Westminster Hall
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Westminster Hall House of Commons
Follow its sittingsJeremy Paul Wright
Order. He can see the level of interest there is in this debate. He must resume his seat when I'm standing up. We must have short interventions, please. Two or three more words and then we'll let the honourable gentleman respond.
İmran Hussein
I'm grateful, Chair. Will the honourable gentleman agree with me that the urgent need requires immediate housebuilding?
Chris Hinchliff
Absolutely, I agree. My honourable friend is absolutely right about the immediate need and I will come back to that later on in my speech. But the point I was going to make was I'm sure, and it's slightly incongruous, but I'm sure that every member in this room often visits schools in their constituency as I do. And when I see the potential in pupils like those at Little Hadham Primary School where I was last, I can't help but contemplate what future we are building for them. If that future is one in which hundreds of thousands of council homes have been built in every community, and I do mean in our most rural villages as well as our greatest cities, for people of every background, for doctors and academics, farmworkers, bus drivers, binmen and bar staff, then what our country can offer them will be far greater than the prospects adulthood currently holds.
I won't give way at this point, I think I'd better make progress. Chair, housing is by far and away the most depressing, anxiety-inducing and life-stunting part of the cost of living crisis in this country, and the price of rent or a mortgage leaves millions struggling to make the bills add up at the end of the month and millions more only just staying afloat with little left over to experience life's other possibilities.
If we build enough council housing, end the years and years wasted on waiting lists, ensure every child has somewhere safe to learn and play, and also make it a normal part of life again, providing an anchor on housing costs for our whole society, then our economy, society and culture will be very much healthier than they are today. Let us briefly imagine a boy or girl in a primary school classroom today. If when they reach adulthood they are able to begin an independent life without shelling out upwards of a third or even half of their salary for a roof over their heads, imagine what this would mean for our high streets, coffee shops, pubs, clubs, bars and restaurants. In a future with plentiful council housing, when genuinely affordable housing is recognised as a right of our citizens, not a rare collector's item, no one, no matter how wealthy, will be able to buy up property and charge others extortionate rents for somewhere to live. And with that model of economic vampirism finally laid to rest, billions of pounds currently sucked out of our local economies will begin to flow through our independent shops once again.
Or suppose that this young man or woman have artistic talents they want to make their contribution to our society. With our current lack of council housing, how many of us really have the opportunity to explore talents and abilities that aren't immediately able to help pay rent? With plentiful genuinely affordable homes, so that covering the cost of life's essentials is no longer such an uphill battle, who knows how many more McCartneys we might have, or Joan Armatradings, or Michaela Coels? Chair, delivering council housing is about more than just bricks and mortar. It is about unleashing lost creativity across Great Britain and re-establishing our place as the world's pre-eminent cultural superpower.
I better make progress, I'm sorry. And perhaps most importantly of all, if we succeed in delivering council housing in every community, we will achieve one of the most important steps in fighting the atomisation of our society that brings with it so many social ills. If today's children are able to put down roots wherever they are growing up, should they want to, with no need to move away in search of prospects and a home of their own, then friendships forged at school no longer need be looked back on with regret as connections that once meant the world but could not survive splintering imposed by lack of homes for the young. Similarly, if the next generation is able to grow into adulthood alongside their parents, supporting them through older life will be a natural part of everything we do, not something we struggle to find time for with the constant sense that we are left snatching for precious moments all too quickly passing by. And if our imaginary hero should fall in love and think about children of their own, if we deliver council houses now, we can hope for a future in which the choice is simply whether a couple wishes to start a family, not whether they can afford one, and parents will be able to take the time out of employment to raise their child and share all their first memories rather than living on borrowed time as bills mount up.
In short, delivering the council homes our country needs to transform our housing market will make possible a society in which all the parts of life that really matter can finally come ahead of the relentless and disproportionate financial costs of housing that we see today. How then to realise these hopes? First, building a new generation of council housing is being held back by a pile of largely fictitious debt created by central government. We cannot ask local councils to deliver the homes of tomorrow while burdened by a model that failed yesterday. Armed with even the best intentions, councils remain suffocated by housing revenue account debt, and cancelling HRA debt could deliver over 280,000 additional social rent homes in the next decade.
And to reverse decades of retreat from public housebuilding and restore the public sector as the driving force in our housing market, new funding must come with new powers for local democracy. If we recognise social housing delivers a public good, its provision cannot be put on a playing field on a level playing field with speculative land promoters looking to make a quick buck or beholden to the supposed right of wealthy landowners to inflate the value of their land to extract more from the public purse. Councils need to be able to assemble all the land we need for developments large and small, including where it is already optioned, and to acquire land at existing use prices so that council housebuilding is viable in every part of the country.
Above all, we must invest in our councils' institutional capacity to deliver the housing we need. Even with the fairest possible wind, and even if all the economically destabilizing military conflicts around the world came to a close, the truth is that if the Chancellor showered every local authority with all the funding they could want, the expertise and institutional knowledge to use it is no longer there. To deliver the council housing that every MP I suspect in this room wants to see, we need to attract the best and brightest in the country to working in our local authorities. Whether that is as an elected member or as an officer, we need to restore the standing of our underfunded, undervalued, and overworked councils so that the whole country can see that a career in local government is the most tangible route to shaping the future of our nation. From town planning to architecture, design, ecology, and construction standards, only the very best is good enough for our constituents, and local councils must be where you go to excel.
And in our determination to remove the institutional barriers holding back council house building, we can't undervalue solutions to get families out of temporary accommodation and off waiting lists now. The Prime Minister was right in his recent conference address to set out plans to take control of empty properties. We should back councils to acquire neglected and empty properties at scale. And we've seen throughout our modern history, in times of crises, our citizens are conscripted for the common good. Where housing lies dormant during an emergency, we must be willing to take the same approach to property.
In fact, the truth is, from the standing start we have inherited, where local authorities like mine haven't built a single council house in decades, new house building will take years to ramp up. But the housing crisis is a crisis that requires urgent resolution, so we must make acquisition of existing properties to rebuild our council housing stock as important a part of the government's mission as new builds. With the housing markets in the doldrums, we have a much-needed opportunity for councils to purchase and re-let at affordable rates hundreds of thousands of homes across the country to bring down waiting lists now. There are of course upfront costs, legislative hurdles, and I expect a mouthful of teething problems, but it's the bitter medicine we must take today to stop the bleeding of public money to those profiting from the broken system. Because we must never forget that the government's 39 billion pound investment in affordable social housing is dwarfed by the 70 billion pounds the government is set to spend over the next five years on housing support to subsidize the gap between the rents private landlords charge and what tenants can afford.
The need for the housing is there, we're already paying for it. The only question before us is whether we turn that spending into a lasting public asset or keep paying over and over again for failure.
Jeremy Paul Wright
I thank the honorable gentleman. Can I remind all backbench colleagues you should continue to stand up and down so we know you still want to be called. You can see there's a great deal of interest. I'm going to suggest that if we can all keep to around about two and a half minutes, we will get everybody in. And the question is that this House has considered the delivery of council housing.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Thank you very much, a real pleasure to serve on your chairmanship and a big thank you to the honorable member for North East Hertfordshire for raising what's an extremely pressing issue.
And the fact that so many honorable members are here is an indication of that. Some more than 1.3 million households in England are on the waiting list for social housing. It's been estimated it will take more than a century to clear the waiting list in England alone if the speed of delivering new social homes is delivered at the rate it's being delivered currently. For every social home delivered this year, there was an average of 110 households still waiting. And despite these shocking figures, in 20% of council areas across England, not a single social home has been built in the last two years and 30% of areas fewer than 10 have been built.
So it's a massive issue. We are seeing the effects of a lack of social housing on private rental properties. As in 2025, rents reached the highest level on record, amounting to a staggering 36.1% of average earnings. Rental accommodation out of the pocket of so many, buying a house a dream for so many as well. So what does this do?
It perpetuates a devastating cycle as wages fail to keep pace with rising living costs, including energy bills and food prices, pushing more people into poverty and increasing demand for already limited social housing. A quick perspective on Northern Ireland to add to the debate, Mr. Chairman. Northern Ireland, although social housing is supplied by the Housing Executive, they face similar issues as councils in England. And as of June this year, there were some 50,000 households on the social housing waiting list with no existing Housing Executive tenancy. For those who are already on Housing Executive properties, the wait can be long for a transfer when their needs do evolve.
In August 2026, it was estimated some almost 800 households had spent over a decade on the waiting list for transfer. So if there's a light at the end of the tunnel, it'd be great to have it, but unfortunately we're not seeing that. In rural constituencies much like mine in Strangford, it's been found that the allocations of rural social homes have not kept pace with the rising demand, which has been particularly acute as our rural areas face hidden housing need, older homes, and increased exposure to fuel poverty. This investment, Mr. Chairman, is urgently needed to end the distress. Investment in social housing, recognizing that this will indeed deliver long-term benefits.
And this investment is currently needed to end the distress and uncertainty faced by families left in limbo waiting for a home. Thank you.
Linsey Farnsworth
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship and I congratulate the honorable member for North East Hertfordshire for securing this important debate. Chair, if you track the history of council housing in Amber Valley, you'll see a story that I fear will sound all too familiar for members across this House. It's a story of decline, neglect, and short-sighted political choices whose consequences are still being felt today. In 1985, there were more than 5,000 council houses in Amber Valley.
By 2003, there was just one remaining. Why was that, Chair, you may ask? Well, during that period, a Conservative-led borough council sold off virtually the entire stock. And Chair, make no mistake, this was not because the need for affordable housing had disappeared, nor because it represented some great act of financial prudence, because to add insult to injury, these houses were sold off to private ownership at an estimated one-ninth of market value. Now, assets built up for generations, paid for by local people and intended to provide secure and affordable homes, were effectively given away.
But when Labour took control of the borough council in 2023, councillors inherited not only a shortage of council homes, but the legacy of decades in which the council's capacity to deliver had been hollowed out.
It was not just the housing stock that was gone. But as a result, the first task of facing the Labour-led Borough Council was to rebuild the council's ability to build homes. It had to restore confidence, capacity, and the mechanisms of delivery before bricks could be laid and properties acquired. Now, council officers have reskilled themselves admirably, and since 2023, 32 council houses have been acquired, with plans to deliver a further 33 in the pipeline. Now, those numbers sound modest, but they represent the hard work of rebuilding a housing programme from almost nothing.
And more importantly, the council is now in a position to look beyond individual acquisitions towards larger-scale regeneration and housebuilding. After years of stagnation, Amber Valley has adopted a local plan for the first time in two decades. And it includes proposals that could deliver up to 180 new council homes on land around Aldred's Lane, while the council is also working closely with East Midlands Mayor Claire Ward to unlock brownfield sites for future development. So now there is real momentum. A Labour-led council has begun rebuilding the stock it had lost.
So with that in mind, can the Minister outline what support the government will provide to councils such as Amber Valley that have demonstrated both the ambition and the capacity to deliver new council housing, and can he outline how the government will help authorities scale up those ambitions so that more families can access the homes that they need?
Hannah Kathrine Spencer
Thank you. Britain's housing crisis did not happen by accident. It is the direct result of political choices that place profit over people. And for decades, governments have chosen to allow the stock of genuine council housing to decline whilst expecting the private market to pick up the pieces, and it clearly hasn't. Across our region of Manchester and Tameside, 3,180 households are in temporary accommodation, including over 5,000 children.
And kids should be thinking about whether they're having their favourite meal for tea, not how they will crowd into accommodation unfit for purpose or facing the prospect of sleeping rough. And to pay for this temporary accommodation, councils have spent almost 3 billion pounds in the past year, a staggering increase of 88% in just five years. And that is money that is going straight into the pockets of private landlords, often to banks and big corporations that call property investments assets rather than homes. And I see what this means for people in Gorton, Denton, Abbey Hey, Burnage, Longsight, Levenshulme every single day. Domestic abuse survivors paying eye-watering private rents while sat on waiting lists despite being assessed as a priority.
Hard-working young people giving up on the dream of ever owning a home of their own, and elderly people who know that they will simply not be able to afford their rent once they retire. And the Green Party is clear: we need a new generation of council housing that matches the scale of the challenge before us. And that starts with putting an end to the loss of housing stock. Right to Buy has removed hundreds of thousands of homes from the social sector, which are often now being rented out by private landlords. And to be clear, I do not blame anyone who has bought their council homes.
The problem is with the policy that allowed affordable homes to be sold off without replacing them. But protecting existing stock is only part of the answer. Councils have to be given the tools and resources to build their own homes and to purchase privately owned ones as well. It means making better use of public land and helping councils acquire the hundreds of thousands of long-term empty homes that should be brought back into public use. The government can continue to kick the can down the road by spending billions to manage the ever-worsening consequences of the housing crisis, or they can invest in solving it.
My message to the Minister is simple: stop the loss of social housing, allow councils to buy homes back into public ownership, build council homes at scale, and bring empty homes back into use, introduce rent controls, and give councils the powers they need to lead the way. Because every family deserves more than a roof over their head, they deserve a place to belong, and council housing remains one of the most effective ways that government has of making this a reality.
Jeremy Paul Wright
Well done. I'll be a little more generous, allow you a whole extra 30 seconds each.
So, with three minutes, Josh Newbury.
Josh Newbury
Thank you, Sir Jeremy. I want to start by singing the praises of what we've done in my constituency, because I think Labour's record at Cannock Chase District Council shows what can be achieved when a council is ambitious about providing the homes its residents need. After more than 30 years without building new council homes, the last Labour administration, which I was proud to be part of as deputy leader, got building again. It started with the most unglamorous of sites, old garage blocks that were becoming increasingly difficult to rent out and many had turned into magnets for anti-social behaviour and drug dealing. So we turned them into new homes, filling some of the biggest gaps in our housing stock.
We also partnered with Lovell Homes to redevelop the former Aelfgar school site in Rugeley, where 58 new homes have now been delivered, including 29 council houses. The ribbon may have been cut under reform, but the groundwork was done under Labour. And that brings me to the government's plans to help councils do more, because in Cannock Chase, a lack of ambition was never the problem, finding affordable finance was. That's why I welcome the extension of preferential Public Works Loan Board rates, which will help make the numbers stack up for councils looking to invest in new homes. I also welcome the Council Housebuilding Support Fund, because councils need the right people and expertise to develop schemes, build pipelines of projects and put together strong bids for funding, something that my council found that we often missed out when councils of other similar sizes were getting funding awarded.
And I hope that my district council will make full use of that opportunity. I also want to touch on empty homes, something that two constituents have raised with me just last week. One who is concerned about the number of greenbelt sites having to be released, and another who is trying to get on the housing ladder, very much welcomed the upcoming Your First Home scheme announced by the Prime Minister, but felt that bringing empty homes back into use should also be part of the answer. So I welcome the government's boost to the powers that councils can use to tackle long-term empty properties. I'd encourage Cannock Chase District Council again to make full use of them, including with two semi-detached homes on Poplar Street in Norton Canes that have stood empty for many, many years.
I'd also be interested to hear from the Minister whether there's scope to take the number of long-term empty homes into greater account when housing targets are calculated. And finally, I welcome the government's plans to tighten right to buy, because we need to make sure that the council houses we build today remain available to people who need them well into the future. But as we make it easier for councils to build again, I hope that we can gradually work towards ending the right to buy altogether and protect that housing stock for the long term. Because that's ultimately what this debate is all about, Sir Jeremy, making sure people have access to a decent, secure and genuinely affordable home, whether that means building on a neglected garage site, regenerating a former school or bringing an empty property back into use. Cannock Chase Labour has shown that councils can deliver, and I hope the government's measures will give more councils the means and confidence to do so in future.
Perran Moon
Mr. Sir Jeremy, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. May I thank the member for North East Hertfordshire for securing this debate. The single greatest barrier to economic regeneration in Cornwall is housing insecurity and affordability. Employers can't recruit and retain, young people can't remain in their home communities, and families can't put down roots, not unless they have access to a secure, affordable home. And that's before we mention the key workers required to run civic society.
Social housing accounts for less than 13% of Cornwall's entire housing stock, compared with 17% nationally. In peak season, we have 24,000 short-term lets across the Duchy, whilst 25,000 Cornish households sit on waiting lists on the housing register. Cornwall Council has, in fairness, delivered 850 homes in the last six years through its housing revenue account and general fund, but its capacity to go further is deeply constrained. So how do we revitalize social housebuilding in Cornwall?
First, ministers must review Cornwall Council's 90 million pound HRA debt arising from 2012 self-financing settlement. The assumptions underpinning the settlement no longer reflect today's pressures and servicing that inherited debt diverts money from maintaining existing stock and rebuilding new homes. Second, councils should receive the same access to low-cost development finance as registered providers. Refinancing 52 million pound of planned development borrowing at 0.1% could save Cornwall Council 19 million over 14 years, creating up to 1.8 million in annual revenue headroom and support up to 41 million pound of additional borrowing for new homes. Thirdly, Cornwall must not be excluded from housing and investment powers because of our national minority status.
A strategic place partnership with Homes England could provide both the framework and funding needed to deliver social housing at scale. We'll never be part of a mayoral combined authority because of our national minority status and we cannot be discriminated against and locked out of that funding. I ask the ministers therefore to review the HRA debt, extend low-cost finance to councils and ensure Cornwall's immediate access to a strategic place partnership with Homes England.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Thank you Sir Jeremy, it's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair and I congratulate my honorable friend the member for North East Hertfordshire on securing this important debate. Now in Poole we have one of the widest gaps between average wages and private rents in the country and we suffer from a distinct lack of truly affordable housing for local people. House prices are 16% higher than the national figure and sit alongside rents far higher than other parts of the South West. In the period 2024 to 25 my local council built just 89 affordable homes out of a total of 988 new properties. Yet what we do have is a proliferation of luxury seafront apartments that local people are unable to afford.
No wonder then that housing is the biggest issue raised by my constituents. Just 1% of properties in Poole are affordable to rent at the local rate of housing benefit. The freeze on local housing allowance is making rents unaffordable and needs to be urgently uprated. And we need to see a system of rent controls as a step towards easing the housing crisis whilst the building begins.
Jess Brown-Fuller
I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way and he's giving an impassioned speech about Poole which is really resonating with me as the MP for Chichester because we see large-scale developments in my constituency and they are delivering four and five luxury houses that are not affordable for most people. Does he agree with me that it's the middle income earners, a lot of our frontline services workers who can't afford private rents but also earn too much to be eligible for social housing and that's why we need to see a number that the government is going to deliver of social homes across the whole country so that developers can't renege on their commitments to actually deliver the homes that we're asking for?
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Yes, I thank the honorable member for her intervention. I mean obviously there's an issue about viability and and the way in which developers use that to renege on early commitments that they've made to local authorities. There's also a key point that if we want the public sector and public services of the future, the workers who provide those services need to be able to afford to live in the area. So this is a circular argument that we need to keep making with the government. Building a new generation of council houses is therefore essential, Sir Jeremy, to ending the housing crisis.
Now the 39 billion social and affordable homes program is welcome, but it doesn't go far enough. I think the government needs to be more creative when it comes to longer-term financing of the sector. Now currently 88 billion pounds worth of UK pension funds is invested in fossil fuel companies. What better use could there be than to redirect that money into council housing? So let's be more ambitious in our growth agenda.
Let's see the council house building program as a key part of that ambition. Let's remove the historic debt from council's housing revenue accounts as other members have mentioned. Let's unlock low-cost financing for council house building, enable councils to buy land at the right price to build social rent homes and bring empty properties back to life. Let's give future generations the hope that was there after 1945 with a real housing revolution that offers everyone a place they can call home.
Caroline Jane Voaden
Thank you, Sir Jeremy. It's an honor to serve with you in the chair. South Devon is a beautiful part of the world with its stunning coastline and idyllic rural villages, but scratch the surface and you will find a severe housing crisis, one that is literally eating away at the viability of our rural and coastal communities, threatening the very fabric of village life and turning parts of it into a theme park for the rich. Wages have fallen so far out of step with housing costs that local people are just being priced out of the very communities they grew up in. I do welcome parts of the Social Housing Bill, but it simply doesn't address the mechanics that are driving this crisis.
Housing associations, they exist to provide homes for people who cannot afford to buy or rent on the open market. Yet a growing number of those homes are leaving the sector altogether. Since 2018-19, English housing associations have sold more than 25,000 social and affordable homes to private buyers and the pace is quickening. Last year's sales were the highest on record, up 89% in just two years. And in South Devon, towns like Salcombe and Dartmouth are among the most expensive places to live in the country.
Absolutely they they are full of second homes and short-term lets, but they are not just holiday destinations. Real people live there, people who grew up there, people who work there, people who keep local essential services running, and they are being priced out. One local housing association has sold 49 homes, social homes since 2022 with the biggest losses in those high-cost areas. In Kingswear, another beautiful village on the sea, more than a third of the social housing stock has vanished in just three years. The primary school has closed down and with so few affordable homes left, there's nothing to draw young families back to the area.
And when challenged, the local housing the housing association points to replacement homes that it has bought in Sherford, which is a new town on the edge of Plymouth, 30 miles away. That's no comfort to a family forced out of of Kingswear. Now set that against demand. Across the South Hams and Torbay, 3,600 homes have been built in five years. Yet more than two and a half thousand households remain in formal housing need.
And when a social rented home does come up, the competition is extreme: 119 bids for one home in Marlborough, 113 in Salcombe, and 190 bids for one home in Brixham. Even so, the council has no say when a housing association decides to sell. So the bill introduces new disposal notification requirements intended to give local authorities a better chance of acquiring homes that would otherwise leave the sector. That's a step in the right direction and I welcome it, but it's not going to work because being told a home is about to be sold is not the same as being able to do anything about it. The bill gives the council no first refusal, no priority, and no right to step in ahead of a private buyer.
And that's because most of the new homes are sold at full market price, which is far beyond the reach of those who need them.
Now, just to finish briefly, I would like to shout out Clay Park in Dartington, where a community land trust is delivering 39 energy-efficient homes, all for social rent for people with local connections. And this is absolutely what we need to see in all our villages: a few social homes in every village to keep them viable, to keep young families there, to allow older people to downsize. And we have to have the ability for community land trusts to be able to build more easily. So I ask the minister what provisions he has made in this bill to support the work of these much-valued community land trusts.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you, Sir Desmond. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I congratulate the honorable member for North East Hertfordshire for securing this vital debate. I know from years in Cornwall how big an issue the lack of affordable and council housing has become in my constituency of Truro and Falmouth. In Cornwall, the picture is stark. We have far lower levels of council housing than other parts of the country: only 11% of our stock is social housing, and the countrywide average is 18.
Cornwall's Homechoice register has over 26,000 households waiting for a home against an estimated stock of 33,000 social and affordable homes right across Cornwall. We also have 800 households in temporary and emergency accommodation. However, the Housing Revenue Account has a legacy debt of 92 million from the 2012 self-financing settlement, and that severely constrains Cornwall Council's ability to build, maintain, and deliver social housing. Cornwall housing also has very low rental income, the result of decisions made by previous Lib Dem and independent councillor administrations. Bringing rents closer to national levels through rent convergence will take time, and the lack of income from low rents has resulted in a backlog of repairs that they're really struggling to get on top of.
The government's extra billion for social and affordable homes program and the preferential rates for council house borrowing are very welcome, as are the safeguards in the Social Housing Bill, for example on rights to buy on new builds. We have housing associations in Cornwall that are strategic providers working hard to build and provide homes in Cornwall, but our HRA struggles with its debt and repairs and has no headroom to borrow. HRA reform will be crucial if we're to build council homes in Cornwall, as will making it easier for HRAs to borrow.
John Milne
Thank you, Sir Desmond. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I thank the honorable member for bringing this debate. In my constituency of Horsham, the council stock was long ago sold off to Saxon Weald Housing Association, and they do a pretty good job. For years, during a series of Tory administrations, there was little interest on the council in building any more. So I applaud the current Lib Dem-led council for their recent announcement of 22 new homes for social rent.
It's a start, at least. However, the truth is that having the will isn't enough; you also need the means. And in this context, the government's main housing strategy, the standard method for allocating local targets, is having a destructive effect.
It didn't work for the Tory government and it's not working for Labour either. There's a new Horsham District Local Plan passing through the system right now, but it's simply not possible for an authority in an area like mine to require the provision of large amounts of social housing, or indeed any. The subsidy system, based on S106, Section 106 taxes, doesn't generate nearly enough. And that means that councillors can't set a guaranteed percentage of homes for social rent in the plan, even if they want to. Such a plan would be ruled unsound by the inspector because it's financially undeliverable.
And that is exactly what happened to me when I was cabinet member for planning a few years ago. Because Horsham ranks as a relatively affluent area, we're not in line for government subsidies. So ironically, the very locations that face the highest housing costs are precisely those least likely to get any government investment support. We have a system designed to deliver cheap housing in areas that on average have more cheap housing. The government obsession with counting permissions instead of actual real-life houses has directly undermined Horsham's ability to deliver low-cost housing.
Unfeasibly high targets force the council to accept developer proposals which are optimized for quantity, not affordability. The reality is that private developers are principally in control of choosing the sites, councils merely edit them. In an area like Horsham where most of the district is farmland, the market drives developers to buy up green spaces on the edge of existing settlements. The result is a strong incentive towards suburban house building, which by its nature tends to poorer affordability and wasteful land use. At the same time we have a construction industry trapped in a boom-and-bust cycle.
The absence of consistent local authority house building makes it much harder to bring in low-cost models, such as modern modular construction, because that depends on a continued reliable delivery pipeline. And that's one reason why a company like Legal & General, which bravely invested in this market, was forced to close its modular arm a few years ago. But whatever the government decides to do, some change, further change of policy is necessary. So I hope the Minister will be honest with himself and realize that the current trajectory is not going to solve anyone's problem in any reasonable length of time. Thank you.
Speaker 25
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And thank you to the member for North East Herts for securing this debate. Norwich was there at the birth of social housing. One hundred years ago, Norwich built its first council house on Angel Road, and shortly after came the Mile Cross estate, one of the first of its kind. And by the 1970s, our city had a higher proportion of council housing than any other in the country.
And Labour in Norwich kept that delivery. We delivered Goldsmith Street, 105 council homes built to Passivhaus standards, the first council housing project to win the RIBA Stirling Prize. The old Mile Cross depot in my constituency, where a Labour council planned and funded 67 new council homes for rent, with more on the full site. And Anglia Square, for so many years it has stood there not developed. And it was a Labour government that came in that gave the funding to a Labour city council to unlock that site that we are now able to get the building going and delivering 1,100 homes with a commitment that at least 50% of those will be affordable, with many at social rent.
And I want to pay tribute to the former Labour council leaders, including Mike Stonard, Alan Waters, Brenda Arthur, and Steve Morphew for their work on this, for driving that vision forward, and Carli Harper-Penman, our candidate for mayor, who has put housing at the center of her campaign to be Norfolk and Suffolk mayor. And that's what delivery looks like, but it isn't finished. We have to do much more to ensure that the council homes my constituents need are delivered. Since May, the Green Party has run Norwich City Council, and I want them to succeed, not to squander the Labour's legacy on housing. So my message is simple.
Almost 4,000 households in Norwich are waiting for a home. These aren't statistics, they are people who've done everything right and are still waiting. So what needs to happen? First, investment, and I welcome the government's 39 billion pound program for social and affordable homes. I declare an interest as the chair of the East of England housing delivery group.
See those schemes through, don't let them slip, and don't dilute them, because the need is real.
The East of England as a whole is expected to deliver 227,000 homes to support the government's targets over the course of this parliament. But if we are to do that, we must get our fair share of investment. And houses do not build themselves, so we need to make sure that we have the skills in the pipeline to deliver them and to accelerate the construction. And our need for homes must be recognized as urgent. Secondly, as many other people have said, I welcome the decision to let councils keep their right to buy receipts.
That will make a huge difference. Thirdly, quality. It isn't enough to build homes, they have to be good ones. People in council houses deserve very high quality homes, like the ones that Norwich Labour built on Goldsmith Street. But too many constituents still contact me with concerns about the quality of housing.
Fourth, homes must be eco-friendly. As I've said before, Goldsmith Street proves that warm, low-energy homes which tenants can afford aren't a luxury, they're what council housing should be, and every new council home we build should be built to the same ambition. And fifth, community. Mile Cross worked a century ago because it was never just about housing, it was also about community, and that was celebrated so beautifully by the Common Lot in 2023 at its centenary. Because a home is only as good as what surrounds it: the bus that turns up, the GP you can book, the school within walking distance, the park, the shop on the corner.
And when we build homes, we have to build that community too. In Norwich, Norwich Labour still believes that, and I know Labour in government believes that, so we have to keep building to deliver the council homes that so many people still desperately need.
Ayoub Khan
I thank the honourable member for North East Hertfordshire for securing this debate and for presenting a very persuasive argument. One of the biggest casework inquiries I get in my constituency of Birmingham Perry Barr is around housing and the shortage of housing. Birmingham being one of the largest councils, in fact the largest council in Europe, has an enormous chronic housing issue. Just in terms of stats, when we look at West Midlands as a region, we have 7,500 homeless families living in temporary accommodation, 15,000 children living in temporary accommodation. Now that's not just having an impact on those families, it's actually having an impact on those children, often which are living many miles away from their school and parents struggling to maintain their job because they have to escort their children to school.
So it's having a dramatic effect on our future generations, and of course Birmingham is the youngest community in terms of age group, and so I really fear the impact a lack of affordable homes is going to have on our next generation. There are 65,000 families waiting on the social housing waiting list. Now I'm sure the minister will say that the regional West Midlands regional authority has received somewhere in the region of 400 million pounds to develop and build 3,000 additional homes, and of course that's welcome. But when you contrast the numbers, it really is a drop in the ocean as to the requirements. Now of course there's also going to be private developers, but one of the biggest issues that I see and my constituents feel is that it's not just about building homes anywhere just to meet the quota.
It's about building communities and ensuring that you have the right infrastructure: GP surgeries, medical care facilities, and local shopping centers.
So it's a whole infrastructure that needs to be thought of. And so in terms of planning, which is another big issue, because the Labour government often says we champion devolution, localization, we want local people involved in decision making. But Birmingham is being asked to be anti-devolution because powers, planning powers are sought to be given to the regional mayor. Now, if that happens, it really does take away that community on the ground that wants homes where they fulfill all the criteria. So can I ask the minister quickly, because I know we're limited for time.
We had the Perry Barr village developed at the taxpayer's cost of 700 million pounds. 350 million pound is a loss to the taxpayer because it was sold to Legal & General. Would he inquire into what has happened with that loss of 350 to Birmingham taxpayers? Thank you, Chair.
Amanda Martin.
Amanda Martin
Thank you, Sir Jeremy. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I want to thank the honorable member for bringing this debate. I want to speak up for Portsmouth today, a city that at its peak had 27,000 homes, council homes, and now has less than 16,000. Our city is in the grip of a housing crisis with too many people struggling to find a secure and affordable home. We have a waiting list of almost 3,000 households with almost 50% of those being exceptional or urgent priority.
Yet in 2024-25, Portsmouth built just 40 new homes. Not 40 social homes, 40 new homes in total. And in the same period, only 15 units for social rent were added to the council stock, with just six more being started. Behind these figures, Sir Jeremy, are families waiting for a home, young people struggling to find somewhere they can afford, and residents facing the insecurity of unaffordable rent or moving from temporary accommodation to temporary accommodation. I know personally what a council home means.
I grew up in one, and many of my aunties, uncles, and my own parents were born and lived in council housing. For my family, it meant stability, security, and the opportunity to build a future. Council housing is more than bricks and mortar. It gives people a foundation in life, a community, and a place to call home, and every family deserves one. That is why I'm proud this Labour government has committed to the biggest increase in social and affordable housing in a generation.
We're invigorating council house building and taking action to protect existing social housing, but that national ambition must translate into homes on the ground in Portsmouth. More families need the security I experienced growing up in a safe, affordable home and the chance to build a better future. Cannock Chase and indeed historical Norwich Council has shown what can be achieved when a council creates opportunity, and I commend their vision. Portsmouth should be looking at what works elsewhere and looking at how we can do that in my city. So I ask the minister, will he meet with me to discuss what practical support the government can provide to help Portsmouth Council overcome barriers to planning, building, developing derelict sites, regenerating empty homes, and unlocking investment to deliver council houses, social rented homes, because my residents desperately need it.
Chris Kane
Portsmouth City Council must act. My residents cannot afford to wait any longer to have a secure place to call home.
Thank you. I want to bring a Scottish perspective to this. In May 2024, the Scottish Parliament declared a national housing emergency. That was a significant admission, but declaring an emergency isn't the same as resolving one. More than two years later, the figures make uncomfortable reading.
Across Scotland, more than 10,000 children are living in temporary accommodation. That's the highest number on record. There are almost 35,000 open homelessness cases, which is also a record high. And last year, there were over 21,000 recorded incidents where local authorities failed to offer temporary accommodation to households entitled to it, an increase by almost a third. These figures come from the Scottish government's own statistics, and a couple more out just this morning.
Housing is a constant feature of my constituency casework. We hear from families in overcrowded homes and people living in unsuitable accommodation. Most express a lack of confidence they'll ever find something appropriate to live. As a former council leader, I know that providing good council housing takes more than ambition, it takes resources and power, something that this Labour government is looking to devolve to local communities in England, but in Scotland the SNP are centralising rather than devolving powers. I've seen what can be achieved when these things come together because Stirling has been ranked first in the UK for rooftop solar installations relative to households.
Speaker 28
Housing statistics for Scotland say house building has fallen by 8% in the last year, and at the same time, we have over 10,000 council houses all sitting vacant, often through lack of funds and people to bring them back into use.
Chris Kane
I believe our long-running program of installing solar panels on council houses contributed significantly to that achievement. Success of council administrations investing in improving housing stock, helping tenants with energy costs while delivering environmental benefits. I also want to highlight housing's importance to rural economies. Stirling Council has recently allocated UK government funding towards new houses in Tyndrum at the northern end of my constituency. Local tourism businesses tell me they struggle to recruit staff because prospective employees cannot find affordable accommodation.
If a hotel or restaurant cannot recruit because workers have nowhere to live, housing becomes an economic issue as well as a social one. In small rural communities, even a handful of new affordable homes can make an enormous difference, but much more needs to be done. I welcome the UK government's commitment to increasing council and social house building in England. There are lessons though to share across the United Kingdom because devolution should never mean we stop learning from one another. Ultimately, the test of housing policy isn't how many targets we announce, strategies we publish or emergencies we declare, it's about how many families finally receive the keys to a safe, secure and affordable home.
And for far too many of my constituents, that day feels still too distant. And if I can finish with a little bit of history, it pains me to admit that Scotland's first pioneering council housing development was in Dundee rather than in my constituency of Stirling. But I was fascinated to discover that even before these Stirling houses were occupied in May 1920, the Commons was debating their affordability. In April 1920, Labour MP Alexander Wilkie questioned the Secretary of Scotland about rents which threatened to price out the very working people their homes were intended to help. More than a century later, we're still grappling with that same fundamental challenge about providing good homes that people can afford.
Lee Pitcher
Thank you, Sir Jeremy, it's indeed a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Council housing saved my family's life. Council housing gave me a life. Council housing meant a once homeless lad actually got to be here to fight for everybody to ensure that they were never any homelessness in this country again. So Minister, when we talk about council housing delivery, most people think about building from scratch, but there are other options.
Buying and refurbing existing long-term empty houses or buildings means we can increase our housing stock at a lower cost and crucially we can do it faster. When we talk about housing, it's easy to think primarily about the housing market, the economic impacts, the cost of mortgages or rents or the cost of living, but we're also talking about whether people have a permanent home or whether not. When we talk about homelessness, we often think first about rough sleeping, yet homelessness takes many forms and family homelessness can't be overlooked. This is often not on the streets, it's whole families with children living on one mattress at a friend or relative's house, as I did at 15 years old, or moving between a series of B&Bs and other emergency supposedly temporary accommodation that can be lasting for years. And because it's not visible, because we don't see the impact, we often don't treat it with the urgency it deserves.
At the end of March this year, there were 177,530 children living in temporary accommodation in England. In Doncaster in 2025, we had over 200 children living without a permanent home over their heads. Perhaps even more concerning is that over 22,000 families with children have been living in temporary accommodation for between two and five years. For children, that could be the majority of some of their lives. Over 7,800 active households are on the register in Doncaster right now.
Now, that insecurity of not having a place that's permanent over your head can be devastating. It affects children's education, their physical and mental health, their relationships, and their opportunities later in life. A permanent home is about so much more than having somewhere to sleep. It's about having somewhere you belong. And I can absolutely vouch for that, having had lived experience.
There are more than 300,000 long-term empty homes across England. Acquiring long-term empty houses for social housing could deliver more than 8,000 additional social rented homes by June 2029, requiring 38% less government grant per property than new build alternatives. That means more homes for the same level of investment, and it means families in them much more quickly. When we have families spending years in temporary accommodation, we cannot afford to overlook opportunities to deliver permanent homes much more quickly. And it makes sense financially.
Councils are spending billions each year on temporary accommodation. Investing in permanent housing can reduce our reliance on those arrangements. Ultimately, the success of our housing programs must be measured not just in the number of homes delivered, but in the number of families who are able to leave homelessness behind and build secure, stable lives in the future. We need to deliver those homes, and we need to deliver them as fast as we possibly can.
Joseph Ronald Morris
Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's a pleasure as always to serve under your chairmanship. In my constituency, speaking across the span of one of England's largest constituencies, housing, or the lack of it, is one of the main drivers to my constituency surgeries. It's one of the main drivers of people in desperate need of a place to call home, as my honorable friend has just very movingly set out. It's an issue that needs to be taken far more seriously, not just in this place, but across the country.
And I think the particular lack of access to affordable and social housing in some of our most rural communities is something that's escaped a lot of the national debate in recent years. Unfortunately, and I say the Morpeth Conservatives who run Northumberland County Council are currently engaged in what I can only describe as an ongoing misinformation exercise about the impact of trying to provide more housing. It's very clear to me that what's needed across Northumberland is appropriate development of homes that are needed to allow people to build lives and build communities, to keep those communities together and functioning, but also to provide the long-term stability to young people growing up in those communities to know that they'll be able to have a life where they've grown up should they wish to, rather than growing up with their noses pressed at the windows of communities that they won't ever be able to be a part of because they won't be able to get a home there. So I won't keep colleagues standing for too long, but I think the crucial thing from where I stand is delivering those homes in an area in areas where people can have access to them, where they are able to be rented at a reasonable at a reasonable rate, but crucially that they are not removed from circulation and that they are accessible to local people in order to work in the pubs, in the shops, in businesses that keep the lifeblood of our communities moving. Because without them, we will continue to see younger people forced out of rural communities, forced to leave their families, forced to be unable to care for their elderly relatives.
Speaker 31
And that's something that I see come up far too often, time and time again, in my regular constituency surgeries.
Jeremy Paul Wright
Thanks very much, and I make the backbenchers for their cooperation and discipline. We come now to the frontbench speeches, beginning with the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Andrew George.
Andrew George
And thank you, Mr. Chair.
And I warmly congratulate the honorable member for North East Hertfordshire not only for securing the debate but also the usual powerful and also thoughtful way in which he commenced the debate. And indeed I also congratulate all of the other 14 or 15 members who contributed. I can't disagree with any of the points which were made very, very powerfully by all of those. And I do hope that the minister is indeed listening. I should start by declaring an interest.
I'm a member of the Cornwall Rural Housing Association and was a past chief executive and now voluntary board member of the Cornwall Community Land Trust which is a registered provider of affordable homes across Cornwall and indeed on the Isles of Scilly. And I noticed that not only were we debating the issue of council housing but we were straying into questions about the integrity of the planning and development system which of course is critical to delivering the biggest house building program which the government has promised because it's quite clear that in many parts of the country house building has indeed stalled and particularly when we're talking about social and affordable homes.
Jess Brown-Fuller
I thank my honorable friend for giving way. One of the issues we've seen in my constituency is developers trying to renege on their commitment to delivering the social and affordable homes that they originally outlined citing viability assessments. They then would rather pay something called a commuted sum, in effect a fine, which doesn't actually then go on to deliver the social homes at scale. Does he agree with me that the minister should be taking away and looking at the way that the commuted sum is assessed so we don't lose the opportunity to see social homes delivered?
Andrew George
Indeed I welcome that contribution. Indeed there are many ways in which I believe that ministers need to look at the way in which the whole system, I mean our housing and planning system operates almost as if local needs were an inconvenient afterthought. And despite tinkering at the edges successive governments have left the planning system which still rewards land value speculators more than council or indeed charitable housing providers, puts developer profit which can be set at 20% on all developments when they're undertaking valuation of developments before affordable homes and turns a blind eye to the transfer of thousands of homes intended for permanent occupancy to be added to property investment portfolios for recreational and holiday use as second homes. I wanted to also just to reflect on the speeches that obviously my two neighbors the members for Truro and Falmouth and Camborne and Redruth spoke in the debate and I just wanted to put on record my strong support for the case they made for investment in Cornwall's desperately needed social and affordable housing stock as well. The announcement this week for further investment in social and affordable homes which I'm sure the minister will repeat is of course welcome on top of the 39 billion in the social and affordable homes program which was announced last year.
But this is dwarfed by billions of taxpayers' money which is gifted through various tax reliefs and loopholes and private capital driving investment into in my part of the world holiday lets created when local tenants are evicted to make way for such investment.
It's bad enough that such tax subsidies are granted at all, but not all of this, which is what local authorities are obliged to grant, are compensated for by Treasury, thus contributing to a growing black hole in local government finance leading to cuts in essential local services. I'm bound to take this opportunity, Mr Chair, to draw attention to the fact that I was very fortunate in the private members' bill ballot and indeed have my Homes and Planning Bill coming before Parliament on Friday the 13th of November. And I hope that all those who've spoken in this debate and their colleagues will be coming along to support this bill as it stands a good chance of being enacted and indeed provides the tools for which the government and their local communities can deliver the kind of affordable homes which we've been talking about and are desperately needed today. Our housing system is a shameful display of just how widening inequality in this country is. We need to better understand why the planning and housing policies of successive governments have failed.
Planning policies are, as the honourable member for North East Hertfordshire articulately put, based on house building targets, but have not delivered. Policy designers seem to have overlooked that house building targets are after all merely a means to an end, the end being of course to meet housing need. My own territory of Cornwall is a classic example where the policy has failed. It's one of the fastest growing places in the United Kingdom, indeed it's almost trebled its stock in the last 60 years, and yet over that period of time the housing problems of local people, as you've heard from my neighbours, have got worse. So we know that actually simply having house building, particularly if it's the wrong type and is simply for wealthy people and for investment purposes, doesn't actually help to meet housing needs.
The government housing policy, successive government housing policy to be fair, is based on a delusion that private developers are prepared to collude with government to drive down the price of their finished product. Local authorities should be given the option to set targets to meet need rather than simply told to go out and to build homes and to allow those to go ahead. Indeed what the government have done is to make matters worse. I'm sure it was done for the best intentions, perhaps ministers became, as the honourable member for North East Hertfordshire implied, sidetracked or distracted or obsessed with facing down anti-development NIMBYs, quite rightly of course they should, that they didn't consider that imposing unachievable house building targets overnight on local authorities might in fact become counterproductive because local authorities suddenly found themselves 18 months ago unable to demonstrate that they'd carefully identified and consulted on the sufficient five-year land supply. And as a result of that, development opportunities on the edges of our communities, instead of being able to be delivered under a rural exceptions policy for affordable homes, are now being granted by planning inspectors because there isn't a five-year land supply for unaffordable homes.
And so we lose that opportunity, it's been totally counterproductive. So the purposes for example of my private members' bill are to give communities the right to buy, so a community asset then becomes a land or buildings which could help that community deliver affordable homes, so community-led housing of the type that my honourable friends for South Devon for example have talked about, and also to give new planning limits on second and holiday homes. So you have to apply for planning permission to convert a property from permanent to holiday or second occupancy. And that is something which I would hope that government-supporting members would support on the 13th of November and come along and support that bill because at the present time the housing minister, who's obviously not here because he's supporting, he's engaged in the Social Housing Bill, which is obviously very relevant to our debate today, has indicated that he is currently unable to support that bill. So we have a debate on our hands.
Now the Liberal Democrats would increase the building of new and affordable and social homes and we would make sure on a number of fronts to make homes warmer and cheaper and to to heat with a 10-year emergency upgrade program to ensure that all new homes are zero carbon pass control of right to buy to local authorities who will be enabled to vary discounts based on local need as a or as a last resort to suspend the right altogether. And indeed in view of time I won't list all of the policies that would deliver the utopia that a Liberal Democrat government would undoubtedly deliver as far as housing is concerned. But I would urge urge the minister that particularly as we still have the vehicle of of the social housing bill in committee at the moment to take heed to what his colleagues have said to him this afternoon and to accept amendments to improve that bill. Thank you Mr. Chair.
Jeremy Paul Wright
Thank you. And in the interest of order we should probably make it clear that other private members bills are available. And I call the shadow minister Sarah Bool.
Sarah Bool
Thank you Sir Jeremy. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and to take part in this debate about the delivery of council housing. And it is a very important topic and I do thank the member for North East Hertfordshire for securing this debate. Building more homes is a critical mission for anyone governing England and Wales today making the dream of home ownership a reality for even more hardworking families. With a record number of people homeless 177,530 children in temporary accommodation and 49,120 adult households also in temporary accommodation clearly the priority must be to build more council homes.
That is what the opposition wants to see however that is what the government is currently failing to do. Now let's just take a look at the government's own data. Just 208,600 net additional dwellings were added in England in Labour's first year of power a 6% drop from 23-24 during the last Conservative government's final year in office. Of these 190,600 were more were new homes a fall of 8,000 around 4% on 23-24. Taken together the government is on track to build around 400,000 fewer homes than it promised at the election meaning yet another broken promise made to the British people.
And the government knows this. The minister's boss the Secretary of State admitted this on national media. Now this poor showing on homes directly impacts the pressing issue we are debating today which is the delivery of council housing. Now we heard the Prime Minister's proudly making his summer promise of the comeback of the council house. But what little details we do know on that policy shows that the money he is earmarked would equal just 15,494 homes a year barely 5% of the government's annual housing target.
This is an exchange for another 79 billion pounds added to the housing subsidy bill despite the fact that the UK already spends the most on housing allowances as a percentage of GDP of any OECD country. Now one might have been forgiven for thinking that the aptly titled social housing bill introduced earlier this year might have been the answer to get local authorities the government industry and the nation building again.
However, as is becoming a theme in this government, we are left severely disappointed by the reality. The government have presented a bill to the House that fails to build a single new council house. Instead of making social and affordable housing sites viable and pushing developments through the pipeline at pace, as the government loves to use that phrase, to get people off the street and help children into permanent homes, the government has chosen to use up parliamentary, governmental, and civil service time on an ideological assault on right to buy. It is a shameful course of action and far from what the 1.34 million people on the social housing waitlist need. Even worse is that this government itself known, themselves know that this social housing bill will not deliver new homes.
According to data from the minister's own impact assessment, in 2026-27, the pre-November 2024 baseline was 8,050 right to buy sales leading to 5,450 replacement homes. The document goes on to show that if this bill were to pass and the legacy impacts were to wind down in the period of 2031 to 2035, annual right to buy sales would fall to around 1,100 a year with around 1,450 replacement homes. That means that by their own analysis and admission, the government will be overseeing a housing system in which there would be 4,000 fewer new social homes funded every year. Moreover, research conducted by the House of Lords library shows that only a net 3% of social homes become available each year to new tenancies. That means that around 90 additional homes will be available for a new tenant each year instead of 5,000.
The bill not only sees no new homes built, but it also actively prevents them being delivered. The government really must refocus its efforts on building more council housing, and that requires serious reforms to the viability of sites for social and affordable homes. We are halfway through a parliament in which we've spent much time debating the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025, various updates to the National Policy Planning Policy Framework, and the aforementioned bill. Yet after all of this, we are still left without a clear route to building more homes, and projections from the government themselves show that they've managed to build just 26% of their target in 50% of the time. So what would it, I'll give way.
Speaker 25
I thank her for giving way. I just wondered, obviously we are in government now, but I wondered if she was going to give any reflections on her party's policies in terms of not letting councils keep right to buy receipts or the fact that I think it was nearly 200,000 homes were lost in in one decade under the Conservatives.
Sarah Bool
I thank the the member for her intervention. Of course, it is always absolute and important to reflect on any of the legacies, but what we've got to be doing here is talking about the here and now and, rightly as has been said, this government is in control. It has brought forward a social housing bill which is supposed to unlock this system, and yet it isn't doing that. So I think the questions should be directed to the minister about how they are actually going to achieve this and actually unlock the potential that everyone in this room wants to see. This is why what we've proposed as Conservative Party in terms of the importance on house building is that actually what we want to see is taking £50,000 off the cost of building a new home in England and Wales by cutting back on regulations and taxes.
By backing a genuinely brownfield first approach to see new homes being built on the existing 1.41 million sites viable for development, and building, not blocking, a genuine council house comeback and supporting aspiration. So I call on the minister, I will just, I'll come, I'm nearly there at conclusion, so I'll just conclude. I call on the minister to commit to changing the social housing bill to back the delivery of council housing and to help bringing the shocking number of people in temporary accommodation down. That is the only way to see more council houses built, to see more people into safe and affordable accommodation, and to get Britain building. Thank you.
Speaker 40
Thank you, Mr. Wright. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I'd like to congratulate the honorable member for North Hertfordshire on securing this important debate on the delivery of council housing. I appreciate his passion for the subject following the debate he brought forward on the provision of council housing in September of last year. I'd also like to thank all members who've taken part in this debate and for the rich contributions that have been made, really reflecting the challenges that exist across the country.
There are nearly 180,000 children in temporary accommodation in this country, over 1.3 million households on local authority housing registers, and members across the House will agree that we cannot allow this to continue because behind every one of those statistics is a person, a family, and a child. The Secretary of State, the Housing Minister, and all of government is clear on our resolve and our intention to tackle this issue and that councils have a leading role to play. Under the leadership of the Prime Minister, the government is committed to delivering the biggest council house building program since the postwar period. This level of our ambition is necessary because of the scale of the challenge we are facing. This government is removing barriers and backing councils to use all of the levers at their disposal to deliver safe and decent homes at a scale not seen for decades.
We have taken decisive steps to improve councils' financial resources, capacity, and capability to invest in new and existing homes, and the Social and Affordable Homes Programme funding is putting councils at the heart of that delivery. This is the biggest long-term investment in social and affordable homes in recent memory. Initial allocations under this program were announced in August, and for the first time, three councils outside of London, Newcastle, Eastleigh, and Cambridge, were awarded strategic partnership status, and the GLA has offered allocations of at least £6 billion to providers of social and affordable housing, with 60% going to local councils. There is over 21... Yeah, give way.
Alex Sobel
Thank you, Alex. Leeds is the largest local authority in England, and we have 27,000 households on the waiting list for council housing, 5,000 which are in priority need. So many of my constituents come to me saying they just can't afford private rented homes. The main issue is there is just not enough council housing. I welcome the government saying we're building more houses, but there needs to be specific help for Leeds, both more funding for land remediation and purchasing city center developments which are unoccupied or under-occupied.
What additional support can the government provide for this type of housing?
Speaker 40
Well, obviously, Leeds is ambitious for its city, and it's of course a key member of the West Yorkshire Combined Authority, and they're doing a lot of work actually not just on housing, but how they're bringing forward brownfield sites in particular through growth funding, infrastructure funding to make sure that, as many members have said, the housing goes alongside that wider community infrastructure. But in addition to the social, the funding that I've just mentioned, there is over £21 billion still to allocate, which will be prioritized for social homes and particularly for council homes. This reflects our commitment to increasing council house delivery. To further improve financial capacity and deliver new supply and invest in existing homes, we have committed to a 10-year social housing rent policy with a convergence mechanism. This gives councils much-needed certainty on their income to enable them to increase and manage their housing portfolios efficiently and effectively.
Yeah.
Jim Shannon
Jim Shannon. I thank you for that, and also that I think we do need to remember that the government is committed to building a large, a million-plus social homes over the next period of time. In Northern Ireland, the house prices are rising by a greater rate than anywhere else in the United Kingdom consistently in the last 12 months of the year. Housing rents are also going up.
So with that, could I ask the minister please, would he share the government's strategy to address the issue of the need for social housing with the relevant minister in Northern Ireland to ensure that we can learn something from the process that government's putting forward?
Speaker 40
I think he makes a very good point about different approaches across the UK and actually how we can all learn from each other on what works and learn in perhaps some areas where it didn't go quite as planned. I'll make sure that I pass that on to the housing minister to have those conversations across government. We've also provided greater certainty on future costs associated with a decent home standard and the minimum energy efficiency standards and allocated over a billion pounds through the Warm Homes Social Housing Fund to improve the energy efficiency of social homes. And quality matters, as rightly outlined by the honorable member for Norwich North and Cannock Chase in the debate today. In addition to revenue, we know how important borrowing and capacity to borrow is for councils in terms of delivery.
Since 2023, a preferential borrowing rate has been available from the Public Works Loan Board for council house building. This rate will be extended and will be announced in more details in due course. We're continuing to work closely with councils and the wider sector to understand remaining barriers to council house building and investment, including the impact of the housing revenue account debt and borrowing rates. We've also increased the threshold at which councils must open a housing revenue account from 200 homes to 1,000 homes. This has enabled smaller councils to deliver more homes without incurring the additional operating costs.
We've also heard from councils that workforce shortages, skills gaps, and capacity pressures will constrain their ability to build. This is why we're investing a further 46 million pound over the next three years through the capacity to build funding on top of the 17 million pound already invested since 2025. This will help councils develop an ambitious pipeline, strengthen specialist housing capacity, and make the most of the government's wider investment in council house building. And these are gaps that have been identified in members in the debate today, including from Camborne and Redruth, from Hexham, from Portsmouth North, and Furrow and Falmouth in the debate. Finally, we're taking decisive action to reform the Right to Buy scheme, which has acted as a brake on council confidence to invest on new social housing for too long.
We're reforming the scheme to ensure that more homes are built than lost while maintaining an important route for social housing tenants to own their own home, as mentioned in the debate by the member for Amber Valley earlier on. My honorable friend the housing minister is at this very moment in the bill committee debating the detail of our reforms. The Social Housing Bill builds on the reforms to cash discount we implemented in 2024 to ensure that more social homes are protected while removing powerful disincentives to build. Notably, we're tightening the eligibility requirement and exempting newly built social housing from the scheme for 35 years to ensure that homes are not sold before councils have recovered their investment.
Ayoub Khan
I thank the minister for giving way. The minister's obviously heard me talk about 400 million pound being invested through the regional authority for 3,000 homes. Contrast that with more than 700 million that was invested taxpayers' money into the Perry Barr athletes' village, which was then sold at a loss to the taxpayer of 350 million. Can the minister assure that this matter will be investigated?
Speaker 40
Well, I'm hesitant about getting into the rights and wrongs of individual programs at a local authority level, and he and I have had many conversations about Birmingham City Council in the past, and I'm sure that will continue. But the matter here today is how does central government ensure that we have the framework, the incentives, and the funding to get councils building council homes and social homes in their area. In addition, we've enabled councils to retain 100% of receipts from the Right to Buy sales and provided greater flexibility on how those receipts can be used.
This includes permitting councils to combine receipts with grant funding to unlock capacity for house building. These measures are already bearing fruit. Councils delivered around 10,600 homes in 2024-25, which is the highest level since current records began in 1991-92. Our package of right to buy reforms is estimated to deliver a net gain of around 18,000 social homes over the next 10 years, compared to a pre-reform baseline of a loss of 26,000 homes. On empty homes, which was mentioned by the honourable member from Doncaster East in the debate, we are strengthening powers to bring empty homes back into use by reforming the empty dwellings management orders.
We are reducing the period a property must be empty for before it becomes eligible from two years to six months under that program. Now, we know that we must go further and we know that we must go faster to deliver the good quality and affordable homes that people need. And we also know that councils share that ambition too. This government is committed to backing councils to build at a scale not seen for decades and to build the right homes in the right places. This government will continue to work with all levels of local government and regional government to turn that ambition into homes and to better outcomes for local people.
So that everyone across the country has access to a home that is decent, that is secure and affordable.
Jeremy Paul Wright
I'm grateful to the minister. There is time if the honourable gentleman who proposed this debate wishes to wind it up. I'm happy to call him again, Chris Hinchliff.
Chris Hinchliff
Thank you, Sir Jeremy. Just very, very briefly, I want to thank all of the members for taking part in the debate today. It was a wide-ranging and passionate debate, so thanks to everyone for their contributions. I note that the minister didn't quite answer the one question I left him with, which was about what what number of council houses the government is projecting to to achieve. A quick search on my phone during the debate suggested that 47,000 council houses were built in 1979, which I suspect might be where most of us would suggest the post-war period came to an end.
So I would be genuinely interested to know if that's the figure that the government is aiming for, something like that per year. But but to conclude more generally, Sir Jeremy, I think there are two key points I would like the minister to take away from the debate today. Firstly, that we must move away from a failed housing delivery model in this country where we've seemed to accept for a long time that that we can only afford to build unaffordable homes. It's been a ludicrous failure and we must put an end to it. And secondly, we've heard so many times in this debate about the 1.3 million people on waiting lists in this country, the nearly 180,000 children in temporary accommodation.
I think it must be one of the most important yardsticks by which this government measures itself. That by the time we come to the next next general election, those figures are not just no longer rising, but they have very substantially fallen. Thank you.
Jeremy Paul Wright
I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman and to all who have spoken. The question therefore is that this house has considered the delivery of council housing. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.
Order, order, we will suspend until 4 o'clock.
Order. I will call Carla Lockhart to move the motion and I will then call the Minister to respond. Can I remind all other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission both from the member in charge of the debate and from the Minister. And there will not, I'm afraid, be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up as is the convention for shorter debates. I call Carla Lockhart to move the motion.
Carla Lockhart
Mr. Chairman, I beg to move that this House has considered domestic farming and food supply. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Hunt. Tomorrow, the Chancellor will stand at the dispatch box and tell us what this government intends to do for the economy. Before those decisions are finalized, I want to make the case for the people who put food on our tables. Because whatever ministers say about supporting working people, farming families have every reason to feel that they have been singled out.
I know personally how hard farmers work. I know the hours, the worry, and the sacrifices needed to keep a farm functioning.
There is precious little spare money on many farms and certainly no shortage of bills. Yet this government seems to look at a farm valuation and see a pot of money waiting to be taxed. It shows very little understanding of how farming actually works. Agriculture, I get it is devolved, I recognize that and I've plenty to say about the decisions being taken at Stormont, but inheritance tax, trade policy and Treasury decisions are matters for this government. Their consequences are felt on farms throughout our United Kingdom.
I'll give way to my honorable friend.
Jim Shannon
The Ulster Farmers' Union here represented here and I declare an interest as one of those that our national food security lies inherently in the economic viability of our local family farms. And I would say the agri-food capital that is Strangford, my constituency, domestic farming is not just an industry. Does the honorable lady agree that and share my concerns that the family tax, inheritance family tax, will could well be the death knell for the family farms in Northern Ireland?
Carla Lockhart
Absolutely and certainly that is the focus of my speech today. I'll give way.
Speaker 49
I thank the honorable member for giving way. I regularly meet South Shropshire farmers who work night and day to put food on the table and the challenges that they face. Does she agree with me that everything should be done to unlock all the red tape that the farmers have to produce food and it should be part of national security and resilience because we need to make sure we're self-sufficient?
Carla Lockhart
Obviously I agree fully. Labour often say it is national security but action speaks louder than words in many in many ways. Northern Ireland punches well above its weight. We have less than 3% of the UK's population but produce more than 10% of its food output by value. We supply around one-fifth of UK egg production and approximately one-sixth of its dairy, beef and poultry output.
Those figures should leave ministers in no doubt about Northern Ireland's importance to feeding this nation. In Upper Bann, farming keeps a whole network of businesses going: the feed merchant, the machinery dealer, the haulier, the veterinary practices and the processors all depend on a viable industry. When money stops being spent on farms, those businesses feel it too. I'll give way.
Robin Swann
And again congratulate the honorable member for bringing this. Will she also acknowledge that the Ulster Farmers' Union pre-budget membership survey actually showed that 85% of their membership, 84% have postponed, cancelled or reduced investment in at least one of the seven areas surveyed and that has a knock-on effect to the supply chain across the country?
Carla Lockhart
Absolutely and that was the next point that I was going to make around the 84% of respondents to that survey have reduced, postponed or cancelled investment. And that's really stark because it's more than and more than half identified inheritance tax policy as a barrier to investment. Farmers are holding back on replacing machinery, improving livestock housing and carrying out drainage work. Ministers keep telling farmers to become more productive. How are they supposed to do that if the money needed to invest is being held back to prepare for a future tax bill?
I welcome the increase in the combined agriculture property and business relief allowance from the original 1 million proposed to 2.5 million per person, but I have never accepted that this resolves the problem. I'll give way.
Alex Easton
Thank you. I thank the honorable lady for giving way and for giving leadership on this issue in and on so many other issues also. Does the member agree that in Northern Ireland and across the UK domestic farming must be viable? To achieve that, government must provide support helping farmers manage rising costs and ensure that producers receive a fair return.
Carla Lockhart
Absolutely, I agree with my honorable friend in his assessment. The family farm tax, I can't be clearer, should be scrapped. And if Labour do not scrap it tomorrow, they will not be forgiven when it comes to the ballot box, particularly for their rural MPs.
The land, the sheds, and the machineries are needed to earn a living. Their value cannot simply be withdrawn from a bank account. If land has to be sold, the farm loses some of its ability to produce food and generate an income for a business already operating on tight margins. That can make all the difference. And I do not think it is unreasonable for a farmer who has worked all their life to want their children to carry on that work.
These are families who have gone without, borrowed, reinvested, and spent years building something they hoped would outlast them. More than a third of respondents to the UFU survey anticipated an inheritance tax bill of at least 100,000 pounds. More than seven in ten are less confident about passing on a financially viable business. Almost nine in ten reported increased family stress or worry because of the changes. I would ask the Minister to think about the conversations behind those figures.
A father wondering what will happen when he's gone, a mother worried about the burden being left to her children, and a young person who wants to farm but cannot see how the figures will actually stack up. There is enough worry in farming without government adding to it. Tomorrow the Chancellor can lift some of that uncertainty and I urge the Minister to make the case for restoring the historic reliefs and allowing working family farms to be passed on. There's also decisions closer to home which are holding our industry back. In Northern Ireland, farmers are told to improve their buildings, reduce emissions, and invest in better slurry management.
But when they try to do those things, they can find themselves caught in planning delays and environmental assessments with no clear way forward. In some cases, they cannot even get betterment through the planning system. A farmer may want to replace an old shed with a modern building, improve animal welfare, and reduce emissions, yet still struggle to secure approval. How does leaving the old building in place help anyone? I accept that applications must be properly assessed, but there must be a workable route for proposals which demonstrably improve the existing position.
Farmers are spending money on advice, reports, and revised applications while the costs of proposed works continues to rise. The relevant ministers at Stormont need to get to grips with this. Farmers cannot be expected to modernize if the system prevents them from doing so. And I know that the situation is exactly the same here in GB. And I'm fed up, farmers are fed up with being made the fall guy in the pursuit of net zero.
They are expected to produce affordable food, look after the countryside, and pay for changes demanded of them, often without any realistic explanation of how their business is supposed to bear the cost. Some of those making the demands would do well to spend a week on a working farm. Driving production, I will indeed.
Charles Edward Robin Morello
I thank the honorable lady for giving way. She's making an excellent speech raising a lot of the points that go far beyond just Northern Ireland. When she's talking about the need to improve farms and to combat climate change, how are farmers supposed to engage seriously in a process when my farmers in West Dorset are unable to apply for SFI because that window is closing so quickly, is not properly funded, and is leaving them drastically under budget for their financial year ahead and wondering why they are continuing to make all the, meet all the demands government is making when it is not getting a fair settlement for farmers?
Carla Lockhart
I know his farmers will have heard his point very clearly today and I know he's a real advocate for the farming community and his constituents and he's absolutely right. Driving production, it's actually driving production overseas. It will not remove the need for food. It will leave us buying more of it from elsewhere with less control over how it is produced and further distances to transport it.
I will indeed.
Timothy James Farron
The honorable lady is incredibly generous as ever. She'll recall the Defense Secretary last weekend told us all as families to be ready because of potential shocks that might come our way. But would she agree with me that the UK as a whole needs to be far more ready given the things that she was just saying to become food secure? Only 60% of the food that we produce in this country or eat in this country is produced across the four nations of our country. Isn't it the job of government, all four governments in this country, the three devolved and the UK Parliament, to make sure we have farm payment schemes that encourage the production of food so we can become food secure?
Carla Lockhart
Absolutely. Farm payments are critical to ensuring just that. So I would wholeheartedly agree with the honorable member who is again another real advocate for our farming and rural communities. When talking about imports, our farmers will make improvements where there are practical affordable ways to do so, but they should not have their livelihoods put at risk by targets pursued with little regard for the consequences. And the same applies to imports.
Earlier this year I raised concerns about imported eggs and egg product, including reports that imports have increased by 60% since 2021. Our producers have spent considerable sums meeting the standards required of them. They are rightly angry at the prospect of being undercut by egg producers under systems which would not be permitted here. Government cannot impose those costs on our farmers and then shrug its shoulders when cheaper products arrive from elsewhere. I will quickly give way.
John Slinger
I thank the honorable lady for giving way. And on that point about imports, I think she might be touching on one of the really important topics as regards the farming community, which is the huge power of the supermarket chains in setting prices. And farmgate prices are clearly making it very difficult for our farmers to earn a decent living that they so deserve. So does she agree with me that the government absolutely should take on board some of the comments by Baroness Batters around this and do everything that we can to ensure that farmers get a fair price and that competition works not just in the interests of the supermarkets, but in the interests of our farmers?
Carla Lockhart
Indeed, I agree again with the point and it's well made. Another area that I think government can help our farmers in is public procurement and should be doing far more. And I've challenged the sourcing of food for Northern Ireland schools. Information provided to me showed that approximately 80% of the Education Authority's beef came from the Republic of Ireland with around 20% from Northern Ireland. Given the quality of beef produced on our doorstep, I believe that is wrong.
I have also raised the use of halal certified chicken. The Education Authority has said it could not meet demand if halal chicken were excluded from its supply. You know, again, when you look at Northern Ireland and the number of chicken producers, that should not be the case. We should be able to supply our own markets. Parents are entitled to know what their children are being served and to have clear information about the choices and they want homegrown food.
I want the Department of Finance and indeed here to use public money wisely and to support our local markets. I also want to return to an issue I've raised repeatedly with this government: illegal meat imports. Our farmers can do everything asked of them on biosecurity and still have their livelihoods put at risk by failures at the border. In January last year, around 600 kilograms of non-compliant meat was stopped at Larne after traveling through Great Britain.
I commend the officials who intercepted it but it should concern every minister responsible that it had traveled so far before being detected. At Dover almost 99 tons were seized during 2024 in 868 separate seizures. In December that year more than 6 tons were intercepted within just 14 hours including pork reported to have come from areas of Romania affected by African swine fever. 58 tons were seized in the first three months of 2025 alone. I have raised this in writing and directly with ministers last year.
The government outlined joint working between agencies funding offered to Dover Port Health Authorities and plans to tackle vehicles used by smugglers. I want the minister today to tell us what has changed as a result. How many additional inspections capacity is now operating? What prosecutions have followed? Are enforcement agencies getting the resources they need and has the government properly addressed the weaknesses raised about the border targeting operating model?
Farmers remember foot and mouth. They remember the destruction, the restrictions and the heartbreak. We cannot allow those lessons to be forgotten. The cost of effective enforcement must be weighed against the devastation a serious disease outbreak could cause. Those involved in this trade need to face consequences which make them think twice.
Seize the products, disrupt the operation and pursue prosecutions wherever the evidence allows. Northern Ireland's farmers also face the additional friction within our own UK market created by the Windsor Framework. A great deal has been made of how the EU reset will benefit them. We are apparently supposed to welcome the rest of the United Kingdom being brought under SPS rules. It does not make and cannot change.
Jim Allister
I will indeed. There's a certain irony in the title of this debate, domestic farming, when in respect of one part of this United Kingdom we are governed not by domestic laws but by foreign EU laws. Does the honorable member agree of the absolute folly of a reset which would subject the whole United Kingdom to that same disenfranchisement of being governed by laws we don't make and can't change? And does she note that this government has yet to tell us how much the reset in terms of farming would cost in the EU's demands for contributions to its budget?
Carla Lockhart
Absolutely agree with the honorable member. Maybe the minister can elaborate on that. I've never been convinced that the answer to the disenfranchisement of Northern Ireland is the disenfranchisement of Great Britain. How can laws made elsewhere without the United Kingdom having a vote on them be the right basis for governing our farming industry? Some changes applying to Northern Ireland barely attract scrutiny at all.
The Windsor Framework retail movement scheme plant health regulations brought forward this year changed requirements in Great Britain to match those already applying in Northern Ireland. Parliament was considering legislation for GB while corresponding requirements in Northern Ireland were already a fact of life. That is no way to treat part of our own country. We should also remember the freedoms denied to the Northern Ireland farmers. England has legislation to allow precision breeding work in progressing on cattle TB vaccinations in Great Britain while Northern Ireland remains subject to the EU prohibition.
Since the 1st of January retailers in Great Britain have been unable to supply veterinary medicines directly to Northern Ireland.
Other supply arrangements remain, but farmers have lost an established route for obtaining medicines from the rest of their own country. There are also differences in the rules governing mycoxins in cereals and additional requirements on organic production. These are practical matters affecting what farmers can use, what they can produce, and what it costs them. I want ministers to look again at properly enforced trusted trader schemes for good crossing, for goods crossing the land border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Protect the EU market through target controls on goods entering it, allow trade within our own United Kingdom to take place without these barriers.
Extending rule-taking to Great Britain does not restore Northern Ireland's voice. We should be protecting the freedoms secured through Brexit and ensuring that Northern Ireland's farmers can benefit from them too. At the end of the day, this debate is about domestic farming and food supply, yet in Northern Ireland, so many of the laws governing our agri-food industry are made by the European Union with no vote for those we elect and no ability for them to change the laws. How can ministers talk about securing our domestic food supply while accepting that part of our own country must take its agriculture rules from elsewhere? Northern Ireland's farmers help feed this United Kingdom.
They deserve the same democratic voice in the decisions affecting their livelihoods as farmers elsewhere in it. All these pressures fall on the same businesses: rising costs, disease, planning difficulties, barriers to trade, and uncertainty over whether the next generation will face a tax bill they cannot afford. Ministers may deal with those issues separately; the farmer has to deal with them all at once. That is why tomorrow's budget matters so much. The Chancellor has an opportunity to restore confidence, realize the investment, and give farming families some certainty about the future.
I will continue to speak up for the farmers of Upper Bann, Northern Ireland, and across this United Kingdom. They have worked hard and kept producing through some exceptionally difficult years. They have been patient, they have made their case, they deserve to be heard. Once a family farm is broken up, it is not easily put back together. Once a young person walks away from farming, we may never get them back.
We cannot keep weakening the industry and assume there will always be someone else to carry it on. Scrap the family farm tax, let farmers invest, give the next generation a reason to stay. No farmers, no food, and no future. Thank you.
Jeremy Paul Wright
Thank you very much. The honorable lady, the question is that this House has considered domestic farming and food supply. Minister.
Speaker 56
Pleasure to serve with you in the chair, Sir Jeremy, and I'd like to start by thanking the member for Upper Bann for securing this debate about these important matters. She will know agriculture is a devolved issue and we are committed to working closely with the devolved governments as we work to support UK farmers and boost the nation's food security. And I welcome her focus on UK matters today alongside the various insights she's brought from Northern Ireland. Before I respond, Chair, allow me just to begin by stating that farmers are the backbone of our food system, our rural economy, and our national resilience. Yet I recognize that many are working under extraordinary pressure: volatile markets, extreme weather, animal disease, rising input and energy costs.
Gregory Campbell
I thank the minister for giving way. He's outlined accurately that while it's devolved, there are issues that fall to the Treasury and to his own responsibility. He's heard the concerns, which I'm sure he's heard many times before. Can he outline the representations which I'm sure he's made to the Treasury on behalf of the farming community ahead of tomorrow's budget?
Speaker 56
I thank the member for his intervention. Obviously, matters of taxation are matters for the Chancellor and more will be known in the budget tomorrow, but I can certainly share that I work closely with my colleagues in Northern Ireland and have met with colleagues and in my previous ministerial responsibility was delighted to visit Northern Ireland and hope to do so in future on these important issues that are being discussed today.
Speaker 57
Chair, I'd like to make some progress and to say that the importance of the issues that I addressed earlier, those pressures cannot be overstated. Agriculture alone contributes 14.5 billion to the economy while the wider food and drink sector contributed 153 billion in 2023. The agri-food sector employed 4.1 million people in 2025 and food security is national security. I will happily give way to my honorable friend.
Perran Moon
I thank the minister for giving way. After months of drought, 175 wildfires and 369 cases of blue tongue this summer alone, Cornish farmers have had an exceptionally hard year. Rising fertilizer costs driven by disruption from a completely avoidable conflict with Iran has placed a particular burden on British farmers. Can the minister comment further on media reports that the government is going to support the cost of fertilizer in tomorrow's budget because if that is the case, that would be very good news indeed.
Speaker 56
I thank the member for his question. He's a real champion on farming issues, very evident from my time down in Cornwall over the summer with the Prime Minister and I know that he's a real champion in this place on those issues. I obviously can't comment on speculation. Obviously there is an indication that there may be some announcements tomorrow that will be supportive of our farming community, but I ask him for a little more patience ahead of the Chancellor's statement tomorrow. Chair, on the issues of importance raised by the member today, I thank her for the specific issues identified.
Trade is a very important matter which of course affects Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK. In order to address the pressures that raised by farmers in Northern Ireland and across the country, markets must work fairly. UK farmers should not be undercut by imports produced to lower standards and we will maintain our food and animal welfare standards, use quotas, exclusions and safeguards where necessary and open new export opportunities for high quality UK produce. The last four deals we have concluded with Switzerland, India, the Gulf Cooperation Council and South Korea created new opportunities for Northern Irish exports while protecting sensitive sectors like pork, poultry and eggs. For example, tariffs on Northern Irish beef, lamb and dairy exports will be removed in the Gulf and will be reduced further in Switzerland.
Tariffs on whiskey exports to India have been halved and will continue to go down over the next 10 years. We also have a global network of 16 agri-food and drink attachés who create new opportunities for export and help businesses access markets around the globe. So far this year, they've removed 26 barriers worth nearly 90 million annually. So the proposed SPS agreement with the European Union is intended to remove the routine border checks and costly paperwork, reducing friction for exporters and supporting the UK's food supply and security. The agreement will remove almost all SPS checks and certificates between Great Britain and Northern Ireland and this will reduce costs for a whole range of businesses and increase choice for consumers.
I know Northern Irish farmers welcome the deal. They see the benefit in the removal of checks on used agricultural machinery like tractors which are often bought from Great Britain. As another example, seed potatoes will be easier to bring in and Northern Irish farmers will be operating under the same rules, for example on pesticides, as the rest of the UK. We're also supporting farmers across the United Kingdom, including in Northern Ireland, through our program of fair dealing reforms.
On the 2nd of October, the first case of highly pathogenic avian influenza of this season was confirmed in Scotland, and we have now had our first case in England. Stringent biosecurity remains the best defence to protecting the health and welfare of birds and reducing the risk of avian influenza entering the kept bird populations. On bovine TB, worth stating that the government is developing a cattle vaccine and DIVA skin test, widening sensitive testing, expanding badger vaccination, and working towards TB-free status for England by 2038. The reason why I stress these points is that the honourable member made a number of points around enforcement at our borders and illegal meat, and I can confirm that government continues to work across departments to develop a new framework in partnership with the Home Office, Border Force, FSA, and others, and more details will be published in due course. With regards to matters on tax raised in the debate this afternoon, I recognise that when the government initially announced reforms to agricultural property relief and business property relief in 2024, there was significant concern in the industry about their impact.
The government listened to those concerns and acted, going further to protect more farms and businesses. Up to 5 million can still be passed on free of inheritance tax depending on people's individual circumstances. Farming families will be able to pass the family farm down to their children just as previous generations have done so. Turning to the points raised with regards to certainty to invest and where there have been issues in the past around planning, the farming roadmap was published earlier this year. We recognise that the sector needs confidence to invest to grow their businesses, plan for the future, and secure farms for the next generation, and these are important for profitable food production and resilience to global shocks.
In England, through our farming roadmap, we have set a new long-term direction for the sector, a direction that is more profitable, productive, sustainable, and resilient, and will be better able to withstand climate, market, and geopolitical shocks. Through the roadmap, we have committed to maintaining domestic food production at least at current levels, and our commitment to farmers is backed by record 11.8 billion pounds for sustainable farming and food production over this Parliament. This year, 788 million in new funding has been committed to boost productivity, develop new technologies, and maintain a healthy natural environment. Support includes a 225 million for capital grants, 173 million for productivity and innovation, and a 15 million for on-farm reservoirs to strengthen drought resilience. On issues with regards to red tape and bureaucracy, I recognise the frustration of farmers about ever-increasing bureaucracy.
Regulation is necessary to address risks, but compliance requirements can be a burden and slow growth. We are delivering actions through the government's regulation action plan to reduce these burdens on farmers and will take further action. Sir Jeremy, the pressures facing UK farming are real, and no responsible government should dismiss them. I thank the honourable member for Upper Bann for her insight on the issues raised in today's debate. Our task is to stand alongside farmers, strengthen profitability and resilience, and to ensure that UK farming can continue to produce the food on which we all depend.
Jeremy Paul Wright
The question therefore is that this House has considered domestic farming and food supplies. Many as are of that opinion say aye. The contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order, we will adjourn for less than a minute.
Christopher Chope
Mr Stewart, I beg to move that this House has considered the government response to the COVID-19 inquiry module 4 report. Can I begin by saying how refreshing it is to see the public health minister here today, because if there's anybody who will be empathetic to what we are discussing today, it must be the right honourable lady, because she has campaigned fearlessly on behalf of another group of victims, the victims of contaminated blood scandals. And although I don't want to overdo the connection between the contaminated blood and the vaccine damage victims, I think the responses to those tragedies from successive governments have had a similar pattern. Total denial of responsibility to start off with, then recognition that people have suffered, but not because of anything which the government was responsible for, and then eventually to conceding that the cause and effect of the damage was there, but still stalling on providing any effective redress. And I'm afraid it's the stalling of providing any effective redress that I wish to concentrate on today, because the Hallett inquiry made some very clear recommendations in April this year.
Recommendation 5: the UK government must reform the vaccine damage payment scheme as soon as possible. The reform should include as a minimum: increasing the 120,000 pound payment, at least in line with inflation to date, subsequently applying annual increases in line with inflation, introducing multiple levels of payment commensurate with the degree of injury suffered, and any transitional arrangements necessary to provide for fairness between applicants to the existing scheme and applicants to the revised scheme. The response from the government published earlier this month is, in my submission, Mr Stewart, inadequate. And it may be that that's because the right honourable lady has only been in post for three months. It may be because the government officials have not been doing the review work which they've assured me and others for the last several years that they were doing.
But I hope we'll be able to hear from the Minister in due course. And I hope that she will be able to say that the government does agree to increase the 120,000 pound payment. It is going to agree to applying annual increases in line with inflation. That it is going to introduce multiple levels of payment commensurate with the degree of injury, etc.
Jim Shannon
I commend the honorable gentleman for his stalwart and leading the campaign for this and very well done. But for too long a small minority of families who suffered severe adverse outcomes have been left stranded by administrative failures and a lack of fair support. So does the honorable member agree that the promised reforms must be designed in direct collaboration with the vaccine injured and their families, ensuring they are treated with the dignity, the speed, and the fairness that they very much deserve?
Christopher Chope
I agree with my honorable friend absolutely. And I think it's fair to remind everybody that my honorable friend participated in the very first debate I had on this subject, which was on Friday the 10th of September 2021, Mr. Stewart. And that was the occasion on which I moved the second reading of a private member's bill and in so doing drew attention to what were then 1,632 yellow card reports of deaths having taken place shortly after vaccination. I also drew attention then to the public petition which had been put to Parliament and the government's response. The petition called for improved support for those injured or bereaved through COVID-19 vaccines.
And the government response then stated, once more is known about the possible links between the vaccine and potential side effects, it will be considered whether a wider review of VDPS is needed. Well, that was over five years ago. And we've now got that review. We've had the public inquiry. We've had the outcome.
And yet we haven't had the acceptance by the government of the clear recommendations to which I've already referred. And back in September 2021, I requested the then Secretary of State to establish an independent review of disablement caused by COVID-19 vaccines and the adequacy of the compensation awarded. And I wasn't then requesting a mammoth public inquiry, but only a short judge-led inquiry into how we should most fairly compensate those who'd suffered the adverse consequences. And I contrasted the government's pessimistic view with the World Health Organization's COVAX scheme, which, as the right honorable lady will know, indemnifies claims for vaccine damage in third world countries. And we, the British taxpayers, pay for that, but we haven't got an equivalent scheme in our own jurisdiction.
On the 2nd of March 2022, I raised the specific subject of the 1979 Vaccine Damage Payments Act in an adjournment debate. And in that debate, I referred to Kate Scott, whose husband, a fit 44-year-old software engineer, spent 124 days in hospital following severe brain injury caused by the vaccine. Boris Johnson, then the Prime Minister, had written to Kate Scott and her family back in August 2021, stating, you're not a statistic and must not be ignored. He said that the government would, and I use the word again, consider Kate's suggestions for reform of the scheme.
And in concluding my speech on that occasion, I referred to what David Ennals, the Secretary of State for Social Services, a Labour Secretary of State, had said back in 1979 on the 5th of February at column 32 of Hansard, when introducing the legislation. And he said, for most people, vaccination is a beneficial procedure, and it is right for the community to give financial aid and support to those who suffer as the result of vaccinations given as part of the public policy program. That was the rationale for the vaccine damage payment scheme, a scheme introduced by the then Labour government in its dying days, but I won't criticize them for having put that as their priority at the end of their term of office. In responding to my adjournment debate in February 2022, the then minister, Maria Caulfield, refused even to accept any causality. She said there'd been 920 claims by then, but the work currently going on is establishing whether there's a causal link between the vaccine and the adverse events that people have been suffering.
So fast forward to today, Mr. Stewart, and we see that we've got the findings which I've already referred, and then the government response. The government accepts that there's a need for reform of the VDPS and is, according to its response, committed to reviewing the scheme to ensure it is fit for purpose and delivered effectively. But that implies that that's a review that was going to start after the inquiry had reported. But when I and other people who are campaigning on behalf of the victims met the Public Health Minister, the honorable lady, the member for Lancashire West, probably about a year ago, she told us that the government was already reviewing the scheme. And we asked her in what respects it was reviewing the scheme.
She said she couldn't say, but she was conceding that they were reviewing the scheme. But now it seems as though the government is starting afresh, saying they're committed to reviewing the scheme. We will work closely with the vaccine injured and their families as we consider how the scheme could be strengthened in the future. This is a long way from the specific, clear, strong recommendations made by Baroness Hallett. And let's think about what the Prime Minister Boris Johnson said to Kate Scott in August 2021.
A review, he said he'd review it. Hasn't the review already taken place? And I think it, I assume it must have already taken place. But there's another issue here, because we now know that as at the 30th of June, 264 claims had been successful, and 582 claims under the scheme had been rejected, causation where it had been established, but they did not meet the 60% disability threshold. So that means, Mr. Stewart, that about, on my calculation, about 32 million pounds has been paid out in compensation.
And yet in answer to a question I put down in September, the 3rd of September, I found out that the costs of the staffing, the non-staffing and the medical assessment and payments to healthcare bodies, the cost of all that over four years is no less than 82 million pounds. So all that expenditure of public money in bureaucracy to try and block people who've suffered damage and in some cases bereavement as a result of doing the right thing and taking the vaccines. This is just unacceptable. And I hope that the Minister will include within her response an explanation as to what the government is going to do to simplify the scheme and stop blocking through technical measures the legitimate claims and ensure that instead of spending another 82 million pounds over the next four years on bureaucracy, we actually use some of that money to actually compensate the people who have suffered as a result of the vaccine program. I can help the Minister because I anticipated in a sense when we had the private members' bill ballot and I put in a number of bills and presentation bills.
And one of those bills is the Vaccine Damage Payment Scheme UK Covid Inquiry Bill. And that is set down for second reading on the 15th of January 2027. So it's ideally timed to be able to incorporate any recommendations that the Minister comes forward with. And the long title of the bill is to require the Secretary of State to publish proposals for the implementation of recommendations of Module 4 of the UK Covid-19 Inquiry relating to vaccine damage payment schemes and for connected purposes. And so that is a real opportunity, a legislative opportunity for the government.
And I hope that they will take advantage of it. In the meantime, they have been blocking my Covid-19 Vaccine Damage Payments Bill for this session, the one which has already been published. And the explanatory notes in that bill set out a number of suggested reforms, including looking at the benefits of having a system which doesn't cost the government anything, but it would ensure that people got recompense. And that would be by introducing a scheme similar to that, for example, which covers motor insurance, the Motor Insurers' Bureau scheme, or the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, where the industry pays for the costs of the compensation arising from problems in the way in which those schemes have operated. And what could be more equitable than that?
But instead of doing that heretofore, both the previous government and the current government, what they are doing is they are indemnifying Big Pharma. Indemnifying Big Pharma against any costs associated with vaccines that don't work properly. And that I think is intolerable. So my bill has got a number of recommendations and suggestions. I hope that the Minister will be able to engage with me, if not necessarily in today's debate, but privately afterwards.
Graham Stuart
Question is this House has considered the government response to the Covid-19 Inquiry Module 4 Report. I'm going to call back to wind-ups at 5:08.
So if everybody is reasonably disciplined, then we can have four minutes for each speaker. And I call Dr. Becky Cooper.
Becky Cooper
Thank you, Sir James, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I thank the honorable member for Dorset for calling this important debate today. He has focused on one particular aspect of module 4, vaccines and therapeutics, looking at the recompense scheme. I would like to broaden the conversation slightly in my remarks. Alongside the learnings that this module brings, there's also a lot of positive narrative here.
So as a public health consultant working during the pandemic, both here and with public health partners in other countries, I would like to recognize the huge public value of our sustained investment here in the UK in our NHS, public health, and scientific research. Thanks to this investment, capabilities were in place prior to the pandemic, which meant that the UK was in a position to authorize and begin delivering effective COVID-19 vaccines within a year of the first identified UK case. And by September 2022, more than 150 million doses of the three principal vaccines had been administered in the UK, including the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine, which was developed here in the UK thanks to years of scientific research. And this research, of course, is part of a wider global partnership that allows us to ensure that vaccine development can be undertaken swiftly and accurately, both during a pandemic and for other essential vaccinations, such as our flu response. I want to mention the Centre for Epidemic Response and Innovation, CERI, in South Africa.
It's a key partner that identified the Omicron variants during the pandemic and is now critical in identifying influenza strains for the development of our influenza vaccine program every year. It would be good to hear from the minister a little more about how we are continuing to build that international scientific partnership for vaccine development and pandemic preparedness, particularly around the 100-day mission, where the aim is to work with global partners to make safe, effective, and affordable diagnostics, therapeutics, and vaccines available within just 100 days of identifying a future pandemic threat. As well as ensuring that we have the capacity to develop vaccines swiftly and efficiently as part of a global response, the module also highlighted the issue of equitable access to the vaccines and the role that existing health inequalities played in the UK in terms of vaccination coverage. The inquiry found familiar themes around why there was lower uptake of the vaccine in some communities and groups of people. And as the inquiry rightly highlights, vaccine inequality is not simply an issue of individual behavior.
It is also a reflection of how services are designed, how communities experience public institutions, and whether the health system can meet people where they are in their daily lives. There is also the issue of public trust in the system that is administering the vaccines. And it should be noted that this cannot simply be manufactured through a national communication campaign at the moment of crisis. It must be earned over time through reliable services, honest information, and meaningful relationships with communities. There is also a useful distinction to be made between legitimate questions about vaccine safety and deliberate misinformation.
Again, this is an area that needs to be engaged with proactively and positively, allowing people to have their voices heard and making sure that all available facts and evidence are clearly communicated. So could the minister please update us on how lessons learned from vaccine hesitancy and the health inequality patterns that were observed during the pandemic are now being used to inform our UK vaccine strategy, particularly in light of worrying recent patterns around childhood vaccinations for diseases such as measles and dropping the explicit World Health Organization target of 95% put in place to ensure population herd immunity. Finally, with closing remarks, I would like to acknowledge my public health, clinical, and care colleagues who contributed so much to the pandemic response, with some tragically giving their lives in order to care for other people. Directors of public health, local authorities, primary care, and community organizations should remain a central part of the solution to ensuring vaccine equity. We must ensure that the lessons learned from this inquiry allow us to support their essential work in order to swiftly respond to the next pandemic.
Jeremy Paul Wright
Thank you very much, Mr. Stewart. It's a very great pleasure to see you in the chair, not least because through your generosity in taking over from me, I'm allowed to participate in this debate. And can I also pay huge tribute to my honorable friend for Christchurch, not just for his skill in securing this debate, but also for his long-standing campaigning on behalf of those who have been injured by COVID vaccinations. And I think between he and I, we must have met and discussed this with almost every occupant of the minister's job and almost every occupant of the Secretary of State's job over the last few years. And it seems to me, Mr. Stewart, that we should start here.
The argument which I want to concentrate on around reform of the vaccine damage payment scheme is not an argument about the wisdom or otherwise of mass vaccination. Quite remarkably, in my judgment, many of those who have been injured or who've lost loved ones in the process of mass vaccination during the COVID pandemic also support the idea of mass vaccination, but they take the view, which I think we should all support, that for those who were doing what their government asked them to do, it is only right that they are properly compensated for any loss or damage that they have incurred. And it seems to me also that the issues that people like Kate Scott, who is my constituent, my honorable friend mentioned and who I know the minister has met, have maintained throughout is that what is wrong with the vaccine damage payment scheme essentially comes down to two things. First of all, the amount of money available and the fact that it is an all-or-nothing amount, and secondly, the requirement that there should be 60% disablement in order to take advantage of the scheme. And it is fair to point out that nobody ever claimed when the scheme was developed that it was designed to be the only compensation available, but the reality of the position, as I know the minister appreciates, is that it is extremely difficult to obtain compensation by any other route, including through the courts.
And therefore, it seems to me that vaccine damage payment scheme reform is about two things. It's about fairness to the individuals affected, but it's also about the effectiveness of government policy. And I know this will concern the minister and I hope the rest of government. It would be brave of any of us to claim that this sort of widespread pandemic event will never happen again. And if it does happen again, then we will rely on the confidence of the British public once again to literally roll up their sleeves and assist in the process of combating whatever disease it is we face next.
Their confidence in a mass vaccination program will depend on whether they think people who are injured in that program have been fairly treated. Thus far they have not. And so if the government wants to be confident of the effectiveness of a future pandemic response, it needs to deal effectively with the fallout of the last pandemic response. And finally, Mr. Stewart, let me simply make the point that my honorable friend made. There is urgency to this.
People who have been injured, those who have been bereaved, don't just expect a fair response from the government, they expect it soon. And there is a mismatch, I'm afraid, between the urgency described in the report of Baroness Hallett and the approach that the government has taken in their response. So for example, Baroness Hallett says that with regard to the 60% threshold, this part of the scheme should be reformed as a matter of urgency. Compare and contrast that with the wording of the government's response, which accepts there is a need for reform of the scheme, and I welcome that, and is committed to reviewing the scheme to ensure that it's fit for purpose.
But it then says the government will provide further details in due course. Those of us who've served in government know what that means. It doesn't mean an urgent response. And I know the minister will recognize that this situation deserves just that.
Graham Stringer
Mr. Stewart. Can I congratulate the honorable member for Christchurch for sponsoring this debate. One of the surprising things is given how many people died during the COVID epidemic, and the cost of approximately 400 billion pounds, and the cost of this inquiry heading northwards for a billion pounds, is how little debate there has been either in Westminster Hall or on the floor of the House of Commons. So I just want to use the opportunity of this debate on the fourth part of the inquiry to not just point out the lack of debate so far, but to use recommendation one to highlight a number of things. Recommendation one and the government's response both draw attention to how SAGE behaved during COVID.
And it says uncritically that they gave coordinated scientific and technical advice during. Well, yes, to a point. But on the 11th of February, I think it was, 2020, they had a report before them from Imperial College, one based on Chinese statistics, showing that there was a very strong relationship between age and mortality of people who caught COVID. Basically, if you were a child, you were not at risk. And if you were over 70, you were at serious risk.
SAGE did not discuss that at that meeting, even though the paper was there. And had they discussed it, they may well have come forward with different policies to keep children in school and to protect the most vulnerable people, rather than having a blanket policy which said protect the NHS. It's not our job to protect the NHS. It's the NHS's job to protect us. And actually, I always read protecting the NHS as protecting the government, because they were frightened of having people on trolleys in corridors.
So I think that was a mistake, and the information was there and could have been used. The heroine of this episode and mentioned in the report is Kate Bingham, who ran the vaccine task force and was primarily responsible because of her expertise both in science and in funding for getting the vaccine out quicker than anywhere else. And so we should, given that she was so successful in doing that, we should have listened to what she said. When she spoke to the Science and Technology Committee, the Health Committee of the House, when she spoke to the inquiry, she was excoriating about the government's response to what had happened. She talked about there being institutional blockages, warfare between the business department and the health department.
She didn't recommend what's here, which is a pharmaceutical expert advisory panel, which doesn't seem to have very many powers. She wanted to protect and develop our vaccine manufacturing ability and our science ability. And what do we get? The sale of the vaccine manufacturing and innovation center and nothing else. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Stewart.
Rupert Lowe
It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. The COVID lockdowns were the darkest period in recent British history, bar none. Our freedoms were stripped away in ways most of us never imagined possible. And alongside all of that came extraordinary pressure on millions of people to take the COVID vaccine. Pressure from politicians, employers, media institutions, everything, everywhere.
For some, refusing meant losing their livelihood. They did it anyway. We were told to trust the science, but the science is not a commandment. It's a process of questioning, testing, and challenging of evidence. And when a government asks millions of healthy people to undergo an unproven medical intervention with unwanted consequences, scrutiny should increase.
COVID posed very different risks to different people. An elderly vulnerable person faced a very different calculation from a healthy 25-year-old. In fact, they could not have been more different. The 25-year-old was at no risk whatsoever. They were more likely to drown to death than have serious issues with COVID.
Yet so much of the messaging treated vaccination as though it were the same decision for everyone. Why? Why were people asking questions treated with such hostility? And why were people who refused a medical intervention made to feel like social pariahs? I'm particularly concerned about children.
For the overwhelming majority, the risk of severe COVID illness was non-existent. It was a cold. There was no threat at all. And let's remember that the rollout to teenagers was forced through against the advice of JCVI, who originally declined to recommend a mass rollout for younger teens. The facts are quite clear.
We do know that cases of myocarditis and pericarditis occurred following COVID vaccinations, particularly amongst adolescent and young adult males. Millions of healthy young men and women should never have been forced to take that vaccination, and those responsible for that decision must be held accountable. Informed consent is the only way. Then there was Nadhim Zahawi, the Conservative government's vaccines minister at the time, now speaking for Reform UK. He stated that children 12 to 15 could receive the COVID vaccine even where their parents objected.
A 12-year-old could take this vaccination against their parents' wishes. Think about that. 12 years old. And then came vaccine passports, again forced through by Reform's Zahawi. I found the entire concept morally repugnant.
It was criminal. The idea that the state could make access to ordinary parts of life dependent on disclosing your medical status. That is not how a free country should operate. I did not take the COVID vaccine. I didn't want it, I didn't need it, and I didn't take it.
That decision cost me money. It affected my travel. I lost friends. It made my life considerably more difficult, but I don't regret it for one moment. But this cannot end with another speech about how badly things were handled.
We all know that. There must be accountability. By law, this inquiry cannot decide whether anyone is liable for what went wrong. That responsibility now rests with government, regulators, and where necessary, the courts. The inquiry itself recognized the heavy cost of lockdowns, even if it criticized how decisions were made.
Pandemic censorship and conflicts of interest demand answers too. Who decided which questions the public was allowed to ask? Who profited from the answers? These are questions any healthy democracy should ask. The government has accepted that the reform is needed, but it hasn't offered no timetable and no detail.
That is exactly why there must be a full, honest reckoning of their true costs and benefits, and of the treatment of the care home residents.
Those who have been injured by these vaccines cannot be left waiting any longer. The scheme needs an overhaul. Nobody can be above the law.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Mr. Stewart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Some across this House will be aware of the tragic case of NHS pharmacist John Cross in Bromsgrove, who developed paralyzing complications after receiving a COVID injection. The effects began two weeks after the vaccine and John was then hospitalized for seven months. He worked hard on his recovery through private physio and under medical advice he applied to the Vaccine Damage Payment Scheme where he was deemed 55% disabled, therefore falling short of the 60% requirement for qualification.
A few months later, John tragically took his own life. After a grueling five-year legal challenge by his family, at a time when they should have been grieving the loss of their husband, father, and grandfather, the decision was finally overturned. The Cross family has been clear. The current vaccine compensation scheme is failing victims. The government has repeatedly stated that it is evaluating options to reform the VDPS.
Yet no official timescale has been set for making a decision on any alterations or recommendations for a change. This is unacceptable. It leaves victims and their families trapped in a state of anxiety and uncertainty. So will the government publish a timescale for conducting its review of the Vaccine Damage Payment Scheme and the changes that it intends to implement to ensure certainty for victims? Having received fewer than 800 applications in the decade before COVID-19, it is clear that the VDPS needs to adapt to respond to the significant increase in applications from those affected by COVID-19 vaccines.
Since the COVID-19 pandemic began, the number of claims made has risen significantly, with more than 24,000 claims relating to COVID-19 alone. Yet despite this stark rise, just over 1% have received the tax-free payment. John Cross was a part of that forgotten 99% until his family fought for justice. Does the government believe the 60% threshold is still appropriate and is the binary yes or no process that awards a flat rate payment for a successful claim still fit for purpose? Has any consideration been given to the introduction of a tiered compensation framework that implements varying thresholds for payment amounts based on case-specific circumstances, such as the severity of the damage and long-term care requirements?
The Cross family is one tragic story amongst many. And I want to stress, Mr. Stewart, that I am pro-vaccine as are the Cross family, but there must be clear accountability for severe side effects that people have suffered and those impacted must receive the help that they are owed, particularly after they followed government advice. The Cross family have always been unequivocal that their fight has never been about money. No amount will bring back John. To them it's always been about accountability, the ability to give others in similar situations hope and the need to change a system that told a man he effectively was not disabled enough.
Speaker 67
I'm proud to support the Cross family and I will continue to do so until they receive the justice that they deserve.
Esther McVey
It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Stewart. In a democratic society we should be able to rely on an inquiry to accurately establish what happened, what should happen and how things should happen better in the future. However, I'm incredibly concerned that this inquiry is failing to do just that, with sweeping assumptions that from the start the vaccines were to be used and the phrase used was safe and effective.
The module 4 report states it is neither proportionate nor practicable for the inquiry to reach a view on the safety of particular vaccines, but then goes on to declare the utmost reassurance that the steps taken by the UK government and the regulatory bodies did not compromise the UK's rigorous safety standards. How can they be sure when they haven't reached a view on the safety of this? Time is limited, so I'd like to go to an issue that happened to a person, a mother in my constituency, who was given the Moderna COVID-19 booster vaccine in a care home in my constituency. They have recently been successful in their claim to the vaccine damages payment scheme. Their case describes mass serious adverse events in the fellow residents of their mother's care home and the death of a second resident, also attributed to the side effects.
The family have since spent years painstakingly collating evidence and research that shows that the MHRA not only failed in its statutory duties by not properly investigating the clear safety signal of multiple care home residents suffering a series of fatal reactions, but also failed to be honest about the wholesale lack of safety evidence for using Moderna in the frail elderly care home cohort, either as a main dose or as a booster. 70% of the elderly in our care homes have dementia, and over half of residents are frail, yet, and I quote, frail subjects with unstable health conditions and comorbidities, including chronic neurological diseases, were identified as missing information in Moderna's own risk management plan. I have written twice as chair of the APPG for pandemic recovery and response. I have not yet heard from the MHRA, so I just wondered in conclusion if I could ask for the minister to meet with me and the family to see why we haven't had a response and if she'll take the time to do that.
Clive Jones
It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Stewart, and I thank the honorable member for Christchurch for securing this debate. Today we must remember all the loved ones who were taken from us by COVID, and all those who suffered so terribly during the pandemic and the lockdowns. It is for that reason, during the pandemic, that I proposed a COVID memorial wood in my Wokingham constituency, where people could go to remember their loved ones, and I'm delighted that a wood of nearly 8,000 trees has been planted. Those who suffered deserve not only our sympathy, but our determination to learn every lesson from this tragic chapter in our country's history. The inquiry has confirmed that the failure of the last Conservative government time and time again, the Conservatives left our country vulnerable and unprepared.
The British public will never forgive them for partying while communities were engulfed by grief, fear, and isolation. Never again can such a tragedy be repeated. We must learn the lessons from the inquiry and ensure we never return to a politics that ignores expertise and evidence. We cannot afford political leaders like those in Reform who would cut back vaccines, trash medical science, and spread disinformation. Every party leader should commit to implementing the inquiry's recommendations and supporting the vaccines that help end lockdowns and save lives.
While today's debate concerns module 4 on vaccines and therapeutics, if I may, I want to briefly touch on module 6, which examined the pandemic's impact on adult social care. That report confirmed what bereaved families have known: the last Conservative government failed to prepare the country, and its failures on social care cost lives. Years of neglect left the sector exposed and created conditions that allowed this horror to unfold. That is why the Liberal Democrats agree with bereaved families calling for former Health Secretary Matt Hancock to be stripped of his place on the Privy Council. Returning to module 4, the inquiry highlighted one of the genuine successes of the pandemic response: the vaccine rollout.
The rollout was, in the inquiry's words, an extraordinary feat. The success belongs to our scientists, to NHS staff, community pharmacists, and volunteers who delivered around 132 million jabs in 2021 alone, creating the largest vaccine program in British history. The vaccine saved almost 475,000 lives in England and Scotland alone. We should never forget that, and we must never allow anyone to rewrite that history. Yet the inquiry was equally clear that trust in the vaccines must be rebuilt.
Childhood vaccination rates have been falling for years, leaving more people vulnerable to preventable disease and increasing pressure on our health service. We must listen to our scientists, not to conspiracy theorists. Nigel Farage and Reform are amplifying dangerous anti-vaccine rhetoric associated with Donald Trump. We cannot allow Trump's America to become Farage's Britain. That is why the Liberal Democrats are calling for a strategy to combat anti-vaccine and medical disinformation, alongside a new drive to deliver record vaccination rates.
Vaccines should be brought closer to communities through trusted local venues, including church halls and community centers. The best way to honor those we lost is to learn from the lessons of this inquiry, defend science, rebuild trust in vaccination, and ensure that when the next crisis comes, Britain is never again so unprepared. Thank you, Mr. Stewart.
Gregory James Stafford
It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Stewart, and I congratulate my honorable friend the member for Christchurch for securing this debate. He's pressed this issue for many years under both governments, and he deserves credit for his persistence. So I want to begin where the inquiry begins: with success. Baroness Hallett described the UK's vaccine development as one of the success stories of the pandemic, and I am proud of the leading role the former Conservative government played in that. It backed vaccines early and at risk, set up the vaccine task force under Kate Bingham, and on the 2nd of December 2020, the UK became the first country in the world to approve the Pfizer vaccine.
Across 2021, some 132 million doses were given, the largest vaccination program in our history. The credit belongs to the scientists, the NHS workers, the pharmacists, the 360,000 volunteers who signed up for trials, and the public. But the inquiry's report is not only a story of success. Its five recommendations set out what must be done better, and it is on those that the government's response published on the 16th of October needs scrutiny. On recommendation 4, faster access to health data so that the MHRA can monitor vaccine safety, the government agrees, and then it says it will need, and I quote, significant investment over time.
There is no timeline and there's no funding promise. Reports to the Yellow Card scheme rose by 75% between 2020 and 2022, which shows that people are willing to report; the system must be able to act on what they tell it. Now, as my honorable friend expressed in his remarks, recommendation 5 is where the response is weakest.
The inquiry said the government must reform the vaccine damage payment scheme as soon as possible. And it set four minimums: raise the 120,000 pound payment at least in line with inflation, uprate it annually, introduce multiple levels of payment according to the degree of injury, and provide fair transitional arrangements. Now, as my honourable friend for Bromsgrove has said, the government's response gives no date, no figure, and no commitment to any one of them. Meanwhile, the cost of administering the scheme rose from 8.9 million pounds in 22-23 to 29.2 million pounds in 25-26, around 83 million across four years. By my reckoning, awards over the same period come to about 31 million pounds.
A scheme that spends more than twice as much on administration as on compensation is not working for taxpayers or for the claimants. Now, my right honourable friend the member for Louth and Horncastle ordered a review of the scheme before the last election, and I wish it had concluded sooner. But this government has now had more than two years. I concede that on this occasion the government has kept its word and responded within six months. But a response delivered on time is not the same as a response that commits to anything, and as I say, there is still no timetable.
As my right honourable friend the member for Kenilworth and Southam so eloquently put it, ultimately vaccine confidence matters. The best way to protect it is to show that when something goes wrong, the state stands behind the person. The vaccine programme was a success. Let us make sure the system built around it is worthy of that success. So I ask the minister a number of questions.
Firstly, will the government set out a timetable for its review of the vaccine damage payment scheme and the reform it intends to make? Second, which of the inquiry's four minimum reforms will the government commit to? Thirdly, will it look again at the 60% threshold, set performance targets for processing claims, and bring administration costs under control? Fourth, will it strengthen the yellow card scheme with funding commitments and a date for the health data framework? One I've just added now, will she meet with my right honourable friend for Tatton, who's been seeking a meeting for such a long time?
And finally, Mr Stewart, will the minister bring forward proposals before my honourable friend's bill, which as he mentioned is scheduled for second reading on the 15th of January? I'm sure my honourable friend and I look forward to the minister's response.
Diana Ruth Johnson
Thank you, Mr Stewart, and it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this afternoon as my next-door neighbour in East Yorkshire. I'd like to start by thanking the honourable gentleman the member for Christchurch for securing this debate, and I want to pay tribute to him for his work on the APPG for pandemic response and recovery and for all of his campaigning work over so many years. And it was interesting that he referenced his first speech in this area on the, I think in 2021, so persistence is certainly a quality that my the honourable gentleman has. And can I also say, of course, I'm very willing always to meet with honourable members and right honourable members too. And I think this has been a very a very good debate on such an important topic.
My honourable friend for Worthing West, I think, who speaks with great authority as a public health consultant, set out some of the very good work that happened during the pandemic and also the international perspective as well that we need to be mindful of. The right honourable gentleman for Kenilworth and Southam, obviously a very doughty campaigner on behalf of his constituent Kate Scott, made a very eloquent speech as ever, and I agree with him about the issue of timeliness.
I absolutely take that point. My honorable friend for Blaydon and Middleton South, who took us back to some of the decisions, the key decisions that were made during the pandemic. The honorable member for Great Yarmouth, who delivered a speech that sadly I felt was anti-vaccination, didn't recognize the public health benefits of vaccinations. The honorable member for Bromsgrove, who spoke very movingly about John Cross and his family and the fight that his family had had and the need for reform of the vaccine damage payment scheme. And the right honorable lady for Tatton, who of course I will meet as soon as possible with and the family as well.
So, Mr. Stewart, during the pandemic, we on these benches did our best to offer constructive opposition to the previous government, and this government is committed to learning every lesson from the COVID inquiry. We are extremely grateful to the noble Baroness Hallett and her team for the thoughtful and thorough advice that they've offered to us so far. At the end of next week, we will mark 80 years since the National Health Service Act became law, paving the way for the introduction of the NHS two years later. And it will be a chance to remember and pay tribute to all those who served the public with such courage and professionalism over the pandemic, not least our social care workforce, whose contribution has been overlooked for too long. So turning to module four, we are also grateful to the small army of researchers, clinicians, and regulators who worked around the clock to ensure that vaccines were deployed at speed, having gone through the rigorous safeguards of a clinical trial.
But while it is recognized the success of the vaccine program, module four reports also sets out a series of recommendations in areas for improvement. For example, the future vaccination and therapeutics program must of course have people's trust, be guided by the best available evidence, and remain available to all who need them. The inquiry also notes that safety monitoring must continue to evolve with improvements to health data infrastructure, and the government published our response to these recommendations earlier this month. And we're taking action across the board to improve vaccination uptake, pandemic preparedness, and the strength of UK life sciences, especially through our pandemic preparedness strategy. If the last pandemic taught us anything, it's the UK life sciences are not just vital for UK growth, it's that they play a central and strategic role in how we respond to health threats.
We propose to establish an advisory group with our partners in industry, building resilience across our supply chains. Now, vaccination uptake is not where it needs to be, especially for children, and that is why we need stronger engagement with communities, particularly with those communities where uptake is lower than average. And as the Minister for Public Health, I'm especially concerned by the re-emergence of measles and other diseases that we thought had been banished when I was a girl. I also just wanted to respond to my honorable friend on the issue of targets. We still have the target, the World Health Organization target of 95% coverage.
Now, I'm determined to make sure that protection that vaccines afford remains available to the many and not the few. And I've also been clear that there must be strong collaboration across our United Kingdom, because diseases do not stop at Offa's Dyke or at Hadrian's Wall. And we are strengthening the way we monitor outbreaks while improving access to linked healthcare data across all four nations.
But I now want to turn to recommendation five, and specifically to the Vaccine Damage Payment Scheme, which is an important financial support for anyone who has been severely disabled following a vaccination. 53 million people followed the example of Her Late Majesty the Queen and took the jab to protect themselves, their loved ones, and their communities. This country has a global reputation for our uncompromising approach to safety, and vaccines are only authorised once they have met robust standards of effectiveness, safety, and quality. However, in rare, devastating circumstances, some people have gone through the nightmare of losing a loved one or suffered severe adverse outcomes following vaccination. These are people who did as they were asked in good faith, and through no fault of their own, have become disabled or worse.
And we can never turn a blind eye to the tragic instances where things go wrong, and we must continue to be honest with the wider public that no vaccine is completely free of risk. So this afternoon, I have listened very carefully to the concerns raised about the current scheme, the support available to those affected, the experiences of those who've made claims, and the time it's taken to respond to these concerns. People who experience severe outcomes deserve appropriate support. This is not just about the welfare of those families, important though that is. As the right honourable gentleman said, it's about public trust in our wider vaccine programme, because people must be confident stepping into the clinic that the state will be there for them if things go wrong.
Now, the honourable gentleman asked me about when did we start to review the VDPS scheme. I wanted to be very clear on this, because I know previous ministers have stood and given answers on this. The department has been considering options for reform and will now initiate a period of open engagement with those affected. We're going beyond the case for reform and turning now to the detail that must underpin any reforms. And the honourable gentleman for Bromsgrove asked me if the government, and a number of members did the same, asked me whether the government accept that 60% disability threshold is too high and will we consider changing it.
The government understands the concerns raised about the 60% disability threshold by the inquiry. The inquiry's recommendations will be central to our ongoing work as the government considers a range of options for potential reform, including introducing those multiple levels of payment. Last week, I met with injured and bereaved families. I understood their frustrations about how long this is taking, when successive governments have kicked this can down the road. I'm happy to give way.
Jeremy Paul Wright
I'm very grateful to the minister for giving way. On the point she makes about whether or not graded payments might be available under the scheme, can she be clear that what she's considering is linking that to the disablement requirement, because of course what we would not want as an outcome is simply reducing the 120,000 pounds for those who are 60% disabled or more. What we are interested in is perhaps giving some money to those who are below the 60% threshold. Can she confirm that's what she's thinking about?
Diana Ruth Johnson
Yes, I'm very happy to say that's what I'm thinking about, because of the unfairness of just that 60% barrier that you have to get through.
So yes, I'm certainly looking at that and that that will be considered. Not saying exactly what's going to be decided, but that's certainly an option that I've asked officials to look at. So I was just saying that I'd met with some injured and bereaved families in recent days and understood their frustration about how long everything was taking and that successive governments appear to have kicked the can down the road. And I note that the scheme has not been reformed since I was a member of the last Labour government in 2007, and of course it must now be made fit for the future. And I think we can all agree on that.
And that's why ministers will again meet with families of those injured and bereaved before the end of the year. And in the coming weeks, before Christmas, my officials will meet with advisers put forward by the families of those injured and bereaved to listen to their views on possible options for reform of the vaccine damage payment scheme. From now until spring, officials will meet and engage with our key partners, including those injured and bereaved, to discuss the reforms. And I look forward to updating colleagues in the spring. Nearly everyone in our country, yes, I'm very happy to give way.
Esther McVey
Thank the minister indeed. My specific concerns as well is about the MHRA, which is meant to highlight, give out warnings of what's going on, and it is their failure throughout this. So again, when we meet, can we also discuss the failings of the MHRA?
Diana Ruth Johnson
Yes, I'm very happy to meet with the right honourable lady and to discuss all of the points that she wishes to raise. I think nearly everyone in our country remembers when they walked into their local clinic or pharmacy, or even their church hall, or the school sports hall, or the village hall to get their jab. We remember with pride how a country rallied together as part of a national effort to save lives. For most of us, the vaccine was a welcome relief, offering additional freedoms and safety. But for some families, it brought that devastating loss and hardship.
And as the new minister responsible for this policy, I want to say to colleagues that I am committed to working closely with those families that I met just last week, and I want progress to be made quickly. And I also want to say that we'll report any interim progress through the UK COVID-19 inquiry implementation updates. The public have a right to know that we are learning from past mistakes, and as the Minister for Public Health, I will never take their trust for granted. The government's response to module four will not be some exercise in box-ticking or window dressing, because we know when it comes to preparing for future public health emergencies, that readiness is all and we need the trust of our communities.
Christopher Chope
Minister, I'm grateful to the minister for that response and I'm grateful for everybody who's participated in this debate. And nobody can doubt the sincerity of what the minister has said. I hope that not just she's going to be talking to the families, but also to parliamentarians, because lots of us have got constituents. And I've got an extract here from the Telegraph saying, paralysed vaccine victim not ill enough for payout. That's an example of the issues that are in that particular victim was working for the NHS as a nurse.
And so we need action. And can I say that what the tone of what the minister has said seems more like a placebo. And placebos have their place in healthcare, but I think we need to go further than that. And she talks about the spring. Well, we're still in the autumn.
Why can't we get some action now? And all the time the government knew what was going on at the inquiry. The victims gave evidence at the inquiry. The inquiry made its recommendations. And why can't the government now accept those four recommendations in the recommendation five?
That's what I don't understand and I'm not satisfied in that respect, and I shall continue to campaign on this, I hope for not another five years, Mr. Stewart.
Graham Stuart
The question is that this House has considered the government response to the COVID-19 inquiry module four report. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. Order, order, the sitting stands adjourned.