Westminster Hall

28 October 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:04 - 00:09
Speaker 1
Order, order.  Abtisam Mohamed to move the motion. 
00:09 - 01:36
Speaker 2
I beg to move that this House has considered higher education funding, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship.  As co-chair of the APPG for students and international students, a member of the APPG for universities, and representing a constituency with one of the largest concentrations of students, I know first-hand the enormous value of higher education and the growing challenges facing the sector.  It's worth saying from the outset that I'm applying for a separate backbench debate specifically on students, covering the cost of living, maintenance support, and the wider student experience.  Those are important issues in their own right, but today's debate focuses on the foundations and the long-term sustainability of higher education itself.  My constituency is home to two outstanding universities: the University of Sheffield and Sheffield Hallam University. 

I have had the privilege of studying at both institutions, and like many people, I know personally the doors that higher education can open and the horizons it can broaden.  We have a world-class higher education system whose institutions are often seen as a great equaliser, especially for working-class communities.  Walking into a university, you know right away why they are described as centres of innovation and industry.  A good university acts as an anchor in our cities, far more than just lecture halls and graduation ceremonies. 
01:36 - 02:05
Speaker 3
I will give way.  I thank the honourable member for giving way and congratulate her on securing the debate.  Just on the issue of providing opportunities, particularly for working-class communities, would she agree with me that in my area, the likes of regional colleges, both in the North Coast and the North West, offer excellent opportunities, particularly for people who feel disadvantaged and possibly have left school without any qualifications and are really caught in a bind, and this offers them a way out of the position they're in and offers prospects for the future for jobs? 
02:05 - 02:32
Speaker 4
I agree with the honourable member.  I think he makes an excellent point, and I will come on to talking about disadvantaged students and the role that universities play.  Universities train the nurses and doctors who treat us.  They train the teachers who educate our children, the engineers who build our infrastructure, and the researchers whose discoveries save lives.  They support businesses, attract investment, create jobs, and drive progress. 
02:32 - 03:43
Speaker 2
In Sheffield, we see that contribution every day.  Sheffield Hallam University trains around 3,900 healthcare professionals and 2,800 teachers every year.  In a single academic year, those healthcare students contributed more than 365,000 hours through NHS clinical placements.  Meanwhile, the University of Sheffield generates an estimated 4.82 billion pounds for the UK economy and supports 138 start-ups and spin-outs.  Its research activity contributes billions more in economic value. 

And whilst these figures are impressive, behind them lies a fracture point.  There is a growing disconnect between what we ask our universities to deliver and the resources that are available.  We want universities to drive growth, to boost productivity. 

We want them to tackle regional inequality.  We want them to undertake world-leading research.  We want them to support the NHS, public services and local in local economies.  But yet the sector is facing a financial crisis that threatens its very survival.  Madam Chair, we have to recognize the failed funding experiment of the last 16 years and bring it to an end. 
03:43 - 04:41
Speaker 5
I draw colleagues' attention to the Education Committee's comprehensive report from earlier this year, identifying the real-terms cut in undergraduate tuition fees as a huge factor, the one of many in financial instability.  It's also widely recognized that the UK's public education funding levels rank well below the OECD average of around 70%.  Funding levels have fallen so far that funding direct to universities now just makes up 2 billion out of a total of 16 billion, the complete inverse of what it used to be.  The majority of government funding is spent on a bloated student loan system that is wildly out of control, while current repayment threshold freezes are punishing lower-earning graduates.  And last year, the Office for Students forecast that up to 40% of higher education providers will be in deficit. 
04:41 - 04:46
Speaker 2
Put simply, far too many institutions are being forced into a cycle of cuts just to temporarily balance the books. 

04:46 - 04:49

Abtisam Mohamed

I'll give way to...

04:49 - 05:25

James William Naish

Thank you very much for giving way. She will be aware about there being around 600 job cuts in Nottingham at the University of Nottingham. There's been alternative proposals brought forward, 120 in total by staff, but the impact is going to be significant. What's been noticeable in my conversations with the university is the emphasis on commercial elements, whether that's covenants, whether that's 30 days' access to cash, whether that's access to a revolving revolving credit facility. Does she agree with me that that emphasis has gone too far and we've forgotten what the public benefit of universities is, and the government and the universities need to reflect on that?

05:25 - 06:21

Abtisam Mohamed

I agree with my honorable friend and he makes an excellent point. I think Nottingham University is seen as a university that does need the support and I think, you know, colleagues across the sector will look to see how Nottingham is supported alongside their own universities. He makes an excellent point. Put simply, far too many institutions now are being forced into a cycle of cuts just to temporarily balance the books. Over recent months I've spoken to university leaders, staff, trade union representatives including the UCU, students and employers.

And whilst they all come from very different perspectives, they all present a common diagnosis: the current funding model for higher education does not work. And so it raises a fundamental question: if we recognize universities as national assets, as our rhetoric often does, why have we systematically stripped back public funding and left them to shoulder so much of the financial burden themselves?

06:21 - 06:22

I will give way.

06:22 - 06:45

Jade Jessica Toale

I thank the honorable member for giving way and for setting out just the real challenges that our higher education institutions face. I wondered if she would agree with me that this difficult financial position they're in is actually causing universities to oversubscribe their courses, putting unsustainable work pressures on their workforce, reducing the student experience, but also increasing that financial instability as a result of that boom and bust.

06:45 - 12:29

Abtisam Mohamed

My honorable friend makes an excellent point and I think universities do need to be supported so that the financial pressures the financial burden is not purely left for them to deal with. Madam Chair, I now want to come on to international students. International students should be welcomed as an enrichment of our campuses and strengtheners of Britain's international ties. Their fee income, international students' fee income has become an essential pillar propping up our universities, cross-subsidizing home student education and supporting research that would otherwise be cut. But universities did not become dependent on international fee income by choice.

They have increasingly relied upon it because domestic teaching and research funding has failed to keep pace with the real costs of delivery.

I and many others remain concerned about using an international student levy to pay for maintenance grants. It's seen as little more than an additional tax on one of the UK's most successful exports. At a time when global competition for talent is increasing, we should be asking how are we strengthening one of Britain's greatest success stories, not how we make it less attractive. A restructured maintenance support system for home students separate from international fee income would be a vastly more successful policy, and it's a policy I will continue to support. Fundamentally, any solution to the sector's funding crisis and support for the most disadvantaged home students should not further destabilise university finances.

And this is especially important in a context where universities are already cutting staff, courses, and research programmes. Data from Universities UK shows nearly eight in ten universities have pursued voluntary redundancies in the last three years, and the same amount have frozen recruitment. UCU estimates that 30,000 jobs have been lost over the last three years. This is devastating, and we should be clear about what this actually means. It means rising workloads and pay erosion for remaining staff.

It means staff who support students every day losing their livelihoods. In Sheffield Hallam University's case, more than 1,200 posts have gone in just over two years. Having met with staff representatives and UCU members, I know that these numbers are not abstract. They represent people who have got mortgages to pay, families to support, and bills to meet. I also hear from many talented academics who are moving from one short-term arrangement to another with little certainty about their future.

The consequences are felt by individuals and the community beyond the university gates, but it also has implications for the future of British research. A system increasingly characterised by insecurity will only drive talented people away. So if universities are one of the UK's greatest assets, then why are they not involved in our economic growth? Because whilst we speak of growth, skills, and Britain's future competitiveness, we are not seeing growing financial, sorry, we are seeing growing financial fragility across the very institutions that help make those ambitions possible. Universities cannot continue to be expected to do more with less, chasing efficiencies and instead eroding capacity.

And once that capacity is lost, rebuilding it is neither quick nor easy. So I'd like to put a number of questions to the Minister today. First, what is the Government's long-term vision for higher education? Not simply how individual institutions survive the next financial year, but how will universities fit into a national strategy for growth, skills, research, and regional development? Secondly, does the Minister recognise that the current funding model has become overly reliant on international student income, mainly because teaching and research funding no longer meets the real costs that universities face?

And if the Government continues the international student levy, what real impact will it undertake on how fluctuations in student recruitment will affect university finances? For example, does the Minister recognise that institutions are likely to pass these costs on through higher fees, potentially making the UK a less attractive destination in the international student market? Thirdly, does the Minister believe that the current balance between public and private contributions to higher education funding is sustainable? The Government now contributes around 16 pence for every pound spent on teaching. Does the Minister believe that that is a viable basis for the future funding of higher education?

Will the Government examine how over the long term we move towards a fairer balance between the individual and state contributions, recognising the enormous public benefit that universities provide?

Fourthly, how is the government assessing the economic impact of university job losses? Because we cannot talk about universities as regional anchors while simultaneously accepting the loss of thousands of highly skilled jobs across the sector. And finally, where do universities sit within the university's sorry, within the government's growth mission? Because if universities are as we say the engines of growth, then they should be treated as such and they need a funding framework that recognizes the enormous contributions they make to our economy, our public services and our communities. I want young people in Sheffield to have the same opportunities that education gave me.

I want our universities to continue training the nurses, the teachers, the engineers and researchers our country desperately needs. But I want Britain to remain a world leader in higher education and research. If we want our institutions to survive at all, we've got to stop treating them as an afterthought. Thank you.

12:29 - 12:50

Speaker 1

Thank you. Could members please remain standing so that the clerk can make a note of how many members wish to speak? And given the numbers, I think I'm going to have to impose a hard time limit of four minutes. So the question is that this house has considered higher education funding. Dr. Rupa Huq.

12:50 - 16:51

Rupa Huq

Thank you, Ms. Rees. Crisis and world-beating, both overused terms and both apply to UK HE, which after over-reliance on international fee income during years of underfunding now feels ready to snap. Four in ten of the best universities on earth are in Britain. Imperial College, its White City campus is in my seat, is one. It attracts the brightest brains for groundbreaking postdoctoral research.

Its scale space facility incubates startups, but Home Office restrictions on dependents, the cutting of the post-study work visa, ILR changes and the new basic compliance assessment that's inexplicably resulted in record visa refusals has has threatened all this. And in a competitive world, there are other options for international purses, which we see are being opted for. I'm also MP for University of West London, not top ten, but an anchor institution locally, big employer, vital hub for underrepresented communities. Both are concerned by the international student levy. Yes, the return of maintenance grants, which is what the proceeds will fund, are welcome.

But really, the nine hundred and twenty-five pound fee universities must produce per international student per year of study that they're enrolled at a time of falling roles is unreliable. Why not, given how course fees vary, a percentage, six percent was originally mooted? And what's the logic of the first two hundred and fifty students free? Sadly, Suffolk University for the first time has gone below that, an unwanted situation and perverse disincentive. Could we not increase this number?

And why are the subjects funded in these grants only the ones in the government's industrial strategy, computing, maths, pure science, but no arts or social sciences, which will potentially leave these to elites? Indeed, creative sector education, e.g. at UWL, the old Ealing Art School, which for a hundred years specialized in this and humanities, where The Who formed and Freddie Mercury studied, risks being wiped out as the UCU fear, along with the jobs, because such subjects don't fit financial forecasts. Our universities are not simply dreaming spires and ivory towers, they're essential invisible exports, soft power, regional capacity building, growth in every postcode.

Westminster, the first polytechnic, was founded to enrich the working man. Its Soho Poly venue was where Pink Floyd played their early gigs, and things still happen there. We must treasure our wide diversity of institutions, not just throw them to the wolves. But the OfS estimates 119, 43% of universities, will be in deficit this academic year, with 24 of them in danger of bankruptcy. And after mergers and departmental closures, the next step, as predicted by the Education Select Committee's excellent report, is insolvency.

Now, the Oxbridges will go from there to there, but the Suffolks, the UWLs, they're to down there. Will it take someone to go bust before the government finally takes notice? When I taught in the sector, international students were seen as the golden goose to compensate for real-terms funding cuts, and they spend money locally. But our over-reliance is now exposed. The BCA rag ratings have become existential.

You can't rely on past laurels, cash-starve a sector, demand gullible international students with limitless pockets to prop it up, staff goodwill, and magically expect growth. The elasticity of demand inevitably snaps.

16:51 - 19:01

Jim Shannon

I want to thank the honourable lady for setting the scheme, the debate, incredibly well, and thank her for that. Thank her for having this debate, because having this debate has enabled us also to make a contribution on a subject matter that's incredibly important. So thank you for that. We are looking at a matter of grave overriding concern for the future of our people, our youth, our economic prosperity in Northern Ireland. The minister has no responsibility for Northern Ireland, but I always like to bring a Northern Ireland perspective to these debates, because what's happening here in the mainland is happening to us in Northern Ireland as well.

We're standing here debating the broader systematic challenges facing higher education funding across the United Kingdom. Yet, as so often the case, a view from Northern Ireland also reveals a distinct and far more perilous landscape. Good to see the minister in her place. I look forward to asking the minister at least one question, which hopefully the honourable lady will be able to answer. While universities across England and Wales adjust to tuition fee caps from rising to some £10,000, our local institutions remain strictly bound by the Department of the Economy.

We deliberately keep undergraduate tuition fees lower at £4,750 to ensure accessibility for our working-class communities. It's important to me as an MP, it's important to our assembly that we look after those and give opportunity for all. I know the Labour Party wants to give opportunity for all. I've no doubt about that whatsoever. So I think the motivation the honourable lady has put forward here is something that I wholeheartedly support.

Look no further than the devastating crisis currently unfolding at Ulster University. Some 735 members of staff, nearly 24% of the entire workforce, have applied for redundancy. The university is forcing through a planned reduction of jobs to plug a catastrophic £25 million deficit. Dedicated lecturers, researchers, support staff across Belfast, Coleraine, and Magee are watching their livelihoods vanish. This is an absolute gutting of our regional skills base.

19:01 - 19:11

Gregory Campbell

You're cutting away the very fabric of Northern Ireland's future. You're setting the long-promised expansion of the Magee campus in Londonderry, just as an example of something for the future that we're looking at.

19:11 - 21:22

Jim Shannon

I thank the honourable member for giving way. Would he agree with me that the issue of particularly Magee and Coleraine campuses need to be addressed, and particularly the MaSN cap, which restricts the numbers of students that universities can take in Northern Ireland? We have to review that urgently.

I thank my honourable friend and colleague for East Londonderry for bringing that forward and backing up practically what he sees on the ground and what I see in the Northern Ireland perspective as well. By any decision against Magee campus in Londonderry, you were telling local businesses, they're crying out to fix their skills deficit, that the talent simply won't be there.

And that's what we've got to look at as well. That worries me greatly, Madam Chair. The provost of Ulster University warned just days ago that these consequences are not abstract, nor are they years away. They're not. They're happening right now, at this very minute as we sit here, it's happening, affecting the student places and long-term investment.

Once the intellectual capacity is lost to redundancy, it's incredibly difficult to ever build it back up again. Our institutions create value for far beyond their campus walls. So I urge my minister back home, and my question to the minister here today, difficult times, and I know the minister at the end will respond to the requests, and that's important that we have a strategy to respond. Can I ask the minister please discuss the policy changes and strategy that the honorable lady is going to produce here and government's going to produce here with the relevant minister at the assembly to ensure that we can move forward with a positive future, even though it looks incredibly black at this moment in time. Unlike England, which boasts well over a hundred higher education institutions, Northern Ireland has only two, two for our population, Queen's University and Ulster University.

In a region with only two distinct academic employers, the impending job losses at Ulster University do not simply represent a standard corporate restructuring. They represent a catastrophic hollowing out of nearly half of Northern Ireland's university network. Because academics and researchers have practically nowhere else to turn locally, these cuts create an inevitable brain drain, forcing elite talent to flee across the water to Great Britain while triggering course closures that push local students to follow them. In conclusion, and very conscious others want to speak, Madam Chair, when one of only two pillars of your higher education framework is forced to cut a quarter of its applicants for redundancy, the structural integrity of the entire region's skills economy faces immediate collapse. That's how serious it is for us in Northern Ireland.

That's why I seek the minister's help. Thank you.

21:22 - 21:24

Speaker 12

Dr. Scott Arthur.

21:24 - 25:09

Scott Arthur

Thank you, Madam Chair, Mrs. Vaz. It's a pleasure to serve under you today. And I do thank the member for Sheffield Central for the way in which she introduced the debate. Sheffield University was actually the first place I visited outside Scotland, and I think the Red Deer pub was the first English pub I ever went into, which is right next to the university. Before becoming elected to this place, I did work in the university sector for twenty years in Scotland.

And our universities are amongst Scotland's biggest assets. And across the sector, there's incredible innovation, and each year they attract the very best staff and students from right across the world. And I always say, Mrs. Vaz, that any country which is serious about its economy should be serious about its universities. And it's great to see our Prime Minister having universities at the heart of that triple helix model he talks about so often. Eighteen months in a similar place in this place, I quoted the then president of NUS Scotland, who warned that Scotland's education system was crumbling.

At that time, I hoped her words would prompt the Scottish government into action. Sadly, they didn't, and Scotland's sector is lurching from crisis to crisis. While undergraduate university education in Scotland is free, it is grossly underfunded. Broadly speaking, the average student fees in Scotland are well over two thousand pounds less than what universities get in England. That means less money for facilities and less money for the wages of staff.

I should say actually, in terms of my register of interest, I'm a member of UCU and I have an ongoing connection with Heriot-Watt University, which I should have mentioned at the start. So because of these huge stresses, there's industrial action right across the sector in Scotland right now, I think at six universities. I think industrial action at one university might suggest a local issue, but when you have industrial action right across the country, it maybe suggests that the government needs to step up and do something about it.

In my own constituency, both Edinburgh Napier University and Heriot-Watt are internationally recognized institutions. They are home to dedicated staff, ambitious students, and world-leading research. But both face serious challenges. In the past year, there's been talk of compulsory redundancies and also course reductions. And there's similar issues at Edinburgh University, which is actually outside my constituency, but quite a lot of the staff and students are based in Edinburgh South West.

This situation can't continue. We really need the Scottish government to bring together the universities, the staff, and the students and the trade unions to agree a way forward. I do want to talk briefly about immigration. During my time at Heriot-Watt, I worked along fantastic academics from around the world. On one side of me, I had in my office next door, I had Professor Adebayo Adeloye from Nigeria, and on the other side, I had Benny Suryanto, who came from Indonesia.

Our students were lucky that these people choose to come to the UK. And I feel lucky that students also came from right around the world to spend time in Edinburgh and enjoy the education here and also the opportunities that provides. And I'm really concerned that the government is making it harder for both staff and students to come here. If we're serious about growing our economy, we have to recognize the benefits that universities provide both nationally and also locally in our towns and cities. So it'd be great to hear about what's happening inside the government to support universities to ensure they can thrive, both in terms of their funding, I know in Scotland that's largely a matter for the Scottish government, but I think the UK government could do more to support the immigration status for students and staff.

25:09 - 25:11

Speaker 15

Thank you, Ms. Fiaz.

25:11 - 29:10

Hannah Kathrine Spencer

Britain has a proud tradition of higher education. Our historic universities, our culture of learning and discovery, and the world-class research carried out in this country have earned us a reputation that is recognized around the world. And it is an asset that we must celebrate and that we must protect. Because that tradition belongs to all of us. Higher education is so much broader than a three-year degree.

Higher technical qualifications, foundation degrees, degree apprenticeships, and lifelong learning all have a vital role to play alongside academic study. I left school at 16 and built a career as a plumber and gas engineer through vocational training at Bolton College and later apprenticeships, including the Prince's Trust's brilliant enterprise program. And I raise this because too often the voices of working people, tradespeople, people who maybe didn't get on with school or just prefer steel-toe-cap boots to suits, are missing from the debates and decisions that shape higher education. And in the areas that I represent, there is no shortage of ambition or people willing to graft to make something of themselves. But far too many people struggle, through no fault of their own, to see a clear route into secure, well-paid work and a decent life.

A stronger and accessible higher education system should be part of that route, and that system is clearly now at breaking point. Across the country, higher education institutions are facing a deepening financial crisis driven by years of underinvestment and a funding model no longer fit for purpose. Universities, specialist colleges, and other higher education providers are grappling with a multi-billion-pound funding gap as tuition fee income and public funding have failed to keep pace with their rising costs. Yesterday, more than 400 students graduated from UCEN Manchester. Many of them were the first in their family to enter higher education, while others were mature learners returning to education.

And yet providers like UCEN that specialize in widening participation are increasingly being asked to do more with less, with their funding steadily eroded. And the consequences of this underfunding are already painfully clear: courses closing, experienced staff being forced out, and departments having to make severe cuts just to make ends meet. And at the same time, working conditions have worsened for all staff members, with growing workloads, stagnant pay, and increased job insecurity.

And in vocational education, things have got so bad that institutions can't persuade people to leave industries like plastering to take up teaching the next generation because the wages are far below what they are already earning. And at the same time, students are facing exorbitant fees and the prospect of being burdened by decades of debt. And if we're serious about equal opportunity, we must recognize that higher education is a long-term investment in our people, in our communities, and in our country. And the inventions and discoveries made by higher education researchers have the potential to benefit all of us, like the COVID-19 vaccines or the development of famine-resistant crops. The government faces a choice in today's budget.

They can continue papering over the cracks, or they can finally make a long-term investment in Britain's future. The Green Party's position is clear: higher education should be free, and students should be provided with adequate maintenance support funded through public investment, not private debt. A 1% tax on wealth above 10 million pounds would raise around 15 billion pounds a year, money that would more than cover the cost of scrapping tuition fees and giving our higher education institutions a vital injection of cash. Higher education policy must focus on spreading opportunity and investment more fairly across the country, in areas like Gorton, Denton, Abbey Hey, Burnage, Longsight, Levenshulme. People from these places have never, ever lacked talent or drive.

We must stop wasting it by properly funding higher education and finally recognizing learning for the national asset it is. Thank you.

29:10 - 30:51

Darren James Paffey

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I congratulate my honorable friend for securing this important debate. Southampton's home to two excellent universities, and yet kids growing up in my constituency, of those on free school meals, only 7% of them will hold a degree by the time they are 22. Even of those who don't receive free school meals, just 19% in Itchen will get there. Go a few miles up the road to Winchester and that becomes 39%.

We must make sure that higher education is not shut down as an option for young people. So in my contribution, I just want to focus on three points which I think are becoming worryingly clear, and that is that the funding system as it is is not working for students, it's not working for universities, and I worry that the only one it is working for is the Treasury, and that's not what I believe this Labour government is about. On students, so I was the first in my family lucky enough to go to university, and I started in 2000 when, wait for it, fees were 1,025 pounds. My annual loan was about three and a half thousand pounds. Now, we looked enviously on the generation before us who didn't pay fees and who actually received a grant to go there.

This generation is looking enviously on my generation, and I think that tells us something very worrying. I went on to spend 20 years as a university lecturer and so saw every subsequent wave of student finance agreements. And the Treasury Committee has concluded that where we are now is essentially mis-selling some of the previous loan agreements, and these are on terms that no commercial lender would ever be allowed to offer.

30:51 - 31:06

Scott Arthur

I know I don't look it, Mrs. Vaz, but when I went to university, Margaret Thatcher was still our Prime Minister. And I find it incredible, incredible that the funding for students was better then in terms of their day-to-day living costs than it is today. Doesn't he agree?

31:06 - 31:39

Darren James Paffey

He makes an absolutely salient point, and, you know, I think many of us never imagined we would get to an even worse place, but here we are. Only the top three earning deciles of recent intakes will ever pay off their student loans in full. The nurse, the teacher, the engineer on 35,000 pounds will pay 9% for decades and still never clear the balance. Dare I say it, if it walks like a tax and quacks like a tax, call it a tax, treat it as one, properly sort it, and it could well be a better deal than the current loan system.

31:39 - 31:40

Will my honorable friend give way?

31:41 - 32:17

John Slinger

I thank my honorable friend, he's making a very compelling speech. I wonder if he has noticed the coverage in the Telegraph that reports that next year graduates on the minimum wage will be making repayments on three out of the five student loan plans from next year onwards. And would he agree with me that this in many ways breaks the social contract that we have with our student population who were essentially told that they would earn a huge amount more and therefore they should contribute to their higher education?

32:17 - 35:28

Darren James Paffey

I agree that this is not the deal that I think our country wants to offer its young people, particularly if this government is about breaking down barriers to opportunities. Secondly, for universities, the Office for Students reported in May that more than a third of English higher education institutes were already in deficit last year, and that if recruitment simply flatlines, then nearly six in ten could be in deficit within five years. International student numbers, as honorable members have stated, have fallen by around forty-five thousand last year, and study visa applications in the first months of this year were down by a third. Our Education Select Committee that I sit on warned in May of the real threat of insolvency. Universities like ours, University of Southampton and Southampton Solent University, are anchors of our local economy, and I know that's reflected around the country as well.

We can't afford to let them fail because they are not immune from the job losses that are affecting other HEIs. Thirdly, the taxpayer. The government estimates that the state meets thirty-five to forty percent of the cost of higher education. Others take a different view, the IFS puts the figure for 2022 cohort at around three percent, with ninety-seven percent of the cost met by students themselves. Sir Philip Augar recommended a fifty-fifty split.

Whichever number you look at and whichever one you choose to believe, we are a long way from the balance that Parliament intended and that that bill is being quietly passed to young people. Which brings me to the international student levy. Now, don't get me wrong, I absolutely welcome the return of maintenance grants. For families on low incomes, these really matter. But a grant of up to a thousand pounds a year is around twenty pounds a week, and it's to be funded by a levy of nine hundred and twenty pounds per international student from 2028, forecast last November to raise four hundred and forty-five million in its first year.

But that forecast was made before visa applications fell by a third, and I fear that a grant that depends on a shrinking tax base is a good intention but it's built on sand. So I ask the Minister if she'll commit to publishing before the levy legislation completes its passage an updated forecast of what it will raise on today's recruitment figures and confirm that maintenance grants will be protected if that falls short. And finally, alongside that, the government has said that the whole student finance system is under review. That is news that I welcome enthusiastically. Will she set out how and by when that review will report and whether it will move us back towards a fair balance between the state and the individual?

All of this, as honorable members are making their points very eloquently, is about intergenerational justice. It's about whether twenty-two-year-old me would look at university and say, yeah, I can risk that, or more likely, as would happen now, I'd be like, nah, my family has never done that and I cannot simply afford it. It is about growth and it is about the seven percent in Itchen and more across this country who deserve better opportunities and better odds.

35:28 - 35:31

Speaker 29

Thank you. Perran Moon.

35:31 - 39:11

Perran Moon

Ms Vaz, it's an honor to serve under your chairmanship and I also would like to thank the member for Sheffield Central for bringing this debate.

And as remarkable as it is to imagine, I also began university under Margaret Thatcher. The higher education funding settlement is currently failing both universities and young people in Cornwall. Institutions such as Falmouth University, based largely in my Camborne, Redruth and Hayle constituency, are central to our local economy and our skills base. Yet they're increasingly being asked to educate students at a loss. Delivering a full-time degree costs more than £12,000 a year.

Even when the maximum tuition fees rises past £10,000 next year, it will still fall well short. No sector can remain sustainable if growth depends on losses. And the funding gap is particularly acute for regional and specialist institutions. Universities therefore are forced to compete for short-term grants and rely on international student income to balance the books. But when that income falls, courses and jobs are at risk.

We've seen this play out over the summer at Exeter University's Tremough campus, also in my Camborne, Redruth and Hayle constituency, with voluntary redundancies and the closure of its geography course. The system is not working for students either, especially those from lower-income backgrounds. In my constituency, less than 23% of 18-year-olds went to university in 2025. Compare this with 51% in London. That is not because young people in Cornwall lack talent or ambition.

It is because in one of the poorest regions of Northern Europe, the costs of pursuing a degree with the associated debt are too great to even consider. The barriers to higher education are simply too high. Even students who remain in Cornwall but rightly want to live on campus find that the rent for a single room consumes almost their entire maintenance loan before they've spent a penny on food, travel or other essentials. Nor does the loan system make things any better. Those from wealthier families may avoid taking out a loan altogether, whilst low-income students have no such option.

A low-income student for a three-year course could be left with a £67,000 debt the moment they graduate. The interest on the debt often accumulates faster than repayments, leaving poorer graduates paying a higher effective rate for their entire careers. Higher education should expand opportunity and drive growth in places like Cornwall. Instead, we have a system that asks universities to do more with less while operating a student loan system that, for all intents and purposes, functions as a regressive graduate tax. We cannot build a fairer, more productive country on that foundation.

So I ask the Minister, what steps is the government taking to make higher education funding fairer for students and more sustainable for universities?

39:11 - 42:29

Margaret Pamela Cox

Thank you, Mrs. Vaz, and thank you to the honorable member for securing this debate today. I declare an interest as a member of UCU and a member of the APPG for universities. Now, everybody in this debate wants to see young people and lifelong learners succeed in their chosen path in life. And most would agree that the government has done a great deal to invest in education and skills since 2024, and I want to pay tribute to that.

We've seen that uplift in our schools, in our SEND provision, in youth hubs, colleges and apprenticeships. Our debate today, however, is focused on the situation in higher education and my discussions with those who work in and represent that sector give me cause for concern as I know it does many colleagues here. So I've spoken before in this place and elsewhere, as have other South Essex MPs, about the very significant challenges that my former colleagues at the University of Essex have faced over the past year. The university closed its Southend campus and made large numbers of staff redundant there and at its main Colchester campus. But the University of Essex is not alone, as we've heard, in facing these painful challenges.

Many universities are closing departments and issuing redundancies. At least two other universities are considering campus withdrawals or closures. The University of Buckingham has withdrawn from its Crewe campus to be replaced as the main operator by Apollo Education. The University of Brighton is closing its Eastbourne campus and is considering closing its Falmer campus. Now other institutions are merging: the University of Kent with Greenwich, City University with St George's, King's with Cranfield.

These new arrangements are I think the start of a of a of a new era in higher education. They raise the very thorny issue of how universities that were brought into being by the Privy Council via Royal Charters merge with those that were brought into being as companies limited by guarantee. I suspect this is a policy rug that nobody really wants to lift. Other universities are being bought out or privatised. Lincoln Bishop University, for example, is now operated by Global University Systems, a global body with millions of students around the world.

Now this new era of campus closures, redundancies, mergers and buyouts comes at a time when many in the sector face huge financial challenges. The Education Select Committee has has been referenced here recently reported that, and I quote, the higher education sector in England is facing a financial crisis that now poses a real risk of institutional insolvency. This is a situation that requires our close attention. So, Madam Chair, we need our universities to thrive in our rich research and teaching ecosystem. They're part of an ecosystem.

Our industrial strategy depends on it, as does our ability to create sovereign innovations in every sector. Now universities, it seems to me, are very ready to adapt and have adapted over the years, but they need us here to have more open conversations in this place about how they can best do that. So I would ask the Minister to continue to champion our universities, but to support them by enabling more open conversations like this one about the scale of the challenges they face. Thank you.

42:29 - 42:31

Speaker 32

Neil Duncan-Jordan.

42:31 - 46:20

John Neil Duncan-Jordan

Thank you, Ms Farris. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair and I congratulate my honourable friend the member for Sheffield Central in securing this timely debate. Now my constituency of Poole doesn't have a university within it, but of course I do have many constituents who study and work at the two nearby universities in Bournemouth. However, my interest in this subject comes from the fact that when I was a regional official for UNISON, I was head of the HE section in the South East and this experience taught me a lot about the way in which the sector was financed. Today, a growing number of institutions are forecasting deficits and many have either or soon will be introducing cost-cutting measures that other members have mentioned, including redundancies among both academic and support staff as well.

Now for years there's been a financial over-reliance on international students and during COVID when I was working as a trade union official we saw that decline greatly and it hasn't yet been able to come back. Coupled with changes to visa restrictions, international students are being put off from coming to UK.

There's also rising operational costs, energy costs, pensions, national insurance rises, they've all had an impact on large campuses. And we have a tuition fee funding model that's failed to keep pace with those rising costs. But the real reason for the state of HE funding is the marketization of the sector. Pitching one university against another to compete for students has driven an arms race to build the shiniest buildings they can, often at the expense of the teaching and student experience. And at any time, many of our campuses look more like a building site than a university.

The financial risks, however, are not evenly spread across the sector. Institutions with smaller reserves, limited international recruitment and weaker balance sheets are particularly exposed. But the most invidious result of these financial pressures is the move to make staff pay for the failure of the system. At a number of universities, including those with whom I used to negotiate, we are seeing the creation of subsidiary companies to transfer staff out of direct university employment. And the effect of this removes them from either the local government pension scheme or the teachers' pension scheme.

Now staff who refuse to transfer are often faced with the threat of redundancy. So despite the government's best efforts, this looks remarkably to me like fire and rehire. Now the government cannot secure the future of the HE sector simply through further fee increases on students. I believe we need an immediate cap on student numbers for each institution, rather than allow the larger institutions to hoover up all the available students in an area. We need financial support for those universities facing immediate financial pressure and we need to put a halt to the redundancy and wholesale course closures that are taking place across many of those institutions.

Now the Prime Minister has made it clear that his growth agenda is based on a triple helix model of business, government and universities working together. But for this to succeed, we need a healthy HE sector and for this to happen, we need greater government intervention and support.

46:20 - 49:45

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and thank you to the member for Sheffield Central for securing this debate. Access to higher education can be life-changing for young people. However, this opportunity is already harder to grasp for young people in Cornwall. Students face the high costs of travelling from remote disconnected areas and if they stay local, high costs of private renting in a tourism-heavy region.

Students across the South West face the second highest monthly living costs in the UK at 1,212 pounds per month, which is only 114 pounds less than London. These financial barriers directly impact whether young people pursue higher education. While the 2024 UK-wide entry rate for 18-year-olds was 36.3%, the South West was joint lowest at 30% and in Truro and Falmouth this was 27.2%, which is actually the lowest proportion on record since 2016. The value of having universities close by with a variety of courses and offerings is key for young people in Cornwall being able to access the opportunities of higher education.

HE is an investment in place, nowhere more so than in Cornwall. It leads to economic growth, productivity, innovation, including higher wages and skills and regional development. Funding concerns have been ongoing in relation to higher education institutions in Cornwall and it's integral that support for these vital institutions is considered. Losing higher education opportunities here, especially with the campus that's in my honourable friend's constituency across the border, means Cornish students risk losing out on those opportunities. Additionally, Falmouth University, which began in my constituency, offers both traditional creative arts alongside technical and entrepreneurial courses and produces nearly 7,000 highly skilled graduates each year.

Tuition fee income doesn't meet the costs of delivering these degrees, particularly in creative and technical universities like Falmouth. That leaves universities with a difficult choice: sacrifice their core academic delivery for research investment or engage with more corporates. Government funding is cost-intensive to obtain and competitive, and frequent changes to government funding models make it very hard to plan effectively. Specialist institutions like Falmouth are unevenly affected with those higher costs to secure fewer grants. Funding for these integral institutions can't fall by the wayside.

They offer employment opportunities locally, wider economic benefits and give young people in Cornwall a tangible place to pin their aspirations. I welcome the government's reintroduction of funding for higher education through targeted means-tested maintenance grants, something that will support low-income students from deprived areas to access and excel in higher education. We need to make sure that funding for a diverse range of courses that allow young people to gain skills and access new experiences is accessible, realistic and allows for the higher education sector to continue to foster ambition in Truro and Falmouth, Cornwall, the South West and indeed across the UK.

49:45 - 53:41

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank you, Madam Chair, and it's a pleasure to serve this morning. I'd like to thank my honourable friend the member for Sheffield Central for securing this important debate. Now Sheffield is my university. I attended the 45th reunion last weekend and apart from the fact that many of my former student colleagues had decided to dye their hair grey, everybody was looking remarkably well. And I'd also like to say that I actually went to university before Mrs Thatcher was the Prime Minister.

So I'm as you know a former NHS surgeon, a father of three children who've all been through our university system. Now our universities are among our greatest assets, as we've heard from the many thoughtful contributions in this morning's debate. They drive research, they support our local economies, but we cannot take them for granted. They are facing considerable financial pressure: rising operating costs and an increasing reliance on international student income have left many of them in a very precarious position. Now we all know the importance of universities far beyond the lecture theatres.

Just this Monday I spoke in the House about the genetic research at the University of East Anglia that will help us distinguish between dangerous and less dangerous prostate cancers, a subject that we absolutely need to sort out. Now that sort of groundbreaking research depends on well-funded universities with a confidence to invest in the long term, particularly in subjects such as my own in medicine but also in the sciences and many others where the costs of providing higher education and training are considerable.

So, the government's decision to increase tuition fee caps in line with inflation, rather than allowing their value to erode, makes sense. And I also welcome the return of maintenance grants. These are important steps towards supporting universities and students. But we must recognize there is a difficult balance at the heart of this debate. Universities need more money, yet increasing tuition fees means we're asking students to take more debt.

Now, I can see that generational difference in my own family. My my two eldest children studied under plan one, my my youngest is on plan two, and the students I met at Thurston Community College in my constituency face the prospect of something called plan five, with repayments potentially stretching over 40 years. Now, when I graduated from medical school, I did so without tuition fee debt. I began my career, I entered the housing market, and I gradually became more secure. But for today's graduates, that looks very, very different.

A maths graduate who recently attended one of my constituency surgeries brought home just how complicated our student finance system has become. He brought a very, very well-worked-out spreadsheet, which explained this to me, at least at the time, although I couldn't possibly explain it to you today. Now, we we must avoid a situation in which the financial sustainability of our great universities is secured simply by transferring the ever-greater burden onto the next generation. For generational unfairness is the great challenge of this Parliament. Now, I ask the minister to consider just two things.

First, how can we provide universities with greater long-term funding certainty, rather than leaving them so dependent on tuition fees and unpredictable international student recruitment? Second, how can we ensure that efforts to ensure to stabilize university finances are accompanied by a fair and transparent student finance system, so that young people really understand the financial commitments they make? Now, our universities need financial stability, but our students need financial security. And this is a hard thing, but our government knows how to do hard things. Thank you, Chair.

53:41 - 54:24

Speaker 41

Thank you, Ms Vaz, and I congratulate my honorable friend from Sheffield Central for securing this debate and the contributions from across the chamber today. Lee Steeley said that issues facing our universities are preserve of big city MPs or from leafy suburbs as speakers, obviously Sunderland's MP, and want to highlight the University of Sunderland's importance to my city. This is as much a red wall issue as it is for anywhere else in the country. The University of Sunderland's educational and economic impact and what the higher education funding environment means for our city. The university that I speak about comes from the proudest of polytechnic traditions.

54:24 - 55:06

Speaker 43

It's rooted in the city with a mission to be open to anyone that can benefit from higher education, and it's shaped by what local employers and the professions need. Nowhere is that clearer, Ms Vaz, than in health. Sunderland trains the nurses, pharmacists, paramedics, and doctors that our NHS relies on. Its medical school was explicitly set up to bring more working-class and local students into medicine, and it's now moving into dental education now, in a region where too many people struggle to see NHS dentists. When it was named University of the Year for Social Inclusion, more than six in ten of its students were the first in their family to go to university.

55:06 - 57:37

Speaker 41

And can I associate myself with the remarks of my honorable friend from Southampton Itchen about the intergenerational and social mobility missions of our universities that is crucial in Sunderland as it is elsewhere. This is what widening participation looks like in practice. Young people from Pallion, Hendon, or Southwick in my constituency having the chance to get a degree, de-risking by living at home some of those financial issues facing students that we've talked about.

The university also as we've heard from other colleagues brings people to the North East from across the country and as successive government's international strategies have encouraged from around the world. In terms of its economic impact independent analysis found that the University of Sunderland adds over 250 million a year to our city's economy and supports more than 4,000 jobs in the city. One of our biggest employers. The university however is under real financial pressure and this has serious consequences for the city as a whole. While home tuition income has fallen behind costs and the visa landscape for international students has changed rapidly and unpredictably as a result the university has had to set out plans to save 40 million pounds over the next two years and staff are understandably worried about their jobs.

That pressure didn't come from nowhere for years the previous government froze tuition fees while costs kept rising with no long-term plan. As others have said government now expects to fund just 16 pence in every pound of home student funding. Universities that do the most to open doors like Sunderland are left the most exposed. I know government is working within significant fiscal constraints. I know it's taken steps to set stable expectations for future fee income so that proper financial planning can happen and I of course welcome the return of targeted maintenance grants.

But in previous responses the government have been keen to highlight that universities have always been autonomous institutions. And I understand that and my understanding and experience has been that they take that responsibility to be very financially sustainable seriously even when that means making deeply painful and locally unpopular decisions like the withdrawal of funding from our national glass centre in Sunderland. But I say this we can't treat them as autonomous institutions while assume they will always be there as anchors in communities like Sunderland and across the country and I hope we can hear more about the government's strategy in the long term in response. Thank you.

57:37 - 57:43

Speaker 39

Thank you. We now move to wind-ups I call the Lib Dem spokesperson Ian Sollom.

57:43 - 01:05:55

Ian Sollom

Thank you Mrs Vaz it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I congratulate the honourable member for Sheffield Central on securing this debate. And Sheffield is an excellent place to ground this debate because it has two great examples of the origin stories of many of our universities. The University of Sheffield is a civic university in the truest sense when it sought its charter in 1904 steel workers factory workers and other local people raised over 50,000 pounds in penny donations to support it. And Sheffield Hallam traces its roots to the School of Design founded in 1843 to train designers for the city's industry and became a university in 1992. One red brick one post-92 both serve the city.

And both embody the idea of universities as anchors of their community. That idea is now at risk. Ms Vaz later today the Chancellor delivers his first budget. And every signal is that universities should expect very little from it. But we can't continue to ignore the stark choice before us when it comes to university policy.

Either we carry on with a managed decline courses cut talent lost places left behind. Or we can choose transformation universities as engines of learning throughout life as innovation hubs driving economic growth and as civic institutions embedded in the places they serve.

The Liberal Democrats would choose transformation and I hope the government will do the same. Because at the moment too many universities are fighting for survival. More than a third of English providers were in deficit last year. The department's own costing study found that universities lose around 3,000 pound on every home undergraduate they teach. And research is worse.

Universities now recover only two thirds of research costs. And according to the Russell Group, universities put in 6.3 billion pounds of their own money into research last year. For many years now, the funding gap has been filled by international students. But that income is now also falling away. Visa applications in August, the peak month, were down 17% on a year ago.

Education as a Great British export is of course about much more than money. But the business model that has saved the government from spending more on home students and research is being undermined. In the finance bill that will follow today's budget, the government has said that it intends to legislate for a 925 pound levy on every international student. And only a tiny sliver of that money raised goes to the maintenance grants that were put forward as a justification for it. Now this crisis does not simply affect an ivory tower elite sitting apart from our communities.

In many towns and cities, the university is one of the largest employers and the source of the next generation of teachers, nurses, engineers and many other professions, producing graduates likely to stay and work locally and serving students often least able to move away to study. When a nursing course or an engineering department closes in such a place, it does not relocate. It disappears from that region. And with it goes a route into a profession for everyone who cannot simply up sticks and leave. And post-92 universities carry a burden their older neighbours do not.

For no other reason than institutional history, they are tied into the teachers' pension scheme where employer contributions reached 28.7% last year, roughly double what many older universities pay. That's around 8,000 pound extra a year for a typical member of staff. In July, the government ruled out any help, but part of solving the crisis in the sector must include working towards a single fairer pensions framework. And there is also the question of what happens when one of these institutions does not survive. The Office for Students told the Education Select Committee that 24 institutions could exit the market within a year.

The committee recommended a special administration regime so that a failing university can keep teaching while its future is resolved. But the government has said it's not currently persuaded because legislating would be too complex. I would argue that that is an argument for starting now, not for doing nothing. Further education colleges have had a special regime since 2019. And having no regime has its own risks.

With no orderly way to fail, many simply assume the government will step in. Sir Philip Augar has said a handful of universities are already getting secret bailouts. When I asked ministers about that, I was told emergency support is not provided, but also that officials meet universities and their banks regularly in confidence.

Now, discussing potential rescues behind closed doors gives us all of the moral hazard and none of the transparency. Liberal Democrats see universities as essential national infrastructure, not cost centers to be squeezed, and that means a new settlement. In the short term, reform the levy before it reaches the statute book, re-profile student loan fee payments to ease the cash flow, offer low-interest loans for restructuring, and remove the VAT penalty that stops universities sharing back-office services so they merge finance and HR rather than cut teaching. We need to fund the breadth of subjects in every region and make sure public research grants actually cover the 80% of costs they're supposed to. But this also needs to be in partnership with obligations on universities as well; the money alone will not fix it.

After 2030, the number of 18-year-olds falls by 17%. Yet 82% of the growth in priority occupations in the industrial strategy sectors will require a higher education qualification. Put those two facts together and a model built around school leavers simply won't work long-term. Many of the people who will fill the jobs in that growth are already in work and will need to retrain as technology reshapes what they do. So universities do need to open up to adults through modular lifelong learning, and we would suggest that needs to be through lifelong skills grants, not simply loans.

They also need to work hand-in-hand with further education colleges with credits that transfer between them, and they need to turn British research into businesses that stay in Britain.

01:05:56 - 01:05:57

Yes, I certainly will.

01:05:57 - 01:06:27

Scott Arthur

Good for giving way. You're diagnosing the problem excellently, I mean you're detailing all the issues. I mean personally I don't want to go back too far, but we do have to think about the role the Lib Dems played in the coalition government and the decision to go back on their pledge not to raise fees and of course raise it to £9,000. But the budget this afternoon isn't just about spending money, it's also about raising money to pay for policies. So a range of policies...

01:06:27 - 01:06:29

Speaker 45

The opposition spokesman's only got one minute left.

01:06:29 - 01:06:33

Speaker 46

Yeah, so it'd be good to hear how the money would be raised to meet all these obligations.

01:06:33 - 01:07:42

Ian Sollom

I thank the member for his intervention. Actually a lot of the interventions that I've suggested on the university side are cost-neutral and around restructuring. To conclude, so to conclude, Ms Vaz, sorry, I have three questions for the minister. First, will the government update its impact analysis to reflect this year's fall in international recruitment and publish the effect by region and type of institution of the international student levy before the Finance Bill is debated? Second, will it think again on special administration before rather than after a university fails?

And third, will the government commit to working with the sector to end the pensions penalty on post-92 universities?

Universities did not get to this position overnight, they will not recover overnight. But today's budget is a chance to stop the managed decline and start on the transformation, and I hope the Chancellor takes it. Thank you.

01:07:42 - 01:07:44

Speaker 48

Spokesperson Rebecca Smith.

01:07:44 - 01:16:53

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Ms Fiaz, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and also to be responding on behalf of His Majesty's Official Opposition. I want to start by thanking the honourable member for Sheffield Central for tabling this important debate and for everybody's contributions this morning. And just to pick out a couple of things, I have to say, Madam Chair, I didn't expect to find quite so much agreement for Margaret Thatcher's education policies this morning, and I'm very grateful to the member for Edinburgh South West and Camborne and Redruth in particular for their positivity around that. But I also want to just pick up on the points that were made by the honourable member for Southampton Itchen, who, although I think we are the same age, started at Southampton University a year after me, and we have many mutual friends from both of our times at university. But I do think it's worth noting that the changes that we experienced as that first cohort that had to pay fees and take on a loan was entirely because of the 1998 Teaching and Higher Education Act that was snuck through by the New Labour government, and I think conveniently forgotten about in a time where social media didn't exist.

And I dread to think the furore that there would have been today had students realized what was going to happen to them, but I for one, aged 16, thought I was going to university for free, and by 20, by the age of 18, that was not the case. I'm going to make some progress on my speech if I may, but I think it's just worth putting that on the record. And I don't want to burst the bubble of the member for Sunderland Central, but Plymouth has also seen dentistry offered as a subject, and unfortunately only about 5% of the students are actually from Plymouth and nearly all of them leave the area. So while we absolutely need more dentist students, in terms of it being a mechanism for solving that crisis, so far I think that's not quite the case. That's a whole other debate for another time, but I just want to highlight that that isn't always the solution that we hope it will be.

But in response to the topic itself, I want to start by putting on record that the opposition recognize the enormous value and significance of the UK's university sector, both in terms of its economic and societal contribution. The National Centre for Universities and Businesses argued that the UK's universities are one of our greatest strategic assets. They educate the future workforce, conduct world-leading research, and act as anchor institutions in regions, much of which we've heard today, supporting businesses, driving innovation, and powering local growth. Economically, universities contribute around 265 billion pounds to the UK economy and support over 800,000 jobs. The return on investment is also staggering: for every 1 pound of public money invested in the higher education sector across the country, 14 pounds is put back into the economy.

In addition, there is no doubt that universities are some of the most critical engines of growth and prosperity at a regional level. And as a proud Member of Parliament for South West Devon, I know the huge role the sector plays across the South West. We have 10 universities, several of which have been mentioned today, with over 200,000 students, employing over 31,000 people and contributing 7.8 billion of gross output. Indeed, Plymouth Marjon's, University of Plymouth, Arts University, and the University of Plymouth are certainly playing their part. And unfortunately, I'm meeting with the Vice-Chancellor of Plymouth University tomorrow on this very topic, so cannot add any more at the moment, but I know that he is wanting to talk to me because of the struggles they are facing.

Notwithstanding this vital economic contribution, it would be wrong to purely look at universities in terms of their economic output. Universities help shape the society we all live in, they equip young people with the skills needed to navigate an increasingly fractured society. They teach young people to think critically and outside the box, skills that I undoubtedly believe will be essential in a Britain where communities are more divided than ever and one where the spectre of the AI revolution looms over us all.

It is beyond clear that universities are going to play a central role in Britain for decades to come and that is our view but we are not blind to some of the big challenges the sector always face also faces. It is no secret that there are real and imminent challenges facing the UK's university sector. A report from the House of Commons Education Select Committee from May 2026 has gone so far as to claim that the sector is facing a financial crisis that now poses a real risk of institutional insolvency. The report lays bare the terrible state of some universities' finances with the Office for Students fearing that 24 providers could face insolvency within the next 12 months. Against this uncertain backdrop universities are being forced to close courses and sell buildings to cut costs and make efficiencies.

Some of the difficulties the universities are facing is explained well in the Policy Exchange report Tarnish Towers. They argue that high inflation, pension pressures and a reduction in international student numbers have created a perfect storm for our universities and this all seems to be compounded by a lack of action from the government thus far. A Universities UK report from February 26 finds that government policy decisions have led to an estimated 3.7 billion pounds reduction in funding to higher education providers in England from 2024-25 to 2029-30. Their analysis shows the impact of government immigration policy but also the damaging shock the sector received through increased pension and employment costs which has been mentioned already this morning. In 2020 Keir Starmer made scrapping university tuition fees the centerpiece of his leadership campaign.

Indeed the previous education secretary even had the audacity to claim that graduates would pay less under a Labour government in June 2023. Students right across the country felt betrayed and let down by the government's broken promises when the previous education secretary announced in November 2024 that Labour would push up tuition fees for students. In that debate the shadow education secretary said that she would be willing to work with the government to support universities and students but as of yet His Majesty's opposition are yet to be invited to work constructively with government on this. Indeed we have heard very little from the government about what they want to do at all. So I hope the minister can shed some light on the government's plans to support our university sector this morning.

The new education secretary has been very keen to talk about her plans to reform technical education. She has come to this House to give a statement on that particular issue but aside from that we have heard little else. The new education secretary has not come to this House to clarify when the government will bring the legislation they promised at the King's Speech forward to support children and families with SEND and the education secretary is yet to come to the House to talk to some of the challenges facing the university sector. Now I'm grateful as I've already said to the honorable member for Sheffield Central for this debate as it gives His Majesty's opposition some time to ask the minister who I respect very much some important questions in relation to higher education funding. Firstly can the minister shed any light on how the government intends to support the 24 institutions that the Office for Students claimed were at risk of insolvency in the 12 months from May 2026.

Secondly can she confirm whether the government intend to make any changes to Plan 2 student loans. Thirdly can the minister tell this House whether they have had any meetings with institutions which might be facing significant financial uncertainty over the course of the remainder of this academic year and lastly whether the government will rule out pushing up tuition fees for students again before the end of this parliament. These are very important questions which His Majesty's opposition, the higher education sector and most important students right across the country need answers on. Universities need them to begin to develop long-term financial plans and students need to have certainty about their finances and indeed the stability of the institution they are studying at and the course that they are taking.

Regrettably, Madam Chair, I hold little hope that the government has answers to these questions given the lack of focus the new Education Secretary seems to have shown to higher education since coming into office. Of course, this is in stark contrast to the official opposition who have outlined detailed and fully costed plans to lower interest on Plan 2 student loans and have also set out reforms to the university sector to ensure the government stop funding dead-end university courses. All of this is part of our new deal for young people. To conclude, Madam Chair, I want to reiterate His Majesty's opposition's firm belief in the strength and value of the UK's higher education sector. It is indeed a high strategic, a huge strategic asset.

However, we must be honest and recognize it faces huge challenges over the course of the next decade. The digital revolution means universities need to rethink how they prepare students to get into the world of work, and they must also be open to accepting the fact that they must adapt to stay solvent in the new economic reality. Government should be there to guide the sector through these turbulent headwinds, but we have seen little indication that they are there to do that. The new Education Secretary urgently needs to shed some light on what steps they will take to address some deeply concerning reports about the financial health of our institutions. And Madam Chair, with the budget little over an hour away, I hope the Chancellor will be setting out some steps to solve these problems, but I hold out little hope today.

Thank you.

01:16:53 - 01:16:57

Speaker 49

Minister Georgia Gould.

01:16:57 - 01:20:42

Georgia Gould

Thank you, Ms Vaz, it's an honor to share, to be under your chairship, apologies. And I very much congratulate the honorable member for Sheffield Central on securing this really important debate. She is a passionate advocate for this, these issues. She has chaired the APPG for students and has regularly raised issues related to universities and students. And I think we heard from her speech earlier how thoughtful and knowledgeable she is on these issues.

I also wanted to thank my honorable friend from Colchester for her characteristically thoughtful speech. And I think she called for a wider debate and discussion and focus on these issues. And I think we've had a very important debate here today. We've heard the range of expertise within this chamber and within our parliament, from lecturers to those who have real experience of working within universities. And a range of different decades that everyone went to universities.

I can't believe that anyone in this room looks old enough to have gone to university under Margaret Thatcher. And we should be really rightly proud of our world-class higher education sector, a sector that remains by any objective metric one of our nation's greatest exports and a global beacon of intellectual excellence. We heard from my honorable friend from Ealing Central and Acton that our university sector in the UK includes four of the world's top ten universities, of which we can be very proud. It contributes over 265 billion into the UK and supports over 750,000 jobs. And in my work as schools minister, I get to see directly the contribution that universities make to places and how integrated they are into local innovation, support, and access.

And I have spent quite a bit of time in Sheffield and seen the contribution that both Sheffield University and Sheffield Hallam make to the local area, whether that is their pioneering work around opening up participation to university or some of the wider research they're doing, the Sheffield Innovation Spine, the work Sheffield Hallam is doing around early years and the Children's University, and the work that Sheffield University is doing around adult social care.

And I also, as the my honorable friend from Sunderland Central was talking, I was reflecting on two weeks ago being in Sunderland where we're working on a Northeast mission and the the role that Sunderland University was playing as an absolute partner to to supporting wider outcomes for for children in the area. It's why the government are committed to maintaining a world-class higher education sector that delivers for students, our society and the and the economy. And um we of we of course recognize the sector's financial environment is challenging. We the sector is rightly independent from government with providers managing their finances and ensuring their business models provide long-term sustainability. But I recognize the the long-term challenges that that many members have have talked about, the strain that we saw over the last decade, um including the legacy of seven years of frozen tuition fees and universities having to to deal with that, um and and the issues that that that has caused.

01:20:42 - 01:20:44

Speaker 50

And we re- Of course.

01:20:44 - 01:21:15

Rupa Huq

Doctor of the House. Yeah, no, I know she's really passionate about these subjects and she's done excellent work, her department with DWP on the NEETs phenomenon. I just wondered if she might be able to have a word with Treasury colleagues. A statistic my honorable friend from Sheffield raised was that the UK's bottom of OECD countries for proportion of public spend within the overall university tertiary spend expenditure. I just wonder if she could have a word with them to nudge that upwards because that's a statistic we're not so proud of.

01:21:15 - 01:23:55

Georgia Gould

Minister Gould. Of course, I'm always supportive of greater funding for education and young people. But I was actually just going to go on to to talk about some of the the changes the government are making to to support sustainability. So, this is why after being frozen for eight years, increased tuition fee caps in line with inflation for 2025-2026. We'll increase them once again in line with forecast inflation in 2026 to 2027 and to and in 2027 to 2028 and then legislate when parliamentary time allows to increase tuition fees fee caps automatically for future academic years.

This is over the coming year six billion worth of safeguarded indexed increase in income underpinned by the government, which will make a real difference. My honorable friend from Sheffield Central asked about the vision the government has for universities and we have set out an ambitious program of reform through the post-16 education and skills white paper with a clear vision for a more sustainable and collaborative higher education sector. We want providers to be clear about their distinctive roles but to be working working in collaboration in place. And she also mentioned the importance of research and my honorable friend talked about the the pioneering research of East Anglia around prostate cancer and research is an critical role that universities play. The government are investing a record 86 billion in R&D from 2026-27 to 2029-30 and as part of this, UKRI will deliver an expected 38.6 billion of research investment rising to nearly 10 billion per year by the end of that period.

In the Department for Education, we're working closely with DSIT to deliver the white paper's commitments which include research funding reform and improvements to research cost grant cost recovery. And we also heard, I think, from from almost all of the people that spoke about the importance of opening up access around outcomes for young people and ensuring that that young people who want to go to university and pursue a university route always have that access open to them.

And I have to say that that is why we do not support the Conservatives' proposals that would pull up the drawbridge because if it's about reducing young people going to university, we know it is young people who come from disadvantaged backgrounds who will be the ones that don't get that opportunity.

01:23:55 - 01:24:11

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

I thank the Minister for giving way. I think it's important to note that those people who went to university in the 1980s are only about 10% of people who went to university. So what the Blair government did is really open that up to 50% of the population. I do think that's worth putting on record.

01:24:11 - 01:24:26

Georgia Gould

Thank you. And we want two-thirds of young people to participate in higher-level learning, whether that's going to university, pursuing an apprenticeship or a technical route, and we see all of those as deeply connected.

01:24:26 - 01:24:45

Jim Shannon

Thank you very much for a very, very helpful response. And I think that outlines a very clear strategy to try and address the issues that I've approached the Minister for. I ask a specific question of the Minister: would she consider outlining the strategy with the relevant Minister back home? Thank you.

01:24:45 - 01:30:06

Georgia Gould

Thank you very much. And of course, we, I regularly talk to colleagues across the four nations and I know my right honourable friend, the Minister for Universities, does the same. And I think it's very important we have that, that spirit of learning. But yeah, so I think it's, the, those, those different routes are deeply connected. And we think it's really important that that relationship between higher education and FE on, on supporting outcomes for young people, but also as we think about how we respond to a kind of changing nature of education, the introduction of the lifelong learning entitlement and long-term flexible learning because we want people to have access throughout their lives.

I've got to make progress. The lifelong learning entitlement will transform the student finance system, giving people flexible access to high-quality education throughout their working lives. And from January 2027, for the first time, learners will be able to use their entitlement to fund individual modules as well as full courses at levels 4 to 6 at colleges, university and independent providers. A number of members, including my honourable friend from Sheffield Central and Edinburgh South West, raised the issue of international students and support for international students. And I just want to be really clear that international students are welcome in the UK, they enrich our campuses and communities and become ambassadors for this country long after they graduate.

They make a vital contribution: 12.7 billion in fee income in 2023 to 24, almost a quarter of sector income as, as others have said. And the new international education strategy confirms our commitment to welcoming students who meet the requirements to study here. And there was also a range of questions about the international student levy. The levy is part of a wider package that also includes inflation-linked fee rises and, really important to stress, every penny it raises will be reinvested in higher education and skills, including new maintenance grants for disadvantaged students that, that many have, have raised, as well as some of the barriers we see around costs of, of studying. So we know how important those are.

It's simple and proportionate: a flat 925 pound fee per international student per year from 2028 to 29, paid for by providers with an allowance of 220 students each. And we listened to the sector: the flat fee is equivalent to around 4% of international fee income, down from the 6% first provided. And to answer the, the question that I've been asked by honourable friend from Southampton and others, we will publish an updated impact assessment ahead of a finance bill. I, I had a number of questions about the pressure many, many students are facing, including from my honourable friends across Cornwall, Camborne and Redruth and Truro and Falmouth.

And we know that cost of living pressures have hit students hard. The previous government removed maintenance grants and the real-term value of loan support for students fell by almost 20% between 2020 and 2024. And we're taking action to put this right. We're introducing a targeted maintenance grant from 2028 to 29 up to £1,000 a year for disadvantaged students on top of their loan, putting cash in their pockets without adding to their debt. The new grants will support students from low-income households studying full-time courses aligned with government's missions and industrial strategy.

And we're future-proofing maintenance loans by increasing them in line with forecast inflation every year, with the biggest cash increase going to students from the lowest income families. I'll move on to the final point because of time. My honorable friend from Southampton raised the issues of student loans and I wanted to address that in the in the time that I had remaining. The chance to study in higher education for those who want to and who have the ability changes lives as we've heard across the chamber today. We're determined to support students who want to go to university to fulfill their aspirations and we can't lose sight of the value that student loans provide in enabling that and leveling the playing field at the point of access.

They remove that upfront financial barrier to study and enable students to repay when they're earning. We inherited a student loan system that's not working as fairly as it should and we recognize that some students and graduates feel the impact of that. We're making the tough but necessary decisions to deliver a fairer and more sustainable system. We've increased the plan 2 threshold in 2025, its first increase since 2021, and we raise the plan 2 repayment threshold again in April to £29,385. And we've capped interest rates for plan 2 and plan 3 loans at 6% for the academic year 2026-27.

The whole range of very important discussions that came up today, I know that myself and...

01:30:06 - 01:30:34

Speaker 1

Order, order. Order, order. I will call Jon Trickett to move the motion and I will then call the minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission from the member in charge of the debate and the minister. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up as is the convention for 30-minute debate.

Order, order, Jon Trickett to move.

01:30:34 - 01:33:09

Jon Trickett

Thank you very much, it's a great pleasure to see you in the chair. I'm sure you'll be very firm with us but very fair as well. And it's a special privilege to see the minister in her place. I know that her Barnsley, which is she's very proud to represent, does have a strong rugby league tradition too. So let me just say why I think this department is is so important and it's a great privilege to be able to speak on this sport.

As we know, there are two codes in rugby. Rugby union is very familiar and presents great sporting spectacle. Rugby league too offers great moments of sporting prowess. And I remember vividly attending the probably the most iconic rugby league final ever in 1968 with my dad and granddad at Wembley when it felt the whole of the north of England came down to invade London, quite rightly bringing our civilization to the south. It was one of those great days when the rain never stopped, it hadn't stopped for several days.

The pitch was a mud bath, it was literally covered in mud and water and very exciting. In the last two minutes it was 11-10 to Leeds, of course in those days I was supporting Leeds as somebody who was born there, against Wakefield, which I am a proud MP and have been for 30 years. The score was 11-10 and in the last minute a penalty was given to Wakefield right under the post. You would expect that to be converted by a great Rugby League player, Don Fox, coming from a great Rugby League family born in my constituency. But the weather was atrocious, everybody turned their back because they couldn't bear to watch, Wakefield supporters hoping to hear the victory and Leeds supporters fearing what might happen.

It was an amazing moment and I'll never forget it, but he missed the penalty, but that doesn't pay any disrespect to the Fox family who were brilliant, but of course it meant that Leeds were victors and it's something which is fondly remembered. I am sure I'm the only Member of Parliament who was there at that great sporting event. So Rugby League does offer great spectacle, but it has been the subject of really being treated in a second, in a way which hasn't really been fully appropriate. And I fear for the future unless we can correct things. Let me just briefly remind the House.

01:33:09 - 01:33:11

Speaker 56

Honourable friend give way?

01:33:11 - 01:33:13

Speaker 54

I will give way to my honourable friend.

01:33:13 - 01:34:04

Ian Lavery

Thanks very much for giving way and congratulations for bringing this really important debate to Westminster Hall. My constituency, Blyth and Ashington, is well renowned for some of the world-class sportsmen. It's commonly said as far as that you shout down the pit shaft and a world-class sportsman will emerge. But I wonder if my honourable friend with his great knowledge and wisdom of Rugby League, and Rugby League being a traditionally working-class sport, I wonder if my honourable friend can say why, despite many opportunities, Rugby League hasn't flourished in areas like mine in working-class Northumberland.

01:34:04 - 01:34:50

Jon Trickett

I thank my honourable friend for his important intervention. He's right that Rugby League is a sport which grew up in working-class communities, especially in mining communities, and it is surprising that in his constituency it hasn't taken root. But when you consider the discrimination which Rugby League has suffered from over the years, it maybe isn't so surprising. And one of the things I'm going to try to argue is we need to do more to develop the sport across the whole country, but especially in communities like his. He's right too that whenever there was a player injured in Featherstone in my patch, they would go to the pithead and shout down, "Send us up another forward" or whatever, and one would emerge quickly, get changed and get onto the pitch.

01:34:50 - 01:34:58

Speaker 57

It was very, very part of the mining tradition. But let me just remind the House that... I will give way, I want to make some progress though.

01:34:58 - 01:35:37

Jim Shannon

I'm glad, first of all, thank the honourable gentleman for bringing this forward. Rugby Union was my game, I apologize to the honourable gentleman, but Rugby League has a very magnificent transformative impact across the United Kingdom. The beating heart of the towns, providing the vital structure, the mental health support and community pride for young people, yet they're all facing a financial squeeze. So does the honourable gentleman agree that government funding for Rugby League must extend to all of this to secure the sport's future and to enhance funding strategy to protect these invaluable community assets from the financial ruin that they face?

01:35:37 - 01:44:48

Jon Trickett

The honourable member makes a very important point and I agree with the point he's making, but I was just going to develop a little bit about Rugby League itself.

In the areas which I'm most familiar, rugby league can be the most important agency for social cohesion. It gives something and sport in general, but in rugby league I'm talking about today, sport can provide something which brings everybody together whatever different points of view or life experiences that they may have. In Featherstone in my constituency, where Featherstone Rovers has played for for decades, there is a massive amount of pride in the fact that we do have that team. I'm going to come to the difficulties which it's facing at the present time and hope we can find a way forward. But let me just remind the House that the BBC used to cover almost weekly on what was called Grandstand rugby league and there was a very famous commentator, Eddie Waring, most people in this room are probably not old enough to remember him, but I do well.

So familiar was rugby league in those times because of BBC coverage that many of Eddie Waring's favorite expressions were well known across the whole country and Mike Yarwood, who was a great mimic at that time, used to talk with Eddie's accent, which I can't do, but he used to talk about up and over, which was one of the ways you could kick a ball. But more importantly, when as often happened somebody was sent off, his favorite expression was, "Well, he's been sent for an early bath." And I'm very much hoping that I won't be sent for an early bath today by you, Ms. Frit, in the chair today. But look, the thing is, it was a national it is ought to be a national sport, nationally recognized. I'll come to the discrimination in a second or two and the problems which we've got with television.

But let me just remind the House that if you want to watch TV on TV now rugby league, you would have to go to two separate pay-per-view channels. It would cost sixty-one pounds a month, which is five percent of the total income of a person who's living on the minimum wage. It is being people being priced out of the spectacle and that is a great shame because it's leading to the atrophy of the sport across the communities where rugby league ought to be played and it's stopping us from spreading it further. And I'm going to come back to that in a second or two. Rugby league was a product of the class system which operated in sport in those days where the so-called gentlemen who didn't need to be paid would play rugby union.

If you were too poor to be able to afford to do that, you couldn't play for rugby union, so rugby league was set up whereby players could be paid. And that was obviously the start of this rugby league as a code. But the truth is, the divisions which existed then continue today and I'm just going to maybe surprise the House with one or two statistics which I've identified. First of all, if you look at the way the honors system has worked, there have been eight separate rugby union players who've received a knighthood, only two in rugby league, one of whom was actually knighted for his contributions to charitable giving, the great Kevin Sinfield. But the truth is, it shows a level of discrimination.

When you look at the the national squads for rugby union, two-thirds or more of all players for rugby union for the national side went to public school. I can't find a single player who's played for the national side for rugby league who went to public school and it shows the class divisions which continue surprisingly after all these years in sport. And it's disappointing that in the universities, less than forty universities have a rugby league side, whereas every single university that I can find does have a rugby union side.

And I think that again shows that there is something not quite working between the two codes. Now, I think I've referred already to the, well let me just make one other point. When it came to COVID, as we know, sports were remunerated. But here's an astonishing fact. Rugby union received about 130 million pounds.

Rugby league got 10 or 11 million pounds. That's 10 times more went into rugby union from COVID. And you do wonder, and I'm sure the House would agree with me, whether the people who make these decisions in the civil service went to universities and schools which did do rugby union but had little comprehension of the importance of rugby league in areas such as mine. I think that does demonstrate clear discrimination. And I'm hoping that the Labour government is aware of that.

If it wasn't, then it is now because I've brought it to the attention of the minister. Now, I want to then just to move on to the situation facing Featherstone Rovers. Wakefield, which I now represent, has the honour of having three separate professional rugby league sides: Wakefield, Castleford, and Featherstone. And Featherstone, unfortunately due to bad management, has gone into administration. And we've been really struggling to try to find a way to bring Rovers back to life.

It is the core of the people of Featherstone's identity, as was mining. But mining was stripped away many, many decades ago, but still you will see everywhere references to mining in the township of Featherstone. But rugby league, Featherstone Rovers, is a matter of great pride. The fact it went bankrupt and there's nobody playing on the pitch at the moment is heartbreaking for so many people that I represent. Now, gradually we've been putting together a plan to try to bring Featherstone Rovers back to life.

It has been difficult. I've spent many, many hours trying to achieve that. But thanks to the appointment recently of a new chief executive at the rugby league, at the RFL, I think we are now making progress such that the RFL has said that they themselves are prepared to help to acquire the assets, bearing in mind there's a stadium, the buildings around the stadium, and several acres of land at the back of the stadium. The administrator has been difficult, but he's come to the view in the end that because it's a community asset, he's prepared to sell it out, the asset, for slightly less than he might have thought it was worth on a completely commercial sense. So we think it can be acquired for about a million pounds.

Now, when Labour was in charge of the council, and it has changed hands recently, Labour put aside several million pounds for each of the three rugby league clubs. There's 700,000 pounds still unallocated to Featherstone. And the council under its new management have now said that a substantial part of that, possibly half a million, will be made available to the rugby league to for them to be able to acquire the assets. Now, here comes the interesting part because in Featherstone, thanks again to the Labour government, we have something called the Pride in Place. We've been allocated 20 million pounds over the coming 10 years.

And so the board of Pride in Place, which I'm a member of by virtue of being the local MP, so I don't know if I need to declare an interest, but I do in any event, have said that they are prepared to make a substantial contribution to the acquisition of the of the stadium and the surrounding land.

It has been difficult to put this together, but the board are unanimous and led by the chair, Kay Binnersley, we are now in a position to say that when the money arrives from the government in the next financial year, that money then can be made available to the RFL. So I have met with the chief executive of the RFL, the new chief executive, a very dynamic and progressive individual, and we have agreed that we want to create a partnership between the PIP board, Pride in Place board, and the RFL to try to take this whole thing forward. It's desperately important because without Featherstone Rovers playing, it's not very easy to create a fixture list because there will be one less team than is required to set up the fixtures. So there's an urgency about this. I have to say it's been frustrating dealing with the RFL over the last year and a half on this matter as they went from one temporary chief executive to another, but now we do have a decision maker in place and I'm very confident that he is determined to make this happen and clearly he needs it for all the other teams in the rugby league.

01:44:48 - 01:44:53

Speaker 59

Now, on the point... I will give way, yeah.

01:44:53 - 01:45:21

James Mark Sewards

I thank him for giving way, he's been generous with his time. On the Pride in Place point, I couldn't agree with him more and I commend him for his efforts with the Pride in Place board. I've done something similar in my constituency, Leeds South West and Morley. Our Pride in Place Farnley East board is giving money to Farnley Falcons. It's one of the hearts of our communities, it brings in young people from right across the constituency and further afield.

Would he join me in encouraging all those with Pride in Place boards to give some money to local rugby league clubs?

01:45:21 - 01:50:46

Jon Trickett

I thank him very much for his intervention. By the way, many, many years ago as a building worker and plumber, I did lots of work on Morley Labour Rooms, which is probably familiar with to this day, but that's completely by the by. And of course he's right that Pride in Place is there to give pride to communities or to reinforce a pride which exists on a new basis, which is bottom-up, local people deciding what they need for their communities. And rugby league is part of that, but it needs to come from the community, not from above. And on the subject of Pride in Place in Featherstone, and I think this applies to others as well, let me just say this: the council, the local council needs to be aware that its rules, its codes don't apply to Pride in Place, although they are currently managing the finances, because the board itself has to decide its priorities.

We have a vision for a town, a sporting excellence, which will bring together all of the different services, whether it's education, because there's much to do in Featherstone in terms of education, or whether it's health services, because there are many people with long-term health problems and mental health. We have a vision for a town built around sporting provision, but which reaches out to all of the various cultural and health and educational needs which Featherstone people have. All of those people may have different views and experiences in life, but the one thing they have had is Featherstone Rovers, and it's important that that's brought back together again. So our vision is for a renewal of the town, building on its existing pride, and hopefully it'll be a place where people feel extremely proud to live, that they can go and join in the activities there, social and cultural activities as well. But it requires Featherstone Rovers to be brought back in place.

So I think we understand that the RFL can't own the assets forever because the other clubs will begin to resent it, but the other clubs need to understand that without Featherstone Rovers playing, they will not have a functioning league.

So, I think it is important that the RFL do the things which the chief executive said that he wants to do. And the resilience fund, which the Labour administration put into place for the council, we've had different figures from the current leadership of the council. I believe there's £700,000 still left in the kitty, and £500,000 will go to the RFL, but the other £200,000 will be needed for some renovations to the existing stadium. So, when I've just explained all of that from the background, I think it's been very helpful to me to be able to both speak about rugby league in general, the discrimination which it suffers, and also to speak about the situation in Featherstone. So let me just press the minister, who I've already said I'm delighted to see in her place, on three matters.

The first is, would it be possible for her to have a careful look, or the department, at the Rugby Football League's bid for funding to help? We need to develop the, as we've heard just this morning, we need to develop the sport and take it into new areas where I think there are many people hungry for that kind of sporting experience. And all I would ask for the moment is she looks carefully at it. The second thing is, could she take a close interest to ensure that the partnership which I've described between the PIP and the Rugby Football League does proceed at speed, because we've got an empty stadium with people all around it saying, what's happened to our team? And then my final point to her is this.

The problem that rugby league has is that the feedstock has been cut off, that is the ordinary kids watching sport on TV, living in poorer families, and a lot of the rugby league clubs come from quite deprived communities, such as Featherstone. They're not able to pay for pay-per-view TV, and therefore they don't see their heroes, they don't see the sport, they don't see its code, how it's played and so on. And that, I think, leaves us with a problem. Now, the department does have the power to list sporting events, and it's tragic that the World Cup Rugby League, which is played at the moment, isn't seen on terrestrial television. It's disappointing and tragic that that should have happened.

Of course, the BBC now is saying, well, we've got a deal where we can play it on the radio, but listening to it on the radio is not the same as watching your heroes actually on the pitch playing, as I did when I was 17 back at the match which I just described earlier. Could the minister have a careful look about whether or not we can get some of these matches listed so that it's available for communities everywhere to see the great sport which is rugby league? With that, I am looking forward to hopefully a positive response from the minister, and thank you very much.

01:50:46 - 01:50:54

Speaker 1

The question is that this House has considered government support for rugby league clubs. I call the minister, Stephanie Peacock.

01:50:54 - 01:52:52

Stephanie Peacock

Thank you, and it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Ms Vaz. I'd like to congratulate my honourable friend, the member for Normanton and Hemsworth, on securing this debate, a near constituency neighbour of mine. As a fellow Yorkshire MP, I know how important rugby league is to his area. I know how much of a champion he is for this sport, both in this place as he's illustrated this morning and beyond. For over 130 years, rugby league has made a huge contribution to our society.

They are places where thousands of people play sport and get active every week. Now, my honourable friend spoke passionately about the particular impact of that on post-industrial towns like the ones that we represent. And he's right to say I am very proud to represent Barnsley South in Parliament. And we have fantastic grassroots teams in Barnsley, like the Dearne Valley Bulldogs and the Dodworth Miners. The Dodworth Miners under-12s became the first junior rugby league team ever from Barnsley to win a league and cup double this week, and I'm sure the whole House will join me in congratulating them.

Week in, week out, local people come together to support their clubs, their children's teams, and the players.

Now, we see teams like this all across the North of England, and the vital role they play is reflected in the interest in today's debate. We know that community sport, and especially sports such as rugby league, can play a major role in building confidence and teamwork, supporting life skills for future generations and improving community cohesion. The social value generated by community sport and physical activity is vast, in excess of 122 billion pounds a year. And every pound spent on sport by rugby league community clubs generates a social return of over 4 pounds. These figures underscore the vital role that sports such as rugby league can play in driving positive public health and societal outcomes.

And that is why this government believes access to sport should never be determined by your postcode, your background or your gender.

01:52:52 - 01:52:53

I would give way, yes.

01:52:53 - 01:53:15

Jon Trickett

On the question of gender, she's right to raise that. It's fair to say that rugby league in the past, in the dim distant past, was kind of a male sport. But now there are women's teams all over the country, including universities. But the proud thing is Featherstone Rovers does have one of the most successful women's rugby league teams in the country, and we're very proud of that. So thank you for the opportunity for allowing me to raise it.

01:53:15 - 01:58:36

Stephanie Peacock

Well, the honourable gentleman is absolutely right. He makes a really important point, and that's why as sports minister I've set up the women's sports task force, and I'll touch very briefly on women in later on in my contribution. Now, the single biggest thing most likely to get a child active in sport is watching it live. If kids cannot watch their heroes, they are far less likely to pick up a rugby ball. Now, the honourable gentleman is a huge champion of his local club, the Featherstone Rovers.

Featherstone Rovers has been at the heart of the local community for many years, and the uncertainty since it entered administration has, I know, hit the town hard. And I commend the collective efforts of the honourable member, the community and the RFL to revive the club. And indeed, I met with the honourable gentleman to discuss this earlier this year. And as he has spoken about, I understand that Wakefield Council have set out proposals to provide a half a million pounds worth of emergency funding, matched funded by the RFL Resilience Fund in a bid to get the team back on their feet by 2027. Under separate proposals, the likely scenario is that the RFL will take control of the ground and lease to an ownership group.

Now, on the topic of pride in place funding, power is being put in local hands through resident-led Featherstone Neighbourhood Board working with the local council and of course him as the constituency MP. While spending choices rest locally with that board, I am fully supportive of local communities choosing to use that funding to protect and revitalize vital sporting institutions like Featherstone Rovers, and I will raise this with the relevant MHCLG minister. Now, I've seen first-hand the importance and impact of rugby league, having taken part at the Yorkshire versus Lancashire match at Labour Party conference at Everton Stadium. And indeed, I was joined by the member for Leeds South West who's in attendance today, and I am very pleased to report a Yorkshire win. But it was a great opportunity to showcase the sport, to learn more about their work with the Community Integrated Care, a registered charity supporting people with learning disabilities, autism, mental health needs and dementia.

Now Sport England has committed 15.7 million to the Rugby League up to 2029. In my honourable friend's own constituency, that support is already delivering on the ground, funding new facilities at Hemsworth Dragons and pitch maintenance at Ryecroft Hammers. Nationally, we are directing 400 million pounds into upgrading grassroots sports facilities, deliberately prioritising the areas with the highest levels of deprivation and inactivity. Now, my honourable friend highlighted today the RFL's bid for funding sports facilities and the community programme. I of course can't make spending commitments today, but I'd be very happy to discuss this further with the honourable gentleman and indeed with the RFL.

And it was a great opportunity to talk to the RFL, and I look forward to meeting them again soon.

Now, my honourable friend has made an important point on broadcasting, and I have heard his concerns. Of course, the Challenge Cup final remains protected on free-to-air television under the listed events regime, but I do acknowledge the concerns raised before the World Cup, and the Secretary of State expressed her views that she was disappointed. Of course, there was a last-minute agreement that the BBC would carry highlights, but I appreciate the concerns that this has not gone anywhere near far enough. We must of course help sports rights holders strike the right balance between broadcast revenue and keeping clubs solvent and ensuring matches remain accessible to the public. Now, on the subject of watching England play, this time last year I was pleased to be cheering on England at Wembley as they played in the Ashes, and of course the team are now down under competing in the World Cup.

I wish them all the very best as they prepare for their final pool game in two days' time. But Rugby League's value goes well beyond the 80 minutes on the pitch. Through our 330,000 investment in Rugby League Cares, current and former players are in our schools and in our towns, having open, honest conversations with young men about mental health, isolation and loneliness. And that's why my honourable friend was right to mention the social impact of the sport, and in the summer I visited Castleford Tigers to see Rugby League Cares in action. I was delighted to go to the home of the Castleford Tigers to meet Rugby League Cares and Men's Sheds over the summer, seeing first-hand the powerful role of sport, including Rugby League, plays in tackling social isolation and loneliness.

Now, I have heard his points he's made about honours and these concerns that he has put on the record, and I know the Secretary of State is on the record too sharing those. We have all witnessed the extraordinary bond between the late great Rob Burrow and Sir Kevin Sinfield, a reminder of the loyalty, courage and compassion that define the Rugby League family. And we are seeing the same spirit drive the growth of the women's game through initiatives like Rugbees and inspiring expansion of Wheelchair Super League. Now, the Secretary of State recently attended and supported Sinfield during a leg of his endurance run, Part 7 in 7 Challenge, running seven ultramarathons in seven days at Leigh Sports Village in October 2026, just a few weeks ago. Sinfield's runs raise awareness and funds for motor neurone disease in honour of his former teammate and close friend, the late Rob Burrow.

01:58:36 - 01:58:55

Speaker 1

So I thank my honourable friend once again for securing this debate and for standing up so effectively for his community and his sport. I look forward to working with him closely with the RFL in our coming meeting to ensure Rugby League gets fair treatment, support and the long-term investment it so richly deserves.

01:58:55 - 01:59:06

Thank you. The question is that this House has considered Government support for Rugby League clubs. As many as are of that opinion say aye. On the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

01:59:06 - 01:59:08

Order, order. Sitting suspended until 2:30.