Westminster Hall

21 October 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:13 - 00:21
Speaker 1
Order.  Helen Maguire to move the motion. 
00:21 - 00:40
Speaker 6
Thank you, Mr. Stringer.  I beg to move that this House has considered the regulation of e-scooters and e-bikes.  It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Stringer.  And I'm absolutely pleased to have secured this debate and really grateful for the opportunity to raise this issue that needs urgently progressing.  It's a timely debate because last week I hosted a round table on this very topic. 
00:40 - 01:28
Speaker 4
There were 25 individuals that attended.  There were senior ranking representatives from nine police forces from across the country, five police and crime commissioners, one borough commander, one assistant chief constable, and the officers that were present were from the Met, Derbyshire, Merseyside, Surrey, Lancashire, Gloucestershire, Warwickshire, Hertfordshire, Devon and Cornwall.  There were industry representatives, campaigners, policy experts, academics, doctors and MPs.  And I'm thankful to all those who attended and shared their insights and expertise with me and those other MPs that were there.  The fact that so many individuals representing diverse groups and interests traveled across the UK to London to speak about this issue highlights the urgency and the need for action. 
01:28 - 01:58
Speaker 2
So how did this issue become so important to me?  It all first started when I was canvassing to become an MP and I met so many constituents who raised the issue of e-scooters and e-bikes in my constituency in Epsom and Ewell.  It became a top issue.  And one of my constituents, Ed Dark, told me that his little boy is now too scared to go to the park, the beautiful park that's next to his house, due to the...  I will, yes. 
01:58 - 02:33
Speaker 3
I thank the honorable member for giving way.  Many people in my constituency of Wolverhampton West feel frightened and intimidated when just walking out on the pavement can run the risk of being in collision with an e-scooter or e-bike.  And I have raised the matter with the police, but they say that they are unable to take action unless the riders are caught riding the vehicle.  So does my honorable friend agree that we need greater enforcement powers, clearer national guidance and stronger controls on the sales of illegal e-scooters and e-bikes so that we can better protect our residents and restore confidence in our neighborhood? 
02:33 - 03:01
Speaker 4
I thank the honorable member for his intervention.  I absolutely agree with everything and I will be talking about these points in my speech.  So Edward Dark's son, they were walking home from school one day and he was nearly hit by an e-scooter.  Now this could have been fatal.  Thankfully it wasn't. 

Another constituent told me that they've even considered moving house, just consider that, moving house because of the e-scooter misuse in their neighborhood.  One told me that her...  Yes. 
03:01 - 03:30
Speaker 7
I thank the member for giving way and she is rightfully got a debate on an extremely important topic.  In the summer in Tamworth, we had an extremely serious collision between a six-year-old girl and an e-motorbike.  She is in, she was in a critical condition, but fortunately she did not die as a result.  But I wondered whether or not she will be obviously pressing the minister to find out what more can be done to give resources to policing and to help clarify the situation around the legislation for e-bikes and e-motorbikes. 
03:31 - 03:59
Speaker 5
I'm really sorry to hear about the member's constituent and I hope she's okay now, but I will absolutely be raising these issues.  Thank you.  So one constituency told me that her car was hit by an illegally ridden e-bike on the wrong side of the road.  She got the individual's details, she reported it to the police, and she was told that they'll keep a look out rather than seize the bike from the known address.  But this issue goes far beyond Epsom and Ewell as members have raised already. 
03:59 - 04:07
Speaker 4
What we're seeing across the country is young people on e-scooters riding at high speed through red lights, parks, and in pedestrianized areas. 

04:07 - 04:41

Anna Dixon

I thank the honorable lady for giving way and for the excellent seminar she held last week, which I was able to attend. Illegal e-motorbikes are also a blight on my community in Shipley constituency. But having spoken to the police and the lead police officers that she convened last week, this is a preferred vehicle of choice for organized crime and criminals. So does she agree and will she help press the minister to work with DVSA to make sure these non-compliant conversion kits are banned from sale as soon as possible?

04:41 - 05:18

Helen Maguire

I thank the member for her intervention. I absolutely agree and this is one of the matters that we need to take forward with the minister. So we have illegally modified e-scooters that could now reach speeds of up to 70 miles an hour. We have the issue of e-bikes which are catching fire due to uncertified lithium-ion batteries. The use of e-vehicles in criminal activities and anti-social behavior as the member's alluded to.

Fundamentally, pedestrians have the right to feel safe. They shouldn't need to feel worried about being hit or knocked over when they're just simply walking in the park or on the streets. And this is particularly important for vulnerable groups, especially those with vision loss or mobility needs.

05:18 - 05:42

James Mark Sewards

Thank you for giving way. She's making such a strong argument. I recently met with the Guide Dogs, I know other members here did too. They made a strong case for the visually impaired and the blind who are often put off going out onto their own streets because of the silent nature of these e-scooters and e-bikes. Doesn't she agree that on that point alone underscores the need to enforce the law properly in this area?

05:42 - 06:36

Helen Maguire

I absolutely agree with my honorable friend. And in my constituency, I have Swail House right in the center of Epsom where we have a huge amount of people living there who are visually impaired and this is a critical issue for them. So there are currently flaws in the current collision data. In 2023, there were at least 1,299 collisions involving e-scooters. But these statistics don't show the full picture.

How can they? Because the data is not consistently collected or clearly identified. Data on death and injuries in reported road collisions is reported to the Department for Transport by police forces in Great Britain via Stats 19. A new personal powered transporter category was introduced. This covers e-scooters, but not all forces are currently using the new Stats 19 specifications.

So I urge the minister to enforce the use of the new Stats 19 specification for all police forces so that we can understand exactly what is going on.

06:36 - 06:58

Andrew George

I'm very grateful to my honorable friend who's making an excellent point. But surely the answer is relatively simple, that if a scooter or a bike operates purely through electronic motor and not human propulsion, then they should be taxed, insured, and have an MOT like any other motorbike.

06:58 - 07:24

Helen Maguire

I thank the honorable member for his contribution. I'm sure he can put those issues forward to the minister. Thank you. So e-bikes aren't currently distinguished from pedal cycle or electric motorcycle categories depending on their power rating. And the government has stated that there aren't any plans to change Stats 19 data to introduce specific categories for e-bikes.

So I urge the minister today to reassess introducing a specific category for e-bikes within Stats 19.

07:24 - 07:46

James William Naish

I thank you very much for giving way. The reason I intervene at this point is I went into QMC, which is the main hospital in Nottingham, specifically to meet the pediatric teams. And they told me that there'd been 10 acquired brain injuries, serious brain injuries, since April this year. They're looking at two a month and the curve is on an upward trajectory. And so actually the data on the ground is clear.

07:46 - 07:51

Speaker 8

This is a problem and the lag in the data is something that ministers need to get beyond and start taking the action that people are calling for, like the medics that I met.

07:51 - 07:57

Speaker 10

So would she agree with me that the human cost and the long-term impact on these young people needs to be prioritized?

07:57 - 10:54

Helen Maguire

I absolutely agree with the honorable member, and I will be talking more about the human cost in a moment. Thank you. So these changes will provide an accurate oversight of the scale and distribution of the issue, which would effectively lead to more effective enforcement and legislation. How can we begin to address this issue if we don't even fully understand the full picture? But behind these limited statistics, there's an unacceptable price of injury and death, and particularly for children.

At my round table, I spoke to Dr. Durand. She's a consultant in pediatric emergency medicine, and her research from the Emergency Medical Journal analyzed e-scooter injury data over six years from three major children trauma centers in Manchester, Liverpool, and Sheffield. And what it found was 447 children attended hospital following an e-scooter related injury. One in 10 had serious head injuries requiring hospital admission and surgery. 95% of injuries involved the rider, and the average age of an injured child was 12 years old.

Half were aged between 10 and 13. Annual cases rose from less than 10 in 2019 to almost 150 by 2024. 74% of the injured children also live in areas with the greatest socioeconomic deprivation. Less than 2% of riders were wearing a helmet. So I'm going to tell you about Jacob, Jacob's journey.

Because behind each of these statistics is a child with possibly life-ending injuries and permanently changed families. And one of these families is the Calland family. I was fortunate to meet Carly for the second time at my round table. The Calland family tragically lost their son, Jacob, in an e-scooter incident. On the 19th of March 2025, Jacob left his home and just met up with another boy, his friend.

He decided to ride as a passenger on the back of that boy's e-scooter without any protective gear. And this decision cost him his life. Because at 3:59, the e-scooter collided with a car. Jacob was thrown into the other side of the road and landed in front of oncoming traffic. He suffered a catastrophic head injury and was brought into the ICU and put in a coma.

He underwent multiple surgeries to try to control the bleeding and swelling on the brain. But his condition began to deteriorate, and there was nothing more that could be done to save his life. Jacob Calland passed away at 5:18 AM on Thursday, 25th of March 2025. He was just 14 years and nine months old. How many more children need to die for the government to take this issue seriously?

There was no mention of e-scooter and e-bike legislation in the King's Speech. And DfT say the earliest legislation could be considered is May 2027. This is unacceptable. The lack of time in the parliamentary calendar is not an excuse for failing to act to save our children's lives.

10:54 - 11:20

Speaker 13

I thank the honorable member for giving away. Would she agree with me that just in advance of any change that there needs to be seen to be across the country a consistency of approach? Because I have had parents say to me senior police officers in one part of the country take one attitude to this ongoing and worsening problem compared to other compatriots. And we need to see a consistency of approach in advance of the change that we all want.

11:20 - 12:45

Helen Maguire

Absolutely, and that's something I'll be going onto, which is police powers and the actual acts that they have to act. I have three children myself, and Jacob could have been one of mine, or any of our children in this room today.

As MPs, we have a duty to ensure that we keep our children safe. And for the Prime Minister, Jacob Calland lived in Wythenshawe, Manchester, close to Macclesfield, so if he is listening today, I urge him to act now. So this brings me onto the unending rental e-scooter trials. Trials began in July 2020 and intended to run until November 2021. They were launched to review if e-scooters reduced pressure on public transport, motor traffic, and their safety impacts.

The trials were then extended until March 2022 to allow more time for evidence to be gathered due to COVID. They were then extended again until November 2022 due to the DfT issuing guidance to enhance safety measures. They were then extended again to May 2025 for the DfT to reflect on further analysis. And it's now been extended again until May 2028 to help fill evidence gaps to inform legislation. This will be eight years of trials with no action.

Why are these trials unending? What are we trying to achieve in this period of time? In Ireland, they had a six-month trial. In Germany, they had a 180-day trial. In France and Spain, they didn't even have trials.

And these countries were able to implement legislation and improve road safety in a fraction of the time. So my question to the Minister is, why can't we?

12:45 - 13:27

Speaker 12

I thank the honourable lady for giving way. Derbyshire Constabulary have seized and crushed over a thousand illegal electric scooters, some capable of travelling at speeds of 50 miles an hour and being ridden by children at speeds like that. The damage that can be done is catastrophic. And I've also had older constituents who've told me that they are afraid to go into Derby city centre for fear of being hit. And that's not even to mention the house fires that we have seen due to e-scooter batteries.

So does the honourable member agree with me that the sooner that we legislate to tackle illegal scooters and protect the public, the better?

13:27 - 14:33

Helen Maguire

I absolutely agree with the honourable member, and Derbyshire Police have been doing an outstanding job seizing e-scooters and e-bikes, so I do congratulate them on that. So since the start of these trials in 2020 to December 2025, there have been 7,591 reported casualties in collisions involving e-scooters. In 2025 alone, there were 1,477 reported collisions and 10 deaths. The time for data collection has long passed. Legislation is now needed to save lives on our roads.

So looking at policing e-scooters and e-bikes, the lack of government action is currently forcing police forces to deal with this issue on their own because there's no centralised guidance on operational tactics. And so police are adapting seizing powers. So Derbyshire Police have got a system at the moment called 'See it, Seize it', and they're empowering PCSOs under Section 165A of the Road Traffic Act to seize and remove e-scooters within 24 hours. But this isn't consistent across the country. Every police force is doing it differently.

14:33 - 15:04

Anthony Bradley Thomas

I thank her for giving way and calling this debate, which is very timely. Does she agree with me that this is a particular problem where policing borders meet? My constituency is under the West Mercia jurisdiction, but Cofton Hackett, a village where we have an acute problem with e-bikes, the bikes often originate from Birmingham, which is under the jurisdiction of West Midlands Police. It feels that some areas fall between the cracks and that increasingly the e-bike problem is one where we're increasingly living in a society without consequences.

15:04 - 17:52

Helen Maguire

I thank the honourable member for his intervention, and I agree when police forces are using different tactics, there absolutely will be cross-boundary border issues. So Derbyshire Police also implemented a huge public awareness campaign with the fire brigade, housing providers, schools, and retailers. And what's really important is that we inform the public more about this because they're incredibly confused about e-scooters because they can be bought legally, but they can't be used on our public roads or in parks. Only the e-scooter trials can be used legally. And right now we're entering the Christmas season, when many parents will be thinking maybe about an e-scooter or an e-bike as a gift.

So I urge the government to put safety first and to reconsider.

Since implementing the scheme in Derbyshire, they've seized 30 e-scooters a month, a total of 1,060. This strategy is effective. It's seen a reduction in e-scooter crime by 40% and a reduction in e-bike crime by 11%. Now, recently Surrey Police have announced Operation Scramble where illegal e-bikes and e-scooters will be seized and destroyed. The government must support police forces.

Police forces are calling for this and they're calling for workable legislation. That's why there were so many representatives from police forces around the country at my roundtable the other day. To be clear, I'm not against e-scooters or e-bikes because the benefits of them are clear. They're affordable transport alternatives. They make difficult routes accessible.

The impact on the environment is less than cars. They improve public health, local air quality and they cut congestion. And they support the hard workers in the gig economy. But they must be properly regulated, legislated and this must be enforced to protect all members of the public. So in conclusion, there is currently no practical legislation on the use of e-scooters and e-bikes.

There's no coordinated guidance for police forces. There's no effective regulation on the import or sale. There's no control of the online or grey marketplace. And there's no public understanding of what is and what isn't legal. Failure to act is not just lives, but it's also lost revenue to HMRC, further strain and costs on our hospitals and on the NHS, increased pressure on pressured police forces and confusion to retailers, consumers and parents.

So will the Minister today commit to ending the ongoing trials, commit to outlining the next steps for legislation, commit to the safety of our children and young people in the UK so that another parent doesn't need to spend this Christmas without their child?

17:52 - 18:30

Graham Stringer

Right, there's obviously a huge amount of interest in this debate. I'd remind honorable members that if they wish to speak to Bob and I will be imposing to start with a time limit of two and a half minutes on speeches. I'd also like to ask members to keep their interventions brief if they're going to make interventions. The question is that this House has considered the regulation of e-scooters and e-bikes. Dame Siobhain McDonagh.

18:30 - 21:08

Siobhain McDonagh

Thank you, Mr. Stringer, and can I congratulate the honorable member for Epsom and Ewell. She you can the chair can see just how big an issue this is for constituencies across the whole country. In 2017, the London Fire Brigade attended just seven e-bike fires. Last year, the number reached a record 206. That's an e-bike fire somewhere in the capital every other day.

Since 2023, six people have lost their lives in e-bike and e-scooter fires in London. Of those, six were not themselves charging the vehicles responsible for the fires. These are people who lost their lives because of a danger they had absolutely no control over and they may not even have known existed.

In my constituency alone, 14 fires have been lost due to fire. And just last week at my advice surgery, I met Mr. and Mrs. Gifford, whose home was devastated by an e-bike fire on Lewis Road in Mitcham in October last year. They lived next door to the property where the battery was being charged. Almost a year later, they are still unable to return to their home. Imagine losing your home through no fault of your own, losing everything you know, own, all your memories, where your children grew up, and a year later, you're still unable to return.

This is the lasting devastation these fires can cause. But the reality is that some people caught up in these fires never make it out of their home. At a round table I also held last week, we heard the devastating story of Sofia Duarte. Sofia was just 21 years old when she died on New Year's Day in 2023 as a result of spending the night at her boyfriend's flat in Old Kent Road when a converted e-bike charging in the communal area caught fire. Everyone else got out.

She didn't, and she didn't see another year. That shouldn't be the consequence of anybody who is not doing anything wrong but being subject to some illegal and unauthorized battery exploding.

21:08 - 22:48

Matt Vickers

Thank you, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Stringer. I congratulate the honorable member for Epsom and Ewell on securing this important debate. In Stockton West, the plague of balaclava-clad yobs on illegal e-motos comes up constantly on the doorsteps and in my surgery. Three years ago in this hall, I named Thornaby as a hotspot and warned that we could not wait for someone else to lose their life. On the 31st of January this year, in Thornaby, a 15-year-old on a Sur-Ron plowed into a father of seven riding a pushbike.

Months later, he's still in hospital with life-changing injuries needing round-the-clock care. The boys got driving bans and referral orders and were ordered to pay just 495 pounds in compensation. The recent changes to seizure powers are welcome, but they go nowhere near far enough. I tabled amendments to the Crime and Policing Bill to give the police greater powers to enter properties to seize these bikes, to destroy illegal bikes rather than sell them on, and to register and control sales. The government rejected them all.

Meanwhile, anyone can buy a machine that's illegal to ride on a public road or a kit that turns a legal e-bike into an unregistered motorbike and have it delivered the next day. So I ask the minister, will the government control the sale of these vehicles and of the kits used to modify them? And will they now give the police the power we proposed to seize these bikes wherever they're hidden? My constituents simply want the law to be on the side of the law-abiding majority. It's time for the government to make sure that is.

22:48 - 25:21

Speaker 20

Yeah, thanks, and congrats to the honorable lady on securing the debate. I'd like to focus comments on the cycle hire regulations in Southwark because we should be a success story: more lanes, more users. But, and I have a big but which makes me a very wobbly cyclist, complaints are colossal and rising, and increasingly from other cyclists. The need to regulate is only too apparent when you visit any transport interchange in Southwark in my constituency: bikes dumped, even blocking the only pedestrian crossing from London Bridge station onto the, onto the bridge itself Saturday last week, not in rush hour, on a Saturday lunchtime. I get so many complaints, including Stephen about bike dumping at Canada Water, Sasha and bikes in pedestrian areas in local parks, Sandra about insurance after a recent collision.

And then there is Wheelans, a pub in Rotherhithe where the bike bay outside overflows regularly, blocking the way of customers, blocking a bus stop, but most worryingly, bikes being dumped that block the delivery of beer to that pub.

A pub without beer cannot stay open very long. This is a red route, alternatives are very limited. I'm working with Lime and others to get this addressed and raised it directly with the City Hall's cycling commissioner last week, but a business and jobs are at risk through the failure of Lime and others to regulate themselves. Regulations are necessary and welcome. I hope the Minister will tell us this morning when the next consultation secondary legislation will come forward, but I hope the Minister also recognizes that some solutions are available now.

Southwark Council could replicate Ealing and remove bikes at cost to providers. Constructively, the council could move the bay outside Wheelans to the verges on the opposite side of Rotherhithe Old Road. Council inaction is inexcusable, especially under a Green leader who last year filmed a promotional video for Lime inside the council office, breaking its rules, and I await the council investigation into that with some interest. Inaction is also inexcusable because the council announced a new deal for discounted bike use three months ago in an arrangement that has delivered no better management of bikes and not one person has yet had a discounted fare. It's an amateur, premature fanfare of a scheme, and conditions should have been set for clearing bikes with the providers.

Lime claim they have 400 staff to clear bays and more need directing to those sites, but they claim Southwark Council sends no one to them. Council inaction is even more inexcusable because Lime have a five million pound fund to provide bays that local authorities can bid for. Southwark has embarrassingly bid for nothing. The summit of their aspiration for our community. It seems the Greens and their Lib Dem sidekicks in Southwark are too busy obsessing over Israel and international affairs to get on with helping people in our community in Southwark.

It is incompetent, frankly, and I'll be pushing further to help everyone affected.

25:21 - 25:22

Jim Shannon.

25:22 - 27:53

Jim Shannon

It's a real pleasure to speak under your chairmanship. A big thank you to the honorable lady for Epsom and Ewell for raising this debate. I want to give a Northern Ireland perspective if I can. A senior doctor in the Belfast Trust has aptly described the number of children being injured by e-scooters as an epidemic. It is an epidemic, not just in Northern Ireland, but indeed across this whole United Kingdom.

More than 120 children within the Belfast Trust area have been treated for injuries sustained in accidents involving e-bikes and e-scooters in the past 24 months. Similar picture of course is emerging in England where a study estimates that some nearly 500 children have been injured in e-scooter accidents since 2019. Sadly, these figures don't surprise me. From my own constituency office in Strangford, I regularly see e-scooters practically fly past the window in front of my office and along the footpath, pedestrians jumping aside to avoid a collision and to avoid being injured. Across the UK, 59 deaths have been reported as involving e-scooters, 10 of which were under 18.

We can't wait for another child or an older person to be hit and suffer life-altering injuries or worse. We must do everything we can to prevent a 60th death. I welcome the Minister to his place, good to see him back in harness again, so to speak. Pedestrians are not the only ones at risk. Riders themselves are vulnerable to serious injury.

Research into major trauma cases highlights the potential for devastating head injuries and damage to internal organs. Meanwhile, reports suggest that fewer than 6% of e-scooter riders in Northern Ireland wear helmets. In England, this figure is estimated below 2%. Again, the threat of injury and maybe long-lasting injury is a serious concern that demands immediate attention. I must commend the Police Service of Northern Ireland for the work that they have done and continue to do to raise awareness that it is currently illegal to use e-scooters on public roads and footpaths in Northern Ireland.

I'm aware that the Irish police in my own constituency have made several seizures of e-scooters. Some 20 have been seized so far, giving you an idea of the problems that we have in our territory and that were being driven illegally. However, it's clear further legislation is needed to address the scale of this issue. So when the Minister gets up to speak, can he give us an idea of legislative change and the engagement that there would be with the Assembly and the PSNI in Northern Ireland? So I call on the Minister to take stronger action to regulate e-scooter use, to consider more appropriate age restrictions and a mandatory helmet requirement.

E-scooters may seem like a more convenient mode of transport for many, but the fact is they're a danger and they're a danger to the general public. Thank you.

27:53 - 27:54

Alice Macdonald.

27:54 - 30:12

Alice Macdonald

Thank you very much, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to speak in this debate and I'm very grateful to the member for Epsom and Ewell for bringing it, and particularly for underlining the potential impact of catastrophic injuries from these illegal vehicles. I would add a couple of other problems that we're seeing resultant from the lack of regulation in this area. We've seen a reduction in sales of legal e-bikes, surely not something we want to see, but that's because the proliferation of these illegal ones. We're also seeing unfortunately links with exploitation in the gig economy as well as with criminality.

And we've seen a catastrophic drop in the sales of L1 category motorbikes too. And for me this problem is really symbolic of people's feelings that there's a lack of control over their local area. This is exactly the kind of thing the Prime Minister is getting a grip on right now. So I think it's really important that we show leadership on this. My questions, Mr. Stringer, are all going to be about solutions in this area.

First, when is the Department of Transport going to be releasing its research into illegal e-bikes and food delivery, and will they push for parliamentary time to talk about that? I believe it's due in the spring. Secondly, what progress has there been on the national work-related road safety charter? Can we see some details of that please and hear about them? Thirdly, we need to see more control over the supply chain and the sales of these illegal e-bikes and e-scooters and the conversion kits.

Oversight and enforcement. One mechanism for that of course would be through the Product Regulation and Metrology Act 2025. I know that a number of us have been pushing on this. There's been three months since the consultation on that. When are we going to see some outcomes from this please?

We need to see action now. I'm sorry I won't because I want to be fair to everybody else. And finally, can we please have a commitment for the Department of Transport to be convening other departments on this? I know the minister cares passionately about this. He really cares about local people having control over their areas.

He's shown that in every role that he's had. Will he, with his department, take the initiative to bring together all the departments concerned about this? Can they do it before Christmas? Can they make a big splash about it so people hear about it in the media, so people aren't buying their kids these dangerous kits and products before Christmas and leading to those kind of injuries that we just heard about? Thank you.

30:12 - 30:13

Luke Taylor.

30:13 - 32:46

Luke Taylor

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I thank my honorable friend the member for Epsom and Ewell for bringing this important debate to the House. It's worth starting my contribution to make clear that I'm a huge fan of e-bikes. I rode my e-cargo bike to the station this morning and in term time would have dropped my two boys at school first using the bike, and I've covered more than 18,000 kilometers over the last six years.

But our discussion today should focus on illegal e-bikes and scooters, and we need to be clear and careful that we support the contribution that e-bikes make to active travel, to taking cars off our roads, reducing emissions, congestion, and also reducing road danger. I differ slightly from the honorable member. I believe that e-scooters are far too dangerous to be considered for regulation and legalization and do not in any way qualify as active travel. They should be banned or removed from our streets entirely. Like many other members here, I've spoken in this hall repeatedly about the need for tougher regulation on illegally modified e-bikes.

These vehicles plague the high street in Sutton and sadly deter many local residents from visiting the shops my town center has to offer. Delivery drivers on these bikes treat the stretch of Sutton High Street like a racetrack. They rampage along pavements at speed with no consideration for pedestrians around them. With the nights now getting darker, many even ride without light, endangering pedestrians and riders themselves.

My constituents should not have to spend their weekly shop looking over their shoulder, worried they might be mown down by a vehicle that should never have been on the road or the pavement in the first place. The dangers do not end when the bikes stop moving. E-bike batteries are causing fires across the capital, as we saw recently locally in Mitcham, a fire that ripped through homes, as the honorable member for Mitcham and Morden has already mentioned. The increase in illegal e-bike conversions, fires, and accidents on our streets are driven by two main causes: the sales of high-powered e-bikes like Sur-Rons, and secondly, the multi-million pound delivery companies who incentivize riders to use faster vehicles but take no responsibility for ensuring their vehicles are legal and being ridden legally. We Liberal Democrats want to see delivery platforms required to verify the bikes being used by their riders are road-legal.

Regular checks should be in place to ensure that illegally modified vehicles are not being used to complete food orders for pay. There must be clear consequences for companies that repeatedly fail to act to protect the public. Corporate giants of the gig economy world cannot continue to hide behind the self-employed status of their riders to seek impunity from responsibility. They already have the technology to track their drivers, identify them, and verify that they are using the right accounts. They must be required to take reasonable steps to ensure the vehicles being used to make delivery orders are legal.

Thank you.

32:46 - 32:48

Speaker 26

Lola McEvoy.

32:48 - 35:16

Laura Marie McEvoy

Thank you, Chair. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I pay tribute to the honorable lady for bringing this important debate. On May the 16th, 2024, just before 1:00 p.m., 86-year-old Gloria Stevenson was walking her daughter's dog using the zebra crossing when she was hit by an 18-year-old riding a Sur-Ron e-bike. Gloria died at the scene. My constituent, Julie Francis, lost her mother that day, and she has a petition for more police funding and has been a vocal campaigner for more action to get these bikes off the road.

In September, I brought her to this place to meet the policing minister, and Julie's ask of all of us is simple: don't let my mother's death be in vain. The rise of these e-bikes, e-scooters in Darlington is a major problem. It's obvious by the cross-section of representation here today that we are not alone. Balaclava-wearing men tearing through our town, deliberately intimidating everyone else on and off the road, is a visible degradation of our collective social contract. They're literally running amok, Minister, and I and my constituents have had enough.

Ban them is the most tempered and appropriate for this place call from residents. Many have suggested other measures that I won't go into here, but the truth is they are banned. It's already illegal to ride these dirt bikes, motocross bikes, and e-scooters on our roads. But aside from seizing them and crushing them, which Durham police are doing a great job of, and I attended a scrapyard recently and crushed 70 of them with the police, they do not have the powers alone to tackle this issue. One of the reasons this issue has become so prolific is that it requires a multi-department approach.

So my ask of the minister today is that will the minister review the dirt bike licensing regime because it's clearly ineffective, and in the Northeast, we currently have 34 licensed Sur-Ron bikes. I saw more than that crushed two weeks ago. So would he consider mirroring the gun licensing regulation to enforce stricter requirements for UK legitimate purchases? Would he consider increasing the penalty for driving these dirt bikes without a license? Would he consider banning the sale of e-scooters entirely from our high street retailers?

And finally, would he bring together a cross-department task force to regulate the importing of these dangerous kits and ultimately these illegal bikes from our streets?

35:16 - 35:17

Chris Coghlan.

35:17 - 37:03

Lewis Cocking

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I thank the honorable member for Epsom and Ewell for securing this vital debate. Every time I speak to people right across Vauxhall, this is on top of their mind.

If you were to ask someone about the regulation of e-scooters and e-bikes, they would say quite simply, what regulation? As far as they're concerned, there is none. All of us know the day-to-day anti-social behavior linked to e-bikes and e-scooters and are familiar with the horrific stories of their misuse. I have seen it many times, gangs of masked up hooligans riding in packs, terrorizing our high streets with no regard to anyone else's safety. It makes a mockery of law and order and we need to see a proper crackdown.

So what are the regulations? I checked the government's website before this debate, not something anyone would do who's riding an e-bike anti-socially. The fastest e-bikes need to be registered, taxed, and insured and riders need a license and a helmet. But you don't need to be Sherlock Holmes to figure out the individuals hiding their identity with a balaclava would not do any of that. We need to see a joined up approach right across government including the Department of Transport.

In the other place, the transport minister said the government recognizes the role that electric cycles and scooters can play in supporting growth, improving health and reducing emissions. What a load of nonsense. This is far from the reality faced by people right across the United Kingdom including my constituency of Vauxhall. The government needs to get a grip and use the full force of the law to stop illegal use of e-bikes and e-scooters.

37:03 - 37:06

Speaker 30

Oh, sorry. Julie Minns.

37:06 - 39:17

Julie Minns

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I congratulate the member for bringing this important debate. I will confine my remarks to e-bikes and let me begin by emphasizing that legal e-bikes do have an important role to play in sustainable transport and active travel. But vehicles that do not meet the definition of an electrically assisted pedal cycle and are used on the highway are illegal road vehicles and should, in my view, be banned from sale. Earlier this year, I presented a bill that proposed exactly that.

Illegal e-bikes, whether sold as such or converted using kits, pose serious safety risks as we've already heard. They reach speeds for which their frames and braking systems were never designed. They kill pedestrians and endanger other road users. Their batteries catch fire and cause devastating house fires and death. They facilitate criminal activity such as phone theft, drug dealing, and they're a persistent nuisance in parks, pavements and around stations.

Their ready availability online also undermines legitimate markets as we've heard. They depress the sale of legal tested EAPCs and low-powered motorcycles. Meanwhile, the Motor Insurers' Bureau is settling millions of pounds in claims every single year for accidents involving these illegal bikes and the cost of that is borne by law-abiding motorists through higher premiums. Mr. Stringer, the government must act with urgency to tackle this problem and it has the means to do so. The Product Safety and Metrology Act gives ministers powers to designate products that are unsafe and regulate to remove them from sale.

So can I ask the minister to therefore tell members what discussion he has had with colleagues in the Department for Business about using those powers? And does he agree with me that the continued availability of illegal e-bikes is undermining confidence in legitimate cycling and risks tarnishing the cycling celebration that is the Tour de France when it comes to Britain and more importantly, my constituency of Carlisle next year.

39:17 - 39:18

Josh Babarinde.

39:18 - 41:53

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Thank you, Mr. Stringer and thank you to the honorable member for Epsom and Ewell, who is a legend for bringing this debate forward and giving us all the opportunity to speak about this issue that blights our communities.

150 years ago, the fastest vehicle that you would find on Eastbourne seafront was a horse-drawn bathing machine taking people down to the sea. Today, it is an e-bike or e-scooter, illegal e-bike or e-scooter, jockeyed by a balaclava-wearing rider. And the same is true of places like Terminus Road, our high street, or indeed King's Drive, where the Eastbourne mobility scooter no longer rules the pavement, but it is the vehicles that we have been mentioning. And Sussex Police recorded a 53.7% rise in reports of illegal e-bike and e-scooter use in the year to June, and seized 321 vehicles between January and July. And as has been rightly said by many, including the member for Sutton and Cheam, we're fans of active travel and encouraging people to use more environmentally friendly means to get from A to B.

But the dangerous minority of these riders and indeed these vehicles put pedestrians at risk and give responsible users of active travel a bad name. And more than this, failed e-bike and e-scooter batteries have been responsible for devastating fires, like that in Whitley Road in Eastbourne. And indeed the fire service have said that we've seen people forced into jumping from windows as they cannot get out of their front doors as the bike or scooter which has caught fire is in front of it. There are enormous safety risks. But other jurisdictions are showing the way and leadership on this issue.

In New York City, banning the sale of uncertified e-bikes saw deaths from battery fires fall from 18 to just one in two years. In New South Wales in Australia, police now test bikes at the roadside and crush illegal ones on the spot. So I hope the minister will consider granting our police and law enforcement the same kind of tools, will regulate this sector adequately.

41:53 - 42:13

Siobhain McDonagh

Very quickly. Is he aware, is the chair aware that it has cost the Metropolitan Police half a million pounds in illegal e-bike battery fires in their own pounds because they have confiscated 3,000 illegal e-bikes in the last year?

42:13 - 42:35

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Of course, the costs are financial, but the costs are to human life and livelihood as well. And so I hope the minister will recognize that and commit to meeting representatives of Sussex Police who hold the national brief for road crime in order to look at how we can best tackle this in Sussex and the town of Eastbourne.

42:35 - 42:37

Speaker 33

Richard Baker.

42:37 - 45:16

Richard Baker

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And the human impact of the illegal use of e-bikes was powerfully set out by the member for Epsom and Ewell at the beginning of this debate. And this is certainly something we're aware of in my constituency, where Peggy Maxwell, who is 94, was mown down by a teenager on a Sur-Ron e-bike. Peggy suffered a broken neck, back, clavicle, and ribs, and she was hospitalized for three months.

Many people would not have expected Peggy to come back from those injuries at her age, but she's determined and she is formidable. And she did, and she attended a public meeting on e-bikes we held in Lochgelly last month with her family, who are now also campaigning for new laws on their use. And can I add to the calls which have been made right across this chamber this morning for more action on enforcement, on point of sale and regulation, and also diversion from the illegal use of e-bikes as well.

In Scotland, this requires action from both Westminster and Holyrood. I've been working on this issue with David Barrett MSP for Cowdenbeath. I'm pleased he's secured a commitment from the Scottish Government that any bikes seized by police will be destroyed and not sold on. I think that should be the course of action by all police forces. This government has taken more action to give police more powers to seize e-bikes.

It's vital we have that action by the Scottish Government as well for forces in Scotland. And it's also very, very important we consider what action we need to take at point of sale as well. Many people buying these bikes will be unaware they can't be used on public roads. So there needs to be information from vendors to those buying these bikes at that point, often for their children. And we also have to consider further action on regulation and registration as well.

I very much support the comments made by both the members for Darlington and Carlisle in this area. Vendors need to have more responsibilities on this issue placed on them by government. And finally on diversion, we've got a great charity in my constituency, Kingdom Off Road, who give people who've used e-bikes illegally previously the chance to use them safely and legally on a purpose-designed track, often on bikes which have been seized by the police, which sounds to me a really good approach to take. And I hope we can see that supported across the country. The enjoyment and the convenience of e-bikes and e-scooters for some is now seriously outweighed by the harms caused for many, and that is why it is now time for this government to take further action.

45:16 - 45:18

Speaker 35

Adam Dance.

45:18 - 47:25

Adam Dance

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. And I want to thank my honorable friend for securing this debate and all the campaigning she's been doing on this really important issue. Illegal modified e-bikes and scooters have become more and more of a problem in Yeovil. Peter lives on Sherborne Road, which is a very, very busy road out of Yeovil. He is always very careful when he crosses.

He always sticks to the pavements. But for Peter, pavements have become just as dangerous as the roads. Not for the first time, he was left one step away from A&E after someone came crashing by on an e-scooter doing 30 miles per hour. Sadly, Peter is not alone, because the problem isn't just one or two troublemakers in Yeovil, but this is happening at a scale across our communities and often comes with other forms of anti-social behavior. Carol has been telling me how she keeps seeing people on modified e-bikes traveling at speed down Middle Street in the wrong direction, dodging pedestrians.

Nikki told me about how it's unsafe to take her seven-year-old nephew to the park because kids are crashing up and down on e-scooters. Katrina has told me about the near misses involving dogs, young children, and the elderly. I mean, just the other day I was out canvassing and three lads shot past me on e-scooters in balaclavas shouting abuse at other residents. It is just a matter of time before someone gets really badly hurt, including the people riding these, as we've heard today. So it goes without saying that we need to get our police to carry out focused enforcement interventions.

So we need interventions from the government in the form of training and funding. I think we also need proper education campaigns on this, and that by I do not just mean going into schools and giving them more work to do. We need something on the scale of Think! campaign, particularly on social media. In Parliament, we need to be pushing clear legislation on this because the current legal framework for e-bikes is confusing, outdated, and rarely enforced. And most importantly, government needs to proper crank down on the supply chain and unregulated online marketplaces that are selling floods our streets with these illegal vehicles.

That means road tax, insurance, and sticking to the rules. People in Yeovil are rightly angry that these people on illegal e-bikes and scooters, and those that sell them, do none of that, put people at risk, and get away with it. That cannot be able to go on anymore. Thank you.

To get anywhere in Somerset, you pretty much have to drive.

47:38 - 47:39

Beatrice Costigan.

47:39 - 49:47

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Pleasure to speak under your chairmanship, Mr. Stringer, and I thank the honorable member for bringing this debate. From commuters trying to get to Southall station in the morning to my 82-year-old constituent trying to get to Ealing Hospital along Boston Road, e-bikes on the pavement are a daily annoyance in Ealing Southall. Now, people think that the council is to blame, but the truth is the council has almost no powers when it comes to e-bikes and e-scooters. In fact, anyone in Ealing could set up an e-bike company in the morning. I could do it myself, and there is nothing the council could do to stop me.

All the council can do is try to agree a voluntary memorandum of understanding with e-bike companies. But this is just a gentleman's agreement. It's not the law. In reality, e-bike companies can do whatever they want. This has led to a Wild West situation in London, a patchwork of companies all operating in different boroughs.

It's why you've got bikes piled up at borough boundaries, and it's almost impossible to hold companies to account for bad parking or massive oversupplies of bikes in some areas. In Ealing, in fact, Ealing made a voluntary agreement with two companies, Forest and Lime, but a third company, Voi, is refusing to leave the borough, and there's really not a lot the council can do about it. So I'm absolutely delighted that this Labour government has actually already taken concrete action after years of inaction by the previous government. And the English Devolution Act, which was passed before the summer, will finally give councils and mayors the powers to license e-bikes and hopefully also e-scooter companies. Although there are still some steps needed to be taken in Parliament to formally pass these powers to the Mayor of London, it will mean we can set London-wide rules for e-bikes, including on mandatory parking spaces, age limits for riders, and insurance.

We'll also be able to fine companies who don't play by these rules. The previous government just didn't have the courage to act, but Labour is doing what we promised, devolving powers to local communities so they can make the rules in their areas. Now, all we need now, and I look at the minister, is for him to hop on his e-scooter and pick up the pace a bit so that we can get these powers transferred to the Mayor of London as soon as possible. Thank you.

49:47 - 49:48

Charlie Maynard.

49:48 - 52:18

Charlie Maynard

Thank you, Mr. Stringer, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I thank my honorable friend for Yeovil, Epsom and Ewell, for securing this debate and her excellent speech. Like others here today, the dangerous misuse of e-bikes and e-scooters is being raised with me more and more, and in my Witney constituency, current regulations are not working well and lead to a lot of confusion. One of my constituents wrote to me saying that their friend had been arrested for riding an e-scooter. It turns out they had no idea that their privately owned e-scooters are illegal on roads, cycle paths, and pavements in the UK. Another constituent wrote to me saying that they had seen e-bikes advertised on Argos's website, and only in the questions and comments did it say, oh, this is only for private land use.

And Thames Valley locally are finding bikes and seizing them, which are able to go 120 miles an hour. So and this problem keeps growing. By some estimates, there's more than a million e-scooters now in use across the country with no standards for speed, brakes, or batteries. High-powered e-bikes and conversion kits are being sold for off-road use and then ridden on roads. Uncertified batteries sold online cause deadly fires.

Victims of illegal machines face an insurance gap, and rental scooter trials, as my friend has mentioned, has been extended again and again for the last since 2020. There is some good news. Since June, the Crime and Policing Act has let police seize antisocially ridden e-bikes without a warning, and seizures nearly doubled to about 7,000 last year. But overall, legislation is outdated and hard to enforce. I believe we should do what many others many other countries have done already.

Private e-scooters should be legalized and regulated with a speed cap, product standards, lights, and a minimum age, so police can concentrate on machines that don't comply. Over-specced e-bikes and conversion kits should be stopped at the point of sale. That means making online marketplaces legally responsible, funding trading standards appropriately, and requiring battery certification. Faster or modified bikes could be required to carry registration or plates, and delivery platforms required to check that their riders' bikes are legal. And the police also need practical help: funding for testing equipment and specialist teams, cheaper storage and quick crushing of seized bikes, fixed penalties for lower-level offenses, and compulsory insurance for faster e-bikes.

52:18 - 54:49

Speaker 41

Thank you, Mr. Stringer, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and could I also thank the member for Epsom and Ewell for securing today's very important debate. I am aware of the pressure on time, so I'll try to be brief, and I should say that I strongly support cycling and legal use of electric bicycles where permitted. However, Mr. Stringer, I'm afraid to say that the irresponsible use of e-bikes and e-scooters is a serious problem in my constituency of Reading Central, and there are a range of issues that have been raised with me by residents on a range of fronts. So first of all, intimidating behavior on footpaths and pavements, in particular near parks and in parks, is causing a serious level of concern in many parts of the town. This includes e-scooters whizzing down narrow streets where the pavements are less than a meter wide, e-bike riders riding over bridges, the two bridges across the Thames, the two road bridges over the Thames on the pedestrian footpaths and intimidating residents, the lack of use of bells, the speed with which people are riding these bikes.

And also it includes high-powered electric motorbikes, I think is the only way to describe them. And I myself have seen two absolutely shocking incidents relating to these types of vehicles. In one case, I saw a group of young people, black-clad with black balaclavas on, riding around the Reading inner distribution road, which is a major highway around the town center, pulling wheelies in front of cars. At another occasion, I saw another group, similarly dressed, doing dangerous stunts, jumps in a park close to where families were picnicking with toddlers. This is absolutely irresponsible and utterly unacceptable, Mr. Stringer.

I am pleased, however, there is some good news. Thames Valley Police, as one of the other members mentioned earlier, are taking a very firm line on this. They have been crushing these bikes. They've been using drones to follow them in parks and to use the new legislation introduced by the government recently to arrive at people's houses and confiscate them immediately rather than having to issue a warning, which was previously the case. Also, in our area, our local council has secured a public space protection order, which gives local council officers more powers to address this very serious problem.

So I would like to praise the police and the council for the action they're taking, but I would also like to ask the minister to see what further powers could be used to try to constrain this very, very serious problem. Thank you, Mr. Stringer.

54:49 - 57:18

Charles Noah Law

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. Within my constituency of St Austell and Newquay, the communications I recently held on anti-social behavior with residents have highlighted major concerns about e-bikes and other powered bikes being ridden not just around town but in abandoned China clay pits, on footpaths, and along other rights of way. My constituents have rightly raised concerns about safety and the impact on those shared spaces, on anti-social behavior where rules are deliberately ignored by riders. These concerns should not be dismissed, and our constituents are right to expect the law to be enforced effectively. So I welcome this government's additional powers to seize and dispose of dangerous vehicles being used unlawfully and the wider efforts to tackle the sale of unsafe and illegal products.

Those measures should help us ensure that the enforcement agencies can respond much more effectively.

But at the same time, I think there is a wider point to contribute to this debate, particularly when it comes to young people. Many young people are drawn to e-bikes because of the freedom they offer and the independence and a sense of community that they offer. Now that interest in itself is not a problem to be regulated as strict as we must be in some of the other measures that we've described today. And that is something that an interest that can be channeled into sports, into skills, into training and volunteering opportunities. And that's why I want to highlight the work of the Cornwall Bicycle Project in Par, which provides those vital skills development, volunteering and community engagement opportunities, engaging people from a wide range of backgrounds, including those who've struggled in mainstream education and are looking for routes into employment and training.

So the model ensures that the enthusiasm for e-bikes can be channeled into a positive way. It can be a practical route into learning new skills. It can build confidence and responsibility. It can create connections within those communities. I should lastly recognize the role that Imerys has played more broadly in supporting access to nature, outdoor recreation and sports within the China Clay area.

But it shouldn't be down to one company to solve this huge issue in our area, Mr. Stringer. This means that government, local authorities, police, business, community organizations and education providers need to be supported by our government in a strategic manner to play their part.

57:18 - 57:26

Graham Stringer

We now move on to the frontbench speeches. Olly Glover on behalf of the Lib Dems.

57:26 - 01:02:59

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And can I thank my honorable friend, the member for Epsom and Ewell, for setting out the case for regulation of e-bikes and e-scooters with great passion and conviction. She spoke very movingly of the loss of her constituent's life, Jacob, and she highlighted how there is an enormous geographical range of police forces that are very concerned about this issue. And honorable members from across the country spoke with great thought on some of the key themes of this debate.

First and foremost, the human impact of this problem of illegally modified and used e-bikes and e-scooters. The deaths, the injuries, but also the fear that so many people have, particularly people with disabilities or who may be partially sighted. And the fact that this problem means that pavements are no longer thought of by everybody as a place of refuge from motor traffic, somewhere that can be relied upon to safely complete a journey. And some honorable members also highlighted the growing financial impact of this problem in terms of insurance payouts as a result of users of these vehicles who are not insured and therefore everybody else is bearing the cost of that through increased premiums. Honorable members also highlighted the problems of battery fires and how this growing problem sometimes leads to loss of life.

And they also quite rightly highlighted the need for greater enforcement, more support for our police and more resources for our police in dealing with this issue. Now part of that comes from the complexity of what an e-bike or an e-scooter is or isn't. A legally, a legal e-bike is has pedal-assisted electric power up to a speed of 15 and a half miles an hour, no more. And e-scooters, there is a in some place parts of the country there are trials that have been going on for very long, but in most places there aren't and that adds to the complexity of this topic. Now on battery fires, the vast majority according to statistics from the Office for Product Safety and Standards do arise from conversion kits and unknown brands of e-bike, highlighting the need for much greater product regulation.

In 2025 London's Metropolitan Police seized more than 2,200 illegal e-bikes and e-scooters across London. In the first seven months of 2026 it seized more than 2,500 already exceeding the whole of 2025. In March 2026 a two-day enforcement operation seized 52 illegal e-bikes and mopeds. London's Fire Brigade reports that e-bike fires have doubled between 2022 and 2025 with most fires caused by illegally modified or designed e-bikes and their batteries. And many people see some food delivery couriers using e-bikes sometimes illegally modified in a reckless and inconsiderate manner.

Mr Stringer there is also a great opportunity if we can get e-bikes right. In 2024 the UK sold just 2.1 e-bikes per 1,000 people compared to 8.5 in France and a staggering 36.1 in Denmark. And if we don't buck that trend it means we're unlikely to achieve the continuation of cycling into older age that still happens in the Netherlands with e-bike travel accounting for over 50% of cycling distance in the 65 to 75 age bracket. So there is an opportunity here as well as a problem that needs to be solved. Now as well as the many honourable members from many parties who have spoken on this issue, the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Cycling and Walking conducted an inquiry into this issue last year and produced a very thoughtful and wide-ranging report.

At the Liberal Democrat conference in September, that's still last month, how time is a very strange concept in this job I find. At our party conference we passed definitive policy on the need to take much tougher action on this issue of illegally modified e-bikes and their use. And the strength of feeling in this room shows that there is a widespread lack of confidence that the current government is taking the coordinated sustained action that we need to see on this issue. It's a multi-faceted problem that covers that straddles many government departments. And we know from many select committee reports and Institute for Government that alas problems that straddle multiple departments are not always ones that we have been good at tackling.

But hopefully the minister will give us some assurance that a multi-pronged multi-departmental approach will be taken on this issue. Our ask of the government are as follows. We need to tackle the root cause which is the supply chains. We need to make online retailers police and stop the sale of all non-conforming e-bikes, conversion kits, batteries and chargers, deal with the problem at its source. We need to deal with the perverse incentives created by the gig economy.

The phenomenon of worker substitution makes avoiding individual identification and accountability too easy. And the pay-per-delivery model used by many of the delivery platforms incentivises reckless and illegal behaviour. And delivery platforms should be undertaking their own speed and e-bike checks. They need to take some responsibility of this issue.

01:02:59 - 01:03:18

Siobhain McDonagh

Is the member aware that UCL published data this week indicating almost three quarters of those delivery riders surveyed were concerned about the batteries of their own bikes catching fire while one in ten had personally experienced overheating?

01:03:18 - 01:04:53

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

I thank the honourable lady for her intervention. And those statistics absolutely highlight the problem and the fact that these delivery companies they need to take ownership of this rather than dumping the problem on everybody else leading to the demonisation of their workforce and expecting the government to clear up their mess.

They need to take action as well and if they won't, then they need to be regulated much more toughly. Government also needs to get on with legislating to clearly and consistently regulate e-scooters. The current post-COVID lottery of arrangements is unhelpful for everybody. We also need a government-backed e-bike safety certification scheme, building on actions being taken by the cycling industry to come up with their own kite mark showing that an e-bike is indeed safely manufactured and compliant with legal standards. Our police need much greater support.

They need greater powers, they need more training on how to identify illegal e-bikes and they need appropriate resources. And we should also consider a national swap or amnesty scheme for illegally modified or designed e-bikes and e-scooters so that people can come forward. And we heard a little bit about that from the honorable member for Glenrothes and Mid Fife about how seized e-bikes can be used for positive purpose. And there are good examples from New York of where such amnesty schemes have been done. Now of course the biggest issue that, the biggest reason why this needs to be tackled is the human impact that we've heard, both in terms of deaths and injuries and the increase in fear and nervousness for using our streets.

01:04:53 - 01:04:55

Speaker 42

I shall give way to the honorable lady.

01:04:55 - 01:05:14

Anna Dixon

I'm very grateful to the honorable member for giving way. I spoke recently to an A and E doctor in my constituency who was witnessing the rising catastrophic injuries, particularly to children and young people as a consequence of these. Does he not agree with me that we have to get to the source of this, ban the conversion kits and stop these deadly bikes?

01:05:14 - 01:05:44

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

I do agree and she's absolutely right to highlight the impact that this issue has on our health service as well. And there's also the economic impact that we've heard from the insurance issue. But in addition to that, there is a real risk that if this problem isn't dealt with, it will undermine the government's commendable aims of increasing walking, cycling and wheeling and all of the health and congestion reduction benefits that result from that. So I look forward to hearing the minister's comments and I hope to see the multi-departmental tough action we need on this issue.

01:05:44 - 01:08:17

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. A pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I commend the honorable lady for Epsom and Ewell for securing this debate. We have all heard from constituents about the problems caused by the illegal use of these vehicles. Whether that is people riding e-bikes on the pavement, e-bikes clearly operating in violation of existing rules, private scooters on the road and the serious issues that has come out in this debate of lithium-ion fires on public safety. The concerns we hear from the public about these devices underscore why effective and proportionate regulation is necessary.

People need to know that those using these vehicles are following the rules of the road. However, I do think it's worth acknowledging that combining the two issues in this debate does risk being somewhat redundant. Given that where we are not discussing dockless rental schemes, the regulatory regimes governing the two types of vehicle are very different. When it comes to e-bikes, there is a clear set of rules that govern their use. The technical limits set out in the Electrically Assisted Pedal Cycles Regulations and standards sets out a reasonably robust framework for their use, but as we've heard in this debate, there is a need to go further.

This raises the fundamental point that we need to consider when examining the regulation of these vehicles. Are the regulations we already have in place being followed? That is why we must address the need for much stronger approach to enforcement of the existing laws and regulations. Over the last couple of years, several local and national news organizations have highlighted the increased illegal use of e-bikes and e-scooters.

For example, Mr Stringer, data obtained under Freedom of Information requests revealed that the number of crimes committed on e-bikes in London alone exceeded 10,000 in 2023, but only 221 of them resulted in the perpetrator being caught and charged, a pretty poor rate of 2.2%. If we are to be completely honest, it would not take long to spot an e-bike flouting the law, or someone riding an e-bike flouting the law, if you were to walk out of Parliament right now and observe a nearby crossing.

01:08:17 - 01:08:46

Anna Dixon

Will the honourable gentleman give way? Having been out with my local police, it is clear that they do not have the powers to pursue these very fast illegal e-bikes in order to detain people, and the evidence is not possible because of balaclavas. So does he recognise that this government's action to give police stronger powers to seize and destroy bikes from garages and lock-ups is a really proportionate response to tackling this problem at source and helping the police do their job?

01:08:46 - 01:09:35

Greg Gregory Smith

I'm grateful to the honourable lady. I don't think we are a million miles away on this, but there has been a debate in this chamber this morning of colleagues from all parties in the House, all setting out serious concerns. And greater powers and greater enforcement abilities for the police is always to be welcomed, but as my honourable friend for Stockton West set out, he tried to get much stronger regulations and enforcement powers put into legislation during this Parliament and the government resisted it. So I think it would be... one second... I think it would be foolish to pretend that all the powers that are needed are out there. We would not, literally not be stood in Westminster Hall this morning debating it if all was fine and rosy, and I'll happily give way.

01:09:35 - 01:10:00

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way on this point. Obviously after 14 years in a position of power to do something about this issue, we would expect that the party opposite would be supporting our next stage of policing regulation that should be coming down the line in this King's Speech. Does he agree with me that it would be great if we could see some of the amendments in the Policing Bill, the forthcoming Policing Bill, that relate to the regulation of off-road bikes?

01:10:00 - 01:10:19

Greg Gregory Smith

I'm grateful to the honourable lady. I mean, I would suggest, I know the 14 years line is well-rehearsed, but e-bikes weren't actually a thing for a long, a long proportion of the 14 years of the last government, nor were e-scooters. I will give way once more.

01:10:19 - 01:10:37

Julie Minns

Just, I mean, just on this point, the loophole on the use of off-road bikes, which is what's exploited for the use of illegal e-bikes, has existed since the 1988 Road Traffic Act. So it could have been closed, does he accept it could have been closed in the last 14 years?

01:10:37 - 01:15:12

Greg Gregory Smith

I, I accept the honourable lady's point on off-road bikes and dirt bikes, but the, the point I was addressing was one of e-bikes and e-scooters, the technology of which did not exist. These products were not even for sale for a large proportion of that, of that time. I, I said I was, I said I was going to only give way once more. I fully appreciate it's a debate and I do give way a lot in, in debates, but I do need to make the rest of my comments. So, almost as if it had been pre-written for the intervention I took first, that is why we need to support the police with the resources they need to tackle both the illegal use of these vehicles and their use as enablers to other offences.

I appreciate that the government introduced legislative changes last year to make it easier to seize some of these vehicles, but those changes can only be effective if the relevant authorities have the resources to actually enforce them. Furthermore, I hope the minister will ask their colleagues to consider policies that enable the police to intervene whenever they witness dangerous behavior involving e-bikes and e-scooters, as well as ways to impose tougher penalties. Illegal behavior must be appropriately punished. There must be consequences. This must be combined with increased police recruitment to ensure that officers are available to tackle this reckless behavior, including targeted enforcement in locations where crime is most prevalent.

However, under this government, we have unfortunately seen a reduction in overall police officer numbers. As such, we should commend the police forces that are using existing regulations to tackle the illegal use of these vehicles and finding innovative ways to discourage illegal behavior. One recent example is the City of London Police's use of its so-called sin bin, designed specifically for cyclists who ride through red lights or across zebra crossings. Those caught are required to watch a safety video, which takes considerably longer than simply waiting for the light to change. Now, of course, this could apply to any bike, but we regularly see users of e-bike schemes engaging in this kind of behavior.

By removing the perceived benefit of jumping a red light or riding illegally across a crossing, measures such as this could help deter such behavior. At the same time, many of us have seen the increasing use of private e-scooters alongside the illegal use of e-bikes. Figures released by the Metropolitan Police in July showed that it had confiscated more e-scooters in the first seven months of the year than it had in the previous whole calendar year. Now, some people may ask whom this behavior harms, but the answer is clear. If we cannot enforce the rules we already have in place, we risk endangering the public, particularly disabled people who rely on our road safety infrastructure to protect them.

That brings us to the dockless e-bike and e-scooter rental schemes that have also been mentioned in today's debate and have become increasingly prevalent. Disability charities, particularly those representing people with visual impairment, have highlighted the significant challenges posed by these schemes. Research by the Royal National Institute of Blind People has shown that 81% of survey respondents said that bikes or e-scooters left on pavements made their journeys more difficult. Therefore, I understand the desire to call for appropriate regulation of these businesses. In fact, a number of these organizations have called on local government and in particular the Mayor of London to show leadership on this issue, to be clear what local government wants to achieve from these schemes.

I hope that we should follow the approach set out by the leadership of Westminster City Council. Dockless bikes are here to stay, but poorly parked bikes have become a major headache for pedestrians and businesses, indeed a danger. It is worth noting that at a meeting with the major operators in August, Westminster City Council agreed to share data that would give the authority a much more accurate picture of the thousands of vehicles operating in the borough. The council also stated that dockless bike operators were considering removing or relocating parking bays near taxi ranks and disabled parking bays to help keep pavements clear. Working with these companies in a way that allows them to operate safely and legally is the principal way we should approach the problem.

01:15:12 - 01:15:32

Speaker 20

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. Is he on the point about Westminster Council and that data issue, is he supporting the Mayor of London's request that the new regulations coming forward from the government do actually require all providers to share the information on how many bikes and vehicles they have on the road in our capital and wherever they're operating elsewhere? Obviously, I have a London interest.

01:15:32 - 01:15:41

Graham Stringer

I'm grateful. The honorable gentleman has been generous with the interventions, but he's coming to the end of his time, I presume he'll draw his remarks to a conclusion.

01:15:41 - 01:16:14

Greg Gregory Smith

Of course, Mr. Stringer. I recognize the honorable gentleman's point and data sharing as as led by Westminster City Council and if the Mayor of London is doing that, that is something that is straightforward and sensible to be done. We need real action from this government. We need the serious problems that have been identified by all sides of the house in this debate to be taken seriously and that means listening to all sides of the house and ensuring that the sensible suggestions that have been put down during this debate are actually met.

01:16:14 - 01:16:25

Graham Stringer

In calling the minister, can I request that he leaves two, three minutes at the end for the proposer to wind up. Minister.

01:16:25 - 01:18:01

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to see you in the chair this morning. Can I start by thanking the honorable member for Epsom and Ewell for securing this debate and for the many honorable members who have made contributions this morning. Although this is billed as a transport debate, there's clearly a number of other government departments who have some influence and interest in this matter, not least the Home Office as I think a lot of the debate has talked about the impact of reckless and illegal use of e-scooters and e-bikes in all of our constituencies, ranging from nuisance to antisocial behavior to downright criminality. And of course we've heard a number of tragic stories about the serious harm that misuse can cause, including serious life-changing injuries and indeed fatalities.

So I want to start by reassuring honorable members that I and the government do understand the importance of the issues raised today. And it is correct to say, as a number of members have said, that e-bikes and e-scooters have a role to play in our communities. They do provide another transport option and they have the potential to improve individuals' health and reduce emissions. But, and as we've heard very clearly today, an inconsistent approach to regulations and sales over the years has left loopholes that at best confuse people and at worst leave this area open for criminal abuse. And as the honorable member for Carlisle said, this illegal activity is undermining the positive story that we would want to be talking about for the use of these vehicles.

01:18:01 - 01:18:03

Speaker 48

I will, yes.

01:18:03 - 01:18:38

Speaker 50

Thank you very much, Minister. As people across this debate, indeed across this chamber are facing huge problems in my constituency with bike gangs and those who are causing real harm to my community, I'd like to thank the Minister, the government for all the work that they've done, the more police, the more powers, the more local work as well, banning balaclavas, careless social careless bike riding banning as well, as well as getting TikTok accounts taken down, winning for all of us, building a safer community. But can the Minister assure me that this is not the end, that we will keep going further and further to stop these bike gangs and keep my community safe?

01:18:38 - 01:18:53

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Grateful to the honorable member for his intervention. As he will hear in the rest of my speech, there are a number of areas where we will be going further and and absolutely recognizing the concerns raised today. One after the last one, we've got a lot to fit in.

01:18:53 - 01:19:18

Jim Shannon

Just quickly, Minister, while it comes to legislative change and we all look for that there, there has to be something within the system of purchase of bikes to ensure that young people don't enter them, those who have the e-bikes. We've had over a hundred people in Belfast Trust who have been injured, young people driving them. Is it not important to have some sort of regulation and some sort of guidance for those people who perhaps don't want to break the law but end up doing so and injuring themselves?

01:19:18 - 01:27:35

Justin Piers Richard Madders

I'm grateful to the honorable member for his intervention.

There is an awful lot we need to be looking at in terms of the retail element of this, which I'll come on to shortly. Mr. Stringer, we've heard a number of contributions from members today, from the right honorable member for Oxford East, honorable members for Darlington, Mitcham and Morden, Bermondsey and Old Southwark, Carlisle, Glenrothes and Mid Fife, Ealing and Southall, Reading Central, St Austell and Newquay, Rushcliffe, Leeds South West and Morley, Tamworth, Derby North, Wolverhampton West, Shipley, Roxburgh, Stockport, Stockton West, Eastbourne, Sutton and Cheam, Yeovil, Witney, Strangford, and East Londonderry, which I think explains quite clearly that this is a nationwide issue that members across the House are particularly interested in. So if members will forgive me, I won't be able to address every single comment that's been made, but I'll pick out a few that I can address now, and we will respond in writing either from myself or the relevant minister for other issues that we are not able to pick up. My honorable friend the member for Mitcham and Morden, who I know has campaigned for a long time on this, has mentioned the e-bike fires issue, which as the former minister responsible for the Product Regulation and Metrology Act, I am personally well aware of and have met Sofia Duarte's mother, and absolutely agree on the importance that we bring forward the regulations on that, and I will address that in due course. My honorable friend the member for Bermondsey and Old Southwark probably shared a little bit too much information about his body shape with the House, but he did ask an important question about the national licensing framework, and I can confirm that the consultation will be beginning on that imminently.

My honorable friend the member for Darlington mentioned the tragic circumstances of her constituent Gloria, and I absolutely hear what her daughter Julie has said, and can reassure her that we will act on that. She mentioned a review of the dirt bike licensing regime, that's something I'll come back to her in writing on, but she was also right, as were the honorable members for Glenrothes and Mid Fife, and the honorable member for Witney, and indeed several other members mentioned about the responsibility of retailers in this area. Frankly, Mr. Stringer, putting in small print that these vehicles are only for use on private land is not good enough. It is not the action of a responsible retailer. So let me be clear, we expect retailers to clean up their act, and if they're not able to do that, then there are more levers available for us to deal with that.

I think it would help, Mr. Stringer, if I briefly set out the current legislative framework. The Electrically Assisted Pedal Cycles Regulations 1983 set out the parameters for what is legal and what is not. The power of the electric motor on a legal e-bike cannot exceed 250 watts, and the maximum assisted speed cannot exceed 15 and a half miles an hour. Anything faster or more powerful is an electric motorbike and therefore should be approved and registered with the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency, taxed and insured, and the rider must also wear a safety helmet and hold a driving license. A vehicle that is too fast or too powerful and which is not properly registered as an electric motorbike is illegal for use on public roads, and we need to absolutely restate that.

But as the honorable member for Epsom and Ewell has mentioned some of the concerns that the police don't have enough powers, I think it is fair to say, as a number of honorable members recognized, that the government have made this process easier for the police to act thanks to measures in the Crime and Policing Act, which I'm afraid the opposition spokesperson forgot to mention his party voted against at third reading. But the police can now seize vehicles without first having to issue a warrant. And I think the honorable friend for Reading Central mentioned there are a range of different tactics that police forces are using, and I think that we are keen to learn from experiences up and down the country. And I'm pleased to report that actually there is a lot of cracking down in different forces. They're tackling this from London to Liverpool.

Operation Gears in Merseyside Police seized 500 illegal electric motorbikes and e-scooters in 2023. Only last week in my own constituency of Ellesmere Port, the local constabulary seized around 13 illegal vehicles alongside one of my local councillors, Katie Kendrick, because this is an issue that really matters to people. This is an issue that we all see on the streets. Balaclavas and on bikes is criminality hiding in plain sight. It is an equivalent to the dodgy vape shop, and it is important that we support the police to use the powers they've got and to look at whether there are more powers that are needed to deal with this issue.

But of course, that's only one side of the problem. As we've discussed, it is far too easy to get hold of these vehicles, which means looking at doing more at the point of sale. And this isn't just the bikes, it's the e-bike conversion kits, which as we've heard have the potential to pose real harm to cyclists and indeed others. E-bike batteries, as we know, can be dangerous if they're not properly installed, and they must be properly regulated to keep people safe. So, as members will be aware, the Department of Business, Innovation, Science and Trade consulted on a range of updates to the product safety framework over the summer, including clear duties for online marketplaces to take due care to identify, prevent and remove unsafe products from their sites, such as unsafe or non-compliant batteries and their use in e-bikes and conversion kits.

And as members will be aware, that consultation is now closed. BIST officials are considering the responses as part of the drafting the government response. And as members will probably be aware, as the minister who originally brought that enabling legislation through, I am keener than most to make sure that we make the best use of that. And I think I probably need to remind the opposition spokesperson yet again his party voted against that particular set of laws. So, I want to turn briefly to the issue of e-scooters.

Mr. Stringer, the honourable member for Epsom and Ewell told us about the tragic death of Jacob Caland, and my sympathies are with his family. And I understand that they have actually met my predecessor, and I'm keen to continue that dialogue. And as has been pointed out by members, it is the case that private e-scooters are illegal for use on public roads. They can only be legally used through the government's trials, which have been extended to May 2028. This trial system was implemented originally back in 2020, but as members have pointed out, has never been placed on a statutory footing.

But we are making a firm commitment that we will legislate to define e-scooters in law, which will provide certainty that we currently have not got. And people will know what is legal and what is not, and what can be enforced against. If you don't mind, the honourable member will have an opportunity to respond at the end. It is fair to say, though, that there is no international consensus on the right package of regulations for e-scooters, which is why our trial extension is important. We recognise there will be trade-offs when regulating e-scooters, which is why we will consult next year on detailed proposals.

And on my final comments, Mr. Stringer, because I know the honourable member will want an opportunity to respond. My honourable friend, the member for Darlington, the right honourable member for Oxford East, asked if I will use my convening power in the department to get action across government. And I am pleased to confirm that I am working with colleagues across the Home Office and the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, and we are setting up a cross-party, cross-departmental working group to look at this issue because we consider this an important matter to be tackled across the range of government. So I'll be shortly meeting with colleagues across the House who've raised interest on this, and I hope to be able to provide regular updates because this is an important matter to all members and we are determined to tackle it.

01:27:35 - 01:27:37

Speaker 51

The honourable member to wind up.

01:27:37 - 01:29:58

Helen Maguire

Thank you Mr. Stringer and I thank everyone who's attended this incredibly important debate here today for their contributions. And just to highlight a few, so the member for Mitcham and Morden and her constituent Sofia Duarte who sadly died following a fire, my heart goes out to her and her family. The MP for Oxford East mentioned about bringing the departments together and this is absolutely critical because this is a cross-departmental issue and fundamentally governments are not usually not very well at working cross-departments so I hope that the minister really takes that on board and we can really find some solutions. The MP for member for Sutton and Cheam spoke about impunity from responsibility for employers in the gig economy, this is absolutely vital that we resolve this. And the MP for Eastbourne also spoke about some interesting measures in New South Wales and New York and I think it's really important that we don't just look here but we look abroad at what's been done and what's been successful in other places as well.

And I know the member for Carlisle mentioned about the depression of sales of legal motorbikes as a result of this and this is a consequence also for the Treasury, you know, there's less income coming in as a result of that, incredibly important. The member for Yeovil spoke about the blatant ignorance of individuals not paying road tax and just being able to get about, flout the rules and again this impacts the Treasury. The member for Reading Central spoke about intimidating behavior and I'm sure many members across the house have seen that. We need stronger police powers, that's been raised by many members today so that they can not only enforce on the streets and roads but also identify what is legal and what's not. We need point of sale responsibility and that isn't taking place at the moment.

We also need a decision about the trials and I welcome that the minister said he's going to bring some people together and that there will be legislation at some point but we need that to be time-framed. We can't have this trial going on for another two years. We need action and we need decisions. We need to fundamentally end this confusion at the moment about what is legal and what is not because there's no legal retailers do not have to provide information about that when people purchase. And fundamentally we need to make our streets and parks safe again for our constituents and I hope that the minister will take away all of the contributions that we've made here today.

01:29:58 - 01:30:00

Speaker 52

Thank you.

01:30:00 - 01:31:28

Graham Stringer

The question is that this house has considered the regulation of e-scooters and e-bikes. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no, I think the ayes have it. Order, order. Can members leave as quickly and as quietly as possible.

But we need to start the next debate if members could leave quickly. Order. I will call Matt Vickers to move the motion and then we'll call the minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission from the member in charge of the debate and the minister. I've had no notice that such permissions have been given.

There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up as is the convention for 30 minutes debates. Order, order.

01:31:28 - 01:31:30

Speaker 53

Matt Vickers to move the motion.

01:31:30 - 01:33:28

Matt Vickers

Thank you. I beg to move that this house considers the future of University Hospital of North Tees. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Stringer, and I'm grateful to the minister for being here to respond. I was born in North Tees Hospital, so were tens of thousands of my constituents, and so were many of their children and grandchildren. For nearly 60 years, it's been where Stockton goes when something goes wrong.

It's where we're stitched up after an accident, where we welcome our own children into the world, and where we sit beside our parents in their final days. There are very few families in our town whose story doesn't run at some point through North Tees. I want to begin by thanking the incredible people who work there: the doctors, the nurses, the porters, the cleaners, and everyone who keeps our hospital going day and night. I've seen their dedication for myself, and I've seen the challenges they face in a building that makes an already difficult job harder. They deserve decent facilities, their patients deserve them too, and I have to tell the minister plainly: the building they work in is running out of time.

When we were in government, I campaigned for a new diagnostic center in Stockton. Thousands of residents signed my petition and backed that campaign, and around 25 million was secured, with a further 8.4 million from the community diagnostic fund, bringing scans and tests into the heart of our town. For somebody waiting to find out whether they have cancer, that means answers, and it means treatment can begin. Alongside it came 3 million for the new mental health hub at Brook House, a new respiratory unit, upgrades to the urgent care center, and 4.3 million in robotic and emergency maternity theaters, where a woman who needs urgent surgery in labor can now get it next door to the delivery suite. That's what investment can achieve, but you can't keep bolting 21st-century medicine onto a 1960s frame forever.

01:33:28 - 01:34:01

Jim Shannon

I will. I thank the member for bringing this forward, and it's not just specific to one corner of the mainland. Indeed, our South Eastern Health and Social Care Trust has a set-point savings of 50.7 million pounds just as an example. But does the honorable member acknowledge that these capital and resource crises are interconnected across our United Kingdom? And what should always be paramount should be patient safety, so to ensure that the resources are made available and that they need to keep the patients safe.

That should be the priority of the NHS at all times.

01:34:01 - 01:40:26

Matt Vickers

I thank the member for a very, very valid point actually. Where we've seen that investment, we talked about those robotic theaters actually, now part of the world, not only are they the facilities that the staff deserve to work within that space, but actually that investment in technology means they can be treated more safely, it means their recovery times are reduced, it means more people can be treated more quickly, and there's a real value in looking after those patients at the worst times of their life all too often. I made the case for a new hospital when my own party was in government. I held a similar debate to this five years ago and backed the trust bid for one of the new hospitals. I was devastated when in 2023 those places went instead to hospitals built from RAAC, the concrete that put them at risk of collapse.

I understood why: when a roof could fall in, safety must come first. But it pushed North Tees back in the queue, and I've kept pressing ministers ever since. North Tees opened in 1968. The trust's own board papers identified 2031 as the point by which its main buildings would be beyond their useful economic life. That's just five years away, and parts of the estate are already past it.

The maintenance backlog stands at 126 million pounds, despite around 100 million pounds being spent on repairs in the past decade, and it's projected to reach 300 million pounds by 2033.

Staff work around leaky roofs, broken ceiling panels and pipes that freeze in winter. This is not a hospital that needs a lick of paint. It's a hospital whose fabric is failing. On the 2nd of June this year, heavy rain hit Stockton and the drainage at North Tees could not cope. The trust chief executive has told me that every one of the hospital theatres for inpatient surgery bar one was flooded.

More than 400 patients had their surgery cancelled. Repairs have cost 1.5 million pounds and re-providing that surgery a further 1 million pounds. That's 2.5 million pounds gone, not on treating a single extra patient, but on catching up after a rainstorm. Think about the person waiting for that operation. They've arranged time off work, their family have made plans to look after them.

They've spent weeks preparing themselves, then they're told to wait again because the theatre is flooded. That was not a freak event. It's what happens when a hospital runs past its design life and it'll happen again unless something changes. So what are local people seeing under this government? Not a new hospital, not a place in the hospital programme.

What they're seeing is job losses. Around 600 posts are to go across hospital trusts with a voluntary redundancy scheme and a vacancy freeze. The trust's own figures raise further questions. Since 2024 total staffing has fallen from 6,084 to 5,958. Over the same period the number of managers and senior managers has risen from 91 to 110.

2% fewer staff, 21% more managers. Of course hospital needs good management, but when vacancies are frozen and a 2.5 million pound flood bill comes out of the same budget, that increase needs explaining. Every year we wait, the bill gets bigger. A few years ago replacement hospital was expected to cost around 380 million. The trust now puts it at between 1 billion and 2 billion.

Before the election the honourable member for Ilford North, then the shadow health secretary, came to North Tees and said there is no doubt we need a new hospital here. I agreed with him then and I agree with him now. But when his government reset the new hospital programme in January last year, not a single hospital on Teesside was in it. When I asked last October what assessment has been made of replacing North Tees, the answer was none and that there were no plans to invite further schemes into the programme. North Tees is failing in a different way from those RAAC hospitals.

Its problem's not one dangerous material. It's a whole building past its life. It's not on the list and there is no list it can join. A hospital whose theatres flood and whose backlog is heading for 300 million pounds should not be left without a route simply because it's failing in the wrong way. Meanwhile the Tees Valley mayor has written 25 times asking for a meeting about this hospital.

Mr Streeting's answer was that the mayor could show him the colour of his money. Three health secretaries later, there's still not been one meeting. A hospital that's running out of time cannot wait for the government's revolving door to stop spinning. The trust is drawing up plans, but a plan with no route to capital is just a very expensive document. So I have five questions for the minister.

First, what has changed since that answer last October? If the new hospital programme is closed, what route is open? Will the government assess the case for replacement and set out a timetable? Secondly will she commit to resilience funding to keep the current building safe until then so that flooded theatres do not become an annual event? Thirdly will she guarantee that North Tees keeps its offering, its A&E and its core services while the future is decided?

Fourthly, will she look at why management numbers have risen by 21% while overall staffing has fallen, and ensure that cuts never come at the expense of frontline care? And fifthly, will she make sure the Secretary of State finally meets the mayor, along with me, members from across Teesside and the trust before the end of the year? Or better still, come visit our hospital to see firsthand the challenges our incredible workforce are facing. People across our area, whatever their politics, want the same thing: a hospital that they can rely on when someone they love needs help. I'll work with anybody who wants to make that happen.

North Tees has seen us born, patched us up, and cared for the people we love at the end. Its staff have kept caring through every challenge put in front of them. The honorable member for Ilford North was right. There is no doubt we need a new hospital. What my constituents want to hear today is not whether, but when, where, and how it will be paid for.

Our staff deserve it, our patients need it, and our community has waited long enough.

01:40:26 - 01:41:32

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, and I congratulate the honorable member for Stockton West for securing this important debate. And it is good to hear him rightly put across the strength of feeling that I'm sure many people in Stockton and elsewhere nearby feel in support of the staff of the hospital and how people feel about it. It's very important to the communities that it serves, and patients and staff rightly deserve facilities that are safe, modern, and fit to deliver high-quality care. I must just offer a brief apology to the member.

I'm obviously not the minister directly for this area. We have a clash, unfortunately, which is why I am responding to him, but I will make sure that the minister with direct responsibility here hears all of the points that he makes, and I'm going to do my best to respond to the questions as he asked them.

01:41:32 - 01:42:16

Luke Myer

Thank you, Minister. This is a Teesside-wide issue, and it is felt by communities across the region. And all of us as MPs representing the Tees Valley believe there needs to be a long-term future for this hospital. I know the honorable member for Stockton North is also supporting the trust's strategic outline case for the future of the hospital. So we do need to see a future here.

But there are also other hospitals within the trust's area which are sitting and rotting, and I see one in my constituency in East Cleveland. It's controlled by property services, so there are huge parts of that building that are sitting empty, which could have more services in. So I'd urge her to meet with us collectively to talk about the future for hospitals across the Tees region.

01:42:16 - 01:49:38

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Stringer, and I'd like to thank my friend for that question. And as I just was mentioning, I will make sure that the minister responsible hears his point, the discussion that we've had in this debate, and that is able to take forward that strategic discussion about the future. I hope and anticipate that I'll be able to answer the questions that the member has put in the contribution that I'm going to make. If that's not the case, we'll certainly follow up in writing with him and with other members in Tees as well. Now, we recognize the need to plan for the hospital's long-term future for all the reasons that members have set out and that are understood.

This requires three things: more investment in the NHS estate, greater certainty so that investment can be planned over the long term, and greater autonomy for local leaders to decide how it's best used. And that is the approach we've set out in our 10-year capital plan for health and social care.

The challenges at North Tees reflect a much wider problem across the NHS estate. For too long, capital investment was insufficient and short-term, with capital budgets repeatedly raided to meet day-to-day pressures. The result is an estate carrying the consequences of years of underinvestment, and the members have set out the consequences of that which people are living with. Previous governments allowed these pressures to build, leaving too many NHS buildings ageing and in poor condition. Patients and staff across the country are living with the consequences.

We cannot undo that legacy overnight, but we can change the way the NHS invests in its buildings, moving away from short-term fixes towards sustained investment and proper long-term planning. First, we are investing more. After years of underinvestment, we're providing the largest health capital budget in NHS history, with annual spending rising to 15 billion by the end of this spending review period. And within this, we're targeting funding where the need is greatest. The Estate Safety Fund, established in 25-26, will be provided with 6.75 billion over the next nine years to tackle the poorest quality parts of the NHS estate and to ensure safe environments for patients and staff.

And this sits alongside around 21 billion in operational capital over this spending review period, empowering local health organisations to invest in their priorities, including their estates. We're also investing about 5. about around 5 billion over the spending review period to expand and modernise diagnostic, elective, mental health, and emergency services, helping to increase capacity, cut waiting times, and improve urgent and emergency care performance, as mentioned by members in this debate already. Second, we're providing greater certainty over that investment. We're providing 65 billion over 10 years for operational capital and estate maintenance, giving the NHS unprecedented long-term certainty to plan and improve its estate. For the first time, providers have multi-year operational capital allocations alongside longer-term certainty over estate maintenance funding.

Instead of having to plan from one year to the next, NHS leaders can look ahead, prioritise investment over several years, and develop longer-term plans for their estates and services. And third, we're giving local leaders greater autonomy about how that investment is used. We're devolving more control to the frontline, streamlining capital approvals, giving local leaders greater freedom to invest according to local need, helping projects move forward more quickly and delivering better value for money for taxpayers. Now, Mr Stringer, this matters because those closest to patients are best placed to understand what their communities need, and we're giving them more investment, greater certainty over resources available, and greater freedom to decide how those resources can best support local services, which brings me back to North Tees. Now, I've heard the case that honourable members have made about the University Hospital of North Tees to become part of the New Hospitals Programme.

And as he's mentioned, there are currently no plans to invite further schemes to join the programme, as our focus is on delivering the existing schemes set out in the plan for implementation. But the New Hospital Programme is not the only route through which we're investing in the NHS estate. As I've set out, we've provided long significant long-term capital investment through the Estate Safety Fund, operational capital programmes to expand and modernise services, alongside that certainty and flexibility that I've mentioned. And over the next nine years, more than 1.1 billion is planned through the Estate Safety Fund for the North East and Yorkshire region. Importantly, the fund gives local NHS leaders greater flexibility to prioritise that investment against most pressing infrastructure risks across the region.

So, the member asked me a couple of questions on funding and what route is open. And this this funding means that the case for further investment at North Tees can be considered through that process, making sure that it's those local priorities that drive decision-making.

The longer-term funding certainty we have provided means that those decisions can be based on strategic plans for the estate rather than short-term pressures alone, although I acknowledge absolutely the point that has been made about flooding and so on. North Tees and Hartlepool NHS Foundation Trust has already been allocated more than 3.2 million through the estate's safety fund for vital repairs at North Tees and Hartlepool hospitals over the next four years, and this sits alongside more than 78 million in operational capital for local priorities, including repairs at North Tees. But I would just say again that I will make sure that ministers responsible and others are aware of this debate taking place and the points that members have quite rightly raised about the consequences of the position right now and what staff are dealing with. The government has recently announced 1 million pounds to refurbish the emergency department at North Tees over two years, part of our 140 million boost to NHS urgent care, and this builds on 2.7 million already invested in the emergency assessment unit to increase capacity and improve patient flow, safety, and experience. We're also investing directly in services across the wider Tees Valley, and in 2025, the trust received more than 4 million to expand the Tees Valley Community Diagnostic Centre that we've discussed.

As part of our 343 million pounds expansion of community and crisis mental health services, new facilities are planned in Hartlepool, Middlesbrough, and Redcar and Cleveland, alongside a dedicated mental health emergency department at Roseberry Park, and together this sits within 671 million of planned capital investment to support improved NHS performance in secondary and emergency care across the North East and Yorkshire region over the next four years. I will, of course.

01:49:38 - 01:50:05

Luke Myer

I'm grateful again. There isn't yet much clarity on where some of that funding will go in terms of setting up those mental health services in Redcar and Cleveland in particular. It seems to me as a no-brainer if we've got a hospital with a wing sitting empty that that be a site for some of those services, but obviously I'd just like to have the conversation with the department to understand if there are any plans and if not whether we can get some confirmation on that.

01:50:05 - 01:52:47

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Stringer, and I'd like to thank my friend for asking me a question that is actually within my direct responsibilities, which does make my life slightly easier. So I would just say to him that the issue that he mentions about the suitability of location is very important. It's one that I'm considering through our work on the mental health strategy, and if he would like to have a discussion with me about it alongside local leaders, I'd be more than happy to do that. Now, just in addition to that, I would say decisions about the future of local services and estates should be shaped by those who understand them best. And I might just take this opportunity to say on the record that includes members of parliament, because I think too often we haven't seen members of parliament playing that role.

We often as local MPs have a huge amount of intel about how to make services work best, and I would encourage all of my colleagues in the NHS to work with and use that knowledge that MPs have. North Tees and Hartlepool NHS Foundation Trust, working with the local NHS, though, is best placed to assess the needs of its patients, determine the right model of care, and plan the infrastructure required to deliver it. And the member for Stockton West asked me some questions about A&E and management numbers, and I would just say to him that I've said what I've said about the importance that MPs, the insights that MPs have, and I would encourage leaders to listen to what he and colleagues have said in this discussion as they're taking decisions.

We do want to make sure that local leaders have that strong foundation for taking decisions and multi-year funding allows them to look beyond immediate pressures, consider investment across their estate and develop credible plans over a longer period. And given what he's said in this debate, there's clearly two jobs here, which is to try to deal with the problems that are in front of us at North Tees and plan that longer-term future in a credible way. And I hope that some of the decisions that we've taken will enable them to do that. We know that these are significant problems and I am realistic, as I've said in my speech, Mr. Stringer, I'm realistic about our ability to deal with what is a substantial and strategic problem overnight. But we must use the opportunity to plan for the longer-term future of North Tees to get that clinically-led, affordable plan that is supported by a clear business case.

01:52:47 - 01:53:20

Matt Vickers

Not planning one year at a time, but being able to look to the long term with that investment, greater certainty and more autonomy as tools to properly plan for the future for the services and the estate. And I'd just like to finish... Will she give way? There was a point raised there about the fact that the mayor's written 25 times, we haven't managed to get a meeting together yet. I wonder whether she might be able to cajole or commit her ministerial colleague or even the Secretary of State to meet with local members and that mayor and representatives of the trust to see where we go next and have that sort of a discussion.

01:53:20 - 01:54:46

Alison McGovern

Thank you, Mr. Stringer. I meet members of Parliament of all parties regularly, very happy to always agree to meetings with ministers and I'm sure my colleagues likewise. The mayor, obviously we have built in new institutions like the Mayoral Council and other things so that mayors can make representations directly to government and I'm sure that the mayor is capable of doing that. I will also make sure that the Secretary of State is aware of the question that he has asked in the follow-up to this debate. And I'd like to return, Mr. Stringer, just as I finish my remarks, just on the comments that the member for Stockton West opened with about the importance of hospital facilities to local communities wherever they are in the country.

I hear him in the importance that North Tees has to the people that it serves. I think that just goes to show what a foundational role the NHS plays for all of us in our family life. I commend him for bringing this debate today. We've got a lot of work to do to get the NHS back to what it should be. We are in a turnaround process.

It will be hard, but I feel if we work together collaboratively, one eye on the immediate, one eye on the long term, we'll get the job done. Thanks, Mr. Stringer.

01:54:46 - 01:54:59

Graham Stringer

The question is that this House has considered the future of University Hospital of North Tees. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it.

Order, order, the sitting is suspended until 2:30.