House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittingsSonny Liang
Well, look, I hear what the noble Lord says, but let me say again, my Lords, our 100 million pounds R&D procurement scheme will help British startups develop innovative solutions to government challenges. We're making government a smarter, more accessible customer, creating procurement opportunities for smaller firms instead of favoring established suppliers. So through the AI Sovereign Fund, we are also supporting early startup procurement, enabling innovative businesses to demonstrate their technologies, generate revenue, and attract private investment. My Lords, I would encourage noble Lords to visit local university science and technology hubs and see the innovative AI companies. I was up in Manchester yesterday and I saw young people, exciting projects there, and perhaps if noble Lords could go out to these university science parks and be encouraged by what's being developed in this country.
Speaker 9
My Lords, does the minister agree that the government's support for an adoption of an open-source AI framework could greatly reduce the barriers to entry for smaller firms and accelerate investment, particularly if this could be done in partnership with other allied nations across the world?
Sonny Liang
Yes, I do, I do agree with the noble Lord. And that is why the British Business Bank has a 25.6 billion in financial capacity to support smaller, or rather smarter and smaller businesses, including 4 billion pounds in growth capital particularly for innovative research-intensive companies. So the Sovereign AI Fund works alongside the bank, including co-investing in a company called Ineffable Intelligence, which is a London-based artificial intelligence research lab. And meanwhile, the National Wealth Fund, with 27.8 billion pounds to deploy, is mobilizing private investment in AI infrastructure, including a 202 million guarantee supporting various AI companies.
Speaker 6
My Lords, I draw the attention of the House to my interests as set out in the register. I too welcome the investment in AI in yesterday's budget.
My Lords, AI presents a significant opportunity for businesses to innovate, attract investment, and grow our economy. However, it also risks widening existing gender gaps in skills, pay, innovation, leadership, and investment. Our own research found that 43% of young women entering the workforce are concerned that AI will replace them. And we also know that only 2% of funding from venture capitalists has gone to all-female founding teams. Can I ask my noble friend the Minister what steps the government are taking in partnership with businesses to ensure that women have equal access to AI skills, AI-enabled employment, opportunities for innovation, leadership, and investment?
Sonny Liang
My Lords, I co-chair the Women in Industry Taskforce. I'm very proud to be the co-chair, and I work with women leaders every day to encourage them to start their businesses, especially in tech. And I'm sure my noble friend will appreciate and welcome the budget yesterday when the Chancellor has said that he will be working with the Women Tech Taskforce in finding ways how women founders can access finance available. And if we empower women the same way that men does in tech, it would generate 300 billion pounds to the economy, and we must support women tech founders.
Andrew Sharpe
A nice short question. AI investors have told the government that energy costs are the barrier to investment here. So can I ask the noble lord the Minister why did yesterday's budget find room to cut tariffs on gherkins but not to cut the energy costs holding back our AI capacity?
Sonny Liang
Well, I mean, I would say to the noble lord, perhaps he should read the entire Red Book. There are many ways that we are supporting AI companies. I mean, yes, as far as data centers concerned, we are ensuring our national grid is linked up to all those data centers. At the same time, we're also supporting AI in the entire ecosystem in every aspects of the company within that system itself. There's a lot more to do, and we're doing that.
Speaker 14
The Made Smarter Review identified that a major impediment to SMEs adopting the then-available technology was the expertise and knowledge of the management, particularly around digital issues. So putting his small business minister hat on, can the Minister tell your Lordships' House what the government is doing to enable those small businesses that could grow using AI to get the expertise they need to do it?
Sonny Liang
My Lords, I spend every day as Minister for Small Businesses talking to businesses of all sizes, including small AI startups as well. My Lords, firstly, we've got to ensure that small companies have the access to finance to start their business. At the same time, we need to encourage young people to take up AI skills. We are committed to train 10 million young people with AI skills, and so far 2.2 million have completed programs.
Narendra Patel
My Lords, I commend the government on their investment in Isambard 1 computing in Bristol University, which I gather now has approaches from several hundred SMEs to use their computing power, which is one of the fastest processors globally. So what plans does the government have now to install Isambard 2, which I understand the Bristol University would welcome, which would increase even more compute power for United Kingdom?
Sonny Liang
The noble lord is absolutely right. I mean, we've got to invest in not only the compute power but also in quantum as well.
And the government has set up its program whereby it will mobilize the investment through the sovereign AI investing in some of these supercomputers across the country.
Timothy Kirkhope
It's not just a matter of government resources. There are many, many enterprising businesses now who are coming into this field. And I welcome the work going on in Yorkshire at the present to which the minister has referred. Surely though this is to do with even greater encouragement by government of those who are investing to try and make sure that academia is heavily involved, to make sure that all the businesses that are rearing to go to develop and innovate in AI are able to do so with full government encouragement.
Sonny Liang
The government is absolutely encouraging universities and academics to support the government's program as far as AI. And like I said in the earlier question, I have spent the last couple of weeks visiting various universities, science and technology hubs and all that. And some of the exciting startups being set up at these university science parks, all of us should really welcome because UK is not short of innovators and we have got the pipeline and we would like to see some of our innovators be unicorn companies.
Speaker 19
Great British Energy Nuclear is continuing to drive forward Gwynt y Ddraig, the UK's first small modular reactor project. Great British Nuclear and Rolls-Royce SMR entered contract earlier this year and are now undertaking design work to progress the Gwynt y Ddraig SMR project on Anglesey in North Wales. The project, which represents the most significant industrial investment in North Wales for a generation, will support up to 3,000 skilled jobs on site at peak construction and thousands more across the supply chain.
Speaker 21
I thank the noble lady the baroness for that, the minister for her answer. But project Gwynt y Ddraig does indeed present a unique opportunity to create thousands of skilled jobs, to transform local communities and to help Wales become a world leader in nuclear technology and its supply chain. But to achieve that ambition, we must also invest in the infrastructure and connectivity of that region, including an upgrade to the A55. What steps is the government planning to take to ensure that this project is not held back by the current deficiencies in infrastructure?
Speaker 19
Of course infrastructure is vital and I recognize the point that she makes about Wales becoming a world leader and her commitment to Wales. And this government does support the development of infrastructure very strongly as is evidenced many on many occasions. The government will work in partnership with the Welsh government to deliver better transport in North Wales. This was demonstrated by Transport for Wales increasing the number of trains on the North Wales coastline by about half in May. And in its planning for the delivery of the Gwynt y Ddraig project, Great British Energy Nuclear will consider the necessary infrastructure required.
Narendra Patel
We have in NHS a network of cyclotrons which produce low-lived medical isotopes. What we do not have is a reactor-based production of isotopes, so we import 80 to 90 percent of those isotopes from abroad with supply chains often precarious, which means our patients, particularly cancer patients, have delays in getting their treatment. The Welsh government produced a good business plan to base a reactor-based production of isotopes in Wales, cost of 400 million pounds and will last 70 years. If Wales is not the ideal place, maybe the government will consider Scotland.
Speaker 19
A very important question that has been raised and I would always support the performance of devolved governments in the UK. And I note the point that he makes. I understand that there has been discussions on the Project Arthur proposal with the Department for Health and Social Care, though there has not been any formal commitment to the specific project. I can assure you that the government is committed to ensuring resilient medical radioisotope supplies and making use of diverse international supply chains alongside greater UK manufacturing capability. Wider funding, including the 520 million pounds Life Sciences Innovative Manufacturing Fund, has been made available to support UK manufacturing.
But I note the point that he's made about Scotland. And I note the points that the noble lord has made. And I will ensure that they are communicated to the relevant departments because if it's raised in Parliament in this manner, it matters to departments and they should pay attention to it.
George Foulkes
On Scotland, as my noble friend knows, Hunterston and Torness are coming to the end of their lives shortly. And yet new nuclear is being opposed in Scotland by the Scottish government. I know that the UK government doesn't want to upset the Scottish government. However, since energy is a reserved area, is this not exactly the area we should use our sovereign powers and overrule the Scottish government?
Speaker 20
Interesting and challenging as ever from the noble lord. And I don't know how well people know this, but I'm not really on record as being frightened to upset the Scottish government. I don't think they would have that view either. But he raises a very serious point and there have been discussions about nuclear power in Scotland. The Green Party had a debate at their conference.
They have resisted it, unfortunately. And the SNP has stood against it. And I would say that they miss huge opportunities for the contributing to the development of clean energy in Scotland and across the UK. They're also turning their back on huge opportunities for investment and infrastructure development and the development of skills. And of course, we have high standards of safety and security overseen by independent regulators.
We've made enormous progress in this. I think the SNP have been very backward in their attitude and will use every opportunity I can to pursue this issue with the SNP government and I'm not frightened to do so.
Speaker 23
My lords, on these benches, we very much welcome the progress that's been made on this important project at Gwyndod. I wanted to ask the minister to give some further information on the skills pipeline needed. We recognize that there's the opportunity of 300 apprenticeships and 3,000 jobs. But what action is the government taking to ensure that local Welsh residents, including Welsh speakers, are able and empowered to apply for these jobs and that they turn into long-lasting opportunities?
Speaker 20
I think it's really important to make the point about Wales too, that Wales must be part of this because often we've seen projects in the past that haven't emphasized that connection to the local community and we must take those opportunities to do that. So I agree with his emphasis on that. And also, I think as John Healey said, the Chancellor said yesterday, we must make investment work twice. And I think we need to really make sure that we do that in the energy department as well so that we get a skills bonus as well as a delivery bonus. And so we do agree that it must represent a significant industrial investment in the region for in Wales for a generation.
Speaker 19
As I've said, it will support 3,000 jobs. There is a nuclear skills plan. It's focused not simply on growing the nuclear workforce, but on creating a strong, sustainable pipeline of skills and it's something that we'll keep under close attention.
Speaker 16
My Lords, it is absolutely right that the Scottish Nationalist government has been a blocker of nuclear power, but they are not the only Luddites in our political system. It was, of course, the case that Nick Clegg, as Deputy Prime Minister, stood in the way of new nuclear, and this government faces opposition from regulators who use legacy EU rules to stop new nuclear power. Fish protection measures have already cost more than 700 million pounds in development of, forgive me, of Hinkley Point. It is the case the government-commissioned Fingleton review pointed out how we could deal with these measures, but the government has refused to implement recommendations 11, 12, and 19. Why?
Speaker 19
My goodness, there's a lot in that, and I'm not sure I heard it all with some of the demands for a question out of it. But I can assure the noble Lord, I would never deny that there's been challenges in delivering our nuclear policy. We have had challenges in planning, and it's been far too slow. That's why the Fingleton review was undertaken. We've committed to implementing the 47 regulations of the Fingleton review.
Speaker 20
We're implementing some of those already. I can say to him, there will be lots of opportunities to discuss this matter further, and perhaps we can have a more detailed discussion as we take forward the legislation. And I suspect the notion of Brexit and the EU will be a continuing matter for discussion in this House.
Speaker 22
As someone that grew up on Ynys Môn, many of my friends had to leave the island to get a job. And after 15 years of a Conservative government in London and many years of a Labour government in Cardiff, that's been an economic disaster for Wales. So can the Minister commit to recruiting locally for this project so that we don't have another generation that has to leave the island just for a job?
Speaker 19
Again, a very serious question and a matter that demands close attention. I would need to look at the details of the particular island rather than give you guarantees, but I can assure you that the principle of local employment, ensuring local communities benefit from infrastructure development, is at the center of what we do. We will keep it closely monitored. We will ensure there is a skills pipeline coming through, because there's a range of jobs that are associated with nuclear projects, from the very highly skilled through to apprenticeships, and we must make sure that that is vital. Overall, our commitment is to growth in every postcode, economic regeneration for all of the UK.
And can I just say, I think it was a model between the Plaid Cymru government and the UK government to develop this project. Michael Shanks was there last week under the title with the Welsh government minister, saying delivering together. I think that's a constructive approach. We have our differences, but I think on employment regeneration, we can work together on that.
Speaker 29
My Lords, just on this point, while I welcome the employment opportunities expected from the Gwndod project, does my noble friend the Minister agree that success should not be measured simply by the numbers of jobs created, but also by whether they are secure, highly paid, union-recognized jobs and filled by local people? And what steps are the government taking to ensure that this ambitious project creates a sustainable pipeline of engineers, technicians, and skilled tradespeople, not just in North Wales, but nationwide, supporting both this initiative and the UK's future nuclear program as a whole?
Speaker 20
Of course, again, a vital dimension of this. I should have said earlier that the nuclear skill hubs includes the Wales hub, and it is a UK-wide approach that brings employers, training providers, and partners together to address local skills needs and strengthen that pipeline of talent needed to support the sector's future.
But we are also the plan is strengthening apprenticeships, graduate programs, doctoral research and technical career paths to develop the engineers, technicians and skilled workforce needed to support the UK's current and future nuclear ambitions. But we all know that economically that has a read across to other industries, it's a read across to other skills and there are supplier knock-on effects in that. And can I say to him we do want to release this money to make it work twice, to make sure that we do have high-level, well-paid jobs that of course are unionized too.
Speaker 26
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Feryal Clark
My Lords, Ofcom assessed and designated services on the register in line with the regulations passed by Parliament in February 2025. These set category one threshold conditions combining user numbers and functionalities. Category one is intended for platforms with a minimum seven million monthly UK users, reflecting their reach and influence. Smaller services are required to tackle illegal content including suicide, self-harm and anti-Semitic content that meets the legal threshold and protect children from harmful content.
Speaker 31
The noble lady the minister very much indeed for her answer. But the real reason is that in 2025 then ministers chose to accept Ofcom's advice to categorize online platforms on the basis of user numbers alone. So do current ministers now accept that Ofcom would have been better able, for example, to block a notorious suicide forum, to tackle platforms promoting hateful anti-Semitic content or those recruiting people for activities hostile to the United Kingdom if they had followed what this House legislated for in 2023 and if ministers had pushed back on Ofcom's advice to categorize platforms, the House wanted them to categorize platforms on the basis of functionality or size, giving ministers that flexibility.
Feryal Clark
Categorization of course as the noble lady knows does not determine whether a service is regulated or subject to the enforcement of Ofcom. The government did consider options to categorize small but risky services including those proposed by many thoughtful people on this complicated issue, but ultimately a workable and robust condition for capturing small but risky services was not found. But I would highlight and emphasize and underline that the government shares the significant concerns about small but risky services such as those which exist purely to stoke hate and division. Ofcom has established the small but risky task force. It has monitored and carried out active engagement with providers of four services that represent a significant risk of harm to children from harmful content they host or disseminate.
And a number of those have geo-blocked the UK as a result. But the government keeps the effectiveness of the Online Safety Act under review and will not hesitate to take further action where there is clear evidence it is needed.
Speaker 30
My Lords, currently the Online Safety Act requires platforms to conduct suitable and sufficient risk assessments but does not legally require platforms to take action to address the risks identified in these assessments. Does the noble lady the minister think the OSA should be amended to deal with that problem?
Feryal Clark
The question of the Online Safety Act and the implementation is something that the government is highly focused on. We have asked Ofcom to look at the capabilities, the chair of Ofcom is looking at the capabilities around supervision and enforcement.
That is something that we are doing. We have we are taking forward further measures to protect children with the under-16s restricting social media companies providing services to under-16s. So we are very live to the effectiveness of the Online Safety Act. As the Secretary of State and others have said, where we find evidence that more action is needed, we will take it.
Speaker 39
Pro-anorexia online forums promote extremely dangerous content exacerbating eating disorders. Yet Ofcom have chosen not to take powers to tackle these pernicious sites knowing that anorexia has the highest mortality rate of all eating disorders. Is the government reviewing how Ofcom are using the powers this Parliament gave them to tackle small high-harm eating disorder forums and if they're not will they commit to do so?
Feryal Clark
As I mentioned, the government does share the significant concerns about small but risky services. The Ofcom task force is working to ensure compliance with the Online Safety Act, focusing on platforms hosting priority harm content such as CSAM, hate and terror content, suicide, self-harm and eating disorder forums and violence against women and girls. That is a very important focus of activity. As I also mentioned, the question of Ofcom's enforcement capabilities is something that we expect we expect Ofcom to enforce robustly. Ofcom has the government's full backing to use its enforcement powers and the chair of Ofcom is undertaking a review of Ofcom's enforcement capabilities and powers and the government is in discussion about what more needs to be done here.
Speaker 36
Isn't it the case that once again Ofcom is hopeless and that what we need to do is review the role of Ofcom? Because unless we have an effective regulator, things like this will happen on a regular basis. We need to do something about the poor standard that regulators have in this country.
Feryal Clark
Ensuring there is a safe digital experience for citizens and young people in this country as my noble friend alludes to is absolutely essential. And we expect robust enforcement of the Online Safety Act. We welcome the capabilities review commissioned by Sir Ian Cheshire as the new chair of Ofcom. That is expected to conclude this autumn and we expect the review to identify practical improvements needed to strengthen the pace and impact of Ofcom's enforcement function. So and enforcement goes hand in hand with the further measures the the government is is going to bring in in terms of regulating the online environment for young people.
Speaker 37
My Lords, it is clear that smaller platforms are causing disproportionate harm to society. We supported the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, with his regret motion on quite rightly regulating these smaller platforms in February 2025 in which the contents had it. Does the government now accept it was a serious mistake to resist the will of the House?
Feryal Clark
The small but regular small and risky services are regulated under the Online Safety Act. They are subject to the duties around illegal content and harm for children. It is very important that those duties are abided by. It is very important as I mentioned before that Ofcom enforces focusing on those services who who are disseminating or creating the environment for such harm. It is something that we absolutely back.
Speaker 33
My Lords, can the noble lady the Minister comment on how the exclusion of small high-harm platforms from category one support the government's violence against women and girls strategy, given concerns that online abuse, coercion, the spread of misogynistic content often occur on very niche platforms with relatively small user bases?
Feryal Clark
Small but risky or small services are subject to the illegal content and the child safety duties. So where there is evidence that they are not abiding by those duties, it is absolutely for Ofcom to enforce. And that is one reason we have asked Ofcom and Sir Ian Cheshire is taking forward his review of capabilities of Ofcom. It is very important that the online and offline space is safe for women and girls and that illegal content is clamped down on.
Timothy Clement-Jones
My Lords, I thank the noble Earl for his reference, but I want to commend the noble Baroness Morgan for her work on this, my Lords. I'm not surprised that she's raised this again. We all thought when she put an amendment to the Online Safety Bill, my Lords, that this categorization matter was sorted. But my Lords, will the government now firmly commit to a fixed date for reviewing the categorization thresholds informed by evidence of harm rather than user numbers, so that this isn't left to drift until the statutory review of the Act?
Feryal Clark
The focus in terms of taking forward the categorization duties is to ensure that during 2027 those duties can take force. But let me just come back to the question which I think everyone in this House agrees with, which is small but risky services that are providing illegal content or harm to children should not do so, and Ofcom should take the necessary action to enforce the duties under the Act.
Ilora Finlay
My Lords, may I ask how is Ofcom working with the Consumer Council to look at control of so-called toys targeted to children as young as three, which have AI responses in them and that actually are linked through the internet and can give really disgusting answers if children pose even simple questions from the age of three onwards, some of which are highly sexual?
Feryal Clark
We must obviously keep examples such as that in mind. I would prefer to write to the noble Baroness answering specifically on that question, which crosses a number of activities and regulation. We are taking action to restrict children's access to services that provide the kind of harm that she mentions, but let me follow up with her afterwards.
David Alton
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Speaker 35
The increasing use of aerial warfare, including drones, is inflicting devastating harm on civilians and civilian infrastructure in Sudan, killing over 1,000 civilians in the first half of this year, and it's contributing to the growing risk of famine in Sudan. The UK, both publicly and in our diplomatic engagements, is urging the warring parties to protect civilians, comply with international humanitarian law, and facilitate safe and unhindered humanitarian access.
And at the UN General Assembly, the Foreign Secretary and Minister for International Development convened international partners to coordinate action to protect civilians in Sudan, issued a communiqué on behalf of the UK-convened Coalition for Atrocity Prevention on the impact of drone warfare on civilians.
David Alton
My Lords, in thanking the noble Lord, Lord Wood, for that reply, can he tell us what response we've received from the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons about credible allegations concerning the use of chemical weapons in Sudan and the bringing to justice of those responsible, along with the quartermasters whose actions have led to an estimated 400,000 deaths in Sudan, including terrible atrocities in Darfur and El Fasher, the displacement of some 14 million people, and 19 million people facing acute food insecurity and famine? And my Lords, as penholders in the Security Council, will the noble Lord take this opportunity to clarify reports that the UK intends to support a candidate to become Secretary-General of the United Nations who has dismissed the findings of the UN's own panel of experts about the involvement of the UAE in arming RSF paramilitaries? What convoluted message would this send in seeking an end to the world's most deadly catastrophic war?
Speaker 35
I can thank the noble Lord for that and also pay tribute to the noble Lord. No one in this House or indeed outside of this House does more to keep the spotlight shining on what is the worst humanitarian crisis facing the world in the 21st century, and I want to thank him for that. On the chemical weapons issue, we take any alleged breach of the Chemical Weapons Convention very seriously. As Sudan is a state party to the Chemical Weapons Convention, we expect all those in Sudan to abide by the prohibition on developing, producing, processing, transferring, or using chemical weapons. And we have consistently raised concerns about allegations of weapon use by the SAF, the Sudanese Armed Forces, including at the Organisation for Prohibition of Chemical Weapons.
In fact, I hosted the Director-General of the OPCW a couple of weeks ago in this very building and discussed exactly that. And we are using our national and Sudan-specific statements at the Executive Council of the OPCW to further this agenda. On the issue of the United Nations Secretary-General, I'd urge everyone in the House not to believe wild speculation that's in the newspapers on any UK preference for any candidate. We do not comment in public on that and that's the way we'll continue to approach this issue.
Jeremy Purvis
My Lords, concerning the actions that the UK has taken with regards to the credible information on the use of chlorine gas on civilians, is it that the UK has asked the alleged perpetrators to investigate their own actions? This is wholly insufficient. Under Article 9 and 10 of the Chemical Weapons Convention, the UK as a state party can take actions to demand independent investigations of this credible information of the use of gas. And as the UN Security penholder for Sudan, why have we not taken this action?
Speaker 35
Well, I thank the noble Lord for that question. We are engaging on a number of strands in this issue with the OPCW. The noble Lord is absolutely right that part of that is urging Sudan to conclude the investigation that is underway. But we have a range of discussions at the OPCW and at the UN in our role as penholder across the community of nations about ways of addressing the issue and taking allegations seriously. The OPCW, as the noble Lord knows and I think everyone in the House knows, has enjoyed extremely strong support from the United Kingdom for a number of years, and we take it extremely seriously as the primary vehicle to investigate very serious alleged breaches.
Margaret Ritchie
My Lords, given the humanitarian crisis and the extent of it in Sudan over the last number of years, and like the noble Lord Alton, I would ask again my noble friend, would he, along with international counterparts, put some diplomatic pressure on President Trump to persuade him not to allow control of the UN to go to the UAE as they fund the rebels in Sudan who have committed immeasurable atrocities in Darfur and El Fasher?
Speaker 35
Well, my noble friend is right that in pointing to the role of external interference in this conflict and the way in which that interference fuels the conflict. We have been clear from the start that all external support for either side only serves to fuel the bloodshed and prolong the violence and must end. That's why we have imposed an arms embargo on Sudan. With reference to the United States, that's why we continue to call not just for compliance with the United Nations arms embargo on Darfur, but also we are working with the US and others to support efforts to strengthen the scope of that UN embargo.
Speaker 48
Further to the question asked by the noble Lord, Lord Alton, it was exactly a year ago that the RSF attacked El Fasher and 6,000 civilians were killed. A similar appalling atrocity was committed in El Geneina a few months later. These are vile, wicked, evil crimes being committed by people who are beyond reproach. What more can be done to bring them to justice?
Speaker 35
Well, I agree and I think everyone will agree with the noble Lord about the vileness of the actions in El Fasher. The events were horrific. Earlier this week, the Minister for International Development, jointly with the All-Party Group on Sudan, held an event in Parliament to remember the victims. And we announced on the first anniversary of the RSF's assault on El Fasher a new round of sanctions on suspected perpetrators of sexual violence and other atrocities. The answer to what can be done is a whole range of things.
And I'm pleased to say that, frustrating as it is, that the United Kingdom is leading on both humanitarian support, 146 million pounds a year at the moment, on justice and accountability through leadership of a coalition for atrocity prevention and justice, and using its penholder status at the United Nations in a variety of activities.
Speaker 45
My Lords, I very much welcome what my noble friend the Minister has had to say about our continuing support, particularly the humanitarian response. Can he update the House on the processes that are being led by the US through the Quad? And also can he commit that the UK, because these Quad processes and other statements and new processes have so far been unsuccessful in preventing the grim atrocities that we continue to see, can he continue to commit the UK to playing a leading role in the painstaking work of working with civil society and local political civilian leadership in order to bring about a peace that is lasting?
Speaker 35
Well, my noble friend knows what she's talking about on this. She played a leading role in the response to this for a number of years and I work with officials who are extremely who are grateful for all the leadership that she provided on this over a long time. And she's absolutely right that the UK must and does continue to play a leading effort in not just formal multilateral fora, but also in informal environments as well. Recently, my right honourable friend the Foreign Secretary was in Istanbul for an, excuse the acronym, E3 plus R4 meeting, which engages countries with different kinds of access to involved parties in ways of trying to find ways through on the range of difficult issues that are involved in the Sudan conflict.
Speaker 40
My Lords, churches have been widely used as shelters over the course of the conflict in Sudan, particularly in the Nuba Mountains from where the majority of Sudanese Christians originate.
Attacks on places of worship and religious leaders have been widely documented and both sides have used places of worship for military purposes. So in in the light of these developments, can I ask the noble Lord the Minister what assessment the government has made on the situation of freedom of religion in Sudan and what steps particularly is the government taking to ensure that the urgent humanitarian assistance that he's already referenced is also reaching vulnerable and historically marginalized religious communities, including in the Nuba Mountains?
Speaker 35
Well, the right reverend prelate is right to point to issues to do with freedom of worship and also issues to do with the use of religious buildings, of churches and other locations for parties to the conflict. And I think one of the guiding principles of the humanitarian support provided, not just the amount, 146 million a year, which I'm pleased to say is reaching millions of millions of people, but I think one of the developments, in fact my noble friend I think was partly responsible for this evolution, is that we are providing help to local responders using NGOs, local organizations, including religious organizations as partners and destinations for funding. And I think that's an important principle in the response that the right reverend prelate pointed out.
Colin Moynihan
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question for which I have given private notice. The question is to ask His Majesty's government what assessment they have made of the exploration of the Rosebank oil field following its development being accounted for in the OBR's economic and fiscal outlook published on the 28th of October 2026.
Speaker 19
The OBR makes assumptions about future oil and gas production in order to forecast tax receipts. It uses the North Sea Transition Authority's projections, which include potential production from potential new fields, including Rosebank and future discoveries. It is therefore normal for the government's future revenue forecasts to include both current and potential future oil and gas projects. Rosebank, for example, has been included since at least 2019. This in no way reflects the Energy Secretary's independent decision on the project, which will be made through the quasi-judicial process taking into account all relevant factors in the case.
It will not surprise the noble Lord to hear me say I'm unable to comment further on individual projects and the Energy Secretary will be making a decision on whether to grant consent or not in due course as in the normal way.
Colin Moynihan
My Lords, I declare my interest as chair of EMIAC in Amersham. My Lords, the legislation governing the OBR gives it an explicit, legally binding right to access information and seek assistance from government departments. When it is uncertain, it says so. However, what it says on pages 93 and 94 is as clear as crystal. The projection for oil and gas receipts, and I quote, includes production from currently producing fields, including Jackdaw, and the NSTA's estimate of production from development of new fields, which includes Rosebank.
No prevarication, no rider, specifically named. My Lords, at today's oil prices and with current reserve estimates, it's likely that the tax take could be north of 10 billion pounds over the life of the field. Can I ask the Minister why it's taken over a year for the government to announce the decision to produce Rosebank, with the Secretary of State stating to the Guardian that she is, quote, leaning towards refusing Rosebank, when the words of the Chancellor this morning in the context of Jackdaw was that it's, quote, common sense, it's practical, it's really welcome, it adds to our energy security and it produces revenue, all of which are equally applicable to Rosebank.
Will the Minister agree that if these figures are wrong, then the OBR, despite their right to consult DESNZ, should bin their projection and rewrite them? Or should not Parliament be informed first when the government makes an announcement, especially when backing the Conservative campaign to approve Rosebank and back Scottish workers, indeed over a thousand Scottish workers and their families?
Speaker 19
The noble Lord makes a number of points. I have to emphasize in terms of what he said about the OBR, I have to re-emphasize the points that I've made, that this is a normal process for the government's future revenue forecast to include both current and potential oil and gas receipts, and it has been included since 2019. But he goes on to make a number of other points, and the Chancellor did indeed say that Jackdaw was common sense. I think I used that very phrase myself when I was at the dispatch box earlier this week. And I have to emphasize that we've had a legal challenge through this process, as this government who will understand that because the Court of Session did say that scope 3 emissions had to be taken into account.
So we've had to revisit. I want to be as clear as I can be that this is quasi-judicial and I do not wish to jeopardize that in any way whatsoever. I take the point he's made. I'm under no illusions about what the Conservative Party's view on this is. It has been pointed out to me countless occasions what your view is.
And I want to just leave it at that. I'm sure as the questions develop we may go into a bit of a political party debate, but at the moment I just want to emphasize the quasi-judicial nature of the Rosebank decision.
George Foulkes
My Lords, further to that point, will my noble friend confirm that if this decision is made on a political basis and not on the facts for and against going ahead, there could be another legal challenge which would delay it for a further two years, which would certainly not be of any benefit to the people of Scotland?
Speaker 20
Very well said, Lord Foulkes. Not for, I don't mean that disrespectfully. I mean more that he challenges me usually in his questions, not that he doesn't put his case well, so humble apologies for that, that was inappropriate. But he does make the point very well that the decision is quasi-judicial. All the factors will be taken into account.
Speaker 19
They must be taken into account. If not, they are bound to be legally challenged. We know that there are stakeholders with great interest on all sides of this decision. And for those who are against and those who are for Rosebank, I would counsel them to think about that because it may jeopardize the future if we do not get the legal process right in this.
Speaker 23
My Lords, I thank the Minister for the earlier answers she's provided to give clarity on the OBR forecasts. But can I ask, separate from the decision, does the Minister agree that 90% of Rosebank's oil reserves would be destined for international markets and would be sold at global market prices, providing little or no benefit to UK consumers, and that the 254 million tons of scope 3 CO2 emissions would be equivalent to 70% of the UK's annual emissions in 2024 and seem to be very incompatible with our carbon budgets?
Speaker 20
Again, I have to say make the same point. I cannot be tempted into making any comment about that. He has made his point. It is on the record. I heard some challenges to him, I heard some support for him, that's on the record.
Mark Harper
Didn't the Chancellor really give the game away yesterday when he referred to Jackdaw and accidentally let the truth out, which was that the Energy Secretary was opposed to it, but the Prime Minister and the Chancellor said yes? Isn't that exactly what we're going to see with the Rosebank decision? She's against it, the Energy Secretary, but the Prime Minister and the Chancellor know it's the right thing to do. That's what the government's going to do. And if they do the right thing, we'll support them.
Speaker 19
I understand the process and I understand politics. I can understand why you are making that point. But I have to say it is quasi-judicial and I can absolutely guarantee, because I know the Energy Secretary very well, she has not made the decision. She will make the decision on the facts and the government will stand by that decision.
Speaker 53
I'm under previous Conservative governments and that that really is not important in this discussion. She is quite right, of course, to say that the Secretary of State will make the decision in her own time, exactly as a previous Conservative Secretary of State would do it. All I would say to her is that I hope the Secretary of State realizes how important it is for Britain not to encourage other people to extend the exploitation of oil because we are fighting a battle against climate change which is crucially important for our children and grandchildren.
Speaker 19
I never thought I'd ever be in a position to find myself saying this, but I have listened to the noble Lord's speeches on climate change and have had a very positive response to them. I think he makes very significant contributions on climate change and we pay tribute to the work that he's done. I will reference the Jackdaw decision because I don't want to reference the Rosebank decision, but we, the government, is very clear that we are maintaining our commitment to get off the fossil fuel roller coaster. It is entirely consistent with our commitment to building clean energy and we remain committed to understanding and explaining to the British people the threat of climate change and the way that it will impact on their lives. It is happening now.
We need to adapt. We need to mitigate now. And we need to get off the fossil fuel roller coaster. And I do recognize the arguments that he has put so well in this chamber about that.
Alex Alexander Carlile
The noble lady has kept saying, and so has the government, that this issue is quasi-judicial. Would she explain why a judicial decision was made in the Scottish courts about a year ago? The duty of the government is to make a factual decision taking into account a judicial decision already made. That cannot be regarded as quasi-judicial.
Speaker 20
I answer the noble Lord with some degree of trepidation because I know of his great expertise in this matter. And my understanding, and I have been told categorically by officials, that it is quasi-judicial because given the range of factors that the Secretary of State has to take into account on this, that that could be opened up to a court challenge. But I am happy to further explore this matter so that in future I give a more adequate legal answer to the noble Lord.
Speaker 49
My Lords, may I ask a very simple question of the noble lady the Minister?
Given what my noble friend Lord Moynihan said about what the OBR has stated, can she confirm therefore that if Rosebank does not go ahead, the government's fiscal headroom will be much reduced?
Speaker 19
Well, the OBR will have to republish the figures if Rosebank does not go ahead and it will need to be addressed.
Helene Hayman
Does the noble lady the minister agree with me that perhaps noble lords opposite should be a little more careful and a little more nuanced in their interpretation of the OBR report? They did indeed, for the reasons that the noble baroness set out, include both Rosebank and Jackdaw in those assessments, but the overall assessment was that receipts from the North Sea or revenues and taxation would decline as they have over the last 20 years in the next five years almost to zero. So isn't it really important that we concentrate on the future and could the noble lady the minister tell me what progress we're making, and it was mentioned in the papers and the budget, to that important issue that would save consumers money, delinking the price of electricity from the price of gas?
Speaker 19
Can I thank the noble lady for that, for pointing out that that is what the OBR actually says about, well, because there is a discussion going on across the benches at the moment and we will return to that no doubt if there's disagreement about it. But my understanding, I share that understanding with the noble lady and that's what I have been briefed on. She's absolutely right about the importance of delinking because fundamentally, and we all know that the North Sea is a declining basin, we all know that's something we have to come to terms with. I understand the politics of what the Conservative Party are trying to do here, but as I've often said at this dispatch box, the front bench of the Tory Party are in utter denial about what we face in terms of climate change and as a country, and as a country we have to come to terms with it. And I can just point out there are some nods on your own benches that agree with that.
Speaker 20
You are in utter denial. I said before, I think it's a dereliction of duty not to address, not to, and you've broken the consensus on it and not to address the interests of the British people on that matter. And that is why our move to clean energy is so important and that is why delinking is so important. As I said earlier, the price of electricity was around 90%, was determined by 90% and now it's 60% today and the Chancellor yesterday did reference the contracts for difference process that will keep us maintaining that momentum to delinking. It is fundamental to our policy going forward.
Natalie Bennett
My lords, a lot of the focus on the Rosebank decision has been on climate change naturally, but this is a development at a depth of over one kilometer, the deepest ever proposed on the UK continental shelf. The remote location, the depth and the harsh Atlantic conditions make it a very difficult site. A major oil spill could have serious impact on at least 16 UK marine protected areas. Can the noble lady reassure me that that is really seriously being taken into account?
Speaker 20
I'm afraid I'm going to have to disappoint the noble lady because I just do not want to be dragged into any detail about the decision. I will absolutely assert that when the Secretary of State makes her decision, she will be given a range of information that I know that she will read carefully and study carefully. She will make the decision in the round and that will address that.
As I said to the noble Earl Russell, those issues are on the record in this House.
Speaker 51
My Lords, I don't know about other noble Lords, but I would welcome a little bit of financial context on this following the question by the noble Lord, Lord Bridges. When I look at the OBR document, it's very hard to understand what the financial difference is. It refers to the with Rosebank a 10% decline in revenues over the period and without it a 14% decline over the period. Could she tell us what that means in terms of pounds and pence over the financial forecast period?
Speaker 20
I was going to say thank you for that question. I don't know if I do to be honest. The OBR does not actually have forecasts. It does recognize the tax, the potential tax receipts for Rosebank, but it doesn't actually give pounds and pence forecasts for it.
Speaker 58
Its quasi-judicial nature has been shown to be a quasi-excuse by the noble Lord over there. I can assure her, having taken quasi-decision, judicial decisions, they don't need to take a year. And if the government decides that it is illegal under the present law to go ahead with Rosebank, why doesn't it change the law and as soon as possible?
Speaker 20
I can only assert and state what I have already stated. It is our understanding, my understanding certainly, that this is quasi-judicial. I mean, I'd need to understand some of the points made in greater depth. It did, was raised at the Court of Session. We do not want that to go through another legal process again.
We have to give it proper consideration. That means these decisions take time and we want to be absolutely clear that when a decision is made, it's the final decision and does not end up in the courts again.
Speaker 57
My Lords, we will have a short break before I call the next business. Order, order. Motion for debate, mediation and conflict prevention, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale.
Jack McConnell
Thank you very much. I should start by noting several entries in my, in my Lords' register in relation to work I have done over recent times for the World Bank, for CHD, for Conciliation Resources, my position as a ministerial adviser on soft power and attendance at more than a couple of conferences on mediation and conflict prevention over the past year. I'd like to thank all the speakers who have volunteered to speak in this afternoon's debate. I'm very grateful for your participation and I'm particularly grateful to the Minister who has stepped up to address this important topic in his, in his closing response. I'm also grateful for this opportunity in the ballot to address the escalation in violent conflict that we have seen across the globe over recent years, but also to speak a little about the hope that exists in the efforts that are themselves escalating to prevent violent conflict and what we here in the UK can do to contribute to that.
We face across the globe today the highest number of states involved in violent conflict that the world has seen since 1946. A recent report, Peace Works, by 11 international NGOs based here in the UK, showed that the cost to the world of this conflict is about 10% of global GDP, approximately 16 or so trillion pounds. Nearly 120 million people across the world are displaced today, approximately half of them children. Over 200 million people face humanitarian need as a result of the impact of conflict. Tens of thousands of children are impacted directly by violent conflict every year.
And of course, sexual violence is increasing as a weapon of war after many years when it was being enthusiastically tackled. Just under a quarter of a million people were killed, combatants and civilians, in 2025 as a result of violent conflict. And here in the UK, we face the impact of that. We see increased division, distrust. We also see the impact of displacement from different parts of the world, and of course, disruption most of all to our energy supplies.
And unfortunately, over the last decade, the UK has more than stepped back rather than stepped up into this challenge. We used to lead the world in global thinking and global action on conflict prevention and peacebuilding. Between 2005 and 2015, successive governments took the action that was required at home and abroad, and of course in the multilateral organisations, to make a real difference to action to combat global conflict, to bring about peaceful resolution, and to support those who were trying to implement peace agreements. But there has of course been no refreshing or updating of the conflict prevention strategy of the United Kingdom since the 2016 Building Stability Overseas Strategy. And over that decade, we've reduced our capacity for working both in the multilateral organisations, but perhaps more importantly on the ground in local peacebuilding initiatives.
Our spend on conflict prevention reduced from 296 million pounds in 2017 to 118 million in 2023, and the figures for the next three years have not yet been published. It was noted in an independent report this time last year to commemorate the 25th anniversary of Resolution 1325 on Women, Peace and Security at the United Nations, that there was an increasing gap between policy and rhetoric on the one hand, which was all very positive, not just about women, peace and security, but about peacebuilding and conflict prevention generally, and a gap between that and action and delivery by the UK. Globally, of course, we face enormous challenges, not just by the scale of the conflict, but the fact that a United Nations that was designed for approximately 50 member states in 1946 is increasingly unfit for purpose for nearly 200 states in 2026. But I think there is good news amidst all this misery and violence. We have countries around the world stepping up, stepping into the area of conflict prevention and mediation.
Turkey, for example, joined with Finland in 2010 to establish the Friends of Mediation at the United Nations, and they also are co-chair Friends of Mediation in the OIC and in the OSCE. And they have been involved over these last 16 years in helping to resolve disputes between Ethiopia and Somalia, in supporting the peace process in the Philippines, and of course very regularly in their own neighbourhood, closer to home, engaged with a number of conflicts there.
In Japan, just this year, the new Prime Minister established the International Peace Mediation Unit in their foreign service, and to quote her, to take a more proactive role in peacefully settling disputes in other places. And that I think is particularly significant in Asia, given some of the challenges that take, particularly in Southeast Asia that we see at the moment. And of course Qatar have become both a location and a voice for mediation and conflict prevention since 2004, and they have been involved in several ceasefires and the return of hostages and the establishment of peace agreements and supporting them afterwards. Not least and in particular in recent times in Gaza, but also in the DRC, and on an issue particularly close to my heart, in helping to secure the return of some of the Ukrainian children that were stolen by Russia, many thousands of whom still lie behind Russian lines. The UK established a partnership with Qatar just 12 months ago to take forward this work on mediation and conflict prevention, and I'd be interested to hear from the Minister an update on the progress with that partnership and the actions that have been or could yet be taken.
There's a common thread running through this international action that of course is supplemented by the historic and important work of the Scandinavian states and the Swiss, more recently the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and others. And that is that every mediation, every sincere effort at conflict prevention has three key elements. It has to have sincere dialogue. It has to have a sustained, patient, consistent approach to the mediation itself. And it has to have, increasingly has to have regional ownership, because in the neighborhood people understand the history, the cultural issues, the identity issues that drive many of these conflicts, and who the local leaders might be who could bring about an end to the conflict and sustain the peace.
I've seen this for myself, working with the FCDO and with a number of NGOs with the Philippine national government and with the former Moro Islamic Liberation Front in the Bangsamoro region of the Philippines. Centuries of division between the Catholic population and the Muslim population of the Philippines, decades of armed conflict in Muslim Mindanao, which led to a quarter of a million or so people dying between 1968 and the early part of the 21st century. But in 2014, in the comprehensive agreement for the Bangsamoro, supported by the United Kingdom and by the international community, but led locally, chaired by the first ever woman to sign a peace agreement anywhere in the world as the chief negotiator, in 2014 the comprehensive agreement for the Bangsamoro was signed. And I'm delighted to be able to report, I suppose in a sense, because I've spoken about this process before in your Lordships' House, that in September, just two months ago, in the Bangsamoro region, they held their first elections to the democratically elected autonomous parliament that was promised in the peace agreement, and that those elections have been relatively peaceful, and that the new Chief Minister will be elected by the new parliament tomorrow in Cotabato. The UK has been a partner in that process, just as we were a partner in Colombia, we were a partner, indeed a driver, for the peace process in Somalia, and we will continue, I hope that we will continue to help build the peace in the Philippines, elsewhere in Southeast Asia, and perhaps the Minister might be able to reflect on that too.
The UK has significant assets that we can contribute to conflict prevention and to mediation and peacebuilding across the world. Not only are we, we have that honor, the responsibility that comes with it, of a permanent seat on the UN Security Council. But through our other networks, whether it's NATO or the Commonwealth, our partnership with the European Union, through our considerable diplomatic assets, still one of the best and most respected diplomatic networks in the world despite perhaps some of the cutbacks of recent years.
We have the expertise and the trust, not just in government, but outside of government here in the UK, that so many people feel that they can, or at least they have been able to rely upon. And we must use those soft power assets that we have to be engaged more in the years to come and try to reverse this increase in violent conflict and support those who are seeking peace. That same report, Peace Works, that was published just last month, and in fact was launched here in Parliament by the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Conflict Prevention, Conflict Resolution and Peacebuilding, had five key priorities that the UK could follow. The first would be, and this is a statement of purpose that might seem very obvious, but is not yet, I don't think, up there, up front in the government's international strategy, would be to prioritize prevention and to say that quite clearly and to embody that in the work that we do on an everyday basis. The second would be to energize coalitions.
We've discussed on many occasions, in fact, I think my last contribution in your Lordships' House was about the coalition of the willing to support Ukraine in this time of desperate conflict against the Russian invasion. But we should be energizing other coalitions for peace and supporting and participating where we can. We need to harness the capabilities that exist here in the UK, not just in government, but outside of government, and use those capabilities in the way that can be most helpful. At the same time, and fourthly, to champion local peacebuilders, because ultimately, without local ownership of peacebuilding processes, then those peacebuilding processes cannot be sustained. And finally, in a world where technology is increasingly changing the nature of conflict and violent conflict, we also need to spearhead technology for peace too.
We can use many of these new technologies to help support peace rather than just to deal with war. So my questions to the Minister in securing this debate today would be to perhaps clarify for us the current state of funding and the plans for support from the government for conflict prevention, not just this year, but in the next three years. To say if that funding is going to be maintained in this difficult financial climate, or if there's even a possibility that it might be increased. And will we commit to being a reliable, engaged, long-term partner for those, not just those internationally, those partner countries that we can work with on mediation, conflict prevention and peacebuilding, but also a reliable, engaged, long-term partner for those trying to build peace on the ground and within countries trying to recover from conflict and ensure that future generations have a better future. And will we, ultimately, will we refresh that strategy from 2016 and ensure that we use our assets for the best purposes, but also to the maximum impact as we intervene and take our responsibilities seriously around the world.
We do have that responsibility. We have a historic responsibility, we have a very current responsibility in our role at the United Nations, but we also have an opportunity using the skills and talents, capabilities and passions of people here in the United Kingdom.
responsibility, but we use that opportunity to not just resist and defend from violent aggression and prepare for that properly, which I fully support, but will we also contribute and prevent conflict, contribute to peacebuilding and prevent conflict in a way that will ensure that future generations can live more safely and maximize the opportunities that they deserve. There's been a bit of debate over the last 18 months within the government, outside the government, and perhaps even elsewhere in the world too, about the competition between hard power and soft power. And many countries, not least the UK here in the developed democracies of the world, have had to step up rightly and improve their capabilities in relation to hard power. But I would submit to your Lordships' House that that cannot be at the expense of soft power. That we need to not make this a choice between hard power and soft power, but we need to use smart power.
And it will be smart power that will not just allow us to prevent and deter violent conflict against ourselves or against our allies, but it will be smart power that will allow us to make a difference around the world and ensure that people are able to live in peace. And with that hopefully positive potential outcome to all of this, I'd like to move the motion standing in my name.
John Redwood
My Lords, I'd like to thank Lord McConnell for introducing this debate. There is no more important topic. The world would be a much better place if there could be peace in places today torn by war with the damage, destruction, and the violence that brings. And I agree with a lot of what the noble Lord said about the opportunities for the United Kingdom, the great diplomatic skills, the reach of our diplomatic service, the experience we've gained over many decades and centuries of intervening around the world and where we could, trying to find resolution of conflict, and our own experiences bringing peace out of the very difficult situation in Northern Ireland. But as the noble Lord referred to at the end, one of the reasons the United Kingdom does have a role in the world and is taken seriously is that we do have serious and important defense forces.
And it is most important that they are used with a view to promoting peace where we are intervening or to righting wrongs that can be righted relatively easily by the judicious use of force. And that hasn't always been true in the interventions we and our NATO allies have made in recent decades in different parts of the world. I do hope the government, as it goes through a rather long defense review and discussion about how best to spend the moneys that are clearly needed, will have very much at the forefront of its mind how those forces can be used to deter violence and the outbreak of new conflicts, and how they can be used for expeditionary forces that can make timely interventions where necessary, particularly where those interventions can help create a peace or where they are needed to police a peace which has been brought about by diplomatic process. I'm sure all of us agree that talking and diplomatic compromise is usually better than conflict extending into aggressive war. And we all here believe that politics, particularly democratic politics, should be a benign force, channeling the conflicts and disagreements into words and arguments and resolving them by compromise or votes.
But that won't always be possible in different parts of the world, and that is why we need to choose to spend our moneys on defence wisely and to see how we can best help the world through those places that we have power, through the United Nations, through our senior membership of NATO, and through the Commonwealth and all the associations that brings. So looking at defence priorities, I think it's most important that the government doesn't forget the main priority is to be able to defend these islands and to show that these islands are so well defended that they would be a very hostile environment should any external force wish to intervene. And that must mean strengthening our sea forces and it must mean strengthening our ability to respond to drone and missile attack and to know how to police our waters when we see possible hostile powers looking enviously at our cables and pipes that are such an important part of our economic progress. So please will the government make sure that that is all beefed up and the best modern technology adopted. But when it comes to expeditionary force, we have in the past shown that we have that expeditionary capability and at times it has been very successful.
The Falklands are only free today and the people of the Falklands are only safe in their wish to be British because we had enough expeditionary force on our own to drive out the Argentinian invader and restore order. And it's most important we now keep enough force available in case anybody should change their minds in Argentina about what they might wish to do to try and gain control of islands that are clearly British. And the British forces were very successful alongside the American allies leading the particular operation when Kuwait was liberated, a very good example of a sharp use of overwhelming force to right a very obvious wrong where a country had been badly invaded. But today we have two very big conflicts which are damaging in themselves and particularly damaging for those involved with them with too many deaths and too much destruction of property, but also very damaging to the rest of us economically and because we are morally offended by how they originated. And those are the conflicts in Ukraine and in the Middle East.
And I think we do need to hear from the government a bit more about how they wish to proceed. If we take the case of Ukraine, the war has dragged on for so long and we keep Prime Ministers for such a little time that there have now been five United Kingdom Prime Ministers who've had to respond to the difficult situation in Ukraine. And they have shown complete unity of understanding and purpose. They have all condemned the Russian invasion and the atrocities that have resulted. They have all wished to offer sensible support to the very brave Ukrainians defending their country.
But they have all been very, very clear that we are not going to declare war on Russia, we're not going to commit British forces, we're not going to drag NATO into a conflict with Russia because that would greatly worsen the position and is much against everybody's interests, including the Ukrainians, because it would intensify the exchange of barbarity with all the extra firepower it would bring to the conflict. But that does mean we in the West have a dilemma because we're not going to offer military coalition to beat the Russians, and the Ukrainians fighting very bravely have not yet been able to evict the Ukrainians, the Russians from their territory.
So I'd be interested to know what the latest government thinking is about when and if there is going to be any chance for talking to replace war fighting and for the two belligerents to be brought to the table in a way which might produce some kind of diplomatic answer. It is not obvious how you do it. And President Trump has been much criticised for trying to do it because people thought he was being too kind to Russia, which is not something people want to happen. But it would be interested to know what the United Kingdom and the European Union position on all this is and whether there is any way through, because I think we all feel five years of war is excessive and the the awful problems it's creating for the Ukrainian people are unacceptable, difficult though it is to see a way out. In the case of the Middle East, I don't think the United Kingdom does have a big role to play because it appears that we don't really have serious forces to offer to try and police the sea lanes and to deal with some of the attacks upon our allies in the Gulf.
America has the near monopoly of power that can be committed to that and it is in that sense America's war and we all rest upon what happens in the exchanges between the President of the United States of America and those now leading Iran. But I'd be interested to know if the government does feel there's anything we can do by way of helping our allies in the Gulf and whether they they can see any way forward more likely to be led by local interests there as Lord McDonald was very sensibly saying. But we too are friends of the UAE and Qatar and so forth and these are the places that are most likely to be able to help. And it would be good if we could get our defence forces into a shape where we could play a more significant role in trying to help the restoration of normal shipping in the Gulf and Red Sea area because clearly energy prices and interest rates and other things globally have been driven up by the extent of that conflict and by the interruptions to trade in a world which should have plenty of oil and which is in transition to using less of it, we find ourselves short of it because of a very nasty war. So I would hope that the defence review would come up with good answers on that combination of defending the home base, which I think needs more defence, and on the appropriate expeditionary force for policing commerce and sea lanes and going to the aid of allies.
And it would be very useful to know from the government minister how they can extend the skills and the experiences we've had diplomatically and of governing places that are subject to these conflicts, because the world desperately needs peace, particularly in those two centres of warfare at the moment, and we would all be better off if that could be brought about.
Anderson
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord McConnell on securing this debate. I thank him for introducing it so well and I declare an interest, a non-pecuniary interest, as chair of Intermedate, the charity founded by Jonathan Powell and inspired by the Northern Ireland peace process. Intermedate has engaged for almost 15 years in dialogue with heads of state and armed groups in attempts to resolve some of the most dangerous and intractable conflicts of our time. Some of its successes, Colombia, Mozambique, are matters of public record. The great majority of its work is not, and for good reason.
Speaker 63
Suffice it to say that I am more proud of the achievements of our remarkable staff, led by Clare Judge and Moqbel Ali, than I am of anything else apart from my own family.
Anderson
When this House amended the National Security State Threats Bill this summer to avoid penalising or chilling dialogue between good-faith conflict resolution organisations and designated foreign bodies, it was acknowledging that states do not have a monopoly in conflict resolution. Some of the principles identified by Jonathan Powell in his book, Talking to Terrorists, may indeed be more usefully performed by non-state entities than by governments: dialogue with actively hostile groups, the establishment of back channels, and the taking of calculated risks to build trust. Unlike some noble Lords present today, my experience of international conflict resolution is largely second-hand. I am not out there cutting deals with national leaders or armed insurgents, just sitting in London, checking the kidnap insurance and signing off on the accounts. So I shan't detain your Lordships for long, but I venture to make three points that have struck me with particular force during my eight years with Intermediate.
First, we in the United Kingdom have a very good name for this sort of activity. I'm regularly impressed by the regard in which our diplomats and third-sector peacemakers are held for their influence, their convening power, their trustworthiness, and their moral leadership, including, even perhaps especially, in those parts of the world where we were once the coloniser. When 65% of those polled expressed support in a 2026 Conciliation Resources survey for UK investment in peacebuilding around the world, they were backing a British success story that, with the right support, has the potential for more success still. Secondly, conflict resolution is not some wishy-washy nice-to-have. It is, and here I go perhaps a little further than the noble Lord McConnell, an essential ingredient of our hard power.
Conflict, weak governments, and institutional collapse can create opportunities for terrorist recruitment, regeneration, and expansion, and provide hostile actors with opportunities to undermine UK interests. Integrating early warning intelligence, local partnerships, and international resilience, or institutional resilience, into security planning enables us to anticipate threats and head them off. If our counter-terrorism or containment strategy begins only when a threat becomes operational, we have already surrendered the advantage. Enhanced military power is certainly necessary, as the noble Lord Redwood has said, and a year on the Armed Forces Parliamentary Scheme has left me in no doubt about that. But it can only be strategically effective when accompanied by work at every level to develop relationships, forge compromises, make agreements, and see that they are implemented.
Thirdly, money spent in this field offers remarkable value. Public investment in civilian peacebuilding, conflict prevention, and mediation is minuscule as a proportion of overseas development aid, and barely noticeable by comparison with defence spending. The annual budget of Intermediate would barely stretch to the purchase of a single fixed-wing attack drone or a Patriot missile. If we're serious about boosting our security, our self-reliance, and our ability to respond to and shape international events, then planning for a serious investment in mediation and peacebuilding needs to be a long-term priority, both in our world-class capacities here at home and in local partners who are essential for reach and for delivery.
although after years of the brutal cuts that have been referred to, that would be a good start. We need funding vehicles that are flexible and responsive, partnerships across government and with peacemaking organisations, and returning to where I started,
a political and legal environment that supports the risks necessary to make peace.
Speaker 66
I'm grateful to the noble Lord for securing this timely debate, though I confess I speak with some trepidation given the considerable expertise in this chamber. But as a refugee who arrived in this country from Iran as a young girl because of political violence and religious persecution, and as someone who's stayed abreast of developments in Iran and across the wider Middle East, this is a subject that is close to my heart.
Speaker 65
I've spoken previously on why I think the joint US-Israel attack on Iran in February was an act of strategic folly, the consequences of which we continue to live with. The prospect of a renewed assault on Iran soon after the midterm elections in America and the recent elections in Israel fills me with dread, and illustrates all too well that our collective ability to mediate and prevent conflict is diminishing. While our assessments of the 1945 global order as broken, bruised, or in the process of being bolstered may diverge,
surely those who care about human flourishing and the conditions that support it cannot be content with the current era of disorder and unpeace. From a faith perspective, I certainly find this state of affairs deeply troubling. The Apostle Paul wrote in 1 Corinthians 14:33 that God is not a God of disorder, tumult, or dissension, but a God of peace, order, harmony, and shalom. Some will argue that if you want peace, you must prepare for war.
That logic is evident in last year's strategic defence review, and in subsequent conversations about how we fund Britain's military commitments going forward. Now, I don't deny the utility of military deterrence, and I'm immensely grateful and indebted to our armed forces who risk their lives to protect us. At the same time, I fear the practice of some countries in recent years suggests that we're now moving towards a new formulation altogether,
namely, that if you want peace, you must first wage war. My Lords, that is a dangerous path to tread. It invites a new global arms race, renewed wars of conquest, shrinking trade and prosperity,
and the collapse of the cooperation needed to confront shared global threats. It is a dystopian path that threatens both our God-given human dignity and the very integrity of God's creation. I worry that both the preparation for war and the act of war itself become our principal ways of imagining the road to peace. We need instead, as the Lutheran Archbishop of Estonia has suggested, to take an alternative pathway, namely, if you want peace, then prepare for peace and invest in the instruments necessary to uphold it.
The 2025 strategic defence review was necessary,
Where is the strategic peacebuilding review to complement it, I wonder? At a time of heightened insecurity, we need a focused assessment of whether the UK has the policies, institutions, capabilities, and partnerships needed to prevent violent conflict and strengthen the conditions for sustainable peace. At a time where considerable attention is rightly being given to defense, to deterrence, and national resilience, we also need to examine the other side of the security equation: how Britain prevents conflict, how it addresses the conditions in which violence and instability develop, how it strengthens social cohesion and supports peace before, during, and after crises. A strategic peacekeeping review could bring together the domestic and international dimensions of peacebuilding and consider the contribution of government, civil society, faith communities, business, and international partners. None of this is to belittle steps that have been taken in recent years.
The creation of a 16-person peace process and mediation team at the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office is a welcome step. But how might this capability be strengthened and embedded across government, rather than remaining primarily as an FCDO-led operational function? Rather than undertaking such a strategic peace review and investing in peacebuilding mechanisms, we seem intent on financing our rearmament by salami-slicing the development budget, and in so doing, diminishing our ability to tackle the drivers of conflict in many parts of the world. This is a false economy, and it feels self-defeating. Instead, we should invest in peacebuilding with fresh funding and a more joined-up national conversation than we've had today.
This is an agenda that the church takes seriously. The commitment to peacebuilding is part of our very DNA. We're willing to work together with government and others in creating the conditions in which war and conflict no longer feels like the logical choice or the inevitable outcome. Only last year, the Church of England's Pensions Board established the Global Center for Peacebuilding and Business to respond to the growing global demand for minerals and energy, the expansion of extractive industries into fragile and conflict-affected contexts, the risks that flow from this, and the extraordinary presence and reach of the church in many of those places. In South Sudan, a country where for ordinary people the situation is getting worse and nothing seems to be getting through to the political inner circle, the church continues to be the most trusted and far-reaching national institution, engaged in peacebuilding, humanitarian responses, education, and healthcare.
This role is replicated in other fragile and conflict-ridden countries and underscores the church's commitment to being a force for reconciliation and peace. My Lords, all of this is by way of saying that in today's age of disorder, peacebuilding should be understood not merely as a humanitarian endeavor, but as a strategic imperative to national security, economic resilience, and long-term stability. In a world increasingly focused on preparing for conflict, it's important that we continue making the case for peace and peacebuilding with all due seriousness. Committing to a strategic peace review to sit alongside the strategic defense review would be an important but long-overdue step in this direction.
Speaker 45
My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the right reverend prelate who brings unique experience to this conversation. Could I point her in the direction of the emerging markets and developing economies task force that the Church of England pension trustees are participating in? Because if successful, that project will achieve and deliver investment at a far greater scale than any development assistance from any country ever could, and will unlock the real gains that are needed in developing countries that will see more stability and relates directly to the topic of today's debate. And I'm very grateful to my noble friend Lord McConnell for securing this debate. I think occasions such as these often allow this chamber to be at its best, and so far the contributions this afternoon have proved that to be the case.
Lord Anderson referred to Intermedate, and I thank him for the work that he has led alongside Jonathan Powell with Intermedate. They've done tremendous work, almost all of it invisible and by necessity. And I think that the work that it's done, I've had some involvement with some of it at various points along the way, I've had some amazing advice from Jonathan about the necessity of patience and discretion and building of trust that I think often in today's world of reactive diplomacy too often, where everything needs to be said publicly and responded to instantly, that the work that Intermedate does just proves what can be achieved by taking a slightly different approach. Last night, I had the pleasure of attending an event here to mark ten years since the signing of the peace agreement in Colombia. Former President Santos spoke about the painstaking work, the political risk, and the essential role of the international community and the commitment that is needed to this day to protect and secure that agreement.
When he was asked how the UK had helped, he said this. He said, "The most significant change happened when we instructed the armed forces in Colombia, the Colombian armed forces, to stop killing the FARC." President Santos explained that when the army began to capture fighters to demobilise and to reintegrate them into society, the army was no longer seen as devils by the fighters, and he said that real progress was achieved when the enemy became viewed as people, not to be destroyed but to be defeated. Defeated because you need them to negotiate with in order to bring about a stable peace. There are obviously lessons that can be learned from the Colombian experience, just as there are from other fragile and all too rare lasting peace agreements such as the Good Friday Agreement and Dayton, and they are incredibly fragile and we must protect them at every opportunity.
But there is a warning about trying to learn lessons and apply them directly in different contexts. It is tempting to search for a template, a set of principles to deploy that will guarantee success in other contexts.
But as we all know, each conflict is unique. The motivations, the relationships, the history, the political space, the involvement, and we see this more and more, of neighboring states, the approach of more distant but powerful nations, the presence of hard power, deployment of technology, the characters of the protagonists, they are all different. And instead of the hard work of innovation, of coming up with creative new approaches, combining our defense, our diplomacy, and our development work, working alongside the multilateral development banks and the multilateral systems, too often I see the international community's response is to look to the tools that it used last time, to ask itself which of those it ought to deploy. And this is fine, it is important, it can lead to some success. UN resolutions, increasingly outraged statements, I've done these myself, of condemnation, sanctions, demands for accountability, side meetings and symbolism.
These are all important and they have their place. But issues and places are too often picked up and put down by the multilateral system and by nations. Look at Haiti, there are so many examples where, Sudan even, is picked up and who is holding it close? Who is really taking responsibility for what is happening and saying we're the pen holder, you know, who's saying we have the job of making this better however long it takes? In an era where countries can trade off their relationships, not just with their neighbors, but with US, with China, Russia, Europe, and protagonists can and do ignore the standard toolkit responses.
When agreements work, they're the result of deep understanding and often local leadership. This is especially true in Africa, where one year since the fall of Al-Fashir, we continue to see widespread massacres and atrocities. In Sudan, while high intensity wars in Ukraine and Gaza generate so much news and attention and the massive share of casualties, it is true, it is in Sudan and in Africa that is the deadliest continent for deliberate non-combat violence directed deliberately and specifically at civilians, with women paying a particularly high price. We see non-state armed groups, private armies, Russian mercenaries, extremist terrorist groups, weak states, and communities desperately trying to survive despite it all. And this debate though is about what the UK can and should do.
If the UK and its partners want to help, as I believe we do, we must supplement the statement making with statecraft. We need less reliance on shaky deals, and I say we as meaning the international community, less reliance on shaky deals between warlords and more time given to building long-term resilient civilian relationships that form the foundation of any lasting peace. We saw Kagame and Tshisekedi summoned by the White House to sign a deal. This did not bring about peace to eastern DRC. It's now ravaged by Ebola, it lacks the community trust or the state apparatus to do what is needed.
When I asked President Santos last night what his experience told him would help in Sudan, he gave an answer that I agree with completely. He said the UK should give its time and its attention to the supporters of the warring parties in neighboring countries and further afield, and that we should work hard to support civil society and local civilian leadership. It's low-key, it's unglamorous, it's time-consuming, but it is vital. Trade, transactional approaches, saying we'll bestow or withdraw development assistance or other such gestures, they will always fail. They have always failed.
There is no example of where that approach, so often advocated for, has succeeded. But the UK, as others have said, has credibility in building and sustaining peace alongside others, notably Qatar or Norway, and there are others too. And we must use this well and do so urgently, especially in places where the ordinariness of earning a living, raising your children, seeing out your days in peace is far too often denied and it should never ever be taken for granted.
Speaker 69
My Lords, I join in the congratulations to Lord McConnell, not just for his luck in the ballot, but also for his continuing zeal and determination in trying to focus our minds on these vastly important, indeed giant world issues. Mediation, conflict prevention, peacebuilding, our role in it all, these are very, very big words indeed, covering enormous areas. And at least half our home troubles, which seem sometimes just local matters, are in fact issues which, in a world in which the Chancellor calls global economic storms are coming along, they have their roots in precisely these areas we're trying to discuss today, we are discussing today. And they require strong and respected international and multilateral institutions to handle and calm them down. My Lords, probably the most important of all in the calming down process that is so badly needed is the multilateral agency area, the multilateral agencies and respected fora which are where our global decisions can be reached and the frameworks designed and rules must be established.
Speaker 71
Trusted and respected multilateral bodies must be rebuilt as they were in 1945. People forget that in 1945, with the out of the rubble of the Second World War, we created from nothing, Americans and British in the lead, but many others as well, an entirely new structure of international cooperation. Yet all those postwar institutions, which served quite well for decades in the 20th century, are now in deep trouble. They are the rule-makers, or they're meant to be, and the referees, but they must have respect and some trust if their writ is to run. Obviously we need a new Bretton Woods to shape the financial regulations of an entirely different world than 80 years ago.
We plainly need new trade rules in a far more complicated trade and investment world of supply chains. We need new maritime controls, entirely new subsea and surface. We need overhead and international overhaul in international courts, new insurance systems and so on and so forth. Where are they today, these visions? Where are the equivalents of Truman, Marshall, Maynard Keynes, Dexter White, for instance, although I'm told he had other interests as well?
And they were supported by a dazzling cast of American and British economists, officials, and financiers. National plans and solutions, we've got two a penny, they're coming out all the time. But missing is the other half of the story, the global network, the new international organizations, the shield under which our own reforms become possible and relevant. And where are the new levels of cooperation we need to assume some control over artificial intelligence and of super-intelligent machines that are beginning to think for themselves and have their own agenda? All this, my Lords, all this, my Lords, is ignored or barely reported or discussed in the media or in public policy.
Speaker 72
The spirit of 1945 and those visionaries is plainly needed all over again, but in an even more ambitious form. Without that, of course, we can carry on attacking each other and attacking the nearest targets as well, but we remain the playthings of past economic fantasy theories, swept along in a rudderless craft, a world without rules, without referees, without restraints. Amidst many uncertainties, one thing can be said with absolute certainty, that such a world without the handrails of accepted standards is fatal to the prospects of a nation like Great Britain. To those who shake their heads and say that the required degree of cooperation is politically impossible today, the answer is not so. Political parties may be harder than ever to keep together, but authors like the brilliant Adrian Wooldridge, whose book I strongly recommend, who writes about centrists in all parties needing to come together, is pointing a way to a new kind of revolution.
Speaker 70
The middle ground may sound a quagmire for party warriors from the old ideological set wars, but the new common ground, which is a very different thing, undoubtedly lies ahead. That's where the real revolution is, and those with the real foresight should be concentrating their views. This is the political pathway and style of cooperation in the internet age and beyond. It avoids the traumas of party betrayal, which the press love to play out, but unites society for a common ground. The barrier, of course, is the old left-right battle that grew out of Marx-Leninism versus laissez-faire capitalism and led to unstable ideological stalemate and worse.
My Lords, the moderating instincts of balanced international liberalism ought to be the ones driving global financial stability and restoring free trade, which Trumpism has, of course, plunged into turmoil. They ought also to be the ones who open the gates to closer cooperation rather than a standoff between private funding and public needs in almost every sphere of public policy. I end with one final observation. This is that with the binding forces of the English language still dominating the globe and global trade and our security, and holding together a still-growing Commonwealth network, much incidentally the largest network in the world and the largest network in history, it may be that a new vehicle of thought, action, and hope is about to be born. Let us anyway wait and see.
Speaker 67
My Lords, Lord Campbell-Savours is taking part remotely. I invite Lord Campbell-Savours to speak.
Dale Campbell-Savours
My Lords, I've spent 47 years in Westminster. I've supported conflicts worldwide, most notably in the Middle East and Eastern Europe. But some recent conflicts have caused me to reflect and have cost me dearly. Friendships have been fractured. My view that we have sometimes questionably intervened in matters overseas has been unpopular.
Today's debate is about global mediation and conflict prevention, and I shall concentrate my remarks on the Ukraine and Russia. In 1992, as a Labour agriculture shadow minister, I visited Moscow to investigate our beef export trade. This eye-opening visit gave me an early opportunity post-Gorbachev, Yeltsin was president, to look at developments in Russia. I visited the Duma, NGOs and institutions. The Russian economy was in freefall.
Its proud people, the spirit of Stalingrad, were being humiliated before a civilized world, its administration often riddled with corruption, with many former Soviet apparatchiks openly exploiting the system to survive, their actions often underpinned by reckless acts of official-sanctioned violence. I particularly recall the poverty. To witness a respectable well-clad woman effectively begging over a small table in the street with her meager offerings, a bunch of vegetables, a tin or two, some vodka, to raise money to survive on little pension. She was one amongst many that I witnessed. The currency was in freefall.
My hotel rates 150 rubles for foreigners, five, sorry, dollars for foreigners, five dollars for locals, black marketeers touring the hotels dealing in currency. Russia was in a state of total humiliation and collapse. The political response, suspicion of the West. Of course, totally unwarranted, a complete misunderstanding. The truth being, across our political divide, a hope that their suffering would end and a new Russia committed to democratic values would surface and enter the world of advanced civilized nations.
But it was not to be. As within two years of this period of humiliation, Russia signed the 1994 Budapest Memorandum. It was a treaty born in duress that was praised in aid by the noble Lord Bruce of Bennachie last week. That memorandum was signed by Russia at its lowest ebb. Russia in humiliation never accepted that treaty.
It arguably led to the election of Putin in 1998, a former spook with his visions of rebuilding Russia which appealed to its humiliated peoples. And which brings me to the Putin years. I well recall that day in October 2001 when my noble friend the Lord Robertson of Port Ellen, as NATO Secretary General, met Vladimir Putin, I think it was in Vienna. My noble friend had proposed a working group be established to promote a NATO-Russian relationship, all very welcome. But to be completely undermined by President Bush's calls in the same year for NATO expansion into Eastern Europe.
These Bush interventions were critical as they heralded an end to detente and the revival of a militant Russia where they were seen as acts of hostility.
Russia had relied on the maintenance of a string of non-nuclear, non-NATO barrier states stretching from Finland to Georgia. I, ever suspicious of the West, Russia had followed up with its desperate but ill-considered attempt to take over the Ukraine and of course Zelenskyy was elected on the backlash. It was about this time that I started myself more closely following events in Russia which I follow to this day. Gone had talk of detente. The Robertson-Putin agenda was dead.
We now had an inflexible Russia extending political control, grabbing territory, the Crimea, manipulating populations in Ukraine's eastern provinces whilst provoking a fearsome and brutal response from the Azov brigades, in their case with their history of support for Germany in the Second World War, thus the Russian references to the Nazis. When historians reflect on developments in the Ukraine during its darkest periods, do not underestimate the significance of those battalions on Russia's decision to use them as foil in justification for their invasion of Ukraine. For me, the issue is how should we respond? We now face a future where a Russian leadership, paranoid and challenged, stands in isolation. I fear for the future of mankind in this period of conflict.
A rogue operator in Russia's nuclear military establishment could act in isolation and I well recall with concern the actions of Yevgeny Prigozhin, the rebel commander of the Wagner brigades, a former confidant of Putin who died in suspicious circumstances. Putin himself saw the dangers and it's in that light that the drift into war where Zelenskyy controls the agenda worries me. So now how shall we proceed? A proud Russia is cornered and I suspect seeks a settlement without humiliation. We need an agenda that avoids humiliation for all concerned.
We need to settle this dispute. I've called repeatedly for the UK government to seize the initiative and take on the settlement agenda. In my most recent interventions, I've called for the establishment of protectorate status in eastern Ukraine. There are well-established precedents. A settlement to include much of Donetsk and Luhansk underpinned by guarantees from the major powers to include the United States, Europe and Russia.
I still believe that Russia's future lies with the West. I still believe that Putin, for all his misplaced anxiety, Putin for all his misunderstanding, I'm sorry, can be returned to rational discussion. It's the British who should take the lead, but it's an agenda requiring courage, understanding, wise counsel and risk, an agenda that listens to those of us who take a different view without the name-calling. Thank you.
Tariq Ahmad
My Lords, let me begin my remarks with a simple reflection.
The true test of diplomacy is not how eloquently we respond to conflict, but how effectively we prevent it. And in drawing my attention, drawing members' attention to my interests on the register with the World Humanitarian Fund, the International Communities Organisation, and indeed as a member of the International Relations Defence Committee, the issue of conflict prevention is very close to my heart. May I also begin with thanking the noble Lord McConnell for both tabling this debate, but over many years I saw this as a minister, his passionate advocacy for both conflict resolution and humanitarian affairs. Today, as we confront a world marked by more than 65 conflicts, depending on how you define a conflict or a war, deepening geopolitical divisions and immense humanitarian suffering, the responsibility on all of us, and yes, the United Kingdom in particular, has never been greater. Behind every statistic of a life lost, and we heard harrowing statistics from Lord McConnell, there is a human story: a family displaced, a child deprived of education, a woman subjected to violence, or a community whose hopes for a peaceful future have been shattered.
Having served in government, represented the UK internationally and worked extensively through the United Nations, I've seen both the potential of the delivery and success of diplomacy, but tragically the consequences that comes when you act too late. You know, we were part, the UK, of the conflict resolution between Azerbaijan and Armenia. Perhaps we don't get the credit we deserve. I remember shuttling between foreign ministers, but that was the true sense of British diplomacy: discreet and understated. I've learned that peace is not achieved through declarations alone.
It requires, as the noble lady Baroness Chapman said, sustained political engagement, conversations, crucial trusted partnerships, and above all the courage to keep working when progress seems elusive. Prevention, mediation, peacebuilding are not separate stages of our international responsibility. They are indeed interconnected parts of the same endeavour. The United Nations, an area of clear focus of our debate, was founded on the determination that future generations should be spared the devastation of war. In my view, millions have been failed in this regard.
The founding vision remains as relevant today as it was in 1945. And yes, the UN, as I saw myself, brings together the international community, brings a framework for collective security, supports peacekeeping, facilitates mediation, and gives a voice to nations that might otherwise be unheard. Yet we must be candid. The UN's effectiveness in recent years has been diminishing or indeed absent from the negotiating table. And as the noble Lord McConnell and others have said, we've seen other countries stepping forward: Qatar in the Middle East and beyond, regional players playing their part to ensure that conflicts can come to an end.
When divisions, as I saw myself within the Security Council, prevent meaningful action, the credibility of the international system suffers. Yet my own experience also taught me that multilateral diplomacy has reinforced a fundamental lesson. International institutions, whether we talk of the UN, the ICJ, or the ICC, are only as effective as the political will that sustains them. We need a more responsive, dynamic, agile United Nations, but importantly with the right people who can act as advocate.
Reform matters, but so does the willingness of member states to use the instruments that already exist. One of the most important lessons of diplomacy is that conflicts rarely emerge without warning. Political exclusion, discrimination, the erosion of human rights are often the basis, economic insecurity and the deliberate targeting of communities. Yet too often as a collective, we wait too long. We wait until violence has erupted before mobilizing the full weight of international diplomacy.
This must fundamentally change. Prevention requires investment in early warning systems, strong inclusive governance and the protection of fundamental freedoms. It also requires listening to communities, faith leaders as the right reverend prelate reminded us. And I saw directly the importance of sustained relationships and direct engagement with international partners. Trust built before a crisis in diplomacy is essential.
And my lords, a plea. It applies to my party as well as the current government. We must stop the revolving door when it comes to ministerial change on the global stage. Relationships matter and we must invest in those relationships. Without that, the UK loses credibility.
We have excellent diplomatic networks, international relationships. We have the experience in this house as well. So I say to the minister, leverage those experiences. We have names who have built security and trust. We need to ensure that we get the optimum benefit for the world as a whole.
And the most successful act of conflict prevention, my lords, may be one that the world never notices. Those who have been involved in this have seen it, precisely because that conflict never happened. My noble friend Lord Redford also mentioned the importance of diplomacy, but it needs the strength of all our assets, including defense. So I ask the noble lord the minister, as the United Kingdom previously has and continues to operate in issues such as Operation Prosperity Guardian, what is the current support we're extending in ensuring that places like the Bab-el-Mandeb and the Red Sea continue to be secure despite the Houthis' attacks. My lords, mediation also means that we keep the door open.
It requires patience and political judgment. And when we believe in peace, we must be prepared to do the hard work of pursuing it. Let me emphasize an important distinction: engagement does not mean endorsement and dialogue does not mean abandoning principle, especially when it comes to dealing with conflicts such as Ukraine and Russia. This is where the UK and its regional partners can make a real difference: coordinated diplomatic pressure, ensuring negotiations are accompanied by a realistic pathway to peace. We also must resist the temptation to measure success solely by whether the parties all sat around a table.
It's far more than that. The real measure is whether the process produced meaningful progress, peace and security. A ceasefire can stop the immediate violence. Only sustained political engagement can help prevent its return. Peacebuilding begins long before a peace agreement is signed.
And we must emphasize the importance of women peacekeepers. The UK led on the issue of conflict mediators, creating the very networks of women mediators. Yet with the one exception that the Lord McConnell pointed out, we have not seen women mediators involved in the current live conflicts that we witness. And I also turn to a subject which was very close to my heart. I pay tribute to the noble lord Lord Hague, my noble friend Lord Hague, my noble friend Baroness Hellych on the issue of preventing sexual violence in conflict.
I spent seven years on that. And as far as listening to voices, to affecting change, to bringing effect global change, we listen to survivors, not after the event, but we put them at the heart of our strategy planning.
So I hope the minister can assure me that we will continue to stand by UK leadership and I welcome an update on the international alliance that was created in this respect. My Lords, just to conclude my remarks, the UK's responsibility is immense. I don't subscribe to the fact that we're a middle power. We're slightly more enhanced than that. We're not China or the United States, but we are the United Kingdom.
We have incredible diplomatic networks as has been already mentioned and we need to invest in that, sustain our principled diplomats. Secondly, practice principled consistent engagement, maintain channels of communication. We must be the champions. It's not woke to stand up for women in mediation, it's simply the right thing to do. We must support peace beyond the negotiation table and build effective coalitions.
But above all, we must maintain consistency between our words and our actions. Let me conclude with a reflection drawn from my own experience on the international stage. You know, diplomacy can be frustrating. I served five Prime Ministers and six Foreign Secretaries, I can know it starts at home. Yet history reminds us that conflicts once considered intractable have found pathways towards resolution when political leadership, international engagement and public determination have come together.
We must never confuse the difficulty of achieving peace with the impossibility of achieving it. The UN has a vital role but must be revitalized. Let us therefore move from reacting to crisis towards preventing them, from managing temporary pauses to political settlement. And let our legacy be measured not simply by the conflicts we help to resolve, but also by the conflicts we help to prevent, the lives we help to protect and the generations who are able to grow up in peace.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, I begin the chorus of thanking the noble Lord, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale for introducing, bringing us this debate and introducing it so clearly. And it is a really great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Ahmad, who as we've just heard has maintained an acute focus on gender issues in conflict, something that I would echo the noble Lord's comments of saying that I hope we will continue to see this from our current ministers. And I also note that the noble Lord, Lord Ahmad, did a brilliant job in the recent Lord Speaker's lecture with Dr. Fiona Hill. For those who missed it, it is on YouTube and I can strongly recommend it. Now I'm going to focus on three issues.
The largest one, the first one, is about atrocity prevention, which is of course absolutely crucial to maintaining and restoring peace. Now this is an issue that I've raised previously in your Lordship's House and it is an acutely urgent one. The noble lady, Baroness Chapman, referred to the first anniversary of the El Fasher massacre this week. I was at the commemoration in your Lordship's House of that massacre, an indescribably awful event. And we heard there from a woman who described herself as a child of El Fasher who has lost 40 people in El Fasher.
And of course one of the realities of such massacres today is that she was on the phone to one of the people killed and their children were killed as well just before, hours before El Fasher fell. And if we think about the kind of experience people are going through, we must not forget that. She made a plea, so often heard and so often not delivered, never again. And I think it's worth looking, there's a great deal of academic work being done on atrocity prevention, looking at the simple question of why do leaders choose to engage in mass atrocities?
They do it because the rewards seem greater than the costs. And they end mass atrocities either because they've achieved what they've seen as their goal or because the balance of risks and costs has changed. And that really is where the international community could and should be coming in. What we've seen sadly is that three of the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council to varying degrees have been challenging increasingly the post-war legal order and seeking to weaken the institutions which should be acting to increase the costs of committing atrocities. That means for the middle powers, Canada, Brazil, Japan and the UK, we have a huge and even larger responsibility to act.
Now as the Right Reverend Prelate set out, we have a huge moral responsibility, but there is also a practical outcome of why it is in our own interests to take action. Atrocity crimes drive human displacement, they destabilise entire regions and many would point to the fact they disrupt markets and demand costly responses. I note that the Institute for Economic and Peace Global Peace Index estimates that such violence cost 2.8 trillion in 2025, equivalent to 18.5% of global GDP. Now back in November last year, I put a written question to the then minister, Baroness Chapman, about the staffing level of the mass atrocity prevention hub in the FCDO. That was created in 2022 and as the noble lady told me, that had been integrated into the conflict and atrocity prevention department in 2024.
I was asking for numbers and I didn't get numbers in that written question, so this is a direct question to the noble lord the minister, I'll understand if he needs to write to me. How many people are now working in that conflict and atrocity prevention department? How does that compare to the number of people working in the department 12 months ago and where does the government expect the staffing in that department to be in 12 months' time? Now I ask that in the context of an important report that came out earlier this month from the standing group on atrocity crimes, an independent but very respected group, which published the atrocity crimes review, a comprehensive UK strategy for atrocity prevention and response. Now it, this review concludes that the UK's approach remains fragmented and reactive.
There is no coherent framework to ensure that early warning of atrocity crimes, and there is now a great deal of academic literature and professional understanding of how you can see these crimes approaching. This is not being translated into timely action. There is no comprehensive national strategy, no dedicated ministerial lead and not a clearly identified budget as we've seen from the structural changes I've just referred to. And the review stresses that this is talking about successive governments, it's not picking on any government in particular. The review warns that this is directly affecting the UK's national security, economic interests and has impacts in terms of migration pressures and in the overall application and exercise of the international rule of law.
Acting before the atrocity happens not only saves enormous human costs, it also saves almost enormous economic costs. So what the review recommends is a dedicated cross-government atrocity prevention strategy with clear funding and parliamentary reporting, an independent statutory expert body to assess atrocity risks and advise government and parliament, and a named ministerial lead for these issues, stronger mechanisms to get action. So my question to the noble lord the minister is will the government be seriously looking at this review and responding to it?
Now, I come to briefly two further points, and one, both of these relate to the UK's position in the world. And if we are going to take action, be regarded as a leader, be effective in that action, then we have to, when we make commitments to the global community, to scientific researchers and citizens, we need to ensure that we can meet them. So I note that it's recently emerged that HMS Protector will not be deploying to the Antarctic for the 2026-27 season, which is going to leave the UK without an ice patrol vessel in the South Atlantic for the second year in a row. We last had a vessel, the HMS Protector, in 2024-25 season. The vessel could not sail from Teesside to Devonport this month.
Reports suggest that it has suffered a catastrophic double engine failure. Now, this is a vessel that was taken on in 2011 as a short-term replacement for the HMS Endurance, which had been crippled by flooding in 2008. Now, what this vessel does is it carries out survey and inspections under the Antarctic Treaty and supports the British Antarctic Survey, as well as, of course, taking on more obvious defense responsibilities. Can the noble lord the minister reassure me that by whatever means necessary, we will be meeting our responsibilities to the Antarctic Treaty and indeed supporting the British Antarctic Survey? Now, I come finally briefly to a very large subject, which I can only cover quickly, but the noble lord Anderson of Ipswich spoke quite absolutely rightly about how our diplomats and our third sector organizations have a very good international reputation.
But we are seeing world's views shifting in the view of the shifting geopolitics. I note that the UN adopted a resolution in March 2026 declaring the trafficking of enslaved Africans as the gravest crime against humanity. And of course, the Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottley has launched a new manifesto from Caribbean leaders asserting their moral, ethical, and legal case for reparations. As a report by the UCL Policy Lab and Hertford College Oxford noted in 2024, former colonies are making increasingly vocal demands around the need for reparations from colonialism and compensation for the loss and damage arising from historical industrial emissions. And this, of course, I have to cross-reference the Rosebank debate we were having earlier, and that Rosebank decision will have impact on our international standing in the world, as well as all of the other impacts.
We have traditionally, and some other noble lords have already referred to some very unwise military interventionism, adventurism that we have engaged with with the US in recent decades. Not being Airstrip One is something that we need to think about very hard in terms of our international relations and how we will be treated by the rest of the world. The UK needs to be an independent actor standing up for human rights and the rule of law, and if we're not in that position, then we are not going to be able to be as effective as we could be and should be.
Leslie Griffiths
My lords, a week ago I was taking part in a debate here on the desirability or otherwise of a written constitution. I was put on the speakers' list to follow a slew of learned lords whose knowledge, experience, and fingertip ability to bring out the right quotation and citation was extraordinary and belittling. And this week I'm put on the speakers' list to follow diplomats, politicians, and others who have run the world or been close to people who have run the world.
And so now here I stand, seeking to make as much sense and legitimacy for my being here today as I tried to do last week. Now, we've had all I can call the features in common for both debates, of course, were the noble and learned Lord Anderson of Ipswich. I think this week, I'm so used to you, it's comforting. Last week, it was less so. My lords, I want in my remarks to move from macro to micro.
And those who know me will not need much help to understand that I wish to speak about a country that's very dear to me, namely Haiti, where I lived for ten years and did all kinds of things from microfinance to organizing cooperatives to planting trees to doing it with Haitian people in the fields and in the council chambers and sometimes in the midst of alarmingly hostile situations. I come from that, and that allows me to declare as a possible conflict of interest my co-chairing of the Haiti APPG. I was ordained as a Methodist minister in Haiti. Our two sons were born there in a local hospital with Haitian medical care. So nobody could ever accuse me of being impartial as I share my remarks with you now.
Three items concerning Haiti have come to my attention in the few days since I put down my name to speak. The first was the news that the United Nations has agreed to extend its remit to maintain a gang suppression force in Haiti for a further six months. Secondly, one of the countries providing troops to that force is Sri Lanka. One thousand five hundred of its soldiers have been present in Haiti since June of this year. And then thirdly, a long article in the Spectator by a man called Bruce Gilley under the headline "It's time to colonize Haiti", an article which I found provocative, ill-informed, and malicious.
And that's not untypical of the approaches to encapsulate or describe what's happening in Haiti. Now, time limits me, even the longer time than usual, to just two of those items. Between 2004 and 2007, at least 134 Sri Lankan peacekeepers sexually exploited and abused Haitian children, some as young as eight, boys and girls, anal and oral, as revealed by an internal United Nations report. It's excoriating to read it.
None of these peacekeepers was imprisoned for sexual assault or misconduct or brought to justice. There's no evidence of any credible, transparent, or independent vetting process for troops constituting the present deployment from Sri Lanka. The complete absence of such measures is causing great concern to members of the Sri Lanka Campaign Group, with whom I've been in conversation. Yet 1,500 Sri Lankan soldiers are on Haitian soil again. It's doubtful that many lessons have been learned from the previous dreadful experience.
Indeed, such happenings in Haiti seem to be a regular occurrence. Let's remind ourselves that Haiti suffered an enormous earthquake in January 2010. Over a quarter of a million people died, more than twice the total number of people in Nagasaki and Hiroshima combined. Over a quarter of a million dead, the world made a show of rallying round. The United Nations strengthened what it called a stabilization force to keep order on the streets.
But abusive events seemed to flourish in the chaos of those times. Uruguay was forced to recall five of its peacekeepers from Haiti in 2011 amid allegations that whilst wearing their country's uniform, they were involved in the sexual assault of a young local man. Apart from that recall, even though there is much informal sharing of information that can't be ascertained, no further investigation was mounted. In that same year, an internal investigation conducted by Oxfam revealed that some aid workers, including the charity's Haiti director, used local women, described shamefully as prostitutes, as if they bore some of the blame for what was happening. All they had post-earthquake was their bodies, nothing else could earn them a penny or two, and that they took part therefore in what were called the orgies amongst the development workers under the aegis of Oxfam was a horrid thing.
Amid widespread allegations of a cover-up, details of that 2011 event didn't become public until 2018. The peacekeepers from Nepal, they were accused of being responsible for a cholera outbreak, subsequently proved to the satisfaction of the investigation, which has killed as many as 10,000 in Haiti, which had never known cholera before. Compare the blanket of silence that has fallen on this experience with the publicity given to the incidence of Ebola in Sierra Leone at roughly the same time and in the Democratic Republic of the Congo in more recent times. Then there's Donald Trump, bless him. I paused for effect, didn't seem to get it.
In the 2024 election, he, and please note his vice president too, alleged that Haitian immigrants were stealing and eating their neighbors' pets.
There were no credible reports, police records, or substantiated evidence of pets being stolen, harmed, or eaten by Haitian immigrants. The grotesque Mr. Trump repeatedly referred to Haiti as a shithole country, an adjective which, if he continues on his present course, might become useful to all of us in our attempts to describe his country. He's begun the process of repatriating 300,000 Haitians to the land of their birth, where 10 million are already subjected to poverty of an order it's almost impossible to understand, the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere. Now, those observations on my part that I put together for this, this talk, I call it a charge list. The United Kingdom is a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council.
The United Nations has signally failed to engage with the needs of Haiti. The hundreds of millions of dollars it's poured into Haiti for various iterations of peacekeeping, stabilization, or gang suppression forces represents a downright waste of money of the first order. Can our representative in New York show an interest in these matters and see how a fraction of what has been lost and wasted there could have done immense good in country, in the country I'm referring to? With that, my Lords, I rest my charge.
Hastings
My Lords, I join with all of us in thanking Lord, thanking Lord McConnell for his permanent passion and pursuit on these issues, knowing that he digs away when many of us would rather sleep, and we're very grateful to you for allowing this debate. I also want to thank my dear friend Lord Griffiths of Burry Port for his heartfelt and painful open speech. And many aspects of it are difficult to hear, but in many of our private conversations you've expressed the horrors that you have described well today, and the whole House owes you the respect with which you have lived there, served there, and continue to advocate there. Thank you. I'm so grateful to Baroness Chapman for referring to President Santos, and I will be with him in Cape Town next week Friday.
President Santos will be delivering the Nelson Mandela lecture, the 24th Nelson Mandela lecture, in which he poses the question, importantly, when is silence complicity? He's going to ask us to consider what has happened to our voice. Our voices as nations, our voices as leaders. Of course, he is a Nobel Peace Prize winner, he did strenuous work to bring opposing forces together. And in the other meetings I've had with him around the One Young World event, which takes place in Cape Town next week, which is why I'm there as a trustee of One Young World, he has been strident, as also the leader of the Elders as he is, that the voice is vital to the piercing power of impact we seek to find.
One of the other elders, Desmond Tutu, said if we are neutral in situations of injustice, we've chosen the side of the oppressor. My Lords, that is a very painful thing to hear because I suspect that many of us look at our governmental processes, both the previous government to some extent, but obviously long-serving and honourable ministers who saw out many who found the exit door, but even this current government and wonder where is the voice. To what extent are we silent in the face of evil events? Albert Einstein reminded us the world will not be destroyed by those who do evil, but by those who watch them without doing anything. And maybe the minister might reflect on to what extent are we watching but not commenting, are we seeing but not speaking, are we afraid to express our voice in public?
Nelson Mandela reminded us that in the end, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends. I was thinking about the last time there was a governmental conference on one of the most difficult and intractable wars currently underway, which is Sudan, probably the most vile of all of the wars that are underway. And we have to give credit to the former Foreign Secretary David Lammy for holding a conference to address those concerns. But subsequent Foreign Secretaries, certainly to my awareness, have not done so. And the point that was very ably made by Lord Ahmad is if we keep swapping around Foreign Secretaries, Defence Secretaries, ministers who are meant to carry memory, and the memory should help us to continue mature conversation and should enable us to make better decisions, if we simply constantly refuse to listen to hear because the voices have gone silent, then we are complicit.
And we must ask ourselves why. To what extent has Britain lost its backbone? I was noting to students that I have a joy to teach in an American business school last night, I teach them online of course because I couldn't have got from there to here to be here for this debate, but teaching them online, I was pointing out to them an article that appeared in a very local Carolina newspaper, South Carolina newspaper, by the former executive director of the World Food Programme, David Beasley. It appeared on the 20th of October. He's a great personal friend and I was pleased that the university I represent gave him the Stephen R. Covey Leadership Award just three years ago for his life of principles.
In this article, David Beasley, who was also a winner of the Nobel Peace Prize for his exceptional work leading the World Food Programme, takes the question to the very heart of what I want to think about. And this is the title: Before America can be great, she must be good. And he's currently running a campaign called Make America Good Again. Now that's not our business. It's not the business of this House or the House down the corridor, but it is a very important point.
I listened intensely to yesterday's, may I say, tinkering budget.
Some may have loved it in every bit, but I've gone through the budget book this morning. I've looked up what is said about foreign affairs, what is said about defense, and what is said about conflict resolution. Helped, I must say, by AI a little bit, especially the words conflict resolution. Nothing. Nothing.
A lot is said about, quite rightly, 10 billion for Ukraine and acquiring of weapons and structural systems, but not about conflict resolution. Maybe we've given that up, buried away somewhere in the Foreign Office, Foreign and Commonwealth Office, as a, we don't know how many, group of civil servants beavering away advising ministers, but we don't know how many and we don't know what they're saying. And we don't seem to express stridently a voice on the global stage that really matters on these issues. I'm going to say something dangerous, which is that the United States President has invited the Russian President to attend the G20, which will take place in the United States. I hope every grown-up European politician and our own Prime Minister will take that as an opportunity for dialogue and will not run away in order simply not to be seen to have communication, to shake hands, and to be present.
That's an easy response. Trust between opposing powers is only built when we meet. I also spoke to my students last night about the work of Menachem Begin and Anwar Sadat. 1977, 1978, of course everyone in this house remembers that because we were all around and very old at that stage. But we all remember the very, okay, maybe, maybe not, but let's allow youth to speak.
But we all remember what it took for President Carter to sit for 23 days with Menachem Begin and Anwar Sadat at Camp David to discover a peace between Egypt and Israel that has held to this day. The same can be said in Northern Ireland, as it could be said in South Africa. Whether we like it or not, dialogue is essential, even with opposing people, powers, and those with a vile disposition as we see it. I'll be meeting President Santos next week for the third time. I've been in Colombia three times, and the last time I was in Colombia, I went to Medellín, which is, as you know, the town in which Pablo Escobar managed to conduct his vile campaigns of police corruption, army corruption, and destruction.
I witnessed 20 women telling stories about the killing of their husbands and sons. And then I witnessed 20 of Escobar's men step forward to apologize. That necessity of facing what we don't want to hear and dealing with others because we must is what I call heart power. We say a lot about soft power and hard power, but we need heart power to solve conflicts and to bring people together. And that requires guts, and I hope the Minister has it.
Speaker 79
My Lords, it's always a privilege to follow my noble friend Lord Hastings. He is the last of people who could be accused of remaining silent in the face of injustice. He has been to the forefront in so many cases and I agree very much with what he has said and also in his words about Dave Beasley, who I had the privilege of working with when Minister of International Development at the World Food Programme, does an immense work there. I also thank the noble Lord Lord McConnell and I join others in doing so for initiating this debate. No one in this place has done more over the years to advance the agenda of stopping wars and saving lives than him.
And we owe him a great debt of gratitude, not just for the work that he does here in this place, but as we've heard in his introductory remarks, the work that he does around the world doing just that. I wish to place on record my interest as a qualified mediator with the International Mediation Institute and serving as an officer with the All-Party Group on Sudan and South Sudan. Peace-seeking and peacemaking are never popular. In the short term, everyone wants to be a Churchill, no one wants to be a Chamberlain. Yet in 1954, Winston Churchill became so deeply concerned about President Eisenhower's refusal to talk to his Soviet counterpart amid rising tensions that he went to the White House to tell the President publicly, jaw-to-jaw is better than war.
Eisenhower listened and agreed to hold talks which temporarily diffused the tensions. Often we're unable to meet jaw-to-jaw on our own and we require an intermediary, a trusted mediator or a mediating institution to bridge the gap and facilitate the dialogue. When both sides are shouting, no one is listening. Mediation doesn't compel us to agree with our enemy, but it does require us to listen to them, and they to us, and for both sides to do so respectfully. I recall 1994 being the most junior of bag carriers to the Security Minister in the Northern Ireland Office when messages were being received about a possible ceasefire.
But the experiences of the terrorist atrocities and the lack of trust and a deep suspicion meant that we couldn't bridge that chasm on our own. It was not until President Clinton sent Senator George Mitchell as a gift, as an envoy to Northern Ireland later that year, that we had someone who would stand in the gap for us and form a bridge for us for mediation which led to the Good Friday Agreement. There is nothing weak about negotiating that agreement. It was done with huge political and personal risks by all of those involved, but it saved hundreds if not thousands of British lives. It's so much easier to throw a brick or build a wall than it is to build a bridge.
Easier to raise a fist in vengeance than it is to extend a hand in forgiveness. That's easy for me to say. I've never lost family members in war, been a victim of violence. Erich Fromm on the other hand was a German Jew, one of the greatest psychoanalysts of the last century. He was living in Frankfurt when the Nazis came to power.
He narrowly escaped the Holocaust, but his members of his family did not.
He had every reason to be filled with self-righteous hatred and judgmentalism. But instead, he wrote a small book called The Art of Loving, and I want to quote some of it here today. It, the quote begins. The lack of objectivity as far as foreign nations are concerned is notorious. From one day to another, another nation is made out to be utterly depraved and fiendish, whilst one's own nation is everything that is good and noble.
Every action of the enemy is judged by one standard, every action of oneself by another. Even the good deeds of the enemy are considered a sign of particular devilishness, meant to deceive us and the world, whilst our own bad deeds are necessary and justified by our noble goals which they serve. The faculty to think objectively is reason. The emotional attitude behind reason is that of humility. End of quote.
In a world where nine men have at their fingertips enough nuclear weapons to destroy all life on this planet many times over, our only hope is human reason. But Erich Fromm reminds us that reason is built on objectivity and humility. The capacity to reason that we see things not as they are, but as we are. Where we sit determines where we stand. We don't see the whole picture.
We may be wrong. Our enemy may even have a point. Let me illustrate this. I follow Newcastle United Football Club. Thank you.
As you can tell, I'm an optimist. Even my blood group is B positive, that helps. But when I'm at St James' Park and I'm watching a game from the stands, the minute one of our players just trips over a shoelace in the opposition box, 50,000 fans rise as one to call for a penalty for such an obvious and devious foul. Yet when the opposing player is flattened by big Dan Burn in our box, the crowd rises as one to call it a clear dive, which deserves nothing but a yellow card for simulation. When I watch the game at home on TV, I see multiple different perspectives, replayed endlessly at slow motion from every angle.
And then we have them assessed by a referee and a linesman, independent commentators, and we see things differently. We see things perhaps more objectively. The point being that we live in a Westphalian world of sovereign independent states, where each state is its own referee. We call events as we see them. But then so does everybody else.
Speaker 80
We believe we are right. But then so does everybody else. We believe all our actions are just. But then so does everybody else. It is a system designed for chaos and conflict.
Speaker 79
Yet with our incredible human ingenuity, we have designed mediating institutions to compensate for our human weakness, chiefly the United Nations, to act as a bridge between sovereign states and within states to maintain order and over which they can seek to mediate their differences. When we uphold the United Nations, we are upholding international order. When we attack or undermine it, we are destroying the critical infrastructure on which the very future and hope of civilization depends.
I believe it's no coincidence that today we are seeing armed conflicts at their highest level since 1946, when at the same time great power rivalries are undermining the United Nations at every turn and cutting its budgets. In international relations, as in life, you get what you pay for. Global military spending last year was three trillion dollars. That's one thousand times the budget of the UN. The entire peacebuilding budget of the United Nations to respond to 65 active armed conflicts around the world is 124 million dollars, less than the cost of a single modern fighter jet.
We could mediate an entire peace process for less than the cost of a single cruise missile. Moreover, we are blessed in this country with some of the most skilled and respected diplomats in the world. The convening power of London is second to none. We are a soft power superpower, but that superpower is hard power. We have also been the beneficiaries of peace and patient mediation in Northern Ireland ourselves, and that imposes an obligation on us to repay it by mediating for others.
It's in our own self-interest to do. Around three quarters of those arriving in small boats in this country were from areas of conflict abroad. We are more secure at home when there is peace abroad. We are more prosperous too. Peace is the greatest generator of prosperity humans have ever discovered, and war is the greatest cause of poverty.
The Prime Minister and the Chancellor told us yesterday that they are seeking opportunities to invest for growth. My message to them is simple: invest in peace.
Speaker 81
It's an honor to follow the noble Lord Bates and thank you for that contribution. We have the privilege of catching the bus home together occasionally, and on Monday we discussed his recent trip to Sudan, which was fascinating, and this upcoming debate, which we were much looking forward to, and I don't think either of us have been disappointed. I might disappoint some people now, but up until now we have not been disappointed. My thanks to my noble friend Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale for securing this debate and for other noble lords for what has been a fascinating and broad-ranging set of contributions. I point to my register of interests and the work I do at the Good Faith Partnership in some of the work that I'm going to talk about next.
Speaker 83
Around the world, faith leaders are often on the front line of peacebuilding. From them we can learn that religious diplomacy can reach the parts that governments struggle to reach. And in my honest opinion, there are some false and lazier assumptions that sometimes prevent us from harnessing the power of faith for mediation and conflict resolution, and that's what I want to talk about today. One false assumption is that relationships, the relationships of faith leaders, are largely held with other religious people. It's not true in Western countries, often our faith leaders are the most well-connected people across different sectors and the range of society, and it's certainly an irrelevant assumption in much of the world where more than 80 percent of people say that faith has a role in their own personal identity.
Speaker 82
I am really grateful to the right reverend prelate, the Bishop of Chelmsford, for highlighting earlier the role of the church in the work of mediation and conflict resolution, and I hope what I say next will bring more power to your elbow, Bishop. Lord Bates rightly said that London has a remarkable convening power, and my noble friend Baroness Scotland hosted earlier this year a group of Christian-Muslim leaders, senior religious leaders from Nigeria, prior to a peacebuilding summit that was hosted and convened in London by a former colleague of ours, Bishop Justin Welby.
Speaker 83
Those leaders were all at one time opponents of one another, and some of them enemies of one another. And over the last months, starting in that event here in London, they have started to build relationships and plot paths to peace in parts of their country where conflict is rife. My noble friends, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale and Lord Griffiths of Burry Port, both made it clear in their interventions that local ownership is essential for successful mediation. And those Nigerian leaders would have been clear, and are clear, that there are only really Nigerian solutions for Nigerian problems. Coming to London doesn't put things right.
Speaker 82
However, what we have learned from this experience is that the support of our government and the US government in helping to enable and empower those leaders to take a role in their community has been more than powerful. My thanks to my noble friend, Baroness Chapman of Darlington, who addressed the leaders when they came to your Lordship's House in her role as minister. I'm grateful for the, for Minister McNeill, the new Minister of International Development and Africa, who confirmed her support for the government working with these faith leaders in Nigeria only this week. And I'm particularly grateful for David Smith MP in the other place, who is our envoy, our UK envoy for freedom of religion or belief, who has worked really hard with these faith leaders to encourage them in the work that they are doing in their own country. We met recently again in Abuja in Nigeria, and again received great support from both the British and the US embassy, with the High Commissioner and the US Chargé d'Affaires attending and engaging in the discussions.
And while conflict is not going down in Nigeria, sadly, in large parts of the country it is rising, these discussions, wherever you go, are a cause for real hope and, most importantly, for real practical action. A path to peace is being laid out by these leaders. Far from only engaging with other people of faith or other faith leaders, these leaders in Nigeria are demonstrating an extraordinary capacity to build relationships both wide and deep. Together they can engage those people who perpetrate violence. Together they can engage those people who are in danger of being drawn into violence.
Speaker 81
And together, sadly, they have to engage the victims and survivors of violence. I would obviously encourage the government to continue its support for the work of those faith leaders in Nigeria, but I would also ask that we explore what are the other regions in the world where religious diplomacy might be a route to help us support mediation and conflict resolution. Following that false assumption, I want to raise a lazy assumption, and that is the assumption that faith is more responsible for conflict than it is peace. We don't have to go long into that right now, but more often when religion is blamed for these conflicts, it's a false or a thinned depiction of that faith, often through radicalisation and extremism. Exploited by others, these false depictions become something that adds to conflict and local tension.
Speaker 83
And in these situations, faith actually isn't the poison, it's the antidote. Faith leaders have a moral and theological authority to call out bad actors in their community, to influence people to take a different path, to modify bad behaviours.
In Mozambique, the United Nations has worked extensively with bishops to prevent acts of terrorism, the fight against ISIS. Where government lacks sometimes the ability and the authority to ask communities to do things differently, faith leaders provided powerful and practical solutions and over a period were able to significantly reduce the recruitment of community members into extremist activities. In Mozambique, we experienced that authentic expressions of faith can enable mediation and prevent conflict. In 2025, my noble friend Baroness Scotland, who I mentioned earlier, had already met two of the Nigerians who came to London here in September because she had presented Pastor James Wuye and Imam Muhammad Ashafa with the inaugural Commonwealth Peace Prize in 2025. For 40 years, James and Muhammad, 40 years ago, sorry, James and Muhammad were rivals in rival militias fighting, they had been recruited by local extremists and they were waging war on one another's communities.
James actually lost his right arm in the process. But as faith leaders, they've built a friendship. They've become reconciled. They've created an interfaith mediation center and they now run a national network of peace clubs with more than 10,000 members in their country. They are a parable of the power of faith leaders to build lasting relationships, but also to provide moral leadership that changes attitudes and behaviors and changes communities and hopefully one day their country.
Speaker 82
I very much look forward to the response of my noble friend the minister later and I just want to close with two questions for the government. Firstly, I'm so grateful for the ongoing support of His Majesty's government for those faith leaders in Nigeria who are working so hard to build a path towards peace. In Nigeria and other countries besides, David Smith, our FORB envoy, is playing a leading role in helping His Majesty's government to harness the power of faith to build our capacity for religious diplomacy. And at the launch of our freedom of religion or belief strategy at the FCDO in 2025, the department committed to publishing an annual report on the progress made and the impact made in this area. I'm interested to know from the minister when we might expect the first of these reports because it will provide valuable opportunities to recognize, celebrate, and promote the important work our government is undertaking.
And in dark and difficult times, hopefully we can find some good news which is desperately needed. Secondly, the FCDO's Office for Conflict Stabilization and Mediation provides excellent specialist expertise in conflict prevention, mediation, peace process, and stabilization. It works with governments, international institutions, and civil society and only this week a leading actor in this field was lauding their work to me. So I'm interested to know from the minister how this unit can make an even greater impact by working with faith communities and religious diplomacy to draw on their unique relationships, local knowledge, and moral authority to strengthen the UK's impact in preventing and resolving conflict. In closing, let's exercise smart power as Lord McConnell mentioned earlier.
Speaker 81
Let's not be the victims of false or lazy assumptions. Let's recognize the vital role of religious diplomacy in mediation and peacebuilding. Let's recognize the unique and remarkable relational capacity and the moral and theological influence and authority of religious leaders in conflict zones around the world. And let's do all we can to support them as they work faithfully on the frontline of international mediation and peacebuilding.
Malcolm Bruce
My Lords, I want to join everybody else in congratulating Lord McConnell for initiating this debate and for the way he introduced it, because we've had a pretty wide-ranging debate with lots of different perspectives brought into play, which is as it should be and is extremely valuable. At his opening, Lord McConnell said the problem with the government is we've tended to step back rather than step up. I'm glad to say he went on to say there were some more positive things, and I think we should relate to that. But it seems to me the conversation we have is less about peacekeeping at the moment, but actually conflict resolution, because until you resolve the conflict, it's very difficult to keep the peace, and things have been moving in a pretty bad direction. But I think this debate has been extremely instructive.
Lord Anderson, with his role in intermediate, I thought was was fascinating. And I think he he made it absolutely clear, and as did many other speakers have, that it's quiet engagement below the the headlines that can often make the difference. And he quoted some really interesting examples, and I think the work that's been done there is extremely valuable and not to be overlooked, and I'm glad he's brought it to the debate. I think it's also been pointed out that peacekeeping represents value for money, and conflict prevention is value for money. But unfortunately, we're not actually providing the money at the moment.
And the Bishop of Chelmsford, I think she touched on a very powerful point, the right reverend prelate, because she said the concept at the moment seems you have to wage war to secure peace. And that is increasingly the way some of the conflicts look. And it's extremely difficult to know how you can pull them back to say, actually, no, you have to fight for peace. And I think that was an interesting analogy because, as I will come on to say, I think one of the problems we have is too many of the protagonists are not interested in peace. And Baroness Chapman, I think she quite rightly said we shouldn't just reach for the same old toolkit.
Useful as it may be, we have to recognize in a changing world we're going to have to find different ways of doing things, and that increasingly it's not just about states but also non-state actors, and that sometimes we've got to invest in the long term. And I think the point I was cited by Lord Campbell-Savours, whose intervention was not unexpected. But I think the point, I don't wish to discredit his own genuine view, which isn't widely shared, but it's one he's come to on his own basis. I'm not suggesting he's an agent for anybody else. But the reason I raised the Budapest Memorandum is that he's looking for a solution which will require the same guarantors who haven't honored the original memorandum.
It's difficult, therefore, to see how you can get a settlement that can be trusted, which is really the problem we face. So I would really pick up particularly what Lord Hastings and Lord Boateng said was that we have to engage with people we don't like. We have to take the criticisms as to why we are talking to them, and we have to do it both publicly and privately and extensively. And we have to be more objective. And I think those are really, really powerful arguments, and I think all the best peace outcomes have actually always had that characteristic to make them happen.
So perhaps a point to make is that, as Lord McConnell made in his opening remarks, conflicts have proliferated to the extent that we have the highest level and number of conflicts since the Second World War currently in place.
Now the worst ones are clearly Sudan, the Middle East and Gaza, with none showing any capacity for peace interventions, and of course Ukraine. And I'm afraid, as Lord Howell said, the UN's current weakness is revealed for all to see. Much of this is exacerbated by the disengagement of the main players on whom the UN depends, notably Russia, the US and to a lesser extent China. So the UK, which supports peacekeeping and conflict prevention and resolution, has actually cut its funding to peace initiatives. I just checked the figures for the International Security Fund: the current year 854 million pounds, next year 545 million pounds, the following year 499 million pounds and the year after that 471 million pounds.
That is the government's financial commitment to peacekeeping declining. It's not all about money, I accept that, but it is, I would suggest, a movement in the wrong direction. So if we look at some of the conflicts in Sudan, I find it slightly extraordinary with Saudi Arabia supporting the Sudan Armed Forces and the UAE supporting the Rapid Support Forces. They are also half the mediating quad with Egypt and the United States. It's difficult to see progress or even the capacity to prevent the most appalling atrocities and humanitarian abuses when the mediators are also protagonists in the process.
And the UK is the penholder, so one question to the minister is: to what extent can we in that exert some pressure? We had an earlier question about aerial bombardment in Sudan, which has been perpetrated as extensions of two of the outside players. What can the government do to put pressure on those two players to stop these atrocities and to pay a price if they don't, as my noble friend Lord Purvis called for in the question? And if in the Middle East, we've just had, we haven't had the results of the Israeli elections, but Prime Minister Netanyahu has escalated assaults in the South Bank and Gaza, and he's been actively encouraged to do so by the White House. Well, I'm not quite sure who is encouraging whom when President Trump described him as a warrior Prime Minister, which is supposed to be a compliment.
We're talking about peace and we praise a warrior Prime Minister. Both sides in the Middle East are now promoting single-state solutions, turning their backs on the two-state solution that's the only thing that offers long-term peace and stability. And we still mustn't abandon our aspiration to get there, however difficult it may be. Tony Blair commented after the Belfast Agreement, when he was made envoy for the quartet, that it was ironic that there was no agreed long-term solution to the division of Ireland, but peace had been secured, whereas there was an agreed and viable long-term solution to Middle East peace and there was no peace. And in the midst of this current situation, Trump and Netanyahu have started a war that they don't know how to end.
Now in Ukraine, we have equivocal support for Ukraine, not from us, but from the United States or from the White House, I do see the difference, and pressure to end the war by surrendering.
And it's no longer just equivocal support, it's now switched to outright support for Putin's Russia, with Trump's envoy Witkoff describing Putin as humanitarian for releasing one US prisoner. Well, that might be welcome, but ignoring the daily slaughter of Ukrainian civilians by Russian drones and missiles, aggravated by the United States' degrading of Ukraine's defense capability. So it's really difficult to see how we can get out of these situations while the main players are behaving in this way. It almost has to be observed that they don't want peace, they just want their side to win at all costs. Now, how on earth are we supposed to respond to this?
We must, of course, support the United Nations, and we must support initiatives that may fly. But when President Trump seriously nominates Viktor Orbán as the candidate to be Secretary-General of the United Nations, it really is pretty obvious we're going to have to look for the time being to other ways of promoting peace. These conflicts, the ones I've referred to, frankly are promoted by misogynistic leaders with the characteristics of bullies and cowards. And the UN recognized in the year 2000 with Resolution 1325 that lasting peace required the active participation of women. Yet precisely because so many of these conflicts are about power and control by men, they are still too often ignored whilst mobilizing humanitarian relief and exposing abuse is all that we're left with.
Yet, as has been said, women played a key role in the Northern Ireland peace process, and women are conspicuous in the fight for Ukraine's survival. So I guess we're talking about the United Nations, international community, what is the role of the UK? And I can just finish by saying this: we need a reset, a SWOT analysis to see what our strengths are and to deliver them on a priority basis, and I recommend and ask of the Minister if that would be considered.
Speaker 85
My Lords, I'd like to join with other noble Lords in thanking the noble Lord, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale, for initiating this really important debate, and the contributions from all other noble Lords. Throughout the course of the debate, there are a number of points that have sort of appealed to me and have struck a chord. Funny enough, it was noble Baroness Lady Chapman who talked about trust, and her predecessor, Lord Ahmed, who talked about relationships. We're talking about smart power. We're talking about regional ownership, local peacebuilders, and the importance of moving quickly on mediation when conflict occurs.
But none of this will actually proceed unless there is the political will for it to succeed. So this is the whole debate has been looking at how the contributions from different sectors can actually push more mediation and prevention of global conflict.
My Lords, we live in an increasingly dangerous world. It has been said many times in this House, but in a debate like this, I think it is right that we reflect on the conflicts we are seeing all over the world, as noble Lords have. Whether it be in Sudan, in the Holy Land, in Ukraine, in Saudi Arabia and Yemen, in Iran, in Myanmar, in Pakistan and Afghanistan, or in the Philippines. It seems almost wherever we look there's conflict, as mentioned by many noble Lords, including the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, and my noble friend Lord Bates. 2023 saw 65 active state-based conflicts across 35 countries, the highest number recorded since 1946.
Indeed, there are many more places in the world today that seem to be in tension to an extent that threatens conflict. The appalling scenes in Ceuta earlier this year showed the threat illegal migration poses to countries across the world. And in France, internal disorder has seen the mass destruction of livelihoods and public buildings. Every one of us, my Lords, wants to see order and peace in every part of the world, and His Majesty's government should continue to use all the diplomatic tools available for it to work towards that goal. My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, has highlighted the importance of mediation in his motion today.
And we're particularly well-placed as a nation to support mediation. We are a nation that respects the rule of law and is known the world over for our respect for fairness and, as other noble Lords have said, our diplomatic service. But Britain today does not have the global reach it once had, and we must reflect on that. When the noble Lord the Minister replies to this debate, can the noble Lord comment on the reality of Britain's role in our increasingly unstable world and say what specific steps his department is taking to promote peace and an end to conflict across the world? And in particular, my Lords, can he say what work his department is doing towards a stable and long-lasting two-state solution in Israel and Palestine?
As a member state, Britain supports the work of the United Nations in promoting peace and stability through its Peacebuilding Commission, the Peacebuilding Fund, and Peacebuilding Support Office. I understand that this structure has recently been reviewed. Can the noble Lord the Minister say whether the United Kingdom fed into that review process, and if yes, what submissions did we make? I'd also be grateful, my Lords, if the noble Lord could comment on the broader challenges faced by the UN, not least as a result of the fact that Russia, a permanent member of the Security Council, is pursuing an illegal war in Ukraine, and what is His Majesty's government's position on that? My Lords, on UK funding for the UN, we have contributed 630 million pounds per year for the last decade.
Can the noble Lord the Minister say whether the government intends to continue that level of contribution or increase it? And further to that, my Lords, can he say what work his department is doing to ensure that funding is going to the right places? We have all followed with interest the controversy surrounding the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East. Can the noble Lord the Minister update the House on the government's assessment of the situation at UNRWA?
But mediation after conflict has begun is not enough, my lords. Constant engagement, rebuilding and trade across cultural divides has an important role to play. Can the noble lord the minister say what work ministers are doing to promote constructive engagement between nations in conflict areas across the world? The harsh truth, my lords, is that when conflict occurs, there is often a call for more direct intervention. Peace cannot always be achieved through mediation and international cooperation alone.
We saw that in Sierra Leone, where a total of nearly four and a half thousand British personnel were deployed in country. We must not forget the five dedicated British military personnel lost their lives in that conflict. We saw it again in the Balkans, where tens of thousands of British troops served as part of the NATO-led peacekeeping mission. A total of 72 British armed forces personnel died as a result of those operations in the Balkans, including Bosnia, Croatia, Macedonia, Kosovo and Serbia since 1992. We should remember their service too, my lords.
Diplomacy is essential, but without hard power, as mentioned by other noble lords, Britain cannot play a full role alongside our international allies and partners. That is why defence spending is so important, and why it was disappointing to hear the Chancellor of the Exchequer fail to set out a clear plan to hit the 3% of GDP spending target on defence yesterday. The budget was in many ways an exercise in avoiding the tough decisions that we expect ministers to tackle, and that was true on defence. Not only are we still waiting for the 3% spending plan, but the Chancellor has been accused of stealth cuts to the defence budget by diverting pensions savings to the Treasury rather than the defence budget. The situation we are in on defence spending sends the wrong message to our allies, and it's really important to get that message right.
My lords, overall this debate has been entirely, has really been informative. It's given much food for thought, and I really look forward to the response from the noble lord the minister.
Speaker 35
Well, my lords, I'm very grateful also to my noble friend Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale for securing this debate and for the way he opened it with his experience, with his reflections and his wisdom on this broad issue. And I pay tribute to his work as co-chair of the All-Party Group on Conflict and Peacebuilding, and to his long personal commitment to peace in many parts of the world, and particular in Mindanao, which he spoke about. I thank all noble lords who have spoken today. I think it's a debate that's brought not just experience of diplomacy, of negotiation and of the slow challenging work of building peace on the ground, but a sense that peacebuilding is not the work of governments alone. In fact, sometimes governments are not the best placed partners to make progress, and I'll come back to some of those points in a minute.
And I'll try to respond to as many points as I can, apologies if I don't get to everything, but I will come back to you if I don't. I'd particularly like to start to endorse the noble lord Lord Ahmed's point that we should stop the revolving door of ministerial appointments. I couldn't agree more. I think we should start that right now. My lords, we do meet at a sobering moment as many noble lords have said.
As noble lord Lord McConnell said, noble lord Lord Courtown said, there are more conflicts in the world today than at any time since the Second World War.
I think the figure Lord McConnell used was a quarter of a million people in 2025 died in violent conflicts across the world. It's driving terrible humanitarian crises, forcing families from their homes, seeing the most appalling atrocities committed against innocent people. We talked about Sudan earlier on, I'll come back to that in a minute. That's the most egregious example perhaps, but sadly they're all too common. Just last month I was in Ukraine, the noble Lord Lord Redwood mentioned Ukraine, and I was there meeting veterans, families, civil society leaders and others who are enduring a brutal assault on their country.
I went to the village of Yahidne, some of you may know about Yahidne, where residents just after the invasion were held, I think about 400 people were held in a school basement for 27 days. And I was taken around that basement by people who were in that basement for those times, without food, without any lighting, without any provisions, whose family members had suffered, some of whom had died. Ten people died in that basement. In Kyiv I visited a UK-funded centre that is doing the heartbreaking but extraordinary work of tracing children who have been stolen from occupied territories and deported to Russia where they've been adopted by Russian families. So the human cost of this one example I've had in my short time in my job of this war and the incredible courage of ordinary Ukrainians is something I won't forget.
And a few days after that I went to Toronto where I joined over 80 countries at a conference to discuss how to respond collectively to the problems that Ukrainians who are under Russian control face. And there we committed to convene a core group with Ukraine in London on the identification, return and reintegration of citizens from the occupied territories detained by Russia. That is a small example perhaps, but an example of peacemaking, an attempt at peacemaking, the patient often unseen work of getting people home, working with NGOs in the community of nations, trying to secure a just and lasting peace at a time when prospects seem pretty bleak, and using international law to do so. But I do take the Lord noble Lord Lord Redwood's point seriously on the need to have a hard-headed strategy to go along with that. And to put it in a nutshell, our strategy is to raise the costs of conflict for Russia so that they are forced to come to, reluctantly perhaps, but to come to negotiation and discussion at a time when Ukraine has made it clear, even at some cost to itself, that it is prepared to engage in those discussions.
And I'm pleased to say that we are doing a variety of things from sanctions to incessant diplomatic work to try and achieve that outcome. On prevention, beyond tragedies overseas, we've all seen how the effects of conflict reach our own shores through irregular migration, organised crime, higher costs for families here at home. So prevention is national interest for those who don't look abroad perhaps as much as noble Lords in this debate do with their expertise and interests. And noble Lord Lord McConnell is right that prioritising prevention is crucial. It's a hard-headed choice, it is not a soft option.
Acting early saves lives and it saves money. And mediation, helping those who are fighting to find a way to stop, is one of the most practical tools we have. And I think this is a theme that's recurred in this debate, that prioritising prevention is not a single small group of people sitting in the Foreign Office's job.
It is something that runs through the activities across the Foreign Office and across government departments. It cannot be reflected money money of course is crucial I'll come back to that but it is not reflected in a single pot of money allocated to something called prevention. It is much broader than that and Noble Lord Lord Ahmad who has extensive knowledge of this across six foreign secretaries and five prime ministers rightly talked about the interconnection of different activities peacebuilding prevention peacekeeping mediation. But we have to acknowledge that the world of peacemaking in particular has changed although the Noble Lord Redwood is right we need more imagination in thinking about preemptive action in the way that the UK government should be acting in the future. But peacemaking has changed on the one hand the group of states playing significant mediation roles as Lord McConnell mentioned at the start has expanded.
But some deals as my noble friend Lady Chapman pointed out some deals are short-term and transactional they do not stick they leave the causes and drivers of conflict untouched. Some deals between states have that characteristic as well as deals between non-state actors. And the United Nations has found it much harder to play the role it once did a point many colleagues at Noble Lords have made and that must shape how we think about our role as well. So what is our role and Noble Lord Altrincham rightly challenged me to spell it out I'll I'll put it in three sets of categories three activities or clusters of activities. But before I say that what's very striking is that there was universal agreement I think that the UK for all our faults does have pedigree in this area.
It does have a strong reputation despite some parts of the world thinking we are historically perhaps tainted in some ways we we are someone who we are a country full of organizations and diplomats and experts that does have a positive role to play and that I think we should be proud of and it continues to be true for all the challenges we face. But I'd put the UK strategy in three parts the first is to bring expertise the second is on partnerships and the third is to strengthen and protect the institutions of peace. So let me start with bringing expertise we we rarely lead mediation processes ourselves often because others NGOs other countries faith groups to come back to Noble Lord Lord Rooks point are better placed and more trusted by the parties concerned. Instead we tend to back mediators regional organizations and parties themselves drawing on our diplomatic relationships our influence our expertise back channels and ceasefires. And we have experience sad painful experience as the Noble Lord Lord Hastings referred to Northern Ireland which gives us a mixture of pain experience credibility wisdom which enables us to have some perspective and authority.
And my noble friend Lord McConnell knows this from Mindanao in 2009 at the request of the parties the UK led the formation of the international contact group alongside others like Japan Saudi Arabia and helped pave the way to a peace agreement that has significantly reduced violence. In Colombia which Noble Lord Lord Hastings referred to and he's about to meet President Santos as he said and Baroness Chapman noted in in quite moving detail the role the specific way in which UK engagement actually made a difference in particular perceptions of the enemy that she she talked about at the point of demobilization. Here the UK used its role on Security Council to keep international support behind the peace process. And through our new conflicts and violence community of expertise we deploy specialists on mediation atrocity prevention and conflict-related sexual violence where they're needed. Through our conflict resolution program we have funded expert partners to support dialogue in some of the hardest places to achieve that.
And much of that work is very discreet and is not talked about for good reason because discretion as noble many noble lords have mentioned is an important part of people's keeping people safe and keeping talks alive. And on this issue I want to go back to my noble friend Lord Rooks comments on the role of faith faith-based organizations and faith-based individuals in this area. I always love listening to Lord Rook for some reason it's one of my he's one of my favorite speakers.
But on this- two issues that he raised, the government made a commitment to announce it- when it announced its approach to freedom of religion or belief last year that we would outline a- that we would have a report and I can confirm that that progress- the report that outlines the progress we've made will be presented to the Prime Minister before the end of this- of this year. And on contact between FCDO experts, conflict experts and religious leaders, I'm pleased to say that is not only crucial but it happens frequently and it's absolutely pivotal to informing the understanding that the FCDO has on how to use their influence, when not to use their influence, where to delegate, where to use partnerships and other approaches. The second theme is building partnerships. And as Lord McConnell mentioned we have since 2025 formalised cooperation on conflict resolution with Qatar and Turkey, for example. I know from our ambassador in Qatar how much effort he and his team are putting into that- that partnership in particular with the parts- with the Iran conflict and other conflicts in mind.
They are partners with growing roles as mediators whose expertise we value. We've also begun working with Japan's new mediation unit which I know my noble friend has championed and we're deepening our cooperation with the European Union as provided for by the security and defence partnership. But again our job is not to crowd an already crowded field, it is to help those with access and more legitimacy than we sometimes have to succeed. I mentioned earlier on in answer to a question on- on Sudan the role of my- my right honourable friend the Foreign Secretary was at- was in Istanbul last week with a E3 plus- R4 meeting looking at ways in which countries with other kinds of relationships in areas like Sudan and Iran can play a more constructive role. And by the way I'd just like to come back to a point that my noble friend Baroness Chapman raised, it's complete- I think she's completely right, it's a very important point about the framing of responses being overly dictated by the last response.
It's a- if I- with my academic hat on, I can never quite give up being an academic, there's a wonderful book by someone called Yuen Foong Khong called The Analogies of War which is precisely about military engagement falling prey to exactly the same vice, fighting the current war based on the lessons from a different previous war. And I think peacebuilding can suffer from some of those same vices as well, I think that's an incredibly important point. The third set of activities I want to draw attention to is strengthening the institutions of peace. I was in Vienna last month, I opened the UK's chair- chairpersonship of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe, by the way one of the few multilateral institutions where we sit around the table with Russia. And more valuable for that in my view.
I talked about in my speech about dialogue, I'm sure noble lords have all read it, but I'll- just to summarise for those of you who may have missed it, I talked about how dialogue matters most when trust is at its lowest ebb and how Europe's security institutions still have a role despite it being unfashionable in many quarters to manage risk, prevent escalation and we will keep investing in them.
We have contributed over 200 million pounds to the UN Peacebuilding Fund, for example, since 2006, which makes us a very long-standing, loyal donor. But the noble lord, Lord Howell, I think gave us a chastening and correct challenge to try and recapture, I think the way he put it was the spirit of 1945. Let's be honest, this is not a good time for multilateralism. It is not a good time for the UN. It is not a time therefore for us to walk away from these multilateral institutions.
It is a time, to go back to noble lord Lord Bruce's point, to try and put some steel back in the multilateral architecture. And I'll respond to my noble lord Lord Hastings' challenge in a minute. It's also time to beware false choices that have been presented in some noble lords' comments today. False choices between hard and soft power. The right reverend prelate the Bishop of Chelmsford's point about if you want peace, you have to invest in the institutions of multilateral cooperation that bring it about and not assume war.
I completely agree with that, as well as the false choice of thinking that it's either defense or development. And of course this has been a very difficult time because of the cuts that have been made in the development budget. But there's a more fundamental challenge than just zero-sum trade-offs of funding, which is to rethink the way we think about defense to bring in security, economic and military dimensions, preemptive downstream interventions into our concept of what proper security and defense is about. We helped shape last year's review of the UN's peacekeeping architecture. We fund the UN's own mediation experts.
And as the UN prepares for a new Secretary-General, we want a United Nations that uses its good offices actively and early. And regional organizations matter too, in particular the African Union, for example. We will support these organizations to make that commitment real and work with the World Bank and other international finance institutions so that money flows to prevention before violence breaks out. Several noble lords raised early warning. As noble lord Lord Ahmad mentioned this, for example, the problem is rarely that we cannot see a crisis coming.
We usually can. It's the turning warning into action. And the FCDO has developed a variety of mechanisms and tools to support early warning and early action across the network. And the importance of using technology to improve that early warning translation of warning to action was a point well made. The Foreign Office is bringing conflict, atrocity and humanitarian analysis together into a single view of risk, drawing on our embassies, open-source data and horizon scanning.
And we support local civil society organizations to strengthen their own early warning functions. And on the question of atrocity prevention, my noble lady Baroness Bennett mentioned this. And I welcome the challenge in the PeaceWorks report launched by my noble friend's all-party group and in the atrocity crimes review published earlier this month. We're considering their recommendations carefully. I'm particularly considering their recommendations carefully because my old boss Gordon Brown spoke at the launch of the review.
So I've learned over the years not to ignore Gordon Brown, especially on early warning issues. Officials are meeting the authors and I'd be glad for our officials to meet my noble friend and the group's officers as well. I was going to talk about some particular cases. Given time, I probably won't. But just on Sudan, I know we've talked about Sudan earlier on, but noble lord Lord Bruce challenged us on Sudan.
There are definitely complexities with those involved in peacemaking also being parties that have interests. And that is a complexity not just of Sudan, but clearly is a complexity there. What are we doing? We had a UN, an UNGA event specifically on the drone attacks in order to try and make some progress on that. We are leaders of the coalition atrocity prevention group.
And there is constant engagement on this. I'm sure there's more that can be done, but it is not a field in which we are silent. I also wanted to turn, mention Lord Ahmad's leadership on this question of the International Alliance of Preventive Sexual Violence in Conflict, which I know he was instrumental in starting, I believe. And we are continuing to prioritize that.
We work with Colombia, the DRC, I think who are chair this year, Ukraine and others. We are vice-chair this year and it is an agenda that is being actively pursued with energy from the United Kingdom. Inclusion, of course, is absolutely vital. Peace agreements are more likely to last when, for example, and in particular, when women participate in a meaningful way. And parties are more likely to come back to the table if talks falter.
And we do need women's leadership and meaningful participation in these spaces. We have protected funding for women, peace and security, and we're refreshing our national action plan on this. And inclusion also means hearing, as I said earlier, local peacebuilders, the people who raise the alarm first and who stay the longest and have most at stake. So we must do more to protect women peacebuilders, human rights defenders who face growing intimidation, reprisals and violence. Just turning quickly to resources, many noble Lords asked about resources.
I won't pretend that reducing aid to 0.3% was easy and has not had trade-offs. Of course it has. It's had consequences. But we are concentrating where we can do most good. I'm pleased to say over 70% of our country and regional aid will go to fragile and conflict-affected states by 2028 to 2029.
But as I said earlier, and I speak as someone who used to come up with pots of money as a Treasury special adviser for a previous Chancellor, this is an area where money of course is crucial, but the magnitude of commitment cannot be expressed by simply how many people work in a particular unit or how much money goes to a particular sub-activity inside the Foreign Office, crucial as that is. Noble Lord Alton rightly challenged us on defense, although I would say the spending review is the place where spending decisions are made traditionally, at least that's my understanding. But there will be more to say on that. To conclude, the success of prevention is often invisible. The war that didn't start, the ceasefire that held, the talks that kept going when everyone thought they would fail.
These are non-events that are huge events in the world of peacekeeping and peacebuilding. It's among the best investments we can actually make in security for people living through conflict and for us here at home. And our role is to bring expertise, build partnerships and strengthen institutions. Can I make two quick last remarks, even though I've hit my time limit? Noble Lord Lord Hastings says, is the British government or is Britain afraid to speak?
Absolutely not. I say that with all respect. And I see myself, without being pious, as part of a team of ministers at the Foreign Office that is on Israel, even though many noble Lords will not agree with our position on Israel reset, on Sudan, on Ukraine, that is putting suffering and an end to violence at the forefront. But please, I'm sure everyone will keep us challenged on that, but that is absolutely at the center. And lastly, are we afraid to talk to those with whom we disagree?
A point made by noble Lord Lord Bates, congratulations for bringing Dan Burn's name into a debate on conflict prevention, by the way. Noble Lord Lord Hastings, noble learned Lord Lord Anderson and others. I think the answer is yes, sometimes we are too afraid to speak to those with whom we disagree. And I think that's probably true of our government as well at times. And I think that is a good challenge because lines of communication are more, not less, important when tensions and conflicts are at their greatest.
And I think that is a salutary lesson to take away.
Jack McConnell
First of all, my Lords, thank you so much for such a fascinating, interesting, thought-provoking series of speeches in a debate that I'm sure will live in the minds of those of us who have been here to listen for days, weeks, and perhaps even months to come. Thanks particularly to my noble friend the Minister for his wide-ranging response. There is much there for us to think about, but also for us to welcome. It would be impossible to comment on even a range of the points that have been made, but I hope I can be allowed perhaps to just very briefly comment on two. The first is in relation to the United Nations.
Many noble Lords mentioned the importance of the United Nations. Many others reflected on the frustration at the ability of the United Nations to do its job in 2024. And I just wonder perhaps, and given the government's commitment to decentralization, to devolution, to the understanding that not everything can be done centrally, that perhaps one of the questions we need to address over the next 20 years towards the centenary of the United Nations is whether everything centralized in New York is the right format for an organization that has grown from 50-odd states in 1946 to nearly 200 today. And maybe these regional organizations that I've referred to regularly in debates such as this, the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, the African Union, the Gulf Cooperation Council, even these days its important role in the Middle East, and so many others, perhaps they provide forums through which we can deal with many of these issues much more successfully. And then just finally, I want to just comment on this issue of patience and persistence and sticking with the difficult business of peacebuilding.
When I first became involved in the Philippines in 2014, there was much enthusiasm about the peace agreement. And nine months later, the Philippine National Police, at the instigation probably of the United States of America, went looking for a couple of Malaysian terrorists in the area that was controlled by the previous Moro rebels. They were not warned in advance. They thought they were under attack. They attacked the police officers who had gone into the area, and they killed, I think it was 41 police officers.
There were calls in Manila at the time to scrap the peace agreement, to tear it up, to go back to square one, to go in and to kill everybody who was associated with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front rather than stick with the peace agreement. And I was in Manila at the time, and I was asked to do a series of interviews. And I recalled 1998, the Omagh bombing, the worst bombing in Northern Ireland during the whole of the conflict in Northern Ireland, six months after the Good Friday Agreement, and the calls on Tony Blair and Bertie Ahern to cancel the Good Friday Agreement because of the bombing that had taken place. And their determination not to do so at that time. And my calculation in 2015 was that every single child leaving school in Northern Ireland that year at the age of 16 had lived their entire life in peace as a result of that decision not to cancel the peacebuilding in Northern Ireland.
And I'm glad to say that our colleagues in the Philippines stuck with it through three presidents, through even a change of local leadership from the Liberation Front, and tomorrow they will elect their first-ever elected Chief Minister in an autonomous parliament that hopefully will give them peace for many decades to come. So I think persistence, sticking with it, going through the bad times as well as the good times, dealing with your opponents and having an inclusive process is essential, and I'm very glad that our debate reflected that today.
Speaker 88
The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. My Lords, I'll pause for a short while before calling the next business.
Speaker 89
I'm sure the House will be most grateful. Excuse me. Order. I'm sure the House will be most grateful if noble Lords leaving the chamber will do so as quickly and as quietly as possible. Thank you.
Speaker 87
Question for short debate, support and resources for refugee settlement, the Bishop of Chelmsford.
Speaker 66
My Lords, I'm grateful to have secured this debate and for those who will speak. Community sponsorship offers a distinctive approach to refugee settlement. It enables people not simply to welcome refugees in principle, but to stand alongside them in practice, securing a home, navigating unfamiliar systems, building relationships and new lives. It's a considerable commitment and an expression of the best of our civic life, or as the Prime Minister might choose to see it, a courageous example of hope where families are welcomed by their neighbors. It's been a privilege to witness the scheme's extraordinary capacity to transform the lives of displaced people and enrich communities in my own diocese of Chelmsford and across the UK since its launch at Lambeth Palace in 2016.
Speaker 65
People want to help provide refugee protection. The government's role is to create a safe, managed and sustainable framework that turns that willingness into action, and I'm grateful for their commitment in wanting to make that work. My understanding is that the government will today open applications to the scheme. If I'm correct, that will be an important milestone, and I hope that this debate offers an opportunity for the noble Lord the Minister to share more about their ambitions for partnership working with communities and sponsors to make this pathway a joint success. Communities need to know what is expected of them, how many refugees the program hopes to support and what resources are available.
These are questions of ambition, capacity and responsibility, which I hope we can explore a little today. The government wants to restore public confidence in the migration system. We all see the human tragedy of people risking their lives in small boats, and we hear concerns about pressures on services, housing and cohesion. Yet these concerns are too often presented as a choice between compassion or control. The model of community sponsorship demonstrates that this is a false choice.
It offers a safe, regular and well-managed route for refugees to rebuild their lives while strengthening communities. In this scheme, communities choose to participate. Numbers are known, arrivals prepared for, accommodation and support are planned and secured beforehand. This contrasts starkly with disorderly arrivals, emergency hotels and last-minute dispersals, which undermine trust and fuel anxiety. Sponsorship instead encourages cohesion, establishes relationships from the start and leads to faster integration.
Evidence shows that sponsored refugees learn English faster, find work sooner, and rely less on public services because support helps their independence, reducing long-term costs associated with homelessness, unemployment, and poor health. It's right that the scale of sponsorship is driven by the willingness and capacity of communities rather than by an arbitrary cap. But can I ask the Lord, the noble Lord the Minister, how the government will assess that capacity and also the potential for growth as infrastructure develops through new pathways for education and employment? How will faith groups, refugee-led organisations, voluntary sector organisations, and local authorities be consulted before numbers are determined? Sponsorship should also be a flexible national asset that can be mobilised rapidly in response to emerging humanitarian disasters.
A mature system could provide a durable framework for future crises without requiring entirely new programs. Homes for Ukraine demonstrated the public's willingness to respond with over 175,000 arrivals. The government has said arrivals through the resettlement scheme and sponsorship routes will initially number in the hundreds, rising to the low thousands. However, it must ensure not to constrain the ambition of willing sponsors, and I hope the scheme may in time become fully, become fully accessible to other parts of the world, not just those currently named. The existing scheme has supported more than 1,200 refugees through over 200 sponsors.
Canada's comparable program has resettled over 440,000 refugees since 1979. In preparing for this debate, I contacted organisations supporting refugees to gauge their interest in participating, as well as the Church of England. I heard from the Salvation Army, Welcome Churches, the Pickwell Foundation, Refugee Education UK, Citizens UK, REST, Rohingya Association UK, Welsh Refugee Council, and Micro Rainbow. That is an impressive and diverse group of potential partners. It's important that government and this House welcome the welcomers.
Community sponsorship is emotionally and practically demanding, particularly in divisive times. Those giving their time and resources should be recognised and protected. Civil society and government must work closely together so the welcomers feel confident to provide support effectively. I hope that today is a helpful opportunity for the Minister to place on record the government's thanks to the thousands of volunteers who've supported refugees through sponsorship schemes over the past decade and will be integral in the future. My question also concerns the support available to sponsors.
It would be easy to focus on funding without acknowledging the government's considerable investment into the processing requirements, including overseas vetting and logistical arrangements. What plans does the government have to build societal infrastructure so that community sponsorship becomes a self-sustaining, resilient, and community-owned model? Generosity cannot replace professional support. So how will the government help lead sponsors to offer specialist assistance, including training, safeguarding, and administrative support? And how will it ensure that sponsorship remains accessible to less affluent groups that wish to participate, including local churches and faith groups?
My Lords, the question before us today isn't simply how many refugees the government intends to welcome through sponsorship. It's whether the government is ready to build a program that communities can participate in confidently and refugees can rely on. Community sponsorship can be a powerful expression of shared responsibility. It's a safe and controlled model and importantly, it's rooted in the best of who we are as a society. With proper planning, sustained support, and a clear commitment from government, it can offer refugees not only safety, but the opportunity to belong, to flourish, and to contribute.
Speaker 90
My Lords, I'm incredibly grateful to the Right Reverend Prelate, the Lord Bishop of Chelmsford for bringing this vital issue before the House today and for the excellent and eloquent introduction to the debate. The question of how we resource, support, and scale our resettlement programs goes to the very heart of who we are as a nation. I welcome the government's commitment to expanding our safe and legal routes, specifically through the introduction of the new community sponsorship, refugee study, and refugee work streams. These are commendable steps in the right direction. However, having had the privilege of serving as a minister for faith, communities, and resettlement, I know firsthand that a policy framework is only as strong as the infrastructure supporting it.
During my time in office, I was consistently humbled by the immense untapped generosity and operational capacity of our civil society. From churches and mosques to local neighborhood coalitions and secular charities, the British public has a profound desire to step up and welcome those fleeing conflict and persecution. Community sponsorship is not merely an alternative delivery model for immigration policy. It is a gold standard for integration. Traditional state-led resettlement provides a roof and basic safety net, which is vital, but community sponsorship provides a community.
When a local group wraps its arms around a refugee family, the results are transformative. We see accelerated language acquisition, swifter entry into meaningful employment, and deep-rooted social connections. Neighbors don't just hand over keys, they help register children at the local school, navigate GP appointments, and introduce new arrivals to local employers. This model actively fosters social cohesion, bridging cultural divides and building shared purpose at a grassroots level. My Lords, if we want to see the true transformative potential of this model when it is backed by real government ambition, we only need to look across the Atlantic to Canada, as mentioned by the Right Reverend Prelate.
For nearly five decades, Canada's private sponsorship of refugees program has been the global benchmark. Since its inception, ordinary Canadian citizens, faith groups, and community associations have directly sponsored more than 400,000 refugees. The Canadian data speaks for itself. Decades of independent longitudinal studies show that privately sponsored refugees consistently find employment faster, learn the local language more rapidly, and report a higher sense of belonging than those entering through standard government-assisted routes. Why?
Speaker 91
Because they arrive with a ready-made social network of citizens completely invested in their success. Canada proved to the world that when you trust civil society, when you build a robust partnership between the state and the community, you create an engine for successful integration that scales naturally.
Yet, if we are to unlock that same potential here, the government must match the ambition of our international peers. The recent indication from the Home Office that initial arrivals across the UK resettlement scheme and these new streams will number only in the low hundreds is frankly overly cautious. While I understand the need for careful management, we must remember that community sponsorship is uniquely scalable. Because it relies heavily on civil society's energy and private goodwill, it alleviates rather than exacerbates the immediate strain on hard-pressed local authority budgets. The low hundreds should not be treated as a comfortable ceiling; it must be a strict baseline for year one, backed by a clear roadmap for growth.
Furthermore, we must address the bureaucratic barriers that historically cause enthusiastic local groups to lose momentum. If we are opening these routes to non-profits and charities, the accreditation and vetting processes must be rigorous but accessible. Overly complex financial checks and prolonged processing delays can smother community goodwill before a single family even arrives. My Lords, our finest asset in integrating refugees is the open hearts and operational capability of our faith and community groups. Let us give them the tools, the streamlined processes, and the long-term certainty they need to succeed.
Speaker 90
I urge the government to expand its vision, resource our sponsors adequately, and allow British communities to do what they do best: welcome, integrate, and heal. My Lords, to ensure our communities are truly empowered to deliver this vision, I would like to put four specific brief questions to my noble friend the Minister. My noble friend has noted that initial arrivals across the UKRS and the new community sponsorship routes will be in the low hundreds in the past; this has been mentioned. Can the government outline what specific criteria or milestones will be used to trigger an expansion of these numbers as more charities and non-profits achieve accredited status? Secondly, as the government opens up the new community sponsorship streams, what steps are being taken to streamline the application and vetting processes so that smaller grassroots community groups are not inadvertently locked out by prohibitive administrative red tape?
Speaker 91
Thirdly, will the government consider establishing a dedicated regional Home Office liaison unit tasked specifically with providing ongoing operational advice, training resources, and troubleshooting support to accredited sponsors during their first critical year of hosting? And finally, while community sponsorship leverages immense voluntary resource, local statutory services like ESOL and healthcare still experience impacts. Can my noble friend the Minister clarify how the funding architecture for these new routes will ensure local authorities are adequately compensated alongside voluntary sponsors? I look forward to the response of my noble friend the Minister.
Munton
My Lords, I declare my interest as someone who has hosted a family from Ukraine for four years, who have recently moved on, and I'm expecting another family to arrive just before Christmas. I agree with the Right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Chelmsford that we need to be certain that steps are taken to provide adequate support and resources to sponsors. So it is in that context that I think it is worth looking at the Homes for Ukraine scheme, which has supported thousands of Ukrainians, with individual families opening their homes and hearts and welcoming them in. Hosts were originally allocated five hundred pounds a month to help with extra costs. Last year, this was reduced to three hundred and fifty pounds a month.
And now the Department for Communities and Local Government has said that the monthly rate is going to be reduced to one hundred pounds a month from the first of January next year.
Ostensibly, this is based on the view that Ukrainian families should by now have been able to develop their own resources here. Yet the same cut of over 70% will apply to UK families taking Ukrainians who have just arrived. And the situation is getting worse. Even while we have been sitting in this chamber in the last hour, 14 people were killed at a Kyiv railway station by a Russian drone. A fortnight ago, the Lord Privy Seal rightly argued in this place that the moral obligation of this country to do what we can practically to help Ukraine and its people remains as high as ever.
And the noble lady seemed surprised when I told her about the change to the arrangements of funding for hosts. Research conducted by the Office for National Statistics outlines how the cost of living has already forced many host families to abandon the scheme. Hosts were originally asked to commit to six months. After that time, 23% pulled out as they could no longer afford it. And 99% of these hosts citing significant extra costs such as utilities and food.
And the Local Government Association has told us that thousands of Ukrainian households have had to register as homeless here after their hosting arrangements collapsed. Apart from the fact that this may well cost the local authorities more than the proposed cuts, it is also incredible to me that we offer families a safe haven from a country at war and yet they may end up sleeping on our streets. My Lords, Ukraine and particularly its capital is facing a devastating winter. The worst of the war so far, given the increased Russian ballistic missile attacks on infrastructure and the almost complete cessation of the supply of US Patriot defense systems. The father of the family who we have hosted for four years is still in Kyiv.
In the last three weeks, he has had three hours of running water. He spends nights either sleeping in the corridor or in an underpass. And he's lucky if he gets two hours electricity a day. And this week, I received an email from the guest who is joining us shortly with his young son. The mother is no longer alive.
He said, "The situation in Kyiv feels more dangerous now than at any other time during these four years of war." "With almost constant air raid alerts and attacks, the city sometimes feels more like a place near the front line." "Even going outside has become a source of uncertainty and concern." And as a result of this escalation, more families, more parents from Ukraine with traumatized children are looking for homes here. Yet the combination of reduced funding and high living costs has drastically reduced the number of families who are able to sponsor.
And another factor causing concern, which I think also needs to be taken into account, is the lack of clarity on the duration of visas, which not only affects Ukrainian children, many of whom are now totally integrated into our education system, but it also affects their mothers or parents who are trying to get a job, trying to find somewhere to rent, but with no fixed idea of how long they will be here. And this adds unnecessary stress to an already intolerable situation. So I would urge His Majesty's Government to look again at their changes to the Homes for Ukraine scheme, to reconsider the proposed cut of almost three quarters in the amount paid to host families, and to make sure that lessons are learned and that the resettlement of refugees through community sponsorship is adequately resourced. Thank you.
Speaker 94
Baroness Brinton is taking part remotely. I invite Baroness Brinton to speak.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, I declare my interest as a vice president of the Local Government Association. And my Lords, I congratulate the Bishop of Chelmsford for securing this short but important debate on the process of allowing refugees to settle through community sponsorship, to assess the numbers involved, and to look at whether the government are taking adequate resources and support to sponsors. I join her in thanks to the many communities that have already supported refugees. And it's an honor to follow Baroness Munton of Darlington Forest. Her example as a sponsor of a Ukrainian family and shortly to be another is absolutely to be commended.
But I share her concern in the reduction of grants for host families and the consequential loss of hosts. Please, Minister, can this be changed? And Lord Khan spoke powerfully of the strength of welcoming community to ensure that arrivals settle and become part of the community, and I agree with him. In 2016, under Prime Minister Theresa May, the community sponsorship scheme was launched, and in that scheme, managed by the Home Office, families were allocated to approved sponsors, who could be charities, faith groups, or other civil society organizations. My Lords, it has developed very slowly.
The Sunak government said in 2023, over a thousand vulnerable refugees fleeing regions of conflict and instability, including Syria, Iraq, Sudan, Eritrea, Iran, Somalia, and Afghanistan, have been welcomed under one of the UK's safe and legal routes by local communities across the UK so they can start their new lives here. That's not many over the previous seven years. The scheme does have good ideals. The sponsors have to demonstrate capacity to deliver their side of the scheme, which include available funding of at least nine thousand pounds, as well as the appropriate accommodation, as well as written consent from the local authority. And once approval was given, they were given the responsibility of supporting a resettled family for at least one year, providing accommodation for two years, and providing support for all that they might need, from accessing medical services, language tuition, schools, social services, and importantly helping them to find employment.
And absolutely this encourages cohesion. But my Lords, the low numbers have demonstrated a problem, and that is the capacity of local authorities to be able to play a practical role in this without any extra resources. Let me be blunter than that. Most local authorities are struggling to deliver anything beyond their statutory duties, and it's disappointing that yesterday's budget wasn't able to change that. However, even if it had, I suspect that local authorities' capacities to help community sponsors would remain a low priority compared to the statutory duties of children's services, children in care, and adult social services.
Lady Munton has graphically laid out the consequences to local authorities of the government grant to hosts being reduced. Also, my Lords, what's exploded in the last few years is a worrying resurgence of groups on the far right who, instead of objecting to government about their concerns for refugee policy, have taken to demonstrating, marching, and intimidating those refugees themselves. And too often police resources have been needed to intervene to stop these aggressive patterns of behaviors by protesters. And so I believe that's why twelve months ago, then Prime Minister Starmer, excuse me, published his restoring order and control statement on the government's asylum and returns policy.
And along with my party and Lord German, I've been arguing for years for effective safe and legal routes to asylum for people with real cause. And I'm not sure that we've really got effective safe legal routes at the moment. And I'm interested in understanding how quickly this scheme, if it works, can be developed further from the scheme first introduced a decade ago by the previous government. Because, my Lords, despite what many people want us to believe, there are refugees with a real and understandable fear for their lives in their own countries who seek to come to the UK, often because of direct, that is familial, or indirect, for example the Afghan troops who worked with us in the war in Afghanistan. The 2025 government policy paper said that refugee sponsorship would become the framework for most of the UK government's refugee settlement efforts.
The three new routes still include the route I described earlier, but unless resources are improved, I can't see that increasing very much. Second route is by universities through the study sponsorship route and by companies through the work route. And this too is very welcome. But I am sure I was not alone in absolute despair when our universities had found money and offered some places to prospective students stuck in Gaza last year and this, but who could not leave their small children behind in a war zone. Some of those prospective students also couldn't get their status confirmed in time to start their courses.
So the sponsorship opportunities were wasted by the universities through absolutely no fault of theirs or the prospective students. So can I ask the Minister what steps the Foreign Office and the Home Office are taking to improve visa processes for candidates under this scheme, especially universities, where new students have a deadline that cannot be changed? The third route is the UK Refugee Settlement Route, which opened to new referrals recently. And I echo the questions of the Right Reverend Prelate, who asked what the numbers in each of these three schemes the government expects over the next few years. I mean, the government says it will set annual limits, but are the appropriate resources available to make sure that once the community sponsors have fulfilled their side of the bargain, the government will have capacity to deliver its side, especially timely approval of visas?
The other area that community sponsors, including Reset Communities for Refugees, are asking for is support in clear guidance, appropriate resources, effective safeguarding arrangements, and access to specialist training and support. I look forward to hearing the Minister's response on these. Finally, my Lords, there is one community who I know well and have worked with for some time who have been accessing a safe and legal route to settlement in the UK for many years, but not without some problems. Unfortunately, the government still refers to this group as refugees. But I believe that they are wrong to do so and have said so before.
This is the brave opponents of the Chinese regime in Hong Kong who already hold British National Overseas status, who have fled to the UK because the Conservative government of the day we handed China back Hong Kong recognized that they were entitled to be British Nationals. Now, since that handover of Hong Kong to China on the 1st of July 1997, and especially over recent years, when people fleeing Hong Kong arrive in Britain, they are often treated by Home Office staff as if they are exactly the same as all other refugees without British National status.
Please will the minister ensure that this practice stops. Yes, they may seek help and support if they arrive in distress with no or few possessions, and they will need help with resettlement. But the first and biggest hurdle for them is overcome already. They have a right to come to this country, and it is shocking that their first encounter is immigration staff who don't even know this.
Speaker 97
My Lords, it's always a pleasure to speak after my colleague Baroness Brinton, who has so eloquently laid out the position of those groups of whom she has some direct interest as well. I must declare my interest as being supported by the RAMP organization, and I must also thank the Right Reverend Prelate for being ahead of the curve again and being able to bring forward debate on an issue which, of course, is very potent in the current, current scene. I must also express my interest with a small i, not a big i, not a big capital I, as the general rapporteur on European migration and asylum policy for the Parliamentary Assembly for the Council of Europe, because I will be reporting on this debate as I feel it is an important part of the structure which we are facing across the whole of our continent. My Lords, for generations, Britain's proudest chapters have been written not when we turned our backs on the world, but when we stepped forward to offer sanctuary to those fleeing terror, persecution, and war. We saw that spirit when our towns and villages welcomed displaced families from Ukraine, as we've heard so eloquently earlier.
Speaker 96
We saw it in the response to the fall of Afghanistan, and I remember many decades ago the crisis of Ugandan Asians, where we sought and brought to this country those who were being displaced so horribly. And we've seen it across hundreds of quiet, compassionate community sponsorship groups who've opened their homes and hearts across our country. Liberal Democrats have long argued that the best of British values is found in our local communities. And that is why we welcome the principle behind the government's now new community sponsorship scheme. Establishing new and safe and legal routes is a necessary step in the right direction.
Speaker 97
Allowing communities, faith groups, universities, and local organizations to step forward to directly sponsor named individuals, to support students, and to welcome displaced workers is a proven and powerful concept. When local communities have direct ownership, integration flourishes. Refugees do not arrive as numbers on a Home Office spreadsheet. They arrive into an existing network of neighbors, mentors, and friends who help them find work, master our language, and truly belong. We on these benches reject outright the cynical, ungenerous claims from those on the political right.
Speaker 98
Those who demand that no safe routes be created until every boat is stopped miss the fundamental reality. People take to dangerous dinghies precisely because safe legal routes do not exist. You do not smash the vile business model of criminal smuggling gangs by building higher walls. You smash it by opening controlled, orderly doors that render the smugglers obsolete. Yet while we support this scheme in principle, we must be brutally honest about its practical realities.
Compassion without ambition is mere sentiment. And as it stands, this policy suffers from glaring shortcomings that risk setting it up to fail. And first and foremost, as has been mentioned earlier, is the question of scale. The government talks of this scheme breaking the cycle of irregular channel crossings.
But look at the figures to which the Home Office has now quietly admitted. Total arrivals across the reopened UK resettlement scheme, and that includes all three new sponsorship routes, will start in the hundreds before slowly growing into the low thousands. By the end of this decade, reports suggest an ambition of just over 10,000 altogether. Schemes need to be known, they need to be understood, they need to be provided with sufficient information for people to make a difference and be able to make a choice. To present a scheme that admits a few hundred people as a serious deterrent to the tens of thousands not just crossing the channel but also entering by other means is frankly a tokenistic drop in the ocean.
Speaker 96
The Refugee Council and civil society have made clear that if we are serious about safe routes, we must aim for real ambition, restoring resettlement to at least pre-pandemic levels of 5,000 people a year, not trickling places out in the low hundreds. Secondly, the government is engaged in passing the buck to local communities from local authorities. Ministers say they want to relieve local authorities and end the reliance on expensive asylum hotels. We agree with closing the hotels, but the government's answer is to offload core statutory responsibilities onto volunteers, charities, and churches. And under the scheme, sponsors are required to secure independent accommodation for at least two years and raise substantial private capital.
Speaker 98
My Lords, in the middle of the worst housing crisis in modern memory, how on earth does the Home Secretary expect local charities to outbid the market to find two-year tenancies without statutory backing? Under the Homes for Ukraine scheme, the state provided monthly thank-you payments to assist most households. Yet under this new scheme, ministers have completely failed to guarantee whether similar financial support will exist. If the state treats volunteer goodwill as an unpaid substitute for proper government, burnout will follow and the intake will grind to a halt. And thirdly, I'm afraid we cannot ignore the punitive rollback of refugee rights baked into this wider agenda.
For years, community sponsorship granted refugees immediate indefinite leave to remain, giving them the certainty needed to rebuild their lives and contribute. And now the government has reduced that to a precarious five-year route for permanent settlement, while slashing domestic asylum protections into 30-month temporary visas and threatening 20-year delays on resettlement. Fourthly, there is a serious danger that by shifting the bulk of resettlement to named study and employer routes, we risk abandoning the most vulnerable. Resettlement must never become a corporate recruitment fair or an elite academic exercise. We cannot ignore the disabled, the elderly, or those who lack language skills and overseas connections, those whom the UNHCR identifies as facing immediate peril.
My Lords, we want this sponsorship scheme to work. We want British communities empowered to open their arms. But a genuine safe route cannot be treated as an afterthought or a PR shield to justify harsher enforcement. If the government genuinely wants to offer sanctuary, it must meet the four tests and the four queries that we have made earlier. And as our immigration moves towards net zero, those coming in and those leaving, we need to be absolutely certain that we are giving people the compassionate best we can.
We as a country are at our best when we are open, generous, and fair. Let's not build a scheme of token numbers and shifting burdens. Let's build a system that is controlled, compassionate, and truly fit for purpose.
Byron Davies
My Lords, can I thank the Right Reverend Prelate the Bishop of Chelmsford for securing this debate. The Right Reverend Prelate asked what assessment the government have made of the number of refugees who will be settled annually through community sponsorship. And the honest answer so far from what I can see is that we do not know. In response to a written question that I asked on the 5th of October, the Noble Lord the Minister said that, and I quote, "The government expects the total arrivals across the UKRS and the three new community sponsorship routes to number in the low hundreds at first." My Lords, it is the words "at first" that really concern me.
What time frame does "at first" cover? Is it a few hundred people in the first year or the first three years? How many people do the government believe will be able to come to Britain after this undefined initial phase? Does the government even know how many people they want to bring into the country under these new schemes? Now the Noble Lord the Minister must tell Noble Lords how the cap will be set and by whom, whether Parliament will have a say, and what happens if the cap is exceeded.
He must also say if the numbers will sit alongside a commitment to reduce overall migration. Furthermore, in that same answer, the Minister said the Home Office works closely with the local authorities that volunteer to participate in the UKRS. So can I take this to mean that local authorities will only have to house these refugees if they volunteer to do so? And if so, can the Noble Lord the Minister rule out any local authority being forced to house refugees who enter the country under one of the new schemes if they do not wish to do so? Or will we see a repeat of the current situation whereby local authorities have no say over where asylum seekers are housed?
My Lords, the context matters. We are told this scheme depends on illegal migration falling. So let us look at where it stands. More than 41,000 people crossed the channel in small boats in 2025. In the 12 months to June this year, around 33,000 did so.
The government points to a fall, and they are right that the number has fallen. But 33,000 people in a year arriving in dinghies in defiance of our laws and at the mercy of criminal gangs is not a problem solved. The government's answer to this is to reopen the resettlement scheme, but my Lords, to open the front door while the back door is still being forced open sends exactly the wrong signal to the people smugglers, to the illegal migrants, and indeed to the British people. And what of the cost? The National Audit Office has estimated the cost of asylum accommodation at 15.3 billion over 10 years.
Every one of those places is paid for by the taxpayer. Now the government propose additional intakes and they say the sponsors will carry some of the burden. So can the minister tell us what the total Treasury cost will be? What funding will be given to local authorities for school places, GP registrations and housing when a sponsorship arrangement falls through? The government's policy of dispersing asylum seekers across the country has placed enormous pressure on small towns and rural communities that never asked to be at the center of a national problem.
Even after recent reductions, around 16,000 asylum seekers remain in hotels and many thousands more are in other Home Office accommodation.
Residents in places with one GP surgery and one primary school have found hundreds of newcomers placed among them with little warning and even less consultation. Local councillors and police have told us how hard it is to preserve cohesion in those circumstances. Whatever one thinks of the policy, those communities have a right to be heard. The government are now asking those same communities to take on a further burden through sponsorship and they are doing so before they have shown they can manage the problem they already have. My Lords, under these proposals, charities and non-profit organisations will be able to apply to become sponsors and approved groups will be able to choose the refugees they support and take responsibility for their housing, integration and employment.
That is a significant degree of trust to place in an organisation. So my Lords, let me be plain. There have been a number of cases over many years of charities, mosques and NGOs that have hosted extremist speakers or whose trustees or associates have held views hostile to our way of life. The Charity Commission has opened statutory inquiries, I beg your pardon, into such cases and we have a duty to ask whether an organisation of that kind could become an approved sponsor with direct responsibility for vulnerable people who may depend on it for their housing, their income and indeed their daily lives. And this is even more important given that we know that the Iranian regime has been sending operatives to Britain on small boats.
And what is to say they will not attempt to do so through the community sponsorship routes? So I have a few specific questions to the noble Lord the Minister. Will every applicant be vetted against Charity Commission records and security service advice? Will trustees and key personnel be checked? Will there be ongoing monitoring and will approval be withdrawn swiftly if concerns arise?
And will the government ensure that no sponsor of any faith or none is able to exploit a position of influence over refugees, whether to radicalise, to coerce or indeed to profit? My Lords, we need a real assessment of the numbers involved in these schemes. We need a full costing of the policy, including the burden on local authorities. And we need proof that the small boat crisis is under control before the legal routes expand. And we need a commitment that communities will be consulted and not simply informed.
Speaker 100
And we need a rigorous, transparent vetting regime for sponsors. And I look forward very much to the Minister's response.
My Lords, I am extremely grateful to the right reverend prelate for initiating this timely debate and let me just reassure her, the written ministerial statement announcing two of the three new safe and legal routes was laid about an hour and a half ago and I'm hoping that as I speak it will be published. So extremely timely. And my Lords, the two of the three safe and legal routes with applications will be open to become lead sponsors for the named community sponsorship and the refugee study routes.
This is an important step, demonstrating the UK's commitment, as noble Lords have said, to playing a part in the international protection system. And let me assure the noble Lord, Lord Davies, and I think he's heard me make this point in earlier debates. The Home Secretary said in her conference speech this year, our purpose is to create that fairness in our immigration system and to hold this country together at a time when others seek to divide us. In the restoring order and control statement of November 2025, the Home Secretary announced the development of three new safe and legal routes to offer sanctuary to those genuinely fleeing war and prosecution: a named community sponsorship route, a refugee study route, and a refugee work route. These new routes will operate under a lead sponsor framework.
UK-based charities and non-profits will be accredited as lead sponsors, supporting community groups, universities, and employers to sponsor refugees. These sponsors will identify refugees they wish to sponsor, and accredited lead sponsors will then refer cases to the Home Office for consideration. Individuals will not be able to apply directly. The UNHCR will confirm that individuals are refugees before they travel to the United Kingdom. And again, a direct answer to the noble Lord, Lord Davies, to assure him, all individuals will be subject to the necessary security and identity checks by the UK government.
Arrivals under the named community sponsorship and refugee study routes are expected from autumn 2027 onwards, and the refugee work route is expected to open in spring 2027, with the first arrivals to follow later that year. And Baroness Brinton and I think a couple of other noble Lords raised about the question of eligibility and the application process, and their guidance for lead sponsors has been published and that will be available to noble Lords. My Lords, the lead sponsorship framework draws on proven international experience, and my noble friend Lord Khan and the Right Reverend Prelate referred to the Canadian experience and the figures of that scheme. And the government has worked with a range of stakeholders, including Canadian and Australian governments, to develop the new routes. Lead sponsors will support sponsors, enabling successful integration of arrivals and intervening where difficulties arise.
Sponsorship will be responsible, sponsors will be responsible for accommodation and integration support, helping refugees work towards self-sufficiency. The model will lessen the burden on local authorities and ensure that routes do not strain local services. The Right Reverend Prelate raises an important question about support for sponsors, and the Home Office has today published guidance outlining roles and responsibilities and will ensure that there is appropriate training and support. The Home Office will also look to build a lead sponsor network to share knowledge and best practice. And on anticipated numbers, as noble Lords have said, the government expect the new routes to number in the hundreds at first, growing into the low thousands as levels of illegal migration fall.
A cap will be set annually based on the capacity and willingness of communities to welcome refugees. Participation is voluntary and arrivals numbers will depend on sponsor demand and capacity.
Can I just answer a few of the questions that were raised, particularly by the right reverend prelate in terms of that capacity. In contrast to previous resettlement schemes, the new routes are community-led, meaning that communities will be able to determine who they support. We have worked with local authorities throughout the development of the new routes to ensure local authority feedback is incorporated into the new routes. The right reverend prelate and my noble friend Lord Khan raised about how we build societal infrastructure. And the government is committed to supporting community groups, universities, and employers to play an active role in refugee sponsorship.
As the new routes are implemented, we will continue to work closely with stakeholders, including through appropriate training and support. And we'll look to develop lead sponsorship network, as I said before, to share knowledge and good practice. And to reassure the right reverend prelate, lead sponsors, the government will put in place that training to deliver that role. I would also like to pay tribute to the noble lady Baroness Monkton. I think she's an example to us all.
I wish we could all play the role that she's played because the United Kingdom is absolutely united and the government of the United Kingdom is determined and steadfast in its commitment to Ukraine and its people. And what she described was incredibly moving. The Homes for Ukraine scheme has evolved from an initial emergency response into a more established program. Nobody expected this war to continue as long as it has. And that's why the government is making changes to funding to ensure that the scheme remains sustainable for much longer than we had originally thought.
So that's so that we can continue to support those fleeing the war in Ukraine. The Homes for Ukraine per person tariff will decrease from 5,900 to 3,300 for claims made after the 1st of January 2027, as I say, to ensure that this funding remains affordable. And thank you payments will be reimbursed at 100 pounds per month per household, again reflecting a sustainable level of support while continuing to recognize the generosity of sponsors and hosts. I know that won't satisfy the noble lady, but I do believe that what we have to do is show that we are totally committed to Ukraine and the people of Ukraine. Can I just also pick up the point also by the noble lord Lord Davis and others that we the cap is a, you know, as part of the fundamental change to the UK's protection offer, the annual cap will be set following engagement with local authorities, mayors, and other partners and existing community sponsor groups.
The methodology will consider community capacity. That is an important part of this scheme. And of course, sponsors' willingness to support integration. My lords, I could respond to the noble lord Lord Davis and talk about the boats. Our program on immigration, as I say, is to ensure fairness.
We have, in the recent time, ensured a reduction in the boat people, not just by the arrests of the gangs that are doing it, that is really important, but our collaboration with France is also ensuring results. And I think you have to see, and I think noble Lords have said this, we are absolutely committed to remaining, retaining the values that the noble lady, Baroness Monkton, referred to. We are a country that has acknowledged the need for refugees to come to this country. We've done it and we're proud of it, and many people in this chamber are, of course, descendants of refugees and we should not forget that. Can I just conclude that, you know, throughout our history, we have offered sanctuary to those in genuine need of protection.
The new routes will ensure we continue to do so, drawing on the generosity, expertise, commitment of communities across the country, whilst maintaining, which is really important, whilst maintaining public confidence in the immigration system. I hope my answers have resolved, if I have not addressed a specific point, I'm sure we'll be able to write to noble Lords and cover them.
Speaker 105
My Lords, there's been a slight change of timing, I think there was a mistake made on the order paper, and so Lord Palmer of Childs Hill and Baroness Stedman each have 12 minutes. That means there are no minutes in the gap, so I'm sure we'll all be very grateful in the House if everybody will stick very precisely to time, and then both Baroness Jenkin and the Minister will have time to respond.
Speaker 104
My Lords, I'm grateful for this opportunity in the aftermath of the budget to debate one of the most pressing challenges facing our country, and I'm grateful to all noble Lords in the graveyard slot who have stayed to debate it. This is, of course, the sustainability of our welfare system, and in particular disability benefits, including Personal Independence Payment and the wider set of entitlements passported by PIP. The basic purpose of our welfare system ought to be straightforward. It is a safety net for those who need it, to help people who are out of work to return to employment where possible, and to provide proper support to those who cannot work because of illness or disability. PIP has a particular role within that system.
It is to cover additional costs associated with long-term disability or health condition. That is a legitimate purpose, but we know that in practice, it is not always how PIP is functioning. When we look at the disability benefit system more widely, there are serious questions about whether it too is fulfilling its objectives. We have a system which too often fails to provide people with the practical help they need, which can leave people dependent upon financial support without addressing the underlying difficulties they face, and which, through its interaction with other benefits, can create uncertainty and financial disincentives for those who might return to work. And my Lords, despite the increasing sums being spent, the government have yet to demonstrate convincingly how they intend to bring the welfare bill under control while improving the effectiveness of the support being provided.
PIP itself is a generously conceived benefit. It is unconditional, non-contributory, not means-tested and does not need formal medical evidence. International comparisons by the Taxpayers' Alliance show that PIP is a looser regime that also pays more generous rates than our nearest colleagues in the European countries we like to compare ourselves to. So it needs skilled assessors who can discriminate effectively and maintain thresholds. And assessors need strong support from immediate managers all the way up to ministers for some tough decisions, as well as appeal mechanisms that consistently apply those same thresholds.
PIP was also designed before courts interpreted the relevant law as encompassing a wide range of mental health conditions and before COVID and furlough normalized paying healthy people to stay at home and not work. Now let us now have a look at the figures. As of July 2026, some 4.1 million people were entitled to PIP in England and Wales, of whom approximately 3.4 million were of working age. Some 37% were receiving the highest level of award, while over the preceding five years, 42% of new claims made under the normal rules resulted in an award. According to the Department for Work and Pensions statistics, 79% of planned award reviews resulted in an increase or no change in the award.
For reported changes of circumstances, that figure was 89%. Meanwhile, 27% of mandatory reconsiderations cleared, excluding withdrawn cases, resulted in a changed award. These are substantial, indeed enormous figures, and they make it all the more important that we understand what is driving the growth in claims, how eligibility is being assessed and whether the support being provided is producing the outcomes we should expect. PIP is designed to support people who find daily living or mobility more challenging because of a disability or health condition. And there is an important question here about the distinction between recognizing a condition and identifying the practical support that someone actually needs.
Take for example conditions such as anxiety, depression or ADHD. We should also be asking whether the assessment system is sufficiently effective at distinguishing between different levels of impairment, identifying the additional costs people actually face and determining what form of support would be most beneficial. The current system presupposes that a cash award is the most appropriate intervention. But surely with the substantial rise in those claiming benefits on the basis of a mental health condition, should we not consider that timely therapy, appropriate treatment, occupational support, workplace adjustments or other practical interventions may do far more to improve their quality of life and indeed that they might enable some to return to work. The purpose of the disability benefit system should not simply be to recognize that someone is experiencing difficulty.
Rather it should help them overcome that difficulty wherever possible. And that brings me to how PIP awards are assessed and reviewed. The figures I just cited raise important questions about how consistently assessments are conducted, how effectively changes in circumstances are identified and whether decisions are made correctly in the first place.
Where a person's circumstances have materially improved, there must be a fair and reliable means of recognizing that change. And where an initial decision is overturned, we must consider whether an avoidable error was made in the initial assessment. I would therefore be grateful if the noble Baroness the Minister could explain what steps the government are taking to improve the accuracy and consistency of PIP assessments, and how they intend to ensure that reviews respond appropriately to permanent, fluctuating, and potentially treatable conditions. There is a related point here about face-to-face assessments. Can the noble Baroness the Minister commit to restoring face-to-face assessments in their entirety, rather than relying on assessments conducted over the telephone?
If not, can she explain how the government can be confident that they are accurately assessing an individual's physical needs and their entitlement to support without ever seeing the person concerned? According to the Office for Budget Responsibility's report yesterday, spending on sickness and disability benefits alone is forecast to reach 100 billion by 2028-29, a year earlier than the forecast in March, and that's up from 85.6 billion in 25-26. These are very substantial sums, particularly at a time when public finances are under such considerable pressure. And they bring us to a fundamental point which is sometimes overlooked in debates about public spending. Every decision about government expenditure is ultimately a choice about whose interests we prioritize and who bears the costs, and this was made abundantly clear in the budget debate yesterday.
And that is why fairness must be at the center of this discussion. Not just fairness to those receiving support, but fairness to those whose taxes fund it, and to those who depend on the other public services competing for the same resources. My Lords, this brings me to the question of incentives. We cannot consider PIP entirely in isolation from the wider benefit system. For people who receive PIP alongside other forms of support, particularly means-tested benefits, there is a serious question about whether the interaction between different payments creates the right incentives.
For some people, returning to employment or increasing their working hours can mean a substantial reduction in means-tested support, at the same time as they face the additional costs of going to work. The result can be that someone takes on greater responsibility, works more hours, and contributes more in tax, but sees relatively little improvement in their disposable income. And where people are concerned that attempting to return to work or demonstrating an improvement in their condition might place their existing support at risk, that uncertainty can become a barrier in itself. There is something fundamentally wrong with a system which can leave people afraid that making progress in their lives might result in them being worse off. We should want people to recover where possible, to become more independent, and to enter or remain in employment where their circumstances allow.
And the welfare system should support those ambitions, not discourage them. If we want people to enter employment, then work must offer a clear and worthwhile reward. It should not be the case that the structure of the welfare system itself discourages people from doing precisely what the country needs and wants them to do. What does it say about the fairness of our system when people who work hard, pay their taxes, and contribute to the economy can struggle to see the financial rewards of doing so? And what message are we sending when we ask those working families to shoulder an ever-greater tax burden while failing to demonstrate that the substantial sums being spent on welfare are delivering the best possible outcomes?
Those people, my Lords, are increasingly impatient and intolerant about how their taxes are being spent. These are perfectly reasonable questions, and ones we should not shy away from asking.
My Lords, the welfare system ultimately depends upon a degree of trust and shared responsibility. Those who contribute must have the confidence that their taxes are being spent effectively, that support is going to those who genuinely need it, and those who are capable of working are being given every reasonable opportunity and incentive to do so. Equally, those who depend upon the system must have the confidence that it will provide them with proper support when they need it. For those receiving PIP, that means knowing that assessments will be conducted fairly and consistently, that decisions will reflect their actual needs, and that they will not be penalized simply for attempting to improve their circumstances. These two principles are not in conflict, and indeed I would argue they are mutually dependent.
Before I close, I have some straightforward questions to ask the government. Are PIP assessments consistently and accurately identifying the practical difficulties people face and the additional support they need? Are we sufficiently distinguishing between permanent disabilities, fluctuating conditions, and circumstances in which someone's health or independence might improve? Are the reassessment periods we have sufficient to capture those people whose conditions improve, meaning they no longer require the benefit? Are we doing enough to connect people with treatment, rehabilitation, and practical assistance rather than relying upon financial payments alone?
And are we ensuring that those who wish to return to work or increase their independence can do so without the fear of abruptly losing essential support? We cannot simply continue increasing expenditure without addressing these points, nor should we allow legitimate proposals for reform to be dismissed as a lack of compassion for people with disabilities. We need a disability benefit system which protects those with the greatest needs, provides effective and practical support, helps those who can work to do so, and treats those who pay for it with fairness and respect. That is the balance which the government should seek to restore. It is deeply concerning that they have yet to demonstrate either the political conviction or the practical plan required to do so.
Until we see meaningful reform, we risk not only growing pressure on the public finances, but also a growing loss of confidence in the welfare system itself, and ultimately it is those who depend upon that system most who have the greatest amount to lose. My Lords, I beg to move.
Bryn Davies
I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Jenkin of Kennington, for securing this debate. I look forward to hearing other contributions and in particular the response to the debate from my noble friend Baroness Dakers of Lewisham, who I very much welcome to the front bench. I'm going to address particularly PIP. The motion goes a bit wider, but I think it's really focusing on PIP.
And of course, we will receive the final report of the Tims review next month, followed by a white paper, and we expect legislation in the coming year. So I think it is an appropriate moment for Parliament to discuss the principles that should guide reform and the questions to which the government must provide convincing answers. The decisions taken over the next year will shape the future of support for millions of people with disabilities. Now, the interim report from the review reaches a striking conclusion. While PIP remains highly valued by many who receive it, the system itself is no longer fit for purpose.
The review drew on more than 38,000 responses from people with disabilities, charities, professionals, and others, making it one of the largest exercises of its kind undertaken by the government. And more than 90% of responses concerning the claims process were negative. Now, much of the public debate has focused on the rising cost of PIP. Costs do matter, and no responsible government can ignore them. However, figures on expenditure do not speak for themselves.
They require proper analysis. The overall caseload at any point reflects three separate factors: how many people are making new claims, how many claims are being accepted, and how many people remain entitled to the benefits. If we are to make sensible policy, we need to understand which of these factors is driving growth. Now, reviews and reassessments alone do not explain the increase which has been identified. There has been a genuine rise in reported disability and long-term health conditions, particularly among younger people.
Now, the interim review highlights the changing nature of disability and ill health since PIP was introduced in 2013 by the coalition government. I therefore hope the Minister will ensure that the forthcoming white paper will provide a detailed breakdown of caseload growth, separating the effects of new claims, award rates, and claim duration. We also need to work on the quality of decision-making. The points-based descriptors that underpin PIP have changed little since the benefit was introduced. Throughout that period, they have struggled to deal properly with fluctuating conditions, multiple conditions, and many less visible impairments.
The result is a system that too often fails to capture the realities of the lives of disabled people. The consequences can be seen in the appeals process and the relatively high proportion of changes through the appeals process. The most efficient way to administer any benefit is to make the correct decision at the outset. Now, this brings me inevitably to the question of fraud. Some recent media coverage has created an impression that abuse of PIP is widespread.
That narrative deserves careful scrutiny. Stories about social media influencers explaining how to complete claim forms may generate headlines, but guidance on filling in what are in truth complex applications is not in itself fraud.
What matters is what the department's own evidence shows. The latest DWP estimates put PIP overpayments due to fraud at 1.4% of expenditure in the last fiscal year. That represents an increase and should be taken seriously. However, it also means that over 98% of spending was not lost to fraud. The overall PIP overpayment rate at 2.3% remains below the average across the benefit system.
And it's also important to understand the nature of the fraud that does occur. A substantial proportion arises where an individual's condition has improved and that improvement has not been reported. This is plainly a risk where conditions may change over time. It is much less relevant where conditions are lifelong and progressive. Learning disability is lifelong by definition, and the same is true of many degenerative conditions.
Yet people with such conditions continue to undergo repeated reassessments. That was one of the major complaints to be exposed by the Tims review. More broadly, across all claimants, the great majority of planned reviews lead either to no change or to an increase in entitlement. Those figures raise a legitimate question: are we directing administrative effort to the places where it is most useful? The sensible conclusion is not that everyone should be reviewed more frequently; it is that reviews should be targeted where needs are genuinely likely to change, while people with lifelong conditions should be spared unnecessary reassessment.
Turning to the review, many of the emerging recommendations point in exactly that direction. They include a redesigned, improved application process, improved treatment of fluctuating conditions, and the creation of an advocacy service to support claimants. These proposals are to be welcomed, but good intentions alone will not be enough. An advocacy service without adequate funding will achieve little, and better assessments will require assessors who understand learning disability and other complex conditions. I hope the Minister can assure the House that both will be properly resourced.
The more significant question concerns the long-term future of PIP. The review is exploring a shift away from the current assessment of functional difficulty towards a test linked more directly to categories of disability-related extra costs, while retaining cash support as the foundation of the benefit and preserving its non-means-tested nature. There is an obvious logic here. PIP is described as a contribution towards the extra costs of disability, yet eligibility to now has been determined primarily by functional tests rather than by assessing the costs that people face.
Aligning the assessment more closely with the purpose of the benefit has an intuitive appeal. However, Parliament should not endorse such a change without answers to some important questions. First, there's the question of evidence. Extra costs can be difficult to identify and even harder to quantify. Many are indirect, intermittent, or hidden.
People who need support with communication, decision-making, or money management may find it particularly difficult to document them. How will costs be defined? How will evidence be gathered? And how will the government ensure that fixed categories do not exclude claimants whose circumstances fall outside a predetermined list? Secondly, there's the issue of choice.
The review suggests that some support could potentially be delivered through services or other non-cash provision. Services have a role, but they cannot offer the flexibility of cash. People with disabilities know best what support they need, and any move towards non-cash provision should therefore be optional and claimant-led. Thirdly, there's the question of distributional impact. Reform has to operate within the government's spending framework, but changes within a fixed budget inevitably create both winners and losers.
Parliament will need to see detailed analysis showing the effects by condition, age, and component of the award. That analysis should also consider employment outcomes. It's important to emphasize that PIP is not an out-of-work benefit. Indeed, it's actually a benefit designed towards directing and enabling people to work. PIP is payable both in and out of work, and for many people, it's precisely what makes employment possible.
The interim review has performed a valuable service by bringing together evidence and challenging assumptions. The test now is whether the government respond to that evidence. Reform should be guided neither by expenditure figures in isolation, nor by alarming stories in the press, but by the realities of disabled people's lives and by the goal of creating a system that is fair, accurate, sustainable, and worthy of public confidence.
David Willetts
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Baroness Jenkin on bringing this important subject to the House and also her very important speech with very important facts and statistics within it. And as well as welcoming her in leading this debate, I should also say a word to welcome the Minister, because I believe that for the noble Baroness Davies, this is her first engagement and speech in our chamber as a Minister, and I welcome her to that and look forward to what she's going to say and indeed have at the end of my speech some particular questions I hope she may be able to address. The importance of this issue arises for many reasons, as we've heard from the noble Baroness and indeed the Lord Davies. The well-being of people who are disabled and who are claiming PIP is important, but so is the backdrop of a really shocking increase in spending on welfare benefits, which is estimated to rise by 38 billion pounds in real terms between 2026-7 and 2031-32.
And of that £38 billion increase, it is just worth reporting the components of that £38 billion. £12 billion is non-pensioner health and disability benefits, what we're debating today. £21 billion, significantly more, is increases in spending on the state pension, driven above all by the triple lock. And £6 billion is all other benefit spending. So absolutely it is right to look at what we can do on ensuring that we reduce the costs of benefits for disabled people where the money is not having the effect we hope, but we should just remember the wider context of where the money is going.
I should declare an interest because I am president of the Resolution Foundation, a think tank, and indeed we produced only earlier this month a report, Hard Truths, which is absolutely about the whole issue of PIP, written by my distinguished colleagues there, Lindsay Judge and Louise Murphy, and I'm going to draw on our Resolution Foundation research heavily throughout my remarks. The estimates of the costs of PIP are of course very significant, perhaps running at £35 billion a year or more. And absolutely, this was not what PIP was supposed to do. I was serving as a minister, attending cabinet, when PIP was brought in, and I can still remember it was supposed to be a cost-cutting measure in contrast to DLA, but claims are surging and costs are surging. 36,000 claims a month in 2019, now running at 76,000 claims a month this year.
So it's right to reform it, but reform has to be careful and evidence-based. And at Resolution Foundation, we actually did a survey of 2,500 claimants of PIP to try to understand better exactly what was going on here. PIP of course is an unusual benefit. It's in many ways like child benefit. It is not, it doesn't depend on whether you are working or not, though it is possible that the way that PIP functions is it could be a deterrent or barrier to work.
It is not means-tested. The aim is that it covers the costs of some key condition. It is rather like child benefit, which is also aimed to cover simply the costs of having children. The difference is that knowing whether or not you've got children is rather easier to ascertain than establishing exactly what your disability is and what the condition is and what the costs are. And you could have a condition-based system or a cost-based system.
But perhaps one of the most striking findings in our report at the Resolution Foundation is that 16% of people claiming PIP do not report any costs associated with their condition. However, of those people that we surveyed who are receiving the condition, and the survey was done carefully so it's a representative sample, 47% said that PIP payments helped them or enabled them to do economically valuable activities, and 82% said that it boosted their wellbeing. So in other words, we should be careful as we try to find ways of saving costs and ensuring it only goes to the people who most need it.
It does also have some beneficial effects which must not be sacrificed. There's a lot of talk about particular conditions, and another significant finding from our research was that 56% of claimants of PIP have two or more conditions. And indeed, there's often a mix of physical conditions and mental conditions. In fact, 30% of recipients seem to have a combination, 28% seem to have just a physical condition, 18% just what we'd broadly regard as a mental condition. So we do need to reform it, but we need to reform it with care.
And we have the broad outlines of what we propose at Resolution Foundation is first of all the functional assessment, the assessment of what you are capable of doing, is currently a very domestic set of tasks and we say that should be more outward looking, it should be more focused on what you can do in society and what you can do in the economy. We should also be looking very carefully at a breakdown of PIP. We think that there is a case for a capital element, certain costs which are not regular monthly costs, but certain things that could be paid for that in turn made your condition more manageable. We here, and I have to disagree I think with the point that Lord Davis, the noble Lord Lord Davis with you, we do think there is some value in services, especially accessing services which help functioning and promote participation, including increasing your chances of getting into work. And if the PIP could be used for as a contribution to the cost of receiving these services, we think that could be very useful and help tackle the so-called notorious improvement trap, people who worry that if they do report that they're getting better or are helped to get better, this will cause them to lose the benefit entirely.
We think there needs to be more routine engagement with people on PIP, not left totally disengaged from the system for years on end. And we do believe that there are some lower level conditions which really, given the fiscal environment, should not of themselves lead to an entitlement to PIP. And put all this together, and we think that you can imagine we propose a package that we believe could save four to five billion pounds in PIP. I'd like to now just turn to some specific questions where I hope the Minister can help and give us some advice and guidance. The first issue is young people.
And young people aged 16 to 24 are a group that whose claims for PIP are particularly scrutinized, and there are some people who say they just shouldn't receive PIP. Indeed, there are reports around in the media that Alan Milburn might say they should not receive PIP at all. Now, it is absolutely clear, and again from our research at Resolution Foundation, one quarter of young people receiving PIP say that they have no costs associated with a disability or no condition. So there is absolutely a case for tightening up the regime there. However, the other three quarters do say that they have some costs associated with their condition and say PIP enables them, and this is very relevant for the remit that Alan Milburn has, three quarters say PIP enables them to work, participate in education or volunteer.
So if there is to be a significant reduction in entitlement to PIP for younger people, or it's to be removed entirely in favor of some other new means of helping them work or participate in education, what assurances do we have that Alan Milburn's report will ensure that in some other way those young people who are currently using PIP for exactly the kind of purposes that he wants to get attention and support in order to reduce needs, how can we ensure that simply removing PIP from all of them doesn't have exactly the opposite effect intended and mean for some of these people their risks of being NEET go up rather than go down?
So young people matter. That leads me onto my second point to the Minister if I may, and I hope she will forgive me for this, but education, particularly education for young people aged over 16 or 18 is something that I attach a lot of value to. And the links between education and disability benefits and work are very strong. If you have no qualifications and you are disabled, your chances of being in work are 40% lower than if you have no qualifications and are not disabled. So from amongst people with no qualifications sadly the employment penalty for being disabled is very severe.
If you look at people who have got a degree, the penalty for being disabled, your chances of working if you have a degree and are disabled is 14%, 1-4% lower than for people who have a degree and are not disabled. In other words, one of the many values of higher education, and I was one of the people who unleashed the evidence and fought long battles to get out the evidence on specific pay returns, that some of the benefits to higher education, the wider benefits are captured here. People who've participated in higher education and are disabled, it gives them a massive chance and opportunity of getting into work. And I hope the Minister will assure us that those type of considerations will be very relevant as we look to reform of PIP. And indeed for people who do have a disability, including a mental disability, people with a mental illness or mental problem are more likely to be in work, significantly more likely also to be working despite this condition if they're graduates than if they're not.
Finally two other points to the Minister. Pensioners. Pensioners can't apply for PIP but they can carry on receiving it. In effect PIP becomes a lifetime award if you're a pensioner. There's an argument that actually Attendance Allowance is better suited for the needs of these people and it's actually a lower cost than PIP.
There are already 700,000 pensioners on PIP. Will the government consider this as an area for saving and looking at ways in which Attendance Allowance could be used because this absolute lifetime caseload of people pensioners claiming PIP will grow. The one point on which I was going to disagree I have to say with my noble friend Baroness Jenkin is, and this is my final point to the Minister, is there's a lot of belief in face-to-face assessments. The evidence from our review is if your likelihood of making a successful claim from a face-to-face assessment is 39%, from a video assessment is 40%, from a phone assessment is 41%. The big gap is with paper claims where the chances are 78%.
So we do not need to focus on particularly expensive face-to-face claims, there are other means as well. I very much look forward to the Minister's response to our debate.
George Young
My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Willetts who has shaped progressive thinking on welfare for many years and has asked a number of penetrating questions. I also congratulate my noble friend Baroness Jenkin on her choice of subject for this debate and her thoughtful and balanced introduction. Some 47 years ago I was a minister at what was then the Department of Health and Social Security and my boss was Patrick Jenkin, my noble friend's father-in-law.
And social security expenditure in that year was 19 billion. It's now 333 billion pounds. My Lords, although this is a Conservative-led debate, I want to look at the issue through the eyes of two Labour politicians: Stephen Timms and Alan Milburn. The Timms review asked whether PIP is fair, accessible, and fit for disabled people. Those are the terms of reference, and we have the interim report and emerging recommendations.
The Milburn review is broader, looking across welfare, health, and skills, but is more concerned about the interaction of welfare, including PIP, on incentives to work and the sustainability of welfare expenditure. And again, we have his interim report. Now, the two reports have different remits and different priorities, which in turn, I think, represent the tensions within the government on the way forward on welfare reform. First, Stephen Timms. The press often quote the very words he used himself about PIP not fit for purpose.
And against the background of the current debate about welfare expenditure, some people think that meant it should be cut back. But that is not at all what he meant. I could find one mention in the interim review about finance, but the whole thrust is about making the journey more user-friendly. And if you look at the emerging recommendations, they take forward the terms of reference: improving the experience for people applying for and receiving PIP; increasing the availability of accessible digital services across the PIP journey to streamline the process and improve accessibility; ensure that people who need help to navigate the process can access advocacy services. All highly commendable objectives.
After reading the report, along with other peers, I got an invitation to a virtual briefing session with Stephen Timms and his co-chairs, Sharon Brennan and Dr. Parkinson. And I joined that session, and it reinforced the message of the Timms review that the process could be dehumanizing, soul-destroying, and degrading. And there were some very moving stories indeed in that session. The tone of the Milburn review is different. He approached the subject not so much from the point of view of the claimant, but from that of society as a whole, and in particular the taxpayer.
He's concerned about the cost, and I quote: "Benefit spend on young people for PIP alone is expected to rise to 6.5 billion by 2031-32. If spend on DWP employment support remains at the levels currently being funded through the youth guarantee, we estimate that by 2030-31, for every one pound that DWP spend on employment support for young people, around 10 pounds will be spent on welfare support for young people." And this is what he said: "This is not a spread of investment that prioritizes participation. It is an investment choice that prioritizes income transfers." And when he looked at PIP, this is what he says: "PIP is the welfare system's first point of contact for disabled young people from the age of 16, and for many, it is the only point of contact before an out-of-work claim.
Analysis we have undertaken, however, does not suggest this is achieving good participation outcomes. Administrative data shows that PIP claims are getting longer in duration, with 87% of 16 to 24-year-olds in the 2019 cohort still on the benefit five years later, compared to 74% of the 2013 cohort.
The employment prospects of a young person claiming PIP get 21% worse over six years, whereas for everyone else they get 31% better. And he goes on to say the data makes it clear that PIP does nothing to support this key point of transition from education to work. At no point in a young person's application or journey on PIP are they asked about or supported to work. This is not an accident of delivery, it is how PIP is designed, end of quotes. Now, very different from the Timms approach, which leaves the basic design alone.
So the implication for Milburn is not that we should spend more on PIP, but that we should spend less. And this is what he concludes. It is a symbol of a wider failure on the part of the benefit system to provide practical help for sick and disabled youngsters into work. The consequence is that a disabled young person who seeks support is offered a benefit assessment, not a conversation about their goals, their struggles, the support around them and the help they need. And he goes on to say it measures what someone cannot do and writes a check, it does not ask what they could do and build a plan.
The benefit system is founded on a deficit model of disability, one that pays for what a young person cannot do rather than investing in what they could become. And then he says for a young person with a health condition who is unemployed and potentially seeking work, taking a pathway to inactivity can offer higher income, less hassle and lower risk. This is a perverse incentive. It is the polar opposite of what a participation-first welfare system should be providing and means more and more people are being trapped on benefits, end of quote. Now, on that Milburn claim about higher income, I worked out what a young person under 25 could potentially claim using figures on the government website.
Universal Credit standard, 338 pounds 58 a month. Universal Credit LCWRA, that's limited capacity to work, 429 pounds 80 pence a month. PIP, highest living and highest mobility, 843 pounds 27. Combined, 1,611 pounds 65 pence per month. Now, it could be more were they getting housing benefit.
I then worked out how much a young person could earn doing the national average, 36.7 hours a week, on minimum living wage of 12 pounds 71. And the answer is 2,021 pounds, from which you have to deduct the costs of getting to work, which are on average 55 pounds a week. So you're left with 1,800 against 1,600. But the 1,600 is guaranteed and involves no effort, and the 1,800 isn't. Then it is claimed that not everyone gets the maximum available, and that is indeed the case.
And here I come to my final point, the ability to game the system, something touched on by the noble Lord, Lord Davies. I want to make one thing absolutely clear, I'm entirely in favor of people getting proper advice about applying for PIP, as Lord Davies said. The application form is 20 pages long and it can be a daunting task to complete it. The Timms review makes the point that claimants are entitled to professional advice, and many organizations such as the CAB do exactly that, absolutely right. But if you put into Google help with PIP, the titles of some of the sites are clearly aimed at helping people to game the system.
I quote, PIP assessors hope you don't know this. Beat your PIP phone assessment. PIP telephone assessment masterclass. Seven PIP mistakes don't get caught out. Secrets to scoring maximum PIP points.
Unlock the secret steps for winning your PIP claims, and so they go on. Some of them actually advise you to tell a lie. One site says this. Why do PIP assessors ask you if you have a dog or a pet? Even if you have a pet, just say no, I don't.
They can't prove you have or haven't got one, end of quote. Another site gives the same advice and advises you to go into another room where your PIP pet can't be seen or heard. Another asserts wrongly that the assessor gets paid eighty-five pounds for every refusal. Now, these sites, all on videos, have been seen by tens of thousands of people. Worse, they have been actually monetized by the advertisements that punctuate the sites.
So people are making money by telling lies and assisting fraud. Now, this does underline the point my noble friend made about a more robust assessment process. So the final question I have for the minister is what is her department going to do about all these sites?
Speaker 110
Some statistics, my lords, some raw numbers that are sobering, alarming, and in their way, shaming. Thirty thousand people every day are signing on for long-term invalidity and incapacity benefits. The largest rise, incredibly in every sense, is among people aged between twenty-five and thirty-four, the cohort just above that identified by the noble lord, Lord Willetts. Sixty thousand people every year go straight from university onto long-term sickness benefits. Twenty-five percent of people, twenty-five percent of adults, identify as disabled, which suggests to me that the definition that at least some of them are using is very far from the definition traditionally understood.
Speaker 112
And then of course, the cost. We heard from the noble lady, Baroness Jenkin, that three point four million people are claiming this benefit, that is on the government's own figures supposed to rise to four point one million by the end of this parliament. Now, why is this happening? Well, part of the answer was the lockdown, which introduced a lot of working people who up until then had never really claimed anything from the government to a different way of living. We saw a large move away from employment and into other kinds of grants and benefits all over the world.
Speaker 111
But for some reason, whereas in most Western countries and almost every other European country, that spike was reversed when the lockdown ended from the end of twenty-one, in this country, a lot of it has remained institutionalized. The huge improvements that were made between twenty-ten and twenty-twenty in reducing the number of people who were out of work permanently were reversed almost overnight. Why did that happen? Well, as Warren Buffett's right-hand man Charlie Munger used to say, show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome. And we just heard the incentives very ably adumbrated by the noble lord, Lord Young of Cookham.
Speaker 112
If you can work and earn almost, you know, earn slightly more, almost the same as you'd be getting without doing anything, and the noble lord, Lord Young, was too generous or too polite to point out that of course within those benefits you could also be doing some side-hustling which would push you over the limit, some people, we can hardly blame them, are going to follow the rational incentive.
Speaker 111
And the real tragedy here is not so much for the taxpayer as for the people who get trapped in a life of low income and low expectations. Now, none of what I've said should be remotely controversial, and indeed I think there is a cross-party consensus that the system needs to be tightened up. There was indeed an attempt in another place to tighten up the system, and the reason that that attempt failed and ended up indeed extending some of the claims that were open to people, I think bears scrutiny. I remember talking to a Labour MP, a friend of mine, who showed me on her phone what the WhatsApp groups of some of the Labour MPs were saying. And they were particularly circulating a survey by a disability charity that tabulated by constituency the number of PIP claimants and showed in how many constituencies the number of claimants was bigger than the MP's majority.
Well, those of you, my Lords, who have served in another place will know that that tends to concentrate the minds of parliamentarians. But we are doing people no favours if we shy away from reform. I think we're indeed encouraging an atmosphere where mental health conditions become not just normalized, but almost we almost serve as a vector for more and more of them. I've noticed that this rise in mental health conditions has led to an extraordinary change in language among young people. Ask yourselves, my Lords, when did you last hear somebody under the age of 30 saying, "I am unhappy," rather than "I'm depressed," which is almost always their go-to adjective?
Speaker 115
Or when did you last hear them saying, "This makes me nervous," rather than "This is giving me anxiety"? Or "This is giving me PTSD" is one that I hear from a lot of my children's friends. No, no, that's probably not PTSD, that's someone said something mean to you, it's not quite the same thing. But as we normalize the medicalization of language, it's no surprise that people genuinely think that they are succumbing to these conditions. Indeed, I read that there is so much so many antidepressants are being flushed into our sewage system that it's beginning to affect the fish in the channel.
Speaker 114
Must be true because I read it in the Daily Mail. And so are we doing anybody any favours, other than those MPs worried about their majorities, when we shy away from tackling these conditions? I agree very much with what Lady Jenkins said at the beginning, right? What is the rationale for having these personal independence payments? Well, the clue is in the name, they are to deal with the additional costs that come from a disability.
Speaker 112
Now, we can all see that if by disability we understand what was traditionally understood, somebody who has a physical impairment, that there might be costs, that you might need to adjust the access to their house, there'd be transport difficulties, there might be care. How does somebody who has anxiety or depression have a more expensive lifestyle than somebody who is unemployed but does not have those conditions? And I don't mean for a moment to belittle those really very unpleasant conditions, but it does not follow, unpleasant as they are, that they lead to a more expensive lifestyle. It's quite extraordinary that as the word the definition of disability has expanded, we haven't adjusted its financial consequences. Perhaps the key point is this: for those who really do suffer from anxiety, depression, or related mental health conditions, are we helping them when we encourage them to stay home taking pills?
When we give benefits payments that discourage people from working, we cut them off from the things that are usually the surest route, not in every single case, but usually the surest route towards recovery.
Speaker 111
We all need to be needed. We all need to have others relying on us. Taking people out of employment takes that very real psychological need away, or that very real psychological prop away, and often worsens the condition that we are purporting to care about. So my Lords, I hope that we will have the courage and the vision properly to tackle this growing problem. Problem, yes, for the economy of the nation, but problem much more seriously, much more gravely, for that growing number of millions of our fellow citizens who are trapped in these lifestyles.
Speaker 113
Show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome. The incentive for us should be to do the right thing by those of our fellow citizens who have been put in this situation and to do the right thing by our own duty as parliamentarians.
Speaker 116
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Baroness Jenkin of Kennington for securing this debate and share in the welcome of my noble friend Lord Willetts and the welcome for the Minister, the noble Baroness the Minister in her new responsibilities on the front bench. And particularly important obviously that we should be debating this matter in advance of publication of two very significant forthcoming reviews on the Milburn review and the Timmins review. My Lords, I declare an interest as director of Policy Exchange, which has undertaken extensive work on disability benefits over the past couple of years. I draw noble Lords' attention in particular to two reports by my colleague Jean-André Prager, who will be known to some of you and who played a significant part in policymaking on these matters under a number of previous governments over the past decade. Firstly, For Whose Benefit, and secondly, Lapse of Judgment, which have examined both the purpose of PIPs and along with that the constitutional questions surrounding its administration.
It is through these particular lenses that I'm going to focus my comments today. Jean-Andre Prager correctly puts it, there is sometimes a reductive quality to our desire to protect disabled people. Protection, though always well-intentioned, can become a form of infantilization at times, overlooking the great economic and creative potential of disabled people. Our disability benefit system embeds this paternalism in its architecture. Too often, however, it defines disabled people by their functional limitations rather than what their potential or their capabilities are.
Speaker 117
If we focus exclusively on what disabled people cannot do, PIP can never act as a means of empowerment for disabled people. Our approach therefore should be recalibrated to enable disabled people first and foremost and then to protect them when necessary. This brings me to a second, I think equally important point. If we're to reconsider what PIP is intended to achieve, we must also ask some difficult questions about who exactly should be entitled to it. As the Secretary of State for DWP has said to the Times recently, we began this decade with 2.4 million people claiming PIP.
Today, that figure stands at 4.1 million, with projections suggesting 5.4 million by the end of the decade. Expenditure is forecast to double to 41 billion over the decade, which is indeed more than double what we spend on the British Army. These are staggering figures and they underline the need for a benefit system capable of adapting to the changing world around it. That adaptation needs to take place in that way rather than allowing eligibility criteria to evolve without regular parliamentary scrutiny as has happened too often to date.
Eligibility criteria should not, therefore, be treated as immutable. They must be reviewed regularly to reflect changing medical understanding, technological advances, and the objectives which Parliament intends the welfare system to serve. It must, in short, be properly accountable. Policy Exchange has recommended that the government reviews PIP criteria every two years to ensure that they remain an appropriate proxy for the additional costs disabled people must face. I implore that the minister take forward this recommendation and for the government to create a more responsive PIP system.
My Lords, we need fundamentally to reform PIP to ensure that it meets the needs of disabled people, retains public consent, and remains sustainable for many years to come. Our PIP system should be an enabler, and it is my firm belief in the enormous contribution that disabled people make in our society that motivates my comments today. My Lords, my first thanks to Baroness Jenkin for setting this debate in process, and I trust the government will listen to the interesting comments which have been and are being made. I welcome the new front bench and wish them well. My Lords, I want to begin with a practical question about whether the benefit system responds when people tell it that their circumstances have changed.
Speaker 118
I recently raised with the Minister Baroness Sherlock the case of someone receiving sickness benefits who had reported that he had recovered, but was still waiting for a reassessment four years later. I was not asking the minister, and I'm not now asking the minister, to discuss an individual's personal circumstances. What I'm asking is about the administration of the system. Could I ask the minister how common are delays of this kind? How many people who have reported an improvement in their condition are still awaiting reassessment?
How long have they been waiting, and what has been done to put it right? If someone tells the department that their circumstances have changed, surely they should be able to expect a timely response. This is not a question about an individual, it's a question about how the department operates. But my Lords, let me be equally clear about what I'm not arguing. I'm not calling for everyone to face more frequent assessments.
We need fewer unnecessary reassessments, particularly for people with lifelong or degenerative conditions. Repeatedly asking someone to demonstrate needs that have not changed serves neither the claimant nor the taxpayer. My Lords, we need to distinguish between reassessments that serve a purpose and those that simply repeat and repeat and repeat what is already known. Reducing unnecessary reassessments and responding promptly to reported changes are not contradictory objectives. They are two elements of a competent administration.
Turning specifically to PIP, we must distinguish between failures in the way the benefit operates and the value of the support it provides. PIP helps people meet the extra costs of disability. It is not, it is not an out-of-work benefit. People can receive it while working, and becoming able to work does not in itself mean that they no longer qualify. The distinction matters.
Otherwise, we risk discussing disability benefits as though everybody receiving them is in the same position, with the same needs and the same prospects. My Lords, they are not. For many people, PIP is a lifeline, not a luxury. Its purpose is to support independence and participation, helping disabled people exercise choices that others can take for granted. Payment in cash is an important strength of the system.
By that, I mean giving people control over how the money is spent. Disabled people should be able to decide how best to meet their own needs, rather than having those decisions made arbitrarily for them. An extra journey may help with a daily task, or a different way of managing life at home may seem a small matter to someone else. To the individual concerned, it may make the difference between dependence and independence. That freedom should be protected in any reform.
I hope the department will think about that. We must also take care with the language of this debate. Rising claimant numbers deserve scrutiny. Ministers must explain expenditure, account for decisions, and demonstrate that public money is being used properly. But a debate dominated by numbers risks losing sight of the people behind them.
We should not allow legitimate questions about administration, which I've made, and affordability, which I've made, to become a general suspicion of people who need support. Nor should we make someone feel that applying for help is an admission of failure. A fair system must command public confidence, but it must also command the confidence of those who depend upon it. This brings me to the assessment process. In our 2024 manifesto, the Liberal Democrats call for greater transparency in PIP assessments and an end to unnecessary reassessments.
Those remain important objectives, but transparency alone is not enough. We need decisions that are better informed, more accurate, and easier to understand. Assessors need the training and time to understand how conditions interact. They must be able to recognise that the effects of disability and ill health can fluctuate. An assessment should not reduce someone's life to how they appear during a single appointment.
Someone may manage a task on one occasion but struggle to repeat it. They may present confidently while finding daily life extremely difficult. The question should be what someone can manage in practice, not simply what an assessor sees in what is often a brief encounter. Supporting evidence must be properly considered, and decisions explain clearly how that evidence has been weighed. When a decision is wrong, the individual should not have to become an expert in the benefit system to challenge it.
Getting decisions right first time should be a central measure of success, not an aspiration left at the margins of reform. We must also recognise the limits of what benefits reform alone can achieve.
Changing an assessment process cannot substitute for timely NHS treatment. It cannot by itself make a workplace accessible or ensure that appropriate employment support is available. If the government wants more disabled people who can work to either remain in employment or enter employment, it must address those practical barriers along with the benefit system. And disabled people must have a meaningful role throughout the reform process, not simply be invited to comment after the principal decisions have been made. Their experience should help shape the questions asked, the evidence considered, and the way success is measured.
So I today ask the minister for three assurances. First, that unnecessary reassessments will be reduced while reported changes in circumstances are dealt with promptly, and the government will provide information enabling us to judge progress. Secondly, that the assessor training and the use of supporting evidence will improve with a clear focus on getting decisions right first time. And thirdly, that disabled people will help design and evaluate reform with their independence and dignity treated as essential tests of success. And lastly, after those three items, not to forget the person who asked for a reassessment and was not given it, is that a one-off?
We should not have to choose between compassion and competent administration. A properly functioning system must provide both. It should support people when they need help, respond when their circumstances change, and explain its decisions clearly. That is how we build trust, not through repeated promises for reform, but through a system that works fairly, accurately, and with respect for the people it serves. The many points are made during this debate.
It's not against PIP. It's showing the value of PIP and how it needs to be administered.
Speaker 119
My Lords, I thank my noble friend Baroness Jenkin for putting down this important motion, and I also welcome Baroness Dakers to the front bench. Yesterday, the Chancellor delivered a budget that left one of the greatest challenges facing this country untouched. He did acknowledge this in an interview yesterday when he said, "There will be a reduction in the benefits bill, and we'll do that in a labour way." I can hardly express how inadequate this is as a statement of government willingness to tackle a real crisis. Others have already rehearsed the terrifying arithmetic.
Speaker 121
The OBR has said unequivocally that the borrowing trajectory is unsustainable. But this is not just a financial crisis. It's a crisis for those who act rationally, using the safety net of sickness and disability benefits at points of real need, but for whom the net becomes a trap, confining them to worklessness as efficiently as a lobster pot. It's a crisis for the young people who turn to benefits in a labour market where their job opportunities have been drastically curtailed by Labour's poorly directed tax, national insurance, and minimum wage measures, and by the Employment Rights Act. It's a crisis for those with mild mental health conditions who could and should live and work normally with just a little extra help, but who are incentivized by the availability of these benefits to drop out of work, or worse, never start work.
Speaker 120
It's a crisis for those who see others exploiting disability benefits to achieve lifestyles that many working families cannot hope for.
This is understandably breeding cynicism and disaffection, and moral corruption is contagious. It's also a crisis for those with real and serious disabilities who need a fair and stable welfare system and are unfairly tainted by the increasing suspicion and distrust around PIP and its claimants. And all this is a disaster for the mutual trust and cohesion that are essential to sustain public willingness to pay for a generous welfare state. Many people are now studying this, most recently Fraser Nelson in his excellent project at The Times. The Centre for Social Justice has also been looking forensically at the problems for years.
The Chancellor's done another media round today to respond to criticisms that his speech essentially ignored what must be a flashing red light on the Treasury dashboard. Now he's promised proposals before the end of the year after the Melburn and Timms reviews are published. So what indications do we have of what the Labour way might be? First, we have the ill-fated Liz Kendall reforms. These were a serious if modest attempt to start tackling the growing problem.
But the government was unable to carry them through, forced to eviscerate its plans by its own backbenchers. This is not encouraging. Next, we have the Timms review. As my noble friend Lord Young has pointed out, there's little in its interim report to give confidence. The Minister's assertion when this was published was, I quote, "My view is that the current level of spending is not a great concern."
Yet the OBR has already had to revise its projections for PIP substantially upwards. The Green Paper from which the review arose rightly emphasized that good work is good for health and plays a vital role in recovery from illness. Not all disabled people can work, but for the majority who can, work gives more than just income. It gives purpose, social interaction, and respect. Much of the recent rapid growth in disability relates to ADHD, autism, and other mental health conditions such as anxiety, and in most cases, these conditions should not be a barrier to work.
Speaker 121
Yet the interim report quotes without apparent concern a recent finding that of non-working disability benefit recipients, only one in 20 believed they could work now, even with the right job or support. And only just over a quarter thought they might be able to work in future if their condition improved. That leaves more than two-thirds believing that they will never be able to work, some of them very young or in the prime of life. This finding, and the fact that only 20% of PIP claimants are working, and that the longer they claim, the less likely they are to work, casts serious doubt on the suitability of PIP for many of those currently claiming it, as my noble friend Lord Young has also pointed out. Granting PIP to anxious teenagers may be downright cruel.
Speaker 120
It doesn't help young people into work, it doesn't convince them that they're capable of maturing into resilient adults. Instead, it confirms their own pessimistic self-assessments and very likely locks them into dependency for life. It is so easy for the state to be kind on a short-term view and so much harder to be honest about what will really help young people in the long term. The Timms review should have asked about disability definitions. The UK uses a harmonized definition of disability based on individual perception, self-perception I should say, rather than clinical diagnosis.
The ONS has published a study showing that roughly three times as many people are categorized as disabled under our definition as under the UN-recommended Washington Group methodology.
This may help explain why reported disability has risen in Britain in recent years at rates not seen elsewhere. Yet Britain is not unique. Other countries experienced similar levels of COVID, others have similar levels of poverty. We have universal free healthcare. We don't carry any particular genetic disadvantage.
So why do we have high and increasing disability? How much of it comes from perceiving as disability what's previously been considered normal variability in the human condition? How much comes from poor welfare system incentives? At the margin, does a disability label help or hinder? As my noble friend Lord Godson said, are we infantilizing or empowering people here?
This needs honest analysis and discussion. So in the light of all this, it is indeed disappointing that the interim Tims recommendations were mostly about improving the claimant experience rather than addressing more fundamental concerns. So I turn to the Milburn review. This is more encouraging. Much of the Milburn diagnosis is accurate and expressed admirably clearly and frankly.
He has said that welfare spend must come down to make way for better support to get young people into work. But this might translate in the face of fractious backbenchers into a minimalist approach, just enough welfare reduction to fund a support package, nothing that will make a real impact on our parlous national financial position. A common theme from government ministers and reviewers is the importance of supporting people into work, which is true. But what isn't acknowledged is the fundamental problem that for too many people, if they can succeed with a PIP claim and the passported benefits that brings, including unlocking the benefit cap, they are often better off financially on benefits. And no amount of support and encouragement will stop most rational people on an unconditional package of benefits from doing that arithmetic.
And even though PIP is not means-tested, people do see working as a risk to maintaining their claim to the benefit. The disappointing findings published this week from the government's Connect to Work program, meant to help health and disability claimants back to work, they show that support does not compensate for unbalanced incentives. Despite a budget of over a billion for the program, take-up has been very low, including from young people. NEET numbers were declining pre-COVID but have risen steeply since and stand at close to a million. Yet only 6,000 young people in that age bracket have signed up for Connect to Work.
That's less than 1% of NEETs. In the first 15 months of the whole scheme, fewer than a thousand people have worked for more than 18 hours a week for at least 26 weeks. Sadly, the likelihood is that spending on support will make little difference unless the incentive to claim disability benefits is reduced. And as I touched on earlier, there also need to be jobs. A government that destroys jobs quickly builds up a sticky welfare pipeline.
That pipeline is starting much earlier than many people realize. I talk to head teachers who are profoundly uncomfortable about the pressure they experience from parents to have perfectly normal children labeled as SEND to help the parents claim Child Disability Living Allowance. Claims for child DLA have shot up in the last two years. Why?
Well, it's a generous cash allowance that also unlocks other benefits and disapplies the household benefit cap. I know of one case where a parent is refusing to potty train their seven-year-old because that would remove the justification for their DLA claim. That child is being betrayed by the parent. And most DLA children move on to PIP at age 16, even though many should have outgrown childhood problems by then. We should be ashamed of this.
And finally, I welcome the announcement of 2,000 additional DWP investigators to follow up on suspicious welfare claims. It may have been unwise for the Tims interim report to dismiss the distrust associated with PIP as a false and damaging narrative derived from stigma and misinformation. Since I took up this role, so many people have told me of someone they know personally who is claiming PIP but who either is not meaningfully disabled or whose disability does not bring extra costs. And my noble friend Lord Willetts has shown solid evidence that these cases are far from exceptional. But while extra investigators are a good thing, fraudsters are deterred by a high likelihood of detection and sanction, it doesn't begin to address the problems of a disability benefit system that is now, quite simply, incentivising worklessness and trapping the youngest adults and now also children in an indefensible way.
So I'm going to add a few more questions to those put by my noble friend Baroness Jenkin and my other noble friends. What exactly does the Chancellor mean by reducing the welfare bill in a Labour way? What assessment is the government making of the impact of our unusually broad definition of disability? What steps is the government taking to identify and eliminate disability-linked welfare traps, as happens in Sweden with their FASIT model? And what work is the government doing to establish whether claiming child DLA improves or worsens the long-term outcomes for a child?
Seb Dance
My Lords, I'm grateful to all of you who've participated in this debate. If I cannot respond to all points and questions that have been raised, I will review Hansard and I'll write to noble Lords and place something in the library. Now we've had a wonderful debate this afternoon. We've covered a huge variety of issues and touched upon the lives of millions of people with disabilities and long-term health conditions across the country. And today's debate has been an invaluable opportunity to address some of the topics that go beyond party political debates and go to the heart of what really matters.
And it's about what we expect from our welfare state, how to recognise the lived experiences of those with disabilities, and how to support and empower disabled people to live an independent, fulfilling life with opportunities and choices to participate fully in society. And with that said, I would like to thank the noble Baroness Jenkin of Kennington for bringing this debate to the House today. We truly appreciate it, as you could hear from all the contributions we've had today. Now, as has been commented by many Lords, there are millions of people relying on Personal Independence Payment, or PIP, to help them meet the costs associated with daily living, mobility, communication, transport, equipment, support services, and countless other aspects of just living an everyday life. Entitlement to PIP is assessed on the basis of the needs arising from the health condition or disability, rather than the health condition or disability itself.
The central purpose was and remains to help with the extra costs associated with a disability and long-term health health conditions. And I just want to acknowledge, if I can find my notes, sorry, excuse me, basically the noble Lord who I believe was at the genesis of from what he was saying as a minister when PIP first came into being, so I just wanted to acknowledge that. So similarly with work work capability assessments or WCA, we that determines the eligibility for employment support allowances and additional health-related amounts of Universal Credit, but it assesses an individual's capability for work. And that's a key principle for both assessments, is to consider the impact of that person's disability or health condition, be it temporary, be it fluctuating condition on their day-to-day lives. But while the purpose of these assessments has remained the same, the world around us has continually changed.
The labour market has changed, technology has changed, healthcare has changed, society's understanding of disability has evolved. My Lords, before discussing where reforms may be needed, it is important to be clear about the principle of and values that underpin the government's approach. A successful state should prevent people from falling into long-term economic inactivity. We should be helping more people into work, restoring trust through a fair and effective assessment system, and protect those who cannot work by supporting them to live independently with dignity. It also needs to ensure that the system is financially sustainable and to keep providing for those who need it most.
The budget on the 28th of October set out our latest forecast on government spending. Before I go further, my Lords, I just want to just talk a little bit about the clearance times, because we are committed to ensuring that people across can access financial support through PIP in a timely manner, and that's been mentioned by a number of Lords this afternoon. Reducing the claimant's journey through the times that a PIP claimant is a priority for the department, and we are working constantly to make improvements to our services. I'd further like to assure you that we are always aiming to make an award decision as quickly as possible. I know the Lord Noble Lord Palmer had mentioned this as well as Lord Davis.
We need to take into account the needs to review all available evidence, including that from claimants, and I shall come back and return back to Baroness Jenkins' points regarding face-to-face assessments. But we have seen a decrease in PIP clearance times since August 2021, with the latest statistics showing that the average end-to-end journey has reduced from 26 weeks in August 2021 to 18 weeks by the end of July 2026.
And this is because we have a blend of phone, video, face-to-face assessments to support claimants and deliver a more efficient and user-centered service. Increasing case manager and assessment provider health professional resources. Making sure that we're improving on training those who are doing these assessments and prioritizing new claims while safeguarding claimants awaiting award reviews. My Lords, you, as I know you have, are aware of the Timms review because a number of noble Lords have mentioned it this afternoon. It's been referred to by Lord Palmer, Lord Young, Lord Davis, and it's the very first full review of PIP.
And possibly some might say long overdue, which seeks to ensure that we have a system that supports disabled people to achieve a better health and high living standards with greater independence, including through employment. On the 9th of September, the review shared a set of emerging recommendations. Now, these are not the final recommendations, which will be, as we know, that will be published by the end of the year. But it was a starting point for the steering group to be able to test and challenge and improve with feedback going back to the Timms review. And I think that sort of symbolizes maybe possibly part of what might be a Labour ethos of nothing about us without us.
The Timms review, as you know, is being co-produced with disabled people, the organizations that represent them, and other experts. This means that the government is sharing ownership and responsibility for how the review runs and what it recommends. The Timms review is not working towards a fixed set of outcomes. It's listening to the lived experience and expertise of disabled people because that is critical to the success of this review. So we cannot today preempt what the recommendations will be, but we shall patiently wait.
And I acknowledge what Lord Young mentioned in his contribution, that there needs to be a balance between the Timms review and the Milburn review. The Milburn review, as he said, is taking a broader look at welfare, health, education, skills, and employment. And it is focusing on, you know, the challenges facing young people who are not in education, employment, or training. And we look forward to the final report and the policy recommendations that will help young people to access education, training, and employment. As I said, these are not the final recommendations.
But moving on to PIP expenditure and the caseloads, which have grown substantially over recent years. And as of 2006, which has been mentioned earlier, around 4 million people receive PIP. A responsible government cannot ignore the long-term sustainability of the system. The system must remain capable of supporting future generations as well as today's claimants. But alongside this, we have to be, we've been clear that we need to build a welfare system that supports participation and opportunity.
And that is part of what the Milburn review is looking at.
So looking ahead, both the Timms review and the Milburn review will play a central role in shaping the future direction of policy. Lord Young mentioned that there could be tensions in that, but we shall wait and see how that flows when we get the full report. But the onus will be on us as members of this House and the other place to look at the reviews and to work together for the best benefit of those who we seek to help through such, you know, through PIP and through getting people into work, into employment, regardless of age, with disability or without disabilities. But I can assure the House that the government will consider the recommendations and the reviews very carefully. I'll now attempt to continue to address other points that was raised during this debate.
So I'll make my first stop regarding the budget yesterday that was brought forward by Baroness Spillman. The Chancellor and the Prime Minister have both said clearly that we have to bring the benefit bill down and fix the broken welfare system we inherited. But you don't do that by crude cuts, especially when people are feeling the cost of living pressures. As I've mentioned already, we have two ongoing reviews which are due imminently, and the Chancellor set out the government will respond by the end of the year. But we aren't complacent.
We are already taking action. We are already delivering on a welfare reform, but in different ways. We have been rebalancing Universal Credit to reduce the incentive to be labelled too sick to work, increasing face-to-face assessments for health benefits, which declined under the previous government. We're reforming mobility and tax breaks restricted to save over one billion over the next five years. And we are acting to get young people into work with record funding for apprenticeships, grants for businesses taking unemployed young people and our youth guarantee programme.
I said that I would come back to Baroness Jenkin and the face-to-face assessments, which are sometimes the best way for some people to get their assessments. It allows for a more human approach where people can sit down and better explain their circumstances or show what they are, or illustrate their condition which affects them in practice. It helps to ensure that decisions are fair and accurate and based on the whole picture. But that's just one part of the routes that we can take to do such assessments. It's an important part and one which we have taken seriously, and we plan to increase our face-to-face delivery by 30%.
And we are already making steps to increase and improve that face-to-face assessment. By July 2026, face-to-face accounted for 14.6% of PIP consultations and 23% of WCA consultations. So as you can see, we are moving in the right direction and we will continue to do so. Another point that was raised was regarding the PIP criteria for individuals' abilities over and the fluctuating conditions that was mentioned by Baroness Jenkin, Lord Davis and Lord Palmer. So the criteria to consider individuals' ability is over a 12-month period, ensuring that fluctuations are taken into account.
It is essential for assessments to accurately reflect the impact of those variations in individual levels of impairment. This is important for all health conditions and impairment, not only those with more typically fluctuating conditions.
Lord Palmer you mentioned about sorry Lord Palmer regarding mentioned about workplace capability assessments. Now claimants who report deteriorations in their health conditions or new conditions continue to be referred for reassessment but are waiting longer than we would like. We are prioritizing the initial assessments over reassessments but we're also prioritizing those who are looking to get seek employment in a few weeks time so that they can get their assessments to make sure that they are having the right assessments for when they go into work so that's another thing that we are doing. We know that this is a very important issue for claimants and stakeholder groups which is why we're urgently considering options for expediting reassessments of these cases as part of our wider intentions set out in the pathways to work green paper to resume assessments at a scale when capacity in the system allows. Regarding awards durations which was raised by Noble Lord David and Palmer it may be helpful if I explain that once somebody has been awarded PIP which can be paid at one of eight rates the awards can either be reviewed or the claimant will be required to submit a new claim.
Award rates and their durations are set out on an individual basis based on the claimant's needs and the likelihood of those needs changing. The government is also prioritizing welfare reform putting work and opportunity at the center of our system should support should support people to get into work and to get on in work while ensuring that those who cannot work get the support that they need. We've already discussed at length the Milburn and Tims review but in the meantime we will continue reshaping the system into one that puts work at the center while we always support those who may not be able to work. I'd also like to discuss about accuracy that's a point that has been made by Lord Davis and Baroness Jenkin. It is our aim to make the right decision as early as possible in the claimant's journey.
To support this we have made improvements to our decision making process to help ensure that people get the support that they are entitled to without needing to appeal. This includes giving the decision makers additional time to proactively contact claimants if they think additional evidence is required and may support their claim. It is a fundamental principle of our legal and political system that citizens should be able to challenge decisions made by the government through the legal system. Mandatory reconsideration is a key element of the department's decision making process. It offers claimants the opportunity to challenge decisions and provide additional information which may be relevant to their claim.
Since the summer of 2026 where claimants tell us that they no longer consider themselves to have restricted ability to work their case is reviewed to determine whether they have limited capability for work or limited capability for work and work related activity status should continue. The review considers whether there is sufficient evidence that the claimant's circumstances have changed. In clear cases the decision maker can remove the LCW or LCWRA status without any further assessment.
Where there is doubt, including where health conditions are complex or fluctuating, the claimant may be referred for a reassessment. In some cases, following the review, entitlement remains unchanged. For example, where the claimant has reported a change in error or available evidence does not support removal. I'd like to also bring to the chamber this afternoon that the government is committed to giving disabled people and people with health conditions the confidence that working will not trigger a reassessment and potential loss of benefit. I hope that reassures Baroness Jenkins, Lord Young, about the principle of right to try.
There are already rules in place that are intended to encourage working-age people who are in receipt of health and disability benefits, be it PIP, Universal Credit, or the new style Employment and Support Allowance, to try work. Yet the DWP suggests there is a lack of awareness in these rules, and we shall be working to ensure that this is widely promoted and that those who wish to seek and have the right to try take advantage of this opportunity, as well as what we do, as well as the welfare reforms in putting opportunities at the center of everything that we do. I haven't had the opportunity to talk about or to mention about the claims management system. Lord Young and Lord Davis talked about, you know, the codes that we have online and claimants that are getting sort of poor information or people taking advantage. We will be introducing a new code of practice in the coming weeks that clamps down on the activity by claim managements, as well as the work that we're doing in guiding people to the government website so claimants get the right information firsthand.
My Lords, I just want to thank you all for your contributions this afternoon. We want to, I want to ensure the noble Lords across the house that we will engage constructively with the process of building a fair and trusted sustainable welfare state that is centered on the need of disabled people.
Speaker 104
Thank the noble lady for her response and wish her luck in the many debates which lie ahead for her. I was glad to hear that she'll be writing to us to address some of the many points that she was unable to do so in her remarks. As I hope the noble lady takes from the many powerful speeches by my noble friends Lord Godson, Baroness Fielman, Lords Willetts and Lord Young of Cookham, who speak from considerable and relevant government experience, this is a topic about which there is tremendous concern on these benches, especially given the delays in the publication of the Milburn review. I therefore hope that we'll have time soon in this chamber to debate both reviews and then the concrete proposals to address the welfare budget that should follow swiftly. So finally, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken today.
I appreciate their commitment to this important topic and their willingness to be here for what I think I described earlier as the graveyard shift.
Speaker 94
The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. My Lords, I will press on because I don't think the statutory instruments are going to take us very long.
Speaker 131
I hope not. We come to some instruments previously debated in Grand Committee. Pneumoconiosis etc. Workers' Compensation Payment of Claims Amendment Number 2 Regulations 2024 and one other motion. Lord Kats on behalf of Baroness Sherlock.
Speaker 127
My Lords, I beg leave to move the motions standing in the name of my noble friend Baroness Sherlock on the order paper en bloc.
Speaker 130
The question is that the two motions in the name of Baroness Sherlock be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. And the second one, Human Rights Act 1998 Remedial Order 2024.
Lord Kats on behalf of Lord Lemas.
Speaker 129
My Lords, I beg leave to move the motion standing in the name of my noble friend Lord Lemas on the order paper.
Speaker 126
The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.
The question is that the House do now adjourn.