Work and Pensions Committee

4 November 2026

Work and Pensions Committee House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:04 - 00:39
Speaker 1
And welcome to this evidence session on the DWP annual report and accounts.  And it's a pleasure to welcome the new permanent secretary, Dame Sarah Healey.  Your first session with us here today, very warm welcome.  And you're joined by Catherine Vaughan.  And I have your title, Catherine, here. 

You're the Director General for Finance.  And Katherine Green, Director General for Labour Market and Skills.  And Neil, as well, warm welcome again.  You're Director General for Services and Fraud. 
00:39 - 00:41
Speaker 3
Hello, Chair. 
00:41 - 00:50
Speaker 1
Let's start then.  Dame Sarah, you've been permanent secretary now for, what, a couple of months now, coming up to three months? 
00:50 - 00:54
Speaker 4
Coming up to three, just over three months in fact. 
00:54 - 01:11
Speaker 1
Wooden anniversary.  So, what were the things that you were expecting?  What were surprises?  And what are the three things that you would want to change and how are you going to go around and do that? 
01:11 - 03:33
Speaker 6
Thank you so much, Chair.  And I just want to say like, it's obviously real pleasure to have the opportunity to have such a wide ranging session with the committee as the very first time.  I've actually been in post just over a hundred days.  I think that's the kind of new job marker that people tend to use.  So, it's a good moment to pause. 

And I want wanted to sort of start really by just play paying quick tribute to Peter as my predecessor.  Peter was a much-valued colleague for me around the permanent secretary table and had been for seven years in my previous roles.  But it's obviously only when you actually succeed someone that you really get an impression of the sort of scale and breadth of everything that Peter handled and managed in DWP and what he did.  As for sort of first impressions, obviously, I sort of knew about the scale of what DWP did and the scale of its operations, but you can't really help but be very struck by it and struck by its kind of both national and local presence when you come in.  The scale of its operations, the extent of its interactions with the public, and also I think kind of the significance of the outcomes that it's trying to effect through interactions with customers and that has been very striking. 

I've also been really struck by the enthusiasm and commitment of the DWP staff I've met in different parts of the country visiting job centers and service centers since I started, and a real sense of passion for what they do, but also a kind of passion for trying to change what they see in front of them and change the way that they work to try and improve outcomes.  I think in many places as well, I've been struck that we really do have world-leading systems and processes for making those changes happen.  But when you talk about things I would like to change, I think it is fair to say that I've heard from people both in the core sort of HQ of the department, but also in operations, that they don't always have the systems that they need in order to do their jobs as well as they would want to.  They are things that hold them back in trying to achieve what they want to achieve. 
03:33 - 03:35
Speaker 2
Such as? 

03:35 - 04:33

Sarah Healey

Well, quite often we are working on extremely old computer systems. We are working on kind of processes which are quite inflexible and don't necessarily allow people to tailor the support that they want to give to the customers that are in front of them. And you can really see the benefit that comes when those change. So, I visited the Child Maintenance Service and hearing about their digital transformation, what a difference it's made to the way that they operate. It's very striking kind of the satisfaction that comes for the people who are working on these cases when they actually are dealing with much more modernised systems.

So, I do think there is a lot still to do on the sort of back-office systems and processes. We're obviously only partway through the reform of the Jobs and Careers Service. And so, I'm very keen to learn from our pathfinders there and ensure that we're encouraging innovation in the Jobs and Careers Service up and down the country.

04:33 - 04:35

Speaker 5

You have a report from us that you might want to look at.

04:35 - 05:57

Sarah Healey

Indeed. I've seen I've seen both the report and the correspondence about it. And I also just think it's worth reflecting a little bit on the context that we're in all of this, because actually I do think, coming up in the next few months, there are a set of things that we will need to respond to as well as things we ourselves would want to change. So for instance, clearly, the Prime Minister's ambition on devolution will be something that I know the committee is thinking about, and you will want to ask about today. We will have the Milburn and Timms reviews coming up for publication.

That will make a difference to how we do our jobs. And it is worth also reflecting that we are operating at a time of serious fiscal pressure. We sort of played that, saw that played out in the budget and that is something that DWP will want to think about as we go into a spending review at some point in the next year or so. And then, I'm sure committee will want to, as it has done in these similar hearings before, touch on AI and technology. I think it is technology including AI rather than AI alone.

But it is obviously beholden on the department to make sure that we're taking advantage of the opportunities that gives to enable our people to work better, but also addressing some of the risks and challenges that we know arise with that kind of new technology.

05:57 - 06:25

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Indeed. Well, let's start then in terms of the devolution by default approach. And as accounting officer, what are your, how do you see this? Do you see this as an opportunity? Do you see it as a major risk?

And if so, have you is it in on your risk register, you know what how do you see this, and how are you going to mitigate against those risks?

06:25 - 09:04

Sarah Healey

Obviously, I come at this with a really unique perspective from my previous role, because I was previously permanent secretary at the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government. Yes, it's very helpful. And I hope, well I hope it's going to be helpful as DWP kind of navigates that sort of scale of ambition and therefore was responsible for lots of conversations with my fellow accounting officers, Peter included, around government as we set out the integrated settlement and thought about the ways in which we could preserve accounting officer accountability in a sort of devolved world, remembering that DWP obviously has committed to devolving more, but already devolves, over the course of the spending review, 3.1 billion of employment, support and other funding as part of the integrated settlement. So, I'm very familiar with the mechanisms that are currently in place for the integrated settlement, but I think it is very clear that those are going to have to transform and change over the course of the next few years, not least because of two things: first of all, the commitments that were set out in the Rewiring the State blueprint just after the Prime Minister came into office, the ambition to have devolution by default, and the desire to have very proportionate accountability systems, so it may involve local accounting officers and scrutiny processes that sort of respond to that, but also I think critically, fiscal devolution.

So, you will have seen the plan for fiscal devolution set out alongside the budget. I think that fundamentally will sort of change the way that mayoral strategic authorities receive their funding rather than through grants from departments. It's a very different way of doing it. That will require different accountability arrangements. But I ought to also say that I do think it is possible to have a significant amount of devolution of responsibility to local areas and still maintain accounting officer responsibility to Parliament.

And if you look at how that is done in the local government system, for instance, as the accounting officer in the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, I was the accounting officer with responsibility for the overall local authority system and spending. I was not individually responsible for the spending and performance of individual local authorities. And I think there is a lot to learn about how that system operates. Catherine probably knows it better than I do, frankly, having been the accountable officer in local government before. And I think there's a lot to learn from that about how we can get the real benefits of allowing local decision making, local design of services, but ensure that there is proper accountability for taxpayers' money alongside.

Mhm.

09:04 - 09:34

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

So, do you think in relation to that, thinking particularly about employment support and devolution of that budget, do you think that will mean that we have a greater uptake? Because we haven't had a very good response, we've had 190,000, which is considerably less than was the target of getting young people and other older people into work.

09:34 - 11:05

Sarah Healey

Well, the what I know I've heard from mayors up and down the country in my previous job speaking to them about what they see as the benefits of having greater ownership of these budgets at regional level and at MCA level is that they can link up those budgets with other forms of support, that they have very strong relationships with employers. That is obviously building on fantastic stuff that happens in our jobcentres where there are kind of really strong links between jobcentres and the communities that they serve. But the kind of mayoral sort of perspective they see as really vital in kind of ensuring that people, especially people with a kind of range of vulnerable needs, can have services wrapped round their needs at local level. And that's what they see as some of the benefits. You can see that in some of the pilot projects that have been done in Manchester, the prevention trailblazer which obviously we've been contributing to, and we've enabled them to use that funding flexibly.

But the very nature of devolution is that you are sort of challenging and encouraging individual areas to do their very best with the flexibilities that they've got to tailor their support to the particular circumstances of their communities and their populations in a way that we just can't do at national level in quite the same fashion. But with any approach that is testing and is about testing and innovation, you will get variation in outcomes, and I think we can expect to see that.

11:05 - 11:18

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

And is that one of your responsibilities then, sorry for interrupting, one of your uninterrupted, one of your responsibilities then about ensuring the performance is standardized, if you want, but in terms of the standards of delivery?

11:18 - 11:27

Speaker 8

Well, I don't think we want standardized performance, because standardized performance can standardize down as well as up.

What we want is everyone to learn from the very best, I think.

11:27 - 12:37

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Okay. Okay, that I'll note that one. Going to move on to safeguarding. You know that this committee has taken a real not interest, it is a passion that this committee is absolutely focused on about ensuring that the deaths and serious harms that we have seen of claimants, including 110 deaths, 55 serious harms in the last year alone, that the department does everything within their power to take safeguarding responsibly and to have this as the focus of the work that is undertaken in the department.

We were disappointed by the response back in May 2025 to our first report, but we think that there have been incremental changes. So, culturally, you know, change is driven by the top, by you as a leadership team. How are you going to change the culture within the department so that everybody sees safeguarding as a priority?

12:37 - 16:33

Sarah Healey

Thank you, and I'm obviously aware of the committee's work on this subject and grateful for you sort of pressing us and making sure that we raise it up the list of priorities that we have to address in the department. Very grateful for that, and it's very important work. And I know that you had a substantial session with Sir Stephen Timms and with Neil in September in order to examine the progress that we'd made, and I can definitely confirm that we're on track with all of the actions that were discussed at that hearing. I think you've had a letter from Sir Stephen Timms only yesterday setting out some of that progress. I think you've heard in that there is a commitment to both the publication of a policy framework by the end of the year and also a commitment to rolling out training, and we've seen a significant increase in the number of staff who've picked up on the training.

And I know that, you know, I think it's very reasonable for you to ask me to set out what I'm intending to do to change the culture, but I just kind of very briefly want to kind of claim newness as a slight excuse for not kind of giving you a sort of substantial plan on this yet, because I think it would be really casual of me to think that I had a thoroughgoing understanding of the existing culture of the organisation, considering this is an organisation of 95,000 people in offices up and down the country, each of which will to some extent have their own individual work culture, and I need to understand better what that is in order to be able to tailor what we do to change it. What, however, I would say is that in a world in which we are have a set of people who are doing very difficult things, serving 23 million people each year, responsible for 640 million payments, millions of interaction with the public, everyone I have met while I've been travelling around, seeing DWP servers, has been really committed to doing the best they can for them. So, it's really important we help people to do that well. I know that the committee has been a bit critical in the past that perhaps our response on safeguarding has been a little process-driven, and felt quite as though it was sort of focused on individual actions, rather than on culture. And I just wanted to say that my what I have learned over seven and a half years as a permanent secretary is that you need both leadership, and you need process in order to create culture change.

It actually really matters that we set policy in the right place, that we follow that up with compliance, that we develop the capability of staff, because without all of those things, we will not fundamentally change what people are able to do.

But obviously, it is also about how we bring the DWP values to life, how we reward behavior at every level in the organisation, so what are people rewarded for, how do we how do we get our leaders to role model the behaviors that we want to see, and of course, honest reflection when things go wrong. And I know quite a lot about honest reflection when things go wrong from the experience of leading a department that has been through the process of the Grenfell Tower fire and indeed the inquiry. And I do think one of the most important things in developing the culture that you want in an organisation is encouraging people to be honest in reflecting on mistakes and be prepared to learn from them to the greatest possible degree. And obviously, it would be ideal not to need a public inquiry and a tragic set of events in order for that to happen. And I have already seen it happening in DWP, but I'm absolutely sure there's more to do.

16:33 - 16:35

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you. Peter Bedford.

16:35 - 17:16

Peter Bedford

Thank you, Chair. You touched on culture there in your answer there. Just touching on The Committee has previously expressed concerns about the culture in the department and potentially contributing to previous failures. Your recent customer perception survey had some stats in it that were quite concerning to the Committee, that one in three customers do not believe that the DWP does its best for service users, nearly three in 10 customers did not feel treated with respect by DWP staff. I can I could go on basically.

What are you doing to turn around that lack of trust and from the customers with the department?

17:16 - 18:58

Sarah Healey

I mean, again, I think it is important to reflect that kind of I couldn't possibly tell you everything that is driving all of those things after three months in post. I do think there are, you know, there are obviously concerning aspects to that. We would want all of our customers to feel that they have been receiving a very good service and that they are treated with respect in their interactions with staff. And actually, I think that's what our staff would like as well and they would want to see that. So I mean, a couple of reflections and I might ask Neil to come in, since Neil is very familiar with the services that we offer and knows much more about them than I do, which is just that in the reform that we're trying to do on the Jobs and Careers Service, one of the key things I've heard from people in the pathfinders that I've visited is the benefit that they have in being able to have some flexibility in how they interact with customers, because when they're very sort of fixed in the way that they can do those interactions, it can be hard to take people's individual circumstances into account.

And I can really see that when that if people feel their individual circumstances are not taken into account, that can really affect the degree of satisfaction that they feel with those services. And then I'd also point to things that we can learn from other modernisation that we've done in DWP. So, for instance, one of the things that was very striking when I went to the Child Maintenance Service is the fact that we now have a way of communicating which enables people to communicate with us digitally whenever is suitable for them, rather than expecting them to fit that into a certain number of hours a day where they can call a help line. But Neil, I don't know if you want to reflect further.

18:58 - 19:47

Neil Couling

Yeah, I've got slightly more than 100 days experience, I can't use that excuse. 40 years. But I think I'd ask the Committee to remember that we do some quite difficult stuff. And you heard last week from the minister Maeve Sherlock about just how hard it is sometimes administering a child maintenance claim and that happiness for one of the parties is unhappiness for the other. That's the sort of thing that gets picked up in some of these surveys and you know, we want to improve, we want people to be satisfied with their interactions with us, but sometimes we are saying to them, "No, you're not entitled to this benefit," and they will feel that they are, and they will challenge--

19:47 - 20:17

Peter Bedford

Just on that point, I just wonder if there's if you would reflect on the quality, or the kind of questions being asked. So, there's a difference between a decision being wrong and a process or an experience, the two separate. So you could I could be unhappy that I don't I'm not entitled to a particular benefit, but I feel I've had a fair hearing, I had a good communication, all those things,

separate from the actual decision. Does your surveys and interactions with customers, actually draw that out?

20:17 - 21:04

Neil Couling

So, we try to discern between that, because that's of You know, it's a very obvious point, one I agree with. But how the survey works, it is with people who've had a recent interaction with us. So, you know, it will pick up frustration with outcome, as well as give us important feedback on the quality of the service that we've delivered, and it's probably difficult to interlink those two from a survey response.

So, I'm not complacent about this, and I'm not dismissing it, not in the least, but it is worth bearing that in mind. It's a bit different than say, getting your driving licence renewed or your passport renewed, where there's a straight outcome to it. Yeah.

21:04 - 21:36

Peter Bedford

Just turning on to staff surveys, and the perception amongst your own employees, I think in 2025, the people survey said only 53% of your staff responded positively to questions about managing change. Now, clearly there's a lot of change going on in the department, both in terms of policy, and in terms of modernisation, technology, all those things, transformation. If only half of your staff have, you know, are confident that the department's responding positively to that,

how are you going to achieve that change?

21:36 - 24:39

Sarah Healey

So, again, I really wouldn't want you to think, in responding, just pointing this out, that I'm in any way thinking that there isn't more we can do. We obviously want, you know, vast majority of our staff to feel that change is managed well, but I was actually looking at those results only yesterday in preparation for coming to the committee and actually reflected that in comparison to the rest of Whitehall, we're doing rather well on managing change, most of the other departments across government. And it is a very difficult score to increase actually, in my experience as a permanent secretary,

even at DCMS where I was the permanent secretary for 3 and 1/2 years and was a much smaller department which didn't deliver services, and therefore experience the sort of scale of change that DWP does. It was actually really hard to get that score over 50%. And this was a department which had the highest engagement score in Whitehall. So, overall people were very engaged by the department. They love working there.

But that particular measure is really hard to get up, because people do find it difficult to deal with change. They do find change hard. I'm not suggesting we shouldn't be trying to push that score up, but considering the scale of what DWP does, I actually think the rest of Whitehall have got something to learn from us about how we've done it in the past and what it has involved. And I think that is partly because the things that we change frequently make the lives of the people who work for us easier

because they are improvements to systems, they are kind of changes in the ways that they work that are positive. There are obviously some issues that are reflected in that score which are challenging, not least kind of changes in policy or changes in priorities, which are an inevitable part of a civil servant's life, and so they should be, that I think are reflected to some degree.

But I have always thought that the most important thing that you can do, if you want to raise that score and you want to see people be even more positive about the way that the department manages change, is focus really heavily on your communications and engagement. So really, people want, what they want to understand when you're changing something is that you are changing it, why you are changing it, whether they are being involved in the decision about how, what the change will be, or whether they're being involved in the decision about how you're going to roll it out, clarity about that, and an opportunity to give feedback. And I've always said that one of the things that I mat- that I prioritize most in the departments that I've run is trying to create a culture in which people feel safe to challenge, because that is one of the kind of closest correlations with the overall level of engagement that people have with the organization that they work for. And that can only be done if you set up, relentlessly, actually, and this is back to the kind of importance of process in culture change, relentlessly set up the opportunities to listen to what people have got to say.

24:39 - 24:40

Thank you, Chair.

24:40 - 24:41

Thank you so much. Rushanara Ali.

24:41 - 26:26

Rushanara Ali

Thank you. Good morning. Dame Sarah, I had a follow follow-up on the devolution agenda, and you talked about wanting to see the areas learn from each other and where there's good results and progress, supporting others to also follow that. Can you talk us through how you're going to make sure that this very exciting agenda of transferring more power and resources to local areas, closer to communities, which we, you know, of course, broadly, we can all see the benefit of that, but the concerns are around outcomes, and how the department will oversee and set up a set of processes that will get you the results that you want to see in terms of improvement, good value for money, and support to those areas that are struggling? Do you feel that Whitehall, and, of course, your former department, have the powers and the institutional frameworks to get better outcomes in areas where there are poor outcomes at the local level?

And is the system acting fast enough to make sure that those institutions that are not performing well, failing or failing, is adequate enough to be able to get that improvement, so that people's lives are not affected because of poor leadership at the local level or, and of course, that doesn't exempt the national side as well, where that is an issue, or poor management, and what are you going to do about that?

26:26 - 28:10

Sarah Healey

So I'll start, and then I'll actually hand over to Catherine, who's been thinking about this quite a lot in the context of sort of transfer of contracts previously held by the department. I mean the first thing I would say is that the integrated settlement comes with it an outcomes framework. We spent a lot of time negotiating what was in the outcomes framework. It is very important that it is pitched at a level where it enables the kind of innovation and local testing and local design that is the great benefit of devolution while at the same time expressing what is very important in terms of holding people to account and testing their performance. We've got tried and tested ways in MHCLG of intervening where we see failure and a process of assessing against that outcomes framework through transparency, but also through regular discussion with mayoral strategic authorities.

And then I just point you to what I said earlier, which is that as we deepen and broaden devolution, I think there is more that can be done to set up a self-improving system, so it isn't just all local areas looking at the national level, waiting for the national level to say, kind of, come in and do it this way. Actually, it should be about learning and self-improvement between mayoral strategic authorities, not just nationally determined.

And also, to work out what an accountability system like that looks like when you've got fiscal devolution. And I think, you know, the government has set out its plans to do more to say more about how it's going to deliver devolution before the end of the year. And I think we can see there's some, like, more in-depth thinking about how that's going to work in future. But do you want to say something about how we're doing this with the contracts that we've devolved?

28:10 - 29:59

Catherine Vaughan

Yes, thank you. And as Sarah mentioned, I come with a particular perspective, having spent more than a decade as a chief finance officer in local government, and really recognise the importance of the whole system working together to share and learn good practice. And it's very much at the forefront of mine and my team's thinking at the moment. As an example, we're setting up a what works centre for local employment support in collaboration with the Economic and Social Research Council. That's going to go live in January next year, which is a structured way to enable sharing of evaluation about what works, so that people can learn from each other.

There is a lot we're thinking about in terms of what data we can make available to local areas. So, thinking about making it simpler to share data across organisations. We will be in a few weeks' time making our public Stat-Xplore data cut by combined- on authority and mayoral strategic authority layers, so that local areas can look differently at some of the publicly available stats about what's going on in their area. And then we already deliver a huge amount in partnership with local authorities and strategic mayoral strategic authorities. So, Connect to Work, which I think the Chair mentioned earlier, is delivered locally, and we facilitate a huge amount of sharing of best practice, peer support, and thinking about how capability can be shared across organisations.

So, I think there are strong foundations for us to continue to build on.

29:59 - 30:44

Rushanara Ali

Well, thank you very much. So, turning to the issues around responding to mistakes. The department in recent years has had an quite a few reviews and investigations and correction exercises into administrative failures. You know, we recognise that this, as you said, this is a department with huge amount of responsibility, very complex and a lot that is different from other departments, but it would be useful to get your reflections on why you think what you think is going wrong and what you intend to do to fix it.

30:44 - 34:04

Sarah Healey

Thank you, and it's obviously, kind of, right that we should be attempting to be as accurate as possible and not see some of those errors of the past repeated and get as much right as possible first time. I mean, I've already set out that one of the challenges here is that not all of our systems and practices, for nobody's fault, are as necessarily as strong or as modern as they should be. And indeed, I know when Peter was permanent secretary, he did a lot to try and look at how to fix those underlying systems and processes, including initiating a number of pieces of work to improve them.

The review that he asked the Government Internal Audit Agency to do to look at how we update operational guidance being a good example. As you say, and I know you acknowledge this, kind of with 23 million customers a year and 600 million payments going out, I think it would be really, I don't think it displays complacency to say that inevitably some things will go wrong. That is partly because we are dealing with the complexity of people's lives and the complexity of their circumstances, and I really am not here to make a set of promises that somehow, under my watch, nothing will ever go wrong. That would be extremely foolish thing for me to do. But, a few things that we can do, I think, to build on what is already happening in the department to try and address some of this:

We can obviously modernise our systems, and I'm sure we'll want to talk later about some of that service modernisation we've got underway. We can, of course, train and develop the capacity of staff and capability of staff, and if we think about the safeguarding example, I think it's a good example of where, kind of in order to improve the quality of practice and like prevent errors in how people are dealing with vulnerable customers, we've been doing that. Again, we can deal with the culture of raising issues quickly when they arise. I think it's really important that we do that in a way that avoids sort of punitive sense of blame on staff who, where things may have gone wrong, because actually that sort of defeats the aim of transparency and sort of doesn't encourage people to come forward. So, it's important to do in a way that's kind of safe and where we're being clear with staff that they're safe to raise those issues.

And, obviously, we need to reflect on and have in all the kind of reviews that we've done reflected on what we've learned from the things that have gone wrong. I think it is, however, sort of worth saying that I think it would be a little unfair to conclude from the different issues that we know are very serious, and I'm definitely not sort of suggesting that they're not very serious, that they suggest a sort of single cause in the department, not least because they happened at different times. So, you know, some of the things that we're dealing with in terms of State Pension age notification were sort of 20 years ago. Some of the things that we know we need to respond to, such as Carer's Allowance Carer's Allowance overpayments, which I'm sure you'll also come on to later, happened more recently. So, I think, you know, there's a range of time, so we shouldn't, I don't think what we should be searching for is one single cause and one single set of actions.

We need to take action across a wide range.

34:04 - 35:02

Rushanara Ali

Not argue with that, but I think what we're interested in is what's going to be done to address those because I recognise your point about complexity, but when you've got people who are at the receiving end of mistakes, I mean, we've got a number of, you know, a number of cases, issues, State Pension underpayments, as you said, legacy ESA, SDP, premium, PIP, national insurance number errors. And then, of course, there's the Civil Service Pensions issue which is which has come up and a number of us have dealt with that where civil servants who've given a life of service and not getting their pensions, and they're, you know, I've got a case like that at the moment, a number of cases. So, the reality of what it means to people's lives, which is why this department's so important and we're invested in wanting to see progress. Can I just take you to the question of the EHRC's investigation, what progress you can report on that?

35:02 - 35:41

Sarah Healey

Absolutely. So, I mean, as the committee will be aware, we have been involved in a confidential process of engagement with the EHRC about their review, which is obviously on a subject we take very seriously, and we recognise the importance of in dealing with particularly vulnerable clients. And I know the committee are particularly interested in how DWP engages with those who have the greatest needs, and we often deal with people at very vulnerable points in their lives. We'll obviously want to update the committee about where we've got to on that as soon as we possibly can, but that is currently ongoing. And I think, I'm looking at Neil, that is all I can really say at the moment.

35:41 - 35:48

Neil Couling

Yeah, I think what we can say is we are cooperating fully with the EHRC on this.

35:48 - 36:14

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Sorry for interrupting. Can I just say the latest investigation is 2 years old. This has been going on for 5 years. It first started in 2021, and the EHRC was so frustrated with a lack of progress from the department, they escalated it to an investigation. It is quite serious.

It is.

36:14 - 36:46

Neil Couling

So, we were so, we were unable to reach an agreement with them under section 23, which led them to initiating 2 years ago, you are quite right, a section 20 investigation of us. We are limited in what we can say back to you. I appreciate that is frustrating for the committee, but we are bound by legislation that governs the investigation that they are mounting, for which they are responsible. So, you know, we cannot say any more today. As soon as we can, we will do so.

36:46 - 37:00

Sarah Healey

We absolutely will, yeah. Our total commitment to you that kind of once we are in a position that we can say more, we're very happy to, and we'd be very pleased to explore not only that investigation, but the underlying issues.

37:00 - 37:04

Speaker 17

Are you able to give us a timeframe when you're able to tell us or not?

37:04 - 38:28

Sarah Healey

I think that's for the EHRC, rather than for us. Can I just say something on civil service pensions, just because you've raised it and I think it is really important that our staff hear from us today about just how seriously we take this. It is a Cabinet Office project and a Cabinet Office run service. Only in the last week, I've spoken a couple of times to the second permanent secretary who's taken over the new agency that will is looking after this issue, and it's been discussed amongst heads of department because we recognise how serious it is. I'm really clear that it is not good enough at all that people who have worked for DWP for years and years are unable to access their pensions.

I am not surprised that they have been raising this with Members of Parliament, and we are obviously very worried about the hardship that some of them have been facing. We have of course provided hardship loans, but we recognise that isn't really a replacement for having the money that you're entitled to in your pension. So, we continue to lend all the resources that we can to the Cabinet Office in trying to rectify the situation, and offer all of the expertise that we can in trying to rectify it, and to ensure that it remains a key priority for them and for Capita to fix it. So, I just wanted to say that.

38:28 - 38:35

Neil Couling

I have transferred two of my very best pensions experts into the team trying to minister this.

38:35 - 38:37

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you. We're going to have to move on. John Milne.

38:37 - 38:56

John Milne

Thank you, Chair. I want to talk about the Sainsbury review into the overpayment of carer's allowance. Liz Sayce, she talked about the attitude of senior leader senior leaders contributed to the serious mistakes. How will you ensure that this won't happen again?

38:56 - 41:46

Sarah Healey

I think it's really an excellent question and a really good example of what I was talking about earlier of a sort of culture of kind of being open to listening to issues and challenges. One of the things that I really reflected on in reading the Grenfell Tower Inquiry report, as the permanent secretary in MHCLG, was that it was very clear that the issues with building regulations were well known and understood elsewhere, and that they were being raised consistently with the department over a substantial period of time. I think it was a situation in which we did not there was a culture of explaining why the department was right, rather than a culture of listening to what might be going wrong underneath it all.

And it is obviously true that there was also appalling behaviour by a whole series of other players in that arena, but nonetheless, the inquiry report is very clear that we should have taken that more seriously. And I think that is about kind of questioning whenever we receive a set of complaints or issues raised with us, what actually is going on underneath the surface of this, because it obviously shouldn't necessarily need an external review in order to determine that. So, I think that would be my sort of first kind of critical lesson, is that you just always need to ask yourself what would happen, like what might be going on here that we haven't quite got to the bottom of, and not wanting to get to the stage of having to ask an external reviewer to do it. Now, we can do that partly by tracking complaints. I think it's also about how we engage with stakeholders.

I was fortunate enough to go to Carers UK as one of the first visits that I did as Permanent Secretary, and I'm really grateful for them for spending time talking to me about these issues, making sure I obviously knew about the carer's allowance issue before I came Permanent Secretary here, but obviously didn't, hadn't got under the skin of it to the extent that I obviously need to now. And indeed, I'm really grateful to the carers who gave up their time to come and talk to me about their experience, because obviously there are sort of, as the budget showed with the introduction of a taper on carer's allowance, there is the issue of fixing the overpayments, but there's also the kind of overall issue of fixing the some of the issues with the system in general. So, I do think it's about it's about opening your ears to complaints, spotting patterns. And in fact, one of the things in our action plan on pensions, State Pension communications, is to highlight that we need to have a way in which that we can spot patterns of complaints and investigate them early to sort of test whether there is something more serious going wrong. But it's also about it's about your stance, I think.

41:46 - 42:17

John Milne

Thank you, and I do think it needs a change in philosophy, I've come across it in other areas of government, too. It's an obsession with process rather than what is the actual problem that needs to be solved. But moving on, so there's a big reassessment exercise going on with a target of March '29 to complete. And now, in the first 6 months, only 1% of cases have been reassessed, and I think it's been estimated it would take about 40 years if we carry on at the present rate to get through it. So, we're being told that it's ramping up.

42:17 - 42:22

Speaker 18

It needs to ramp up quite significantly, to where are we now?

42:22 - 43:40

Sarah Healey

I mean, actually, can I, yeah, Yeah. I mean, you know, I'm fond of process as I've already made clear to the Committee, but I accept it's also about attitude. So, I mean, on that, I sort of was obviously anticipating that you might ask about it, because the latest sort of release that we did and update we did to the Committee set out that we'd reassessed just over 2,000 cases as of the 13th of September. You will be pleased to hear we're not intending to continue at that rate, and indeed, when we set up this exercise, we were clear all along that this would not be to do with this would not be something where we were going to we were going to start slowly, and we were going to start slowly deliberately.

We're going to start slowly deliberately because it is very important that we prioritise accuracy and that we learn from the early reassessments that we do, to ensure that we can ramp up safely and not introduce new inaccuracy into the system. So, we have done that. We have employed extra people to be involved in the exercise.

We're now able to, for them to have the benefit of the learning that we've done, and I can't give you a sort of verified figure for how many we've now done, but I believe it's in the order of around 7,000, so considerably faster.

43:40 - 43:45

Speaker 19

You feel reasonably confident that you will meet the 20-, March 2029 deadline?

43:45 - 44:44

Neil Couling

Yes, we will. For example, as of today, we have 2,500 cases we're actively looking at. So you know, when we wrote to you in September, we said we'd done 2,400 to complete. Just this week, we're looking at 2,500. It seems to be the bane of my life, this, for the last 15 years, I've been trying to explain to committees that things are not linear, okay?

You start small, and you ramp up at the end. When I rolled out Universal Credit, I did twen-, I did 75% of the job centres in nine months, the last nine months. I spent the previous four years doing the first quarter, so I learnt how not to make mistakes. And we're following that pattern with the Carer's Allowance review as well. I'm pleased with the progress we're making there, and we're on, we're on track.

So you will see it ramp up. You know, we've gone from zero staff doing this to 250. So it wouldn't be linear. It will be this kind of hockey ship shape.

44:44 - 44:53

John Milne

Just as a suggestion, you might even publish your own anticipated trajectory so that people can understand what they're looking for, because, unsurprisingly, they're looking at a, an average across. That's great.

44:53 - 45:02

Sarah Healey

They are, and we have been clear absolutely all along, and I've looked back over previous kind of statements on this that we expected it to start more slowly than it would go further down the line.

45:02 - 45:28

John Milne

Thank you. So, it was a, it was the big conclusion of the Sayce review that the majority of carers were not at fault for the overpayments, so the debts were accumulating because of administrative failures, and the department accepted that, yet, so far, you've changed the outcome in only 8.3% of cases, which seems a very low figure if, given the other considerations.

45:28 - 45:52

Sarah Healey

I mean, the first thing I should say is that when, last time Peter discussed this with the committee, I believe he was, we were predicting that it would be around that percentage of cases that we ended up with overpayment. So, actually, what is happening is consistent with the modelling we had at the beginning, and I think he explained it in quite a lot of detail when he was here, why our modelling suggested that it would be around 10%-ish, just under.

45:52 - 47:26

Neil Couling

So, we're doing two things here, and the two occasionally get elided in some of the commentary about this. There was a problem with our averaging guidance. This is what that act-, that exercise is about. We made a mistake. Our guidance did not conform to what the law required for averaging irregular earnings.

It's actually quite a difficult process to do. I've sat with the teams doing it. Crikey, it is, it's really difficult, which is why it's taken a bit of time to skill people up to do this and get it right. Then there's a second issue, which was, we were receiving information, it's called VEPS. It's a Verification of Earnings Payments System.

It tells us where there might be an overpayment on a case. We got Treasury funding back in 2019 to only do half of those, to concentrate on the half with the biggest overpayments. That left, and what Liz complained about in her report, was that we were leaving half the cases, so we knew that there were overpayments, but we weren't doing anything with it. On that, we have doubled the number of staff working in this area, so we are now clearing all of those prompts to us. It's not stopping overpayments occurring, but it is reducing the size of the overpayments because basically we're getting to them quicker.

So, it's two separate issues here we're working on, and you know, and our letter tried to split those two out for the committee so you could see that we're on both cases.

47:26 - 48:02

John Milne

Thank you for that explanation. In recommendation 7A of the review, again, accepted by government, was to ensure that the, I quote, "ensure the presumption in Carer's Allowance is to apply a civil penalty only when justified". But in the seven months after that, DWP issued over 17,000 civil penalties to penalties for Carer's Allowance, and that's about a third of all civil penalties issued by the DWP. So, what why were you continuing to find a very large number of carers? Why is that?

48:02 - 49:05

Neil Couling

Do you want me to take this? So, I think we put this in our response in our six-monthly update that Peter promised the committee. We looked at whether these civil penalties are being properly applied and they are. They meet the criteria that Parliament and ministers have set out for us to apply them. If anything, what our study unveiled was that we weren't properly applying them in other benefits.

So, it was looking like in Carer's Allowance that there was a higher proportion in Carer's Allowance compared to the other benefits in the system, most notably Universal Credit, something I used to be responsible for. So, you know, we're not wrongly applying these. Civil servants can only follow the policies set out by ministers and legislation, and we've satisfied ourselves, and we responded in our letter to you all about this, saying that we're getting this right. You know, we're discharging the policy as Parliament intended.

49:05 - 49:09

John Milne

Thank you for that. Perhaps we need to reconsider the policy, but

49:09 - 49:10

Not for us.

49:10 - 49:27

John Milne

Fair enough, yes. And then, lastly, the minister set out the actions that the department has taken to improve Carer's Allowance. When can we reasonably expect to have a fully functioning, fit-for-purpose system for carers?

49:27 - 50:20

Sarah Healey

I suppose one thing to say to that, and Neil might want to add, is that of course we are now fundamentally replacing and like improving the Carer's Allowance system in response to the decision to introduce a taper. And that will take, you know, Carer's Allowance, I think we all know, is based on a system that is quite old. It lacks the flexibility to be able to tailor it to do this, and that is why, frustratingly, even though the policy to announce 100% paper came as part of the budget, it won't be implemented for a few years because we need to actually change the whole system. I completely understand why there is nothing I can say that can make that less frustrating. It is, however, the case that long experience shows that attempting to change these systems very quickly is not, tends not to be very successful.

50:20 - 50:46

Neil Couling

I mean if you want the fun fact on here, it's not really a fun fact, but the IT system that runs Carer's Allowance is older than the our Head of Digital. I mean it is incapable of adaptation to produce the taper, and Catherine, maybe you want to say a couple of words just about the policy development here, but we've got a bit of policy development to do, as well.

50:46 - 51:14

Catherine Vaughan

Yeah, just to add to that, I mean, as Sarah says, we think it's really important for modernization of the policy that we introduce this taper and lots of stakeholders and organizations are very supportive and pleased that we've been able to do that. And we are all frustrated and keen to get on and implement, but as Neil says, the systems are simply so old and take that amount of change to them that it will be a few years, but we're also continuing to just look at the policy and how we could potentially modernize it in other ways, as well.

51:14 - 51:16

Speaker 25

Thank you very much.

51:16 - 51:18

Speaker 22

Thank you. Chair. Liz Twist.

51:18 - 51:41

Liz Twist

Thanks very much, Chair. I'd like to move on to the issue of awareness of State Pension age increases, please.

And firstly, direct my questions to you Dame Sarah because I think as permanent secretary, you've got overall responsibility for the action plan that's everything, actually.

51:41 - 51:45

Speaker 23

Yeah.

51:45 - 52:03

Liz Twist

So, the overall aim of the action plan agreed with the Parliamentary Ombudsman is to improve state pension age communications. Yes. What specific weaknesses in the current strategy should the new systems seek to address?

52:03 - 53:34

Sarah Healey

So, we, I know that the Committee was paying a very keen interest in the action plan when Peter appeared at a similar hearing this time last year. And we have set out a really comprehensive plan to ensure that in future nobody can remain unaware of changes in their own state pension age. I decided to try out the test your state pension age service the other day in order to test my own, and it worked very efficiently and very quickly. And the purpose of the plan is to set out a series of actions, campaigns, ongoing in order to ensure that people are aware that they should check their state pension age and aware of how they can do it. That includes paper channels as well as digital channels, but the digital channel is obviously kind of one which is most convenient for people.

So, since that was published, we promoted the check your state pension age actively as a service in September during Pension Awareness Week. And we are on track with all of the different actions that are set out in that action plan. We've also been keeping the Ombudsman updated on it, with the most recent discussion with the Ombudsman on it taking place only days ago. So, I am satisfied we are on track with the actions that we set out in June. You will have been able to see some of them making an impact as part of our campaigns.

And we are continuing to engage with the Ombudsman to ensure that the Ombudsman is satisfied with our progress.

53:34 - 54:02

Liz Twist

Thank you. Now your own research found that about 1 in 5 people with the state pension age of 67 underestimated their state pension age. What targets have you set for improving state pension age awareness, and how will you measure whether the new communication strategy is successful in actually achieving them?

54:02 - 54:48

Sarah Healey

It's a very good question. I'm afraid I'm not aware that we've set a specific target in terms of changing that number or the source of that. Very happy to sort of follow up with exactly what we're expecting in terms of awareness. But the plan has a really wide range of actions that we've set out in order to try and make a difference to this. I mean you can sort of write to everybody, you can't force them to sort of engage with the things that you give them.

So, there will always be a proportion of people who are not engaging with those services, but they are honestly so easy to engage with. I cannot tell you when I decided to check, and my pension age is also is 67, so I'm not one of those 1 in 5 now, which is obviously good news. But Neil, did you look like you wanted to

54:48 - 55:36

Neil Couling

I was just going to say, well, my wife and I got our letters about 3 months ago, because we are in the age range for the change from 66 to 67. So, we've sent millions of letters out now to people. But as some of the work around, you know, the Ombudsman found when they looked at the WASPI issue, people have a very low recall from letters, unfortunately, which is why that our approach is multimedia. It does look at using social media, advertising. I don't know if you've heard recently, but if you've been listening to the radio at all, you'll hear some adverts on the radio.

We're trying absolutely everything, but I suspect there still will be people who will not take account of this. And we will try

55:36 - 55:55

Sarah Healey

And we will try and it's not the multichannel nature is really important, and obviously that we target it to that the particular population that needs to know, which is why we will have chosen these channels quite carefully, and why we amplified it during a moment where people would be thinking about their pension anyway in September during Pension Awareness Week.

55:55 - 56:20

Liz Twist

Yeah, I want to come on to some of those people who might not access, or hear through usual means. So, because your research also found that vulnerable awareness was lowest amongst the more vulnerable, financially vulnerable groups, what do you think are the main barriers to those groups receiving or acting on communications?

56:20 - 56:43

Sarah Healey

I mean, my assumption is they're the same barriers that exists for vulnerable people in accessing and engaging with any service, which is that they lack the means to the same degree as other groups, and they lack the time in the same way as other groups, and the understanding.

56:43 - 56:46

Speaker 29

Thank you, Catherine.

56:46 - 56:50

Speaker 30

Yeah, I imagine it would be exactly the same things. I can't imagine it would be anything different.

56:50 - 57:11

Liz Twist

Well, I'm just looking at some of the groups that were identified, people who are neither working nor retired are less likely to identify their SPA correctly, and low-paid people earning under 12,000 pounds a year, for example. So, those are

57:11 - 57:18

Sarah Healey

Highly likely because of course they won't be receiving communications from their employer if they're neither employed nor retired.

57:18 - 57:22

Speaker 31

So, do you think there are specific measures that need to be taken to keep those

57:22 - 57:40

Sarah Healey

As I say, we've agreed this plan with the Ombudsman. The Ombudsman was satisfied with it and with our progress on it and it does involve writing to everyone and using a lot of different channels in order to try to communicate. So, we're not currently thinking of updating that action plan, no.

57:40 - 57:45

Speaker 28

Okay, but you're continuing to work with the Ombudsman on the points in the action plan for communication?

57:45 - 57:47

Speaker 27

Of course.

57:47 - 58:36

Liz Twist

Thank you. I'd like to talk now about inflated state pension forecasts which have may have happened. So, on more than one occasion now, significant numbers of people have been affected by inaccuracies arising from the interaction between DWP and HMRC systems and records. And I know that you've mentioned, a number of you have mentioned, the kind of old computer systems and programs that we have which clearly is featuring in a lot of these issues. But are you confident that the governance arrangements between the two departments are now sufficient to identify and resolve issues before they affect customers?

58:36 - 58:42

Speaker 32

And if so, why do you feel confident about that?

58:42 - 01:01:22

Neil Couling

Yeah. So, the issue around forecasts, I'm not saying, "Not me, guv", but it really wasn't the Department for Work and Pensions or anything that we had inputted. It was a question about how the forecasting system that HMRC run was set up and the inputs that they were making from the National Insurance recording system into that, and we don't run the National Insurance recording system, we haven't done since 1999.

Although, interestingly, people have often talked to you about Horizon. One of the reasons why the department pulled out from the Horizon thing early on, something Harriet Harman and Alistair Darling did, was our experience working with the predecessor to Fujitsu who were running the then National Insurance recording system,

and we saw the problems that were created in the national insurance recording system. So, back to Ms Ali's questions earlier, some of these problems go back decades. Okay, and I think that was what was going on here. But what we have done, to be more positive here, is we have shared governance arrangements between the two permanent secretaries, now Sarah Healey and Jon-Paul Marks from HMRC.

And then, my directors sit with HMRC directors working on issues that where there's the overlap between the national recording of national insurance and entitlement to benefits, most notably for the retirement pension, but of course the employment and support allowance and jobseeker's allowance, the contributory versions of those are dependent on HMRC holding the records properly and up and updating them. And if you want a good example of that, the Home Res- Home Responsibilities Protection LEAP exercise, that you can see I think is in pages 129 to 31 in the annual report and the accounts, it's listed there.

That was activity where we planned with HMRC their for their actions to contact women who may have been able to qualify for extra contributory years through HRP and then that had been missed on the HMRC systems. So, we were ready to take the cases when they corrected the national insurance records to come back to us to recalculate pension entitlements. So, we work quite closely with them, just the forecasting issue really wasn't us, Gov.

01:01:22 - 01:01:59

Catherine Vaughan

Can I perhaps just add about you asked about assurance? So, following that, there's a couple of pieces of work that we did jointly with HMRC. So, they now provide us with an annual letter of assurance about the processes for maintaining accurate national insurance records, and we talk about that in our governance statement in the annual report and accounts. And we also have a regular program of internal audit work, where they follow up the actions that were agreed as part of the review that was done jointly across DWP and HMRC to look at the ways of working.

01:01:59 - 01:02:11

Liz Twist

Thank you. So, in in fact you think you've identified what the causes of the problems were and you're working to resolve those issues, working with HMRC?

01:02:11 - 01:02:38

Catherine Vaughan

If the question is specifically about Home Responsibilities Protection, then we have completed that exercise, although it is still possible for people to come forward if they identify corrections are needed. But in terms of the processes that we recognized could have worked better, that assurance framework is in place and we have completed the actions arising from the internal audit work.

01:02:38 - 01:03:32

Neil Couling

And to be fair to HMRC, there are things that flow from us that need to flow into them. So, a few years ago, the UC system wasn't communicating national insurance credits correctly into HMRC. Basically, their older systems couldn't cope with the new data that was coming in, so we had to correct at our end to make sure that worked, and everybody's national insurance records who were on Universal Credit in the past or are on Universal Credit now are now up-to-date because of that.

So, we got issues between the two of us, which is why I say we have this joint meetings to make sure that we, you know, resolve issues as they emerge.

I'm sure new issues will emerge of some sort or another. And as Catherine was saying, the Concordat, the governance arrangements are set out in the annual report and accounts, because we take this very seriously.

01:03:32 - 01:03:58

Liz Twist

Okay, thank you. Because the government initially referred to a worst-case estimate of up to 800,000 customers affected by inflated state pension forecast. But it doesn't say how wrong the forecasts were. What's the department's current validated estimate for how many people were affected and the extent of the forecast?

01:03:58 - 01:04:18

Neil Couling

As I say, I don't think any of us can answer that question, because the forecasts are the responsibility of HMRC, and it was their estimates of the level of problems they had with their sort of coding. I think it's a lot smaller than that, but these are not things that we have direct responsibility for.

01:04:18 - 01:04:21

Liz Twist

Right, so you don't have those numbers or any

01:04:21 - 01:04:31

Neil Couling

No, because the forecasts are produced off of your if you go into your tax account, you can get a forecast for your state pension, for example.

01:04:31 - 01:04:42

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Can I just ask quickly, is that something that the you the Concordat that you have with the HMRC then will look to try and address as uh clear clearly um

01:04:42 - 01:04:51

Neil Couling

I'd be very happy to talk to my HMRC colleagues and say the committee's interested in this, and could they do you a note on just the latest position on it?

01:04:51 - 01:05:01

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

That would be very nice, but reassurance that it's not nearly a million people that have had no would be good. And if given that you report here, it would be almost

01:05:01 - 01:05:10

Sarah Healey

Well, we're very happy to ask them for their information and pass it on to the committee. But I think what Neil's saying is it is their information and systems rather than ours.

01:05:10 - 01:05:37

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

I think from our constituents' perspective, it will feel that, you know, when it comes to deductions for example, overpayment of tax credits, that everybody's very quick to find that and to target people, not so much when the reverse applies. Information about how you plan for your pensions, I'm sure we can all agree, is really important.

Absolutely. Let's move Have you got one more Thank you.

01:05:37 - 01:05:47

Liz Twist

Yes, just one more question. Have you considered whether complaints about state pension forecast errors will result in compensation? This may be another HMRC one from what you said.

01:05:47 - 01:05:50

Speaker 35

Refer to committee to my earlier answer.

01:05:50 - 01:06:04

Liz Twist

Yeah. And just a final comment from me, Chair. I'm noting all the references to the computer systems not matching up, and wondering what is happening to make Things that should be easy are becoming more

01:06:04 - 01:06:44

Sarah Healey

Well, I mean I wish they were easy. I think I fear they're not quite as easy as they might sort of sound from the outside, and that is certainly something I am learning during my time at DWP, that they're not straightforward, actually quite complex. But I think the answer that Catherine gave you earlier, which was about kind of exactly how we provide ourselves with assurance going forward, the way we manage the relationship with HMRC, I know JP Marks very well and kind of have a very strong relationship with him, so did Peter. I'm sure we're going to kind of maintain that going forward, and ensure that assurance is can be given in future. But obviously, we also can't take responsibility for things that they run.

01:06:44 - 01:07:34

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you, Liz. Thanks so much. I'm going to quickly ask you a question on following up on the letter particularly that we received yesterday afternoon from Sir Stephen on safeguarding. We are we do need to speed up on our responses if I could ask you for pithy responses, that would be great. So first of all, thank you for early earlier question or responses rather around the culture and about the training that you are facilitating within the department.

So the 12,000 of the 90,000 staff that have gone through level one, how many front-facing staff dealing with customers are there outstanding to do that level one?

01:07:34 - 01:07:38

Neil Couling

We're now up to 17,500 people have done the level one safeguarding training.

01:07:38 - 01:07:41

Speaker 34

Fantastic. And how many out of how many?

01:07:41 - 01:07:45

Neil Couling

Well, we haven't said it's going to be everybody in the department.

01:07:45 - 01:07:47

Speaker 38

No, I'm saying how many of the front-facing staff?

01:07:47 - 01:08:34

Neil Couling

So, about 16,000 of those, roughly 16,500, are front-facing staff, as you described in your question.

But I would ask the committee to remember, as well, that we also we have a slightly different definition around what safeguarding is. I know you use it to throw across vulnerability. We have separate vulnerability training that everybody has done in the department. So, our safeguarding training is about referring people on to experts, so, for example, domestic violence, you wouldn't want us trying to deal with domestic violence in a jobcentre. But where we identify that somebody is at risk of this, that's where the safeguarding training cuts in, that's where we refer to our partners in local authorities to deal with that.

01:08:34 - 01:08:49

Neil Couling

So, I just want the committee to know everybody has had training in dealing with vulnerable customers and those circumstances, and the safeguarding training is on top of that. 16,000 frontline staff have done that, 17,500 across the department.

01:08:50 - 01:09:01

Catherine Vaughan

It might be useful to just add to that, as well, we've recently, as you'll know, taken in 500 careers advisers, as we've merged the Jobs and Careers Service. And all of those 500 careers advisers have had the safeguarding level one as part of their induction.

01:09:01 - 01:09:19

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

That's good, that's good to hear. So, in previous years, there was a breakdown in terms of IPRs and deaths in relation to different service areas. That wasn't done in this year's report. Why was that?

01:09:19 - 01:09:21

Speaker 39

I'm afraid I don't know.

01:09:21 - 01:10:09

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Could they Could you respond to that after in writing to? Thank you very much. Then moving on quickly to the letter I received yesterday afternoon. It's a very detailed letter, and I'm very grateful to Sir Stephen. And as you rightly said, Dame Sarah, you cover everything in as responsible officer. Can you explain, in terms of we asked that domestic abuse be one of those areas where if customers expressed concerns about domestic abuse, that this would be identified so that people were aware and could respond appropriately.

You've rejected that.

01:10:09 - 01:10:15

Sarah Healey

The letter says that we've taken a decision not to do that, but instead to identify it under the other category.

01:10:15 - 01:11:07

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Can I just say this November is elimination of violence against women and girls. Two women a week will die at the hands of their partner or ex-partner. If we are to monitor, we had people who were affected by domestic abuse where money, being able to leave their abusive partner, was absolutely vital. And they felt completely lost, I have to say, in terms of how they could access support from DWP. How can we, if we're looking at systems and processes, having other doesn't identify somebody who is experiencing that.

How can we ensure that we are aware of the claimants, the customers, as you call them, who may be vulnerable in this way?

01:11:07 - 01:11:09

Speaker 37

There is a there is a reason here.

01:11:09 - 01:11:32

Sarah Healey

I'm sure there is a reason, and I will pass you to expand on it, Neil. Please don't think that we are not mindful of, and that our staff, who actually are in many cases the only face-to-face service that the government has, who are coming across people who are victims of domestic violence, and I know

01:11:32 - 01:11:51

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

I appreciate that, Dame Sarah, but I mean that's a little bit patronising, to be fair.

You are the only statutory agency that is required to provide support when people are eligible to. If somebody is fleeing domestic abuse surely we want to know about it so that we can then avail them of that support.

01:11:51 - 01:12:06

Sarah Healey

Yes, all I was saying was please don't take the response to that particular question as an indication that we don't take violence against women and girls seriously and that kind of the people who engage with our customers kind of don't come across these cases and deal with them very regularly, Neil.

01:12:06 - 01:12:42

Neil Couling

So, some of the and the committee will know this much better than me, but some of the instances where domestic violence is an issue the relationship has not yet broken down. The woman in which is nearly always the case, has not yet fled the home. The UC system is accessible to both partners. So, we were mindful that we could if the one partner had said I'm at risk of domestic violence, we recorded it in a very open way in the system the other partner might see that and that might cause them to do more harm.

01:12:42 - 01:13:05

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

I can remember as the UC system was being developed raising this specific issue and that there should be automatic alter APAs of alternative payment arrangements as there are in Northern Ireland, but you the English system refused to do that. There is a way that could have been overcome, but it wasn't. So,

01:13:05 - 01:13:10

Speaker 40

That's a separate issue. That is about payments. This is about recording in the system.

01:13:10 - 01:13:17

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Because the system only has one named person instead of allowing there to be two separate people.

01:13:17 - 01:13:46

Neil Couling

Yeah, that's the payment issue. The question you asked us was about the recording of this. In the recording there is a risk and in a design sense, we took a decision to minimise the risk here of inadvertent disclosure, which is what Sir Stephen's letter says back to you. If you're now raising an issue about the alternative payment arrangements, that is a separate issue and I will be happy to respond to you on that and what we do in those circumstances.

01:13:46 - 01:14:06

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

I think what I'm saying, Neil, is that if there had been an automatic right for APA, there wouldn't be one person, and then that one person, that abusive person, wouldn't know if somebody was trying to leave them. So, let's leave it, let's leave it there, and I'm going to hand over to Peter Bedford.

01:14:06 - 01:14:46

Peter Bedford

Thank you, Chair. Turning now to fraud and error. So, in the your annual report and accounts, just in summary, you had overpayments of 9.9 billion in year 25-26 with underpayments of 1.2 billion, so net overpayments of 8.7 billion. The government last year tried to put through the most modest of welfare savings to save just 1 billion, but we've got multiples times that's being basically being wasted in the system due to fraud or error. What are you doing to address that, and what are your targets to ensure that comes down?

01:14:46 - 01:17:42

Sarah Healey

So, we're absolutely not complacent about the level of fraud and error in our systems. We recognise these are very large sums of money because of the amount of money in the benefit system, and we are very focused on doing everything that we possibly can to reduce the level of fraud and error in the system, and indeed have seen significant amounts being saved through a series of interventions, not least targeted case reviews in recent years. We have been clear that we want to get the level of fraud and error down to 2.8%. That would be the lowest level it has been since the introduction of tax credits in 2003-4 and is therefore and it is currently down at 3.2%, which is a significant reduction since 21-22, a sort of peak during the pandemic.

You'll obviously be aware that we have recently taken through legislation which is being implemented, which is part of our strategy to reduce from current levels to 2.8%: the Public Authorities Fraud and Error Recovery Act of 2025. And I can confirm that aspects of that are already in implementation: eligibility verification measures, the first notice under that provision has been issued, and that we are making progress on debt recovery, we're making progress on administrative penalties, and we are working towards implementing other aspects of the Act which are not yet implemented, such as entry, search and seizure. I'd also point you to some announcements in the budget with regard to fraud and error, which include expanding of the network of verification assurance officers in jobcentres. That's, interestingly, a really good example of an innovation which was promoted by to us by people in jobcentres, who found it really helpful to have somebody on hand with a bit more expertise where they suspected there might be fraud underway, to help them with it. But as I have learnt to understand, while we would very much like to bring fraud and error levels down even lower than that, there are just some fundamental challenges with the nature of a highly targeted benefit system in doing this, that if you look at something like the state pension, for instance, our fraud and error rates are incredibly low, well under 1%, because of the nature of what it takes to qualify for it being much simpler to determine.

And in the level of benefit system that we have and the level of access we have to personal circumstance information, the level of access that people are comfortable with us having in order to verify, we think it is very challenging to get down to those kinds of levels in other areas.

01:17:42 - 01:17:59

Peter Bedford

Those measures you've just listed off, so, earlier in the year, I think the Public Accounts Committee made clear they it was unclear how you were going to spend the £2 billion that was allocated for this. Is that the stuff you've just reeled off, is that following on from what's been allocated to address this?

01:17:59 - 01:18:25

Neil Couling

So, I didn't quite follow their question on that, given the annual report and accounts sets out exactly where we spend our money. But we're very clear on where we're investing in anti-fraud activities. We're investing about £9 billion to save £40 billion by 2031. So, I thought we had been specific; they may well still argue that we're not, but it's set out in the annual report and accounts.

01:18:25 - 01:18:38

Sarah Healey

Yeah, there's sort of page There's quite a substantial amount in the annual report and accounts of transparent sort of declaration of information about fraud, error and debt, because we recognise how important it is in terms of the accounts for DWP.

01:18:38 - 01:18:54

Peter Bedford

And you mentioned the case of I think state pension, where the error rate was extremely low. But then you've got you've got other benefits, like Universal Credit claims are one in three, pension credit sorry, one in four, and pension credit with one in three is incorrectly

01:18:54 - 01:19:59

Neil Couling

So, if you take the state pension, it basically asks two questions, okay: have you paid National Insurance, are you over pension age? I mean, there is some about residence, but just for point of my argument, just take two questions. Universal Credit asks 1,000 questions, okay? So, any one of those could have some error or fraud in them. So, it The way the state pension works is almost like a universal basic income.

It's paid to every citizen, basically, because it's not actually you've paid National Insurance now, the contribut the sort of credit system, we were touching on a bit of this in earlier questions, extends that.

So, it works like a universal basic income, has a very low level of error. So, if you wanted to take Universal Credit and make it a universal basic income, you would get rid of about 7-8 billion pounds worth of fraud and error, but it would cost you about anything from 400 to 800 billion to run such a system. So, I'd save the exchequer 8 billion, but cost them 800 billion. So, that's an example of, you know, your complexity reduces expense.

01:19:59 - 01:20:28

Peter Bedford

Yeah, drives complexity. Just on your point around the complexity of the Universal Credit forms and filling in. When we consider error or fraud, the fact that some of these benefits are extremely complex and the forms and the, you know, what's required is extremely complex, how do we distinguish between what's a genuine error, you know, someone's confused when they're filling in a form, and what's someone's willfully trying to gain the system?

01:20:28 - 01:20:30

Speaker 41

Well, it's what we discover about what their actual circumstances are.

01:20:30 - 01:21:36

Neil Couling

Yeah, so in the annual report and accounts, it says about 3/4 is fraud of some sort of the total. Which I've got, going back to this point because I think, you know, it's not complexity because we want to be complex. It's the it's how you target something on individuals. If you take the rule around having a partner, so the couple's rules, okay, there's about a billion pounds worth of fraud caused by people not being straight with us that they're in relationships, okay? Having a couple rule saves you 40 billion pounds, because otherwise, you know, if you individualize the benefit.

So, am I bad for having a billion pounds fraud and error or am I good for saving the exchequer 40 billion pounds by not having an individualized system? And that's what's going on here, which is why it is very difficult to reduce fraud and error in the big income-related benefits below 3%. I think the 2.8% target is extremely stretching.

01:21:36 - 01:22:01

Sarah Healey

I think it's worth saying, you mentioned Pension Credit and two of the biggest drivers of fraud and error in Pension Credit is to do with people not letting us know how long they've been abroad for, and to do with fluctuations in the amount of capital that they have and not declaring those promptly. And two of the measures that we've been taking via that legislation will help with both of those.

01:22:01 - 01:22:14

Neil Couling

And it's a really good example. Expenditure on the state pension is about 150 billion a year, goes to practically every citizen over the age of 66. Expenditure on Pension Credit is 6 billion, overpayments 600 million.

01:22:14 - 01:22:27

Peter Bedford

It's Just conscious of time, Chair. Just a really quick a succinct answer. What impact do you expect moving the Public Sector Fraud Authority from the Cabinet Office to the DWP will actually have?

01:22:27 - 01:23:06

Sarah Healey

Well, I actually think that number one, the decision to machinery-of-government-change the PSFA over to DWP is a vote of confidence in our expertise on fraud. We obviously want, as we do with a range of other services that we are responsible for such as the Health and Safety Executive, to ensure that they still maintain their independence in challenging us to be better on fraud. But I think it puts them closer to understanding what implementing systems to address fraud and error are, and therefore, we hope that will enable them to have an even bigger impact on the advice that they and challenge that they offer to other public authorities.

01:23:06 - 01:23:07

Okay, thank you, Chair.

01:23:07 - 01:23:08

Thank you, John Milne.

01:23:08 - 01:23:37

John Milne

Thank you, Chair. And I'm conscious of being tight on time, so just to say. But continuing on the on a similar theme. So, errors directly by the government caused about 1.1 billion of overpayments, 1.2 of underpayments. That's quite a substantial sum of money, maybe not in the great scheme of DWP, but it's

So, what do we think we can do to, can we reasonably reduce that those figures?

01:23:37 - 01:24:48

Neil Couling

So, they are very small, you know, they're like 0.4% this is official error overpayments by volume of expenditure.

So, that is already quite small. And I have had, Mr Bedford raised this, some exchanges of the Public Accounts Committee on this to say, if I put effort into official error, I might not be able to put it into fraud. So, and, you know, if I reduced official error by a quarter, I'd only see 0.1% come off our fraud and error loss. If I reduced fraud by a quarter, I'd be closer to, you know, half a percent coming off of that figure.

So, we are not, we invest in quality, we train our staff, we do quality checks to try and lift the level of official error, but I do not think it would be cost-effective to do more today than we already do because I think there is more for the exchequer and the taxpayer I can get back by honing in on the losses we're seeing on fraud and customer error, which are much higher than our official error losses. Yes.

01:24:48 - 01:24:57

John Milne

Do you think it would be helpful for the for DWP to separate fraud and error rather than treating them as the same problem which itself leads to a lot of confusion in the public mind?

01:24:57 - 01:25:21

Neil Couling

There's a bit of a, you could get into lots of definitional arguments about what is customer error and what is fraud as such. And indeed in the statistics make this apparent that in the end you have to make a judgment about what wh- which side of the line does it fall. It's all loss to the exchequer in that regard. Can I think in terms of,

01:25:21 - 01:25:55

Sarah Healey

But I think also in terms of the action that we're taking quite a lot of it will be similar with both. If we think about the issue over kind of making it clear, easy for somebody to declare where they are, whether they're abroad or not, that helps because it reduces the error and hope- that allows us to hone down on where it's fraud. So, I mean, you know, I think actually it might make it more complicated rather than us actually thinking about how we can up-front kind of do as much as possible to prevent fraud and error in how we set up our systems, but also do as much as possible at the other end to find it once it's happened.

01:25:55 - 01:26:01

Speaker 52

The Targeted Case Review, for example, is targeted on error, but it finds quite a bit of fraud.

01:26:01 - 01:26:21

Neil Couling

Yes, exactly. So, the two travel together at times. Sometimes they don't, it is as Mr Bedford said earlier, people just make genuine mistakes, too. We need to be sensitive enough in the department to recognise that, as well as focus on the people who are, you know, defrauding us.

01:26:21 - 01:26:30

John Milne

If we were leaving it as one, we might as reasonably character- characterise it as error, rather than fraud. The word that the word that people hear is fraud.

01:26:30 - 01:26:58

Neil Couling

Yeah, so HMRC characterise nearly everything as error in their side of things, in fact they call it error and fraud. They've swap- swapped the two around. Because fraud is 3/4 of the error of loss, we call it fraud and er- and error. But, you know, that's a choice no doubt people can make.

I just would say in the statistics we do break all this down for everybody, so you can see, you know, there's full transparency here about what's going on,

01:26:58 - 01:27:06

Sarah Healey

Rather than separating it up-front in a way which might mean that we actually kind of don't have mutually reinforcing interventions which affect both.

01:27:06 - 01:27:24

John Milne

Appreciate that, there are political consequences, is all I'm saying, but anyway. Lastly, so underpayments have increased and a- and there's a further 3.7 billion which went unclaimed last year, so you've got awareness campaigns, but they don't seem to be getting the number down, any comment on that at all?

01:27:24 - 01:27:28

Speaker 42

Well, I think the, well, sorry.

01:27:28 - 01:27:29

Sarah Healey

On a roll, Neil.

01:27:30 - 01:28:08

Sarah Healey

I was just going to say a couple of things, then obviously you'll want to add some extra detail, Neil. All I was going to say is kind of where it comes to underpayment, I mean, we've already mentioned quite a lot of the things that we've changed that will help to address some of this, not least, strengthening the use of evidence, making it easier for people to update us on what their circumstances are. TCR, actually, targeted case review is there kind of to identify error, as Neil said. It will identify underpayment as well as overpayment, and that is a helpful mechanism that we use to do that and one which we're obviously expanding.

01:28:08 - 01:29:11

Neil Couling

Yeah, before I rudely interrupted my Permanent Secretary and ruined the career once more, I was just going to say the committee has made some really good points previously about confidence in the DWP. So, the heart at the heart of the unfulfilled eligibility numbers, which is the 3.7 you're talking to, Mr. Doogan, is a lack of confidence that if I tell the DWP something, my benefit will go down when it should go up. And you can see in the DLA figures particularly, where there's nearly a quarter of expenditure there is unfulfilled eligibility.

It is fear from existing claimants contacting the department that's stopping them telling us things that have changed on their case that would give them a bigger award. So, the committee before has said to us, you know, "You need to take this confidence in you issue seriously." And you are absolutely right, and that is what is coming That is at the heart of the unfulfilled eligibility thing here.

01:29:11 - 01:29:46

Sarah Healey

And just to sort of add to that, you will have seen that this is another area where we're using communications in order to encourage people to tell us about updates and circumstances, and that is from the perspective both of encouraging people not to fail to tell us of changes of circumstances, but also to tell us about changes of circumstances, which might actually result in a higher reward. And we've done the same with, because of DLA, we've also written to every to recipients in order to set out the need for them to update us on circumstances, and that might result in a higher reward.

01:29:46 - 01:29:55

Neil Couling

Yeah, we're just doing targeted case review with Pension Credit at the moment. We've just started it. And that is uncovering quite a lot of underpayments as well as overpayments.

01:29:55 - 01:29:56

Thank you very much.

01:29:56 - 01:29:57

Thank you. Patrick Hurley.

01:29:57 - 01:30:23

Brian Patrick Hurley

Thank you, Chair. Still on fraud and error, time doesn't stand still, so I expect you'll be utilising new technologies, artificial intelligence, all that sort of stuff, to continue to drive down on fraud and error. Can you talk me through what your plans are there, especially given that we all know AI has a propensity to error itself, and how are you making sure you're not going to make things worse?

01:30:23 - 01:31:17

Sarah Healey

So, we will use, I mean, broadly, we will use technology whenever technology is available that is reliable in order for us to do this. We actually have tried and tested ways of identifying fraud and error which are quite resource heavy, and we are very aware that it would be good if we were able to streamline those in future and use more technological means in order to do this and not rely on such a resource-heavy approach to it. Clearly, as you say, technology can make mistakes, and some of these technologies are, as yet, very untested on this kind of application. And we would not be and we would not be using, we would not put them into practice until we were more certain of how effective they would be and of them being reliable, not least because of the impact on individuals if they throw up false results.

01:31:17 - 01:31:38

Neil Couling

And we wrote to you I mean, you won't have seen the letter yet, but we've wrote to you to tell you about some machine learning we're experimenting with, trying to identify cases to review.

We look at that very carefully. We also see, sadly, AI being used against us as well. So, I don't know if you were coming onto that, but

01:31:38 - 01:31:59

Brian Patrick Hurley

I'll come onto that now actually because how are you firstly going to make sure that the DWP systems aren't going to be the frontline in some sort of hybrid warfare from the Kremlin? And you know, we're we're we're we're we're seeing supermarket fridges being attacked, which is inconveniencing people, but if the DWP's

01:31:59 - 01:32:01

Speaker 44

You're absolutely right, and in fact one of the things It's not the same thing, Neil.

01:32:01 - 01:32:14

Brian Patrick Hurley

catastrophic for the country. And so, what safeguards have been put in place there? And just also, are you going to be looking to implement within decision making capability as well as dealing with fraud and error, or is that just further down the track?

01:32:14 - 01:32:47

Sarah Healey

So, I'll say a few things about, actually, what I will do is turn to Catherine on cyber security because, clearly, the security of DWP systems is absolutely paramount. The amount of personal information that we have, the amount of money that is flowing through our systems, it is really, you know, as we've all reflected during this meeting, an incredibly high sum, and so our cyber security and resilience measures are critical, and one of the things that definitely keeps a new permanent secretary awake.

01:32:47 - 01:32:49

Speaker 46

Very briefly if you could, Catherine. Thank you.

01:32:49 - 01:33:38

Catherine Vaughan

Thank you. Yes, so it is part of my responsibility to look about our enterprise security risk management as a whole, so that is about thinking partly about cyber security risk, but also how it interplays with personnel security, with risk in our supply chain, with physical security as well. We use a whole range of government assurance frameworks and industry standards to help us assess our maturity. That includes the GovAssure framework, the NIST framework, and a whole range of governance mechanisms to make sure that we understand what risk we're taking, how we are mitigating, and at what pace.

01:33:38 - 01:33:42

Speaker 50

So, I mean, you know, we're very conscious of this.

01:33:42 - 01:33:43

Appreciate that. I will

01:33:43 - 01:34:32

Sarah Healey

Very quickly on AI, do you want me to talk about AI? So, I mean, we just need to be clear upfront, we will not use generative AI to make decisions, kind of we use it to support human decision making, and we and that is the purpose of it. We are very transparent about where we use algorithmic tools in the work that we do, as we should be, and we do a lot. The department is actually quite mature in having had a sort of responsible AI framework and approach for some time. But it is also really important to my mind that we make the best possible use of technology where we can to make both the customer experience better and our staff's lives easier.

And I won't, because of time, list all of the different ways in which we're using AI at the moment, but it's a range of different ways in order to improve both customer and staff experience.

01:34:32 - 01:34:55

Brian Patrick Hurley

Time is against us, so briefly, on a different topic if I can, pension credit. The take-up of pension credit is flatlining at around two thirds over the last few years despite pretty much all of the publicity measures that you're trying to get out there to encourage take-up. So, what are you going to do different this time round to encourage more people to take up pension credit?

01:34:55 - 01:35:13

Sarah Healey

I mean, we've got an incredibly active campaign out there at the moment, which we are rolling out in phases in order to encourage the take-up of pension credit, and we will continue to implement that with energy. And we will also evaluate it to see how well it's done and whether there's anything else that we can do.

01:35:13 - 01:35:43

Neil Couling

Yeah, we did nudge the numbers up 33,000, which is the first time it's nudged up. It's working against an uphill path because as the state pension is rising fast now under the triple lock, it's accelerating away from the pension credit entitlement, and that is reducing the number of people who would be entitled. That is a policy choice that the last government made to do.

01:35:43 - 01:35:48

Speaker 49

That's the denominator, isn't it? The percentage is still not gone up to 70%.

01:35:48 - 01:36:02

Neil Couling

Well, the percentage is slightly it is As I say, it's up 33,000. It's You know, I've been around, as I said, for 40 years, Pension Credit's been around for 25. It has stubbornly been at around that level ever since its introduction.

01:36:02 - 01:36:05

Speaker 48

So, we'll keep trying is the answer.

01:36:05 - 01:36:07

Speaker 45

Thank you. Thank you, Chair.

01:36:07 - 01:36:08

Thank you. Rushanara Ali.

01:36:08 - 01:37:06

Rushanara Ali

Thank you. So, I've got a couple of questions on health transformation and PIP the PIP customer experience. In 20 25-26, the Department processed 82.2% of new PIP claims in a timely manner, and that's up from 62.4% from 2024 to 5, which looks very positive and encouraging. With the downside is that you've increased the measure of timeliness from processing a new claim from 75 days to 120 days. Can you talk us through why you think that's acceptable in terms of the shift in goalposts where it'll take 6 months for the processing of a disability benefit?

You can appreciate, like if we had to wait for something quite straightforward for 6 months, it would be pretty bad, but this is disability benefit.

01:37:06 - 01:38:11

Neil Couling

So you're looking at the guilty man who made this change. And I made this change across the entire I came to start my job in April 20 25 and I looked across and there weren't standards for producing timely benefit awards. And the PIP one was nonsense. So, it would be Basically, I could have played that target. I know how to play targets as well as set them, and basically I could have done 75% of the cases and left the other cases, and I'd be hitting that target and you'd all be saying, "Oh, well done, you're hitting that target."

So, I set a 90% target across all the major benefits in my areas: Carer's Allowance, Attendance Allowance, DLA child, all got 90% targets, because you can't game a 90% target. I'm an old operatee, I know how to sort these systems out. So, it wasn't about moving the goalposts, it was about actually having some goalposts that worked.

01:38:11 - 01:38:33

Rushanara Ali

Okay. But can I just say, the concern here is that there'll be some there'll be some people for whom 6 months is really bad. And we need some reassurance that there are systems in place to address that. I hear what you're saying, but 6 months is just not going to be good enough for some of our constituents.

01:38:33 - 01:39:36

Neil Couling

And let me explain why it's that period of time. The process, you know, involves assessment. Committee has rightly absolutely applaud the Committee for this, gone about the importance of handling vulnerable people carefully, with sensitivity, with humanity in this process. 50% of assessments are not turned up at. 50% of assessments are not turned up attended.

People fail to attend, often for good reasons. We allow lots of failed to attend circumstances in the process because of this vulnerability. So, that chunk of the time is taken up in the assessment process and trying to make sure that we don't rush to an assessment, because when we found we did that and the chair has rightly called out, you know, IPRs and the like in the past, and we found out in the IPRs that people were rushing for the performance targets to close people's claims inappropriately.

01:39:36 - 01:39:39

Speaker 53

So, that's why we've allowed that period of time.

01:39:39 - 01:40:01

Rushanara Ali

That's very helpful, actually. What I would like, and perhaps you could write to us, is to for some clarity on areas where, actually, that's the length of time is a challenge and could be detrimental, because, actually, those are the sort of cases That's reassuring.

01:40:01 - 01:40:01

Whether we can offer

01:40:02 - 01:40:05

Speaker 55

Yeah, that's right, what we do to respond to particular circumstances, yes, that's right.

01:40:05 - 01:40:29

Rushanara Ali

Because those are the cases that can be very serious and can find their way to a committee, and MPs raising it with ministers, because there's nowhere else to go. And we just need to make sure that we're really clear that this six-month, this extension doesn't have detrimental effects on those who are likely to suffer in the circumstance.

01:40:29 - 01:40:49

Neil Couling

Vulnerable people will need more time, okay? That's what we've allowed for in the targets, try and get the right culture in the department. Other cases do go quicker than that. I'm also building lots of capacity in the assessment bit of the process so that they can cope with the volumes, because there's a volume issue to the delays as well.

01:40:49 - 01:40:59

Rushanara Ali

Just a final question which you can come back to or tell me now: when can we expect to see a full roll-out of the case management system for PIP claims?

01:40:59 - 01:41:08

Neil Couling

So, there are two things. I think we've said 2029 for full case management, which is the completion of the Health Transformation Project.

01:41:08 - 01:41:10

Speaker 54

You're on track?

01:41:10 - 01:41:30

Neil Couling

We're on track, but to an earlier question, I talked about doing things small first, we're at that small learning stage. We're uncovering bugs in the code. We're uncovering things. That's good that we're small so we can correct the individual cases quickly. When I'm confident that we can, you know, we'll scale.

01:41:30 - 01:41:39

Sarah Healey

So, if we've only got a certain percentage next time, it falls into Neil's non-linear category. Thank you very much. East Belfast.

01:41:39 - 01:42:20

Peter Bedford

Thank you, Chair. Turning to service modernisation, you touched on it a bit earlier on. You're four years into an 11-year programme on this, and you mentioned some of the challenges such as legacy IT systems and processes, etcetera. Clearly, a lot of outdated processes and systems here, but what are you going to do to ensure that actually, by the end of the 11-year period, the stuff you're bringing in isn't actually outdated? You know, technology is moving on fast, right?

And, you know, in a few years' time, the stuff you're bringing in could be completely archaic. So, what are you doing to ensure that we're or the department is abreast of that risk and is adapting the programme accordingly?

01:42:20 - 01:42:45

Sarah Healey

Yeah. I mean, it Service Modernisation Programme is made up of lots of separate programmes, so it isn't just sort of one big thing, which I think really helps with this. And also the fact that we have such extensive experience with the failings and challenges of legacy systems that, wherever possible, we are building in the ability to update and develop our systems as we procure them, but I can see that Catherine would like to say something about the commercial process here.

01:42:45 - 01:43:41

Catherine Vaughan

Well, I think it's the NAO have recently done a really helpful study on innovation in DWP and recognise that there are a whole range of ways in which we need to keep up to date, a range of ways of innovating both through systems, but also through ways of working, and recognising of course that there are significant systems that we lean on, many of which we are trying to develop in more modular ways so that they are more flexible for the future, because actually one of the challenges we've already talked about today is how long it can take to adjust old systems.

So, when we are developing new systems through the service modernisation programme, building systems in a way that enables them to be more quickly adaptable in the future is really important.

01:43:41 - 01:43:59

Peter Bedford

Could I probe a little bit into this? In terms of learnings from the I mean I come from the commercial sector, and my expectation of what I would learn after becoming an MP and I've seen the systems that not just your department, but many different departments use, I mean I was shocked how you know poor the systems are.

01:43:59 - 01:44:00

You're not the only one.

01:44:00 - 01:44:15

Peter Bedford

Right. And the thing that I learned from the private sector was the innovation there and the collaboration between various organisations. I'll give you an example. So, in the utility sector, a company, Octopus Energy, developed a system called Kraken, right?

01:44:15 - 01:44:21

Sarah Healey

We know a lot about Octopus Energy and, in fact, the department has done an enormous amount of work with Octopus in understanding that and how it and how it works.

01:44:21 - 01:44:36

Peter Bedford

Yeah. So, Kraken was a really good piece of innovation, and now a lot of other companies are starting to use it because of its it's just the functionality of the interface, the customer service, all the rest of it. What kind of stuff is the department doing to engage with the commercial sector to

01:44:36 - 01:45:14

Sarah Healey

Yeah. Well, I mean that is a really good example of some very intensive engagement with the commercial sector and understanding where what is the cutting edge of innovation, and what we might be able to learn from it. And I know a lot of in-depth work was done with them on that. We will always look for the best examples that we can take from the commercial sector, but I think we also need to acknowledge there are also things that we can learn from benefit systems in different parts of the world, which actually will tell us things as well, because we need to recognise the unique nature of what we do in our systems, because they need to be the level of reliability needs to be so high, and the level of cybersecurity around it needs to be so high.

01:45:14 - 01:45:24

Neil Couling

And there's one thing the commercial sector can do that we can't, which is that they can decide not to pursue a customer. We don't have that choice. So, we have to provide a service for everyone.

01:45:24 - 01:45:29

Peter Bedford

To some extent, I mean in the regulated utility sector that's not quite true, but

01:45:29 - 01:45:31

Speaker 59

We're a sort of universal in that sense.

01:45:31 - 01:45:41

Neil Couling

Retain the banks or insurance, which is we're quite similar to being a bank in a lot of ways. Banks can say, "I don't want your custom, you can go somewhere else." We can't do that.

01:45:41 - 01:46:00

Peter Bedford

Yeah. Just conscious of time, just briefly, I'm really keen on KPIs and holding departments to account. You know, if you were to come back in three years' time, what progress, you know, tangible progress are you going to present to us today to say that this has been a success so far?

01:46:00 - 01:47:41

Sarah Healey

So, I would be extremely foolish, and somebody who was only in their first select committee, if I set out for you a load of very specific KPIs right now before we've been through the publication of Wilburn, the publication of Timms, set out the next phase of our reform of the Jobs and Careers Service, seen what is going to be required of the department through devolution, got spending review settlement, that would not be sensible. Having said that, I would like to say that whenever we have set these performance targets, the annual report and account is report and accounts is where we set out the targets that the department holds itself to account for. What I can tell you is that, from my everything that I have done in the past and that I know, I would be obviously looking for the department to respond to the challenge that I think we will be set by the reviews that are coming out in the coming weeks in terms of reforming our services and seeing a real impact on the rate of those not in education, employment and training, because it is such a priority for the government, a particular priority for our Secretary of State; would have implemented kind of reforms agreed on the rest of the welfare system, and had a taken a view on the recommendations of the Timms review; and also that we will have continued to strive to deliver a modernised, transformed welfare system fit for the future, but one which is also localised and responding to local circumstances, and where kind of we build on the very best that jobcentres already do in terms of working with local services, local authorities and MSAs.

01:47:41 - 01:47:46

Speaker 57

Well, thank you for the offer for not coming back for three years. We'll never take that.

01:47:46 - 01:47:48

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Moving on, if I may, Damian Egan.

01:47:48 - 01:48:32

Damien James Egan

Thank you very much, Chair. So, I've got some questions on the new Jobs and Careers Service. So, it launched at the beginning of the beginning of October. As you'd call it, a soft launch because and I know that there's more to come. I wanted to think from a customer or a claimant coming to a jobcentre and what they might notice is different.

And I know that I know that from my one of my local jobcentres in Kingswood that they told me the signage will be changing next year and that they feel that will make a positive difference. But in terms of the actual practical differences that people can experience, what might they expect?

01:48:32 - 01:49:42

Sarah Healey

I can say a couple of things, then ask Catherine to come in. I mean, one practical difference is obviously the absorption of the National Careers Service into the Jobs and Careers Service means there's a broader range of careers advice as well as as well as broad sort of advice on how to get into work available. And the use of that has been really positive. And jobcentres that I visited, they can point to the real benefit that they get from having careers advisers as part of the jobcentre with their sort of particular insight into employment and links between it and skills offers.

And then the other thing I'd say, in terms of what you can see, obviously we've been rolling this out via a set of pathfinders. And if you haven't been to visit one of those, it's very much worth it. It's not just the signage that is different. It's the layout. We've really been testing different layouts so that they're a more positive environment for people to engage with a focus on privacy, listening to feedback from the people who work in the jobcentres, from work coaches, about what is effective and giving it a much more sort of modern feel in those places in order to make jobcentres open for all.

But Katherine, do you want to say a bit more?

01:49:42 - 01:51:08

Catherine Vaughan

Yeah, thanks. I mean, I think underpinning this is obviously we do want to get the evidence right for how we do transform, modernise the service. So, as Sarah referred to, we've got this series of pathfinders, and I know some of you have visited some of them. We've also got some longer-term trials about frequency of our interactions with customers and also the channel through which we communicate, so whether it's face-to-face, video, telephone. And we'll be publishing some of that evidence very soon.

So, we want to use that evidence to test and learn and then reform the jobcentres. But in terms of what we've seen already, to add to what Sarah said, I mean, the other thing that we've got now is digital tools for our customers. So, we've introduced an AI chatbot, which, in fact, any member of the public can use at all who's looking for work or looking to progress in their careers, and also a CV builder because we found actually with the careers advisers, actually their main use was really to advise people on CVs. And if you can do that electronically, then we can make sure careers advisers are adding even more value in their interactions, their face-to-face. I mean, I'm pleased to say that there's been a smooth integration of the careers advisers.

They're already doing lots of face-to-face appointments, lots of telephone calls. So, we are seeing we are seeing that integration. The other thing that customers are noticing as well is more outreach. So, lots of our work coaches based in libraries, community centres, youth hubs. We've got vans that go driving around local communities as well.

So, it's not just about what you see in the jobcentre. It's what you see out in the local community.

01:51:08 - 01:52:34

Damien James Egan

Good, I'm excited about this element around the focus around careers advice. One bit, we've talked in a number of questions, AI and changes in digital and tech has come up and obviously one place is in the workplace.

and I've worked with constituents who've been in always worked and then found that after decades industry changes have meant that they've had to go to the Jobcentre. We've had also been on visits as a committee to and heard, it won't surprise you, that sometimes people feedback to us that the support they get can be a bit one-size-fits-all. So, I imagine the careers service and careers advice is trying to do that. But could you speak, I'm particularly worried about those people who have been in employment for a very long time and then the level of support doesn't match.

And it's probably one for you, Catherine, because it's a policy question, something that came up with my work coaches. There's something at the moment called four-week permitted period where people can go and spend that trying to find a job in their sector, but after that the expectation is that they look at more broadly. And just feedback that I've had from customers and from work coaches, is that four-week permitted period in the world of work that we're in now, people need more time,

just would appreciate some reflections on that.

01:52:34 - 01:54:02

Catherine Vaughan

Be on that. Yeah, and as you say, the economy and the labour market is changing really rapidly and we obviously need to make sure our services are keeping up to date with that and are responding to that. On the impact of AI more generally, I mean what we are seeing in the economy is that it's actually changing the nature of work as much, you know, the types of jobs that people do and how that's augmented by technology. So, people both need upskilling in their current jobs and careers and with Skills England that we are also now responsible for, they're rolling out a programme of AI upskilling. I think there's 10 million places, so it's a huge kind of national scheme for that as well as short courses and things through apprenticeship.

So, there's upskilling available for people whose jobs need to be augmented, but in our Jobcentres, we're obviously offering services across a whole range of needs in terms of people who are becoming detached from the labour market. We don't forget we've got the contracted employment service as well, which will be devolving some of that so that works in partnership with our Jobcentres, but we've got a whole kind of range of support available depending on how close you are or how detached from the labour market. On the four-week permitted period in particular, I mean, really happy to reflect and have a look on that.

It has been raised. It's a judgement really because obviously within the system of benefit receipt, we want to make sure that people are actually looking for work and are, you know, living by the conditions under which we give out benefits. So, it's a judgement about balance on that.

01:54:02 - 01:54:38

Damien James Egan

The example I was one of my residents was a graphic designer and he's just said the time to put forward a quality portfolio needed more time. In the end, found a job that was paying more than he was on before. Final question so in DWP published an update in July which outlines what will be happening. And in there's it says that from early 2028 additional support, employment support, will be based on need not time away from employment. I just wondered if there are thoughts about how need will be defined.

01:54:38 - 01:55:32

Catherine Vaughan

Yeah, I mean the whole concept of the jobs and career service is that it's more personalised, it's more flexible as we've referred to today, but it's more focused on need. So, for example, what we're finding in our Jobcentres is a lot of our work coach time is spent with people who are unemployed and less work coach time is spent with people who are inactive, for example, so people who are on health and disability benefits. We've tried some voluntary experiments in Jobcentres which has been really successful about offering a greater level of service to those people who are inactive and on health and disability benefits and we're finding some really positive in-work results from that. So, it's that sort of thing reflecting as you know we've got a big trend in the economy of inactivity, not just for young people, but for older people as well. So, trying to personalise and actually redouble our efforts on groups that we might not have spent so much time with in the past.

So, I think the inactive group would be my main example of that.

01:55:32 - 01:55:34

Speaker 61

Thank you.

01:55:34 - 01:55:41

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you. And that concludes our oral evidence session with the Permanent Secretary and her officials. Thank you so much for joining us. Order.