House of Commons

2 September 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:17 - 00:20
Speaker 4
Order.  Motion of the Committee of Selection whipped to move. 
00:20 - 00:21
I beg to move. 
00:21 - 00:24
Speaker 1
The question is as on the order paper.  As many of that opinion say aye. 
00:24 - 00:25
Aye. 
00:25 - 00:31
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
The contrary no.  I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.  We come to questions to the Secretary of State for Wales.  Douglas Lumsden. 
00:31 - 00:35
Douglas Lumsden
Member for Aberdeen South
Question number one, Mr. Speaker. 
00:35 - 01:09
Lab Member of Parliament | Aberafan Maesteg
Member of Parliament | Aberafan Maesteg
Nathan Stephen Kinnock
Thank you, Speaker.  Thank you, sir.  And with permission, I will answer questions one, four, nine and ten together.  A stronger Wales in a stronger United Kingdom.  That will be my driving principle as Secretary of State for Wales, building on the outstanding work of my right honourable friend, the member for Cardiff East. 

Just last week, the Prime Minister and I saw the strength of our union in action on a visit to Port Talbot, where the UK government has invested nearly seven hundred million pounds to secure the future of Welsh steel, protect jobs and reindustrialise Wales. 
01:09 - 01:36
Douglas Lumsden
Member for Aberdeen South
I thank the Secretary of State for that answer.  New figures from August show that being part of a strong United Kingdom is worth an extra two thousand seven hundred and twenty pounds to every person in Scotland compared to the UK average.  So does the Secretary of State agree that this demonstrates the economic benefits of our union, and what assessment has he made of the financial benefits to Wales of being part of the United Kingdom? 
01:36 - 01:55
Lab Member of Parliament | Aberafan Maesteg
Member of Parliament | Aberafan Maesteg
Nathan Stephen Kinnock
Well, I thank him for that question and I agree with him.  It is of tremendous benefit to Wales to be part of our United Kingdom.  Just look at the investment that the UK government has been putting in.  I mentioned steel, two point five billion pounds for the Wylfa nuclear project, five hundred million pounds through the local growth fund.  The list goes on and on. 

01:55 - 02:02

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

So I absolutely agree with his assessment that this is about building a stronger Wales in a stronger United Kingdom.

02:02 - 02:04

Speaker 2

Sir Desmond Swayne.

02:04 - 02:26

Desmond Swayne

A strength of the union is unity in diversity. Notwithstanding much progress since 2010, the last two years have seen a diminution in the number of Welsh speakers in Wales, particularly amongst young people. Has the minister a plan to nip that in the bud and stop it becoming a trend?

02:26 - 03:01

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank him for that question. We are tremendously proud of our Welsh language. I'm certainly signing up to improve mine from what I would embarrassingly admit to be a relatively low base, but I certainly look forward and enjoy learning languages, so I'll be doing that. I think generally speaking, we need to ensure that the trend towards Welsh medium and Welsh language across our education system continues, and we need to ensure that those who are committed to the diversity of which he speaks also commit to learning the Welsh language.

03:01 - 03:30

John Lamont

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Strong transport links between the nations of our United Kingdom are vital to strengthening the union. However, since Loganair withdrew its regular Cardiff to Edinburgh service earlier this year, there is now no direct air link between the Welsh and Scottish capitals. So will the Secretary of State agree that this is a backward step for connectivity within the UK, and will he work with the Transport Secretary, the Welsh and Scottish governments and Loganair to see if this route can be reinstated?

03:30 - 03:58

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank him for that question. Cardiff Airport plays an absolutely crucial role in connecting our United Kingdom. Of course, we want the maximum number of flight routes between Cardiff and the rest of the UK.

Loganair, I obviously is a commercial operator, it makes decisions on the basis of the commercial realities that it's facing. But perhaps if he'd care to write to me with any thoughts or ideas he might have about how we might get back to the table on that issue, I'd be more than happy to engage on that basis.

03:58 - 04:35

Chris Kane

Chris Kane. The Prime Minister's spoken about practical government interventions that can make everyday life just a little bit easier. One of the great advantages of devolution is that different parts of the UK can try different approaches to common challenges. My experience in Scotland is that the SNP often turns differences in public policy into arguments about the constitution, when people really want government focused on making their lives better now. Does the Secretary of State agree that we should look for things that unite us and share what share what works so that good ideas from across Scotland, England and Northern Ireland benefit Wales and vice versa?

04:35 - 05:06

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I wholeheartedly agree with my honorable friend about the the importance of learning lessons and seizing opportunities. Over the last six weeks, the Prime Minister has shown real leadership, introducing practical changes that will benefit people's lives, such as the two pound bus cap in England. Now, of course, it will be up to the Welsh Government to come to a conclusion on whether they too might introduce such a measure. But I'm hopeful that both governments will learn from each other about how best to improve the lives of the people that we serve.

05:06 - 05:32

Nick Symonds

Nick Thomas-Symonds.

Speaker, and we saw the practical benefits of the Union in action with my right honorable friend's swift action on military personnel coming to deal with the wildfires. Will my right honorable friend join me in paying tribute to the farmers and indeed to the firefighters who dealt with those wildfires, and also agree that with climate change making them a more regular occurrence, we need a long-term plan to deal with them?

05:32 - 06:08

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank my right honorable friend for his question and like him, I would like to pay tribute to those all of those involved in the collective and heroic response to the wildfires. I can confirm that South Wales Fire and Rescue Service submitted a military aid to the civilian authorities request for consideration. It was endorsed by both the Welsh Government and the Wales Office by myself immediately and authorized by the Ministry of Defence. While matters related to agriculture and the fire and rescue services are devolved in Wales, we are committed to working with the Welsh Government to strengthen resilience against wildfires and provide assistance to those affected.

06:08 - 06:09

Ruth Jones.

06:09 - 06:36

Speaker 20

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Plaid Cymru Welsh Government marked their first 100 days in office last week with little fanfare. Their achievements to date seem to be setting up committees and commission reports rather than focusing on the needs of the people of Wales. So can I ask the Secretary of State if he agrees with me that spending time and money on a commission into independence and undermining the union of the United Kingdom is not the best way to deliver on the priorities for the people in Wales?

06:36 - 07:15

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I I thank my honorable friend and I I think it's fair to say that Plaid ministers, let's say, are still finding their feet. But I am hugely proud of what our new Labour Prime Minister has achieved for Wales in his first six weeks. It really shows what a leader can do when they roll up their sleeves, listen to our people and communities and deliver on their priorities. The Prime Minister's visit to Wales and his commitment to reindustrializing our communities comes after a summer of announcements that will benefit communities across Wales. Real action, delivering for people right in the here and now.

07:15 - 08:02

Mims Davies

Mims Davies, Shadow Secretary of State.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I welcome the right honorable gentleman to his place and I wish him well with his team in this important role.

As a former health minister in the NHS in England for the last two years, he will know the challenge of tackling hospital waiting times in the face of rising corridor care. Mr. Speaker, the time for devolving, and I think we've heard from the Secretary of State, and forgetting outcomes has long since passed. And all nations in our precious Union need fair treatment. Will the Secretary of State, sadly unlike his predecessor, do more than simply watch from the sidelines and take action when it comes to the people of Wales who are waiting for far too long for proper care under devolution?

08:02 - 08:57

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank her for her kind words and I look forward very much to our exchanges across this dispatch box and of course I'm very much ready to engage with her on issues that are about getting the maximum benefits for the people of Wales. Look, we respect the devolution settlement. It's very important that we keep that to the forefront of our minds when it comes to ensuring that the decisions that affect the people of Wales are taken in the in health by the Welsh government. But of course, as I said in a previous answer, I think there are real opportunities for all governments across the UK to learn from each other. And I hope that our colleagues in the Welsh government will look at the success that we're having in terms of bringing waiting lists down, in terms of improving the performance and delivery of general practice in England, and will perhaps follow suit in Wales.

08:57 - 09:53

Mims Davies

Well, I thank the Secretary of State for his answer, but if being devolved means you can't get involved when things go wrong, that's the reason that we're in the Welsh NHS mess. Mr. Speaker, a significant ITV Wales investigation, this is important for our Union and the people of Wales, uncovered 28 prevention of future death reports over a 16-month period relating to the scandal-hit Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board. The House might want to listen. North Wales resident David Jones tragically lost his wife and father there. He is angry.

He has accused the UK Labour government of failing victims and their families for not intervening and leaving them in limbo. Will the Secretary of State actually use the Inquiries Act of 2005 and seek accountability?

09:53 - 10:31

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank her and just to be clear, this is not about staying out of the issue. It is about respecting the devolution settlement but being prepared to work constructively and where we can in partnership with the Welsh government. But she will be aware that health is devolved and as such Welsh government ministers have powers under the Inquiries Act 2005 to initiate statutory inquiries into devolved areas. Given the clear lines of responsibility and accountability between the Welsh government and the devolved health service in Wales, I do not feel it would be appropriate for the UK government to intervene in this matter.

10:31 - 11:04

David Chadwick

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and can I welcome the new Secretary of State to his place. Many of my constituents are reliant on cross-border healthcare, particularly in Hereford Hospital. Indeed, many of them will end up stuck in Hereford Hospital because we don't have enough community hospital beds in Powys. Powys Teaching Health Board acknowledges that it needs 100, it needs 400 beds. We've only got 148 and they're considering cutting that number further.

So can he please outline what are his priorities for fixing cross-border healthcare issues?

11:04 - 11:41

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank him for that question. Cross-border healthcare is a really important issue. We need to find a better way of working together in partnership with the Welsh government, identifying, I think it's about drilling down into specific cases where people have not been given the treatment that they should be getting at the speed at which they should be getting it. I think it's about clearing out some of the red tape and bureaucracy that is that exists between the two governments. And I think that's about the hard yards of government working with the Welsh health ministers and ourselves to get this issue resolved.

11:41 - 12:21

Liz Roberts

Diolch yn fawr, Llefarydd. If this is a union of equals, let me turn to the wildfires we suffered in Wales and in England, of course, this summer. The Rhinogydd mountains of Eryri National Park are the last true upland wilderness in Wales. They burned for over two weeks in July, causing immeasurable damage to peatlands and wildlife. Despite heroic work by local firefighters, there were no UK-wide resources available, including the military, to tackle this ecological disaster.

So what steps is he taking to ensure Welsh government have sufficient resources in the face of overwhelming climate change?

12:21 - 13:03

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank her and again look forward to working with her. My understanding is that there were challenges around the helicopter capability. I think decisions were taken by Natural Resources Wales some time ago in changing the way that the tendering worked for helicopter capability. We certainly need to look at that. But I also would hope that she would welcome the fact that when the Welsh government and the fire services did put in a request for MACA, the MACA request was turned around by myself within an hour.

And so that shows, I think, Team Wales, partnership between the Ministry of Defence and the Welsh authorities to get on top of these deeply troubling situations.

13:03 - 13:41

Liz Roberts

Miss Saville Roberts.

I appreciate the tone of the Secretary of State. And I note that the PM said yesterday, the Prime Minister said yesterday, that change begins with honesty. So let's be honest. Harping on about the strength of the union in the same breath as calling for change is a distraction. A union that treats people differently depending on where they live must change.

So does he honestly believe that the city region of Greater Manchester should have more powers over policing and keeping communities safe than the Parliament of Wales, the Senedd?

13:41 - 14:21

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank her for that question. I think many of the ideas coming forward around devolving power right across our United Kingdom, beyond Cardiff Bay and Holyrood, for example, are very exciting ideas and I look forward to exploring them with her. With regard to policing, the Prime Minister and I have been very clear that we will engage on the future of devolution, including deepening devolution into communities across all corners of Wales. On policing specifically, our focus has and always will continue to be on cutting crime. Our priority will always be ensuring the safety and security of the people of Wales.

What matters is what works.

14:21 - 14:22

Andrew George.

14:22 - 14:23

Question two.

14:23 - 14:47

Andrew George

Housing is a devolved matter in Wales, but we know people are struggling with the affordability of everyday life. That's why easing the burden on the cost of living is our priority. And we've taken immediate action by removing VAT from energy bills from the first of October, giving millions of households breathing space this winter.

14:47 - 14:48

Andrew George.

14:48 - 15:21

Andrew George

I'm grateful to the minister for that reply. However, as the minister is well aware, the Welsh government has failed to meet its own 2021 to 2026 social housing target. And I wonder what lessons have been learned from that and indeed from the Welsh government's introduction of curbs on second homes through the planning system. Surely this refreshed government must be taking lessons from Wales and applying them across the UK as a whole.

15:21 - 16:12

Speaker 23

Well, I thank the member for his question. I'm sure he will agree that there's always lessons to be learned in this place. But we recognize that more needs to be done on second homes and short-term lets.

The UK government will consider a wide range of evidence on the issue, including learning from other parts of the UK. But affordable housing is of great importance to the Prime Minister, and just last week he announced where more than 70,000 new social and affordable homes will be built across England over the next 10 years. This will be transformative, and I hope the Plaid government in Wales will follow through on their promise to build 20,000 new social homes in Wales by 2030.

16:12 - 16:41

Jessica Morden

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister's promised to do all he can to end rough sleeping by offering everyone who needs it in England a route off the streets by Christmas. In Newport, we have excellent charities like Eden Gate that I visited recently, working with the council's outreach services, but they need more support. Does the Minister agree that the Plaid Cymru Welsh government should follow Labour's lead by making tackling homelessness a priority?

16:41 - 17:17

Speaker 23

Well, I completely agree with my honorable friend. The Prime Minister's announcement to give everyone a route off the streets by Christmas comes with a 442 million pound boost in funding and a landmark summit to bring everyone together to end rough sleeping. This won't only change the lives of those being given somewhere to sleep and a foundation to rebuild lives, but will have huge benefits right across the country. And I hope the Plaid government will follow suit and ensure everyone in Wales has a roof over their heads this Christmas.

17:17 - 17:18

Ruth Jones, Chair of the Select Committee.

17:18 - 17:20

Ruth Jones

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, question three, please.

17:20 - 17:21

Secretary of State.

17:21 - 17:46

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

I thank my honorable friend. Tackling child poverty is an essential investment in the future of our children and our country. That is why we announced the child poverty strategy, including the removal of the two-child limit, which will benefit nearly 70,000 children in Wales. Alongside this, 320,000 families in Wales will see the first ever sustained real-terms increase in the Universal Credit standard allowance.

17:46 - 18:17

Ruth Jones

I thank the Secretary of State for his response, and I welcome him to his place and wish him well in his new role. As he will be aware, the Welsh Affairs Select Committee has launched an inquiry into child poverty in Wales, which stands stubbornly high at 31%. With a new minority government elected in Cardiff Bay, many of the levers relating to child poverty being split between the UK and Welsh government, what conversations has the Secretary of State had with Welsh Senate ministers regarding ending child poverty in Wales?

18:17 - 18:41

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I fully agree with my honorable friend. The cooperation between the UK and Welsh governments is essential for addressing child poverty in Wales. The UK government worked closely with the previous Welsh Labour government on the design of the child poverty strategy, which will lift 550,000 children out of poverty across the UK by 2030, delivering the largest expected reduction in child poverty since records began.

18:41 - 19:17

Jim Shannon

Jim Shannon.

Mr. Speaker, can I thank the Minister very much for that answer? And he's right to recognize the reduction of child poverty in Wales. But of course, government here took that decision to reduce child poverty not just in Wales, but in Scotland and Northern Ireland and in England. And does the Minister agree, when it comes to recognizing the good work that this government has done in reducing child poverty, this whole House should collectively come together and say thank you to the Labour Party for doing that and taking 60,000 families out of poverty in Northern Ireland?

19:17 - 19:40

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank my honorable friend and absolutely agree with the sentiment of his question. Let's look at what the Welsh Labour government did deliver: breakfast clubs offering free healthy breakfast to children in primary schools, baby bundles, more than 50 million meals served since the introduction of universal primary free school meals, an expanded childcare offer, free prescriptions, hospital parking to help with family finances.

19:40 - 19:48

Speaker 21

That is the difference that a Labour government makes.

19:48 - 20:35

Mims Davies

We've all witnessed in the last 100 days the Plaid Welsh government in Cardiff Bay that has failed to publish costings and properly explain their flagship childcare policy and how it will work. Maybe Plaid just wants higher taxes and higher handouts like the welfare party which is Labour sitting across from us. Does the Secretary of State agree that hardworking families deserve to know whether these plans will mean higher taxes? And what discussions the Secretary of State has had occurred with Welsh government to ensure that these election commitments are properly delivered for struggling families?

20:35 - 21:43

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank her for that question. Frankly staggered that she's raising the issue of welfare given the explosion on the welfare bill under the watch of the party opposite. But when it comes to working with the Plaid Cymru government, I would agree with her that there do seem to be a lot of reviews and commissions and reports and committees. I think it's very important that the Plaid government does now roll up its sleeves, get on with the job, and we look forward to working constructively in partnership with them delivering for the people and communities of Wales. I thank him for that question.

I recognize the connectivity benefits in terms of transport and the overall cross-border connectivity that's been announced relates to the 14 billion pounds that we have invested, are going to invest in rail in Wales. 455 million pounds secured at the spending review. This plan will transform connectivity across Wales and between Wales and the rest of the United Kingdom.

21:43 - 22:27

Mark Pritchard

Can I congratulate the Secretary of State to his appointment to the cabinet and he will know that I have very fond memories of his constituency growing up as a young boy. Could he throw his support behind this open access application by Wrexham, Shropshire and Midlands Railway Company to the Office of Rail and Road? The new revised application would include Wellington in my constituency and give a 3 million pound economic boost to that market town. So will he work with the Minister for Rail, work with the Office of Rail and Road, work with the Transport Secretary and get this new timetable and route delivered?

22:27 - 23:03

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank him and know about his strong connections to Wales and of course welcome those. I recognize the connectivity benefits that WSMR's proposal could deliver, particularly for passengers in Wales and the West Midlands. I'm very pleased that the Secretary of State for Transport has provided conditional support for the application subject to the Office of Rail and Road network rail being satisfied that services can be accommodated without compromising network performance or affecting the rights of other operators. And I will certainly be joining with him in making the case for this very compelling project.

23:03 - 23:34

Jessica Morden

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Secretary of State to his new role and wish him all the best? Earlier this year, my Cardiff East constituents were thrilled to hear of the agreement between this Labour government, the Welsh Labour government and private investors on funding to proceed with our long-awaited Cardiff Parkway station on the cross-border mainline.

The station and adjoining business park are set to unlock around 6,000 new jobs. Can the Secretary of State tell us whether the new minority Plaid government in Wales have confirmed whether they will honour this agreement?

23:34 - 24:27

Nathan Stephen Kinnock

Well, I thank my right honourable friend and I pay tribute to her as the first female Labour Secretary of State for Wales. Wales is better off as a result of her work on rail, nuclear, steel and more. Now, I recognise the central importance of the Cardiff Parkway project, which could unlock up to 6,000 jobs. I will do all that I can working with the Welsh government and private investors to progress the delivery of this vitally important project at pace. Farming is central to Wales's economy and rural communities and we are steadfast in our support for farmers.

That's why I regularly meet and speak to farmers and their unions, visiting farms and agricultural shows across the country, including the Royal Welsh Show this summer.

24:27 - 24:46

Speaker 36

Mr Speaker, the Prime Minister yesterday said that he would give people back control of their destinies. The best way he could do that for farmers in Wales and across the United Kingdom is to reverse the family farm tax. So will the Secretary of State actually advocate for that?

24:46 - 25:24

Speaker 23

Well, I thank the member for her question. We are listening closely to farmers, as we've always listened closely to farmers, and we have announced more to protect family farms. We have changed the allowance of 100% rate of relief to be increased from 1 million to 2.5 million. This gets the balance right between supporting farmers and businesses, fixing the public finances and funding our public services.

25:24 - 25:55

Speaker 34

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Farmers in Wales are suffering the dire consequences of drought, topped off by the horrific wildfires we had in South Wales and across the Monmouthshire borders in recent weeks. I'm extremely grateful to the Prime Minister for sending troops to help the amazing fire service, including to Blaenavon. But at this really difficult time, can the Minister update me on how the UK government is supporting our farmers?

25:55 - 26:32

Speaker 23

Well, I thank my honourable friend for her really important question just now. She's absolutely right, these are challenging times right across the country and wildfires are a stark reminder for us to take care of our environment as we face the ongoing challenges of our changing climate and we need to mitigate against more summers like this. But most importantly, I do want to pay a huge tribute to our incredible fire and rescue services, our police and military for putting their lives on the line to keep our communities safe.

26:32 - 26:46

Speaker 26

That completes questions for Wales. We now come to Prime Minister's Questions. Ann Davies.

26:46 - 26:49

Ann Celia Davies

Diolch yn fawr, Mr Llefarydd, question number one.

26:49 - 26:51

Speaker 37

Prime Minister.

26:51 - 27:47

Speaker 31

Thank you, Mr Speaker. It was good to be back at this despatch box yesterday for the first time in 16 years. And I understand I broke records, Mr Speaker, on my first day back for the longest statement in modern history. Thanks for your help with that, Mr Speaker. On my engagements, this evening I will join Their Majesties the King and Queen and President Macron at the British Museum to celebrate the arrival of the Bayeux Tapestry.

The loaning of the tapestry is a great example of French-British cooperation, the same cooperation that has helped us reduce summer small boat crossings to a seven-year low.

27:47 - 27:59

Speaker 29

Mr. Speaker, this morning I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my duties in this House, I will have further such meetings later today.

27:59 - 28:38

Ann Celia Davies

May I firstly welcome the Prime Minister to his place. And I also welcome the Prime Minister's exemption of offences including death by dangerous driving for early prison release. But it comes after months of anguish for bereaved families like my constituent Lisa Jones, whose husband Aaron was killed on the 23rd of December 2024. Will the Prime Minister now apologize to victims and their families put through significant distress throughout this process? And can he also assure them that unlike the Labour precedent, there will be no government U-turn on this?

28:38 - 29:47

Speaker 31

Well, Mr. Speaker, can I start by paying tribute to the honourable lady for the way in which she has represented the family, the Jones family, and can I say I do understand their anguish and that of many other families who found themselves in their position. I listened to what they were saying. I came in and asked for changes to the early release scheme and we excluded rape, grooming and child sex offences. But hearing those voices, I wasn't satisfied and I pushed the system to go further. And as a result of that, we are going further and excluding death by dangerous driving and other manslaughter offences.

So I hope now she can give that certainty to the family, give them also my best wishes. I believe we're coming to the right position and I can assure her that the Justice Secretary will be on top of this situation so that we ensure we are never in this position again.

29:47 - 30:23

Jessica Morden

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My Cardiff East constituents are pleased the government are funding extra neighbourhood policing for us. But Cardiff is the only capital city in the UK that doesn't have specific capital city police funding. So that means that neighbourhood policing as a matter of course are pulled away from the job that they should and need to do for my constituents. The Prime Minister knows Cardiff well.

This historic anomaly is unfair and indefensible. So will he ensure that this problem is resolved once and for all by delivering capital city police funding for Cardiff?

30:23 - 31:29

Speaker 31

Well, can I start, Mr. Speaker, by paying tribute to my right honourable friend for everything she has done to stand up for her constituents, but more for Wales and particularly in her role as Secretary of State for Wales. I do understand the point she's making, how big cities outside of London and particularly a capital city faces extra pressure that other police forces don't face. So I do understand the point and we are reviewing the funding formula as part of a wider programme of police reform. I would be happy to engage with her on that very issue as part of that review. We have ensured that forces including South Wales Police are receiving a boost in their funding, but I do understand the position of cities that are, if you like, the focal point for many people to travel towards them, the extra pressure that results in.

I know that from my previous job and it's why I will pay very close attention to what she is saying.

31:29 - 31:59

Kemi Badenoch

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I congratulate the Prime Minister on his stamina? Three hours. Yesterday, he faced 125 questions from MPs across the House. Of course, Labour and the Lib Dems just wanted more government spending as taxpayers' money.

But can he name a single spending request to which he answered no?

31:59 - 32:56

Speaker 31

Prime Minister. What I can say to the right honourable lady is I was quite clear in my statement about the need to get the welfare bill down. I do not want to be a Prime Minister that sees a situation where we have so many people in their 20s not in education, employment or training. I can't defend that. And I want to change that by giving more support to young people so that we start investing in their success, Mr. Speaker, rather than paying for failure as we have done for many years under successive governments.

Now, this seems to me, Mr. Speaker, to be one area where we can both engage in problem-solving rather than point-scoring. And I hope the right honourable lady will take up my offer on that point.

32:56 - 33:34

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, he avoided the question. He did not say no to a single spending request. And personally, I think it's delightful that he wants to make everyone happy, but a Prime Minister needs to be a leader, not a people-pleaser. He's talking about working together on welfare. I already made that offer, but that does mean cuts.

He wants to bring the welfare bill down by spending more money. Yesterday, the Prime Minister told the House that his summer of promises would be paid for by reprioritising within government. So what exactly has he cut?

33:34 - 34:50

Speaker 31

Well, in terms of what has he cut, tax is the simple answer to that question. Mr. Speaker, within days of taking office, I indicated that we would remove VAT off electricity bills. And that, Mr. Speaker, will help people with the cost of living. And then days later, with the support of my right honourable friend the Chancellor, we said that there would be a cut in business rates for pubs, social clubs, live music venues. So this government lowering the cost of living, lowering the cost of business, and that is what we will continue to do.

And can I say to the right honourable lady, it has to be fully funded and those commitments are fully funded. And we made a decision early to be clear about our priorities. Digital ID is not a priority for me or for this government. We reallocated the funding and we made those commitments as a result.

34:50 - 35:36

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, I asked what he cut. He says tax cuts. He hasn't said where the money is coming from. He talks about digital ID. Yeah, I know, he said digital ID, but the Chief Secretary to the former Prime Minister said that there was no money allocated for digital ID.

You can't cut something that never existed in the first place. Mr. Speaker, Lord O'Neill, a close friend of the Prime Minister, said yesterday's statement in the Commons was the last thing investors wanted to hear. Lord O'Neill is a serious economist. He knows what he's talking about. And sure enough, yesterday, the cost of government borrowing rose to its highest in 18 years.

How does he plan to tackle the government's rising debt costs?

35:36 - 37:00

Speaker 31

Well, can I say to my... to the honorable lady... right honorable lady... I've worked with Jim O'Neill for 10 years. Jim O'Neill always gives me candid advice. We don't always agree, but he and I worked together to turn Greater Manchester from a former industrial heartland to the fastest growing city region in the country. They complain, Mr. Speaker, but where are their ideas about growth? When they were in... when they were in government, we saw 14 years of stagnant growth.

We saw 14 years of debt rising as a percentage of GDP. I would say to her that the turbulence on global markets are because of that exposure that they left behind. We are turning that corner, Mr. Speaker. In the first half of this year, we've had the fastest growth in the G7. Borrowing fell to its lowest level in six years.

We're cutting the deficit faster than any other G7 country. I say to the party opposite, particularly to the right honorable lady, that is problem solving rather than point scoring.

37:00 - 37:43

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, I don't know what any of that has to do with tackling the cost of increasing debt, Mr. Speaker. Collaborating with... collaborating with Jim O'Neill is not how we're going to get the debt cost down and he said yesterday that the markets would be worried. The markets are clearly worried that we now have a spendthrift Prime Minister who wants to say yes to everyone but cannot tell us... he said change begins with honesty. So will he be honest and tell us, is he preparing to raise taxes again, yes or no?

37:43 - 39:26

Speaker 31

Can I say to the right honorable lady, I've already indicated my first moves were to cut tax, but I'm not going to do what any Prime Minister has done and write the budget here. That will... but he and I took a deliberate decision to set an early date for the budget so that we reduced the period for prolonged speculation of the kind that she is wanting us to indulge in today. But can I also say to her, and indeed to the whole of her new shadow cabinet, the majority of whom were part of a government that lasted for 49 days. A short-lived government that crashed confidence in the economy, hammered people's mortgages. She took a decision at the weekend.

She removed... she removed a shadow chancellor who said that the Truss mini-budget was a mistake. And she replaced that shadow chancellor with one that helped to write the Truss mini-budget. And dare I remind the House, Mr. Speaker, the leader of the opposition herself is on record as saying... I say, Mr. Speaker, in response to all of that, other than God help us.

39:26 - 40:43

Kemi Badenoch

...about tax rises. Instead, what he did was lots of point scoring.

He says he wants new politics, he says he wants honesty, so why is he pretending that a junior minister wrote that budget? The fact is, gilt yields now, cost of borrowing, the cost of borrowing now, Mr. Speaker, the cost, they're laughing, they're laughing, I don't know why they're laughing, Mr. Speaker, the cost of borrowing now is far more than it ever was under Liz Truss. Mr. Speaker, the reason why that budget failed is because spending was announced before the money to pay for it, which is exactly what he is doing right now. He says it's the new politics, it's the same old Labour politics, tax and spend. He did not rule out tax rises, and what markets see is a government that cannot control its spending.

So the markets will charge us more to borrow. That means higher mortgage rates for families. It makes life more difficult for everyone. Higher borrowing costs are the biggest threat to family finances. So will he rule out any more borrowing that will make people poorer?

40:43 - 41:51

Speaker 31

Well, can I say to something I said earlier, debt was rising as a percentage of GDP under the previous government. He was some PPS to the DEFRA Secretary with all respect to my right honourable friend at the back. He was in, he was in the Treasury, Mr. Speaker, as a senior minister on the day of the Truss budget. She mentions mortgage rates, well that was the day that they spiked, and that was the day that the British public were hammered by the previous government. We are taking the action needed to get debt down.

This will be a government grounded in fiscal responsibility. It will stick to the fiscal rules, but at the same time we will help reduce cost of living pressure on our constituents, and that's the approach that we will take, and that's the one I would suggest the party opposite they should follow too.

41:51 - 43:00

Kemi Badenoch

Same old, Mr. Speaker, he is the Prime Minister now, he needs to answer the questions instead of spending time attacking someone who has more private sector experience than his entire cabinet. I asked him whether he would rule out more borrowing, he did not do so. We spend more servicing our debt than we do on defence, almost double. There is war in Europe, Mr. Speaker. Yesterday, Germany confirmed that Russia was behind the attack on the SPD.

The Prime Minister's first flight was to Edinburgh, the Foreign Secretary's first flight was to Berlin, and the Chancellor's first flight was to Moscow. We need the plan to hit 3% on defence now, but the armed forces won't know what they'll be getting until next July's spending review. There is a simple answer to this: cut welfare spending and invest that money in our defence now. Mr. Speaker, the honeymoon is over. Isn't it time for the Prime Minister to ditch the vibes and get serious about defending our nation?

43:00 - 44:44

Speaker 31

I'm glad she mentioned the German government yesterday in relation to the attack in Leipzig, and I think that should unite the House in sending complete condemnation of that attack by Russia and complete solidarity in this House to support both Germany and to support Ukraine, and that position will not change. And it takes me to defence. The very reason I appointed this Chancellor to his position is because of his strong commitment to the defence of our country and defence spending.

We will fully fund the defense investment plan and at the spending review we will set out a plan to meet our NATO commitments by 2035. There is no problem with our commitment to defense, Mr. Speaker. But more broadly, the honorable lady has made a lot of accusations there about what went wrong. But I go back to what was the position that she left. The country was not heading in the right direction.

Now we have a clear, coherent, credible plan for growth based on 10 years of delivering it myself. This is grounded in reality. I want to take it to all parts of the country. And it's all about bringing back a sense of positivity, Mr. Speaker, a sense of possibility, growth in every postcode. Let this country believe in itself again.

Let people have some hope. And that is what this government will do.

44:44 - 45:21

Jeff Smith

Thank you, thank you, Mr. Speaker. There is really promising and exciting evidence about the successful use of psychedelic therapy treatments for trauma, mental health, PTSD and addiction. It makes access for clinical research bureaucratic and difficult. So would the Prime Minister and indeed members across the House consider supporting my amendments to the Health Bill next week when it returns, which would keep safeguards in place but remove some of the barriers to some of this important research and treatment?

45:21 - 46:02

Speaker 31

Well, can I thank my honorable friend and pay tribute to his campaign on this particular issue. I was talking about getting the economy going in all parts of the country, innovation-led economy, and that applies to research and research into life sciences as well. And I believe strongly, Mr. Speaker, we must address all barriers to high-quality research in the life sciences. I'm happy to look at his amendment particularly, Mr. Speaker. I will ask a health minister to meet him to discuss it.

But of course, we must ensure that any changes are safe and effective.

46:02 - 46:58

Speaker 42

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister said yesterday that Brexit ushered in a decade of low growth and stalled regeneration. He is right. Our economy is stuck in this mess thanks to the Conservatives and the Leader of Reform and their terrible Brexit deal. Unless we grow the economy, there is no way we can end the cost of living crisis or cut the cost of borrowing for the government.

The answer is staring him in the face. Join the single market, get a new deal with Europe and cut costs for families, businesses and government. It's the bold step our country desperately needs. Will the Prime Minister take it?

46:58 - 48:03

Speaker 31

Well, can I thank the right honorable gentleman and I think he is absolutely right to share the analysis that I laid out yesterday. It's clear the growth, the low growth we've had, the decade of low growth has been partly a result of Brexit. And the sooner the party opposite accepts that, the more we can start to face up to Britain's future and where do we go from here. I do want a closer relationship. I will build on the work of my predecessor.

There are issues facing British farming right now and there are issues facing British steel right now. And the Made in Europe agenda could pose significant problems for British steel.

So as he will know, we are approaching a UK-EU summit in the next couple of months. It is imperative, I believe, that we work hard to get a good deal for British steel, for British farming as part of that new deal that he talks about.

48:03 - 48:04

Sir Ed Davey.

48:04 - 48:53

Speaker 42

Well, I hope at that summit he will negotiate a good deal for our country, our economy and our defence, and that means rejoining the single market. But moving on, Mr. Speaker, North Devon's maternity unit has been closed for three weeks due to staff shortages. So women now have to travel up to two hours to give birth. When my kids were born, I can't imagine the extra stress that would have caused. And some women have even had to give birth in their cars.

This should be unthinkable in our country. So will the Prime Minister commit to reopening North Devon's maternity unit in days, not weeks? And will he stop maternity closures across the country so expectant mums never have to face travelling such terrifying distances?

48:53 - 49:49

Speaker 31

So let me give a direct answer. I will commit to reopening it, but not within days. I don't think I am in a position to make that commitment today, Mr. Speaker, but I do understand the concern. It is not right for his constituents, for people living in the North Devon area to have to travel that far. Apologies, I realise his constituency is somewhere else.

So let me take that away and let me also, though, say to him with honesty, there are structural issues here affecting maternity services across the UK because this is not the only hospital where there have been difficulties. And I am aware from my former time as Secretary of State for Health, and I believe it is right that we look at all of those issues. But I can give him a guarantee that my right honourable friend the Health Secretary is looking at those issues following the recent maternity reviews that we've had.

Natasha Irons.

49:49 - 51:25

Speaker 44

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A wise man recently called for good growth in every postcode and hope in every heart, and in Croydon these cannot come soon enough. Gatwick expansion could provide Croydon's young people with world-class employment and training close to their home. But cuts to investment in rail infrastructure around East Croydon station by the previous Conservative government means these opportunities could still be out of reach because Croydon's young people physically cannot get to them. So will the Prime Minister look again at the Croydon area modelling scheme, back my campaign to unblock the Croydon bottleneck, and can he outline what his government is doing to give young people in Croydon East access the opportunities that they deserve?

Well, can I say to my honourable friend, we certainly will do that. I am in no doubt of the importance of good transport connectivity to young people's life chances. And I will ask Number 10 North to make contact with her so that we can get that scheme back on track. More broadly, we do need to change the way we support young people. And I've announced already a change to education so that we have a technical path for young people from 14, so that we give young people a path towards good T-levels, BTECs, work placements, degree apprenticeships.

And we support them with travel costs, which is something that I did in Greater Manchester. Bringing back hope very much starts with our young people, Mr. Speaker. Give them a clear path from school towards a good job. And that is something that the current education system is failing to do. And both of us will be sitting on the back benches when we don't back it.

51:25 - 51:27

Sorcha Eastwood

Sorcha Eastwood.

51:27 - 51:37

Speaker 31

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the people of Northern Ireland are absolutely scunnered. At the moment we have poisonous parade and disputes and border polls spats. Meanwhile, the Northern Ireland economy is in the doldrums.

51:44 - 51:47

Speaker 47

And both of us will be on the back benches when we don't make it.

51:47 - 51:49

Speaker 45

Sorcha Eastwood.

51:49 - 52:26

Sorcha Eastwood

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the people of Northern Ireland are absolutely scunnered. At the moment, we have poisonous parading disputes and border polls spats. Meanwhile, the Northern Ireland Assembly has no budget. We can have reform at Stormont, or we can have sound public finances in Northern Ireland, but we cannot have both.

Alliance have led the way on calls for a change in our broken system of government in Northern Ireland. Will the Prime Minister commit to meeting with me and my colleagues to discuss how we can reform the Belfast Good Friday Act?

52:26 - 52:51

Speaker 31

I will work with her and her colleagues on precisely that. I was in Northern Ireland with the Northern Ireland Secretary last week. Our first responsibility is to get Stormont government up and running and functioning properly with a budget. I've empowered the Northern Ireland Secretary to go into talks to resolve that issue, and the broader issues about reform, we can continue that conversation once we've got that in place.

52:51 - 52:53

Liam Fox

Sir Liam Fox.

52:53 - 53:27

Sadik Al-Hassan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm delighted that North Somerset is finally getting two fantastic new stations at Pill and Portishead with the reopening of the railway line. But, and I hate to sound greedy, with Bristol Airport's potential expansion on the horizon, it risks becoming one of the worst connected major airports in the country. Will my right honourable friend the Prime Minister agree that now we need a proper mass transit system for North Somerset and WECA, linking Felton, the new Woodspring development, Long Ashton, and the wider economic area?

53:27 - 54:04

Speaker 31

Well, I know my honourable friend worked hard on getting those new stations. People in Portishead and Pill have waited far too long for those new stations, but they're now on the way. And can I say, it does reflect what I was saying to the House yesterday. The big cities of England, and I'm talking about Leeds, talking about Bristol, they should have mass transit systems, Mr. Speaker. And I will work with the wonderful Mayor of the West of England, Helen Godwin, to make progress on that, to connect Bristol, its new arena, the station, the development at Temple Meads, into a mass transit system that takes Bristol forward.

54:04 - 54:06

Speaker 46

Stanley Johnson.

54:06 - 54:36

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Prime Minister to his place? Now, the Prime Minister knows the importance of protecting local green belt, indeed he made it a key part of his by-election campaign in Makerfield. It's incredibly important in my constituency too, where there's an 85% increase in the housing target and we are 89% green belt. The Prime Minister says that he wants to do things differently and share the burden across the country, will he meet with me to discuss a new path forward?

54:36 - 55:18

Speaker 31

Well, I thank him for his question. It is about getting a balance, isn't it? Yes, we need to protect green belt where we can, but we also need to build the homes that people need. And it is about striking a balance. In Greater Manchester, I always took a brownfield-first approach, and that's what I will do.

And I've asked the Chancellor to work with my cabinet colleagues to release more public land so that we can build more homes on brownfield land. But I do understand the concerns that he's raised. I will ask the Housing Minister to meet him to see if we can further build some common cause. But there is a balance to be struck, and I would say to the party opposite, it's important they do not turn their face away from building the new homes this country needs.

55:18 - 55:19

Kim Leadbeater.

55:19 - 56:01

Kim Leadbeater

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and welcome back, and can I also welcome the Prime Minister to his role.

We have many shared passions: sport, music, and a deep sense of community. I know we both have a strong desire to ensure that everyone in our country has a sense of pride, identity and belonging, that everyone feels safe and no one feels lonely. But sadly, that isn't always the case. So what steps is he taking to support people in communities like Spen Valley who may feel isolated or are dealing with anti-social behaviour such as speeding and dangerous driving, inappropriate use of e-bikes and off-road e-scooters and off-road bikes, and fireworks, to give residents confidence that their concerns are being taken seriously.

56:01 - 56:47

Speaker 31

Well, I do thank my honourable friend for this question because she's speaking for many people at home who'll be nodding away when she says what she's said. I spoke to these issues in the Wakefield by-election where we had an illegal waste tip that just looked like nobody was taking any action on. Fireworks, I think there is a case for going further regulating those. But on anti-social behaviour more broadly, I supported Greater Manchester Police in taking the toughest possible approach to rooting out anti-social behaviour through Operation Vulcan. I think it can be extended elsewhere.

We shouldn't accept that this is just the daily norm in communities. I happen to support the broken window theory of policing. If you let small things go, bigger things come along, and we should change the way we think about neighbourhood policing as the Home Secretary is doing.

56:47 - 57:18

Liz Roberts

Diolch yn fawr, Llywydd. A new Plaid Cymru government has laid the foundations for change, showing what Wales can achieve with the powers we have. The Prime Minister says devolving powers means better public services, and I agree with him. But policing in Wales is still controlled from afar here in Westminster. So will he please put his devolution instincts into practice, confirm that devolving policing will be on the table when he meets the First Minister next month.

57:18 - 57:51

Speaker 31

The approach I will take, Mr Speaker, and I say this to the honourable lady, and we did, we met the Deputy First Minister last week at Port Talbot. Where proposals come from the Senedd government, we will give them a fair consideration. We do need to work together to get growth, growth going. We do need to secure the future of Port Talbot together, and if that can be done with more locally devolved power across Wales, then I am absolutely ready to work with her and the First Minister on that.

57:51 - 58:50

Tanmanjeet Dhesi

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. The British people should be under no illusion that the nation faces a significantly increased threat level, especially from Russia, but also we have a US leadership for whom European security is no longer a focus or priority. And that is why it is imperative that we invest in our armed forces in the here and now, rather than be sorry later. Indeed, defence is definitely one area where vibes alone just isn't going to be enough. So rather than kick the can down the road waiting for a fiscal event in the future, in a future year, will the Prime Minister urgently commit to charting a pathway to reach 3% of GDP spend on defence by 2030, which as his Chancellor rightly noted, is critical to keep our country safe.

58:50 - 59:41

Speaker 31

Well, I've made that commitment, made it very clear, Mr Speaker, and I have done for a considerable period of time. And I was in Ukraine last week for a very specific reason to repeat it on the world stage there, so the honourable gentleman can be absolutely sure of that. But I also think alongside our commitment to defence, we also have to build the resilience of Britain. We need to ensure that the maximum amount of that funding committed to the defence investment plan goes back into the reindustrialisation of our communities. That we do more to maintain sovereign manufacturing and production capability here, and this will be a theme of my government, making sure that the British taxpayer's money goes in to supporting industry in our own country to make us more resilient going into the future.

59:40 - 59:41

Andrew George.

59:41 - 01:00:27

Andrew George

Whereas, Mr. Speaker, my community-led homes private member's bill aims to help combat widening inequality in the UK. In Cornwall alone during the last decade, through tax loopholes, over half a billion pounds of taxpayer's money has been handed out to second home owners while the housing problems of locals have got significantly worse. And the planning system, which is fueled by greed rather than need, simply allows land value speculators to fill their boots while the housing problems get worse. So will the Prime Minister meet with me so that we can identify tools within my private member's bill to empower communities to address that desperate need?

01:00:27 - 01:01:00

Speaker 31

Well, can I say to the honorable gentleman, I've worked with him over many years and I remember in the coalition years he didn't always take that line and I respect him for that. I will look very closely at his private member's bill. How about this? I will agree here and now to meeting with him and all Cornish MPs to discuss what we might also do alongside his bill, what we might do to put powers and levers within the devolution deal to deal with those very specific issues he's just raised in relation to second homes in Cornwall.

01:01:00 - 01:01:51

Helena Dollimore

Helena Dollimore.

So excited about the return of the Bayeux Tapestry coming back to our shores for the first time in almost a thousand years and testament to this Labour government's work to strengthen our relations with European neighbors. Hastings has often been at the center of historical events, but we have not felt the benefit and we rank in the bottom ten places nationally for social mobility. Thanks to my campaign, the young people I represent will get free priority access to the tapestry exhibition and not be priced out by the cost of a ticket. Does the Prime Minister agree with me that this is great news and that the British Museum must do all it can to ensure as many people from my area can see the exhibition?

01:01:51 - 01:02:33

Speaker 31

Well, can I say to my honorable friend, I will relay that very message to the former Chancellor of the Exchequer who runs the British Museum tonight. And I hope I will do so with the support of the benches opposite, that we want the maximum number of kids to have access to stand in front of that tapestry while it's here in the UK. It's a major moment in our island's history and it's such a powerful one. They learn about it in school, they should be able to stand in front of it. And can I just credit her for the amazing campaign that she has run on this issue.

I know her school children in her own constituency will be there, but I can hear in her voice she wants it for every child in this country and let's see what we can do.

01:02:33 - 01:03:03

Daniel Danny Rayner Kruger

Danny Kruger.

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I applaud the Prime Minister's focus on civil society and on support for young people. But the fact is that in his time as Mayor of Greater Manchester, youth employment there did not improve, in fact it got worse. And no amount of taxpayer-funded support is going to fix that. So will the Prime Minister accept that the way to get young people into work is to provide meaningful tax cuts for businesses and also to ensure that people who can work should be working?

01:03:03 - 01:03:55

Speaker 31

I indicated that earlier today, Mr. Speaker. Young people who can work should be working. I believe they want to work. The question is have we always given them the support that they need? As Mayor of Greater Manchester, proudly I delivered a huge increase in the work placements attached to T-levels that benefited young people.

I did, I introduced a free bus pass for sixteen to eighteen year olds to connect them to opportunity. And actually the rise in NEETs was not the same in Greater Manchester as in other parts of the country, so he might want to go back and check that.

On this issue, let's work to get the best possible package we can to support our young people. It is too hard growing up as it is at this moment in time. We can make it better if we do it as a cross-party... with cross-party support. That's the best message we could send to the next generation.

01:03:55 - 01:03:56

Mohammad Yasin.

01:03:56 - 01:04:42

Mohammad Yasin

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Labour government has already delivered real investment for Bedford, including our community diagnostic centre, urgent care centre, and funding for the Putnoe walk-in centre. I was pleased to open Bedford's new mental health crisis house this summer. But Mr. Speaker, the inpatient mental health services my constituents lost in 2017 have never been replaced. So will the Prime Minister commit to working with me to take the next steps towards restoring adult and young people's inpatient mental health provision in Bedford, so that my constituent can access the right care in the right place at the right time?

01:04:42 - 01:05:05

Speaker 31

Well, that last point, Mr. Speaker, is the point. And with mental health services, we have to do better on that. And the Health Secretary absolutely agrees with this. It's why we committed in the summer to community-based mental health provision to make it easier for people to access that provision. I am aware of his concerns about Bedford Hospital.

I will work with the Health Secretary to address them with him.

01:05:06 - 01:05:48

Jack Rankin

Frankly, Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister did not answer any of the questions the Leader of the... the Leader of the Opposition put to him on spending. Over the summer, the markets were clearly anxious when he failed to articulate the fiscal rules to Victoria Derbyshire. In his statement yesterday, he waxed lyrical about a decade where we had a three-day week and blackouts, presumably because he liked the music. But we now know what the international capital markets have made of that. Can he now, in front of this House, confirm what the fiscal rules are and categorically say that the government will stick to them?

01:05:48 - 01:06:02

Speaker 31

No borrowing to fund day-to-day spending, debt falling as a percentage of GDP by the end of the Parliament, and yes, we will.

01:06:03 - 01:06:33

Speaker 66

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In High Peak and across the country, we suffered devastating wildfires this summer. I'm grateful to the Prime Minister for the action he took, including the temporary ban on disposable barbecues. But we have to face the fact that our climate is changing and communities like mine are suffering the consequences. Will the Prime Minister set out what more he will do to ensure that we are better prepared to prevent and tackle wildfires next summer, including making the ban on disposable barbecues permanent?

01:06:33 - 01:07:21

Speaker 31

Well, can I say, Mr. Speaker, my honourable friend was an important voice in the summer, and I am aware of the problems in his constituency on the border of Greater Manchester. And these have been problems we've seen over a number of years now. He was right to call out the... the need for a ban on temporary... on temporary barbecues, disposable barbecues. More broadly, this is a bigger challenge. So I'm going to call a wildfire summit.

He'd be welcome to attend. I think our fire and rescue services are not set up properly for the changing climate. We do not have the most modern equipment. We do not have aerial support to tackle wildfires as we see in France or Italy or other countries. And when it comes to the latter part of this year with the flooding that is expected, it's not even a statutory responsibility of our fire and rescue services.

01:07:21 - 01:07:25

Speaker 56

If you will join me at that summit, we can make further progress.

01:07:25 - 01:08:25

Seamus Logan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Energy Secretary will shortly choose between six NESO pathway options for the Strategic Spatial Energy Plan, which will shape where and when energy infrastructure is developed over the next 25 years. ScotWind is key to Scotland's industrial future. It represents 78.5 billion of potential investment, part of an overall package that Crown Estate Scotland estimates could support more than 21,000 jobs. But, Mr. Speaker, the GMB union in Scotland has warned among others this week that the wrong pathway could deny energy transition opportunities for our world-class, skilled, and experienced Scottish energy workers and industries.

So, after the betrayal of the last administration at Grangemouth and Ardersier, can the Prime Minister commit today to selecting a pathway that enables the full ScotWind pipeline, including floating offshore wind and the grid investment to deliver Scotland's energy potential?

01:08:25 - 01:09:15

Speaker 31

Well, can I say to the honorable gentleman, this is exactly what I'm talking about when I'm talking about supporting industrial transition so that we can reindustrialize Scotland and other parts of the country. It has to be done in a pragmatic way so that we can make that transition work, rather than being too ideological about it as other parties are. So I will work with him. I intend to visit Scotland soon to look in detail at the issues in the Aberdeen community, because I know they've struggled with the impact of transition. Let's see what we can do to build common cause, and let's look at Grangemouth too, which could be the home of sustainable aviation fuel.

I'm interested in making progress on all of these issues, Mr. Speaker, and I will work with him on that.

01:09:15 - 01:10:17

Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett

Final question, Samantha Niblett.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I congratulate the Prime Minister on his first PMQs? It is my first PMQs too. I also want to declare an interest as I'm the chair of the APPG for sexual and reproductive health. My and Cindy Gallop's campaign for lifelong sex education has seen tremendous response and support from many, including professionals across occupational health, medicine, nursing, public health, academia, the NEU, and the police.

I have discovered that shame, guilt, and embarrassment around talking about sex and body parts like penis and vagina is even leading to late diagnosis of health conditions and illnesses such as cancer for many in my constituency of South Derbyshire and across the country. Something I have spoken about with the Eve Appeal and constituent Louise Clark, a GP who specializes in cancer of the vulva. They're really great for my campaign. So, as September is National Gynecological Cancer Month, and as the summer of sex comes to a close, will the Prime Minister agree to meet with me to talk about my campaign?

01:10:17 - 01:10:29

Speaker 31

I will indeed, Mr. Speaker. And she's been raising important issues that others haven't spoken about. And it's very clear to me that her summer was more exciting than mine.

01:10:29 - 01:11:34

Speaker 64

That completes Prime Minister's Questions. We'll let the front bench change over.

01:11:34 - 01:15:26

Speaker 61

Mr. Speaker, with your permission, I would like to make a statement on the work of the newly formed Office of the Prime Minister and Cabinet and the change it will bring. On the steps of Downing Street six weeks ago, the Prime Minister set out the priorities that will guide this government. He was clear that 40 years of overly centralized decision-making and over-privatization has stripped power and resources away from communities in every nation and region of this country. That public control over the things that matter so much to people's lives have been systematically eroded and become a barrier to businesses to start and grow. That a broken economic and political model has cost good jobs and opportunities in many parts of the country while delivering sky-high prices in exchange for poorer customer services.

The Prime Minister was clear that this government will be the circuit breaker that our country needs. The government that will take power from Westminster and Whitehall and put it in the hands of the communities who are best placed to use it. That will rewire Britain so that our politics and our economy work for every person and every place. Built on a bedrock of fiscal discipline, we will build a pro-business culture, an innovation-led economy that delivers good growth in every postcode. Mr. Speaker, we have wasted no time in delivering on that commitment.

In the newly formed Office of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, we are rewiring the machinery of government so that the Prime Minister has the resources and levers he needs to deliver on his priorities. By stripping out many of the bureaucratic functions of the office, we have created a stronger, more focused department that is capable of driving forward the Prime Minister's agenda. Because this government recognizes that for far too long, there has been a disconnect between the Cabinet Office and Number 10. And it is that lack of joined-up thinking that has hampered the ability of successive Prime Ministers to drive forward their own agendas across government. We have had a dichotomy at the heart of government: the most centralized state in the G20 with one of the most underpowered centers.

So in the newly established OPMC, we are ensuring that the Prime Minister has the support and resources he needs to deliver the change the public are impatient to see. And from this office, we will drive forward work across government to put the essentials like water, transport, energy and housing under greater public control. To regenerate our communities, breathe new life into our high streets, and to give people more room to breathe through action on the cost of living. And that work of change has begun, Mr. Speaker. Working closely with the Prime Minister and Cabinet Secretary, we have begun the work of shifting power and resources away from Whitehall.

Through our devolution blueprint and the establishment of Number 10 North, we have created a new engine of regional economic growth that will empower places that have been overlooked by Westminster for too long. We are granting new powers to strategic authorities to take more control over the future of their regions. A greater share of locally generated revenues, beginning with business rates, more control over housing, public transport and infrastructure. For the first time, local leaders will have the power and resources they need to invest in the things that matter most to their communities. And this government is filling in the map to bring an end to the system of two-tier devolution so that we are able to extend the same offer to all parts of England by the end of 2028 that the rest has enjoyed for many years.

01:15:26 - 01:23:33

Speaker 59

This is how we can empower communities, drive local economic growth, create new jobs and deliver maximum benefit to the people who live there. This is devolution by design and devolution by default. And working across government, we will build a new economic model that begins to put life's essentials back under stronger public control and make them affordable for people again. Working with my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government and the honourable member for Doncaster Central. Building on the strong foundations laid down by my predecessor, my right honourable friend the member for Bristol North West, who I give my thanks to for his work today.

We are delivering a once in a generation rebalancing of power in this country. This is what a rewired state looks like, Mr Speaker, one that is relentlessly focused on delivering for the people of this country. Empowered communities, good growth in every postcode, these are the tests against which our decisions will be measured and the metrics by which our actions will be judged. Last month, the Chancellor and I announced reforms to public procurement that will cut red tape and unleash a new wave of British job creation. Too often small and medium-sized businesses have struggled to navigate complicated procurement processes that seem to prioritise everything.

And when we prioritise everything, we prioritise nothing. So we are making the process simpler and doing things differently. From next year businesses seeking to win a share of 90 billion pounds in central government contracts will be left in no doubt about what we want from them. Creating good jobs and giving young people the skills they need for the future. These new rules will ensure the 90 billion pounds that is spent each year through government contracts supports British jobs, skills and people in every postcode.

And we are going further in our reforms to public procurement to ensure taxpayers' money is delivering more for our communities. For the first time since 2020, we are removing the defence exemption from social value. That means billions of pounds of defence contracts will soon give weighting to jobs and skills for young people across Britain. This is how we back businesses in every part of the country. And in my ministerial colleagues, the honourable member for Gateshead Central and Whickham and the honourable member for Chipping Barnet, businesses that are looking to build and grow here in Britain, creating those good jobs and driving that good growth will have strong advocates in this government.

Mr Speaker, the work of my department in strengthening our national resilience and coordinating the government's response to emergencies remains central. Over the summer we saw communities across the country impacted by unprecedented wildfires, precipitated by one of the hottest and driest summers on record. A reminder of the very real and present threats to the UK posed by climate change. During the third week of August four major incidents were declared across South Wales, Hampshire, Cambridgeshire and the West Midlands. By the 13th of August fire and rescue services were tackling 47 wildfire incidents.

79 separate requests for additional equipment and resources were made by fire and rescue services. In South Wales alone, more than 200 military personnel were deployed to tackle 14 separate incidents. Such was the extent of support being provided across the country, almost every fire service was impacted or involved in the response. And some of the most stretched services faced the prospect of having to deprioritise certain call-outs due to the pressures on the system. The day before the national alert was issued close to 12,000 999 calls were recorded in a single day, six times the average call volume.

Many services were stretched to breaking point, but continued to work around the clock to protect lives, communities and properties. I am sure everyone in the house will join me in thanking our emergency services and military personnel who put themselves in harm's way to keep us safe. On the 14th of August, when the government received direct requests from fire and rescue services for urgent government intervention, we took decisive action. A national emergency alert was issued to provide the public with clear guidance on the steps they should take to avoid inadvertently contributing to an already dangerous situation. And Mr. Speaker, it should come as no surprise that the British public did their bit.

Within 48 hours, there was a 42% decrease in the number of 999 calls, falling from 12,000 to 5,200, and by Monday morning, the number of live wildfire incidents had fallen from 47 to 27. This gave our fire and rescue services the breathing space they needed to tackle existing fires and keep us all safe. Over the coming weeks, I will continue to work closely with cabinet colleagues to ensure the government's response meets the scale of the challenges we face. I'll be working closely with my ministerial colleague, the security minister, in ensuring this government takes a long-term and strategic approach to the country's preparedness. And the government will continue to work closely with our frontline services and local resilience forums to mitigate against the risks posed by extreme weather and drought, including a 100 million pounds increase in funding for the fire services and a 65 million boost in support of our farmers.

Mr. Speaker, in the interest of brevity, I will touch briefly on the work that is happening elsewhere in my department. I've been delighted to welcome the right honorable member for the Vale of Glamorgan, not only to his role as the minister for AI, but also in joining us around the cabinet table. The Prime Minister has been clear that he sees harnessing the potential of artificial intelligence as a central part of our country's future, and the elevation of this role reflects the ambition this government has to make Britain a world leader in these advanced technologies. I am also pleased to welcome the minister for intergovernmental and European relations to his role. The right honorable member for Lincoln has wasted no time in the vital work of building stronger ties with our closest neighbors and allies, and I was very grateful for him interrupting his honeymoon to come home and be appointed to the post.

My department is also bringing forward a program to modernize the operation of the state. We are taking public control of the way government works, cutting out the unnecessary processes and needless reviews that slow decision making and stifle innovation. At the heart of this agenda will be the restoration of ministers' responsibility and agency to deliver the change they promised, with increased accountability to parliament and the public for the direction they set and the decisions they take. We will bring forward new methods of public deliberation into policy development and do away with box-ticking consultation with the usual suspects. Fewer decisions will be delegated to unelected bodies, and the way decisions are made will be scrutinized in parliament and not in the courts, ending the warm bath of constructive ambiguity which politics has been too happy to soak in for far too long.

Mr. Speaker, I am aware and deeply honored to be the first woman to hold the role of First Secretary of State since the late great Barbara Castle. If I can channel even a fraction of the energy and determination that she brought to this role, then I'm confident that collectively we can change our country for the better. For too long, too many places have been written out of our national story, with their contribution ignored and their potential overlooked. People feel like the system just doesn't work for them. That is why in 2024, they voted for change.

Mr. Speaker, this government is on a mission to ensure we can deliver on the Prime Minister and the public's priorities. It is a collective endeavor, and we will deliver the lasting change that people deserve together.

01:23:33 - 01:23:36

Speaker 72

I commend this statement to the house.

01:23:36 - 01:29:37

Alex Burghart

Shadow Secretary of State, Alex Burghart.

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And I'd like to thank the Deputy Prime Minister for advance sight of her statement and congratulate her on her appointment. It's a major achievement and I look forward to working with her. I'd also like to congratulate her on the wording of her statement. Rewiring the state was a phrase first coined by the leader of the opposition in her leadership contest in the summer of 2024 for a very good reason.

Yeah, the state does need rewiring. We agree on that. It's in urgent need of rewiring. Needs rewiring so that politicians can make decisions. It needs rewiring so that elected governments can fulfill their mandates speedily.

And it needs rewiring so the state does not continue to grow ad infinitum. Now, I know that the new administration delights in nothing more than criticizing the Blair government. There were many reasons to criticize the Blair government, but I just wish to talk about three. The first is quangos, the second is the nature of the Treasury, and the third is the issue of legal constraint. Some of the worst of these problems entrenched institutional inertia.

On quangos, we've seen over time that they have led to ministers having less agency over important decisions that affect our constituents' lives. So it is unfortunate that the Deputy Prime Minister's today announced the creation of a massive new quango in OneGov delivery agency. This is going to be in charge of government recruitment, civil service pensions, shared services, security vetting and so on. It will oversee considerable public money. It is a step in the wrong direction because ministers will retain responsibility for those services, but they will lose power over them.

One of the reasons why we've seen a proliferation of ALBs is because they have become a way of dodging the excessive bureaucracy put on by the center. And by the center in this instance, I really mean the Treasury. The Treasury, which was the behemoth created in its modern form by Gordon Brown, designed to control Whitehall, designed to reduce department ministers' authority over their spend and over their decisions. So I was genuinely interested to hear the right honorable lady say over the summer that the Treasury was an imperial finance department. Yeah, and I rather hope that she was going to lead the charge to, you know, smash, smash over the barricades and destroy this terrible imperial power.

But instead, Mr. Speaker, it appears that the empire has struck back. Because, you know, the briefing that we were given initially was that Number 10 North was going to take control of growth. That seems to have been watered down. It's now rumored that the Chancellor is going to give the speech on growth next week and that the real power remains within Number 11 South. You know, so will she tell the house what powers, levers and budget will she, as head of Number 10 North, have to increase growth across the UK?

Legal constraint is obviously a massive problem. Over the Blair years, we saw legislation like the Human Rights Act create environmental legislation, create endless sources of, endless sources of judicial review. And it made it increasingly difficult for government to do things, to build infrastructure and so on. It is a colossal drag on the capabilities of the state. And if the honorable lady wishes to work on that, we would be very happy to work with her on it.

What we did hear today was a further exposition on devolution and on the merits of Number 10 North. Now, for this to be credible, the government needs to be able to give three basic guarantees. The first is that it's going to lead to an overall reduction in the size of the civil service. Despite promises made after the election, the opposite has happened under Labour. Since the general election, the headcount of the civil service has risen by over 11,000.

Is that going to be reduced? By when? The second is on the nature of devolution, whether it's driven by the interests of local people or just by those of one party. Over the summer, Labour councillors were allowed to redraw the boundaries of the very authorities that they hope to represent, and to do so before any independent review by the Local Government Boundary Commission. Labour set about the biggest reorganization of local government in 50 years, with no mandate to do so, and announced it on the day before recess, with no scrutiny.

One wonders, Mr. Speaker, how it can be localism if it is imposed, and imposed with constraints. Again, over the summer, after the Prime Minister had made his interesting announcement about assigned income tax and retained business rates, Tees Valley Mayor Lord Houchen said that he would create a new rebate scheme to put money back into people's pockets and let families keep more of the money they earn. It's an excellent idea, Mr. Speaker. It's an excellent Conservative idea. It was so excellent that it was immediately shot down by the Deputy Prime Minister.

Will the Deputy Prime Minister tell us whether combined authority mayors will be able to cut taxes or give rebates so that working people can keep more of their money? Or is this just going to lead to higher taxes? Because otherwise, Mr. Speaker, it appears that local mayors will not have the freedom to cut taxes, they will only have the freedom to increase them. They will only have the freedom to increase the size of the state, not to reduce it. It appears that this government is rewiring the state, but just to grow it.

And so the last point, Mr. Speaker, is simply about cost. How much is this reorganization costing? How much is being spent on Number 10 North? How much will need to be spent in order to power the localization agenda that this administration has put forward? How much?

And where is that money coming from? Is it coming from other departments, in which case from where? Or is it coming from tax, if so which taxes? And if it is coming from borrowing, well I think the bond markets will have something to say about that. Because until the government can show that it is able to cut taxes and cut spending so that we can get real growth across the country, I'm afraid all of this will just be another northern pipe dream.

01:29:37 - 01:32:38

Speaker 59

Premiership. Let me thank the Shadow Secretary of State for his kind words. My title is the First Secretary of State. He may wish to be the Shadow Deputy Prime Minister, but that's not shadowing me. But I'm very glad we can find such common ground and I'm very grateful for his kind words.

Let me start by the cost of Number 10 North, which I imagine he knows already by the number and the sheer quantity of PQs and FOIs that have come in over the summer. That has been fully funded within existing Cabinet Office budgets with no additional spending pressure there. We're very grateful to colleagues in Manchester in Heron House for hosting us so graciously and it's working exceptionally well. Look, can I say that I absolutely agree and I hope that we can work together on looking at where we can streamline the state, on how we can ensure that elected governments of any stripe can make the decisions that they have been elected to do. I think there is an awful lot of common ground and frustration that people would share across this House around unelected regulators, unelected quangos standing in the way of democratically elected politicians.

And there is a serious commitment from this government to tear away that red tape and make sure that we can deliver on the change that we were elected to deliver. Can I just gently point out then the irony that he's just asked me to ensure that the quango, the Boundary Commission, takes those decisions on local government reorganization rather than the democratically elected communities secretary.

Can I also say that we've already been very clear that the central civil service is expected to shrink, that we do want it to be more streamlined, more efficient, and that our commitment to devolution and to rewiring the state absolutely means fewer civil servants at the centre and building the capacity and capability of regional and local government, local government of which has been a huge, huge victim of course of the decade of austerity and has held back growth in our local economies. The moving of policy functions out of the Cabinet Office is in order to streamline the priorities for the Prime Minister and ensure that we can be ruthlessly committed on delivery and on delivering his priorities. I make no apologies for that. And in terms of the new functions of Number 10, we have transferred a number of strategic functions into Number 10 North, including moving local economic growth and devolution strategy from the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and local economic growth policy from HM Treasury. It's a little bit of a chip on its empire.

01:32:39 - 01:33:35

Clive Betts

Thank you, Speaker. First of all, could I offer two congratulations? First of all, to my right honourable friend and constituency neighbour for this well-deserved promotion. I'm sure she'll do an excellent job. And secondly, to her and the Prime Minister for the real commitment to devolution.

It's something I've wanted to see for an awful long time, and I hope it goes to local councils as first-tier authorities as well as to strategic authorities. Could I ask about one area which isn't really covered so far, and that's education? She's probably aware in my constituency that in five wards with some high levels of deprivation, there is not a single sixth form. But responsibility for that rests totally with academy trusts, and the local council has no power or influence over it whatsoever. So when she looks again at devolution to bodies who have democratic control, could she look again at the education system, which is going to be absolutely key in tackling the problem of NEETs?

01:33:35 - 01:34:02

Speaker 59

Very grateful to my very good right honourable friend. He's absolutely right, and my constituency shares exactly the same problem. In the east of the constituency, there are very few options for sixth forms in comparison to the wealthier west of the constituency, and it's a huge issue for educational inequality for our constituents. It's absolutely something I will take away and look at with the Education Secretary, but he'll also note that we have committed to devolution of 16 to 19 as well.

01:34:02 - 01:36:27

Lisa Smart

Lisa Smart, Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

Mr. Speaker, and I thank the First Secretary of State for advance sight of her statement and warmly welcome her to her place. The Liberal Democrats agree strongly that the current political system is overly centralised. We believe the best decisions are those taken closest to the people they affect. Renewing communities must also mean giving councils the powers and resources they need to revitalise our high streets, support independent businesses, and improve local public services. After years of severe financial pressure, devolution cannot simply mean transferring responsibilities from Whitehall without the funding necessary to deliver them.

She mentions national resilience. That's about whether the lights stay on, whether the shelves stay stocked, and whether a family in Hazel Grove can get through a week or more of serious disruption without losing their livelihood. And the COVID inquiry was blunt. It found that we were ill-prepared for emergency, never mind a pandemic, and these failures cost lives, and people deserve to know the lessons have been acted on rather than filed away. And there's certainly progress to welcome.

We've got the Resilience Action Plan, UK Resilience Academy, and Exercise Pegasus being the largest pandemic exercise this country's ever run, and these are steps my party has long called for. But announcements are not preparedness, and I'd welcome hearing from the First Secretary what plans she has to improve public awareness and understanding of what the whole of society needs to do to be ready.

We're in an increasingly uncertain world, so will the government think again on digital sovereignty so that the critical systems our constituents rely on are not dependent on suppliers this country cannot control? And I agree strongly with the First Secretary that the country has a broken political system. Later this afternoon we will be debating the Representation of the People Bill, which is meant to fix it. It takes some steps in the right direction, but it fails to rise to the moment. Does she agree that there is still so much more to be done, starting with halting the scourge of big money that is poisoning our democracy by capping political donations and bringing in a fairer voting system?

We need to fix our politics so we can get on with fixing the country, and I have heard her previously in this House talk about moving fast and fixing things. I urge her to crack on.

01:36:27 - 01:36:28

First Secretary.

01:36:28 - 01:38:02

Speaker 59

Well, I'm very grateful to the honourable lady and I can confirm my motto is still firmly in place of moving fast and fixing things. She's absolutely right that in order to deliver devolution effectively and deliver the growth and improved public services that we need to see, it has to come with resource and revenue as well, which is why we've committed to allowing strategic authorities to take a share of income tax and business rates so that they can be incentivised to grow their economies and to take their fair share to reinvest in their local economies. On digital sovereignty, this is exactly the work that my right honourable friend the AI Minister is looking at through his taskforce, and I'm sure he will update the House in due course as one of his important workstreams that he is considering with colleagues across government. And as she rightly says, this afternoon we will be debating the Elections Bill. She and I absolutely share a commitment to stop big money and foreign money in particular interfering in our politics, and I will be working with colleagues across government through the Defending the Democracy Taskforce, which my right honourable friend the Security Minister chairs, to look at what further steps we can take beyond this Bill.

Finally, in relation to preparedness, in July my predecessor announced that we will be delivering a campaign to raise awareness of the simple steps households can take to keep themselves safe during everyday emergencies like extreme weather, and we'll be announcing more information and beginning the campaign later this year.

01:38:02 - 01:38:42

Andrew Paul Foster

Paul Foster.

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. Lancashire has missed out on government investment for decades. My constituents in South Ribble have been treated to nothing other than scraps of investment left in the pot at the end of the year. We now have an opportunity like no other in generations. Lancashire needs devolution and an elected mayor.

Will the First Secretary of State please facilitate an urgent meeting for myself and Lancashire colleagues with Number 10 North to unlock this desperately needed opportunity for real investment and prosperity in Lancashire? Thank you.

01:38:42 - 01:38:43

First Secretary.

01:38:43 - 01:39:09

Speaker 59

I'm extremely grateful to my honourable friend the Member for South Ribble and to hear his enthusiasm for that settlement for Lancashire. He's absolutely right that it is the way to deliver power and resources for his community and to unlock its potential. I'm sure the Speaker agrees. Number 10 North are going to be extremely busy with the number of requests that are pouring in, but I will make sure he is top of the queue.

01:39:09 - 01:40:02

James Oliver Dowden

Sir Oliver Dowden.

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I congratulate the First Secretary of State and welcome her to a very important role in government? And indeed, I agree with a number of things that she's said, particularly about strengthening the role of Number 10.

But I do think there's a very large gap in this statement on rewiring the state, and that's to do with civil service reform. Now I know there are many excellent civil servants, but I'm afraid it remains a classic 80-20 model, where 20% of exceptionally good civil servants do about 80% of the work. And if we are really to rewire the state, we need to look at this and empower those 20%, not just to deliver more, but to find savings from the headcount amongst the 80%. And I would urge the Secretary of State, if she really wants to rewire the state, she should grasp this nettle while she looks at the entire picture.

01:40:02 - 01:40:43

Speaker 59

Grateful to the right honourable gentleman. There is a significant programme of civil service reform that is underway, led by the Cabinet Secretary. The programme has already begun reforming the civil service recruitment system to make sure it hires and promotes truly brilliant people, reviewing the talent strategy to develop and grow talent right across the civil service and the whole UK, launching capability reviews to assess departmental delivery and identifying areas for improvement, and building on successful transformation already underway through the Places for Growth programme. But I absolutely agree we need to go further.

01:40:43 - 01:41:26

Speaker 83

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Over recess, a number of disturbing cases became public of AI agents escaping control of their owners and undertaking unauthorised activity. That included 1,200 agents collaborating on an unsanctioned message board before 700 engaged in an attack on the company Hugging Face. Can she confirm that following the governmental rewiring she described, her department is responsible for dealing with risks from so-called AI misalignment, and will she introduce regulation in this area given the lack of frontier model controls and coordinate with international partners on this matter?

01:41:26 - 01:42:20

Speaker 59

Well, I'm very grateful for the work my right honourable friend has done on this very issue, and I know she's extremely expert in this. Mobilised action across government and industry, asking cabinet ministers to work directly with regulators and supply chains, writing to UK businesses with clear steps to strengthen their cyber defences is ongoing. NCSC have engaged over a thousand stakeholders in the wake of Mythos's release to galvanise action and share best practice. And over the summer, she's absolutely right that there was a routine cyber evaluation, AC identified an incident in which AI agents took sustained unsanctioned action directed at real people and organisations. It was detected within an hour, we have been completely transparent about the incident and we've immediately learned lessons from it.

01:42:20 - 01:43:28

Simon Hoare

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I also welcome the First Secretary of State to her place? It's great to see her back on the Treasury bench. I also welcome the creation of the Office of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. She's absolutely right, in a centralised system it was the most underpowered organisation imaginable and it needed some turbocharging.

I hope she will agree that rewiring has to be a process, not an event. We remember, and my committee will remember, the great fanfare that mission-led government was mentioned or talked about a couple of years ago, and it died a rather slow, lamentable death. So can she assure us that she does have the personal energy and commitment to see this through to the end, but also the support resources around her in order to achieve it? And can I echo the call from my honourable friend the shadow minister about the importance of looking at quangos and arms-length bodies, particularly within the devolution and decision-making space? Too many of them have got out of control.

And also outsourcing, because outsourcing takes away a lot of agency from local communities and individuals, and that needs to be looked at with some urgency.

01:43:28 - 01:44:08

Speaker 59

Mr. Speaker, I am loving all the common ground that we are finding with the benches opposite today. I completely agree that we need to look at outsourcing across government and the previous administration already took significant steps to reduce spend on consultancy and has begun the work on the largest wave of insourcing in a generation as promised in our manifesto. I have worked with the right honorable gentleman in the past. He has witnessed my energy up close. He can be reassured of my continued commitment to this agenda.

01:44:08 - 01:45:04

Speaker 87

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And may I begin by welcoming my right honorable friend to her place and wish her every success in her new role. Can I also thank her for this statement and this government's renewed focus on reindustrialization in the UK bringing opportunity and economic growth to every corner of the UK. But with everything pushing towards increased manufacturing and construction, PPE is more important than ever as a last line of defense between workers and the hazardous materials and incidents. And the state does have a role to play here.

It can lead by example and ensure that every worker gets the protection that they need to do their job in safety. So will she meet with me to discuss public sector procurement specifications and BS 30417 on inclusive PPE?

01:45:04 - 01:45:27

Speaker 59

Well, can I congratulate my honorable friend on her sustained campaign on this area. I know she has done an extraordinary amount of work and continues to raise issues around PPE when they have fallen out of the public spotlight post-COVID. My honorable friend the Minister for Procurement would be delighted to meet with her to discuss this issue.

01:45:27 - 01:45:56

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And the number 10 of the North actually moves it two hours further away from constituents of Torbay and Devon and Cornwall. And whilst we as Liberal Democrats genuinely welcome devolution that brings power closer to people, I represent a constituency that has high levels of deprivation. Can the Secretary of State advise of how their reforms will particularly support areas such as mine?

01:45:56 - 01:46:45

Speaker 59

Well, he's absolutely right and the reforms that have been proposed through the devolution blueprint and the cabinet statement are designed to address exactly this issue. For too long devolution has been too tier in this country allowing certain areas of the country to steam ahead whilst others have not been given the powers and resources that they deserve. Devon and Cornwall will be incentivized with potential powers and resources including the overnight visitors levy and you will have heard the Prime Minister, Mr. Speaker, mention his trip to Cornwall and engagement with the authorities there including Devon. I appreciate it is a long visit to Manchester. It's quite an irritating visit from Sheffield to be honest, Mr. Speaker.

But I hope he will engage with number 10 North on this important issue so we can deliver for his constituents.

01:46:45 - 01:48:02

Toby Perkins

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Start by congratulating my right honorable friend on securing this role and I'm no doubt she'll do a wonderful job in it. I was particularly interested in what she said in the statement about her department strengthening the national resilience and that remaining central. We've just had the hottest summer on record. We are in now a climate, this country was built for a climate that no longer exists as we were told at the Environmental Audit Committee.

And two and a half thousand people are estimated to have died this summer as a result, diabetics, asthmatics, the very old and very young particularly at threat. So can my honorable friend tell us whether she has any plans to bring forward the new national adaptation plan? National adaptation plan three under the previous government was widely derided but there is not currently a plan for a new one until 2028. And it is clear that the pressures we are facing in these summers is worse than ever before.

Can she tell us either whether there'll be a new national adaptation plan or if not what she's going to do to ensure that we're better prepared next summer than we were this?

01:48:02 - 01:48:39

Speaker 59

Well, I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for his continued work in this important area and around the environment. Tackling the threats posed by climate change requires consistent and coordinated action across every department, from 710 million to fund upgrades to our school estate to the construction of nine new reservoirs across the country. This government is taking the necessary steps to ensure our country is more resilient and our communities are kept safe. He will have heard the Prime Minister reference an upcoming wildfire summit. I hope he will participate fully in that, and I will return to him on our commitment on the national adaptation plan.

01:48:39 - 01:49:23

Julian Lewis

Normally when functions and roles are devolved from London to another area, you see a diminution in the capital and an increase in the area concerned. There is an obvious danger of duplication by having a Number 10 North and a Number 10 South. So will the First Secretary, whom I congratulate on her appointment, be transparent about this and agree that the public should be able to see how many people are working permanently in Number 10 North, how many working permanently in Number 10 South, and how many are going back and forth between the two?

01:49:23 - 01:50:08

Speaker 59

Well, he's absolutely right that traditionally the model of moving people or roles out of London has meant duplication in the centre, and that's exactly what we're attempting to fix. We want new senior roles across the country, just as, and I pay tribute to the former Prime Minister, the right honourable member for Richmond, who created the Darlington campus, a proper model of delivery and senior policymaking and senior civil servants that sits in Darlington based around the Treasury there. That has helped to deliver and change decision-making, and that is exactly what Number 10 North is attempting to do as well.

01:50:08 - 01:50:33

Speaker 85

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I really welcome the steps by the First Secretary to ensure that strategic authorities like Cornwall have the capacity to deliver on our growth agenda. But I want to ask specifically what steps she is taking to ensure that both local and national government has the financial analytical capability to identify those most promising investment cases and help shepherd them towards success.

01:50:33 - 01:51:01

Speaker 59

It's an excellent question, Mr Speaker, and something that my honourable friend, the minister who we share with the Treasury, has been working on through Number 10 North. We are planning a brand of civil service reform that will move civil servants from the centre to regional and local government in order to share expertise and provide them with the AI and data expertise that we currently have at the centre in order to do exactly that.

01:51:01 - 01:51:52

Speaker 88

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I remind the minister that during this summer my own constituency experienced the extensive Cairngorms wildfire, also a major incident in difficult terrain that destroyed around 20 square miles of iconic hillside and forestry, threatened homes and businesses and required the efforts of over 500 firefighters and volunteers.

There are actions required of UK government, devolved governments and numerous public agencies and landowners and I'm pressing all of them on these issues. With a growing risk, my ask is that the First Secretary is that the lack of military aerial firefighting capability within the UK is urgently reviewed so that aerial assistance can be provided in these extreme and often prolonged incidents and what work is being done with our European neighbors in respect to mutual aid in tackling wildfires. We must recognize that exceptional local effort cannot substitute for national and international preparedness.

01:51:52 - 01:52:26

Speaker 59

I'm very grateful to the honorable gentleman for his question and my thoughts and sympathies are with all those affected in his constituency by the wildfire. 100 million has already been invested in fire and rescue services and we will continue to look at the issues that he raises with equipment in future budgets. We are engaging with our European neighbors on exactly the deal and the issue he raises and we're well aware of the opportunities that arise from it.

01:52:26 - 01:53:06

Amanda Martin

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to welcome the First Secretary of State to her place and to thank her for making her first constituency visit to Portsmouth North and the fantastic Griffin Marine. Mr. Speaker, as a coastal city, residents in Portsmouth are rightly furious at Southern Water continues to pump sewage into our seas. We have had hardly any rain this summer, yet sewage pollution and rising bills continue while private companies make profits. It is abundantly clear that under the Tories privatization has failed again and again the British public.

So could the First Secretary of State set out a little more detail of the government's plans to reforming the industry and giving the public greater control over our water companies.

01:53:06 - 01:53:45

Speaker 59

I'm very grateful to my honorable friend and it was indeed a great pleasure to visit her and announce our procurement reforms at Griffin Marine in her constituency. The Prime Minister has been repeatedly clear that more public control of our water industry is not just desired, it's absolutely necessary that the current system that involves poor infrastructure investment, higher water bills and the kind of sewage and leakage and poor quality that she has described cannot continue any longer and we will set out our plans for reform shortly.

01:53:45 - 01:54:12

Speaker 92

Welcome the right honorable lady to her post and I'm sure she'll be very effective at this job. On the issue of wildfires, could I urge her to talk to DEFRA who are putting further constraints on moorland owners. Moorland owners have traditionally undertaken controlled burning and they're really worried at the moment that this change in DEFRA policy will make moorland in areas such as the one I represent more vulnerable to wildfires in the future.

01:54:12 - 01:54:25

Speaker 59

Well, I'm extremely grateful to the right honorable gentleman for his characteristically constructive and thoughtful contribution. I will of course raise that with DEFRA and look into that specific issue on his behalf.

01:54:25 - 01:55:16

Speaker 93

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and it's a pleasure to welcome my right honorable friend to her place. Mr. Speaker, the greatest shift of power in rewiring this country we have seen started in Rochdale in 1844 when the Rochdale Pioneers came together and created and inspired a worldwide movement. We now have our first ever Labour and Co-operative Prime Minister and a historic commitment to double the size of the co-operative and mutual economy, highlighting the vital role of double devolution, not just to institutions, but powers directly handed to people to form and take part in creating their own solutions and their own power in their communities. Can I ask my right honorable friend what assessment she has made of the machinery of government and its ability to deliver on this fantastic ambition.

01:55:16 - 01:55:48

Speaker 59

My honorable friend has put it incredibly poetically, better than I ever could. He's absolutely right, the machinery of government and the culture across Whitehall needs to be challenged and the Prime Minister has been clear that this government will bring about an end to local government and regional government coming to Whitehall with a begging bowl. Whitehall and government as a whole has been told in no uncertain terms, they will now be required to justify why policies are not devolved rather than the other way around.

01:55:48 - 01:56:47

Alexander Carmichael

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The transition to clean energy could be an opportunity to build a different model that would, to use the First Secretary's own words, end the overly centralized decision-making and over-privatization. The development thus far has simply concentrated power in the hands of the big corporates and left communities feeling left behind and disempowered. In Shetland, we host one of the largest onshore wind farms in the country, but we have the highest levels of fuel poverty. And last year, the developer SSE was paid nine million pounds in constraint payments not to generate electricity.

That is regulatory madness. So in this rewired state, will the communities that host renewable energy developments control and get direct financial benefit from them?

01:56:47 - 01:57:14

Speaker 59

Well, the right honorable gentleman raises a number of really important and interesting issues that will absolutely be considered as we look to greater public control of our energy system. Local and community control is absolutely central to the Prime Minister's vision for public control. And the madness, as he describes it, is something that will absolutely drive our energy reforms.

01:57:14 - 01:57:52

Edward Joseph Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I also welcome the First Secretary to her place and welcome today's statement and the one in July. The first English devolution settlement was, of course, London. And despite some incremental improvements since 1999, our capital's mayor, the GLA, and the 32 London boroughs are not currently set up to deliver on the full potential of our capital, whether that's on productivity and growth or dealing with our housing crisis and the massive increase in temporary accommodation spending to combat homelessness. So I wonder if she can outline whether revisiting London's devolution settlement would also be on the agenda for her and her team.

01:57:52 - 01:58:06

Speaker 59

The Mayor of London has absolutely been involved in continued talks through Number 10 North on their devolution settlement. And we will continue to consider what further powers and resources London deserves.

01:58:06 - 01:58:57

David Mundell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I congratulate the First Secretary on her appointment. Can she confirm to me and to the House that the intergovernmental relations responsibilities in her department will be given the weight that they require? And indeed, that part of that is making the case for the continuance of the United Kingdom. We have three First Ministers across the United Kingdom whose position is to break up the United Kingdom.

The Scottish Government have already brought forward a time-wasting and unnecessary bill to hold another divisive independence referendum. And it is vital that this government plays its part in pushing back against independence in Scotland and elsewhere and making the case for the United Kingdom.

01:58:57 - 01:59:24

Speaker 59

Well, I absolutely agree with the right honorable gentleman. And the Prime Minister has been repeatedly clear that we stand against Scottish independence, we stand against an independence referendum. And we will continue to make the case for the Union. And that responsibility will be held very highly and very importantly and very closely by my right honorable friend, the Minister for Intergovernmental Relations.

01:59:24 - 02:00:04

Speaker 34

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I also welcome the First Secretary to her place, particularly as she smashed another glass ceiling being the first woman to do this role. And I know in her statement that she talked about wildfires. There wasn't one in Monmouthshire per se, but all around the edge of Monmouthshire and there was a lot of smoke in households in Abergavenny. So I really look forward to the summit that you're going to be holding on wildfires.

But one of the things you didn't mention that I'd really like to draw your attention to is civil service pensions. And I've got a huge number of constituents waiting and I know that is under your department, so I'd really like your support on this.

02:00:04 - 02:00:41

Speaker 59

Very grateful, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I be absolutely clear that the service levels following the move to Capita on the Civil Service Pension Scheme have been completely unacceptable. Our immediate priority is to stabilise the service and give current and former civil servants the service they deserve. We're using all commercial levers, including withholding payments, to hold Capita to account for their failure and will continue to do so until service levels are fully restored. My honourable friend the member for Doncaster North will be updating the House shortly on further progress.

02:00:41 - 02:01:23

Adrian Philip Ramsay

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This summer we have seen extreme heat and prolonged drought, with far too many people losing their lives in heatwaves, huge pressures on farming and many wildfires. We are unlikely to have another cooler summer than this year and we need to be prepared for an ever-warming world. And this requires a cross-government approach. So while there's been lots of talk of a Number 10 for the North and devolution is welcome, does the Secretary of State recognise that we could have a Number 10 for the future in the form of a climate protection unit in the Cabinet Office, which is needed to drive the cross-government approach that we have to have to keep people safe?

02:01:23 - 02:01:49

Speaker 59

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable member and he's absolutely right. We have to learn to live with this new normal that we have experienced over the summer. COBR is absolutely the right team within the department to coordinate activity across government. And we work, we have worked closely with the Environment Agency, DEFRA, the Met Office and others in response to the extreme heat that we've seen and preparing for future summers.

02:01:49 - 02:02:36

Jonathan Peter Tom Davies

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I very much welcomed what the First Secretary of State had to say about using Number 10 North to drive a pro-business culture, empower communities and deliver growth in every postcode. And we have one of the best projects in Mid Derbyshire to help her and the government meet that aspiration. It is the regeneration of the Belper Mills. It will bring 130 new homes to the Derwent Valley and also a visitor centre where we have a UNESCO World Heritage site.

We are so close to securing an investment from the East Midlands Combined County Authority to make this happen. So can she help me by offering a meeting at Number 10 North with its staff to make sure that we get that investment over the line, build the homes we need and deliver growth in Mid Derbyshire?

02:02:36 - 02:02:45

Speaker 96

I'm very grateful to the honourable gentleman and he's absolutely right to champion this important development. I'd be delighted to facilitate a meeting for him in Number 10 North.

02:02:45 - 02:03:24

Andrew Murrison

Madam Deputy Speaker, will the First Minister's, First Secretary's exercise in delivering democracy, local accountability and empowering local people include a look at large organisations that can't be described as governmental or quangos, but nevertheless exist firmly within the public domain, serving the public and on which the public have a direct interest and are established by statute and are large and big employers, such as the National Trust, which is ripe for review as it is meant to be reviewed periodically and would certainly fall, in my view, within the scope of the work she's been talking about today?

02:03:24 - 02:03:48

Speaker 59

Well, I'll take that away, Madam Deputy Speaker. But we've already made significant progress on our review, closing or merging arm's-length bodies, including NHS England and ACAS. We know we need to go further and we'll close or merge those that are justified as part of our plans to rewire Whitehall. But I will write to the honourable gentleman on the particular issue he raises.

02:03:48 - 02:04:31

Peter Swallow

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As this government works at pace to move power out of Westminster and into our communities, I'm keen for Bracknell to get a share of that, and that's why I support devolution for the Thames Valley. She will know that leaders across Oxfordshire, Berkshire and Swindon have written to her setting out their ambition for a mayoral strategic authority. That's excellent progress, but we've been here before and I don't want to see us lose the momentum. So will she set up a meeting with herself and her Number 10 North team with leaders and MPs across the region so we can sign on the dotted line, get this agreed and finally get the devolution that Thames Valley so badly needs?

02:04:31 - 02:04:50

Speaker 59

Well, fantastic to hear my honourable friend's enthusiasm. That's exactly why we have set ourselves such a tight deadline in order to ensure that we fill in the map of the whole of England and that we do not lose the momentum of this moment. I'd be delighted to meet with him and his colleagues from Thames Valley to sign on the dotted line.

02:04:50 - 02:05:46

Manuela Perteghella

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I also warmly welcome the First Secretary of State to her place. Last month, my constituency experienced wildfires, including a major incident in the parish of Salford Priors, where Warwickshire Fire and Rescue Service worked through extremely challenging conditions to protect homes and save lives, and I pay tribute to all the firefighters, ambulance crew and local community who assisted. As we heard, given the increasing frequency of heatwaves, drought and severity of wildfires, particularly in rural areas where access to water is challenging and also access to burning fields is difficult, can the First Secretary of State tell the House what urgent actions are being taken to better protect rural communities, farmland and natural habitats from future wildfire risk?

02:05:46 - 02:06:15

Speaker 59

Well, I'm very grateful to the honourable lady and again send my thoughts and sympathies to those affected by the wildfire in her constituency. The Prime Minister has set out funding over the summer specifically for farmers in relation to resilience. We have awarded 100 million to the fire service and we'll be coordinating a wildfire summit, more details of which will be announced in the near future on where we need to go further.

02:06:15 - 02:07:21

Charles David Robertson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome my honourable friend to her place and thank her for her comments earlier about the wildfires this summer. Staffordshire Fire and Rescue Service saw more than 600 outdoor fires in July alone. That doesn't include any of the ones that came in August. And I think it's really important that in this place we recognise the bravery of those firefighters who were out day in, day out.

Every single human instinct will look at a wall of flame that they were faced with and tell you to run the other way, but those men and women went out there day after day after day and ran towards danger and kept our communities safe. So I'd like to thank them. But can I ask the First Secretary of State to ensure that the voice of firefighters are at the heart of preparing for the changing climate, that they get what they need to protect our communities, and particularly those retained firefighters? I'm aware of retained firefighters in Staffs who did an eight or ten hour shift fighting wildfires, went home, got in the shower and went to their day job. They are absolute heroes and they deserve all of our respect, and if we can make sure their voices are at the heart of the response, it would be a very, very, very good thing.

Thank you.

02:07:21 - 02:07:53

Speaker 59

Well, I'm extremely grateful to my honourable friend for his words and praise. My grandfather was a firefighter in Chesterfield, so I absolutely join him in sending our thanks and gratitude to the heroes that kept us safe over the summer. He's right to draw attention to the fact that there were so many fires that didn't even make the news that they were quietly fighting on our behalf, and we will absolutely ensure that their voice is central to the work we do as we prepare for future summers.

02:07:52 - 02:08:35

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Just following on from that point about firefighters, one of the wildfires and one of the major incidents that she referred to in her statement was in Cambridgeshire at Home Fen Nature Reserve, which had up to 20 fire engines responding to it and up to 150 firefighters from as far afield as Merseyside, Durham, and Devon and Somerset. My thanks to all of those firefighters who assisted Cambridgeshire Fire and Rescue in tackling that dangerous peat fire. But on that point, could she just explain how the 100 million that she referred to will be allocated? Is it a one-off payment or is it an uplift to the current funding formula, which does need to be updated for fire and rescue?

But also, could she just give a little bit more detail on the asset refresh program and whether those assets that firefighters crucially need will be allocated very quickly?

02:08:35 - 02:08:50

Speaker 59

I'm equally grateful to the honorable gentleman's support for the fire service. 100 million has already been allocated, so will have been done under the existing funding formula, and future funding allocations will be determined at the budget.

02:08:50 - 02:09:31

Chris Curtis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I just want to ask about devolution and transport, because since we introduced transport work act orders in the 1990s here, we have dramatically decreased the number of new tram lines that we've been building in the UK, which we know is a big driver of local growth. France has a mass rapid transit system for every town and city with a population of over 150,000 people. Leeds is the biggest place in Western Europe without any mass rapid transit system at all. So can she please tell us what powers she's going to be pushing downwards to combined authorities to allow them to build new tram lines and how she's going to make that a success?

Thank you.

02:09:31 - 02:10:18

Speaker 59

Well, I'm very grateful to my honorable friend. He makes an incredibly important point, and I've seen for myself in places as small as Dijon in France, who have incredibly well-functioning integrated transport systems, including tram networks. And that is in large part because they are able to raise and keep revenue themselves and continue to invest it in their transport networks. We are removing the veto on decision-making for transport infrastructure and devolving a number of transport and works act powers that will speed up the delivery of mass transit networks. But he will have heard the Prime Minister's commitments to both Leeds and Bristol and his commitment to work with their mayoral authorities in order to deliver this at pace.

02:10:18 - 02:10:49

Richard Tice

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I can congratulate the First Secretary on her appointment. I'm sure these reforms planned to rewire the state are well-intentioned, but it seems that we're going from Number 10 plus the Cabinet Office to Number 10, Number 10 North, the Office for Prime Minister and Cabinet, the Cabinet Office, and a new OneGov delivery agency. So we're going from two to five. So does she understand our concerns that actually she is increasing the size of the state, increasing the cost, and slowing down decision-making?

02:10:49 - 02:10:56

Speaker 59

No, we'll be reducing the size of the central civil service, shifting power and resources into Whitehall, and speeding up decision-making.

02:10:56 - 02:11:29

Andrew Graham Cooper

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I congratulate the First Secretary of State on her appointment and welcome the creation of Number 10 North as part of the government's commitment to drive good growth in every postcode? And in that vein, I wonder if she's aware of the series of funding decisions that have been taken by the Science and Technology Facilities Council that, taken together, will shift publicly funded R&D activity from north to south. Now, the Prime Minister has already committed to intervene over Jodrell Bank, but I wonder if she'll look at the broader issue and consider how the balance of R&D spend across the country can support economic growth in every region.

02:11:29 - 02:11:46

Speaker 59

He raises an incredibly important point and is exactly to the issue that I raised earlier about making sure that non-elected bodies are not given free range to make decisions that are not accountable to politicians.

I'll of course take this issue away.

02:11:46 - 02:12:06

Speaker 100

Madam Deputy Speaker, when the British public voted to take back control, they did not vote for the Westminster to then later duplicate the cost of politics and the civil service. Can the Secretary of State confirm today whether civil servants now working outside London will still receive the London weighted salary and will ministers now working outside London still be able to claim for London-based housing?

02:12:06 - 02:12:17

Speaker 59

The staffing up of Number 10 North has been done on an interim basis in order to get it set up and running. We will be recruiting permanently and of course those roles will be based in Manchester.

02:12:17 - 02:13:01

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and bearing in mind your family connection to fire services in Harlow, I want to pay tribute to fire officers across Harlow. I also want to welcome the First Secretary to her place. I know she's a friend of Harlow and I want to thank the government for their investment in our town, not just the UK Health Security Agency, but also funding for rough sleeping and the 48 businesses that are going to benefit from the DIP. However, what I do want to ask about when we talk about rewiring the state is about how the state works with the charity and voluntary sector. I think previous governments have seen the charity and voluntary sector as a cheaper option.

However, actually those voluntary and community services actually have expertise that we can really utilize, but we do need to think about how they're funded properly and supported in the long term.

02:13:01 - 02:13:27

Speaker 59

Well, my honorable friend is absolutely right and I think we can see far better working with the charity and voluntary sector at the local and regional level if we are ensuring that they are properly funded and empowered to make decisions, procure and work in partnership because they know that they are closest to the ground and that double devolution will ensure that the CVS sector is properly utilized and funded as well.

02:13:27 - 02:13:53

Adam Dance

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the First Secretary to her place. One area the state also needs rewiring is in how it supports neurodiverse people because lots of decision makers do not get it. Will the First Secretary appoint a minister for neurodiversity to the Cabinet Office to help make sure decision makers across the country do get it and help them solve any challenges that may face them related to neurodiversion?

02:13:53 - 02:14:12

Speaker 59

Well, it's an extremely interesting and important point and I absolutely appreciate the importance of the issue he raises. I will take away the wider point and establish what work needs to be done to ensure that properly dealing with neurodiversity is embedded across the whole of government.

02:14:12 - 02:14:53

John Slinger

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the First Secretary of State to her place and support her determination to rewire the state. In her statement, she spoke about an underpowered center of government and how ministers often lack agency. In my view, members of this House, MPs, also often lack agency and are underpowered. And in light of the welcome devolution of greater powers to unitary authorities and metro mayors, would she agree with me that it's important that we discuss and debate in this place and elsewhere the role of MPs, something that I have applied for debates about as we look to rewire the state, we need to enhance the status and the powers and the authority of members of this place.

02:14:53 - 02:15:04

Speaker 59

He makes a very important point. I would encourage him to raise it with the Leader of the House to ensure that we have proper time in the chamber to debate that issue.

02:15:04 - 02:15:36

Ann Celia Davies

Diolch yn fawr, Madam Dirprwy Lefarydd. It is great to see the powers being devolved to England to drive economic growth. Yet the most minimal powers are not being considered for Wales. The promise made by the UK government in February to jointly consult with the Welsh government on the devolution of the vacant land tax has stalled. So can the First Secretary of State say what conversation she has had with the Treasury of this matter and tell us when the consultation will be published?

02:15:36 - 02:15:54

Speaker 59

The honourable lady knows, as the Prime Minister said yesterday, that we'll be hosting a National Economic Council with the First Ministers of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland in order to discuss devolution at length, and decisions around devolution as she's expressed will be made from there.

02:15:54 - 02:16:33

Vikki Slade

Vicky Slade. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to align myself with the comments about firefighters and suggest she might need a bigger room for the summit as there's so much interest. But I want to seek some clarification on business rates. The right honourable lady mentioned that devolution may lead to business rate retention, but it's the structure of business rates that's causing the decline of our high streets and the decimation of our hospitality sector.

Simply giving local authorities like BCP and Dorset the right to cut them will simply move the problem from the business to the statutory services of councils. So I wonder if she could clarify and expand a little bit on her intentions.

02:16:33 - 02:17:08

Speaker 59

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable lady for allowing me to be clear about this issue. The Prime Minister made clear his intention around business rates very early on in his premiership in cutting business rates for pubs and hospitality and businesses that really benefit our high streets. Where we are proposing devolution is for business rates retention, encouraging areas to grow their economy and then enjoying a share of that. They won't have any difference in altering the level of business rates, but they will be incentivised and be able to keep a share of them.

02:17:08 - 02:17:44

Ayoub Khan

Ayoub Khan. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I congratulate the First Secretary to her post and appreciate the work the government is doing around extreme weathers? In my constituency of Birmingham Perry Barr, last week more than 60 families were left devastated with rainfall and flooding. I appreciate the 65 million pound that's being offered to farmers, the 100 million for emergency service, but would the First Secretary meet with me to see what package of offer which would support those 60 families and also Birmingham City Council to prevent a repeat of what's took place last week?

02:17:44 - 02:18:08

Speaker 59

Well, I'm incredibly sorry to hear of the impact on the 60 families in his constituency and their displacement. We will continue to make, off the back of the summer and the preparations we're making for wildfires, we are now preparing for flooding, and we are making extensive preparations for a wide range of scenarios ahead of winter. I will ensure the relevant minister meets with him to consider what response we can have to his community.

02:18:08 - 02:18:41

Jess Brown-Fuller

Jess Brown-Fuller. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On the subject of wildfires, the Prime Minister said he doesn't believe our fire service have the right equipment, and I couldn't agree with him more. West Sussex Fire and Rescue Service currently don't have access to wildfire PPE, and their newest off-road vehicle is 26 years old. So will the First Secretary or the relevant minister please meet with me and the Chief Fire Officer of West Sussex Fire and Rescue so we can talk about how we can make sure that we keep them on a sustainable financial footing so they can keep us safe but we can also keep them safe?

02:18:41 - 02:18:53

Speaker 59

Well, she's absolutely right and raises incredibly important points, and I can assure her that these issues will be subject and considered by the wildfire summit, which I agree will need a bigger room at this rate.

02:18:53 - 02:19:27

Brendan O'Hara

Brendan O'Hara. Madam Deputy Speaker, a 15-minute statement on rewiring the state, yet Scotland doesn't merit a single mention, not even the Cairngorm wildfire. It's becoming increasingly clear that this Prime Minister is almost exclusively focused on pursuing an English domestic agenda. And having lost five parliamentary elections in a row and having slumped to 17% of the vote last May, I can understand why the Labour Party has given up on Scotland. But does she think it is wise to make it so obvious?

02:19:27 - 02:19:57

Speaker 59

Apologies, Madam Deputy Speaker, I chose to address issues that I was directly responsible for.

He'll be aware that fire and rescue services are well and truly devolved in Scotland. And as we've repeatedly said, we'll be hosting a meeting of the National Economic Council with the First Minister, who the Prime Minister has already met with and is committed to devolving power outside of Holyrood, which is an equally centralized government to the one that we are transferring power out of now.

02:19:57 - 02:20:35

Thomas Gordon

Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the First Secretary of State to her place. Two weeks ago, I held a hospitality business round table and they'll be pleased to hear that she mentions a pro-business culture and cutting barriers that businesses face. One of the issues that came up at that event at North Bar with lots of hospitality businesses such as Fat Badger, Westmorland Coffee and various other lovely hospitality businesses in Harrogate and Knaresborough. One of the things that they brought up was the high VAT rates that our businesses face, some of the highest in Europe. So will she make it her mission and this government's mission to look at how we can cut VAT to support local businesses and get our high streets and local areas thriving?

02:20:35 - 02:21:01

Speaker 59

We're incredibly conscious of the burdens that small businesses, particularly the ones like Fat Badger that he mentions in Harrogate, are under. And that's why the Prime Minister set as his priority reducing burdens and cutting taxes for businesses, hospitality businesses in particular, in the first days of his premiership. High street regeneration and breathing life into our villages, towns and cities is absolutely a priority of this regime.

02:21:01 - 02:22:05

Caroline Jane Voaden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The First Secretary talks about a broken political model that will cost jobs and opportunities. And I'm afraid the decision that the predecessor government has made on local government reorganization in Devon is exactly that and is going to create a two-tier Devon, leaving one area behind. It's carved out three urban growth areas and then left all the bits that are left behind, dumped them together in a vast rural local authority, which is a hundred miles from north to south, a road network equivalent to that of Luxembourg's, communities divided and little chance of ever being sustainable. This rural local authority has no chance of the same growth opportunities that the other ones have.

And it goes against everything the Prime Minister believes in about devolution from the ground up, with the consent of communities, not done from the top down from Whitehall. He told me that himself in July. So I urge the First Secretary and the Minister for Communities to listen to me, to other Devon MPs, perhaps not the Labour ones, and the thousands of my constituents and review this decision.

02:22:05 - 02:22:18

Speaker 59

Well, I will ensure her concerns are heard by MHCLG and I can confirm that the Communities Secretary will determine next steps on local government reform by the end of October 2026.

02:22:18 - 02:22:57

Daniel Danny Rayner Kruger

Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to be constructive because I welcome the creation of a stronger center and a proper political center in Number 10 and also a corporate HQ for the non-political functions. My question to her is, what is the residual point of the Cabinet Office in this new structure? There's 12,000 people currently employed under the Cabinet Office in all its quangos. Some of them I know will be redistributed. But what is the point of that office in future?

Likewise, what's the point of the Cabinet Secretary's post as well? How is anything going to change when the same people are working in the same buildings under the same incentives?

02:22:57 - 02:23:16

Speaker 59

Well, the Cabinet Office supports the wider civil service and still fulfills a number of incredibly important functions, including cross-coordination of governmental priorities. The Cabinet Secretary's role is to run the civil service as a whole and her role will always be required.

02:23:16 - 02:24:09

Layla Moran

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I warmly welcome the First Secretary to her post and also her good judgment of taking one of our esteemed former members of our committee to be her PPS, the member for West Worthing.

So I know already she's probably had some of this in her ear already, but I can't lose this opportunity. This morning, the Health and Social Care Select Committee with the Education Select Committee heard moving evidence about why death by suicide has now overtaken almost anything else as being the number one reason we lose children in this country. And when we dive so often into issues like this as to why, it's because education isn't talking to health, isn't talking to local authorities. It cannot be beyond the wit of man, or indeed a shared governance structure with the right fiscal flows, to stop these stories from happening. Will she meet with me to discuss what we are seeing in the committee and unlock the potential in all parts of society?

Because without doing that, the devolution agenda, I fear, may fail.

02:24:09 - 02:24:44

Speaker 59

Well, I'm incredibly grateful to my honourable friend, who I've worked with over many years on a number of campaigns, and as ever, she raises an incredibly important point. I can't imagine there are many people in this House who've not been touched by suicide in one way or another. I certainly have in my close family, and so it is an incredibly important point that she raises and one that should and could be easily fixed in terms of the specific problems that can lead to state failings. Of course, I'd be delighted to meet with her to discuss how we can address it.

02:24:44 - 02:25:13

Speaker 128

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The First Secretary has said that the purpose of rewiring the state is to get power and resource to communities and deliver for people in every postcode. In Blackburn, patients are being treated in corridors because our hospital simply does not have the capacity it needs. So I ask, how will these reforms ensure that communities like mine, where the need is the greatest, actually receive the investment we need?

02:25:13 - 02:25:34

Speaker 59

Well, health is absolutely part of the devolution agenda. We're already pursuing a number of reforms, including the abolition of NHS England, to make sure that decisions can be made democratically at the centre of government and then pushed to locally and ensuring that they are resourced where possible. I will take away the specific issue he's raised and raise it with the Health Secretary.

02:25:34 - 02:26:17

Max Wilkinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The First Secretary mentioned the heroics of firefighters in fighting those wildfires during the summer. Gloucestershire Fire and Rescue Service was involved in fighting those wildfires, even though we didn't have any within our county boundaries. But the funding pressures on the fire service in Gloucestershire are now so acute that Cheltenham West Fire Station is going to be closed overnight if the consultation proposals are accepted. That can't be right in the current circumstances where we know we're going to be having more wildfires, perhaps even in Gloucestershire in the future.

So will the First Secretary have a chat with her colleagues in MHCLG to work out how we can get the support that the county fire service and the county council needs to keep Cheltenham West Fire Station open overnight?

02:26:17 - 02:26:31

Speaker 59

We are incredibly conscious of the historic underfunding of fire services across the country. That's why the previous administration committed a hundred million additional to local fire and rescue services. Future funding decisions will be for the budget.

02:26:31 - 02:27:02

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Madam Deputy Speaker, my summer tour took me to such wonderful villages as Forest Hill, Little Milton, Stanton St John, and Warborough. No one I met wants to be part of the new proposed Greater Oxford Authority. These are parishes that have been press-ganged into a new authority they don't want to be part of. Will the government review the decision to split Oxfordshire into three into a messy solution and support other solutions such as the two and one local authority proposals?

02:27:02 - 02:27:19

Speaker 59

Well, the Prime Minister has been clear we don't want to impose anything centrally on areas that don't want to combine areas. So I'm sure we can facilitate a meeting or discussion in Number 10 North to make sure that we get the right authority, the right powers, and the right resources for his area.

02:27:19 - 02:28:11

Jim Shannon

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I welcome the First Secretary to her new role and wish her well? The honourable lady's appointment comes at a very critical time for the United Kingdom.

However, the First Secretary will know that the fundamental pillar of our Union is fairness, and right now the funding model for Northern Ireland is anything but fair. The current Barnett consequential framework is fundamentally broken. It fails to account for the unique, severe and acute objective needs of our public services, of the health sector and infrastructure in Northern Ireland. As the Minister for the Cabinet Office and coordinator of government policy, will the honorable lady agree that rewiring the funding formula must be treated as a priority for cross-cabinet issue, and will the honorable lady commit to working across the Treasury and the Northern Ireland Office to replace the outdated mechanism with a much-needed based funding flow? Thank you.

02:28:11 - 02:28:46

Speaker 59

Well, as the Prime Minister said in Prime Minister's Questions earlier, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland has opened a negotiation process with Stormont to look at the funding and the funding pressures that have emerged. Fundamental to that negotiation will be reform of the decisions that Stormont make and the way that the Executive have made decisions historically that have repeatedly left led to funding pressures. And we need to make sure that true reform is a result of these negotiations so we don't end back in this position again.

02:28:46 - 02:29:21

Speaker 125

Can I thank the First Secretary for her statement this afternoon? I'll allow a couple of moments for the front bench to swap over. Presentation of Bill. Bradley Thomas. Second reading what day?

02:29:21 - 02:29:24

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Friday 26th of February.

02:29:24 - 02:29:34

Speaker 124

Friday the 26th of February 2027. Programme motion, Minister to move.

02:29:34 - 02:29:36

Speaker 119

I beg to move.

02:29:36 - 02:29:53

Speaker 122

The question is the Representation of the People Bill Programme (No. 2) motion as on the order paper. The question is the Representation of the People Bill Programme (No. 2) motion as on the order paper, as many as are of that opinion say Aye.

02:29:54 - 02:30:01

Speaker 121

Of the contrary No. I think the Ayes have it. The Ayes have it. The Clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.

02:30:01 - 02:30:11

Speaker 120

Representation of the People Bill, as amended in the Public Bill Committee, to be considered.

02:30:11 - 02:33:44

Florence Eshalomi

We will begin with new clause 72, with which it will be convenient to consider other new clauses, amendments and new schedules as listed on the selection paper. I call the Minister to move new clause 72, Minister Asholomi.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Representation of People's Bill is central to our plan for fixing politics. Every one of us in this House has a responsibility to show the value of participating in our elections. But the reality is too many people have lost faith in politics, and we must address the reasons. At the heart of this must come measures to reassure the public that the elections they are voting in are fair and free from foreign interference, and we must stand against the unprecedented tide of abuse that those who put themselves forward to represent their communities face.

This Bill will secure our elections against those who threaten them, protect those who participate, ensure our democracy remains open and accessible to legitimate voters, and strengthening and preserving and modernizing our elections for the next generation.

It delivers our 2025 strategy for modern and secure elections. It takes forward the recommendations from the Rycroft review and it meets our manifesto commitment. Together it sets the foundations for elections which are fairer and a democracy which is stronger. Before I speak to government amendments tabled in the name of my right honourable friend the Secretary of State, I would like to thank those who've participated in the passage of this bill. In particular, I'd like to pay tribute to my predecessor, the honourable member for Chester North and Neston, for her tireless work in getting the bill to this stage.

The issue of crypto assets has come up in our debates. Crypto assets transactions create a new and clear route for untraceable money to enter into our politics. Therefore, these government amendments propose a ban on political donations made in crypto assets in line with the recommendations in the Rycroft review. The ban applies to donations of all values. The specific risk associated with foreign interference and crypto donations is not the same as the risk made by bank transfers.

The ban will apply retrospectively. Any donations made in crypto assets from the 25th of March 2026 must be returned within 30 days following commencement of these provisions. This is to prevent malign actors taking advantage of the advance notice of the ban. If recipients fail to comply, they risk enforcement action and potentially criminal liability. The government intends to end the ban once the Electoral Commission and Parliament are satisfied that a regulatory environment around crypto assets is robust enough to protect the integrity of our political finance from foreign interference.

Ending the ban will therefore require further legislation. We are also amending the definition of donations to include arrangements where a property is used to pay for the expenses of a recipient.

02:33:44 - 02:34:30

Dominic Liam Byrne

I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for giving way and my warmest congratulations to her on her appointment to the role she will be a brilliant minister. She will know that many in this house welcome the update to the legislation proposed by ministers to ban crypto assets, but she will also know that the measures that have been proposed by His Majesty's government do not go far enough. In particular, they still permit money to be routed through crypto exchanges turned into fiat and then donated on, and second, they still permit donations through things like meme coins. So will she look at the measures proposed in new clause 34 supported by 51 members of this house so that over the passage of this bill through this house and the other place, we can actually make sure this is as tight and as tough as possible?

02:34:30 - 02:35:05

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the right honourable member for making that important and valuable contribution and it is right that a number of amendments are seeking to limit the donations originating from crypto assets. We agree that the anonymity of crypto transactions creates a really worrying route for illicit actors to channel money into our politics and I think this is an area that the government is definitely keen to continue to review, ensuring that we end any unintended loopholes that may still arise.

02:35:05 - 02:35:36

Anne Emily Thornberry

She refers to the anonymity of source of crypto and does she not agree with me that it's difficult to know what the attraction of crypto is further than the fact that you can hide where the money comes from?

In those circumstances, why don't we just become straightforward and simply ban its use? Not a temporary ban or a moratorium, just ban it. We don't... why can't people just simply give old-fashioned cash to support political parties?

02:35:36 - 02:36:12

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the right honourable member, the chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, and I know that this is work that they've looked on their committee. And I think it's really important that we continue to look at making sure we will ban... the ban will apply retrospectively and making sure that any donations before the 25th of March 2026 will be returned. And as I mentioned earlier, we will continue to review the ban on cryptocurrency because this is an issue that has cross-party support. We need to ensure that it is clean, traceable money coming into our politics. I will give way lastly.

02:36:12 - 02:36:49

Paul Holmes

The minister for giving way, and I welcome her to her position. I know that many people, not only on that side but on this side of the House, will be delighted to see that she's been made the minister. Can I just challenge her or ask for her guidance a bit further on the moratorium point, which is that the government is intending the Electoral Commission to be... have strengthened powers to try and tackle the regulatory regime that will be created by the moratorium. But does the minister not share my concern that actually, if those responsibilities are not enshrined and given to the Electoral Commission in the correct way, then actually it will not be solved as we would want it to be?

02:36:49 - 02:39:46

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honourable member for that, and it's a shame that we won't get to spar on this now that he's left the shadow front bench. I think this is a real big issue and an area that the Electoral Commission need to be given the space to develop the right regulatory framework. And as I mentioned earlier, any new additions or changes will require primary legislation, which we will bring back. I'm mindful of time, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I will... I will make more progress. Next I turn to government amendments relating to overseas electors.

We will impose an annualised limit on the amount that overseas electors is able to donate or otherwise contribute to the UK finance system. This will apply to individuals who have been resident outside the UK at any time in the current or previous calendar year, whether or not they are registered as an overseas electors during that time. The Rycroft review noted two major concerns regarding donations from UK citizens resident overseas. First, investigating and tracing the origins of the funds used for such donations is more complex than for domestic donations. The review's second concern was democratic fairness.

We have to ask ourselves, why should a wealthy individual who has minimised their contribution to the UK Treasury be able to make unlimited donations into our political system? The review proposed an annual cap of between 100 and 300k on the amount that an overseas elector can contribute into UK political finance. The amendments' provision seek to cap this at the lowest recommended threshold of 100,000 per annum. I just want to make some more progress, please. To ensure the efficacy of this cap, we are introducing a minimum residency period.

This will mean that an individual moving or returning to the UK will be subject to the 100k cap for the remainder of the calendar year plus another full calendar year. Measures relating to overseas electors and those who have been registered as overseas electors will be retrospective to the date that they were announced on the 25th of March 2026. This again will prevent bad actors funneling money into our elections in advance in the change of the law. We are also applying the cap and a minimum residency period to individuals who move to the UK after the 6th of July and were not previously overseas electors. The 100,000 pounds annual cap will apply per recipient on donations and regulated transactions made from the 6th of July until commencement, after which they will be treated in the same way as former registered overseas electors.

Further amendments relating to the declarations required for this will follow in the Lords. I will give way.

02:39:46 - 02:40:19

Speaker 132

I'm grateful. Just to develop a theme from the chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, she's making some steps to control foreign contributions and donations to politics, but why not just ban it? She touched herself on the malign influence of people who would seek to offshore their tax liability, so not contributing to the business of government, and then from some offshore location direct that government about how to spend that money, which they won't be subject to the consequences of, and neither will they have to donate to it. It's totally unjust. Why is it not banned?

02:40:19 - 02:47:22

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honorable member and I will refer him back to my... I need to make progress. I have a number of areas and amendments to cover and there are many members who do want to... Who do want to make... Who do want to comment on this debate today.

I'll refer the gentleman to my previous statements on this area. Following on, the cap for overseas electors and those who fail the minimum residency period will be required to provide a declaration to provide any necessary information to the recipient to enable them to check whether the donation is permissible. This declaration must provide, must be provided before the donation can be accepted. The cap will apply UK-wide and will operate consistently across the political finance regime across UK electors. Turning now to our amendments to strengthen the company donation framework in clause 60.

After carefully considering calls from stakeholders and experts in this field, most recently echoed by the Ryecroft review, the government has agreed to introduce a profit-based test for corporate donations. I would like to commend the work for the member for Early and Woodley and others in this House for their efforts in this subject. Profit, by contrast with revenue, provides a clearer indication of a company's financial position because it reflects what remains after expenditure has been met, including tax liabilities. Our intention is not simply to identify companies that have generated income, but to ensure that political donations are supported by genuine economic activity and financial substance. A profit-based test is a stronger indication of that than turnover alone.

The amendments establish a clear statutory framework for applying a profit test. We understand that naturally companies can face legitimate fluctuations in their profits, so companies will be able to demonstrate profit over a five-year period. The government has also sought to ensure that the regime operates in a way that is both practical and familiar to companies, LLPs and recipients. The amendments provide that profit is determined by reference to existing standard accounting principles using financial information that companies are already operating as part of their ordinary reporting requirements. Where no qualifying profit and loss exist, the relevant financial year will be treated as one in which no profit was made.

Further on company donations, an additional set of amendments build on existing bill measures to strengthen safeguards around political donations and loans from companies and limited partnerships. These amendments extend and clarify the operation of new company and LLP permissibility tests in relation to regulated transactions, including loans and other arrangements.

These arrangements close potential gaps and ensure that the regulatory regime remains effective throughout the lifetime of the transaction, rather than only at the point it was originally entered into, as well as ensuring that the regime reflects economic reality and operates fairly in practice. We have also tabled a set of amendments to clarify how the aggregated provisions work where connected transactions are involved. The bill already prevents a company or LLP from exceeding the amount that its financial position justifies splitting support across multiple donations. These amendments ensure the same principles apply where the support is provided through a combination of donations, loans, or connected transactions. As initially introduced, the bill proposes a significant control test to help to ensure that companies and LLPs donating to political parties are majority owned or controlled by UK electors or citizens.

Further amendments have been tabled to target improvements for the operation of that test. In particular, they address cases involving trust and firms to ensure that the test functions as intended and ensure that political parties can take account of the information held by Companies House relating to unconfirmed persons with a significant control. Taken together, these amendments strengthen the coherence of the bill's political finance regime by ensuring the new safeguard apply consistently, close loopholes, and improve transparency. Government new clause 75 and government amendment 100 introduce targeted regulation powers to allow key political finance restrictions introduced by this bill to be extended where appropriate. As drafted, a number of the bill's provisions apply specifically to registered political parties.

These include the restrictions relating to donations and regulated transactions involving crypto assets, the cap on donations by and transactions involving overseas electors, restrictions on donations made by transactions including companies and LLPs. Government new clause 75 enables the Secretary of State by regulations to make provisions of equivalent effects across the wider political finance framework. Regulations extend the restrictions on donations and transactions for both crypto assets and the cap on overseas contributors, which may have effects no earlier than the 25th of March 2026. This amendment also allows the Secretary of State to impose similar restrictions on the use of gifts made by overseas contributors and companies to incorporated associations making political donations. The powers have a number of safeguards.

Any regulations made under these powers will be subject to the affirmative procedures. Before laying such regulations, the Secretary of State must consult the Electoral Commission and, where relevant, obtain consent from Scottish ministers and Welsh ministers. Without this power, those seeking to circumvent the new rules could simply redirect activity through areas of the regime where comparable safeguards do not apply. That would risk creating a loophole in the electoral regime, undermining the effectiveness and the protections this bill is intended to provide. These amendments have a time-limited mechanism ensuring that they are introduced and where possible consistently across the categories of political activity and to the recipients of political funding.

02:47:22 - 02:47:24

Speaker 134

Will she give way? I'll give way very quickly.

02:47:24 - 02:47:58

Speaker 137

Very briefly, thank you Madam Chair. And I really thank the honorable lady for the statement she is making about restricting donations and she's talked about loopholes and the new powers that the commission is going to have. A loophole that I'm really concerned about is a loophole around donations to candidates and the definition of candidates and how that interacts with other parts of the legal framework. Would she be able to share thoughts that she has on any progress that the government is making on this particular loophole and whether or not there is a chance for this to be considered any further?

02:47:58 - 02:55:34

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honorable member, my constituency neighbor, for raising that really important example of where there may exist loopholes in this really technical and large bill. And I think this is an area that we will continue to seek and work with the Electoral Commission as we continue to develop this bill in the later stages. I want to make some progress please. New government clause 78 strengthens the information sharing provisions already contained in the bill by establishing a reciprocal statutory gateway between the Electoral Commission and relevant public authorities. We have carefully considered recommendation nine of the review and we agree that if we are to expect the commission to regulate political finance effectively and respond to the emerging risk, it must be able to receive relevant information from the bodies it works alongside.

This amendment enables the commission and relevant public authorities to share information with one another where doing so assists the performance of their respective functions. The government also recognizes that information sharing must be accompanied by robust safeguards. That is why the gateway is tightly defined. It does not override express statutory prohibitions on disclosure and includes additional protections for sensitive personal information received from revenue authorities, backed by potential criminal sanctions for unauthorized onward disclosure. Government amendments 125 to 131 respond to recommendation 10 of the Rycroft review and give the Electoral Commission greater powers to require the disclosure of documents, information and giving of explanation outside of an investigation.

They also make some minor amendments to ensure that former accredited recall campaigners can be investigated when they cease participation in recall petition process. Currently, outside of an investigation, the Electoral Commission can only issue a notice to specific regulated entities requiring disclosure. To issue a notice requiring disclosure from anyone else, there must have been reasonable grounds to suspect an offense has been committed. This places the commission in an impossible situation. The only way it can get the information is to take serious steps of opening a formal investigation.

However, without such information, they are unable to establish the reasonable grounds for suspicions which they need to open an investigation in the first place. These amendments extend the commission's powers outside of the formal investigation so that they are able to require disclosure of information relating to the income or expenditure of regulated entities from any person or organization. I must make way. Government amendment NC 114 implements recommendation seven of the Rycroft review by giving the Electoral Commission clear powers to require campaign spend returns to be submitted in a standardized format across the political finance regime. This will make spend returns more consistent and easier to scrutinize, supporting greater transparency and more effective oversight.

Turning to the set of amendments relating to know your donor measures, these make a series of technical and clarification changes to the aggregated powers within the know your donor regime.

The know-your-donor provisions require recipients in certain circumstances to take, undertake a risk assessment where relevant or controlled benefits reach the specified threshold. In determining whether that threshold has been met, the legislation contains provisions which require benefits to be considered together. These amendments are technical amendments, clarifying the operation of aggregation rules, how the rules apply to the connected transactions and when regulated transactions are entered into, and correcting a drafting error relating to regulated participants. The amendments also remove the requirements of the weekly donation reports under section 63 of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 to include a declaration about carrying out a know-your-donor risk assessment in relation to donations accepted during the reporting period. Government amendments 138, 139, 143 and 144 are minor and technical amendments which remove powers granted to inadvertently in respect of a reserved matter to devolved governments' ministers in Scotland and Wales.

The government has been in contact, in constant contact with the devolved governments throughout the development of this bill, as well as making sure they're in touch on specific points. New government clause 113 closes the gap in current legislation whereby if an overseas elector becomes, ceases to be British, they could potentially remain on the electoral register, thus remaining eligible for up to three years. This amendment allows such individuals to be removed from the electoral register as soon as they cease to satisfy eligibility criteria, which essentially allow them to register as overseas electors. Finally, I turn to government amendments 140, 141, 147 to 150. These extend the maximum duration for postal and proxy postal voting arrangements from three to five years.

They also extend the maximum donation for the anonymous election registration to five years to better align with this and provide the creation of a clearly defined reapplication window for postal and proxy postal applications. Together these amendments will make voters' and administrators' lives a lot easier, I can speak from experience on returning my postal vote form, particularly benefiting vulnerable electors while maintaining the vital security arrangements needed to ensure the integrity of our democratic system. As my predecessor, the honourable member for Chester North and Neston said at the second reading, we have a vital opportunity in this bill to strengthen our institutions and the processes to ensure that they work for the people they serve. This bill delivers a modern and secure and inclusive electoral system that the public rightly deserve, bearing down on those who seek to harm or undermine our elections, protecting those who participate and opening up our democracy to a generation of new and able voters. This is how we safeguard the trust and ensure that every eligible citizen can take part freely with the safety and confidence that they deserve.

With that, Madam Deputy Speaker, I commend this bill to the house.

...etc. in crypto assets.

The question is that new clause 72 be read a second time. Shadow Secretary of State, Katie Lamb.

02:55:34 - 02:59:36

Katie Lam

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to begin by paying tribute to my predecessor, the right honorable member for Braintree, for his work in this role. He's left big shoes to fill, and I look forward to following in his footsteps as best I can. I'd also like to register my thanks to the honorable members for Orpington, for Broxbourne, and for Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner, alongside whom I'm so fortunate to be working, including on this bill, and to the honorable member for Hamble Valley, who has been incredibly helpful in handing over and has worked so hard on this bill in particular. In the same vein, I would like to thank the honorable lady for Chester North and Neston for her work on this bill, and pass on the thanks of my honorable friends too.

And I would like to welcome the honorable lady to her new place and congratulate her. I know she is much liked and regarded across this house, having chaired the select committee for the past few years, and I look forward to working opposite her and her departmental colleagues. Madam Deputy Speaker, our democracy is incredibly precious. Each and every member in this house owes their position to the British people, and we would do well to remember it. That we live in a country where fundamental decisions about our nation's future are made by representatives of the people chosen through free and fair elections ought to be an immense source of pride.

It is a sacred duty incumbent upon all of us to make sure that the will of the people is not subverted, undermined, or diluted. We should, therefore, consider very carefully any changes to the process by which the British people express their will. When we do make such changes, they must always be designed to make sure that the British people can better hold their representatives accountable, that would-be representatives can meaningfully put their case to the British people, and that our democratic process is conducted according to the national norms and practices which have made this country such a successful democracy for so long. Unfortunately, that careful consideration is absent from the changes before us today. This is particularly true of the proposals on or some of the proposals on political donations and campaign finance.

Protecting our democracy from foreign influence is a noble aim and one we share on this side of the house. But the changes proposed by the government have not always been produced with the proper care and attention. They have been moved with too little consultation and opportunity for scrutiny. It is particularly concerning that parliamentary questions have revealed that there has been no meaningful engagement with the house authorities, despite proposals directly affecting the registration of donations. That is why we have tabled an amendment to prevent this bill, if and when it becomes law, from coming into force until the Secretary of State has consulted the political parties panel.

Changes of such fundamental importance must never be made on a knee-jerk or reactive basis. The British people deserve better. Which brings me to the amendment laid down by the member for Leeds Central and Headingley, which proposes to establish a commission on electoral reform. To attach such a monumental change to an already overloaded bill at this late stage would be completely absurd. And to take steps towards changing our electoral system despite never seeking the support of the British people for doing so would be more absurd still.

Reform of our entire electoral system is not a minor technical adjustment. It would fundamentally alter the way in which democracy in this country functions. In particular, the system of proportional representation favored by some members on the other side of the house would forever break the link between the performance of members in this house and the will of the people. Under our system, at the level of the constituency, people have the opportunity to choose an individual to represent them. They can hold that person accountable and ultimately remove them if they wish at the next election.

Under proportional representation, the decision about who gets to serve in Parliament would be made not by the people, but instead by the central offices of political parties. I will happily.

02:59:36 - 03:00:11

Christopher John Vince

I thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and the shadow minister, because I actually agree with her on this point, because I proudly represent my constituency of Harlow and I think it's really important that I have that local accountability. That means a great deal to me. But would she, as I'm going to turn this into a question as an intervention, would she agree with me that actually we do need to take the foreign interference in our electoral system really seriously, which is why it's important that this bill is, as I believe it is to be, really solid, really detailed and willing to make changes because we recognize that these malign influences will do anything they can to weave their way into our political system.

03:00:11 - 03:03:11

Katie Lam

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is never anything but a pleasure to allow the honorable gentleman to put Harlow again into Hansard and I'm happy to repeat him. He is right, we must be incredibly vigilant. We must not be naive about the extent to which foreign powers are actively pursuing these sorts of strategies to undermine our democracy and ultimately therefore to undermine our nation, and they must be treated with the utmost seriousness. But while some of these changes have been suggested to be rushed through in a sweeping way, we feel this bill has shockingly little to say about the threats to our democracy that we do already know enough about to take decisive action on.

This includes the effective disenfranchisement of many British citizens living overseas. Our citizens abroad remain citizens and are often directly affected by decisions taken by this Parliament, but all too often find it very difficult to register to vote or to cast their ballots. To that end, we have tabled amendments that require the Secretary of State to make provision for overseas voters to cast their votes in person at British embassies, high commissions and consulates. But chief among the threats to our democracy today is the rise of coercion, fraud and sectarianism in our democratic process. These are in turn most often the result of a poisonous separatism which has taken hold in far too many of our towns and cities.

Migration has been far too high in this country for far too long against the wishes of the British people. Many of those who have come to this country come from cultures with very different norms from our own. At the same time, Britain has been complacent about enforcing our cultural norms and democratic norms and far too tolerant of those who weaponize group-based identity politics for their own gain. One consequence of this has been the rise of explicitly sectarian political campaigning, whereby candidates appeal not to the individual interests of voters, nor to the national interest, but to particular ethnic, religious or cultural groups. This is profoundly poisonous and we must do everything that we can to root it out.

One symptom of this emergent separatism in our society is the rise of so-called family voting, whereby a senior male family member directs other members of their family, particularly women, on how they ought to vote. I will when I have finished this point gladly. At the Gorton and Denton by-election earlier this year, volunteers reported, I quote, the highest level of family voting at any election in the past decade. Family voting was observed at more than two-thirds of polling stations. It may have influenced the votes of more than one in ten people who turned out to cast their ballots.

And in Birmingham, at this year's local elections, polling station staff reported instances of family voting in fifty polling stations. Despite evidence being passed to the police by the council, no further action has been taken. I will happily give way.

03:03:11 - 03:03:45

Anne Emily Thornberry

The allegations that the honorable lady is making is extremely serious and should be based on robust evidence. To be told that, I can't remember what the phrase was, volunteers had reported, is not sufficient and she must understand the implications of what she's saying in terms of social coherence and undermining our very, the status of our democracy.

I do ask her to be a little more cautious and to proceed on the basis of evidence.

03:03:45 - 03:05:38

Katie Lam

Polling station volunteers reporting what they had seen in their polling stations is evidence. It is not for us to decide what is appropriate to discuss in this chamber. It is for us to talk about it and for the public to decide. They can see this, it was very, very well reported at the time. Family voting is a direct assault on two important principles.

The first is that each and every voter must be able to cast their ballot on the basis of their individual beliefs and interest. The second is that those ballots should be cast in secret, without pressure or oversight. These two principles are fundamental to the functioning of British democracy. That we live in a country where we have been able to take these things for granted is no small achievement, but it must be defended vigorously. Any practice which results in husbands instructing their wives how to vote or allows fathers to instruct their daughters on how to vote is an insult to the liberties enjoyed by women in this country and it must not be allowed to stand.

And yet, this Labour government has turned a blind eye. They've rejected Conservative proposals to strengthen enforcement of the Ballot Secrecy Act. Indeed, they are scrapping guidance to local councillors and councils about how to stop family voting. Our new clause 62 would help tackle this catastrophe. Another favoured tactic of sectarian candidates is the use of foreign language in their campaign material.

To return to the Gorton and Denton by-election, during the course of the campaign, the Green Party published leaflets in Urdu telling voters that if they wanted to, quote, give the Muslims a strong voice, they should, quote, give their vote to the Greens. Depressingly, this is far from the only example, though it is one of the most reprehensible.

03:05:38 - 03:05:41

Speaker 138

When I have finished this point, I will.

03:05:41 - 03:06:05

Katie Lam

It should terrify all of us that election material in our country is being produced in a foreign language designed to drum up support amongst a particular religious community. Not only does this contribute to a culture of group-based grievance politics, it also makes it impossible for the vast majority of the British public to scrutinise what these candidates are saying. I give way.

03:06:05 - 03:06:44

Lisa Smart

Extremely grateful to the Shadow Secretary of State for giving way. I wonder if she sees a certain sort of irony in attempting to legislate for linguistic purity in a language which for over a millennium has borrowed vocabulary ad hoc from other languages such as Italian, Latin, French. Maybe in a bill where we're talking about elections, referendum, veto, manifesto, that there is perhaps more than a little hint of irony in what she might be proposing.

03:06:44 - 03:07:06

Katie Lam

The fact that English takes words from other languages does not mean that English or indeed any British voter would be able to read them in Latin. The point is that our voters must be able to understand the election literature that is being produced. If they can't, if it is not produced in a language of the British Isles, they cannot. There was an earlier, yes, I will.

03:07:06 - 03:07:38

Luke Akehurst

I thank the honourable lady for giving way. Could she confirm to the House whether or not the Conservative Party has ever published election leaflets in particular constituencies or wards in languages other than English? Because I have a vague memory and my honourable friend sat next to me has memories of seeing Conservative Party election literature in community languages in elections in various parts of the country.

03:07:38 - 03:07:53

Katie Lam

Our proposal has, is clearly intended to be one rule for everybody.

The Conservative Party position is that all election literature should be produced in the languages of this country. I have given way twice on this point and I will make some progress. Oh, I will give way to my honourable friend.

03:07:53 - 03:08:40

Paul Holmes

I thank the Shadow Secretary of State. Seeing as it was my amendment, I think I'm allowed to intervene on it. I welcome the Shadow Secretary of State to her position. The reason that I know she will agree with me that we brought this amendment was the fact that it said the Green Party leaflet said, "Punish the Labour Party for Gaza, vote Green." Now they have every right to say that, but I would argue that that's divisive.

And can I just assist my Shadow Secretary of State by saying from the other from the honourable gentleman opposite that it is actually Conservative Party policy not to put English not to put election literature in the short campaign in a language other than in English. And actually CCHQ dismissed some of our candidates for doing so.

03:08:40 - 03:08:43

Speaker 142

I thank my honourable friend.

03:08:43 - 03:08:45

Speaker 141

Will she give way for a constructive question?

03:08:45 - 03:08:47

Speaker 140

I will give way one final time on this specific point.

03:08:47 - 03:09:42

Luke Taylor

Thank you, and I thank the honourable lady for her patience. Does she see the conflict between problems with family voting, which may well be caused by members of family not having English as their if not their first language, a language at all, and therefore needing to be informed in a language which they are comfortable with, with also a step to restrict any languages that a family member may well need to understand the arguments that are being made about an election? And we can all agree that understanding the language, learning a language, having access to the English that the vast majority of us speak is important for integration. But does she not agree that these have two conflicting outcomes? One is to restrict communication with all members of a family, the other is to ban that influence in the first place.

03:09:42 - 03:12:14

Katie Lam

I thank the honourable member for his intervention and I understand his point. But it is a deep and frightening and fundamental problem if we have people in this country who cannot operate in the shared language of our nation. I understand what he is saying, but there are two possible ways to deal with that and I believe that the one that he is suggesting will ultimately be deleterious to our nation and our democracy. We must make a choice, which I think is also the point that he is making, and I am making a different choice. I have given way many times on this point and I would like to make some progress.

The fundamental point about producing election literature in English or another language of the British Isles is that the public must be able to scrutinize what it is that candidates are saying. We must put a stop to election literature in foreign languages once and for all. We have therefore laid an amendment which would require that campaign material published during the regulated election period is not promoted or published in a foreign language. Instead, campaign material must be published in English or another native language of the British Isles. Those who engage in our democratic process must do so in the common language of public life.

That much is the bare minimum. But this Labour government is either blind or unfortunately weak on the issue of electoral sectarianism, which represents the single biggest threat to our democracy today. They have repeatedly chosen to soften our approach to coercive family voting and to allow candidates to continue campaigning in foreign languages with the explicit intention of appealing to particular ethnic, religious or cultural minority groups. Unfortunately, I expect they will do so again today. But fortunately, because we live in a democracy, it is ultimately for the British people to decide what they think of that.

For it is their decision, Madam Deputy Speaker, which matters most. And what a wonderful thing that is. The democracy that we enjoy in this country was hard-built.

It is deeply precious and far from common. Its maintenance relies on our constant vigilance in this place and as citizens of the nation at large. It cannot be sustained unless we tell the truth, however difficult that may sometimes be, about anything which threatens it.

03:12:14 - 03:17:36

Florence Eshalomi

Thank you very much. And first of all, I'd like to welcome the member for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green to her place because she has taken on an immensely challenging role, but one that will bring her great joy, I'm sure. It's often said that a week is a long time in politics, and I would say a year has been an extremely long time in terms of this particular bill. And the evidence of that we see in the hefty number of amendments that have come forward as each political event moves on, as people fall on their swords, more amendments come forward. And I know it's been of real interest to members across the House, but also to many civil society organisations, that this bill should be crafted to respond to events as they happen.

And I should actually pay tribute to the bill team who have responded incredibly well to the number of amendments that are coming forward and to the legislative challenge that this bill represents. The bill removes barriers to voting that were put in electors' ways. It protects our democracy, as my honourable friend has described. And it's extremely important in terms of votes at 16, automatic voter registration and the powers that will be taken to pilot it so that we can find those lost voters who fall out of our electoral system and bring them back into democratic engagement. The committee stage was lively, and I certainly enjoyed it.

And I have to pay tribute to the honourable member for Hamble Valley, who I think we have struck up something of an accord together. And I have to refer him back to one particular point in committee stage when he said, "We have a groundbreaking piece of legislation." He continued, "I am sure when we get to report stage, the minister will now say in the chamber, 'The shadow minister said this is groundbreaking legislation.'" It has its bad points and very good points, but I accept it is groundbreaking. Neither he nor I are minister or shadow minister, but I think we agreed on those particular points.

And I want to thank him for the spirit in which he and other members of the committee conducted themselves. I think what we have to remember is that any political party, any candidate, any elected representative who abides by the rules that this legislation brings forward will be able to flourish in our political system. And those who do not can expect to be held very firmly to account. One of the points, the only point I have to say on which I agree with the shadow secretary of state, and I welcome her to her place, is that I would urge my colleagues on this side of the house to continue working with other political parties constructively. It is not the case that we have not engaged as a government on this particular legislation.

We have been at great pains to do so and I would urge her to continue to do so as this bill makes its progress through this House and the other place, but also as we go through the secondary legislation that falls from it. And my final point that I wanted to raise was about the Rycroft review. The final recommendation from Philip Rycroft's review concerned the organisation of the civil service in response to democracy and elections, and he suggested that there was a permanent secretary appointed to look after democracy and elections. And given we've just had the statement from the right honourable member for Sheffield Heeley about rewiring public services and government, it often felt to me that many of the areas this legislation covers are not just the remit of MHCLG, they fall to DCMS, they fall to the Cabinet Office, they even fall to the Home Office. And I would urge her and the Secretary of State to consider all of this in the round and whether or not a more strategic government position could be found to actually take this legislation forward.

There is sometimes a tension between the powers that MHCLG has and the powers that other government departments have, and I'm sure these will be debated as we go forward this afternoon. But I wanted to say it was enormously a privilege for me to actually take this through second reading and committee stage, and I am very grateful to my honourable friend for bringing it in such a timely way for report.

03:17:36 - 03:17:39

Speaker 145

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Lisa Smart.

03:17:39 - 03:25:50

Lisa Smart

Madam Deputy Speaker, I wish to move new clause 88 and the other amendments tabled in my name. But let me begin by putting on record my thanks to the Minister, whom I very much welcome to her place, and in particular to her predecessor, who I think with her comments there has shown the grace and the thoughtfulness that she conducted herself with throughout the whole process. We didn't agree on everything at bill committee, but I think it was... indeed we didn't with all members of the bill committee, but I think we conducted our discussions with good grace and occasionally a hint of humour. The other members of the bill committee I'm also grateful for the work they put in, and particularly my honourable friend the member for Guildford, who led for us on all matters to do with candidate safety and candidates, particularly given her hugely relevant experience as a member of the Speaker's Conference.

It would also be remiss of me not to share the gratitude of the House for Philip Rycroft's efforts in conducting his review, the recommendations from which have given this legislation more teeth than it started out with. I don't think it'll surprise anyone though, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we Liberal Democrats think much more could and should be done. The political freedoms and assurances we have relied upon for decades are increasingly vulnerable to insidious hostile actors. We saw a by-election over the summer that was entirely unnecessary. It was a waste of taxpayers' money brought about by a resignation whose circumstances are under investigation by the Standards Commissioner.

Our rules should not permit a member under investigation to trigger a by-election and then walk straight back here at the public's expense, and that's precisely what new clause 79 in my name would prevent, but I don't believe it's selectable, so I'll move on. The whole saga was yet another example of how big money is infiltrating our politics: millions of pounds paid to politicians, uncapped donations, direct payments for inflammatory social media posts.

It is totally disfiguring our politics. We have to tackle big money wherever it comes from, and this is a major omission in the bill. New clause 88 would require the Secretary of State within three months of Royal Assent to publish proposals for a Royal Commission to consider a cap on political donations and the level at which that cap should be set, and to consider whether existing limits on campaign expenditure and the period over which they bite are still fit for purpose. It requires these proposals to cover terms of reference, membership and funding, and it requires the Commission to report within 12 months. This is a straightforward request.

It does not demand or impose limits without buy-in. It does not ask any member to sign up to a particular figure. It takes a conversation that's been going on for the better part of 20 years or more and gives it a proper remit, a proper deadline and a proper independent home. Now I want to be fair to the government here because over the summer things have moved in a positive direction, and I welcome the Prime Minister's words about the Defending Democracy Taskforce yesterday. But we need to hear more detail about how it will function, particularly around money coming into political parties in and around our politics, how its recommendations will come into force and importantly when they will come into force, because the threat is real, the threat is now and urgent action is vital.

We have tabled further amendments on money in politics. New clauses 9 and 10 introduce barriers on who can donate, preventing those who are or have been members of or political advisors to foreign administrations and those convicted of promoting or inciting political violence. New clauses 11 and 12 require candidates and parties to declare and mitigate the risk of foreign-linked donations, and taken together these are a natural extension of the know-your-donor scheme this bill enhances. We should know exactly who funds us, and the public have that right as well. Money though is not the only way in which influence is bought.

We now live in a world where a handful of people own the platforms and write the algorithms that decide what millions of our constituents see about politics every day. When the owner of a social media platform can openly discuss handing tens of millions of pounds to a British political party, the danger is in plain sight, and this bill does not meet the moment. The government chose to reject sensible amendments on deepfakes, on AI-generated content and on the clear labelling of digital campaign material. Those were not wrecking amendments, they were an offer of cross-party work on a threat that is moving faster than we are legislating. And I ask the government even now to commit to real-time disclosure of donations and a publicly searchable database of every pound spent on online political advertising so that voters can see who is trying to influence them and with whose money.

And this will be more important as we extend the franchise. Lib Dems warmly welcome the introduction of votes at 16. Indeed we've campaigned on it for decades, but we're concerned that the current voter registration system does not work well for young people. If we want votes at 16 to be a success, we need the voter registration improvements that this bill enables implemented in time for the next general election. So I'd welcome when she's winding up hearing from the Minister some reassurance for the House that this will be in place for the next general election.

And I come to my final point, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's one I feel matters the most. This bill tidies the rules of the game, but it leaves the game itself untouched. There is no silver bullet for fixing our politics.

It requires will, consensus and graft. But there is one thing that I know is shared by dozens and dozens of members across this house. And that's the understanding of the need for fairer votes. We cannot have a conversation about representing the people without addressing the elephant in the room. We have a voting system that handed one party two thirds of the seats in this house on barely a third of the vote.

Millions of people cast ballots that changed nothing and elected no one. And then they're told to have faith in the result. And that's why I tabled a new clause to bring in proportional representation for elections across the United Kingdom, new clause eight. It details the way in which a fairer voting system could be implemented, and it is disappointing that this government has not taken the opportunity this bill presents to rise to the occasion. First past the post is unfair.

It is unrepresentative, and it lets governments take voters for granted. No amount of tightening around the edges fixes a system that was out of date a century ago. Despite identifying the crisis of confidence in our political system in its 2024 manifesto, this government has yet to back even modest steps towards making our voting system fairer, such as a national commission on electoral reform as detailed in new clause... Order. Before we delve into a rabbit hole about proportional representation, it might be helpful if I reminded all members that it is out of scope of the bill.

Lisa Smart.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for confirming that the government is putting forward a piece of legislation written in such a way that prohibits proportional representation and fairer votes from being discussed on the floor of the house. We need to fix our politics so that we can get on with fixing the things we need to fix in our country. So we will support this bill as a step forwards. But a step is not the final destination. Until this house finds the courage to give people a parliament that actually reflects how they vote, we will not have restored trust in our democracy.

We will keep making that case, and we will support this bill as the beginning, but certainly not the end of this work.

03:25:50 - 03:25:53

Speaker 146

Mike Reader.

03:25:53 - 03:29:03

Michael Reader

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you for calling me so early. Without wanting to upset you, I was going to talk about new clause 31, but I will keep my comments to a minimum on that for fear of upsetting you. I want to thank the government actually first of all for the work that's happened to bring the bill to the state it is now. I think the improvements brought through the new clauses and amendments strengthen the bill, and I feel very positive that we're moving in the right direction now on what should be a once in a generation change to fix some of the inequality and unfair influence on our electoral system. But I would want to put on record my concerns that there are very experienced members of the house, including on this side of the house, who are still raising concerns over donations, over foreign influence.

And I hope the minister can confirm that as the bill passes into the Lords, we'll see the government working with those who've brought forward amendments to further strengthen the protections we have on our democracy. Being a delegate to the UK to the Council of Europe on behalf of the UK, we have seen across Europe how Russia's influence has changed elections, not just in Eastern Europe, even in France and Germany and others. And we have to take that threat seriously. But this bill is about fairness. Representation of the people is about fairness.

And I am frustrated that even though this third reading, sorry, this report stage was delayed until after the summer, we haven't been able to move forward on new clause 31.

It has been ruled out of scope. And I think it has been misrepresented. And I'd like to put on record that this isn't about forcing proportional representation. This isn't about forcing change as perhaps was suggested by the shadow Secretary of State. This is about bringing forward a commission to look at electoral reform.

We have so many different forms of the electoral process in the UK. If you're in Scotland, you elect your MP differently to your, to your other representatives. In Wales, in London, if you've got a mayor, your electoral system will be different for different elections. It is confusing. It puts people off.

And it makes it harder to get people to buy into our electoral system. We are opening up the electoral system to new people through this piece of legislation, through votes for 16 and 17-year-olds and automatic voter registration. And I feel concerned that the Prime Minister recognizes that there will need to be a manifesto commitment to make the final change, but a commission now will help to shape that thinking. So Madam Speaker, I did plan to speak in depth on new clause 31 and I won't do for fear of upsetting you and your favor of letting me speak early so I can pop downstairs now to speak at the Portakabin reception if anyone wants to come down and join me. But I just want to put on record those concerns.

Yes, I feel that we can still go further on protection of elections, on foreign interference, particularly as we see Russia's threat. And I would ask the government again to look at whether we can bring forward this national commission on electoral reform to make sure we can give a clear answer on how we go forward on how we make sure people are represented in our country. Thank you.

03:29:03 - 03:29:05

Speaker 147

Esther McVey.

03:29:05 - 03:30:00

Esther McVey

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise to speak today on amendments 49 to 55 and amendments 56 to 62 tabled in my name to clause 1 and in support of amendments 6 to 12 to clause 1 in the name of my honorable friend the member for Mid Leicestershire. Now this bill, or through this bill, this government has taken inconsistency to a new level. In its desire to give votes to 16-year-olds, it brings more confusion to the legal age of adulthood. In one breath, it's giving votes to 16-year-olds and yet at the same time in another piece of legislation, it's saying that 16-year-olds aren't mature enough to use social media.

There will be curfews for those under the age of 16. This bill...

03:30:00 - 03:30:21

Sam Rushworth

I'm grateful to her for giving way and I can see that she's clearly opposed to this measure. I just want to remind her about nine years ago, she and I debated at Wilmslow High School. And I remember a clear commitment that she made to the students then that she would support giving them the vote at 16.

03:30:21 - 03:32:40

Esther McVey

I think, I think the honorable member clearly gave support. I had various caveats. And as things have changed, like recently, can children even get married now at 16? That has been increased. At the same time, we're saying we don't think those under the age of 18 should be able to be on social media.

That is new addition. So we are changing the age of adulthood consistently. The Labour benches don't even think that the child, the brain is mature enough to even maybe be considered for criminal actions until the age of 25. Things are changing constantly. Yes, that is right.

Things are changing continually. And so this bill goes against the age of adulthood with lawmakers raising the age on many different things as I've mentioned. As a country, we collectively agree that the age of 18 is adulthood and with it comes rights, responsibilities and things that you can and cannot do.

Once you reach the age of 18, then the individual can stand for election to this House, can make decisions about their own medical treatment, enter into binding financial agreements, place and be able to buy cigarettes and vapes. They can even get a tattoo. But perhaps the greatest right of them all is the right to vote and the responsibilities that come with that. Yet under this bill, 1.7 million 16 to 17-year-olds will be granted the right to vote. And what we could all see this was about was fixing the right to vote.

It was about ballot fixing. It was in the hope that the Labour party could win the next general election if it could get this generation of young people to vote for it. But maybe now that it's seen the latest polling and actually the young voters are turning green, it might do what this government does on a regular basis, screeching U-turns. It might be one not through common sense, but actually through self-interest, it might do another screeching U-turn here.

03:32:40 - 03:33:06

Craig Gareth Snell

I thank the honourable lady for giving way. The shadow Secretary of State made a defence of the right for overseas electors to vote for an indiscriminate amount of time based simply on their citizenry. So why is it right for someone that does not live in this country to be able to vote as a right of them being a citizen, but she's now making an argument that a 16-year-old who lives here and contributes, who has the same citizen rights, should not be able to vote?

03:33:06 - 03:33:49

Esther McVey

We're talking about two completely different things. We're talking about the age of adulthood, the age with which we think people have got the ability to weigh up everything that is going on and come to a decision. And yet at the same time this House is saying these young people cannot go on social media, they shouldn't be on certain types of iPhone, they shouldn't be able to do other things, but they are saying they are mature enough to vote. Inconsistency. And I'm saying that we need to be consistent.

A bit of common sense, a bit of consistency would go a long way in this House. The gentleman behind.

03:33:49 - 03:34:09

Chris Curtis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So in line with that, would she therefore, is she therefore calling for the age in which you can get a job to be raised from 14 to 18, ruling out 16 to 18-year-olds from being able to work? And is she calling for the age in which you can learn to drive to be raised from 17 and 18, because to follow her argument, to not do those things and not support those things would be inconsistent.

03:34:09 - 03:37:55

Esther McVey

And I agree there are inconsistencies and we are trying to get them right. But unlike the opposite benches under which unemployment always goes up every time they're in office, we want young people to get work experience and we want young people to go to work. And we have for a long period of time allowed driving at 17. But my goodness, possibly the opposite benches for more inconsistency would want it to go up. I am dealing with the matter at hand of the voting of 18-year-olds and I'm saying the opposite benches, it was more about vote rigging than whether 16-year-olds should be able to vote.

So if we carry on for a second, we are not saying that 16-year-olds would be sent off packing to combat, nor would we be saying that as I said these inconsistencies carry on about the age of marriage. In England and Wales, the legal age of marriage and civil partnerships is 18 and arranging a marriage for anyone under 18 is illegal. The Marriage and Civil Partnerships (Minimum Age) Act passed by Parliament only four years ago revoked the previous legal provision that allowed 16 and 17-year-olds to marry with parental consent. The legislation made clear that marriage is an adult decision and the law treats anyone under 18 as a child. The Act passed with cross-party support and the Labour front bench at the time supported it.

Why did they believe then that people under 18 can't make the decision to marry, but now they believe they can make the decision to vote?

The same applies to property ownership and mortgages. My amendments 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61 and 62 would link the age at which an individual is eligible to vote with the age of which they can have a mortgage or own a property. Our laws dictate that individuals under 18 lack full legal capacity so cannot enter into binding land or loan contracts. If a 16 year old is not legally able to own a property or enter into a mortgage in their own right, why are they considered sufficiently mature to vote in elections? And if a 16 year old is not sensible enough to buy alcohol, something that has been law in our country since 1923, why are they trusted to vote?

I'm pleased to support amendments 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 in the name of my honourable friend the member for Mid Leicestershire, which would tie the age at which you can buy alcohol to the age with which you are eligible to vote. The question is simple: why has the government decided that the voting age in one area of 16 is adulthood while in so many other areas this has not met the threshold of adulthood? We're told that votes at 16 are essential in engaging young people in our democracy, that they will empower young people to participate in society and affect change. But what young people have the government spoken to? I know I've spoken to many across my patch, visiting many local schools and it's very interesting that many of them do not think that they feel fully qualified enough to vote and don't feel that they are prepared to be able to vote.

Look at the impact of lowering the voting age in Scotland where academic studies have found that the boost in interest among young people was short-lived and has failed to translate into wider political participation.

03:37:55 - 03:38:22

Brendan O'Hara

I thank... two points, Madam Deputy Speaker. Is it the Conservative Party policy to reverse the votes for 16 and 17 year olds in Scotland? And every single piece of evidence that you can point to says that engaging people at 16 and 17 year olds makes better citizens. Are you... is the honourable lady seriously wanting to undermine that?

03:38:22 - 03:39:26

Esther McVey

I don't believe that if Scotland wants to carry on with this vote rigging they are fully entitled to do so. I'm sure they'll conjure up many other ways to do that as well. But look, this government can wax lyrical all they long about the virtues of lowering the voting age. But we know, and I... we know how important it is for people to fully understand, fully appreciate what they are doing. And it is this inconsistency.

How is it that they can't buy alcohol, can't have a tattoo, can't be on the front line, can't get married and yet we are pushing for 16 year olds to have a vote? No, it does not make sense at all. So my amendment clauses 49 to 50, 56 to 62 and those in the name of my honourable friend I would... I would urge all members to support them and put their self-interest for extra votes aside.

03:39:26 - 03:39:55

Joseph Ronald Morris

Joy Morris.

Madam Deputy Speaker, I just want to follow up on my hon. friend particularly on 16 and 17-year-olds. Having spent my summer conducting about 80 events across my constituency, meeting with some of the youngest, some of the oldest constituents I represent, and regularly holding, hosting work experience in my office and hosting sixth form surgeries at the schools across my constituency, can I just say that I find more political maturity and wisdom in the sixth form of my average school than I do in the Northumberland County Council Conservative group. More than happily.

03:39:55 - 03:40:08

Christopher John Vince

I thank the hon. gentleman for giving way, and it gives me an opportunity to welcome my two work experience students, Maya and Stacey, to the gallery, and they are, I'm sure, enjoying your speech.

03:40:08 - 03:42:06

Joseph Ronald Morris

Very, very glad to set my hon. friend up for that. I do want to speak particularly, though, about money in politics, and particularly with reference to New Clause 17 and the hon. friend from Oxford East, for whom I have the utmost respect and admiration. It's been clear, not just over the summer, but speaking to voters since I was elected and beforehand, that the influence of money on politics is increasing. It is something that is undermining faith. It is an assault by algorithms on our democracy itself.

This is no longer what was once the kind of, you know, the figures that we see chucked around historically now seem relatively parochial. What we're looking at now is the, is the complete and utter oligarchic, oligarchic takeover of our voting system by those with the very deepest pockets. So I do hope the government can emphasize, and emphasize in her wind-up, just what more can be done and how they're going to work constructively as the bill progresses through the other place, to tighten the, tighten the safeguards that are already in the bill. Because I do sense the amount of disquiet in my inbox from people who do think that there needs to be more done within this bill to guard against the influence of money in our democracy, to guard against particularly the role of international social media, social media platform owners that are poisoning the very lifeblood of democracy itself, and we all see the conspiratorial narratives that are often put into our inboxes. I do also briefly want to touch on New Clause 31, which I know is not in scope, so I won't major on it too much.

But suffice to say that it is those people who are losing faith with politics who feel disenfranchised the most. We do owe it to them to have a national conversation about how we can reform our voting. But I won't go any more into detail on that. I just want to plead again with the minister to, to bring forward again clarity on the pace that we can see in terms of tackling the influence of money in politics, and again further welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to electoral reform earlier this week.

03:42:06 - 03:45:32

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Speaker, it was an absolute privilege to serve on the bill committee for this legislation and prior to that, Speaker's Conference, where many, many of the recommendations by the conference have appeared in the bill. And I am particularly pleased to see the government taking forward the long-held Liberal Democrat policy extending the right to vote for 16 and 17-year-olds. Giving young people a say on the decisions that shape their lives and their futures is long overdue, and I'm glad to see that we get to see it become reality. And I would actually agree with many colleagues who I've spoken with on this, that I see so much awareness when I speak to young people about politics, so much desire to be able to contribute to the political debate and to have agency over their vote and their future. So I'm very pleased to see it come to reality.

And before I focus on some key amendments, I'm very pleased to move NC2 and all of the others in my name. And I want to thank the organizations who've worked with me on the people-focused amendments I have tabled, particularly Centenary Action and Elect Her. So moving to my amendments, I'm, I'm really disappointed that the government has continued to fail to act on the Access to Elected Office Fund or some of the concerns around personal safety that I've sought to raise through a range of amendments to this bill. And on the Access to Elected Office Fund, I really do have to ask the government, what are we waiting for?

Back in June last year, the government announced a working group to develop a new fund. When we debated this issue in committee before recess, we were told that work was ongoing, and when I met the previous minister for this bill, I was again assured that the new fund was being developed. But we're not reinventing the wheel here. An access to elected office fund has existed in England before, and equivalent schemes are operating in both Wales and Scotland right now. Why does England need an entirely new fund rewritten from scratch, one that is taking over a year to create?

We know what this support is for, we know the difference that it can make, and we know that disabled candidates continue to face additional costs simply to participate equally in our democracy. And this bill is precisely the vehicle, Madam Deputy Speaker, to put that right. So rather than another working group, another review, or another reassurance that something will eventually happen in due course, I urge the government to support my amendment NC37 to reinstate the fund in statutory form through this bill. Warm words do not pay for accessible transport, personal assistance, or an interpreter. Disabled candidates need practical support and certainty, and we want our elected representatives to truly be representative of our communities.

And the same frustration applies for me on the issue of personal safety for those who participate in our democracy. We heard before the summer recess in a conversation in this chamber after the tragic murder of Amess, the Home Secretary addressed the issue with great seriousness, and I was very grateful that she assured the house she would consider amendments to this bill with colleagues across government and look at what further action was needed to protect those in our democracy. Sadly, at the moment, I haven't been able to spot those things being delivered in this bill. And it's particularly disappointing that we did not hear more from the minister on this aspect of the bill from the minister in her opening statement. I will give way.

03:45:32 - 03:45:58

Anna Dixon

I thank the honorable lady for giving way and speaking about the security of candidates. That's the motivation behind my own amendment NC81, which would automatically make addresses anonymous for all candidates, and I wondered if she also supported the view that we need to do further steps to ensure that all candidates feel secure and able to stand for public office at all levels.

03:45:58 - 03:48:12

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

I thank my honorable friend, the member for Shipley, for her intervention, and I couldn't agree more. We've seen the difference it has made at local government level where actually councillors' home addresses are no longer in the public domain, and I certainly think it should be the same for candidates. So, turning to my point around candidate safety and those in elected office, that is why I have tabled amendments 1 and NC6 to extend the existing protections beyond the candidates themselves to their staff and their families as well. Threats and intimidation do not stop, sadly, at the candidate. Campaign staff are on the doorstep with us, running our campaign offices often late into the evening, and our families can find that as well can find themselves targeted simply because of the public role that we are choosing to take on.

We must do everything we possibly can to protect candidates and all those who serve in our democracy at every level. And I really want to urge the government, if they are taking these issues seriously, they will both support my amendments but also commit to continually reviewing the threat to candidates, to work with people like the Local Government Association, to listen to the plethora of councillors at every single level from town and parish right up to unitary who are telling terrible stories of death threats, of attacks on their homes.

We have to address these issues because we must ensure that candidates are kept safe, but also our democracy is kept safe. And it is a rapidly changing political environment, and we all have a responsibility to address it. So to close, I really hope that the government and the new cabinet will act on these issues as the bill progresses. And it would be deeply disappointing if this opportunity for change on the access to elected office fund, or something of a different name that does the same thing, were not put into the bill. But I would say to the government, if you will not act in this chamber on these issues, we will continue with our colleagues in the other place, the Liberal Democrat colleagues and others, to ensure that these important protections for equality and safety become a reality.

03:48:12 - 03:48:13

Rushanara Ali.

03:48:13 - 04:06:14

Rushanara Ali

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to begin by congratulating my honourable friend on her appointment as the Minister for Democracy, and for the work that her predecessor has done with the brilliant officials in the department on this very important bill, and of course in putting forward the government amendments. I had the privilege of serving as her predecessor's predecessor in working on the strategy that formed this important bill. This is a significant piece of legislation, and the proposals to bring forward votes at 16 is important and radical and necessary. And it's right that we give young people the right to vote when they can participate in other areas of life.

And when they get the vote, it is absolutely going to be the case that political parties are going to pay much greater attention to their interests. So for those who are opposing this particular change, I'd like to see whether they go and canvas for the votes of 16 and 17-year-olds when they have the vote. We certainly will, because we believe that it is important to encourage participation from an early age. This bill introduces important changes to tackle harassment and intimidation, automated voting, moving towards that, and of course picks up on the important findings from the Rycroft review. This is a significant piece of legislation that has been improving as it's gone through the different stages.

And today marks another opportunity for my honourable friend, the new minister, to take on board some of the suggestions that have been made in the form of the amendments being proposed. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to express my support for new clause 34 standing in the name of my right honourable friend, the member for Hodge Hill, and others, which beefs up our resistance to crypto assets flooding our political system. I'm grateful for the minister's reassurances and the movement in the direction that we want to go in, but it needs to go further, as the chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, my honourable friend, has also pointed out, for the reasons that are well documented. It must include, as it has been said by my honourable friend, the member for Hodge Hill, digital tokens and memecoins accepted into crypto wallets as defined by the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. My right honourable friend has done a huge amount of work showing the analysis, in his analysis, to warn about the dangers of crypto assets being used to drench our democracy with malign messages, fueling populist hate and misinformation.

We're seeing that playing out in our streets, in our communities at the moment.

As his excellent book on populism, I don't think I'm allowed to make a plug for the book, but it's an important point, which is he's outlined 200 million pounds has already been spent in the UK on promoting division and undermining our democracy. That is terrifying. We need to put a stop to it. And that's why this bill needs to go further. Nothing less than a full ban on crypto donations will do.

And I hope that ministers consider doing this now rather than coming back later. I have seen the enormously talented group of civil servants being able to move at pace in amending legislation, being more and more ambitious over time in making this bill much more significant, even from the time I started working on it to the end of the period when the strategy was published and subsequently. So I think where there's a will, there will be a way. And in the interests of moving away from incremental changes that has been committed by this new Prime Minister, I hope that we can get this done in one go. So I appeal to my honorable friend the minister to be bold and get this done now.

Furthermore, I support new clauses 41, 47, 82 and 83 in the name of the honorable member for Milton Keynes Central, which seeks to tackle online harms, online hate in the context of elections and deepfakes, especially videos purporting to depict politicians and candidates. This has become more and more dangerous and serious, Madam Deputy Speaker. In the 2024 election, only a handful of candidates were being subject to AI-driven deepfake images that were already presenting disinformation and causing damage to candidates' elections chances. Now these have become more and more sophisticated and more and more problematic and at worst, damaging and dangerous. And it means that the elector often can't see the distinction between a real image of a candidate and a deepfake-created image of a candidate.

Now don't get me wrong, Madam Deputy Speaker, I have seen some of those and some of them are quite entertaining. The problem is that the ones that are filled with poison and hate can do deep damage to the reputation of candidates, or where they are clearly not the candidate, that is very damaging. And that is moving very, very fast, which means that for the citizen, when they are looking at this material, we're asking a lot of them to be able to make the distinctions between what is real and what is fake in the context of social media that is heavily funded with billions of pounds by tech companies, and ordinary citizens are having to compete with that. That is not feasible. That is why it's really important that we make those changes.

I have said that at the time when I worked on the elections strategy that formed this bill, that was the foundation for this bill, that it was challenging getting DLUHC to do more. So I hope that they can work with my honorable friend in her department to include the changes that are needed in my honorable friend's amendment so that we can get this done in one go rather than waste time while the damage is done at the speed of lightning in the form of deepfake and disinformation spreading and infecting our democracy and forcing candidates and elected representatives out of politics. And Madam Deputy Speaker, increasingly that is how too many members of Parliament or candidates who didn't make it here, or in local government and other areas of public life, are feeling. That actually, is it going to be, how is it going to be in the next election?

As well as trying to keep ourselves safe, how do we protect our reputations when lies are spreading at breakneck speed? What is the point? How do we protect our families when these lies are being spread online? How do we compete with that as candidates? How do we protect our protected characteristics when people of colour, people of minority faiths are particularly targeted?

Women are being subjected to a scale of misogyny and hatred using deepfake and disinformation, female candidates on a scale and a level that I never thought I would see in this lifetime. And for too many of us, Madam Deputy Speaker, if we don't act, too many of us are already feeling like if we knew what we now know when we were considering going into politics all those years ago before the acceleration of this kind of online hate and disinformation that is infecting and destroying our politics and our public sphere and our public life, would we have gone into politics if we knew what we know now? And sadly for far too many people now in local and regional and national politics, particularly women, but not exclusively women, because I've seen male candidates being targeted and harassed, the online hatred spilling over into physical threats and intimidation, threats to their families, threats to their lives, it's out of control. And deepfake and disinformation and the online space, if we don't regulate, if we don't legislate to protect our democracy, protect those who decide, who dare to stand, increasingly it's a matter of daring to stand, Madam Deputy Speaker, then we will regret it. This is the opportunity, this is the time to act now, not leave it till later.

So I hope that my honourable friend will work to make sure that these amendments are included in this stage of the bill. I'm reminded of the words of the late great Terry Pratchett, a lie can run around the world before the truth has got its boots on. That was true a long time before the online world became so prevalent in the negative sense in political discourse, it has become even more so now. This crypto-fuelled AI-driven fakery has real-world consequences as I've pointed out. The Rycroft report calls out foreign interference, both in terms of bribes and bungs to UK politicians and parties and in terms of attempts to sow division and distrust.

We have seen the conviction of a British politician for accepting Russian bribes. Do we seriously think that Nathan Gill was the only British politician that the Russian security services and their proxies managed to turn? In future they'll continue to do that. So we have to continue to act robustly to tackle foreign interference in political finance, which is absolutely critical to this bill. And as we have seen a British Prime Minister, the former British Prime Minister, whose home was firebombed by Russian assets and the Russian-backed tsunami of misinformation surrounding the case smearing the former Prime Minister, my honourable friend the former Prime Minister.

And I would guess that most colleagues here today will have experienced, if not all, intimidation, be that in their homes, on the streets, in their communities as a result of online hate. And it's not just online hate, but the big concern, big problem is online hate is not just about people letting off steam anymore, it plays out in the streets very, very rapidly.

Some of us have experienced it many, many years ago, but this is now widespread and it cannot go on. That's why I support the new clauses which tackle the industrial scale threat from foreign interference, foreign state actors and other hostile actors. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is crucial that we also as part of this look at foreign influencers as well as influencers within the UK who are also seeking to destroy our democracy. We can all, we don't have to spell out the names. We all know who those people are.

They are pouring in billions. They are worth billions. And they think they can dictate how we conduct our democracy, how we function, how our democracy functions. And they are succeeding. That's why we cannot do this incrementally.

We have to be bold. We have to be radical to make sure that these threats that are coming our way, you know, within the space of a year, we've seen the acceleration since this legislation has started to pass through this Parliament, the acceleration of those threats in every direction. So I hope that we can act swiftly in terms of accepting and the government accepting these very important amendments. I'm proud of the fact that the government introduced under the Crime and Policing Act, Policing Act, the amendment that restricts protest outside public office holders' homes. This is really important because what we've seen is too many elected, too many candidates and election officials' homes being targeted by people who are not interested in protesting.

It's not about freedom of speech. It's about sowing terror and fear in the families of candidates, among the families of people who are working in parties, who are officials, who are the decent people who make our democracy function. I have heard too many testimonies of that. I have seen too many colleagues already experience that, the threats, the intimidation outside people's homes, video footage of people's home addresses which then leaves their families exposed and at risk. I am really grateful to the Security Minister, the honorable member for Barnsley North, for working with me to make sure that that amendment was passed, supported by the government and was passed because that will protect candidates and election officials working in parties and for our democracy across parties because it's crucial that we protect people who put themselves forward to ensure that we have a functioning democracy.

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm grateful for the colleagues who've introduced, who've supported new clause 39. I support that clause, not least because I've experienced some of the things they're talking about in the name of the member for Belfast South and Mid Down and the honorable member for Leeds Central and Headingley, which prohibits intimidation at polling stations. This is a serious issue and at its worst, it means that voters find it very difficult to get into polling stations because of the intimidation outside polling stations. In the last general election in my own constituency in some polling stations, the level of hostility towards me when I went outside polling stations to see how things were progressing was off the scale and that is not acceptable, with loud, you know, noisy, mainly men screaming, shouting at me as well as voters trying to get in to vote. That is not acceptable.

We must make sure the existing laws are enforced. They weren't at the time by the police. Vans were chasing us with banners which were full of disinformation and fake slogans and all sorts of things in a way that I never imagined I'd see in our democracy.

That is not on. People should be arrested. And while arrests happened, the onus is on the candidate to then seek prosecution. And then that generates more abuse and more hostility. And also for those who are being harassed, local members and activists, they are too scared to go for prosecution because those people know where they live and they threaten to target them.

So it is on the state to take action to protect the democracy rather than candidates and ordinary citizens who are simply campaigning for democracy, for their party. So we need to look at these issues and ensure that people are protected and they are able to vote safely, securely, without fear, without intimidation. And while it's in certain places, and I do not want people to read that as across the board in my constituency or my borough and so on, and to racialise this because this has happened in places like York, which is very different from my constituency, where election officials were being harassed and intimidated. So please, my plea to colleagues across parties is let's not racialise this, let's not demonise whole communities just because of the bad actions of certain individuals who don't believe in democracy, who want to threaten and intimidate the vast majority of people in a community. Let's not demonise the wider community because of the actions of those people.

Let's make sure they are properly prosecuted and the law, the full force of the law is used to do that and the state is there to make sure that people do not think that they can threaten and intimidate candidates and citizens. So thank you to my honourable friend the new Minister and her predecessor and all those officials and all those who've been working on this Bill. I am really grateful for the work that colleagues have done across the board and particularly those who put forward those amendments. And I very much hope that this work will strengthen our democracy. I know it will.

And we've got to keep a very close eye on this issue because it's too important. Thank you.

04:06:14 - 04:06:16

Shivani Raja

Shivani Raja.

04:06:16 - 04:08:42

Speaker 162

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. At the 2024 general election, just 52% of overseas postal ballots were returned in time to be counted. That is a shocking systemic failure of our democratic process. It means that nearly half of all overseas electors who took the time to register, requested a ballot and tried to exercise their democratic right were effectively disenfranchised by international mail delays. As members of this House, our fundamental duty is to maximise participation in the democratic system we are privileged to represent.

When we look around the world at regimes where the public voice is silenced or undervalued, we must redouble our efforts to prevent a democratic deficit here at home. The amendments tabled by my Conservative colleagues offer practical, common sense fixes to the deficit we see today. They ensure that all British citizens can partake in our great democracy and that this Representation of the People Bill lives up to its name, representing all who belong to our nation in a fair and equal way.

Clause 63 addresses the core logistical bottleneck by permitting in-person voting at designated UK embassies and consulates across the globe. For British citizens who cannot rely on slow, unpredictable international postal transit, this provides a secure and reliable alternative to put their cross in a box on election day. This works hand-in-hand with clause 64, which mandates a comprehensive review into the overseas participation to establish best practices and expand registration. Furthermore, clause 65 introduces another simple improvement, allowing citizens to register on the electoral roll when renewing their British passport. That will dramatically boost engagement among our global community.

Madam Deputy Speaker, having rightly expanded the overseas franchise in recent years, Parliament has a moral obligation to provide the administrative infrastructure that makes that right meaningful. It is deeply regrettable that the government has failed to incorporate these practical solutions into the core text of this bill. But we will continue to champion these measures to ensure that every British citizen, wherever they live, work or serve, can make their voice heard at the ballot box. Thank you.

04:08:42 - 04:08:44

Speaker 159

Stella Creasy.

04:08:44 - 04:11:57

Judith Stella Creasy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I start by paying tribute to the new minister for all the work she's done on the committee on these issues. I know she's going to be a brilliant person in this role. And I also want to pay tribute to everyone who's been part of this bill today, because for all of our ambitions for the things we'd like to change in the world, if the process by which we do it isn't a fair and free one, we can't achieve anything. And we all know and understand that.

Like everybody else, I recognize that new clause 31 is out of scope, but may I add my support and just gently suggest to the shadow minister that there are many versions of proportional representation and electoral reform. For those of us who've nerded out on this for years, we know that. We welcome her to having that conversation, which might be a more illuminating one than whether she's concerned about Zac Goldsmith's leaflets. Can I also add my support to my colleague's amendments about domestic abuse. My colleague, all of my colleagues from East London, many of us, maybe that says something about politics in our part of town.

My colleague's amendments about abuse of candidates. I know well what she's been through and it's a testament to her character that she's here fighting for change. And also to my colleagues from Birmingham on crypto. I don't really understand the technology, but I know it's something that he does and I understand and share his fear accordingly. We come here today and we're doing this bill because we all know that trust is a bygone issue in our politics.

It takes quite something for us in this house to be lectured by IPSA, but we are being lectured. Turkey's being told that Christmas is a good idea. IPSA pointed out to us that only 28% of the public think that MPs care about their local community at all. Two-thirds of your constituents think that you are here out of your own self-interest. And only 4% think you're doing anything good for the country.

So the difficult question we all have to take on the chin is in whose interest do they think we are acting? From today, if we do not take a stand in this bill to tackle the way in which money has infiltrated our politics, the risk is they will think we are acting for our back pockets. We've had a lot of quotes today, so let me bring in William Blake. William Blake said, hindsight is a wonderful thing, but foresight is better. Because we have all seen it.

We know that money is coming in and we know it's something different. But we know enough to know it is a problem. I want to start by recognizing that people giving money to causes that they care about is a noble and honorable thing. We don't have state funding in this country. We do have many ways that we support our politics.

And I recognize and value the contribution that people have made, however big, to that process. The problem is when the cause becomes themselves. And that is the fear that we are seeing echoed across every community in this country. Because we know that the next election will be like one we have never seen before. And that's not just because of the AI deepfakes.

It's because of the amount of money that is now swirling around seeking to determine the outcome of the next election.

04:11:54 - 04:22:19

Speaker 165

This is a relatively new trend. The share of private political donations coming from individuals and countries, companies rather, giving a million pounds or more has surged from just 1% in 2015 to over a third of donations in under a decade. Now that also matches the fact that we have an election spending arms race that we've never seen before. The last election we spent 90 million pounds, the most in modern history, and nearly 80% more than in 2015, which is why I also support my colleagues' call for a reduction in the spending cap. Now, I want to absolutely back all the changes that are being made on overseas donations and the work that Philip Rycroft did.

We can all see the influence of foreign money and activity in our communities. I've seen it in my own constituency where there was targeting of local mosques by Russian agents on Telegram, and we see it in our local social media. But we have to admit that when it comes to money and mega-donors, we have a homegrown problem too. And if we don't deal with this now in this legislation ahead of the next general election, we'll just be playing whack-a-mole as a result. Because the data shows how quickly things are changing for some.

In 2024, the Reform Party had just four donors, sorry 2020, the Reform Party had four donors who made a reportable donation compared to 77 in 2025. A quarter of all their funding comes from people donating more than 100,000 pounds. How quickly that process is happening. This year alone, the Reform Party took 9.9 million pounds, more than the government and opposition parties put together. 8 million pounds of that came from just three people, all of whom have a UK postcode.

So nothing in this bill as it stands will affect that. That's 3 million pounds more from Christopher Harborne to help trigger the Clacton by-election. And there are more of these people with UK passports waiting in the wings. Sir Paul Marshall owns the Spectator and GB News. He has a personal fortune of 875 million pounds and he's previously donated to political leadership campaigns.

At present, he funds what most people might think of as a PAC, the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship, which has been organizing conferences and research events to promote Western and conservative values. It doesn't stop there. Reform again will tell you about Ben Delo, again somebody with a UK citizenship, has a personal fortune of a billion pounds. Now he's already given them 4 million pounds this year alone and has said explicitly that he's moving back from Hong Kong to ensure that he can donate in time for the next general election. It's not just Reform.

We know that Restore has taken half a million pounds in the last 24 hours alone and 2.5 million pounds to set up. But frankly, who are we to judge? Because the honest truth is in every political party, every political party, people are chasing the millionaires. Labour Together donated more than 2.5 million pounds to Labour ahead of the 2024 election, amalgamating millionaire donors. We took money from Quadrature Capital, 4 million pounds, the largest single donation in our party's history.

The opposition party is up to it too. The IT billionaire Bassim Haidar gave more than 700,000 pounds to the Conservatives and has since donated half a million pounds to Reform. That's the same amount they've had from JC Bamford, and then of course there's Jeremy Sun, who is a British video game entrepreneur and gave them 3 million pounds in 2025. If we do not recognize in of itself how distorting these sums are, we are locked into an arms race that frankly none of us want to pay the price to win. And every party will face it.

So yes, I welcome talk of a lower spending limit, but it has to go hand in hand with a cap that covers all of this. Because otherwise it is only retrospective and we know that political parties will simply become prepaid. Obscene wealth is increasingly dictating who is heard, whether we like it or not, what issues are being prioritized and whose interests shape policy decisions. That was the outcome of the Rycroft review. Now the Rycroft review was asked to look at foreign interference, but the arguments it makes about the sums of money do not have a postcode.

The point is about the volume, not the location. The public will not forgive us if we do not recognize that and the impact it's having. Indeed, 84% of them believe that wealthy individuals use political donations to advance their personal interests, and there is widespread public support for a cap on all donations. And frankly, the donations cap the public think of is much lower than anything in new clause 120. Because for the public, indeed for most people, the sums we are talking about are astronomical.

Christopher Harborne's gift of 9 million pounds to Reform in 2025 would take the average person 3,000 years to match, even if they donated all of their savings. At this point I want to talk to my Labour benches and colleagues direct, because I have huge amounts of respect for all of you and the challenges that we are facing with this. I go back to our manifesto. Our manifesto did not specify foreign donations. Our manifesto recognized that all donations were having a distorting effect and therefore needed to be reviewed.

That is why we should welcome the fact that this bill offers a vehicle to do that, and indeed formats for doing that. I know there are those who are implacably opposed. They will not even speak to me about these issues at all. I hope it's not because they are thinking that when their career in Westminster ends, the comfortable world of an expense account and lobbying their mates awaits. There are also those worried, understandably so because in the past this conversation has come up, that it opens a Pandora's box on trade union funding.

One of the cleanest ways we know to fund our politics, and a way of funding I will personally always defend and speak up for. And I know there are others in other political parties who may not have looked at the litany of legislation regulation that already guides trade union legislation. That is why new clause 120 completely exempts trade unions, because they are already well regulated in how they donate, and that is why it is clean money. But there is something fundamental here about why we should be backing these changes in a UK cap for our trade unions. Because the unions are the voice of the people against the interests of capital.

6 million voices will be drowned out by a single daily donation of 6 million pounds if we do not act. That voice, that balance in our political system is at risk if we don't address this distortion. We cannot ignore what impact that could have on our trade union movement and on our ability to ensure that everybody is heard in our political system. Since 1913, the political fund of trade unions has been well regulated. We know what the rules are.

Goodness knows, many of us have spent hours in deathly boring meetings going through them to make sure that they're being upheld.

And we also know the role of trade unions in our political movement is evolving when it comes to funding. But I for one want to make sure that it is heard loudly and clearly because I recognize that our trade unions regularly, because of the law, poll their members about how they want to spend their money. You cannot say the same about the crypto millionaires. I say to those people who claim that addressing this issue will slow this bill down. This issue is already in this bill and the Lords are already here and clear that they can see the damage and the distortion of the money on this house.

So it is going to happen. That debate is going to happen and I hope that our colleagues in the other place will hear those concerns. But I think we will all regret if our union brothers and sisters are blamed for opening the door so that what is out there clawing its way in with its checkbooks into British politics can enter. The Phillips review in 2007 collapsed over this dilemma despite the support from major donors including David Sainsbury for a cap on donations. With hindsight, we can now see that that has opened the door to the crisis that we face.

So we know why the unions give to represent their members' interests. The real question I keep coming back to is why do the millionaires give so much? And perhaps we should take a lesson from that well-known source, President Trump. Because Trump said, "I gave to many people before I became president. Before two months ago I was a businessman.

I gave to everybody. When they call, I give. And you know what, when I need something from them, two years later, three years later, I call them. They are always there for me. That is a broken system."

We are all damned by association if we do not close this loophole. Hindsight is a wonderful thing, foresight is better. I don't often say this but I agree with President Trump. A system that can create those kind of relationships is broken and it damages all who touch it. So we need to act now to protect the next general election.

Nothing less than action before it for a proper cap will do and that is what NC 120 does. It gives a process. Let me reassure you in that process that trade unions can be heard, that non-party campaign organizations like Hope Not Hate can be heard. But it does mean that we can look our constituents in the eye with the difficult choices that we face ahead and say we can be confident we didn't act for cash, we acted for our communities and our country. Surely everybody in this country deserves that confidence in their elected representative.

04:22:19 - 04:27:06

Luke Taylor

And I'll be starting with an immediate five-minute time limit. Luke Taylor.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to speak particularly in favor of new clause 88 from the Liberal Democrats which would require the government to establish a Royal Commission on political donations and campaign expenditure. It would examine the case for a donations cap, review whether existing campaign spending limits remain effective and report back within 12 months. And crucially it would take account of the modern flavors of old challenges because money can now shape political debate through social media platforms, algorithmic amplification, third-party campaigning and political advertising that can reach millions of voters almost immediately. When we knock on our doors in our constituencies or even when they're only our prospective constituencies, we're taking part in the most important act of our democratic system.

We are listening to the concerns of citizens, we are empowering them to test us on our politics, to push us to champion their causes and through taking forward the electorate's concerns we are giving them a voice.

The principle is simple: one citizen, one vote, the basis of a democratic system. If a voter is particularly taken by our arguments, they may choose to donate to us to cover the cost of those snappy little pamphlets we leave behind in our wake, something the Liberal Democrats on these benches are particularly passionate about. And at this point, I'd like to explain something that we did in Sutton to welcome the huge number of Hongkongers who moved to our borough and to my constituency over the last few years. We produced leaflets in local language so that they could read the information about our political party for those who did not have particularly strong English skills. They'd travelled here, they'd escaped the communist regime to take part in a democratic process, escaping the crackdown on those democratic rights that was happening in Hong Kong.

And I would invite an intervention from the benches next to me to explain to me why that communication in a language that was understood by those who hadn't been in our country and did not have the language skills to understand the English leaflets is such a bad thing. And come there is none. When our election laws were written, donations to political parties would have probably been covered by the existing laws. Maybe a big local donor would pay for an advertising board or pay for posters and a loudspeaker on the roof rack of a clapped-out old Volvo, as my dad used to circle his prospective constituents in the 90s. But our citizens still held the levers of power relatively directly.

But today, the spending in our politics and therefore the influence and power of money and donors has shifted so dramatically, the question is about how we rise to the difficulty of constantly having to patch the cracks and the potholes in our outdated election law. And if we fail to answer that question, we condemn the voting public to powerlessness as those with the deepest pockets and strongest influence rip our hands off the wheel of the ship of state. And if we fail to address the modern challenges first posed by those who bankrolled the Brexit campaign, who promised to give back control to the public and then handed it straight to their oligarch friends. So for that reason, I was disappointed the government did not use this bill to introduce a meaningful cap on political donations. Wealthy individuals are increasingly able to spend something that would be completely beyond the reach of ordinary voters, while public confidence in the way politics is funded remains extremely weak.

We see how members of two parties in this chamber have received more than £56,000 through X, a company owned by the very model of a modern fascist oligarch, and with an algorithm that he designs and therefore the payments decided and funnelled directly to those political actors. Now look, there's always going to be those with bigger pockets who can make a larger contribution to political parties and projects than others. The vast majority do so for the right, effectively philanthropic or ideological reasons, and the honourable member for Walthamstow's given a passionate explanation of why political donations through unions with proper controls is absolutely an appropriate way to deliver political support and political power to those groups of people who need that representation the most. But when money has been flowing in from those who would do our country harm and who want to rip control of the state away from the voting public and turn our nation into a Russian-style oligarchy, and where democratic institutions are just shopfronts for a nefarious state captured by the rich and powerful, we cannot stand idly by, and it's why new clause 88 is so important. Thank you.

04:27:06 - 04:29:51

Anne Emily Thornberry

I call Emily Thornberry.

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I applaud the government's ambitions in this bill and the fact that they want to fix politics and they want it to be fair and free from foreign interference. There is much to be enthusiastic about in this bill, but in the five minutes I've been given to speak, I am not able to go through it all.

But this may be the only legislation that we have before the next general election. And I do believe that it is entirely incumbent upon us to prepare ourselves and our constitution for the possibility, God forbid, that a populist party might take control of our country. And we are allowing ourselves to be wide open to all kinds of things. The Foreign Affairs Select Committee did a report into foreign influence across Europe. And we saw a number of very shocking things, and I recommend the report to members if they are in any doubt of the ways in which malign influence, malign actors, either state or non-state, are trying to influence and undermine democracies across Europe.

But if we think that we're free of it because we're on the other side of the channel, we've got another thing coming. We are so complacent. We are so complacent about the things that can happen and have happened and might happen to our country next. We must protect ourselves. We must take this seriously.

There is not enough in this bill to protect us. We must go further. I do not understand why we don't. For example, when it comes to disinformation, disinformation from other countries trying to influence our democracy. Do you know how many ministers we have responsible for disinformation in this country?

We have seven. If we have seven ministers for disinformation, we have no minister for disinformation. But disinformation is the sort of thing that undermines our democracy right now, and it will get worse coming up to the next general election, and there is not enough in this bill to be able to deal with that. But the points that I have put forward in the amendments that I put, I ought to speak in the time I have available just to that. They're supported by the TUC, they're welcomed by Transparency International.

85, a complete ban on overseas voters donating to political parties. I mean, why not? You know, I don't understand why not. RIF says that foreign money is more difficult to trace, it's more difficult to make sure that it's clean. That's why he puts a hundred thousand cap on it.

Well, why don't we go further? We're the politicians, why don't we just ban it? Like, just come to this country, live here, pay your taxes, get involved in our democracy, then you can make donations. If you live somewhere else in a tax haven, tough. You can't.

04:29:51 - 04:30:01

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Yes, of course. Is she suggesting that all 3.5 million overseas electors shouldn't be able to donate to political parties?

04:30:01 - 04:33:05

Anne Emily Thornberry

Yeah, I am. I'm saying, I'm saying that if you live abroad, then there are arguments, why I'm not getting into all of that, whether you can vote, whether you can't. But why, no, no, wait, I need, I've only got two minutes. Come on. So, so just pay your taxes, get involved, and, and this.

Now, 86 is you've got to be a total citizen. So you can't kind of like, it isn't enough to kind of come back to Britain and go, oh well, I'm here now, I'm going to pay a little bit of tax because there are various tax dodges and I can do that. No, no, no. You've got to be here paying your full whack of taxes and then you can make donations to political parties. If you care so much about Britain, if you care so much about our democracy, come and be a full citizen, in my opinion.

And, and I, and I, I mean, I have to say my other two are that in, in, in instead of 84, which is instead of descriptions being allowed on ballot papers, we should simply have, at the moment you can have instead of just like the Labour Party, you can have the Labour Party, the party of equality and fairness. Fair enough. But what you can't have is what has, what, what is happening at the, and happened at the last local elections, was that on the ballot paper, and the Greens did this, they registered with the Electoral Commission parties that were, that were first choice candidate or lead candidate.

So when you had an election with three votes, there was an instruction on the ballot paper as to who it was that you voted for. Now that is an abuse and it should be stopped and that's what that amendment is about. And 87 is about why we why don't why are election why are ballot papers always in alphabetical order? I speak as a T. My constituents had to look very hard to find me, fortunately they did and they did.

But when we used to vote in in alphabetical order, me and the Ts at the far end of the alphabet, there were hardly any of us. It is definitely an advantage to be at the beginning of the alphabet. Why don't we do the Australian system and just randomize it? It seems to me that these things are the ways in which but this is but there is so much more that we could do. And my concern is that although there are rumors that there may be a group that may discuss further how much more that we could do, is there really going to be in the time available enough legislative time to be able to bring forward another bill that will actually be able to deal with so many of the issues that we that we are that we have as problems.

My predecessor 180 years ago was the MP for Finsbury, Thomas Slingsby Duncombe. He brought in the massive Charter petition, which was 3.3 million people wanting to be allowed to vote. There were so many people who'd signed it they had to take the doors off the chamber in order to be able to get all the all the bits of paper through. I presumably didn't go into the into the bag at the behind the chair. But there was that much enthusiasm, that was what democracy was about.

I don't want to be the MP for Finsbury who sits back complacently and allows our democracy to be undermined. We have to fight back.

04:33:05 - 04:38:17

Daniel Danny Rayner Kruger

I call Danny Kruger.

Um, so this bill contains a lot of useful tightening of electoral law, uh, and of course it's a very important debate that we're having here this afternoon. It's very important that we think about how we police donations from abroad and from home. And indeed I I want to pay tribute to the remarks made by the member for Hexham and also by the honorable lady for Bethnal Green about the impact of algorithms, of social media, of deep fakes. There are clearly threats to our democracy from technology which are not being addressed closely in the bill. But let's face it, Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill isn't concerned with those questions.

There is a the point is made, the claim is made that this bill will defend democracy, but actually it's a flagrantly partisan attempt to kneecap Reform UK. And I'm grateful to the honorable lady who spoke just before me, the member for for Islington South and also the honorable lady for Walthamstow, always reliable, who made clear exactly what this bill is about and who it's aimed at. And I'm grateful to her too for pointing out that this bill exempts from any suggestion of a restriction on donations the trade unions, which have given 17 million pounds to the Labour Party in the last five years, 10 million pounds of it at the last election. They're delighted, they welcome it, of course they're happy with that sort of support. So it is a wrong, it is an it's a partisan, a highly partial legislation.

And I just want to put on record my resentment and my outrage on behalf of the people who have generously given to Reform UK, called by the minister malign actors. I wonder who she's referring to. She is talking about individuals, British citizens, who have who have made money, who are choosing to donate their money in support of political causes that they believe in, as is their right. As is their right, I'm not going to no I'm not going to give way no, as is their right to support the political cause in their own country where they are registered to vote, of which they are citizens. Absolutely wrong to traduce them in that way.

So the attempt is or the suggestion is made that this bill will restore trust in politics. And that is exactly what is needed, Madam Deputy Speaker. But what they all mean is to restore trust in the class of politicians and in the political parties that have got us into the mess that we are in. That is what including including I'm afraid including I'm afraid say the party I'm including I'm afraid say the party that I was part of, which is why I left it. We need change.

And I'm glad to say that our democracy is actually working. A new force is arising which is going to put the interests of the British people first, not the class of politicians and parties that have got us into this mess.

So that is what the populist revolt is doing, demonstrating the effectiveness and the vibrancy of our democracy. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me turn to the amendments that I'm supporting because we do have, we do have, we do have a real threat to our, to our democracy. And let me make these points as seriously and as soberly as I can. Our democracy is underwired by a series of principles and practices that were traditionally, historically implicit in the system and therefore didn't need to be stated. They didn't need to be stated, but now they do.

And they need to be stated because over the last couple of generations we have brought into this country millions of people, many of whom do not understand or honor those implicit principles. So let me go through the change that I think need to be made to make explicit formerly implicit principles. The first one is this, that voters belong to this country, that they are citizens of this country with the allegiance and the commitment that that brings. Now there was historically exceptions made for small numbers of Commonwealth citizens and Irish citizens who were in this country. That now needs to change.

The number of Irish citizens is still very low, but there are now two and a half million Commonwealth citizens resident in this country entitled to vote in our elections who are not citizens of the United Kingdom. I feel that is wrong. I think it is time to correct that, that anomaly. The second, no I'm not going to give way. The second implicit principle that we now need to bring to the surface is that we are one country, speaking a common language, taking part in a single election concerning matters about our country.

That means elections materials printed in English and in the other native languages of the British Isles. It is, I'm afraid, this might feel a small thing or a petty one, but it is an important principle. How can we integrate, genuinely, how can we bring our divided country together if we don't do our democracy in the same language? Right, the third principle, quickly, implicit before is that you vote in person. So we now have a quarter of all votes in the last general election being cast by proxy.

That is flagrantly open to flagrant abuse and we will restrict that. And lastly, lastly, the system depends on the principle that you vote individually, on your own. It's a secret choice. Now that principle is not clearly fully understood or honored as we've seen in the abuse of voting in recent elections, so-called family voting. It's already illegal, so we need to ensure...

Order, order. Darren Paffey.

04:38:17 - 04:40:12

Darren James Paffey

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I begin by congratulating the new Minister and wishing her well in her role. I share the confidence of the House that has been expressed in her excellent role as the chair of the Select Committee and I know she will do her best in this role too. Madam Deputy Speaker, this Bill and the amendments that we're discussing today matter because they go to the very heart of something that we all hear on the doorsteps, and that is that people simply do not trust in politics or in many of the people who are in it anymore. Trust and turnout, regrettably, are at a record low.

Now that's not an abstract complaint, that's not just something that would be nicer if we had a bit more of it, that's something which is corrosive to democracy itself. So this Bill is a significant and welcome step forward to do things like give young people a voice, iron out some of the inconsistencies in voter registration and crack down on the money and abuse that too often poison our elections. But in addition, a number of the amendments that are before us today, taken together, are a genuine opportunity to further build, rebuild that trust by making our voting system fairer, getting big money and dodgy money out of politics, and making sure that everyone can safely, confidently, independently, secretly, and you know, who knows, one day enthusiastically be able to cast their vote.

I just want to start with a broader point, Madam Deputy Speaker. I acknowledge and accept that there is a new clause that cannot be named, that is no longer in this, but I do just wish to express my regret that it is not in there. This bill is an opportunity to go as far as possible in restoring that trust. Many of us believe that is now missing. I will give way, yes.

04:40:12 - 04:40:24

Luke Akehurst

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. Would he agree with me that the objective that was in the clause that we're not talking about because it's not in scope...

04:40:24 - 04:40:36

Luke Taylor

The honourable gentleman needs to sit down. Can I just remind members that discussion of an amendment that's not in scope and has not been selected is not in scope. Darren Paffey.

04:40:36 - 04:44:22

Darren James Paffey

My point, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that in addressing as I intend to, amendment 69, 70, 80, 120, 72 and 48, there is a context. And many of us believe that, you know, the world that no longer exists of two-party politics really needs a political system that supports what every other amendment and every other part of this bill is seeking to do. I will address then new clause 80, and there are others similar to this, 69, 70, 120, all about capping donations. Trust in politics is not only about how we vote, it is about who politics works for. That's why I support a number of those amendments, and as has been really eloquently expressed by some of my colleagues, when a small number of individuals can hand over hundreds of thousands, even millions of pounds to a single party, is it any wonder people conclude that politics has a price tag?

A sensible, proportionate cap with an independent review set to the right level is a basic common sense safeguard against undue influence from any direction. Again, it comes back to trust. And the honourable gentleman from the Reform Party makes the point about millions of pounds coming from trade unions. Well, they represent millions of people across this country. That is very different to millions coming from single individuals.

So that is a bit of a fallacious point. But if we're serious about restoring trust, we can't dodge the question of money in politics. That's why I welcome the government's new clause 72, dealing with the flood of money beyond what is reasonable for election costs. And I say this as someone who's never been on the receiving end of those amounts of money, but it's not just out of jealousy. It is about how that money gets to the candidate.

And I would associate myself with the words of my right honourable friend, the member for Islington South and Finsbury, who pointed out the only benefit of crypto is that you can hide. There is simply no reason for it other than that the source can be hidden. Again, corrosion to trust in democracy. Our elections have to be fought, not bought. And to a brief comment on new clause 48 in the name of my honourable friend, the member for Carlisle.

I hope the House or the ministers at least will address this and support it. The right to a secret ballot has existed since 1872, and yet today many, mostly blind and partially sighted voters, still can't cast their vote independently and in secret. So that's a basic democratic gap, I believe.

So minimum accessibility standards for polling stations are long overdue, and I hope that ministers will back that change. In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, none of these measures alone, we know, will fix the trust deficit in our politics. But hopefully the weight, the might of the bill as it stands and so many of the amendments that are being put forward today, a fairer voting system, or lack of it at the moment, a cap on donations and truly accessible elections, they say something important: that this House is serious about a democracy that works for everyone, not just those with the safest seats, not just those with the deepest pockets. So I commend many of these amendments and would ask the minister to accept them.

04:44:22 - 04:49:24

Manuela Perteghella

Manuela Perteghella.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This bill gives us a real chance to defend and strengthen our democracy, and although not in the scope of this bill, I hope the government will look in future legislation to electoral reform and proportional representation. I've tabled new clause 20 and new clause 21 and supported many amendments because I think this bill as it stands does not go far enough. New clause 21 enshrines in the bill the principle of a cap on political donations. It's time to kick big money, foreign or domestic, out of British politics and restore public trust in our political system.

As I said previously, it is the people of this country, not the deep pockets of billionaires, foreign or otherwise, or corporate interests who should decide our country's future in elections and referenda. I welcome the government's amendment on the donations by overseas electors, but at present there is no limit at all on how much a single individual here in the UK can give to a political party. New clause 21 would require the Secretary of State to set an annual cap on political donations informed by an independent review so that he can ensure the cap is sustainable. The bill is titled Representation of the People. New clause 20 would extend the parliamentary franchise, that representation, to qualifying EU citizens and to foreign nationals with the right to enter or remain in the UK, and would extend the local government franchise in England on that same basis.

Having leave to remain does not automatically give someone the right to vote, no matter how long they have been in the UK. And now we have different franchises in relation to EU citizens living in the UK following Brexit. This means that millions of residents have no right to vote at all. I represent a constituency, as many of us do, where people who have lived here for years, who pay their taxes, work in our hospitals and run our businesses, still have no vote in the elections that decide who represents them. Residents pay council tax, but some of them cannot vote on who is going to be in charge of their refuse collection.

As the old American Revolution slogan goes, taxation without representation is tyranny. Voting based on residency rights means that democratic participation is extended fully to all British society. I want to set out where else I think this bill needs to go further, because the argument runs the same way throughout: open up participation and representation, close down improper and malign influence, restore trust in our politics and raise the standards for the campaigns we run. On widening participation and making voting genuinely accessible, I want to see a proper feasibility study into overseas voting, because British citizens abroad still face real practical barriers to casting a ballot.

As the chair of the APPG Citizens' Rights, we heard from British electors living abroad the challenges, the barriers that they face just to exercise their right. Government... Yes. I also want to see government, I mean I support government extending the franchise to 16 and 17 year olds. This is really, really brilliant news for our young people and for representation.

And I welcome the case for automatic registration so that the right to vote does not depend on people navigating forms. On the integrity of political money, which is where I believe this bill still has the furthest to travel, the same logic that drives new clause 21 applies with even more force. The loopholes that currently let donations flow from foreign administrations, from those linked to political violence, from undeclared foreign income, from corporate interests like those of fossil fuel companies, have no place in our politics and I want them closed. I fully support closing the loophole currently exploited by non-permissible donors giving in small amounts and tightening the rules on crypto-asset donations, which are far too easy to hide. Parties should be required to carry out proper due diligence on where donations actually come from, and I support a proper independent look at spending limits.

And finally, on standards and the way we now campaign, candidates deserve proper safety guidance. AI-generated campaign material must be honestly labelled, and I want the Electoral Commission to have real strong powers over online arms and disinformation, along with proper measures against foreign interference. Madam Deputy Speaker, our democracy should be open to everyone who lives under its laws and closed to the money, undue influence and manipulation that nobody voted for.

04:49:24 - 04:53:56

Claire Jodie Gosling

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I start by welcoming the Minister to her new seat. It will be truly brilliant to work with her, and this is a transformational bill to start on. I think it will take British politics through huge strides to restore the trust that has been lost in our political system and protect our democracy from being sold off for profit. I personally have set up and host an inspiring youth parliament, and hearing the voice of 16 year olds and under is truly humbling experience, and to hear their dedication and education is always an awe-inspiring experience. The amendments I have tabled in this bill I had hoped would improve it even further and to return integrity in British politics.

And I am reassured that the government is seeking other ways to strengthen our democracy and transparency. I would like to pay tribute to my honourable friend the member for Ellesmere Port and Bromborough, sorry, and Bromborough, and congratulate him on his promotion and thank him for the work that he has done bringing these amendments forward, as too to my other colleagues who have brought forward very valuable amendments today, especially what the member for Walthamstow, Islington South and Finsbury and Milton Keynes. Our election law was written in an analogue age and has not kept pace with the legislation which dictates how safe or unsafe it is. Modern campaigns now reach voters in the palms of their hand 24/7. Election campaigns with highly targeted content delivered direct in social media feeds, distributing at speed, and some of it only seen by the members it is designed to influence.

Legislation rightly restricts commercial advertisers from making false claims about shampoo, broadband deals, financial products, sausages. Food producers face a wealth of legislation to restrict what they are allowed to say about their products and make sure it is rightly factually accurate. Porkie sausages cannot tell porky pies, pie manufacturers cannot tell lies.

It is ridiculous that our political adverts hold no such restrictions. The present, this presents a serious risk to our democracy and undermines any attempts to improve our integrity and trust in our political system. When AI-generated campaigns, which look so convincing, look... ...produce misinformation spread at scale and speed, while elections are increasingly being based on wafer-thin margins with more and more candidates on the election papers. In elections that close and with increased budgets of 80% in 2023, misleading electoral advertising can make a real material difference to our politics and to our futures.

New clauses 49 and 51 in my name present practical solutions to this issue. They deal with the narrow, clearly defined categories of factual claims in paid materials. Crucially, they do not regulate political opinion, argument, satire, pledges, speeches, interviews or ordinary democratic debate. They simply apply to statements of fact that can be tested against data. And this distinction matters if we wish to restore faith in our politics.

Any reasonable person would agree that voters must have accurate information to build their opinions on. Research by Opinium found that 76% of residents agree, sorry, of people agree, alongside a backing from this House. I also bring forward new clause 52, which again builds on the excellent work of my colleagues to strengthen a code of conduct into a statutory footing and make sure that harassment, intimidation and standards are on a statutory footing to ensure that people have the right and the safety to stand for election and represent their views. I accept this government's decision on these issues and look forward to further debate, but do wish that this government would push some of the other amendments been mentioned today to make sure this bill achieves the enormous potential it creates and to make sure that our democracy is protected in the future. Thank you.

04:53:56 - 04:58:51

Brendan O'Hara

Brendan O'Hara.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. During the second reading of this bill back in March, I said that we generally welcomed its introduction, particularly extending the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds, and we in these benches still do. And evidence is always helpful, and unfortunately the honourable member for Taten is no longer in her place, but Scotland has had this in place for 12 years and it has been an unqualified success and no serious person is planning to backtrack on it. That said, we do still have serious concerns about the bill, because what's currently on offer is a far cry from what the Labour party promised at the passing of the 2022 Elections Act. Because back then, we all recognized that that 2022 Act was an appalling piece of legislation.

It was nakedly partisan and quite rightly, when opposing it, the Labour party promised to shred that legislation, and I fear now in power they've chosen to tinker rather than shred. And I think we can see for ourselves the levels of frustration that exist on the benches opposite, because they know this was an opportunity to undo great democratic harms that were caused by that 2022 Act, and an opportunity to introduce an entirely new system, one that would have fairness, equality, transparency and accountability at its heart. And I fear that the bill as it currently stands squanders that opportunity.

And I think the clearest manifestation of that frustration is the number of proposed amendments that the bill has and which have originated from the government's own backbenches. There are scores of amendments, 215 pages worth of amendments. And I want to highlight a few which I believe would have significantly improved the bill had the government taken them on board. New clause 34 from the member from Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North to tighten up crypto cryptocurrency. He explained earlier on in an intervention that the government's position as in the bill does not go nearly far enough and we agree.

The right honourable member for Hayes and Harlington's new clause 35 would extend the franchise to those with indefinite leave to remain. Such a system has been in place in Scotland for over six years and it works very well and has been entirely uncontroversial. The honourable member for Leeds East in new clause 54 proposed new rules around declaration of gifts or benefits worth over 5,000 pounds in a year before in the year before someone can be nominated as a candidate. It's an eminently sensible proposal and I can't see why the government would not take it on board. New clause 58 from the honourable member from Poplar and Limehouse over domestic abuse added to the list of schedule nine offences.

Again, I can see no reason why the government would not adopt that into the bill. And as we've heard, there are multiple amendments on cleaning up the amount of dirty money circulating around UK politics, about curtailing foreign donations and examining how the reins can be pulled in on campaign spending. And I applaud the member for Leeds Central in his new clause 69, the honourable member for Oxford East new clause 70 and the right honourable member for Islington South and Finsbury with new clauses 85 and 86 and the member from Walthamstow for new clause 20. Every single one of these amendments, Madam Deputy Speaker, and many, many others in the order paper would have made this bill significantly better. And it is hugely disappointing that the government have chosen not to take on more of them.

And may I say purely in passing, Madam Deputy Speaker, I just wish that on that order paper there had been a vote on proportional representation to bring this parliament into line with every other parliament on these islands. Madam Deputy Speaker, of course, of course we will support this bill. But I cannot help but feel this has been something of a missed opportunity, an opportunity to right a great wrong. And I'm sure I wasn't alone in hoping that the new Prime Minister and his team when they when this was pulled before recess would take an opportunity to look at those amendments, many of which originated from his own backbenches and thereby adopt and make this legislation far more radical, far more ambitious and much, much more democratic. And I sincerely hope that this isn't a signal that the great radical reformer is becoming yet another timid conservative.

04:58:51 - 04:58:52

Chris Curtis.

04:58:52 - 05:03:54

Chris Curtis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Before I turn to the substance of the bill, may I take a moment to put on record how much I enjoyed serving on the select committee under the chairmanship of my honourable friends, the member for Vauxhall and Campbell Green. And I'm proud of the work we did together on that committee, including on tackling rough sleeping and confronting Britain's housing crisis and I know she will take that into her work in the government as she takes on her new role. Now, I'll turn to clause 56 standing in my name on the implementation of voter registration, automatic voter registration, hopefully slightly less controversial than some of the other topics we've covered today and also something I'm hoping the minister will support given it was in her name until just a few weeks ago.

Fundamentally, if we want high participation in our elections, we should make it as frictionless and easy as possible for eligible citizens to take part. We know that participation is too low, turnout at the 2024 general election was a bit under 60%, the lowest since 2001. But that figure still doesn't tell us the whole story, because the published turnout figure is the percentage of registered voters who go out to vote in the election. It excludes the estimated, according to the Electoral Commission, 8 million people across the country who are eligible to vote but do not go out to vote because they're not on the electoral register. Could be because they're registered incorrectly, they've moved home, or they didn't get around to registering.

Meanwhile, research from the University of Manchester showed us that we make it harder to register to vote here in the UK than almost any other democracy. And this problem isn't evenly distributed across our constituencies or across demographics. Young people, private renters, disabled people, and those who are more transient are all less likely to be registered to vote. For too long, we've operated a slightly absurd system where the British state can know where you live, it can know your age, your demographics, it can know whether you're eligible to vote, and yet you still have to fill out a separate form in order to be registered to vote. This bill creates a new process through which electoral registration officers can register eligible voters without requiring them to make that separate application, once the necessary commitments are met.

It allows existing registrations to be updated without requiring somebody to submit a fresh application, and it creates data sharing and piloting framework needed to move towards a genuinely modern system of electoral registration. This is all a brilliant thing that really moves automatic voter registration in the right direction. The purpose of this clause is simply to make sure that we now turn that legislative framework into a reality. At the moment, the bill gives us the architecture for automatic registration, what it does not yet give us is a clear public timetable for when the different parts of that architecture will actually be implemented, and it would be good to hear from the minister something on that timetable in her closing remarks today. I think we should have a clear pathway to delivering substantial change within this parliament, something that the Electoral Commission says is possible, and new clause 56 asks just for that.

Within two months of the new clause coming to force, the government would have to publish a plan setting out the steps needed to implement registration without an application, the dates by which those steps would be completed, when it expects regulations for the registration pilots to be laid before parliament, and how many additional people it expects to be registered by the 15th of August 2029 as a result of implementing part 2. And I would just make one very quick point on the pilots of this, because I mentioned this at second reading and I still think it's something that we need a response to. There is a fear when you're piloting projects to do with automatic voter registration that if you're piloting them on local authority boundaries, as you would because they're responsible for voter registration, you may have a constituency, Vauxhall and Camberwell Green being a perfect example given it's in both Lambeth and Southwark, where part of your constituency stands under the new scheme that is being piloted and part of it does not stand under that scheme, and that can create a problem if part of one party's votes comes from a system where that registration has gone up and another part doesn't. So can we please get a commitment from the government or from the Electoral Commission that when they're running these pilots they're going to consider that, and preferably not run them in places where those constituency boundaries don't line up.

Finally, I'll just say I completely understand the government's argument that reform cannot happen overnight and we need to do this securely, accurately and carefully, especially when it comes to ensuring that only those who are eligible to vote go out and vote. The government has made the right decision to put legislative framework in place for automatic and direct voter registration in this bill, we just need to know when it's going to be implemented. Thank you.

05:03:54 - 05:03:55

Dr. Ellie Chowns.

05:03:55 - 05:06:01

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to speak to amendment 15 and new clause 30 tabled in my name and clauses tabled by other colleagues across the House too. But first of all, I'd like to welcome the new minister to her place and I welcome this bill. I always like to start with where there is common ground and it's certainly true that there are steps forward in this bill. Implementation of the Rycroft recommendations to tackle foreign influence in our politics, movements towards automatic voter registration, dealing with crypto to some extent but not enough, these are all positive steps forward.

And of course, I warmly welcome the introduction of votes at 16, a long-standing Green Party policy too. But there is a big but, I'm afraid, Minister, because this bill could and really should do far, far more to clean up our politics. There are three big things that we need to do. We need to get rid of the influence of dirty and big money in our politics. We need to eliminate the poison of disinformation in our politics and we need to fix the fundamental structures of our politics that disenfranchise so many people.

And so I'm afraid it is frankly ridiculous that in a bill about elections called the Representation of the People Bill, we are not even allowed to discuss new clause 31 about a national commission on electoral reform. This is fundamentally important to our politics. The fundamental principle of democracy is that everybody's vote must count equally. Now, of course, the government doesn't need to legislate on a national commission on electoral reform, the government could kickstart one anyway. And so I really hope that the minister will take that back to the Prime Minister, who after all is supposedly a supporter of electoral reform, and strongly encourage him to put his action where his mouth is on this issue and demonstrate that if he's serious about problem solving, then he needs to work to solve the problems in our democracy.

05:06:01 - 05:06:10

Luke Taylor

Order, please, please take a seat. Will the honourable member please remember to speak into scope of what's in front of us at the moment? Dr. Ellie Chowns.

05:06:10 - 05:06:18

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was speaking to the title of the bill.

05:06:18 - 05:06:25

Luke Taylor

Please take my comments as said and stick to the scope of the bill. Dr. Ellie Chowns.

05:06:25 - 05:09:04

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So to move on to my amendments. Amendment 15 seeks to ban all corporate donations. Donations from companies, as they do in fact in France and Canada as many other countries. Research by Centax has found that around a quarter of donor companies are so opaque it's not possible to identify who controls them and almost one pound in every ten given by companies comes indirectly from people who could not donate themselves.

This is a loophole in our politics. The bill already accepts that a company has no independent right to donate as it depends on the individuals who own it being in the electoral register, so it makes sense to complete the step and ban corporate donations altogether. And if the House isn't willing to go as far as a ban, it can still strengthen the bill by strengthening clause 60. I've also tabled new clause 30 for a review on how limits on campaign expenditure could apply on an annual basis. Again, this is a huge loophole.

We recognize that money skews politics, that's why there are spending limits during the short campaign.

But we know that politics doesn't just happen in that short period before an election. Politics happens year-round, and especially now that the online world is such a big part of our politics. So long gone are the days where elections were only fought in those short weeks. Political campaigning happens year-round, not just on doorsteps but also online, and so it is imperative to put limits on annual campaign expenditure to prevent our politics being skewed out of all proportion by big money. And this is also why I support the amendment tabled by the new clause 70 tabled by the honourable member for Oxford East to lower limits for campaign spending altogether.

Moving on to other amendments tabled by honourable members. New clause 120 from the honourable member for Walthamstow. She makes a very clear case for this. We have to have a cap on all donations. Big money's been allowed to skew our politics for far too long.

I'd like to see it much lower, perhaps fifty thousand pounds per year. That's the position supported by the majority of the British people, but any move in this direction is an improvement. And frankly, some donations simply shouldn't be allowed. I welcome new clause 22 from the honourable member for Leeds East. There's no place for fossil fuels in a sustainable future and no place for dirty fossil money in our politics.

The amendments tabled by the honourable member for Milton Keynes, particularly amendment 43 on a repository for political advertising, absolutely crucial. And we have to guard away against the way that AI is being used to fuel disinformation. We have to get big money out of politics, get disinformation poison out of politics, and fix our political system once and for all.

05:09:05 - 05:10:45

Alex Sobel

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As chair of the Fair Elections APPG, the largest APPG in Parliament, I'm delighted to welcome this bill, a significant cultural shift for our democracy and a generational step towards a fairer politics. I also welcome the minister to a place of trusted friend and ally on fair elections. The APPG's loss is certainly the government's gain. It is fitting that the Representation of the People Bill is the new government's first piece of legislation to bring to the House.

The Prime Minister's long-standing commitment to free and fair elections, support of young people, and commitment to clean up politics is well known. I look forward to this being the first of many steps the Prime Minister will take to make our politics fit for the future and reflective of the United Kingdom we live in today. The Labour Party is the party of change: system change, culture change, democratic change. I'm proud to be part of a party that has always fought to strengthen our democracy. We must now do that for a new generation by facing up to the triple threat of disinformation, dark money, and a failing electoral system posed to our politics.

Westminster is unfortunately becoming dangerously outdated. A five-party electorate can no longer be represented by a two-party system. Business as usual and high voter turnout is changing everything. I am sad that my amendment NC31 has been ruled out of scope today. I am delighted that so many members... I'll give way to my honourable friend.

05:10:45 - 05:10:55

Luke Akehurst

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. Would he agree with me and with the honourable lady opposite that it doesn't actually require legislation for the government to set up a commission to look at electoral systems?

05:10:55 - 05:13:36

Alex Sobel

Without wanting to anger the Deputy Speaker, who I've served with not just here but in other democratic fora, he is absolutely right, and really the amendment now shows the level of support in this House. So I think it just reflects how many members here support change, but I understand exactly that it's not in the scope of this bill today. But I just also trust our Prime Minister, who has long been supportive on this issue. So I'll now talk about my second amendment, new clause 69, which is a one million pound cap on individual donors in a single calendar year.

This very, I would actually say timid amendment is a safeguard to prevent the ultra-wealthy from thinking they can come and buy our elections wholesale. As per the Rycroft review, an excellent review that I was absolutely delighted to contribute to, we cannot have election-distorting behavior by the ultra-rich, such as 12 million pounds worth of donations from one person in 2025 to Reform UK. Ten years ago, 1% of political donations came from millionaires. Today, it's more than a third. Our politics is being bought in front of our eyes.

A third of political donations come from individuals. What's free and fair about that? I welcome spending limits and foreign donor regulation. There is much to celebrate in this bill about cracking down on dark money in our politics. But the risk of inaction is too great.

We are approaching a dangerous tipping point in our politics. Decades ago, parties used to need close to 50% of the vote to win a majority. This has fallen steadily to low 34%. So it's becoming easier and easier to buy that influence, utilizing that money to buy into the system, to influence those results. I know the Prime Minister is committed to safeguarding our electoral system, and I and all the MPs who signed these amendments want to work with him to set the UK on a road towards free, fair, and modern general elections.

So let's represent the people freely and fairly. Let's make votes matter. We must ensure power is transferred back to a reformed Parliament and then passed into every part of these islands, rewiring our whole system. Thank you.

05:13:36 - 05:13:38

Eleanor Laing

Freddie van Mierlo.

05:13:38 - 05:16:54

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to speak to new clause 19 tabled in my name concerning overseas voters. The new clause would require the Secretary of State to conduct feasibility studies on improving voting arrangements. New clause 19 has over 50 signatures from members across the House, including many of my Liberal Democrat colleagues, but also Conservatives, Greens, Independents, demonstrating a clear call for change. It also briefly had a Labour member supporting it before the government whips presumably intervened.

We are demanding change on behalf of the 3.5 million overseas voters, including our armed forces stationed abroad. Postal ballots all too often arrive too late for them to be returned back to the UK in time. The postal ballot return rate was just 48% in the last general election. Proxies, a potential solution, are problematic to arrange if you have no longer contacts where you previously resided. The UK is lagging on the international stage.

In France, voting is allowed at overseas embassies. In the Netherlands, constituents can print their own secure ballot, as I have actually previously done. Estonia permits the use of electronic voting, and New Zealand's voters can download and return ballot papers online. Any change to our voting arrangements would of course need to be secure and adapted to the UK context. But if other countries can improve their participation of overseas electors, so can we.

However, the government has so far refused to act. In a recent meeting with the former Minister for Democracy, I was disappointed by the lack of ambition. I was told it is not possible to make printing of ballots secure. Yet other European and Commonwealth countries do it. So I ask the Minister, what is so unique about either the UK electoral system or the British state that means we are either incapable or incompetent to enfranchise our own overseas voters?

The minister's response, if there is one, will refer to some minor changes made to the timeline for registering to postal votes and the mailing of ballots, but this will not be enough. Half of all overseas voters were registered before the last election and still suffered from delayed ballots, so we know already changes proposed will not be effective. One voter got in touch with Liberal Democrats in Europe to share her story. Angela, a voter in Oldham living in France, was registered to vote before the election. She received her ballot in the post the day after polling day.

If this is the experience of France, what hope is there for Australia? I wonder now if under the new leadership, the previous Prime Minister's incrementalism can be dropped in favor of a solution that meets the size of the problem. As we've heard, Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill has interest across the house and not all amendments will be voted on. But I do hope this new clause or similar will be pursued in the Lords and in the spirit of cross-party cooperation expressed by the Prime Minister get a fair hearing.

05:16:54 - 05:21:33

Richard Burgon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'd like to speak to my own amendment, new clause 22, to stop oil and gas companies from donating to political parties. The context. The extreme heat, the tens of thousands of heat-related deaths in Europe alone this summer, the dangerous wildfires, the droughts. All of these things give us a terrifying glimpse of what climate breakdown means.

And they underline just how dangerous it is to deny climate breakdown or delay the action needed to tackle it. The reality is that climate breakdown will shape our country for decades. It will affect food prices. It will affect whether people can live and work safely, and it will impact the functioning of key public services as well as our economic and national security. We must do all we can to tackle climate change and protect people from its increasingly severe impacts.

But if we are to have a fighting chance of preventing the worst of it, we need to rapidly cut fossil fuel use. And that will mean breaking the vast power that oil and gas companies have in our politics. And that's where my new clause 22 comes in. Fossil fuel giants have not only driven us towards climate disaster, they did so knowing of the consequences. They did their best to cover up the science and they used their vast wealth and power to distract and delay action.

They did so in order to keep raking in obscene levels of profits. Profits that have soared even higher in recent years while people have been hit with horrendously high bills. The principle of my amendment is clear. Those profiting from and helping to drive this crisis should not be using their wealth to pollute our politics, to spread misinformation, to delay the action needed. So my amendment would stop and put a stop to any donations from oil and gas companies to political parties and candidates at elections.

Now, of course, the problem goes way beyond direct donations, but my amendment can be part of the action needed to break the link between fossil fuel wealth and the influence it seeks to exert on our politics.

For example, research by the environmental investigations group DeSmog and the Guardian found that when the previous Conservative government was considering new North Sea fossil fuel licenses, the Conservative Party received more than 400,000 pounds in one year alone in donations from individuals and companies linked to the oil and gas industries. That was part of what DeSmog estimated was over 2 million pounds donated to the Conservative Party by fossil fuel interests between the 2019 and 2024 general elections, and DeSmog research has also highlighted what it describes as Reform links to oil and gas interests. But beyond party donations, there's a complex web of fossil fuel interests, climate deniers, donors, so-called think tanks, and other organizations seeking to shape our politics. And no doubt they were delighted with the Conservative Party's shift against climate action in recent years. And those interests, as we've seen, have had huge success in shaping US politics.

We need to avoid that scale of influence ever happening here. So to conclude, for decades, oil and gas money across the globe has sought to buy influence to help delay the action we desperately need. My amendment is one step towards ending that, and I want to thank the cross-party group of MPs who've backed it. I hope that we can continue to work together to stop fossil fuel money polluting our politics. The decisions we take on climate action should be driven by the public interest, not fossil fuel interest.

05:21:33 - 05:26:40

Catrin Emily Darlington

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And in the five minutes you've allotted me, I will try and speak to my new clauses 41 through 47, the clause 82 and 83 that are now in my name on behalf of my right honorable friend the Education Secretary, and clause 82, which I'm also tabling in my name on behalf of my honorable friend who is now the Minister at the Home Office. I want to thank the previous ministers from Bethnal Green and Stepney and from Chester North and Neston for their constant engagement on this with me over the past year and a bit, as well as the Online Safety Minister. And I want to welcome the new minister to her place. She is a fantastic appointment.

I also want to thank the Electoral Commission, Philip Rycroft, members of the Online Safety Network, in particular Demos, Adobe, and British broadcasters, and colleagues from across this House for working with me to lay these crucial amendments. Our democracy is under attack by foreign actors that want to destabilize our country and individuals in our own country that want to create chaos and division. They use the online space to create and spread disinformation, create deepfakes, use algorithms to amplify bots pretending to be British citizens. These distort the debate and negate the facts and take our right to free choice in a free election away. AI-generated material can be fun, like cats riding on dolphins, but can also be destructive.

A network of 73 TikTok accounts that pretend to be authentic news organizations suddenly sprang up in March 2025. They have nearly a million users who are followers and have published thousands of deepfakes of government ministers supposedly announcing controversial policies using real BBC footage. In the first week of December 2025 alone, they had nearly a million viewers.

It translates to the doorstep. I spoke to a voter in December 2025 that was convinced the then Prime Minister was imposing a Christmas tax because she saw a video of him announcing it. These accounts have just made it, made us less sure of who and what we can trust. And when it happens, you still vote and make a choice, but the ground beneath your judgment shifts. Therefore, NC47 would ensure all material that is AI-generated is clearly labeled.

Doesn't stop any party or candidate from creating crowds at their speeches or wearing a superhero outfit to leap Elizabeth Tower, but it would bring transparency to the public. And as often has been said, democracy does not require us to agree, but it does require us to live in the same reality. Therefore, NC82 would create a liability for false statements and NC41 will ensure that the law offline is applied online, mainly section 106 and 114A from the Representation of the People's Act 1983. These needs to be made priority offenses under the Online Safety Act. And I want to thank my honorable friend, the Minister for Online Safety, for his engagement so that we can work together to make sure this happens and ensure Ofcom understand the importance of respecting, protecting democracy.

And the algorithms are powerful because they don't look dramatic. It looks ordinary. It's just content in our feed. No single message changes our mind, but scale does, volume does, emotion does, the cumulative effect does. And online social media bosses can use their control of algorithms to promote their political views without reporting to the public, which is why I've laid NC42.

I will skip the NC44 giving the Electoral Commission, just wanted to raise particularly NC43 that requires a repository for political advertising so any voter can see what a party is advertising in different parts of the country and on different platforms. And it also ensures that all political advertising and the money spent can be audited and properly declared. Finally, everyone in this House knows that the harmful activity is not limited to election periods. It is happening all the time and spreading disinformation or nudifying or humiliating female candidates and politicians. NC46 and NC83, which looks to introduce the broadcast code to online platforms, would deal with this.

And finally, in the my last seconds, I just wanted to say that we need a, we need an emergency election protocol that is appropriate, transparent and holds public confidence, and that's what NC45 is about. None of my amendments have been selected for decision, so they will be relaid in the Lords. I want to thank the Minister, Minister for Online Safety, Number 10 and the Secretary of State for their engagement with me. Working together, I am sure that we can find a way to protect our democracy.

05:26:40 - 05:31:44

Dominic Liam Byrne

I thank very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me start with a word of thanks to the honorable member for Chester, who's not in her place. She said quite rightly that an awful lot has changed since this bill was first introduced to this House, and indeed a lot has been revealed over the course of this summer. In fact, the reporting in the Times, the Sunday Times, the Financial Times, the Guardian and Byline Times has now revealed 37 different questions around the finances of the Reform Party. And no doubt we will find, Madam Deputy Speaker, that there's been an innocent explanation for all of it.

No doubt there is an innocent explanation for why Mr. George Cottrell passed two million dollars through US-based crypto exchanges just a day or two before he moved the money to his mother, and she then went to make big donations to Reform. No doubt we will learn that Mr. Cottrell was in fact on the electoral register when that money was passed.

No doubt we will discover that his mother Fiona Cottrell declared and did not disguise the fact that the money had ultimately come from her son. No doubt there will be an innocent explanation for why loans to Reform through Britain Means Business were reclassified as donations even though the party treasurer wasn't told about that. No doubt there will be an innocent explanation for why the honorable member for Clacton, who is surprise surprise not in his place, did not declare a five million pound donation before he was elected to this place and went off to lobby the Governor of the Bank of England on behalf of his cryptocurrency allies. No doubt it is a complete coincidence that the man who has given Reform half of its fortune, over twenty-five million pounds, made his fortune in the crypto industry. No doubt there is an innocent explanation for all of this and I very much hope that absolutely no offenses have been committed.

No doubt, no doubt, no doubt there is an innocent explanation for all of it and no doubt to the British public it will stink to high heaven. I very much hope that all of this has been above the law, but that is not the test for political finance regulation in this country. It is not enough to be above the law, you have got to be above suspicion and right now the conduct of political finance in this country is not above suspicion and that is why the measures in this bill are needed and that is why it would be madness if we do not use this bill to eliminate once and for all not just cryptocurrency donations but the cryptocurrency system from British politics. Now I welcome the moves that the minister has made, I very much welcome the commitment that she has made at the dispatch box this afternoon to continue to listen to this debate and ensure that the rules are as tight as possible in this bill. But the kind of revelations that we have seen in the newspapers over the summer underline why we have got to be as hard as possible and as tough as possible.

And the truth is right now the amendments that the government have brought forward to the bill are full of holes. It would still be possible under the rules on the table today to move money through digital tokens. It would still be possible to move money through meme coins like the Dollar Britain token. It would still be possible to aggregate it, to convert it into conventional currency and then to donate it, for example, to Restore Britain. And we know that this is not some speculative feature of the system.

We know that donations that have gone to Reform have been routed through cryptocurrency exchanges like Radon. Now I've got nothing against Radon, they are clearly wholly committed to transparency, which is why they have moved their domicile from Poland to that beacon of transparency, the Cook Islands. So with risks like this multiplying, why on earth, why on earth would we leave loopholes open? So the effect of new clause thirty-four would ban on-ramping, off-ramping, it would ban new forms of digital currency transactions, it would ban meme coins and these are exactly the kind of measures that I think ministers now need to bring forward because if we want to take out the crypto system from political finance then this is what we need to do. The final point, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I want to make is a larger hole in the bill which I hope we will square up to over the course of this debate.

There are now members of this House who are making more out of ad share revenue than they are from their salary. And if Elon Musk decided to write a check to a political party under the terms of this bill it would be outlawed. If he decided to retweet something and generate tens of thousands of pounds in ad share revenue then it would be allowed. We've got to recognize that over the last five years two hundred million pounds has been assembled to build a media political complex on behalf of a party that thinks that there is a problem with foreigners but there is not a problem with foreign money. And frankly it is time that we eliminated that kind of politics, that kind of argument, that kind of system from our country.

05:31:44 - 05:36:19

Edward Joseph Powell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I join the others in warmly welcoming the democracy minister to her place. I know the select committee will miss her excellent chairing, but it's great to have such a strong ally on these issues in government. We've returned to this place after a summer when barely a day has gone by without another political funding scandal on the front pages. As the previous speaker referred to, accusations of impermissible foreign donations, undeclared donations, undeclared gifts, conflict of interest, undeclared assets, foreign interference, and more. So I doubt anyone in this house could say with confidence that we currently have the right safeguards in place to ensure that dodgy money is kept out of our politics and that sufficient transparency is in place so the public can judge whether a politician is acting in their interests or in the interests of foreign-based billionaires.

And that's why this bill is so important and why so many of the measures in it are welcome. And I'm delighted that following the Rycroft review, there are strong amendments to strengthen the bill, the cap on donations from overseas electors and this new residency test to close that potential loophole of people coming back to meddle in our politics. The moratorium on crypto, ensuring companies can only donate up to the value of their post-tax profits, and the swift recent action we've seen to look at lower caps on how much parties and candidates can spend during regulated periods. These are all really welcome steps that will help limit the influence of big money and curb foreign influence. We have to be alive, though, to the constantly evolving nature of this threat and to make sure that our electoral traditions are not open to abuse.

And in that spirit, just a couple of suggestions. I do hope in the Electoral Commission's review of spending limits, per the government amendment, they could also be asked to look at whether the whole concept of the long and short campaign is working to keep spending in check. Candidates have already been selected by parties for the next general election, and many more will be in place by the end of this year. But the long campaign regulated period does not kick in till February 4th, 2029. That means in many cases more than two years of further uncapped spending with declaration of interest rules only formally in place for the year before an MP is elected and nothing for candidates who do not win.

This is really important because we know the reality of modern politics is campaigning never switches off. I'm really glad in this country we've avoided the money pit of TV advertising that the United States has. But social media does mean that vast sums of hard-to-trace money can be spent promoting a candidate or a party outside of these regulated periods. So I'm fully supportive of the government's intention to bring down the spending cap, and I think a thorough look at these regulated periods would help deliver that goal and make sure that capping spending works permanently, not just in those limited periods. I'm also glad that the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State and the Minister have been clear that this bill is the start of a political reform agenda and not the end.

Unfortunately, many of these big money interests and foreign states with malign intent are very good at finding loopholes and working around our laws, and they will continue to do that and adapt once these new laws are in force. So to avoid that risk, I think the Electoral Commission could also look at donation levels, currently uncapped, to ensure a further check on big money interests.

I welcome the Democracy Minister's positive engagement on this topic, and I hope there may be a way to use this bill to review this issue and build consensus while ensuring we don't have to wait for a further legislative route in this Parliament, which we all know would be challenging. And in that spirit, of course, we don't need legislation to talk about the National Commission, we could do that immediately. So Madam Deputy Speaker, I hope this bill, as I said, is the start of a political reform effort of the new administration and not the end. We all know the context: the plummeting trust, the big money influence, the fact that many of our voters feel that their politicians are not serving them, but they're serving other interests. I know that this Minister is absolutely committed to going as far as possible.

This bill is in really good shape and it's been strengthened, and I hope at the dispatch box in summing up, we might hear some of the next steps just to take it that little bit further. Thank you.

05:36:19 - 05:36:21

Eleanor Laing

Jim Allister.

05:36:21 - 05:40:13

Jim Allister

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you for your indulgence. I was absent from the House for some time to attend a delegated legislation committee. Speaking in this debate is a privilege because it is the ultimate manifestation of being involved in our democratic process. The policy document that goes with this bill says this: "The right to participate in our democracy is a defining aspect of our national identity." A defining aspect of our national identity.

Of course, what that speaks to is equal citizenship: that every citizen, no matter from where, who's on the electoral register in the United Kingdom, should be able to have the same right to elect those who make their laws, whether it's a council, a devolved institution if you have one, or the Parliament of this United Kingdom. That those who make our laws, whoever they are, should be subject to the right of every citizen to elect those people. But what I bring to this debate is the situation in Northern Ireland. That's how it used to be. My constituents until 2021 had the equal right to elect, whether council, Stormont, or Westminster, those who were making their laws.

But under what we now call the Windsor Framework, in Northern Ireland, in 300 areas of law, 300, we are denied the right to elect those who make those laws, because those laws are not made in this place, they're not made in Stormont, they're made in a foreign parliament elected by no one from the United Kingdom. So that takes me right back to that founding principle that underlies this: "The right to participate in our democracy is a defining aspect of our national identity." And that is why amendments new clause 122 and 152 bring that matter to the House's attention by suggesting that unless and until there is an equality impact assessment in respect of the whole United Kingdom's participation in all aspects of democracy, then this bill should not have effect. Let me put it to you like this: this bill proposes that a 16-year-old in Cardiff, London, Edinburgh, who's paid no tax, who's never served their country, has full franchise on all aspects, can elect everyone who makes rules governing their lives.

But a 60, 70-year-old veteran in Northern Ireland, who's paid tax for all his life, who's served his country, or any other citizen, is denied the right to elect, when I finish the point, is denied the right to elect those who make his or her laws in over 300 areas of law. That's the inequity that this House, I respectfully suggest, needs to face up to. Yes, I'll give way.

05:40:13 - 05:40:55

Florence Eshalomi

Gratefully, I think the honorable member is confused as to the constitutional process. That individual constituent of his, the 60, 70-year-old, votes for a representative to come to this place, and this place takes decisions on their behalf equally on behalf of any part of the United Kingdom. And this institution has decided that it was in the best interest and continues to be in the best interest of this country and of Northern Ireland to maintain the Windsor Framework in lieu of any better alternative available on the table. And to try and withhold from other people the ability to have representation in this place, directly elected representation in the case of 16 and 17-year-olds on this issue, frankly I find spurious at best.

05:40:55 - 05:43:52

Jim Allister

I think the honorable gentleman should just reflect on what he's said. He has effectively said that it is right for this House to disenfranchise my constituents, to take from them the right to vote for those who make the laws in 300 areas. And those 300 areas are what shape our economy in Northern Ireland: how you manufacture your goods, how you package them, how you sell them. All of that, all of that has been removed from the reach of any single constituent in Northern Ireland to elect anyone to have any say over it. That is disenfranchising.

And that is the fundamental objection from a democratic point of view to the Windsor Framework. And therefore I say to this House, yes, we can have an argument whether or not 16-year-olds should have a vote. What I'm saying to you is, if 16-year-olds are to have a vote in Great Britain, 16-year-olds in Northern Ireland should have an equal reach on their franchise. It should enable them to elect those who make their laws, not subcontracted out to those we don't elect. And that's why those two amendments are there.

And I do think that is a probing, fundamental issue touching upon our commitment to equal citizenship and our commitment to the fundamental of our democracy, which is the right of everyone to participate on an equal footing in our democracy and electing those who make our laws. And I do think it's incontestable that it is wrong to say to my constituents and every other constituent in Northern Ireland, it's good for us in Great Britain to have those rights, but it's not good for you. That's fundamentally wrong. Final point I want to make on a different subject. I tried to intervene with the Minister, she wouldn't take the intervention.

On the 100,000 pound cap, can the Minister in winding up confirm that Sinn Féin, for example, a party registered in Northern Ireland, will be exempt from the effect of that cap if an Irish citizen living abroad makes a donation in excess of it?

Is that the position? And if that is the position, as my reading of the bill that it is, then why is that loophole not being closed? Why should I or anyone else have to compete with a party which is not subject to the same constraints that the rest of us are subject? So perhaps the minister would address that, because that seems to me to be a loophole crying out to be closed.

05:43:52 - 05:48:47

Speaker 83

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As so many have said in this debate, our democracy must not be for sale. So it is disturbing that the arms race in campaign spending has been getting out of control. As has been mentioned, in 2023, the previous cap on campaign spending of 19 million pounds was increased massively to 34 million pounds. None of our constituents were asked whether they wanted this, and the Electoral Commission said at the time it had not seen evidence to justify the increase.

We all know what can happen when campaign spending spirals out of control. A number of members have referred to the situation in the US. Their opaque crypto interests spent 119 million dollars just between January and the end of June this year. That's with four months to go before the midterm elections. And of course, we've seen huge donations from crypto interests in our own country, but they were given in pounds.

My amendment, new clause 70, would set a limit on campaign spending of 24.4 million pounds. That's what the previous limit of 19 million pounds would be now, allowing for inflation, minus 15 percent, as per the recommendation of the Committee on Standards in Public Life. I do understand that the government is keen to avoid additional legislation at this stage, given time pressure for ensuring votes at 16 are delivered. And I acknowledge the letter urging the Electoral Commission to examine this matter that was published last night, coming from the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government and the First Secretary of State. That letter makes explicit that, in their words, spending limits on parties and candidates are too high and ought to be reduced, and asks the commission to provide recommendations to the government by July 2027 at the latest.

I'm pleased that the government has heard the call from members from right across this House and many different parties represented here and who have supported my amendment. I'm really grateful to members who've supported it. As the government has made that request to the Electoral Commission clear, I won't push for a vote on my amendment, but I really want to see progress on this. The Electoral Commission has got to work now speedily on a lowered limit for campaign spend to stop this arms race. That message has come clearly from this House.

They need to act on it. Now, in my remaining remarks, I want, Madam Deputy Speaker, to urge the government to move at pace on the further risks to UK democracy that so many speakers in this House have referred to during this debate, many of which are covered by the amendments that have been tabled by my friend for North-East and for Milton Keynes Central. As others have said, we've got to ensure greater transparency on targeted online political advertising, including that facilitated through artificial intelligence, and additional measures on third-party campaigning and political funding. The stakes here, as so many have said, really couldn't be higher. The UK Extremism and Democratic Resilience Centre recently showed that online platforms and AI-generated content are playing a powerful role in amplifying not just divisive narratives, but extremist narratives and conspiracy theories.

Over one in ten people in our country now say they could accept political violence. It's also led to an increase in those who reject at least some democratic norms, with almost a third of people saying we should ignore democratic institutions and rules if they get in the way of change. In the center's words, hostile states and domestic extremists are deliberately accelerating fractures to further destabilize Britain. So while this bill, including the government's amendments to it, will help, they don't yet meet the full scale of this challenge. The government has got to engage in the kind of protection and promotion of democracy that it successfully urged many other nations to do under the threat of foreign interference.

Extremist narratives have to be contested and online platforms regulated and reformed. So while welcoming this bill overall, I'll continue to push for change so we really can ensure what is the right of every citizen in our country: free and fair elections. Thank you.

05:48:47 - 05:48:50

Eleanor Laing

John McDonnell.

05:48:50 - 05:53:21

John Martin McDonnell

I think listening to the throughout the debate, I think part of the problem that we have is that the bill is being brought forward now in an enormous transitional period where maybe some of the original objectives of the bill are being met within the legislation itself that we're proposing. But since then the debate has moved on. The debate has moved on, we have to admit, within the Labour party because the change of leadership as well. So in some instances we might not be talking to this bill, we might be debating what we want to contain in the next bill, which I think needs to be brought forward with some urgency, particularly because I think the general tenor of the debate is a recognition that we are in a dangerous political moment within our country at the moment. And we have to address the we have to address the threats that are making this dangerous political moment.

The number of amendments here, I can understand the government not willing to accept today, and it might not be time enough when it goes in the other place to ensure that those amendments are shaped in such a way that can be legislated for quickly. But I would urge that there is a rethink now about the next bill that should be brought forward certainly before the end of the year to take into account this whole range of measures, and particularly those that have been excluded from the debate overall because of the title of the bill itself. It is to be frank a bit shaming for the debate, the political debate within the house itself. I have two amendments I put down which are very straightforward, and I thought they were I thought they were in the the tenor of the original bill, and I was surprised when when they weren't included. In fact, the current Lord Chancellor moved similar amendments to this in 2022.

And what they relate to is the bill aims to bring England and Northern Ireland in line with the reforms that have taken place in Scotland, both in terms of the age of 16, but also I thought what was going to happen is that we'd also ensure that the franchise was the same. And as people know in Scotland and Wales, they lowered the age of voting, but they also extended the franchise to all residents. And at the moment, because we base it on purely on citizenship, there are 4.4 million people residents who cannot vote in a general election within our country. There are 1.2 million in England and Northern Ireland who cannot vote at all in any election. In my constituency, that means there are 16,300 people who have no vote whatsoever.

And people who they people who live here, they work here, most pay their taxes, they fund our public services, but they're locked out of the democratic system itself.

So what these amendments do basically is to argue the case as has happened in both Scotland and Wales, that voting should be based upon residence rather than citizenship. And if there is to be a debate about well, there should be in some investment of time, well, there are other, there are other countries where that, that timescale of residency can be, can be designated. In New Zealand, for example, you're 12 months residence then you're able to vote itself. So Article 36 deals with local elections and it gives permission to vote in elections for those who have permission to enter or stay in the UK. And Article 35 extends it to general elections for those with settled status, an acceptance in many of our pieces of legislation that we have at the moment.

So settled status, indefinitely to remain. And again, as I say, it's an amendment that we've supported in the past. It means there'll be a simpler system with regard to registration. I actually do think it will increase voter participation. But above all else for me, it will bring about a greater sense of social cohesion where those people who are living within our society yet have no say within our society will be brought into the political system effectively.

I know we've had the debate about different languages and all the rest. I wish we'd never got rid of the Latin mass to be honest, but that's another, that might offend the other side on that particular issue. But all my amendments are trying to do is to recognize the reality of our society. The reality is our society is we are a diverse community. And what this legislation could do is ensure we recognize that diversity but make sure everyone has a stake in our society and has a democratic right to vote.

05:53:21 - 05:58:23

Florence Eshalomi

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I express my, my delight at the member for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green making it to the front bench. I know she's going to do a fantastic job. It is, it's, I'm very grateful for the opportunity to speak in this debate. 14 years in local government, I was very involved in electoral administration within my area.

And when it came to the Elections Act, which so much of what we're talking about today involves really, I was appointed to chair the working group of the Local Government Association going through it. It was a cross-party group. By the end of it, we came up with a consensus viewpoint and very little of that bill that was thought to actually make much sense based on the evidence and the expert testimony we received. I won't insult the members opposite by saying that it was a nakedly political attempt to rig the electoral system to their benefit. But if you were going to set up a nakedly political attempt to rig the electoral system to their benefit, it would have looked exactly like the Elections Act.

Personation was, was the basis on which they were arguing the case at the time. It's vanishingly rare that people actually turn up and try and pretend to be anyone else at a polling station. I'll deal with that more in just a second. But in terms of the remarks of the Shadow Secretary of State at the start of this debate, we knew that they would say something to try and excuse why widening the franchise or making it easier for people to register to vote was a bad idea. But I wasn't expecting, frankly, I mean, it was a good thing we had sort of free hearing tests here just before recess, but I didn't need to because the dog whistle there was so loud coming across the chamber that it was apparent to all of us.

And when Reform eventually turned up to say something, it was the exact same talking points. And I have to say on this, you will not, the members opposite will not rebuild their party by just aping the Reform party. You know, we've had this and we've seen this with parties time and time again. It might play well within their own ranks, but it will not rebuild it with the country. And while I've never voted for the Conservative party, I do know that there are many moderate Conservatives out there who must feel a great deal of shame at what is happening to their party today, driving towards the right and away from common sense positions in our system.

Personation is vanishingly rare in our system. The reality is, you'd need to know a seat was on an absolute knife-edge to make it work at all. You couldn't do it as a single person going round all polling stations. You need hundreds of people to go around with you. The idea you could rig this in a way that wouldn't leak out, that you wouldn't run into someone in the process.

You need decades of marked registers, which are only available to purchase for six months after an election if you're going to do this. You're going to need so many people and so well-organized a campaign, and even then, you could just get unlucky in the process. Personation, I can confidently say, has never changed any national seat ever elected and is very unlikely it's affected a local seat otherwise. Well, what has caused a real problem in this, because this is not a real-world problem, personation, is foreign interference in our political system. And we know that there are people who we may very soon be at war with who are directly trying to intervene in our election.

We know questionable money is a problem, and frankly, Russia was pretty happy to give Conservatives money at one point. We know that there are tens of thousands of people who since the introduction of ID have been turned away from polling stations. We know that millions of people are not registered. One in seven eligible voters is not registered in our system, and individual voter registration helped to make that the case. Disenfranchisement in our system is an absolute travesty, and this bill gives control back to the British public by re-enfranchising them.

When it comes to voter ID, looking at the actual report of that, and I've got to say, people involved in drafting that bill didn't look at the actual evidence base around how many people had voter ID. But if you look at the one study cited, they state in the study it is not a reliable figure on how many people have ID, and even in that study, it was a much wider range of ID that they used than is currently permissible. Widening the range of ID as the government's proposing to do is making it far more likely that everyone will be able to vote in an election. The possibility of automatic voter registration pilots will also re-enfranchise many of those who have been lost from the system in the course of it, and giving people confidence back in our system through Electoral Commission independence and greater controls over campaign finance. And I should just say on campaign finance, as people bring up the trade unions, the trade unions don't finance the Labour Party.

The trade unions are part of the Labour Party. Their members are a part of our movement, and we are proud of the support that we receive from the millions of people, ordinary people, who make up this system. And when it comes down to 16 and 17-year-old voting, frankly, so many of them when we go on school visits have such good questions. I would say, I think we get dangerously close in this debate sometimes to seem to argue there has to be a mental capacity test for voting. We do not test people in our system on their intellectual ability.

The franchise is there because people who do not have a say do not get represented in terms of their needs and their issues, and that's why it's vital we re-enfranchise 16 and 17-year-olds. This act gives PR back that was taken away from the Elections Act. And can I with my last few seconds just briefly say, council officers run so many of our elections. They do a fantastic job. Too often they are given, sorry, a few more seconds, too often they are not given the financial support they need to do the work when things are...

05:58:23 - 05:58:25

Eleanor Laing

Order. Lloyd Hatton.

05:58:25 - 06:02:55

Lloyd Hatton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, as it has been mentioned already, it is common knowledge that too many voters think that money talks louder than their ballot paper does, and that those with the deepest pockets have far too easy access to power. In short, increasingly the British public do not trust their elected politicians or their democratic institutions. If we truly are serious about rebuilding that trust, then we must tackle this problem head-on. That is why the Representation of the People Bill really does matter.

As the Minister rightly noted, and I welcome her to her place, this landmark piece of legislation introduces some of the most ambitious changes to Britain's democracy for a generation, including tougher rules to keep dirty money out of politics and safeguard our democracy from interference and harm. Each of these measures is essential, Madam Deputy Speaker.

It will help to rebuild trust in our politics. And each of these measures sends an unambiguous message that this Labour government takes the health of our democracy far more seriously than its predecessor. Many of the safeguards needed against democracy, against corruption, undue influence, dirty money and foreign interference are already built into this bill, and I welcome the changes that have been made already. But as we explored in some considerable detail at the bill committee, effectively defending our democracy requires addressing a number of remaining gaps. It is clear to me that closing these loopholes is fundamental.

And building on those constructive conversations, I have tabled an amendment, new clause 61, which seeks to close one such loophole. With the existing rules, there is a complete absence of scrutiny of the funds that new parties hold upon registration. While new parties are required to submit a declaration of assets and liabilities when they register, there are no checks on the permissibility of these funds. Members in this place will recall that when the honourable member for Great Yarmouth launched a new political party, Restore Britain, that there was no such checks in place. Prior to the launch, Restore Britain was though a political movement that may or may not have received substantial contributions from questionable sources before it was formally registered as a political party.

This is, as things stand, entirely legitimate. Parties do not need to demonstrate that funds or assets accumulated before registration originate from permissible donors. And there is nothing as it stands in this bill to prevent brand new political parties sidestepping controls on donations by simply accepting as many donations and gifts as they please before registering. We should not wait until formal registration before asking questions about the true origins of major political donations. My amendment seeks to do just that, meaning that any new party would have to subject any funds it holds over 250,000 pounds to post-registration permissibility checks.

Having already raised these proposals at the bill committee, I know that ministers are keen to ensure that there are no loopholes of this kind remaining in the bill. So I hope that in winding up, the minister will consider introducing some level of vetting on any significant funds that parties hold upon registration. This will help us to crack down on new parties accepting major donations but not facing full and meaningful scrutiny. As we look ahead, I certainly hope that the minister will hear not only the enthusiastic support for this bill, but also the strength of feeling on all sides of the house that this bill must be ambitious enough to tackle the scale of the threat that we currently face. We must rebuild trust in our democratic institutions and protect our democracy from corrupting influences, deep-pocketed individuals and unwanted foreign interference.

And this landmark bill, with the right changes, is our opportunity to do just that.

06:02:55 - 06:02:56

Ewan Stainbank.

06:02:56 - 06:07:58

Euan Stainbank

Madam Deputy Speaker, our democracy is precious but faces significant challenges. If we want to protect our system, it must keep change with the times. The 2024 general election, the turnout was still far too low, but turnout in the poorest areas below 50 percent, property ownership still dictating representation with renters voting at a rate of 38 percent and owner-occupiers at a rate of 71 percent. The delta between younger and older voters is still too high. Expanding participation and trust in politics is an issue of equality, but also of social, economic and generational fairness, and I'm proud of the efforts the government have shown in this bill to address this.

No member and those speaking today is under any illusion that trust in our political system and the bandwidth of our current system to enable that meaningful democratic participation, especially amongst those who need it the most, is limited. MPs being elected on increasingly fractured minority votes in a parliament that sometimes is unrepresentative of the voting intentions of the country repels the trust, participation and engagement that our elected representatives and government need.

It isn't a party political point to state this. This is about every person who we talk about stepping up to participate, seeing their vote reflected in this place. When MPs and governments are enabled of a lower share and turnout of the vote, that means that there's an increasingly lower amount of people that see their ballot meaning anything in this place. And if that is their first experience of their vote, they are far less likely to come back and vote again. Now, I believe that the government can come back with giving us a route that starts from the first principles of enabling our system to become fairer, more representative and one that sustains public confidence in an independent national commission.

I know that this is something the government is not going to do today, but it's something the government ought to do in the future so that the next parliament is not starting from scratch on long overdue reform to our electoral system. NC68 in the name of my honourable friend from Glasgow West, which I added my signature to, requires registration officers to accept postal proxy vote applications received after the deadline where there's proof of timely posting. I think this is a meaningful effort and step to prevent people losing their votes over having made reasonable steps in order to submit it. It isn't reasonable to have voters lose their say in the election because of the potential and quite common unreliability of the postal system, and this would empower returning officers to count the votes of people who are making a good faith effort to do so. From the other side, sadly, though, we see amendments that would conversely limit postal voting, such as reforms NC108, which would create serious issues and would have created serious issues, especially in Scotland.

When the general election was called, the last Tory Prime Minister called it for the first Thursday of the Scottish school holidays. Thousands of people under this amendment would have lost their vote and been made ineligible to vote through no fault of their own if it had been updated in this manner. There have also been amendments in the last wheeze of parliamentary effort to stop votes at 16 and 17 go through, and I have to thank the Conservative party because their arguments have only compounded my belief that this is the right step for our party to make. The amendment 6 and subsequent amendments to link voting to the age that you can buy alcohol in a way of getting around the government's manifesto commitment to this bill to extend the franchise is ludicrous. Perhaps members would have been persuaded to support the amendment if we allowed 16 and 17-year-olds the vote if they vote and then go to a licensed restaurant and go for a sit-down meal accompanied by an adult, but this sadly seems to have been omitted by this amendment.

If members' serious concern is about where we draw the line at capacity, I'll make the principal point that because we allow 16-year-olds to vote, they should have their democratic say in how the taxes that they contribute are spent and how the conditions of their labour are regulated, and that is a far more rational place to tie that milestone than whether they would be able to have a pint at 8 o'clock whilst watching the Scottish premiership this evening. I think the government's principle is right on this, and I'm glad to see it overcoming this milestone today. There's been a lot of references to vote rigging in the opposition towards this. I find that ludicrous principally because when this was passed in Scotland, it was passed with cross-party support, including from the Scottish Conservatives at the time, and because engagement has been increased ever since this has been brought out for 16 and 17-year-olds. I cast my first vote at age 16 in the 2016 Scottish Parliament elections.

I wasn't grateful to the government to the day that I went out enthusiastically and voted SNP. A ludicrous proposal considering how much time I spend in this place and have in my career opposing many of their measures. It was because it was the right thing to do and it was recognised by the Scottish Parliament, and I'm glad that we have that cross-party consensus today that even if it's a majority and not the unanimity we had in 16, it's going to bring it over the line. Conservative reform amendments, sadly, that we've heard about today have been about restricting political participation.

Comparatively from colleagues what we've heard is about expanding political participation. I think the government would go further by setting up a national commission but look at this as the first stage of our political reform agenda.

06:07:59 - 06:11:51

Chris Hinchliff

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. A political system, even one with regular elections, is not really a democracy if rich individuals and corporations are able to use their wealth to buy access and influence and shape decisions in a way that ordinary citizens will never enjoy. And this is something that new clause 25 in my name seeks to address. The British people will never be able to trust that we are genuinely representing their interests if those with deep pockets can wield disproportionate political power. And unless we use this bill to drain the influence of money from our politics, that doubt will continue to rot away at the foundations of our democracy, driving more and more of our constituents to disbelieve that Parliament is here to serve them, and meaningful engagement with politics in our country will continue to sink to ever more dismal depths until no government has the mandate to legitimately call itself representative.

The amendment in my name, Madam Deputy Speaker, focuses on a specific aspect of this problem, which is particularly pernicious and should be banned in its own right: developers donating to political parties to weight the planning system in their own favour. Madam Deputy Speaker, what gets built where shapes our daily lives like nothing else, and the decisions made through our planning system are often the most tangible touchpoints with democracy for local communities. Yesterday, the Prime Minister spoke about the urgent need to put agency and power back in the hands of the people, but in recent years, the near-universal experience of those engaging with the planning system as ordinary citizens is that their hopes and concerns are dismissed and trampled on by decision-making that overwhelmingly favours the interests of speculative developers. This is not an accident. Developers are amongst the biggest donors to political parties, and the successive waves of planning deregulation that have served to silence and curtail community participation in planning decisions have allowed those businesses to make vast sums of money throwing up expensive housing that most young families could never hope to afford while providing as few amenities as they can get away with and destroying our countryside in their pursuit of profit.

Madam Deputy Speaker, our constituents aren't daft. They can see the depressing results of the triumph of speculative developers' interests all around them, and they can also see those same developers and their lobbyists donating huge sums to political parties. The public can read the reports of exclusive fundraising events and access for those able to pay thousands for dinners with ministers, and they can put two and two together. Developer donations to the same political parties writing the rules of national planning policy creates the powerful perception that our housing crisis and all the damage being done to our country by speculative profiteering development is the direct result of a system moulded by those getting rich from it. And frankly, Madam Deputy Speaker, that is a perception it is difficult to dispute.

What confidence can the British people have of a fighting chance to protect the landscapes they love and that are their home if the developers who seek to concrete them over are paying for the election campaigns of their politicians? What confidence can the British people have that national policies supposed to reduce the traffic congestion blighting their lives and choking the lungs of their children will actually be kept to if the politicians who should be responsible for enforcing them are being funded by developers whose profit margins improve the more obligations they wriggle out of? And what confidence... I'll happily give way.

06:11:51 - 06:12:09

Ashley Peter Fox

I'm grateful to the honourable member for giving way. What consideration did he give to extending his proposed amendment to trade unions, who a neutral observer might conclude gave very large sums of money to the Labour Party precisely to influence the employment rights bill that they have now turned into law?

06:12:09 - 06:13:06

Chris Hinchliff

I thank the honourable member for his intervention. As we've heard many times in this debate today, there is a vast difference between trade unions made up of millions of members making small contributions collectively donated to the Labour Party of whom they support, as compared to corporations and rich individuals seeking influence for their own vested interests. And to continue where I left off, what confidence, confidence rather, can the British people have that the houses that will be built in their area will meet the actual needs of local families and enhance the beauty of their communities when the developers throwing up sprawling, characterless rip-off estates across the country are able to buy seats for a quiet chat lobbying ministers? Madam Deputy Speaker, it is time to ban developers from donating to political parties, to wash away the stain of undue influence and deliver a housing and planning system that puts people before profit.

06:13:06 - 06:13:07

Lizzie Collinge.

06:13:07 - 06:18:04

Elizabeth Rachel Collinge

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Representation of the People Bill brings in much-needed changes that I'm very pleased to support. The bill and the government amendments that we've seen today show that this government is taking protecting our democracy seriously. Now, government new clause 72 would introduce a ban on donations using cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrency is unregulated and untraceable money, we are right to take it out of our democracy.

Now, the amendment today is to put a moratorium on it, a non-permanent ban until regulation can be put in place, but I've heard some very compelling arguments today, Madam Deputy Speaker, that this should just be a complete ban. Any hostile foreign actors wishing to disrupt our democracy are able to fund it through these cryptocurrency donations. There's no way to trace this, and any political party that takes crypto donations should take a long, hard look at itself. It is clearly a risk that they are taking money from those bent on harming our country. Government new clause 116 would put a cap on donations from overseas electors so that those who don't live or contribute to this country can't unduly sway our elections.

Our democracy is not the business of individuals and organisations based abroad. British democracy should be in the hands of the people who live here, who contribute, not rich individuals who choose to live elsewhere. Now, this should be something that all parties can agree on, but sadly it's not, and I know some parties have benefited a little more from foreign donations than others and perhaps wouldn't want to bite the hand that feeds them. Now, perhaps I should congratulate the newly elected member for Clacton, who's not here again, because he's never here, is he, never engages properly in legislation. Congratulate him for not only winning the most pointless by-election in history, but also for the fact that his party broke the UK record for the single largest individual political donation by a living person, nine million pounds from one person in one donation from a Thailand-based businessman.

Now, with foreign friends like this, no wonder he has no need to spend time in his constituency. Madam Deputy Speaker, these new clauses will add strength to our democracy. Now, votes at 16 have been discussed today as well.

The Conservatives say that 16-year-olds are not mature enough or wise enough to vote. I disagree, and actually I don't think there's a really clear correlation between age and wisdom. I think all of us here, we speak to people of all different ages. And I know in my experience of going to local schools and colleges, that some of the best questions I've ever been asked and some of the best suggestions I've ever heard have come from 16 and 17-year-olds. But I think the most compelling argument for votes at 16 is actually that it gets people in the habit of voting, because most 16 and 17-year-olds will still be at school or at college or in some sort of training.

It is a way to show people how elections work. I know adults who have never voted simply because they didn't understand how it worked. I've had to talk them through, you know, you go with your ID, you go and you'll have a list and you'll mark it with a cross, no you don't tick it, that would make too much sense. And so if we get young people involved in democracy younger, they are more likely to be lifelong voters, and that is really, really important. However, this bill does not address what I think is the most pressing question when we come to our democracy, the glaring problems with our current voting system.

It's clear that first-past-the-post simply doesn't work anymore, and that's why I am calling for a national commission on electoral reform. Now, I know the new clause has been ruled out of scope today, so I will not go any further, but if anyone would like to talk about the problems with first-past-the-post and potential for a new voting system, please do get in touch. It's one of my favorite subjects. Very briefly, Madam Deputy Speaker, I wanted to speak against new clause 67 in the name of the honorable member for Humble Valley. I'm really puzzled by the idea that leaflets in other languages are somehow detrimental to our democracy.

Now, I used to live in Spain, and I was in a minority because I actually spoke Spanish. Now, some Brits are eligible to vote in local elections in Spain, and yes, they absolutely should be able to speak Spanish, but I know from experience the difference of being able to understand a language and actually understand the political nuances, the history, some of the code that's used in political texts is different. We want to expand participation in our democracy, and so I think it's perfectly fine to have leaflets in different languages. And I'd just like to note that only 0.3% of people in Britain don't speak English. It's a tiny, tiny minority of people who don't speak English.

And I think unfortunately, yet again, this place is being used to whip up culture wars that have no basis in reality. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:18:04 - 06:18:28

Florence Eshalomi

I'm even reluctant to mention this because all of the members in the chamber are so highly experienced, but when mentioning another honorable member in the chamber, the etiquette is to give them prior warning so they have an opportunity to come in and offer a rebuttal in real time. Now, I'm looking for Luke Akehurst. Well, he's not there, so he's missed his turn. David Burton-Sampson.

06:18:28 - 06:23:32

David Edmund Burton-Sampson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm extremely grateful for the opportunity to speak in this debate, because ultimately, at the end of the day, nothing matters more than protecting our democracy. It's the bedrock of our society and we've got to defend it at all costs. And in that spirit, I'm delighted to welcome the new minister to her place. I know she's going to do a fantastic job. Madam Deputy Speaker, we need to show that intimidation has no part to play in our public life.

This bill makes provision to ensure that not only candidates, campaigners and elected office holders are given protection, but electoral staff too. I'm sure many of us in this place can point to times when we've been intimidated whilst out campaigning. Civil and robust debate is important, but it's very different to intimidatory behavior.

We require changes in order to keep pace with the changing world we live in today and the increasingly digital life we experience. So I note the new clause 41 to new clause 47 proposed by the honorable member for Milton Keynes Central to prevent online harms. Harassment online or worse is growing exponentially year on year. AI generated images, deep fakes, disinformation and misinformation being circulated on social media and other forms of online harassment are simply unacceptable. It must be addressed as a matter of urgency for the preservation of members in this chamber, particularly women who suffer even higher levels of abuse.

The spirit of these new clauses are spot on and I'm pleased that the government are taking these issues seriously through the works on the Online Safety Act and through the Defending Democracy Taskforce. I'm also pleased to see that the government are establishing an AI labeling taskforce and I hope they'll continue this work as this bill passes through the other place to tighten up further on this area. For the very preservation of public life itself, proposals to mitigate these risks both online and offline are absolutely key. And we know this only too well in Southend West and Leigh and our thoughts remain with the families of Sir David Amess, Jo Cox and Ann Widdecombe. The question of cleaning up political donations too is vital.

One critically important clean up is that we've heard today is with cryptocurrency. And I've spoken in this house many times about my interest in financial regulation and I harbor concerns about crypto world as it stands today. Rules around this sector need to be watertight before it would be safe to allow contributions to political parties from crypto assets. Crypto in my view has a place in the future of the UK financial system and there are many in the UK industry who are working hard for tighter, more appropriate regulation to get this moving. But for now, the anonymity that currently presents itself through the current set up is simply not acceptable within the political donations world as it creates a risk of a significant reduction in transparency.

So I believe measures in this bill to ensure the reliability of such donations are of paramount importance to safeguarding our democracy. To conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, I wanted to confirm that unlike others, I support bringing forward rules to update voting for 16 year olds so that they could have the opportunity. After all, 16 year olds can join the armed forces, they can pay taxes or they have to pay taxes if they're working and ultimately they are the ones who'll be most exposed to good or bad decisions made by governments of the future for the longest period of time. We've got to start crediting our young people with the ability to make up their own minds. I've met some incredible young people both through work experience in my office and through my youth days and visits to schools.

And I've got to say at my last youth day, 70 pupils, the clear majority with only two against, were in favor of votes for 16 year olds. Even the teachers, the people who know these children best, were overwhelmingly positive about the move. The bill will take us forward into a new age when young people can have a proper say on their future. Democracy has endured because of its ability to accommodate change and we are now in a rapidly changing world. These changes that we need to make to protect our democracy for years to come are vital.

Thank you.

06:23:31 - 06:24:05

John Neil Duncan-Jordan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, what's clear from this debate is that the public have lost trust in politics and the political process. And part of that is linked to the way in which they see money having an undue influence on the decisions that politicians make. In 2015, just 1% of private donations came from individuals or companies giving £1 million or more. But by 2024, that figure had risen to over a third.

06:23:32 - 06:23:33

Bill Duncan Jordan.

06:24:05 - 06:27:58

John Neil Duncan-Jordan

We have seen the obscene amounts of money that some MPs have made doing second or even third and fourth jobs whilst they are supposed to be representing their constituents. Equally, we know that the businesses that donate to political parties are often in line for government contracts in return. This has got to stop because if it doesn't, more than a half, more than half of all political donations could soon come from just a handful of individuals, leaving elected politicians increasingly reliant on the patronage of a small elite. We will have wealthy individuals and companies with influence over the direction of our country despite never having won a single election. Now, new clause 26 in my name would begin to address these concerns.

It would ban political donors from securing government contracts from the administrations they paid to elect. Over the past 25 years, companies that donated to political parties have secured £60 billion worth in government contracts, including during the COVID era. In the middle of a national crisis, people needed confidence that decisions were made on merit and in the public interest, not shaped by big donors. Now, the government is quite rightly starting to claim some of the COVID contracts back, but it would also benefit from distancing itself from those donors who are only interested in the party as a vehicle for achieving their own ends. In this debate, we are rightly having a wider conversation about our democracy.

There is scrutiny of a Westminster-centric political culture in which communities have often been left behind. Redistributing power on the basis of place is one side of the coin. It must go hand in hand with redistributing power on the basis of wealth. A recent Oxfam report found the super-rich exert influence in three main ways: buying political influence by funding parties and candidates, gaining direct access to decision-makers and institutions, and shaping public opinion to defend elite power. That's why I'm supporting amendments today to limit donations from harmful lobbying interests and place stronger caps on what wealthy individuals and private companies can give.

We can't have money from overseas coming into our politics, and we can't have cryptocurrencies that are untraceable flooding Westminster. We know where that will lead. Now, associating with these super-rich donors, however many suits they buy or receptions they sponsor, in the end only causes harm to the political parties they support. And we should be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, how many of our constituents could even dream of donating hundreds of thousands of pounds to a political party? Any cap needs to be much more realistic in my view, and not still pander to those who are well-connected and use their money to gain advantage.

Let's start to recognise that our democracy will only flourish when we start to redistribute not only wealth, but the power that goes alongside it. The Prime Minister has spoken about rewiring Britain.

We all want to see better outcomes for our constituents, but to build a better country, we need a better politics as well.

06:27:58 - 06:33:01

Sam Rushworth

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's been a privilege to be on the Bill Committee for this bill, it's my first time. And can I also congratulate the new Minister and welcome her to her place, I think it's a long overdue promotion. I enjoyed the Bill Committee and I enjoyed the spirit in which we debated. I felt that there were many occasions where amendments were being proposed by opposition parties that I thought were sincere and done with good intentions.

And more than one occasion, the former Minister, the honorable member for Chester, had to sort of take me to one side and patiently explain to me why the government position was that we couldn't do something that I felt seemed like a reasonable request. And so I think that there are some complex issues here as well. But I was listening with interest to the member for Hazel Grove earlier, who talked about perhaps a need for a second phase to this. And there've been many members' contributions today from people who are more expert than me in various fields, where I think there's a real sense of concern at the point that we're at as a democracy. And I've listened to all of those people with interest.

I wanted to just take a couple of minutes to continue my debate with the honorable member for Tatton, who's no longer in her place, but respond to some of the comments that she made with regards to her amendments. And this is broadly, she seemed to be of the opinion that contributing a single vote towards electing a representative for a four to five year period should be done at exactly the same age that people choose who should be their marriage partner until death they do part. I want to express why I don't think that that's correct. We can play a quick game of higher or lower. Compulsory school age is five.

The age of criminal responsibility is ten. At twelve, you can be trained to take part in dangerous performances. You can be kept in police detention if arrested and you have to sign your own passport application. At fourteen, you can get a Saturday job. At fifteen, you can apply to join the Royal Navy or the Royal Air Force.

At sixteen, you can buy spray aerosols, you can enter a pub on your own, drink beer or wine with a meal, join the armed forces, change your name by deed of poll without parental consent, hold a license to drive a moped, you can gamble by buying a lottery ticket, you could enter a housing contract, you could leave home, you could apply for legal aid and be assessed on your own means, you could consent to surgical and dental treatment, you can buy premium bonds, you can become a pet owner, you can consent to sexual activity and you get your national insurance number. You have to be seventeen, however, to donate blood. At eighteen, you can be deployed in the armed forces, you can act as the executor of a will, you can buy fireworks and explosives, you can buy firearms. And you have to be twenty-one, however, to adopt or to supervise a learner driver. And the point that I'm making is that the transition from childhood to adulthood is not flicking a switch.

It is a process. And the question that we're really debating is at what point within that process should we trust somebody to take their first step as a democratic citizen by thinking deeply about and contributing one of many, many thousands of votes in an election for who represents them. And speaking as someone who's raised three children now to the age of sixteen, but also someone whose career has been with children and youth, I believe that sixteen is the right age. I believe that for a number of reasons. In particular, I feel that the evidence is strong that getting young people at that age engaged in the democratic process means that it sticks with them throughout the rest of their life.

But there's another reason too, and we've heard talk here of this being vote rigging. Now, I have to wonder what it is about so many members opposite that makes them automatically assume that a 16-year-old won't vote for them. They have an equal opportunity, and every party in this place has an equal opportunity to appeal to that young person for their vote. But when they don't, when they don't have a vote, they can be ignored. And we only have to look at the Conservative record: cutting child trust funds, closing down Sure Start centres, cutting primary school budgets, cutting the educational maintenance allowance, cutting school transport, closing careers services, closing youth centres, tripling tuition fees, locking people out of the housing market and not doing enough on climate change to see why it's important that we give that generation a say in their future.

And she did make that commitment in Wilmslow High School nine years ago, and I'm disappointed that she'll be going back on it today. And if I may just take my last 17 seconds to say that I strongly endorse the comments by the honourable member for Milton Keynes Central. We need to look at this issue of deepfakes as well and protect our democracy because we're all subject to it.

06:33:01 - 06:39:20

Anna Dixon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to add my congratulations to the member for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green, it's great to see her on the front bench. I really welcome the Representation of the People Bill. We can go back in history and look at some amazing enfranchisement that happened with the Representation of the People Bills of 1918 and 1928 when suffrage was extended to women and those with no property. And I love when, Madam Deputy Speaker, when I have visitors here taking them and showing them the stained glass windows where here in this place we celebrate giving more people the vote. And I hope that when this bill becomes an Act of Parliament, we too can celebrate the enfranchisement of those 16 to 18, and I'm really proud that this Labour government is extending the vote, not only to them, but also through the great measures around reversing the Conservative measures which disenfranchise people about voter ID and also going further with automatic voter registration.

These are all really great strides forward in enabling more people to vote. There are lots of other provisions in the bill which I hugely support, which ensure that our elections are free and fair. But Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to speak specifically to the clause in my name, new clause 81. One part of a free and fair democracy is that it is essential that candidates and indeed elected officials feel safe. So my amendment would take forward a recommendation from the Speaker's Conference on the security of MPs, candidates and elections and put an end to the publication of candidates' home addresses.

Today, it's a default option for a candidate's home address to be published, and clearly in the increasingly hostile and toxic political climate that we operate in, this is a cause for concern and I believe has a chilling effect on our democracy. I'd like to echo the member for Southend West and Leigh in remembering our dear colleagues Jo Cox, David Amess, who obviously were both tragically murdered, and of course we think of the family of Ann Widdecombe as her horrific murder continues to be investigated. It's a travesty that death threats are now seen as part of the job.

And as we know, it is women who are more at risk and more likely to be threatened. It has been reported, so Madam Deputy Speaker, no worries, that a constituent of mine has recently received a suspended custodial sentence and a lifetime restraining order for a threat to kill me, in which he wrote, if I see you in public, I will try my best to kill you. I will work hard to find out where you live and I will kill you there. That is why this amendment is personal to me. As things stand, if a candidate does not want their address to be published, they must actively request it.

Thankfully, I had the foresight and I did. But it does put people like me who choose to do that as a disadvantage to other candidates by creating the impression that you don't want to be open and transparent. If this clause were implemented, the requirements for those who decline to have their address published would become the default for all candidates, giving everyone confidence that at least in their own home, they and their families would be safe. So I thank the member for Chester for her early engagement and I look forward and hope that the Minister will continue to work with me and the Jo Cox Foundation as this bill progresses through to the other place to make sure that we can put in safeguards and protections for candidates, their families and indeed others like agents who support them. So while I'm obviously not going to push my amendment to a vote today, I do hope that we can take measures to protect all those who put themselves forward for elected office at all levels.

And I would just like to add my thanks to my honourable friend who's no longer in his place, the member for Leeds Central and Headingley, for his leadership of the APPG for Fair Elections, of which I am a member. And I think others have commented just how unfair and unrepresentative and unsustainable our electoral system is at the moment. And so I do hope in summing up and in her wind-up comments, even though we are not considering it, that the Minister will give assurances about the steps the government might take to further protect our democracy and ensure that every vote counts by looking at further measures in the future for electoral reform. It is vital that we protect our democracy against foreign interests and others who wish to undermine our democracy. And I hope the Minister will consider my amendment and some of those of other honourable members.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. First, let me put on record my thanks to the Minister and her predecessor, the honourable member for Chester North and Neston, for their collective engagement so far on this bill. As a former anti-corruption specialist for more than a decade and chair of the APPG on Anti-Corruption and Responsible Tax, I've had the pleasure of working with colleagues from across the House on this bill, seeking to drive foreign interference, dirty money and undue influence out of our democracy. To that end, there are a number of amendments I want to wholeheartedly endorse in the brief amount of time I have. Those include new clause 34 from my right honourable friend the member for Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull on cryptocurrency, amendments 31 to 34 from the member for Leeds South West and Morley on strengthening know-your-donor requirements, new clause 61 from the member for South Dorset on closing the political party startup funding loophole, new clause 70 from the formidable right honourable member for Oxford East on reducing campaign spending limits, and new clauses 93, 94 and 95 from the member for Warwick and Leamington on foreign-sourced donations and loans, and new clause 86 from the member for Islington South on overseas donations.

And I hope the Minister will respond to each of those amendments substantively in her wind-up. But I want to focus my remarks on two amendments standing in my name on the order paper, namely new clause 121 and amendment 151.

06:39:20 - 06:42:36

Speaker 195

Both are ultimately about one deliverable I know the government wants to achieve, namely restoring trust in politics as a force for good. First, new clause 121. Now, I welcome the government's move over the weekend to expedite its existing ask of the Electoral Commission to review campaign spending limits. But if the Electoral Commission concludes that spending limits should come down, we need to ensure that that decision is future-proofed. That's what my new clause 121 would secure.

Critically, it would ensure that spending limits are set according to three key tests: one, the fairness of elections; two, the impact on the political parties; and three, public confidence in electoral integrity. It would also ensure that future increases could only take place following an independent recommendation from the Electoral Commission. This matters because politics is caught in an increasingly unsustainable fundraising arms race. In 2023, spending limits were increased unilaterally by the Sunak government by 80%. The result was that the 2024 general election became the most expensive in British history, with parties spending £94 million between them.

As spending limits rise, so does the pressure on parties to raise ever larger sums of money. And when the demand for money grows, it follows that the risk appetite for parties accepting donations, and therefore the window of opportunity for bad actors, also grows. The Rycroft review made exactly that point. Reducing spending limits can help reduce incentives to seek funding from problematic sources and lessen the pressures that fuel concerns about foreign interference in our politics. Secondly, my amendment 151.

I welcome the government's decision in July to move to a profit-based cap on corporate donations. It's a clear improvement on the previous proposals, which would have tied the cap to revenue, and one which the APPG I chair had been calling for for months. However, two significant loopholes remain. My amendment would close both loopholes by ensuring that only the profits of the donating company itself are counted, and by calculating donation limits using average profits over five years, rather than accumulated profits. That would provide a more accurate measure of genuine economic activity and make it far harder for corporate structures to be used to circumvent the intention of the law.

Madam Deputy Speaker, we have all seen growing concern about offshore wealth, murky financial funding networks, and increasingly cryptocurrency billionaires seeking political influence. Reform UK's reliance on support from offshore crypto figures has brought these questions, quite rightly, firmly into the public eye. That is a problem for all of us, regardless as to which political party or tradition we belong to. The public deserve confidence that political influence in this country cannot be bought, whether through shell companies, foreign money, cryptocurrencies, or corporate loopholes. That is why we must close the gaps that remain, strengthen transparency, and ensure that our democracy serves voters rather than vested interests.

06:42:36 - 06:45:05

Apsana Begum

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise to speak to my amendments new clause 58 and new clause 59. Madam Deputy Speaker, for far too long, survivors of domestic abuse have been locked out of our politics, from the risks to physical safety to the threat of further exposure to post-separation harassment, and of course the serious toll on mental and emotional well-being, as I know too well from my own horrific election experiences where my ex-husband stood against me. But I know that my experiences are not unique and there are others that have suffered, and in fact many people who are survivors of domestic abuse cannot actually make the decision to run and stand for office because of the associated risks. New clause 58 and new clause 59 would resolve one of these issues at play by extending to survivors of domestic abuse the protections that are afforded to the victims of other offences by enhancing disqualification orders under the Elections Act so that domestic abuse offences are adequately covered.

I'm proud to say that so many leading women's rights and walk organisations, including Elect Her, the Jo Cox Foundation, Right to Equality, Women's Aid, Southall Black Sisters, and many more have joined me in calling for the law to change, along with at least 40 members from all parties across this House.

I'm very grateful for this support. The chief executive of the Electoral Commission wrote to me recently agreeing that these amendments would, and I quote, help strengthen candidate protection and enforcement against perpetrators. So I'm asking members today to support NC 58 and 59 and call upon the government to adopt these changes. I am grateful to the Minister for her engagement over the past few weeks on my amendments and for meeting with me. But I hope that in the closing remarks that she makes today she may be able to confirm whether the government will consider looking at secondary legislation as a mechanism of updating schedule nine of the Elections Act, looking at how there can be protections for survivors of domestic abuse including a greater number of relevant offences being included so that survivors can confidently and safely stand in elections.

Because our democracy cannot be said to be representative, Madam Deputy Speaker, if we tolerate these structural barriers which block out survivors. And because every survivor of domestic abuse should have the same right as anyone else to stand for office. Thank you.

06:45:05 - 06:45:06

Roberta Adie.

06:45:06 - 06:49:00

Roberta Adie

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to take the opportunity to welcome my honourable friend and neighbour to her place. I know she'll make a fantastic minister. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, I wanted to start by talking about what the risks we are seeing to our democracy and that is the emergence of AI, the use of crypto to fund parties alongside an expanding electorate and a move away from the traditional two-party system. So it's vitally important that this bill introduces a much-needed refresh. But one area that the bill has overlooked is electoral participation, which has been in stark decline for many years.

At the last general election, just 59.7% of the electorate voted. That's the lowest turnout since 2001. And the picture is far worse in local and by-elections. The Clapton by-election, for example, saw a mere 44% turnout, although there may have been some other reasons for that. But even with this low turnout, it really is indicative of a worrisome lack of engagement in the most integral act of political participation.

And that's why I've tabled new clause 57, requiring the government to publish proposals for compulsory voting at UK general and local elections in England within 12 months of this bill passing. Since the introduction of compulsory voting in Australia in 1924, they've seen consistently a minimum turnout of 90% with only a minimal fine for non-participation. There are of course legitimate reasons why some cannot vote and this amendment recognises that while also protecting the right to spoil one's ballot paper or return a blank one. Coupled with the provision, new clause 57 would introduce a programme of civic education. And that's important.

Research from the IPPR shows that fewer than 42% of teachers in England report that their school provides regular citizenship lessons. And as the incredibly bright young people who participated in my activism academy this summer told me, it's not just young people who need political education. Through no fault of their own, many adults also do not understand the basics of our political system. Knowledge is power and that is why NC 57 calls for the production of learning materials for adults too. Now, alongside this new clause 57, I support a number of other new clauses that would extend the franchise in parliamentary elections to qualifying EU citizens and to foreign nationals with a right to remain in the UK.

I've also supported amendments which address the wild west of UK political donation regulations. Our democracy is seriously at risk of being hijacked by those who only have their own interests at heart. I'm also extremely proud to support my honorable friend who has just spoken, the honorable member for Poplar and Limehouse, with new clause 58 and 59 to protect survivors of domestic abuse in public life. Now, I don't understand why it is a question that we would even support new clauses such as this, and I don't understand why we wouldn't support them right now and today. Finally, although the bill doesn't cover the issue of constituency boundaries, I would really like to see a review of how these are set.

We represent a constituent regardless of their right to vote. And when I think about the numbers in terms of the electorate that actually go on to vote, that means less and less people are involved in our political decisions. But not just that, our boundaries being drawn on the electorate and not residents means that inner-city constituencies like mine, with a highest level of residents relative to electorate, face disproportionately higher levels of casework and representing far more people. So I hope the minister will consider this when enacting part two of the bill. Now, bills of this nature do not come around often.

They offer a generational chance to refresh our democracy, and I hope the government will recognize the benefits that these amendments would bring. Thank you.

06:49:01 - 06:52:55

Sojan Joseph

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a real pleasure to see this bill back on the floor of the House. I pay tribute to my honorable friend for Chester North and Neston, who's just came back into the chamber, for the work she did on the bill until now. It was a pleasure to serve with her in the committee stage. And I congratulate my honorable friend for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green on her appointment as well.

As was acknowledged during the bill's second reading debate, there were significant concerns about the potential for donations made in cryptocurrency to undermine the integrity of our politics. This concern was raised by many members in the bill committee from this side as well, and we were reassured that there would be amendments brought in at the committee stage. It's not at least because it can be difficult to determine the true source of these funds. During the bill's earlier stage, the government committed to incorporating the findings of Sir Philip Rycroft's review and ensuring that its recommendations were reflected in the legislation. I welcome the fact that ministers took the time to do this, so that we now have government new clause 72 before us.

This new clause would prohibit UK-registered political parties from accepting donations made in crypto assets. Any donation made wholly or partially in crypto assets would automatically be treated as coming from an impermissible donor and could therefore not be accepted. What the government is proposing is that parties to take reasonable steps to identify anyone attempting to make a crypto asset donation, and where such donations are received, to return them to or otherwise dispose them in accordance with the existing government the rules governing prohibited donations. It also introduces a statutory definition of crypto asset and give the Secretary of State the power to update the definition through regulations. This is sensible and proportionate measure since the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act was passed at the start of this century, the financial landscape has changed considerably, most notably through the growth of cryptocurrencies.

This has created new challenges for regulators, law enforcement agencies, and those responsible for maintaining public confidence in democratic institutions. However, after listening to many of our colleagues today, I hope I think the concerns are still not is still there, so hopefully the minister will address some of the concerns raised to to close all those loopholes that has been raised today. The another amendment I would like to address in this group is a government new clause 116. This amendment would introduce an annual cap on 100,000 pounds on political donations and certain regulated transactions from overseas contributors.

The another amendment I would like to address in this group is a government new clause 116. This amendment would introduce an annual cap on 100,000 pounds on political donations and certain regulated transactions from overseas contributors. The cap would apply to individuals registered as overseas electors and to certain individuals who are on the UK electoral register but have spent time living outside the United Kingdom. It is of course welcome that since 2022 British citizens living abroad for more than 15 years have once again been entitled to vote in UK elections. However, as Philip Rycroft noted in his review, while British citizens living overseas can legitimately participate in UK democracy and make political donations, donations from overseas electors present additional risks that need to be managed.

And we heard numerous concerns today in this debate as well and I hope the ministers will relook into those concerns and address some more of those loopholes as well. Thank you.

06:52:55 - 06:53:05

Florence Eshalomi

I call Mark Seward, but we will extend the speaking limit because we've gathered some time. So Mark Seward, and you now have six minutes.

06:53:05 - 06:57:56

James Mark Sewards

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know many of my colleagues are keen to get in, so I'll try and keep it under five minutes. And I'm going to speak very specifically about my amendments 31 and 34. When the government brought forward this legislation, I was so pleased that they referenced enhanced know your donor checks because all political parties, before accepting donations from anyone, should know who those people are and where that money is coming from. We do know that malign state actors are seeking to influence our politics.

We know this, and they're often trying to do it through wealthy individuals who have the means to try and distort things here in the UK. So I was pleased with the government's announcement on know your donor checks. However, looking at the original bill as drafted, I didn't think it was strong enough. And with the support of my honorable friend, the member for Bolton West, was able to draft some amendments which I think will greatly strengthen the know your donor checks. So for example, on amendment 31, this states that parties must consider things like the location or the jurisdiction of the donor, any links the donor has to politically exposed people, and the source of the wealth being donated from.

I was equally as delighted when a few months ago, the government in a statement to this house at that dispatch box, in response to the Rycroft review, said that location would be incorporated within the know your donor checks. However, it is the second day back, I've had two select committees, some work on funeral regulation, I've looked through this and I haven't, other than in my amendment, been able to find that in any of the government's amendments. So I'd appreciate the minister's comments on that and whether the government is still committed to ensuring that location is something that political parties have to check before accepting a donation. I'd also like to ask the minister about those other two areas as well. Why did the government not consider it was necessary to also include politically exposed people or the source of the wealth being donated from?

I ask this because recommendation five of the Rycroft review said that know your donor rules should, and I'm quoting here, more closely mirror the customer due diligence provisions in the anti-money laundering regulations.

If a young couple from Leeds South West and Morley seeks to take out a mortgage, they have to answer these questions. So I think it's only reasonable and fair that a political party accepting millions of pounds in donations should also have to answer these questions. And I would just say to the government, if they have fully accepted the Rycroft review and yet have not incorporated these two recommendations, I would suggest that there might be a contradiction here that I would like the minister to acknowledge. And it is just worth saying as well, the things that I'm stating today in amendment 31 are not radical. They are not new.

The Electoral Commission said as far back in 2018 that these kind of changes could prevent foreign money being used to influence UK politics. The Committee on Standards in Public Life also said in 2021 that the introduction of these measures would be useful and that they should again rely on the money laundering regulations as the model that we should follow. So I would just be very interested in the minister's comments as to why those additional two things were not incorporated into the bill. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, just on amendment 34, as the bill stands, the Secretary of State can rewrite these risk factors by regulation. So that means that whoever stands at that dispatch box in two, five, 10, 20, 30 years' time will have the power to undo any of the progress made in this area without due consideration for anything else.

So my amendment here simply says that those factors, those risk factors, can only be changed to give effect to a recommendation from the independent Electoral Commission. They should be the arbiters of what is a risk factor and what is not. Now the government were absolutely right to withdraw the strategy and policy statement and also strengthen the Electoral Commission's independence, absolutely support that. Well amendment 34, my amendment, follows that principle exactly. So I'd be keen to hear the minister's thoughts on that too.

In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's so important that we recognize the threat posed by these malign state actors, by these individuals who want to disrupt our politics, and we should do everything we can to erect walls, to erect safety barriers to ensure that these individuals do not disrupt our politics for the long term. Thank you.

06:57:56 - 07:02:05

Catherine Eccles

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I rise to support the members whose excellent amendments I put my name to, there's dozens of them, I couldn't list them all, but they included electoral reform, capping political donations, crypto, and preventing domestic abusers from standing for election. But today I'm speaking in support of my amendments, new clauses 32 and 33, requiring candidates in parliamentary elections and local government elections in England and Wales to obtain an enhanced Disclosure and Barring Service check. Public trust in politics is at a historic low. The National Centre for Social Research found that 79% of people surveyed believe Britain's system of government needed significant improvement, and this long-running survey conducted since 1986 shows a marked decline in confidence in our political institutions over recent decades.

And the reasons for that decline are complex, but repeated cases of misconduct by elected representatives have undoubtedly played a part. In recent years, Parliament has seen a series of high-profile cases involving bullying, harassment, and sexual misconduct. In the last Parliament, several members were suspended, sanctioned, or forced to leave office following serious findings or criminal convictions. And in 2023, it was reported that more than 50 MPs had been referred to Parliament's Independent Complaints and Grievance Scheme for bullying, harassment, or sexual misconduct.

And the overwhelming majority of MPs and councillors serve with integrity and dedication, but the actions of a small minority damage the reputation of all of us in public life. The same principle applies in local government. Councillors often hold positions of public trust and responsibility, including things connected to safeguarding and child protection. Yet there have been numerous examples of councillors being convicted of serious offences or resigning following allegations of misconduct. We rightly require taxi drivers, teachers, social workers, healthcare professionals and many others to undergo DBS checks before they can work in positions involving public trust and contact with vulnerable people.

And it is therefore reasonable to ask why those seeking elected office should be exempt from the equivalent requirement. But of course, a DBS check is not a guarantee of good conduct. No safeguarding measure is foolproof. However, it would establish a minimum standard and set an important precedent. And it sends a clear message to those seeking elected office that they should meet the same basic expectations that we apply on everyday workers.

And as elected representatives, we regularly interact with constituents, volunteers, parliamentary and political staff, members of the public. We visit schools, youth groups, hospitals, care settings, community organisations, and in many cases we are coming into contact with children, young people, vulnerable adults. And in any other role involving that level of contact, a DBS check would be regarded as the basic and proportionate requirement. And since becoming an MP, I've had schools ask me if I have a DBS when I've visited, and they've been very surprised to learn that we are not required to have one. These amendments are not about restricting democracy, they're about strengthening confidence within it.

They're about safeguarding the public and improving standards in public life and helping to rebuild trust in our public and democratic institutions. My amendment would require candidates to hold a DBS prior to submitting their application to the returning officer, therefore not placing any financial burden on government or councils. I would urge the government to consider these proposals seriously, and could the minister set out what further steps the government intends to take to strengthen safeguarding, improving standards in public life and restoring public trust and confidence in elected representatives. Thank you.

07:02:05 - 07:03:32

Julie Minns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank my honourable friend, the member for Chester and Neston, for all of her work on this bill, and also welcome the minister to her place today here in the chamber. I wish to speak very briefly to new clause 48, which stands in my name. And can I thank the many members from across the house who have supported this amendment and the RNIB for their assistance and support in drafting it. The bill before us takes a significant step to strengthen and protect our democracy and extend the franchise.

But we must also recognise that one group of voters remains disenfranchised and unable to vote independently and in secret because they cannot see the ballot form in front of them. I first worked on the issue of accessible voting at the 1997 general election when I had the privilege of working for Scope on the Polls Apart campaign. Polls Apart shone a light on the physical barriers disabled people face when exercising their right to vote. And it went on to secure changes in the law to remove many of those barriers. But nearly three decades on, blind and partially sighted people still cannot reliably vote independently and in secret.

07:03:32 - 07:03:33

I'd be delighted to give way.

07:03:33 - 07:04:17

Marsha Cordova

Can I thank my honorable friend for the work that she has been doing on this bill, but particularly on trying to level the playing field to ensure that every member and every person has the ability to vote independently and in secret? And she rightly highlights that one group that includes myself are unable to vote independently and in secret because we're unable to actually see clearly our ballot paper. Does she agree with me that it's time for everyone to work together to ensure that we level the playing field and ensure that every person has the right, the ability and the right to exercise to vote independently and in secret?

07:04:17 - 07:07:21

Julie Minns

Thank you, and I thank my honorable friend for her contribution. She is absolutely right. This right was first enshrined by this Parliament, as the honorable member for Southampton Itchen said earlier in the debate, in 1872. Over 150 years later, blind and partially sighted people are still being denied that right, and it's time it was brought to an end. People like my constituent John, who at the last general election, when he arrived at his polling station with his guide dog, found that there was no usable tactile device at the polling station.

So John had to fold his ballot paper to make creases as reference points and ask the staff to read out the names in order as he navigated the creases to identify his candidate of choice. But unlike me and most of the people in this chamber, John could not be sure that his vote was private, accurate or truly his, because he was dependent on someone else verifying that for him. John's experience is echoed by RNIB research that found that only a quarter of blind voters said they were able to vote independently and in secret, while two-thirds had to rely on a companion or polling station staff. New clause 48 offers a practical way forward, and I am very grateful to the Minister for engaging constructively with me and my honorable friend the member for Battersea regarding this amendment and for indicating the government's readiness to act as the bill moves to the other place to give blind and partially sighted voters the right to vote independently and in secret. Will my honorable friend briefly give way?

I thank the honorable member and very much support her work to make sure that voting is accessible to blind and visually impaired people. Does she also agree with me that there are other groups, such as those with learning disability, who also face barriers in participating in elections and that there should be further work in future to make sure everybody has that ability for a free vote? I absolutely agree, and again, going back to my work in the 1997 election, I know that Mencap have looked extensively at this issue in the past in terms of accessible information for people with learning disabilities. In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would ask that the Minister in her concluding remarks places on record the government's commitment to dealing with this issue once and for all when it moves to the other place and ensuring that blind and partially sighted voters are able to make their own choice, mark their own ballot and know that their vote is their own.

07:07:21 - 07:10:26

Speaker 203

Public faith in our democratic system has been steadily eroded. Now, my honorable friends the members for Walthamstow and Oxford East provided some statistics on public opinion, but I'll provide a few more. More than half of the public believe that politicians almost always lie, while only one in eight believe that we put the national interest above party advantage.

Now, that level of disillusionment did not emerge overnight. Broken promises, diminished opportunity, and a growing distance from decision-makers have left many people feeling unheard. Money in politics has deepened that divide and has fueled the perception that access to power is available to those who can afford it, creating a suspicion that influence can be bought rather than earned. This is no longer simply a question of public confidence, it is a question of democratic resilience. Hostile states and malign actors seek to weaken institutions and corrode trust.

Disinformation poisons debates, blurs the line between fact and fiction, and encourages citizens to doubt what they see and hear. Every loophole in our political finance system is a potential point of entry for those who wish our democracy harm. Questions are also raised when voters see members earning substantial sums from outside interests, public duty traded for private gain. Taken together, these issues foster a growing belief that politics is something done to people rather than with or for them. That belief has consequences.

Where trust weakens, democracy weakens. Where democracy weakens, those who seek to exploit division find opportunity. So I do welcome the measures in this bill that I think seek to address much of the public concern around many of these issues. But rebuilding democratic legitimacy requires more than just tightening a few rules. It requires us to ask deep questions about whether our institutions still deliver the representation and accountability that people expect, and whether, if so many no longer trust the system, the system itself needs to change.

And it's for that reason I hope that the government will reconsider and commit to establish a commission on electoral reform, not to pursue a predetermined outcome, but to ask whether our political system is working as well as it should, whether it remains capable of rebuilding public confidence, and whether it is worthy of the trust that is placed in it. The cure for public disillusionment is not less democracy, it is better democracy. The answer to distrust is not disengagement, it is accountability. The answer to frustration is not to retreat, it is to reform. That is not optional, it is necessary, and it is urgent, and I'd urge the minister to take that into consideration.

07:10:26 - 07:13:32

Florence Eshalomi

Right, that was the final backbench contribution. Colleagues should be making their way back to the chamber, and I now call the minister, Florence Eshalomi.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I start by thanking all members who have contributed to today's debate for their constructive and informed contributions. Madam Deputy Speaker, I don't want to face a telling off by you, so given the timings, I will not reference each amendment, but instead will talk broadly to the main themes across this debate. Can I also assure members that have asked a number of detailed and serious questions that I've taken note of many of these questions, and I can commit to writing to them individually if I don't cover their areas in my closing speech.

I will however begin by addressing the points made by the Shadow Secretary of State and I really do want to welcome her into her new position and I wish her the best in her new role. I know that she will be a formidable force to battle across the chamber. But let's be honest, this isn't the first time that the honourable member's jumped on that reform bandwagon on their call for so-called non-native languages during elections. And it is good that thankfully we now have and we've decided that Welsh and Cornish are no longer on the banned list. But it would be very helpful to know exactly how far the honourable member wants to go on her war on native language.

And I will give the honourable member and I think it is good to see the 2024 intake in that role, but just a little bit of advice, you won't be able to out-reform Reform so don't bother trying. Turning to those who've engaged with the substance of the bill, several honourable members, including my honourable friend the member for Walthamstow, have sought to reduce the influence of large donations in our politics by introducing an annual cap on donations and domestic donations, which is why the bill already contains a package of significant measures designed to strengthen the political finance regime whilst ensuring that legitimate donors can continue to fund election campaigns. The Secretary of State and the Prime Minister are determined to tackle the UK-based issue of mega-donors in UK politics as the Prime Minister outlined yesterday. That is why I am happy to commit and announce the new cross-government task and finish team will be working at pace to find a solution with unintended consequences, without unintended consequences. And I can reassure members that once these solutions have been found, we would want them in force as soon as possible.

07:13:32 - 07:13:43

Speaker 165

I thank the minister for giving way. That is incredibly welcome news. Will she commit that this government will always act to protect the integrity of the next general election?

07:13:43 - 07:17:19

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honourable friend for making that contribution and I can tell her that all of us need to work to protect the integrity of all elections, not just the next general election. Every election should matter: local elections, regional elections, mayoral elections, every election should have the same weight in ensuring that they are free from from from any foreign interference. That's how we strengthen our democracy. A number of honourable members have tabled amendments in candidate safety, including my honourable friend the member for Poplar and Limehouse and my honourable friend the member for Bethnal Green and Stepney also spoke about her own lived experience. The threat to candidates, campaigners and elected officials is totally unacceptable.

Those who are convicted of relevant offences motivated by hostility against the candidate, campaigner or elective office holder can already be banned from standing for or holding elective office for five years. This bill will also introduce a new aggravating factor for those same offences and extend the regime to include relevant offences motivated by hostility against electoral staff. New clauses 58 and 59 tabled by my honourable friend the member for Poplar and Limehouse would add offences amounting to domestic abuse to schedule 9 to the Elections Act 2022 for the purpose of the disqualification order and require courts to make a disqualifying order alongside court orders relating to abuse or harassment when the relevant behaviour was aggravated by hostility towards someone's status as a candidate, campaign or office holder. This government takes domestic abuse extremely seriously and we recognise the devastating impact it can have on victims. I know the extremely difficult personal circumstances faced with my honourable friend and I thank her for her bravery and continued efforts to raise this important issue.

I can commit that we will review these laws and ensure the necessary protections are in place as the member describes with regards to domestic abuse convictions. The list of offenses that sit within schedule nine can be updated via secondary legislation. Regarding candidate requirements, the government recognizes that trust in our elected representatives is vital to the effective functioning of our democracy. It is precisely for this reason that the Representation of the People's Bill includes a number of measures to strengthen the nomination process for candidates. I would like to speak specifically to new clause 91 tabled by my honorable friend, the member for Warrington North.

This clause aims to require candidates who have been convicted and sentenced under the Sexual Offenses Act 2003 to make a declaration as to whether they are required to comply with the sexual offenses notification regime. This is a complex and sensitive matter, and we must ensure that any proposals that might restrict or deter individuals from taking part in our democratic system are carefully considered.

07:17:19 - 07:18:07

Catrin Emily Darlington

I thank my honorable friend for giving way, and she's making fantastic progress in protecting our democracy. In relation to criminal convictions, as she'll know, I have taken on my honorable friend's amendment about DBS checks to be listed as part of your register of interests once you are elected, in order to provide the clarity for schools, care homes, women's shelters to feel safe with candidates that they're inviting to their venues, whether they're their own MPs or counselors. Will she consider those as part of a way of transparency so that people can understand who may or may not be appropriate to invite to particular venues?

07:18:07 - 07:19:15

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honorable friend for making that important contribution, and I think it is right that we do look at the range of different requirements placed on candidates. My understanding is that for some local electors, local counselors, they are required DBS checks, but again, I think as many honorable members have noted, for us as parliamentarians, there is no such requirement. So I think this is something that we do need to test and look at further, and I can continue to work with her and other interested members in looking at this area. I turn to new clause 48 and the concerns of accessibility for voters and seeks to mandate the provision of an audio and tactile devices in polling stations. The government is firmly committed to support democratic participation for all eligible voters.

I recognize the important work that honorable and right honorable members from across the house have undertaken to champion accessibility and ensure that disabled people can participate fully in our democracy.

07:19:15 - 07:19:29

Alex Sobel

I know the minister has long supported changing the system of election to the House of Commons. The Prime Minister has also committed to it. Will the minister confirm the government is actively considering changing the system from first past the post?

07:19:29 - 07:22:05

Florence Eshalomi

I'll come onto the honorable member's remarks later in my closing speech.

Coming back to the issue of accessibility, I recognize the important work that honorable and right honorable members from across the house have undertaken to champion accessibility and ensure that disabled people can participate fully in our democracy. We agree with the principle outlined by the member for Carlisle in her amendment, supported by the lived experience of the member for Battersea and many other members. We will continue to work with her and other interested members from both houses on a suitable amendment that can be tabled in the Lords. Turning to electoral reform, a number of members right across the house have mentioned this. In the spirit of transparency, I think a number of members also know my position on electoral reform.

The government's priority is a politics that works for all people in all places, not some people in some places. The Prime Minister remains committed to electoral reform as a way of supporting that objective. However, we must be honest, this is a complex constitutional matter and it is premature to legislate now for one approach. I would be very happy to meet with many members from across the house to hear the views and look at how we can work on a stronger proposals and discuss the next steps. With regards to new clause 53, tabled by the honorable member for Stoke-on-Trent Central, the government recognizes the importance of ensuring that the rules on third party donation campaigning are clear, proportionate and workable in practice.

On new clauses relating to spending limit, we are aware of the opinion that an independent assessment is needed of the adequacy of the current spending limits in electoral law. And we agree that the Electoral Commission is best placed to provide that assessment. That is why the Secretary of State and the First Secretary wrote to the Electoral Commission on the 29th of August, asking them to expand the review of spending limits to include candidate limits, building on the government's current arts of the Commission to provide recommendations by July 2027, ensuring that the electoral spending framework is scrutinized and fit for purpose for the modern campaigning world we see today.

07:22:05 - 07:22:38

Lisa Smart

Very quickly. I thank the Minister and I think the asking the Electoral Commission to look at spending limits is really welcome. Can I just clarify though, as much as I love a task and finish group, almost as much as I love a task force or indeed a sub-committee, could she give a little more meat to what she's doing on donation caps, specifically timing and whether things will be in place ahead of the next general election, because I wouldn't want a member to withdraw an amendment for a separate division on not enough meat on the bone.

07:22:38 - 07:24:14

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honorable member and the Lib Dems spokesperson on this. I think it is important that I can't stand here unilaterally and write the terms of reference for that task force, but I'd be very happy to discuss with her at a later stage what that will entail. The honorable member for Hazel Grove spoke on voter registration provisions. We will move towards a more automated voter registration, but this takes time and we hope to use existing powers and non-legislative approaches as part of that. On amendments concerning AI, the government fully recognizes the challenges posed by AI-generated content, including deepfakes.

Whilst there is not yet a reliable or widely adopted technical basis for determining AI, we will continue to explore solutions and are taking a first steps forward. Several amendments relate to social media and elections. The government agrees we must protect the integrity of our elections from malign influence and greater transparency is part of that.

We believe that the way to achieve this is through a new targeted transparency regime, which is why we are strengthening the imprint through this bill. We have taken steps on tackling a range of threats from foreign states who are actively seeking to disrupt our political system. We are live to those issues that members have raised in this debate and through their amendments, such as deepfakes and online harassment. The Government is continuing to assess the best way to mitigate those concerns.

07:24:14 - 07:24:56

Peter Swallow

I'll give way very quickly. I thank her for giving way. I declare I'm the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Schools, who conducted a inquiry into votes at 16, speaking directly to young people. They are delighted that this bill will empower them with the vote, but they're equally concerned about mis- and disinformation and having the tools they need to engage in the democratic process. Does she agree that this is a key issue, and that if we are going to empower young people with the vote, we also have to empower them with the tools they need to use that vote in an informed and engaged way?

07:24:56 - 07:29:51

Florence Eshalomi

I thank my honourable friend for that important contribution, and these are many areas which the House and Select Committee, which I formerly chaired, will be continuing to look at, and I know that many honourable members will continue to feed in as we develop on those proposals. Madam Deputy Speaker, in closing, I want to briefly reflect on the purpose of this legislation again. Many members will recall the toll that the last general election took on those who stand. The Electoral Commission's own research told us that more than half of candidates faced harassment or intimidation in the course of campaigning. The Speaker's Conference heard worse: families targeted, tyres slashed, campaigners driven away from the streets where they were trying to represent.

Women and candidates from minority ethnic backgrounds bore this disproportionately, and I know from conversations across this House, including with members who sometimes don't want to discuss this because in doing so can invite further abuse, that this was not confined to the doorstep; it reached people's homes and their families. This is not robust political debate; it is organised intimidation, and it strikes at the willingness of good people to stand for office, or even not stand. A democracy that cannot protect those who offer themselves for its service is not in any sense one that is secure. This bill will not fix that on its own; no legislation could. But it takes this House further than it has done before, extending disqualification for hostility-motivated offences to cover election staff as well as candidates, adding a new aggravating factor for such offences, working with the Electoral Commission on a code of conduct and improved safety guidance for returning officers and candidates alike.

It sits alongside wider purpose. Trust in our elections is not owed to us as parliamentarians; it is earned through the integrity of the system we ask people to trust. This bill secures the system against foreign and illicit money, closing routes that hostile actors have sought to exploit through cryptocurrency, opaque company structures and unlimited overseas donations. It protects the people who make our elections happen: candidates, campaigners and electoral staff alike.

It keeps our democracy open to legitimate voters, including for the first time those aged 16 and 17, a change that I have long campaigned for and I'm glad to bring to this House as the Minister now responsible for it. And it modernises the machinery of registration and absent voting so that those participating in our democracy is neither harder nor more confusing than it needs to be. The next stage of this Bill is shaped by extensive engagement, by the Rycroft Review's recommendations, which the Government has accepted in full, and by many members across this House who have brought expertise, lived experience and in some cases at a personal cost to this debate. I want to thank all colleagues involved in getting us to where we are at this stage and to state again that the Government remains committed in doing whatever's necessary and I commend this Bill to the House.

Right. The question is that the Government new clause 72 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it.

The ayes have it. The question is that new clause 72 be added to the Bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it.

The ayes have it. We now come to Government new clause 76. I call the Minister to move new clause 76 formally.

Formally, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Entering into a regulated transaction with a part 4A of the PPERA 2000. The question is that new clause 76 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it.

The ayes have it. The question is that new clause 76 be added to the Bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it.

The ayes have it. So I love the vote now. Perfect, perfect, perfect, perfect, perfect, perfect. Order, order. Under the order, order.

Under the order of the House of today, I must now put the questions necessary to bring proceedings on consideration to a conclusion. Right. We now come to new clauses 77 to 78 and 113 to 117. I call the Minister to move new clauses formally.

07:29:52 - 07:30:11

Florence Eshalomi

The question is that new clauses 77 to 78 and 113 to 117 be added to the Bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it.

New clause 65 has been selected for separate decision. I call the opposition spokesperson to move new clause 65 formally.

07:30:11 - 07:30:12

I'd like to move.

07:30:12 - 07:30:17

Speaker 204

The question is that new clause 65 be added to the Bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no.

07:44:55 - 07:46:45

Speaker 206

Order, order. The Ayes to the right 166, the Noes to the left 346. The Ayes to the right 166, the Noes to the left 346. The Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock.

New Clause 67 has been selected for separate decision. I call the opposition spokesperson to move New Clause 67 formally. I beg to move. The question is that New Clause 67 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say Aye.

Aye. Of the contrary No. No. The Noes have it. Clear the lobby.

Colleagues should be seated or out of the chamber. The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Aye. Of the contrary No.

No. Tellers for the Ayes are David Reed and Gregory Stafford. Tellers for the Noes are Emma Foody and Jay Bottrell.

08:00:22 - 08:00:45

Florence Eshalomi

The ayes to the right, 105. The noes to the left, 410. So the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. New clause 88 has been selected for separate decision.

I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson to move new clause 88 formally.

08:00:45 - 08:00:46

Move formally.

08:00:46 - 08:00:55

Speaker 205

The question is that new clause 88 be added to the bill. As many as that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The noes have it. Clear the lobby.

08:17:15 - 08:17:18

Speaker 210

I call the Minister to move the amendments formally.

08:17:18 - 08:17:21

Speaker 208

I beg to move.

08:17:21 - 08:17:38

Speaker 209

The question is that government amendments 138 to 141, 63 to 68, 142, 69 to 84, 28, 86 to 99, 143 to 145, 100 and 146 be made. As many of that opinion say Aye.

08:17:39 - 08:17:49

Speaker 209

Of the contrary, No. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We now come to government new schedule 1, 2, 5 to 8. I call the Minister to move new schedules formally.

08:17:49 - 08:17:51

Speaker 207

I beg to move.

08:17:51 - 08:17:56

Speaker 209

The question is that new schedules 1, 2 and 5 to 8 be added to the bill. As many of that opinion say Aye.

08:17:57 - 08:18:08

Florence Eshalomi

Contrary, No. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We now come to government amendments 147 to 150 and 101 to 131. I call the Minister to move amendments formally.

08:18:08 - 08:18:09

I beg to move.

08:18:09 - 08:18:17

Speaker 209

The question is that government amendments 147 to 150 and 101 to 131 be made. As many of that opinion say Aye.

08:18:18 - 08:18:38

Speaker 209

Of the contrary, No. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Consideration completed, third reading. Now, Minister to move third reading. I call the Secretary of State.

Just be mindful, this whole business has to conclude at 8:03 and the shadow front bench may wish to speak as well. I call the Secretary of State.

08:18:38 - 08:21:14

Speaker 215

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that the bill now be read a third time. This bill strengthens our elections and takes a stand against hostile actors at home and abroad who seek to threaten them. It extends the franchise to 16 and 17-year-olds and automates voter registration. It protects candidates and officers and introduces new tougher rules around political donations.

The legislation reflects the commitments made in our strategy for modern and secure elections, which I published as Secretary of State in July 2025. It also now delivers a much of the Rycroft review into foreign interference.

It meets our manifesto commitments and sets the foundations for a new model of politics which is both stronger and fairer. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to reassure the House and honorable members during the bill's passage, we have committed to returning to various issues in the other place and I look forward to a strengthened bill returning. I want to briefly pay tribute to my honorable friends, the members for Chester North and Neston, Streatham and Croydon North, and Vauxhall and Camberwell Green, who have carried this bill through the House. And the member for Bethnal Green and Stepney, who delivered much of the policy which led to the bill. I also want to thank those members across the House who have contributed to the debates in this bill, and in particular, the opposition benches and those who took part in the bill committee.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, it would be remiss of me not to pay a special tribute to the honorable member for Humble Valley. As he said at the committee, this bill is truly groundbreaking legislation, and I most certainly agree with him as well. And finally, I'd like to thank my team in the private office, all of the officials at the Elections Directorate in my department and the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel, who have worked so hard to produce the bill before us today. This bill will leave our politics stronger and fairer, and all those who have contributed to its drafting and passage should take huge pride in having done so. These measures are the next step in the evolution of our democracy, strengthening our institutions and processes to ensure that they work for the people they serve.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, I commend this bill to the House.

08:21:14 - 08:23:23

Katie Lam

The question is the bill be now read a third time and I call the Shadow Secretary of State, Katie Lam.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I would like to begin by welcoming back the right honorable lady to her place. I very much look forward to working opposite her. As members on this side of the House have set out so well throughout the passage of this bill, this legislation professes to strengthen our democracy, but our democracy is not strengthened by proposals rushed through with too little time for proper scrutiny. Our democracy is not strengthened by allowing candidates to campaign in foreign languages and to escape accountability as they build campaigns based on group-based grievances. I was amazed at report stage to see the reaction on the government benches to the conservative policy that election campaign materials should be produced only in English or in native languages of the British Isles.

An election is a fundamentally important part of our conversation. It should be a matter of universal agreement that that conversation should happen in a language that everybody can understand. Our democracy is also not strengthened by allowing men in particular communities to direct how the women in their families vote, or by making it difficult for our citizens overseas to be able to cast their ballots. As I said in my remarks in report stage, when we make changes to the way that our democracy functions, those changes must always be designed to make sure that the British people can better hold their representatives accountable, that would-be representatives can meaningfully put their case to the British people, and that our democratic process is conducted according to the national norms and practices which have made this country such a successful democracy for so long. Given the importance of those aims, any such changes must be developed and proposed carefully and thoughtfully.

This bill fails those tests. Those of us on this side of the House will always remain open to measures designed to genuinely strengthen the integrity of our democracy, to protect our democratic process from foreign influence, and to ensure that our hard-won and dearly held liberties are extended to every citizen of this country wherever they may be. These duties are incumbent upon all of us as elected representatives of the people.

08:23:23 - 08:23:32

Speaker 214

We do not believe the bill before us reflects them and we will oppose it.

08:23:32 - 08:25:21

Lisa Smart

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker, it's been a privilege to be part of this process and listen to the impassioned contributions from members across the house from second reading through to bill committee and report stage. The contents of this legislation have been a long time coming and I owe a great deal to the hard work of the people who have campaigned tirelessly for improvements to our system and to clean up our politics. And of course those who do the work on the ground, our returning officers and those who deliver democracy on often shoestring budgets rarely get the praise they deserve so that we can sit here and we should be strengthening what they do and how they do it. We owe them the resources to do what's needed. The Liberal Democrats will support this bill tonight and we will do so because it extends the franchise to 16 and 17 year olds, something we have argued for over many many years and I would be delighted to vote for this evening.

We will also support this bill because without it corrupt practices will only entrench further. The know your donor regime is not perfect but it is a step we welcome and we will not obstruct it. We do not stand in the way of progress. This bill will make it easier for people to register, safer for people to stand and harder for the wrong money to stain our politics. These are good things and will have a long lasting effect.

I really look forward to the discussions with ministers that were promised on further work they're doing on donation and spending limits, they outlined them earlier. But the true test of whether the people really are represented fairly will be whether votes count when they are cast. That argument has not been resolved yet and I do not think it is an argument that will fade away anytime soon. For tonight though, I am content that this is a better bill than the one that arrived and that is down to the scrutiny and grit this house has been supported to deliver. I look forward to seeing how our noble friends in the other place can make it even stronger.

08:25:21 - 08:25:28

Speaker 212

The question is that the bill be now read a third time. As many that opinion say aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it.

08:39:22 - 08:39:33

Florence Eshalomi

The ayes to the right 411, and the noes to the left 102. So the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Unlock.

08:39:34 - 08:40:09

Hannah Kathrine Spencer

A point of order, Hannah Spencer.

In her opening remarks on the report stage of the important Representation of the People Bill, the Shadow Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, the honorable member for Weald of Kent, I'm sure very inadvertently, repeated misinformation about family voting in the Gorton and Denton by-election. Despite the fact this was run within the law and saw me elected with an overwhelming majority and that Greater Manchester Police found no evidence of criminality. So I want to ask what steps can be taken to ensure that that record is properly corrected.

08:40:09 - 08:40:37

Florence Eshalomi

I thank the honorable member for prior notice of her point of order. Fortunately or fortunately for the chair, I am not responsible for the content of members' or Secretary of State's or Shadow Secretary of State's content of their speeches, but it's up to them to be responsible for the content of their speeches. I do notice that the Shadow Secretary of State may wish to respond as she's in the chamber. We do not wish to prolong the debate, but a very quick response will suffice.

08:40:37 - 08:40:56

Katie Lam

No, I quite understand, Madam Deputy Speaker, thank you. It is an established fact that observers reported widespread concerns about family voting at the by-election which returned the honorable member to the House. It is up to every member and to the public to decide what to do with that information. The honorable lady is within her rights to dismiss it. I do not.

08:40:56 - 08:41:32

Florence Eshalomi

I do not wish to prolong the debate, but both points have indeed been put on the record and we'll leave it there. If the front benches wish to shuffle over, I will continue with the remaining business of the day. With the leave of the House, I will be grouping the following motions. Motion number three, Registration of Births, Deaths and Marriages. Motion number four, Energy.

Motion number five, International Development. Motion number six, Defense. Minister to move.

08:41:32 - 08:41:33

I beg to move.

08:41:33 - 08:41:42

Florence Eshalomi

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion on House of Commons Commission.

Minister to move.

08:41:42 - 08:41:44

Speaker 217

Move formally.

08:41:44 - 08:42:12

Florence Eshalomi

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. I'm now going to go on to the presentation of public petitions.

I see some people wish to leave the chamber. They should do so now if they wish to do so. Petition, Gareth Snell.

08:42:12 - 08:43:19

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, the great residents of Stoke-on-Trent Central constituency, like so many, enjoy accessing our airports to go on holiday. And so they are quite rightly concerned about the lack of a train link that exists between Stoke-on-Trent and Manchester Airport, similar to the system that we have that runs to Birmingham Airport. They're having to change at Piccadilly, it adds delays, it means that we have trouble getting businesses down, and all the evidence suggests that economically this would be a benefit to our city. So the petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the government to encourage the relevant train operating companies to establish a direct train connection between Stoke-on-Trent railway station and Manchester Airport, and the petitioners remain, etc.

Petition, Stoke-on-Trent to Manchester Airport train service. Petition, Caroline Voaden. No, not here. Petition, Rebecca Smith.

08:43:19 - 08:44:35

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Further to a similar online petition of over 4,200 signatures, I present this petition on local government reorganization in Devon.

The plans published in July by the government appear to have been configured entirely to benefit the urban areas of Plymouth, Exeter and Torbay and call into question service delivery, local democracy and local identity across the county's rural communities. Arguably there is no conceivable way that it can result in growth in every postcode. As a result, I welcome the Prime Minister's agreement yesterday to revisit the current plan and my hope is the strength of feeling shown by my residents in South West Devon, and I know the residents of South Devon too, as well as right across the county, will result in a meeting with ministers to discuss a way forward that benefits the whole county of Devon with local services we can all be proud of and does not create a two-tier Devon, urban versus rural.

Petition, local government reorganization.

08:44:35 - 08:46:34

Adam Jogee

Thank you very much, Madam Speaker, and a very happy birthday to you for yesterday. I rise to present a petition on behalf of hundreds of local people in Newcastle-under-Lyme who, like me, want to see a direct train connection between Stoke-on-Trent railway station and Manchester Airport, a connection that will benefit constituents not just in Newcastle-under-Lyme but across Staffordshire as you can see by my colleagues here this evening. The petition declares that there is a growing concern amongst residents and businesses about the poor connectivity between North Staffordshire and Manchester Airport. Notes that local people traveling to Manchester Airport by rail must currently travel via Manchester Piccadilly on a train that goes past the airport. Further notes the current reliance on a connection through Manchester Piccadilly risks a delayed journey, is inconvenient for families with several children and lots of luggage to carry, for older people and for those with mobility issues.

Further declares that too many people are forced to rely on a taxi, which is often more expensive and is at the mercy of the M6, the A500 and the A34. Further declares that a direct connection between Stoke-on-Trent railway station and Manchester Airport would be good for inward investment to our communities, including for jobs for local people. And further declares that a direct train connection will also help to ensure that Keele University and all the excellent businesses based at Keele Business Park are able to remain competitive with their rivals in other parts of our United Kingdom. And further notes the decision of August 2026 to confirm the rollout of such a connection. The petitioners therefore request the House of Commons urges the government, the relevant train companies and the relevant local authorities to successfully and speedily deliver the direct train line connection for passengers who live, learn and work in North Staffordshire between Stoke-on-Trent railway station and Manchester Airport.

Petition, train service between Stoke-on-Trent railway station and Manchester Airport.

08:46:34 - 08:47:46

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I present this petition on food security following extreme summer heat that has left tons of safe, nutritious but cosmically imperfect produce rejected at the farm gate, deepening import reliance and showing the urgent need for a good food bill. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urges the government to take urgent action to end the waste of cosmically imperfect fruit and vegetables by working with retailers to relax rigid cosmetic specifications and end unfair sourcing practices, introducing stronger powers for the groceries code adjudicator to guarantee farmers a fair price and bringing forward legislation to establish a national food strategy, including creating statutory duties relating to food security and access to affordable, healthy food. And the petitioners remain, etcetera.

Petition, food security and cosmically imperfect food produce.

08:47:46 - 08:47:49

Claire Louise Young

I beg to move that this House do now adjourn.

08:47:49 - 08:48:00

Florence Eshalomi

The question is that this House do now adjourn, and I call Claire Young on National Highways and the M49 Severnside junction. Claire Young.

08:48:00 - 08:57:10

Claire Louise Young

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Just off the M49 in Severnside is a junction that has never carried a single vehicle. It was built six years ago. It cost the taxpayer 40 million pounds, and in those six years, not a car, van, or lorry has used it. The national press has dubbed it the ghost junction.

I'm grateful for the opportunity to bring this matter before the House today, Madam Deputy Speaker, because the future of the M49 Severnside junction is one of real consequence for my constituents in Thornbury and Yate. I'm here because I want the junction fixed, and so do my constituents. I hope that the Minister listens and acts. Doing something about this kind of issue is exactly how you show people you're here to serve them and not yourself. We are all quite fed up with ineptitude.

First, some housekeeping. In response to my letter, the Department refers to this as the Avonmouth junction. It is not in Avonmouth. The Avonmouth spur lies some three miles down the motorway. This junction sits in Severnside.

I raise it because a botched junction whose supposed name is three miles adrift of where it stands tells you something about how far the responsible authorities are from the reality on the ground. I would be grateful if the Minister could adopt the correct description in his own dealings so there's no confusion in the future. I would not want the honourable member for Bristol North West to think I'm in any way moving the boundaries of our constituencies. Let me set out the background briefly. National Highways built this junction in 2020, as I have said, at a cost of 40 million pounds to the taxpayer.

It was designed to connect the motorway to the Severnside Enterprise Area, one of the largest concentrations of industry and logistics in the West of England, and it was forecast to support some 14,000 jobs. Yet in the six years since, not a single vehicle has used it. There is a reason for that. Ever since it was built, the junction has stood unconnected to the local network because the short stretch of road linking it to the estate had not been built, and no one would agree who was responsible for building it. In a letter to me, the Minister blamed a private developer for this.

Questions could be raised around whether National Highways and the previous council administration could have secured an enforceable agreement. But I will not rehearse that whole saga tonight. It is at last being resolved. South Gloucestershire Council has taken the work on itself, with funding from the Department. Construction is underway.

The council expects it to be finished by the end of this year. I want to put on record my recognition of the councillors and council officers who stepped in to deliver what others would not. They have done their part. However, that issue is not the reason I've sought this debate. We have now learned that the junction itself is defective.

National Highways has admitted that it's identified defects at the junction which must be repaired before it can safely open to traffic. A junction built by National Highways, completed six years ago and signed off as finished, cannot safely carry traffic until National Highways repairs it. Is the Minister as baffled as I am? National Highways has set out no programme for those repairs and no timetable for opening. The council has been told there'll be no further update until later this autumn, and the Roads Minister echoed this to me personally in response to my recent letter.

I would like to enlighten the government. The traffic that the junction would have carried has not simply vanished. It runs instead through my constituency's small country lanes.

Heavy goods vehicles day and night on roads that were never built to carry them. Residents in villages and isolated homes live with the noise and the lights of lorries passing at all hours. How can residents feel safe crossing their own roads? A parent with a pushchair should not have to weigh up whether it is safe to step out of their front door. Cyclists and runners have to tread carefully through what should be peaceful country lanes.

When National Highways told me the problem, they saw businesses as stakeholders, but not local residents. My constituents vehemently disagree. It's not just the smallest roads affected. Councillors and constituents alike tell me the A403, the B4461 and others are facing misuse by HGVs. Horse riders, agricultural vehicles and families are finding it difficult to access the roads.

If the Minister was looking for a way to apologize to my constituents for the debacle once it is fixed, he could do worse than improving the providing permanent safety improvements on roads like the A403. One constituent has told me he recorded multiple HGVs in just 15 minutes, seemingly over seven and a half tonnes, using the B4461 despite environmental weight restrictions. This is a regular issue in Hallen too. My constituents tell me it is difficult to report the vehicles because the short time you see them for is not enough to grab the registration and necessary details. They feel the companies using the roads pay lip service but never take concrete action.

I am totally against them breaching the weight limit in these ways, but I understand their motivation. They have no direct access to the motorway. The businesses of Severnside continue to wait. This is a major logistics centre and its operators depend on efficient access to the motorway and to the docks. Every year the junction stays shut is a year of longer routes and higher costs.

The economic case for this junction was made years ago and accepted by the then government, but the delivery has lagged behind. I need not explain to the Minister, Madam Deputy Speaker, why getting this junction functional is so important to the economic aims of this government. There are also further costs that fall on the council and local people. The council spent scarce funds repairing the very roads that this delay will now be damaging. HGVs continue to blitz through country lanes and newly repaired roads will only be subject to the same continuous pressure for longer.

The council expected the roads to be used by local people and that is why they repaired them now. It is utterly farcical from the perspective of both local people and the public purse just how much money and effort is being wasted due to the delays in opening the junction. The council will now have to find the money to mend them once again after traffic finally arrives on the junction. I need not explain why the funds are not there. This is public money spent once and needed again to repair damage caused by a failure that was not of the local authority's making.

This government's devolution agenda will be undermined if situations like this are not put right for local communities. National Highways is not a private developer the Minister can gesture towards. It is an organisation answerable to the Minister's own department. When it builds a junction that does not work and then declines to say when it will put that right, then I must ask the Minister just to justify their approach. My constituents and I find that approach unacceptable.

I understand that there may be legal issues and investigations the Minister cannot reveal, but the lack of communication from the department has been shocking. I want to raise one further concern, and I raise it as a question, not as a claim. I understand that this junction used a novel construction technique. One other location where this has been used has, I understand, been identified as defective. The House deserves to know whether these are isolated faults or two instances of something more systematic, more systemic, sorry, in how these structures were built and signed off.

So we already have an aging infrastructure. It's worrying if we are adding new problems to that. Let me close with a few questions and I would ask the minister to answer each of them directly. First, will he require National Highways to publish a clear timetable for the repairs rather than the open-ended promise of an update at some point this autumn? Second, will he tell the House what the defects actually are and when they were first identified, given the junction was declared complete in 2019?

Third, will he commit to a firm date by which this junction will finally open to traffic? Fourth, will he establish how a newly built junction came to need structural repair before carrying a single vehicle and whether the same fault affects other National Highways structures? Fifth, who is responsible? Will this government do what is right and launch an investigation so that the public and indeed all stakeholders can properly scrutinize those responsible? And finally sixth, will he provide additional funding for the council to repair the roads again once the junction is finally open?

My constituents have waited six years. They have watched a 40 million pound junction sit empty above a motorway they cannot use the junction to access and they have carried the traffic and the disturbance in the meantime. They're not asking for very much. They are asking for a date and for someone at last to take responsibility. I hope the minister can give them both tonight.

08:57:10 - 09:05:03

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Minister, if you're ready, Minister Justin Madders.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I also echo the many happy returns to you for yesterday? I do recall in a previous life you said across the dispatch box some many happy returns to me on a very special birthday which we don't need to remind ourselves of. But can I start, Madam Deputy Speaker, by congratulating the honorable member on securing the debate and highlighting an issue which is clearly of real importance to her constituents and to the wider Avonmouth and Severnside area? And I welcome this opportunity to update the House on the junction one of the M49. And I would like to apologize for the department's wrong description of the junction in previous correspondence, but it is correct to say that we are talking here about junction one of the M49.

Now clearly, as the honorable member has articulated, I recognize the strength of local feeling. Residents, businesses, local representatives and road users understandably want the junction to be brought into use as soon as possible. The government of course shares that ambition. The purpose of the junction has always been clear: to improve access between the Avonmouth Severnside enterprise area and the motorway network to support economic growth and reduce pressure on local roads. The government wants local communities, businesses and road users to realize the full benefits of this infrastructure.

The Severnside enterprise area is one of the most significant employment and logistics locations in the southwest region. It is home to major industrial, warehousing, distribution, energy and port-related activity. Better access to the strategic road network has long been recognized as important for the area's continued growth and for reducing the impact of traffic on surrounding local communities, as the honorable member mentioned. However, while I understand the frustration that the junction is not yet operational, the House should be clear about the complexity of the position.

arrangements and technical matters requiring further investigation and remediation before the junction can safely open to traffic. It is worth recalling that this was delivered as part of a wider programme intended to unlock economic development in the Severnside area through direct connection with the junction at the Western Approach Distribution Park. This is essential if the benefits of the junction are to be realised. The strategic road junction and local link road to connect to the existing network were being progressed through different delivery arrangements. And as we know, the link road connecting this junction to the existing road network was originally the responsibility of a private developer, with planning permission sought by South Gloucestershire Council.

National Highways was consulted, of course, as a statutory consultee, but had no legal power to compel the developer to develop and deliver the link road. And despite continued engagement, the developer was not willing to meet its commitment. But when it became clear that the original developer arrangements for the link road would not deliver the necessary local connection, this department, National Highways and South Gloucestershire Council worked together to identify an alternative way forward. That work led to the current link road scheme being progressed by South Gloucestershire Council. Therefore, rather than allowing the project to stall indefinitely, the government has engaged with its partners to enable the local link road to be constructed and establish a practical long-term solution that will bring the junction on the M49 into use.

And this has, of course, included ten million pounds of government funding. Of course, as we've heard and the House will appreciate, completing the local link road is not the only issue that needs to be resolved. As part of the monitoring and more recently detailed engineering investigations, National Highways has identified technical issues at the junction that require further assessment and remedial work before the junction can be safely opened to traffic. And I recognise this is disappointing for local communities and businesses. A junction visible from the motorway but not yet available for use is, of course, understandably frustrating.

Local representatives, as the honourable member has done, are right to seek clear answers about what has happened, what is being done and when the junction will open. Some may argue that the junction should simply be opened and any problems dealt with later, but that is not an approach, I'm afraid, the government is prepared to take. Where technical concerns have been identified, they must be understood, addressed and assured, and the public would rightly expect ministers and National Highways to act prudently and responsibly where engineering concerns have been raised. The House would expect no less in any constituency across the country. However, the honourable member has raised a number of important questions, and I would like to address each of those in turn.

First, she asks, will National Highways publish a clear timetable for repairs? And I will continue to press National Highways for a clear remediation plan, including the technical solution, delivery route and a clear timetable. However, the technical matters do require careful assessment. Engagement is taking place with the contractor, and an appropriate solution is dependent on the shared understanding of the engineering evidence and clarity on where responsibility and liability lie. Therefore, we can only confirm timescales once the ongoing technical and commercial discussions have concluded.

And it would be inappropriate for me to prejudge those discussions from the despatch box, but I have asked National Highways to update key stakeholders monthly and to publish the plans as soon as possible. Secondly, the honourable member asks what the defects are and when they were first identified. Defects were visible on the junction in 2021, including loss of topsoil and surface cracking. These came to light as part of the standard inspections that take place across the network, and at that stage, these were not deemed significant, and so National Highways put standard operating arrangements in place to monitor the structure.

However, this ongoing monitoring identified the need to undertake detailed investigations which were commissioned in 2025, resulting in the identification of geotechnical issues. These later investigations will allow the root cause of the defects to be better understood, and this is ongoing and can only be confirmed once engagement with the contractor has concluded. I have now discussed this with National Highways and formed the view that the honorable member should have been informed about this when the decision was taken to undertake detailed investigation report investigations rather than wait for the outcome of the work. Thirdly, the honorable member inquires whether I will commit to a firm date by which the junction will finally open to traffic. And as the honorable member will probably appreciate from what I've said so far, it is not possible to provide a definitive timeline for remedial works.

Responsibility, liability and funding matters remain subject to ongoing technical and commercial discussions, but once these are concluded, National Highways will be able to develop detailed designs for the necessary remedial works and to establish a delivery program. It would not be possible or appropriate to announce arbitrary dates before those assessments are complete or before a deliverable program has been confirmed. However, I do recognize it is particularly frustrating that after a long wait, the junction still sits empty, and that is why I have emphasized to National Highways the importance of their looking at options to open the junction as soon as possible. Safety is of the utmost importance, but I also recognize that given the remediation will take some time, we need clarity on whether the junction can be opened in any capacity in the interim. I expect National Highways to provide a timely update on this review.

I'll certainly give way.

09:05:03 - 09:05:25

Claire Louise Young

Thank, thanks, I thank the minister for giving way. I would just like to clarify, um, the minister said that, um, it would have been appropriate for me to be, uh, notified earlier. I think probably more importantly, South Gloucestershire Council, who are proceeding with the work, it would have been helpful for them to have been aware earlier. So could he just take that point back to National Highways?

09:05:25 - 09:10:14

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Grateful for the intervention. I absolutely take that point. I think all, all stakeholders ought to be informed at the, at the appropriate point, particularly when, as you say, there's, there's connected works to do with that particular junction. The honorable member's asked, asked how a new-built junction came to need structural repair before carrying a single vehicle and whether the same fault affects other National Highways structures. So I've been assured that National Highways are undertaking a significant quality incident investigation process to look at lessons learned, and once this has concluded, this will embed these lessons to ensure that this does not happen on other structures.

I would like to highlight, though, that these occurrences do not happen often, and I believe that this is not a systemic issue. But of course, we need to look into this to be assured of that, so I've asked National Highways to update the honorable member and other key stakeholders on the outcomes of the lessons learned process as part of their regular ongoing engagement. The fifth question the honorable member asked is who is responsible, will the government do what is right and launch an investigation so that the public can scrutinize those responsible. Questions have understandably been raised about responsibility, liability and funding of remedial works. National Highways is continuing confidential commercial discussions with its principal contractor, and as I said, I will not prejudge the outcome of those discussions from this dispatch box, but I do want to reassure the honorable member that National Highways is pursuing the matter with the seriousness it requires.

I know that as soon as these processes conclude, National Highways will provide a clear remediation plan setting out the technical solution, delivery route and program, as well as, I hope, a clear answer on where responsibility lies. As I've said, National Highways is conducting a significant quality incident investigation to establish what went wrong, identify lessons and prevent recurrence. I've asked National Highways to share the lessons learned following the conclusion of this investigation. Finally, on the question of funding, as I have explained, the government has already provided around ten million pounds of support to the, support the development of the link road, recognizing its importance. And I'm sure the honorable member understands there are limits to the funding we can provide, but we will commit to prioritizing the technical issues that we've described today.

But the government's approach is clear: National Highways must identify the right engineering solution, agree an appropriate delivery route, protect taxpayers' interests and provide stakeholders with realistic, deliverable timescales. The public deserves certainty, but that certainty must be grounded in technical evidence, not speculation.

Stakeholder engagement, of course, as we've touched on today, is very important. Local communities and businesses need to understand why the junction is not opened, what is being done to resolve the issue, and how progress will be communicated. There are, of course, as I'm sure the honorable lady will appreciate, limits on what I can say publicly when commercial discussions are ongoing, but commercial sensitivity must not become a reason for avoidable silence. So I've asked National Highways to keep the honorable member and key local representatives informed monthly, and updates should be provided when there is reliable information to share. And if the honorable member does not feel she is being kept up to date, I would ask that she let me know.

There are also wider lessons to learn. The public do not distinguish between a motorway junction, a local link road, a developer obligation, a council-led connection, and a National Highways asset. They see one road, one promise, and one delayed outcome. So we must be clear as a government and delivery bodies that managing infrastructure must be done coherently, with clear accountabilities, dependencies, and communications. That is why the department will continue to work with National Highways and South Gloucestershire Council as a delivery partnership.

South Gloucestershire Council is progressing the local link road, National Highways is responsible for the strategic road asset. The department's role in this is to support the overall objective of bringing the infrastructure into beneficial use, whilst of course ensuring safety, value for money, and effective governance. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, before I conclude, I want to return to the central point. Everyone involved in this wants the same outcome. Local communities want the junction open, businesses want better access to the strategic road network, local authorities want the economic and transport benefits to be realized, and of course the government wants all of these things to happen.

So we remain committed to seeing this junction brought into operation and to ensuring that its benefits are realized for local communities, businesses, and the wider regional economy. But we will do so in a way that protects road users, maintains public confidence, and reflects proper stewardship of public investment. So I would like to thank the honorable member once again for securing this debate, for the important points that she has raised, and for her continued campaign on behalf of her constituents. I assure her that I will continue to engage with her as we work to ensure that this junction is opened safely and that the intended benefits are delivered for the communities and businesses it was designed to serve.

09:10:14 - 09:10:20

Florence Eshalomi

The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order.