Lords Grand Committee

13 October 2026

Lords Grand Committee House of Lords

Follow its sittings
00:00 - 00:10
Speaker 1
The first order is the Code of Practice on Access and Unfair Practices during the Recognition and Derecognition Process.  Lord Leong. 
00:10 - 02:08
Speaker 2
My Lords, I beg to move that the Committee consider the Code of Practice on Access and Unfair Practices during the Recognition and Derecognition Process.  My Lords, I'd like to start this debate by sharing with the House why we are introducing this code for your consideration today.  The Plan to Make Work Pay included a commitment to simplify the process for trade union recognition.  The Employment Rights Act 2025 updates the legal framework for statutory trade union recognition, ensuring workers have a meaningful right to organise through trade unions.  Last April, the requirement was removed for unions to demonstrate likely majority support at the application stage and to have at least 40% of the workforce supporting union recognition. 

The 2025 Act also makes changes to improve access arrangements for unions and aims to deal more effectively with unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition processes.  The Government is therefore updating the 2005 version of this code to ensure that all parties, including employers, workers, unions, understand how the legislative change on access and unfair practices affect them.  My Lords, we consulted on the revised code from 4th February to 1st April 2026.  The consultation asked for feedback on the clarity of updates to the legal framework, structural amendments from the Employment Rights Act and other changes to the code, including updated guidance to reflect modern work practices.  A number of revisions to the existing 2005 code have been made following consultation. 
02:08 - 03:12
Speaker 3
Previously, the 2005 version applied only to the recognition or derecognition ballot phase.  Now the code reflects the changes made by the 2025 Act to access and unfair practices and applies from the point at which the Central Arbitration Committee, or CAC, accepts an application for recognition or derecognition.  The code also sets out a clear timetable for negotiations on access: 20 working days from the date the CAC accepts a trade union recognition application.  If no agreement is reached, the CAC will have 10 working days to determine a reasonable access agreement.  Further, the code has been revised to reflect that the 2025 Act allows five working days after the close of the recognition ballot for companies alleging unfair practice to be submitted to the CAC. 
03:12 - 05:38
Speaker 2
Where such a practice is alleged, the Act makes it easier to determine such complaints by requiring the CAC to consider only whether an unfair practice has occurred, without considering the effect it may have had.  The updated code also increases the suggested frequency of access meetings and minimum length of meeting to once every five working days and 45 minutes respectively during the access period. 

My Lords, during consultations, employers expressed reservations about the proposed increase in the frequency and duration of access meetings.  However, my Lords, these changes will create more opportunities for meaningful engagement between the union seeking recognition and workers in the bargaining unit.  This will allow union representatives to answer any questions the workers may have before the balloted workforce decides whether to agree to statutory union recognition.  Employers will of course have similar opportunities to engage with their workers.  Additionally, my Lords, we work to reassure employers, especially small businesses. 

For instances, we've clarified that the statutory recognition process does not, and I say does not, apply to employers with fewer than 25 workers.  We've also ensured that the revised code won't require employers to breach general data protection requirements, giving them peace of mind.  The updated code guides on good access agreements, detailing key areas like eligibility, access methods, including digital, timing, privacy, and communication.  Finally, my Lords, the government has taken the opportunity to bring the code up to date with changes in digital communications and the code now provides significantly more detailed guidance in this area, including guidance on digital access.  My Lords, the revised code before the committee today reflects the updated legal framework for statutory trade union recognition. 

Together with the 2025 Act, these changes strengthen the collective voice in the workplace, enhance workers' representation, and help foster a new partnership of cooperation between trade unions and employers.  My Lords, I beg to move. 
05:38 - 05:46
Speaker 4
The question is that the Grand Committee do consider this instrument. 
05:46 - 07:13
Speaker 7
My Lords, I'm very grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for opening this important debate on the code of practice on access and unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition process.  By way of background, as the noble Lord the Minister knows, the government have committed to cutting the administrative burden on businesses by 25% by the end of this Parliament.  So I think it right therefore that this Grand Committee should consider what this draft code actually means for the businesses expected to implement it.  Employers will be required to navigate earlier union access, negotiate access arrangements within prescribed timescales, organise more frequent meetings, and manage digital communications.  So how does adding these responsibilities help to deliver that important government ambition to reduce the amount of bureaucracy? 

07:13 - 13:13

David Hunt

Now, under the revised framework, a union normally has five working days after notification of the Central Arbitration Committee's acceptance of an application to request access, as the noble Lord the Minister has just explained.

There then follows approximately 15 working days to negotiate an agreement. And if the agreement cannot be reached, the CAC will determine the arrangements. Now, for a large employer with an established industrial relations team, that may be manageable. But for a smaller business encountering the statutory recognition process for the first time, it means that they will have to find advice, understand unfamiliar obligations, and negotiate arrangements whilst at the same time continuing to serve customers and pay its staff. Now, the code also increases the suggested frequency of access meetings from once every 10 working days to once every five.

And their suggested minimum duration from 30 to 45 minutes. Now, more meetings means more scheduling, more arrangements for staff cover, and more time away from ordinary business activity. Now, my Lords, employers made their concerns abundantly clear. In the consultation, 98% opposed the proposed meeting frequency, and 97% opposed increasing the minimum duration to 45 minutes. And yet the noble Lord the Minister has not sought to justify why the government has retained both these proposals in the face of such outright opposition.

Now, the concerns extend beyond meeting arrangements. Employers feared that ordinary performance management, quarterly reviews, and shift changes could become entangled in allegations of unfair practice. 96% of substantive respondents said the draft provided insufficient guidance on unfair practices. Even ACAS issued the following warning, and I quote: "We are particularly concerned about recognition requests and decisions being legally challenged because of unclear language and guidance in the code." End of quote.

ACAS also identified risks of accidental non-compliance, inadequate practical guidance, and disproportionate difficulties for employers unfamiliar with trade unions. Its consultation response called for much more detailed guidance on digital access, including privacy, cybersecurity, and online intimidation. Now, the noble Lord the Minister will realize that digital access adds another layer of administration. The code envisages online meetings and union material circulated through email or the employer's intranet, normally within two working days of a request. In report stage of the Employment Rights Act, the government expanded the bill's general access provisions to include digital communication.

And that was only at report stage in the other place. Employers examining the bill as originally introduced could not have assessed obligations that were subsequently added. Now, whether ministers discussed those proposals with trade unions beforehand is something that only the noble lord the minister will be able to clarify, and I invite him to do so. What businesses deserved was a clear explanation of what the implications for them were. My lords, it does seem once again that this government regards employers' concerns as something to acknowledge and then disregard.

Businesses do need clear, workable rules, particularly when they are being asked to assume unfamiliar responsibilities. So I just ask the noble lord the minister not only to answer the questions which I've already posed and also deal with the very serious concerns that I've outlined. Will the noble lord the minister additionally commit at the very least to publishing better practical guidance for employers with clear examples distinguishing legitimate day-to-day management from unfair practices? And explaining, explaining please how digital access can be provided securely. I invite the noble lord the minister to respond to that point in particular as well as the other questions I have raised.

13:13 - 17:12

Sharon Bowstead

My lords, I would like to speak in praise of the guidance which has been produced by ACAS and declare my interest as a former general secretary of a major teaching union and president of the TUC. I read the guidance over the last few days. I think it is balanced, useful, and it clearly delineates the respective responsibilities of unions and employers. It's very clear, it's suitably detailed, and it's got the tone right with the emphasis on unions and employers working together, respectful relationships between unions and employers, and clarity of detail. And all those things are absolutely essential for effective and productive workplace relations.

I think it's really important to realize that unions should have the right to organize and should have the right to represent workers in the workplace, and that barriers to that right should not be artificially erected as they have been with previous trade union legislation. The draft ACAS code strengthens the collective voice in the workplace. I think that the guidance is really, really clear. For example, paragraph 18 says that nothing should militate against the employer's responsibility for health and safety, safeguarding, security issues, and where relevant the need for the employer to protect commercial confidentiality. It also says that these issues are generally not insurmountable and should be resolved through negotiation.

Parties are encouraged to take a practical problem-solving approach. There is clear guidance about digital access, and I do really want to emphasize here that we live in the 21st century. It is not the case anymore that you can reach most of the workforce through vast workplace meetings. Most employees deal with a lot of their working lives with digital access, and the factors to take into account are clearly delineated in the guidance. And indeed, guidance says the union shall ensure that disruption to business is minimized.

It is absolutely clear that nothing in the code encourages the employer to go against their legal obligations.

Nothing, the employer is not required to disseminate material which is harassing, discriminatory, threatening or defamatory. And equally, the employer should not refuse to distribute the union's materials simply because the content is contrary to the employer's wishes. Now, when it comes to digital communication, the guidance is really clear. Paragraph 59, the employer should allow the representative to make reasonable use of internal electronic communications, particularly if the employer uses such forms of communication to send the workers information arguing against the union's case for recognition. So, I would just say in conclusion that the guidance is clear and it's very sensible.

It commits and it encourages employers and unions to discuss how each party, the employers and the unions, will work together and campaign to avoid ill-judged activity which can damage trust and long-term employment relations. It is absolutely essential that this guidance is implemented in order for employers and unions to work together and to negotiate in a productive way which will reduce workplace stress and workplace disputes and enable employers to manage their businesses correctly and unions to organize and represent their members as they have a democratic right to do.

17:12 - 22:31

Sonny Liang

Well, firstly, before I respond to the respective question from the noble Lord Hunt, I need to make a correction when I was referring to the small business exemption to statutory recognition process. I said 25 days, which, 25 workers, which should be actually 21 workers. So I stand to correct that. My Lords, I'm really grateful for the support from my noble friend Baroness Bowstead on the code of practice on access and unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition process. Now let me address some of the questions that the noble Lord Hunt posed earlier.

Firstly, in respect of the five days and 45 minutes. My Lords, look, I have run businesses previously. I understand that staff time matters. But what's really important also is employers with fewer than 21 workers are outside the recognition, the statutory recognition scheme. So for those covered, the code's suggested meeting frequency and duration allow flexibility over practical arrangements.

Smaller meetings and arrangements suitable, suited to shift patterns on basically on minimize disruption. Workers should have a meaningful opportunity to ask questions and businesses should have a workable arrangements for providing that. And in respect of the granting access earlier, sorry, what I mean is the level playing field. I mean, employers have access to the workforce throughout the recognition process. By granting the union access to the workplace from the point when the CAC accepts recognition claim, this enables the union to also have access to the workplace from the start of the recognition process, at least once the terms of access are agreed and determined.

My Lords, also the code is a statutory guidance. It does not impose further cost on employers beyond what Parliament has agreed to in the Employment Rights Act.

My Lords, the noble Lord Hunt also asked about review. We will keep under review whether further non-statutory guidance is necessary alongside updated CAC guidance. We will also consider whether any further updates to the code are required when alongside revision in due course to reflect phase two of e-balloting in relation to recognition and derecognition ballots. We also recognize that in many of the respondents want additional guidance for those less familiar with the statutory recognition process. So the government intends to amend existing guidance on the gov.gov.uk website to support employers and trade union representatives participating in the recognition process.

The CAC also provides guides to the parties to enable both the union and employers to navigate the statutory recognition and derecognition process. These will also be revised in time for the implementation of the changes to the 2025 Act itself. It was also a question I think posed by the noble Lord Hunt in respect of digital access. My Lords, times have changed and moved on since the last revision of the code back in 2005. The increased emphasis on digital access reflects that and digital access is an important element of the access provisions in application process, recognizing that businesses with increasing reliance on digital forms of communication and in many businesses employees may not work from a physical business premises due to hybrid or home working arrangements.

So digital access will give them that ability to communication to communicate with their members either with the workers. So my Lords, the government is committed to simplifying and improving the recognition process, ensuring workers have a meaningful right to organize through trade unions. The revised code is part of that. It supports the Employment Rights Act by providing better access arrangements for unions and dealing more effectively with unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition process. We have listened very carefully to the views expressed during consultation early this year.

So we have amended the code to aid clarity and support practical use as far as possible. I believe my Lord, the code before us will assist both unions and employers in complying with the new statutory requirements regarding access and unfair practices.

22:31 - 23:50

David Hunt

My Lords, I'm listening very carefully to what the noble Lord the Minister said, but he still hasn't explained to us the extent to which such a huge percentage, nearly 100% of those who were consulted did not feel that the government had listened carefully to their points on the code. And also he hasn't explained how we can ensure that digital access is proved to be secure. Allowing a trade union access into the internal mechanisms and lines of communication of any employer without establishing, as was previously necessary, any evidence that the employees would like to entertain the idea of joining a trade union. This is a huge change and it really must be provided securely. To allow anyone to come into the internal mechanism of any employer in the UK is surely a step too far.

23:50 - 25:49

Sonny Liang

Well, I thank the noble lord for that. Let me try to address this whole thing about security and digital access. The code does not require the employer to give the union itself, including any union official that is not one of the employer's workers, information that would be in breach of GDPR. So that's a safeguard itself, or for that matter, any other data protection law requirements. Nor does the code require an employer to give the union itself, including an employee of the union, access to the employer's electronic system or to change their IT system to meet access requirements.

So that safeguard actually protects that security itself and nothing will affect the GDPR rules that I stated earlier. Now, what I want to say about in response to the consultation and listening to employers, look, we have consulted. Yes, employers may not agree with some position that we have taken, but look, in government, we've got to ensure that the rights of workers, the right to union recognition, and also employers have an opportunity to also consult their workers if they so wish to, is there. And this is what we are doing. We are giving the unions and the employers the opportunity to work within a framework to whether recognize or derecognize the unions.

So we may disagree with what the employer says, but we believe this is the right decision that we are taking to give employers and unions that framework. So my lords, I believe the code before us will assist both unions and employers in complying with the new statutory requirements regarding access and unfair practices during the recognition and derecognition process. And my lords, I beg to move.

25:49 - 26:11

Speaker 1

The question is that the Grand Committee has considered this instrument. As many of that opinion say content. Content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.

Modification of the Law British Steel Limited Property Transfer Regulations 2026, Lord Leong.

26:11 - 33:01

Sonny Liang

My lords, I beg to move that the committee consider the modification of the Law British Steel Limited Property Transfer Regulations 2026. The instrument before the committee is a necessary part of the wider legal framework that has brought British Steel into public ownership. My lords, I will begin by setting out why this legal certainty matters. Steel is a foundation industry. It supports our national infrastructure, our defense and security, our clean energy ambitions, and wider economic growth.

British Steel is a major producer in the United Kingdom, providing products that are essential to the construction, maintenance, and operation of critical infrastructure. This led to my friend, the right honorable member for Hove and Portslade, the Secretary of State at that time of the transfer, to conclude, following careful consideration of the public interest test in the Steel Industry Nationalisation Act 2026, that it was necessary to bring British Steel into public ownership. This was an exceptional step and it was not taken lightly. The government had previously used the Steel Industry Special Measures Act in 2025 to maintain continued and safe steel production. Following unsuccessful negotiations with the owner and given the risk of serious disruption to domestic steelmaking capabilities, the government determined that public ownership was the only viable route to secure continuity while longer-term options for the businesses are explored.

The instrument we are debating today did not transfer British Steel into public ownership. This was done by the British Steel Limited Property Transfer Regulation 2026. The purpose of this statutory instrument is narrower but critically important to the transfer. Together, the two instruments give practical effect to the transfer. The Modification of the Law British Steel Limited Transfer Regulations 2026, which are before the committee today, ensures that the mechanics of the transfer operated effectively and provided for effective operation of the business post-transfer.

In doing so, it protected the continuity of operations and gave legal certainty to employees, customers, suppliers, and other parties affected by the transfer. My Lords, I know Noble Lords will rightly want assurance that scrutiny has not been bypassed, and I therefore welcome the scrutiny today. The instrument was made using the made affirmative procedure because it needed to come into force simultaneously with the property transfer regulations in circumstances that were commercially sensitive and where operational continuity was essential. Notices were provided to the speakers before the instrument was laid, explaining why it was necessary for it to come into force before laying. The instrument is now before both houses for approval, as Parliament intended when it passed the 2026 Act.

The modifications are deliberately targeted. They are made under Section 50 of the Steel Industry Nationalisation Act 2026, which allows the Secretary of State to modify the law only for the purposes of enabling the transfer powers in Part 1 of the Act to be used effectively. This is not a general power to rewrite the law. It is a limited power tied to the effective operation of a particular transfer. This instrument relates specifically to the British Steel transfer.

There are five technical areas of the law which require modification to ensure the effectiveness of the transfer of British Steel. This is necessary because a legislative nationalisation at pace was not envisioned when those laws were first drafted. Firstly, the instrument ensures that the Transfer of Undertakings Protection of Employment Regulations 2006, TUPE, apply to employees moving on from the old company to the new company. This meant British Steel employees have certainty about their continuity of their job and the terms and conditions after the transfer. Secondly, the instrument disapplied the TUPE requirements for the current employer to inform and, where appropriate, consult with elected or trade union employee representatives due to the unusual situation and pace of this legislative transfer of British Steel business.

This is only in the context of this specific transfer. Thirdly, it rules out the possibilities that ministers and civil servants count as shadow directors of the company. And fourthly, the instrument provides that British Steel doesn't count as a public authority subject to the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and the Procurement Act 2023.

This reflects the fact that it operates and competes in the private sector rather than as a traditional public body. Fifthly, it disapplies rules around reuse of the company name by a new company when the original company goes into insolvent liquidation. These modifications have enabled and will continue to enable the new publicly owned company to function properly while the government stabilizes the business and consults its longer-term future. The government's objective is to maintain continuity, protect capability and provide stability while the future of British Steel is developed. Public ownership gives the immediate platform from which the company can be stabilized, operations can continue and options for a sustainable long-term future can be considered.

That work will require close engagement with management, employees, trade union, customers, suppliers and other stakeholders. In summary, my Lords, this instrument is technical but important. It ensures that the nationalization of British Steel operates effectively in law. It supports employee certainty, business continuity and the continued operation of a strategically important steel undertaking. It is targeted, necessary and proportionate.

And for those reasons, my Lord, I beg to move that the committee consider these regulations.

33:01 - 33:06

Speaker 1

The question is that the Grand Committee do consider this instrument.

33:06 - 43:53

John Redwood

My Lords, I find this, these instruments very worrying as they seem to be part of a pattern that the nationalized British Steel is not going to be properly accountable and is not going to provide decent information for the taxpayers' representatives who are now funding the operation. We all wish every success in saving jobs and maintaining a basic steelmaking capacity in this country. But I fear this vehicle is not going about it in the right way and we are not learning about what we are actually buying for the huge sums of money which are currently being put into it with no proper budget line and no proper business plan to explain expenditure. We learn in the Scrutiny Committee's report that in the first year or so it was 555 million pounds. And so it is eating into the budget line for investment support in new steelmaking activities, which is I think how it's being funded by the Treasury, when presumably all or most of that has nothing to do with capital spending but has everything to do with operating losses.

And much of it is based around the non-competitiveness of UK energy prices and the phenomenal cost of burning fossil fuels in blast furnaces with carbon taxes and the other net zero impedimenta which are gradually deindustrializing very large areas of British activity and would have deindustrialized this completely from basic steelmaking if the government had not stepped in in this rather clumsy way to route very large subsidies into a business that cannot conceivably compete at its current cost levels. I think it would be timely if the Minister could update this committee and therefore the wider Parliament on where we are getting to now on the losses to date, because those loss figures relate to the summer and the monthly loss is obviously very considerable. Is there any sign of the monthly losses coming down at all or are we going to assume 500 million or so a year every year? It would be very good if the Minister could tell us what the plans are for these two blast furnaces.

They are extremely old. I don't know whether they are both still producing, and I don't know what maintenance schedule they have to be on, but at some point they will obviously need fundamental maintenance. Is that going to be something which is put into the budget plans? Or is it that the nationalised industry will carry on with the plans that the previous government, and I think this government at the beginning, were trying to negotiate with the Chinese owners, that it would be a case of switching over from blast furnace-based steelmaking to an electric arc furnace arrangement for recycled steel, which would clearly come with the loss of a lot of jobs because they are far less job-intensive and would mean the termination of any ability of our country to make primary steel in the traditional way? And sometimes you need primary steel to then provide the additives and special steels that are more difficult out of recycled steel.

So I think Parliament does deserve to know more about the long-term plans. Capital expenditure for an electric arc furnace would be very considerable and would need to have its own budget line, but it would be a more legitimate drawdown of the monies in the current overall budget for steel modernisation out of which this seems to be funded. I think the government wishes to drop the idea of quarterly reporting of the financial figures. I think if in the private sector you had a business losing this much money, quarterly would be a bare minimum and you would be wanting monthly, and the executives would be wanting weekly because this is a terrifying rate of loss which implies it is unsustainable. And I'd have thought the unions and workforce would be very interested as well because I cannot see how the current operation represents a way of saving these jobs.

At some point there is going to be a crisis because of the lack of competitiveness and the very high level of cash burn which will force the government into a change of mind. I am concerned at the wide-ranging and sweeping legal powers the second statutory instrument which is to take. And there would be many companies trading in the private sector who would love to have friends at court who could suddenly suspend or remove all kinds of legal obligations upon them, but rightly the government will probably not be doing that. So why does it think it's reasonable to suspend important legal obligations on a company because it happens to be nationalised? I mean the idea that you shouldn't consult over TUPE when transferring people's jobs seems particularly strange because I'd have thought many of the employees and the union there would have welcomed the nationalisation.

So why do they have to be told that they no longer have the normal rights to consultation over what could be quite important changes to the contracts they're operating on? More worrying still is I think the idea that no senior official doing this as their day job, liaising carefully with the board and the company, and no minister designing the steel policy should be deemed to be a shadow director, whereas surely they will be able to influence or control or to order the company because he or she who controls the money controls the business. And this business really only has one important customer, which is the British government, and the British government supplying these monumental sums of cash to keep the jobs going and to keep the blast furnaces operating if possible.

And so of course the ministers and the senior officials are in practice making very crucial decisions which will dominate board discussions. And if they are determined to suspend company law in relation to those activities because they are ministers and senior officials, I think it should be even more of an obligation on them that they should come regularly to the Commons and Lords to report what progress that they have been making so that we can apply the kind of scrutiny to them that would otherwise have been applied by company law and by normal board discussions by directors who genuinely had the power to determine the future of their company, whereas the directors the government appoints will not determine the future of this company. The big decisions will be clearly taken by the government and its very future is entirely dependent upon the government continuing very large sums of money going into it. I do think we should also ask why the Freedom of Information Act will not apply. But again, it leads to the suspicion that they think the results and the performance and the plans of this company are going to be so bad that they should not be revealed to the taxpaying public that pays for them.

And again, I would be a little more reassured if in return for taking this big power, removing freedom of information inquiries from this expenditure of moneys and this very important company, that we were told that there would be more regular and frank reporting through Parliament and direct to the public by normal company information so that we could be reassured that they are not trying to avoid all kinds of accountability. I think it would be good to know from the minister when the finances of this group are going to be regularised with a normal budget line which we can see in the Red Book and the budget statements, because I don't think they can go on for much longer saying this is just part of a general steel package designed for something else and that we need an honest line in the budgets so that we can see it's being properly financed and is part of the budget settlement. I think it would be good to hear something about the cost of energy, because this is one of the major reasons why the losses are so huge. And are they going to be benefiting from recycling of government moneys? The government takes money off businesses through carbon taxes and then gives some of it back through the so-called supercharger we've been hearing about this afternoon in the main chamber.

Now this is a very unsatisfactory way of doing it. It increases administrative costs instead of just taking the tax off, you have to ask to get some of the tax back. So can we know something about how much of the tax they will be getting back so that that can help us form a judgment of how competitive this might become. Above all, I think we do need to know from the minister when is there going to be a proper government plan or a proper company plan basically approved and directed by the government that does meet the requirements of this legislation to say that they are charged with the duty of making a competitive and sustainable industry. And those two words are very interesting, because does sustainable mean that they do definitely have to close the blast furnaces on the grounds that these don't meet net zero standards?

And the competitive implies moving into break-even if not into profit. And we are so far away from that that I think it would be extremely good to have a deadline or timetable for the first plan and the knowledge that Commons and Lords had an opportunity to debate that plan given that very large sums of money are being discussed, given that a very important number of jobs are at risk and if the finances aren't gripped those jobs will eventually go, and given that it is surely good order for a government to be open and transparent in its dealings about such an important national industry.

43:53 - 50:41

Magid Magid

My Lords, I welcome these regulations and the support that the government intervention to protect British Steel and safeguard future steelmaking in this country. Because steel is not simply another industry, as we heard from the noble Lord the Minister, it's a strategic national asset, essential to our defense, infrastructure, energy security, and economic resilience. Without a strong domestic steel industry, we risk becoming dependent on overseas suppliers for materials that are fundamental in our national interest. And for Sheffield and South Yorkshire, from where I'm from, this issue is particularly important. Steelmaking is woven into our history, our identity, and our prosperity for our communities.

Generations of families have worked in our steel industry, developed skills, expertise recognized around the world. And my own family is part of that history, as I've mentioned previously, my grandfather, uncle, and father all worked in the steel industry in Sheffield. Their experiences remind me that steel is about much more than production figures and balance sheets. It's about livelihoods, it's about family traditions, as I said earlier, skilled employment, and pride in what our country can manufacture. We will, when we allow steelmaking capacity to disappear, we do not simply lose factories, my Lords.

We risk losing skilled workers, specialist knowledge, supply chains, and the ability to train the next generation. That is why the government was right to act to prevent the blast furnaces at Scunthorpe from going cold. The consequences of allowing that capacity to disappear would have been felt far beyond Lincolnshire, affecting businesses and communities across the country, including in South Yorkshire. These regulations make the transfer of British Steel business into public ownership legally workable. I recognize the exceptional circumstances in which the government has acted, and I welcome the protection this intervention offers to domestic steel production.

However, rescuing British Steel is only the first step, my Lords. The real test is whether the government can secure its long-term future. My Lords, I have several questions for the Minister. The first, on the future ownership of British Steel. Can the Minister confirm that the government's intention is to use public ownership as a temporary measure while securing a sustainable future for the business?

What progress has been made in identifying credible private sector co-investors willing to provide the capital needed to modernize the plants, improve productivity, and create new jobs? Secondly, on domestic production, the Liberal Democrats believe that the UK should aim to meet 50% of our domestic steel demand through British production, compared to roughly 30% at the moment. Does the Minister agree that this should be an objective for the government's steel strategy? What timetable and measurable milestones will there be to establish this, if the Minister agrees? Thirdly, what assessment has the government made of the opportunities for South Yorkshire in particular?

How will the steel strategy protect the region's specialty steel producers, engineering businesses, and advanced manufacturing supply chains, as well as the thousands of people whose livelihoods depend directly and indirectly on the industry?

Sheffield has a world-class expertise in specialty and high-performance steel. These capabilities are vital to the sector, including aerospace, defense, medical technology, and renewable energy, my Lords. Protecting British steelmaking must mean supporting the wider industrial ecosystem, not simply keeping individual furnaces operating. Fourthly, on public money and accountability, these regulations are holding government-owned companies with certain requirements under freedom of information procurement legislation. I understand the need for commercial confidentiality and the industry of the transfer.

Nevertheless, given the potential scale of public expenditure and the liabilities taxpayers may have to assume, what safeguards will ensure transparency, value for money, and effective parliamentary scrutiny, as we've heard earlier? Can the Minister also confirm when an independent valuation of the transferred assets and liabilities will be available and how Parliament will be kept informed of the financial risks? And fifthly, the transition to electric arc furnaces will be an important part of the future of British steel. So how will the government ensure that this transition protects skilled employment, supports workers through retraining, reduces emissions, and maintains the production capacity needed for national security? And finally, the government must make it easier for British manufacturers to buy British steel.

Will the Minister set out further steps will be needed to ensure public infrastructure projects and private sector manufacturers to use domestically produced steel while ensuring that procurement delivers value for money? And what progress is being made towards an improved agreement with the European Union to support British steel exports? My Lords, we must learn the lessons of the past. Britain cannot afford to rescue its steel industry today only to see it decline again in a few years' time because investment planning and political ambitions have fallen short. The government must work in partnership with the steel producers, trade unions, local authorities, universities, and the industry that depends on steel.

Decisions about the future of this strategic industry must be informed by the needs of defense, energy security, and the wider economy. And for Sheffield and South Yorkshire, a thriving steel industry would mean more than protecting existing jobs. It would mean more apprenticeships, opportunities for young people, stronger local supply chains, and a renewed confidence in our manufacturing future. We should be ambitious enough to produce more of the steel we need, invest in modern and cleaner production, and ensure that the benefits are shared by the communities that have sustained this industry for generations. I therefore support these regulations, but I urge the government to match its immediate intervention with a clear, properly funded, and long-term strategy that delivers sustainable steel production, attracts private investment, and protects the future of British steel.

So the question is not simply whether we can save British steel today. It's whether we have the ambition to ensure Britain remains a country capable of making the steel on which its future depends. I look forward to the Minister's response.

50:41 - 56:48

Andrew Sharpe

My Lords, I'm grateful to the Minister for explaining or setting out the case for these regulations, which make the legal adjustments needed for British steel to operate under public ownership. I'm also very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Maheed of Tinsley, and my noble friend Lord Redwood for their contributions and for their detailed questions. My Lords, the thing is we still don't know how nationalization will make this business financially sustainable. During the passage of the Steel Industry Nationalization Bill, we repeatedly challenged the government to explain why public ownership was the answer, and we never received a convincing economic case. We heard, and we've just heard again, arguments for preserving steelmaking, protecting jobs, and maintaining strategic capability.

I believe the Minister called it foundational. But those objectives do not in themselves demonstrate that nationalization is the best means of achieving them. A separate question, and perhaps a brief digression, is that the explanatory memorandum says, and I quote, "Steel is also critical for defense, expected to rise by an annualized 4.8% to 58,000 tons in 2050 with increased defense spending targets," end quote. But we haven't got those defense spending targets yet.

So how can such precision in that assertion be justified? My Lords, it does rather look as if the government is inventing post-facto reasons for taking these steps. The government has pressed ahead with their nationalisation agenda, but now the Public Accounts Committee has warned that they have not yet set out a credible plan for British Steel's financial sustainability. My Lords, why is that plan still missing? The committee recognised that the initial intervention bought time, but buying time is an expensive exercise when the taxpayer support continues at about 1.3 million pounds a day.

Given the fiscal pressures facing this country, pressures which this government's uncontrolled spending over the last two years has caused, the public deserves more than another open-ended commitment. So can the Minister tell the committee how much it is expected to cost to put British Steel on a financially sustainable footing? What investment will be required, over what period, and from whom? What evidence do government have that nationalisation will reduce operating costs or improve productivity? Then, my Lords, there is also the cost of decarbonisation.

Transitioning to electric arc furnace steelmaking requires substantial investment. Tata's transformation programme at Port Talbot amounts to approximately 1.25 billion pounds, which includes 500 million pounds of government support. But even today in Politico, we read a story that that investment is at risk. When the first blast furnace at Scunthorpe was built in, I think it was 1939, I don't believe that environmental concerns were foremost in people's minds. I would imagine that the decarbonisation and decommissioning costs of these, when we finally transition to electric arc furnaces, will be enormous.

We've asked the government before, and we've never really heard a convincing argument. Can we please have some idea of a breakdown of costs, potential costs? Meanwhile, the government still intends to introduce their carbon border adjustment mechanism in January 2027. That will impose a carbon charge on specified imported steel products. This will create additional costs and administrative obligations for businesses that rely on those imports, including products that they cannot obtain from British suppliers.

So will the government reconsider this measure before adding yet another burden to British manufacturing? And what assessment have they made of its combined effect with existing steel tariffs? My Lords, the Business Secretary warned last week against pursuing net zero at the expense of British jobs and industry. Will the government apply that same principle to steel, ensuring that their policies preserve industrial capability rather than price it out of existence? My Lords, the tariffs that have already introduced illustrate the danger.

Measures presented as support for domestic steelmakers have not resolved British Steel's underlying viability problem, while downstream businesses face higher costs. And we have repeatedly warned ministers about those consequences. My Lords, when asked by the Public Accounts Committee whether the tariffs could put smaller firms out of business, the department's response was, I'm afraid that may well be the case. What an extraordinary response to the prospect of businesses closing and livelihoods being lost. They have not helped boost domestic steel and are killing jobs across other sectors.

So will the government now reverse these damaging tariffs rather than treating the consequences for downstream industry as an unfortunate detail? Finally, as the noble Lord the Minister said, these regulations exempt the publicly owned company from freedom of information and public procurement legislation. If the government seeks those exemptions while committing substantial public money, the case for clear financial reporting and parliamentary scrutiny becomes stronger still, as I think my noble friend Lord Redwood explained very clearly. The public deserves transparency. How is their 1.3 million pounds per day being spent and on what?

My lords, the government needs to produce a credible plan, a realistic assessment of costs and an explanation of how the government will protect jobs across the whole supply chain. When will we receive that plan? And just to reiterate a few questions that we do need the answers to: where are we now, how much money has been spent, what is the plan for the blast furnaces? I understand a new chairman has been appointed for British Steel and I was wondering if I could persuade him, if he's not willing to change these transparency rules, whether we could persuade the minister to invite the new chairman in for a chat with interested peers to find out his views on the viability of the business. I think my noble friend Lord Redwood asked an extremely interesting question about defining sustainable and what it means in this context.

And finally, if the noble lord Lord Mohammed of Tinsley thinks the EU would have ever helped us export steel when even when we were members, I have a bridge to sell him.

56:48 - 01:03:37

Sonny Liang

My lords, firstly let me say thank you for all the contributions that noble lords have made to this SI. Let me try and address some of the questions that have been raised. Firstly, the SI does not remove the usual company reporting requirements that a company of its size is subject to. So additionally we have committed to further ways of sharing that information on the company's progress, including, and I think I do remember mentioning this at the dispatch box when the passage of this bill was going through the house, that including quarterly written statements and reporting financial assistance. So that is a commitment that we will keep, so we will report every quarter.

And since April 2025, the government has provided approximately 671 million pounds for working capital, which includes raw materials and salaries just to keep the plant going. My lords, look, we have recently appointed, and I'm sure noble lords know, Alan Lovell as chair of British Steel, alongside a board that will stabilize operations, oversee health and safety regarding the environmental aspects of it, and develop proposals to secure a commercially and environmentally sustainable future for the business. My lords, may I just sort of share this with noble lords, and I'm sure noble lords opposite would know, that this is a turnaround situation. Now, and I'm sure noble lords opposite have many years of experience in undertaking turnaround businesses and all that. And for a business this size, the turnaround will take a few years to take it from where we are to where the company should be to be attractive for private investment.

And that turnaround can be anytime between three, five years or maybe even longer. But we've got to make this business commercially attractive to bring in private investment. As it stands, no private investment would want to invest in British Steel, hence the government has taken the necessary step to nationalize it. And we've appointed the chairman, which is, I'm sure noble lords know of his background, he is a turnaround specialist.

...and he's supported with, if I may say so, a board of people who really knows this sector very well. I mean, you've got John Bolton, who's got 40 years experience on both sides of the Atlantic in this sector itself. Janet Ashdown as a non-executive director. Then you've got Andrew McNaughton, who has been non-executive director and board advisor to several infrastructure and capital-intensive industry companies, including Sheffield Forgemasters, Thames Valley, Thames Water Utilities, and Speedy PLC. So he's a chartered civil engineer by profession, so he'll bring experience to the board in turning around this business.

And he's supported by David Bond, an experienced industry leader having worked for BAE Systems. So these directors are people with experience, together with Alan, will turn this business around. But we've got to make this business commercially attractive for private investors. Until we do so, right, no private investor will be interested in this business. So we will do so.

And at the same time, we've got Ian Parker, who is representing the shareholder as a non-executive director, and together with Lorna Gratton, Graton rather, who's the representative from the government investment. So these two individuals are protecting the government's position on the board itself. So we are, I am very impressed with the experience and the skill of Alan and his fellow directors, and I believe that they are able to turn around this business itself. So I'm very confident of that. Now, obviously there are important immediate issues right now, the future of blast furnaces.

And as I said earlier, so we really need to stabilize the business before we can bring in investment into the replacing the blast furnace with electric arc furnaces and all that. So that's something that's ongoing. As far as the steel strategy, I mean, I mean, we want to ensure that our domestic demand meets 50%. But we've got to ensure that the steel, the businesses that we have now up their game in order to actually supply the domestic demand. And following from Lord Sharpe's point, I mean, yes, of course we don't want tariffs, but at the same time we want to increase domestic supply, so we've got to protect our domestic manufacturers as well.

So that's where we are. Now, you mentioned that. May I say also, I mean, to noble Lords, look, we don't take this nationalization easy, as I said at the debate earlier. This is a last resort. We have to ensure that British Steel has got a future, and we've done everything that is necessary to give it that future itself by appointing eminent board of directors to turn this business around.

And I hope noble Lords will appreciate what we have done so far. So, my Lords, look, the changes made to this instrument are deliberately limited. I mean, I mentioned again, it's very technical. And they support the continuity, the running of the business, clarify the application of the employment protections, and help the publicly owned company operate effectively while the future business is considered. So, my Lords, for those reasons, I firmly...

I wonder before he ends if he could just reassure us that both blast furnaces are currently operating and whether they're, when they would need major maintenance, major relining. Yes, they are currently working, I've been told. So for those reasons, I remain firmly of the view that this instrument is necessary, proportionate, and targeted. It supports the effective operation of British Steel in public ownership and gives certainty to those affected by the transfer. My Lords, I beg to move.

01:03:37 - 01:03:45

Speaker 15

My Lords, the question is that the Grand Committee has considered this instrument. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.

01:03:45 - 01:05:20

Speaker 20

Do we need to take a moment to shuffle the ministers? All right, my Lords, shall we kick off? Electrical safety standards in the private rented sector and social rented sector England amendment regulations 2026 debated with one other instrument, Lord Wilson of Sedgefield.

01:05:20 - 01:07:32

Phil Wilson

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My Lords, the committee is to consider the draft hazards in social housing prescribed requirements England amendments regulations 2026, otherwise known as the second phase of Awaab's Law, and the draft electrical safety standards in the private rented sector and social rented sector England amendment regulations 2026. This government is determined to drive a lasting change in the safety and quality of social housing. These draft regulations play an important role in keeping people safe by giving social landlords clarity as to their responsibilities. I will take each of the regulations in turn, starting with Awaab's Law.

Awaab Ishak was two when he died because of a severe respiratory condition due to exposure to mould in his family's rented home. His death was completely avoidable. His parents raised their concerns time and time again, but their landlord took no action. Since then, their tenacity and their fight to secure justice not just for their son but for all renters has led us to this point, and I'm deeply grateful to them for their passion and persistence. These regulations are so important because they empower tenants to hold their landlords to account when they fail to investigate and fix hazards within their homes.

The first phase for social housing is already in force, covering significant damp and mould hazards and emergency hazards. The draft regulations before us build on this by introducing an extended range of significant health and safety hazards. This means that in social housing a greater range of hazards are in scope: serious excess cold and excess heat, falls, structural collapse, fire, electrical and explosions and hygiene. This reflects the government's close collaboration with tenants and the sector through the test and learn approach, incorporating feedback and lessons from implementation that have been welcomed across the sector. We have clarified thresholds for the types of hazards covered by Awaab's Law.

01:07:32 - 01:08:22

Speaker 18

We have updated the definitions of emergency and significant hazards that fall from the scope of Awaab's Law to help landlords make their assessments. This will support more consistent application of the requirements and help tenants more easily identify when landlords must act. It is now clear that landlords must consider what a reasonable landlord would make safe, not just take steps to make safe within 24 hours for emergency hazards and 15 days for significant hazards. Our updated guidance covering all phase one and phase two hazards will also help tenants and landlords to determine what hazards are in scope and out of scope. Potential significant hazards must be investigated within 10 working days.

01:08:22 - 01:12:33

Phil Wilson

Following an investigation, landlords must send written summaries to tenants within three working days and take action within five working days. Emergency hazards are to be investigated and made safe within 24 hours. If the landlord cannot make the home safe in relevant timescales, they are required to secure suitable alternative accommodation. And additional works to prevent the hazard from recurring must begin as quickly as possible, no later than 12 weeks from the time of the investigation and be completed within a reasonable time. Social landlords will still need to investigate potential emergency hazards and take action to make all emergency hazards safe as soon as possible and within 24 hours.

Once the regulations are in force, all social landlords will have to comply with this next phase of Awaab's Law. If they do not, tenants can take legal action through the courts for a breach of contract or seek redress through the Housing Ombudsman. Awaab's Law also includes a provision for a defense if landlords can prove that they have used all reasonable endeavors to comply with the requirements. So landlords will not be liable for a breach of the regulations if there are reasons genuinely beyond their control. To carry on our phased introduction of Awaab's Law in social housing, we are going to continue to test and learn as phase two is implemented to make sure the new requirements are operating effectively ahead of the introduction of phase three.

We will clarify and adapt our approach if necessary. It is important to stress that this phased approach in no way means that social landlords have any leeway when it comes to meeting their existing duties to provide safe and decent homes. Tenants must be aware of the protections they are entitled to and landlords should be clear on their responsibilities. The Make Things Right social housing information campaign will launch in January to raise awareness of the new protections amongst social housing tenants and residents. Ahead of the regulations coming into force in November, my right honorable friend the Housing Minister will write to all social landlords in England setting out clearly what the regulations require and the standards they must meet.

I will now turn to the Electricity Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026. Last year, we brought social housing into scope of the electrical safety requirements that private landlords have had to meet since 2020. All landlords must now check the electrical installations in their properties at least every five years. As social landlords are more likely to own large, multi-occupied buildings such as tower blocks, risks associated with faulty appliances are higher, so social landlords must also test any electrical appliances that they provide as part of the tenancy. We will now align these regulations with the latest version of the relevant British Standard BS 7671, known as the Wiring Regulations.

Because of those changes, the existing reference to further investigative work are no longer relevant and are being removed.

We are also clarifying that a pre-tenancy inspection and test is not required if the previous inspection and test took place within the last five years and the report is still current. It will not be necessary to amend the electricity safety regulations following every update to the British standard. But in this case, these amendments are necessary because the change to the British standard directly impacts the way electricians inspect installations in residential accommodation. This will make sure there is clarity and consistency on the standards that are expected of landlords in both rented sectors. In conclusion, both these sets of regulations are rightly supported by the social housing sector and across this house, and I am confident they will make people safer in their homes.

01:12:33 - 01:12:35

Speaker 21

I beg to move.

01:12:35 - 01:12:43

Speaker 22

Question is the Grand Committee do consider this instrument.

01:12:43 - 01:22:13

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

My Lords, I first ought to draw the attention of Grand Committee that I am a councillor for a local authority which owns social housing. So this is something close to my heart. First of all, on the issue about the social housing regulations for hazards, the extension of Awaab's Law, totally agree with what is being done. Awaab's Law has already ensured that mould and damp within social housing is being treated appropriately. So that is a positive and extending it in the way that is proposed in the regulations is something with which we will support.

So I do have some questions. So the first one is this. The Minister referenced the reasonable landlord. Now then, a definition of reasonable would be helpful. One person's, a landlord's reasonable may not be the tenant's reasonable, and that often is the case in my experience in my local authority work.

So let's see if we can have a bit of clarity around that. Secondly is to just emphasize one of the hazards that has been listed, which is that of the regulation of excess heat and excess cold. So during the summer, obviously it was even in Yorkshire it was quite warm. And those properties, it was in properties built in the 70s, so with limited sort of insulation and so on, which were for housing with additional care. They became extremely hot.

And because of risks of opening ground floor windows where vulnerable tenants lived in the ground floor accommodation, it was difficult to keep those open, especially at night.

So the cost of putting in say air conditioning or something is going to be fairly significant. So when I looked at the impact assessment, there wasn't much in relation to the cost of issue dealing with issues such as that. That's the first one. The second issue is more broad, which is that the local housing allowance on which as the noble Lord the Minister will understand, many tenants in social housing rely. So that has been frozen for two, three years, is it?

It was first frozen in 24 and is not going to be unfrozen, can you unfreeze, until 27 at the earliest. Now that has a significant impact on the revenue income from rents or housing allowance for the landlord. And that means we're putting additional costs on the social landlord, be it local authority or housing association, meanwhile freezing the local housing allowance. So I mean I do think that needs some thought as to how those that you're going to square that off. Because I know in my own local authority a lot of consideration is already being made into adding to a to the rent of social tenants in our in our local housing to pay for some of the side issues like you know trimming hedges, doing the grass, that sort of stuff.

And that is an additional cost sometimes on tenants who cannot afford it because they qualify for housing benefit. So I really do want to understand that. The other point I want to there's two others really. One is it talks about hygiene standards. I'm not quite sure what hygiene standards meant, so it might be good to clarify that.

But where does the responsibility lie when tenants behave in a way which creates some of these hazards? Hygiene hazard may be one of them, as I know in my own town where a tenant is piling up rubbish in their I mean literally piling up rubbish to the level of the ground floor windows. And it is quite difficult to deal with that to the detriment of course not only of the people who live there but also their neighbors. So what happens then when it's a tenant responsibility or irresponsibility or lack of being able to be responsible and where does this these new regulations impose on the land the landlords the powers to do something about it? And finally on this area before I just mention briefly the electrical safety issues.

So there is, the government does want to, and I applaud this, build a lot of new housing for social rent. Will these regulations be applicable to the building regulations for those properties? Because there's nothing worse than having to be post-hoc. And that would be, would be a very unfortunate situation if these regulations are passed and then new homes were built which didn't enable those regulations to be adhered to. So move on to the electrical safety briefly.

As we know, the Grenfell fire caused the tragic loss of 72 lives, was caused by, initiated, I should say, by a fire in a fridge with a plastic back. And I know the regulations have changed for new fridges not to have plastic backs. But a lot of tenants in, who are short of money, will buy second-hand white goods and with fridges with plastic backs. And fridges last, fortunately, last a long time. So what, what can be done within these regulations for the landlord to apply the electric PAT testing to particularly fridges which are more likely to cause a fire, and particularly in high-rise blocks which the noble lord the minister referenced?

That would be worth knowing. And the final point, what happens when the tenant refuses entry? Because that happens and it is difficult to square that circle where a tenant refuses or is never there, will not open the door to get those checks, be it gas checks or in this case electrical tests. But just to conclude, I mean, it's a good thing to do in both instances, but I have questions that I've asked.

01:22:13 - 01:28:42

Gareth Jameson

Thank you. Can I thank the noble lord the minister for bringing forward these regulations? If I might first go on to the electrical safety ones, which are largely a technical amendment to reflect other changes to regulation. And landlords do have that duty and they will continue to have that duty. I do have some issues about monitoring of that legislation which sits with local housing authorities.

I'd be interested to hear from the minister what impact local government reorganization will have on local authorities' capacity to do this, and what will happen with the pause, non-pause, on-off reorganization that we're seeing and who will be responsible in the various interims that we are seeing. And secondly, the noble baroness Pinnock raised the other key point I had on this. It's all very well being responsible for electrical safety, but you actually need to be able to deliver it. And if the tenant is not enabling you to deliver it, how is that going to be addressed? And I think we addressed that in the Social Housing Bill, and I don't think we have an answer yet from government, or not a clear answer.

Turning to the hazards in social housing. Now these are well-meaning regulations.

The original Awaab's Law was introduced by the previous Conservative government, rightly, to address a very important concern. And we pay tribute to the family of Awaab Ishak for that very unfortunate and sad death, and the action that they've taken to ensure that that doesn't happen again. Now, phase one of this law is already in force, and these regulations seek to expand the scope of the existing law to cover additional hazards, as has been mentioned, whether it's temperature, hygiene hazards, structural and so forth. But we should take serious note of concerns raised by industry groups and key stakeholders on these matters. The National Housing Federation has warned that there will be substantial increased costs for housing associations, which could take resources away from more routine repairs and maintenance.

Homeless Link has warned that there is no dedicated government funding for implementation for providers already operating on thin margins. This is a real pressure, particularly as phase two significantly increases the volume of hazards in scope. Now, looking through the impact assessment, there is an increase in costs of 213.6 million pounds. However, and as Baroness Pinnock alluded to, that's the administrative increase in costs, and doesn't include all the administrative increases in costs because a number of those were hard if not impossible to assess, so they were ignored, which I find slightly odd. And as Baroness Pinnock pointed out, actually, if this results in more work being needed to be done, then those costs could be very substantially higher.

Now, we're at a point in time where many RPs and social landlords are not expanding their estate because they are spending so much money meeting existing regulations. We find new developments not proceeding because RPs and social landlords cannot afford to take on the 106 housing that those developments have. So there is a balance to be had here. Do we want social housing, or do we want to ensure that every last little thing is perfect about every house? And there is a balance, and we do not want to see people homeless because we cannot build sufficient housing for them.

I'm not saying where the balance should be, it's just we do need to reflect that in this. And there is a real cost to families. Housing is costing more money, whether it's private rented, whether it's buying your own home, or for the RPs, the bringing forward of social housing. Which I was hoping that Baroness Taylor would be here today, and I'm very disappointed. Well, sorry, disappointed, that's the wrong phrase.

I need to be sound more empathetic, apologies. Well, I am disappointed she's not here because I would much rather she was fit and well and here. So yes, absolutely, it's the right phrase. But I have several times asked the question. The government has frequently announced a very large investment over many years in social housing.

And I've asked how many social housing does the government expect to be delivered and occupied by July 2029, the fifth anniversary of it coming into government? I wouldn't expect the noble Lord to have the answer at his fingertips, but it would be tremendous if he could actually write to me afterwards. I'll come back to some of the things that Baroness Pinnock said, which I do totally agree with. What is the tenant's responsibilities in this? Not everything is down to the landlord, and we do need to consider that.

We also need to consider the view of reasonable. Reasonable is a very ill-defined term unless it's defined. And as Baroness Pinnock said, a tenant's view of reasonable and the landlord's may be different, and the views of different tenants may be very different. We need to get a balance here, and my key concern, our key concern, is balance. This will cost money.

It will have an impact on social landlords. It is right that we provide safe and secure homes to people. But actually, we also need to think of the balance of safe and secure and enough homes. And I want to ensure that that balance is correct. So I ask the noble Lord the Minister what plans this government has to support and incentivize responsible landlords to keep investing in safe homes that are needed.

01:28:42 - 01:28:46

Speaker 27

I look forward to hearing the Minister's response.

01:28:46 - 01:31:53

Phil Wilson

Thank noble Lord and noble Baroness for their contributions. I'm pleased to know that we've got cross-party and cross-house support for all this, and some valid questions that have been asked that I will try my best to address. And if I can't, then I've got no problem with writing to the noble Lords and all. The one issue, just to go through them one by one, overheating was the one that you mentioned there. Awas Law does not apply to overheating which is due solely to outside temperatures being particularly high due to climate change.

It is about ensuring landlords take prompt action where a defect or deficiency in a home is creating a serious excess heat hazard for a tenant. For example, this could include a window that can't be opened, defective ventilation, or a fault with the heating system that is causing excessive indoor temperatures. And I think that's fair because outside temperatures, you can't blame the landlords for climate change, I would have thought. But these issues, which are practical issues, are something that the landlords can address. That doesn't mean landlords shouldn't address heat hazards.

They still have duties to keep homes safe. The Decent Home Standard requires homes to provide a reasonable degree of thermal comfort, while minimum energy efficiency standards will help improve the thermal performance of homes and can reduce overheating risks when installed properly. We are also developing guidance for landlords on practical steps to manage overheating and other temperature-related hazards. So these regulations are about what practical things, like can you open the window or is the boiler working, you know, that's what it's basically there to affect. A big issue that both the noble Lord and the Baroness mentioned was what if the tenant doesn't allow access?

A landlord is not in breach of their duty to comply with the remedial notice served under the regulations if they can show they have taken all reasonable steps to comply. A landlord could show reasonable steps by keeping copies of all communications they have had with their tenants and with electricians as they try to arrange the work, including any replies they have had. Landlords may also want to provide other evidence they have taken that the installation is in good condition while they attempt to arrange work. The government is aware of growing concerns regarding the legal frameworks surrounding access to social housing, and ministers and officials are giving careful consideration to the matter and are working closely with residents, providers, and other experts to examine whether future clarification is necessary and will update the House as that develops.

01:31:53 - 01:32:52

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

On hygiene, I think... I'm sorry to interrupt, because there is an issue that I'm quite concerned about, so particularly about gas checks actually. So if the tenant refuses access and a gas appliance, say a fire or a boiler, has not been serviced, say for five years, and causes a fire or an explosion, whose responsibility would it be? Because what it's doing is putting at risk other tenants who live round and about, especially if it's in a block of flats. That's the concern I have, and I wonder if the minister could just say a bit more... sorry, because you maybe don't know, but if you could write to me about what action the government intends to take about access to tenants' homes to do these essential checks.

01:32:52 - 01:36:04

Phil Wilson

I mean, as I've said, the government is well aware of these issues and they are looking at concerns regarding the legal framework, and what I'll do is write to the Baroness about exactly where the government is on all this and what the legal position is and what we're looking at. Other issues, hygiene... I just want to follow up on that. It does appear the government is coming forward with some very strong powers as regards to HMRC and inspection for things like mansion tax, and yet something that is about life and death, we seem to be a little bit skirting around the houses. Surely life and death is more important.

Certainly is, that's why we're making sure that we're going to address the issue, and what I will also do is write to the noble Lord about exactly where we are on the legal framework and in developing it. Hygiene was another issue. It's about a deficiency in the property that makes it hard to keep clean, not the tenant's behavior. Oh God, here we go again. And the reasonable landlord, both noble Lord and Baroness asked this question.

The reasonable landlord test is an objective test. What would a notional reasonable landlord do? It's the landlord equivalent of the man on the Clapham omnibus. It's a legal concept that can be applied by the court. It's not relevant what a particular landlord or tenant thinks is reasonable to do, but what the notional reasonable landlord would do in the circumstances.

Good luck. So that is the definition of it. And also there's the cost element that I think noble Lord Jameson mentioned. We've published a final stage impact assessment for phase one of Awaab's Law. We have previously published a final stage impact assessment... sorry, we've updated the policy in light of consultation feedback from both the sector and tenants.

We've assessed that costs have been kept to a reasonable level while delivering necessary impact for tenants. Social landlords that will incur the greatest costs are those not currently meeting their obligations regarding hazards and deficiency. Our estimate is that the total cost to the sector of our proposals will be 146 million pounds over 10 years for the first phase, which is obviously the introduction of that was started under the previous government, and then for the second phase, that figure over 10 years or 12 years is going to be something in the region of 190 million pounds.

And the costs associated with the investigation and repair timescales are likely to be to be a result of additional staffing, familiarization costs, etc. On the two or three issues that were raised, fridges.

01:36:04 - 01:37:42

Gareth Jameson

Sorry to be finicky, so I just want to understand because I did read through the impact assessment. And the point I was trying to make is, and you're right, familiarization, triage, postage, these are essentially administrative costs of the process. It does go further on to talk about non-monetized costs because they were impossible to assess. I am making an assumption here, and it may be wrong, as a result of this, we are expanding the scope of what needs to be done. I'm not saying it doesn't need to be done, but clearly if you are doing more, that has a cost.

And so I'm just trying to get an idea, has government looked at those further costs? Because if all we're going to do is do a lot of admin and not do any actual stuff that actually improves the accommodation that someone's living in, I would ask the question why we're doing it. And I'm pretty sure we are going to be doing various changes, or not we, the landlords will be making various changes to properties, make them better. But that does have a cost. And I want to understand whether government is going to look at that cost, going to come back with that cost at a later stage, just so that the House has a better understanding.

And finally, before I sit down, I need to apologize to the committee because I also forgot to mention that I am a councillor in Central Bedfordshire and we also have an HRA. So apologies for that.

01:37:42 - 01:40:39

Phil Wilson

I think I think we've covered the information as far as the figures are concerned. If there is any other figures that we've will come across, then surely we can I can, you know, pass them on to the to the to the noble Lord. But obviously this is just part of a wider regulatory framework, which is to help to keep people in the social social housing safe. And obviously if these are complied with, then the extra additional cost will be kept to a will be kept to a minimum, I would have thought. It means that the social social landlords are doing what they should be doing anyway.

There's two other issues. One is on fridges. Due to the variety of electrical appliances used in rented homes, whether or not they are provided by landlords and the different type of tenancy, one single mandated approach is not viable or practical. And we still recommend, however, that everyone regularly carries out appliance testing on any electrical appliances. And also what if issues caused in the home are the results of the tenants and not of the landlord?

The government is completely clear that it is unacceptable for social landlords to assume that a hazard such as damp and mold or pest hazards is based on a tenant's lifestyle. It is unavoidable that everyday tasks such as cooking, bathing, washing and drying laundry will contribute to the production of indoor moisture. These activities are therefore unlikely to constitute a breach of contract on the part of the tenant and should not be a reason not to take action through Awaab's Law.

It is therefore rightly the responsibility of landlords to identify and address underlying causes, such as structural issues, repairs and inadequate ventilation. Landlords should of course continue working with tenants to make small reasonable adjustments to their behavior, if appropriate, to reduce their risks. To conclude, the support these draft regulations have received from the sector is heartening, and I recognize the role landlords play in providing safe, warm and secure homes for millions of people across the country. It is however not in dispute that far too many tenants still live in homes that are not well managed or maintained and often struggle to secure adequate redress. We are taking action today to further address this indefensible situation by ensuring that Awaab's Law phase two is introduced and extended to a wider range of significant hazards in social rented homes, including excessive cold and heat, and are addressed within fixed timescales, and that all landlords have to meet standards of electricity safety, and we will drive up the safety and quality of social homes, and I beg to move.

01:40:39 - 01:40:57

Speaker 13

Question is that the Grand Committee has considered this instrument. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.

We have to dispose of the next item as well, Hazards in Social Housing (Prescribed Requirements) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026. Lord Wilson of Sedgefield, move formally.

01:40:58 - 01:41:22

Speaker 13

Formally. Question is that the Grand Committee has considered this instrument. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Content. To the contrary, not content.

The contents have it. That brings us on to our next item of business. Do we need to take a moment to rearrange or are we all in our places? I think we're all here. Okie dokie.

Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) (Amendment and Transitional Provision) Regulations 2026, Lord Wilson of Sedgefield.

01:41:22 - 01:47:15

Phil Wilson

My Lords, the Committee is to consider the draft Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) (Amendment and Transitional Provision) Regulations 2026. These regulations were laid before the House on the 16th of June and following minor corrections relaid on the 1st of September. If Parliament approves, the regulations will come into force on December the 8th. I will start by providing some context and background to these regulations. A well-functioning planning system is essential to delivering the homes, infrastructure and economic growth that this country needs.

Local planning authorities sit at the heart of that system. They make decisions on the development of our towns, cities and communities, but for many years planning departments have been operating with insufficient resources. There remains a significant gap between the income generated through planning application fees and the cost of providing planning application services. That underfunding places pressure on local planning authorities' ability to recruit and retain skilled staff, invest in modern systems and deliver timely decisions. These regulations address that challenge by providing local planning authorities with an immediate increase in fee income.

By enabling authorities to recover a greater proportion of their costs, this will help strengthen capacity and capability across planning services, supporting more efficient and responsive decision-making for applicants and communities alike. These regulations also form part of a broader program of planning reform. Through the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025, Parliament provided powers that will enable local planning authorities, subject to appropriate safeguards, to set or vary planning fees locally. The government intends to bring forward regulations to implement those powers later this year.

These regulations provide an immediate boost in resourcing for local planning authorities and a robust national baseline from which future local fee-setting powers will operate. We consulted on increasing planning fees between March and June 2026. There was broad support across the sector for increasing fees, provided that the income is used to improve the quality, capacity, and performance of planning services. Developer representatives, including the Home Builders Federation, have emphasized that under-resourced planning departments are a significant barrier to housing delivery and have called for greater planning capacity and performance. The government expects local planning authorities to reinvest this income in their planning application services, helping to deliver those performance improvements and support a more effective planning system.

Turning briefly to the details, the regulations make four principal changes. First, they establish a revised set of national fees, which we refer to as a national fee schedule, by increasing all existing fees payable to local planning authorities by varying amounts to achieve up to approximately 90% recovery of estimated costs. These increases are informed by evidence gathered through a benchmarking exercise undertaken by the Local Government Association and the Planning Advisory Service. That work showed that every application category currently operates below cost recovery, with funding gaps ranging from around 18% to more than 60%. Increasing all fees up to approximately 90% of estimated costs will provide a meaningful and immediate boost for local planning authorities.

We are not increasing fees to 100% of estimated costs as this would risk over-recovery for some authorities. We also want to incentivize local planning authorities to make efficiency gains through process and service enhancements. Secondly, the regulations simplify and modernize a number of fee categories, including removing some existing baseline fees for larger developments. These changes are intended to make the fee regime clearer and easier to navigate. Thirdly, the regulations introduce a standard fee of 310 pound for prior approval applications that currently attract no fee.

Prior approval applications require local planning authorities to devote time and resources to their assessment and determination, and it is therefore appropriate that applicants make a contribution towards those costs. As part of that third change, the regulations also enable a fee to apply to prior approval applications relating to larger electricity substations. The statutory instrument introducing these changes was laid in Parliament on the 30th of September and comes into effect on the 21st of October. Finally, the regulations correct an omission in the existing indexation provisions. This amendment ensures that mixed-use outline applications fees are subject to annual inflationary increases in the same way as all other planning application fees.

In summary, these regulations are an important step towards a better-resourced and more effective planning system. They will provide local planning authorities with an immediate increase in funding, help strengthen planning capacity and capability, and ensure the foundation for future local fee-setting powers. Together, these reforms will support faster, more reliable planning services that are better able to deliver the homes, infrastructure, and economic growth that our country needs. I beg to move.

01:47:15 - 01:47:20

Speaker 13

The question is that the Grand Committee do consider this instrument.

01:47:20 - 01:51:37

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, I wish to rise briefly. This is just another step in the nationalisation of planning. We've seen it, well, in two weeks' time, the national scheme of delegation is going to take planning further away from the people it affects the most. Only last week in my own ward, I am a councillor in South Norfolk, I was asked by a resident to go and look at a barn. The delegated scheme of report said it was inconsequential, there would be no overshadowing because the building was only two storeys high, right next door on the southern side of an existing dwelling house.

The proprietor of that dwelling house is horrified because the barn is 10 metres high, it's the size of a warehouse, overshadowing completely that person's point. Now, I don't want to get into the whys and wherefores and negotiate this particular complaint, but it demonstrates that this taking power away from local councillors and having an excessive trust in the scheme of delegation is making planning worse. And as I look through this draft regulation, I see there are increases in the charges between 20 and 30%. And that's quite a burden on top of the fees from the Building Safety Act, from the community infrastructure levy, new charges from the mayoral community infrastructure levy, new taxes from the 1st of January on steel and cement, which are going to devastate, increase the cost of building rather, for the small builders. And that's on top of the new fees announced by the EDPs under the Planning and Infrastructure Act for nutrient neutrality and biodiversity net gain.

So whilst this regulation looks at planning fees in isolation, what it's not doing is taking into account the enormous cumulative increase in the burden faced for by developers, whose costs have gone up by 40% while house prices in real terms are down by 20% over 10 years. But I don't think those people in building or even applicants applying in a listed building or in a conservation for example for a certificate of lawful use would mind if there wasn't the other side, because 90% cost recovery seems like a good thing, but it ignores the increasing use of pre-application fees and pre-consultation advice whereby applicants are encouraged to go into and speak to planning officers on a chargeable basis beforehand. And I think that was a good idea to begin with, but it's just become just another profit centre with generic advice being given to applicants with no certainty and certainly no reliability, to use the points of the noble Lord the Minister, in helping people to get it right first time. So what I think we see here is in and of itself relatively modest increases in planning fees, but it's adding to the total burden of development, additional layers, more complexity, not less. And I would say that it makes the government's task of building one and a half million homes in this parliament, a target they are missing already by a country mile, even harder.

I think we would have had more sympathy, well, I certainly would have had more sympathy if we could have said, you know, let's have greater certainty, let's make the system easier to navigate, but let's see it in the context of the entire fee load, including building safety, CIL and all those other points I've made, than just having this one, which is just chipping away once more at the viability, the commercial viability of making of building the homes our nation needs.

01:51:37 - 01:52:27

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

Well, I don't want to go back into a debate on the Planning and Infrastructure Bill Act, now as it is.

I remind the committee that I am a councillor with an interest in planning as it happens. And, um, we Liberal Democrats do not take the view of the Noble Lord Fuller that regulation is to be swept away to, uh, make it less costly for housebuilders, because we, I hope, learned the lesson where regulations were swept away or ignored, led to 72 people dying. And, uh, I think we just always ought to have that at the forefront of our minds.

01:52:27 - 01:53:32

Charles John Fuller

Order. Might I just, uh, ask the Noble Lady just to clarify? I wasn't calling for regulations to be swept away. I was just asking for those costs of those regulations to be contained so that they did not actually become such a burden on the viability of schemes that actually nothing gets done, because collectively and cumulatively, we're not getting the homes built this nation needs. And it's because of the policy inflation and the cost inflation, regulatory burdens.

The Home Builders Federation, uh, in the last week has said the additional regulatory costs of building a home have added £38,000 in the last six years, and for flats, it's a further £22,000 over and above that. At some stage, we're going to have to call a stop to this inflation or absolutely nothing will get built at all. But that doesn't mean holding back on regulation, it just means constraining the cost.

01:53:32 - 01:57:49

Kath Kathryn Pinnock

Well, there we go. So, um, they're the numbers. So, on the one hand, the Noble Lord Fuller, uh, decries centralization of planning, so do I, um, but wants to have regulations without them costing anything. And, uh, that, that is the conundrum that is, for those who are always saying let's get rid of red tape, never ever tell us that which ones they're going to sweep away and what will be the cost on people when they do. So, um, look, I, 90% of, let's go back to what it's about, planning fees.

So, 90% of, uh, the planning service, uh, because it's going to provide an incentive to planning services to digitize and to streamline their processes. What hap, what about those planning services where that has already taken place and will find it really difficult to find that extra 10% saving, which is what is being proposed here? Um, and I do think, well, I would welcome the op, the regulations to enable planning services to, um, have a, have more variation in planning fees within strict limits, because the table provided is fine as it is, but doesn't, when it gets to very large planning applications, probably fails to reflect the cost of planning applications.

Very large commercial development, for instance, would be one. So that's one comment. The second is that the noble Lord Fuller, where I did agree with him, was on pre-application fees. I, as a local councillor, attend pre-application discussions with developers. And they do take planning officers' time to consider an outline case brought by a developer.

So a pre-application fee would be, I think, appropriate. Yeah, I think that ought to be, some consideration of it would, I think, be valuable. Whether or not then that was deducted from a final fee, but having some sort of pre-app fee, I think would be good. The prior approval fee I agree with. That is, I'm glad that has been introduced.

And just a final point is on this centralization of planning. And the government's argument is, which I partly understand, is about making it more consistent across the country. What I would welcome is for local authorities to be required to create and agree a local plan and local plan policies. Because that is where changes can be made, such as not having a 10-meter barn within one and a half meters distance of a... That's where you could do it.

And it does seem to me the government's missing a trick here about not requiring local plans to be a requirement of every local authority, every local planning authority. But otherwise, give us 100%, not 90.

01:57:49 - 02:03:48

Gareth Jameson

Sounds like an exam. My Lords, I thank the noble Lord the Minister for bringing forward these regulations for scrutiny and for my noble friend Lord Fuller for his comments, as ever stealing a little bit of my thunder, and Baroness Pinnock, who as ever I agree with on some things and not on some others. This SI ultimately increases planning fees. And I understand that the aim of the policy is to allow authorities to recover more money so they can provide a better planning service and deliver planning applications more swiftly. Now, we welcome a simplification of the fee categories and the improvements to planning system performance.

But we do have concerns that those increased costs will impact developers and therefore ultimately the cost of building a home and the price that someone will have to pay for a home or, as Lord Fuller suggested, not getting built. We believe the cost of the planning system overall needs to come down. Now, the government seems to be going about this the wrong way. When a system becomes too cumbersome, too complex, and too difficult, you don't charge higher fees, you fix the system. We need a system that is simpler, more consistent, more coherent, more proportionate, and speedier.

That would also be better for all parties, both the developers, for local homeowners, they would know where they stood and we wouldn't get such a complex system and it would be cheaper.

And it's not only developers I've spoken to who would be in favor of a simpler, more consistent, more coherent system. Several of the planning officers I speak to have complained that the increasing complexity of the system, the need for more reports and so forth, make their job more of a processing agent rather than a planner, which is what they were trained to do and where they add most value. Now, as Lord Fuller raised, the government continues to layer costs on building. Now, the sums are not insignificant, even for this, 144 million per year, according to the impact assessment. Now, if you applied that just to the government's target, the slim chance target of 300,000 homes per year, that's around about 500 pound a home.

Now, I know it doesn't just apply to it, I use it purely for illustrative purposes. So is it surprising that someone like Taylor Wimpey has said, a major housing developer, that it is not intending to build any more homes in London once its current projects are completed? The chief executive has said, baseline viability is, I think, fundamentally broken in London. The reward for undertaking what is a very high-risk form of development in London has just evaporated. The government's housing target requires 88,000 houses a year to be built in London, with a national target for 1.5 million homes over the course of this parliament.

Yet estimates indicate that the cost of building housing is highest in London and in many instances, if someone is to comply with all the regulations, it is simply not viable at the prices that people can afford to pay in London. Can the noble lord the minister explain what further policy changes the government is intending to make to improve the economic viability of building those much-needed homes in London? Now, Baroness Pinnock fairly raised the question of the importance of regulation and the fact that we genuinely do need regulation, and we do, to ensure safety, such as at Grenfell. The problem is we have too much regulation, it's too complex, it's too difficult. What we need is good regulation and that's what we need to address.

We cannot keep piling regulation, levies and so forth on developments. And the Baroness Pinnock also raised a second good question: so what regulation would you remove and change? Fortunately for her, I have an excellent blue book written by my friend in the other place, Kemi, that I am more than happy to share with you to explain what these things will be. I don't mind if you plagiarize it. Enough of the joviality.

The key point that we're trying to say is that this is indicative of the government's approach. While in isolation we can have sympathy and we can understand, as part of a package of continuing to seek higher costs, higher levies, more regulation, rather than seeking to address the underlying issue of a planning system that does not work. You shouldn't have to hit a nail in with a bigger hammer.

You should drill a hole through it. I'm not sure that's the world's greatest analogy, but hey. But I would appreciate if the noble minister could explain what the government is going to reverse its approach, and I look forward to hearing how it is going to improve regulation, lower costs, and get Britain building again.

02:03:48 - 02:08:26

Phil Wilson

I thank noble lords for their contributions, and I'll try and answer as many of the questions that I can, the points that were raised. First of all, with Lord Fuller, we, I mean, I can't go into any discussion on the barn. We, I mean, we recognize that developers must meet a range of costs when bringing forward development, and that viability remains an important consideration. I think we all accept that. However, planning application fees, even with these changes, are a very small proportion of overall development costs, less than 1%.

That's what we're talking about, just 1%. The purpose of these regulations is to ensure that planning application services are properly resourced to process applications efficiently. A better-funded planning system can reduce delays, increase certainty, and improve the overall development process. And this is something that developers themselves are saying to the government. And the money, and it's absolutely right, the money that is raised should be just plowed back in to the planning process to make it more efficient.

The government's planning reforms share a common objective: creating a faster, more effective, and more predictable planning system. Local fee setting is designed to improve the resourcing of planning application services. Planning committee reforms are intended to improve the efficiency and consistency of decision-making, and these reforms serve different purposes but are complementary. Together, they will help ensure planning services are better resourced, more effective, and better able to support housing, infrastructure, and economic growth. And the additional burden on top of pre-application fees, planning application fees fund the statutory planning application service and are set through legislation.

Pre-application advice and planning performance agreements are different. They are discretionary services that applicants can choose whether to use. Many applicants find these services valuable because they can help identify and resolve issues at an early stage, improve the quality of applications, and support the effective handling of the complex development proposals. Baroness Pinnock and I think Lord Jameson mentioned about ring-fencing. The government is clear that planning fees income should be invested in planning application services.

The Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 introduces a statutory ring-fencing requirement to ensure that fee income is retained and applied to the delivery of the planning function once commenced. The ring-fencing measures will come into force through separate regulations at the same time as the local fee setting measures. The ring-fencing duty will apply regardless of whether fees are being set nationally or locally. Baroness Pinnock mentioned about the pre-application fees, which I think I've mentioned there, but just to say that local planning authorities already have powers to charge for discretionary services, such as planning performance agreements and pre-application advice. And as for Lord, the support in digitization of planning and reducing the cost of planning and the whole process, if we can use digitization for an example to do that, what that should impact upon is that what we're clear about, fees should rise where costs rise, but they should also fall as innovation and digital transformation return savings over time.

And as I've said, this is only 1%, less than 1% of the total cost to the developer. And we agree with the developers, and I think we all agree that the money that is raised goes back into the planning process and it should be ring-fenced to do that. And where costs can be reduced, we will do that through any transformation using digital services. And with that, these regulations are a practical but important step towards a better funded and more effective planning system. They will provide planning authorities with the resources they need to strengthen capacity and capability, support more timely decision making, and help deliver the homes, infrastructure, and economic growth that this country needs.

02:08:26 - 02:08:28

Speaker 29

The noble Lord wants to intervene.

02:08:28 - 02:09:56

Gareth Jameson

Just before you finish, thank you very much. The noble Lord the Minister is very keen to emphasize that it's just 1%. I think the key point that I was making, and that all of us were making, is the cumulative layering of a whole series of regulations, levies in particular, that house builders are seeing. So it's not the one 1%, it's the multiple 1 and 2 and 3%, each of which in their own way can be looked at and go, yeah, well, probably that is appropriate. But actually cumulatively is making house building unviable in many parts of this country, which is why we are seeing people like Taylor Wimpey moving out of London, the place where we have amongst the most high need for housing.

If we raise the cost of building a home to such an extent that it is higher than the market will bear, we will not get any houses built. As I said in the debate before recess, I think it was before recess, when the times were good and the developers' margins were high several years ago, that may have been a different case. That is not the case today. If we want homes built, we must ensure that the cost of building them is below the price that they will sell at.

02:09:56 - 02:10:52

Phil Wilson

Can I just say in response to that, the developers are actually saying that they accept these increases as long as they are ring-fenced. Because they see themselves that, you know, the lack of investment in planning departments are a significant barrier to housing delivery in the first place and have called for greater planning capacity and performance. And that's exactly what these fees are going to do. So I think it's good news, especially when, as I've said, once it becomes more efficient, we can digitize services, if costs come down, the cost to the industry should come down as well. But this is something that's going to help us deliver houses in the future.

It's not going to be a restriction, it's something that everybody wants to see. And together with our wider reforms on local fee setting, they put planning services on a much more sustainable footing for the future. I beg to move.

02:10:52 - 02:11:06

Speaker 30

The question is that the Grand Committee has considered this instrument. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content, the contents have it. My Lords, that completes the business before the Grand Committee today. The committee is adjourned.