Social Housing Bill
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Social Housing Bill House of Commons
Follow its sittings


Matt Western
Thank you, Minister. So, as we heard, Gideon Amos is not present. Lee Dillon, do you know what his wishes were, whether he wanted to withdraw his amendment?
Matt Western
Is everyone content for the amendment to be withdrawn? Fine, amendment by leave withdrawn. Amendment three to clause 12 was just debated in group 11. Amendment three proposed to clause 12 as on the amendment paper. Ah, sorry.
In the absence of Gideon Amos, would any other member of the committee wish to press amendment three to a division? Formally? No. Okay. In which case, we move on to amendment 10, which has just, which was just debated.
Amendment 10 was tabled by Andrew George, who is not on the committee. Does anyone wish to formally put it to a division? Okay. We move on. We now come to group 12, which is led by amendment 82, proposed to clause 12, with which it will be convenient to debate government amendment 20, amendment 7 and 100, and new clause 8.
I call Gareth Bacon to move amendment 82.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you very much, Mr. Weston. It is a pleasure to serve on your chairmanship. I rise to move amendment 82, which stands in my name. I'm going to be relatively brief on this. I've tabled amendment 82 to introduce a vital legal safeguard to protect the structural integrity of the UK housing association sector.
Private registered providers are independent non-profit businesses and they work hard to run a fair and efficient sector, providing social housing and much-needed homes built. The amendment protects registered providers from overreaching state interventions that could have serious, if inadvertent, financial consequences. Housing associations can rely on private debt to fund development and any perception that central government can arbitrarily dictate their financial operations is a threat both to the business independence and the positive outcomes they effect. We must ensure that even well-intentioned regulatory oversight does not compromise the financial viability and building capacity of some of the most important businesses in our housing industry. So we will be seeking to divide on this point.
Thank you.
Matt Western
Amendment 82 proposed to clause 12, as on the amendment paper. Question is that the amendment be made. Leader.
Lee Dillon
Yeah, thank you, Mr. Weston. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I would like to speak to amendment number 100 and amendment number 7. So number 7 is tabled in my honorable friend the member for Taunton, and this really gets to the issue of the what. So what is being offered for disposal, whether that is social rent or it is energy performance certificates, and the amendment goes through a various array of what.
And then amendment 100 is really then the follow-up of that, which is the why. So why is a property being disposed of? Is that the financial viability? Is it because of the cost of retrofit? And we think that if we were to collate that data, then government would be able to reflect on the success or not of this policy in later years.
Thank you.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I beg to move government amendment 20, which requires sales notices from private providers to include information about whether the rent standard applies to the dwelling and if it does, the rent category of the dwelling. Engagement with the sector has highlighted the importance of potential purchasers knowing the rent category of a home when taking decisions about purchasing it. This is because the rent category has implications for the future rent that can be charged and therefore the future income potential of the property. I remain mindful, Mr. Weston, of the need to ensure that disposal notification is proportionate and limited to the information that is most useful to those considering purchasing the property.
We believe information relating to the dwelling rent category is a useful and reasonable addition to the information requirements. I therefore urge the committee to support that amendment. Turning to the other two amendments which were spoken to by members opposite, beginning with amendment 82, which would require the Secretary of State to have regard to the operational and financial independence of private registered providers when making regulations under section 171B or 171A. Mr. Weston, a common theme in my responses to the amendments on the disposals measure in this bill is that I recognize that private registered providers are private bodies who need to be allowed to make their own business decisions. In short, for that reason, I don't think this amendment is required.
If making regulations, the Secretary of State would necessarily be aware that housing associations are private bodies, and I can reassure the shadow minister that we have no current intentions to use these powers. The honorable member opposite spoke, I believe, only to amendment 100, am I wrong, not amendment 7?
And 7.
Matthew Pennycook
And 7. I'll deal with both in that case. The honorable member for Taunton and Wellington's amendment 7 would significantly expand the information required to be included in sales notices where a private registered provider intends to dispose of a property outside of the regulated sector to include, for example, whether a property complies with the decent home standard, its EPC rating, and whether it's been adapted for accessibility. The government's view is that adding requirements for more information to be included in the sale notice would not be proportionate. We don't want to impose additional unnecessary burdens on providers and certainly would not wish to see information requirements introduced that would mean additional reports need to be produced or surveys carried out, though I note the honorable member's amendment seeks to avoid this.
Our view is that extending the notification window to eight weeks, as we've previously discussed, will allow providers the opportunity to request further information they judge to be necessary to their consideration of a potential purchase. However, I do not think that requiring the inclusion of all this information by law is a proportionate response. Our aim is, as I've said previously, to capture the basic elements that would always be relevant to providers when considering purchasing a home and provide more time for inquiries to be made where needed. And that is the point that has come up in a couple of debates previously. This doesn't, the provisions in this bill prevent those notifications, those requests for further information between the parties in question being made.
And it's on the basis that I brought forward amendment 19, which I spoke to earlier, which requires information on the category of rent, which we do think is an important improvement. The honorable member for Newbury's amendment 100, which the honorable gentleman also spoke to, would require providers to categorize their reason for disposing of a property as either financial viability, the cost of energy efficiency retrofit, stock rationalization, or some other reason that might be specified through secondary legislation. My concern with this amendment is that seeking to prescribe particular categories of reason in the notice might result in a less helpful notification. Let me explain why. First, it requires providers to identify one particular reason behind the sale.
It is possible that the proposed sale will be based on more than one of these categories. It's also possible that there might be a different driver entirely. In response to a question, very reasonable question from the member for Broxbourne earlier, I tried to give a sense of the variety of reasons that individual providers might be disposing of particular stock. Second, there's also a risk that by setting out these categories in legislation, providers will just use these default descriptions of the reason and fail to provide a fuller and more helpful description for those being notified. And third, this amendment would have the effect, though I don't think this would have been the honorable member's intention, of preventing sales from going ahead if no sale can proceed without a notice.
That notice must be valid, and to be valid with this amendment in place, the notice must include one of a limited list of reasons. The government for that reason can't support an amendment which would have the effect of preventing legitimate disposals in this way. And for those reasons, I hope the honorable member might withdraw.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you. And thank you very much, Mr. Weston. I heard the minister's response to what I've said, and as always, I don't in any way doubt his sincerity, but unfortunately he will not always be in post, and I think we would prefer to keep the government honest on this point, so we do intend to press for a division.
Matt Western
So amendment 82 is proposed to clause 12 as on the amendment paper.
The question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. To the contrary, no. No.
Division. Division in 11. Lock the doors.
Speaker 19
Sajid Abu-Bakr. No. Stuart Aldridge. Aye. Sarah Bacon.
Aye. Danny Beales. No. Rachel Blake. No.
Serena Brackenridge. No. Lewis Cocking. Aye. Deirdre Costigan.
No. Lee Dillon. No. Mary Kelly Foy. No.
Speaker 15
Matthew Pennycook. No. John Slinger. No. Patrick Spencer.
Aye. Lloyd Turner. No. Steve Yianni. No.
Matt Western
The ayes were 4, the noes were 11, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. Amendment 8, and stood was debated earlier with amendment 102. Amendment 8, I think was put by Gideon Amos. Does any member wish to move amendment 8?
No. Right, in which case we move on. Government amendment 20 to clause 12 was just debated. I call the minister to move the amendment formally.
Move formally.
Matt Western
The question is that the government amendment 20 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. To the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it.
Amendment 7 to clause 12 was just debated in group 12. In the absence of Gideon Amos, does any member wish to move? No. In which case we move on. Thank you.
Amendment 100 to clause 12 was just debated in group 12. Does Lee Dillon wish to move? Does any other member wish? No, in which case we move on. We now come to group 13, which is led by amendment 4 proposed to clause 12, with which it will be convenient to debate amendment 11, clause 12 stand part, and new clauses 17, 64, and 65.
I would call Gideon Amos to move amendment 4 in his absence. Lee Dillon.
Lee Dillon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I would like to move amendment 4 in the name of my honorable friend, the member for Taunton. This amendment seeks to ensure that registered providers and local authorities discuss solutions to possible disposal in sensitive rural communities well before that disposal has taken place. I won't rehearse the arguments we made this morning around rural communities and the exceptions that they face, but I think the minister will understand from our side the concern that they have as much protection as possible.
Matt Western
Amendment 4 proposed to clause 12 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. As I've said out and we've now debated a number of amendments relating to this clause. The government is committed to protecting our much-needed social housing stock. As it stands, there is no requirement for advanced notification of disposals of social homes, meaning opportunities to retain them within the social housing sector can be missed. While private registered providers may choose to dispose of homes for valid reasons, including to support investment in new supply and the effective management of their stock, we understand this can have a particularly acute impact in areas where supply of social housing is already constrained.
It's therefore important that opportunities to retain homes within the social housing sector are not missed, particularly in areas with significant demand or where replacement is particularly difficult. Clause 12 achieves this by requiring providers to notify the relevant local authority and other registered providers in the area before a sale can be completed. It creates a short window during which completion of a disposal cannot take place while still allowing providers to market the property and continue with their disposal plans as usual. This window was set at four weeks upon introduction of the bill and as set out earlier in the debate, the government is seeking to extend that window to eight weeks in response to concerns raised by both houses and stakeholders that it was too short. This new window of time allows local authorities and other providers to consider whether they wish to acquire the property, helping to retain homes within the sector.
To help them in that initial assessment, the notice is required to provide certain basic information, for example, the address, the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, and its estimated value. I earlier spoke to amendment to also include the category of rent in the sale notice, which we think is a reasonable and fair addition. The clause overall, Mr. Weston, is targeted and proportionate. It includes sensible exceptions such as sales to another registered provider, sales to the tenant, and certain low-cost home ownership transactions. It is important to be clear that this is not a consent regime.
The clause does not prevent disposals, does not restrict who a property may be sold to, and does not interfere with the provider's ability to make legitimate stock management decisions. But it's a light-touch and proportionate measure to improve transparency, embed consistent good practice across the sector, and I've detailed some of the non-legislative means where we intend to work with the sector to go further and to support the bill's broader objective of safeguarding and sustaining social housing stock. Therefore, commend the clause to the committee. Turning briefly to amendment 4 in the name of the honorable member for Taunton and Wellington. This adds additional requirements to disposals in designated rural areas.
I do support the intention behind the amendment to ensure that a private registered provider and the relevant local authority discuss appropriate solutions to possible disposals of social housing in rural communities well before a disposal has taken place. However, I am not convinced that the best way to achieve this outcome is by requiring annual reports on stock condition and a statutory consultation on options for the regeneration of social housing prior to disposal. That's what this particular amendment calls for. The provisions in the bill will ensure a local authority is aware of a potential disposal. I would hope that that will give local authorities, particularly in rural areas, an opportunity to ensure that there is an effective dialogue before the disposal takes place.
Requiring statutory consultations on the regeneration of social housing would likely place a significant time and administrative cost on both local authorities and private registered providers and materially impact the ability of private registered providers to make the necessary commercial decisions required to manage their assets effectively and safely. More broadly, it's worth saying, Mr. Weston, through information published by the regulator of social housing, local authorities can already access information about PRP-owned social housing stock within their local authority area, including information related to whether stock meets the decent homes standard. An annual report on stock condition in many ways would be duplicative of the existing rigorous requirements that are in place. I'm therefore sympathetic to what lies behind the amendment, but not convinced it is a sensible one and that we need to legislate in this way to achieve our shared aim in this respect.
Lee Dillon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I thank the minister for that reply and in particular, I hope that local authorities and housing providers are listening to this debate and understand that the government expects them to work in a collaborative manner for the best outcome for social tenants. I won't be pushing it to a vote.
Matt Western
Is everyone content for the amendment to be withdrawn? Amendment withdrawn. We now come to amendment 11, which was just debated.
Amendment 11 was tabled by Andrew George who is not on the committee. Does anyone wish to formally put it to a division? No. In which case we move on. Clause 12 as amended has just been debated.
The question is that clause 12 as amended stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 14 and the question that clause 13 stand part with which it will be convenient to debate new clauses 41 and 45.
The question is that clause 13 stand part of the bill. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you Mr. Weston. Shared ownership is an important route into home ownership and it has enabled hundreds of thousands of people to get onto the property ladder who otherwise would not have been able to do so. However the government is fully aware that shared owners continue to face serious difficulties relating to affordability, transparency, management, staircasing and resale challenges. While some of these challenges affect leaseholders more widely, high and rising service charges would be a good example of that, they can have a disproportionate impact on shared owners given that the product is aimed at households on lower to middle incomes. Yesterday, it was yesterday Mr. Weston, I'm losing track of the days, yesterday I tabled a written ministerial statement setting out the government's position on shared ownership and the action we're taking to improve the experience of shared owners.
We are determined to ensure that shared ownership is fair, transparent and affordable across its life cycle. That's why we are taking forward a phased program of targeted improvements. The first phase which has been underway for some time has focused on improving the customer experience and giving providers greater certainty, stability and confidence to deliver new shared ownership homes. We've set clearer expectations for registered providers receiving funding through the social and affordable homes program, including giving greater consideration to long-term customer affordability, increasing transparency and fairness around costs and allowing customers to opt out of fees for optional services. We've also made clear that fees charged to shared owners should not be used as a source of profit or to cross-subsidize other activity.
Work is now underway on a second phase of our improvement program. This will include reducing barriers and costs associated with staircasing, exploring options to support resales, improving information and guidance for existing shared owners and reviewing buybacks as an exit route for those who cannot afford to remain in or sell their home. Alongside this we will improve shared ownership data quality and collection, helping us to better understand the experience of shared owners over time and pressures such as long-term affordability. Clause 13 would require a statutory review of shared ownership. I recognize the concerns that motivated the amendment in the other place.
Lord Young has been a consistent and forceful champion for shared owners and I commend his work in doing so. But these are precisely the issues the government is already focused on, will continue to progress through the improvement program that is already underway. As set out in the written ministerial statement I made on Monday, we have done lots to date, there is more to come on those issues I identified. And for that reason we feel that a statutory review would duplicate that work rather than deliver any practical improvements that shared owners need beyond the work that the government is already undertaking. And for that reason I urge the committee to oppose the question that clause 13 stand part of the bill.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you Mr. Weston. I rise to move new clauses 41 and 45 which stand in my name. I was aware obviously coming in here that it is the government's intention to strike down clause 13 from the bill and remove it in its entirety.
I've heard what the minister has just said about work the government is doing at the moment. We're not convinced on this side that that would require unnecessary duplication. What it would actually do is make sure that it is actually done and published. So we disagree with him or with the government on this entirely. My noble friends in the other place worked hard and successfully on a cross-party basis to bring shared ownership into the debate and into this bill.
Shared ownership has gone on for far too long and for far too many people it's been a logistical, legal, and financial nightmare when it should have been their first and proudest step onto the housing ladder. This is an important national issue and the commitments my noble friends made must not be stripped from the bill. Indeed, we must build on them. That's why I've tabled new clause 41, which would require publication of a strategy for expanding shared ownership. And I call on the minister to repair shared ownership for first-time buyers and support this new clause.
With regards to new clause 45, this amendment asks the Secretary of State to publish a model of shared ownership agreement within six months of this bill receiving Royal Assent. The opposition believes this is a crucial development for the future of shared ownership. What should be a pathway towards owning your first home is, for so many people as I've just said, a logistical and legal labyrinth of rent review, service charges, admin fees, and staircasing costs, which makes the dream of home ownership a nightmare. A model shared ownership agreement would provide a consistent framework with clear protections for buyers. It would also require registered providers to have regard to it.
I hope the minister not only agrees with that, but will at least give assurances as we debate this amendment, even if the government choose not to support it individually.
Edward John Argar
Thank you very much. It's a great pleasure as always to serve under your chairmanship. I rise in support of clause 13 remaining part of the bill. The minister himself set out with his typical eloquence the challenges, the opportunities that those with shared ownership face, but also the challenges and regulatory challenges that can sit around that, and the very real impact that when it doesn't work well it can have on those individuals often starting off on the path to home ownership, the impact it can have upon them. And therefore I do think that this clause is an important one because that review, without in any way gainsaying the important work that he is doing, and as I've said in this morning's session, I have a lot of respect for the minister, he's an extremely able minister and I know that he will be pursuing that work with vigour.
But I believe that the statutory review offers the opportunity for a much broader look at this in the round, under which actions such as those he's announced he's taking can sit perfectly reasonably. But the two are not in contradiction to one another. A statutory review doesn't stop the minister from continuing to pursue some of the immediate actions he's already set out he's taking, but it does give an opportunity to take a step back and look at this important sector of home ownership and assess whether it's working well and whether there are things that he may, however diligent he is, and I know he is, may have missed or the government may have missed. And it just gives that extra opportunity. And I know that the minister has been very clear in his determination to continue pursuing the course he's set out in his written statement and in his announcement.
But I do have to say this minister, who I have a lot of confidence in, may not always be in this post. When he inevitably ascends to higher office, his successor may not be as focused on this as he is. And therefore I think that a statutory review as set out in clause 13 offers the opportunity to have something that's been considered carefully, is published, and which members of this house and indeed future ministers can refer back to when considering the way forward. I don't think it trammels his freedom of what he decides to announce or his discretion in any way. I just think it would be a very important addition.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
I thank the honorable member for giving way, he's being very generous. Does he agree that the shared ownership eligibility cap, which has been frozen I think since 2016 and the previous government took no action on, that this minister has shown that he is willing to take action and has already announced that he is raising that from I think it's 80 and 90,000 to 90 and 110,000 in London and outside, and that shows the vigor that he is already progressing reforms to the shared ownership system.
Edward John Argar
Well, I think the honorable lady amplifies what I've already said about this minister, and before I do his, in front of a whip, before I do his political career too much harm by being too nice about him, I've been very clear in my respect for this minister and the work he is doing. But as we know, under, I was going to say under previous governments, but also under this government since 2024, ministers come and go with a certain alarming rapidity. And it is important that when there is something of such importance as this to so many people, that there is something that can underpin it, whether ministers move, in this minister's case I hope ascend, or whether they leave government, that whoever succeeds into that office and those responsibilities has something on which they can sort of hang their hat and plan their strategy. That's why I think that a review would not be a hindrance to any minister or to a government, but actually potentially of great help, not least in potentially giving the opportunity to further consider some of the issues objectively that the honorable lady has just raised. So I hope the minister will...
Lee Dillon
I thank the honorable member for giving way. Within the bill itself, there is clause 13, is the review of shared ownership and staircasing, which we support from this side. But upon exploring new clause 41, the clause says that the strategy for increasing opportunities for access to the shared ownership scheme, and it seems to me that it would be logical to carry out the review first of shared ownership before then committing to increasing shared ownership opportunities.
Edward John Argar
Well, I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman, it's always a pleasure to give way to him in this committee. I mean, one of the points I'm seeking to make is that I think that's why this review has the potential to underpin a much longer-term approach to this important sector, and that's why clause 13 is important. I don't see my honorable friend's amendment as being in contradiction to that, but rather complementary to it. Now, there may be a question of phasing and how it works, but I don't believe that that's a reason not to look to retain clause 13 for what it seeks to do. So I hope, and he is always a reflective man, I hope the minister will reflect carefully on that.
Danny Beales
Danny Beales. Thank you, Mr. Western. I just wanted to briefly talk about the challenges of shared ownership, building on what the minister's already outlined in the government's response in the written ministerial statement. I think this was an issue that was raised in the Commons when this bill was discussed recently. Many of us shared our constituent stories of shared ownership, the hopes of a first step on the ladder quickly turning into a nightmare, trapped, unable to staircase, facing all of the responsibilities of ownership but none of the rights to decide about major works, having to shoulder all of the costs of major works, both mortgage increases and rent increases, and really feeling kind of lost and unable to have a voice.
And much of the government's agenda on reforming leasehold or improving the rights of tenants, many shared owners feel they kind of fall between the gaps in this specific and unique tenure. Which is why I think when the bill was first discussed, there was many colleagues who were interested in the potential for a review as a means to address some of those concerns and issues.
I'm encouraged by the Minister's response and the written ministerial statement which has been laid, which I think specifically commits to review these areas of concern, the issues that I've heard from my constituents about the challenges of buybacks when major repairs are needed, particularly Union Park development in my constituency. Many shared owners are trapped at the moment with Home Group, their landlord, unable to get buybacks unless they're in extreme financial distress, but unable to sell because the market value is now not there with millions of pounds of repairs, the cladding and heating systems due, and their lives, as all of our lives change, and the need to move often happens, but they're unable to do that. So I kind of welcome the commitment for a comprehensive review of buybacks, the consideration of the challenges of staircasing. I think we all envisage that shared ownership will be initially a step that hopefully grows in future, but many find that that isn't the lived reality of shared ownership, and it becomes difficult to staircase and difficult to sell out of it. And I think I'd welcome in the summing up from the Minister if he could outline, in the written ministerial statement it commits to kind of hear the voice of shared owners in this phase two review, if he could elaborate a bit more about how exactly he envisages shared owners will be involved in sharing their experience to shape this work, and if he could outline a bit more about the timeline for phase two, which is very welcome.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Mr. Western. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I have lived in a shared ownership home, so I thought it was only right that I speak in support of this clause staying part of the Bill. Usually when I'm on Bill committees, I'm speaking the opposite, I'm asking the government to take something out of a Bill rather than to keep something in. I do think it is really important, and the Minister summed up in his opening, summed up the issues that lots of shared ownership constituents face right across the country. And if the government is already doing part of the review anyway, and if the government is committed to the review, I don't see why it can't stay part of this Bill.
Now, the cynic in me only thinks the only reason why the government wants to remove it from this Bill is so that they can change their mind and not actually do a review into shared ownership. It has been a long-standing feature now of the housing market for a number of years, so it is high time that we do do a review. And the previous speaker before me spoke eloquently about the issues that his constituents face in some of the developments that he's had. It's not too dissimilar from developments in my constituency of Broxtowe. There is major issues with staircasing, and when you have a shared ownership property, particularly with, I find, a large social housing provider, so a housing provider that operates, for example, all across the South East or all across London, residents who buy those shared ownership homes do feel like the social housing provider is unaccountable.
They lack transparency with the fees that they get. I mean, I've heard some horrific stories about people buying into shared ownership, using that as a stepping stone to want to buy a house on the open market, then having to buy selling packs off the social housing provider at extortionate cost, the social housing provider not getting back to them so the sale of their property falls through. So there are a number of issues that these amendments do try and solve within this Bill. And I urge the government, if they're already doing some of the work already and they feel that this review is needed, then why not keep it in this Bill? As I said, the cynic in me only thinks they want to take it out of this Bill so we can get a few months down the line and then the government go, we've changed our mind, we're not going to do a review of social housing.
If the government really wants to do a review of social housing and really wants to listen to them, and the Minister, as I said, outlined quite eloquently some of the issues that affect shared owners, affect leasehold and commonhold, and we look forward to that Bill coming forward, but shared ownership does fall through the cracks and we haven't spent enough time across this chamber speaking about the issues shared ownership tenants face. So I really urge the government to change their minds. And I was left with the impression after second reading on the floor of the House that this would remain part of the Bill and they would accept the amendments that the noble Lords did in the other place. And I hope the government can reflect and can keep this clause part of the Bill.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. Can I thank honorable members for the for those contributions? I said in my opening remarks, but let me reinforce it, we absolutely appreciate the fact that shared owners across the country, although I do think there is a regional element to this, the experience of shared owners in London and other parts of the south seem to me in terms of the feedback I receive to be far more problematic than shared ownership in parts of the north where it's quite a successful product and doesn't have the issues that often confront it. But there are serious affordability, transparency, management, staircasing, and resale challenges being experienced. I know that from my own postbag.
I have lots of shared owners, and I speak as a someone who grew up with a single parent myself, but lots of shared owners who are often single women who got a mortgage on the basis of an affordability calculation and have seen within two, three years service charges and other costs increase to the point that that their home is no longer affordable and wouldn't be counted as much on that affordability check. And they're under real, real pressure. So we recognize those. And I understand any shared owners watching will see this clause as a sort of lifeline. What I would come back to and I make a couple of points, notwithstanding the right honorable gentleman's points about the frequency with which ministers in previous conservative administrations were cycled through.
And I think I'm right in saying, Mr. Western, if I make it to Thursday, I am the longest housing minister to serve since 2010. So I've got a bit better form on permanence of our policy certainty and stability and ministerial policy certainty and stability. But notwithstanding that or his attempts to sort of beguile me with flattery, I can't accept these amendments for the following two reasons. And let me turn and take both in turn. But essentially, I don't think either are proportionate or necessary.
On new clause 45, this would require the Secretary of State to publish a model shared ownership agreement. But model shared ownership leases are already available, and they contain the fundamental clauses governing how shared ownership operates, including many of the matters raised by the honorable member. Providers delivering grant-funded shared ownership are required to use leases containing these clauses and comply with wider grant funding requirements. On the point of new clause 41, and I just to give members a sense that we are thinking about these things, and part of the reason that I made the written ministerial statement on Monday is that, and I throw my hands up to this one, we have done a huge amount of work in this area, and we have never brought it together into one place to state to put that in the context of a wider improvement program. And the fault for that is on me, but there is a lot of work that has already been done, and there is a lot of work to come, tackling specific issues.
Let me just name two. Staircasing: we know that shared owners who want to staircase can face barriers such as transaction costs, a lack of information, rising property values, and wider affordability pressures. The Homeowners Alliance, for example, estimate typical transaction costs around 2,000 pounds. That was two years ago in 2024. So in the WMS, we have committed to considering measures to reduce existing barriers to staircasing, such as those upfront and ongoing transaction costs.
Or buybacks: and I'm very acutely aware, and we had this issue arise in the context of the Renters' Rights Act as well, again from Lord Young pressing the case for shared owners. But I'm I'm absolutely and acutely aware that buybacks can be a lifeline for shared owners who through no fault of their own find themselves unable either to afford to remain in their home or to sell it, whether that be to building due to building safety defects, high service charges, or lease-related restrictions. Again, we have committed and made clear in that WMS that we are already and intend on undertaking a comprehensive review of the functioning buybacks to better understand practical barriers and solutions and look at specific issues such as the current use of recycled capital funding grants. So that work is underway. It's also worth saying that lots of the problems that affect shared owners go beyond them to affect other leaseholders.
And the actions we are taking in a number of areas will benefit shared owners along with other long residential leaseholders. A good case is the standardization and transparency measures that we are introducing in respect of service charges using powers previous government's Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act. We will be commencing, sorry, we will be laying those statutory instruments in the very near future so honorable members can look forward to those. But shared owners who are seeing those high and rising service charges will benefit from those provisions. But on the substantive matter at hand, the right honorable gentleman got to the point.
He frames this as an extra opportunity. I just gently say to him, he can put his ministerial hat on when he stood here over many, many years. Is it reasonable and proportionate to require through a Social Housing Bill a statutory review of shared ownership given all that the government is doing? Is it really proportionate to require that statutory review to just give that extra opportunity? Now, if honorable members are saying to me that we need to do more and we already consult shared owners network, other representative groups, if there is more that we can do and I'm happy to work with honorable members to get shared owners and their experiences into the government's thinking so that they are better reflected.
If there's more that we can do to improve the current improvement program already underway, I'm more than happy to hear that. But I do think it is a little stretching to say it is absolutely essential just for that, to quote the right honorable gentleman, little extra opportunity to cover those issues. We are looking at issues in the round. We are looking at the comprehensive set of challenges that shared owners face. So I think taken together...
On that basis, is he prepared to commit formally that there will be a review, whether it's on the face of the bill or not, that the government will launch a formal review of this? Well, what I would say to the right honorable gentleman is in some ways it is pure semantics. We have a comprehensive improvement program underway. If he goes and looks at my WMS from yesterday, he'll see the work that we've already undertaken, material changes including to the social and affordable homes program where we are setting firmer expectations on providers who receive grant funding. There's lots of work already underway.
So whether he calls it a review, an improvement program, whatever it is, I think shared owners across the country will be rightly focused not on what we term the work underway, but on the benefits they see coming out of that work. And they can already see some of those in terms of the expectations we set, but there will be more to follow. So just to draw out that point a little bit further then, will he commit in the near future to doing an oral statement on the floor of the house so that members from across this chamber can question and he can update us about what he's doing about shared ownership and improvements in shared ownership? My whispers in my ear, it is a matter for the speaker. It is indeed a matter for the speaker.
It is available to him and any other member of the opposition to call a Westminster Hall debate on this subject, an adjournment debate on this subject. I am more than willing to debate shared ownership or any other housing matter at any issue that we can look at. But I have made a written ministerial statement that sets out the government's work in this area. But taken together, Mr. Weston, the existing framework of model leases and guidance alongside the substantive program of improvements that's already underway, we think addresses the issues at the heart of both clauses. We continue to have constructive engagement with Lord Young and others in the other place who have concerns about this issue.
But we don't believe that either a further statutory model agreement or a separate statutory strategy is necessary. And therefore, I ask the shadow minister to withdraw new clauses 41 and 45.
Matt Western
The question is that clause 13 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
Of the contrary no.
Saqib Bhatti.
Edward Argar.
Aye.
Gareth Bacon.
Aye.
Danny Beales.
Rachel Blake.
Serena Breckenridge.
Lewis Cocking.
Aye.
Deirdre Costigan.
Lee Dillon.
Aye.
Mary Kelly Foy.
Matthew Pennycook.
Patrick Spencer.
Aye.
Laurence Turner.
Steve Yemm.
Matt Western
The ayes were five, the noes were nine, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 15 and the question that clause 14 stand part, with which it's convenient to debate government amendments 22 to 25, 46, 47, 26, 29, 27, 28, 30, 31, 48 to 57, 32, 58, 33, 59, 34, 60, 35, 61, 36, 37 to 42, 62 to 65, 43, 44, 66 to 72, 45, 73 and 12, schedule 1 stand part and new clause 30. The question is that clause 14 stand part of the bill. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. Clause 14 and its associated schedule, schedule 1, address a clear legal gap in respect of social housing tenancies, namely that existing legislation provides scant protection for social housing tenants who are victims of domestic abuse and who wish to remain in their current home without their abuser. Landlords can evict perpetrators, but only in cases where the victim has already left. That means that all too often victims are forced to choose between staying in danger or losing their home. As I argued at second reading, this is an utterly unacceptable state of affairs and taken together clause 14 and schedule 1 will end it.
Schedule 1 introduces stronger powers for landlords to enable them to take possession of a property where domestic abuse has taken place without the requirement for the victim to leave. Schedule 1 also strengthens protections to help victims remain safely in their homes where possible or move to suitable alternative accommodation where necessary. These measures form part of the government's wider commitment to tackle violence against women and girls, ensuring that the housing system supports rather than frustrates a victim's route to safety and recovery. The new mandatory grounds within schedule 1 seek to provide a clear framework by which courts must grant possession if the threshold has been met. Crucially, under the discretionary grounds within schedule 1, the court must take into account the opinion of the victim before making a decision, helping to ensure victims remain at the center of the process.
A key focus of the measures is providing certainty in cases of joint tenancies. Schedule 1 ensures that if conditions are met for joint tenancies, the court will transfer the perpetrator's interest in the joint tenancy so that the victim becomes the sole tenant. Where it is not appropriate for a victim to remain in their current home, the bill allows the court to order suitable alternative social housing where the landlord has such accommodation available. The court must as far as possible take into account the victim's views when considering the suitability of alternative accommodation.
If a landlord cannot satisfy the court that a suitable home will be available, the victim will not be forced to move under these provisions. Clause 14 and schedule 1 provide that the new measures will apply where the victim and perpetrator are personally connected and the victim currently lives in the property or left due to domestic abuse. The measures critically remove the requirement for the victim to have fled the property before possession action can be taken. The measures also protect victims of modern slavery where the victim and perpetrator are personally connected and the other conditions in the bill are met. We will continue to work with the independent anti-slavery commissioner, the Home Office and the wider sector to ensure effective implementation.
I should say on that point, Mr. Weston, it would be remiss of me not to do so, that our work with the Ministry of Justice and the Home Office has been, in my view, an exemplary example of cross-departmental working to resolve a really pressing issue. In aligning with the definition of domestic abuse under the Domestic Abuse Act 2021, the measures also cover a broader range of conduct. The measures protect those most at risk who currently live or previously lived in the property with the perpetrator while remaining clear and workable in practice. Turning now to government amendments 22 to 73, which address concerns raised in the other place about the evidence needed to use the discretionary grounds in domestic abuse cases. We've listened carefully to those concerns and we have acted.
These amendments strengthen the discretionary domestic abuse grounds by ensuring that the existence of a relevant protective order is sufficient to satisfy the first stage of the ground ahead of the court determining whether it is reasonable to grant possession. Where either a non-molestation order or a domestic abuse protection order is in force against a perpetrator, landlords may rely on it as evidence for the courts to then progress to consider whether it is reasonable to grant possession. This removes the need to separately establish whether domestic abuse has taken place where an order is in place, making it easier for social landlords to take possession action where a court has already made an order protecting the victim. An order will be disregarded if an appeal remains unresolved or results in the order being overturned. The amendments do not make possession automatic.
The courts will still need to consider whether it is reasonable to make a possession order, retaining judicial oversight through the existing reasonableness test. The amendments will simplify the process and give greater confidence to landlords and victims when seeking possession. These amendments also make technical and consequential changes to the domestic abuse provisions in schedule 1. They align the terminology used in the bill with the definition of domestic abuse in section 1 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021, make consequential changes and align wording across equivalent provisions in the bill and finally clarify how the tenancy transfer and possession provisions operate. The proposed amendments ensure that where the conditions for making a possession order on the basis of suitable alternative accommodation apply, the transfer of tenancy provision will also operate.
The effect is that the perpetrator's tenancy interest is severed in all cases where the ground for possession is met and where the court is satisfied that an order should be made. This will help deliver more consistent outcomes for victims in joint tenancy cases. Taken together, Mr. Weston, these amendments improve the clarity and consistency of schedule 1 and ensure the domestic abuse provisions operate as intended. I commend clause 14 and schedule 1 to the committee and beg to move amendments 22 to 73.
Lee Dillon
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I rise to speak to amendment 12 tabled by my honorable friend from Taunton and Wellington. The amendment looks at the impact of rent arrears on a victim of domestic abuse and quite simply asks that that not be a consideration when bidding for a future social home. If I can also while on my feet just talk to clause 14 in its totality. On this side we absolutely welcome the amendments that the government have tabled around domestic abuse, but I wonder if the minister can outline why you only use discretionary powers rather than mandatory, such as ground 7A which is mandatory for anti-social behavior.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you very much Mr. Weston. I rise to move new clause 30 which stands in my name. This is a probing amendment. I think there's much in this bill that is fundamentally political and ideological, but I'm sure that I speak for all members when I say that supporting the victims of domestic abuse is an issue that we all agree needs critical and cross-party work. We will not be opposing any of the 52 amendments that the government tabled to this part of the bill because it's vital that anyone stuck in an abusive household receives the urgent care and support and access to legal pathways that they need.
And that's why I've tabled new clause 30, which would require the government to assess the effectiveness of the provisions of protecting domestic abuse victims. If this bill is to make real change in this area, I believe it's only right that a guarantee is made to the victims of the government and that the government will closely analyze and monitor effectiveness of these measures, and I would look for an assurance from the minister when he sums up.
Edward John Argar
Thank you Mr. Weston. Can I just rise to speak very briefly to this grouping, simply to reiterate what my honourable friend the shadow minister has said. There is inevitably in a bill of this sort much that we will term for across this chamber about and disagree on, but throughout my time as victims minister under the new government now, there has been a significant degree of consensus in this space about a shared desire across both sides of the house to make progress to support victims of domestic violence and domestic abuse. And so can I just reiterate my honourable friend's and my party's support for what the minister is seeking to do here. I think there is genuine in this group, there is genuinely a high degree of consensus that we want to move forward and we want to make that difference.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you Mr. Weston. Can I thank the honourable gentleman the member for Newbury, the right honourable member for Elford and Siston. I never know whether I pronounce that entirely correctly. He can tell me on a different occasion. The shadow minister, I do welcome the cross-party support for the intent behind these provisions and their effect.
In some ways, I mean I'd go so far as to say they are groundbreaking in terms of what we have tried to achieve and as I've said very effective cross-departmental working. On the specific point that the honourable member for Newbury raised, there are mandatory grounds for possession in the bill. They apply only when a breach of a relevant order has taken place. The changes we have made to the discretionary possession grounds is to allow for the existence of an order to be relevant grounds for the court rather than a breach having to take place. But there are mandatory grounds in place.
I'm happy if he would like to set out that in more detail to him in writing if he would be interested. I know he takes keen interest in these areas. Turning to the two amendments that have been tabled, starting with amendment 12. This issue in a version of this amendment was raised in the other place by the noble lady Baroness Neep, and I'd like to give the committee the same reassurances that we gave the noble baroness and that the baroness accepted in debates in the other place. Firstly, I have to say that the government agrees with the principle that survivors of domestic abuse should not face unfair barriers to social housing because of debt arising from that abuse.
I think we would all agree on that point. That is why in the national plan to end homelessness, we committed to address the barriers faced by survivors of domestic abuse with debt when applying for social housing through our update to the statutory guidance on social housing allocations. We continue to believe that primary legislation is not the right approach in this area. There are sensitive and inherently complex cases at play here and the amendment would introduce a rigid rule which would not allow local authorities to take proper account of individual circumstances. Updated statutory guidance will allow us to set clear national expectations while preserving the flexibility needed to reach fair and sustainable decisions in individual cases.
Work is already underway Mr. Weston to review the guidance in question. We will consult on updated guidance early next year. As I made clear during the second reading of the bill, we continue to believe that guidance is the best route to resolving this issue. And I am happy to reiterate here, I think it was my honourable friend for Uxbridge and West Ruislip and my honourable friend for Birmingham Yardley who pressed me on the point that if guidance does prove insufficient, we do have the option of making regulations to amend the relevant legislation.
The government's position in that matter has not changed. We support the objective of removing unfair barriers for survivors. We believe updated statutory guidance, backed by existing regulation-making powers if necessary, is the more proportionate and effective approach. I will give way.
Danny Beales
I thank the minister for referencing the previous debate about this topic. I mean, I welcome the government's action in developing guidance in this case. There are very worrying cases that I've seen in my own constituency of rent arrears being a barrier for victims of domestic violence getting a tenancy. And I think there is concern that even though rules are already changed about local connections tests, they may not always be being applied effectively and local connections may still be being used as a route to block a victim of domestic violence. So I welcome the development of guidance in this space.
Would the minister further commit to collecting evidence about the implications of that guidance and whether it is or isn't effective enough on whether further measures might be needed?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honorable friend for that point. We will absolutely keep the effectiveness of that guidance under review. And I hope I can reiterate the commitment I've made, which I've tried to put in as plain a term as possible: if that guidance is not effective, we will use the regulations that are in place to ensure that we are resolving the issue in question. But we think in the first instance that there is a high chance that that guidance is successful in achieving the outcomes we want to see, and that is our preferred route in the near term. But I absolutely am determined to ensure this issue is addressed, as the Baroness accepted in terms of the commitments we made in the other place, and those regulations are available if we require them.
Turning to new clause 30, Mr. Western, the department already collects data through core social housing lettings on how many new tenancies were given to victims that left their previous tenancy because of domestic abuse. This provides an important baseline for monitoring outcomes as the reforms are implemented. The Ministry of Justice also publishes quarterly statistics on landlord possession proceedings in the county courts of England and Wales. These cover claims, possession orders, warrants, and repossessions, including for social landlords. We will work with the Ministry of Justice, social landlords, and the domestic abuse sector on implementation.
He would expect nothing less. This includes developing clear guidance so that landlords know how and when to use the measures and to support victims. The new clause would also require an assessment of how courts and other organizations identify domestic abuse. On the 5th of October, I'm sure he's aware of this, the government launched the judicial finding of domestic abuse as a significant step forward in improving the identification and management of domestic abuse offenders across the criminal justice system. As part of sentencing, judges will be required to make a judicial finding of domestic abuse in open court where the evidence supports such a finding as defined by the Domestic Abuse Act 2021.
This will provide a formal record where an offense involves domestic abuse. These findings will be recorded within court records and shared with police and probation. The judicial finding will enable police, courts, prisons, and probation services to more effectively recognize domestic abuse offenders and respond to the risks they pose. Finally, subsection 2B of the new clause extends beyond the purpose of these measures. The measures in the bill do not alter the way local authorities identify previous victims or perpetrators when allocating new social housing tenancies.
This is a matter for local authorities to determine when assessing need and priority for an allocation of social housing. On that basis, I would respectfully urge the shadow minister to withdraw the new clause. Mr. Western, as I've set out, the measures that the government has put forward in this group will help ensure that the reforms in the bill can operate effectively in practice.
The government amendments provide the necessary technical changes to support the operation of the provisions, ensure the legislation works as intended. I again welcome the cross-party support for the clauses in question. I ask the committee to support government amendments 22 to 73, and I commend clause 14 and schedule 1 to the committee.
Matt Western
Question is that clause 14 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
Of the contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Government amendments 22 to 25, 46, 47, 26, 29, 27, 28, 30, 31, 48 to 57, 32, 58, 33, 59, 34, 60, 35, 61, 36, 37 to 42, 62 to 65, 43, 44, 66 to 72, 45, 73 and 12 to schedule 1 have just been debated. With the leave of the committee I will put a single question on those amendments. I call the minister to move the amendments formally.
Matt Western
The question is that government amendments 22 to 25, 46, 47, 26, 29, 27, 28, 30, 31, 48 to 57, 32, 58, 33, 59, 34, 60, 35, 61, 36, 37 to 42, 62 to 65, 43, 44, 66 to 72, 45, 73 and schedule 1 to schedule 1 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
Of the contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Mr. Dillon, did you wish to...?
Lee Dillon
Given the minister's commitments from the dispatch box and his eagerness to move it himself, I won't push number 12 to a vote.
Matt Western
Thank you for that confirmation, in which case we move on. That is withdrawn. Schedule 1 has already been debated. The question is that schedule 1 as amended be the first schedule to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 16 and the question that clause 15 stands part, with which it will be convenient to consider government amendment 74 and schedule 2 stand part. I call on the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. Clause 15 introduces schedule 2 which gives the Secretary of State power to create one new general consent and removes the need to obtain the Secretary of State's consent for certain transactions altogether. There are a range of circumstances where local authorities must obtain the Secretary of State's consent to undertake certain actions relating to their social homes, including how they account for it and when and how they can dispose of it. Some of these consents also apply to private individuals who own property that was once owned as social housing by a council or a new town corporation. The first of these gives the Secretary of State power to issue a general consent to non-housing assets, for example shops or recreation grounds, being accounted for in the housing revenue account in accordance with part 2 of the Housing Act 1985.
This will enable the Secretary of State to permit all such accounting practices where they meet certain criteria. That will remove one obstacle from the process of planning new council developments.
It will also make it easier for councils to include these additional premises in their developments, supporting the creation of thriving, liveable communities. The second streamlines the process by which local authorities can serve demolition notices where homes are due to be demolished, which suspend or end tenants' right to buy. Under schedule 5 and 5A of the Housing Act 1985, initial demolition notices can be issued for up to seven years, and final demolition notices, which can be issued once a local authority has acquired all the relevant properties for demolition or has entered into binding agreements to acquire them, for up to two years. This provision removes the requirement for Secretary of State consent where local authorities need to serve further interim or final demolition notices if demolition cannot be completed during the time of the original notice, and it sets out requirements that local authorities must follow when serving further interim or final demolition notices. These changes, as I've said, will help local authorities manage redevelopment schemes more efficiently while still requiring them to follow clear statutory conditions.
Finally, the clause amends or repeals provisions in a number of acts that require Secretary of State consent for the onward sale of homes that have previously been owned by a local housing authority or new town corporation, even if those homes are already in the private market. These changes do not have effect in Wales, where the previous regime will continue. The changes will take away a completely unnecessary brake on these housing transactions in the private market. There is no longer any rationale for these now private homes to be subject to Secretary of State's consent, and consent is never in practice denied. All of these changes are part of a suite of measures planned by the government to simplify and streamline the council housing consent system in England and empower local authorities who know their communities best.
Turning now to government amendment 74, which makes minor and technical consequential amendments to schedule 2. Paragraph 1, subsection 3 of the schedule omits section 171D, subsection 2 of the Housing Act 1985. That subsection currently requires the Secretary of State's consent for certain onward disposal of homes already sold under the right to buy. As a consequence of that omission, references elsewhere in the Housing Act 1985 to consent under section 171D, subsection 2 are no longer required. Amendment 74 removes those redundant references, ensuring that the legislation operates coherently once the requirement for consent is removed.
The amendment does not make any further substantive change to the policy; it simply makes the necessary consequential amendments to give full effect to paragraph 1, subsection 3 of schedule 2. I commend clause 15 and schedule 2 to the committee and ask that the committee support government amendment 74.
Move formally.
Matt Western
Move formally. Yes. Something has gone wrong here. All those in favor, all those in favor of clause 15 standing part of the bill, say aye.
Matt Western
To the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Government amendment 74 to schedule 2 was just debated. I call the minister to move the amendment formally.
Move formally.
Matt Western
The question is that government amendment 74 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
To the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Schedule 2 has already been debated. The question is that schedule 2, as amended, be the second schedule to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
To the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 17 and the question of clause 16 stand part. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. It is essential that local housing authorities have flexibility to manage their stock in the way that best enables them to meet the needs of their local communities. Clause 16 therefore removes provisions in the Housing and Planning Act 2016 that would have forced councils to sell their highest value council homes whenever they came became vacant.
I would say would have forced because these provisions were never implemented by previous governments. Even so, the presence of the provisions on the statute book has a negative effect on local authorities' spending plans since they could not be certain of the income streams from these properties, which were typically earning higher than average rents and cheaper to maintain. The policy was intended, and I recall this because I sat on the Bill Committee at the time as a relatively new member, it was intended to raise capital to supply new social homes, but it would ultimately have led to the net loss of social homes. Furthermore, when the 2016 Act was passed, a major aim of the policy was to help fund the extension of the right to buy to housing associations. This government has made clear that it does not intend to take that extension forward.
The last Conservative government, as I said, chose never to implement these measures due to the negative impact they would have had on local authorities, and we are now going one step further by repealing the provisions altogether, and I commend the clause to the committee.
Matt Western
Shadow Minister, no one else wishes to speak. The question is that clause 16 stand part of the bill. Minister's moved. All those in favor say aye. Of the contrary, no.
The ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 18, the question of clause 17 stand part, with which it will be convenient to consider government amendment 75, government amendment 76, government amendment 77, schedule 3 stand part, new clause 40, and new clause 58. I call the Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. Clause 17 introduces schedule 3, which repeals uncommenced provisions of the Housing and Planning Act 2016, which would have phased out lifetime secure tenancies and required new social housing tenants to be given fixed-term secure tenancies instead. As per the previous provisions which we have just debated, these rules were never brought into force, and they would have reduced security for tenants. Indeed, the inclusion of the fixed-term provisions in the Housing and Planning Act 2016 received strong objections throughout its passage. The government supports the use of lifetime tenancies because they provide stability and security for households and help people put down roots in their communities.
Security of tenure matters, particularly for families, older residents, disabled people, and others for whom a settled home is the foundation of wider well-being and opportunity. This was the very rationale for the changes we've recently implemented through the Renters' Rights Act. Whilst promoting the use of lifetime tenancies, the government does expect landlords to make the best and most effective use of their homes to meet housing need. Landlords can support tenants to downsize, transfer, or mutually exchange their homes if their circumstances change. This helps people move to properties that are better suited to them and helps to make sure social housing is used in the fairest way possible.
Retaining the option for them to grant fixed-term tenancies is also an important tool, allowing councils to respond to specific circumstances, for example, supporting time-limited resettlement schemes. The schedule also retains the existing approach of succession by reinserting the relevant provisions from the 2016 Act, ensuring there are no substantial changes to how succession works in practice. The repeal of these uncommenced provisions will provide greater certainty to tenants and landlords and ensure the law continues to work properly after those provisions are removed. The previous government confirmed that they had no intention themselves of implementing the provisions in their 2018 Social Housing Green Paper after listening to residents' concerns. Once again, this government is going a step further and repealing these measures from the statute book.
I now turn to government amendments 75 to 77 in my name. These are minor and technical amendments to the succession provisions in schedule 3. Amendment 77 corrects the provision dealing with demoted tenancy so that it refers only to changes that apply to those tenancies. References to provisions that apply only to introductory tenancies are removed, as those cases are already covered separately.
Amendments 75 and 76 make clear that sections 143H and 143J referred to in the provisions are sections of the Housing Act 1996. These amendments do not change the policy or tenants' rights. They simply clarify the wording and make sure references are correct and in order. I commend clause 17 and amendments 75 to 77 to the committee.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Western. I rise to move new clauses 40 and 58 in my name. Social housing is not a one-size-fits-all, and new clause 40 seeks to protect the invaluable local expert knowledge of local authorities by giving them a greater say over the type of tenancies they can offer to local people. That would preserve local authority discretion to use fixed-term tenancies for social housing. Used appropriately, fixed-term tenancies allow landlords to review household circumstances at the end of a term and to make sure that the home can be put to the best use of those who need it most.
They allow for the flexibility necessary to ensure that where a tenant's situation has improved, a home can be made available for local people with the greatest requirement. This new clause is about empowering local authorities and delivering an efficient social housing system, two things that this bill fails to do in many ways. New clause 40 importantly imposes nothing and takes nothing away. It protects local knowledge, expertise, and discretion. With regards to new clause 58, social housing exists with the express purpose of providing those most in need with not just shelter, but a place to call home.
In a system under severe financial strain and lacking in adequate supply, it's essential that social homes are allocated to those in genuine need at the severest risk, not just those who once needed them but no longer do. And that's why we've tabled new clause 58, which would require local housing authorities to review lifetime secure tenancies every five years to ensure that the social housing continues to meet tenants' needs. It would also ensure that existing stock is used as effectively as possible. With 1.34 million people on the waiting list, a record number of people sleeping rough, and a staggering 178,000 children in temporary accommodation, not a single social home can afford to be filled by somebody who could reasonably afford market rent or buy their own property.
Danny Beales
Thank you. I completely agree that there's a desperate need of social homes in this country after decades of under-delivery, which this government is starting to turn the tide on. But I find it interesting because earlier in the passage of this bill in this committee, the members opposite were pushing amendments to support the further loss of council homes through allowing expensive right-to-buy provisions. The arguments don't seem to be compatible. I wonder if he has any reflections on that.
And do you not think that the threat of a review of losing your council home if you earn a bit more money might be a damper on aspiration and on trying to progress in life and get a better job?
Andrew Gareth Bacon
As I said earlier on, Mr. Western, this bill does not add a single social home to the tally that we have in this country at the moment. If social housing was in abundant supply, then I would agree with the honorable gentleman, but it is not. It is a scarce resource. And the important thing we're trying to make clear here is about how you use that scarce resource. Right-to-buy generates receipts which can be reinvested in building more social housing.
Given that the overwhelming majority of people living in social housing are on lifetime tenancies regardless of their circumstance, that housing is not available for people on the waiting list. It is already occupied, and nobody is saying that that should change. So it's not the case that right-to-buy causes a depletion of available social housing stock. It simply does not. New clause 58 is not an eviction notice.
It doesn't grant new powers to see people removed from their homes. This new clause is a common-sense move to assess how best to ensure that scarce resources are used for those who need a home most.
Matthew Pennycook
Let me start with new clause 40, which seeks to clarify that social landlords can continue to grant fixed-term tenancies. Fixed-term tenancies will no longer be available within the assured tenancy framework once the relevant Renters' Rights Act reforms take effect. I therefore understand this amendment to be aimed principally at ensuring that local housing authorities and other secure tenancy landlords can continue to grant fixed-term tenancies where appropriate. I want to be clear, Mr. Weston, this amendment is not needed. Nothing in this bill prevents secure tenancy landlords from granting fixed-term tenancies.
Thank you, Mr. Western.
The bill repeals uncommenced provisions, as I've said, in the Housing and Planning Act 2016, which would have required most new secure tenancies to be fixed-term. Those provisions, as we've just debated, were never brought into force, and we are now removing them to provide clarity. Secure tenancy landlords will still be able to offer fixed-term tenancies where they consider appropriate, as I've said, the bill doesn't change that. These amendments risk repeating what is already the case in law for secure tenancy landlords and would create confusion by suggesting the bill removes flexibility in this area when it does not. For those reasons, I'd ask the shadow minister to withdraw new clause 40.
Turning to new clause 58, which would require local housing authorities to review lifetime secure tenancies every five years. As I've already made clear when speaking to clause 17 stand part, this government supports the use of lifetime tenancies because they provide stability and security for households and help people put down roots in their communities. That is precisely why we are repealing uncommenced provisions from the 2016 act that would have phased out lifetime secure tenancies in favor of mandatory fixed-term tenancies. We do, however, expect local authorities and other social landlords to make the best and most effective use of their stock to meet housing need. However, we do not believe that a statutory requirement for local authorities to review every secure tenancy once every five years would be an appropriate way to support local authorities in doing so in terms of the administrative burden it would entail, and we believe it would have detrimental impacts on tenants and communities.
These are precisely some of the reasons that the previous government did not commence the provisions that it had legislated for in the 2016 act.
Speaker 43
Thank you very much. Minister, I'm losing track of the narrative here in this debate. You don't want to, the government does not want to sell the unit to the tenant and in that process foregoing all of the benefits of home ownership, you know, all the long-term health, economic, social, community benefits of home ownership. And at the same time, you want to lock them into lifelong tenancies, which would take that house out of action and reduce its availability to other households more in need. Maybe I've misunderstood the bill, but that's the narrative that I understand this government is taking currently.
Matt Western
Can I remind members that I am not involved in any way in this legislation and therefore to not refer to you in either of my roles. Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I fear the honorable gentleman does misunderstand the bill in a number of respects. Firstly, we are not abolishing or phasing out the right to buy. As I've persistently made clear, we want to ensure the right to buy is available for long-standing tenants who have lived in, he can intervene on me once I've answered his previous intervention, those tenants that have lived in and paid rent on their homes for many years. As I've already made clear in response to a previous debate, landlords can already consider changing tenant needs through a variety of methods from tenant surveys to direct engagement.
They already can support tenants to downsize, to transfer, to mutually exchange their home if their circumstances change.
What this amendment does is to mandate through primary legislation a review of every secure tenancy once every five years. And I simply put to the honorable gentleman, and this picks up on the precise reasons that previous conservative government did not enact the provisions that it took through its own 2016 bill, that that would entail huge administrative burden for local authorities. And we think because we believe in the principle of secure tenancies in social housing, both in terms of the benefits for tenants but also communities more widely, that we should not impose such a statutory review every five years. I'm struggling to see how that is incompatible with trying to place the right to buy scheme on a more fair and sustainable footing. I should say in closing, Mr. Weston, the government is reviewing how effectively social housing providers are using their stock.
This work is considering issues such as under-occupation... I will. I'll just let me make this point and then I will give way. But it's considering issues such as under-occupation, overcrowding, and how landlords are supporting tenant movement. We will set out findings from that review and next steps in due course.
So it is the case that we think social landlords can in some instances make better and more effective use of their stock. That doesn't necessarily require as a means to support them to do so a statutory requirement to review every secure tenancy every five years.
John Slinger
I thank my right honorable friend for giving way as he was wrapping up this section. Regarding social landlords reassessing the use of their stock, does he agree with me that there needs to be some more focus on the needs of disabled members of our community? And if I could just briefly with your agreement, Chairman, mention the case of Keely Cullen, my constituent who came to see me on Friday, who is disabled, but I would argue is actually disabled by the housing system, by the social housing system, because she's been waiting for at least five years to move into her own accommodation, which is totally unacceptable given her equal rights to housing in law. So I just wonder if you would reflect briefly on that as he sums up.
Matthew Pennycook
I'm sorry to hear about that case my honorable friend raises. If he wants to write to me with further details, I'm more than happy to look into it. I'd make two points. Local authorities are best placed to decide the types of social homes their communities need and to plan for them appropriately. And local authorities also have a statutory duty to promote adaptations for disabled people in all housing tenures subject to a needs assessment.
And there's obviously the disabled facilities grant that government provides to support them. I'm happy to set out in writing to him some more details about the support that should be in place, the expectations that government has in respect of local authorities. But as I said, if he wants to write to me, I'm more than happy to come back to him on the particular general points that might arise from that case he's mentioned. In general, Mr. Weston, we can't accept new clause 58. I've already spoke to the previous amendment tabled by the shadow minister.
I ask the committee to support the government amendments 75 to 77 and commend clause 17 to the committee.
Matt Western
The question is that clause 17 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Government amendments 75 to 77 to schedule 3 have just been debated.
With the leave of the committee, I'll put a single question on those amendments. I call the minister to move the amendments formally.
Matt Western
The question is that government amendments 75 to 77 to schedule 3 be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no.
The ayes have it. Schedule 3 has already been debated. The question is that schedule 3 as amended be the third schedule to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
Of the contrary no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to group 19 and the question that clause 18 stand part, with which it will be convenient to consider new clause 42. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. Clause 18 repeals unimplemented provisions that would have required councils to charge higher rents to higher income social tenants. We are now removing them to provide certainty and to clean up the statute book. These provisions, as with others we've debated this afternoon, were never implemented. Once again, I note that the original provisions in the Housing and Planning Act 2016 received strong objections during the passage of that legislation.
A mandatory pay to stay scheme would be difficult and costly to administer. Indeed, the previous government, despite legislating for this policy, chose not to commence it on the explicit basis that the costs outweighed the benefits. Income alone is also not the only determinant of who is allocated social housing. Some households may have additional needs or circumstances which mean that social housing remains the only viable or appropriate option for them. This can be the case even where their income may be somewhat higher than others on the waiting list.
Social housing is targeted to those who need it most, but some tenants' incomes may rise over time. Our focus is on keeping rents affordable and supporting all social tenants, not penalizing tenants for improving their circumstances. Landlords, as we've previously debated in a group just moved, landlords can encourage tenants to move if their circumstances change. Where tenants want to move or downsize, we expect landlords to support them to do this through transfers or mutual exchanges. This helps people move to properties that are better suited to them and helps to make sure social housing is used in the fairest way possible.
Where they choose, councils and private registered providers are able to run voluntary pay to stay schemes. This allows landlords to decide whether a scheme is suitable for their area. Councils can also consider an applicant's income and financial circumstances when deciding whether they qualify for social housing and what priority they should receive. Households with higher incomes may be given less priority or may not qualify at all. However, councils will also consider whether the household has other needs, as I've referenced, which can mean that social housing is still the right option for them.
Repealing these measures, Mr. Western, provides a fairer and more workable approach. This change will help keep rents affordable for social tenants, especially those on low and middle incomes, avoid disincentives to work, and mean tenants are not incentivized to reduce their working hours to avoid higher rent. I commend the clause to the committee.
Shadow minister.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Mr. Western. I rise to move new clause 42, which stands in my name. If the bill fails to build any new social housing, which we know that it does, then it could at the very least make sure that stock is allocated to those most in need. We believe that one of the fairest and most suitable ways to do this is to review the income eligibility thresholds for social housing. At present, up-to-date figures from the English Housing Survey suggest that around 186,000 social housing households have incomes above 50,000 pounds.
That is both an injustice and an inefficiency in need of fixing, yet the bill does not do so. We must ensure that any changes to the structure of the social housing system are made to make it a fairer and more effective program for the most vulnerable to find shelter. Social housing is a safety net, not a guarantee. People's circumstances change over time. Those who have the means to pay market rent should do so, and that's why new clause 42 would require regular reviews of income eligibility thresholds.
Without new clause 42, the bill provides no avenue through which to manage stock to free up more homes, no route towards building more social housing, and no light at the end of the 1.34 million person strong tunnel for those who find themselves on the waiting list.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western.
Before I respond to new clause 42, I've got to take on a point that the shadow minister keeps saying: this bill does not build any new social housing. I've made incredibly clear, and I encourage him to go and talk to his local authority, although I'm not sure its record on social housing is a particularly good one, but local authorities are very clear and have said to us in plain terms that the measures in this bill will incentivize them to build more social homes. But of course it's the case, of course it's the case that this piece of legislation is not the only means by which we are building new social and affordable housing. We have a 39 billion pound social and affordable homes program, dwarfs anything the previous government allocated in this area, and there is additional funding to come on top of that. On the content of new clause 42, this would require the Secretary of State to review income eligibility thresholds for social housing within two years of the act's passing and every five years thereafter, and to publish the findings and lay them before Parliament.
Each review would consider trends over the previous five years in household earnings, regional housing costs, housing affordability, and demand for social housing. Now I recognize the importance of considering income to ensure social housing is targeted at those most in need. Indeed, it's a sad truth that the residualization of social housing over many years, not least because of the engineered decline of it under previous governments, those increased right-to-buy discounts explicitly targeted to ensure more are being sold, but because it is residualized, it has become in most cases targeted at those on very low incomes. But we don't believe this amendment is necessary. Eligibility for social housing is considered through the allocations process, and there is no general national income eligibility threshold for social rented housing.
Local authorities, as I've made clear, can take financial resources into account in determining qualification and relative priority under their allocation schemes, subject to statutory requirements. Private registered providers also operate their own lettings policies. This allows local and individual circumstances to be taken into account. I will give way.
Speaker 46
The minister's been incredibly generous in these particular groupings, and I wonder whether he's going to be reflecting on these particular groups which are repealing what were, in my view, ideological attacks on something that is a very practical solution to a range of market needs and a range of affordability options for people. I wonder whether he's going to reflect in his closing remarks as we get to the end of this group that the previous government did not enact these measures because they were found to be impractical and also to actually cost the taxpayer money in terms of their implementation because of the risks of an additional administrative burden on local authorities and a risk to increasing homelessness, or is he going to remain as gracious and generous as he has been in terms of these groups so far?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honorable friend for the invitation to become ungracious in respect of the members opposite. I would say the following: I remember the debates on that 2016 bill committee. These were deeply ideological measures that were implemented. But I think it says everything that conservative ministers decided they were impractical, unworkable, couldn't be implemented, and made clear they did, and they made very clear, I encourage members opposite to go and read the 2018 social housing green paper where conservative ministers make very clear the huge administrative burdens that come from some of these measures as well as their detrimental impact on tenants and communities. What we are doing is going a step further, as I've said, and removing them and the uncertainty they provide for from the statute book.
On the provisions of this particular amendment, it is important to be clear that only a minority of social housing lettings are to high-income households, a very small minority. This is based on household income, not individual income, and in many cases could reflect two people each earning a modest salary rather than a single person on what anyone would reasonably describe as a high income. Now some households may have additional needs or circumstances which mean that social housing remains, as I've said, the only viable or appropriate option for them. Income should be considered alongside a household's wider housing needs and circumstances, but we don't believe this duty is necessary, nor that it would be appropriate use of resources for government to review every one of these independently set thresholds. In repealing the Housing and Planning Act 2016 pay-to-stay provisions, councils and registered providers will still be able to operate voluntary pay-to-stay schemes for households earning over 60,000 pounds if they wish to do so.
That discretion is important, it remains, but there will be no mandatory national requirement. This approach will avoid, as I've said, disincentives to work or increase earnings and support a more sensible system overall. I therefore ask that the amendment be withdrawn and I commend clause 18 to the committee.
Matt Western
The question is that clause 18 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it.
We now come to group 20 and the question that clause 19 stand part. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. Clause 19 makes a minor technical amendment to the Housing and Regeneration Act 2008. Section 320 of that act sets out the parliamentary procedure that applies to regulations made under its provisions. Regulations made under section 70, 72 and 126A are subject to the affirmative procedure. This means that a draft of the regulations must be laid before and approved by both Houses of Parliament before they can be made.
However, the provision governing the negative procedure currently excludes only regulations made under section 70 and 72. It does not also refer to section 126A. Clause 19 corrects this inconsistency, ensures that all regulations which section 320 specifies as being subject to the affirmative procedure are properly excluded from the negative procedure. This clause does not confer any new powers or reduce the level of parliamentary scrutiny, it simply ensures that existing statutory provisions operate clearly and consistently, and I commend the clause to the committee.
Matt Western
The question is that clause 19 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it.
We now come to group 21 and government new clause 21, with which it would be convenient to consider new schedule 1 and government amendment 79. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I rise to speak to government new clause 21, government new schedule 1 and government amendment 79. The right to manage can be a powerful tool through which social housing residents can take greater control of the housing services they receive, but it must operate within a clear, robust framework that protects residents and clarifies respective responsibilities. Taken together, these amendments will update and strengthen the right to manage, making it easier for social housing tenants to exercise that right with confidence while ensuring that appropriate safeguards are in place. These reforms have been informed by the findings of the review of the right to manage which was undertaken by the government.
Through the review, we heard clearly from stakeholders that the current right to manage framework has not kept pace with wider regulatory change. They highlighted the need for governance that is more proportionate and for greater clarity on roles and responsibilities and information sharing. We also heard from landlords and residents that the current routes for intervention if things go wrong can be slow and cumbersome. Sections 27AD to 27AF of the new schedule will enable a more proportionate approach to governance requirements. They will put in place lighter touch requirements where residents take on more limited services and stronger requirements where tenant management organisations assume more complex functions, including building safety responsibilities.
These provisions will also provide broader powers to strengthen the framework governing right to manage arrangements, helping to ensure it keeps pace with wider regulatory requirements, including on the safety and decency of social homes and quality of services to tenants. These are enabling powers that will allow us to update the right to manage regulations and guidance to govern management agreements, ballots of residents, regular reviews, and information sharing. These powers will come into effect on Royal Assent, but we will consult on the detail before introducing the new regulations and guidance. Sections 27AG to 27AL will also require regular reviews of the management agreements, strengthened requirements for residents to be balloted on continuation of TMO arrangements, and better information sharing between TMOs and their landlords. They will also strengthen requirements on landlords to consult TMOs on policy changes affecting functions exercised under management agreements.
Sections 27AM to 27AQ will create a targeted court-backed route for intervention in exceptional cases, including removal of board members where there is serious mismanagement of a TMO or a risk to resident safety. That route will be subject to judicial oversight, with the court required to be satisfied that urgent intervention is appropriate. This will help address the type of concerns raised by my honourable friend the member for Dulwich and West Norwood about the ability of councils to act swiftly where serious failings are putting residents at risk. We know that many TMOs work hard to deliver good quality housing services that respond to local priorities and are supported by tenants who give up their own time to serve on committees. These reforms will make the right to manage easier to exercise, clearer to operate, and safer for residents.
They'll support resident empowerment while ensuring that landlords have the tools they need to meet their regulatory requirements and safeguard residents, and I beg to move.
Matt Western
Management of local authority housing by TMOs. The question is that new clause 21 be read a second time. Minister.
Matt Western
New clause 21 as proposed. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many as of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
The contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 22 and government new clause 22. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Western. I beg to move new clause 22. Many councils and housing associations already work closely together to secure settled homes for people facing homelessness. We are committed to building on the many examples of good practice and collaboration that exist. However, informal agreements between councils and other providers do not always work, and private registered providers are less likely to offer accommodation to homeless households than councils.
This amendment therefore gives local housing authorities an additional tool to help them discharge the main homelessness duty. Where a council owes a household the main homelessness duty, it will be able to ask a private registered provider with social housing in its area to offer that household social housing. The provider must respond and offer suitable accommodation within a reasonable period unless it has good reason not to do so. We will consult councils, housing providers, and other relevant bodies before setting out in regulations what constitutes a reasonable period and a good reason. But to give an example, a private registered provider would not be expected to offer accommodation if they do not have anything suitable available in a reasonable timeframe.
The power includes important safeguards. Before making a referral, the council must take account of the type and amount of accommodation the provider has locally and the extent to which it is already housing homeless households. This will ensure that referrals are fair, proportionate, and reflect local circumstances. The approach builds on established practice in Scotland and delivers a commitment in our national plan to end homelessness. I commend the new clause to the committee.
Matt Western
Duty of private registered provider to offer accommodation after local authority request.
The question is that new clause 22 be read a second time. Minister, wish to move for me?
Matt Western
That new clause 22 is is the question is that the new clause 22 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye.
Matt Western
The contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 23 and government new clause 23, with which it would be convenient to consider government new clause 24. I call the minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Weston. I beg to move two new clauses, new clause 23 and 24, both of which look to strengthen homelessness prevention and ensure support reaches those who need it most as quickly as possible. Let me start with new clause 23. We owe a debt of gratitude to those who have served in our armed forces. They have given so much of their lives in service of their country and it's right that we support them to have a safe home on leaving active service.
Whilst thankfully the number of former armed service personnel seeking homelessness support is relatively small, the government recognizes that those that do can face challenges, particularly if they seek to establish themselves in an area where they may have no existing local connections. The existing legislation permits a local housing authority to refer someone to another local housing authority if a person seeking housing support does not have any connections to their local area to one where they do. This amendment provides a power for the Secretary of State to define in regulations where that should not apply. We propose to use that power to exempt our armed forces veterans from local connection referrals. This means that there will be no barriers or delays to veterans receiving homelessness assistance.
They will be able to seek support from anywhere in the country and the local authority will be required to provide assistance. This builds on the action we took last year to exempt veterans from any local connection tests that councils might apply to determine who qualifies for an allocation of social housing.
Will he give way?
I will give way.
Speaker 46
I strongly, well, welcome this move to remove the local connection test from armed forces veterans. I think it indicates the recognition that this government has for the role of local connection in sometimes providing barriers for people, particularly when they're vulnerable to make their way off the streets. I welcome that this issue has been acknowledged within this particular bill and I hope that there can be an ongoing conversation about the role of local connection in terms of particularly rough sleeping and how we support people to stop sleeping rough.
Matthew Pennycook
I very much welcome my honorable friend's support for this measure and I'm more than happy to have an ongoing dialogue with her about this issue as I do with so many others, but it's absolutely right that we look to do everything possible to support our veterans. I'll turn now to new clause 24, Mr. Weston. Homelessness rarely occurs without warning. We know that, yet too often people only come to the attention of local housing authorities when they have already reached crisis point. Many have been in contact with different public services long beforehand, but opportunities to identify risk, coordinate support and intervene early are often missed.
People often face homelessness despite engaging with services that are well placed to help prevent it. Our amendment addresses this challenge by introducing new duties on specified bodies to identify and act on a person's homelessness or risk of homelessness. This supports the government's commitment to prevent and relieve homelessness at the earliest possible stage. Those bodies will also be required to take meaningful action as part of their existing functions to address or relieve that homelessness. The duty will replace and extend the existing duty to refer.
It will mandate earlier engagement with local housing authorities alongside notifying them if someone requires support. It also mandates continued engagement with the local authority to enable it to support an individual as effectively as possible. It will also require specified bodies to consider other sources of support for the individual. Mr. Weston, preventing homelessness should not be the responsibility of a single organization. People at risk of homelessness often have multiple and overlapping needs, including poor health, unemployment, financial hardship or involvement with the justice system.
Danny Beales
I will give way. Thank you, Minister, and he's been very generous with his time. Just on this point about specified bodies, could he clarify that this would extend to hospital trusts, to prisons in the criminal justice system? As I'm sure he knows, that one of the most significant routes onto the street is from both of those public sector institutions.
Hospitals unfortunately rarely, if ever, count those who are likely or currently rough sleeping in hospital on discharge. And you know, positively, the government's rough sleeping strategy is committed to end discharge to street from hospitals, but getting that engagement from the NHS, from trusts, as well as the asylum system and prisons will be crucial to making this happen. So will this be a step forward in that regard?
Matthew Pennycook
I note and appreciate the points made by my honourable friend. We will set out the specified bodies in due course. I hear what he says about hospital trusts in particular. I think there's engagement to take place on the precise scope of the specified bodies we want caught within the new duty. But on the point of principle, and these are broad enabling powers, effective prevention depends on earlier identification, coordinated action, and shared responsibility across services.
Importantly, this is not about creating an entirely new system. Many services already undertake these activities to support homelessness prevention, whether that's identifying vulnerabilities, signposting support, making referrals, or working with partners to resolve housing issues. These new duties build on existing good practice and should drive a consistent national framework to support those most vulnerable. The government intends to define in secondary legislation, as I've said, both the bodies within scope and the actions required to comply with the duty. But my officials and I have heard my honourable friend's point.
Lee Dillon
I'm grateful for the Minister for giving way. Within the amendment, it talks about identifying the local housing authority to which the notification could be made. In additional legislation, is it possible that H could notify more than one local housing authority if they had a local connection, say in Liverpool and in Berkshire, to get them off the streets as soon as possible?
Matthew Pennycook
If he'll allow me, I'll write to the honourable member on that specific point. I don't have an answer to hand. I'm more than happy to set out how these provisions might work where multiple local authorities are involved. I take his point on that. As I've said, Mr. Western, we will define in secondary legislation both the bodies within scope and the actions required to comply with the duty.
This will allow us to work closely with stakeholders to ensure implementation is proportionate, effective, and reflects the differing functions of individual services. Ultimately, this amendment is about ensuring that services work together to identify risk earlier and intervene before people reach crisis point. By creating a more joined-up approach to homelessness prevention, we can help more people remain in their homes, shift the system away from crisis response, and deliver our ambition, as the Prime Minister has rightly outlined, of ending homelessness and rough sleeping. And I commend these clauses to the committee.
Matt Western
Referral of homelessness cases to other local housing authorities. The question is that new clause 23 be read a second time. Minister. New clause 23. The question is that new clause 23 be read a second time.
As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it. Government new clause 24 has just been debated.
I call the Minister to move the new clause formally.
Matt Western
Duties of specified bodies to collaborate and act on homelessness. The question is that the government new clause 24 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.
The ayes have it. The question is that the government new clause 24 be added to the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The ayes have it.
The ayes have it.
The bill is adjourned. Order, order.