International Development Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
International Development Committee Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsSarah Champion
Um, and Abadi, could I ask you to introduce yourself and your organization, please?
Abadi Kalayu
Thank you. Good afternoon. I am Abadi Kalayu, Executive Director, Family Guidance Association of Ethiopia. It is the oldest family planning organization in the country. We are about 60 years on business.
We have worked along with the government to reach people who are under hard to reach. We founded in 1966. We are accredited member of IPPF family since 1971. We work with a chain of 774 service points across the country, FGA clinics, public clinics, private clinics, as well as workplace clinics.
We work also in refugee, in IDP, in displaced people. We are a key partner to the Ministry of Health. We are part of the national system. Thank you.
Sarah Champion
Thank you all very much for joining us and thank you for the absolutely vital work that you do. I know it's a very tough, tough landscape to be working in at the moment. Jerop, if I could start with you and then I'll ask the other panelists. I wonder if you could tell us in recent years, what have you been witnessing in the field of work that you operate in and also if you could look at how you work with the government and has the government's approach to health changed in recent years?
Jerop Limo
Let me just start by saying that I've worked in the HIV space for 10 years now, started when I was still in high school. So I have kind of grown in the system, but also just being a young person living with HIV myself and having been in this journey for over 20 years, then I have actually interacted with the health system for a very long time. Let me start by saying we were at a point where we were saying things have progressed, science has evolved. Many years back when we were taking more than five pills as people living with HIV and now we're just taking one pill. So things have changed and there are so many successes.
And then we wake up one day and the first text I actually found on my phone that in that day after the funding cuts was, "The UK government has cut money and so we're going to die, all of us." That was the first text and it was from one young person who was panicking.
I work with young people. I am a leader of so many young people that really seek help and we support in our programs. And so I remember even thinking to myself, "What is this?" "What is going to happen?" People are looking up to us as an institution or organization to give support and guidance, but we are also in darkness.
I always say the HIV system was created parallel away from the primary healthcare system for a reason. It was because people living with HIV had very, I wouldn't call them special, but very distinct needs. We are diverse. We have young people. We have girls and young women.
We have men. We have queer people. We have key populations.
And so we had moved and evolved to a point where we had service providers who were patient, who were kind. For my community, young people, it was that clinician that had just become so familiar to you that you felt safe with them. And overnight all this is gone. So one aspect for me is that we had a proper functional system, not proper, it was a bit in between, of course it had its own challenges, but we had a system that we had gotten used to for so long and we were familiar with it. And overnight all these things has changed.
So what our Kenyan government did was to talk about the need for integration. Integration is now combining these two systems, so it becomes everyone goes through the primary healthcare system, which is good, but on paper integration cannot happen overnight.
It's a process. You're shifting people, you're shifting a system, you're changing healthcare providers, all the things that we were familiar to have gone. And so people are most likely to be confused, to retract from the health system in itself. And up to date I can confidently say that we are still dealing and trying to find people who were lost from the healthcare system during that transition. So now we are implementing the integrated system where all of us accessing care in one system.
It has its a lot of challenges and I use the word chaos.
I think our health system is chaotic as of now. We are yet to find our footing, majorly because a lot of money had been invested in this holistic healthcare system that was supposed to offer distinct services to different populations and serve us all equally. And overnight all that is gone and we are all expected to go through one service and system which is not the easiest thing. I think one thing the government did nice was to just react and try and figure out then how do we ensure there's continuation of services, how do we ensure that people are still accessing medicine. But in the same breath there are so many gaps and challenges just to mention but a few.
Sarah Champion
Thank you so much for sharing your personal experience of this as well. And I wonder when you got that first text message, was that the first that you knew about the cuts and do you think the government had any more advanced notice than that?
Jerop Limo
Yes, for me that was the first time actually. And I didn't understand what that meant because I was just going through emails and X and trying to figure out what does this actually mean.
I also think our government did not know. I have had the privilege of working with the government and in 2024 we sat in a committee put together by our cabinet secretary for health thinking about sustainability. And we'd sit in these rooms and I was representing civil society and young people. And we'd sit with government and members of parliament and we'd talk about sustaining our health system and the HIV response in general. But I don't think we all envisioned that it would happen that soon, neither did our government because from their reaction, no one was prepared for what happened.
Yeah.
Sarah Champion
And it sounds as though your government responded really well, but by pooling all the services together rather than having the ones for which were more tailored to distinct groups.
Does your government have the money to do the procurement and delivery, specifically when we look at HIV/AIDS?
Jerop Limo
So I think that's where now the problem comes in because there's what you can say on paper and instruct and give memos to healthcare providers and county officials, but the actualization of it requires a lot of resources. So I would say I don't think they had money. One aspect is heavy, a lot of funding for the HIV response was coming from PEPFAR and USAID programs and the Global Fund. And so our country was divided into two. We had some areas that were fully funded by USAID and some areas that were funded by Global Fund because they did not want to double deal in areas.
And so we had a whole part of our country that didn't have donors and support. And so we have one basket, the government has a quarter basket, and we're just trying to see how the money can be shared across. But I think for me, one aspect in Kenya is that health is devolved, meaning counties have the responsibility of putting money into health and making independent decisions. So we did see some counties actually quickly react and tell the healthcare providers, we know you don't have jobs, but please continue going to the hospital, we will figure out your salaries, continue offering services. And on this other end, as communities, as an organization, we positioned ourselves as the bridge to remind communities that the medicine is still there, the hospital is open, please make sure and access your service.
So I would say they didn't have the money, but we made, we made, we made it work. Yeah.
Sarah Champion
Goodness. Natasha, same question to you, what recent changes have you seen and how is your government responding to them?
Natasha Kaoma
Thank you so much for that question. First of all, I just want to give a background and a context based on my experiences. First of all, Copper Rose is an organization that we started 11 years ago and primarily we have focused on reproductive health and HIV programs up until about three years ago when we incorporated other aspects of development.
And from what we saw from the stop-work order and the reduction in funding, especially over the last two years, is we've been seeing we've lost scale and scale factors. So as community-based organizations, we move from reaching one community, two communities. For us, we were reaching more than 400 communities and more than 200,000 people every year with access to information and services, and now are down to 45,000. And this is not only us as Copper Rose, but we have seen it in many other institutions. There has been a reduction in the community-level support.
Just for context, about 84% of Zambia's program funding for HIV was coming from PEPFAR, and almost 80 to 90% of the SRH funding was coming from other funders, UK and other European funders.
So with the reduction in funding, what we are seeing on the ground is that while the facilities in the hospitals are continuing to work, like the hospitals are still there. Looking at the social and cultural barriers around reproductive health and HIV stigma, things like that, they need a lot of community interventions. So last year the government came up with a essential services package and the community interventions have been removed. They've also removed standalone sexual health centers that used to exist. There were about 32 wellness centers for HIV and Dreams centers in more than 21 districts that we were a part of and they no longer exist.
I did my masters at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. And one of the things I remember is that I could go to a sexual health clinic there and access services because in a clinic that is designed like that, there is no issue of stigma, discrimination.
I don't have to explain several times to a provider about why I need something. And we had a similar arrangement here with the different kind of wellness centers, dream centers, but we don't have those anymore. And so now everyone has to go to the main health facility which deals with TB, malaria. And as we know from even insurance data, in any community, only about 15% of people are comfortable enough to go to a hospital. So meaning that we are losing a lot of people, we are losing a lot of prevention opportunities and that has been a very big challenge.
Some of the other challenges we've seen is a loss of momentum in some of the work that we were doing.
As Copper Rose, we were in the last few years before the funding cuts, we were able to influence about seven policies in government. So we influenced the Family Planning 2030 commitments and we ensured that government had a specific commitment for adolescents' access to reproductive health services. And last year we were working on a gender strategy with the Ministry of Health because they did have a strategy, there is a national gender strategy, but it hasn't been brought into direct ministries like the Ministry of Health. So we were working on a USAID program for gender, and from the time this stop order happened, that gender strategy has just remained hanging. So that's a missed opportunity because there's no funder that is now willing to continue with that work.
We have a draft, it's there, but it's just not going to go on because there's just no support.
Lastly, what we've seen also is there's a loss of staff and a lot of people have lost their jobs following the funding cuts. UNAIDS estimated that about 16,000 people lost their jobs and only about 6,000 have managed to get jobs back. So what that means is that there's still many, many people that are not only unemployed but underemployed because with a lot of these programs, there's a high technical expertise that is required to interpret data, epidemiologists, statisticians, but a lot of those people are not working or they've just gone down to work a job that just earns them an income. So for me and where I'm standing, that's one of the biggest challenges I see.
However, what works and what has been working so far is for those organizations whose models are embedded into the government way of working, we've seen them continue. However, in the immediate sense, like in the first three months, what we saw, which was very, very scary on our end, and that has brought a lot of trust issues, is data management. Because a lot of data was sitting on USAID sites, some of the HMIS systems, health management information systems, and many systems were actually on US government servers. So as soon as the funding cut, a lot of those servers have been lost.
But also a lot of staff who sit in even in the government facilities, like M&E and data staff, have been lost and some of them haven't come back. So, what this has also brought is a lot of trust issues because while we want and we need to be self-sufficient as countries, we think that it was it's been very disturbing to be abruptly removed from the system because we think that good partnership is in effective communication. And so there's a lot of trust that has been lost, but I still think that there's a lot of opportunities going forward. But if I'm being very honest, that's where we are. The biggest hit has been the community.
And if I had to quantify the data, and there has been a research that has been released, a study was published in 2025 in the Open Forum Infectious Disease journal, and it was co-authored by Ministry of Health staff.
They estimated that in the first three months since the funding cuts, there were 32,000 new preventable deaths for the first three months interruption. And they said that if the disruption continued for a further four years, we should estimate 330,400 deaths. And these deaths are greater in children, because if you understand the reproductive health landscape, which is the HIV most importantly, there's 1.3 million people living with HIV in Zambia right now. Now, when you look at our UN targets, so the UN has set 95-95-95. It means 95% of people should know their status, 95% of people should be on treatment, and 95% of those on treatment should be virally suppressed.
As a country, we have achieved these targets, which goes to show that whatever these programs were, they were working. However, these targets haven't been met in children.
So from zero to 14, these targets have not been met. In children, we are at 82% of them know their status, 88% are on treatment, and 86% have suppression. So what this means is that we have missed an opportunity either in preventing mother-to-child transmission of HIV or in testing children who have already been delivered. And so when it comes to additional work that needs to be done, it will definitely have to be in children, and that's something that we shouldn't overlook. I'll just pause here.
I could talk all day, but I'll just pause here so that others...
Sarah Champion
Oh, we could listen all day because the information that you're giving to us is both shocking and gripping.
And I think it was particularly wicked of Dodge to wipe that data because it wasn't theirs to destroy. Abadi, I wonder if I could ask you the same question, sort of recent changes that you've seen in your field and how your government is responding to it.
Abadi Kalayu
Thank you. Regarding the current development in terms of the organizational overseas development assistance, we have been observing significant cuts on the overseas ODA assistance at national level.
Practically, it was sudden and impactful. For us, we lost 40% of our budget in 2021 due to GCRF cuts, due to the cuts. So for this cut, the people paying the price are women, young people, people living with HIV/AIDS. The cut accounts also reduction in human resource. In terms of personnel, we lost technical personnel about 162 personnels.
We have to be forced to withdraw from 366 public health facilities from the community, which are highly affected by the funding.
It has been while when we estimate the impact of those withdrawal about...
Sarah Champion
Abadi, I think we're going to have to come back to you because the line is not good. Can I pass over to Brian for the next set of questions, please?
Speaker 10
Thank you, and if I can start with you, Natasha. I've just actually come back from Zambia, but it was on a different mission. We've lost your picture, though. Are you back? Good, good.
So, Natasha, you've given us some idea of the impact of cuts to funding for health in the communities you serve, but perhaps you could elaborate a bit more, and also what concerns you have for the sustainability of the historic gains that you've seen.
Speaker 14
Oh, Abadi, we're going to come back to you in a moment, if that's okay. Natasha, over to you.
Natasha Kaoma
All right. So, I was saying that some of the impact we've seen, the long-term impact, definitely we have lots of statistics around that. You know, the sad part about health, negative health outcomes, is by the time you realize how many more deaths could be caused, then I honestly think it's too late.
So most of the data has to be done through modeling studies where we try and estimate what the impact of this would be. So the impact, for example, on HIV and access to reproductive health services is right now only an estimation. One of the things that really helped when it comes to the commodities side, because a lot of the commodities were being supplied by donor funding, has been forecasting. So for example, most of the drugs are procured eight to ten months in advance. And so from the time when we received funding cuts last year, we've only had to procure one more time.
So most of the impact we anticipate will be seen more clearly in the coming years.
One way that I think would be very effective and would create sustainability is ramping up of the private sector. As a serial entrepreneur, I must say that I also run a pharmaceutical business. And in my pharmaceutical business, I've been able to see that because there are not a lot of contraceptives in the health facilities, there are more women that are willing to buy and purchase contraceptives from the community. And what that means is that there is a market for private sector investment and engagement. And I think that is a long-term sustainability plan.
If you look at developed countries with a national health insurance scheme, while the national health insurance scheme guarantees free services for many of its citizens, it does receive a lot of bailouts from billionaires and government and generally wealthy people. But on this side, there's very few billionaires in Zambia, I must say. And so I think that, but people still have money. Even if someone is living on a dollar a day, they can spare five cents a day towards health or some kind of health plan. And we do see them spending money on many things for life and living.
So I think that ramping up the private sector or doing some private sector development work in health would be one of those investments that would bring about long-term sustainability. And I think that's one of those areas. Another area would be to see how best to improve the way government works. So we work a lot with community health workers and peer educators.
And one of the things that is very common is that there's a very high attrition rate of between 60 to 80% depending on the region. And with high attrition, it means that organizations like us are constantly training healthcare providers. Just last year, a medium-sized organization like Copper Rose trained more than 500 healthcare providers. You can imagine how many people larger organizations are training. More than 20,000 healthcare workers are trained every year.
So and these people need to constantly be trained.
So we believe that putting up a digital training platform or a digital training system, investing in something like that would be very effective at dealing with some of the costs of delivering healthcare to the last mile. There is a lot of training needs, supply chain and many different areas, and I think that an investment in more of long-term sustainability measures would be much more effective. Lastly, one of the things that really helped local organizations like us grow was the localization agenda, where a certain amount of resources was designated or was ensured that local organizations receive certain amount of funding. So you put a cap or a percentage to say at least this amount of funds should go to local organizations. Because local organizations will work whether there's funding, whether there's no funding, we'll continue working in our communities.
And so investing in local partners is one of those long-term sustainability measures. Because for me, even if I have no money to go to a meeting, I'll still receive the call, "Natasha, where are you?"
"You need to come and work on this document." Even today I received a call about a meeting that is probably 10 hours' drive from where I live. And I might still find myself there even if I'm no longer on an organizational salary. So investing in local leaders is one of those things that would definitely move the lever when it comes to sustainability. I hope that answers the question.
Speaker 10
Right. Abadi, perhaps would you be able to answer that same question? So it's what has been the impact of cuts to funding for health in the communities you serve, and what concerns do you have for the sustainability of the historic gains you have seen?
Abadi Kalayu
Sorry for the inconvenience. The network has been, you know, unstable. In terms of the current HIV/AIDS funding, the funding has been provided by USAID grant, almost 50%. Because of the cut funding, around 5,000 health workforce, their contract has been affected.
So the hidden cost in this regard is some clinics may stay open, but they have no commodities, they have no HIV drug outlets, and there is no outreach program, even there is no follow-up support as well. So this is just to give you an example in Gambella, where the HIV prevalence rate is very high, it accounts to 23%. Young teenage positive teenage, they are currently sharing their antiretroviral medication due to the shipment stoppage as well as stock out at that level.
In Amhara region, where a 14 years of years old survivor of sexual violence is now pregnant because the nearby clinics which she could access is out of run of contraceptives. So at the same time, the parents are forced to get her married for early marriage at the age of 14. As such, it becomes a denial of the opportunity to continue her education as well. So the effect on contraceptive is not only in terms of the access, but in terms of the future earning as well. So in terms of funding cut, including the UK, we were fortunate enough to have a funding support from UK government through WISH.
In WISH 1, we were implementing in 15 countries as global, so one of them are ours. In WISH 2, we are currently implementing in seven countries, so there is only a reduction of implementation area of 45%. In terms of the regions, we were operating in Oromia, Southern region and some better region areas, which accounts about 65%.
Now we have reduced to conflict-affected regions, which are highly protracted, which requires additional funding, but in terms of the proportion has been significantly reduced. We had in WISH1, we were operating 645 health facilities, including private health facility, public health facility and universities. Now we are only operating in 129 health facility, which is account only 20% of due to reduction. So in terms of the development, FGAE also witnessed the UK government investment works.
Ethiopia has made significant progress over the last 25 years, including the WISH program as well. It was a critical part of that success development. When we look into the national progress, contraceptive use rose from 8 to 35% of married women. Children deaths falls by two-thirds in terms of maternal mortality as well as child mortality rate. The WISH contribution has been significantly contributing.
Around 13.4 million pregnancies and 68,000 maternal deaths was averted due to this contribution from the WISH, thanks to the UK government.
The new WISH phase is focusing on the conflict-affecting region in Amhara, Tigray, and Oromia, as well as in Afar region. This shows that UK's reach the hard, the hardest place, and FGAE knows how to deliver on those, on those place because we are at the community level. We work with the government...
Sarah Champion
Abadi, I'm just going to pause you there so that we can ask some more questions, because it's amazing what your organization's doing, but I want to get into more of the detail around it, if I may. Tracy.
Speaker 16
Thank you.
I'm going to speak about the rollback on rights and I'd like to come to Jerop first of all, please. I know that you and Natasha have mentioned this already. I'd be interested in hearing a bit more. Could you tell us a bit about, have you experienced ideological or political resistance to your work and that of the groups that you work with? And probably more importantly, what can the UK government do to counter those rollbacks on human rights to help?
I'll start with you, Jerop, please.
Jerop Limo
Okay. So I'll start with just giving context. I think for the first time after the funding cuts, our president made a public remark about where he stood on issues of gender. And I remember the first thing he said is he recognizes that we only have male and female. And that statement alone, alone caused an uproar of confusion among rights of queer people, issues of reproductive health and rights.
And I remember people actually coming at organizations who were funded, who work in the HIV response, attacking us and saying we are the ones who are promoting all these things. So when a leader of a country makes such a statement, then it influences communities and people to just decide the direction of what should happen, what services should be accessed. And at that particular time, our organization and other organizations here in Kenya had taken the government to court over missing links in a reproductive health policy. It had omitted issues of rights. So we are no longer even allowed to just say the word rights.
We are no longer allowed to say freedom, expression. There was questions around all this conversation.
We had made a lot of progress in conversations around comprehensive sexuality education, and all of a sudden, we were not allowed to even mention that name in any space, in any conversation, and even in documents. And of course, we saw this start with the US government retracting and changing documents, and it poured down to what our government was allowing us to say. And after that statement, it was the way the government says things should be done and no other way. Our Minister of Health, you know, was saying integration is the way. There was no any other way.
It doesn't matter if it works for the people, if it works for communities, that was the way the government had dictated things to happen. And so we've seen government really questioning why should abortion be allowed in Kenya.
In context, Kenya, abortion in Kenya is legal, but only under certain circumstances. So we had organizations and who offer services that would offer safe abortion to women and girls, reproductive health rights, contraceptives, having to close down, Daises having to close down, and even them being attacked by communities because the government had given direction that these are not things we should be practicing as a country. So I would say yes, we have seen a lot of pushback on women's rights, confusion in terms of at what age should young people and young women access reproductive health services, what service can they receive and what service can they not receive. So I'd give an example. In the HIV policy, we say a young person who is at the age of 15 can walk into a clinic, they can get tested.
But in the reproductive health policy, it does not allow that. So you have two policies serving the same population but speaking different things.
So one of the things we were pushing for as civil society is the alignment of policies, guidelines and laws. But so we were completely shut out and hence why we chose to go to court. We did not win that case and that policy is going to be serving us for the next 10 years or so. It is sad and we actually went to the streets because of that. But then it goes to show you how confident our government became in terms of gender, cultural, African way of living and saying this is not what we practice as a country.
And so that means access to contraceptives, safe abortion, sitting in rooms and defending human rights, women's rights is no longer on the table. And even government officials do not allow it even in spaces where we are supposed to negotiate and converse and plan together jointly.
Thank you.
Natasha Kaoma
Thank you so much for that question. So there has been evidence of a rollback on sexual reproductive health and rights. Let me just start by the word sexual reproductive health and rights, I mean the phrase. It can no longer be used in any government setting. So they've removed the word rights and we can no longer say SRHR, we have to say SRH.
So every government document, every meeting, every setting that you are in, you can no longer add rights to SRH.
Sarah Champion
Natasha, could I pause you?
Either why do you think that is, or what was the explanation for why that change was made?
Speaker 21
Ah, that is a tough one. I'm trying to see whether I should give a factual reason or my own individual opinion.
Natasha Kaoma
I don't know the facts, let me be honest. I don't know the facts behind this. But as a spectator or someone that's in the second round, like not in the actual ring, but just someone external who doesn't work at the Ministry of Health, what I'm seeing is like if I'm going to pay for this, then I'm going to do it at my own choice. When someone else was supporting me, like supporting the government, when another entity was supporting the government, they could determine the terms. But now that I'm in charge, I'm going to determine the terms.
Natasha Kaoma
And we saw this rollback even with comprehensive sexuality education. So last year, there was a movement that came up that was a comprehensive sexuality education movement. They were against CSE in schools. So comprehensive sexuality education is training that is given to adolescents, preparing them for life. So it's a life skills program, which really embeds the sexual reproductive health aspect.
It talks about aspects of gender and many other things. Now, there was a religious movement that came up. So there has been anti-rights movements that have been growing.
But what made the CSE movement unsuccessful when it tried to remove CSE from schools sometime last year was the fact that CSE has been embedded in every single subject. So it's been embedded in every single subject. So even when a movement comes up, it means they have to fund a whole curriculum revision for them, and that's expensive. So as we roll out programs, I also learned that we need to think long-term and we need to think about what does a backlash look like and if resistance comes up. So that's what I saw.
The second, the third thing I've seen so far is the word gender in documents is not being taken up. So I'll give you an example that gender in some documents has been replaced with sex, gender-based violence has been replaced with violence against women and men, sexual gender-based violence has been replaced with sexual violence. And this is guidance that has been coming from the Department of State and what's left of US-funded programs. So a lot, that is affecting how people work. And lastly, I would say from a CSO perspective, we were doing a lot of, providing a lot of technical assistance to governments, but with the shrinking of the funding, a lot of CSOs are spending most of our energy on survival fundraising rather than true advocacy.
So our advocacy capacity has shrunk as a civil society sector in direct proportion to the funding crisis. So whereas we see a problem in one area, because we don't have access to funds, we're going to go where the funds are.
And I don't think that's an ideal way, and that's not something we as Copper Rose are doing, but a lot of organizations... I was just looking at, for example, FCDO funding in Zambia, and three quarters of the funding is going towards social cash transfer programs, agriculture, climate resilience. So half of the organizations I know are now doing climate work, even though they started off as health organizations. And for me, I feel like we're losing a lot of the health advocates because they are doing what we call survival fundraising instead of advocacy. And also that means we've lost a lot of the technical expertise to the other sectors outside health.
Abadi Kalayu
Thank you. Yes. We are observing the rollback effect on rights, especially we are seeing foreign actors using funding and influence to shape the Ethiopian health system and in terms of policy. We have been observing some changes in terms of the framing, in terms of the MOU, what the America First Health Strategy, one of which Ethiopia has signed.
This has been also seen across the region in terms of the right in Kenya, Uganda, Ghana, as well as there is a new draft which is presented to the African Charter in terms of the value, family values. These are a coordinated effort to make the rollback, you know, more effective. Ethiopia has signed the MOU till now, we are not yet, we don't know the details, the full conditions, and the lack of transparency which worries us much in terms of this effect.
I can say, but in terms of the organized actors, they are targeting parliamentarians, especially individual parliamentarians, individual government officials to make policy change. At the same time, they are targeting using health professionals, including gynae and obs specialists, religious leaders to influence their cause. So they are also engaging in disinformation and misinformation as well, targeting service providers. Even our service provider has been targeted because by availing a service for safe abortion care service in our facilities as well. So it is a very worrisome to look into.
David Mundell
Um, thank you. Natasha, can I ask you first, do you see if there are any opportunities at all from this this new situation with the reduction in outside aid? Do you think there's anything positive that can come from it?
Natasha Kaoma
One of the first positives I would say is that as um, organization, I mean, countries in the global south, we do have a lot of work that was done on policy development and good both economic and social policies.
So there are, we have a strong policy background on which different programs can be layered. Something I didn't mention just before I answer this question, something I didn't mention earlier is that when you look at the way the different country governments were operating, I don't know about Jerop in Kenya, but in Zambia, you would find that if the UK government is working in these provinces, the EU or other governments will be working in other provinces and the US government will be working in these provinces. So there was a, there was a geographic allocation and another thing that was there was also the programs were layered on top of the other.
So for example, if the HIV program was the one that was carrying the digital health information system, whenever there was a family planning program or a different program, it would not need to create a new government system. So a lot of those systems are still existing and that is something that I think means that we don't need as much resources as we did when those systems were being developed. So one of the opportunities is to rely on the systems that were already built. The second thing I see is private sector and blended finance is something that's very, very important. I have seen FCDO working with private sector in different sectors outside health.
I have seen FCDO and working with private sector in different sectors outside health, and I think that that opportunity could also be opened to the health space, because I honestly think that there is some room to fill parts of the gaps with the private sector investment. And one of the opportunities also is when it comes to things, for example, like abortion, Zambia does have good, I think almost identical to the UK law around access to abortion services. However, many of the gaps are in training and development. So what, for example, if resources are reducing, some of the high-reward, low-effort opportunities are to focus a lot on the workforce and the health and information systems.
And so when the UK, the US government came back with, I think Abadi mentioned them, the MOUs, a lot of them are leaning on the workforce and they're leaning on data. And a lot of stakeholders were looking at it from a sovereignty point of view. And I totally agree with that, a nation should have access to its own data. However, I think that the lack of data is one of the things that affects, for example, planning, budgeting. So one way or an opportunity from here would be looking into digitization, data systems, because there's still a lot, definitely a lot of opportunities there.
So while funding decisions seem like a catastrophe, I feel like they're an opportunity to rebuild things in a different way and they're an opportunity to make changes to what is known as business as usual. So I think there are a lot of opportunities in how this can be rectified.
Charles Noah Law
Thank you, Natasha. And earlier Jerop mentioned the need to, you know, reduce costs and find ways to be innovative in today's environment. But specifically on bringing in a bit more innovation and kind of private partnership, how would you like to see FCDO engage in that and supporting you to find the right partners to help you deliver some of the things you've described, whether it's on data, perhaps, you know, AI-type interventions, and making sure, as I think was alluded to earlier, that you, that you're doing local sourcing in all of that where you can?
Natasha Kaoma
All right. I would say that investments in health would start from first of all, investments in data, and because one, one of the ways to understand, for example, how much investment needs to go into a certain sector, in certain areas, and even the gaps, I'd start with investing in data to understand the landscape.
I know there are so many like hackathons or entrepreneur-driven activities, but I am very sure that there are already lots of tried and tested businesses that are functioning in Zambia who would need either direct funding, similar to how grant funding would come, but with more of like better conditions because it's feeding into something that has the ability to regenerate. And so, you know, when we write proposals we're always talking about sustainability and it sounds good on paper, but more often than not we are looking for the next funding after that funding has come through. And in this case I would say weight-bearing some of the heaviest parts about running a healthcare business would definitely go a long way in sustaining it long-term. And so if I have to be honest I would say the two pain points for most health businesses right now is data and access to data, and AI is one of those things that we could leverage, but with AI also comes with things like data protection.
I know Europe has very strong data protection policies and we just don't have the similar ones here. So as we encourage use of different systems, some of this financial support could go towards strengthening our data protection laws, strengthening our data protection systems, especially for health services data. Yeah, I would say that.
David Mundell
Yes, Natasha, the second question for you is what can the Zambian government do or what should they do to adjust to this situation, or what are they doing to adjust to it?
Natasha Kaoma
So they just appointed a new health minister and we just got a new, we haven't even got a full cabinet yet, in case you're not aware. We had our election in August this year and so our cabinet is not yet fully formed.
But if I could be the health minister for a day, I would introduce fees into our health system, minimal fees, but they would definitely be a step in the right direction as far as sustainability is concerned, because I see even people who can afford going to access healthcare for free.
And I honestly think that that reduces the amount of commodities that are available for those people who genuinely cannot afford it. Right now, the Zambian government even pays for people to be evacuated to other countries to receive treatment. And most of the times, rich people are the ones that get that kind of healthcare support. So the first thing I would do if I was a minister for a day is introduce service fees, because they would generate some income. I would also restructure the National Health Insurance system, because the National Health Insurance system could be doing a lot more.
I mean, the insurance was a good start, but I think we could do a lot more in making it more functional and better able to support our citizens. Those are the two things I would do if I was a minister for a day.
David Mundell
Excellent. Thank you for that very clear answer. Jerop, can I come to you and basically ask you the same questions?
I mean, what opportunities or positives, if any, can you see from the impact of the reduction of aid and what's happening in Kenya with the government to adjust or otherwise to this situation?
Jerop Limo
So, I think one good thing is that our government woke up. Genuinely, if you ask me, I think there was so much over-reliance of donor funding, of development funding, which really helped us, honestly. But it had gotten to a point where, you know, there's zero prioritization to reproductive health and HIV because they know a civil society somewhere will support that meeting, will support that dialogue, will train that healthcare provider.
And so even governments were not allocating resources to health, and even if they did, it didn't end up actually being used for health. So for me, I think it was a wake-up call that this money is here today, tomorrow it might not be there. So as a government, we actually need to do something about it and make sure we put money into healthcare and ensure that that is actualized at the end of the day. So for me, I think that's the biggest opportunity, but also integration. It is a beautiful system on paper, honestly.
And even prior to the funding cuts, one of the things we kept on pushing for as civil society was we want a young person to walk into one room in a facility and access all the services under that one roof. So that then it's a one-stop shop. They don't have to be sent to the other side of the hospital to get contraception and then to the other side for lab results.
You kind of end up losing the client in between the referrals and linkages. So already designing and thinking about a one-stop center that offers all the services for this individual was something we had in mind. And integration really looks good on paper, but the one essential aspect is it takes time and the time is with the people. So you have a system that looks really nice on paper, but it really doesn't serve the people as it should be. So one of the most essential thing is integration provides an opportunity for people to interact less with the clinic.
So I just enter a room, I get my services and I go home, quote-unquote no special services. It's not necessarily special, but that's how we look at it. And so people can access services at the same time, but there are still limitations.
So for example, someone has TB, they are seated in a waiting bay with over 50 clients. All those people are at risk of contracting TB if that structure of the facility is not well ventilated, it doesn't have enough windows, there are no masks. So there are so many gaps even though this integration system really looks good on paper. So for me, those are the two positive things. When I think about what our government needs to do, there are a lot.
I am a Gen Z, we've had a problem with our government, so my list is endless, but I'll stick to just two. One, I think is when we deal, when we're saying you want people to utilize a system, the first essential aspect is people to trust that system. If they can't trust it, they will question it.
It doesn't matter if one person had the best services, it takes one person to have a bad experience and then that is all of a sudden everyone's approach and thoughts. And so we have our national health insurance, it's now called our social health insurance, that is really good because then depending on the level of earning or job that one does, there's a certain amount that is cut. So if you're really earning little, then you're going to be charged little, but at the same time you're going to be able to access care. But then at the end of the day, the question is, even if you tax people and they walk into a clinic and there's no medicine, there's no test tubes, the pharmacist is not there, the watchman was rude, the latrines are unusable, at the end of the day people question, then why do you deduct this money or tax for health and give me bare minimum in terms of health?
So I think for me, it's really actualizing what is on paper and making it a reality, so in terms of our systems and our social health insurance. But number two is really investing and strengthening communities and civil society. Our role is very distinct. I say every single time, you can give me a bottle of medicine, but it takes a peer educator who understands how scary it is to live with HIV and be a queer person at the same time and be a young person at the same time to actually understand and give me the support that I need to remain adherent to my treatment.
And so you have a facility on this side, it has medicine, but you have a community person who is in dire need of this medicine, but they just can't leave their house to get to the facility. But that peer educator, the organization called Copper Rose, the mentor mother is what will support, will be the bridge and ensure that that community gets to the hospital. So for me, it's really those two things.
David Mundell
Okay. And Abadi, what do you think if there are any positives or opportunities that's come from the new funding situation and how are the Ethiopian government responding or should respond? Thank you.
Abadi Kalayu
Thank you. Yes, there are positive areas which we have observed.
One thing is the way of thinking in terms of the entire spectrum. Currently, the health system has been supported significantly around 40-40 plus percent by foreign aid. So the reduction of the funding is very critical. Basically, they were assigning, the ministry has been assigning a budget about 30 percent, the other 30 percent is from individual pocket.
So from after the incident of this instant cut, the first thing the government do is, you know, to look into the funding portfolio. So they make at least some commitment as to fill in, especially to allocate to the SRHR from 7 percent to 9 percent in terms of the real outcome. But in terms of the gravity and the gap we have, still it is a long way to go as such. So the country ownership initiative has been, you know, revitalized, which is good. Second, the government and in every sectors, they're promoting domestic resource mobilization.
So how we can avail resource from local element has been done.
The Ministry of Finance, they introduced some taxation in terms of, you know, to mitigate the emergency response program at national level. So every payment in any transaction, there is at least 1% to finance those emergency response programs as well. So the government are taking seriously, which is good. Second, they gave space for partnership, meaning the private sector has been pulling to the front to take part on investing in some local manufacture in partnership with other development partners. This is a new initiative which has been introduced in industry parks, special economic zones and so on.
The third is in terms of the space which is given to local civil society organization. Civil society organization has been mandated to generate their own local income so as to bridge their own funding. With that respect, we were fortunate enough to look into our system as well to make specific adjustment in terms of our way of doing business to generate certain amount of money so as we could finance for those who cannot pay. This is a cross-subsidizing framework. So from policy perspective, they have been looking into the domestic resource mobilization.
Previously we were not having a policy on domestic resource mobilization. Now they have done. We were part and parcel of the Ministry of Health's new strategic plan from strategic 2026 to 2030. The adolescent and youth health strategy as well as reproductive health strategy has been jointly designed. Previously they were doing at government level.
Now the civil society and other actors has been involved. We make sure the SRH agenda has been there as part of the commitment.
But in terms of the stage, it is a gradual move to make country ownership at national level. So working with the government has been very supportive, which we have to do. We have to support the health system, which is on board, so as the health system generates and purposefully financed by Finance Ministry as well as by allocating specific amount of money to run the business.
So the good thing is they are positive in terms of they make even some commitment at global level, but in practice we are looking into tracking how they could be implemented on such area. So I think in terms of the government there is a need of shift of allocating resources. In terms of the civil society...
Sarah Champion
Abadi, just because of time we're going to have to stop there, but you've ended on a good note that the government is looking to make those changes. We would actually write to you if that's okay about civil society and panelists as a few other questions we'd like to follow up. Thank you so much for your time. You've given us loads of information at the start of our inquiry. It's good to hear some potential positives, but let me personally say I'm very sorry for the cuts that came from the UK and like you we were all really, really shocked and surprised at the cuts that came from USAID, both the severity of them and how swiftly they were delivered.
But thank you for still going. Thank you for what you do every day and please do relay our gratitude to your teams as well. Order, order, we're now going to suspend the session and if I could ask the second panel to join us.
Order, we are now starting our second panel on the International Development Committee's inquiry into global health. Thank you very much everybody for joining us. Dr. Kennedy, thank you for joining us remotely, we appreciate it. If I could start by asking the people in the room to introduce themselves and their organization. Dr. Jeanne, if I could start with you please.
Jeanne Salje
Thank you very much and thank you for giving me the chance to be here to speak today. My name is Dr. Jeanne Salje. I'm an academic research scientist at the University of Cambridge. My personal research is on bacterial neglected diseases, called scrub typhus in particular.
And we work both on the fundamental mechanisms of how this bacteria infects humans and causes disease, but we also work on more applied work. So at the moment, we're very actively engaged on trying to develop a new diagnostic test that would help us better diagnose and detect this disease. So both fundamental research and some more applied work. I have lived and worked and run research labs for extended periods of time in Thailand and also in the USA, and I relocated to Cambridge University four years ago. And the evidence that we submitted was as part of a consortium, so three other academics at the University of Cambridge and my colleague Professor Bhavesh Kana in South Africa.
And so I'll try to the best of my ability to share both my own experiences and also experiences that have been shared with my colleagues.
And so what I'm hoping to be able to share is our perspectives on infectious disease research and research partnerships and how the cuts have affected that.
Sarah Champion
Thank you, and your colleagues are more than welcome if they want to follow up in writing as well. Dr. de Polnay, over to you.
Kirrily de Polnay
Again, thank you very much for inviting me to represent MSF today. My name is Kirrily, I am a medical doctor trained down the road at Guy's and St Thomas'. I started work with Médecins Sans Frontières in 2011, worked with them for 10 years. I also did work for WHO and UNICEF. My specialty is pediatric malnutrition and maternal malnutrition.
Speaker 34
As most of you will know, MSF is an independent international medical humanitarian organization. We provide care to people affected by conflict, outbreaks, and others excluded from healthcare in over 70 countries.
For over 50 years, we've been working in some of the world's most fragile and insecure contexts, and we deliver assistance based solely on need.
Sarah Champion
Thank you. Monica, you and I know each other from the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Global and Sexual Health Rights, which the UNFPA supports, but I wonder for our audience and committee members if you could introduce yourself and your work, please.
Monica Ferro
Thank you so much. So, my name is Monica Ferro. I'm the head of the United Nations Population Fund office here in London. And as you probably know, the United Nations Population Fund is the UN leading agency on population data and on sexual reproductive health and rights. We work to uphold the rights and choices of women, girls, young people, and all population groups in situation of vulnerability in more in about 150 countries and territories.
We do provide essential health services, protection from violence, and vital information about sexual and reproductive health and rights. We partner with governments and with civil society to provide and to shape evidence-based policies, strengthen health systems, prevent gender-based violence and harmful practices. And we also use demographic intelligence to inform policies, anticipating population change and therefore building systems that are resilient in a very brief way.
Kennedy Uadiale
Thank you very much. My name is Dr. Kennedy Uadiale.
I'm a medical doctor by background and a researcher at the Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine. I am based here in Blantyre, Malawi, where I'm hosted under the Malawi-Liverpool-Wellcome Research Programme. And basically running a research that is NIHR-funded here, the Opt-AMR project. Opt-AMR is Optimising Antibiotics Usage to Mitigate Antimicrobial Resistance. So I'm a health system researcher with focus on antimicrobial resistance.
And we're doing this across four countries of Malawi, Uganda, Zambia, and the UK. A big consortium that includes the Centre for Infectious Disease Research in Zambia, Doctors with Africa CUAMM in Uganda, as well as Makerere University in Uganda. And here in Malawi, it's Malawi-Liverpool-Wellcome Research Programme.
Our focus basically as a consortium is looking at how we could develop rapid approaches to address antimicrobial resistance surveillance, but also using the same approach to monitor quality of care at primary healthcare level because of its linkage to antimicrobial resistance. So we're not just researchers, but we're also looking at theory and using our partnership, leveraging on that with strong collaboration with the Ministry of Health to really facilitate the utilization of the outputs of our research, thereby enhancing our health system strengthening agenda. So I'll stop there.
Thank you very much.
Sam Rushworth
Thanks. It's just to you, Monica, firstly, just if you could talk to us a little bit more about what your organization does and its relationship with UK funding.
Monica Ferro
My pleasure. And also please stop me. So we are, as I was saying, we are the lead agency on sexual reproductive health and rights, which means that we work to deliver a world where you can actually meet zero preventable mortality. So we work, it's not only a health issue, it's also a human rights issue. So we work to remove all obstacles between women and an access to healthcare services, to information.
We work, the other big outcome of our strategic plan is securing universal access to family planning. Then we have another big goal where we commit to ending gender-based violence, where we include harmful practices such as child marriage and female genital mutilation. We co-lead with UNICEF the two global programs to end these harmful practices. And we've also decided to highlight again our work on demographic intelligence, providing countries with information so they can build resilient projects when it comes to social welfare, when it comes to health. Because what we've seen in the last couple of years, it's different but still a lot of resemblance with what we had when UNFPA was created in the end of the 60s, which is a lot of demographic anxiety.
In the 60s, the demographic anxiety was towards an exploding population and now the anxiety has very much to do with low fertility and this has to do with so much of the issues we heard on the first session, how rights are being challenged because there's a lot of anxiety mostly in low fertility countries, but we can go back to that if you feel it's important.
Challenged by who?
Monica Ferro
So we see a lot of narratives and this is really a big change in the last couple of years.
A big change in the last couple of years in countries with low fertility, with aging populations, we see a lot of pressure on either taking out of the curricula comprehensive sexuality education, even reducing access to family planning, allowing certain discriminatory narratives on gender, in a way appealing that women should go home and reproduce and deliver babies, which is a very good option, we have nothing against it, of course, voluntary, but it's becoming, we heard also about misinformation, this has become a big topic when we talk about rolling back on rights. So it has to do with what the colleagues shared in the first panel, but it also has to do with this issue from our experience in analyzing what's happening in many, many countries because as Honorable Sarah Champion mentioned, we do work with a lot of parliamentary networks because we do see the value of mobilizing support when it comes to our agenda.
But to your question with the UK, so the UK is our largest donor. In 2025, we mobilized, the UK invested in UNFPA a grand record of over, a bit over 200 million dollars. And which is very encouraging because the UK is also my second largest donor for humanitarian programs. We know that one of the biggest investments of the UK in UNFPA is the supplies partnership. It's the program that we use to deliver reproductive health commodities and maternal health commodities to 54 low-income countries.
Monica Ferro
We mean medicines, products, equipment.
And it's and the investment the UK has done in this in our supplies partnership has helped to establish our supplies partnership as a flagship global health initiative. It's in this the current moment the largest public sector provider of contraceptives, just to give you an example. And and we know the power of family planning when it comes to reducing maternal mortality and empowering women, allowing women to decide over their bodies and their fertility. So it has a rippling effect that's very, very positive. And I know the UK is very focused on impact and efficiency of the of the investment.
Sam Rushworth
When when this committee was in Washington and we met with the the remnants of USAID in the State Department and the Dodge team that's been put in charge of them, they were talking about how they they're still funding drugs for HIV but quote, we've got rid of the woke stuff. What I'm what I'm understanding is that maybe that woke stuff is actually quite important if if what that woke stuff is is is preventing unwanted pregnancy or educating people about and that's the area that you're essentially working in and you're seeing evidence on the ground of that improving health outcomes.
Monica Ferro
One of the biggest outcomes that we have from the investment on family planning, it's really the reduction of maternal mortality and it's been absolutely extraordinary. We reduced 40% of maternal mortality in the last 30 years, which is something that we should celebrate.
Sam Rushworth
What's done that? What what's led to such a reduction in maternal mortality rates?
Monica Ferro
Mostly investment in healthcare facilities and assisted skill birth. The huge investment in midwifery. Because we do know why women die in childbirth. It's not biology, it's not fate. It's there's three big causes and we know how to treat them because the data shows us that around 90% of all maternal mortality happens in low and middle income countries, half of maternal of all the maternal mortality happens in humanitarian settings.
So we do know what works and we know how to reduce maternal mortality, but it requires investment and it requires something that that we need to to be very clear. It requires sustained investment. It's one of the first areas, once you've reduced the funding, it's one of the areas where you see immediately the impact, because you may still have a clinic, but there's no doctors in it. You may still have a hospital, but maybe there's no medicines, there's no skilled birth. You know, the clinic is there, the lights are on, but there's no services for women.
And this has a tremendous impact on on women and girls and on this goal that we like, that we are so proud of as as a community to say we've reduced maternal mortality in in 30%, which is true.
Sam Rushworth
One more question. Is FGM a part of your work and a part of reducing...?
Monica Ferro
Yes, yes, yes, yes. We co-lead with UNICEF the global program to end FGM.
And on that, we also have good news. The rates are really lower, but still, we know there are millions of girls and women at risk if because the funding is also being reduced. So if we cannot sustain the programs, we know a lot of countries have made tremendous advancements on law. But law alone is not enough. We also need budgets to implement the programs.
We need to monitor the success of the projects. So we do need investment. And we need investment that's sustainable because otherwise the continuation of the projects is at risk. And once you've interrupted a program, we see the setback. And also, if I just may add, the crisis and climate change are exposing a wider number of women and girls to FGM because some of them are being married off earlier because their parents maybe believe they are better protected if they are handed to someone who can actually feed them, take care of them.
And in many scenarios, we know that comes with FGM. So it's, it's sometimes one of the cases that it's not at first sight. So and we make the point of connecting the dots to show how even climate change and conflicts are affecting child marriage and, and female genital mutilation.
Speaker 45
Thank you, Chair. Just sort of continuation from this discussion really about the implications of aid cuts, but I wondered if I could turn to you first, Jeanne, and ask your perspective.
Jeanne Salje
Yep, so this is obviously quite a different perspective from what we've been hearing about so far. I think the the headline would be that the sort of rapid and unexpected cuts that we heard about earlier overnight in the context of infectious disease research meant that research programs, diagnostic labs, as we were talking about, you know, labs that have the lights, have the buildings, have the equipment, but now no longer have the funding to do those things that they were trained and established to do, are no longer able to do that from sort of from one day to the next. And that has led to and and will lead to, sort of in scientific terms, two things. And one is an increase in the spread of antimicrobial resistance because that important work in controlling those pathogens is no longer able to go ahead. And a reduction in our ability to detect and identify outbreaks early on and control them before they get out of control.
So, sort of as an example to illustrate that first point, so I happened to be in South Africa in February 2025 at a conference of microbiologists from all over the world. And my colleague Bhavesh Kana, who contributed, was there.
And I remember a conversation with him. So he is a research academic scientist based in South Africa, but he runs over 40, or ran over 40 clinical trials on TB, over 30 clinical trials on TB across South Africa. And he told me that, you know, they'd got the announcement that their NIH-funded grants would stop. So from one day to the next, those patients who were enrolled in those trials could no longer be treated. And so of course these were research trials looking at sort of whether the disease is transmitted in households and so on.
So they were studying research questions, but in fact what they were doing was delivering healthcare. And TB is very difficult to treat. We have a limited number of drugs available and you need to take a cocktail of drugs every day. And so what he told me was that from one day to the next, these cohorts, these communities that they'd established trust, worked with over long periods of time, they had the medicines in their freezers but they could not administer them.
So these people had to go and look for treatment elsewhere. So what are the consequences of that? Of course, for the individual treatment, that's catastrophic. Their TB is no longer controlled. In theory, they can seek treatment elsewhere.
In reality, that's not always available. So you'd have, you know, people sort of, you know, looking around trying to find desperately treatment where they can. TB, you really have to be careful about using the right treatment. So these individual patients, their disease is no longer controlled. Some of them, the disease would have escalated and got much worse.
There would also be increased onward transmission, so there'd be greater spread in the community because their disease is no longer controlled. And over the longer term, we know that if you don't carefully control bacterial, your treatment regimen with antibiotics, those bacteria evolve to be resistant to those drugs.
We're really limited to the number of drugs that we have available for TB. And so following up with Babesh six months, 12 months later, he tells me anecdotally he starts to hear more and more cases of doctors, or when he's able to scramble together some money or come back to his cohorts of patients six months, 12 months later, who had TB strains that at that time could be controlled by the available antibiotics and now are resistant to two, three, sometimes all the available treatments. So already anecdotally you're starting to see, and this is being replicated across the world, so not just in South Africa, in all those places where the research, sort of research for TB was actually doing healthcare as well, and so we'll see this emergence of AMR. And then a point I would make about the, so in reality a lot of the clinics and centers that we use for antimicrobial resistance detection and diagnostics that the UK funded, so through the Fleming Fund, I don't know if you're aware, that's, so this was a big ODA funded...
Yeah, okay, so you've heard. So that was a huge investment and that was fantastic, nearly 300 laboratories in 20 countries. So this is a big investment the UK has made, but of course now that it's unclear what will happen to that next.
Speaker 47
So can I just clarify, so up until this point you've been primarily talking about the USAID cuts, is that correct? Or are you now talking about specifically...
Jeanne Salje
So yes, so I was talking primarily there about the USAID cuts, but here I'm now talking about specific, because I want to talk a little bit and pivot and talk a bit about diagnostics and the importance of diagnostics. And an example I want to give, which I don't know if it's linked to USAID or ODA, but the recent Ebola outbreak, you may be aware, but it's been reported that one of the reasons why there was a significant delay was that the initial diagnostics were done using a test for a different species. And I don't know the reason for that, probably it's because that was the test that was available in the lab at that time.
And so that patient tested negative and it was only two and a half weeks later when the sequencing data became available that it was confirmed as an Ebola case. Now that means there was a two and a half week delay before it was recognized that there was an outbreak. And I think Dr. Kennedy can probably speak a lot more to that, to that particular case. So I'm not saying that that's directly linked, but I'm giving that as an example of the importance of having these really robust networks where the diagnostics are good, the diagnostics are funded, and we're not just, you know, buying a PCR machine and dumping it somewhere and then walking away. But we're actually investing in the reagents that we need, in the people, training the people and making sure that there's that continuity and that the laboratories are well connected locally and regionally.
And so because in reality that's how outbreaks are detected, that there's an unusual cluster of cases and someone phones their colleagues that they've got long-term relationships with, that they've got these partnerships.
And so, because in reality that's how outbreaks are detected, that there's an unusual cluster of cases and someone phones their colleagues that they've got long-term relationships with, that they've got these partnerships, and they say, "Hey, I've got these cases, have you got these cases?" and then you start to do an investigation. And so the sort of reduction of investment in that risks leading to a loss of our ability to detect outbreaks early.
Sarah Champion
When the committee last visited WHO, we were told that because of the US pulling out, it was leaving to big gaps in data sharing and therefore knowledge. So is that something that you've experienced?
Jeanne Salje
So that's a little bit outside my expertise, so I don't know, but I wouldn't be at all surprised and I could certainly comment that the consequences of that would be exactly what I'm saying, that if if those data sharing networks are disrupted, that's what you would expect to see.
Monica Harding
At thank you. Um, can I come to you, Kirrily? Um, could you uh tell us how the UK government ODA policy could best adjust to the new reality of less global funding?
Kirrily de Polnay
Big question. I think from from so I I really can speak from MSF's perspective and to be honest, we listening to the first session, listening to my colleagues here, we as MSF end up seeing the sort of final results of so much we've talked about today.
So when there's been a lack of funding in that primary healthcare, in the family planning clinic, in those labs, so many of those people end up on our doorstep as MSF, when we are still open, our lights are still on, we still do have supplies. And so so often now we are really seeing that those opportunities for simpler, cheaper, earlier health interventions has been missed already. So we're sort of ending up and we're collecting data and seeing how much our increases in admissions for children with malnutrition, for women with complications. So we're really seeing really the final results of all of this. And it's a health ecosystem.
We all, we'd love a world where we didn't need an MSF, but we still do. And we know that we have different organizations who partner with local organizations, different who partner with government. As MSF we don't take any funding from governments, which does keep us more independent, but it doesn't mean that we're not part of that system.
So we do start to see when other services are suffering, we're trying to scale up, but we can't fill all of those gaps. So for us in terms of what we're going to come back and ask the UK government for, we're not naive and, you know, we know that it's not just the UK government funding cuts we've seen, it's a very complex funding landscape. But I mean, my, my specialty is nutrition. And so sort of my comfort zone to talk about that. And from my perspective, the UK government, FCDO has been an incredibly strong intellectual leader in nutrition from the first Nutrition for Growth summit, the work that you all do in the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Nutrition.
It's been so important. We've appreciated again, every part's needed, the investment that FCDO's made into prevention of malnutrition, the research, the services.
And so I think we are really asking sort of two things: please protect the funding, the existing funding. Please try, we would love to see a roadmap back to 0.7%, but really protect that existing funding. We can't see further breakdowns in these services which lead these people really falling at our door. But also to be, you know, you're known as a very reliable and responsible donor when it comes to nutrition. And so we ask to keep that, keep that role and to sort of to keep standing up for those rights of people.
So that's kind of what we are coming to you with.
We also understand that a lot of the strategy is to invest in multilaterals, and that's, you know, that's been that decision. But I think again with the evidence we had earlier about the importance of those local partners, but also that we really do ask that again that accountability for those multilaterals is maintained from the UK government and asking the right questions, looking at the data, following where the money's going is also important.
Monica Harding
Just on that last point, can you just expand a little bit? What do you mean? Have you got any examples of that?
Kirrily de Polnay
So, I mean, I've also worked in other UN agencies. So, it's what it means. It's so that we know when we're writing our donor reports, when we're reporting back to you, we really ask you to have the systems in place that would really allow an interrogation of the data, the explanations you're given, to really make sure that it's getting to exactly the people who are in need, that the action is being based on need rather than any other kind of agendas that may be existing.
Monica Harding
And then just on your the first point you made, that when things come to you they're more complex and therefore I'm guessing more expensive and that there are cheaper solutions upstream. Have you just got a live example of that that would bring that home? In terms of an example of where it's been taken away, support or aid has been taken away or aid spent.
Kirrily de Polnay
Yeah. So, I mean, again, for us, you know, as you a lot of you know, malnutrition often isn't just about hunger. So often it's about this interplay of hunger and disease. And so if you have a child who's had multiple episodes of diarrhoea, hasn't been able to access care for that, which could have been simple rehydration solution, some monitoring, that child can end up in our services really sick, really dehydrated, with malnutrition, and those children are really complex to manage. I manage them myself, they keep you up all night, there you have to use completely different protocols for the malnourished than you do for the non-malnourished.
It's, they're very, really, really complex cases. And also if that child just hasn't been vaccinated, there are so many places now that we're seeing measles outbreaks, you know, and again the interaction with measles and malnutrition is awful, you know, these kids are so, so unwell. And so we're seeing just those basic services which could have stopped that kid coming to us, we're now seeing these peaks in our admissions into hospital, which again, like I said, by the time a malnourished child reaches one of our MSF hospitals, they're really sick.
They're really sick and there's so many things that could be done. And even, I mean, at the moment for us in South Afghanistan, we are seeing these increases compared to previous years in our inpatient admissions. And so many of those children are less than one year old. And so that again for me speaks so much about the interaction with the mother's health and the mother's nutritional status. And that so much of those services as well have been broken down.
You know, if we have young moms or we have moms who are not getting antenatal care, not getting good maternity care, postnatal care, malnourished themselves, you're going to get preterm babies, you're going to get low birth weight babies, and those children, their risk of malnutrition is so much higher.
Monica Harding
That's really useful, thank you. Monica, can I come to you? In your experience, do the public in donor countries support international health spending?
Monica Ferro
They do. They do.
And I have to say that, well, maybe I should start to respond to that question by saying thank you, because the UK is UNFPA's largest market for individual giving, for donations from the public outside the US, because the legislations are quite different. And if I actually asked them to pull the numbers, and for the first six months of 2024, we already had one million pounds donations from the UK public. And it's also very interesting that the largest donations were solicited for our campaigns to provide life-saving services in Gaza and the West Bank, and also on our birth kits. So it's quite heart-warming to see how the UK public is responding to our appeals. And I think this also kind of encourages you, as representatives of the people, to also understand that it's very much aligned with what the public wants.
Speaker 51
The UK is a very generous public, so we are very thankful for this extraordinary level of support.
Kirrily de Polnay
Can I just add one thing? I've much smaller numbers, but I was just going through some supporter numbers just it was actually only 31, but it's so heartwarming to see the messages that we get from the British public. And so many of them increased their their contributions to MSF directly linked to funding cuts by governments, including the UK, but also from the US and other governments. And they really cited that as their reason. And and that's it's very heartwarming.
You know, we know the British public are very generous in that way. And I think that I think that mustn't be forgotten in in these discussions.
Speaker 52
Can I just clarify that? So you were seeing the public give more because they saw the government cut?
Kirrily de Polnay
Yeah. Not just the UK, but generally, you know, many, many funding cuts.
People were literally writing that it was directly related to that they were going to increase their direct debit.
Speaker 10
That's a new one. What, and feel free to be completely honest with this, what opportunities, if any, has the international decline in funding created for governments and organisations delivering health programming or research?
Kennedy Uadiale
I do think that the funding cuts definitely came with a lot of challenges for governments, mainly because of the abruptness it happened and not too many governments can switch immediately to take up such responsibilities that were previously being covered. So, if you look at the way countries responded, and I'm going to focus on the countries that I'm working currently, Uganda saw an opportunity, just the way others probably would have seen the opportunity to say, let's begin to look inward, let's begin to do things a bit differently to be able to absorb the shock.
So Uganda was moving more and more into integration of health services, bringing HIV programs into an integrated healthcare system and trying to, you know, mount some level of response to absorb the shock. But different countries have got different capacity to be able to do that. And if you look at the scenario in Malawi, Malawi with all its economic challenges, it's not, it wasn't that easy to really have that switch happening. And what that means is that there is a lot of challenges at the primary healthcare level all the way to the tertiary healthcare level.
And maybe very quickly to also talk about the fact that even though these opportunities are there and countries try to respond differently, but the suffering of the people is really there. And I give you an example. Jean was talking about the Fleming Fund withdrawal. For us, the Fleming Fund withdrawal came even beyond, the impact came even beyond the issue of the laboratory. One of my colleagues I was talking with a few days ago told me as soon as that happened, the district hospital where he was working could not produce lab results for 150 days owing to the fact that even the system, the data management system of the lab, there was no one to operate that, even looking at provision of blood culture bottles, it was not there.
So that created a lot of difficulties for health workers.
And for us as a team that is involved in research, we have a research component that involves ethnographic approach. And Fleming Funds were the ones who were actually sponsoring those meetings. So in the technical working group meetings, that part we are supposed to go when implementing that research package, we go to those meetings just to observe how people who make decision on antimicrobial resistance policy, how do they make those decision? And where are the bottlenecks? What are areas that could be addressed in those decision-making process?
Sarah Champion
So Kennedy, can I, can I pause you there because we pushed the government very hard on this decision that the committee thought was wrong. We had a Minister of Health and an FCDO minister here in front of us. And they both said that the scheme was always time-limited, that this was the end of the first tranche and it was up to other governments to pick up the second phase.
Do you have any sympathy with that position?
Kennedy Uadiale
Well, really every project is time-bound. That's the truth. Every project is time-bound, but it does not stop halfway. There is always a transitioning process. Whether the government is going to take it over, there is a timetable to transition.
The tap is not just closed immediately. So that's the kind of thing we have seen where the tap is closed and the core group meetings for AMR, technical working group meetings, some of them are either not happening at all or they've moved to being virtual occasionally.
And for me as a researcher who wants to do an ethnographic research to really be able to support and improve how decisions are made on AMR, I'm not able to do that anymore because I need to be in a physical meeting where I watch the way people do things around. So, this is just trying to bring out those difficulties that have come with this, though countries are trying looking at this from the side of there could be opportunities to look inward, being able to transition has not been easy for those countries.
Speaker 10
Thank you. If I can continue, you mentioned in Uganda, however, they were able to look inward to see what they could do there.
And I'm wondering, can countries like the UK help to realize those sort of opportunities?
Kennedy Uadiale
Absolutely, absolutely. And this is where I strongly believe that the UK can champion a number of causes. Like the work we do where we are developing rapid approaches to antimicrobial resistance surveillance is sponsored by the UK. It's already a very positive thing that is happening that has got real value for money because we know that antimicrobial resistance is one of the biggest threats to public health at the moment and surveillance is a key pillar to addressing antimicrobial resistance.
So with this work we've just done, if if countries are empowered to be able to use rapid approaches that are affordable to be able to, you know, identify hotspots for antimicrobial resistance, be able to target, uh, you know, interventions, it would go a long way in changing things. So I think I would be very happy to see the UK championing this kind of causes that will be able to address, you know, this kind of situations. Additionally, um, when you when you look at the workforce, funding cuts also have affected, especially the frontline workers, community health workers. You you look at countries trying to reprioritize.
Those community health workers are far down on the list of priority because those ones that were sponsored by projects previously, since they don't have funding, some of them are laid off and staff who were not trained previously to probably take care of HIV patients are the ones taking care of HIV patients. So, on some occasions where they try to want to absorb those staff that were previously working under other projects, some of them stay very long without salary. And for every human being who works in a low and middle income country, there are chains of people who depends on that person. So it's just a chain effect of things that ends up, you know, happening from just one event. So this is just how I think the UK can come in, support countries, leverage on those opportunities, champion them.
Very briefly, please.
Kennedy Uadiale
I strongly believe resources can be leveraged. There are other donors who are making effort and the UK can also tap, can also leverage on those resources.
The UK has got the technical know-how for research. The UK has got the ability to provide technical advice. So those in-country projects that are being sponsored, whether by UN agency or other donor, the UK can, on her own, employ researchers or technical people that could support that. So in-country expenses can come from that, from the funding that is already available by the other donors. Leveraging and collaborating could support that.
Sarah Champion
Thank you, Kennedy, because we're running out of time and we want other people on the record.
Speaker 10
Sorry, sorry, Kirrily.
How do these opportunities change when we consider fragile or conflict-affected states?
Kirrily de Polnay
I think it's sort of relating to what Kennedy was saying in that so many of the places that we're working in as MSF, yes, we would love that domestic financing or that ownership to take to happen, but it can't happen overnight. And especially in those areas where we work and, you know, if we if we be honest about in Yemen at the moment, they're not ready, they can't take over the health system, they can't sort of switch. In Afghanistan, it's the same. Those places where I'm afraid there is still the need for MSF, yes, for sure, that would be a long-term goal, but that's not the reality today. And the reality today is us having to add another 50 beds into our inpatient, you know, ward for malnourished children.
And it's not it's not an easy task.
And so I think that's, it's, there is so, there are opportunities and we see that, and there are opportunities with UN research and efficiency, but there are just so many contexts where we can't expect that to happen overnight. And so then we, you know, we do need the UK to again be protecting that, that kind of humanitarian funding.
Speaker 10
So that was, that's, sorry, that's the one for, for Jeanne. Sorry, I'm, I'm jumping all over the place. Jeanne, UK wants to base its provision of aid around the partnership model. What does a good partnership look like to you?
Jeanne Salje
Yes, okay. So I'm quite positive about partnership in terms of research. And the reason, so obviously we need partnerships at all levels. I'm most familiar with scientist to scientist. And in many cases that's a genuine partnership because scientists, we're like wild cats, we get to do what we want.
No one tells us what to do or who we work with. So you only enter into a partnership if both parties are going to get something from it. And so the way collaborations really work, whether it's with someone in the US or with someone in Nepal, it's because both parties are getting something from it. And generally they're long-term collaborations. You design a project together, you write a project together, you develop a grant together.
I'd say the cuts and the loss of Newton funding and Global Challenges Research Funds has made it more difficult to establish those sorts of partnerships. But one example that I would also speak to very quickly is we bring in students from LMICs and from other countries. And so I've just got a new MPhil student who started yesterday from Bangladesh.
And he is absolutely fantastic and sort of equivalent to the other master's students that we have and have a very, very competitive program. And it's exciting having someone like that here in Cambridge for a year because he will come, he'll do great things, he'll probably go on to do a PhD, have an international career, may go back to Bangladesh, may work internationally. But during his time in Cambridge, he will build networks both with me and my lab, but importantly with his cohort. They will all go on, become international scientists. And that's somewhere I think we really have a way of just sort of scientist-to-scientist, investing in the next generation.
And that's something where I think science really lends itself bottom-up to building these really solid, foundational, long-term partnerships that can sort of filter up through the ecosystem.
Sarah Champion
We have a parallel inquiry on higher education and research, so we may well lean into you for evidence on that as well. It's a great pleasure to welcome Tulip Siddiq to our committee, new member.
Over to you, Tulip.
Rizwana Tulip Siddiq
Thanks, Monica. You've already mentioned this rollback on rights in a previous answer, and really I just wanted to ask you a bit about how have you experienced this in your work across the world, but in particular just to focus on how has it affected sort of future and past achievements.
Monica Ferro
Thank you, thank you for that question. If I may, I'm just going to steal 30 seconds of my allocated time just to mention that I really think this message of ecosystem is very, very important. And I think that, you know, we come from three different backgrounds, Kennedy adds a fourth, and I think that's really, if I could highlight a key takeaway that I would like this committee, it's the ecosystem.
We are all working in an ecosystem. The fact that I don't have money to deliver supplies or, as I've mentioned in a previous hearing, sometimes we don't have the money to bring the ships to dock or to deliver on the last mile, that's affecting the civil society organizations that downstream depend on us to getting them the supplies. It's really, and also Kennedy was highlighting the health workforce. We have been terminating contracts with some of our skilled SRHR professionals, midwives, and that's a pipeline that really gets blocked. And it takes years to train someone.
And I know it's amazing that women can still go to general practitioners, but they do need skilled attendants. And this goes very much to the question on the rollback.
So what we are witnessing is a bit all over the world, language being challenged. We heard Natasha saying that in certain places, the expression SRHR, sexual reproductive health and rights, has become too politicized. I prefer too toxified, because everything is political. But it's mainly the question on rights, because it broadens the scope of services that you actually need to provide. Because when we talk about rights, we also talk about, if you have a right, it means someone has the duty of fulfilling your right.
We are in some places we are seeing the rights being narrowed, either because there was a cut, either because there's an ideological position on some of the rights that are set on the table. And I'm not kind of make any comments on that. But I think if I could say what we fear is that with the rollback on rights, the agenda will be compromised and we will have bigger difficulties in fundraising for certain programs like that are included in SRHR. So if I can just say just four very quick sentences. I think that one of the things we need to do is really to reclaim the language on rights and choices.
And I think that's part of the conversation.
A lot of the opposition are making these niche concerns, like it's something that only interests to academics, to scientists. No, it's a core public policy responsibility.
The other thing I would say is challenge misinformation with evidence. We often see these narratives being replicated in all types of media without being challenged, like that comprehensive sexuality education sexualizes children, or that access to information on abortion leads to an increased number of cases. That's not right, and I think we need to challenge, and then broaden the coalition. It has been referred here that we all play complementary roles. So we need governments, we need civil society organizations, we need the academia, we need the media, we need parliamentarians on this.
And my last claim would be make consequences visible. I'm not talking about political arguments. They often seem abstract. And this is why a commission like this one, you asked us to come here and tell you that due to the cuts, we had to close over 10,000 health centers, that 260 safe spaces were closed, that over 11 million women and girls lost access to services. This is what it looks like, the rollback on rights.
And sometimes the rollback on rights also comes with funding cuts. I'm sorry if I exceeded myself.
Sarah Champion
And what is the UK doing to address this, particularly around sort of the ideology that's driving some of it?
Monica Ferro
I think the UK has a critical role to play in this conversation, not only because it's a member of the G7, it's a member of G20, it's a permanent member of the Security Council, it has an extraordinary diplomatic network. And I think that the message has to be very clear. These rights are non-negotiable.
These rights are red lines as strong as economic rights or access to certain markets, and that would be what I would really ask from the UK, and also that you invest your expertise in supporting some of our countries, some of our organizations in responding to the challenges that we have, but clearly a leading voice, a thought leader with a huge presence on this, all these forums where these policies are decided.
Charles Noah Law
Thank you. Turning back to you, Dr. Salje, as well as the bilateral programs, multilateral funding has been cut significantly, so what do you feel that the impact of that is on achieving our global health goals?
Jeanne Salje
So honestly, that's something I've got less direct experience, so I don't really want to comment on that, especially since we're short on time. The only I would say is those organizations such as FIND, the Foundation for Innovative Diagnostics and Neglected Diseases or something. And that's an example of an organization I have worked with who helps, you know, give advice and helps various academics develop diagnostics and for neglected diseases and get them out in the field. That's an example of an organization that has rapidly contracted and is at risk of closure, although it's not directly funded by, you know, USAID because the funding that it gets is indirectly through academics who are funded by. I know that they're at risk.
So that's an example of an institution that's been going for a long time and has been foundational in the sort of ecosystem of scientists developing infectious disease research and is indirectly affected by those.
Charles Noah Law
Okay. And are there any areas that you would like to see the government pushing for more reform in the multilateral system?
Speaker 67
I don't want to comment on that because I think I'm going to say something unhelpful.
Speaker 68
If any other panelists would like to come in briefly on this. You've made us interested. Would anyone else briefly like to come in on this from the panel?
Kennedy Uadiale
Well, I can just a few statement mainly from field experience. If you look at countries and how ministries of health needs to be supported in terms of standards, WHO plays that role, supporting countries based on making sure that the standards are there and they are adapted contextually. One example is when you look at emergency preparedness plans against pandemic, another one is the national action plan on antimicrobial resistance.
These are all standards that WHO brings in. But with the funding cuts, we know that they have also reshaped the way they operate in terms of having personnel to actively do this. And I do think WHO needs to be supported in that regard. Not just WHO, UNICEF is there as well, really looking at issues related to children under fives and above. And I do think that these multilaterals need to really be supported to continue to do their work in terms of supporting that level of standards.
Jeanne Salje
Right. If I could just make a quick follow-up because you mentioned standards and I didn't get to answer any questions about the strengths of the UK, but we're a particular leader in the development of standards and reference. And so NIBSC is something, I mean, we provide over 95% of those references and standards that the WHO recommend. And so this is an area which I think the UK is already a huge leader and is so important in the developing. It's the sort of boring, unglamorous stuff, but on your COVID test, the bottom line is the one you don't want to have and the top line tells you the test is working.
And without that top line, you know, you have no idea what you're doing. And so that's something where the UK has historically been a leader and so continuing to invest in that sort of work is building on our strengths.
Charles Noah Law
Thank you. And Monica, the merger between the UNFPA and UN Women has been mooted, so what do you see as the inherent threats and opportunities of that?
Monica Ferro
So, we are now waiting for a decision. The decision is in the hands of the Secretary-General and member states.
How lovely that a man is in charge of that. We went through a long process. I know the committee has followed. I know the committee has raised the issue with several ministers and we thank you for the attention because it shows that you actually care about the mandates of both agencies. So what happened was that the executive boards of both organizations decided they didn't have enough information to support the merger.
And UN Women and UNFPA are working on areas of collaboration where we can still move forward with efficiencies, with rationalization of purposes.
And, but we are waiting for further guidance. As far as we know, the Secretary-General and member states are now on the process. And we are very keen, we are very keen to support, as it was said here in the hearing. We know the UN needs to be fit for purpose. We know the UN needs to reform.
We celebrated on Saturday 81 years, the UNFPA is slightly younger. But this means that the processes that were set in place no longer fit. You know, we are doing the best we can and the UN has reformed. I don't like this idea of looking at us as if it was October 1945. Everything has changed, a lot has changed.
But we do understand that we need to rebuild this kind of social trust contract with the people we serve and we are very keen.
Sarah Champion
Can I step in here?
I'm aware that you're in the midst of this and so you're giving us a beautiful political answer. But can I just say that I am absolutely incensed that when there was the opportunity for the Secretary General to reform the UN, the two organisations he went for out of the couple of hundred that there are were the two that give very specific services to women, that are very small organisations that have two completely different tasks. And for us to lose the only, you know, 51, 52% of the population, to lose the only two specific organisations for our needs, which are documented are very, very unmet, I think was an absolutely appalling decision to make. And if he does go ahead with this, that's going to be his legacy and that is not a good legacy that I would want to have on my record.
So thank you for your diplomatic answer, and let me take you off the hook and Noah, I'll move back to you.
Charles Noah Law
Um, Kirrily, sorry, so we've heard about some of the potential threats and opportunities of that proposed merger, but what do you think the multilaterals could do more to perhaps unlock some of those efficiencies or synergies between, or better collaboration together?
Kirrily de Polnay
Um, I mean, like I said, I've worked in two UN organisations, so I have seen a bit of the sausage factory. But, you know, there are so many people in country offices in those UN organisations doing an amazing job, working really hard, working with their government counterparts, supporting them, and I think that's really admirable and that needs to go on.
I think how we see it in MSF is that what we would love to see, and again, I'm sort of, you know, speaking to a smaller sort of vision of the child, but sometimes we feel like some of the mandates and the territories of UN organizations mean that the child and the mom have to fit in with them, rather than turning it around and saying, what does this mother and child need? And they can't come back next Tuesday because it took half a day to get there. So is there a way to think about some reform that actually speaks to, let's try and do everything we can for this one child? And again, we've talked about HIV and TB a lot, and they're such a strong link for us within malnutrition as well.
A lot and that's such a strong link for us within malnutrition as well, so that again just looking at all those services, could we, could we think about reforming into what that, I mean again I'm biased about the mother and child, but what they need rather than we'll serve this and we'll serve this and we'll serve that and you all kind of fit in about our funding and our, and our mandates. And just the final thing, you know, especially when we are in this hyper-prioritisation where we are seeing stock-outs of therapeutic foods everywhere and we hear that one agency can't transport this type of therapeutic food because it's not their mandate, it does worry us. You know, we really want to see those supplies getting to where they need to go to.
Sarah Champion
Can I build on that with a question to all of you if I could just have a one-line answer? The previous development minister told us she was gambling on multilateral investment and she was putting basically the majority of her chips into that. You've all described very well that it's an ecosystem, so personally I would be going for a spread bet on this rather than just urging multilaterals to do the right thing.
The World Bank has also expressed concern over the decision that we've made to invest so heavily in multilateral banks. So is it something that you see as creating gaps in the areas of health that your organization specialize in? So the fact that there is less bilateral money, less direct intervention that countries like the UK are now making.
Jeanne Salje
I'm not sure exactly what you mean in terms of research. So in terms of the multilateral funding for research, so are you talking about...
Sarah Champion
The UK, the majority of UK's ODA spend is now going to multilateral investments rather than bilateral investments. So does that decision have an impact on your area of work?
Jeanne Salje
Yes, if it means that we can't fund those direct research partnerships that I had talked about of sort of building long-term partnerships. So the Newton Fund, the GCRF, absolutely, it limits our ability to establish and maintain those partnerships.
Kirrily de Polnay
I think the other aspect with MSF is that often we end up in areas where there aren't any multilaterals, where they can't access or, you know, they're unable to. And so we don't want to be telling anybody else what to do. It's just that we want to be the ones who are bearing witness when we see that there are some patients, some communities who are falling through those cracks and that we are there in those areas and seeing where it's not working. So as I said, we see, we work, we want to work with people as best we can.
We want to be a good partner, but there is many places we see it's not working.
Kennedy Uadiale
Well, to be honest, I can't speak strongly to this, but I do think that the UK investments with governments is important to really push certain health-related agenda and being able to really direct and collaborate on how funding should really be targeted would make a lot of difference in that regard.
Sarah Champion
Thank you.
And Monica, UNFPA is one of those multilaterals that has benefited, but one could argue at the expense of those direct bilateral relationships.
Monica Ferro
Not necessarily. First of all, there's a commitment made by the humanitarian system, the Grand Bargain, that aims to reach 25%. It means 25% of our spending should go through local and national organizations. We've exceeded it. We are delivering about 38% of all our funding through national and through local organizations, most of them women-led organizations.
And our strategic plan aims to reach 45% between 2026 and 2029. So we are actually very much aligned with local response first.
Sarah Champion
And is that a condition of you receiving the funding, or is that a choice that you've made?
Monica Ferro
It's a commitment we made.
But another good example is, and this is why I mentioned that the UK could pressure the international financial institutions. We just signed an agreement with the African Development Bank in order to include maternal health as one of the top priorities of the bank. And we just supported Bangladesh that just renegotiated an agreement with the European Investment Bank to repurpose a loan they had of 250 million that's now going to be reallocated to women's health and strengthening the national health system in Bangladesh. 25,000 new midwives are going to be trained in Bangladesh. So we are working with the financial institutions also to position the maternal health agenda, the mother and child survival agenda, because we also see it as an integral component of the work we do.
So it's a challenge because we need to be constantly readapting, but it's a challenge that we have to face.
Sarah Champion
Thank you all very much. We really, really appreciate the evidence that you've given to us. It's been enormously helpful, but also the work that you're all doing on the ground. So please pass on respects and gratitude to your team. Thank you, committee.
Order, order, this session is now closed.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.