Joint Committee on Fisheries and Aquaculture

1 October 2025

No chapters available yet

Joint Committee on Fisheries and Aquaculture California State Senate

00:48 - 06:18
Speaker 1
Hi.  Good afternoon.  Thank you all for joining us, and welcome to the Joint Committee on Fisheries and Aquaculture.  We're gonna call the meeting together on behalf of the Joint Committee on Fisheries and Aquaculture.  We're gonna welcome you to the annual Zeke Greater Fisheries Forum, and today's hearing serves as California State of the Fishery, and we are truly appreciative that folks have come from far and why to be able to be here today. 

A few housekeeping items before we get right into it.  We have folks who are participating remotely now that the technical difficulties have been fixed.  And again, want to say thank you so much to the technical team for all the work on that.  Of course, we're coming to you from Room 2200 in the capital.  Just for a few items, obviously, we're not permitting any conduct that disrupts the hearing. 

Any individual that advances that type of conduct will be immediately escorted out.  We are going to be having remote participation here today.  We're going to respectfully request those who are participating online that each time you're recognized, if you don't mind just hitting that pop up window, that will appear in asking you to unmute.  So, make sure that you hit that, and we do have some technical advisors who are going to be on Zoom with you, and really appreciate you participating today.  For public comment, we are going to welcome public comment. 

The way what we'd like to be able to run, if it works for each and every one of you, is that we'd like to be able to get through each of the panels, and then at the end, we're going to be taking public comment, and public comment will be limited to two minutes, and we, again, cannot say how grateful we are to have each and every one of you here today.  We are so appreciative that Senator Cortese, is here as well.  The good senator, nice to see you, sir.  We appreciate you being here today.  So let's let's talk about what what is in front of us. 

We're gonna hear from governmental leaders, representatives of the commercial fleet, top scientists, environmental leaders here at the fifteenth annual Zeke Greater Fisheries Forum.  We have panels focused on salmon, on Dungeness crab, kelp.  The blob, I was just hearing from mister Ogg who's been up fishing in Oregon, 68 degrees.  He has never seen it warmer, and it's just that impact that we're seeing in The Pacific right now.  And we're gonna hear from various fishery committees who are required to report to the legislature each and every year. 

I think that we can all agree fisheries on the West Coast, especially salmon and Dungeness crab, both top tier have been incredibly challenged over the past several years.  And it seems for every step forward that we take, two steps are taken back.  And the latest that we're seeing is on government funding from the federal level.  Funds have been reduced for NOAA across the West Coast and, of course, across the nation.  And we're also seeing that fiscal cliff based off of the shutdown, and we'll wait to see the total ramifications and how long that shutdown lasts here in the coming days. 

But here in the Golden State, we continue to do our part.  We're beginning to roll out a few billion dollars from proposition four, and I wanna say thank you so much to the voters who stepped up to be able to fund proposition four.  If I could be so candid, we would be in real trouble if we did not see proposition four funding in the state of California.  And a lot of those dollars are focused on mitigating the impacts of the climate crisis, especially within the coastal zone.  And a lot of those funds are being invested in watershed and coastal restoration and forest health, which is absolutely critical long term to the health of the salmon fishery. 

This year, the legislature and the governor have appropriated a total of about $267,000,000 for coastal resilience.  24,000,000 of that is, pegged for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife.  We're gonna hear from the director in just a moment for parental salmon tagging and, of course, climate ready fisheries management, which is absolutely critical.  And 12,000,000 has been allocated to the Ocean Protection Council for the restoration and management of kelp ecosystems as well as restoration of island ecosystems.  We're gonna hear more on the challenges with kelp in just a few moments. 

In addition, 256,000,000 in prop four funds have been allocated to the wildlife conservation board for actions to protect and enhance fish and wildlife resources.  So, this hearing could not come at a more critical time to be able to get the facts straight, talk about the challenges, how we can all work towards solutions in the months and years to come.  I want to wrap it up right here and just say this.  We are living in challenging times.  Our government, politics, the climate, we've had some wins though. 

We had the first recreational salmon fishing season in California in three years.  The challenge that we continue to see, no commercial salmon fishing for the third straight year.  And that has had a massive impact on rural coastal communities, especially in Northern California.  A win though, we cleared four dams in the Klamath River, unlocking more than 500 miles of salmon habitat.  That would not have happened without the work of our secretary of natural resources, the governor, and of course, the Biden administration, for all of their work, we would have never seen that happen. 

06:18 - 08:19

Speaker 1

Dungeness crab season yielded a strong catch last year even though it was a truncated season and, with delays and restrictions, about $7 a pound last year for Dungeness crab. Total fishery was worth about 50,000,000, but obviously, there are continued concerns. We're going to hear more from the director and, of course, our panel on Dungeness crab in just a few moments. I'll end it here and say protecting and preserving our state's fisheries and aquaculture is vital. It is vital to the long term health of rural economies up and down this state, and then it is also key to the social and cultural diversity we celebrate here in California, especially with tribal nations.

So let's talk about what we have in store today. First, we're gonna hear, from state leaders about the state of the fishery. Next, we're gonna talk about the challenges and opportunities surrounding salmon in the Golden State. Following that, we're gonna get the outlook for the twenty twenty five, twenty twenty six Dungeness crab season. We're gonna then hear all about the health of kelp.

We're gonna talk about that hot blob that is the largest that we've ever seen in The Pacific, and then we're going to get a glimpse at the Fishery Committee and Aquaculture Program reports. So, without further ado, and I know that he is one of the busiest in the capital, and that is Wade Crowfoot, and we'd like to move directly into our first panel, and that is with the Secretary of Natural Resources as well as Department of Fish and Wildlife. Secretary Crowfoot has led the California Natural Resources Agency since 2019, and I gotta say, just, working with him directly, I'd say one of the most engaged individuals that I have ever met in state service. If you were to ask him what's going on in the Jackson State demonstration force, or what's happening in the Eel, or what's going down in Alviso, he will know it. And it is because he returns phone calls, he returns emails, he engages with the public, and we are really grateful for your work, mister secretary.

You're gonna be giving us an update on all issues from the agency. The floor is yours, and we're grateful that you're here.

08:20 - 16:05

Speaker 2

Thank you so much, Senator and Senators, for the opportunity to speak, and thank you for holding this every year. California is a big state. We have a lot of economic priorities and environmental challenges, and the Ziggler Fisheries Forum keeps us focused, and it brings us together. It's a forcing function to update on the state of play with our fisheries and understand where we're making progress and where we have continued challenges. As you point out, it's been a very challenging decade.

You know, two millennial droughts in just over a decade, so called because science told us that those droughts would only happen once every thousand years, and we've had two of them. They've battered the health of our rivers. They've brought species to the brink. They've meant fishery closures and all the livelihood impacts that they've had. And those same droughts have put 5,000,000 Californians underwater rationing.

And believe it or not, at the 2022, with the end of the driest three years in California history, we had the salmon situation, we had 5,000,000 people under the water rationing. We were preparing for 20,000,000 underwater rationing had we not had those string of atmospheric rivers. I think, as Director Bonham and others may note, there are cause for optimism in some of the recovery of at least some of the runs in the past couple of years, recognizing salmon have this triennial life cycle. But we still have huge major challenges, and the biggest challenges lie ahead. The fishing sector has been very clear on how discouraged they are by the state of their ability to have a livelihood, and it's been remarkable to see their perseverance.

I was prepared to touch on some high level points, many of which that you already touched on, but I think I appreciate this forum every year being so clear eyed in terms of the challenges. I think at the same time, let's reflect on some progress that has been made. Clearly, the Klamath River Dam removal that has been led by the perseverance of tribes over the last twenty years, the Yurok, the Karuk, and other tribes, gained global attention to demonstrate that big things are possible. The removal of four defunct dams, the restoration of 400 miles of habitat, the return of salmon, not in years or months or weeks, but in days, into that restored, river that's once again living in its full form. Big shout out to Director Bonham and so many allies that supported that tribal leadership.

Director Bonham was working on Klamath Dam removal, actually, for the last twenty five years, long before he was in state government. More progress has been made beyond the Klamath River. Many don't know that the largest wetland restoration in the Delta took place when Lookout Slough, several thousand acres inundated for the imperiled endangered species of the Delta. Those are just big projects. There's all sorts of small projects underway.

Thanks to funding from the legislature and the governor, there's really a no regret strategy to restore flood plains, to restore habitat, and to restore flows. We know that the combination of restored flows and restored habitat and more adaptive management, more nimble management, is the key to recovering these fisheries, and we've seen progress on that front. In the ocean, which is, of course, as you point out, challenged in so many ways by climate change and ocean acidification, the loss of oxygen, hypoxia, the harmful algal blooms, more progress. The Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Ocean Protection Council getting money out the door to reduce the risk of entanglement of sea life in fishing gear, which has been critical, not only for the survival of remarkable species like the whale, but for the ability of those fishing seasons to happen. So we'll look forward to hearing from Director Bonham and others on that.

January, we aggregated all that we're working on to restore the health of aquatic habitats, the rivers, the delta, into an effort or document we call the state's Salmon Strategy for a hotter, drier future. And it's not that we decided all of a sudden that we were going to prioritize this, but we've been doing all of this work that's been fairly decentralized, and we wanted to hold ourselves accountable for putting this in one place. So director Bonham led an effort to put all in one place exactly what we're doing and what we need to do in order to hold ourselves accountable, removing stream barriers, restoring aquatic habitat, bolstering stream flows at important times, expanding floodplains, restoring wetlands, and we made progress. We provided an update earlier this year, and I won't bore you with numbers, but for those who want to check it out, action by action, we've characterized the progress that we're making. And I think we have a lot to be proud of.

The way I would put it is proud of our progress with the hardest work ahead. Proposition four has the potential to be a game changer. We've developed a sort of a task force within our agency to identify all the funding streams within Prop four that can advance that salmon strategy, or that set of actions that we're taking to restore the health of our rivers and aquatic habitat. And numbers that we think there's upwards, you know, of the universe of $1,400,000,000 in that bond that can advance the salmon strategy actions. And that of that, the legislature and the governor have approved about $376,000,000 Now, these are in different pots of money.

They're competitive. So, it's not suggesting that all of this necessarily goes to priority actions for salmon and our fisheries, but the potential is there. And you've got folks across Fish and Wildlife, Natural Resources Agency, our conservancies, Department of Water Resources, all focused on how to optimize Prop four funding for the benefit of our rivers and fisheries. Last point of progress I'd raise is our effort to cut green tape, to reduce the time and expense of taking the environmental actions we need to take. When I took office seven years ago, I heard from conservation groups that sometimes a third of their budget for a project was spent on the planning and environmental permitting for a restoration project.

So thanks to Director Bonham, Chair Joaquin Escobel at the Water Board, we've shifted that paradigm and made it much easier to get good projects in the ground. And I hope, Director Bonham, you'll be able to share real specific objective facts in terms of money saved and time saved getting these improvements in the ground. Last point I'll make, and then I'll turn it over, is we have to continue to break down silos and the conflict that holds us back from achieving what we need to on water. The fact is, climate change is terribly disruptive with our water systems. It's not FISS versus farms, North versus South, urban versus rural.

It's we need to balance these needs, and we need to take care of the health of our rivers and our people. I'll say that I'm increasingly inspired by the connection between land conservation and water conservation, led by tribes. Earlier this year, I had a chance to visit the Machupta tribe in Big Chico Creek in Butte County, where they're partnering with the university to actually get land back, ancestral land return funded by the state legislature and the governor, and then put that to use actually managing the land for the benefit of salmonoid recovery. What tribes have educated us is that actually prescribed fire, cultural fire, was used not only to reduce wildfire risk, but to actually cool temperatures for fish in the summer. So breaking down this distinction between land and water conservation is important.

And then lastly, just again, finding common ground so that we can restore the health of our fisheries and rivers, build the certainty of our water supply. It's never going to be an or, an either or, it's always going to be an and. So, senator, just huge thanks for your years of leadership on this and your leadership once again of this forum.

16:05 - 16:28

Speaker 1

No. Thank you so much. And, mister secretary, I know that you are gonna need to roll out here in just a moment. What I'd like to be able to do is I just wanna make sure that you were able to share your opening statement. I want to say thank you so much to Senator Cortese, who's also joining us here today.

And I want to see Senator Cortese has any opening remarks or any questions, for the secretary, and we're grateful that you're here. Senator Cortese, it's really great to see you, sir.

16:29 - 19:01

Speaker 3

Senator Thank you. It's great to be here, I appreciate, you know, having been appointed to this committee a couple of years ago, it's one of the better places to be in terms of getting the kind of information that we need to do our jobs, try to help you folks out. I don't have a lot of big questions. There are two or three things that popped into my head while you were talking in terms of restoration fisheries, riparian areas, the last example you just gave in Butte County, in Santa Clara County with the miles and miles. I think there's if you go by the area that was consumed by fire, 600,000 acres, most of which is in my district, which is hard for people to believe since I represent 80% of San Jose, essentially Silicon Valley.

And I hate to hit you with this question, especially if you're in a big hurry, but maybe the nutshell version of the novel. I know it's an area that the Pro Tem is interested in too, always has been given his district and otherwise illegal growths. We have riparian areas in the Mount Hamilton Range, the Diablo Range are populated with trout. They are spring fed, they always have been. They come down from the highest altitude you know, generally source pick up volume and depth and quantity of water.

And when you get into the fall of the year here, you know, it's a real important time for habitat. What's happening in the last few years outside of drought years is all of a sudden we're seeing that water dry up. If you're out in the rangeland or you talk to the range associations, they'll tell you there's all kinds of water. You know, the springs are trying to feed those corridors, so what's happening? So people are making, drawing conclusions sometimes from law enforcement information, sometimes from what we think we just know from doing these jobs for a long time and sometimes anecdotal.

How big of an issue is that? That's all I'm really asking. You know, it's something I think, something I think a lot a lot of members of the legislature have some experience with and would like to follow-up on, like to be helpful with.

19:01 - 19:42

Speaker 2

Yeah. I'll just say at the highest level, and I'll turn it over to director Bonham because he's spending a lot of time on it. It's a big deal. You know, in certain parts of the state, these illegal cannabis grows are decimating the environment. Not only are they diverting water, but they're introducing illegal pesticides, rodenticides that are getting into the ecosystem.

They're horrible. I mean, they're and that's just on the environmental from the environmental standpoint. So, as Director Bonham will share, there has been increased enforcement, and there is a focus on continuing to increase enforcement, get those illegal grows out. You know, like I said like I would say on these other topics, proud of some of our progress, but with more work ahead. But maybe Director Bonham?

19:42 - 19:49

Speaker 1

And if it's all right, Director Bonham, I'm going have you I know you have opening remarks that you're going be providing. I'll just Wait for my answer. Yeah, that's great.

19:49 - 19:52

Speaker 4

I can build. That's perfect. That's great. Whichever you prefer.

19:52 - 19:58

Speaker 1

Right after your opening remarks, if that's okay. Anything else for Secretary Crowfoot before he has to roll out?

19:58 - 20:16

Speaker 3

No, I appreciate your appreciate your work. And I I think for as for as for my office, we'd love to, you know, to get, you know, whatever the information is or sort of the audit trail on some of those restoration projects, especially the ones that the tribes are helping to fund and and drive just as best practices.

20:16 - 20:24

Speaker 2

Absolutely. And would love to share more about the progress of wetland restoration as well in the bay, thanks to Measure A and there's a lot of great work happening in your district.

20:24 - 20:29

Speaker 3

Big deal in my office. Thank you. And I appreciate the Pro Tem mentioning LVSL a while ago.

20:29 - 20:30

Speaker 1

Was Hey, so there we go.

20:30 - 20:31

Speaker 3

It's like, you know

20:31 - 20:31

Speaker 1

A hot deal.

20:31 - 20:33

Speaker 3

All right. Thank you.

20:33 - 21:10

Speaker 1

No, thank you so much. Secretary, before you head out and I know you have another meeting just quick glimpse and some of this isn't a crystal ball. Yeah. Your prediction over the next twelve to twenty four months in regards to federal funding, we have been attached to the hip of the federal government when it comes to restoration work across the state. A lot of federal funds are coming in for restoration work, both on cold water habitat for creeks and streams, but then also, obviously, forestry restoration throughout the state.

What's your prediction on that? And I can't believe it's going to be very No. It's going be a bit dire.

21:10 - 22:09

Speaker 2

I mean, I would say all bets are off. I can tell you that we're working professionally with our colleagues in these federal agencies to make the case for continued investments. These are investments that support rural economies. They support the fishing sector. They demonstrate success.

And we've seen cuts to these projects as recently as last week. So our focus is doing what we can through state funding and, again, cutting bureaucracy to get these projects in place and to continue to to make the case. I can tell you this. As remarkable as the state investment has been, thanks to you all and Governor Newsom, it's not enough. You know, the federal government simply can't divest in our fisheries in order for our fisheries to recover.

It just can't happen. So we'll continue to make the case for that and to persevere. But, you know, I just want to be clear eyed that we haven't seen signs of support from this new administration, really, in any respect.

22:09 - 22:38

Speaker 1

Yeah. And I think that, the ongoing concern will be, and I don't want to predetermine, but with the state side funds that are available, that is supposed to look at program expansion project expansion across the state. Some of this may have to be used to be able to backfill, some of what we may lose. Again, I don't wanna look into that crystal ball too far, but we're in a situation of do or die on some of these projects.

22:38 - 23:16

Speaker 2

Well, and I'll say the, you know, the hasty and disorganized cutting of large portions of the federal workforce not only impact projects that haven't happened, they they impact operations right now. Our federal network of refuges, for example, we've been very concerned around those early cuts from Doge and what they did to those programs and those federal facilities. And now, with the shutdown, there continues to be uncertainty, even as we speak here today, about will there be enough federal staff to actually operate the facilities that the federal government right now has a responsibility to operate.

23:16 - 23:43

Speaker 1

100%. Secretary, thank you. Very grateful that you're here. Appreciate your work, sir. Since it certainly meant what I said is that, you are active and engaged and you deliver.

And you're really good at the governmental side. And then also, what I really appreciate is that you directly engage folks at the community level. And especially when times are hot, that's what folks expect. And I am grateful for that leadership style, sir.

23:43 - 23:59

Speaker 2

Well, and lastly, I'll just say this has been a remarkable seven years since I've been in this role. And if you look at the amount of funding that our legislative leaders have delivered in partnership with the governor, there's no comparison. Yeah. So, we are doing more than we ever have, even as the challenges are greater than they've ever been.

24:00 - 24:26

Speaker 1

A 110%. Thank you so much. Secretary Crowfoot, appreciate you. Thank you for being here. Ladies and gentlemen, committee, we're now gonna be turning over to the longest serving director of the Department of Fish and Wildlife.

Grateful for his work. He's gonna be updating us on the department priorities for 2026. He's gonna be focusing on salmon fishery issues, dungeons, crab fishing issues, and then, obviously, all other fishery and aquaculture items. Better report. Director Bottom, the floor is yours.

We're grateful for your leadership, sir. Welcome.

24:26 - 39:41

Speaker 4

Great. Thank you, senator, committee members. I'd like to do three things. I'd like to step back and do a quick survey across many different fishery updates. Then I'd like to zoom in and talk a moment just about salmon.

And then I'll end by backing up again and closing with remaining, like, fishery updates and address the senator's question about illegal cannabis cultivation. Maybe in your position, I know in my position, I'm often either hearing complaint or compliment, and can be both on the same topic. And that is true for some of our fishery issues, of course. But to begin, what I really wanna do, because I'm not sure who's watching and I have the captive microphone for a moment, is help people understand all California, all the Department of Fish and Wildlife is doing for the public interest, for those things that live in the ocean. So this is one of our oldest core work areas at the department.

When you go into our files, you can find historical photos. They're the black and white photos of sailboats, literally schooners, men and women doing scientific work in the ocean, and managing the historic fisheries like we've read about his youth at Cannery Row, and anchovies, and sardines. And when you think about this context, and look even to the beginning of time, of course, we've had indigenous people, native American tribes sustainably managing in the ocean since the beginning of the time and in their cultures. If you're an angler, you you've got hope baked into your DNA. Whether you're a recreationalist or a commercialist, every time you throw that line out, you're hopeful that you'll catch something.

It's not a strategy hope, but it is something you can base joy in and think about the positive. So here are a couple of things that were happening at the 2024 coming into this year, which I think are an expression of that hope and that joy. At the end the summer and end of last year, we had a ground fish based boat season for the first time in the Calcod Conservation Area in more than twenty years. So you're always hearing about loss of opportunity. Here's a tangible new opportunity after twenty years.

At the end of last year, we celebrated the seventy fifth anniversary of something called the California Cooperative Oceanic Fisheries Investigation Program. That is the biggest, longest kind of effort to gather information in the fishery space that's been conducted on the West Coast. And then when you start to think about the work the department does for you, our constituents, it's spread across about 5,800 square miles. San Francisco Bay is included. San Pablo Bay to the Carquinez Bridge is included.

And then you can look at the states still thriving, and we need to help them thrive more port areas. Santa Barbara, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Eureka, San Diego, Bodega Bay, Monterey, Fort Bragg, Morro Bay. Looking at the data for 2024, and we aren't complete on 2025, folks brought in 117,684 pounds of seafood. A total x vessel, which means the amount paid to the fishermen, man or woman at the dock, was about 190,000,000. And in our commercial fishing space, the top value fishery for quite some time has been market squid, and it came in at about 67,000,000.

It's also the top weight, about a 130,000 pounds. You can break these dynamics out in a lot of different statistics, but we still have, when you look at vessel registration and fishing license, about 3,000 vessels that are out there trying to make a living on the ocean, and about 5,500 licenses that are being sold in the commercial fishing space overall. You can start to try to understand our top fisheries. You can look at that by weight or value. Weight, you really see squid, dungeness crab, anchovies, sardine.

When you go to value, you have some fish that really aren't weight, if you will, at the dock, but are incredibly value valuable. So you'll see market squid at the top of both, Dungeness crab up in that perennial second place right behind squid. But then you'll see spiny lobster come up. Not much weight, but a lot of value, red sea urchin, halibut. So then you can turn to our recreationalist, and you can see kind of what's going on in that space.

Over the course of twenty twenty four, we collected data from about 77,000 angler trips. So hardworking men and women who are your public employees engaging with anglers at the dock, running them through questionnaires, that's an estimated recreational fishing trip in our ocean waters of 2,100,000 fishing trips. That's its own industry in your districts, for all the secondary services that relate to people coming in and out of our coastal areas. Total fish caught in that recreational space last year, an estimated 4,200,000. And we know that from measurements collected, from about 80,000 fish.

You can also get a sense of what people like to fish for recreationally. The tunas are extremely popular. And in one of the most ironic but super depressing dynamics around a warming ocean, we may be seeing tuna way further north, farther north than we've ever seen them before. Rockfish comes in kind of second, our halibut, our sand sandabs, our soles, our starry flounder. That's kind of where you see our top tier most preferred recreational fisheries.

When you think about licenses sold in the recreational space, we're selling about 1,500,000 recreational angling licenses a year. I'd say that's in the bound of pretty predictable for the last couple of decades, a little bit more, a little bit less. We sell a lot of spiny elastir report cards, about 33,000. And I think right now in Southern California, we have the opening of the lobster fishery going on. Our marine staff actually also do a lot of permitting.

With our commission, they're putting out experimental fishing permits, which we'll talk about in a moment in the crab space. They're doing a lot of permitting for the collection of science, particularly in our MPA network. All the researchers need permission to be in those spaces and take fish for purposes of their science. We're doing artificial reef work. We're out with, you know, probably almost 20 different types of vessels doing all of this scientific work.

And then, when you think with our enforcement staff, we have 50 full time wildlife officers out in the ocean. They're on seven large patrol vessels and several large skiffs, everywhere from the border with Baja all the way to the border with Oregon doing enforcement. That's the broadness of the work. And then when you zoom in on particular fisheries, I'm a salmon person by passion and by prior careers. So let's talk a little bit about where we are in salmon.

Everyone in this room knows we've had a very difficult three years. But just as the senator mentioned in his opening, we've had a couple of moments of super fantastic joy this summer. After two years of complete closure, people got to go out with their families and their kids and fish in the ocean. That happened in the summer season in early June with great conditions, lots of participants, high catch rates. We caught our 7,000 fish recreational harvest kinda guideline in a short two days, early June.

But people loved it. They remembered what they used to be doing and it has created great optimism. We did this again in fall recently, the September, September '7. It was a much smaller geographic area. Point Reyes down to Point Sur.

Same kind of dynamic. In a quick couple of days, a lot of people out, success rates high, happiness. We were able to do this in part because we did something for the first time. Working through the federal process, our state leaders in the fisheries, tribes and others, our department deployed a guideline, a harvest catch rate guideline, where we set an upper limit, we tracked it instantaneously, and we called the fishery off when we got close to that benchmark. It's the first time we've tried it.

Technology is helping us do more of that. I foresee that as part of our future. The docs were bustling. So now let's talk about the future. I, of course, can't make a guarantee as I sit here in September or October 2025.

We won't fully know until we get into the early spring of next year, but I'm very optimistic we're gonna have both a recreational season and one of our first commercial seasons in quite some time. Can't guarantee it, but all the anecdotal information we're getting from folks in the ocean, a lot of our preliminary work indicates we've got more fish. More fish than we've had in the last three years, and part of that is just based on the simple fact it's rained more going back three years ago in the last several years than it was right before that in the period of drought. So when you think about these improved, like hydrology conditions, the rain, you think about some of the surgical increased hatchery production we've been doing around Fall Run Chinook, you think about your investment in our technologies around parental based tagging, our ability to fine tune some of our release strategies out of our hish our hatcheries, preliminary data suggesting the abundance of young fish holding out in the ocean is looking pretty good. Certainly much better than it has in the prior, say, three to four years.

But even within those good parts of my update, there are some difficult parts. The pro tem and secretary Crowfoot were talking about federal issues. We're going to have to to drastically reduce our Chinook salmon production levels at the Nimbus fish factory, not too far from here, up on the American River. It's owned by the federal government. We operate it under contract.

It's been happening for like fifty years. But due to a reduced budget starting this fall, our fall run production levels are gonna drop from around 4,500,000 smolts to about 2,250,000 smolts. And you can see a corresponding kind of proportional drop on steelhead production. That's an issue. We're gonna spend a lot of time trying to change the federal government's opinion on the contract and the amount of money, but we're in the middle of that right now.

We know enough to forecast we may have to reduce some of that production. But even when you have a moment of less joy, we can find other moments of great hope in the data we're seeing right now. Let's talk about winter run. One of our most consistently imperiled fisheries that keeps the whole fisheries dynamic kind of in a more curtailed, conservative approach because we have so few of them, we have to manage for that heightened risk. We're expecting higher than average natural production of winter run this year.

And a lot of that's reflected by some of our calculations on the estimates of how many reds, which as you all know are kind of the nesting bed created in the water, in the riverbed for the young fish. We're seeing an estimate of a little over 3,000 reds right now in a part of the Sacramento system, and that's a high number. And when you think about that coupled with the good spawning, incubation temperatures, the low rates of red dewatering, we're actually feeling really optimistic about a turnaround in the winter run compared to where it was three years or five years ago. Livingston Stone National Fish Hatchery, as an example, has met their spawning targets, and that's good this soon. And then when you turn to spring run, we're seeing really strong returns in Mill And Deer Creeks, Butte Creek compared to more recent history.

And we go to Deer Creek, we've been doing adult snorkel counts from this summer, and we see 343 adults. Last year, it was 33. A year before that, it was only 16. And when you look at video counts in that same creek, we're at 60 fish, and a year ago, that was 18. So that field work that's being done by California's public servants in conjunction with tribes more and more across the state is showing we have reason to be optimistic as we head into 2025.

Butte Creek's a similar example. Looking at those numbers, you get a rough estimate of about 5,500 to 6,000 adults this year, which is more like twenty fourteen. And last year, there were fewer than 50. Some similar stories in the Feather River on fish counted at the Department of Water Resources new fish monitoring station through last week. So things are looking good.

And then when you go very large on salmon, I've got to come back to where we were two years ago when we launched the salmon strategy.

39:41 - 39:43

Speaker 1

Wait about two more minutes, sir.

39:44 - 39:47

Speaker 4

Give me one second to think about how do you best use two minutes.

39:47 - 39:48

Speaker 1

There we go.

39:49 - 43:19

Speaker 4

71 actions in the Salmon strategy. A year ago, we reported 67% were underway, 26% were fully done. Then you can turn to crab. And let me say on crab, we owe a huge thanks to the men and women who fish for crab. To you, senator Maguire, and the Pacific Coast, Federation of Fishermen's Associations, we have had a very successful effort at distributing marked line.

Marked line is really important because it allows us to understand which gear may be entangling marine mammals and how to attribute it to which sectors for purposes of making management decisions. We had two events, August and September. We had over 360 Dungeness crab permitted fishermen and women show up. We've had additional distribution events across the whole coast, and we've gotten out the door about 4,000 coils of line, and we've distributed all that at no charge to folks using the million dollars in the OPC funding, which you've helped produce through the annual budget cycle process. Groundfish, another great story.

You know this well because of Del Norte County. Go back about fifteen months ago, and we were dramatically reducing fishing opportunity for quill back and closing that. But we took a hard look at the science, the science that you support by investing in our department, and we realized the science was not as sharp as it should have been, and the stocks weren't as declined as many were suggesting in the federal scientific space. We've reopened it, working hard with NOAA fisheries and local communities. Crab, as you mentioned, was a shortened season yet again.

More or less starting January and wrapping up in some sort of sequence, April, May, and June. But nonetheless, a lot of people on the water made $55,000,000, which puts the total value still within about the average looking backwards over the last ten years. Let me end with a story. I think I might have thirty seconds. And this is an example of how you can make a difference where you sit, and I can share with you the story of that success.

We've been running large patrol vessels up and down the coast for a long time. One of them, I think the swordfish was about 20 years old. Four years ago, three years ago, when the general fund surplus era, the legislature approved, the governor endorsed an investment in our department. We specked a new patrol boat. It's called the Barracuda.

We have it in Hefman Bay. Why is that important? We were able to build it with a bigger platform on back and a better hoist technology coming out of the stern so that when our enforcement officers are out collecting abandoned fishing gear in the ocean to reduce the risk of entangling whales, they can collect more of it on one trip faster and more safely, saving multiple trips back to the harbor to gas and go back out. It's an efficiency that's been produced for the good of fishermen and women and our species because of your leadership in the appropriation space. And with that, I'll send it back to you for any questions.

Thank you.

43:19 - 43:30

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Mr. Director. Grateful for your work, Mr. Director. Before we turn it over to Senator Cortese, if you want to address the issue of cannabis and, those illicit grows and the impact on the fishery, please.

43:30 - 43:32

Speaker 4

As I'm getting older, I'm forgetting No.

43:32 - 43:33

Speaker 3

No. You're I'm

43:33 - 45:49

Speaker 4

supposed to do at the panel. It's a real deal, senator Cortese. It's been a real impact for our natural systems for some time, and the governor is taking it more serious than any other state in These United States. He has formed a unified cannabis enforcement task force. I co chair it with the director of cannabis control.

It is patterned on similar enforcement activities on illegal substances like fentanyl, where you sit with your intelligence gathering agencies, you sit with your local law enforcement, you sit with your Department of Justice, all of your other unified enforcement entities, and you're designing risk profiles, and you're conducting operations to go after these e legal criminal enterprises that are doing harm to our environment, producing substances that can harm our people, and our department is specially trained to follow these criminal actors as far into the backcountry and wilderness as they may go. So to give you examples of success on this front, between April 2025, this unified task force served 214 search warrants, completed about a 100 arrests, and took $476,000,000 worth of illegally cultivated cannabis off the market. Just in that short time frame. The task force has been up and running almost two years. The total number is north of a billion of seized off the market.

And just this month, September 25, our department did a specialized operation in the North Coast area to take off the landscape about 21,000, cannabis plants where we're still finding the use of illegal pesticides, which are harmful to the environment, our employees, and the public if it gets into the stream of commerce.

45:51 - 46:21

Speaker 1

I'll just say, going turn it over to Senator Cortese. I think that the biggest challenge that we have, and, Mr. Director, feel free to chime in on this, is enforcement dollars, right? I think we had that one focus North Coast is some of the most egregious, Alyssa Groves. That one time 1,500,000, I think that's think Mendocino County maybe has 300,000 left, somewhere right in there.

That is just the biggest challenge that we have of having the dollars be able

46:21 - 46:59

Speaker 4

to do these joint operations. In many ways, the challenge is reasonably well understood. One of the main transitions that appears to me is some of this illegal activity has moved off of public onto private lands Yeah. Which has been a transition in the recent couple of years. But because the problem is generally understood on how to scope for scale, it really does become how do you generate the year over year capacity Mhmm.

To apply it to the ongoing problem.

46:59 - 47:02

Speaker 1

Thank you, Mr. Director. Senator Cortese, floor is yours, sir.

47:03 - 51:30

Speaker 3

Thank you, Chairman Maguire. I appreciate the, you know, the comments and the report the overall report. On cannabis issue, know, again what I was trying to say maybe a little more explicitly is we know really just by deduction that when you have a stream that's flowing or should be flowing, it's flowing in certain parts of its corridor and not in others that in in the springs that are feeding, you know, that that corridor are are running, you know, typical artesian, to the point where you can see surface water coming from the springs and you've got it dried up, essentially dried up fishery habitat. Obviously, somebody's dammed it up. Yes.

You know, I think probably the state of the art is as simple as, you know, damming it up, putting a a solar sump pump in the water, and then pumping the water, to irrigate, right? Yes. Which can be done all summer long and the driest part of some of that property, private or public. I guess I would just like to know going forward what we can do. I appreciate what Chair Maguire said about the enforcement dollars.

Having been we've both been county supervising having been a county supervisor, there's a reluctance to to take sheriff deputies out of the urban area and up into those areas. I think on two levels. One, they're pulling them off of human enforcement activity in the urban areas that that may be life and death. Secondly, fear. Know, that's real.

I've heard testimony, maybe not the exact use of that word, but we don't want to go up there with insufficient boots on the ground because we might not come out. I know without mentioning names, a fishing game officer from our area who's a tremendous reputation. I think was shot in the in the thigh by one of those, I'm sure you're quite familiar with that, one of those, perpetrators. You know, all the reason in the world to be, you know, sort of humanly reluctant to go in without. This is something that if you were probably in some kind of combat you'd have air support and all kinds of things helping you out, not just a scout troop that's going out there.

I don't mean a scouting troop, I mean the equivalent of you know, a US army, you know, set of advanced scouts going out there hoping they don't run into Mhmm. You know, enemy fire. And that's what we these are not and you I know you know this, and I know you know I mean none of none of what I'm saying is exaggeration. This is actually happening. People get hurt.

So all I want to know going forward and so we don't have to take the deep dive today in an informational hearing that has a packed agenda, but is is just information to my office. Yes. We want to be informed as to what we can do. I think it's hard in our subcommittees to say this somewhat gingerly, but I think with executive agencies where budget appropriations have sort of been established before we start trying to work them over. Not easy to get alternative spending scenarios, and frankly it's not easy to sell our urban members on why we're even why we didn't prioritize in something like this.

So anything you can do to elevate not just the need but quantify it what actions we could take. You're never going to see a prop 36 for these kind of problems. And I think there are probably people in the representing some of these rural areas of the state who are otherwise very progressive, know, who would be very, very willing to step up penalties. These aren't ordinary trespass.

51:30 - 51:30

Speaker 4

That's

51:30 - 52:47

Speaker 3

right. You know, these aren't, you know, ordinary minor, they're certainly not misdemeanors, they're not minor felonies when you're completely destroying waterways and habitat. So I didn't intend to make a speech. I just want to invite, you know, it's just an invitation. You know, I think I'm on my own behalf and on behalf of others in the legislature who are interested in carrying legislation and working with the Pro Tem's office and others who have been working on these kind of issues to bring forward whether that's two bills, three bills, four bills, you know, maybe there's a package of bills somewhere that just is really just on the enforcement side.

That's right. Not on the federal issues, not on licensing, not on banking, not on transport. You know, all these other issues that we run into with commercial, with legal and illegal growth, but just what can we do about enforcement? And what would you do? With all your experience, you must have some thoughts.

Know, if you could wave a magic wand and get, you know, three or four bills that Yeah. Did exactly gave you exactly the support that you wanted to help eradicate this problem, what would that be? I I think we'd love to hear that. Whether we could pull it off or not, who knows? I think we'd love to hear that.

52:48 - 52:51

Speaker 4

I appreciate the invitation. We'll follow-up this week with your office.

52:52 - 52:57

Speaker 3

Any time. We're in inter recess. It's a good time to Yeah. You know, take your time and get back to us.

52:57 - 54:08

Speaker 4

And I just wanna tell you directly the facts you raise as impact, drying up streams, dewatering habitat for fish, leaving diversion, water diversion infrastructure. That is a central focus of the filtering we do, working with local law enforcement, coordinating with, the state office of emergency services, our state water board, and our highly specialized marine enforcement team at the department. So when that's occurring in the legal space, we're using administrative authorities, penalties and fines, which have been increased over time because of the legislature's leadership. And we're also helping people come into compliance. But on the illegal front, we're we're in there doing the operation, and then we're getting all that stuff out of our streams so they can get wet again.

That is top of mind for us when we're trying to figure out which watersheds we rank for purposes of prioritization when we go do enforcement and investigations.

54:08 - 54:10

Speaker 3

Good to know. Thank you.

54:12 - 55:04

Speaker 1

Thank you. Thank you so much, Senator Cortese. Doctor Baum, you had, you offer, some glimpse of hope for commercial salmon season that has just been so challenged over the last three years. Talk to us about Dungeness crab, a top tier fishery. Candidly, so many ports are dependent on it for long term economic success.

What do you see especially with whales? And obviously, the department has become much more aggressive in, in its observation efforts both boat and plane. But what do you see right now as we move into what was historically dungeons crab season, Thanksgiving through the new year?

55:05 - 55:17

Speaker 4

So, this weighs on me. I think about it a lot. Mhmm. In the crab season, you definitely moved me up in your speed dial on your phone.

55:17 - 55:17

Speaker 1

It's true.

55:17 - 56:29

Speaker 4

And we end up engaging a fair amount. And I've learned a lot from your championing your district and trying to find the right balance between these issues. Let me segue out of salmon just to put a final exclamation point on how hard it has been for our salmon salmon communities, and it's been harder for our tribal communities. And I mean no disrespect to our commercial sector when I say some of the most emotional moments for me have been when our tribal chairs tell me they don't have fish for their beginning of creation ceremonies. I saw Chair Atterbury of Karuk last week because the leaders were in town for their tribal forum.

Mhmm. And he told me for the first time in, I think, three years, they had fish for those ceremonies. That feels good Mhmm. Compared to the worst alternative. But on the commercial front, it took too long.

As you know, senator, we were going through a revised federal process.

56:29 - 56:29

Speaker 1

Mhmm.

56:30 - 59:41

Speaker 4

This was not the state's fault in any regard, but we've been finally able to get out the 2023 federal disaster relief package. And we've been able to get about 20,000,000 in federal relief funds out to over 1,200 qualifying California commercial trollers, processors, the passenger fleet vessels, and guides. The salmon 2024 request package that's gone to the federal government, the determination has been made, but we are now in that even more opaque. How will the federal government issue the funding problem? Mhmm.

And then, Sam, in 2025, the request is in queue to submit. So then turn to Crabbe. I think this is something where I'm going to get complaint and I hope a little compliment. And I know you have crab panels behind us. I think on like the marked line dynamic, part of the practical problem is how much gear is out there, how do we keep track of gear, how do we know whose gears, you know, inadvertently getting into what, impact.

That we were able to identify that as an area to solve in, find assistance from you and state funds, collaborate with the Ocean Protection Council, use about a million dollars and get out the door, you know, moving towards 4,000 coils of marked line, and then seeking input from the fleet. What colors? Like, what colors should we use? Remember those conversations and strong opinion on whether we should use purple or black. But getting it out the door, that's fixing part of the challenge.

That's good. Things like the Barracuda and other ways to use some of the legislative direction you've created over your tenure to go get more derelict gear out of the water. Those are all good. But last season was a lot like the year before and the year before and the year before, And that may be the predictor for next year. Last season, we conducted 13 risk assessments.

We did 11 aerial surveys. That's us putting planes in the air with spotters. We're bringing in data streams from all the recreational whale touring vessels, and we're engaging with the fleet and nonprofit conservation groups on a regular frequency. What should we do? What should we do?

What should we do? How elevated or not is the risk? Where are the whales migrating? And if you look at last year, it looks it feels a lot like the prior three or four years. That that beginning most loved traditional moment of November and December is not happening.

59:41 - 59:44

Speaker 1

Yeah. Whales are hanging longer.

59:45 - 01:01:43

Speaker 4

And it's when our whole market structure has been based and I take advantage of this. I walk down to my local fishmonger, and I'm trying to get that crab for Thanksgiving. Mhmm. Or Hanukkah Christmas, whatever your you may be celebrating New Year's. And what we're seeing when we look at that ten year, five year track is it's more like mid January, January.

And then what we're seeing on the backside is just not an open ended anyone can fish like they may like when you get into April, May, and June, but rather starting to do zonal closures Mhmm. And trying to build out that technology of ropeless for that season. Our future might be something that's more predictable in that beginning part of year, still remains uncertain and risky in that holiday season, but we know we can also plan for a pretty reliable spring if we're using this alternative technology gear. Not up to me over time whether our fleets will embrace ropeless gear all year long and always. We're seeing more people wanting to test it in the experimental fishing space.

Uh-huh. Those permits are going out more. People are feeling more confident about it. It may be over time that the market and, you know, people's choice making is they start wanting to try that gear in the holiday season. I don't know.

What we also can't tell, the thing that may have started all of this off in the most accentuated way was the warming of the ocean Yeah. About ten years ago. And, we don't know what pattern we're in right now. That was as you remember, because you and I were in similar spots. The moaic acid, heat, change of migration pattern, food source for whales.

01:01:45 - 01:02:08

Speaker 1

The other piece I think on the craps is in is warmer water conditions and we have a a crap panel. I know we also have mister Schumann here as well. But with this warmer water, the blob, as they call it, and predominance of the moic acid Mhmm. And algal blooms, concerned with that this year?

01:02:09 - 01:02:24

Speaker 4

Haven't had anyone in the department come to me and say, we're seeing the Demoic, like triggers Mhmm. That move us into decision making and management. But I'm super worried about it. Yeah. It's just past experience

01:02:24 - 01:02:25

Speaker 1

we had. That's what I

01:02:26 - 01:02:44

Speaker 4

But even with my discussion a moment ago about crowd, the total value was $55,000,000. Mhmm. And that is right in line with that ten year average.

01:02:47 - 01:02:49

Speaker 1

It's just a shorter season, which is tough.

01:02:49 - 01:03:26

Speaker 4

Yes. And that's a whole transition dynamic that's really hard to struggle with. The most recent information coming some the federal streams of information is entanglements with whales are going up again, not down. Yeah. So at some point, this is the kind of dynamic that'll drive a person like me out of the position I'm in.

Because trying to square all these corners and balance all these interests is just becoming increasingly difficult as we see these dramatic climate disruptions. We are starting to test for domoic acid right around now.

01:03:26 - 01:03:32

Speaker 1

Yeah. And first planes will go up when? Ballpark.

01:03:32 - 01:03:40

Speaker 4

I'm guessing doctor Schuman will text me here in a moment, and I'll because he's behind me. And when he does, I'll tell you that. Alright. I see.

01:03:40 - 01:03:41

Speaker 3

There we go.

01:03:41 - 01:03:45

Speaker 1

I appreciate it. Thank you so much. Senator Cortes, anything else that you have?

01:03:46 - 01:04:35

Speaker 3

Just along with whatever else, you know, you end up providing in terms of potential augmentation, you know, especially by way of legislation, there was some kind of historic trend on FTE overall would be good. Assume it's been fairly stagnant or worse in some of our areas. I appreciate the numbers you gave us earlier on the ocean team, the number of people out there. But I don't need that information right now. I can't do anything right now at the moment but you know II think law abiding folks you can ask California Waterfowl Association.

01:04:35 - 01:04:35

Speaker 4

You can

01:04:35 - 01:05:33

Speaker 3

ask just about any of the groups that you know, support the work that you're doing and support our conservation work. Don't want to run away from enforcement. They'd like to actually see you know, more efficient game officers out there once in a while and and and it could be just a perception that there hasn't been enough growth over the years. I suspect it's not because we have other agencies that have certainly had their challenges in trying to add positions or even fill positions. Just would love to get that kind of information from you.

Just honest, you know, candid information on the graph or something as to how it's been going. I don't know how you differentiate, you know, your your your ocean Yes. Or, you know, waterways enforcement team versus your your land team, but I'm interested in both, but separately.

01:05:33 - 01:06:17

Speaker 4

Be careful what you ask for, senator. I can have a whole suite of information sent over because our department is one of only two departments that have ever done a top to bottom, what's called service based budgeting of our entire budget. We have everything we do broken down to about 6,000 tasks across every labor hour. Mhmm. We track it annually.

We update it every three years. We did this construct with Deloitte. Senator McGuire was very influential in starting that kinda analytical effort. The takeaway, it's publicly known. We talk about it all the time.

We're underfunded by threefold. But we'll send that information out to you. And, senator, to wrap it up, we're gonna be up in the air mid November.

01:06:18 - 01:06:32

Speaker 4

Because we got the possibility of the recreational opener oh, excuse me, mid month, because we have the possibility of recreational open early November. Some of our plan work involves some federal folks, so, you know, question mark.

01:06:32 - 01:09:36

Speaker 1

Okay. No, I appreciate it. Thank you so much. We have a couple of follow ups, for Senator Cortese's office. That's going to be one on the cannabis funding.

The second will be on the FTEs. Appreciate that. Thank you so much. And I know that we're going to be in, contact as Dungeon and Scraps season, is upon us. And I just want to take a moment, mister director, for your work.

It's, it has become an increasingly difficult job. It's always been a tough job. Let's just be blunt. Right? But it is becoming more and more challenging just because the problems become larger and more complicated.

Mhmm. Right? Yep. And folks are being squeezed. And I think the biggest challenge that we have right now, especially within the fleet, is an individual's livelihood.

Mhmm. And when it comes to salmon, when it comes to Dungeness crab, what was always counted on to bring home the bacon simply isn't there anymore. I think that just causes It hurts. Yeah. It's really challenging.

Yep. And I know you work it really hard. So thank you so much, sir. I'm very pleased that you're here. Thank you so much.

Thank you, Mr. Director. All right, ladies and gentlemen, we do appreciate Director Bonham, and for all of his work and to the team as well. We're now going to be moving on to our next panel. We're going to have our panel representing the salmon fleet.

If they can please come forward, we'll take a thirty second break as they get situated. We're going to first welcome Mr. McCubby to be able to come forward. He's the fisheries director for the Yurok tribe. We're also going to invite Mr.

Bradshaw, who will be joining us virtually here today. He's the president of the Pacific Coast Federation Fishermen's Association and, Charlie Schneider, senior project manager for Cal Trout, as well. If you want to come on forward, we're going to give it sixty seconds to get folks situated, and we'll be right back with you. All right, ladies and gentlemen, we're now back. We're going to be talking all issues of the challenges and opportunities for California salmon season.

We welcome our esteemed panelists here. First and foremost, we're going to talk to Mr. McCovey representing the Uruk tribe. I got to say, one of the experts on all issues, Sam, and he's the fisheries director for the Uruk tribe. He has spent two decades with the tribal fisheries program and now serves as the fisheries director.

He's gonna be talking candidly about the tribe's leadership, and a lot of that is under the chair and himself on salmon restoration and water quality and the stewardship of the Klamath. Then we're gonna turn it over virtually to mister Bradshaw, and then we're gonna hear from mister Schneider. Mister McCovey, the floor is yours. You have five minutes. As you get close, I'll give you a thirty second prompt.

01:09:36 - 01:12:45

Speaker 6

Okay. Great. Thank you, senator Maguire, senator Cortese, for the invite. I'm here representing the York tribe. You guys originally had invited chairman James.

Chairman James couldn't make it today, so I'm here instead, but, chairman James sends his regard, senator. So, thanks for that. I'm gonna talk a bit about the Klamath River more specifically and Sam in particular. I'm going to talk a little bit about some challenges we're facing right now. I'm going talk about some of the successes that we've had recently in the last year or so.

And then I'm going to talk a bit about some of the opportunities that we have in front of us. So, first, the bad news, some of the challenges that we're facing. So, as, Senator McGuire, you pointed out, as did the secretary and and the director, things aren't great right now for salmon in California, and that includes the Klamath River. I think the run size prediction for 2025 was was one of the lowest predictions on record since we've been keeping track of this since the late '70s, early '80s. Not a lot of opportunities for fishing.

The state fishery was closed. The state recreational fishery on the Klamath River was closed. The tribal fishery was very small, a very miniscule amount of fish available for the tribe to harvest, not nearly enough to meet even our subsistence needs, let alone the tribe's commercial needs. The tribe hasn't had a successful commercial fishery since 2015. And so, director Bonham mentioned that tribes have been affected by this, and and, he's telling the truth when he says that.

You know, the overarching kind of thing that has been mentioned a couple times here is climate change, and that's definitely something that we're dealing with in the Klamath Basin. We're seeing higher water temperatures. We're seeing catastrophic wildfire and the impacts that that has on fisheries. We're seeing all these things happen, and we're not seeing it slow down. We've had some good years related to rain and snowpack, but the overall trend, we feel like, is still in the wrong direction.

Things aren't changing as far as global climate change goes, and so that's a challenge that we're facing right now today and that we're going to continue to face on into the future. We're dealing with funding issues, of course, with the federal government. That's something that I think everyone's dealing with. That's going to be challenging. We're going to have to work together.

We're going have to be creative to figure our way out from underneath of this and work through all this. Then from a federal level, on the Klamath, we're also really concerned about how ESA, in relation to river flows, is going to be protected or not protected moving forward into the future. Right now, a lot of river flows on the Klamath are dictated by ESA, and the ESA might not look the same as

01:12:45 - 01:14:30

Speaker 6

has in the past as we move into the future. That's kind of some of the bad news. But there's a lot of good news, too, and this has been pointed out. Dam removal, of course. Over the last couple of years, we removed the four dams on the Klamath, the largest dam removal project in history, probably one of the largest fish restoration projects in history.

Fish are returning. We saw fish returning last year. Fish are starting to come back this year. We're doing a lot of restoration in the Klamath. Investment, and there's been a huge state investment into restoration in the Klamath.

It's not just dam removal. There's restoration projects going on in in the in the Scott River. There's rest the restoration projects going on, related to the impacts of of catastrophic wildfire, and there's restoration projects going on in the Trinity River, a lot of this work was funded by the state of California. And those projects are ongoing, and we're making great progress there. Of course, Proposition four funding, looking forward in the future, that's going to be huge to continue the work that's happening in the Klamath Basin.

Recently, was passed, AB two sixty three. I think the governor may have just signed that. That's helpful to secure baseline minimum river flows in two really important tributaries on the Klamath. That's going to be helpful as we move forward. We know that to make wild fish, we need habitat and we need river flows.

And so with the investments in restoration, we're working on the habitat part. And with things like AB two sixty three and working with our federal agencies, we're working on securing water flows. Water flows plus habitat equal fish.

01:14:31 - 01:14:32

Speaker 1

We have about thirty seconds.

01:14:32 - 01:15:05

Speaker 6

Okay. And then opportunities for the future. We're not done with dam removal. There's still a lot of work to do there. We can work together on this.

We can there's a lot of opportunities for people to work with private landowners, with farmers, with ranchers. We can all kind of work together on a lot of these restoration projects, not just dam removal. I think there's a big opportunity for us to all work together to secure river flows. Again, habitat and adequate flows and water quality equal, good healthy populations of wild fish. Thank you.

01:15:05 - 01:15:51

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, mister McCovey. We're grateful you're here, and please give our best to Chairman James in Missham, and appreciate you being here today. We're now gonna turn it over to George Bradshaw. He is president of the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Association. He is a lifelong fisherman out of Crescent City and, of course, serves as president of PCFFA.

We're grateful that Mr. Bradshaw is going to be joining us, and I know that we also have a big meeting tomorrow for the fleet, and appreciate that he's made himself available today virtually, and do apologize about the scheduling conflicts. Mister Bradshaw, mister president, good afternoon. You have five minutes, sir, and we'll give you a thirty second prompt as you, get close to your time. The floor is yours.

01:15:53 - 01:15:56

Speaker 7

Alright. Thank you. Good afternoon. Do and I coming in clear?

01:15:56 - 01:15:59

Speaker 1

You're coming loud and clear. Looking good. Thank you so much.

01:15:59 - 01:22:59

Speaker 7

Perfect. Alright. Thank you. And, first off, I wanna say thanks for the opportunity to speak here today. You know, voiced our opinions from the commercial fleet.

And I wanna apologize for not being able to, be in person, but as you said, senator, there's a pretty booked schedule ahead. You know, I I'll follow kind of the same trend. I'll I'll highlight some, you know, positive actions. You know, speakers before me have have spoke to some of them, and then some also concerning topics and, you know, stuff that we might be able to do to secure a better future moving forward. You know, what was also mentioned earlier was, you know, the large project of the Klamath Dam removal.

The federation was, you know, a key supporter in that project, and, you know, the long term viability of that upper basin, you know, needed that project to happen for, you know, continued success of of our salmon populations. You know, as the director and and secretary mentioned, you know, PBT is another, you know, big positive win for for fisheries and for salmon and for management moving forward. It's, you know, a record breaking and and new scientific technology to monitor, our fish, not only, you know, the hatchery populations of cut wire tag, but also the natural populations. We'll also help us in, you know, some of our reintroduction plans moving forward. You know, fry releases, diversifying our hatchery release portfolio, you know, trying to get better life strategies for our hatchery productions has been, very positive in the last, you know, five years or so.

It's, you know, I think already showing benefits as, you know, director Bonham mentioned for, what we saw in the ocean in our, you know, very short recreational fisheries. I mentioned a little bit about it, you know, our salmon, reintroduction efforts. You know, those are being, enacted right now into, you know, key tributaries for the spring run and winter run and, you know, Sacramento and Central Valley. You know, this is another, you know, positive momentum to get those fish back into their natal waters and preserve the genetics, you know, and we look forward to, supporting that moving, you know, moving forward. Another really great project that hasn't been highlighted yet is that, nature like fishway passage on the Yuba.

It's gonna open up, some more spawning habitat and and give, you know, anadronous species and others access, you know, back into some more of their natal grounds. You know, a very good project and and, you know, a a lot of hope there in the future for it. You know, some of our concerning topics, however, is, you know, the speed report spoke, you know, mister Makovi to the Klamath. You know, we have some concerns of, you know, Fall Creek hatchery and not meeting, fruit stock, you know, egg cake goals. You know, it didn't perform well last year.

You know, looking into it with the agencies and the tribes of, you know, what could potentially be done differently this year to try to achieve some of those egg cake goals, I think, is very important. One of the biggest issues I think that we face for the Central Valley is is and and around the state is, you know, our aging the aging hatchery infrastructure. It's a pillar of the salmon recovery. You know, governor's salmon recovery plan, you know, it's going to take some investments, you know, and there's a lot of work to do. Most of those facilities, at least the anadromous ones, are at least half a century old, fifty, sixty, seventy years.

You know, we need to invest in that. We need, you know, for the Central Valley, increased hatchery production. We we went through drought, had some investments from legislature and state to, you know, increase some productions at various hatcheries to try to combat and lighten the impacts of drought, which I think, you know, we did the best that we could, but those need to be looked at and reassessed and and reinvested in as well. You know, we obviously have a continued water problem in all of our rivers and basins. You know, we need to do all that we can to juggle, you know, that water resource that the secretary talked about.

You know, there is competing interests, obviously, and and, you know, trying to find a happy medium to, you know, stretch that resource the best that we can. And then, I guess, you know, obviously, for the commercial fleet and, you know, recreational anglers as well, but, you know, our our three years of complete consecutive closures has been devastating to our coastal communities and, you know, individual fishermen. You know, as the director mentioned, we we did get one year of, you know, federal disaster relief funding two and a half years after the first closure. You know? But I can't express any clear, you know, the the the negative impact that that has had to, you know, not just the fishermen, but the, you know, rural coastal communities and communities at large that, you know, support and, you know, the fishery support, and and they depend on those fisheries to bring revenue and excitement to, you know, those coastal regions.

You know, I'll wrap up, you know, with just highlighting again, you know, that we we, senator and and, you know, committee staff, that we are in desperate need of of hatchery infrastructure investment in the Central Valley. McMillan report, you know, that was just done and and was supported through the legislature as well, you know, highlights a lot of those infrastructure needs. You know, again, like I said, it's part of the salmon strategy plan, one of the main pillars of it. And, you know, while we're doing that, though, it you know, not just the hatchery needs infrastructure themselves. We need to keep in mind, you know, the production goals and production needs, that could support, fisheries and escapements, you know, in the Central Valley.

You know, on the Klamath side, like I said, you know, I I I think that we need to ensure that fall that Fall Creek gets the brood stock needed to meet those production goals because, you know, in our view, you know, the intent there was to boost in a short period, you know, the the poor salmon populations, which was a crucial tool in our minds, you know, to ex expedite that upper basin recovery. And, you know, we need to, you know, put all of our heads together and try to figure out how to, ensure that we get that Falk Creek Hatchery, you know, operating correctly.

01:23:00 - 01:23:00

Speaker 1

Thank you.

01:23:00 - 01:23:01

Speaker 7

Thank you for the time today.

01:23:01 - 01:23:41

Speaker 1

No. Thank you so much, mister president. We're grateful that you've joined us. And, again, know that it is a busy week, and, appreciate your flexibility, mister president. It's good to see you.

We're gonna open up questions just a moment. But before we do, we're gonna turn it over to mister Schneider, senior project manager for Cal Trout. And I just wanna say thank you because, let's just be honest, tough time. Right? And Cal Trout has been on the front lines to be able to preserve, the waterways of this state, for healthy habitat.

You're going be talking about the threats and solutions that we are seeing for California salmon runs. Mister Schneider, thank you so much for taking time in your busy schedule. The floor is yours. You have five minutes. I'll give you a thirty second prompt.

01:23:41 - 01:29:35

Speaker 8

Thank you so much, senator. Happy to be here and, really appreciate the invite. Yeah. Cal Trout's a nonprofit organization. We've been working in the state for about fifty years, and we use science restoration and policy to solve for the needs of fish, water, and people.

We have about 60 active restoration projects across the state, and we're working to ensure wild fish thrive, here in California. California is a salmon state. Many of the other speakers have touched on it. The status of salmon in California is not great. In 2017, we published our SOS two report, and that report found that if current trends continue, 45% of California salmonids, that salmon and trout are likely to be extinct in the next fifty years.

You know, as as director Bonham mentioned, we're as anglers, we're hopeful. And so I'd like to touch on some of that hope. I think hope is the the fuel for momentum, right, to to keep this ball moving forward. We're so grateful to the people of California for approving prop four and providing that investment in the future of our waterways. Several of the other speakers have mentioned the Klamath Dam removal.

And just this week, the first Chinook salmon was observed moving above Keno Dam passing the fish ladder, which is really exciting. And I wanna touch on some rivers that are close to my heart, is the Mendocino Coast, and I know Zeke greater would be proud as well. But several of those rivers over the last couple years have reached their recovery targets for endangered coho salmon. And so it's just a testament to the hard work of the folks restoring those rivers up there, and the state's continued investment to do that restoration work, and we're seeing those benefits. A recent NOAA paper looked at salmon and steelhead populations across the West Coast and found mixed results for individual populations, but also that many of those listed stocks are holding steady and we're not getting any closer to extinction.

And some are even improving in numbers. As I mentioned, those Mendocino Coast fish are are looking better than they have historically. But none of those none of those listed stocks have been delisted, which shows there's a lot more work to do. And so when we think about how, right, what is that work that we need to get done, I I like to bucket it in sort of two buckets. One is management.

So what information do we need to more effectively manage that fishery? As we harvest those fish, what are the tools we need to better understand how we're impacting escapement? Escapement meaning the number of salmon that return to spawn. And as director Bonham mentioned, you know, the department's chronically underfunded, and we need those scientists to help us to help inform those fishery, you know, what we take in that fishery. And then as mister McCovey mentioned, habitat.

Cal Trout's focuses on wild fish, and those impacts are often described as death by a thousand cuts, water management, poor habitat conditions due to historic logging, road building dams, catastrophic wildfire, ocean conditions. Right? There's a myriad of factors. And so as a as a restoration organization, and I know many tribes and other restoration organizations across the street, we we try to tackle problems one by one and solve them. Right?

So so what are the opportunities? And we really need to redouble our efforts to increase the pace of the work we're doing to keep up with climate change. And we see several areas that are ripe for improvement. Again, we we discussed the historic investment in prop four. So reconnecting habitats, barrier removals like those on the Klamath, Battle Creek, Eel River, Matilija Dam in Southern California, huge opportunities to reconnect large portions of intact habitat for salmonids.

Reconnecting floodplains, so the the side to side movement of rivers in the Central Valley that provide, really productive feeding grounds for salmon and steelhead, and focusing on other highly productive habitats like estuaries and springs. We need to expedite that restoration with structural support. So funding from agencies like CDFW, WCB, Coastal Conservancy, and others, leveraging prop four, cannabis tax dollars as well, and also looking to the cutting programs like cutting the green tape that that make those projects easier to do. So while we're investing in those programs, we also need to make it simpler to get them done, to make it easier to do good things. And we also need flexibility in those grant programs for restoration practitioners like us to implement the projects quickly and, again, keep up with the pace of climate change to make those necessary changes.

We also need to improve water management. We need to keep cold water in stream at the right times for fish. And that's using different tools and different geographies, so things like the environmental flows framework where we have control of systems, and improving water management in distributed systems like those on the coasts where you've got, you know, a lot of small water users that are uncoordinated. And so getting those folks together to better understand the impacts of their actions and and providing them with water resiliency solutions that ultimately meet their needs as well. Thanks.

Additionally, we need to support that science and monitoring I mentioned. So implementing things like the coastal monitoring program, life cycle monitoring stations, again, better help to quantify the investments we're making and also improve our management. And finally, I'll just touch on partnerships. You know, none of this work happens without strong partnerships between NGOs like ourselves, certainly with tribes, the state, federal partners as we mentioned, academic partners, landowners, and and, of course, our our our anglers, right, our fishing community. Ultimately, what's what's good for salmon is good for us.

It's good for people. We've heard a lot about the impacts to people, and we look forward to working with you, to meet the moment and make sure California remains a salmon state. Thank you.

01:29:35 - 01:29:48

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, mister Schneider. We're very grateful for senior project manager for Cal Trout. We're grateful for your work, sir, and appreciate you being here today. What we're going do is turn it over to Senator Cortese to see questions or comments, and then we'll take

01:29:48 - 01:30:19

Speaker 3

I don't have any additional comments. I appreciate the overview from all of you and, you know, the urgency, in all of these areas and probably particularly around the Klamath in terms of that initial presentation. Just want you to know you're heard and again, we'll stand ready for any kind of, input or information that might, you know, give rise to some legislative help. Thank you so much,

01:30:19 - 01:30:41

Speaker 1

Senator Cortez. Let's talk about Mr. Schneider and monitoring. You did not use these terms, but we're falling short. Talk about that, and what do you think is needed?

Look, just being very blunt, right, especially in these times, won't be able to invest fully of everything we need to, But what do you think is needed to be able to get to a better baseline?

01:30:42 - 01:31:37

Speaker 8

Yeah. Well, I, you know, I I would note our tribal partners have been doing a lot of the heavy lifting on monitoring certainly on the Klamath. The California monitoring program is is, you know, been in existence for for some time in the state. And, again, it's chronically underfunded. Right?

We we receive a lot of the funding we receive from from the federal government, from the the PACSAR fund goes to fund CMP projects across the state. So I think to start, it starts with a a small network of rivers that are that are heavily monitored that provides just sort of ongoing baseline information that we can then use to benchmark, know, other important salmon rivers. So it's that ongoing investment. It's not it's not a sexy investment. Right?

It it's it's often tough to fund, but just a a simple baseline investment in in monitoring across the state would make a huge difference, not just in understanding those rivers, but sort of all of our salmon rivers.

01:31:37 - 01:31:43

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Mr. Director. Any items that you'd like to follow-up on with that?

01:31:43 - 01:32:47

Speaker 6

I think, you know, there's opportunities to increase monitoring, particularly on the Klamath River, we're falling short. Some things would be disease monitoring, and especially there's a lot of monitoring that was funded or slated to be funded and may not be funded anymore, unfortunately. And so immediately, maybe we were already falling short, and now with some funding cuts, we're definitely going to be falling short. And so there's some immediate short term needs for monitoring related to the Klamath River and salmonids. They're both juvenile and adult.

But one thing I think that's really important is monitoring the fishery as we see recolonization and reintroduction reintroduction to the upper basin after dam removal, a lot of the work is being done. There are plenty of projects out there. People are getting out there right now. I know the state of California is already doing monitoring up there. So a lot of the work is being done, but there are gaps that could be filled.

So thank you.

01:32:47 - 01:33:06

Speaker 1

No, I appreciate that. Thank you so much. I'm going go to Mr. President, Mr. Bradshaw.

Any additional concerns that you're having with the challenges that we've had with salmon season over the last three years on processing, having that infrastructure continuing to be in place in the ports that's needed. Mister Baratro?

01:33:06 - 01:33:09

Speaker 7

Yeah. Yeah. Did you hear me, senator?

01:33:09 - 01:33:10

Speaker 1

Yeah, please. You're coming in loud and clear.

01:33:11 - 01:34:55

Speaker 7

Perfect. Thank you. Yes. You know, obviously, there has been, you know, impacts to the coastal communities, like I said, you know, to the fishermen themselves and and the support facilities that, you know, support the the fishing industry along our coast, know, docks, marinas, ice docks, fuel docks, you know, all those direct businesses, have taken the hit as well. And, you know, I I I think, you know, with a lot of the conversation that's been highlighted here today, there's there's a lot of really good outlook, you know, long term and and and even some more short term on on the climate with dam removal and, you know, reintroduction and and restoration.

You know, I think there's some hurdles still with with water. Right? You know what mean? How do we balance that water usage, specifically on the climate? But, you know, more so on on the Sacramento, you know, Central Valley side, you know, it it isn't as as, you know, hopeful in our in our eyes.

It became abundantly clear through this three years of full closure, you know, what our natural production and hatchery, you know, complex can produce through drought and climate change in the Central Valley, and, you know, it it shut our fisheries down. You know, there was barely enough to, you know, keep some populations alive. And and I think that, you know, it it's, you know, bluntly clear that we need to look into those hatcheries and look into that hatchery complex in the Central Valley, you know, simply because, you know, I I don't think that those large dams are coming down in the near future. And our our fisheries, you know, we won't have fisheries, you know, in the near term if we don't, you know, relook at and reinvest in into those into the hatcheries in the in the Central Valley.

01:34:55 - 01:35:25

Speaker 1

Yeah. 100%. And I and I know that we're a little late, but quickly on the issue of the Sacramento, we saw this during the drought, we continue to see this now. Some of the worst hot water conditions remain in the West on the Sacramento. Right?

And that is just, one of the main grounds for disaster that we've seen. Mister Director, please, mister Schneider, any comments on that?

01:35:27 - 01:36:27

Speaker 6

Yeah. The last ten years or so, you know, started around twenty fourteen, twenty fifteen, we really started kind of feeling the effects of the drought and seeing changes in water temperatures. And, you know, salmon, have a very specific window of water temperature that they need to survive. We've seen that threshold be exceeded many, many times in many different streams throughout the Klamath River Basin. That may be something that just happens with climate change, so we have to look at how can we make these streams resilient to climate change, and a big part of that is creating cold water habitat, protecting streams that provide cold water habitat, enhancing streams that have the ability to provide that cold water habitat.

So it goes back to habitat enhancement, and then making sure that there's enough water in the river and in these streams to support good water quality and good cold water.

01:36:28 - 01:37:04

Speaker 8

Appreciate that, please. Yeah. I think that's similar to what I was gonna say. And we need to look for opportunities to reconnect that habitat when they present themselves, places like Butte Creek, Battle Creek, and the Sacramento system. You know, we we know that many of the large dams in our Central Valley are not going away, our society depends on them.

But when we have opportunities to remove smaller dams that are that are outdated, we should seize on those and as quickly as possible to ensure that those salmon populations, both the wild populations, are also resilient to to droughts. Places like Battle Creek offer that cold water refuge, you know, year in and year out.

01:37:04 - 01:37:17

Speaker 1

100% to our panel focused on challenging opportunities on salmon. We are grateful. Thank you so much, gentlemen, for being here. Mr. Director, thank you so much.

Mr. President, I appreciate you being here. Mr. Schneider, thank you. We're really, really grateful.

Thank you

01:37:17 - 01:37:18

Speaker 6

so Thank you.

01:37:18 - 01:37:20

Speaker 1

Appreciate it. Doctor. We so appreciate your time.

01:37:20 - 01:37:21

Speaker 7

Thank you.

01:37:21 - 01:39:02

Speaker 1

Doctor. Thank you so much. We're now going be moving on to the outlook for the twenty twenty five-twenty twenty six Dungeons crab season. We're gonna have doctor Schumann come on up. He is the marine region director for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife.

We have, Lisa Domrash, executive director of the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Association, come on down. We have Dickogg, commercial fisherman, out of Bodega Bay, a real leader within the fleet. And then we also have Kate Kauer, who, is the associate director for the Oceans Preferable Nation Nature Conservancy. We're gonna take a thirty second time out, let folks get situated, and we'll start with Doctor. Schuman.

Give us thirty seconds. Alright, ladies and gentlemen. We started high level with the secretary and the director. We then did a deep dive on all issues of salmon, and now we are going to focus on a top tier fishery here in the state of California, that's Dungeness crab, and this is our annual outlook of the season ahead. And an individual who has really dedicated his life to this issue is Doctor.

Schuman. He's gonna give us a brief recap of the 2425 season, and then he's gonna talk about the season ahead. If you don't know this, Doctor. Schuman carries a crystal ball in his backpack. Am I right, sir?

Always. Yes. That's hot

01:39:02 - 01:39:04

Speaker 9

yes. It's cracked and it's cloudy, but I

01:39:04 - 01:39:38

Speaker 1

have one. Yeah, exactly. Hi, Dick. And it's going to We're going to hear all issues about what the department is preparing for, right? Monitoring of whales off of the California Coast, talking about domoic acid testing, talking about quality testing, and of course, everyone's least favorite issue, and that is RAMP.

And, Doctor. Schumann, and I say that with peace and love, everyone. But, but he is also going to do a deep dive on that. Each one of you will have five minutes. I'll give you a thirty second pump, not at all trying to be rude, and then we'll open it for questions.

Doctor. Schumann, why don't you kick us off? You have five minutes.

01:39:38 - 01:45:46

Speaker 9

Thank you, Senator McGuire, Senator Cortese. I appreciate the opportunity to be here. I'm Craig Schumann, Marine Region Manager, Department of Fish and Wildlife. First, want to give out a shout out to Mr. Nielsen.

Thank you for all the hard work putting this together. This is not easy to do. Also thinking about just flying up here this afternoon or this morning. I always try to sit on the the right side or left side of the plane depending on which way I'm going and looking at our coastline and just how fortunate we are as Californians to have this resource offshore from the Channel Islands, the Big Sur coastline, the Lost Coast and everything in between. It's just spectacular that we have this at our disposal.

And despite all of our challenges, it's amazing that we have these opportunities. So looking back towards last year's crab season, after a few years of soft prices, we saw record price per pound last year. So the first time ever, the fleet statewide eclipsed $7 a pound. That's non adjusted dollars for prior years. We also had the highest number of active permits since the twenty nineteen, twenty twenty season.

As was previously stated, the fleet landed about eight and a half million pounds of crab worth close to $55,000,000. What's notable about that and because of the high price per pound, that eclipsed the $20.23, $20.24 value, which would came in at 48,000,000 at 14,000,000 pounds and the twenty twenty two, twenty twenty three value of 54 and a half million, which had almost three times the amount of crab landed at 21,000,000 pounds of crab. So just interesting to see how the dynamics and how that price can really play into that ex vessel value. The fleet was delayed in the North until January 15, and that was due to quality issues and delayed in the South or central area to from January 5 due to whales. And in both areas, the fleet opened under trap reductions in both zones.

Looking ahead to the 2526 season, this will be the first season that we will be operating under our new ramp rules, and that will be under ramp two point zero. Those regulations are currently under review at the Office of Administrative Law, and we expect they will be effective by November 1 for the start of the season. Some notable changes this year. Marked lines, so Director Bottom touched on that. For the 2526 season, 100% of surface gear must be marked with the California purple and black line.

And then we'll be phasing in the vertical line, that's the top 15 Fathoms of line, over the next three years, 25%, 26%, 27%, 50%, 27%, 28%, up to 100% in 28%, 29%. We're also updating some of our entanglement numbers and impact scores. So for example, if we have three humpback whales entangled in one calendar year, that will automatically delay the start of that season the next year until January 1. I'll touch on that more in a moment. We're updating our electronic monitoring program to specify data transmission time frames.

We're updating our alternative gear authorization process. So we are going to be working towards authorizing alternative gear for this spring. A couple other changes for the fleet to make things more streamlined for them. The season opener. So now it's time to pull out my crystal ball.

First thing to note, for the calendar year 2025, we have three confirmed entanglements in California commercial Dungeness crab gear involving humpback whales. And there have also been four entanglements in unknown gear, two of which just occurred this past weekend and are still being evaluated. Given the entanglement history and recent entanglements and historic migration patterns, I expect the department will likely take a conservative approach. And a delay is possible, I can't say with certainty, until risk is reduced. The whales may clear out.

We don't know. Important to note that if we were fishing under Ramp 2, the fleet would automatically be delayed until January 1. I think the one silver lining of that, if we were under those rules, is the fleet would have the certainty that they've been looking for. So this time of year, the phone starts ringing off the hook. Everyone's trying to figure out, should I go north?

Should I go south? Am I fishing half stacks or full stacks? When are you gonna open? What should I tell my crew? It's really tough on the fleet.

It's tough on us. It's tough on everyone. So we're looking to see if we can find some certainty. We're continuing to monitor for action species, humpback whales, blue whales, leatherback sea turtles. We've got a plane going up in the air, I think at the end of next week, to start looking at that.

We've got preliminary data for Monterey Bay Whale Watch showing elevated levels in Monterey Bay. Anecdotal reports that we still have unpacked whales up in the central and northern portion. I know Dick just rode down the coast, so he'd be the best to tell us how many whales he saw up there. As I said, we're working toward gear authorization for alternative gear this spring. And, you know, yesterday morning when I got up, it was cold for the first time in a while.

And it felt like fall. It was crisp. It was chilly. Fall was in the air. I started thinking about pumpkins.

I started thinking about scarecrows. I started thinking about the the four horsemen of the crab apocalypse. And those are whales, demoic, quality, and process. That process is kicking off tomorrow with the Dungeons Crab Fishing Gear Working Group with their annual meeting, where they're going to be looking at those four horsemen, primarily whales, but those other pieces fit into it. And we can take them head on.

Demoic, I know that had brought up earlier. Warm water is a concern. So we're seeing warm water. We do not have any reports of elevated Demoic acid levels yet. I believe the first samples are coming into the lab shortly.

So we're starting testing early. I'd say the one piece of good news about Domoic is we have established protocols and procedures. So we know what to do. We know how to get samples. We know what happens if we get hot samples.

It's a horrible inconvenience and it's a drag on the fleet if we get hot areas and it moves things around. But at least we know what we're doing. We've learned a lot from the last several years. And I will stop there because I'm probably out of time.

01:45:46 - 01:47:13

Speaker 1

No. I appreciate that, doctor. Yeah. Look, I think in those early days, and and mister Aug, please chime in on this. Working through those domoic acid challenges that we had, it was an s show.

Right? I will not swear, here at the hearing. And, I think one positive piece of all this is that we have a process in testing now that we are proactively moving on so that we know what we're getting into, which is, really, incredible compared to where we are coming from. And first thing, had said to mister Nielsen, I do appreciate everything that he does each and every day. He's coming off of also working on all the energy bills is, this warm water is just the last thing that we wanna hear about.

And hearing that it's the largest we've ever had, stretching over across, almost over to Japan, it's not a good sign. And so we're going to be knocking on wood on this. With that, we are really grateful that the executive director of Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen Association is here. And I just wanna say thank you so much to Lisa Damrosch, for all of her work that she puts in, each and every day. You're gonna be talking also, about the fleet in particular and your outlook for Dungeness crab.

Madam executive director, the floor is yours. You have five minutes, and I'll give you thirty second prompt. Ms.

01:47:13 - 01:54:31

Speaker 10

Great. Thank you, Senator McGuire, Senator Cortese. Before I get started, I want to note that you will hear me use the term fishermen. And while our industry is not all men, it is the widely accepted, all inclusive term, and it is okay to use. And I come from a long line of fishermen, and I'm proud to be trusted by the commercial fishing fleet as their executive director of PCFFA.

We have recently rebuilt our organization to truly represent the fleet with a board of active commercial fishermen working in every fishery off of California, both state and federally managed, from San Diego to Crescent City. And by representing such a diverse fleet, that allows us to tap into that collective wisdom and expertise and really step up when there are problems to be solved. Fisheries management can be complex, but we like to keep it simple. Show up, make sure the voice of commercial fishermen are heard, focus on practical solutions that will provide maximum opportunity to keep boats working, feeding communities, supporting coastal economies, and protecting our way of life for future generations. I often say that I grew up believing that pretty much anything could be fixed with a roll of electrical tape and a needle of crab pot wire.

And I learned as I got older that it was really the commercial fishing mindset that got that work done, not the tools. And they won't say it, but I will. Commercial fishermen are the most brilliant, innovative, and capable problem solvers you will find. But fishermen know the first step is always to fully assess the problem. At sea, can't afford to overreact or jump to a solution that looks good on paper or is politically popular.

They must fully understand the actual problem, and that solution needs to not only work in the moment, it needs to be measurable, and there needs to be an opportunity to continually adapt as conditions and and situations change. And, unfortunately, it doesn't always work that way on land. Shutting down our commercial access is too often the default. And we settle for feel good fixes that are likely not fixing anything because we don't fully understand the problem. And I don't think anywhere that's more clear than in our Dungeness crab fishery.

Size, sex, and season management of Dungeness crab has kept the resource sustainable since the nineteen hundreds. And our current management ramp, as you said, senator McGuire, that is a required solution to a perceived problem of co occurrence that we don't fully understand at this yet. And I just want to take a quick look back, even though PCFFA is all about looking forward. But this all started the ten years ago with the last marine heat wave, the domoic acid crisis, the unprecedented delay. And this resulted in what the last decade of data has proven was a single season spike in entanglement numbers and an NGO reaction in the form of a lawsuit, which resulted in a settlement which required ramp.

And, that's how we got here. And, I think, it's important to keep that in perspective. And, it's also important to remember that that settlement also imposed arbitrary and interim triggers for management actions, and that's what we still live under today, and we will still live under those same triggers in Ramp two point zero. And those triggers are the single most impactful thing on how our season's open, how much gear we get to use, how much access we get to have to the fishery. So, we have not reevaluated them since that time.

They weren't based on science originally. And by all accounts, over this time, humpback populations are growing, and we have new data. So, PCFFA is committed to revisiting these triggers, and I want to thank Doctor. Schumann and Director Bonham for their commitment to doing the same and working with us to address this as soon as possible. I do want to say, though, when a problem is identifiable, the commercial fishermen find solutions, and PCFFA as a statewide organization is in a great spot to help.

There's already been talk about the line marking. PCFFA has distributed the first 650 coils. Was interesting process, but we did get it done. We helped support the next section of distribution. And we want to thank everyone for that, but also want to flag for you that we need one more round of funding in order to meet that 2028 deadline of full implementation.

We also successfully piloted an EFP through PCFFA using alternative gear that requires no investment for pop up gear and new technology that was very successful, and we're excited to work towards authorization of that as an additional option for the fleet in the spring. And another thing that we've contributed to is the lost gear recovery. Commercial fishermen have been bringing in each other's lost pots since my grandfather's days. This is not a new phenomenon. But in the world of entanglement mitigation, in 2015, The Nature Conservancy and port based organizations worked together, and we've collected thousands of pots.

And last year, the Dungeness Crab Task Force asked PCFFA and TNC to expand that work. And we're really proud to announce that we'll be launching the Fisherman's Gear Recovery Network. And this is going to be an umbrella that can bring all of those port based projects under one umbrella and share technology and resources. And we want to thank OPC and the department for their support of that work as well. We'll be reporting out more tomorrow at the working group and at the task force later this month.

And speaking of the task force, I also want to point out that that is a very important group of commercial fishermen chosen by the fleet that volunteer their time to identify problems and solutions and to provide direction to all to you, our legislators, to carry those solutions forward. And thank you for your work on that in the past, Senator McGuire. I know my fellow panelists will share more details, but we are very supportive of the task force. And there are several DCTF recommendations that have been out there for a while that have not yet moved forward. And we really can't overstate the need to get that done.

And one of them is to make sure the task force itself stays in place beyond its sunset date of 2029. So we we humbly ask for help on that and getting those things move forward. I think maintaining process certainty matters even more in these uncertain times, and we've talked a lot about uncertainty. You know, growing up in a commercial fishing family, our lives revolved around those opening days of crab and salmon. Was on the calendar like my birthday and Christmas, and everyone could count on the season's opening.

And and that certainty is gone. And that's not just for crabs, but in all of our fisheries, and it has far reaching impacts. And I think what's the saddest is that our dependence on imports flown from around the world that don't meet California sustainability standards just continues to increase while our coastal communities literally crumble before our eyes. And that's something we need to deal with. And so what are we gonna do?

Well, the other rule in fishing is there's no whining. So we're going to keep working. And we're gonna tap into that commercial fishing mindset, and we're gonna work tirelessly to fix what's worth fixing. And we're going to keep reminding everyone that will listen that commercial fishing is not the problem. We are food producers, economy drivers, ocean stewards, and problem solvers, and we can't always be the ones that pay the price, and we are, often, and especially not the price of solving a problem that we're not sure what we're doing is solving.

So with that, I, you know, wanna thank you for having me and say that we will be here always at PCFFA to work for balanced, reasonable regulations that really balance protect our ocean resources and allow for maximum commercial fishing access to feed our our our state and our communities.

01:54:32 - 01:55:32

Speaker 1

My name is executive director. Thank you so much. I'm very grateful, for your eloquent remarks and for your leadership. It's good to see you. We're now going to turn it over to a real legend.

And he does amazing work each and every day, but it's also very true, Mr. Ogg. He comes to us out of Bodega Bay, and we're really grateful that you are here today. He's going be sharing his perspective on the working group, and then also the testing of new fishing technologies, look, let's be honest, Mr. Aug has been, a bone of contention over the past many years.

And what I deeply appreciate about Mr. Aug is he's always at the table, seeking solutions and be able to build bridges. And when there is a hot issue, you run towards it. And that is not always easy, working internally with politics. Right?

I think some of the most difficult politics are internal politics. So, mister Hock, we're really grateful for your leadership. The floor is yours. You have five minutes. We'll give you a thirty second round.

01:55:32 - 02:01:42

Speaker 11

Okay. Thank you very much, Senator McGuire. I I you know, it's really an honor to be here. I really, really sincerely appreciate it. I'd like to just kind of start out with, you know, I mean, we all understand that the crab industry or our commercial industry has been severely impacted by a reduction in seasons, gear restrictions, time area closures, and marketing conditions.

These situations have not only immediate financial impacts but also local long term economic impacts that result in devaluation of our fishery assets. Looking into the future and considering how to support young men and women interested in continuing this amazing industry is difficult at best. Our role as elder, and I say that kind of jokingly, elder commercial critical food providers is to secure that future for up and coming generations and to ensure that the opportunities are solidified for them to continue that tradition. With that, I'd like to remind the committee that we are stewards of the ocean, and we're here to provide a resource that belongs to the public in the most sustainable manner possible. We remain committed to staying engaged and providing solution oriented support.

As fishermen, we are detailed observers and it's been said that we have to think like the resource that we harvest. And stepping back and understanding this, we're a data source that needs to be used to help manage and to help management decisions. We are real time information that should be utilized and integrated in the scientific community. I'm here to support science based management decisions. The department's been doing its best to protect the industry, but it's hindered by situations beyond their control and they must prioritize responding to risk.

The overall entanglement numbers that do not really truly represent the true verified interactions within the commercial dungeons crab industry. For example, between 2017 and the 2025, the average confirmed interaction has been just slightly over four. By collaborating with the department and doing what we can, we've successfully maintained overall interaction levels while the humpback whale population has continued to grow at approximately seven to 8%. This is a win for everybody. And if we really sit back and think about this, that's a possibility of anything from 300 to 500 animals each year.

Right now, I mean, that population is continuing to increase, and it's going to impact our opportunities to potentially interact with these animals. It's no different than when you're driving on the freeway and there's more cars on the freeway, the opportunity for an accident is a higher there's a higher percentage. So additionally, one one other thing I'd like to bring up is that just at the the last time we were able to start our season on in the Central Management Area, normally was in 2019. From November to late January, the maximum number of vertical lines are in the water. And yet, interestingly enough, that's when the fewest confirmed entanglements actually occur.

I know, you know, you can't precisely say when those entanglements occur, but in reality, there's more eyes on the water at that particular time than there are just about any time during the year. And we would obviously see that if it was if it was occurring. So, I mean, I really think we need to remember that the the industry itself is not the only human impact on these majestic creatures. And the fishermen I know, and every single one of them, are trying to do the best they can to avoid any interaction. That's our this is our livelihood.

This is what this is what we do. This is and we address these issues, you know, as soon as they arise. So, you know, I'd like to sit back and think about, you know, having some flexibility and bringing back our holiday markets. You know, I mean, we really, really truly need those. So, we just kind of have to think about how we can kind of manipulate and work with these different issues.

Additionally, you know, Lisa touched on it. The task force was formed to provide recommendations from the industry to the legislators. The last few years, those recommendations by the task force, they haven't really received much recognition. And, you know, I mean, we really truly need to work together to try and move those things forward. I mean, some of them, as she as Lisa pointed out, the reauthorization is critical.

You know, the the fleet's ability to serve as an advisory body is gonna go away in 2029 if we don't re reauthorize it. Gear servicing intervals. That's another issue that's been brought up and been unanimously approved by the task force to try and, you know, allow for a little more flexibility, so the fishermen have more time to service the gear based on weather and, you know, financial impacts of a shortened time to have to go out and, you know, service the gear. Crep tag, account surplus management. That's another thing we really need to look at.

You know, so all of that's really, really important to evaluate.

02:01:44 - 02:01:45

Speaker 1

You have about thirty seconds.

02:01:45 - 02:03:11

Speaker 11

Okay. Thank you. PCFFA has been, you know, a solution based oriented action group led by Lisa Damrosch and the newly formed Board, are opportunities, you know, to be a collective body of fishermen advocacy through the state, you know, such as, you know, things that we need to work on loss gear and the alternative gear that was, you know, promoted by PCFFA to try to minimize vertical lines and offer the opportunity for fishermen to be able to fish without having to buy large amount purchase large amounts of equipment. And, you know, I mean, they've been the impetus behind this. I mean, you know, so the PCFFA has been the driving force behind a number of these different things, you know, that are very, very important to the fleet.

So, conclusion, I'd like to say that, you know, the fleet is doing all it can to protect and preserve the seafood production in an environmentally safe, sustainable and sustainable way. My request is for you to believe in the fishermen and women and know that we're doing our very best, you know, to preserve and protect the environment and the creatures that inhabit the ocean that we fish in. Thank you.

02:03:11 - 02:03:52

Speaker 1

Mr. Hong, thank you so much. I have a couple questions I'm going to bring forward Yes, sir. In just a moment. But thank you so much for your testimony today.

We're now going to go to Kate Cowher. She's the fishery strategy lead for The Nature Conservancy. And just want to take a moment to say thank you so much to Ms. Cowher. She is working with the fishermen, the fleet, to develop solutions, right, to better reduce the risk.

And it has been a dedication that the Nature Conservancy has had and we cannot say thank you for the partnership enough. And whether it's on the electronic monitoring or on the management You've been there every step of the way, Kate. Thank you so much. The floor is yours. You have five minutes.

We'll give you a thirty second prompt.

02:03:52 - 02:09:50

Speaker 12

Great. Thanks so much, Senator McGuire. Thank you for the opportunity to be here today. Thank you, Mr. Nielsen, also, for the opportunity to participate.

The Nature Conservancy is a science based organization. We work worldwide on developing conservation solutions that benefit both people and nature. And in California, we've been active collaborating with fishermen, with managers, with scientists, many other partners, all to advance sustainable fisheries and really protect biodiversity and thriving coastal communities. And since 2015, we've been partnering with the Dungeness crab fleet to develop solutions that reduce whale and turtle entanglement and maintain a productive fishery. And we've been active members of the Whale Working Group and the Dungeness crab task force, and through that, have helped shape adaptive and climate ready management strategies that really do balance these economic and environmental priorities.

And so today, I wanted to focus my comments on highlighting two priorities I see for the coming year and the need for diverse, sustainable funding sources for those priorities. So first up, I thought I'd highlight the importance of data that really serves as the basis for RAMP. Everyone knows RAMP is our framework for reducing entanglement risk through responsive action. And its success really does depend on accurate data about whale presence and abundance along the coast. And one of the Whale Working Group's priorities right now is ensuring that RAMP is informed by a diverse set of credible data sources.

And we know that RAMP is adaptable, it was set up to be adaptable, but it is vulnerable to data gaps. For instance, if we can't get aerial surveys out, we can have a situation where an entire management zone, say, the North Coast, doesn't have any observational data. And so to address that, we partnered with the California Crab Coast Crab Association, CCCA, and other stakeholders with OPC's support and piloted industry led vessel based whale surveys starting back in 2020. And those surveys are conducted by fishermen, Mr. Ogg here in particular, using vetted protocols and using their own vessels to go out and monitor for whale observations and fill these critical data gaps.

The information from those vessel surveys has been used in ramp decision making even to support delayed fishery opening when the risk was too high. But Ramp is currently lacking a formal process for evaluating and improving new data sources, which limits its ability to fully incorporate valuable information like the industry led vessel surveys. And so, the working group is developing a process right now to address this, and we are looking forward to working with the department and with the working group to see this process implemented and to ensure that RAMP is still grounded in the best available data, and that it remains a really adaptive and science driven and effective framework. The second priority that I wanted to touch on today is the work that Lisa and Dick both shared here, the partnership with PCFFA, with support from OPC to expand lost fishing gear recovery, which is another key strategy to reduce entanglement risk. We know lost fishing gear is a contributor to marine life entanglements, and sometimes precise data on gear sources and timing is limited, but it is still a significant risk to whale and other species.

And so since 2015, we've helped pioneer and formalize this port based recovery model. The efforts were formalized under California's Trap Gear Retrieval Program, and the program has removed thousands of traps, reducing entanglement risk and ocean debris. Last year, the task force formally recommended expanding these recovery efforts statewide through this partnership between TNC and PCFFA. And so with help from OPC, we've formalized the Fisherman's Gear Recovery Network, and it appoints these port coordinators, recruits retrieval captains, and uses shared tools like the CrabGear app to locate, track and return gear. This year, we're expanding that to additional ports, and we're also launching a new gear spotting application for public reporting of lost gear.

And the port based program that is designed under this network really ensures that recovery is efficient, that the crews are compensated, and that all retrieval complies with two different regulatory pathways we have available today. So we're focused right now on Dungeness crab, but we also think that this is a model that could be scalable to other fisheries as well. Finally, on to funding, which I think is the most critical point here. Since 2019, TNC has been working to secure public investments in data delivery and entanglement risk reduction. And thanks to the leadership of the legislature and support of California voters, the passage of Prop four really provides a historic opportunity with 75,000,000 dedicated to climate ready marine fisheries.

At a time when we know federal funding for anything fisheries related has been uncertain at best, the Prop four investments and other state funding are really more important than ever. This year, we advocated for nearly $17,000,000 in Prop four funding for vessel based whale surveys, for other technologies to inform risk reduction, for lost gear recovery, for alternative gear purchases and for modernizing fisheries information systems at CDFW. And so the FY 2526 expenditure plan puts $11,000,000 to CDFW for climate ready fisheries. I think while the implementation details are still emerging, it is clear that we still need to leverage diverse sources of funding, especially continuous funding beyond Prop four for priorities in Dungeness crab fishery.

02:09:50 - 02:09:52

Speaker 1

You have about thirty seconds.

02:09:52 - 02:10:50

Speaker 12

So my specific ask is that the task force recommendation to amend the statute for the Dungeness crab account would actually take happen and would allow surplus funds to be directed to some of these task force priorities, including lost gear recovery and data collection for ramp. So these funds are all industry derived. It comes from the trap tag, the permit tag and trap tag fees. And would, right now, has a balance of over $3,500,000 and those statutory changes could free up about 1,300,000 in surplus for these critical needs. Task force is going to revisit this recommendation at our meeting in the next two weeks, and we're looking forward to working with the legislature to explore opportunities to amend the statute and try to unlock this industry derived funding so that we can support entanglement risk reduction, maintain a productive and resilient fishery, and really strengthen California's leadership in sustainable fisheries management.

So thank you again for the opportunity.

02:10:50 - 02:11:47

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Ms. Skowrie. I think that one of the items that we were talking about earlier today is looking at advancing the biannual fishery omnibus bill here this coming year. So that is something that we'd love to be able to see the recommendations on. So greatly appreciate that.

Thank you so much. Let's talk entanglements real quick because I think that is one of the biggest challenges, right? Mr. Ogg, Madam Executive Director, Mr. Schumann, which all mentioned.

A lot of theories in regards to whales hanging out longer now than they have been, right? Populations are up, and then warm water. So, your thoughts, doctor Schuman, on is it both, a little bit of both? Your thoughts about whales hanging off of the California coast longer? More whales plus warmer water conditions?

02:11:50 - 02:12:44

Speaker 9

So I'll well, thank you for the question, Senator McGuire. I'll preface it that I'm not a whale expert. I think it's a combination of factors. And we've got more whales, which is a good thing. We do have a lot of gear in the water.

I think we're still trying to figure out is it lost gear, is it actively fish gear, is it some combination? Are there patterns that we can discern based on the entanglements? Is it just random unluckiness? I think we're still trying to figure that all out. And I think one of the biggest challenges that we have is working through the federal incidental take permit application process.

The numbers that we're held to are extremely low. And I think that is one of the challenges that's really limiting our ability to expand fishing opportunities because of that very low entanglement number, especially as that population is increasing and we're seeing more whales out there.

02:12:46 - 02:12:48

Speaker 1

Madame Exitory Director, Mr. Og.

02:12:49 - 02:14:06

Speaker 10

Yeah, I'll just, you know, dovetail on to what Doctor. Schuman just said. Thank you for the question. It's that number that's too low is another place that we can look. I mean, we can't control if the water's warmer.

We can't control if the whales are hanging out longer. But but we can look at the data, and we can examine those triggers and figure out what's reasonable, and what's a reasonable expectation. The problem is we're being held to an expectation of zero. That's like saying you're being held to an expectation of driving on the freeway and there's never an accident. And if there is an accident, we're gonna stop driving, and no one's going to get to get anywhere.

And, unfortunately, for us, when there's an accident, the commercial Dungeness crab fishery stops, but all the other ocean uses don't. Ships don't. There's a lot of other components. So I think for me and for PCFFA where we really see an opportunity to broaden our opportunities is by using updated science and real data to figure out those triggers. Ramp is built with those numbers because those are the only numbers we have, but we contend that those numbers could be reevaluated, and that could have the single biggest impact on increasing opportunity and production.

02:14:06 - 02:14:07

Speaker 1

Thank you. Mr. Rauch?

02:14:07 - 02:15:28

Speaker 11

To dovetail on what Lisa is talking about, I mean, sit back and think about this logically. And when we look at, you know, the migratory patterns of these animals and thinking about, you know, when they decide when they if there's three or 400 smaller juvenile animals, we need to know if those are going to be migrating with the entire group, or are they gonna be able to are they going to be sticking around longer in the areas that we might be fishing in? And those numbers that Lisa's talking about, that threshold that we're set at has no wiggle room. And, you know, we don't know for sure that some of these animals don't hang around for two, three years, and we don't have an opportunity to fish because we can't work with that set threshold. That adjustment needs to be adaptable to the population.

As things change, we need to be able to change that threshold to adjust for that. So, really think it's important that the data be the driving force, you know, and not a set, you know, not a set thing, you know. So, yeah. Thank you.

02:15:28 - 02:15:31

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Mr. Ogg. I'm going turn it to Senator Cortese.

02:15:34 - 02:15:56

Speaker 3

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just curious about the trap fee surplus, I guess you referred to it as. It seems like it's kind of just a reserve sitting there. Or is it the usage of the dollars that needs to be statutorily changed because it's because it isn't defined broadly enough to cover the areas you want to cover?

I'm just trying to understand.

02:15:56 - 02:16:49

Speaker 12

Yeah. Thank you, Senator Cortese. It is so in statute, I believe and actually, Doctor. Schuman is probably the expert on this but it does say that the proceeds from that fund can be used to cover department costs associated with implementing and enforcing the trap limit program, and also to facilitate and administer the Dungeness Crab Task Force. And then any excess funds do just sit in that account.

So that's why, since 2013, we've built up quite a surplus that has not been used. I think the average biannual usage by the department is somewhere around $1,100,000 over the last six years or so. And so if you removed that and you maintained a $1,100,000 buffer for uncertainty purposes, you would still have about $1,300,000 in surplus that could be freed up and used for some of these priorities.

02:16:49 - 02:17:45

Speaker 3

And is there maybe it's a question for you, I don't know, but is there risk propensity for risk to the program beyond the six year average that we're seeing? It seems like a rather basic kind of a cleanup item, if the administration is agreeable to it. But it would seem like with all the moving parts that we're hearing about today, is there some kind of possibility of an enforcement spike that's going to want to draw on that money? I think that's what our colleagues would want to know. Are we going to bottom out the fund and then not have it there for you?

I understand you're leaving $1,000,000 there as a buffer, but it's just a general question. Has much analysis been done as to worst case scenario planning?

02:17:46 - 02:18:15

Speaker 12

Thank you, Senator Casey. I don't think we have looked at the worst case scenario. I think that $1,100,000 buffer is the expected need for a worst case scenario, potentially. I do know the statute also includes a provision right now that allows for reducing those fees in case there is a buildup of surplus, and that has not happened. And so there has been interest in going and looking at ways to actually leverage and use those funds towards some of these priority needs.

02:18:15 - 02:18:37

Speaker 3

That's why I asked the question initially. It seemed like, administratively you should be able to take the fund down and use it, but evidently it's not some of these items, even though they're very pertinent to the topic, are not specifically called out in the statute as items that are eligible for expenditure. So, okay. Exactly.

02:18:37 - 02:18:37

Speaker 1

Just want

02:18:37 - 02:18:41

Speaker 3

to make sure I understand. In case I have to vote on that bill someday.

02:18:41 - 02:19:34

Speaker 1

Hey, there we go. Hi, Dion. Here, the Executive Director and Mr. Aug in regards to look, we got to talk numbers, I'm paraphrasing here, based off of ramp. Something that we've been talking about for quite some time is when does commercial season start when it comes to dungeon scrap.

And whether it's issues of quality domoic acid or presence of whales, we are creeping into the New Year and missing that historic boom time of the holidays. Your thoughts on looking at a January 1 date? Please, Madam Executive Director.

02:19:34 - 02:20:33

Speaker 10

Thank you for the question. That has come up several times. And I can tell you, I don't think that we are ready to give up on the statutory season starting November 15, even if the hardcore hard, cold reality is we haven't done that in a long time and we may not get to for a long time, we don't know what's coming. We don't know what's coming with changes in the migratory pattern of the whales. We don't know if the whales are going to be delisted.

There's conversations about that. We don't know how much this population may grow and how much we may learn about co occurrence and be able to fish with traditional gear earlier. So I think at this time, even though that may be where we are in practicality, cutting off that first, couple of months and no longer having the opportunity to go back to it if conditions change would be tragic. So, I think that's where we're

02:20:33 - 02:20:34

Speaker 11

at. Okay.

02:20:36 - 02:20:37

Speaker 1

Ditto.

02:20:37 - 02:21:12

Speaker 11

I you know, I have to completely agree. I don't think we should ever give up that opportunity. I really firmly believe that in time, it's possible that we might be able to figure out ways to work around this. I I I just could never say never. I mean, I just can't, You know?

And I don't think there's anybody in our ports or anywhere that I can think of that would say, hey, you know what? We'll just give it up and we'll just say January 1. I I get it. I understand. But I really feel it's important that we maintain that opportunity.

02:21:12 - 02:21:31

Speaker 1

Got it. And very quickly, Mr. Og, if you just want to talk a little bit about what you're hearing from those fishermen within the fleet that have adopted new and or testing new technologies. Give us some feedback.

02:21:31 - 02:23:14

Speaker 11

Thank you for the opportunity. Actually, I think that in general, you know, there's optimism. I do feel that, you know, that the opportunity to continue and have a chance in the springtime to be able to fish is very important. That spring fishery means a lot to a lot of people. And there has been a shift in the way the resource has kind of rebounded in the springtime.

I think that one thing we do need to consider is alternatives. And, you know, as we said, know, the PCFFA was instrumental in trying to do a grapple only technique that does not require the purchase of thousands of dollars of equipment, and it was extremely successful. I had the opportunity to do that. And I also have had the opportunity to test a number of the different pieces of equipment, all of which work most of the time. But one has to remember there are vertical lines, and there, you know, there is the possibility of non deployment, mid water deployment, and all sorts of other things that can occur.

We are just trying to find other methods that offer opportunity to the industry that don't cost an arm and a leg to operate, and we want everybody to have a chance. So I think that in general, the fleet is is, you know, beginning to kinda look at options. I won't say it's in a always completely positive, but, know, I mean, we're trying our best.

02:23:15 - 02:23:19

Speaker 1

Yeah. Look. And transition is never easy.

02:23:19 - 02:23:20

Speaker 5

Correct.

02:23:20 - 02:23:42

Speaker 1

To be blunt. Right? And I hate it. I don't like transition. So, I I hear what you're saying in regards to, you've done thing something all of your life or your entire career and then expect it to be able to advance something that's different, and something that may work majority of the time, but still has some kinks to work out.

Right? And it's very frustrating.

02:23:42 - 02:23:43

Speaker 13

Can I

02:23:43 - 02:23:43

Speaker 1

ask some

02:23:43 - 02:25:03

Speaker 10

Yeah, please, Manuel Zikra? Thank you. I would just like to add, I think it's difficult for people who aren't in the industry to understand the significant difference between the opening of a season and spring. While it's one season on paper, statutorily, they're essentially two different fisheries, the opening season and the spring season. And these alternative gear types work in the spring.

And I think there's lot of optimism because it does allow fishing to continue because the participation is so much lower. The weather is different, the price is higher, the additional effort it takes to do that kind of long lining, whether it's with pop up or not, works in that environment. And that's why we're seeing more adoption because there's no salmon season. Guys want to keep fishing crabs longer. And we are very supportive of increasing that access at the end.

But the math, for those of us on land that think, well, hey, let's just do that all the time, it doesn't math. It doesn't work in a situation where four twenty boats are fishing and it's a derby and it's a virgin biomass and it's the weather and it's fast and it's furious. It just doesn't work. So I just think it's important as we're talking about alternative gear that we keep in mind that it's something for the spring where 6% of the harvest happens and not for the 94% that happens at the beginning.

02:25:03 - 02:25:11

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Senator and Secretary. Very grateful. I want to turn over to Doctor. Schuman. We're going to need to start wrapping up.

Doctor. Schuman, on the issues of domoic acid.

02:25:12 - 02:25:46

Speaker 9

Thank you, Senator McGuire. So apparently while we were sitting up here, one of the horsemen has struck. And we have hot crab, three of them out of the first sampling out of Trinidad, one of them very high. So it's early. So we've got several more weeks or months of testing ahead of us.

I think Monterey is the next sample that will be coming in. So we'll be tracking that closely, working with our partners at CDPH, the California Department of Public Health and Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, and the fleet, of course, to get the samples and track that and go run through our protocols.

02:25:47 - 02:25:53

Speaker 1

100%. Thank you so much. And first area will be up next week as well, correct?

02:25:53 - 02:25:54

Speaker 9

I believe, yes, next week.

02:25:54 - 02:28:30

Speaker 1

That's great. To our entire panel, thank you. Thank you for taking the time. Really, really grateful for your work. Thank you for being here today and for your leadership.

Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you so much. All right. We're gonna take a thirty second, break, but we're gonna in that time, we're gonna invite our next panel to come up.

This is what we call help for kelp and beware of the blob. And look, one of the biggest challenges that we've seen in some parts of the earth, it's coral. Here in California, we've seen a lot of devastation when it comes to our traditional kelp forests, and we're really grateful, to have this conversation about the health of kelp across the state, and what this impact of the blob is gonna be here on California's fishery. We're gonna take a thirty second recess, and we'll be right back with you. All right, ladies and gentlemen.

Thank you so much for your patience and grateful for this next panel. This is a really important one, and we want to say thank you so much to Jen Eckerly. She's with the California Natural Resource Agency, as the Deputy Secretary for Oceans and Coastal Policy. And, if that was not enough, she's OPC's acting executive director. Just a few things going on.

And Madam Director's gonna be speaking on the partnership with DFW in regards to the health of kelp across the state of California and the investment plan in research and restoration efforts, here throughout California. Thank you so much, madam secretary. It's wonderful to see you. The floor is yours. You have five minutes, and this is something that is near and dear to so many of us, who live in California, and it's been devastating to be able to see the die off.

And really grateful for the work and the research. The floor is yours, and I'll give you a thirty second prompt.

02:28:30 - 02:35:15

Speaker 14

Thank you so much, Senator McGuire, and Mr. Nielsen, for the invitation to be here. I'm really proud and honored to be sitting here, with these panelists and also everyone you've heard from today. I have close relationships and deep respect for everyone who is doing this work to protect the ocean, whether you're a conservation organization or a fisherman. I don't have to tell you that California's kelp forests host extraordinary biodiversity.

They support ecologically and economically important species, and they hold significant cultural importance for California Native American tribes. They drive California's coastal economy by supporting fisheries and fishing communities, and they draw thousands of tourists to the coast each year. And we know that kelp forests are dynamic ecosystems, and they generally fluctuate from year to year. Disturbances like El Ninos and large winter storms can have significant impacts, but kelp forests have historically tended to bounce back. In 2014, however, an unprecedented marine heat wave, coupled with the onset of sea star wasting disease in 2013, caused the near collapse of kelp forests in Northern California and significant declines in Central And Southern California, with impacts cascading across the ecosystem and coastal communities.

We do have some good news. Preliminary satellite data from 2025 suggests that kelp forests are beginning to recover in much of the Central And Southern California coasts. And while that recovery is promising, in May, as you mentioned, Senator, a new marine heat wave arose off the coast of off the West Coast, presenting concerns for marine life and ecosystem health. We are actively tracking the extent and severity of this marine heat wave, and my fellow panelist and colleague Doctor. Marissa Baskett will share more about this during her presentation.

The loss of nearly 96% of kelp forests in Northern California and kelp declines in Central And Southern California have really catalyzed state action over the last several years. Since 2019, the Ocean Protection Council has invested close to $11,000,000 in kelp forest research, community and tribal engagement, and restoration efforts to combat these losses. These investments have supported research to inform the location, timing and efficacy of restoration removal of sea urchins by commercial urchin divers with over 27 tons of urchins removed from pilot restoration sites in Mendocino County, facilitating early signs of kelp forest recovery development of innovative aquaculture approaches to grow kelp for outplanting the improved understanding of the impacts of increased sea surface temperature and marine heat waves on kelp growth and resilience tribally led kelp forest monitoring, novel pilot scale restoration experiments, including the testing for urchin removal and defense of kelp edges against urchin incursion, and undergraduate, graduate and early career training for the next generation of marine scientists and restoration practitioners. The initial results from these state investments highlight the success of a portfolio approach to restoring kelp forests, and they will directly inform the development of a statewide kelp restoration and management plan, otherwise known as the KRMP, currently led by the Department of Fish and Wildlife in partnership with OPC.

The KRMP will be California's first ecosystem based fisheries management plan and will include a restoration toolkit and a harvest framework for giant and bulk help. The KRMP is being formed through a community working group composed of urchin fishers, recreational scuba divers, and restoration practitioners, as well as a science advisory committee made up of experts in marine ecology, social science, and fisheries, including Doctor. Baskett. Tribal leaders and scientists are participating on both groups. We anticipate the final KRMP will be presented to the Fish and Game Commission for adoption in late twenty twenty six.

More broadly, the Ocean Protection Council is partnering with California Ocean Science Trust on an expert and an expert scientific working group to develop science guidance for coastal and ocean marine, restoration in California in the face of a rapidly changing ocean. My colleague Monica LaFleur from the Ocean Science Trust will share more about that effort in her remarks. The KRMP and this new science guidance will support the conservation and restoration of kelp forest and other threatened ecosystems as climate change accelerates. Importantly, the state has adopted a learn by doing approach that meets the urgency of the moment, supporting actions that help us learn and ensure that project outcomes are integrated into our policy and management. Supporting the recovery and reintroduction of sunflower stars is also a key emerging priority for the Ocean Protection Council and the Department of Fish and Wildlife.

Just yesterday, the Ocean Protection Council approved funding to the Nature Conservancy, the California Academy of Sciences, and the Department of Fish and Wildlife to support captive breeding, disease testing and resilience, and experimental outplanting of sunflower sea stars. These efforts, along with the discovery of the cause of sea star wasting disease this summer, provide the foundation for eventual successful reintroduction of this critical species into the future. Some additional good news: Wild sunflower sea stars have been reported by scientific divers and community scientists both in Sonoma and Mendocino Counties, sparking hope for this species and future kelp forest restoration and resilience. Protection of our kelp forest ecosystems and the communities that rely on them remains a priority for the state. This was clearly demonstrated by climate bond appropriations to the Ocean Protection Council for kelp forest recovery totaling $19,000,000 in the budget that was just signed by the governor.

OPC, in close partnership with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, is committed to supporting long term monitoring, management and continued investment in restoration, tribal stewardship, community engagement and scientific research to fill critical knowledge gaps and support coastal communities. However, the restoration of California's kelp forests will require long term support as the state grapples with the threats of climate change.

02:35:15 - 02:35:17

Speaker 1

You have about thirty seconds.

02:35:17 - 02:35:48

Speaker 14

Perfect. In summary, climate change presents real and ongoing threats to our coastal ecosystems, but there is cause for hope and optimism, and I've heard that theme of hope optimism across all of the panels today. We can learn from the deep knowledge of tribes and the expertise of scientists, fishermen, agency partners, conservation organizations and others, and we have the partnerships and the intellectual foundations necessary to address these challenges with resilience and purpose. Thank you.

02:35:48 - 02:35:49

Speaker 1

Thank so much. It's really good to see you.

02:35:49 - 02:35:50

Speaker 14

Good to see you.

02:35:50 - 02:36:38

Speaker 1

We're now going to turn it over to Monica LaFleur. She's a science officer for the Ocean Science Trust. She also leads the restoration working group, which we're really grateful for. And, I got to say, she has been hyper focused on advancing science based solutions for adaptive fisheries, especially, when it comes to the issue of the climate crisis. And I cannot imagine what your life is like when you hear so much from the federal government, one, doesn't necessarily believe in science, and then two, climate change is fake news.

So but you are gonna teach us otherwise, and I just wanna say thank you for your commitment. And especially with these headwinds that we see, your leadership is needed now more than ever. So we're really grateful you're here. You have five minutes, and I'll give you a thirty second prompt.

02:36:39 - 02:41:48

Speaker 15

Ms. Great. Thank you, Senator McGuire and colleagues, the opportunity to participate today. I'm truly honored to be part of the conversation. My name is Monica LaFleur, science officer with the California Ocean Science Trust.

A quick reminder about Ocean Science Trust. We are an organization dedicated to strengthening the bridge between scientific research and sound ocean management. We are created by state legislation passed in 2000, and we support and bring world class science and innovation together with state and federal policymakers to accelerate progress toward a healthy and resilient California ocean and coast. We work on a broad range of issues that are priorities for California through which we convene science based conversations to find a path forward for which none apparently exist and offer spaces for dialogue removed from jurisdictional boundaries. Today, I'm here to speak to what Ocean Science Trust has learned from convening this science working group over the past year that's been focused on ocean and coastal restoration in California.

Although conserving our healthy kelp forest is definitely preferred to having to restore lost or degraded sites, we know that that's not always possible. Restoration is a powerful tool in our toolbox to support kelp recovery. This project, convened in close collaboration with the Ocean Protection Council, has brought together four leading researchers and restoration practitioners, including Doctor. Marissa Vasquez, who you'll hear from next, across the state to identify science guidance for coastal and ocean restoration in California under the realities of climate change. This effort has not conducted novel research.

Rather, its purpose has been to synthesize science based information and best practices across the field of restoration practice into a single document that is applicable across a range of coastal habitats, including kelp forests, to inform restoration efforts under climate change. Today, I'll share a few key messages from this effort that are most relevant to this discussion on kelp restoration and supporting fisheries. In case you're interested in learning more, we anticipate that the report will be made publicly available early next year. So here are the three key science messages for today's discussion, relevance of which is highlighted by the marine heat wave we're currently seeing. First, it's important to frame restoration to include both the recovery of historical systems and the proactive adaptation of ecosystems to new environmental realities.

Through proactive management of existing kelp ecosystems and coordinated restoration of lost or degraded kelp forests, California can support thriving kelp into the future. However, as climate change persists, our state and local ability to manage stressors may decrease as regional and global scale climate related stressors become more prominent. Down the line, these changing ocean conditions may make restoration in place of past ecosystems very costly or even impossible. Challenging decisions may arise that require values based decisions about whether we should attempt to restore a past ecosystem or prioritize restoration of ecosystem services, like habitat provision for commercially important fishery species, even if that means accepting a new normal. Although we as a state may have to make these difficult decisions, we don't have to do this blind.

For example, we can rely on advancements in ecological science to inform and support difficult decision making. Second, local communities in California Native American tribes must be involved as meaningful partners in restoration efforts. Decision points along the restoration process cannot be informed only by ecological need based on numbers in a spreadsheet or spatial maps. Social values, particularly those held by the communities located nearby lost or degraded kelp forests where restoration is occurring or could occur, should inform restoration goals and therefore drive decision making. Healthy kelp forests bring enormous benefits, both tangible and intangible, to Native American tribes, fishermen, coastal communities, Considering the provision of ecosystem services throughout restoration decision making can multiply the positive impact of successful kelp restoration.

Finally, information is power. Data availability is crucial to restoration in any system, and particularly for kelp. Determining whether to restore relies on a solid understanding of kelp extent and knowledge of dynamic patterns. You need sufficient historical data to indicate whether a system is lost or degraded past the potential for natural recovery or whether the system is in a cyclical, normal period of lower productivity or extent. For this reason, it's impossible to overemphasize the importance of durable investments in long term ecosystem monitoring.

Monitoring can have an outsized impact on the field of restoration ecology if data is collected over a long period of time and shared publicly in an accessible, coordinated format. Long term monitoring also helps us identify environmental anomalies as early as possible, like the marine heat wave that Marissa will chat a bit about next. California will continue to improve its restoration capacity and increase the value of every dollar spent on kelp restoration if long term monitoring and data are supported. Thank you so much. Perfect.

Great.

02:41:48 - 02:42:37

Speaker 1

Really appreciate you. Thank you so much. We're going to have some questions in just a moment, and grateful for your presentation. Doctor, it's good to see you. Thank you so much.

Doctor. Baskett is with University of California at Davis, Go Aggies, and she's a professor of environmental science and policy. She's going to talk to us about kelp ecosystems, but then also about this extreme heat event that we're seeing in The Pacific. And this was a recent add to the presentation. So, Doctor, I really appreciate your flexibility with that.

And really, the two go hand in hand as well. So, the floor is yours. Really grateful for your presentation today. Also has a PowerPoint, and we'll turn it over to you, and I'll give you a thirty second prompt as you get close to that five

02:42:37 - 02:42:45

Speaker 13

Okay. And hopefully the PowerPoint is coming up shortly. But as it is, I do want to, you know, acknowledge as

02:42:46 - 02:42:48

Speaker 1

Can have that microphone pulled a little closer to you, please?

02:42:51 - 02:43:03

Speaker 13

The restoration and management plan, and more than happy to answer any questions about updates on that plan and where it's currently at. But I wanted to speak a little more to all of the science going on.

02:43:04 - 02:43:09

Speaker 1

Why don't we just pause for a second because we're going to get that up on the screen. Give us one moment.

02:43:09 - 02:43:21

Speaker 13

Okay. Great. And if the slides can't come up, that's okay.

02:43:21 - 02:43:23

Speaker 1

Yeah, we'll just give it just one second.

02:43:23 - 02:43:23

Speaker 13

Okay.

02:43:23 - 02:45:04

Speaker 1

Yeah. I'm going to do a little bit of a tap dance here, and we'll get going. What we're gonna do is we're gonna take a sixty second to a two minute recess. We're gonna come right back with folks. So let's just take a quick recess.

All right. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. We are going to be talking all issues of Kelp and the Blop. Sounds like a horror movie. My goodness.

But, Doctor, the floor is yours, and very grateful. Let's go right to the presentation. Please.

02:45:04 - 02:49:48

Speaker 13

Absolutely. So just, first of all, speaking to how rapidly the science on kelp restoration is increasing in California, that really kicked off following all of the events the director accurately described, and has really been spurred by the investments that you just heard about from Ocean Protection Council, California Sea Grant, and CDFW in kelp restoration. So, Director Eckerly already talked about all of the great projects being going on funded by those endeavors. But in addition to those, many of us in the scientific community have been able to leverage or supplement those with funding from National Science Foundation, NOAA, and other sources. And of course, we're facing uncertain futures about those types of funding.

But an example is I'm part of a large collaborative group that is looking at how CALP restoration might anticipate future marine heat waves using NSF funding. And one of the ways we might anticipate future marine heat waves is having a well coordinated collaborative network for rapid response. So, we are in the process of analyzing what that collaborative network looks like in California to be able to do a gap analysis on it. These are hot off the press results. One thing we can say is that these agencies, through the efforts you just heard about, again, CDFW, OPC, OST, California Sea Grant, those are really central to all the coordination that is currently happening and how collaborative kelp restoration is in California right now, connecting across academia, agencies, NGOs, those in the fishing community, and other community members.

But you guys had lots of questions about the blob, so I am not an oceanographer, but I have been trying to learn as much as I can. And what we do know is that, yes, we have this very large extent blob forming in the North Pacific with that stagnant weather pattern and persistent high temperatures with, an over a large area that's the signature of the blob. Also, August had record high temperatures across the North Pacific. So the blob is forming. The big question for how much it'll affect kelp is whether it'll persist and whether it'll affect deeper water, and that's a big unknown right now.

The most recent forecast I could find from September 2 from NOAA was suggesting that it wouldn't persist past several months, which means that upwelling would occur, and that would be healthy conditions for kelp again, hopefully, like we saw with this resurgent growth. But then the temperatures have become more and more and more near shore than that forecast originally anticipated. So that might be changing. But whether these marine heat waves are happening this year or happening in the future, there is this question of how do we anticipate and prepare for them. And you mentioned coral reefs earlier.

In the coral world, there's a lot of attention to these climate ready restoration approaches, and those are starting to get attention in the kelp world as well. These questions of how do we accelerate genetic adaptation and acclimatization to these high stress conditions, things like finding the very stress tolerant genotypes, preserving those, breeding those, potentially moving those around. These hold a lot of promise. They also could be really risky. And none of them are quite ready yet, or quite needed yet.

But as a scientific community, there's a large group of us coming together to look at what research do we need to do to be ready when they come in demand, so we can be forward looking on this. And that means identifying those research needs for which could even be relevant to CALP systems, how do you implement them effectively, and how to implement in a way that recognizes and mitigates risk. And one final note on these emerging climate ready interventions, they don't just pose scientific challenges, they also pose a number of regulatory challenges. Because of their novelty, because of their high risk, they might not be the type of thing that our regulatory agencies have dealt with typically. And so another thing our group has done is looked to other places where regulatory agencies have grappled with how to balance risk with innovation and say which of those policy tools could be relevant to this case of climate ready interventions.

And I'm not going to have time to go through all of these, but our main takeaways are that we were able to find a number of these regulatory tools that do enable this balance of risk and innovation, as well as consideration of the risk of inaction. But implementing any of these rests in having resources and personnel at the regulatory agencies to support them. So again, thank you for the opportunity to speak here.

02:49:48 - 02:50:56

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Doctor. I have a few questions, but I want to turn it over to Senator Cortese to see if there's any items that the good Senator has. You're good. Thank you so much. Doctor, so 2014 through '17, twenty fourteen through sixteen, I think, is when we saw that really big die off of bull kelp, especially off the California coast.

And it seemed like there was a perfect storm. Right? You had really warm ocean conditions, a die off of the starfish, and then purple urchins popping up in giant numbers. The starfish used to eat urchin. I know I'm a lay person and oversimplifying.

Talk to us about what are we looking at a new normal now, do you believe, especially with kelp? Because it is so critical for salmon and for crab, Right? There there is a whole habitat in which kelp helps spawn. So, talk to us about that and what you see. Do we get back to where we were?

Or is it going to be a new normal and more challenging?

02:50:57 - 02:52:56

Speaker 13

I there's a lot of unknowns. I wish I had a crystal ball for I would say that the fact that, the existing restoration, projects in places like Big River and Albayonet Bay have been successful at getting kelp back in small scale on the North Coast shows that when action is taken, that it is possible to recover these systems, that the question of can it spread beyond that right now, right? These are expensive, intensive. And so a major challenge is how do you scale that type of restoration activity? And one of the grants that's currently funded in Big River is really looking at this question of how do we scale up our restoration approaches.

And our own research, and I have to emphasize this is modeling research, so says what can happen, not what actually does happen, but suggests that our current toolkit of reintroducing kelp, removing urchins has the capacity to recover kelp systems as we've seen. But having them be able to be resilient to future marine heat waves really rests in bringing in that sunflower star or urchin predator reintroduction as well because of that one two punch that you mentioned. Right? That perfect storm in those two events. If it had just been any one of those, we don't know that we would have seen the level of decline that we saw.

And but in terms of the question of a new normal, there's a lot of ways one could picture what a new normal could look like. It could mean, is this more of a managed system? Right? Is intervention you know, if we have more frequent and extreme marine heat waves, does that mean that restoration is just much more common than we think of in this system? That really depends on what those future climate conditions look like, but also, like Monica was talking about, what the societal goals are in those places.

02:52:56 - 02:53:06

Speaker 1

But don't you if if you look at what the outlook is Mhmm. It's depressing, especially when it comes to the climate crisis.

02:53:06 - 02:53:06

Speaker 13

Mhmm.

02:53:07 - 02:53:14

Speaker 1

And my understanding is that we have never seen these type, at least in recorded history

02:53:14 - 02:53:14

Speaker 14

Mhmm.

02:53:15 - 02:53:20

Speaker 1

These type of warm ocean events that we're seeing now.

02:53:20 - 02:53:20

Speaker 14

Yes.

02:53:22 - 02:53:32

Speaker 1

So, it's gonna have to be managed, I would imagine. Your thoughts on that? And then, the other piece is the volume of starfish, for example

02:53:32 - 02:53:33

Speaker 13

Mhmm.

02:53:33 - 02:54:02

Speaker 1

That would need to be bred and dispersed into the ocean. It's a huge endeavor as well of reintroducing that predator species. So, it's just this multi layer, and I'll turn it over to each of you to be able to talk about this. But, Doctor, you're please and I know some of this is you projecting your opinion as well on base of the modeling what you've seen. But, I mean, it's not happy news when it comes to climate.

02:54:03 - 02:54:34

Speaker 13

Well, as somebody who works in both coral reefs and kelp forests, that that it is a world of a lot of challenges. Right? And facing these challenges, the reality is without and we can say this clearly with coral reefs, with kelp forests, how the changing ocean is interfacing with upwelling has more uncertainty to it. But with coral reefs, there is no hope if there is no global greenhouse gas mitigation.

02:54:34 - 02:54:35

Speaker 3

Yep.

02:54:35 - 02:54:44

Speaker 13

But there are these tools, like I was just describing, that can build a bridge to a future where that mitigation can occur. And that's how I very

02:54:44 - 02:54:45

Speaker 1

much see You're saying on kelp though.

02:54:45 - 02:55:17

Speaker 13

Yeah. So that's for corals, right? And those the fact that that's being has been worked on in the coral world can help provide a a road map for kelp to say, how can we jump start this and get a little ahead of the ball on it. Learn some of those lessons for how do we be a little more ready so we don't end up like the Florida Keys where suddenly the marine heat wave is so extreme that you have to pull everything out of the water to get anything to survive.

02:55:17 - 02:55:17

Speaker 1

Jesus.

02:55:17 - 02:56:37

Speaker 13

And so, and that started in 2013. And now, what they're looking at, and Doctor. Andrew Baker is leading, as well as a number of other scientists leading work on hybrids between more heat tolerant corals in Honduras and local corals in Florida to anticipate that future, to be able to enable these more extreme persistence under these more extreme temperatures. And so, really, it's I think there's a question of how to look to these other systems to say what are some tools that could be useful here to to be able to future proof is it I don't like that term. Right?

Because there is no proofing. But to be that little more climate ready approaches. And, again, it's about building that bridge to when greenhouse gas mitigation occurs, that none of this works in a vacuum. And, yeah, a lot of the restoration approaches are smaller scale. So it's a question about how you can balance small scale approaches that preserve those source populations and preserve those opportunities.

And we have a highly variable system here of good years and bad years. So if and when good years come, the system can capitalize that on expand. And there's a real balance there consideration of, yeah, how much can we scale. That is one of the big challenges.

02:56:38 - 02:57:33

Speaker 1

And Madam Executive Director, when we first saw that die off, we were hearing from divers who want to go in and smash the urchins. It's just the volume. Right? And so if you want to do a little bit of a deeper dive on what you've seen in your thoughts, and I know this is going be a little bit of projection, and I don't want to project onto you. But if you don't mind your opinion on this because we're not going at least for the time being, we're not going back to where we were.

And what we know from all the data, the climate crisis is gonna continue to get worse. And I think it is a fair assumption that these heat events within the Pacific are going to continue. So your thoughts, on how you reintroduce a predator to the urchin, right, because it's just it's a multilayer approach. Please.

02:57:35 - 02:58:32

Speaker 14

You gave me an easy one. I guess I will start by saying reiterating what Doctor. Baskett said, that there's a balancing about the level of intensity and the investment in doing these restoration efforts. So at the beginning, we were able to actually pay fishermen to do this work, fishermen who were actually not able to do their normal fishery because of the things that are happening with climate change. And we saw some really positive results.

But the level of effort and investment to do that at scale is going to be pretty intense. And so what we're looking at now is, are there strongholds? Are there places that are more resilient, climate refugia areas or beds of kelp that are more resilient to these places that merit focused attention and application of these restoration techniques.

02:58:32 - 02:58:38

Speaker 1

That's Do you think, for example, Albion is one of them? Like, what are you seeing in regards to the project areas?

02:58:38 - 02:58:42

Speaker 14

Yeah, I might kick that over to Doctor. Baskett to respond.

02:58:43 - 02:59:49

Speaker 13

In terms of where refugia are, there's a lot of observation of these persistent kelp at river mouths. And a number of scientists, our large collaborative group, as well as others, are finding that at river mouths, you have low salinity, which kelp can withstand pretty well until you get really extreme, but urchins hate it. And so, that's a tendency, that's why that's been one source of the few persistent kelp forests on the North Coast through all of this. And so that's really, again, emerging new science that's just coming together to look at that. But also deeper waters is another area of refugia where we're seeing the remnant kelp forests.

And so those all of these have different drivers to why they're refugia to them. So a lot of great emerging ability to identify those drivers, but still a lot more to figure out how do we better leverage that for restoration approaches.

02:59:49 - 03:00:16

Speaker 14

And I'll just add that some of the investments that we've made in research and restoration techniques include kind of growing bull kelp that could be resilient to these higher ocean temperatures. So really, you know, taking advantage of the institutional, academic expertise in California to figure out kind of how we innovate in the restoration space, to address these uncertainties that you flagged?

03:00:17 - 03:00:36

Speaker 1

In my ignorance, I apologize. Just that we just like we heard about coral, of introducing coral that may be off of another area in the world with the bulk another breed of bulk kelp, you're saying, that could be heartier, correct?

03:00:37 - 03:00:44

Speaker 14

Well, they're looking at bulk kelp, different strains that might actually just have higher tolerance for heat. So, introducing new species. And where would

03:00:44 - 03:00:47

Speaker 1

that be, essentially? Like, here?

03:00:47 - 03:00:50

Speaker 14

In the lab yeah, in the lab. Lab experiments.

03:00:50 - 03:00:57

Speaker 1

But what I'm saying, though, is like, does that kelp currently grow off of the California Coast? Yes. Or are you bringing it Yes. In from somewhere

03:00:57 - 03:00:59

Speaker 14

No, from the California Coast. Interesting.

03:00:59 - 03:01:03

Speaker 1

Yeah. And how many different varieties of bull kelp are there?

03:01:04 - 03:01:05

Speaker 14

Well, there's go ahead.

03:01:07 - 03:01:30

Speaker 13

Bull kelp is relatively genetically homogenous across the state, is my understanding. So there aren't really different varieties, but that doesn't mean that there isn't local adaptation to or acclimatization. That's another key piece tease apart. How much of this is physiological versus genetic when you see different stress tolerances of kelp at different locations with different micro climates throughout the California Coast?

03:01:31 - 03:01:32

Speaker 1

Fascinating, do you think? Science.

03:01:33 - 03:01:36

Speaker 14

Yeah. Exactly. Yeah.

03:01:36 - 03:01:38

Speaker 1

Yeah, please. Senator.

03:01:38 - 03:03:47

Speaker 3

I'm just curious about the regulatory side of it. Again, not the same COVID I've used with other panels and not looking for, extensive response in that area because I know enough to know it would be very extensive. But the chairman just happened to mention casually mentioned Alviso, which is down in my area, in an area that I spent a lot of time working on as a county supervisor. And it just strikes me listening to the good ideas or in the science about what you could do that my experience, you know, as a local official trying to go in and make changes, you know, to that brackish area of the bay, the Slough area that's because of human impact has a saltation such as is nowhere near restored to what it was a hundred years ago or even fifty, sixty years ago. We talk about trying to go in and do that.

I don't want to get into calling out any particular agency or anything like that. You know who they all are. I mean, they're just this, don't touch it. You know, don't touch it. Leave things the way they are kind of I'm I'm simplifying.

So just I'm just wondering as you you know, maybe it's not your know your focus area of course and the work you do is very valuable where you do it and what you do and how you're informing us but are there significant regulatory implications to navigate? I mean, sounds like Florida went in and just kind of did what they want to do, but they do that. And I'm just wondering to hear if you can get through the hoops, you know, to do some of this work without just getting killed from a regulatory standpoint?

03:03:47 - 03:05:18

Speaker 14

Yeah, thank you for that question. And Doctor. Schumann has left the room, but I will do my best to represent the department. I will say that, I think, to Senator Maguire's point, this collapse came so suddenly and so unexpectedly and and unprecedentedly. We'd never seen anything like it.

And I really think the state and partners, across the coast really activated as quickly as we could to take action that was precautionary enough but didn't get in our own way of actually trying to do something to address the problem. So I think that's really powerful. And we're making these learning by doing investments to try to get answers quickly to the questions. At the same time, the Department of Fish and Wildlife is working to develop this statewide kelp restoration and management plan, which is really going to create that regulatory framework so that we're being thoughtful and precautionary. We are using science, but we're not just sitting around waiting for the science to be perfect before we take action.

So, I feel confident in saying that the department is, you know, leading in this effort and is, fully committed and invested, along with OPC and and everyone else, to, address kelp forest recovery and resilience, in a way that's going to move forward, you know, at the pace that we need to address the issue in the face of climate change.

03:05:18 - 03:06:50

Speaker 3

So I guess what I'm wondering is the legislature came in and kind of occupied part of the space and said, hey, look, there's a thing in transportation in the Bay Area that my colleagues are familiar with here, including the chair, called fix it first. And it's really a proclamation, policy, it's a legislative policy that says resources first need to go to, you know fixing it literally fixing and restoring what we have before we start you know going off in other directions. It just makes me wonder if we you know as a foundation to all this work that's coming rule making regulatory work or whatever is there a place, this could be a rhetorical question, I guess. Is there a place for legislature to say as a legislative, as a statutory policy, legislature requires that these areas be restored as a first priority, as the highest priority to where they should be, to try to cut through the regulatory resistance. It just seems like if we're silent on it as a legislature, maybe things end up in the right place or maybe those who would, like I was alluding to, say don't touch it, know, win out.

And and then that just seems like what I'm listening to here would be, at least for this panel, kinda tragic, not to be able to go in and try to, make adjustments.

03:06:51 - 03:07:59

Speaker 14

Yeah. I I do have a couple of responses to that. One, I I think the legislature has made a lot of meaningful, taken a lot of meaningful action and leadership in this space. We've got the 30 by 30 initiative that's really prioritizing protecting 30% of our lands and coastal waters by 2030. The amount of climate bond investments in the budget this year, again, dollars 19,000,000 for kelp recovery and rocky reef restoration, in addition to all of the investments for climate ready fisheries, sea level rise adaptation.

And so I do think there are, you have already done so much. And I don't have any good suggestions on what else needs to be done other than to say, like, the state agencies, and the partners that are working with us to do this work, we're all committed to making sure that we're taking action in a way that's thoughtful so that we're not going to look back and say, oh, we had unintended consequences of the actions that we've taken, but that we're not just sitting around waiting for the perfect science to make meaningful action.

03:07:59 - 03:09:22

Speaker 3

Yeah. Agreed. Agreed, at least from my standpoint. But and I don't want to belabor it, it's just thought provoking for future reference but when I try to draw analogies into things like air quality, like carb, like transportation, regional transportation efforts and so forth, the trend has been to some degree for the legislature to chart, know sort of put a stake in the ground and say this is, or the governor, this is where we're trying to go. You know just look at EV policy in the state right now on the transportation side.

This is where we're trying to go and then it sort of it seems that legislative intent kind of starts to clear the way and send the right signals to the regulatory bodies that, well, then that's where we need to go. We need to be we need to make sure we're not being obstructionist to that policy, you know, even inadvertently. Even if it's just because we're going through lengthy rulemaking or something, we need to speed it up. Sounds like that is a part of it. Thank you so much for citing all the appropriations and things that the legislature has done to sort of back the play.

And I appreciate your responses.

03:09:24 - 03:10:15

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Senator Cortesio. My last question is chicken or egg, but I'm going to say starfish or kelp. What is visiting the Noyos Center in Fort Bragg, they have the starfish breeding program. I am absolutely butchering the name of the program. But what was shared with us is just the volume in which would be needed to be able to actually make a significant difference.

Your thoughts on that because if we are reintroducing kelp, but we have significant population of urchin without any type of predator, does that defeat the purpose? And we'd love to get your take on that, and that's why I ask, is it a starfish or the kelp first?

03:10:16 - 03:10:36

Speaker 14

I think it's all of the above. Truly, we're running down the field across all of these different approaches. We need a portfolio. We need a multi pronged approach. I was just at Cal Academy last week.

I got to see the baby Pycnopodia being grown there. They have

03:10:36 - 03:10:37

Speaker 1

much better than I, because I was

03:10:38 - 03:11:02

Speaker 14

just made a starfish show. No, it's Okay. It's Okay. And they have to actually grow teeny, tiny little urchin to feed the tiny starfish. So the science is incredible.

The amount of effort and work going into that is so important. And it has to be combined with all of the work that we're doing to understand the kelperfugia.

03:11:03 - 03:11:07

Speaker 1

What's the volume that you have to actually get to in regards to the starfish?

03:11:07 - 03:11:10

Speaker 14

Like how many stars do you need to put back in the Yeah,

03:11:10 - 03:11:21

Speaker 1

because it mean, has to be in the I don't know. I mean, to the noise I as I say that, it's in the millions. I mean, it literally is in the millions. We saw just this massive die off.

03:11:21 - 03:11:22

Speaker 13

Yes.

03:11:22 - 03:11:42

Speaker 1

And so, there is just no system to be able to produce the volume which is needed. And that's why I ask, Is it the chicken, the egg, the starfish, the kelp? Yeah. Right? And so, that's why I just I know we have to do it all, but we really don't have the system to be able to generate that volume of starfish that we need.

Am I mistaken in that?

03:11:42 - 03:11:55

Speaker 14

I mean, I'm not sure about the answer to that. I know there's billions of tiny stars in Cal Academy, and there are programs up and down the state that are growing them. Marissa, you may have more information to share here.

03:11:56 - 03:13:21

Speaker 13

Yeah. So, Sunflower Star Lab, well as Cal Academy, growing lots of stars. There's also other places throughout the West Coast looking at how do we improve our raising our capacity to raise them. They are voracious little eaters. Even when they're tiny, they eat And a the there are really three things that will deter urchins mowing down kelp.

One is being eaten by a star. Can't eat a I mean, if you or another predator. Right? If you're dead, can't mow down kelp. The other is being afraid of that.

So, there's actually a multiplication effect of having that fear response. Then they're more likely to hide and less likely to actively graze and more likely to hide and just live off of whatever kelp might drip trickle down to the The third thing is just having enough kelp trickling down to the seafloor that they're satiated and not so worried about going out and actively grazing. They have these two modes, passive and active. And so, it's a question of what triggers that switch to a passive. And so, all of that comes into play together, and that that's why the portfolio right?

But that also means you don't it's beyond it's not just you need enough stars to eat enough urchins. You need enough stars to scare enough urchins, essentially. And that helps the math on this quite a bit.

03:13:21 - 03:15:45

Speaker 1

Passing Starfish sounds like my four year old's appetite. So that's what I'm saying. Oh, my goodness. I I I just I wanna say, number one, amazing work. Thank you, especially right now.

As I've said before, California continues to lead the way and won't be deterred. And I'm just so incredibly grateful. And, madam executive director, I think you said it best. We gotta do it all. Right?

And thank god we have voters who passed prop four that's gonna continue to help fund these climate initiatives. And thank god we have the three of you on the front lines. I just wanna say thank you and did not mean to ask 2,000 questions on starfish and kelp. So very, very grateful, but really nice job. Thank you so much.

Thank you. Great job. Thank you. We're now going to be moving on to our final panel. And this is the Fishery Committee in Aquaculture Program Reports, and we're really grateful that we have folks who are here today.

Miss Fisher is joining us, via Zoom. She'll be with us in just a moment. She's the chief administrator for the California Dungeness Crab Task Force, and we saw Rochelle on, after we got our technical issues fixed. We have Darren Maru, who is here, chair of the California Advisory Committee on Salmon and Steelhead Trout, and Doctor. Whiteman is here.

Really grateful to see the executive director of the Ocean Science Trust. We're going to take a thirty second recess. We'll be right back with you, and we're going to, just make sure that Ms. Fisher is good to go. Give us three seconds.

All right, ladies and gentlemen. We're going to be taking public comment immediately following this panel, we really appreciate everybody hanging with us here today. This is our Fishery Committee and Aquaculture Program reports and reports back to the legislature. We are going to welcome Madam Administrator, Ms. Fisher, who has the best last name of anyone in the fisheries and aquaculture hearing.

And this is gonna be on the California indigenous crab task force. We're really grateful that she's joining us. She is joining us electronically here today. Michelle, it's nice to see you. The floor is yours.

You have five minutes. I'll give you a thirty second prompt. How are doing?

03:15:45 - 03:15:51

Speaker 16

Good. Thank you so much for the flexibility. Good to see you again. Thanks for letting me join remotely.

03:15:51 - 03:15:54

Speaker 1

Of course. You're coming in loud and clear. Take it away.

03:15:54 - 03:21:28

Speaker 16

Awesome. Awesome. Since the last fisheries forum update, the task force has shared a few recommendations reports with the joint committee with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Fish and Game Commission, and the Ocean Protection Council. And over the last three years, the task force's recommendations have focused on providing fishery management guidance, especially related to marine life entanglements and the ramp program, domestic acid, all of the things that have been discussed earlier today. The department has responded to some of these recommendations.

They incorporated the task force's guidance into the ramp regulations. They distributed replacement tags when quality issues arose. The Nature Conservancy and PCFFA has been really responsive as well, as you heard earlier, in responding to the task force's recommendations on last year retrieval recommendations. And we've been grateful in the past for for, the pro tem support in addressing the task force's recommendations. However, the legislature hasn't acted on recommendations from the task force in a number of years, which has raised some concerns by task force members.

And as Lisa and Dick and Kate referenced earlier, that surplus in the Dungeness crab account continues to accrue since the trap limit program was implemented in 2014. And last October, the task force recommended depositing those surplus funds in an interest bearing account managed by Pacific States Marine Fisheries Commission, similar to what they do with, quality testing, account management. And this would be to support, commercial fishery priorities. However, if that's not possible, the task force recommends reducing trap tag fees to prevent ongoing overcharges to fishermen. And with the added financial pressures from the ramp program, the shortened fishing seasons, the DCTF just continues to be frustrated that excess fees are neither returned nor benefiting the fleet.

And I'm happy to respond to any questions around the account. I know that that was discussed earlier. And I suggest caution with how this is responded to because simply opening those funds to any use would be worrisome to the fleet because there's fear around the funds not being used in the best interest of the fleet. The task force has also recommended some change to fishing game code sections that are outdated given that the ramp now requires all commercial Dungeness crab vessels to carry electronic tracking devices. And as Dick mentioned, the task force has reaffirmed this same recommendation three times, about amending the gear servicing interval, and that hasn't been responded to.

And if it's something that the legislature can't respond to, I think that they would appreciate some feedback on that. And they would appreciate some, support from the legislature in helping to liaise with the state and federal agencies and urging them to streamline these processes, especially there's a lot of parallel processes associated with the whales, things, the incidental take permit ramp, take reduction team, among other issues. And the task force would like to learn from this committee on how these recommendations will be addressed. And just a gentle reminder that this fishery is very unique and that it's managed by the legislature. The task force is gonna meet again in two weeks, October.

Everybody is welcome to attend. It's open to the public. The highest priority agenda item that they're going to be discussing is that there are a number of fishing game code sections that are critical to the management of the commercial Dungeness crab fishery that will become inoperable 04/01/2029. This includes the ability to revoke a permit for certain violations, a trap limit program, vessel length restriction, vest or permit fees, the Dungeons Craft Task Force, ramp. It's endless, really.

Not endless. There's a lot. The DCTF will begin discussions on which provisions will be that they would recommend be reauthorized, updated, or eliminated, and we anticipate this will be the first of several conversations. And we'll we're having these conversations in partnership with the Department of Fish and Wildlife. And just a a reminder that the legislature will need to act on this in the next two years to avoid significant impacts on the fisheries management.

And in the past, in twenty seventeen, eighteen, we did work with the pro tem's office, to to update these sunsetting regulations. Other topics on the agenda in two weeks, lost gear recovery. As you guys heard, that is so crucially important. Funding priorities, ramp, and whale entanglements, unfortunately, are standing agenda item. And then some folks want to discuss the executive order for restoring America's seafood competitiveness.

Following the meeting, there will be a report to you all, and it will also be sent to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Fish and Game Commission, and we do anticipate some legislative requests as I mentioned. The task force welcomes the committee's guidance on appropriate pathways to engage in advancing its recommendations and how to make the process for addressing the sunsetting fishing game codes as smooth as possible. And, you know, we appreciate the challenges that the state is facing as was discussed so, so many times in the hearing today. And because this fishery, again, is managed by the legislature, it's just so crucial that the committee remain actively engaged with the task force to ensure effective and responsive management. So we look forward to collaborating with you and your staff on these these and other important issues.

And we also invite you all to share your priorities so that we can work together to strengthen this fishery. And on behalf of the task force and the administrative team, we'd like to thank the committee, mister Nielsen. Really appreciate the challenge of hurting all the folks. So thank you for for all your work there and especially, the pro tem pro tem Maguire. Thank you all for the opportunity to provide this update.

Happy to answer any questions.

03:21:29 - 03:21:43

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Phenom. I appreciate you very much. We're going to turn it now over to Darren Maru, Chair of the California Advisory Committee on Salmon and the Sealhead Trout. It's good to see you, sir. Thank you so much for taking the time.

The floor is yours. You have five minutes, and I'll give you a thirty second prompt.

03:21:43 - 03:27:43

Speaker 5

Thank you very much. Good afternoon, Senator McGuire and Senator Cortese, you stepped out, and Mr. Nielsen, thanks for inviting me here today. My name is Darren Maru. I'm the North Coast and Science Director for California Trout and Chair of the Salmon Advisory Committee, speaking on behalf of the committee today.

I wanted to start by thanking you, Senator McGuire, for your lengthy and commendable tenure chairing this committee. Your clear commitment to these issues, care for our fishing communities up and down the coast, and your attention to detail are really notable. So on behalf of the committee, I just want to say thank you sincerely for your service here. I also want to thank you for approving our nominees. We have a full committee now, and we have had for several years now, so thank you for ushering through those nominations that we send your way.

I'm going to go off script a little bit in response to some of the prior speakers and go back to an issue that you raised in the first panel, which is the California Monitoring Program. I do so because our advisory committee has taken this issue up since I was chair beginning in 2017. The California Monitoring Program is our vital source of information for tracking responses to investments in restoration and watersheds from our salmon and steelhead populations. We need this program to expand. We're currently at probably a 20% to 30% funding level.

We need on the order of 20,000,000 to $30,000,000 a year, to keep these, monitoring programs going throughout coastal and Central Valley watersheds. The only source of funding right now comes from PACSURF, which is federal funding through the state. But as you're probably aware, we passed AB eight zero nine that created the California Monitoring Program itself. It's essentially a bank account that needs state legislature to put money into it. And so I want to offer three suggestions that perhaps we could look into together.

The first would be looking at AB fourteen ninety two, which is a timber tax passed over a decade ago, that, you know, if you think about it, funding from timber sold at lumber stores from the resource coming from our watersheds that also has impacts to salmon and sealhead populations would be a logical source of funding to track the populations in those watersheds. And I currently don't know how those funds are allocated but could be put into this AB eight zero nine California Monitoring Program account. The second is the cannabis tax fund. As Senator Cortese mentioned, you know, there are impacts from cannabis grows in these coastal watersheds. Taxes could be available to be put into that account as well to help support and expand the funding that's available for these monitoring programs.

And the third suggestion is a little more complicated, but propositions that the state legislature the state citizens pass through the legislature typically is invested in infrastructure and not available for these kinds of monitoring programs, but we could justify effectiveness monitoring and take a portion of those prop funds and put it into that account so that we have independent monitoring programs that track the success of those projects that are supported by proposition funding. And so I think each agency that allocates funds, whether it's CFW, WCB, SEC, could take a portion of that, you know, a percentage, and put it into an account that supports monitoring so that we understand the response to those projects that are vitally, you know, important to our investments. Back to my script. I had quite a bit of comments about Chinook salmon from the Klamath River. We've heard a lot about that today, so I'm going to skip down to some of the important conclusions.

Going back to a comment that Lisa from PCFFA mentioned, the commercial fishermen are paying the price for the salmon closures. You know, I represent and our committee represents commercial, recreational, and tribal interests, and we're sincerely aware of the burden that commercial, recreational, and tribal, you know, entities pay for these closures, it's not us causing the crisis. Some recent research that's come out from Doctor. Emily Chen, a colleague of mine, is pointing to reduced productivity and survival from tributaries in the Klamath River, right? So we know that water impoundments, diversions for irrigation, dams, and poor water quality leading to disease are causing low abundance and small fish arriving at the oceans.

And so, you know, not to belabor the commercial issues, but looking at our inland waters as the as a place where we can invest, where we can make a difference. We heard Senator, or excuse me, Secretary Crowfoot mention two millennial droughts, and certainly those droughts are fundamentally affecting our watersheds, but there's a lot that we can do in those watersheds to bring back in stream flows and support better water quality and start to recover that productivity that's currently lacking in our watersheds. So one of my three recommendations for the Klamath issue was to restore and protect the productivity from Klamath River tributaries to produce healthy and abundant juveniles, which leads me to my second topic, the Shasta And Scott Rivers, which are vitally important tributaries in the Klamath Basin. You're aware that AB two sixty three was passed by the legislature and signed last week by Governor Newsom. This bill specifies that emergency regulations for Scott River and Shasta River watersheds will remain in effect until January 2031.

So we have this five year window, which we think is a really important window of time to compile and synthesize information for these watersheds so that we can develop and adopt what the State Water Board calls long term recovery flows, those kinds of in stream flows that will lead to recovery of those populations in those watersheds. Ideally, at the end of that five year lifespan of AB23263, we will have the science and the regulatory policies in place to sustain those flows.

03:27:43 - 03:27:45

Speaker 1

You have them thirty seconds.

03:27:45 - 03:29:24

Speaker 5

Okay. Boy, okay. I also want to note that we had ten years of CDFW trying to put in place a watershed wide permitting program. Had We another ten year process by NIMSS trying to develop safe harbor agreements, so we're nervous about another process by another agency. We want to get to that place where we have those flows put in place.

I'm going have to skip the rest of this. Also sent our advisory committee sent a letter to Director Bonham and to your committee about the exempted fishing permit for the Pacific Whiting Conservation Cooperative. We just want to make sure you're attentive to that. That permit will allow take of listed salmonids in the ocean in a time when our commercial fleets can't fish for them. And so that permit, it's a federal permit, but we just want to bring it to your attention, certainly should not be allowed.

I just wanted to close with a couple of stories. Obviously, the Klamath Dam removal has been great to see PG and E submittal of a license surrender application for the Potter Valley projects and our Russian River and Eel River partnership coming to a water diversion agreement that will allow that diversion to continue, vitally important for the eel. The NOAA and CFW scientists determining the cause of thiamine deficiency syndrome just been remarkable success that those really, really, really dedicated scientists dedicated to that issue. And what was mentioned today, the Governor's Salmon Strategy, with the department really getting a lot done and being accountable to their actions. We're very grateful to see that.

And finally, the legislation that you've led to get Prop four funds allocated this year, and we're just grateful for your efforts there. So thank you very much.

03:29:24 - 03:29:45

Speaker 1

Mr. Chair, really grateful you're here. Thank you so much. You're going to hang with us, and we'll come to questions in just a moment. Thank you.

Okay. We are now going to turn over to one of the smartest people I know in this area, that's Doctor. Whiteman. Thank you so much, Madam Executive Director from the Ocean Science Trust. We're grateful that you're here today.

It's so good to see you. The floor is yours. You have five minutes, so I'll give you a thirty second prompt. How are doing?

03:29:46 - 03:30:12

Speaker 17

Great. Thank you so much for senator for the opportunity to be here today. I am pleased to provide an update from the California Ocean Science Trust. As a quick reminder, we strengthen the bridge between scientific research and sound ocean management. We hold steadfast that science is a powerful tool for uncovering, building and aligning policy pathways.

Every day in 2025, I wake up glad to be in California.

03:30:12 - 03:30:12

Speaker 1

Oh, yes.

03:30:13 - 03:30:35

Speaker 17

So first, the business item. As you know, we are required to report annually to the legislature and to this joint committee. Today, I'm pleased to present our 2024 annual report to uphold that legislative requirement. I hope you see in that report our commitment to serve as science advisers to both executive branch agencies and to

03:30:35 - 03:30:35

Speaker 14

the

03:30:35 - 03:36:08

Speaker 17

legislature. Now more than ever, it's essential that California has a place to turn for trusted science advice and the decisions that are shaping the future of our coast and ocean. And thank you for your support. And given that 2024 feels like a different world than the one of today, let's fast forward to some current work and two specific updates that I wanted to share. I wanted to lift in this venue some work that we're engaged on.

It's early days, but on fisheries insurance. As we've heard in the testimony today, on a daily basis, the fishing community is grappling with challenges where no road map from the past can adequately tackle today and the future. We need new tools, new solutions and new partners. Back actually in 2024 in spring, we convened a symposium on federal fishery disaster declarations, which indicated a growing interest in supplementary support for communities facing fishery disasters. To continue the conversation earlier this year, we brought our OST's cross sector convening power to bear on one potential solution, that of fisheries insurance.

And academic researchers, industry representatives and government officials came together to explore what insurance may or may not be able to do in a fisheries context and to identify next steps to further understand the viability and utility of insurance for West Coast Fisheries. Spurred by interest from several congressional offices, we're now preparing to co host a briefing in D. C. Later this month to explore whether and how insurance could have a role in fishery disaster response and to reinforce, with a primarily congressional audience the importance of ocean science research and fisheries surveys. It's early in this conversation, and we don't yet know if this is the right viable solution.

But encouraging cross sector dialogue is essential, and it's possible that this is an issue that can thread that needle on aligning state and federal priorities and engage the private sector alongside public investments in novel solutions. So on the thread of novel solutions and novel funding mechanisms and turning to my second of two updates, I was reflecting yesterday at the Ocean Protection Council meeting that as science advisor, it used to be the case that we could rely upon the deep bench and leadership in California's universities and broader scientific communities to be there when we needed it. And through shifts in federal priorities this year, that's no longer the case. Senator, you began with acknowledgment of California's commitment to science to through funding and recognition of the federal funding cuts. As you also alluded to, the science community is under attack, both from that funding and support lens, but also through the lens of academic freedom to scientific knowledge advancement.

And we often focus particularly in venues like this in our role as science advisors to you all and to the executive branch agencies. But that's actually only half of what the Ocean Science Trust was set up to do. The other half is to mobilize capacity and resources, both human and financial, to strengthen that body of advancing knowledge that is then available to bring to this role and responsibility as science advisors. In this moment, we don't know what the future of research funding is going to look like. But it's definitely going to look different than the model that has been established in The US since World War II, a very strong federal public support for scientific research innovation and R and D.

So in recognition of that other half of our organizational mission, our mission really calls on us to step up in this moment with partners in Oregon and Washington with whom we've now formed a formal tristate effort to create the venues and opportunities to come together, listen to each other's priorities and design that future for science funding. Readying for scenarios with different mixes of public and private capital, supporting and rebuilding where appropriate our longstanding leadership in this state of scientific research and innovation. Some folk here may remember, Senator, I'm sure you do, back to the West Coast Ocean Acidification and Hypoxia Science Panel. And the way in which taking that regional approach led by science led not only to a science road map and state investments, but also to policy and funding investments at federal and international levels. So we're now emulating that, aiming to lift shared priorities with a unified voice in a West Coast Ocean Science Action Agenda developed through listening sessions that will occur throughout 2026, and we invite participation in those that can form the foundation for designing those public private investments for delivery in 2027 and beyond.

In the midst of how we're reeling from changes and impacts this year, we have to start now to look forward so that we can mobilize and rebuild as opportunities allow. And I will just close by saying that more information, if you're interested, that specific effort is available at oceanscienceagenda.org. Thank you.

03:36:08 - 03:36:15

Speaker 1

Doctor. Thank you so much, Doctor. Very grateful. I'm going to look to Senator Cortese if there's any items that you have. Senator Cortese.

03:36:19 - 03:36:22

Speaker 3

Don't I pass for Oh, if that's okay with the chair, and

03:36:22 - 03:36:23

Speaker 1

I may. Thank you so much. I have

03:36:23 - 03:36:24

Speaker 3

one follow-up question.

03:36:25 - 03:37:08

Speaker 1

Thank you so much. Madam Secretary Director, you focused on dispelling myths on offshore wind. When you go back to D. C, I assume that's going to be something that we'll be talking about. I'm just being blunt, and I'm not trying to be overly political here.

I think there's only probably three people in the world that think that offshore wind or windmills cause cancer. And so I would just hope, because we had that $420,000,000 pulled from Humboldt, the money pulled from Long Beach, It's good for the environment, but also it is really good for the economy as well. And is that something that you're going to be talking about when you go back to DC?

03:37:08 - 03:37:20

Speaker 17

We will be carrying we are currently organizing hill visits, and we will be carrying the stack of information from California to represent appropriately.

03:37:20 - 03:37:56

Speaker 1

Good times. All right. I appreciate that. But really, I'm very grateful for your work on that on the myths that have been out there. The work that you did in Humboldt on the sunken seaweed tour was also really cool in giving folks a I think once folks see the work that you do, first to enable to feel it and candidly taste it, right?

Literally? Yes. Yeah, totally. It changes minds. Indeed.

And I think that's just really important these days of going that extra mile. Your thoughts, doctor?

03:37:57 - 03:38:18

Speaker 17

I would actually reference in this moment a collaboration with the Ocean Protection Council to release later this year the inaugural Coastal and Ocean Report Card that will break through to, we hope, to public audiences in scoring and grading aspects of our Coastal and Ocean system that we all care about and want to know how they're doing.

03:38:18 - 03:38:26

Speaker 1

So go through that a little bit. Is it going be looking at water quality? Walk us through what's being measured.

03:38:26 - 03:38:49

Speaker 17

It's a set of indicators that collectively encompass the broad aspects of the ecological and social system that include things like beach water quality, fisheries, fishes, rocky intertidal habitats. So a range of habitats, drivers and stressors on the system, and human interactions with the system to be able to grade in this first ever report card.

03:38:49 - 03:38:58

Speaker 1

Interesting. That's incredible. On the insurance side, any other market like that in the world?

03:38:59 - 03:39:21

Speaker 17

There are some. There is none in California or even in The United States. There are some early models being developed in places like Indonesia, in The Caribbean. There's a parametric insurance product that has been operational for the last five years. We can learn from those and then look to how they adapt to West Coast.

03:39:21 - 03:39:27

Speaker 1

So it's covering what? So when you just mentioned that, said talk about the parameters.

03:39:27 - 03:39:48

Speaker 17

Yes. So, of course, insurance is not a new thing for the fishing industry. Traditional indemnification insurance applies to loss of physical assets, like boats and gear and life, as part of fishery operations. This is about bringing insurance to bear on addressing the disruptions to fishing that happen as a result of climate change.

03:39:48 - 03:39:51

Speaker 1

Crop insurance. I know a little different, but I'm over symbolizing.

03:39:51 - 03:40:38

Speaker 17

That is an analogous example, yes. So we can think about parametric insurance. And can you build an insurance product based on triggers in the environment that will pay out very quickly and provide that fast relief to fishing community members? Do we have enough data to connect a fishery to those triggers and design a product like that? We can think about risk pooling where there's a community product that can be paid into and again can pay out upon specific design criteria in the product.

These are all early days, but I think it is a thread worth pulling on that will require a multi sector dialogue.

03:40:38 - 03:41:00

Speaker 1

And what you mean by that is creating their own pool. Because we see that a lot. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. I guess the piece is just what the cost is going to be, right?

As far as I would be interested is, you know, what that cost is going to be versus what that return could look like

03:41:01 - 03:41:25

Speaker 17

Yes. For the So there's the cost to participate, whether that's part of a risk pool or individually. And then there's the cost to administer and who holds the risk transfer as part of administrating product. That's where we're interested in engaging the private sector in potentially, first, a working group to explore other models worth piloting and then potentially piloting.

03:41:25 - 03:41:28

Speaker 1

And the most successful is where and what does that model look like?

03:41:29 - 03:42:13

Speaker 17

The most well known is the parametric insurance product in The Caribbean that supports the hotel and industry primarily, not solely, primarily through payouts that happen if hurricane triggers, wind speed triggers met and damages are incurred to the hotel industry and the tourism sector. But the payouts, the benefit of a parametric insurance is the payouts can then go to restore coral reefs in that particular geography that are integral to the tourism industry and the hotel industry there. So it's sort of a win win for coral reef restoration as well as the local economy.

03:42:13 - 03:42:17

Speaker 1

Interesting. That's great. Thank you, please.

03:42:17 - 03:42:37

Speaker 3

Just following up on that, Mr. Chair, at the same time I can thank Pro Tem McGuire and Mr. Nielsen for helping so much work with my office on a bill that had to do with the similar challenge with fire insurance,

03:42:37 - 03:42:38

Speaker 13

with

03:42:38 - 03:48:50

Speaker 3

catastrophe loss, where you can kind of work with the private sector insurance companies all day long. But at the end of the day, that data that you're talking about is proprietary, it's theirs. And the bill that moved along that I was just referring to, I think actually Humboldt, if I remember right, was the if I remember wrong, Bill correctly. Humboldt was You're right. Was basically capable of setting up or kind of mimicking what the private sector insurance model would look like in catastrophe kinds of situation.

Climate is part of this a little different outcome from climate obviously than fire. But it it seems like getting something like that stood up to the extent state legislative helps you to do that, would make a lot of sense. In effect, before you even have the insurance, you know, we did this on fire, you know, sort of after the train had left the station, and we're now trying to figure out is the risk analysis of the private sector really is it accurate? Is it really we would come up with, you know, in an academic model or a model that you might be able to put together yourself with your own organization. It's just a thought to add on to the thoughts you already provided.

I think it's you would actually in some sense be getting on in front of the insurance industry for a change. And then you could see will insurers come in and actually do that indemnification and aligned with the same actuarial forecast that you've come up with. If they would then it should be financeable. I mean it should be a workable model. Somebody collects premiums and then it pays out accordingly.

I wanted to ask a question of so that was just a comment, another invitation. Mr. Morell, when you were talking about different fees that you could use, I appreciate that very much. I appreciate the fact that you focused in on some existing statute or models, the cannabis tax fund, timber tax. The problem with all those is every time we try to enter into that world legislatively appropriations.

Pro Tem certainly had his fill of that. By now, you you're dealing with a zero sum game. I mean, you go in there and say let's use some of this money for this much needed effort and somebody else isn't going to get some money in all likelihood. I would just encourage, because this all involves water, a much broader look at what can be done in terms of fees. I'm really talking about scale here.

It takes a very small fee, for example, per unit of water moved in this state to finance what you're trying to finance. The data you need there, you know, we may be getting closer to DWR actually putting out, which is what water is moving, where, when, federal project, you know, state project in terms of how we move agricultural water, potable water and so forth, how we move water out of the delta, there's not been a single place where you could go to to just, you know, track that data or certainly to put some kind of a fee on that. But I would encourage a I'm just saying I would encourage a broader look. Those are tough pieces of legislation to move through because of all the interests and I think frankly suspicion skepticism about what are you trying to do, are you going to hurt somebody, are going to hurt residential rate payers, are you going to hurt wholesalers, are you going to hurt agriculturalists. Really, I mean it just seems to me, obviously I don't have any data in front of me, but I think I know the magnitude of acre feet of water that's moving while we speak in this state.

And really pennies per acre foot would generate massive scale for you in terms of some of the challenges that were, not you personally, but all of you who have spoken today in terms of financing some of the challenges that we're looking at. So maybe some modeling around that could be done. And maybe all of you, because you're dealing with other agencies, know, you have that interface, could frankly make more progress, you know, with DWR and with the folks in the state that actually have that you would need cooperation from to work with that data just to do some modeling, just to do some projections, to use a protest word, a study bill that came back and said what would it look like to have a climateenvironmental fee on all water movement defined as follows in the state of California, I think could do, you know, a world of good. And I don't think that's ever been done, Mr. Proteyn.

Mean, I don't think that's certainly not been done in our state. Would love to be a part of any of that kind of work or any of that kind of study as a legislator myself or work with others like the chair, you know, in terms of trying to figure out if there's a there. Same with the insurance issue because I think there is a there there. I just think it would take obviously some tremendous political will to get it across the finish line in cooperation from the administration but it's worth looking at. Both those things are worth looking at.

That's my take. You.

03:48:50 - 03:49:42

Speaker 5

Yeah, appreciate that comment, and it's a great suggestion. We can look at that. You know, I think you're probably more aware than I am that new legislation new appropriations and new taxes are probably the most challenging things you guys could ever take on, and that's why my suggestion is we're trying to look at existing funding and routing some of that to the places where it seems logical to spend that money from either that timber tax or cannabis tax. And then also, the largest pot of money that's coming out of the legislation now is the proposition of the bond money. And so if we can find a way to justify using some of that bond money for these monitoring programs that feed back into where to spend this money wisely, You know, that's what we want.

We want to learn from the monitoring that we do to inform future investments of bond money. So it's well spent. We're getting from it what we intend to. So, that's our hope. Thank you for

03:49:42 - 03:49:42

Speaker 1

the comment.

03:49:42 - 03:49:46

Speaker 3

Appreciate it. Through the chair, I just want to thank you for bringing up the issue of

03:49:46 - 03:49:47

Speaker 1

finances

03:49:47 - 03:50:12

Speaker 3

and appropriation. A couple of the panelists have done that. It's actually refreshing because we don't always get that in informational hearings. We don't even get it sometimes in our budget subcommittee meetings. Know, there's a little bit of a, I think of, you know, people tend to be a little bit reserved about, you know, coming in and talking about what's really needed in terms of appropriations of finances.

I think we need to hear that, though. It's helpful. It makes it worth coming here to

03:50:12 - 03:50:27

Speaker 1

listen. Thank you. Thank you, Senator. Mr. Chair, quickly, if you don't mind, on top recommendations, top three recommendations you think we need to take in from the committee for 2026.

03:50:29 - 03:51:08

Speaker 5

Look at the letter that we sent you about the Pacific Whiting Emergency Permit and anything that we can do to make sure the public is aware of that and grassroots organizations are aware of that permit. You know, the estimated take of salmon from that whiting fleet operation is, like, on the order of 10,000 per year. That's more than was allocated for the recreational fishing this year. So we can't let that happen when when our fleets are not allowed to go catch fish. I think making sure this is a tough subject because, like I said, I represent we our committee represents commercial, recreational, and tribal interests,

03:51:09 - 03:52:11

Speaker 5

there are different perspectives across those entities. But making sure the fish are recovering before we allocate to an ocean harvest. And I know we want to see our industry get back to fishing, that's for sure, But we we need to make sure that those populations rebound in the ocean and come back to to subsequently spawn before we let fishing happen again. And I think the third is continue that investment in in priority locations that have outcomes that we we identify as as as vital to those inland waters. You know, water water being the the primary, you know, so I mentioned the the Shasta and Scott, and, you know, we we need to get those regulations in place that that permanently protect in stream flows so that we don't have breakdowns during droughts, so we don't have continued low productivity and survival of those fish that are coming out of those watersheds.

So those investments are really important, but we need to put them in priority places.

03:52:11 - 03:52:22

Speaker 1

Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Very grateful to this panel. Thank you for your time, your effort, your energy. We are really, really grateful for your hard work, and your dedication.

Thank you so much. Yeah. Thank you so much.

03:52:22 - 03:52:23

Speaker 5

Thank you for inviting us.

03:52:24 - 03:52:56

Speaker 1

All right, ladies and gentlemen. What we're going to do is we're going open it up for public comment. Any individual who would like to be able come speak with the committee, we welcome you. We really appreciate each and every one of you for hanging with us here throughout the afternoon. We're going to open up, if you don't mind, saying your first and last name.

Organization, you have two minutes. Any individual who would like to be able to come forward, come on down. We welcome you. Anyone who would like to be able to come forward at this time? Yeah, come on down.

It's good to see you. Thank you again for hanging with us. This Yes, please. Thank you so much.

03:52:56 - 03:52:58

Speaker 18

I'll just break the ice. Get it over with.

03:52:58 - 03:53:00

Speaker 1

Thank you. Appreciate you being here.

03:53:00 - 03:54:44

Speaker 18

Good afternoon, senator McGuire and mister Nielsen and senator Cortazi. My name is Melissa Mahoney. I'm the executive director of the Monterey Bay Fisheries Trust. And I think I was last at a fisheries forum maybe ten years ago or so when we used to have a barbecue and more of the social time. But I am just appreciating that you are holding the space for folks to come forward and talk about what's happening in our fishing communities and our waterfronts.

I'm not gonna repeat. I think what you all know is a really challenging time for our fishing community, and I did just wanna take a moment to thank you for something that happened actually back in early September. I you faced an urgent ask by governor Newsom to support the Delta Tunnel and CEQUA trailer bills. And myself and several others called your office to ask that you not support those. And I actually got a live person from your office, and we actually had a conversation.

And I believe that those bills did not get out of committee. And so I just wanted to thank you personally for having having such a great staff that they actually answer the phone that I've never had that happen. And just please keep saying no to that devastating kind of water water policy that going to hurt our salmon and hurt our fishing families more than they already are. As you know, salmon is part of that three legged stool with crab, with local ground fish, and where the state and communities are working really hard to get all that back. So just thank you for supporting us in the legislature.

03:54:44 - 03:54:51

Speaker 1

Thank you. I'm very, very grateful, and thank you for your leadership as well. We appreciate you being here. And thank you for hanging with us so long, truly.

03:54:51 - 03:54:54

Speaker 18

No problem. It's a nice room. It's a nice group.

03:54:54 - 03:54:56

Speaker 1

I see. There we go. It's good to see you. Thank you so much.

03:54:56 - 03:54:57

Speaker 13

Thanks a lot.

03:54:57 - 03:55:29

Speaker 1

Thank you. We'd to be able to see if anyone else would like to be able to come forward and speak. We welcome. I really appreciate the comments today. Anyone else would like to speak, you're more than welcome to come up with a microphone.

First, last, organization. We're going to do a last call. Alright. Let's bring it back to committee. I'm gonna turn it over to senator Cortese.

I wanna say thank you so much to senator Cortese for being with us this entire time. I am grateful for his partnership, his friendship, and candidly his leadership. I'm gonna turn it over to you, Senator Cortese. Know this is an important issue. Any closing remarks?

03:55:30 - 03:56:20

Speaker 3

Just a thank you. I think you said it all. I appreciate everyone being here. I appreciate the people who had stayed till the end. That's always a little extra challenge and informational hearing.

I appreciate being on this committee and it was really through your actions that I ended up on this committee. And I just learn a ton every time I come in and it really kind of whets my appetite for more and to make sure that with all the crises going on, with all the federal issues we're facing and all the short term issues we're facing politically and otherwise that we don't lose sight of these issues because they're as existential as any that are out there. So thank you again, and thank you for your leadership as Protem and as Chairman of this Committee.

03:56:20 - 03:59:04

Speaker 1

Thank you so much. Very, very grateful for you. Appreciate you. A few thank yous. First and foremost, want say thank you to our panelists.

If you are a fisherman, you have one of the toughest jobs. And I think one of the most challenging parts of being a fisherman is you know what it's like during good times, and we've been struggling over this past decade. Thank you for sticking with it, and you are a main driver in rural community economies, and we're grateful for your leadership. I want to say thank you to all of those who are involved in science who presented here today and for your work. And you're really sticking your neck out in a really difficult time in our country, And, your voice is needed, more than ever.

I want to say thank you so much to Chris Nielsen, who is consultant for this committee. Very grateful for his work, always, and this would not have gotten off the ground without Chris Nielsen. To LDC who and Senate TV who moved, and got us up and running here. We had a little bit of a blip. We could have floundered.

Yes. Okay. There's a fish pun. Thanks, Cortese. So, but we didn't, and we ended up, swimmingly.

There we okay. You so much, everybody. We're casting a wide net here for funds. You want to make more of Yeah, know. Sunshine's going to throw her shoe at the dice, I think.

So but look. For fifty years, this forum has, brought the community together, to talk about top tier fisheries, the challenges that we need to face. And what I also appreciate, during good times and bad, we're able to have open and honest conversations. And then many times coming out of this forum is action is taken to be able to help whether it is the fishing community in the fleet, if it helps recreational, or also the environment. And I think the bottom line is the truth coming out of today, salmon, dungeness crab, kelp all need our help.

And there is one existential threat, and that's the climate crisis. And it and that is why California needs to continue to chart our own future. Again, I wanna say thank you so much to senator Cortese and all of our colleagues, our Vice Chair, Ms. Pappin from the Assembly. Thank you so much for joining us here today.

We look forward to seeing you here very soon, and this meeting is formally adjourned. Thank you.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.