Westminster Hall
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Westminster Hall Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsJim Shannon
When we look at the global picture as well, and we will look at the global picture because it's incredibly worrying as well. The scale of the crisis is mammoth. The United Nations estimates that approximately 200 million people aged 60 and over are currently living in fragile or conflict-affected settings. And just for a few moments, just let that number sink in.
Living in fear, living without adequate healthcare, living without adequate sheltering, shelter, living too often without any recognition that their needs are specific, are urgent, and are distinct from those of younger people in the same crisis zone. Now, I wanted this debate because I felt, I have felt for some time, that we look at the wars and we do things as we see in common, as we, we see the young people and we see the deaths and we see the non-education, we see the medical health, but in the middle of that, you'll see old people, and elderly, those of a, of an older generation, those of an older generation who are having incredible problems. We see this with devastating clarity in Ukraine. And, and whenever we read the stories out of Ukraine, they, they always move me quite, quite significantly, Mr. Chairman and members. And, and you see who's left in the villages that are destroyed, who's left amongst the ruins?
Usually the older people living in the basements. And, and I, I want to just focus on them for a few moments if I can.
So I've stood consistently, or as has this House, as has the Minister, and as has every member here, with the Ukrainian people in their hour of need. Ukraine has the highest proportion of older people affected by conflict anywhere in the world, with one in four Ukrainians aged over 60. In eastern and southern Ukraine, near the front line, it's even more acute, with one in three people needing assistance being aged over 60 years of age. When the families fled, of course, to get away from the violence, to get away from the attacks, to get away from the Russian aggression, 5.4% of those refugees arriving in Europe were over 65. Why? Because our elderly people are left behind, either choosing to remain in their homes because it's the only place they have, usually with their pets, their cats or their dogs.
But also because of severe health conditions, and that makes fleeing conflict zones more difficult, even though the Ukrainians always try and give them the choice of being able to leave.
This has left older people facing acute challenges. Shockingly, around 50% of documented civilian deaths in Ukraine have been people older than 60 years of age. They face severe disruptions to their support systems as family members, friends, or carers have all left. And 90% of older people in Ukraine are unable to pay for even their basic medical needs to be met. And the other thing about it is they're probably in the conflict zones, and very often their medications or the medical help that they need cannot get to them.
And 43% of those, of course, have at least one disability.
We know from my position as health spokesperson for my party here that when you get to a certain age, you don't just have one thing wrong with you, you maybe have a half a dozen things. Complex needs are incredibly common amongst many older people. And that makes evacuations and displacement even more challenging. They face barriers of mobility, of digital exclusion, and bureaucratic complexity that becomes insurmountable when you're 80 years old and have lost just about everything that you ever had, including your family, including many others as well. Mr. Chairman, I speak as someone who has spent considerable time examining the collapse of health systems under the pressure of conflict.
And I want to underline the point of account with some force. Older people have healthcare needs that are complex, that are chronic, that are ongoing. They need orthopedic care.
Many of the old people you see will be struggling to get about at all. And whenever you're in a war zone and you're under attack, it makes it even more difficult. They need cardiac monitoring as well. They need management of long-term conditions like diabetes, of which I'm a recipient of that, respiratory disease, hypertension, dementia. These aren't luxuries.
These are the basic requirements of survival. So when a conflict destroys a hospital or a medical center or a GP surgery, when it displaces a medical team, when it cuts off a supply chain of medicines, it is the older people who suffer first and who suffer most.
Long-term conditions are worsened, of course, by food and income security, the pressures of displacement, living in complex situations, no shops. You live by the most small means of cooking. It may only be a wee calor gas thing or something. It may be even wood in a fire that may be your methodology of cooking. The waiting lists that I have seen grow to crisis point here in Northern Ireland, even in peacetime, are as nothing compared to what older people face when the infrastructure of healthcare is obliterated by war itself.
So let's look at some of those places across the world, Mr. Chairman and fellow members, where the harrowing theaters of war, I would like to focus upon two if I can, please.
Lebanon: older people face compounding risks from the escalation of hostilities, rising displacement, economic collapse, and pressure on a weakened health system. A 2024 HelpAge assessment of 670 older women and men across five regions found that they were frequently excluded from assistance and recovery planning because they're at an age, they're probably still in the danger zones, and little or no effort is made to help them. 61% received no humanitarian aid after the conflict, 39% reported being completely left out of the response even during active hostilities, and only 12% of those who did receive aid said it met their needs. So many have been unwilling or indeed unable to leave their homes despite evacuation orders, while those who fled found shelters poorly equipped for mobility, for care, and for dignity.
And all those three things are so important. Lebanon illustrates a wider failure. Aid may be present, yes, but if it is not designed around older people's access needs, including the right reach, including transport support, continuity of medication, assistive devices, home-based care, and mental health support, it will not reach those most at risk. Because who's at the back of the queue? Those of an elderly generation.
Sudan's my second place where I want to focus. And today in business questions, a question was asked about Sudan. There was also questions asked about Sudan in an earlier question, which the Secretary of State replied to earlier on. I led a debate in this hall, Mr. Chairman, I think it was four weeks today, on Sudan, and we highlighted the issues of Sudan, and it is absolutely tragic what's happening there.
Since fighting erupted in April 2023, Sudan has seen repeated waves of displacement. More than 20 million people need health assistance, and around 1 million of them are older people. Civilians face worsening conflict in the Kordofan region and risk escalated violence, confinement, and starvation. And the UN figures, which corroborate and give an evidential base to this, show older men and women each make up about 4% of the population living in displacement camps, while around 3% live in refugee camps in neighboring countries. So older people remain, remain one of the least supported groups in Sudan.
Human rights monitors report that they are often left out of the aid programs, especially in remote areas.
I know there is a massive task to respond to, to, to the aid that's needed and to get to the remote areas. I understand that. But there has to be some consideration given for that. I've some ideas at the end, which I'm hopeful the Minister will give us some encouragement with. Due to limited mobility, many struggle to flee explosions or attacks.
You just, I mean, I'm 71, I can't run the marathon no more. I could probably walk it, but I couldn't run it. And those who are on mobility aids can't walk or run at any speed whatsoever. So they can't get away from the impending destruction that's coming their way. With health, younger people, or sorry, older people also face high rates of depression and post-traumatic stress.
As you get older, Mr. Chairman, maybe you and I would recognize this particular trait, we do tend to perhaps maybe things worry us more perhaps than they did when we were younger, you know. But I say that in jest, but the fact is that we do sometimes dwell upon things longer than perhaps we should.
As you get older, Mr. Chairman, maybe you and I would recognize this, this particular trait.
Clive Betts
I hope the honorable member doesn't take my views for granted in this sort of debate, and he can speak for himself, I'm sure.
Jim Shannon
Yeah, I speak for myself, but I think you're not too far off my age, Mr. Chairman, and I suspect I'm older than you, but there you are. Due to the health centers being destroyed, medicines in short supply, even those with manageable conditions are at grave risk. In parts of Darfur, dozens of older people are among those who have died of hunger in recent months after armed groups blocked the food deliveries themselves.
And who can't get to the aid centers or the food centers because of their disability, because of their needs? The older people. Why is this allowed to happen? Because older people are invisible in the data. And we often come back to data when it comes to debates, debates on health, debates on anything perhaps, because older people, when it comes to data collection and analysis, fail to capture older people's realities, with data collection often stopping before the age of 60.
So if you're over 60, your time in this world, according to those who take data, is limited.
Where they are included, they're often lumped together as a single group, those over 60 years, which obscures diversity and hinders effective policy making. Evidence shows that age inclusion specialists can change humanitarian systems by improving assessments, the data collection, the training, the program design, and the data collection tools used by HelpAge Ethiopia as one example, identified six times more older people in one region of Tigray than had been previously known because the data wasn't there, because the information wasn't available, and the numbers of older people were unknown. In Venezuela, age inclusion specialists supported humanitarian actors through adjusted food basket guidance to better meet nutritional needs. So they used the data for the betterment.
And Venezuela, unfortunately, at the moment, has had some double earthquakes and many people are missing and they have incredible problems. Furthermore, a 2025 systematic found the barriers to age-inclusive healthcare include inaccessible health service, shortages of medication and equipment, limited geriatric expertise, age discrimination, low mobility, and dependence on others. And more often than not for elderly people, there is a dependence on others. Funding reform is desperately needed. HelpAge's 2025 analysis found older people are rarely named in humanitarian funding databases.
So how can you deliver the need, the aid, the medication, the food, the help, the support to the numbers of elderly people if you don't know how many they are? With 6.5% of descriptions mentioning older people and only 0.1% of the project's titles.
I must also raise the question, and I always do it, Mr. Chairman, you'd expect me to, on the question of freedom of religion or belief because it's intrinsic to this debate in ways that are not always acknowledged. In many conflict zones, in Myanmar, in Nigeria, in Syria, in Ethiopia, older people are targeted not merely because they're in the wrong place at the wrong time, but because they are the custodians of their community's faith and culture. The honorable lady who is going to speak after me, she and I share this concern and I look forward to her contribution. Those elderly people, those who are the custodians of a community's faith and culture, they're the ones who hold the memory of worship, of tradition, of identity. They're the heartbeat of the congregation, they're the lifeblood of the community.
And because of that, they are targeted. They're driven from their homes because of their faith.
They are denied the right to practice their faith that has sustained them across a lifetime of living. This is not simply a humanitarian failure, it's a moral outrage. And the question, one of the questions, does the Minister agree that the protection of older people in conflict zones must explicitly include the protection of their right to freedom of religion or belief? I know the Minister's answer to that, of course, but just for the record for Hansard, perhaps we can have that. I don't want to be churlish either in relation about the progress that has been made in international humanitarian law.
There are frameworks, there are conventions, there are and there is a Sphere Handbook. There is the Inter-Agency Standing Committee's work on inclusion.
But let me be direct, if I can, in a respectful way. The gap between the frameworks that exist on paper and the reality experienced by an 80-year-old woman sheltering in a basement in Kharkiv, or a 75-year-old pastor driven from his church in Kaduna State in Nigeria, is vast and it is unconscionable. So I have a number of questions to ask the Minister, please, and I think there are seven to be precise. Can I ask the Minister these things in order? Make humanitarian aid age-inclusive by default.
By default, will the Minister commit to requiring UK-funded programs to explicitly and systematically identify and reach older people, including those living alone, with disabilities, with chronic illnesses, or unable to travel to distribution points? And when it comes to protecting older people's healthcare and well-being, will the FCDO prioritize the continuity of medication, accessible health services, assistive devices, safe evacuation, accessible shelters, home-based care if possible, and mental health support in active conflicts? Will the government support universal social pensions, inclusive cash assistance, and shock-responsive systems that enable older people to meet their own priorities with dignity? That's when it comes to age-inclusive cash and social protection. And will the department also include older people in the protection and in their responses?
Pre-existing patterns of discrimination are exacerbated during conflict, and extreme levels of violence against women and girls is a recurring theme. Older women are particularly at risk due to age, gender, disability, carrying responsibilities, widowhood, or financial dependence. And the UK international strategic framework on women and girls fails to consider how older women are affected. And I think it must, there must be some focus for older women in particular. Will government ensure implementation includes explicit reference to older women's humanitarian protection, safeguarding, and programs that tackle gender-based violence through a life-course approach?
The Russian army, and some of them, not them all, but a proportion of them, have carried out some horrendous sexual attacks upon girls as young as eight and women as old as 80. And I've spoken about this in the chamber in the past, and I think we need to protect women of all ages.
And will we count older people properly? Will the minister require age, sex, and disability disaggregated data, including specific age cohorts beyond 60, that age 60 where it seems to stop? Well, if you're over 60, you're in a category of we don't know about you, for all humanitarian assistance that the UK government provides or supports. And we must recognize older people as rights holders as well. And will the UK support the creation of a UN convention on the rights of older persons to recognize older people's agency and contributions, and better facilitate their participation in humanitarian planning, peacebuilding, monitoring, and local decision-making?
And will the Minister engage directly with the relevant ministers in the devolved administrations of Scotland and Wales, and also in Northern Ireland, where we have hard-won knowledge of what conflict does to older people across generations, so that the lived experience of communities like mine can inform and enrich our international humanitarian policy? So I opened the conversation, Mr. Chairman, with Margaret. So I close as I began with Margaret. She told me once, and some of the words I can't forget, that the worst thing about conflict is not the noise of it. The worst thing, she said to me, is the silence that comes after, when the world moves on and forgets that you're still carrying all that pain and all that memory and trauma.
So the older people, Mr. Chairman, of Ukraine, of Sudan, of Lebanon, of the Sahel, and of every conflict zone across the world are still carrying it. The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, this great nation, the four nations together as one, has both the capacity and the moral duty, I believe, to ensure that they're not forgotten. So I commend this debate to the House. I thank members for turning up. I look forward to their contributions.
I look forward to the shadow, I very much look forward to the Minister's contribution and looking forward to his encouragement. But I look forward as well to ensure that the older people in conflict are not forgotten about. There's ways of doing it better. Let's start now. Thank you.
Rachael Maskell
The question is this House has considered humanitarian impact of conflicts on older people. Rachael Maskell.
Mr. Betts, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I do congratulate the honorable member for Strangford in securing this debate and also wish his mother a very happy birthday for next Tuesday. In many areas of deep conflict, the population rarely reach the definitions that we give to older people. In Gaza, life expectancy has plummeted from 73 years to just 40.5 years. Sudan, 66 years.
Nigeria, 55, and likewise with Chad. Compare that to 81.3 years here in the UK and the privilege we have in being safe and secure as a nation, conflict-free. And of course, Japan, 84.7 years.
It shows that conflict shortens lives by decades through poor access to healthcare and pharmaceuticals, disability, disruption and displacement, prevalence of disease and hastened frailty in an environment of climate change, floods and famine. Gender-based violence scars the lives of its survivors, an issue I am so proud our Foreign Secretary has rightly placed at the heart of her work as we see the prevalence as this weapon used in war. Access to healthcare, an issue I particularly look at here in the House, is significantly reduced as the targeting of health facilities and health professionals has now been seen as central in many conflicts. We've seen that happening in Gaza and we've also seen that in Sudan, where health professionals run the risk not only in the work that they do, but are targeted by weapons to take them out. And of course, breaking the rules of just wars.
But these wars, of course, are never just. But also we have seen the shrinking capacity of healthcare against increased demand, whether that is from the the wounds of war, but also the sharp rise we're seeing of sexual violence against women, the poor mental health which is sustained. And as a result of that, the the access, the ability to access healthcare is reduced and that, of course, will always impact older people most. And often in war we look at the wounds and of course we understand why. But it's the chronic conditions, the cancers, the diabetes, the other illnesses which often get forgotten.
The drugs not getting through, the treatments not available, the clinicians simply diverted onto the acute phases.
And of course our hearts beat when we know that a child has been rescued or a life has been saved. But the life of an older person is of equal value. And yet often the resources are not there to either save or sustain that life. It's often seen in conflict zones that as the honourable gentleman said, it's the elderly that stay behind because they cannot move, they cannot be displaced. They stay in those areas and of course in Ukraine we have seen that, but also in so many other areas.
We know from our own research that if you move when you're elderly, it will have other weights on you and can cause much confusion, it can also have a real impact on your mental well-being.
So when we see older people in those most acute areas of conflict, we are really, we really take on board why so many older people die in conflict because they're in direct firing line, or of course the facilities and the infrastructure which keeps them going is removed. And of course, it's not just about healthcare. It's about social care. It's about that social infrastructure, the family no longer available to provide that support. Even things like state provision are disrupted, pensions no longer available.
And of course, simple things like food supplies are diverted into emergency and humanitarian aid. And this is why it's so important that we put older people at the front of all agendas.
I say this also, Chair, as the Chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Ageing and Older People, a matter I take so seriously. And now, of course, with severe cuts to international aid, it makes the humanitarian response more challenging. And I really do urge the government to return to 0.7% as a matter of urgency to provide that leadership once again to ensure that we can provide the aid, of course not that everyone will be able to receive, but as many people as possible, because older lives matter too.
And of course, when the infrastructure breaks down, the resilience plummets, and particularly stark amongst older people. So government must be mindful of this when appraising its priorities, because without financial resilience, and especially for women in conflict zones, even the basics become barriers. Ensuring aid has this concession and makes provision in food, care, medicines and support needs to be such a lifeline. But of course, it's not just about the physical impact of destitution and health consequences, the psychological trauma must be recognized too. It is the elders who play such a pivotal role in communities and families.
If their resilience is broken, so is that of their societies. In many societies to this day, women are at particular risk of violence and abuse, including sexual violence, and it has been such a taboo subject, not least amongst that generation, and yet so traumatic.
I recall last Ukraine Day when in our constituency an event was held and I heard from a Ukraine woman and saw a film about the sexual violence being perpetrated against women in Ukraine and the horrors that that and the scars that it has left them with. They didn't speak because of the shame it brought them of the trauma that they were going through. And yet when they started to share their stories, it brought that healing between them. But of course, without the proper support, the psychological care wrapped around individuals, that healing doesn't come. And that's why I'm so proud again that our Foreign Secretary has recognized that and put resource into it, particularly in the Sudan region.
But for those women, we need to make sure they do access that support too. Of course.
John Milne
I'm grateful to my honorable friend for giving way. She's making a very powerful and important speech, particularly on women in Ukraine who have suffered sexual violence during war. I wonder if she agrees with me that having proper support for those women and an ability to record what they have experienced is important, not just to support them, but to make sure that when the war in Ukraine ends, that justice, as much as it can be done, is done for those people.
Rachael Maskell
I'm really grateful to my honorable friend raising this point because of course, having that catalog of war crimes being made is so important.
And whether they're elderly or anyone who has experienced that sexual violence or any forms of violence, it's absolutely crucial that good records are kept because we need to be able to hold to account the perpetrators of that violence when that opportunity arises. And of course with older people we know that if you don't get the right nutrition it has such a massive impact on your ability to function. Without the right nutrition you can have greater episodes of confusion, life can be much more challenging, you become more frail and with rapidity you then you can lose your mobility and as a result face more complex needs. So ensuring that we see that good distribution of humanitarian aid is absolutely vital for the vulnerable and that always factored in is that access to to that targeted support.
Not only making sure people have got the ability to to reach that food, but that it is prepared in the right way for them as well. And of course, in talking about some of the challenges we've seen in Sudan of late and of course it's a most horrendous complex war and I'm glad that it was discussed at the NATO summit just recently and and remains at the forefront of our government's minds. It is very much a forgotten war in so many places. And what evidence has showed is that the elderly there have been in the direct line of violence and it is so important that that is not forgotten either. But older people, not least women, have a crucial role in home, community and often that role ripples out far beyond.
They are often the ones that build the bridges, build the civil society, create the pathways to peace, organize communities at their most challenged. And it's often the older women using the wisdom that they bring that are able to bring that coordination and build a way to the future. And indeed I've been inspired by many leaders of older women who have led that charge out of conflict and into a more resilient future. But we also must recognize there are significant challenges there. So first of all I really want to ask the government what they're doing to provide better protections for older people.
The rights of older people.
As an all-party parliamentary group, we undertook an inquiry into the human rights of older people, looking at what are the frameworks, the mechanisms that we can deploy in order to enhance them, protect them, and ensure people were able to uphold them. And looking at the work that the UN convention has been focused on on the rights of older people has been inspiring, very much along the lines that other rights have been established, whether around the child or disabled people, ensuring that the protected characteristic of older people is upheld.
And of course it falls on the Foreign Office to be able to advance that work and ensure that the UK plays a full role, bring our experience into that space so that older people's identity can be seen and their needs particularly supported. So I ask the Minister exactly what are we doing in leading that work and whether or not the UK will adopt the UN convention once it has been established in order to ensure that women, men, and older people across the piece are able to have their value recognized and their rights upheld. And having a rights-based framework then moves the agenda. It enables us to then focus on that protected characteristic, have age-inclusive specialists who can help reprioritize the humanitarian response, like changes to health or care, but of course making sure that we also have good data to accompany that as well so we know exactly how to focus the humanitarian response we have.
And of course with regards to healthcare ensuring pharmaceuticals and equipment are available to meet the demographic that we're talking about today in conflict areas. And when only 0.1% of humanitarian funding databases even mention older people currently, we know we have a problem. And so the Foreign Office must ensure that older people are written into all of our work, and I seek that assurance from the Minister today, and that we spread that good practice to agencies but also other nations too.
So will the Government ensure that its humanitarian response is always age-inclusive and understands the risks that older people face when social infrastructure is destroyed by conflict? And will the Government also ensure that it understands the distribution has to be targeted to reach the elderly with both chronic and acute health needs, wherever that focus is required? Will the Government also promote the opportunity of social protections, like social security pensions, amongst older people in areas of conflict zones to ensure that people are able to access the resources they need? Of course, like here, in many countries, being able to use more traditional ways of accessing those services is really important too.
And ultimately, can the government also ensure it does crunch the numbers in conflict areas to use that data to well-design humanitarian responses, recognizing the prevalence of older people and recognizing the focus that they need? Finally, as I just bring my remarks to a close, I recognize that the game changer, the pivotal part in this, will be having a UN convention on the rights of older people. And I just want to make that point again, because it is about giving older people agency in conflict zones to better facilitate their participation in humanitarian planning, in peacebuilding, monitoring, and decision-making.
So I look forward to the Minister's response and indeed shadow minister and the spokesperson for the Lib Dems and trust that we can rebuild our humanitarian response with good data, programs and rights to support older people in conflict.
Clive Betts
We now move on to the front benches. Each of the front benches has got at least their entitled 10 minutes. Of course we're not particularly time constrained today, so I'll leave it with them to make a judgment. On to the Lib Dem spokesperson, it is John Milne.
John Milne
Thank you, thank you Mr. Betts and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I'd like to thank the honorable member for Strangford for securing this debate and shining a light on an important but often overlooked issue. It's a strange thing to see that many of the same voices who mourn Britain's declining influence on the world stage are also the first to say that we should spend nothing beyond our own shores. They say that the 0.7% commitment to development spending was some kind of national indulgence we can no longer afford. But our influence never really relied on hard power alone.
Our leverage in the world comes from working with others and leading by example. That is what internationalism means, and it is why the Liberal Democrats believe that the commitment to international aid is not merely sentimental. It's fundamental, it's strategic. It rests on a simple principle of equality: we help those who need help most. I don't want to create a league table in suffering, but some groups do bear a heavier burden in humanitarian crises.
Older people, especially if they're disabled, are almost always among the most affected.
When Hurricane Katrina struck New Orleans in 2005, 75% of those who died were over 60, yet older people made up only 16% of the local population. And when the Great East Japan earthquake and tsunami struck in 2011, 56% of those who lost their lives were aged 65 and over. The world today is less stable than it has been in a generation. Since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine began in February 2022, OHCHR has found that older people account for almost half of all civilian deaths where age could be verified. Older people, especially women, remain at disproportionate risk, and that's particularly in frontline areas.
So knowing all this, it is extraordinary that the FCDO confirmed cuts to precisely the funds that support the most vulnerable groups in humanitarian response. The International Development Committee found that the FCDO's own equality impact assessments concluded that ODA reductions on programming with a strong focus on equalities is expected to be severe. In South Sudan specifically, the committee heard that work on disability and inclusion will cease altogether, and that will have a direct impact on elderly people. UN figures show that more than 46% of people aged 60 and over live with a disability, and more than 250 million older people worldwide experience moderate to severe disability.
In the UK, the House of Commons Library's analysis shows that disability prevalence rises from 23% among working-age adults in the UK to 45% among adults over state pension age and to 58% among those aged 80 and over. So when disability inclusion funding is cut in a humanitarian response, older people will therefore be hit twice over. It's not an unfortunate side effect, it is a foreseeable and measurable consequence. I want to press the government on the false choice it keeps presenting between defense and development, particularly in the context of Ukraine. ODA budgets are part of defending Ukraine.
For example, they fund in part accessible bomb shelters. They fund healthcare adaptations for people with mobility needs or age-related conditions. If we are serious about supporting Ukraine, are the lives of its oldest citizens not part of that commitment?
Liberal Democrats reject the idea that we must choose. We have set out how defence spending can rise to 2.5% of GDP and beyond through mechanisms like defence bonds and a higher digital services tax on the largest technology firms, and that is without hollowing out our aid budget. We advocate for the immediate restoration of ODA to 0.5% of GNI with a clear roadmap back to 0.7%. The American example in this is not one to follow. USAID has been gutted by an administration that treats development spending as something somehow unpatriotic.
Within the older age group, the situation of women reveals a heightened case of danger.
Amnesty International's submission to the UN independent expert on the human rights of older persons documents this starkly. In northeast Nigeria, older women displaced by Boko Haram face particularly severe discrimination and invisibility. They were often unsuccessful when they tried to petition simply to be added to food distribution lists. And in Ukraine, women's pensions are on average 30% lower than men's, which is a consequence of shorter careers and interrupted employment caused by caregiving responsibilities. Older women also experience higher rates of disabling conditions than men of the same age, such as arthritis, osteoporosis, and frailty.
As a result, older women are disproportionately exposed to poverty when displaced.
The social role played by women, as mentioned by my colleague earlier, as caregivers means that if they suffer, the impact is felt by the whole extended family. If they're left without income, without accessible healthcare, or without a place in the food queue, the people who depend on their care feel it also. If the government wants to talk about return on investment in its development spending, this is exactly where that return is the greatest. Supporting older women is not a niche ask, it's a multiplier for entire households and communities. I'm speaking for the Liberal Democrats, but of course it's not just us.
Amnesty International has set out practical, deliverable recommendations.
We must disaggregate humanitarian data by age, gender, and disability so that we can actually see who's being missed out. And we must ensure that older people are not systematically excluded from livelihood and cash assistance programs on the discriminatory assumption that they cannot work. The humanitarian inclusion standards for older people and people with disabilities, which is developed by the sector's own age and disability inclusion consortium, already exist and they are freely available. I ask the minister to confirm that the FCDO is using them, and if not, why not. So to conclude, the Liberal Democrats believe that this government does not need new evidence to act.
It needs to start listening to the evidence it already has.
It needs to listen to its own equality impact assessments, rather than commissioning them and then quietly setting them aside, as has happened all too often in previous rounds of cuts. It needs to make use of the evidence-based inclusion standards that the humanitarian sector has already built, rather than trying to reinvent the wheel or indeed ignoring it altogether. And of course, it needs to restore ODA to first 0.5% of GNI with a published roadmap back to 0.7%, so that the targeted programs reaching older people, and older women in particular, are not the first thing to be sacrificed when budgets tighten. I look forward to the minister's response. Thank you.
Andrew Snowden
Thank you very much, Mr. Betts.
It is a chair, what a pleasure once again to serve with you in the chair. And I thank the honorable member for Stretford for bringing this debate. Although the last debate that the honorable member brought that I contributed into was a few weeks ago on stoma care, when we managed to get some rather interesting entries into Hansard when we were giving out the names that people give to their stomas, some of them quite inappropriate. But actually in that debate that was quite interesting, which connects through to this, is the way in which conditions do affect older people in different ways. And particularly therefore if you translate that, and for example the way we had that debate a few weeks ago about people with stomas and how older people with stomas have very specific care needs, and how that would translate into a war zone or into a refugee camp, can give you an example very much of how that suffering would be greatened.
And as always through referencing his constituent Margaret, he brings to life the fact that whilst we often in these debates talk about statistics and we talk about facts and we talk in broad terms, each of those are indeed a person with their own story to tell and their own suffering. I thank the honorable member for York Central for her contribution and for her long-standing commitments. I've been in a number of debates where the honorable member has spoken and whilst I have a different view to her in terms of aid spending and support the government's position, I do recognize that she has long-standing and very sincerely held views on this subject and debates like this are where those views can be exchanged and she has remained consistent in her views and advocated for them over a number of times.
I shall break the jolly consensus just to respond to one little bit the Liberal Democrat spokesperson brought forward about this whole idea that we can use defense bonds as a magic answer for defense spending and means that then we would have to make no cuts whatsoever to the aid budget and get it back up to 0.7% with no worry. Borrowing costs are at the highest levels they have been in decades and the bond market is not a great place at this moment in time, and you still have to pay bonds back. And what we've not seen from the Liberal Democrats yet is any understanding of how those bonds would be paid back and how those ever-increasing borrowing costs would be factored into that, and therefore I don't think it is as simple as just take out a few extra bonds and all will be fine with the international aid budget. I'll happily give way.
John Milne
I thank the honorable member for giving way. There is no easy fix there, that's for sure. But of course, the borrowing or the loans are not coming from the bond markets, they're coming from British people. So we're not imposing on or demanding on the bond market. I do think that is a difference, they have been used successfully in the past.
Andrew Snowden
Indeed, I hold government bonds myself, so I should probably declare an interest at this moment in time, as I'm sure many people do. But as we know, the interest rates that all bonds are generally driven by is by the headline interest rate and the bond markets overall.
Otherwise, the government would just borrow from the public every single time, and it isn't that simple. And there are knock-on effects of doing that as well, particularly if there's a reason why premium bonds are capped, which is because you're moving people's money out of taxable savings into non-taxable savings, and it hits the Treasury somewhere else. So it isn't as straightforward as is presented by that.
Um to get to the actual subject, it is evident that we are currently living in a more dangerous world than any time in our recent past. Humanitarian crises in Africa are exacerbated by the actions of governments, war in the Middle East with the terrorist regime in Tehran hell-bent on causing chaos and instability, Putin's illegal invasion of Ukraine signaled the end of the post-war peace dividend and brought the realities of war to Europe once again. Evidence shows that conflict disproportionately affects older people, as the member for Strangford has highlighted. Almost half of the civilian deaths in the conflict in Ukraine are persons older than 60, despite this demographic constituting about one quarter of the population. Older people are more likely to remain in conflict zones because they have strong ties to their homes, lands, and territories, or because they are physically more limited.
It is with this in mind that we must seek to ensure our overseas aid is targeted at those who need it the most, with budgets properly scrutinized and value for money sought in every penny spent. Whilst many will want to discuss the size of the budget, it is equally important that we consider reforming the budget and improving the way the existing budget is spent. How can we ensure that every pound we spend overseas delivers the greatest possible benefit for the British people, our national security, our prosperity and health, as well as for the recipients abroad? With approximately 1.9 million pensioners living in the UK in relative poverty, we owe it to them to ensure that the money we send abroad is money well spent. That is why throughout this debate we must ask ourselves what is the best way to deliver for the needs of older people.
We also must deliver a message to older people, both at home and in conflict areas overseas, that we see them, we hear them, and we are here for them when needed. We have been given numerous reminders of older people's vulnerabilities to conflict over recent years. In 2020, elderly Armenians who stayed in Nagorno-Karabakh were subject to summary executions. Indeed, older people made up more than half of the Armenian civilian deaths. We saw this trend again in Myanmar: older Rohingya who stayed in the face of advances were killed and tortured.
Some people indicate that the highest rates of Rohingya deaths are among people aged 50 and older.
It is no surprise, though nevertheless shocking, to see the suffering Putin's illegal invasion has caused older Ukrainians. As previously mentioned, Ukrainians over 60 make up only 25% of their country's population, yet they account for nearly half of the civilian deaths and more than a third of the injuries in frontline communities. The UN refugee agency polled older Ukrainians who remained in or near Russian-occupied areas last year. They found that many older Ukrainians stayed because they lacked an alternative. Indeed, 20% of the respondents said they would not evacuate because they felt helpless and did not know where to get the help they needed.
Many felt they would have nothing left if they evacuated. There is an opportunity to think outside the box on how we assist older people in conflict areas. For example, we know many older people's finances stop them from evacuating.
Ukraine and Poland have innovated and agreed a mechanism to allow refugees access to their pensions. Is the Minister discussing similar proposals with counterparts in war-torn countries elsewhere in the world where this could possibly be replicated? Many cited older people related reasons for poor health as a reason for not evacuating their homes. After all, older displaced Ukrainians are more likely to report difficulties accessing healthcare.
I would therefore like to ask the Minister how his department is working with our humanitarian partners to make clear to older people who want to evacuate how they can access this help. And what steps are the government taking to ensure internally displaced peoples are able to return home when appropriate rather than being forced to seek refuge in another country. Displaced older people in Sudan report difficulties accessing information on essential services. Many older Syrians remained in war-torn areas to continue accessing healthcare. Some older Syrians are now returning to those same war-torn areas in search of more affordable and accessible healthcare.
With this in mind, what steps are the government taking to ensure best practice on healthcare is shared. Of course, evacuating older people from conflict zones is only the first step. These people can be vulnerable at every stage. Many older people are not mobile enough to reach official displacement camps.
Some stop at unofficial locations. These are often overcrowded and have inadequate access to essentials. Some older people become separated from their families while evacuating. They are vulnerable, particularly those with dementia, to becoming lost in institutional systems. Some evacuated older people struggle to register their presence at displacement camps.
They often lack official documents and registration points can be inaccessible. They can miss out on aid distribution and medical care as a result. The international landscape is, sadly, defined by conflict and instability.
Older people in conflict-threatened zones continue to be vulnerable. Problems accessing healthcare and finances persist. The government has an opportunity to support older people affected by conflict. This will involve working with our partners to find new solutions and address the specific needs that older people have as part of a wider programme of meaningful reform. I hope the Minister will explain how his department is meeting the realities of our more dangerous world.
I look forward to his response to my questions and indeed, as we would have expected, the very detailed requests from the honourable member for Strangford.
Minister to respond.
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
Thank you very much indeed, Mr Betts. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. Can I start by thanking the honourable member for Strangford for securing this debate?
And if the house didn't need any more confirmation that he comes from good stock, may I wish his mother a very happy birthday for next week. I think anyone reaching their nineties is a great achievement. So it is no surprise to me that the honorable gentleman's mum will be reaching those great milestones in age. Can I thank my honorable friend member for York Central for her contribution in particular. I know having worked with her over many years how much she cares about these issues and has always been steadfast and utterly consistent in her views in supporting older people not just in the UK but internationally.
Can I start Mr Betts in the more broader sense of the debate around the honorable gentleman's constituent Margaret. I speak often in international fora as multinational minister about the issues around peacebuilding, around conflict resolution.
And I talk often about Northern Ireland. I think it is often forgotten that we've had conflict on our own shores that lasted for decades and a lot of the peacebuilding that followed was from women and often from older people who lived through the entire period of the troubles. And I think we forget that we have much to celebrate in terms of the work of the peace process in Northern Ireland but also more broadly of the impact that that conflict has had and still has on many of his constituents and people across Northern Ireland. And I pay tribute to Margaret for I'm sure what must be a fascinating conversation for him as her local MP. The Foreign Secretary has been clear that tackling humanitarian need and reducing the violence caused by conflict and atrocities is a key priority for the Foreign Office.
And we are committed to delivering the vision for a reformed humanitarian system which has been set out by the Emergency Relief Coordinator, Tom Fletcher. To put a system which is focused on the most vulnerable and prioritize the views of the communities affected by crisis. The needs of older people must be central to that work. Too often when we think about the human cost of war, we think first of children separated from their families, women and girls facing violence, or communities forced from their homes. We should continue to do so.
But we should also recognize that older people are among those hardest hit by conflict, and yet they remain largely invisible. At the same time, older people are not one homogeneous group. Age alone does not make someone vulnerable. Many continue to lead, care for others, and support their communities even in the most difficult of circumstances. That's why we must take three steps to address the humanitarian impact of conflict on older people.
First, we must recognize that older people can be disproportionately affected by conflict. Today, more than 100 armed conflicts are taking place around the world. From Sudan and Ukraine to Myanmar and Gaza, the experiences of older women and men are too often missing from discussions, data, and humanitarian planning. Many are unable to flee when violence erupts. Older people are often hardest hit in crisis.
Many depend on regular medicines and healthcare, as mentioned by the honorable gentleman, my honorable friend, so disruptions can quickly become life-threatening. Poor health, disability, limited mobility, or caring responsibilities can leave older people trapped in conflict zones long after others have escaped. Others become separated from family members and support networks of which they rely. Yet humanitarian assistance is frequently designed without adequately considering their specific needs.
This creates barriers to getting food, water, and basic services. Older people also face greater risk of neglect, abuse, and exclusion, with older women in particular often facing additional and intersecting challenges linked to age, disability, and gender. That is why the UK consistently presses all parties to conflict to uphold international humanitarian law and allow rapid, unimpeded humanitarian access to all those in need, including older people. But this alone is not enough, as mentioned by members across the House today. We must work proactively to understand and integrate the needs and perspectives of older people into humanitarian responses.
For many years, humanitarian actors have highlighted the lack of systematic data on the needs and experiences of older people during crises. Without data, needs are often overlooked.
Without visibility, resources are not allocated. And without representation, policies and programs risk being developed without the participation of those affected. That's why the UK is taking practical action through our humanitarian programs and partnerships to build the evidence base to inform effective responses. And I know members across the House have raised this point today on data, so I hope to answer as much as I can on this particular point that I know is of concern. We work with UN agencies, the International Red Cross, the Red Crescent Movement, and non-governmental organizations to support humanitarian responses that take account of age, disability, and other barriers people may face.
We also encourage partners to collect and use age-disaggregated data so assistance is informed by evidence and reaches those who might otherwise be invisible within humanitarian responses.
This is not simply a technical point. As has been mentioned by the honourable gentleman, it helps determine whether food distribution points are accessible, whether healthcare reaches those with chronic conditions, whether shelters are sustainable, and whether protection services are identifying those most at risk. In Gaza, for example, the UK has funded assistive products for people injured in conflicts. Each kit can provide practical life-changing support for hundreds of people. For an older person, it can be the difference between being left behind and reaching safety, medical care, and essential services.
Third, we cannot just look through the lens of vulnerability, but must recognize older people across the world as leaders, caregivers and contributors to community resilience. Many continue to care for grandchildren, support neighbors and maintain community networks and help others navigate crises. Humanitarian and conflict responses are more effective when older persons are involved in decisions that affect their lives and those of their broader community. Their knowledge and networks can make responses more effective, more trusted and more sustainable. And I want, as we've gone through the debate today, to try to answer some of the more specific points that have been raised by honorable members.
My honorable friend for York Central is right to raise Sudan. It is the greatest humanitarian crisis of our age. And the Foreign Secretary, the Deputy Prime Minister as Foreign Secretary, and indeed Lord Cameron of the other place, have spent the last four years leading the work internationally and multilaterally and bilaterally to ensure that Sudan remains high on the agenda.
In February of this year, when we chaired the Security Council as the UK Government, the Foreign Secretary chaired a special session purely focusing on Sudan. And across since February, including at the NATO summit where the Foreign Secretary gave a statement to the floor of the House today, where she was able to update the House on the issues around Sudan and the fact that the UK is leading the conversation on trying to bring a peaceful resolution to the conflict. We always need to do more to highlight, to broadcast what is taking place in Sudan, because it's truly important that we find a resolution that brings about a ceasefire and of course back to peaceful stability.
My honourable friend for York Central, Mr. Betts, made a particular point around older women that are not overlooked in conflict, and the honourable member for Strangford talked about women in relation to the atrocities of sexual violence being used in conflict and as a weapon of war. I want to reassure the House that we do support women-led and women rights projects and organisations that recognise that they are often the most trusted actors in helping to identify those victims of sexual violence, but also of the risks specifically faced by older women, including widows, carers, women with disabilities and women separated from family support.
And particularly as the envoy within my role as minister for protecting sexual violence, preventing sexual violence in conflict, we have a women, peace and security wider commitment that focus as well as on younger women and girls, but also on older women as well and making sure there is support there for survivors. Because my honorable friend, who's now not in his place, the member for Glasgow South, made the point that evidence gathering and justice and retribution because of these heinous crimes of sexual violence in conflict. We work as a UK government to ensure that evidence is gathered. We work as a government to make sure that hopefully in the near future, when we have peace in Ukraine, in Sudan and in other conflicts, that there is accountability for the crimes against those people who have committed sexual violence acts in the name of conflict. I will give way happily.
Jim Shannon
I thank the minister for his contribution and for his response so far. I did mention about those who of an older generation who are the custodians of the community's faith and culture.
They're the ones who hold the memory of worship, of tradition and identity. They're the heartbeat of the congregation, the lifeblood of the community, and they are targeted. Can the Minister give us some reassurance in relation to those women and men, the older ones who are also targeted because of their religious belief, sexually as well, that there be help for them in relation to their retaining and ensuring that they have their religious beliefs protected within what government is trying to do, please? Thank you.
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
Thank you, Mr. Betts. Can I say to him to offer that reassurance?
He knows that I have a personal commitment to working with our freedom of religion belief envoy, the member for North Northumberland, who never shies away from the particular point that he's raising, and nor will I as minister. And I think he raises a wider point that my honorable friend for York Central also raised around the work of supporting and working with older people in peacebuilding and resolution. And I want to reassure him and the House that we have an instinctive view as a department of locally led, inclusive peacebuilding that needs to include elders, older women, older men who understand many of the challenges in the community, because part of the need for that support is that they bring trust, knowledge.
They are leaders in their communities, whether of faith or of none. I say to the honourable gentleman, it's extremely important that older people are part of that peacebuilding resolution and to ensure that often in many cases where older people are engaged in peacebuilding, the process actually lasts longer. That's particularly true of women. Where women take part in peacebuilding, there is much evidence that there is many years of peace that follows. So it's extremely important to us as a government that that work continues.
A number of members have mentioned Ukraine, including the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.
First, can I reassure the House that the budgets on overseas development and indeed for additional support through the 100-year partnership have been protected, specifically on Ukraine, Gaza, additional support for Lebanon and for Sudan. And I wanted to just sort of reiterate that point because it's extremely important. The House will also know that Ukraine is also disproportionately affects a huge number of older people, as the honorable member for Strangford talked about. And there is some concerning data that the suffering is disproportionate for civilian casualties, accounting for more than 45% of civilian deaths. These are real people, not just statistics, but it does show the incredible impact that conflict does have on older people across Ukraine.
And there are specific pieces of work that we do to support older people. And a number of colleagues have raised the issue around assistance and pensions, and I want to try and offer some clarity on that. Through the UK government's partnership with the UNHCR and with UNICEF, we are supporting the government of Ukraine in relation to strengthening national social protection systems.
We're also trying to do that work so that it has more specific support for winter cash assistance. We're also trying to make sure that older people have more support in power outages. So the work that we do as a government is focused in many of these areas where there is adverse impact on older people. There's been much conversation this afternoon, Mr. Betts, on data. And I wanted to reassure the House that the FCDO partners should use disaggregated data, including on sex, age, and disability, to understand who is being reached and crucially who is missing out on the support.
So I just wanted to sort of make sure that was very much on the record, because part of the reason for this expectation is that when considering age-related barriers, we are talking about the risks linked to disability on based on gender, poverty, health, isolation, displacement, and other forms of marginalization. So that expectation is very much set out by the department. In my time as a minister, Mr. Betts, I've never been given a list of questions in advance by the member moving the debate. And I think I've tried where I can to answer each of them, but I have tried as we go along to make sure I haven't missed anything. The one couple of points, Mr. Betts, on this if I may.
One is around the violence against women and girls response and to reassure the honorable gentleman that older women are part of that work as I said earlier within in my speech, but just to make that very clear point that it's not about forgetting any women that are victims of sexual violence.
It's about trying to be as inclusive as we can to offer support to victims in recovery, but also to try and prevent this sexual violence in conflict. Both my honorable friend and the honorable gentleman raised the UN Convention on Rights of Older Persons to recognize older people and their legacies. Can I confirm, as I've done in PQs and to various colleagues who've written to me in my time in this role, we are supportive of the UN Convention on Older Persons. There are many, many existing support mechanisms for older people within the UN multilateral system. That doesn't mean to say that it shouldn't come through in some form of convention.
But when that does happen and those negotiations are ongoing, I do hope, I can't give a cast-iron guarantee in the sense of who will be the minister.
Um, but there is, but to be clear, there is genuine support across HMG to ensure that we do support the work of that, of that resolution in supporting older people.
Rachael Maskell
Gladly.
I'm really grateful because this is such a fundamental issue that I've focused on for some time. So could he say what steps the government are taking to expedite that process and roughly what kind of timescale we're looking at to be able to see that convention in place?
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
Can I thank her for her intervention? On timescale, this has been a matter of debate for some years, I should, I should sort of warn her, as she probably knows far more about it than I do. So I can't stand here and say it'll be done by X date. What I can say is that we are part of those conversations. And that's what our contribution is, is to try and make sure that as this work is brought together, that may lead to the convention on older people, we're not stepping away from it.
We're a part of that actual work that's ongoing.
I'll happily give way again.
Rachael Maskell
I'm really grateful, not least because of the work done in Wales around the rights of older people and having the commission there. Will he ensure that our government takes a real leadership role in moving that work forward, in ensuring other nations contribute and participate in that, and that we can get these rights established? Because ultimately we know that this could be really transformative for establishing a rights-based system for older people across the globe.
Hamish Nicholas Falconer
Just to reassure her that I meet frequently with other ministers internationally within the UN space in New York, but also in Geneva at the Human Rights Council, where these issues are discussed.
And there is a willingness for this to succeed, I think, in my, in my opinion. So that work is very much part of conversations of which we are there in the room for much of it. So just to give her that reassurance. To conclude, Mr. Betts, as the global population ages and as conflicts and humanitarian crises continue around the world, the number of older people affected is likely to increase. That is why the UK is working with humanitarian partners to ensure older people are not overlooked.
And at the heart of this debate is a simple principle. No person should become invisible because of their age. And no society should overlook the dignity, rights, and contributions of those who have spent a lifetime contributing to their communities. The United Kingdom will continue to champion the protection, inclusion, and participation of older people in humanitarian action around the world.
Jim Shannon
Chairman, thank you very much.
First of all, can I thank everyone for their contribution. Can I thank my honorable friend, the honorable lady for York, for bringing forward, and also for the work she does in the APPG for older people. She does a lot, and only when you hear these debates do you realize just how much she does do, and I thank her for that. She referred to the conflict shortens lives, referred to frailty to gender violence, and the complex needs that people have. Older people are the ones that usually lose out in conflict.
She refers to resilience, to food, care and support, and also to the sexual violence in Ukraine and indeed across the world. Better distribution of international aid is vital, and I thank the honourable lady for outlining very clearly the way forward and for all that she does. Thank you. Honourable member for Glasgow South also in the intervention referred to the need to have the data and focus especially on the issue so we can know just how many people are suffering. Honourable gentleman for Horsham, thank him very much for his contribution.
I do think we need to look at the international aid, but just where that money comes from is the question we have to look at, and it can't be ignored.
But the main thing is the honorable gentleman referred to humanitarian crisis, older people suffer more, challenges government to address the issue of international aid and also referred to that women and young girls as well suffer disproportionately when it comes to any of these crisis. Data is needed. The honorable gentleman, the honorable member for Foyle, in his shadow minister, as he always does, makes an incredible contribution. Reminds us of Armenia. Sometimes we forget about places in the world and it's good to remember.
It's good to remember because it keeps our minds focused upon the subject matter that we're discussing here today. Older people were murdered because they were still there, because they were a surplus to the enemy's requirements. He also referred to the executions that took place in Myanmar.
Sometimes we need to remember that as well, because across the world in many places, those over 60 are tortured and then murdered. Also follow the, he mentioned about the pension issue about Poland and Ukraine. And I think to be fair to the Minister, he mentioned that in his response and gave us, I think, a decent response in relation to that. The Honourable Gentleman also referred to displaced people in Sudan and Syria and who can't access healthcare. And the Minister, I thank him very much for his contribution as always.
I never doubted, I say this very respectfully and sincerely to the Honourable Gentleman, I never doubted that the Honourable Gentleman wouldn't respond to us to give us encouragement. And I always give the Minister my points in advance.
It's a way I do things because I'd rather have a decent response if you don't mind and not be attacking anybody. That's just me. That's the way I am. But I want to thank him very much for responding to the pension issue and giving us some encouragement about how that will work. He also referred not forgetting about any victims.
That's really important. Also referred to getting, making sure we get the data and the willingness to succeed. I took some of his phrases out of it. And he referred to the lack of data and how government are responding to ensure that they can collect that data better. Also older people adversely affected in conflict and how that focus of medical aid, of attention of support for disabilities, for trauma.
And referred and something that worries me greatly when I hear it, Mr. Chairman, that's the fact that enemies, strong men, monsters they are, use their strength to abuse women and girls.
And the Minister has grasped that in a way. He also referred to Northern Ireland, and I think I know his knowledge of Northern Ireland, by the way, it's not lost on me, indeed in this House, in relation to, he referred to the peacebuilding and the revitalization which was predominantly and primarily driven by women. And very often that is the case. Their persuasion of men, maybe sometimes while not always to the fore, is recognized very much by the Minister.
So can I thank him in particular for all of his answers to the questions and for his commitment and the commitment of the special envoy, the honorable member for Northumberland, who does a grand job as well. And can I thank you, Mr. Chairman, for your chairmanship of the debate today and to the civil servants who organize and the department civil servants who keep the Minister right. Well done. And also can I thank everyone for their contributions. It's much appreciated.
Today we start something and we look to help the people, those older people who are often forgot about. Today in this hall, they weren't forgotten about. Thank you.
Clive Betts
Question is that this House has considered humanitarian impact of questions on older people. As many that opinion say aye. Contrary no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
Order, order. The sitting is suspended until 3:00 PM.
Order.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Just before I call John Mill, we have quite a lot of members of the public in the gallery and it is lovely to have you. And you have been through the experiences and you're affected by the topic of the debate, but it is a convention and I must encourage members to speak into the chamber and through me and not turn round to the gallery. That is not to be impolite, it is a convention of this chamber, please understand that. John Mill to move the motion.
John Milne
Thank you, Mrs. Hobhouse, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship. And I move that the House has considered support for the Lobular Moon Shot campaign. MPs from across the House are here today to mark the anniversary of the death of my constituent Dr. Susan Michaelis, founder of the Lobular Moon Shot project.
And I would like to thank the Backbench Business Committee for finding time at very short notice in the parliamentary schedule for this debate. Unfortunately, the short notice has prevented many who would have liked to have spoken today from joining us, and unfortunately that was necessity. This today is a sad moment because Susan is no longer with us, but it's also a time to celebrate what she has achieved. Susan was a remarkable woman. She was warm but incredibly stoic.
At no time was that clearer than on her last trip to Parliament in the summer of last year, oxygen tank in tow. Determined but evidently suffering, Susan stood for 22 minutes in a silent vigil outside 10 Downing Street with fellow campaigners and lobular ladies around her.
We all understood Susan was in her last days or weeks. So to watch her husband, campaigners, and fellow Lobular Ladies rallying around her, literally supporting her, was a sight to behold. In her haste to deliver her petition to Number 10 that day, Susan had forgotten her ID. She was distraught. All that effort would be wasted as the rules were clear: no ID, no entry.
But that, of course, was not Susan's way. Susan, with support, blagged her way past security. Susan was never one to take no for an answer.
Not long after Susan died, in fact days, just days before her meeting with the then Health Secretary, that is the moment when sadly she lost her life. It might seem odd to say, given that I met Susan when she was already very ill with lobular cancer that she was campaigning to prevent, but I feel that I met Susan in her prime. It was immediately clear to me that this was a person with an unparalleled commitment to her cause. Despite her illness, Susan never looked for the sympathy vote. She was always calm and matter-of-fact.
She led by example. But it is a reminder that her cause, whilst not yet complete, is a worthy one and with a champion to match. Susan's first campaign was in fact not lobular breast cancer, it was aviation safety.
She flew commercial aircraft in the Australian outback, one of the few female pilots to take this challenge, and she piloted the first all-female crewed Qantas flight. This was before contaminated cabin air ended her flying career in 1997. She spent the following decades building the evidence base on aircraft cabin air contamination: a PhD, an MSc, peer-reviewed research, and a leading role in her home country's Senate inquiry into cabin air quality. Her focus in her final years was on lobular breast cancer, and it is on this endeavour that I was pleased to support her as her local MP. Susan was diagnosed with invasive lobular breast cancer in 2013.
It was a one-millimetre mark, no lump, no pain. Two mammograms and two out- ultrasounds told her that there was nothing to worry about.
An MRI found 2.5 centimetres, surgery then confirmed seven. That gap between what standard imaging can see and what is actually there is the heart of why lobular breast cancer needs its own research programme. It behaves differently. It is missed because it's different. And it is currently treated exactly the same as the most common form of the disease because the underlying biology has never been properly funded.
In May 2023, with her husband Tristan, she launched the Lobular Moon Shot Project in Horsham.
She built it from nothing into a campaign with cross-party support in this House, and a partnership with the Manchester Breast Centre and a research plan costing £20 million over five years. In June 2024, Susan travelled to Manchester to help launch the scientific programme she had spent years fighting for, a programme which of course she knew she would never benefit from herself. Nine days later, Susan died. She never received the reply from Number 10, and she never got her chance to make her case to the then Health Secretary. And so today I will make the case again to the Government on Susan's behalf, for the 22 patients diagnosed today with lobular breast cancer, and also on behalf of the 463 MPs, which is I believe the highest number for any individual campaign, who have publicly supported this campaign so far.
Every day, 22 women in this country are told that they have lobular breast cancer. That's over 8,000 women a year. This is not a rare disease.
It is in fact the sixth most prevalent cancer in women.
Will the gentleman give way?
I will indeed.
Jim Shannon
Madam Chair, first of all, can I commend the honorable gentleman for Horsham for bringing this forward, a subject matter that he's been very vocal on and we all support him in coming forward. And I apologize to you and to him and to the ladies in the gallery as well. My flights have come earlier and I have to go home and I can't be here to make a contribution. But it's not just about the women that the honorable gentleman refers to. We met with women in Northern Ireland who have lobular cancer with the Minister Mike Nesbitt.
And I was very, very moved by their contribution. And does he feel that now is the time for the minister and for government to make sure that the small amount of money that's needed to help alleviate the health issues for the women comes forward and also the money that's needed for research is also there as well? If that happens, then the ladies here today and my constituents in Northern Ireland can get the help that they need.
Some of them women I met will not have long time in this world.
John Milne
I thank the member for his contribution and I very much agree with him. And I would also note that the honorable member for Macclesfield, who is potentially to be our new Prime Minister, is himself of course from Manchester, has visited the clinic and is already familiar with the campaign. So I am hopeful. As I was saying, this is the sixth most prevalent cancer in women. That puts it ahead of melanoma, ovarian, brain, kidney and pancreatic cancer combined.
Incredibly, there is still no specific treatment.
Breast cancer as a whole costs this country over three billion a year. It takes around 11,200 lives annually, which is roughly 31 women a day. Many of these are lobular cases, and yet it receives none of the targeted treatment that drives down mortality in other forms of this disease. Every woman diagnosed with lobular is given the same drugs, the same protocols, the same guidelines as someone with an entirely different cancer. That's because the basic biology of lobular has never been established.
And it's this gap that the Moon Shot Project exists to close.
We need 20 million over five years. So that's just 4 million a year to crack the biology of this disease. That's not speculative research. That is, that is a certain outcome. Other researchers in the UK and around the world can then take this forward to find targeted treatments because this is a world problem and the world can find the solutions.
Of course, there are many demands on government funding and the national budget is always under pressure. But I think you'd be pushed to find another project with such a relatively small need for such a big reward. This is a precise unfunded gap and we already have a delivery partner in the shape of the Manchester Breast Centre ready to begin. I'd like to conclude with some words from Susan's husband Tristan, who sits behind me, and it is strange that I have to speak them rather than him, but as that is the procedure of the House.
So I quote from Tristan now. The last overseas holiday Susan and I took together was to Easter Island, one of the most remote places on earth. Like so many people, I had always imagined the island's famous stone statues, the Moai, looking out across the Pacific Ocean. But when we arrived, we discovered something rather beautiful. Most of them face inland.
We were told that they were positioned that way because they watch over their people rather than looking out to sea. Whether that is history, tradition, or simply one interpretation, it touched us both deeply. Before we left, Susan found a beautifully carved wooden replica of one of the Moai. We brought it home together, and today it sits in our house.
Every time I look at it, I think of Susan. It reminds me that although she is no longer physically with me, her love, her courage, and everything she stood for remain with me every single day. In my heart, I'd like to think that she is still watching over me, just as those remarkable statues have watched over their people for generations. If Susan could stand in Westminster Hall today, she would not ask members to remember her. She would instead ask you to remember the thousands of women diagnosed with invasive lobular breast cancer every year who still have no treatments designed specifically for their disease.
And that is why this debate matters. That is why the Lobular Moon Shot Project matters.
And that is why Susan's legacy deserves not only our admiration, but our action. As Susan's husband, I know she would have been deeply humbled that members from every corner of this House have come together today to honor her life. She never sought recognition for herself. She simply wanted to leave the world a little safer, a little fairer, and a little kinder than she found it. My sincere hope is that history will remember this debate, not simply as a tribute to one remarkable woman, but as the day Parliament chose to transform admiration into action for future generations of women diagnosed with invasive lobular breast cancer.
That would have been the greatest tribute we could ever have paid to Dr. Susan Michaelis. Thank you, Chair.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Thank you. May I remind members that they should bob if they wish to be called in this debate.
I am intending to call the front benches at 3:58. I'm currently not imposing a time limit. I'd say eight minutes at the maximum, especially if you call for interventions. The question is that this House has considered Government support for the Lobular Moon Shot Project, and I call Sam Rushworth.
Sam Rushworth
Thank you, Mr. Henderson, for your chairmanship. Could I also thank, I think I'll call him my honorable friend for Horsham, for the initiative to lead this debate. And although she's not here today, I also want to pay tribute to the member for Maidstone, who is a great campaigner on this issue. And I think that that really demonstrates the cross-party nature of support for what we're here to talk about today.
I'd like to just begin by also paying tribute to one of my constituents, Katie Swinburn. She's a mother of three and a very popular local school teacher. And she has lobular breast cancer. I first became aware of Katie actually through my predecessor, Dehenna Davison, who was the MP for Bishop Auckland before me. And she did fantastic work supporting Katie as her constituent at the time.
And anybody who knew my predecessor knows that when she picked up a single-issue campaign, she was a formidable campaigner. And so I became aware of her. And when I was elected, Katie asked to see me. And I was delighted to pick up the baton and to support my constituent.
In fact, this Saturday, she is organizing a fair and a tabletop sale in her village in Hilton to raise funds for the Lobular Moon Shot Project. Through Katie, I was privileged to be introduced to Dr. Susan Michaelis and her husband Tristan Lorraine. And Susan was visiting them in their home in County Durham because through the Lobular Moon Shot Project, I've observed a real sisterhood and solidarity that has emerged among those who are campaigning together. To be in a position where you're told that your cancer is terminal is something I've never experienced and find difficult to imagine.
But I do imagine that people facing that have a choice about how they spend their remaining years, months, and weeks on this earth. And do they spend it on holiday? Do they look for to enjoy all of life's riches and pleasures? Well, Susan chose to spend it in the service of others, campaigning for the science to be done to develop a cure for lobular breast cancer. She helped founded the Lobular Moon Shot campaign and has been, I think, not just a campaigner for better cancer research funding, but also has developed a real group of solidarity of people that are suffering from this type of cancer.
And I was privileged also to meet Susan and her husband and to learn about the Lobular Moon Shot campaign. And as we've heard already from the Member for Horsham, this was not her first experience campaigning. She has success campaigning on aviation safety in particular, the jet fuel and the pollution in cabins, which is a potential cause of her own cancer. The Lobular Moon Shot project so far has been successful in raising significant funds. Those funds have been used to develop funding proposals, to develop the early work.
And as we've heard, there is an opportunity to fund significant research at Manchester University. And I must declare an interest, I am a Manchester alumni myself.
And I was privileged to meet with the campaigners and the former Health Secretary. That led to a commitment from government to issue a highlight notice to demonstrate the importance that the government places on this type of research. The government's approach has been, and I do respect this, to say that whilst we all of course want to find a cure and need to do the scientific research, that it's important that this be through a peer-reviewed process, through competitive funding rounds, because that produces the best science. But it is absolutely vital that those funding rounds do exist and that the funding is made available to meet this particular need. And as we've heard already, the unique part of lobular breast cancer is it's very difficult to discover.
It often goes undetected. Indeed, only 28% of cases are detected in stage one, compared to 38% in, in non-lobular. There's 8,400 cases a year. And, and what the campaign is calling for is for the discovery science to be done. And I appreciate that the minister today is, is answering on behalf of the Department for Health, but, but we also need to have engagement with the Department for Science, Trade and Industry on this, because it, what we need to see as well is UKRI bringing out bespoke funding calls that universities like Manchester can, can tap into to make sure that this vital work gets done.
I was privileged to meet with Professor Rob Clarke from Manchester and hear about the work that he's doing. I'll make sure to leave time for others, but I just want to conclude by urging the Minister to really pick up this issue because we're two years on since I was elected, we're about three or four years on since I first heard about this campaign. Progress has been made, but progress is too slow. And it's important when we have this many people that are really in situations that I can't really even imagine, giving their time to campaign for something that's so important, not even necessarily for themselves, but for the generations that come after them.
I just implore government to listen to their calls and to do what we can to make sure that the correct funding calls are available so that we can once and for all get this research done and answer these people's pleas. Thank you.
Clive Jones
It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Ms. Hopehouse, and I thank the honorable member for Horsham for securing this very important debate. I also pay tribute to everyone who has campaigned tirelessly on this issue.
When I met the Lobular Moon Shot Project team in April, their determination to improve outcomes for patients was unmistakable. This debate is also an opportunity to remember Dr. Susan Michaelis on the first anniversary of her passing. After being diagnosed with invasive lobular breast cancer in 2011, Susan devoted her final years to advancing research into this awful disease. In 2023, she founded the Lobular Moon Shot Project, and in December 2024, many colleagues and I spoke in a Westminster Hall debate echoing the project's call for greater investment in lobular breast cancer research. And I hope the Minister will be able to give us some idea as to whether they listened to us those months ago and whether they're listening very much today.
Because very little appears to have changed. Invasive lobular breast cancer is the second most common type of breast cancer, between 7,500 and 8,000 people diagnosed every year in the UK. That's around 22 women every day. Despite accounting for around one in seven breast cancer diagnoses, it remains under-researched, with no treatment specifically designed for this form of the disease. As a result, patients are often treated with therapies known to be less effective for lobular tumors, increasing the risk of metastatic disease, greater toxicity, and poorer outcomes.
This is not inevitable.
With targeted research, outcomes can improve. The Lobular Moon Shot Project is calling for 20 million pounds over five years to fund lobular-specific research. In the grand scheme of things, 20 million pounds over five years is not a lot of money. That investment would deepen understanding of the disease, support the development of targeted therapies, and improve diagnosis and treatment for thousands of patients. Without it, progress will remain far too slow.
The project estimates that 3.75 million people worldwide will be diagnosed with invasive lobular breast cancer over the next decade.
That makes the need for action so very urgent. This investment also represents good value. Modeling by the Lobular Moon Shot Project suggests that preventing or delaying metastasis in even a relatively small number of patients would more than offset the proposed 20 million investment through reduced treatment costs. I know many across the cancer community are eagerly awaiting the government's workforce plan. Can the minister update the House on when it might be published?
In closing, I urge the government to support the Lobular Moon Shot Project and commit 20 million pounds to improve research, diagnosis, and treatment for invasive lobular breast cancer. I also once again pay tribute to Dr. Susan Michaelis. Without her tireless campaigning, I doubt we would be here today debating this issue or pressing for the change that so many patients and families deserve. Thank you.
Sarah Hall
Thank you, Mrs. Hobhouse. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I would also like to thank the honorable member for Horsham for bringing this hugely important debate forward today and the very powerful speech that was given.
Just a few weeks ago, I stood outside Downing Street alongside women living with invasive lobular breast cancer, their families and campaigners for the Lobular Moon Shot Project's 22-minute silence. Those 22 minutes represented the 22 women who lose their lives to lobular breast cancer every day. And it was a deeply moving experience. Standing in silence with women who are living with this disease alongside those who have lost loved ones brought home why today's debate really matters. They were not asking for sympathy.
They were asking to be seen. They were asking for better research, earlier diagnosis and better outcomes for women diagnosed in the future. Today, I want to share the story of my constituent, Trish. She has kindly given me permission to share her story because she hopes that by doing so, another woman may recognize the signs of lobular breast cancer sooner.
Trish did everything we ask women to do. Between 2014 and 2022, she attended six mammograms. Six opportunities for cancer to be found, six occasions when she believed that if something was wrong, it would be detected. But none of those mammograms picked up any signs. And like many women, Trish believed cancer meant finding a lump.
It wasn't a lump that led to her diagnosis, it was a shadow. After getting out the shower one morning, she noticed a shadow underneath her breast while putting her hair up. She took a photograph and could clearly see dimpling in her skin. Thankfully her GP listened and referred her urgently on the two-week wait pathway. I want to put on record my thanks to that GP because despite there being no obvious lump, they recognized that something wasn't right.
At the breast clinic she underwent mammograms, ultrasounds and biopsies. Initially she was reassured that there was no lump to feel. She was then told there was a small area of concern. The plan was for a lumpectomy, a short course of radiotherapy and as she recalls being told, she would likely be back at work in a month. She underwent an MRI and that's when everything changed.
The MRI showed that the tumor measured approximately 72 millimeters. Following surgery it was confirmed to be 75 millimeters. Her treatment changed completely. She needed a mastectomy with immediate reconstruction followed by 15 rounds of radiotherapy and is currently undergoing 10 years of hormone therapy. She certainly wasn't back at work after a month.
But her experience raises important questions. Lobular breast cancer is the second most common type of breast cancer, yet many women have never even heard of it. Unlike the breast cancers many of us are more familiar with, lobular breast cancer often doesn't form a distinct lump; instead, it grows in a strand like tumors, making it much harder to detect on mammograms and often much harder to feel during examination. That is why women with lobular breast cancer are so often diagnosed later when tumors are much larger and treatment becomes far more extensive. For Trish, six mammograms over more than a decade failed to detect her cancer.
And that is why the work of the Lobular Moon Shot Project matters.
Campaigners are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for research, they are asking that research into lobular breast cancer reflects the scale of the challenge. They are asking for earlier diagnosis, better understanding of how this disease behaves, improved imaging, and more effective treatments. And above all, they are asking that women with lobular breast cancer are no longer overlooked because their cancer behaves differently. Awareness of lobular breast cancer must improve.
For many years the message has quite rightly been check for lumps, but breast cancer is not always a lump. Women also need to know about dimpling, puckering, changes in breast shape, thickening of the breast tissue, and changes to the skin. As Trish said to me, you should know your breasts as well as you know your face.
I welcome the engagement ministers have already had with campaigners and researchers and I hope today's debate marks another step forward.
Speaker 21
Thanks, Mrs. Hobhouse, and may I just say that my honourable friend and other colleagues are making some very powerful points today. I just wanted to really ask my honourable friend if she's also going to come onto the important issue of looking again at medical training and education for doctors and other medical professionals and indeed the possible benefits of greater public awareness. And I know that the Department of Health has historically done some very important work leading on public awareness campaigns of illnesses and other issues in the health world and I do hope she might be able to highlight that as well.
Sarah Hall
I thank my honourable friend for that. Trish is actually a phenomenal campaigner, a lot like Susan actually, and she wants to work together to create that awareness campaign so that women do actually understand that there is a difference.
And we are looking to establish a support group for women as well who have lobular breast cancer, so that is absolutely in the works. And on training, you're absolutely right, that recognition, that training, I think that forms part of the research and understanding, the detection, what it is, what causes it, but also what we need to do and the training that people in the profession need as well. So thank you. So I hope the government will continue working with researchers, clinicians, and the Lobular Moon Shot Project to improve understanding of lobular breast cancer, support further research, and ensure that women receive the earliest and most accurate diagnosis possible. Because behind every statistic is someone like Trish, a woman who did everything that she was supposed to do, a woman who wants her experience to help somebody else.
Next week, many of the women I stood alongside outside Downing Street will gather once again. My hope is that one day they will no longer need to.
My hope is that through better research, greater awareness and earlier diagnosis, fewer women will hear the words that Trish heard. And I hope that colleagues from across the House will continue to stand with them until that becomes a reality.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Thank you. Before I call Josh Newbury, can I encourage you to speak into your microphones? It's quite difficult to hear even for me. It must be even more difficult to hear the debate if you're sitting in the gallery. And please direct your remarks into the room.
I know the temptation is great to direct it to our guests. As I said before, we know you're here, we acknowledge you, but please make sure, A, you speak up, you speak into your microphone so everybody can hear, and to speak into the room here. Thank you.
Josh Newbury
And now I call Josh Newbury.
Thank you, Ms. Hophouse. It is a real pleasure to serve under your chairship today, and thank you for the reminders. I would like to very sincerely thank the honorable member for Horsham for leading the effort to secure this debate and for his incredibly powerful speech. His recounting of Susan's final visit to Parliament and the words of her husband Tristan were very moving, very moving indeed, and I believe that he has done Susan, her loved ones, and the thousands of supporters of her campaign proud today.
I too would like to welcome Tristan Susan's aunt Sally and her cousin Andrew to Parliament today. Tristan kindly shared with us the briefing he prepared for members ahead of this debate. I know that many of us have drawn on that and absorbed that this afternoon. Susan had just one symptom. One tiny millimeter long mark on her breast.
No pain, no lump, none of the warning signs that many of us have been told to look out for. But that tiny mark concealed something a lot bigger. As we've heard, seven centimeters of invasive lobular breast cancer. There's something profoundly cruel about that. The disease was growing silently while every reassuring scan understandably gave Susan and her family reason to believe everything was fine.
As we've heard, incredibly nine days before she passed away, Susan launched the scientific program for the Lobular Moon Shot Project. Even while facing the unimaginable, she was looking beyond herself. She was fighting to ensure that other families might one day be spared what hers had endured. I've no doubt that she would be immensely proud to see her family, her Member of Parliament continuing that work in her memory today.
Since being elected, 14 of my constituents have contacted me about breast cancer. 14 people who felt compelled to write to me because this disease had touched their own lives or the lives of somebody that they loved. One in particular contacted me in every way she could to rightly command my attention to make sure that I signed up to this campaign. But if my two years in this House has taught me anything, it's that for every person who writes to us as MPs, there are hundreds more who have been affected but for who whatever reason don't write into us. I'd be surprised if there is anybody in this room whose life has not been shaped in some way by cancer.
In my own family, we unexpectedly lost my wonderful aunt during the pandemic after her cancer was spotted too late. It reaches into every family, every community, every constituency. I'm sure most of us know somebody whose chair at the dinner table is empty because of cancer, or somebody who still sits there because it was found in time.
That is the difference in early diagnosis. A cancer diagnosis is literally a race against time, and every second of delay gives cancer a head start that it really doesn't need. Our NHS can only fight with the tools that we give it. So if those tools can't see a disease or can't treat it properly, then we can't expect patients to get the outcomes that they deserve. Invasive lobular breast cancer accounts for around 15% of all breast cancer diagnoses, yet there is still no treatments developed specifically for it, as we've heard, and 1,000 people across the world are diagnosed with this disease every single day.
For those people, this debate is about far more than statistics. It's about whether future patients can hear the words "we found it early" rather than "if only we'd got it sooner".
Cancer is a race against time, and every misdiagnosis gives the disease a head start. The Lobular Moon Shot Project seeks, as we've heard, just £20 million over five years to better understand the biology of the disease and develop targeted treatments. It's already secured the support of hundreds of members of this House. Surely that level of cross-party support reflects a belief that patients with this horrendous disease deserve to be seen, to be understood, and to benefit from research that gives them the same hope as every other breast cancer patient. That was Dr. Susan Michaelis's mission, that was her call to us.
As the honourable member for Horsham said, we have a window of opportunity to do that now. And I hope that every possible effort can be made to seize that opportunity. Thank you.
Scott Arthur
Thank you, Ms. Hophouse, and it's a pleasure to serve under you today.
And like others, I do want to thank the member for Horsham both for introducing the debate and for the way in which he did it. And I don't want to make a prediction, I'll make a prediction, Ms. Hobhouse. I think the remaining speakers are going to say that they support this campaign and they want to see a difference and they'll acknowledge the gap that needs to be filled. But I think our challenge is making that pledge and those words something that's real. Because I've been in these debates before where we all agree something has to be done, but yet we come back and we speak about it again and again and again.
So perhaps this is the time, if we all carry this campaign forward, to actually make it happen. So I am really very happy to...
Sam Rushworth
I think he's just made a really excellent point.
And we know the research questions that need to be answered. So would he agree with me that it shouldn't be beyond UKRI to put out a specific call asking people through competitive peer-review process to answer those questions?
Scott Arthur
Exactly. And you know, in a former life I was an academic, and UKRI does at times engage with academics to fine-tune those questions. And also UKRI does provide funding to universities if needed to bring the very best people to the UK, either temporarily or on longer-term contracts to help make a difference in the UK. So these things are perhaps all part of the solution. So absolutely, he's absolutely right.
So I'm grateful for the opportunity to support this vital debate today. And it does shine much-needed light on a disease that is still under-resourced, as we've just said. And it does honor the legacy of a woman who dedicated her final years to fighting it, the late Susan Michaelas. I wasn't fortunate enough to meet her, but I think through the Member for Horsham's excellent introduction, I do feel like I know a little bit about her and her character. So I am really, really grateful for that introduction.
So lobular breast cancer, despite being the second most common form of breast cancer, has historically received a mere 1% of breast cancer research funding. Susan refused to accept that disparity, and the Lobular Moon Shot Project is her legacy. But it has to be more than a project. Hopefully, progress will be her real legacy, demanding better treatment for every woman who receives a lobular breast cancer diagnosis. And that's why we're all here today, all of us.
I recently received an incredibly powerful letter from a leading oncologist, Dr. Mitchie, who is based in Edinburgh, treating patients within Scotland and works closely with this community. She expressed deep frustration, professional frustration on the behalf of her patients, explicitly stating that lobular breast cancer has been neglected for too long. So these are people who are actually meeting people day in, day out, week in, week out, and still there's a real frustration about the lack of progress. Her letter also highlighted the fact that lobular breast cancer is a different disease to the more common ductal breast cancer types, as we've already heard, with an entirely unique tumor biology, different responses to drug treatments, and a distinct and highly challenging pattern of spread. And that different response to drug treatments is really important, because in the absence of proper treatments, often that's what the women are faced with.
A drug that wasn't actually designed for the condition that they have.
Yet clinical trials are rarely even present separate response data for lobular cases, and today there are a grand total of zero lobular-specific clinical trials actively recruiting patients in the UK. That should shame us, based on what we've discussed already today and the scale and the breadth of the campaign that's been run. Additionally, the incidence of lobular breast cancer is rising rapidly, climbing at nearly 3% annually, and because it does not form the typical lump, it is notoriously difficult to detect using classical imaging. So, a 3% annual growth in this condition in terms of the diagnoses.
I mean, I know as a government we're really keen on growth, but not not that kind of growth, I don't think. And to fix this, we need to improve our preclinical understanding of how and why this disease spreads. And believe that the work package I believe that the work package plan from the Lobular Moon Shot Project is precisely the kind of ambitious and collaborative plan that can help us improve patient outcomes across the board. And if people don't believe that, let's have a conversation about how it can be improved. Very happy to give way.
Speaker 25
I'm grateful to the honorable member giving way, and and he speaks about the value of research. 50 years ago this year, my cousin was diagnosed with breast cancer. She had three years. She left five children under the age of 10. Yesterday I met Leslie, who was diagnosed 20 years ago.
And Leslie is well, still receiving treatment, but it demonstrates the value and the advances that research can make.
Would he agree that it's absolutely vital that we invest in this area?
Scott Arthur
Absolutely. I mean, yesterday I met with Cancer Research UK just outside Parliament before they came in. And they had around 100 activists there who had been touched by cancer in all its shapes and forms. And I'm just making it, I want to make, just reinforce the point that he was making. In that, whilst the room was big and it was full of people who were full of energy, it's just a tiny, tiny part of the footprint of cancer and its impacts across the UK.
It's absolute tip of the iceberg stuff. So we have to acknowledge both the emotional impact as on individuals, their families, but also the economic impact, and we should never be ashamed of talking about that. And also the economic impact of bringing the best research to the UK, into our laboratories, into our universities, into our hospitals to work on this.
All this is pushing in the right direction. So the government and the biosciences sector is notoriously slow moving and what we need is to expedite work in this area, dedicated funding commitment, a dedicated funding commitment from the government to launch the Moonshot Project would help do that. When we talk about housing, we talk about being builders, not blockers. Maybe we should use the same narrative and the same energy for this. On a related note, while the fight for a new funding model is critical, we can't afford to overlook the importance of immediate and compassionate support for people who have the condition.
In my Edinburgh South West constituency, we are incredibly fortunate to have the House of Hope, a wonderful charity that provides a safe space for women navigating a breast cancer diagnosis and for their families, for their husbands and for their children as well.
And as I understand it, they have planned to start a support group which will meet for the first time on the 11th of August to focus specifically on lobular breast cancer. And I do wish them well in that endeavour, and I'm wearing my House of Hope badge today. And they actually gave me three badges, Ms. Hobhouse, but I've went for the glittery one, three different designs, I went for the glittery one because we all need a bit of glitter in our life sometimes, I think. I've always found the House of Hope to be an incredibly inspiring and hospitable place, and I would encourage any women in Edinburgh and the Lothians or further afield with a diagnosis to check out the services they provide. And I'm sure the Minister would be very welcome to visit any time as well, and I can guarantee him it will be cooler than it is in London right now if he goes to Edinburgh.
So returning to Susan and her project, I believe there's a clear and fundamental shift needed in how we fund and prioritize the research we do into this condition. So I would strongly encourage the minister to actively engage with the project's demands, meet with the campaign, and agree a plan going forward about how we can address their concerns. And as people have said already, 22 women will be diagnosed with this condition today, and we need to give them hope, and we need to give their families hope. I did check Hansard this morning, and in the last parliament, 2019 to 2024, lobular breast cancer was mentioned 10 times. In the current parliament, just two years in, we've mentioned it 56 times here in parliament.
And I think what we need to do is stop talking, stop talking about it in this place, and actually start to get stuff done. Thank you, Mrs. Hophouse.
Helen Maguire
Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Helen Maguire.
Thank you, and it's an absolute pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mrs. Hobhouse. And I thank my honorable friend, the member for Horsham, for leading this really important debate on government support for Lobular Moon Shot Project. I want to start by paying tribute to Dr. Susan Michaelis and her tireless campaigning on the first anniversary of her death. The debate here today celebrates a legacy that continues to inspire researchers, clinicians, patients, and parliamentarians alike. Whilst this debate is about her story with lobular breast cancer, I'd like to focus on what made her Susan.
While Susan is known for her campaigning on lobular breast cancer, she was so much more, something her loved ones who are here today know all too well. She was an Australian who grew up in Melbourne before moving to the UK in 2003.
As a child she had dreams of becoming a pilot, but due to the lack of women in the industry at the time she settled on working in the travel industry instead. But she soon realized that she really didn't want to become a pilot, and she really did want to become a pilot and set about becoming a qualified commercial pilot. This dream came true and she trailblazed as the co-pilot on the first all-female crewed flight with the Qantas Group. She also obtained a PhD at the University of New South Wales in Sydney in 2010. Her thesis was titled Health and Flight Safety Implications from Exposure to Contaminated Air in Aircraft.
She was a researcher who devoted her career to improving public health and aviation safety, and her contributions towards aircraft cabin air contamination remain recognized today.
In 2007, Susan and her husband raised concern with the world's leading jet engine oil manufacturers about crew and passenger exposure to engine oil decomposition products. Whilst most ignored the issue, the French company NYCO investigated and confirmed that the fuel additives affected gene expression. As a result, NYCO developed a new less hazardous jet engine oil, NYCO 940 SE. The oil received SAE approval in 2023 and the US military approval for all NATO aircraft in 2024. But her legacy undoubtedly remains the Lobular Moon Shot Project and the change she championed, whilst knowing that she would not live to reap the benefits.
Susan was diagnosed with lobular breast cancer in 2013 after a small 1 millimeter mark was noticed on her left breast. She had no lumps and had experienced no pain.
Two mammograms and two ultrasound scans and two ultrasound scans showed no cause for concern. An MRI scan suggested the presence of a 2.5cm area of lobular breast cancer, which was later confirmed by a biopsy. Susan underwent a double mastectomy and post-operative pathology revealed that the cancer actually measured 7cm. This was much larger than what had initially been detected and was missed entirely by mammograms and ultrasounds. Had Susan been given regular MRI scans in the last 10 years before her diagnosis, her lobular breast cancer would have been detected much earlier.
For all cancers, early diagnosis and effective treatment is essential to increase survival. Susan's story tragically highlights how these challenges continue to be experienced by the millions of patients living with lobular breast cancer. The current NHS imaging techniques can fail to detect the disease accurately, which often leads to diagnosis at a later and more advanced stage.
Unlike other breast cancers, lobular breast cancer tends to spread out in straight lines rather than amassing to form a firm lump. A patient is more likely to have a thickened area of breast tissue as a symptom rather than the expected lump. This is what makes lobular breast cancer so difficult to detect during a physical examination and when using imaging scans such as mammograms and ultrasounds. Research evidence indicates that MRIs, which can produce detailed images of inside the breast, offer improved detection and characterisation of lobular breast cancer. If Susan had been given a regular MRI scan in the 10 years prior to her diagnosis, there is a very real chance that her cancer would have been detected sooner.
This would have reduced the risk of it metastasising and ultimately claiming her life.
Susan also only received generic breast cancer treatment, as there is currently no specialised treatment for lobular breast cancer. Susan underwent eight systemic treatments over the span of 12 years. This led to the lobular breast cancer spreading to her spine in 2021. A PET-CT scan was unable to detect the disease progression, but once again, this was detected on an MRI scan, something that's not available on the NHS. Lobular breast cancer accounts for one in seven, or 15%, of all new breast cancer diagnoses.
It's the second most common subtype of breast cancer. There are approximately 8,400 lobular breast cancer diagnoses in the UK each year. This amounts to 22 people being diagnosed every single day. More women are impacted by lobular breast cancer than cancers of the kidney, brain, pancreas, liver, or ovaries.
The impact of any cancer for both the patient and their loved ones is always devastating, and lobular breast cancer is no exception. We must better our understanding of this disease to improve treatment and outcomes for all those affected. It's unacceptable that this cancer has no specific treatments and is treated the same way as the more common types of invasive cancer. The Lobular Moon Shot Project, created in May 2023 in Horsham by Susan alongside her husband, is striving to change this. The campaign is asking for the government to invest 20 million over five years to understand the biology of the disease to enable targeted treatments.
I, alongside all my Liberal Democrat colleagues, wholeheartedly support and will continue to support this very important project.
The Liberal Democrats were the first major party to fully endorse this campaign. Sir Ed Davey, the member for Kingston and Surbiton, has written to both the Prime Minister and former Health Secretary on Susan's behalf. And our Chief Whip, the honorable member for North East Fife, has repeatedly raised this issue in the chamber. Support of the Lobular Moon Shot Project has grown to 465 members of parliament, making it the most widely supported health campaign in parliament. On the 15th of July 2025, the then Health Secretary, the member for Ilford North, stated that he'd instructed his Chief Scientific Advisor to plan a path forward to understand the biology behind this cancer to make a difference to those affected.
But one year in and with a new Health Secretary, this research project has still not got the green light. We can't allow this to fall through the cracks, so I urge the minister and all the members here today, regardless of their party, to continue to advocate on this issue.
Alongside supporting the work of the Lobular Moon Shot Project, the Liberal Democrats are clear: cancer must be a top priority for any government, and the UK should be a global leader in cancer research and outcomes. The Liberal Democrats would introduce a guarantee that 100% of patients will be able to start treatment within 62 days from urgent referral. The Liberal Democrats would also recruit more cancer nurses so that every patient has a dedicated specialist supporting them throughout their treatment. To end, I once again want to honor the legacy of Dr. Susan Michaelis and her Lobular Moon Shot Project. The contributions made here today show the continuing impact of her legacy that inspires me and everyone in the room and beyond.
I once again ask the Minister to play his part in ensuring Susan's legacy continues for her and all those who have been and continue to be impacted by lobular breast cancer.
I ask him to find the 20 million to fund the research so more people survive from lobular breast cancer. Will he commit to this today?
Neil Shastri-Hurst
Thank you. Shadow Minister, Dr. Neil Shastri-Hurst.
Thank you very much, Mrs. Hoshouse, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship today. And I'm grateful to the honorable member for Horsham for securing today's debate and to the members from across the House who have given their voice to this campaign over a number of years. And it is entirely right that Parliament should pause today to consider not just the science, not only the policy, not only the funding, but the human reality that sits behind all three of those. Because behind the words lobular breast cancer are women who knew something was wrong, but the system just couldn't prove it.
And that is the point and the heart of today's debate. This is not a call for special treatment, it's not a demand to place one cancer above another, it is a recognition that different cancers behave differently, present differently and may require different approaches if we're serious about improving outcomes. And so today we are also remembering Dr. Susan Michaelis. And many people in public life are described as courageous, Mrs. Hobhouse. In Susan's case, that word feels insufficient.
She was, as we've heard, a commercial pilot, she was a researcher, a campaigner, a wife, and a woman whose instinct when faced with injustice or uncertainty was not to turn away from it, but to investigate it. She'd already devoted much of her professional life to public safety, particularly in the aviation sector, we've heard about how she challenged assumptions, she gathered evidence and she pursued truth in an area where the consequences mattered for passengers, crews and the wider public.
And then of course in 2013, she had her devastating diagnosis of invasive lobular breast cancer. And as I've understood and as we've heard today, her symptoms were not dramatic. It was a tiny mark on her breast, and yet after two mammograms and two ultrasounds failed to identify the disease, it was ultimately an MRI scan that did. And we've heard how that revealed what had appeared to be a relatively small lesion of about an inch was later confirmed to be over seven centimeters. And that single account tells us why this debate continues to matter.
It shows the particular challenge of a cancer that can be harder to detect through standard imaging.
And what is remarkable is that Susan didn't live her final years in retreat from the world. She continued working, she continued researching, she continued campaigning. And as we've heard, nine days before her death, she traveled to Manchester to help launch the scientific program for the Lobular Moon Shot Project, knowing full well that any breakthrough would come too late for her. And I think that is an extraordinary act of generosity. It is also a challenge to all of us in this place.
And it's a challenge because if someone is living with advanced cancer and can spend her final days and her final strength asking for progress for others, then surely it is the responsibility of us and government to find the clarity and the urgency to respond to that. As we've heard, lobular breast cancer is not in fact rare.
It's the second most common type of breast cancer accounting for around 15% of cases. Yet despite that, it remains too often hidden in plain sight.
Speaker 25
Thank the shadow minister for giving way. I think he agrees with me that this is not a party political issue. This is something which the whole house can agree on. But in 2022, the Scottish government began a process of improving its imaging kit with the introduction of 3D mammography, which is a major step forward. Two months ago, the Scottish Parliament lodged a motion supporting the Lobular Moon Shot Project and called for this 20 million to be allocated.
Would he agree with me that the breadth of support for this campaign, including the over 440 MPs who now support it, including myself, is now irresistible and the Minister should award this funding?
Neil Shastri-Hurst
I'm very grateful to the honorable gentleman for his intervention. He is right, there is a collective movement that we must do more on this issue, and that starts with getting the research right, because without the research, we don't know how to plan for the treatments of the future. And I'll move on to the points, but he's also entirely right, this is not a party political issue. This is an issue that affects all of us and all of our constituents, and we've got to work with a sense of urgency around it.
As we've heard, the Lobular Breast Cancer Moon Shot Project is looking for £20 million over five years to advance that understanding of invasive lobular breast cancer, to support better detection, better treatment, and better surveillance. Now, we can't dispute that is a significant sum, but we have to look at it in the context of national health spending, and in that context of what cancer costs: the cost to families, the cost to patients, and the cost to the NHS when it's detected late or it's treated inadequately. And we have to bear those factors in mind. We should also be clear about what research funding means in practice. It doesn't mean a guarantee of easy answers; science doesn't work like that.
But it does mean giving our best minds the chance to ask the right questions. It means building the evidence base. It means moving beyond a generic understanding of breast cancer and towards a more precise understanding of this specific disease. And that's the direction of travel that we have seen over the last few decades.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.