, the country more publicly of just how exceptional these people and their capabilities are. It is in that spirit that I find it utterly unthinkable and shameful that anyone who has served this country in whatever capacity would think it in any way acceptable to support the Russian state as it wages war in Ukraine. Their fight is our fight, their frontline is the frontline for freedom and democracy, and those actions are an affront not only to this country and to our values, but to the values that underpin the uniform that those who serve our armed forces wear.

I know I speak for the entire armed forces community in that, and let me just reassure the House and send a very clear message that we have robust legislation in place to tackle foreign hostile activity. The NSA gives our intelligence agencies and the police the tools they need to detect and disrupt threats, but the National Security Act specifies under its interpretations that information includes information about tactics, techniques, and procedures, and is applicable to any individual and extends beyond the period in which personnel are employed by the UK armed forces. Let that be a warning to anyone who has or considers supporting the Russians as they wage war in Ukraine.

04:04:12 - 04:05:52

Julian Lewis

I warmly endorse almost everything that the Secretary of State has said today, and I genuinely congratulate him on his appointment. In my first speech in this House almost 30 years ago, I promised to support Labour governments as long as they supported the nuclear deterrent, the conventional armed forces, and NATO, and I'd like to think that I've kept that promise. The one area where I have to dissent, however, is the section where he comes on to the proportion of GDP spent on defence. As I've said to some of his predecessors, it is no good banging on about something being the largest increase since the end of the Cold War. We are now in a situation that is worse than that at the height of the Cold War, and so the comparison we have to make is what we're spending now with what we spent during the Cold War, which was, in modern calculating methods, between 4.5 and 5.1% on defence.

So let us not talk about increases to 2.7%. We really must remember that even when the Berlin Wall came down, we were spending over 4% of GDP at that stage. These are the sort of efforts that we have to make because if Putin fails in Ukraine, then the threat to this country will recede for a generation.

04:05:52 - 04:07:37

Speaker 214

Can I thank the right honourable gentleman for his question and give him an undertaking to make it as easy as possible on those three things: supporting the nuclear deterrent, building capacity in our armed forces, and supporting NATO. Those are things I believe very strongly in and I will make it as easy as possible for him to support this government. But in the spirit of these exchanges, I will absolutely just take at face value the point he makes about the comparison with the Cold War and resist the temptation to get into the starting point that this government arrived with on defence spending and the condition of our armed forces. I think he's right to draw historical comparisons and to provoke all of us to think more widely about the kind of context we're operating in domestically, across Europe, and internationally. I don't think, and I've not heard from the official opposition, a suggestion that the government should be making a 4% commitment or a 5% commitment and certainly no proposals to that effect.

But let this help the public to understand why, at a time of constrained resources for households, for businesses, and indeed for government, we are making an active political choice to invest more in our defence. Because I respectfully say, as someone who has been responsible for hospitals and the NHS, that schools, hospitals, homes, those are important things, but they are valueless if those things are reduced to rubble. That is the experience of the Ukrainians. That is the kind of threat we are operating amongst, and that is why we must commit and continue to commit to increased defence spending.

04:07:37 - 04:08:42

Speaker 226

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I warmly congratulate the Defence Secretary on his appointment. I'd like to raise awareness with him of a range of fantastic organisations and charities around the country that regularly do convoys from the UK to Ukraine, and not just in terms of humanitarian aid, but some military equipment, including pickup trucks that are repurposed so soldiers can use. And I've had the honour of going out on one of these and driving one of these vehicles myself. Unfortunately, there are a number of issues that could make that journey, these journeys smoother, right from making it easier for public bodies such as hospitals to get rid of old vehicles in the UK that are coming to the end of their life and place them in the hands of these organisations, as well as issues, frankly, on the Polish side of the border, where the approach is less than consistent and sometimes these convoys can be held up for hours unnecessarily. So would it be possible to meet with an MOD official for them to meet with me and some of these organisations to just thrash through some of these issues and help increase the impact of their brilliant work further?

04:08:42 - 04:09:41

Speaker 214

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank my honourable friend for all of the work he's doing in this space and the considerable experience and expertise he brings to debates on these issues. I'm really proud of the fact that in addition to the support that we've provided as a government, the five hundred and seventy-seven million pounds in humanitarian assistance, that the British people have gone above and beyond and dug deep through financial contributions and through gifts in kind to actively support our friends in Ukraine, and of course welcoming Ukrainian families into their homes. It is why when the Prime Minister and I were in Kyiv, we were able to say with confidence and credibility that our support wasn't just on behalf of the government, but on behalf of people up and down our country. I'm very much up for supporting those sorts of initiatives described by my honourable friend, and I'd be very happy to facilitate the meeting he asked for.

04:09:41 - 04:09:43

Speaker 228

Christine Jardine.

04:09:43 - 04:10:32

Christine Jardine

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome everything that the Secretary of State for Defence has said today. I was particularly taken by what he said about learning from Ukraine. Learning not just the way that warfare has developed. I think we also have to develop from, we also have to learn from Ukrainian society. I've been involved with an event I organised here with a Ukrainian organisation called Still We Love, and I'm doing one in Edinburgh next month.

And that's the loved ones and partners of those who are on the front and who've been left at home and who are trying to build resilience in society. Does the Defence Secretary agree with me that we have to look as well at building our defences as building our social resilience and making sure that our fire service, police service, our NHS is ready in case of Russian aggression?

04:10:32 - 04:11:33

Speaker 214

Strongly agree with the honourable member. Thank her for her support. We've had under a Labour government a resilience committee of the National Security Council to play other government departments into the conversation about national defence and resilience, which I certainly benefited from as the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care and also was able to respond to and to plan for. We do need a wider national conversation. And government is very happy to lead it, and we will, but it does need to involve everyone: government, business, civil society, all of us as citizens.

And that's not just in the context of warfare and security threats this country faces, as I reflected recently, it is in the context of wildfires, in the context of flooding, in the context of a wide range of disruptions this country could face. We are not as prepared as we ought to be, and as a result, we need to work collectively to improve our national resilience because it is everyone's responsibility and duty as a citizen.

04:11:33 - 04:12:18

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Fleur Anderson.

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I have been shocked to hear evidence from Amnesty International about Russia's criminal trafficking of people from around the world taking them taking their passports away giving them a gun they had a promise of a job giving them a gun and sent off to the front line to have to fight. This is the enemy that we are talking about. This is the enemy that I am proud to hear all of the things that the Defense Secretary has talked about including and especially the Patriot missiles which I know from talking to Ukrainian parliamentarians and politicians that is what they have been asking for. With another winter coming in the war can the Secretary of State outline how the UK support is matching what Ukraine needs to win this war.

04:12:18 - 04:12:48

Speaker 214

I'm grateful to my honorable friend for her question and she's absolutely right to nail the character of this particular regime that we are facing. It is through our leadership of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group that we are mobilizing support for Ukraine and making sure that the support that we provide matches what the Ukrainians need and I engage very closely with my Ukrainian counterpart Minister Kamara and will continue to do so.

04:12:48 - 04:13:32

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Alicia Kearns.

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I welcome the Defense Secretary to his place. Romanian Polish and Latvian airspace have all been violated by the Putin regime in the last year and Russian drones are regularly shot down over NATO territory yet the threshold for a NATO response is far too high. That only encourages Russia's recklessness it encourages their probing of us and it means the risk of miscalculation by them or attack on us becomes that much higher. So will the Defense Secretary commit to working with allies to increase the number of Article 4 recommendations put forward the number of Article 4 referrals so that we crack down on these because when we don't pay any attention to them when we dismiss them we only put the consequences higher of the risk to us and we do not deter against future threats.

04:13:32 - 04:14:05

Speaker 214

I'm grateful to the honorable member welcome her support and value her expertise in these matters. I would say to her two things she's right to flag the issue of miscalculation and that's all the more reason for us to have a number of lines into into Moscow to avoid that risk of miscalculation and she is right to challenge all of us across the NATO alliance to think about how we provide the right level of deterrence and I will certainly reflect on what she has said.

04:14:05 - 04:14:56

Tim Roca

Tim Roca.

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I welcome the Defense Secretary to his place and his absolute commitment to our national security and also the very mature tone of his statement talking about working cross-party on what is in our national interest. We've seen Madam Deputy Speaker the critical importance of integrated missile and air defense evidenced by the war in Ukraine and the need for low-cost options that tackle cheap Shahed-style drones through to ballistic missiles. We've also seen that you not only need the asset you also need the ability to replenish stocks rapidly. Many countries in Europe Spain Germany France and so on have Patriot or SAMP/T systems but the UK currently lacks a ground-based missile interceptor. Can I ask him to talk a little bit about what progress the government has made on procuring the right range of air defenses for our own national defense and in building our industrial capacity.

04:14:56 - 04:15:32

Speaker 214

Can I thank my honorable friend for his support and the work that he does particularly in the NATO context. Let me just reassure him that through the defense investment plan we're investing 790 million pounds for new homeland integrated air and missile defense building on our broader air defense investments including directed energy weapons Sea Viper upgrades and a new integrated airspace and missile defense operations center.

He is right to bring scrutiny to this issue and it's right that the House maintains its focus on improving our air defenses, not least given what we're seeing in Ukraine.

04:15:32 - 04:16:24

John Whittingdale

Sir John Whittingdale.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I first of all strongly welcome the Secretary of State's confirmation of our continuing support for Ukraine? But he has set out the sustained threat which is faced not just by Ukraine, but by this country and the whole of Europe from Russia. Yet for too many people, it is still business as usual. So will he consider first of all a public awareness campaign to raise awareness of the threat, as is now being taking place in Finland and in the Baltic states?

And what message does he have to the companies that continue to trade in Russia and by doing so, both undermine sanctions and provide funds for Russia's war machine?

04:16:24 - 04:17:07

Speaker 214

I'll consider some parliamentary words in response to the right honorable gentleman's second part of that question. It's an extremely serious issue. And I think the companies concerned and those with executive decision-making responsibility ought to think about the level of risk involved to this country, this continent, and the values that we're trying to uphold in supporting our friends in Ukraine. Let me just reassure him, the national conversation we need to have is very high on my list of priorities. We do need to raise awareness.

We don't need to raise alarm, but we do need to raise awareness and that is both in a conventional defense and security context and a wider national resilience context. And I'll report back to the House on plans for a national conversation.

04:17:07 - 04:18:51

John Slinger

John Stinger.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Ukrainians living in my constituency of Rugby contacted me ahead of this statement and not only to inform me of the devastating attacks in the Sumy region overnight, including on a shopping center and on trains. But I asked one of these people what they think is missing from the debate here. And if you'll allow me, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to read what this person said. And I quote: "The constant psychological pressure.

When you live inside it, everything feels incredibly urgent. If drones are flying towards your city, every minute matters. And then you look at the outside world where decisions naturally take weeks or months and it can feel painfully slow and very far away. Sometimes you feel almost alone in it. There is also the information war.

After years of this, people are exhausted and of course there is anger. Why was this not stopped? Why is there not more protection? Russia tries to use exactly that exhaustion and fear and frustration to deepen mistrust. At the same time, it pushes another message outside Ukraine, that Ukrainians are tired of fighting, that Ukraine cannot win, and that continued support is pointless.

But that is not what I hear from the people I know. They are exhausted, yes. They are frightened and angry. But they do not want to surrender. They want the opposite.

The chance to live their normal lives again without Russia deciding whether they can sleep, travel, work, keep warm, or see their family." So will my right honorable friend just reiterate once again that this House is united in standing with Ukraine and helping them militarily and diplomatically, economically, and for the psychological battle?

04:18:51 - 04:19:34

Speaker 214

I'm really grateful to my honorable friend for that very powerful contribution. I'm glad he shared it with us and that those first-hand words from Ukraine are on the record. I want to reassure on two points in there. The first is we recognize that challenge on pace and I'm determined to keep up momentum through the UDCG and we'll be meeting again in November. And the second point is I want to pay tribute to the leadership of Ukraine, the Ukrainian people, but also President Zelenskyy and his team operating in the most extraordinarily difficult circumstances.

I think the Ukrainian people can be proud of his leadership and they can be proud of their resilience too.

04:19:34 - 04:20:18

Speaker 241

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome the Secretary of State to his place and also say how pleased I am that the honorable member for Plymouth Sutton and Devonport remains a member of the defense team too. On the 19th of March last year, Madam Deputy Speaker, I asked the former Prime Minister about the seizing of Russian assets. There's reported 185 billion pounds worth of Russian assets in Europe and 30 billion alone in the UK. And the Prime Minister responded and I quote, it is complicated, it is not straightforward, but we are working with others to see what is possible.

So will the new administration now act like you have done on Gaza when previously you said it was too complicated.

04:20:18 - 04:20:43

Speaker 214

Well, of course, as my honorable friend the Minister he praises has just remarked, it is difficult and it is complicated, but I take up the challenge. We do want to do everything we can in this space and we'll continue, he's right to keep pressing us on this and keep it in line of sight. We will continue to do as much as we can as fast as we can.

04:20:43 - 04:21:27

David William Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Warmly welcome my right honorable friend to his place and I also want to thank him for characterizing this conflict as one between freedom or tyranny. I was very privileged to go to Kyiv in July in my role as UK special envoy for freedom of religion or belief. And whilst there, I heard from our Ukrainian partners about how the Putin regime is weaponizing the Russian Orthodox Church, particularly in the occupied territories, such that no one there can have freedom of religion or belief unless they are in the Russian Orthodox Church. And that includes other Christians or Tatars in Crimea.

So would my right honorable friend agree with me that a key dividing line in this conflict is about freedom of religion or belief, is about wider human rights between a Ukrainian free open democracy and an increasingly authoritarian Russia.

04:21:27 - 04:21:55

Speaker 214

Can I express my thanks to my honorable friend for that question. I wholeheartedly agree with him. And I would just make the point, particularly around the weaponization of Christianity, that's not just something we're seeing in Russia, that is something we're seeing here in Britain too. And if people are going to wear the cross, they should at least bother to read the gospel before preaching the contrary message.

04:21:55 - 04:22:31

Blake Stephenson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Secretary of State for his statement and also welcome him to his place and welcome the ongoing commitment to defend Ukraine. In the Secretary of State's statement, he reaffirmed the UK's commitment to provide more than 120,000 drones to Ukraine through the course of this year. I very much welcome this. He also mentioned the recent plot to sabotage a UK drone factory.

What action is being taken to ensure UK manufacturing facilities are safe and secure and if any action is required, who's funding that.

04:22:31 - 04:22:54

Speaker 214

I'm grateful for his support on Ukraine and he's right to raise the issue. He will understand I'm not going to comment on operational details. Suffice to say that we do take threats to this country and our assets seriously and we work closely across society to make sure people are prepared for any challenges they may encounter.

04:22:54 - 04:23:26

Mohammad Yasin

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. If Russia succeeds in weaponizing the freezing winter by destroying civilian power grids, the United Kingdom and the rest of Europe will face a vastly superior threat. So will the Defense Secretary confirm that helping Ukraine stop these attacks is not only the right thing to do for our Ukrainian allies, but a strategic necessity to directly safeguard the long-term security interests of the British people.

04:23:26 - 04:23:43

Speaker 214

I wholeheartedly agree with my honorable friend and it is important that we continue to make this case that supporting Ukraine is the right thing to do morally, but it is also an act of national self-interest and national security for us in Britain too.

04:23:43 - 04:24:32

Clive Jones

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I welcome the Secretary of State to his new position.

The Wokingham area is home to many Ukrainians who are concerned that international support is weakening for their fight against the Russian invasion. Like me they will welcome the assurances from the Secretary of State that this government will continue supporting Ukraine against Russian expansion and the same strong commitment from the Prime Minister. But can the Secretary of State confirm that this support will continue even if the USA under President Trump back away even more from supporting Ukraine.

04:24:32 - 04:25:18

Speaker 214

Can I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. I have to say in my experience international support is galvanising and remains extremely strong and resilient for Ukraine and I've seen no sign of that commitment weakening in fact only this week we've seen significant commitments made right across Europe and beyond to support our friends in Ukraine. And I have to say in relation to the United States too I've found them actively engaged on this issue in our bilateral conversations and the diplomatic track that the Americans are driving is also important. So I think it's important not to understate the level of engagement and commitment we are seeing from our friends in Washington.

04:25:19 - 04:25:47

James William Naish

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Secretary of State knows how drone technology has transformed activities in Ukraine. He will appreciate the importance of innovative companies like Skycutter to my regional economy in the East Midlands. They won a major contract with the US government and have been encouraged to move there but I would like to see them investing here in the UK. So I wonder if he can confirm to me what specific measures he'll be taking to make sure that UK-based drone companies stay and manufacture here in our country.

04:25:47 - 04:26:27

Speaker 214

I'm so grateful to my honourable friend for once again raising this issue with me now on the record his constituents should know he has been actively campaigning on this around the corridors of this place too. And the minister will be very pleased to meet them about his constituency-based issue but just to say to the whole House that there is a big opportunity with our defence investment to reindustrialise this country to create jobs to create growth and to create opportunities and they will see the commitment of this government this Prime Minister this Chancellor and this Defence Secretary reflected in deeds not just in words in the coming weeks and months.

04:26:27 - 04:26:28

Richard Tice.

04:26:28 - 04:27:01

Richard Tice

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I welcome the Secretary of State to his place. I knew it wouldn't be long before we would see him back on the front bench. With regard to the frozen Russian central bank assets I've urged the government before to use these and as he has just previously said to another honourable member it may be difficult but that doesn't mean it's impossible. And given the leadership the United Kingdom has shown on leading the way can I urge the Secretary of State to lead the way in turning the difficult into the possible.

04:27:01 - 04:27:14

Speaker 214

I will resist making the point made by the opposition front bench to maintain the tone of these exchanges. Let me just say simply to the honourable gentleman that that is absolutely the challenge that I will take up.

04:27:14 - 04:27:45

Alex Barros

Alex Barros-Curtis.

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I welcome my right honourable friend to his place and thank him for his statement. The New York Times today published an article saying that Ukraine has a defence budget shortfall of around twenty billion pounds. Now he will know that more than a hundred and forty-five billion pounds of frozen Russian assets are currently being held in the Euroclear system in Belgium.

So will he work with European partners in order to press Belgium to release that funding so it can fill those shortfalls and secure Ukraine and secure European defense?

04:27:45 - 04:28:06

Speaker 214

My honorable friend is absolutely right to link those two issues as we've heard from across the house. And I can assure him, particularly through the UDCG but also through our bilateral conversations, we'll continue to do whatever we can to liberate frozen Russian assets and put them in Ukrainian hands to fight for Ukrainian freedom.

04:28:06 - 04:28:46

Thomas Gordon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Secretary of State to his place and support the statement that he's just made. I'd like to just press him a little bit further upon the point that my colleague, the Liberal Democrat defense spokesperson, made about looking to turn off the taps on the Russian war machine when it comes to funding. Earlier in this parliament, I raised the issue of cultural exports like the likes of Masha and the Bear and how that was directly contributing to the Russian war machine. Ukraine has now sanctioned Masha and the Bear, but it's still on ITVX and Netflix in the UK.

Will he work with his cabinet colleagues to look at how we can make sure that we tackle the ways in which Russia finances its war in the round?

04:28:46 - 04:29:00

Speaker 214

Can I thank the honorable gentleman for raising that issue and that example? And I know that across government, there's a real willingness across the cabinet for people to, through their departments, do more to support Ukraine. So I'll certainly pick that issue up.

04:29:00 - 04:29:19

Speaker 256

Speaker, and I thank my right honorable friend for his statement. We know that Putin will be preparing to use winter as a weapon by continuing barbaric attacks against civilian and energy targets in Ukraine. Can the Secretary of State outline the steps that this government is taking to mobilize allies and provide more support wherever we can?

04:29:19 - 04:29:42

Speaker 214

I'm grateful to my honorable friend for that question. And I'm proud of the role that the UK is showing through the UDCG with our friends and allies. We will continue to mobilize international support in that way to raise the resources and the capability that Ukraine needs to win their freedom.

04:29:42 - 04:30:18

John Richard Foord

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I agree with the Secretary of State that differences on defense should not be manufactured for party political advantage. And it's sad to see this happen elsewhere in Europe. The EU still gets 12% of its gas imports from Russia. And while this is down from 45% before the full-scale invasion, the proceeds are still fueling the Russian war machine.

So as well as unity across the house, what is he doing to maintain unity across Europe, including to encourage our friends in the European Union to cease all imports of Russian gas?

04:30:18 - 04:30:47

Speaker 214

Well, I certainly welcome the support we've seen from member states of the European Union through the UDCG. But I also want to pay tribute to the work that the European Union has been doing itself to mobilize support and financing for Ukraine, including some considerable announcements made only very recently. He's right to raise the issue of Russian imports. And of course, these are the sorts of conversations we have with our friends and allies.

04:30:47 - 04:31:21

Chris Kane

The threat from Russia is clearly changing the way we think about the defense of our country, in our country. In my constituency, the Civil Defense Social Club still exists, but civil defense itself does not. What discussions is the Defense Secretary having with cabinet colleagues and crucially the devolved nations as well, including the Scottish government, about what modern civil defense should look like? As many countries demonstrate, the closer you get to the Russian border, the more military and civil society converge in a system of mutual deterrence and, if ever required, national defense.

04:31:21 - 04:31:26

Speaker 249

What more should Britain learn from that whole of society approach?

04:31:26 - 04:32:09

Speaker 214

My honorable friend is absolutely right to raise this issue and the importance of learning from those who lead by example. We do need to raise our game in this respect. We absolutely will and we're drawing on international counterparts as we prepare for our own national conversation and also thinking through the capability we need in terms of national resilience too. I'm very happy to involve them in those conversations and also underscore the importance of UK government, this is our responsibility, working closely with devolved governments as well. And I really want to have a constructive relationship in this post with Scottish, Welsh government as well as the Northern Ireland executive.

04:32:09 - 04:32:11

Speaker 247

Perremu.

04:32:11 - 04:32:52

Perran Moon

Moras, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the defense secretary to his place. This morning, the Parliamentary Assembly to the Council of Europe has proposed a mechanism that could allow Ukraine to receive frozen Russian assets based on rulings by the European Court of Human Rights. The document states that directing Russian assets towards compensating Ukraine could be a legitimate countermeasure and is consistent with the norms of international law. Can the Secretary of State consider this mechanism in relation to the UK's seized Russian assets as well as in discussions with European allies?

04:32:52 - 04:33:15

Speaker 214

I can certainly give my honorable friend the assurance we'll look very carefully at this development. I'm keen to do all we can to liberate Russian assets to invest in Ukraine's defense. And I'm grateful to his question for also invoking the ECHR in a positive context, which is not always a feature of debate in this house.

04:33:15 - 04:33:47

Peter Swallow

Peter Swalla.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This government through its representation of the People Bill is already doing a lot to protect our democracy from dodgy foreign donations. But my right honorable friend will know I'm concerned as well about foreign mis- and disinformation undermining our democracy, our support for Ukraine, and our community cohesion. So what conversations is he having with cabinet colleagues about what more we can do to target foreign mis- and disinformation, particularly from Russia, and protect our democracy?

04:33:47 - 04:34:46

Speaker 214

My honorable friend is absolutely right to raise this, raise this issue. And as well as land, air, sea, space, and cyber, we should absolutely see information and communication as a front in modern warfare and as a risk to our own national security. We actively robust, rebut Russian misinformation and disinformation as well as mis- and disinformation from other state and non-state actors who pose a threat to our democracy and our way of life. There is more to do and this certainly needs to form part of the national conversation because this is where each of us can play a part, particularly at a time when trust in politics is low, trust in mainstream media is low, and we need in the context of the threats we face to completely change the dial on the level of trust and confidence that the public have in us.

04:34:46 - 04:35:42

Christopher John Vince

And the final question on this statement, Chris Vince.

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I welcome the new defense secretary to his place and thank you, thank him for his statement, particularly his ongoing commitment to support our Ukrainian allies. Going last in a question answer is very difficult, particularly when the member from Bracknell asked exactly the question I was going to ask. So I'm desperately trying to think of something else to ask. But I would absolutely echo what my honorable friend from Bracknell said about disinformation online, normally from Russian sources, whether it's extreme right-wing views or extreme left-wing views. These views, these AI-generated nonsense is designed to disrupt and to undermine our democracy.

So can I ask the Secretary of State as the last question to reflect on that, but also to once again give this government, this Labour government's commitment to support our Ukrainian allies?

04:35:42 - 04:36:23

Speaker 214

I'm very grateful to my honorable friend, the member for Harlow.

He should know by now that repetition is not a crime in the House of Commons. It is a regular feature of our exchanges. I'm very much looking forward to working with him in this capacity. He managed to leverage an enormous amount of money out of me when I was the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, and I'm looking forward to those high-security containment labs being up and running in his Harlow constituency before too long. Let me also give a commitment to him not only to support Ukraine and to continue to press on investing more in our national defence and security, but also to make sure the good people of Harlow benefit from the jobs that defence provides in his constituency, not least through Raytheon.

04:36:23 - 04:36:53

Speaker 257

And that concludes this statement. I'll give the frontbenchers a few moments to shuffle along. We now come to the presentation of bills. Presentation of bill, Secretary Heidi Alexander.

04:36:53 - 04:36:59

Heidi Alexander

I beg to move the Financing Bill.

04:36:59 - 04:37:00

Second reading what day?

04:37:01 - 04:37:09

Speaker 257

Tomorrow. Presentation of bill, Gideon Amos.

04:37:09 - 04:37:11

Gideon Amos

Housing Bill.

04:37:11 - 04:37:12

Second reading what day?

04:37:12 - 04:37:14

Speaker 255

Friday, 27th of November.

04:37:14 - 04:37:23

Speaker 252

Friday, the 27th of November. The Clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.

04:37:23 - 04:37:27

Speaker 258

Social Housing Bill [Lords], second reading.

04:37:27 - 04:37:38

Speaker 252

The reasoned amendment in the name of the official opposition has been selected. Minister to move second reading. Minister.

04:37:38 - 04:39:31

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that the bill be now read a second time. Good housing is the foundation of a flourishing life. Decent, safe, secure and affordable homes provide a platform for families to live, grow and build better lives. They make for stronger, healthier and happier communities.

Everyone, and I mean everyone, deserves to have one. Yet as we all know, far too many families in need across the country are languishing on social housing waiting lists, struggling in the private rented sector or in expensive temporary accommodation as a result, and driving up rents and the housing benefit bill in the process. At the same time, the ability and willingness of councils to invest in the building of new social rented homes has been undermined by the steady and significant loss of existing stock through the Right to Buy scheme. It is for these reasons that the government committed in its manifesto to delivering the biggest increase in social and affordable housebuilding in a generation, to prioritising the building of new social rented homes, to enhancing protections for existing and new-build social housing, and to supporting councils and housing associations to make a greater contribution to affordable housing supply. In the 26 months we've been in office, we've faithfully sought to honour those commitments, making the biggest long-term investment in social and affordable housing in recent memory, vigorously prioritising social rented housing, rebuilding the capacity of councils and housing associations to borrow and invest in new and existing homes, reinvigorating council housebuilding, and taking initial steps to better protect existing stock.

This bill supplements those efforts. It builds on the funding and regulatory certainty that we've already given the sector, and it supports the five-step plan we published last summer to deliver a decade of renewal for social and affordable housing.

04:39:31 - 04:40:16

İmran Hussein

I'm very grateful to the Minister, and he starts off very strong by highlighting the real reason why this bill is here. And he's absolutely right that for many families, the only option is social housing to find that dignity, security and stability.

In my own community, 25,000 adults are waiting for social housing. So I absolutely welcome the government's ambition for 39 billion over the next 10 years for social and affordable housing. Will the Minister make it clear, he alluded to this in his earlier submissions, that he will make sure that all the resources and flexibility is available for local councils to deliver on this pledge?

04:40:16 - 04:43:04

Matthew Pennycook

We absolutely do need to give local councils that flexibility. My honourable friend is right, we've already helped councils to build their capacity. We've allowed them to keep, as I'll come on to say, 100% of right to buy receipts. We are looking at everything we need to do to move the dial when it comes to house building and build on the steps we've already taken. Madam Deputy Speaker, the bill has three core objectives.

First, to protect much-needed social housing stock and thereby incentivise the building of more social rented homes. Second, to create a fairer tenancy system with greater protections for tenants who are victims of domestic abuse. Third, to reduce unnecessary bureaucracy and give providers greater regulatory certainty so that they can invest in new social and affordable homes with confidence. Let me provide some further detail on each in turn, starting with measures designed to better protect existing social housing stock and incentivise the building of more social homes. At the heart of the bill are comprehensive reforms to the right to buy scheme.

In speaking to them, I want to emphasise that we are not abolishing the right to buy. I know and respect the fact that there are honourable and right honourable members who object to that decision in principle. But this government remains firmly of the view that social housing tenants who have lived in and paid rent on their homes for many years should retain the opportunity to purchase them with a reasonable discount. We do, however, need to radically reform the right to buy to reduce the significant outflow of stock that has taken place since discounts were drastically increased by the coalition government in 2012, to incentivise councils to build, and to attract broader investment into council housing. As honourable members will know, we've already acted to reduce maximum right to buy cash discounts, to increase the cost floor protection period, as I've just said to my honourable friend, to ensure councils keep 100% of right to buy receipts, and to allow them to combine those receipts with developer contributions and grant funding.

The bill delivers the broader set of reforms necessary to put in place a fair and sustainable right to buy scheme for the future, informed by the feedback we received to the public consultation that ran from November 2024 to January 2025. Key measures in the bill include increasing the right to buy eligibility requirement from 3 to 10 years, amending percentage discounts to better align with new maximum cash discounts so that long-standing tenants benefit from the largest reductions, and exempting newly built social homes from sale under the right to buy for 35 years. The bill also exempts homes from sale under the right to buy in areas designated as rural, given that homes in these areas are extremely difficult and expensive to replace. In the other place, peers sought to persuade the government to set the criteria for rural designation in regulations, and we've committed to amending the bill to enable that.

04:43:04 - 04:43:05

I will give way.

04:43:05 - 04:43:48

Andrew George

On that point, the Minister will be aware because he's also introducing clause 12, the proposal that housing associations can't dispose of stock which, for example, is very expensive to achieve EPC C on. I mean, in my area, we're haemorrhaging large numbers of social homes because of that, than through right to buy. So will he ensure that actually some protection is given so that rural communities, which he's saying there is the scarcity of properties there, rural communities are protected and they're supported in retaining those important properties?

04:43:48 - 04:45:53

Matthew Pennycook

I thank the honourable gentleman for his point.

I'm sure we'll have ongoing discussions about this and other issues. He may wish to hone down his private members' bill, perhaps, to focus in on this among some other issues. What I would say on disposals in general is I do, as I said at oral questions on Monday, recognize the strength of feeling regarding this matter in the House. I want to ensure that every opportunity is taken to retain homes within the social housing sector. The new disposal notification requirements in the bill, which I'll come on to speak about, will maximize opportunities for social housing providers to buy and retain social homes.

But housing associations do remain independent organizations responsible for their own asset management decisions. So we are looking, yes, at what more we can do to protect much-needed social housing stock, but there are limits to the extent we can go. I should say, further to that point, we are also taking steps, and this is just as important, to ensure that councils are in a better position to buy any disposals, for example, raising the cap on grant funding for acquisitions. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm just going to make a little bit of progress and then I will happily come back to my honorable friend. Taken together, Madam Deputy Speaker, these measures will fundamentally alter the trajectory of social housing supply.

Between April 2012 and March 2024, there were over 124,000 council right to buy sales, with fewer than 48,000 homes replaced in the same period. Under the previous pre-reform baseline, we could have expected to see a net loss of around another 26,000 council homes between 2026 and 2036. Following implementation of this government's right to buy reform package, including the measures contained in the bill, we instead expect to realize a net gain of around 18,000 homes over the same 10-year period. Or to put it more simply, Madam Deputy Speaker, instead of vainly watching the loss of precious social homes massively outpace their building, we will, for the first time in decades, be building considerably more than we are losing because of this Labour government and this bill. I'll happily give way.

04:45:53 - 04:46:33

James William Naish

I thank the minister for giving way. This bill widely prioritizes building new social rented homes, but my own authority, Rushcliffe Borough Council, transferred all its council housing stock away back in 2003 and has built none since. Yet it praises itself repeatedly for being debt-free, despite being much poorer asset-wise as a result of that decision back in 2003. So does he agree with me that if this bill is to succeed, we can't treat stock transfer as virtuous, and we've got to get to the point where housing revenue accounts aren't treated and talked about as being traditional debt for local authorities?

04:46:33 - 04:47:40

Matthew Pennycook

Well, I, there is lots that I agree with in what my honorable friend has just said. We do want to see councils once again directly delivering homes themselves at scale. We also want councils working in far closer partnership with housing associations to increase the number of homes that are built and managed by local authorities. And the points he's made about his local authority will be on the record for people in his area to see. Madam Deputy Speaker, in addition to the comprehensive reforms to the right to buy that are in the bill, the bill also requires private providers of social housing to notify the relevant local authority and other social housing providers in their area before they sell a social home, to the point the honorable gentleman just made.

Madam Deputy Speaker, there can be good reasons why private registered providers sometimes choose to dispose of social rented homes. And we don't prevent, we don't propose to prevent them from doing so.

But when a social home is to be sold, councils and other social housing providers should have the opportunity to consider whether they are interested in purchasing it. Legislation to provide them with that opportunity will prevent homes being lost to the private market when they do not need to be.

04:47:40 - 04:48:07

Daniel Francis

Twenty-seven years ago, my local authority in London Borough of Bexley sold all its council housing stock to Orbit and L&Q. And L&Q now routinely sell those homes at auction, which were council homes owned by my local authority. So will the Minister commit to looking further as we go forward, because my council will have no intention of rebuying those homes, at how we can ensure those homes remain social housing going forward.

04:48:07 - 04:49:11

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honourable friend for his question and it is disappointing to hear that his local authority are not interested in any way in trying to bring those back, those homes back under local authority control. As I've said, there are limits to what we can do. Housing associations remain independent organisations. Honourable members will, I'm sure, be aware of the risks around reclassification in terms of steps the government might take in this area. But we are exploring what more might be done to protect much-needed social housing stock.

And as I've said, just as importantly for those councils that do want to buy, and there are plenty of them and other providers, what more we can do to ensure they are in a position to do so. Madam Deputy Speaker, on the issue of disposals, having listened carefully to the debate in the other place in respect of this matter, we have committed to bringing forward an amendment to extend the window of time that must pass between notification and the sale of a property, giving councils and other providers more time to consider whether homes can be purchased and retained within the social housing sector as we want to see.

04:49:11 - 04:49:34

Andrew George

On that point, would he also consider extending the option to consult community groups, community land trusts, housing co-ops, who could take on these properties rather than them leaking out into the private sector? In areas like mine, they leak into the private sector, they'll most likely become second homes.

04:49:34 - 04:51:07

Matthew Pennycook

Well indeed, and that's precisely why through the notification window we want to give local authorities, other providers, the maximum opportunity to bring those homes back under their control and being as able as I said, because it's just as important that they are able to do so in practice. There are other issues affecting local authorities. My honourable friends, a number of them in orals at the start of the week spoke about pressures on HRAs. All of these things are bearing down on councils' ability to do, but we are looking at reforms in this area, not least as I said, the cap on acquisitions. I am going to now make a bit of progress.

I know there's a lot of people that want to speak, but I will come back to my honourable friend a bit later in my remarks. I want to turn now, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the bill's second core objective, namely increasing protections for tenants who are victims of domestic abuse. No one should be forced to remain in an unsafe situation because they fear becoming homeless. And yet last year around 15,000 households in England had to find a new social home as a result of domestic abuse. Existing legislation provides scant protection for social housing tenants who are victims of domestic abuse and wish to remain in their current home without their abuser.

Landlords can evict perpetrators, but only in cases where the victim has already left. This means that all too often victims are forced to choose between staying in danger or losing their home. This is an utterly unacceptable state of affairs and through this bill we will end it, as part of our department's ongoing efforts to deliver on this government's unprecedented commitment to halve violence against women and girls in a decade.

04:51:07 - 04:51:47

Danny Beales

I thank him for giving way, he's been very generous with his time. I strongly support the provisions in this bill to support victims of violence, which far too often, as he's mentioned, have to be evicted or leave while the perpetrator stays with the tenancy.

Another issue which is really preventing those victims from gaining a tenancy or moving out of temporary accommodation into settled accommodation is rent arrears, where requirements which prevent a new tenancy for those with rent arrears don't take into account if someone's been the victim of domestic violence. I know the department are looking at consulting and guidance around this. Could this bill be a key mechanism for changing that across this country?

04:51:47 - 04:52:22

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honorable friend for that question. I know there is interest in this chamber in regards to this issue. There's certainly interest in the other place about it. I can assure him we appreciate fully that survivors of domestic abuse with debt can face barriers when applying for social housing. We continue to believe that guidance is the best route to resolving this issue.

But we've been clear in the other place and I'm happy to reiterate it once again here today that if that guidance proves insufficient, we do have the option of making regulations to amend the relevant legislation. And I'm happy, I will happily give way to my honorable friend.

04:52:22 - 04:53:05

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

I thank the honorable gentleman and it is very good to hear him commit to checking whether guidance is enough. Many of us who have tried to rehouse victims of domestic abuse, even after great laws are written into legislation here in this place, will know that getting them the priority need that is in the Domestic Abuse Act still takes a huge amount of advocacy. So can I, I really welcome the commitment that if it doesn't work in just guidance that we will look at legislation to do this and offer to work with his department to ensure that we are making sure that we are assessing whether it works not by from Whitehall but by the actual frontline.

04:53:05 - 04:57:17

Matthew Pennycook

Can I thank my honorable friend for that intervention and she knows that I have the utmost respect for her and all that she has done to make women and girls safe. In response to both of my honorable friends' points, as I've said, the government has committed in its national plan to end homelessness to address this issue. There is consensus on that point. I am more than happy to make clear that if that guidance is not effective, does not have the intended effects that we all want to see, we will not hesitate to pursue changes through regulations. She has my commitment on that point.

I am going to give way. The Madam Deputy Speaker is glaring at me as to the time I'm taking and I know there is many members. I will try to come back to colleagues as I make some progress through my remarks. Madam Deputy Speaker, to ensure victims of domestic abuse can access safe and secure housing, the bill provides for stronger legal mechanisms to remove a perpetrator from a social housing tenancy and enable victims to stay in their home or move to alternative accommodation as a sole tenant. In response to constructive debate on the subject in the other place, we intend to bolster the discretionary possession ground so that the existence of a relevant protective order can provide the basis for proceedings rather than requiring evidence that the order has already been breached.

The new powers will apply where the victim is personally connected to the perpetrator tenant and is a current or former occupant of the property. By aligning the approach with the Domestic Abuse Act 2021, the bill will cover a broader range of relationships, including partners, former partners and family members. And turning finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, to the bill's third core objective, namely reducing unnecessary bureaucracy and providing regulatory clarity so that providers can invest in new social and affordable homes with confidence. The Housing and Planning Act 2016, the bill committee incidentally of which I happened to serve on as a young PPS to the then shadow housing secretary, now Chancellor of the Exchequer, the right honorable member for Royal Marsh and Connisborough, contains a series of social housing provisions which have never been brought into force. The bill will repeal the following measures to clarify the statute book and provide the sector with certainty that they will never be implemented.

First, provisions that would have required councils to charge higher rents to higher income social tenants, also known as mandatory pay to stay. This government has no intention of implementing this policy, which could incentivize tenants to reduce work hours to avoid higher rent, and so we are removing it from the statute book.

Second, provisions that would have required councils to grant fixed-term tenancies of between two and ten years generally to all new tenants. This government will continue to encourage landlords to make the best and most effective use of their homes to meet housing need, but we have no intention of prohibiting lifetime secure tenancies, which provide much-needed security for many households and support social mobility. And so we're removing this policy from the statute book. Third, provisions that would have required councils to sell off higher-value vacant housing stock and make annual payments in respect of expected sales to the Treasury. This government has no intention of implementing this policy and wants to see these assets remain for councils to manage and use as they see fit.

And so we are removing it from the statute book. As well as repealing provisions from the 2016 Act, the bill reforms the outdated housing consents regime, which can be time-consuming and resource-intensive for councils and often leads to delays in delivering new social and affordable housing. The bill will streamline the consents process to empower councils and remove bureaucratic impediments that restrict council flexibility in managing their housing stock, while retaining checks and protections where appropriate. Did my honourable friend want to intervene or have I caught him unprepared? I was going to give him a chance there.

To conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, after years of marginalisation, this government has emphatically and unashamedly asserted the necessity and value of social rented homes. They are a crucial national asset to be proud of, to invest in, to protect and to maintain. This bill will protect precious social homes for future generations. It will incentivise the building of many more of them. It will give social housing providers the confidence they need to invest in new social and affordable homes.

And it will support social tenants who are the victims and survivors of domestic abuse.

04:57:17 - 04:57:58

Elizabeth Helen Hayes

I will give way. There's a part of the bill that he hasn't referred to, which is part two in terms of a review of shared ownership. Shared ownership is a tenure that provides a great opportunity into home ownership for many people, but yet far too many people find themselves indebted and in a really difficult position because of the service charges that are imposed upon them and the quality of shared ownership. I'm particularly interested in the different models of shared ownership that can come forward. I'm interested to know what this review will be covering and how the outcomes of the review might be reflected in any future investment in genuinely affordable homes going forward.

04:57:58 - 04:59:59

Matthew Pennycook

I thank my honourable friend for her question and for her passionate advocacy on behalf of her constituents and others around the country on housing issues generally. On shared ownership, I know the pressures that shared owners face. I get them in my own constituency postbag on a daily basis. We have already taken positive steps to improve the shared ownership model, including introducing new expectations for landlords who bid for shared ownership grant funding to improve fairness and transparency, and we are supporting shared owners affected by specific challenges such as building safety issues. Clause 13, as honourable members might be aware, was added to the bill in the other place, does require a review of the shared ownership model to be carried out within 12 months of the bill's passing.

Madam Deputy Speaker, we do not believe a review is necessary as we are already actively considering specific issues that have been raised in debates, including data and long-term affordability for customers, and we will of course consider what more we can do to act on these issues within our wider programme to improve shared ownership. I'm just going to make some progress, I'm afraid. I am immensely grateful, Madam Deputy Speaker, to my noble friend Baroness Taylor of Stevenage for the customary skill with which she oversaw the passage of the bill through the other place and for the extensive engagement she undertook with peers throughout initial Lords stages.

further in a series of areas. For example, in response to concerns raised by my honorable friend the member for Dulwich and West Norwood and the noble Lord Best, we are giving serious consideration to what more might be done to provide greater security of tenure for social tenants who are fleeing violence, including serious youth violence. We are also considering what more can be done to bolster public control of social housing, to ensure that social housing serves and supports those who need it most. Madam Deputy Speaker, I won't give way, I'm just about to conclude. Apologies to my honorable friend.

I look forward to engaging with honorable members on both sides of the chamber, Madam Deputy Speaker, in relation to these and other matters as we look to improve the bill further, and I commend it to the house.

04:59:59 - 05:00:07

Speaker 252

The question is that the bill be now read a second time. I call shadow minister Gareth Bacon.

05:00:07 - 05:01:36

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move the amendment tabled in my name and the names of my honorable friends as listed in the order paper. Madam Deputy Speaker, we come to the house as we have done many times to find the government still failing to build more homes and still failing to support home ownership. This bill is no different, indeed it is a par excellence because for a bill supposedly concerned with housing it does nothing to build new homes. The bill does nothing to support the aspiration of home ownership, in fact it goes out of its way to diminish it.

The bill doesn't even free up any social homes for the 1.34 million people on the waiting list. It is a dud bill and an ideological red herring. Most egregiously, however, the government have taken a much-needed reform, that is the need for a new and effective framework to enable landlords to take possession action against perpetrators of domestic abuse, and surround it with unnecessary, damaging, and punitive reforms to right to buy. Now we agree with the government that it is vital that anyone stuck in an abusive household receives the urgent care, support, and access to legal pathways they need. So His Majesty's opposition supports this aspect of the bill.

So it is a shame to find the government wedging it uncomfortably alongside the ideological and anti-aspirational measures that make up the majority of this counterproductive bill. Madam Deputy Speaker, let us come... I'll give way.

05:01:36 - 05:02:10

Jess Jessica Rose Phillips

I just, as somebody who I would wager has rehoused more victims of domestic abuse than almost anybody in this house, I can just, I just want to say on behalf of victims of domestic abuse, building more council housing and making sure more council housing is in the system is literally the thing that almost every victim in the country would ask us to do. And so with that ideology, I would like to commend the ideology of the bill and suggest that maybe wedging it together, they're the same issue.

05:02:10 - 05:03:57

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I thank the honorable lady for her comment. I'm sorry, I missed that. I missed that comment from the sedentary position. This bill doesn't contribute to building a single extra social home. I agree that people who are victims of domestic abuse... I said that in my remarks, should be rehoused.

We don't agree, however, that this bill is the way to do it. Madam Deputy Speaker, let us come to the main thrust of the government's policy, the effective end of right to buy as we know it. In 1980, Margaret Thatcher's government offered millions of people a hand up onto the property ladder by extending the opportunity to own property to hardworking and aspirational people living in social housing. Ever since, and right up to the present day, Labour MPs have called for the restrictions on the scheme. They have essentially called for an end to the opportunity to exercise the right to own one's own home for around five million households.

When owning one's own home can bring such pride, such a sense of community, can offer security and safety, one might wonder why on earth anyone would seek to lock millions of social housing tenants out from doing so.

Well, aside from ideology, which is of course a major part of the problem for those opposite, the benches opposite seek to do this because they have misdiagnosed the problem. In the government's mind, it is somehow acceptable to lay the blame at right to buy's door as 1.34 million children, families, the elderly, the disabled and others wait for social home every year, whilst every year, approximately 33,000 new social tenancies funded by British taxpayers are going to households where the lead tenant is not a British national. I will give way on that point.

05:03:57 - 05:04:37

Dawn Natasha Irons

I thank the honorable member for giving way. I just wanted to speak as the granddaughter of Jamaican immigrants who came to this country and had a council house and bought that council house and profited from right to buy. The conversation we had around our dinner table isn't right to buy great, the problem is they're not rebuilding the housing. The idea of changing this is so that we stop the leakage out of the system. We cannot continue to pour more into the top whilst it comes out of the bottom.

So I hope we can agree on the point that building more social homes is everyone's objective, but to keep them in the system is also going to help alleviate the pressure on social housing.

05:04:37 - 05:08:24

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I agree with the honorable lady that building more social homes is part of the answer, but I will address the central point of her question a bit later in my speech. Right to buy is not the reason for diminished available social housing, nor the reason for our current shortage of social housing. Indeed, as my noble friend Lord Jameson pointed out in the other place, the government's own impact assessment shows that in 26-27, the pre-November 2024 baseline was 8,050 right to buy sales leading to 5,450 replacement homes. The document goes on to show that if this bill were to pass and the legacy impacts wind down in the period 2031 to 2035, then annual right to buy sales would fall to around 1,100 a year with around 1,450 replacement homes. This means that by their own analysis and admission, the government would oversee a housing system where there would be 4,000 fewer new social homes funded every year.

The government's data isn't the only... I'll give way.

Thank the honorable member for giving way. Just a statistic while we're talking about statistics, between April 2012 and March 2024, over 124,000 right to buy sales, fewer than 48,000 built to replace it. Which party was in charge during that period of time?

The point that I'm making, as my honorable friend has said from a position behind me, is that there's going to be even fewer under this bill. This is not the answer to the problem that he is addressing. The government's own data isn't the only data available that disproves the justification for restricting right to buy. The government have argued that this bill will mean around 3,000 additional homes are retained a year. But research conducted by the House of Lords library shows that only a net 3% of social homes become available each year to new tenants.

Now this means that around 90 additional homes will be available for a new tenant every year. 90 instead of 5,000. And the very premise itself that right to buy is taking homes away is also a fallacy. The only people who qualify for right to buy are long-term tenants. And government data has shown that 78% of new lettings remain lifetime tenancies.

This means that in three quarters of cases, we are looking at social homes that are unlikely to ever be available to a prospective tenant when they need it. Madam Deputy Speaker, all of this clearly demonstrates that right to buy is not the issue, it is part of the solution. Yet it is not the only avenue available to the government that they could take to support those on the waiting list and to get more people into the housing they need. I hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, you won't mind if I offer two key areas in which progress could be made.

And first and foremost, of course, is house building. The government have put forward clear and definite promises to voters in 2024. We were told that by the end of this Parliament the government will have built 1.5 million homes, including the biggest increase in social and affordable house building in a generation. The new Prime Minister, a self-proclaimed opponent of 1980s policies, has similarly committed to a social housing revolution, albeit without a defined target or an idea of what this looks like. But now, halfway through this Parliament, and the slog of the Planning and Infrastructure Act, the multiple updates to the National Planning Policy Framework, and the publication of this bill, we are left without a clear route to building more homes.

And projections from the government themselves showing that they have managed to build just 26% of their target in nearly 50% of the time. And this bill does nothing to prioritize building. It will not add a single social home to the housing stock.

05:08:24 - 05:08:53

Scott Arthur

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I do thank the honorable gentleman. Is it not slightly misleading, however, to suggest that the delivery rate for those homes, that pledge in the manifesto, is going to be constant throughout the term of this government? In fact, we're going to do the enabling works in terms of legislation, and we're going to see more of those homes built towards the end. And is it not also right and good that we have a target which stretches us, and I would hope the opposition would join us in helping us deliver that target?

05:08:53 - 05:09:15

Andrew Gareth Bacon

The opposition would be very happy if the government hit that target, but the point is they are not going to, Madam Deputy Speaker. The target wasn't nuanced like that in the manifesto, nor was it nuanced straight after the election. We were told that 1.5 million homes would be built by the end of this Parliament, and there is no chance that they are going to hit that target, Madam Deputy Speaker. I will give way.

05:09:15 - 05:09:43

Catherine Eccles

Thanks the honorable gentleman for giving way. Does he recognize that under the current right to buy rules only 20 to 25% of the receipt goes back to the local council, and under our government's proposals it will be 100%, which will make it much easier to build those homes? And in the West Midlands, Richard Parker, the West Midlands Mayor, has already delivered nearly 2,000 new homes and on target to deliver 5,000. So would you agree that it is possible to deliver?

05:09:43 - 05:10:12

Andrew Gareth Bacon

On the contrary, Madam Deputy Speaker, it was the last Conservative government that introduced 100% receipts going to the councils to rebuild the homes that have gone. That was introduced in 2023. And although the members opposite like to pretend that history only began in 2010, I would point out to them that successive governments since the 1980s could have changed that and didn't, and it was the last Conservative government that did. I'll give way.

05:10:12 - 05:10:55

Mark Francois

I thank the shadow planning minister for giving way. On housing numbers, there's no Reform MP present this afternoon. But Reform-led Rochford District Council have just published their Regulation 19 local plan. During the May elections, they made a great thing about defending the green belt, and in the intervening period, they've been telling lots of local campaign groups or intimating to them that when the plan came out, they'd be all right. And yet we now find that nearly every single one of those green belt sites has been recommended for development.

Does my honorable friend agree with me that if they didn't really mean to defend the green belt, which they clearly don't, they should never have said it?

05:10:55 - 05:12:32

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Well, I share my honorable friend's shock that no Reform MP is present in the chamber today. I'm similarly totally, totally taken aback that they would say one thing and then do another. Of course they shouldn't have said that if they didn't mean to do it. Very, very well put by my honorable friend. Madam Deputy Speaker, this government does nothing to prioritize building.

It will not add a single social home to the housing stock.

What this bill represents is a government seeking to heal a problem before they have properly diagnosed it. Offering a solution to something that already has an answer. If the government were serious about reforming right to buy and building more homes at the same time, perhaps they would look at how proper management and effective reinvestment of receipts can lead to an increase in housing supply, especially on brownfield sites. As my colleagues in the other place noted, it is better for everyone and for the economy that we make two homes out of one. Through efficient, productive and successful management of right to buy receipts, we can both sell a family home and support a family onto the waiting list with another one.

As homelessness peaks at record levels and the number of children in temporary accommodation reached the dizzying summit of 178,000, it beggars belief that the government are not looking at this more closely. However, I do recognize that house building is not an overnight fix. It takes time. And for many families on the waiting list, that is something they simply do not have. I will give way in a moment.

We must therefore consider how best to free up existing stock to support those most in need. I'll give way.

05:12:32 - 05:12:54

Luke Murphy

I thank the shadow minister for giving way. He's talking very eloquent about eloquent about his view on social housing. But in 2010, the then coalition government cut the affordable housing budget by 60%. Five years later, there was a 97% fall in the house building of social rent homes. Would he like to apologize to the house for that record?

05:12:54 - 05:13:24

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I will I'll listen to what the honorable gentleman says, but of course, one of the things that we don't get from the opposition benches is any commentary at all about the state of the economy in 2010 after 13 years of their party being in power. It is the case, it is the case that the public finances had to be right sized. The country was heading towards bankruptcy. And whilst they are happy to disown their own record and criticize everybody that follows, perhaps it would be slightly more honest if they acknowledged that when they prefaced their their arguments. I'll give way to my honorable friend.

05:13:24 - 05:13:51

Louie Thomas French

My honorable friend will be aware that the Mayor of London has been in power for over 10 years now, and London's housing record and housing starts has fallen through the floor. There are over 300,000 Londoners estimated to be on housing waiting lists, the predominant majority of those are in Labour boroughs. Does he therefore find the rhetoric of today somewhat confusing, given this government have cut Sadiq Khan's housing target by 22%, and even still he continues to miss that affordable housing target?

05:13:51 - 05:15:56

Andrew Gareth Bacon

My honorable friend knows of what he speaks. The Mayor of London's record on housing is of course execrable. It is totally mystifying that a time when London's population is the highest it has ever been and housing need is the highest it has ever been, the government has simultaneously reduced the housing target for London whilst massively ramping up the target in outer London where most of the green belt is. And I would suggest to my honorable friend that that tells you everything you need to know about their intentions both with regards to housing and also with regards to the green belt. Madam Deputy Speaker, for the opposition, two answers seem too obvious to miss, and yet the government willfully choose to ignore this part of the puzzle.

The first answer is efficiency of stock management. Many councils and housing associations are well run and proactive organizations, but too many remain plagued by poor stock utilization, improper management and under-occupation. A proper understanding of national stock will go some way towards creating a fairer and more efficient system in contrast to the failures we witness now. For example, up-to-date figures from the English Housing Survey suggest that around 186,000 social housing households have incomes above £50,000, while approximately 389,000 households are under-occupying social housing. This is clearly an inefficiency, not only worth fixing, but one that would not be beyond the realms of possibility for many suppliers and managers to fix.

Yet it does not feature in this bill. And the government looks again at the broadness of the issue ahead of them and answers with a narrow and ideological legislative response. Onto the second of the answers. For too many struggling families, for too many families, it is understandable that they should be frustrated to find foreign nationals in homes paid for by the British taxpayer. To be clear, we're not talking about just anyone, of course, because after all, it was only until recently that the British taxpayers were funding the First Lady of Sierra Leone's central London pad, or rather a British social housing flat.

And there are other egregious cases. More precisely, another 127,000 cases, as official figures show that 72% of those who identify as Somali in England and Wales live in social housing.

05:15:56 - 05:15:58

Nesil Caliskan

I'll give way.

05:15:58 - 05:16:32

Dawn Natasha Irons

I thank the honourable member for giving way, and I just wanted to clarify on this point of people born in other countries living here. Born somewhere else does not mean not a British citizen. Born somewhere else does not mean that you're not in work, and being in social housing doesn't mean you're not being in work. It also doesn't mean your children are not born in this country. So is the honourable gentleman suggesting that if someone had becomes a British citizen after moving to this country, that they should have a different tier of support in the system, even if they have paid into it?

05:16:32 - 05:19:46

Andrew Gareth Bacon

No. No, I am not. No, if the honourable lady will listen to the remainder of my speech, then she'll hear what I've got to say. It is understandable, Madam Deputy Speaker, that as more and more people watch more and more of their salary slip away from their pockets into the hands of the taxman, they begin to ask why they bother and to question the fairness of the system. Because if the government aren't going to build enough social homes, then they could follow our example as laid out in our alternative King's Speech and end all new social housing tenancies for all foreign nationals, as well as current tenancies for couples where neither person is a UK, Irish or EU citizen, and free up those homes for British families.

To be clear of the scale of what we are talking about, this would add 228,144 homes to the social housing sector, a figure which represents more homes than the government built in its entirety in 2024-2025. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, may I also turn to the problems that could be fixed around shared ownership, an issue raised by the honourable lady who's no longer in her place. This is an issue that I know my noble friends in the other place worked hard and successfully to bring to the attention of the government and see added to this bill. For far too long and for far too many people, what should be their first and their proudest step onto the housing ladder instead becomes a logistical, legal and financial nightmare. I'm proud of the opposition's work in the House of Lords to force the government to finally realise what a national issue this has become, and so therefore obtain a welcome commitment from the government to review shared ownership practices.

And I call on the minister to reiterate this promise and not to seek to remove any such commitment or obligation from the bill when it goes to committee. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is clear that this bill fails the British people. By effectively destroying right to buy, it does nothing to increase available social housing stock. It merely keeps people trapped in the system and not in control of their own lives. It fails to provide more homes.

It fails to support aspirations of home ownership and it fails to free up existing stock. Most crucially, however, it undermines the very essence of what makes for a successful and viable housing system. In such a system, people are supported to get into housing when they need it and supported to own housing when they aspire to it. But as in the case of this bill, this government and indeed the absent Secretary of State for reasons I think we all probably understand, it is clear that there is not just a failure but a refusal to create such a system. This is why the opposition has tabled a reasoned amendment at second reading of this bill.

We believe this bill is so lacking in ambition, so ideological in its motivation and so punitive in its measures that it should not proceed beyond this stage or get anywhere near the statute book.

Now I do say this with great sorrow for the helpless victims of domestic abuse and violence who deserve everything this bill promises on that front. It is a shame that the government have wedded such necessary support to such punitive legislation. I hope the Secretary of State will reassure the House that if this bill makes it to committee and beyond, it will be amended to make it fit for purpose for those in need of housing, in need of escape from abuse and those in need of shelter.

05:19:46 - 05:21:21

Nesil Caliskan

And with an immediate four-minute time limit for the backbench contributions, Nesil Caliskan.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Safe and secure housing is the foundation of a good life and the availability of social and affordable housing plays an important part in the provision of housing in this country for what should be a mixed housing picture. And I'd like to begin by talking about the right to buy. Because between 2012 and 2024, 124,000 right to buy sales took place with fewer than 50,000 replacing them in the same period. The maths alone demonstrates what's happening to social housing.

Therefore, I particularly welcome the government's commitment to reforming right to buy, including exempting newly built affordable and social housing from the sales under the right to buy scheme for 35 years. I also very much welcome 100% of the right to buy receipts being left to local authorities. As an ex-council leader, I know the frustration I felt that we couldn't use those moneys, ploughing them back into affordable homes. I know that councils will now be able to combine that money with developer contributions and grant funding that will mean that the councils that are committed to affordable and social housing can build more. Happy to give way.

05:21:21 - 05:21:38

Paul Holmes

I thank the lady for giving way and it's good to see her in the chamber. She mentioned her frustration when she was a council leader at the fact that she wasn't able to use 100% of right to buy receipts. Seeing as she was leader of her authority and the last Conservative government gave her the power to, why didn't she?

05:21:38 - 05:23:12

Nesil Caliskan

There are a number of reasons why we're hindered from delivering affordable homes. It didn't go as far as the proposals that the government is setting out today. But I have to gently say a number of the other reasons included record interest rates which completely decimated the HRA accounts for councils up and down the country. Madam Deputy Speaker, in my constituency of Barking, rising rents and bills take a bigger piece of the housing spend each month for my constituents. That is the result of a housing crisis in this country that has progressively got worse.

And that's because building simply is not keeping up with demand. The case of my constituents, every week that I speak to, tell me that they experience the housing crisis which leaves them with the anxiety that they may be left without a roof over their head any moment. And that's with a local authority that is building at a record rate. I'd also like to speak to the new powers that support domestic violence victims. Because I also, like many members in this place, speak to constituents who tell me their fear of being left homeless should they speak out and leave their secure home.

I very much welcome the changes in this bill because it means that women and children can sleep safer. And at that point, happy to give way.

05:23:12 - 05:23:50

Katrina Murray

One of the issues that we discussed at my constituency women's safety summit back in January was the issue around gender debt and economic abuse and particularly how it affects rent arrears.

As a result of that, North Lanarkshire Council, Aberlour Children's Charity, the voluntary sector, and registered social landlords in North Lanarkshire are adopting an authority-wide approach, common approach, to being able to support women. Would you agree that this would be an excellent example for the Minister to take forward of what is a voluntary action?

05:23:50 - 05:25:52

Nesil Caliskan

Thank you very much, and I thank my honorable friend, and there are excellent examples up and down the country of local authorities doing very, very good work. And with the backing of a Labour government, I think we can see a real progress from supporting women who are the victims of domestic violence and their children. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd also like to speak to part two of the bill that would require the Secretary of State to conduct and publish a review of the operation and effectiveness of shared ownership. My constituency has a significant number of shared ownership properties. And I speak to constituents in Barking who tell me what was a move that was full of hope now quickly turning into a nightmare.

I speak to many constituents who talk about the increase in their charges, in some cases from £2,000 now paying £4,000. For a three-bedroom property, in some cases they're paying up to £6,000 in charges. Simply put, a shared ownership property that is categorized as affordable has become unaffordable for many of my constituents. And so I welcome the commitment from the government to review this, to ensure that affordable means affordable. And in cases where charges mean they don't become affordable, my constituents should not feel like they are trapped in those properties.

Madam Deputy Speaker, housing and the provision of decent homes, with social housing and affordable housing being part of that mission, was the reason why I ever ran for public office. I'm delighted to be able to support the government's bill. We need to build more social and affordable homes. We need to protect them and we need to invest in them so that they are fit for the future. And so I welcome this bill and I look forward to it being rolled out so my constituents in Barking can benefit.

Thank you.

05:25:52 - 05:27:21

Gideon Amos

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Gideon Amos.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I draw the House's attention to my register of interests, my experience as a social landlord. Liberal Democrats have long called for a major program of social housing, 150,000 per year. And so there are elements of this bill that we on these benches really welcome and we will support the bill today. Extending the qualifying period to 10 years and cutting discounts will slow the loss of social homes that we've been hearing about. Protecting a newly built social home from sale for 35 years should give councils more confidence to build again, as will the improved right of first refusal.

And the protections for tenants fleeing domestic abuse are welcome and overdue, and we support them. So there are important steps in the right direction, but the bill as a whole is nowhere near the scale of what is needed. Right to buy on its own, as other members have pointed out, was not the biggest issue on its own. It was the complete failure to replace home for home. In Taunton and Wellington and the rest of the country, thanks to the Conservatives, there are thousands fewer council homes than there used to be, all while the need for social housing has grown and grown.

There are 4 million fewer council houses in this country than there were in 1980. And even taking into account replacements and social housing and RSLs, the number of social homes in this country has dropped by 1.5 million homes. I give way, John Whitby.

05:27:21 - 05:27:46

Christopher John Vince

I thank the honorable member for giving way, and so far the majority of what he said I agree with, there may be some that I don't agree with later, so we'll wait and see.

However, would he reflect that actually the impact of councils losing their council house stock has been they've had to spend more and more money on temporary accommodation? So it's actually a zero net sum for local councils and also the impact that's had on families and young people has been particularly difficult, including in my constituency of Harlow, Madam Deputy Speaker.

05:27:46 - 05:31:33

Gideon Amos

The honourable member for I forget where, he doesn't mention it very often, maybe Harlow, is right and I will be coming on to exactly the point of temporary accommodation. The Resolution Foundation found that only one home is replaced for every five sold. That's a direct failure of governments of all persuasions to build enough social housing. The Conservatives reversed their policy of allowing councils to spend 100% of receipts soon after they introduced it and in 2004, in comparison, the Labour government required three quarters of receipts to be sent straight to the Treasury. So we had homes sold at around half their value and what money there was from receipts went elsewhere, not into building new social homes and building rates plummeted.

The new Prime Minister, I'm glad to see, talks a good game on devolution, but even under this bill councils will remain unable to stop the loss of council homes from right to buy. Liberal Democrats would give councils that power to end right to buy in their areas if that is right for them and their community and the government should trust councils to understand their community and their own housing markets. And when it comes to Conservatives who seem to be chasing ideological bedfellows in a Reform party, apparently the priority isn't building houses, it's finding a minority to blame for the problem, a group to alienate as the other when we should be focusing on building for the whole of the UK and everyone who lives here. Their amendment, their amendment banning people not fully British citizens from social housing overlooks the fact that people subject to immigration control are already ineligible for social housing. That is the law.

But they want to go further. The nurse on the ward in Musgrove Park Hospital in my constituency, not welcome under a Conservative amendment, not allowed to have a social home or a council house. The care worker who looked after people in the pandemic, not welcome under this Conservative amendment. They will have nowhere to live when it comes to council and social housing under a Conservative government. Ironic for a party that produced two Prime Ministers born outside Britain.

I don't, as a Member of Parliament for Wellington, I don't know whether I should inform His Grace the Duke of Wellington that the first Duke of Wellington wouldn't fully be a British citizen under the Conservatives' amendment put on the order paper today because he was born outside of Britain. The honourable gentleman from a sedentary position says total rubbish. I suggest he reads his amendment which refers to reserving social housing for British citizens. No, the Duke of Wellington was not born in Britain. The honourable gentleman needs to have a look at his history.

The fact is, regardless of the history of the Duke of Wellington, attempts to pump up divisive culture wars claptrap in this bill doesn't deserve our attention. Rather than pointing the finger of blame at minorities, we should be talking about how to build more social homes and that's exactly what I shall go on to do, Madam Deputy Speaker. The failure to replace social homes means that more and more people are in temporary accommodation, amongst other factors. There are 132,000 households in temporary accommodation. Councils spent 2.8 billion pounds on it last year and the scourge of poor quality temporary accommodation exists for far too many children.

That's why we need a big public housing programme to match the scale of the challenge, if nothing else because it's incumbent on us all in this House, across party, to end the tragic loss of 140 children's lives in the last five years, highlighted by the Shared Health Foundation, for whom temporary accommodation was found to be a contributory factor to their death by the coroner.

05:31:33 - 05:31:54

Paul William Forster

I'm well, of course, I'm grateful to my honourable friend for Taunton for giving way. I've got almost 180 families in Woking in temporary accommodation, it is tragic for them. There's 20 of them located outside the borough.

Does my honourable friend agree with me that we need to ensure that councils can locate people in temporary accommodation locally so it doesn't devastate their lives as much as it does at the moment?

05:31:54 - 05:32:10

Gideon Amos

My honourable friend for Woking is entirely right, and people should be able to stay in their communities, which is why we need local affordable housing and social housing at scale to deal with that issue. Richard, quickly.

05:32:10 - 05:32:25

Richard Quigley

Thank you. I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. Does he agree with me that the Tory idea of capping the local housing allowance will mean that families that can't afford to stay in their area will have to move out of the area, tear their children out of school and turn their lives upside down?

05:32:25 - 05:36:35

Gideon Amos

The honourable gentleman's absolutely right about the local housing allowance and the huge effect it has on local families and housing markets, and it needs to be uprated. I must return to my speech or Madam Deputy Speaker will start giving me looks. My colleague, amongst other things, we must free up councils to build. So my Lib Dem colleagues on Somerset Council will build 600 council houses. They're already building council houses in parts of the county for the first time in a generation.

It has sites for another 600. It wants to build them. What it does not have is the headroom in its housing revenue account. The government promised to confirm its approach to discounted borrowing rate for housing revenue accounts in the autumn, so we are waiting and councils are waiting eagerly for that news. If ministers will not raise the 3.9 billion pounds per year to the 6 billion pounds per year that we put in our manifesto for social housing, will they use some additional funds to write off some or all of that housing revenue account debt so councils like Somerset can get building again, as Shelter and others have called for?

And on the scale of the need, the government has re-announced that 60% of its 300,000 program will be social housing. That's 18,000 a year, which is of course welcome. And when that was first announced in July 2025, we said though it was not enough, and re-announcing it this summer does not make it enough either. So will the government raise the target of social homes, if not to 150,000, our target, then to a higher number than its 18,000 a year? In addition, the bill does very little to address unique issues of affordable housing in rural areas.

In Taunton and Wellington, all people are seeing is unprecedented plans for private housing, which many can't afford. The council's instructed to consent homes for 180,000 people in the next 15 years. Somerset's never grown by 25% in population in any 15-year period in its history, and it won't in the next 15 years, but acres of beautiful countryside will be gobbled up for private housing permissions that many people in my constituency can't afford. And there's a consequence of this for social housing and the proposals for eating up the green belt. My honourable friend for West Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly has brought to my attention an inspector's decision in Gweek in Cornwall, a decision following the minister's own policies, where all social housing was removed from a previous consent on appeal because under new mandatory government housing targets, the new five-year supply could not be met and therefore he must allow all private housing and remove all the social housing from the scheme.

That needs to be addressed. But it's not just Cornwall. Most of England, at least most of Southern England, is covered by councils that thanks to the new standard method can no longer achieve the new five-year land supply, so in the majority of those councils we have a planning free-for-all where social homes are not being safeguarded. The standard method has to go. We should replace it with a return to properly researched household projections that take into account movements between regions and safeguard exception sites for social housing, which are being lost as a result.

The government's bill does protect rural social homes from being sold, which I welcome and we on these benches welcome. However, as long as the planning system alongside it closes down the supply of new ones, that simply will not be enough. Overall, this bill does not go far enough. In contrast, therefore, our Liberal Democrat housing bill, which I had the privilege of presenting to Madam Deputy Speaker not so long ago, would establish a target of 150,000 new social homes a year, including a new wave of rent-to-own allowing people, young people to get on the housing ladder, would require the Secretary of State to report on progress on this target and give local authorities proper powers over social housing they need to achieve it, including the right to end right-to-buy in their area if it is right for them and their community. That's the Liberal Democrat vision for a revolution in the delivery of social housing and I commend it to the house.

05:36:35 - 05:37:46

Edward Joseph Powell

Joe Powell.

Madam Deputy Speaker, the housing crisis in Kensington and Bayswater is one of the biggest drivers of inequality in our community, overcrowding, damp and mold, families stuck in temporary accommodation and a lack of options for people with accessibility issues is a huge drag on life chances and opportunity, including for children. The issue is not helped, by the way, by Conservative-run Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea receiving a C3 rating from the regulator of social housing, a staggering failure nearly 10 years after the Grenfell Tower tragedy in which the inquiry found major failings at the council, and it certainly would not be helped either by an entirely arbitrary 4 billion pound cut in housing benefit that would dramatically increase homelessness, require the local authority to spend more on temporary accommodation and dramatically change the socio-economic makeup of communities like mine, a truly shameful policy and I'd happily take an intervention from the front bench if they want to defend it, but it certainly would not support any of the issues that we're talking about today.

05:37:46 - 05:37:47

Would he give way on that point?

05:37:48 - 05:38:06

Speaker 275

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. My area Bournemouth West is probably like his in that the local housing allowance doesn't nearly stretch to the market rates, market rates are well above the national average and wages in my area below. So would he agree that the Conservative policy of capping that and the lack of social housing building over the last decade have exacerbated the issues we're now seeing in our constituencies?

05:38:06 - 05:39:51

Edward Joseph Powell

I completely agree with my honorable friend and as the Prime Minister said yesterday, it would just increase homelessness and will be entirely self-defeating because it will just shift the bill to local authorities who then have to deal with the problem rather than tackling tackling the problem as we're doing today in this bill. So what we actually need is more social and genuinely affordable housing and I welcome the steps this bill takes to address that issue because there is no doubt that unchecked right-to-buy has contributed to the problem. The measures in this bill are sensible, they'll make a difference, they build on previous policy changes the government has already made, including making permanent the retention of 100% of right-to-buy receipts. But how the implementation of these measures work in communities like mine will obviously be vital. In many of our council estates and buildings, the current owners of right-to-buy properties are actually open to selling.

Now that is partly because of estate regeneration costs, concerns about service charges and quality, and these leaseholders may not necessarily benefit to the full extent of other private leaseholders from the easier path to commonhold and resident-run buildings that the government will be bringing in for leaseholders in general. So I'd welcome further information about how local authorities can be supported to buy back properties in blocks where the council is already the freeholder.

And I fully understand that is an admission of failure of the historic right to buy policy, which certainly would not be helped by retaining the three-year eligibility requirements that the shadow minister supported in his speech. Changing that to 10 years makes much more sense, much more strategic sense for councils because it incentivizes both those buybacks, but also investment in new council housing.

05:39:51 - 05:40:19

Feryal Clark

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. In my constituency of Ealing Southall in the borough of Ealing, 3,000 families are in temporary accommodation, 7,500 families on the housing list, 9,000 homes were sold off under the right to buy since the 1980s. Does my honorable friend agree that in fact this bill has the right balance of continuing social mobility for long-standing tenants while protecting homes for those most in need?

05:40:19 - 05:43:20

Edward Joseph Powell

I do agree, we have to increase supply in any way we can. And my point on buybacks is that that demonstrates the false economics of the system because councils are buying back at premium, and often they have to buy back only for temporary accommodation because that's where the costs are so high, rather than for secure tenancies, which is what we need for lifetime secure tenancies. We also have a real challenge on housing association disposals, which I know others will speak to. The classic example's been Victorian era street properties in North Kensington and Notting Hill. I'm hearing of accelerated sell-offs as housing associations raise revenue to deal with the recent challenging financial situation they've had, given requirements to improve standards and remediation costs.

But given the government has now backed the sector with access to the building safety fund, a 10-year rent settlement, low-cost loans and more, I really hope those disposal numbers will drop because I know from experience those homes in my constituency are unlikely to be replaced in the same community. The new notification period for a housing association to the council of four weeks is therefore extremely welcome, but it must lead to more purchases by local authorities of these properties. So I'd welcome further information from the minister of what impact he expects these notification periods to be, what guidance could be provided to housing providers, given their independence, to make clear private sector sales should be a plan B, and what support local authorities will have to purchase these properties. Moving very briefly onto shared ownership, I welcome the minister's close attention to the operations and effectiveness of shared ownership. Ministers will know about the case of Shaftesbury Place because I've raised it before, a building near Earl's Court where approximately 30 shared ownership flats have experienced a 21-fold increase in building insurance due to a disputed fire risk assessment.

The shared ownership leaseholders there have consistently raised issues with the management of the building by Notting Hill Genesis, from broken security gates to cleaning and unauthorized access requests and late accounts. In many ways, these residents are experiencing the same challenges that many leaseholders have with managing agents in the private sector, which I hope the government will introduce a new independent regulator for. So can the minister assure me that how housing associations manage shared ownership properties will be considered under forthcoming leasehold reforms, but also in the department's work to review the challenges of shared ownership? I also of course welcome the new measures in this bill on keeping victims of domestic abuse safer and look forward to seeing them, those powers be used by landlords. Clearly there is no one solution to the housing crisis in a community like mine in Kensington and Bayswater, but today's bill is a really important step forward and I strongly welcome it.

05:43:20 - 05:47:22

Speaker 241

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to put on record that I'm a passionate advocate for social housing. I've lived in it and I've worked in it. For the 14 years before I entered this House, I worked for a social housing provider in customer service, community development, and housing management, and I put on record that my wife still does. I saw the passion and do see the passion of staff who deliver those services every day, and I saw the frustration of customers who relied on it.

I know how good this sector can be, and I know where it can sometimes fall short. Now, as an MP, like others in the House, we also see through casework issues where tenants demand and deserve more, from housing allocation to repair issues to ASB. I'm also happy, Madam Deputy Speaker, to put on record that this Government has helped, not hindered, social housing since coming to power. Rent convergence, long-term rent settlements, listening to the sector about phasing in additional safety checks are real and I welcome them, and they deserve recognition from these benches. And so I welcome the Government bringing forward more changes that are needed.

But I have to be honest that I'm disappointed that the bill is limited in scope, and I genuinely ask the Government to reflect on that, particularly the report from the Regulatory Policy Committee's opinion on the bill. On the 24th of July, the RPC rated the bill's impact assessment as not fit for purpose, based on its scrutiny of the evidence and analysis put forward to justify the case for regulation. This is not a technicality, it's a warning that the case for this bill does and does not what this bill does do and what it doesn't do and what has not been properly made. If we're going to legislate on something as important as the future of social housing, the evidence base before it should be beyond question. Now I'd like briefly to address the four main areas of the bill.

On right to buy, I support increasing the minimum tenancy requirements and on reforming discounts so that they start at 5% of property value and go up to a maximum of 15%. Exempting new builds, newly built social and affordable homes for 35 years will make a real impact, despite what the official opposition say in terms of house building. It absolutely will. Moving on to disposals, and this is where I don't feel protections are adequate enough to empower local communities. I note that the National Housing Federation believe the new requirement strikes the appropriate balance, but I have to disagree.

In constituencies like mine, large-scale voluntary stock transfers were the reason that those providers got the stock that they did. In West Berkshire, the main registered provider there has been created from an LSVT. That stock must be protected. It's not enough for the local council just to be notified. It must also include the reason for the sale, how, when, and where they will replace the stock within that LA, and if not possible, a financial contribution to a section 106 pot, following the practice of local authorities keeping right to buy receipts.

As a constituency with many rural areas, I welcome exempting rural properties from the scheme, but I also think we should consider exemptions for much-needed larger homes, like four and five beds, so that they're not lost forever within the social housing stock. And of course, I support the protection for victims of domestic abuse. I have live pieces of casework on this very issue, so those constituents will find relief that the Government has acted on this, and the housing sector will be supportive of greater powers to help those who need it. And I have no major concerns relating to the repealing of unused legislation. But there are other areas of the bill, Madam Speaker, where they are completely silent, from protecting existing stock through to empowering existing tenants and young people to have a stronger voice, and for the bill to help make homes safer by supporting housing associations with gaining access for safety work.

05:47:22 - 05:47:23

Rebecca Long-Bailey.

05:47:23 - 05:51:30

Speaker 277

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In Salford, around three and a half thousand applicants are on the housing waiting list today, with 1,335 children living in temporary accommodation. And across England, more than 1.3 million households are waiting for a social home. But at the current rate of delivery, Shelter estimates it would take 119 years to clear those waiting lists. But the crisis didn't happen overnight, and it wasn't inevitable.

We didn't suddenly discover that council housing didn't work. Previous governments sold it off. They stopped building it. They cut the funding and hollowed out the housing departments that had given local government the skills, capacity, and ability to build at scale. And in their place, we became increasingly dependent on a private housing market whose primary purpose has always been to generate returns.

So it's no surprise when the market didn't deliver the social homes that we needed; it was never going to do that. So that's why I really do welcome the measures before us today to protect existing social housing, particularly the reforms to right to buy. But it's only the first part of the story. And what we need to see now is the need to build council houses at scale and to give councils the powers, the funding, and the confidence to do it. And we know it can be done, because in the greatest city on earth, Salford, we've already shown us how to do it.

And in 2017, Paul Dennett and Salford City Council established Dérive, a council-owned housing company created to develop land and increase the supply of council and genuinely affordable homes. The first homes were delivered in 2019, and by April this year, 513 homes had been built, with another 700 in construction or development. Now, that's public ownership in practice. And it's particularly significant because much of this happened during austerity, when councils were on their knees. We used our land, our democratic mandate, and our own housing company to rebuild the capacity that successive governments had allowed to disappear, and we did it on a shoestring.

So imagine what could be achieved with government support. And that's the lesson that I want the House to take today from Salford. Councils can acquire land, they can develop it, and they can build high-quality, energy-efficient homes. But crucially, they can retain those homes as public assets for generations to come. So I very much welcome the government's ambition to put councils back at the heart of housebuilding, including the 39 billion affordable housing programme and the commitment to a major expansion in council housebuilding.

But if we're serious about delivering that ambition, we need to see the detail that will make it real now, not in 10 years' time, now. How many of those homes will actually be owned by councils? How much funding will go directly to local authorities? Will councils have the borrowing capacity they need to deliver, and will grant rates make genuinely social rent homes financially viable? And finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, we've got to be honest about what we mean by affordable.

A home doesn't become affordable simply because we put the word affordable in front of it. For a family on a low wage, 80% of an inflated market rent can still be completely unaffordable. Social rent has to be different, and it's different because it's designed for what people can genuinely afford. So we have to invest in council housebuilding and make that a central pillar of our industrial strategy going forward. There's been lots of talk about crowding in private investment this week.

That'll only happen if the government sets the strategic direction here and puts the funding on the table for councils to deliver. Thank you.

05:51:29 - 05:54:43

Liz Jarvis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As someone who grew up in rented accommodation with all the uncertainty that goes with it, I fully understand the pressures faced by so many families who just want a permanent home of their own. So I welcome many of the provisions in this bill, notably the reforms to right to buy and the strengthened protections for tenants of domestic violence. Right to buy transformed the lives of millions of social housing tenants, letting them own a home when that seemed a distant dream, but its implementation ravaged the social housing stock in this country. Over two million homes sold, only 500,000 new social rent homes built since 1980.

That is why I welcome this bill's provisions protecting what remains of that stock, extending the minimum tenancy requirement, curtailing discounts the number of times a tenant can exercise right to buy, and giving local authorities first refusal when a social home is resold. These are positive steps towards redressing the balance between social and private rented housing. The Liberal Democrat run council in Eastleigh has invested heavily in housing across the borough through partnerships with housebuilders and housing associations and by commissioning homes directly. The recent announcement that Eastleigh is one of three strategic partners in Homes England's social and affordable homes programme 2026 to 2036 is testament to their success. Madam Deputy Speaker, for too long it has been the victims of domestic abuse who have been forced to escape their homes.

Clause 12 and schedule 1 begin to correct that, giving survivors a simplified legal mechanism to remove an abuser from a joint social tenancy, so it is the perpetrator who loses the home they use as a weapon of control. Crucially, this bill also closes a loophole that has too often been exploited where an abuser can currently end a joint tenancy on a technicality through a notice to quit while possession proceedings against them are ongoing, leaving the survivor with nothing. This bill stops that, giving housing associations the clear workable powers they've lacked to help survivors remain safely in their own home or move to suitable alternative social housing without losing tenancy rights. My constituent Karen and her two children fled domestic abuse. She was refused social housing because she jointly owns a property her ex-partner deliberately keeps off the market as a form of control.

After a year spent in a refuge, living in a single room, Karen and her children were served a notice to leave with nowhere secure to go. They have since found a home but should never have had to fight this hard to get one. Her case shows that a joint title property can trap a domestic abuse survivor just as surely as a joint tenancy can, and the same is true of housing related debt caused by an abuser. Madam Deputy Speaker, clause 17 removes uncommenced provisions from the 2016 Housing and Planning Act that would have phased out lifetime secure tenancies. I strongly support this.

It gives tenants housing security and lets a family build a life within a community, not just occupy a home. In conclusion, this bill seeks to simplify what never needed complicating and protect what matters to tenants. So I support the bill and trust the committee will ask how this proposed legislation could go further to ensure everyone has a home to call their own.

05:54:43 - 05:56:02

Darren James Paffey

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I congratulate my honourable friend the minister for bringing this forward. This is a manifesto commitment and it is one that will matter enormously to communities like mine in Southampton, prioritising the building of social homes and protecting, better protecting the stocks that we already have. And we're talking a lot about bricks and mortar, but I'm sure we all know that these measures speak directly to whether children have a stable place to grow up, whether survivors of abuse can live their lives in safety, and whether places like Southampton can offer its residents decent affordable housing as a reality, not a pipe dream. Our city council manages around 18,000 homes.

There are another two and a half thousand leasehold and shared ownership properties. It's a huge and valuable asset, but it is an asset under strain with more than 8,000 people on the waiting list. And in that time, that means families live in overcrowded flats, they're in temporary accommodation, and workers who come and contribute enormously to our city can't afford a home that is genuinely affordable or secure.

And these are the kinds of situations that come up in my surgery, and I'm sure others too. I will give way.

05:56:02 - 05:56:22

Sarah Russell

Many thanks for giving way. Does the honourable gentleman find, as I do in my patch, that those who are on the social housing waiting list far longest are often those with a disability who need a fully adaptable home, and that it is vital that when we spend the money on building public money on building new homes, that they should be built to an accessible and adaptable standard from the off?

05:56:22 - 06:00:06

Darren James Paffey

I thank the honourable lady for making a very salient point. It is true on my patch as well, either for themselves as the tenants or needing homes with adaptations for disabled children. So that is something I hope the minister will be able to speak to. All of these are reasons why one of the most important and most welcome aspects of this bill is its central measure to protect existing social housing stock by reforming the right to buy. Since 1980, this country has sold more than 2 million social homes through right to buy, replacing only a fraction of them.

And of the three council homes that I remember growing up in as a child with my family, I often wonder whether those have been lost to the system rather than the great memories of a secure home that we had. Southampton has felt that loss directly as well, as at the same time as facing rising costs for emergency accommodation for homeless families. So the measures in this bill on extending the qualifying period, on tapering the discount, and on exempting new social homes are sensible, proportionate changes. They preserve a genuine route into home ownership for long-standing tenants while removing the perverse incentive that has for decades discouraged councils like mine from building. I welcome the new requirement for private registered providers to give notice before selling a home so that the council or another provider has a real chance to keep it in the social sector.

It's a small but it's a practical protection and one that I will strongly be encouraging Southampton City Council to use. And I also particularly welcome the provisions in part three related to survivors of domestic abuse. As other members have said, a home should be a place of safety. Yet for many victims, housing insecurity is what stops them from escaping abuse. That is unforgivable and we have to remove that barrier.

These measures will make it easier for survivors to remain in safe accommodation, and I hope that members across the house should be able to unite behind that principle. Can I ask the minister to address two questions in his winding up? Firstly, how will the government ensure that these protections translate into a genuine long-term increase in social rented stock in high-demand areas like Southampton, where waiting lists and temporary accommodation costs are already straining local services? And secondly, what support will be available to local authorities and to housing associations to implement the bill successfully? We know that the legislative reform is essential, but councils need the financial and operational capacity to deliver the outcomes that we are all so behind.

So will the department match the ambition of this bill with the capital investment needed to ensure that authorities like Southampton, which already carry a decent homes backlog on more than half their stock, can genuinely invest?

As others have said, legislation alone won't solve every aspect of the home, the housing crisis that faces Southampton and the country. But this bill takes bold and meaningful steps in the right direction, protecting social housing, stopping the leaks in the bucket. It protects survivors of domestic abuse in their own homes and it gives councils the tools and the confidence to build again. I know that for residents in Southampton and across the company, across the country, sorry, who need a safe, affordable and secure home, that progress matters and that's why I will proudly vote for this progress today.

06:00:06 - 06:00:55

Bobby Dean

Deputy Speaker, 7.9 billion pounds a year. That's how much the Chartered Institute of Housing estimates is spent on housing benefit for tenants renting privately. Now, in my local area, a lot of that will be going to people living on the St Helier estate, which was one of the largest London council estates built during the interwar period, but much of which has been sold under right to buy over the past few decades. So that means that instead of our local authority receiving rent from those properties, the national government is paying market rates to private landlords of homes that we built. This is maddening.

And it surely makes the scale of right to buy sales alongside the failure to replenish the stock one of the single greatest policy failures for a generation.

06:00:55 - 06:01:12

Feryal Clark

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way and indeed I know the St Helier estate well. But wouldn't he agree that it was his own party, the Liberal Democrats, in coalition with the Conservatives, who massively increased discounts for the right to buy that caused the very problem he is talking about today?

06:01:12 - 06:04:25

Bobby Dean

I'm sure the honourable member is well aware that right to buy sales were happening throughout the 90s and during the last Labour government as well. So I think there is a stain on all parties over the last few decades on this matter. The impact of this loss of stock is of course not only to the taxpayer, but to our constituents. My inbox is full of people struggling in the housing market. It's by far the biggest issue that I face in my patch.

And it's the one that I end up feeling the most hopeless of. Sure, we can get things fixed in relation to condition of housing and repairs, and sometimes we are able to get people's position on the waiting list successfully reviewed. But a lot of the time, the fundamental issue is supply and that we've got thousands of people waiting and just a couple of hundred of properties becoming available a year. And for that I have no magic wand. And it means that I have families living in one-bedroom accommodation where teenagers are sharing the only bedroom and parents are sleeping on the sofa.

And I have hard-working families come up to me all the time who are frustrated that they're told that there's no point in them even applying to get on the list. And it didn't used to be this way. I myself benefited first-hand from growing up in council accommodation. My parents are working-class parents, scaffolder and cleaners, and they raised a family in that household well. And when my youngest brother was born, the third sibling, we managed to move from a two-bedroom flat into a three-bedroom house.

And that was considered normal back then. And now that sort of situation feels like a luxury. We've turned social housing into an emergency provision for the vulnerable instead of being the foundation of our society. And to fix this supply problem is going to require pretty bold reforms to local authority resources and powers. They need greater staffing capacity, they need relief from the unjustified housing revenue account debts, and they need to be liberated to build directly.

Now, the right to buy reforms in this bill and the form the centerpiece of this bill are very welcome and it will stem the losses. But it must surely only be the first step if the Prime Minister's ambition in this area is to be realized.

And given how precious legislative time is in this place, I would hope that more work will be done as this bill progresses through the House to increase the supply of homes too. And finally, I want to remark upon how what has happened to social housing in this country is part of a broader public policy failure, one where the government is forced into throwing good money after bad, intervening late rather than investing early. And I hope that we can in the future understand that social housing is recognized as national infrastructure, is part of our national resilience, and we must invest to save more often as a government. So I welcome this bill as a first step on that journey, and I look forward to the government going further to reverse the failures of the past. And seeing as I have the time, I'll make one more remark.

I think it's notable that the Conservative party have put forward a wrecking amendment today, one that picks on minorities, but not a single one of their backbenchers have come to defend it. What a disgrace. They should have the bravery to make the argument in full if that's what they want to do today. Thank you.

06:04:25 - 06:08:30

Andrew Graham Cooper

And with a three-minute time limit from after the next speaker, Andrew Cooper.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I am mindful of time so I'll just make two points. Firstly, on right to buy. No one would dispute that the right to buy scheme has helped many families achieve the dream of home ownership that might otherwise have been beyond their reach, but its ideological implementation has had consequences. More than two million social homes have been sold since the scheme was first introduced, yet far too many of those properties were never replaced. The result has been a significant reduction in the stock of good quality affordable social housing that's available to meet today's demand, and the risk that newly built homes could be lost before the investment costs can be recovered has weakened confidence of providers to invest in new social housing at anywhere like the scale required.

We have more than 1.3 million households on social housing waiting lists while close to 180,000 children are growing up without the security of a stable home. I therefore welcome the measures that seek to place right to buy on a more sustainable footing, to protect existing social housing stock, to encourage new house building, and to ensure that more people are able to access the decent, safe, secure, and affordable homes that every family deserves. Where I would like to see the bill go further though is in ensuring that homes sold at a discount through right to buy do not immediately end up being let out for private profit. The New Economics Foundation estimates that 41% of homes sold through right to buy are now in the private rented sector. This cannot be justified as a good use of public money.

I hope the government will consider amendments to prevent this from occurring in future, at least for a period of time after a property is sold, and I'd be happy to speak to the minister about how we can bring that forward. Finally, I want to turn to the introduction of meaningful safeguards for survivors of domestic abuse. These measures recognize that access to safe and secure housing is often fundamental not only to a survivor's ability to escape, but to rebuild their lives afterwards. We know that perpetrators can exploit housing insecurity as a means of control, leaving victims facing an impossible choice: remain in an abusive situation and continue to endure harm, or leave and risk homelessness and further insecurity. No survivor should ever be forced to make that choice.

It is therefore a significant step forward that we are giving social landlords stronger tools to respond, particularly in relation to complex cases involving joint tenancies. The ability for survivors to seek the removal of an abusive partner from a tenancy, enabling them to remain in the safety and familiarity of their own home is extremely positive. Personally, I'd like to see the bill go further though by introducing specific measures to tackle furniture poverty among survivors. Escaping an abusive relationship often requires people to leave home at extremely short notice, taking with them little more than a few personal belongings.

Worse, many survivors have been subjected to financial abuse, leaving them without savings, access to credit, or the means to replace the items needed to create a new safe and secure home. Whilst it's fundamentally important that victims of domestic abuse are always given priority access to social housing, the reality is that many of the allocated properties are entirely unfurnished. As a result, families who've already experienced trauma can find themselves moving into an empty property without beds, kitchens, appliances, flooring, curtains, or other basic household items. In these circumstances, the challenge is not simply accessing housing, but being able to live in it. A safe and secure home should be the foundation from which survivors rebuild their lives, not the start of another period of hardship.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is an important pillar of the government's work and commitment to create a social housing system that is fairer, more secure, and works better for the people who depend on it. I'm proud to support this bill and the positive changes it seeks to address across our social housing sector.

06:08:30 - 06:11:27

Andrew George

Thank you, George. Deputy Speaker, I support the bill and I think it's the beginning of what the government should be doing, but I do think that they can and should go a great deal further, both in relation to addressing the need for significant growth in the scale of social housing being built and also to support those particularly vulnerable groups and as the bill rightly says, the victims of domestic violence. I'm also surprised that the right to buy, or the protections from right to buy, hasn't been extended by preventing sales of those homes which are held by community land trusts, housing co-ops, and not-for-profit housing providers who have very small stocks and really those do need to be absolutely protected. I'm also surprised that the government hasn't brought forward measures to stop the bedroom tax, which is something which it campaigned against during the coalition government and indeed I brought in an affordable homes bill at that stage which the then Labour government supported and they haven't proceeded to continue to include it in this bill as well. In relation to disposals in clause 12 of the bill on which I intervened on the minister earlier, I do hope that the minister will take a second look at this issue because certainly the hemorrhaging presently of the amount of stock going out into the private sector as a result of understandable requirements of government to achieve higher levels of EPC levels and obviously decent home standards and where it becomes too expensive for housing associations to deliver that, what they should also do is there should be a presumption in favor of disposal to democratic bodies such as community land trusts at a value consistent with affordable housing.

The problem is the housing associations sell them at open market value when in fact they could be taken on by local charitable bodies and still be provided to local people in housing need. I know that the minister referred to my private member's bill and certainly there are a number of provisions in it which I hope he would consider, which I don't need to propose myself, and also to strengthen the protections of areas outside immediately adjoining communities vis-à-vis the reference to rural exceptions policies which were made by my honorable friend the member for Taunton earlier. We do need to protect those and indeed find out how we can deliver more social housing when the hope value is being fueled by counterproductive housing targets which is undermining so many measures which should be available to communities to deliver what is desperately needed.

06:11:27 - 06:13:33

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Housing remains one of the biggest challenges in my inbox, and I meet weekly with constituents who are stuck on a waiting list for social housing. In fact, almost 5,000 families are waiting for somewhere to call home. And I'm proud to support this government, which is committed to the biggest increase in social housing in a generation. And that is in stark contrast to the record of the party opposite.

Rough sleeping up 165% under that government. The number of children living in temporary accommodation more than doubling. And their current plan to add another 100,000 to that list is simply not acceptable, not on our watch. So I welcome this bill. I agree that it is right that we incentivise the building of social homes.

We need to build more in Gloucester, and I stand ready to work with Gloucester City Council on a cross-party basis, local housing associations, and Homes England to deliver this. But it's also important that we improve the quality of existing social homes too, and follow through on the promises made to local residents in Podsmead and Matson, who've been promised regeneration of their areas for far too long without it being delivered. And finally, I'm pleased to see the cross-departmental work that this department is doing to tackle violence against women and girls. No one should be forced to stay in an unsafe situation because they're worried about becoming homeless. So I welcome measures to support survivors and victims of domestic abuse, especially new mechanisms to remove perpetrators from their tenancies, not victims.

Alongside our government's commitment to offer everyone sleeping rough a roof by Christmas, with 1.6 million pounds for Gloucester City Council to deliver this, we're making a clear argument on these benches that everyone deserves a safe, decent place to call home. Those are the foundations that we need so that we can rebuild hope in Gloucester and deliver the better future that my constituents deserve.

06:13:33 - 06:16:31

Charlotte Cane

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I refer Member to my register of interests. I'm an East Cambridgeshire District Councillor, a district council which erroneously boasts of being debt-free because it sold its housing stock many years ago, and criticises the other district council in my constituency, South Cambridge, and indeed Cambridge City, for having major debts without mentioning that they've retained their council houses and indeed built more, continue to build more. So I absolutely agree we have to, have to address that. Average house prices in my constituency are about 10 times average salary.

The average rent is over 1,000 pounds a month. So it's not surprising that a lot of my inbox is talking about social housing need. And indeed, I've had people in my surgeries in tears because they can't get decent homes for their family. So we must build more council houses. I support that.

I would like the Minister to consider carefully rural areas where we might be able to only accommodate two or three, but we really do need them. And it's not just a case of building large quantities in, in the bigger towns. And that we need a good mix of council housing, larger houses for larger families, bungalows for people who are getting more elderly and, and want to downsize. And we also need to make sure that those houses that we have are in really good condition. And I, I really welcome the Warm Homes Social Housing Fund, which is helping many of my constituents replace their oil-fired boilers with air source heat pumps.

But I wonder if there could be a similar sort of grant to bring those houses up to a good standard.

Many of them were built in the 20s and 30s and then very poorly insulated in around the 70s, which is adding to the damp problems. And it's a huge cost for the social housing providers to address that. And as we've heard, what is ending up happening is when those houses become empty, because they cannot make the figures stack up, the cost of the repairs versus the future income rent stream, they're selling those houses in the private sector. And some of them are in my villages where we already don't have anything like enough social houses. So they really do need some financial help to bring that stock up to a decent standard.

And shared ownership, I also get people worried about that because they feel trapped. The very high service charges, they can't afford, but when they try to sell it, potential buyers look at the very high service charges and pull out of the scheme. So I'm really glad the government is going to review that.

06:16:31 - 06:19:15

James William Naish

James Naish.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome this bill and the government's commitment to a decade of renewal for social and affordable housing. And I want to use my time today to speak on behalf of the villages in my Rushcliffe constituency and to draw the House's attention to the work of the Labour Rural Research Group. Too often affordable housing is discussed as though it is purely an urban and metropolitan problem. It is not, as we've just heard.

In villages across Rushcliffe and across rural Britain, families are being priced out of the places where they grew up. Young people are leaving because they cannot find a home. And the stock of social housing that once anchored our rural communities is shrinking, not growing. The LRRG's report from March 2026 on rural poverty in England sets this out starkly. In 2024-2025, just 17,506 affordable homes were delivered in rural local authorities, against 47,256 in urban ones.

And rural delivery actually fell by 2% on the year before, while urban delivery rose. And in a significant number of rural councils, only 4% of homes are affordable to someone on an average local income, against 10% in urban authorities. And that is why I particularly welcome the fact that this bill already exempts properties in designated rural areas from right to buy. That principle reflects exactly what the LRRG called for in its report: recognition that rural housing is structured differently and that policy needs to treat it accordingly. But I do want to press the Minister to go further on three specific areas.

First, on the disposal of rural social housing stock. We would particularly welcome a local replacement guarantee so rural communities are not subsidising urban housing waiting lists at the expense of their own when stock is disposed. Secondly, on rural exception sites. These small sites deliver really important housing opportunities in rural areas. But the LRRG has called for these to be placed on a statutory footing alongside the bill's right to buy reforms and for the policy to be strengthened and simplified so that planning authorities can accelerate delivery.

And thirdly, on measurement and targets. As it stands, we do not properly track rural affordable housing delivery as a distinct category. And the LRRG has called for a dedicated rural affordable housing delivery target with separate monitoring by tenure type, because without that data, we cannot know whether policies are working for rural communities.

06:19:15 - 06:19:17

Speaker 287

Will the honourable gentleman give way?

06:19:18 - 06:19:30

Sarah Russell

Might I suggest a fourth area on which the Minister could go further, which is producing social housing which has flooring as standard?

That is what's delivered by the private market, but it's not a requirement for social housing providers at the moment. Thank you.

06:19:30 - 06:20:11

James William Naish

I thank you for intervention, and I think there're several areas where we can definitely provide greater intervention to support our rural communities. But let me be clear, this bill is a good and necessary step. It protects social housing stock, it gives greater security to survivors of domestic abuse, and reduces unnecessary bureaucracy for providers. But if we are genuinely serious about a decade of renewal that reaches every postcode, rural Britain cannot be an afterthought. And so I hope the minister will look closely at the LRG's recommendations as this bill progresses, so that we can make sure that rural communities are not left behind.

06:20:11 - 06:23:15

Hannah Kathrine Spencer

Green MPs welcome this bill as a step in the right direction. It includes important changes, but it doesn't match the scale of our housing crisis, and it needs to be braver and bolder and deliver the council homes our communities desperately need. Social housing is not just a roof over your head, it is a secure home where you come back to after a long day, it's where your kids grow up and your grandkids come round. It's knowing your neighbours and having somewhere safe and secure to put down roots. That is the kind of security that everyone deserves.

But more than 1.3 million households are waiting for a social home, and more than 170,000 children are living in temporary accommodation. And that statistic alone should shame us into action. Councils are giving millions of pounds to private landlords. And I see what the lack of council housing means for people in Gorton and Denton every single day. Across Manchester and Tameside, 3,180 households are in temporary accommodation, including 5,368 children.

There are parents of four children, including twin babies with additional needs, squeezed into a two-bedroom home. A family of seven, including a child with a rare genetic disorder, living in an overcrowded three-bedroom home. And the couple who've been on waiting lists for over 10 years, now approaching retirement and terrified that they simply won't be able to afford their rent when they have to stop working. So we need to do three things. First, stop selling off the homes that we've already got.

We need to abolish right to buy. And this bill makes it harder, but if more than a million households are waiting for a social home, how can we still justify selling them off at all? And this is not to criticise anyone who has bought their council home. Those people aren't to blame, but the policy is. Scotland ended right to buy in 2016, Wales has done the same, and it is time for England to join them.

Second, we need more social homes. We need to build more social homes. After the Second World War, councils were building more than 120,000 social homes a year on average. We need that ambition again. Because today, councils in England are building an average of just 1,320 social rent homes a year.

And on my maths, that is an average of about four per constituency. And when the Prime Minister was campaigning to be MP for Macclesfield, he said that all of the 39 billion pound affordable housing fund should be dedicated to building council homes. But he has now backtracked on that. Why? We need to get building again, properly and at scale.

And third, we need to buy back the stock. Green MPs are fully behind the councils that are buying existing homes to bring them back into council housing. And buy the supply is an idea brilliantly championed by my honourable friend, the member for Brighton Pavilion. We need more of this. So my message to the government is simple: be braver, abolish right to buy, build social homes at scale, and do more of buy the supply.

06:23:15 - 06:26:08

Chris Hinchliff

Can I also declare an interest as the chair of the APPG on council and social housing. The scale of the housing crisis in our communities today represents, in a crowded field, the most consequential and damaging retreat of the public realm in the UK and a dereliction of its most basic duties.

Madam Deputy Speaker, everyone deserves a safe, comfortable and stable home where they can put down roots. So it is very welcome that through this bill our national politics begins to recognize that that which you cannot live without cannot be left to private markets which respond to demand, not need, and that those will never be the same thing in a deeply unequal society like ours. Madam Deputy Speaker, the consequences of the failure to understand this fundamental economic reality are writ large across our nation. More than 130,000 households trapped in temporary accommodation with many stuck in B&Bs and hostels which are no place to raise a family. Frankly, it will remain difficult to talk seriously about national pride while at least 170,000 kids are homeless in this country and are left without the space to learn and play, to grow and simply enjoy their childhood.

That human cost, measured in the futures and happiness of a generation, is proof enough of the urgent need for a change in direction. The choice before us then, and our new Prime Minister is absolutely right in this regard, is whether we continue with a model that provides unsuitable accommodation at extortionate prices or whether we put the public back in the driving seat. I welcome this bill's attention to retaining the social housing stock we already have. For far too long we've lost social homes faster than we have built them. Putting a firm stop to this trend alongside the Prime Minister's commitment to a new generation of council homes puts us in a commission to position to finally get the housing crisis under control.

And I would remind the house that in six years, at a time of shortages, debt, constraints and competing demands on public expenditure even greater than our own, the post-war Labour government oversaw the construction of more than 800,000 council houses, some of the best ever built in this country. So Madam Deputy Speaker, now is the time to once again recognize that the only way to get high-quality homes that those on waiting lists can actually afford is to directly plan and deliver council housing for people on low incomes, and that only the government on behalf of the people can mobilize the patient capital capable of realizing all the wider benefits that decent homes for all will secure for our society. With fresh leadership in the department, I look forward to supporting this important legislation to ensure we deliver the quality social homes our communities need.

06:26:08 - 06:28:55

Charles Edward Robin Morello

Edward Morello.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In 2021, there were 6,145 social housing units in the West in my West Dorset constituency, representing just 14.2% of the housing stock compared with 17.1% across England and Wales. More than 300,000 people are currently on rural social housing waiting lists. At the current build rate, it would take 89 years to clear that backlog. I welcome the bill's measures to disapply right to buy in national parks and designated rural areas.

In places where social housing is already scarce, we cannot afford to lose more of it. It is therefore right that we protect the limited stock that we currently have. More than anything though, I welcome the bill's protections for the victims of domestic abuse, because this is where the question of housing becomes a question of safety. If someone knows that leaving means homelessness, temporary accommodation or being separated from their children, family and support network, the decision to leave an abusive relationship becomes enormously harder. The bill rightly proposes protections allowing victims in joint social tenancies to remain in their home while the perpetrator is removed, as well as helping victims secure alternative accommodation.

four-year-old son Neo who because of verbal and emotional abuse from her former partner who was a joint tenant. Neo has cerebral palsy and has recently undergone back surgery. He's learning to walk again using mobility aids. Stephanie is temporarily staying with her mother and urgently needs suitable housing. But because the rent on the family home is not up to date she has been told assistance cannot be provided until the arrears is resolved.

She is terrified she'll be placed in temporary accommodation away from Bridport away from her support network that her son relies on. This is precisely why housing-related debt arising from domestic abuse must not become a barrier to accessing social housing. A survivor should not be punished for financial circumstances created or exacerbated by their abuser. And I therefore strongly support strengthening the bill so that survivors can leave unsafe homes retain their tenancy rights where appropriate or secure suitable alternative housing without being trapped by the financial consequences of the abuse. I also want to raise the point that a home is not suitable simply because it is technically available.

I have casework involving Ruby who was offered a first-floor flat in Bridport despite having serious physical disabilities. She was told she couldn't refuse the property she would not be offered alternative housing. I have numerous other caseworks that time simply is not going to allow me to get to which is a shame but I just want to say that I would want to see the government go further in ensuring that social housing allocation in rural areas reflects local needs accessibility disability age and family circumstances but otherwise I support this bill. Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:28:55 - 06:28:56

Jon Trickett.

06:28:56 - 06:32:06

Speaker 293

Thank you very much Ma'am. And I must say I was disappointed with the spokesperson for the opposition who sounded complacent when he talked about aspiration. The aspiration to buy a house of course that's but doesn't he understand the aspiration of people on the waiting list millions of people many children in 170,000 children in temporary accommodation who aspire just to have a key for a council house and has he ever seen the gleam in a family's eyes when they've got that key and managed to get a secure home knowing it was there for the future. It is not good enough to simply say the aspiration to buy a house is more important than the aspiration to have a home that is warm and secure. Now and also there was no sense of contrition that the right to buy legislation resulted in two million council houses being sold since the legislation went in.

Two million whereas only a quarter of a million new houses were built in that period of time. And of those two million that were sold 800,000 now belong to private landlords. And that is quite a shocking thing as well because the rents which private landlords charge are a multiple of what a council or a social landlord would charge as well. In my constituency 6,000 homes have gone to private landlords. Now the council received about 140 million pound in capital receipts for those 6,000 houses.

140 million. They are now worth 1.1 billion. This has been a racket. It's been like a gold rush of in the Klondike or something like that a race to money. And in the meantime rent levels in the remaining social housing are only 61% of the level of the rents which are being charged by the private landlords.

And it is totally anomalous that in the same street on the same estate two or three houses will be charging a larger rent by the private landlord than the people next door who are still renting from a social landlord. The whole thing has been anomalous and I think the government does need to move fast. We cannot allow so many children and families to be left in that very very perilous situation. 55,000 individuals in the in the district of Wakefield struggling. But let me just make one point because the Treasury's dead hand of economic orthodoxy prioritizes house building by housing associations over house building by councils.

That is a mistake. Now, this legislation today isn't addressing that, but I wonder whether the Minister will respond in some way because those rules that a council can borrow money for an asset and build an asset which is worth more than the borrowing and then receive an income which pays for the rent, but yet it still counts against the national debt, whereas a housing association can do something different. And so that, I think, explains the retreat from the commitment to building more houses by councils rather than social landlords.

06:32:06 - 06:35:00

Caroline Jane Voaden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome much of what is in this bill. The reforms to right to buy are overdue and the new protections for tenants experiencing domestic abuse are an important step forward. But this bill lacks the ambition needed to address the wider social housing crisis and it does little to address a problem hollowing out village after village across South Devon: the disposal of social housing by registered providers. Since 2018-19, housing associations have sold over 25,000 social and affordable homes on the open market.

In 24-25 alone, they sold 5,250, the highest figure on record. In the South Hams, one housing association has sold 49 homes since 2022, with the heaviest losses in Salcombe and Dartmouth, where property is extremely expensive, and in Kingswear, 36% of social housing stock has been lost in just three years. The primary school has since closed due to a lack of pupils and with so little affordable housing left, there is little prospect of new families moving in. So we've seen across my constituency 3,600 new homes built over the last five years, yet more than 2,500 families remain in housing need. Most are at full market price, way beyond the reach of local people, and I absolutely refute what the Shadow Minister said.

The answer is not building more open market homes that cost a million pounds. When a single social rented home became available in Marlborough, 190 households bid for it. In Brixham, 190 people bid for one social home. Yet councils have no power to stop housing associations disposing of the few affordable homes that remain. Now, I'm really proud that council housing was introduced by the Liberal Party under Lloyd George.

I'm furious that Conservatives enabled so much of it to be lost. Just this morning, I heard from a constituent whose disabled son was offered a bungalow perfectly suited to his needs, allowing him to live independently while remaining close to his family. The family were then told that the housing association intended to dispose of it. A home that could have transformed someone's life is being sold. It's heartbreaking.

I'd also like to address the issue of smaller developments of affordable, including social rented homes, being needed in villages. We have to build small amounts of social housing around villages so young people who've grown up in the village can afford to stay there and older people can downsize. And yet the social housing providers are just fixated on large developments on the side of towns. The future of rural communities depends on homes that local people can afford. Without real powers for councils to protect social housing and hold developers to their affordable housing commitments, we will keep watching schools shrink, shops close, and villages empty out.

One sale and one broken promise at a time. It's not good enough.

06:35:00 - 06:38:00

Elizabeth Helen Hayes

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The housing crisis is the single biggest issue facing my constituents in Dulwich and West Norwood, and every single year since I was first elected as a local councillor on the same day that the coalition government came into power in 2010, I have watched the housing crisis deepen and become more entrenched in my constituency.

Our local council had vital grant funding for new social homes withdrawn. Subsequent Conservative governments froze and cut council rents, leaving gaping holes in the housing revenue account and hamstringing our councils on repairs and investment. And right to buy changes have hemorrhaged council homes out of the system and into the private sector, sometimes only for them to be let back to our councils as temporary accommodation at extortionate rents. So, after 14 years of harmful policies, the impacts are clear. Tens of thousands of families living in temporary accommodation in unsafe, damp, moldy conditions, harming health, undermining the essential stability and security that every one of us needs to thrive.

The housing crisis is a housing crisis, but it is also a public health crisis, a cost of living crisis, and a basic human decency crisis. But I rise in particular today to speak to the campaign that I have been running since 2022, a reform to social housing regulations called Georgia's Law. Georgia is a former constituent who had been a social housing tenant for five years when her eldest son was threatened by gang members, having done nothing wrong. The police told Georgia that his life was at risk and that she needed to move. That move into temporary accommodation was catastrophic for Georgia and her family, ultimately resulting in the murder of her second son, a horrific act that would never have happened had that family's life not been destabilized in that way.

And what we discovered was that Georgia had no security of tenure as a social housing tenant in those circumstances where her family had to move through no fault of their own because they were the victims of a threat of serious violence. So I welcome my honorable friend's commitment on this issue and his engagement on this issue. And I particularly want to thank the noble Lord Best for picking up this issue in the Lords and for the debate and discussion that happened in that place. And I look forward to engaging further with my honorable friend on the amendments that might be brought forward to the bill to secure in law the protection for social housing tenants who have to move due to a threat of violence where the police deem that that is necessary, so that they do not suffer the compounding trauma of the destabilization of their lives into temporary accommodation. I will bring forward an amendment at report stage if necessary, but I look forward to further engagement with my honorable friend on this issue in the meantime.

06:38:00 - 06:39:50

Melanie Onn

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And of course we need more council homes and social homes, and it is welcome that this bill makes provision for just that. But for social housing, we would not see the growth in HMOs that are blighting communities up and down the country. That indicates that there is clearly a need for council homes and social homes of the right kind in the right place. It's also worth noting that it is essential that we take action now because by 2024, it is anticipated that an additional 1.3 million pensioners will be living in rented accommodation.

And as their earnings start to level out and become more restricted, whether they are just state pensioners or whether they have some private pension as well, the private rented sector is not necessarily going to be the kindest place for them. And actually, social homes are going to be the places that provide them with security and comfort in their elder years. The Minister will not be surprised to hear me move on to empty homes. It's not the first time that I've mentioned it to him. But we have nearly 2,000 in my constituency.

And so while we talk about building new social homes, I really do think that there is an opportunity to look at not just building new social homes, but looking at houses that are have been in the private sector, that have been empty for a long, long period of time, that makes it easier for local authorities and for third sector voluntary organizations to get access to those homes and utilize them, including bringing in apprenticeships to support bringing them back into use into local communities.

06:39:48 - 06:39:50

Speaker 295

I give way.

06:39:50 - 06:40:11

John Hayes

I thank the Honourable Lady for giving way. She's making a really important point about empty homes. When I was the Shadow Housing Minister 20 years ago, the Empty Homes Agency estimated 700,000 empty homes in England and Wales alone. That number's barely shifted, and no government has brought forward appropriate policies to alter it. And so I do hope this Minister will look at that closely.

06:40:11 - 06:42:12

Melanie Onn

I thank him very much for his intervention and supporting me on that point. I know it is an issue that affects many constituencies across the House. I just finally want to move on to housing associations because obviously they are purveyors of social homes. I do think that there needs to be some form of a review of housing associations in terms of their accountability alongside expectations of how well they work with local authorities because when it comes to things like land management and trees, and there is dispute over who looks after the land. I mean, ultimately, the people who are living in that area really shouldn't have to be worried about who it is who has responsibility, and it seems to be a real sticking point.

I see it all the time in my area. And also housing associations that are holding on to empty land. Particularly in my constituency, there were high-rise flats. They accommodated around 700 people. The housing association decided to tear those down.

It has been an eyesore since 2016. It is space where another housing association or the council or charitable sector could easily access that space and build much-needed new homes in the town centre so we're not seeing that doughnut effect of town centres being hollowed out. And finally, just as a welcome point, it kind of ties into the housing associations. I'm really pleased that despite government not really wanting it to be in there, they have accepted that, or it's been voted in, that the shared ownership rules will be looked at again because where shared ownership properties are owned by housing associations, they are very often a consideration, a very last consideration in their portfolios. And it leads to people who perhaps buy those properties for their first rung on a bit of the housing ladder suddenly finding themselves entirely trapped and then taking up a home that would be somebody else's first step on the ladder.

And there is no requirement for housing associations to take that more seriously.

06:42:12 - 06:44:58

Nadia Whittome

Nadia Whittome.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. One of the major drivers of the housing crisis has been the selling off of our council homes under Thatcher's Right to Buy scheme. Not only has it greatly reduced the supply of social housing, exposing more people to higher rents and the insecurity of private renting, but we now also know that it's indirectly inflated private rents by shifting low-income households into market-rate renting. That's why I welcome this Bill in its aims of protecting existing social housing stock and incentivising the building of more social rented homes. I also commend its commitment to provide greater social security and stability for social tenants who are victims and survivors of domestic abuse.

However, while this Bill turns over a new leaf in our housing policy, I am concerned that it doesn't go far enough on Right to Buy. New social homes will only be protected for 35 years, and existing tenants will wait seven more years to buy their homes at a discount. So we'll still lose our social housing stock, just at a slower pace. The argument we often hear against removing Right to Buy from existing social housing is that it would be unfair to those hoping to buy their homes at a discount.

But selling public assets to private individuals at a loss to the state is accelerating the housing crisis for all. Since council homes began being sold off at a discount, the state has effectively given away an estimated 194 billion pounds. And to add insult to injury, 41% of these homes are now in the hands of private landlords. The government rightly recognizes that we need to replenish our social housing stock. So as well as a mass program of council house building, we must also help local authorities to recover former council homes through grants and a stronger right of refusal policy.

These measures will in the long term pay for themselves. When a typical private tenant spends over a third of their income on rent today, compared to only 10% in 1980, we need more drastic measures to tackle the housing crisis and that includes stabilizing our social housing stock. We should be ending right to buy completely, as Wales and Scotland have. Because every year delayed, Madam Deputy Speaker, is another year that we fail the hundreds of thousands of people without a secure home, the over 170,000 children in England who are in temporary accommodation, and of course the millions paying extortionate rents to their landlords.

06:44:58 - 06:47:54

Peter Swallow

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wholeheartedly welcome this bill and all that it will do to support the very Labour promise that everyone should have access to a safe and secure place to call their home. While the leader of the opposition apparently believes that if nurses, teaching assistants and tradies can't afford to live in Bracknell Forest with its high rents and house prices, they should be forced to move out, I believe the answer is more social and council housing to support people from Bracknell Forest to stay in Bracknell Forest. And that's why I support the leader of Bracknell Forest Council, Helen Purnell's push to make the council a leading force in delivering new council housing. I welcome the measures in this bill on the disposal of social houses by registered providers, but it will not be a surprise to the minister to hear me say that I think we need to go further.

Since 2018, housing associations have permanently sold 28,585 social homes to private and other non-social purchasers, with 5,806 sold in 2024-25 alone, the highest annual figure on record. 87% of those went at open market value, far beyond the reach of local authorities' purchasing power. And unlike right to buy, these homes aren't being sold to the families living in them, they're being sold out of the sector entirely into private ownership. In my constituency, 154 homes have been sold since 2018, including bungalows and several three and four bed properties, the very homes Bracknell Forest families are most in need of. As it stands, this bill is asking for housing providers to give local authorities notification of any disposals they are planning.

But I don't think that they are sufficiently strong enough. And I know at third reading in the other place, the minister confirmed government is planning a Commons amendment on the notification period. So can I press the housing minister for more information on this and what we can do to strengthen that measure? But I also want him to consider two further changes to the bill. Firstly, Homes England should develop a code of responsible disposal practice with the regulator and sector more widely, to which housing providers can be held to as a condition of holding long-term partner status under the social and affordable homes program.

A very simple principle here: if they're receiving government money, they should not be disposing of homes wherever possible. Second, where a social home is disposed of, the government should do more to ensure that the income is reinvested in a replacement social rent home in the same local authority area. I know my right honourable friend shares my concerns about this issue, and I'm committed to working with him and the government to make sure this bill addresses disposals properly. And I look forward to constructive conversations with the minister as this bill progresses.

06:47:54 - 06:50:45

Apsana Begum

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As chair of the APPG on domestic violence and abuse, but also as a survivor of domestic abuse with direct experience of how this issue relates to social housing, I hope that this bill can truly ensure that it leaves no survivor behind. Indeed, survivors and survivor-led organizations that have been campaigning for decades do welcome many provisions in this bill, but have also expressed concern that some of the proposed protections would apply to too small a proportion of survivors. With criminal justice outcomes for domestic abuse so poor, it is clear that civil outcomes should be considered as part of the mandatory grounds for eviction, and I'm glad to have heard today that the issuing of a protective order will be introduced to schedule one. I also believe that we should consider enhancing these grounds to include victims and survivors of rape and other sexual offenses, including where a perpetrator is not an intimate partner, for instance, a flatmate.

I also hope that the ministers can clarify how it will incentivize or ensure, how the government will incentivize or ensure that these powers are actually used by landlords rather than leaving them as wholly discretionary. On joint tenancies, there are grounds to say that the proposals exclude many survivors who are not listed as tenants, disproportionately affecting younger survivors and survivors of familial abuse. So I'd be grateful if the minister is able to clarify if the government has considered or is considering expanding these protections by accepting established evidence of residency in place of named tenancy. Further, when a perpetrator has been removed from a joint tenancy, then an unsustainable financial burden may arise for a survivor holding sole custody. With the benefit system likely to be too slow to respond, Women's Aid and Refuge and others have called for consideration to be given by the DWP and the minister's own department as to how to incorporate affordability assessments at the point of transfer.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, when it comes to provisions on alternative accommodation, this brings up the issue of furniture poverty faced by far too many survivors, and the calls from experts to introduce a statutory duty for social housing provision for survivors to come furnished is a matter I hope the government can also pick up. To conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, I understand that I've raised many different points of consideration, but there should be no doubt that the ambition of halving VAWG in a decade will require painstaking efforts across all departments and to examine all frameworks. On housing, there is just still far, far more to be done. And that means listening to the VAUX sector and to survivors when they point out shortfalls in these proposals. I hope that the minister will listen to these concerns and offer to meet with members of the APPG to discuss our concerns and recommendations.

Thank you.

06:50:45 - 06:51:37

Speaker 301

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I actually had a much longer speech prepared for this debate, but with constraints on time, I don't think I'm going to get to give it. So I'll just reflect on the fact that for the majority of this debate, the Conservative benches have been next to empty, with almost no contributions from their side other than the front bench. And I posit whether that is because of an element of shame on the part of the backbenchers of what contribution we had from that front bench. A Tory party who not too long ago were led by somebody born on the Upper East Side of New York, deciding that they're going to start defining your value as a British citizen on whether or not technically you were born here.

For shame. And I'm more than happy to get behind fully this legislation.

06:51:37 - 06:54:25

Perran Moon

Hear, hear. Madam Deputy Speaker, Cornwall's social housing shortage is a major contributor not only to our severe housing crisis but one of the greatest blockers to economic regeneration. In the Conservative years, the construction of new social housing in Cornwall plummeted in 2015-16, for example, just six new homes were built for social rent across the entire Duchy. Combine that with 14,000 second homes and nearly 24,000 Airbnb listings, which further reduces the overall housing stock, and it comes as no shock that our social housing waiting list now stands at a staggering 25,000, which incurs vast costs for emergency and temporary accommodation. The size of that register will only grow in coming years unless urgent action is taken.

In light of our acute housing crisis, I warmly welcome measures in this bill to protect our existing social housing stock, particularly the right to buy exemptions for new social homes and for those in designated rural areas. But the scope of this bill addresses just one element of Cornwall's housing crisis, and I welcome the former Chancellor's stamp duty increase for second homes from 3 to 5%. I also welcome the Secretary of State for DCMS's confirmation last week that a new registration scheme for short-term lets will be live by March. But we must go further, and to that end, I have three quick asks of government. Firstly, I would urge the government to review Cornwall Council's 90 million pound housing revenue account debt associated with the 2012 self-financing settlement.

Servicing that inherited debt settlement diverts key resources away from repairs to existing homes and delivering additional affordable housing. Secondly, the government has already recognized the value of low-cost development finance through 0.1% loans to housing extensions. Extending those opportunities to councils would unlock significant additional housing delivery. And thirdly, Cornwall must not be locked out of further powers and funding for social housing simply because we won't be joining a mayoral strategic authority. A strategic place partnership with Homes England would give us not only the framework to deliver social housing for Cornwall, but also the funding which has so far only gone to mayoral strategic authorities.

Cornwall cannot build a stronger economy on a foundation of housing insecurity. The only sustainable answer is to increase our stock of genuinely affordable social homes and to do that at scale. And to that end, I strongly welcome this bill.

06:54:25 - 06:55:21

Speaker 303

Hear, hear. It's a great pleasure to speak in today's debate. I would like to welcome this bill, particularly the very important measures to support the victims of domestic violence and also the sensible measures to reform the right to buy. In the limited time that's available to me, I would just like to point out how valuable this is to my constituents in Reading and other similar parts of the country where there's growing demand on public services, a growing population, and a shortage of housing. Both as an MP and as a councillor, I was very aware of the housing shortage in our town.

And to just describe some of the kind of issues that residents face, they are quite severe. The cost of housing is high. It can be up to 370,000 pounds for a three-bedroom terraced house where I live. And that obviously means that for many people, it's extremely difficult to become an owner-occupier, and social and affordable and council housing is extremely important in our community. I've seen terraced houses split up and subdivided into HMOs or into two flats for residents under extreme pressure.

06:55:21 - 06:57:10

Speaker 302

I've also seen residents have to live, families have to live in emergency housing. And so I'm very much in favour of more social and in particular council housing. And I do believe this bill will help that and support it. We're lucky that our local authority is already taking steps, but I do believe this bill will make, help them and other local authorities to go much, much further. One of the great pleasures recently of my time as an MP was visiting the opening of new council houses in Coley in Reading and seeing wonderful modern homes that have been built by Reading Borough Council next to existing council properties, using land more efficiently, finding more space for houses, improving local facilities like a children's play park.

And I would like to see more of that. And I do believe that the measures, particularly the sensible reforms, will help and support that. And I'm looking forward to working with ministers on exactly that. And in fact our local authority, I should commend them because they have a number of other sites underway. And other local authorities are the same.

But I would like to see a broader measure, a broader movement across the country where more councils take up these sensible policy options, invest in council housing and provide more council homes for residents who aren't unfortunately able to buy a home of their own. And as part of that, very briefly, I would like to just flag to the minister there's an excellent policy which he's announced around liberalising development near stations, which will help hugely with the supply of housing, particularly in our area where only about 10% of the land near Reading station has been regenerated. So I do hope he can perhaps link up these two policies. And I would look forward to talking to him more and perhaps hearing some more this afternoon about that. I also look forward to further action to crack down on irresponsible landlords and to try to support tenants.

And I know he's working very hard on a number of those measures, including on areas like management companies. So I do look forward to hearing more from the minister. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for allowing me to participate.

06:57:10 - 07:00:08

Catherine Eccles

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I welcome the bill that the government has laid before us today. But I want to use my time to talk about community-led housing and its role in delivering on the government's social housing ambitions. I have supported such projects in my constituency for many years because they embody exactly the sort of innovation and local empowerment that we should be encouraging. I would like to acknowledge the work of Eddie Morton, the chair of Stourbridge Community Land Trust, and the development manager of West Midlands Urban Community Homes.

And through their engagement with Birmingham City Council, they have successfully helped secure the adoption of community-led housing policy, creating a valuable precedent for how local authorities can work positively with community-led organisations. Because too often the process highlights some of the structural barriers that continue to hold back community-led housing. And the reality is that many community land trusts face years of delays before a single home can be built. And every one of those delays has a consequence. Money that could have been used to reduce rent locally or improve environmental standards is instead absorbed by additional development costs.

And for small organisations, those pressures are especially acute. And one of the most consistent concerns I hear is not a lack of ambition but a lack of understanding within parts of local government. Officers may support affordable housing in principle, yet lack the knowledge, guidance or confidence needed to engage constructively with community-led organisations. And the result of that is delay, inconsistency and missed opportunity. So if the government is serious about unlocking the full potential of community-led housing, then financial support must be matched by practical support for local authorities and housing associations.

And there is a broader point about trust and confidence. Partnerships between housing associations and community organisations must remain true to the principles upon which the projects are founded. And as recently highlighted by my gallant friend for Birmingham Selly Oak, these agreements don't always play out as planned. So could the minister provide some assurance and guidance to ensure that housing associations honour their commitments to communities and work constructively to deliver genuinely community-led schemes?

And could I also ask the Minister what steps the Government will take to ensure that local authorities have the knowledge, training, and guidance necessary to support community land trusts and other community-led housing? And would the Government consider encouraging councils to identify dedicated officers or champions on these issues to give greater consideration of community organisations when disposing of public land? And finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, what mechanisms does the Government believe are necessary to ensure that community-led housing partnerships remain financially viable and community ownership remains at the heart of the movement? Thank you.

07:00:08 - 07:00:09

Danny Beales.

07:00:09 - 07:02:32

Danny Beales

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As someone for whom a council house was an absolute lifeline out of the cycle of homelessness, I strongly welcome this bill and the Government's action outlined within it. I was homeless not because of someone born abroad, but because of decades of Government inaction, the mass sell-off of council homes without them being replaced, and the housing crisis in this country that's developed over decades. And so I think the comments of the party opposite and their spokesperson were absolutely shameful today. People in temporary accommodation in my constituency will not be served better by those actions.

They will be served better by the measures in this bill. I strongly welcome the Government's action to support victims of domestic violence. So many of us would have seen victims have to leave their accommodation above perpetrators and awful, awful situations result in that. So I strongly welcome the measures in this bill. As I said to the Minister earlier, I do hope that action around rent arrears, only I think around one-fifth of local authorities specifically exclude the rent arrears provisions for victims of domestic violence.

I welcome the guidance but would encourage the Minister to outline perhaps more the timeline for that guidance and how it will be assessed as effective. And I also support the measures to review shared ownership. I've been contacted by Fiona and David and so many constituents who were sold a dream that turned into a nightmare around shared ownership, with a percentage of ownership but all the responsibility when things go wrong. So I encourage that review to be comprehensive and thorough. And lastly, Madam Deputy Speaker, we've heard from a number of other members in this debate about the trap of furniture poverty.

I heard from Shannon who said, who's a victim of domestic abuse and said, "At times I considered returning to the abusive relationship so my daughter would have a bed to sleep in." We have to end furniture poverty. It is not a luxury to have a bed or white goods. They are essential, and not having them trap people in a debt cycle and push them towards rent arrears and future homelessness. I would encourage the Minister to meet with me and with other colleagues interested in ending furniture poverty to explore how this bill could generally do that.

Thank you.

07:02:32 - 07:04:23

Anna Gelderd

With the two-minute time limit, Anna Gelderd.

Whereas, Madam Deputy Speaker, the housing crisis is urgently felt by local people in South East Cornwall and I warmly welcome this Government taking action. In Cornwall, we need first homes, not just second homes, and we need genuinely affordable homes for local people that allows them to stay in the communities where they've built their lives. This is good news for our rural communities because if or when a social home is lost, replacing it can be exceptionally difficult in areas like mine. Our land is constrained, development costs are high, and the pressure from second homes and holiday lets can make it harder for local people to compete in the housing market. I am working with local people to support greater financial literacy and women's financial independence because I believe and know that everyone needs that knowledge to be secure.

So I welcome this focus on the provisions in the bill to protect victims of domestic abuse because often for a woman who's living with an abusive partner, the question of whether she can leave is often tied up to the question of where can she go.

So I ask the Minister to work with Cornwall to secure that strategic partnership and give them more power to make our communities resilient. I welcome the PM's focus on growth in every postcode, and it might interest you to know that in South East Cornwall we have many postcodes that are PL Plymouth area postcodes. So we must see our PL postcodes included in a Homes England deal in Plymouth, and I invite the Minister and the Secretary of State to see how much that investment could matter for our area. I know that the Minister wants to see lots of progress and I'm glad to support the bill. I want to see urgent implementation with Cornwall's help, that partnership, and the same applies to Plymouth.

07:04:23 - 07:05:56

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Jane Kirkham.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the measures in the bill regarding right to buy and exempting properties in designated rural areas and council homes from market rent from the scheme, and welcome Baroness Taylor's commitment to looking at introducing a power for those rural areas to be designated in regulations and potentially with local authorities. Between 1979 and 2025, Cornwall Council sold off 10,000, over, well nearly 11,000 council houses, which is more than the current remaining HRA council housing stock. Meanwhile, we have nearly 25,000 households on the housing register and more than 800 people in temporary and emergency accommodation. Too often, homes that were once part of the social housing stock have been converted into holiday lets or student accommodation, which places huge pressure on an already stretched housing market.

And the covenants in the deeds of ex-council houses, which are intended to prevent them being used for profit, could and should be properly enforced. I recently found a former council home on the Beacon in Falmouth being advertised on a website for 2,500 pounds per week, that is not right. Our ambition for council homes must reach every corner of the country, including rural and coastal communities like Cornwall, where the need is so acute. One of the barriers to delivering more council homes locally is that level of HRA debt, which along with repairs, the state of the construction market, and that council expertise to build, is really important, and would the government please look at options to help councils build when they're faced with those barriers.

07:05:56 - 07:12:29

Lewis Cocking

Which brings us to the front bench contribution, Shadow Minister Lewis Cocking.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it is a pleasure to speak opposite the new Minister, who I very much enjoyed working with on the Housing, Communities and Local Government Select Committee, and now she is on the front bench, I suppose it is left to me to ask the tough questions. This government has said this bill has been designed to encourage social housing providers to invest in the building of new socially rented homes. They want to encourage councils to build by restricting right to buy. That is the wrong approach.

Yes, waiting lists for council homes are far too high, but making it harder for tenants to get on in life and escape the clutches of the public sector is not the right solution. Ministers should look at what their policies are doing instead. Despite their promises, Labour are going backwards on housebuilding. As our reasoned amendment states, last year there were fewer, 12,800 fewer, net additional dwellings delivered in England compared to the previous year. Why aren't the government pledging to take on the developers who are sitting on thousands of unbuilt planning applications?

The Institute for Public Policy, Labour's favourite think tank, has found that 1.4 million homes have been left unbuilt since 2007, despite planning permission being granted. 1.4 million homes sounds rather close to the government's challenging target of 1.5 million new homes. People are fed up with the eyesores in their neighbourhood, levelled ground left abandoned, surrounded by hoardings. I can show the Minister many examples in my Broxbourne constituency, and I'm sure honourable members right across the House could do the same as well.

Taking on the land banking developers would have widespread public support, but this government only seems interested in making it easier to build on the green belt. We are still waiting for the government to reveal what action they're taking to speed up building following the consultations held more than 12 months ago. So Madam Deputy Speaker, there is clearly no urgency. The government should also consider who should be eligible for the help of a social home. People coming to this country and wishing to live here should not be relying on the generosity of taxpayers.

Making Britain your home should be earned by working hard and integrating. It should not come with a free ride on the benefit system. That's why this party will end social housing tenancies for foreign nationals, ensuring that only UK nationals can access social housing would free up 230,000 homes for British families. That change would make an immediate significant difference to those stuck on council house waiting lists, but the government would prefer they sit around waiting for this bill. Sadly, this government, especially its backbenchers, are blindsided by their ideological dislike of right to buy.

It is clearly, it is clearly, and we had a number of people from across this chamber ask where members behind me were today. There are lots of, as I made the point in Westminster Hall, there are lots of calls upon members of parliament's time and I'm sure when we go to our, I'm sure, I'm sure when we go to our constituencies and do surgeries and people ask when I turn on the TV, when I turn on the TV and see hardly anyone in the chamber, we all explain and I suspect there'll be times when all honorable members, when all honorable members can't make important debates that their constituents want them to make. It is clear, it is clear the view from the party opposite that if we had no right to buy, social housing waiting lists would disappear. But where do they think the 2 million families that have utilized the scheme would be without right to buy? Well I can tell them, they would probably be in the same home.

It would just be subsidized by the taxpayer rather than privately owned. Abolishing right to buy is not the silver bullet they think it is. The government is also placing huge burdens on social housing providers to help ministers meet their own net zero targets. The cost of complying with new energy regulations is causing significant financial pressure. Getting 713,000 homes up to a minimum energy efficiency standard is estimated to cost 4.5 billion pounds.

The Chartered Institute for Housing told the select committee that housing associations do not want to buy properties with gas boilers because they know it will cost them more money to strip them out and make the property energy efficient, which is pushing up council house waiting lists. The National Housing Federation is clear what this means, spending billions to comply with net zero regulations will make it harder to build new homes. Ministers already know this. They reduced energy efficiency targets for social housing in January this year, and on that basis, on the basis, sorry, that providers could not build the new homes because of their financial burden of dealing with upgrading of their existing stock. If ministers want councils to be incentivized to build, then getting rid of those expensive regulations entirely would be a good place to start.

What is positive to see in this bill is the review of the shared ownership scheme and I hope when the minister gets to her feet, she can confirm that the government's intention is that this will stay within the bill. This obligation was only added onto by the government by the diligent work of the conservative team in the other place. I have lived in a shared ownership property and I know that alongside other forms of ownership such as leasehold, reforms are desperately needed to fix the many problems residents are facing.

And on this side of the house, we agree that provisions in the bill to protect victims of domestic violence are needed, but a separate legislative measure would have been the right way to bring those forward. And what I would gently say to lots of honorable members that have made impassioned speeches today, I was a council leader, I had a number of meetings with housing providers and housing associations, and not once out of the hundreds of hours of meetings I had with social housing providers did they say to me, the reason why we cannot build new social homes in Broxbourne or for that matter across the country was because of right to buy. That was never mentioned as a reason as to why housing associations are not building social homes. In summary, I will very briefly.

07:12:29 - 07:12:47

Luke Murphy

They did however in the period that the Conservatives in government point to the 60% cut in the affordable housing budget which nearly led to the abolition of social rent under the Conservative government, 97% reduction between 2010 and 2016. That is the record that his party stands on.

07:12:47 - 07:13:38

Lewis Cocking

Well, I just have to say gently to the honorable member who has come to intervene on me quite a lot and we've had quite a ding-dong in this chamber. When I speak to housing providers now, they tell me one of the reasons why they can't build new social homes is because of the national employers' contribution that the government increased on its employees, so they are spending more money on taxes rather than building new social homes. In summary, Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is the wrong approach and it's fundamentally built on the wrong belief. It will not build a single new social home, but what it will do is deny many families the opportunity of ever owning a home of their own. The Conservative party will always be on the side of aspiration and opportunity.

That is why we will be voting for our reasoned amendment today.

07:13:38 - 07:16:35

Florence Eshalomi

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Before I begin, I would like to thank all right honorable and honorable members for bringing their experience and expertise to today's debate. As many honorable members have highlighted, I was also fortunate enough that my family was able to secure social housing following a period of homelessness in my childhood. And as the honorable member for Normanton mentioned, that relief and that light in your eyes when you get a set of keys and know that you and your family do not have to move yet again with plastic bags and a suitcase, the relief that social housing brought to us, the safety and security of having a roof over your head is priceless. And I share the disappointment and anger expressed across this house that this isn't available to many families today.

The contributions from many members this afternoon highlights the importance of social housing across our communities up and down the country. I would like to turn first to the reasoned amendment tabled by the opposition against this bill. Whilst I'm happy to see my honorable friend, my fellow and former member on the Housing Select Committee here in his place, I am worried to hear that the opposite bench are actually contradicting themselves. They welcome our support for protections for victims of domestic abuse, but I'm disappointed with their contradictory response to our wider reforms. The opposition want to both permit homes to be sold under the right to buy system at an unsustainable rate that is discouraging our local councils from building them, whilst also saying on the other hand we should support more councils to build and increase the supply of social homes.

It cannot work like that. I'm mindful of time, Madam Deputy Speaker, and we do need to finish, but I just want to reflect on some specific remarks made by some honourable members this afternoon. I turn to the comments from my honourable member and constituency neighbour from Dulwich and West Norwood on the fact of protecting tenants who are fleeing from violence. I'm sad to say that this is an issue that I've helped three families in my constituency where tragically they've lost young people due to knife crime. It is important that we look at this issue and highlight some of the changes that my honourable friend the right honourable member for Greenwich and Woolwich has outlined.

I also want to turn to the issue that many members have raised this afternoon with regards to shared ownership. As my right honourable friend the Minister, Housing Minister, outlined, we've taken positive steps to look at the issue of shared ownership model, including the expectations on landlords who build and bid for shared ownership funding. As the Minister highlighted, we do not believe that the review is necessary, but we are already considering specific issues that have been raised, including the data and long-term affordability for customers, and we will report back on this at a later date.

07:16:35 - 07:16:59

Andrew Graham Cooper

On that point, very quickly. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wonder if she's aware of the issues that people have when they're deceased and they own a shared ownership home, how difficult it is to sell that, and the estate can end up paying service charges, they can end up paying rent for quite a long period of time. I wonder if she would consider whether there's further action the government might need to take on that point.

07:16:59 - 07:23:29

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honourable friend for raising that point. I think these are some of the areas that we will definitely be looking at when my right honourable friend the Minister is reviewing the shared ownership. The other area that a number of honourable members and right honourable members raised is the issue around domestic abuse and debt. It is really important that we know that this is a key area for survivors of domestic abuse. The government is committed in its national plan to end homelessness in addressing this issue.

We believe that the best guidance out of this route is ensuring that the regulations are amended and relevant legislation is to be looked at. And my understanding is that the right honourable member for Greenwich and Woolwich will be looking at this. I'll also point to my honourable member for Poplar and Limehouse. I am due to meet with the All-Party Parliamentary Group she highlighted and I welcome other honourable members to attend that meeting. Another issue that a number of members raised is around the issue of disposals and council disposals.

I recognise the strength of feeling in the House regarding this matter and I want to reassure honourable members that we take this issue very seriously and we want local authorities and housing associations to, where possible, retain the homes within the social housing sector. We believe that the new disposals notification requirements in this bill, which will help maximise opportunities for social housing providers to retain the homes. I'll repeat what my honourable friend highlighted. Housing associations remain independent organisations responsible for their own asset management decisions. However, we'll continue to explore what further steps we can take to stop social housing stock being sold.

Our right to buy reforms mean that we will see a net gain of 18,000 social homes over the next 10 years, as opposed to a loss of 26,000 homes if we retain the current system. The right to buy remains a crucial route into home ownership, but we must also confront the reality before us. Social house building has struggled to keep pace with the sales of right to buy. This has resulted in the number of families in costly temporary accommodation and expanding social housing waiting lists across the country. Our right to buy reforms, notably the new build exemption, will give councils the confidence to get building again.

Madam Deputy Speaker, we also refute the accusation that we are doing nothing to ensure that social housing is being used effectively. This Government expects social housing landlords to maximize the use of existing homes as well as building more. We have launched a review into how effectively social housing providers use their properties and we will report on its findings later in the year. Now, regarding the opposition's concerns about the allocation of housing to non-UK nationals, this Government does not support restricting social housing based solely to British citizens. Such an approach would be unworkable and it would cut across legal obligations, including obligations relating to EU citizens with settled status in the Equality Act.

Eligibility for social housing is already tightly controlled by local councils, and if a person's immigration status does not allow them to recourse to public funds, they are not eligible for social homes. This racist rhetoric has to stop and demonizing people who want to work. The vast majority of those allocated social homes in the UK are UK nationals. That is a fact. So I hope that the opposition will withdraw this amendment.

Madam Deputy Speaker, when the Prime Minister stood on the steps of Number 10, he put building more council homes at the heart of this Government's agenda, because for far too long, successive governments have failed to deliver the homes up and down the country we need, while simultaneously failing to protect our stock. But we know we can and we must go further. This bill is about bringing an end to the era of social housing homes. It's about protecting the homes that we have, supporting the building of new homes we need. It's about ensuring the system works fairly for those who need it the most.

It's about reducing the over-reliance on temporary accommodation, which is crippling so many councils up and down the country. Collectively, London councils are spending five point five million pounds on temporary accommodation. This is unsustainable, Madam Deputy Speaker. Up and down the country, we need to help and turbocharge. Social housing is not just about a roof over people's heads.

It creates strong, connected communities. It enables families to live happily. It enables healthy lives and provides long-term sustainable housing. The Government is taking and making progress to reverse the decline of social house building, which is represented by sixty-five percent increase in social rent completions in the latest figures from Homes England. And across the country, we have, we are seeing the fact that over one hundred and eighty thousand children are growing up in temporary accommodation, and as many honorable members have mentioned this afternoon, over one point three million people on the housing waiting list.

This has a devastating impact on the wellbeing of our children and families, who are facing poor conditions, lacking the space to grow. How can we expect those young children to contribute in later life to society when they don't have a safe place to call their home? This bill is bringing an end to that failure. This bill creates the crucial step that many families want to see, the same that my family was given many years ago, ensuring that when families face homelessness, when women are fleeing domestic abuse with their children, they are not the ones being evicted, but the perpetrator. This bill ensures that we are restricting right-to-buy sales and that one hundred percent of those receipts are going back to councils so that they can reinvest that back into their local areas.

This bill will ensure that we turbocharge and bring a new lease of life to local council building across the country, working with our councils, our providers, our housing associations, and private developers to get this housing right. With that, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's important that we continue to progress on this bill, and with that, I beg to move.

07:23:29 - 07:25:05

Nesil Caliskan

Before I put the question, I need to inform the House that in the event of a division, I pass no comment on whether there will be one or not, some of the pass readers in both lobbies are currently not in operation.

Can I ask all members to follow the directions of doorkeepers and division clerks and to use the working pass readers, which I gather have notices on them to record their names. The Parliamentary Digital Service are working hard to restore the remaining pass readers for any divisions tomorrow. Order. The original question was that the bill be now read a second time, since when an amendment has been proposed as on the order paper. The question is that the amendment be made.

As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. Division, clear the lobby. Smith, the tellers for the noes, Shaun Davies and Emma Foody.

07:38:45 - 07:38:53

Speaker 312

Order, order.

07:38:53 - 07:39:06

Speaker 313

The ayes to the right 77, the noes to the left 292.

07:39:06 - 07:39:33

Nesil Caliskan

The ayes to the right were 77, the noes to the left 292, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:39:34 - 07:39:46

Nesil Caliskan

Of the contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Program motion to be moved formally.

07:39:46 - 07:39:47

I beg to move.

07:39:47 - 07:39:53

Nesil Caliskan

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:39:54 - 07:40:11

Nesil Caliskan

Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to motion number three relating to a joint committee on the draft conversion practices bill. Minister to move.

07:40:11 - 07:40:13

Speaker 317

I beg to move.

07:40:13 - 07:40:34

Nesil Caliskan

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

We now come to motion number four relating to the committee on standards. Whip to move.

07:40:34 - 07:40:36

Speaker 316

I beg to move.

07:40:36 - 07:40:54

Nesil Caliskan

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

We now come to motion number five relating to the committee on privileges. Whip to move.

07:40:54 - 07:40:56

Speaker 314

I beg to move.

07:40:56 - 07:41:08

Speaker 319

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

07:41:08 - 07:41:15

Speaker 318

I beg to move that this house do now adjourn.

07:41:15 - 07:41:25

Speaker 321

The question is that this house do now adjourn. Point of order, Ellie Chowns.

07:41:25 - 07:42:01

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. At the end of July, the Prime Minister announced that he was holding cross-party talks on social care. He did not invite the Green Party despite our involvement in the Casey Commission cross-party talks for the past 18 months. When I expressed my concern about this in business questions this morning, the leader of the house suggested smaller parties had not taken up an invitation. No doubt inadvertently, this is misleading because no such invitation was ever issued to the Green Party.

Can you advise how I might go about getting the record corrected?

07:42:01 - 07:42:10

Nesil Caliskan

I thank the honorable member for her point of order and indeed for giving notice of it. Can I ask if she raised this with the leader of the house prior to making the point of order?

07:42:11 - 07:42:37

Nesil Caliskan

Indeed, as she will know, the content of ministerial answers to questions and contributions on the floor of the house is not a matter for the chair, but the government front bench will have noted her remarks. If any correction of the record is necessary because of an inadvertent error, I'm sure it will be forthcoming. The question is that this house do now adjourn. Gideon Amos.

07:42:37 - 07:44:24

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. After a summer of drought in England and in my constituency of Taunton and Wellington, we are bracing ourselves for flooding and storm overflows. And then more drought, and then more flooding, and then more storm overflows, and then more drought, and then more flooding and storm overflows. On the levels around Staithe, Helland, Boroughbridge, Stoke St Mary and North Curry, my constituents must get used to the risk of their land being underwater almost every year, and sewage being surcharged into the River Tone, and hosepipe bans and drought, if not at the same time, then in very quick succession. A future, Madam Deputy Speaker, of water scarcity, too little water and too much water.

The proposed solutions sound familiar: more reservoirs, more underground stormwater tanks, thicker concrete, bigger pipes, more pumping, more energy, more chemicals. And yes, we are going to need some of that. But that alone would mean one of the most carbon emissions-intensive infrastructure investment programs this country has ever seen. But by treating the symptoms, not the cause, these measures risk failure. Indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's time instead, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's time to tackle the problem where it begins: our homes, streets, and buildings, the way they have been designed for decades and those that will be designed in the future.

The truth is that England does not lack water, Madam Deputy Speaker. I will be able to point to an awful lot of it this autumn across my constituency. Rather, it lacks the ability, or perhaps the political will, to manage it sustainably where it lands.

07:44:24 - 07:44:26

Speaker 315

Will the hon. gentleman give way, please?

07:44:26 - 07:44:27

I will give way briefly.

07:44:27 - 07:44:58

Jim Shannon

Madam Deputy Speaker, first of all, can I commend the hon. gentleman for bringing this forward? The one thing that perhaps maybe would help the hon. gentleman and help government: for those developers who have a number of projects for housing where there could be hundreds of houses being built, is it not time to ensure that the developers, because of the profit margin they're making on the houses, that they pay towards the upgrading of the waste and water management, thereby taking the onus off government and off the minister?

07:44:58 - 07:50:17

Gideon Amos

The hon. gentleman is quite right that developers should pay their way. And there's much to do, which I will come on to. On average, each roof in England, each house roof in England receives enough free rainwater to meet all its household's non-potable, that is non-drinking water needs, including flushing toilets, washing clothes, watering gardens. But instead of that, we send it off at high speed into the sewage network where it surcharges sewage into our rivers. While at the same time we spend millions of pounds making pure drinking water, pumping it into our homes, and flushing that down the toilet.

Around a quarter to a third of drinking water in our homes gets nowhere near being drunk. In fact, it's all flushed down the drain without a single drop quenching anybody's thirst. It's an appalling and pointless waste of drinking water and of energy. And it means we must respond by investing tens of billions of pounds in reservoirs to hold a bit more rain so we can treat more of it, pump more of it into our homes, and yes, flush more of it down the toilet unnecessarily. That is not environmental progress.

That is a high-carbon, high-expense papering over the cracks, high-expense papering over the cracks of our water system. And the water from our homes and highways, vast volumes of rainwater, is continuing to go straight down the drain as well. Mixing with sewage, pointlessly being pumped and treated, and pumped and treated, and far too often creating a backwash that sends sewage tumbling into the River Tone in my constituency and to rivers and beaches across the country. Our wastewater treatment plants can cope with the sewage that's produced. What it can't cope with is the millions of liters of rainwater we add to the sewage before we send it to the wastewater treatment plants.

Too often we respond by investing huge amounts into storage tanks to hold stormwater so we can pump more of it and treat more of it. But that is not environmental progress. That is high-carbon, highly expensive papering over the cracks of our water system. The climate is making the problems worse, and ironically our addition of rainwater into the mix is making the climate worse. A classic doom loop.

As the atmosphere warms, England's winters become wetter, its summers drier with more intensive thunderstorms. Meanwhile, housing delivery continues at scale, covering land with more impermeable surfaces, whilst we continue to legally entitle developers to collect new rainwater and add that to the sewage systems as well, which cannot cope with it.

We're quite literally building the problem into existence before our eyes. Contrast this with how we look at energy and deal with energy. We no longer assume that all power has to be generated centrally. Instead, we actively encourage decentralized generation, solar panels on roofs. Thanks to my Lib Dem colleague, the honorable member for Cheltenham, now to be required on every roof of every new home.

Batteries in homes, heat pumps replacing distant combustion, and we offer grants to make it happen. On water, we remain stubbornly stuck in the, I was going to say the 20th century, it feels like the 19th century. Other countries have progressed. In parts of Belgium, new homes must capture rainwater for beneficial use. No wonder they have achieved the lowest per capita water consumption in Europe and no doubt the lowest water bills that go with it.

Australia, Germany, Singapore have embedded rainwater harvesting and source control drainage into mainstream development. In England, by contrast, we continue to ignore the massive asset value that rainwater is. Even the amendment I proposed to the planning bill that new homes should capture rainwater to use it and lower residents' bills was rejected, I'm sorry to say, by the government. But I can commit, Madam Deputy Speaker, that this issue will not go away. Because this alternative approach really isn't that radical.

It's all remarkably simple. The simple principle is what's called source control. Capture rain where it falls and use it wisely. And return the excess rain to the ground where it fell. Why use it to top up our sewage?

Do we love sewage so much we actually want to make more of it by adding more water to it and create even more volumes of it? And for all those homes built in earlier centuries where rainwater is directed into the sewer already, why not offer grants to retro-split two drains from the one they have at the moment? Lower cost for the consumer, lower water bills, less sewage for water companies, less sewage going into our rivers, and less cost for the government and the public and the agencies to cope with. This could cut water bills by roughly a third, meaning 225 pounds off the average household bill. A household in Taunton Deane and Wellington that captures its own rainwater and takes it out of the sewer would cut its water bill by a quarter to a third.

That's around 225 pounds a year off a 695 pound bill. Nationally, 28 to 35 percent. Gross that up, 29 million households. That's six and a half billion pounds off people's bills. Imagine what that would do if it was freed up to be spent in the economy in other ways.

I will. I know. Please do.

07:50:17 - 07:50:55

Peter Swallow

I thank him for giving way. I do confess I am a little confused. There are plenty of places in the country, including in my region, where we already have a separate system for sewage and for rainwater runoff that should keep them separate. And yet, over many, many years, we have seen that that has not had the desired effect and we are still seeing, I'm sorry to say, far too much sewage going into our rivers. So whilst I recognize the point he is trying to make, I don't think that it's the silver bullet that he suggests.

Does he not accept that if we are going to capture more rainwater, the way to do that is building the reservoirs we need?

07:50:55 - 07:51:52

Gideon Amos

As I said at the beginning, we certainly need some reservoirs and I completely accept that. But as I have explained with energy, we don't assume the only solution is massive centralized power stations, in the same way that collecting water on our roofs, in our homes, can make a massive contribution. Six and a half billion pounds worth of contribution back into people's pockets. That's not to be sneezed at. Done at scale, this approach simultaneously tackles water scarcity, water excesses, and carbon emissions.

Toilets flushed with rainwater reduce demand for new reservoirs and enable more new development. Soakaways, green roofs, property-level SuDS, slow runoff, reducing flood risk and storm overflows. Less pumping and treatment means lower operational carbon. Less concrete and excavation means lower embodied carbon. Crucially, decentralized rainwater management delivers these benefits exactly where people experience them.

07:51:50 - 07:52:16

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. He is sharing his usual erudition on these topics. He mentions suds, sustainable drainage systems, which of course can be a very important part of the solutions he outlines. But I find that many homeowners in my constituency find that those sustainable drainage systems do not work as intended because they're not properly designed and maintained. And we don't currently have unenacted legislation that means developers are not being held to account.

07:51:52 - 07:51:53

Gideon Amos

I will.

07:52:16 - 07:52:22

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Does he agree and believe that we need to do more to make sustainable drainage systems work effectively?

07:52:22 - 07:55:02

Gideon Amos

My honorable friend for Didcot is characteristically right. And I will come onto schedule three of the Flood and Water Management Act, which he and I tried on several occasions to have enacted in the passage of the Planning and Infrastructure Bill. Crucially, decentralized water management delivers the benefits I listed. Homes that are more resilient, bills that are lower, streets that flood less, rivers that have less sewage surcharging into them. My campaign before I was elected as an MP was to get the River Tone designated as a bathing water.

Working with the friends group, we succeeded. But unless we take action to reduce sewage volumes in the Tone catchment and around the country, we will not be able to meaningfully reduce surcharges of sewage going into those rivers and beaches. Crucially, none of this requires an AI data center to make it happen. What is required is a shift in mindset. Managing rain before it becomes a problem rather than using it to make a problem and then trying to manage the problem we've created.

We can personally do our bit. My son thinks the enormous water butt I'm trying to make in my back garden is a Heath Robinson creation. Well, he would if he knew what Heath Robinson was, because he's far too young. But following all the regulations is challenging and I'm working on it. But what is really needed is government to take action on the regulation.

And three key changes are needed from the government. First, we need to stop designing homes that treat rain as an inconvenience to be sent elsewhere, but rather sent into people's homes and harnessed as the asset and essential natural resource that it is, requiring rainwater harvesting in all new homes. Second, government needs to bring schedule three of the Flood and Water Management Act into law, as my honorable friend pointed out, so that we start to drain more of our drain water in the ground where it falls and we have a properly regulated system for doing so. And thirdly, government needs to grant-aid retrofitting of household drains so people can save on their bills and save our rivers at the same time, like our precious Tone, which can be spared the sewage these drains create, add to, and augment. England is about to spend unprecedented sums on water sewage infrastructure.

We cannot solely rely on carbon-heavy centralized systems. We should finally change our relationship with the rain that falls right on the top of us all. If we want cleaner rivers, secure water supplies, lower emissions, and homes fit for a changing climate, the answer is learning to value rain and use it to save us all money where it lands.

07:55:02 - 07:57:38

Emma Hardy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I genuinely thank the member for Taunton and Wellington for securing this debate. I really enjoyed listening to his speech and there was so much agreement from this side of the House on everything, pretty much everything he had to say. He described what I would refer to more as pre-pipe.

...to more as pre-pipe, and this is something that I'm really interested in doing, which is one of the things where you look at exactly as he's described, how do we stop rainwater ending up in our sewage system, contributing to often pollution incidents because the system becomes overwhelmed when it's actually rainwater and could be elsewhere. And he touches on almost one of my favorite things to talk about, and that's nature-based solutions, how we can use nature more, how we can create soakaway areas, sustainable urban drainage is absolutely, absolutely correct. And I'm so passionate about thinking about how we manage water, and I think so many times the conversation when we're talking about, you know, how do we solve problems around pollution, if we manage the water that falls from the sky, we manage the rainwater better, we can help deal with pollution as well as, you know, many other attributes. Reservoirs are hugely important, as my honorable friend pointed out, and we should absolutely be using those, but that's all part of that wider system is collecting the rainfall, putting it where we want it rather than it ending up where we don't. Obviously, it's for the Department of Housing, Communities and Local Government to talk about building standards, but I can tell you, because I asked them ahead of this debate, that they're reviewing water efficiency standards in the building regulations for new homes, and they're considering how to enable water reuse systems, including rainwater and greywater systems where they're safe, practical, and cost-effective.

And I know I've mentioned this a few times, I think, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I share his sort of, not astonishment, maybe a bit too far, but his concern about the fact we use drinking water to flush our toilets. But this is, to give the other side of the argument I've had played back to me, that this is to do with the rules around you have to supply drinking water quality to domestic properties. And so it's making sure that if we introduce changes, which I, hopefully not telling things I shouldn't, we are sort of exploring, is that how can you guarantee that you don't mix up the sort of water pipes that are going into a home and therefore, you know, cause problems that way. So it's always got to be safety first, which is why the only water that can enter a property, unless it's done as a private individual setting up their own system, has to be drinking, drinking water quality.

07:57:38 - 07:57:39

Can I have a point with the Minister?

07:57:39 - 07:57:40

Yes, of course.

07:57:40 - 07:58:09

Julia Buckley

I thank the Minister for giving way. And would the Minister agree with me that actually so much progress has been made in regard to rainwater harvesting, not just from MHCLG, but also from within your own department, and not least the landmark report published this March by the Drinking Water Inspectorate, which exactly explored a potential governance framework setting out those standards for non-potable water in domestic settings, but also talking about accreditation standards to ensure that these systems, when we are ready to bring them in, are safe and will be properly maintained.

07:58:09 - 07:59:07

Emma Hardy

I thank my honorable friend for, because I was trying in my head to remember what the report was, and so I very much appreciate that, that intervention. But she's absolutely right. It's about how do we, we have some of the best drinking water in the whole world. We have incredibly high standards when it comes to the public health of our, our drinking water. And so that report from the Drinking Water Inspectorate of looking at how we can do this in a safe way is something I am really, really keen to explore because we're quite right, we are going to be short of drinking water if we continue at the scale we are into the future.

If we use, we start thinking about where we're using it and not using it to flush our toilets, then that feels like a way we can go forward. So I think there's a huge amount of sort of cross, cross-party thinking on, on how we can do that. But it also goes back to that how do we manage water, how do we think about water, where is it, where is it falling. And he's right as well.

07:59:07 - 07:59:31

James William Naish

Thanks very much for giving way. She's obviously aware of the work of the Labour Rural Research Group, but one of the things we've been talking about is whether there needs to be longer-term certainty for ELM schemes where farmers are trying to invest in proper water management as she's describing it, but they need more than three years often to be able to do that.

So I wonder whether she'd agree that maybe her department needs to look at how and specifically when it comes to water, we could be arranging for ELM schemes to be over a longer period of time.

07:59:31 - 08:00:03

Emma Hardy

I thank my honourable friend. I'm hesitant to agree something that isn't my brief, but I will certainly mention it to the to the farming minister. And and the honourable gentleman's right, when we think about water management, we often do talk about reservoirs, which are very, very much needed. And it is that does matter and it is important, but so is managing water where it falls. So is thinking about roofs, streets, gardens, farms, development.

This is why we want a more practical, prevention-focused approach to water management. Capture more of the water, waste less of it and plan developments in a way that looks at local catchments. Because...

08:00:03 - 08:00:44

Jonathan Peter Tom Davies

Yes. Thank you for giving way. One of the things that's going to benefit farmers in my constituency is the 50 million pounds which is coming through the SFIs to allow farms to build more water storage on their land. And that's going to be a huge benefit because we know their food stocks are down this going into the winter because of the hot summer that we've had. But we also have an issue with flooding.

And at the moment, schedule three of the Water Management Act, it's not been enacted. And it means that every development has a right to be connected to the drainage system, which increases the amount of flooding that we have. So perhaps you should take that forward with colleagues at MHCLG would be ever so grateful indeed.

08:00:44 - 08:01:43

Emma Hardy

I thank my honourable friend. So on the point around farm reservoirs, he's he's so correct. Today I held a meeting of the National Drought Group and we had a focus on agriculture and the impact of drought that's had on farmers. And I know we're talking now about potential rain and El Niño and flooding, but drought is still here and in the country. And that was one of the conversations we were having to how can we support farmers to hold more of the water that comes down from the sky.

Because we're focusing a lot on funding farm reservoirs, but we also need to be thinking about filling farm reservoirs. How do we get them farmers to be able to have them full for the summers that we need with our changing climate and more, you know, more rain in winter, drier in in summer. On the issue of SuDS, I love SuDS. I get very geekily excited about sustainable urban drainage systems. I know I'm shocking you, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I I will at some point maybe try and convince you that they they can be really nice.

They can be spaces for nature as well. I'm not winning here, am I? Um, um, yes, go on.

08:01:43 - 08:01:56

Peter Swallow

Briefly, if at all. Can I simply say that I completely agree with her. There are many SuDS in Bracknell Forest that have been delivered as part of alternative natural green space and they create lovely nature corridors in our community. And I just want to put that on record.

08:01:56 - 08:02:22

Emma Hardy

I think this is like geeks unite now, aren't we on this? Like we love our SuDS. Um, but yes, absolutely, they are brilliant. Um, but he's quite right that point around maintenance has been raised a few times before because it's okay to build them and I actually think most are built and designed in a very effective way. But that question of maintenance and how do we make sure that the ones that are built are maintained, who's responsible, of course, who's responsible as well.

08:02:22 - 08:02:58

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Madam. Thank you. I'm grateful to the minister. Briefly. I just I just want to make the observation.

I mean, I trained as an architect. I had a whole series of regulations about drains. How wide, what the diameters were, what the gradients were. Everything has to be followed. SuDS, no such regulations.

One is regulated, the other is all down to policy. And I and I think that, you know, as many members have said, we need to proper regulation for SuDS because, you know, things will go wrong if we don't get that schedule three or similar legislation in on to the statute book in my opinion.

08:02:59 - 08:03:57

Emma Hardy

I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention and and for the expertise that he brings to this house from his previous occupation. And I think this is one of the things we're trying to sort of work through with industry, working with MHCLG, looking together because we all agree that SuDS are a really good thing. Where they may be not been as effective is around the maintenance issue and who is responsible and and who pays to maintain them.

So they're the kind of things that we're thinking about. But it goes back to that point I made earlier about when we're thinking about planning, when we're thinking about areas, are we thinking about the management of water in an area? And with our changing climate, going from drought to flood, it's like, how are we thinking about where do we want the water? And I think it's a slightly different nuanced conversation to, you know, when it floods, where do we want the water to go? When it's drought, where are we going to get the water from?

It's thinking about it sort of more holistically in a way perhaps we haven't done previously when we thought about each point in isolation.

08:03:57 - 08:04:19

John Richard Foord

I'm grateful. In January last year, Storm Chandra caused devastation in East Devon. There was significant flooding in Ottery St Mary. Does she think that, besides the attenuation ponds and the SuDS, that people should also be encouraged to store water in their own gardens using such things as water butts?

08:04:19 - 08:06:05

Emma Hardy

Absolutely. I think the more we can all do collectively, the better. I mean, we're coming up to Flood Action Week, the week beginning the 12th of October, and I'll be calling on every single Member in this House to do what they can to get the message out to their constituents about being prepared and how we can all collectively play our part together in what could be a quite a challenging, challenging winter. But on sort of sustainable urban drainage, the National Planning Policy Framework requires all new developments to incorporate SuDS designed and maintained in accordance with national standards. So there are some new national standards, and the hierarchy within these standards prioritises collecting rainwater for non-potable uses.

We're also committed to that better joined-up water planning, so decisions on housing, drainage, water supply and wastewater taken together, so growth is supported in the right places and communities are better protected. So in conclusion, I've really enjoyed this debate and talking about sort of my favourite things, which is natural flood management, SuDS, rainwater, water management in a catchment. It's sort of ticked all my favourite boxes. So managing rainwater where it falls is practical, local and important. It can help households use less mains water, reduce pressure on sewers, improve drainage, support flood resilience and make new developments more sustainable.

That is why this Government continues to support better management of rainwater. Our water system faces significant challenges, but this Government is taking action: cleaning up rivers, tackling pollution at source, holding water companies to account and improving resilience to flood and droughts and securing investment needed for the future. Through reform, investment and stronger regulation, we are rebuilding public trust and creating a water system that works for people, the environment and our economy.

08:06:05 - 08:06:11

Nesil Caliskan

The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". The Ayes have it. Order, order.