Justice Committee

3 November 2026

Justice Committee House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:07 - 01:00
Speaker 2
Order.  Welcome to the session of the Justice Committee.  This session has been designed to provide the committee with evidence about how we improve the way we learn from inquests.  For our first panel, we will be hearing from three witnesses with lived experience of inquest: Johnny Santer, Richard Caseby and Dr Kate Shimankiewicz.  Nearly got there. 

For our second panel, we'll be hearing from Deborah Coles, Executive Director of INQUEST, and Dr Georgia Richards, the founder and director of the Preventable Deaths Tracker.  But before we begin our questions, I'm going to ask members of the committee to briefly introduce themselves and make any declarations of interest.  Can I start with Sir Ashley? 
01:00 - 01:08
Speaker 4
Good afternoon.  I'm Ashley Fox, the Member of Parliament for Bridgwater.  I'm a former solicitor and my interests are on the register. 
01:08 - 01:29
Speaker 28
Good afternoon, I'm Neil Shastri-Hurst, I'm the Member of Parliament for Solihull West and Shirley.  Prior to coming to this place, I was a barrister who undertook a large number of inquests as part of my work.  I was also a medical clinician working in Birmingham for a period of time at a number of hospitals, albeit not in the field of psychiatry. 
01:29 - 01:47
Speaker 10
Hello, I'm Vikki Slade, Member of Parliament for Mid Dorset and North Poole and my interests are as per the register, none relevant for this committee.  But I should declare that I do know Kate, as Kate and Ruth used to live in my constituency. 
01:47 - 02:01
Speaker 2
I'm Catherine Atkinson, I'm the MP for Derby North and chair of the Justice Committee and I'm a non-practicing barrister, having practiced for 17 years, including undertaking work at in inquests. 
02:01 - 02:20
Speaker 15
I'm Tessa Munt, I'm the Member of Parliament for Wells and Mendip Hills, in Somerset.  I'm also the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Penal Reform, and a director and vice chair of WhistleblowersUK, which is a not-for not-for-profit organisation. 
02:20 - 02:39
Speaker 17
Hello, good afternoon, I'm Warinder Juss, Member of Parliament for Wolverhampton West.  I'm a member of the GMB trade union, Central Executive Council.  I'm a solicitor, but not practicing at the moment.  Co-chair of the APPG on legal and constitutional affairs, and a officer and member of various other APPGs. 
02:39 - 02:50
Speaker 3
Hello, I'm Sarah Russell, I'm Member of Parliament for Congleton in Cheshire.  I am a solicitor and I chair the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Access to Justice. 
02:50 - 02:55
Speaker 1
I have other interests that are on the register, as you would expect: member of various trade unions. 

02:55 - 03:06

Janet Jessica Daby

Lovely, so I'm Janet Daby, Member of Parliament for Lewisham East, a London MP, and I have nothing to declare for this committee and everything is on the Register of Interests as usual.

03:06 - 03:17

Tony Vaughan

Hi there. My name is Tony Vaughan, the MP for Folkestone and Hythe. I'm an associate tenant at Doughty Street Chambers and I'm a barrister, practiced for many years and hold a practicing certificate.

03:17 - 03:37

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you. Could we start by my asking each of you to introduce yourselves and say a few words about why you want to change the current approach when it comes to following up on inquests, and I thought if we could start with Johnny and then Richard and then Kate.

03:37 - 04:09

Johnny Santer

Thank you very much, Catherine.

So, my name is Johnny Santer and I am the founder and campaign director for Gabe's Law, after we had the multi-storey car park safety bill introduced into Parliament in 2023. And I'm here really because I believe, through lived experience and lived experience of others who I've been in contact with, that the current system that we have unfortunately at the moment is woefully inadequate. It's broken.

04:10 - 05:27

Richard Caseby

Hello. My name is Richard Caseby. I'm here on behalf of my son, Matthew, who died at the age of 23 back in 2020. He'd suffered an acute psychotic episode, and three days after being admitted to the Priory Woodbourne hospital in Birmingham, he escaped. He escaped over a very low fence whilst left unaccompanied in a courtyard.

Other patients had escaped over the same fence before, but the Priory had done nothing to fix it. And 14 hours later, he stood in front of a train. I'd rushed up from London to search for him, and I was 200 yd away from him when he was hit by the train, just 2 miles from the hospital, but mercifully I didn't actually see it happen. So, I've campaigned extremely hard over several years for accountability in my son's case, through the investigative process, which I did myself, the coronial process, the criminal process, because the Priory was convicted in a Crown Court, and, finally, the civil litigation that followed. And along the way, I've learned there are many urgent changes that need to be made to the coronial service, and specifically the PFD report process and how it functions once the inquest is over.

05:27 - 05:31

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you, Richard. Kate.

05:31 - 08:06

Kate Szymankiewicz

Thank you, everyone. I'm here really as Ruth's mom. I am a GP. My husband's a cancer surgeon, and our daughter, Ruth, died just over four and a half years ago. She was an inpatient at the time in a NHS-commissioned, privately-run hospital with an eating disorder.

She'd been there for four and a half months, and we'd spent every day of that time fighting for her to be placed somewhere more appropriate for her to have the care that she needed, for her to have access to her family. And her inquest was just last summer. The jury at her inquest concluded that she had been unlawfully killed, which is pretty much the most damning outcome you can have at an inquest. And there was a whole litany of systemic failures that they've listed for that. Our coroner didn't decide that he should go ahead with issuing a PFD, and our experience really, having been through that whole incredibly traumatic process, was that it didn't really lead to anything, and nothing really has changed from when Ruth was in that hospital, from when she died.

And I've ended up following all sorts of threads in trying to create that change myself with various things, with the Mental Health Act last year, with work that I'm doing with the Department of Health, trying to enable children in mental health units to have access to their families, which seems like a really basic principle, but also with trying to get national eating disorder strategy and a tic and Tourette's disorder service.

There are so many elements, as that jury found in that list of failures, but really that, I'm here because it felt like the inquest process doesn't really serve a purpose to create a change. And as someone who professionally kind of likes to learn, and that's how we all, you know, mistakes are made, things happen,

08:06 - 08:20

Speaker 23

but we have to reflect, and we have to learn, and we have to make changes based on that. And that's what I'd like to see from the coronal process and ultimately from PFDs.

08:20 - 08:23

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you very much. I'm going to hand over to Tessa for a few questions.

08:23 - 08:49

Tessa Munt

Thank you. Thank you very much, and I'm sorry. Could I realize this could be difficult, but can I ask you, could you explain what you understood at the start of the inquest about what the potential outcomes of an inquest might be? Can I start, can I start with you, Johnny? Is that all right?

08:49 - 09:46

Johnny Santer

Yeah, sure, no problem, Tessa. Unfortunately, I was just retraumatized the night before I went into my inquest because, despite asking both Merseyside Police and the coroner's office for the bundle, it wasn't forthcoming. And this was after I had to reschedule the inquest.

Gabriel died a preventable death on the 3rd of October 2020. The original inquest was scheduled for the 23rd of December, two days before Christmas, before the first Christmas without my son, and that's when they wanted me to attend for an inquest. So, I had to get that postponed until later in January, alerting the clerk that my daughter's birthday was mid-January, so could we possibly avoid that date as well? And there you have it.

09:46 - 09:53

Speaker 12

So, I went into that inquest pretty much completely blind.

09:53 - 10:04

Speaker 9

Thank you. Can I just ask you what you anticipated the process of an inquest might do?

10:04 - 10:30

Johnny Santer

Just the four questions, I guess: you know, the, who died, where they died, how they died, and when they died. You know, so I was aware of that, but obviously now knowing what I know, and having been through a very similar inquest that had incredible representation, I know what an inquest is capable of doing.

10:30 - 10:36

Tessa Munt

So, I was going to ask you whether you had, and it sounds as though you did not, any legal representation?

10:36 - 10:37

Unfortunately, I didn't.

10:37 - 10:51

Tessa Munt

Okay. So can you explain what difference, clearly you have experience of what legal representation might have done so to the outcome, what different outcome?

10:51 - 11:21

Johnny Santer

Importantly, a prevention of future death report. So, and the circumstances around this are important because the inquest that I was sitting in on was the inquest of a young man who died in very similar circumstances to my son, Gabriel, a young man called Josh Parry, who died from a fall from a multi-storey car park in Liverpool in 2025. That was the second death from that same multi-storey car park within three years.

11:21 - 12:02

Speaker 20

I'd actually written to the operator after the first death and asked them what they were going to do to make that structure safe, to protect the most vulnerable members of my community and the impact of these preventable deaths that they have on the community. Needless to say, I didn't get a response from that operator, and then Josh was allowed to die a very preventable death just two years later. But having seen the barrister Christian Weaver represent Josh's family at inquest, and I'm proud to say I was able to introduce Josh, his family to Christian, to facilitate that, the difference was just they was worlds apart.

12:02 - 12:03

Thank you.

12:03 - 12:04

Thank you.

12:04 - 12:09

Tessa Munt

Richard, can I ask you the same, so, what your expectations were?

12:09 - 15:30

Richard Caseby

Well before the inquest, between Matthew's death and the first pre-inquest review, I'd already started my own investigation, using freedom of information requests, subject access requests, because I knew that The Priory was deliberately trying to cover up the truth of what had happened, and that was plain. And because in my career I've been a managing editor of two national newspapers, I you know, I knew how to mount an investigation. But at the start, I knew very little about the inquest process. I mean, I had I don't think I'd even covered one as a reporter, so I didn't really know much. And I made a big mistake at the beginning of thinking, oh, I was arrogant enough to think I could do it myself, which would have been a huge mistake.

And then I kind of read this book, you know, the inquest practitioners guide, you know, the 800 pages, and then I got a very clear view that I might actually need a lawyer. And thanks to the INQUEST charity, I did actually find one who specialized in inquests, and that was Craig Court at Harding Evans, and then also a barrister, Oliver Lewis at Doughty Street Chambers, and both were excellent. Because Matthew was in state detention and in the custody of the state, it was an Article 2 inquest. It was held before a jury, and it lasted 3 weeks. What I didn't know until I'd been through it was actually the emotional effect that can have on you.

It is really hard. The coroner, who was excellent, Louise Hunt in Birmingham, name check, she was brilliant, excellent coroner, opened it by telling everyone that you know, we're all here for the same reason to find out why and how Matthew died. But actually we all know that is basically a false assurance. It's well-meaning, but it is naive. That is not what happens at an inquest, not like the one I was involved with.

You know, the government has, you know, repeatedly said that families are put at the heart of the inquest process, but in my experience and those of many families, they are most certainly not. I mean, families usually probably like Johnny, you know, you enter this coronial arena, you know, believing that everybody present is only concerned in discovering the truth. And as I say, nothing could be further from the truth. You know, public bodies like NHS trusts, like The Priory, the police, you know, they all turned up fully armed with battalions of highly paid lawyers, you know, and most of them were funded out of taxpayers money. Luckily and thanks to a campaign led by the INQUEST charity, I did get exceptional case funding, because I would I actually vowed I was not going to spend my own money on this, I'd do it myself.

Then I got legal aid. But the single concern of all those other interested persons, I think the name is, they're sit- you know, the single concern is just to protect the reputation of their own organizations by, you know, by deflecting any hint of accountability onto each other, or to you, or whatever it might be. You know, and I found it shocking. You know, it was manipulative, obfuscating, defensive, you know, and aggressively adversarial towards families. It was truly shocked, and, you know, I've seen a lot in my life.

15:30 - 15:31

Does that help?

15:31 - 15:46

Tessa Munt

Yes. Fine, thank you very much indeed, thank you both. Kate, can I ask you exactly the same, what you thought was going to be the potential outcome of the inquest itself?

15:46 - 20:00

Kate Szymankiewicz

I think we all have very similar experiences, although different backgrounds from it all. I was aware of inquests from a professional capacity and speaking with coroner's officers, but I hadn't had any ideas to what an inquest like this would look like. And we had actually already gone through the police were investigating Ruth's death under charges of corporate manslaughter, and the CQC also launched a criminal prosecution investigation, which they then dropped. And we haven't been able to have access to what they actually looked at. So we were stumbling through all of that before we were able to start the inquest process.

And it is purely by chance that my sister read a very small article which mentioned the charity INQUEST. So I picked up the phone to them just not knowing where to even started. So, they were the ones who actually explained what process would look like. They were the ones who suggested that, actually, we should have legal representation. They were the ones who linked us with our fantastic solicitor, Charlotte Haworth Hird.

And she, I don't know how we would have got through that process without her and the barrister and, subsequently, the QC she enlisted. She was very experienced in inquests and recognized very early on with this that the legal teams from the other side, as it were I know everyone comes back to, it's an inquisitorial process, but it felt like, having spent four and a half months fighting for Ruth while she was alive, we were then fighting every step of the way to try and get her voice heard, to even address the questions that we had. And I don't know how that would have even had a chance of happening without the legal support. And, in terms of kind of potential outcomes, they were the ones who explained to us what the coroner would give the jury because, again, like Richard, it was an Article 2 inquest with a jury, and it lasted for nine days. But they, the coroner, guides them on what they're allowed to have as their outcomes.

And, again, we, our legal team really had to push him to offer anything more than suicide or neglect to allow that to be wider. And he actually said on the last day of her inquest, he said, "I can see I've been blinkered. And thank you to the jury for seeing the wider picture," because he'd been so focused on those four questions, which are really important, on how had she died. But that bit was really simple, it was really clear: she shouldn't have been left unattended with access to, you know, how she ended in her life.

But that for us wasn't That wasn't it. We wanted to know how on earth our 14-year-old daughter was made to feel so utterly isolated and trapped that the only way she could see out of there was by not being here anymore.

And that's what we wanted to know. And that was not that was not just the 4 and 1/2 months of her being there. That was the actually all the decisions about her going there. That, you know, there's so many layers to it. And I think that's why inquests are really important.

But you are at the mercy of the person who's sitting there overseeing that, and that is very variable. And I'm conscious I have strayed slightly off the question there. Um.

20:00 - 20:14

Tessa Munt

That's fine. I think you've explained well that you were taken to INQUEST by a short article that happily I think Did you say it was your sister who'd seen it?

20:15 - 20:18

Speaker 16

Gosh. Goodness.

20:18 - 21:40

Kate Szymankiewicz

And if I hadn't picked up that phone, I don't know at what point anyone would have said, "Oh, you know, you are eligible for legal aid to have legal representation." Yeah, just even the understanding the language that is used, and I'm sure I'm just as guilty using medical jargon. But sitting through the pre-inquest hearings and coming out the other end and saying, "I didn't actually understand half of what was just said." Gosh. That's just the pre, you know, and then the actual, I don't know how you would go through the inquest itself.

Like Richard said, it is and Jonny, too, it is re-traumatizing. I think for us, almost you know, I think and going through that, I don't think we were even able to start grieving Ruth properly until after that process, because we had to hold all of that information in our heads, trying not to lose that. And, you know, it was 4 years from when she was admitted to actually to the day that the inquest went ahead. So yes, it took several months for both of us before we could even think about going back to work.

It really I can't explain how that, you know, it is.

21:40 - 21:45

Tessa Munt

Well, I thank you, all three of you, for being so brave. Thank you very much.

21:45 - 21:47

Speaker 19

Thank you. Can I pass over to Vicky, please?

21:47 - 22:31

Vikki Slade

Thanks, Catherine. So, surprisingly having read all of the case cases, only Richard's case ended with a the issuing of a prevention of future deaths report, which is shocking given the circumstances. And I've read that you specifically said that the scandal was that the coroner has no powers of enforcement in terms of the what that report has said. So, can I just ask you specifically, Richard, what was your reaction to the prevention of future death report in your case and the way in which it was responded to?

22:31 - 26:26

Richard Caseby

Let's take a step back slightly. I knew that having an independent report into what had happened with Matthew was going to be massively important. So, before the inquest, I'd fought for like 40 days to get the NHS Trust to commission an independent investigation into his death, because the Priory one was just unforgivable. And it was led by one of Britain's leading psychiatrists, and they found like two core reasons why he died and 29 contributory factors. So, it was extremely damning because he'd only been there 3 3 days.

So, that became the central plank of the inquest, as well as a lot of, as I say, Freedom of Information requests I'd put into both the trust and the Priory. So, I knew we were heading down this you know, this path towards what I wanted was not just a PFD, but a verdict sorry, conclusion of death contributed to by neglect by the treating hospital. That's what I wanted. And that's the most serious one outside of unlawful killing. I mean, one of the core reasons why there was a PFD was because actually during the inquest, which is about a year and a half after Matthew's death, another patient escaped over the same fence from the same hospital during the 3-week inquest.

So, nothing had been done even after Matthew's death. So, how could a coroner not issue a PFD? Anyway, so I was content with the PFD, but even the Priory, right at the last minute on submissions, was arguing that there shouldn't be a PFD. I mean, how do you do that? I mean, I know you can go through the motions as a barrister or as a lawyer, "Well, I might as well throw that in, I might as well try that."

But it was pretty unforgivable behavior by the KC who represented the Priory. Anyway, the PFD I was satisfied with. It was good. As I said, Louise Hunt is a great coroner. You know, it covered things like record keeping quality, risk assessment, serious incident reports.

I mean, honestly, all the things that happen time and time again at deaths at Priory hospitals, time and time again, year after year. But there was one that was outstanding. It was about fence height because Matthew had escaped over a fence it was about I think it was about seven foot six, and, really, it should have been nine foot. You know, he was as tall as me. He was six foot tall.

He was a personal trainer. He was well-built. And he could And I inspected the hospital courtyard. You could put your hand I could put my hand without even standing on tiptoe to the top of the fence. And he was left unaccompanied in that courtyard.

And he'd made three attempts over those three days to escape before. Not that each shift knew about them because they'd got the notes all wrong. So, there was also a recommendation to the Department of Health, you know, there should be a standard guidelines for perimeter fences and security in acute mental health units. And as if you know anything about mental health units, sorry if this is a bit detailed, but I'll try and make it fast. There are three levels of mental health units.

There's acute, maybe 3,500 beds in this country, medium, and then high. And there are only regulations on height of fences and outside areas in medium and high, which seems a little bizarre because if someone is held under the Mental Health Act and is being sectioned for their own safety and they want to escape, why wouldn't you keep them safe with a recommended fence height? Anyway, it was what happened afterwards. And I don't know whether you want me to explain that now, and what they the Department of Health did or didn't do, but I was satisfied by what happened to the Priory, to be perfectly honest, because they increased the height in fences in about a dozen of their mental health facilities afterwards. But that might have also been the product because I basically bullied the CQC to bring a criminal prosecution against them.

26:26 - 26:58

Vikki Slade

So, can I just go back if that's okay? You've explained how much investigation you did, and presumably that's linked to your previous background, right? You know, people in a different circumstance, either wouldn't have had the wherewithal to do that, they might have been managing other children at home, their own grief. You said that you thought that the Prevention of Future Deaths report happened because of that additional death that had happened. But do you think

26:58 - 27:00

Speaker 21

Sorry, it wasn't a death that happened, it was just someone escaped, it was an escape, just to be precise, yes.

27:00 - 27:14

Vikki Slade

Sorry. Apologies, the escape. Sorry, the escape over the same fence. Do you think that it would have happened if you hadn't been able to provide all of that up front in terms of your rather investigation? Cause if it did, that would feel quite an unfair

27:14 - 28:01

Richard Caseby

I don't I don't want to take anything I don't want anything to take anything away from Louise Hunt because she is an excellent coroner. She may well have done that for somebody else, but the evidence was overwhelming. You know, to your point, you know, I could play upon my, you know, previous career experience, but, you know, I'm very well aware that people are not as privileged as me.

You know, I'm middle class, I have resources, I could give up full-time work as soon as Matthew died to investigate this. You know, and I have the basically the networks, money, and wherewithal to basically grind down these institutions and to, you know, bend them to my will. But had I been a single mother with two other children working a minimum wage, you know, I'd have been crushed. I'd have been crushed by the system.

28:01 - 28:07

Speaker 26

Okay. That I think that was the bit I was trying to get. Okay, yeah. Thank you, Richard.

28:07 - 28:42

Sarah Russell

This question is to Kate and Johnny, and in both cases, I just want to start by saying I'm so sorry for your loss and thank you for coming today to talk to us. So, in common with a number of my constituents who have had young family members who have died in avoidable circumstances, I know that you, in each case, your family didn't have a Prevention of Future Deaths report. And what has the impact of that been? And Johnny, do you want to answer first and then Kate, please?

28:42 - 31:06

Johnny Santer

I mean, I think the impact has been huge, really. You know, I've had to go through a similar process as Richard in as much as I've just taken the organization that I feel is directly responsible for Gabriel's death, which was Q-Park, through civil action, and we're still awaiting the verdict from that. And you know, I don't think any of that would have happened had we had the Prevention of Future Deaths report, to be honest with you, because it would have highlighted the absolute, obvious issue that was at stake here. So Gabriel fell from an edge perimeter, you know, it's very similar sort of circumstances I suppose to Richard's case, Gabriel fell from an edge perimeter on a multi-storey car park, and that edge perimeter at the moment is mandated by building regulations document K, approved doc- document K, to 1.1 m. And this is despite the fact that the parking industry produces, you know, suicide prevention strategy, and it's such a well-documented fact that it just seems almost insane that this hasn't been raised before, this issue.

And what I know subsequently from other inquests that have happened, as I alluded to before, you know, that Prevention of Future Deaths report should be a very powerful tool to focus the attention and the relevant authorities into recognizing there is an issue here around, guess what, preventable deaths. So yeah, it's meant that, you know, six years on from Gabriel's preventable death, there's still no action that's been taken against the organization, Q-Park, by any authority. And this is despite the fact that Gabriel fell from an edge perimeter that didn't even meet the building regulations. And I established that fact in court, but I had to go through that process of civil action because nothing had been established in the inquest. Literally nothing.

31:06 - 31:11

Speaker 25

So sorry to hear. Yeah, sorry.

31:11 - 31:13

Speaker 24

It's fine.

31:13 - 31:17

Speaker 27

Kate.

31:17 - 33:57

Kate Szymankiewicz

I have mixed feelings, because I think we were completely baffled as to why on earth our coroner wouldn't have done PFD, because the list of contributory factors to that unlawful killing outcome was long and specific, but very general across the background of what we know is happening again and again in mental health services, but particularly for young people.

So, you know, there were things like lack of training for staff and access to social media and the internet, lack of access to her family. It was a long list, and it seemed crazy that his justification for not doing a PFD was to bring in somebody high ranking from Active Care Group to come and say, "Oh yes, we're doing all these wonderful things now" and sit there and say how marvelous they were, but for us to all take that at word, and it was very strange sitting there listening to them say all this stuff that we were actually told a lot of this stuff of what they did when Ruth was admitted, but it clearly didn't happen. And they could just sit there and say that they were doing things magnificently, and no one was going to check up on whether they're actually doing any of that. And the fact that actually it's not just one provider, we know it's not just Active Care Group.

We know there's plenty of people, The Priory, we are so heavily reliant on that private sector. But to be honest, I'm not sure necessarily that a PFD would make any difference, because there have been so many similar cases again and again with things like sending children out of area, sending children to adult units, the stuff that is coming up in PFDs that actually there's still no action. So I'm not sure that it doesn't just go off to a drawer somewhere in Whitehall and it's great that Richard there was some action for his son, but I'm not sure I've got any faith that currently the PFDs do any more than the coroner giving some recommendation.

33:57 - 35:09

Johnny Santer

Sorry, can I just pick up on just that one fact that Kate so eloquently alluded to? There's been 22, now 23, because since Dr Georgia Richards posted on the Prevention of Future Death Tracker's live tracking portal about multi-story car park safety deaths and Prevention of Future Death reports that are issued as a result, there's been 22 since 2013 on exactly the same instants that, you know, that they will be almost verbatim the same in terms of exactly and it's such a narrow parameter, isn't it, what we're looking at. It's the edge perimeter of multi-storey car parks. There might be other things that are alluded to, but in essence, they're all the same. So I'm absolutely in total agreement with Kate here, it's like what is even the point at the moment when you can have Prevention of Future Death report after Prevention of Future Death report after Prevention of Future Death report, and nobody takes any accountability, takes any responsibility, you know?

35:09 - 35:32

Richard Caseby

I mean, I totally agree with Johnny on that. I mean, all you have to do is, and I know Deb Coles is going to speak to this, about the Lampard Inquiry, it's investigating 2,000 deaths in Essex. You know, how many of those is shocking, how many of those deaths have had PFDs, and that they're the same thing year in, year out, you surely want to take a look at that.

35:32 - 36:22

Warinder Juss

Thank you for all that you've said so far. I mean we've heard that there are cases where a PFD should have been prepared and there wasn't one. And even when there is a PFD, it makes you wonder what the point of that PFD is, because it relies upon the organisation who is in receipt of the PFD to do something about it. The coroner has no enforcement powers. The PFD cannot be followed up in any way.

So, we've got those problems in existence anyway. But from your own experiences, are there any other problems that you see exist with the current approach to following up on inquests?

36:22 - 36:24

Richard Caseby

Do you mean outside PFDs?

36:24 - 36:26

Speaker 29

Can I ask Johnny first, then Kate?

36:26 - 37:28

Johnny Santer

Well, I think it's a really good point here, because what we're talking about and concentrating on is PFDs. And Dr Georgia Richards will be able to speak to this much more, with much more authority and much more eloquently than I will be able to. But PFDs only represent a tiny fraction of outcomes from inquests, okay? So, when we're talking about in Gabriel's case, the fact that he didn't have a PFD from his preventable death and the fact that we know now there are at least 23 other prevention of future death reports from the exact same preventable death scenario, there's hundreds of other people that have died exactly the same deaths of Gabriel that aren't recorded or represented. And there's no learning from those deaths.

So, what we actually need is a system that looks at all deaths that end up in the inquest process and are not just focusing on this very narrow outcome of a prevention of future death report.

37:28 - 37:59

Richard Caseby

And it can't be that difficult these days. In all honesty, I did some work for the Serious Fraud Office about their disclosure documents. And, you know, people are now starting to use AI to actually, you know, check words through, up to now, it's always been done manually. But it can't be that difficult in this age of AI to actually rapidly go through trends in these sorts of, well, PFD reports, there's like 650 a year, I mean that's not many. Anyway, sorry, I didn't cheer them up.

No, it's that's absolutely fine.

37:59 - 38:07

Speaker 31

Kate. Have you anything else to say on top of that?

38:07 - 39:02

Kate Szymankiewicz

I think it's a difficult one, isn't it? But I it I agree with Johnny and Richard there in that actually we either need to make the guidance for what leads on to a PFD much more consistent for coroners. Not that's probably not either, is it? Both really, it's looking at, because every inquest has outcomes that we can learn from. But it's such, you know, it varies so widely, aren't they?

It's all sorts of fields that is relevant to, but without anybody overseeing that and able to then direct down to the appropriate departments and then to make sure something's being done about that, it just is all getting lost in ether.

39:02 - 39:24

Warinder Juss

It just occurs to me that where, following an inquest, there is culpability, that there should be a PFD in every one of those cases, but backed up with some kind of enforcement procedure, whereby if the organisation isn't doing what the PFD says- Mmh, somebody should follow that up. -exactly, may be the way forward.

39:25 - 39:50

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Can I build on Virendra's question and, based on your experience, what do you think needs to be improved so that inquests do properly capture, but then also then act upon the evidence that they hear? Kate, don't know whether-

39:50 - 43:25

Kate Szymankiewicz

I've got yeah, I've got a few thoughts on that really, because I think the actual coronial process itself is still really very flawed. Ruth's inquest went ahead with vast swathes of missing records, so we had several months where they just didn't bring the records for those. We were refused our requests for a lot of the witnesses who we felt would have been able to answer questions about her therapy. We also asked for an expert witness to be brought in, rather than just relying on the consultant who ran that ward saying how things should be done. And I know that one of the things that I think would be really helpful, particularly for deaths within mental health settings, is actually to have a separate investigation to provide the evidence, because you're relying on you're relying on the providers to be bringing that.

And if we hadn't had our legal representation, even with them pushing to have that, we you're looking at stuff without even having the evidence to go through, so you're not you're not getting a full picture in the first place. I think that disparity between the individual coroners is a really big one. Our, as soon as our solicitor heard who our coroner was going to be, she said, "I'm going to have to set your expectations right now. It's going to be very hard to get him to look beyond this kind of immediate picture." And that seems madness.

You know, there I understand that coroners come from all different backgrounds and different experiences, but actually it feels like there needs to be a lot more guidance as to I say the best analogy I can think of is if I'm if I'm duty doctor, I'm triaging all the patients coming in that day, I pretty much guarantee that anyone under five and anyone over 80 is definitely going to want they're going to be needing to be seen. And I suppose it feels similar surely there's similar ways of doing that within of saying, well, actually, any children, any young people with deaths, surely they're going to need more looking at it. And that disparity, I think we've all spoken about between the family trying to let their loved one's voice be heard, and to look openly versus what inevitably feels like quite defensive behaviours from the other side. And I know there are so many different contexts to inquests, but I think having that level playing field would be really helpful. I know I'm sure our outcome and level that we got to was partly because our solicitor did say, "Well, like, actually, the other side will be bringing a KC."

And so she applied for funding for us to have a KC so that it felt an equal footing. There's lots of other thoughts, but that's probably plenty to go with.

43:25 - 43:28

Speaker 32

Bring in Tessa before I come to both Johnny and Richard.

43:28 - 43:56

Tessa Munt

Kate, I was going to ask you if you might actually write to the chair with your thoughts if that's possible, and I that would extend to both of you. Johnny, I had one particular question I wanted to ask you, and that was you referred to the fact that you'd had a an original date for the 23rd of December, then you'd shunted it on and asked for avoiding the middle of a future month.

But I think you said that you hadn't received the bundle until the night before?

43:56 - 43:58

Speaker 33

The night before I was the

43:58 - 43:59

The night before the 20

43:59 - 44:53

Johnny Santer

The night before the inquest. I had not had the information with regards to witness statements, with regards to toxicology reports, with regard So the coroner's bundle basically that is the whole of the information with what I was going to be expecting at inquest did not come to me until 7:30 on the night before the inquest. And then I'm reading through this, okay, for the first time, and there's evidence that is in that bundle that was brand new to me throughout that whole period from October till the end of January, and that was where the retraumatisation happened because I was like, "Oh, my God, what has actually happened here?" It was mind-blowing.

44:53 - 44:57

Speaker 9

Did you have the opportunity to ask how that had even happened?

44:58 - 45:00

Speaker 35

I mean, I'm sorry, I'm not expecting you would,

45:00 - 46:11

Johnny Santer

No, it's fine. So, I've I've I've I've recently, and this is only recently because I've been engaging much more thoroughly with stakeholders everywhere. So, Merseyside Police, through work that I'm doing with them moving on through the public health issue that obviously Gabriel's death represents, and we're trying to do work around obviously suicide prevention, and that's basically what the multi-storey car park safety bill will be. You know, the police encouraged me to actually make a complaint, and this was just at the back of the end of 2025, okay? And then the complaint was split between some things that the police was going to answer and some things that the coroner was going to answer.

And I've had replies back from both Merseyside Police and it was actually the senior coroner for Merseyside, André Rebello, who also sits as the honorary secretary for the Coroners' Society. And they're woefully inadequate as well, I'm afraid.

46:11 - 46:19

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I know that Sarah has a question as well, but I do want to hear from Richard around wider changes. Did you want to come in now, Sarah?

46:19 - 46:20

No, it's fine, Richard, please answer first.

46:20 - 47:46

Richard Caseby

Now, I just want to speak to Kate's point. There, you know, although I keep saying I had a terrific coroner, and I did, you know, I helped try to support other families who are going to something similar, you know, in that period before the death and they're notified about the inquest, and they don't have legal representation, I, you know, I speak with them. But there's this enormous variability among coroners, the quality of coroners, it is utterly shocking. I actually intervened in one in was the death of a young girl in the Priory hospital in Cheadle Hulme, and it was the I think it was the fourth death in about less than a year at the same hospital. And the father couldn't speak English and he had his brother there who could speak a bit of English.

So, I you know, I attended and wrote the pre-inquest review even though I was just a member of the public and wrote to the coroner to say, "You need to instruct these people that they have to get legal representation because they were going to be walked all over." But the things that coroners say and do, not my experience, the experience of others, is shocking. And there seems to be huge variability between a coroner and a judge and a you know, what do you might you will have your own views, but judges, there is a general consistency about a judges, whether in civil cases or criminal cases, but coroners, it's wild out there.

47:46 - 47:48

Speaker 34

Sarah.

47:50 - 48:19

Sarah Russell

Primarily to Kate, but it may well be relevant to all three of you. When obviously there'd been an unlawful killing finding, I wondered if there was then any follow-up in terms of potential gross negligence manslaughter, because that feels like the natural step. Had anyone talked to you about that beforehand? Did anyone talk to you about it afterwards?

48:19 - 50:24

Kate Szymankiewicz

In terms of afterwards, we have not had any further correspondence from the coroner's court at all. I think our expectations of a of from the police investigation, which had looked at corporate manslaughter was that it was incredibly hard to prove without doubt that kind of hierarchical knowledge going upwards. So, even though there was the unlawful killing outcome, I think obviously, in a criminal court, it's a very different level of needing to prove that. And I know that there is there are some discussions about of that unlawful killing verdict in the coroner's court. I think it's a really important one because I think it, we had We hadn't pushed, to be honest, to go any further in other investigations.

I think as a family, we've got Ruth has two younger sisters. Our youngest is now 13. We somehow both managed to keep working within the NHS. There is only so far your energies can take you. But in terms of, yeah, no one else has pick picked up. I don't know whether other unlawful killing verdicts have then gone on to actually have We have big questions about CQC. We're deeply unhappy with how they have handled things with their investigation, which could have been a prosecution.

We were told that there was some kind of loophole, because they issued a warning the week before Ruth died to Huntercombe Hospital about their observation levels, which is clearly a big factor in Ruth's death. They were then unable to prosecute. But they haven't released any of their information to us from what they've actually looked at in their report. And we've questioned that through our solicitor, but we've been told we're not allowed to access it.

50:24 - 50:28

Sarah Russell

Please don't think I'm suggesting that you should have done any more than you did.

50:28 - 50:47

Kate Szymankiewicz

Not at all. No. I know that a lot of families would really want to push for justice. I think for us as a family, there is no justice for Ruth's gone. And for us as a family, but I need to hold on to a little bit of hope that things can change for other people. That's why I'm here.

50:47 - 52:18

Richard Caseby

Can I just add something to Kate said about the CQC? The CQC is a terrible regulator. Between Matthew's death and the inquest, I asked them to go in and look at the hospital again and do an inspection. And they did, and they found it to be good, as they had previously. I said, "You've got to be kidding. You know, look what I've found." After the inquest, I said, "Okay, you're going to go in there again, and you need to actually do another inspection, because it's been a PFD." So, they kind of couldn't avoid it.

And they found it inadequate, surprise. So, I said, "Right, this is the evidence I've collected. This is the evidence of the independent investigation report by, you know, one of the leading psychiatrists in the UK." And, luckily, I had argued for 6 weeks with that psychiatrist to get this question in the TOR, the terms of reference. And it was, did the Priory undertake all reasonable measures to prevent harm to Matthew while he was detained in their care?

Because I knew, if she said no to that, I'd probably have the grounds for a prosecution under the Health and Social Care Act.

And I did. And the Priory was prosecuted. And they pleaded guilty on a corporate charge. And they had to pay a fine of £650,000. It would have been a million had they not pleaded guilty, and it was the highest fine in their history.

But you have to bully these organisations, these public bodies and these regulators to get anything done.

52:18 - 55:27

Johnny Santer

So, can I come in on that as well, Sarah? So, I put that question to Merseyside Police quite early on. The coroner found in Gabriel's case that it was an open verdict, he couldn't really, well, there wasn't enough evidence he felt to be given a verdict of suicide in Gabriel's case because there has to be this question of intent around what would happened. And, you know, in this country, we have an absolutely appalling record of particularly holding corporate bodies to account. And this is exactly why I tried to have a conversation with Q-Park about the fact that my son had died a preventable death, and I was urging them to review all of their internal procedures so that this could never happen again.

And that was the main reason for my first interaction with their managing director, Adam Bidder, via a GDPR request. And his initial response to that GDPR request was that, "I'll get back to you within the 28 days that's mandatory." And he did. And then he said, "We don't have to talk to you because your son's dead." So, this is a grieving father trying to find out all the information that his organisation holds about the preventable death of my son, and at the earliest opportunity, what he wanted to do was shut me down.

And he concluded that communication with me by saying, "But you may have a dress through a legal process." So, his first communication, the managing director of a company that has over 250 multi-storey car parks in the UK and Ireland and is part of a much bigger group, third largest operator in Europe, almost bottomless pockets, was to force me into premature legal action. Luckily, I'd already been in contact with my local MP Maria Eagle about what we were going to start to get into, and I'd made sure that her office was copied into all of the communication. And it was only the intervention from her office to pull them up on this that we started a dialogue, which then lasted approximately nine months before they just then completely shut me down again, and then left me no option other than to seek redress through a civil case. And the only reason I did that was to obtain the information that I knew they would be withholding.

And it is jaw-dropping. It is so damning. Ignoring Prevention of Future Death Reports, refusing to do any risk assessments to make their structures safe, which I'm being told it contravenes health and safety legislation.

55:28 - 55:35

Speaker 42

Nobody is holding them to account. I have to do this all of my own volition.

55:35 - 55:57

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Can I ask you, there's a live debate at the moment about how you design a new follow-up system for inquests? So, do you have a view on which organisation should be responsible for monitoring and for following up on the outcomes of inquests? Could I start with Richard and then Johnny, and then end with Kate?

55:57 - 58:28

Richard Caseby

Yeah. Yes, all right, yeah sure, go on Richard. Yeah, my ideal is what INQUEST is basically asking for. You know, they talk about it an oversight body, I would call it like a commissioner for the prevention of future deaths. And it doesn't have to be a big organisation, you know, a high-profile individual who's not afraid to speak out with a small secretariat looking at the trends, finding out, going out there finding out whether these things have actually been followed up with NHS Trusts or the police or with prisons, etc. That would be an ideal, but it doesn't need a huge number of people.

We're talking about public inquiry recommendations, and we're talking about PFD recommendations. And as I said, there were 650 last year. I can't remember, I don't know how many independent public inquiry have been, and when it closed. I know there's a debate about an existing body doing this, and you know, in all honesty, I worked in Whitehall for five years as a senior civil servant, and I know there's been talk about the National Audit Office. Well, you know, the National Audit Office is, you know, it's the public spending watchdog, you know, it's all about value for money.

It doesn't quite fit there. You know, they'd just be a separate organisation with the NAO. But I can understand why there is that sort of debate, because the NAO is something that gives scrutiny to all government departments. You know, if you've ever been with your permanent secretary to the Public Accounts Inquiry, that's the one they fear most. And they always try and best the head of the NAO.

So I'm not sure that is really the right answer. I think it should be, you know, a commissioner who has powers of embarrassment for these organisations. I'm not saying all PFD recommendations should be enforced, because some are actually, I wouldn't say ludicrous, but actually just impossible. They're just impossible to put in place, they're too expensive, it isn't value for money, and often you might get a coroner actually covering their own backside because they want to placate the family or something else. And I know I may be arguing against myself on that, but it is true that not all PFD recommendations are great ones.

However, a secretariat could actually spot the ones that come up time and again, just as the Lampard inquiry is looking at all the PFDs in all those 2,000 deaths and finding the same things have happened again and again.

58:28 - 58:30

Speaker 36

Thank you. Johnny.

58:30 - 59:42

Johnny Santer

Yeah, I'd just really echoing what Richard's already said. And but you know, what I'm constantly finding out and coming up against is that you know, it's this question of accountability and also the question around, you know, being able to ensure that whatever system we put in place, and I think that, you know, we probably will end up hopefully with a new system, that there's actually some power that they can wield, you know, because, particularly with regards to, say, you know, corporate responses, because obviously that's, you know, where my lived experience lies. And we saw this after 2008, didn't we, unless there is, you know, real fiscal or moral hazard for these organisations involved, they just will not do anything about it.

like, literally will not do anything about it. You know, in in in in in in our case, you know, the organisation has gone out of its way to make sure it doesn't have to do anything above the absolute statutory minimum, and they haven't even complied to that.

59:42 - 59:45

Speaker 37

Thank you, Johnny. Kate.

59:45 - 01:01:29

Kate Szymankiewicz

Very similar thoughts to Johnny and Richard, I agree. I think it needs to be a new and separate body, and I like the idea of the like the Children's Commissioner, or someone, but you're right, they need to have the power to enact those changes, and to follow up,

and I suppose I would envisage them being able to and then feed down to the appropriate, whether that's Health and Safety or and to then say, "Well, actually have you done that?" or to link into government to say, "Well, okay, actually, we need Do we need to have some legal changes here?" or, but I think that separate body, of that accountability, and I suppose, actually partly just talking it aloud today, of realising that, yes, you know, Ruth, her inquest said that she was unlawfully killed, but nothing has come from that. So, who's accountable?

Who, and for me really, it's getting those things to change. Actually, somebody who can look at those repeated things that are coming in and say, "Okay, that clearly is a theme. How do we make this happen?" You need them to be innovative, I'm all too aware that top-down, often by the time it comes to the shop floor, it doesn't translate terribly well,

but we have to start somewhere, and I think having an oversight mechanism for all of this to feed into would be really helpful.

01:01:29 - 01:02:01

Catherine Helen Atkinson

And obviously this is the Justice Select Committee, but each department and area has their own, and we're able to question and put things to ministers, including the Secretary of State. What would your views be on whether individual select committees would be able to raise concerns if that thematic work was done particularly where you've got multiple deaths? What would your view be on select committees taking a role in that?

01:02:01 - 01:02:44

Richard Caseby

I'd say that you need Sorry, I just jumped in there, didn't I? I'd say you need that sort of, as I say, commission for prevention of future deaths, whatever you want to call them, but unless you're actually plugged in to the parliamentary system, nothing, you know, it's not going to work. It has to be plugged in somewhere, and it needs to be plugged in to something like Constitutional Affairs Committee, because then, you know, like the public service ombudsman, I think it's Constitutional Affairs Committee that plugs into.

So, that can be has an effect all across government, rather than a single select committee, because as you say, recommendations are going to affect the Health Department, or whatever. So, reporting to the Justice Committee doesn't feel quite right. It needs to be something that's overall of government.

01:02:44 - 01:02:57

Catherine Helen Atkinson

If it was relevant to, because there'll be specific prevention of future death reports, that will be relevant to prisons, or relevant to health, and if it was if it was put to the relevant select committee, Yes, exactly, yeah. can you feel that would be a way of plugging into the parliamentary system?

01:02:57 - 01:03:02

Speaker 38

Yes, yeah.

01:03:03 - 01:03:34

Janet Jessica Daby

Thank you. If you had one message that you'd like to get to the government on how to improve how we learn from inquests, what would that question be? So, I believe this is the last question, so this is trying to get you to think about, you know, how can we improve what we learn from inquest, and what is that message to the government? And I was thinking we could start with you, Kate.

01:03:34 - 01:04:47

Kate Szymankiewicz

I was gathering my thoughts there. I've got next to me, just to remind me why I'm here, a picture, I don't know, probably won't show, but of Ruth. I think we need to hold at the forefront of all of this, is that people have lost very special loved ones. And it feels like this vast, big system, but actually, I'm speaking for myself, but I think a lot of families feel very similar, is that somehow, to survive all of this, you hope that we can learn from that. And that's what we have the opportunity to create to change, is to let's bring the minister in.

Let's speak to the ministers of all these different departments to bring everyone together, and let's make this action really happen. Let's, you know, create an oversight mechanism that's actually going to make a difference to all of these deaths.

01:04:47 - 01:04:49

Janet Jessica Daby

Thank you, Kate. And Johnny?

01:04:49 - 01:06:16

Johnny Santer

Yeah, I just, I there you go, I've got Gabriel and Cassie there with me as well, Kate. They never, I never go anywhere without them in my bag, just to remind me again, why am I doing this? What's it for? And it's to honor Gabe's memory and, but it's for all the others that have died these preventable deaths. And, you know, the last six years, the work that I've been doing and the families that I've been involved in through the Hillsborough Law Now campaign and now with the families on the steering group for the national oversight mechanism, it's that's all we ever want as families, is exactly what Kate said, for us to learn these lessons from the mistakes that have been made.

But they're so glaringly obvious in so many instances. And the complete lack of inertia by anyone in any you know, position of power is it's so devastating to feel like, well, who is here that is actually going to stand up and say, because in all of these cases, I can categorically say, it is so obvious what's wrong and what's right. And it really is as simple as that: what's wrong and what's right, and what are we going to do about it?

01:06:16 - 01:07:11

Richard Caseby

A simple message really is: end the cliff edge of prevention of future death reports. Just falls off a cliff. You know, appoint a commissioner to follow up reports, spot trends, fix those worst failings. You know, the chief coroner's guidance already says PFDs are vitally important if society is to learn from deaths. A bereaved family wants to be able to say, "His death was tragic and terrible, but at least it shouldn't happen to somebody else."

You know, but every single bereaved family, and all of us, you know, we're sick to death of this, particularly public sector mantra, you know, lessons will be learned, because they aren't. After all the investigations, after all the traumatizing inquest hearings, the fixes, the solutions, they're rarely put in place. You know, we need an oversight body now.

01:07:11 - 01:07:13

Speaker 40

Thank you so much. Thank you.

01:07:13 - 01:07:33

Catherine Helen Atkinson

That brings us to the end of questions, but I would really like to thank you. The evidence that you have given has been so articulate and brave, and you've shown great strength, and we really appreciate the time you've spent with us. Thank you.

01:07:34 - 01:07:38

Speaker 43

Thank you.

01:07:38 - 01:07:39

Order. Order, I will now suspend the session for a short break and allow the panels to change over.

01:12:41 - 01:12:55

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Order. We'll now resume with our second panel. Our witnesses are Deborah Coles and Dr Georgia Richards. Would you briefly introduce yourselves?

01:12:55 - 01:13:05

Deborah Coles

Hi, I'm Deborah Coles, I'm the executive director of the charity INQUEST that works with families following state-related deaths.

01:13:05 - 01:13:22

Georgia Richards

Hi everyone. Good afternoon, I'm Georgia Richards. I'm an epidemiologist based at King's College London. I sit across the health faculties and the law faculty. I'm also an associate tutor at the University of Oxford and the founder and director of the Preventable Deaths Tracker, which we'll talk about this afternoon.

01:13:22 - 01:13:42

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you. We've heard compelling and powerful evidence from early families this afternoon on how the current system doesn't do enough to ensure that lessons are learned from inquests. Do you have any immediate reflections on what we've heard?

01:13:42 - 01:15:19

Deborah Coles

Yeah, I mean I can start. I mean, I found that evidence extremely powerful, but also really upsetting, and I feel quite angry about it because I know Kate, Richard, and Johnny, but to be perfectly honest, we could have suggested a whole series of families who would have told you very similar accounts of their experiences of the system. And I would say that there is such a culture of harmful actions or omissions by state and private bodies that are leading to avoidable deaths resulting in inquests, and yet the preventative potential of those inquests is completely undermined by the lack of any framework to monitor compliance with actions taken in response to inquest findings. And I'll talk about findings in the context of not just prevention of future death reports, but narrative conclusions that inquests can return about systemic failings, and, of course, recommendations that result from other kinds of investigations and inquiries. And I would say that you've heard from three individuals who've had the worst thing imaginable happen to them, and yet they are the ones who are having to be the advocates for change.

01:15:19 - 01:15:31

Speaker 46

And accountability should be a legal and operational duty of the state, rather than a burden placed on grieving families.

01:15:31 - 01:15:33

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you, Deborah. Georgia.

01:15:33 - 01:16:29

Georgia Richards

Yeah, so I'd like to thank the families again for sharing their experience. While as Deb said, it's almost unimaginable that could happen, we have 36,000 inquests every year across the country in England and Wales. So, there's 36,000 families that have had this experience. And so, PFDs only represent 1.7% of all inquests. So, less than 2% of all inquests get a PFD.

So, PFDs are not enough. They will not help us learn from inquests. They'll only help us learn from 1.7% of all inquests, and that's why with my work, we're calling for a national statutory database of all inquests, so we can identify trends and patterns for learning and prevention after every inquest that happens across the country.

01:16:29 - 01:16:45

Catherine Helen Atkinson

As you've set out, we heard about Prevention of Future Death reports, but can you set out the various potential conclusions of inquests and what follow-up mechanisms already exist, just to assist the assist

01:16:45 - 01:17:44

Georgia Richards

Yeah, of course, I'm happy to start, and Deb, please come in at any point. So, there's two main conclusions that can occur after or at the end of an inquest. The first is short-form conclusions, so they can be things like suicide, natural causes, accidental, road traffic accidents, alcohol and drug-related, and then they can also add on contributed to by neglect with those short-form conclusions. But the most common conclusion, which we've found in 44% of all PFD reports, is a narrative conclusion, where the coroner will then describe other factors that led to or caused or contributed to the death. But regardless of the conclusion, that doesn't lead to any mechanism or follow-up or learning, and the examples we just heard before had different conclusions, and that didn't change the outcome of a PFD or of any learnings from those deaths.

01:17:44 - 01:18:47

Deborah Coles

I think just following on from that, I mean, one of the problems is that there's no central repository or database where all jury conclusions or records of inquests are actually held. And so, some very significant narrative conclusions, which are often returned in deaths where there's been evidence of systemic failure and where you heard Kate talk about the jury identifying in her unlawful killing conclusion, identifying a whole series of systemic failures. Unless there's a PFD or an organisation like INQUEST do a press release where we would put in the findings of that jury, they're not collated anywhere, which, you know, going back to Georgia's point, you know, it just means that really important evidence about systemic failure that could result in proper learning is just lost.

01:18:47 - 01:19:05

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I think you've covered it, but just wanting to ensure that you have the opportunity in your view, what follow-up from inquests needs to be. So, you've already talked about that need to have that follow-up, was there anything further you'd want to add before I bring in Georgia?

01:19:05 - 01:20:18

Deborah Coles

I mean, if you'd like me to talk about the national oversight mechanism now, I can, or if you want to wait until a little bit later, it's a matter, you know, it's entirely for you. I mean, I think, you know, what you've heard from the families just points to the fact that all the families that INQUEST work with have had the worst imaginable happen, but all are motivated to try and ensure it doesn't happen to anybody else.

And at the moment we have a broken system, and I would say that's across both inquests and inquiries, where families go through very protracted, distressing processes in the hope that there will be change, and yet we have no mechanism from which we can see what actually happens from a post-death investigation to a recommendation to implementation. And irrespective of whether or not a recommendation is accepted, there needs to be that oversight and transparency of that recommendation and how it's being responded to.

01:20:18 - 01:20:25

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I think there will be some specific questions, so I'm sure you will absolutely get that opportunity. Georgia.

01:20:25 - 01:21:36

Georgia Richards

So, but I think before we can start to follow up, we need the right evidence and the right data. So if we're just it's not good enough to just focus on these PFD reports because we won't include deaths like Ruth and Gabe in that data, and without having that full picture, we're really not going to be able to learn across the country. But I think for the data component in the analysis and trends, I am obviously biased as an academic, but there is something about the academic freedom and independence of academics that conduct research in environments that aren't swayed by political policies or different sort of biases that may come in. So at a as a sort of at an academic institution, we are independent, and we have academic freedom to analyse and present that data in the most sort of evidence-based way. So I think there is a place for an independence where data sits outside of government and is analysed in a very objective way and presents that and presents that data to government for action.

01:21:36 - 01:21:38

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I'll hand over to Tony.

01:21:38 - 01:22:14

Tony Vaughan

Thank you, Chair. You both participated, thanks for your evidence, you both participated in the Justice Committee's work on coroners in the previous Parliament, and I understand that in 2021 one of its recommendations was, well, one of its observations was that the failure to have a mechanism to ensure that these PFD reports were implemented was a missed opportunity. So in 2026, I just wondered what progress has actually been made to ensure that inquests are responded to, and if none, or inadequate progress, why?

01:22:14 - 01:24:04

Georgia Richards

Yeah. I've got a few things. So the first is we've seen since about 2023 we've seen an increase in the number of PFDs being written. It was sitting at about 450. This has increased to about 550, 600.

So in the last three years we've got about a 100 extra PFDs coming through. Whether that's positive or not is at the discretion of the coroner. We track every report that's ever been issued from 2013 until today, every day, and we also track response rates. So we were the first platform to ever track responses. We started doing that in 2020.

And when we started in 2020, less than a third of all PFDs had responses published. Three years later, that increased to about 40%, because we have live tracking and we name and shame organisations that don't respond. Last January, the Chief Coroner's office started publishing a list of non-responses to PFDs. Now, that has led to, overall, now two-thirds of all PFDs have responses, which is a positive increase. For 2024, in particular, this is now sitting at 92% of all reports for 2024 have all responses published, which, in the coroner world, as we've been talking about this afternoon, is a huge achievement.

But while that is great, we're seeing that improvement in response rates, there have been some recent changes by the Chief Coroner's office this, which started this May, which I am very concerned about. One of those changes is delaying the publication of PFD reports purely for an administrative purpose to help the Chief Coroner's office, which goes against open justice and transparency. What sort of

01:24:04 - 01:24:09

Speaker 50

reasons would they be relying on to delay the publication of one of those reports, if any?

01:24:09 - 01:25:08

Georgia Richards

It's at the discretion of the Chief Coroner. So, we now have to wait at least 56 days until they have responses for any sharing of PFD reports, which is a concern. The second thing is they've changed the report structure and the response structure, which I was really looking forward to, because we made recommendations last time that we need to improve the consistency of PFD reports and improve basic things like reporting age and date of death. You would think that's a simple thing to report in a PFD, which often doesn't get reported. We have 1,000 PFDs with no age, which is concerning.

These new templates got published also in May, signed on the 1st of May, and they make it almost impossible to see who's actually responded to the PFDs, because they used to respond on letterhead, so it was very easy to see. Forgive me, this

01:25:08 - 01:25:09

is on some website, or what How would I see that, for example?

01:25:09 - 01:25:49

Georgia Richards

Correct, on the website. And the new template of the PFD is very confusing, it repeats itself, and it's structured in a very poor way. So, I was really looking forward to these new reforms that were suggested by the committee to improve the consistency and standard of PFDs, and I think we've really taken a step back, despite the positive increase in, you know, we're getting about 100 more PFDs and the response rates. But overall, these arbitrary administrative changes really demonstrate there is no digital infrastructure in the coroner system to enable learning from inquests.

01:25:49 - 01:26:02

Speaker 53

I wonder, Deborah, when you're dealing with this question, whether you could focus not only on this sort of issue of transparency, but on the substance. Do we lack legal powers? Why are the actual substantive changes not occurring?

01:26:02 - 01:30:36

Deborah Coles

I mean, just to highlight another kind of positive, and that would be that a lot more coroners are now notice noting in their prevention of future death reports other prevention of future death reports that they may have made or colleagues may have made, and that I think that's something that we certainly raised when we did some training for coroners a number of years ago. And also, I think, I mean, both Georgia and I did training for coroners, and I like to think that perhaps coroners' understanding of the importance of those PFD reports, particularly to families, has kind of influenced and also, you know, the importance of these reports, well, the importance of these reports to public health and safety with the caveat, of course, you know, if any notice is paid to them. I think just to talk about some of the kind of ongoing problems, I mean, and you heard this in the evidence from Kate and Richard, and that is around the way in which lawyers representing public bodies and public and corporate bodies still treat the whole PFD process within inquests and the extremely adversarial way in which lawyers will try and persuade coroners that they shouldn't make a PFD, often by introducing evidence of action that they say has been taken.

And I think what's important to say there, well, there's two things. One is that there is no way of testing whether or not what organisations say has happened is actually happening on the ground and there's no way of testing that. It's not like a coroner can go and actually look at the particular systems, say, within a prison, a suicide prevention act system within a prison, whether or not that's actually changed. But secondly, it absolutely undermines the potential use of these reports for national learning. Even if something has been remedied within a local area, these reports should be informing learning on a national level.

I think the other problem is the way in which reports are drafted, distributed, and published. And quite often, when we look at the PFD reports that we see in the context of INQUEST's work, they are quite formulaic. They often look like they're just kind of cut and paste. They very often focus on, "Oh well, we've reminded staff of a particular policy" or and you know, they're often kind of tick-box exercise. And there's a there's a report that I was involved in, a piece of research that the Independent Advisory Panel on Deaths in Custody did looking at Prevention of Future Death reports where we actually kind of delved into this area in quite a lot of detail.

And I think you know, what didn't surprise me was that, when we did the research, it did show that kind of more formulaic approach. But also, I think many coroners themselves are very frustrated with the current system, because you know, they make reports because they have identified that the failings in an individual death need to be remedied in order to protect lives in the future. And yet, their power stops at the point that they make a report, and yet we know that there is no proper follow-up to see what action has actually been taken and how change has impacted on the ground. And you know, my I think my frustration from INQUEST's perspective is that you know, as an organisation that works around deaths in a variety of state institutions, we do see the same issues being repeated time and time again, both within individual settings, individual prisons, mental health settings, or we see that the same issues being repeated within the, you know, the wider the kind of wider

01:30:36 - 01:30:39

Speaker 52

Can you give us a flavour of these recurring issues in this justice context?

01:30:39 - 01:35:19

Deborah Coles

In the justice context, I think probably an example of the ACCT process in prisons, which is the process, the suicide prevention process. I think in I'll just check my notes that policy manager has given me for this. At the time of at the time of writing, the Chief Coroner's web site website shows over 60 PFDs which refer to the ACCT process in prisons. Issues raised include the fact that ACCTs are not always opened where evidence shows that they should be, a lack of accountability when ACCTs are not properly monitored, and particular concerns about monitoring and observation of at-risk prisoners, and very poor quality assurance.

And it's interesting, there's one particular case of a prisoner in 2024, where the coroner reported that the act ACCT care plans were still being overlooked, noting that in a prevention of future death report six years earlier, they'd issued a PFD at the same prison indicating that ACCT case reviews were not being adhered to. And I think that's sadly that's just that's one kind of small example, but it is indicative of, and Kate was reflecting on this, you know, in the context of the death of her daughter in a privately-run mental health setting, that the issues that Kate's inquest sorry, Ruth's inquest, flagged up were depressingly familiar to other deaths of children that we'd, you know, whose cases we'd worked on in mental health settings. So those kind of patterns of systemic failure, and there's nothing, you know, for us, there's nothing more frustrating to see those same repeated failures, but for a family who've engaged in a process in the hope that change will come, you can just imagine how retraumatising it is to read of a death in similar circumstances. So in terms of the the the the the PFD system, it it it it it is a broken I think in my view, excuse me, it's a broken system.

And it also I think it kind of speaks to the lack of accountability of those organisations responsible for the care of people in those institutions. And, you know, I think there's one you know, it's bad enough when it's bad enough that there's been a death. I mean, that's shocking, where somebody's completely dependent on somebody else for their care and their well-being. You would expect that where somebody dies, that the biggest concern of those institutions would be, "How can we learn? How can we stop this happening again?"

When what we see within the culture of a lot of inquests is this reputation management. It becomes the primary concern. It's not about learning. It's not about reflecting. It's about how can we resist full proper scrutiny, how can we resist a prevention of future death report, how can we risk mitigate the risk of a very critical narrative conclusion?

Then the inquest stops, and I think too often what happens is all those organisations concerned just sit back and they breathe a sigh of relief, then they think they issue some trite press release about, as Richard was saying, about, you know, we can write the script: we will learn the lessons, we will ensure that, you know, this is all taken seriously. Very often, that's the last thing families will ever hear from any of those institutions, which I think is absolutely disgraceful. You know, and then it becomes the families who chase down organisations to try and find out what has actually happened, what have you done. And the importance of the follow-up is to make sure that, you know, you can issue a formulaic response and you can say something, you need to go back, you need to go back in six months time, you need to go back in a year's time and find out has that change actually improved things on the ground, because otherwise what happens is what we see at INQUEST is that you see those deaths continuing.

01:35:19 - 01:35:48

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Thank you very much, Chair.

Ms Coles, in your last answer, which was extremely helpful, you've described a broken system, one that lacks accountability, one that is formulaic in how people approach it, and, effectively, it's a tick-box exercise. And that is a theme that we've heard across the evidence today. Are you able to give us any examples, and I'll start with you, Ms Coles, and then go to you, Dr Richards, of where PFD reports have actually brought around positive change?

01:35:48 - 01:38:45

Deborah Coles

I can give you I think we had to work hard on this one because I think the nature of the system makes it actually quite difficult to find out what positive change there's been because we don't always find out about it. Hence the fact that a, you know, a good oversight mechanism could actually celebrate good practice as well as identify, you know, changes that are needed. We have an example of Awaab's Law, which followed a PFD which noted a host of gaps in the policy framework to address damp and mould in social housing. And that led to joint-agency guidance on the issue and led to Awaab's Law, which provides a time limit by which, you know, social housing or landlords need to get the issues sorted.

Another example, which is both positive and also I think shows some of the inherent systemic problems with the current system, is around Seni's Law, which is the use of force in mental health units, which was which followed the restraint death of a black man, Seni Lewis, by police in a mental health setting. And it was one of a pattern of similar deaths following restraint, resulting in prevention of future deaths reports, and the pre the predecessor to those, rule 43s. And it saw some those deaths were very high-profile and had a lot of parliamentary interest and resulted in some concentrated action by policing and mental health organisations. And driven by Seni's family, working with INQUEST and their MP Steve Reed, saw the legislation, use of force in mental health units, being enacted. Now, that was very positive, but there were a number of elements within the use of force bill that weren't enacted, and this is going back to 2018.

And since then, it's been left to the family, with, you know, with the help of ourselves, to try and drive the full implementation of that bill. So, it's an example, I think, of something that can be very positive, and you can see some kind of positive initial initiatives that follow deaths that have received, you know, a degree of kind of public and parliamentary interest, but then it's left once again to the family to try and ensure that change is actually followed through. So, those would be kind of two examples.

01:38:46 - 01:41:35

Georgia Richards

Yes, so there are, of course, several high-profile cases that have led to change. And the three I'll touch on very briefly is the death of Martha Mills, which has led to Martha's rule, which has been rolled out across the NHS and now more recently for maternity care, which has had is NHS claims it saved 500 lives. So, that was the result of a PFD, but it wasn't just the PFD. It was the tireless campaigning of Martha's mum, and she's a journalist herself. So, she obviously has the expertise, the tenacity, and the other factors that Richard and Johnny were talking about to really drive forward that campaign.

Another one is the death of headteacher Ruth Perry, which led to changes in Ofsted's recording of school inspections. But at the same time that PFD came out, there was a Select Committee inquiry also ongoing.

There was a change in leadership. There was a lot of journalism and media reporting. And so, it's never just the PFD. It's always a combination of other factors. And the final example is I've worked closely with the Natasha Allergy Research Foundation, now the Natasha Foundation, which was the death of Natasha following consuming a sandwich at Pret.

The Natasha Foundation has done incredible work with many families that have children with allergies. So, Natasha's law was enacted in 2021. But that was the tireless campaigning of her family. And more recently, Benedict's law, which is now implementing allergy training in schools. But all of this is driven by families.

And so, we've really created this two-tiered system that's driven off class and campaigns. And so, that's really the backbone of how we learn from inquests at the moment. It is means we have inequalities in the system. And it means the deaths of those that matter most are really not being counted. And so, the final thing to say to this is I think the government needs to take a look at itself and answer the question of how do we learn from deaths where inquests play a small, but important role in that.

But there are many statutory bodies that have been set up. There's silos across every government department and public bodies, and they're all doing their own things. And so, the Justice Committee is in a unique perspective to bring together all those statutory mechanisms from road, rail, marine, child death reviews, domestic homicide reviews. The list of statutory mechanisms that exist really need to come together, and we can't have this inequalities where it's driven by class and campaigns.

01:41:35 - 01:42:03

Neil Shastri-Hurst

You've both sort of set out how PFDs can be a force for good if applied properly, often as part of the solution, opposed to the solution in and of itself, you know, working alongside campaigns that run alongside it. I just wonder whether you have a view of how generally possible it is to determine whether a PFD has an impact upon policy and decision-making.

01:42:03 - 01:42:42

Georgia Richards

So, in the Tracker, we do look at that. So, we record where there's been any sort of policy reforms after PFDs, and we track those over time. But I would say these are random, often arbitrary and a really knee-jerk reaction of the government to high-profile cases. So, we monitor those high-profile cases that do lead to that. But at the moment, it's there is no evidence base.

There is no systematic way to do that in a way that is equal across all inquests. So, we do it in the Tracker, but it's a very much so knee-jerk reaction response.

01:42:42 - 01:44:04

Deborah Coles

The only thing I'd add to that really is that sadly we do it, but it's in the context of when a death happens in maybe in the same institution, revealing the same kind of issues which shows that the learning from previous deaths have not been enacted. I mean, there's an example of just bearing in mind the Justice Committee interest in prisons, there've been a number of repeated deaths in individual prisons. Woodhill Prison being a good example, where there've been a succession of critical inquest outcomes and the same issues keep being repeated.

the Nottinghamshire Coroner following a number of deaths in Lowdham Grange Prison has written to Nottinghamshire Police, asking them to investigate a pattern of deaths at Lowdham Grange because of the repeated and similar failings that have been identified in those cases. So, I would say in the absence of any proper mechanism to actually do that deep dive and see what action's been taken, it's often you only know

01:44:04 - 01:44:08

Speaker 54

when the same thing happens again.

01:44:08 - 01:44:25

Neil Shastri-Hurst

I think it would be fair to summarize both of your evidences that the quality and consistency of PFD reports are is mixed. How do you think we can improve that to ensure that it is a more consistent approach, or a more consistent approach is taken to them?

01:44:25 - 01:45:53

Georgia Richards

Yeah. So, I just gave the news of the new template that obviously hasn't worked to improve the consistency. I think there needs to be a digitalisation of the inquest of the PFD system. So, the Chancellor announced last week and about the AI strategy for the Government, and I know the Coroners' Service could really deal with some basic IT infrastructure that would improve the consistency and standardisation of PFDs.

So, that is certainly one area. The other area is really around the guidance and training, which has been improved, but overall, I think it we can't there is an element of, it's at the discretion of the coroner. So, we have geographical variation in them getting issued across the country. I don't think we can require we can't require a coroner to write a PFD,

but we can improve the digitalisation of how they actually write those, and where the data goes, and how that data flows, because at the moment it's an email. It's all driven off an individual coroner area emailing that to an organisation. They email that back. That then gets emailed to the Chief Coroner system, and it gets manually published as a PDF document on a website.

So, that is the fact that we are relying on that PDF email to save a life is a real national scandal in terms of the infrastructure that we're relying on for a life to be saved.

01:45:53 - 01:46:07

Neil Shastri-Hurst

That's one part of the equation, the sort of output bit from the coroners. There's also the input bit from those who are receiving PFDs, and how they respond to them. And I just wonder whether Ms Coles, you've got anything to comment on that aspect of it?

01:46:07 - 01:47:24

Deborah Coles

I mean, I think that there's also a question of to whom these reports are disseminated, because I think what we've found is quite often you'll look at a PFD and you'll question why it hasn't been more broadly circulated to those whose attention should be brought to, you know, some very serious kind of, you know, systemic failings. I think that Georgia's point, I mean, the Coroners' Service is ill-resourced. And that is a that is a I think something that's impacting on families' experiences of the inquest system from start to finish. But just in terms of your the point about the quality and consistency of PFD reports, I think it's also about coroners recognising that, you know, you should make a report irrespective of whether or not you think that an organisation has addressed something at the local level. I feel very strongly about the fact that, you know, these reports should be viewed as a really important opportunity for learning when something has gone catastrophically wrong, and those reports should be made irrespective of any organisation arguing otherwise.

01:47:24 - 01:47:49

Neil Shastri-Hurst

And just picking up on that, you know, you've identified the importance of shared learning, and I think most of us who've worked in any sort of large organisation recognise the importance of that.

I can almost predict the answer, but how well do you think particularly in say the healthcare setting, for example, shared learning across institutions, not just within institutions, is being delivered through PFDs?

01:47:49 - 01:48:36

Georgia Richards

I mean, I know for a fact that Department of Health and Social Care and NHS England do not get all the individual PFDs that go to NHS trusts. So, there is no national learning, is the short answer. I could delve into that a lot because I've sat at for many meetings with CQC, HSIB, NHS trusts, NHS England, Department of Health and Social Care, to try and bring these organisations together to try and have a national approach, which is exactly what the Tracker does. So, we can bring all those PFDs together for all health and social care related PFDs, but there has been no appetite or interest to have a national approach to analysing all PFDs relating to the health and social care system.

01:48:36 - 01:49:46

Deborah Coles

I mean, I would just say, I think it's pretty scandalous how bad the system within different organisations is. I mean, this is not something that we're just talking about today. This is something that you've already referred to the previous Justice Committee inquiry into this, but this is something that we've been talking about for decades now, in various bits of government, in various select committees. It's not something that government aren't live to. And so, I kind of think that, you know, for every family that you hear from, there are hundreds of families for whom they've had the worst experience possible and yet we cannot say with confidence that those organisations are going to respond in a not only in a humane way to families and tell families what they intend to do to try and make sure this doesn't happen again, but that kind of coordinated learning and cross-sector learning which is so important you know, to public health and safety, it's still it's still not happening.

01:49:46 - 01:50:08

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Can I ask a follow-up on that because you've been talking about the quality and consistency of PFD reports, but can you comment on the quality, consistency, and timeliness of responses to PFD reports and what changes you'd like to see there? And then, I think Brenda also has a question.

01:50:08 - 01:51:52

Georgia Richards

Yeah. So, I can talk on that because we track the times, the timeliness. So, I mentioned earlier some of the stats, it was less than a third now we're more than two-thirds of reports have responses. In terms of timeliness, we look at also the from the date of death to the date of PFD report, and this is a new dash we've just published on the Tracker to show if we need to learn from deaths, we need to have near real-time reporting of this near real-time responses. So, that's exactly what the Tracker is there to do, to analyse that information in real time as it comes through. So, we have seen an increase in response rates, which is positive, but the big challenge we have is any organisation can request an extension for responses.

And now with the new guidance from the Chief Coroner that won't publish PFDs until all responses are received, it could be years and years before we get to look at PFDs that are getting written today because all the Department of Health and Social Care is one of the worst offenders and they will just request for an extension, and they could get a six-month extension, a two-year extension. The coroner could say no, but the coroners that I speak to really want to get those responses to the families, and the families are often asking the coroner, "Hi, do you have a response for my PFD?" So, there's timeliness of both issuing PFDs because we need to save lives now, not wait five years, and the timeliness of reporting and taking action is really crucial to having any type of system where we can learn from inquests.

So, it's a huge challenge that is a real problem.

01:51:52 - 01:52:28

Warinder Juss

Linda. So, we heard that in Ruth's case, Kate's daughter, there was a finding of unlawful killing, but no FD PFD report was issued, and we've heard earlier from Dr Georgia Richards that in less than 2% of cases is a PFD prepared. So, how is it determined whether or not a PFD should be produced? Are there any clear guidelines for the coroner to indicate to the coroner that this is a case where there must be a PFD, or not?

01:52:28 - 01:53:50

Georgia Richards

Short answer is no. It's at the discretion of the coroner, and it's in the justice, the Coroners and Justice Act of 2009, it's at the opinion of the coroner. There is case law now, which is Dillon v HM Coroner for Rutland in 2022, where a brother, someone who lost their brother in prison from an anaphylactic reaction, he took the coroner, he did a judicial review of the decision not to issue a PFD. This decision was handed down by the court to say that it was lawful for the coroner to not issue a PFD. So, we now have case law, which means a coroner, it's at the discretion of the coroner.

There is nothing, there's no threshold that a case must reach, whether it be a civil or a criminal case, it doesn't reach any sort of threshold for when a PFD will or won't be issued. And so, there is just huge geographical variation. I have some coroners that have never issued a PFD and there's coroners that have issued hundreds of PFDs. So, it's there is no there is no yeah, way that we can enforce a PFD or whether it we can't even take now we wouldn't take for judicial review on a decision not to issue a PFD because we have case law that says it's lawful to not issue a PFD.

01:53:50 - 01:54:27

Tessa Munt

Leslie. So shocked. I'm so shocked by what you've just said in the last five minutes. I'm Dear oh, dear. Can I take you back, if I may, to So, Johnny said something about the bundle arriving so late, which places somebody at an even greater disadvantage.

Does that happen only to litigants in person, if I can use that phrase, or does that happen in the case of people who are represented as well, and how common is it, do you know?

01:54:27 - 01:58:57

Deborah Coles

I mean, from our experience, late disclosure is an ongoing issue, whether or not you're represented or not. Yeah. I mean, I think what's so shocking about Johnny's evidence is the fact that it's quite clear that he wasn't given any information about his legal rights, that the process, I mean, I think the inhumanity of the process is he articulated so well. But to give somebody disclosure the night before the inquest into their child, I mean, that is just so cruel and it just simply shouldn't happen. I would say that legal representation for a family from the outset can make a real difference because, obviously, you then have lawyers who understand the inquest process, who can make the necessary requests to the coroner for disclosure and, hopefully, get disclosure in a timely way in advance of the inquest.

And I think it's important just to say how legal representation can impact on a family's experience of an inquest, because from the outset, they know that they are supported at a deeply traumatic time, as early as possible. At the moment, it's just worth mentioning that Hillsborough Law is making its way through the parliamentary process, and one issue that we are waiting for government to make a decision on is the point at which funding for families' representation is made, what we're calling the trigger point. And the kind of point I'd want to make here is that for bereaved families who are about to go through a very complex legal process, the earlier that they have access to a lawyer who knows what they're doing not only means that they can get on with the kind of post-death cultural, you know, practices and, you know, grieve and look after other family members, etc., knowing that their interests are being represented by a lawyer, but it also means that they can impact on the potential scrutiny afforded to their loved one's death, because they can make representations to the coroner about kind of evidence that they should hear. They can impact into any pre-inquest investigation so that investigation does examine evidence as far as possible, and can help minimise the experience that Johnny had, which is that they will get disclosure in advance, so they have some degree of preparation for what is going to come up at the subsequent inquest. And of course, the other thing I would say is that, you know, that can impact on the scope, but it can also mean that a family lawyer can stand up to some of the kind of quite aggressive, adversarial conduct that we see by state and corporate lawyers in the context of what I mentioned earlier on, which is about arguing against a particular jury conclusion, arguing against the making of a PFD reports.

Because state and corporate lawyers are very good at knowing how to argue against the making of a PFD. When I did coroners training, I highlighted some of the firms, how they would advertise their services online, and it would, you know, effectively be: if you want to try and avoid a PFD, come to us. And I mean, you know, that is real. And I'm not talking about all lawyers. I mean, you know, I should make that clear, but in some of the some of the most contentious cases, there has been really appalling conduct by those lawyers.

And it'll be very interesting to see whether or not Hillsborough Law and a duty of candour and more openness and transparency will change the culture within inquests, because one would hope that if we try and move away from this defensive culture and this kind of concern with reputation management, that we could have a cultural change and see inquests as that really vital opportunity for learning and prevention, which is really something that's in the interests of all of us.

01:58:57 - 01:59:00

Speaker 55

Thank you. Did you want to add anything?

01:59:00 - 01:59:35

Georgia Richards

The only thing to add is around with Hillsborough coming through, if we had a national database of all inquests, we could actually monitor the impact of Hillsborough. We have no national database to monitor legal representation, who gets it, who doesn't get it, decisions on PFDs, and also what will happen with Hillsborough, and if we see an increase in or a decrease in PFDs.

if we see an increase in or a decrease in PFDs, a national database, properly structured statutory database would allow us to actually evaluate the impact of policies like Hillsborough to see the impact and the outcomes.

01:59:35 - 01:59:39

Speaker 56

May I make the, sorry, did you want to interject?

01:59:39 - 02:00:01

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I was, just in relation to trying to get representation as early as possible. Obviously, the Hillsborough law will apply in cases in and inquests where a public body is an interested person. Is there anything further that you need think needs to be done so that the decision as to who are the interested persons happen at an early stage?

02:00:01 - 02:01:09

Deborah Coles

Yeah. I mean, I think that the what there needs to be, and I can follow up this answer with our latest briefing on this, it's about the point at which an interested party is designated by the coroner. And we can't afford to wait for that because, obviously, it can be some time before there's a pre-inquest review. It may not be, it may not be evident straightaway as to whether or somebody is an interested person. But, in a lot of the cases that we're involved in, it will be very evident, if somebody's, you know, if you're talking about a death in a state institution by way of example, or if you're talking about, you know, a death involving a corporate body where the expectation will be that the state or corporate body will be represented.

But irrespective of whether or not the state or corporate body is represented, the family should have access to funding at the earliest opportunity. And that's what we're currently kind of debating with government over.

02:01:09 - 02:01:17

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Is there something that needs to happen so the finding in relation to interested parties is made sooner, so that there is that trigger point?

02:01:17 - 02:01:20

Speaker 59

Absolutely. Yeah.

02:01:20 - 02:01:26

Tessa Munt

So, yes, I presume anything that you view, your views on this, you could put in writing to the Chair. And we'd encourage you to do that.

02:01:27 - 02:01:29

Speaker 58

Thank you. Sarah.

02:01:29 - 02:01:31

Speaker 57

Yeah.

02:01:31 - 02:01:39

Sarah Russell

Obviously, we heard very movingly earlier about the involvement of a private sector, well, two private sector organisations.

02:01:40 - 02:02:23

Sarah Russell

Hillsborough obviously covers where someone is providing a public function. So I am guessing that the interpretation of it will probably cover privately provided mental health services, but it wouldn't cover the Q-Park example that we heard about.

Yes.

Do you know how many cases involve a public body versus those that don't involve a public body? And how are families going to function? It seems to me quite arbitrary whether or not there is a public body or a private body involved in a preventable death.

02:02:23 - 02:03:04

Tessa Munt

Can I just interject on your interjection? Is that all right? So I sat on the bill committee for the health bill and pushed really hard for contractors and subcontractors.

Yes.

So where you have, for example, a council or a hospital that's using, perhaps they contracted their services out to a car park company, they might be covered. They might not. But I think there's a there's an element of that probably needs to be drilled down, because there is private provision contracted from public services. And my view is that should be included, but I think there's a bit of pushback on that, but.

02:03:04 - 02:04:11

Georgia Richards

To give context around data in terms of what we know from the statistics that get published because there is no national database, we know last year there was 360 deaths in prison and about six- In including those, there was about 600 odd deaths in state custody. So that only represents 1 to 2% of all deaths in state custody of all inquests.

So, that is a very small proportion of the 36,000 inquests that happen every year. We don't have data on the other public service-related deaths because we don't have a national database. So, it's not possible to give what the statistics look like. But it likely could be create this third-tier system where those that are solely managed by the state, as in deaths in prison, in a state prison, would obviously get legal aid. But there'll be a majority of inquests where families won't have legal aid, like Jonny's family.

So, the data isn't there yet, but state custody deaths is about 2% of all inquests.

02:04:11 - 02:04:23

Catherine Helen Atkinson

I mean the Sorry. I'm conscious that I'm conscious of time and we haven't actually yet got really to the questions on national oversight mechanism, so I think I would ask if we can move on to Janet's questions.

02:04:23 - 02:04:57

Janet Jessica Daby

Yeah, thank you. I'll try and put the two questions together because of time, as well. So, obviously, INQUEST is to Deborah first. Deborah, INQUEST is calling for a national oversight mechanism to follow up on recommendations made by inquiries and inquests. Could you just tell us what that is and how it would work?

And then the second part of the question, which is probably for yourself, for both of you really. If you can outline how the national oversight mechanism would work in conjunction with data, really. Yeah.

02:04:57 - 02:10:16

Deborah Coles

I mean, I'll be as quick as I can, and then follow it we can follow each up with more information. I mean, I think the proposal for a national oversight mechanism has come out of our frustration with the current system, and after lots of consultation with families, with lawyers and with academics. And effectively, it bridges the gap between recommendations being issued after post-death investigations and meaningful, potentially life-changing recommendations and change actually happening. So, that's the kind of first thing. And what it what we're proposing is that it would be a new independent public body which would collate, analyze and, crucially, follow up on recommendations made following investigations into state-related deaths.

So, that would include inquests, statutory and non-statutory inquiries, reviews and investigations. And as I say, it would have the three main functions: collating, and we can follow that up and Georgia's tracker is a good example about what is actually possible into in the context of PFDs. The second point would be the analysis, and I think this is particularly important. It would be able to analyze the kind of themes and patterns and issues coming out of the recommendations that are made following all these processes.

But crucially, the third power would be to follow up, and a mechanism would need those clear powers to follow up and report on action or inaction. And that would be done through the ability to gain access to information and, importantly, work with other regulatory or, for example, prosecution bodies. It would be independent of government. We think that's really important because, you know, inquests and inquiries involve kind of deep scrutiny into all arms of the state. So, that functional and operational independence of an oversight body is critical to public confidence and its ability to function effectively.

The other thing that's really important and a kind of key principle is that the views of bereaved people, victims and affected communities should be built into the kind of governance and operation of a NOM.

And we've kind of suggested previously that this should be done through potentially an advisory board made up of those groups. And the reasons for saying that is because what you've heard thus far is how families are very often the drivers to try and effect change, and they never hear from anybody about what's actually happened. So that's really crucial. The accountability to Parliament is important, and I would say, as well, that also speaks to a question that the Chair mentioned earlier about the role of select committees, because we would see the NOM as having a very significant research function, that you know the analysis and research function, and given it would cover quite a lot of different areas, it could produce thematic reports, you know specialist reports on different areas. So, for example, the high number of prison deaths, it could analyse, do the follow-up, report to yourselves as a select committee in the same way as the Housing Committee looked at Grenfell and the fact that, you know, what preceded Grenfell was the Lakanal House fire and an inquest, and we saw the kind of contempt with which that report was treated.

And then it would importantly have a key kind of transparency role, which is to bring this information into the kind of public domain. And that's really important because, clearly, one of the issues is about, you know, the lack of transparency and accountability of those responsible for change. And I think I mean, finally, I'd just say that, you know, I think one of the frustrations that we have is that we've been talking about these issues for many years now, and a lot of energy seems to be, at the moment, being kind of expended on who could carry out this role, which who could we give this job to—Richard talked about the National Audit Office—rather than thinking about the key role that one body could play, and making this a really, very powerful body to try and drive change. And that of course cuts across so many important areas of public health and safety. So, having kind of reflected at length about what would be possible, we have come to the conclusion that a new body needs to be set up, properly resourced.

02:10:16 - 02:10:22

Janet Jessica Daby

And, Deborah, how long has INQUEST been working on this in terms of the new body and this type of strategy?

02:10:22 - 02:13:07

Deborah Coles

I mean, we've been work As an organisation, we're over we were set up in 1981. I would say that the work around the national oversight mechanism and the current iteration has probably been for a few years now, and we've met with various governments around this. We've given evidence to all sorts of different committees. I think there is a lot of debate within government at the moment about what should happen, and obviously the PACAC committee are hearing evidence at the moment in terms of particularly with a focus on inquiry recommendations. But I think in our view, you know, the importance of these issues and how often they are interlinked.

And Richard already talked about the Lampard Inquiry. Now, that inquiry was set up because of the repeated nature of deaths involving Essex Mental Health Services, and it had to be a statutory inquiry because there was a lack of cooperation of senior management with the initial review that was set up.

And it kind of in a way for me, it speaks to the difficulties that we have identified in following up where what change has actually happened. And just finally, I mean, I would just add that you know, the reason why we think it's so important is Johnny spoke to the fact that he subsequently found out through the benefit of Georgia's work as well about other deaths that have occurred. And one of the things we think a NOM could do is almost have that kind of alert system, so where you see these patterns you can spot recurring dangers across different institutions and you can escalate those concerns. And it could be a vital resource for parliamentarians, for coroners, for inquiry chairs, for academics. I think, you know, that we can't wait any longer.

Every time, you know, every year we have these conversations and we see avoidable deaths occurring, you know, and at great cost, not of course, the human cost and the trauma of these avoidable deaths, but also the cost to the public purse because death investigations are expensive. Public inquiries are expensive. And why are we putting families and victims through these processes only then to ignore the learning that can potentially you know, flow from them? That's a really cruel system.

02:13:07 - 02:13:19

Janet Jessica Daby

It sounds like a huge preventative measure really. And, so, Georgia, in terms of like the national oversight mechanism, how would it work in conjunction with a coronial database?

02:13:19 - 02:15:42

Georgia Richards

Absolutely. So, I would say that there can't be a mechanism without the national database, without knowing what deaths are occurring across the country. So, I would see I would sort of encourage that the first two parts of the mechanism, which is to collect and analyze reports, that should be independent from government and at a institute that has academic freedom to analyze that data in a transparent way. At the Preventable Deaths Tracker already collects and analyzes all PFD reports. We have lots of different types of dashboards that issue live alerts when new deaths do occur, so we've already built the infrastructure to do that component.

So, we analyze every PFD that comes through and we've produced the live alerting system for multi-story car parks for Johnny. So, that's that infrastructure already exists and has been built, but PFDs are not enough. And so, if there is a mechanism that just focuses on public inquiries and PFDs, it's going to be a really biased system, so it needs to look at all inquests. And the final bit is we produce live dashboards that update in real time. Annual reports often sit in someone's shelf and gather dust, and so it's 2026, and we have lots of digital infrastructure where we can build these live systems.

So, I would urge against an annual report and focus on a digital live reporting system, like we've already built at the Preventable Deaths Tracker. The final thing to say, I know we've run out of time, but this already exists for the for children in England, so there is the National Child Mortality Database, which collects all deaths in children in England, and it already exists in many Commonwealth countries that have adapted the coroner service. So, I'm from Australia, originally. It exists in Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the US. So, this is not an innovative thing that we are explaining.

A national coroner system database exists in other countries that have coroner systems.

So, it's not new. Australia started in the year 2000, so it's more than 26 years old. So, it's really the foundational bit needs to be we need to get the right data and the right tools to start learning from inquests.

02:15:42 - 02:15:47

Janet Jessica Daby

Sounds like it's crucial information for the committee to hear about, so thank you. Thank you.

02:15:47 - 02:15:50

Speaker 60

Mary, did you want to come in before Vicky?

02:15:50 - 02:16:32

Sarah Russell

Yeah, I have a couple of really brief questions. One of which is, it sounds like this database already exists, Georgia, and I know that this committee has previously recommended that there should be funding for this. I, as a local MP, cannot currently can't access this information, and nor can any of my colleagues without paying for it's behind a paywall. So, what happened in terms of follow-up on the payment funding point? And what do other You've said that other countries have these sorts of systems.

What changes have resulted in the law, for instance, in Australia as a result of having this system?

02:16:32 - 02:19:04

Georgia Richards

Yeah, so first on funding. So, after the previous evidence that I gave in February 2023, no, 2024, the minister, I then met with the minister straight after that meeting, which was Mike Freer at the time. He was the minister now what is now the minister for victims, and he just said, "We will not fund this, put a paywall in." And so, that's exactly what happened at the conclusion when I got home that evening. And I still have had no funding from anyone to for the digital infrastructure.

My team is now funded by a philanthropist, so I have a philanthropist who funds two team members, and we have two more joining in time, but I still self-fund the digital infrastructure behind the tracker. It's very difficult to get funding for building digital infrastructure in a research environment, because it's research answers research questions, so that is a challenge that I bear the burden of that financial cost. From an other country perspective, in Australia the triggering event that led to the national coronial information system in Australia was the there was a Royal Commission into the deaths of our Indigenous people, when they identified 99 deaths that had occurred in prison, and that was the triggering inquiry that said made the recommendation to government that we need a national database to ensure we're counting the lives that we're that we're losing for our First Nations people. So that happened in the late or the late '80s, early '90s, and there was several, you know, feasibility studies that went on in the '90s that brought that in 20 in the year 2000. In Canada, it was driven by the opioid crisis, which is what my PhD was on.

So, I was looking at how we could prevent deaths from opioid overdoses, and the increased prescribing in this that we were seeing in long-term pain medications. And the government went to coroner's office in Canada and said, "How many people are dying from opioids?" And they couldn't answer that because they didn't have a national coronial database. Now, that exists. That came into effect in 2016, and there was two small legislative changes in the Ontario Act, for example, that led to that national database.

So, it's possible, but it does need to be statutory for it to be sustainable, because if I'm not here, there is no Preventable Deaths Tracker.

02:19:04 - 02:19:23

Sarah Russell

And just if there were a couple of things that you can see, because you've just described other countries where they're very there was a very clear gap in the data, they recognized and they decided this was a the Are there obvious gaps in our data that you can see from the work that you've done already that you think that this would enable us to know?

02:19:23 - 02:21:25

Georgia Richards

Yes, so I So, the data bit, yes, but the way that I've now decided to work is actually just follow what government policies are going through Parliament.

So, violence against women and girls, we see continuous deaths of children and partners in PFDs that come through. Road traffic accidents is another one, suicides. They There are so many deaths that we can't choose, and so we just follow what policies are going through Parliament, which is how we target what deaths to look at. I was hoping COVID would be the moment that we would realize that we could do this, and we needed to do this. Usually, it takes something, I was thinking a global pandemic would be enough; it clearly wasn't.

So, I really don't know what else to do, but I'm hopeful through the Health Bill, we just tabled an amendment last night to the Health Bill, that would enable this national database for all inquests. The final thing I should probably say, which is controversial, but the minister in charge, the Ministry for Justice is the worst responder to PFDs. They respond to about 30%. They've only ever responded to 30% of all reports, and I think this Committee could really take forward what's happening in, really try and understand what's happening at the Ministry for Justice to understand how they are using PFDs, and they should be a role model. If they came out, they should come out with a 100% of all PFDs responded to, so that I can take that to the Department of Health, to the Department of Transport, to the Department of Education, show them the Ministry of Justice is the leader.

They're 100%, everyone else should follow. So, I think the justice department or ministerial department could become role models, which might be a lever for change. But, I could talk about lots of other deaths that are tragically happening every day across the country that we could use as a mechanism for this.

02:21:25 - 02:21:35

Catherine Helen Atkinson

That is a sobering insight that you have shared with us. I do want to ask Vicky to ask her question.

02:21:35 - 02:23:06

Vikki Slade

Yeah, and I'm modifying it, because I was originally going to ask you about what powers and features an existing organization might want to have, but you've been really clear that an existing organization is not the way to go. You've also covered, I think in quite some depth, some of the features and functions, so I'm not going to go into that. But, I suppose, the two things that leaves me with is, firstly, reflecting on what Richard said earlier about, in fact, he didn't say it, I said it about the article that he'd written, about the fact that there is no enforcement power through a P- a PFD. So, my- it reflects back in what are the powers that this organization would need? And secondly, given your absolute clarity that PFDs is not the way to go, PFDs is a microcosm, and we've seen that today with the two that didn't happen,

what powers, if no PFD exists, how can an organization have powers over something that didn't happen? So, I'm interested to know, firstly, where there is a PFD, what are the powers, and, you know, what are you looking for in that? And then in terms of the non-PFD cases, how would having powers actually work in those cases?

02:23:06 - 02:25:55

Deborah Coles

I mean, I think the point that's been well made is about the importance of collating inquest conclusions, because they are such an important body of evidence. And within the NOM proposal, we talk about recommendations from investigations. Now, that obviously includes inquests, but it also includes the investigations prior to an inquest being held, so the different investigations that would take place. I think the other thing to say about, you know, that the narrative conclusions are jury findings of systemic failure. They have to be treated as important sources of learning.

So, that would be the first thing I'd say to that. The other thing about a national oversight mechanism and I completely agree with Georgia's point about, you know, a national database and the value of having data, but I think one of the big areas that we're being failed by is the lack of follow-up on all these recommendations and on the evidence that is identifying systemic failure. The actual, there is nobody who is following up what happens to this evidence. How is it changing things for the better?

And that's why, I think, the national oversight, we've come up with that proposal. And there is no organisation, you know, according to our knowledge anyway, that has the specified role in their governing statute or their terms of reference to look at conclusions of investigations into state-related deaths. And that's where there is that real accountability gap and there is a complete disconnect between the, kind of, inquest process and then learning and prevention across different government agencies. And just to the point that Georgia made about the Ministry of Justice, I mean, you know, given that is the department that is responsible for coroners, it's quite shocking that, you know, we're here in 2026 giving evidence about something that has remained a consistent theme for decades.

And there's some, you know, this we should be learning from that. We've got a point of, kind of, inertia here, you know, and as I said in my previous answer, unless, you know, unless we do something and we do something quickly, you will continue to hear from families like the ones you've heard from today. Powerful point to end on. Thank you.

02:25:55 - 02:26:07

Catherine Helen Atkinson

That brings us to the end of our questioning and the end of this session and I know you've worked on this for a very long time and we're really grateful for that work and your time today. Thank you. Order.