Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies, Monday, February 23, 2026
No chapters available yet
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies California State Assembly
Speaker 2
Alright. Assembly member Petrie Norris, do you have any opening remarks? Senator Blake's chair?
Speaker 4
I do. Thank you. Well, thank you. Thank you chair chairs, for hosting this today. As the chair of the senate environmental quality committee and a member of the senate's cap and trade working group last year, I'm interested to hear from today's panelists about how the legislation that we passed last last year will be implemented.
I appreciate that there are many conflicting considerations that CARB has had to reconcile in writing these proposed amendments because we faced many of these same challenges last year. I'm generally glad to see CARB prioritized affordability for everyday Californians where they could, although I do also wanna make sure that we're implementing the legislature's intent and California's goals. Cap and Invest is so intertwined with our state's economy and climate ambitions, so I really look forward to hearing today about the many considerations that went into developing these regulations.
Speaker 2
Thank you. Thank you, senator. And we do have assembly member Petrie Norris remembering she had something to say.
Speaker 5
So before we begin, I think it's just really important to center our conversation and, I think, remind all of us and all of the Californians who might be watching why we continue, to prioritize climate action in the state of California. We're not doing this because it's nice to have. We're not doing it because it's, you know, someone's pet project. We're doing this because this is a must have. Climate change is dangerous.
It's expensive, and the cost of inaction is enormous. We've seen climate disasters devastate communities all around the globe, and California has and continues to be on the front lines. So I I think in the world we're living in with the misinformation machine that we're all navigating against, I just think it's really important for us to stay focused and grounded and be honest about why we're having these conversations and why we continue to do this work. So thank you, to our chair and vice chair for your leadership, and I look forward to today's conversation.
Speaker 2
Alright. Thank you. Thank you, colleagues. Now I would like to welcome chair Sanchez of the California Air Resources Board and Rajinder Sahota, deputy executive director for climate change and research at CARB. Welcome.
Speaker 6
President's but what we didn't anticipate was the speed and scope of the destruction only made possible by a total disregard for the law and for facts. But this time around, the clean energy economy isn't just a plan or a goal that we're going at it alone. It's an unstoppable global transition that continues to main main maintain momentum fueled by the leadership of governments around the world, many of whom are now looking to California and our fellow states to carry the mantle of American climate leadership. Your success in extending the cap and invest program to 2045 and ongoing support for our climate and clean air programs shows the world that even as the federal government exits the global clean energy race, California is staying the course as a stable partner and a global innovator. I thank you and look forward to today's discussion.
Next slide, please. As was mentioned last month, CARB staff released proposed updates to the cap and invest program pursuant to legislative direction and are taking public comment through early March. The updates are designed to ensure that California stays on track to meet its climate targets for 2030 and 2045 while supporting affordability, cost effectiveness, and regulatory and market certainty for program participants. Next slide, please. Formerly known as cap and trade, the cap and invest program is a cost effective policy tool that makes polluters pay while reducing climate emissions over time.
It's one of many programs that the state is using to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It sets a declining limit on major sources of climate pollution covering the largest polluters, including factories, energy companies, and oil and gas suppliers. These account for 80% of California's climate emissions. The limit is an aggregate limit set for all sources. There are no facility specific caps.
The program creates a powerful economic incentive to use cleaner, more efficient technologies, and it is four to six times less costly than alternative approaches to addressing climate pollution, like direct regulation or a carbon tax. The cap and invest program has been operating successfully for thirteen years with nearly 100% compliance. Next slide, please. Cap and Invest has been working and has a track record of proven success. California met its 2020 climate target six years early while growing its economy.
Beyond reducing emissions, the program has already delivered $34,000,000,000 for climate investments across this state, funding over half a million projects like affordable housing and accessible transit, supporting 30,000 jobs and cutting millions of tons of carbon emissions. To date, over 70% of those investments have benefited disadvantaged and low income communities. The cap and invest program has also returned over $15,000,000,000 in bill credits directly to household utility customers. The draft changes are designed to support affordability, to strengthen cost effectiveness features, and to send a clear and steady price signal that encourages investment in cleaner energy and more efficient technologies across this economy. They also aim to support doing business here in California, provide market certainty to program participants, and protect against market manipulation.
Next slide, please. Next slide, please. Oh, one more. Thank you. These draft amendments nope.
One back. Perfect. Thank you. These draft amendments ensure long term allowance budgets beyond 2030, support achieving the state's 2045 carbon neutrality target. They make changes from a previous process to remove allowances from circulation when offsets have been used for compliance where allowances would now be removed on an ongoing basis.
They implement a new legislative requirement to transfer free allowances from natural gas utilities to electric utilities to address electricity affordability concerns and to further incentivize electrification. We are continuing the ongoing protection for ratepayers on utility bills by providing free allowances that cover all of the compliance costs that utilities have for this program. These amendments make requirement make updates to requirements related to reporting business relationships to further protect against market manipulation. They add post 2030 allowances to the allowance price containment reserve to continue and strengthen that mechanism, which avoids price spikes and helps keep costs low. And they maintain the number of allowances that are provided to the industry to incentivize manufacturing in California, protect jobs, and make sure that drivers won't pay additional pass through costs at the pump.
Next slide, please. As required by law, staff completed an economic analysis of this proposal and found that the overall benefits of the program outweigh the costs. The estimated total cost of compliance is $124,000,000,000 over a twenty year lifetime. This cost is negligible compared to California's current annual $4,000,000,000,000 a year economy, which is projected to grow to over $5,000,000,000,000 by 2046. In being responsive to legislative direction and considering affordability, it's important to note that this proposal is $20,000,000,000 less costly than the scenarios initially analyzed in April 2024.
The benefits outweigh the costs. The proposal delivers significant return on investment, including total statewide benefits of $180,000,000,000, including $123,000,000,000 in avoided health care costs resulting from improved local air quality and up to $485,000,000,000 in global savings due to avoided climate damages. The program is also projected to generate $56,000,000,000 to benefit utility ratepayers and $37,000,000,000 for additional climate investments. Next slide, please. As the chair mentioned, we are in the middle of a formal forty five day period for public for the public to provide comments.
Staff will present the proposal for consideration by the CARB board at a public hearing at the May. As we hear from the public affected industry and, importantly, our partners in the legislature, we have included time to make adjustments to the draft proposal prior to board consideration. I invite your offices as well to provide comment into our formal record. Importantly, we are working to have an effective date of 09/01/2026. A completed rulemaking is important to support regulatory and investment certainty in this program.
Next slide, please. In addition to the proposed updates presented today, the legislation passed last fall includes several other requirements. Assembly bill 12 o seven requires CARB to present to relative legislative committee subcommittees on rulemaking materials and expenditures of the program's auction proceeds to report annually on the use of the value provided to the utilities through allocated allowances, and to consider developing new offset protocols, including for carbon dioxide removal. Senate bill eight forty requires CARB to conduct a study on of the compliance offset program by December 2026, including a study of the contribution of offset projects towards California's climate goals and to ups update all offset protocols by January 2029 to reflect best available science and reevaluate protocols for every five years thereafter. For evaluating existing offset protocols and developing new protocols, CARB has requested additional resources to begin implementing those provisions.
In closing, I want to recognize the financial pressures Californians are facing and emphasize our commitment to striking a balance between the costs and benefits of all of our actions. This balance is a primary goal of the legislation that extended the program. In a desk addressing this critical issue, it is also important to consider how much we're already paying. Climate impacts once thought decades away are here now, and Californians are already paying the price. For example, a 2024 national report ranked California the worst state for natural disasters fueled by a changing climate with expected annual losses totaling more than $16,000,000,000 statewide.
The cost of inaction is too great, and our efforts will help to minimize costly future impacts while also delivering significant benefits to Californians through the reinvestment of auction proceeds and the annual utility bill credit. That wraps up my overview today. I'd like to invite deputy officer executive officer Rajinder Sahota to join me at the table, and I look forward to your questions.
Speaker 2
Oh, just to answer questions. Okay. Alright. Alright. Do we have questions?
Yes?
Speaker 2
I think it's easier to do when Karb is here to ask the questions of Karb now. So why don't we start with the co chair?
Speaker 1
Yeah. I'll I'll start off high level. And thank you, chair Sanchez, and deputy executive officer Sohota for being here. Your second to last slide on, next steps was encouraging. My first my first question is just about timing.
We know the world's watching. We know our markets are watching. We just had an auction last week. Everyone feels whether you're, living in an EJ community, on the front lines of of things or you're, you're a compliance entity that everyone wants some certainty out there. So my first question is just, you know, we know how rule makings can go.
Things do take time sometimes. I'm sure there's gonna be a a ton of comments that come in, a lot of competing interests, but, you know, there are significant problems with blowing through that May deadline, in my view. I think if we go past June and deeper into the year, not just for our market and for, for our compliance entities, but also other states and even other countries sort of watching what we're gonna do. So first question is pretty simple, which is do you do you feel like you're on track to hit that May 28 ish deadline? I mean, do you do you think you can get this done before June?
Speaker 6
Yeah. Thank you for that question, senator. As as you know, the Air Resources Board has a long track record of administering this program, including a number of amendments that have come to the board. So we are committed to making to meeting that May deadline. I'll note, you know, we are in public comment through March 9, but I, myself, and the executive team and our program staff have been meeting with stakeholders ever since the legislation was passed.
So I think we have a good understanding of perspectives coming to the board. And as I mentioned, we did allow time for changes to the staff proposal if needed. But as you know, it is incredibly important that we stick to that May time frame so that we have an effective date of September 1 for the market and regulatory certainty.
Speaker 1
I appreciate that's encouraging here. When I think about sort of some of the interlocking pieces that start to click in beyond that rule making could be incomplete, I think about things like our our carbon removal industry trying to get on track and the, the related role of SB nine zero five rule making, which I also hope you all keep, on the front burner, and stay on track with that. And we know that that that industry is sort of waiting to see how crediting could work here. So we're hoping that that continues to get fleshed out and stay on track. But also in terms of linkage, we know Washington's looking to us.
We know Quebec's looking. Oregon, we're gonna see how that system plays out. They're going a little different route than us at the moment, but I I'm I'm hopeful that they'll they'll consider in the future joining us. Do you feel that is is there still interest in pursuing those linkages with those jurisdictions? And and with that rulemaking timing, will that keep us on track to to be able to stay linked to our our two partners?
Speaker 6
Yeah. Thank you for that question. We are still working towards linkage with Washington, and completing this rulemaking on the May time frame is an important next step towards linkage, just as Washington has a current open rule making for their program as well. I'll note that any future linkage would be, would depend on the governor's findings under s b ten eighteen and that process concluding as well. But we know that there could be many benefits to our program from linking with Washington.
I'll also note that those conversations are done in close coordination with our current linkage partner, Quebec. To your earlier convert comment on SB nine zero five, we've looked at our priorities coming to the air board this year, and a lot of them start with an SB or an AB. There's been a lot of legislative direction our way, and we look forward to working closely with you all and stakeholders across this state to implement that legislative direction.
Speaker 1
Should have probably mentioned my own bill's implementation first as well as senator Weiner. Although we knew we do have a a hearing this week on s b two fifty three and two sixty one, so I didn't didn't need to plug that. I'll defer, to the rest of the committee. I have further some further questions, but I believe
Speaker 5
Okay. So couple of areas that I wanna dig into, and I'll start with a couple of follow-up questions related to the, role of carbon capture and sequestration. So, I think you mentioned that you're hoping that the regs are on track. I think that SB90Fig nine 05 regs were due last year. Is that correct?
And they have not been promulgated, to my knowledge. And I I wanna so I wanna make sure that we don't miss an opportunity, for the necessary investments that we need companies to make in order to implement these, you know, CCUS technologies across the state. It's an area I've worked in, you know, the senator has worked in. I think it's foundation I don't just think. I think it's in your own report.
It's foundationally important to California's ability to achieve our climate goals. Right now, if I understand correctly, the draft regulations are somewhat vague and kind of have a sort of placeholder language. So, is there an opportunity for us to refine those regulations to acknowledge that CCUS is indeed going to be a viable compliance pathway at this stage?
Speaker 6
Yeah. Thank you for that question, assembly member, and we completely agree with you. Carbon capture and carbon removal are we know we're going to play, an incredibly important role in meeting California's climate goals, including carbon neutrality by 2045. You're right that our 2022 scoping plan says that as does global science from the IPCC and others. We are delayed in part because of, some delayed resources coming to the AIR board.
But now that we are adequately staffed up, we're confident that we can bring that regulation to the board later this year. I'll ask deputy executive officer on your specific question regarding the cap and invest, proposed amendments and how those relate to our activities under SB nine zero five later this year.
Speaker 8
Thank you, chair. And to, further expand on the chair's response here, there's two pieces of regulatory action that we're undertaking. One is the broader SB nine zero five regulation that is due that we are planning to bring to the board by the end of this year for consideration. But in the cap and invest proposal that is out for public comment right now, we have placeholder language in there in recognizing the role of CCUS and CDR. And I think the question that you're really asking, and you can correct me if I'm wrong, is can we further refine the language in the cap and invest proposal?
We can, and we are continuing to meet with stakeholders to invite what additional language or additional parameters they need in this regulation to keep those investments flowing to those technologies.
Speaker 5
Alright. So we're working on that. And and I guess maybe what I've what I'm unclear on is is the delay on rigs from 09/2005 going to adversely impact the ability of us to fully harness these technologies as part of our our cap and trade. Mhmm. Or, sorry, cap and invest.
Speaker 8
I think that's a really great question. And I'm really happy to say that on our website for SB nine zero five, we just posted, I think, several months ago, a list of projects moving forward. And so we have about 44 projects moving forward in California that are in various forms of planning, investment, or even doing some of the technical qualifications around those, and over half of those are related to the energy sector. And what we're continuing to do is meet directly with some of those project proponents to make sure that as they're laying out the planning documents, as they're structuring those projects, that there is nothing that would prohibit them from being able to be recognized under the language in SB nine zero five and then in the future programs for cap and invest.
Speaker 5
Okay. So you alright. So do you agree then that CCUS should be, you know, should fully count towards compliance obligations?
Speaker 8
Absolutely. That's been a long standing decision Okay. That it should reduce your emissions compliance obligation.
Speaker 5
Okay. So then we just need to make sure that the letter of what's actually in the regs reflects the spirit that I think we share. Alright. I have a couple of other questions related to electricity affordability, but I think that might be something you wanted to ask. So I can ask follow ups for after if you want.
And then I have some
Speaker 2
other Yeah. And and, the the co chair has some other, questions too. So I I think the, feedback that I've heard the most about is the the changes to allowances for the electric utilities. And so could you walk us through it? Obviously, affordability is a huge priority.
It was, like, the the lens through which we did everything last year, and it seems that this is moving in the opposite direction. It almost seems that if utilities were green faster, that's in in some ways their customers are going to be punished. And so could you tell us a little bit about that and why and how perhaps you see that it doesn't affect affordability?
Speaker 6
Yeah. Happy to, Cher. Thank you for that question and for your efforts on this issue as part of the, legislative efforts to extend the program last year. I, completely agree with you that energy affordability remains a top priority here at the air board, but in, importantly through these proposed amendments. I'll ask deputy executive officer Sohoda to walk through the, specifics around utility allocation, but I would point out that we are the staff is proposing allocating free allowances to cover all of the compliance costs for the program.
That that is to say, ratepayers should not see an impact from these proposed amendments. Also, the legislature gave us the explicit direction to transfer natural gas allowances over to electress electric utilities to further enable affordable electrification. So there are two components of your question. I'll ask, deputy executive officer to walk Suhota to walk through the detail.
Speaker 8
Thank you, chair. And that is probably one of the questions that we are getting a lot of incoming on, especially from utilities and stakeholders that are, environmental organizations or just general members of the public. So when it comes to the allocation to the electric utilities, what we do is we take their submitted data to other energy agencies like the CEC or CPUC. They're planning for how they're going to get closer and closer to the RPS of 60% by the end of this decade or even exceed it because we know some of them are exceeding that and then the targets for 2035. So based on their reported data, that gets fed back into the same methodology that we've always used to allocate to the utilities.
So over time, as they get greener, they have less carbon in their portfolio, and they need less allowances for compliance. But we understand that, as you stated, so eloquently, are we punishing utilities for doing more and doing it faster? That is not the goal here. That is not what we want to do here. And so we have been inviting the utilities to provide additional data and additional information that we could use to potentially adjust what we're providing them for their allocation.
So we welcome that information and data during the formal public comment period from the utilities themselves and, of course, yourselves in terms of, you know, are we striking the right balance here? Do we need to consider something else?
Speaker 2
Yeah. And and I I guess the part of the concern is, they were there was planning based on what they assumed the allowances were going to be going out into the future. If they are greener faster, it might have been that they just invested future allowances early, and so that would have an impact on their ratepayers. So we will certainly comment on, that later. Do you have anything specific to that issue?
Speaker 5
Yeah. I think just, a a little bit of a follow-up. And I think, again, just I think sort of the reason that this matters is that electricity affordability is, I mean, almost like the backbone of our ability to achieve our climate ambitions. Like, if we don't keep electricity affordable, we are never gonna be able to effectively drive this transition. So I think that's why it's been such, a huge area of focus.
So I think if there's one thing that cap and invest should should protect, it's electricity rates. And what I'm what I am confused about is that I think you said that there wasn't going to be a rate payer impact as a result of the draft regs, and that is absolutely not what we're hearing from both IOUs and even more so from, our publicly owned utilities. So, I mean, they've been raising an alarm and saying that this will lead to increased cost rate payers. So I guess, how are you or how can you rethink the draft regs so that it better protects rate payers from these increased costs when it comes to this aspect?
Speaker 8
Okay. So there's two things there. One is we are continuing to give them all the allowances they need to make sure any cost impact of this program does not flow through to ratepayers. So we're protecting ratepayers from any cost of compliance for this program. Are there other reasons that rates may increase?
There may be other reasons like hardening of the grid, other things that need to be brought online in terms of renewables, transmission, etcetera. I think as we're talking through some of these pieces with the utilities, it will be important to hear from them what other, early action they've taken, how can we support giving them more allowances for that early action that they plan to take where they felt like they had made early investments, what's the data for that. And if they're asking for more allowances beyond them protecting for the cost of this program, it will be important to have comments as to how any additional allowances will further protect rate payers in the record. We're open to all of that data and that dialogue. I think we're struggling to get to the point where we actually get things into the record that explicitly say, if you give us this many more allowances based on this data or information, this is how it will further protect rate payers in the state of California.
Speaker 5
So are you saying that, you know, when these so these stakeholders are saying that their allowances have been reduced to the tunes of billions and billions of dollars. Are you saying that they were, I guess, confused about what the starting point was?
Speaker 8
I'm not sure if they're confused because the methodology has always been about giving them enough allowances to cover the costs of this program. I think every time we update the regulation, we get a chance to look at new data and new information. I think this disconnect that we're having in the conversation with the utilities is when we went to update their allocation, we have new data that's been submitted to CEC and CPUC. And based on that new data, it shows that they are greener than we anticipated in the past. And so what we try what we need to do is try and bridge the new data that's been submitted since the last time we updated this regulation and how do we smooth that path from what they thought they were getting under old data to what they're gonna be get receiving under the new data.
So we're asking for more information to understand what investments were made and what ratepayer protections can be in place if we smooth that path into the the proposal that we have right now, which we are fully open to amending because we have built time in for it. But I think we're just struggling with we have to use the latest and best data that we have. If they've made existing and early investments, how do we bridge that path between the two in terms of costs?
Speaker 2
I I just wanna say, like, the way I see it is you had sort of the original, interpretation of the climate credit to be for compliance of to to to help with compliance. For us, though, in the assembly, at least last year, we were just talking about keeping electric rates lower or or driving electric rates down. And so I think we had we sort of changed the interpretation of the climate credit to to to make sure that we weren't not just be with compliance, but in general, electric rates are too high to really push toward an electric future. And so to really make our climate goals, we need to make sure that people it's worthwhile for people, for instance, to purchase heat pumps and and to move to electric cars electric vehicles. All that is being stopped with the cost of electricity being so high.
So I think it's a different interpretation than kind of the originalist idea is the way that I would put it. Do we have
Speaker 2
Oh, okay. Before we, yeah, before we before we switch to refining, then I I just wanna talk about the the other thing. For us, it was very important to switch the natural gas credit over to the electric bill, again, for the reason that it's gonna help electrification going forward. When I look at CARB's proposal, it waits till the late twenty thirties, and we've all talked about, how urgent, the the problem of climate change, how urgent it is to reduce emissions. Natural gas is a fossil fuel.
And if we are talking about another fourteen, fifteen years, I think we're really missing the urgency of the problem. So could you talk a little bit about why it is going to take that long and what the legislature can do to urge you to move more quickly to moving those those gas credits over? Again, we need p we need to drive down electric prices.
Speaker 6
very important component of the legislative discussion in extending the program last year. Staff had an early workshop after the bill was signed into law to to ask for feedback on how we might set up a framework to transfer those natural gas allowances over to electric utilities. And what we heard from a number of the stakeholders with the was that it would be incredibly complicated based on the territories and the POUs not actually giving a climate credit yet. So the staff proposal puts forward both a framework that we are soliciting feedback on and a draft timeline. We understand, from from conversations with you and from other stakeholders that they would like both changes to the framework and also an accelerated timeline.
We look forward to additional feedback and engagement on that piece.
Speaker 2
Alright. Thank you for that. Do we have any other questions on the natural gas credit or no. Okay. So why don't we switch switch over?
Speaker 1
I well, I'll just echo your point, though. I think we can go faster. I then we should be. I and I and that was one of the most meaningful contributions I thought the assembly made last year was bringing that transition framework into place, especially if we wanna accelerate decarbonization. So I'd second second the chair's point there.
I wanna build on a line of questioning we went through in our chair of environmental qualities hearing last week on refining. And, we heard from, vice chair of the CEC, Sivagunda, about, sort of evolving nature of of our refining landscape and what will probably be an increasing trends an increasing trend towards the importation not of of crude to be refined here, in fact, just imported gasoline. We talked to mister Botil, who's part of your Yarol's team at at CARB, and he did clarify for us that imports of gasoline are not some somehow exempt from our our carbon regulations. That just like a barrel of oil that's drilled in Kern County and refined, say, in Los Angeles, likewise, a a barrel of a barrel equivalent, I guess, of gasoline that came from who knows where would also be subject to to our carbon rules. The who knows where question is the hard part for me.
The world and especially some of these trickier jurisdictions, tend to be a black box. We just saw last week announced that Russian oil had found a way to hide itself. $92,000,000,000 worth of Russian oil found a way to hide itself, basically through India's refining sector and Azerbaijani assets where essentially now, whenever that stuff comes into our port, we're burning Russian, gasoline, while we're at war with the Petro dictator. Similarly, you could foresee scenarios, especially given Chevron's outsized capacity in our state, their assets in Ecuador, right in the heart of the rainforest, or even, say, Venezuela continues on the path. It's on that suddenly now, California drivers are, you know, propping up, or destroying the rainforest or propping up Putin.
And so the issue I've got, and I've heard it from my Republican colleagues as well, so I actually think there's some bipartisan consensus about this, is how to ensure that we have the right data at that at that point of importation. You know, the those who you know, when we're dealing with the Europeans, they do a great job of carbon inventory, and we know what comes in from over there. We we tend to trust that information. But from some of these other ships, we don't always know. And so are there tools or new techniques that we can use to better come up with what is now based on approximation exercise?
The way I understand it is I think the the way the OPG model works within the low carbon fuel center at least is we give a broad average. So we say if the, you know, the oil is coming from, you know, if it's Saudi, and we sort of assume certain things about how they flare or how the refining sector works, and we sort of take a rough estimate. But are there is there better data than that we can start to get out of the system so that we don't, sort of put an unfair disadvantage on our in state refining or in state oil and somehow make it a lot better to just bring in wholesale gasoline to our ports and sort of end around our carbon math. Is there are there can you can you speak to that in terms of new tools, better data, and maybe just clarify the the point that that our cap and invest regs apply equally to both imported gasoline as well as in state refined crude. Is that okay?
Speaker 6
Yeah. Yes. Thank you, for those comments, senator. Several things. First off, as you know, the cap and invest program has several design features to protect California businesses and to keep in state refining, here so that we can maintain a reliable and affordable supply of transportation fuels.
Happy to go deeper into that, in subsequent discussion. But on the issue of reporting and data, it is true that mister Botel at the committee last week shared our accounting gives us a life cycle analysis of the emissions for in state gasoline, but we would always welcome, more refined tools for that data and analysis. One regulation that you mentioned earlier, s b two fifty three, for example, may give us better insights into out of state refining operations and, you know, arm the airborne with additional data and tools moving forward.
Speaker 1
I would certainly encourage you, I believe the statute already make gives you the opportunity to the discretion at CARB to take some of that data into account if you're doing that sort of metadata analysis. In other words, of what the filings are, I think we've already had a 160 or so companies filed under two fifty three even before the regs are complete. Folks want to want to comply, it seems like. So, you know, anything that that is needed to get a more granular and accurate picture of the carbon intensity of these fuels that are potentially gonna come into our ports at much higher regularity in the coming years, I think, would be welcome. Know, the thing I worry about right now is that the those who wanna sort of play the gasoline import game are gonna wait on us and and not.
There's a Bushnell, study put out, I think, last week, week before, that if they play the waiting game on us, in other words, don't, get proactive and buy carbon allowances or don't participate in the auction and just sort of hope they can stall on us and then make it hurt really, really bad unless we gave all these foreign oil companies free allowances forever. Like, I I I just I wanna get ahead of that, and I think sending the clear signal here today that the rules apply equally to everybody is is certainly helpful. But I would certainly encourage you yet to just to use that two fifty three data and also, you know, any other tools that you feel like are gonna help. It's not so much that I'm hoping you all give a sweetheart deal to our in state refiners because I actually think we need to keep aggressive, and I think we need to maintain ambition. To be quite frank, you know, it's hard for me to to look at dropping it down to a 40% ambition by 2030 and be okay with that.
I was the one who wanted 55%. So I I don't mean to send you the signal that we're looking for you to go slow, especially in the near term. It's just to go in a manner that's fair and then doesn't sort of burden that inner in state commerce or or result in this kind of leakage. So I'm hoping we can we can start to work on that. I I will have questions at the in the next panel and for the for the commenters.
Those of you out from industry gonna testify a little later, I think the the corollary to this is if there is a deal to be had on on in this sort of refining and gasoline imports puzzle from a regulatory perspective, industry itself is gonna have to find a way to make real commitments as well. I think that's gonna be the nature ultimately of a stabilized mid transition plan is not just that they want more out of carb. We've seen the letters from the building trades. We've seen industry complaining about, how the in state refining sector is being treated. If they are willing though to commit and not in a, you know, press release commitment, but in a contractually enforceable way to actually operate in this state in in the midterm and say, take that ten year horizon and actually commit that to us, that's a very different conversation than we demand the air board, give us, you know, all the allowance we could ever want, but we still we still withhold the right to bail on you whenever our private equity or our our our shareholders say take off.
Because that's not gonna be a durable deal. So to to just the the broader public watching, I I I want them to understand that, you know, this this isn't has gotta be a two way Street here if we're gonna figure out a way to solve this, and it's very difficult. But the one encouraging note I would say is that the US Congress just passed themselves the Pruvit Act. So for the first time ever, the US Congress led by Republican senators said that, we also wanna know what the carbon intensity of imported oil is. So we may actually have some alignment there.
And, you know, rarely do we align with Washington these days, but, you know, I hope I hope that that if our regs start to align with what the Pruvit Act's gonna do, that we find some path to a more transparent process, especially for those who wanna import oil into the state. I had one more question about mobile sources, but I can I can turn it back to you if you had a comment on that? Okay.
Speaker 5
So, again, just to sort of frame this part of of the conversation, I think there's sort of two things that I'll start with. So one, we all recognize that we are in a transition. We are working real, real hard to build a fossil free and a clean energy economy. But spoiler alert, we are not there in 2026, and we are not going to be there for many, many decades. And California is going to continue to consume large amounts of oil and gas even under our most ambitious scenarios.
So I guess you know? And second, you know, I think we recognized the end of last year, you know, the importance of keeping in state refining capacity. The legislature, the administration worked really hard, to advance a proposal to stabilize, refine in state refining for all of those reasons. So we've heard, and I'm sure you've heard from industry since these draft prop this draft proposal was released that, this will drive them all out of the state. Is have you heard that?
Do you believe that? And do you think that would be like, leaving aside what that means for California's economy, what that means for California's labor force, all the bad things that would mean. Do you think that's a good thing for the climate?
Speaker 6
Thank you for that question, assembly member. And in addition to feedback that we've been getting on the utility allocation, this is a primary area of feedback that we've been hearing from stakeholders. We continue to meet with regulated entities on the proposal and how it might affect business operations here in California, and we look forward to those continued conversations. I personally have met with a number of our refiners. We come I want to acknowledge and commend the legislature for the efforts in passing s b two thirty seven last year to stabilize in state petroleum refining.
And importantly, extending the cap and invest pro proposal, a b 12 o seven continues the statutory direction on minimizing leakage. So it's important to note that the staff proposal maintains a status quo both in terms of industrial allocation for refiners and also in terms of pegging them at high risk for leakage. That said, we have heard that there may be additional considerations for why the regulated entities need more support, we look forward to continuing those conversations with them.
Speaker 5
Can you help us understand the process that you go through to first evaluate that leakage risk, whether for refiners or other industries? And then how do you quantify that, you know, and translate that into allowances and other mechanisms that will adjust for that leak leakage risk?
Speaker 6
Yes. Happily. For that detailed question, I will turn to deputy executive officer Sohoda. Thank you. Thank
Speaker 8
you, assembly member. So when we initially did the regulation, we had three categories of leakage, high, medium, and low. And that was based on industry surveys in California and looking at market share and market presence nationally and internationally for these industries. And so we went through a robust process that we documented in our rulemaking package back then on which sectors of the economy fit into those three categories. What we did last October was preview some of the technical work that we're going to be sharing, in the coming months that we went back and looked at the leakage risk again, looking at trends in the sectors, looking at market share, looking at impacts of broader economic policy, certainly some of the whiplash that we've been seeing at the federal level more recently, and recognizing that some of that whiplash may continue that what we expect industry to see as a steady pattern or steady market share may not be there, we decided to keep all industry at high risk for leakage, which is what a b three ninety eight had directed CARB to do for 2021 through 2030.
So we are continuing status quo through the end of this decade, recognizing that we still have a few more years under some unpredictable decision making that may happen and recognizing that long term planning for these companies is not over a year or two years, but it can be over five to seven years. And so the way that we do that is to make sure we don't reduce their allocation more than what they expected under the existing regulation so that any plans that they've had for how to comply, how to invest, and how to become more efficient over this decade, those plans are not disrupted, and the compliance doesn't become more expensive for them. The issue becomes when things are more expensive, then it's harder for them to compete with other market, share that may be taken up by companies outside of California or companies outside of The US. And so there's a technical appendix, and we would welcome the opportunity to do a technical session if you so choose with any of the members here, but there's there's a methodology by which we look at all the data that we can for each of these sectors before establishing this.
But, again, in the abundance of caution, we did set everyone at high risk for leakage through the end of this decade to minimize disruption for them for their financial planning. And so you you
Speaker 8
That's right. So when you think about the allowances an industry gets, one is what risk are they at leakage, and then how does that how do their allowances change with a declining cap? So you can imagine that the cap the overall program declines at about 4% average each year because we're dropping 40% over this decade. And so we kept them at that average 4% cap decline. So if you look at the existing regulation and the proposal through 2030, the numbers aren't changed.
What they thought they were going to get last year for the rest of this decade is what staff is proposing that they continue to receive through 2030.
Speaker 5
And I guess it just it feels to me like I mean, we've had, what, two refineries announce closure just in the past year. It feels like things are getting worse to me. It feels like the leakage risk is getting worse and that keeping them at that same level doesn't reflect the realities of where we are.
Speaker 8
So we have heard the same the same input from some of the refiners in state, and we have invited them to help us better understand and quantify what that leakage risk change is now for them and be able to adjust as necessary. And I think part of this is really what is that additional leakage risk that has occurred? How does any recent legislation like February help or, stabilize? And what other factors that are we doing that help, like, transition some of these assets? You've seen some of the refineries turn to producing renewable fuels, especially if they produce sustainable aviation fuel.
They're also gonna produce gasoline to meet ongoing demand. And so we're continuing those conversations to better, to better understand and to actually have some quantified information about how how has leakage risk changed for them in particular, how many more allowances do they believe they need, and how does that help on actually stabilizing that sector? You know, getting back to senator Stern's point, we wanna make sure that if we're going to give more allowances to the refining sector, they're going to actually be available to meet consumer demand and provide that reliable, affordable, you know, energy that we are going to consume.
Speaker 5
We wanna make sure it's based in data. Got it. And okay. So senator Stern at at one point said that the rules apply equally to everyone. But that is that true?
I mean, cap and invest doesn't apply equally to everyone. We can't apply that to foreign producers or foreign refiners. Correct?
Speaker 8
So the point of regulation for transportation fuel, there's two points. One is the facilities in state where we give allowances to minimize for leakage for those assets in state. And then when the fuel hits the rack where it's subject to all sorts of other fees and assessments, all of that fuel, whether it's imported or whether it's produced in California, is treated the same. When it enters the economy, that fuel is treated the same.
Speaker 5
But but not I mean, you don't they're they don't contribute to our cap and invest program.
Speaker 8
They they do because importers and in state suppliers of gasoline on on road fuel, they have a compliance obligation just like producers of in state fuel does does. And what they have to do to comply is they have to purchase allowances, and those allowances are what, we sell at quarterly auctions.
Speaker 5
And so that is at the same level as our in state? That is correct. Alright. You learned something new
Speaker 5
So yeah. I think I'll just and picking up, you know, perhaps on another threat of senator Sarin, I'm very concerned about a strategy that doubles down on imports. I feel like that is incredibly risky. I think it's bad for energy secure it's bad for energy security. It's bad for jobs.
It's bad for our economy. And I also think that's got to be bad for the planet and for our environment. So I guess I'd love somebody to show me the math that that shows that imports are actually going to be a better climate strategy than figuring out a way to support in state refining capacity. Again, as we're in the midst of this transition, we know transitions are bumpy, and I think we gotta be really mindful that we make it as as smooth as we possibly can, acknowledging the challenge of what we're all trying to navigate.
Speaker 2
So can we talk a little bit about the cap adjustment factor? And that's for the hard to decarbonize sectors. Right now, it's only cement that's in there because of the chemistry. Are there other sectors that qualify for that?
Speaker 8
The alternative cap adjustment factor, which is for sectors where their emissions are less than 50% combustion. So let's take cement as an example. Because it is a defined process, that product has to meet a certain chemical requirement for strength, tensile, heat, tolerance, all of those factors. Cement, glass, and a few of the other sectors that are more than 50% for, process emissions, they all get the alternative cap adjustment factor. And so if any sector meets that threshold, they automatically fall into that category.
We don't hold anyone back from that category of the alternative cap adjustment factor. The other thing that we recognize for some of these sectors is that it may be hard to come up with new chemical processes for that end product that they're producing because that chemical characteristic has to be you know, meet a certain strength or heat capacity or tolerance for for cold temperatures. And so we also included the manufacturing decarbonization incentive, mechanism into this program because many of these industries were going to rely on federal incentives, federal funds to help them decarbonize. Those have now just disappeared, and it's unclear, you know, if they will appear anytime soon. And so we are looking for a way to make sure that their plans for continuing to decarbonize, at least on the combustion side, can move forward, by having them invest in projects, invest in production in state that continues to reduce their emissions.
Speaker 2
And so I've I've heard some requests to have oil put in this carbon adjustment cap adjustment factor. It doesn't you're saying it doesn't qualify. And what would the but if it did, what would the cost be to the climate credit and GGRF over over the years?
Speaker 8
Proposal or the formal request. We've heard that the sector the refining sector wants more allowances. I'm sure that given the chance, everyone would like full compliance covered in perpetuity. But when you have a declining cap, you have a certain amount of allowances each year. And if we're going to give more to one sector, it means we're taking from somewhere else.
And so as part of taking that data and comments that are due by March 9, we're gonna take that and run a few scenarios to better understand what the implications are, whether it's to the climate credit or to GGRF or whether it's to the refining sector. Right now, when you look at the staff proposal, the sector that is growing in their share of the pie is the industrial sector. And the climate credit is getting smaller, and then what's going to GGRF is getting smaller. So we will continue that analysis. We will wait to see what what full, ideas and data that we get from the sectors themselves.
For refining in particular, it's really important for us to understand what their new leakage risk is based on any new data they themselves can provide us to understand what that may mean for what more they need to keep those assets in state.
Speaker 2
Alright. So I've I guess, just to summarize, so everybody status quo, everybody has a 100%, leakage risk. The cap cap adjustment factor is just as it was before, but there were credits taken out of the the the electric sector. And, and but you're open to looking at making sure that, we're using the the these credits in a way to help affordability. Would that be kind of the alright.
Speaker 1
One last follow-up on this point. So this cap adjustment factor is one way to to address the, sort of things that aren't dealt with, say, in the the leakage risk. I I I tend to agree with you all that, you it gets tricky when you're you're adjusting different folks caps at different rates and there's a parity issue and I mean, I should a glass manufacturer be it, you know, some different be adjusted differently than, say, oil or whomever. You know? It shouldn't just be rewarded based on the the power of the industry.
It should be based on data, like you said. But to to, chair Petrie Norris's point, I mean, can you get can you just help us get in the weeds for one more quick second about why the the gasoline imports are treated the same? The the question I get is, you know, if you're a stationary source in India, you don't have there there is no allowance allocation to you. Right? You're you're not, you're not subject to the cap and trade program.
So how does that assessment work at the rack and how are how, yeah, with those kind of blind spots out there or those lack of external regulations beyond our borders, how how is it a level playing field? Do you mind going a little deeper?
Speaker 8
Sure. So when you when you look at the rack, that is where all fuel, finished fuel, enters into the economy. That is where we have a good understanding of fuel that's being put into the economy from whether it's internationally provided fuel that's coming in by rail or ship or whatever or whether it's fuel produced in state and put on the rack. At that point on the rack, all of that has to be reported to us under our mandatory reporting regulation. And every one of those parties is identified as to who owns that fuel when it comes into the rack.
So then we calculate the volume of that fuel, the carbon associated with that fuel, and that is assessed a compliance obligation.
Speaker 1
But the but the carbon intensity of that fuel being just gasoline, but not the life cycle carbon intensity.
Speaker 8
That's that's a that's a very good distinction because in the cap and invest program, it is not based on life cycle. It is based on actual tailpipe and smokestack emissions in the state of California.
Speaker 1
So in theory right now then, all that carbon embedded in the gasoline that, say, has traveled here from India or from, you know, refinery in Venezuela, those those emissions aren't currently accounted for at the rack.
Speaker 8
Not in the cap and invest program, but they are picked up in the low carbon fuel standard.
Speaker 1
Yes. So give us that piece then. Do I know I threw out OpGee earlier and that modeling that we use to assess carbon intensities beyond our borders that has been incidentally upheld in federal court a number of times and, you know, foreign importers didn't wanna be subject to it be because it's sort of done across the board and in in our state's police powers, we weren't, you know, overturned on extraterritoriality or commerce clause grounds. But can that LCFS backstop be enough to sort of level that playing field? Is OpG accurate enough to ensure that the those emissions sort of aren't escaping our system?
Speaker 8
So there is a built in incentive in the low carbon fuel standard to give as detailed and disaggregated data as possible. Because if you believe you are more efficient than the benchmark, you will do that, and you'll go to all the trouble to give us that data. And we see this because it helps to create more credits for that fuel that's brought into the economy. For fuel, where if somebody isn't doing that detailed assessment and providing that detailed data, you're absolutely correct. We have the OptG model, which gives us estimates and average, and that is where we are continuing to do work to improve our understanding of the intensity of the fuel where it's produced, the energy used to produce it, and also the distance and how it's being brought into the state of California to be used in California.
And as chair Sanchez mentioned, SB two fifty three gives us another opportunity to try and get that detailed information where where people may not be choosing to provide it, but they are choosing to use the average values.
Speaker 1
But if, let's say, it doesn't come through two fifty three and for whatever reason, we don't get that data, does the Opti model need to be updated, and does do the LCFS regs need to feed that data, in other words, back into the cap and trade system? Or it doesn't really work that way. It's not as if you would assign a different carbon intensity at the rack under cap and trade just because you had a higher or lower carbon intensity fuel. Right?
Speaker 8
That's correct. And I think it's because of the way that the cap and invest program is designed, which is your actual emissions from your smokestack or your taro pipe, and it aligns with how we do our inventory Yeah. It would be hard to try and put into the cap and invest a life cycle kind of assessment because it's hard to set a cap when you're thinking about emissions that are going back, you know, thousands of miles around the globe. How do you even set a cap, that kind of data? So it makes it very challenging to do a cap and trade program that way and mix that those two different accounting frameworks.
For LCFS and the OpGee model, you know, we are continuing to have conversations and look at research to update those models as much as we can because we do believe that we should be incentivizing the least carbon intensive fuel to be coming to California. And so that is work that continues at CARB.
Speaker 1
And and timing wise on that, I mean, we know you finished your LCFS regs last year. It's not as if there's an open rule making on that front. But is there still an opportunity to update OPC even without reopening the LCFS?
Speaker 8
So the technical work on what OPC needs to represent can continue to happen right now. And once we have a sense of whether or not the changes warrant at LCFS to reference an updated op g, we could have definitely initiate that rulemaking, but the technical work continues. And you you very eloquently talked about how complicated it is to understand where fuel is coming in, who's backfilling it, and what's flowing to California. Those global markets are very difficult to try and track and to then quantify. And so we are continuing to figure out, you know, who is best situated, which researchers are best situated to try and do some of this work to help us, you know, come to come to a place where we feel like we're ready to do an update to OpGe.
Speaker 2
Alright. Well, I would like to thank both of you, and we might be calling you up for more questions. But, right now, I'd like to just bring up the next panel. Thank you. Our pan, I would like to welcome our panelists to the podium for an in-depth discussion of the cap and cap and trade investment program and CARB's proposed amendments.
We have, Helen Kirsten, who is the principal fiscal and policy analyst with the LAO. We have Meredith Foley, the faculty director of the Energy Institute at Haas, at UC Berkeley and the chair of the Independent Emissions, Market Advisory Committee. And we have Caitlin Rodner Sutter, California state director for the Environmental Defense Fund and also a member of the IEMAC. And finally, we have Natalie Seitzman, government affairs manager for the Southern California Public Power Authority, also known as SCAPA. Thank you.
Why don't we let's see how we're starting. So we will start with Helen, please.
Speaker 11
Helen Kirstein with the legislative analyst office. Good evening, chairs and members. Thank you so much for inviting me to speak today. I'm gonna be speaking from a handout. Hopefully, you have copies.
I have extras here. I'm not sure if there's a surgeon who's available to to help pass them out, but I do have plenty of extras for anyone in the room or for any members. I'm gonna try to move quickly because I know that the hour is late, and you all are extremely familiar with the recent legislation that was passed having authored, some of it yourselves. So, really appreciate your, you bearing with me, and I'll try to move quickly. So if we turn to page one of the handout, just going I'm gonna go over what I'm gonna talk about very quickly, summarize some of the high points in terms of the two pieces of legislation, a b 12 o seven and s b eight forty.
And then after I talk about some of those key features of those pieces of legislation, which basically changed some of the design features and allowance allocations, also added some reporting evaluation and oversight requirements, and changed the distribution of, greenhouse gas reduction fund revenues. Then I'll close with some implications of those two pieces of legislation and try to tie it to some of the the things you've heard in terms of the upcoming or the in progress regulations, I should say. So if you turn to page two, I'm not gonna go over this. This is a very busy table, and partly because there were a number of changes to the design features and allowance allocations that were made through these pieces of legislation, but this is here for your reference. On page three I highlight some of the kind of key ones.
In terms of design features, I just wanted to highlight that one of the key things that AB 12 o seven did was to put offsets under the cap. That was something new, and so in under that approach you're removing an allowance from the subsequent year's allowance budget for every offset that's used. Also, there were some key changes that were made to the utility and industry allowances, and we heard some about those in the discussion with CARB. One of the key changes was that CARB is required to design regulations that, as you heard, by 01/01/2031, would shift those free allowances from natural gas to the electric side. That was a key piece of, the the legislation.
And as you heard, that's gonna be done over a a several year time period that concludes in 2037. There's also a change to the months in which the California climate credit will be provided. And then there are changes to, some changes to how industries are provided allowances. Specifically, there used to be a requirement, that all industries be considered high highest the highest risk for leakage, and that was replaced as of 01/01/2031. So if you turn to page four, one of the other changes I wanted to highlight was, something I don't think we've talked too much about, but the use of the allowance value when we hit the price ceiling.
So previously, the value was used basically to purchase offsets, and now it's available for the legislature to use, for example, to provide rebates. So that was another key affordability provision that was included in that legislation. If you turn to page five, we highlight some of the key reporting evaluation and oversight requirements that were added as part of the legislation. Really, are are helpful to to support your work as a legislature in terms of making sure you're comfortable with this program and where it's going. That includes the creation of a new or intent at least to create a new oversight entity.
It included extending the work that our office does in an annual report and that the IEMAC does. You'll hear from a couple of IEMAC representatives here today. And it also includes some new reporting, work from CARB. So on page six, we talk a little bit about some of the modifications to the statutorily required DGRF appropriations under s b eight forty. I'm not gonna go into those again in the interest of time, and it's not the main focus of our discussion today, but that's also here for your reference.
Speaker 11
starting on page seven, we highlight some of the key issues that we think are really before you. And I think one of the key things to note is that these pieces of legislation were very important in highlighting some of the priorities that the legislature has. We've heard about them today too in terms of affordability while maintaining environmental ambition. So those were clearly two key goals that we really see throughout that legislation. The legislation also kind of continued the prior approach of giving CARB quite a bit of discretion in terms of how to really design the specifics of the program in some pretty key ways.
And we see that in the in the rulemaking that's before you, it's before the board. And I wanted to just highlight a couple of key areas where CARB has quite a bit of discretion and that we really think are critical in terms of really affecting how this program operates, how it affects the environmental ambition, well as affordability. So the first is the number of allowances issued, and that's a key decision that CARB is CARB is making a number of decisions about how many allowances to issue. That basically affects the size of that allowance pie. So that's important in terms of looking at affordability.
It's important because it affects environmental ambition. The more allowances, the less ambitious the program is. And but also the fewer impacts on in terms of potentially, costs on consumers. So that's a really key set of decisions, and CARB makes some choices there, in terms of how many allowances to issue. If you turn to page eight, I think perhaps this is perhaps the most important thing that I wanted to highlight, which is another key area where CARB has a lot of discretion and they're making a lot of choices in this rulemaking are related to how to divide up that pie of allowances.
And we heard quite a bit about that in the discussion previously. But, basically, once you've once you decide how many allowances, then a key decision is who gets those allowances. And that really is the revenues from this program, which entities do you want to receive those? The three main ones that historically have received allowances and are expected to continue to are utilities, and that typically goes to ratepayer benefits, so the climate credit we talked about. Industry to prevent again prevent and and protect against leakage.
We heard about both of those. And then whatever's left over goes to GGRF. So one of the key things to keep in mind is as you allocate more, for example, to industry or if you were to increase the allocation to utilities, probably less is gonna be available for GGRF. That may be good or bad, but there is sort of that set pie. And one of the key decisions that CARB has before it is how to allocate that pie, and you'll we think you'll wanna make sure that the that you understand the implications of the decisions they're making.
You'll understand how that pie is gonna shift and that you are comfortable with that. And if you're not, we really think this is a time for you to make your voices heard during this rulemaking, and make any comments you have and suggestions or additional direction because it's much easier to change now before the regulation goes into effect. Once it goes into effect, it'll, I think, be much more difficult to change that. It'll be we know the train will be going. So we think this is a key key point.
We're so glad you're having this hearing. I know it's late in the in the day, but really appreciate your attention to this matter because the stakes are high. This is a critical program for the state, and it allocates tens of billions of dollars, over the program's lifespan. And so, really, it has a huge potential impact on consumers. The uses of the allowances have big impacts, as well for industry, for rate payers, and for the programs that rely on DGRF.
So very important. So glad you're so engaged, and, we'll be happy to take questions at the, right moment.
Speaker 12
Excellent. One is always a follow. So thanks for the opportunity, to participate in this conversation, and thanks for all your leadership in this important area. So I'm a UC Berkeley economist. It's my day job.
I work on energy markets and climate policy and increasingly thinking about climate change adaptation. Also honored to serve as the chair of IMAC. But I should be clear, I'm not speaking on behalf of IMAC. We'll have a report out shortly that will summarize our consensus views on the topics we're discussing today. I'm I wanna reiterate a lot of what Helen just said and just kinda put a finer point on it and underscore that this is just that's why we're having this hearing at such a critical time.
There's big decisions being made in the coming months that will sort of lock in some important features and trade offs. And so this is I I really appreciate the opportunity to have my time to focus your attention on some key issues. And I think the point of departure for my comments is this complicating reality that the program is being designed. We're in an opportunity right now where we're we're rethinking the program to make sure it's fit for purpose, but the challenge is we have, like, seven purposes. We want to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions.
We wanna think very carefully and very seriously about affordability. We're worried about leakage and adverse impacts on competitiveness of of industrial operations in California, And we wanna set an example that other jurisdictions can follow, other jurisdictions interested in following us down this path of climate ambition. So designing a cap and invest program to advance all these multiple objectives, we got one program and multiple objectives, so they're gonna be trade offs. So that's what we're talking about today, and and I just wanted to dive into some of the weeds of those trade offs. So I these are nonessential slides, but oops.
Helen talked about a pie. I'm using bars, same idea. So this is just a graphic from our annual report the IMAC annual report last year. Just to remind you, you know this already, but this is just showing you the height of the bars of the billions of dollars of allowance value every year, over the history of the program. And the colors are just showing you how those those that value has been allocated across the three key, sort or sort of uses that Helen mentioned.
The blue is the GGRF. The shades of orange are utilities, electricity and natural gas respectively, and the purple are the industrial allocation. So those are really what I wanted to focus on today. Say a word about utility allowance value. We've already talked in detail about this.
I wanna just highlight a a couple more points. So I'm gonna show one more graph. I can't I've made this graph, I might as well show it. This is just showing, but the font is impossibly small. So what I'm just showing you here is inflation adjusted retail, energy prices, electricity, residential, commercial on top, natural gas, and gasoline on the bottom.
The red is California. The blue is the national national average showing you what you already know. California retail electricity prices are relatively high in electricity. They are rising and increasingly out of line with the rest of the country. And research that I have done with Berkeley colleagues and others have done has established that our retail prices in particular are significantly higher than what it actually cost to produce and consume electricity.
And as we've talked about, that is a barrier electrification. If electricity looks artificially high, households don't wanna electrify. And so what CARB is is is doing and what the PUC will be involved in, and this is part of the reauthorization, is we're using the climate credit. But here again, we're using one instrument, climate credit, to pursue three objectives, affordability or thinking about affordability, kind of reduce the impacts on consumers and commercial customers. Energy efficiency, we talked about this.
We wanna lower the electricity price so that electrification looks as cost effective as it can be. And I think there's another, you know better than me, but there's another objective in play here, and that's public awareness. We want households to see those revenues coming back to them and notice that. So briefly, CARB and the CPUC are proposing some design changes here, and I wanna focus on the how, the what, and the where. So, the ISO proposes to remove this prohibition on nonvolumetric returns.
And so this change would allow the CPUC to consider using allowances to reduce the electricity price versus handing it back to customers in this lump sum way. And that's really important. That's like a step in the right direction because we can reduce those electricity prices that we all agree are too high. The what, carb is required to design these regulations to transition the natural gas allocation towards electricity. Caitlin's gonna talk about, like, how quickly we will do this.
I wanna get into, like, I I just I I wanna elucidate the connections between these objectives. Because if we don't use this climate credit to reduce the volumetric rate, handing lump sum credits back to households is not gonna help with the electrification. It's still gonna be really expensive to charge an electric car or run your heat pump. So that that that how and the what are those are really important connections to be made. And then there's the when.
There's this suggestion or requirement that these climate credits get concentrated in the four high use months, and I think that's could be important for salience. I might notice that more than if it's spread out over twelve months. But if we're concentrating in the summer, heating with the heat pump in the winter is still really expensive. So there again, I think our competing objectives, we just gotta think about how to trade how to balance them as we redesign that credit. So it may seem like weedy details, but important details important choices being made that I think will make the difference between really realizing the potential of this credit, or falling short.
Okay. I know I'm almost out of time. So let me talk about industrial allocations, and let's put my rainbow staircase back just to remind you. So we've talked a lot about this already. Reauthorizing this cap and trade cap and invest program, really important opportunity to re evaluate how our leakage met mitigation strategy is working.
And CARB is revisiting, as we heard, the industrial allocation methodologies. I wanna make three observations about this. There's already been really good discussion. One, this is a this is like theory shows, like, makes perfect sense allocating some allowances for free to leakage, to industries at leakage risk is a very sensible thing to do. It's an effective way to mitigate, leakage risk.
That said, second point, this strategy comes at a cost. There's an opportunity cost. Every allowance we give to a refinery for free, we don't give to a household as a climate credit. We don't put in the GGRF, so there's that opportunity cost. There's also, an abatement cost because handing allowances for free to the cement industry or refineries does dilute that carbon price signal.
So we're shifting more of the abatement requirements or obligations onto entities that don't receive that reallocation. That's not to say it's bad. It's just a cost. So we gotta balance those costs with the real benefits, the leakage mitigation benefits that free allocation can secure. And so that leads me to my third point.
So under allocation increases the likelihood of emissions and economic leakage. We don't want that. But over allocation to industry does increase opportunity abatement costs. Right? And so we just need to balance those.
And so, I guess my third point is is a really good time to be recalibrating and rethinking. If I understand what CARB is proposing, they are proposing to calibrate these parameters in a way that would increase the share of allowance the allowance value pie that's allocated to industrial allocations versus other sources. Karb has stated in workshops that this increase is warranted. The assertions have not yet been supported with a lot of analysis and data, although miss Suhoda says that's coming. But I just think it's gonna be really important to, think carefully.
And in the interest of transparency, just try and bring all the information we can to this recalibration. Final point I'm gonna make Helen already made, but, you know, the GGRF is kind of a residual claimant on the the allowance is not allocated to these other sources. Senate bill eight forty, changed the GGRF into sort of a four tiered strategy. And in the ISOR, the CARB staff analysis projects that the GGRF revenues will never meet the minimum spending requirements anticipated for SB eight forty. So there just won't be and, you know, this is a really hard projection to make, and I'm this this is based on carbon analysis.
It's been made available. But I just think this could be the right thing to do. Like, maybe that long list of of purposes and and projects that could be covered by GGRF. We wanna allocate more to industry or we wanna allocate more to the climate credit, but underscoring what Helen said so clearly. Like, now is the time to look at the trade offs we're making, bring as much information as we can to understand those trade offs.
Really appreciate all the work you've already done to get us here. And just the next few months, there'll be some important decisions made to understand how we're trading off priorities. In closing, I just wanna say briefly, members already mentioned, you know, there's the months ahead, we're locking in some important design details. Years ahead, we're thinking about how carbon capture gets integrated into the program, how we link with Washington. So a lot more important, design features to be thinking.
So I appreciated that IMAC's mandate was also extended, in the, reauthorization, and IMAX members look forward to reinventing our own process to try and understand how we can best serve, this important policy, initiative that California is moving forward. So I'll stop there. Thank you for your attention.
Speaker 7
Yes. I'm Caitlin Rodner Sutter. I'm the California senior director for Environmental Defense Fund. Thank you for the invitation this evening. I'm also the assembly appointee to IEMAC, but like Meredith, I'm just speaking in my, non IEMAC capacity, in my case, EDF.
So I wanted to just start with a couple of overarching points, and I'm gonna talk briefly about allowance allocation and then finish with my favorite topic of climate ambition. My first overarching point was actually about balancing affordability and ambition, and I think both Helen and Meredith covered that really well. So I will move to the second, which is that it is essential that these program updates are adopted this spring. You know, there's a lot of pieces moving here, but we cannot afford to have any further delay. This rulemaking has already gone on for well over two years when we go back to all of the informal workshops that started this.
And that delay is causing a lot of uncertainty still, which makes it harder for compliance entities to to plan, but also is contributing to the low auction prices and depressed GGRF revenue that we've seen. So there is urgency to get this adopted. These you know, get the whatever the final package looks like to complete this rulemaking in the spring. I'll touch quickly on allowances to electric utilities. I and Meredith already covered part of this.
But in terms of timing, as you know, a b 12 o seven required CARB to to design the program to transition support from natural gas utilities to the electrical distribution utilities by 01/01/2031. The proposal from CARB, though, has that transition taking place between 2029 and 2036. So I think it's very reasonable to phase this transition in over multiple years, and I appreciate that the transition is complex. But this proposal is completing that transition a full five years after the date sent by the legislature. And I think that's a real missed opportunity for addressing electricity costs as as Meredith talked about all the implications of that.
I also wanna talk briefly about allowances to industry. Some of this is in your backgrounder, but there are four factors that go into determining industrial allocation. The industrial assistance factor, the product benchmark, cap adjustment factor, and the annual output of a facility. I'm gonna talk about the first three quickly. Those those are the ones that are set by the state.
So the industrial assistance factor. This was set at 100% for every sector under a b three ninety eight. It is important to note that does not mean they get 100% of the allowances that they need. But a b 12 o seven rightly directed CARB to go back and set those based on, you know, real leakage risk. However, CARB is planning to leave that industrial assistance factor at 100% through 2035, which I have to say I pine find personally very frustrating, but it is an acknowledgment that industry does need assistance.
I mean, they are still getting free allowances through this this program. The product benchmark is the second piece, and this is a measure of how efficiently a product is produced. These have not been updated since the original rulemaking back in 2011. And CARB is, which is good, proposing to update some of those. Some of those will result in fewer free allowances to certain industries, including oil and gas, after 2031.
The third piece is the cap adjustment factor, and that's how fast the free allocation declines with the cap. And CARB is proposing to keep that the same through 2031 and decline after that. But because the cap itself is proposed to be somewhat tighter before 2031, that means the overall percentage of allowances allocated to industry for free is actually increasing. The proposal also adds a new industrial allocation for innovative decarbonization strategies, which would make more free allowances available to producers that are, you know, using innovative technology to decarbonize their production. There's a lot to still be determined in what that looks like, but I I, you know, potentially see that as a positive step, to both, you know, build out some new technology, as long as we can get the rules right for building that technology and avoid unintended consequences for host communities.
But the point of all of this is saying is that there is a mix of gives to industry and takes from industry in this system of industrial allocation. And CARB is really seeking to find this balance between ambition and affordability. So I just you know, as as you hear that this is going to close down industries or what have you, there is a mix here of things that I wish were more on the climate ambition side and less on the free allocation side and vice versa. So I I think CARB is really hitting for a balance here. And then there's climate ambition, and this talks this gets back to Helen's point about sort of that overall pie of how many allowances.
Before we talk about how they're allocated, just how many allowances are there in the first place. And from analysis that that EDF has has commissioned, we really think that CARB could afford to be moderately more ambitious in the near term, and it is the near term that matters most for impacts to the climate. And they could do this while still preserving the cost containment of the program, and maximizing net benefits for California households. So, specifically, we have some preliminary modeling updates from Green Line Insights that finds if California were to adopt a tighter near term emissions cap by removing 180,000,000 allowances through 2030 instead of the proposed 118, that would significantly incentivize decarbonization while still saving money for working families, specifically over 860,000,000 in net savings through 2045 for families earning a $100,000 or less annually, which is more than half of California households. And importantly, that is done without hitting any of the price containment points in the program, those APCR tiers.
So we're keeping allowance prices manageable and steadily increasing, not spiking. This would cumulatively generate about an additional, 1 to $1,500,000,000, for the greenhouse gas reduction fund. It would also help to increase near term confidence, in the market and counteract some of these very low prices we're seeing right now and the resulting anemic GGRF revenue that that we're seeing in the market. The very last thing I wanna say on ambition is I wanna acknowledge the legislature's direction to retire allowances equal to the offsets turned in for compliance, offsets under the cap. This also provides an an important increase in ambition.
Specifically, after the last compliance period, we would have had 26,000,000 cumulative fewer allowances in circulation had this previously been in place. And I think that increase in ambition is a very important part of a b 12 o seven. And I think the way CARB is proposing to implement it appears effective and and reasonable to me. So I think that is looking like a good win all around. So happy to take any questions and appreciate this.
Speaker 10
Thank you so much. Thank you, chairs, assembly member. I'm doctor Natalie Seitzman, government affairs manager for SCAPA. SCAPA is a joint powers agency comprised of 12 publicly owned utilities or POUs. POUs are distinct from investor owned utilities as not for profit, full service utilities with governing boards that are either elected officials or appointed by elected officials.
As such, POUs are directly accountable to their local communities. SCAPA, as a public agency, performs joint procurement of generation and transmission projects for our members, allowing them to achieve economies of scale. So thank you for having me here today to share my concerns with CARB's proposed changes to the cap and invest program, particularly in the near term. Under the proposal published by CARB in January, SCAPA members, our 12 POUs, stand to lose 9,000,000 allowances from 2027 through 2030, equating to hundreds of millions of dollars of revenues that are not collected from rate payers. So before explaining precisely why this is so problematic for the maybe more general audience, let me offer some background of how POUs fit into cap and invest.
I know you're all pros at this. So California's electric sector, as you mentioned, some member is the backbone of the state's decarbonization strategy. So through bold legislative action with SB 100, their renewable portfolio standards, utilities have been set on a direct path to decrease their greenhouse gas emissions. So that puts us in a unique position with the market based mechanism of cap and invest. So as Karb alluded, utilities are allocated allowances sufficient to cover the GSG emissions that are left over in their portfolios as they comply with clean energy policies, thus protecting electric rate payers from extra costs that don't provide commensurate climate benefit.
There's also a big difference between how IOUs and POUs interact with cap and invest. IOUs distribute allowance value as climate credits. POUs have more options. So we are authorized to do a climate credit, but they primarily invest those funds into buying renewable energy projects and funding programs to help customers decarbonize. These other options allow POUs to give their rate payers the biggest bang for the buck.
When POUs so because of that, when POUs think about cap and invest, long term planning is key to actually achieving those rate payer savings. So unlike a climate credit, which can vary in amount from year to year, infrastructure investments operate on a five, ten year time scale. So it's critical for us to know how many allowances POUs are gonna be allocated for as many years in the future as possible. In the last update that CARB did to the then cap and trade program, CARB gave utilities a ten year projection of our allowance allocation. But now CARB is proposing to change the utility's allowance allocation in year seven of ten.
This is the reason for our deepest concern about the proposed regulation. One of the major benefits of this ten year projection was that it allowed utilities to rely in good faith on those allowances allowances to accelerate their decarbonization plans. They had confidence that by outpacing CARB's projections, their early action would free up more allowances, thus creating a revenue stream that would offset the costs of that early action. So for example, six of Scapa's 12 members were participants in a coal plant in Delta, Utah called Intermountain Power Project, which was constructed in the nineteen eighties in the wake of the oil embargo. Scapa's members contract with IPP was set to expire in 2027, but seeing an opportunity to decarbonize more quickly while the CAP and Invest program could provide benefits to their rate payers that would offset the extra cost, they accelerated their plans, amended the contract, and got off coal in 2025.
And IPP is just one example. Another Scapa member has been nearly a hundred percent zero carbon for several years, making big investments early on and relying on the long term benefits of their allowance allocation. So CARB changing the allowance allocations midstream erases the benefit of that early action and is creating cost at a time when maintaining affordability is one of our greatest challenges. So what does this mean for ratepayers in California and specifically POU ratepayers? First and most importantly, rate increases are a real possibility.
When you have additional costs as a nonprofit utility, there are only two things you can do, raise rates or pull back on spending, including decarbonization investments. POUs have long said that a well designed cap and invest program can be a benefit to electric rate payers. But if CARB's proposal is finalized as currently written, we are deeply concerned that POU rate payers will be adversely impacted as cost pressures mount on their local utilities. So thank you very much for the opportunity to speak, and I'm happy to answer any questions.
Speaker 2
Alright. Do we have questions for the panelists? How about do you want me to okay. Thank you very much. This was very informative, and and I'm gonna have to look back at the tape because it went went very fast also.
Miss Rodner Sutter, the the CARB's proposal contains a table of projected GGRF revenues, and the numbers are lower than expected. Can you go a little bit more deeply into why that is? I think you've covered it generally, but could you talk a little bit more in what we specifically need to beyond what you mentioned already, what we specifically should be focusing on? Absolutely. I might also thinking of your report, if
Speaker 7
you wanna speak to that too. I I mean, I I will say I think we, within IEMAC, have been trying to parse this out a little bit and and are are struggling a little bit to connect from what we understand about allocation to the projected revenue. So the the short answer is I don't have a very concrete answer for you because we're we are having a hard time sort of connecting those dots within the proposal. I mean, I will say sort of overall, as the cap declines, we will see decreased GGRF revenue in in the out years. If GGRF revenue is a priority, we need to be auctioning more allowances and giving fewer away for free.
I mean, that is the direct trade off is we have a finite number of allowances. By definition, that number declines year over year. And the more we give away for free, the less we have to sell and the less GGRF revenue we have. But like I said, I I think even within IEMAC, we were discussing this at our last meeting trying to piece together sort of where specifically those projections come from. I don't know if you have
Speaker 11
Yeah. Absolutely. All of that, I I second. I think, it has been a little bit of a challenge. I think because of some of the market constraints that CARB has, We haven't been able to get a lot of detail about what's behind those numbers.
But, fundamentally, there are two possible things. Right? Because the amount of money that goes to GGRF is determined by the number of allowances that goes to g go to GGRF and the price that's assumed. And so they're sort of assuming a kind of intermediate price. So, really, it seems, least on its face, that what must be driving this largely is a smaller number of allowances that are going to GGRF.
And part of that, we understand, is because, just broadly, these regulations give more to industry, and so probably that's partly, affecting how much goes to GGRF. But I think in terms of the details, I think that's something that we're still assessing. And I think to the extent that the legislature is interested in understanding that, I think additional questions to carve would probably make sense because I think it is a critical question. Right? I think there are probably stakeholders who very much care, about how much money might go to DGRF.
It's hard to predict because we don't know allowance prices, but at least having a sense of how many allowances do we reasonably expect. Obviously, there's some uncertainty, but do we reasonably expect under these regulations would be provided to the big categories, to GGRF, to industry, and to utilities? And if you can understand that, then you can make decisions about is that the is that the mix is that the pie that we like? Does that you know, is that consistent with your priorities, or would you like a different pie? And there's trade offs, because all of these, you know, all of these different ways of allocating can provide benefits, whether it's to rate payers or to programs or to, you know, industry that might lead the state.
But, you know, you can't really assess those trade offs unless you know sort of unless we're all on the same page about what these regulations will do. I don't know if that's helpful.
Speaker 2
It it is helpful. Probably the most helpful would be to for GGRF proceeds is to actually move things like CalFire out into the general fund. Alright. I appreciate all the sorry if there's any fans of that. So so I I understand the different allocations.
And and, again, for us, I think we made clear that that's the the climate credit is helping everybody, and so that is definitely a, you know, for me, that's a priority. Think for the assembly, it's a priority. But is there can you go a little bit more into, like, why did the cost not, are we waiting for the regulations to go through? Why is the cost lower than we expected? And I don't know who might be able to answer that.
Or what are things that could actually drive is is is the market not stabilized yet because the regulations aren't done? I guess that's the question. Do you
Speaker 7
think there is some uncertainty about are these going to be done in time this spring, you know, on the the timeline that Carb has put out? How ambitious, you know, how tight is the market going to be? And you will see, you know, compliance entities probably have a little different perspective on what they would like to see versus investors in the market, which you know, so there's there's sort of different priorities there. But I think broadly speaking, you know, there's uncertainty about how many allowances are gonna be available at auction. Are the regulations going to be updated this spring to go into effect September 1 to do next year's allowance allocation?
So I think I think those are the two biggest drivers. And and as a result, we are seeing lower prices at auction and lower GGRF revenue.
Speaker 2
And why so is is because the regulations are were not done, is that the reason there was not a real real big, rebound of prices when we reauthorized? Because we really thought that we would see the prices jump up after that.
Speaker 7
This is my speculation as someone who is not, you know, a market participant. But, when we look back a year or so ago at this point or more, when CARB put out three potential scenarios of of tightening the allowance budgets pre 2030. The central scenario was removing 265,000,000 allowances, which at the time CARB said was necessary to put the state on track. We we would basically beat our 2030 target to be on track to meet our 2045 target. So that they did not commit to that scenario.
I wanna be clear, but but that was the central scenario. If you look at their slide, it's in bold. And then when the October workshop right after the bill passed, it was clear that from that, the staff proposal was going to be removing only 118,000,000 allowances. And I my speculation on the market is that was a real surprise to some market participants, especially investors in the market who, you know, actually want to see higher, allowance prices. And so that sort of perceived backing off of ambition, I think, is is part of is part of it.
And I think there is very much a perception that there is extra space here pre 2030 to remove more allowances. We have too many allowances in the program in the near term is the bottom line.
Speaker 2
And I guess that it it goes to the balance that we've been speaking about through the entire panel of affordability and and, ambition. So do I follow-up on that? Yes.
Speaker 1
Yeah. Just following up on the chair's point, is there more are there other impediments to more robust market participation from unregulated entities from from noncompliance entities that you all see? I mean, are there other are there other parts of the eyesore that you see as impediments to those who want to invest in our carbon market or other other factors? Leave that open to the whole panel.
Speaker 12
I mean, the one that I don't this isn't directly answering your good question. I think the one other, factor that I think about is, importantly, with this reauthorization, CARB is charged with,
Speaker 12
help California achieve its goals, but also keep affordability top of mind. And I believe there's explicit language. Right? If if the if adverse impacts become too significant, we need to reevaluate. So I don't know.
I think that's an important balance to be very deliberate about, but it does signal to the market that, you know, if prices rise too much, we need to pull back. And I I don't think that's a bad thing, but I think as a market participant, you might not fully understand, you know, what that means and how it might play out.
Speaker 1
Do do you do any of you see any validity to this? I I mentioned the Bushnell study. I don't know if you all are familiar with it. The the new, his new, analysis of why carbon prices are so low that one scenario might be around these, gasoline imports sort of waiting to see what happens and that that may not come into the market? Do you think there's validity to having concerns about a sort of flood of foreign gasoline causing spikes in the near term?
Maybe not right now, but, further out in the future. Do you see that as a concern with that discussion we had with, miss Sahota and the chair in terms of the the disparity at the rack when you're just assessing, basically, tailpipe emissions intensity versus life cycle intensity in the program that they can use that as as a way to gain the market, in other words, to send super high carbon intensity gasoline to us without having to actually pay the full cost? Do you you see that as a valid concern?
Speaker 12
I think all I will say, is that Jim Bushnell is a colleague who knows a lot more about fuel markets than I do. Yeah. So I I see him as a credible authority and a thoughtful Yeah. Voice in this, but I can't pretend to have the expertise that he does in that space.
Speaker 1
Any comments on that from EDF just in terms of how to deal with that that that gap between the LCFS and cap and trade and that sort of that hole there?
Speaker 7
I I wouldn't probably not at right at this moment. I would I would agree with Meredith. I mean, I have a lot of respect for Jim's
Speaker 7
Doctor Bushnell. Sorry. No. I'm calling everybody by their first name. For for his expertise and his analysis here, I don't have an an independent perspective on that work.
I will say, you know, CARB does have very you mentioned sort of, like, manipulating and flooding the market. CARB has very, very robust rules to protect against market manipulation. Yeah. And we have never, you know, seen any any anything like that. And when there's been a concern about it, there has been an investigation.
And so I Sure. I do have confidence that the market rules would prevent any sort of potential manipulation like that.
Speaker 1
So low risk of the on the manipulation side, but but not necessarily a clear path to dealing with this treatment of gasoline imports. Like a two I mean, this is, I guess, feedback we'd love to get going forward. Just what what tools do you think are out there, that we might not already be using to make sure
Speaker 1
That that rack is in a point of of sort of, you know, tale of of two two barrels, right, where where you're sort of where carb just has to sort of take it on its face as gas just fungible gasoline, whereas it really is not if it's been, you know, brought to us on a secret Russian ship like $92,000,000,000 of gasoline was around the world last year.
Speaker 7
I mean, I think on that question specifically, I'm gonna wanna come back to you Yes. And not, you know, speculate right now. There you know, more broadly, I mean, there are a lot of steps the state is taking to stabilize transportation fuels market. Maybe taking off my cap and trade hat and putting on, you know, my CEC petroleum working group hat. But there's a lot more the state can do as we think about sort of how we work through this mid transition while also keeping California households whole, you know, ensuring that we are reducing our demand for fossil fuels even as we know we need them in the short term.
You know? So I think we're having a lot of conversations about what what does what are the trade offs of imports both from an economic and environmental perspective
Speaker 7
And a labor perspective. And and how do we, you know, continue to move toward cleaner fuels and maximizing electrification and all of that? So there's Yeah. Like, there's a lot of pieces to this puzzle. And as you are implying, they go far beyond California.
I mean, this is a global market that
Speaker 1
Yeah. I just would note that, you know, at our border, for example, with electricity imports, we have a carbon adder right now. So we we do that with electricity where you don't get to just sneak in California's border and sell us a bunch of coal power and not be responsible for the full life cycle you're missing. Emissions, why should it be any different with gasoline? So I just I would encourage you all to maybe put your heads on that a little further and and through that discussion, you know, hopefully avoid, you know, avoids creating sort of a lopsided regulatory approach.
But I appreciate all that. Thank you for testifying.
Speaker 5
madam chair, and thank you all for, for joining us this evening. Professor, in your presentation, you said that now is an important time to review the parameters that define output based allowances in light of the best available evidence. Further that this analysis that the analysis that informs this recalibration should be publicly shared to the extent possible. What what should we be doing that we're not already doing?
Speaker 12
Yes. And I think this really builds on what Caitlin went on, like, the details. So, and, you know, I've done work as an economist in the theory of that formula, and it's a beautiful formula in terms of the pieces. And, in theory, you can calibrate them precisely and and and make those output based allocations commensurate with the leakage risk we're exposed to, in practice, it's so much messier. So I just wanna start by acknowledging that this is a really hard job, and it's easy to say.
You know? We wanna strike this balance. It's a much harder balance to actually strike. But I do think that, you know, and and I really just respect tremendously the work that CARB is doing in this space. But in in the workshop and in the ice war, there's reference to analysis that's been done to support this conclusion that we should leave the adjustment factors as they are and leave everybody at a 100%.
And I think to build trust in the process because this is this is whether you wanna use a pie or a bar, it's like allowance is allocated to industry or allowance is not allocated to customer credits or or the GGRF, the more transparent we can be in terms of, okay. What how do we support that conclusion? What analysis has been done? It's gonna be messy and imperfect and based on assumptions, but can we bring any more transparency to those high stakes questions? And miss Sohoda mentioned that we should be seeing soon, so I I think I hope it's coming.
But I think it will be important to offer some substantiation for some important decisions that are being made that determine that know, the share of allowances going to industry is gonna get bigger, which means that the other pie pieces are gonna get smaller. I don't know if that answers your question adequately.
Speaker 5
Are there any other thoughts on that front? Alright. And then I think, you did a great job of framing the the fact that we're trying to achieve a lot Yes. This program. We've got a lot of very important, sometimes competing goals, but I think our our goal is certainly to try to harmonize those where where we possibly can.
So coming back to this the conversation, around, you know, ensuring that there's not sort of this tension between decarbonization and affordable electricity, miss either, you know, Seitzman or anyone else who has other perspectives on things we should be doing differently to ensure that the program can accomplish both of those important goals in tandem?
Speaker 10
the question. I think to balance that decarbonization and that electric affordability, there has to be a kind of broad recognition that the electric sector is the pathway to decarbonization, is a key element of the pathway to decarbonization. And, unfortunately, it's facing a lot of challenges right now in terms of maintaining that affordability. There's market disruptions, cost increases in renewables driven by tariffs, loss of tax credits, and just delays related to interconnection, permitting, supply chain. So since 2018 when s p 100 was enacted, the contract prices of solar and wind have doubled and tripled respectively, And that's, like, North America wise.
So I think the solution is to invest in the electric sector. So reducing allowances at this time would negatively affect both of those. So if there's one thing that cap and invest can do to achieve both electric rate affordability and decarbonization, it's to protect the cost of electricity.
Speaker 5
Yeah. I would just double down on a a point, madam chair, that you were making, which is that it feels like, we're sort of rather perversely punishing the folks who have been doing the best work and punishing the folks who actually made those early investments. So I think, ensuring that we are rethinking that approach, as we move forward and perhaps not as you and you and your amazing consultant, Sam, have talked about, Perhaps we're not talking about the originalist interpretation, but rather an interpretation that, ensures that the climate credit is being deployed really to drive that affordability and, really, I think to ensure that continued progress.
Speaker 2
Alright. And with that, thank you, very much for joining us this afternoon. And, now we will be hearing, public comments. And in the interest of time, we will give each speaker a a minute.
Speaker 13
A b 12 o seven because it made some improvements in existing law. I think there are a couple ways that the car proposal falls short of fully implementing what you put into law. Your law says that the climate credit should transition from natural gas to electric by 2031, 01/01/2031. So you shouldn't have to remind them, but I urge you to remind Karb what 2031 actually means. Secondly, they're being overly generous with the industrial allocations.
I think that you invited them to reexamine those assistance factors, and they've declined. They haven't provided any evidence. They just wanna continue on the path that they were on. And, yeah, it's it's continuing to give away to the big industrial polluters that should be contracted. And finally, just wanna agree with chair Irwin that, GGRF is not the appropriate funding source for CALFIR.
Speaker 14
Thank you, chair and members. Jason Eichard with Edelstein Gilbert Robeson Smith on behalf of the California Municipal Utilities Association. You all know this, but just to remind you, we represent publicly owned gas, electric, water, and wastewater members, and we provide about 25% of the power in the state, and we do it really well. We're very proud of our members because they provide that power at cost, and they provide it very affordably. They're the gold standard on affordability.
I just wanna really thank the members of this joint committee for the discussion today on on electric utility allowances in general, but in publicly owned electric utility allowances specifically. It was great. And I wanna get to the very last question that you raised again as a member of Petrie Norris. It may not be the intent to punish electric utilities who have done well. That is absolutely the upshot of what is happening in the proposed regulations.
You heard doctor Seitzman say it well. A group of utilities worked to get off of coal earlier. They did that knowing that the allowance allocations that they were counting on that had been set in the regulation by CARB were coming. Now under this regulation, they're not. And the impact to ratepayers is enormous, and it's something that's very easy to quantify for us because we do provide service at cost.
And our estimate is around $750,000,000 in the next four years. We oppose this. We hope that you will oppose it as well, and we're gonna continue to eliminate the allowances that were already planned to be allocated and then minimize the changes going forward. Thank you.
Speaker 15
Hi. Good evening. My name is Chloe Ames, and I'm a policy adviser with NextGen California. First, thanks to, chair Irwin and the committee for all of your work on passing a strengthened cap and invest program. We also supported a b 12 o seven, but, we're here today to raise significant concerns with the proposed cap and invest regulation and also state our support for a more ambitious ambitious regulation that cuts near term emissions, supports electricity affordability, and generates more funds for the greenhouse gas reduction fund to reduce unnecessary free giveaways to industry.
Specifically, we would like to see, one, a tighter carbon allowance budget before 2030 to avoid delayed ambition and generate more funds for GGRF by strengthening the market overall. Two, a faster transition from the natural gas to electric climate credit, by 2031 in line with e d 12 o seven to support overall electrification and affordability. Three, an updated industry assistance factor starting in 2031 based on actual leakage risk and for consultation with the Environmental Justice Advisory Committee, to provide input before finalizing those proposed regulations. As you all know well, we have an opportunity to currently bolster the cap and invest program and make it the emissions reduction and affordable solution we need, but this regulation does not go far enough. Thank you.
Speaker 16
Madam chair, members, Theo Paios, representing Calpine. We're very heartened to see the positive comments made by the airborne relative to carbon capture. I just wanna emphasize that it is important to flush out how it will be used to comply with the program in these early regulations as people are planning and financing these projects as we speak, and cap and trade is a big part of financing those projects. Thank you.
Speaker 17
Thank you, chair and vice chairman. It's Marquis King Mason with NRDC. So NRDC and 37 organizations sent a letter to legislature asking for a quicker transition to the climate credit immediately to decrease, high electricity costs next year. During the capital investment making process, NRDC has also proposed an alternative transition plan that are predicted to transition the natural gas climate credit by by January 2031 to target relief for its most needed. My colleague, Joe, is happy to provide some details on that.
Speaker 18
Good afternoon, chair and committee members. My name is Allison Hilliard with the Climate Center, and I wanna align my comments with NRDC that just had just presented and add that the proposed amendments represent small but necessary steps in the right direction. However, we face a rapidly worsening climate approaching dangerous tipping points, which was mentioned a lot today, and now is not the time to slow walk our emission reduction efforts. The proposed removal of a 118,300,000 allowances from the auction pool is the bare minimum required to meet California's twenty thirty targets. And as noted in the 2022 scoping plan, deeper reductions are needed to remain on track with our 25 carbon goal neutrality goals, and we recommended removing at least 265,000,000 allowances to generate stronger pollution, price signals, and greater g, GGR revenues.
I look forward to working with EDF, and learning more about how they got to the one eighty and can and moving forward with that. We also oppose the continuous subsidies to fossil fuel industry through a 100% industrial allocation factors extended to twenty thirty five. These factors should be addressed no later than 2031. Furthermore, the proposed amendments to the cap adjustment factor for industrial or I'm sorry, for industry could potentially increase the share allowances for this sector and reducing GGR pro proceeds and shortchanging urgently needed investments in our community, based decarbonization and resilience. Thank you so much.
Speaker 19
Good evening, madam chair. Members Shane Levine on behalf of the Northern California Power Agency and our municipal utility members. I'll align my comments with CMUA and SCAPA. Appreciate the robust, discussion. We also believe that the car proposal as it relates to electric distribution utilities is also gonna have an adverse impact on two things, rates and, prudent, resource planning.
So for those reasons, we're also opposed, and we think any outstanding issues addressing the program should be focused for 2031 and beyond. So thank you for your attention. Appreciate it.
Speaker 20
Good evening, chair and members. Margie Lee Stamson Advisors on behalf of the California League of Food Producers, a trade association representing food processors and beverage processors, many of whom are covered by the Cap and Invest program. We're concerned that the proposed increase in program sufficiency may affect food and the communities that these processors serve. Specifically, we're worried that the changes will result in higher compliance costs that could translate to higher prices for food produced here in California. Food production, depends a lot on natural gas to generate high heat, which is necessary to meet food safety requirements as well as to process, our equipment.
Our members have worked very hard to reduce their GHG emissions, and many have already exhausted the most accessible options. Further reductions will require access to reliable hydrogen as well as biofuels that are not widely available or are the cost to these alternatives are exorbitant. So we appreciate that carbon is working to address leakage risk, but we wanna highlight that food producers have some unique challenges compared to some of our other partners, particularly on our reliance on fuel combustion for these high heat intensive processes. So without tailored support, we're really concerned that there's a real risk that consumers may shift towards less expensive food options produced in regions with less stringent GHG emission reduction requirements like China. So we're asking that the cap and invest regulations be revised to better support industries that depend on height high heat processes such as expanding the alternate cap adjustment factor, and we would encourage CARB to consider whether increasing program strategy is the most, effective and equitable path as it relates to food production.
Speaker 3
Thank you, madam chair. Mister vice chair, Israel Solace with Southern California Gas Company, but also San Diego Gas and Electric. Thank you for the hearing today and for your engagement in the issue. We've long supported the program as an as an important affordability tool for our customers. There was a lot of discussion today about the, natural gas allowances.
Last year, we did raise concerns, about the ratepayer impact of eliminating those allowances. As many of you know, those allowances flow back to our customers as part of the climate credit that customers receive on their natural gas utility bill. So very concerned about any, changes to that. We think that the program or at least the the bill last year made clear that the transition, is intended to minimize the impact for both electric and natural gas utility customers, so we we we think that the current regulation is reasonable in that respect. And then on behalf of SDG and E, echo the concerns about the impact on affordability for electric customers, and welcome the the support of the committee in keeping that as a centerpiece of affordability as well.
Thank you.
Speaker 21
Good evening. Valerie Trello Vlahos with Pacific Gas and Electric Company. Thank you so much for for the hearing today. We've heard, from many stakeholders about the need for a robust utility sector allowance allocation, and that translates directly, to customer affordability. PG and E is going to continue to advocate, for an allowance allocation with affordability as the center point for our customers.
And this includes advocating first for certainty. You heard from other utility, partners that we work with that there was an expectation of a set amount of allowances to twenty thirty, and, we think that, that should be honored and and locked in as we were told. And secondly, we will be advocating for a reasonable, transition or glide path, approach for the transition of allowances away from our gas customers. Our gas customers also do face affordability challenges, especially those that do not have the means to leave the gas system. Thank you for your time today.
Speaker 22
Thank you, madam chair and members. Zach Lary on behalf of the Western States Petroleum Association. Let me be clear. In addition to the LCFS, our in state refiners have two obligations under the cap and trade program, one for the stationary source emissions at the refineries and one for the fuel they sell into the market. Importers only have that one obligation for the fuel that they sell into the market.
We are already the most competitively disadvantaged refineries in the world. We are disadvantaged because of the hard costs imposed by state policy. These draft rules only make those hard costs worse. An independent analysis shows that the draft rig will hit in state refiners with 5 to $9,000,000,000 in compliance stationary
Speaker 22
over the next ten years. That's not stabilization. You are seeing the leakage in real time under the status quo. These regs will make that worse, and we will likely be a triggering event for other refinery decisions. Don't rush to get this wrong.
Understand the complexities. Take the time to get it right. Thank you.
Speaker 23
Good evening, chair Erwin, vice chair Stern, member Petrie Norris, John Kenrick on behalf of California Chamber of Commerce. As we've heard today, decisions around cap and trade are incredibly consequential. The program directly affects utility rates, fuel prices, industrial investment decisions, and, ultimately, whether production occurs in the state of California or someplace else. I'd like to respectfully note something about today's panel. You know, we saw regulators.
We saw an environmental advocate, policy analysts, but there's no representation from emissions intensive trade exposed sectors here. Right? Those types of facilities, cement, food processing, refining, glass, metals, and others, they're the entities that actually, the leakage provisions were designed for. And so when they make investment decisions, they're they're comparing California not to an ideal policy, but to other markets as well that don't have comparable carbon costs. Without hearing from emissions intensive trade exposed industries, the committee's risking evaluating the program without input from the parties most affected by compliance costs and those who have to choose whether to pass those costs through to consumers or ultimately relocate.
At least kind of the second point of the current regulatory package does not yet provide sufficient cost containment or leakage protection for the trajectory the program is being asked to follow. As the cap becomes significantly more stringent, the safety valves are relatively unchanged. As allowance budgets decline, price volatility likely increases.
Speaker 23
up, please. One more thought, and I'll wrap it up. Thank you. If prices rise faster than expected, companies cannot immediately electrify or redesign industrial processes or relocate their supply chain overnight. So instead, the response is reduced in state production and increased imports.
It doesn't decrease emissions. It just relocates them. Thank you.
Speaker 24
Good evening, madam madam chair. Christian Mota on behalf of the California Council for Environmental and Economic Balance. Thanks to the committee for holding this hearing. CEEB is in the process of gathering feedback from members, but would like to highlight a few early priorities for the committee. First, the very much discussed changes in the electric utility allocations for 2027 to 2030.
The new proposed allocations remove approximately 30% of the current rules allowances. And as discussed in the committee materials and today in the hearing, this will have an impact on ratepayer relief by reducing allowances available to fund the California climate credit. Second, we'll be encouraging CARB to take additional steps to minimize leakage in the industrial sector, especially with respect to in state refining. Third, the proposed post 2032 cap adjustment factor decline is steep. It's a 13% decline from 2031 to 2032, increasing the importance of strong cost containment, to protect, consumers and prevent leakage.
CARB has proposed some strengthening, may wanna consider additional measures. I just wanna thank, you for the opportunity to comment. Look forward to working with the committee. Thank you.
Speaker 25
Chair, senator, assembly member, wants to extend our appreciation to the staff for all the hard work they put into this. Mick Sklarla here on behalf of Climate Build California. Ambition alone is not a design principle. The card proposal doubles year over year ambition from the current program. It's imperative that we increase the cost containment and leakage protections to maintain stability of our industries and energy of costs.
AB 12 o seven was clear. The board must achieve technologically feasible and cost effective reductions. It must minimize costs, avoid disproportionate impacts in low income communities, consider affordability, minimize leakage, and reduce administrative burden. These are not side notes. They're guardrails.
At the end of session, we supported a compromise to preserve the program stability. Stability matters, but it's not complacency. We must adjust cost containment and leakage protections to be commensurate with the goal. The goal has changed from when we initially, codified those, and we now are seeking carbon neutrality by 2045, not just 40% by 2030. To that end, if we do not adjust these things, we will see higher allowance prices, which will show up in your utility bills, your fuel prices, and at the checkout counter.
4,000,000,000 in the program design should be the highest goal. If we get that right, we protect households and we maintain industry. Thank you.
Speaker 26
Hi, chair. Mariella Racho with leadership council for, for justice and accountability. Thank you for the opportunity to comment here. These comments are based on concerns we have for low income impacting low income and, environmentally disadvantaged communities who have experience cumulative impacts, from the environmental burdens. We continue to be concerned with carb incentivizing dairy bio, biomethane in the cap and invest program, which leads to continued subsidies, to one of the most polluting industries, mega dairies, to overburden communities.
We are also troubled with the use of CCUS as identified pathway to reduce emissions because of the threat to public health and and the environment, from carbon pipeline leaks to drinking water contamination while minimizing, if any, climate benefit. And as you pointed out, there is no current rulemaking on, nine zero five. We continue to be concerned with offset projects, many of which, such as the dairy digesters, have harmful impacts on the environment and surrounding communities through ongoing air and water pollution. Lastly, a weak regulation threatens one of the primary sources of funding for environmental justice programs. CARB's proposed update, to cap and trade, are too weak, continue to offer lavish, free allowances to industry until 2035 and even creating a new industry credit program.
This program continues to, be weak in a sharp decline to, GRF revenues, so, that cut into half for 2025. So last lastly, we urge the legislature to ensure CARB is, taking meaningful steps to, meet our climate targets in a way that do not threaten the health and safety of environmental justice program, communities.
Speaker 27
Good evening, madam chair and members. Michelle Kanalis on behalf of Union of Concerned Scientists. Thank you for the opportunity to comment. UCS strongly supported the reauthorization of the cap and invest program last session and is as it is California's most important remaining tool to achieving our emission reduction goals in the face of rollbacks from the federal administration. We appreciate CARB working diligently to finish its regulatory process as quickly as possible to provide market certainty and ensure California will combat climate change at the pace, scale, and level of ambition this moment demands.
While the twenty thirty goals of a 40% reduction is a strong start, we urge the state to push harder for greater near term reductions. We also strongly supported the transition of the gas climate credit to entirely electric and look forward to working with the legislature and CARB to ensure that this transition happens as quickly as possible to help the ratepayers with their electricity bills, which demand urgent action. We are looking forward to supporting the implementation of the strongest possible cap and invest program. Thank you.
Speaker 9
Good evening. Mike Monaghan on behalf of State Building Trades. The messaging out of California has not been very good, especially to the refinery industry. We've lost, what, two refineries in the last twelve months. I don't want to I'll be blunt about this.
This comes from our letter which went out last week. It says, if these regulations are implemented, every California based refinery will shut down. Thank you.
Speaker 28
Thank you, madam chair, members. Keith Dunne here on behalf of the district council of ironworkers as well as the state building trades. I would echo mister Monning's comments to just say there's no other groups that support, the renewable portfolios as much as the the building trades. We're remaining committed to that. We are committed to working with you.
We supported the extension of the cap and trade program and appreciated your partnership. We look forward to working with you to get this right. It's very important. Every California depends on it. Thank you.
Speaker 2
Alright. Well, thank you all again for joining us this evening. And with that, this meeting is adjourned.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.