House of Lords

9 September 2026

House of Lords

Follow its sittings
00:45 - 00:49
Speaker 3
I think if you just go, sorry, if you talk loud enough, you might just be heard. 
00:49 - 02:02
Speaker 7
I, Lorraine, Baroness Fullbrook, do swear by Almighty God that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs and successors, according to law.  So help me God. 
02:02 - 02:05
Speaker 2
First oral question, the Lord Archbishop of York. 
02:05 - 02:09
Speaker 1
I beg leave to ask the question in my name standing on the order paper. 
02:09 - 02:37
Speaker 5
My Lords, the government laid a written ministerial statement on the 1st of September confirming that detailed proposals for formal regulation of the funeral sector are being developed.  The Department of Health and Social Care is leading this work with the Ministry of Justice and other departments working closely with bereaved families, funeral providers, faith groups, local authorities and others. 
02:37 - 03:20
Speaker 4
In thanking the Minister for her response, could I pay tribute to those affected by the terrible failures in Hull where I serve, and to the clergy and local community services who've supported the bereaved?  And I welcome proposals for regulation.  What happened in Hull must really never happen again.  Could I therefore ask the Minister when the department will set out further details on the timeline for these proposals and their implementation, and also mindful that many of those who suffered in Hull were those least able to afford a funeral for their loved one, could I ask the Minister whether questions of cost and its links to bereavement will also be considered? 
03:20 - 04:16
Speaker 6
Well, I also want to express my sorrow and support for those who are so deeply affected.  Those who have died cannot speak, so it leaves it to the rest of us to speak for them.  And in this case, a terrible tragedy, as I think, were put in the path of proper grieving and understanding about loss.  So I very much want to associate myself with that and to say that all of the matters that the Right Reverend Prelate referred to will be considered.  We have already accepted the majority of the inquiry's 75 recommendations on the Fuller inquiry, but obviously in the written ministerial statement it says how much further we're going to go. 

And when I'm able to update on timelines, I'll be glad to do so. 
04:16 - 04:47
Speaker 41
I too would want to register our condolences to the people in Hull who are affected so badly.  Scotland, as of 2025, has a fully searchable database of registered funeral directors.  One can work out who the owners are, you can read reports and also have details of any complaints which have been made.  How long is it going to take us to get to where Scotland already is? 
04:47 - 05:41
Speaker 6
Well, we will certainly look forward to working with other jurisdictions about how their best practice works, and that will of course include Scotland.  I am very keen that we work, continue to work closely, for example, with the funeral provider cohort, who most of them, and let us acknowledge this, do a first-rate job with immense dignity and professionalism, and they've been let down also.  And safeguards do have to be effective without imposing disproportionate burdens, but whilst it's a bit premature for me to prescribe how the regulatory framework will work, I can assure the noble lady we are looking very closely at what she raises. 

05:41 - 06:28

Speaker 12

I support the government in regulation, because what has happened in Hull has been tragic for the people concerned. But also, we've noticed of course increasing television advertising for funerals without any form of ceremony or service. Of course that is up to personal preference, but it does look as though the public are increasingly putting their faith in funeral directors to have sole charge of the deceased from the time they die to the time they are cremated, without necessarily having any input from people who are around them. And of course there are those people who have no surviving relatives or friends. I do think that trust needs to be regulated.

06:28 - 06:34

Speaker 8

And that, my Lords, is exactly why we're taking the action that we are.

06:34 - 06:47

Speaker 10

My Lords, some communities prefer to have an open-air funeral pyre. What is the government's policy on that?

06:47 - 07:14

Gillian Merron

I can't give a detailed reply to my noble friend, much as I'd love to. But I will be glad to look into that to write to him. But I think the main thing to say is in all this work, our focus is on the security and dignity of people after death across a wide range of settings, and that is what will guide us.

07:14 - 07:38

Speaker 9

My Lords, it is quite shocking that in this second, third decade of the 21st century, there are currently no minimum standards of care for the deceased, no system of statutory professional regulation, and no duty of care to a person after they have died.

Is it the government's intention that those matters should be covered in the regulations they intend to bring forward?

07:38 - 07:44

Gillian Merron

I can assure my noble friend that that is indeed what will guide us.

07:44 - 08:27

Speaker 11

My Lords, I warmly welcome the Right Reverend Prelate's question and the government's response to it. And the terrible events in Hull remind us that there are occasions when terrible events do lead to worthwhile reform. In the 1820s, when it was discovered that Burke and Hare were murdering people in Edinburgh, it led this House to pass the Anatomy Act in 1832, which was a step forward in this area. Can I just ask my noble friend what range of consultations will be held, because there are many reputable funeral director chains, but there are also individuals, and it's a wide field. And can I just ask my noble friend to outline the extent of the consultation that will precede what I hope will be government action?

08:27 - 09:15

Gillian Merron

Well, my noble friend does endorse the point that I made earlier, and the House, I know, does recognize this, that the majority of funeral providers, even within the current setup, are providing a first-rate service that encourages trust as well as respect and service. But we do have to act because of these terrible circumstances to protect people. So I can say to my noble friend, we are working very closely with funeral providers in order to get it right, so they can do the work they need to do without undue burden, but with protection for those to whom they are working for.

09:15 - 10:10

Speaker 19

My Lords, I wonder if I could associate these benches with the comments that were made about the poor people who had to suffer in Hull and their families. My Lords, the Most Reverend Primate spoke about the impact on local communities and how legislation should consider costs. Now, given this, does the government intend to ensure that those smaller independent funeral directors, most of which, as the noble lady says, do an amazing job in helping families through a very difficult time of bereavement. Many of these smaller directors, they serve many of our communities with great care. How do we make sure that they are properly involved in shaping these reforms and it's not just only the bigger companies or organizations that are involved?

And what steps will be taken to guarantee that any new requirements are proportionate and do not place unsustainable providers with extra burdens, but of course while avoiding a repeat of the scandal that we saw in this case?

10:10 - 10:45

Gillian Merron

Well, this is the way that we are conducting ourselves. It would, I feel, be a bit premature to draw conclusions on any funding requirements, and of course we are talking about private businesses. But we are looking, as we always do, but particularly in this area, on cost-benefits and the impacts of different approaches before decisions are taken. And within that, we are working with the full range of funeral providers, not just the large funeral providers.

10:45 - 11:24

Ilora Finlay

A funeral is a very important part of marking the passing and respect of a person. So in the consultation, will the government ask hospice bereavement counselors, specifically those who are seeing people on the ground face-to-face, about their comments? Because often managerial people higher up in a bereavement service may not know some of the details that have actually been extremely important to families, that may have caused great offense or may have been particularly helpful, and they can get lost in the retelling as things get passed up the chain.

11:24 - 11:56

Gillian Merron

The noble lady is quite right that funerals are very personal matters, personal to the deceased, who may or may not have left their wishes, and very personal and affecting for those who are left behind.

So indeed hospices and other groups in the way the noble lady describes will also be worked with closely as they are very important stakeholders for us.

11:56 - 12:32

Speaker 21

My Lords, I'd like to pick up a point that was made from the opposition front bench a few moments ago around family funeral directors. Over the last 20 years or so we've seen many of those effectively bought up by large conglomerates. It's important any regulation that is created that it's done in a way that makes it commensurate for those small providers so it doesn't create yet a further incentive for the large sometimes multinational bodies who don't have that degree of personal understanding of a particular local community.

12:32 - 13:18

Gillian Merron

I was interested to this point that the right reverend prelate raises to look at the figures that the largest three businesses collectively account for approximately a third. But I think that the point the right reverend prelate makes emphasizes the point that was made by other noble lords of just of the importance of ensuring that regulation does enable all sizes and scales of businesses in this area to do the job we need them to do and have regard to all of the points that we have referred to here whilst letting them actually conduct the business.

13:18 - 13:24

Speaker 16

Second oral question, Lord Bailey of Paddington.

13:24 - 13:34

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, in the absence of my noble friend Lord Bailey of Paddington, I beg leave with the leave of the House I beg to ask the question standing in his name on the order paper.

13:34 - 14:09

Jane Sharon Taylor

My Lords, nationally significant infrastructure projects are well they do what they say on the tin, they are national. No devolved powers have altered the consenting of the decision-making route for NSIPs so no assessment of impacts has been made. Decisions on nationally significant infrastructure projects remain nationally accountable with the relevant Secretary of State taking decisions following of course examination and recommendation by the Planning Inspectorate. Devolution supports infrastructure delivery by giving local leaders stronger tools to align housing, transport, growth and supporting infrastructure.

14:09 - 14:32

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, water companies have warned there's only enough water supply to handle another 420,000 new homes, far less than the one and a half million planned by the government. How will the government ensure there is sufficient water infrastructure built that keeps pace with the building of new homes, homes our nation needs?

14:32 - 15:11

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well this government has instigated the building of a whole new set of reservoirs where the party opposite did nothing on that for 14 years. So we are very cognizant of the issues around water and I know the noble lord is in the very part of the country that the same part of the country that I live in where there is a water shortage. But the way to tackle this is through the delivery of the infrastructure that's going to support the housing delivery which is exactly what we're setting about to do and making sure that decisions are taken where they're taken nationally they have local input so that the national decision maker can take account of local circumstances.

15:11 - 15:43

Dafydd Wigley

My Lords, will the noble lady the minister raise with her Treasury colleagues the perverse way in which the funding of infrastructure projects in England which should generate Barnett consequential payments to Wales fail to do so?

For example, with the Oxford to Cambridge rail project being designated as being directly beneficial to Wales and so avoiding any appropriate Barnett payment. Please can this system be reviewed to avoid such ludicrous situations?

15:43 - 16:09

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I don't want to comment specifically on the issues around the Oxford-Cambridge rail link, but of course that part of the country generates wealth which benefits not only England but the devolved administrations as well, because if the wealth that's generated is shared across the United Kingdom, that would be the case. However, I will, I will respond in more detail to the question around Barnett formula.

16:09 - 16:45

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

My Lords, when the noble baroness minister responded to the noble Lord Fuller, she referred to local leaders. Could the noble baroness minister confirm that by local leaders, the reference is to city and county mayors? And if so, where do local councils and local people fit into the decision-making of what could be very disruptive and important infrastructure in their area?

16:45 - 17:23

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, devolution and infrastructure reform definitely do not remove the role of local communities. For NSIPs, communities and local authorities continue to have opportunities to engage with projects and participate in the examination process. And the government continues to expect applicants for NSIPs as well as local planning to undertake meaningful and proportionate engagement. So the reforms are about making engagement more effective, not removing it. And so the aim is to focus consultation on the issues that matter, avoid unnecessary process, and support better quality applications and decisions.

17:23 - 17:53

Speaker 10

My Lords, my Lords, West Mercia has a police commissioner, but we have no mayor. That's Shropshire, Telford and Wrekin, that's where I used to be the leader, Herefordshire and Worcestershire. And the area is known as the devolution desert. What is the government plan for that particular area? Are we going to get a mayor or are we going to carry on as we are going for the last years and years?

17:53 - 18:31

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, I'm always very keen to hear the enthusiasm of friends in Shropshire for the devolution program. And the devolution program is moving ahead at pace. Achieving good growth in this country does require that fundamental rewiring of the way the country works and making sure that power that's been held in Westminster and Whitehall is returned to the people and places where they live, work, and invest. So our ambition for this government is to ensure every area in England, including Shropshire, has or is in the process of establishing a strategic authority by the end of 2027, with strategic authorities in place everywhere by the end of 2028.

18:31 - 19:14

Anne McIntosh

My Lords, the minister will be aware that Anglian Water have raised objections to a planning application specifically in an area of water stress. As matters currently stand, water companies do not, are not statutory consultees, and they are deemed to have to make the connection even if the connection is unsafe. Would the noble lady look favorably on water companies becoming statutory consultees to prevent this situation happening where there could be a sewage spill in these particular circumstances which could be avoided were they statutory consultees?

19:14 - 19:34

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, we've tried to avoid increasing the list of statutory consultees because it does affect the process. However, any authority can contribute to the planning process. I know the noble lady is aware of that. And so we would expect local water authorities where they consider there's going to be a problem, they can contribute both to an NSIP application or to a local planning authority application.

19:34 - 19:47

Speaker 26

My Lords, there is hard evidence that infrastructure development... I didn't get out quick enough then, I did get out quick enough this time. My Lords.

19:47 - 19:52

Speaker 27

There's plenty of time for both noble Lords. We've just had a Conservative member, we'll have a Labour and then we'll have the front bench.

19:52 - 20:24

Philip Hunt

Thank you, my Lords. My Lords, as I was saying, we've already... we know that infrastructure development in this country is more expensive than many other developed countries and it takes longer, mainly due to our planning system and the way regulators in this country are risk-averse and often work in silos. Could my noble friend explain what the government is doing further to the Planning and Infrastructure Act to actually improve this?

20:24 - 21:04

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, we put the Planning and Infrastructure Bill through, we now have a Planning and Infrastructure Act which does remove some of the... the obstacles that were causing delays in the planning system. But also we've just recently republished the National Planning Policy Framework. It's now a much more straightforward rules-based system of planning, which we hope will both make the planning system run more smoothly as well as making sure that we have removed some of the jeopardy around JRs and so on in the planning system. That alongside investment in planning officers and the planning system, I think will make a real difference.

21:04 - 21:33

Speaker 40

My Lords, in January, the government announced plans to allow data centers to opt into the nationally significant infrastructure project scheme. What is the government doing to promote innovation in this area to increase their reliance on grey water rather than drinking water and the use of closed-loop cooling systems?

21:33 - 22:04

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, of course data centers are a useful example of why the planning system needs flexibility. Some will go through the local planning routes and some data centers will be NSIPs because of their scale, power requirements, economic role or resilience applications. So I do think the noble lady makes a very valid point around how we use grey water and so on and also how we can use the heat output from data centers for use in residential or commercial applications as well.

22:04 - 22:43

Speaker 38

My Lords, I worked at Number 10 twenty years ago when the decision was made in principle to build a national high-speed rail network in the UK. As we know, that network now just goes from Birmingham to Euston, is not yet open, is 140 miles long. At exactly the same time that decision was made, the Chinese started building their high-speed rail network. Twenty years later, it's 31,000 miles long. What conclusion does the Minister draw from that?

22:43 - 23:26

Jane Sharon Taylor

I'm not going to make any... any points about the... the nature of... of governments that can move without fear of having to be re-elected. But we do... we do have to get better at this and that's why all... all this work has been done since our government came into power to make sure that we improve both the infrastructure planning but also the process for delivering infrastructure. We not only need to have the planning system working more smoothly, but we need far better ways of making sure the project management of these schemes is working effectively and smoothly. But the first step is to get these things through planning without having years and years of hold-ups in the courts and elsewhere.

23:26 - 23:52

Speaker 34

Further to the question asked by the noble baroness, Baroness McIntosh, can I ask the minister, are we any closer in this country to setting up a national water grid? Because obviously every single reservoir that's in the planning process is going to be a national infrastructure project, and all of them give rise to a huge amount of opposition understandably. But can we look again at the idea of a national grid?

23:52 - 24:24

Jane Sharon Taylor

Well, my colleagues in Defra I know are working extremely hard on the whole issue of water provision, water, how we save the water when we've got floods and lots of rain, and how we make sure that we've got the means to do that, and how we distribute that water better around the country. So I know that the water task force will be looking at this and making sure that we do work together across the planning system and the water delivery system to make this work better in the future.

24:24 - 24:27

Speaker 22

Further question, Baroness Davies of Devonport.

24:27 - 24:33

Speaker 24

My lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.

24:33 - 25:14

Gillian Merron

My lords, in the 10-year health plan, we committed to eliminate agency spending by the end of this parliament. We are making significant progress. Medical agency spending fell by a third from 963.5 million in 24-25 to 642.6 million in 25-26. Overall NHS agency spending fell from 2.1 billion to 1.2 billion over the same period, a reduction of 43% and the lowest level on record.

25:14 - 25:53

Speaker 24

I thank the noble baroness the minister. It's important to ask what efforts the government are making to increase permanent staff against bank or agency work. A friend of mine is a senior mental health nurse, and she tells me agency staff cannot intervene in a severe mental health situation or give immediate medication in A&E. Can I ask specifically what mental health nursing permanent staffing is going to be happening and how the government can try to increase this, bearing in mind that we have an epidemic in mental health in young people?

25:53 - 26:27

Gillian Merron

Well, there will be, in the not-too-distant future, the mental health strategy, which will pull together all of the strands that the noble lady and her colleague are concerned with, and she's right to be concerned about them. I would say in all these areas, patient safety comes first, and that is the driver as to why we are reducing the use of agency. And I do agree that the end game in all this is to increase the numbers of permanent staff, and the forthcoming workforce plan will support us in that.

26:27 - 26:44

Narendra Patel

Noble lady the minister, can the noble lady the noble baroness the minister say which spring, which year of which spring will the workforce plan be published?

26:44 - 27:19

Gillian Merron

On the basis we've moved beyond spring of this year, what I can say about the workforce plan is to ensure it's reflecting the priorities of the new government that we have. We're working, the Secretary of State and also my colleague minister Karin Smyth MP, who's the responsible minister, are working to ensure that the workforce plan properly reflects the priorities. And I hope we won't be keeping your lordship's house or the noble lord waiting for too long.

27:19 - 27:22

Speaker 14

My lords, we're here from the Liberal Democrats.

27:22 - 27:44

Caroline Pidgeon

My Lords, CQC inspections repeatedly warn that caring for unmonitored patients in hospital corridors carries severe safety risks. What assessment has the government made of the use of agency staff in corridor areas and the clinical risks of deploying such staff in non-designated care areas?

27:44 - 28:34

Gillian Merron

Well, I'm not sure about something that specific because what agency staff are used for, and bear in mind our whole, as I've said, our whole emphasis is actually to end spending on agency staff, but patient safety has to come first. And that is why we still have some use of agency staff and an increased, where we need temporary staff, using the NHS staff bank, where actually we can call on a pool of healthcare workers who are more established to directly fill temporary shifts. So I wouldn't say there's an allocation to what is described as corridor care because corridor care we are also driving down.

28:34 - 28:43

Speaker 18

My Lords, does the minister agree, it's this side, does the minister agree, it's this side, this side.

28:43 - 28:49

Speaker 23

My Lords, there has not yet been a Labour question in this question. There'll be Labour then the Conservative benches, please.

28:49 - 29:11

Speaker 33

My Lords, does the minister agree with me that health trusts could do a lot more to offer flexible hours for nurses and other medical staff than they do at the moment? I've known of many cases where nurses, for example, have tried to get flexible hours and have been refused and then end up coming back as agency staff.

29:11 - 29:53

Gillian Merron

Well, I think the key thing here that my noble friend is raising is very much about staff retention within the NHS, and certainly that is the ideal, and not just an ideal but the practical best way forward. So we are taking action, including as my noble friend talks about flexible working, but also we're taking action to make staff feel safer in the workplace, enhancing support for staff health and wellbeing, for example, improving access to support for mental health and musculoskeletal conditions. They are the two biggest causes of sickness absence, which also drive demand for temporary cover.

29:53 - 30:27

Speaker 29

When the permanent staff are asked to do overtime or to fill in rather than have agency nurses, they're paid at a lower rate. Why don't we pay them the same rate as the agency staff, which would boost morale and lead to more continuity of care and also reduce the hassle of finding agency nurses?

30:27 - 31:16

Gillian Merron

The important thing to the point is it is the case that agency staff can cost the NHS more, which the noble lord refers to. But that's why we've now got, which didn't exist when agency spending completely rose out of control, and for example it was standing at around 3.7 billion in 2015-16, that's because there were limited national controls. So actually I would approach it about the agency price cap, and that's the maximum amount an NHS trust would normally pay for an agency worker. I don't quite recognise the situation the noble lord has referred to for NHS staff, but I will take that away indeed and check the situation on it.

31:16 - 31:44

Speaker 31

While the minister talks about reduced agency spending, which is welcome, total temporary workforce costs remain largely unchanged, simply displacing into bank premiums, overtime and other insourcing.

So will the minister commit to publishing the total combined cost of flexible staffing so Parliament can judge whether taxpayers' money is actually being saved or merely reshuffled within budget lines?

31:44 - 32:21

Gillian Merron

I'm not, again, I'll certainly take that away, the points the noble lord raises, but I don't recognize the description of reshuffling, not least because of the requirements on local health providers in reducing agency expenditure are quite clear and they have to report against them and drive further reductions, and that money, those moneys are directed into frontline care because after all that's what we all want to see.

32:21 - 33:04

Speaker 19

My Lords, can I thank my noble friend Baroness Davies for raising this very important point? And I want to touch on a number of issues that have been drawn together. One is within the NHS, there are three very different categories of non-permanent staff. We have agency, bank, and temporary staff, each with different implications for continuity of care, as my noble friend referred. Now, given that agency staff are supplied externally, bank staff are on the trust's own books, and temporary staff move between services, can the noble lady the minister tell the House whether her department monitors the impact of each of these differences on the continuity of care for patients, including where patients can see the same doctor if possible, and if so, where's that data available?

33:04 - 33:52

Gillian Merron

Well, the noble lord, I know, has welcomed our emphasis on continuity of care, and it is the best form of healthcare that we can offer. And the truth is, the only way to properly do that is by an established NHS workforce. But the reality is, as noble lords will be very aware, there are just times when you do need to use some kind of temporary cover in order to secure patient safety. But I think the main thing I'd want to say to the noble lord is that we are committed, and it will be through the workforce plan, to a more settled and a workforce that can provide properly the care that we need. We're not in that place yet, but I do believe the steps we're taking will get us there.

33:52 - 34:31

Speaker 43

My Lords, the noble lady quite rightly said that retention is one of the most important things both for our own staff but also the advantage to patients. Yesterday, the APPG for Health heard evidence from senior staff in Georgia who explained that by starting to pay off student loans between three and five years of continuous service, they had managed to retain and get a much more stable workforce. When will the department look at the cost-benefit analysis of such an approach?

34:31 - 35:27

Gillian Merron

The noble lady hasn't actually asked me to make a commitment, and I'm glad she didn't because I couldn't give that commitment at this stage. However, I think what I would say to you is in addition to the examples of actions that we are taking, which I referred to earlier in this question, we are looking broadly about how we can retain people. I am aware that the cost to individuals is a key matter. The noble lady will be aware about the constraints upon us, but it is a matter of seeing what else we can do. But we are undertaking targeted retention work, not least understanding why staff have left.

That is for a variety of reasons, some obvious, some less obvious, but they all need to be tackled and we are taking that multi-faceted approach.

35:27 - 35:36

John Spellar

Fourth oral question, Lord Spellar.

35:36 - 36:19

Sonny Liang

My Lords, we understand the anxiety that this announcement causes amongst workers and families and communities in the area where JLR is based. We are determined that Britain will remain a world-leading automotive nation. Our industrial strategy reduces electricity costs, commits 4 billion pounds to Drive 35 to advanced manufacturing and research and allocates 2 billion pounds to boost electric vehicles demand. We are strengthening supplies through the Drive 35 transformation programme and securing better access to markets in the EU and the United States, thereby protecting investment and jobs.

36:19 - 37:11

John Spellar

Can I thank my noble friend the Minister for that answer and he obviously recognises the importance of our auto components industry which underpins our car assembly plants and also is a significant part of our exports and also our regional economies. And he and the House will be aware of the significant impact of the hack at Jaguar Land Rover last year which actually led to an overall drop in GDP but also a really much more significant effect on the West Midlands economy. So with those current problems which he's identified at JLR, what is the government doing to support the supply chains and the British car plants and wouldn't one measure be for public bodies to prioritise buying British vehicles built by British workers?

37:11 - 37:52

Sonny Liang

My Lords, my noble friend rightfully reminds us that cyberattacks attack companies of all sizes and the cyberattack is really a stark reminder that JLR is not the only manufacturer but also the anchor of the supply chain. We are working with JLR, lenders, local partners and suppliers to safeguard viable businesses, improve access to finance and strengthen cyber resilience. On procurement, we will use the government purchasing power strategically to ensure British manufacturers can compete fairly and that social value, resilient supply chains and UK capability are recognised in purchasing decisions.

37:52 - 38:25

Speaker 45

My Lords, the Minister will be aware that the Chinese government and their motor manufacturing are eyeing up the European car market, flooding the European car market with millions of good quality cars which are undercutting our home-made domestic market with Lord Spellar's excellent question. What assessment has the noble Lord made of this strategy of the Chinese government to flood the European car market and is he aware that Volkswagen have closed down their state-of-the-art plant in Dresden?

38:25 - 39:03

Sonny Liang

My Lords, we are closely monitoring the growing presence of Chinese electric and hybrid vehicles and engaging directly with the UK manufacturers. My Lords, my loyalty lies with Range Rover, although mine is almost five years old now, so I'm waiting for the electric version to be coming on the market. So we have strengthened our trade remedies, my Lords, to respond more swiftly to evidence of harm and the Trade Remedies Authority can investigate when industry brings forward a credible case that these Chinese cars are causing to the sector.

39:03 - 39:34

Speaker 46

My Lords, the best support that the government could give to the car industry is to end the uncertainty in the European car market which is hindering investment and could decimate our industry in the near future. Shouldn't we be rejoining the single market and the customs union to provide a strong countervailing force with Canada against Trump tariffs and unfair Chinese competition?

39:34 - 40:16

Sonny Liang

My Lords, our position is very clear, we are where we are and we're not joining the customs union.

My Lords, the government will defend interests of British manufacturers and our deeply integrated UK-EU automotive supply chains. Where the proposed IRA, which is the Made in Europe, risks disadvantaging them, the Secretary of State and Trade Minister have raised our concerns directly with EU member states, their Commissioner and MEPs. The proposal is not final and we continue working with the industry to assess its impact. Now is the time for light-minded partners to strengthen growth, resilience and economic stability.

40:16 - 41:01

Speaker 54

My Lords, Jaguar partly blame the ZEV mandate for these job cuts, a situation that the government, I'm glad to say, acknowledges with its current consultation aimed at reducing this mandate to protect up to 200,000 automotive jobs. However, does the government regret the recent announcement that Jaguar are going to build the new Freelander, originally built in Halewood, in China with Chery, whose sister company JAECOO, the top-selling Chinese brand in Britain, are making and selling Range Rover lookalikes for less than a third of the Range Rover price? Stealing the family silver's one thing, giving it away is another. How's that good for British jobs?

41:01 - 41:38

Sonny Liang

My Lords, I mean, I don't think the government has any intention in intervening with individual business decisions. What Jaguar Land Rover decides, who their partners are, is entirely the responsibility of Jaguar Land Rover. However, having said that, I mean, we work very closely with JLR, the trade unions and local partners to ensure that no affected worker is left without support. And we will continue working with unions, community leaders and the company itself to ensure that all workers will be treated fairly when the consultation comes into play and that no worker will be left without any support.

41:38 - 42:46

David Hunt

My Lords, these job losses at Jaguar Land Rover are deeply concerning and our thoughts are with the employees and their families affected. But we on these benches have repeatedly been warning the government over the past two years that higher energy costs, damaging steel tariffs, the increase in employers' national insurance contributions and the Employment Rights Act are making it harder and more expensive to do business in Britain. With one of our most important manufacturers now cutting thousands of jobs, will our new Prime Minister start to overcome the damaging policies of his predecessor and now restore Britain's competitiveness? Otherwise, we will have more jobs and investment being driven overseas.

42:46 - 44:07

Sonny Liang

My Lords, with due respect to the honorable Lord, I think that's a really simplistic answer or question he's given. My Lords, the scale and speed of global transformation in this sector is facing every single automotive manufacturer, not only in this country but elsewhere in the world. Manufacturers everywhere, and I mean everywhere globally, are responding to fierce competition that new technologies and changing international trading conditions are in place. That is precisely why this government have committed 2.5 billion pounds through Drive 35, providing long-term support for research, development, manufacturing and the transition to zero-emission vehicles. Our objective is to secure investment and high-value production, rather, here in Britain.

Now, for the benefit of noble lords, JLR has said it will seek voluntary departures wherever possible and still plans and still plans to invest 15 to 18 billion pounds in this country. They have faith in this country and I hope noble lords across the aisle will also have faith in this country.

44:07 - 44:35

Speaker 38

My lords, we would all wish Jaguar Land Rover to succeed, but does the minister recognize that more than any other country in the G7, the UK economy is overwhelmingly focused now on high-value services, which give the economy nine times what the manufacturing sector currently and now does?

44:35 - 45:04

Sonny Liang

My lords, I mean the United Kingdom is a trading nation. We we trade with every country across the world. We are doing free trade deals right across the globe, the recent one obviously with India and with the Gulf countries as well. We are a trading nation and we have to support our manufacturers and our companies to trade seamlessly and easily throughout the world.

45:04 - 45:36

Speaker 47

Can I begin by declaring an interest like the minister in owning a Jaguar Land Rover car? But the minister said that government procurement could be competitive. But if he goes to France or Germany, no government minister would get in a foreign-made car in any of those countries. So what more can the government do centrally in terms of its procurement, but also insisting, for example, that local authorities and police forces buy British?

45:36 - 45:53

Sonny Liang

I just want to sort of reassure my noble friend that the department that I'm in, the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, all our ministerial cars are actually manufactured in the United Kingdom, and I'm sure I can speak for other departments as well.

45:53 - 47:28

Speaker 50

My lords, that completes oral questions for today. This may be a convenient moment for those who wish to do so to leave the chamber quickly and quietly.

47:28 - 47:57

John Steve Bassam

First reading of a private member's bill, Lord Bassam of Brighton.

My Lords, I beg to introduce a bill to make provision about the governance of event venues where seat owners or their nominated representatives form part of the governing body of an event venue, to regulate the sales of the use of such seats by seat owners or their nominated representatives and for connected purposes. I beg to move that this bill be now read a first time.

47:57 - 48:26

Speaker 51

The question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. Message from the Commons that they have passed the Health Bill to which they desire the agreement of your Lordships.

Question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many are of that opinion will say content.

48:26 - 48:34

Speaker 27

My Lords, Health Bill, I beg to move that this bill be now read a first time.

48:34 - 48:54

Speaker 51

The question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many of that opinion will now say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. Questions on a statement made in the House of Commons yesterday on Israel-Palestine.

48:54 - 53:32

Martin Callanan

My Lords, let me firstly thank the noble Lord the Minister for granting us the opportunity to ask questions on this important statement. These measures amount to a major change in the UK's approach to the region, so it's right that we are scrutinizing them in your Lordships' House today. In the other place, both the Foreign Secretary and my right honorable friend the Shadow Foreign Secretary rightly noted the consensus across both our parties on the need for a two-state solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict. We agree that the settlements are illegal. We are both firm in our resolve that Israel has a right to defend itself, and I welcome the Foreign Secretary's explicit statement that he is unwavering in my support for the state of Israel.

We also agree that His Majesty's government were right to designate the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, although I remind the right honorable the noble Lord the Minister that the government consistently resisted our amendments to prescribe the IRGC and had to be dragged to this position by noble Lords on all sides of this House. But the question we must ask ourselves today is whether the government's actions have moved us closer to a two-state solution or is it in fact a backward step. The Foreign Secretary said a number of times that the UK must not be a bystander. Today we have learned that Israel has ordered the closure of the British consulate. Can the noble Lord the Minister say whether the news will undermine the UK's ability to influence the future of the region?

Has the government actually now made the UK a bystander and a weaker influence on Israel as a result of these announcements? Can he also say what the FCDO advice was on the risk of the UK's influence in the region being weakened as a result of yesterday's announcement? Then there is the matter, my Lords, of the timing. Only a matter of weeks ago, ministers in the previous government, some of whom now serve in this government also, were saying in writing that any trade ban targeting settlements would be practically very difficult to enforce. So can the noble Lord the Minister confirm that this ban will in fact need primary legislation that will not be enacted for many months?

The Foreign Secretary indicated nine months, but even that seems optimistic to me. Can the noble Lord indicate when we can expect to see this draft legislation? It has also been said by many that the government have made a serious mistake by announcing this dramatic change in policy just weeks before an Israeli election. Bloomberg reported yesterday that British Foreign Office officials were quietly reassuring the Trump administration that these trade sanctions were, and I quote, largely symbolic, which perhaps explains the somewhat muted US reaction. My Lords, it seems clearer by the day that this announcement has nothing to do with peace in the Middle East but everything to do with peace in the Labour Party.

Can the noble Lord the Minister say whether the ministers even considered the risk that these measures would in fact strengthen the hand of extremist politicians in Israel who oppose the two-state solution? Yesterday, my honourable friend the Shadow Foreign Secretary asked him to say what instructions had been given to the Foreign Office on the accreditation of diplomats to the so-called Palestinian embassy, should Hamas win the elections in November and send their envoys here. He did not receive an answer. The Foreign Secretary also refused to answer the same question on Radio 4 this morning. Let me give the noble Lord another opportunity to do so now.

My Lords, I have deliberately left the most important issue last. Whatever His Majesty's Government's approach may be to issues across the world, its first duty should be to the British people. We must always stand up for British Jews. Antisemitism has no place in this country. The Chief Rabbi yesterday accused the government of mendacious anti-Israel rhetoric that would put Jewish people in danger.

Can the noble Lord the Minister please reassure the House that the government will do everything in its power to keep British Jews safe? They are our fellow countrymen and women, and no conflict in another part of the world should be allowed to feed hate in this country. It is not just security measures for synagogues, for schools and community centres that we need, although these measures are essential in this time of rising antisemitism. We need a much wider approach across our politics and in communities across the country to stamp out antisemitism. So may I ask the noble Lord Minister one final question before I sit down: what more is the government going to do to end the scourge of antisemitism in the UK?

53:32 - 59:20

Jeremy Purvis

My Lords, the choice of who forms the Israeli government is for the Israeli people and them alone. Our foreign policy is for our government, and our legislation is for this Parliament. No British Jewish person should be held to account for the actions of another government, an Israeli government. And antisemitism at too high a rate is utterly repugnant and has no place in our communities. And I reiterate what I've said on a number of occasions, and I hope the Minister might take this forward, that there should be the highest level cross-party talks on increasing measures to tackle this scourge in our country.

That said, I agree with the Foreign Secretary's comment in his statement that the Labour government have not done enough in response to the humanitarian crisis in both Gaza and the West Bank. Therefore, these benches welcome the actions taken by twelve countries, including the United Kingdom, to act on ensuring that there is no impunity for the comprehensive disregard for the rule of law in the West Bank. The Foreign Secretary referred to the time of the Oslo Accords and the number of those who resided in the illegal settlements. That number was very high. But I want to go a little bit further back and quote the first speech by Lord Carrington as Foreign Secretary in the Thatcher government in 1979 in this chamber.

He said in his first speech as Foreign Secretary of the West Bank, I quote from Hansard: "The objective here must be full and genuine autonomy for these areas as a step forwards towards determining their final status." "Nothing would do more to help these negotiations to build trust in the area and to win the consent of the Palestinians than for Israel to cease the expansion of its settlements in the occupied territories." Then there were not much more than 15,000 settlers in the illegally occupied areas. Today there are more than three quarters of a million. The challenges ahead are enormous, but the prescription of the problem Lord Carrington got exactly right.

I have seen myself the impunity for those that are both in the illegal occupied territory and those with the outposts.

In September 2024 I visited the area. I saw part of the destruction and I saw part of the intimidation by those who were illegal settlers. These were in outposts in the West Bank which are illegal under Israeli law. Our sanctions will not make any difference to those, but I called for action and the end of the impunity on my return in this house, because settler violence was the worst on record in the year leading up to October the 7th and has got worse since. If the established view across all the parties in this house is that outposts are illegal under both Israeli law and international law, and settlements are illegal under international law, then it is a surely natural position that UK law should not facilitate the trade and investment with those illegal outposts.

I don't understand those who are saying that we should not have our law to respect Israeli law. It is further surely a natural position that for those who facilitate illegal settlements and outposts which are illegal under Israeli law, then our law should ensure that both finance and violence by intimidation should also be illegal. In the first hand sights of intimidation that I saw, it was on a particular occasion where the settler was South African and had secured his Israeli citizenship formalized on the flight from South Africa. There is unfortunately actions to ensure that there is no peace in the in the Gaza and the West Bank by a systematic approach by some of those outpost communities. Lord Carrington was right that the outposts and the settlements were a hindrance and a block to peace.

So I want to ask the minister how we in the United Kingdom will now ensure that both Hamas gangsters are prevented from being part of governance, and indeed we called for the IRGC to be proscribed and we on occasions were frustrated that the previous government refused to do so, and we've welcomed this government's proscription of them. But we also have been supportive of the recognition of the state of Palestine. But on the balance of ensuring that Hamas is not part of governance, we need to ensure that there is good governance for Palestine, and that is why we were critical of the government cutting development partnership support for the very governance and transparency for Palestine that we will need in the future. The previous government perpetuated a cut of ODA to Palestine by 80% that this government is continuing. I hope the minister might review this to ensure that the UK support for good governance increases and not continues to fall.

The travesty of the Trump administration's failed humanitarian agency shows the need for there to be clarity, law and order as well as good governance. Finally, I hope the minister will be able to confirm that the sanctions regime that will be being put in place will ensure that all of those included in circumvention of the sanctions regime will be caught will be caught within it, so that there is no impunity for those within this country under our law to continue to support the expansion of outposts that are illegal under Israeli law.

59:20 - 59:24

Speaker 61

Well, can I thank both Noble Lord Callanan and Noble Lord Purvis for their comments.

59:24 - 01:08:01

Tariq Ahmad

I will answer the questions in a minute, but I think it might be helpful just to give a little bit of context, which I think helps me provide some of the answers that the noble lords are looking for. This government thinks that the situation in Palestine is a moral emergency. And what the Israeli government has inflicted on the people of Gaza, we all know, we can see with our eyes, and it is an outrage. There is increasing evidence, we think, that war crimes appear to have been committed in Gaza, and we are witnessing unprecedented violence, including settler terrorism in the West Bank. What the Foreign Secretary announced yesterday was a decision not to stand by and let this happen.

We are going to be stronger in standing up for what is right and bolder in the action we take. What's striking is that all parties, Liberal Democrats, Conservative, and Labour at the very least, others I know as well, support the two-state solution as the Noble Lord Callanan eloquently stated at the outset of his remarks: freedom, security, and self-determination for both Palestinian and Israeli people. This is action which is designed to defend this policy at a time when the already diminished prospects for that solution are under serious threat. That's why we've concluded that Israel's ongoing occupation of the Palestinian territory is unlawful, in line with the finding of the International Court of Justice decision advisory opinion in 2024. And that's why we've brought in the various sanctions regime measures we talked about, that the Foreign Secretary talked about yesterday, and I'm happy to talk about those in more detail in a minute in response to some of these questions.

Turning to the Noble Lord Callanan's questions. I do think it's striking that he started his remarks by supporting our policy but is unwilling to support the means by which we prosecute our policy at a time when it's needed most. He asked about whether our actions will undermine influence. How Israel responds is a matter for Israel, just as our foreign policy is a matter for us. We have very strong, continuing security cooperation with Israel.

That will continue. It is in the interests of both our country, Israel, the wider region, and the West in general. We also, of course, he asked about support, we have support most notably from the Palestinian representatives of the people whom these measures affect the most. We also have support directly from France and Canada who aligned their policies yesterday, the same day that the Foreign Secretary announced his new approach, our new approach, and 12 other countries as the Noble Lord Lord Purvis said, who are going to support economic measures to pursue the same goal. He asked about legislation for sanctions.

It's a good question. There's a series of separate things. We're taking immediate action under existing legislation to target individual settlers, action which the Conservative government also took against individual settlers a few years ago. We are going to extend the global human rights regime to expand it to include violations of humanitarian law. We expect that to be brought into force in the next few weeks.

And thirdly, in the longer term, and he's right to say six to nine months, it'll take about six months or more to develop a new targeted approach to companies who assist or profit from the expansion of settlements. There are challenges in bringing that about. There's no doubt about it. There'll be tough cases, particularly as we are committed to protecting the integrity of trade with Green Line Israel. But we are confident we have a very sophisticated sanctions regime with various institutions that have obviously played a part in applying sanctions elsewhere.

I've taken decisions in my short time in this job with regard to Russia, for example. We have a sophisticated coordination between HMRC, OTSI, OFSI, and other bodies which we are confident can deliver a manageable regime. He asked about timing in advance of the elections.

The elections, as the Noble Lord Purvis eloquently, more eloquently than I could say, said, elections are a matter for the Israel and the Israeli people. Our responsibility is to our country and to advance a policy that defends the commitments which are just shared are just shared across parties, but we believe are shared across the country. On Hamas, let me be absolutely clear about Hamas, there is no place for Hamas in the future governance, there should be no place for the Hamas in the future governance of Palestine. And we have taken strong action to on proscription of Hamas, we will continue to take strong action against Hamas in funding, but also against individuals. The priority at the moment with Hamas obviously is to support the United States 20-point plan.

And that's a crucial plank of achieving some a restoration of order and peace in the region at the moment. But we will not hesitate to use the powers we have to to target Hamas individuals and collectively in the future. He asked about the Chief Rabbi's comments. I have huge respect for the Chief Rabbi. I disagree with the Chief Rabbi's conclusion.

Antisemitism is a scourge, not just in our country but elsewhere. It is something that everyone should take hugely seriously and do the utmost to stamp out. But the government has to be able to take decisions about foreign policy of another government. It has to have the freedom to do that. And it is, as Noble Lord Purvis again eloquently said, I think it is wrong, it is something that we should all condemn to elide the distinction between British Jews and the responsibilities they have and the Israeli government the responsibilities they have.

We should deny that that connection. Turning that to Lord Purvis's questions. I agreed with much of his, I mean he supported much of of the announcement from yesterday and I'm very very grateful that and he's right to point to the number of countries that have coordinated in in aligning themselves with the Foreign Secretary's new approach yesterday. And he's also right to point to the cross-party roots of action against settlers, the quote from Lord Carrington shows that action against settlers is not a new part of Labour government policy, it's a it's a consistent theme that's gone back across distinguished members of both parties and other parties for a for a very long time. I too have visited areas where settlers have let's let's be honest, are wreak have wreaked havoc, have caused misery, destruction.

I went with the Foreign Secretary when he was then the leader of the Labour Party to the E1 area where we met and dined with a Bedouin community who had been there for decades and were being forcibly expelled by settler violence. I think he's absolutely right in putting his finger on the key rationale here, which is that once you take a position on the legality of the occupation as we have done, then our trade policy aligning with that is not just an extra, but a duty. And that's the policy that was was announced yesterday. And that's why we are targeting not just those who perpetrate violence settler violence, but also individual companies in the future who will seek to assist settlement expansion and profit from it. He's right also to point to the need to ensure Hamas is not involved in future Palestinian governance arrangements and right also to say that the UK needs to play a strong part in supporting good governance in Palestine.

My noble friend Lord Barber, I'm not sure if he's here, plays an important part as an envoy to on Palestinian governance, we have a range of support measures that we will continue continue to provide.

And on the last point about sanctions circumvention, he's absolutely right that a regime needs to be devised which is not easily evaded. The regime will be based on postcode declarations. This is an established mechanism which is used elsewhere. And the combination of activity by HMRC, the Office of Trade Sanctions Implementation, Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation, they've worked together many for many ways for a long time. They'll continue to work together to ensure that this regime is as watertight as we can make it.

01:08:01 - 01:08:18

Speaker 62

My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, before we go on to the next 20 minutes, which is for backbench questions only, if we have short questions, not statements or speeches, we'll be able to get in as many noble Lords as possible. And with that in mind, we'll start with the Conservatives and work around the chamber.

01:08:18 - 01:10:22

Tariq Ahmad

My Lords, in thanking the Minister for his answers to the two frontbenchers, the proud traditions of the Conservative Party, not just the noble Lord Carrington, but successive Conservative Prime Ministers who called out the E1 settlement, which was the trigger at this point. In declaring my interest on working on organizations involved in resolving conflict in the Middle East, I'd ask the noble Lord the Minister two practical questions. In response to British sanctions, again, and I agree with him, the Conservative government also initiated indeed the sanctions regime which he is referring to. What are the practical consequences of the closure of the consulate in Jerusalem in terms of Palestinian representation? And also importantly, what engagement are we directly having with the Israelis?

Because there are many in Israel who wish to see a final agreement and indeed settlement so there's security and peace for Palestinians and Israelis in ensuring that this vision, which has gone on for far too long, turns into a working practical reality.

Well, thank the noble Lord for that for that question. He's right that the we were disappointed that the Israeli response was to close the UK consulate in East Jerusalem, a 30-day notice period. We will continue to endeavor to provide the the kind of activities that the consulate provided in in other ways. There were other measures also that were none affecting security, but other measures also that Israel responded. That of course is their their right to respond in the way that the way that they see fit.

The noble Lord is also right that there has to be dialogue with those forces in Israeli society who want peace, who see cross-community cooperation as the future. And and that is something that this government is going to support and the Foreign Secretary is very keen to support as well.

01:10:22 - 01:12:14

Speaker 64

My Lords, I first must declare an interest as the president of the Liberal Democrat Friends of Israel. And in that context, I and we unequivocally oppose expansion of Israeli settlements in the West Bank and condemn settler violence. Those responsible for the violence should face the full force of the law. However, the government's decision to ban trade with settlements is the in my view the wrong response and at the wrong time. Announced just before the Israeli elections, which are next month, this strengthens the far right of Ben-Gvir and Smotrich, whose claim that Israel is under siege, pushing voters away from the less hardline parties and weakening Israel's Israelis' hope for change.

My Lords, Britain should refrain from acts which will influence Israeli elections, as I say, which are next month.

We wouldn't like it happened if a foreign country was doing that during the course of the UK elections. We should be supporting moderates, and the minister mentioned them. Could the minister confirm that we should be supporting moderates like Yair Lapid's party and Samuel Sinlawi's new party that challenged the Fatah PA, PA which has not held an election for decades? Um, we must also, could the minister also confirm that we need to safeguard UK's vital security and intelligence relationship with Israel, which helps to protect British lives? And lastly...

And lastly... The noble lord should sit down please, I think he's had ample time to make his point.

01:12:14 - 01:13:35

Tariq Ahmad

Well, I thank the noble lord for those, those comments and, um, he obviously speaks with great authority and, and passion and interest in this, in this subject. I agree that we should be supporting moderates, not intervening politically to support moderates, but supporting moderate voices across Israeli society and within the Palestinian Authority. There is serious reform that needs to be done in the Palestinian area as well. On timing, um, let me be clear, the reason for the timing of this announcement, obviously there is a new, a new Prime Minister and a new cabinet in place. But the timing is a result of a sharp rise in settler violence, an accelerating expansion of settlements, a new tender process in the E1 settlement area which was issued in August, which by the way completes a week before the Israeli election.

Um, a consistent failure on many of those in power in Israel to hold those who perpetrate violence to account. That's the, that's the explanation for the timing. Israel's elections will proceed according to Israeli law and we will not intervene in Israeli politics. We have to make decisions based on the facts that we see. The new government has come in and made an assessment and that's why we responded when we did.

01:13:35 - 01:14:11

Speaker 66

Will the minister recognize, will the minister recognize the wisdom of the statement yesterday by the President, the much-respected President of the State of Israel, Isaac Herzog, who said that what is needed in this context is constructive dialogue, not gesture politics? And is it not therefore most unfortunate that since the appointment of Prime Minister Burnham in July, he is yet even to speak to Prime Minister Netanyahu?

01:14:11 - 01:15:31

Tariq Ahmad

Well, I thank the noble and learned lord for that, um, question. Dialogue is of course absolutely fundamental to the way forward in this as in any, any comparable crisis and in any complex situation like this. President Herzog did urge dialogue. Um, when it comes to the expansion of settlements though, there seems to be precious little dialogue going on domestically in order to restrain what is an accelerating and deeply disturbing trend. I mean, let me just give you some statistics about this.

Noble Lord Purvis referred to this. There were about a quarter of a million settlers in 1993 at the time of Oslo. In 2026 there are three quarters of a million settlers. There are six settler violence incidents per day. Sixty-five Palestinian communities in their entirety expelled since 2023.

So I absolutely agree with the need for dialogue and I think dialogue should be the first port of call between Israel's government and the settler community. Um, I'm sorry, I forgot your second part of your question, I do apologize.

01:15:31 - 01:16:11

Speaker 65

My lords, I warmly welcome the statement by the Foreign Secretary yesterday, um, and particularly the tone in which he delivered the statement.

And I truly believe that the calling out of the illegal occupation and the sanctions on the illegal settlements is a game changer to the progression towards peace in the region. But whilst that is happening and the implementation is key, can I ask my noble friend the Minister what actions the government are taking to bring force to bear on some of the other actors in the region, Iran and their proxies?

01:16:11 - 01:17:18

Tariq Ahmad

I thank my noble friend for that question. It's absolutely right that the action we took yesterday in announcing a new policy on sanctions with regard to the West Bank was accompanied by further strong action against Iran, in particular taking action against the supply chain for its nuclear program. The government already reapplied the snapback mechanism, as those of you will know from the United Nations resolution mechanism last year. We yesterday announced further financial, trade, energy, and transport sector targeted actions, and targeting financial assistance and banking of Iranian companies for those companies connected to the nuclear program. We're also going to expand the sanctioning of vessels involved in activities supporting the nuclear program.

And secondly, we took action yesterday in prescribing Al-Qard al-Hassan, the financing arm of Hezbollah in Lebanon. So taking strong action against Iran and its proxies, as my noble friend said, is a crucial part of ensuring that Israel remains secure.

01:17:18 - 01:18:23

Stephen Cottrell

My Lords, I came, like others in this House, I came face to face with settler militia and the impact of settlements visiting the South Hebron Hills last year. And therefore, with many on these benches, we welcome this statement, and we've called for such principled action over many years. We believe these measures are just, necessary, and frankly overdue. Though we also want to emphasize that in acting against specific policies of the Israeli government, we of course remain unreservedly opposed to the evils of antisemitism here in the UK and everywhere. So a specific question: would the noble Lord the Minister accept that with E1 tenders, E1's already been mentioned, but tenders I think are coming up, I think on the 19th of October, they're about to be opened, are further measures needed to deter Israeli banks from guaranteeing such bids?

01:18:23 - 01:19:58

Tariq Ahmad

Well, I thank the right reverend prelate for those comments. He's right that the E1 settlement is, the tender process finishes on the 19th of October. Our announcement yesterday is a sign, a signal, sorry, that any company that wants to take part in any of the construction or related processes in that tender should think twice, because we are bringing forward steps that will, not a blanket services ban at all, but targeted measures to focus on any company that assists or profits from the expansion of settlements. I appreciate also the comments at the beginning about broad support for this policy. And I should also point out that of course it's not just Muslim Palestinians that are the victims of settlement expansion.

Palestinian Christians have seen terrible suffering. They've seen arson attacks. They've seen churches in Taybeh, I believe the 5th century St. Peter's Church was attacked. They've seen their agriculture, their land taken away.

So this is action in support of Palestinians of all descriptions who experience the horrors at the face of settler violence.

01:19:58 - 01:20:31

Kevin Shinkwin

My Lords, first to an additional 250 million pounds investment for community security. Do I ask the noble Lord the Minister, is that not an implicit admission that this announcement on the boycott will fuel and indeed legitimate further anti-Jewish racism directed against British citizens?

01:20:31 - 01:21:42

Tariq Ahmad

Absolutely not. There is and there must be no connection between the actions of the Israeli government and any attribution of responsibility to British Jews. That is a connection we totally, totally deny. The new Prime Minister has shown his commitment to the reason this needs to be provided is because there has been over a period of time a shocking rise in antisemitic incidents. Everyone can see it.

We just last week commemorated the upcoming anniversary of the appalling Heaton Park attack. That was followed by antisemitic attacks in Golders Green, including on Hatzola ambulances. Antisemitic incidents are shockingly on the rise, not just here but across countries, across countries. That's why we provide over 300 million in fact over three years to protect Jewish communities, tackle antisemitism. That's why the Foreign Secretary in October is meeting with the G7, the group of countries with the largest Jewish populations.

It's a priority for the new Prime Minister, he's made clear already. That commitment will remain absolute and I hope enjoys cross-party support.

01:21:42 - 01:22:58

Magid Magid

My Lords, could I welcome the Foreign Secretary's statement and in particular, my Lords, I'm not going to sit down, so exactly, Liberal Democrats. My Lords, can I just thank the Foreign Secretary, can I actually support the Foreign Secretary's statement on this? Ever since Mr Rabin's tragic death in the mid-nineties, the Palestinians have been strung along with the hope of an independent state and people like Mr Netanyahu have done everything possible to hinder it and this E1 is the final straw that will break the camel's back, so I actually support it. I also welcome the Foreign Secretary's comments in his statement around our extension of global human rights sanctions regime enable those, enable us to target those responsible for violations of international humanitarian law, whether in Gaza or elsewhere. Can I ask, will that be extended to Mr Netanyahu or Mr Gallant where there's already arrest warrants, but also those individual soldiers that are seen on various videos committing crimes against humanity, whether that's in the Gaza Strip or actually in the West Bank where it's settlers and police colluding to target innocent Palestinians who have been shot dead?

01:22:58 - 01:23:45

Tariq Ahmad

Well, thank the noble Lord for those questions. He's absolutely right that the cause of decent Palestinians, the overwhelming majority of decent Palestinians has been neglected for too long. I agree with that and I hope this does start to correct some of that. On the global human rights reforms, what we're doing is beefing up the existing regime and by the way, this is a universal regime rather than targeted on specific countries to include not just those who abuse human rights, but also those who violate international humanitarian law in Palestine and throughout the world.

That doesn't stop us using existing global human rights regime to target individual settlers and that's why five individuals were targeted yesterday.

01:23:45 - 01:24:31

Alexander David Hugh Hannay

My Lords, my Lords, would does the noble Lord the minister consider that does the government consider that the government of Israel has the right to order us to close the consulate in East Jerusalem given that the consulate is situated in East Jerusalem which is recognized by the United Nations and practically all its members as being occupied Palestinian territory over which Israel does not have sovereignty. So could he say whether we are going to contest the attempt to order us to close the consul which is the consulate which is both disproportionate and ultra vires.

01:24:31 - 01:25:06

Tariq Ahmad

Noble Lord Lord Hanny knows much more about this than I do. I feel like I'm in my introductory day at the foreign office trying to work out difficult questions. I think the answer is that they he may have a point. It's an interesting it's an interesting point on the legality of it. De facto Israel can prevent the operation of that consulate and that's why we are endeavoring to ensure that the functions that the consulate provides that will be provided in another way.

01:25:06 - 01:25:57

Ros Rosalind Altmann

Noble Lord to give us some example of where the Palestinians have accepted a two-state solution. Israel has accepted it. As a British Jew I would welcome it. But the government must know and if not should hopefully take note that the Jews in this country have felt under attack and under pressure from the double standards that seem to be applied to the only Jewish state in the world which is surrounded by enemies and trying to defend itself while the Palestinian Authority is getting aid and it still supports the pay for slay policy. Can the noble Lord the minister please explain how these double standards can be accepted.

01:25:57 - 01:26:46

Tariq Ahmad

Well I thank the noble lady for her question and her she obviously has great interest and expertise in this issue. The two-state solution is a solution which is expected on all parties, Palestinians and Israelis. It's something that we expect the leaders of those of Palestinian Authority but also of Israel to support. We want their actions to match the commitment to that and and on both sides symmetrically where actions fall short we will take we will take action in response with our foreign policy.

01:26:46 - 01:28:08

Tessa Blackstone

Minister on both the tone and content of his statement both on the West Bank and on Gaza. Moreover I regret the hypocrisy of those opposite who claim to support a two-state solution yet refuse to endorse actions against the Israeli government whose settlement policy is making such a solution impossible. I also wonder why they don't condemn its continuing breaking of international law on occupation. As so often the Israeli government have overreacted including by including by deciding to close the British consulate.

More than one speaker has raised this issue, and I would like to ask the minister whether particular care will be taken to ensure that Palestinians wishing to get visas to come to the UK, and who would do that normally through the consulate, will be able to do so. Finally, if I can just finish, will the government make clear to the Israeli government that the overwhelming support of the measures that it produced yesterday, coming from the British population as demonstrated by polling information, is something that should be taken into account in any constructive dialogue that takes place?

01:28:08 - 01:29:13

Tariq Ahmad

I thank the noble lady for those questions. And I think she raises an important point. If I'd be interested down the line to find out whether the Conservative Party agrees with the advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice in 2024. We've made our decision. I'd be interested to find out down the line what the Conservatives' and other parties' positions are.

On the provision of consular services, including visa provision, as I said earlier, we are going to endeavour to provide functional replacements for what was provided in the consulate in East Jerusalem once the consulate is forced to close after 30 days. And on the last point about public support, I do strongly believe that this expresses, it clearly does not express everyone's view. This is an issue which divides, and sometimes divides in impassioned ways, of course. But I do believe that the position the Foreign Secretary outlined yesterday expresses a broad majority support for taking action against some of the, both the violence and the turning of a blind eye by the Israeli government, particularly in settler areas.

01:29:13 - 01:30:07

Speaker 74

Report of the Financial Services and Markets Bill, Lord Pitt-Watson.

01:30:07 - 01:30:18

David Pitt

My Lords, I beg to move that this bill be now considered on report.

01:30:18 - 01:30:54

Speaker 51

The question is that this bill be now further considered on report. As many as of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The contents have it. Clause 17, amendment 34.

My Lords, I should say by reason of preemption that if amendment 34 is agreed to, I will not be able to call amendments 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 43, 44, 45, 46, 48, 49, and 50. Baroness Northover.

01:30:54 - 01:34:26

Lindsay Northover

Goodness me. My Lords, I rise to move amendment 34 and speak to amendments 55, 65, and 91, and I'll speak briefly. I thank other noble Lords for their support and that of Peers for the Planet. There can be no doubt of the climate challenges we face after another summer of drought, wildfires, and loss of life. Underlying all these amendments is concern about the vulnerability of the financial system and the huge consequences of that.

We saw the results of ignoring weaknesses in the financial crash of 2008 and its aftermath. The Adaptation Committee of the Climate Change Committee emphasizes the risks in the UK of intensifying heat, floods, and wildfires. We need to ensure that these risks are addressed in the financial system. Clause 17 removes whole swathes of protection to be replaced by as yet undefined strategies. The FCA is to be given huge new responsibilities when we know that regulators have a poor track record in monitoring areas under their responsibility, let alone horizon scanning for new risks.

The deletion in the bill takes out regard for climate change, the need to focus on sustainable growth, and to be compliant with the Climate Change Act. Amendment 34 addresses climate risk. It would replace Clause 17's amendments to the regulators' general duties with a single new duty requiring both regulators to consider the financial stability risks associated with climate change. And I'm grateful to the noble lady Baroness Hayman and the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Manchester for their support. There have been extensive discussions in this bill about the sweeping away of the duties in this clause, and this amendment seeks at the very least to ensure that climate risk must be addressed.

Amendment 55 would require annual reports by the FCA and the PRA to include consideration of climate-related financial stability risks. This way we can see exactly how climate risk is being factored in. Amendment 65, which is led by Baroness Hayman, seeks to enable the government to set out how and when it intends to implement its manifesto commitment to mandate UK-regulated financial institutions to develop and implement credible transition plans. Amendment 91 is relevant to climate risk in the housing sector. It would require the Treasury to report on the case for clearer standards for mortgage products which are described as green.

We need to develop measures that will drive higher environmental standards in the housing market, including ensuring that measures are taken to improve a property's resilience to climate risk. I am encouraged by what I have heard informally about the minister's sympathy in relation to this group of amendments. I am led to believe that he fully gets the potential risk to the financial sector and thence to the whole of economy and society. What is always best in this house is if people come together and find a positive way forward where the government sees the case and helps to draft suitable changes to legislation to move things forward. I hope that is what we will see here.

I therefore look forward to hearing how the minister proposes to address these risks. I beg to move.

01:34:26 - 01:34:38

Speaker 51

Amendment proposed, Clause 17, page 21, line 34, leave out subsections 2 to 11 and insert the words printed on the marshalled list.

01:34:38 - 01:39:18

Helene Hayman

Lords, I am very pleased to follow the noble baroness Lady Northover and will speak to her amendments and my own on this subject in a moment. But first of all, could I express my gratitude for the time and the effort that the minister and his colleagues and all the team built in have put into addressing these issues and attempting to reach exactly the sort of conclusion that the noble baroness referred to. Perhaps I could first just say a few words about the other amendments in this group. As far as amendments 90 and 97A on forest risk commodities, I have a great deal of sympathy that over the last five years we have not made progress in this area, and I hope very much the noble lord the minister will be able to give at least a little glimmer of hope that this kicking of the can down the road will not continue.

And I'd also like to make clear my support for amendment 91 by the noble lady Northover again, seeking further clarity from the government on the issue of green mortgages, which will become even more important as the effects of climate change on the housing market become even more apparent than they are now. And I also have amendment 65 on timetable for transition plans. We discussed this at length at committee, but I think this summer made all of us think about our future plans, whether it was to plant more hibiscus and less hydrangeas in our gardens, or how to make our homes more habitable with shutters or with air conditioning. This summer's extreme weather has had some very serious impacts: 2,877 heat-related deaths estimated in May and June alone, a thousand wildfires raging, and disruption and dangers to our transport system, causing knock-on impacts to productivity and daily lives. I recognize that transition plans need to be part of a wider program of action, but I also think that if we wait until we have every duck in a row and every avenue explored, we'll actually be leaving a very dangerous gap in progress in this area.

And I hope that the government, which recognized in its manifesto the importance of these plans, can give us some sense today of the timetable they see for implementation. Turning to amendments dealing with the major and for many of us the most concerning issue, that of the downgrading of the regulatory principles that the FCA and PRA should have in regard to the exercise of their functions contained in clause 17. Lady Northover has made it very clear, and I won't rehearse the arguments she made, about the risk to financial stability that we're already seeing in the housing and insurance markets, which could go far wider. And that is precisely why we fought and gained in the 2023 FISMA Act the climate and nature provisions that are contained in the 2023 FISMA Act. They ensured that these considerations would be taken into account across the regulator's work and day-to-day functioning, not simply something to be looked at at every five years with a retrospective assessment of what had happened and a strategic statement about what might happen next, as is proposed in the current bill.

The government has recognized the concern around clause 17 and it's changed its approach to proportionality by putting forward amendments to ensure that it is reflected in the regulator's annual reporting and day-to-day operations. The issues of climate and nature risk to our financial systems and their viability for the future are just as important. Hence my amendment seeking similar treatment for climate and nature risks as for the proportionality regulatory principle, and my support for Baroness Northover's amendment 34. The minister and his officials have, I know, thought very carefully about these issues when we've discussed them since committee stage, and I hope very much that today he will be able to recognize the centrality of them to the future stability of our financial systems and the role that the FCA and the PRA need to play.

01:39:18 - 01:44:51

Shas Sheehan

My lords, I rise to speak in favor of this group of amendments on re-embedding climate and nature considerations into UK financial institutions' investment decision-making, and in particular I want to speak in favor of amendments 90 and 97A.

May I start by thanking the Minister for his constructive conversation with me earlier this week. I'm reassured that he shares the ambition to see this through and has the steel to deliver it. The Minister understands the urgency of the risk climate change presents to the financial stability of the city, and he is the right messenger, not least because he used to work for Hermes. Hermes, the messenger of the Greek gods, was known for his great cleverness and speed. He wears winged sandals and carries a staff.

And I can vouch for that staff. Amendment 90 in my name was tabled with the support of the noble lady Baroness Young of Old Scone, the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Manchester, and the noble lady Baroness Coffee. All co-signatories have been long-standing passionate advocates of getting this legislation onto the statute books, and it would be patronising of me to thank them when they have already done so much. And I'm delighted to see the noble lady Baroness Boycott in her place, because she too has been a passionate outspoken advocate of legislation against deforestation. Amendment 90 simply requires regulations under schedule 17 of the Environment Act 2021, which refers to the use of forest risk commodities in commercial activity, to be made within six months of this Act receiving Royal Assent, and would commence the Treasury review into deforestation-linked finance.

My amendment 97A was submitted to come after clause 22 and was in fact accepted by the Public Bill Office. It was only very late in the day yesterday that I learned that it had been moved to after clause 47. So, my lords, my attempt to move it to a possible vote earlier in the day was scuppered, which I admit leaves me a little disappointed. 97A is exactly the same as 90, with the small addition of specifying the FCA as the verification and enforcement agency. And in his response to this amendment, if the Minister feels that the FCA is not the right regulator, where does he think that responsibility lies?

And that is a question to which I would welcome an answer. My lords, these measures are five long years overdue, as the noble lady Baroness Hayman has said, and the prevarication must end, especially now that the EU has agreed its deforestation regulations, and they will be implemented on the 30th of December this year, 2026, and will apply to Northern Ireland. We on the mainland will be operating under different rules. That's an untenable position. The government's announcement in June this year to consult and deliver legislation to align next year isn't really good enough.

We don't know when and we don't know what it will say. Businesses, such as the UK Cocoa Coalition, whose members include Sainsbury's, Waitrose, Ferrero, Hershey and other very big organisations, are calling for certainty to plan investment and growth. A clearer timetable for the UK's forest risk commodities regime would avoid further uncertainty for both businesses and investors.

Companies are already making decisions about supply chain management, traceability systems and compliance processes in response to the EUDR and other international requirements. Greater clarity on the UK's timelines and next steps would support investment, facilitate preparation and provide confidence that the UK is moving towards a coherent and predictable regulatory framework. My Lords, we've been round this particular block a number of times and as Einstein said, it's a sign of madness to do the same thing time and time again and expect a different result. And it won't surprise the Minister if I say that had circumstances been different today, I would have pushed my amendment 90 to a vote. Instead, I hope the Minister will give assurance from the dispatch box that he gets it, that climate and destruction of carbon sinks, i.e. deforestation, are two sides of the same coin.

And if climate is a financial risk, then so too is deforestation and investment decisions will be poorer if these considerations are not taken into account.

01:44:51 - 01:48:05

Speaker 21

My Lords, financial stability is crucial for sustainable growth. It's what allows people and families to plan for their future, to reliably hold savings, pensions, mortgages, and of course it supports businesses to create the jobs on which we depend. In the same way, financial growth and environmental stewardship are interdependent. Growth provides the resources that allow us to invest in new sustainable fuels, clean infrastructure and new ways to tackle the climate crisis. But it goes both ways.

The climate crisis, and many of us now do call it the climate emergency, also threatens financial stability. Increasing extreme weather events may well, as the noble Baroness Hayman has already reminded us, reduce access to insurance for both households and businesses. And again, as we face the prospect that the heatwaves of this summer become the new normal, agricultural assets are already projected to be affected by drought, impacting on our farmers. And yet these risks have a disproportionate impact on the most vulnerable. Financial shocks hit hardest for those who have no savings to fall back on.

Food shortages load further pressure on those who are already going hungry. So my Lords, the amendments in this group seek to recognize that interdependence between a stable environment and stable financial markets and services. We'll hear a bit later Baroness Hayman's amendments that would require financial institutions to develop credible transition plans consistent with the Paris Agreement's 1.5 target, if it's not already too late for that. Prevention is of the utmost importance if we're to stop the worst impacts of global warming before opportunity lapses. But prevention must go hand in hand with preparedness.

As we're already feeling the impact of climate change at home, we must do all that we can to supplement preventative work with measures that allow us to adapt for this changing reality. It was my privilege, I was then the chair of the Church of England's Ethical Investment Advisory Group and deputy chair of the Church Commissioners for England, to be present at the opening of the London Stock Exchange when we launched, with support from FTSE, the first index that was weighted towards environmental issues. These voluntary measures enable those investors who need to track indices to take environmental factors into account. But I doubt many of us here in your Lordships' House today believe that voluntary action alone is going to solve the climate crisis. Amendment 34, to which I've added my name, would, as the noble Baroness has already said, create a responsibility for regulators to consider the effects of climate change in their decision-making, in the same way as they would any other significant financial risk.

That is, my Lords, an important step towards ensuring that our financial institutions are resilient in the face of the growing risks posed by global warming, and that financial services continue to serve the needs of consumers as we pursue prevention on a wider scale. My Lords, if we're not to place the amendments in this group on the face of the bill, will the minister please explain, I know others have already asked this, how the government intends to ensure financial services and markets do not develop without regard to their environmental impact.

01:48:05 - 01:53:33

Barbara Young

My Lords, can I declare my interests as chair of the Forestry Commission and my other environmental interests in the register. I want to speak to amendment 65 and to amendment 90. I've put my name to both of those amendments, and also to the noble lady Baroness Sheehan's amendment 97A. And can I add my thanks to the noble Lord the Minister for the time and care he's taken to engage with noble Lords over our concerns. But all these amendments arise from the same issue, the inordinate length of time it's taking government to come forward and fulfill its commitments which have already been agreed some previous time before.

Others have laid out the reasons for the importance of these amendments in detail and I won't repeat them. But simply to say amendment 65 is already a manifesto commitment that UK financial institutions should be mandated to develop and implement credible transition plans that align with the Paris Agreement. The amendment that has been laid today is very, very gentle. It simply asks for a roadmap within six months of Royal Assent of this bill, and it allows the government plenty of wiggle room to decide how and when and in what manner it would prevent the drifting along that is so at odds with the urgency of the climate change threat. Business and investors need clarity to be able to have confidence and to deliver growth and competitiveness.

As I said, it's a manifesto committee, this summer heat has underlined its importance, the public want action, it has electoral salience, this is a just-do-it moment. Can I call on my noble friend the Minister to restate the government's commitment to the principle and clarify the pace by accepting the amendment or giving some assurance about the timescale to which the government will deliver these transition plan commitments. And now I had a very lovely speech written about amendment 90 to which I'd put my name and amendment 97A in the name of the noble lady Baroness Sheehan, because they were about an even more delayed issue and would bring in a requirement for government to make regulations that were already provided for in the Environment Act 2021, and I stress 2021, five years ago, but still not implemented, to prohibit the importation and use of illegal forestry goods. And we're now in the position where the European Union is bringing forward its deforestation regulations. They're going to come into effect at the end of this year for large and medium companies and during 2027 for micro and small enterprises.

Northern Ireland will be in a position of having to follow these EU regs. The government has said it wants to align rules across GB. And at the time of laying this amendment, I felt that it was reasonable to ask for this to be done and completed within seven months after a five-year delay period and some consultation already having taken place. Because all the while UK financial systems, including public equity and corporate bonds, are funding and fueling climate and biodiversity declines directly. Now at the committee stage, I kind of lost the will to live because the previous minister described all the stages that had to happen and if they didn't stretch into infinity, at least they stretched for several years, I thought a couple of years' worth at least.

And to be honest it's a major international embarrassment for the new government. We led the change internationally for the forest risk commodities action at COP and we persuaded umpteen other countries to sign up. Yet here we are five years later still claiming we want to demonstrate our leading role in green finance yet not delivering this legal commitment that we were a prime actor in. But this afternoon I had a little ray of light. I just want to read to you some excerpts from a letter which I've received from DEFRA ministers about pressing the issue of forest risk commodities forward.

The letter says that we are progressing the policy and legal work needed at pace to deliver the approach in GB. We're developing the consultation material. There's a statutory duty to consult on these regs. Our plan is to consult during autumn. I think autumn's almost here.

We are planning to deliver the legislation required to implement this regime in 2027. At the center of our considerations is the pressing need for us to make rapid progress to address the role that deforestation plays in the climate and nature crises. This summer's extreme heat waves have brought home the urgency of tackling climate change while halting and reversing forest loss is a vital part of that effort. I absolutely welcome this statement from DEFRA that they are moving forward at pace. And I hope that we can hear today from the minister that the Treasury is as one as one with DEFRA and that we can confidently expect the regulations to be implemented during 2027.

Of course once we've got the regulations in place there is a commitment in the legislation that the Treasury will review legal deforestation challenges and the extent of the deforestation issues for the UK including the range of products included. So I do hope we can get assurances from the minister on this issue this afternoon.

01:53:33 - 01:55:50

Rosie Boycott

My Lords I rise to support 97A in the name of Baroness Sheehan but I also absolutely support 34, 55, 65, 91 in this group. And like others have said we're really grateful for the government's support. And actually what Baroness Young just said I think puts a spring in everybody's step that this very very overdue I mean as many people have said this has been going on for five years and why we haven't done it is a puzzle but it does sound like some doors are opening. I think sometimes people get a bit confused about what forest risk commodities actually are. They are beef, palm oil, soy, cocoa and rubber.

On the whole they're ingredients that run right through the ultra-processed food system which is already I'm really pleased to say on behalf of this government getting a lot of action in terms of trying to slow it down. But the facts are nonsensical. For instance beef, the largest driver of tropical deforestation, beef production is responsible for 25% of global land use emissions. But it's estimated that 60% of agricultural land is used for beef production. That includes all the food that is grown for them, the soy, the palm oil etc.

But it is 2% only of global calorie consumption. So that's just one example about why not only is this terrible for the forest, terrible for nature, terrible for the infrastructure of life on which we depend and which is at the moment in a very very fragile condition but it is also nonsensical on many other levels. So I feel very encouraged that this government will set out legislation as well as ways to enforce it because it is extremely difficult enforcing this. There are many companies who will put proudly on their products that they have got non-illegal legal soy. That was something for instance that Unilever always used to trumpet.

But I'm not entirely sure how you do it and I'm very in favor of what the Europeans are now looking at which is saying it's legal and illegal deforestation that should count because we can't afford to cut down any more forest.

01:55:50 - 01:56:21

Speaker 82

Really, there are many things we can't afford to keep doing, but this is one of them. And the El Niño that is brewing up in the Pacific is going to come bursting across the Amazon rainforest, producing heaven knows what in terms of damage to that incredibly precious environmental resource that affects the weather of the entire world. So this legislation cannot come too soon, and I really welcome the government's progress.

01:56:21 - 01:59:23

Natalie Bennett

My Lords, I rise with great pleasure to follow all of the speakers thus far in this group and to support all of these amendments. I haven't attached my name specifically to any of these. Some of the most prominent are fully subscribed, and I left, wanted to leave space for the breadth of that broad subscription, noting particularly amendment 90, which has also been signed by the noble lady Baroness Coffi, not currently in her place. I want to just take a second to reflect on the point where we are at now with this whole bill overall. What we have before us is essentially the same bill that was introduced under a different Prime Minister and a different Chancellor.

I remain astonished that the term, the approach to competitiveness and deregulation that was directed by Rachel Reeves is now being continued, although after hearing the new Chancellor's speech two days ago, I'm somewhat less surprised. But I will particularly reflect on all of the environmental measures here, and we do still have before us essentially the same thing as the bill was under the previous government. And I note that our current Prime Minister in June 2025, when Mayor of Manchester supported the fossil fuel treaty, and when running for the Labour leadership in 2015, said then, Labour under my leadership will never turn our back on our duty to tackle climate change. So all of these amendments are putting the bill back on the track that it should be on, a bill that the track that the government's apparently signed up to. And I'm going to focus just very briefly on amendment 90 and the forest risk commodities, because as with pretty well everyone who's already spoken, we, I think we remember the long wrestle to get not the strong thing we were looking for, but at least the promise of schedule 17 into the Environment Act in 2021.

And there's a real problem here for in terms of members of the public. They heard that fight, they saw that fight, they saw the law put down by the government, and they expect it's going to be delivered. Yet five years later, we still don't have this provision. Now I actually have, having listened very carefully to noble lady Baroness Young of Old Scone, I actually have a constructive suggestion to make, because the timetable coming from Defra suggested that within 12 to 18 months we will finally see the delivery of what was promised in 2021. So it would be very positive if we could hear from the noble Lord the Minister, saying, as I'm sure he will say, that he can't accept amendment 90, but perhaps at third reading the government could table an amendment committing to these regulations in say 18 months' time, which would be a minor adaptation to the amendment put down by the noble lady Baroness Shean and others.

We have the noble lady Baroness Young has that promise, that pledge in a letter.

01:59:23 - 01:59:34

Speaker 83

Let's go a little bit further and put it on the face of the bill.

01:59:34 - 02:01:46

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, we have a lot to cover today, so I'll be brief. We don't believe that imposing additional reporting duties, transition plan requirements, and regulatory processes on financial services firms is the right way to address the concerns that have been addressed in these amendments and this evening. One of the merits of this bill is the way it cuts out needless and repetitive operational requirements on financial services firms and regulators, and instead introduces a more effective approach based on five-year strategies. As we've heard on Monday, stakeholders' views will be sought in the course of establishing those strategies. Now, of course, climate change and environmental objectives already remain an important statutory regulatory principle, which are intended to contribute to the UK's net zero target under the Climate Change Act and to the environmental targets established under the Environment Act.

However, requiring banks and other financial institutions and the regulators themselves to fill in forms, tick boxes, and produce more and more reports about climate change will not have a meaningful effect on global temperatures. It will simply add costs. We need a regulatory environment which supports growth, enterprise, and investment, and that means cutting down on the red tape and extra requirements that are putting our international competitiveness at risk. These amendments would add a further layer of process and obligation without a sufficiently clear demonstration that the burdens would advance the environmental objectives being pursued. This is a time when we should be seeking to streamline regulations, be careful about new requirements, however well-intentioned, because of the need to get the economic growth that we lack.

I think these amendments risk taking us a step backwards, so we can't support them and we'll be voting against them if noble Lords press them to a vote.

02:01:46 - 02:10:38

David Pitt

My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Baroness Hayman for these amendments and for the wider debate on sustainable finance and adapting to climate change. These amendments address a number of important issues: climate transition planning, tackling deforestation, how the regulators consider climate risk, the products commonly known as green mortgages. As several noble Lords have argued today, both climate-related risks and nature-related risks can have significant implications for the economy, for financial markets and their ability to deliver for customers, and for long-term prosperity. As many of you may know, it's a topic close to my heart, including through my past chairing of the United Nations Environment Programme's Finance Initiative at the Paris climate talks. UNEP FI is a voluntary organization of over 500 financial organizations from the north and the south, with over 100 trillion pounds funds under management.

It's established some of the world's foremost sustainability frameworks for finance, including involvement with the REDD project, reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation, which I believe is now preserving many millions of square miles of forest. I share the underlying objectives behind these amendments. The question before us is therefore not whether action is needed, but how best to deliver that action in a way that's effective and proportionate and aligns with the wider framework we're putting in place. Let me come to amendments 34 and 55, which raise important points regarding how the regulators consider and report on climate and environmental-related issues. I have spoken to Baroness Hayman and members of the Peers for the Planet throughout the week on this important issue.

I also hosted a drop-in session for peers with the FCA. During that session I heard a number of concerns about the absence of climate and environmental targets have regard operating at a day-to-day level. And I have of course heard the issues raised in this debate today. While I still believe there is significant value in streamlining the regulators' have regards, I appreciate it is important that the regulators continue to focus on the vital issue of the sector's contribution to climate change at a day-to-day level, and I appreciate the importance of regular reporting on this issue to aid parliamentary scrutiny. While I cannot do anything today, I am prepared to return to this issue at third reading and would be prepared and undertake to table amendments to clause 17 which would require the PRA and FCA to continue to consider their existing climate change and environmental targets have regard at a day-to-day level and to maintain appropriate notification and reporting requirements.

Amendments 34 and 35 introduce a new have regard and reporting requirements on climate-related financial stability issues. I therefore ask noble Baroness, Baroness Northover and Baroness Hayman not to press amendments 34 and 35 on that basis, and I will return at third reading with the amendments I have described. Let me now turn to amendment 65 on transition plan requirements. The government remains committed to this area. We consulted in 2025 on options for implementing transition plan requirements and are considering responses alongside wider work on sustainability and corporate reporting reform.

In February we finalized the UK sustainability reporting standards for voluntary use. The FCA has also consulted on aligning listed company disclosure requirement with these standards. The FCA aims to publish final rules this autumn with requirements expected to take effect from January 2027. This amendment would place on a statutory a statutory timetable on an area where policy development remains under active consideration across government. We believe in the importance of finalizing this work before imposing an arbitrary roadmap.

Let me turn to amendments 90 and 97A. I recognize the strength of feeling on the issue of deforestation and I agree that urgent action is needed. I am therefore pleased to report that this work is moving forward. As Baroness Young said, Defra have confirmed that they will consult later this year on Great Britain's approach to tackling deforestation in domestic supply chains and the next steps for forest risk commodities regime for the forest risk commodities regime. My officials have spoken to Defra who have confirmed that they plan to consult during the autumn and that legislation will be delivered in 2027.

The responsibility for enforcing the regime will be determined by Defra when they design the regulations, but we share the objective of progress as quickly as possible.

However, a six-month statutory deadline risks prioritizing speed over effectiveness. The government believes the better approach is to ensure any resulting regime is robust, proportionate, and capable of decoupling supply chains from global deforestation. The government has also already committed through the Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 to review the regulatory framework for tackling deforestation-linked finance within nine months of DEFRA's legislation on domestic supply chains. Further, the principle that I committed to reapply to day-to-day activities also explicitly covers consideration of environmental targets in the Environment Act 2021, and so this will remain part of the regulator's day-to-day work. Turning to amendment 91, the government supports high-quality green mortgage products that can help households to finance energy efficiency improvements and improve resilience to climate-related risks.

However, the amendment risks duplicating efforts by regulators, departments, and existing frameworks. FCA rules already require clear disclosure, and the FCA is considering disclosure further through its mortgage rule review. The Green Home Finance Strategic Partnership also has a dedicated working group focused on consumer protection and standards. With over 90 green mortgage products now available compared with fewer than 10 in 2019, the government considers that imposing a statutory timetable would be premature while policy and the market continue to develop. The current approach provides the flexibility to develop clear, proportionate standards while maintaining consumer protections.

In conclusion, the government supports the objectives that sit behind these amendments. Indeed, we have listened to the House and will, for third reading, table amendments to clause 17, which would require the PRA and FCA to continue to consider their existing climate change and environmental targets have regard at a day-to-day level and to maintain appropriate notification and reporting requirements. More broadly, we support credible transition planning. We support action to address deforestation and forest risk commodities. And we support the development of high-quality green mortgages, and the government is already taking forward substantial work in these areas and will continue to do so in a coordinated and proportionate way.

I therefore ask the noble baroness to withdraw the amendment.

02:10:38 - 02:12:58

Lindsay Northover

My Lords, I thank the noble lord the minister for his very encouraging reply. I think that we are in agreement that there couldn't be a more important area. No one paid attention to the subprime market, and then we had the 2008 crash, and the economic and social costs are still with us a generation later. Incomes stalled, politics driven left and right and causing further economic and social damage. So we know the risks of not paying attention to the risks to financial stability.

And I'm afraid I do not accept what the noble lady Baroness Neville-Rolfe says, and I regret the loss of cross-party agreement in this area.

But of course, beyond those risks, what is even more important is to address climate change and nature loss, and the noble lord the minister acknowledged that. That is an existential crisis, and we increasingly see the reality of that. And I noted with interest his history, and I remember the commitment that Mark Carney made, and how he said that he thought others were doing this, others were addressing this, and he realized that that wasn't the case and that he needed to address this, and he led the move, particularly at Glasgow and in the financial sector, in the way that the minister has just described. So I am encouraged by what the minister has said that he will bring forward at third reading, and I trust what the noble lady Baroness Hayman has said in relation to the conversations she's had with the minister and about his commitment. He's made this commitment for third reading, and I look forward to seeing how that is to be delivered, and that he clearly is very much involved in this, and so therefore I take what he says at face value and look forward to seeing that, and on the basis of that, withdraw my amendment.

02:12:58 - 02:13:08

Sheila Noakes

Is it your lordship's pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 35, Baroness Bowles.

02:13:08 - 02:19:26

Sharon Bowles

My lords. As discussed on Monday, we have received constructive letters from the chief executives of the FCA and the PRA. They show genuine willingness to engage, and they elaborate on transparency of activity, that is consultations, responses, reports, strategies, and evaluations. And I do not dispute any of that. And the government amendments that are proposed now restore proportionality as an operational day-to-day have regard, and thus they cover my proportionality requests during committee and those parts of my amendments that I speak to today.

But unfortunately, the bill still relegates the transparency have regard to the long-term strategy report. And that provokes me to articulate something that has not been said clearly before. Parliament cannot check proportionality unless it can see it. And indeed, the select committee tried to do exactly that during our inquiry into the competitiveness and growth. And that is why transparency of reasoning is an integral part of cost-benefit analysis and proportionality.

So today, I ask the minister to confirm that this is understood and that it applies at the operational level under the proportionality requirements. To be clear, what I am talking about here is the transparency of the cost-benefit analyses. Now internationally, this is well understood. In the United States, the SEC publishes an economic analysis with major SEC rulemaking, setting out costs, benefits, distributional impacts, and alternatives all considered.

And that allows Congress and the courts to scrutinize it. They show their working in detail. In the European system, the ESAs publish impact assessments showing how burdens fall on small versus large firms and how rules were adjusted to reflect proportionality concerns. A lot more specificity than we get. Again, they show their working.

And we simply don't get that level of working shown. So our regulators are not top of the class by international standards. And while I note the letter on cost-benefit analysis from Nikhil Rathi, the CEO of the FCA, that the minister has recirculated to members today, the frequency and working detail of them is just not as much as elsewhere. The FCA have also denied a statutory requirement to do that and have been criticized for insufficient workings by their own cost-benefit analysis panel. For example, in CP 24/30, which is on changes to the safeguarding regime for payments and e-money firms in September 2024, the panel said, "The CBA does not include analysis of how sensitive its results are to variations in its main assumptions and estimates."

So that's not very helpful if you're trying to understand them. The panel went on to say that this was important in identifying which assumptions were critical to the expected costs and benefits. Now, the FCA did accept the criticism and went back and added sensitivity analysis covering different compliance levels and insolvency rates. But the fact is, they resisted it, including the objection to the fact that they hadn't to do it by statute, and it wasn't their first instinct. So I think that that is a very good example that we need to have a lot more transparency around the cost-benefit analysis.

And I think that that is hindered by this demotion of transparency to just being looked at at the strategic level. And as the minister has already recognized and shown willing to make changes to clause 17, I ask that he thinks about this one seriously and whether in fact he has to do something about transparency. And in any event, going forward, I challenge the regulators to deliver on the detail of proportionality with full reasoning, working, and concrete examples, showing how burdens were weighed, alternatives considered, and adjustments made. After all, it's what government departments are required to do for significant regulatory proposals, but which our regulators do not follow. I hope that the regulators will step up and do this.

I hope that the minister will step up and put it in its rightful place back in clause 17. And I expect the select committee will also want to pursue this. But quite frankly, this legislation is leaving an awful lot of heavy lifting to the select committee.

02:19:26 - 02:19:30

Speaker 86

I beg to move.

02:19:30 - 02:21:18

Sheila Noakes

My Lords, amendment 35 in clause 17, page 21, line 34, after duties, insert the words printed on the Marshall list. Amendments 36, 39, and 42 in this group, and I thank my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe for adding her name. My amendments sought to achieve through slightly different drafting what the noble Baroness Lady Bowles of Berkhamsted sought with her amendments 35 and 41. In my view, proportionality is the most important of the regulatory principles, and we try to elevate it above the other regulatory principles. Now, I regret the downgrading of regulatory principles in general under clause 17, but I am glad that the government have recognized that they went too far on proportionality and have amendments in this group effectively preserving the status quo for proportionality.

We've not achieved an upgrading of proportionality in the regulatory hierarchy, but we have at least protected it from being downgraded. As my noble friend, as the noble Baroness Lady Bowles of Berkhamsted said a moment ago, the Financial Services Regulation Committee will now have to bear some of the burden. We will need to make sure that the regulators do not ignore the other important regulatory principles. Noble Baroness Lady Bowles mentioned transparency, and I agree with her in that. I would also single out the principle that consumers need to take responsibility for their own decisions.

The committee will certainly call out the regulators if necessary.

02:21:18 - 02:25:49

Natalie Bennett

My Lords, I rise in the interest of time just to focus on my amendment 38, which appears in this group, which retains the need to have regard to regulatory principles, which has already been broadly discussed, but I'll focus on the way in which it specifies the need to have regard to financial crime related to organized environmental crimes. I must, however, take a second to welcome the comments and commitments from the government front bench to bring in some climate components to the bill, to bring them back into the law at third reading. It's always good to celebrate when campaigning works, and I think we can all hope to reach a time when we don't have to do campaigning on such environmental basics. But I spoke extensively at committee about the issues around financial crime related to organized environmental crimes, and I won't repeat what I said then, but I and other careful observers were not satisfied with the minister's response there at committee. The response from the noble Lord the minister then was extremely general.

The response was that financial crime and money laundering, whether related to environmental crimes or not, is illegal and something that financial regulators and this government take extremely seriously. The FCA has a broad remit to tackle financial crime. That was a very general response that didn't address the specific concern about environmental crime and the way in which many other jurisdictions are taking actions in this area. And I acknowledge the support I've received in preparing this response from WWF and refer to a WWF and Themis survey of 644 financial service professionals from 17 countries, which found almost half of the financial institutions sampled operated in high-risk sectors or area for environmental-financial crime.

Yet over a quarter said they did not undertake specific related due diligence. Additionally, 60% of financial institutions surveyed had no land conversion risk policy in place. A 2025 survey by financial investigations unit of financial investigations unit by the Egmont Group identified a lack of alignment of environmental laws with anti-money laundering and anti-terrorist financing standards and a limitation on their ability to share data or conduct specific activities related to environmental crimes as regulatory constraints. Without explicit recognition of this through the regulatory principles of the FCA and PRA, relevant actors are not required or equipped to respond with the necessary action. Indeed, the above-mentioned survey respondent said that self-regulation is not a sufficient driver of change when it comes to land conversion and called it, quote, optimistic to think financial institutions would commit to affirmative action with just voluntary frameworks in place.

And I note that around the world, the FATF, try that again, FATF recognizes environmental crimes as predicate offenses for money laundering. The European Union has strengthened its criminal law framework through an environmental crime directive, requiring member states to publish a national strategy on combating environmental crime offenses by 2027. And just as an example from the global south, Zambia's economic and financial crimes division of the High Court recently forfeited to the state a vast array of assets associated with a major illegal lobbing operation. Diplomatic momentum for the fourth protocol under the UN Convention against Transnational Organized Crime to address crimes against the environment is also advancing with support from the UK. That's what we're saying internationally.

What are we doing domestically? As a global financial setter, the UK has a specific responsibility to ensure that it is taking effective action against environmental crimes globally and against any involvement of our financial sector in those crimes and can play an important role in achieving a stronger global approach.

02:25:49 - 02:28:38

Jason Stockwood

My Lords, it's a privilege to make my first contribution as a backbench member of this of this House in a slightly more relaxed environment than the last time I spoke on clause 17 in the Moses Room. Indeed, I'm told that some of the color's started to return to my face, which is entirely due to the recess, but rather than having to face off against the rather formidable experience across the House. Having spent a considerable amount of time defending clause 17 before the summer, I want to say a few words about this group and particular amendment 37. I argued then and continue to believe that the basic architecture of clause 17 is right. We need regulators capable of exercising expert judgment and we should also be cautious about responding to every legitimate concern by adding another statutory duty or layer of prescription.

But I also heard very clearly the arguments made across the committee that greater regulatory discretion must be accompanied by proportionality and meaningful parliamentary accountability. That is why I welcome the direction of these amendments. They reflect the concerns that were raised repeatedly before the summer whilst preserving the regulators' ability to exercise judgment. Amendment 37 is particularly important because there is a practical problem underneath the question of accountability. Parliament is scrutinizing institutions such as the FCA, PRA, and Bank of England with enormous analytical policy and research resources.

And by comparison, even the Financial Services Regulation Committee operates with a very small team across an extraordinarily broad agenda, and that imbalance does matter and we heard that. Better accountability cannot simply mean regulators producing more information, and Parliament must be able to interrogate that information, track what regulators have previously said and promised, and challenge them when the evidence does not match the rhetoric.

I have written to the noble Baroness Lady Noakes offering some practical help, including exploring whether new analytical tools and AI using publicly available information could help narrow that resource gap and do some of the analytical heavy lifting for the committee. Technology, just to be clear, will not replace the judgment of those members or the expertise of the committee staff, but it can potentially make the judgment better informed. But there is also a broader lesson in this group. One thing I learned during those six sittings of committee is that scrutiny works best when government is prepared to listen. There may have been moments when I appeared rather detached, rather attached rather, to the drafting in front of me, which may be putting it mildly, but the purpose of this House is not simply to test the minister's powers of endurance, although sometimes it felt like that, it is to improve legislation.

I think the group demonstrates that process working well. The government has listened without abandoning the principles of the bill, and the House has helped strengthen the framework around proportionality and accountability. I particularly welcome amendment 37 and support the approach represented by this group.

02:28:38 - 02:29:38

Anthony Vaux

My Lords, whilst they don't go quite as far as I would have preferred, I do welcome the government amendments that will bring the essential regulatory principle of proportionality back into the discharge of the regulators' general functions. I think it's a reasonable compromise to have met. I've added my name to the noble lady Baroness Neville-Rolfe's amendment 62, which emphasizes the particular importance of proportionality to small and medium-sized enterprises, where the regulatory burden can have a much greater impact than for large companies with dedicated compliance departments. I raised this on Monday in relation to the concern that the transfer of AML supervision to the FCA might disproportionately impact smaller firms. So I very much hope the noble lord the minister will be able to say something that will give us comfort that the regulators will take size as well as other factors into consideration when deciding what is proportionate regulation and supervision.

02:29:38 - 02:31:27

Barbara Young

My Lords, can I welcome the statement that was made by my noble friend the minister in saying he was committed to bringing forward amendments at third reading? I think it's very relevant to this group of amendments, and I simply want to just draw the House's attention to two sessions we have had with the FCA in the last three or four days. The minister very kindly organized a session with the FCA about their role in climate and environment, and to be honest, I think the kindest thing I could say was that I was underwhelmed. I mean, I think they have a lot more that they are doing than they displayed on that day, and the defensiveness that they demonstrated in front of a bunch of really friendly and helpful and not at all terrifying baronesses was a bit of a worry to me, to be honest, because I just felt that there was a real defensiveness and pushback against a responsibility. But I thought perhaps we'd just given them a hard time and they were having a bad day.

But we had another session with them yesterday, which Peers for the Planet organized, and I was horrified, and I've got it written down here because I wrote it down and I went home and wept. A fairly senior representative of the FCA said, absolutely in terms, the FCA does not have a mandate to tell businesses what they should do on climate and environment. And I would just like, A, the House to know that, and B, for the minister to bear that in mind when he's coming forward with his third reading amendments, because I think there is a real need for a stronger line in guidance than we might otherwise have imagined.

02:31:27 - 02:34:55

Susan Kramer

My Lords, that at I think fairly on in the committee stage, I said to Lord Stockwell that who was then obviously in charge of bringing the bill through, that when there was a common opinion held by Baroness Noakes, Baroness Bowles and Lord Forsythe, that he ought to listen. These are the three real experts that we have in the House on markets, on regulation and on the financial services industry. And all of them set aside political ideology when they're coming forward with recommendations, look to the common good and look to the well-functioning both for markets and for consumers. So I am very glad that on proportionality, which of all the issues was the most serious that in the sort of downgrading of principles, quite frankly, that that the minister is will has now amended or is now amending that. And I'm also very appreciative that there's going to be movement on climate change because as colleagues have said, that this is a crisis that is on our doorstep and we have no choice but to act and it means we need to focus all strengths on dealing with that crisis.

I am very conscious of the impact of financial stability and how it crept up on us because we only looked at through a very narrow lens instead of looking across the piece and recognizing how holistic and how interconnected so many issues are. My Lords, I have amendment 67 in this group, which is why I'm standing on my feet. I have to confess it's kind of an odd place for 67 and I'm going to deal with it very briefly. But 67 arose because a number of banks have been refusing to take small businesses and SMEs generally in the defense industry as their customers, usually because they're concerned about reputational risk. And this has made it very difficult for these SMEs to raise credit and it is seriously undermining the UK's plans to build up its defense forces, which I think we'd all agree is not acceptable.

That some members may not be aware, but the most innovative defense firms are SMEs. It's not just the big players, it's the SMEs that are critical, particularly at a time when so much is changing in the strategic and defense sector. So these small SMEs already face high regulatory hurdles. They often face slow procurement processes when they work with the Department of Defense. But the absolute killer blow is not to be able to finance the projects, no matter the quality of the contract that they have.

Now the FCA has said that its rules present no obstacle to lending to SMEs and considers that to be a green light. It's not having very much impact. My amendment essentially attempts to put some welly behind the FCA in dealing with these issues and would require it to conduct and publish a review at least once every three years, including identifying any barriers. And I would have thought that a report like that might get the government going as well. I know the government is aware of the problem, but can I just emphasize, knowing about it isn't enough, it actually needs to act and to change minds.

02:34:55 - 02:37:48

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, we welcome the government's decision to retain proportionality as an express statutory consideration for both the FCA and the PRA when they exercise their general functions. This responds to productive discussions in and outside committee for which I thank the minister and indeed the noble Lord, Lord Stockwell, who I'm delighted welcome to welcome back to discussion of the bill and thank him for his efforts to improve it. I also thank my noble friend Lady Noakes and the noble lady Lady Bowles and Lord Forsythe for their constructive and very flexible approach to the substantial problems on these clauses.

Now time and again, one of the concerns we hear from business is that regulation can be disproportionate to the risk it's intended to address. And that is particularly true for the small and medium-sized firms we rely on so heavily for competition, innovation, and economic growth right across this country. The proportionality changes help to address this. And we will not therefore be pressing our amendment 62 on SMEs to a vote, even though it is my favorite amendment and I have the support of the noble lord Lord Vaux. And I think the noble lady Kramer is right to focus on lending to small defense companies as well.

The requirement for the FCA and PRA to explain in their annual reports how they've taken these proportionality principles into account, alongside the requirements relating to consultation and parliamentary committees, create an important mechanism through which Parliament can examine whether the principle is actually being applied in practice, with concrete examples as the noble lady Bowles suggested. This is important because the ultimate test of these amendments will not simply be whether the word proportionality appears in statute, it will be whether firms see a genuine difference in the way regulation is developed and applied, particularly by the regulators. We hope that the government's amendments will prove to be a meaningful mechanism through which regulation can become easier to comply with, less costly, and ultimately more successful in achieving the objectives Parliament has set for the regulators. And of course the proof will be in their implementation. The government have listened to concerns raised during the passage of the bill and we support the amendments the noble lord the minister has moved in response.

This is good House of Lords practice. Like my noble friend Lady Noakes, I do not intend to pursue the other amendments today.

02:37:48 - 02:43:16

David Pitt

My lords, thank you for this debate. I hope it does demonstrate that the government has listened carefully to the arguments made by noble lords during committee debates and recognizes the strength of feeling and the logic around addressing clause 17. In committee, noble lords made clear they had concerns with that clause, which removes the requirements to consider regulatory principles each time they exercise a general function in favor of considering them just at a strategic level. But these points were particularly strongly made with regard to proportionality and in response we have tabled amendments 37 and 43 in my name. These amendments ensure the two proportionality regulatory principles will continue to apply to the regulators' day-to-day actions.

There was also a rich debate at committee about the different facets of proportionality and the factors that the regulator should consider. Here again, I think the government has listened. Amendment 44 makes changes to the existing principles to explicitly include that the regulator should recognize the differing abilities of firms to engage and comply with regulation owing to their size, a point raised both by the noble baroness Neville-Rolfe and by the noble lord Lord Vaux. This means that regulators will need to consider the specific impact of their proposal on SMEs.

It was also clear that a number of noble Lords had concerns about the possible effects of clause 17 on Parliament's ability to effectively scrutinize the regulators. In response, amendments 40 and 46 to 50 ensure that existing reporting requirements on the proportionality regulatory principles will remain in place, including as part of the consultation on annual reports. So the government is retaining the majority of existing transparency and reporting requirements, including through panel reports, consultation requirements, and annual reports. In their letters to me, which have been shared with interested members and laid in the library, both the regulators set out details of their approach to delivering proportionality. They also commit to ongoing engagement with the parliamentary committees on their approach, and I am deeply grateful to the noble Baroness Noakes for saying that as chair of the committee she will take up this challenge.

But I'd also like particularly to recognize the generous offer made by my noble friend Lord Stockwood to use his expertise in artificial intelligence to support Baroness Noakes and the Financial Services Regulation Committee and the Treasury Select Committee in their work to scrutinize the work of the regulators. It just feels to me like an offer that is made in the spirit of consensus and team working about what it is that we would like to do here. So the government is grateful to noble Lords for the careful attention they paid to this matter and is confident that these amendments will support effective scrutiny and target regulator reporting more meaningfully at the issues Parliament cares most about. Let me then turn to the non-government amendments 35, 36, 39, 41, 42, 45, 62, 67, and 69. I hope I have demonstrated that the government is taking action to ensure that proportionality does remain a central consideration in the framework and that the framework supports SMEs of all types and that these amendments are therefore not required.

With regard to amendment 38 concerning financial crime related to organized environmental crimes, the FCA already has a broad remit and the power it needs to tackle all financial crime. My Lords, I hope I have demonstrated that the government has listened carefully to the strong feeling from across the House about the need to ensure that the regulators exercise their power in a way that is responsive to the differences between firms and business models. I'm grateful to all those present for the focus that they have brought to this issue.

02:43:16 - 02:44:32

Sharon Bowles

My Lords, thank you very much for the reply to the debate that we had from the Minister, and I recognize the movement that he has indicated.

I did ask him to say something about transparency, which was, I'm afraid, absent from what he said just then. He talked about proportionality, but I was talking about the linkage between transparency and proportionality, and that with transparency still languishing at strategy level, I was not sure whether we were going to get adequate transparency over things like cost-benefit, which are part of proportionality. I know that's a little bit convoluted, and I won't pursue it any further here, but I would be very grateful to have a meeting with the minister before we get to third reading, because if he's going to be addressing points about clause 17, then we should at least cross-check whether there's anything relevant in that too. But for now, I do beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

02:44:32 - 02:47:01

Sheila Noakes

Is it your pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 36, Baroness Noakes, not moved. Amendment 37, Lord Pitt-Watson, moved formally. The question is that amendment 37 be agreed to.

As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment 38, Baroness Bennett, not moved. Amendment 39, Baroness Noakes, not moved.

Amendment 40, Lord Pitt-Watson, amendment moved formally. The question is that amendment 40 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.

Amendment 41, Baroness Bowles, not moved. Amendment 42, Baroness Noakes, not moved. Amendment 43 and amendment 44 moved en bloc, moved formally en bloc. The question is that amendment 43 and amendment 44 be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment 46 to amendment 50... sorry, 45, many apologies, my Lords. Amendment 45, Lord Holmes, not moved. Apologies.

Amendment 46 to amendment 50 moved formally en bloc. The question is that amendment 46 to amendment 50 be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.

Amendment 51, Baroness Bowles, not moved. Amendment 52, Baroness Noakes, not moved. Amendment 53, Baroness Noakes, not moved. Amendment 54, Baroness Bowles, not moved. Amendment 55, Baroness Hayman, not moved.

Amendment 56, Baroness Bowles, not moved. Amendment 57, Lord Holmes, not moved. Amendment 58 and amendment 59 moved formally en bloc, Lord Pitt-Watson. The question is that amendment 58 and 59 be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

To the contrary, not content. The contents have it. Amendment 60, Baroness Kramer.

02:47:01 - 02:47:04

Speaker 91

Moved formally as a decision of the House.

02:47:04 - 02:47:08

Speaker 90

Moved formally. The question is that amendment 60 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

02:47:41 - 02:47:45

Speaker 93

Amendment 60, Baroness Kramer.

02:47:45 - 02:47:54

Speaker 92

Moved formally.

02:47:54 - 02:51:34

Speaker 93

The question is that amendment 60 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The question will be decided by a division. House when voting is open.

Order. Voting is now open, clear the bar.

02:51:34 - 02:51:57

Speaker 94

The question is that amendment 60 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary not content. The... turn the page. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the non-contents to the left by the bar.

02:59:02 - 02:59:39

George Young

My Lords, there have voted contents 248, not contents 163, so the contents have it.

Amendment 61, Baroness Tyler, not moved. Amendment 62, Baroness Neville-Rolfe, not moved. We come now to amendment 63, Baroness Bowles of Berkhamsted.

02:59:39 - 03:03:28

Sharon Bowles

My Lords, I declare my interest as chair of the ownership dividend inquiry into employee ownership and also as a director of Veloop Holdings Limited. Amendments 63 and 66 address a structural flaw in financing employee ownership, cooperative and mutual transitions, a problem sharpened by recent tax changes and incoming Basel prudential rules. Amendment 64 concerns the systemic misuse of section 166 investigations. In the interest of time, I have not split this rather diverse group. Amendments 63 and 66 do not mandate outcomes.

They simply require regulators to consider a distinct exposure class and review lending to these entities. The PRA already possesses the power to do this, just as it has for infrastructure. But this asset class is too niche to attract regular focus without a push, so this is my push. The government's manifesto commits to doubling the cooperative and mutual sector. Yet reducing capital gains tax relief for employee ownership trusts has already drastically reduced conversions.

And Basel 3.1 compounds the damage. Removing the SME supporting factor increases risk weights under the standardized approach used by challenger banks, the very lenders willing to finance these transitions. The large IRB banks could theoretically model lower charges, but generally won't incur the cost for such a small market. The result is clear: funding these transitions will become harder, if not impossible. Yet these business models carry lower default rates, higher survival rates and greater economic resilience.

These are prudentially relevant characteristics that justify differentiated treatment, just like infrastructure, green mortgage or project finance does. Recognizing this profile is cost-neutral, Basel-compliant and entirely within existing regulatory powers. And without it, I suspect the government's own policy commitments will fail. Turning now to amendment 64. Section 166 powers were designed for serious exceptional concerns, allowing regulators to appoint a skilled person, typically an expensive consulting firm, to investigate a business.

As the noble Lord, Lord Altrincham and I set out in committee, section 166 has suffered severe mission creep. It now seems used routinely, disproportionately and beyond its intended scope. These reviews impose high costs, disruption and management distraction on firms, often for issues that supervision could and should handle. My amendment restores the original statutory boundary. It ensures section 166 is deployed only where there is material risk of detriment to regulatory outcomes and where its use is strictly proportionate, having regard to the burden on the firm and whether normal supervisory tools would suffice.

This House must signal that regulators cannot delegate routine supervision to high-priced firms at the expense of regulated businesses.

And I do intend to seek the opinion of the House. I beg to move.

03:03:28 - 03:03:37

George Young

Amendment proposed, after clause 22 insert the following new clause as printed on the Marshalled List.

03:03:37 - 03:05:23

Edward Altrincham

I thank the noble Lord the Minister for hosting this second day of report with such grace. And I want to focus my remarks on amendment 64, to which I have added my name. I'm very grateful to the noble Baroness Lady Bowles of Berkhamsted for bringing this important issue before the House again. Section 166 review is the name given to FCA investigations. These investigations were originally quite rare, but there are now dozens of these launched every year and they are paid for by the target firms.

These investigations are expensive and time-consuming. They can have a rather arbitrary regulatory purpose and are somewhat unconstrained. This regulatory power can be exercised without a statutory threshold requiring the regulator first to demonstrate that the matter is sufficiently serious and that using this particular tool is proportionate. We hear consistently from firms that section 166 reviews are increasingly becoming the norm rather than the exception. Without a degree of restraint or oversight, these powers may create regulatory uncertainty.

Our amendment would not prevent the regulators from acting where there is a serious problem, nor would it remove section 166 from their toolkit. It would simply mean that such a costly and burdensome power is used proportionately where it is genuinely warranted. I very much hope the Minister will accept the amendment, but if the noble Baroness Lady Bowles decides to test the opinion of the House as she has indicated, we will support her.

03:05:23 - 03:10:28

David Pitt

My Lords, this group raises two important but distinct questions: how the prudential framework should treat lending that supports employee ownership cooperatives and mutuals, and when regulators should use skilled person reviews under section 166 of FSMA. The government has carefully considered the case made for each amendment but doesn't believe that these changes should be made through legislation. Let me begin with amendment 63 and 66, which seek to create a bespoke prudential framework for lending to cooperative and mutuals, including through lower risk weights. The government recognizes the valuable contribution that cooperatives and mutuals make to the UK economy and is undertaking a multi-year program of work to support the growth of the sector. This includes making amendments to the Building Societies Act 1986, which we debated last week, to align it with company law and give societies greater funding flexibility.

However, prudential capital requirements should reflect the underlying risk of a lending activity rather than the ownership structure of the lender. Prudential requirements are generally set by the Prudential Regulation Authority through its rules rather than being prescribed in legislation. This allows the framework to respond to evolving risks and market developments while operating within a statutory framework established by Parliament. The Prudential Regulation Authority has clear statutory objectives and is accountable to Parliament for the exercise of its functions. It's therefore the appropriate body to assess risk characteristics and determine the appropriate prudential treatment of different exposures.

The government therefore does not consider it appropriate to prescribe preferential prudential treatment for particular business models through legislation. Such decisions should remain matters for the independent Prudential Regulation Authority, and for these reasons I'm unable to support these amendments.

Turning to amendment 64 concerning section 166 skilled person reviews, I agree these reviews should be commissioned only where appropriate and proportionate. However, the government is not persuaded that a further statutory threshold is necessary. As we discussed in committee, regulators already consider the circumstances of the firm, the costs involved, and the availability of alternative supervisory tools before commissioning a skilled person's review. The FCA and PRA have established supervisory processes for doing so. Requiring the regulators to satisfy an additional statutory test could delay supervisory action and make it harder to intervene before problems occur that could damage the interests of consumers or affect the functioning of markets.

I know a concern has been raised about there being more and more section 166 reviews, and I'd like to reassure my Lords that the FCA's use of skilled person reviews has been broadly consistent over the past 10 years. Indeed, in 2025 to 2026, 31 were commissioned, which is the second lowest usage since 2016. In their letters to me, which have been shared with interested members, and I'm happy to send those figures to members if they're interested, but in their letters to me, which have been shared with interested members and laid in the library, both regulators set out details of their approach to delivering proportionality, with the FCA explaining how its approach to supervision is proportionate, risk-based, and targeted. They also commit to ongoing engagement with parliamentary committees on their approach. I hope this reassures the noble lady about the process and proportionality of section 166 reviews, and therefore ask the noble lady to withdraw her amendments.

My Lords, I thank Lord Altrincham for supporting my section 166 amendment. With regard to my amendments 63 and 66, the government has interpreted exactly as I said it wasn't. I said it is not telling the PRA what to do. It was asking them to consider a prudential distinction, but I didn't tell them what to do with it. So, of course, they have that power anyway, and the purpose of this amendment was to draw attention to a very important sector, and I'll take the measure up with the PRA directly.

So, for now, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

03:10:28 - 03:10:37

George Young

Is it your Lordship's pleasure that amendment 63 be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 64, Baroness Bowles.

03:10:37 - 03:10:39

Sharon Bowles

I do wish to test the opinion of the house.

03:10:39 - 03:14:53

George Young

The question is that amendment 64 be agreed to. As many of that opinion say content. Contrary, not content. The question will be decided by a division. I will notify the house when voting is open.

Voting is now open. Clear the bar.

The question is that amendment 64B be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.

03:19:44 - 03:19:46

Speaker 99

Order.

03:19:46 - 03:22:11

Speaker 103

The question is that amendment 64 be agreed to. My Lords, the House have voted contents 226, not contents 162, so the contents have it. Amendment 65, Baroness Hayman, not moved. Amendment 66, Baroness Bowles, not moved. Amendment 67, Baroness Kramer, not moved.

Amendment 68, Baroness Noakes, not moved. Amendment 69, Lord Ashcombe, not moved. Amendment 70, Lord McKinley, not moved. We come now to amendment 71, Lord Holmes of Richmond.

03:22:11 - 03:24:42

Lord Holmes of Richmond

My Lords, I rise to move amendment 71 in my name and to speak to the other amendments in this group, which I support. My Lords, there are two critical threads running through this bill. I say running through the bill, in reality they are two critical threads that don't appear at all in this bill. Those are all things digital finance and artificial intelligence. Be it embedded finance, open finance, digital assets, stablecoins, CBDCs, or the whole subject of AI and how it's currently transforming all things across consumer, retail, wholesale, and financial markets right around the world.

You could be forgiven for not appreciating this if you just looked at the contents of this bill to see the impact that these forces are already having. And when it comes to digital assets, or indeed AI, there are many elements clear and present requiring primary legislation.

We have this current Financial Services and Markets Bill in front of us, and yet it is silent on all of these issues. We have the excellent report of the Digital Markets Taskforce, the great work so far of Chris Woolard, and indeed the report of Mark Austin, all having elements within it already at this stage requiring primary legislation, and yet nothing in this bill to say of those subjects. My Lords, I believe the UK has an extraordinary, a unique opportunity when it comes to both digital assets, stablecoins, tokenization, market D-MAT, and artificial intelligence. But we require the primary legislation and indeed the attendant regulatory framework not just to give effect to that and to enable that innovation and that economic growth that would come, but to give the signal from government as to the direction that they want the UK to go when it comes to all of these extraordinary, transformational, growth-creating economic opportunities. I look forward to the Minister's response.

I beg to move.

03:24:42 - 03:24:51

George Young

Amendment proposed, after Clause 22, insert the following new clause as printed on the marshalled list.

03:24:51 - 03:28:56

The Lord Ranger of Northwood

My Lords, I also rise in support of this group of amendments, but particularly in support of Amendment 88. I also welcome and echo my noble friend's comments in terms of the challenges that are being faced in the area of financial services from the forces of technology and technological evolution. And I welcome the direction of travel from the government, the FCA, the Bank of England. There has been real progress on crypto assets, stablecoins, tokenization, and I particularly also am encouraged by the work of the government's wholesale digital markets champion, Chris Woolard, his published report and the work towards his forthcoming reports. And would like to thank the government and the Minister and the Economic Secretary and the champion for their engagement so far.

But this amendment, Amendment 88, asks a bigger question: are we simply regulating digital assets or are we building a digital assets economy? That distinction matters. Chris Woolard's work on tokenizing wholesale financial markets is extremely important, but digital assets are bigger than financial services regulation. They are becoming part of infrastructure of money, payment, settlement, capital markets, and the wider economy. That is why I strongly support the work of the Bank of England and the Governor on a multi-money system, or even a multi-moneyverse, where traditional bank money, tokenized deposits, stablecoins, and central bank money playing complementary roles.

We should be thinking about the whole ecosystem, not simply individual technologies. That is what this amendment seeks to do. It requires the Treasury to develop a proper digital assets strategy informed by regulators and, crucially, by industry. It specifically asks government to look at practical conditions in which firms operate, including access to banking, payments, and settlement. That matters because a firm can be authorized and compliant, but it cannot access the financial infrastructure it needs.

That authorization is largely theoretical. Industry is telling us that this is a real barrier. We should listen. There is also an international dimension. In my regular discussions with senior policymakers in Washington, including the US SEC and the CFTC, it is clear that United States is moving rapidly to shape the digital assets market through Genus and Clarity Acts.

But we do need to recognize the competition and recognize the particular opportunity for the United Kingdom. Of course, the UK is a global financial center with extraordinary strengths in financial markets, legal services, fintech, and professional services. That gives us an opportunity not simply to follow international developments, but to lead international standard setting. Indeed, the Bank of England is already showing what that leadership can look like through its work on interoperability and multi-asset, multi-currency tokenized financial systems. So I welcome the increased engagement with industry from the government.

But we now need a consistent drumbeat, a stronger leadership, and a clear plan of targets and delivery so industry can plan alongside government and regulators. That is why I believe this amendment is important and would press the minister and the government to give further consideration. It asks for a strategy that sets out where we want to go, what barriers we need to remove, what infrastructure and standards we need, how we remain internationally competitive, and what success looks like. Willard's work is an important part of that, but we need to be more ambitious than a single workstream. Other countries are moving quickly.

The UK should not simply seek to regulate the digital assets economy of tomorrow. We should build it and help write the international rules for it here in the United Kingdom.

03:28:56 - 03:32:04

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, this is an important and forward-looking group of amendments covering open finance, digital market infrastructure, and the future of digital assets. And I'm very grateful to my noble friend Lord Holmes of Richmond for his amendments and for explaining the scale of the digital tide and the AI wave and the lack of specific signals in the bill on these opportunities. I want to focus my remarks on amendment 88 standing in my name and those of my noble friend Lord Altringham and the noble Baroness Lady Kramer, who I thank for her support. We debated these issues in committee, but the central concern remains. Digital assets are becoming an accelerating part of our financial and economic landscape.

Yet policy is still developing too often issue by issue, product by product, and regulator by regulator. What is missing is a comprehensive strategy. This matters. Industry is telling us that the most basic building blocks of a comprehensive regulatory regime, such as legal definitions, do not exist. This uncertainty is translating into a lack of confidence, which is driving wealth creators away.

Amendment 88 asks the Treasury to step back and set out a coherent strategy for the regulation and development of digital assets and related financial market infrastructure in the UK. It asks them to establish their objectives, consult properly with industry and other interested parties, and explain how the different strands of policy fit together. This can build on the work of the Bank of England and of Chris Woolard, the new wholesale digital markets champion at the Treasury. And we are most grateful for yesterday's briefing at which Chris set out his forthcoming plans for another report due to be published next year. The opportunity for the UK is considerable.

We have the legal system, deep capital markets, and an extensive professional services ecosystem. But firms need to know which regulator is responsible for which part of the system, what rules will apply, how different regimes will interact, and how quickly decisions will be made. We're seeing the effects of current ambiguity in reports of firms wishing to offer digital asset products being debanked, a point to which my amendment refers. Other financial centers are moving rapidly to establish their own frameworks for digital assets and for tokenized markets, as my noble friend Lord Ranger explained from his position of great expertise.

If business conclude that another jurisdiction offers greater regulatory certainty or a clearer strategic direction, they can quickly go elsewhere. Amendment 88 therefore offers the government an opportunity to bring those strands together. The work of Chris Woolard is welcome, but our amendment encompasses a wider range of concerns raised with us. So I hope the government will engage with the amendment, but if I'm not satisfied with the minister's response, I will seek to test the opinion of the House.

03:32:04 - 03:37:41

David Pitt

My Lords, I thank the noble Baronesses Lady Neville-Rolfe and Lady Kramer, the noble Lords Lord Tyrie and Lord Holmes for their amendments in relation to the adoption of technology in the financial services sector and for their contribution to this debate. Technological change is already having a significant impact on the sector and there are huge opportunities for the UK alongside risks to be managed. Amendment 71 seeks to require the FCA to create and maintain a framework for open finance. However, the government already has powers to create a framework for open finance under the Data Use and Access Act 2025. Parliament has therefore already legislated here, and that legislation includes the power to require the FCA to regulate for open finance and includes appropriate safeguards and scrutiny.

The Treasury has also confirmed at Mansion House in July 2026 its commitment to open finance and said it will consult on open finance next year. Amendments 88 and 89 are both focused on digitalization. Amendment 88 seeks to support the UK's approach to digital assets by requiring the government to publish a digital asset strategy. It sets out a number of important issues that such a strategy should consider. Amendment 89 similarly seeks to support digitalization by requiring the government to make regulations establishing an issuer digitalization council composed of representatives from issuers, intermediaries, FCA, PRA, Bank of England and the Treasury.

As noted in the debate at committee stage, the government is a strong supporter of digital assets and sees them as a key strategic priority. As such, the government has been very active on this agenda and has a comprehensive strategy to drive forward digitalization of wholesale markets through the wholesale financial markets digital strategy published in July 2025. The government has been taking forward the actions of the strategy at speed. There has been progress even since the issue was debated at committee stage. Chris Woolard CBE published his first report as the government's wholesale digital markets champion in July, setting out a comprehensive cross-sector approach to digital assets.

The Economic Secretary to the Treasury and myself hosted a drop-in session with Mr. Woolard here in Parliament just yesterday so members of your Lordships' House could hear more about his agenda. I think those of you who were there would agree we should be impressed by the scope and comprehensiveness of the work that he is doing. He outlined not one workstream, no, nine taskforce action groups who are taking forward the industry roadmap, including an action-focused group on primary issuance of digital securities with an initial focus on delivering an end-to-end use case.

These groups and the overarching orchestration group represent a huge amount of work, expertise, and industry input that Chris is leading. They include the industry. They include a strategy. They include 50 companies just to be joined with the head from of Europe from BlackRock and from the London Stock Exchange. Absolutely great work, as Lord Holmes said.

At that meeting, Chris Woolard was asked did he see there as being any need for further primary legislation. I think Lord Ranger was there at the meeting and can confirm that he said right now he did not think that there was and could confirm that I also said to him that should there be that need, myself and the Economic Secretary to the Treasury would be listening to that. Because look, there is a real threat to UK competitiveness if we fail to act in this area and a considerable opportunity if we get it right. I hope the opportunity to engage Mr. Woolard prior to this debate should have given insight into the extent and the vast amount of work that is taking place already constructively to make sure that this happens. There are many other actions that are taken to support this work, such as the Bank of England and the Financial Conduct Authority's call for input on tokenization, which closed in July.

They intend to publish a further roadmap in the autumn. In your speeches, I have heard that you want momentum and a strategy involving industry. That is indeed what is happening right now. The government has also highlighted progress on the digital security sandbox, the digital gilt instrument at committee stage. My Lords, the government strongly believes in the need to digitalize financial markets.

And I had hoped that the measures that the government was taking forward and the further updates that you'd received from Chris Woolard of Wholesale Digital Markets Champion show that the government is working with the sector and the regulator to deliver a strategic approach to digitalization.

03:37:41 - 03:38:17

The Lord Ranger of Northwood

My Lords, may I forgive me for interjecting, but the minister's quite right, we had a very progressive session with Mr. Woolard yesterday. But the question we did raise, and I did raise with him, was about the future strategy, where we were heading because his focus is quite clearly on tokenization, but we did notice that there was a discussion to be had further on standard setting internationally and also on agentic finance and various other elements that are in development that need strategic thought. And I think the champion did take that on board, that there was a broader vision that needed to be identified, which is what we would be looking for in a set strategy.

03:38:17 - 03:38:47

David Pitt

He did indeed take that on board, and I would thank the noble Lord Ranger for coming and making that point. And he was also asked whether at this point further primary legislation was needed. And he said that it was not, but was invited should that situation change to talk to the ministers in the Treasury. And therefore I ask the noble baronesses and the noble lords to withdraw their amendment.

03:38:47 - 03:39:32

Lord Holmes of Richmond

My Lords, can I thank everyone who's taken part in this debate and indeed the minister for his answer, and I would echo every word he said about the fantastic work that Chris Woolard and indeed Mark Austin have done in this area. For the time being, I will withdraw the amendment, but it remains to be seen whether we are potentially building a faster horse or regulating existing products in a digital form. I would suggest there's still more thinking to be done around composability and around the extraordinary opportunities that exist, but it's fantastic that we have such champions in Chris Woolard and others working in this area. I look forward to seeing how it develops and for the moment I withdraw the amendment.

03:39:32 - 03:40:44

George Young

Is it your lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 72, Lord Holmes of Richmond. Not moved. Amendment 72A, Baroness Bowles of Berkhamsted.

Not moved. Government amendments 73 to 79 moved en bloc.

Moved formally. The question is that amendments 73 to 79 be agreed to en bloc. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.

Amendment 80, Lord Howard of Rising. Not moved. Amendment 81, Lord Pitt-Watson, moved formally. The question is that amendment 81 be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content.

Contrary not content. The contents have it. We now come to amendment 82, Baroness Kramer. Not moved. Amendments 83 to 86, Baroness Kramer.

Not moved. We now come to amendment 87, Baroness Bowles of Berkhamsted.

03:40:44 - 03:42:51

Sharon Bowles

I'm glad you let me sit down. My Lords, I'll speak briefly to amendment 87 and I support Baroness Altmann's amendment on superfunds. I think these are two issues that need attention. My amendment is about one thing: tax certainty for insurance-linked securities. It does not weaken anti-avoidance rules and does not seek any advantage Parliament never intended.

It simply asks for clarity in a regime Parliament created to attract ILS business to the UK. And the problem is commercial. Rival jurisdictions give clear outcomes. The UK does not. HMRC's guidance leaves too much ambiguity and advisers reach conflicting conclusions on identical transactions.

So in a market where speed and predictability drive choice of domicile, capital goes elsewhere. And the consequences are stark. London is the world's largest commercial reinsurance center, yet we have only 2% of global ILS activity. The catastrophe bond market is over $60 billion and the wider ILS market exceeds $140 billion. And we could have a big chunk of that, but we are letting this substantial business and indeed the tax revenue that would come from it pass London by.

New PRA reforms in this bill are welcome and London Bridge 2 has brought in new capital, but even that structure repeatedly runs into HMRC uncertainty. So I say if the government wants the market, the guidance has to be clearer. And it's only government that can fix this if they want the business in the UK. I beg to move.

03:42:51 - 03:42:57

George Young

Proposed after clause 44 insert the following new clause as printed on the marshalled list.

03:42:57 - 03:45:54

Ros Rosalind Altmann

Lords, I too support Baroness Bowles's amendment 87 and I would like to speak to my own amendment 92 and I'm grateful for her adding her name. This inserts a provision in the bill to allow life insurers to set up defined benefit pension superfunds outside of their Solvency UK ring-fences and enabling them to participate in the superfund market, potentially even to help the UK build its own version of Canada's much-vaunted Maple 8.

UK insurers with suitable ring-fencing as set out in the amendment to ensure separation from their insurance business are ideally placed to run large pools of pension investments with existing in-house expertise in areas such as investment, actuarial and legal. At present, insurance buyout is seen as the gold standard for defined benefit pension scheme end-game strategies. But super funds could provide a means to add billions of pounds worth of productive capital into the UK economy and allow pension members to enjoy better benefits, rather than super funds remaining niche players if the current system is not changed. Insurers could bring large amounts of capital pooled into the pension scheme area and to collect pension assets so that scheme members would have better upside opportunities and robust alternatives to the finality of annuity buyouts, which are generally considered 100% safe, but which could well not be. Buyout pushes assets into low-return unproductive opportunities and denies members greater returns and better pensions, which could come from super funds, but more particularly there are concerns about systemic risk with annuity buyouts.

And I wondered if the noble Lord the Minister might agree to meet with myself and other interested parties to discuss the risks involved in the government's current perception that annuity buyout is the gold standard 100% safe end-game strategy. I hope that he will recognize the Financial Services Compensation Scheme may not be as secure as expected, and therefore I beg to move that this amendment be considered.

03:45:54 - 03:48:38

David Pitt

My Lords, I thank the noble Baronesses Lady Bowles and Lady Altmann for their amendments. I'll take each in turn, starting with amendment 87. As was noticed by my predecessor, this government recognizes the role which the bespoke tax regime for transformer vehicles plays in ensuring the UK's competitive. We also recognize, as does this amendment, the importance of robust anti-avoidance measures and clear guidance in ensuring that the regime functions effectively, provides certainty to business and safeguards the integrity of the tax system. It is right that we preserve HMRC's ability to effectively pursue instances where vehicles are established for the purposes of avoiding tax, and it is important that we preserve that ability and avoid creating risks for the Exchequer.

However, I recognize the strength of feeling in industry over this issue. I would therefore offer the Baroness a meeting with HMRC and Treasury officials to discuss in more depth. I remain of the view that this legislation is not the appropriate place to make provision for the tax regime governing transformer vehicles, the Risk Transformation Tax Regulation 2017 being the specific legislation designed to govern this. Turning to amendment 92, the government recognizes the important role that defined benefit pension scheme consolidation can play in improving outcomes for pension scheme members and providing additional options for schemes. This amendment seeks to place in legislation an explicit permission for PRA-authorised insurance to establish, own or operate DB super funds that would introduce statutory requirements requiring the separation of super fund and insurance activities.

However, insurers are already able to establish and operate super funds under the existing regulatory framework.

The amendment therefore does not create a new route into market, rather its primary effect is to place requirements relating to ring-fencing, capital treatment, and the separation of activities into primary legislation. The government's view is that matters relating to prudential regulation, capital treatment, and the supervision of regulated firms are more appropriately addressed by relevant regulators rather than through detailed provisions in primary legislation. For those reasons, while I appreciate the intention behind the amendment, the government does not consider it necessary and therefore asks the noble baronesses to withdraw their respective amendments.

03:48:38 - 03:48:45

Ros Rosalind Altmann

Could I just ask whether he would be willing to meet to go through some of these issues?

03:48:45 - 03:48:58

David Pitt

If I would be the relevant person to talk to on this matter, I would be happy to meet. If not, perhaps I can direct the noble baroness to appropriate officials.

03:48:58 - 03:49:31

Sharon Bowles

My Lords, I thank the minister for his reply. There's nothing in my amendment that is intended to stop pursuit of things that are wrong, but the evidence is that the guidance is not understood, and so I welcome the opportunity to have a meeting with HMRC officials so that we can explain more clearly where the problems lie and see if a solution can be found. And so with that, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

03:49:31 - 03:49:38

George Young

Your Lordship's pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 88, Baroness Neville-Rolfe.

03:49:38 - 03:50:00

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

Amendment 88 addresses a simple problem: digital assets are developing rapidly, but UK policy remains fragmented and uncertain relative to international competitors. Despite the good work being done by Chris Willard and the Bank of England, I beg leave to test the opinion of the House on my amendment.

03:50:00 - 03:53:30

George Young

The question is that amendment 88 be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The question will be decided by division. I would advise the House when voting is open.

Voting is now open, clear the bar.

The question is that amendment 88B be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.

04:01:09 - 04:01:58

Speaker 105

My Lords, there have voted contents 194, not contents 138, and so the contents have it. Amendment 89, Lord Holmes, not moved. Amendment 90, Baroness Sheehan, not moved. Amendment 91, Baroness Northover, not moved. Amendment 92, Baroness Altmann, not moved.

Amendment 93, already debated, Baroness Neville-Rolfe.

04:01:58 - 04:02:16

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

Amendment 93 and its consequentials are intended as a compromise with the government. I don't feel that the government have fully engaged with the practical proposal that we put forward on Monday. I therefore wish to test the opinion of the House on amendment 93.

04:02:16 - 04:05:58

Speaker 105

The question is that amendment 93 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The question will be decided by a division. I will advise the House when voting is over.

Voting is open, clear the bar.

The question is that amendment 93 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion say content. Contrary not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar. Michael.

04:10:50 - 04:10:50

My Lords, the question is that amendment 93 be agreed to.

04:12:38 - 04:13:08

Speaker 109

My Lords, there have voted: contents 196, not contents 138, so the contents have it.

04:13:08 - 04:13:18

Speaker 107

Amendment 94, Baroness Neville-Rolfe. Not moved. Not moved, 94, not moved. 95, Lord Howard.

04:13:18 - 04:14:05

Speaker 105

I understood 100, 200, and 3 were consequential. Is this one consequential, 94?

No. Not moved. 95, Lord Howard. Not moved. 96, Lord Holmes.

Not moved. 97, already debated, Baroness Bennett. Not moved. And now I call 97A from the supplementary sheet, Baroness Sheehan. Not moved.

Not moved. 98, amendment 98, Baroness Neville-Rolfe.

04:14:05 - 04:15:02

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, I rise to move amendment 98, which would remove clause 50, thus returning to the broad principle we raised in our discussions on clause 3, which led to a majority of 81 in a vote on its deletion. Clause 50 allows the Treasury to amend or repeal primary legislation without introducing another bill, so another Henry VIII power. We need clarity from the minister about how the government envisaged the power to be used. Our concern is that it goes further than technical housekeeping, as the text of the clause gives ministers a broad and potentially permanent power to amend or repeal primary legislation, including devolved legislation, without the full scrutiny afforded to a bill. I'm grateful for the support of the noble lady Baroness Bowles, and in the absence of a satisfactory reply, I'm minded to test the opinion of the house.

04:15:02 - 04:15:05

Speaker 106

Amendment proposed: leave out clause 50.

04:15:05 - 04:15:18

Sharon Bowles

I signed this amendment because I think there are bad things in this bill and I don't want any more of them.

04:15:18 - 04:15:42

Anthony Vaux

I'm not sure how to follow that, my Lords.

I've added my name to amendment 98. Clause 50 is a very, very broad catch-all Henry VIII power. Given that the bill already has over 50 delegated powers in it, this seems entirely superfluous and it should be removed.

04:15:42 - 04:17:42

David Pitt

My Lords, amendment 98 would remove the consequential power contained in clause 50. The government understands the concern that delegated powers should be used appropriately and should not become a vehicle for making substantive policy changes without parliamentary scrutiny. And indeed, I think on Monday, in response to issues to do with Henry VIII powers, I gave some sympathy to that argument. However, the power in clause 50 is not a power to introduce new policy, nor is it a power to revisit the policy that Parliament will have approved by passage of the bill. It is a narrow regulation-making power limited to dealing with matters that arise as a consequence of the provisions that Parliament has already approved within the bill.

It is common and often necessary for legislation of this scale and complexity to require consequential adjustments elsewhere on the statute book so that provisions operate as intended. Without such a power, relatively minor or technical changes would require further primary legislation, creating unnecessary delay and complexity. For these reasons, the government does not believe that removing this clause would improve the bill. I'd also note that this was not a point raised by the Delegated Powers Committee about this bill. And finally, I would like to assure the noble lady that parliamentary committees will, of course, be able to call the government to appear in front of them and account for the use of consequential power or indeed any other power in this bill.

I therefore ask the noble baroness to withdraw this amendment.

04:17:42 - 04:18:06

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, fact is clause 50 gives ministers a broad and potentially permanent power to amend or repeal primary legislation, including devolved legislation, without the full scrutiny afforded to a bill. And unlike other bills, this is a bill with many new unspecified powers. So I seek to test the opinion of the House.

04:18:06 - 04:21:35

Speaker 105

The question is that amendment 98 be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. And to the contrary, not content. The question will be decided by a division. I will advise the House when voting is open.

Voting is open, clear the bar.

The question is that amendment 98 be agreed to. As many as of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.

04:26:28 - 04:26:28

The question is that amendment 98 be agreed to.

04:28:04 - 04:28:52

Speaker 105

My Lords, there have voted contents 188, not contents 125, so the contents have it. Amendment 99 already debated, Lord Sharkey, not moved. I understand that it's been agreed that amendments 100 to 103 inclusive are consequential. The question is that these amendments be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content.

The contrary not content. The contents have it.

04:28:52 - 04:28:56

Speaker 108

My Lords, I beg to move the House do now adjourn.

04:28:56 - 04:28:56

That the House do now adjourn.