Energy Security and Net Zero Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Energy Security and Net Zero Committee Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsFintan Slye
Oh, sorry, absolutely. As chief executive, part of that is absolutely my role, but it is a big organisation. I have colleagues like Kayte and others on the executive team who also need to be out there, but as the chief executive of the organisation, I take responsibility for that.
Bill Esterson
Now, I had it described to me that the challenges of the energy transition, the electrification of the system, means more grid generation storage, which is the fastest change in a generation, all while keeping bills down and bringing communities with us and keeping our climate commitments.
How well is NESO performing on that metric, assuming you accept that that is the challenge?
Fintan Slye
So I think the challenge of the energy industry and indeed of NESO is to balance those three things, right, around security of energy supply, affordability for consumers, and transition to a sustainable energy system. And I think if you look at some of the big transitions that we are part of delivering, because this is an energy transition across the industry, there are bits of it that we are leading on, there's bits of it that we are participating in. But things like reformation of the connections queue, that is a once-in-a-generational change of how we think about connecting to the electricity system.
And I think we have progressed that and that is now progressing to plan and people have are getting the the connection offers that they need to connect.
Bill Esterson
I mean the engineers, so it's an engineering challenge and and if they if they're given the appropriate challenge, they will meet it. Do you think that's that's right?
Bill Esterson
Yeah, in bringing those three elements along together, that it's feasible, they just need to be tasked with with doing so.
Fintan Slye
Absolutely and and that is what the engineers in NESO are doing in terms of trying to ensure that as we keep the system secure, that we manage the increased complexity that we see as we move from a fossil fuel-based system to a more renewable-based system. It's undoubtedly more complex.
But we have brilliant engineers, and there are brilliant engineers right across the energy system who are absolutely dedicated to making sure that we marry all of those three things up.
Bill Esterson
Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, one of the, one of the criticisms we hear is that there is a, and I think this came out somewhat in the reporting over the summer, a resistance or for some reason a delay in using the latest technology. And digitization of the grid is where we get efficiencies from, for example, and enable better use of demand flexibility. Is that a fair criticism that NESO is not embracing technology and the use of AI as fast as, as it could?
Kayte O’Neill
So actually technology and the use of AI hugely important to us in a number of places. So how we use it ourselves in our ways of working in the organisation and in the control room, but also how we think about the value of data, digitalisation, AI technology enhancements across the sector. So where our control room and our teams are connecting with market providers, market participants and the work that they're doing. I'd say we've actually seen some really great progress. In fact, we're nearing completion of a very, very significant technology change-out programme in the control room where we've introduced new systems, new processes for colleagues, giving them much better visibility of what's going on in the system and a much greater ability to sort of optimise.
So that's within our own control room day-to-day as we balance the system. But we've also taken on a real leadership role in engaging with industry on the value of being able to share data and information, being able to do that in a real sort of standardized way, creating the potential for that data to be used to think about how we plan the system for the very long term, how we operate markets to deliver what the control room needs, and then to be able to make use of it.
Bill Esterson
Okay, look, thank you for that. And I was looking at an example, a pilot example, and this goes to what you were saying, Fintan, about curtailment and curtailment costs. A pilot example of a heavy user of electricity being paid to use electricity during periods that otherwise you'd be paying to curtail wind farm production.
So they've set up the system of storage to benefit from it. And yet they're not being allowed to use it because NESO never gives them the consent to do so. And allied to that, it got me thinking, well, if this is something that NESO's looking at, why is it not rolled out more quickly? Why are we not already there with encouraging heavy energy users more widely to benefit from this option of storing electricity when at the moment we're having to pay to switch it off?
Fintan Slye
Um, so, Chair, I obviously don't know the specific examples or the specifics of the example that you quote, but maybe two things.
One, the use of flexibility in a widespread sense down to household level was something that NESO has pioneered through ESO previously with the demand flexibility scheme. And we have recently run a really significant further innovation trial with partners called CrowdFlex around how do we build out and expand that. On the subject of sort of industrial and commercial consumers and how they do that, one part of that is what are the signals that NESO gives, but the other part of it is how does the market reward that type of flexibility because really NESO should be just stepping in as the residual balancer in the market when when in the first instance the market should resolve that.
And what we need to look at is how do we make sure that the right signals and market incentives are there such that the type of situation that you described, where an industrial customer has some storage assets, maybe has some flexible load, that they can operate in a way such that the value that they deliver back to the system is recognized in either cheaper electricity that they pay or a payment stream for that, that flexibility. And we're working with Elexon as the market facilitator on that and the flexibility commissioner that has been appointed as well to look at all of the mechanisms that we can do to get that. I mean, we're hugely supportive of enabling demand flexibility. We see it as part of the long-term solution.
It was one of the early things, one of the first things listed in our clean power advice to government back in 2024 around how to do that.
Bill Esterson
I suppose my question is why hasn't it already, why aren't we further advanced with it? You said that this was something that happened before NESO came into existence, that's more than two years ago. You also said when you were describing it there that you recognize that this is a technologically feasible and it goes to the previous question I was asking, I think, about whether NESO is using technology in as advanced a way as it could. Is that a fair criticism because that's what's been said to me?
Fintan Slye
So I don't think it's NESO's use or lack thereof of technology that is impeding the rollout or the adoption and payment for flexibility in sort of the commercial and industrial space that you're talking about. I think what we haven't seen is the market arrangements developed to a point that that is a commercially attractive proposition for that individual.
Fintan Slye
So I think that you'll have, so government published, I think it was last year, the Clean Flexibility Roadmap, which is a roadmap setting out across industry participants, the regulator, ourselves, market facilitator, the things that need to be done across the different sections of the market to enable that flexibility to come on stream. And all of the parties are working to try to progress that as quickly as possible.
Fintan Slye
So that is a roadmap of increasing open, increasingly opening the market and getting rid of the multiplicity of barriers over time.
Speaker 7
So we haven't got a timeline, a timeline on it, we haven't got dates on different stages?
Fintan Slye
Sorry, there is a timeline within that and I just don't have it to hand, but we can absolutely share it with you, apologies.
Melanie Onn
Thank you, Chair. Connections reform, strategic planning, control room activity, grid build-out and policy advice are all things that fall under NESO's responsibilities. Is that too much to do?
Are there competing priorities within that?
Fintan Slye
So there, I think as with anything in the energy space, there are competing priorities and competing tensions, and in fact, the energy system is ultimately how do you balance, as we talked earlier, those elements of the trilemma. I think it is a huge role and set of responsibilities that we've been given, and we have looked to scale the organisation very significantly since its inception in October 2024. I mean, we started with just over 1,000 people, we're nearly at 3,000 people now, so we are really scaling up the resources and the capabilities we have in the organisation across all dimensions.
So it is a really, except it is a really broad remit. I think that one of the benefits that NESO brings is that you have all of those elements within one organization and therefore can see the trade-offs between them and take that whole system perspective such that you can focus on getting the right answer for consumers and for the system.
Melanie Onn
And you don't seem to be managing that very well in terms of the levels of expectation and delivery. You've admitted yourself that you knew about issues in the control room but failed to take action, have said that there was lots of change happening in the organization. You're used to working in large organizations.
Would it be better if there was someone who was in a position to deal with or has more experience of change management if you're not able to take on board significant concerns that an investigation has revealed, exposes deep cultural issues?
Fintan Slye
So I think we take incredibly seriously the findings of the Eversheds investigation. I think the organisation has been on a journey since it was established at the end of 2024. We've grown the organisation significantly and have delivered some incredibly big and important things for the energy system and for the country over that period.
I think what the report showed is that there are some things that we need to focus on and to improve. And absolutely as the chief executive I take responsibility for making sure that we do that, that the organization grows and that we build the capability within it and address those issues such that we continue to deliver for society and for the economy.
Melanie Onn
And do you think you're going to be in a position to aid in delivering clean power by 2030?
Fintan Slye
Absolutely. I mean the organization, as I say, continues to deliver across the really broad remit that you outlined earlier.
Fintan Slye
In terms of the delivery, in terms of the achievability of 2030, I think when we first set out our advice to government, I think the term we used that it was a Herculean task that would require all parts of the system to do things at a pace and in a way that hadn't been done previously. And I think that remains.
Melanie Onn
And we know that all parts of the system are not doing that, because in your organisation, bits of it have failed.
Fintan Slye
I think our view remains that it is an incredibly challenging target to hit 2030. In terms of the pieces of the plan that we are responsible for, we are absolutely focused on making sure that we do deliver those bits. But it is an energy system-wide, indeed economy-wide change.
We do not hold or control all of the levers necessary to hit 2030, but we are absolutely committed to working with industry partners, government, and the regulator to play our part and make sure our bits of it are delivered.
Melanie Onn
And in terms of the biggest risks to delivering clean power 2030, what are those?
Fintan Slye
So I think probably at the moment it's infrastructure delivery. So if you think about the scale of the transformation that clean power 2030 is, both on the generation side and on the network side, these are really big, hairy infrastructure projects.
And I think the delivery of those within the timeline is probably the greatest. So, so will the generation, renewable generation, etc. come on stream and will the network build be delivered in line with the expected timelines? I think is probably... And, and within that there are obviously a series of specific risks with each of those categories. But I would at a macro sense say that infrastructure delivery is, is probably the, the biggest risk.
Bill Esterson
Thanks very much. And we welcome Catherine Fookes to the committee for your first session. Catherine.
Catherine Fookes
Thank you. Thank you, Chair. And thank you for appearing before us today. Why do you think people whistleblow or whistleblew if there wasn't a problem?
Fintan Slye
Um...
So I think if we reflect on the report and what it said, it didn't substantiate the four specific allegations. But what it did find was that there was a set of other cultural issues within the organisation that we needed to look at, and we are completely committed to doing that. And one of the reflections is that, so one of the things that as you would expect that we did, we looked at our whistleblowing and speak up policy to make sure is it fit for purpose, does it have all of the elements in it that it should for an organisation such as us. But my reflection is that while it does and it did, we need to go further as an organisation and be best in class at this and ensure that we have a culture in the organisation that encourages this and encourages people to use the internal channels and indeed the other external channels, for example, that Ofgem have whistleblowing facilities as well.
And we're in the process of engaging with both the trade unions who'll have really great examples of where this works really well in other organisations and external experts to make sure that actually we have we're not just the policy isn't just what it needs to be. Actually, we have a culture so that people's lived experience in the organisation is that they feel free to raise things that they and whether that is within their teams or anonymously. One of the things I did take some comfort from in the in the report and hands up there was difficult reading in there was that people actually feel quite comfortable raising issues with their managers and within their teams. What we weren't really good at at all was providing a feedback loop as to say to them, this is what we've done with your concern.
So you've raised a concern, a team somewhere else in the organisation would have dealt with it, but we never or we weren't as good as we should have been at closing the feedback loop so those individuals who raised it could see how that feedback loop was closed.
Catherine Fookes
Even so, those people they obviously raised concerns in your organisation, they felt they weren't being dealt with and therefore they had to whistleblow. So what are you actually doing to instil a culture where next time we have an issue like we did in June 2026, how will you ensure that people don't have to go outside the organisation whistleblow but you deal with their concerns and that culture of honesty within the organisation actually changes and delivers?
Fintan Slye
Yeah, and that is a program of work that we are setting out to do to absolutely make sure that we have that in place and that we have a best-in-class best practice.
Catherine Fookes
So what has changed to make that happen already? What have you done already?
Fintan Slye
So very specifically in terms of the things that we've done, we've set up an engineering forum run by our chief engineer that provides a forum whereby any concerns that the operational teams or control room teams can raise. Those things are then explicitly triaged and dealt with with a feedback loop back to that individual.
So that is one very specific thing that we have done. We've also established a new committee at the highest level, so a committee of the executive team, the Operability Committee, that looks at and that has senior managers as well on it, that enables any of those issues that are coming up through the organization in a very explicit way to be dealt with at the highest level and make sure that those concerns, to the extent they need to be addressed, are addressed. And it's cross-functional to make sure that we join up all the bits of the business. And that committee will provide updates on a regular basis into the board to make sure that we have closed that off, because as I say, one of the issues was this feedback loop wasn't there. So we've done that.
We're also talking to the organization in a really open way about this and trying to engage both individuals and cohorts of teams across the organization and looking to engage with the trade unions to get their advice and input on how to do this.
So we're trying to move on multiple fronts to address this and to do it in a really open way with the organization and the people.
Kayte O’Neill
I think the big thing for me is, you know, we recognize that trust with our colleagues is crucially important. And one of the things for me from the from the report is if there is a single individual in the organization who feels that they don't trust that that we will take their concern seriously and see that then then that is one too many. And we, you know, the proof will be in the pudding.
is one too many and we you know the proof will be in the pudding they need to see us behave differently they need to see that change flow through and hopefully you know we will have that trust which I think we have in you know in many in many ways and in vast ways across the organisation but for any individual to have to go outside and use a whistleblowing channel because they felt they weren't being listened to is one too many so we need to we need to
Catherine Fookes
Just my final question in in this set so how how are you dealing with the high levels of operational stress that the report found that your colleagues were going through in the control room?
Yeah so um again something we take really really seriously the the teams in the control room the guys and girls in the control room you know they're very very well trained that is an environment where they thrive it's where they do the amazing work that they are there to do but they are very open in talking to us about where that feels challenging and where they're looking to us to sort of provide that support so we have really practical things on the ground which is the ability for them to you know as they come off shift talk to people who if they feel that they just need to sort of vent and you know talk about what it's like to be on shift and to operate the system sometimes in very challenging circumstances
Kayte O’Neill
But also, you know, we've got really good team structures, a great leadership team in and around the control room who are continually having that dialogue with colleagues, making sure that they've got the support that they need. The forums that Fintan talked to will allow us to identify where they think there are specific things that we can do that will help. So a good example of that is, you know, we know that one of the challenges in the control room, one of the things that can make it challenging to operate the system is visibility of what's going on. So they talked to us about that. We're now looking at how do we give better visibility, better situational awareness in the control room.
That's as a direct, you know, sort of outcome of of having those really open conversations.
Bill Esterson
Thanks very much. What I don't understand listening to your answers is why it took a whistleblower and a review for you to recognize the cultural problems.
Fintan Slye
Well, I think there was a huge amount that was already underway that we were doing to to address those those issues.
I think that the review because of its nature and and being a public report put a very fine point on it. But I think, you know, we are a relatively young organisation that has been growing significantly and to the extent that there were cultural issues within the organisation, we were looking to address them proactively through all of this. Obviously with having those very specific seven recommendations in the report which, you know, the board have accepted in full provides a focus for delivering on them.
Bill Esterson
Yeah. I mean you're not the first large organisation to face cultural issues but of course the safety critical nature of your organisation puts it on a different level.
The very big difference between people in theory being able to engage with senior managers to raise any concerns and in practice feeling, having the confidence, and Kayte used the word trust, it's a really important word, trusting that they will be listened to and not just listened to but respected and not suffer adverse consequences as a result. How are you making sure that this is a success?
Fintan Slye
So we're acutely conscious of exactly the things that you say, Chair, because it is the lived experience of colleagues that matters, not the set of processes. Processes are important, they're necessary but not sufficient. We need to make sure that people feel that they will be heard.
As I say, one of the key things in the report that came through was that the people that were interviewed indicated they were relatively comfortable actually raising the concern with their manager. What they felt was that that feedback loop wasn't closed, and that will have a knock-on consequence, so the next time they may not actually raise it at all because they feel that it hasn't been heard or it hasn't been acted on, even if it has somewhere in the organisation, we just haven't closed the feedback loop. So we are looking to put in those both behavioural changes, so at an executive level in terms of how we engage with the teams, but also put in place the processes such that those feedback loops are really clear and really closed.
Bill Esterson
You've talked about your executive level engagement a few times now.
Does this mean that you and your executive team are going to be talking to engineers and people at all levels of the organisation to build those relationships and to demonstrate by leading that that's the culture change you want?
Fintan Slye
Absolutely, we will be out there doing that, talking to them. And it's something I do all of the time. I go into the control room, talk to the teams. It's something we do around the organisation. But I think we need to, it's clear we need to do more of that and be better at doing it.
And also, where things come up in those conversations, that there is actually a follow-through or follow-up and back to that individual who raises something. So I think that is, that is really important. And that, those are the things that will change the culture of the organisation and indeed the lived experience of the people who work for us.
Speaker 16
Just to pick up some of that, when did you first become aware that there was a disconnect between the senior leadership team and the control room?
Fintan Slye
Well, I suppose when I read the report, it brought it into... Yes, sorry, so you had no knowledge, before you read the report, you did not believe there was a disconnect between the senior leadership team and the control room? Not as articulated in as stark a set of terms as was in the report when it was published. And I think, you know, when you read something like that as Chief Executive, it, you know, you are very thoughtful about what it says.
Graeme James Downie
Given, given that you've been in post for two years, do you not feel that that level of disconnect, given that you've just told the chair that you're speaking to these people all the time, you've got all these processes in place, do you not feel that in that two years you should have been aware of that disconnect between the control room and the senior leadership team?
Fintan Slye
So I think through the two years we've worked really hard across all of the operational teams and the control room and all of the staff in the organisation to make sure that they have a voice, that they are connected with the organisation. We do extensive staff engagement surveys. We do...
Graeme James Downie
None of that showed up to you as the chief executive that there was a disconnect. It was only the report that has highlighted the severity of that to you.
Fintan Slye
The report brought home the severity of that in a way that caused me to reflect and to look at what I can do, what and what the rest of the leadership team can do to address that.
Graeme James Downie
And what reflections did that lead to, that perhaps the steps you'd been taking for the initial two years were not working in terms of identifying that disconnect?
Fintan Slye
So so I think some of the things like the chair talked about in terms of engagement with the teams in the control room, some of the things that we are putting in place and had moved to put in place before this report came out, for example, the engineering forum, which is chaired by our chief engineer and specifically designed to enable people to raise concerns and or opportunities. So so it's not just the risks, but it's also we think we could do we think that this new tool would would allow us to do something in a different way.
Graeme James Downie
And you presumably would say that the measure wouldn't have had time for it to be reflected to pull through for the report to reflect?
Fintan Slye
No, and we are continuously looking at how do we improve the engagement right across the organisation with colleagues and how can we do a better job of ensuring that the brilliant people that we have can do the great work that they need to do. And that is, as a Chief Exec, that is a continuous job and a continuous role to look at how we can do that better.
Graeme James Downie
And how can you have, again, I'm going back to your two years of not realising that this level of disconnect existed? What gives you confidence that there's not other things that you're missing as well, despite having put in place over two years continuous improvement in all these things?
Fintan Slye
Yeah, well, so I suppose we have the report and the things that it found, right? So I think that is a set of actions and recommendations that we'll now take forward and deal with. But as I say, we do extensive surveying of our staff on an anonymous basis that allows them to provide feedback to the executive team and provide their perspectives on the organization.
Graeme James Downie
But clearly they haven't been effective up to this point, up to the point of the report.
Fintan Slye
I think the report identified a specific issue of a disconnect between the control room teams and executive management. And I think, you know, a control room is a really specific environment given its shift work, it is a day-to-day, minute-to-minute operational task that is incredibly complex.
And I have such high regard for the brilliant people that are in there and the job that they do. But engaging, because of the shift patterns, because of the type of work that they do, it is a different form of engagement that you need to ensure you bring them in.
Graeme James Downie
Is that not fairly obvious from two years ago? That's a fairly obvious different part of the organisation, a critical part of the organisation that has to be engaged with differently. And yet it doesn't sound like that was maybe happening as much as it should have been.
Fintan Slye
And I think what the report has shown is that a disconnect did develop and that is something that we are now working very actively and are very seized of the need to address.
Graeme James Downie
Just briefly looking forward, you mentioned in your opening remarks and questions to my colleagues about this upscaling of the organisation. How are you making sure that in that upscaling you're not embedding the difficulties that you've faced up to now and that have been highlighted by the report?
Fintan Slye
So I think we think very carefully about sort of the culture of the organisation that that we want to have and the values that that we have within the organisation. And we are, one of the things we've in our plans is to do a broader cultural diagnostic around the whole organisation.
Graeme James Downie
Okay. My concern here, having sat through and worked with many corporate organisations who use phrases like corporate diagnostic, most teams will go, "What the hell is that?" and they will switch off immediately.
So can I suggest that in engaging with the workforce, those kind of terms perhaps point to a cultural problem rather than trying to solve one.
Fintan Slye
Absolutely fair enough point and point taken. And maybe to take a step back then and just say that the culture of the organisation is really, really important. As an executive and indeed as the board, we're acutely conscious of that. We are a growing organisation and in doing that, we need to make sure that we instill absolutely the culture that we want.
It is an organization that has transitioned from being a subsidiary of a sort of FTSE 20 large private sector organization to being a standalone public corporation and that is quite different and that is something that we actively talk to our teams and our staff around around what the different expectations are of leadership, of openness, of transparency, of delivery within that type of organization. So it is a conversation that we continue to have with the organization about this.
Bill Esterson
Before I go to Torcuil Crichton, I'm going to ask you this. Are you the right person to take the organization forward?
Fintan Slye
So I believe I am, Chair. I am absolutely committed to the organization, to its mission.
I think it is an absolutely phenomenal group of people who do a phenomenal job delivering for the country, society, and the economy. And it is really hard, obviously, as chief executive when you read a report such as the one that was published. I think the helpful thing is it points to the things that need to be done, and I am completely committed to ensuring those things are delivered and that the organisation is the great organisation that it can and should be.
Torcuil Crichton
Thank you, chair. You stole my thunder slightly. Thanks for coming in, and I know this is difficult. But Fintan, I'm a journalist, I like whistleblowers. They tend to speak truth unto power.
And the picture they present in newspaper reports is quite different from the one you've presented to us today. They say that, you know, that safe-to-say program to allow staff to raise concerns, they describe that as a running joke. And they say that people get beaten down if they're not acquiescent, if they don't comply with management thinking. Do you think you've got the confidence of your staff?
Fintan Slye
So I think I believe I do. I think that it is always difficult and it is a disappointment to me that there is any individual or team within the organisation that doesn't feel that they can speak truth to power, that they can have their voice heard.
That is always a disappointment. But when I look across the organisation and look at the feedback that we get through both informal channels, one-to-one, through teamworks that we do, but also through anonymous staff surveys where people have the opportunity to speak up, we don't see the same story as replicated within as I outlined in some of the media reports. And we don't see it reflected in sort of staff data around turnover and things like that. So I believe that I do. I believe there's a huge challenge ahead in the organisation delivering on what is a really, really important mission.
And as I say, it is one person who feels that they, as Kayte said earlier, one person who feels that they have to go outside the organisation to be heard is one person too many.
And we are, I, Kate, the executive team, the board I know, are absolutely committed to improving in that space.
Torcuil Crichton
I get that. Kate, do you get it? Because this is critical safety stuff, you know, keeping the lights on and stuff. And we need everybody going this way, not that way. How are you going to turn that around?
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, as I said, I think, you know, for me, trust, trust is key, alignment around NESO's purpose, mission, the thing we are here to do for GB. I think we have that in spades in the organization.
When I talk to colleagues in the business about why do they work for NESO, it's because they know it's an organisation where they can have impact, they're doing work that really matters and they're hugely proud of doing that work. But it is absolutely on us to make sure that people feel that they can be really honest and really open when they're thinking about the challenges that face us today and will face us as an organisation going forward, and that they believe that as they surface those things, we will listen, we will act, we will follow up, and we will always do that.
Speaker 25
We need you to make it work. We rely on you. How are you going to do it?
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, we take it really, really seriously. We've talked about the recommendations in the report, we've talked about our commitment to following up on them. I think one of the things that's very clear to me is, you know, the organisation, they will hold us to account if they don't feel that we're acting, they will call us out, and I'm delighted about that. I think that is really important. We are going to be completely transparent with the plans that we put in place.
We have kicked off our thinking, but we're out in the organisation today talking to colleagues. Do these plans resonate?
Do they make sense? Do you feel like it will make the difference?
When was the last time, could you remember?
Kayte O’Neill
I spoke to the trade unions the day that the, the day before the report was published. I've been talking to them over the summer about some of the themes that we're seeing coming through in the organization. We are very privileged to have a good, positive, sort of engagement and relationship with the unions. They hold us to account. They feel like they can challenge us, and I hope that they would say that they see us respond.
Thanks, Mike Reader.
Michael Reader
Thank you, Chair. The organisation sitting between households in the UK experiencing power cuts and blackouts this winter has a toxic culture, has a leadership that didn't know it had a toxic culture, and has repeatedly missed critical deadlines it has to meet. Kayte, how can people be assured their lights won't go off this winter?
Kayte O’Neill
The security and resilience of the system is our number one priority. It has always been our number one priority, and it continues to be. As an organisation, we have a very broad mandate, and we have a mandate that allows us to see from what does it take to keep the lights on today through to what will it take to keep the lights on way out into the future. And we spend all day, every day, teams across the organisation focused on that challenge.
Michael Reader
Fintan, in a leaked meeting in the Times, you made it clear your priority was connections, not on security. So is Kate right there?
Fintan Slye
She is right. Sorry, I don't recall the, I don't have the transcript of the meeting that the Times quoted or whether that was out of context. But I think NESO's mandate around security of supply is crystal clear.
Michael Reader
Okay. I will come back to grid connections in a second because if you've prepared for this meeting, this session, you will know that's my focus area. But I want to talk about remuneration. Could you confirm you're both salaried employees working directly for NESO?
Fintan Slye
So my salary is reported in the annual reports and accounts, subject to review by the remuneration committee, and my base salary was £309,000.
Okay.
Kayte O’Neill
Mine is similar to Fintan's, reported publicly available, our total comp is published, my salary is just below that, high 200s.
And do you have a bonus structure?
We do.
Fintan Slye
That bonus is calculated by the independent remuneration committee of the board in line with an agreed remuneration policy that's published and approved by the regulator.
Fintan Slye
It is based on a series of metrics. The metrics are published in the annual report, the remuneration committee's assessment of those metrics is published, and the outcome of those are published.
Fintan Slye
So they are set out in the, they're set out in the company's annual report and they reflect the sort of strategic objectives of the company.
Fintan Slye
There are metrics around people and the Remuneration Committee will obviously take into account culture of the organisation as it reflects upon the overall outcome of, of the bonus as you would expect them to.
Michael Reader
So culture, staff satisfaction and obviously the issues raised in the Ofsted report, do you therefore think your remuneration was fair given the failings that have been found in the organisation?
Fintan Slye
So the remuneration committee of the board have not yet determined outcomes for the last year. So they will, and I am sure that they will take an objective, transparent view about overall performance of the business and performance against the objectives in coming to a conclusion.
Michael Reader
And do you think, based on the performance of the organization and the scale of the organization, that your remuneration is fair and reasonable, both of you?
Fintan Slye
So I think that the remuneration, as I said, is set by an independent remuneration committee of the board, and they benchmark the salary and the package against...
Do you think it's fair?
Okay.
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, I'm just in the processes that the remuneration committee will operate.
Michael Reader
And you feel, having been measured on culture and performance of the business, a business that has been found to have a problem with culture and which has repeatedly missed deadlines, you are happy that the way you've been remunerated is reflective of the performance of the organization? As I say, the remuneration committee of the board has not taken a decision on... It will have done in previous years, right? And I'm asking about your position, not what the remuneration board asks. I'm asking for both of you.
Fintan Slye
And if I reflect back on the last year for which, for example, the independent regulator provided a view on the performance of the organization, they said it met its expectations. So that is one metric that you can use. As you point out, there are a various other ones, including staff satisfaction, staff engagement, where typically we score above the industry norm.
Obviously, the recent Eversheds report has pointed to a number of issues where we need to make improvements. And I trust in the objectivity and transparency of the remuneration committee that they'll take those things into properly into account as they reflect on it.
Michael Reader
Do you feel, Kayte, you've got all of the tools you need now to deliver the changes that need to happen as the Chief Operating Officer?
Kayte O’Neill
Yes, I do. We've got a very broad mandate as a team. As I say, everything from operating the electricity system, keeping the lights on in real time, all the way through to planning the system out to 2050. We spend a lot of time as a team, as an organisation, thinking about what it will take to deliver across that suite of priorities. And I do believe we've got what we need to be successful.
Michael Reader
I'm going to come on to connections and grid reform if that's okay. So we're now on the second extension for phase, Great Grid Upgrade phase one offers, 31st of October. Kate, are we going to see that there's no more extensions, those remaining 10% tricky ones are going to be all done in three days' time?
Fine.
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, so we're working with every individual customer who is still waiting for their phase one offer. And when those, so we are on track to hit those deadlines. But as you say, that tail of offers that are still to go out are the ones that are extremely complex, the ones we're working very closely with the customer to make sure we're meeting their needs.
Kayte O’Neill
If the customer is ready to receive the offer, i.e. if the customer feels that we have given them everything they need to be confident that they can accept that offer, then we would be ready to be done. But actually some of those conversations with a very small, you know, single-digit small number of customers are still going on this week.
Kayte O’Neill
No, but it won't be because of the process. It will be because some of these offers, these projects, these are the really big, really complex ones that are very important to the energy system, very important that we get them right so that the customer can accept that offer and we can move forward.
Michael Reader
When you missed deadlines last time, it was blamed on National Grid's design and engineering. Does NESO have all the... you actually, and you've said earlier, Fintan, that you don't have all the levers you need to pull to deliver clean power 2030 and this stuff.
What conversations have you had with government about giving you all those levers to make sure that you can get these things done?
Fintan Slye
So, referring back to earlier for clean power 2030, NESO will never and should not have all of those levers. It is the delivery on the ground of big-ticket infrastructure, which is delivered by the transmission owners, it's delivered by the DNOs. You also have all of the generation companies delivering their individual projects. And then alongside that, you have issues such as planning reform that government is engaged in. So it is a multifaceted program to get to 2030.
And I don't, I suppose I don't think that NESO can or should have all of the levers necessary to do that.
Michael Reader
And coming back to these current offers, when National Grid's design must have been on your critical path, at what point did you become aware there were problems?
Kayte O’Neill
So we are in continuous, and I really do mean continuous, daily engagement across the network companies, NESO, the Ofgem teams on connection and the DESNZ teams on connections, such as the ways of working on connections reform. So once we had the full queue published, we started to understand the scale of what was ahead of us collectively in getting offers out for those projects. We completed the issuing of protected offers and as we were sort of coming into close on those, we started work on the phase one offers.
And then that was when we started to understand how much more was going to need to be built. So with all of the batteries and projects that had successfully come into the queue with their protections, with the additional demand that we'd seen in the queue, there is a huge amount to be connected in phase one. And that did require a level of restudy and we've worked really closely with the network companies.
Kayte O’Neill
We possibly had underestimated how much restudying work would be done. It was only as we saw the volume of stuff that was meeting the protection clauses and therefore coming into the queue. We knew it was a risk, but it really crystallized as a risk once we had that full visibility of the new pipeline and we were translating that into what it meant for the network build-out to accommodate it.
Michael Reader
And so what measures have you put in place to avoid this happening again?
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, so we've fundamentally changed our ways of working. We had historically in the very early phases of connections reform been working in, you know, less of a sort of a collaborative ongoing way. So we've really brought that together. We've also implemented some very rigorous, sort of what I would refer to in operational terms as command-style governance. So we're meeting twice a week at an executive level where we, you know, we really hammer out the challenges.
We have the decision-makers in the room. We take decisions, we move the program forward. And then we meet again at an executive level with DESNZ and Ofgem fortnightly. So anything that needs escalating because it's a policy question, we now have a very fast route of people who are sufficiently in the detail to be decision-makers, take decisions and move the program forward. Both of those have been fundamental.
Michael Reader
So can you assure us that in future connection offers etcetera that we won't see further delays?
That's very positive.
Kayte O’Neill
I think phase two, we've been really transparent, is also going to be difficult. There is a huge amount still to be connected in phase two and we're in really active discussions with industry.
Michael Reader
So what's, I don't know actually off the top of my head, what's the deadline for hitting your phase two offers?
Kayte O’Neill
So it goes out into the early part of next year. So when you take transmission and distribution into account, it's the end of Q1.
End of March.
Kayte O’Neill
I wouldn't want to sort of knee-jerk into giving a confidence level right now. I think there are some difficult challenges.
Michael Reader
If you're on a twice-weekly drumbeat of meeting, you must have a confidence level in whatever dashboard you're receiving.
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, so we're working really hard to get to one. And the best way to get to one is to understand every single offer that needs to be issued, what type of studying is required, the order in which you can do that, the complexities you're going to find. I'm confident that we've made really significant improvements to our processes. So the processes themselves are more slick. We were having errors previously that we're managing to sort of remove now.
So we're doing everything we can from a process perspective. But I think it would... I would be uncomfortable giving you a sort of a probability number without us having fully yet understood the queue, but we are actively doing that work.
Michael Reader
You should have a probability position as a basic rule of your project controls. Even if it's like P20, P30, whatever it's going to be, you should have a probability of what... of how likely you think you are to meet that deadline.
That's a fundamental of running a program.
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, we do, but it, you're absolutely right, it's a fundamental, those are exactly the terms in which we think. But whilst we are so actively trying to unpack, you know, in real time right now, these are conversations that are happening in the organisation.
Michael Reader
And we've talked a lot about engineers, how many qualified planners and project controls professionals work in NESO?
Speaker 51
Qualified engineers work in NESO as planners and project controls professionals?
Could you write back to us and let us know?
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Chair. So on the 23rd of June, after the grid performance fell below normal operating limits, and given the Eversheds report and the cultural issues, what's your assessment on the scale of the disconnect between management and operators in the control room, given that they are fundamentally quite different functions within the organisation?
Fintan Slye
So I suppose in respect of the 23rd of June, just to say, I mean, I think that the control room did a phenomenal job managing what was a really difficult set of circumstances. And I think you can see from the interim report, interim Ofgem report, the number of different things that were happening on the system and the scale of the challenge that they had to manage.
And I think, as I say, I think they did a terrific job doing that. And, you know, and we have continued to support the investigation into it. And I'm sure, given the nature of that extreme event that went on for a week with sort of repeated red weather warnings, that there will be learnings for the energy industry, for us, to make it more resilient going into the future. In terms of sort of a disconnect between executive management and control room teams, I mean, I think what's also clear on the day is that the control room teams had all of the operational independence and decision-making that they needed and support from the executive for the decisions that they took.
When we take a step back at sort of the broader conversations between executive leadership and the control room, back to the conversation we had earlier, I mean, that is something that we are reflecting on, how do we improve that? And forums like the ones that we have established are ways that we can do that and ensure that to the extent people have concerns or issues or ideas that they want brought forward, that there is a really clear path to do that. But as we've said, it is also about the lived experience of those colleagues, right, and making sure that in addition to the processes being there, that they feel that they should use them and that they will be heard if they do use them as well.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
So given that, do you think that senior executives understand the reality of the pressure that is faced by those in the control room who are tasked with keeping the lights on day in and day out?
Fintan Slye
I think we do. I'm not sure that we have communicated that back to the control room sufficiently. But the sort of the conversations that that we would have and and the issues that we look at is looking at what are the tools and processes, like how is the system getting more complex and more challenging? So what are the driving factors within that? And it undoubtedly is getting more complex as a system to operate.
And therefore what are the tools, resources and capabilities we need to make sure that those teams in the control room have, and indeed outside the control room, because, you know, it arrives in the minute in the control room. How their ability to do their job is hugely influenced by the jobs done by all of the teams that sort of set up that day in advance, sort of the outages that are in place, etc.
So we spend a lot of time making sure that we understand what are the tools and processes, capability builds, shift patterns, shift resource numbers.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
So that I can understand that, how many, as a way by way of an example, how many days per year might each of your executive teams spend in the control room so that there is that really close affinity with the pressure that they're facing to develop your understanding of the job and obligation that they've got to reduce that detachment, the size of that gulf between the control room and executives? How many days per year would you spend in the control room?
Fintan Slye
I'm based in Wokingham, right where the control room is, and I would try to drop in as much as I can into the control room, talk to the power system managers, the person who is managing it on the day to see how it is. We also have different sort of engagement forums whereby we would do it. But Kayte would spend more time in the control room, Craig, who's our director of system operations, even more time in the control room. We did a process a while ago where we went in and even did a portion of a night shift, because that's really different as well, how the control room experiences that. We also operate across two sites, and actually there's a different dynamic in both sites, the team setup etc. is different.
So we would have gone and done that. So we are conscious of that.
I mean if I if I reflect on the report probably need to do more. And and I think you know as I said the report made for me as chief executive for me as an individual and as a leader uncomfortable reading and and made me want to you know lean in more and understand more from those individuals and teams across the control room and as I say the wider operational teams that support them.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
And given the event in June this dropping below normal operating limits what's your confidence level for winter and what would we need to see in order for NESO to call a stress event?
Fintan Slye
So our confidence for this winter I mean we we believe that sort of margins and security of supply is broadly in line with previous years when we look at sort of margins we look at operational patterns through the year.
So, you know, we're not flagging any increased levels of risk this winter. I think the control room absolutely know when they need to issue warnings and you've seen them do that when the sort of the surplus is not as much as they would like to see. So, you know, if at the start of the day when they look to the peak, the market position, the sort of the position the market has notified them is closer than they would like or they feel that they need in order to manage the system, they will issue an electricity margin notice and, you know, we will issue them based on the operational realities that the control room face, have done, will do, will continue to do. What we see is that there's an increasing desire for even more transparency and more explanation behind that.
Maybe that's a back to conversation earlier or point the chair raised earlier about explaining some of these things. I mean, there was a time when issue of a market notice would go unnoticed in the wider public, but there's a huge interest in these things. And I suppose we are looking also at how do we provide the wider information and context around what's happening on the system. But the control room and the leaders in the control room will take the required operational decisions based on the operational reality that they face. And we're crystal clear that that is the only thing that should matter to them.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Okay, and one final question if I can, chair, on the remuneration point again.
Given that you're Chief Executive of NESO, responsible for the overall performance and the culture within the organisation, and given the failings reported culturally within the Eversheds report, in 2024-25 your package was almost £1 million, including a sizeable bonus. Given the failings of NESO this year, regardless of what the committee recommends, will you decline a bonus for this year given the performance of NESO?
Anthony Bradley Thomas
But you personally, do you think you should decline a bonus this year given the performance of NESO?
Fintan Slye
I think that the performance of NESO and my performance should be looked at over the full suite of things that we have delivered. And as I said, one of the metrics that I can point to is that the regulatory assessment of NESO's delivery was that we met expectations for the particular year that you're talking about.
Fintan Slye
So I suppose I trust in the impartiality, the fairness, and the processes of the independent remuneration committee of the board.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
Thank you, Chair. So we've talked quite a lot about the day-to-day stress that the control room is under and the Eversheds report looked at that day-to-day stress. Earlier you described the stress that the system was under due to the extreme heat this summer as extreme. I think you may have used the word unprecedented, I'm not sure. But what the Eversheds report also identified is that your staff know that this is actually much more likely to be the new normal.
That going forward, a summer like we've just seen, given climate change, is much more likely than it used to be.
And the report identified high levels of stress and concern within NESO about the longer-term picture as well, not simply these extremes. So what are you going to do to give your staff confidence that in the long term they will be able to deliver their roles and be able to keep the lights on?
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, so, you know, we do spend a lot of time with the organisation talking about how the nature of the energy system is changing and how that changes what is required of our teams in the control room day in, day out. I think we can point to areas where it is becoming more challenging in real time to operate the system. Sometimes we talk about the volume of actions that have to be taken in the control room. And to paint a picture for you, we used to take, you know, maybe 35,000 actions a year, and now we can take 15,000 actions a day.
That gives you a sense of just the, sort of, the volume of what our teams are dealing with. We spend a good amount of time trying to, sort of, understand that and prepare and plan for it. The good news is that, you know, technology, the market, innovation, everybody else in the energy system who's trying to solve some of these long-term challenges are all making great progress in, you know, how, how we can ensure that we mitigate any future risks, manage down those levels of challenge.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
Do you have confidence in the rest of the system that it will meet the challenge?
Kayte O’Neill
I do have confidence. I think we've seen incredible progress over the last five or six years.
It was back when we established the electricity system operator as a ring-fenced part of National Grid back in 2019 that we first started to talk about over a number of years what it would take to be able to operate a clean power system, a very renewables-driven power system. And we've seen incredible innovation in the six or seven years since then to solve those challenges such that now, in today and for a period this year, we've operated the system.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
So what are the risks going forward? Have you identified any new or imminent risks to your operations?
Kayte O’Neill
So we think about seven big operability challenges that we've been talking publicly about for a really long time. We publish an annual operability strategy report that explores those risks and talks about what NESO needs to do, but also what market needs to do, where we need to see regulatory or policy changes to sort of mitigate and manage those risks going forward.
Kayte O’Neill
Yes, so a good example would be, you know, as you take off, and as we have seen, a decline in big thermal fossil-fueled generation on the system, and as we've seen renewables come on, one of the characteristics of a fossil-based system is inertia, and we've had to find innovative ways to replace that inertia in the system. We saw the market respond brilliantly well to you there, both in terms of the technology solutions they could provide, but also the market tools that we would use to procure that service.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
So you've taken me quite nicely onto my next area of interest, which is the road to clean power 2030. Now you've previously talked about two pathways: the new dispatch pathway, which focuses much more on carbon capture, a bit less on offshore wind and depends on shorter duration energy storage, versus a further flex and renewables pathway, which focuses much more on offshore wind, flexibility on the demand side, longer duration energy storage. Now you have said to us previously that it's not one or the other. I would suggest then that pathway is probably not the best metaphor because by definition you choose one or the other.
But what, are you clearer now than you were when you came here a couple of years ago as to where the focus will be on that clean power 2030 pathway? Will the system be focusing more on carbon capture and storage, will it be focusing more on the further flex and renewables pathway? Are you clear about where we're at and where we're going and how that impacts your organisation?
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, so where clarity starts to emerge for us is the projects that actually hold a connection offer to connect to the system and we now have a picture of everything that's in the current queue that is likely to connect. Of course there remain though policy choices for government that will inform to what extent we end up deploying more of those technologies like CCS or hydrogen to power.
To the extent those decisions are taken and then they flow through, we would ultimately see that show up in a connection to the system.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
So, you noted that the new dispatch pathway would leave Britain more exposed to volatile international gas prices because gas would still be used 47% of the time. I don't have a timeframe for that stat though. Do you have a view on which is the best pathway? Is there a pathway that makes it easier or harder for your organisation to manage?
Kayte O’Neill
I don't think there's a easier or harder. I think, you know, there are, as we talked about, there's a level of flexibility that exists in both pathways. There are a set of operational challenges that we already think about and will solve for in either pathway, sort of irrespective of what connects to the system.
So I'm confident that sort of whatever the trajectory, with the time and the focus, we will be able to, you know, continue to operate a secure and resilient system. That was a big test in putting together the Clean Power 2030 advice that we proposed to government and then ultimately their action plan. Everything that went into our advice had been tested for a resilient, secure, and operable system.
Bill Esterson
Thanks very much. I am briefly on to the other side of the room while Melanie Onn takes over as chair.
Torcuil Crichton
Thank you, new chair.
Just a quick question on the back of grid connections on community connections, which don't seem to be a priority at all because no new community schemes will get into the queue as the queue stands just now. And this committee has recommended that NESO shouldn't be agnostic about community connections because they're the best way of getting neighborhoods that are going to be next to this huge infrastructure to benefit from it. Have you taken a view on that, on prioritizing community connections?
Fintan Slye
So, it is not for us to decide to prioritize one type of connection based on ownership structure over another. That is a government policy decision if they want that to happen. Notwithstanding that, we recognize everything you said around the benefit of community schemes and their ability to get communities more engaged in the energy transition and potentially understand better and be more accepting of energy infrastructure and the benefits that it can bring.
So those things are true. Because of that we are looking to see are there things, what we cannot prioritize community energy connections over others.
Fintan Slye
Because we have an obligation to act in a non-discriminatory way and it would be a government, it would be for government to set a policy in the first instance.
Fintan Slye
We can't within the policy framework that exists, so it would require government to take a policy decision that we should do that.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
There's a lot in there that I would like to follow up, but I'm just following what I've prepared as questions. So I hear that you said earlier that a lot of your cultural difficulties that you have within the organization is ultimately because sort of three crises collide. We've got a climate crisis, we've got an energy and affordability crisis, and all of that you have to balance out as an organization. And you had to take quite a lot of heat in questioning from us. For you, it's an opportunity now to maybe turn that around a little bit and tell us whether you think that the government has actually effectively supported policies towards Clean Power 2030.
Do you feel that you've been sort of left here to hold the baby? There are political pressures, Clean Power 2030, but then there's on top of that all the global pressures that we have on energy and affordability.
Do you feel supported by the government enough?
Fintan Slye
So yes, I suppose we don't feel that we're holding the Clean Power 2030 baby. I mean, that is a government policy that they have set out and they own. We play an important part in enabling bits of that to deliver, but as I said out earlier, there are many other parts of industry, government, the regulator, etc. that need to do things in order to deliver clean power by 2030. I think one of the key things for us is, A, how do we make sure that we keep the lights on today? And we talked a good bit about that and making sure that that is secure.
But thinking then in the long term about how do you think about designing an energy system that works for Great Britain? And that is how do you think through the infrastructure that's needed, the impact that that will have on communities? How do you think about the affordability of building out anything that you want to do and reliance on imported fossil fuels? And through doing the strategic spatial energy plan and the regional energy strategic plans, I think that is the mechanism through which we can work with government, help inform government around some of those policy choices that they need to make.
But in transforming an energy system, you do have all of those things at play. And, you know, we are seeing in real time the cost of energy being really high up the agenda, if not at the top of the agenda, from a public point of view, and tackling that has to be an absolute priority.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Do you therefore think that actually Net Zero Clean Power 2030 will ultimately lose its ranking in the priority line?
Fintan Slye
Maybe in the narrative, but I think when we looked at Clean Power 2030 and we gave the advice to government, one of the things we looked at was on a sort of system-wide basis, was it more or less expensive than not going for that target?
And the answer at the time was that they were broadly equivalent in terms of total system costs in the 2030 target. I think one of the key things that we reflect on is at that time the gas price was 100 pence a therm, and indeed we faced some criticism for that being too high an assumption to have. Gas this morning, I think, was 217 pence a therm with no prospect of it coming down anytime soon. So what Clean Power 2030 or a transition off imported gas and onto more homegrown generation, be that renewables or nuclear, does provide Great Britain with more control over the input costs to its energy system. And therefore I'm not, I suppose I don't think that the two are mutually exclusive.
But I do think that the overarching imperative at the moment is to address the affordability crisis.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
And do you believe the government has recognized that and their policies, because we've just heard some decisions are just government decisions, you know, prioritizing community energy is ultimately a policy thing, therefore you're just following policy decisions. Do you feel that that needs to get that policy direction from the government, you know, in the heat of the moment, because, you know, a lot of things collide together?
Fintan Slye
Yeah, so we work really, really closely with both government and Ofgem across a range of things. I mean, Kate talked about the very close working, for example, on connection offers, right, and that is fortnightly meeting with decision makers at DESNZ and Ofgem around it. On the longer-term issues such as strategic spatial energy plan, we also work really, really closely with them.
So I think we have a really good relationship with them. I think that we feel that we have the ability to to raise issues and input those into the policy debate. And I think that, you know, as far as government policy making is is concerned, you know, from NESO's perspective, you know, we adhere to government policy once it's decided.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
And just one one very quick one, Chair, because we talked about flexibility and it's one of our big focuses as well. Would you say it's a technical problem or is it a market regulation problem to make flexibility really work?
Kayte O’Neill
I think it's largely getting the the market signals, so the routes to market, the ability for for that flexibility to be brought forward, to be valued appropriately, and then to have access to the markets to to extract that value. There are, you know, important coordination questions, how do you make those markets effective across the multiple players? And I think there's a lot of focus on that with the flexibility commissioner, the market facilitator, and all of us as organizations sort of working to resolve some of those challenges.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
And can we come back to the government policy point? Do you when you talk about market signals, a lot of those are being sort of ultimately set by government. Do you think the government does enough market signaling policy-wise in order to make that flexibility work properly?
Kayte O’Neill
I think there's a huge amount of work going on under the reform national pricing work that government is currently leading on. We really look forward to, you know, that work delivering clarity and conclusions on market design going forward that will unlock things like the value of flexibility but provide all of the right signals to all market participants to enable that.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Earlier you've been put under pressure to sort of put timelines or deadlines onto your answers. Do you think there should be a timeline for that or a proper date when that should have happened or should happen?
Kayte O’Neill
I think it is always really helpful for industry to have clarity on when decisions will be taken. Undoubtedly the complexity of the market reform is, you know, it is impacting on the time taken to make the decisions in this space. I think there's a huge amount of consultation has happened, is continuing to happen.
But I know from talking to government there is a real appetite to to get this locked down and provide that certainty into the market.
Speaker 68
Thanks Chair. Thanks very much. Mr Slye, are you responsible for scrutinising the costs of balancing the grid?
Fintan Slye
Responsible for scrutinising the costs of balancing the grid? Yes so we incur the the costs that are paid for for balancing the grid but in many cases they are the costs provided to us for example by generators to turn up or down their output and the scrutiny of those costs for example belongs to Ofgem those are sort of market players and Ofgem regulates.
Christopher Chope
The NAO has said that you are you do have a role in scrutinising the costs. You accept that? The National Audit Office has said that you have such a role.
Yes okay.
Speaker 68
So, so what is going to be the cost of balancing the grid in the current financial year?
Speaker 70
In the current financial year, we think it'll be about three billion pounds.
Eight billion pounds.
Christopher Chope
Okay, let's put this in context. Today, I think the Chancellor of the Exchequer is going to make a big announcement about removing standing charges from gas bills. And there are 23 million users of gas, and they are going to have these standing charges removed. The cost, calculated at just over £100 per year per user, is about £2.5 billion. So the Chancellor is going to make a big thing about £2.5 billion being saved from bills for the coming year in 2027.
And yet you are forecasting that between this year and 2030, there is going to be an increase of about £5 billion in the costs of balancing the grid, which are four-square put upon the consumer, aren't they, the user of the electricity?
Fintan Slye
Yeah, and those those numbers and those projections are something that we've highlighted for a number of years now.
And we are absolutely committed to making sure that they are as low as possible. We recognize that that is the current costs today, we recognize are a huge burden on consumers and flow through, you're absolutely correct, they flow through to bills. And we are doing, I think there are two things to to note. Maybe one, in the in the medium term, the thing that will get constraint and balancing costs down is the delivery of new network. And we are working with all of the transmission companies and with government and Ofgem to get network delivered as quickly as possible.
That is the thing that ultimately brings those constraint costs down.
Christopher Chope
But these but these balancing costs are a stealth tax on consumers. They're contributing to the cost of living crisis.
And I was looking at the figures, and back in 2013-14, the balancing costs were only one billion pounds. And you are now complacently saying, well, we may be able to limit it to about eight billion pounds by 2030. This is unacceptable. And am I right in saying that if we hadn't got this obsession with net zero and clean energy by 2030, that these costs would be significantly reduced, in fact could be put back to the level that they were in 2013-14 and thereby save consumers the order of seven billion pounds a year?
Fintan Slye
So maybe just first of all to clarify, there's nothing complacent in how we view that level of cost and those levels of costs flowing through to consumers' bills.
We are absolutely doing everything we can to try to minimize those costs. They are the costs that arise due to the actions that are necessary to ensure security of supply in the control room. We have been flagging for a while now that they are due to rise. Some of that increase this year is is down to the increase in the wholesale gas price because some of the actions we take are to turn up gas generation in parts of the country and if that is significantly more expensive then that does flow through to balancing costs.
But notwithstanding that, the key to getting constraint costs down, and we share absolutely the concern about that level of cost, is the delivery of network infrastructure. In the short term, we are working with the transmission companies to maximize what can be got out of the assets that are already there, using things like dynamic line rating, where in real time you can push more power through lines.
Christopher Chope
Okay, so when are we going to get these balancing costs back to where they were in 2013-14 of a billion pounds a year?
Fintan Slye
So they drop significantly in the very early 2030s. Our projections are that they drop significantly, and that is in line with the delivery program by the network companies.
I think they come back down to our projection is two billion pounds a year, but I would have to come back to you on that. We we published a an estimate of these. I'll I'll I can't I'll have to come back to you on the number, but I think it's two.
To a billion pounds a year?
Christopher Chope
When people complain about the cost of net zero policies and the insistence on the 2030 target for clean so-called clean electricity, then what I'm saying is that these are costs, these constraint costs or balancing charges imposed upon the consumer are a direct consequence of that insane policy, aren't they?
Fintan Slye
So the level of constraint costs really come the biggest driver of them is a mismatch in infrastructure delivery times between generation and transmission with the generation connecting before the transmission infrastructure can build.
And we've seen transmission infrastructure take longer. But it is also important to point out that constraint costs are not the sum total of the benefits or disbenefits, costs, let's not use slang, costs to consumers. When you connect this generation earlier, it actually displaces gas and brings down the wholesale price of electricity. So the eight billion pounds is too much. It is too high.
We are focused on getting it down. But I wouldn't want you to walk out of here with the impression that delivery of the renewable infrastructure early is just a cost. There is also a benefit to it that accrues to customers through lower wholesale prices.
Christopher Chope
Well, we have yet to see any reduction in electricity prices. Our electricity prices are the highest in Europe, if not in the rest of the developed world. So when are we going to get electricity prices down to the same level as gas prices are at the moment?
Fintan Slye
Well, so hopefully soon, but I mean, it is the, it is the very high gas price that is one of the key drivers of high electricity prices.
Fintan Slye
Well, you have the, the spark gap, which is, which is the difference between them. But high gas prices play an important role in the feeding through to the high electricity price that we have.
And I think one of the benefits of a transition away from gas-fired generation to nuclear, renewables, etc., is that you are less reliant in your electricity system and therefore the price is less set by the gas.
Christopher Chope
There's a difference, isn't there, between nuclear, which is always constant, and the renewables, which are variable? And what you're having to do is use public money, taxpayers' money, consumers' money, in order to try and enable the grid coming from the electricity to accommodate surges in power from windmills and surges in power from solar.
If we didn't invest so much in Chinese windmills and Chinese solar panels, then the costs to you of balancing the system would be far lower, wouldn't they?
Fintan Slye
So without getting into different origins of location of technology, but I think that it's really important that you have a diverse portfolio of generation. It provides greater resilience for the country as a whole to have a diverse portfolio. And when taking into, when looking at the costs that consumers face, absolutely we should factor in constraint costs and we should absolutely focus on getting them down.
But we also need to look at what are the whole system costs that consumers face, because consumers pay all of the costs within our energy system. And it is incumbent on us as NESO, but on the energy industry, to make sure that we are trying to get the lowest cost system. And I suppose one of the ways to think about it is we will never and probably should never get to a situation where constraint costs are zero. If you get to that point, you have probably overbuilt your network such that never for one hour on one day is there a constraint. You've probably over, so there is an, there is an optimal.
Christopher Chope
Okay, all I'm asking on behalf of consumers is a reduction in these enormously high costs. And I think there was one day earlier on this month where some 47 million pounds was spent in a day on balancing costs, direct costs upon consumers of electricity. This is intolerable. And you seem to not recognize the need to try and prevent these increases taking place. You're already three times what it was in 2013-14.
You're projecting to go up another 5 billion pounds a year beyond that. Why aren't you taking immediate action to level that off so we don't go beyond, say, 3 and a half billion pounds a year? Just limit it for the future.
Fintan Slye
So they're a function of, as I said, the main driver of the constraint costs and driving them up to the numbers we talked about...
Christopher Chope
I must finish, but these are a direct consequence of misguided government policy, aren't they?
Fintan Slye
As I say, in order to assess the, so constraint costs add to consumers' bills, and I wouldn't want anyone to leave here with the impression that we were doing anything other than trying to minimize them. But we also, it is important to recognize that constraint costs are one part of the set of costs that consumers pay. And when you bring generation on, for example, ahead of the transmission infrastructure, that can give rise to constraint costs. It also can reduce the wholesale price of electricity.
And what I'm saying is that I think we're all should be focused, and we are focused on trying to ensure that consumers' bills are as low as possible. Energy prices are too high, and we need to pull, to use your language, every lever that we have available to us to make sure that we're doing that. And we are absolutely focused on trying to get constraint costs to be as low as they can be using the things that are within our control, and where they're outside our control, trying to use the influence that we have to... And you will be judged on the results. Always.
Claire Louise Young
Um, I'd like to start with a very quick question, which I hope will get a quick answer. Um, you talked earlier about dropping in on the control room as being a way to connect.
Do you recognize that the boss dropping in could be perceived in different ways, and if you've got a toxic culture, or a perceived toxic culture, then it may be perceived not as a positive?
Fintan Slye
I suppose that that is possible, and to be honest, that's why probably I always ring the PSM before I walk into the control room so I'm not doing it unannounced and say, "How's things going in the system?" "Is it all right if I drop in and have a quick chat?" So I do that. I try to be as open and engaging with staff right across the business as I can be.
staff right across the business as as as I can be, but but yeah, I mean for a, you know, control engineer within any part of the business it can be intimidating if, you know, the CEO wanders over and says how you doing today, what's what's this going on and that's why we're acutely conscious of that and try to make sure that we do it, that I do it, and that I do it in a really thoughtful way as I say, you know, that and I know it's a trivial example but but just saying like I do call the PSM before I would walk into the control room.
Claire Louise Young
I'm just just wondering about your awareness of how you're coming across given the what we've read in the press. But if I can move on, we want to return to I want to return to demand-led flexibility because I think it's illustrative of some of the issues. So out there businesses and consumers care about security of supply and cost. And you said earlier despite what had been reported in the press, you believe keeping the lights on is top priority. Yet the clear flexibility roadmap is focused on the clean power target.
So are you on track for the flexibility to the 10 to 12 gigawatts of flexibility by 2030 needed to deliver that target? And is that also the right roadmap for maintaining energy security, or are there conflicts there?
Kayte O’Neill
So think about flexibility in two parts, sort of demand-side flexibility and then supply-side flexibility. We've talked a bit this morning already about demand-side flexibility, whether that's consumers in their homes or whether that's businesses, and we're making really good progress in that space towards...
Kayte O’Neill
Because we actually set ourselves targets for the amount of flexibility that we would want to see coming through, and we are meeting and in some cases at this moment in time exceeding those targets.
And we've, you know, worked really hard with industry to put those targets in place, make them very transparent, work with industry and they're holding us to account to make progress. Um, but as Fintan said earlier, you know, many of the different parts of the Clean Power Action Plan required really significant change, and growth in flexibility was, was one of those. And the supply-side flexibility is a, is a really important part of that. There is largely going to be sort of policy-driven as to where the different sources of, of flexibility come forward. But that is not to say in the meantime that if some of those big sources of flexibility don't come forward that we have an insecure or inoperable system.
As we said, we're confident that, you know, there is movement between the different pathways and that if we have less flexibility, we have to account for that elsewhere. But certainly from NESO's perspective, and in fact when we were creating the Clean Power Advice, we started with what is the maximum flexibility we can get on the system and then, you know, that minimizes what else you need. So we take it very, very seriously in that sense.
Kayte O’Neill
On the, you know, on the demand side, some of the things that we've already talked about continue to be important. We do know from talking to the market that they still see barriers to getting in. The deployment of smart meters has been a really big part of enabling customers to be able to see what they're using, when they're using it, and to see the value of flexing their demand, for example.
So we continue to push on all of those fronts. As I say, I think we're making good progress, but, you know, there ultimately will be decisions for others in the energy system to make as well.
Claire Louise Young
And if it does if you can't achieve the flexibility, have you worked out what you're going to do instead?
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, we, you know, all of the time through all of our strategic planning, we are looking at how do we maintain a secure and resilient system. We do that for the very, very long term, but we're also doing it for, you know, every time horizon from from real time, you know, this minute, the next hour, through to the medium term, through to the long term.
Claire Louise Young
In response to the chair in the initial questions, you said that NESO's role was effectively making sure the right incentives were there to enable the market to do its job, rather than NESO stepping in directly. Later, you said you don't think NESO can or should have all the levers, yet in answer to the last set of questions, you were suddenly pulling all the levers. Are you clear on where NESO has a direct role to intervene and when its role is to create the right environment? Because it appears, just looking at demand-side flexibility as an example, you know, you've got the enabling demand-side flexibility program where you're sort of doing a research role in identifying barriers to participation. You've got a policy development role, developing a plan to remove them.
It's not clear to me how that plan then, how your responsibility lies, where your responsibility lies for delivering that plan.
You've obviously got this operational, which is a very direct role. Is NESO's remit too complicated and too extensive?
Fintan Slye
I don't think so. I think that what we need to do though is to explain better what the roles and remits are and in particular the dividing line between us, government/DESNZ and Ofgem are. This was a theme that also came up in the Public Accounts Committee, which was where I was with DESNZ and Ofgem last week talking about their audit.
And it's something that we recognize that we need to do. I think internally we are clear on the levers that we have, but back to what I said at the start, we are also a relatively new organization that has been given a new set of roles and responsibilities. And I don't think yet that there is the shared understanding right across the industry about where the boundaries are, as evidenced by your question. And that is something we're talking to DESNZ and Ofgem about, getting a greater... publishing something with greater clarity that would help that.
Claire Louise Young
But you don't think that perhaps having a more focused role where it was... or if you had a situation where you split up operational day-to-day from the sort of looking to the future, the sort of more research policy development side of it?
Fintan Slye
So I don't actually. I think that one of the benefits of having say that long-term strategic planning in the same organization as the operational of the system means that in developing those long-term plans you can ensure that when the situation arises in the control room that you've factored in all of those things into those long-term plans in whatever the time horizon is is that you needed to do because in a lot of cases by the time it gets to the control room, you know, they're the the the set of things that they can do shrinks down as as you get closer to real time. And what you've got to make sure is the toolbox that you give them in the room on the day is sufficient to deal with anything that can happen on the system.
And that's what we're focused on. And therefore it's really important, I think, that in developing those long-term plans for the system, we factor in right from the offset the operability of the system, the constraints, how we think about what how it runs day ahead, week ahead, in the minute in the control room.
Claire Louise Young
So how do you ensure that you've achieved that? Because other than absence of it going wrong, absence of it going wrong just proves that the circumstances haven't arisen yet. It doesn't prove that you've got that right. So how do you have confidence, particularly given all the issues raised in the report, how do you have confidence that you have given them the right toolbox?
Fintan Slye
I mean, there's a number of mechanisms by which we sort of provide assurance. So one, we do this very publicly. So we publish an operability strategy report that sets out how we see the key challenges facing the system as it evolves and what we're doing to address them. That is publicly available and we run a set of industry engagements to talk through those and to get feedback on it. We work very closely with international system operators, in particular those who face similar challenges or whose systems are going through broadly similar transitions as we are.
And we share best practice, we share experience, we challenge each other on what is happening in there.
We also have an engineering advisory committee with external experts, academics, etc., and international system operators that provide a level of challenge and assurance over over what we're doing. So that's in terms of the plans. We also have, as we talked about earlier, the new operability committee in place, which ensures that those forward-looking concerns by the control room are fed into to this as well. So it's a multi-layered approach that we adopt to this because it is so important that we're thinking about these things right out into the future such that where we have the time to address them.
So an example would be as the level of inertia goes down on the system inherently with the closure of some of the fossil fuel stations, for example, the closure of coal off the system. We put in place a program many years ahead of time to go out and purchase effectively inertia as a service from the market and that required us to run a tender and people then had to build assets and deliver them onto the system. That's how we think about those things and think about them ahead of time.
Claire Louise Young
One final question then. You've described a really complex system with lots of different aspects to it. Do you personally have the capacity to keep on top of all these aspects?
Fintan Slye
I believe so.
So obviously the day-to-day challenges that the control room manage, they will manage as a team of 25 people in there as we speak, dealing with a set of really, really complex, interdependent challenges that they're dealing with on the day. But in terms of the long-term view of the system, I think, you know, I've a set of experiences working here, working in other system operators, in control rooms, and looking at sort of the long-term development of these things. And I think that through that and through, you know, the learning and engagement I get through working with brilliant people around the organization, that affords me the opportunity to do that.
Catherine Fookes
Yeah, I had a quick final couple of questions, please. I wanted to talk about the queue and the connections queue, and is Wales getting its fair share, if you like, of the connections queue? Butterfly Solar Plus Storage was canned, that project, which would have been a really fantastic project, was canned in April because of the queue, because they believed the queue would take too long for them to get connected.
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, so we worked really closely with government to set out what was needed where on the energy system for the initial round of connections and through the work, the long-term strategic planning that we're doing, that we're, so we talk about the spatial strategic energy plan, so the longer-term view of what's needed. That was co-commissioned by Welsh government, Scottish government, and UK government, and we've worked closely together on setting out what the system will need across the nations and regions.
I can't speak to that specific project, but certainly, you know, if you recall one of the problems with the queue, one of the reasons reform was needed in the first place was we had more than four times the number of projects in the queue than we actually need on the system to connect. And the process that we've been through has been to prioritize projects that are needed, i.e. strategically aligned, and that are ready to go. And that does mean that some projects have not got a connection offer in the current process. They'll come forward over time should there be space on the system to connect them.
Catherine Fookes
Presumably that queue is really holding back growth, and it's holding back growth from renewable energy. And you say need, but obviously there is a need. We want to replace our fossil fuels with renewable energy. So there is a need. There's a need for all these renewable energy projects.
Kayte O’Neill
It's just that there were four times as many in the queue as we needed. The size of the energy system today, a 50 gigawatt system, less than 50 gigawatt system with 800 gigawatts in the queue waiting to connect, just gives you a sense of we don't need all of the projects that are in the queue. So the process that we've worked with industry to develop over many years has given priority to one, the order in which they applied. So again, I can't speak to that individual project without going and checking on it. But if the project is needed, i.e. if that technology is needed in that area, if the project is ready to go, and then based on the order in which it's applied, those are the projects that have been prioritized.
Completely agree.
But through our ongoing strategic planning processes, we keep re-looking at what is needed where across nations and regions to make sure we do have what we need.
Catherine Fookes
And another question related to Wales, which is, I've recently seen that the Plaid Cymru government have put out a consultation about not using pylons and undergrounding a certain amount of the grid through Mid Wales. Will that slow down again our transition and slow down grid capacity considerably if they decide everything has to be undergrounded?
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, it's, I mean, it's not NESO's sort of specialist area for want of a better word, but it has been an ongoing debate over many years as to sort of the pros and cons of undergrounding versus overhead lines. There is a timing question, there is also a cost question and all of those play out in the decision making.
Bill Esterson
Do you have a figure for how much more expensive, how many times it is?
Kayte O’Neill
We could definitely provide it for you. NESO has done that analysis, I just can't remember in the moment, Chair, but we can share our analysis on that.
Bill Esterson
On the subject of connections, one of the concerns raised with us even after the reforms that you've carried out is that where storage is being added by developers, it's not being, it's being discounted, it's not being allowed to be added to the mix, which seems odd.
And I take your point about you trying to reduce the numbers and there's four times as much... as many applications as there is capacity. But do you understand why people are so frustrated by this? Because it's giving two opportunities at the same time in the same location often, and that's being turned down for developing the new capacity that is ultimately your objective.
Kayte O’Neill
Yeah, we absolutely understand the value of what we would describe as hybrid projects, so a project that puts solar and storage together has huge value to the system. And we are really keen that as we look ahead, we can extract the value of those types of projects.
The first phase of connections reform didn't allow for storage to laterally be added to an existing project, mainly from a fairness point of view, because there's already so much in the queue, if you were to change those projects in real time, that storage is effectively jumping ahead of other projects that are already there and waiting to connect. But as we, you know, we're deep now into implementing the first phase of connections reform, but we actually review the methodologies and the rules annually, and this question of hybrid projects is one that has been consulted on and is currently being thought about. So as we open new windows in future for new projects to come forward and join the queue, how can we make sure that we can extract the value of, of those hybrid type projects?
Bill Esterson
And similarly, as new technology emerges, as existing technology advances, that changes the calculation, whether it is storage or generating technologies.
Is are you going to change your methodology to to reflect this?
Kayte O’Neill
So we think it's really important that the that the rules and the processes stay agile to the changes that are going on sort of on the system and on the technology. That's why we're, you know, very strong supporters of having these annual reviews and we spend a lot of time with customers, with developers of these projects, with the trade bodies that support them, making sure that we understand, you know, how projects are evolving and changing, how do we think about those evolving technologies.
Bill Esterson
Yeah. And obviously there's a crossover with Ofgem with their responsibilities in in regulation and things like cap and floor with with with long duration storage. So you're in close contact there on on updating methodologies and I mean you make the point about fairness.
Is it fair to consumers to have to wait for increased generation of cheap electricity?
Kayte O’Neill
No, we absolutely want to get these projects connected. That was exactly why connections reform was such a, you know, it's been a really bold step for industry, but one that was absolutely needed. And we've worked really hard to advance and bring it forward. You know, we also recognize that as we get the generation connected, we need to build the network to move that power from where it's generated to where it's needed. Very interdependent challenges.
Bill Esterson
Thank you. I'll just finish with this point. You've set out in this session, we've been talking to you for two hours now, we've set out the scale and range of the challenges.
Talked about the grid queue, the speeds of connections, the balancing and constraint costs, the challenge of building the new network, the demand flex and the clean flex roadmap. That's a very, very wide and extensive list. And there are other responsibilities, what you're in the control room day-to-day, of course. Doesn't all of this set out just how critically it is that you engage with staff at all levels? That it's not a command and control culture.
That the expertise within the organisation, and this is true of many organisations, the expertise within the organisation will deliver the agenda that addresses all of those problems. And it's just not possible for you to do that centrally. Do you accept that? And do you take that point away from not just this session, but from the review findings?
Fintan Slye
So, absolutely, completely agree. I think, Chair, it's fair to say that NESO has brilliant people working for it who will rise to any challenge that they are set and solve it. And I completely agree with your point around making sure that we have the environment in place that allows them to do that.
Bill Esterson
Yeah. Okay. Well, we will invite you back soon for an update on how well you're doing against that pledge. Kayte O'Neill, Fintan Slye, thank you very much for your evidence. That's the end of our session.
Order, order.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.