House of Lords

16 September 2026

House of Lords

Follow its sittings
02:15 - 02:18
Speaker 2
First oral question, Lord Garnier. 
02:18 - 02:24
Speaker 1
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper. 
02:24 - 02:54
Speaker 3
My Lords, the Lord Chancellor has announced that we will bring forward legislation to end the IPP sentence once and for all by the end of this Parliament.  In the meantime, HMPPS has strengthened safeguards around recall decisions and improved quality assurance, streamlined recall processes, and expanded the use of risk-assessed recall reviews to support swifter re-releases where it is safer to do so. 
02:54 - 03:31
Speaker 1
My Lords, it was interesting to hear what the noble Lord the Minister had to say.  Earlier this year, the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd and I studied about 80 sets of IPP recall papers provided to us by the noble Lord, Lord Timpson.  Many of the decisions were poorly reasoned or plainly irrational and had nothing to do with public safety.  Will the noble Lord the Minister agree that recall should not be used lazily and defensively, and only when it is in the interests of justice? 
03:31 - 04:06
Speaker 3
Well, of course, a recall should be used in the interests of justice and not lazily.  But I do have to say to the noble Lord, recall remains a vital public protection measure, but safeguards and oversight have been strengthened for IPP cases, partly as a result of the noble Lord's work. 

And there has been a 31% decrease in IPP recalls in 2025 compared to 2024.  All IPP life recall decisions are now agreed by senior HMPPS decision makers, precisely to mitigate the point that the noble lord makes. 
04:06 - 04:48
Speaker 5
My lords, it's fantastic to see that we're now moving along the road of getting justice for IPP prisoners.  But, my lords, once an IPP prisoner has been deemed safe and released by the parole board, then that should be the end of the matter, IPP finished.  If recalled for no further offence, it should be for the normal 56 days like every other prisoner on regular sentence, not back to the indefinite torturous IPP sentences.  Therefore, for the sake of fairness, justice, and equality for all prisoners, does the noble lord the minister agree with my comments? 
04:48 - 05:19
Speaker 3
Well, I thank the noble lord for welcoming our decision to bring forward legislation to end IPP sentences by the end of this parliament.  A further announcement will be made later this year.  We are actively working on the right approach to ending the IPP sentence once and for all, but also to put in place a careful and planned approach to recalls.  But of course we want to do the right thing and our approach is an approach of principle, not just convenience. 
05:19 - 05:51
Speaker 7
My lords, when an IPP prisoner is recalled to prison, they usually spend at least two years or more in prison.  So it's effectively a resentencing exercise, but by a probation officer, not a judge.  So shouldn't they at least have been charged with an offence by a police officer, rather than merely exhibiting behaviour which in the view of a probation officer might lead to an offence? 
05:51 - 06:39
Speaker 3
As I've said, we do need recall provisions.  There must be some jeopardy if offenders break the conditions of their license.  But on the specific point about the time it takes, we have addressed this, partly by what I've said earlier, that decisions are now agreed by senior decision makers.  We did introduce in the Victims and Prisoners Act reforms which reduce the number of IPPs in the community on license by 936.  And this is the really important point, we're starting to use the risk assessment recall review, and that has led to the re-release of 61 IPP prisoners many months before their parole hearing would have been scheduled. 

06:39 - 07:02

Sally Hamwee

My lords, in the work that the government is doing towards final arrangements, will they consult families of IPP prisoners? Many of us have heard so much from the families. They understand what prisoners have gone through and what they may be capable of or not capable of on release.

07:02 - 07:18

Richard Fuller

Yes, we will, I can reassure the noble lady about that. And following the Lord Chancellor's announcement on IPPs, victim liaison officers have started to issue notices to victims, with 375 notices already issued.

07:18 - 07:53

Daniel Moylan

Over the past few decades, the use of recall by the probation service has moved really from being a last resort to being something very much more common.

Now that seems to me a policy and process decision in which ministers could rightly intervene without actually getting involved in individual cases. Would the noble lord be willing to agree that ministers should look at how frequently recall is being used by the probation service with a view to restoring the earlier position?

07:53 - 08:36

Richard Fuller

I agree with all of that except the very last phrase, the going back to the earlier situation. But that is why we introduced the risk-assessed recall review because we did want to put an end to this situation that he describes where once people are recalled, then they face a long period before their case is reconsidered. And that's what gives rise to this feeling that they are in effect serving a new sentence. That's not what we want and that's why we've tried to mitigate those delays. On the wider point about policy, we are monitoring these trends and we will keep looking at them.

08:36 - 09:01

Speaker 14

I'm sure the noble lord the minister understands that many of the or some of the IPP prisoners are so badly damaged by their long incarceration that they would find it extremely difficult to move into mainstream society. Is there enough help given to those people, for example housing and support of all kinds, financial and medical if that's what needed?

09:01 - 09:48

Richard Fuller

That is precisely the one, that I can join with Baroness Jones. That is precisely the reason why as one of the things we're thinking through about how we end this sentence is what support we need to put in place both before they're released and afterwards. But I would just refer to the work my noble friend Lord Timpson did on the IPP action plan which was to seek to ensure that IPPs were in the right sort of prison for them and that they were getting support while they were still in prison. But I can assure the noble lady that the question of support before and after release is absolutely top of our list of things to worry about.

09:48 - 10:34

Speaker 12

My lords, might I suggest that there is a problem with part of the minister's answer which is the reference constantly including by the Justice Secretary before the end of this parliament. Nobody knows when this parliament is going to end, which might mean that it could be 2029 or it could be 2027. In which case if this issue is not resolved, it will drag over again for a further 30 years. Is it not possible for the government to bring forward rapid legislation this autumn which deals with the residue of those already released but who are recallable at any instance? And a simple one paragraph piece of legislation as was done similar to the post office workers could clear the long-term matter up.

10:34 - 10:52

Richard Fuller

Well I can reassure the noble lord that we do not intend to let this drift. But the noble lord will understand I can't give specific dispatch box commitments on dates. But I think that frankly is a pessimistic view of how this will go. We are going to do this in this parliament and we are very actively working on it.

10:52 - 11:37

David Wolfson

My lords, it is important in this area where there is a measure of agreement between the front benches and indeed across the house to make sure that we legislate and make changes in possession of the facts. The proven reoffending rate between July and September 2024 was 29.9%. But there were no equivalent figures for IPP prisoners who've been released. Will the noble lord the minister either provide the house with those figures or place the figures in the library so that we have the material before us before any changes are made? And will he also undertake to provide that information before making any further changes?

11:37 - 12:14

Richard Fuller

I don't have that information, but I will seek to get it and I will come back to the noble Lord and others about it. But on the point of principle that he raises about the risks of reoffending, this relates absolutely to the point I was making to Baroness Jones, that we do need to ensure that when they are released, people are properly supported and that reduces the risk of being recalled. I think all noble Lords recognize that when anyone leaves prison, there is always a risk of reoffending and it's our job to get better at preventing that. And the way to do that is to stop having over-crowded prisons and over-stretched staff.

12:14 - 13:01

Speaker 23

My Lords, I declare an interest as patron of Music in the Ville in Pentonville. So my question is very much to do with rehabilitation, which I know the noble Lord cares about very much. One of the things that IPP sentences have engendered is total despair. There's a lack of hope. So my question is really, and I've spoken to an IPP prisoner about this, and the thing that would help enormously would be if prison staff now could actually be in touch, not just with families, as the point was made, but with prisoners themselves to make them see that there may be a light at the end of the tunnel.

13:01 - 13:22

Richard Fuller

I do agree with the noble Lord about the importance of hope, particularly for this group of prisoners. I can hardly imagine what it would be like to be in prison serving more than ten years over your tariff offense. So we do have to instill that hope. And I also agree with the noble Lord that the arts and music in particular is one way where we might do that.

13:22 - 13:30

Prem Sikka

Second oral question, Lord Sikka.

13:30 - 14:01

Steve McCabe

Most businesses pay the rates that are due, but a minority abuse the system to reduce their bills or avoid paying altogether. This imposes an unfair burden on the majority and prevents funding from reaching local services. This government will not tolerate tax avoidance and is committed to taking the necessary action to address avoidance and evasion. Decisions on tax are set at a fiscal event and I'm not going to speculate on the upcoming budget.

14:01 - 14:52

Prem Sikka

My Lords, I thank the minister for his reply. After claiming empty property relief, some businesses place empty boxes in premises to give the appearance of occupation, subsequently removing them to trigger an additional period of relief. One scheme operated by Principled Offsite Logistics Limited has deprived councils of five hundred million pound of business rates. Can the minister ensure that business rates avoidance receives the same priority as tax avoidance and the government publishes an annual estimate of the revenues lost, requires registration of all business rates avoidance schemes and prosecutes the enablers?

14:52 - 15:49

Steve McCabe

The noble Lord actually does raise an important part as far as tax avoidance is concerned with rates. There's been coverage of some of the most egregious instances of business rate avoidance over recent years, including the use of snail farms and prayer rooms. And a recent court case, which I think the noble my noble friend referred to, has made it significantly more difficult for the most common avoidance schemes to be effective.

The case was a Court of Appeal case brought by the City of London. The Court of Appeal ruled in favor of the City of London. And as a result, the attempt to secure repeated periods of empty rate relief using box shifting in this case has failed. The ruling has closed down this particular avoidance scheme, and as a result, local authorities can, if they are satisfied that the scheme in use in their area falls within the ruling, withdraw empty profit relief.

15:49 - 16:15

Speaker 27

My Lords, does the Minister agree that more also needs to be done to tackle the antics of rogue rating agents who exploit small businesses by submitting false valuations, charging huge fees, and often locking them into lengthy and expensive contracts of little or no value?

16:15 - 17:13

Steve McCabe

I thank the noble friend for his question. For example, while not applying to business rates, additional criminal sanctions were introduced in the Financial Act 2026. That will enhance the deterrent against promotion of tax avoidance and increase protection against harm caused to the Exchequer, the taxpayer, and the tax system. The new measures, when combined with HMRC's existing powers, mean that promoters of market tax avoidance will face large fines or criminal sanctions if they do not disclose their avoidance scheme, promote types of schemes that have no realistic prospect of success which the HMRC has set out as prohibited, do not comply with our information notices, and do not stop promoting their schemes when issued with a legal notice requiring them to do so. So there is a lot going on, but I accept the point that the noble friend makes.

17:13 - 17:52

Susan Kramer

Despite the court ruling that which made it illegal to practice box shifting as described by Lord Seeker and some of the issues around the ridiculous thing of snail farming, that many local authorities are finding it very hard to enforce. They don't have the resources and they get caught into fairly elongated court processes. Has the government looked at giving them more direct and immediate powers to be able to crack down on this because basically these landlords go from one sort of strategy to another, that one form of cheating to another, and the close down is vital.

17:52 - 18:14

Steve McCabe

Yeah, I accept what the noble baroness is saying. What the government is committed to is actually consulting on a general anti-avoidance rule so that covers all local authorities. I know there's something similar to that in Scotland and Wales, and it's something that the government is seriously looking at. When it's going to happen, I think I'll leave that to the Chancellor of the Exchequer and the budget to say.

18:14 - 18:45

Timothy Kirkhope

It's fine for the government to take action against those that break the rules and break the law. I think that the high streets in this country currently are virtually crippled as a result of taxation and indeed including business rates that are applied on them. What is the government going to do to lift these burdens and encourage small businesses to continue to trade on our high streets?

18:45 - 19:28

Steve McCabe

I'd just kindly say to the noble lord, at the last budget, the Valuation Office announced updated property values for the 2026 revaluation. In recognition of the impact of the revaluation on bills, the government has introduced a support package which is worth 4.3 billion pound to protect against ratepayers seeing large overnight increases. As a result, over half of ratepayers see no bill increases in 2026-27, including 23% whose bills go down. This also means most properties see increases of them capped at 15% or less in 26-27, or 800 pound for the smallest.

19:26 - 19:49

Anthony Berkeley

Has my noble friend seen an increase in the use of unused buildings for snail farms? Because of course people who run snail farms can claim agricultural relief from some of the rates. Is he aware of this and if not, could he look into it?

19:49 - 20:04

Steve McCabe

Well, we're talking about snails so I don't know how quickly we're going to act on this. But just to say to the noble friend that I will look into this and write back to my noble friend.

20:04 - 20:42

Speaker 18

My Lords, with the two-tier system that we have on our high streets, such that there are many thousands of shops that are opening up all over in our villages, towns and cities. Some of those shops, most of those shops, not having to pay any taxes and are cash-only. We know actually they don't even require any customers because their focus is organised crime. Why should legal shops have to pay their taxes when they're right next door to others who are committing crime and no one is touching them?

20:42 - 21:16

Steve McCabe

Yes, I accept that point made by the noble baroness as well. We are looking and I think we've just introduced something where these shops that don't have any social responsibility, such as vape shops etc., where we are looking at the impact that we could have on them with additional rates etc., so that we can invest in those shops in those communities that do a really good job, especially those in rural areas. And I know very well myself, living in a village, how important the local shop is.

21:16 - 21:43

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, I know from having had ministerial responsibilities for public sector fraud that there's much scope for reducing it in local authorities. Scams relating to empty business premises is a very good example of this. Does the government have any wider plans to tackle fraud in local authorities, perhaps with the support of the Public Sector Fraud Authority and get at these problems that we've been hearing about?

21:43 - 22:09

Steve McCabe

As I mentioned in the answer to my noble friend Lord McCabe, the government is looking seriously at this. We did lay out plans in the Financial Act in 2026 earlier this year and we do realise the points that was raised by the noble baroness that they do need to be taken into consideration. So there's a lot more initiatives that are going to take place to accommodate the issues that she's just raised.

22:09 - 22:37

Natalie Bennett

My Lords, the noble Lord Lord Sikka referred to the role of enablers in supporting business tax avoidance schemes. And we know that in many areas of financial crime, estate agents, bankers, lawyers and accountants are corruptly aiding these avoidance schemes. Can the noble Lord the Minister tell me how many such enablers have been prosecuted for business tax avoidance schemes in recent years?

22:37 - 22:46

Steve McCabe

I don't have that actual figure off the top of my head. But what I can do is look into that and obviously write to the noble baroness with the answer.

22:46 - 23:30

Speaker 19

My Lords, years ago when I was a leader of the council, we had some instances where there were large, really large buildings there and they were lying empty and they had to pay some form of business rent or something on it. And what they did was they had a desk and a chair in there from one of the charities. And then the reason was that they wouldn't have to pay any business rates on it. And of course the landlord of that, because they had to pay such a large amount of rates on it, they would pay something to the charity.

23:24 - 23:27

Speaker 24

Is the government aware of that kind of a scam as well?

23:27 - 24:00

Steve McCabe

We know that these quite a few scams that are going on in the industry, if I can call it the industry, have a very good way of evolving and changing and adapting. And that's why we don't want to make any kind of policy decisions prior to the budget because they do morph into another kind of entity. And we need to, we want to stop that. But we know that there's a wide range of scams that are going on and we want to crack down on them. And the idea of a general anti-avoidance rule may be the answer.

24:00 - 24:02

Speaker 15

Third oral question, Baroness Neville-Rolfe.

24:02 - 24:11

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.

24:11 - 25:23

David Pitt

My Lords, this question about the government's interest bill is a really good one. One in ten pounds of government money is now spent paying interest. There are three elements causing this. One is the level overall of borrowing and there consistent disciplined fiscal rules that are kept to are we believe the right answer. There's also of course the growth in global interest rates, for example following quantitative easing, but also we're living in an extremely uncertain world, particularly in the Persian Gulf.

And then there's a third thing, which is the premium that the UK now pays over the G7 average, a premium that's been apparent since September 2022. And again the best remedy for that is sustained fiscal discipline, including I would say particularly respecting the independence of the Bank of England and of course the Office for Budget Responsibility.

25:23 - 25:54

Lucy Neville-Rolfe

My Lords, as most of us agreed in my noble friend Lord Bridges of Headley's debate last week, we need to be honest about the trade-offs that we face. Given the sheer scale of our national debt and the moron premium on our gilts, which the minister mentioned, I believe the only way to avoid a financial crisis is to reduce spending. Does the noble lord the minister agree?

25:54 - 27:11

David Pitt

I think it's the overall fiscal discipline that is the central question. You mentioned the moron premium. Discipline is really important. I don't know whether all the noble lords understand what the moron premium refers to. It was a slight by an economist describing the behavior of the team responsible for the September 22 mini-budget.

To give a sense of the cost of that, it's 15 billion pounds a year. And I think we have learned lessons from that. When I talked at the debate last week, I think speakers from across the house agreed that fiscal discipline, independent oversight, not moving the goalposts, this was absolutely critical. The balance of spending on tax might be something where we disagree, but I think on fiscal discipline we agree entirely.

27:11 - 27:52

Susan Kramer

My Lords, in the government's 2026-2027 Treasury remit to the Debt Management Office, index-linked gilt issuances will account for 9.3% of total new gilt issuances. Why was this decision made when a quarter of UK gilts are already index-linked, well above the international norms, when we're in a period of inflation and rising interest rates, and when defined benefit plans, the schemes which had a hedging rather than a speculative use for index-linked, are rapidly disappearing?

27:48 - 27:52

Speaker 13

Does this make any sense?

27:52 - 28:04

David Pitt

So I think the Debt Management Office is part of the Bank of England. I'd be more than happy to write to them, although the noble baroness might write herself and ask the answer to the question.

28:04 - 28:19

George Foulkes

Is the government going to join the Defense, Security and Resilience Bank to enable us to borrow money at lower interest rates for defense spending?

28:19 - 28:34

David Pitt

Let me reply properly to you in writing on that particular question to make sure that I give you an accurate reply, but I believe that is under discussion.

28:34 - 29:16

Speaker 30

Is not the real problem here our chronic dependency on borrowing, as debt's tripled over the last 20 years in spite of our fiscal rules? Has the minister found the time to read the Economic Affairs Committee's insightful report on our fiscal architecture, 45 pages, 22 sparkling recommendations, and also available in all good print offices? It poses the key question: is our fiscal framework fit for purpose, to which the answer in brief is no, it's not. How much does that concern the minister?

29:16 - 30:06

David Pitt

So I have read that document. I'd point out that in 2025-26 our borrowing will be the lowest for six years, and for the first time since 2004 we're projected to borrow less than the OECD average. In terms of external evaluation of the fiscal rules, let me read from the IMF: "The plans that have been put forward by the UK Treasury strike a good balance between providing favorable conditions for growth and the emphasis on public investment is welcome in that regard and safeguarding fiscal sustainability." That was from the IMF's 2025 Article IV report.

30:06 - 30:34

John Redwood

Since September 2022, there's been a big sales program of longer-dated bonds by the Bank of England to drive up longer-term interest rates. Can the minister tell us how much over the last two years the government and Treasury have had to send the Bank of England to cover the enormous losses they have heaped up by selling these bonds at low prices needlessly?

30:34 - 30:51

Speaker 28

So I don't have those figures offhand. I could write to the noble lord, but I think they are publicly available.

30:51 - 31:19

Speaker 25

Generating growth is the key to paying off the interest and reducing the debt. The government is doing good work on that across the economy. I hope that it won't forget public sector productivity as part of generating growth. We spend as a government £3.5 billion every day. The question I have is: is the Treasury and is the minister encouraging the Treasury to focus on getting value for every one of those tax pounds?

31:19 - 31:44

David Pitt

I think my noble friend Lord Barber is absolutely correct on this and indeed has huge expertise in the area.

We too often, all of us, all parties, announce inputs and don't think about outputs. And on the question of public sector productivity, I'm not even sure that we measure outputs correctly.

31:44 - 32:22

Speaker 38

My Lords, a recent report by the Institute of Public Policy Research projects that debt interest payments will increase from the current 10% of revenue to 20% by 2075. The decisions that we take today about taxation and spending should be taken with regard to our moral obligations to the generation that follow us. What assessment have the government made of the extent to which today's debt interest payments transfer the burden of current spending to future generations of taxpayers?

32:22 - 33:11

David Pitt

So look, there are numbers that can project out for 50 years and would leave future generations with a potentially very large debt. They are of course extremely sensitive figures and I think the first thing that the government's got to do is to have the fiscal discipline that brings the debt down. As I said, last year the lowest borrowing for six years and for the first time since 2004 projected to borrow less than the OECD average. That I hope at least is a start and we can go on to think about where we go to 2070 as we move forward.

33:11 - 34:00

Jeremy Purvis

In reply to my noble friend's question about the Debt Management Office, the minister said that it was part of the Bank of England. He said he would write to my noble friend, which I'm grateful for. In to help him draft the letter, might he quote from the DMO website, which I can just quote from now, which says about who we are? Because the DMO says, in institutional terms, the DMO is legally and constitutionally part of His Majesty's Treasury. The Chancellor of the Exchequer determines the policy and financial framework within which the DMO operates.

Was that assisting the minister in the drafting of his letter to my noble friend?

34:00 - 34:17

David Pitt

I do apologize if I've made an error and if you would send me those paragraphs I would find that very helpful. You are, as you know, talking to a rookie minister here and I apologize.

34:17 - 34:19

Speaker 33

Fourth oral question, Baroness Brinton.

34:19 - 34:24

Sal Sarah Brinton

I beg leave to ask the questions standing in my name on the order paper.

34:24 - 34:53

David Hanson

The United States Embassy has confirmed that they have recalled a member of staff to the United States due to an investigation in the United States. The Metropolitan Police were notified on the 25th of August and remain in contact with US law enforcement. It's inappropriate for me to comment further during a live investigation, but I do expect all diplomats in the United Kingdom to respect our laws and any breach is treated seriously.

34:53 - 35:33

Sal Sarah Brinton

I'm very grateful to the minister for his last sentence. Unfortunately it's exactly the same as the government said in 2019 when Anne Sacoolas killed Harry Dunn in a road collision and the US authorities spirited her out of the country saying she had diplomatic immunity. So can the minister explain what the government is doing to ensure that the USA government abides by the rules that the USA insists other countries have to follow when crimes are committed by foreign diplomats there? And have the US authorities agreed that the Met Police can now interview the suspect and any other evidence of this crime?

35:31 - 36:28

David Hanson

With respect to the noble lady, I wouldn't conflate the two cases together. There are different issues at hand and as I've said, the United States has recalled the individual back to the United States, informed the Metropolitan Police who are investigating and cooperating whether there are issues that they need to investigate and examine. There is a protocol between the United States and others. And in relation to the Harry Dunn case, may I just say that that was under the last government. There was an investigation.

There have been 12 recommendations made. We intend to accept all those recommendations. We are looking as to how we can update the family of Harry Dunn, which we will do by the end of this year. But I assure the noble lady that we take these matters seriously and the Metropolitan Police are examining and discussing with the embassy what the circumstances were.

36:28 - 37:01

Henry Bellingham

Further to what the minister said about the review which was carried out by Dame Anne Owers. What she concluded was that the FCO actually missed multiple opportunities to influence the US government and also failed to treat that case as a priority. And HMG, this HMG, not the last one, said that lessons would be learned from that review and from the Sacoolas case and applied to future cases. So I think that the Sacoolas case, with great respect to the minister, is highly relevant.

37:01 - 39:18

David Hanson

Well, with due respect to the noble lord, the details of the reasons why the individual was recalled to the United States are still under discussion. The Metropolitan Police were informed that there was a US investigation relating to indecent images of children. But the offences are now being investigated and the individual has been recalled to the United States. The Metropolitan Police are examining and cooperating and discussing with the authorities. But I just say to him as well that the previous case he's mentioned, this government looked at the lessons learned, have accepted all 12 recommendations, will implement all 12 recommendations and will write to the family by the end of this year on progress on that implementation.

39:18 - 39:23

Speaker 39

My lords, that concludes oral questions for today.

39:22 - 41:00

Speaker 44

This might be a good moment for us to pause for those who wish to leave the chamber to do so quietly and quickly now. First reading of a private member's bill, Baroness McIntosh of Pickering.

41:00 - 41:51

Anne McIntosh

My Lords, I beg to introduce a bill to require the Secretary of State to set prescribed safety requirements for e-scooters offered for sale, including limits on speed and power output, to prohibit the marketing, sale and supply of e-scooters for use on roads or other public places where such use is unlawful, to prohibit the sale and supply of equipment capable of modifying an e-scooter to circumvent prescribed safety requirements, to make provision about consumer information requirements for the sale of e-scooters, to confer powers on trading standard officers and constables to enforce compliance and for connected purposes. I beg to move that this bill be now read a first time.

41:51 - 43:59

Speaker 40

Question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it. Motion to agree the Procedure and Privileges Committee report on behavior and courtesy in the chamber, the Senior Deputy Speaker. Lords, I beg to move the first report of the Procedure and Privileges Committee be agreed to.

The first part of the report proposes changes to guidance in the companion with a view to upholding high standards of behavior and courtesy in the chamber. The committee recommends the strengthening of guidance to reinforce the long-standing conventions on attendance in the chamber during debates and referring to other noble Lords. We also recommend an update to the guidance around the reading of speeches and propose a new paragraph on the dress code. In order to help the House make best use of the time allowed for oral questions, the committee proposes that the first supplementary question on each oral question should not exceed 45 seconds and subsequent supplementaries should not exceed 30 seconds. Finally, we remind the House of the guidance already set out on interventions and talking in the chamber.

The committee also considered the rules on speaking times at amending stages of bills to encourage the efficient use of time. The committee proposes that the advisory speaking time for backbenchers at report stage and subsequent amending stages should be reduced from 10 to 8 minutes.

43:30 - 45:26

Ray Raymond Collins

This reflects well-established practice that debate should become increasingly focused and avoid repeating previous arguments at length as a bill progresses through its amending stages. We also propose strengthening the guidance on withdrawing or pressing amendments to emphasize that the mover of an amendment should not make an extended speech at the end of a debate on a group of amendments. We further recommend strengthening the guidance in the companion on debate at the bill do now pass stage to emphasize that members should not thank lists of named people who have supported them in their work on the bill, well-intentioned though this is. These changes, if agreed, will come into effect following the conference recess. Finally, my Lords, the committee has authorized the production of a new edition of the standing orders.

As part of this new edition, we propose four broadly technical amendments. Firstly, that standing order 21(4) be deleted to remove the reference to the Earl Marshal and the Lord Great Chamberlain as they are no longer members of your Lordships' House. Secondly, that standing order 56 be amended to make clear that a quorum of 30 applies to any question relating to subordinate legislation. Thirdly, that standing order 83 be repealed because its provisions are now obsolete. And fourthly, references to virtual contributions be changed to remote contributions for consistency across the document.

My Lords, I beg to move.

45:26 - 45:29

Speaker 42

Question is that the motion be agreed to.

45:29 - 48:22

George Foulkes

Can I first of all welcome the report in general? And can I say a personal word of thanks to the leave of absence subcommittee who have dealt sympathetically with those of us who have got either chronic or incurable diseases. It is very encouraging in relation to that. But I wanted to mention the other aspects of the report, particularly member speaking, reading speeches, and the question of the length of questions and ministerial answers. Now that has been part of our procedure supposedly for some time now.

And in spite of the fact that the government chief whip gets up regularly and asks for questions and answers to be shorter, most members pay no attention whatsoever to it. And I mean I do everything our government chief whip tells me. So I don't know why everyone else doesn't do what the government chief whip tells them. However, it may be that it isn't the most he isn't the most appropriate or she as it was before are not the most appropriate person to do this. And I'm wondering if the committee, procedures and privileges committee, might consider once more the role of the Lord Speaker.

Now I heard some hear-hears, I also heard some muttering, mostly from the other side, which I'm used to of course. However, if we think about it, if we are to improve our procedures, if we are to get shorter questions and shorter answers, we do need some discipline.

And the best person, I would argue, to make sure that we do get that kind of discipline in the House is the person sitting in the chair. Now, I know some people opposite and even one or two people on our side say we don't want to adopt the procedures of the other place. But with respect, it isn't just the procedures of the other place. It's the procedures of any meeting, whether it be a trade union meeting or a political meeting or a church guild or or whatever, that the person in the chair says you've had long enough. Bring your remarks to a conclusion.

That's just common sense. And I can take the hint.

48:22 - 49:02

Henry Bellingham

My Lords, I just raise a couple of points and seek clarification from the Senior Deputy Speaker. Under 19 4 1 4 A, about business attire. What does that exactly mean? As I understand, if you bring a guest to the bar of the House, they have to wear a tie. So do we all have to wear a tie in here?

I hope that is the case, because most of us do. And can I also ask another clarification, because under number 30, obviously the Earl Marshal is a hereditary peer who's been defenestrated. But as I understand it, the Lord Great Chamberlain is a life peer. So presumably it wouldn't apply to him.

49:02 - 51:02

Bryn Davies

My Lords and Baroness, I want to follow up the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Benyon. What my noble friend, the Deputy Chair, Senior Deputy Speaker, thank you, failed to mention as marks was the introduction for the first time of a reference to dress code in the companion. Previously it was just effectively folklore. Now, I'm not against putting that in, but the term business attire is meaningless. You cannot take the way people dress here as being business attire.

I take it to mean what people wear in the city, what people wear in Canary Wharf. In truth, the only people now wearing ties for business purposes are estate agents and funeral directors. The tie is disappearing. And if the term business attire means anything, it means we wouldn't be wearing ties. Now, the truth is the term business attire is meaningless.

It certainly means nothing in relation to the noble Baronesses in this House, who effectively can wear whatever they like. And as indeed I think I'm suggesting that we can leave it to the good judgment not just of the noble Baronesses, but also the noble Lords in this House as to what we should wear. And don't get me started on the bishops.

51:02 - 52:02

Prem Sikka

My Lords, I think saying that questions need to be completed in 30 seconds or 45 seconds is incredibly regressive. We have more members, we have more ministers, more ministries, more legislation than ever before.

And to imagine that in about 30, 35 words you can actually ask a detailed question is impossible. Somebody mentioned, just been mentioned, people reading notes. The people who read notes are ministers. They just read out off to their briefings, don't even often answer the questions which is asked. I don't know if that is going to apply to the ministers as well, to say that they mustn't read any question and they've got to memorize all the briefings.

I actually think it is a bad move and I would certainly not support this kind of change.

52:02 - 52:43

David Wolfson

I don't know if any of the noble lords has ever been to a synagogue board meeting, but I can assure that that is an exception to the rule which he put forward as to orderly conduct of business. But more substantively, I wouldn't appear in the High Court without a tie, and I wouldn't want to appear in the High Court of Parliament without a tie either. And I would gently remind, I would gently remind the noble lord that when Arthur Andersen introduced dress-down Fridays, a Savile Row tailor was asked whether this would be the end of the suit and he replied it would be the end of Arthur Andersen, and he was right.

52:43 - 53:26

Speaker 53

My lords, I actually was going to intervene on the question of business attire and what its definition is and I look forward to the senior deputy speaker elucidating that in a moment. But since we are talking about speeding up the affairs of business, the business of the house, I have to say the suggestion that to reduce the time-wasting that sometimes occurs here we should reduce the time limit from 10 minutes to 8 minutes hardly seems to be a game-changer. And in fact, if at that stage of the consideration of a bill you are not able to make the critical point succinctly, why are we not considering reducing it to three or four minutes?

53:26 - 54:23

Alfred Dubs

My lords, may I make two brief points? One is to support the comment made by my noble friend George Foulkes about supplementary questions. Our chief whip does a great job in identifying which party should come next, but he can't choose between members of one party. And we still have a situation of relative chaos, and I know at least one member of the Conservative party who point-blank said to me he will not intervene in question time because he doesn't like the chaos that there is. My second point is a minor one.

In paragraph 36, it talks about not repeating lists of named people who've contributed in helping. I thought there was a tradition that we respect maiden speakers, but the only person who should thank the maiden speaker is the person speaking afterwards, not every other speaker in the debate, which seems to be the pattern at the moment.

54:23 - 55:06

Annabel Goldie

My lords, further to the point raised by the noble lord, Lord Foulkes, as I think he likes to be addressed, in relation to bringing oral questions under control, and I'm very grateful to the senior deputy speaker for his efforts to do that. I think the proposals are very sound. But may I seek clarification from him that in attempting to monitor these newly introduced time limits, that the clock will, as it does when we exceed speaking allocation limits, flash in red and show the speaker they are out of time? And that might be a more reassuring prospect to the noble lord, Lord Foulkes, than the thoroughly alarming prospect of the Lord Speaker intervening.

55:06 - 56:33

Speaker 51

I appeared in this your lordship house in 2006 and there were questions being asked and I had listened, time was nearly running out and I spoke, but I had a piece of paper. And all around the house words went out: reading, reading, reading.

And I showed my piece of paper, which did not have a word on it. So, dear friends, I'll call you friends because if I call you lords, it sounds a little bit too grandiose. And a self-regulating body, I think, to give power to intervene in a debate to the Lord Speaker is trying to imitate what happens in the other place. Secondly, we need to discipline ourselves. For example, if there are only 20 seconds left for the 10 minutes questioning time on that particular question, people should not ask a question.

But we've been breaking the time limit beyond anybody's... So we need to discipline ourselves, and I for one would like to endorse the report of the committee that worked on it. Let's try it out and see what happens. Maybe next time when I hear a very long read speech, I'll stand up and say: "Reading, reading, reading!"

56:33 - 57:08

Speaker 54

I just want to say something about dress codes. I think dress code is a sign of respect. And we sit in this beautiful house, and it is respectful to dress properly. We are on the television, we have people who are viewing the proceeding in this house. And we're the only house that does not have a strict dress code, because when you look in the United States, in France, at the European Union, every man wears a tie, women dress suits, and especially in the summer, they cover themselves.

57:08 - 57:19

David Blunkett

This is an important short debate, but I do hope that all those who have contributed will be with us at 10 o'clock tonight.

57:19 - 01:01:13

Ray Raymond Collins

My lords, I think I've got an answer to all the questions which have been asked. So first, my noble... the noble lord Lord Faulks. He seems to be advocating a power grab by the Lord Speaker and the Deputy Speakers. And I have to say, we are a self-governing house. I've been in this house a very long time, longer than most noble lords, and I've twice seen it where noble lords have intervened on fellow peers and put the motion that the noble lord be no longer heard.

So there are procedures for doing that. But the bottom line is it's a self-governing house, and any change from that would be a radical change and a matter for the usual channels. The noble lord Lord Bellingham talked about business attire, and I agree with the general points he made on that. He mentioned whether the Lord Chamberlain is a life peer, and it's not the Lord Great Chamberlain who is a life peer. I hope that clears up that matter.

I'd make the point that no women wear ties in this chamber. And I'd also make another point that while I was a magistrate, I did go through this exact issue about whether men should wear ties, whether magistrates should wear ties when they sit in magistrates' court. And in that context, the rule of the court is that court participants should uphold the dignity of the court. There's no explicit reference to wearing a tie, but I think that guidance is appropriate for this chamber as well. And it's for each individual member to dress appropriately.

And there are a few noble lords, male noble lords, who choose not to wear a tie, and that's a matter for them.

My Lords, my my friend the noble Lord, Lord Davies, also mentioned the dress code, and I can see that he is excelling himself because he's wearing his aubergine suit at the moment, which is which is unique within this chamber, and I'm glad he's he's raising the standards of of male dress within within the chamber. The the other noble Lords, Lord Sikka, Lord Harris, Lord Dubs, basically put forward ideas which were were were more radical, if you like, than than is being currently proposed in the report. What what we've tried to do in the report is is emphasize the the existing tenor of the of the the guidance of how to behave in the in the chamber. There has been a proposed reduction in the speaking time at report stage and later stages of the bill, just to answer the noble lady, Lady Goldie, accurately. The clock will flash at eight minutes at the later stages, but there will be no change to the way the clock will behave in oral questions.

So that will be for the the chief whip or the party whips to intervene if they feel that somebody's going over the allotted time. My Lords, I think I think I've covered all the points, really. So I I beg to move.

01:01:13 - 01:01:25

Speaker 39

The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary, not content. The contents have it. Standing orders, public business, the senior deputy speaker, formally.

01:01:25 - 01:01:26

I beg to move.

01:01:26 - 01:01:38

Speaker 39

Question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary, not content. The contents have it. Business of the house, the Lord Privy Seal.

01:01:38 - 01:01:44

Nicholas True

My Lords, I beg to move the motion standing in my name on the order paper.

01:01:44 - 01:02:01

Speaker 39

Question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary, not content. The contents have it. Motion for debate, Retirement and Participation Committee, Baroness Taylor of Bolton.

01:02:01 - 01:17:36

Ann Taylor

My Lords, I wish to move that the house take note of the report from the Retirement and Participation Committee. And I think it's probably quite appropriate that we are going to discuss this immediately after we've heard several comments about us being a self-governing house, because it does enter it does enter into this as well. Can I start, however, can I start, however, by thanking those members of the committee who gave up so much time to put in a great deal of effort to try to get a consensus on this matter. And can I also thank the staff that we had, who worked very diligently, Judith Brooke, Rachel Burrell, and Ellie Hassell, because there was an awful lot of work involved in the production of this report. And I must thank the leader of the house for organizing an early debate, because I think it is important that we can get the feeling of the house as a whole.

Perhaps I should start by reminding the house of the starting point for the discussion that we're about to have. In the last Labour Party manifesto, the government manifesto, there was a commitment to introduce retirement and participation requirements for the House of Lords for all peers to retire at the age of 80 at the time of the next election, whenever that election came along. It was a very significant commitment and one that was paired with other aspects of reform to this house, some of which have taken place.

When we were established, many people immediately got in touch with the committee about some of the wider issues of House of Lords reform. But I have to emphasize that the committee's remit was very tight and very specific, and quite rightly so. We were charged with considering and making recommendations on retirement age and a participation requirement and the impact that any such requirements might have on the size, membership, and functioning of the House, and we were given the opportunity to consider transition arrangements and indeed what arrangements might be made for implementation. When established, we decided very early on that we wanted to involve as many people as possible in the decision-making process, and so we embarked on a very important consultation exercise where we had an invitation for written evidence to be submitted, we had drop-in sessions, and we had many individual members collar different ones of us at different times in different corridors. We welcomed all of that, and I reckon that probably 25 to 30 percent of active members actually took part in that consultation process.

We did of course have a significant range of views, and I'll come onto some of those later, but all of the submissions that were made were carefully considered, I think by every single member of that committee. And therefore it was quite a heavy workload on every single one, and in the end, we did manage to produce a unanimous report. And I would emphasize that to the House because I think it's important to realize that people with very different starting points actually did come to a consensus in the end. So, what do our recommendations involve? First of all, let me talk about retirement because I think that that is the one issue that concerned many members when they were thinking about our committee.

And let me just say a few words by way of context because the average age of members of this House is 71. The average age of members on appointment is 59. The average age of retirement in the last few years has been 82. And I think it's worth keeping that in mind when we think about the conclusions that we came to. And we did model many options with the help of our assistants.

We did look at a whole range of options that had been presented to us by many colleagues in their submissions. The first question that we had to ask was at what point did we look at as an end date, and it was very difficult because we don't know when the next election would be. So what we took was the last sitting day of this House in this Parliament, the maximum sitting day, and that is why the modeling that we did was based on July 2029.

And so some people might be surprised at that, but it is, there is an actual logic there, and there wasn't a logic for taking any other date of that kind. I think we've also got to remember that the figures that we produce are the maximum number of peers affected at any one time. Because we are not saying that everybody has to stay until a certain time. We are saying people can retire at whatever point they feel is appropriate, but there is a maximum cutoff. If the government's proposals that all peers over 80 were to retire at the next election, and if that election was on the last possible date of July 2029, then a maximum of 257 peers would be required to leave by that date or at that time.

And as a committee, we agreed that such a number, such a cutoff point, would be too severe and would have implications for the working of the House. Unintended consequences have always got to be considered. So what we did was to take the age of 80, which is what the government has been proposing. We did have suggestions from other people. Some people were against retirement age altogether.

Some people suggested 75, some people suggested 85. We looked at all the evidence that we got, and we decided it was probably appropriate to look at the age that the government was proposing, and that's why our modeling was based on the age of 80. So we considered all of those options, and we recommended that by July 2029, all peers over the age of 85 who hadn't already retired should do so, and that subsequently, the maximum retirement age should reduce annually by one year. And of course, as I say, it is the maximum age of retirement. In Appendix 4 of this report, we set out exactly how transition would work in detail, and there is an app available so that anybody who wants to know how they themselves are affected can actually be told.

And just for the sake of transparency, we did include in our report how this would affect each of the members of the committee, just to prove that there was no bias there and we weren't actually looking after ourselves. And for anybody who's interested, mine is the 2nd of July 2031. So we thought this was fair, we thought it would be workable, and we thought it gave individuals a proper timescale for thinking about their futures. And that is where we have landed so far as retirement is concerned. We did consider the alternative of term limits.

There were submissions that we received that were in favor of fixed terms, and I do have a degree of sympathy with that. People talked about 15-year terms, 20-year terms. I think we've probably all come here and accepted a position on 10-year terms, but there was a range of opinion.

And it would, fixed terms would provide for the refreshment of the House, people would know where they were, there would be predictability. But in the end, after discussing this quite in detail, we decided that the disadvantages and the problems would be too much. There would be a difficulty in transition, there would be significant cliff edges. There was the question of reappointment and the fact that if people had the possibility of reappointment, that might actually alter how they behaved in the House, depending on who was making the reappointment. And we also looked at the question of younger members who might find it difficult to re-enter their profession after 10, 15 years here.

And so because we thought that there were too many disadvantages, we rejected that thought. On participation, can I say first of all, very clearly, that we do not equate participation with attendance. They very often are different things for different people. We had various suggestions as to how we might measure participation. Some of these were very complex, very complicated.

And many had the real problem that they could lead to performative activity, people speaking just for the sake of getting a tick in the box, and in no way would that enhance the quality of our debates. So we are not suggesting a participation threshold. However, the committee did think that there is a problem with the attendance provision. The 2014 Act does say that if you attend once during a session, then you continue to be a member of this House. And that is just not good for the reputation of this House, and people who are members should take this House seriously.

So whilst we acknowledge and whilst we appreciated the expertise from appropriate outside interests, we did think that membership of this House should be taken seriously. And therefore the committee recommended an attendance threshold of 20%, but 20% over two sessions to allow people to adjust according to their own circumstances, and with the provision of the kind of short-term leave of absence that my noble friend was talking about earlier, and I think that that would be helpful to everyone. We, ah yes, I should mention a couple of other things that we did touch on, though we didn't go into great detail. We also made a recommendation on leave of absence because of the fact that such members are not bound by the provision relating to the register of interests in the code of conduct, despite the fact that they do have clear access to members of the House and indeed to ministers. It wasn't directly for us to deal with, but we did want to highlight that because a case that there was a problem here has been made to us, which was very impressive, and therefore we did want to highlight it so that the appropriate committee can look at this again.

And just one word about another point in our report. We did suggest that peers who retire, peers who leave the House, should become peers emeritus, and that there should be an association for former peers to keep in touch and to be aware of what is going on and have access to the libraries they do under the new arrangements. I have been struck by the fact that several people have already come to me and said, "How do we arrange this?" and that they're willing to take it on. I'm very happy for them to take it on, but I do think that there is merit in following that through. So, my Lords, I've actually been heartened by the response that I've had talking to people, talking to groups, talking to individuals.

Some people have said, "Well, at least I now know how this will affect me," and others have said that they've made it's made them think what they should be doing, how they should listen to their families, how they should talk about their future, and I think that that has been very useful. We do in our report mention implementation. And we were told that a retirement age could be implemented by legislation very easily and very quickly by a one-line amendment to the 2014 Act. As a committee, we decided that it would be preferable for the House to take control of this and to introduce such a provision through a resolution of the House. And I think that that is appropriate to be recommended.

I do believe that change is coming, and I do believe that it is better done by us than to us. I recommend the report.

01:17:36 - 01:17:42

Speaker 42

Lords, question is that this motion be agreed to.

01:17:42 - 01:29:26

Nicholas True

My Lords, I thought it might be helpful to intervene at this point to set out the position of the official opposition, though I can assure the House that I will listen carefully and weigh every contribution, including from the many who may disagree with me. First and foremost, I thank the noble Baroness, Baroness Taylor of Bolton, for introducing this important debate in such a typically thoughtful fashion. And even if I don't agree, I thank her and all the members of her committee for their careful work and balanced report. And incidentally, I do agree with the recommendation on leave of absence and declaration of interests; I hope that will be taken forward. My Lords, I declare an interest: like the noble Baroness, I will be expelled under these proposals, in my case on the 8th of July 2033.

And let's be get the language right: mandatory retirement for sitting members means expulsion. And I confess that I find that prospect painful. Like others here, no doubt, I ask, "What have I actually done wrong?" Appendix 5 of the report tells me that up to 367 peers could be expelled from the House over the next seven and three-quarter years. In addition to expulsion on grounds of age, 94 peers now sitting would have failed the proposed 20% threshold.

Taken together, my Lords, that is a monster cull on top of dozens of peers recently expelled by this government. Of course, I concede, as the report says, that the figures may well be significantly lower. Some of us lined up for the sack may die; some may retire voluntarily. And after all, as the noble Baroness said, the average retirement age is 82. 82, 80, what problem are we trying to solve, my Lords, to inflict such a purge on the House?

Unlike the Select Committee, I'm not constrained by terms of reference, so I will address some wider questions.

And I do ask, why are we here? Now, some said it's to reduce our numbers. I've never really bought that argument, as noble Lords know. The largest division this year had 475 votes. Such numbers are not an adequate reason for a mass cull of near half the House potentially.

And what guarantee is there that prime ministerial patronage would not be used to fill the empty spaces with more compliant members than those forced out? And if not numbers, my Lords, is the reason party balance? Now, there was an unacceptable and unequal balance between the two main parties in 2024. But that balance is now nearing equality. A difference of 14 and narrowing between Labour and Conservative doesn't justify a mass cull.

And actually, the group that would suffer most from the report's proposals are the crossbenchers, who could lose half their number. We should be careful what we wish for. No, my Lords, as the noble baroness said, the reason we are here is because the Labour manifesto bushwhacked the House with a draconian and frankly discriminatory and ageist proposal. And now we are threatened that if hundreds of us do not go gently into that dark night, then the government will slam down a legislative guillotine. Really?

Wherefore, my Lords, this mania to expel people from our House? Who is driving this? Sir Keir Starmer, who wrote the manifesto, is gone. Mr. Burnham has said that his inspirations were the noble Lords, Lord Kinnock and Blunkett, and the noble baroness, Lady Beckett. All remarkable figures, much valued here.

But under these plans, Lady Beckett and Lord Kinnock are booted out on the 8th of July 2029, and the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, on the 6th of June 2031. The 6th of June, it would be nice if that day could be remembered for another D than the departure of the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. Is this really the new Prime Minister's wish, my Lords, or is someone else driving all this? Can our leader explain? My Lords, two criteria are proposed for the cull: age and participation.

First, Labour want to expel hundreds of peers simply because they are older. Now, there are many over 80 who make extraordinary contributions to public life here in this House and elsewhere. Can you imagine on the 21st of April 2006, someone rapping on the late Queen's door saying, "Happy birthday, Ma'am, you've had a good run, but today you've got to clear your desk, but you can come back for a cup of tea"? How much wisdom, my Lords, and leadership would this nation have lost? And isn't the same true among us here?

Is it wise to attack all those who can and do perform their duty here and not address the issue of capacity of those perhaps no longer so able to act? Age or incapacity, which more risks our disrepute? Might cognitive tests be a better focus than the blunderbuss of an age bar? Can the noble baroness, the noble Lord Privy Seal, say if this alternative is being considered? My Lords, this age bar will purge from our Parliament the voice and outlook of a major cohort of the British people.

7% of our adult population are over 80.

After these measures, the numbers from that cohort in our Parliament will be barely one-tenth of 1%. Who then from the ranks of the elderly will speak in our Parliament for them? We should be cautious about silencing the leavening voice of experience. My Lords, every noble Lord will judge this matter freely. But let me say a word as leader of the opposition.

My party will not support mass expulsion of sitting members who are well capable of doing their job and are doing it well. We can discuss rules that may apply to new members, but we think it wrong to quash the rights of all sitting members over 80. If the government were to seek to legislate, attempts may be made to amend a bill to ensure any age bar should apply for the future, not expel those valued colleagues now sitting here. This House has voted before for grandfather rights, the principle that workplace rights should not be taken from those who have them. It might well vote again for that very fair principle without overturning the idea of a future age limit.

And my party has a constitutional problem with the central mechanism of the report and the precedent it would set. For the House of Lords to pass a resolution to tell people to go would mean this House alone would seek to decide who its members should be. My Lords, it is not for the government to decide who sits in Parliament, and it is not for a single House. It is for Parliament. My noble friend the Shadow Attorney General will address the legal points.

The report is correct at paragraph 84 that a resolution of this House cannot override the legal right under the 1958 Act to a writ. Some take comfort in paragraph 85, which concedes peers may simply say no, I've heard much fruitier language, my Lords, when their birthday comes and they will go on attending by virtue of the writ. This is hardly satisfactory. Most would no doubt comply, but some would not. Invidious divisions would arise.

And my Lords, there are reasons, perhaps 72 million reasons, why this is also a bad political precedent. Let us suppose Reform might form a government. Prime Ministerial patronage would allow Reform leader, even in a minority government, to do what he says he would: pack this House. His new peers too might pass a resolution. They might say their party was elected to sweep away the establishment, and so any peer who'd been in the House for more than five years should leave forthwith.

No doubt many of us might refuse, as paragraph 85 says we could. The mother and father of constitutional crises would erupt between the two Houses. My Lords, I submit this House should be cautious about laying that precedent on the table. And away from such a looming example, what is to stop a future House passing a similar resolution excluding this category of peer or that? My Lords, these are murky waters, but the constitutional principle to us is clear.

This House alone should not assert the right to choose who here should stay and who should go without the assent of Parliament as a whole. My Lords, on participation, I recognise many wish to see action. The select committee rightly rejected the measure of performative speaking, and it was sensitive to the truth inherent to a House of experts that some will only come when they have something worthwhile to say, and we will be glad to hear them when they do.

And as the report points out, there will be cases where unforeseen illness or other commitments may make it hard for peers to attend. We shouldn't build intrusive mechanisms probing sensitive personal circumstances. And there are other questions. In a typical 150-day session, on attendance, not always judged on attendance, but on attendance it would cost £11,130 a peer just to the daily allowance simply to establish the threshold right to remain. My Lords, is the 20% threshold too high?

Does the exclusion criterion favor those who live near London? Who precisely are the peers who will be affected and how many? The principle is workable and unlike retirement, legally enforceable, but it does bear further reflection on the details, building on the committee's excellent report. To conclude, my Lords, if we are to go forward, I submit the outcome must meet four clear tests. Will it improve the ability of this House to hold governments to account?

Will it enrich the experience in this House? Will it enhance the independence of the House from recent or present governments? Will it enable the House and its committees to do their revising work better? In my judgment, these proposals, however ingenious and constructive, would fail those tests. They gild the manifesto thornbush but do not remove the thorns.

And instead of plunging forward with haste, we should take time to think with honesty and humility across party lines about the far-reaching implications of an age bar for this House, for its members, and for the voice of the elderly in the councils of our nation.

01:29:26 - 01:33:27

Kathryn Parminter

My Lords, I strongly support this report and I congratulate the noble lady, Lady Taylor of Bolton, not only for her introduction of the report but her excellent chairing of our select committee, which it was a great privilege to sit on. And like her, I would like to thank the committee staff whose professionalism and good humor aided us on that path. As Lord True said, the backdrop to this report and the debate today is the manifesto commitment of the government to introduce a requirement for participation and retirement. We are a self-governing House and this report is a workable and fair way for us to take charge of our own future. On proposing a retirement age of 80, we would allow members to make a significant and meaningful contribution to the work of this House over a good number of years.

But it recognizes that all organizations benefit from the refreshment and new perspectives of new members. That is important. Equally, the way that the report sets out a tapered exit for existing members, a significant number of existing members, it will avoid a cliff edge and the problems that that would cause for the workings of the House and the good work that we know that we do. Secondly, on the issue of participation, I think there is no one in this House this afternoon who thinks that the conferral of a peerage is merely a gilded bauble. It is a commitment to contribute.

That is what our requirements in this report on participation seek to do, but it balances against the very real fact that for many in this House, the very reason that we want to listen to their contributions is the expertise that they bring from their outside professions.

That fact that they have those outside professions and those perspectives and experiences means they can't always be with us. And therefore we have to be very careful, particularly in the case of the crossbenchers, in setting a participation requirement which does not actually exclude the people that we most want to hear from on particular debates and issues where they have expertise that the house needs to hear from. That, to my mind, is extremely important and valuable. We want people who can participate, but we also want people who can recognize that there is a time that their voices are the most important ones that we need to be hearing. My Lords, this is an important report from the house.

It was drawn up with cross-party membership and we came, as the noble Baroness Taylor said, to a unanimous position of agreement. That is important. It is workable and it is fair, and I support it. My fear is that if this house is not seen to be supporting these proposals for whatever reason, it will be seen by those outside this house as self-interest. That will do nothing for the reputation of this house, which I know we all think of and worry about very deeply.

If we do not accept these proposals, then those who know less and care less about this house will shape our future.

01:33:27 - 01:38:32

Helene Hayman

Pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Baroness Parminter, and I won't repeat what she said, except to say how well-chaired we were as a committee and to give my congratulations to the noble Baroness, Baroness Taylor of Bolton, and my thanks also to Judith Brooke and her team who supported us extremely well. I'd also like to give my thanks to my fellow committee members because we did have four members from the official opposition. They didn't all think the same way. We all came with different starting points and with different foci as to how to deal with this issue. I think certainly for myself and for many others, we would have liked broader terms of reference.

We would have been interested in looking at, and I'll come to this later, how people get into this house as well as how people leave it. But we did our best, my Lords. And I do think that we have provided a nuance to the proposals in the manifesto that is respectful of members of this house and that does, as the noble Baroness Lady Taylor said, give people the opportunity, and that's from whenever we decide on this issue till July 2029, to make their own plans for the future. I know the noble Lord, Lord True, talked in dramatic language of expulsion.

Most of us have worked in organizations at some point in our life where our contract came to an end, where there was actually provision for retirement. It didn't strike us that there was some terrible sword of Damocles over our ability to go on ad infinitum to give our wisdom and to take up really precious space on the benches in this house. So I think the language is slightly hysterical because the concept of retirement, though it should be later in this house, I think for good reason, and that it shouldn't be destructive of the knowledge base and the corporate memory that we have. But the concept is really not quite as revolutionary as to say that we've been bushwhacked by the Labour manifesto. So I very much support the report that we've brought together.

And I also support the approach of trying to do this ourselves with the nuances that we have put in, with the transition periods that we have put in. The noble Lord Lord True is very, very optimistic about a one-clause bill on this going through the house and the House of Commons like a dose of salts and making everything perfect. In my long 30-year experience in this house and my short five years experience in the House of Commons, I very much doubt that it would be as simple as that, my Lords. But there are two things that I actually agree with the noble Lord Lord True. One is that we have to be very, very careful about the numbers of the crossbenchers.

And I think we have to preserve that view that 20% of the house should be crossbenchers and look at how the interaction of that with the age limit comes about. And the other thing I think we have to look at and where I agree with him is that the unconstrained prerogative of the Prime Minister to make as many appointments whenever he wants to this house is a dangerous weapon and the wrong place for us to be. It leads to the ratcheting of numbers after every election. We could do that better and I believe we should try and find a way to do that better.

01:38:32 - 01:43:50

Speaker 38

My Lords, I'm grateful to the committee for its report and for the serious and thoughtful way in which it has approached the difficult question of the future size and composition of this house. My right reverend friend the Bishop of Manchester, the convener of the Lords Spiritual, made a written submission to the committee on behalf of these benches and he's unfortunately unable to be in his place today. The Lords Spiritual have long supported reforms that strengthen the effectiveness and credibility of this house while safeguarding its distinctiveness from the other place in its expertise and culture. We therefore welcome the opportunity to consider proposals that seek to create a smaller and more sustainable house. However, I know he would wish that I highlight several concerns, particularly in relation to the recommendation of a mandatory retirement age.

The report itself acknowledges one of the principal concerns raised in evidence, namely the potential loss of experience, expertise, and institutional memory of members who continue to make valuable contributions well beyond the age of 80. One notable example of the expertise on which the house relies is that of senior judges.

I'm not persuaded by the committee's conclusion that because committees in the other place function without senior judges, committees in this House can and therefore should do likewise. We should be cautious about assuming that arrangements appropriate to one House must automatically apply to the other. One of the principal strengths of the House of Lords is that it complements rather than mirrors the House of Commons, drawing on forms of experience and expertise that enrich parliamentary scrutiny, such as independent chairmanship and experience in interpreting the law. The contribution of senior judges to committee work exemplifies that distinction. Their role is not simply a matter of who occupies the chair; it reflects the independence, judgment, and habits of scrutiny acquired through judicial office.

The Ecclesiastical Committee, for example, benefits from the specialist expertise of judicial leadership, and their contribution helps to shape both the character and quality of its deliberations. Indeed, the Ecclesiastical Committee has benefited from senior judicial chairs since its formation in 1919. Our current chair, the noble and learned Baroness Butler-Sloss, offers invaluable expertise regarding the interpretation of church law and the measures passed by General Synod, along with her understanding of church processes and structures. These benches and the committee are, I know, most grateful for her diligent contributions. Introducing a mandatory retirement age within the House may significantly reduce the number of members able to undertake such responsibilities.

Their loss would therefore represent more than a procedural change; it would alter the nature of the scrutiny that such committees are able to provide. More broadly, if a significant cohort of members were required to retire within a relatively short period, we risk creating clusters of departures and arrivals that could alter the balance of expertise. Institutional memory could be lost more rapidly than it could be replenished. It is, of course, worth acknowledging that bishops do retire earlier than any other members of the House, perhaps explaining something of our youthful vigour. Members may have noticed that we have not benefited from a steady turnover of bishops in recent months, but rather my right reverend friends have retired in batches.

Their loss of experience and wisdom is acutely felt on these benches and, I know, across the House. For these reasons, any reform must be introduced gradually and with great care. A phased approach is essential if continuity is to be maintained and the House's scrutiny function safeguarded. Equally, I wonder whether greater attention might first be given to encouraging the retirement of members who rarely participate or attend before measures are introduced that remove highly active and valuable contributors solely on the grounds of age. This report also welcomes the consideration of how new members of this House are appointed.

Do they directly replace the expertise of their retired counterparts? We must be careful in the interpretation of this report not to ring-fence seats on this basis. The House must remain agile to respond to developing policy areas.

So while I welcome the report and the debate it's initiated, I'm not yet convinced that we've fully considered the implications for the functioning of the House, the operation of its committees, or the preservation of the expertise on which Parliament depends.

01:43:50 - 01:49:06

David Blunkett

My Lords, I'd like also to congratulate my noble friend Baroness Taylor for her skill, her good humor, and her patience, not least with me, and my thanks to fellow committee members. I actually found myself agreeing with Lord Strathclyde who follows me. I was quite astonished on those occasions and I've reflected on them since. Either he was wrong or I was right, one of the two. When I joined the committee, I accepted the terms of reference and therefore the remit, and I speak to support to that today.

The manifesto had two commitments in relation to the House of Lords. One was that there would be a rebalancing regionally of members of the Lords across the regions and nations. Well, that went for a Burton very quickly. The second was this ridiculous sentence, which was clearly discriminatory. I'll come to that in a minute.

As my noble friend said in opening this debate, the impact was to create a cliff edge of 257 members going all at once. It was actually a greater number when we started our deliberations. The person who wrote the manifesto pledge clearly didn't understand we didn't have fixed-term parliaments. Briefly we did, but no longer. Perhaps the person reflecting on their social democratic commitments might have understood that discrimination doesn't just apply to gender or sexual orientation or ethnicity or disability.

It does apply to age. And I believe that the manifesto commitment was a proxy for incapacity. And I say to Lord True, if you don't wish to adopt the proposals in this report, we do need to take very seriously and find ways of dealing with that. Things have changed over the years. Aficionados of P. G. Wodehouse will remember Lord Emsworth, the owner and dithering overseer of Blandings Castle.

This benign, endearing, dithering old fool was only 60 in P. G. Wodehouse's recollections. Now, as some of us, as Lord True has described, come towards the age of 80, we like to think that we've got our marbles together. In fact, I'd like to think, perhaps paraphrasing Saint Augustine, I will retire, Lord, but not just yet. Because the advantage of this report provides some certainty. It provides a respect for those who have given their lives and commitment in the House.

It allows the House to function appropriately and properly. And it also avoids us getting in that clash with the House of Commons. Now, those who remember Michael Foot and Enoch Powell scuppering previous massive proposals in relation to this House, or even the demise of the Clegg Bill just 15 years ago, will understand why we should try and avoid that at the plague.

I don't pretend that I'm happy with where we are, or that we've had to make these proposals. I think that we should, however, retain some influence over our own future, our reputation, a bulwark against ill-thought-through constitutional change, against those who haven't a clue what we do or the implications for our constitution, or, by the way, for the operation of the House of Commons, because massive reform of this place requires a complete change in the way the House of Commons operates. Reform and modernization I'm in favor of, yes. Dislocating our constitution, no. So this afternoon, I think we should send a message to ourselves.

Let us get our own act together. Let us make this House work better. Let's put aside the nonsense of discrimination, but let's understand that the House of Commons can deal a blow in time to come against us. It would inevitably mean the complete disruption of their own timetable and other priorities. But you know, we've seen over recent years how even the stupidest suggestion can be adopted and pushed through by people who don't know better.

01:49:06 - 01:53:55

Thomas Galbraith

My Lords, I hugely enjoyed sitting on the committee with Lord Blunkett, and in fact, as he pointed out, many of his views were a revelation to me, and ones with which I wholeheartedly agree. My Lords, I'm going to speak up in favor of older members of this House remaining here. But I'd like to thank and congratulate the noble Baroness Lady Taylor of Bolton for chairing the committee in the way she did and the excellent clerks that we had. And some of you may be wondering how I can square what I've just said about older members of the House with support for this committee report. We had many discussions and we consulted widely in the House.

We came up with a scheme outlined in the report. It has its flaws, but it fulfills what was set out in our terms of reference. However, my Lords, and this is the point, at its heart lies a lacuna. And that lacuna we were unable to bridge, namely, what is the justification for this desire to expel so many members of the House? You can look at the Labour Party's manifesto, much has been made of that, but it provides no explanation either.

So I really hope that when the noble Baroness leader of the House winds up, she might just spend a couple of sentences in answering the question: what problem was the Labour Party trying to solve in its manifesto? Was it the overall size of the House, perhaps? Well, there are many different ways of dealing with the problem of the size of the House. Is it that older members have lost cognitive ability to be able to continue in the House? Then there must be other ways of dealing with that.

So I ask again, what is the government's motivation? What is its objective? It would be very helpful to allow us to know, because otherwise there is this suspicion that some people have mentioned, that what the government wants to do is to remove older members of the House and replace them with new, younger supporters. And that doesn't help us at all on numbers. As the noble Baroness reminds us in paragraph 51, the average age of joining the House is 59, the average age of retiring from the House is 82.

So I do wonder to what extent is there a real problem if those who wish to leave already do so at the age of roughly 82. My Lords, ever since I've been here, I've always been below the average age. And it may surprise some of your Lordships to know that I still am. I've always held the elder members of the House in great admiration. I think of Lord Callaghan, former Prime Minister, who died aged I think about 90 in his 90s.

But in the 1980s, he moved an amendment to a Conservative bill which preserved the right of Great Ormond Street Hospital to still claim its royalties from J.M. Barrie's Peter Pan. He had the authority and the political clout and the will to get it done. Under these proposals, he would be turfed out and we would miss him. I look over at the other side, I see Lord Dubs, I see Lady Andrews, so important. I don't see sadly Lord Reed, but he's an old friend of mine and I'm a great admirer of his.

All of them would be turfed out. Now, of course, none of them need to stay, they can retire voluntarily, which I think is very much the way forward. We lose so much knowledge, experience and wisdom by expelling these peers. And constitutionally, I'm not sure it really stacks up. If we've got to remove peers from this House, then surely we must reform the way new entrants come into this House.

Otherwise, it's just a free-for-all for the government, whatever that government is. My Lords, the committee's report has produced some very useful statistics and commentary on the work of the House, which is extremely useful and revealing. There are some good suggestions that lie within it. But having done the work, I suggest respectfully to the noble Baroness and to the government that they should perhaps think again about what is proposed. We do have a new Prime Minister with his own agenda.

We've plenty of work to be getting on with over the next few years. My advice to the government is park this in the slow lane. There is nothing to be gained from pressing on with it.

01:53:55 - 01:59:27

Narendra Patel

My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde. And I thank the noble Baroness Taylor of Bolton for introducing her report, a sensible report that introduces retirement. And personally speaking, I will do what is recommended in the report when my time comes to fulfill the retirement proposals. But today I don't want to speak about the report itself, but the consequences of this report that will have particularly on the crossbenches. As Professor Meg Russell in her brief submitted to us all said, it will have an uneven effect on different groups and particularly the crossbenches.

With the help of Sam Anderson in the convener's office, I've managed to get some figures to illustrate this. And I'm afraid after the erudite speeches that you've just heard, mine will be a boring lot of figures, hopefully making the important point. I use the figures in the report itself, but realize that they change all the time by new appointments and retirements and occasionally some deaths. So if we look at the figures, the HOLAC appointments, which have been declining, and currently amongst the crossbenches there are 53 HOLAC appointments compared to 101 appointments that are mainly prime ministerial appointments.

And I'll come back to that later on. So the para 33 of the report states that at the end of the session 24-26 there were 776 members of the House in total of which 154 are crossbenchers, close to 20% which the House has agreed ought to be the right proportion of representation of the crossbenchers. So if we now look at the retirees as planned in July 29 all those over 85 and those who might become 85 in the year, there'll be 38 crossbenchers leaving the House of the 135 total that will be leaving. That's 30% of those that leave will be crossbenchers. That will reduce the numbers of crossbenchers to 116.

In 2030 when the 84 year olds should leave, there'll be 43 total leaving of which 13 will be crossbenchers, again 30% of total that will be leaving and will reduce the number of crossbenchers to 103. In 2031 at the age of 83 those leaving, the total leaving will be 56 and of those 56, 17 will be crossbenchers, again 30% of those leaving. And that will reduce the number of after three years the number of crossbenchers remaining to 86 out of 154. The total number of the House will then be 542. That is 16% of the total House.

So the there's already a 4% reduction of crossbenchers. If I now look at the participation briefly, of the figure of 42 of current crossbenchers will come into the category of attendance of less than 20% of which 21 will already have satisfied the retired age group but that still is 21 who will not fulfill the requirements of participation. Therefore the total number of crossbenchers leaving in the three years and I haven't looked beyond that is three years is 89 of 154. Remaining after three years if no more appointments are made the crossbenchers will therefore be 65 in number. That would be 12% of the total of the House of 542.

Now if you look at the appointments, currently there are 53 members of the crossbenchers who were appointed by HOLAC and as I referred Prime Minister appointments and some others which are hereditaries is 101. Since 2014 the Prime Minister appointments have been twice in number compared to HOLAC appointments. The message therefore is clear. Unless this is taken into account the cohort of crossbenchers within three years, not six years or seven years will be reduced to less than half the number that we have now, considerably less. And they will not be HOLAC appointments.

So two things needs to be addressed. The numbers of crossbenchers needs to be appointed starting now if we're going to start even in 2029 of people beginning to leave which will be significant numbers and the numbers appointed by HOLAC needs to change compared to the Prime Minister appointments. I hope that's the point the message is about the figures that needs to be addressed.

01:59:27 - 02:04:42

Sebastian Coe

It's a privilege to have served on the committee whose report we are debating today. I should thank my noble friend Lady Taylor of Bolton for her exemplary introduction, and even more for her remarkable skill in drawing out unanimous conclusion from the committee and the evidence that we heard, mainly from members of this House. I'm sure that skill is innate, but I was regularly reminded of how this may have been honed by her training in the House of Commons whips' office, as so brilliantly portrayed in James Graham's great play, This House. I believe that of those speaking today, I have been a member of your Lordships' House for longest, longer even than the noble Lord Lord Strathclyde, having served nearly 45 years with a six-month sabbatical between the 1999 Act and my appointment as a life peer. I say this not to claim great wisdom or expertise, more the opposite, but to make two points.

First, I've witnessed the evolution of the House during that time, from when one where the expectation was undoubtedly one where irregular participation, bringing in some cases exceptional expertise, was seen as the norm, to more recently, a more professional, political, full-time culture. I think that on balance, that has been a positive development. I've also during my time had periods of relative inactivity myself, whether because of particularly intense outside commitment or because of, for instance, my slow transition from the Social Democrat Party to the Labour benches. I understand the concern that the minimum that minimum participation should not be set too high. I believe the committee's recommendation of 20% of sitting days averaged over two sessions strikes a well-judged balance.

My noble friend the Leader of the House gave a very clear remit to the committee to identify if possible ways whereby its recommendations could be implemented without new primary legislation. The committee had particular regard for this, particularly in proposing sensitive and generous transitionals for the retirement age proposed in the manifesto, which I very much hope will be seen by all members of the House as fair and supportable. I deeply regret that the noble Lord Lord True's opening remarks seemed to be discouraging that, even while describing the report as excellent. The committee's remit did not explicitly refer to the objective of reducing the size of the House, or to be pedantic, the numbers of its members. But the government's manifesto commitment of a retirement age of 80 was quite clearly in the context of reducing numbers, following the undermining of the excellent recommendations of the Burns Committee by first the Johnson government, of which the noble Lord True was a member.

That context is important, as it is central to the point that the proposal makes no judgment about the capacity of people over the age of 80 generally, or specifically members of this House of that age.

I am afraid I disagree with my noble friend Lord Blunkett on this, who I otherwise revere. My noble friend Lady Taylor described the debate in the committee about fixed terms as an alternative or complement to a retirement age. And I would have been delighted if we could have achieved the necessary consensus to make terms the sole or significant test of continuing membership. I very much hope that today's debate, despite Lord True's malign tone-setting, gives my noble friend the Leader of the House the confidence to follow the self-regulatory path she asked the committee to consider. If, however, the support is not there for this, I would fully support primary legislation to implement a retirement age or perhaps term limits to achieve the regular, consistent rotation and refreshing of the House's composition.

02:04:42 - 02:10:01

David Wolfson

It's a pleasure to follow the noble Viscount and it gives me an opportunity to thank him and the other members of the committee for the work which they put in under the obviously skillful chairmanship, if I can use that word, of Baroness Taylor of Bolton. I hope it wasn't particularly malign of the Shadow Leader of the House to refer to me, if I can pick up that word, because I was going to follow to make a couple of legal points and in particular one legal point, which I think is important for the House and perhaps those outside it to bear in mind as to what these proposals will do and importantly what they will not do. And I would suggest that paragraphs 83 to 85 of the report repay careful reading. Because this House is self-regulating and therefore enjoys exclusive cognizance over its own proceedings. But as the committee correctly recognizes, that principle operates within the wider law of the land.

Parliamentary privilege does not enable the House, whether by standing order or resolution, to alter, let alone to abrogate, statutory rights. And that matters here, I would suggest. Existing life peers have under the Life Peerages Act 1958 a statutory entitlement for life to receive a writ of summons and to attend, sit and vote in this House. And as paragraph 84 of the report records, the advice received by the committee from senior officials of the House was clear: neither a standing order nor a resolution can override that statutory entitlement. Indeed, the report says that an attempt to do so would arguably constitute a challenge to the rule of law because the law is the law and a standing order is, with respect, just a standing order.

So we should therefore be clear about the legal effect of what's proposed. For existing members, the proposal is that they should retire at the specified age. Now, that is an expression of opinion of the House. It carries an expectation. It may carry some moral or indeed some political force.

Political groups may support it, they may somehow seek to give effect to it. But it does not, it cannot change the law. It does not extinguish the statutory right of an existing member who might choose for whatever reason not to comply. And indeed the committee itself is candid about that.

Paragraph 85 says that the resolution would not purport to be binding and the implementation would therefore depend upon the cooperation of individual members and party groups. By contrast, the position would be very different for new members. The committee recommends that anyone nominated for a peerage should, before the peerage is conferred, give a written undertaking to retire by the 80th birthday. And of course that then can be enforced under the House's power of sanction under the House of Lords Expulsion and Suspension Act 2015. And that distinction seems to me to be constitutionally important.

For future members, the obligation is one which they accept when they enter the House. The consequences of breach are made clear to them in advance. But for existing members, for everyone sitting here today, Parliament has already conferred the relevant statutory rights for life. And those rights, and they are legal rights, cannot be rewritten or abrogated retrospectively by resolution. Now let me be clear, none of that is an argument for or against retirement at 80.

My remarks are not addressed to that issue at all. My remarks are addressed to an argument for constitutional clarity. Because if the government wants to impose a legally binding requirement for a retirement age on members, the report identifies the route, and that's legislation. That legislation would permit Parliament to identify and to decide the issue expressly. But if we decide to proceed by resolution instead of legislation, we ought to be clear about what we are actually doing.

We are expressing the view of the House and we expect existing members to comply with it, but we are not changing, because we cannot change by way of resolution, those members' current existing legal entitlement to remain members of the House. Now that distinction, I suggest, is not a legal technicality. It is, as the committee itself recognizes, a matter of the rule of law. And whatever view we take of the merits of these paragraphs of the report, the rule of law is not an inconvenience to be worked around. It is the framework within which all of us must operate.

02:10:01 - 02:14:41

Dianne Hayter

My Lords, I strongly welcome the report. I congratulate my noble friend and her colleagues for producing a unanimous, thoughtful, and a forward-looking report, which I hope we can effectively endorse today and in due course adopt its recommendations. Taking on the implementation of a manifesto commitment ourselves is surely the best way to bring about change, not dragged screaming and shouting to the inevitable outcome, but by debate, consensus. I therefore very much regret both the tone and the content of the speech by the official opposition. I would have thought that the noble Lord, Lord True, would have learned from his experience of resisting and resisting the Grocott bill, which would have very gradually ended the hereditary principle, and we probably would never have had to, in his words, expel, in our sense, let go of the hereditaries.

He resisted that in government and then in opposition, and that is a shame. I hope we can do this differently. This is a working, a legislative house. Whatever decisions we take on this today must be centered on what enables our time, the time of peers, our expertise, and our collective wisdom to be best used. It's not a retirement house.

It should not be a thanks for services rendered. It should be as the heading on my list when I came here said, a working peer. And our central role is to share responsibility with the Commons to make laws. I have indeed always worried about being appointed for life, rather than for as long as you can contribute, which is why I welcome the introduction of a participation requirement, though like my noble friend, would quite like term appointments. But I strongly welcome the introduction of a retirement age, partly because we all fade with age, but more importantly, because if we're to do good work here, we need to be continuously refreshed by those more recently in their particular area of work or expertise.

When I arrived 16 years ago, I was very fresh from the consumer and the charity world. But that experience is now 16 years old. So surely it's right that we begin to move over and let those with more up-to-date experience, contacts and knowledge make their contribution to emerging legislation in their areas of expertise. We do not hold in our heads all the experience of the world. We could do this by maximum terms of appointment, as I've said, but the Labour manifesto took the other decision that it should be age and that that was the correct criterion.

And of course, we'll lose some members who we will miss a lot. But I think we'll still be friends with them. But we would be able to welcome a new generation with much to offer. These proposals won't solve the issue of the size of the house, but they do do two things. One is to signal that we recognize the need for a reduction in size and that we have designed a tool to start that process, rather than leaving it to the Commons and the government, who could be rather more draconian.

Secondly, it begins our side of that bargain. We're choosing to slim down and our example should help stay the hand of future Prime Ministers, I hope, whether this or any other government, about how many people they appoint here. The government was elected on a manifesto with a retirement age of 80. We should help that happen. The process is ingenious.

It is staged but clear and predictable. We've all looked to see if our date of retirement, and I'll tell you a secret, I'll be leaving on my birthday, I'm one of those there. There will be a time therefore when I will be the oldest person in the house. I never thought that would be my aspiration, but it is now. I support the report.

Let's do this ourselves. Let's do it willingly, not enforced on us, and let's do it with a bit of humility as well.

02:14:41 - 02:15:22

Speaker 63

My Lords, I thank the committee for their work and their report, and I note of course the limits of their remit. My Lords, I support the principle of a retirement age. As an unelected house, I think there is good reason for us to put in place boundaries where the electorate may decide our fate differently if given a choice. But my Lords, logical thinking forces me to confront reality. I also know the electorate may well not choose any of us to serve given half the chance.

02:15:22 - 02:19:54

Thomas Galbraith

So I think it's really important before we make structural changes that don't result in us becoming an elected chamber, that we are clear what problem needs fixing for us to best serve the public in our appointed state. And I very much echo what my noble friend Lord Strathclyde has asked of the noble baroness the leader, which is that she is clear when she comes to wind up what problem she thinks her proposal is there to address. Because if it is the size of the house, as suggested by the Labour Party manifesto, then a retirement age would be a quick answer. But I think size is a symptom, not the cause of the real problem we must address, which is that this house has become less about service and expertise and is becoming far more politically motivated in our work. And if we are to change that, we must understand and address the part we've all played in causing that to happen.

Now, members of this house have often criticised successive prime ministers for appointing increased numbers of politically aligned peers, but rarely, if ever, acknowledge our own contribution to this ratchet effect. Just because noble lords are not partisan does not make them non-political. And what constitutes political in the eyes of the public often crosses party lines. And this problem reached its nadir after 2016 when this house enthusiastically defied the majority of leave voters in its efforts to prevent Brexit from being implemented and did all it could to dilute legislation to tackle illegal immigration. Now, all that said, that doesn't mean this house doesn't still do good and important work.

And of course, it is not the role of the House of Lords to make life easier for the government of the day, whichever party is in power. But as we have become individually more political in our intent and style, showing the same vices as the Commons without the virtue of being democratically elected, we can't ignore that the case for us continuing in this unelected appointed state is harder to make. As to what's in front of us and how the recommendations stack up, as much as I support the principle of a retirement age, I believe that more importantly, we all have an ongoing duty to question whether we are still doing our best and are still best equipped to remain. And although I can see some support, a minimum participation level for peers, if we want a more expert and less political appointed house, we will need more, not fewer peers, as any credible measure of effectiveness would require them to attend less. My lords, the Labour Party manifesto restated its commitment to, and I'm quoting now, replacing the House of Lords with an alternative second chamber.

But not only do we not know what that might involve, it's a promise we've heard before, and perhaps the noble baroness the leader could give us an update on that when she comes to wind up. What we do know is that Labour when in government has form in attacking the structure of the second chamber without addressing the real problem it has helped to create. And in doing so, has exacerbated this house's greatest weakness of being a political chamber without a democratic mandate.

Expelling the over-80s alongside the hereditary peers won't fix that problem, even with a staggered exit as the committee proposed. My fear is not just that these changes on their own will have little if any impact on declining public trust. More importantly, recent history tells us that the consequence of these changes risks making matters much worse.

02:19:54 - 02:24:19

Ann Taylor

My Lords, I agree that the committee have done a very good job in answering the questions that they were given. The report is thorough, it's persuasive, and I thank Baroness Taylor and her committee for their work. Lady Taylor and I worked together on the Lord Speaker's Committee, and I know how hard she has worked on this whole subject now for many years. Taking the retirement age first, if a retirement age is to be introduced, I agree that 80 is a sensible retirement age for new members. Any older retirement age I think would be extremely difficult to sell to the public.

I also support the proposed transitional arrangements for existing members and the suggestion to begin with a fixed date. Together these eliminate the uncertainty of any proposal tied to election dates, and it avoids too many existing members leaving at the same time. I also think the committee have reached a sensible conclusion on the issue of participation. It's a blunt mechanism, but the reality is that there is no other solution that isn't excessively complex and probably unworkable. I looked at many of them during the time of working with the Lord Speaker's Committee.

However, whilst the report provides good answers to the exam questions in isolation, my view is that the proposals do not solve the underlying problem. The Prime Minister has said that he's in favour of problem-solving rather than point-scoring. I was taught that before making changes you should ask two questions: what is the problem you're trying to fix, and what are the causes of the problem? The Labour Party manifesto in 2024 said the problem was that the House of Lords was too big. And of course there are two important reasons for the present size.

The first reason, and the one that we're discussing today, is that members are appointed for life unless they choose to retire. The proposals in the report would help with this. If implemented, there would be a one-off reduction in the size of the House, and subsequently the numbers leaving will be slightly higher than they otherwise would be. But the second and more important reason for the size of the House is that Prime Ministers are under no constraint about the number of peers they appoint or the party balance of the appointments they make. Whenever there is a change of government, we see a pattern of leapfrogging as Prime Ministers appoint disproportionately to their own party.

The manifesto also said, "We will reform the appointment process." Yet the government has not gone anywhere near this, as far as I'm aware. Consequently, there will be no obstacles to Prime Ministers appointing any number of new peers to fill the space that will be created by the retirement proposals. My Lords, we need a package of measures which will reduce and contain the size of the House, not just for a year or two, but for the longer term. As Baroness Hayman pointed out, and I think Lord Strathclyde agreed, such a package should include a commitment by the leaders of the main parties to exercise restraint in making new appointments and to maintain a fair balance of appointments between parties.

The Leader of the House has often said that the House works best when the two parties are of a similar size. As Lord True pointed out, we are now approaching that position with the gap between the two main parties closing. This is the ideal time for some kind of movement on the question of appointments and a fair balance of appointments between parties. My view also, the package should also include a generous term limit for new appointments. I don't want to rerun the argument of age limits versus term limits, but I do think we could have both.

A retirement age on its own would encourage younger appointments. Surely it can be no part of a reform process that means that we could have members here for 40 years or maybe more.

I find that quite astonishing. To summarize, I'm content with the participation proposal. I'm not in favor of a retirement age on its own or for its own sake, but I can envisage that it could play a valuable part in a more comprehensive package, a wider package to reduce and control the size of the House.

02:24:19 - 02:28:16

Bryn Davies

I've, I am, I've come to listen as much as to contribute and I particularly look forward to contributions from the next three speakers from my side of the House who all, like me, will be leaving on the 8th of July 2029. That will be after nine years service in the House. And given that in broad terms I'm in favor of having a retirement age with a term if longer so that we can appoint older people to the House, I've got no grounds for complaint. I also congratulate the committee on the work they did. They've fulfilled the terms of reference.

And I'm also mindful of my party's manifesto promise that there should be a retirement, that there should be a retirement age. But there's no doubt that what we are proposing, what is proposed, my party's proposed and the committee has put into form, is age discrimination. Now we're not employees, so employment law clearly doesn't apply. But using that as a parallel example, now for there to be a retirement age it has to be for cause. And so I think it's quite reasonable for this debate to touch on the issue: what is the cause for having a retirement age?

Now in terms of size of the House, and I know it was in the manifesto, my experience of the House tells me the size of the House is not a problem. On this if nothing else I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Trefgarne. It clearly is a resource. The size of the House I believe is a resource that can be used productively. What the cause really is, as the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett said, it's a proxy.

And it's a proxy for incapacity. And incapacity doesn't work just with age, as as many noble Lords in this House demonstrate. So I think there is a real problem and in pushing this policy through, it was in the manifesto, but there's also the need to seize the, the public mood that you have to explain we're doing this because, and because it's the manifest, it was in the manifesto, I believe is insufficient. I also agree with the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson of Tredegar, not so much on the basis of his views on ties, but on the self-regulatory nature of this proposal. It, it is a real problem which I think is downplayed in the report and will be downplayed in practice.

Of course, if the party wants me to resign in accordance with the rules, I almost certainly will. But I will suffer an almost irresistible urge if I knew when I get to the 8th of July that in the following session there was going to be an important pensions bill, I would find it very difficult not to push the limit in my particular case. And so I think more thought needs to be given to how that part of legislation of these proposals will be put into practice.

02:28:16 - 02:33:36

Speaker 66

My Lords, like the noble Lord, Lord Davies, I shall, if I'm still around, leave your Lordships' House in July 2029. I shall do so with regret and equanimity, and I assure your Lordships that the few observations that I'm about to make do not spring from self-interest. I pay tribute to the work of the committee. They have faithfully fulfilled their remit. But as others have suggested, was it the right remit?

Of course, your Lordships do have an obligation not to obstruct government legislation which gives effect to a manifesto commitment. But I know of no convention which requires your Lordships' House to take the initiative in implementing the government's manifesto when the government itself has not seen fit to bring forward legislation. I endorse the question put by my noble friend Lord Strathclyde. What is the mischief which these proposals are designed to remedy? It is said that your Lordships' House is too big.

By what yardstick? What harm does the size of the House inflict? What are the practical consequences of the size of the House? The largest number who voted in the three highest attended divisions of the 24-26 session was 523 twice and 512, a number close to but smaller than the number who will remain after the first tranche of these proposals are implemented in July 2029. So it's reasonable to assume from those numbers that there are perhaps 200 members of your Lordships' House who rarely attend except perhaps to fulfill the requirements necessary to maintain their membership.

What harm do they do? I've always believed that if something isn't broke, you shouldn't fix it. I don't believe your Lordships' House is broke, regardless of the number of peers who are eligible to attend its proceedings. But my Lords, not only do I believe that these proposals are unnecessary, I believe they would have unfortunate consequences. There are many members of your Lordships' House who make valuable contributions to our proceedings long after they've reached the age of 80.

Who can doubt that our proceedings would have been the poorer if we had been deprived of the wisdom of the late and very much lamented Lord Mackay of Clashfern after he reached the age of 80? I had the privilege of sitting in cabinet with James where he was listened to with the same respect and attention as he was later as a backbench member of your Lordships' House. Why should we impair the quality of our proceedings by this act of self-harm?

My Lords, the committee's report contains no reference to cost, so I asked the library to do a few calculations. First, we have to make a few assumptions. I hope the ones I've made are reasonable, though one can't of course be certain. Suppose, just suppose, my Lordships, my Lords, that the 200 or so members of your Lordships' House who rarely attend now decide that in order to maintain their membership between now and 2029, they ought to fulfill the participation requirement and attend 20% of the sittings of the House. That of course might impose some strains on the facilities of the House.

And they might decide to speak. We have a generous time limit of five minutes in this debate. Could we in future be allowed to intervene in debates only for a matter of seconds, not just at question time, as we were told earlier today? And the cost? These members would no doubt claim the allowances to which they'd be entitled.

I asked the library to estimate the cost which that might involve. They provided various estimates, the highest of which was £9.8 million, nearly £10 million, my Lords. Is that the best use of taxpayers' money? Has the Chancellor been told? Could this be the straw that breaks the camel's back for the bond markets?

My Lords, we're all familiar with the law of unintended consequences. Do we want to provide an example which may be cited with relish for many years to come? My Lords, these proposals are unnecessary and could lead to consequences which I suggest many of your Lordships would find undesirable. I think they should be rejected.

02:33:36 - 02:39:22

Bruce Grocott

My Lords, I very much associate myself with the people who've already congratulated particularly my noble friend Baroness Taylor of Bolton, who's performed the trick of delivering unanimous support from people who didn't agree with one another on more than one occasion over the 40-odd years that she and I have been around in this House. I should also declare an interest, well, I don't know whether I declare an interest or whether I'm a beneficiary or a victim of this bill, because I too am affected by it and I have to say that from July the 8th, 2029, the House will have to learn how to cope without me. I expect that the nation will remain calm. And I do mention this, my Lords, because much of my view of it is affected by the time I spent as Chief Whip. And I'm certainly not going to name any names, but there were people coming in at very advanced ages who were not fit to come in, whose spouses desperately didn't want them to come in.

The House didn't want them to be here, but as long as they were clinging as they did to the explanation that they'd been appointed here for life to support the government, the Labour government at the time, it was their duty to do so. I think a retirement, I welcome a retirement age as far as I'm concerned. It gives you a date to work to. I do not regard it as expulsion, I've had more than a good innings.

And I also think it's desirable because what does it tell you about the about the composition of this House when I say that by 2034, if everyone in this House now over the age of 75 were to depart, we'd lose 367 people. Or put it another way, 367 people of the 776 current members of the House, virtually half the House is over the age of 75 and lingering around the age of 80. Now, that is not a good population balance. And I think we really ought need to recognize that. And not least, I find a pretty weak argument, I have to say, that somehow or other losing these people will be one step short of a disaster.

We've got precedent. In 1999, 667 peers left this House, or were expelled, would be what the Lord True has said. I hate to say this because it may upset people, 88 went in 2026. The House carried on. As my noble friend Lord Chandos has said, in many ways it improved.

It is not that the institution's bigger than the individual. If we look down the corridor to the Commons, at the last general election, as a result of the last general election, 335 new MPs arrived. In other words, people over half the House is brand new since 2024. And the House is coping well, well, I happen to think it's a lot better than when I was there, but it's doing well and it's functioning properly. So I support the retirement age.

I also support the participation requirement. And I'd only make a very brief point about this, that I do think 20% is quite low. I think it should be higher than that. And I'll make another uncomfortable observation, which is this, that there are broadly two broad-brushed, broadly two groups of people in the House, those who see it as a full-time job and those who don't. And it's a good job those who see it as a full-time job, if they all reverted to working for just 20% of the time, it would not be good for the House.

But the the real problem we've got, and I must make this point and I have to make it brief, there are a group of people in this House who will block every attempt at reform of any sort. They opposed the 1999 Act. They opposed the appointment of Lord Speaker. They opposed the powers of the Lord Speaker. Any change in sitting times they've opposed.

And of course they also opposed my bill, simple little bill to end the hereditary peers' by-elections. Whatever we come up with, there's a block of people in this House who will say, no, we're not going to do it. And that makes consensus very, very difficult indeed. But surely they've learned the lesson, and this is my final remark, they've learned the lesson from the experience with hereditary peers. If you don't deal with obvious absurdities in the operation of the House, i.e. the hereditary peers' by-elections, then sooner or later someone else will come up with something to do it for you.

And there are people sitting in this House, I won't name them and embarrass them, who ferociously opposed every small step and ended up, of course, with the big step of all the hereditaries being expelled on the same day. There's a lesson for that. We do it ourselves or someone else is going to do it for us.

02:39:23 - 02:43:55

David James Hope

At first sight, the retirement section of this report has much to commend it. I welcome the fact that the committee was looking for a solution that would avoid the need for legislation on this issue, very much for the reason that the noble Lord Waldegrave has just been mentioning. It must surely be right for the House itself to decide what to do and how to control this process. I also welcome the decision to identify a notional date for the end of this Parliament in place of the words used in the manifesto commitment. They left the date open to whatever date is chosen for the next election.

For my own part, the element of certainty that it introduces, as I'm in the same position as the noble Lord Waldegrave on this point too, I can now plan ahead as to how I should date my retirement without running the risk that an early election would upset these plans. That said, my Lords, I wonder whether it really was right for the committee to accept that the retirement age has to be set at 80, given the situation we're in just now, without giving greater weight to the effect that this would have on the various party groupings. Many of us on the crossbenches have already reached the age of 80. Of course, the effects of advancing age vary from person to person, and views about what people over 80 can do tend to change the closer one gets to that age. But many of us are still very active in the service of this House.

I was already over 80 when I was elected for the second term to serve as convener of the crossbenches. My Lords, if we have to set a retirement age, and I emphasize the word if, it would surely be better to aim higher and set it at 85. I have no self-interest in making that point as I'm now over that age, but it would give more time for those such as former judges who cannot come here until they have retired to make a meaningful contribution to the work of the House before they must leave. Further, setting the age at 85 instead of 80 would mitigate a very real problem for the crossbenches to which my noble friend Lord Patel has referred. The number of those on our benches who would be facing compulsory retirement by July 2029 under the proposed scheme is 69.

That is getting close to one half of the number of those sitting on the crossbenches referred to in paragraph 33 of the report, which is 154. Setting the age at 85 would reduce that number from 69 to 31, which is more in keeping with what we could cope with, given how slow recruitment is to these benches. As for the participation section, I accept that the most practical solution is to concentrate on attendance. My practice as convener was to write to those who fell below 10% suggesting that it was time for them to retire. Given that we would be setting a threshold and not making a suggestion, 20% would seem more reasonable.

But there is a practical problem that the report does not address. How are the less frequent attenders to keep track of their performance? It would be most unfortunate if a member who had very good reasons for not being able to attend regularly was to fall short by a tiny margin which could easily have been made up if he or she had been given notice that there was a risk of falling short. Something does need to be done to address this problem if we are to proceed with this proposal. I make one further point.

Mention is made in paragraph 97 of setting up an emeritus association for retired members.

This idea is all very well for those who live in London and the South East, for whom keeping in touch will be relatively easy. But further thought does need to be given as to what this would have to offer for people like me who live further afield, given that reimbursement of the cost of travelling from the places where they live will no longer be available when they retire. An emeritus association is a very good idea, but it must be suitable really for everyone.

02:43:55 - 02:48:53

Norman Fowler

My Lords, I was privileged to be a member of the committee. But before I come to the report itself, I want to just focus on a curiosity, which is this, which is why was the select committee set up in the first place? Because the commitment in the Labour manifesto was very clear, which was to remove, to have a retirement age of 80 and for peers to leave at that age. And the government didn't hesitate to bring in the bill to remove the hereditary peers, so why are they hesitating about this? And I think there are two reasons.

First of all, I don't think the people who wrote the manifesto on this subject thought through the implications at all. They just scribbled a few words that sounded good. But secondly, I don't think the government really want to have a bill going through Parliament which could open up a Pandora's box on House of Lords reform. Which is why I believe the leader of the House instead wanted to find a way to bring in a retirement age without legislation. Hence the device of the select committee to let the government off the hook.

And this is why the terms of reference specifically asked us to look at options which would not require primary legislation. The committee's terms of reference were also curious in some other ways. We were not asked to consider whether there should be a retirement age. That there would be a retirement age was a given. The terms of reference did not specify what the objective was we were being asked to achieve.

There was no mention of reducing the number of peers in the House. Yes, we were asked to say what impact our proposals might have on the size and working of the House, but not on whether the impact would be positive or adverse. In other words, the terms of reference meant that we had to skirt round many of the hard issues which would be debated more thoroughly if there were legislation. Nevertheless, within these constraints, the committee did produce, I believe, a thoughtful and comprehensive report. And I have to thank in particular the chair, the noble baroness, Baroness Taylor of Bolton, who steered us to our conclusions skillfully.

And I also want to thank the clerk, Judith Brooke, and her team, who were very patient as we made more demands upon them. Finally, I want to turn to what I regard as a core issue, which is if there is to be a retirement age, how to implement it for existing members. The terms of reference asked us to report on options, and we do. We set up two options: either legislation or a resolution by the House. The legal advice was clear.

Option one, legislation would make retirement mandatory. Without legislation, retirement would not be mandatory. However, a resolution could be passed by the House expressing the view that members should retire no later than the age of 80. But it would not be binding on members. It would instead depend on the cooperation of individual members and on peer pressure.

And there was another factor which prayed on my mind. Would it be right for the House of Lords alone to decide for itself at what age members should be compelled to retire? Should an unelected House, as we are, decide who could and who could not sit in the Lords? Yes, of course, when it comes to transgressions of personal behavior. But otherwise, should we?

Nevertheless, after much discussion, the committee did come to the view that if the primary objective was simply to implement a retirement age, a resolution of the House was the simplest way. But the two options are very clearly set out in the report, and I believe it is now for both the House and the elected government to consider each of them and to evaluate each of them.

02:48:53 - 02:52:41

Maeve Sherlock

My Lords, I too thank my noble friend, Baroness Taylor of Bolton, for introducing this debate, and her and her committee for this impressive report, a model of clarity and brevity. As I have often said, it is an honor and privilege to listen to the depth of expertise in your Lordships' House, sometimes from some of the most venerable peers, as we are witnessing today. Nonetheless, I support the committee's proposals: a retirement age at 80, all members being treated equally, irrespective of expertise or position, and with generous transitional arrangements. This is a genuinely modest proposal, which will bring the profile of this chamber more in line with legislators worldwide and the adult population generally. Quite simply, at an appropriate moment, at a time which is well into retirement in most walks of life, we should make way for the rising generations.

They are entitled to bring their valuable expertise and current experience to the challenges of the time in which we live. Our younger noble Lords on all sides of the House have demonstrated many times that age does not confer superiority. I am inspired in moderation by my noble friend Lord Kinnock, the first Labour leader who I had the honor of working for and who was an inspiration for me as a modernizer. He was once an advocate of total abolition of your Lordships' House. Indeed, he once called noble Lords unelected busybodies, descendants of brigands, muggers, bribers, and gangsters.

Now, in his maturer years, my noble friend, while still advocating for wider constitutional reform, proposes nothing more radical than retirement at 80 for today's noble brigands. I know that there are many exceptionally active octogenarians and nonagenarians in your Lordships' House, many of whom I have long admired and are speaking in this debate today, and who I hope will not consider me presumptuous, being relatively new. But I think we should be honest. Our faculties fade, first the body and then mental capacity. I know that only too well, my Lords.

At the age of 71, the average age I think I heard earlier, this will be my last contribution to debate here for a couple of months because I am shortly having a knee replacement operation. I will miss you all, but I hasten to add that I look forward to resuming fully and I am still all there up top.

Regarding the other matter to note, participation, measurement is a difficult task. Valuable unseen work versus seen work, quality v quantity, popping in or popping up. I bow to the committee's considered judgment, attendance of 20% of sitting days. I agree more emphasis needs to be made prior to appointment on the nature of our work, with a higher contribution bar made clear from the outset. I wholeheartedly support these proposals and look forward to the response from my noble friend the leader, and in the hope that your Lordships can reach consensus in a resolution of the House on this matter.

02:52:41 - 02:58:09

Joan Bakewell

Lords, I'm very grateful to even be allowed to speak in this debate. I'm one of the recent life peerages, but mine was granted when I am already 80, and I would have thought it was surprising that the current government would agree to my nomination. However, and of course I should say here that I'm very pleased to follow my old friend Baroness Hunter. In the debate on the Hereditary Peers Act, I asked the government not just to remove the hereditary peers, but also to carry out some other manifesto commitments, such as retirement and participation. I was therefore very pleased to hear the leader of the House in that debate proposing a committee to consider these matters, thus allowing me not to press my amendment on that point.

I congratulate, as others have done, Baroness Taylor and the committee for writing this report, which I totally support. The phased retirement starting in 2029 and the 20% participation requirement seem to me eminently sensible. When this matter is put to a vote, I will certainly vote in favor. But I do want to refer to two other matters which I alluded to in that earlier debate, namely removal of peers for misconduct and the disturbing idea that peerages are apparently sometimes given to large donors to political parties. In the House of Commons, there is a mechanism for removing members for misconduct.

In the House of Lords, it is more complicated. Conviction of a crime and receiving a jail sentence of more than 12 months does lead to expulsion. But breaking the code of conduct normally only leads to suspension for a number of months. In my opinion, this is not sufficient and therefore brings this House into disrepute.

In the King's Speech, the Government announced that they would introduce a bill to remove peerages from disgraced peers. I would like to suggest to the Leader of the House that she and the Prime Minister should consider rather a bill to remove membership of this House from any member who has misbehaved. The title in itself no longer carries an entitlement to sit in this House. Look at all the hereditary peers and life peers who've retired. So for the integrity of this House, there should be, if necessary, legislation to remove the right to sit in this House.

Removal of titles could lead to unnecessary discussion of holders of peerages who are no longer members of this House. It could only be a gesture. In the Labour Party manifesto, it says Labour will ensure all peers meet the high standards the public expect of them and strengthen the circumstances in which disgraced members can be removed. It seems to me that this manifesto commitment could be fulfilled by the removal of the right to sit in this House rather than the removal of the title. The other matter which has always concerned me is the apparent granting of a peerage to a donor of a large sum of money to a political party.

We will all have noticed that Reform have specifically said that the two recent large donors would not be given peerages if Reform is ever in government. I think it is regrettable that they felt it necessary to state that and shows sadly that the giving of peerages to party political donors has in some sense become normalized. I hope all political parties could somehow agree to make it impossible for the impression ever to be created that membership of this House can be given in return for large donations. So my Lords, this report only deals with retirement and participation but should certainly be agreed. It is another step in the continuing reform of this House of which I am so grateful and honored still to be a member.

02:58:09 - 03:03:09

Speaker 72

My Lords, my only caveat on what I think is an excellently written and structured report is that perhaps it would have benefited from asking the people their view. I have done. Over many years, I asked the people when I was an elected representative their views on many issues. And there was a rather strong view in relation to the House of Lords. The overwhelming majority repeatedly felt it should be elected.

There was a bigger view on that than any other single issue I ever polled on. There were people who had a different view. There was a group who felt that would be outrageous, we should simply be abolished. That was a consistent but small minority. And there was a small subsection who very graphically were much more in favor of reverting back to the systems used when Henry VIII lived here in terms of his methodology for reducing numbers of the House.

The people's view on this is rather clear and clearly rather different to the views of this House. The views of this House have been consistent, not just over the years, but over the centuries. When the Great Reform Act was being debated here, the arguments that were put most frequently against it were about the unintended consequences and the effect on the markets. The then Duke of Wellington had a strong opinion. He argued against, quote, because this would lead to the slippery slope towards total democracy.

Something which hasn't quite happened in relation to the House of Lords, but has elsewhere. So when universal suffrage was brought in and it was debated here, then instability, confusion, unintended consequences and problems in the markets were again repeatedly cited, though one politician, Asquith, did go a little further because Asquith suggested that the real reason for opposing it was because women didn't really want the vote. When the age was reduced, voting age from 21 to 18, the House of Lords had a lot to say about it. It would be legally messy, legally confusing, was one of the arguments that was put strongly, along with the unintended consequences, the impact on the markets, the confusion that would then prevail. So there has been a consistency.

Every time there's been any move towards a change in the system, the House of Lords has come up with the same set of arguments and in a way is doing so again. I have a one slight caveat to that though, because I'm in favor, having spent nearly seven years in, I can perhaps take a long-term view on this place, that it would be better if it was elected. So I propose to Sir Keir Starmer, I put the same proposal to the new Prime Minister, that we should move immediately to elections. We should elect 40% at the next general election, 40% at the election after that, and there should be a commission to determine the separation of powers and the other 20% in the interim, with a much reduced figure of 300 peers. So should Lord True get anywhere with his proposals, that would be a huge boost to my proposal.

The Commons would, I'm sure, rally behind it and I'd have the opportunity to put it to the vote. If we compromise with the more traditional approach that's put forward in this report, then it will be incremental change. But the people out there, I put it to the House, wish to see significant change. If we lag too far behind them, we'll wake up one day and someone will have got rid of us.

03:03:09 - 03:08:13

John Redwood

Well, well, my Lords, I've always believed in the supremacy of the House of Commons and I've therefore always favored an unelected upper house. And I've always thought it right that this House should concentrate on two things: it should concentrate on amending and improving legislation which has been initiated by the government, and that in cases where many peers feel that the government is going in the wrong direction, it can ask the government to think again, but it is not here to prevent the government from governing.

And I think it's in that context we look at the membership of this upper house, because as I understand it, that is still the view of His Majesty's government. I see nothing magic in the year of your 80th birthday. We know in this house that a number of people well over the age of 80 are very acute, are extremely well informed, and they help our debates. And we know all too often in our local communities that there are all too many people under the age of 80 who become enfeebled or disabled and would not be able to carry out their normal duties. And that will still be the case for a, I hope, a very few minority in this house, and that will still need to be handled in a sensitive way by friends, by family, by colleagues, advising the person to take advantage of the retirement provisions, or if necessary, the whips being involved.

But we should also remember that the grant of the peerage comes from His Majesty the King. And all those of us who've been through the ceremony will remember that it is the words of the crown investing the peerage in the individual. And the words are particularly significant because it doesn't just invest a title, a bauble, it invests the right to have a vote and a voice in the parliament of the United Kingdom in the democratic context I've just described. And so what this report says we can do is that by a simple resolution of this house, we can undermine the will of the sovereign on the recommendation quite often of the Prime Minister, that these people so appointed have the right all the time they wish to do so to come to this chamber. Now, I think there are also big handling problems, some of them have been well brought out in the debate so far, but let me give another case where there can be issues for the parties.

And that is that a party may have appointed someone who is good and doing a good job as a minister or a shadow minister or a spokesman, or the house may have appointed them as chairman of a committee. And I think it'd be much better if there does have to be an imposed retirement age to say that they would not have to retire until the end of the parliament in which they became 80, so that there wasn't any unnecessary interruption in their work and their abilities. One way of implementing part of the Labour manifesto would be to say that as from tomorrow, no new peer will be appointed without expressly saying that the right to a place in the parliament is limited to age 80 and they would have to retire at the end of that date. And that would meet the requirement of the manifesto without having the disruptive impact that we're seeing through these proposals. And I do hope the government and the colleagues will think again, because I don't think this is going to have a happy outcome.

I think it does disrupt the talent and the expertise in the house. And one of the things that has impressed me when I came here from another place slightly skeptical about self-regulating houses is to see that on this big issue of how many people participate, we nearly always get about the right number for a big debate and the right number to cross-examine ministers without a whole queue of others outside who can't even get a seat in the place. And so self-regulation of numbers seems to work. Indeed, I think there are occasions when in this very chamber we're considering the detail of legislation when despite the large numbers, we're still a bit short of backbench participation in those debates.

So I don't really see the desperate need to reduce the numbers. But my final simple thought is if the government still does think there are too many and would like even fewer participating, then the obvious thing to do is to just stop choosing peers for a little while because given our natural wastage from tragic death and from voluntary retirement, you can slim it quite quickly.

03:08:13 - 03:12:33

Jeff Rooker

My Lords, the precision and clarity and the delivery of this report shows what a class act is my noble friend Baroness Taylor of Bolton. When I do Learn with the Lords programs, I explain to the students that every decision in Parliament, the elected House has the last word. There might be a delay, but they have the last word. We are nothing more than a large subcommittee of the House of Commons with the authority and power to ask them to think again and again and maybe again, but not after that. That's the reality of our status, which is why I don't support an election for this place.

I want the power to remain with the elected House as they have today, the last word. I am covered by my noble friend Lord Grocott by this off on July 2029. I'll be 88. What grounds have I got to complain? I mean, just think about it.

So I don't complain. There's a precision to that and I think it's a benefit to the whole House. I would like my vote back though when I go. I really would like my vote back and there's no reason why peers who retire shouldn't have their vote returned. And it's always been a disgrace and I think that's the one thing I might want to push for when duty arrives.

And on the manifesto, manifestos are important, the public never read them. And this one was a fraud on the tax. Freezing tax allowances is a tax increase. That's the reality. The manifesto was broken the day the Chancellor moved to freeze the tax allowances.

So it's important to take it as a guide for what we want to be able to do. So I actually supported the process of 80. I think the solution and the transition that's come up through the committee is to be commended. But what we mustn't do in my view is add any bells and whistles. Under no circumstances should we attempt to legislate because it would involve the House of Commons and they will have a different view about our structures than we have.

And I think that would be wrong because it's based on ignorance. My ignorance was massive in the other place before I came here. And it was only when I became a minister I discovered how flexible this place was and I wish I'd known when we were in opposition how flexible it was. I'd have had a lot of questions pushed down to my noble colleagues that we couldn't get dealt with in the Commons. So there's a reality there.

But it is important that I think we deal with this and own the change. And I freely admit it's a couple of changes in terms of the transition, retirement and performance if you like, attendance. But I realize over the years to come other changes will flow from that. There will be a constant drip of change. We all want to do more, I fully accept that.

But in this case we should stick to exactly what the report covers and not try and add on to it and give others the chance to write our rules for us. So I don't have any problem with this at all. I look forward to my noble friend's response to the debate and I look forward to a time...

So I don't have any problem with this at all. I look forward to my noble friend's response to the debate and I look forward to a timetable about when we might get some resolutions. I have a mental note that it's maybe early next year we'll have some resolutions to put into practice. Quite clearly, we've got a division between us. I mean, we've, you know, I freely admit that.

But I just hope there's a majority consensus to protect the well-being of the House from legislation and to actually support this unanimous report put together by a cross-party group of people who all disagreed to start with.

03:12:33 - 03:17:36

Lord Hawkhurst

My Lords, it does feel strange to be addressing your Lordships' House this afternoon on the question of reform of the membership of the House of Lords whilst not being directly in the crosshairs of the process as has occurred on every other previous occasion. But I have to tell your Lordships that when I re-entered this House as Lord Hawkhurst after a few weeks in exile, I expected to be overwhelmed by a feeling of legitimacy by virtue of my shiny new life peerage in comparison with my rather aged and tattered viscountcy, which had served me so well for 38 years or so. But my Lords, I was, I was disappointed. But referring to the remarks of the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, his wisdom, whose speech I very much enjoyed, he referred to P.G. Wodehouse. I had hoped to take the title of Lord Emsworth, but as we all know, that really should be reserved for an Earl, so I was disappointed on, on that front again.

But my Lords, turning to the business of the day, the committee has done a very thorough job, I would say, in considering these intractable issues and it's really no surprise at all that there is a considerable diversity of opinion around the House. But I think no one could argue that the committee hadn't discharged its function, hadn't approached this issue in an extraordinarily thorough way and hadn't come up with a solution that in its mind was designed to avoid the, the cliff edge that the noble Baroness referred to. I was also very amused to hear the different views about election manifesto pledges that have come through and I rather find myself, as ever, in the same field as Lord Rooker to treat them merely as guidance because there were obviously other commitments in the manifesto around a more substantially reformed House about which we're not hearing too much. So all election manifesto commitments are equal, but I suspect, my Lords, that some are more equal than others. But my Lords, this issue of retirement and it, it is strange when we know that there are peers over the age of 80 who make such fantastic contributions to your Lordships' House and we've heard from Lord Hope and Lord Dubs has been referred to, of course, and indeed my noble friend Lord Young of Cookham, who I have to tell your Lordships' House is utterly unchanged in every way and in capacity since he had the misfortune of becoming my boss as Secretary of State for Transport now nearly a third of a century ago.

So, my Lords, I think what we're really talking about here, we're talking in code, what we're really talking about is capacity. And we have made progress on that issue, and I feel more can be done by party managers and the convener, and I hope will. And I would suggest that the changes that have been made, the allowance of voluntary retirement has been a positive development, and perhaps something more of an expectation that we should be self-regulating in the great House of Lords tradition in terms of our own retirement has been, perhaps, is something of a solution. But, my Lords, whatever the House decides, I feel that we are tilting at the wrong windmill with this report, and the primary challenge to the credibility and reputation and therefore the authority of this House is not, my Lords, one around age and retirement, but I think it has to do with the executive's ability to control the numbers and make-up of this House. And we now have a situation where entry to this House is entirely at the disposal of the Prime Minister's patronage with no limits on numbers.

The executive of the day can to a large extent choose the new members of one of the juries it faces, and if it finds itself losing the argument, then it can just add some more. So, my Lords, that method of controlling the composition of your Lordships' House is ridiculous and is no more defensible, I would suggest, than the situation that we had in the pre-1999 House. So, my Lords, that should be the focus and much less on retirement. We need to control the numbers of people coming into this House. I would suggest whatever the merits, and they're very considerable, of people arriving in the House, we go through a period of indigestion, and that doesn't help us do our job.

03:17:36 - 03:21:26

Speaker 75

My Lords, of those who have already spoken, more than half welcome this report, as do I. And I really had hoped that all that remained would be to vote in favour and hope that the report was fully accepted by the House and then implemented as soon as possible. That said, my Lords, it's unlikely that any process would be entirely simple. Some will, as we've heard, continue to object to the idea of a retirement age and argue for life membership. Others will query the suggested retirement age together with perhaps additional creative ideas on how best to measure participation.

But, my Lords, what we have here is a workable, sensible, well-thought-through plan that will contribute to the reform of the House. We should seize it with both hands as a step towards much-needed further regulation of appointments to the House of Lords. And in so doing, my Lords, we hope to begin to establish a leaner culture which will become an established convention unto which all involved in the recruitment process and the working of the House will respect. A House that is certainly smaller and one in which all members are committed to contributing to the work of the Lords. My Lords, the non-legislative incremental changes put forward in this report allow the House to exercise its much-valued self-regulation.

However, the fundamental issue, as most have touched on, is that the recommendations are based on the assumption that the Prime Minister of the day will exercise restraint in the appointment of new peers and cooperate in maintaining numbers below perhaps 650. Should this not happen in the coming years, it is likely that the government will enforce stringent legislative changes.

These changes would not necessarily, my Lords, take into account dangers such as creating a cliff edge or of taking account of party balance. In seeking balance of numbers between the two major parties, there may need in the future to be some constructive cooperation, not to say courage, at least on the part of the whips who will have to persuade some minimally contributing peers to retire earlier than the rules require. My Lords, as we have heard, the crossbenchers will be disproportionately affected by retirement rules, having an older age profile than other groups and due to rather heavy losses of hereditary peers. This diminution of what must be agreed and considered to be a valuable voice in the Lords is further exacerbated by the extremely spare recruitment rate of independent peers, approximately two per annum in recent years. Given that the HOLAC appointment system ensures an inflow of experts in fields often far from politics and the growing need for expertise in technology areas that have not as yet been established, there is a case to be made for an increase in nominations to the crossbenches.

My Lords, this report represents a genuine step forward and it should be embraced so that arrangements for leaving can be matched by those addressing recruitment to the House of Lords.

03:21:26 - 03:25:46

James Douglas-Hamilton

My Lords, it's customary to congratulate the chairman of the committee, the noble lady Lady Taylor, on this report, but I'm afraid I can't do that because it's completely incoherent. And let me explain why. I'm going to be 85 at the end of this year and I will be asked under the terms of this report to retire from the House in 29, 2029. That is the date of the next election. So are we really saying that the priority of the next government, of whatever color it is, is going to be to produce statutory legislation to enforce these recommendations?

I think I will probably have gone by 2029. But supposing I completely lose my marbles and become completely unhinged, I might decide to stay on. And who can stop me? Without primary legislation, there's no way that I can be prevented from serving out my time until I actually die. So this doesn't make any sense whatsoever.

My noble friend Lord True, when he spoke in this debate, said, "What is the question that we're trying to answer?" I believe the question we're trying to answer is that your Lordships' House is too big. There are too many of us and it doesn't look at all good. We know that the people who do the work very rarely exceed 500. But the fact is that it looks as if there are nearly 800 members of this House and that is too many.

I wrote a recommendation to the committee, which was never addressed at all as far as I can make out, which actually suggested we should have internal elections. So each party group in your Lordships' House would be told to decide on how many should stay in your Lordships' House. So if you decided to reduce, you could do more than one of these elections, so your first slice might be 10% and you elect out of the House the 10% of people that you don't want.

And who would they be? They would be the people who had lost their marbles, they would be who might be of any age. Age is not not a determinant of whether you've lost your marbles or not. There's a lot of people younger than that who actually are completely incoherent and should be got rid of. There are people who don't come to this House and therefore we could get rid of all the people who aren't contributing and keep the people who are contributing to the holding the government to account and revising legislation, which is the purpose of this House.

When I raised the question of internal elections in a previous debate, the noble Lord, Lord Cromwell, got up and said he thought elections were a terrible idea. He said people briefed against each other. I spoke to him afterwards and I said, "How many elections have you, Lord Cromwell, actually participated in?" He said, "One." My Lords, I've contributed as a candidate in six parliamentary elections and one parliamentary by-election.

A number of those elections have been against Liberal Democrat opponents and I say that they really have a lot to teach all of us about briefing against people in elections. And although democracy is imperfect, it is not a reason for us to reject it. We should elect the people out of this House that we don't want and that is a much better way forward. It will reduce the numbers. This leaves us with a problem of those who are independents and so forth and I think that they should group together and they should take the the percentage of cut that they need as well.

But that's something the committee could decide on. There's a slight problem there, but otherwise we would see the same reductions across all party groupings in the House and we would get rid of the people that we really don't want and don't contribute to the workings of this House.

03:25:46 - 03:30:43

Alfred Dubs

My Lords, I fully support this report and I congratulate my noble friend Baroness Taylor on having produced it and on having got a unanimous report, even if some of the voices are now dissenting from it. I'm also relieved that I no longer have to go on the media and always face the question of why am I the token oldie. I can now say I won't be much longer and the House will have decided. But I do think it makes sense to have a to have a retirement age. I suppose I'm the oldest person who's spoken so far.

I may in fact be the oldest person who's going to speak altogether, so I take that as a as a as a claim as to why I no longer I no longer want to be the token oldie in the future. My Lords, I'm glad to have a fixed date of 8th of July 2019. It's a contrast, those of us that have been in the Commons and lost our seats in the Commons will say, well, that comes very suddenly. We don't know it's going to happen till about the early hours of polling day and then out we are. So I think it's good to have the certainty and it means that we can prepare ourselves mentally for not being here.

One benefit which has already been referred to is that we shall now be able to vote in general elections. I understand that is the case, maybe my noble friend will confirm that. I once got a private member's bill through this House to give effect to our being able to vote in general elections and it was objected by objected to when it got to the Commons by an anonymous voice, I think a Lib Dem, but it was by an anonymous voice anyway, which I thought was pretty outrageous. So so now I'll be able to vote and I hope the timing of of my leaving here will be such that I can vote in in in the next election.

By the way, I was looking at the leaflet about the arrangements for retired members. And I think they're very generous, being able to sit, sit below the throne, being able to use the dining rooms and so on. In fact, they're so generous, I wonder whether there won't be too many people swamping the, swamping the arrangements. My Lords, I've always felt it's a privilege to be in this House. I think it's an honour and I, I, I feel, I feel that this is something we, we should acknowledge.

So I'm not happy that there are several hundred people here, the ones who are not active, who use the title and who use the perks of being in this House without in fact making any contribution. I think that is wrong in principle and that's why I don't like the idea that's been put forward that, oh well, there are 550 active members, so the others don't cause any problem. I think they do cause a problem and I, I think they're abusing the privilege of being here and I, I don't think they, I don't think they should be here. Now, the committee wasn't asked, and I understand why, wasn't asked to make, to consider issues that stem from the recommendations. And I'm grateful to Professor Meg Russell of University College London for a very helpful briefing which some of us had.

Yes, I think there's widespread agreement the House is too large. I've already referred to that. But there seems to be no, not a sufficiently great advantage in getting rid of the 80-pluses if they're quickly replaced by a stream of people keeping the numbers very high. I think there has to be some more radical approach to this by the way in which Prime Ministers make, make their appointments. And I think we need to look again at the basis of appointment to this House, which should be considered in parallel with the 80-plus arrangements that we're talking, talking about now.

Noble Lord Hamilton talked about individual party groups making their own decision and voting. I once also floated that idea and I was told it wasn't a good idea because it resembled a circular firing squad and it would cause too much, too much dissent in, in each of the groups. Well, I don't know about that, but it, it was certainly an interesting idea. My Lords, I, I still look at the way in which people are appointed and I'm afraid any system of appointing will be seen by outsiders to be flawed. May not be flawed, it may be totally above board, but it will be seen to be flawed.

And that's why I share the view of Noble Lord Mann and others that I think an elected second chamber has to be an option, provided we retain the primacy of the Commons. And then we can do the job we do, which is to scrutinise what the work that the Commons do and possibly even make some interesting counter-suggestions. So I think an elected second chamber is inevitable sooner or later. We do need a second chamber. I don't believe in a unicameral system, but I believe that we could provide better scrutiny, more sound-based scrutiny and better safeguards for the individual, individual citizens.

Therefore, I would like us to move in that democratic election, but in the meantime, I think we should adopt these proposals.

03:30:43 - 03:35:57

Speaker 77

My Lords, I have two interests to declare. The first is I'm remarkably young. I've followed the oldest member of the House speaking just now, and I'm probably one of the youngest. And I like that. Here I feel so youthful.

It is even more effective than some type of anti-ageing moisturiser. And when I leave this chamber, I feel immediately very old. My children think I'm a hundred, the techies I work with think I'm a dinosaur. So I would hate to think that there's going to be a cut-off point at the top, a glass ceiling to my age, because I like the youthfulness that I can exhibit when I'm in this wonderful chamber. And the second point I'd mention is that this place makes me feel foolish.

I look around this chamber and I hear the extraordinary wisdom of my colleagues, my noble friends, the noble Lords. And I realise that I am in the presence of greatness. So I feel young and foolish. These are emotions I want to maintain. And I think these measures sadly will change that for the worse.

Because this is a Witan, a council of elders. The whole point is to have wisdom, which is a combination of knowledge and experience.

And so if you set a time limit on that, you immediately derogate the principle. And when I look around this chamber and I think of the individuals here, the idea that they should retire at 80 is bizarre, if not absurd, if not slightly offensive. I've just followed one of the most brilliant speeches, one of the most inspiring individuals of our country, who's 93 years old. I am having the good fortune to speak at the memorial service of Viscount Bridgeman, who died recently at 95, who until this year bicycled to the House of Lords every day, and only couldn't attend for a short period because he'd suffered an accident on his trampoline. The idea that there is some type of arbitrary age is also bizarre when you think that by the time this legislation or this act takes force, seven and a half percent of the population of this country will be over the age of 80.

And whilst I don't believe in DEI, I know that the government benches do, in fact they hold it as one of the core tenets of their existence. So how can they bring into force an act that deliberately discriminates against people who are over the age of 80, when they're going to represent one in 15 people? And I also point out that Baroness Hayman mentioned, you know, in most jobs you have a contract. Well, our contract is for life. And I think it's important that we remember that duty.

I think it's also important to point out that in reality, in most businesses now, and in fact we've recently changed the law to reduce the enforcement of retirement ages. So these policies go exactly against all the policies that the government themselves think are right. And if you think of the future, and this is important to think of the future, anyone born after the age of 2005, I'm told by my scientific friends, they may not die. The country's aging, and we're going to find ourselves in a bizarre situation where we set an arbitrary limit of 80 when the whole population itself's average age could be over that point in the next hundred years. I also find the report, and I have the greatest of respect for Baroness Taylor, Baroness Palmerston and so on who contributed to this report, seems to be one of those situations where it's trying to find a map to a location that they've been preset, rather than actually analyzing whether these called reforms benefit this house.

The word reform has been used many times by my colleagues, reform, reform, and not in the sense of congratulating significant donors, but in the sense of making something better. But no one has yet been able to point out to me how these reforms make this house better. An arbitrary retirement age of 80 would immediately preclude a large number of people who participated in this debate. So why should we want to remove those people, and how would their removal improve the work of our scrutiny and oversight of legislative and government action? No one has told me that yet.

And I think we have to be very careful when we suggest that we somehow have to react to this move because it is popular. This isn't my policy, it is a Labour government policy. It is entirely performative so that they can say that they have reformed the House of Lords when they've done exactly the opposite. And if I may follow in the footsteps of my noble leader, Lord True, for us not to take this through legislation, I think would be a gross dereliction of our duties. It shouldn't be for this house to decide who sits in it, it should be for Parliament, and we should have a fight about it, if nothing else to embarrass the government about their performative politics in the first place.

And my second interest is my noble kinsman, my father-in-law, Lord Hamilton of Epsom, who this measure, and I said this as a declared interest, will expel from the house, which means he'll be at home full-time.

And I think it behooves my family to make a plea to keep him here safe and sound where he can, as we've just heard, although I'm not entirely sure whether it was the electrifying speech I was hoping for, Lord Hamilton, but where we've just heard he is continuing to make a significant contribution even though he's passed the age of 85 or so soon will. And that, I'm afraid, is why I object to this committee report.

03:35:57 - 03:38:36

Ilora Finlay

In previous debates on the future of this House, the phrase form should follow function has been used on many an occasion. In Baroness Taylor's clear introduction, she stressed the committee's remit in that it was only allowed to deal with a small segment of the role and makeup of the Lords, but by ignoring input, the proposals cannot ensure long-term expertise to undertake the fundamental functions that we have of scrutiny and holding the government of the day to account. My Lords, I was in the first cohort of the 15 so-called people's peers selected by the Appointments Commission. There are only six of us left now, eight died and one retired. But the indomitable Countess of Mar was one of the female hereditary peers selected to remain in her time and was an exemplar in how to conduct effective scrutiny, as well as a mentor to several of us and a guardian extraordinaire of the rules and conventions of the House.

She retired at 80 and is still missed. Now with the hereditary principle gone, prime ministerial patronage is supreme, able to drive input of peers with few breaks on the process. Surely entry and exit must be considered and balanced. Our function requires expertise in the widest range of topics, a breadth that requires carefully vetted appointments to the crossbenches. Yet as we've heard, it will be the crossbenches that will lose the greatest number of peers in the plan laid out in the report.

The Professor Meg Russell's briefing has already been referred to, and my noble friend Lord Patel explained superbly the mathematics involved. The independent House of Lords Appointment Commission must be put on a statutory footing and urgently allowed to appoint if any of this goes forwards. To borrow a phrase from my noble friend Lord Sedwill used on the Today programme today, the question for each of us is, what can I do for my country? The report recognizes the need for leave of absence for those in major roles at home and abroad, but they have a duty to come back to share their in-depth knowledge or to leave. As the noble Lord Lord Rooker said, will the emeritus peers regain the vote?

And as the noble Lord Lord Blunkett pointed out so clearly, one aspect glossed over in the report...

03:38:36 - 03:38:47

Baroness Taylor

If I can just interrupt, it might be helpful to the House, there's a retirement booklet that I arranged to be published and it clearly states in that that when members leave this House, they regain their vote. That might be helpful.

03:38:47 - 03:40:44

Ilora Finlay

I'm really help, that's most helpful and I apologize for not having read that properly. It was raised earlier in the week as well. Thank you for the clarification. One aspect that glossed over is that some become less able to contribute well before the age of 80. Infirmity is not a preserve of older people.

There was no reference in the report to an occupational health service to which those who appear to have dwindling faculties but no insight or other problems could be referred for in-depth assessment, and some of us have been seeking that for some time.

Standard appraisal processes wouldn't work effectively because those who attend rarely would not be adequately known to colleagues and staff, but the staff here know only too well who should be seen by an occupational health service. As for wider reform, no one should think that the widely varied and independent crossbench peers could be elected. They couldn't be elected if they don't have a funding or the know-how or the support to run an electoral campaign, and that lack will exclude many. This report is sensible as far as it goes, but it won't solve all the difficulties of infirmity or simply being out of touch. Unless prime ministerial patronage is curbed or ceases, until HOLAC is the route through which all potential peers are assessed, and until we recognize that younger appointees will be in the House of Lords for decades and they may also fail, our functions may not be enhanced.

But this thoughtful report that Baroness Taylor has presented very well is one that we should heed. The danger is it could be consigned to the shelves unless we're brave enough to embrace it and end prime ministerial patronage as it stands today.

03:40:44 - 03:45:55

Speaker 79

My Lords, I've been increasingly concerned over the years about the preoccupation with numbers. It seems to me that this is putting the cart before the horse. What we should be looking at is: does the House of Lords function, what is its function, does it function as well as it should, and then you base the numbers on your assessment of that particular position. So I believe that getting rid of so many peers, particularly the crossbenchers, is going to be a mistake because I think that it will reduce the ability of the House of Lords to function as well as it does, particularly with its forensic examination of the committee stages and subsequent stages of bills, and in the work of the select committees. Those select committees produce reports which are revered way beyond this House, and I believe that they have an important role in helping to guide policy by the government or to throw a spotlight on issues which have been neglected by governments.

And I believe that the way we are now going forward to reduce the numbers is going to affect the effectiveness with which this House performs. And let us remember also that when it comes to considering bills in their detail, the House of Commons has long since given up any pretension of looking at bills in any detail. When I was a young MP, God knows how many years ago now, it was an important part. But over the years that has diminished and diminished, and I suspect that the newer intake of MPs don't even realize that that was an important function and in my view should still be an important function. So, my Lords, as I say, I am concerned, particularly about the impact on the crossbenchers, which has already been alluded to.

And I am very unhappy, and it was alluded to also by Baroness De Souza, that only a measly two peers are appointed each year. And I would like to hear from the leader: is this going to change? Because to me it is extremely important that this is revised. Indeed, I would go further: I would like that commission to be made statutory and given proper powers. But that is perhaps going wider than we should at this point.

Let me turn for a moment to having an age limit. I remember as a young woman I was told, "Oh, you're much too young to do that, you haven't got the experience, no, no, no."

Before you can say knife, you're too old. So I am not happy with any kind of limit. I fully agree that we need to deal with the relatively few numbers who are incapable. But it certainly doesn't deal with the pre-80s who may be functioning, who may attend the relative easy amount of 20%, but still contribute pretty little. And they will have a free rein, whereas many of those, and I confess I'm well over 80, so I'm pretty soon for the chop if it goes ahead, but there are so many who give of their wisdom and experience and knowledge, and I would be very loath to see that go.

So you will not be surprised, my Lords, to learn that I am opposed to the suggestion that we should help ourselves by a resolution. And I also take the point that I believe we are on very, very difficult legal grounds. I think it was Lord Wolfson and Lord Redwood who both gave very cogent arguments against relying on that as a, or relying on the doing it ourselves mode, and saying that it should be by legislation. I agree with that, my Lords. I think it is right and proper that that should be the case.

It was the government's own decision to put it in its party manifesto at the election. So therefore I think it should take it forward in what I regard as the proper constitutional position. So, my Lords, you will not be surprised to hear that I am not prepared to help the government in any way to build the guillotine by which I and so many others will be decapitated.

03:45:55 - 03:48:40

Mary Goudie

My Lords, I would like to thank the committee for this report on retirement and participation and for their thorough work on this report and for giving the House their clear direction as a result through the consultation process, and to thank my good friend Baroness Taylor for chairing this committee and also for being available to every member of this House and other organisations to talk about the report so that everyone knew where we were coming from. I welcome the government's manifesto commitment to introduce a retirement age in the House and the steps taken to advance this pledge here today. My Lords, by allowing the House to lead this issue rather than proceeding immediately to legislation, we have created the space for a sensible and considered conversation and approach, my Lords, not just once in the night. Allowing for the best outcome, as the committee itself recognised, my Lords, the House is a better place to retain control of the transition and for the practical details it takes in the lead through a resolution of the whole House rather than waiting for a legislative process. My Lords, the committee has proposed a retirement age of 80 and a minimum participation threshold of 20% sitting days.

I worry about participation. I think that we need to have very clear rules or induction to new peers about participation in the House and in the work of the House, not only here but taking things outside like universities, working with the UN, working with Council of Europe as many of our members do, and all of those global things as well as being part of this House representing ours where it can. But definitely 20% just turning up is not enough.

I think people have to be active within the House. I know some people will disagree with me on these things, but I do think it is very important. Both suggestions will avoid a problematically high number of departures and will ensure that the House continues to benefit from a full experience of active members as long as they're able to contribute. My Lords, I look forward, I look forward to the government's response, which I understand will be given later this year, and I support the government in taking its time to consider these proposals carefully, given their particular significance in the future shape and the functioning of this House and our democracy by relation. Thank you, my Lords.

03:48:40 - 03:53:01

Speaker 84

My Lords, I'm not sure if one has to declare an interest if you're an old man, but anyway. The reason I'm told for wishing to get rid of members of this House who are over 80 is that there are too many peers. I can't think why this opinion is held when there's absolutely no evidence to support it. I think we're trying to solve a problem that doesn't exist. Except for the rarest occasions, there's always a seat in this chamber.

When not in the chamber, there's always space in the library, the Salisbury room, or the peers' writing room. The maximum number of peers going through the voting lobby on any one occasion in the last year was, as my noble friend Lord True pointed out, 475. If you want to spread your net a bit wider, the average number voting in divisions in the last two years was 319. And these numbers of course include hereditary peers who've been got rid of, so the numbers in practice would be smaller. At the last state opening of Parliament, peers had to be moved around by the doorkeepers to stop the place looking empty.

They were all too embarrassed at what it might look like in front of the TV cameras. My Lords, when the Labour government under Tony Blair made the timetabling of bills normal practice, this prevented the other place from having sufficient time to properly examine new legislation. This resulted in an even greater revising duty being placed on this House. For this House to do its job properly at committee stage of a bill, a sufficient number of peers is required who know the subject well enough to make sensible, constructive comments. Peers who are prepared to sit from after questions until 10 o'clock at night with just a short dinner break.

I won't upset you all by commenting on the food. My Lords, you need a large pool to find enough peers meeting these criteria for the many different and diverse subjects which go through this House. How do you find them without a large number of peers to call upon?

There's something in my view even more important than the practical difficulty I've just outlined. I am shocked by this discrimination against a group of peers, of which I am one by the way. First it was hereditary peers, now the over-80s. What will be next? What would this government next like to get rid of?

Liberal Democrats? Limit the number of crossbenchers? Former trade union officials? The idea that under the cloak of claiming the House is too large, a government of whatever political persuasion can play fast and loose with members of the second chamber is truly shocking. I leave your Lordships with one thought.

On the 5th of January 2026, an amendment on the Chagos Islands was tabled and moved successfully by the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig of Radley. He was 96.

03:53:01 - 03:57:46

Speaker 85

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness Lady Taylor of Bolton and her committee for their report and the thoughtful way in which they have approached the subject, which there are unsurprisingly strongly held views. There's much in the report that I agree. Membership of this House should carry responsibilities and the public are entitled to expect active participation from those entrusted with the role. However, I'm less convinced that the proposals before us address the wider questions facing this House. My assumption is that the purpose of introducing a retirement age is at least in part to address concerns about the size and composition of your Lordships' House.

Indeed, the Labour Party's manifesto argued that because appointments are for life, the second chamber has become too large and committed to introducing a mandatory retirement age. If that remains the government's objective, I'd welcome some clarity from the Leader of the House in response to this debate. Is the primary purpose of a retirement age to reduce the size of the House? Because if the objective is to reduce the size of the House, I struggle to see how retirement alone will achieve it. The committee itself makes this point.

It notes that increasing departures through a retirement age will not reduce the size of the House if those departures are simply used as opportunities to make additional appointments. It also observes that focusing only on departures and not arrivals will have limited effects. I think the committee is right. The unlimited power of the Prime Minister to appoint whomever they wish to a job for life cannot be ignored. For many years, proposals such as those contained in the Burns report have recognized that reducing the size of the House requires restraint in appointments.

Without some mechanism to manage inflow, we risk treating the symptom while leaving the underlying problem unresolved. I must also confess to some disappointment that the committee did not look more favorably on the idea of term limits. Although I was pleased to hear the support for term limits by the committee member, the noble Lord, Lord Viscount Chandos. I believe we should think seriously about the principle that no parliamentary position should be held indefinitely. Being a member of this House should not be something we cling to for life.

I say this as someone who, under the committee's recommendations, would be retiring in 2076. Regular renewal is healthy. Fresh perspectives are healthy. Term limits would also create a culture in which members know that their time is finite. That encourages people to participate, contribute, and make a positive impact.

Quite frankly, I do not think positions for life are a particularly healthy principle in a modern democracy. On participation, I welcome the committee's recognition that the current threshold is too low and that reform is needed. The proposed requirement is a step forward, but I'd emphasize that this is a small improvement rather than the transformational one. Participation matters, but participation requirements alone will not address the deeper questions that continue to surround this House. Scandalous is what the new Prime Minister described this House during his recent by-election, and I therefore look forward to seeing what is presented by the Prime Minister.

As noble Lords will know, I have a strong interest in wider reforms of your Lordships' House. I have a private member's bill due for second reading later this year to explore the next stage of the government's manifesto commitment to replace the House of Lords with an alternative second chamber. While I welcome this report and the practical transitional recommendations it contains, I hope that the leader of the House can clarify how the government believe these proposals will achieve the objectives set out in Labour's manifesto. If the intention is to reduce the size of the House and strengthen public confidence, what measures will accompany retirement and participation requirements to address appointments and memberships as a whole? My Lords, I look forward to hearing the rest of this very interesting debate and my retirement in 2076.

03:57:46 - 04:01:52

Speaker 87

My Lords, I too thank Lady Taylor and her committee for their work. My Lords, as one of the House's endangered species, being in the over-80 bracket, I was reluctant to put my name on the speakers' list. Clearly, I have an interest in the outcome of the process. As the speakers' list is sizeable, it is very unlikely that I will add anything new or exceptional to the debate. However, the more I pondered on the issue for debate, the more I became unclear about the assumed problem the supporters of the proposals are claiming and aiming to resolve.

So I look forward very much to the leader of the House responding to the question posed by the noble Lord Strathclyde. Why are peers over 80 perceived as such a problem? Institutional memory is of vital importance. Those of us who have been involved in large institutions and organizations where we've seen a raft of senior figures leave, or haven't seen them being removed, we know of the dangers that follow, the dangers of the constant reinventing of the wheel, and that so often happens. I am pleased that Lord Blunkett raised the issue of discrimination.

Age discrimination does not relate to mental capacity, health, or ability to contribute. If any members of your Lordship House do develop issues of limited capacity, I understand we do have already powers and caring ways of helping resolve this issue both for them and for the House. There are already these mechanisms in existence. Members, of course, under 80 may also lose capacity. The scrutiny work of this House is vital.

As we heard from Lord Rooker during Monday's second reading, the other place is failing to thoroughly scrutinize much of the legislation they send to us. Thorough scrutiny by this House is essential. The loss of peers over 80, and I understand 301 will be reaching this age by 2029, the House will have a serious destabilizing effect on the chamber. Committees will be underpopulated and the daily function of the House could be seriously disrupted. We're regularly told that as a nation we have an increasing elderly population.

Surely the elderly need representation in this House. We, the elderly, do have experience of and understanding of the problems of being old. And I thank Lord Johnson for his comments on diversity and inclusion, which I think were very appropriate in this context. Having heard many speakers, many of whom I think disagree, that it's still not certain why these proposals are perceived as necessary. If the aim is to have a smaller House, then why not use participation in the chamber and the contribution made to the working of the House to guide such decisions?

I look forward to hearing the leader of the House and her responses to the comments made.

04:01:52 - 04:06:03

Prem Sikka

My Lords, I support some of the committee's suggestions, but not others. I have never knowingly supported discrimination based on gender, race, religion, disability, or age, and will not support mandatory retirement age of 80 for members of this House. There are excellent members of that age and above who have brought unparalleled wisdom and experience to this House. It is worth noting that the UK does not actually have a general retirement age, though we have a state pension age. Two are not the same.

There's no mandatory retirement age for an MP, Prime Minister, head of state, councillor, company director, or a mayor. People can continue in office as long as they can discharge their duties. Therefore, the introduction of one retirement age for members of this House is inappropriate. Yes, there is a maximum retirement age for judges and magistrates. But the crucial difference is that in most cases they make decisions as individuals, whereas in this House members make decisions collectively.

Some have argued that forced retirement at 80 will help to renew this House by bringing in younger peers. Actually, there's no barrier to that, and it is good to see younger peers in this House. Some complain that we have too many peers, but that hasn't prevented parties from appointing new ones.

I have no problem with the 20% attendance requirement as a condition for continued membership of this house. However, I wonder who will be sending reminders to members of how close they are to the 20% threshold and what the scenes would be in the last chance saloon. I can understand the committee's difficulties in grappling with a possible requirement to ask for participation instead of attendance. Participation depends in part on luck in ballots and whether the bills fall within the area of expertise of the noble lords. During oral questions, members can bob up and down but may not catch the government whip's eye.

Some may wish to be a member of a committee but may not be favored by the party whip and be silenced. Ultimately, working peers need to be distinguished from the rest and as an emeritus professor, I like the concept of emeritus peer. There's a kind of a symmetry to it. The reform that I really wish to see is unfortunately beyond the remit of the committee. It is the replacement of this house by an elected chamber.

In the 21st century, we should not have an elected chamber of political appointees with reserved seats for clergy from just one religious denomination. Other countries have two elected chambers of parliament and we should learn from their experiences. This possible reform raises complex constitutional issues and needs very broad public and prolonged conversations. The last thing we need is a clone of the House of Commons where ruling parties over the years have curtailed debates and leaders have silenced critical voices by banishing dissenters altogether. It is also unacceptable to have both houses under the control of one party and its members must also not be on the payroll of private interests either.

So I urge the government to begin the process of a meaningful reform of the House of Lords and bring proposals forward so that we can make the desired constitutional change as soon as possible.

04:06:03 - 04:11:23

Richard Balfe

My lords, Baroness Taylor is gone somewhere so I don't but I would congratulate her on presiding over this report. Almost impossible to get an agreement, I would have thought. People from time to time ask me what's unique about the House of Lords. My answer's quite simple. It's the only pensioners' parliament in the world.

We have in this house a lot of experience, a lot of age and most of us have been in some area of the public realm. That's why it works because there's a lot of former MPs, MEPs, trade union officials, but basically people who've worked within the system of the rule of law and that's part of our success. I would like to say briefly and remind people that this week we welcome Lord Leveson to the house. He is 77 years old. I'm sure he'll make a distinguished commitment as he has during his working life.

But to bring him in at 77 and throw him out at 80 doesn't seem to me to be the sensible, friendly or well thought out. The next point I'd like to make is for Lord Hope who is also not here, but he mentioned the difficulty of having a emeritus association and the difficulty of it representing Scotland where a lot of people live long way from London. Well, I was the person who established the European Parliament former members association. It now has members stretching from the north of Norway right through the continent to Cyprus. It can be done, but it's not cheap.

One of the problems our former members always had with the Brits is that they were always trying to do things on the cheap, not pay their subs, get away with things. If you want a proper former members of the House of Lords association, you're looking at 300 to 400 thousand pounds a year to build a structure that will actually work and keep people in touch. The next point I'd like briefly to touch on is the matter of a compulsory retirement. I just don't agree. We've had many speeches, I agree with them all.

I think it's the wrong way forward. I certainly will not be voting for it. One of the problems with a compulsory age of retirement quite simply is it doesn't distinguish between people. But I have been a member of the group run by Lord Norton and Baroness Hayter for many years and I've consistently said there, if you want to get retirements, you've got to give people some form of financial recompense. We pretend that everybody in here is millionaires.

There are many members of this chamber who rely on their daily allowance to keep their standard of living up. I think after a period of years here, you should be able to rely on some sort of termination payment. You could if you wanted to retire people at 80, make 80 the peak year and let it then fall back. But what you can't do is just throw people out. That I began life as a trade union officer long before I was in politics.

And we never expected people to work for nothing. We always regarded people should be paid and should be paid fairly. If people come into this house and they get an income, frankly, it should just not be taken away from them and then deprived of any financial recompense. So what I would say, if you want to get retirements, get yourself a financial proposal which enables people to retire with some sort of pension and if you like base it around 80 and then bring it down, but don't just throw people out. I hope these thoughts have been of some value.

If we move to the next stage, I may well be tabling an amendment about a pension or financial recompense for people who are thrown out.

04:11:23 - 04:16:07

Sheila Hollins

And this thoughtful and well-argued report, I just don't agree with all of its conclusions.

I suggest in some ways it could have been braver. In paragraph 26, for example, the report says, and it's been mentioned, that its remit included considering the impact of its recommendations on the size and functioning and membership of the House. To me, this includes what happens after an age limit has been implemented. The public discourse focuses in part on size and participation, and a fixed age will have no impact on either of these unless we also look at how people come in. And there's been a lot of talk about the lack of any limit on the number of life peerages which a Prime Minister can recommend.

So we could require experienced and active members of the House to leave at 80, only for their places to be filled, or more, through Prime Ministerial patronage. Now, the Lord Speaker's Committee proposed an overall limit on the size of the House with appointments linked to departures and allocated according to an agreed formula. And I'd go further than the Lord Speaker's Committee and propose an annual limit on Prime Ministerial appointments. So if 46 leave each year, as current projections suggest if the 80 age limit is introduced, then a cap of 46 new appointments could be applied. And further to my noble friend Lord Patel's number crunching, I estimate that the percentage of crossbenchers will have dropped from 20% to less than 8% by 2034.

Less than 8%. So at least 20% of all new appointments would need to be crossbenchers. And maybe, you know, that sort of, it's just worth thinking about. The crossbenchers do bring a very particular expertise and also tend to be appointed at an older age. We're a revising chamber and much of what we bring here is accumulated knowledge, judgment, and experience, and those things do not necessarily disappear on our 80th birthday.

So I find myself troubled by one aspect of the proposed solution: the assumption that a particular birthday is the best way of deciding when somebody should stop contributing. I've spent much of my professional career thinking about disability, mental capacity, and the assumptions we make about people's abilities. One thing I've learned is we have to be really careful about using a characteristic such as age or disability as a proxy for capacity. People age very differently. Some people at 80 have lost abilities they once had.

Others remain intellectually vigorous, extraordinarily knowledgeable, capable of making a contribution which would be very difficult to replace. And of course, incapacity can occur at any age. So are we asking the right question? Rather than simply asking how old is this member, should we not simply be asking is this member still making a valuable contribution? And are they able and willing to continue doing so?

So I would suggest a slight modification: let it be the expectation that retirement at 80 is the norm, but not necessarily an absolute rule. There's a separate and sensitive question of health and capacity. I'm not suggesting routine medical examinations or cognitive tests at 80, like you have to have for driving, for example, not that they're very effective. That would risk confusing age with incapacity and disability with incapacity, two mistakes we've tried to eliminate elsewhere in society. But we should not avoid the issue altogether.

And if there is substantial reason to believe that a member, and this is the key point, if a member at any age no longer has the capacity to discharge the responsibilities of membership, we must have a fair, dignified and confidential way of addressing it, based where necessary on independent professional evidence and with proper safeguards. Finally, I agree with an earlier speaker that age does not confer superiority, but members over the age of 80 have experience of the needs and life experience of the fastest growing generations in our population, and the House would be poorer if we entirely lose their experience.

04:16:07 - 04:21:29

Stephen Benn

My Lords, can I begin by joining the queue of noble Lords who've paid tribute to my noble friend Baroness Taylor of Bolton and the committee for the work that they did, and they've produced a good report. I know they didn't publish any of the evidence, but can I just say that I hope historians of the future will have access to that evidence as part of the business of explaining how the House has evolved over the years. And I don't in fact envy my noble friend the Leader of the House the job of trying to sum up today's debate, given the range of speakers we've had so far and what we will still to come. Is there any member here who does not have an interest in the outcome of this debate? The answer is, I doubt it.

I'm sure many members looked at the report and the moment they saw it, they turned to the point at which they would know their own end date, and I'm no exception. But I hope the House will understand, my Lords, if I say that I've been here before, and for the most of the last two and a half years, I was only too conscious of the fact of the effects of the final day of the last session. Now the whole House knows the significance of the issues identified in the report, and they do arise as a result of a manifesto commitment by my party at the last election. But I admit to being slightly conflicted by two arguments. One is that it should be for the government itself to bring forward proposals on a mandatory retirement age, if that's what is planned.

The other is that perhaps it is better for this House to take what action it can, because the government bill considered by the Commons might well find itself broadened well beyond the subject matter of this report. So on balance, I can see the case for us to take action ourselves where our objectives can be achieved by non-legislative means. But my Lords, there is a broader context to this debate. It is both about the case for reducing the size of the House and about our relationship with the House of Commons. The other night, we listened to my noble friend Lord Rooker make some very persuasive points about the extent to which it increasingly falls to us to scrutinize government legislation that the same government itself effectively prevents the House of Commons from considering properly by the use of the timetable motion and the guillotine.

And meanwhile, efforts in this House to reduce our size, and I pay tribute to the work of the noble Lord Lord Burns and others, have not yet succeeded and cannot succeed, partly because we have no ability effectively to reduce the power of prime ministerial patronage. And hence the proposals before us today. Now I admit to being ambivalent about the retirement age, though I appreciate the committee's suggested phasing in of it over a number of years. Why? Well, it's not just because it jars with the principles of discrimination against people who are older, and we live in a country where the population itself is getting older.

Now, funny enough, I bumped into a group of school children today when I was in the House early this morning, and I asked them, "Do you think it's unfair that you should throw people out of Parliament at the age of 80?" And amazingly, the vast majority of that school group put up their hands and said yes, they thought it was unfair. That's quite interesting. So I am slightly nervous of a fixed retirement age. It would never be applied to the House of Commons for this reason: you could never restrict the rights of the electorate to elect whomever they wish to serve in that place.

Now, I know that there are many members of this House who are over 80 who make an extraordinary contribution and continue to do so to the work of this House.

And mention was made of Lord Mackay of Clashfern. I was sitting on the benches opposite when he made his final remarks on leaving the House. He was cogent. He made some very good points. He said he'd reached the view that he reassessed certain legislation even though he'd introduced that legislation decades earlier and he was 95.

My point really is that capacity is perhaps a better guide than mere age to what matters. Now, by contrast, there are members decades younger than that noble Lord who do not often come. They do not often speak. They do not often vote. In short, they do not often participate.

And in my opinion, this can bring the House into disrepute. That's why I find myself in much greater sympathy with the report's recommendations on participation. However, I entirely understand the reference to the risks of performative activity, but the right balance has to be found to enable the House to fulfill its core functions: scrutinizing legislation, holding the government of the day to account, engaging in committee work, and raising issues for debate. And I think the commission's, the report's recommendations are a stage further forward. I'll end by saying this.

I'm one of those members who regards this place as a workshop and not a museum. But I consider myself a working peer and it was on that basis that I stood for election to this House. And I shall listen to the rest of the debate with great interest. And in my experience of this place, which goes well beyond the five years when I first arrived this month, is that incremental change is usually what works best.

04:21:29 - 04:27:02

James Lupton

My Lords, many speakers in this debate, including the noble Lord Viscount Stansgate, have made the arguments against an arbitrary age limit. So I won't repeat those arguments other than to say I agree with them. And as I look in particular at some of the long-serving peers who sit on the Privy Council benches, it seems to me Parliament will be weaker and much less effective if we lose their experience and institutional memory. But I would like to spend some time talking about the attendance requirement. And that, your view on that, I think depends on what kind of House you believe we should be and what kind of membership we should have.

I pay tribute to those peers who are regular attendants here almost every day, whose main activity is the legislation passing through this House. The House needs those members. We depend on them to get the business done and they are true public servants. But I also believe the House benefits tremendously from those more part-time peers whose main career is outside of politics and bring the expertise and wider experience of that parallel experience into Parliament. The value of contributions to this House is not just measured by the frequency of attendance and speaking.

It's also the quality of the contributions. And while the primary function of the House is detailed scrutiny of legislation, I think the House also has an important constitutional role as an ultimate backstop against government on major issues. And having a wider group of peers who aren't necessarily here every day but will come in and vote and listen and attend on those major issues actually is another strength of the House.

And on that basis, I believe the threshold of 20% that's been suggested, while it might seem reasonable, when you think about it as if it's going to be meaningful attendance, a day a week is too limiting for those who are maintaining an active career outside of Parliament. My Lords, I would not want to hold myself up as any kind of role model, and I've now retired from active commercial activity, but my experience of the changing scope for participation through my career, I suspect is representative of many others. I joined this House almost 30 years ago, and like many others had a background of a mixed career in business and in policy development across Whitehall. When I arrived, I was in full-time employment in a corporate world, but I made arrangements to attend when I felt I could contribute. But I had the advantage of working and living in London.

If I worked and lived elsewhere in the United Kingdom, I'd have found it very difficult, even on a passing 15-minute tick-the-box exercise, to be in the House one day in five every week. I then moved on and I had a period as a non-executive director with a portfolio career, that gave me much more capacity to be involved over a period of years. But then I moved on to another role where I was chairman of a major UK bank for over seven years, and during that period, that activity naturally took primacy. So, I think that kind of experience over a period of years is typical of many members of this House who have maintained an active role in a profession or career outside the bank, whether it's in law or medicine or teaching or any other activity which requires them to keep an active role that doesn't necessarily enable them to spend one day every week on average participating in the House, but nevertheless when they do come, have experience and expertise to bring. And I think the House benefits from that experience and wider engagement.

And I understand there's a demand for some kind of participation requirement, but if that is required, I would just urge the House and the Minister to consider whether a lower threshold would be more acceptable in terms of keeping those members of the House who can contribute in that way. For example, 10%, once a fortnight, I think would be much more reasonable, but still implied people were actively involved. So, my Lords, I just urge the House and the Minister just to think again about that threshold requirement to ensure we don't exclude people who can make a major contribution.

04:27:02 - 04:31:42

Alexander David Hugh Hannay

It's a pleasure to follow Lord Blackwell, my old foe, and a pleasure to congratulate Baroness Taylor of Bolton on her excellent report and her feat in securing unanimous agreement on it. And some of the speeches today have shown us what a feat that was. I thought I detected what Private Eye calls a reverse ferret, but I may be wrong about that. I'm certainly a bit baffled by the disingenuous claims that it's not clear what problem the government and the committee are trying to solve. My Lords, we know it's how to bring in new blood without having the place get absurdly large.

And I think that the talk of expulsion is, with all due respect to Noble Lord True, a little overblown. I myself would have preferred a fixed term or a combination of the two of them. Not for any personal reasons, I'd be caught either way. I came here in 2004, shortly after my expulsion from the Foreign Office. And as for age, well, I prefer just to say that I was expelled from my pram well before D-Day.

And clearly, given the manifesto commitment, it's going to be a retirement age.

But, Lord True, it happens. It's called aging. But I hope the report's case for gradualism is bought by the government and the other place, because the cliff-edge point seems to me a very real one, particularly for us crossbenchers. We're the oldest group here, and 60% of us would be over a 2029 ledge, edge, lemming-like, all in one go. On participation, I go for a criterion of attendance rather than verbosity.

They also serve who only think and vote. But the minimum requirement shouldn't be set too low. We are sent here primarily to legislate, and we should be ready to commit the necessary time, as many, alas, now don't. HOLAC needs to be able to check that in advance, as well as propriety, and for all people coming here. Our active membership is only about half our nominal membership, as some have pointed out, but that seems to me to be bad news rather than good.

It certainly isn't very good for our image. And we're doing nothing to bring down overall numbers. I naively thought the departure of our hereditary friends would produce a big fall. But it hasn't. Leaving aside those on leave of absence, there were 827 of us this day last year.

Today there are 797, a fall of 30. But it's rapidly being reduced as new peers flock in. A fall of only 30. Yes, there are fewer Conservatives, but only 38 fewer, still the largest group. And of course there are many fewer crossbenchers, that endangered species.

We're down by much more proportionately than the Conservative Party. But there are more Labour peers, of course, more Lib Dem peers, more non-aligned peers, there even are more bishops than there were a year ago. Of course we all know about the post-election ratchet effect. I think that's ratchet, not racket, though I'm not entirely sure. But it would be good to remind the three great parties, so busy rewarding their friends, that Lord Burns's 2017 report convinced us all that 600, not 800, would be about the right size, and that until we got there, a two-out-for-one-in rule would be right.

We voted for that. To her credit, Baroness May respected it as Prime Minister, but no other subsequent Prime Minister has done so, and it's high time they did.

04:31:42 - 04:33:16

Janet Fookes

My Lords, I want to add my thanks to Lady Taylor of Bolton for the many months that she and her committee wrestled with this matter. But I just cannot accept the report. I feel strongly that some peers do not consider all the relevant issues before accepting a peerage. The first thing I did was to find out my husband's views. He had had a stroke, and I knew his life would change if I was away most of the week.

He was, of course, delighted for me, and we worked together on how we would make it work. I know others who reorganized their arrangements before entering the House, planning their future, knowing that they would be here for life or when they wish to retire. Now they face an about-turn which could have many ramifications, while those who enter early in their 30s and 40s would have the privilege of spending tens of years of service in the House. My Lords, I hate retrospective legislation, and I think this proposal would be a mistake. And with the world in such a topsy-turvy state, it would be wise to go into the next election with all the stability we could muster.

04:33:16 - 04:38:48

Elizabeth Kay Andrews

My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble lady. I rise to speak very much in support of this report and to congratulate my noble friend, like so many other people have already. I do so with the privilege of having been in this House 27 years and really appreciating enormously the vast range of expertise and experience in this House. But I have always thought that there should be as a matter of course a retirement age, not as an expulsion, but just as a matter of course. And I'm grateful now that we have the responsibility ourselves as a self-regulating House to decide, if we take the opportunity, what is best for the House as a whole in the future.

And I'm therefore very impressed by the work of the committee and for the careful and very inclusive way that it listened to so many opposing, passionate views, and we've heard many around the House tonight, but they still agreed on what I think was a fair and practical solution. We have to consider context, my Lords. The committee has done its work in very heavy weather. Democratic politics can no longer be taken for granted, much as we cannot expect this House to survive without radical intervention. The rule of law, as we've debated in this House recently, is under siege.

The guardianship of the constitution is at issue. It is all the more important that Parliament retains respect and is truly effective and fit for purpose. The House cannot be defended against change, but a retirement age creates the opportunity to think not just about the size and composition of the House, but also what it needs to match the huge demands on it in the future, not least the changing nature of expertise, as well as perpetual questions about credibility and dignity as members of the House grow older and more frail. Capacity varies enormously, we know that. I accept and I'm grateful for the phasing of retirement between 80 and 85, just as I am grateful that the ludicrous notion of a mass exit at any point with all its perverse and undignified consequences was put down.

I'm also relieved that the idea of a participation bar was rejected. There is no fair way of doing this, my Lords, given the present size of the House and the way we frankly do not make full use of our current expertise. A participation metric would have been bizarre as well as impossible to enforce. Much better to have attendance as a standard. So the committee avoided the two huge bear traps, but it has come to the difficult but rational conclusion that age has to be a factor in the future.

And I agree with that, just as I agree that our older members have a unique and impartial wisdom and invaluable institutional memory, even if, my Lords, if that institutional memory is rarely called upon. But it is an aide-mémoire for what can go wrong, alongside all the missed opportunities that might still be there. And it covers not just revision of legislation and scrutiny, but how we manage the House and our relationships within the House. But there is no doubt, my Lords, that institutional memory can also have a chilling effect on change. We are past masters in this House of arguing the case for unripe time.

We have to be brave, my Lords, in recognizing the need that the time is ripe. Judgment may improve in ways with age, but I do not think that the other value we hold close, our expertise, is of equal measure. And I speak from experience. Knowledge has never moved faster, nor has raised such hard ethical or existential questions. We must look for the scope for a continual renewal of knowledge in this House, whether it's the regulation of AI, hard choices over scarce resources, or providing what young people need for a very different future.

And I agree we must look at the way that people, noble Lords, come into this House. And that brings me to the size of the House. I do not think that there is any one right size, nor can we predict the future size of this House. But it should be a smaller and nimbler House, but we only achieve that if we have the courage to radically think hard about how we do legislation and how we do scrutiny. Indeed, we do not have to wait to do that.

I think the House is already too large to be effective in many respects. Finally, I profoundly believe that the House has a duty of care to older members and at the moment it is difficult to exercise that. Phasing in retirement gives us a predictability and a safety for the future. As often, I've turned to Trollope for a perspective. In his final book, The Fixed Period, he foresees a future British colony where a young unicameral parliament decides that the national lifespan should be 67 to improve productivity.

The only recompense is that at age 66, in the final year, citizens will be provided with all their heart's desires. My Lords, his prescription goes even further than the Labour Party manifesto, and I am not recommending it. But I do think that I shall certainly be taking advantage of what that last year holds. And finally and most important, let us for goodness' sake decide for ourselves what is best and embed that decision within the practices and the principles of this House. We do not need legislation to bring change.

04:38:48 - 04:43:57

Michael Stahel Farmer

My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the Baroness Andrews. My Lords, it's also worth reflecting on Ian Duncan Dunce's comments on how Westminster works and why it doesn't. Quote, "There is a place with a proud record of standing up to government. It works diligently and thanklessly to improve legislation. It applies expertise to policy.

It seeks consensus. It is independent-minded and rejects partisan point-scoring.

It acts with a seriousness that is absent almost anywhere else in the political system. It is the House of Lords. Participation requirements would enhance that contribution. This is a job, not a status. We are legislators, so voting should count.

However, as iron sharpens iron, so one man sharpens another. Ideas become refined by being together, listening to and disagreeing courteously with each other. Prospective members should be informed before their appointment is finalized what sustained contribution to this House entails and is expected from day one. Requiring retirement would, however, threaten what Hunt admires. The 2024 Labour manifesto said, "Although Labour recognizes the good work of many peers who scrutinize the government and improve the quality of legislation passed in Parliament, too many peers do not play a proper role in our democracy."

It is peculiarly ageist to have a cutoff point at 80 when many octogenarians are contributing very substantially and some younger peers, often by virtue of other significant responsibilities, are not. Declaring an interest, I, like many others, if this report were implemented, I would be retiring in 2029. For me, declining cognitive and possibly physical ability might require retirement at some point, but not age. Whilst I can contribute to society through my work here, I think I should. To him who has been given much, much will be expected.

As an aside, it is assumed that noble Lords leaning on the red benches with their eyes closed are asleep when we have actually our ears to the speakers in the rosettes and are concentrating hard. Perhaps it's the sound system that is archaic and needs retiring, not those using it. We are a self-regulating House. Like Baroness Hollins, I have concerns about declining cognitive abilities that should be dealt with sensitively by party whips or others with seniority who might ask trusted colleagues to initiate difficult conversations. They could encourage reduced participation, suggest retirement, or even agree that a peer will not speak.

There is already subtle pressure in this House not to outstay one's welcome. I hope someone would take me to one side if needed. I've seen this work. Someone with a remarkable work history and a strong track record of contribution here began to show effects of dementia. A peer they trusted gently suggested they lay down their responsibilities, and they did.

Any peer might need this. Five to seven percent of dementia sufferers in the UK are below 65. To reiterate, it is simply ageist to tie ability to age. But more importantly, we're here to serve the country, not ourselves. Firing the over-80s disenfranchises the many octogenarians, nonagenarians, and centenarians still contributing enormously in our society.

The rigors of the Second World War are still in their hearts and bones. Their perspective is invaluable, and a nation that forgets its past is in danger of repeating its mistakes. David Attenborough's 100, the late Queen died at 96, but there are many older men and women in more ordinary walks of life still contribute enormously. One of the four centenarians in this year's honors list received the BEM, indicating remarkable community service. I appreciate the committee's efforts to smooth the transition for existing peers, so retirement is not suddenly forced upon them and the House is not suddenly bereft of subject expertise and experience.

But even with the committee's more gradualist plans, we've heard almost 60% of crossbenchers would be gone by 2034. I will end with Dylan Thomas. I think Lord True started with Dylan Thomas. We should not go gentle into that good night of auto-retirement. For those of us still in command of our faculties, still up for the job, old age should burn, maybe not rave, but it should burn until close of day.

04:43:57 - 04:49:17

Mary Watkins

My Lords, it's a pleasure to speak in this debate and I want to thank the Retirement and Participation Committee, and in particular Baroness Taylor of Bolton as chair, for such a well-constructed report, which I believe makes sound suggestions for the continued reform of the House following the legislation associated with hereditary members. I spoke in support of the Burns report, which recommended fixed terms of 15 years, but acknowledged that this issue was not widely accepted at the time. The report before us today acknowledges that some members find fixed terms an attractive proposition. However, the committee concluded that the potential benefits of fixed-term appointments were outweighed by the potential disadvantages and that this may deter younger members from joining the House. The House is not reflective of our population in terms of generational representation, rural and ethnic diversity.

And in the longer term, I suggest it will be necessary to return to that issue about whether fixed-term appointments, particularly for new appointments, say of 20 or 25 years, would be effective in not only containing the size of the House, but result in a more multi-generational representation within our body. I'm particularly impressed by the ingenuity of Appendix 4, which explains in plain English how transitional arrangements would work in practice regarding a retirement age of 80. If accepted, the recommendations would provide certainty to all our members in terms of their own anticipated retirement date, and I would be one of the first to go on the dot of 80, actually. The committee members demonstrate how they will be affected in Table 1, illustrating their personal commitments to the Nolan principles of public life. It is an honor and a privilege to attend this House, and committee members presenting this report acknowledge this while recommending a solution that will affect us all, including themselves, that is consistent with upholding integrity, selflessness, and leadership as they apply to appointed public office holders.

I came here through Appointments Committee when the chair was Lord Kakkar, as a people's peer, based largely on my expertise in nursing. In the four countries of the UK, there are currently 500,000 nurses on the professional register, probably a little more. Do you not think it would be arrogant of me to say that at least we could find suitable replacements to replace my expertise as I approach the age of 80? With certainty on my retirement date, subject to not succumbing to illness and early retirement, the nursing profession would undoubtedly plan to work with me to identify a range of excellent potential replacements to apply to the Appointments Committee. I'm certain that similar potential succession plans could occur across the House, resulting in excellent new appointments, bringing contemporary knowledge and experience to inform the House.

I do like others get concerned about the size of the crossbench. With the recent deaths of the noble Lord Laming and a little while ago the noble lady Baroness Howarth, we are for in my opinion very short of social work practice and knowledge and particularly in child protection. These are the issues we should be looking at. I am fully supportive of these recommendations and want to thank the committee members again for a carefully considered review of evidence and their manifesto commitment to introduce a retirement age. The recommendations will protect some of our youngest members who have given up other career opportunities understanding that their appointments would be for life.

Reducing this to 80 seems a fair approach for younger members too as Baroness Smith said earlier. It also avoids the necessity to consider the introduction of an occupational health assessment at a predetermined age in line with other professions to ensure competency and safety in the workplace. I also want to express my support for the idea of an emeritus association and I live five hours away but I would be happy to pay my fare if I wanted to come up and meet a group of friends as I do on other occasions with other members. I finally want to say that I think watching the last night of the proms there was a new definition of AI and that was that Dolly Parton had always had authentic integrity. I challenge us as a body to display a similar approach to this particularly important report.

04:49:17 - 04:53:45

Philip Norton

The most important words in the report of the select committee are not in the conclusions but in the opening summary. We are bound by our remit. As the noble Baroness Baroness Finlay said earlier, form should follow function. The government have focused on form. That has tied the hands of the committee.

Good law is a public good. That must be front and center in addressing what this place is for. This House is core to ensuring that bills brought forward by government are as good as they can be to deliver what the measure seeks to achieve. That is a task that if not fulfilled by this House, it's not going to be carried out at all. An arbitrary age limit will remove some members who contribute significantly to legislative scrutiny bringing to bear experience that is exclusive to them while retaining members who make no significant contribution.

Expecting members to attend for a certain percentage of sittings may remove some who are not making much of a contribution but again it's a blunt weapon. It is not sufficiently calibrated to deliver the core task of the House. It would make more sense to have more sophisticated participation criteria focusing on quality rather than quantity. If we go for targeted qualitative participation as recommended by the campaign for an effective second chamber, we achieve both a reduction in numbers and enhance the meaningful participation of members. The select committee has come up with formulas we've heard for retirement and participation that could be delivered by the House.

There's an obvious principled objection to that, namely that it should not be for the House to use its procedures to deliver government policy.

We've heard the argument that implementing the committee's recommendations means that we are in control of what happens, but that's akin to a kidnapper letting the victims tie their own hands. If the government introduce legislation, that will provide us with the opportunity to use the bill to deal with the problem that is not within the select committee's remit, but is addressed by the Labour Party's manifesto. Any reform focused on composition must address how members come here and not in isolation how they leave. Simply removing members at a certain age creates the opportunity that we've heard for the Prime Minister to fill the House with new nominees. That is open to criticism from the perspective of sheer size.

Much more importantly, it is objectionable if those nominated do not have the skills and commitment necessary to contribute to the work of this House, especially the core task of legislative scrutiny. We need workhorses, not grandstanders or theatergoers. My Lords, a Constitution Unit survey some years ago found that the public rank trust in the appointments process as the most important factor in determining the legitimacy of this House. We should be driven by what is the best interest, not of the House, but of the nation in delivering good law. I have three questions for the Lord Privy Seal.

First, does she agree that form should follow function? Second, does she recognize that the public attach more importance to the process by which peers are appointed than to how they leave? And third, given that, can she tell us what the government will do to implement their manifesto commitment to reform the process by which people are nominated for peerages? Because that, my Lords, is the most pressing issue.

04:53:45 - 04:59:11

Ara Darzi

My Lords, it's a very great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Norton of Louth, and in so doing, of course, join other noble Lords in thanking Baroness Taylor of Bolton for the very thoughtful way in which she's introduced this important report and indeed the work of her committee. I'd like to follow the noble Lord, Lord Norton, by building on the question of appointments, and here I declare a former interest as chair of the House of Lords Appointments Commission. What is very clear in the proposals that your Lordships are considering today is that on the 8th of July 2029, there could be as many as 135 vacancies created. And we've seen in recent experience that within the first two years of administration, some 50% of all peers appointed by a Prime Minister, appointments are made in that first two-year period. So there might well be a substantial temptation and indeed perceived opportunity for a new Prime Minister to make substantial appointments to your Lordships' House.

And of course, the point has been well made that this will impact in terms of achieving the objective of reducing the size of your Lordships' House and indeed may also have important implications with regard to the effectiveness of the scrutiny that your Lordships' House can deliver. But there is another, more important, I believe, fundamental constitutional risk, jeopardy, associated with continuing to provide the opportunity unfettered for more and more appointments to your Lordships' House. And this rests upon the 1911 Parliament Act and indeed clause 2.1 of that act, which reserves for your Lordships' House a unique veto over measures passed by the other place.

And that is a retained veto to prevent the other place from passing a measure that would extend the life of a Parliament beyond five years. It's the only clearly retained veto that your Lordship's House retains. The importance of this matter was considered in a case by your Lordship's Appellate Committee at the time, the case of Jackson versus the Attorney General, where the question of whether the Parliament Act procedure could be used to force the House of Lords, despite that restriction in the 1911 Act, to adopt or to ensure that a measure could be passed to extend the life of a Parliament beyond five years without consent of your Lordship's House. And at that time, by a majority, your Lordship's Appellate Committee decided that that measure could not be applied to overcome the restriction in the 1911 Act. So the only way that a Prime Minister having a majority in the other place could proceed with extending the life of a Parliament beyond five years would be to ensure an effective majority in your Lordship's House.

And therefore the independence of your Lordship's House is absolutely critical. Now, it could be argued that that could have happened at any time since the passage of the 1958 Life Peerages Act. But we are now in a process of continuously changing the composition of this House and in particular the way and the number of peers that might leave this House at any given time. And therefore it must be a real concern that we take ourselves to a position where ultimately there could be an effective majority in your Lordship's House, matching the majority in the other place, and that a government that decided to do so could pass a measure to extend the life of a Parliament beyond five years and in so doing deny the electorate the opportunity to give their view on the performance and behavior of that government, potentially for an indefinite period. It might be argued that the courts could intervene at that stage and protect democracy.

The problem is that the Article 9 of the 1689 Bill of Rights would ultimately potentially prevent that from happening because the measure had been passed on the proper bicameral procedure. And I'd like to ask the noble lady the leader, in considering all of the measures which are very carefully laid out in the report led by Baroness Taylor of Bolton, how are constitutional safeguards going to be maintained so that we don't find ourselves in a position ultimately where an effective majority might be secured in your Lordship's House in such a way that the government might proceed as I have described.

04:59:11 - 05:04:02

James Sandys

My Lords, my noble friend Lord Howard of Lympne got to the nub of the question when he asked: what is this all for?

The answer, I suggest, is at least in part as a result of a certain squeamishness. Cognitive decay is cruel. Age, as we all know, affects all of us unequally. This retirement proposal is not just about reducing the numbers in this House. At its heart, it seeks to remove those who might, in the colorful words of my noble friend Lord Hamilton, have lost their marbles.

A retirement age of 80 is really a measure to avoid a hard conversation. Now, while I approve of avoiding awkward conversations, the cost, I suggest, my Lords, is too high. The loss of expertise and experience would gravely damage the work of this House. Therefore, would not a capacity test be a better measure and avoid us and allow us to avoid an arbitrary deadline at the age of 80? Consideration has been hinted at in other speeches from noble Lords this evening, and no doubt the conduct of such a test, following the measures that were permitted by this House to be added to the Hereditary Peers Bill, could allow tests of capacity to be conducted with humanity and kindness by the House authorities and, dare I say it, by the whips.

This, I suggest, is an answer that warrants careful consideration. One last point, if I may, a bugbear of mine: there can be no such thing as a peer emeritus. We have no monopoly on the title Lord. There have been, since at least the Act of Union of 1707, two categories of peers: parliamentary peers and non-parliamentary peers. From 1707 to 1963, the Scottish peerage elected from among themselves 16 to attend this House.

The rest of those Scottish peers were non-parliamentary. Similarly, from 1801, only 28 of the Irish peerage were sent here to serve in this House. The rest were non-parliamentary peers. Now, as a result of the iniquitous legislation, as I see it, passed by the government, all hereditary peers are now non-parliamentary peers, unless, of course, they have the good fortune also to hold a life peerage. That category of non-parliamentary peer now includes all life peers who have retired from this House under the provisions of the 2014 Act.

And therefore, I can reassure the noble Lord, Lord Rooker, that the Lord Privy Seal is entirely right, as is often the case, when she says that those who are not members of this House are entitled to vote, and they are still entitled to use the title that they have been given by the Crown in accordance with their letters patent, as is right and proper and has been the case, as I say, for many centuries. Especially if they're still on the roll of the peerage, why not? I'm grateful. I just, I think I might be correct, but I'm sure the noble Lord will correct me. The Scottish Lords of Parliament, who were part of those elected to serve after the Act of Union, had themselves to be re-elected at the start of each new Parliament.

So they indeed didn't have a lifetime right to serve in Parliament, as he suggested.

Yes, thank you. I entirely agree with the noble Lord, Lord Purvis. And there's a curious quirk that the Irish elected peers were elected for life, not just for Parliament. But that's the joy of our glorious constitution. As I would say, though, it's right that this House is considering the issue of whether or not a member should be compelled to carry on serving once they are past their prime, if I might put it like that.

The answer is not a hard age bar. The answer is more humane.

05:04:02 - 05:09:15

Jeremy Purvis

My Lords, I'm down as the 50th speaker out of 65. It's amazing the level of participation their Lordships manage to achieve when we're discussing our own future. My Lords, I'd better declare an interest. I have been here for nearly 30 years and I am over 80. I used to, at one time prior to coming to this House, have some influence over Labour Party manifestos.

Regrettably, that no longer is the case. And I was slightly amused that the Labour Party seemed to consider in their writing their manifesto that the most important thing that was wrong with the House of Lords was that there were far too many old codgers like me left in it. Now, whilst that may be a criticism and may be a public impression not entirely erroneous, but nevertheless, there are much more fundamental things that the government could have addressed, but nevertheless they didn't. They put this in their manifesto and the responsibility on the House of Lords is to carry out a manifesto according to the Salisbury Convention, just as it would with any other piece of potential change that was clearly endorsed in the manifesto by the election of the government based on that manifesto. I therefore think that my noble friend Baroness Taylor has done a very good, useful report in spelling out the problems and how we should go with it.

I do think we should go with it now. I think we should do so in terms of a House of Lords resolution which could fulfill that requirement on the House of Lords, and we can then have the subsequent arguments later. Because, my Lords, there are a lot of things wrong with the House of Lords. And the question of how appointments are made by successive governments to the House of Lords and the numbers in the House of Lords and in the different groups in the House of Lords, which will not be resolved by retirement at 80 or shortly thereafter. I had intended, shortly after my 30 years are up, sometime in the next year, to retire.

That gives me a little bit more time in these propositions. But I will consider the noble Baroness's recommendations and the government's position. But the argument on actual membership of the House of Lords will go on. It'll go on for two very good reasons. The main role that my noble friend Lord Rooker has been underlining over recent weeks very effectively is that this is a revising House, it's a scrutinizing House, and there has been a failure in the elected House to carry out their scrutiny functions effectively in a way which we need to remedy.

But to remedy that, we have to have some authority and some recognition of that authority ourselves. That requires us to be a little bit more representative of the general population than we are now. And the other big political development over the years since I have been here has been we have become a quasi-federal state. And in view of the present Prime Minister's dedication to greater devolution within England, we're going to become more so.

Most jurisdictions which have an upper chamber, this second chamber is based directly or indirectly on the lower regional or in our case national and regional parts of the United Kingdom. We must move, whether it's by election or by some other process, we must move to a more representative membership of this House of Lords geographically speaking, as well as by age, by gender and everything else. So my Lords, I think we need to postpone that argument for tonight, but we'll fairly rapidly need to get into it. And the government are going to have to face up to the fact that this proposition, which will remove a coterie of old codgers like myself from the House of Lords over the next few years, needs to be replaced by a much more coherent approach to both the appointment system and to the retirement system from this house. These retirements for people over 80 are not going to do anything about the numbers or about the balance of the House of Lords.

So we need another stage in order to do that. So I hope my Lords, this is the beginning of that debate, but let's focus tonight when we come to take our decision on what we are required to do under the Salisbury Convention, under the proposition from the government, and adopt the proposition from my noble friend which makes it for real and move to a situation which the government have put to us. And I hope we can do that without wider legislation and without involvement therefore of the House of Commons or indeed anybody else.

05:09:15 - 05:14:12

Gloria Hooper

My Lords, first I'd like to thank my noble friend Lord True for his comments. I'd like to take you back to the early 70s, 69, 1970. I think most of us in this house, not all, can probably remember those times fairly clearly. So it's, we have two state airlines, state-owned airlines, BEA and BOAC. The state-owned, it's a closed shop if you want to join that company.

And the trade union representatives are all male. The cabin crew are a mixture, but only the male cabin crew have what's called really a full-time contract in terms of a career type contract. I joined BEA and this is my contract. This is memorabilia. We had no seniority.

We had no promotion to be pursers. And one of the key aspects of my employment contract was that there was an age limit. You had to leave by the time you were either 36 or after 10 years. And if you did leave between the age, after serving five or 10 years, you'd get 300 pounds after five years and 600 pounds after 10 years. And if you served the full 10, you got an extra 150 pounds.

So the reality was of course, it was age discrimination. I just have to pick up my speech. Sorry about that. It was age discrimination. The employer, I joined, I was absolutely excited.

The employer was absolutely open to changing the contract. But it was actually my colleagues, the Transport and General Workers Union shop stewards, who were wholly opposed to the female, the stewardesses, having their contract and equalizing contract.

This resulted in my being elected as a, one of the first female shop stewards in BEA. Wasn't something I planned, but it was something that happened. And I rather enjoyed industrial relations and spent quite a few years actually being involved in industrial relations years after too. So by today's standards, this was not only sexist, but it was ageist, so we did change the rules. And our terms and conditions were equalised, and the rest is history.

So if we fast forward to today, five years ago, I was appointed to this House. I didn't have a contract, but I did have my letters patent from Her Majesty the Queen, which meant I'd be here until I died or I decided to retire. But within two years, well just within two years of a Labour government from 2024, they've now dispatched our hereditary peers because of who their fathers were, despite the fact they're a diminishing number of colleagues in this House, and I did not agree with that. Now, we wish to impose an age limit on members, including possibly looking at taking retrospective action on those who are already sitting in this House. And so, notwithstanding that, the government benches or the Prime Minister appointed two Labour peers to this House who very recently last year were 81, which I find quite interesting.

Which brings me to my conclusion. As has been clearly pointed out by my noble friend Lord Wolfson, that we were appointed and we should be able to remain in this House as long as we choose to and as long as we contribute to this House, because to do otherwise is basically based on age, if basically based on age, is simply age discrimination. So here I am at the end of my career, yet again in the hands, it appears, of the left or a Labour government who purport to stand against discrimination but have no compunction in carrying it out on the age of the members of this House.

05:14:12 - 05:18:21

Elizabeth Butler-Sloss

I'd first to thank the Right Reverend Prelate for his very kind words, totally undeserved but very kind. I very much support this report and its recommendations. As we have a manifesto commitment, it seems to me extremely difficult to go behind it. And I am well over the age of 80. So the proposed staggering of the exits of over-80s seems to me entirely sensible, and others will have to work out what happens to the loss of crossbenchers.

I hope that the Leader of the House will bear in mind how diminished we're going to be. It will of course affect a number of people coming in late, as the last speaker pointed out, we had two Labour peers coming in over the age of 80 very recently. And it will affect particularly the judiciary, who come in anytime over 70 and many at 75, which is the retiring age.

And as has already been said, many of the judiciary chair committees and have a useful function in this house. And we are very short of judicial peers at this moment. I think the consequence of this, the idea that we don't have to leave, which is perfectly true, quite clearly Lord Wolfson is right. But I feel that if we're not wanted, we ought to go. I feel that's, but I'm much more concerned about participation.

Peerage, the peerage it seems to me is the gateway for working in this house. And I, and I think that we really ought to consider whether there should be two sorts of peers, quite apart from the peers who don't sit here anyway. The first should, as it happened to me, I happened to have come through HOLAC. And the only question I was asked was, if you get it, will you turn up? To which I said yes, and so I do today.

But I do believe, and I did speak to the leader of the house some years ago, that there should be another sort of peer appointed at the head of the honors system. That peer would not sit in this house. It would be an honor. But any peer who wants, who is asked to sit in this house, really ought to be required to say, I will not come in unless I'm actually going to work. And I don't know whether that happens today.

It certainly happens for HOLAC, but I suspect it doesn't happen through the patronage at number 10. So I would like to see these two sorts of peers. And I just wonder whether there's any chance that might come over. I do believe that a degree of self-denial by prime ministers would help enormously to reduce the house of, and would be much preferable to the present system. And I have to say, I was very disturbed and remains so by the speech of the noble lord, Lord Kakkar.

I think that should be reflected by this house and possibly discussed again at number 10. I, final thing I want to say is I would oppose legislation. I think this house has got to work it out. If we have legislation, it'll open the gates in the House of Commons and we don't know what might happen. It could be extremely dangerous for this house.

05:18:21 - 05:23:00

Timothy Kirkhope

I thank the noble baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton, and her committee for this report. And I declare my calendrical interest as set out in the register. Some of this report is welcome, though I regret that the committee were unable to also examine the admission system, which is clearly integral to any changes reducing the size of the house that might follow. At paragraph 115, the committee says that some members do not contribute and this damages the reputation of the house. That's perfectly true and has been for years.

The committee proposes a requirement of 20% of sitting days averaged over two sessions, with expulsion for those who fall short. I welcome a requirement in principle, but further scrutiny is required as to whether the figure the committee has arrived at strikes the right balance. It should remove those who have in practice stopped coming, without removing members who may be here a dozen or so times a session, but who do good work when they are here, contributing their particular expertise. On age, I'm afraid I disagree. The main work of this house is going through bills line by line, and we do it well because so many members here have run departments or businesses, sat as judges or served in the forces, so they know where a bill might be deficient and need improvement.

Right now, the other place is younger and less experienced than at any time I can remember. And a great many of its members only started in 2024.

A consequence of this is that more work has come our way in the past two years. It is a strange moment, my Lords, to part with 367 of our most experienced colleagues, which is what the committee says it expects between 2029 and 2034. Our current oath on assuming service, as far as I'm concerned, commits us to the service, that service for our lives, and I take that personally as a primary obligation. We are not salaried in this House and we receive no pension. Paragraph 19 acknowledges as such, and that younger members are often mid-career with families to support.

Paragraph 102 notes that they naturally come to have real time for this House only once those pressures ease. The members this report would send away on our expiry date are often the very ones who are here every day and would go on doing their duty to this House and to the country for years to come. The workload they bear will not disappear, but will ultimately pass to colleagues who, as the committee has just explained, have the least time for it, and the House must be the poorer for that. Anyway, the premise of a retirement age is that our capacity falls away at a certain age. Well, it clearly does not.

A week ago or so, or just over a week ago at the Royal Albert Hall, Martha Argerich played Beethoven's second piano concerto, 60 years almost to the day after her Proms debut in 1966. She played it perfectly, almost as well as Alfred Brendel. She fully expects to return next year to perform again. Her rendition received a 12-minute standing ovation. She is 85 years old.

Sir Roger Penrose was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics at 89. He turned 95 last month and was further honored and entertained at Oxford a couple of weeks ago. Margaret Atwood published 600 pages of memoirs at the age of 86 to the best reviews of her career. Johanna Quaas competed as a gymnast until she was 92 and was still giving demonstrations to younger people at the age of 100. Nobody told any of them that their age had settled the question of their usefulness.

I was, my Lords, going to mention also Sir Tom Jones, but sadly, like the Labour Party, the BBC appears to be somewhat ageist in its approach. Age is a crude measure of capacity for the job, and I believe the committee knew it. Ageism has no place in this 21st-century Britain, and especially in this House. So I would finally ask that a well-thought-through participation requirement might indeed achieve everything necessary and the ambitions of the Labour Party without this unacceptable and totally prejudiced provision.

05:23:00 - 05:28:24

John Stokhoe

Goodness, what an education we've had tonight across such a broad range of topics and ages. My remarks may fall short in that regard. But during the thankfully now concluded debates on the hereditary presence in this House, I put down an amendment which, in line with the government's wider manifesto commitments, proposed that a group be established shortly after the passing of the bill to address ongoing membership criteria, in particular the issue of participation, and this was widely supported.

I was therefore very grateful when the committee that produced this excellent report was promptly brought into being. And I congratulate in particular the noble Baroness Taylor, who perhaps like a modern Odysseus has had to navigate a very, very difficult course between the whirlpools of controversy on one side, the sirens of special pleading, and the ever-present danger of mutiny, as whatever course they took would impact friends and colleagues in this House. But my Lords, as the committee itself highlighted, if these issues are not addressed by this House, something less understanding of the role and workings of this place might be imposed on it by the House of Commons, and my Lords, that remains a real risk if the report's proposals are not now acted on. On the age cap, if I may comment to the mere stripling. While perhaps most of us surely accept, like the noble Baroness Watkins did in her speech, that we are not completely irreplaceable, we all know members who are valuable contributors with a depth of long-term experience and wisdom that the House would be sad to lose on the basis of age alone.

I suggested in my evidence to the committee that age should not be the issue, but rather capacity, perhaps on a medically tested basis. But my Lords, I have subsequently come to accept that the graduated progress towards an age cap recommended by the report would be less personally intrusive and also give members more clarity and thereby manage expectations. I also would like to suggest, my Lords, that it is a privilege not just to come into this House, but also at the age of 80 to have served well beyond the retirement age in almost any other role. On the negative side, which has been touched on widely, this will have an unbalancing numerical impact on party groups and in particular the crossbenches, and perhaps the noble Baroness the leader of the House will comment further when winding up on what the government has in mind or its proposals to bring forward on this. One suggestion perhaps might be that everybody on the crossbenches gets three votes.

Just an idea. Settle down, settle down, settle down, please. Settle down, please. On participation, I initially felt that a more detailed approach could be taken, with a weighted metric across all the diverse forms of participation. We might come back to that in the future, because the participation request is, I'm afraid, in practice an attendance amount.

But I now accept the committee's view that this would make things over-complex at this stage. I cannot resist, however, being intrigued by Lord Hamilton's earlier reference to me and his suggestion for a solution. I thank him for the previous notice he very courteously gave that he was going to be rude about me, but I would just correct his understanding that actually I was defeated a number of times in by-elections before the one in which I was successful, but perhaps I was too shy to tell him about that. My Lords, these changes are, as the report points out, just two elements of possible reform. Prominent among the rest, as many have mentioned, is the ability of Prime Ministers and party leaders to treat peerages as a tool of patronage, something that has been exacerbated recently by a rapid turnover in Prime Ministers.

My Lord, my Lords, rather like in the Lord of the Ring, the ring of power once obtained and wielded becomes very precious, very hard to give up. I believe that at least for those who accept the existence of an appointed rather than elected House, this wielding of patronage is the greatest single issue for reform, and that's reflected in the many comments we've had tonight. Its continuance is in part due to the difficulty in creating an alternative that addresses the "who appoints the appointers" test. But my Lords, while I still hope that the House will grip this, I am straying from the subject of this debate.

As regards next steps, my Lords, we have a track record in commissioning reviews, notably the Burns report, and then simply shelving them. I really do hope that we can do better this time. My Lords, we should not let perfect be the enemy of good. Implementing this report's findings will represent definite progress in line with manifesto commitments. In short, I congratulate the committee on the report, I repeat my hope that we can get it implemented, and I look forward to hearing the winding up comments from the noble Baroness the leader of the house.

05:28:24 - 05:32:18

Margaret Mary Sheila Lawlor

My Lords, it's a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, and I thank the committee for its thoughtful work and its thoughtful report on the manifesto commitment that peers retire at 80, and the implications of such a retirement age and of participation in the functioning of this house. But I echo some of the concerns that have been expressed about the remit to which the committee was made to work, about the appearance of seeming to do a deal to manage the government's manifesto commitment, and thus sidestepping the law. I am glad my noble friend Lord Wolfson reminded us that we must obey the law. If change is to be made, I would prefer to have a full piece of legislation which can have an explanatory memo, consultation, scrutiny, and debate. There are reasons principle to be against the proposed changes.

We no longer nationally have a retirement age at which people can be forced to give up a job, except in a few professions as we've heard today. A formal retirement age constitutes discrimination on account of age, which we should reject as firmly as we reject discrimination on grounds of race or sex. If someone does not do a job as well, that is a good reason for removing them. Their reaching a certain age is not. Age does not stop, as we've heard today, does not stop people from doing a job well.

Often older people, often older people do a job best. I think this is the case in the complex job we do in the House of Lords, where experience and sagacity are needed. Even if a retirement age is introduced by law for peers, I would suggest that it is combined with a fixed term minimum membership of 15 or 20 years. These were mentioned in the report as suggestions when it considered fixed term membership in general. This would mean that those who come to the Lords later in life can play their proper role and allow the nation to benefit from their expertise.

Like all jobs, membership of this house is a constant learning curve. It takes time for peers to learn about each bill, about each government, about each parliament, and the workings of the house, and to perform them effectively.

And finally, as part of the UK Parliament, itself one of the three constitutional powers, our role is that of a complementary legislative power in scrutinising legislation, revising it to make the laws better, and holding government to account or asking the other House to think again. We should be wary of changes that undermine the ability of peers to do their work, and our main question in thinking about retirement and participation should be what arrangements best facilitate the work done by the House. For these reasons, I fear that the recommendations in the report raise too many concerns for us to support it.

05:32:18 - 05:36:42

Deborah Bull

My Lords, I join other noble Lords in thanking the committee and indeed its chair for taking on the task and for their report, which I widely, which I generally welcome. The size of the House was one of three rationale for reform in the 2024 manifesto, and I do share the regret that the committee had no mandate to tackle what is surely the fundamental problem, that any retirement measures we put in place will have limited effect on size without corresponding measures on the numbers that come in. The data since 2024 demonstrate this problem. When the manifesto described the Lords as too big, there were 785 eligible members. Even with the removal of the hereditary peers, the chamber today is bigger than it was then, and all but two of the new appointments arrived through prime ministerial patronage.

I also share concerns about the impact of age-based retirement on the balance of the House. The analysis already mentioned from Professor Meg Russell suggests that the crossbenchers will indeed be hit hardest, reduced by 61% by 2034. And with no agreed formula for HOLAC appointments, the refreshing of these benches will be dependent on the will of the party in power, and here history gives little cause for optimism. The last five years have just seen have seen just eight HOLAC appointees. Does the noble lady the Leader of the House agree that without a step change over the five years ahead, the valuable contribution of these benches will be seriously diminished?

But my Lords, we also need to be mindful of how age-based retirement impacts on the skills and the diversity of our membership. I firmly believe this House will only be fully effective if it is fully diverse, and it is without doubt more diverse now than it has ever been. Yet even with these advances, the combined effect of our procedures, our timetable, and the allowance system still force an unhappy trade-off between socio-economic diversity, age, regional background, and attendance. Put simply, anyone who is in early to mid-career, needing to juggle income generation with family or caring responsibilities, had better live within the M25 if they're going to meet participation requirements while simultaneously working enough hours to pay a mortgage, accrue a pension, and be home in time to look after their dependents. And that's before we even consider maternity leave, sick pay, or paid parental leave, all statutory rights for most people of working age.

The report does acknowledge the impact of a participation requirement on peers in early stage careers or on those who come from outside the South East, but it is silent on this more complex issue of intersectionality. And yet, this House needs members who bring a range of overlapping backgrounds, identities, and experiences.

Intersectional representation broadens the range of perspectives that we bring to legislation and to policy. It enhances the effectiveness of our scrutiny and our oversight. I do fully support a requirement on participation, partly because as a HOLAC appointee, like the noble and learned lady Baroness Butler-Sloss, I always understood that fulfilling this role meant turning up and contributing. And partly I support it because non-participation so seriously damages public perception of this House. My point is that we need to face up to the ways in which our processes and practices already create barriers to participation and then consider the impact of any changes, not just on diversity, but on intersectionality too.

And so, my Lords, I welcome this report in as far as its remit allows it to go. But I end by circling back to the point on which I began. If this House is to play its part in fixing the mechanisms out, we should insist that government plays its part and fixes the mechanisms in.

05:36:42 - 05:36:51

Speaker 103

I thank the noble Lords who served on the committee, ably chaired by the noble Baroness Lady, um, sorry, that's gone completely out of my head, sorry.

05:36:52 - 05:41:47

Anne Thérèse Coffey

Taylor of Bolton, apologies. My Lords, participation I believe is more important than age. There's certainly no age limit on becoming a Member of Parliament, and there are plenty there intending to continue to be an MP after the age of 80, but of course that is the decision of their electorate. I'll start with a few other things. The leave of absence.

I would like to suggest to the House that it should only really be available for those people who are ill, those people who are still working in the diplomatic service or working in the Royal Household. I don't see why anybody else should have leave of absence at all. If they want to be part of this House, it's the second House, it's got a legislative purpose, they should be here, or at least turn up. And if we are not intending to remove leave of absence for those people who choose to not spend their time here at all, then I think that we should apply the full declaration, registration of interests just the same as anybody else. There's no reason why they should be any different.

My Lords, in terms of voting, I'm a great believer in voting, of course I would be, in terms of how many times we have voted in this House in the last, in the first session. I think it's fair to say that there are people who have never voted and have never spoken in that first session. There are 16 of those, and half have joined the House since 2019. 25 peers hadn't voted at all. 89 peers voted fewer than 10 times.

And so it goes on. And I appreciate that there are several people, particularly crossbenchers, I think this is recognized in paragraph 108, don't necessarily feel comfortable on voting. But that is why we are here, we're legislators. So I'd like to see a little bit more about participation and a requirement on perhaps, perhaps a modest number of having to do at least 10 votes in a session. My Lords, I was a bit disappointed earlier this year, in March and April, two peers turned up just a few weeks before the House rose, went to prorogation.

One peer had served in this House for 20 years, the other for 30 years. They turned up on that day, I'm not sure I've seen them since, just so they could meet that one element there. In terms of the fewer than 20% sitting days, again the 24-26 session, on the figures I was given by the House library, 116 people were not here, were for fewer than 20% of the sitting days for which they're eligible. I'm not talking about people who arrived in whenever it was, March earlier this year, it's about what they were eligible to do.

48 were crossbenchers, 28 Conservative, 10 non-affiliated, 10 Labour, including a minister, 3 Liberal Democrats, and indeed 17 bishops. Of those, 28 of those are over 88 years old, 15 less than 55 years old, and so on. So I guess I'm coming back to why we're here. And I do believe it's more than just giving an opinion, giving an opinion of a select committee. We could ask people to give that anyway.

We can invite them to be a witness. I think it is really about the scrutiny of what is happening with the government and with the legislation and indeed their manifesto that they are trying to deliver. Now I do respect what has been said that it's in the manifesto about 80. I do remind people, sorry, noble Lords, that of course one Parliament cannot bind its successor. But that's a matter for us I think to consider carefully because I'm conscious that we don't just want however long War and Peace is in manifestos in the future on exactly what a government wants to do or not.

I was really struck by the noble Lord Lord Rooker's speech yesterday. I appreciate it's a repeat of one he'd given earlier. And there is an issue about how much legislation is suddenly going through at report stage. And I know it's not new, but I genuinely believe it's got worse. I used to be a whip in the Commons and I did some comparisons.

The Commons were taking twice as long to do bills of similar size and the impact was that actually this House was doing far fewer days than it is doing at the moment. We do have the Lord Privy Seal and the Government Chief Whip sitting on the Cabinet Committee and I do encourage them to think carefully about how we can get that balance right for future. I appreciate in the first two years governments want to get their legislation through quickly. But that's the other final point, my Lords. Governments will continue to appoint people here if they keep losing votes.

There's no doubt about that. So I think we need to just be mindful as we move forward on these big changes and again I come back to participation is more important than age.

05:41:47 - 05:45:14

Francis Hare

My Lords, it's getting late in the evening, so I've cut, you'll be pleased to hear, what I was going to say. I start with the report itself. I was a member of the committee and I've been quite surprised by some of the comments because on the committee there were four members of the government, four members of the opposition, two members of the Liberal Democrat party and two members of the crossbenchers of whom I was one. And the report was agreed and not only because of the skillful chairmanship of Lady Taylor. Many times this evening it's been said that we're a self-governing House and we all subscribe to that, which is why I think this report is pragmatic, practical, modest, reflective of a manifesto commitment while not, while accepting it's not the business of a select committee to implement a manifesto commitment, but softening the edges of that commitment in such a way that we would hope, and I refer to what Lord Grocott said, that we avoid a simplistic law coming from the other place which we would not welcome.

I think we also need to listen to ourselves. I have to say I find it arrogant to assume that major damage will be caused by the gradual retirement, and I use that word deliberately, of current members. What price recent experience, fresh generational perspectives, employment recently, experience in cyber, in AI, in younger perspectives? Of course it'll be a sad loss to say goodbye to some of our members, as it was to say goodbye to so many of our hereditary friends.

We liked them, they contributed in most cases and we miss them. But here I'm going to quote Dylan Thomas again, like Lord True did, in which he equated death with leaving the house. There's a further quotation from that poem which goes like this: Wise men at their end know dark is right. Three things I'd like to mention which were not in the remit, inevitably, the- of the committee, inevitably the house would have liked us in different ways to do things we weren't asked to do. Very briefly, the first, which lots of people have mentioned, is how people arrive here.

What Lord Burns recommended, one in for two out, about 600, still looks appealing. Secondly, HOLAC, please can the shackles be removed so it can go back to a few more people than two. Thirdly, from my recollection of the committee, it wasn't about capacity, it was about retirement age. We talked about capacity and at one stage we had a draft paragraph, but given that the house authorities themselves are addressing the issue, we didn't pursue- perceive it. I hope the house will approve the principle of this report and I recommend it.

05:45:14 - 05:50:56

Charles John Fuller

My Lords, I was new then, but I'm reminded of the March 2024 debate in the Moses Room on veterinary medicine regulations, which was going nowhere until a cross-bench Baroness told us she was the retired president of the Royal Society of Veterinary Surgeons, she proposed a course of action and of course we did that. My Lords, that noble lady only needed to come once in that session and she would have earned her corn because participation in and of itself isn't the point of this house, nor as the noble lady Baroness Taylor said, is attendance, but we must recognize that not all participation is equal. Now I don't come from that far away, I come from Norfolk, but it's just impractical to commute daily when a debate can keep you late and then you've got to get to Liverpool Street on the Circle Line, it's crazy. So my wife and I, we bought somewhere near in Handsworth to help me attend regularly. But for plenty of others, this proposal is at risk of reinforcing the already overweight proportion of peers from London and the South East over those who live in the sticks and other far-flung places.

You see, there's a world of difference between nipping in on the District Line from Fulham and making the slog from York, Norfolk, Penzance, Edinburgh, or particularly Northern Ireland, because minimum attendance quotas work against the richness this house gains from the devolved nations within our United Kingdom. I thought we had a Prime Minister who wanted to have all the nations represented, all regions too, but the committee's proposals will deliver the worst and make it harder, as the noble Baroness Lady Bull said, to bring those who work and want to bring their current experience to the legislature. Now I approached this consultation on this report and I started with the data. Now the die had already been cast for the hereditaries, so I excluded them from a spreadsheet that I cobbled together myself from different sources, including from the library. My Lords, it is a source of deep regret that the committee did not make a full data set available to all noble Lords so we could do our own analysis, as it seems the cross-benchers did for themselves.

This data should have been provided but was not. But what did I find when attempting to analyze that data? Well, take the arbitrary cutoff of 80 years. I won't repeat the data, but a third of noble lords would go. For those aged 77 or over today, they're in the cart.

But the decimation of life peers is not uniform by party. My analysis shows that 27% of the Conservative members would suffer enforced retirement, but 37% of Labour, 42% of the Liberal Democrats, and 45%, nearly half, of the crossbenchers. We've heard about the need for special treatment for the crossbenchers, but no one's mentioned in my hearing about the Northern Irish, who would be absolutely, completely, and totally decimated by this proposal. This is a material change in the composition, tone, and expertise. It's a blunt instrument.

It wouldn't just affect the individuals, it would affect the balance of the House. The committee should have spelled this out more clearly. Now let's look at gender. Of the 773 members at the time the committee sat, excluding the hereditaries, a third are women. But when we look at the party breakdowns, yes, a third of Conservative baronesses would be expelled, but 43% of the Liberal Democrats and 45% of Labour baronesses would be forcibly evicted.

This would further aggravate the existing gender balance. And uncharacteristically, I find myself agreeing with Lord Sikka on this point. Now let's move on to experience. Unsurprisingly, those with the longest service tend to be the oldest. Of those who have served more than 15 years, the average age is 77, the average age of the House.

But this indicates to me that if past experience is taken as a guide, then on average, by arithmetic, nearly everyone who has completed 15 years will be out. My lords, 15-year term limits have been discounted, but the arithmetic shows that retirement at 80 produces 15-year term limits by other means. Let's look at those second-order consequences, with the shortest proposals for the R and R on a full decant being much more than 15 years. We risk losing our entire oral history if mandatory retirement is forced at 80. Forced retirement at 80 and the arithmetic tells us there would be nobody to come back who could remember the old days.

Let's just let that sink in. My lords, we're volunteers who bring our outside experience on the days we contribute. When we don't attend, we don't get paid. There's no prejudice there. But if you have onerous minimum attendance requirements or other participation needs, then we start to become employees, subject to HR and all the stuff that comes with it, including a ban on zero hours.

And of course, we are the original zero-hours people. Would Fridays be included? With the average age of baronesses being 68, we still have some of childbearing age. Where is the thought given to maternity rights and the needs to look after a very young family? Another point I'm in total accord with Baroness Bull on.

My lords, these are big changes with unknown consequences. We're shooting in the dark without the data. There's a lot of opinion but precious little analysis of the second-order consequences, and we should have expected that in this report.

05:50:56 - 05:56:20

Philip Hunt

Well, my lords, rather like Strathclyde, I came into the House, I was well under the average age of your lordship's House, in fact 30 years under. Sadly, my lords, I am now over the average age and under these proposals will retire from your lordship's House in 2033. But my lords, I welcome it. Retirement is a fact of life for most jobs, most professions, as Baroness Hamee said. And my lords, I welcome the certainty it gives me, planning my future life.

My Lords, there is life after the House of Lords, and I'm rather looking forward to it. And for me, the proposals in the report, they're well-judged. They allow for a transition which is not overly generous. They reduce our size to a more manageable level. They allow an opportunity to refresh our membership, and they deal sensitively in a way with the capacity issue.

And my Lords, I would say to Lord True, he set the challenge very early on, hours ago, that I think it does enhance this House's ability to scrutinize legislation, which, and this is where I very much agree with my noble friend Lord Rooker, becomes ever more important the more we can see the failure of the House of Commons to scrutinize legislation. My Lords, I always welcome Lord True's contributions. His affection for this House is always readily evident, but I did think his language was unfortunate when he talked about expulsion, a monster cull, a purge of a major cohort. I do think that was rather overblown. And he then referred to hereditary peers, and it's a point my noble friend Lord Grocott made, my Lords.

If only the noble Lord True had supported my noble friend in his efforts to remove the elections for future hereditary peers when some died, my Lords, we wouldn't have had the cliff edge that we had with the loss of so many hereditary peers at one moment. And the lesson for me, my Lords, here is that incremental reform is the way forward in the absence of substantive proposals. I see this as a sensible incremental reform. And I have to say to Lord True, I did think his response was as dispiriting as it was predictable. My Lords, would legislation be desirable?

Well, be careful what you wish for. I think this is a matter we should handle ourselves, and it's an example of the House taking the initiative. Will paragraph 85 hold? Well, this House is well used to operating on conventions and understandings. I think it would hold, and that members would accept the principle of the retirement.

My Lords, I'm confident too that when it comes to the issue of future membership and size, I would just say to Conservative members, their fear that the Prime Minister will flood the House with Labour peers, I'd just say I think their argument would be rather more convincing if Mr. Johnson, if Liz Truss, and Mr. Sunak had followed Mrs. May in showing restraint in appointments. On Lord Hamilton's plea that reductions in size should be, should occur through elections, I would just say to him, if I can see him, I would just say to him that I was here in 1999 when the hereditary elections took place. My Lords, it was not a pleasant sight. And thinking about how these elections would operate amongst parties, the fact is that there would be grandstanding in the chamber all during the period of elections. There would be slates, there would be rival slates, and actually the whips would actually have an undue influence because that is inevitable how it would be conducted.

I do not think that that would be a wise thing to do at all. I acknowledge this is not substantive reform.

I might anticipate what Lord Purvis is going to say in his wind-up. I would just say to him that the reason the Clegg Bill failed largely was because he never worked out what the respective powers of two elected chambers should be, what the relationship should be, what that would mean in terms of disputes about whether we needed a written constitution or not. And we will never ever deal and bring substantive reform forward unless we really tackle those hard issues. So, my Lords, finally I would just say I hope my noble friend will listen to the crossbenchers in terms of future balance of size. Overall, this is such a sensible report.

I hope my noble friend will agree to speed on with these proposals, and I hope your Lordships as a whole will support them.

05:56:20 - 06:01:11

Richard Dannatt

My Lords, it's a great pleasure to follow the typically very energetic Lord Hunt. I enjoyed his contribution as ever. And may I be yet another person to add my congratulations to the committee and in particular its redoubtable chair, Baroness Taylor of Bolton, who must have been in a great sea of ideas and proposals and statistics and somehow managed to find the islands of consensus in that. So quite an achievement. My Lords, we had a major debate on House of Lords reform in November 2024.

And in that debate, I advocated a transitional arrangement for the retirement age whereby only new members were subject to the retirement age. I also advocated a participation rate of 10%. This number being set to take account of the low-frequency, high-impact members who, because of their professional careers, find it harder to attend. The report has come down in a slightly different place on both these issues. With a 20% participation rate, the crossbench with our larger number of low-frequency, high-impact members would need to manage their attendances most carefully.

And I have looked at this a lot, but I assess this as being difficult but possible. The first proposed mini cliff-edge on age of July 2029 is in terms of managing the bench strength of the House frighteningly near. Appendix 5 makes it clear there could be 135 gaps. And when one looks at the actual names, some of the names bring great expertise and experience here, and we would need to replace that. And thinking on how to ensure that the House retains its necessary skill and experience base would need to start very soon.

I and others therefore believe that the date of July 2029 could not be wisely brought closer than that for that reason. I come to the issue peculiar to the crossbench, and it concerns of course the supply of replacement members for us. We receive today about two-thirds of our members directly from the Prime Minister's office and his list as it were, and about one-third who begin in HOLAC. We are today actually 19.4% of the House, so we're below the 20% which was the number that was suggested and accepted in the Burns process. And I think there's a logic behind that.

But we will lose in the first tranche up to 37 members in July 2029. And we heard from the excellent speech and all of the data for which I'm very grateful to the noble Lord Lord Patel right at the start of this debate just how significantly horrible it is for us. We therefore need a supply of replacements. And ensuring that we have appropriate new members with appropriate skills and expertise will greatly benefit our House. And HOLAC in particular has been very successful at finding good colleagues.

And I know has many suitable applicants for whom there is no place.

And I'm looking forward very much to the noble Baroness the Leader's comments on this most important area for us and I think for the House. In that constitutional debate of November 2023, I described the Prime Minister's prerogative as the biggest unfairness in all of the various arrangements that we have in our House. The power of one person, the Prime Minister, irrespective of the size or state of their majority, to appoint as many members as they like to this legislature is outsized and without precedent in any other liberal democracy. At this time of challenged political stability, there is, I feel, a very strong case for the revision of this prerogative so that it cannot be misused following a future general election. It is something of great importance to this House, to Parliament and to the country in general.

And I'm hoping we will hear some comments from the Leader, and I do feel it is time to have a cross-party discussion about this without any preconditions. In closing, I would be in favour of treading down the path that the committee has outlined, acknowledging the legal risk that Lord Wolfson of Tredegar and others have pointed out. But I say this feeling there must be associated clarity on the crossbench replacements, and most importantly, there has to be action and discussions on the Prime Minister's prerogative.

06:01:11 - 06:07:05

Charles John Fuller

I'm sure that all noble Lords will recognize how delighted I was when I saw that I was going to be the final backbench contributor in this long debate today. But I understand that my claim to fame may have been pinched by my noble friend Lady Hooper, who will be speaking in the gap. I'm grateful to have the opportunity to speak in this debate following my service on the committee, and I would like to take this opportunity to thank my fellow committee members, our chair, the noble Baroness Lady Taylor of Bolton, and of course to the excellent House of Lords team that supported the committee during its deliberations. I approached my own contribution to the committee's task wearing a collaborative hat. Nevertheless, I think it is important to establish that this collaborative view was taken on the basis of the task that had been set out by the noble lady the Leader of the House, that the committee was created in order to come up with a feasible alternative to the government's manifesto commitment to introduce a retirement age of 80 and to create a new level of participation.

I think we have done exactly that. May I, my Lords, make my own position clear. I would personally not wish to see any introduction of a retirement age. I think many peers over 80 years of age make a valuable contribution to the work of the House, as has been demonstrated in the debate we are having today. Equally, I did not support the changes to the hereditary peers serving in your Lordship's House, another manifesto commitment, but that argument was lost.

Reforming this House requires care. But care, as I've had to remind myself, should not become an excuse for inaction. The public are entitled to expect us to examine our own arrangements with the seriousness we bring to legislation affecting everyone else. For me, the test was straightforward: would these changes impact the ability of the House to carry out its work effectively while at the same time strengthening confidence in the institution? The committee's principal retirement proposal is an age limit of 80, phased in for existing members from the 8th of July 2029.

The initial threshold would be 85, falling annually until it reaches 80 in July 2034. That timetable would apply irrespective of when the next general election is held.

As my noble friend Lord Wolfson has said, there is an important distinction in implementation. For existing members, the committee proposes a resolution expressing the House's expectation that they should retire, and this of course would depend on cooperation from members and party groups, but it would not, however, override the statutory rights of noble Lords. New members would be given a written undertaking before receiving their peerage to retire by their 80th birthday, and breaching that undertaking could attract sanctions including expulsion. We should, my Lords, be candid about what this means. If the House chooses a system founded on cooperation, each of us must take responsibility for making it work.

Agreeing a resolution would be the beginning of that responsibility. I also recognize that retirement is a deeply personal matter. A member may have devoted decades to public service and still feel capable of contributing. Any change should therefore be implemented with dignity. We can uphold a common rule while still expressing gratitude to those affected by it.

The second main proposal concerns participation: attendance on at least 20% of sitting days averaged over two sessions. This requirement would be implemented through standing orders using existing statutory sanctioning powers with expulsion for failure to comply. Members on leave of absence would be exempt and exceptional circumstances would be considered through a separate process. I would hope that anyone accepting a place in your Lordships' House does so with an ambition to contribute substantially. Equally, we should ask whether our rules allow someone with valuable experience to combine parliamentary service with continuing responsibilities elsewhere.

A doctor, an employer, or a charity leader may bring particular insight precisely because they remain engaged in that work. The challenge is to secure a dependable commitment while preserving that connection. Alongside these changes, the committee's reports deals with capacity issues and raises concerns about members on leave of absence retaining access without registering financial interests. Finally, the report cautions that departures will not reduce the size of the House if they simply enable additional appointments. That point deserves a clear response from His Majesty's Government.

Members who are being asked to accept changes to their own service should be able to see how those changes contribute to a coherent approach to the future of your Lordships' House. My Lords, I support taking these proposals forward. They are perhaps a start of a process. Their success, however, will depend on clear rules, fair administration, and a willingness to honor the commitments we made. We have an opportunity to demonstrate that this House can address difficult questions about its own future responsibility, and in my view we should take this opportunity.

If we decide not to take it, then it would leave the government entirely free to implement its manifesto pledge to introduce a retirement age of 80 by primary legislation, and it would have every right to do so and could do so under the Salisbury Convention.

06:07:05 - 06:09:18

Gloria Hooper

My Lords, my thanks for the opportunity to speak briefly in the gap and my apologies to my noble friend for pinching his slot. It's been a good and necessary debate with contributions from the youngest member, Baroness Smith, as well as a number of fully competent and coherent older members. And I of course must declare a personal interest in this respect.

I'm told that I'm now the longest serving woman peer. Not the oldest, the longest serving. I was introduced in June 1985. And like the noble Lord, Lord Dubs, I still consider it to be a great privilege to serve in your Lordship's House. During my 41 years here, I have spent seven years on the government front bench as a minister in three departments.

I subsequently served as a Deputy Speaker for 25 years. And I'm now much involved in a lot of behind-the-scenes activities in the field of international relations as an active member of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association and the Inter-Parliamentary Union as well as various APPGs. I also have two motions for debate, for balloted debate on the order paper. There are many ways of participating in the work of Parliament. But my Lords, I end by reminiscing, if I may.

When I first nervously answered questions as a minister way back in 1985, I was asked a supplementary by the noble Lord, Lord Shinwell, better known as Manny Shinwell. He was then 101. So whilst I may support some of the measures in this report, I have no intention of retiring before I'm at least 101 to preserve party balance, of course.

06:09:18 - 06:21:09

Jeremy Purvis

It is a pleasure to follow the noble lady who spoke in the gap. I have the, she knows that I have the highest admiration for the work she does and the utmost affection. And she has been and continues to be an outstanding ambassador for Parliament as a whole, not just for this House, especially in Latin America and the work that she does in that. I am in awe of the service that she has done. Notwithstanding the fact that this is a government manifesto commitment, these benches have decided that this is now a House issue.

And thus if it comes to a point where we will be making decisions on a way forward, each of my colleagues will vote on their own judgment rather than there being a whipped line. There is, however, widespread support among my colleagues for the work that my noble friends Baroness Parminter and Baroness Suttie have done on the work of the committee so ably chaired by the noble lady Baroness Taylor. And not only for the conclusions that the committee has reached, but the means by which they've done it and the consensus that they have sought. My noble friend Baroness Parminter spoke succinctly and clearly right at the beginning of this debate a number of hours ago, and I agree with every word that she said. The noble Lord Hunt very politely pre-butted a speech I wasn't intending to make.

But these benches do believe that this House should be fundamentally reformed. Our country's legislature should be democratically chosen. And we believe, as others have mentioned in this debate, that there should be an opportunity for fundamental reform. Some have asked in this debate about these proposals, what is the problem that we are seeking to solve, the noble Lord Howard and others. And indeed they were asking what the problem is of this House.

A number of years ago, the Conservative manifesto for the 2010 election had come to that conclusion and answered his question.

And I quote from it. This is the Conservative manifesto. We will work to build a consensus for a mainly elected second chamber to replace the current House of Lords, recognizing that an efficient and effective second chamber should play an important role in our democracy and requires both legitimacy and public confidence. Perhaps the problem that continues to burden us is that of legitimacy and public confidence. We've heard of the need, and I agree with it, for a second chamber to be efficient.

Many made the case for reform, and others, however, said that it would be wholly wrong to break the link of a life peerage and a lifetime right to sit in this House. As most things about debates about our House that we've had today, rarely there is much new. The House had previously passed, after seven days of debate, a resolution which stated: one, that a strong and efficient second chamber is not merely an integral part of the British constitution, but is a necessary to the well-being of the state and to the balance of Parliament; two, that such a chamber can best be obtained by reform and reconstitution of the House of Lords; and three, that a necessary preliminary of such reform and reconstitution is the acceptance of the principle that the possession of a peerage should no longer in itself give the right to sit and vote in the House of Lords. This was from 1910, and the last part was almost identical to what the noble Lord the Duke of Wellington was calling for in this debate today, and I agree with him. Moving the debate on that resolution was the Earl of Rosebery from the crossbenches at that point in 1910.

And I just wanted to quote as when he was introducing what he said. Because we've heard from the noble Lord True and others that it is to change the link between the peerage and the ability to sit in this House by right and not alter that either by retirement or by participation would be constitutionally improper and anomalous. The Earl Rosebery said in the debate, I quote from Hansard: "After all, nothing can be so anomalous as the British constitution itself." "We are afraid to introduce new principles into it, but really, when you come to analyze the constitution itself, one might be inclined to think that a little novelty might to some extent improve it." This indeed is a novelty that we are seeking to improve it, and 116 years later, this novelty perhaps is a little bit overdue.

But more recently, for 50 years, some who sit in this House have served under age limits as a result of an innovation. I personally don't believe there should be reserved seats for the established church of a nation south of the border where I live, but as with judges and the bishops, there seems to have become a settled view that age limits are appropriate and connected to efficiency and effectiveness. And indeed the debates in the Synod in 1975, which I read, were sensitive, which were pragmatic, and came to a conclusion that retirement linked with sitting in this House was appropriate 51 years ago. And as with judges, the reforms in 1959 introduced by a Conservative government to introduce age limits for those senior judges was debated sensitively but pragmatically and with a degree of self-awareness, which in the kindest possible way I agree with the noble lady, my lady Baroness Manningham-Buller, who indicated that we sometimes should see ourselves for the reality of how representative we are in society.

In 1959, the then Conservative government decided that for senior judges, the retirement age of 75 should be put in place. Of interest in that debate, as we've heard today, it was the settled will that it was the appropriate age collectively of that profession for those that apply the law. We're simply suggesting that we should consider for those who make the law also. Viscount Kilmuir, introducing the measure, Lord Chancellor, said on the 8th of December 1959: "I would also put this point, that there is no more difficult problem in life than to judge one's own dispensability and expendability. We all find it, and some of us find that that problem gets more difficult as the years advance.

But I ask your Lordships to face up to the existence of that psychological problem." We need to do that in this House today also. Now we have for those that apply the law, and we should also for those who make the law. This inevitably will mean that some valued colleagues will be retiring. And the noble Lord Grocott, in his shrewd contribution, as all of his are, asked us to consider the time when we might have to cope of life without him in this House.

I personally will grieve when he leaves this House, because I'm a great admirer of his. Lord Johnson indicated that Lord Hamilton's family might have to cope with him being with his family on retirement. So we've had both sides of the argument, but I'm certain that both this House and Lord Hamilton's family will manage to cope in both of those circumstances. Baroness Smith made the point that this reform should not be simply about making space, but it should fundamentally be about effectiveness and efficiency, and I agree with that. We heard from the noble Lord Kerr and the noble Lord Burns about the previous attempts for reforms about the size of this House.

We've always shared that view. I would point out to Lord Kerr that our size of the Liberal Democrat benches are now exactly what they would have been if the Burns review had been implemented in full. And I'm certain both noble Lords would not wish our size of our benches in particular to be diminished for any reforms going forward. I'm sure that they'll agree with us on that one. When it came to the issue of age, I have to confess I was not expecting Dolly Parton to be mentioned in the debate today, but the noble Lady Watkins did.

I was trying to think of something witty to say, but I'm thinking that us working nine to five might be a bit of a stretch when we're... yes, okay, I'll move on. So we heard about the difficult issue of how representative we are as a non-elected chamber. Now Lord True did make the point, and I do share it, that a key part of our society and the elderly need to be represented. But I think that we should be a touch cautious to say that only the elderly in society can be represented by the elderly in this House. We can't really persuasively make that argument unless you also argue that young people are all... can only be represented by young people in this House.

If you hold that argument, then when I entered this House, I was only one of two members out of the entire House under 40, who had... and both of us had to share the burden of representing 49% of the country's population. So we can't automatically make a direct link of the age of our profile here and those that we represent in society.

I also think that we must be cautious of the argument that if the committee's proposals are taken forward, that we will enter a constitutionally wrong type of expulsion, cull, sackings, or purges, as we've heard referred to. Obviously, there will be a collective view about what an appropriate level of participation would be, as well as those who would be participating in it. The committee, I think, should be commended for doing the difficult task which has beset us for many years, as the noble lady Baroness Coffee had indicated, of what is the appropriate means by which we recognize ourselves as legislators, not as a voluntary think tank. Now, the setting of a 20% participation rate over two sessions, I think is reasonable. I personally believe going forward this should be the floor and not the ceiling of what we should be expecting participation to be in a parliament, because we have a great responsibility to be legislators, and active participation is required.

My Lords, we on these benches will work constructively going forward. We do wish to see reform, and what we will try to do is to reflect the way that the committee worked constructively to try to find a way forward with the correct tone, with sensitivity, with a degree of pragmatism, but also try and approach as much as possible a consensual way the way that the committee established. I commend them for their work and I hope to see progress.

06:21:09 - 06:23:46

Jane Scott

My Lords, this has been a considered debate and I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton, for the careful way in which she opened our debate. But my Lords, the fact that we have once again spent an entire day of precious parliamentary time debating our future as a house will be surprising for those outside this chamber. Businesses and employers might have expected us to be debating national insurance, the job-killing employment rights act, and some of the highest energy costs in Europe. Farmers may have expected us to be focusing on food security and the family farm tax. And most importantly, hardworking families might have expected us to be debating energy bills, personal taxation, housing delivery, and rising unemployment.

But my Lords, the future of this house is important. Any change to the rules by which we govern ourselves, no matter how important the issue it seeks to resolve, must be weighed against the imperative that we must preserve our ability to do our duty as a house and hold any government to account. My Lords, across the house, I think we've heard a number of themes begin to emerge in our debate today. We've heard how these proposals will have a disproportionate impact on the crossbenches. If both rules were applied as of today, 30.5% of the house would be affected, but my Lords, that rises to 46.6% of crossbenchers.

And my noble friend Lady Eden raised the issue, the important issue of effective running of this house, and particularly about effective committees in the house, should many of our so experienced peers be expelled. A number of peers also raised the lack of clarity about the problem we are actually trying to solve with these proposals. My noble friend Lord Howard of Rising reminded us just how many peers are actually present in the average division. By that measure, the house is clearly, my Lords, not too large.

06:23:34 - 06:27:23

Speaker 117

Sadly, my Lords, the Labour Party's manifesto gave no evidence for its claim that the second chamber of Parliament has become too big, and I quote. It merely gave its unevidenced diagnosis and prescribed a mandatory retirement age. And my noble friend, and my noble friend Lord Howard of Lympne told the House that it's not for this House to obstruct the government's manifesto commitments, but it is not incumbent on us to expedite the government's measures by amending our own rules in this House. The bitter taste of discrimination has been remarked upon in by many noble Lords in this session. In the last session, members of your Lordships' House were expelled simply because they were of the wrong sort of peer.

This session, we're being asked to expel noble Lords because they are of the wrong age, not that they have a lack of capacity to do the job. As we've heard from so many noble Lords this afternoon, and I thought the noble Lord Lord Sikka spoke eloquently on this point, and I hope his noble friends will listen to him. My Lords, why can't we find a way to deal with capability? Why do we have to use age? Two tests are proposed in this bill, my Lords, age and participation.

The participation proposal is born of understandable concerns. The committee was right to reject a speaking requirement which would only serve to encourage performative contributions. Mandatory attendance is not without its negative consequences either. Fundamentally, it is a good thing that noble Lords who are experts and still working at the top of their respective professions may come to the House when they have something to say without having to clock in to retain the right to do so in the future. Equally, my Lords, there are some peers who come to the House so infrequently that they make no real contribution to our public life.

So the principle of participation is not unsupportable, but its implementation, my Lords, must not weaken the House. Turning to age, a mandatory age limit for sitting members of your Lordships' House was a commitment made in a discredited manifesto of a discredited Prime Minister who no longer holds high office. The noble Lord Lord Rooker reminded us of how the manifesto was broken on the day the Chancellor moved to freeze the tax allowance. I wish Sir Keir Starmer well, of course I do, but his departure should give us pause for thought about how we go forward now. We on these benches have not sought to agree a collective position across our benches.

Slightly surprised from the party opposite that went through rather a lot of Prime Ministers, but I don't remember them somehow decalling the manifesto discredited at that stage. I'll ignore that comment. We on these benches have sought to agree a collective, not sought to agree a collective position across our benches. It is for noble Lords to come to their own view. Of course the front bench has a view, but we must always respect that of our backbenchers.

06:27:23 - 06:34:53

Speaker 114

But my Lords, it's not for a single House of Parliament to expel parliamentarians. This is a proposal that was being brought forward by the government. Let them bring forward a bill. It is for Parliament to decide. Indeed, as my noble friend the leader of the opposition said earlier in our debate, Parliament may wish to implement grandfather rights without opposing the government's plans for a mandatory retirement age.

That was the solution when the Irish representative peers were expelled, and it is what the House voted for during the progress of the House of Lords Hereditary Peers Act in 2026. We also know a resolution of the House would not prevent peers refusing to leave in line with the committee's proposals. Peers may fairly argue the test should be the competence, not the age of the peer. As the noble Lord Lord Blunkett referred to earlier, age is being mistaken for capacity. They may also argue that the other place has no mandatory age limit, so why should they not be voluntarily departing?

But my Lords, the thing is that all this is a recipe for a continuing rumbling discord in this House. If we are to have mandatory age, let the government bring it forward and allow both Houses to scrutinize it thoroughly. Perhaps the most painful part of the committee's report, my Lords, is the proposal that peers be expelled from the House mid-session once they reach the age of 80. But of course, grandfather rights would avoid that. Transitional arrangements are proposed in this report, but that does not mitigate the real impact mid-session expulsion will have on the work of peers.

If a peer knows that they are expected to leave the House in the middle of a session, that will disincentivize them from being involved in speaking at second reading and tabling amendments at committee stage in those final months of their public service. In that sense, our most experienced peers might step back sooner than they should, depriving the House of their wisdom and their good judgment. So therefore, my Lords, we must carefully consider all these issues. In the case of previous expulsions, which themselves caused real acrimony and unpleasantness, peers saw out the session. We oppose those expulsions, but the House at least accepted that peers must be given the opportunity to complete their current work before being forced to leave the House.

Surely that is the least we can do. Indeed, my Lords, we know that the average retirement age is not much over 80 at present, so therefore why are we doing this? We must balance the negative effect mid-session expulsion will have on the scrutinizing work of peers against the reality that these measures are solving a problem that exists in theory, but which on average will have very little impact. The impact of this change will not merely affect an average. It is not just a question of numbers.

Behind these statistics, we have heard today our noble Lords who have dedicated their lives to public service. Noble Lords who have known, worked with, agreed and disagreed with, and they are the people that we voted alongside for many years. The moment of their expulsion marks the end point of a long and distinguished career in public service, and we must consider the individual impact of these proposals and how that affects our work as a House.

They should be given the opportunity to complete their work as parliamentarians rather than be expelled suddenly as the guillotine falls. That would allow noble lords to bring their contribution to public life to an end in the way they wish, as they deserve, rather than being bound by an arbitrary date. My lords, the government's plans mean, as we've heard, the departure of the noble and gallant lord, Lord Craig of Radley, who won the house's support for his amendment, as we've also heard, in the Diego Garcia military base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill earlier this year. And as my noble friend Lord Howard of Rising reminded us, Lord Craig of Radley was 96 when he won that division. It will mean losing the expertise of my noble friend Lord Hunt of Wirral from the opposition front bench.

We have benefited from his extensive ministerial experience, and he helped lead the house in challenging the most damaging elements of the government's employment rights bill. Under this proposal, we will lose distinguished noble lords from the government benches too, the noble lord Lord Blunkett and the noble baroness Lady Beckett, both singled out for special praise by the Prime Minister in his first speech as the leader of the Labour Party in July. We will lose the noble lord Lord Rooker, who has so ably demonstrated his reputation as a defender of parliamentary scrutiny in recent weeks. The loss of noble lords across the house is not just a point of personal pain, although we on these benches do ask the government, what have they done wrong, these friends of ours? It has an impact on our work, my lords.

Losing the expertise of long-serving noble lords does risk the quality of our scrutiny. It is that effect that we should put at the forefront of our minds. My noble friend the leader of the opposition has set out four tests that we should consider in our deliberations. Will what we do improve the ability of the house to hold the government to account? Will it enrich the experience of the house?

Will it enhance the independence of the house from recent or present governments? And lastly, will it enable the house and its committees to do their revising work better? My lords, those are the tests we must apply before taking any decision on the future of our house, and we believe the proposals before us fail those tests.

06:34:53 - 06:39:24

Nicholas True

My lords, I think I want to start the speech by thanking my noble friend Baroness Taylor of Bolton and all members of the committee who took part in the deliberations. They carefully considered the issues. Many doubted that they could come back to this house in the time that was allocated with a proposal and with some consensus of a way forward that was workable. And it's only through the diligent work that they have undertaken that this report is before us today, and we should thank them and be grateful to them. I think all noble lords bar one did thank them for their work.

I have to say, my lords, listening to a broad, they listened to a broad range of views as I have tonight as well, and I think the government does welcome the approach they've taken and the spirit in which their report was produced.

We've seen past attempts at reform of this place and consensus often feels quite elusive. And, my Lords, and I think we should recognize that this report has found a way through that and that all members of the committee agreed with it. I've also been very interested to listen to all the contributions that have been made today. Of course, my Lords, this is a valuable revising and scrutinizing chamber with expertise and dedication to public service. But the expectations of our members is not just about experience, it is also and their expertise, it is also about their judgment through their life experience.

We don't just ask members with experience to only take part in debates on their area they know the most about. We have them here for their judgment. And I've referenced our manifesto, and I think the Labour manifesto at the last election was the first manifesto of which I'm aware that recognized explicitly the good work of many peers who improve the quality of legislation passed in Parliament. And the noble Lord asked me about form following function. My Lords, we're not, we're not dealing with the function, we are happy with the function of the House of Lords.

The criticism comes from how we are perceived and the way we are constituted. And over the years, looking at these issues, we have produced and debated numerous reports: the Cunningham report, the Burns report, the Wakeham report, now the Taylor report. Each has brought a different perspective to issues. But then the frustration starts, as Lord Burns alluded to very eloquently, how so little progress has been made. And I've spoken before about the track record of stagnation, stalled attempts at reform.

And I've been clear we want to work with the House to get a better outcome and how incremental change can make a difference. My Lords, the committee and many members have spoken, often have acknowledged that change is needed. And there's a general, but not universal I have to say, agreement that we do need that the House is too big, that we as we need more certainty about as noble Lords are leaving. The point made by many of the crossbenchers, we need that certainty when people are departing to look at how you can replace members and bring in new expertise and experience. We're also clear that we want to see an active contribution from all members of this House.

That's not to say that all members have to be full-time members of the House, that wouldn't serve the purposes of what we seek to achieve. But we want members to value their membership and contribute during their membership. And that's why we made a commitment to mandatory retirement age and participation requirement. Now, some of the arguments against taking any action on this report sounded very similar to those we've heard before when debating other changes. Noble Lady Scott said these proposals affect, I think she said 46% of the House.

She's wrong, my Lords. These proposals, I couldn't remember the exact percentage, whatever percentage you said, these proposals affect 100% of this House because every member of this House and future members would be affected by these proposals. They are completely non-discriminatory in that way. And my Lords, the other argument often used is don't make this reform until we've got lots of other reforms in place as well.

06:39:23 - 06:39:40

Speaker 114

They are discriminatory in the way that the fact that the people that are in here now came in not knowing that they were thinking they were staying for life, and the ones that will come in from now on will know that they finish at 80. That's the difference.

06:39:40 - 06:42:08

Nicholas True

Well said. It's that point, my Lords, because if you look at that, she's sort of implying there is no notice. That is the very reason why to give notice, that these proposals, it sounds like they're going to happen tomorrow, do not come into... I did not heckle the noble lady, she should listen as well. We did not... these proposals do not come into force or start to come into force until 2029, when there will be a retirement age of 85, which until goes down each year to 80 by 2033, or 34.

So, my Lords, just to make the point though, that every time a change is suggested, there's those who say, "Well, we want change, but not this change, in this way, and not now." And so, my Lords, I think often to survive and to do our best work, we have to embrace some kind of change. Now, noble Lords, Ashdown, Shobdon, and others, why did I set up this committee? And I think he attributed motives which I would dispute. Why?

One of our manifesto on Lords reform issues looked at certain stages, a number of issues are there. And when we were debating one of the earlier stages on hereditary peers, there were more amendments, there was more debate, there were more pages of amendments in Hansard about retirement age and participation. And a number of noble Lords on the other side spoke far more about that than they spoke about hereditary peers. Why aren't we doing anything about this? So, that's why I set up the committee.

I promised this House that rather than just bringing forward legislation, we would give this House the opportunity to examine and look at the issues, to give the House the opportunity, as noble Lords asked for, to take some responsibility. My Lords, no good deed goes unpunished, as it is. But, my Lords, it is an opportunity for us to look at this. So that was the first point. But also, I would have thought we would have learned a lesson from the hereditary peers legislation.

Time and time again, my noble friend Lord Grocott brought to this House proposed legislation to say, "We'll end the by-elections, which means no new hereditary peers come in, and those that are there remain." That was rejected time and time again by the party opposite when they were in government. That would have been a much smoother transition to take place. So the noble Lord wants to intervene on me, please do.

06:42:08 - 06:42:41

Speaker 119

I'd just say it was not a government whip that actually... it was not the party opposite, it was individual peers. It was a private member's bill, and private members had an authority to challenge the proposal of legislation. I'm sorry, I disagreed with them. I actually thought Lord Grocott, who is a friend of mine sitting opposite, was a... was right on this issue, and I felt he was right, but it was not a party thing. We are not dealing with this as a party, we're dealing with this...

I hope you respond.

06:42:41 - 06:47:55

Nicholas True

And I will do, but I've given the chance to. I will say the noble Lord True, when he was leader of the opposition, did tell me his party opposed it and it was not the party policy. I even offered and got support from the shadow cabinet for the legislation, and noble Lord will confirm it was rejected by the party opposite when they were in government. I was told it was a government did not want that policy. So I did try.

It would have been a better way forward. And that's why I thought this was a better way forward as well, let the House make decisions. And when we talk about we need legislation, and noble Lord Wolfson, I think paraphrased the report very well when he spoke, and he took the comments they'd made in the report about the issue of legislation.

Does this house really believe that there is a one clause bill that will introduce a retirement age that when it goes to the other end of the House of Commons, they're not going to change that number? I think it, I think this house could take responsibility and also show that we are able to do so. My lords, I hope that was the reasons why. The issue of size is an issue, but I, you know, if we're looking at the issue of the size of this house, as other noble lords have said, the way to address this is not just through a retirement age. I don't think anybody thinks that will be the entirety of the way to address that.

My lords, the point I made a moment ago as well, when we've looked at these issues before, and I said this during the passage of the hereditary peers bill, this will be an opportunity for the house itself to bring forward proposals, to take action, and to show that it can lead reforms rather than resist them. And if this house wants to have an influence on policy that affects this house, the way to do so is to actually take action ourselves. And I hope we would consider that. It's an opportunity here to do so. My lords, the report before us today that we're debating has been genuinely led by the house.

Over a hundred members submitted evidence to the committee. And after an interesting listen to the views of the house today, I have been clear that I'm listening to the debate. I haven't yet responded to the report formally through the government, but we'll do so and take note of this debate as well. My lords, turning to the sort of specifics on the report, the committee does make the point that because members of this house tend to be appointed later in their careers, an average introduction of 59, it is entirely logical for our retirement age to be higher than other professions. And I think striking the balance of the age of 80 by 2034, which is later than judges, later than magistrates, later than our bishops, we don't lose the benefit of a peer's experience prematurely, but we do address some of the concerns that have been raised and allows us to bring in the new expertise and talent we need.

Can I say I was particularly grateful to the committee for looking at transitional arrangements? And the point the noble lady Scott didn't seem to take to was this, this does give colleagues time to prepare. And I think that will help members know when they are likely to retire and how we can bring new members in. My lords, the comments I think from the crossbenchers, can I address this point about 20%? It's never been formally recognized, but I think that is a fair size for the crossbenchers.

And I would certainly support that. And I would talk to the convener and others about it. But I think nobody in this house would want to see the crossbenchers fall behind that kind of level. But I do think the certainty would help in terms of trying to address the kind of skill set you need. The issue about the numbers of HOLAC peers.

I was quite shocked. I checked this earlier today. Two peers, HOLAC peers came in last year. But in 20, and the party opposite were calling, yes, there must be more HOLAC appointed peers. It's rather a surprise then to find in 2014, 2016, 2017, 2019, 2020, and 2023, there were no HOLAC appointed peers.

Now, I think that, you know, it's a matter for the Prime Minister, but clearly there has to be a much better allocation.

The only reason I hesitate over the percentage 20 is that the point I've made before is the imbalance around the House. And I think the House works best, as noted, if the two party of government and major opposition are roughly the same size. And I think that's perfectly doable with the crossbenchers around 20%. But it does need to be worked with the crossbenchers and look at the skills you need. I hadn't said yes, but I will sit down now he's standing up and start.

06:47:55 - 06:48:09

Charles John Fuller

She seems to be referring to the special pleading made by the crossbenchers, to which I am sympathetic. But I raise the point about the almost complete eradication of our colleagues from Northern Ireland. And would you address that point too?

06:48:09 - 06:56:42

Nicholas True

I think he was only talking about the DUP in that sense, because we are members on our benches certainly from Northern Ireland as well. One of the things I think we need to look at, and that we'll be bringing forward further proposals on this, is the House as a whole has to be better representative of the whole of the UK. Now that's been recognized, and part of the issue possibly is allowances and people talk about the financial cost of travelling further distances if they've got to stay overnight. So yes, totally agree, we'll be bringing forward further proposals. And we have to have a House that is better represented on all kinds of levels, but certainly I think being more representative geographically is very, very important.

Can I turn to some of the other issues that were in the report as well? I was pleased to hear the Noble Lord True and Lady Coffe, their comments were interesting about the leave of absence, how they think that should apply, the conduct should apply to all of them, whether they're on leave of absence or members of this House. I thought the comments about not having a, I can't remember which Noble Lord referred to this, a retirement association, whether it's called emeritus or not is pretty irrelevant, I don't mind what it's called. But I think that's really important. One of the things that I suggested some time ago when we were debating the Hereditary Peers Bill, Noble Lords may not be aware of the booklet, but one of the things that's always concerned me about this House, often as members age, they come in a bit less.

We see a bit less of them. Then they get ill and we don't see them for a long time. Then they may come in occasionally and they just disappear and fade away. We don't show them the respect and the value that we put on them by ever saying thank you or recognizing their work. They fade away, we don't see them again.

I wanted members to know when they retire from the House what is available for them. One of the things is they can vote in a general election, as the Noble Lord Rooker asked me and the Noble Lord Dubs asked me. That is in the booklet. So I recommend this booklet, but it's a way of saying to members who retire from this House, we value your service, these are the kind of facilities that are still available to you, and you still remain our friends and colleagues and come in the House. It was really important we should do that.

I was rather taken aback by the Noble Lord True's comments at the beginning. I know he's a bit snippy generally, but he's cross about this anyway, when he talked about the issue of capacity. Because he knows that one of the first things I did when I became Leader of the House is talk to the administration about this. And we also had a meeting through the usual channels to talk about this issue. I see a number of Noble Lords who've been at these meetings acknowledging that.

And we've progressed that work, as he well knows. It's work that's underway. So, and I know the Noble Lady Williams, who's not here, oh she's there, she's moved, has said. But my noble friend the Chief Whip has held a series of meetings following on from those initial meetings we had with the usual channels, with the Clerk of the Parliaments and other House officials, which have been productive. And they form the basis for an agreement on a way forward to deal with the issue of capacity.

Now, my Lords, this is a sensitive issue, and I think we all want to treat our friends and colleagues and other Noble Lords with respect and kindness.

And that's been uppermost in the Chief Whip's minds as they've been dealing with it. Um, the next step is that the Chief, respective Chief Whips and the Convener are going to lead this work to take it forward and will bring a report forward to be agreed in the usual channels and presented to the Procedure Committee. So that is work that we find very important and is ongoing.

Um, my Lords, I'm sorry if I appear snippy, sometimes the opposition's permitted to criticize proposals or probe them. Um, the point I'm making about capacity, and I'm aware of the welcome action we agreed on power of attorney and that we have had these discussions. My point is the point that the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett made, and which many people have made in this debate and I made, which is this is an ageist and discriminatory measure in using age as a blunderbuss to take a lot of people out of the house, as the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett said, as a proxy for capacity. Why do we not focus on capacity and let the capable aged stay?

My Lords, if this was a proxy for capacity, we wouldn't be bringing it forward, wouldn't be both at the same time. And I think the noble Lord misunderstands the reasons why a retirement age has been proposed. And I was perfectly willing to accept that our manifesto was rather crude in its approach in that it said members would retire at the end of the Parliament in which they were 80. I think the proposal brought forward by the committee is much more sophisticated and thoughtful for members of the House. But the noble Lord seems to think that no member of the House should ever retire unless they want to.

And if we constantly do that, the House will continue to grow in size and we won't be bringing in new members with new experiences, new expertise to understand what's happening. This is not in any way to disrespect those members who have given many years' service to the House and have given, you know, a lifetime of service in some cases, or those who thought they would be here until they chose not to be. But it is about saying how do we have an effective House, how do we do our best work as the House of Lords and best contribute to the role we have. Um, my Lords, the noble Lord, Duke of Wellington, has probably got a different title now that I can't remember, um, made the comment about donors, and I entirely agree with him. If the only reason somebody is being made a member of this House is because they've made large donations to a political party, that is entirely inappropriate and wrong.

Um, he also talked about the size of the House and ensuring that we didn't create, as people left, it wasn't a case of just creating a vacancy. He's absolutely right and I would agree with him on that one. Um, the noble Lord, Kakkar, mentioned he was particularly concerned that the House could be packed and flooded with members in order to keep a government in power for a long time. In a sense, that could have happened at any time in our history. Remember, we did have an unlawful prorogation under a previous Prime Minister, um, which the courts were able to deal with.

One thing I would say is this House, um, does have the right to say how members are introduced. And it's not sharing a secret, as I spoke to a number of noble Lords opposite about this at the time, um, but he will recall that shortly after I became leader, Jacob Rees-Mogg said he would introduce a thousand new peers to force Brexit through in exactly the way the government wanted. And there were a number of us that felt if he tried that one on, we'd introduce one peer a week and it might take him some time. So there are ways of addressing that through our constitutional arrangements at the moment as well. Um, my Lords, we've already taken some action, I'm running out of time but I have got some injury time I think.

We've taken some action on, uh, Appointments Commission. We've already strengthened the transparency in appointments as well, um, and we've worked with the House of Lords Appointments Commission to update its vetting forms. I think the vetting has to be stronger and we're looking at that indeed in terms of my own party vetting processes, we've looked at that as well. Um, my Lords, I think finally, just sort of, I want to reiterate my thanks to the committee. I think they were given an almost impossible task to do and they did it with great aplomb and sensitivity.

I value the work of this House. But I also think if we say we're never going to change, we always do things in exactly the same way, then and leave others to make the change and take no responsibility ourselves, we don't get the change we want. And I think this is an opportunity for the House to show that we can manage our own affairs. We don't need things to be done to us and we can show that we have a responsibility to the work we do. I was struck by the noble lady Palmer's comments and I think it's a point to end on.

If it's not led by us, it will be led by those who know less and care less. My Lords, we have a responsibility.

06:56:42 - 07:03:27

Ann Taylor

My Lords, it's been a very interesting day. And I think that all members have learned something from somebody else. I'm not sure whether there are any two members in the House who actually agree with each other perfectly on every aspect of what we're talking about. But I do thank everyone who has participated. And I won't even try to go through every individual contribution.

My noble friend the leader has done a great deal on that. But I do want to mention just a few of the themes that have come up. The first thing that I think I should say is that several people have criticized the remit. Well, it was the remit we were given. But I would say on the basis of the discussion we've had today, if we'd been given a wider remit, we'd still be here until the next Parliament because clearly these issues run very deep and there's a great deal of feeling on everything.

Secondly, in terms of the size of the House, that was not in our remit, though we had to look at the implications on the size of the House. I would just say that if the House, which agreed the Burns report all those years ago, if that had been implemented, then perhaps we wouldn't be talking about these issues quite as much at the moment. And you know, the lessons of the Grocott bill I think should be remembered in all of this. In terms of the fact that we said little on appointments, we did very clearly say that if numbers are going to be reduced, then there are implications if there isn't better consideration of the open door and the flow in as well as the flow out. On HOLAC, I'm going to be very careful about what I say because I'm a member of HOLAC.

But we do talk very clearly to prospective members about the commitment. And I think that that's appropriate and that's probably something that has happened more in recent years than perhaps was the case previously. Questions have been raised also about the impact on the crossbenchers. And I think that the comments my noble friend the leader was making there about the years in which there were no appointments to HOLAC are a salutary reminder that we do need to keep that drumbeat going.

And it really is important that we don't do anything in a way which totally causes unbelievably difficult problems for any element in the house, and in particular the crossbenchers. But I was very reassured by what Lord Kinnoull said about this being difficult but manageable for the crossbenchers. And it is a fact that there is a larger number of crossbenchers affected by the participation requirement. But when we looked at the numbers, quite a lot of those people who were in the under 20% weren't that far off it. And if it is over two sessions, then there is far more opportunity to be aware of where you are and get that kind of information.

Incidentally, one of the things that we suggested in order to make it easier to be precise about your attendance was that there should be an ability to clock in in the chamber with your pass so that everybody knows you've actually been in the house, and that would make sure that it was a very proper record. In terms of implementation, Lord Wolfson quoted what we've said in the report. And it is true that if you do this by resolution, then you are actually talking about a self-governing house and peers respecting that. And I think that Lord Smith made the point that it is incumbent on each of us to take responsibility for respecting exactly what the house wants to happen. And I think that was an important consideration.

One of the things that I thought was most interesting about the discussion today was the question of refreshment, which quite a few members mentioned. Baroness Meacher of Bulla mentioned it. My noble friend Baroness Hayter talked about her experience in consumer affairs and in charities, but somebody else now might have more recent experience. Baroness Watkins said the same about nursing. Interestingly, it was the women who mentioned these aspects.

It really does matter that we can have up-to-date experience, and the pace of change in every field is accelerating, so we do need to make sure that we have got relevant and up-to-date experience. Now, there is a concern about the reputation of the house. We are not elected. We are vulnerable, and therefore I think we have to do things that matter. And I think that was the point that Baroness Bull made.

And Baroness Scott said we're being discriminatory if we talk about people who've been put here for life having to leave. But it was a Conservative government with the Liberal Democrats who produced the Clegg Bill, which would have got rid of so many people, and we could be abolished at any time. So yes, we have a right, but it's not something that can never be changed. I do share Lord Grocott's concern that there will always be those who oppose any change. But I think those who oppose any change should be aware of the consequences that bigger change very often catches up with them.

So I do think it's been a very useful debate, and I agree with what my noble friends have said. It is better that we take this on board ourselves and that we do not have change imposed upon us. And I hope that the Leader of the House will be able to find time in the not-too-distant future for the house to come to some decisions on these particular matters, and I beg to move.

07:03:27 - 07:03:35

George Young

The question is that this motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.

07:03:35 - 07:03:38

Speaker 112

My Lords, I beg to move the house do now adjourn.

07:03:38 - 07:03:38

That the house do now adjourn.