House of Commons

14 October 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:18 - 00:23
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
Order, order.  We start with questions to the Attorney General.  Ian Sollom. 
00:23 - 00:25
Speaker 1
Number one please, Mr Speaker. 
00:25 - 01:00
Lab Member of Parliament | Hammersmith and Chiswick
Member of Parliament | Hammersmith and Chiswick
Andreas Slaughter
Welcome.  Thank you, Mr Speaker.  We are determined to make the UK a more hostile environment for all forms of economic crime, including fraud.  In the last financial year, the CPS completed over 8,000 fraud and forgery prosecutions, which is an increase of around 10% compared to the year before.  And we are not stopping there. 

In June, the CPS launched its new serious economic and organised crime strategy, which is modernising its response and strengthening capability to address increasingly sophisticated crime. 
01:00 - 01:41
Ian Sollom
LD Member of Parliament | St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire
Member of Parliament | St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire
Ian Sollom
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank the Minister for that answer.  Fraud is growing and AI is making it easier to commit at scale.  And while cases can be complex, too often victims tell me that they feel abandoned by the system.  Now, he mentions the CPS's strategy in June.  That actually folds fraud in with organised crime and national security, and none of its seven priorities is actually about victims, unlike the previous economic crime strategy. 

So how will the Attorney General make sure that fraud victims are not lost in the CPS's new approach? 
01:41 - 02:06
Lab Member of Parliament | Hammersmith and Chiswick
Member of Parliament | Hammersmith and Chiswick
Andreas Slaughter
Well, the honourable gentleman will be aware that organised crime is an important part of fraud and the two do go hand in hand.  And of course, the SFO investigates the most serious types of fraud and bribery and other other matters.  But we are very conscious of the fact that tens of thousands of individuals of our constituents are the people who are affected by that, and that will be central to this this aim. 
02:06 - 02:22
Lab Member of Parliament | Stoke-on-Trent Central
Member of Parliament | Stoke-on-Trent Central
Craig Gareth Snell
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.  Is the Solicitor General able to update the house on whether or not he believes there are sufficient asset recovery powers to make sure that crime doesn't pay, and can he explain how those powers are being used? 
02:22 - 02:53
Lab Member of Parliament | Hammersmith and Chiswick
Member of Parliament | Hammersmith and Chiswick
Andreas Slaughter
Yes, Mr Speaker, the answer to that question is we have taken considerable steps along that that line.  Alongside securing convictions, prosecutors can use confiscation and asset recovery powers to seize the proceeds of offending.  From 2020 to 2025, the CPS recovered over 530 million pounds from confiscation orders, of which 102 million was paid to victims in compensation. 
02:53 - 02:57
Speaker 3
Tom Collins.  Question two, Mr Speaker. 

02:57 - 03:34

Andreas Slaughter

Solicitor. Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. Whistleblowers can reveal criminal activity that would otherwise go undiscovered, help unravel complex cases, speed up investigations and deliver justice for victims more quickly. But we do believe more can be done. That's why on Monday, the government launched a consultation on the whistleblowing framework, which includes seeking views on a proposed scheme to financially reward whistleblowers who report economic crime to the SFO.

03:34 - 04:04

Tom Collins

I am working with a constituent who has been subject to bullying and prejudice in high-level amateur sport. Current whistleblowing protections only apply to employees of an organisation, however sportspeople often have just as much, if not more, to lose if a sporting organisation turns against them. So does the Solicitor General agree with me that whistleblowing protections are important for good governance, safety, and safeguarding in organisations across sectors?

04:04 - 04:35

Andreas Slaughter

Yes, Mr Speaker, and I'm sorry to hear my honourable friend's constituent's experience. I would encourage him and his constituent to share that experience in the whistleblowing consultation launched this week, which I've previously referred to. Whistleblowers can dramatically cut the time and resource it takes to get to the heart of a case by providing the necessary information to focus investigations, and I welcome my colleagues from across the House to feed into the consultation.

04:35 - 04:56

Bob Blackman

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Far too often whistleblowers are protected when they initially blow the whistle on fraud and economic crime and other things. However, later on, they're eased out of organisations unfairly. So what further protection can the Solicitor General offer to those people who do the right thing and blow the whistle on crime?

04:56 - 05:22

Andreas Slaughter

Well, I thank the honourable gentleman for that question, and I go back to the consultation I mentioned. It's the widest consultation on the most comprehensive government review of the whistleblowing framework since its introduction in 1999, and I hope that he and others may feed into that so we can make a sea change in the way that whistleblowers are dealt with.

05:22 - 06:07

Ben Maguire

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Simon Andrews, a former finance manager, blew the whistle over hundreds of millions of dollars of financial crime, exposing links between US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Jeffrey Epstein, and Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor. The FCA wrongly told him he'd lost his legal protection as a whistleblower, and in Simon's words, the personal consequences of whistleblowing and the retaliation that followed have been devastating for me and my family. Last month, Simon sadly took his own life. The FCA review is being done by a member of its own board.

Will the Attorney General meet cabinet colleagues to discuss this and the case for an office of the whistleblower?

06:07 - 07:01

Andreas Slaughter

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the honourable gentleman for that question, and can I begin, as I'm sure the whole House will be with me, in expressing the deepest condolences to Simon and his family. It's right to say that the FCA, the Financial Conduct Authority, is conducting an investigation regarding the allegations of wrongdoing, and therefore I don't think it would be right for me to comment in detail at this time. I know concerns have been raised in relation to that inquiry as well, but it is being conducted by a new non-exec director. It will report, and it will look at, and the chief executive of the FCA has said this, that she will have carte blanche to look at across the piece at the dealings between Simon and the FCA.

07:01 - 07:06

Speaker 11

So I think we should in the first instance wait and see the outcome of that inquiry before going any further.

07:06 - 07:12

Speaker 10

Question number three, please, Mr Speaker.

07:12 - 07:41

Speaker 17

Mr Speaker, we remain completely committed to upholding international law. That commitment reflects our values, but also the real benefits that international law brings to our everyday lives. It underpins the global rules that allow us to travel on holiday more easily, for UK businesses to sell their goods abroad, and it enables greater cooperation between international law enforcement agencies, keeping our streets safer at home.

07:41 - 08:14

Charles Edward Robin Morello

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. President Trump's administration stated that it would dismantle the International Criminal Court brick by brick and has imposed sanctions following ICC judge Navi Pillay's being awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize. The International Criminal Court's chief prosecutor has had access to emails and bank accounts removed following sanctions by President Trump. So what steps is the government taking with European allies to uphold international law and human rights in the face of threats to the ICC by the US administration?

08:14 - 08:49

Speaker 23

The honourable gentleman raises an incredibly important point. The UK stands with the International Criminal Court and we stand united with our partners in strongly disagreeing with the sanctions imposed on the court. The ICC must be permitted to continue its critical work holding perpetrators of the most horrific international crimes to account. The FCDO are in close contact with the court and individuals impacted to help support them during this period.

08:49 - 09:10

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Sometimes this topic can seem like an abstract idea for residents of my constituency in Harlow. So I wondered if the Attorney General could talk about the practical ways in which obeying international law can benefit my residents in Harlow.

09:10 - 09:41

Speaker 17

My honourable friend is a fantastic champion for the people of Harlow, including on the topic of international law. International law does bring real benefits to us. For example, when your constituents, when the honourable member's constituents set off for their summer holidays, presumably from Stansted Airport, it is the Chicago Convention governing flights which enables them to do so safely and securely.

09:41 - 10:21

Speaker 32

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And I think I'm in the slightly novel position of being fresh to the dispatch box myself, but also in the position to welcome both the Attorney General and the Solicitor General to their new places, and which I do with gusto. Last month, the Attorney General published her new Attorney General's legal guidance, a direction to all government lawyers on how to advise ministers on lawfulness and legal risk, replacing the advice of Lord Hermer. Across the board, she has removed reference to international law. She's removed Lord Hermer's demand that, and I quote, "the rule of law requires compliance by the state with its obligations in international law as in national law."

10:21 - 10:50

Speaker 27

She's removed Lord Hermer's direction that the government, and I quote, "should not invite Parliament to legislate contrary to international obligations." And she has removed the whole paragraph where Lord Hermer instructed government lawyers, and I quote, "that compliance and respect for international law must be a critical factor in legal advice." She served as Solicitor General under Lord Hermer for a year. What persuaded her that his guidance to government lawyers was wrong, that the Conservatives were right all along, and that it needed to be replaced?

10:50 - 11:31

Speaker 23

Well, I welcome the honourable gentleman to his post, and I'm pleased that he has raised the updated legal risk guidance. This is a government committed to getting things done, and in the revised guidance, I make clear that where there is a tenable legal argument, we can take action. But in relation to international law, my new updated guidance makes clear that domestic law and international law should be treated in the same way. It is important that we adhere to both, and that is set out in the guidance.

11:31 - 12:17

Speaker 27

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Having removed Lord Hermer's focus on the importance of international law, the Attorney General has, in fact, added a new consideration: whether or not an international court has jurisdiction. Mr. Speaker, this could have Chagos written all over it. Without express United Kingdom consent, there is no international court with binding jurisdiction on the sovereignty of the Chagos Islands. So, applying her own legal guidance, does the Attorney General now agree that the decision to cede sovereignty of the Chagos Islands has never been a legal imperative forced on the government, but a political decision taken by Labour?

12:17 - 12:56

Speaker 23

The military base at Diego Garcia is critical for our national security and for keeping people safe here in Britain. And our priority has always been clear: to secure the long-term effective operation of that base. Since its creation, that base has been challenged through various international courts and tribunals, threatening the long-term and secure operation. And that's why, that's why we continue to work closely with the US and with Mauritius to find a way forward that's in the UK's best interest and continues to protect our national security.

12:56 - 13:04

Speaker 21

Sam Dixon. Four, Mr. Speaker.

13:04 - 13:37

Speaker 17

Mr. Speaker, stalking in all its forms is a horrendous, life-shattering crime. In September, I spoke at the national multi-agency conference where government and the third sector came together to discuss this issue, including analyzing a non-domestic stalking case. We've asked Richard Wright KC to review the criminal law on stalking, which will be published shortly, and have widened stalking protection orders so that they can be put in place to protect victims on conviction as well as acquittal.

13:37 - 14:11

Anna Dixon

I thank the Attorney General for her response. I recently spoke to two of my constituents, Julie and Jody, about the repeated harassment they'd experienced at the hands of a former neighbor. The police failed to link the incidents and reports and identify a pattern of behavior as stalking. So could the Attorney General give additional assurance to me and my constituents that she will urgently look into both how the CPS and the police assess and deal with non-domestic stalking and ensure the training and standards are improved?

14:11 - 14:47

Speaker 17

Well, I thank my honorable friend for her question, and I'm deeply sorry to hear of Jody and Julie's experience. As part of our strategy to halve violence against women and girls in a decade, the government will soon issue new statutory multi-agency guidance on stalking, setting out a robust framework for police, the CPS, local authorities, and healthcare services to better recognize and respond to this crime. In the meantime, if my honorable friend wants to pass on details of this case, I will happily raise it with the CPS.

14:47 - 14:49

Speaker 13

Zoe Franklin.

14:49 - 14:54

Speaker 14

Question number five, Mr. Speaker.

14:54 - 15:33

Speaker 17

Mr. Speaker, last month I announced the national rollout of the CPS's victim transformation program, including a universal service for all victims and an enhanced service for domestic abuse survivors, which is already offered to victims of rape. Under the enhanced service, every domestic abuse victim will have a dedicated victim liaison officer who will remain a point of contact from charge through to trial.

I said I would put victims at the heart of the justice system and we are getting on and delivering on that commitment.

15:33 - 15:34

Zoe Franklin.

15:34 - 16:16

Zoe Franklin

Mr Speaker, and I thank the Attorney General for her answer. But my constituent from Guildford has endured repeated delays in a domestic abuse prosecution, including the Crown Prosecution Service failing to secure a barrister and a trial collapsing after eight days as the proceedings overran and jurors could no longer continue due to other commitments. She now faces the prospect of awaiting until June 2028 for justice, almost five years after her husband's arrest. By then, there's a real risk that crucial evidence will be lost. Does the Attorney General recognize administrative failures like this undermine victim confidence in the criminal justice system, and what accountability is there when CPS failings cause such devastating delays?

16:16 - 16:18

Speaker 16

Attorney General.

16:18 - 17:07

Speaker 23

Well, I'm very sorry to hear of the honorable member's constituent's experience, and if she wants to provide details of the case, I will raise it directly in the with the CPS. She's absolutely right, victims deserve timely justice and delays can have a profound impact on victims. That's why the government is taking action to deliver a faster and more effective justice system, including investing at record levels in maximizing court capacity. We've invested an additional 96 million pounds in the CPS, increasing its funding by more than 10% between 26 and 29. This means more prosecutors being able to make charging decisions, prepare cases for court, and bring offenders to justice.

17:07 - 17:09

Speaker 29

Marcus Campbell-Savours.

17:09 - 17:30

Markus Campbell-Savours

Thank you, Mr Speaker. With Cumbria experiencing rates of domestic abuse significantly higher than the England average, and with victims often feeling traumatized by the process of securing justice, how is the Attorney General working with the CPS to ensure victims' voices are not ignored by the justice system?

17:30 - 17:32

Speaker 19

Attorney General.

17:32 - 18:05

Speaker 23

And I thank my honorable friend for that question. Specifically in relation to victims of domestic abuse, the enhanced service that they'll now be offered by the CPS means that they will have a dedicated victim liaison officer supporting them from charge through to trial. In three CPS areas, we are also piloting offering victims of domestic abuse in the Crown Court a pre-trial meeting with the prosecution team to support them on their journey to justice.

18:05 - 18:06

Lee Barron.

18:06 - 18:08

Speaker 20

Number six, Mr Speaker.

18:08 - 18:13

Speaker 31

Attorney General.

18:13 - 18:52

Speaker 23

Mr Speaker, with your permission, I will answer questions six and eight together. Last month, the government announced plans to roll out specialist rape and serious sexual offences courtrooms in every Crown Court across England and Wales. These courtrooms will transform how the justice system treats survivors of some of the most serious crimes, ensuring a victims-focused, trauma-informed approach. The changes are designed to encourage more victims to come forward, prioritizing their cases by fixing trial dates to avoid delays and last-minute changes.

18:52 - 18:53

Lee Barron.

18:53 - 19:22

Jason Lee Barron

Mr Speaker, it's almost two years now since Harshita Brella was murdered in Corby, her body dumped in the boot of a car, and arrest warrant was issued for Harshita's husband who fled the country. Could the minister raise Harshita's case with other relevant departments and give her family the reassurance that all is being done to bring Harshita the justice that she and her family so desperately deserve?

19:22 - 19:24

Speaker 18

Attorney General.

19:24 - 19:43

Speaker 23

My honorable friend raises a deeply concerning case.

Our thoughts remain with Harshita's family as they continue to seek justice for their daughter. I would of course be happy to raise this matter with my ministerial colleagues and get back to him.

19:43 - 20:23

Sarah Olney

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last year, the Public Accounts Committee warned that the government will not meet their manifesto commitment to halve violence against women and girls if they do not get to grips with the evolving nature of abuse. Technologically facilitated abuse is growing rapidly, as referrals to Refuge rose by nearly 80% last year. This includes intimate image abuse offences, which rose by 27%. However, over the same time period, the proportion of cases resulting in a charge fell from 5.8% to 4.5%.

So I would like to ask the Attorney General what steps she is taking to help increase prosecution rates in cases of technologically facilitated abuse.

20:23 - 20:55

Speaker 23

The honourable lady is right to point out the deeply worrying rise in tech-facilitated abuse. To that end, in July, I hosted a round table with the CPS, police, and third sector specifically to focus on tech-facilitated violence against women and girls. The CPS will be publishing a dedicated action plan on tech-facilitated violence against women and girls, building on their VAWG strategy published last November.

20:55 - 20:59

Speaker 28

Seven, Mr. Speaker.

20:59 - 21:44

Speaker 23

The government is clear that it is firmly in the UK's interests to remain a member of the European Convention on Human Rights. The ECHR has allowed people to object when do-not-resuscitate orders are put on their beds without their consent. And it's the reason why victims of rapists such as John Worboys have been able to force the police to investigate rather than being turned away. That's why I will continue to defend the ECHR, and it's why the UK played a leading role in the Chisinau Declaration, working to modernise the ECHR with our European partners.

21:44 - 22:09

Speaker 44

Mr. Speaker, the Conservatives and Reform want to leave the ECHR, which Winston Churchill championed, putting us alongside Russia and Belarus. Does the Attorney General agree with me that that is no place for a country that helped to write it?

22:09 - 22:39

Speaker 23

Mr. Speaker, our commitment to the ECHR is clear. It plays an important role in all aspects of our life, including, for example, the Good Friday Agreement, which would unravel without it. It is important that we modernise where necessary, but our commitment is steadfast.

22:39 - 22:43

Speaker 26

Nine, Mr. Speaker.

22:43 - 23:09

Andreas Slaughter

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The government inherited a justice system on the brink. The record backlogs mean victims are facing devastating delays for justice. This government continues to invest in our courts, but vital reforms are needed too. The Prime Minister and Justice Secretary have rightly listened to the strength of feeling from victims and this House, and they have decided not to establish the Crown Court bench division.

23:09 - 23:22

Speaker 35

But we will now act more quickly and implement the rest of our vital reforms sooner, delivering swifter justice for victims who the party opposite appear to have forgotten about entirely.

23:22 - 23:54

Speaker 37

Mr. Speaker, the government has finally performed another U-turn following widespread concern in this House, rightly retaining trial by jury. However, the government still intends to allow judge-only courts for complex cases, yet doesn't define what complex means. This risks mission creep and has attracted significant concern from organisations including the Criminal Bar Association. Why does the Attorney General believe that this lack of clarity is still acceptable?

23:54 - 24:28

Andreas Slaughter

It seems to be, Mr. Speaker, that the party opposite oppose everything that is in the recommendations that Lord Leveson came forward with. They created, they are the party who created the Crown Court backlog, and yet they oppose every single measure which we devise to deal with it. When are they going to come up with proposals of their own? Why do they continue to oppose for opposition's sake?

24:28 - 24:47

Speaker 27

Can the Attorney General explain to the House how, having spent many months arguing for the abolition of most jury trials, she now thinks that they're indispensable? And does she accept that whilst juries are indispensable, an Attorney General forced to perform such a spectacular U-turn may not be?

24:47 - 25:40

Speaker 35

Well, again, Mr. Speaker, this will be complete news to the opposition, but we do occasionally listen, listen to what this House has said, listen to what the professions have said, and we are going forward with proposals that will tackle the backlog. They never want to talk about the backlog because they caused the backlog. What we're looking for is solutions to that, and they're welcome to put forward their suggestions. Domestic abuse has a significant impact on victims and their families, and those who are brave enough to come forward deserve to have their cases resolved quickly. Last month, I announced the national rollout of enhanced services for survivors of domestic abuse.

25:40 - 25:53

Speaker 17

This service will mean victims of domestic abuse will be provided with a dedicated victim liaison officer, providing better support from charge to trial.

25:53 - 26:13

Speaker 39

Mr. Speaker, last month Woking's Your Sanctuary, the women's refuge in my constituency, hosted a conference to tackle domestic abuse. One of the key issues that they want to see done is tackle the 2020 Harm Review that has not been implemented. What steps is the Attorney General taking to correct that wrong?

26:13 - 26:46

Speaker 17

Well, I've taken many steps to tackle domestic abuse, from rolling out the enhanced service offered to victims of domestic abuse to piloting meetings with the prosecution team pre-trial for victims of domestic abuse. This is a government that is committed to halving violence against women and girls in a decade, and we're getting on with the job.

26:46 - 28:02

Lindsay Hoyle

Before we come to Prime Minister's Questions, colleagues will know that tomorrow marks the fifth anniversary of the death of Sir David Amess. A dear friend to me and all, and to so many across this House. He served in this House for 38 years, and including proudly representing his Southend West constituency, where he was tragically killed carrying out his democratic duty. The deaths of both Sir David and former colleague Jo Cox, along with the threats that those in political life continue to receive, drive me every day to do whatever I can as Speaker to improve the security and safety of members, their families, and staff. This includes the important work being done by the Speaker's Conference on the security of candidates, MPs, and elections.

It's incumbent on us all to help prevent the continuing climate of attacks on those in public life. No members should fear carrying out their democratic duties.

Sir David will always be remembered and our thoughts are with his family and friends on this day. We now come to Prime Minister's Questions. Jerome Mayhew.

28:02 - 28:04

Speaker 33

Number one, Mr. Speaker.

28:04 - 28:05

Prime Minister.

28:05 - 29:35

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, could I add my tribute to Sir David on the fifth anniversary of his death. David was someone of whom I was very fond and worked with very closely on the Health Select Committee when I arrived in this House in 2001. We send our deepest condolences to David's family. There is more work to be done on the security of members of this House and we will do it. Mr. Speaker, I look forward to welcoming President Zelenskyy to Downing Street later this afternoon.

Our support for Ukraine is unwavering and I have asked for further military and financial support to be drawn up ready for the coming weeks. Later today I will also meet Archie Gouldburn, an incredible athlete and inspiring campaigner for brain cancer research. And finally, Mr. Speaker, can I also pay tribute to Councillor Pat Karney, who served North Manchester for almost 50 years as a councillor in such a dedicated way. He saw the city through some of its greatest challenges. He has fittingly been called Mr. Manchester on the front page of the Manchester Evening News today.

Thank you, Pat, for your contribution to Manchester and to politics in our country. This morning I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my duties in this House, I shall have further such meetings later today.

29:35 - 29:58

Speaker 32

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister sees himself as a man of candour. So will he tell the House, did anyone associated with the running of Manchester City Football Club raise the charges they were facing and have now been found guilty of, either with him or with any member of his team?

29:58 - 29:59

Prime Minister.

29:59 - 30:36

Speaker 45

They did not raise those issues with me. I'm very happy, Mr. Speaker, for everything to be set out in full. It is why I asked the Greater Manchester Combined Authority, in response to a call from the Leader of the Opposition and others, to set out a full statement of my key dealings with the owners of Manchester City Football Club. That statement was published on Monday and it includes the issues in the news today and that is the position.

30:36 - 31:26

Speaker 36

Mr. Speaker, I'm sure we were all incredibly moved by the Prime Minister's tribute to his late father at Labour Party conference and can I pass on my personal condolences to him and his family. During the Prime Minister's speech, I also thought about my own grandparents, two former teachers with decades of public service. But when they needed looking after, they had to go through their savings and their pension just to receive the care my granny needed. I'm sure that's a story that resonates with thousands of people in Ipswich and across the country. And that is because we have a care system that puts profit before people, leaving behind not only the people who depend on this service but the incredible people who work within it as well.

So can I, as a Labour and Co-operative MP, ask our country's first Labour and Co-operative Prime Minister, will he consider a co-operative approach to social care so we can finally put people before profit?

31:27 - 32:12

Speaker 40

Well Mr. Speaker, can I thank him for his kind words and can I pass on my sympathies in relation to his grandparents. Any family in this country who has lived through the journey through dementia and experiencing the social care system will know that we should not accept the status quo and the failure of this House to fix social care through the decades bodes does not reflect well on any party in this House. We will fix it. We will create a National Care Service and in laying out that path to the National Care Service, I can give him my word as the Labour and Cooperative MP for Makerfield that cooperative principles will be at the heart of the new National Care Service.

32:12 - 32:17

Speaker 41

We come to the Leader of the Opposition, Kemi Badenoch.

32:17 - 33:18

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, can I thank you and the Prime Minister for your words about Sir David Amess. We miss him dearly on this side of the House as do his family. He was a fellow Essex MP and a very good friend to me and so many across this House and I know he is still very much loved by his constituents in Southend. Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister has had a busy few weeks tying himself in knots explaining why national security shouldn't come at the expense of social security, bumbling into a row still ongoing about Manchester City and I don't think his carefully worded answer to my honourable friend is going to suffice, doesn't sound like that one's going away. And he spent the last 48 hours trying to un-say that Russia influenced the 2016 referendum when we all heard him say it.

Does he ever get tired of putting his foot in his mouth?

33:18 - 34:36

Speaker 45

Mr. Speaker, I am glad that she's raised my comments because it gives me an opportunity to say to the whole House how I intend to lead this country. We have lived through a decade of division and we know that hostile actors have been seeking to interfere in our democratic process. That is a matter of fact. We need to call that out and look straight at it in a way that the party opposite didn't do. I have a quote here from the right honourable lady when she stood at this dispatch box, when she was responsible for steering through the Elections Bill and she said this right here: "I have not read the Russia report."

It's because they didn't want to see it. They wanted to look in the other direction. I won't do that Mr. Speaker. I will draw a line. I will defend our democracy and I will lead this country forward with positivity, unity and hope in the next decade.

34:36 - 35:19

Kemi Badenoch

Sounds like he's digging in Mr. Speaker, but you can't fight misinformation with misinformation. This is the first time I have ever heard the head of MI5 slap down a Prime Minister for doing Russia's dirty work for them. Either the Prime Minister knew what he was doing on that podcast trying to undermine the 2016 referendum or he opened his mouth on a matter of national security and said the first thing that came into his head. So does the Prime Minister agree with the Director General of MI5 that talking up Russian interference was a mistake?

35:19 - 36:07

Speaker 45

Well I could ask her Mr. Speaker whether she's even read, whether she's even read the Russia report yet. But I also wonder whether she's read the full comments from Sir Ken McCallum, whether she heard the comments from the former head of MI6 because if she had she wouldn't have made the statements that she just made in this House.

I think it's important, Mr. Speaker, that we are clear-eyed about what happened in the past. There is incontrovertible evidence that outside actors, enemies to this country, have interfered in our democratic processes, and it is inconceivable that that was not taking place across the whole of the last decade.

36:07 - 36:56

Kemi Badenoch

Still digging in, it's not me MI5 was talking about, Mr. Speaker. The fact is, this Prime Minister will say anything instead of dealing with the tough decisions that only he can take, like on Britain's energy security. In July, he said he would approve the Rosebank and Jackdaw oil and gas fields in the North Sea. What's he waiting for? If he'd approved them back then, we would have British gas warming British homes this winter.

So will he now, it's true, it's true. All of the gas, all of the gas from Jackdaw, Mr. Speaker, goes onto the British grid. So will he now stop faffing about and approve Rosebank and Jackdaw?

36:56 - 37:29

Speaker 45

She asks me, Mr. Speaker, what I'm waiting for. I've had to wait for the government process which was struck down by the courts under the Conservative government to be fixed, because they messed it up and we inherited that situation. So I will take a pragmatic approach on oil and gas, Mr. Speaker. We will set out our decisions shortly.

37:29 - 38:31

Kemi Badenoch

So much time wasting, Mr. Speaker. This is a government, this is a government, this is a government that approves importing oil from Russia, approves new drilling off the Falkland Islands, but won't approve new drilling in the North Sea. The truth is, Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is delaying a decision on energy to avoid a row with his backbenchers, just as he's avoiding another row on cutting welfare. The Times reports that two million people are being paid sickness benefits and they may not even be sick. Billions of pounds paid to people who shouldn't be getting it.

The last time a Prime Minister tried to cut welfare, Labour MPs stopped him, and they're still chuntering now, look at them, yeah, there she is, they're still chuntering now. Is the Prime Minister afraid to cut benefits because he doesn't want to fight with his backbenchers?

38:31 - 39:17

Speaker 45

Mr. Speaker, we commissioned the Milburn report because we do not want to see a country where young people in their twenties are stuck on benefits. I want a system where we give the right support to young people upfront so that they can be in training, education or employment from sixteen onwards. I think they do need better mental health support. I've argued for a different education system that gives parity to technical education alongside the university route. And we will bring forward the Milburn report soon, we will set out our response to it, we will bring down the welfare bill.

39:17 - 40:14

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, I didn't ask him about the Milburn review, but he wants to talk about it. I spoke to Alan Milburn and he said that that review was due before the budget. He's kicked it into the long grass. The budget is in two weeks. Let me tell the Prime Minister what should be in it: cutting welfare to fund defence.

In a BBC interview, Mr. Speaker, in a BBC interview on Sunday, the Defence Secretary refused to commit to spending three percent of GDP by 2030.

I see he's not here today, still not doing his job. People used to resign over this. This is the money that Britain needs to keep us safe. Now, the Prime Minister won't even tell us what his plan is for another year. So why won't he announce a date for 3% in this month's budget?

40:14 - 41:29

Speaker 45

Well, Mr. Speaker, I'm meeting President Zelenskyy as I said this afternoon, and we will honor our commitments to him and his country. And we will honor our NATO commitments as I've said every time that I have appeared at this dispatch box, and she will have to wait for the budget. But she comes here every week, Mr. Speaker, and poses as the the world-leading authority on defense. Now, I recall an interview she gave, she talked about interviews, I recall an interview recently about the Conservatives' plans for an Iron Dome. And then she said, it isn't our plan.

And then it emerged that it was briefed by her team, which doesn't sound like she's in control of her own policy on defense. And then under questioning on LBC from Mr. Farage, she said, you've got to speak to a defense expert about exactly how it will work. Well, obviously we worked out in that interview she wasn't a defense expert, and I think Mr. Farage is still waiting for an explanation.

41:29 - 42:55

Kemi Badenoch

Mr. Speaker, a month ago, the Prime Minister was boasting that it was time to engage in problem-solving rather than point-scoring. It seems that's another thing that he said without thinking. He wants to talk about defense, let's talk about defense. We are the only party that actually has a plan to get to 3% by 2030. He tells us, I asked him about the budget, Mr. Speaker, I asked him about the budget, he said he's meeting President Zelenskyy.

President Zelenskyy is not writing the budget, he is. The last two Labour budgets have been a disaster, a total disaster. Yesterday, Mr. Speaker, I met a beauty salon owner who is struggling with the impact of Labour's tax rises. She told me she is dipping into her pension to pay the young people she employs. That is the brutal reality for tens of thousands of small business owners just after two years of Labour.

The Prime Minister entered Downing Street promising the biggest change in 40 years. Now Labour MPs are briefing journalists they hope this budget does as little harm as possible. Isn't he too busy appeasing his MPs, excusing his own mistakes, and avoiding difficult decisions to give the country the leadership it needs?

42:55 - 44:13

Speaker 45

Well, Mr. Speaker, I used my conference speech to face up to difficult decisions. I faced up to a difficult decision about supporting older people in later life related to adjusting the triple lock so that we can lay the ground for a national care service. I took a difficult decision about developing closer ties with Europe, supported by a majority of people in this country. Why?

Because we've got the chance to do a deal, Mr. Speaker, before the end of the year that can add growth to the British economy, support our farmers and our food industry. But let me finish today in a spirit of problem-solving, not point-scoring, in a spirit of unity with the right honorable lady, because I'm going to make one further point about her conference speech. And I'm going to commend her for drawing a line on a decade of division, where she drew a line with the party over there for suggesting that her children weren't British. That is wrong, Mr. Speaker, in every single respect. She was brave and she was right to call it out.

That is what I want to see more of in the next decade as we go forward.

44:13 - 45:06

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Almost ten years ago, the shutters on Southall police station were pulled down for good because of austerity cuts by the Conservative government. A shuttered police station in the middle of our town center makes criminals feel that they can get away with it and residents feel like no one cares. So does the Prime Minister agree with me that we must do all that we can to end the blight of empty and shuttered buildings in our town centers, and will he back my campaign to pull up the shutters on Southall police station so local residents can feel safe again?

45:06 - 45:41

Speaker 40

Well, she puts her points very powerfully, Mr. Speaker. High streets across the country, including Southall, have for too long been a symbol of the decline of our towns, and I'm determined to do something about it. Immediately, I cut business rates for pubs, clubs, music venues by 20%, working with the Chancellor when I came into office. We are bringing forward a high street strategy later this year. We've announced a 210 million pound package for councils to reopen empty buildings.

45:41 - 46:01

Speaker 50

I will look at the specifics around the police hub, but this is an issue I think, Mr. Speaker, should be one that unites this house and one where we can work together.

46:01 - 47:01

Edward Jonathon Davey

Mr. Speaker, they'll be getting more. Mr. Speaker, can I join you, the Prime Minister, and the leader of the opposition in praising the late Sir David Amess and sending our condolences to his family? He was a man who had respect across this house and had friends across this house. Mr. Speaker, when the Prime Minister announced cross-party talks on social care over the summer, I was delighted and immediately accepted because getting this right really matters. He said then that to build a lasting solution on funding care, we're going to have to listen to each other and find common ground.

And he said when he tried before back in 2009, his mistake had been leaving it too close to an election. Does he still think that now? And if we are to find the common ground well before the next election, will he tell us when the next round of cross-party talks will be?

47:01 - 47:28

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, I'm happy to admit that again now. I was working with a colleague of people on the Lib Dem front bench, Norman Lamb, and it did get too late, and it got caught up in, inevitably, the climate of the election. And then it happened to Theresa May in 2017. This side of the house perhaps was doing the point-scoring at that point in time. This is not an issue for point-scoring.

47:28 - 48:04

Speaker 45

When is this house going to learn that? How long is it going to turn away from this issue? My honorable friend mentioned his grandparents.

I saw mine go through the care system and then I vowed as a minister in the Blair government that I wouldn't let it happen to my parents, but it's just happened. It's not good enough for him, for many thousands of people like him, but also for the people who work in social care who give everything to it. I see his genuine commitment to this issue. It will be difficult, but let's get on and build this National Care Service and raise the esteem of politics with people across this country.

48:04 - 49:12

Edward Jonathon Davey

Mr Speaker, the Prime Minister knows I share his passion to get this right. He knows I share his passion to work cross-party to find the consensus which is the only way we can put this right. But I hope we can get on with the cross-party talks. We can't push this to the end of the next decade. We have to act now for the millions of people who need our help.

Mr Speaker, can I move on to other matters? Scared of the midterms, President Trump has done a deal with Vladimir Putin to buy Russian diesel, ripping up international sanctions against Putin. The Prime Minister studiously avoided commenting on Trump's behaviour on Monday, but this House does deserve to know his position, as does frankly President Zelenskyy and our brave Ukrainian allies. So let me ask the Prime Minister this. Doesn't he agree this is yet another shameful Trump betrayal of the Ukrainian people and European security?

49:12 - 50:34

Speaker 40

Mr Speaker, can I firstly just say I will arrange a new round of cross-party talks on social care certainly before the end of the year, but hopefully within the next month. And the former Shadow Health Secretary from the opposition, a leader of the main opposition came, and I will make sure it's available to all sides of the House, all parties in this House. On the question around what is happening in Ukraine, obviously I'm looking very much now at my meeting with President Zelenskyy in a couple of hours. I called him on Saturday because I recognised it was another very dark and difficult moment for him as they contemplate a winter that will be severe for his people. I recognise that he is carrying the heaviest of weights right now and it is extremely difficult for him.

What I have to do in my role is try and repair bridges so that the support comes back. And therefore I should at this moment in time be careful in terms of laying the ground to bring people back together. That is the role I intend to play. It's the right role for me to play in this moment. I will listen to President Zelenskyy carefully, but he won't be going away from Britain today empty-handed.

50:34 - 51:31

Jennifer Craft

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My six-year-old constituent Holly's school does not allow siblings to attend school events. Her brother William has profound multiple life-limiting disabilities and needs 24/7 specialist care. He's also a delightful little boy. As they cannot bring William or leave him with a babysitter, this effectively means that Holly's parents must always stay away from school events, missing everything from parents' evenings to Christmas plays to phonics workshops.

Yet Catalyst Trust, which runs the school, and its CEO Tony Parfett have repeatedly refused to make an exception to accommodate William or even to meet with myself to discuss ways forward. So will the Prime Minister back my call for the Catalyst Trust to do the right thing and can he ensure that academy trusts are meeting their reasonable adjustment obligations to disabled children and their families?

51:31 - 52:08

Speaker 40

Mr Speaker, can I thank my honourable friend for giving me advance knowledge of this case? And I'll be honest in saying it worries me. It is crucial clearly because of the circumstances that my honourable friend describes with relation to Holly's school that the family are able to spend as much time together as is possible.

That's why I've asked the Department for Education to speak to the trust. It must be possible to resolve this situation. It shouldn't be causing any stress to the family. I would ask that they do it without delay.

52:08 - 52:50

Speaker 52

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. MI5 boss Ken McCallum yesterday revealed that there have been 50 arrests in the last year linked to Iran. And I have to say, this government deserves praise. It deserves praise for proscribing the IRGC, a very, very important move. But every single week, there are young unidentified males from Iran coming into this country, some of whom pose a genuine security threat to our nation.

Is it not time the government recognize that what is going on in the English Channel is a national security emergency?

52:50 - 53:45

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, could I start just by recognizing, with the charges that have been laid against the individual responsible for the murder of Amadukum, and indeed also making threats against the honourable member, can I start by recognizing it's been a hard time for him and his family? There's a lot we disagree on, but I defend his right to say it, and I will work hard to secure his safety and every member of this House. And we will involve all sides in the Lovegrove review that my right honourable friend the Home Secretary has established. On the issues related to Iran, obviously we've seen the issues at RAF Fairford recently, Mr. Speaker, and they have been dealt with in the right way with the utmost seriousness by the police and security services. And the key point is, of course, we do need to get boat crossings down.

53:45 - 54:05

Speaker 45

I hope he would recognize that they are coming down. Removals are up. There is much more to be done, but there is clearly progress in the right direction.

54:05 - 54:37

Dawn Natasha Irons

Mr. Speaker, it's tough growing up in Britain today, and with one in five young people now with a mental health condition, the wellbeing of our young people remains in crisis. And in communities like mine in Croydon East, where young people are waiting up to four years for support, families are desperate for help. So can the Prime Minister outline what his government is doing to invest in early mental health support in communities across the country, and how will he tackle the long wait for support that is robbing young people of their future?

54:37 - 54:55

Speaker 40

Can I say to my honourable friend, Mr. Speaker, I'm going to go back to the response to the Milburn review. I think we need to give guarantees of mental health support when young people need it, not waiting months, not waiting years, exactly when they need it, and that will be a part of my response.

54:55 - 55:41

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Exactly five weeks ago, I asked the Prime Minister if he would back my three-year campaign to get a new mental health inpatient hub in Hertfordshire, which would begin to pay for itself as soon as it is built. Now, I know that the Prime Minister understands the principle of invest to save, because he himself has used this argument to explain why building social homes will reduce the housing benefit bill. So will the Prime Minister stick to his principles, and having reviewed the proposal which I sent to him, will he now commit to provide the upfront resources to build this self-funding mental health hub in Hertfordshire?

55:41 - 56:13

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, I will be writing to the honourable lady soon.

And I have to say, it might sound disappointing, but we will not be taking forward her specific suggestion. But I can tell her that we will be bringing forward four new community mental health centers across Hertfordshire, as part of 159 across the country. I would be happy to ensure the Health Secretary works with her to involve her in the design of those, those new hubs, so that we can deliver the mental health support she's rightly calling for.

56:13 - 56:45

Speaker 60

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In the summer I visited a holiday activities scheme where the organizers told me they'd had to increase the size of the lunch portions because children were hungry. With the schools closed, it was the only meal some of the kids were getting. The Prime Minister has rightly talked about the need to tackle the cost of living crisis and bring people hope again, which is essential in my constituency. So can I ask my right honorable friend, would you join me, our trade unions and community organizations in prioritizing the elimination of food poverty?

56:45 - 56:51

Speaker 53

Because Mr. Speaker, no child in our country should go to bed at night feeling hungry.

56:51 - 57:25

Speaker 40

I praise my honorable friend, Mr. Speaker, the honorable member for West Derby who's run the Right to Food campaign. And of course our trade unions, I'm a proud supporter of them and they've supported me, and I declare that interest in that matter in the way that I discussed it with the honorable member for Crewe and Nantwich recently. We do need to expand free school meals and the government is doing that, so half a million more children can access them at school. We've tripled investment in breakfast clubs. We need to keep working so that no single child in this country goes hungry in any single day.

57:25 - 57:57

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Mr. Speaker, in rural Somerset, distance has a price. Every school bus, bin round, and pothole fix costs more. Yet the government are diverting hundreds of millions from rural to urban councils, leaving Somerset 21 million pounds a year worse off. Roberta from Martock told me yesterday, we need more affordable homes, but slashing funding won't build a single one. So will the Prime Minister use December's settlement to restore remoteness funding to Somerset, yes or no?

57:57 - 58:16

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, I am determined as Prime Minister to ensure that we support all communities in this country, including our rural communities. I will listen carefully to what she's got to say as we bring forward our plans to show that we are on the side of her constituents.

58:16 - 59:11

Maureen Burke

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A recent BBC Disclosure documentary exposed violence, open drug dealing, child exploitation, and a staggering 1,200 sexual offenses recorded in Glasgow city center in the year to March 2024. We must have an honest discussion about the city's pressures, including addiction, deprivation, immigration, and community cohesion. While SNP underfunding has crippled local public services and Glasgow City Council's response has fallen short, Reform is exploiting public safety fears to stoke racial division in our welcoming city. Will the Prime Minister hear this call for help and support a coordinated response to make Glasgow safer?

59:11 - 59:44

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, policing is obviously a devolved matter, but I am very open to working with the SNP government, Police Scotland, Glasgow City Council to deal with the issues that she is referencing. As Mayor of Greater Manchester, I brought forward Operation Vulcan, which was a multi-agency approach to changing Cheetham Hill. And it did rip out entrenched criminality in that area. I'm more than happy to talk to her about how we pioneer that in Glasgow too, and that is an offer that's open to her.

59:44 - 01:00:09

Speaker 55

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Leader of the Opposition has made it crystal clear about doing deals with other parties. So will the Prime Minister make it equally clear, following the Green Party's descent into the most abhorrent antisemitism, that he will rule out cooperating with them?

01:00:09 - 01:00:38

Speaker 45

Mr. Speaker, can I condemn the motion that was passed unequivocally? It was wrong, it is antisemitic, and this side of the House will have nothing to do with it. And we will always take the right response when it comes to any partnerships we have with other parties. We cannot support a partnership with a party that holds a position that has recently been adopted.

01:00:38 - 01:01:11

Chris Kane

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On a recent visit to Stirling High School, senior pupils studying politics and modern studies asked me about everything from climate change to war in the Middle East. One young woman asked how young people can know they're being heard by politicians. So I've brought her question here so that she and her classmates can see that a question asked in their assembly hall can get an answer from the Prime Minister. Whether we're discussing mental health, housing, jobs, our relationship with Europe, or the upcoming report in NEETs, we're discussing their future.

01:01:11 - 01:01:17

Speaker 58

How will the Prime Minister ensure we talk with young people rather than just about them, and show them that their ideas and opinions shape the decisions we take in this place?

01:01:17 - 01:01:50

Speaker 40

Well, I couldn't agree with him more strongly, Mr. Speaker. And I will be in Scotland on Friday making a speech on these issues, looking at how we can do more to support young people and help the government in Scotland develop its approach to getting more young people into work. So we've also got the Your First Home scheme that we've brought forward, Mr. Speaker. We need to do much more to help young people get themselves established in life, and we will do that in all parts of the UK, including Scotland.

01:01:50 - 01:02:25

Munira Wilson

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Despite the desperate need for pitch space in my constituency, Udney Park playing fields in Teddington have lain derelict for over a decade. The most recent owner, a Chinese businessman, has now been sanctioned by the British government and had his assets frozen. So given the Prime Minister has made clear that he wants communities to take back control of precious sites like Udney Park, will he work with me to ensure these playing fields are put back in the hands of the community right where they belong?

01:02:25 - 01:02:45

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, I am a complete champion for green space and physical activity, and I'm concerned to hear about the situation her constituents are in. I've just had a commitment from the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport to meet her to get this situation unlocked, and I hope that's helpful to her.

01:02:45 - 01:03:19

Edward Joseph Powell

Mr. Speaker, it's now nearly ten years on from the Grenfell Tower fire, and I welcome the recent progress on criminal accountability. But from Hillsborough to infected blood to the Countess of Chester Hospital, too often inquiries and inquests make recommendations that sit on a shelf, leaving victims chasing answers and avoidable harms continuing. So will the Prime Minister give his support to an independent national oversight mechanism to sit alongside the Hillsborough Law and ensure that when tragedies like Grenfell do occur, the state is held properly accountable for change?

01:03:19 - 01:04:04

Speaker 40

Well, can I agree strongly with my honorable friend?

I remember bringing the Hillsborough families to meet the Grenfell families shortly after the disaster. It's painful that it's taken so long for charges to be laid, but at least they have been laid now. I know the First Secretary has met with the chair of the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee this week to look at the oversight mechanism that he describes, and I'm confident we can develop a model that gives exactly the commitment that he's looking for. Mr Speaker, I want to leave him and his constituents in no doubt whatsoever, as Prime Minister, I will work to support him every day to get justice for Grenfell.

01:04:04 - 01:04:41

James Cleverly

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The NPPF is 130 pages long. The London Plan is over 500 pages long. The Mayor's guidance to the London Plan is over 2,000 pages long. Will he concede that that, added to the increase in taxes that his government is putting on businesses and employers, that Labour has been a disaster for homebuilding in London, pricing young people out of the market and putting pressure on home counties constituencies like mine?

01:04:41 - 01:05:27

Speaker 45

Mr Speaker, can I say that the right honourable gentleman just gave me a moment of déjà vu. I remember standing up in these benches auditioning for a mayor's job many years ago. He didn't do a bad audition, but maybe it needs a little bit of work because I think the administration he worked in left some of that bureaucracy behind in London City Hall. And I hope he will show more candour and directness than the right honourable lady the Leader of the Opposition if he's ever asked the question, has Brexit been good or bad for London? What's his answer?

01:05:27 - 01:06:40

Speaker 65

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The 21st of October marks the 60th anniversary of the Aberfan disaster that claimed the lives of 116 children and 28 adults. In the coming days, the community will mark the occasion with a range of events, and as a precursor, this evening in Portcullis House, the Lewis Merthyr Band will perform a piece of music dedicated to the lost children of Aberfan. It was the most unimaginable horror that befell the village, and just how the community came together in the days and months ahead was and is testament to the spirit of the people of that community who responded with such dignity and fortitude. It is fitting that the chair of the Aberfan Memorial Committee and a survivor of the disaster, Mr David Davies, is with us in the gallery today.

01:06:40 - 01:07:16

Speaker 40

So could I ask the Prime Minister if he will join with me in paying tribute to those who were lost and to what Her Late Majesty Queen Elizabeth II described as the most indomitable spirit of the people and the community of Aberfan?

Can I thank my honourable friend for his question and say that I will be meeting David shortly and look forward to paying tribute to him as chair of the Aberfan Memorial Committee for all of the support he's provided over the years to the 144 people who died, of course many of them children, the families who've lived with that grief for generations.

01:07:16 - 01:07:21

Speaker 59

Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's 43 days since the Prime Minister received a letter signed by all opposition parties expressing support for the Lobular Moonshot project.

01:07:21 - 01:07:46

Peter Timothy Fortune

Can I also say to him that I intend to visit Aberfan next week on the occasion of the 60th anniversary.

It's a project which seeks funding to fight the insidious disease that is lobular breast cancer. Sadly, no response has been received. When the Prime Minister was Mayor of Greater Manchester, he committed to supporting the Lobular Moonshot Project. Would he reaffirm that commitment from the dispatch box today?

01:07:46 - 01:08:03

Speaker 40

I will indeed, Mr. Speaker. I remember the meeting very well indeed. And I speak as someone whose family's been affected by breast cancer. Yes, I look forward to meeting them again, perhaps with him and other colleagues on all sides of the House.

01:08:03 - 01:08:06

Speaker 70

Peter Dowd, final question.

01:08:06 - 01:08:23

Speaker 76

In recent weeks, Mr. Speaker, the Argentine government has increased its aggression, its economic aggression towards the Falkland Islands. Given this, could the Prime Minister update the House on the actions the government are taking in response to that belligerence?

01:08:23 - 01:09:03

Speaker 40

Mr. Speaker, our position is unwavering. The Falkland Islands are British and will remain so because that is the overwhelming will of the Falkland Islanders. We have made that clear to Argentina directly. We will not allow the Islanders to be used as a prop in Argentinian domestic politics. I raised this issue directly with President Trump just a few weeks ago.

We will not allow Britain or indeed the Falkland Islands to be bullied in this way. We will seek to resolve the situation, but we will not hesitate to use more robust measures if necessary.

01:09:03 - 01:10:02

Speaker 78

That completes Prime Minister's Questions. Let the front benches change over.

01:10:02 - 01:10:13

Speaker 73

Right, if the House has settled. Go through quickly, keep going. Marvelous. Presentation of bill, Secretary Angela Rayner.

01:10:13 - 01:10:25

Speaker 74

Tomorrow. Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc.) Bill. Second reading what day? Tomorrow.

01:10:25 - 01:10:29

Speaker 72

Tomorrow. Presentation of bill, George Freeman.

01:10:29 - 01:10:36

Speaker 71

Flooding Bill. Second reading what day? Friday, 4th of December.

01:10:36 - 01:10:43

Speaker 73

Friday the 4th of December. Presentation of bill, Josh Babarinde.

01:10:43 - 01:10:57

Speaker 75

Armed Forces Compensation Scheme and War Pension Scheme (Report) Bill. Second reading what day? Friday the 13th of November.

01:10:57 - 01:11:13

Speaker 73

Friday the 13th of November. Fantastic. Well done. We now come to the ten-minute rule motion, Wet Wipes (Labelling, Sale and Marketing), David Burton-Sampson.

01:11:13 - 01:20:55

David Edmund Burton-Sampson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to make provision about the marketing, advertising and offering for sale of wet wipes, to make provision about the labelling of wet wipes and for connected purposes.

Madam Deputy Speaker, the city of Southend has seven miles of beautiful beaches and Leigh-on-Sea is well known as a picturesque fishing village which still has a very vibrant cockling industry. My constituency is also home to many wild swimming groups such as the Blue Tits who find the refreshing waters of the Thames Estuary provide great exercise as well as benefits to their mental and physical well-being. Although I have to say when I took a dip in December for charity, I didn't find it too relaxing. All this might help you understand why water quality is so important to my constituents and to me. Like so many, they were rightfully outraged at the sewage dumps that sadly have become routine during the years under the former Conservative government.

So the people of Southend West and Leigh did what they so often do. They came together to make a difference on something they care about. They worked together to form quarterly water summits in 2024, giving residents the opportunity to hold water companies directly to account, to collaborate with the council, Ofwat and the Environment Agency and many more to find solutions to our water problems in Southend. This was the first summit of its kind in the country and those summits continue to this day. And I thank my constituent Daniela Boon, who's up in the gallery today, for her leadership on these summits and in this area.

It was through chairing these water summits as a newly elected MP that I came to learn just how complex the issues affecting water quality and sewage discharges are. Certainly, water companies play the most important role and I welcome the work being done by this government to hold them to account. But sewage discharges happen when the water system fails on so many different levels. Councils, the community, planning decisions, green spaces, even the choice of whether or not to pave your driveway, all these things come together to influence outcomes. Last year, when spending time at our local sewage treatment plant, I learned that blockages are a leading cause of sewage discharge.

When the sewers block, there are only two places for that sewage to go. In Southend, it will be out into the estuary or back up into people's homes and toilets. We will have all seen in the media that these blockages are often caused by fatbergs. The pictures can be very shocking. The Guinness World Record belongs to the fatberg found in Whitechapel in London in 2017, which was 250 metres long, longer than Tower Bridge.

There's no wonder with blockages of this size that our sewage system sometimes struggles to cope with its functions. And alongside grease and fat, these bergs are most oftenly made up of wet wipes. In Anglian Water's network alone, around 500,000 wet wipes are flushed every single day. Instead of breaking down, many wet wipes remain largely intact. They snag on roots, pumps and rough surfaces within sewers and they combine with fats, oils and grease to create these large blockages.

In my constituency alone, Anglian Water dealt with 610 blockages last year, all caused by unflushable items. Now this government has brought in legislation to ban plastic in wet wipes, a measure which both me and my constituents welcome.

This is an incredibly necessary step. It reduces harmful microplastics that poison wildlife and enter the food chain. But biodegradable doesn't necessarily mean flushable. And the truth is that even plastic-free wipes are made of tougher fibers that don't break down in the toilet in the same way that paper does. At our water summit, Anglian Water will often remind us that there is no such thing as a flushable wipe.

When I visited Anglian Water's water treatment plant on Stock Road, I got to see a whole skip, yes, an entire skip filled with long, stringy fibers from wet wipes that had been fished out of our water system. And you can only imagine how that smelt. People flush wipes because they're labeled as flushable. The package is packaging is often clearly marked with a flushable logo. The wet wipe may disappear when the handle is pressed, but disappearing down the toilet is not the same thing as passing safely through the sewage network.

Consumers can't see and don't know what happens after that wipe has been flushed. And if the packaging says it's flushable, why would you think otherwise? We shouldn't expect consumers to decipher competing claims from water companies and manufacturers. And we can't expect them to conduct their own experiments before deciding to flush their wipes down the toilet. We did conduct some experiments in my office and we could see that some of these flushable wipes don't actually dissolve in water.

People should be able to trust what's on the packaging. Every October, campaigns such as Unblocktober encourage people to think before they flush. These campaigns have helped to raise awareness, but awareness alone is not enough. We cannot spend one month of the year urging people not to flush wet wipes while allowing manufacturers to market those same products as flushable the whole year long. Education and labeling should not be pulling in opposite directions.

The public need a clear and consistent message to just bin it. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to be clear, the ultimate responsibility for fixing our water systems does not lie with consumers or even wet wipe manufacturers. It lies with the water companies. We know that they took on the serious responsibility of protecting our waterways, rivers and seas, and often they have failed. This Labour government has successfully passed the Water Special Measures Act to strengthen regulations of the water industry, allowing bonuses to be banned for company owners who pollute our waterways and even making it possible to hold water company executives criminally responsible.

It will also enable independent monitoring of every sewer outflow outlet. And we will go further with plans for greater public control of water coming later this year. No amount of responsible flushing is going to repair the outdated infrastructure, prioritize investment or build new reservoirs. But it is part of the picture in keeping our waterways clean. I would like to welcome the 90 million plus investment by Anglian Water working in partnership with Southend City Council, which will help tackle flooding, improve water systems and public spaces.

Now this bill proposes that there should be a clear indication on all wet wipes showing you that they should be disposed safely in the bin and encouraging people to only flush the three Ps: pee, poo and paper. Non-flushable wipes should be clearly labeled as such with a visible symbol on the front of the packaging.

Wipes that pass rigorous testing could continue to be labelled as flushable, but the onus should be on the manufacturer to prove that they will break down and cause no damage to the water system or to the plumbing of people's homes. Labelling should also clearly and prominently instruct consumers as to the restrictions, such as only flush one wipe at a time. Now, the ISO published a technical specification on flushability in August this year. It's vitally important that the water industry works closely with manufacturers to establish clear and realistic specifications around what can be classed as flushable moist toilet tissue. Consumers need confidence that flushable actually means flushable, and right now this is not the case.

This is a matter of consumer trust. I'm not telling people to use alternative to wet wipes, although alternatives do exist. I know that people will want to use wet wipes for medical reasons or just because it's what they prefer. But they should know that for the sake of our pipes, our plumbing bills and for our wildlife, they should just bin it.

01:20:55 - 01:21:06

Speaker 81

The question is that the honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. As contrary no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?

01:21:06 - 01:21:24

David Edmund Burton-Sampson

Madam Deputy Speaker, Lee Ingram, Cat Eccles, Chris Law, Chris Vince, Danny Beales, Alex Barros-Curtis, Lee Barron, Mike Reader, James Naish, Lizzy Collinge, Bayo Alaba and myself.

01:21:24 - 01:22:05

Speaker 83

David Burton-Sampson. Wet wipes, labelling, sale and marketing bill. Father of the house, what second reading what day?

01:22:05 - 01:22:07

Speaker 80

Friday the 13th of November.

01:22:07 - 01:22:41

Speaker 73

Friday the 13th of November. Well done, well done. If we're ready, Deputy Chief Whip, if we're ready. We now come to the opposition day motion on MOD Bicester and illegal migrants. I inform the house that the speaker has not selected any amendment, and I call the opposition spokesperson to move the motion.

01:22:41 - 01:22:44

Speaker 79

Shadow Minister, Joy Morrissey.

01:22:44 - 01:24:18

Joy Morrissey

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I beg to move the motion in the official in the name of the official opposition in my name. And the benches opposite would not go and meet the women of Piddington and to hear their concerns. So today, these benches have brought the women of Piddington to them. They are in the gallery today.

So now the Minister for Women and Equalities and her colleagues on the front and back benches opposite have nowhere to hide. The women of Piddington have written to all female Labour MPs and are still waiting a response. How they vote today will be seen by the women of Piddington and by the women in towns, cities and villages across the country. So let me start with a simple question to Labour MPs. Today, will they put the interests of women before those of the Labour Party?

I have been to Piddington. I've been there twice. The right honourable friend, the leader of the opposition and our shadow Home Secretary have also been there to speak with the women first-hand. We all could see clearly that the safety of women and girls in that small village is at risk. A village of 350 people shortly to have 1300 migrants imposed on them.

Men who have already broken the law by coming here illegally. Men... I will give way.

01:24:18 - 01:24:44

Greg Gregory Smith

I'm grateful to my honourable friend for bringing this motion and opening it in the customary powerful way she is. Piddington has the headlines, but it's not just Piddington. It's also the women in Oakley, in Marsh Gibbon, in Ludgershall, in Brill, in Boarstall, in Long Crendon and many other villages just over the Buckinghamshire border that are within walking distance of MOD Bicester Site A.

01:24:44 - 01:25:00

Joy Morrissey

My honourable friend makes an excellent point and it is not just in that area but it is across the country. It is... and it is affecting women and girls and constituencies everywhere across the UK. Shall I give way, please? I will give way.

01:25:00 - 01:25:38

Jim Shannon

To reiterate that... that issue and the honourable gentleman put forward in his intervention. It's a massive issue, illegal immigration and illegal migration in my constituency of Strangford. My constituents tell me that every day that I'm on the doors. Illegal... migrants aren't just a problem for the UK mainland, they're a problem in Strangford across Northern Ireland. The... of the annoyance amongst my problem... my constituents is that illegal migrants use the ECHR system to bypass the system to be an obstacle.

Does the honourable lady agree with me it's time for the ECHR to be abolished and for those illegal migrants to be sent back home?

01:25:38 - 01:26:18

Joy Morrissey

Thank you. My honourable friend makes an excellent point and we will be voting with... we are back in government to leave the ECHR as Conservatives because we believe that we want to deport... illegal immigrants from the start, from the moment they arrive. And the village of Piddington, Madam Deputy Speaker, it does only have 350 people, but the 1300 migrant men will be a blight on their small village. Men from cultures where women are treated worse than animals. Men that the government have decided need a leaflet asking them to not rape women and girls.

I will give way.

01:26:18 - 01:26:45

Craig Gareth Snell

I thank the honourable lady for giving way and I... and I commend her efforts to raise the voices of all people from across this country. So under the Conservatives, my city Stoke-on-Trent has something around 1400... migrants living in there... dispersed there. That number's come down significantly under this government. So can she tell me which Conservative ministers and maybe herself visited Stoke-on-Trent in their government time to listen to the voices of that community or is it only now she cares about the voices when it's politically expedient?

01:26:45 - 01:27:42

Joy Morrissey

Thank you. Well, actually, I went as... as the PPS for the Prime Minister at the time because we held a cabinet meeting in Stoke-on-Trent. So actually, I was able to see... first-hand the... the issues that the honourable gentleman has mentioned. So thank you for raising that. It was good to remember that.

And... and I did raise this issue about the safety of women and girls, Madam Deputy Speaker, a few weeks ago in my first oral... oral questions to the shadow minister. And I asked two questions very directly. Did the government agree that men entering this country illegally from countries such as Eritrea, Afghanistan and Sudan pose a direct threat to the safety of women and girls? And did the government agree that men who enter Britain illegally and need a leaflet telling them not to rape women and girls should instead be deported immediately?

01:27:42 - 01:27:43

I will give way.

01:27:43 - 01:28:33

Mark Pritchard

I'm grateful to my honorable friend for giving way. She lists some of the countries: Pakistan, Eritrea, Iran, Sudan, and Afghanistan. They're the top five countries. And of course it's right to talk about national security, and we hear a lot about that over the last few days. But today we are talking about personal security.

The personal security of women, of young girls, and indeed young boys. And of course not everybody coming over here illegally would seek to attack, but too many do. And even when they go to prison, because of the ECHR, we're not able to deport them. So we need to leave the ECHR, we need to secure our borders, we need to have a deterrent. And we are a fair-minded country, but enough is enough.

01:28:33 - 01:30:22

Joy Morrissey

I agree with everything my honorable friend has said, and I will echo those things in the speech as we go along. So thank you for that. Because when we ask these questions, the legitimate questions raised about women and girls being under threat, the minister at the time could not find the answer. And perhaps today the minister can. The women of Puddington deserve our thanks in this house because they have made their voices heard.

But they are far from alone. The women of Linton-on-Ouse in North Yorkshire are worried about the 1,200 men about to descend on their community. The women of Barnham in Suffolk facing 1,250 illegal migrant men in their midst. The women in Crowborough in Sussex who have been working so closely with their excellent local Member of Parliament for Sussex Weald to deal with illegal migrant men already in their community. May I pay tribute to their very hard-working local MP who has been battling a coalition of Greens, Lib Dems, Labour, everyone, and the Home Office, interestingly enough.

In a moment. The Home Office interestingly made an asylum application for 540 asylum seekers which moved in in January, and now they have extended that application to 2030. And the member for Sussex Weald has been single-handedly battling against the council, battling against the Home Office, and she is at the front lines of this issue. So thank you for raising women and girls' voices.

01:30:22 - 01:30:24

Speaker 85

I will give way.

01:30:24 - 01:31:10

John Hayes

I'm extremely grateful to my honorable friend for giving way, who's making a powerful speech in defense of right and decency and my constituents and hers. The problem we face, and she's alluded to it in her remarks just now, is the whole of the liberal establishment either can't see this or won't see it. And at the root of the problem is they don't recognize that cultural equivalence doesn't exist. Some of these people are coming from countries where their values are entirely different from us, where they regard things as acceptable that we see as either unpalatable or frankly horrendous. And the failure to accept that fact underpins the unwillingness to do anything about what she's just described.

01:31:10 - 01:31:25

Joy Morrissey

My honorable friend makes an excellent point, and it isn't just their values being different from ours, it is taking advantage of our nature and our culture and our values. And I will give way.

01:31:25 - 01:31:47

Zubir Ahmed

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm really grateful to my honorable friend for giving way. She's talking about values and culture. She's already alluded to the fact that she served in the previous government. I wonder what the culture of that government was when boat crossings were at record high, when the honorable member for Newark was opening hotels like they were going out of season.

What was the culture in that government in terms of attempting to combat this issue then?

01:31:47 - 01:32:07

Joy Morrissey

Well, luckily we're under new leadership and I'm waiting and I would love to hear from the honorable gentleman why not one member of the Labour Party has responded to the women of Puddington who have written to them about this issue.

01:32:07 - 01:32:17

Speaker 90

There is one person speaking at this moment. That's the only voice I wish to hear. Joy Morrissey.

01:32:17 - 01:33:33

Joy Morrissey

The government has said that middle-class areas need to bear their fair share, using class as a new weapon to silence concerns. It is a dangerous, lazy approach from a government who are supposed to unite our country. This isn't about class or race or anything else that the party opposite want to use to silence those speaking up. That technique was used to silence rape gang victims in our cities and towns. It is appalling that Labour has not learned from that scandal.

This is about women speaking up about fears for their safety and that of their children. The Prime Minister should listen. The benches opposite should listen. They know that these women and their communities will suffer. They know this because we already have proof.

Communities across this land have seen their women and girls' lives ruined, ruined by the fundamental failure of this government to protect them from the threat posed by men who come here illegally. Men... yes, I will give way.

01:33:33 - 01:34:01

Ben Goldsborough

The honorable lady for giving way. Would she join me in congratulating this Labour government for shutting down the Brook asylum hotel that is just 200 yards over my constituency border, which was opened on the 28th of September 2022 by the Conservative government, making sure that the constituency of South Norfolk and South Norwich took into account the concerns of women, girls, and all other constituents within our area?

01:34:01 - 01:34:18

Joy Morrissey

I would ask the honorable gentleman why HMOs have increased by 12% for asylum accommodation since this government took over, why there has been this movement from hotels to HMOs, and what is the long-term solution about these asylum... yes, I will give way.

01:34:18 - 01:34:42

Luke Morgan Evans

I appreciate her giving way. The point of fact is the hotels have been closed down because HMOs have been opened up and the government won't even specify how many HMOs because it conglomerates the data. So we can't even get transparent answers for my community when we see HMOs open up, which puts my community at risk and the people who are housed in the HMOs. Does she not agree?

01:34:42 - 01:34:52

Speaker 91

I do agree with my honorable friend and you make an excellent point, which I will bring up later on in this speech because... Miss Morrissey, Miss Morrissey.

01:34:52 - 01:34:57

Speaker 89

Just because it's going to be a long debate, no you or yours. Joy Morrissey.

01:34:57 - 01:36:33

Joy Morrissey

So this issue of the asylum accommodation, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to show the House a few examples because we have men who have raped and assaulted women and girls. Mohamed Sheikh, a Syrian asylum seeker, came here illegally by boat. He was placed in asylum accommodation, then sexually assaulted two women in Falkirk. He told police he was just roaming around. The judge sentenced him to four years, saying that he treated those women as though their autonomy, dignity, and bodily integrity counted for nothing.

Three asylum seekers from Iran and Egypt were convicted in April of raping a woman in Brighton. They travelled from their asylum accommodation in Horsham, they kicked her, grabbed her throat, raped her, and filmed it. Mohammad Abbas, an illegal migrant claiming to be Palestinian, was put up in a taxpayer-funded house in Cardiff. He broke into a nearby property and exposed himself to two girls aged 16 and 13 in their bedroom. An Afghan illegal migrant raped a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton just four months after he arrived here by boat.

He abducted her, raped her, and filmed her. These are just a few of the, I will give way.

01:36:33 - 01:36:50

Luke Morgan Evans

That was my neighbouring constituency. Does she now understand why my community is so upset when we see people moving into HMOs because of the risk posed and the evidence base that she's just announced?

01:36:50 - 01:37:28

Joy Morrissey

Indeed, and my honourable friend makes that point very eloquently. And it is very important that we stand up for our local communities to protect them from illegal migrant men. And these are just a few of the horrific crimes committed by illegal migrant men, men who should have been deported before they could roam our streets and forever change the lives of young women and girls. Men who have, who will pay no notice to a gently worded leaflet trying to encourage them to understand our cultural values. These men do not care about our values.

01:37:28 - 01:37:35

Speaker 96

They are here to take advantage of our welcoming culture. I will give way.

01:37:35 - 01:38:06

Christopher Murray

I thank the honourable lady for giving way. The proposal from the government is to open large sites far from the centres of town where there can be resources and such as Home Office officials and when the police can be informed. When I was, when before I was elected and I worked for asylum accommodation, the honourable lady's government would open hotels in the centres of cities without telling local authorities and without even telling the police. Why is she proposing that her system is more safe for local communities than this alternative?

01:38:06 - 01:38:46

Joy Morrissey

Well, I would encourage the honourable gentleman to come to Pittington to see that there is a very small village right up against what is going to be a very large asylum camp which has no additional police protection, which has no additional provision, and the men will be allowed to roam free through the village. It will create a safeguarding issue for young children, for girls, and there is no reason why this community should have to suffer just like communities in York and across the country. They are suffering because we are not deporting these illegal migrants. And that is why we need to leave the ECHR. And I will.

01:38:46 - 01:39:21

Andrew Murrison

I'm very grateful. Is it not the case that the benches opposite have entirely missed the point? And that is that dealing with the problem once it's arrived here and in our communities won't do. We need something fundamental that deals with the problem which admittedly didn't arrive in 2024, it's of relatively long standing, but we need a solution just like the Rwanda solution that was on the cusp of being implemented at the general election. The first thing that the party opposite did on coming into office was to can that.

01:39:21 - 01:41:07

Joy Morrissey

My honourable friend makes an excellent point. We did suggest Rwanda and that is also why we as Conservatives are committed to leaving the ECHR so that we can deport foreign nationals who come here illegally within a week.

And that is why we want to leave the ECHR. And these... I will give way just let me make some more progress first. These are just a few of the horrific crimes committed by illegal migrant men. Men who should have been deported before they could roam our streets.

Now, these are cases that show the women of Pittington, of Litton-on-Ouse, of Barnet are right to be concerned. So let me be clear to the benches opposite. When their only political response to hearing of these crimes and the legitimate fears that are being raised by these women and girls is to shout weaponization, that says more about them and their priorities than their political opponents. When their only policy response is to launch a talking shop on misogyny, they should recognize how weak that makes them look. When they refuse to meet these women, it speaks volumes about their commitment to women and girls.

It is not hard to see why this commitment is lacking. I wrote to the Minister for Women and Equalities offering to work cross-party and facilitate a meeting with the women of Pittington. I haven't had a response. But I heard in the media it was a no. She is chair of the Labour Party first and women's minister second.

I will give way.

01:41:07 - 01:41:27

Peter Wishart

I'm grateful to the honorable lady for giving way. I just want to take her back because she's mentioned a couple of times now and the motion also references this exit from the ECHR. Now I know she's somebody who's all over her brief, so can she tell me what this would mean for the devolved settlement and what implications it would have for the Scottish Parliament?

01:41:27 - 01:43:49

Joy Morrissey

Thank you. Yeah, I'm... Not at all, but I don't want to go into that from my honorable gentleman. But what I would say is that the issue of the asylum seeker in Falkirk and the issue that personally I have had from women not just in England but also in Scotland and Wales raising the concerns of illegal migrants in their midst roaming the streets, there is a problem. There is a difference in how these men are treating our women and girls and people are genuinely afraid.

And I am sure somewhere lurking in the whips' brief speeches for the members opposite are some of the tried old tunes. So let me quickly save them some time from intervening on me to engage in the substance and we can just go back and I'll trot out a few of them and give you my response to save time. So, when they trot out 14 years, I will say they've had two years and the British people are already desperate for them to stop there. When they say that illegal migrant men aren't the threat to women and girls, men known to them are, I will say both things can be true and I want to tackle both. Why don't they?

I will say why won't they give us the data on the crimes committed against women and girls by men with active asylum claims? The truth is this government has a hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil approach to this issue. The benches opposite do not want to hear the women of Pittington, Litton-on-Ouse or Barnet because of an uncomfortable truth they will speak. The benches opposite do not want to see the data on how significant a problem the crimes of illegal migrant men are against women and children for fear of Pandora's box being opened. The benches opposite do not want to speak about this issue because of the ideological capture of their own party, capture by people who have placed an obsession with multiculturalism above a cohesive British society.

01:43:49 - 01:43:54

Speaker 99

This is about the choices we make as a country. We have let in... I will give way.

01:43:53 - 01:44:45

Layla Moran

I'm extremely grateful to her giving way. She is giving a powerful speech and a reminder to the people of Oxfordshire why there are no Conservative MPs or councils led by Conservatives in Oxfordshire anymore. Because while the women of Piddington, I absolutely commend them for speaking up, I commend those young women in Oxford who have come to me with saying that their voices have not been heard. There are women across this country, in all parts of this country, in all sorts of circumstances, where this is true. And it should have been the violence against women and girls strategy, which is criticised by the NAO in January 25, written by the leader of the opposition when she was women and equalities minister, that should have tackled it.

Would she answer, is the leader of the opposition going to also apologise to the women in Piddington and women across this country?

01:44:45 - 01:47:23

Joy Morrissey

I thank you for that intervention, and I would point out that there may be some buyer's remorse across Oxfordshire, but I couldn't possibly say. But I will say that we and the Liberal Democrats have a very different view of open borders, of immigration, of migrants welcome here, and that is perhaps coming home to roost across the country, but it is not for me to comment, it is for the voters to decide. And we have let in men, and we have lost control of them. They have roamed around our streets to rape and assault women and girls, and we have placed them in British jails at our expense. Enough.

It is time to be clear that if you come here illegally, you have already broken the law and you will be deported. The ECHR should no longer be a weapon that the left-wing lawyers can use to keep you here if you arrive illegally. The government are placing British women and girls in harm's way. The government refuses even the common courtesy of listening to women when they speak up about their concerns. They just want to be heard.

Please, can the government take the time to listen to these women? The Conservative benches have listened. Listen to the women who are concerned about their safety. Listen to the British people who want action on illegal immigration, not gimmicks and TikTok videos. Our border plan will deliver the control needed and the protections British women and girls deserve, a plan built on clear values and the detailed hard work needed to make it work.

If you come here illegally, you cannot claim asylum. You will be deported in a week. We will take Britain out of the ECHR. We will establish a removal force to remove illegal immigrants. The choice for the benches opposite and across the house is clear.

Do they believe that thousands of illegal migrant men from cultures that treat women so badly pose a direct threat to the safety of British women and girls? If not, how many more appalling stories of crime against women and girls do they need? On these benches, we have heard enough of these crimes to know it is time to act. We must not be housing immigrants who come here illegally. The ECHR has stood in our way for far too long for acting to the common sense and the good of British people.

It is time to leave the ECHR. It is time to put the rights of British people first.

01:47:23 - 01:47:25

Speaker 104

I will give way.

01:47:25 - 01:47:52

Andrew Murrison

Lord Wolfson has put that beyond fear of peradventure in his report. We have to leave the ECHR, but would you agree with me that is not enough because some of the countries that we want to send people back to won't take them, and in particular Pakistan. And is it not the case we need to get real with the government of Pakistan and say if you refuse to cooperate with us, you can forget about visas and you can forget about foreign aid.

01:47:52 - 01:48:17

Joy Morrissey

My honorable friend makes an excellent point and our shadow home secretary has already made this point of we need sanctions, we need proper ways of enforcement with those countries that refuse to take back our asylum claimants. So he will be referring to that later as well. And let me finally say... I will give way.

01:48:17 - 01:48:54

Suella Braverman

Four years ago, I was the first Conservative minister to say publicly that in order to stop the boats and protect women and girls, we needed to leave the European Convention on Human Rights in order to achieve that. My honorable friend, the member for Clacton, has been advocating departure of the ECHR for many years. Will the shadow minister take this opportunity to apologize to the nation for refusing on behalf of the leader of the opposition to support my policy proposal when her party had the opportunity, had the power, and indeed the duty to stop the boats and deal with the invasion.

01:48:54 - 01:50:05

Joy Morrissey

May I thank the honorable lady. And may I point out that when the honorable lady was home secretary and was in charge of all of these things and making these key decisions... Immigration was at record levels, but I will commend her for calling many of these things out, but when she had the opportunity at the helm to do something... I will just point out that and leave that there. But enough said.

Let me finally say this to the women here today in the public gallery, to those I have met in Piddington and elsewhere, to the women who have written to me, to the women and girls across Britain worried about their safety. I hear you. My right honorable friend, the shadow home secretary hears you, the leader of the opposition hears you, the Conservative party hears you. We are here for you. We will act.

01:50:05 - 01:50:13

Speaker 103

The question is as on the order paper and I call the minister, Minister Ann Attorney.

01:50:13 - 01:51:00

Speaker 106

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And let me begin by thanking the honorable lady opposite for calling this debate and I'd also like to place on record my thanks to all the honorable members in this house who have engaged with me in the few weeks since I took this role to talk to me about asylum accommodation in their constituencies and I think it's really important that we continue that powerful dialogue including yourself, Madam Deputy Speaker, who I know has engaged with me often on this issue and I appreciate that engagement. Thank you. But I particularly like to thank the honorable lady opposite because I really do welcome the opportunity to update members on the government's work to fix our country's broken asylum system. A system which was in a state of absolute chaos and disarray when we took office two years ago.

01:51:00 - 01:51:32

Speaker 107

The legacy of the honorable lady and her team is actually what we're dealing with here today. I'll come onto the action we're taking to restore fairness, order and control shortly, but it's really important that any debate on asylum must be put in its proper context and that means recognizing the situation that we inherited. Because it was this government, Madam Deputy Speaker, that picked up the pieces after the general election following years of inaction and ineptitude that we've already heard with mudslinging across the opposition benches this morning and finger pointing and blame. We are getting on with fixing the mess. We are getting on with fixing the flow which they allowed.

01:51:32 - 01:52:54

Speaker 105

And the honorable lady referred to the 14 years and the two years, well I look forward to setting out the difference between that 14 years and the two years over the course of my speech. In 2018, Madam Deputy Speaker, around 300 people arrived here by small boat. In the years that followed, on the party under the party opposite's watch, an entire criminal industry built up along our borders. Ruthless smugglers sent people on dangerous, unnecessary, and far too often fatal journeys, making a fortune in the process. The consequences of all of this are well known to the House, but they do bear repeating.

Between January 2021 and June 2024, 110,000 people came here by small boat. Meanwhile, the asylum system ground to a halt. Decision making collapsed, leaving thousands in limbo for years at taxpayer's expense. So too did the returns of those with no right to be here in the UK. And a further 175,000 claimed asylum by other routes.

As the numbers rose, so did the cost to the taxpayer. In just a single year, spending on asylum support under the the party opposite was 4.7 billion pounds. That's an incredible cost to the taxpayer that we could and should be spending on other priorities that we debate in this place. And that includes... Of course I will.

01:52:54 - 01:53:17

Christopher Murray

I thank the Minister for giving way. On the Home Affairs Committee over the last two years, we've looked into the cost of this cost to the taxpayer. Does the Minister share my outrage that huge amounts of public money there have gone to private companies, some of whose owners entered the Sunday Times Rich List while our communities suffered? And does she agree with me that the signer and the author of those contracts was the member for Reform sitting opposite?

01:53:17 - 01:53:54

Speaker 105

I thank the honorable gentleman, he makes an extremely important point. And that under the last government it was 9 million pounds a day on housing people in 400 asylum hotels, costly, inefficient, and actually evidence has shown that this was part of the draw for people. They knew that they were going to come and be put in a nice hotel, and we know that that was actually part of the pull factors that we're trying to deal with and tackle here today. In response to this industrial scale people smuggling, all we had, as we've heard, was the farce of the Rwanda scheme, 700 million pounds spent on sending four volunteers to Rwanda. Madam Deputy Speaker, the British people, the British people have a natural... I will.

01:53:54 - 01:54:13

Andrew Murrison

Well, she talks about Rwanda, but she didn't give it a chance to generate results. On day one, the previous Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, canned it without any prospect of showing demonstrable results. Looking back, does she think that was wise?

01:54:13 - 01:56:06

Speaker 105

I don't know how much money the honorable gentleman wants to keep spending good after bad, but 700 million pounds on four volunteers was an incredible waste of money. Madam Deputy Speaker, the British people, the British people have a natural sense of fairness. We know we are a nation which has benefited from centuries of facing outwards towards the world, both reaching out across the globe and welcoming in. I can't imagine there is barely a member here who doesn't have either some historic migration or family ties. The British people will always accept those who are genuinely fleeing peril.

They will welcome those who come here legally and who contribute. They know we are a place where people can come to build their lives and aspire to do great things. Even this House reflects that, particularly in the last week or so, with so many of our representatives here and their stories. But what the British people will not accept is chaos at our borders. They will not accept a lack of control over who comes in.

They will not accept the unfairness of a broken system where those who break the rules are the ones who benefit from our welcome. Nor will they tolerate expensive and often iconic hotels across their communities being used to house asylum seekers at vast expense to the taxpayers.

Or, I'm going to make a bit of progress if I may. Or illegal migrants placing pressure on our public services while efforts to remove them are frustrated. Now Madam Deputy Speaker, there's no quick fix, but the task of ending the chaos and crucially restoring fairness falls to this government and we embrace it. Because it is only a Labour government that will fix the broken system, restore control at our borders, bring fairness back to our public services, but who will do so, and I look forward to the honourable lady's chuntering from the opposition bench, I look forward to, I'm coming to exactly our progress so far, which I hope she will contrast nicely with the previous 14 years. I will.

01:56:06 - 01:56:35

Speaker 109

I thank the opposition spokesperson for this debate today, but can I also say how grateful I am that the right honourable member is in her place. More than 20 years ago, she and I worked in the Home Office, inheriting another Tory mess on asylum, where with a great Home Secretary and a brilliant team, we reduced the backlog, we made appeals much more difficult, and we made this country a much safer place. Will she bring some of that experience that she had more than 20 years ago to this job after the mess that the Tories left us?

01:56:35 - 01:58:03

Speaker 105

I really appreciate the honourable gentleman bringing attention to that. It was a privilege in 2000 and I think it was 2-3 to work for the now Lord David Blunkett to close the Sangatte refugee centre, to put juxtaposed controls on French shores, and to end the situation of people coming through as clandestines on the back of lorries through the bill that we took through at that time as civil servants, and it was a privilege to play that role. And yet again, here we are fixing the legacy of the previous government. The British people, as I said, will not tolerate illegal migrants placing pressure on our public services while efforts to remove them are frustrated. And thanks to the action this Labour government has taken, the picture today is improving.

I'd just like to say as well, it's only a Labour government, as I said, that will fix the broken system, restore control and bring back fairness. But we will do so, Madam Deputy Speaker, without performative cruelty, without the deliberate fomenting of grievance, and without destroying our international reputation. And thanks to this action the Labour government is taking, this picture today is improving, with crossings down, removals up, and the system's now finally on a more stable footing. Over the last two years, this government has acted to restore fairness and control to our asylum system. Firstly, by taking the fight to the criminal gangs and bearing down on illegal crossings.

01:58:03 - 01:58:21

Speaker 110

One of the first steps the then Home Secretary took following the general election was to establish Border Security Command. The command has had a significant impact, especially in its efforts alongside a strengthened National Crime Agency to ramp up law enforcement action on organised immigration crime. I'll give way to the honourable gentleman.

01:58:21 - 01:58:53

Speaker 107

Does she reflect on what the National Crime Agency have said about the need for a deterrent, and what assessment has she made of how effective the Australian approach of third country processing had in bringing their crossings down?

I appreciate the honourable gentleman raising the point of deterrent, it's extremely important. But as I said, the Rwanda deterrent was not effective. It's thousands, millions of pounds, a handful of volunteers. It's been disproven, it's clearly not going to have any impact. I'm going to come on to the deterrent that is actually working in my speech.

01:58:53 - 01:59:47

Speaker 105

The Border Command has had a significant impact, as I said, alongside its efforts with the National Crime Agency to ramp up law enforcement action on organised immigration crime. We've also given our agencies counter-terror style powers via the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act. In the last financial year, organised immigration crime was disrupted on over 3,700 occasions, up by 46% over the same period. This includes organised immigration crime arrests, which were up 74% as we took down the criminals behind this vile trade.

...testing dangerously overcrowded small boats across the channel. That's a deterrent. That's working. We are also denying gangs the equipment and infrastructure they rely upon. In May, an operation involving the National Crime Agency and German, French and other international partners seized more than 30 boats, over 20 engines, 360 pumps and more than 9,000 life jackets.

Since entering office, we've seized over a total of 1,100 boats and engines. And in part... I will give way.

01:59:47 - 02:00:11

Speaker 111

I thank the Minister for giving way and for setting out the arguments as she is. I'm just wondering if in her speech she is actually going to come to Piddington and the impact on the residents there. Because we have people in the gallery today and this is about the impact on women and girls there. I would be interested to know how many of the government's ministers have actually been to Piddington and spoken to the residents there directly themselves.

02:00:11 - 02:00:42

Speaker 107

I appreciate the honourable lady and, yes, of course I will come to Piddington. That is the content and the subject and the title of this debate. But I think it's really important to understand the people that we are talking about having to house, how we are having to house them and the problem that the issues that we're dealing with. And I'm proud of the issue the the steps that we have taken to reduce that number so that we can hopefully reduce the numbers of people dependent on asylum accommodation as we go forward. In partnership with French law enforcement, we've now stopped more than 50,000 attempted channel crossings.

02:00:42 - 02:02:26

Speaker 105

As a result, small boat arrivals are down around 40% on last year. Asylum claims are down by 20%. Real action, real results. Madam Deputy Speaker, the task of responding to large-scale movements of people is one that we share with many governments across the globe. This is without question one of the defining challenges of our age.

And to meet it, we must work with source, transit and destination countries alike. And that is why this government has made it a priority to strengthen our cooperation with a range of international partners, striking new agreements and strengthening existing partnerships. Just last month, the Home Secretary signed an agreement with her Belgian counterpart to intensify UK-Belgium cooperation and tighten the net around criminal gangs behind small boat crossings. And we are taking our partnership with France further following the new deal signed in April. French boots on the ground have already increased by 24% and a further 50 specialist officers will now be deployed on high-risk red days when conditions indicate crossings are likely, doubling the size of the current unit.

So firstly, by disrupting the movement of goods and infrastructure, tackling the gangs across borders and working with our international partners, we are reducing the flow of people heading towards our borders. And secondly, we are, as the honourable gentleman opposite flagged, we are addressing the pull factors that fuel illegal migration and we are enforcing the laws of this land. Madam Deputy Speaker, to live in this country is a privilege that comes with responsibilities. When people abuse our hospitality, staying for longer than they are entitled to or committing criminal offences in our communities, the public rightly expect every effort to be made to remove them from the British soil. That is why the total failure to remove illegal migrants and foreign offenders in the years before the general election was so damaging and it's why this government is putting right the wrongs of the past.

02:02:26 - 02:02:28

Speaker 112

We have restarted... I will.

02:02:28 - 02:03:00

John Hayes

She's right, of course, that international cooperation matters in terms of dealing with these things, particularly channel crossings. But the point that was made earlier in the debate was that where countries refuse to take back their nationals who've committed crime here, we should take further action, should we not? And part of that might be cutting aid, part of that might be dealing with visas as has been suggested. There's all kinds of other levers that can be used by government to tell those countries you've got to take them back because they're not our responsibility, we're not going to pay for them anymore.

02:03:00 - 02:03:23

Speaker 107

I think we're in danger of having a rare moment of cross-party consensus and agreement on this because it's something the government is already taking many steps to. We are looking at visa enforcements and we have already had a number of successes in that front and we'll continue to use that because where where we do see countries refusing to take people back, we do have those levers within our power and we are using those and so I can continue... Of course, yes.

02:03:23 - 02:03:54

Andrew Murrison

Would she like to look at the way the previous government dealt with Albanian immigrant migrants, illegal migrants to this country, which was hugely successful? Yet this government doesn't appear to have learnt any lessons from that and it persists with allowing illegal migrants to this country to remain here for indefinite periods of time without any realistic prospect of being returned and no pressure, no meaningful pressure on governments, particularly Pakistan, to take people back.

02:03:54 - 02:04:25

Speaker 107

I'm afraid that one moment of consensus has already broken down because I do disagree with the government. I'm afraid, you know, we are undertaking a range of consultation and engagement and measures with those partners. The Albania agreement was an important one, but the Home Secretary is making a number of arrangements, and we look forward to announcing, I hope the honorable members in this place will be patient with us, but look forward to giving more announcements in the weeks and months ahead. I'm going to move on, thank you. Forgive me.

02:04:25 - 02:07:35

Speaker 105

Yeah, so we've driven up removals to the highest level in a decade, and I think that's an important point to stop and reflect. Removals at the highest point in a decade because of the progress that we are making with 80,000 individuals returned since the general election, including immigration offenders, people in the country illegally, and foreign criminals. But we know too the ability just to melt into the illegal economy here lures people here too often. So we've raised illegal working enforcement to record levels. And thirdly, as we rebuild our shattered asylum system, we are lightening the burden on local communities.

The government committed to end the use of asylum hotels within this parliament, and we will do so. Two years in, we've already emptied one in three, reducing the hotel population by 50% in the last year and by 71% since the peak under the previous government. And we've cut asylum costs from hotels by 1 billion pounds. That's a billion pounds that we can spend on the other priorities of the British people, and I think that should be recognized. But going further, Madam Deputy Speaker, from the chaos we inherited two years ago, we have made significant progress, but we know there is more to be done to restore fairness to our asylum system.

Fairness for genuine refugees who deserve our sanctuary and wish to contribute to our society. And fairness for British citizens, our constituents, who shoulder the current burden in their taxes and in their communities. And that is why we continue to work relentlessly at home and abroad to prevent people coming here illegally in the first place, to dismantle the criminal networks that facilitate dangerous and unnecessary crossings, to remove those who break our laws and have no right to be here, and to ensure the country maintains its proud tradition of helping the world's most vulnerable people where it can, but in a secure and orderly way through safe, through new safe and legal routes. And this is why we've introduced a new immigration and asylum bill. This bill will cut the asylum backlog by making decisions faster and fairer.

It will close loopholes so that those with no right to be here can be rapidly removed, and it will ask those who have benefited from public support to contribute to their costs where they were able. And I'd like to thank all the committee members who are currently scrutinizing the bill as it makes its way through this place. I turn now, as the honorable lady has implored, to the issues of MOD Bicester. For too long the way in which we house asylum seekers has not been fair. Billions of pounds have been spent putting them up in hotels while communities have seen these hotels, often at the center of their towns or cities, become a symbol of a broken asylum system.

Areas where housing costs are low and which have already felt left behind were asked to bear more than their fair share. And this has been a source of anger and frustration for many people, and understandably so. Therefore, as well as reducing the backlog, we're working with local authorities on a fairer distribution of asylum seekers across the country. That means ending the use of costly hotels and instead moving asylum seekers into more appropriate accommodation. I'm going to make some progress because I'm afraid I've detained the chamber a little too long.

02:07:30 - 02:07:48

Speaker 107

As part of that planning process, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government provided members of the public and local organizations an opportunity to give their views, ensuring we can fully understand the impact on the local community. And I also want to pay tribute to the campaign in Piddington. It's been an incredibly imaginative and very forceful democratic campaign, and I recognize and respect the campaign that they have run. There are many facets to this process, a lot of different considerations to take into account. But let me be clear, public safety is and always will be right at the forefront of our thinking.

That includes former military sites which are basic, safe, and self-contained by their nature. As I've said, this approach has already saved the taxpayer a billion pounds, but of course we do recognize the concerns of certain communities. While the Home Office has submitted a planning application to use the MOD Bicester site for asylum accommodation, no final decision has been made.

02:08:03 - 02:12:13

Speaker 105

If this site is taken forward, there would be a specialist security on site 24/7, supported by CCTV. Everyone must sign in and out. And we would, of course, work closely with police, council, and other local organizations to address concerns. But it's important to note that this is not the first proposal of its kind. Similar sites such as Wethersfield have operated for years with no evidence of any significant increase in criminality attributable to the operation of that site.

In fact, in September this year, the Chief Constable of Essex Police confirmed that crime linked to the Wethersfield site is very low and that there is no reason for the public to be concerned about possible criminality in the area associated with this site. So let me emphasize, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I fully understand the desire, and it's an important one, for members across the House to press for what they see as the best outcome for the areas and the people they represent. That's their democratic duty, and it's right that any government is held to account over the decision it makes. At the same time, it's the duty of government to act in a way that reflects the needs of the whole country. The approach we are taking is in the national interest, and it's the fairest way to restore order and control to our asylum system, ending the use of hotels, reducing the numbers in the system by addressing pull factors, and removing those with no right to be here, and opening safe and legal routes underpinned by community sponsorship, so that those with genuine claims can come to this country in an orderly and controlled way.

And finally, let me just also address the reference in the opposition motion to the European Convention on Human Rights. As I've set out, removal of those with no right to be in this country are at the highest level in years, and that's thanks to work this government has done and continues to do. But there is much more to be done. The idea that leaving the convention is the way forward is not borne out by reality. Not only is it unnecessary to restore effective control of the immigration system, it would be counterproductive, given the risk of undermining crucial cooperation with European partners, some of which we're already still dealing with as a consequence of Brexit.

Now let us be clear, the convention delivers for people in this country too. It guarantees their rights to privacy, their rights to a fair trial, their rights to free speech, and permanent privileges that cannot be chopped and changed. And, Madam Deputy Speaker, in an increasingly dangerous and uncertain world in which conflict and cross-border crime present shared challenges, a close relationship with our European allies has never been more important. It is for those reasons we remain committed to the ECHR and those relationships. But of course, commitment does not mean complacency.

This government has worked hard to listen to the concerns of the public with respect to the ECHR and the immigration system. That's why our focus is on reforming the domestic application of Article 6 and restoring the proper balance between individual rights and public interest. The UK is proud of the role we played in drafting the convention. Now it is our responsibility to ensure it is strong and relevant for today's world. That requires honest conversations and continued evolution, not turning our backs when it matters most.

In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have ahead of us what I expect to be a wide-ranging debate. Let me conclude by recounting the central facts about our record. Crossings down, asylum hotel use down, removals up, order and control returning at last. But let us also, the honorable gentleman has chanted for quite a while from there, but I do remember that when he was Home Secretary, his government began the use of many large sites, sorry, when he was in the Home Office, I beg your pardon, I promoted him. Because he began the use of many similar large sites such as Wethersfield.

I'm just reminding the honorable gentleman, Madam Deputy Speaker, that Wethersfield was opened under his watch. But I was concluding, forgive me. Let us also, removals are up.

Let us also remember the why as well as the what. The reason underlying all that we've done, are doing, and will do in this area: fairness. Fairness to those in genuine need of sanctuary from tyranny, conflict, and persecution, and fairness for the British public, who rightly expect their government and not criminal gangs to determine who can come to this country, and who expect asylum seekers to be fairly housed across the country. Fairness is the principle on which our progress to date has been built, and Madam Deputy Speaker, the work continues relentlessly.

02:12:13 - 02:12:30

Speaker 73

Unfortunately, the backbench speeches went on for quite some time, so backbenchers, forgive me, the frontbench speeches went on for quite some time, so backbenchers will be on a six-minute speaking limit to begin with. And I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Max Wilkinson, also to respect the amount of time that we have for this debate. Max Wilkinson.

02:12:30 - 02:12:44

Max Wilkinson

I will indeed respect the amount of time, which is ten minutes for the third party, I understand, Madam Deputy Speaker, so thank you for giving me that time. Of course, it would be inappropriate to house twelve hundred asylum seekers in a military base next to a village of a few hundred people.

02:12:44 - 02:12:49

Speaker 114

It is a guide, not a target that he has to reach, Mr. Wilkinson.

02:12:49 - 02:15:07

Max Wilkinson

Your advice is noted, Madam Deputy Speaker. And of course, it would be inappropriate to house them on a site that has never previously been used for residential accommodation. That goes without saying. So we can back that element of the motion today, even if we don't agree with the wording deployed by the official opposition. I will allow my friend, the honorable member for Bicester and Woodstock, to deal with the specifics of the local matter in his contribution later on.

But what must be disputed today, Madam Deputy Speaker, is the second part of this deeply harmful motion. Brexit has made us all poorer. It has reduced Britain's standing in the world and made it more difficult for this country to run a safe and controlled asylum system. So why on earth are the Conservatives suggesting leaving the ECHR, which would be Brexit 2.0? Not only would this make the UK a pariah state, it would likely result in the end of the Brexit deal that they negotiated.

The Conservatives often tell us that the Brexit settlement must not be reopened, but that is exactly what they are suggesting. Once again, the Conservative Party is arguing that this country should pursue what would basically amount to a no-deal Brexit deal. Except that this time, it is not a fringe argument being contested among factions within the Conservative Party, it's the position of the frontbench and the leader of the opposition, and it's backed by all Conservative MPs. Indeed, their leader has told them they'd be barred from their party unless they adopt it, which is why so many of them have now changed their mind on the issue. The drift of the Conservatives away from the center-right to the hard-right is a dereliction of duty.

It runs counter to many of the traditions in this British country, in British conservatism. But we know why they are doing this. It's because they are terrified of the honorable member for Clacton, so they chase after him. They increasingly make his arguments as they prepare for their grubby deal. We all remember what happened in 2019 when the honorable member for Clacton stood down his candidates in alliance with Boris Johnson.

People up and down this country are more than aware that those two parties would engage in the same sort of stitch-up again without a second thought, no matter how much Tory MPs and their leader plead the opposite in public. And I will give way.

02:15:07 - 02:15:20

John Kieran Mullan

Finally. The spokesperson talked about being a pariah state not being in the ECHR. Does he think Canada, which isn't in the ECHR, isn't able to provide a framework of rights to its citizens?

02:15:20 - 02:17:01

Max Wilkinson

The point is that we are in Europe and we are a European nation and most of our relationships are with the ECHR nations. I gently caution the Conservatives that every time they change position in an effort to catch up with the Reform Party, the honorable member for Clacton will just move further and further to the right. This week that resulted in the horrifying suggestion made by Reform that our military should be told to murder civilians on small boats in the English Channel. Madam Deputy Speaker, the suggestion that leaving the ECHR will help us deal with a broken asylum system is absolute nonsense. And by the way, it's a system that was broken by the Conservatives who now spend so much time brazenly telling us that they alone have the solution.

Leaving the ECHR will not stop a single small boat crossing from France. It won't, as the Conservatives suggest, make it easier to deport people because when you ditch international agreements, other nations are less likely to work with you. What it will do, as I've said, is make this nation an international pariah. It will likely result in the conditions once known in the public debate as a no-deal Brexit, which they told us they were against. And in fact, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Trade and Cooperation Agreement makes continued UK adherence to the ECHR a major part of our current Brexit conditions.

If we were to leave the ECHR, we would also end cooperation with our neighbors on law enforcement and criminal justice. That risks leaving dangerous criminals walking free, unidentified or able to escape overseas and evade prosecution and would seriously jeopardize public safety, including that of women and girls. That is deeply irresponsible and I will give way.

02:17:01 - 02:17:24

Peter Wishart

I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way. And it also has a huge implication for settlements across the United Kingdom. The Conservatives didn't know this, but it's a massive implication for Scottish devolution where all our legislation is predicated on a commitment to be compliant with ECHR regulations. So will he tell the Conservatives exactly what this means in terms of what this will do to our internal arrangements across the UK?

02:17:24 - 02:19:04

Max Wilkinson

I will come onto that point later on with specific reference I hope to Northern Ireland. There is more than that to this debate though, Madam Deputy Speaker. Leaving the ECHR will rob British people of hard-won British rights. Rights for so long championed across political divides in so many notable cases by Conservatives who now argue that we must scrap those rights on the altar of the debate around small boat crossings. Article 2, for example, the right to life, which helped the brave families of Hillsborough victims secure fresh inquests to get to the truth of what happened in that tragedy.

Article 3, which helped victims of John Worboys, the black cab rapist, to get justice and build into British law additional protections for victims. Article 4, which alongside Article 3 helped victims of the Rochdale grooming gangs that the Conservatives and Reform talk about so often to secure damages and better justice from Greater Manchester Police. Article 10, the right to freedom of speech and expression. Something the right tells us that is so important, just for them maybe not so much for everybody else, but not important enough certainly, Madam Deputy Speaker, to retain and protect in law for all of us. This article also guarantees the right for journalists to protect their sources.

And while it is not for me as a one-time rubbish journalist and an hour politician to tell journalists how to do their job, there is so far disappointingly little scrutiny from the fourth estate, particularly in the right-wing media, on the matter of the Reform and Tory proposals on the ECHR. By the way, Madam Deputy Speaker, Article 10 also protects the rights of people to hold their politicians to account in the most direct terms. This is established in law. And I will give way.

02:19:04 - 02:19:34

Markus Campbell-Savours

I thank you for giving way. The... thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The minister spoke fondly before of working for a former Home Secretary who on one occasion after 9/11 disapplied part of the European Convention on Human Rights using Article 15.

Do you recognize sorry, does the does the honorable member recognize that there's a difference perhaps from leaving the European Convention and suspending elements of it whilst we deal with a crisis?

02:19:34 - 02:21:28

Max Wilkinson

I thank him for his intervention and of course the second part of the convention does tackle with those sorts of derogations and it is important that we see the convention in its entirety. And as I was saying earlier on, Madam Deputy Speaker, all of this is before we consider the implications for Northern Ireland, which are well rehearsed in this chamber. When British people up and down this country hear the Conservatives and Reform politicians pledging to erase these rights, we must all ask whether we trust those politicians to give us those rights back when they no longer exist. The answer is of course they will not give us those rights back and do not argue with me about the Wolston report because that is nonsense. And leaving the ECHR will mean we have even less opportunities to work on agreements with the EU, the place small boats set off from to prevent those crossings.

And that goes to the nub of the matter that we are discussing today. If we have learned one thing over the past decade, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's the concept that the UK becoming more successful and prosperous while distancing itself from its closest allies is a total fiction. It was a lie in 2016 and it is a lie today. The only way to move towards an asylum system that works is by working with our European allies. And that means that this government must firstly drop its self-defeating red lines and then apply to join the EU migration and asylum pact.

While the media is excited that the Prime Minister has been more expansive in his wording on relations with Europe, it is important to note that he is pledging to retain all his red lines and he is not promising to remove any of them. He says this even though he knows his red lines are making us poorer and that he knows they scupper our chances of an asylum system that could in future command public trust and look after genuine asylum seekers and create a fair system as this country has always had. And it will cost UK taxpayers more and more money and I will give way.

02:21:28 - 02:21:39

John Kieran Mullan

He's talking about the benefit of a cooperation with the EU and how that might help us. Does he accept that when we're in the Dublin Convention we took more asylum seekers than were sent back?

02:21:39 - 02:22:16

Max Wilkinson

Well the honorable member will know the honorable member will know that this is different to the Dublin agreement and the framework within which signatories to the EU migration asylum pact work is different from the Dublin agreement. So today, Madam Deputy Speaker, we renew our calls for ministers to drop their red lines on Europe and to join the EU asylum pact. And we renew our call for the Conservatives to recognize the reality. The first Brexit they gave us has failed this country so don't pretend that giving us Brexit 2.0 is going to be any better.

02:22:16 - 02:22:22

Speaker 73

Backbenchers are on a speaking limit of six minutes and I call Connor Naismith.

02:22:22 - 02:23:08

Connor James Naismith

Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to begin my speech by saying that I respect the right of honorable members from across this house coming here to give voice to their constituents. I respect the voices and the presence of the women of Piddington in the gallery today in making that presence known to government. That is their democratic right and and I respect that. But the Conservative Party, when in office, designed an asylum accommodation program which took over much loved hotels in some of the most deprived parts of our country, including the Crewe Arms Hotel and the Royal Hotel in the center of Crewe. Local services and community cohesion were put under severe strain.

02:23:08 - 02:26:51

Speaker 118

People were forced to cancel weddings and other events of sentimental value in their lives. Of course it is not only the Tories who are up to their necks in that policy because who designed it?

Who championed it on the airwaves, boasting more and more hotels being brought on stream in deprived towns like mine? Well, of course, it was the honourable member for Newark, now Reform Shadow Chancellor, aided and abetted by former Tory ministers who betrayed our country. Not my words, the words of Zia Yusuf. But in opening this debate, the honourable lady said that this shouldn't be about class. And I think that she's right.

But why were places like Crewe chosen by that side when they were in government? Precisely because they were deprived, precisely because land values were lower in those places. I'm not going to give way because I don't want to take time from other people. I don't think that that approach is fair. And I was delighted when I was informed after much campaigning that the Crewe Arms Hotel would be closing as an asylum hotel.

Now, I want to say I hope to see in the coming months the Royal Hotel also be closed for those purposes. And I urge the minister if she can to say more about when we might see progress in that regard. But I think it's important to say that outcomes like that are only possible if we continue to see the progress that this government is making on small boat crossings coming down, which they are, processing of claims going up as they, you know, in stark contrast to the previous government where they collapsed, and also deporting people who have no right to be here. But also, and crucially in respect to this debate, if accommodation for asylum seekers is spread more fairly across our country using appropriate disused military sites. So the proposition that the Tories put in front of us today seems to be that my constituents have to accept more of the burden of asylum accommodation, but some parts of our country don't.

And that just simply is not fair. So I'm sure I know where my constituents will stand on that question. And I am with them, not with that side of the House. I want to turn briefly before finishing to the question of the European Convention on Human Rights. The ECHR blocks just 3% of total removals from this country.

And it also underpins our relationship with other countries around the world, including the Good Friday Agreement. Indeed, even the Tories' much-beloved Rwanda deal, which has been mentioned in this debate, was contingent upon compliance with international agreements on human rights and refugee law, not because any UK or European court said so, but because the Rwandan government insisted on it, as any other third country we might want to work with would do. In conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, this motion seeks to tell my constituents that they should continue to do more than their fair share in respect to the phenomenon of small boats crossing. And it signifies the official opposition's retreat, frankly, from being a serious national party of government, and I won't be supporting it.

02:26:51 - 02:32:57

Speaker 120

Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. I draw the House's attention to my entry in the register. The reason why I sought to intervene on the member for Crewe and Nantwich is that I agree with the point that he made about the unfairness of asylum dispersal. It's something which is of huge importance to my constituents, two-thirds of whom are in Hillingdon, which has the highest number of asylum seekers per capita of any local authority in the country. And because of Heathrow Airport, has borne for decades the consequences of the asylum dispersal policies.

But I would invite him to call to mind, and the minister too, the name of the member of this House who created the asylum dispersal system, who brought into being a system that placed asylum seekers on the basis of accommodation in the cheapest parts of the country because that made taxpayers' money go further.

And I worked with that Member of Parliament when I was involved in local government. When he introduced it, he was the member for Leeds. Now he's the member for Maidenhead and he's our Prime Minister. And members who seek to criticise that system might wish to reflect that their party has been hearing, as has ours for many years, that this is something where the British people expect us to do better. And nobody has a monopoly on virtue when it comes to dealing with the asylum system, particularly the member who I hope will reflect now that he's Prime Minister on the importance of rebuilding the system that had so many flaws when he first put it into effect many years ago.

Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is hugely important, I know, to you. The relentless campaigning that you've done on behalf of your constituents around Crawley reflects the campaigning many of us have needed to do. And in my case, the lessons that have been learned by my constituents, the consequences of the huge numbers arriving at Heathrow, and then in more recent years as the asylum system has become even more overloaded with new applications, as people are placed on coaches in Dover, in Kent, driven up and housed in that Home Office asylum accommodation placed there by the then Minister who is now the Prime Minister in the close proximity of Heathrow Airport. And more recently adding to that pressure, significant numbers of Chagossians fleeing the consequences of the government's deal where they're currently living in Mauritius and needing to be supported by the local authority. So this is something that really matters to constituents.

And I have to reflect that following the murder of Wayne Broadhurst, who was killed whilst walking his dog in nearby Hillingdon about a year ago by Dawod Shafi, an Afghan refugee, that community has done marvels to come together to show its hospitality and its welcome for people who are genuinely vulnerable. But there is that sense of exasperation that we need to see serious progress on this. And in the spirit of accountability and recognising we're in opposition, I have some questions I'd like to put to the Minister. It is very clear from the points a number of members have made that this is not just about ECHR, it's about the Refugee Convention, it's in particular about the Human Rights Act. I know, I went to visit the court in Strasbourg, that we've only seen one case in the last 16 years concerned with immigration matters go against the British government.

But we have cases day after day after day within our own courts. But the ECHR has no jurisdiction over borders. It covers immigration but not borders. And as we see every day at Heathrow, people arrive as undocumented migrants, they don't have a visa, they don't have whatever is required, and they are turned away. And they're not able to access the process which causes such frustration and leaves people stranded in our system for so many years.

That sovereignty of decision-making at the border is an asset that we have not used sufficiently. And I know our opposition front bench have set out in a borders plan the much broader range of initiatives that we need to take. But I am going to ask the Minister, given the pressure this is causing on my constituents, will the government consider a different approach to sovereignty of simply saying to those who arrive on small boats, we will not let you cross our border. You have no documentation, you will not be allowed to access that system at all, and we will not accept that continued pressure on our courts, on our local authorities, on our health services, the other parts of the system. And at the same time consider ideas, one of which I've certainly advocated in this House before, like an asylum visa, of bringing this into the system of simply saying, if you arrive to work, you arrive to get married, you arrive for family reunion, you have to have a visa to cross our border.

Asylum is the sole exception to that. And we are an island. People who come to our country know in advance that they're going to make that journey. There is ample opportunity for them to seek permission. And I have total sympathy, having been there on the French beaches and seen people and the footage that the French police have, that we need to make sure that we deal with this really robustly.

So, Madam Deputy Speaker, something which I know you and I share, and again I'm going to finish on this point with the government, is that need, given the way that the system operates, to ensure that there is full consultation and there is planning, so that those communities that are playing host to thousands of people who may be stuck in some sort of limbo for a long time, who will acquire through that process rights to housing locally, that we have a much more effective system in place for planning. We need to address this in government with a much more robust approach to borders. But there are things this government could do today that would make the situation for mine and your constituents so much better.

02:32:57 - 02:34:02

Ben Goldsborough

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Today we're debating a support calling for the United Kingdom to leave the European Convention on Human Rights. Now I'm going to do something slightly unusual as a parliamentary speech and look into the detail of the law that we're currently considering in committee stage. Because whilst the opposition is busy demanding we tear up an international agreement, an agreement may I add written by one of our greatest wartime Prime Ministers, Winston Churchill, this house is already considering substantive reforms to how human rights law is applied in immigration cases. The Immigration and Asylum Bill is currently being scrutinized in committee.

That is where we should be having serious discussions about how the system works, what needs to change, and how we make sure the law serves the public interest. And clauses 17, 18, 19, and 20 are central to that work. They're not cosmetic changes. They're not empty promises. They are detailed legislative provisions designed to change how courts and tribunals consider human rights claims in an immigration case.

Now, oh, I'll happily give way.

02:34:02 - 02:34:12

John Kieran Mullan

Well, it's going on in relation to Article 8. What's his view on how Article 3 has changed and morphed from a protection against torture to an access to particular forms of healthcare? Does he think that's reasonable?

02:34:12 - 02:40:07

Ben Goldsborough

I thank the honorable gentleman. And as we're going through the Bill Committee, which I'm a proud member of the Bill Committee at the moment, we're looking at things such as the ouster clauses which are included in there. We're giving the detail that is needed for the lords, the law lords and everyone else involved in this process to actually integrate and concern what needs to be done. As I say, so these are not cosmetic changes that we're looking at. Clause 17 addresses bogus human rights claims.

It creates a route for a person based in the UK to appeal a decision refusing entry clearance to an overseas family member where the decision engages their right to family life under Article 8. That is a specific change to the operation of the appeal system with clear rules about how such claims are considered. Clause 18 goes further by establishing a clearer statutory definition of family life for the purposes of Article 8 in immigration cases. It provides that family life will normally be limited to core cohabiting families, partners and, in relevant circumstances, children and parents living together. Where someone seeks to establish family life beyond those core relationships, the legislation sets out the circumstances and evidence that courts should only consider.

For relationships between adults, that includes whether there are additional elements of dependency beyond normal emotional ties between them. It also makes clear that the courts must first determine whether Article 8 is engaged before going to consider the public interest.

That is an important distinction. The existence of a human right does not automatically determine the outcome of an immigration appeal. The court must consider the circumstances and apply the relevant legal test. Clause 19 strengthens the public interest consideration that courts and tribunals must take into account. It reinforces the importance of financial independence and being able to support and house yourself and your family without relying on state support.

It also introduces further considerations relating to criminal convictions, cooperation, and immigration processes and good character. It clarifies the weight that should be normally given to a private and family life established by people who are in the UK unlawfully, have obtained permission through deception, or are in serious breach of the conditions of their immigration status. And it strengthens the considerations that apply when decisions could affect a child, including whether removal would have a very significant and long-lasting adverse effect upon them. These are important changes to a framework within which immigration decisions are made. Clause 20 then goes and addresses cases involving foreign criminals and others liable to deportation.

It strengthens the statutory framework for considering deportation, making clear that the public interest in deporting those liable to deportation must be given significant weight, particularly where the offending is serious. It also sets out an exceptional circumstances in which a deportation may be disproportionate, including the impact on qualifying partners and children and cases involving very compelling circumstances. These precisions matter because a public rightly expects a system that takes criminal offending seriously, enforces immigration rules, and makes decisions that reflect the interests of our country. So I ask the Conservatives again, if you believe the law needs to change, why are you not engaging seriously with the changes already before Parliament? If you think these, if the honorable benches opposite think these clauses don't go far enough, explain why, put forward amendments, test the legislation, make a case for using evidence and legal arguments, because that's what legal parliamentary scrutiny is for.

But instead we have a motion calling for the full withdrawal from the convention altogether, as though leaving an international agreement would somehow make every difficult question disappear. Brexit, anyone? It would not. Leaving the ECHR would not by itself clear the asylum backlog. It would not automatically speed up decisions.

It would not make every removal straightforward, and it would not erase the consequences of years of Conservative mismanagement. The Conservatives had 14 years in government to get a grip on immigration and the asylum system. They had 14 years to improve decision-making, tackling backlogs, and ensure that public money was spent effectively. Yet they left behind a system beset by delays, mounting costs, and a reliance on asylum hotels. Now they want to present themselves as the people with the answers.

It truly is extraordinary. They created the conditions of many of the problems that are still dealing with in this government, and now they want to distract from that record with another dramatic announcement. Our constituents deserve far better than political theater. They deserve an asylum system that makes decisions promptly, removes people who have no right to remain, tackles criminality, and treats people fairly. They deserve effective enforcement and value for taxpayers' money.

That requires practical solutions, competent administration, and legislation that works. It requires government to get on with the job rather than pretending that one grand gesture can solve everything. And a practical example is the Brook Hotel, just outside of my constituency in Barnet. Opened under the previous Conservative government, closed under a Labour government. That is what effective management of the asylum system does when you are serious instead of doing large grand gestures.

The Convention is not beyond reform. There is so much we are doing and so much more to be done, but leaving the Convention altogether is a much wider step than reforming how Article 8 is applied. We have heard already the impact that this will have on the Northern Ireland Peace Agreement and therefore we cannot just singly pull ourselves out of the ECHR. I'm sad to say the Conservative Party that we all knew when growing up has now no longer staying with us and we must take the action we're doing in government.

02:40:07 - 02:42:16

John Kieran Mullan

I welcome the opportunity to take part in this debate today because I think the concerns and worries of the women in Pinnington are concerns of women up and down the country who share their same worries about the sorts of people that are being placed alongside them. And you and I, Madam Deputy Speaker, know better than many others because of the camp in Scampton exactly what those concerns are, where in Scampton, in Madam Deputy Speaker's constituency, the government have placed more than 500 young men and are pledging to keep them there all the way till 2030. And Madam Deputy Speaker's had to do her best in the face of a Green, Lib Dem, Labour council that's totally failed in its responsibilities to support those residents. And the scale of contrast for Pinnington is even greater where there are just 350 existing residents. And at the heart of this debate is whether women have a legitimate, reasonable concern to be worried about the people that are being placed in their communities.

And I'm not afraid to say that I do think the culture of the people very often placed in these constituencies is inferior to ours when it comes to the question of women's rights and attitudes to women. Because let's be clear, more than 72% of the people crossing in small boats are men and the vast majority of them are aged between 18 and 39. And they come predominantly from countries like Eritrea, Sudan, Somalia, Afghanistan and Iraq. And what do the people of those countries, what do the men primarily in those countries think about women and women's rights? This isn't speculation, this isn't stereotyping, this is the evidence of social surveys and reports of the parties.

In Syria, more than 70% of the women report that they are severely restricted in their ability to leave their homes. In Afghanistan, more than 90% of the population think that spousal physical abuse is justified. In Iraq, more than 46% of currently married women are exposed to at least one form of spousal violence and 8 in 10 women have suffered some form of sexual harassment. In Pakistan, the UN estimates that between 70 and 90% of Pakistani women experience some form of domestic violence in their lifetime. In Eritrea, the embedded misogyny is so deep that over half of women in Eritrea aged 15 to 49 think that it's entirely justified to beat their wife.

02:42:16 - 02:42:41

Layla Moran

Giving way. I mean, frankly, misogyny exists in many cultures and I would point out it does in ours too and that's well recognized. Did it ever occur to him that perhaps some of those people are leaving those countries because they also do not agree with those values and that they would rather come to a country that does better respect the rights of women, notwithstanding the issues that we have too? And is he suggesting that every man in those countries holds those views?

02:42:41 - 02:44:12

John Kieran Mullan

I wish we had a system in which we could test the member's proposition because at the minute we have absolutely no idea what the attitudes and values of the people coming from that country are. And you're quite correct to say we have issues of misogyny in this country, but the equivalent figures to the ones that I've just read to you in our country are significantly lower. And that is the point. These cultures are worse than ours on the very many issues that we care about in relation to women and girls. So on the one hand we have a government that's pledging action on women and girls and driving improvements in that area as we have done in our society for many decades, and then pretending that these countries who have done none of that work, their citizens are exactly the same, will come over and treat our women exactly the same.

That flies in the face, I'm afraid, of common sense and as I said, the clear statistical evidence about rates of crime and social attitudes of these people. I'm not afraid to say our culture when it comes to women and girls has a lot to do, a lot to do, but it's significantly better than the culture towards women and girls in countries like Eritrea, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan and a whole range of countries. So I think it's perfectly reasonable for women who are being asked to live alongside huge numbers of people coming unvetted from those countries to be concerned and have worries and we should not be afraid to call that out. And it's nothing to do with racism. We have a culture of football hooliganism in this country.

Predominantly white people engage in football hooliganism in this country. I'm happy to say that, doesn't make me racist towards white people and it doesn't make me racist towards other cultures when I point out their issues and their problems which they have and we should not be afraid to, to call out. And so the question... Oh.

02:44:12 - 02:44:26

Max Wilkinson

I, I thank him for giving way. He mentioned I think one of the countries having a rate of 80% of women saying that they've been sexually harassed in public. What is the rate of women in the UK who report being sexually harassed in public?

02:44:26 - 02:48:03

John Kieran Mullan

Around one in four. So yeah, significantly more. So 80% in the country I referenced and the equivalent figure in this country is one in four. Much, much too high. I would want that figure to be zero, but it makes the exact point that he, I think he didn't want to draw out, that these countries are worse than we are and we should not be importing unvetted large quantities of young men from those cultures without a proper way of dealing with that, and we don't have a way of dealing with that.

And actually the government has inadvertently admitted that by having to tell these people not to rape women. They have to actively tell these people and that's because they know the things that I've said today about the difference in attitudes towards women in very many of these countries. And so the question comes, what do we do about it? And I'm absolutely clear that it should be up to us to decide who comes from what countries and on what basis. We should decide asylum policy, not the people smugglers or the, the routes from which people come.

And we were absolutely clear, I, we should have been quicker in bringing in our own deterrent policy and, and we've admitted that, but we're committed to doing it now and we have a plan to doing it now and that's what actually counts. The only country that successfully deal, dealt with this issue was Australia. They brought more than a 90% decrease in the number of people entering illegally across the sea and they did that by saying if you come here illegally under that method, you don't get to stay, end of story, and that worked and we should do exactly the same thing. The government likes to talk about the failure of the Rwanda plan, the four people sent by volunteers. They know those people went voluntarily.

It's clearly not a deterrent if you go voluntarily and we were never allowed to use it actually as a deterrent to deport people whether they wanted to or not. And the government can do everything it wants to reform and tweak the, the, the operation of human rights laws in this country and the two ways in which that approach is fundamentally flawed. It doesn't matter if you're able to successfully reject a claim if you're not able to deport someone back to the country that they came from. It's completely futile. Unless the member opposite thinks that we're going to be deporting people en masse to Afghanistan or to some other third world war-torn country, then clearly whatever we might want to do around the validity of their claim is worthless if we can't send them to another country or back to the country that they came from.

And secondly, we talked about the, the nature of the claims and how we might tweak them. The ECHR is a precedent-setting court. It's a precedent-setting court. If the ECHR makes a ruling and sets a precedent, ultimately they will hold sway. And I asked him to comment on Article 3 which he failed to do.

That's just one example of how the ECHR has become totally distorted. Article 3 was originally envisioned to prevent people from being deported to a country where they might face torture. That was what the aim of that article was. It's now used to say that if you come to our country, you commit horrendous crimes like rape, but you've got a psychiatric illness, if the country in which we seek to deport you to doesn't have adequate healthcare provision for you, that would be torture to send you back there and you're not allowed under Article 3. Who can reasonably argue that that was envisioned by all the people the member opposite referenced creating this set of rights that at the time were appropriate and applied appropriately, really thinks that those people envisioned 50 years later that that would mean we couldn't deport a rapist because he wouldn't get adequate healthcare in the country in which he'd be deporting him to?

It's totally distorted from its original purpose. And the scaremongering about whether or not we can operate a safe and decent framework of rights in this country without the use of the ECHR is quite clearly scaremongering. Canada manage it, New Zealand manage it, Australia manage it. They all manage to have a framework of rights and international agreements, including Canada that is seeking to seek a closer relationship with the EU, which is not part of the ECHR. I'm happy to give way.

02:48:03 - 02:48:24

Ben Goldsborough

Thank you very much the honourable gentleman for giving way. I just want to point out then that what is the solution that he will come up with that is stated by the Republic of Ireland government, by governments around the world, that by pulling out the ECHR, we are fundamentally undermining the Good Friday Agreement, which means that we cannot operate a safe country and our borders.

02:48:24 - 02:48:52

John Kieran Mullan

I encourage him to read Lord Wolfson's report that makes that clear that absolutely can engage in international agreements. And again, to make the point valid, he's having to suggest that no other countries in the world manage to enter into complex legal arrangements without both being part of the ECHR. Of course they do. They'll be subject to renegotiation because this country is absolutely right to respond to what our people want us to do, which is to protect our borders and put them first, not the sorts of people we're putting up in taxpayers' expense in Scunthorpe.

02:48:52 - 02:50:44

Christopher Murray

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's good that we're having this debate in the House of Commons today because this is a public issue the public care about profoundly and where they want to see substantive action to address their concerns. In order to understand how to do that, we have to understand how we got here. Now I don't propose to relitigate the disastrous asylum system this government inherited, with huge numbers of asylum seekers being housed in hotels across the country. This was terrible for local communities, where hotels were opened in town centres with no support, often without even telling the police or local authorities.

It was actually terrible for genuine asylum seekers themselves, and it was terrible for the taxpayer. The only people this worked for was private companies who extracted massive profits. The Prime Minister has talked about the scandal of outsourcing and privatisation in modern Britain, the most glaring example of it is the asylum accommodation sector. The public are right, we cannot tolerate this and we must fix it. So it's good to see the government doing the hard yards of doing that, and I would argue there are three components we have to tackle as a country.

Firstly, you have to drive down the number of asylum seekers coming into the system. That's why it's good to see small boats down 40%. That's why it's good to see the French have prevented 48,000 crossings. More obviously must be done. You need to prevent them coming in and secondly, you have to increase the number of asylum seekers coming out the system.

So that's a big increase in decisions and an increase in removals, over 80,000 increase in removals. Again, more to be done, but good to see the hard yards starting. But third, yes I will give way.

02:50:44 - 02:51:14

Frederick Thomas

I thank the honourable member for giving way. He speaks about how it's important in this agenda to deter people from coming to this country illegally. Does he share my concern at the Reform Party's notion, their chairman's put forward, that the Royal Marines Commandos could be encouraged to use quote lethal force against unarmed civilians, something which as a Royal Marines Commando I can tell you is completely unacceptable across the military. There are real concerns about this in Plymouth and across the wider military, and does the honourable member share those concerns?

02:51:14 - 02:54:21

Christopher Murray

I thank the honourable gentleman for that point. He's absolutely right to raise it. Whenever I have spoken to law enforcement or military about this issue, that's exactly the issue that they raise.

And moreover, making gestures that we know will never be realistic is what the traffickers want us to do because it encourages them to encourage people to come here. The third component of what we must tackle is dealing with people while they are in the asylum system. That means we've got to drive down the costs, deliver the economies of scale required, mitigate the impact that infuriate community and increase safeguarding for communities. You do need to do that if you want to close the hotels. You cannot close the hotels without dealing with people in the system.

Let me make a defense of large sites in the asylum system. In 15 years working on immigration and two years on the Home Affairs Committee, I must have visited more asylum accommodation than anyone else in the House of Commons. Large sites have an important role to play, particularly in alleviating the issues that local communities find challenging. Firstly, on cost, they are much cheaper than hotels. Secondly, on efficiency, can I get to the end of this point and then I will give way.

Secondly, on efficiency, having people in one place where you can bring in Home Office officials, where you can bring in the relevant people can speed them through the process and get them out of it faster. Third, community engagement. Yes, they are free to come and go, but short of imprisoning someone, this is as much as you can contain them in British society. Let me make some points and I will then take interventions. But charities and groups can come to large sites.

They are far away from town centers, unlike hotels and HMOs. And the authorities, by providing things like transport, can basically can practically organize when people will be in one place, stopping the issues of hotels of people hanging around centers late at night. And finally, on safeguarding. One of the issues with hotels is that we didn't inform police. But when you have larger sites, you can have trained professionals who can spot the depression, the isolation, the re-traumatization, or the worrying behaviors, the dynamics in the groups, the opportunities to observe, supervise and intervene.

This is engaging with police and social services is how you tackle these risks. Let me tell you what persuaded me about this. I was skeptical of large sites until I went to Wethersfield, which had gone well, opened under the last government, opened I think by the right honorable lady over there. And they told me the work they can do to mitigate against safeguarding is far more effective in a large site than it is in a small site. I'll take the intervention here and then over here.

02:54:21 - 02:54:51

Calum Miller

Grateful to the honorable member for giving way. He led his arguments in favor of large sites on cost grounds. I'm sure he's aware that the Home Affairs Select Committee looked at this matter and identified that bed by bed, large sites were more expensive than hotels. And would he also acknowledge that in the site we are talking about today, the evidence is that because it's never had residential accommodation, the costs in capital terms of setting up that accommodation and building a village will greatly outstrip the cost of any other alternative provision.

02:54:51 - 02:55:30

Christopher Murray

I don't accept the honorable gentleman's argument there at all. The like large sites, my argument to the minister would be large sites vary. Now, Wethersfield didn't work until it was until they reformed it and then it did. North Hay didn't. But I'm going to do something unusual and say something positive about the Scottish government for a second.

When the Scottish government open large, I know the honorable member's had a heart attack over there. When the Scottish government open large sites for effectively asylum seekers from Ukraine, two cruise ships, they were very cost effective compared to the MS Stockholm. The argument is whether the Home Office can orchestrate it. The argument is whether the Home Office can do it in public procurement, not the principle. Yes.

02:55:30 - 02:55:41

John Kieran Mullan

The gentleman talked about how a system can effectively manage the risk of these sites. Does he not accept that women in Penistone and other people just don't want the risk there at all? They don't want it managed. They don't want it there at all.

02:55:40 - 02:57:51

Christopher Murray

That's a perfectly reasonable response to risk. However, the role of government is to mitigate risk. The role of government is for public policy to intervene, deploy public resources and capacities the best way to mitigate risk. Now, that's normal across policing and all kind of Home Office security. But in this case, it's quite right.

I absolutely understand why people say that.

The honourable gentleman, his proposal, his government, placed asylum seekers in hotels without telling anybody in the local community, without social work, without police, without anybody knowing. The local women had no clue. Most of the cases quoted by the shadow minister came from that system. Now you can say to these women in Piddington, well leave the ECHR, that'll solve everything. That to me is not realistic and is not treating them with respect.

Far better to say we will try and solve this problem, mitigate the risk and do the stuff required to actually deal with it. I'm just losing time here, I'm afraid. So let me just close by saying I should have expected on this opposition day debate what we heard from Tory and Reform. These are the people who broke the system and let it spiral and are somehow arguing leaving the ECHR can happen tomorrow and will solve an issue in Piddington and Bicester. It's for the birds.

But I am particularly disappointed in the Liberal Democrats and their amendment. They say they oppose asylum hotels and they want a better public debate on immigration. But whether it's in Cameron Barracks, whether it's in Crowborough, now it's Bicester, they oppose every large site. They say we should welcome asylum seekers and have a humane system, but it's not in my backyard the minute there's one near them. Are they really saying that it is for the working class communities of Britain to tolerate asylum seekers in hotels and in HMOs, but not in their constituencies in secure, large, well-resourced public large sites?

I think that's wrong. The public are fed up of posturing, point-scoring and pointless gesturing and NIMBYism on this. They want the issue solved. They want it gripped. And if the government can get large sites to solve the problem, I think they could be a big part of solving this country's asylum accommodation challenges.

02:57:51 - 02:57:58

Speaker 73

Okay, we've had so many interventions and I'm going to have to drop backbenchers now down to five minutes. Suella Braverman.

02:57:58 - 03:02:46

Suella Braverman

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm grateful for the opportunity to speak in this debate. I was honoured to visit Piddington a few weeks ago with my honourable friend, the member for Runcorn and Helsby, representing my party, Reform, one of the first female MPs to respond to the women of Piddington when they wrote to all female MPs in this House. Very interesting that there are no female Labour backbenchers sitting in on this debate. That's how seriously this party in government takes this issue. And when I met the women of Piddington, I was staggered because they are scared.

They are angry and they feel like no one in government is listening to them. And these people there are not far-right thugs. The women that I met, and indeed the men, many of them are elderly pensioners. Some of them are widowed and living alone. Many of them are parents speaking on behalf of their children.

And this small rural village is fighting against the British state right now to protect itself. It is a scandal that no one in this government is willing to listen to the women and girls of Piddington. And unfortunately, it is not contained to Piddington. It is also the people of Watlooville. Last year, I led a campaign with 10,000 local people to fight the Home Office and the Labour-Lib Dem plans to house asylum seekers there.

We were successful on that occasion. Now, I'm supporting people in Gosport, in Portsmouth, who are taking to the streets in peaceful protest against illegal migrants arriving on their shores. So this is extending across our country and it is out of control. Getting better?

The government says it's getting better. The boats are getting bigger. The people coming are coming in higher numbers and British people are more scared than ever. And they're right to be scared because the facts are that Afghan and Eritrean migrant men are 22 times more likely to be convicted of sex crimes than Brits. 40% of sexual assaults in London over the last five years were committed by foreign-born men.

I'm not making that up. That's data. So these are not irrational fears and they're being treated with contempt. The tragedy of all of this is that this is caused by the ECHR. People come here on the boats illegally.

They claim to be victims of persecution. They claim to have family rights here, all gaming human rights laws against us. I saw this as Home Secretary, as Attorney General, and previously as a barrister working in the field. I wrote a paper about it last year, dismissed by the Conservative Party. And of course the truth is, and we've got to be honest about this, we might not even have to be here talking about Piddington or Gosport or Fort Blockhouse or Waterlooville.

This problem could have been fixed. The tragedy is that the last Conservative government utterly refused to do the right thing. And I'll come to that. I was the first Conservative minister who said publicly to fix this crisis we need to leave the ECHR. As Attorney General, as Home Secretary, what, what happened?

The leader of the opposition, she said I was having a nervous breakdown. That party said I had mental health problems. They demonised, isolated and blocked me from doing the right thing. I've asked them to apologise today. They've refused to apologise to the nation for causing this crisis.

And I won't let them off the hook. I've just published a book setting out the painful battles I had with my Conservative Party colleagues to fix this. So I will not take any lectures from anyone in the Conservative Party about their, their promises to leave the ECHR. Don't believe them. What do we need?

What do we need to stop this invasion and fix what is this national security emergency, the emergency that my honourable friend the member for Tipton has been talking about for years? We need to leave the ECHR with credible leadership. We need to suspend our asylum system now, void all of those grants of asylum, deport all of those people who are applying for asylum, deporting 90,000 people. And yes, deploying the Royal Navy into the channel to ensure that we properly secure our borders. This Labour government won't do it.

The last Conservative government didn't do it. This Conservative Party cannot be trusted. Only Reform will stop the invasion and stop these boats.

03:02:46 - 03:02:51

Speaker 123

I think that is a no. Point of order, Jesse Norman.

03:02:51 - 03:03:52

Alexander Jesse Norman

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In his remarks to a question at Prime Minister's Questions, the Prime Minister said, could I start just by recognising with the charges that have been laid against the individual responsible for the murder of Anne Widdecombe. He didn't say the individual accused of her murder, he said the individual responsible for her murder. A man is innocent until proven guilty. The presumption of innocence goes back to Magna Carta.

It applies without exception. But the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom has just publicly spoken as though a man awaiting trial has already been convicted of murder.

It's directly contrary to the rule of law. It is a breach of the presumption of innocence. It is misleading to the House and in any other forum it would be a contempt of court which could be used to suggest a defendant had been prejudged on the merits of a case. The Prime Minister needs to apologize and may I ask your guidance on this Madam Deputy Speaker as to whether the Prime Minister needs to apologize to withdraw the statement and to correct the record immediately.

03:03:52 - 03:04:31

Speaker 73

I thank the honorable member for giving notice of his point of order. I assume because he is so experienced that within protocol he's also mentioned this to the member the Prime Minister that he was going to raise this. Raise assumed. I'll I'll accept that as something he'll be doing incredibly quickly. The content of ministers' speeches and answers are not a matter for the chair but the Treasury front bench will have heard that point of order and I'm sure that they will they will do everything they can to make sure it gets to where it needs to get to and the appropriate action is taken and the honorable the right honorable member can of course take more advice from the clerks if needed.

03:04:31 - 03:04:33

Speaker 125

I'll move on. Dr. Zubir Ahmed.

03:04:33 - 03:07:39

Zubir Ahmed

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I start off by also acknowledging the concerns of the women of Piddington that are viewing this debate today up in the gallery. Those concerns are not limited of course to Piddington. They also include my constituency of Glasgow South West that has historically had the highest number of asylum applications of anywhere in the United Kingdom and it is a matter of record that I've asked the Home Secretary to look at this urgently to see if my city of Glasgow my constituency of Glasgow South West can be afforded some extra breathing space as it contends with its own issues of housing and social social cohesion and I've made similar pleas to the Scottish Government in relation to priority housing rules and local and local connection rules. Madam Madam Deputy Speaker both sides in this debate have acknowledged now that day zero of this issue is not today did not start two years ago it started long ago perhaps 14 14 to 20 years earlier.

And we are not where we would wish to be. But we must be careful about the tenor of the debate that we also engage in on this topic. Because what quickly becomes very legitimate concern about safeguarding about how we tackle asylum how we tackle the backlog then bleeds into issues of multiculturalism as has already been spoken about today ethnonationalism and and other and other matters. And indeed immigration more widely. I can tell you for a fact that after this debate today I'll be having some very uncharitable comments made on my social media because of my background.

And I think therefore it is an important moment to also put on the record that largely this country over the last 100 years has been the most successful at integration and immigration possibly in the history of mankind. I am an example of that. My immigration story began 100 years ago when my grandfather took a boat from Calcutta went to Hong Kong and became a member of the British Hong Kong police force. And then in 1963 when my dad took took a journey by road to come from Pakistan into Glasgow to drive buses and then taxis and he still does you know today in his 80s. We must always remember that once this debate starts to bleed out into other issues that we must stand firm against those that would wish to use it as an instrument for championing deplorable ideas like ethnonationalism that unfortunately have also been espoused at times by members of of this place either you know intentionally or unintentionally.

03:07:28 - 03:07:58

Seamus Logan

And would he agree with me that it's because precisely because of the current Home Office policies that is creating the environment in which paradoxical effects are being felt in my constituency, shortages of labor in fishing, farming, social and healthcare and in hospitality? And this is exactly the point that I think he's trying to make.

But the issue itself does need to be gripped. Because when it it is not gripped it is precisely minority communities that become first and foremost in the firing line for abuse and and attack. I'll take this point.

03:07:49 - 03:08:50

Zubir Ahmed

I'm afraid it wasn't the point I was trying to make, but I will I will take on some of his some of his arguments. What I would say is that in this country in Scotland, we have some of the highest levels of unemployed young people anywhere in the United Kingdom. And we should first and foremost start by addressing them and their issues and getting them into employment before we start opening up a wider debate about immigration and legal migration and and numbers. And can I say to him also, I'm afraid in the city of Glasgow, it is bad enough that the right-wing manipulate immigration and migration issues to march masked men down the streets of my constituencies. But also on the other side, I'm afraid politicians must also take responsibility, including in the Scottish government, that play lip service to social cohesion, that pay lip service to anti-racism rhetoric, but never follow through by funding the infrastructure that fundamentally relies on social cohesion to be a successful endeavor.

03:07:58 - 03:08:00

I thank the honorable member for giving way. He's making an excellent speech and he draws attention to the wider issues that result from this debate.

03:08:50 - 03:10:51

Zubir Ahmed

And back to my point I was trying to make, Madam Deputy Speaker, we must address this issue because we are placing minorities in the firing line if we do not. And therefore, I am so glad that my honorable right honorable friend the Home Secretary is bringing forward precisely a bill that will do that. Because what is missing right now in this debate is trust and confidence. Trust and confidence in the asylum and immigration system and the bill placed before Parliament now currently in its committee stage precisely serves to restore that trust and restore that confidence by making sure we can regulate and produce an independent authority that will fast-track asylum applications, that we can reinterpret components of human rights legislation to make sure they are fit for the present and not the past. And on that, I must note that the ECHR is not some kind of foreign construct as has been tried to be outlined today in this place.

It is a British construct. It is a Churchillian construct. It is the fabric of what it means to be British. It is what made my grandfather and my father serve the British and come to this country. It's because of the ECHR we have freedom of religion.

It is because of the ECHR we have freedom from torture. It is because of the ECHR that we're able to now extricate ourselves from things like corporal punishment. And it is because actually of the ECHR, we're talking about women's safety today and rightly so, that the women who are victims of domestic violence were protected from the benefit system cutting their housing benefit. So what I would ask honorable members on all sides to do today is to remember that when we have this debate, it has consequences for people from many communities up and down the country, legitimately here, some many for generations, who are caught in the net of people that wish to exploit this debate to to question their legitimacy in this country and often people like me to be in this place. And that is something we must always never forget.

03:10:51 - 03:11:00

Speaker 73

I'm afraid we have further time constraints, backbenchers are now on four minutes and Mr. Jopp, I do not wish to hear you speaking from a sedentary position. Greg Smith.

03:11:00 - 03:13:11

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. MOD Bicester site A is but a stone's throw over the Buckinghamshire border into Oxfordshire. And so whilst Piddington have captured the headlines, actually the communities that are concerned by this proposal, that feel threatened by this proposal, many of which sit in my constituency in Mid Buckinghamshire, communities, small villages and hamlets, Boarstall, Oakley, Brill, Ludgershall, Marsh Gibbon, Long Crendon, Twyford, Charndon, Poundon, Worminghall, Honeyburge, many others, all a walking distance from MOD Bicester site A.

And whilst I have absolute confidence that the real answer to this challenge is the Conservatives' borders plan, where those that illegally enter the United Kingdom by small boat should be deported within a week, I want to use the time that I've got today to focus on why the use of MOD Bicester Site A simply doesn't stack up, is the wrong plan, it is the wrong site. And that goes straight to some of the arguments that the Minister actually made about cost and location, none of which actually stack up in reality. This is a site that has to be built entirely from scratch. There is no accommodation there at the moment. This is an entirely modular build on a site where there is no freshwater supply.

There is no ability to take the sewage away by anything other than road. If they want to look at environmental concerns, we hear that some 6,000 litres of diesel a day will have to be burned in order to provide electricity to this site via generators. There is no grid connection to MOD Bicester Site A. It's situated along a very busy fast-moving road. But it's okay, we're told, it's okay that those that are housed there will wear hi-vis jackets as the HGVs zoom past them.

03:13:11 - 03:13:16

Speaker 127

It is just not a site that is credible. I will certainly.

03:13:16 - 03:13:31

Lincoln Jopp

Thanks to my honourable friend for giving way. Diesel is obviously very much in the public mind at the moment. Has he seen any sort of impact statement as to what the daily cost of the Bicester site would be given the increase in diesel prices?

03:13:31 - 03:15:59

Greg Gregory Smith

I'm grateful to my honourable friend for that intervention and indeed we heard the Minister speak, we heard Labour backbenchers speak trying to say that this was going to be cheaper than hotels. Well let me tell my honourable friend and the House what the modelling actually says on the cost of MOD Bicester Site A as an asylum camp. If that site persists for five years, the cost will work out at £235.34 per night. If it goes 10 years, £185.17 per night. The comparator for asylum hotels is £144 a night.

The use of MOD Bicester Site A is intrinsically incredibly more expensive than using the hotels, so this doesn't offer value to the taxpayers that the Government and the Labour Party want us to believe. That is an absolute nonsense that we cannot allow to persist. And of course from a Government, a Government that likes to talk about wanting to follow all the rules all the time etc., they ruled out doing an environmental impact assessment saying it wasn't going to have much of an environmental impact. That's a statutory thing that anyone wanting to build something should go through. Well they can't argue that it's going to have a minimal environmental impact.

There were munitions stores on this site, it's absolutely riddled with asbestos that is going to be released into the local environment. The wonderful campaign groups, not least Wrong Plan Wrong Site, have done an incredible amount of work where they have found rare breeds of bat and newts and the things that I know the Government likes to pooh-pooh this, but in reality the need to actually take attention and do these environmental impact assessments is set down in statute, it is the rules, it is the law we've got. And for the Government to ride roughshod over that is purely unacceptable.

And I urge the government to stop, to pause, to look at the cost, to look at the environmental impact, to look at the unsuitability of this site on practical grounds and withdraw it immediately so that the communities in my constituency, as well as those in our neighbors in Oxfordshire, can breathe once more and live in the peace that they deserve to live in, free from the fear that my honorable friend for Beaconsfield set out in her opening speech, and that we can move on and stop this nonsense.

03:15:59 - 03:16:00

Calum Miller.

03:16:00 - 03:20:17

Calum Miller

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I appreciate very much your efforts to regulate our debate. I might seek your dispensation to speak for slightly longer than the limit you've imposed, given that my constituents are in the gallery and given that the opposition chose to cite a motion mentioning my constituency without any reference to me. Thank you. Madam Deputy Speaker, the government wants to build in my constituency a portacabin village to house male asylum seekers, not in former military accommodation, but on a derelict storage depot at MOD Bicester.

This is totally inappropriate. On that point, I wholly agree with the honorable member for Beaconsfield. From the moment that, without any prior notice, the government published its proposal, I have opposed it. The scheme is wrong for local communities in my constituency, is wrong for asylum seekers, and is wrong for the taxpayer. For three and a half months, I have worked closely with local campaigners to stop the scheme, raising it here with the Prime Minister, the Borders and Asylum Minister, and the Defense Readiness Minister.

We will continue that campaign until the government sees sense. And allow me, Madam Deputy Speaker, to welcome my constituents from Piddington to the gallery today. I hope it will be possible to meet with them after the debate. I further welcome this chance to set out what is wrong with the proposal. For it is not an appropriate site to house 1,256 people.

Back in 2005, when the last Labour government proposed a scheme here, a planning inspector rejected the proposal to house 750 asylum seekers, men, women, and children, on site A. He said it was isolated, unsuitable, and unsafe, and the proposal would create excessive community tensions. All of those things are still true today and apply even more to a larger site exclusively housing male asylum seekers. And I second the comments of my neighbor in Mid Buckinghamshire, who has laid out very clearly the arguments that have been articulated so clearly by the campaigners from, amongst other groups, Wrong Plan, Wrong Site. And I just ask the Minister this: given the legal challenge that has been presented by that group, will the government pause its planning application and commit to conducting a full environmental impact assessment of the site, as required under its own policies, before proceeding?

Madam Deputy Speaker, I know this area very well. Before entering this House, I served as county councillor for the villages of Otmoor. I spent many evenings at Piddington, Arncott, and Ambrosden parish councils, something I'm sure other members will be jealous of. Since this proposal, I've visited Piddington many times, meeting members of the campaign group and knocking on the doors of my constituents, speaking with women and men about their concerns. Local residents are worried that this site would take away stretched local resources, not only water and power, which are scarce, but also health services and policing.

Women and girls in the area have raised concerns with me about their safety. And as someone who has spoken repeatedly in this House against violence against women and girls, I understand why they are fearful today. As a society, we are failing to protect them from predatory men, and when the worst happens, the justice system is not delivering them swift justice. No wonder they lack confidence they will be kept safe. In that context, any proposal to house over 1,200 men in a new site adjacent to small villages would be a cause for fear and concern.

However, let us be clear, the Conservatives and Reform UK are trying to turn this into a race issue. It's not a race issue, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a man issue. Women and girls are at risk from the behavior of men, tragically nine in ten assaults are committed by men they know. I will continue to fight for more police and court resources to keep women and girls safe. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is clear that like the proposal of the motion, I condemn the government's proposal, but I deeply regret that today the Conservatives have sought to link that with their policy on the European Court of Human Rights.

I've spoken with the Police and Crime Commissioner, with Home Office ministers, and with local police leaders about this, and I will continue to seek assurance from ministers that the government will provide sufficient additional police resources.

We could have united on this issue, as I have sought to do at the local level with local Conservative councillors and with my honorable friend, the member for Mid Buckinghamshire. Instead, the Conservatives have sought to divide rather than unite. I will continue to work with all those in my local community to oppose this wrong-sighted proposal and to ensure that the government thinks again.

03:20:17 - 03:23:57

Speaker 111

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The first duty of any government is to keep its citizens safe, and nowhere is that duty more important than across our communities and in the protection of women and girls who have a right to feel safe and a right to expect the government to do everything in its power to protect them. Today's debate is an opportunity to send a clear message that we will not accept policies which put our communities at risk and that we are prepared to take the difficult decisions necessary to restore control of our borders. The grooming gang scandal is a national disgrace. Girls, some as young as eleven, were raped, abused, and trafficked by organized gangs, and when they cried out for help, too often they were ignored, disbelieved, or dismissed.

And those in positions of authority whose first responsibility was to protect them, failed them appallingly. We must never allow that to happen again. That means putting victims first, listening to their experiences, and having the courage to confront uncomfortable truths, however difficult they may be. In July, I raised the case of Shabir Ahmed, the Rochdale grooming gang ringleader, directly with the then Foreign Secretary. She agreed that every possible lever should be explored to secure his deportation.

Yet three months later, he remains in the UK. When the law protects the man who raped a child rather than the child he raped, something is profoundly wrong, and this House must have the power and the determination to put that right. Our rights in this country long predate the ECHR, and under our Conservative borders plan, we will leave it. Illegal arrivals removed within a week, every foreign criminal deported, and an end to the cycle of last-minute claims that let dangerous men run down the clock. But what is this government's answer?

To house over 1,200 single men at MOD Bicester next to Piddington, a village of just 350 people with limited local infrastructure and services. Madam Deputy Speaker, the way these plans have been imposed on a small rural community has left many others feeling they could be next. Villages like Audlem in my constituency of Chester South and Eddisbury, where residents have raised serious concerns about the future of the old grammar school site. Yet when I asked ministers whether any site in Audlem had been approved for asylum accommodation, the government failed to give me a straight answer. And when I asked about the suitability of rural locations, I was told that the Home Office does not even record asylum accommodation according to whether it is in a rural area.

Many of the concerns raised in Piddington are equally relevant to Audlem. Small rural villages simply do not have the infrastructure to accommodate what would realistically be an influx of young men. My constituents deserve clarity.

They deserve straight answers about the future of the site and above all, they deserve an immigration system that tackles illegal arrivals in the first place. That means a credible deterrent and that is delivered by leaving the ECHR. Madam Deputy Speaker, that is why I wholeheartedly support this motion because whether it is Piddington, Audlem or communities across the country, people deserve to feel safe in their homes and in their communities. And above all, we owe it to every woman and girl in this country to do everything in our power to protect them.

03:23:57 - 03:24:02

Speaker 129

Sir Edward Leigh, Father of the House.

03:24:02 - 03:27:57

Edward Leigh

Our hearts go out to the people of Piddington and we've heard a very moving speech from the constituency MP and of course we agree with everything that he says on that. Can I share with you, Madam Speaker, Deputy Speaker, my own experience of the unsuitability of large military bases to house migrants. We had worked for years after failed projects for former RAF bases in Lincolnshire, for years to get massive regeneration into RAF Scampton. The whole scheme was ready to go to raise 300, perhaps 300 million pounds of investment. And then I received an invitation from the then Home Secretary, my personal friend, the right honourable member for Fareham and Waterlooville.

She summoned me into her office, her grand office, and she said to me that all this regeneration is all going to vanish and I'm going to put 2,000 migrants in there right next to hundreds, hundreds of people who had bought their home right next to the site, 100 yards away. Now I fought this battle for two years and she was followed by the right honourable member for Newark, who was even more, his enemies might say, was even more ruthless, even more determined to put the migrants in. But I have to say, and I'm now looking at the Minister, I have to thank this government, I have to thank my friend, my personal friend, the right honourable member for Lincoln, because Scampton is only five miles from Lincoln and they realized, following the NAO report, after 64 million pounds wasted on trying to convert listed buildings, 100 buildings, the runway and 800 acres, it was rubbish, condemned by the NAO, complete waste of money and we've seen them off. So I thank the Minister for the latest deal that we've announced to try and get a world-class defence company in there. So these large military bases simply don't work and they're no deterrent.

You know, if you're in some hellhole like Eritrea, are you really worried about whether you might end up in Piddington or Scampton or Bicester? Of course not. As a deterrent, it simply doesn't work. It would be better frankly to find some isolated state, place, to surround it, to make it secure and detain people there in portacabins. The trouble is we can't do it because the Refugee Human Rights Act, the European Convention of Human Rights, the Refugee Convention, that's the problem we've always faced.

We cannot detain these people. There is no deterrent unless we follow the policy of the opposition to detain people as they land and deport them within a week. So all that we've heard about the ECHR, and I'm on the Council of Europe, it simply stops us dealing with this problem. The only solution is offshoring. Everybody knows that.

Nothing else works. Now, can I end on a positive note because although we're right to hold the government to account, they're never going to listen to us on the ECHR, but I'm on the Council of Europe as I've said. Why don't we have a return agreement to countries which are in the Council of Europe but are far distant away, Armenia or Moldova or Azerbaijan or Serbia? I mean, I just give this free advice to the government. No court would ever stop it.

But something must be done. This is destroying our political system. It is driving people mad when we can't control our own borders. The government must act. And if they don't act, then they will reap the whirlwind.

03:27:57 - 03:30:00

Peter Wishart

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have to say, when I first saw this motion, I had to look twice, as I was absolutely certain that this must be a reform motion, but then I remembered that they don't still get opposition days, and it is indeed in the name of the Conservative party. And for all this "I will never work with Nigel Farage" etcetera, etcetera, we hear from the leadership of the Conservatives, they are now literally indistinguishable from Reform, with their antipathy towards asylum seekers, to immigration, to human rights, now defining these new reformatives. The thing is that the Conservatives are responsible for the crisis that we're currently confronting in the asylum system, having created huge outstanding backlogs from their time in office that require the use of facilities such as Bicester. Now, I know very little about the situation in Bicester, so I'm not going to really comment on the particularities of this.

But what I will say is the government is absolutely right when it's dealing with asylum seekers to try to make sure that there's equity across the whole of the United Kingdom, and it's not going to be towns and cities like mine that are going to be left to accommodate the masses of asylum seekers that we currently have. So it's right that every constituency must play its part to try and clear up the mess that was bequeathed by the Conservatives. The last place where this "not in my backyard" principle should apply is when we're dealing with real people and people's lives. Now, there is blanket opposition to accommodation for asylum seekers right across the United Kingdom, and that has been created by the culture and climate and the language that is used just now when we come to describe asylum seekers. And some of the language, I have to say, that I heard from the Conservative front bench and some of the contributions from Conservative members is simply appalling, demonizing, othering, making trying to trying to depict whole communities as deviant, as of sexual deviancy and the rest.

03:30:00 - 03:30:07

Speaker 132

I just find absolutely unacceptable. No wonder communities are really upset about the prospect of people coming into the constituencies.

03:30:07 - 03:30:32

Speaker 133

I thank the honorable member for giving way. Obviously, he'll not be surprised to hear that I agree with everything he's saying. But I noted that the right honorable member for Gainsborough, the Father of the House, chose not to use the word "illegal". And so would my right honorable friend agree with me that it's anathema to see the word "illegal" in this motion because there are there is no such thing as an illegal migrant?

03:30:32 - 03:31:00

Speaker 134

No one, no one, and there's the chuntering of the Conservative front bench as usual. No one in this world is illegal. What we have is situations right across the world where people are fleeing for their lives, fleeing oppression, fleeing... The honorable gentleman says "France". Where does he think these people come from?

They come from some of the worst war-torn countries. I challenge him to go there and live for six months just to see how he would get on. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm not giving way anymore. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm not giving way. Sit down.

03:31:00 - 03:33:20

Peter Wishart

Order. Sit down. Sir John. Sir Julian Lewis. No, no.

Is everybody calm or does anybody need to leave the chamber? Pete Wishart. And thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Look at them. The appalling behavior from the Conservatives on issues, sensitive issues such as this, and the language that they've used today is an absolute and utter disgrace.

No wonder communities up and down this country are concerned about their very safety because of the language that these Conservatives use. But the issue that most concerns me about this is their proposal to leave the ECHR, because this would send a deeply troubling message to communities across the country and to our partners internationally.

It would deprive our citizens of valued and essential human rights and diminish our very sense of ourselves. The new reformed Tory hostility towards human rights is well established, their disdain for international cooperation and consensus now a defining characteristic. And yet, Madam Deputy Speaker, the fact is that they would drag us out of the ECHR tells us something reassuring about the ECHR. When the likes of the new right Tories and Reform want to do it, that shows that the ECHR is doing its job properly, defending us from the likes of them. And I think that tells us why we actually need it.

And let's remind the company we would keep if we were to leave the ECHR: Russia and Belarus, bastions of human rights and freedoms. And let's just remind us what this document is. The ECHR was born from the ashes of the Second World War, when the horrors of the Holocaust still cast a shadow over the world. The UK was at the heart of its creation. It was the giant of a Prime Minister, a Conservative Prime Minister, Winston Churchill, who was the designer of this and ensured that we got that in place.

Leaving the ECHR, as the Conservatives suggest, would do absolutely nothing to stop the boats coming to the UK, as it would do absolutely nothing to end irregular immigration. But what it would do is put a huge statement to the rest of the world that Britain is closing down, it does not value international cooperation, that it's become more insular. And I loathe the idea of a world that is going to be run under this type of culture, this type of language, and a conservative reform coalition that would...

03:33:20 - 03:33:21

Yes, thank you.

03:33:21 - 03:33:51

Helen Maguire

I thank you on that point for the honorable member for giving way. Does the honorable member agree with me that it's despicable rhetoric like that this that makes a friend of mine recently told me about her mother, who was British born but is a person of color and now she feels unsafe on the streets of Britain? I wonder if he believes that rhetoric like this contributes to the lack of feeling of safety of certain individuals.

03:33:51 - 03:35:01

Peter Wishart

Absolutely, whole communities across the United Kingdom are now very concerned about their safety, very anxious about the type of culture that is evolving and developing in every constituency community, and they're right to be concerned because I hear it in my constituency myself. But on the small boats, let's get this absolutely right. The truth is that there are more National Lottery millionaires than there each year than there ever are foreign nationals who won human rights appeals through the ECHR in the United Kingdom. And what this would also do in Scotland is deprive us of one of our basic fundamentals in the Scottish Parliament, and that is every part of our legislation has to be ECHR compliant. So it's not just Northern Ireland as part of the devolution process that will be compromised by this, it will be my Parliament and our democracy in Scotland that the Conservatives care not a jot about and would pursue our leaving of the ECHR without giving it a second thought.

So for all of these reasons, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a thoroughly bad motion, an abhorrent motion, and I despair of the language and I hope when the Conservatives sum up today, we'll hear a little bit more about decency and let's have a little bit more about common values that we could all buy into, but I doubt it very much.

03:35:01 - 03:35:04

Speaker 137

Order. Siobhan Baillie.

03:35:04 - 03:35:21

Siobhan Baillie

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We all understand that the protection of women and girls is a matter that transcends party politics. This debate today is not about point scoring but is an important conversation that we need to have. The current direction of this government's immigration policy is harming our women and girls.

03:35:21 - 03:36:12

Speaker 135

In communities across the country, those who are most vulnerable are put at risk by hordes of single men who do not understand basic human rights, including the right not to be raped. Why are we allowing individuals into our country who do not have the capacity to function as part of British society? Small boat crossings surged by 50% between 2024 general election and the end of 2025, reaching nearly 65,000 people. I know that honourable members on the opposite benches will have their fair share of statistics to deploy in this debate, but we must focus on the situation right now and how to address it. The impact of this vast influx is felt right now by teenage girls who are too scared to walk to school alone and by young women filled with fear when travelling home after an evening with friends.

03:36:12 - 03:37:31

Siobhan Baillie

This fear is felt by our mothers, our sisters, our daughters, our friends. I myself have felt that fear. Promises from the government benches to smash the gangs are hollow and empty. The Prime Minister is enjoying his newfound rhetoric of hope, but I encourage him and his ministerial colleagues to visit communities like Piddington and Crowborough and see the reality that confronts the women and girls there. Let us not make the mistake of thinking that we do not have a choice in this matter, Madam Deputy Speaker.

In the first instance, can I suggest to my colleagues opposite that a rural village of 350 people is not a suitable site for over 1,000 single men. But beyond that, there are policy decisions that we have the power in this House to make that will protect our women and girls. Our Conservative Borders Plan details just some of the measures we could take to tackle illegal immigration, including leaving the ECHR and repealing the Human Rights Act, removing it from all immigration relation matters. The ECHR, as it stands, is a barrier to common sense. Why, Madam Deputy Speaker, are members on the opposite side of the House so resolutely committed to remaining part of a treaty that prevents the deportation of foreign rapists and paedophiles?

03:37:31 - 03:38:13

Speaker 135

Lord Wolfson's review confirmed that the UK governance is significantly constrained by ECHR membership. As long as we remain bound by these foreign court regulations, we cannot carry out the core duties that we owe to the British people. Any notion that we would lose fundamental rights upon leaving the ECHR is simply false. Advanced democracies like Canada, Australia, New Zealand function effectively without the constraints of this convention, and it is naive to believe that the birthplace of parliamentary democracy cannot do the very same. Madam Deputy Speaker, I agree that our country has been built on legal immigration, but we must be crystal clear.

03:38:13 - 03:38:55

Siobhan Baillie

The doctors, nurses, builders, engineers, and teachers who come here to contribute to our country and strengthen our economy are not the same as single men sitting in asylum camps living off taxpayer money. My constituency of Leicester East is a testament to that distinction. It is one of the most diverse constituencies in the country and also one of the most entrepreneurial, with over 20,000 SMEs driving Leicester's economy. Making that distinction is crucial. Uncontrolled illegal immigration undermines everyone who seeks to come here legally, those who want to integrate, who spend thousands of pounds on visa applications, and who work tirelessly to build a better life for their families.

03:38:55 - 03:39:20

Speaker 135

That is who we as a Conservative Party stand up for. In closing, I encourage any members of this House to talk to women who now fear leaving their homes. Listen to the fathers, the brothers, and their husbands. Hear how little hope they feel under this government's plans. Go to Crowborough and see how the Home Office's occupation of the training camp there is bringing hope to residents in Wealden.

When you force over a thousand...

03:39:20 - 03:41:53

Sarah Bool

Order. Sarah Bool.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, whilst the MOD Bicester site is outside of my constituency, it is actually approximately 11 kilometres from my nearest settlement. And I wrote to the Home Secretary on the 1st of September on behalf of female constituents not only in South Northamptonshire but also on behalf of Piddington women who I'm so pleased to see in the gallery here today.

And they contacted me to express their concerns for safety. And I must reiterate that the guidance understanding behavior and expectations in the UK reinforced their concerns. Now I have a migrant hotel in my constituency. We know the issues that come around having migrants in the area. A big question is what will they do with their time?

Now rural crime already is an issue and this could be exploited and they could be by existing criminal gangs. Why, I'd like to ask the minister, have stab vests been issued to security staff working at the base in the last month when they've never been needed before? The site was deemed unsuitable for an open accommodation center by a planning inspectorate and local authority over 20 years ago and little has changed since. In the early 2000s, the High Court ruled that no more than 750 people could potentially live there, but now it's 1,250. The Home Office argue that not using hotels is to ensure better use of public money, but these large accommodation sites would cost 46 million pounds more according to the National Audit Office.

Now all of this could be avoidable if only the government would take robust approach to our asylum system. And that means reviewing our position with the ECHR. As Lord Wolfson's excellent report highlights, the ECHR does place significant legal constraints on the government's ability to address issues like immigration. And other countries across Europe are also reconsidering their relationship with the ECHR in light of immigration issues. It's countries like Belgium, Italy, Denmark, Estonia, Latvia, Poland, the Czech Republic, Lithuania and Austria.

We are not alone. I will make progress because we are very close to the end of the debate. But the European, all of those have looked at reforming the actual ECHR. Well, the European Court of Human Rights has expanded the interpretation of human rights. For as long as the European Court of Human Rights regards the ECHR as a living instrument such that its decisions and in consequence those of domestic courts are not constrained by the actual wording of the ECHR, we will have problems.

03:41:53 - 03:41:55

Speaker 141

Thank you.

03:41:55 - 03:41:57

Speaker 142

Sir John Hayes.

03:41:57 - 03:44:23

John Hayes

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The growth in population in this country has been fueled by mass migration. When I was a boy, the population was regularly cited as being about 57, 58 million. The ONS now estimate that by 2035 it's likely to be 72.5 million. Leaving aside the pressure that places on public services, the economic damage it does, the truth is that the character of our country is being changed beyond recognition and overwhelmingly the British people resist and resent that change which has happened without their consent.

Now, ministers know that there's a cultural problem. In August, the Home Office published a book for newly arrived asylum seekers which said, and I quote, "If you have sex with someone who does not want to, this is called rape. Rape is a serious crime." The fact that government believe that those arriving were so primitive that they didn't know that is extraordinary, but the truth suggests that they were right. Numerous cases, just this week we saw the sentencing of Hossein Mumadi, a 36-year-old Iranian woman who came to Britain, convicted of 33, raped a 33-year-old woman and has been sentenced to 11 years in jail.

Karin Al-Dansarat came to Britain in a small boat after fleeing Egypt where he'd been convicted of a murder. In the UK he's been convicted of gang raping a woman on a Brighton beach. Then there's the Turkish asylum seeker convicted in Stafford Crown Court in January this year for raping an 18-year-old girl. Case after case of those coming here without our values, with no loyalty to Britain, with no intention of making a positive contribution to this country and committing serious and violent crimes very often against women and girls.

We're now in the position where one in eight prisoners is a foreign national offender, totaling over 10,700 foreign nationals in our prisons. The largest contingent come from Albania, whose countrymen make up 10% of foreign nationals in jail. The number of foreign nationals in UK prisons for drug offences is made up of 20% of all offenders. The number of foreign sex offenders in prisons went up 10% last year. Analysis from the Ministry of Justice last year confirmed that foreigners are convicted of up to 23% of all sex crimes.

And we hear from the Liberal Democrats that this is not about race, but it's certainly about culture. I happily give way.

03:44:23 - 03:45:08

Julian Lewis

The right honorable friend will have noticed that some people from the third party benches seem to think that there is no such thing as a bogus or illegal asylum seeker. But recently, there have been a number of attempted terrorist attempts, attacks, including one against a Manchester synagogue, which was fortunately foiled, but which was planned and to be carried out by people who came in illegally on small boats. Are we to wait for an atrocity to occur before the appropriate remedial measures will be taken?

03:45:08 - 03:47:37

John Hayes

Well, the right honorable gentleman, former chairman of the ISC, on which I'm proud to serve, will know that this is a national security issue as well as an issue of profound concern to our constituents, and the government should see it through that prism as well as through a number of others. The truth is there is a cultural mismatch between these people's understanding of what's right and good and just and decent and that of the British people. Their way of life is simply not compatible very often with ours. Foreign nationals are 71% more likely than Britons to be responsible for a sex crime conviction. The rates based on convictions per 10,000 population for Afghans were 77 convictions at the top, with a rate of 59% per 10,000, 22.3 times greater than that of Britain.

This is a cultural crisis. We're admitting people to this country who don't share our values and don't really, frankly, want to share our values. And so the government really needs to get real and do so quickly. There is a huge gulf between the assumptions of the liberal establishment who believe in cultural equivalence. There's no such thing as Western civilization.

We've heard from the Liberal front bench with an extraordinary paucity of understanding that human rights began in 1947. They've never heard of the English common law, it would seem. They don't know about habeas corpus. They don't understand that free and fair elections existed long before the ECHR. The lawful entitlements we call rights didn't begin with that document.

Well, I won't give way because I'm coming to the end of my speech. Nor will you give way, nor will you give way to a member that's just come into the chamber, Sir John Hayes. I thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So this is an urgent matter because it's an urgent matter because what the failure of successive governments to do to deal with it has created is a belief amongst the population that the government doesn't care and that Parliament doesn't understand. And until we address that, we will undermine the very character of our democracy.

03:47:37 - 03:47:38

Speaker 143

Order, order.

03:47:38 - 03:47:40

Speaker 146

Shadow Home Secretary.

03:47:40 - 03:49:32

Brian Christopher Ian Mynott Philp

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. No case more powerfully illustrates the gravity of this matter than that of Rhiannon White. I met Rhiannon's mum Siobhan a few weeks ago and heard her story. Rhiannon was 27 years old. She worked in an asylum hotel.

And one night after leaving work, she was followed by a Sudanese illegal immigrant who entered the country by small boat in late July 2024. And this man murdered Rhiannon by stabbing her 23 times. He left her for dead on a station platform and was later filmed laughing about it. This terrible crime is by no means isolated. Many other illegal small boat migrants living in asylum accommodation have committed terrible offences against women and girls.

A 31-year-old woman on a Brighton beach gang-raped by two Iranians and an Egyptian who entered the country by small boat. A 12-year-old girl, 12 years old, abducted and raped by an Afghan illegal immigrant. A woman abducted and raped by an Egyptian asylum seeker, illegal immigrant again, in Hyde Park, barely a mile from where we now stand. It turns out that man also had criminal convictions for Islamist terrorism in Egypt. An Ethiopian illegal immigrant who sexually assaulted a young teenage girl in Epping.

Two Iranian nationals, again illegally entering the country, illegal immigrants entering by small boat, have now been charged with preparing terror attacks against Manchester's Jewish community.

03:49:32 - 03:49:46

Speaker 73

Order, order. We don't talk about cases where people have just been charged and not been sentenced because it's sub judice, so I ask the Shadow Home Secretary to be incredibly careful with the words he wishes to use in his closing speech. Chris Philp.

03:49:46 - 03:50:08

Brian Christopher Ian Mynott Philp

Of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, the fact they've been charged is a matter of public record. I won't say anything beyond the fact they've been charged. Another case where an illegal small boat migrant who entered the country is fighting extradition back to Germany where he is wanted for rape. He is also linked to ISIS. Case after case after case where...

Order.

03:50:08 - 03:50:19

Speaker 73

Shadow Home Secretary, if somebody is fighting a case then it's still a live case. Can I ask the the Shadow Home Secretary just to revisit the words before he speaks them out loud in the chamber. Chris Philp.

03:50:19 - 03:56:23

Brian Christopher Ian Mynott Philp

I'm repeating what has been publicly reported today, but I will of course take account of Madam Deputy Speaker's advice. In case after case, we have seen women and girls attacked by illegal small boat migrants. The data, I'm afraid, is very clear. The two of the three most predominant nationalities are Afghan and Eritrean. And the data which my right honourable friend the member for South Holland and the Deepings referred to, data produced using freedom of information requests to the Ministry of Justice, show that Afghan males are 22 times more likely, 22 times more likely to commit sex assaults than average, and Eritrean men a similar amount.

And that of course is why the government felt it necessary just a few weeks ago to produce a leaflet asking these illegal migrants to kindly not rape women and girls. The government themselves know it's a problem and that is why they produced these leaflets. And that is why mothers and grandmothers in Piddington are so concerned about the safety of their daughters and granddaughters, why parents in Crowborough are so concerned as well, because these threats are real.

These crimes have happened. These convictions have taken place. The data is clear. It is true when my honourable friend says these men come from cultures that are alien to ours where women are not respected. This is an immigration crisis.

It is a border security crisis. It is a public safety crisis and it's a crisis for women and girls as well. The government is allowing 92% of small boat migrants to stay. Only 8% have been deported. Yes, there are slightly fewer hotels, but only because they are moving the illegal immigrants into flats instead.

They are up 12% since the election. So to save places like Piddington and like Crowborough and Linton-on-Ouse and Wethersfield and towns and villages up and down the country, the solution is not, as the Prime Minister said, to distribute illegal immigrants equitably across the country. It is instead to deport people who illegally enter our country and to do so within a week of their arrival. Then we'd need no accommodation, no accommodation anywhere, whether in flats or in hotels or in military sites, because we wouldn't be accommodating illegal immigrants at all. And secondly, if we did that, it would deter the crossings, because if people leaving France, by the way a safe country, nobody needs to flee war in France, if they knew they would be rapidly deported either to their country of origin or a safe third country like Rwanda, the crossings would soon stop.

When Australia did something similar in September of 2013, within three months their illegal maritime crossings, which ran at similar levels to ours, stopped within about three months. So there is a solution if only the government would grasp it. But to do that, Madam Deputy Speaker, it is necessary to leave the ECHR. Now what started in the 1950s, or in 1950, as a very well-intentioned piece of human rights legislation has subsequently been stretched, been distorted beyond all recognition. Clauses that were originally intended to prevent the horrors of the Second World War are now expansively interpreted to mean that rapists can't be sent back to their country of origin because of their supposed family rights.

A Zimbabwe rapist, a Zimbabwean rapist, not sent back to Zimbabwe because he might face hostility in Zimbabwe under Article 3, which is unqualified, that can't be amended in domestic legislation. Or an Iraqi drug dealer, not sent back to Iraq because apparently he'd become too westernised. What started off as a sensible set of protections has been stretched beyond recognition, stretched beyond anything common sense would recognise, and is preventing the successive governments, the last government as much as this government, from deporting people who can't be here. That is why there are 21,000 serious foreign criminals still in this country. It is why the Home Office knows of 412,000 people with no right to be here who can't be deported.

Now leaving the ECHR is a necessary but not sufficient step. You need to do it in order to control our borders, but on its own it's not enough. You would have to also amend domestic legislation, for example to ban asylum claims by illegal immigrants, to abolish the immigration tribunal and immigration legal aid, restrict judicial review on immigration matters to all but the narrowest grounds, end modern slavery claims being used as a basis for deportation. All of these measures would need to be taken as well as leaving the ECHR, but without leaving the ECHR none of those measures are possible. And I would say to the ministers, I'm going to just finish, I'd say to the ministers, I know they're trying hard in their bill, but they are essentially tinkering at the edges.

It was tried by the last government and to be honest it didn't work. It didn't work because these legal structures prevent robust action to defend our borders. And I will just, Madam Deputy Speaker, say before concluding, that were we to leave the ECHR, which I fervently believe we must do to save places like Piddington, protect our women and girls and protect our borders, we would not be returning to the dark ages. Rights existed in this country long before the 1998 Human Rights Act, long before the 1950 convention was entered into.

Common law jurisdictions like Australia, New Zealand and Canada have perfectly respectable human rights records without needing to rely on the ECHR. Indeed, this Parliament can legislate to protect human rights in whatever manner it sees fit. But what is true is that we cannot protect our borders, we can't deport illegal immigrants and foreign criminals while we are inside the ECHR. And that is why if we are serious about border protection, if we are serious about protecting Piddington and Crowborough and places like it up and down this country, we need to take that necessary step, leave the ECHR, reform our domestic laws and restore border control to this country.

03:56:23 - 03:56:27

Speaker 147

Call the Minister, Joe White.

03:56:27 - 03:58:48

Joe White

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This has been an important debate on one of the defining challenges of our time. Our constituents rightly expect immigration to be fair, controlled and free from abuse. For too long, it has been none of these. When this government entered office, we inherited an asylum system in chaos, with criminal gangs deciding who could come to this country and hundreds of hotels being used to house vast numbers of illegal immigrants at immense cost to the public.

Unfair to the genuine refugees left waiting over a year to have their case heard, and unfair to the British people being asked to shoulder an ever-increasing burden in their taxes and their communities. From day one, we began the hard work of fixing our asylum system and restoring order and control to our borders. The statistics show that we are making progress. Asylum decision-making is up and returns are up, while small boat arrivals are down. And we remain on track to end the use of asylum hotels this Parliament.

And we know there is a long way to go. And that is why we continue to work relentlessly at home and abroad to tackle the people smugglers who value profit above human life and to remove those who have no right to be here. At the same time, we are ensuring asylum seekers are housed in the fairest, most cost-effective way. We've seen the stress and strains of hotel usage. We are ending that scandal.

And we are moving asylum seekers to more appropriate accommodation. Former military bases which are secure and contained provide one of the best solutions. They allow us to bring in the services required on site, minimizing the impact on the local community with in-house services, 24/7 security and CCTV. Of course, we will always listen to concerns and work with the community. But existing sites including Wethersfield have operated for years with no evidence of any significant increase in criminality attributed to the operation of the site.

03:58:48 - 04:03:36

Speaker 149

On the ECHR, we do not need to leave to restore order to our immigration system. Winston Churchill proposed the establishment of the European Commission of Human Rights at the 1948 Congress of Europe and the UK was the first country to ratify it in 1951. It came from Churchill's experience of dealing with the Nazis before and during the Second World War. 13 million were murdered, unprotected, and ECHR rights define what we mean by never again. How they are interpreted and how they are applied are of course important, and it's why the Home Secretary committed last year to oversee reforms to bring it into the modern age.

What it does include is freedom of assembly, freedom to a fair trial, the prohibition of torture, freedom of thought, conscience and religion, the right to life, including the right not to be murdered in your own state. That's what the Nazis did and this is where this comes from and this is why these principles remain essential. And which, and which two countries have chosen to stay out? Russia and Belarus. And perhaps we should ask the opposition leaders in Russia and Belarus, falsely imprisoned, tortured and murdered by the state.

And this is what we are talking about. This is what we would throw away, protections against show trials and political persecution. We will not hand over our freedoms to the whims of tyrants and dictators. Instead, no I'm not going to sit, no I'm not going to sit down. Instead we stand with Churchill and we will build a fair controlled immigration system that's free from abuse.

We will focus on concerns that people are rightly concerned about, but the issue is not the existence of the convention, it is how it has been applied over time. We do not fix a fault by walking away. You sort it by restoring the right balance and making sure that the system works as intended. And that is why all 46 members adopted the Reykjavik political declaration in May, creating solid foundations for reform. The government is now translating this into practical change and we will see reform of the domestic application of Article 8, restoring the proper balance between individual rights and protecting the public interest.

This is a binary choice, reform ECHR and have greater control over our borders, or leave and lose our ability to return illegal migrants or foreign criminals. I choose the powers that ECHR gives us which protects all our individual rights and freedoms. It also provides us with responsibilities and where people have been subjected to torture or the risk of torture, we have rightly provided them with a place of security and safety. I now come to some of the further points made by honorable members. I respond appropriately to members.

In responding to the member for Crewe and Nantwich, wanted to know a timeline on closing down the hotels in places like Falkirk, which were approved by the Tories when they were in power. The ambition is to end, end hotel use by the end of this parliamentary term. We're now going down from 400, which was when we came into power, to less than 160 and I will celebrate with him when we are in the position to close down the remaining hotel in his constituency. In response to the member for Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner, his, Ruislip, sorry, Ruislip, sorry, apologize for that. The introduction of ETAs at the borders and ports and the use of visa penalties has given us much greater control over our borders, disincentivizing the crossing through the introduction of new strong control methods including border command and by cracking down on illegal working and introducing safe and legal routes for genuine asylum cases from some of the most dangerous countries in the world has meant we're giving us greater power over our borders.

04:03:36 - 04:03:42

Speaker 150

The changing of how ECHR is applied is critical to bringing back order and control.

04:03:42 - 04:05:47

Speaker 149

On women's safety, this is a concern that this government shares. And I do acknowledge the concerns of the women who are here today. No women should live a smaller life and this government is committed to halve violence against women and girls within this decade. And this is a cross-government response to the issue and we will work as hard as we can to achieve this. The Home Office have met with Cherwell District Council Chief Executive and its leader to discuss cohesion challenges linked to the people are concerned about on the site and they are listening to the concerns raised by women.

And this is an imperative for the Home Office. The proposal contained in the planning application includes on-site 24/7 security, CCTV and this is what we have introduced on other large sites such as Wethersfield which has operated in this way for years. As the member for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh identified, safeguarding for the local community is an imperative. It is important and this drives the management of the site. On the planning process and concerns were raised by the honorable member earlier, this already includes an environmental impact assessment.

You just walked in. And there were no objections by Natural England. And the final costs of this site will only be known following the outcome of the procurement process. Concerns were raised regarding Article 3. The government accepts that there will be a generally exceptional medical healthcare cases where Article 3 prevents removal.

04:05:47 - 04:05:53

Speaker 151

However, these must be exceptional. Article 3 was never intended to guarantee...

04:05:53 - 04:06:03

John Kieran Mullan

Does she think that in any circumstances a rapist should fail to be deported from this country because of access to healthcare? A rapist.

04:06:03 - 04:08:00

Speaker 149

So cases are inherently fact-sensitive and must always be assessed on their individual circumstances. It's not for me to say in this house. Absolutely. And following the recent political declaration on Article 3, we are working to secure stronger first instance decisions, better prepared litigation and more consistent application of Article 3. Further operational policy or legislative reform will remain available where persistent barriers are identified.

In response to the member for Fareham and Waterlooville who was in her place earlier and no longer here, oh there she is, she was in the Home Office when she approved large sites including the one that's proposed for RAF Scampton. And this because she knows that in-house services, 24/7 CCTV and security provides a greater level of protection for communities. And in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, this country is proud to offer sanctuary to those fleeing conflict or persecution. It is the right thing to do and it is a fundamental part of who we are. But that generosity depends on the support of the British public.

They must believe that our asylum is fair and for that it must be capped and controlled with decisions and appeals which are fast and fair and those with no right to be here promptly removed. That is the imperative behind every decision this government takes.

We are restoring order to our borders. We are making our asylum system faster and fairer. And in doing so, we will ensure that this country can continue providing protection to those in need, today and for generations to come.

04:08:00 - 04:08:40

Speaker 153

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Division. Clear the lobby.

04:08:40 - 04:08:55

Speaker 152

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The tellers for the ayes are David Simmons and Alicia Kearns. The tellers for the noes, Michael Wheeler and Claire Hughes.

04:16:32 - 04:19:19

Speaker 154

On va y aller.

Compte de deux.

04:19:19 - 04:19:20

On va y aller.

04:19:20 - 04:19:20

On va y aller.

04:21:00 - 04:21:26

Speaker 158

Order, order. The ayes to the right 113. The noes to the left 309.

04:21:26 - 04:21:45

Speaker 157

The ayes to the right for 113, the noes to the left 309, so the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock.

04:21:45 - 04:23:12

Speaker 152

Order, order. I will now announce the result of today's deferred divisions. On the draft ACAS code of practice on time off for trade union duties and activities, the ayes were 328, the noes were 114, so the ayes have it, the ayes have it. On the draft code of practice on the right of trade unions to access workplaces, the ayes were 326, the noes were 115, so the ayes have it. On the draft trade unions right to access workplaces regulations 2024, the ayes were 326, the noes were 115, so the ayes have it.

On the carbon border adjustment mechanism calculation of CBAM rate and determination of carbon price relief regulations 2024, the ayes were 319, the noes were 115, so the ayes have it. Before we move on to the second opposition day motion on inheritance tax, can I remind all members planning to speak in this debate that it is a courtesy of the house that you return for wind-ups. We now come to the opposition day motion on inheritance tax. I inform the house that the speaker has not selected the amendment. I call the opposition spokesman to move the motion.

04:23:12 - 04:23:14

Speaker 156

Andrew Griffith.

04:23:14 - 04:25:17

Andrew Griffith

Thank you. I beg to move that this house calls on the government to cut public spending in order to abolish inheritance tax on family homes, farms and businesses.

Madam Deputy Speaker, there is a divide the size of Manchester's Etihad Arena in British politics today. Between those who want to tax family farms and those who don't. Between those who want to tax family businesses and those who don't. And now between those who want to tax family homes and those who don't. Not content with the highest tax burden in peacetime history, in their first budget, the government chose to impose inheritance tax on farmers and family businesses.

Well, the Conservatives would scrap the family farm tax and the family business tax, and we would abolish inheritance tax on the family home. Because we believe that people who work hard and save hard should keep the rewards. Rather than seeing them sold and snaffled up to pay a tax band who refuses to make the hard choices and to cut welfare. We'll hear later from my colleague, the Shadow DEFRA Secretary, who has been a stalwart defender of Britain's farmers that this government has attacked. So I'll speak briefly to the family businesses that this government is also attacking.

Many of them are small businesses. People who get up every day, take on the responsibility of hiring, often young people, making payroll, and of creating growth in this country.

04:25:17 - 04:25:53

Jeremy Paul Wright

Extremely grateful to him for giving way. And before he moves away from farms, and I appreciate he's told us that our right honourable friend will be responding on that point. Would he agree that one of the many foolishnesses in the government's approach to attacks on the inheritance of farmland is that our farmers face a challenge in the age of farmers? We need more young people in farming. And if you make it more difficult and more expensive for those young people most likely to go into farming, namely the children of farming families, you will exacerbate that primary problem.

04:25:53 - 04:27:39

Andrew Griffith

Well, the honourable gentleman is exactly right. These are by definition, and the original reason for the exemption in death duties that previous Labour governments respected, was that generational aspect. The fact that a business, a farm doesn't necessarily produce the cash flow necessary to hand over an enormous part of that value when tragically death takes place. And I know that's a point that my right honourable friend will pick up later on. So if I can move on to businesses, which as both members of both sides will know, are far more numerous in fact than the farms who we know are impacted on this.

Businesses in every one of our constituencies, in every one of our high streets and every one of our trading estates. Often they are family businesses that have been in that family for multiple generations. And this is causing extreme jeopardy, even to the point that people are having to take action right now to protect those family interests. Madam Deputy Speaker, Edmund Burke, much beloved on this side of the house, said that society is a partnership between those who are living, those who are dead, and those who are yet to be born. And there couldn't be a better manifestation of that than Britain's family businesses.

Rooted in their local communities, providing jobs down the generations. And yet this government is hell-bent on breaking them up and forcing them to sell the pieces to pay an inheritance tax bill that they should never have to face.

We Conservatives are on the side of family businesses.

04:27:39 - 04:28:05

Wendy Morton

I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman for giving way because across my constituency there's a wealth of small businesses that keep our local economy growing. Does he agree with me that at a time when our businesses need the support which enables them to create employment for the next generation, what we're seeing from the benches opposite, of course where there's no business experience, is a government that's just squeezing and squeezing our businesses out of business.

04:28:05 - 04:29:10

Andrew Griffith

The honorable lady is quite right and I would I would urge every member of this House to spend time with family businesses in their constituency. There are excellent organizations such as Family Business UK who would be delighted to make that introduction. My right honorable friend is absolutely right about the relative dearth of business experience, of private sector experience, of an understanding about how the economy works. But that is capable of remediation, Madam Deputy Speaker, if only ministers and members on the benches opposite were to seek to educate themselves and the benefit to their constituencies and constituents of family businesses. We on this side of the House will not let a spiteful, prejudiced Labour Party destroy those family businesses, which is why we will I would be delighted to give way and for the member to talk about the family business contribution in his own constituency and why therefore he'll be supporting our motion this afternoon.

04:29:10 - 04:29:27

Craig Gareth Snell

There are many wonderful family businesses in Stoke-on-Trent, Madam Deputy Speaker, not least Potclays that makes clay for the pottery industry. But when he talks about this spiteful tax, he knows it was introduced in 1986 under Mrs. Thatcher. Did he think it was a spiteful tax when she introduced it?

04:29:27 - 04:31:12

Andrew Griffith

Well, there's been exemptions for family business far beyond that. This is multi-generational, the origins of this date back to the 1960s. And every Labour government under every Labour Prime Minister has understood the contribution of family businesses, including to those in his constituency. We could of course talk about many of the other headwinds that business take, but I would be deviating, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I know many colleagues want to speak this afternoon, so we won't talk about the higher energy costs or the cost of hiring or the red tape that this government has imposed or the many other national insurance job tax. We won't talk about any of those, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Now, inheritance tax more generally was once a tax paid by the privileged few, the super-rich, a tiny sliver of a minority of taxpayers and estates. Today, today inheritance tax, so these are the independent numbers that the government will understand, today inheritance tax is a tax on ordinary middle-class families in every corner of our country. So by 2030, and I invite the minister to challenge these numbers when he eventually responds, by 2030, one in six families will lead to an inheritance tax bill. Now, at the start of previous decades, that was one in twenty. The scope of this tax has dragged so many more people into its terrible net, and it's only getting worse.

One in five homes last year were sold at a price above the threshold where an inheritance tax liability would arise. I happily give way.

04:31:12 - 04:31:36

Christopher John Vince

I thank the honorable member for giving way because I just promoted him. I wondered whether he thinks inheritance tax is having a greater impact on people being forced to sell their homes than the cost of care, and would he therefore recognize the Prime Minister's right to tackle the national care crisis because that's causing a number of people to sell their homes far more than inheritance taxes.

04:31:36 - 04:36:02

Andrew Griffith

I thank the honorable member for his point.

Very few of us, I think, will not be aware of the challenges of the care sector in our constituency surgeries amongst our constituents. It is actually why I regret the fact that one of the first actions of this government on coming into office was to reject the consensus around the Dilnot review, which would have moved that conversation forward. But we on this house will continue to engage in ideas that the Prime Minister puts forward, none of which, none of which takes away from the iniquity of inheritance tax, which is a double tax, often as a result of earned income, sometimes a triple tax as a result of businesses. And as I said, Madam Deputy Speaker, the scope, the breadth of inheritance tax is dragging more people into its net all the time. There is a fundamental difference between our two sides on this issue, and I'm very keen to hear what our colleagues in the Liberal Democrat Party have to say on this matter today.

But our homes, we on this side of the house believe that our homes are special. They're not just another asset to be taxed by a government that refuses to cut out-of-control welfare. They're where we feel safe with our families, where our young take their first steps, where we spend religious festivals and precious family moments. And that's why so much of the Conservative Party policies that we've announced recently focus precisely on those family homes, making it cheaper to buy a first home for young people by removing gold-plated regulation, saving fifty thousand pounds from the price of an average new-built home, making them cheaper to buy because we are the party that believes in home ownership by abolishing stamp duty on people's primary residences, and making homes cheaper to live in by scrapping their tax on Labour's tax on family homes, the so-called mansion tax that in truth applies in many parts of the country to flats and ordinary suburban homes, in Birmingham, in Bristol, in Nottingham, in Edinburgh, and yes, Madam Deputy Speaker, in Manchester too. That is what it means to prioritize home ownership.

And now we are committed to making it free to pass on your family home to direct descendants. Madam Deputy Speaker, the government should follow our plan: no tax when you buy a home, no tax to live in your home, and no tax to pass on your home to the family. If the Chancellor is looking for ideas in his budget in two weeks' time today, he can have that idea for free. Take that back, maybe you'll be the Chancellor. But we all know what Labour will choose: more welfare, because they're not the party of home ownership.

They're our values, they are not their values. We are the party of home ownership, they are the party of welfare. And we know how many people are on out-of-work benefits in Britain today. Now even the leader of the Liberal Democrats can see that taxing this week, the leader of the Liberal Democrats this week can see that taxing family homes is wrong. Just two years ago, he told the BBC when they wanted to hear from him: "A lot of people's homes in many areas of the country are quite valuable, and they end up being clobbered by inheritance tax, and I think that's unfair."

So we shall see whether his colleagues, current colleagues agree with him and which lobby they end up in today, whether they're with their useful helpers of the government or whether they're willing to stand up for their constituents being overtaxed by this government. So we would take the majority of families out of inheritance tax, we would abolish the truly awful family farm tax, and we would abolish the anti-growth family business tax.

And when we can afford it, within our fiscal rules, we will abolish inheritance tax entirely because we do believe it is an immoral tax.

04:36:02 - 04:36:37

Kit Malthouse

I'm very, I'm very grateful to my right honorable friend. He's making a very powerful argument. And also presumably he would recognize that the clue is often in the name where our businesses are concerned, that many of our largest businesses which we regard as national champions owe their origin to family businesses, whether it's Pilkingtons, John Lewis, Sainsburys or our banks with Lloyds. The fact they carry a surname indicates the many generations which it took to build them to their power and that by taxing them, we hold the entire economy back from that kind of growth.

04:36:37 - 04:38:14

Andrew Griffith

Well my, my right honorable friend is absolutely right. I don't think any fair-minded person in the United Kingdom today says the problem is that we have too many successful companies, that there's too many companies setting up, being founded, listing on our stock exchanges, that our economy's growing somehow too fast, that we haven't got enough young people to fill the jobs that are available, that the economy doesn't have enough debt. So you would think that were there a measure that allows productive capital to flow down the generations to allow enterprises across communities in all of our countries to help our economy grow, that this government would clutch on it like a sinking man clings to a life raft. Perhaps, perhaps we will get that Damascene conversion from the minister today. Perhaps we'll hear that in two weeks' time.

But I rather fear not, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's why so many other countries in our situation, so many economies that are growing faster than us don't impose multi-generational taxes on businesses. And it would be interesting to hear as well from the minister why it is that he and his government would single out family businesses, not those owned by private equity, not those owned by international domiciled corporations, not even listed companies, but just family businesses for this iniquitous measure. I'd love to hear that, Madam Deputy Speaker, wouldn't we on this side of the House? So I'll happily give way.

04:38:14 - 04:38:16

Speaker 161

I'm enjoying the contributions.

04:38:16 - 04:38:25

Speaker 162

I thank him for giving way. He mentions countries growing faster than Britain. Can he name a single country in the G7 growing faster than Great Britain?

04:38:25 - 04:40:15

Andrew Griffith

Well, I've said on many times in this House, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I think the G7 is the wrong comparator peer group. Neither are we growing the fastest within the G7. The IMF, if the honorable member took the time to read more than the headlines handed out by the Labour whips, the IMF, the IMF yesterday downgraded, downgraded the forecast for growth of our wonderful great country and enterprise for 2027. They actually reduced the rate of growth. That is what Labour are doing to our economy.

And in the meantime, in the meantime, while the G7 largely consists of relatively sclerotic economies that suffer from the same levels of indebtedness and lack of growth as the United Kingdom, the G20 are coming up on the outside track. They are the countries that are more prosperous. They're building airports. They're building infrastructure. They're forming capital.

Capital and companies are taking on the world and their young people have more jobs opportunity, which is why, not that this Labour government has any interest in calibrating and counting and identifying those that are leaving, but that is why the flow of wealth creators and ambitious young people is not to our wonderful country with its history and heritage, but from our country to those economies that are growing more successfully, faster than ours. And one of the reasons, Madam Deputy Speaker, to conclude, one of the reasons is that those countries are more understanding of family businesses, they are more understanding of family farms, and they are more sympathetic and on the side of those who work hard, who want to create wealth, a better life for themselves, for their family and for the next generation. I beg to move.

04:40:15 - 04:40:23

Speaker 163

The question is as on the order paper. Minister James Murray.

04:40:23 - 04:40:44

Craig Gareth Snell

I seek your counsel. The honourable gentleman has just given a rather long speech about the benefits of family-owned businesses, but he failed to declare that one of the biggest beneficiaries in this country would be JCB, who just happen to have given him thirty thousand pounds over the last year. Is that a matter that should have been declared before the speech was made?

04:40:44 - 04:41:04

Speaker 152

Can I... if the honourable member is going to make a point of order, he might at least listen to the response. As he ought to know as an experienced parliamentarian, that is a matter for declarations, it is not a matter for the chair. He has, however, made his point. James Murray. Point of order, Kit Malthouse.

04:41:04 - 04:41:20

Kit Malthouse

I need to offer you an apology. When I asked my question, I should have declared or drawn attention to my register. I'm the proud founder of two businesses which I hope in time to pass on to my children if the Labour Party don't get in the way.

04:41:20 - 04:41:28

Speaker 164

As the honourable member will know, that's not a matter for the chair either, but I thank him for having put that on the record. James Murray.

04:41:28 - 04:46:10

James Stewart Murray

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, third time lucky for being called to give my speech. And thank you to the Shadow Chancellor for delivering a speech for which it was this time much clearer when it had ended. Madam Deputy Speaker, the opposition motion that we are debating today invites us to speculate on the contents of the budget. And as honourable and right honourable members will be used to me and my colleagues saying, the government does not comment on speculation and the Chancellor will deliver his budget in this house on October the twenty-eighth. But I am free to share with the house some of the context today in which the Chancellor will be taking his decisions.

Madam Deputy Speaker, the budget comes amid unprecedented economic shocks, with conflicts in both the Middle East and Europe hitting people here and around the world. But we are not powerless. And that is why we are giving families and businesses breathing space where we can, and starting to make the big long-term changes needed to create good jobs and growth in every postcode. Everything we do at this budget will be built on fiscal stability. Our fiscal responsibility has been underlined by the IMF this week.

As the IMF made clear, our country is forecast to have the lowest borrowing, that is to say the smallest deficit, in the G7 from 2029. Our country is demonstrating strong resilience in the face of global challenges, with the joint second fastest growing economy in the G7 this year. And so to deliver good growth in every postcode, and to provide breathing space for families and businesses today, we must continue to take responsible choices. That is why, as the Prime Minister and the Chancellor have made clear, fiscal discipline will underwrite every promise this government makes to the British people. We will meet our fiscal rules at the budget later this month with a buffer against uncertainty.

We will control borrowing so that we can bring inflation down and reduce long-term pressures on our public finances. And that is the right thing to do, because there is nothing progressive about a government spending one pound in every ten on debt interest rather than the priorities of working people.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this government inherited public finances that were in a mess and public services that were in crisis. Since the general election, we have put the NHS back on its feet with the waiting list down by more than 250,000 since the government came to power. Last year, we delivered the highest number of affordable homes in a decade. We are lifting over half a million children out of poverty thanks to scrapping the two-child limit and expanding free school meals. We are investing in Britain's future with an additional 120 billion pounds of capital investment across this parliament, investing in Britain's roads, rail, energy and other infrastructure that is so important to driving growth.

And through reforms to how our country works, Madam Deputy Speaker, from planning to pensions and skills, we have helped to create the conditions for private investment to rise by almost 5% since the general election. We have always been prepared to take the responsible choices to fix the foundations of our economy, to repair our broken public services and to deliver the investment needed to support growth. Those decisions include driving down waste and driving up efficiency in the public sector, including a reduction to departmental admin budgets of 16% by the end of the spending review. We are reprioritising spending so that taxpayers' money is spent on their priorities, cancelling digital ID, to remove VAT from household electricity bills, reprioritising MHCLG spending to help tackle homelessness and bringing the national bus cap down to 2 pounds for 2027, funded by savings from the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. We are reforming the welfare system through the Milburn review and the Timms review whilst tackling welfare fraud and error to save over 14 billion pounds by the end of 2030-31.

And we have taken decisions on tax to ensure that we meet our fiscal rules of living within our means. Madam Deputy Speaker, our decisions on tax reflect our commitment to sound public finances. We want to make sure that those with broader shoulders make a fair contribution. Whilst very few people, if any, want to pay more tax, we recognize that only a small proportion of the largest estates pay inheritance tax and it makes an important contribution to the public finances. Inheritance tax is forecast to raise almost 15 billion pounds in 2030-31 to help deliver public services and it is currently payable on around one in 20 estates.

Our reforms to agricultural property relief and business property relief introduced in April of this year are expected to raise around 300 million pounds per year whilst offering substantial protection for family farms and businesses.

04:46:10 - 04:46:21

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you. I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way on that point. He focuses on how much he believes this tax will raise, but what does the impact assessment say for how many businesses will close as a result of this tax?

04:46:21 - 04:47:25

James Stewart Murray

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, the impact assessment or the tax information note is published alongside the publication of the policy at the budget. But can I just make the point, Madam Deputy Speaker, that in order to protect family farms and family businesses, the threshold for the 100% relief still applies and goes up to 2.5 million pounds per person and above that there is still a 50% rate which means an effective inheritance tax rate of up to 20% above that. Furthermore, that the repayments can be spread over up to 10 years interest-free, so there are substantial protections in place for family farms and family businesses. And through that 100% relief on the first 2.5 million pounds of qualifying agricultural and business assets, and in fact means a couple can pass on up to 5 million pounds of qualifying agricultural and business assets free of inheritance tax between them, in addition to the existing allowances such as the nil-rate band. These protections support family farms as we work with farmers to build a sector that is productive, profitable and resilient for the future.

04:47:25 - 04:48:04

Kit Malthouse

Will the minister give way, but there seems to be a disconnect in the Labour Party's understanding of the situation.

Does he not appreciate that the capital value of an enterprise, whether it be a farm or a business, does not necessarily equate to the revenue that it generates? And many farms and family businesses are what they would call effectively lifestyle businesses, where people are happy to sit on what may appear to be a large capital value, but that yields a very small revenue amount that won't support the taxes he's trying to levy, and at the same time only just about supports the lifestyle that people are willing to tolerate. And it's this imbalance that's causing so much anguish.

04:48:04 - 04:48:32

James Stewart Murray

Well, I thank the right honourable gentleman for his question. But I think the fact that we have a threshold of two and a half million pounds of qualifying assets over which the 100% relief applies, and then the 50% relief applies in an uncapped manner above that level, means that we are protecting small family businesses and family farms whilst making sure that there is a contribution towards the public finances. I'll give way.

04:48:32 - 04:48:57

Kit Malthouse

I'm grateful to the Minister for giving way. So say you've got a farm that's worth three million pounds ostensibly on land value. That farm may only be yielding a net income to a farmer of thirty to fifty thousand pounds a year, on which they're surviving. Now they're willing to live that way because they love living on the farm, it's been in their family for many generations, they feel a sense of stewardship and custodianship. But that revenue is not enough for them to live and then sustain the tax that he wants to levy.

04:48:57 - 04:49:46

James Stewart Murray

Madam Deputy Speaker, without commenting on individual tax affairs, even if hypothetical, if a farm was worth three million pounds, the two and a half million pound allowance for the 100% relief would cover a substantial portion of that. And of course that's in addition to the existing nil-rate bands and can be transferred between spouses. So if that hypothetical farm were passed on via a couple to their descendant, five million pounds would be covered. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll make some progress because I want to emphasize that our work as a government with farmers, farmers who feed the nation, sustain rural communities and help to manage the land that shapes our countryside, ranges from the immediate support, like sixty-five million pound emergency package that we announced to help them cope with summer's drought, to opening new markets for British produce through trade deals and export opportunities. I'll give way.

04:49:46 - 04:50:05

Wendy Morton

I'm grateful to the right honourable gentleman for giving way. But when it comes specifically to farmers, he appears to give the impression that he knows about the farming industry. But how often, if ever, does he actually go out onto a family farm and meet with the farmers?

04:50:05 - 04:50:40

James Stewart Murray

Well, as the right honourable lady will know, I've been in a position in the Treasury previously in this government and have had a large number of conversations with people affected by and worried about this tax policy. Where the tax policy is now, as introduced in April of this year, has a two and a half million pound threshold for the 100% relief. And we're confident that that balances raising revenue for the public finances with giving the right protection to family farms, which we think is so important. And Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll give way one more time.

04:50:40 - 04:51:16

Andrew Murrison

I'm grateful to the Minister, he's being very generous indeed. If he was a farmer with a relatively small farm, probably pretty marginal, at say three hundred acres, worth about three million pounds, would he be considering improving his farm, or would he be considering investing capital in upgrading his farm with the very expensive bits of kit that are now necessary to produce any sort of return on the land these days? Or would he think, particularly if he was getting on in years, that would be money that would simply be top-sliced by the Treasury?

04:51:16 - 04:54:47

James Stewart Murray

Madam Deputy Speaker, much like his honourable friend behind him, the right honourable gentleman refers to a three million pound farm.

And again, this makes me confident that the threshold of 2 and a half million pounds for the 100% relief would cover a large proportion of those assets. As I said, that 2.5 million pounds of qualifying assets means a couple can pass on up to 5 million pounds of qualifying assets, and that's in addition to the other existing nil rate bands. So it's a similar point that his honorable friend made around the fact that a 3 million pound farm would in fact be covered by much of the relief and the nil rate bands. But Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to make the point here that our responsible approach to the public finances stands in stark contrast to the approach taken by the party opposite. In government, they crashed the economy whilst the Shadow Chancellor was in the Treasury, and they left us with billions of pounds of unfunded spending commitments.

In opposition, they are showing they have learned nothing from their general election defeat. They claim, Madam Deputy Speaker, that their changes to inheritance tax would cost 6 billion pounds and that they know how they would pay for them. But when they say they would make savings to welfare and asylum, no one can believe a word they say when everyone knows the cost of both soared when they were in power. What's more, independent analysis by tax expert Dan Neidle suggests that the true cost of their changes would reach 10.8 billion pounds a year once behavioral effects are taken into account. That is a cost, Madam Deputy Speaker, almost double the number their Shadow Chancellor has been bandying around.

So let's face it, with their policies costing double what they say and their so-called savings failing to materialize, they would either push up borrowing or they would do what Tories do best: make cuts to schools, cuts to prison places, and cuts to our NHS. And let's be clear, Madam Deputy Speaker, this policy would fail to help ordinary families across the country. That independent analysis has shown that 90%, 90% of the benefit would go to the wealthiest 20% of pensioner households. 40% would go to the wealthiest 5% and 70% of the benefits would go to households in London and the Southeast. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Conservatives' policy stands in contrast to the fair decisions this government will always take.

My right honorable friend the Chancellor will of course set out any future tax measures in the budget in two weeks' time. But let me remind the House of the decisions this government has already taken to provide breathing space to families and businesses. For families rightly concerned about the cost of energy, we've removed VAT from electricity bills, taking around 45 pounds off the price cap, and this is on top of the 150 pounds removed from bills at the last budget. And for those paying business rates, the government has introduced a support package worth 4.3 billion pounds with a further announcement in July taking an extra 20% off bills for pubs, social clubs, and live music venues. Madam Deputy Speaker, these are some of our choices to help families and businesses across the country.

Rather than helping ordinary families struggling with the cost of living, the Tories instead are prioritizing some of those with the greatest wealth. In a world of difficult choices, they are choosing to direct billions of pounds towards some of those with the largest assets whilst everyone else is asked to pick up the bill. I'll give way.

04:54:47 - 04:55:12

Christopher John Vince

The minister for giving way, he's always very generous with his time across the House. Doesn't this motion just show the party opposite have got the wrong priorities? Removing inheritance tax for families when the threshold is a million pounds will make no difference to families in my constituency of Harlow. It's one in 20, less than one in 20 families pay inheritance tax. Actually, isn't the right thing to do to be actually tackling the cost of living crisis in the way that he's talked about?

04:55:12 - 04:55:29

James Stewart Murray

Madam Deputy Speaker, my honorable friend makes an important point about politics being about choices and politics being about priorities. And indeed, in a world of difficult choices, the Conservatives are choosing to direct billions of pounds towards some of those with the largest estates whilst everyone else is being asked to pick up the bill.

04:55:29 - 04:55:31

Speaker 169

I'll give way.

04:55:31 - 04:56:33

Robbie Moore

For giving way. Madam Deputy Speaker, I worry that this Labour government is living in some sort of parallel universe. I will literally put to the Minister, I met with one of my manufacturing businesses in Keighley recently. They employ nearly 250 people in Keighley. They've already worked out that their BPR liability over and above the 2.5 million pound threshold is just about a million pounds.

Their advice is either to sell plant or machinery to mitigate that liability imposed on them by this government or to sell shares in their business. Either way, they're losing control of their business or losing productivity of their business from having to sell plant or machinery. This is as a result of a choice that's been made by this Labour government. How can the Minister sit there and describe this as fair choices to the bosses of that business where now up to 250 people are likely to be exposed at risk from losing their jobs in my constituency?

04:56:33 - 04:57:25

James Stewart Murray

Madam Deputy Speaker, without commenting on an individual taxpayer's circumstances, the fact that we have a threshold of 2.5 million pounds before any inheritance tax is due on relevant agricultural and business property assets provides substantial protection for people from those charges. And as I said earlier, there is a 50% relief which is uncapped above that level and payment is allowed over 10 years interest-free. So the balance that we were striking in the policy which was introduced in April of this year was the policy that provides protection for family farms and small businesses whilst making sure there is a contribution to the public finances, underscoring our fiscal responsibility which is so important to better public services and a stable economy. Because Madam Deputy Speaker, on this side of the house, I'll give way one more time.

04:57:25 - 04:57:35

Speaker 171

I thank the Minister for giving way. Just listening to him, he seems to be doing so much to protect and help farmers. Is he not mystified they're not queuing up to thank him?

04:57:35 - 04:58:56

James Stewart Murray

I was going to say I thank the honourable gentleman for his question, but I'm not sure it was meant in that tone from him. But look, being in government is about taking the right decisions for the future of the country. And I know that when taking decisions in the Treasury, the most important thing to start with is to make sure that fiscal stability and fiscal responsibility are the bedrock of all of our decisions. And if you look at the decisions that we've taken as a government, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the commitment of the Chancellor and the Prime Minister, no one can be in any doubt that we will never return to the recklessness of his party when they were in government. Because Madam Deputy Speaker, we know on this side of the house that to provide breathing space for families and businesses and to fix our economy and our country for the long term, fiscal discipline must underwrite every promise we make.

That is why we will continue to meet our fiscal rules with a buffer against uncertainty. We will support good growth in every postcode by getting power out of Westminster. And we will drive investment to boost innovation and to create jobs. That is how we will bring back hope across Britain. Not the fantasy economics and the unfunded spending commitments of the party opposite, but with a plan to unlock potential in every part of our country so that wherever you live, you and your local community can thrive.

Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to oppose the opposition motion.

04:58:56 - 04:59:00

Speaker 170

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Daisy Cooper.

04:59:00 - 05:00:35

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's good to see the Shadow Chancellor open this debate because after his conference speech, I too was not sure whether he would be trusted to close it. Now of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Shadow Chancellor was not the only Conservative frontbencher to deliver an interesting conference speech. The leader of the opposition simultaneously told us that every spending commitment would be matched by a source of funding, but then proceeded to announce a string of unfunded pledges.

Oh, we've got the numbers. It is now clear, it is clear that Kemm-onomics... Madam Deputy Speaker, I think the official opposition is slightly rattled. It is now clear that Kemm-onomics is simply Truss-onomics 2.0. And if the Conservative Party gets anywhere near the levers of power again, or if they choose to hand the keys to Number 10 to Reform UK, it will once again propel this country towards another crash in the public finances.

Turning to the substance of the motion, Madam Deputy Speaker, we Liberal Democrats agree that the inheritance tax system is not fair. Ordinary families can face an inheritance tax rate of 40%, while those inheriting estates worth tens of billions of pounds are often able to avoid paying their fair share through complex tax planning and accounting arrangements. The UK has one of the highest... Well.

05:00:35 - 05:01:02

Charles Noah Law

Important point that there are issues with the current administration, but those are more to do with the fact that many of the wealthiest are avoiding it. But does she equally agree with me that businesses are genuinely in a better place to receive tax planning advice, so whilst there are lots of retorts about the difficulties of selling plant machinery, for example, businesses are better placed than households to take on that tax planning.

05:01:02 - 05:01:18

Daisy Cooper

Wow. I think right now, I think households and businesses feel absolutely hammered by the tax burden at the moment. On this particular motion of inheritance tax, though, I hope we can both agree that there is a problem where the wealthiest can avoid this through the various loopholes.

05:01:18 - 05:01:27

Charles Noah Law

Have another go. Does she really believe that the top 4% or so of households are being hammered by inheritance tax right now? I don't believe that's the case, Madam Deputy Speaker.

05:01:27 - 05:02:55

Daisy Cooper

Speaker, the first question was broader and was asking about the capacity of businesses generally to pay for advanced tax planning. I think hopefully we can all agree that the tax code in this country is so complicated that I think it's unfortunate people have to seek expert tax advice. Our tax system could be much simpler. But the point that I was trying to make was that there are problems and there are loopholes in this particular tax. We have one of the highest headline rates of inheritance tax in the OECD, yet only 4% of estates end up paying it.

The burden often falls on those who cannot take advantage of the loopholes and the exemptions that are available to those with access to expensive tax advice. So we would reform inheritance tax to make it fairer, but let us be clear, a mini-budget style approach to tax cuts is not the way to do it. There is a better alternative, Madam Deputy Speaker. If we want to help people who are being squeezed by the cost of living, the fairest and most effective approach is to cut income tax. We Liberal Democrats have done this before, and in power, we would do it again.

In government, we cut tax for millions of people, taking 3.4 million people out of income tax altogether. And today, we Liberal Democrats are committed to raising both the income tax personal allowance and the national insurance threshold to £15,000 over five years.

05:02:55 - 05:03:16

Paul Holmes

How are you going to fund it? Liz Truss in a big suit. I thank the honourable lady for giving way, and can I say to her that I think she's making an excellent case for her leadership campaign. But can I just ask her to put on record, does she believe that if she got into government and put these policies forward, would the leader of the Liberal Democrats be there to do it?

05:03:16 - 05:04:25

Daisy Cooper

Yes. I think of all political parties in this chamber, the official opposition will know that the leader of the Liberal Democrats was a climate minister, an excellent climate minister in the coalition government.

Our party leader, our party leader is an economist and would never, ever, ever have done what his party did with the mini-budget. Madam Deputy Speaker, our Liberal Democrat policy, our Liberal Democrat policy would take a further 2.5 million people out of paying income tax altogether. So whilst the Conservatives' proposal today would only benefit around 30,000 people funded through a mini-budget style approach to tax cuts, our plan would deliver tax cuts to more than 30 million people across the country. And crucially, we would pay for it, one moment, we would pay for it responsibly through the growth dividend generated by a new growth and defense partnership with the European Union.

05:04:25 - 05:05:01

Andrew Murrison

I'm very grateful to the honorable lady. What would she say to her constituents? Because I've just been looking on Rightmove at house prices in St Albans, where a very, a very nice but semi-detached house in Carlisle Street is on the market at the moment for 1.4 million pounds. And she has just, in her remarks she's just made, dissed all of those people in saying that they are not going to be a priority for tax cuts at the next general election. Can she advise how they should vote?

05:05:01 - 05:05:56

Daisy Cooper

Well, I know exactly where Carlisle Avenue is, and based on the demographics of that particular ward, I might go and knock on that door and ask if their mortgage went up after the Liz Truss mini-budget. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, we Liberal Democrats are clear. Rebuilding our relationship with Europe is the single biggest lever available to increase economic growth, to boost living standards, and to cut personal tax. And for as long as the Conservatives, for as long as the Conservatives refuse to acknowledge that, they will remain an anti-growth, anti-business party. So we Liberal Democrats know that economic growth is not an end in itself.

And as we grow the economy, it is incumbent on all parties to ensure that the benefits of that growth are shared widely across the country. And I will.

05:05:56 - 05:06:12

Paul Holmes

I thank the honorable lady for giving way. Can I ask her, in her view, what would be the greatest thing to increase growth in this country and business growth? Would it be rejoining the European Union, or would it be halving National Insurance contributions by businesses on people who are aged 18 to 24?

05:06:12 - 05:06:59

Daisy Cooper

I can tell him, based on the statistics, the first thing that would bring the biggest amount of growth would be having a closer relationship with Europe. But we have also, as he, the honorable member will know, that we Liberal Democrats opposed the rise in the National Insurance contributions, and we have said that we would like to see the reversal of the lower threshold as an immediate move to give businesses back that incentive to give young people jobs given the current crisis. But Madam Deputy Speaker, this is why our plans link the additional growth generated by a stronger partnership with Europe directly to tax cuts for working people. That is the fair way to help families facing the cost of living crisis. It is the responsible way to cut taxes, and it is the honest way to pay for those tax cuts.

I'll accept that point.

05:06:59 - 05:07:16

Patrick Spencer

I was going to ask the honorable lady, where is the fairness in rightly reducing an earning couple's tax bill over time for them to accrue capital, buy a house, only for you then to tax it when they want to leave it to their children? Where's the fairness in that?

05:07:16 - 05:07:51

Daisy Cooper

I think we can all accept that there are unfairnesses, many unfairnesses in our tax system, and there are many tax reforms that we want to see for growth.

I have acknowledged in my speech today that there are unfairnesses in the way that this tax currently works. But scrapping taxes in an unfunded way is not the way to reform tax in this country and is certainly not the way to run the economy. So Madam Deputy Speaker, rather than offering another round of economic fantasy, we Liberal Democrats have a credible growth plan that would make the United Kingdom safer, stronger, and more prosperous. Thank you.

05:07:51 - 05:07:55

Speaker 177

Andrew Lewin.

05:07:55 - 05:10:38

Alan Andrew Lewin

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. We live in challenging times: heightened security threats, inflation, and the cost of living pressures being driven by Trump's war in the Middle East. Our NHS is still recovering from the pandemic and from Liz Truss. And yet the priority set out by the party opposite in their motion today is this: to cut public spending to give more money away to people who are inheriting sums of money greater than a million pounds. It's sad, it's predictable, but it's not surprising.

And as it stands, the party opposite knows that they're not serious contenders for government. So they've reached back today into a comfort zone, hoping that by sending a message to some of the wealthiest people in our society that they might hang on to a few more votes. But I'm afraid it's my view that people across the income spectrum in the constituency I represent in Welwyn Hatfield and across the country will see right through this policy, because my constituents know that we can ill afford a tax giveaway to people who are already fortunate enough to be inheriting a million pounds tax-free. And the facts matter. Under the current system, only around one in twenty people pay inheritance tax on their estates at all.

So the winners from their proposition will be about five percent of the population, while the rest of us are left to pick up the bill. Independent analysis has found, as my right honourable friend the Minister said, that the proposal could cost the Exchequer upwards of ten billion pounds a year. And Madam Deputy Speaker, the political choice matters too, because I believe in maximizing opportunities for people from all backgrounds. And I think the question we should be debating in this House today is not how we make things easier for those who rely on inherited wealth, but how we make it easier for those who don't have access to inherited wealth. Last year, the Bank of Mum and Dad provided more than nine billion pounds in gifts to their children, in some cases their grandchildren.

Now of course, every parent, every grandparent who has the ability to offer support to their loved ones will do so and should be encouraged to do so. And the average sum that was given down by the Bank of Mum and Dad was fifty-five thousand pounds, a very significant amount of money wherever you are in the country. And it's great for those who are in such a fortunate position. There'll be people in this chamber who've been able to give money and to receive money, and we should acknowledge that. But I think we should... I'll happily give way on that point.

05:10:38 - 05:10:47

Ben Spencer

Does he not understand that the Bank of Mum and Dad has come from the hard work of Mum and Dad to pass on to their children?

05:10:47 - 05:12:22

Alan Andrew Lewin

I absolutely understand that point, but there are many, many millions of people who work just as hard in this country but are not in a position to be able to give down tens of thousands of pounds to their children through no fault of their own. So my proposal, Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to use the opportunity in this debate to talk a little bit, if you will indulge me, about my own proposal on intergenerational fairness. I've got a policy idea called the Citizens' Advance, which I came up with a year or so ago. And it's a policy offer that would give people the opportunity to move their lives forward irrespective of their background.

This is how it would work. The state would say to people after 10 years in work of National Insurance contributions, we're going to give you a choice. You can keep your current state retirement age, which for most young adults today is 68. Or you can put back your state retirement age by a year to 69 and in return you will receive the value of one year of your state pension as a lump sum. And from April next year that will be £13,000.

Now that's my idea. I'm very pleased that the Social Market Foundation have taken it on. I'd encourage any members who are interested to read their detailed and costed policy paper. And I can assure my honourable friends on the front bench in the Treasury that you'll be hearing more from me on this subject in the weeks and months to come. But I make that point, Madam Deputy Speaker, because I want to engage seriously with the idea of intergenerational fairness.

It's important to me and I know it is to many of my constituents. But sadly I don't think the motion today... I'm happy to give way.

05:12:22 - 05:12:49

Caroline Johnson

Well, and he's clear that he's taking this issue very seriously and thinking about it very deeply. What does he think about inheritance tax on businesses? I'll give an example of a bandage factory making sterile bandages owned by a family where the 40-odd-year-old gentleman currently running the factory stands to lose quite a lot of money when his father dies. That will mean laying off people, selling the factory. How does that help the people who work there?

05:12:49 - 05:13:08

Alan Andrew Lewin

Grateful for her intervention. I obviously don't know the circumstances of this particular business, but I do know as the Minister set out that there is a threshold of £2.5 million whereby no business will pay any inheritance tax at all. I think that is a fair place to start and that is the status quo. And I'll give way to the honourable member.

05:13:08 - 05:13:55

Speaker 186

I wonder if the honourable member has taken a moment to work out the example put forward by one of the honourable members opposite of the £3.5 million worth of assets of a business in his constituency. The actual inheritance tax due by that family business after taking into account the rate up to £2.5 million and then the further million pounds worth of assets is in total £20,000. That will be what is payable, £20,000 per year for 10 years, an amount that ought to be manageable for a business with £3.5 million worth of assets. And so would he agree with me that the Minister has set out why this is important to rebuild the public finances?

05:13:55 - 05:14:46

Alan Andrew Lewin

Grateful to my honourable friend who speaks powerfully and with great experience on these issues. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm going to draw my remarks to a close by returning to the proposition put forward by the party opposite today. I am sad to say that they are a party retreating to their comfort zone. They could have come today and said let's have a debate about how we invest in defence or public services or new ways to support businesses. But I'm afraid that their choice and the choice made by their leader was a giveaway to the top 5% of estates in this country.

Madam Deputy Speaker, I am a meritocrat. I want a society less reliant on family wealth, not more. I want a society that maximises opportunity for all and I'm sorry that it's not a vision that the party opposite seems to share.

05:14:46 - 05:14:52

Speaker 180

With an immediate six-minute time limit, Patrick Spencer.

05:14:52 - 05:16:33

Patrick Spencer

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. If it is okay with you, I'm going to approach this debate in two sections. Firstly, let me paint a picture of the reality faced by my residents in Central Suffolk and North Ipswich. I am blessed to represent a constituency that has everything. Yes, rural communities made up of farms large and small, but also towns populated with small and medium-sized independent businesses like Simpson's Sweets and Bullstrodes of Framlingham, Luxmore of Framlingham, Buckle Shipping of Blakenham, the Lion pub of Debenham and Milsom's of Kesgrave.

Many of them, many of them, many of them, honourable members should visit, many of them family-owned and run businesses.

So many of those family businesses are made up of parents working with children, nephews, nieces, brothers, sisters, even grandchildren. There is a palpable love and passion among family members working for something that their parents and uncles, indeed grandparents built. There is both a care for customers as well as a profound camaraderie among team members that is so very hard to replicate. These businesses aren't just great places to work, they provide world-beating products and services. Dingley Dell in my constituency sells pork products to the Oberoi Hotel.

05:16:33 - 05:16:39

Speaker 182

Is it a real place? I point of order, Oberoi Hotel in New Delhi. Yes, absolutely.

05:16:39 - 05:16:48

Neil Hudson

I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for giving way. Are any of the premises there, are there any black labradors in them?

05:16:48 - 05:20:21

Patrick Spencer

I'm happy to report the black labrador population of Suffolk is thriving. Anyway, as I was saying, Madam Deputy Speaker, Seers Medical in Debenham sells medical equipment around the world. These businesses are invaluable to our economy and society. Not only do they provide jobs, but they pay their taxes that support critical public services. That's right, we need business to boost productivity and supercharge social mobility.

But for so many of my local businesses, there is an unquestionable sadness that the current government seeks to penalise them for wanting to keep a business in the family. This cannot be truer for families of farmers who have tended to land for generations, who have woken up early, dedicated unimaginable hours, seven days a week, 52 weeks a year, and now they're told they have to give up that because this Prime Minister doesn't have the temerity to get to grips with the welfare budget, because this Labour regime cannot bring themselves to stand up to civil service unions who want to work four days for more pay. Yes, everyone heard that right. This government wants to tax the farmers and the entrepreneurs who work seven days a week so that civil servants in London can work four days a week. For a party founded to protect workers' rights, let me tell you, the workers in my constituency feel abandoned by this government.

The iniquity of this social and economic contract negates the utter lunacy that seems to govern the government's approach to our public finances. I would welcome anyone in this chamber, indeed anyone in this country, to make a reasonable argument that public spending in its current form, with interest rates at record levels and rising, is sustainable. We have debt to GDP of approximately 100% with 3 trillion in debt outstanding, and we borrowed more than 134 billion pounds last year alone. As a percentage of GDP, we spend as much now as we did at the height of the global financial crisis when we were bailing out banks, and as much as we did during the mid-1970s, which by complete coincidence was the last time we had a proper left-wing government like this one in place. How many warnings from the IMF do we have to put up with until the government suddenly take note and realise you cannot borrow and spend your way from a crisis?

June 2026, September 2026, now just earlier this week, international economists have said enough is enough. But the gov, but I won't actually, but the government has a chance to U-turn. The government has a chance to U-turn, it's a move they are now all too familiar with. Show some gumption and cut welfare, grow a backbone and don't let the slackers in Whitehall get away with a four-day work week, cut taxes on the productive half of our economy, allowing businesses and families to pass their homes that they work for and they save for onto their children. The Prime Minister loves a football analogy, well this is the biggest open goal he will ever face in his career.

Do the right thing, cut taxes, cut spending and support businesses.

05:20:21 - 05:23:11

Catherine West

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker and it's a real pleasure to speak in this debate and also to reflect on this particular question of inheritance tax brought by the Conservative Party, given that it deals really with about 4% of as a proportion of the population, whereas I think on this side of the house we're rather more concerned with the 63% of the population who are facing really tough times. And so therefore Labour will be voting against this opposition day motion when it comes to it this afternoon. I think we all remember where we were in the summer of 2022 when Liz Truss crashed the economy. The mortgages which ordinary families around the country were paying went through the roof. A shiver went down the spine of all people who had pensions invested, as civil servants were sacked and the general reputation of the economy in the UK was trashed.

And sadly we've been paying for the Truss penalty ever since. Those of us on this side of the house fought to stop the chaos, to restore hope and deliver change, and in two years a lot of progress has been made, and over this summer even more progress has been made and I look forward to the budget coming forward in two weeks with more to offer those struggling with the cost of living crisis. Today, His Majesty's official opposition's asking the house to vote to bring back that version of chaos. Independent analysis suggests that Conservative inheritance tax proposals could cost up to 10 billion pound a year. Most families would rather see that money used to tackle the cost of living for everyone, to increase the wealth for the country as a whole, rather than provide tax cuts for the 4% of the proportion of the population affected by this particular taxation.

Conservatives say they're the party of home ownership, but after 14 years in government, home ownership fell out of reach for too many young people, and the only growth was the growth in homelessness which sadly under the Conservatives went up by 74% in the 14 years that they're in government. Working people took to the government, took the government to tackle the cost of living crisis and give them breathing space. But sadly the Conservatives' priority is tax cuts for inherited wealth, and as the member for Welland so eloquently laid out, we should be looking at all possible options to bring in that meritocratic principle that it doesn't matter where you are born, what your background is, you should have an opportunity throughout your working life to make the very best and to be successful. I'll take an intervention.

05:23:11 - 05:23:32

Rebecca Smith

I thank the honourable lady for her intervention, but I wonder Madam Deputy Speaker if she might like to comment on the fact that from next April, pensions are going to be included in what is being described as inherited wealth. Does the honourable lady agree with me that pensions are not inherited wealth, they are money that has been earned and has been set aside doing the right thing and now that is going to cost ordinary families when they hand that money down.

05:23:32 - 05:27:08

Catherine West

Well, of course, as she's aware, the commitment's been made that for those who are just getting the state pension, taxation will not be taken out of it. But for those who earn a lot, whether that be through pensions, whether that be through inheritance and other things, they will be taxed proportionately, which I think sounds like a pretty fair principle to me. In the meantime, we're on the side of the house, this on the side of the house, getting on with building the fairer country with a new political and economic model, but we do need to help people right now. That's why Labour's taken immediate action to provide breathing space for people and businesses. For example, this was recognized, I was pleased, and a couple of members have mentioned the IMF report.

As often with economists, it's a bit of a curate's egg. Some people can choose the text that they liked on the other side, but the one that I took from the economist Ms. Tenreyro was that the World Economic Outlook report gave the UK GDP an upgrade. So that I think gives us some hope as the budget is just two weeks away. It sets quite a positive background. And for those of us on this side of the house who are waking up to a little bit of positive news, which I think is also quite a good background for these decisions coming up in two weeks' time.

Just very briefly, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm aware there's lots of other people. I'm particularly pleased about the scrapped VAT on electricity bills for this winter, and I know that there's more to come for very, for homes where there's a lot of use of electricity, be that due to disability or a very high number of people living in a particular home. The capped bus fares helping people get to work or get to job interviews, two pounds for the whole of 2027. Changing the rules on branded school uniform items to ease costs for families. Taking 20% off business rates for pubs, social clubs, music venues.

Of course, in London, all children having that hot dinner in the middle of the day in school. Changing public procurement rules to back British businesses and jobs. There's so many things which have been introduced in the short two years in which Labour's been in, and there's much more to come. These measures build on work Labour's done to restore stability and growth to the economy. Difficult decisions have been taken, and I was pleased to see that the Prime Minister did announce a further difficult decision on the triple lock coming forward.

And I think it is a moment in time where we do have to be a little bit gutsy in our politics, and I was pleased to see that the PM did announce that very difficult decision coming down the track, but he did at least announce it so that we can start talking about that difficult challenge we have over social care. To sum up, Madam Deputy Speaker, it has a ring of chaos, these proposals flung out by the opposition. And I know, I was in opposition for 14 years. I know how tempting it is to have a giggle on opposition day debates, but we do have to face the truth that we have to have some difficult decisions made in order to restore the reputation of our economy internationally with the markets, but also to build that important foundation with some innovation which has been brought forward by the member for Welland and others, I'm sure, who will speak in this debate. So that we can, I won't because I've only got 40 seconds and I know you want to speak, members want to speak.

But we will get on with delivering the difficult decisions and the change which our communities are longing to see. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

05:27:08 - 05:27:10

Speaker 187

Peter Fortune.

05:27:10 - 05:28:24

Peter Timothy Fortune

Thank you. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. You cannot tax your way to prosperity. And that is something that I as a Conservative believe. Not only do I believe it, but it has also been demonstrated time and time again in countries across the globe.

When this government first entered office under the previous Prime Minister, we were told one of their central focuses would be to go for growth. We all know that governments cannot conjure growth out of thin air. It is the government's job to create the right environment for businesses big and small to drive growth. But this government spent its first period in office piling cost after cost onto British businesses. The national insurance increase, the employment rights bill, delivering a regulatory burden that keeps growing.

Now take pubs for example. They have been one of the hardest, they have been some of the businesses hardest hit by this government. Since 2023, we have seen nearly 700 pubs close. In my own constituency of Bromley and Biggin Hill, we have been lucky to retain the number of pubs that we have, and that's through no inconsiderable effort by myself. But the people, I will give way.

05:28:24 - 05:28:40

Charles Noah Law

I thank the honorable member giving way. And does he care to recall how many pubs closed under the previous Conservative government's watch? And just how big the deficit that he referred to was that we were trying to fill with some of those interventions he referred to earlier?

05:28:40 - 05:29:48

Peter Timothy Fortune

Thanks again, thank you Madam Deputy Speaker, and Labour proving once again that they are desperate to talk about the past because they have no plan for the future. And talking about the pubs in my constituency, the number of people employed by them has seen a significant decrease. The British Beer and Pub Association estimates that in Bromley and Biggin Hill, we have gone from around 1,150 people employed in pubs in 2023 to around 800 now. A reduction that seems to have hit the young people the hardest, with the number of 16 to 24 year olds employed in the industry down by 200, half the 400 in 2023. Nationally, we have seen total GVA from pubs and breweries fall from 47 million in 2023 to 30.8 million, and the government's tax take fall from 17 to 3.2 million.

Higher taxation and regulation strangling an industry and leaving the government with less money in the end. I will give way to my honorable friend and then my other honorable friend.

05:29:48 - 05:30:21

Gregory James Stafford

I thank the honorable member, my honorable friend for giving way. And I know like me what a champion for his local pubs he is. And I'd also like to put on record that my local pub, one of my local pubs, has just won my best pub competition, the Crown in Otford. But on his point about taxation, if we tax cigarettes to stop people smoking, so if we tax jobs, we have fewer jobs. And if we tax economic growth, we have less economic growth.

Why does he not think Labour gets this?

05:30:21 - 05:30:33

Peter Timothy Fortune

I'd like to thank my honorable friend for his intervention. He is of course absolutely right. You tax something to stop it happening, you tax jobs, they stop being created. I give way to my, my friend.

05:30:33 - 05:30:52

Alan Andrew Lewin

I thank the honorable member and he is a friend. We play cricket together in the parliamentary team and therefore have shared a few pints in a pub. And I would just like to, he is of generous spirit, and would he therefore recognize that this Prime Minister is cutting taxes for pubs by 20% and that's something everybody in this house should welcome?

05:30:52 - 05:33:03

Peter Timothy Fortune

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. He's being too generous. He plays cricket, I sort of stand there and get hit by the ball. One has to look at taxation in the round and if you look at the impact of things like the national insurance costs, it is getting more and more difficult for businesses to survive on the high street. Because if we want to see economic growth that will strengthen our local communities, strengthen those high streets and deliver real opportunities for young people, we need to see a fundamental change in approach.

That fundamentally different approach was outlined perfectly by the leader of the opposition and the rest of the shadow cabinet in Birmingham last week.

It is absolutely right that people should be able to leave behind assets such as family farms, businesses, and homes to their direct descendants without being taxed. And I warmly welcome our plans to abolish inheritance tax on family homes, rewarding a lifetime of hard work instead of punishing those who have scrimped and saved their whole life. Halving employer national insurance for those aged 21 to 24 is exactly the kind of bold policy we need to get young people back into work. Bill Pereira, a McDonald's franchisee in my constituency, highlighted that the employer national insurance increase as the very reason he is struggling to be able to employ more young people. Halving it will greatly assist those hospitality and leisure businesses that give many people their first job.

We know the need to tackle the unsustainable welfare budget and our savings plan will save 71 billion by doing exactly that. And this will allow us to pay for our commitments like 3% on defence spending by 2030 whilst reducing the deficit by 35.5 billion against 2029-30 forecasts. The distinction, Madam Deputy Speaker, between the opposition and the government could not be clearer. We are setting out a comprehensive plan to get our country back to work, grow the economy, and make our communities stronger. The government has no real plan and they have floundered in their first few years in government and they have failed to deliver.

The next Conservative government will deliver. It will deliver a stronger economy and a stronger country, a stronger economy and stronger country.

05:33:03 - 05:38:57

Michael Philip Brickell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to start with the wording of today's motion in the name of the Leader of the Opposition. It calls for public spending to be cut in order to abolish inheritance tax on family homes, farms, and businesses. Abolition, without conditions, without qualification, without any taper whatsoever, without any reference to the growing cost of social care or the vital contribution that inheritance tax receipts make towards supporting our ageing population. So let me be clear that it is the Conservatives who are proposing a tax break paid for cuts to public spending for those who have inherited or accumulated considerable wealth.

A tax break for the wealthiest 5.5% who are forecast to be subject to IHT this year. And let's be honest about what the party opposite are proposing. They're proposing to abolish a progressive, redistributive tax in its entirety at a potential cost of 10.8 billion pounds a year to benefit a small minority of the very wealthiest estates. Now I have no objection to people wanting to pass something on to their children. It is a natural and a valuable part of being a parent.

But the question before us today is not whether families should be able to pass on their hard-earned assets fairly. It is whether the right priority for this country is to abolish inheritance tax altogether regardless of the cost. And I think the answer is clear. I do not want to dwell on figures too much today, but one figure is worth remembering. Because my constituency is a varied one.

It has affluent areas and not-so-affluent areas. Yet at the last general election, fewer than 1% of estates in my Bolton West constituency were expected to fall within the inheritance tax threshold. So I have to ask on behalf of my hard-working constituents, who exactly are the official opposition speaking to with this proposal? Because it will do precious little for the overwhelming majority of people in Bolton, in Blackrod, in Horwich, and Westhoughton. It will not help the small business owner struggling with rising costs in Westhoughton.

It will not help the single mum in Horwich managing the weekly shop. It will not help the pensioner in Blackrod worried about their energy bills, and it will not help the young person in Bolton trying to get on the first rung of the housing ladder. It is designed to benefit a small minority with the largest estates. So let me reiterate the remarks from my honourable friend, the member for Welwyn Hatfield, that this is a return by the official opposition to their comfort zone. Most families in my constituency, and I wager in the country at large, would far rather see that money used to tackle the cost of living crisis, improve public services, and give working people some breathing room.

Now, the official opposition may have concerns about the tapering of the personal allowance for earners over £100,000, the high marginal tax rates that can create, or the economic distortions that follow. Those are legitimate subjects for debate, but they are not the motion before us today. And if the Conservatives wanted to bring forward proposals that would genuinely help ordinary families, they had plenty of alternatives. They could have focused on cracking down on aggressive tax avoidance and evasion, which deprive the public purse of billions of pounds that could otherwise fund our public services. They could have tackled the tangled web of professional enablers who help wealthy individuals, and yes, some businesses, conceal assets, exploit loopholes, and avoid paying what they owe.

They could have proposed a fairer tax system that levels the playing field between online giants and high street businesses. Those are the debates worth having. Those are the sorts of proposals that could command support across this House. Instead, the Conservatives have deliberately chosen to pursue a narrow, partisan agenda that benefits those who are asset-rich while offering precious little to those who need help the most. And that brings me to the wider question of priorities, because this government understands that helping people with the cost of living means taking practical action on the bills they pay, the services they rely on, and the businesses that sustain their communities.

And this government has pursued those, including through scrapping VAT on electricity bills for this winter. And those are practical measures. They speak to the everyday concerns of working people, families, and yes, small businesses. And that's what responsible government looks like. Yet the party opposite, by contrast, want us to believe that the answer to the pressures facing this country is to spend less on public services so that a small minority can pay less tax on their estates.

I must say, it sounds remarkably like they have learned little from the Liz Truss debacle. And what they are proposing means less money available for public services, less money to support vulnerable people, and less capacity to address the pressures facing our country. If the official opposition is serious about rebuilding its support across the United Kingdom, about speaking to people, yes, in every community, and demonstrating that it's ready to govern again, it should scrap this motion. It should focus on the issues that speak to the country at large. Because politics is about priorities, and in choosing the complete abolition of inheritance tax as the subject of today's opposition day debate, the official opposition has sent a very clear signal.

Tax cuts for a small minority over support for the many. The interests of the wealthiest estates over the needs of children growing up in poverty. And chosen to spend billions on a policy that will do precious little for my constituency across Bolton West. And that's why I will not be supporting this motion.

05:38:57 - 05:41:00

Blake Stephenson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm sure you will agree with me that there are few instincts more human than wanting to leave something behind for your children. A home you paid for over 30 years, perhaps, a farm your grandfather worked before you, maybe a business you've built from nothing. I know people on this side of the House know all about all three. On this side of the House, we believe that hard work should be rewarded.

On that side of the House, as we've heard over the past few years and today, they simply cannot resist their natural instincts to penalise aspirational homeowners, farmers, and business owners.

Now, let us remember that inheritance tax was once something only the very wealthiest had to think about. But of course, not anymore. The nil-rate band has been 325,000 pounds since 2009, and this government has frozen it all the way out to 2031. Over the same period, we know house prices have soared right across the country. The result is that receipts have hit a record 8.2 billion pounds, and the OBR expects them to reach almost 14 billion pounds by the end of the decade.

Analysis by Tax Policy Associates suggests that by next year, around one in five pensioner households will face a bill if they died. This was not in contemplation when inheritance tax was first envisaged. And from April next year, because the party opposite can't get enough of hoovering up people's wealth, unspent pensions will also be dragged into the liability. That is not a tax on the super-rich, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a tax on hardworking constituents right across the country, including those in three-bedroom semi-detached houses where they've raised their children, and as we've heard today, including families in Carlisle Street in St Albans no less.

05:41:00 - 05:41:32

Daisy Cooper

Madam Deputy Speaker, it's fascinating that the Conservative benches are so obsessed with Carlisle Avenue. I've just looked up Carlisle Avenue's local election results from last May. One half of the street is in Bernards Heath ward where the Conservatives came fourth, and the other end of Carlisle Avenue is in another ward where the Conservatives came fifth. I wonder what the honorable gentleman thinks about whether there are more structural issues with his party that mean that people living on Carlisle Avenue have no interest in his party's policies.

05:41:32 - 05:43:36

Blake Stephenson

I am impressed by I am impressed by the honorable lady's research between the intervention earlier by my honorable friend and making that point now, so I'm impressed. I might just add that members of the public or your constituents or constituents in that street may have been duped by some Lib Dem bar charts, perhaps. But let's see. Mid Bedfordshire is a rural constituency and and there are many farming families in my constituency, as there are right across the country. And they were told in October 2024 that the government was coming for the land they have worked for generations.

And thanks to their hard work and their campaigning and pressure from this side of the House, the government retreated last December and raised the threshold to 2.5 million pounds, which they are grateful for, but it does not go far enough. And despite debate after debate in this House, what the government still doesn't seem to understand is that a farmer earning a small yield from land worth millions on paper only can only cover the inheritance they they can't cover the inheritance tax liability unless they sell the land. If the government would prefer farmers to sell their land rather than farming it, they should just say so. If not, they should acknowledge that the incentives their family farm tax creates are simply wrong. Under their plans, a 20% charge still applies on land that often yields only 1 or 2% a year, but which is vital for them to help us feed the nation.

And the rules have changed twice in 14 months. You cannot plan a farm succession or a business succession over a generation when the tax rules change every budget. The same is true of course of a family business, the engineering firm, the builders' merchant, the garden center. Up and down the country, great family businesses, they cannot plan their succession when they don't have certainty in the rules. I absolutely give way.

05:43:34 - 05:44:03

Ashley Peter Fox

I'm grateful to my honorable friend for giving way. Doesn't he agree with me that it is completely iniquitous that family farms have to pay inheritance tax on their assets, and yet if those assets were owned by a foreign company or a foreign individual, no inheritance tax would be paid? Why does he think that this Labour government wants to single out British-owned family farms?

05:44:03 - 05:46:36

Blake Stephenson

My honorable friend makes an absolutely superb point, and it is beyond all comprehension on this side as to why the government would target small family businesses and small farms in the way that they have. And I thank my honorable friend for making that point. When the owner of a small business or a farm dies unexpectedly, the family should be focused on keeping the business going and the staff in work, not on raising a tax bill by selling off pieces of the business until there's nothing left. The government can't talk about growth and then take apart small businesses because an owner has died. It is completely the wrong approach.

So what would we do in government? A Conservative government will abolish inheritance tax on the family home. That is the right thing to do. We will replace today's complicated allowances with a single half a million pound allowance per person, one million pound per couple. That is the right thing to do.

And we will restore agricultural and business property in full so that no family farm or family firm is broken up to fund Labour's welfare spending. The Prime Minister says we cannot have national security without social security, an absolutely shocking statement. But we cannot have either without economic security, without an economy where people create jobs, expand businesses, buy homes, and feel the benefits of doing so. Our reforms would make sure that welfare works for British citizens, that people with lower level mental health conditions get treatment rather than being written off with a check, that more assessments are done face-to-face, and that the obligation to look for work means something. Getting people into work is good for them, good for their families, and good for the taxpayer.

Madam Deputy Speaker, in two weeks the Chancellor will deliver his first budget, and I know members on this side of the House are really looking forward to that day. Now he has a choice. He can keep taxing work, savings, and inheritance, taxing everything you own that isn't nailed down, and more besides, perhaps, let's see, to pay for a welfare bill that is truly out of control. Or he can change course, get a grip on spending, and help power the engines of growth that will make us all richer. I know which choice families in Mid Bedfordshire would make.

05:46:36 - 05:50:17

Speaker 197

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We do not only ask today how much have you got, we also ask how did you get it, did you earn it yourself or is it just been left to you by others? The estate duties provide a corrective against the development of the idle rich, and it's a far better thing to tax the accumulation of the past than to burden the industry of the present. And those aren't my words, Madam Deputy Speaker, they're the words of Winston Churchill speaking a hundred years ago. And they raise a question that remains relevant today.

Do you want a country that gives people a fair chance to get on in life, or one that keeps finding new ways to protect the wealth of those who already have the most?

Because this motion tells us exactly where the Conservative Party's priorities lie. It calls on the government to cut public spending to abolish inheritance tax, but it doesn't tell us which services they would cut, whose support they would withdraw, or which communities would pay the price. It simply says: cut public spending. Now, that's easy enough to demand when you don't have to explain what it means to people's lives. The Conservatives are asking us to approve billions of pounds in tax cuts without telling us how they would pay for them.

And that is not a serious plan. It's a tax giveaway looking for someone else to pick up the bill. They say that the proposals would cost around 6 billion pounds by 2029-30, but as we've already heard from other honourable members, once you take behavioural effects into account, the cost could be up to 10.8 billion pounds. And who, who benefits, Madam Deputy Speaker? Around 30,000 estates are expected to benefit.

Estimates suggest that around 90% of the gains would go to the wealthiest 20% of pensioner households, with around 40% going to the wealthiest 5%. Around 70% of the benefits would go to London and the South East, despite those areas accounting for only a quarter of pensioner households. Meanwhile, under the current system, fewer than one in 20 estates face an inheritance tax charge, and that figure has remained relatively stable for several decades now. So let's stop pretending that this is a tax cut for everyone. It is a substantial giveaway that disproportionately benefits the wealthiest households, at the tune of 10.8 billion pounds.

Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, nobody disputes that family farms matter, and families should be able to pass and plan for the future of those farms and of those businesses. But wrapping a policy in the language of family farms doesn't mean we shouldn't stop asking who benefits. And this proposal goes much further than targeted help. It's a wider tax break for the very wealthiest in society. And there are questions about how the policy would work in practice.

Conservatives say they want to help people pass on their homes, but what happens if these tax changes give older people a reason to stay in a larger property rather than downsize? Someone might want to sell a large home, move somewhere smaller and release money to support their retirement or help their family. But if inheritance tax treatment makes moving financially unattractive, their policy could discourage exactly the behaviour that they say they want to encourage. Very happy to give way.

05:50:17 - 05:50:23

Speaker 198

Exactly why we're abolishing stamp duty when you buy your home as well.

05:50:23 - 05:51:21

Speaker 197

Thank you. The Conservatives point to stamp duty as a barrier and promise to scrap it on a home. But removing one cost does not automatically resolve every other tax consequence, and we know that changes in tax policy are very behaviour-sensitive. Now, this is what happens when you write a policy, this is what happens when you write a policy to win a headline for a conference. And it brings me back to Churchill.

More than a century ago, he challenged the idea that inherited wealth should simply be waved through because it happened to belong to the right family. And he asked that straightforward question at the beginning: did you earn your wealth, or was it left to you? Now, of course, as honourable friends have said, people want to leave something to their children. There is nothing wrong with that. But why should the government spend billions helping those who are already wealthy pass on even more, while telling everyone else that public spending should be cut?

Happy to give way.

05:51:21 - 05:51:44

Caroline Johnson

He seems to be making a distinction between money that is earned by somebody and which is earned by the father. If a man and his daughter run a business together, and the elder, the father dies, should the daughter not inherit? Did she earn it? How much did she earn by working in that business and how did she not? And why should it matter?

Because that business employs people, people the honourable gentleman talked about, who will lose their job if the business has to close.

05:51:44 - 05:54:13

Speaker 197

If the honourable member wants to have an argument with Churchill, she may do so.

I won't join her in that. I believe he was a great man. So why should the government spend billions helping those who are already wealthy? Why should families inheriting millions take priority over families struggling with bills? And that is actually the choice at the heart of this motion.

Invest in services and support people who rely on them, or hand a huge tax break to a small minority and leave everyone else to bear the cost. And the record of the Conservatives, Madam Deputy Speaker, makes their claims of fiscal responsibility even harder to take seriously. We already know that between 2010 and 2019, the national debt increased from one trillion to 1.8 trillion pounds. That was before COVID, before the war in Ukraine. Debt to GDP increased from 69% to 84%.

And as members have pointed out, we then got treated to the Liz Truss magic with a disastrous experiment in unfunded tax cuts which sent markets into turmoil and damaged confidence in the UK. And then before the 2024 election, we had many other tax-cutting promises worth billions that did not have any credible plans set behind them on how to fund them. So here they are again with another enormous tax giveaway, but unable to tell us which public services will pay the price precisely. They have not learned the lessons of their failure. They've just found new ways to replicate them.

The public finances are not a bottomless pit that politicians can dip into whenever they fancy announcing a tax cut. Every promise has to be funded properly because it has consequences for real people. The Conservatives spent years telling people that there was no alternative to difficult decisions. Yet when it comes to their own priorities, they make the promise and leave somebody else to deal with the bill. And that's not fiscal responsibility.

That's fiscal incontinence. And their priorities are clear when we look at the two-child limit. The Conservatives have indicated that they would reinstate a policy that would push 500,000 children back into poverty, whilst at the same time today, they want to direct a substantial tax benefit towards a tiny number of wealthy estates. And that contrast, Madam Deputy Speaker, is clear. They tell families on low incomes that the country can't afford to help them, but they propose billions in tax cuts for the very wealthiest.

05:54:13 - 05:54:22

Speaker 201

And that's a choice, and it tells us who they put first in our society. Honorable members have done an excellent... I'm very happy to give way to the honorable lady.

05:54:22 - 05:54:32

Speaker 199

What proportion of people working in the private sector on low wages are employed by people who own businesses?

05:54:32 - 05:55:06

Speaker 197

As they say in Father Ted, that is an ecumenical matter, and I'm sure the minister will pick it up in his roundup. Honorable members, I'm conscious of time. Honorable members have done a great job in outlining the fantastic measures the government are taking on VAT on electricity bills, capping bus fares, the 24-hour bus travel for disabled people from next April, so I won't touch on those. All I will finish on has been the main theme, I hope, of my speech, Madam Deputy Speaker, which is today is all about one thing: tax cuts for the wealthiest, cuts to public services for everyone else. It's the same old Conservatives.

05:55:06 - 05:55:11

Speaker 200

They've not changed at all.

05:55:11 - 05:57:42

John Cooper

Madam Deputy Speaker, nothing illustrates the great divide between rural Britain and this urban-centric Labour government quite like the family farm tax. This was a comprehensive failure to grasp how intergenerational farming works, a willful failure to understand that asset-rich does not equate to cash-rich.

As evidenced by the honorable member for Tipton and Wednesbury, sadly not in her place. A chill was sent through rural Dumfries and Galloway by changes to agricultural property relief, for this was not just about farmers, but about the wider community and the many jobs intertwined with dairy and beef, pigs and sheep, arable and horticulture. Since election to this place, I have had military veterans, some of the toughest people I have ever had the privilege to meet, well up when recalling comrades lost and maimed in service of this country. A woman in tears because duff pension advice had robbed her. And I've also had farmers weeping too.

We are talking here about men in their eighties, men with hard knocks enough for many lifetimes under their belts. And those proud old men were crying not for themselves and what they thought they might lose in what little time lay ahead, but about what future generations will lose. Many families realize that no child will now take on the stark new financial reality of farming. And how incredible was it to sit in this place and watch government ministers giving advice on how to mitigate the damage their own policies were doing. Labour like to roar about the fourteen years we Conservatives had in power.

But what were they doing in their fourteen years in opposition? Precious little proper planning, clearly, because the inheritance tax changes, so toxic no one else would touch them, were dusted off in jig time amid a scramble to be seen to be doing something, anything, in that first hundred days. Inheritance tax is invidious in all its forms. The state exacting a last drop from estates gathered despite the taxman's previous depredations. It's a double taxation, for anything in the purview of HMRC on death has already come through the storm of income tax, capital gains tax, VAT.

It's why we Conservatives have pledged to reverse the cuts to agricultural property relief, abolish inheritance tax on the family home, and raise the individual threshold to five hundred thousand pounds. This will mean a couple can pass on their main home to direct descendants inheritance tax free, plus a further million pounds without any inheritance tax liability. Madam Deputy Speaker, happy to give way.

05:57:42 - 05:58:10

Neil Hudson

I'm very grateful to my honorable friend for giving way. It's people who are doing the right thing. It's farmers who feed us and look after our precious environment. It's family businesses supporting their local economy. And it's families who work hard to provide a family home.

Isn't this about fairness, that those people should be able to pass on their farms, their family businesses, their family homes to the next generation free from inheritance tax?

05:58:10 - 05:59:40

John Cooper

And I thank my honorable friend for his intervention, and he speaks to farmers far more, I think, than the Labour front bench ever do. And he knows this is indeed, it's about fairness. And we Conservatives believe in rewarding those who have done the right thing, who have strived and who have saved. And there is further positive news from our plan, highlighted by the Taxpayers' Alliance. In October 2024, the previous Chancellor of the Exchequer announced an increase in the interest rate on the late payment of taxes.

The rate had been calculated on the Bank of England base rate plus two point five percent, but the budget saw an increase to the surcharge to four percent above base. Currently, this means that the interest rate on late payment of tax is a usurious seven point seven five percent. Asset heavy, cash light taxpayers such as farmers are particularly vulnerable to this change, as it takes time to convert assets into a form which allows them to pay tax balance. Inheritance tax is due six months after death, after which interest is charged daily on unpaid tax. However, executors may struggle to meet this deadline because properties are illiquid assets that can take considerable time to sell, particularly when probate is required.

Selling properties quickly may mean accepting a lower price, while waiting for a better offer can result in additional, additional punitive interest charges. The probate process creates further difficulties, as executors often need probate to sell inherited properties, yet inheritance tax must generally be paid before probate is granted.

05:59:40 - 05:59:43

Speaker 203

Happy to give way.

05:59:43 - 06:00:06

Charles Noah Law

I'm grateful for giving way and he is making a very technical and very important set of points. But does he not accept that for businesses of the size and scale, family-owned or not, that he's talking about, that succession planning and perhaps even life insurance are very important tools that should be considered to mitigate some of the things that he's describing? I don't think that's unreasonable, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:00:06 - 06:01:17

John Cooper

And I thank the honorable gentleman for his intervention there, but he's talking about yet more costs being added onto businesses. And I've had farmers who've tried inheritance planning and they've been told that the bank will not pass on any the working overdraft to young members of the family. This is it's much more complicated than the honorable gentleman pretends. Although HMRC may allow payments in installments over 10 years or grant credit in certain circumstances, interest can still accrue after six months. This leaves taxpayers with higher bills through no fault of their own.

Conservatives allowing family homes to be excluded from inheritance tax plus that additional million pound allowance, allowance, sorry, means the effect of this pernicious interest is restricted. Meanwhile, we need to look again at agriculture to see it not as a dripping roast on which Treasury may feast, but instead as a rural powerhouse helping to feed the nation. If this government were serious about their mantra, food security is national security, they would halt the family farm tax right now and stop turning the human drama of a death into a financial crisis for the living.

06:01:17 - 06:01:18

Richard Baker.

06:01:18 - 06:01:48

Richard Baker

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know from bitter personal experience that the opportunity for a political party during a period of opposition is to reflect on what went wrong in government so you can take a different approach and seek to win the trust of the country again. Unfortunately, it appears the Conservative party are instead using their time in opposition to double down on the mistakes they made in government. Of course we must support our farms. Of course we must support our family businesses.

06:01:48 - 06:02:43

Speaker 204

But the complete abolition of inheritance tax, not only from farms, not only from family businesses, but on all family homes, does not represent sound stewardship of this nation's finances. And I'm afraid it is a proposal all too worthy of one of the key architects of Liz Truss's disastrous mini-budget. The key question for me about this proposal is what impact it would have for my constituents in Glenrothes and Mid Fife. They're already paying the price of the SNP's failures in education, their failures on health services with still too many people waiting in pain on NHS waiting lists. On the economy, too, medium and large businesses in Scotland are paying some 54 million pounds each year more in business rates than their counterparts in England.

06:02:43 - 06:05:30

Speaker 206

And if the Scottish economy under the SNP had grown at the same rate as Manchester's with Andy Burnham over the past 10 years, it would be 33 billion pounds bigger. My constituents need fiscal policies which meet their priorities, protecting both the economy and public services. And this proposal does not meet that test. The latest available figures show inheritance tax is payable on fewer than one in 20 estates. Just 1,620 of those estates were in Scotland.

In Glenrothes and Mid Fife, so few estates pay inheritance tax that HMRC withholds the figure to protect confidentiality.

So the number of people in my constituency who would benefit from this proposal is so diminishingly small, it's not possible for HMRC to publish the figures. So with so few people in Glenrothes and Mid Fife qualifying for the theoretical benefit of this policy, we must then look at the costs. And the opposition have said themselves this proposal would cost six billion pounds. But as a number of honourable friends have referred to, the Tax Policy Associates estimate that the cost could be up to nearly 11 billion pounds a year once behaviours are taken into consideration as a result of the tax change. And 40% of the benefit of this cut would go to the richest 5%.

Once again, the Conservatives are a party of the few and not the many. When we know the pressures facing UK households because of the challenges facing the global economy. When we know how the cost of living increases are affecting families across the country. When we know the challenges facing key public services like social care, how on earth could this be a policy priority? The abolition of inheritance tax, not just on farms, not just on family businesses, but on all family homes.

How could that be a priority for any government which truly had the interests of the whole country at heart? My constituents need action like those taken already by this government, like scrapping VAT on energy bills, like action on business rates, which is needed in Scotland as well, like changes to procurement to back British businesses and jobs. They don't need billions of pounds in investment in policies which will benefit precious few people in the communities I represent. Our pensioners, our older people need a government which is prepared to act on real priorities such as social care. And it's highly regrettable that the First Minister of Scotland has spent more time propagating factually incorrect statements on the proposal to adjust the triple lock rather than deal with the reality of social care in Scotland, where just as in England, people who require care support face high social care charges, social care services are under-resourced and social care workers are underpaid.

06:05:30 - 06:05:32

Speaker 207

I will give way, of course.

06:05:32 - 06:05:53

Paul Holmes

I thank him for giving way. He mentioned the government's pledge to reduce energy bills. When he stood at the election, did he exalt the policy of reducing energy bills by 300 pounds that was put forward by the former Prime Minister? And now that he's withdrawn the, now that he's reduced them by 45 pounds, does he apologise for the bit that he hasn't delivered on?

06:05:53 - 06:06:34

Speaker 206

We're already acting. We've already cut VAT from, abolished VAT from energy bills. And what we're not going to do is invest up to 11 billion pounds in priorities which don't represent the needs of people who are facing those high energy bills at the moment. It is this government which is showing it is prepared to take action on the real priorities for my constituents and this country. And the spending proposals from the opposition, these proposals show regrettably just how far they remain from being a credible party of government again.

06:06:34 - 06:10:17

Gagan Mohindra

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Every day, millions of hardworking people work, earn and contribute to our economy with the principal goal of providing for their children, both in the present and in the future. For many, these jobs are much more than a payslip. They are the pillars that allow a family to function, grow and thrive. As a former family business owner, I know just how valuable such opportunities can be.

Today's debate is important, not simply because it's about business, but because it's about protecting opportunity. It is about ensuring that the next generation has the chance to develop the skills, confidence and experience that will shape the rest of their lives and careers. I spent my summer on my annual work experience tour of South West Hertfordshire, visiting local businesses to volunteer my time and understand how they operate, and also to learn about the challenges they face. In Kings Langley, I went to Wayside Farm to shadow Charlie, who has been running the farm for over 30 years, one of only two dairy farms remaining in Hertfordshire. I pulled pints behind the bar of the Unicorn at Abbots Langley run by Debbie and Addie, with Debbie starting as an employee, learning all about the pub before taking over.

This is exactly the sort of entrepreneurship we should be encouraging. I visited Unit 7 in Ricky, an artisan coffee shop owned by married couple Raman and Zureena, who also host community-focused events for my residents. Finally, I visited a car parts store in King's Langley, a family-owned business which has grown so successfully that they've opened more stores and employed people across the country, helping both the local economy in my constituency, but I'm sure many other MPs in this chamber. All of them repeated the same message. Labour's harmful policies, increasing national insurance contributions, strict rules and regulations, energy costs soaring, means these small independent businesses are now having to make difficult decisions about hiring and looking at opening hours, when they should be supported and encouraged to grow their businesses instead.

Labour have also reduced opportunities for young people to get their foot on the career ladder. Hospitality businesses in particular, who have historically relied upon seasonal work and training young people up, can no longer afford to do so, meaning our young people are going without opportunities that should shape the rest of their lives. Growth happens when family businesses have the confidence to invest, expand, and create jobs. That is why this government must work with businesses, not against them, and why the Conservatives would abolish the high rates of inheritance tax on farms, homes, and businesses which support economic growth and local communities. We would abolish business rates for thousands of retail, hospitality, and leisure businesses, cut the red tape that stops employers recruiting young people, and introduce our cheap power plan, which would cut electricity bills by 20% for businesses.

In conclusion, this debate is ultimately about opportunity. My residents should not work hard to provide for their children's future only to have that investment taken away to pay for an ever-increasing welfare bill. Every family business is a testament to community, to innovation, and to shared prosperity, and these opportunities are worth protecting. And I'm incredibly proud of all the family-run businesses I have in South West Hertfordshire. I urge the government to recognise the damage that they are doing to these family businesses and to work tirelessly to ensure that my residents are not punished for a life of hard work.

06:10:17 - 06:11:36

Charles Noah Law

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The party opposite's decision to cut inheritance tax for the wealthiest tells us exactly where their priorities lie, not with the everyday working man or woman, but with the wealthiest in our society, not with constituents like mine in St Austell and Newquay, but the wealthiest 4% or so of those whose estates are affected by inheritance tax. The Conservatives' proposal would allow couples to leave their children a million pounds of wealth on top of a potentially very large home without paying a penny in tax. And they claim that we're the party of wealth, but what does that make them, Madam Deputy Speaker? Tax cuts for the wealthiest, paid for with spending cuts that take our country's public services backwards.

They tried that for 14 years, and it left our country poorer, sicker, and economically stagnant. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is clear they haven't learned their lesson. Arguing for its effective abolition sends a very different message to what could be a much more reasonable debate about perhaps, say, uprating the threshold for inheritance tax in line with inflation. I will take an intervention.

06:11:36 - 06:11:50

Christopher John Vince

Thank you for taking the intervention. He's making a really powerful speech. Wouldn't he agree with me, actually, the argument for the party opposite would be far stronger if they focused, as many of their speakers are, on family business and on family farms? But actually, what this motion is talking about is the abolition of all inheritance tax, including on estates.

06:11:50 - 06:11:53

Speaker 210

That actually weakens their argument, surely.

06:11:53 - 06:12:12

Charles Noah Law

Quite right. And Madam Deputy Speaker, this is not pragmatic at all. This is complete ideology and and just returning to... It is, it's pure ideology, Madam Deputy Speaker, returning to their core comfort zone of defending only the very wealthiest at the expense of all the rest of us. I will give way.

06:12:12 - 06:12:54

Rebecca Smith

The honorable member from my neighboring county, and I think his constituents will be quite shocked at him accusing the Conservatives of being ideological, when if you happen to be someone in St Austell and his constituency in Cornwall, where's the aspiration for those people to grow those family businesses, to expand their family farm? Ultimately, his constituency is incredibly similar to mine, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm no doubt some of the properties there are incredibly expensive and the salaries are not. And I would just like to challenge him that his constituents are going to have heard him say this afternoon that they are fine with this and that he is just tackling us from a point of ideology.

06:12:54 - 06:13:23

Charles Noah Law

Madam Deputy Speaker, I I respect the point she's making and I respect fully what she's saying about the aspirations of those of us that grow up in rural areas where property prices are often inflated. But I'll be honest, Madam Deputy Speaker, I know very few people in my personal experience from back home that have ever paid inheritance tax. I'll just be honest, I don't know these people. So if if she'd like to correct me on on that for our own... I will give way to the honorable lady and then to the honorable gentleman.

06:13:23 - 06:13:54

Caroline Johnson

My only point of ideology, and I think I've tried to get my interventions this afternoon, is an understanding from those benches over there opposite that actually inheritance tax penalizes people at all levels because if if a business doesn't if people don't start a business because it's not worth the bother, or they don't invest because it's going to be taken off them, or they can't pass it on to their children and as a result the business has to be sold and the jobs are lost, people don't have jobs and employment and everyone is affected.

06:13:54 - 06:14:26

Charles Noah Law

Madam Deputy Speaker, it's objectively untrue that this penalizes people at all levels. It penalizes at best four or five percent of people with the wealthiest estates. So I do look, I understand the sort of cultural arguments that they're making about aspiration and all the rest. We should all strive to support that. But as my right honorable friend, my honorable friend for Harlow pointed out, this is not pragmatic at all.

This is this is bonkers, Madam Deputy Speaker. And moving on, I mean, I would say that arguing for... I will give way to to my honorable friend.

06:14:26 - 06:14:56

Speaker 76

Honorable friend, my honorable friend for Macclesfield referred to Shakespeare. I think to to Winston Churchill, I often like to refer to Shakespeare because I think that goes a little bit above. And Shakespeare said, no legacy is so rich as honesty. And would my honorable friend agree with me that this debate from the other side is dishonest? They left the finances of this country in a mess and they've got to be honest about it and face up to it.

06:14:56 - 06:16:03

Charles Noah Law

Madam Deputy Speaker, we would do far better to have a pragmatic debate as my honorable friend suggests about perhaps perhaps we should look at uprating the thresholds. Perhaps we should look to to bring in more tax revenue through some of the means that the Treasury is already exploring. So I'd be keen to hear in the minister's remarks winding up about some progress on that because this government is already investing 1.7 billion in pounds in improving the efficiency of tax collection, cracking down on tax avoidance, and and that should yield an extra seven and a half billion pounds a year by 2029 to 2030.

Aren't these the kind of discussions we should be having, Madam Deputy Speaker, rather than just encouraging more and more tax avoidance by people who quite frankly can afford to pay their way? It should be clear to all those on all sides of the house that the answer to the very richest avoiding taxes is to legislate against those loopholes and not to cut taxes for them, which is exactly what a would-be Tory government is proposed to do.

06:16:03 - 06:18:37

Robbie Moore

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I, like I'm sure all members of this house, do an incredible amount of outreach with many of those family businesses that we are lucky to represent as constituency MPs, from our manufacturers, our engineers, our garden centers, our breweries, our hoteliers, our farmers. And they are telling me constantly that from the last two budgets alone, business and operating business in this country is difficult. We've seen the increase in employers' national insurance, minimum wage increasing and therefore everyone that's over and above that minimum wage wanting the increased differential over and above that. We've seen business rates now applying much more strongly than what they were ever doing under the last Conservative government.

We've seen the Employment Rights Act now effectively making it much more challenging for an employer to take on an individual and offer that young person an opportunity. And when my inbox, as I'm sure many on this side of the house and probably on the other side of the house, has been filled from emails from those representing those with disabilities and those with special educational needs now struggling to get a job because of the Employment Rights Act making it much more difficult, it's challenging. And then of course we have the additional issue of the inheritance tax changes, which impacts all family businesses. We rightly had a huge amount of pressure being put on this government for increasing the threshold initially, but ultimately wanting the relief for the 100% relief of agricultural property relief and business property relief to go in. And we saw movement from the threshold of a million pounds to two and a half million.

And we now have this bizarre scenario that if you're in a married scenario, the threshold will be five million, the first time ever that we've seen a differential happening under IHT. But the reality of this scenario is it's stifled investment. Because many of those manufacturing, engineering businesses in my constituency are now saying rather than investing in that growth that we were wanting to do over the next five, ten years that we'd already programmed that in, we are now stopping it. Because we are now having to think about mitigating a tax liability at 20% over and above the two and a half million pound that we weren't programming into place, which now is ultimately having an impact on growth in my constituency in Keighley. And I will give way.

06:18:37 - 06:18:58

Speaker 32

I'm very grateful to the honorable member for giving way. I refer to my register of interest because I've been involved with a family farm and also have created a family business. One of the really odd aspects of this is that the government seems to be confusing business assets with personal wealth. How can that possibly be fair?

06:18:58 - 06:20:43

Robbie Moore

My honorable friend makes an excellent point because this was exactly the narrative that his farmers put to me when I was lucky enough to visit them in Norfolk early or late last week. Because there is, if you're running a family business, the rate of return on your capital is maybe a percent, but you're lucky if you're getting a percent. Therefore there is no return and therefore when you are taking the valuation of that farm on death, not just of the farmland, but the maybe a farmhouse, a cottage or two, the growing crops, the stocks in store, the machinery, the livestock, you are well above that threshold of two and a half million pounds or of five million pounds if you are in married status, therefore subjecting your farming business to a liability.

And it is tough. Which is why I was so shocked when the Liberal Democrats today voted not well didn't actually vote, not one Liberal Democrat MP voted against the implementation of the fertilizer tax today, making it much more difficult for those family farming businesses. And then there was the cliff edge that took place in April of '26 this year, where there was no real warning that was given to many of those family businesses. It was a cruel cliff edge that existed. And as a matter of fact, and it gives me no pleasure in saying this, lives have been lost as a result of the decisions that this Labour government has made.

As a matter of fact, as a result of a coroner's report, there has been suicide as a result of this Labour government's choices through the implementation of the inheritance tax changes.

06:20:43 - 06:20:45

Speaker 211

I will give way.

06:20:45 - 06:21:18

John Lamont

My honorable friend's making an excellent speech. I wonder if he's spotted this quote: "Although many of my farmers tell me that earlier U-turns made a substantial difference, others are still deeply worried about the impact this inheritance tax policy will have when a sustainable farm business is being passed on to the next generation." My honorable friend might be aware that these are the words of the member for Penrith and the Solway, the Labour member for Penrith and the Solway's part of his calls for the Labour government to completely scrap their plans to abolish agricultural property relief. He's right. The Labour government should scrap this completely.

06:21:18 - 06:21:45

Robbie Moore

Absolutely right. And it's good to see the member for Penrith and the border in the chamber today. And I hope that he will intervene and make his points clear in this debate, that he is also advocating for this cruel tax to be scrapped as we are on this benches. It is hope that there is at least one individual as I see it on the other side that is willing to be bold enough to stand up against this Labour government. And I will take an intervention.

06:21:45 - 06:22:18

Scott Arthur

Thank you. And I do thank him for the intervention. I regret that you've talked about suicide in this debate. But I do ask, I do ask, sorry, I apologize, I apologize. Madam Deputy Speaker, I regret that the honorable gentleman's talked about suicide in this debate.

But I do ask, where was he when we had reports of austerity implemented by his government causing suicides? Where is anybody on the opposition benches willing, willing to defend, willing to defend that record? Invoking suicide in this debate, you have to also acknowledge your own record.

06:22:18 - 06:25:01

Robbie Moore

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I also regret the fact that I'm talking about it. But the reality of the scenario that has been created, despite the clear warnings being given to this government by many of those farming representatives from the NFU, the CLA, the Tenant Farmers Association, was very clear that if this tax had the cliff edge associated with it did in April 2026, that there was there was going to be emotional consequences, anxiety consequences. And as a matter of fact, unfortunately, and I regret that I have brought it up, but it is absolutely the case that suicide has taken place. And we have a moment of hope in hopefully two weeks' time when the budget comes before this House, that the government could bring in the 100% relief for APR and BPR again.

And I strongly advocate the government to do so, to listen to those strong calls from the industry. And he asks where I was. Well, I've only been a Member of Parliament for nearly six and a bit years. So before that, I was not in this place making any of those decisions.

The point also, Madam Deputy Speaker, with the changes within inheritance tax is the implementation of it. Because the tax first point will be due within six months of death, and when we are now having to value the asset base, there will inevitably be challenges that are put before us. There is not the capacity within the district valuers to be able to challenge the level of challenge that will come forward to them by many of those that are representing probate valuations that will inevitably take place. It worries me that as the course over the last two years when the IHT debate has been taking place in this House, that there has not been hardly any Labour MPs standing up on behalf of their many manufacturing, engineering, hotelier businesses, advocating for those businesses that I suspect are employing many, many of their constituents and providing them with their salaries and their opportunities to continue within a working environment. That worries me because I fear that the narrative has been lost on the Labour benches.

We've got time before this budget for that narrative to change, and I firmly stand with our position that the 100% relief for APR and BPR must go back in place, and I advocate the Government to listen and do something about it.

06:25:01 - 06:28:46

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There is a principle at the heart of this motion and it is a simple one: that what a person earns through a lifetime of work belongs to them and not the Treasury. And that when that time's come, they have the right to pass on what they have earned to the people they love. This is neither a loophole, nor is it a privilege. It is the oldest instinct there is: to work, to save, and leave your children better off than you were.

And this stands in stark contrast with the Government. The question we put before the House today is not complicated: should Government spend less so families can keep more? And on this side of the House, the answer is yes. In the Mandelson files this summer, the Right Honourable Member for Wolverhampton South East, the current Work and Pensions Secretary, wrote to Peter Mandelson: "Every meeting I have is who can we tax in order to pay benefits to others." He was right to be exasperated.

Seven million people, over 10% of our population, now claim at least one benefit. We will spend over 100 billion pounds on health and disability benefits just this year. A full-time worker on National Living Wage takes home 22,500. Someone out of work on credit with the average housing support and personal independence payments receives 25,000 a year. We now pay more to not work than to work.

But then if you have worked, and when that worker dies, her unspent pension will now be taxed because of this Government. The house she spent her life paying for will be taxed. And it beggars belief that Labour MPs looked at these figures and recognized how they are strangling our country and concluded that they would rebel against these modest reforms proposed by the last Prime Minister. Indeed, the party opposite would rather remove a sitting Prime Minister than attempt to create a fairer system. Now imagine you're a farmer in the communities I serve, up at the crack of dawn, working until very, very late, it is relentless every day.

Your profit margins are the lowest of almost any industry. But you persevere because you value the land, your family's connection to it, and you take pride in feeding our country. But Labour, they hit you with increased road taxes on double-cab pickup trucks, increased employer NIC contributions and minimum wage, taxes on fertilizers, and of course the cruel family farm tax.

And now a levy on the land itself when it passes from parent to child. In Lincolnshire and Rutland, we are the breadbasket and agricultural heartland of Britain, and we are proud of what we do to feed this country. So when the Nature Minister says traditional rural Britain, the pubs, ale and loyal dogs we adore, are a far-right fantasy that never really existed, it is offensive. And I would invite her or any Labour MP to come visit Rutland, Stamford and the Harborough and South Kesteven villages, because we are not a fantasy. We are communities who deserve respect, although if I came from her constituency, I'd also consider it a fantasy to see the type of idyllic life that we lead in our villages.

We will never apologize for valuing the traditions and way of life that makes our rural communities so special. Now the Nature Minister was wrong when she claimed that rural pubs never really existed. She would, however, have been correct if she said that she and her government are doing their best to wipe them out of existence. The Bertie Arms in Uffington, under Labour's plans, face a 2,000% increase in business rates by 2029, 2,000%. The hardworking landlady has dismissed the minor relief which came as tokenistic and says it will make no difference because of Labour's other tax hikes.

06:28:46 - 06:28:48

Speaker 215

I will very happily give way on that point.

06:28:48 - 06:29:11

Daisy Cooper

I would agree with the honorable lady that the business rates increases under this government are very damaging, but she will of course remember that her government, previous government, had also pledged to reform business rates fundamentally and completely failed to do so. Does she understand why businesses across the country are fed up with both the Conservatives and Labour on this point?

06:29:11 - 06:32:12

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

We took action, I'm grateful to have a chance to my record. We cut employee national insurance twice, taking 9 million workers out of it. We raised the national insurance threshold. We abolished the lifetime allowance. We cut fuel duty, business rates relief for hospitality and for pubs.

All of these things we did to support our pubs and businesses. Now the Prime Minister told the voters of Mansfield that the family tax needs looking at again. So I wonder whether members sat in this chamber who've also supported it this week will be regretting their words in a few weeks' time. Let us see. Now since the new Prime Minister took office, his frontbench has excitedly chatted about reindustrialization as if the word on its own builds a factory.

It does not. Nor does taxing a business the moment it passes to the next generation. For in April, the family firms in my communities like Rutland Plastics, Coles Plant, Arnold Wills, C.S. Ellis, the Rutland Garden Village, or independent family shops on my high street like Harrison and Dunn or Walker's Bookshops, will all face the same death tax as our wonderful farmers like Percy Gilman. Business property relief existed for a reason, so that a company need never be broken up to pay the Treasury. And these same businesses are not just economic powerhouses in communities like mine, but as Philippa Wills said to me this morning, they are social powerhouses because they are rooted in our communities and they make decisions for the longer term because they care about what happens to our people, to our communities and to our towns.

Now the government doesn't care about this because they've broken the social contract between businesses and our young people and those in part-time work, because they've made it so much harder to hire them. And who loses out most apart from young people? Women, because it is women who rely on part-time employment when raising their children who are now unable to pick up additional work. And that is the true cost of this tax. Not the 15 billion a year they forecast it will raise by 2030, it's the businesses never started, the capital that leaves, and the women and young children left without jobs.

Now tax cuts must be paid for and that is why we have put spending cuts first. But if you, let's be very clear, if you tax the family firm at death and the founder sells early, moves abroad or never builds at all, if you tax the farm, the fields go to the solar developer or they're built upon and we become reliant on foreign imports.

Tax the people who work and pay the people who don't and don't be surprised when fewer people work. We want people to work. We want people to be able to celebrate and benefit from a lifetime of toil and hard work and that is human nature and nothing to be ashamed of. You have a government who is asking whom it can tax, an opposition asking how much more you can keep. So Labour's assault on farms and businesses, their insistence that rural life doesn't exist and their addiction to spending will destroy this country.

We want people to succeed and we hold close to our hearts our rural way of life and that is why everyone today must support this motion.

06:32:12 - 06:32:13

Gregory Stafford.

06:32:13 - 06:34:47

Gregory James Stafford

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And whilst I'm following a vast number of extraordinarily excellent speeches from this side of the chamber, unfortunately I'm going to have to start with some of the really quite stunning comments from the government benches, comments that clearly demonstrate that the government has absolutely no clue about what creates wealth in this country, what drives growth in our economy and what real people who are working hard have to face out in Britain every single day. And no such, there was no such greater example of this than from the honourable member for Macclesfield who I notice has just shuffled out of the chamber. He had the audacity to quote Churchill and to call the people who are working hard in this country, the people who are grafting hard, he misquoted Churchill and called them the idle rich. What a disgraceful thing to say to those people who are building a business.

What a disgraceful thing to say to the farmers who are up at the crack of dawn trying to make their businesses work. He should come back to the chamber and apologise to them because he deserves it. I prefer another Churchill quote. Churchill said socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance and the gospel of envy. And we've seen a lot of failure, ignorance and envy from the government benches today.

Because the real people who are going to be hit by these taxes aren't those idle rich that the honourable member for Macclesfield mentioned, they are the grafters who put in. People like my father's family who ran a business for over a century in Haslemere. They worked hard, they took risks, they saved, they stood on their own two feet. And these are the sort of people this Labour government has decided that they want to tax to the hilt, tax out of existence. For decades, business property relief meant a family firm could pass to the next generation without a bill.

This government ended that. Relief was capped at one million in 2024, only after a backlash did it rise to 2.5 million pounds of combined business and agricultural property relief. But as, as my honourable friend from Broadland and Fakenham said, businesses isn't, aren't a bank account, cash and capital are two different things. Its value is in its premises, its machinery, its stock and its goodwill, not necessarily in cash. So the people who inherit it must find money from the very businesses that employ their staff and extend growth.

06:34:47 - 06:34:50

Speaker 217

Think of an owner, I will.

06:34:50 - 06:35:02

Gavin Williamson

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. Does my honourable friend fear like I do that you'll see so many more family firms being sold and often sold to foreign buyers, people who have no interest in investing for the long term and investing in local communities?

06:35:02 - 06:35:52

Gregory James Stafford

My right honourable friend is absolutely right. In my constituency and I'm sure in his and I'm sure across the country, small family businesses are having to make that really tough decision about what they are going to do. And he is right that they will often go to foreign firms because those won't be hit by these level of taxes. And that is really an odd way for this Labour government to focus, to hit British businesses so that they will be sold to foreign ones. Extraordinary, and the government if it doesn't see it must really think.

So if I was going back to think of an owner in their 60s deciding, I don't know, whether to buy a new machine or to take on another apprentice, now they must first ask, what will this do to my tax bill that my children will inherit? A tax, as the right honourable member said, a tax that makes owners think twice before investing to build growth.

06:35:52 - 06:35:53

Will he give way?

06:35:54 - 06:36:11

Caroline Johnson

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. My husband is a farmer and runs businesses, and I know that he feels a huge responsibility not just in terms of building his business, but also to the people that he employs. And is it not those that will get affected as well if the business does not grow, does not invest, because it's worried about this tax?

06:36:11 - 06:40:22

Gregory James Stafford

Well, my honourable friend is absolutely right, and she neatly brings me on to some comments on family farms. But she is right. It is not just the people who are running these businesses, it's not just those people who may inherit them, but it is the employees of those businesses who will end up losing out. And that is why we are not getting the growth that Labour claims it wants. So moving on to that family farm, like Luffs in Headley, land, tractors, buildings, and a lifetime of labour is passed from generation to generation.

Now, the National Farmers' Union calculated that a typical cereals farm making roughly £34,000 a year would face 10 annual instalments of £53,000 a year at the original £1 million threshold. Even at the new threshold, payments of £33,000 a year would swallow nearly all of the profit. So essentially, to pay, a farmer will have to sell the very fields that earn the living. Now, the Royal Agricultural Benevolent Institution found that over a third of farmers are probably or possibly depressed. The Farming Community Network, which supports over 10,000 people, says its helpline has been taking calls linked to the upcoming budget for weeks.

I think, as my honourable friend for Keighley and Ilkley said, this tax has led to suicides, and that is an absolute disgrace. And the government should recognise that and do everything it can to repair the damage that it has done emotionally and economically to our farms. And it was only when ministers were challenged by my right honourable friend the shadow environment secretary that they raised that threshold. So if it was right to raise the threshold then because it was the wrong threshold, can the government now not look at it again and remove it again? Now moving on briefly to the general inheritance tax points.

The nil-rate band has been at £325,000 since 2009. Labour has now said it's going to freeze it until April of 2031. Now, had it risen with inflation, it would be worth over half a million pounds today. And to dispel the myth that's been put forward by the other side that this affects only a small number of people, the OBR expects one in 10 estates to pay by the end of the decade, and the IFS, the Institute for Fiscal Studies, put that figure at one in six. So this is not something that would just hit a very small number of people.

A married couple of course can pass on up to £1 million if their home goes to their children. Now, that might sound generous, but until you add a family home in my constituency to a lifetime of savings, from April 27th their pension pots, this is not a significant amount of money in the grand scheme of things, especially when that pension relief is what we on all sides of this House were telling people to do, telling people to save for their future. And the reward for their saving now is for the government to take more of it in tax. Households that never thought of themselves as wealthy are being pulled in. Under Labour, aspirational families are hit on the way in, and unfortunately they're hit on the way out.

And as honourable members said, the shopkeeper sells their business to fund a retirement, and the farmer sells the field in order to try and keep just a small measure of their farm. So I say to the minister on the Treasury bench, he must take this message back to the Chancellor. Rule out these changes and make things better for our local areas.

As a Conservative opposition, we present an alternative. We will abolish tax on the family home and we will do that by slashing the welfare bill by seven billion pounds. This is a first step and I know that the Shadow Chancellor has outlined his aspiration and the leader of the opposition has done the same in order to go further. Madam Deputy Speaker, this comes down to a fundamental point. On the one side, we have a government that sees a lifetime of savings, a business built over generations, as just another tax opportunity.

On the other, we have an opposition that believes those savings belong to the family that earned them. Not the grifters, not the idle rich, the grafters. They built this country and unlike Labour, a Conservative government will let them keep it.

06:40:22 - 06:40:25

Speaker 219

And with an immediate five-minute time limit, Rebecca Smith.

06:40:25 - 06:45:05

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And following on from my colleague, the honourable member for Farnham and Bordon, he's set out a huge amount of what I would like to continue talking about, not least the constant referral to the wealthy that we have heard in this debate this afternoon, which quite frankly is offensive to any single person who is out there working and in many cases not earning very much money, but spending a lot of that money to save and work tirelessly to be able to buy a property, to be able to invest it in a business, to be able to do the right thing. And quite frankly, that will be the one thing I take away from today is this absolute generalization that anybody that we represent is somehow wealthy and anybody that they represent is somehow not is just a complete fallacy and a complete disdain for working people. Indeed, we heard the member for Hornsey and Friern Barnet imply that anybody who was not solely reliant on the state pension is earning a lot. That's a complete preposterous thing to say.

For many families, Madam Deputy Speaker, buying a home is the biggest financial commitment they will ever make. It involves decades of saving, of mortgage repayments and sacrifices along the way. The Conservative pledge to abolish inheritance tax on the family home would therefore ensure that families are not penalized for passing on the home they have worked so hard to earn, often at the expense of doing other things. And we know full well that people on benefits are able to get all sorts of discounts for things, but it's the hardworking families across the country who don't go to theme parks at discounted rates because they're paying their mortgage or indeed saving for one in the first place. We will also raise the general inheritance tax allowance to five hundred thousand pounds per person or one million for a married couple.

Now crucially, Madam Deputy Speaker, this increased allowance will also benefit those who are unmarried or do not have children. Currently, if you are a single person, you are only able to get the three hundred and twenty-five thousand pound limit on your inheritance tax, which I think is completely wrong for all the many single people out there who work hard, who sometimes have money because they also have inherited that has also had tax paid on it at multiple points. And I hear from single constituents in my patch who are just so frustrated with the way that they are expected time and time again to pay tax to pay for everybody else. Now our proposal will give them greater freedom to leave more of what they have earned to the people who matter most to them, whether that's a sibling, a niece, a nephew or another loved one. And this is not, as I've already said, about the very wealthy who already use trusts and other mechanisms to protect their assets.

This is about helping normal families who have seen the price of their family home shoot up over the years, tipping them over the threshold for inheritance tax through no fault of their own. And indeed in my own conservative constituency, the so-called wealthy part of South West Devon, the Plymouth median salary is thirty-six and a half thousand pounds. Plymouth is generally seen as quite poor. Well the West Devon and South Hams part of my constituency sees a median salary of between twenty-six and a half thousand and thirty thousand pounds. They are hardly wealthy people.

Inheritance tax has become a tax for normal people who live on new build estates, not fancy people who have estates, as my honourable friend the member for Harborough, Oadby and Wigston has rightly said. Whilst just 2.7% of homes were faced with an inheritance tax bill in 2009 to 2022, sorry, in 2009 to 2010, this could rise to 8.2% in 2029 to 2023, according to research by Oxford Economics. Now this issue is particularly relevant to the South Hams part of my constituency, where the average home costs 355,000 pounds, the third highest figure in the South West. In Wembury, Brixton and Newton Ferrers, the median property sold for over 360,000 pounds in the last year, rising to over 520,000 pounds for detached homes. Indeed in Ivybridge, a property has recently just sold for almost 420,000 pounds.

Many of these properties were bought decades ago for considerably less, yet the basic inheritance tax threshold has remained frozen, as we have heard. And we've also covered the pension increase, where pension funds are going to go into inheritance tax calculations. Now scrapping inheritance tax on family homes is about strengthening the social contract, the invisible bond between those who came before us, those who are here today and those who will follow, those great words of Edmund Burke. Now Conservatives want to protect this partnership. We are backing parents who save responsibly and want their children and grandparents, children and grandchildren to benefit from the sacrifices they have made.

I will give way.

06:45:05 - 06:45:17

Charles Noah Law

She's made a point about the invisible bond between families, but does she not agree that that bond must also apply for the community and the public more generally from generation to generation?

06:45:17 - 06:46:08

Rebecca Smith

I thank the honourable member for his intervention. I think that's called general taxation, and those people have paid that throughout their entire working lives. Why are we now targeting them at the point at which they die, or indeed inherit money? I just don't think that is a workable opinion to hold on that, and I deeply disagree. Conservatives want to protect the social contract.

We are backing parents who have saved responsibly and want their children and grandchildren to benefit from the sacrifices they have made. This stands in stark contrast, as we have heard, to Labour, who are widening the inheritance tax net ever further by sucking in family farms, pensions and family businesses. As Conservatives, Madam Deputy Speaker, we believe that hard work should be rewarded. Families who have done the right thing should be able to pass something on to the next generation.

06:46:08 - 06:47:26

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And one of the liberating elements of speaking at this stage of the debate is that all the excellent and eminently sensible points have already been made, so you can do a sort of assorted highlight of the best bits that come out of it. But it did make me reflect that perhaps if we all took a bit of a stroll down to Clapham and got on to the omnibus and spoke to the man and woman who had alighted it, I suspect their vision of this country would not be the same as the purported utopia that we've heard from the government benches today. I suspect if you asked them what do they want to see from a tax system, they would want to see something that doesn't unnecessarily, isn't unnecessarily detrimental to any single group. They would want to see something that shouldn't be punitive in its intent.

And fundamentally, it shouldn't be something that disincentivises those who have done the right thing. And if we look across the tax landscape in this country, it has become far too complicated and burdensome. We look at the number of tax codes, we're now at more than 20,000 pages when you compare it to 1997 when it was less than 5,000. I will give way.

06:47:26 - 06:47:48

Scott Arthur

I've never been on a Clapham omnibus, but I do expect there may well be people in low-paid jobs on that who are struggling with the cost of living crisis. But when he's speaking to people on the omnibus, do they tell him that they want people who are inheriting properties of around half a million pound and more to pay less tax? Is that the answer to the problems these people face on the Clapham omnibus? Is that what they're saying?

06:47:48 - 06:48:38

Neil Shastri-Hurst

I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman for his intervention. I'd recommend that he does get on the Clapham omnibus because I think it gives a great opportunity to have your finger on the pulse of the British public.

And I think most of them will say that they want a fair system. So when they've worked and they've strived and they've built up a legacy for the next generation, they have something to hand down, because that is the most loving thing you can do. You have built up a business. I have not been in the position where I've built up a family business or run a family farm. I can't imagine the stresses and strains that that involves.

But these individuals want to understandably hand that down to the next generation, and we need them to hand it down to the next generation, because if we do not have the farmers of tomorrow and the generation after that, we do not have the food on the table that we enjoy today and we hope that our children will enjoy in years to come. I will give way.

06:48:38 - 06:48:48

Speaker 221

The honourable gentleman talks about sticking up for farmers when his party negotiated trade deals with Australia and New Zealand which undermined farmers in the UK.

06:48:48 - 06:52:03

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Well, I'm grateful to the honourable lady for her intervention. I just fundamentally don't agree with the point that she's making. And I suspect the farmers in this country will be wondering why her party has not stood up for farmers over fertilizers only today. Well, from a sedentary position, I think my honourable friend has a very valid point. But let us not kid ourselves.

This debate has been framed as though we're in some sort of Dickensian model of the ultra-rich and the idle rich and the poor who are propping up this state. That is not the truth. The reality is those who are very rich will inevitably, as my honourable friend has said, put their affairs into trust and escape this very provision. What we are talking about in this case are very much those who are just about managing, those who are trying to earn a crust, who are trying to support their family, very much that middle class that get caught, who go out to work every day to try and provide for their families. And if I look at the average property price in my own constituency of Solihull West and Shirley, it is now 345,000 pounds.

These are not the toffs that are often derived by the benches opposite. These are people who get up every morning, often work one or two jobs in order to provide for their family. It is by virtue of property prices being pushed up, and yet the threshold for an inheritance tax remaining the same, that has tripped people into this. So the reality is this tax is not operating as it was intended to do so. It is not capturing the individuals it was intending to do so.

It is capturing the ordinary man and woman. And the fact that the government have then frozen the threshold until 2031, a threshold that was first put in place in 2009, will mean that compared to the period 2001 to 2024 where only 4% of deaths were captured by this particular tax, by 2030, 9.5% of deaths will be captured by it. And we compare ourselves to other nations within other OECD nations. Of those 38 OECD nations, 18 do not pay an inheritance tax at all, Australia, Canada, New Zealand amongst them. Of the remaining 20, none of them have it at such a punitive rate as we have here.

The purpose of a tax system is of course to help fund our public services, but it also has to be fair. It has to be sensible and it has to be aspirational in its intent. It has to be there to ensure that those who strive and work hard are not penalized as a consequence. And I'm afraid the direction of travel by this government is simply taking those that do work hard, our family farms, our family businesses and others, it's simply taking them out by the knee.

06:52:03 - 06:54:13

Lewis Cocking

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I want to support the family home, the family farms and small businesses right across the United Kingdom and back this motion before us this afternoon. It is a fundamental conservative principle. As Margaret Thatcher once said, freedom flourishes when people can rely on the security of owning their own home. In that same speech, Mrs. Thatcher also made the very important point relevant to today's debate.

She said that a home is more than a financial asset. It is a stake in the future and it's something to be passed on to the next generation. That's why inheritance tax matters. As we have heard, when someone dies, 40% of their money and property is taken by the taxman if the total value exceeds 325,000. By raising the threshold, honorable members from all sides of this house have accused us of cutting taxes for the wealthiest in our society.

Well, I can tell them that the constituents that I represent in Broxbourne are certainly not some of the wealthiest in our society. In fact, there are parts of my constituency that rank among the most deprived in the UK. But despite that, average house prices across Broxbourne are 433,000. Houses just over the threshold in my constituency include a two-bed maisonette in Cheshunt, a two-bed bungalow in Hoddesdon. Madam Deputy Speaker, those properties are not mansions.

Homeowners in Broxbourne have worked hard to live in those places and it's not their fault that property values have risen by more than 10% in the last five years. And on those trends are pulling more and more ordinary families into paying inheritance tax. And what's making it worse is Labour are freezing the threshold until 2031. By then, one in six families will be faced with paying an inheritance tax bill. I believe this is wrong.

And as my honorable friend, the Shadow Secretary of State, has set out that we would completely abolish inheritance tax on the family home and raise the threshold to a million pounds for a couple. We have a clear plan. I will give way.

06:54:13 - 06:54:30

Markus Campbell-Savours

I just wondered because I've not read it anywhere, is there a cap on the value of that family home which is going to be exempt? For example, would the penthouse at One Hyde Park, which sold for around 175 million, be completely exempt?

06:54:30 - 06:54:46

Lewis Cocking

If the honorable member listens to my speech, it is not the people's fault. If you work hard and buy a family home, you have no idea what that value of that family home is going to be when you die. That is why we are exempting the family home from the inheritance tax. We have, I will give way.

06:54:46 - 06:55:19

Graham Stuart

I'm very grateful to my honorable friend. He'll remember that the Social Democratic Center-Left Party in Sweden abolished inheritance tax years ago because they'd gone down the journey of this envy-filled left-wing socialist approach and they'd found it was counterproductive. It led to complexity, it reduced wealth in the country and afterwards business thrived. And even the Communist Party in the face of the facts in Sweden 20 years ago could see how wrong it was. It's a shame that modern Labour Party doesn't understand.

06:55:19 - 06:55:22

Speaker 222

I thank my honorable friend for that intervention. He is absolutely right.

06:55:22 - 06:57:19

Lewis Cocking

This is a tax on aspiration. If we want to unlock the next generation of entrepreneurs, if we want to back, if we want to back, no I won't. I won't give way. I've taken a number of interventions and there are a number of colleagues that want to speak. There are a number of colleagues that want to speak.

If we want to unlock the next generation of entrepreneurs, if we want to back the people that put blood, sweat and tears, go out to work every day to make our country great and what it is today, then this is what we need to do. And we have a clear, we have a clear plan to pay for it. Cut government spending by 71 billion pounds, including cutting the overseas aid to a billion pounds a year. We would reduce welfare spending by 6, by 36 billion pounds and we would support young people into work rather than a life on benefits. Alongside our pledges to scrap the family farm tax, scrap the family business tax, these are bold changes that will get our economy growing.

Enabling people to keep and pass on more of their own money is how we encourage people to invest, take risk and create new opportunities. Inheritance tax is not the only example. I regularly speak to constituents who feel they are better off financially to refuse a promotion or to refuse more hours at work because it doesn't make sense for them to work harder and get less. I've spoken to self-employed tradespeople who turn down work because they are too close to the VAT threshold. This just cannot be right.

It is absolutely crazy when I speak to businesses and I speak to people who work that turn down employment, that turn down taking on business because they will be worse off paying more taxes under this Labour government. Until we shift the incentives in our economy, incentives that make a life on benefits more attractive than getting a job, incentives that will put off businesses from creating new jobs, we will never improve the situation that our country faces. Labour have a choice on the budget on the 28th of October. They can copy the clear plan that we've set out to make savings and cut welfare, or they can continue down the same road. But sadly, Madam Deputy Speaker, I just think they're not listening.

06:57:19 - 06:57:23

Speaker 219

And with an immediate four-minute time limit, Dr. Ben Spencer.

06:57:23 - 07:00:44

Ben Spencer

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is without doubt one of the most important debates we can have because it goes to the heart of a simple question. When someone works hard, saves diligently, builds a business, a family farm, or buys a family home and wants to plan for their children's future, why are they penalised by this government? Why is their success targeted and when will fairness be restored? So that those who work hard to achieve success are rewarded, not attacked and subjected to the politics of envy.

The answer I hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, will be after the next election. Labour's answer is always the same. Their instinct is to ask who can we tax? That's not me saying it, it's the Work and Pensions Secretary himself who admitted that every conversation he had had with backbench Labour MPs was them asking who they can tax to pay for increased welfare spending. And it's constituencies like Runnymede and Weybridge that are firmly in their sights.

I can picture it now, Madam Deputy Speaker, sitting high in the Whitehall ivory tower, looking for new ways to tax and spend. Surrey and the South East comes into their sights. The successful businesses, the skilled workforce, the resulting high house prices. And rather than looking to replicate that growth and success, they simply look at their spreadsheet. They see a house price.

They see something they think they can tax. But people's assets are not lottery wins. They're the product of decades of hard work, discipline and sacrifice. To tax wealth and savings in this way is not fairness, it's a penalty on individual responsibility. And it sends a damaging message that those who work hard, build a business, save for their and their family's future will be punished for doing so.

I believe in fairness, not redistribution.

And at the next election, the country will be offered a clear choice. A Labour government whose priorities put welfare spending above our country's defense, and whose commitment to raising taxation will bankrupt our children's future. Or, a Conservative party that believes aspiration should be rewarded, not targeted. That savings belong to the individual, not the state, where planning for the future is encouraged, not penalized. Whether it's the increase in taxation on savings and investments, increased taxation on businesses, the mansion tax, the family farm tax, Labour's approach is to tax success.

Labour is asset-stripping our country and targeting the very people and businesses that create growth, prosperity, and opportunity. And at the next general election, the choice could not be clearer. A Labour party facilitated by the Liberal Democrats that sees taxpayers as targets, or a Conservative party that backs enterprise and rewards hard work, and stands up for those who want to build a better future for their children. Madam Deputy Speaker, people's money is their own. It's not the government's money that Labour haven't taxed yet.

07:00:44 - 07:04:26

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. If we want our children to have a better life than us, if we want them to enjoy a better standard of living than ourselves, to enjoy better healthcare, to live in a better environment, then it is necessary to grow our economy. Conservatives understand that governments do not create growth. A wise government will try and create the conditions for growth, and then stand back and allow individuals, families, partnerships, and businesses to do their best, to work hard, to provide goods and services that people want to buy, and thus improve the world we live in. Creating wealth is hard work.

Now, I don't suppose that many members opposite are aware of this, because so few of them have ever worked in the private sector. It is quite remarkable that my honorable friend the Shadow Chancellor has more experience in the private sector, 23 years I believe, than the whole of the cabinet put together. This government often talks about supporting business, yet time and again, it does the opposite. Higher national insurance charges that make it more expensive to employ people. 350 pages of the Unemployment Rights Act further drive up the cost of labor.

Their plans for a tourist tax, eagerly embraced by the Liberal Democrats, which will place additional burdens on our tourism sector, made up largely of family businesses. Instead of helping local enterprises flourish, this government's first instinct is to ask how much more can we tax them. And we know this because the Work and Pensions Secretary has told us that his colleagues are always asking him to pay more benefits to more people. Conservatives understand that the drive, innovation, and hard work of family farms and family businesses do more to create jobs, train apprentices, and sustain communities than government ever could. Now, my constituency in Bridgwater sits in the heart of rural Somerset, and ours is overwhelmingly a small business economy.

More than 99% of the businesses in Somerset employ fewer than 250 employees. These businesses are rooted in the places they serve. They support local sports teams, support village events, and provide opportunities for local people. For those of us representing rural communities, it is small-scale family businesses that underpin our local economies. They grow our food, they make up our high streets, and they support tourism and more.

And this makes the fact that the government feels no remorse in penalizing their hard work in the name of subsidizing those who avoid it even more depressing.

Conservatives are on the side of those who work hard, who save, who invest, who create jobs and wealth, and we will reward those that do the right thing. That is why we will abolish inheritance tax on family homes, family farms, and family businesses. We will restore fairness to a system that has been neglected those who play by the rules. Because when a business passes from one generation to the next, we should be helping it grow and continue a legacy, not forcing it to sell assets to pay a tax bill. I'll give way.

07:04:26 - 07:04:42

Markus Campbell-Savours

The motion says family homes. It doesn't specifically say family farms or family businesses, but you said family businesses. How would, for the purposes of a piece of legislation, somebody define a family business?

07:04:42 - 07:05:32

Ashley Peter Fox

It does specifically refer to family businesses if he if he reads it. It's agricultural property relief and business property relief. They are agriculture and business assets that form part of an estate, and we will reverse Labour's family farms and family business tax. We believe that allowing families to retain and reinvest their assets supports growth, encourages long-term planning, and strengthens local communities. It will actively put money in pockets rather than take out more.

And if we want a prosperous Britain, we must back the people who've invested their lives in the community, building businesses, farms, and homes that can be passed to the next generation.

07:05:32 - 07:12:48

Speaker 227

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as I've listened to this debate today, I too have been reminded of those chilling words describing Labour MPs by their own Work and Pensions Secretary: "Every meeting I have is who we can tax in order to pay benefits to others." And this debate today sets out again the battle of ideas between the welfare party and the Conservatives. Since the disastrous first Labour budget of broken promises, this is the eighth vote that the Conservatives have forced on the family farm and the family business taxes. In that time, we've seen off a Prime Minister, a Chancellor, two DEFRA Secretaries of State, and discovered that a DEFRA Minister views black Labradors, warm ale, and pubs as a far-right fantasy.

But we have also shown the power of rural and coastal communities, because their protests here and across the country, the heart-wrenching stories we have heard from families of the terrible discussions and decisions they have made, set out eloquently by my honorable friend for Keighley and Ilkley, in order to avoid this vindictive death tax, and the pressure we have exerted here in Westminster, forced the government into one of its most humiliating U-turns. There were many, but this was humiliating. Their partial U-turn on these vindictive taxes. This is why we are forcing another vote today, ahead of budget, because we know the damage that these vindictive taxes continue to have on the rural economy. We know that this government has overseen the highest number of farms closing on record in a year.

Shameful.

The Financial Secretary didn't admit that. We also know, as my honorable friend for Dumfries and Galloway has set out, that this 10-year payment scheme they keep talking about in fact only applies if the estate is able to make the first payment within six months of the death, probate having been settled. Well, does anyone know in their own constituencies of such a scenario? This means that the 10-year payment plan is nothing but warm words from the Treasury bench. It is an absolutely impossible condition to fulfill for the overwhelming majority of family farms and businesses that will be hit by these taxes.

The Financial Secretary also didn't acknowledge that investment in rural economies has dropped off a cliff. He's not listening, he might want to. In a recent CLA survey, nearly nine out of 10 rural businesses, family businesses, stated that they have paused investment. In fact, 85% say that the current threshold of which he is so proud doesn't, is not enough to cover the value of their business given the cost of machinery and livestock and the other business costs that this government imposes. And of course, two pubs are closing every day under this government.

In short, rural communities cannot afford Labour. And despite their protestations over the last two years, every single Labour MP has voted for the family farm tax and the family business tax multiple times. Only one had the courage to vote for his constituents. And there is one other: the Prime Minister. That was because he wasn't in Parliament at the time of the other votes.

But he knows that Labour has a rural problem. He has said, and I quote: "I realize we have a long way to go to build back trust with the farming community across the country." It's a shame, therefore, that today of all days, he's put another tax on family farms: the fertilizer tax. Every one of them voted for it. Again, the Work and Pensions Secretary was right.

This is another hammer blow to British farming, only weeks after the shambolic handling of SFI, the collapse of the government's environmental policy, and the Prime Minister's botched response on how his deal with the EU will in fact favor foreign farmers over British farmers and hand our food laws to the control of the European Union. Now, this battle of ideas today, we have seen, if I may say so, some superb speeches on our side of the House. My honorable friend for Central Suffolk and North Ipswich painted a picture of the many local pubs and the black Labradors in his Suffolk constituency. The DEFRA Minister may wish to take note. My honorable friend for Bromley set out sound economic analysis, even if he admitted his cricketing skills are not quite what they should be.

My honorable friend for Mid Bedfordshire set out a description of the Labour Party that I think hits home almost as much as the Work and Pensions Secretary's description. Labour is the party that taxes aspiration. This vote tonight is the proof of that. My honorable friend for Bridgwater did an excellent intervention on the fact that this tax only focuses on family farms and family businesses, British family farms and family businesses, doesn't affect foreign owners of farmland. Perhaps the Minister will explain, please, how he thinks it is fair that foreign farmers shouldn't pay this tax but British farmers should do.

And then we had other excellent speeches by my honorable friends for South West Hertfordshire, Keighley, Rutland and Stamford, Farnham and Bordon, South West Devon, Solihull West, Broxbourne, and Runnymede and Weybridge, who described Labour's approach to taxation as asset-stripping our country.

Let me turn, however, to some of the interventions from the benches opposite. The member for Welwyn Hatfield, who by the way voted for the family farm and the family business tax seven times, tonight will be an eighth. And the honourable member for Macclesfield, who only voted for it three times, I'm sure his farmers are so happy. Both of them asked what can be done to help those who are not yet on the housing ladder. Well, I'm delighted to tell you that the Conservative party have the answer, because we will be scrapping...

If he sits down, if he sits down, I've got some words about his AI-generated speech in a moment. The Conservatives have the answer: we will scrap stamp duty on primary residences. That's how we help people back on the housing ladder. But the honourable member for Macclesfield also described his own constituents who want to pass on their family homes, their businesses, to their children. He described them as the idle rich.

The idle rich. I hope that it was just the AI speech generating that. I genuinely hope that he won't... I genuinely hope... I genuinely hope, if he lets me speak, I genuinely hope that he can explain his comment.

The idle rich. Go on.

07:12:48 - 07:13:06

Speaker 197

I was quoting Churchill, and in particular a lecture given by Professor Dornton at Gresham College in 2021, directly quoting Churchill when he was Chancellor of the Exchequer as a Conservative.

07:13:06 - 07:14:56

Speaker 227

That doesn't, that doesn't plough any furrows with the farmers in his constituency who he has just described as the idle rich. And what is more, he's got his figures wrong, because he keeps throwing these figures around. In fact, that Tax Policy Associates think tank that so many Labour colleagues seem to rely on has said that by the end of this decade, one in six families will pay inheritance tax, many of them in his constituency that I know well. Now, the honourable member for St Austell and Newquay only voted for the family farm and family business tax a mere six times. He missed one of them.

But he had the bright idea of that farmers should get life insurance and planning advice. How on earth are farmers in his constituency on an income of around twenty thousand pounds a year, how are they going to afford that? It's yet more business taxes. And we have also heard today reliance on Dan Neidle and his organisation Tax Policy Associates. I merely make the point so that it's open and transparent, of course Dan Neidle is a senior member of the Labour party and served for three years on their disciplinary committee.

Now on this side of the House, we are setting out the tough decisions to cut spending and to help hardworking families up and down the country invest in their businesses and their homes, ready to hand over to their own family in a moment. Because people who have worked hard, paid their income tax, lived within their means and saved, haven't done so so that the current Labour Chancellor can tax that all over again. They have done so because they have a deep desire that they want to leave something to the next generation that will help them prosper when they are no longer here. I'll happily give way to him.

07:14:56 - 07:15:27

Scott Arthur

Who's him? I do thank her for the courteous way in which she gives way. So of course, where domestic properties are concerned, more people are getting drawn into paying it because the thresholds have been frozen. But I'm sure the Minister who came here in 2022 to say the rates at that time were going to be frozen until 2028 is currently at the opposition dispatch box.

07:15:27 - 07:16:55

Speaker 227

Can I say I'm so glad he's brought that up because not only has his first Chancellor extended the freezing, she's also dragged pensioners into this. So it is the worst of all worlds. They have... it is literally the worst of all worlds. But I'm... just on this point though, because it's an important one. The fact that under this government, one in six families will be liable by 2030 means that many other... many other constituents will be liable to this.

And St Austell and Newquay said that it was bonkers that our ideas to axe inheritance tax on the family home. Well, I hate to break it to him, Austria, Portugal, Sweden, Norway, Australia, Canada and New Zealand all have done the same. But the reason, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we are doing this, that this is so important, is because we know it is families who build this country. Families who put down roots. They build a home, they run a farm or they start a business.

They bring prosperity and vibrancy to our villages and our towns. So I make this promise that the Conservatives will axe these taxes if Labour doesn't at the budget. Because only the Conservatives are the party of the family home, the family business and the family farm. And only the Conservatives will get Britain working again.

07:16:55 - 07:20:22

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank members from all sides of the House for the contributions throughout this debate. Some of them definitely have the volume that means all of us have been able to hear them in this House. I thank the honourable member herself, a former Treasury Minister, for her... for her contributions. Given her experience, Madam Deputy Speaker, we may have expected at least a hint of self-awareness from the opposition front bench today.

Because she spent some time working in the Treasury and the previous government left Britain with crumbling public services, with broken public finances and the worst Parliament on record for living standards. And today, Madam Deputy Speaker, her party have come to this House demanding more unfunded tax cuts worth up to eleven billion pounds a year without any clear plan whatsoever for how they will pay for them, other than a vague commitment in this motion before the House today to cutting public spending. We all know what that means. That means cutting spending on the NHS, it means cutting spending on our schools, it means cutting spending on our police. And that's what they did when they had fourteen years in charge.

And we know if they ever got on this side of the House again, that their first port of call will be taking away money from our public services that constituents up and down the country rely on. Their plans, Madam Deputy Speaker, would do nothing to help ordinary families with the cost of living and would benefit the very wealthiest estates. I do not think that it is the right priority to give a three point seven four million pound tax cut to someone living in a ten million pound mansion. But it is clear today, Madam Deputy Speaker, that that is the party opposite's priority, to give massive tax cuts to people in ten million pound homes. We do not take that decision on this side of the House.

Over and over again, Madam Deputy Speaker, the party opposite sets out fantasy spending cuts that nobody believes that they will deliver and that clearly demonstrate their inability to add up or to even watch what the government is doing. For example, some of the opposition members talked about changes to welfare spending and the fact that the Conservatives plan to bring back face-to-face assessments. Well, yes, that would be a very good idea and that's why we are doing it on this House after members opposite scrapped face-to-face assessments during the pandemic but didn't get round at all to reinstating them. Instead, we are bringing back face-to-face assessments to make sure that we can move people off welfare and into work because that's a Labour value and we support work. Madam Deputy Speaker, in stark contrast to the party opposite, because of the action this government has taken since coming to office, our economy is demonstrating strong resilience in the face of global challenges.

Earlier this week, the IMF upgraded our forecast of growth for this year.

We're now the fastest growing economy in the G7 in the first half of the year. The IMF have also projected that we will have the lowest deficit in the G7 by 2031 and we are on track, Madam Deputy Speaker, to cut the deficit by more than any other G7 economy between 2025 and 2030. And from 2029 we'll have the lowest borrowing in the G7. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'll happily give way on that point, yes.

07:20:22 - 07:20:48

Robbie Moore

I thank the Minister for giving way. I was wondering if the Minister agrees with the Prime Minister's long-term mentor, Lord Blunkett of the other place, who just last month at the Countryside Alliance's Rural Reset conference said that the Prime Minister should use his time in premiership to change the inheritance tax on farms because it was a mistake that the Labour party made. Does he agree with Lord Blunkett's comments?

07:20:48 - 07:21:54

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

I thank the honourable member for his intervention. The Government's policy on inheritance tax is set out today and we will not be voting for the motion before us on the floor of the House today because we do not believe that is the right priority to slash public services and to slash public spending for people living in ten million pound mansions. That's their choice and it is not ours. I should make some progress with just five minutes to go. This Government will deliver good growth in every postcode and provide breathing space for families and businesses today.

And underneath all that we will continue to focus on fiscal discipline. The Prime Minister and the Chancellor have been clear that we will meet our fiscal rules at the budget later this month with a buffer against uncertainty. And we will continue to control borrowing so we can bring down inflation and reduce the long-term pressures on our public finances. And this is the right thing to do because there is nothing progressive about a government spending one pound in every ten on debt interest rather than on the priorities of working people. Madam Deputy Speaker, yes, I will give way on that point.

07:21:54 - 07:22:15

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

He's just touched on what the Prime Minister has said. The Prime Minister also sold told the people of Wakefield that they needed to look again at the family farm tax. So why this evening are the Labour benches so full of MPs saying that we are absolutely not moving on it when he made that very clear promise during the by-election? What are we to believe, the Prime Minister then or the Prime Minister now?

07:22:15 - 07:22:34

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Madam Deputy Speaker, we will be voting against the opposition motion this evening. The responsible approach that this Government is taking stands in stark contrast... Oh, of course, thank you, thank you, I'll give way for that.

07:22:34 - 07:23:01

Markus Campbell-Savours

I thank the Minister for giving way. Please don't let the opposition distract us from what can be done. The SFI debacle the other day demonstrated that farmers are struggling. There's an opportunity to do the right thing at the budget. Don't let the party that want to give tax benefits to the owners of 175 million pound penthouses distract us.

There's something in what they've written here about farm taxes. It's very different from the wider issue they've made in this daft motion.

07:23:01 - 07:26:06

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

I thank my honourable friend for his intervention and for his continued advocacy for the farmers in his constituency and across the country. Members on this side of the House engaged constructively with myself, the then Defra Minister and the Prime Minister on the issue of the threshold in the inheritance tax changes for farms and businesses.

And we did make a change late last year in order to reflect the conversations and concerns that were on our side of the House and the representations received in advance of that. Madam Deputy Speaker, on the changes on residential property, it is worth noting before the House that independent analysis has shown that those changes could cost 10.8 billion pounds a year once behavioural effects are taken into account, effects that the opposition didn't cost, which means that we now know that there's a massive 5 billion black hole in their plans. And that's, I think, that shows, I think the whole House can agree, that they simply haven't learned from the Liz Truss debacle that pushed up interest rates, that pushed up the cost of mortgages for constituents of mine in Chipping Barnet and people across the country. And we will not make that same mistake that the opposition made. And turning to the changes on agricultural property relief and business property relief introduced in April this year, these are expected to raise around 300 million pounds a year while offering protection for family farms and businesses through 100% relief on the first 2.5 million of qualifying agricultural and business assets.

A couple can pass on up to 5 million of assets between them tax-free, in addition to existing allowances such as the nil rate band. Turning, just turning a few pages... Madam Deputy Speaker, I think I should come to conclusion as we reach 7:00 PM. And to fix our economy for the long term, we must ignore the fantasy economics and the unfunded commitments of the party opposite. It will lead to economic ruin.

Instead, we will stay focused on maintaining the resilience of our economy, an economy where GDP growth has been revised up, where we now have the highest growth in the G7, where living standards are rising after they fell in the previous parliament, where investment is up in the public sector and the private sector, and where productivity is rising at its fastest rate outside of the pandemic in more than a decade. We will reject this motion this evening, Madam Deputy Speaker, because we will reject tax cuts for those in 10 million pound homes paid for by cuts to our public services, including the NHS, police, and local government up and down the country. Instead, we on this side of the House will stay focused on delivering good growth in every postcode and, as someone once said, Madam Deputy Speaker, hope in every heart.

07:26:06 - 07:26:45

Speaker 230

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Division, clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper.

07:26:45 - 07:26:54

Speaker 229

As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Tellers for the ayes, David Simmons, Rebecca Smith. Tellers for the noes, Claire Hughes, Michael Wheeler.

07:40:01 - 07:40:05

Speaker 232

Order.

07:40:05 - 07:40:22

Speaker 234

The ayes to the right 99, the noes to the left 291.

07:40:22 - 07:40:44

Speaker 229

The ayes to the right were 99, the noes to the left 291. So the noes have it, the noes have it. Unlock. Motion number three on railways. Minister to move.

07:40:44 - 07:40:45

I beg to move.

07:40:45 - 07:40:49

Speaker 229

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:40:50 - 07:40:51

Of the contrary no.

07:40:52 - 07:41:00

Speaker 229

The division is deferred until Wednesday next. Motion number four on financial services and markets. Minister to move.

07:41:00 - 07:41:01

I beg to move.

07:41:01 - 07:41:05

Speaker 229

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:41:06 - 07:41:16

Speaker 229

Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number five on financial services and markets. Minister to move.

07:41:16 - 07:41:17

I beg to move.

07:41:17 - 07:41:21

Speaker 233

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:41:22 - 07:41:31

Speaker 229

Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Motion number six on building societies. Minister to move.

07:41:31 - 07:41:32

I beg to move.

07:41:32 - 07:41:36

Speaker 231

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

07:41:37 - 07:41:45

Speaker 229

Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.

07:41:45 - 07:42:21

Speaker 235

Madam Deputy Speaker, Devon and Cornwall MPs have received a letter from the Department of Health stating that a decision on reopening North Devon District Hospital maternity unit could be made next week. This directly contradicts the Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust, who have insisted to me and the public again today that a decision will be made on the 26th of October. For the sake of many worried families in North Devon, it is important that government communications are accurate. So please can I put this point on the record?

07:42:21 - 07:42:40

Speaker 229

I thank the honorable member for giving notice of his point of order. He has successfully put his point on the record and I'm sure it will have been noted by the Treasury front bench who can make the relevant ministers aware. Petition, Ian Roome.

07:42:40 - 07:43:31

Ian Roome

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Further to our online petition signed by more than 15,000 people calling for births to be restored at North Devon District Hospital's maternity unit, I present this petition on behalf of all those families across Northern Devon and Cornwall who need local maternity services at North Devon District Hospital reinstated at the earliest possible date it is safe to do so. The petitioners therefore request that the House of Commons urge the government to bolster recruitment and maternity staffing levels among NHS trusts, build local resiliency into the NHS to prevent dangerous travel distances for expectant mothers, and ensure that the National Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce works to stop emergency suspensions of maternity services at NHS hospitals. And the petitioners remain, etcetera.

07:43:58 - 07:44:10

Speaker 239

Petition, North Devon Maternity Services.

07:44:10 - 07:44:12

Speaker 237

I beg to move this house do now adjourn.

07:44:12 - 07:44:18

Speaker 229

The question is that this house do now adjourn. Josh Babarinde.

07:44:18 - 07:46:18

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Debate and discussion about issues of benefits, entitlement and calculation can often be relegated to the mere spreadsheet, but we all know that there are individuals who sit behind each and every one of those awards and numbers. And one of those people, an individual who I've mentioned more than I think anybody else in this chamber, is Pauline Cole. Staff Sergeant Pauline Cole served our country during the Aden Emergency in 1967. She was a trailblazer and she told her story in her book, Army Girl, the untold story that I believe the minister has a copy of, a signed copy of.

Pauline was funny, fierce and utterly determined, and again, the minister got to experience that firsthand. But she also carried the cost of her service for the rest of her life. Her service left her with skin damage and post-traumatic stress disorder, and the military tribunal rightly recognized that reality and awarded her compensation for those lifelong conditions. That compensation was meant to acknowledge her pain, her injury and the quality of life that she lost. It should have given her a little bit more security and dignity in her retirement.

But instead, the opposite happened. And that's because military compensation is treated as income when calculating pension credit that she was receiving. And so most of what Pauline won at tribunal was effectively clawed back by the Department for Work and Pensions.

07:46:18 - 07:46:19

Will the honorable gentleman give way?

07:46:19 - 07:46:20

Of course I will.

07:46:20 - 07:47:02

Jim Shannon

First of all, can I commend the honorable gentleman for his speech, for bringing this forward. He's a fierce and zealous and assiduous member for his constituents and we love hearing him come and make the case he's done again tonight. But does the honorable member agree that it's a grave injustice when the very compensation awarded to our brave veterans for injuries sustained while serving Queen, King and country is subsequently counted against them as an income when calculating means-tested benefits, for instance like pension credit the honorable gentleman referred to? Does the honorable member agree the government must now fix this disparity across all welfare and pension benefits, ensuring that our veterans, the honorable gentleman's constituent, are never penalized financially for the sacrifices that they have made?

07:47:02 - 07:47:18

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

I completely agree with the honorable gentleman. No one should be penalized for serving their country, which is effectively what the current system does. And I will come to some of the other benefits that he referred to shortly. But in the, yes, of course.

07:47:18 - 07:48:07

Tanmanjeet Dhesi

I thank my honorable friend the member for Eastbourne for his dedicated commitment on this particular issue because the Defense Committee last year published its report into the Armed Forces Covenant where we looked at this issue in detail and we heard harrowing testimony from many of our veterans and their families about the disadvantage that they had experienced as a result of their service despite their sacrifices.

Does my honorable friend agree that at the next Armed Forces Compensation Scheme review that ministers need to look very in detail into this particular issue, take remedial action because those who have made enormous sacrifices or were willing to lay down their lives should be treated with the dignity and respect that we as a society owe them?

07:48:07 - 07:48:36

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

I would agree with the honorable member for Slough and the chair of the Defense Select Committee who I know has been working on this issue for some time as well. And I think actually that needs to be done sooner than the next Armed Forces Compensation Scheme review. We also need to remember that the war pension scheme from before 2003, before that system, needs to be looked at as well and I hope that the minister will be able to give us some commitments to that effect later and I'll spell them out specifically. Yes, and then I'll make some progress.

07:48:36 - 07:49:03

Caroline Jane Voaden

I thank the honorable member for giving way, but on pensions, I've heard from several veterans in my constituency who have served and left the forces with a modest occupational pension and who now need Universal Credit to make ends meet, but because their pension is counted as income they receive less support and for some the reduction is substantial. So does my honorable friend agree that this current treatment is not consistent with the Armed Forces Covenant and that something needs to change?

07:49:03 - 07:51:10

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

I do agree with my honorable friend. I'll talk about the Armed Forces Covenant later and indeed the new legal duties that will be on the Department for Work and Pensions and other departments from the new year. But let me animate what she's describing with the example of what happened to Pauline. Her pension credit fell from 77 pounds a week to just 11 pounds a week on being awarded military compensation. And I'll put that very plainly, just like others have, she was financially punished for being injured in service of her country.

And this wasn't an abstract loss. The material impact is that she was forced to leave her home in the end because she could no longer afford to keep up with the living costs. So that's what this policy and the status quo means for people like Pauline. And I made her a promise that I would fight this injustice on her behalf. I used my first ever PMQ to raise this case and met with the Minister for Pensions to press it further.

But with huge sadness on the 30th of November last year, Pauline died and she died without seeing the justice that she was so determined to secure. But at her funeral, I renewed the promise that I made to her, to her sons, Les and Simon Haffenden, and to everyone who loved her. And I am here tonight in an endeavor to keep it. So that is why earlier today I tabled the Armed Forces Compensation Scheme and War Pension Scheme Report Bill, bit of a mouthful, so Pauline's Law will do. But this is not just Pauline's story.

Some 144,000 veterans and their families receive compensation for injury, illness or bereavement caused by their service, according to the Royal British Legion. Over half of our veterans are over 65. To the member for Hartlepool.

07:51:10 - 07:51:56

Jonathan Brash

Thank you very much. I really appreciate the honorable gentleman giving way and the assiduous way he's gone about campaigning on this issue throughout his time in this place, it is to his enormous credit. In November 2023, when I was just a local councilor, I moved a motion so that in Hartlepool all locally administered benefits would have military compensation disregarded and I'm really proud that in Hartlepool that is now the case and remains so.

But there are many councils across the country that are no longer doing this, are not doing this at all. So in addition to the demands you're making of the minister for national action, which I support, isn't it also incumbent on our local councils to do the exact same thing to honour our veterans who have received military compensation?

07:51:56 - 07:52:25

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Yeah, there are so many who need to act here. It's not just a Department for Work and Pensions issue, it's a local authority issue as well. And the Royal British Legion has, I will take it in a second, has a very helpful map that members can access to find their local authority and to identify which locally administered benefits are disregarded. I'm going to take the member for Taunton and Wellington and then I'm going to move up.

07:52:25 - 07:52:47

Gideon Amos

I'm extremely grateful to my honourable friend, member for Eastbourne, for being generous with his time. Would he join me in congratulating the veterans of Taunton and Wellington branches of the Royal British Legion who have been campaigning on this with me and have secured a commitment from Somerset Council, my colleagues at Somerset Council, to review benefits so that all military service compensation is disregarded as income?

07:52:47 - 07:57:31

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

I absolutely congratulate his local veterans and commend them for their service. And when I speak at his annual dinner in a couple of weeks' time, I shall pass on the message personally if any of them are local members. But I shall move on. So of those folks who I mentioned earlier, an estimated 146,000 of them are eligible for pension credit. But only around one in five receives an occupational pension for their time in service.

So many of them live on low incomes. But I think the most important figure here when we're assessing the viability of the disregard in question is 4,120. This is the number of veterans and bereaved spouses who currently receive military compensation and would be claiming pension credit. These are the people who I prioritize in pushing for this reform. But what we know is that if someone is ruled ineligible for pension credit, they don't just lose pension credit, they lose the passported help that comes with it.

And so there's a ripple effect across the forms of support that folks can receive. And on average they can be denied around 5,900 pounds a year in direct and passported support. So for our poorest veterans, this is the difference between getting by and going without. Now, I know the argument that the department has made before. It is the argument of so-called double tapping.

This is the principle that someone should not receive two separate payments from the state that meet the same need. And I do not dispute that very long-held principle within the Treasury. But it simply doesn't apply here. Double tapping assumes that both payments meet the same need. These payments do not.

Pension credit exists to provide a minimum income for ordinary living costs. Military compensation exists to recognize injury, loss, or bereavement caused by service. They're different payments for different purposes meeting different needs, so the double tapping excuse will not fly. Now, counting compensation against pension credit simply uses the benefit system to claw back part of an award that was made for an entirely separate purpose. And the government's own policy already proves the point.

Universal credit fully disregards war pensions and armed forces compensation scheme payments. The government has itself stated that this is in line with the treatment of civil compensation for personal injury, which does not impact pension credit calculations.

And so if military compensation is not double funding under Universal Credit, it cannot be double funding under pension credit. The department cannot accept the principle for working-age veterans and reject it for older veterans. So there's a further inconsistency as well within pension credit itself. Only the first ten pounds a week of military compensation is disregarded, and the minister has told me in correspondence that this partial disregard exists in recognition of veterans' service. So the government already accepts that service deserves to be treated differently.

But everything above that ten pounds is treated as income for everyday living costs, and I've yet to hear a clear rationale as to why ten pounds is the right figure. It seems arbitrary to me. Because if the department believes ten pounds of compensation serves a separate purpose, then why not the rest? Meanwhile, under pension credit, a civilian with a personal injury compensation award, a trust, or a structured settlement may have that compensation wholly disregarded. So pension credit currently gives greater protection to compensation for an injury suffered at work or on the road than to compensation for injury suffered in service of our country, one of the most valiant forms of work at all.

Now, the Armed Forces Covenant promises that members of the armed forces community should face no disadvantage as a result of their service. It also...

07:57:31 - 07:58:06

Lee Pitcher

Yes. I thank the honorable member for giving way. He mentions inconsistency quite a bit, and I hope he doesn't mind me echoing what other members have already said tonight. But alongside that issue the honorable member has raised, there is that related issue around how local authorities treat compensation, and the Royal British Legion's Credit Their Service campaign highlights significant inconsistencies. Local authorities' policies determine what military compensation can be given under different circumstances.

I wonder if he agrees with me that there shouldn't be a postcode lottery, it shouldn't be about where you live, everybody should be treated fairly and equitably across the country.

07:58:06 - 08:00:19

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Absolutely. And it is the Royal British Legion's Credit Their Service campaign that is one reason why I am here, and I pay particular tribute to Elliot, to Joe, to Claire, to Hannah, and Hermine, who were in Parliament today running an event to help promote this campaign. I also pay tribute while I'm here to Sam McManus from my team, but also to Ewan Morrison, who started out as a caseworker picking up Pauline's case and fought and fought and fought. So through the Armed Forces Bill, now Act, the covenant of duty is being extended to central government and welfare benefits and service-related compensation. And when it comes into force early next year, the DWP will be legally required to pay due regard to those principles.

Treating military compensation as income for pension credit fails both tests in my view. It disadvantages veterans compared to civilians who receive compensation. So I'm ultimately asking the government to act with a few key asks.

First, will he commit to amending the pension credit regulations so that military compensation is fully disregarded, bringing it into line with pension credit? Second, if he's not ready to go that far tonight, will he at least set out a commitment to review how much this would cost, because currently the DWP has said that it has not done that piece of work? And third, will he meet me, the Royal British Legion and veterans affected so we can find a way forward? Members across this house from the Labour Party, the Conservatives, the Liberal Democrats, the Green Party, Alliance, UUP, DUP and more have signed my amendment on this in the past, have signed my cross-party letter. We are determined for change here, because people like Pauline deserved better, our veterans deserve better, and this house must do better.

08:00:19 - 08:08:29

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to join other honourable members in congratulating the honourable member for Eastbourne on securing this debate on an issue which I know he has championed passionately for some time, and also for the way in which he's gone about it, both today and over the last few years in which I've been engaging with him on this issue. Indeed, he first raised it, I think, a month into my time as the Minister for Pensions, when I met him and his constituent, the late Staff Sergeant Pauline Cole, and members of his team, who it's nice to hear him paying tribute to today, who have obviously worked hard on this issue. The honourable member's speech included what I thought was a touching and very fitting tribute to Pauline, who served our country and campaigned not only for herself but on behalf of other veterans too. I was very glad to meet her, to have the chance of knowing how accurate his description of her was, and I again offer my condolences to Pauline's family, who have continued to support the campaign which she championed, and I've obviously corresponded with at least one of her sons about this case. As well as paying tribute to all of our armed forces and veterans, I also want to start by acknowledging the work the Royal British Legion does on their behalf to promote and secure the welfare of veterans and campaigning on issues concerning armed forces personnel, such as the one we are discussing today, and ensuring more widely the recognition of what our armed forces have given to this country.

I should also recognise the work of veterans' hubs beyond the Royal British Legion, including in Swansea, where I've discussed this and many, many other issues with veterans face-to-face. Now, the honourable member has been a fierce and determined campaigner on the issue. He mentioned his first question at Prime Minister's Questions, which is always a time-stressful but meaningful moment for a new MP, and he's persistently raised the interaction between the military compensation and the benefit system, and I note the bill he's reintroduced to the house today. I've listened to him and to others, including people in the house today. My colleague, the Minister for the Lords at the Department for Work and Pensions, met the Royal British Legion in November and discussed this, as I'm sure he is aware.

So let me turn to the long-standing policy questions, policy issues in this area and try to do justice to the issues that he has raised. Now, the honourable member is completely right that there is no single rule for how compensation payments are treated in the benefit system. Treatment depends on the nature and the purpose of a payment and whether it is in the form of a regular income or a lump sum capital payment, as well as the legislation governing the relevant schemes. In pension credit, most income is taken into account because the nature of the benefit is intended to top up the retirement income that a person already has. Pension credit is aiming to do something different to anything else in the benefit system.

It is to provide a guaranteed minimum level that we ensure that our pensioners will always have to live on. That's why in the 2000s it drove the halving of pensioner poverty that was such a big feature of the last Labour government. Now, pension credit rules already recognise veterans' specific circumstances, exactly as the honourable member has said, with the first ten pounds of specified war pension scheme and armed forces compensation scheme being disregarded.

I should add and I think this is important that the armed forces independence payment and specific additions to war disablement pension are disregarded in full recognizing the different nature of those payments. I think that's important and hasn't been discussed in this debate so far. Lump sum payments under the schemes that the honorable member is focusing on the armed forces compensation scheme are treated as personal injury capital which can remain protected through a trust or annuity under the applicable rules. Those arrangements are more favorable than the treatment of other similar schemes with disablement elements. For example the industrial injuries disablement benefit is entirely taken into account for pension credit and I'm sure he's aware of the fact that the fire and police service schemes also have no disregards applied.

I think the center of the honorable member's argument however is the different treatment in universal credit. That's the point that he's dwelt on so I want to try and do justice to that. Universal credit was introduced with no partial disregards which is what drove the initial change and had the disregards not applied here. Now pension credit predates the introduction of universal credit and does retain the partial disregard structure that all the legacy benefit system had. But more importantly it is important to highlight that the two benefits serve very different purposes.

One takes work incentives into account the other one as I say is trying to provide that minimum guaranteed income. These are very different purposes. Probably more importantly to some degree to this particular case it's also the case that pension credit's rates are significantly higher than the standard allowances in universal credit because this house has decided in passing that legislation that we are aiming to more or less guarantee pensioners income up to a minimum level. Pension credit is also more generous in its treatment of capital. The first ten thousand has no effect on entitlement and unlike with universal credit there is no upper capital limit.

That's for the obvious reasons that pensioners tend to have larger savings and those savings provide other contributions to people's income. Now by contrast capital above six thousand can affect universal credit entitlement and that entitlement normally ends if somebody has over sixteen thousand's worth of capital. Comparisons with civilian personal injury compensation should also be made carefully. And I know why the honorable member is making the point but I do want to be clear that lump sums paid under the armed forces compensation schemes are themselves treated as personal injury capital and so it would be treated exactly the same as the payments that I think he was setting up as being more generously treated than this. That wouldn't be the case they'd be treated identically.

By contrast ongoing war pension scheme payments and guaranteed income payments under the armed forces compensation schemes are income payments. And that's the fundamental point at which I think there's probably a disagreement. Which is that comparisons can therefore sometimes involve payments with different legal status and they're not like for like payments. Now the honorable member has argued that pension credit and service related compensations meet different needs. Again that was an important part of the speech that he made today.

I actually agree with him on that point. But I think where I need to explain what that means which is pension credit is a means tested income safety net. It's providing that guaranteed minimum income. And that's why we do take people's other income into account when assessing eligibility and need. It's a just very totally different system to how universal credit operates which sets a level of support and then tapers that away as other income comes in.

So it is not really about double funding but it's about the level of the support that the state provides in addition to the income the person already has. That was the nature of how pension credit was introduced. Now the honorable member draws a parallel with the LGBT plus compensation payments. I hope that he'll agree that the circumstances surrounding the government setting up that financial recognition scheme are quite different and involve a different set of considerations. More broadly no one is ever going to say that everything about the benefit system is perfect certainly not anybody that spent long time prior to coming into parliament working on it and trying to help people navigate that and then like all honorable members helping our constituents navigate that.

But to try to give some explanation of what's sitting behind the logic of what I absolutely recognize and Pauline set out very clearly feels like an arbitrary system to people, which is where you have lump sums or extra cost payments, those are disregarded within pension credit. Where you have regular payments that support income, of one of which is the focus here in the way in which Pauline received her treatment, those are treated as income and then the legislation requires us to partially disregard those. That's an explanation and I appreciate a technocratic one that doesn't do justice to Pauline's case, to her individual circumstances, to the circumstances veterans that we all engage with every day.

08:08:29 - 08:08:31

Speaker 250

Of course.

08:08:31 - 08:09:05

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

I thank the minister for giving way. In Pauline's case, she did not choose whether or not to receive monthly installments or a lump sum. Indeed, if she did have the choice, one, she may have preferred the lump sum because it was a big amount of money to do something with and two, because she wouldn't have fallen foul of the very rules that are here. Why should we leave it to almost a lottery as to whether someone receives a lump sum or installments as to whether their payment is disregarded?

08:09:05 - 08:10:17

Torsten Bell

I thank the honorable member for his question. Whether compensation is provided via income or by lump sums is obviously in the schemes of the compensation schemes, but I'd be happy to have a conversation with him about that. I actually don't know enough about the specifics of Pauline's case for how that would have played out, but as I say, it's the scheme rules that determine lump sum payments or ongoing payments rather than the benefit system itself. More broadly, I just want to say I absolutely hear the honorable member's arguments. I have on a number of occasions, I've heard them from Pauline, I've heard them from her family and I hear his clear request for the government to change the regulations.

And I recognize the power of those arguments. He's asked a straight question. I think the most I can do for him is to give him a straight answer, which is the government isn't in a position to change those regulations. I'm not in the position to give him the first answer he would like tonight, but I think he at least deserves a straight answer. I think that is because this is a long-standing position.

It's for the reasons I've set out, the consistency of how the benefit system deals with what are a very large and in fact growing number of compensation payments, all of which have similar issues to the ones we are discussing.

08:10:17 - 08:10:34

Speaker 251

Of course. Just briefly. I thank you for giving way. He's given an incredibly detailed answer and I agree, a straight answer to the arguments that were made by the honorable gentleman tonight. Does he think that system that he has described will fall foul of the Armed Forces Covenant?

08:10:34 - 08:11:00

Torsten Bell

The straight answer is that that question has been tested on a number of occasions and the answer is no. But I don't think that's the legal question is not sufficient. The question is what's the right thing to do and are we in the round supporting our veterans? So I don't want to the legal answer to your question is yes, but I don't want to that does not take away from the need to test that more broadly in the way we are doing tonight and have done on other occasions over time.

08:11:00 - 08:11:24

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Of course. I thank the member for his point on the Armed Forces Covenant. The position of the DWP in relation to the covenant is changed in light of the Armed Forces Act's new legal duties that the DWP will have to adhere to come January. What assessment has the DWP made of its obligations with respect to that change in the context of this pension credit disregard?

08:11:24 - 08:12:27

Torsten Bell

The answer is that's the legal position that I have just set out, which is the DWP does take that seriously, has considered, is content that this is consistent with our obligations under the Armed Forces Covenant.

I'm going to try to go beyond that though to say that there are other things that we should take into account, including arguments in this place and the position of veterans and the rest. But narrowly on the legal question, the answer is yes, that has been tested and our position is that it is consistent with the Armed Forces Covenant. The fact that that is our position does not in any way undermine the powerful arguments that the honorable member has made, that other honorable members have supported, that we have heard from our veterans, and I want to put that clearly on the record. Madam Deputy Speaker, I also should finish by emphasizing again the government's deep-felt gratitude to our armed forces for their professionalism, bravery, and dedication to duty, and to those who were in that position at previous times who now represent large parts of all our communities as the veterans who both continue to honor the work they did while they were serving, but also are active citizens supporting all kinds of work. I've mentioned the veterans hub in Swansea where I see brilliant work being done by people day in, day out.

08:12:27 - 08:12:31

Speaker 252

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.

08:12:31 - 08:12:37

Speaker 229

The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say, Aye. The Ayes have it. Order, order.