House of Commons

3 November 2026

Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
34:17 - 34:23
Speaker 1
Order.  We start with questions to the Chancellor of the Exchequer.  Clive Efford. 
34:23 - 34:24
Number one, Mr Speaker. 
34:24 - 34:26
Speaker 2
Chancellor. 
34:26 - 35:06
Speaker 3
Thank you, Mr Speaker.  My thoughts today are with all those whose lives have been changed forever and with the families who've lost loved ones through the contaminated blood scandal.  I have very close friends who lost brothers and cousins nearly 40 years ago. 

And nothing can undo the suffering they've endured.  And this government is totally committed to recognising that profound hurt and injustice.  Eligible claimants will receive the compensation they are due.  We'll continue working across government to ensure that justice is delivered and compensation reaches the victims as quickly as possible. 
35:06 - 35:58
Speaker 4
I'm grateful to my right honourable friend for that answer and I'm sure the whole House echoes his sentiments. 

There is concern amongst people claimants to IBCA, particularly those claiming for the estates of those who have passed on because there are concerns that the IBCA is required under government regulations to claw back overpayments.  And now these are people who've been traumatized over many years.  And these errors that are government errors, not errors on the part of the claimants are causing distress and forcing people to relive their experiences.  So, can we ensure that government rules and regulations, the treasury rules are not requiring IBCA to reclaim overpayments in this way? 
35:58 - 36:41
Speaker 3
My honourable friend has been a campaigner in this House over almost all the time that he and I have been here since 1997 when we were elected together.  He raises an important point.  If overpayments do happen, it is the responsibility of the Independent Blood Compensation Authority, the IBCA, to deal with this. 

And there do appear to be a small number of cases in which the IBCA is reviewing.  And I the Treasury has agreed that the authority can continue paying compensation under the scheme while they conduct those reviews.  And I've asked the authority to keep us updated on the review, which I will certainly do to my honourable friend. 
36:41 - 36:41
Jim Shannon. 

36:41 - 37:23

Jim Shannon

Mr Speaker, thank you. And thank the and the Secretary for that reply. In the middle of the funding process that we have, and the question that the gentleman asked, we have those people and the families who are have delays in getting their money through. I know in Northern Ireland, we've seen the families who the years catch up, their health catches up, and they pass away. So, I want to ensure that in the lifetime that they have in this world, the short time that some of them have left, that the monies that they are due actually get there.

So, can I ask the minister this question, please?

What has been done to ensure that those who are still waiting for compensation can actually get that as a matter of urgency?

37:23 - 38:11

Speaker 3

Well Mr. Speaker, the IBCA is following the inquiry's recommendations about the priority for payments. It's prioritising claims from individuals who are sadly nearing the end of their lives, followed by those in older age groups. In the last two years, over 2.3 billion pounds has been paid out in compensation to people who were either infected or affected. And I would just say to the honorable gentleman, who has also been a long-term campaigner on this, the Treasury is playing its part.

We're making sure that those payments can be made through the annually managed expenditure so there is no constraint on the payments that can be made by the Treasury rules.

38:11 - 38:12

Brian Leishman.

38:12 - 38:14

Speaker 7

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Question number two.

38:14 - 38:16

Speaker 6

Minister.

38:16 - 38:38

Speaker 9

Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my honorable friend for his work on the Family Protection Plan issue. I know it affects hundreds of his constituents and many beyond. As he knows, we've engaged with the FCA on the impact of the withdrawal. I do want to see this matter resolved in a satisfactory way, and I look forward to engaging with him further to that end.

38:38 - 38:39

Brian Leishman.

38:39 - 38:44

Speaker 8

Mr. Speaker, I thank my honorable friend for her response and her work on this matter.

38:44 - 39:25

Francis Joseph McNally

The most vulnerable families paid FPP funeral cover for 25 years because it was all that they could afford. And data shows that since the withdrawal only 3% of policyholders have been able to secure alternative cover and at least 61 people have died without funeral protection. Despite numerous industry forum meetings to explore redress, on this matter no solutions were agreed, even for the oldest and most vulnerable. So will my honourable friend meet with me, those MPs with constituents affected, and the Independent Coalition of Credit Unions as a matter of urgency so that we can try to identify any possible next steps?

39:25 - 39:36

Speaker 9

Mr Speaker, I will and, as I said, I do want to see this matter resolved in a satisfactory way, not least due to the ongoing harm that he describes.

39:36 - 39:37

Claire Young.

39:37 - 39:40

Claire Louise Young

Question number three please.

39:40 - 39:41

Chancellor.

39:41 - 40:23

Speaker 3

Mr. Speaker, with permission, With permission, I'd like to answer question three and 10 together. My budget last week took action to help people worried about the pressure of winter bills. £100, a household energy payment that will be made direct to people's bank accounts in 20 million households. VAT cut from electricity bills, the 5p cut to fuel duty extended through the winter to July, standing charges removed entirely from gas bills next year.

Mr. Speaker, this is action to give people a bit of breathing space with the cost of living pressures, and I'm asking banks to pay a bit more to fund this help for households this winter.

40:23 - 40:24

Claire Young.

40:24 - 40:53

Claire Louise Young

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

The Treasury is cutting £1 billion from the Warm Homes Fund, including a smaller than planned pot for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme. Combined with tax rise tax rises on heat pumps, these cuts risk creating a boom-and-bust cycle for installers and leaving more households exposed to the volatility of the oil and gas market. Can the Minister explain can the Chancellor explain how cutting support for clean heating is consistent with the Government's own mission for a clean energy transition?

40:53 - 41:34

Speaker 3

Mr Speaker, our priority is to help give people who are facing a winter of worry with rising energy bills just a bit of relief. And that's why the priority is to direct £100 paid directly into people's bank accounts. This will be to 20 million households, that's four in five of the households in England. And this £100 payment will be made directly into people's bank accounts.

It will reach nine out of 10 of the poorest third families. It's timely. It's targeted. It's fair. It's a choice that this government has made in the labour budget that I delivered last week.

41:34 - 41:35

Will Forster.

41:35 - 42:01

Paul William Forster

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yesterday, the Trussell Trust and the Joseph Rowntree Foundation wrote to the Prime Minister, criticising the government for freezing local housing allowance, saying it will not help people with the cost of living and that it will critically undermine plans to end rough sleeping. Does the Chancellor agree with those national charities, Citizens Advice in my constituency of Woking, that rent support must be tied to actual rent levels in the future?

42:01 - 42:03

Speaker 14

Chancellor.

42:03 - 42:38

Speaker 3

Mr. Speaker, those questions of rent allowance, those questions of how we best support the increase in council and social housing building were also part of the budget announcements I made. This wasn't just a bit of breathing space and a relief from pressures that people immediately face, but action to start the long-term fix in our housing, with help for first-time buyers who don't have the back backing of mum and dad, and help also for councils and social housing to get built in this country.

42:38 - 42:39

Rex Dufton.

42:39 - 43:19

Bill Esterson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Speaker, the measures to help with the cost of living through cuts in energy bills were very welcome in the budget. The Chancellor also said he would adopt one of the Energy Committee's recommendations not to add further policy costs to bills, but can I encourage him to look at one of our other recommendations, which is to move policy costs from electricity to gas, which will help people take up electric heat and also batteries, which will enable them to take advantage of the tariffs that are available now.

43:19 - 44:10

Speaker 3

Mr. Speaker, the action I took in the budget last week was on top of help the previous, the government has previously given this year to help across the board with energy costs. It includes some of the measures that his committee has urged us to look at. My priority going into this budget was conscious of the pressures and the worry that people have about rising energy bills driven by the conflict in the Iran war. And the step we take to make sure that we extend the cup the 5p cut to fuel duty, extend the VAT off electricity bills.

We bring in gas charges that remove the standing charge for next year, but above all we'll see the direct payment of a hundred pounds into the bank accounts of 20 million households in January, which will help at that point of maximum pressure as people face those winter bills.

44:10 - 44:11

Catherine West.

44:11 - 44:34

Catherine West

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. The Treasury Select Committee has done an enormous amount of work on the household bill situation, but also on the impact on graduates who have still got significant debts.

Could the Chancellor promise that when things do improve he will look again at this really burning issue for so many of our constituents?

44:34 - 45:33

Speaker 3

I will indeed, Madam, Mr Speaker, that is something that we will keep an eye on, we will return to no doubt. But I just say to her, as I say to my honorable friend, in this budget immediate action to help with the cost of living pressures and give people a bit of breathing space over this winter, but also action to make deep reforms to our energy system that will bring prices down for business and for households in the long term. So, an end to the standing charges on gas bills, an end to government policy costs simply loaded onto consumer bills through levies, and an end also to buying and building new generation that doesn't bring cheaper, as well as cleaner, energy and that can't be connected to the grid. So, a budget with immediate action now to deal with the cost of living pressures and action for the long term changes necessary to bring British energy bills down in line with Europe.

45:33 - 46:00

Esther McVey

Thank you, Mr Speaker. At the weekend, the Chancellor said the budget would provide breathing space for families and working people. So, can he tell the House today, does he agree with his minister, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, who thinks employers aren't working people?

46:00 - 46:47

Speaker 3

Mr Speaker, of course they are.

It's why it's why in this budget I've protected income that is earned, I've protected income that is earned through dividends which are reinvested into business. I promised a breathing space budget, that's what I've delivered. Help with the cost of living pressures, help with the cost of business pressures, 70,000 high street businesses taken out of business rates altogether to lift our local areas including in on the right honorable lady's constituency. Just as I'm asking banks to help with the cost of the cost of this help for households through the winter, I'm asking gambling, online, big online sellers, vape shops to help pay a bit more to help our high streets. I hope she'll back it.

46:47 - 46:48

Baggy Shanker.

46:48 - 47:16

Baggy Bhagat Shanker

Thank you, Mr Speaker. With too many Derby residents dreading their bills as the nights draw in, I welcome 93% of households in our city will get £100 breathing space off their energy bills this winter. But whether it's the weekly shop or filling the car, budgets are being stretched from every direction.

So, what other steps can the Chancellor take to give families struggling to make ends meet that extra breathing space that they need?

47:16 - 47:18

Speaker 20

Chancellor.

47:18 - 47:49

Speaker 3

Well, Mr. Speaker, he's right to highlight the 93% of families in Derby that will get this £100 payment direct into their account at the beginning of the winter. I would say to him also that the VAT that we cut from electricity bills in the first week of this government is extended through the winter and the spring to July, just as the 5p cut in fuel duty is extended through the winter, through the spring, and to July. And we're taking standing charges off gas bills next year to help relieve the pressure that people face and the worry over energy bills.

47:49 - 47:52

Speaker 21

Shadow Minister.

47:52 - 48:25

Peter Bedford

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The OBR said last week that higher taxes are weighing on living standards, with the tax burden heading for a record high. The budget was a missed opportunity for the Chancellor to cut the cost of living by cutting taxes.

Instead, their answer was to cut the price of gherkins. The Chancellor promised breathing space nine times in his speech. Does the Chancellor really think that six pence a day in savings amounts to cutting, amounts to enacting breathing space for hard-working families?

48:25 - 49:14

Speaker 3

Mr. Speaker, a council tax cut in the new year, Mr. Speaker, a VAT cut extended on electricity bills, Mr. Speaker, a 5p cut to the fuel duty extended through next winter into July.

Mr Speaker, this is also a budget that has rejected broad-based tax rises. It's a government and a budget which is making sure that we close the loopholes, we target the measures we're taking to those who can pay and pay what they owe. And these are all policies in this budget which are fully funded because underpinning all is the fiscal discipline needed to rebuild confidence in this country, confidence in our ability to manage our finances that was so badly damaged by the Truss mini-budget in 2022.

49:14 - 49:18

Speaker 23

Daisy Cooper, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

49:18 - 49:59

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Mr Speaker. By using the outdated council tax system to roll out its energy support package, we have an absurd situation where somewhere between 800,000 and 1.4 million people on low incomes are going to miss out on the £100, whilst a wealthy couple who have retired early and have downsized are set to benefit.

There is absolutely no excuse for this. The Government could have followed our plan to use existing DWP and HMRC data to roll out a targeted essential energy guarantee, getting the most help to those who need it the most. So why on earth didn't they?

49:59 - 50:40

Speaker 3

Mr Speaker, I'm disappointed by the honourable lady. Nine out of 10, nine out of 10 of the poorest households will benefit from this £100 direct payment.

Four out of four out of five households in total, 20 million will benefit from this. And for those that are do struggle, she will have seen in the budget, I've also put an extra 100 million into the special fund that local authorities have to administer where there are hardship cases. They can make payments for those under extreme pressure and that's what I'd encourage her to point people to do.

50:40 - 50:41

Will Stone.

50:41 - 50:44

Speaker 25

Question number four please, Mr. Speaker.

50:44 - 51:09

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and with permission I'll answer this question together with question number 25. My honorable friends are entirely right to focus on the need for more apprenticeship opportunities for young people. Reversing the 40% decline in youth apprenticeships twin since 2016 is a top priority and that is why the government is investing 3.3 billion into apprenticeships and why the chancellor has announced the expansion of local apprenticeship services to all mayors.

51:09 - 51:10

Will Stone.

51:10 - 51:33

Lewis William Stone

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In Swindon, Honda trained up around us 170 apprentices over the years giving the young people a real access to good, skilled, high-paid wild jobs.

When Honda left, as did those opportunities. Can the Minister outline what he has been doing to speak with his counterparts in the DWP to ensure that Swindon gets better access to apprenticeships for young people in the future? Thank you.

51:33 - 51:35

Speaker 28

Minister.

51:35 - 52:00

Torsten Bell

Well, I thank my honourable friend for his question. It's absolutely the right question. We all know in our communities there are so many young people that would benefit from the clear transition from education into the world of work that an apprenticeship provides. And we are supporting employers to provide that bridge with a new £2,000 grant for SMEs recruiting young apprenticeships aged 16 to 24. And that is in addition to fully funding training costs for eligible young apprentices at all businesses.

52:00 - 52:01

Kirith Entwistle.

52:01 - 52:34

Kirith Entwistle

Thank you, Mr Speaker.

Every year on A-level results day, I hold a youth drop-in event at Market Place in Bolton town centre to connect young people with the skills opportunities and training that I benefited from myself. But Mr. Speaker, every year, young people tell me that they would benefit from more apprenticeships. So what further action is the Chancellor taking to work with employers, colleges and training providers to expand apprenticeship places and ensure that young people in constituencies like mine can access the skills and training needed to secure successful careers?

52:34 - 53:05

Torsten Bell

Well, Mr. Speaker, let me congratulate my honourable friend on her important work, and what sounds like a feature of the calendar in her constituency. All parts of society have a role to play in tackling the challenges we face when it comes to young people's participation in the world of work. When it comes to apprenticeships, we've already reformed the levy, making sure there's a billion pounds extra over this spending review period. That will provide 50,000 more young apprenticeships. And I note that over half of apprenticeship starts in her constituency are young people, but we need to make sure that is many more in the years ahead.

53:05 - 53:07

Speaker 30

Graham Stuart.

53:07 - 53:45

Graham Stuart

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Construction is a key sector for apprenticeships, and yet, the 1.5 million target for homes, dropped. And London, the city we're in, just 5% of the government target. And that's 5% is what's happening. There are no apprenticeships coming so we're seeing Landsec, we're seeing Taylor Wimpey, we're seeing other companies in London pulling back even further.

So, when will the government recognise that stamp duty is standing in the way of getting those apprenticeships going, getting those houses built, and getting this economy growing once again?

53:46 - 54:19

Torsten Bell

Well let me start with a point of agreement, which is I think all of us around this House value the role of the construction sector and want to see more houses built in this country again. Directly on the apprenticeships point, you'll know that we've introduced new foundation apprenticeships for exactly in the construction sector to get more young people that route into it. And on London, we do need to see more building. That's why we've announced a new package of reforms with the Mayor of London to make sure we get those building rates up. But I would honestly say to members opposite, you cannot be standing in this House saying that you support house building and then in your constituencies, opposing every planning permission that comes forward for building.

54:19 - 54:22

Speaker 34

That is not what this government will do. Those houses will be built.

54:22 - 54:24

Speaker 32

Dr Roz Savage.

54:24 - 54:47

Rose Savage

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. For a young person in a South Cotswolds village, the barrier to an apprenticeship is often just getting there. Buses are rare or nonexistent and the cost of running a car is out of reach on an apprentice's pay.

So, will the Chancellor work with the Transport Secretary to cap bus fares at £1 and to fund more rural bus routes?

54:47 - 54:48

Speaker 33

Minister.

54:48 - 55:08

Torsten Bell

Well, the honorable lady is absolutely right to say we do want to see apprenticeships for young people in every part of the country, including in rural constituencies. That's why the Government within England has obviously put in place the £2 bus fare, but we're obviously conscious that not everybody will be able to get a bus to their place of work and that's why the Chancellor has extended the freeze to fuel duty right the way through to the summer next year.

55:08 - 55:09

Patricia Ferguson.

55:09 - 55:11

Patricia Ferguson

Question number five, Mr. Speaker.

55:11 - 55:12

Minister.

55:12 - 55:42

Emma Reynolds

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, I'd like to group this question with number 24 with your permission.

Last year we provided the Scottish Government with a record spending review settlement, and last week at the budget, we gave the Scottish Government a further £600 million through Barnett. We also announced £18 million for a UK advanced chip design Academy led by Edinburgh University, £6 million to support the expansion of Glasgow Scottish Event Campus, and £10 million co-funding with the Scottish Government for two defense technical excellent colleges.

55:42 - 55:44

Speaker 39

Patricia Gibson.

55:44 - 56:12

Patricia Ferguson

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank the Minister for that answer, and I very much welcome the extra investment that's coming to my home city of Glasgow. I'm sure Glasgow will make good use of it. But I also welcome overall the record funding that this Labour Government has delivered for Scotland, and I wonder if the Minister agrees with me that the SNP Government should now drop the gimmicks, end the excuses, and prioritize making Scotland's public services fit for the future.

56:12 - 56:27

Emma Reynolds

I'd like to agree with my honorable friend, as she says, at the budget, we gave the Scottish Government an additional £600 million through Barnett, on top of a record spending review settlement. Now we need the SNP Government to act to improve public services with that money in Scotland.

56:27 - 56:29

Speaker 38

Chris Kane.

56:29 - 57:02

Chris Kane

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Small and medium sized family businesses in the retail sector create jobs on our high streets and keep money circulating locally. In my constituency, this includes businesses like Pemberton's sewing machines, Europa Music store in Bannockburn, Michael Moore the butcher in Cambusbarron and countless others. I welcome the Chancellor's budget support for high streets in England, including a two years real terms business rates freeze. Does the Chancellor agree that Scottish businesses deserve the same and that the SNP should match this freeze in their Scottish budget, and that failure to do so would mean thousands of Scottish businesses missing out on much needed relief?

57:02 - 57:20

Emma Reynolds

Minister. As my honorable friend says, the Chancellor, last week, froze business rates in real terms for high street businesses and has taken 70,000 small businesses on the high street in England out of paying business rates altogether.

We have given the devolved government in Scotland the Barnett consequentials for this, and I'd urge them to follow our lead.

57:20 - 57:21

Kirsty Blackman.

57:21 - 57:41

Ann Kirsty Blackman

Economic growth in the north-east of Scotland and our green transition relies on the carbon capture and storage project happening at Peterhead. Would the minister make clear what assessment they've made or whether this project will still go ahead given the UK government's massive cuts to the project?

57:41 - 57:58

Emma Reynolds

Can I- Can I reassure the honourable lady, we continue to support the Acorn Project. The initial grant funding that this government is providing until the end of 2026 remains in place, and we are exploring delivery through private investment and government loans or equity investments in the future.

57:58 - 57:59

David Mundell.

57:59 - 58:20

David Mundell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Can the minister clarify the extent to which the data centre covenant announced in the budget will apply in Scotland? She'll be aware that there are some very significant applications in Scotland, not least in my own constituency, and that clarity is very important.

58:20 - 58:24

Emma Reynolds

Can I thank him for his question and suggest that I write to him to set that out in more detail.

58:24 - 58:27

Speaker 44

Andrew Rosindell.

58:27 - 58:29

Andrew Rosindell

Number six, Mr. Speaker.

58:29 - 58:30

Minister.

58:30 - 58:50

Torsten Bell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government is bringing down borrowing, helping to bear down on inflation to support households and businesses.

Last year, borrowing fell by 0.7% of GDP to its lowest level in six years, and borrowing is forecast to fall across the forecast period to 1.8% of GDP by 2031-32.

58:50 - 59:32

Andrew Rosindell

Andrew Rosindell. Mr. Speaker, does the Minister understand just how devastating the effects are of his government's policies by spending, taxing, and borrowing on my constituents in Romford? And does he recall that the last time we had a prime minister that understood that we need low taxes and a smaller state and borrow less was in 1990 when we had 21% of GDP as the national debt? Now it's heading for 100%. So, will he please reduce the size of the state, cut taxes for hardworking people, and actually start living within our means?

59:32 - 01:00:14

Torsten Bell

Well, the this government is bringing down borrowing. That's why the IMF said that the UK saw the biggest reduction in the G20's deficit levels this year.

They said that the UK stands out for having a borrowing reduction plan, with borrowing falling every year across this forecast. Of course, the honourable member was a member of a government that saw debt levels go through the roof over the past 14 years. This is a government getting on with reducing our borrowing so that we can bring debt down in the longer term. The only numbers that the party on the other side benches talks about is how many millions of pounds their boss can take from crypto billionaires around the world. We'll deal with the public finances.

Stop taking money from the crypto billionaires.

01:00:14 - 01:00:45

Speaker 47

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Borrowing is high and I welcome some of the measures in the budget.

But one of the ways that we need to be looking at this is how every pound of taxpayers' money is spent. So, can the minister reassure me that he and his colleague, particularly of course the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, will be holding every spending department tightly to account in the spending review not just for future spending, but for managing existing projects so that every tax pound is spent as wisely as possible?

01:00:45 - 01:01:00

Torsten Bell

Well the honourable lady is, as always, right about this and the Chief Secretary to the Treasury has heard every word she has said. There'll be a spending review next year, and it is important that we don't just debate the levels of that spending, but how we make sure every single pound of that is spent well, whether it's on defence, health or education or anywhere else.

01:01:00 - 01:01:03

Lindsay Hoyle

Shadow Minister, Richard Fuller.

01:01:03 - 01:01:44

Richard Fuller

That was a shockingly complacent response by the government minister, Mr Speaker.

The latest OBR forecast shows that this Labour Government will borrow nearly a quarter of a trillion pounds more in just two years, this year and next year, costing every household an extra £476 per year in additional debt interest. Does the Chancellor accept that this budget was not only a lost opportunity to bring borrowing under control, but that Labour's addiction to borrowing is bleeding the British people dry?

01:01:44 - 01:02:12

Torsten Bell

Oh, well, our record is reducing borrowing. The honourable members, the honourable member's record is being a minister under Liz Truss. And now, what is the Leader of the Opposition's, what is the Leader of the Opposition's big idea? Appointing the Liz Truss fanboy and coming back to the Liz Truss playbook, promising over £30 billion of unfunded tax cuts. The party opposite is offering lettuce-wilting levels of fiscal incontinence.

01:02:12 - 01:02:14

Lindsay Hoyle

Henry Tufnell.

01:02:14 - 01:02:16

Henry Tufnell

Question number seven, Mr Speaker.

01:02:16 - 01:02:18

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister.

01:02:18 - 01:02:31

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. At the Budget, the government announced that it intends to expand CBAM to refinery products, subject to the consultation launched on budget day.

01:02:31 - 01:03:11

Henry Tufnell

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I welcome the government's announcement at last week's budget of the intention to expand the scope of the CBAM to include refined products. This is critical to preventing carbon leakage by ensuring that British refineries are playing on a level playing field in when compared to imported refined products. It will protect thousands of jobs in Pembrokeshire and strengthen our energy national security.

Can the Minister therefore set out a clear timetable for implementation, and what assurances will he provide that in terms of protecting the competitiveness of the export sector for the refineries in this country?

01:03:11 - 01:03:40

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

My honourable friend has a has been a strong representative of the workers at the Pembroke refinery, and I know he has been campaigning on this issue for a long time, and I want to thank him for his continued engagement on it. His constituents should know that he definitely has their back. The government has launched a consultation, Mr Speaker, and is seeking views from a range of stakeholders on the practical, technical and economic considerations of any potential expansion. This is, as my honourable friend will know, a complex area, and it is important that we take the time to get the detail right.

01:03:40 - 01:04:04

Gregory Campbell

Gregory Campbell. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Critical to the competitiveness of the refining sector is the taxation of companies involved.

I know we've just had the budget, but will the Treasury keep in mind for forthcoming fiscal events that essential element of being competitive in a sector like this?

01:04:04 - 01:04:23

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

I thank the honorable member for his question. The government has of course been considering the replacement for the energy profits levy and from 2030, or sooner if prices fall below the relevant thresholds, then the new and improved design of the tax for the long term, the oil and gas revenue levy, will be coming into force.

01:04:23 - 01:04:26

Lindsay Hoyle

Call shadow minister.

01:04:26 - 01:04:57

John Cooper

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Oil is of course the lifeblood of the refinery sector, but the government missed an opportunity to back this foundational industry, both upstream and downstream. And the Rosebank oilfield is already priced into the OBR's assumptions.

If that doesn't get the go-ahead, it's back to the drawing board, Chancellor, isn't it? Isn't the case that the fiscal headroom is already thin, will disappear even more if Rosebank doesn't get the go-ahead? And the reality is this budget is built on sand, Chancellor.

01:04:57 - 01:05:15

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. It was the party opposite that fluffed it up when it came to getting Rosebank and Jackdaw approved. They couldn't make sure that they signed the right paperwork at the right time, and we're the party that had to clean up their mess in that and a whole range of other areas, Mr Speaker.

01:05:15 - 01:05:17

Lindsay Hoyle

Josh Babarinde.

01:05:17 - 01:05:20

Speaker 59

Question number 8, please, Mr Speaker.

01:05:21 - 01:05:51

Speaker 60

With permission, Mr Speaker, I'll answer this with questions 21 and 23. Mr Speaker, at the budget, we announced a two-year real terms freeze to the business rates bills for all retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England.

We cut bills by an extra 20% for pubs and all but the largest live music venues, and we removed 70,000 smaller properties from business rates altogether. Taken together, these measures show how the government is backing our high streets, with all retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England seeing their business rates frozen in real terms, reduced, or cut to zero.

01:05:51 - 01:05:53

Lindsay Hoyle

Jas Athwal.

01:05:53 - 01:06:27

Jasbir Singh Athwal

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents and I welcome the budget measures to support small businesses in Ilford South, including the business rates freeze for retail, hospitality and leisure properties, benefiting over 1,000 businesses across Ilford South.

Will the Chancellor outline what further fiscal steps the government is taking to support business businesses on high streets such as in my constituency to encourage investment and ensure that our town centres remain vibrant and thriving places for generations to come?

01:06:27 - 01:06:29

Lindsay Hoyle

Well said. Minister.

01:06:29 - 01:06:53

Speaker 60

Well, Mr Speaker, I'm very glad to hear from my honourable friend that more than a thousand retail, hospitality and leisure properties in Redbridge may benefit from our real-terms freeze in their business rates bills, giving them real breathing space over the next two years. In addition, we're helping high street businesses through our new high street strategy, which was published at the budget, and we're providing £210 million to transform derelict buildings into new anchors of our high streets across the country.

01:06:53 - 01:06:54

Dan Aldridge.

01:06:54 - 01:07:29

Colin Daniel Aldridge

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The changes to business rates announced in last week's budget will provide some much needed breathing space to many businesses in Weston-super-Mare, Worle and the villages. However, thriving high streets in coastal communities like mine depend on businesses being able to take on new staff, particularly local young people.

At a roundtable I held last week with small businesses, the cost and difficulty of employing young people was raised repeatedly as a major concern. What more can the Treasury do to ease these financial pressures? And can the minister give a bit more information about the new high street strategy and how Treasury will work to make sure that vision is matched with funding? Thank you.

01:07:29 - 01:08:03

Speaker 60

Well, Mr. Speaker, the government wants to support businesses in Weston-super-Mare as well as across the country to take on young people in particular. And that is why our Youth Jobs Grant offers businesses £3,000 for every young person they hire, aged between 18 and 24, who has been on Universal Credit and looking for work for six months. Businesses also benefit from targeted employer national insurance contribution reliefs for young people.

Employers pay no employer NICs on earnings up to just over £50,000 for employees up to the age of 21 and apprentices under 25, which is a saving of nearly £7,000 per eligible employee per year.

01:08:03 - 01:08:06

Speaker 65

Matt Turmaine.

01:08:06 - 01:08:35

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank my right honourable friend for his answer. I welcome last week's budget and its efforts to create breathing space for people and businesses. Watford has a It does indeed. Watford has a popular high street, and I've met with local businesses post-budget. They're keen to see the government cut red tape and stimulate growth.

Can my right honourable friend please outline some of the specifics that the government is doing in order to help our high streets?

01:08:35 - 01:09:05

Speaker 60

Well, Mr Speaker, I thank my honourable friend. And as he points out, the government is working to reduce red tape for businesses in Watford and right across the country by making progress towards our target of cutting the annual regulatory admin burdens for businesses by 25% by the end of this Parliament.

As I also mentioned, at the budget, we published our high street strategy, which is backed by £210 million of new funding that will bring vacant and derelict properties back into use, support the growth of co-ops and mutuals, and help more communities to take ownership of valued local assets.

01:09:05 - 01:09:06

Patrick Spencer.

01:09:06 - 01:09:47

Patrick Spencer

Mr. Speaker, I received an email from a publican in my constituency recently. She said, "I cannot find people willing to work minimum wage because they earn more on benefits. I cannot give my experienced staff a pay rise because minimum wage increases eat into my budget. And often people will turn up for interviews only to demonstrate they are looking for work for the job center before bunking off on their first day."

So, can the Chancellor explain to me, then, why he has used the Budget to compound those problems of an unaffordable minimum wage and an out-of-control welfare system?

01:09:47 - 01:10:13

Speaker 60

Mr Speaker, it's important that people get paid for the work that they do in a fair way. But it's also important that we support our pubs, which are much-loved in communities across the country, and that is why one of the first announcements the Prime Minister made when he came into office in July was an extra 20% cut in the business rates bills for pubs and live music venues across the country. That was confirmed at the Budget, that is being implemented from next year and that will help pubs across our country, including in the honourable gentleman's constituency, to thrive.

01:10:13 - 01:10:14

Rachel Gilmour.

01:10:14 - 01:10:40

Clare Rachel Gilmour

Speaker, while the Budget provides some welcome support for high streets, so many businesses in Tiverton and Minehead tell me that excessive costs, regulation and red tape remain a drag on growth.

Does the minister agree that lasting economic growth will require not just short-term support, but fundamental reform of business rates and tax administration so that businesses can invest, expand and create jobs with confidence?

01:10:40 - 01:11:09

Speaker 60

Mr. Speaker, I agree with some of the principles behind the honorable lady's comments, which is that in addition to the breathing space now that the budget delivered, we're also beginning work to help businesses and the economy to grow in the long run. And she mentioned the importance of us cutting red tape and bureaucracy. And indeed, as I mentioned just a moment ago, we are cutting the regulatory admin burden of businesses by 25% by the end of this Parliament, which is critical to taking some of the pressures of business to allow them to invest, grow and succeed in their local communities.

01:11:09 - 01:11:12

Lindsay Hoyle

Alison Griffiths.

01:11:12 - 01:11:44

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. At my business club last week before the budget, businesses in my constituency on the high street, including ones that will be well known to the shadow, sorry, to the minister, told me about their concerns.

They have not been assuaged by this budget. So, what is this government going to do to reduce the tax burdens on this hospitality and tourism industry, and when will that happen?

01:11:44 - 01:12:05

Speaker 60

April 2027, Mr. Speaker, because that was announced at the budget. As I've set out in my earlier responses, to help businesses on high streets across the country, we are making sure that all retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England have a real-terms 2-year freeze in the business rates bill, or see them reduced, or see them cut to zero.

01:12:05 - 01:12:09

Lindsay Hoyle

Gareth Davies, shadow minister.

01:12:09 - 01:12:45

Gareth Davies

Mr. Speaker, I've just been sat there listening to the minister give some sort of victory lap on business rates.

It's like they've broken the high street's leg, given it a crutch and now asking for a thank you. The British Retail Consortium called the Chancellor's business rates package a smoke and mirrors announcement. I call it a missed opportunity to fix the fact that they cut business rates relief from 75 to 40%. Why doesn't he just back the Conservatives' plan to abolish business rates for 250,000 businesses on the high street across our country?

01:12:45 - 01:13:14

Speaker 60

Mr Speaker, he talks about missed opportunities.

They had a missed opportunity for 14 years when they were in government to properly support high streets across the country. This government is giving real support from April next year to businesses on high streets across the country, starting with a 20% saving for pubs that the Prime Minister announced in July. Added to that, taking 70,000 small RHL businesses out of paying business rates altogether and a real-terms two-years freeze for all other RHL businesses in England. That is real help for businesses, helping them to succeed.

01:13:14 - 01:13:15

Daniel Francis.

01:13:15 - 01:13:19

Daniel Francis

Question number nine, Mr Speaker.

01:13:20 - 01:13:51

Speaker 60

Sorry. Sorry, Mr Speaker. Mr Speaker, as I was just saying, the government is backing high streets and small businesses with a package that means that all retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England will see their business rates frozen in real terms, reduced or cut to zero. The government is also helping employers, particularly small and medium employers, to recruit the workers that they need to by expanding the local apprenticeship services and providing eligible SMEs with a £2,000 hiring payment when recruiting young ones.

01:13:51 - 01:13:52

Daniel Francis.

01:13:52 - 01:14:24

Daniel Francis

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I welcome the fact that a signifi- can't speak, a significant number of independent high street businesses across Bexleyheath and Crayford will be released from paying business rates as a result of those decisions from next April. And one of those businesses is the Bird & Barrel, or barrel, rather, micropub in Barnehurst, which also run the hugely popular Bexley Brewery in Slade Green. So, can the minister outline the additional support that will be given to small alcohol producers and brewers as a result of the decisions within the Budget?

01:14:24 - 01:15:03

Speaker 60

Well, Mr Speaker, I thank my honourable friend for letting us know about the Bird & Barrel and the Bexley Brewery, which sounds like they're both worth a visit.

And I'm very glad that at the last, the budget last week, the Chancellor was able to offer support specifically for small brewers by announcing an increase in the generosity of small producer relief. Now Mr Speaker, these changes made in the budget move to a more generous discount taper for products under three and a half percent ABV, and they uprate the marginal discount for products between three and a half and 8.4% by RPI plus an additional 10%. Mr Speaker, this will provide 10 million pounds of support per year to over 2,000 small alcohol producers across the country.

01:15:03 - 01:15:07

Speaker 75

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question number 11.

01:15:07 - 01:15:46

Speaker 9

Mr Speaker, the last Labour government introduced child trust funds with the intention that every child in this country could access a financial asset as they enter adulthood, and almost 3 million young people have already accessed their funds, currently containing an average of £2,600 each.

Today, we're announcing that we're making fund access simpler for those who lack mental capacity, meaning tens of thousands more young people will benefit from their funds. And I'd like to thank my honourable friend for his campaigning on this, alongside the honourable member for Hyndburn in particular, who I know, both of whom I know, care very deeply about this issue.

01:15:46 - 01:16:22

Charalambos Charalambous

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to congratulate the Minister on her announcement today, which will enable over 120,000 young people who lack capacity to access these Child Trust Funds, and know make a huge difference for them. As the Minister's aware, there are an estimated 800,000 unclaimed Child Trust Funds worth approximately £1.3 billion. So, can the Minister tell the House what steps she's taking to enable these young people who are often unaware of the existence of these Child Trust Funds to access them? And will she work with The Share Foundation to find a long-term solution to this?

01:16:22 - 01:16:42

Speaker 9

Mr. Speaker, I will, and I'd like to thank, again, my honourable friend for the work that he's done in this area.

We are working with The Share Foundation, we're working with other industry partners in this area too. We've set up a Child Trust Fund task force to improve tracing, customer communication and engagement, all with the aim of putting more young people in this country in touch with their Child Trust Funds.

01:16:43 - 01:17:15

John Milne

Thank you, Mr Speaker. This is fantastic news and so many people have campaigned over so many years. I'd like to thank my colleague, Baroness Kramer, in the Lords, who has helped bring in amendments to the Finance Bill, which has brought it to this moment. Would the Minister join with me in paying tribute to my Horsham constituent, Andrew Turner, who is one of the first parents who discovered this when his own child, Mikey, reached the age of 18, 6 years ago, who has campaigned tirelessly on this? He's done a fantastic job.

Would she like to congratulate him?

01:17:15 - 01:17:24

Speaker 9

I would, Mr. Speaker, and I'm grateful for the opportunity to do so, to both Mr. Turner and indeed to the honourable member, as well, for all of his work on this, too. Thank you.

01:17:24 - 01:17:47

Madeleine Sarah Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This change on Child Trust Funds is a huge win for the campaigners who have fought for six years to see this change. I know it means a huge deal to my constituents Paula and Andy Gilbert, and their son, James. But can I ask the minister what the timescales are for when these families will be able to access their money?

01:17:47 - 01:18:07

Speaker 9

Mr. Speaker, I'm grateful to my honourable friend for all the work she has done in this area, indeed working, too, with Mr. with Mr. Turner. I am going to be bringing forward an amendment to the Financial Services Bill, the second reading of which is next week, which will enable the Ministry of Justice to make regulations to put this in action.

01:18:08 - 01:18:35

Joanne Sarah Dyke

Thank you, Mr Speaker. As a YMCA parliamentary patron, I visited their home in Glastonbury, which works alongside the street foyer, supporting young people, including care leavers. Many care leavers have Child Trust Funds opened by the state, but no parent or guardian to tell them the money actually exists. They need it most. So, what is the Chancellor doing to make sure every care leaver receives the savings that are rightfully theirs?

01:18:35 - 01:18:44

Speaker 9

Mr Speaker, I'm grateful to the honourable member for her question. This is an issue that we are looking at via the Child Trust Fund Taskforce, and I'm more than happy to communicate with her further on this issue.

01:18:44 - 01:18:45

Amanda Martin.

01:18:45 - 01:18:53

Amanda Martin

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Although Portsmouth is on the south coast, oh, sorry, question number 12.

01:18:53 - 01:19:07

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

A little preview there. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Our 10-year advanced manufacturing sector plan backs jobs, investment and growth, and we have committed up to 4.3 billion to the advanced manufacturing sector to 2030.

01:19:07 - 01:19:50

Amanda Martin

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Although Portsmouth is on the south coast, the legacy of deindustrialisation and privatisation are challenges familiar to many cities and towns across the north. Reindustrialisation must be national and not confined to the north. Mr. Speaker, the loss of shipbuilding in my city under the Tories devastated Pompey, but we are resilient and proud, and despite huge losses, we've retained a world-class defense cluster in advanced manufacturing and hugely skilled jobs in companies like Accuracy International, Harwin, Griffon Hoverwork and Airbus.

So, to enable real re-industrialization across the whole country, will the Chancellor commit to a national re-indus- industrialization strategy that protects advanced manufacturing, backs innovation, and drives growth?

01:19:50 - 01:20:19

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My honourable friend is right to raise the importance of re-industrialization. Too many places in our country were harmed by the de-industrialization that accelerated in the 1980s, and the need for more good jobs in more parts of England matters in the south, as well as in the north. It matters in our towns, as well as in our urban centres, and of course it matters in Portsmouth too. She is a strong advocate for her community, and I look forward to working with her to build on Portsmouth's proud industrial and maritime strengths.

01:20:19 - 01:20:20

Shockat Adam.

01:20:20 - 01:20:46

Shockat Patel

Thank you, Mr Speaker.

As chair of the APPG on Ethics and Sustainability in Fashion, I ask why our military and NHS uniforms are made overseas in countries like China, when factories in my constituency of Leicester South are ready, stimulating the local economy and providing jobs. So, will the Chancellor use public procurement to bring advanced textile manufacturing back to Britain, and will he meet with me to discuss how?

01:20:47 - 01:21:09

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The honorable member raises an important issue, and it touches on the broader topic that this government is focusing relentlessly on, which is making sure that through reforms to procurement, we can back British business and make sure more of the goods and services that the British government buys are built and made here in the UK.

01:21:09 - 01:21:12

Lindsay Hoyle

We go to topicals. Graeme Downie.

01:21:12 - 01:21:14

Graeme James Downie

Number one, please, Mr. Speaker.

01:21:15 - 01:22:23

Speaker 3

Mr. Speaker, three weeks ago, I attended the International Monetary Fund annual meeting. The IMF said that Britain now stands out among G7 nations for our fiscal credibility.

Last week, my budget continued that progress. This was a budget built on fiscal discipline. I meet our fiscal rules. I bring borrowing down in every year of the forecast period. And it means the UK is now set to reduce the deficit in the UK by more than any other G7 country by 2029.

This was a budget that was a clear political choice to give Britain breathing space today and fresh hope for the future. And as our new Treasury analysis shows, our overall winter support will benefit those in the lowest incomes most. This is how Britain will help British families in the midst in the midst of the Iran war, a war that the party opposite wanted to jump straight into. Support, Mr Speaker, funded by a fair and time-limited tax on banks, which they oppose. This is our choice.

This is our budget. This is a budget for working people.

01:22:23 - 01:22:55

Graeme James Downie

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Chancellor is very well aware of the threat to our economy of Russian cyber and physical attacks, but the UK public are not. My recent report, The Putin Tax, found that it is already costing the economy in excess of 2.5 billion pound a year and each taxpayer more than a 100 pound a year. And with families facing rising bills, I'm sure people would much rather spend that money themselves than give it to a dictator like Vladimir Putin. Mr. Chan- Will the Chancellor help fulfill the Prime Minister's recent commitment to me by gathering and publishing the data on the costs of Russian attacks so the public know how much Putin is costing their family?

01:22:55 - 01:23:21

Speaker 3

Well, I thank my honorable friend for his important work.

We know Putin's aggression is imposing real costs both on Ukraine and here at home. That's why in the budget we've provided an extra £10 billion of new economic and military support for Ukraine alongside new investment to bolster our own cyber defenses in Britain. We will continue to stand up to Russian aggression, to strengthen Britain's security, to ensure that Putin does not succeed in undermining us here in this country.

01:23:21 - 01:23:25

Lindsay Hoyle

Shadow Chancellor Andrew Griffith.

01:23:25 - 01:24:14

Andrew Griffith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week, the Chancellor had his chance to get debt under control. Instead, the OBR confirmed it will rise every single year. It's another missed opportunity. The national debt is now the equivalent of £100,000 for every household.

It's why we recently had the highest borrowing costs for 30 years. Mr Speaker, as a result of his policies, the Bank of England is expected to rise interest rates this week. Will he now admit that it is his failure to get a grip on borrowing that will be causing rates to rise?

01:24:14 - 01:25:07

Speaker 3

Mr Speaker, the budget confirms that borrowing will fall every year during the period. Debt will start falling from 2028-29. The honourable gentleman is right that we inherited a debt mountain. We inherited that as part of the consequence of the disastrous mini-budget that he was part of in the Treasury team. It crashed the economy, it collapsed confidence in Britain's fiscal strength.

We're fixing his failures. The chief investment strategist for L&G said this week our budget makes the UK, and I quote, "the adult in the room when it comes to fiscal discipline." They've learned nothing. Their latest policies are over 30 billion pounds in unfunded tax cuts, with the wealthiest benefiting most. With Labour, we got support for families, under the Tories, it's a return to the Liz Truss playbook.

01:25:07 - 01:25:13

Lindsay Hoyle

Can I just say, we're rerunning the budget and other people do need to get in, folks, go on, let's help each other. Andrew Griffith.

01:25:13 - 01:26:02

Andrew Griffith

Thank you, Mr Speaker.

It's very clear that he doesn't know how to get a grip on borrowing. So let me tell him. Conservatives have laid out plans to cut over 70 billion pounds of spending and he's very welcome to copy them. Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is thousands of miles away talking about wasting taxpayers' money on reparations and debt forgiveness. This government is happy to apologize for things that happened centuries ago, but takes no accountability of its actions today.

So, does the Chancellor agree with me that not a penny of taxpayers' money should be used on reparations?

01:26:01 - 01:26:44

Speaker 3

Mr Speaker, the Prime Minister has said he's open to discussions about an apology for Britain's role in the slave trade. He's also said that reparations are not the right approach. And listen, considering a formal apology does not mean accepting that British people today should be held liable for the past, which they played no part in. He asks this question because he distracts from the budget. And the question the people are asking is: Why does he not back the budget action we've taken to give Britain a bit of breathing space?

Why does he not back the action we're taking to fund that help this winter?

01:26:44 - 01:27:17

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Before the budget, I wrote to the Chancellor to flag that many of the challenges facing the Ministry of Justice are rooted in long-term financial pressures. Austerity saw justice spending cut by a third. And while the government has increased funding, the IFS said that an additional £3.6 billion would be needed if we were to return to pre-austerity spending per person.

So will the Treasury work with the Justice Secretary to ensure that our justice system is properly funding and future crises are prevented?

01:27:17 - 01:27:53

Emma Reynolds

Can I take this opportunity, Mr Speaker, to congratulate her on her election as chair of the Justice Select Committee. As she rightly said, we inherited a prison system at breaking point after 14 years of Tory mismanagement. At the spending review, we significantly increased the funding for at the MOJ: an additional £550 million for probation, £450 million for courts and £7 billion for prison places, and we've already delivered 3,000 new places through the largest prison building program since the Victorian era. I will continue to work with the Justice Secretary on the issues that she mentions.

01:27:53 - 01:27:56

Lindsay Hoyle

Daisy Cooper, Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

01:27:56 - 01:28:28

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister and his cabinet rightly point to Brexit as a major reason for the UK's doom loop of low economic growth, and in two and a half weeks' time, the Government has an opportunity to do something about it. So, rather than just a timid UK-EU youth mobility scheme, which should have been agreed months ago, will they start negotiations for a new growth and defense partnership as the only sure-fire way to put money back in people's pockets and make the UK stronger, safer and more prosperous?

01:28:28 - 01:29:12

Speaker 3

Mr Speaker, we've been there, done that on defense. What we're faced with at the EU at the EU summit later this month is the chance to add billions to our economy and help with prices with a new deal on food, drinks and farming. It's a chance to reinforce the collaboration that were on illegal immigration that would help tackle the small boats smuggling gangs.

And it's a recognition that the Brexit deal done by the Conservatives has just not been good for Britain. And instead of opposing all the steps we're taking to improve Britain's business trading, the Conservative Party are opposing this while we look for practical benefits to make this better.

01:29:12 - 01:29:14

Speaker 91

Patrick Hurley.

01:29:14 - 01:29:42

Brian Patrick Hurley

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Given recent forecasts around GDP growth in the years to come, does the Chancellor agree that improving living standards requires us to focus on GDP per capita rather than merely headline figures? And to help that focus, will he consider a review of the personal tax code looking at cliff edges and perverse incentives that discourage work and investment as part of the Government's commitment to keep growth on track?

01:29:42 - 01:30:15

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for his question.

I totally agree with him that GDP per capita is what matters. It has grown by 2% so far since the election, and it was revised up at the budget after falling in the last Parliament. And my honorable friend is right, too, to raise the need for government to look closely at the design of our tax and benefit system. We did announce at the budget the removal of the Carer's Allowance cliff edge, and I'm sure my right honorable friend, the Financial Secretary to the Treasury, will keep further simplification and reform options under review.

01:30:16 - 01:30:32

Alan Mak

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Hayling Island and Emsworth both need banking hubs funded by our high street banks.

Isn't the government's increase in the bank tax a disincentive and a missed opportunity at a time when more banking hubs are needed?

01:30:32 - 01:30:50

Speaker 9

Mr Speaker, as the right honourable member knows, we've got a commitment already to 350 banking hubs. We're working with industry to delivering those 350 over the course of this parliament. We've also got the access to banking review being conducted by Richard Lloyd as well. The end result of this is going to be more banking hubs right the way across the country.

01:30:50 - 01:30:51

Imogen Walker.

01:30:51 - 01:31:24

Imogen Walker

Thank you, Mr Speaker. There was real progress in the budget on the former Mineworkers' Pension, and I'm very grateful to the Chancellor and the rest of the team for that. But there is more to do and time is pressing. Our mineworkers did incredibly difficult jobs in very challenging environments, and they kept the lights on for all of us. They deserve every penny of their pensions.

So, can the minister tell me when we can expect an update on the release of the remaining funds?

01:31:24 - 01:31:56

Speaker 3

Mr Speaker, I know she welcomes the step I took in the budget that guarantees every penny of the pension fund surplus will now go in full to miners. I know the job's not done. I will go on to ensure that the full transfer of the guarantors fund, I want a way to resolve this in weeks, not months. That work is under way. That work will be done jointly by DESNZ and the Treasury.

And Mr Speaker, I'll ensure that my honorable friend and other members across this House from mining communities like me are fully updated on that work.

01:31:57 - 01:32:13

Speaker 95

Mr Speaker, the OBR's economic and fiscal outlook published alongside the budget last week included forecasted revenues from Rosebank. Yet, the Prime Minister and Secretary of State for Energy and Net Zero maintain no decision has been taken on Rosebank.

01:32:13 - 01:32:21

Speaker 96

So, will the Chancellor therefore acknowledge that if Rosebank is not approved, it will blow a huge hole in his budget?

01:32:22 - 01:32:44

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As I said at this dispatch box just a few minutes ago, it was the previous government that totally fluffed up this decision and these revenues were in the forecast since 2019. They should look in the mirror if they're looking for a political party that isn't able to get the right decisions when it comes to protecting the future of our oil and gas industry, it's them.

01:32:44 - 01:33:18

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Small businesses in Dartford who I spoke to immediately after the budget, including Tiger Tae, Alley's Cafe, and Albion's Bakery, all hugely welcomed the measure to change the threshold for payment of business rates to £18,000 that will cut their costs and those of many other businesses across the constituency. Can I ask the Minister to tell me what other measures they and other high street businesses can expect going forward in order to boost their growth and supplement our high streets?

01:33:18 - 01:33:37

Speaker 60

Well, I'm very glad, Mr Speaker, that our changes on business rates will benefit businesses in the honourable gentleman's constituency, part of the measures we took to take 70,000 small retail, hospitality and leisure businesses in England out of paying business rates altogether, as well as a 20% cut for pubs and a real terms freeze for all RHL businesses across the country.

01:33:38 - 01:34:09

John Glen

Thank you, Mr Speaker. This morning at the Treasury Select Committee, I was taken aback by how ferocious Helen Miller from the IFS was in decrying the government's Founders' Relief.

She suggested that it could lead to cliff edges and contrived business redefinitions. Could one of the ministers explain how Founders' Relief will encourage investment and innovation, because there is enormous skepticism out there amongst the community of entrepreneurs that it will have a positive effect?

01:34:09 - 01:34:24

Speaker 60

Well, Mr. Speaker, I fundamentally disagree with the right honorable gentleman because entrepreneurs who I've spoken to welcome the Founders' Relief that we introduced at the budget last year to back some of the founders, some of those people behind our fastest-growing businesses, creating the wealth, jobs, and opportunity in our country.

01:34:24 - 01:34:26

Speaker 99

Ian Byrne.

01:34:26 - 01:34:50

Ian Robert Byrne

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

The Chancellor rightly said last Wednesday that homelessness is a political choice. Does my right honourable friend agree that hunger is a political choice as well? Earlier this month, the Right to Food Commission published its final report, fully costed by Lord Prem Sikka, setting out credible reforms for food security by 2035. Will my right honourable friend meet with me to discuss its recommendations?

01:34:50 - 01:35:08

Torsten Bell

I thank the honourable member for his question. He's absolutely right to point that nobody should be relying on emergency food parcels in our country today. It's actually if you look at the Trussell Trust figures, they've shown falls over the last two years. That's the first time that's ever happened in the data they produce, but there is much further to do. And I'm, of course, happy to meet with my honourable friend.

01:35:08 - 01:35:09

Richard Tice.

01:35:09 - 01:35:36

Richard Tice

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Minister from Swansea West and the Chancellor have both inadvertently misled the House this morning. They have both said the government borrowing is coming down.

It's not. In the budget, government borrowing for this year will be 20 billion pounds almost higher than at the March OBR forecast, and for the lifetime of the budget book it'll be 65 billion pounds higher.

01:35:36 - 01:35:54

Torsten Bell

I know the honourable member is excitable at best, but borrowing figures in the OBR's forecast are falling every single year as a share of GDP. They will fall every single year, and they will fall because of the decisions made by this Labour government that's getting borrowing down and rescuing our public services.

01:35:54 - 01:35:55

Laura Kyrke-Smith.

01:35:55 - 01:36:16

Laura Kyrke-Smith

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Whether it's pubs like The Rockwood or Craftyard, cafes like Darlington's or restaurants like Kuzu, small businesses are the backbone of our economy in Aylesbury and the villages, and the heart of our community. For many years, it's been tough for them, but we're starting to turn a corner.

Can the minister set out how last week's budget will help our brilliant local businesses to invest, to create jobs, and grow?

01:36:16 - 01:36:33

Speaker 60

Well, Mr. Speaker, we want to support our brilliant local businesses to succeed and I hope that some of Rockwood, Craft Yard, Darlington's and Cuddesdon may benefit from some of our budget measures, which means that all retail, hospitality and leisure properties in England will see their business rates frozen in real terms for two years, reduced, or cut to zero.

01:36:34 - 01:36:56

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. New financial modeling on the government's proposals for an asylum camp at MOD Bicester Site A that affects many of my villages shows that the per night, per person cost is two and a half times that of the equivalent hotels. So if it's cost control the Chancellor's after, surely he'll tell the Home Secretary not to proceed with that plan.

01:36:56 - 01:37:05

Emma Reynolds

We were left a terrible legacy by the party opposite and we have cut £1 billion from asylum costs during the time we've been in power.

01:37:05 - 01:37:06

Johanna Baxter.

01:37:06 - 01:37:40

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

One way to achieve growth in postcode PA1 is to help revitalize our high street, and the best way of doing that is to back the redevelopment of the Paisley Centre, which lies at the heart of it. This is a shovel-ready project which received planning permission nearly 4 years ago and has the potential to bring 330 jobs to our community. The previous Chancellor promised me she would help. Will my right honorable friend agree to meet with me to see how we can get this project moving?

01:37:40 - 01:37:58

Speaker 60

Mr. Speaker, I or a colleague of mine would be happy to meet with the honorable lady to discuss that much-needed investment in her constituency. And more widely, Mr. Speaker, the business rates changes that we have announced for retail, hospitality and leisure businesses in England are the very changes that we would urge the Scottish Government to replicate in Scotland.

01:37:58 - 01:38:00

Lindsay Hoyle

Dr. Roz Savage.

01:38:00 - 01:38:32

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Last week's budget papers assumed that significant tax revenues will be generated by new drilling at the Rosebank oil field. Now, is the government not worried, although I understand it's common practice to rely on these sorts of protect projections, is the government not worried that this signals that they've already made a decision on Rosebank, and are prioritizing short-term gains over protecting us all from the medium- and long-term catastrophic economic damage associated with climate breakdown and burning new oil and gas?

01:38:32 - 01:38:44

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've already answered similar questions on this topic. This revenue was in the forecast since 2019, and the decision is a quasi-judicial decision for the environment secretary.

01:38:44 - 01:38:45

Andy McDonald.

01:38:45 - 01:39:24

Andy McDonald

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

I welcome the budget's council tax rebate, which will provide much needed relief to over 50,000 households in Middlesbrough and Thornaby East, but hardship remains. Trussell Trust reports that local food banks distributed over 10,000 emergency food parcels last year, up almost 50% on pre-pandemic levels. Does the minister agree that more ambitious action is needed, and will he ensure that the government's response to the Milburn and Timms reviews does not further restrict social security support, leaving people unable to afford the essentials, and instead advances Labour's commitment to end the need for emergency food?

01:39:24 - 01:40:05

Torsten Bell

Well, I thank my honorable friend for his question.

I absolutely agree with the point he makes about reliance on emergency food parcels. In his constituency, over 90% of properties fall into council tax bands A to D, which means the residents will receive £100 directly into their bank accounts come January, in the coldest part of the year. But he's absolutely right to say we have to go further. That's why they will see 29 million households benefiting from the extended cuts to VAT on electricity, and 35 million motorists benefiting through extending the fuel freeze to fuel duty. Directly on the social security question he raises, that's also why we have made sure we are changing the support that goes to families with children.

So this Parliament sees the record fall in child poverty of any Parliament on record.

01:40:05 - 01:40:21

Ashley Peter Fox

Mr Speaker, the government has said it wishes to join the EU's internal energy market. This will involve a payment to the EU for the privilege.

When will the government say how much this policy will cost British taxpayers?

01:40:21 - 01:40:40

Emma Reynolds

I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. He'll know that there is an EU summit coming up on the 20th of November, and we are still negotiating with the EU. But what I will say is that we are putting right the botched Brexit that we inherited from the party opposite, that put frictions at our border and increased costs for farmers, family businesses, and others.

01:40:40 - 01:40:42

Lindsay Hoyle

Marcus Gamble-Kempson.

01:40:42 - 01:41:12

Markus Campbell-Savours

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Whilst the government looks to boost economic growth in Cumbria, businesses in the county are frustrated at losing staff to Sellafield and the wider nuclear sector, not just engineers and project managers, but business administrators, tradespeople, nurses, and teachers. Would the Secretary of State consider a review of the NDA's social impact duties under the 2004 Energy Act, and its impact on the growth and diversity of the wider Cumbria economy?

01:41:12 - 01:41:36

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for his question.

Nuclear and Sellafield are, of course, an important part of Cumbria's economy and the NDA's social impact work is vital. I agree with him that all parties need to continue to work together though to grow and diversify Cumbria's economy, and the Government has provided good growth funding to the new Cumbria Strategic Authority to do just that.

01:41:37 - 01:42:02

Llinos Medi

Diolch, Mr Llywydd. Around 5,000 people on Ynys Môn, my constituency, work in the hospitality sector. It is a vital part of the Welsh economy, yet while hospitality businesses across much of the European Union benefit from reduced VAT rates, our pubs, hotels, and restaurants are stuck paying 20%. Why did the Chancellor decide not to prioritize this sector in last week's budget?

01:42:02 - 01:42:15

Speaker 60

Mr Speaker, I question whether the honourable lady was listening to the budget last week if she thinks we weren't prioritizing hospitality, given that retail, hospitality and leisure businesses received real help on their business rates in England, and I would urge the Welsh Government to follow suit.

01:42:15 - 01:42:42

Sureena Brackenridge

Sureena Brackenridge. Speaker, the Green Innovation Corridor in my Wolverhampton North East has investment zone status and £27 million in capital funding, with £7 million earmarked to prepare sites for development. What further Treasury support, including access to finance and targeted tax incentives, will the Government provide to attract private investors and deliver more skilled jobs in Wolverhampton North East?

01:42:42 - 01:42:57

Speaker 9

Minister. Mr Speaker, my honourable friend is a relentless champion for her constituency. The government's devolving powers and funding to the West Midlands Combined Authority to support investment, while the National Wealth Fund is partnering with it to develop many projects which I'm sure will benefit her constituency.

01:42:57 - 01:42:59

Lindsay Hoyle

Martin Vickers.

01:42:59 - 01:43:23

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Economic growth and investment in my Brigg and Immingham constituency is greatly benefited following the creation of freeports and the associated tax benefits that they that come with that. Can the can ministers give an assurance that any reset with our European partners will protect the existing tax benefits?

01:43:23 - 01:43:50

Torsten Bell

Minister. Well, I thank the honorable member for his question. One of the things that has been less focused on in the budget is if you look at the business investment figures right across the country, we are actually seeing the highest level of business investment for a decade. Whole economy investment is now at the highest level since 1990. I absolutely recognize the point he raises, freeports around the country want to know about that.

You've seen the agenda set out for the European summit, and that makes very clear that the issues he raises are not on the agenda for this summit, but I'm happy I'm sure an honorable member is happy to meet with him.

01:43:50 - 01:44:16

Speaker 117

I warmly welcome last week's announcement that business rates relief will be extended to thousands of thousands more cafes and restaurants alongside further support for pubs. However, businesses such as the Village Green Cafe in Eyam face many of the same pressures as pubs without benefiting from the additional targeted relief. Will the Chancellor consider what further support can be offered to these vital employers and community hubs to ensure they are not placed at a competitive disadvantage?

01:44:16 - 01:44:39

Speaker 60

Well, I thank my honourable friend for mentioning the Village Green Cafe, which I know will be valuable to the local community in Eyam, and I can tell him that in addition to the business rate support that we've spoken about today, the new hope on the High Street strategy sets out the government's plan to revive our high streets and it includes taking a High Streets First approach that will bring more public services and civic activity into town centres, driving the footfall to support those local businesses.

01:44:40 - 01:44:58

Sarah Olney

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Treasury Committee's recent report on student loan repayments said that the government has a moral obligation to reverse their decision to freeze the threshold at which student loans are repaid. So, can the Chancellor set out his timeline for when he will end the repayment threshold freeze?

01:44:58 - 01:45:19

Emma Reynolds

Well, I thank the honourable lady, but I remind her of her party's role in trebling tuition fees when they were in coalition with the party opposite. Minister. We have helped this year by capping interest rates at 6% for plan two and three loans, and from the academic year 2028-29 will reintroduce targeted maintenance grants to support students from low-income households.

01:45:19 - 01:45:20

Sharon Hodgson.

01:45:20 - 01:45:51

Sharon Hodgson

Mr Speaker, I'm sure the Chancellor is always open to new ways to save money. Well, new modeling suggests that universal access to fracture liaison prevention services could save £606 million a year over five years, with the investment paying for itself within two years. So will the Chancellor encourage the Department for Health and Social Care to ensure that its promise of universal access to fracture liaison services by 2030 is backed by a funded delivery plan?

01:45:51 - 01:46:15

Emma Reynolds

I will make sure that my honorable friend gets a meeting with the relevant Health Minister. But what I will say to her also, more broadly, is that the Chancellor announced last week that in the spending review next year, we will set out a new, preventative spending category to get ahead of problems before they get more expensive, and recognise that preventing problems before they arise is a good use of taxpayers' money.

01:46:16 - 01:46:55

Rupert Lowe

Thank you, Mr Speaker.

We spend hundreds of billions on debt interest, migrant accommodation, foreign aid, public sector fraud, benefits for foreigners, and let's not forget the indolent, the healthy indolent. We are leaving a record tax burden and a shameful £3 trillion of national direct debt to our children, our grandchildren. Let me say this in a way even the Labour front bench understand: we are bankrupt. So, my question to the my question to the Chancellor:

is bankrupting Britain a consequence of government policy, or is it now the actual objective?

01:46:55 - 01:47:24

Torsten Bell

Well, let me say two things to the honourable member.

The first thing is, when it comes to the public finances, it is absolutely right that those are put on a sustainable basis, and that is this what this government is doing, bringing down borrowing every single year, praised by the IMF for standing out compared to any other G7 economy. And then the second thing I would say is that it's moral bankruptcy that we're worried about on this side of the House, when we see the behaviour of the honourable member opposite up and down this country, whipping up division rather than bringing this country together, saving our public services and investing for the future.

01:47:24 - 01:47:41

Julie Minns

Julie Minns. Mr Speaker, I welcome the Minister's acknowledgment that diversifying Cumbria's economy is key to our economic growth. Will he therefore support efforts to realise the potential of RAF Spadeadam as a future hub for rocket testing and innovation?

01:47:41 - 01:47:46

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

I would be very happy to meet with my honourable friend to discuss this matter in more detail.

01:47:46 - 01:47:47

Final question, Kieran Mullan.

01:47:47 - 01:48:09

John Kieran Mullan

Mr Speaker, the Community Amateur Sports Club scheme supports thousands of not-for-profit sports clubs across the country, including in Bexhill and my constituency with Highwoods Golf Club. The thresholds for participation haven't been lifted since 2015. I've had the pleasure of sparring with the Paymaster General on both Question Time and Any Questions.

Will he make it a hat-trick and agree to meet with me to discuss this?

01:48:09 - 01:48:16

Speaker 60

Well, I think he just has made it a hat-trick with a question today following Question Time and Any Questions. So, I'm happy to pick this up with him outside of the chamber.

01:48:16 - 01:48:43

Speaker 127

Let frontline exchange other. We now come to the urgent question. Gareth Snell.

01:48:43 - 01:48:55

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. To ask the Secretary of State for Business, Innovation, Science and Technology if he'll make a statement on the situation in Poundland and possible actions to protect jobs.

01:48:55 - 01:48:57

Lindsay Hoyle

Minister, welcome. Thank you.

01:48:57 - 01:52:41

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Good morning, Mr Speaker. Before I answer, I'd like to declare my interests as a member of Usdaw trade union. I am deeply concerned, Mr Speaker, about the uncertainty surrounding Poundland's future and the impact this could have on its thousands of staff and their families, who are at the forefront of my mind, especially in the run-up to Christmas. Poundland is not currently in administration and the business continues to trade, but this is a worrying time for employees, suppliers and communities. We are establishing the facts, keeping in close contact with those involved, and monitoring developments closely.

The Secretary of State and I are continuing to engage closely on this issue. We have met and are in ongoing contact with the trade union Usdaw, who I know are extremely concerned about their members' jobs and their livelihoods and I want to thank them for their work and engagement. We'll also be meeting with Barry Williams, the managing director of Poundland, this week. Earlier this week, officials met with Gordon Brothers and the Secretary of State is due to meet with them to continue to press our concerns and establish the facts. However, there are ongoing commercial negotiations concerning a private business and it would not be appropriate for government to seek to influence the outcome or comment on the merits of individual bids.

The owners should be acting in the best interests of their loyal UK staff and stores. What we want is the best possible outcome for Poundland's workforce and the future of the business.

The 12,000 staff and the many thousands of suppliers are at the forefront of our minds. And we want to see an outcome that protects as many jobs as possible and keeps as much of the business trading as possible. Government stands ready to ensure that affected employees can access appropriate support, should that be needed. The Prime Minister has set out his aspiration to bring good growth to every postcode, including by making high streets a new symbol of Britain's renaissance.

Last week, the government published our high streets strategy. The strategy goes further, setting out the principles for high street success, practical support for businesses through the business rates system, and more policies to support vibrancy and footfall.

This includes establishing a high streets first principle to steer the location of public estates, to drive footfall, and co-location opportunities between public services. The fundamentals for doing business in the UK are strong. Our economic strategy to deliver growth is investment across the public and private sectors, and in every postcode. Our industrial strategy, trade strategy, small business strategy, and the plan to make work pay address the long-standing barriers to growth. Retail is vital to employment and the economy, and we recognise that the sector has been through a significant period of change.

We want all types of retail to thrive now and in the future. And that is why we're working closely with businesses to understand what they need to succeed and to grow.

Minister Weston and I are providing a briefing for members of parliament in this House this afternoon on the support that is available to employees who may be impacted. And I want to emphasize that in the event a retail company enters administration, my officials would work, where appropriate, with the administers, the administrators, the Department for Work and Pensions, the Insolvency Service and local partners to ensure appropriate support is available to affected employees. We stand ready to support them if they need to move into new employment, however. And finally, Mr Speaker, our priority is always protecting jobs. And the Secretary of State and I will continue to engage with the company to secure the best possible outcome.

01:52:41 - 01:52:43

Speaker 129

Gareth Snell.

01:52:43 - 01:54:27

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. Thank you for granting the urgent question and can I thank the minister for the tone and content of her answer.

At the heart of this are the 11,000 people whose jobs hang in the balance, who through no fault of their own, now look to whether or not this side of Christmas, they will have a job at all. Mr. Speaker, those jobs are not concentrated as if it were a big factory, but they are dispersed across this country in towns like Hanley in Stoke-on-Trent, may not even be in your own constituency of Chorley, as well as the supply chains in and distributions in Makerfield and Harlow, which my honorable friend from Harlow were talking about this morning. But this company has survived because the workers turned it round. And we are in the situation we are today, because choices have been made by Gordon Brothers. They have rejected solvent bids.

They are seeking to push a company into administration for their own personal profit. And fundamentally, their interest does not appear to be the 11,000 constituents that we all represent, who take home money to look after their kids, put food on the table, and live a life that they deserve. I am very glad that the minister is continuing to meet, but the management of Poundland isn't the problem, it is Gordon Brothers.

So could I ask the Minister very simply, if we get to a point where administration takes place, if 11,000 jobs and the supply chain jobs are put at risk, what levers will she be able to use to save as many jobs as she can? What pressure can this House collectively give her to put on to the owners to accept one of the solvent bids to protect the jobs? And what can this House do to send a message to those to the Gordon Brothers that the predatory capitalism that they are putting into this company will not be tolerated, because we in this country will always stand with people before profit?

01:54:28 - 01:55:13

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend, Madam Deputy Speaker, for his reflections and comments today on behalf of his constituents, and for those many employees across the country. It is deeply concerning to see the uncertainty about Poundland's future.

That's why I, the Secretary of State, and the Prime Minister have been keeping a close eye on what is an extremely worrying situation for the staff, their families, and communities up and down the country. We've been demanding to know what is happening, particularly for Gordon Brothers to explain why they haven't accepted any offer to keep the company going. We continue to establish the facts. Last night, officials met with Gordon Brothers as part of that ongoing engagement. The Secretary of State will meet them later this week, and I am meeting with Poundland tomorrow.

It's absolutely legitimate for this Government to ask the business they're doing everything they can to protect employees and suppliers up and down the country.

01:55:13 - 01:55:17

Speaker 130

Shadow Minister Bradley Thomas.

01:55:17 - 01:57:31

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Mr Speaker, for thousands of Poundland workers, the question today is simple: will I still have a job? Behind every store facing uncertainty are workers, real people with bills to pay and families to support. And as a West Midlands MP, this will hit close to home, with headquarters being in the region. For thousands of shoppers who rely on this store to make their money stretch further as the cost of living worsens, their question is also simple: will they still have a local, affordable place to shop as Christmas approaches? Workers and customers deserve clear answers about what happens next.

Why was a proposed management-backed rescue bid rejected? Can an agreement still be reached? If individual stores are sold, will their employees keep their jobs? And when will communities learn whether their local branch has a future? The current economic landscape is hostile to British business.

Between stifling red tape, skyrocketing energy bills and surging employment costs, another well-known British brand being in trouble feels like a surprise less like a surprise and more like an inevitability.

Rather than admitting their own vindictive policies have driven the cost of doing business to an unsustainable breaking point, the Government is instead locked in a desperate squabble with Reform over who can intervene the most to engineer a state sponsored rescue. The reality is clear, increased political interference is a failed strategy that offers nothing but false promises to workers and consumers alike. True security cannot be micromanaged into existence by Whitehall. If the Government genuinely wants to revive our economy, it must start dismantling the barriers to growth that they put in place since taking office. Running a business should be an ambitious pursuit, not a high-stakes gamble against state-induced risks.

That is why, rather than looking to interfere in yet another business dispute, they should instead focus on slashing the unnecessary red tape that is suffocating businesses, lower business rates that hinders high street growth, reduce the cost of employment and make it rewarding to invest in people, deliver lower energy that businesses across the nation are calling for, and get tough on the wave of shoplifting that's plaguing our high streets. We must protect workers' livelihoods by allowing businesses to get on with driving economic growth and employing people rather than looking to stifle their every move.

01:57:31 - 01:58:41

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I must say, I'm quite disappointed at the tone of the shadow Minister today. Vindictive economic policies and a squabble with Reform, that's your answer to 12,000 people whose jobs are at risk in the run up to Christmas and those thousands of suppliers across the country. And saying that the Government should stop interfering in another business, that is exactly not what we are saying today and not what I am doing. And if you had listened to my statement, Madam Deputy Speaker, he would have known that.

We're not interfering with the auction.

There are current, ongoing commercial negotiations about a private business, and we don't want to impede or influence that process or comment on individual bids, which I said in my remarks. It is legitimate for the government to ask a business that they are doing everything they can to protect employees and suppliers, to get clarity of their plans and a clear understanding of the situation. That's why we're saying that business owners have responsibilities to their employees, and in this case, 12,000 of them across the country. It's right for us to put pressure on the company. Ownership brings responsibilities as well as rights, Madam Deputy Speaker.

We're clear as this government of what our expectations are and why we are taking a responsible approach, not to sit by and do nothing. What's the point in politicians and government if we took that approach?

01:58:41 - 01:58:44

Speaker 132

Chair of the Select Committee Liam Byrne.

01:58:44 - 01:59:33

Dominic Liam Byrne

Deputy Speaker, there are actually 30,000 jobs that are at stake in Poundland and its supply chain. And internal documents that we saw at the weekend show the business sales, margins, and profitability are actually ahead of target. So, is the Minister absolutely convinced that Poundland's directors are fulfilling their fiduciary duty and acting in the best interest of Poundland, or in the interests of a faceless American investment firm? And if the loan of up to 60 million that was raised and imposed on Poundland is the barrier, will she take steps to ensure that we're doing everything we can to restructure it so it's not a barrier to saving Poundland's business?

01:59:33 - 01:59:35

Speaker 133

Minister.

01:59:35 - 02:00:10

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for his remarks and for his close engagement on this issue over the past couple days.

We know how concerning this is for employees across the country. We are still working behind the scenes, as he knows, engaging with Poundland, with Gordon Brothers, with the Secretary of State this week because we still hope we can secure that good outcome from the process, and why we're in close contact with the company and receiving regular updates on many of the points he alluded to today. We'll, of course, keep him as updated as we can. I can't go into all those details at dispatch box today, but I hope he's reassured about our concerns and our engagement with Gordon Brothers and the company going forwards.

02:00:10 - 02:00:13

Speaker 135

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Sarah Olney.

02:00:13 - 02:01:32

Sarah Olney

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The news about Poundland will be deeply worrying for its 12,000 staff members and their families, as the select committee chair says, the 30,000 members of staff in the supply chain, and, of course, for the communities where its stores are located. And as the Poundland founder Steve Smith has said, "Once these jobs are lost, they are lost."

So, and for many families, Poundland is one of the few affordable options left. People are already struggling with an unsustainably high cost of living, and they now face losing somewhere that they rely on to make their money go further. But the fall of Poundland raises bigger questions about our high streets. Its troubles show how much pressure both shoppers and high street businesses are under. The Prime Minister has set out his ambition to revive the high street.

However, the collapse of one of the UK's most well-known and affordable retailers highlights the extent to which our high streets are struggling. The business rate system puts our high street shops at an unfair disadvantage compared to online retail giants, and the National Insurance hike imposed by this government is unfair and counterproductive.

With unemployment levels already at alarmingly high levels, will the minister now listen to the Liberal Democrats' calls to properly overhaul the broken business rate system and scrap the unfair jobs tax, at the very least, for part-time workers?

02:01:32 - 02:02:09

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The UK retail market is rated one of the most advanced e-commerce markets in the world, and that has absolutely got to be celebrated, and we do so. The physical retail remains a key part of the high street and a thriving high street will need a strong retail offering, and we're clear that we want all types of retail to thrive now and in the future. She knows our announcements last week, our commitment to our high streets strategy, our announcements on business rates reform that will support many businesses in her constituency and all across the country.

We're committed to working with the sector as close as we can for them to grow and succeed, and in particular with this case relating to Poundland employees, Madam Deputy Speaker, I hope she hears our concerns and our engagement and how closely we're working with them on this issue.

02:02:09 - 02:02:10

Antonia Bance.

02:02:10 - 02:02:54

Antonia Kay Bance

Uh thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now I'm standing here on behalf of the workers in Tipton Centre and on Union Street in Wednesbury, all of whom provide a vital service to my constituency. And I wanted to ask the Minister, if it emerges that a viable bid to keep Poundland intact was blocked, putting 12,000 jobs at risk, what specific powers will the Secretary of State use to hold Gordon Brothers to account? And will she now establish an urgent review of whether our corporate governance and insolvency frameworks give sufficient protection against asset stripping and short-term financial engineering at the cost of jobs and our high streets?

02:02:54 - 02:03:31

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to thank my honourable friend for her question and for standing up for her constituents and the importance of this business to her local high streets and those across the country.

It's absolutely legitimate for the government to be asking the business that they are doing everything they can to protect employees and suppliers. That's why we're seeking clarity on their plans and a clear understanding of this situation. Officials have met with Gordon Brothers this week. The Secretary of State will and I'm meeting with Poundland tomorrow. They have a responsibility to their employees, as she mentions and rightly so, 12,000 of them and thousands more in terms of suppliers.

We'll keep putting pressure on the company. Ownership respons brings responsibilities absolutely as well as rights.

02:03:31 - 02:03:32

Richard Tice.

02:03:32 - 02:04:14

Richard Tice

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. While today the Tory party have shamefully said they don't give two hoots about 12,000 workers, including dozens in my constituency, what's going on here Madam Deputy Speaker, is the management of Poundland are very concerned about the owners of Poundland, and that the owners of Poundland are looking to abuse the insolvency process in order to maximize their financial return, not giving two hoots about 12,000 workers. So, will the minister confirm that the government will do everything it can to ensure that Gordon Brothers will not act as rogue owners and abuse the insolvency process?

02:04:14 - 02:04:44

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The appointment of an administrator is a matter governed by the statutory insolvency process as he knows and not a decision for government, but I hope he hears my remarks today about our engagement with Gordon Brothers, with Poundland, for those 12,000 employees up and down the country and many more in terms of suppliers. We want to do everything we can to make clear that jobs are absolute priority in this situation, they are so important for our high streets up and down the country, and that's why we're taking the responsible action this government has so far and will continue to.

02:04:45 - 02:05:14

Valerie Vaz

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I too am a member of Usdaw the union. Madam Deputy Speaker, my constituents want to work for Poundland and they have helped it turn a profit at Midland Road in Walsall, so could I ask the Minister whether she could ensure that Usdaw is round the table at any negotiation? They have struck a deal with IKEA and with John Lewis, and their knowledge is valuable. So please, could she ensure that they are round the table?

02:05:14 - 02:05:16

Speaker 139

Minister.

02:05:16 - 02:05:36

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honorable friend for her question and absolutely pay tribute to the union Usdaw for their work, engagement with the members and with the Government. I know how concerned they are about their members' livelihoods and jobs in the future, and throughout this process we've engaged with them closely and will continue to. They're joining me my meeting with Poundland tomorrow.

02:05:36 - 02:05:37

Sir Julian Lewis.

02:05:37 - 02:06:22

Julian Lewis

The great majority of more than 300 online reviews of the Poundland store in Totton in New Forest East give it a five-star or four-star rating. I think the most concerning part of this urgent question from the honourable member for Stoke-on-Trent Central was his concentration rightly on the apparent rejection of viable solvent bids. If ever there were a case of potential asset-stripping, this would appear to be it, and if the Government can't intervene, surely this is where trade unions and their legal advisors have a positive role to play?

02:06:22 - 02:06:26

Speaker 141

Minister.

02:06:26 - 02:06:52

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm thrilled to hear the member talk about the important role of trade unions. It's what I talk about constantly in dispatch box, and it's quite refreshing to hear that repeated back to me. Of course, I can't speak for exactly what Usdaw's legal advice or what they are doing. As I have said and he will have heard, we are meeting with them, we're meeting with the business as well. Usdaw obviously are standing up for their members who are really concerned about their livelihoods in the run-up to Christmas, and I thank them for it and for their continued engagement.

02:06:52 - 02:06:53

Johanna Baxter.

02:06:53 - 02:07:34

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We have three Poundland stores across Paisley and Renfrewshire South: one in Paisley itself, Linwood, and Johnstone. And I've been contacted by many Poundland employees who are concerned about the current situation. One of them is Dawn. She has worked for Poundland for 21 years.

She's been a loyal and hard worker. She's now 64 years old, and she's very concerned that if she loses her job now, so close to retirement, it will mean that she's in a very vulnerable position and unable to get another job before retirement. So what assurances can the minister provide to employees like Dawn in those circumstances?

02:07:35 - 02:08:05

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to thank my honourable friend for raising that really concerning case of her constituent and of those that she represents. She's right to raise them today. We are seeking clarity of the business's plans and a clear understanding of the situation. The department has met with Gordon Brothers this week, the Secretary of State will, and I'm meeting with Poundland this week too. Business owners have a responsibility to their employees and for her constituents, in this case, it's thousands across the country, I know how concerned they will be and how concerned she is, and we share them.

02:08:06 - 02:08:49

Alexander Christopher Murray Law

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The news that Poundland has filed a notice of intention to enter administration will cause deep concern for the many thousands of employees whose jobs are in jeopardy and of course the millions of customers who rely on its low prices. With almost 50 stores in Scotland, including Poundland in my city, Dundee, my thoughts are with the many families who are now worried about jobs and livelihoods at the worst possible time run up to Christmas. Given that discount retailers would normally be expected to perform strongly during a cost of living crisis, does the minister recognize that Poundland's potential administration is yet another damning failure of this UK Government to improve customer consumer confidence in the health of the UK high streets and alleviate the financial pressures facing low-income households?

02:08:49 - 02:09:28

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Business investment grew by 4.8% in the first half of this year. Productivity has grown for six consecutive quarters.

GDP grew for the first half of 2026, and the OBR have upgraded its 2026 growth forecast. Whole-economy investment has increased by 1.9% since the start of this 6.9% since the start of this Parliament. So let's not go into the back-and-forth of what our economy is doing. We've got a good base for businesses to grow and start up here in our country, and we are proud of it. In this situation, regarding Poundland employees, and he references those thousands in Scotland and across the country, that is our priority, and what we're working on this week, engaging with the company in a responsible way as you would expect a Government to.

We want to protect those jobs and those livelihoods.

02:09:28 - 02:09:30

Speaker 144

Clive Efford.

02:09:30 - 02:10:20

Clive Efford

Thank you, Deputy Speaker.

I welcome my honourable friend for Stoke-on-Trent Central's question. What we have here is an American private equity firm who are able to buy a going concern that is present on many of our high streets and that they can put their desire for profit above that of those workers, the 18,000 workers that work for in the supply chain and make a mockery, to be quite frank, of the government's plans for our high streets. So, if we do not have the power to ensure that if there's a viable bid on the table that it should be prioritized, then why don't we have that power?

02:10:20 - 02:11:01

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I'm proud of our plans for high streets and the announcement that the Chancellor made at the budget last week for businesses across the country and as a minister I'm really proud to work with our retail companies and sectors all across the country to support them to grow and thrive in the UK. As I've mentioned, we are committed to asking businesses to do everything they can to protect employees and the thousands of suppliers across the country. It's why we're seeking clarity in their plans at the moment, and a clear understanding of the situation. He will have heard my meetings that we're having this week, and our reiteration of businesses having a responsibility to their employees. It's right for us to put pressure on the company, because we have a responsibility, and ownership brings responsibilities as well as rights.

Wendy Morton.

02:11:01 - 02:11:36

Wendy Morton

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker.

Poundland is headquartered in Walsall, and one of, as one of the borough's MPs, I'm really concerned about the impact that this is having, not just on employees, but on business confidence, and also on our communities. I do feel it's symptomatic of some of the Government's failed policy choices, but for today, I want to focus on the employees, and ask, what exactly is the Government doing, and when the Government talks about appropriate support for employees, what exactly does she mean?

02:11:36 - 02:12:07

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The mayor, Richard Parker, is ready to stand up support and resource for those in the region who might be impacted. We're working closely with the Department for Work and Pensions, as we always would in situations like this, to ensure that we can support employees with training and further job prospects. My priority at the moment is the conversations we're having with the company, with Gordon Brothers, Poundland and Usdaw. We know how extremely worrying this is for their staff, families and communities.

It's why it's right we're taking a responsible approach to engage with them and to protect jobs.

02:12:07 - 02:12:08

Paulette Hamilton.

02:12:08 - 02:12:41

Paulette Hamilton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

In constituencies like mine, Birmingham, Erdington, we absolutely appreciated having Poundland. We've had three Poundlands, two of them have closed in the last year. So, my question to the minister is: what assessment has the department made of the private equity acquisition model, where a 30 million shareholder loan is prioritized over a solvent sale? Thank you.

02:12:41 - 02:13:20

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for her question. She'll have heard that we are demanding to know what is happening, particularly Gordon Brothers, to explain why they haven't accepted any offer to keep the company going and how they'll be acting in the best interests of their loyal UK staff and stores, as we continue to establish the facts.

Last night officials meeting with Gordon Brothers, part of their ongoing engagement and my engagement this week with Poundland and the Secretary of State's with Gordon Brothers too. Well, it's a current ongoing commercial negotiations about a private business, and we don't want to impede or influence that process. But I hope she's heard my concerns and our priorities of how this government is going to be responding.

02:13:20 - 02:13:21

Alison Bennett.

02:13:21 - 02:13:48

Alison Bennett

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've not been contacted by any constituents who worked at Poundland, because the store in Haywards Heath closed in February. We roll forward to November, and that large unit, that is an anchor unit for the whole of that high street, is still lying empty. So what is the government's plan to make sure that there's support for large units on our high streets by reforming business rates that prop up the rest of the high street?

02:13:48 - 02:13:50

Speaker 147

Minister.

02:13:50 - 02:14:27

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm sure the honourable member has welcomed our announcements on business rates from the Chancellor last week that introduced the two-year real terms freeze for all retail, hospitality and leisure properties to cap increase at inflation, and removing 70,000 extra properties from business rates, meaning that half of all RHL properties will pay no business rates at all. High streets, absolutely, are the beating heart of our communities and so important for local people and jobs. That's why we're committed to tackling their decline with our high street strategy and so many other initiatives in partnership with the sector. We want to absolutely back our high streets, back the jobs and back the businesses that support them.

02:14:27 - 02:14:56

Josh Newbury

Josh Newbury. Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.

On behalf of the staff who work at the Poundland stores in Cannock town centre and the Linkway Retail Park, I find this particularly shocking, particularly given that the company recently announced a return to like-for-like sales growth and thanked staff for their, quote, "amazing efforts". Does the minister agree that in light of efforts to rescue Poundland being rebuffed, Gordon Brothers need to get round the table with Usdaw, managers and creditors to save this iconic staple of our high streets?

02:14:56 - 02:15:22

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for his question today, and absolutely agree with him about the importance of jobs and the future and current uncertainty that lots of the employees are working through and the union too, and I want to pay tribute to them for all their work. We are absolutely committed to engaging with all stakeholders as much as we can and making our priorities clear that they are doing everything they can to protect employees and suppliers. That's why we're seeking clarity of their plans and a clear understanding of the situation.

02:15:22 - 02:15:23

Sir Ashley Fox.

02:15:23 - 02:15:55

Ashley Peter Fox

Madam Deputy Speaker, the Poundland in Bridgwater closed in July. And while the Minister is right to prioritise protecting jobs, will she accept that having introduced a 25 billion pound jobs tax, having added 350 pages of additional regulation in the Unemployment Act, having delivered above-inflation rises to the minimum wage, it is her government that is responsible for creating a hostile economic environment for British retail?

02:15:55 - 02:16:14

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm sad, but not surprised, to hear the response from the opposition benches that in response to a situation like this, where it's really worrying for 12,000 employees and for so many more in the supply chain, that the answer is to roll back rights for working people.

That's not our answer. We're getting round the table, we're trying to protect jobs, rightly as a responsible government should.

02:16:15 - 02:17:10

Mary Creagh

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And Poundland is a proud West Midlands business and its three stores, one of which is in Coventry, its three stores provide fantastic products at very reasonable prices to my constituents. And their workers have been writing to me about the concerns that they have over their futures. The 12,000 workers will be contributing tens of millions of pounds in tax and National Insurance to the UK Exchequer each year. Is there not a case for this activist government to stand behind any management buyout or buy-in from the from any bidder, to ensure that these workers continue to play their part on our retail high streets, in the way that they have done through the nationalisation of British Steel, and through the loan facility that they offered to Jaguar Land Rover last year?

02:17:10 - 02:17:54

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for her question. She's right to raise the impacts of cost of living on people and who rely on shops like Poundland in particular, as well as the direct feedback she's heard from her constituents and their worries and concerns to this chamber today, and I thank her for raising that directly with me. She will have heard that we're doing everything, we want to hear that the business is doing everything they can to protect her constituents, employees and suppliers all across the country. It's why we're seeking clarity on their plans to understand the situation. The process is still ever underway, it's an evolving situation.

So, we are continue to engage this week, and I hope she's reassured by our commitment to do that we're making clear that we want to understand the situation, and they have a responsibility on their thousands of employees and for her constituents.

02:17:54 - 02:17:56

Speaker 153

Hannah Spencer.

02:17:56 - 02:18:26

Hannah Kathrine Spencer

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

The Poundland in Denton expanded in 2022, and now employs 55 staff, several of whom have got in touch with me in the last few days, and all of whom now find their livelihood at risk as we begin the run-up to Christmas. And credit here to the union, Usdaw, for their work on this. But does the minister agree that this scandal exposes a very serious problem, that our economy is vulnerable to private equity vultures who swoop in and prey on our high street brands by loading them with debt, and then trying to ditch them for a profit?

02:18:26 - 02:18:55

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's deeply concerning to see the reports around Poundland's future. It's why I, the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister have been keeping a close eye on what is happening in an extremely worrying situation for her constituents and for staff across the country, their families and communities. We've been demanding to know what's happening and how the company will be acting in the best interests of their loyal staff and workforce.

We'll continue to establish the facts this week and in the future make it really clear where our priorities are, and that is absolutely protecting jobs.

02:18:55 - 02:18:56

Speaker 155

Jonathan Brash.

02:18:56 - 02:19:28

Jonathan Brash

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like the Minister and members across this House, my first priority is with the staff of Poundland including in the Hartlepool store at Middleton Grange Shopping Centre. Sadly, the same cannot be said for Gordon Brothers. And let's be clear, this is an organisation that has got form on this issue. So going forward, does the Minister not think it is time that we prevent these predatory capitalist vultures making their profits off the back of our people?

02:19:28 - 02:19:56

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honourable friend for his question. Absolutely key to this is to keep the business trading and protect jobs, as he rightly says. That's why we are continuing to watch the situation closely. Myself, the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister have made that clear.

The company need to account for why they haven't accepted an offer to keep the company going and explain how they are acting in the best interests of the workforce. Those are the conversations we'll continue to have, and that engagement is really important for us as a department and the government.

02:19:56 - 02:20:31

Claire Louise Young

Claire Young. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a hugely uncertain time for the people who work at the Poundland in Yate. And I'm sure I'm not alone among MPs in finding the DWP one of the hardest departments to get answers out of. So, I'm concerned about the practical support that the local Jobcentre will be able to offer anyone who loses their job.

So, can the minister assure me that Jobcentres on the ground will be supportive for people who lose their jobs from Poundland?

02:20:31 - 02:20:55

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Department for Work and Pensions stands ready to support anyone affected by this announcement with our rapid response service offer and it's a service designed to give support and advice to employers and their employees when faced with redundancy. Minister Western from the Department for Work and Pensions will be having a meeting with myself and all MPs later this afternoon if she wants to come and ask any further questions for the Department for Work and Pensions too.

02:20:55 - 02:20:56

Rachael Maskell.

02:20:56 - 02:21:35

Rachael Maskell

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Alongside the 12,000 workers who now face risk over their job are those based at Low Petergate in York who work at Poundland.

In the light of the egregious conduct of Gordon Brothers and their behaviours, will the minister look at the role of private equity companies in the retail sector? I have only just seen the last two weeks, you know, a chatter talk closing TK Jones on our high street and there seems to be a repeated behaviour of these companies. Will she look at regulations that we can debate in this House to ensure that we protect the retail sector?

02:21:35 - 02:22:09

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I thank my honourable friend for her question and hear her reflections of what needs what she feels needs to change in the future. We are at this current stage, the key priority is keeping the business trading and protecting jobs and she'll have heard our commitment in terms of engagement on that. Current ongoing negotiations about a private business, you know, we don't want to impede or influence that process as it is live and constantly moving. She will be reassured, I hope, about our engagement, both myself, the Secretary of State, with the business this week, with the union representatives and will continue to watch this situation closely.

02:22:09 - 02:22:12

Speaker 159

But protecting jobs is the absolute priority for this Government.

02:22:12 - 02:22:13

Speaker 160

Sammy Wilson.

02:22:13 - 02:22:57

Sammy Wilson

Madam Deputy Speaker, employees in the Poundland stores in Carrickfergus and Larne in my constituency are now facing a bleak economic future, all because what appears to be asset stripping of the stores and Poundland by the Gordon Brothers. And yet, there is an alternative because sales are up, profits are up, and there are viable investors wishing to take over the stores. Specifically, can the Minister tell us what pressure is she putting on the Gordon Brothers to do the right thing? And will she assure us she will not hide behind the excuse that this is a commercial decision, which the Government can't do anything about?

02:22:57 - 02:23:31

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I hope the honourable member is reassured about the work and commitment that we've undertaken as a department, whether it's engaging with the union, Usdaw, with Poundland, or with Gordon Brothers, because business owners have a responsibility to their employees, and in this case, it's 12,000 of them, and to many thousands more suppliers across the country. That's why it's right that we put pressure on the company. Ownership brings responsibilities as well as rights, and that's why it's legitimate for us to ask them how they are doing everything they possibly can to protect their employees and suppliers up and down the country. Clive Betts.

02:23:31 - 02:24:07

Clive Betts

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I, first of all, thank my honourable friend for his urgent question and putting very relevant questions to the Minister? I've got three Poundland stores in my constituency and every one of the workers at work today will be worried that they won't be back in a job tomorrow.

That's the reality of the situation. So I say to the minister, it's good to talk about how she can help people into jobs if Poundland shuts. It's good that she should be putting pressure on Gordon Brothers, but in the end if that pressure fails, is she actively looking at what proactive measures she can take to actually intervene and stop closures from happening?

02:24:07 - 02:24:43

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank my honorable friend for his question and for raising it this today. It's obviously really concerning time for so many employees in his constituency and constituencies across the country, and they are at the forefront of our minds when we're approaching this situation. That's why we're asking the business to do everything they can to protect employees and suppliers. It's why we need to keep understanding the clarity of their plans and to really have a clear understanding of the situation, which is why the meetings we're having this week are really important for us to assess that and to make sure that absolutely they have the responsibility to their employees and, as I said, in this case 12,000 of them.

02:24:43 - 02:24:45

Speaker 164

That's significant and what we want to protect.

02:24:46 - 02:24:47

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

02:24:47 - 02:25:29

Jim Shannon

Can I thank the minister very much for her response to all the questions? The potential collapse of Poundland places over 12,000 hard-working staff at risk across the United Kingdom, including on the high streets in Northern Ireland, and my constituency of Strangford, as well. Independent estimates suggested up to 30,000 jobs could ultimately be lost once the wider supply chain and high street neighbours are taken into account. So, what specific discussions is the minister having with the administrations across the United Kingdom, local enterprise agencies, to guarantee that workers in Northern Ireland are not left behind on any restructuring, and to ensure that these vital retail jobs are protected? Thank you.

02:25:29 - 02:26:01

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank him for his question on behalf of his constituents and the impact on his local high street. I hope he's reassured about our commitment to putting pressure on the business to make sure that they understand their responsibility to their employees in his constituency and those that are represented in this House today. That's really important and it's right for us to do so because we absolutely have that responsibility and take it extremely seriously and the ownership does as well as their rights. He will know of our meetings this week and that continued engagement, and we'll make that really clear.

02:26:02 - 02:26:37

Sonia Kumar

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. High streets like Dudley face pressures from online shopping and rising costs. Too many units have stood empty for years, weakening footfall and confidence. Potential loss of Poundland and the 15 jobs in my constituency could blow another hole on the high street.

But this isn't just about my 15 employees, also about the supply chain, as a ripple effect of the potential closure could cause problems in the supply chain, too. Has the minister assessed the full impact of the closures across Poundland, across the country, the supply chain, to hold the Gordon Brothers to account?

02:26:37 - 02:26:39

Speaker 166

Minister.

02:26:39 - 02:27:11

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for her question, and share her concerns around this situation for her constituents and those across the country. It's a very worrying time for them. That's why we are taking the responsible approach, engaging with Poundland, with Gordon Brothers and with the union Usdaw to make sure that jobs, absolutely, are protected as much as they possibly can, and to understand the situation, and demand to know what's happening so we can make that assessment and to ensure that the company is acting in the best interests of their loyal UK staff and workforce, and I thank her for sharing those reflections today.

02:27:12 - 02:27:48

Derek Twigg

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

It is not the fault of this Government. It is not certainly not the fault of the excellent employees at Poundland for this current situation. What it is the fault of is the worst type of greedy capitalism. Can I ask the Minister this, a number of my constituents have contacted me about the current situation, and what they want to know from the Government is what robust response the Government is giving to the owners, that no stone be left unturned, and what the options are that the Government can pursue?

02:27:48 - 02:27:50

Speaker 168

Minister.

02:27:50 - 02:28:26

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for his question. What's absolutely key is to make sure the business continues trading, that we protect those vital jobs up and down the country, in his constituency.

That's why we're watching the situation closely and as I said, Gordon Brothers have to account for why they haven't accepted an offer to keep the company going and explain how they're acting in the best interests of the company. Those 12,000 staff are at the forefront of our minds. It's a really worrying time in the run up to Christmas and that's why we'll be doing everything we can in our conversations to make our position clear of those jobs and that we have to protect them going forwards, and we want to see the business continue trading to do so.

02:28:26 - 02:28:28

Speaker 169

Jim Dickson.

02:28:28 - 02:29:02

Jim Dickson

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Poundland store in Dartford forms a really important part of the shopping offer at the Priory Centre as well as for the wider town centre. It employs local people and clearly those people it employs will be desperately worried about their future in terms of their jobs and their continued survival of Poundland itself.

Isn't it clear that the Government can't look on while a solvent company goes under, as the opposition parties appear to be recommending that we do?

02:29:02 - 02:29:26

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for his question, and he's absolutely right. We're not standing and sitting back, and as I said, what is the role of politicians in this Government if we were to do that? We absolutely are taking our responsibility seriously, and it's legitimate for us to ask the business that they do everything they can to protect employees and suppliers. That's why we're seeking clarity of their plans and trying to get a clear understanding of the situation, and that's absolutely what responsible government should do in this situation.

02:29:26 - 02:29:27

Claire Hazelgrove.

02:29:27 - 02:30:14

Claire Hazelgrove

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'd like to declare an interest as a proud member of Usdaw.

I'd like to share my support for valued Poundland workers across the country at this time of great uncertainty for them, including those in my Emersons Green store in my Filton and Bradley Stoke constituency. Local people work hard here day in and day out for this profitable company and deserve so much better than the worry of possible job losses due to no fault of their own, but inaction from the owners. What reassurance can the minister provide both me and valued local workers that the government is doing all that it can now and to review regulations and processes to see whether poor owner behavior can be further protected against in future?

02:30:14 - 02:30:47

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Minister. I thank my honorable friend, member for, friend, for her question and for raising this today in the House. She's absolutely right, and I share her concerns for her constituents, as families, thousands of families and employees across the country who are really worried about the future of their job. We've been standing ready to take action to support workers and reassure families wherever we can.

We want the best possible outcome for the workforce and the future of the business. That's why we're working hard behind the scenes to protect jobs. We'll continue our engagement this week. It's a real priority for us and we want to work closely with the businesses and with the unions as well.

02:30:47 - 02:30:49

Speaker 171

Alistair Strathern.

02:30:49 - 02:31:20

Alistair Strathern

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. My fair-minded Hitchin constituents are rightly appalled at the news that our local shop workers, Poundland's, jobs have been put at risk by exploitative owners that appear intent on asset stripping rather than preserving a store that's been returned to profitability thanks to the staff's hard work and has viable offers on the table. How can we make sure as a government we're using all of the levers at our disposal to force the American owners to do right by the stores, and what lessons do the government think we might need to learn to ensure we can do a better job at protecting our high street assets in the future?

02:31:21 - 02:31:59

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker.

And I want to thank my honourable friend for his question. He's absolutely right to raise this his concerns on behalf of his constituents and those all across the country who are really concerned about the future of their employment. We've been seeking to clarify the plans from the business and a clear understanding of the situation because it's absolutely legitimate for a Government to ask a business what that they are doing everything they can to protect those employees and suppliers. Of course it's an ongoing situation and an evolving one. We will continue to engage with Poundland, Gordon Brothers and with Usdaw the union this week to absolutely make sure that we can have the best possible outcome for the workforce and the future of the business.

02:32:00 - 02:32:29

John Thomas Hayes

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I called into the Poundland store in the Sovereign Shopping Centre just a few days ago to check in on the team, speak to the manager and find out how they're doing, and unsurprisingly, they're living with extreme uncertainty. So, can the minister speak directly to the employees of Poundland in Bournemouth, speak directly to Bournemouth, and let them know exactly what this government is doing to support them and save their jobs? Because after all, they just want to earn a good wage, they want to put food on the table, and they want to be able to afford presents under the Christmas tree.

02:32:29 - 02:32:31

Speaker 174

Minister.

02:32:31 - 02:33:03

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for raising the very concerning situation on behalf of his constituents in Bournemouth and the hundreds of jobs that are at stake. I hope he takes reassurance from my remarks at the dispatch box today and this government's intention that we will absolutely do everything we can to ask the business that they are doing everything they can to protect his constituents' jobs and those thousands of jobs across the country and with suppliers. We want the best possible outcome for the workforce and the future of the business, and while we'll have working hard to protect those behind the scenes with the company and the union involved.

02:33:03 - 02:33:04

Brian Leishman.

02:33:04 - 02:33:42

Brian William Leishman

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker and I thank the minister for her answers. And my thoughts are with all the staff at the Alloa store. What is happening with Poundland is the latest example of private equity being allowed to do as they please, the type of behaviour which has frankly destroyed our high streets. Now both the UK and Scottish governments need to act to stop private equity raiding our towns and then upping sticks when they've decided that there is nothing else to extract. So will the government take decisive action and take steps like curbing profit shifting and tax abuse by private equity?

02:33:42 - 02:33:44

Speaker 176

Minister.

02:33:44 - 02:34:11

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for his question. He's absolutely right to raise the responsibilities of business owners to their employees and in this case, it's 12,000 of them across the country and many in his constituency as well in terms of suppliers.

That's why it's right that this Government is putting pressure on the company. They have responsibilities as well as rights to their employees. And that's why we're asking them that they're doing everything they can to protect employees and suppliers and why we'll continue our engagements this week. It's a real priority for us.

02:34:11 - 02:34:13

Speaker 178

Gerald Jones.

02:34:13 - 02:34:41

Gerald Jones

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I also declare my proud membership of Usdaw the union? Poundland colleagues in Merthyr Tydfil, like elsewhere, are deeply concerned about their futures. The workforce have given absolutely everything to this company to make them profitable. So, can the Minister give further reassurance about what more the Government can do to ensure that Gordon Brothers do absolutely everything at their disposal to support their workforce and to treat them with fairness and respect?

02:34:42 - 02:35:22

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for his question. He's absolutely right to raise the hard work of the workforce and their dedication and determination to their jobs and the business. And that's why we've been so clear with the company in our engagements, and will continue to this week, of their responsibility to their employees and absolutely protecting jobs in this really concerning situation for so many across the country. And while we'll continue to work with the union, Usdaw, for their members and their concerns that they have, particularly in this difficult time in the run-up to business, we're a responsible government that will do everything we can to speak to the union with the business, and that how absolutely vital jobs are, particularly in Poundland with these high streets, but I know for his constituency and constituents too. So, I thank him for raising it.

02:35:23 - 02:36:08

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the minister for her statement.

As my honourable friend, who I thank for bringing this UQ forward, from Stoke Central mentioned, Harlow is not only home to two Poundland stores, but also a distribution centre that employs hundreds of people. Does the Minister share my concerns that owners are not acting in the best interest of Poundland employees in Harlow, particularly by rejecting legitimate bids for the business? Will she join me in sending her heartfelt messages to Frederick, Jodie, Donald, Tatjana and Jordan, who have personally written to me as well as other employees of Poundland in Harlow? And is there anything she can do, and I have to declare an interest as well as a proud member of Usdaw, to engage with Usdaw to ensure that Usdaw are around the table when having these discussions with the owners?

02:36:09 - 02:36:43

Alexandra Kate Dearden

I thank my honourable friend for his question and for rightly raising the concerns of his constituents, both in the Poundland stores and the distribution centre in Harlow and I thank him for doing that. I absolutely share those concerns and that's why we're taking a responsible approach, engaging with Gordon Brothers, Poundland and with the recognized union, Usdaw, who are of course concerned about the impacts on their members and their livelihoods. When I'll be meeting with Poundland tomorrow Usdaw will also be a part of those conversations. It's really important that we reiterate as far as we possibly can the importance of these jobs and that we make sure the business can succeed in the future and protect as many jobs as possible.

02:36:43 - 02:36:47

Speaker 182

And finally, Dave Robertson.

02:36:47 - 02:37:31

Charles David Robertson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last week workers in Lichfield woke up, put their uniform on, went to work and were told that their job was under threat, not because the company wasn't viable, not because the company wasn't profitable, but because the company's owners Gordon Brothers are just choosing not to do the right thing. They are choosing to put jobs at threat for their own selfish interests. I know the minister is working really hard on this.

I know Usdaw, the trade union, are working really hard on this. Would she can she give me, and I'm sure the whole House, a reassurance that every single thing is going to be done to make sure that Gordon Brothers step up, do the right thing, back their workers, because it's their workers that have turned this business around, not them, and it's time that Gordon Brothers recognise that and back those workers.

02:37:31 - 02:37:33

Speaker 184

Minister.

02:37:33 - 02:38:09

Alexandra Kate Dearden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank my honourable friend for his question. Absolutely, we back the workforce and want to thank them for their dedication and hard work to the business. And it's why we have been engaging with the company and the union this week, that they are acting in the best interests of their loyal UK staff and stores. It's why myself and the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister have been keeping a close eye on what is an extremely concerning situation, and worrying for those staff and their families and our wider community as well.

So, I want to thank him for raising that today, and hope he is assured about our commitment and engagement and work on this week.

And, of course, we'll keep him as updated as we can.

02:38:09 - 02:38:12

Speaker 185

Point of order, Gareth Snell.

02:38:12 - 02:38:20

Craig Gareth Snell

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I apologise, I should have put on record my membership of Usdaw at the beginning of this question, and I apologise to the House for inadvertently failing to do so.

02:38:20 - 02:38:45

Speaker 186

Can I thank the honourable member for putting that on the record? I will allow a few moments for the front benches to swap over. Which brings us to the Ten Minute Rule motion, Esther McVey.

02:38:45 - 02:46:40

Esther McVey

Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to introduce compulsory labelling of halal and kosher meat, and products containing halal and kosher meat, and for connected purposes. I am re-introducing this bill following the considerable support it received when it was previously brought to the House, as the concerns of lack of consumer choice, animal welfare and transparency have not gone away. I therefore hope the House forgives me when I repeat much of what I said last time, as the arguments for this bill haven't changed and remain compelling. Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill does not seek to ban halal or kosher meat.

It seeks to introduce clear, compulsory labelling so that consumers know exactly what they are purchasing. Every consumer has a right to make an informed choice, yet that choice is currently undermined by the lack of clear information, leaving consumers unaware that the meat they are purchasing and consuming may be halal or kosher. Currently, labelling arrangements are voluntary and inconsistent. The bill would address that gap by introducing clear and compulsory labelling, giving consumers the information they need to make the choices that reflect their beliefs, values, and dietary requirements.

Some people particularly want to buy halal or kosher meat; other people particularly want to avoid buying it. This bill will benefit both of those groups.

In order to produce halal and kosher meat, an animal's throat is cut at the point of slaughter. In the case of halal meat, the animal is often stunned before it is killed, although it may not be. Under the shechita method used to produce kosher meat, there is no pre-stunning. For many consumers, whether an animal was stunned before slaughter is an important animal welfare consideration. And what began as a limited religious exemption has become an increasingly significant part of the meat market.

The Government's own figures show that, of the approx 1 billion animals processed in England and Wales in 2024, an estimated 215 million were slaughtered to produce halal meat.

On those numbers, what was meant to be an exemption, an exception, is certainly not. And government guidance is clear: that meat that results from non-slaughter, non-stun slaughter, must be intended for consumption by Jews or Muslims. But production is clearly going way beyond that. And alarmingly, the United Kingdom now exports halal meat overseas, and between 2018 and 2019, there was almost a 700% increase in sheep meat exported to the United Arab Emirates. Consumers are increasingly interested in how meat is produced, and of those concerned about animal welfare, they want to know whether an animal has been stunned before slaughter.

Equally some people wish to know whether meat has been prepared according to a particular religious rite. None of these are unreasonable positions. The important point is that consumers should have the information they need to make an informed choice. The legislation regulating animal slaughter is currently set out in the assimilated EU regulations 1099/2009 on the protection of animals at the time of killing together with the welfare of animals at the time of killing England regulations 2015. Under those provisions, animals must generally be stunned before slaughter, although exemptions exist for slaughter carried out in accordance with specific religious observance.

However, while the law provides an exemption for stunning requirements, it does not require meat produced under those exemptions to be labelled. As a result, consumers are often left without information that they would regard as highly relevant to their purchasing decisions. The Government has previously stated that consumers should be able to make informed choice about the food they buy, yet informed choice is only possible when relevant information is available. In the absence of mandatory labelling, consumers are frequently unaware whether the meat they purchased had been produced under a religious exemption or whether the animal was stunned before slaughter. That cannot be described as meaningful consumer choice.

The lack of compulsory labelling has helped create what is effectively known as a two-tier system within the industry. Some slaughterhouses comply with the general requirement to stun animals before slaughter, while others operate under the religious exemption. Currently, some of the UK's largest retailers, including Sainsbury's, Tesco's, Marks & Spencer's and Asda, sell halal or kosher meat without informing consumers, and takeaway outlets such as Domino's, Pizza Hut's and KFC serve it without consumers being made aware. Non-stunned meat is also served in schools by 17 local councils, the majority of which are not Islamic faith schools, meaning that parents and pupils may have had no idea what they were eating. And it is also being served in UK hospitals, where patients don't know what they are eating.

In late 2024, the Labour Party published its animal welfare strategy, which claimed to set out a comprehensive agenda for improving animal welfare. It addressed issues such as boiling of live lobsters, carbon dioxide stunning for pigs, and the treatment of farmed fish. Yet despite spanning more than 12,500 words, the strategy made no reference to the slaughter of animals without prior stunning, and contained no proposal for clearer labelling of halal and kosher meat. If animal welfare is a genuine priority for this Government, then that cannot be overlooked. For a strategy presented as a landmark contribution to animal welfare, it certainly is not.

Public support for greater transparency is overwhelming. Food and You 2, which is a biannual official statistics survey commissioned by the Food Standards Agency, found that the most common spontaneously expressed food concern in 2024 was food production method. In August 2022, almost 99% of respondents to the government's call for evidence on labeling for animal welfare said that method of slaughter labeling should be introduced. In research from the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board, 92% of halal consumers state that clear halal certification is important. So, is it not time we updated our regulations and demanded that our meat was clearly and fully labeled?

Surely that is what consumer choice is all about. And I would wager that the overwhelming majority of animal lovers in the UK expect the House of Commons to support this bill today. The bill will improve animal welfare and give choice. I urge all members of the House to support it.

02:46:40 - 02:46:47

Speaker 187

The question is that the right honourable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many as of that opinion say aye.

02:46:48 - 02:46:55

Speaker 188

Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?

02:46:55 - 02:47:12

Esther McVey

Sir Roger Gale, Alberto Costa, Dame Karen Bradley, Sir Edward Leigh, Graham Stringer, Rupert Lowe, Sammy Wilson, Jim Allister, Lee Anderson, Sarah Pocher and myself, Madam Deputy Speaker.

02:47:12 - 02:47:40

Speaker 194

Esther McVey.

02:47:40 - 02:47:44

Speaker 192

Food Labelling (Halal and Kosher Meat) Bill.

02:47:44 - 02:47:46

Speaker 190

Second reading what day?

02:47:46 - 02:47:48

Speaker 189

Friday the 15th of January.

02:47:48 - 02:48:00

Speaker 193

Friday the 15th of January. The Clerk will now proceed to read the Orders of the Day.

02:48:00 - 02:48:07

Speaker 191

Ways and means, adjourned debate on question.

02:48:07 - 02:48:15

Speaker 186

The question is as on the Order Paper. Secretary of State Jonathan Reynolds.

02:48:15 - 02:53:59

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is a pleasure to open the third and final day of the budget debate. And colleagues, as we begin, let us, I think, pause and remember what is really essential to the debate today, where are we as a country, what do we really need to talk about in the debate today, and I would put it like this, Madam Deputy Speaker: In the last year, gas prices have tripled, oil prices are up by over 60%,

our borrowing costs, alongside all other major economies, have risen, and yet business investment is rising, our economic growth has accelerated,

And the IMF have singled out the UK for praise for our deficit reduction plan. It is testament to the extraordinary resilience of the British people, British businesses and the British economy. And whilst reading the official documentation, there is no doubt that the ongoing conflicts in Ukraine and in Iran have driven up costs here and around the world. Despite these significant economic headwinds, the Chancellor came here last week and delivered a substantial cost of living package to help the British people. He delivered long-term reforms to strengthen growth.

And he commanded market confidence while he did so, in a way that eluded the previous Conservative government.

And there is not a shred of complacency on this side of the House. But the package he announced built on the success we've already achieved: year-on-year growth again above 2%. An economy that is growing per head not just through higher immigration, but because living standards are increasing. And wages rising faster than prices. So Madam Deputy Speaker, it is clear as we stand here today that we can say the economy is stronger today than when this government came to power.

But we know things are still tough. That's why the budget unveiled much-needed breathing space: for families, for businesses, and for working people.

And beyond that breathing space, we are beginning and proceeding with the big changes needed to put our country on a better course: re-industrialising Britain, driving good growth in every postcode, and strengthening our national security. This budget shows entrepreneurs, inventors and investors that the UK is the best place to start and grow a business, with this Government using its industrial strategy and wider policy platform to back them every step of the way. We cannot insulate people from every pressure or meet every ask in one go, but we can provide the targeted support that's necessary where it can make the biggest practical difference. That is why, to help our high streets and SMEs, the budget contains a £1 billion business rates package.

In England, shops, restaurants and cafés of all sizes will get a two-year real-terms freeze. And around 70,000 more small, retail, hospitality and leisure properties will be taken out of business rates altogether. To ensure that our high streets are vibrant into the future, the Budget also commits us to upgrading 600 Post Office branches this financial year. This will help them provide more accessible, welcoming spaces, simpler transactions and a speedier service for customers. That also includes essential banking services upon which so many of our high street businesses and SMEs depend.

Indeed, the House will know that all of these reforms form part of a much broader package being implemented by this Government to support the 5.7 million SMEs in this country, those which are the beating heart of our economy and the backbone of our communities. With our Small Business Plan, we're bringing down costs and using the levers of government to back British business.

We're in particular cracking down on the scourge of late payments that shuts down the equivalent of 38 firms a day and costs the economy almost £11 billion a year. Our Commercial Payments Bill will give us the strongest laws to tackle these late payments in the whole of the G7, with the bill's second reading set to take place this month, something I hope will command cross-party support. We're also reducing the regulatory burden on our small and medium-sized businesses, too. Indeed, when the Prime Minister, Lord Leong and I met with business owners at No. 10 North last month, we proudly accepted 14 recommendations from the Small Business Taskforce. It has been working in partnership with government to reduce the bureaucracy holding British firms back.

We are now making it simpler for smaller firms to bid for public contracts. We are streamlining ONS business surveys to reduce form filling. And at the same time, we're making it easier for businesses to find support on gov.uk and help them report disproportionate regulations. We're also delivering, too, on our tell-us-once ambition. And as part of this, we are pausing the Companies House profit and loss filing requirement for April 2028.

I would also like to particularly thank the Federation of Small Businesses for all their work on this agenda and for their particular support on that decision. Where there is an opportunity to save businesses time and money, we will seek to do that. And as proof positive of that agenda, the Budget included over £600 million per year savings in regulatory administration, with streamlined company reporting requirements and reduced reporting burdens for asset managers. A simpler home buying and selling process will also save businesses over £100 million a year.

Of course I'll give way to the honourable member.

02:53:59 - 02:54:21

Nigel Huddleston

I have to ask, was the right honourable member listening to a different budget to the one that I heard? Because I don't recognise anything he's said there. And in the OBR report itself, when it came to burdens and costs imposed by regulations on business, the OBR said that the employment bill, the unemployment bill, will actually add to the cost of business, completely contrary of what he just said.

02:54:21 - 02:59:14

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

Don't want to say the honourable member should listen a bit harder to the Chancellor when he's giving a budget because I think the Chancellor went into detail on that and I will expand on, in particular, what the better regulation task force will mean. But specifically on the employment rights agenda, we know you don't like it.

It's not a secret. But I would simply say to the honorable member, we have a commitment, a manifesto commitment to address, in particular, insecurity in the workplace, for instance, those 1 million people on zero-hours contracts. But let's not forget, let's the Conservative colleagues not forget that the premise of that particular measure is where a person works a regular number of hours, they will receive, if they wish to, a contract for those hours, not additional costs.

Additional costs are not present when you're getting a contract reflecting what you are already working. And the rest of the agenda, it may not be popular with the Conservative Party, but it's certainly popular with the country. And because of and because of that agenda,

because of that I know the Conservatives didn't stick to their own manifesto commitments, but I think we will stick to ours in this chamber. Of course, because of that,

Of course, because of that, we want to reduce burdens in other places, and entirely noble agenda and one that reflects the interests of British business. And specifically on his point about whether you may be aware the Chancellor did speak of this in the statement there is our aspiration to reduce business burdens by 25% over the course of this Parliament. That is going to be delivered through the new Better Regulation Executive. It brings together the power of the Treasury, the Cabinet Office, and my department to move us to more a more streamlined and proportionate regulatory system, one that spurs growth, investment, and innovation across the country. And I also warmly welcome the Chancellor increasing access to finance for ambitious founders and entrepreneurs.

In the budget, he introduced the new founders relief to encourage a new wave of wealth creation.

Founders and early investors will benefit from a 10% capital gains tax rate on up to £10 million of lifetime gains. Dom Hallas from the Startup Coalition said this: The Chancellor has delivered the boldest action backing startups and scale-ups of any government in years. Meanwhile, the trading allowance for people starting new ventures is being tripled from £1,000 to £3,000, and £700 million is going towards home-grown innovation, strengthening Britain's sovereignty, and ensuring that tomorrow's technologies are developed and adopted right here in the UK.

On top of all this, the budget gives the British Business Bank 1.4 billion pounds of additional commercial equity capacity, allowing it to back specialist VC funds in strategic sectors, and larger growth funds capable of writing the cheques needed to keep the UK's fastest growing companies scaling here. The package is expected to leverage around 4.2 billion pounds of private capital and create 14 and a half thousand additional jobs. And this builds on the landmark investments the bank has already made, backing businesses across the UK, from Optima Partners, the Edinburgh-based AI consultancy, to Pharos Marine, the Norfolk manufacturer of navigational aids for offshore wind farms and ports, and Oxford Space Systems, whose satellite antenna were launched into orbit earlier this year. And Madam Deputy Speaker, our industrial strategy is also making a difference. It is an essential part of our ambition to re-industrialise Britain, and back our own sovereign capabilities.

And it is delivering on industrial energy costs, reversing what we inherited from the last government with the highest industrial energy costs in the developed world.

We're slashing electricity bills by 25% for over 10,000 British manufacturers through the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme. We are cutting electricity costs for these businesses by up to £40 per megawatt hour, bringing their costs closer into line with competitors across Europe, with eligible businesses also receiving a one-off additional payment in 2027 to cover the support they would have received if BICS had been in place from April this year, correcting years of Conservative failure. And we're also channeling investment into the eight high-growth driving sectors of our economy, including life sciences and advanced manufacturing.

The budget confirmed over £1 billion of new life sciences investment from Kyndryl, from Vertex and ConvaTec, backed by almost £70 million of government funding. And it also gave the green light to a partnership I am particularly proud of, a partnership with Rolls-Royce to develop the next generation of turbine engine technology here in Britain. This is the single biggest re-industrialisation opportunity the UK has before it. This two and a half billion pounds investment, of course, I'll give way to the honourable member.

02:59:14 - 02:59:29

Speaker 117

I thank the Secretary of State for giving way. I very much welcome the investment in Rolls-Royce in particular, many of my constituents work there. So, can I just ask the Secretary of State what impact the investment will have on opportunities for young people in the Derbyshire Dales?

02:59:29 - 03:02:05

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

Extremely grateful to my honourable friend for the question. This £2.5 billion of investment will support jobs across the Midlands, across Bristol and across our country. For the significance is it's not just another public-private investment in an exciting area of the future. It is a genuine opportunity for a leading British firm to break into an incredibly lucrative market, currently dominated by two main players where we, I believe, could be very significant in future. And I'm particularly pleased to tell my honourable friend actually visited the Rolls-Royce site in Derby last week with the Prime Minister and Chancellor, discussing this very issue: British industry, British talent and British jobs.

And I think everyone in the House will be aware of just how outstanding Rolls-Royce are when it comes to apprenticeships and opportunities for the next generation.

I can tell every member of the House that Rolls-Royce themselves are excited about what the future holds for the UK and the Government is going to work hand in hand with them to make their growth ambitions a reality. Madam Deputy Speaker, we are also backing British business, not just through our industrial strategy, but by making sure we are always remaining an outward and open-looking economy, one that stays true to the trading principles upon which the modern British economy was built. We do intend to reindustrialise our country, but we will not use punitive trade measures and tariffs to do so. In many cases, tariffs hinder businesses and hurt consumers far more than they help them. Tariffs are ultimately paid by your own people, which is why this Government is using the budget to suspend tariffs on over a hundred essentials.

This supports farmers who import fertilisers, it supports households who use heating oil, and it supports people with their supermarket shop too, because it lowers costs on products like baked beans, chocolate, marmalade, and fruit. Government cannot reduce all the pressures on the family shop overnight, but we can use all the levers at our disposal to bring prices down.

And that is exactly what we are doing. While other nations turn inward, restricting trade with the rest of the world, we stand as a proudly internationalist country, a global hub for trade and investment, and one which is ready to deepen our partnerships with new friends and old allies, not least the European Union, which remains our largest trading market. That is the message we'll be taking into the UK-EU summit later this month. And our ambition is clear.

We want to continue simplifying trade.

we want to conclude negotiations on our SPS and emissions trading deals, which could add up to 9 billion pounds a year to the UK economy and which would be a huge win for small business.

03:02:05 - 03:02:36

John Hayes

Sir John Hayes.

Can the right honourable gentleman, mindful of what he's just said about trade, reconcile that with the desire to re-industrialize, to manufacture more, to make more of what we consume? For in an uncertain world, national economic resilience is more important than ever, and yet we run a huge trade deficit, which has grown year-on-year, and our dependence is upon many countries who are not our friends, and who may pull the plug on Britain at will.

03:02:36 - 03:02:38

Speaker 199

Secretary of State.

03:02:38 - 03:04:36

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

Well, I agree with the sentiment the honourable member's putting forward. I think it's one of the most substantive issues the House has to grapple with.

I would say, first of all, there is no inconsistency with being proud of the services-led nature of the UK economy whilst recognising the essential contribution advanced manufacturing makes. I believe there are sectors of the UK economy that stand potentially to gain from this current phase of innovation in AI and goods. For instance, robotics could actually reduce our wage differential with lower-wage economies and return industrial functions to the UK. But I also think the basis of British industry will always be export-led. You take the automotive or aerospace sectors, that's key.

So I don't see a tension between strengthening our resilience, our domestic industrial capacity, and being an outward- and internationalist-facing country to the rest of the world. I believe the two things have to go together. And a specific example I would give him of that would be something like our Critical Minerals Strategy. So, we cannot reduce our dependence entirely on other countries, but we can reduce the degree of exposure to particular individual markets and then use the levers of government, whether that's investing in tungsten or in lithium mining in the south-west of England, looking at how the refining process works, working with allies around that.

It's a balance between the two things, but I recognise absolutely the substance of the honourable Member's question and the importance to a debate like this. In relation to the UK-EU summit, Madam Deputy Speaker, I also want to say, in addition to the premise of the deal we're seeking to strike, we do also want to make progress on EV automotive rules of origin, on steel tariffs, and on economic security, recognising that, in many cases, we share similar challenges. We face them together, and we can overcome them together. And to that end, the Prime Minister will say more later this year about our options for our long-term relationship with the EU, one that strengthens our collective security and our collective prosperity. I'll give way to my honourable friend, yeah.

03:04:36 - 03:04:42

Peter Swallow

I thank him for giving way. He's making a really important point about our relationship with the EU.

03:04:36 - 03:04:36

Peter Swallow.

03:04:42 - 03:05:06

Peter Swallow

He'll be aware that Bracknell is home to lots of companies that work in cloud technologies. Is he alive to concerns around the EU's proposed Cloud and AI Development Act, and will he ensure that as part of our negotiations in the summit and thereafter, we are addressing those concerns robustly, because we do need to get that right?

03:05:06 - 03:05:07

Secretary of State.

03:05:07 - 03:06:49

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

Well, I can tell my honorable friend that the agenda known in shorthand as Made in Europe that affects Cardiff, affects the Industrial Accelerator Act, actually runs through as many as 50 different pieces of EU legislative files is not just a top priority for my ministers and I in this department, but actually for the whole government. It cannot be the case that in each separate area we have to seek a bespoke solution to it.

We need something that provides business with the certainty going forward. We need to recognise, in a way frankly the previous government didn't, that whatever our relationship to the EU, things the EU do will affect us. That is the nature of integrated supply chains and a key market on your doorstep. And I am confident, and I would say, and credit the Prime Minister with this, that the approach he has led from the front with has given us the space to provide the answers for this agenda. It is far more productive than the kind of adversarial relationship we saw towards the European Union from the previous government, and the bottom line is it gets results for people in this area.

Well.

I'm tempted to respond to that, but I'll proceed with the speech, as of course, we're all as ever waiting for the shadow home bench. I would just, actually I will, I'll bite, come on. When there is something of such fundamental importance to British industry like access to the single market, when it is, and always will be, our major trading market, gaining access for British businesses, for businesses based in the UK, and for British workers to make sure they don't lose their jobs, that is not giving the other side everything that they want. That is delivering for Britain in a way that side of the house never quite managed.

03:06:49 - 03:06:50

Sir James Cleverly.

03:06:50 - 03:07:45

James Cleverly

I thank the right honorable gentleman for giving way.

I negotiated directly with Maroš Šefčovič, the lead negotiator for the European Union. We had a very good working relationship, we got a lot done. But will the right honourable gentleman not concede, not understand that standing at the despatch box and setting out the UK's desired end position hands a huge advantage to the EU negotiating team, who are not trying to damage the UK, they're just trying to get the best possible deal for the EU. And setting out the desired end state from UK's position publicly like this actually makes his job in future negotiations harder, which is why we get rolled over by the excellent EU negotiators every time that his government goes across to Brussels.

03:07:45 - 03:07:46

Secretary of State.

03:07:46 - 03:08:34

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

Colleagues, it's great to receive some advice from the Conservative party on negotiating with Europe, isn't it? I have a lot of time for the honourable member. I have a lot of time for the honourable member, but let me say first of all, the premise of the UK-EU Summit, just perhaps just listen to the point. Premise of the UK-EU Summit, agreement on SPS, food and agricultural trade, on emissions trading, on electricity systems working with each other, that is already in the public domain, we agreed the memorandum on that last year. This is about implementation of that deal.

On the question of whether we would like the single market to operate rules that completely shut out British industry, British supply chains, I don't think it's a particular secret to say we don't fancy that very much and we're seeking a solution to it. And I would just say, going back to the deal, he said he was very proud of the deal, he will know himself you left us a few things left over with that. I mean the rules of origin for the automotive Sorry.

03:08:34 - 03:08:42

Speaker 202

Order. That's the second time the Secretary of State has said you. I didn't leave anything. Secretary of State.

03:08:42 - 03:12:44

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

Wouldn't possibly suggest you negotiated the deal with the European Union, Madam Deputy Speaker. I can see why'd you want to distance yourself from that as we all would.

Let's move on. The Madam Deputy Speaker, the British people should know that we will always seek to make things a little bit easier where we can. We will transform our country for the long term, but we'll also act now to provide support for people in the short term. That's what the budget was all about, and that's why 2.3 million workers will benefit from increases to the national minimum wage.

Thanks to these changes, a full-time worker on the National Living Wage will see their earnings rise by £910 a year before tax. It is a balanced approach, which I recognise, and it recognises market conditions. I want to put on record my thanks to the Low Pay Commission for their expert advice and support on these measures. I was also pleased that in the budget, this Government committed to expanding parental pay.

We're making the system fairer so that more parents can spend time with their family after the birth or adoption of their children. From April 2029, self-employed fathers, partners and adopters in Great Britain will also be able to access a parental allowance. Those only recently employed, those who have been made redundant and those who have an irregular pattern of employment will also qualify for some degree of financial support. All in all, over 150,000 people in Great Britain per year will benefit from these reforms, thanks to the changes that we're making, things that will be easier for them and for working parents everywhere.

As the Chancellor said last week, this is a down payment that will begin to address some of the issues around working men and paternity provision as we prepare for the full outcomes of our review into the full parental leave system next year. I'd also like to acknowledge that many in this country are people who are quietly, conscientiously providing care for a loved one, whether that's a child, a parent, a grandparent, a sibling, friend, or neighbor. About 5.8 million people in the UK provide unpaid care for family members or friends. In the budget, Madam Deputy Speaker, this government is moving to support them. We're replacing the current carer's allowance earnings cliff edge rules with an earnings taper.

And this alone will benefit 50,000 unpaid carers, a real injustice being righted. We're also reviewing employment rights for unpaid carers to help those balancing their caring responsibilities with work because it is not easy to hold down a job whilst helping a relative out of bed, getting them dressed, taking them to the doctor or to hospital appointments, and cooking them meals while working 35 or 40 hours a week.

This review, looking at unpaid leave, the right to return, paid carers leave and paid leave for parents of seriously ill children, will conclude in early 2027. And I can assure the House that we will act on its findings. So Madam Deputy Speaker, this is what we mean by fresh hope, good growth and support for those who need it. In our first 100 days, this Government has shown that we will do all we can to give people and businesses the breathing space they need. This budget has shown that commitment too, with real, tangible measures to help, with business rates cut, tariffs reduced, energy bills slashed, living costs lowered, and the minimum wage increased.

And we're doing all of this while keeping government borrowing falling faster than any other G7 economy.

We're doing it while getting employment up this year, higher than previously forecast in March, and we're doing it while ensuring that business investment relative to the size of the economy remains at its highest levels for a decade, and whole economy investment is higher than at any other time since 1990. For all of these reasons, Madam Deputy Speaker, people should have hope, fresh hope for what the future holds for them, for our economy, and our country. They should know that we are resilient, that we should be optimistic for the future, and that the best days of this nation lie ahead. And that is why I proudly commend this budget to the House.

03:12:44 - 03:12:47

Speaker 203

Shadow Secretary of State, Julia Lopez.

03:12:47 - 03:18:00

Julia Dockerill

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government's given today's budget debate a theme: fresh hope for the future.

It will be closed by the Chief Secretary, who this weekend let slip, "I don't think employers are working people." I recommend that she does not deliver her message of fresh hope to the salon owners, the café owners, the shop owners, the services firms, the gym owners, the pub landlords, builders, dentists and restaurateurs in her constituency of Wycombe, for she may never get served again. These are the people who are not only providing for themselves, but taking risks to build businesses that employ and serve others. Everything they do is fuelled by hope: the hope that their relentless hard work will one day create something bigger than themselves, a better life for their families and employees.

But they feel hopeless right now, Madam Deputy Speaker. Many are questioning whether they can make the numbers work. Tax, regulation, energy costs have all relentlessly climbed. And if they put their prices up again to cover those costs, they risk driving their customers away. That is the reality they face as working people,

Filling shifts themselves because they can no longer afford the staff. Working harder simply to stand still. Wondering whether they can continue to justify the sacrifice to their families. And if they pack up, it is a problem for us all because it is their taxes that are helping to keep this show on the road. "I don't think employees, employers are working people."

It was one of those Labour truths, Madam Deputy Speaker, the sort of Labour truth that Labour Chief Secretaries have such form in letting slip out. "I'm afraid there is no money, kind regards and good luck", the handover note of another Labour Chief Secretary after their last chance in power in 2010.

Who left the right honorable Member for Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North with no money when he wrote his fateful note? Well, it was one of his predecessors as Chief Secretary, a man who, during his second tilt at the Labour leadership, was forced to apologise for his own failure to get public spending under control before a brutal financial crisis hit. Madam Deputy Speaker, that Chief Secretary is now Prime Minister, and his first Budget suggests he has not learned his own lesson. "Employers are not working people."

"There is no money." "We failed to control public spending before a crisis. Sorry." Three Labour admissions, three different moments in our recent political history that tell us an awful lot about the way this party governs, a neat summary too of this Budget,

For there is precious little in it for working people. Labour has no money to fund the basics of defence, and it is failing to get public spending under control. No wonder that despite all of the briefings about a Budget for bloody-minded entrepreneurs, it undershoots at almost every opportunity. Take business rates. Now, I welcome the Chancellor's decision to exempt 70,000 businesses from rates altogether, but Conservative plans would take a quarter of a million firms out of rates.

On the minimum wage, it is right the Chancellor has not levelled this up for younger workers, but Conservative plans would halve employer national insurance for under-25s. Labour offers employers the temporary bung of the youth guarantee, but it is a scheme necessary only because this Government has made it so much more expensive and risky to take people on in the first place. Then, look under the bonnet of the new founders' relief.

Entrepreneurs will discover something hopelessly complex with very few likely to benefit. This is no return of entrepreneurs' relief, and it comes as this Government halves the limit on business asset disposal relief. Last year, 61,000 people claimed that relief, and only a few hundred are thought likely to benefit from founders' relief. Labour's own entrepreneurship adviser, Alexandra Depledge, has left her role after mere months, saying that the Government treats entrepreneurship and innovation as a sideshow. And what about sole traders and freelancers, the personal trainers, electricians, creatives, the people who don't have an army of accountants?

Their reward for hard work: having to report their earnings to HMRC more frequently so they can be squeezed for more tax, while there is no such vigilance on checking eligibility for benefits claimants. Has the Chancellor ever had to deal with the realities of cash flow, or of a few good months followed by a fallow period?

Meanwhile, by taxing banks, the Chancellor risks making them less internationally competitive while driving up the costs of borrowing for businesses across the economy. Shifting energy costs from green levies to general taxation does nothing to tackle the underlying drivers of our staggeringly uncompetitive energy prices. The Chancellor slipped out another Labour truth last week when he said the Energy Secretary opposed Jackdaw. I expect she's opposing Rosebank, too.

We can forget re-industrialisation. And consider British food producers. It's all well and good to take a few pence off imported gherkins—we support cheap goods— but at the same time, Labour should help domestic producers compete. Instead, they are hamstrung by higher taxes,

higher energy bills, rising wage costs— certainly.

03:18:00 - 03:18:14

Jonathan Neil Reynolds

I'm grateful to the right honorable lady. She knows she left us the Conservative party left us the highest industrial energy costs in the developed world.

Is she saying she opposes taking policy costs off bills into taxation? I think she said that would obviously result in higher bills than we have now.

03:18:14 - 03:23:39

Julia Dockerill

Well, our cheap power plan would lower bills across the board. His is just shifting costs from green levies to general taxation. But perhaps the most damning thing about this budget is what it does not attempt to do. After seeing off Keir Starmer, this new Prime Minister wants to press the reset button, to pretend this is a fresh start, the first 100 days. But Labour owns the last two years.

Labour owns the last two budgets. And if the Prime Minister won't reverse their measures, then the consequences of the decisions that were already taken are his to own as well. The national insurance rise has been devastating.

"Over the last 20 years I've been in the industry," says chef Tommy Banks, "this is without doubt the hardest time it's ever been to operate. I'm seeing restaurant owners saying, 'We're closing tomorrow. We're going to make everybody redundant.'" He points to employer national insurance having increased his business costs by 162%. With a couple of hundred staff, he says, that can mean half a million pounds. The Employment Rights Act has not even begun to have its full effect, yet I spoke to a business, a small business, last week, Madam Deputy Speaker, already having to shell out £8,000 to prepare for its implementation,

another being quoted £200,000 in legal fees to fight a tribunal, another is winding down its disability employment activities. It used to give opportunities to people with cognitive impairments who needed extra support; it will no longer take the risk. 170,000 jobs lost since 2024.

By the OBR's reckoning, another 215,000 jobs to go by the decade's end. Does this budget do anything to stop this slow-motion car crash? No review of the farm and family businesses taxes that are crushing our food producers and entrepreneurs at a time when this nation needs the food security they provide. I recently spoke to a business in the same valley, family since the 1850s. The owners cannot risk losing it on death and are now trying to offload it early, at the expense of investment in the business itself.

That is not going to generate growth. Another private school closure last week in Lewiston, leaving parents and children in limbo because Labour refuses to review its envy-driven tax on independent schools. The pressures on these businesses are flowing out into the wider economy. It is why everything is costing people more: more to go out for a meal, to have your hair done, to take a few rare days away with the kids, to buy the weekly shop.

The Prime Minister now owns Keir Starmer's choices. The most damning part of the budget was the difference between the Prime Minister's homely, breathing space rhetoric and the hard reality that real household disposable income is falling this year and is lower every year of the forecast, nearly £1,500 lower than forecast under the last Conservative government. And what is everyone getting in return for all the extra tax? Better public services? Nope.

The government is spending £124 billion a year on debt interest alone, up £14 billion since March and more than we spend on defence, policing, and prisons combined. Are we at least building up a buffer to make ourselves more resilient, Madam Deputy Speaker? No. The Chancellor has cut fiscal headroom to just £15 billion, the equivalent of barely 3 and 1/2 days of public spending.

It's even kicking defence spend into the long grass. So, businesses are paying more tax, families are getting poorer, public services are not improving and the Government is leaving the country dangerously exposed to the next economic shock. There are only two sustainable ways out of this: grow or cut spending, and on both, this Government is found wanting.

Last week, Ministers went the full Vicky Pollard when asked whether they would grip the welfare budget this Parliament. "Yes", said the Chancellor. "No", said the Treasury and No. 10. "As soon as possible", said the Prime Minister. "No", eventually concluded the Chancellor.

Yeah, but no, but yeah, but no. His leader is making a fool of him. And what about growth?

The Prime Minister's big idea is to reopen a debate about rejoining the EU, it's a debate that the Business Secretary doesn't want to have. He says it creates uncertainty for business, something companies explicitly do not want. He's now trying to nuance his way out of it, but we know what he said. A debate about free mo- movement that his Home Secretary does not want. A debate that will tie us to the slow growth lane and cost us for the privilege.

Why do we have to pay the fees of EU students to access Made in Europe when our participation is in the EU's interests, and the matter hasn't even been settled yet in the EU Parliament? The Prime Minister is weakening our hand to build a left-wing coalition that will keep him in power. If growth is the goal, why does the Prime Minister not pull the levers this government already has? Bringing down energy costs, making it easier to employ people, cutting tax, getting more people off wal- welfare?

Because those are the decisions that require real courage, and the willingness to test the mandate that the Prime Minister fears that he lacks on his own benches, and in the wider country. Employers are not working people. There is no money. We failed to get public spending under control before crisis hit. Three Labour truths that run through this budget.

Overseen by a Prime Minister more interested in the perception of being on people's side than the reality. Offering a debate about a future he may not control, over tough decisions he could own today if only he were to find the courage.

03:23:39 - 03:23:43

Speaker 205

Abena Oppong-Asare.

03:23:43 - 03:29:11

Abena Asare

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I welcome last week's budget and its focus on giving families a bit of a breathing space during a difficult period. Many people in my constituency welcome the hundred pounds household energy payment this winter, alongside the reforms to carers allowance and support for working families. As committee chair, I will want to focus my remarks on devolution, local government, our high streets, rough sleeping and housing delivery. I welcome the government's commitment to devolution and the publication of the fiscal devolution roadmap. However, we do need greater clarity on how these proposals will work in practice.

As powers are devolved, accountability, scrutiny and local capacity must keep pace.

Devolution should not just simply be a move from decision-making out of Whitehall, it must deliver better outcomes for the communities it's intended to serve. The Committee will continue to scrutinise these reforms and how they are implemented on the ground. I also welcome the measures to support and revitalise our high streets, including expanded business rates relief, and support for retail, hospitality, and leisure businesses. High streets are more than economic activity. They are the heart of community life, providing places where people meet, work, and access services.

This is particularly relevant to the Committee, who is currently undertaking an inquiry into revitalising our high streets and town centres, so we look forward to examining whether the measures are delivering the long-term regeneration and economic resilience our communities need.

The budget must also be judged on whether it addresses the long-term pressures facing local government. Councils continue to face significant pressures, from SEND pressures to rising demand for children's services, adult social care and housing support. Previous committee work has repeatedly highlighted concerns about sustainability of local government finance and the growing gap between what councils are expected to deliver and the resources available to them. A sustainable funding settlement remains essential if councils are to plan for the long term, and invest in prevention and deliver high-quality services for residents. Across local government, housing and devolution, the common challenge is delivery.

Communities need to see these commitments translated into tangible improvements in their daily lives. I strongly welcome the significant investment to tackle rough sleeping and help people off our streets. I had the opportunity to attend the summit, but if we are serious about ending rough sleeping, we must address its causes as well as its consequences. That means looking again at issues the committee has repeatedly highlighted including homelessness prevention, the five-week wait for Universal Credit and the continued freeze in local housing allowance. Ahead of the budget, I urged ministers to reconsider the local housing allowance freeze and I'm disappointed that it remains in place.

Charities have also warned that it could push hundreds and thousands of more people into poverty or deeper hardship. If ending rough sleeping is truly a national priority, we must ensure housing support keeps pace with the reality of rents and the pressures facing low-income households. The Budget rightly invests in support services, but lasting progress will require action on structural factors that push people into homelessness in the first place. Finally, I welcomed the additional investment in social and affordable housing, including the 1.5 billion top-up expected to support 10,000 additional homes.

However, it is still vital to consider whether these measures alone translate into homes being built at the pace and scale needed. The OBR has warned that housing delivery is likely to be slower than previously forecasted, highlighting the challenges that remain. The question is not whether we have the ambition, but whether we can remove the barriers that prevent homes being built at the scale required. And our committee will continue to scrutinise what further action is needed to meet the Government's housebuilding ambitions and to ensure that more genuinely affordable homes are delivered.

Overall, there is much in this budget to welcome, from support with energy bills to investment in social housing to renewed commitment to devolution. And this budget sets out an ambitious agenda, but the ambition must be met by delivery. My committee will be scrutinizing these commitments in terms of how they're implemented and whether they are delivering the real change for people and our communities we represent. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

03:29:11 - 03:29:21

Speaker 207

Now, before I call the Lib Dem spokesperson, I am going to put a 5-minute time limit on backbenchers from immediately after she has spoken. Daisy Cooper.

03:29:21 - 03:30:56

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. What we needed to see was a growth budget, because only if we can grow the economy can we cut people's taxes and cut people's bills. We Liberal Democrats have repeated our calls for a new growth and defense partnership with Europe, because growth through a defense partnership like that would enable us in time to raise the income tax threshold to 5,000.

If we can grow the economy, we can put more money in people's pockets. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Government's cost of living package was too timid and not well targeted. The OBR is clear that living standards are not set to improve. I'm really deeply disappointed that the energy proposal from the Government is linked to the outdated council tax system. This does mean that between 800,000 and 1.4 million of the most vulnerable people on low incomes will not benefit from the £100 payment whilst wealthier people who may have retired early and downsized will benefit and this could have been avoided.

Madam Deputy Speaker, we have called several times on the Government to use existing DWP and HMRC data to roll out an essential energy guarantee, to slash the cost of the first chunk of essential energy, benefiting everybody and giving extra support to those who are most in need like the disabled. That is the most progressive way of supporting people with the cost of energy bills, and it is the most targeted way of doing it, and it is within the Government's reach. I will.

03:30:56 - 03:31:23

Peter Swallow

She, of course, is aware that winter is very fast upon us, which is why the Government had to design a scheme that can be delivered quickly. But will she also recognise the £100 million of additional support being given to local authorities to target those exact households that she there has referenced, so that we can make sure that every household who is struggling financially this winter is given a little bit of support?

03:31:23 - 03:36:09

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Government already has the data through DWP, which it uses to roll out the Warm Home Discount, so that data is already there, the system exists with energy providers, it would have operated just as quickly. HMRC has the data on child benefit, it could have been rolled out equally just as quickly. Yes, I recognise that some money has been given to local authorities to roll this out, but that process will not act as quickly as the system that the Government wanted to roll out in January, and this would have been done through the energy providers far more quickly than that additional support. This would have been a more targeted, faster, more progressive way of rolling out help.

We've been calling for it for six months. I think it's unfortunate that the Government hasn't listened. Madam Deputy Speaker, in terms of businesses, of course we welcome support that supports small businesses, and raising the small business threshold will support a number of businesses.

But this is still tinkering around the edges, rather than delivering the fundamental reform of business rates, which this Government promised in its manifesto. If we are serious about breathing new life into our high streets, then we have got to reform the outdated, broken business rate system. In my constituency of St Albans, the rateable values are so high, only eight pubs are set to benefit from this support, and that comes in the face of a whole raft of measures in the last two anti-growth budgets. The chair of my local Save St Albans Pubs campaign has sent me this. He says: "The budget does nothing to help or support most of the pubs in St Albans.

Still no business rates reform, alcohol duties up, no cuts in VAT, no cuts in the horrific employer's national insurance jobs tax, and a huge increase in wages.

This means one thing, it'll put up the price of a pint." Madam Deputy Speaker, founders' relief has been described variously by people as bonkers, dreadful and a pointless lottery. It will benefit at most 600 people and will undermine productivity and growth. This is not exactly the ringing endorsement which I believe the Government was after, so I encourage the Government to look at this founders' relief again. On the BAD relief, the clue's in the title, the Government's measures do not close the loopholes.

On property taxes, Madam Deputy Speaker, we need to see real reform of all of the outdated property taxes, council tax, stamp duty and business rates. But the Government's so-called mansion tax is not the way to do it. All of this funding will go to Whitehall.

It will not go to local councils, and this from a government which says it wants devolution at a time when it is ripping money out of local authorities. The OBR says there is a 20 cha- 20% chance of appeals. Well, just five weeks ago, Madam Deputy Speaker, I stood right here and challenged ministers to contact the VOA because they had issued the wrong valuation to two of my small businesses. I dread to think what will happen to many people who will be wanting to sell their house and move to other parts of the country to support very to support family members, when they can't because they're stuck in an 18-month appeal process with the VOA. And it's not clear that the government even has a definition of a working farm when it comes to the operation of the so-called mansion tax.

This looks to me as though it could be family farm tax 2.0, and I urge the government to look very closely at this. And for what? 400 million quid in three years' time.

This is not going to sort out the cost of living crisis that we're facing right now. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am pleased that the government has shifted on bank taxes. We Liberal Democrats have long called for taxes on the big banks that have made eye-watering profits. And to those on opposit- on the official opposition benches who say they are worried about the competitiveness of our financial services, let me tell them this. Under their botched Brexit deal, they have hammered the financial services.

They have been hit by a loss of jobs and a loss of business. If anybody is serious about protecting our world-class financial services, they should support our calls to join the single market and to move online fraud, the liability for it, from banks to the big tech companies.

If we could do that, we could grow our world-beating financial services market and still increase the taxes further so they can contribute to the cost of living crisis. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, let me just say that there is a role for optimism. There is a role to talk about real hope, and I hope that we can project to the rest of the world that we believe in the future of UK plc. But if we're going to talk about fresh hope, it must be matched with meaningful action, and I'm afraid to say that this budget did not deliver the meaningful change that the country expects and deserves.

03:36:09 - 03:36:11

Speaker 208

Patrick Hurley.

03:36:11 - 03:40:59

Brian Patrick Hurley

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I welcome this Budget and I congratulate the Chancellor on bringing it forward at a time of considerable economic uncertainty. There's much in it that deserves support and colleagues have spoken well over the past few days in that regard, but I want to use my contribution today to make a broader argument, one that concentrates on the interaction between business and trade and prosperity for the country, because, for me, the biggest economic challenge facing this country is the fact that we've become accustomed to an economy that doesn't grow quickly enough, doesn't invest enough, doesn't produce enough and doesn't deliver rising living standards for enough of our people. Worse than that, we've actually constructed an economic system that's learned to accommodate failure. Thanks to the long, dark years of Tory rule, this country has, in effect, institutionalised stagnation.

For much of the last 80 years, people in this country could have reasonably expected to have been better off than their parents. Productivity increased, wages rose, living standards improved. But since 2010, that's changed, the relationship's broken down. Real earnings have barely grown by historical standards, productivity growth has been desperately weak, and the prospect of building a better life has become increasingly remote for too many people. We need to change it, Madam Deputy Speaker.

First, I think we need to be clear by what we mean by growth. Our overriding economic objective should be sustained growth in GDP per capita, driven by higher productivity, accompanied by rising real wages and improving living standards.

And we should judge our success not just by what happens in some sectors like financial services or any other sector, but by what happens in places like my own Southport constituency, or Swindon, or Wigan, or Bristol, or Birkenhead. Second, we need to rebuild our productive capacity in this country. For decades we've promoted consumption whilst allowing production to decline. We've become dependent on importing the things we need, exposed to volatile international energy markets, willing to see promising British innovations commercialised elsewhere.

We need to change that too. We should be ambitious about advanced manufacturing, about clean energy, life sciences, digital, technology, all of those industries of the future. I'd like to see us set ourselves a national mission to create a million additional jobs in production over the next decade,

And that requires an industrial strategy with some proper oomph behind it. That proper oomph should be patient capital, affordable industrial energy, skills provision designed around the needs of employers and public procurement that supports domestic productive capacity. It also requires a closer and more practical economic relationship with our European neighbours. The isolationist turn that this country has taken over the last decade needs to come to an end, not just for the benefit of our country, because it's harmed our trading partners too and has benefited only those countries who want us to fail. We also need to reform the way the we also need to reform the way we govern the economy itself.

I strongly support fiscal responsibility, I believe in independent economic scrutiny, and I have no desire whatsoever to return to the economic recklessness that did such damage in 2022. We should also recognize that fiscal responsibility should be a means to an end rather than the end in itself. The purpose of sound public finances must be to enable a prosperous, productive, and resilient population. But that isn't what we've ended up with. Too much of our economic policy making currently is dominated by what happens over a relatively short period.

Investment that costs money today but only delivers in 20 or 30 years time can appear less attractive, and so we've become trapped in a vicious circle, weak growth reduces tax revenues, weak tax revenues constrain restrain constrain investment, insufficient investment weakens productivity, and weak productivity leads to weak growth.

We need to break that circle. The way we need to break that circle, Madam Deputy Speaker, Madam Deputy Speaker, is to look at how we our fiscal and monetary policies are implemented. And I would encourage Ministers to review the those policies in order to ensure that the future of this country is prosperous. Thank you.

03:40:59 - 03:41:01

Speaker 209

Dr Neil Hudson.

03:41:01 - 03:43:25

Neil Hudson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, the theme of this year's Autumn Budget was said to be one of hope. It raised our hopes akin to the title of a Star Wars film.

Yet, for many of my constituents in Epping Forest, and indeed, for families and businesses across the country, that hope has been sorely dashed. I have huge respect for the Chancellor, who is a deeply honorable man who resigned as Defence Secretary calling for 3% of GDP on defence spending by 2030, but sadly, even his hopes for this clear commitment and plan have been dashed by this Government. Now in Epping Forest, we are fortunate to have fantastic local businesses, restaurants, cafés and pubs, yet many are struggling to stay afloat under this Labour Government. It is deeply regrettable that this budget did not take up sensible proposals from the Conservatives scrapping the family farm tax and family business tax in full, abolishing inheritance tax on family homes, and scrapping business rates for 250,000 businesses nationwide.

Now, one thing my constituents in Epping Forest will note was the Chancellor's talk of a British data centre covenant. Many of my constituents are rightly concerned about the implications and environmental impacts of AI data centres, including the proposal in Loughton with major concerns about the huge water and energy usage. And a speculative and completely inappropriate proposal is being worked up for a data centre near Chigwell that will threaten our precious green belt. Many of my constituents have reached out to me alarmed by this Chigwell proposal, and that it comes in the context of a Labour government that has outrageously taken away large planning decisions from Epping Forest District Council, and is arbitrarily and spuriously moving to reclassify green belt as grey belt to achieve their development targets.

We have seen this, too, with inappropriate, large-scale housing developments being proposed on green belt in Theydon Bois, around Epping, and for solar developments on farmland between Thornwood and Epping Upland. I urge the Labour Government to do the right thing: listen to my Epping Forest constituents, leave our green belt alone, and pull the plug on these damaging top-down policies and inappropriate developments.

03:43:25 - 03:43:27

Speaker 211

Will the honourable gentleman give way?

03:43:27 - 03:43:53

Wendy Morton

Madam Deputy Speaker, I cannot resist the opportunity to say I wholeheartedly agree with my with what my honourable friend is saying when it comes to green belt protections. The Government has an opportunity to stop this reckless, top-down approach and be serious about brownfield-first funding, put the money into the brownfield-first, and, please, protect and save our special and precious green spaces. Does he agree?

03:43:27 - 03:43:27

I will give way.

03:43:53 - 03:46:49

Neil Hudson

I thank my right honourable friend for that intervention. I completely agree with her, and she's a proud champion for her area and actually standing up for the green belt and actually putting pressure on the Government to do the right thing and go for brownfield first and leave our green belt alone. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister is a good man, and I really welcomed his stated ambition to work cross-party to address the long-standing challenges in social care, drawing on his own family's sad experience. I agree wholeheartedly with him that no one should be forced to sell their home to fund essential care.

but that hope, too, was dashed when it became that the Prime Minister is prejudging the Casey report, and his plans will not cover care residential costs, the very reason people have to sell their homes. By failing to address this core issue, the Government has missed the very point it is trying to confront. Now, turning from care to health, many of my constituents will be dismayed to learn that our local hospitals, Whipps Cross and Princess Alexandra, will still be waiting until at least 2032 for any rebuild. This is despite Labour's promise during the 2024 general election that both hospitals would be rebuilt.

Now, the government has spent much time talking of devolution and powers, but my constituents need them to start by working with powers that already exist, like with their relationship with the Mayor of London. For far too long, the Central line that my constituents rely on has been plagued by unacceptable delays, overcrowding, unbearable heat in the summer months, ear-scraping rail noise levels, and ugly graffiti akin to something out of Gotham City. The new refurbished trains that have been promised are arriving extremely slowly indeed, and the services on the Epping line and the Chigwell branch remain unacceptable. Madam Deputy Speaker, in Waltham Abbey, over 3,000 of my constituents signed the Bring Back Red Buses Waltham Abbey campaign petition, urging Transport for London's cuts to local bus services to areas to be reversed. And this has been made worse recently by bus services now ending early on weekdays, when they already have no Tube or train services that serve our Waltham Abbey area.

The government cannot sit on the sidelines and spectate this situation, it has to be a player and push both TfL and Essex County Council to step up. Madam Deputy Speaker, this was a budget of missed opportunities, and if the government is serious about hope, please give us some hope and actually do something on these vital issues.

03:46:49 - 03:46:51

Speaker 213

Preet Kaur Gill.

03:46:51 - 03:51:16

Preet Gill

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Fresh hope for the future must mean something people can recognize in their own lives: a young person finding a skilled job close to home, a patient getting a diagnosis sooner, and someone waiting for an operation finally getting to treatment and getting back to their life. That is how people will judge us.

So I welcome this Budget's determination to give families breathing space now while building a stronger economy for tomorrow. But I want to focus on one opportunity that can help us achieve both: backing life sciences so that Britain can build the future here, developing new treatments, manufacturing them in Britain, and getting them to NHS patients faster, because a healthier country is a stronger country. And for the industries that help us live healthier lives, they can also create the jobs, investment and prosperity that our communities need. Madam Deputy Speaker, I began working as a care assistant at 16, I became a social worker working in child protection, and served as Cabinet Member for Public Health and Protection, and those experiences taught me that public services are judged at the moment someone needs them. Can they get help?

Are they listened to? Does someone take responsibility?

And as a health minister, I brought that same test to innovation. A scientific breakthrough is an extraordinary achievement. Approval matters, but success is a patient receiving treatment. And our ambition should be clear: discover here, make it here, and deliver here. And this budget gives us something substantial to build on.

I welcome the 100 million investment in robotic surgery, supporting the ambition to increase procedures from 70,000 a year today to half a million by 2035. For a patient, that could mean a less invasive operation, shorter stay in hospital, and getting home to their family sooner. I also welcome the life sciences investment in Manchester, Oxford and Loughborough, together worth more than 1 billion pounds, supported by almost 70 million in government grants. And these investments should give businesses confidence to build in Britain, and patients confidence that progress will reach them. The next task is to make that partnership work across the country, and to connect investment with improvements that people can feel.

Birmingham's life sciences district shows what is possible when we bring our strengths together. The University of Birmingham, the Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Birmingham Health Partners connect world-class research with front-line care. Our Health Innovation Campus and Precision Health Technologies Accelerator help businesses turn discoveries into treatments. And we should back this district as an engine of national growth, attracting investment, expanding manufacturing and opening routes into skilled jobs for local people. This is enormous opportunity for our city to know that there could be a place for young people in my city as a laboratory technician, an engineer, a clinical researcher, a manufacturing apprentice, or a specialist working with a health with health data.

And the University of Birmingham is here today in Parliament, launching the Birmingham Health and Life Sciences Quarter.

So, as the Government develops its 10-year plan and prepares for the next spending review, three things should guide us. First, make the adoption of proven innovation a core NHS responsibility, because businesses need a clear route innovators need a clear route from successful evaluation to everyday use, with named responsibility, funding and a timetable. And for a small British business, a successful NHS trial should actually open a door. They should not have to go begging every single trust to procure their product. We should measure success through patient outcomes, and that same discipline should apply to AI.

So, I welcome the Budget's review of NHS productivity and AI. Its purpose should be practical: better care, less avoidable administration and more time with patients. And secondly, connect life sciences investment to British manufacturing and local opportunity. And thirdly, make prevention and earlier diagnosis central to our ambition, because the greatest gain is often the illness avoided.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a serious economic opportunity. Better health can help people remain in work, support families and reduce pressure on public services. Successful British businesses can bring investment, exports and skilled employment. The Prime Minister has opened a conversation about the country we want to become. My answer is a Britain confident enough to back its scientists, ambitious enough to build new industries and determined enough to put their achievements into the hands of the people who need them.

A Britain where a discovery becomes a treatment, an investment becomes a skilled job and a young person can see a future in the place that they call home. That is what fresh hope for the future must mean. Thank you.

03:51:16 - 03:51:17

David Simmonds.

03:51:17 - 03:56:19

David Simmonds

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

The budget debate is an opportunity of course, both to consider the national and the local impact of what's been announced. And it's very clear that this is a centralizing budget. It is a tax and spend budget. It doesn't even raise the tax necessary to cover the spending commitments that are being made. And when we look at the impact across the economy, what is very clear:

the routes out of poverty, the opportunity to find a job, something that is good for your well-being, it's good for your mental and physical health, as well as your financial health. There's been a surge in unemployment under this Labour government.

It's the worst graduate job market that's existed since records began. And those in my party who will have been proud of the fact that, on average, 800 new jobs were created for every day that government was in office, that youth unemployment was halved by the time we left government, will look at the long-term impact, particularly on younger people and their life chances, that are the consequences of that, with nothing whatsoever in this budget to address that except more tax and spend. On productivity, to represent a constituency as I do, which has lower than London-average incomes, but where prosperity and employment is high, and to see a budget that does nothing to address the cliff edges in the tax system, the loss of child benefit when people become a higher rate taxpayer, the loss of access to tax-free childcare, the impact of rising pension contributions and the withdrawal of personal allowances, that, particularly amongst the most productive public sector professionals, is having a huge impact not just on their incomes, but also on their ability to contribute to the service improvements that we all need to see.

And then when we look at our housing market, and we all understand that we want to see that as an engine of opportunity and growth. But all of the measures introduced by this government are making it harder to move house. They're making it harder to rent a home. And they're making it harder to build, with 2/3 of London's boroughs,

in one of the most economically vibrant cities in the world, reporting net zero additional new homes from the start of this year. And at the same time, local authorities like the excellent Conservative Council that serve some of my constituents in Harrow, put in a 300 million-pound bid of shovel-ready housing projects, ready to go,

to the GLA, funded by MHCLG,

to receive an allocation of precisely zero towards the delivery of any of those new homes that are ready to go. Small wonder that the Secretary of State has been so clear that this Government will not meet even its own housing targets. And the Member for Erith and Thamesmead, who's no longer in her place, made reference to the issue of rough sleeping. And I'm glad that the Government is making this a priority, because they certainly need to. St Mungo's have reported a 27% rise in street homelessness since this Government took office.

Something that is on them, that they own. And it is right that they need to clear up their own mess.

And that is a description which would apply to the measures announced on business rates as well. Having promised hospitality and retail a new permanently lower regime of business rates only to impose massive increases which have driven business, driven employment off our high streets. It is good that they are beginning to recognise the negative impact on our high streets that their policies have had. But they should at least have the humility to recognise that it is the consequences of their own decisions that have created that problem. And there is nobody else to blame in respect of this.

So, Madam Deputy Speaker, when we look at this Budget, there are so many clear headlines for the implications that it has.

The increase in the benefits bill under this government is bigger than the entire defence budget at a time when this country faces an incredibly uncertain world. The verdict of savers, of investors, of both the domestic and international market is clear, because borrowing costs for 30 and 10 year gilts have hit record highs. There is no period in recent history where there has been so little confidence in the ability of a government to manage the finances of the country effectively. And when this government talks about the impact in every post code, in my constituency from HA4 to UB9, what they see themselves left with is unbuilt planning permissions granted in their green belt, deteriorating and reduced public services, and a government which is taking away the opportunities to make life, through their own efforts, better for themselves and their families.

03:56:20 - 03:56:23

Speaker 216

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

03:56:23 - 04:01:21

Derek Twigg

Without doubt, the greatest concern for most of my constituents is the cost of living, in particular, cost of energy, with a bit of biggest factors currently driving up the costs are the Ukraine war and of course now President Trump's ill-conceived and, quite frankly, stupid decision to go to war with Iran. It is just not credible that this government in the current financial climate can put right in just over two years, 14 years of Tory mismanagement of the economy and the impact of these two wars. I think it's also very worrying that we have a generation of young people now who feel they'll be worse off than their parents. And clearly, it's shocking that we have a million young people not in education, employment or training. I welcome many of the measures introduced by the Chancellor in the budget,

I welcome many of the measures introduced by the Chancellor in the Budget, in particular the breathing space scheme, which where households in bands A to D will get a £100 payment directly into their bank account this winter to help deal with rising energy bills. It is good that the budget supports households with the rising cost of energy bills by extending the temporary 0% rate of VAT on electricity until 2027, and capping new levies on energy bills at 0% until 2030. Small businesses are the backbone of our economy, so I welcome that in the budget we're taking more businesses out of the pay paying business rates by increa- increasing small business rates relief thresholds for eligible retail, hospitality and leisure properties.

Likewise, I support removing eligibility for vape shops and adult gaming centres to help our high streets survive and to become vibrant places once more, supporting independent businesses and creating town centres where people want to live. In this regard, I initiated a on town centres, a high street, the new town centre plan for Widnes with Halton Borough Council to help regenerate our town centre as that money becomes available. So I was pleased that the government has allocated 1.24 million to renovate derelict buildings, and when added to the Pride in Place, the Widnes Pride in Place Town Centre Impact Fund of 1.5 allocated last year, this can help kickstart some of the improvements we want to see in Widnes town centre. And I look forward to working with Halton Council on that. I'm also pleased that Knowsley has been allocated, Knowsley Council has been allocated 1.55 million, and look forward to discussions with Knowsley Council how that will be used.

I won't given the time. I also look forward to hearing more from the Chancellor about the fiscal devolution roadmap, revolving reforming the long-term funding model for regional and local governments.

This has the potential over time to make a real difference to the economic performance on many of our cities and towns outside of London. I do want now just to refer to the issue around defence spending. It is the case that we have had the biggest increase in defence spending since the Cold War. It's also true that we face the biggest threat since the Cold War. I am pleased that the Chancellor has announced that he is fully funding the Defence Investment Plan and a target date of 3% of GDP by 2030.

However, I think we need to see the plan for reaching that target soon rather than later. It remains my view that threats are escalating and we need to be spending 3% before the end of this Parliament.

The previous Tory government hollowed out and grossly underfunded our Armed Forces, and they left our Armed Forces in a truly shocking state, the smallest army since the Napoleonic Wars, missed every single recruitment target, equipment programs in disarray, over budget and behind schedule, or both. They now have the cheek to try to erase their woeful record on defence. This government is working hard to try to ensure our Armed Forces are ready for war, but there's more to do. I just want to be briefly, Madam Deputy Speaker, and first of all, declare an interest as chair of the All-Party Motoring Group, and I have both the Jaguar Land Rover plants and Ford plants in my constituency, and I want to refer to the recent consultation which closed on the 23rd of October 2026 regarding the zero-emission vehicle mandate, ZEV. And they the both Ford and JLR want ministers to publish their response and clarify the mandate's direction ahead of the 2027 compliance year.

Early clarity will help manufacturers plan sustain investment to support ambitious delivery transition. Ford tell me they are committed to a truly electrified future, but the transition must reflect customer need, charging infrastructure and vehicle user needs. There are specific challenges, especially around vans. Finally, the last two points I want to make, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have big challenges ahead in bringing down debts and the cost of welfare.

It will take some tough decisions and challenging work, but it has to be done. And we must have a credible long-term plan. We cannot just pick an arbitrary figure out of the air to save on welfare. We need a properly thought-out strategy, which will be informed by the Milburn and Timms reviews. And my final point is productivity.

Again, this remains a real challenge in the economy. We need to deal with the lack of capital investment in order to make sure that we have sustained growth in our economy.

04:01:21 - 04:01:24

Speaker 217

Jamie Stone.

04:01:24 - 04:05:32

James Jamie Stone

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And representing the furthest away constituency in the British mainland, you can imagine that the words growth in every postcode would interest me hugely. And in thinking about my contribution today, I thought of that perhaps I would talk about the lack of affordable housing or efforts to promote employment opportunities for the young. But I did something last week which made me think. Now, as some colleagues know, in this place, my wife is disabled.

And that's not what I'm on my feet to talk about. She's a brave lady and she puts up with it and it's all great. But I thought it would be kind to order her a fireside chair.

And I found online one at a very good price, reduced, called a Jubilee fireside chair in the colour mineral. And I It was practically the first one that came up when you Googled "fireside chair for the disabled". So I hit it, and here it was, and I thought, "Yes, we'll have that." And, free delivery. Great!

And yet, when I came to look more closely at what the amount of money was, they had added on £50 because of my postcode. So I went back, and in very small print, under free delivery, it says, "Perhaps not everywhere." Now, I personally think I can afford that, but there are lots of people out there who can't afford an extra 50 quid when they want to buy something for somebody they love. And so, I In preparing yesterday, I remembered what happened. This was only last week.

And I thought, right, let's have a little look at the various postcodes.

And I worked my way down Scotland. First of all, I looked at Orkney, £50. I looked at Wick, £50. And I kept on coming down and down,

and got as far as Perth, £50. So, I went east and went to St Andrews: free delivery. So, I thought then I would look at Land's End, in my good colleague's constituency.

Uh no, you get charged £50 for Land's End. So, then there was a little bit of good news. I looked at the constituency of my good friend, my very good friend, the honourable member for the Western Isles:

Stornoway, you get it free.

In Castlebay, in Barra, down the bottom of the Hebrides, you get your chair for the disabled, your fireside chair in mineral colour, whatever mineral is, I think it's green, delivered free. Now, I don't begrudge the honourable member for the Western Isles. Jolly good luck to him. I'm very pleased he can get. And then out of devilment, I Googled I put in EH99 1SP, the Scottish Parliament, and guess what?

John Swinney gets it delivered free. But this is my point is that we have these extra charges we have to pay in the remotest parts of the UK. And it has been going on for years. I spoke back in December 2017 when I was first elected to this place in the debate about this issue.

And yet we still have the problem today. It is, I would suggest, iniquitous and completely unfair extra tax on people who really can't afford to pay these extra charges, and it is not in the spirit of fairness one little bit. I have had reception a good receptions from ministers in the previous government, but I'm bound to say, at the end of the day, it was fine words, or as we say in the Highlands, tea and sympathy. Now, I don't expect an instant answer from the government on this. There are so many demands of things that should be put right.

Uh but I would respectfully add these iniquitous extra charges to the list, and put it this way: I would be very happy, on behalf of all these people who pay these extra charges, to sit down with a relevant minister and outline the problem in detail and help think of how we can sort it out. I will give way.

04:05:32 - 04:06:03

Layla Moran

I'm extremely grateful to him giving way.

I'm so pleased he's back on his feet. And I think what he is raising is a really important point about a potential blind spot in the government's eyes in terms of rurality. There was an excellent report released recently from Policy Exchange looking at the effect of rurality on access to healthcare in England. Would he agree with me that actually, if we design services around the most hardest to reach, that helps the most unequal society parts of society everywhere?

04:06:03 - 04:06:34

James Jamie Stone

I thank my honourable friend for her intervention. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm not going to string this out any longer.

I think I've made my point. The point is that if we want growth in every postcode, including some of the remotest parts of the UK, I think that we should tackle an issue which says really that some people, simply because of where they live, are having to pay extra charges. And there's a knock-on effect of all this for everything else you buy or do. I rest my case, Madam Deputy Speaker. Thank you.

04:06:34 - 04:06:35

Dr Rosena Allin-Khan.

04:06:35 - 04:09:58

Rosena Allin

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget contains much that people across Tooting, Balham and Earlsfield will truly welcome. In the months beforehand, people in our communities gave me clear criteria for a budget, one that recognizes the polycrisis we are in by giving them breathing space in the cost of living crisis, and easing the burdens of the cost of business, too. My right honorable friend, the Chancellor, has delivered that, and more.

That is why local people have told me that they welcome the £100 household energy payments and the business rates package, which will mean that retail, hospitality and leisure properties in Tooting will see their business rates either frozen in real terms, reduced or cut to zero. That's over 70,000 additional high street businesses taken out of business rates altogether. This budget rightly recognises that high streets are the heartbeat of our local communities and the foundation of our collective identity, and I have seen locally with our bustling town centres, the Prime Minister has made good growth in every postcode the North Star of his government. He is talking about postcodes across our capital, not just SW1, but also E13; not just N1, but also SW17, a vibrant array of neighbourhoods, each with its distinctive history, character, community and unique personality.

Madam Deputy Speaker, despite everything its opponents throw at us online, this is what makes London the best city in the world. We have people from all around the world, from the US to Russia, trying to divide our communities, trying to break our collective cohesiveness, the thing that makes us proud to be British, and we will never, ever let them achieve that. But we do know that there is more to do, particularly on London's failing housing market. That's why the Government is rightly taking action on the Renters Act and the Government's commitment to work with our mayors and councils to deliver more council homes.

As temperatures drop, the immediate priority must now be to truly end rough sleeping. When people see their fellow citizens sleeping rough, it offends their sense of a fair society.

I know that when I'm doing my shifts in St George's Hospital, and I see people who are homeless coming through our doors, it breaks my heart and that of every nurse, doctor, receptionist, any healthcare provider that has to look after them. We have the most incredible and homelessness inclusion team at St George's. But truly, it is a scourge on modern British society that we even have people that are homeless and rough sleeping. A public health emergency,

it's also a moral catastrophe. So, tweaking will never be enough, and the Prime Minister and Chancellor's commitment to doubling spending on ending rough sleeping to almost £900 million is a signal of this government's values of compassion, dignity, and decency. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, that's the difference a Labour government makes. Every day,

the country and our capital, are turning around the trajectory of industrial decline and putting fresh hope in every heart. Thank you.

04:09:58 - 04:09:59

Nigel Huddleston.

04:09:59 - 04:15:13

Nigel Huddleston

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Two years ago, when I was the shadow Financial Secretary to the Treasury, I labelled the then new Labour Government's first budget as the most anti-business budget this country has ever had and I said that the then Chancellor will go down in history as the destroyer of jobs. 225,000 job losses later, I'm sad to say I was right and I take no joy in doing so, Madam Deputy Speaker, because it's my constituents and our constituents across the country who have paid the price.

When Labour increased national insurance on jobs, they knew it would increase unemployment. When they increase business rates, they knew it would increase unemployment. When they introduced the farcically named Employment Bill, they knew it would increase unemployment. This country has paid a high price for Labour dogma. But two years on, with a new Chancellor and a new Prime Minister, they had a golden opportunity to turn things around.

But they haven't. This budget has not backed Britain, it has not backed British business, and despite all the noise and all the promises of hope, the precise theme for today's debate, there is very little to be positive, never mind about hopeful, about in this budget.

It is just more debt, more taxes, and more unemployment. And vital decisions on welfare and defence spending have been kicked into the long grass. Dithering comes at a cost. And the Chancellor included the phrase "breathing space" in the title of his budget and mentioned it 13 times during his speech. That meant breathing space for the government, not for my constituents.

And speaking of my constituents, the Chancellor also said that this budget would unlock growth in every postcode. Really? Not in WR9, WR11, WR12, not in Worcestershire. There were however, loads of new promises, lots of new spending, lots of new powers for cities and mayoral authorities, but sadly as always, rural communities, like mine in Worcestershire, were ignored yet again.

Labour could not make their disdain for rural communities any clearer. And Madam Deputy Speaker, what I find particularly grating were the constant references in the budget to the supposed generosity of this Labour government. Well, it's very easy to be generous with other people's money. And there were also comments by the Chancellor talking about difficult decisions the government is making. Well, what a load of nonsense.

Putting up taxes, dipping into other people's pockets is not a difficult decision. That's the easiest and laziest thing for any government to do. The difficult thing is restraining spending and cutting taxes.

When oh when is this government going to recognise that there is no such thing as government money, it is taxpayers' money, and they need to show the same level of respect for that taxpayers' hard-earned cash as they themselves do when they're making decisions on spending on their own household budgets? But they can't even bother to tackle the out-of-control welfare spending, which will rise another £19 billion this year to £353 billion, almost the identical sum raised by all income tax. The situation is farcical. And on defence spending, again, as they kicked into the long grass, the Chancellor did not announce defence spending. What he actually said was he would set a target date for 3% in 2030.

A target date, that is not a policy. That is not a commitment, it's just noise. And Britain, and bizarrely at the same time, Britain will end up with the highest tax burden in our history.

The tax burden is forecast to increase to 37.9% of GDP next year and continue to rise then to 2031-32. And the Labour answer is, you guessed it, more taxes. The budget confirmed a new tax on the tourism industry. Only the bizarre mindset of a Labour minister can believe that the way you help an industry is by imposing more taxes on it. But as often said, if socialists understood economics...

Madam Deputy Speaker, there are so many, there are so many, there are so many things in this budget well in terms of missed opportunities. Retail, hospitality and leisure were crying out for support and, as my honourable friends mentioned, we had proposals which we would have been happy for the Labour Party to copy that would have taken 250,000 businesses out of paying business rates altogether permanently.

Their solution was to take 70,000 businesses out temporarily, and only basically giving back a fraction of what they had already taken away. Madam Deputy Speaker, as I said, this was a budget of missed opportunities, and what alarms me most is the inability to Labour to recognise the damage they have already done, because that means they don't know how to get out of it. There is an alternative, Madam Deputy Speaker: a pro-business Conservative alternative. Bring on the election, because we're looking forward to implementing that at the soonest opportunity.

04:15:13 - 04:15:15

Speaker 223

Olivia Bailey.

04:15:15 - 04:20:10

Olivia Bailey

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the measures in this budget that will give my constituents in Reading West and Mid Berkshire some much-needed breathing space as they look ahead to the winter. The £100 payment towards energy bills, the scrapping of gas standing charges, and the extension of 0% VAT on electricity bills will all make a difference to household budgets in my constituency at this pressured time. I also welcome measures to support small businesses like the fantastic Elysian that I visited last week, and our brilliant local pubs, our brilliant local brewers like Renegade and Double-Barrelled. But I want to speak today in my capacity as chair of the Women and Equalities Select Committee.

Considering those facing discrimination and disadvantage are often most exposed to financial pressures, I must start by saying that the budget measures to support people with the cost of living are particularly welcome.

I also welcome the funding to tackle misogyny announced in the budget and the government's ambition in this area. In the Women and Equalities inquiry into the manosphere, we have heard alarming evidence about online misogyny fueling harm, and we have been left in no doubt that if we are to meet the government's ambition to halve violence against women and girls in a decade, then we must urgently focus our attention and our resources on prevention. £15 million over 3 years is a welcome start, but compare that with the vast profits being generated by the platforms and industries through which misogyny and hate are amplified. Madam Deputy Speaker, we are being outmatched and, as misogyny continues to plague our society, we must rise to the challenge. The budget also contains some welcome measures for parents and carers.

I welcome the changes to the carer's allowance to remove the cliff edge.

We cannot keep telling carers, the majority of whom are women, that we want them to participate in the workforce while maintaining a system that penalises them for trying to do so. Although, Madam Deputy Speaker, I do note that these changes will not be in force until 2030-31, and I would welcome additional commitments from the Government to support carers in the meantime. I also welcome the paid paternity leave for self-employed fathers and other parents announced in the budget as an important first step towards the wider parental reform that we need, parental leave reform that we need, although it is regrettable that this gap in the system will not be filled until 2029. The Women and Equalities Committee has been clear: we need a pathway towards six weeks of paid paternity leave and a simpler, fairer, more gender-equal parental leave system.

The 18-month period of the government's parental leave review will soon be up, and we hope and expect to see that pathway laid out. Madam Deputy Speaker, one of the biggest barriers to equal participation in the workforce remains access to affordable childcare, so I was a little disappointed that childcare measures were not included in the budget this year. It is a huge achievement of this government that we have overseen a record expansion of funded childcare, something that I was very proud to work on as minister. Too many lower-income parents are unable to access the support they need to re-enter work or work longer hours. The government already fund effectively funds around 80% of childcare delivered in this country.

We have, in effect, Madam Deputy Speaker, already created a new public service.

So it's time we reformed our complex system to reflect that reality and make universal childcare a centerpiece of this Government's 10-year plan.

Hear.

Madam Deputy Speaker, these are not peripheral issues. These are fundamental barriers to economic growth. According to the Women's Budget Group, women's equal participation in the workforce could be worth £113 billion to our economy. And that's before we consider the enormous figures we could unlock through improving employment opportunities for disabled people and other groups who face barriers to work, which, Madam Deputy Speaker, brings me to my final point.

If we truly want to tackle inequality, we must have a conversation in this place about the barriers that prevent people from working, from earning, and from securing a better life for themselves and their families. And that means a proper conversation about welfare reform.

The current system is both fiscally unsustainable and deeply unfair to the people it traps in a cycle of inactivity. So I am looking forward to the final reports of the Milburn review and the Timms review and to the Government setting out concrete proposals in this area. But I am also clear that in that necessary conversation about welfare reform, we must also talk about the wider barriers to employment: the support for carers, the role of parental leave and, above all, access to universal childcare.

04:20:11 - 04:21:28

Victoria Collins

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Britain needed a much bolder budget for growth, one for families, businesses and to boost our economy. For families, heating, or now even cooling, our homes, getting around, and feeding the family are all costs that continue to rise.

The energy price cap is set to rise again in January and 1.4 million low income households in higher council tax bands will miss out under this budget. Our Lib Dem essential energy guarantee, however, would take £100 off the average bill for everyone, paid for by clawing back excess profits made by monopoly energy operators. We'd also cut rail fares by 10%, bus fares to £1 and fuel duty by 10p, paid for by the Treasury's fuel price windfall. For businesses, for most, rent, rates, energy and hiring is going up. At DJ's Play Zone in my local area, Mark says his rates bills have gone up by 52%, from £21,000 to £32,000 a year, on top of national insurance jobs tax and rising wages.

He's a small business in a big building, so small business relief never reaches him and the Chancellor's new £18,000 threshold changes nothing for him and so many other businesses that slip under the net.

On that point?

04:21:29 - 04:21:44

Daisy Cooper

I'm grateful to my honorable friend for giving way. She maintained, my honorable friend mentioned the example of an indoor play centre, where the business rates are going up. Is she concerned like I am that this winter those increases will simply price children out of play altogether?

04:21:44 - 04:22:23

Victoria Collins

Absolutely, and this is why we need that wholesale reform looking at how we're supporting those businesses who need it and the broken business rates system. And we also see Charlotte from Berkhamsted Bookshop tells me that the average independent bookshop will need to sell over 1,000 more books a year just to cover rising costs.

And Christopher, who runs a small martial arts academy in Tring tells me rising rent and service charges threaten his future with almost no protection for small commercial tenants. As Liberal Democrats, we have repeatedly called to do more to help our local business, including replacing business rates with a commercial landowner levy and cutting VAT on hospitality by 5p.

04:22:23 - 04:22:24

On that point.

04:22:24 - 04:22:25

Yes, absolutely.

04:22:25 - 04:22:44

Speaker 226

I'm very grateful to the honourable friend for giving way. Would she agree with my constituent Philippe Messy who was hoping runs the excellent Little Wine Shop in Taunton who was hoping to see a really big move on VAT. Instead, he's described the budget as a soufflé that didn't rise, flat.

04:22:44 - 04:24:40

Victoria Collins

I think I couldn't put it better myself. And on top of that is the cost of hiring that has been mentioned again and again. The Government have to tackle this for businesses. And Madam Deputy Speaker, if we truly want fresh hope for the future, for our wider economy, we need bold action.

Supporting our entrepreneurs is key. And as Lib Dems who have pushed for a type of young entrepreneurs allowance for almost a decade, we're pleased to see this proposal and look forward to hearing more details. I'd also push the government to look at further work to support start-ups and scale-ups, including reviewing SEIS and tax credits and relief that actually work for businesses. And when it comes to that founders' relief, I'd ask the government to work with industry to make sure it works. One founder said to me they felt they had to stand on one leg and turn around for enough time, they might just about get close to getting some of that founders' relief.

When it comes to incentivising innovation, the government must take spin-outs from our world-leading universities across the UK more seriously.

We're calling for the Government to quintuple proof of concept funding, create regional innovation centres, and introduce standardised frameworks for negotiating intellectual property across the sector. As regards innovation spending, the extra £120 billion for the Sovereign AI Fund pales in comparison to nearly £8 billion of active contracts with US tech giants, and the billions spent on procurement. So we call for a proper digital sovereign strategy to back our British business and look at increasing R&D spending, so we don't have to make decisions over, for example, Jodrell Bank and how that is impacting innovation. Finally, we need a bold plan on Europe. We're calling for a growth and defence partnership with Europe, rejoining the single market and customs union.

Not only can we cut taxes for families with that growth dividend, but inject real growth into our economy, for families, businesses and our future.

04:24:40 - 04:24:43

Speaker 227

I call Tim Roca.

04:24:43 - 04:28:37

Tim Roca

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And though the Secretary of State is no longer in the Chamber, I just want to start by saying thank you to him and for colleagues in his department for the work he's doing with myself and other local MPs in securing the long-term future of Jodrell Bank. We're very proud to have it in our constituency and we're grateful for the work he's doing. I want to start, as many colleagues have, by welcoming the Budget. Businesses need certainty and stability in order to invest, and I welcome the prudent and targeted decisions, particularly around cost of living, that other members have touched on this afternoon.

And absorbing some of these costs in a moderate reduction in the fiscal headroom that was set out by the Chancellor is a sensible way to go and creates the stability that helps maintain business confidence rather than undermine it. Britain has proved extraordinarily resilient in recent months to the shocks caused by the conflict in the Middle East, a war which other colleagues have pointed out was recklessly supported by Conservative and Reform members opposite. But despite oil prices remaining above $100 a barrel in Britain, growth has been better than expected. Because of stability from this Government, because of measures in previous budgets and particularly in this budget, there is now renewed hope for the future. And that hope should be a cause for optimism and provide a check on the constant doom and gloom that we often hear,

a reminder that official forecasts are not destiny, but they're a target to beat. In the last year, we've gone from the Leader of the Opposition saying we might need an IMF bailout to the IMF saying that we have the best deficit reduction plan in the G7. We have, in the last two years, consistently performed better than the forecasts.

In March 2025, the OBR forecast 1% growth, we grew 1.4%. In April this year, the IMF forecast 0.8% growth, we hit 0. 1.2 in the first half alone. And even after upgrading their official original forecast, they were still behind the curve. Forecasts are not destiny. Optimism is warranted.

And sometimes it does seem, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the parties opposite almost want to want Britain to need a bailout. They almost will the debt to rise, or growth to slow, or inflation to be higher for their own narrow partisan self-interest, to paint the worst possible picture they can. But the reality is that we should be talking Britain up, not talking it down.

This is a great country to live in, to do business in and to invest in. And I say clearly, particularly to the party opposite, believe in Britain or Britain will not believe in you. So, I welcome the pro-growth, pro-industrialization policies in this Budget, and, in particular, plans to devolve power and funding so that Macclesfield and every town can invest in the things that matter to them, plans to devolve business rates that will empower local communities to benefit from the growth they work hard to generate, and devolution of income tax powers to follow in 2028.

Now, we're very excited in Cheshire, Madam Deputy Speaker, because we're getting our first mayor in May, and we campaigned hard as Labour MPs in Cheshire to get that and to repeat the tremendous journey that Manchester and Liverpool and other cities have had and replicate it in our own area and unlock that potential. And fiscal devolution is an opportunity and a challenge. An opportunity to write our own destiny, a challenge to say that if we invest in ourselves, back good growth projects, support innovation, industry and productivity, we can make ourselves richer without being reliant on Whitehall or the outside world. It's an opportunity we in Cheshire and Macclesfield will seize with both hands. Breaking the link between Whitehall handouts and investment in Cheshire is a huge step towards us having more control over our own future, and I support this budget wholeheartedly.

04:28:37 - 04:28:39

Speaker 229

Thank you.

04:28:39 - 04:28:40

Wendy Morton.

04:28:40 - 04:30:26

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last Friday, I welcomed representatives from over 40 local businesses to my business breakfast. Different sizes, different sectors, but the same clear message, the cost of doing business is too high.

These are hardworking people. They want to be able to get on and do business, expand, and invest in their staff, yet, at every turn, this Government makes it harder. Indeed, six in 10 small businesses feel that government is not on their side, according to a recent opinion poll. Higher employer national insurance contributions, increases in the minimum wage, and soaring energy bills are squeezing margins. Add to that mounting regulation and burdensome employment law introduced by this Government.

Business confidence has been negative for seven consecutive months. Businesses needed Budget that gave them confidence. Instead, they were thrown a damp squib. But perhaps we should not be surprised, Madam Deputy Speaker.

This weekend, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, who I do respect, but she told us she didn't think employers are working people. Well, I'd like to invite her to Aldridge-Brownhills, and let her tell that to the people running our hair salons, our restaurants, our garages, and our delivery companies. People who are the first up on the morning to open up their business, they leave last, and they often pay themselves last after everyone else. That is the harsh reality. They do not stop being working people the moment they give up they give somebody else a job.

And that remark tells us exactly how little this government understands about people who create jobs in our communities.

04:30:26 - 04:30:44

Gavin Williamson

I thank my right honorable friend for giving way. And she raises a number of points, including extra regulation, extra tax. And actually, the people this is hurting and impacting the most is young people in terms of job opportunities. That certainly seems to be the case in my constituency. Is it the case in hers, as well?

04:30:44 - 04:34:29

Wendy Morton

The right honorable gentleman is absolutely spot-on, and that was the point I was just about to come on, the impact on young people. Because recruitment and training were also raised at my business breakfast. Local employers want to recruit, but finding people with the right skills and experience remains a challenge. They need a more flexible apprenticeship system that gives young people the skills and the experience that local businesses are looking for.

With almost 1 million young people outside education, employment, or training, it's time to close the gap between the skills that employers need and the opportunities that young people can access. We need training that leads to real jobs, apprenticeships that work for employers, and a welfare system that expects those who can work to do so. Ministers also need to give businesses the confidence to recruit. And yet, we see a government whose answer is always to spend more and tax more. Its decisions have added £75.1 billion to the tax burden by the end of this Parliament with taxes forecast to reach their highest level on record.

Families and businesses across my constituency are being asked to pay for a government that cannot live within its means.

And you cannot revive our high streets by taxing businesses out of businesses and into closing their doors. And it's time the Treasury assessed the cumulative impact of their tax increases and that this government's policy choices, the impact on jobs and investment before more livelihoods and more opportunities for the next generation are lost. The Prime Minister may like writing a blank check, but what he really needs, Madam Deputy Speaker, is a reality check, a reality check from businesses like those in my constituency. And finally, I want to speak to a sector on a sector close to my heart, and that is hospices. Because for families in Aldridge-Brownhills, hospices, such as Acorns and St Giles, provide care, comfort and support at some of life's most difficult moments.

Their staff, their volunteers and fundraisers make an extraordinary contribution. But charitable generosity cannot keep pace indefinitely with rising costs.

As Hospice UK has made clear, this Budget failed to address the funding crisis, even as hospices are cutting frontline services. There is a crucial distinction between funding buildings and funding care. Capital investment is welcome, absolutely. But a refurbished room cannot care for a child without a specialist nurse to staff it. And when the NHS commissions care from a hospice, its contract should reflect the cost of providing it.

Hospices need fair funding in all postcodes that allows them to retain staff and plan services with confidence. So, to conclude, this Budget falls short.

It may buy the Chancellor some breathing space, but it offers precious little to my constituents and my local businesses. It ducks the difficult decisions, it leaves the ballooning welfare ballooning unchecked, and it pushes today's problems further down the road, leaving the country less prepared for tomorrow. And just yesterday, we heard the ILR U-turn, which will only increase the welfare bill. Was that costed in this budget? I really would like to know.

Because we have a government more concerned with keeping its own backbenchers happy than taking the tough decisions that this country needs. The Chancellor may have bought himself time, but it is my constituents who will pay the price. Thank you.

04:34:29 - 04:34:31

Speaker 232

Gerald Jones.

04:34:31 - 04:39:23

Gerald Jones

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Pleased to be able to make a contribution in this budget debate.

I very much welcome the breathing space that this budget provides for families across Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare. I welcome the additional £450 million spending power delivered to the Welsh Government as a direct result of this budget, which they will hopefully utilize to support public services across Wales, as part of at least £6.5 billion total additional spending power already over this spending review period to the Welsh Government, as a result of decisions taken by this UK Labour Government. I'm pleased also to see that this Labour Government is backing economic growth in Wales, delivering on our commitment on rail, with the £30 million to drive forward new stations in Wales, subject to Plaid Cymru government confirming that the Welsh Government will match our ambition. The Government is giving families in Wales breathing space, with help on things that matter most, energy costs, fuel, food prices, pensions, and wages.

Thanks to decisions taken by this government, around a million households in Wales in council tax bands A to D will receive the £100 payment towards utilities. I'm also pleased that the tariffs have been removed on over 100 food products, helping with the weekly shop. Many of these are small things, but added together, they make a big difference to families across the constituency, and indeed across the country. Wales's patron saint David, is famous for asking people to do the little things. A slightly different context, but the principle is the same: little things taken together can make a big difference.

I also wanted to take this opportunity, Madam Deputy Speaker, to highlight the miners' pension fund, and declare an interest in that my brother is a former miner, and many of my extended family have also worked in the coal industry.

I'd like to focus on the last remaining call to transfer the guarantor fund. Many ex-miners were the lifeblood of community life in my part of Wales, and not only built our communities, but built and powered our country. Many sacrificed their lives and many more sacrificed their health. That was the real price of coal. We owe them a debt, and the injustice of the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme is something that this party has made some huge progress since coming into government.

We are the only party to take this meaningful steps to put this right. In the 2024 budget, the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme £1.5 billion investment reserve was transferred to its 110,000 members, resulting in a 32% pension bonus, around £29 a week.

In the 2025 budget, the British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme fund went through the same process with its £2.3 billion investment reserve transferred to its 40,000 members, resulting in a 41% pension bonus around £100 a week. I'm pleased that in this budget, the Chancellor announced that every penny of the surplus from the mineworkers' pension scheme and the British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme will remain within the scheme and their members rather than being divided with the government. Importantly and crucially, the Chancellor also committed to go on to ensure this is unfinished business and the full transfer of the guarantor fund will follow. This is something that finally rights the injustice that miners have faced for too long.

However, we need this final piece to be delivered sooner rather than later to many ex-miners who are elderly and many in poor health, with many dying every month. I recognise the urgency and I pledge to continue to work with my colleagues, and I say to former miners across my constituency that I will continue fighting for you until you get the justice that you have been waiting for so long. Finally Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the freeze in the fuel duty and I raise again the scandal of the fuel prices locally, particularly in the Merthyr Tydfil part of my constituency. Fuel prices have remained stubbornly higher than other local areas. I've previously noted that fuel prices in central London have been lower than in Merthyr Tydfil, even though our local Asda store were charging around 10p per litre more in Merthyr Tydfil than any other of their local stores.

When I met Asda earlier this year, they recognised this and reduced their prices by 5p per litre within a few days. The remaining retailers did not follow suit.

Whilst the war in Ukraine has made matters a whole lot worse, the impact in Merthyr Tydfil is worse than in many other local communities. And whilst I recognise that the Government cannot force retailers to lower their prices, I've contacted the CMA to ask for their help in highlighting the unfairness of fuel prices in my community and how they're impacting on my constituents who feel that they've been unfairly ripped off at the fuel pumps. And I call in this Budget to ask the CMA to step forward, come to the table, and see what they can do to help my constituents. Thank you.

04:39:23 - 04:39:24

Calum Miller.

04:39:24 - 04:43:57

Calum Miller

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Government has labelled today's debate "fresh hope for the future". But I regret that the Budget failed to meet the hopes of my constituents.

Madam Deputy Speaker, my constituency contains a series of leading spin-out innovation and engineering companies, from Oxford Ionics to Zero Petroleum, from the Jaguar and McLaren Formula E teams to Siemens Healthineers. They want to put the area on the map as one of the fastest growing tech hubs in the country, yet too many face one major constraint: energy. The queue for grid connection facing many new businesses and developments in my constituency is well into the 2030s. Many households in the area are also used to power outages. The Cooper School in Bicester recently had to close for a day because of lack of power.

North West Bicester, a site for 6,000 homes, was delayed by over two years purely due to a lack of grid connectivity. Now we have two mega data centres proposed. South of Kidlington, Exeter College proposes a new centre, whilst south-east of Bicester, a large centre will require electricity equivalent to that needed for 1.4 million homes.

These are huge numbers for an area that already faces energy scarcity. So my constituents are worried that the Chancellor's commitment to push data centres to the front of the queue will overload local networks or delay connections for essential new services. The government must commit to publish an assessment of capacity before allowing data centres to jump the queue. Madam Deputy Speaker, I agree with the Prime Minister and Chancellor that we need to give more power back to the people and end the UK's excessive centralisation in London. In principle, I support the creation of a Thames Valley mayor to create a regional level of devolution.

Devolution must give local communities a stronger voice over the cumulative impact of development in our area. New housing, data centres and major infrastructure projects cannot be considered in isolation. They make demand on the same roads, public services and electricity networks.

Residents experience the combined impact. The pressure on roads, GP surgeries, schools, and utilities must be assessed across the whole area. Madam Deputy Speaker, buried in the budget document is another announcement of real interest to my constituents: £150 million of additional funds to support large asylum centers, such as that proposed for Site A of MOD Bicester. My constituents and I oppose this scheme for many reasons, but in this budget debate, I will limit myself to the eye-watering costs of converting this derelict storage depot, which has never had accommodation for people, into a village for 1,256 asylum seekers.

The best estimate is around £280 million in capital costs and £80 million in annual operating costs, more than £1 billion over 10 years. That raises serious questions about how far the additional £150 million will stretch. I urge the Chancellor, the Chief Secretary and their officials to take a close look at Home Office spending. I fear they will find, once again, that the asylum program is out of control. They will certainly find that building new accommodation at MoD Bicester is a very bad deal for the taxpayer.

Madam Deputy Speaker, turning to hospitality, pubs, cafes and restaurants are key to the health of the high streets of Bicester, Kidlington and Woodstock. In the rural villages of my constituency, the local pub, alongside the church and the primary school, are the key local institutions.

Too many of these businesses, like the much-loved Fat Zebra café in Bicester's market square, have recently been forced to close. Too many others tell me that they're facing mounting and unrelenting cost rises. Relief on business rates is welcome, but businesses tell me it may not be enough to keep them afloat. I urge the Treasury to look again at the Liberal Democrat proposal to cut VAT for hospitality businesses. Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget was a missed opportunity for my constituencies.

It failed to assure them that infrastructure would come first before major development. It backed a failing Home Office program for large asylum centers. It failed to deliver a stronger local voice despite promises of devolution. And it failed to support the pubs, cafés, and restaurants at the heart of our communities.

I urge the Government to give my constituents more hope in the future.

04:43:57 - 04:43:59

Speaker 234

Taiwo Owatemi.

04:43:59 - 04:49:02

Taiwo Owatemi

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. It is lovely to be back speaking in the Chamber and to be contributing to a Budget a welcome Budget for the life sciences. So if you would indulge me Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to put on my pharmacy hat and to geek out a little bit about the life sciences announcements in this Budget. Over 1 billion pounds of private investment in the sector, backed by nearly 70 million of government funding supporting 1,000 jobs. 500 million across the UK, including a new research hub in Manchester for a company making stoma care products, Convatec.

300 million in a research facility in Oxfordshire for Vertex. 200 million in Loughborough to manufacturing respiratory medicines, including the new generation of inhalers.

And closer to home, just yesterday, ministers announced 21 million for the West Midlands Clinical-Commercial Catalyst with Coventry University amongst the partners. That's investment in British research, manufacturing and skilled people who work in both. I also welcome the Chancellor's decision to remove VAT for orphan drugs, rare disease treatments, providing direct care for compassionate use and early access schemes. This makes it easier for people to access new treatments and continue their care. But access isn't only about newest treatments.

It's about being able to get the medicines you already depend on. And recently, Madam Deputy Speaker, Europe's last fully integrated medicine factory in Austria is considering closing down due to Chinese competition.

That should make us think carefully about where our medicines come from, because in Britain, we heavily rely on medicines and active ingredients from India and China. With tariffs returning and global supply chains becoming increasingly uncertain, we cannot afford to depend on a handful of countries or factories for medicines that patients simply cannot afford. Madam Deputy Speaker, we've seen supply problems with Creon, the pancreatic enzyme used by people with cystic fibrosis and pancreatic cancer, and with particular formulations of sodium valproate, lamotrigine, and phenobarbital, medicines used to treat epilepsy, and ramipril, a common drug used by millions of people for high blood pressure and heart conditions.

And as any pharmacist knows, missed treatments can impact health, and it can mean a condition being managed at home ends in an emergency admission. That's worse for patients, and it costs the NHS more. So although I applaud the work the DWP is doing to help more people with health conditions into work, and I look forward to the Milburn review, if someone with epilepsy cannot reliably get their anti-seizure medication, how do you expect them to work,

let alone to be productive? If someone cannot get their medicines that they use for their heart condition to ensure that it's stable and they become unwell, too unwell to work, how can we talk about improving Britain's productivity?

Ensuring people can manage their health conditions, stay in work and contribute to our economy must be part of that conversation too. So, I welcome the government's 520 million Life Sciences Innovation Innovative Manufacturing Fund and the Chancellor's additional 20.4 billion of financial capacity for the National Wealth Fund and Business Bank. The government has made a strong start in attracting investment, but we also need to be strategic and proactive about where that investment goes. So, I would like to ask the Treasury, health ministers and business ministers to work together to identify which essential medicines and ingredients are more critical,

where our supply chains are most vulnerable, and where manufacturing in Britain could make the biggest difference. Then, let us use some of that financing to attract private investment and build up our manufacturing capacity before the next shortage becomes a crisis. Madam Deputy Speaker, we have excellent scientists and researchers.

Let's make sure we have the capacity to make reliable and supply the medicines patients depend on. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to quickly speak about what this budget means for my constituents in Coventry North West. More than 14,000 local people set are set to benefit from the £100 payment towards energy bills this winter, and that is some very welcome help. For those working in our shops, in our pubs, in our care homes, the increase in national insurance national living wage to 13. and £13.21 next April would mean more money in their pockets. And I particularly welcome the additional business rate relief for our high streets, supporting independent shops, cafes and pubs that are so important to our communities, while removing the relief for from vape shops.

Because our high streets are about more than shopping, these places where neighborhoods meet, where local people make a living and where we take pride in our communities. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

04:49:03 - 04:54:03

Bobby Dean

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This has been dubbed by some as a steady as she goes budget and that's been interpreted differently by different sides of the debate. Some have taken that as praise and others have taken that as criticism. And it will surprise you, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I will fall down on the side of that being a criticism. And that is because I hold this really controversial view, and that controversial view is that avoiding market turmoil is a minimum requirement for a budget.

It's necessary, but not sufficient. And especially when you look at the challenges that we face in this country. I accept the constraints we faced with the war that's happening in around and everything that does to the country's finances, inflation, energy prices, and so on.

I accept the constraints we face with the war that's happening in Ukraine and everything that does to the country's finances, inflation, energy prices, and so on, but we have more challenges than that to face up to. And this government actually recognise those challenges. They have commissioned reports on welfare reform, but they have pushed it to the other side of the budget. They have a Chancellor that recognises that we need to have a plan to get to 3% spending on defence, but they have pushed those decisions further down the track too. They understand that growth has been appalling in this country for a long time, and yet they have not revealed what their plan for growth will be.

These are all known issues and unaddressed in this budget. And I think that is a massive missed opportunity. Now, that's not for the want of measures in this budget. There were a record-breaking 98 measures in this budget, but they added up to cumulatively the lowest total value we've seen for a very long time.

So let's get into some of those. The government have been praising themselves for their energy support package, £100, and who could be churlish about £100 in times like this? You shouldn't really be. But the truth is that scheme is insufficient and poorly targeted. And the tragedy for this is that we had an energy crisis in 2022, and we had to deliver huge sums of money almost universally at that time.

And everybody said, we can't let this happen again. We must have a much more targeted, much more sufficiently targeted scheme in the future. Four years on, and what is the system we have? We're relying on valuations of properties from 1991 to target our support. What a failure of government that is.

And more than that, hundreds of thousands of low-income households now are set to miss out on support, and those most in support are not going to get enough. And if you look at all of the breathing space measures combined, the very poorest deciles are getting just £15 more on average than all the others. There are far more that this Government could have done to deliver on breathing space. They could have, for instance, looked at the Liberal Democrat proposal of an essential energy guarantee, more targeted, more support at the right levels of incomes. This has been a real failure of government.

A second thing that the Government have been praising themselves for is the bank tax and the contributions they've got that sector to make.

We called for a bank tax and we broadly welcome it, but why didn't they go further? The banking industry were expecting this measure to be permanent, they're expecting it to be at 8%. And bank shares went up when they found out that wasn't what the government was going to do. And on committee this morning, we heard from people from the banking sector who said they didn't believe it would affect competitiveness and they were unlikely to be passing these costs on to the consumer because basically they've been getting a billion pound a week this year because of mortgage rates, interest rates being so high. They could have been squeezed for more and this government failed to do it.

On living standards, Resolution Foundation this morning described it as catastrophic. The 2010s was the worst decade on record, 14% growth in real household disposable income. The 2020s, the forecast according to the OBR, 1.4%.

This is a tragedy for every working family in Britain. And that's before we get onto the costs of doing business or the spending pressures that are pencilled in down the track. Courtrooms, classrooms, councils all set for real-term cuts under this government. It's all in black and white. That is their proposal to come.

And all of this can be solved really only one way, and that is via growth. And I said at the beginning, there is a lack of a growth plan, but there is one waiting on the table for them. We would like the Prime Minister to stop having a very open, frank conversation with himself on Europe and that to actually start putting forward some concrete proposals, such as rejoining the single market. It's the quickest single measure we could do to boost growth in this country, and we should get on with it.

This has been a budget deferred. Deferred decisions on welfare, on defense, on Europe, on public services and on growth. The Prime Minister came into office promising to end 40 years of neoliberalism, and it will surely make its 41st birthday now.

It has been a missed opportunity that they will come to regret. Budgets do not come around very often, just ask any of the six chancellors in the last six years, and political capital is a depreciating asset. It is best to spend it early, and they have utterly failed to do it.

04:54:03 - 04:54:04

I call Peter Lamb.

04:54:04 - 04:58:47

Peter Lamb

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The theme of today's budget is fresh hope for the future, so I'd like to take the opportunity to review the pledges that I made to my constituents at the general election, how this budget is helping to deliver on them, and given that the government has set out that it itself looks at this as the start of the process, my fresh hopes for the future. But first, since there's so much steam getting into the conversation, I'll deal with the members opposite. My right honourable friend, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, set out the budget last Wednesday that is the best-received Labour budget in 23 years. Now, that's very clearly been indicated that the public and the market have accepted it as a fantastic development.

Now, you can hear the disappointment from the members opposite. You can hear that they're desperate for their attack lines, which aren't getting through, to get public attention back to them. But what have we actually heard? We heard from the opposition front bench, we heard £30 billion worth of unfunded tax cuts.

That is what the Conservative plan is so far. That's their own figures. Their own figures indicate £30 billion so far. That is exactly what happened in the Liz Truss mini-budget. They have learned no lessons from the exact economic situation they put us in here today.

I promised my constituents that we would have a thriving local economy and that there would be support for the town centre, and Crawley's economy is thriving. I think if anyone looks at it, they'd have to accept that.

Our major employers are expanding in the area. Developments such as the Government funded Crawley Innovation Centre are bringing forward the new generation of technologies that are going to generate further economic growth within this country. Business rate changes are making it easier for properties on the high street. Many of the reforms set out in the budgets this week are going to make things considerably easier for people, and high street rental auctions enable us to tackle people who own property and are not putting people in for their own financial reasons. My hope for the future is we can get further rate reform and that we'll start addressing the unfair practices within the delivery industry, which is allowing that sector in online retail to kill off many of our high street businesses.

On housing which delivers for local people, my second pledge, we have the first-time buyers scheme so that your first time, first-time buyer rises. We have planning reforms coming through. We have £432 million for ending rough sleeping. We have over £40 billion the biggest investment in affordable housing in a generation coming forward.

New towns, greater rights for private tenants through the Renters' Rights Act. We are delivering for people on housing. And my hope for the future is more funding for affordable housing, moving away from current financial structures, direct delivery from the Government, an end to hope value, and HRA reform. I'd said that I wanted a better future for Crawley's children. And what do we have?

We have paid paternity leave, so fathers can spend those first critical weeks with their children, more fathers, to set the tone for their relationship to develop. We have the expansion of 30 hours of free childcare. We have SEND reform coming forward. We have the return of Sure Start, I don't know why we've gone with new branding, but the return of Sure Start into our communities. We have an end to the two-child poverty trap that the Members opposite begged us not to remove.

We have free school meals expansion.

We have the fastest reduction in poverty of any first term government in this country's history coming forward. I my hope for the future would be continue to work towards ending child poverty. We have action on NEETs. We ensure that every send child gets the support that they need and that we create real social mobility. I pledged real action on crime and antisocial behaviour.

We have the neighbourhood policing guarantee, an end to the £200 threshold in shoplifting for new offences. We have respect orders coming forward to ban repeat offenders from public places, and we have preventative departmental spending, so we can really put in place the action necessary to protect our communities. My hope for the future is we take the gloves off the police. We bring into judicial reform to make it easier to send criminals to jail. We have better use of automated technology and greater use of on the spot penalties.

And lastly, a better resourced NHS that is there when you need it. We have the NHS 10-year plan, and national plans for the diseases such as cancer, rapid action on waiting lists, new capital investment, and a huge expansion of diagnostic equipment and record investment in our national health service. My hope for the future is that the service focuses on keeping people well rather than addressing only their needs when they're sick, and that we move services back into every postcode where possible. Madam Deputy Speaker, there should be no limits on the aspiration of this government, or those of our constituents for our country. We should look at the progress which has already been made on the ills which affect our society.

This budget is taking us another step closer to the future that we all seek and I look forward to many more budgets for my right honourable friend, the Chancellor of the Exchequer. Thank you.

04:58:47 - 04:58:49

Speaker 240

Sir John Hayes.

04:58:49 - 05:01:49

John Hayes

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget might be described as the John Lennon budget.

It expects us to imagine a better future. But actually the Chancellor's performance was more like a better Lennon lyric: "Life is what happens when you're busy making plans." Because this budget was long on platitudinous plans and short on decisive delivery. Leaving aside the self-evident, exponential crisis of welfare spending,

I mean, self-evident, but no, nonetheless, perhaps it's necessary for me to explain that benefits are due to hit 431 billion,

There are three macroeconomic weaknesses in this budget, which I seek briefly to highlight. The Prime Minister may say that he has to wait for the Milburn and Timms review, but while he is doing so, while these plans are being hatched, percentage of all young people in the UK who are not in education, employment or training in January to March this year was 13.5%. A million people aged 16 to 24 without a job, training or education, and to echo the comments to the member for Widnes and Halewood, this is a waste of talent on a na- on a scale which is a national scandal. The budget represented a wasted opportunity to address any of those issues, in particularly to build skills that those people might enable those people to gain necessary jobs. The failure to address that may become the defining characteristic of this administration.

They're not new problems. I was the Skills Minister as some of people in this chamber will know and I was well aware of the root causes of NEETs and how we might address them. We managed to reduce the number we inherited in 2010 by almost 300,000 by 2015 and I was able also to build a number of apprenticeships to the greatest number in modern times over 500,000. Since then that number has dwindled. It's only by equipping people with skills that have economic value which allow them to be the best they can be, we can also sustain an economy which is desperate for those skills.

What successive governments done instead is to import labour. And every time we import labour, every time we make that easier, we displace the investment in our own workforce, both those young people that I describe, but also existing workers who need to be reskilled or upskilled. And the myth was perpetuated largely by the Treasury. I don't blame politicians entirely. I happily give way.

I'm always happy to give way to my.

05:01:49 - 05:02:12

Suella Braverman

making a very powerful speech, and does he share my disappointment and dismay with this fact, that for every young Brit who is hired today, there are 27 young foreign workers who are hired? This is reflecting, young people being locked out of the labour market because of mass immigration.

05:02:13 - 05:02:49

John Hayes

Well, my right honorable friend is absolutely right. Young people are being forced to compete with those foreign workers for a scarce number of jobs. And the only people who support that policy are dim-witted bourgeois liberals and hard-hearted plutocrats, because both of them glory in the idea of this of foreign labor. And that foreign labor is edging Britons out of jobs and by so doing weakening our economy.

05:02:49 - 05:02:50

On that point.

05:02:50 - 05:02:51

I happily give way.

05:02:51 - 05:03:31

Daisy Cooper

I'm grateful to the honorable, right honorable gentleman for giving way. He surely has not missed the evidence that since his party's botched Brexit deal, it has become more expensive to do business in the UK, businesses are wrapped up in red tape, and many businesses have moved abroad, taking good high-quality, high jobs with them. We have a NEETs crisis in this country caused by many different factors. One of the factors why there are graduates who can't get jobs is because his party's ridiculous Brexit deal has driven businesses abroad. If we get back into the single market and make it cheaper, businesses will come back here and create jobs for British young people.

05:03:31 - 05:05:01

John Hayes

Well, I certainly aim to address the issue of trade later, the honorable lady has encouraged me to do so now. The truth is the balance of payments has been a neglected subject in this Parliament and for successive governments for decades.

We never sold as much to Europe as they sold to us, and that balance was out of kilter for the whole time we were members of the European Union. No, I won't give way again, because there's only there's only so much you can teach Liberal Democrats. And I'm No, there's only so much you teach Liberal Democrats. The balance of trade figures were once a pivotal announcement in parliament and in governments, and that has been forgotten as we've chosen to import more and more goods into this country and make fewer and fewer.

And the honourable lady will recognise that representing a rural constituency that grows a lot of the food we consume, I am particularly sensitive to the fact that we've made ourselves dependent on foreign food imports. That is preposterous. We need to shorten supply chains, make ourselves more economically resilient, as the Prime Minister said, actually. As the Prime Well, I was about to say, as the Prime Minister said, then I will give way once more to see if I can teach her something more.

As the Prime Minister said, we must re-manufacture. We must build our manufacturing capacity again. Successive governments have failed to do this. I don't claim any credit for any political party, and certainly I claim no credit for the Liberal Democrats.

05:05:01 - 05:05:29

Daisy Cooper

The honorable gentleman is absolutely contradicting himself. He has simultaneously said we need to shorten supply chains to improve our food security, whilst defending the very trade barriers that prevent British importers and exporters getting food to each other on a shorter supply chain. It was the honorable gentleman's party that did terrible trade deals with New Zealand and Australia, that has put food prices up and undermined British farmers.

Would he like to apologize for that? Because after ten years we are still teaching the Conservatives how damaging their trade deal was.

05:05:29 - 05:06:56

John Hayes

Well. I mentioned my record on apprenticeship. I was in the coalition government when that I was able to bring about that outcome with the full support of Liberal Democrat ministers. It was Vince Cable actually was the Secretary of State, who understood the need to build skills and train domestic workers so we weren't dependent in the way I described, dependent on European goods or goods from anywhere else in the world. We just need to make more of what we consume.

It's not hard to work out. I said I'd deal with one or two other things, and I time is pressing. Productivity is a macro-economic problem which has faced all governments. Declining productivity over time means that we spend a great deal of money on things we don't get a great deal of outcome from.

Our productivity is worse than some of our key competitors and government needs to focus on that. The previous Prime Minister and his ministers said they would, but there was little about that in the budget. To summarize, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think it was Disraeli who said that men are not the victims of circumstances, they create circumstances. And it's not enough to blame context for the failure to address the macroeconomic problems of skills, productivity, and immigration. More must be done and done soon.

05:06:57 - 05:10:56

Gill German

Thank you, Deputy Speaker.

This past weekend, I was out on the doorstep speaking to constituents in Clwyd North, and I was reminded once again that the issues people care about most are often very different from the arguments that dominate our social media. Away from the toxicity and division that can sometimes feed our fee feeds, people weren't so interested in political point-scoring. They wanted to talk about the practical challenges that they face every day: paying the bills, accessing health care, supporting their families and making their money go a little further. And the message I heard time and again was that people can see that this budget is responding to those everyday pressures despite global challenges. They welcomed measures that will help with the cost of living, whether that's support with rising bills or action to bring down the cost of everyday items in their shopping baskets.

These may be small changes in isolation, but when you're balancing a household budget every month, small savings can make a big difference. They welcome the £100 payment towards energy bills, and the extension of the 0% rate of VAT on electricity bills. And they welcome the removal of the gas standing charge that has long been called for, and will mean that households only pay for the gas they actually use. For too long, households have paid unavoidable fixed costs, regardless of how much energy they use.

It's a welcome step, but I also want to see real progress on electricity standing charges, too. In North Wales, many families are rightly frustrated that they pay some of the highest standing charges in the country, paying before they've even switched on a light. We've heard the Chancellor make clear that removing the standing charge for electricity is the next area of focus, and I will be pressing for that commitment to be delivered so that my North Wales constituents have a fair deal. And of course, I heard local people talk about public services, too. I heard concerns about waiting lists, access to healthcare and support for additional learning needs in our schools.

No one pretends that money alone will solve these challenges, but extra investment gives us a far better chance of tackling them. So, I welcome the extra £450 million of additional funding coming to Wales, building on the largest funding settlements since devolution, delivered in the spending review by this Labour government. My constituents want to see shorter waiting lists, better support for children and stronger public services.

They want to see funding translated into results. So it will be up to the minority Plaid Cymru government in Wales to make this happen by getting on with the day job with fewer consultations and more action. Finally, one thing that genuinely encouraged me on the doorstep was a sense that people were starting to see politics more connected to their everyday lives. There was support for our new Prime Minister, with one constituent saying, "I could imagine the Prime Minister standing on my doorstep having this very conversation." That comment stayed with me because it wasn't just about the Prime Minister, it was about feeling heard.

People want politicians who speak their language, and understand the pressures that are facing them, and are focused on the issues that matter to them most. This budget responds to many of the concerns people have raised with me in person, while providing welcome, additional investment and opportunity for Wales. I will continue working to ensure that the people of Clwyd North see the full benefit of that investment.

05:10:57 - 05:12:11

Liz Jarvis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last Wednesday, my constituents in Eastleigh looked to the Chancellor for real help with the cost of living. Whilst some of the measures he announced are welcome, I'm afraid this budget lacks ambition, is short-term, and poorly targeted.

According to the Resolution Foundation, the one-off household energy payment, based on council tax bands rather than need, means 1.4 million low-income households in higher bands will miss out, while the scrapping of gas standing charges will save the typical household just £1.83 a month. And the cuts to VAT on electricity and fuel duty both end next July, long before the OBR expects pressure on family budgets to ease. For constituents like Susan, a widow who lives in a park home in Fair Oak, the budget offered very little. She is off the main gas grid and has no choice but to heat her home with liquid petroleum gas, which is far more expensive and is not protected by the energy price cap. Her £100 payment will barely touch the sides, and scrapping standing charges does nothing for her.

Will the minister set out what support the government will provide for off-grid households like Susan who rely on liquid petroleum gas and are not protected by the energy price cap?

05:12:12 - 05:15:10

Liz Jarvis

The Chancellor's decision to raise the threshold for small business rates relief from 12,000 to 18,000 is welcome. However, the policy doesn't live up to the headline, benefiting only a limited number of businesses in Eastleigh. On Thursday, I hosted a post-budget budget business breakfast in my constituency. Lucy, who run- runs Telmar CNC, a precision engineering firm in Chandlers Ford, told me her rates bill has doubled in six years and manufacturers like hers got nothing. Jane runs Elite Hair Salon and, as a micro business, she is too small for the changes to make any difference.

She told me, overall, this budget has done little to support my business or many others within the hair and beauty sector. I welcome the extra small producer relief, however raising alcohol duty yet again in February will hit the very pubs and drinkers that small brewers depend on, which is why we oppose it. Madam Deputy Speaker, as we approach Remembrance Sunday, in current climate ensuring our armed forces are properly equipped is more urgent than ever. In Eastleigh, Stuart, who runs GW Martin & Co, has welcomed the Government's commitment to small firms in the defence investment plan, but told me, we would like to see greater urgency funding in funding this necessary investment, as we have capacity and capability to respond quickly, which will create jobs, growth, and revenue. Instead, the plan to reach 3% of GDP on defence has been pushed back to next year's spending review.

James, who owns JLMS, an apprenticeship provider, told me, this was not a budget for youth employment. The payment for taking on an apprentice hasn't gone up in 5 years while the cost of employing and training a young person keeps rising.

Here, the Chancellor had a choice. He could have reversed the increase to employer National Insurance contributions, which has sent job vacancies to a five-year low. Instead, he told young people to wait for another review. On plan two student loans, this budget was again silent. It was an opportunity to reverse last autumn's deeply unfair decision to freeze the repayment threshold from April 2027 for 3 years.

With the minimum wage rising and the threshold frozen, we are approaching the point where a graduate on the minimum wage could have to start repaying. So I urge the Treasury to scrap the freeze and link the threshold to average earnings. I am pleased to see the Chancellor has finally listened to Lib Dem calls to scrap the carers allowance cliff edge.

This is a welcome first step, but it will not come into force until 2030. Carers trying to balance work with looking after a loved one need the safety net now, not in four years' time. So will the Minister commit to bringing forward its introduction so carers don't have to wait until 2030? Esher and Walton needed a budget with real ambition. This one falls short and I urge the Chancellor to go further.

05:15:10 - 05:15:11

John Slinger.

05:15:11 - 05:20:13

John Slinger

Thank you, Madam D- Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am glad to support this excellent budget.

I welcome and agree with the Chancellor's praise for his predecessor, my right honorable friend, the member for Leeds West and Pudsey, whose commitment to secure economic foundations has helped fund sustained public investment and deliver growth, and it has helped the Chancellor to quite rightly offer breathing space now and fresh hope for the future. Now I'm going to focus on the latter, but on breathing space, the budget delivered with 41,760 households in my constituency to receive the £100 household energy payment. And as someone whose professional career was in the private sector, I was particularly delighted to see the two-year business rate freeze, which will benefit 336 local retail, hospitality and leisure properties in my constituency of Rugby, Bulkington and the villages. There was much in the budget, too, on fresh hope for the future. The words of the Prime Minister are important in this context.

Madam Deputy Speaker, in his Labour conference speech, he said, "Hope comes from honesty. It comes from saying the things politicians usually avoid.

It's what I call hard-headed hope. We need what I call the responsibility revolution, a focus on what each of us, as individuals or organizations, should contribute or indeed sacrifice, rather than what our entitlements are to receive. We older folk have a responsibility to the next generation." So, my speech will focus primarily on the physical embodiment of fresh hope for the future, our young people. There can be no more important long-term issue than their interests.

In addressing a long-term challenge for those at the opposite end of the age spectrum, the Prime Minister set out in his Labour conference speech how the Government will adjust the pension triple lock, a bold and much needed move. He also said, he also said that, "We will need to show the same boldness for our young people, too."

And the budget did this in several ways. And I warmly welcome my right honorable friend the Chancellor's announcements of the Your First Home equity loan scheme and the first-time buyer ISA. Madam Deputy Speaker, that young people are priced out of affordable housing is a national scandal. Thousands of people in my constituency of Rugby will appreciate also the much-needed 3.9% increase in the national living and minimum wage. And the young entrepreneurs allowance is a vital pro-young people, pro-entrepreneurship measure.

And let's encourage young people across the country to consider entrepreneurship as a viable career option.

However, Madam Deputy Speaker, we need to go much further to provide hope for the future. We need to keep going until we can truly say that our young people are equipped sufficiently to be the architects of the future, rather than the tenants in a world designed by the older generation, all too often shaped by their interests. So, I'd like to see the appointment of a minister for younger and future generations sitting in Cabinet to scrutinize existing and future policy and legislation through the lens of how it benefits the next generation. We also need an independent body to hold the government's feet to the fire. So, how about an office for intergenerational fairness?

I coined the phrase youth triple lock last year because I wanted to focus attention on young people's needs and the need for some rebalancing.

So, I would suggest an above-inflation student maintenance loan, and the Prime Minister hinted at this in a social media post with the Chancellor when he said that student loans are, I quote, "one to come back to". I'd also suggest free bus passes and something on housing, which, as I stated earlier, was covered extensively by the Chancellor's excellent budget. There remains a risk that the social contract with our young people is fraying. So, let's show that our Labour Government is not slowing down, but is accelerating our efforts to empower young people. Our role is not just doing what will make us popular with a plurality of mainly older voters.

We need to rebalance things, because investing more in our young people is in the best interests of our economy. They are the innovators, the entrepreneurs, the workers, the business owners, the public servants and much more of tomorrow. And we must unleash their potential. But more importantly, it's the moral thing to do, it's the fair thing to do, it's the Labour thing to do.

I commend the budget for all its measures, particularly those regarding young people. As ever, measures to empower young people are a down payment on the future. And like all healthy investments, regular, judicious, and general and generous investment pays dividends in the long run. And the ten-year plan, I hope, is another opportunity to demonstrate this to the younger generation. Thank you.

05:20:14 - 05:21:53

Adam Dance

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Given the time constraints, I will keep my remarks as short as possible. While there are things that are really welcome in this budget, like business rate relief, energy cost relief, I do not think it meets the challenges my constituents in Yeovil are facing, let alone pave the way for the biggest challenges in a generation that this government keeps saying it is going to deliver.

For a start, rural communities have been completely overlooked again. £100 off most people's energy cost is great, although that is not means-tested and matched to a broken council tax system. But for us in rural Somerset, the biggest issue is there was no real help for heating oil, which has doubled in the last year. What we needed was an urgent price cap for heating oil. I've spoken to residents who have said to me that they are not getting heating oil at the moment because they just cannot afford to heat their homes.

This is unfair, and the Government need to help. There was also nothing in the Budget for farmers, the backbone of our rural con- economy, which just adds insult to injury given Labour has increased taxes on farmers, whilst also cutting the farming budget in England by further £100 million and locking farmers out of funding by running applications for SFI as if they were selling Glastonbury tickets. And believe me, I know how hard they are to get. That is not just bad for Somerset's economy, it threatens our food security at exactly the time we need to be strengthening it. That is why we Liberal Democrats have called for the farming budget to be increased by £1 billion a year.

More broadly, many big picture challenges which were missed in the Budget fair fail Yeovil constituency. On defense that can just has Of course.

05:21:53 - 05:22:17

Ben Maguire

I thank my honourable friend for giving way, and he's making an excellent case for rural communities on heating oil and farming and other things. Can I just add the failure of this Government to extend the rural fuel duty scheme? I don't have buses that run to hospitals and to educational opportunities and jobs in my North Cornwall rural constituency.

Does he agree with me that the government missed an opportunity here to extend that scheme to help our constituents in rural areas?

05:22:17 - 05:24:00

Adam Dance

I totally agree with my honorable friend and that's one of their biggest issues we also have in Somerset is actually even if there is a bus sometimes it's so delayed, it's 4 hours late and students can't get to college. On defense, that the can has just been kicked down the road to the spending review next year on how the government plans to meet its NATO spending commitment of 3.5% of GDP on defense. Yet again, that leaves many of the cutting edge defense firms that the beating heart of Yeovil's economy in uncertain times.

Similar, there was nothing in the Chancellor's speech on education, when 70% of schools across England have had less funding in real terms than in 2010, when we have also got a growing SEND funding black hole. Investment in education is an investment in the future of this country and a sure-fire way to drive growth, so it's disappointing to see that funding solutions to this issue has also been kicked down the road, too. One of the biggest issues impacting growth is how we do taxation. Business rate relief is great, but I do not know how many more of us have to call it the broken business rate system before the message gets through. So many businesses have contacted me since the budget saying, "It's great you've helped some, but you've not helped us. We're at the point of closing our doors."

Business rates need abolishing and replacing with commercial land owner levy. But that is not all. Council tax is one of the biggest challenges raised by Yeovil constituents with me, because the system is out-of-date and we need bold government action to change that.

Unfortunately, the government has decided not to raise rise to these challenges in this budget and the people in Yeovil will continue to suffer the consequences of this government's inaction.

05:24:00 - 05:24:01

Margaret Mullane.

05:24:01 - 05:28:49

Margaret Mullane

Uh thank you Madam Deputy Speaker for the opportunity to contribute to the final day of the budget debate. A budget that this government can be proud of, a Labour budget, a budget that will deliver fresh hope for the future, and a budget that will put £100 back into the pockets of 44,430 households in Dagenham and Rainham.

Whilst the council tax rebate of a £100 to help with energy bills might not seem like much, the energy bills breathing space scheme, coupled with the government's other measures such as no VAT on electricity till July '27, the abolishing of standing charges on gas bills, capping new levies on energy bills at 0% until 2030 means that we are taking action to reduce household energy debt in every postcode. With such a focus on making utilities affordable, I can't help but feel hopefully that the failing water companies, who extort us for resources, will one day be brought back into public ownership, finally ending the race to the bottom that Thatcherism started where profit margins and shareholder bonuses are put above quality of service and the people that rely on it. Speaking on services and the fresh hope last week's Budget has set out, I must say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I wholeheartedly welcome the move to finally open up Stratford International providing Eurostar access in east London.

I have no doubt that this investment will provide a much-needed boost to all the local economies in some of the most deprived areas of the capital. However, whilst this gives my constituents easier access to Europe, my constituents living at Beam Park in the south of my constituency are still waiting for the train to Fenchurch Street. In fact, residents of Beam Park are still waiting for the train station, a train station which was promised to new homeowners and renters by the last Conservative government only to have the plug pulled and promises broken. My helpful suggestion, Madam Deputy Speaker, is perhaps we should ask the last government to own that decision.

Despite the absence of an announcement which would deliver for Beam Park, I remain tenacious in my pursuit of the vital infrastructure that my constituents in Dagenham and Rainham were promised, and very much hope that given the renewed focus on transport in London that the 13.9 million shortfall to deliver this station can be found. Whilst my campaign for Beam Park station continues, my campaign to deliver a new and expanded Emergency Department for the Queen's Hospital in Romford, which serves my constituents has been won. Thank you to a Labour government, we campaigned for 35 million and Madam Deputy Speaker, this Labour government ahead of its landmark budget awarded Barking, Havering, Redbridge 42 million pound to redesign the Accident and Emergency at Queen's Hospital. The party that built the NHS are now ending corridor care and are delivering an NHS that are fit for the future. On the subject of health, it would be remiss of me not to mention environmental health.

Not least because of the Rainham volcano, a burning historical landfill which blights the health of the community in part of my constituency. Given the sheer scale of historic landfills in the country, I was disappointed not to see reinvestment in the environment agency to help these problems. But I am hopeful as the government transforms Britain that I can continue ticking off my pledges from 2024. Madam Deputy Speaker, if any ministers are listening, I've covered my wish list in this contribution.

As the Member of Parliament for a working-class constituency often described as London's Red Wall, I was overjoyed to hear the Chancellor unveil plans to deliver paid paternity leave for self-employed workers. I'm honored to serve under the honorable Member for Portsmouth North as deputy chair of the APPG for tradespeople, and this policy will give fresh hope for plumbers, electricians, brickies and other tradesmen who will re- benefit from paid maternity leave from April 2029, giving self-employed dads the opportunity to be at the start of family life when it really matters most. This is a real win for the work of the APPG, and it will make such a tangible difference to family lives in Dagenham and Rainham, which is home to thousands of tradespeople and small business owners.

Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, as I bring my contribution to a close, very simply as I started, there was a budget the government can be proud of, a Labour budget, a budget that delivers respite for today and fresh hope for the future. Thank you.

05:28:49 - 05:28:50

Speaker 251

Steffan Aquarone.

05:28:50 - 05:32:51

Steffan Aquarone

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I refer to my declaration of interests as a former county councillor. It's safe to say that I've not been inundated with praise by email for this budget, crediting it for tackling the thorny issues that my constituents face. Those eligible will, of course, welcome the £100 energy bill payment as a going concern towards their soaring bills, but for the more than 10,000 of my constituents reliant on heating oil, they'll wonder where they're going to find the rest of the often £100 or £500 price hike they've seen on their oil bills. They'll also be asking why the government has cut VAT for those who rely solely on electricity, but is happy to rake in double the VAT receipts from others facing these soaring bills.

Removing VAT on these would put another £50 back in the pockets of those filling a 1,000-litre tank. The government is benefiting from a VAT windfall.

It's time they gave that back to the people suffering from these higher costs. But it's rural communities in general that are struggling from this budget, especially the future of their local schools, which are close to crisis point in too many villages in North Norfolk. Earlier this year, Corpusty Primary shut its school gates for the last time, and it was heartbreaking for the families affected, for the children who were losing the only school most had ever known. We fought tooth and nail against that closure, unlike, I should say, either the Conservative or Reform administrations at County Hall, who stood idly by. I warned anyone who'd listen that Corpusty is the canary in the coal mine.

Its fundamental challenges were not unique, and it was an indicator of a worrying trend that needs to change.

I'm deeply fearful about what comes next because I'm hearing more school leaders and parents telling me of their concerns about their local school. For all their best efforts, head teachers just can't make the books balance. It's not their fault. They're being failed by a funding formula that simply doesn't appreciate the realities of rural life and the importance of rural schools to their communities. In these places which are seeing a fall in the number of children and young people in their areas, schools are crying out for a funding package that could help them stay afloat and adapt to a difficult financial and demographic environment.

They should feel reassured by the falling rolls funding mechanism which triggers a £140,000 payout into local authorities through the dedicated schools grant whenever there's a drop of 10% year-on-year in an area's pupil census. But despite being the reason that this money is coming forward, there is no requirement for that money to be spent on those schools or the issues of falling rolls.

It's clear both sides of this need to change their processes. The Government needs to be more prescriptive about ring-fencing. And I'd argue that it's not an outlandish ask for falling rolls funding to be dedicated to falling rolls. On their side, the local authority cannot just use this as another sticking plaster to cover educational funding crises. Without getting a grip on the schools crisis, we face challenging times in our rural communities.

We lose the schools, we lose the working-age population. If we don't fund rural schools properly, whole communities suffer. No local school means no viable place to live for young families. That means no one of working age to do the inherently rural jobs in farming, but also the energy industry, or defence. And communities without working-age people mean no one to staff the doctor's surgery, or provide care, or even pour a cup of coffee on a Monday morning.

We must act now if we want our cherished rural and coastal communities to flourish. Besides, if there's to be good growth in every postcode, there must be cross-governmental support to commit to rural small schools. It's not just education and economic growth. This Government's goals in transport, in housing, in climate change, in food security, even in defence, all depend on a vibrant future for our rural communities. Yet, this Budget's measures are just another example of Government working in silos, none of which are working for our rural areas.

It's time to re-establish hope for rural communities by backing small schools. Thank you.

05:32:51 - 05:32:53

Speaker 254

Michelle Scrogham.

05:32:53 - 05:37:43

Michelle Scrogham

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a pleasure to speak in the debate today on fresh hope for the future. And the title of today's debate could not be more timely.

Across the world, we're living through a period of uncertainty, unlike anything many of us experienced in our lifetimes. The challenges we face today are different to those faced by previous generations. Alongside the traditional military threats, we face cyber attacks, threats to our critical national infrastructure, hostile state activity and economic instability across the globe. In a world like that, national security cannot be an afterthought, but in my constituency, this is something we've known for generations. It's the backbone of the economy and of our community.

For many of us, defence runs in our blood and in our ancestry. But for too long, communities like mine were asked to believe Conservative promises. We repeatedly were told that defence was the highest priority.

Yet, year after year, we saw programmes delayed, budgets squeezed, and our industry and economy hanging in the balance. This disrupted the lives of my constituents and undermined our national security. Conservatives claim that they are the party of defence. They stand here today, Madam Deputy Speaker, and make more promises that they can't fulfil. By the time they'd left office, the National Audit Office was warning of an unaffordable equipment programme, running up a bill of tens of billions that they couldn't pay.

In Barrow, those failed promises have a cost. It impacts investment decisions, training and development opportunities, supply chain industry and, most critically, confidence for working families that they can put food on the table. That's why this budget matters.

It builds on previous work from the government to support our national security. It moves us away from the short-term thinking that characterized the Conservative years. The full funding of the defence investment plan gives industry, workers and communities the confidence that this government's commitments are backed by resources, not just rhetoric. Fully funding the DIP sends a powerful message, one that my constituents are well aware of. By investing in defence, you support and empower our communities, our businesses and our national security.

Through the defence investment plan, we will deliver stronger military capability, protect our at-sea nuclear deterrent through building up to 12 AUKUS submarines, and help supply chain businesses all over the country reach their full potential. Part of how we're doing this is the innovative defence financing task force.

For a long time, I've called for a financing and procurement system for the modern age. Too many SMEs are held back by complicated bidding processes, timeline pressures, and a risk-averse culture. This task force is the first step in addressing these issues. Like many of my colleagues, I firmly believe that our priority is for to reach 3% of GDP on defence spending. That is why I was glad to hear the Chancellor last week confirm that these details will be set out at next year's spending review.

This Government is prioritising investment in defence and ensuring the path to 3% is built on sound financial planning rather than sound bites. Hope doesn't only come in the form of long-term investment, though. It also comes in the form of addressing the issues that are more small-scale, but no less important. I want to thank the Government for listening on an issue that I recently raised with the Prime Minister.

Just two weeks ago, we spoke in this Chamber about my constituent, Ian, who requires access to a life-extending medicine. After the June announcement that the application of VAT would be reformed, the drugs developer withdrew from the scheme. Ian was left with no remaining options. With nowhere left to turn, his family were left with an awful choice: find the money to fund the huge cost themselves, or, even more unfairly, lose remaining time with their loved one.

That's why I welcome the Government's announcement on VAT-donated medicines. Creating an exemption for medicines is a practical and a compassionate measure that will ensure that life-changing treatments can reach those who need them the most. For Ian, this Budget has proved something priceless: hope for his health, hope that Government is listening,

and that's what links this Budget together,

whether it's the apprentice in Barrow looking towards a skilled career in our defence industry, the local business planning to expand with confidence because of long-term investment, or a constituent gaining access to life-extending medication, this Budget is about creating the conditions for a better future. Barrow and Furness has always stepped up when our country has needed us.

This Budget demonstrates that, in turn, this Government is stepping up for Barrow and Furness. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

05:37:44 - 05:42:59

Tara Beard

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There's been quite a lot of chat about future generations throughout this Budget and even though I feel like I've aged a lot over the last four months in this place, I want to speak today on behalf of a younger generation and, more importantly, the young people who live in my constituency.

So, though he's not in his place anymore, I'd like the Secretary of State to put himself in the shoes of a young person in my constituency. A young person who has come to me in the last few days to tell me that not hopeful, but fearful is how they are feeling since the Chancellor's announcement last week. I'd like the Secretary of State to imagine that he is a young person who has been to university, who has worked hard, who has made personal sacrifices to do everything that they were told they were supposed to do.

I'd like the Secretary of State to understand what it feels like to be a 21-year-old today, to try and see how much breathing space there really is for entire generations of young people who feel more hopeless now than they ever have before, who've been let down time and time again by successive UK governments, young people specifically in my constituency who, despite Scotland voting overwhelmingly to remain in the EU, were dragged out against their will, and so have come of age in broken Brexit Britain. So, let's imagine that this young person in my constituency studied for their undergraduate degree in an English or Welsh university and took out the standard tuition and maintenance loan.

This young person might now have £60,000 worth of debt, which they will watch rise year-on-year, even after they start paying it off, because this Government has changed the terms of a contract that young people signed in good faith. And because the Chancellor has failed to reverse the crucial repayment threshold freeze implemented by his predecessor, young people face a reality where many of them will be paying off their student loans for the entirety of their working life.

And many young people, my peers included, have come and said that they feel that they will never be debt-free. And so, I want the Secretary of State to understand how that feels to be a young person at the beginning of their career, staring at that much insecurity and financial instability. Now, in Scotland, we don't punish people for pursuing higher education, but our young people who choose to study elsewhere in the UK are now facing consequences that were previously unimaginable, debts which have moved past stifling and are now simply oppressive.

And this to me speaks of a Government who is comfortable in specifically targeting low-income graduates for tax revenue, and squeezing young people's disposable income, making it impossible for them to save. I want the Secretary of State to understand that if this young person does find a job, let's say in hospitality, where Labour has refused to cut VAT and they are paid minimum wage, so this young person now earns enough to be making student loan repayments, 9% on their earnings, which coupled with the ever-rising cost of living means that there is almost no chance that young people are able to make savings, and are likely finding it near impossible to the get to the end of every month. And because of Labour's personal allowance freeze, this young person will see a larger chunk of their income eaten by taxes, without gaining any purchasing power.

So I want the Secretary of State to imagine how it feels to be a young person on payday, who instead of feeling financially secure, feels despair. Madam Deputy Speaker, many young people across Scotland, across my constituency and further afield, cannot rely on financial support from their family. So if this young person is renting a flat, they are likely going to see their energy bills increase again in January, taking the total to over £1,000 more than Labour initially promised, dwarfing any minuscule changes made by announcements last week. And in Scotland, this young person may be one of the 800,000 Scots now paying higher gas bills to subsidise English taxpayers, or one of the 150,000 Scots relying on heating oil who receive no support at all for this cost, as this Labour government so often forgets about rural communities.

Now Madam Deputy Speaker, this young person will be watching as the Resolution Foundation predicts that the average household's disposable income is set to fall by £1,000. And for a young person already struggling to put fuel in their car, that is frankly a terrifying concept. For a young person at the cusp of their adult life, who has done nothing but work hard and is staring in the face of job insecurity, the fear of never receiving a state pension, the certainty that they will never be able to afford a house, lifelong student debt hanging over their head, and monthly costs that are completely consumed, this Budget is a cold, hard confirmation that this new iteration of a Labour Government is no better than the last. Madam Deputy Speaker, young people in Scotland deserve to feel hopeful, they deserve to have ample opportunities to learn, to save, to work, and this is not what they get from this Labour Budget.

05:42:59 - 05:43:01

Speaker 257

Perran Moon.

05:43:01 - 05:44:19

Perran Moon

Madam Deputy Speaker, and it will come as no surprise to members that I'm going to talk largely about Cornwall. This budget brings welcome hope to Cornwall with a bespoke devolution deal on a Cornwall-only strategic authority footprint, respecting our unique identity and without the futility of a mayor sitting in parallel alongside one single unitary authority. That fresh hope comes with £2.7 million of good growth funding, a share of the £150 million uplift to capacity funding and local control of the new overnight visitor levy.

Cornwall welcomes millions of visitors, but our communities carry that pressure without receiving the investment needed to manage it. Properly designed, the levy could be provide a revenue stream to support the funding of infrastructure needed to unlock Cornish re-industrialisation and building fresh hope across our communities. But the Government must now recognise that, as a single foundation strategic authority, it is a pointless waste of taxpayers' money to install an elected Mayor in parallel to a single authority, as an ideological quid pro quo for accessing extra funding and powers.

05:44:19 - 05:44:22

Speaker 259

I will.

05:44:22 - 05:44:48

John Hayes

Will he will understand that Cornwall would be quite similar to Lincolnshire in some of the challenges it faces, particularly in the delivery of public services, in a scattered rural area. Will he join the calls for more action on heating oil? Many of his constituents will be dependent on heating oil as they are in my constituency, but precious little about it in the budget.

I hope that we can create a cross-party consensus that more must be done.

05:44:48 - 05:49:33

Perran Moon

Well, I thank him for his intervention, but I would like to remind him that in the budget there was a support package, which I will talk a little bit later in my speech. But I do welcome the government's focus on fiscal prudence and economic competence and determination to crowd in private investment to rebuild our economy. Since 2024, the government has doubled the firepower of our financial institutions to more than 200 billion. Cornwall has seen the value of anchor investments in our tin, lithium and tungsten industries.

Additional capital for the National Wealth Fund sends a signal of confidence in Cornwall's critical minerals, and their contribution to Britain's economic security and energy resilience. Cornwall has vast, untapped economic potential through our internationally renowned resources of critical minerals, and while the Conservatives ignored these resources and abandoned Cornwall, this Government is taking welcome action to bring back Cornish tin mining, and bring back fresh hope to our communities. But the Government must go further and faster to ensure that these vast resources are not offshored by competitive nations to the detriment of UK PLC. Now, there's also a risk that Cornwall will be disadvantaged precisely because we've chosen a model of devolution that reflects our national minority status.

A key offer of foundation strategic authorities has been business rates retention, but Cornwall Council has had this since 2017. Mayoral strategic authorities can also access 1.5 billion borrowing facility and negotiate strategic place partnerships with Homes England, which Cornwall cannot currently do either. With 25,000 homes on the social housing register, getting the deal and its associated funding would be transformative for Cornish house building, and we will not stop demanding this. In Camborne and Redruth and Hayle, house prices have risen almost 18% in 5 years, compared with 6.4% across England and Wales. Young people increasingly feel that owning a home where they grew up is beyond their reach.

So, the first time buyer ISA and the 4.7 billion your First Home Scheme do offer fresh hope alongside the 100% council tax premium on empty homes. They could make homeownership possible again for a new generation of Cornish families.

On energy, this budget fully demonstrates how this side is on this government is on the side of remote communities like ours in Cornwall. 1 in 7 households in Camborne and Redruth and Hayle relies on heating oil. Compare this with 1 in 29 nationally. With heating oil prices up 82% since the start of the Iran War, the 2-year suspension of tariffs on kerosene is welcomed, but I hope this is a first step as opposed to a final destination.

The same is true for the £100 household energy payment for over 43,000 households in my Camborne, Redruth and Hayle constituency, the additional £100 million for targeted energy support, the commitment to abolish domestic gas standing charges, and the extension of zero VAT on electricity to July. I do, however, have some concerns, in my capacity as chair of the APPG on electric vehicles, about the signals we're sending to the automotive sector. The continued uncertainty over the ZEV mandate risks weakening investment in Britain's position in export markets. Charging 20% VAT on public charge points penalises drivers without a driveway or a home charger, and although an eventual road tax for EVs is understandable, introducing it in 2028 through an unwieldy scheme risks discouraging adoption when demand needs to accelerate.

But all things considered, this budget is welcome for Cornwall. Each of the wins, from heating oil to energy bills, from housing to devolution, comes alongside vast improvement to the fundamentals of the British economy since the last election, despite strong global headwinds. The Government is restoring credibility and competence to the British economy, and we are creating breathing space for our constituents and rebuilding our reputation with our closest neighbours, our allies, and our friends in the European Union. It is the in the British national interest to do so. Rather than the withering disdain and distrust of the Conservative Government, this Government is engaging proactively, and I thoroughly welcome that.

05:49:33 - 05:49:34

Suella Braverman.

05:49:34 - 05:51:16

Suella Braverman

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. One million. One million, that's the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training.

Youth unemployment stands at 14%. This is a scandal. It's a crisis, and far from giving them hope, this budget, frankly, throws young people under a bus, because it's fundamentally unfair. We're losing a generation. It's unfair to that 16-year-old who's finished their GCSEs and wants to start working, but currently faces zero opportunities to find an apprenticeship or to learn a skill.

This budget is unfair and offers no hope to that 21-year-old who's done the right thing, studied for a degree, but come out with a qualification which isn't opening any doors and has instead saddled them with crippling debt, and actually, directing them to the welfare office to claim out-of-work benefits. And it's unfair, this budget, on the British taxpayer, who currently lays out £22 billion a year in student loan payments;

a taxpayer who will see hundreds of billions of pounds never repaid back; a taxpayer who faces chronic shortages in our labour market, in particular in the NHS, in construction, or in hospitality. And so we've got a lost generation, and this budget does nothing for our young people. Yes, I will.

05:51:16 - 05:51:44

John Hayes

I'm very grateful to the honourable lady for giving way.

And she will know that we need to recalibrate our economy around a higher level of skills. Too many young people are directed into academic education, I use academic in the broadest sense, only to find themselves jobless. And too few take the opportunity to learn something vocational, technical, practical, which will give them a chance to get a job and not take on huge debt.

05:51:44 - 05:52:49

Suella Braverman

The honorable gentleman is absolutely right. And it's exactly the point I'm about to make. How did we get to this youth unemployment crisis? Well, for the last 30 years, starting with Tony Blair, we've sold one promise to young people, that they need to get a degree, regardless of what it is, or where it's from, and they'll be set up for life. But for so many young people today, that has been exposed as a lie.

We've got 700,000 graduates who are currently unemployed, 400,000 of whom are claiming welfare. Average graduate debt stands at £50,000. Average graduate salaries are falling and graduate hiring is disappearing. So for many of these young people, they've not taken out a student loan, they've been saddled with a life sentence. No wonder they can't start saving, buying a house, getting married or thinking of starting a family.

They are being crippled by the system. And this budget does nothing to support them.

05:52:49 - 05:52:50

On that point, will she give way?

05:52:51 - 05:53:06

Jonathan Peter Tom Davies

One of the aspects of the budget which will make a huge difference to young people in mine is a two- 2.5 billion investment in a partnership with Rolls-Royce.

It's great for civil and military aviation and will be used to create a lot of jobs for young people in my constituency. Does she welcome that measure or would she rather we had not done it?

05:53:06 - 05:55:45

Suella Braverman

Well, I'm afraid it's a small drop in the ocean compared to the enormity of the challenge that we face. And I'll come on to skills and apprenticeships in 1 minute, because I just want to dwell on how we got to this great university scam, as I call it, at the moment. Now, we have some of the best universities in the country and I will always defend them. But for many of our young people, our universities are failing them and they are offering awful value for money. Some of the courses are not worth the paper that they are written on.

Is it right, really, that and vice-chancellors are earning huge salaries and yet offering awful job prospects?

Does do some of these vice-chancellors really deserve their £200,000 or £300,000 salaries when their institutions are leading are offering job prospects for only 40% of their graduates? No. Do we really need courses in politics, sexuality and gender with the vice-chancellor on over £200,000? No. All while we have gaps in our NHS, construction and hospitality.

So, that's why a Reform government would actually deal with this issue. We'd reduce the student loan budget by 20%, and we'd invest those billions saved into actually helping our country, training up British doctors, training up British nurses, and scrapping the arbitrary cap on medical training places. And let me say a word about immigration, because that has been a big factor.

Many of these universities have got fat on foreign students. I'm afraid I've got to say it, the last conservative government opened the floodgates to international students, it's something I started to reverse when I was Home Secretary. And as a result, universities have been selling immigration not education. And as a consequence, as I said earlier, for every young Brit that is employed in this country there are 27 young foreign workers who are also employed. I'm sorry, I don't have much time and I will try to come back to you, but I can't.

And that is locking our young people out of the labour market. Under a reform government, we would put British workers at the front of the queue for British jobs. Now, that used to be common sense. Today, that's controversial. Going moving on next to apprenticeships and skills.

I'm afraid this budget is conspicuously silent on investing in skills and apprenticeships and the vocational trades. The number of apprenticeships has almost halved in the last decade, particularly among small and medium-sized businesses and for entry level. Go on then, I will.

05:55:45 - 05:56:09

John Slinger

I thank the right honourable lady for giving way. She's spoken about apprenticeships and essentially said that nothing has been done. Well, would she acknowledge that in the budget speech, my right honourable friend specifically spoke about how today's budget provides 100 million for a local apprenticeship service to match young people with local firms, funded from savings in welfare fraud and error? Would she acknowledge that?

05:56:09 - 05:56:41

Suella Braverman

The reality is that 100 million is a drop is a small amount compared as I said last night with your colleague the gentleman's colleague, to the enormity of the challenge that is required. Employers are not taking on young people. That is a fact and it's borne out by the statistics.

Employers are not taking on apprentices. Why? Because it's become too expensive for them. It's become heavily regulated and bureaucratic, and there are now too overly rigid requirements on training. Go on, look.

05:56:41 - 05:56:48

Benedicta Wera Hobhouse

Can she remind me what her government did and she did while she was in government to increase apprenticeships?

05:56:48 - 05:58:15

Suella Braverman

Well, I mean, I think you're on a weak point there. It was actually the last Conservative government that started the apprenticeship movement and they peaked at 600,000 at around 2016. I was very pleased to champion apprenticeships in my constituency, and there've been thousands of young people who have taken up apprenticeships in Fareham and Waterlooville. But that number has been halved.

We're now at about 300,000 apprentices compared to a peak of 600,000. So, as I said, a Reform UK government would introduce an apprenticeship wage credit. We would pay small and medium-sized enterprises 30% of an apprenticeship's apprentice's salary to help them with the cost of taking on a new person, investing in our future and investing in young people. I want to live in a country where a young person, regardless of where they come from, regardless of what their parents did, regardless of the kind of school that they went to is able to enjoy is able to enjoy opportunities to prosper, to work hard and thrive in their lives.

I'm afraid this budget offers precious little to our young people, zero hope to the next generation, and is a real disappointment for our young people who are crying out for hope and opportunity. And that is why I'll be voting against this budget tonight.

05:58:15 - 05:58:17

Speaker 263

Elsie Blundell.

05:58:17 - 06:03:12

Elsie Blundell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I welcome the opportunity to speak in today's debate on fresh hope for the future, including for the businesses on our high streets and my constituents who rely on them. Last week's budget, delivered by a Labour Chancellor, was the budget that people in my constituency need.

They know that our high streets cannot become hubs for criminal activity, whilst legitimate businesses are priced out and run down. They also know that our high streets cannot remain clusters for vape shops and gambling premises, and they know that our high streets cannot continue to withstand these hits without serious ramifications for the future of our communities up and down this country. I am proud that this Labour government is making the right choices by putting place of profit profiteering. Too many of the constituents and businesses that I represent feel that day in, day out, their finances are being stretched beyond what's palatable or fair. I understand it, the Prime Minister understands it, and what is clear by this budget is that the Chancellor understands it.

My constituency of Heywood and Middleton North has so much potential. Its people are determined to see a sense of pride, vibrancy, and purpose return to their neighbourhoods. And this is where I want to focus my remarks today: on the high streets that have been eroded because of a sustained lack of investment, but which can prosper again, provide much-needed respite for responsible businesses, and with power directed to leaders with the means to turn things around.

That is what I heard from the budget last week. The £1 billion package announced by this Chancellor will mean that businesses in Heywood and Middleton North will see their business rates frozen, reduced or cut to zero. This measure will apply to around 600 properties in my borough, and we are also taking more businesses out of paying business rates by increasing small business rate relief thresholds for retail, hospitality, and leisure premises. Businesses that enrich our communities getting the focus that they deserve. And there is a choice at the heart of this, how we differentiate between the businesses which strengthen our high streets and those that weaken them.

For years now, my constituents have seen vape shops and similar premises pop up en masse and corrode the ties between local people and the high streets they once knew. And that is why I fully support this Labour Chancellor in not extending business rates relief to those businesses, and instead throwing our full backing behind those who are instead building back our towns piece by piece. And this is alongside the steps announced by the government earlier in the year. We are determined to abort the Gambling Act's outdated aim to permit rule, which currently restricts the ability of councils to refuse new betting shops, even where there are strong local concerns. Additional planning permission will be required for vape shops, to finally give local people and councils a say over where they open, and to stop them from opening near schools.

And this is alongside doubling the maximum duration of closure orders for dodgy shops to give investigators more time to gather evidence and secure prosecutions. Something that I have been calling for some time because I have seen the scars that these illicit operations have left on high streets in Heywood and Middleton. It cannot be right that residents are forced to watch authorities scramble as these businesses skirt accountability and reopen weeks later. It's time we sided with good businesses and made clear that good practice is the only practice that will be tolerated. There is a moral argument here that we must engage with and must win.

Residents, shoppers and businesses in Heywood and Middleton North are all completely justified in not wanting the continued proliferation of these shops. They instead want to see civic ties and family ties and social ties restored on our high streets, rather than ample profits for endless vendors that exploit working classes working-class communities,

run down public health, and chip away at the communities they once knew. And this has been made clear not only in the budget, but in the publication of last week's cross-government strategy, Hope on the High Street, including 210 million pounds to transform derelict buildings into the new anchors of our high streets. In closing, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'd like to put on my record my thanks to businesses, business leaders and workers, each of which are pillars that are holding up the high streets of Heywood and Middleton North.

Each week I visit businesses from Heywood Market through to Middleton shopping centre and the difference that they are making each day to the towns that I represent is immense. From Tilly's Tea Room and Picardo in Heywood to Waffle House in Middleton and Hony Cafe on Bowlee, these are the businesses that we need to be supporting and we should demonstrate to them that their contribution to our communities is both recognised and valued. I'm proud to stand here today and speak on their behalf and I am proud to stand here as part of a Labour government that is well and truly on their side. Thank you.

06:03:12 - 06:03:13

Vera Hobhouse.

06:03:13 - 06:07:28

Benedicta Wera Hobhouse

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I would like to address the barriers businesses are facing right now that make them not so hopeful about the future. The South West is home to many innovative businesses that employ local people and generate growth across the region. Take DRIFT Energy and love more.

Based in Bath, DRIFT Energy is developing a first of a kind sailing vessel that harvests wind energy on the move. This groundbreaking innovator could reduce and would reduce UK reliance on imported fossil fuels, increase domestic green hydrogen capacity, and open new manufacturing and maritime innovation opportunities. CBI Economics has estimated that by 2032 DRIFT Energy could deliver nearly £200 million in growth through operations in the South West alone. Take tepeo, a South West business that has developed a first of a kind battery enabled alternative to the gas combi boiler. It currently employs 42 people and is forecast to double to 80 within the next nine months, making it a significant local employer.

With the right support and conditions, these businesses could generate real growth in postcodes across the South West. The Government says it will cut business costs and support innovation, but the measures in this Budget do not go anywhere near far enough in addressing the financial challenges these businesses currently face.

The Budget fails to address the significant funding gap between where seed investment funds and where venture funds feel comfortable to begin investing in a business. As the financial markets continue to suffer, the risk appetite of these vent venture funds decreases, meaning companies must go to a significantly greater maturity before they can be funded from these sources.

The innovative loans and grant schemes, which have been separated into regional districts and agencies like the Clean Growth Funds, were meant to plug this gap. However, they're now approaching investments in a similar vein as commercial venture capital does. They are looking for greater and greater reduction of risk. This leaves innovative businesses that develop first-of-a-kind technology forced to seek funds from international sources, often with a requirement that operations are moved away from the original region. Madam Deputy Speaker, these businesses want to employ local people, yet this budget does not address government policy's failure to support business to mass-manufacture in Britain, because there are no local incentives that would reduce costs and make them competitive with international manufacturers.

British businesses moving abroad is not good growth in every postcode. It leaves the future uncertain for British businesses.

They make it harder to employ local people, harder to trade with local businesses, easier to move abroad, and ultimately, prevent that growth that we all want. I would also like to address very briefly the unwelcome and shortsighted cuts to the Warm Homes Plan and the Boiler Upgrade Scheme. This is a decision of profound concern not only for our climate commitments, but also for the basic health, security, and well-being of many households across the country. As fossil fuel prices surge, the Boiler Upgrade Scheme is cutting bills for people across the country, employing thousands of people and improving the resilience of homes by breaking the link with oil and gas. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme is more than a grant to help households.

It is creating a UK industry that can deliver cheaper heating, skilled jobs, greater energy independence, and yes, growth. I urge the Government to reverse this disastrous decision and immediately restore full funding to our warm home commitments.

Madam Deputy Speaker, we all want growth. I have pointed out a few things that make growth very difficult for businesses across the South West and across the country, and I hope the Government will look at this. Thank you.

06:07:29 - 06:12:27

Ian Robert Byrne

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. For many of my constituents in Liverpool, West Derby, the cost of living crisis means a daily struggle to keep the heating on, pay the rent and put food on the table. I welcome any measures that ease that struggle and the direction of travel from the Budget last week was very welcome, but breathing space, Madam Deputy Speaker, was nowhere near enough when there's 14 million people struggling to put a meal on the table tonight.

People need to see a credible plan to improve their living standards, and tackle the shameful poverty and hunger we see across this country. The Trussell Trust report that between 2024-25 and 2026-27, the number of people experiencing severe hardship grew by 500,000. That included 115,000 children, and that would have been more, but thankfully, we scrapped the two-child cap. We cannot ask families to keep making sacrifices while offering them so little prospect of things getting better. And we see the unrest across Europe as a result of this feeling of hopelessness with politics and politicians.

The Prime Minister has thankfully and rightly identified the damage caused by 40 years of neoliberal politics. Reversing that damage requires true, radical action on the scale that matches the hardships our communities face. And nowhere is that damage highlighted more than around our kitchen tables.

In September, the Right to Food UK Commission published its final report. We had evidence from across the United Kingdom from communities speaking directly to us. What we heard should really shame this House: parents missing meals so children can eat, people in work relying on food banks, families choosing between heating their homes and feeding themselves. At a community session in London, a stone's throw from this chamber, one woman put it in three words: rent eats first. The rent is paid, then the energy bills, then the debts.

Food is whatever is left. That is the plight of millions in all of our communities in this place. The Commission's central finding is clear: people are going hungry because they cannot afford the food that is available. Low wages, inadequate social security and a rising cost of essentials are leaving families without enough to live on.

These are failures of policy that require political action. The question is no longer whether we can afford the right to food, it's whether we can afford to carry on without one. At Liverpool a woman given evidence said simply, "A right to food is a right to exist". And Madam Deputy Speaker, she was spot on, because we are already paying for failure. Updated analysis from the Food, Farming and Countryside Commission puts the wider economic and social costs of Britain's unhealthy food system at £298 billion a year, up £268 billion from two years earlier.

That includes more than £100 billion in direct costs across health care, social care, welfare, across the enormous cost of lost productivity and diminished quality of life. Those figures cover the wider unhealthy food system. Tackling food insecurity, making healthy diets affordable must be absolutely central to a government's mission. We pay through our taxes, our public services, our health, and opportunities denied to our children. The question is whether we carry on accepting these costs or invest in preventing them.

Alongside the wider reforms, we need the Right to Food UK Commission to set out an initial package of practical measures: universal free school meals, holiday food provision, proper funding for community kitchens and hubs. Our initial costs are fully costed, with funding identified through tax reforms put forward by Lord Prem Sikka. We have set out what needs to be done, what it will cost and how it could be paid for. Whether the Government chooses to act is now a question of political will. The commission's modelling estimates around £100 billion in wider economic and social benefits over two decades.

That includes improvements in health, education and people's ability to participate in society. Those calculations are outcomes that every member in here should want. Children arriving to school ready to learn. People parents able to feed their families without skipping meals. Fewer people developing avoidable illnesses.

These are investments that can improve and lengthen peop- people's lives. That is why the commission calls for the statutory right to food backed by resources, clear duties and accountability. It means clear legal duties on government and independent scrutiny, so departments cannot pass responsibility between themselves while families continue to go hungry. Members across this House have joined with me in calling for the right to food in the next King's Speech. I ask the Government to listen, work with the commission and commit to the legislation needed to deliver lasting change.

Madam Deputy Speaker, hunger really is a political choice. The government has the power and responsibility to end it and give millions in every postcode hope again in politics. Thank you.

06:12:27 - 06:12:28

Peter Swallow.

06:12:28 - 06:14:57

Peter Swallow

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a budget which puts community first. It's a budget for families who will benefit with support on energy costs over the cold winter, for much-loved high street businesses with cuts to business rates, and with the announcement of a Thames Valley Mayoral Strategic Authority, it's a budget that delivers devolution, too, so that decisions that affect Bracknell Forest and our wider region can be taken in our region.

I've heard from countless families across Bracknell Forest about the cost of living pressures they are facing because of skyrocketing fuel and energy costs as a result of the war in Iran. So, I strongly welcome the announcement of a new £2.6 billion energy bills breathing space scheme, which will provide £100 direct support for over 30,000 families in Bracknell Forest, helping them to keep their homes warm this winter. I also welcome the extension of the 0% rate of VAT on electricity until July 2027 and reforms to remove gas standing charges so that people are only charged for what they use. Hear.

I know that the prices we've seen at the pumps in recent months are also a huge source of anxiety for many across Bracknell Forest, and I'm pleased that the Government has recognized the pressures on motorists caused by increasing fuel prices, and has extended the 5p cut on fuel duty to July '27, as well as freezing rates, and making the more generous mileage rates for both employees and self-employed people who are using their own vehicles for work permanent. These are measures which will have real impact on households across Bracknell Forest, especially over the coming winter months. Supporting households is an essential and extremely welcome priority in this budget, but I also welcome the clear signals this Government has given to local businesses.

Wonderful local cafes, restaurants, pubs, and shops drive our local economy,

but I've heard from too many who are struggling in this challenging environment, and are forced to consider raising prices or cutting staff. And for this reason, I was delighted to see the Chancellor announce that he will increase small business rates relief thresholds for eligible retail, hospitality and leisure properties, meaning around 47% of all RHL properties in the South East will pay no business rates at all.

06:14:57 - 06:14:58

Will the honourable gentleman give way?

06:14:58 - 06:14:59

I'd be delighted.

06:14:59 - 06:15:31

John Hayes

The gentleman is right about small businesses, particularly small retail businesses playing a pivotal role in the health of communities, and he's right, too, the Government has done the right thing in the way he described. But those businesses are also suffering from online competition and edge of town and out-of-town development, which is taking footfall away from town and city centres. Will he support a call for government to be tougher on that kind of edge of town development, so we can concentrate footfall where it's needed most?

06:15:31 - 06:15:34

Speaker 267

Well, absolutely. And that's why I welcome the measure in this Government.

06:15:34 - 06:19:04

Peter Swallow

It means a direct tax cut for over 250 small businesses in Bracknell Forest, directly funded by increasing VAT compliance on those online marketplaces, because it is right that the small businesses that thrive on Crowthorne High Street in my constituency, across Bracknell, across Sandhurst do not face unfair competition from the big online marketplaces, and that's a decision that this Government has rightly made in this budget. Madam Deputy Speaker, this Government does not just talk about growth in every postcode, it recognises that our high streets are at the heart of achieving that growth.

And on that note, growth in every postcode means recognising the unique barriers holding back growth in every region of the UK. For the South East, one of the biggest barriers to regional growth has been the slow progress of devolution, and that's why I'm delighted that this Budget also commits to a Mayoral Strategic Authority for the Thames Valley. Nobody knows the specific local and regional challenges we face better than our own local community and no one is better placed to solve them. Devolution will bring more powers for Berkshire, Oxfordshire and Swindon, more funding for our region and a more joined up approach on regional transport, skills and public services. It's not just about local business.

In the South East, we can proudly say we are home to some of our most well-loved and most critical national businesses, from Waitrose, whose headquarters are in my constituency, to our defence sector, where the South East was estimated to contribute 3.6 billion to the economy in 2025.

That's not to mention that we are home to one of our greatest and most innovative British assets, our life sciences sector. So Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the opportunities that a more regional approach to our economy will create. This is a budget which backs our region to do what it does best: drive growth across the Thames Valley and across the whole of the UK. All of these measures will strengthen our social fabric, boost our local economies, and build resilient communities in these challenging times. But Madam Deputy Speaker, there is no community without security.

As war continues to rage in Ukraine and in the Middle East, and as hostile actors swamp our information sphere and sow division in our society, we cannot afford to delay in delivering the support we need for defence. And that's why it's so important that the Chancellor has put forward a budget that delivers fully on our commitment to fund the defence investment plan and ensures we remain on track for the NATO target for defence spending to reach 3.5% of GDP by 2035. Alongside plans for a new multilateral defence mechanism and additional investment through the National Wealth Fund and British Business Bank, this budget treats our security with the gravity it deserves, after decades of underfunding by the party opposite. This is a budget with a clear demonstration that this Government has listened to the concerns of families and businesses in Bracknell Forest, and has decided to act on them.

It meets the challenge of today with pragmatism and the promise of tomorrow with ambition. I know it won't solve all of the challenges facing businesses and families in Bracknell Forest, but it is a gosh-darn good start.

06:19:05 - 06:22:41

Andy MacNae

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a pleasure to speak in this budget debate, one that, a budget that was delivered in extraordinary, difficult global economic climates with limited fiscal headroom. Yet, I do believe that it will be remembered as both radical and important, prioritizing cheaper energy, focusing on prevention, which I think is a massive step, fiscal devolution, supporting high streets and entrepreneurs are all significant measures that will ultimately bring significant benefits to the residents of Rossendale and Darwen, particularly now that Lancashire is not, is on the opportunity to join the mayoral pathway.

And just on that, I'll take the opportunity to urge urge the leadership of Lancashire County Council to listen to communit- businesses and community leaders and finally agree to a mayor and to grasp the huge opportunities that this government has offered. More broadly, the Chancellor has balanced immediate support with the need for breathing space with long-term reforms needed to build a global economy for the 21st century. At the heart of this, the budget lays the foundations of a reindustrialization strategy capable of bringing good jobs to places that need them most. This vision resonates powerfully in Rossendale and Darwen and across the UK.

Making more things in more places means secure, well-paid jobs in a more resilient country. It's why we established the Reindustrialisation Research Group, the RRG, bringing together over 90 Labour MPs to support the Prime Minister's vision and help translate it into action. And it's good to see that the budget has addressed some of the key questions that have been raised ever since the Prime Minister first championed the idea.

First and foremost is clarity on objectives. It's important because if we judge economic success only through national GDP, we risk repeating the mistakes of the past, pursuing the easiest growth while overlooking the towns and communities that have been left on the sidelines for far too long. Instead, reindustrialisation must deliver good growth everywhere, spreading jobs, hope, and opportunity across the country. And the Chancellor has been clear that reindustrialisation, it's a long word, is also essential to national resilience. We must once again produce the things, the steel, fuels, chemicals, and other things that we need to be secure in a turbulent world.

And in understanding this, we see that reindustrialisation is far more than just a rebrand of the modern industrial strategy. Supporting high-growth economic clusters is vital, but it cannot be the whole answer.

As the red book itself says, reindustrialisation means more good jobs around the country. It means more towns and cities making and innovating and having a stronger role in the national economy. This is a UK-wide project to build the great British businesses of the future. Whatever and wherever they may be. Combining our proud manufacturing heritage with world-class innovation, creativity, research and development.

It means tackling the constraints holding industry back. And the budget is clear on what these are, high energy costs, limited access to finance, procurement and so on. Addressing these at a national level whilst drawing on the power of devolution, supporting businesses through powerful local partnerships provides a comprehensive approach to unleashing the potential of British manufacturers. And we need to take up this challenge with urgency because we must recognise that right now we're losing good businesses, ones that could compete and win if only they were on a level playing field.

So, the first step towards reindustrialisation must be to halt deindustrialisation. Amongst other things, this means further action on industrial energy costs. We did call for an extension of the British Industry Competitiveness Scheme to all manufacturing companies in the budget, and I realise the constraints the Chancellor was under, but we must recognise this is an unfinished business,

and we need to continue to look at all options for immediate measures. I will.

06:22:41 - 06:22:59

Charles David Robertson

I thank my honourable friend for giving way. He's given a really powerful speech about the importance of reindustrialising our communities and halting deindustrialisation. Will he agree with me that we need to do everything that we can to get the ceramics impact fund that was designed by the previous government to support that ceramics sector out of the door and into businesses where it can make a difference as soon as possible?

06:22:59 - 06:24:02

Andy MacNae

I absolutely would. Ceramics is one of those industries, along with, say, steel, chemicals, fuels and so on, that is foundational to our economy, and it's part of our national resilience, part of our national story, and it's vital that we main- maintain this in the interests of a safe, secure, and stable country. So I'd absolutely agree with him. And in doing all this, we need the structure to effectively deliver re-industrialization. Re-industrialization, we need to be very clear, requires a whole governmental approach.

It needs dedicated capacity and power to drive the implementation and policy co-designed with businesses and trade unions. And finally, we need to turn ambition into measurable national objectives. The Re-Industrialisation Alliance has proposed a target of one million additional jobs in production by 2035. That would help rebalance our economy and ensure that prosperity is felt in every part of Britain.

The forthcoming 10-year plan is an opportunity to make that vision real. I urge the Government to build on this Budget and work with the ERG, businesses and trade unions to back British manufacturing and ensure we deliver good jobs in every community.

06:24:02 - 06:24:04

Speaker 270

Martin Rhodes.

06:24:04 - 06:27:58

Martin Rhodes

Madam Deputy Speaker, I start by drawing the House's attention to my interest as chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Events. I welcome the Budget from the Chancellor, and I particularly welcome the Chancellor's announcement that the UK Government will provide £6 million for the Scottish Event Campus, the SEC, in my constituency of Glasgow North. This is a vote of confidence in the SEC, in Glasgow and the events sector more generally, hope for the future grounded in proven past and current success. The SEC plays an essential part in underpinning Glasgow and Scotland's position as a global events and conference destination,

and this funding recognises that. Today, the SEC generates more than £605 million in economic value, welcomes 2.5 million visitors a year and supports 5,300 jobs. This budget investment will help multiply that economic and social contribution. It can help unlock private investment in the campus's further development and create more jobs, whilst supporting the wider Glasgow and Scottish and UK economies. Given the SEC's success in hosting COP26 and events for both of Glasgow's Commonwealth Games,

this investment will help secure Scotland's position as an ideal location for future international conferences, exhibitions and live entertainment. It also helps shape a city that treats the River Clyde as a cultural and economic asset.

The success of the Riverside Museum and the Govan-Partick Bridge is a testament to what can be achieved when the Clyde is recognised as an asset. This Labour government continues to prove, through investments like the local growth funds and now this funding, that it takes seriously the task of making Glasgow city region a prosperous and attractive place to live and do business. I also welcome the budget's recognition that the central belt of Scotland, from the west coast to the east coast, is home to vital industries and world-leading research. Yesterday evening, I had the privilege to host the University of Glasgow here in Parliament to mark their 575 years. They certainly have a long and successful track record, but they also have the research and innovation to drive economic growth now and in the future.

I hope this funding for the SEC will help show how important the campus is to that wider regional picture. However, to ensure that the SEC remains competitive against international rivals, we must continue to invest in the city's skills and infrastructure for tomorrow. Also, the upcoming visitor economy growth strategy must deliver a more cohesive, cross-government approach to supporting business events. As Chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Events, I see firsthand how the events industry benefits the wider economy.

VisitScotland estimates that the Scottish events industry brings £6.1 billion to the Scottish economy each year. Some of the biggest economic benefits from the events sector comes not from one-off sporting or music events, but from business events such as conferences and trade shows. These events tend to last longer, so visitors spend more time in the destination, use more hotels and support more local restaurants, bars and cafés. Industry estimates indicate that UK conferences and meetings generated £22.5 billion for the national economy in 2025, up from 19.3 billion in 2024. I very much welcome the specific commitment in the budget to invest in the Scottish Event Campus, both as a significant investment in this key project in Glasgow, but also as a clear indication from the Chancellor that this Government acknowledges the economic importance of the events sector across the UK.

This is a budget that is focused on the livelihoods of today and the economy of tomorrow.

06:27:58 - 06:28:00

Speaker 272

Dr Peter Prinsley.

06:28:00 - 06:30:08

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So, I welcome much of what the Chancellor of the Exchequer has said in the budget. But I will speak tonight of our NHS, for we will not grow our economy if we are not well. Now, Norfolk and Suffolk Foundation Trust is the mental health trust that serves my constituents in Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket, and it has been transformed thanks to the brilliant staff and inspired leadership, and I'd like to thank all of them.

Now, last week, I learned that some of the teams have been early adopters of AI, using it to transcribe patient consultations.

more time with the patients and less time staring at computers. Imagine that. Now, some of us remain suspicious of AI in health care, but who here has not asked their phone about a symptom or a medical worry? Now, many GPs already use AI assisted triage to tackle the dreaded 8:00 rush.

So I'm pleased to hear that we will fund the technology which will increasingly shape our health service. Let us embrace it not fear it. I welcome the government's approach to healthcare, but much of course remains to be done. Too many of our patients are being asked to be just that, patient. We have record NHS staffing and resources since the pandemic,

yet activity has not increased proportionately. Why is that? And how much genuinely improves people's health? For we know that health depends on housing, wealth and much else besides.

Falling life expectancy in some of our communities, and the problems in maternity services demand urgent political attention. Now, I welcome the Chancellor's announcement for funding of surgical robots having heard how they're helping patients at the West Suffolk Hospital. But frankly, if I were asked where I would invest taxpayers' money, my answer would be primary care and neighborhood health centers. Certainly.

06:30:08 - 06:30:39

John Hayes

Thank you, the honourable gentleman. Of course I respect the honourable gentleman's professional expertise, which I don't share, but I have to say to him that much of what he said so far is counter-intuitive. My constituents tell me what they want from the health service is personal interaction, to form a relationship with a GP, or a surgeon, or a specialist, which is meaningful.

On that basis, trust is built, not on machines, and AI, and robots.

06:30:39 - 06:31:09

Peter Richard Prinsley

I'm grateful for that intervention, and if the honourable member would simply listen to the next part of my speech, he may be reassured. So, what I say is: let us build on existing GP partnerships, shifting resources from hospitals into communities, centres which are open in the evening, with specialist nurses, mental health professionals, and pharmacists, patients places where the patients know their doctors, and the doctors know their patients.

06:31:09 - 06:31:10

Will the honourable member give way?

06:31:11 - 06:31:34

Clare Rachel Gilmour

I thank the honourable member for giving way. I'm delighted to hear that as a medical professional, he recognises the importance of primary care.

We spend a fraction of the NHS budget on primary care by comparison to chronic care. And just last night I was hosting a reception for the Independent Pharmaceutical Association and I know they'll be grateful for his words. Thank you very much.

06:31:34 - 06:34:04

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank I'm grateful to my honorable friend's intervention. So keeping people healthy and at home wherever possible should be supported by our developing National Care Service, simple but transformative. And I'm delighted that our government will fund this. Now, in Suffolk, seven new NHS dental practices have been announced, including two in Bury St Edmunds. And I applaud the I applaud the organisation Toothless in Suffolk for its advocacy.

But the dental contract must be reformed. Why has this been delayed?

With a new dental school at the UEA, that's the University of East Anglia, we must ensure graduates choose NHS dentistry rather than private practice. It was a privilege to serve on the committee stage of our Health Bill. I welcome the single patient record alongside the retention of Healthwatch and the Health Services Safety Investigation Body. Patient voices and independent safety investigations must remain central. Some of our political opponents suggest that the NHS has had its day, and advocate for an insurance based system.

I profoundly disagree. Now, my father joined the NHS at its foundation in 1948, having served as an RAF medical officer. I spent more than 40 years as a surgeon, and my son now works as an A&E doctor here in London. Seventy-eight years of continuous family service to the NHS. So, perhaps the NHS is in my DNA.

It's certainly in the DNA of the Labour Party. Finally, something about medical research. We celebrate Jenner, Lister and Fleming, but let us remember the extraordinary British scientists of my lifetime, the Nobel Prize winners Crick, Hodgkin, Milstein, Nurse, Sulston, Hassabis, whose AlphaFold work revolutionised protein structure prediction. And of course, there are many others, including my honourable friend's grandfather who is unsung, Harold Hopkins. Their achievements must remind us why supporting scientific research must remain a national priority.

So, I remain a great optimist for our NHS, fresh hope for the future, but we must cherish our NHS. We must invest in it and protect it, because if we ever lost our NHS,

It's my last sentence. Intervene.

06:34:04 - 06:34:16

Speaker 276

I thank the honorable member. In cherishing the NHS, does he agree with me that the single patient record, which he speaks so eloquently, must be delivered by sovereign British technology?

06:34:16 - 06:34:37

Peter Richard Prinsley

Well, I am not, I thank you for your, I thank the honorable member for his intervention, and I do not claim to be an expert on the selection of software programs for the single patient record, but I do believe that a single patient record will be transformative. But what I would like to say, if we ever lost our NHS, we would never, ever get it back. Thank you.

06:34:37 - 06:34:38

Brian Leishman.

06:34:38 - 06:38:55

Brian William Leishman

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. Now this budget is predicated on inspiring hope and building a fairer, more equal society. I welcome that.

I support that. And crucially, to deliver that, I think we need to understand and learn from the past. After World War I, the country became more inward-looking, adopting the economics of austerity led to low growth, mass unemployment, the General Strike and the Great Depression. Two decades later, we had another war. But after World War II, that Labour Government really did grasp the politics and the economics of hope.

We created a social security system. We built the NHS. We nationalised our mines, steel, railways, even the Bank of England.

All as we emerged from the ravages of war, that saw towns and cities bombed and half a million of our people dead. We don't even need to look as far back as that to see the politics of hope in action. The 1974 Labour Party Manifesto said it would tackle the severe economic problems of the day with democratic socialist policies that aim to secure a fundamental and irreversible shift in the balance of power and wealth in favour of working class people and their families. Five decades on, we again need that level of ambition, because we live in significant times. The most terrifying set of questions we have in this place is defence.

We constantly hear we've got to get to 5%. Let's cut welfare to do it.

Let's issue war bonds. Let's get ready for war. We're already at war. And with the clamour for increased defence spending and defending our way of life, it often doesn't get mentioned that nearly 4 million people use food banks. We have 14 and a half million people living in food insecurity.

So with the be ready campaign encouraging people to stockpile 3 days worth of non-perishable food, how do we think people living in food insecurity will manage that?

Where in your list of priorities is buying a power bank or a wind-up radio when you're having the debate of whether to put your heating on or to eat a meal? Because I regularly hear constituents tell me there is too much month for the end of their money. Doctors tell me how under-resourced the health service is. Teachers tell me that kids are turning up to school exhausted from hunger. Community groups and churches across Alloa and Grangemouth tell me that they are starting to put on warm spaces again as we head into winter.

So politicians and media commentators talking about people making sacrifices, I find frankly insulting.

In Clackmannanshire, residents are expected to have 55 years of good health, making it one of the lower healthy life expectancy regions in Scotland. In Grangemouth, people generally die younger compared to the Falkirk Council area and the Scottish national average. Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget has committed billions more for military spending that will inevitably go to private capital and arms manufacturers, all while the cost of living crisis rages on and public services are still under the most immense pressure. Going forward, the political choice that we face is weapons and war or wages and welfare.

I think we should bear that in mind and the 14 and a half million people who are hungry when we talk about hope.

06:38:55 - 06:39:00

Speaker 277

Accommodate all backbenchers, speaking limit has now been dropped to 4 minutes and I call Matt Turmaine.

06:39:00 - 06:43:10

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Budget introduced by this Government on Wednesday of last week is billed as delivering breathing space for today and fresh hope for tomorrow. These are indeed noble sentiments from a Chancellor and Government determined to make things better for working people, even in these most difficult of times. As war rages in the Middle East and Ukraine, none of us knows when the conflicts will end nor the scale of their impacts on our country and economy. What the people of Watford know is that the cost of living crisis is still very real.

Certainly, when I talk to residents in my constituency, the cost of day-to-day living is a tough challenge for many.

Since the 2024 Labour landslide, chancellors have tried to make things better for people, fixing the foundations of our economy and delivering growth in the toughest of times. That is why Madam Deputy Speaker I so warmly welcome the Chancellor's budget. My right honourable friend has managed to deliver something for most people, and for that, I and my fellow residents will be grateful. Britain has had the joint highest growth in the G7 this year, that's brilliant news. But what matters to the great British public is feeling the effects of that growth in their pockets.

And to that end, Madam Deputy Speaker, the announcements last week will show that Watford wins with Labour. A £100 energy bill relief for those in council tax bands A to D will help my fellow residents. A real cash injection to help those with those energy bills.

37,140 households in Watford will benefit from this. Further, the extension of the 0 VAT rating on electricity bills through to the summer of next year means help for those through those cold winter and spring months, which will be welcome indeed. My right honourable friend's plan to abolish the standing charge on gas bills will deliver further financial help, as will the continued freeze in fuel duty. Watford residents are car users, Madam Deputy Speaker, and so this will help them, just as the £2 cap on bus fares coming in January will help those relying on public transport, and the first rail fare freeze in 30 years is already delivering for those on the train network.

Businesses on the High Street will welcome the small business rates relief threshold for retail, hospitality and leisure, helping around half of those in the sector in our region of the country. For those who don't benefit from the exemption, they will see a real-terms freeze in business rates for 27-28 and 28-29, welcome indeed, especially as times remain tight. In Watford, this will help 662 businesses and a further 373 in Hertsmere, in which the Bushey part of my constituency is located. These measures will bring vibrancy back to the High Street. The new devolution arrangements mean Hertfordshire, the county in which my constituency is based, will become a mayoral strategic authority and this will help unlock further the potential of the town and the county to deliver a brighter future with more jobs and opportunities than before.

Housing remains a challenge across the country, but in a town like Watford, the cost of housing can be prohibitive, with people who grew up in the area sometimes being forced out of the area owing to high prices.

And that's why I welcome the Your First Home initiative, helping first-time buyers in a constituency like mine will really help people make a home in Watford. Madam Deputy Speaker, I became involved in the campaign for better paternity rights organized by The Dad Shift after being elected to this place, and I was particularly pleased to see the hardworking campaign achieve a victory with the Chancellor's move to grant paternity pay to self-employed dads. This is definitely another move that will help families welcoming a new member of a very different variety in Watford. And at the other end of the age spectrum, I also welcome the end of the cliff edge for those delivering care. I have also full-throatedly supported the government's ambition to halve violence against women and girls and welcome the measures designed to help in this respect.

Madam Deputy Speaker, in conclusion, this was a budget designed to provide breathing space for today and fresh hope for tomorrow.

It delivers that for Watford, for the wider community, and I wholeheartedly support it.

06:43:10 - 06:46:50

Steve Witherden

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget is aimed squarely at people struggling with the cost of living. Good. In a year when one in five UK households have experienced food insecurity, and there are 9 million people in severe hardship according to the Trussell Trust, the government should make no bones about putting them first.

It has identified where household budgets are being pinched the most and redistributed wealth accordingly. Slashing bills for 80% of households in England is no small thing, and I am glad that the Welsh Government has since announced it will use the consequential funding to extend these benefits to my constituents in Montgomeryshire and Glyndŵr. A high proportion of my constituents are reliant on heating oil, so I especially welcome that the payment will be applicable for those off the gas grid, which, when combined with the scrapping of import tariffs on kerosene, could amount to a real reduction in heating costs. Let us hope, though, that the additional £450 million this budget allocates to the Welsh Government for public services is spent wisely at a time when three out of four of Montgomeryshire's hospitals are facing the loss of all of their beds, all of their x-ray services, and all of their minor injuries units.

But returning to tariffs, I applaud the removal from a wide range of everyday goods. It's appalling to hear these measures spoken of as small fry by the benches opposite when it's the poorest in our society that are affected most by such price rises. In providing that bit of breathing space, the 3.9% rise to the minimum wage is another positive step. The surest way to improve our food security though, is to produce more at home, and that means supporting our farmers, and so I welcome the suspension of import tariffs on fertiliser, and the extension of reduced duties for red diesel.

These measures will make a difference to the agricultural sector, which has taken a body blow this year in the form of the Iran war driving up input costs, compounded by a summer of severe droughts and wildfires, further compounded by an outbreak of bluetongue. Threats to our national security are compounding, too, from climate change, from AI-enabled cyber attacks, from a new age of interstate conflict, but we cannot forget about the basics. As an island nation, we must have domestic resilience in food production. You'll have to forgive me, Madam Deputy Speaker, but food security is national security. Let me end on fiscal devolution.

The experience in many parts of Wales is that devolution is unfinished business.

Powers have been devolved to the Senedd, but not to our regions and communities, such as north-east Wales or the Marches. I'm happy to hear that English local authorities will start to retain more business rates from next year, but I would like to see greater detail as to how the Government is working with the devolved Administrations to realise the benefits of regional governance across the UK. This Government, like any Government, will be judged on how it will improve the material conditions of hard-working people. It is that target on which this budget is rightly focused.

06:46:50 - 06:46:52

Speaker 279

Blake.

06:46:52 - 06:48:01

Speaker 280

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know that it's unconventional to crowd-source one's speech on the budget, but I did happen to do my annual budget Q&A last night, and it was absolutely a joyful experience, an online budget Q&A.

And the key themes that were raised with me are is this budget bold enough and what does it do for our communities here in the cities of London and Westminster? And you'll be delighted and perhaps unsurprised to know that those key questions raised by my own constituents are very similar to those that are raised here in the chamber. And it's really clear to me as it is to them that we this Government cannot control every challenge or beyond our shores, but we can seek stability, and we can strengthen our resilience and support those most in need. And the foundations for a more stable economy were established by the choices made by my right honourable friend, the member for Leeds West and Pudsey, when she made the tough choices to stabilize our economy. What we need now is for families to need to have the confidence that they can play a key role in the future.

06:48:01 - 06:48:05

Speaker 281

Businesses need confidence to invest, expand and create jobs.

06:48:05 - 06:50:51

Speaker 280

And our economy needs the confidence that public finances are being managed responsibly. And that's why I think this Government's commitment to fiscal discipline and credible fiscal rules is so important. Economic credibility is not an abstract concept discussed only in Westminster, in this Chamber. It affects mortgage rates, investment decisions, business confidence, household budgets, and, increasingly, whether people can afford to own a home of their own. That's in stark contrast to the damaging effects of the mini budget that the Opposition benches want us to forget, but we will very much remember, and sadly, the day-to-day budgets of our constituents remember.

This Government rightly takes a responsible approach, and I particularly welcome those measures that are supporting enterprise, investment, and job creation.

My constituency, the Cities of London and Westminster, has more jobs than people in it. And we see every day the contribution that businesses make to our economy, from small and independent firms to globally recognized companies. Economic security must also include housing security. For far too many people, particularly in London, people cannot afford a home of their own. And what was particularly important to me in this Budget was the announcement of £432 million of additional investment to stabilize the support to those people who are most vulnerable.

It was an absolute honour to welcome the Prime Minister and the Chancellor to my constituency on Monday where we recognized the long-standing work of frontline rough sleeping outreach workers. This was a long-standing call from those people who work in the sector to recognize the skilled work that they do every single day to help the most vulnerable. And I'm really proud that this government has made that decision to make long-term investment in keeping people off the street. Not only is it the right decision, the compassionate decision, I will not give way, we're going to be, hopefully, moving to a vote soon. But my, but I would be, like to make really clear, this is the right moral decision, the right compassionate decision.

It aligns with our values, it should align with everybody's values.

It's also the right economic decision. It is not in the interests of public spending to allow people to live on the streets, and I pay tribute to the work of Connection at St Martin's who hosted us that day. We've shown the risks that the opposition benches are prepared to take with our economy, and this Government is taking a responsible approach to the economy, which enables us to make those investments in some of the most vulnerable in society. I commend this Budget to the House, and I commend this responsible approach to fiscal discipline, which allows us to make those important political choices.

06:50:52 - 06:50:54

Speaker 282

Fantastic. Sarah Smith.

06:50:54 - 06:54:52

Madeleine Sarah Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There is much to welcome in this Budget for my constituents in Hyndburn and Haslingden.

Some of the measures include a £100 for 41,000 of my residents that will benefit from this immediate support for their energy bills as we seek to tackle the cost of energy crisis; the expansion of paid parental leave to self-employed people, which will help around 90 new families in my patch every single year; and the business rates relief for businesses with rateable values of £18,000 or less, which builds upon and goes further than the previously announced plans to increase business rates relief on pubs from April of 2027. I know how hard our pub and shop owners work and the huge contribution they make to our local communities. And I must give a particular shout out to my local, the White Bull in Oswaldtwistle, who have recently undertaken plans to extend their dining area and where I would be delighted to treat the minister to lunch if they were to come to visit. I'd strongly recommend the Hungarian goulash. However, in my remarks, I will focus on two main substantive issues in this budget.

Firstly, I welcome the commitment to a mayor of Lancashire.

This Labour government have made it clear that it is firmly on the table for Lancashire to have that mayor, and at my business event last week with over 130 leaders from across East Lancashire, business leaders were clear that they want this to happen as quickly as possible. Therefore, it is time for Reform-led Lancashire County Council to stop delaying and to get behind this mayor for Lancashire, which is key to unlocking our economic potential. But even better, we don't have to wait for a mayor for us to get going. Following the calls from many colleagues on this side of the House, including my honorable friends, the members for Ribble Valley and Rossendale and Darwen, the budget includes a commitment to capacity and capability funding for areas who are progressing towards a mayoral strategic authority, which will put 7.7 million pounds of funding into Lancashire from next year.

Alongside this, there is the development of the local growth funds, a total of £80 million for non-mayoral areas to support priority projects that will support their economic growth and development. Secondly, I want to turn to what this budget does for entrepreneurs. Some of these measures include the increases to the trading allowance, a proposed young entrepreneurs allowance, and £200 million of additional funding for female founders.

Furthermore, there's a significant set of plans to support early stage and scale-up funding with a commitment of an extra £5 billion to the British Business Bank, £450 million of which is allocated to a new venture debt product to help innovative firms access capital without immediate equity dilution.

Over the last year, I've been raising with ministers the challenge faced by these businesses during their pre-commercialization, so-called valley of death, and the opportunity to help low-carbon technology businesses in Hyndburn and East Lancashire, who face this barrier, through funding the REDCAT proposals that I have shared. REDCAT provides businesses who are trying to produce new products for their first identified customer. And I hope that through these combined announcements, there may be ways of funding REDCAT. So, I urge ministers to meet with me to work out how we can overcome some of the siloed approaches within government to unlock this and to unlock the economic growth not just in Hyndburn and Lancashire, but also in other parts of the country. This budget does go a long way to helping my constituents through these difficult global headwinds, as well as outling- a broader ambition to reshape our energy markets and the economy for the future in a way that delivers good growth in every postcode and hope in every heart.

Devolution is the chance for Lancashire to take control of our own future and to stop having to come cap in hand to Westminster. And while we work towards this, I will continue to work with ministers to deliver the jobs, opportunities, and growth that Hyndburn desperately needs. Thank you.

06:54:52 - 06:54:54

Speaker 283

Lola McEvoy.

06:54:54 - 06:58:20

Laura Marie McEvoy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm the Member of Parliament for Darlington, the home of No. 11 North and the Darlington Economic Campus. So, I just want to put on record my thanks to Beth and Joe and Laura, and all of the civil servants who worked round the clock to make sure that we could deliver this budget, the Chancellor's first budget. So, the Treasury campus in Darlington was the brainchild of the previous government, and it was funded by this government up to the tune of 118 million pounds for a brand-new hub. So, it is proof that the best interventions from this place do garner cross-party support.

So I'm sure that everyone across the House in this chamber will agree with investing record amounts in defense to support our world-leading armed forces and defense industry, backing British inventors, innovators and founders, so if you've got a great idea here, we will make sure you can succeed here. And £100 cash back in January for energy bills for 45,000 households in Darlington and hundreds of thousands more across the country, much needed and well received. Hope for our high streets, that's a freeze on business rates and an increase in the business rate relief threshold to £18,000. This will benefit 222 business rates in Darlington, businesses in Darlington, and I'm particularly pleased to see that these measures are paid for by the global e-marketplaces, and also from taking the relief from those pesky vape shops.

The country and, I'm sure, the representatives across the House can all support that. What seems to divide this House is how we should deliver it. And it is right that this Government, under this Chancellor, continues its commitment to fiscal responsibility. We must reduce the amount we're paying on debt interest. And I welcome the fact that those who've made record profits off global insecurity, that is driven down the cost of living driven down cost of living pressures on households across our country, pay a little bit more through the bank levy.

The truth remains that we won't spend more than we earn. But despite record investment, incredible world-leading growth sectors and an army of grafters, yes, in every postcode, we are getting battered by global storms. That is not the fault of the party opposite, but the severity of the impact we feel is. So I welcome this budget's ring-fencing of prevent preventative policies and services.

Prevention should be ring-fenced in its funding in its funding, and I welcome that. If the last government had redirected the money that it saved in the short-term cuts into upgrading the grid or building new nuclear or building new renewables to create energy security, or building new hospitals, or building council homes, or building any homes, or building roads, or building railways, or indeed investing in our armed forces, perhaps then they'd still be trusted with an ounce of public money. But instead, they proved to a whole generation that they do not and should not have the keys to Whitehall.

They oversaw some of the worst business deals on record, incentivizing hotel use by private contractors housing people seeking asylum, outsourcing our pensions, our social care, our post, failing to prepare for the pandemic, then crashing the economy, leading to the fastest annual fall in living standards since records began. So, yes, this government has more to do, and I welcome this Chancellor and his Budget and the myriad of interventions he's made that are aimed at protecting our economy, protecting our industry and protecting our security. I will give way.

06:58:20 - 06:58:43

John Thomas Hayes

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. Does she agree that we don't need to choose between cheaper and cleaner energy, that the two can go in harmony? And one of the ways in which that's going to be happening is by the abolition of gas standing charges, which will save 23 million homes £45 on average. And that's just some of the good things that this Labour government is doing to not just tackle our climate crisis, but to put more money into people's pockets.

06:58:43 - 06:59:38

Laura Marie McEvoy

I thank my honorable friend for his intervention. I absolutely agree with him, the standing charge policy is something that has come up on the doorstep and has really had cut-through, so I'm delighted to see and welcome that intervention in the House. So, Darlington, yes, is the home to No. 11 North.

Yes, it's the home to the first world's first passenger railway. Yes, it's the home to pease pudding, and soon to be the home to a brand new multi-million pound STEM subject training centre backed with £16 million from the last budget, backed by industry and £5 million of Pride in Place funding. Yeah, we do have all that. But we're way more than all of those things. We're a test case for good growth, and we are bucking the national trend, a resilient, investable ecosystem.

I grew up in a part of Darlington that was historically called Hopetown.

We had hope 200 years ago, and we hope again.

06:59:38 - 06:59:40

Speaker 286

Laura Cox Smith.

06:59:40 - 07:03:40

Laura Kyrke-Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Much of the discussion around the budget has been focused on the national level, and rightly so, but for my constituents, the true test is whether life in Aylesbury and the villages feels any different, whether the decisions in the budget translate into thriving local businesses, stronger communities, and more confidence in our futures. I was out knocking on doors at the weekend, and one lady said to me, "This town is miserable now, isn't it?", which always pains me to hear. She was talking about waking up on a Saturday, she doesn't head into Aylesbury, she'll go over to Tring or Wendover where she can park cheaply and easily, and find all the shops and the cafés she needs. And in some ways, she has a point.

Over the last decade or two, we've lost many of the shops and pubs and cafés that we used to have, but I know that our town has huge strengths and potential, and I think this Labour government's budget is one that helps us to start to turn a corner, and that's what I'll focus on today.

Because the fact is that our towns don't thrive by accident. They rely on entrepreneurs prepared to take risks, family businesses that have served their communities for generations and independent retailers who give our town centres that character and identity. And these are not simply economic actors. They're often the same people who are sponsoring local sports clubs and community events. I think, for example, of the long partnership between Express Labels and Aylesbury United.

And they're helping young people get into work. So, if we're serious about the future of our high streets, we have to back these businesses to succeed. We have to do that nationally, we have to do that locally, as Aylesbury Town Council does very well. I've spoken to many businesses who tell me that business rates remain one of their biggest cost pressures. It's something that the brilliant Buckinghamshire Business First organisation has raised with me, too.

So I welcome the decision to expand Small Business Rates Relief and take thousands more local firms out of business rates altogether. Across Buckinghamshire, 2,000 businesses will now be paying no business rates at all. And for these small businesses who are trying to invest, to take on staff, this makes a real difference. I also welcome that real-terms freeze in business rates bills for the next two years for all our retail, hospitality and leisure businesses. And I know that the additional 20% relief for pubs, social clubs and most live music venues will be welcomed by many constituents who have written to me about this, too.

I also welcome the focus in the budget on the support for entrepreneurs and early start-ups. We should be making it easier for people with a business idea to take that first step, which is why the decision to triple the tax-free trading allowance from £1,000 to £3,000 is really important.

Whether someone's testing a new business idea, turning a hobby into a source of income, or exploring self-employment for the first time, this measure helps to remove barriers and encourages enterprise. And I'm really pleased to see the introduction of the young entrepreneurs allowance to help those young people trying to get into work. I also wanted to mention and celebrate the further support for female entrepreneurs in the budget through the new scale-up program for female founders and the additional backing from the British Business Bank. I know we've got many brilliant entrepreneurial women in Aylesbury. I think, for example, of Carys Dorritt at The Poké, a digital marketing agency, and we should absolutely be on their side.

Helping our businesses to flourish is, of course, just one part of the transformation that I want to see in our town centre and on our village high streets. From creating more spaces for young people, to improving our green spaces, from improving public transport, to sorting out parking, there is much more to do.

But backing the businesses who are the beating heart of our towns and villages is a great place to start. And if anyone doubts that change is possible, then take a walk along the high street opposite Vale Park, because, for eight years, residents have been campaigning to remove the ugly and dangerous scaffolding which blocked the pavement on this main route into town. And I've been pleased to support them. And finally, last week, we won. You may ask, Madam Deputy Speaker, what's the deal with a pile of scaffolding at this late stage in the debate?

But what was supposed to be a temporary fix became, over eight years, a sign of how little Buckinghamshire Council seemed to care about our town. But it's gone, and we've proven that we can start to change things, and I'm hopeful about what's next. Hear.

07:03:40 - 07:03:44

Speaker 287

Final backbencher, Dave Robertson.

07:03:44 - 07:07:44

Charles David Robertson

Always a little bit worried when they cheer because I'm last.

Can I join colleagues in the House recognising and supporting the important measures in the budget which will give people across Lichfield, Burntwood and the villages, the place I call home, valuable breathing space? Whether that's the 34,790 households across my constituency who will receive £100 direct into their bank account in January because of this budget. That comes on top of the removal of VAT from energy bills, the return of the £2 bus fare, the promise to get rid of standing charges on gas, the haulier businesses supported by the delay to the fuel escalator, we could go on and on. Now, any of those individual changes on their own will not be the end of the cost of living crisis, but I am already hearing from people back home who are also happy that this government understand the importance of giving them that breathing space in their personal finances.

Can I also turn to the changes to small business rates relief announced by the Chancellor. Those changes in this budget will mean that many businesses in our town and city centres and in our villages will be lifted out of paying business rates at all and many more will see a smaller bill. At Sankey's Corner, the town in my constituency, 15 premises in that town centre will be taking out of that bill, paying that bill at all. That's a huge number of shops there who will now have more money to put back into their businesses and the community. I haven't been able to get the total bill about what will be saved there, but it's looking like an investment into that community of anywhere between 50 and 100,000 pounds per year forever.

That's a real investment in the high street in Burntwood by this government.

Similarly, in the village high street of Fradley, of around a dozen shops there, four will no longer be paying business rates at all, and a further four will have their bills cut because of this Budget. On top of this, across Lichfield and East Staffordshire, 764 retail hospitality leisure businesses will see their rates frozen in cash terms because of decisions made by this Labour government. I'm also really pleased to see the government pressing ahead with plans for devolution across Staffordshire and Stoke. Whilst the previous government pushed power into and funding into the West Midlands conurbation and the combined authority in the East Midlands, it gave a cold shoulder to the county to the north. This government is prepared to step up and give our county the powers and drive the economic growth to bring good jobs across our area.

Just yesterday, I spoke to the principal of South Staffordshire College about the importance of getting those powers to where they need to be, so that our skills training can meet the needs of our local area and especially in rural areas of my constituency and the wider county.

The economy needs workers and making sure those workers have the skills they need is something so important to areas like Staffordshire, and I am excited to get those decisions and skills made in the right places. There are a few other points I did want to pick up, but in the interest of time, I do finally want to turn to the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme and British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme. The pension schemes for former coal miners and mine workers have been so poorly set up for so long. I am very pleased that this Government has again moved even closer to delivering the justice that coalfield communities like mine in Burntwood, Handsacre and the surrounding areas deserve. The end of the Treasury grabbing half of the scheme surpluses should be applauded.

The end of the standstill clause so that bonus pensions can be guaranteed should be applauded. The previous return of the investment reserve to the people who earned it should be applauded. All of these steps for communities should be applauded, and it simply would not have happened without a Labour Government.

However, that last remaining piece of that jigsaw, it the final reserve, the Guarantor's Fund, needs to happen. The commitment from the Chancellor to move quickly on this, and from the Secretary of State that we should expect that to be weeks not months this week, have been really welcome. But we cannot wait. Miners have already waited for far too long. Every day miners leave the scheme.

Every day we lose people and we cannot afford to wait any longer. We must push that because it's their money, they earned it and this Labour government needs to make sure we do what we should always do and stand up for our mining communities.

07:07:44 - 07:07:50

Speaker 289

I call the shadow minister, if you're ready, Richard Fuller.

07:07:50 - 07:18:59

Richard Fuller

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I would like to thank all honorable and right honorable members who have taken a part in this debate over the last four days and, in particular, the over 40 members who have spoken in the debate today. And, if I may, I'd just mention a few on this side of the House for their contributions. My honorable friend the member for Epping Forest talked importantly about the issues of protecting the green belt. My honorable friend the member for Ruislip and Pinner talked about the fact this was one of the most centralizing governments despite the rhetoric. The honorable member for Caithness and Sutherland made a beautiful speech about looking for a chair for his wife and talked about the delivery charges that penalize people in rural areas.

The honorable member, my right honorable friend, the member for Aldridge-Brownhills talked about the importance of business confidence, and the fact that it has been in negative territory under this government for 7 months. My honorable friend, the member for Droitwich and Evesham, talked about the importance of job losses because of Labour's decisions, and made the absolutely true point that if Labour MPs understood economics, they wouldn't be socialists. The member for Bicester and Woodstock made an important point about competition for grid connectivity in his constituency, which is a matter across the country. And my right honorable friend, the member for South Holland and The Deepings, made a reference to John Lennon, which was a cultural reference about two centuries more modern than I was expecting him to make.

We had a series of excellent speeches on our side, and some interesting speeches on the government side too, trying to pick through the parts of the budget to talk about. But I would like just to point out the first speech by the honorable lady, the member for Erith and Thamesmead. She is also a select committee chair and I think in her speech demonstrated what is best about the select committee system here. Yes, she is a Labour MP, but she will stand up for all MPs in the way that she holds this government to account. From our side of the House, there has been a consistent message that this budget has left the British people facing higher inflation, higher interest rates, greater borrowing, and more debt than was promised last year,

that this budget will leave families worse off, not better off.

So Madam Deputy Speaker, can I welcome the Chief Secretary to the Treasury? Here we are, two working people. Did I get Did I get that right? This was a budget of fiddly bits, according to the Institute of Fiscal Studies, a nothing budget, according to the CBI, remarkable for its lack of action, according to the Resolution Foundation, big in size but small in ambition, according to the Institute for Government.

They're not wrong. The most surprising aspect of this "kick the can down the road" budget is that the debate managed to last 4 days. After 4 days of debate and a week of scrutiny, the abiding sense is this was a budget of missed opportunities. A missed opportunity to demonstrate that we are serious about defence; a missed opportunity to get people off welfare and into work; a missed opportunity to spell out the tough decisions needed to curb public spending, eliminate the deficit and cut our debts; a missed opportunity to support young people waiting, wanting to fulfil their potential, but finding it hard to get work, or worried about their debts. Even the Prime Minister, even the Prime Minister sees this as a missed opportunity, lamenting that it is not, quote, "ideal".

I mean how bad does a budget have to be for the Prime Minister to disown it before we've even voted on it, Madam Deputy Speaker? They say, Madam Deputy Speaker, now we have it. Now we have it from Labour MPs themselves, this budget is as bad as Liz Truss's budget. That's true. The trouble is, the point is, Madam Deputy Speaker, that Liz Truss's period in office was short and sharp, and over in a moment.

The problem with this Labour government is the pain is long and we're still stuck with it, Madam Deputy Speaker. And on defence, my honourable friend, my right honourable friend, the Member for Wetherby and Easingwold, spoke yesterday of the genuine threat of war. Just days ago, the Government told us to prepare for war in a thousand days.

But at the Budget, the Chancellor said he need more time to work out how to fund defence. So, let's get this straight. The commitment to spend 3% on defence was a matter of principle for the Chancellor in the summer, but by this Budget, it had become a matter of inconvenience. How can anyone trust his word? He says he has a target for 3%, but no commitment and no plans.

The Chair of the Defence Select Committee, the honourable Member for Slough, called that "lamentable". And he is right. But opening the debate on Thursday, the Defence Secretary said he didn't care.

didn't care about the views of the Defence Select chair. What an arrogant dismissal from a minister barely 15 weeks into the job. No one in this Parliament has a monopoly of wisdom, least of all him. The OBR says spending will increase by over 100 billion to exceed 430 billion by the end of the forecast period, but the budget had no plans to bring the ballooning welfare bill under control,

and the Chancellor seemed confused, a little lost. In his speech last Wednesday, he said, quote, as the Prime Minister and I have both said, we will bring down the welfare bill,

and we will do it in a Labour way. The next day, on Radio 4, when asked if the welfare bill would be reduced before the next election, the Chancellor said,

"There will be a reduction in the benefits bill. We'll do it in a Labour way." That seemed pretty clear, yeah? But the Chancellor was then forced,

forced to clarify that when he said yes, he really meant to say no. He said it was not correct to say that we're going to bring the welfare bill down in this Parliament. So, there we have it, the Labour way to cut welfare:

"Yeah, but no, but yeah, but no, but yeah, but." As my honourable friend, the shadow business secretary said, "A Little Britain farce from a Little Britain Chancellor." And as my honourable friend the shadow chancellor said on Thursday, the UK Government's finances are walking along a cliff edge,

With our national debt at 100% of GDP and with Government continuing to tax and borrow more, he was right to do so. You don't help the disadvantaged in our society by dodging hard choices and going broke. You make their lives harder, much harder.

A Budget that ignores the warning signals and buries its head in the sand is a Budget that is deliberately increasing the risk to those least able to cope. Rather than cut borrowing, Labour plan to borrow nearly a quarter of a trillion pounds more over just the next 2 years, costing every British household an extra £476 per year in additional debt interest. That isn't smart.

That isn't fair. Not to this generation and certainly not to future generations. And yet, the Chancellor praised his fiscal discipline. But the Chancellor knows he is standing on quicksand. Let's be clear.

By voting through this budget tonight, Labour MPs are voting for real terms cuts to the schools budget, real terms cuts to the prisons budget, real terms cuts to adult social care. It's there in the documents in black and white.

But Labour MPs will not vote for real terms cuts. They don't have the backbone for tough decisions.

So, the Chancellor, the Chancellor will have to start to work on how to raise taxes yet again to fill the 49 billion hole in his finances. The British people should be under no illusion. A fourth tax-raising Labour budget lies ahead, with massive tax increases to fund Labour's addiction to borrowing, Labour's addiction to big government and Labour's addiction to more welfare. This budget is not a fair budget.

It raises taxes on savers for being prudent and reducing their dependency on others.

It raises taxes on people who rent out their properties so someone else can have a roof over their head. It snatches away tax relief for people who start a business not to become a billionaire but because it's their passion and they want to create just a small nest egg for when they retire. And it introduces new taxes when the tax burden is already far too high. A Conservative government would not shirk its responsibilities to make big decisions. We would take the hard decisions to reduce welfare, to improve the productivity of public services, to cut back on overseas aid and on the size of the civil service with 50p of every pound saved going to reduce our deficit under our golden economic rule.

A Conservative plan for governing now with a team with deep experience of the world outside politics and a leader with the backbone to see our country through to a more secure, more prosperous and fairer future.

07:18:59 - 07:19:05

Speaker 290

I call the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Emma Reynolds.

07:19:05 - 07:22:42

Emma Reynolds

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget provides breathing space now and fresh hope for the future, the focus of today's debate. And I would like to thank all honourable and right honourable members across this House for their contributions not only today but over the four days of the debate on this budget,

on the action that we are taking in government to steer Britain through the global economic storms, to kick-start good growth in every postcode, strengthen our national security, and to chart a new course for our country in the years ahead. Madam Deputy Speaker, many honourable members, including my honourable friend for Barrow and Furness and for Rossendale and Darwen, rightly stress the challenges that we are facing because of the storms in the global economy. Madam Deputy Speaker, we heard a lot from the opposition front bench today, most of it hot air, but not a word of apology for calling on this government to join the war in the Middle East that is driving up energy costs, inflation and the cost of government borrowing.

We cannot wish away these global economic storms. Instead, the Chancellor, my right honourable friend, has set out a course to steer this country through them.

That is why we have chosen to use some of the fiscal headroom established last year to absorb the impact of the Iran war, to protect the economy, British businesses and family budgets. And as my honourable friends for the Cities of London and Westminster and for Darlington rightly said, fiscal discipline underwrites every policy that this government makes. We will meet the fiscal rules in full, and for the first time, in the third year of the forecast. Last year, borrowing fell to its lowest level in six years as a percentage of GDP, and it continues to fall across the forecast. And we will not take any lectures from the shadow Chancellor or, indeed, the shadow Chief Secretary.

They like to claim that they were innocent bystanders who just happened to be Treasury ministers during the Liz Truss mini-budget. But of course, we all know that they were the architects of the mini-budget.

And still to this day the shadow Chancellor maintains, as recently as September, there were a lot of good things in the mini-budget. And still to this day the British people are paying the price for his failure. Liz Truss's stint in office might have been short-lived, but the impact was long-lasting. Madam Deputy Speaker, the contrast with this Labour government could not be clearer. I am proud that the IMF has said that the UK stands out as a country where, and I quote, "action to reduce the debt and deficit have been taken decisively", and they have said that we will have the lowest deficit in the G7 by 2029.

And this year, Madam Deputy Speaker, I will in a minute, I'll make a little bit of progress.

As my honourable friend for Macclesfield rightly said, the British economy has proven more resilient than many, including honourable members opposite, predicted, and indeed it has defied expectations. The Tories and Reform like to talk down our economy, but the fundamentals of the British economy are strong. Public investment is up.

Business investment is up to its highest level in 10 years. Productivity has finally turned a corner, and we had the joint fastest growth in the G7 in the first half of this year. I will give way.

07:22:42 - 07:23:06

John Hayes

To the honourable lady, she talked about people talking down the economy.

The Joseph Rowntree Trust say that Labour are overseeing the sharpest fall in living standards in 65 years. Now I wonder if the honourable lady thinks they're wrong, and if she does think they're wrong, how much is the government overseeing in terms of declining living standards?

07:23:06 - 07:23:40

Emma Reynolds

The last Parliament was the worst Parliament on living on record for living standards, and since the last election living standards have increased by 1.8%. But I would urge him to read the executive summary from the OBR that says as a net importer of energy, the rise in energy prices constitutes a negative terms of trade shock for the UK, which pushes up on inflation and lowers real whole household disposable income. Those are the headwinds the global headwinds that we are facing. Oh maybe. Go on then.

07:23:40 - 07:24:10

Graham Stuart

I'm grateful to the minister.

She will be aware that, like my right honourable friend, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation suggests that constituents of mine, families will be at least £440 worse off in this Parliament, and it will be the worst Parliament ever. No COVID, no new Ukraine energy crisis. So, can she answer can she answer the right honourable gentleman's question? Are they wrong or are they right?

07:24:10 - 07:30:17

Emma Reynolds

What I will say to the honourable gentleman is that wages under this government in the last two years have risen faster than they did in the first 10 years of their government. So, we will take no lectures for the honourable gentleman or his party. Against this backdrop, the chancellor is providing immediate breathing space for families and businesses.

Our £100 household energy payment would support 20 million households in England, 80% of households, and this will be paid for by a time-limited 3% increase to the bank surcharge that the party opposite are going to oppose in the lobbies tonight. And we are going further on bills by extending the removal of VAT on electricity until July, extending the 5p cut on fuel duty, and next year, we will abolish gas standing charges. And I'd like to thank my honorable friends for Camborne and Redruth, Bracknell, and many other honorable friends for welcoming this energy support package. Overall, in '26-'27, households in England are estimated to benefit by around £160 on average from the support we are providing on energy, according to new analysis out this morning. Households on the lowest incomes are expected to benefit the most, with the bottom 20% benefiting by around £230 on average, almost four times as much as the top 20%.

And because we know that higher energy costs are a challenge for business, too, we are reducing bills up to 25% more for more than 10,000 eligible businesses from next April through the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme, as mentioned by my right honourable friend, the business secretary, earlier today. This will help to support the British firms at the heart of the future of Britain's reindustrialisation. Beyond energy, we are providing support to families by giving self-employed dads paid paternity leave, and I would like to thank my honourable friends for Reading West and Mid Berkshire, and Dagenham and Rainham, for welcoming this measure.

And we are backing British businesses and high streets, and I would like to correct the record here.

Of course, the brilliant men and women across the country who run small businesses are working people. I thank them for their contribution to our local economies and our local high streets: the bakeries, the cafés, the restaurants, the beauticians, the hairdressers, and the local pub and so many more. In the first week of this new government in July, we cut an extra 20% off business rates for pubs, social clubs, and live music venues from April next year. And I thank my honourable friend for Hyndburn in her constituency for the invitation to the pub in I look forward to coming to eat the goulash.

And at and in this budget, the Chancellor has gone further by taking 70,000 more small retail, hospitality and leisure properties out of paying business rates altogether. For all other businesses in these sectors, we are freezing their business rates in real terms. And I thank my honourable friend, my neighbour for Aylesbury, for what she said about this change in business rates, and the 2,000 small businesses on our high street across Buckinghamshire, including in Aylesbury and indeed in High Wycombe, that will be taken out of paying business taxes business rates altogether. And to pay for this, as my honourable friend for Heywood and Middleton North mentioned, we are increasing machine games duty for higher-stakes machines, and we are carving out adult gaming centres and vape shops from business rate relief. And we are ensuring online marketplaces collect and pay VAT that they should be doing already.

Many honourable members and right honourable members have mentioned young people during this debate.

We want young people to have the chance to earn, learn and get on. We have a moral duty as the Chancellor has rightly said to this next generation. We are raising pay for low-paid workers while being careful not to price young people out of that crucial first job. We've also expanded access to work experience and record funding for apprenticeships. We've introduced a scheme for first-time buyers in this budget and capped student loan interest rates at 6%.

Madam Deputy Speaker, my honourable friends for Lichfield and Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare mentioned the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme and I want to address this in my remarks. It is this Labour government that has returned the investment fund to the members of the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme in a previous budget.

And at this budget, the Chancellor has rightly put in place a measure to make sure that not a penny of the surpluses going forward will come back to the government. 100% of surpluses will go to the members of that scheme. And on the outstanding issue of the guarantor's fund, the Chancellor has also been clear that we will go on to ensure the full transfer. Alongside the decisions to provide breathing space now, the Chancellor also took action for the long-term to kick-start growth across the country. This is the only way to keep Britain's families and Britain's finances secure for the long term.

That begins first with delivering the most ambitious devolution package in a generation, Madam Deputy Speaker.

We are putting power in the hands of local leaders because they know the right levers to pull to drive growth and job creation in their local areas. Second, this budget delivers radical reform of our energy system because our priority is to bring energy costs down to help British business compete and British households to cope. We will only buy and build in a minute new projects when they lower bills and when they can connect to the grid. We will further break the grip of international gas prices on our bills by moving more of our old renewables on to fixed-price contacts, and we will build cheaper, faster grid connections through GB Grid. I will give way.

07:30:17 - 07:30:29

Benedicta Wera Hobhouse

Having just said that the Government wants to support households, but also move away from expensive fossil fuels, why the cuts to the Boiler Upgrade Scheme and the Warm Homes Plan?

07:30:30 - 07:30:31

Chief Secretary.

07:30:31 - 07:33:24

Emma Reynolds

Well, we are securing energy in our country, and we are giving people an energy support package, as I've outlined earlier in my contribution. And crucially, we are putting an end to the Tory practice of loading levy costs onto bills, because unlike them, we are determined to bring down energy bills for families. Third, we are supporting companies to start, scale, and stay in the UK. We're introducing a new Founders Relief for founders of high-growth companies and a new Young Entrepreneurs Allowance to cover a year of living costs for young founders while they turn their businesses, turn their ideas into businesses. And crucially, as recommended by the Women in Tech Taskforce, we are establishing a new scaleup programme to support female founders.

The British Business Bank will also double its commitments to women-led businesses.

Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have taken action to tackle the big challenges facing our country, and most importantly, on defence. The first duty of any government is to keep the country safe. I am proud that this Labour government has driven the biggest boost in defence spending since the end of the Cold War. And at the Budget last week, we took difficult decisions to reprioritise budgets across Whitehall to fund the £15 billion defence investment plan in full. And at the spending review next year, we will set out the details of how we will meet our NATO commitment to spend 3.5% of GDP on defence by 2035.

And, crucially, this includes setting a target date for 3% in 2030.

This is a credible path to the UK meeting our NATO commitments, not my words, but the words of the NATO Secretary General, Mark Rutte, who has welcomed our plans. Madam Deputy Speaker, I know that there's plenty of disagreement in this House on different measures in the budget, but one area where I think we do agree is that we stand shoulder to shoulder with the people and government of Ukraine. This budget provides £10 billion of additional economic and military support for Ukraine. It means that together we send a clear message to Moscow: Britain will stand with Uk- with Ukraine for as long as it takes. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a budget built on fiscal discipline.

It charts a way through difficult global economic headwinds.

It provides breathing space for families and businesses now. It kick-starts work on the big changes needed to put this country on a better course on devolution, on energy, and on defence, and it will deliver good growth in every postcode and strengthen our national security. This is a budget built on Labour choices, breathing space today and fresh hope for the future.

07:33:24 - 07:33:36

Speaker 293

The question is the motion relating to income tax charge, as on the Order Paper. As many of that opinion, say "aye". Of the contrary, "no". The ayes have it. The ayes have it.

07:33:33 - 07:33:34

We now come to motion number three on income tax default, property, and savings rates. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Of the contrary, "No"? As many that are of that opinion, say, "Aye". The question is that the motion be agreed to.

07:33:34 - 07:33:35

Of the contrary, "No"?

07:33:35 - 07:34:02

Speaker 293

Division! Clear the lobby. These motions are set out in a separate paper, distributed with today's Order Paper. We now come to motion number two on income tax main rates. The question is that the motion be agreed to.

07:33:36 - 07:34:02

Speaker 293

I am now required under Standing Order No. 51(3) to put successively, without further debate, the question on each of the Ways and Means motions numbered 2 to 108 and the Money motion on which the Finance Bill is to be brought in.

As many that are of that opinion, say, "Aye".

07:35:12 - 07:35:20

Speaker 294

Colleagues should be seated. The question is as on the Order Paper: as many of that opinion say aye?

07:35:21 - 07:35:21

Of the contrary no?

07:35:22 - 07:35:34

Speaker 293

Tellers for the ayes are Emma Foody and Laurence Turner, tellers for the noes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas. I can't see, Sir Geoffrey? Tellers for the noes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas.

07:47:24 - 07:47:30

Speaker 295

Order.

07:47:30 - 07:47:40

Speaker 296

The Ayes to the right: 337. The Noes to the left: 180.

07:47:40 - 07:48:10

Speaker 293

The Ayes to the right: 337. The Noes to the left: 180.

So, the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Unlock. With the leave of the House, I will put the questions on motions 4 to 6 together. The question is that motions 4 to 6 be agreed to. As many of that opinion say aye.

07:48:11 - 07:48:24

Speaker 293

Of the contrary, no. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We now come to motion number seven on increase in rate of banking surcharge for temporary period. The question is that the motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion say aye.

07:48:25 - 07:48:27

Speaker 298

Of the contrary, no.

07:48:27 - 07:48:28

Speaker 297

No.

07:48:28 - 07:49:12

Speaker 299

Clear the lobby. Division. Colleagues observing the chamber will see that I'm on my feet and they should be seated. The question is as on the Order Paper. As many that opinion say aye.

Of the contrary, no.

07:49:12 - 07:49:12

Tellers for the ayes are Emma Foody and Laurence Turner, tellers for the noes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas.

08:02:07 - 08:02:13

Speaker 300

Order.

08:02:13 - 08:02:23

Speaker 301

The ayes to the right: 420; the noes to the left: 105.

08:02:23 - 08:02:50

Speaker 293

The ayes to the right: 420; the noes to the left: 105. So the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Unlock. We now come to motion number eight on capital gains tax, business asset disposal relief.

The question is that the motion be agreed to. As many that are of that opinion say aye.

08:02:51 - 08:02:52

The contrary no.

08:02:53 - 08:03:28

Speaker 304

Division. Clear the lobby. Colleagues should be seated, Sir John Hayes. Afzal Khan, you're still standing. George, marvelous.

08:03:28 - 08:03:31

Speaker 303

The question is as on the order paper, as many that are of that opinion say aye.

08:03:32 - 08:03:34

Speaker 302

No.

08:03:32 - 08:03:32

Of the contrary no.

08:03:34 - 08:03:34

The tellers for the ayes are Emma Foody and Laurence Turner, tellers for the noes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas.

08:14:23 - 08:14:28

Speaker 305

Order.

08:14:28 - 08:14:38

Speaker 296

The ayes to the right 348, the noes to the left 176.

08:14:38 - 08:15:17

Speaker 293

The ayes to the right 348, the noes to the left 176. So the ayes have it.

The ayes have it. Unlock. With the leave of the House, I will put the question on motions nine to 14 together. The question is that motions nine to 14 be agreed to. As many in that opinion say aye.

Of the contrary, no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to motion number 15 on employment visas. The question is that the motion be agreed to.

As many in that opinion say aye.

Of the contrary no.

08:15:17 - 08:15:19

Speaker 307

No.

08:15:19 - 08:15:45

Speaker 304

Division. Clear the lobby. The question is as on the order paper. As many of that opinion say aye.

08:15:46 - 08:15:47

Of the contrary no.

08:15:47 - 08:15:49

Speaker 306

No.

08:15:49 - 08:15:53

Speaker 308

Tellers for the ayes... Tellers for the ayes are Emma Foody and Laurence Turner, tellers for the noes are Richard Tice and Jim Shannon.

08:28:17 - 08:28:23

Speaker 309

Order.

08:28:23 - 08:28:33

Speaker 296

The Ayes to the right, 414, the Noes to the left, 106.

08:28:33 - 08:29:01

Speaker 293

The Ayes to the right: 414. The Noes to the left: 106. So the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Unlock. With the leave of the House, I will put questions on motions 16 to 54 together.

The question is that motions 16 to 54 be agreed to. As many that are of that opinion say aye.

08:29:01 - 08:29:03

Speaker 310

Aye.

08:29:03 - 08:29:17

Speaker 293

Of the contrary, no. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We now come to motion number 55 on value added tax electric vehicle charging. The question is that the motion be agreed to. As many that are of that opinion say aye.

08:29:18 - 08:29:19

Of the contrary, "no".

08:29:19 - 08:29:22

Speaker 311

No.

08:29:22 - 08:30:08

Speaker 313

Division, clear the lobby. Colleagues observing the chamber. Ms Suella Braverman. The question is as on the order paper, as many that opinion say "aye".

08:30:09 - 08:30:11

Speaker 312

No.

08:30:09 - 08:30:09

Of the contrary, "no".

08:30:11 - 08:30:11

Tellers for the "ayes" are Emma Foody and Laurence Turner, tellers for the "noes" are Will Forster and Lee Dillon.

08:40:10 - 08:40:17

Speaker 295

Order.

08:40:17 - 08:40:26

Speaker 296

The ayes to the right, 324, the noes to the left, 88.

08:40:26 - 08:41:08

Speaker 293

The ayes to the right, 324. The noes to the left, 88. So the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Unlock.

With the leave of the House, I will put the questions on motions 56 to 75 together. The question is that motions 56 to 75 be agreed to. As many of that opinion, say "aye". Of the contrary, "no". The ayes have it.

The ayes have it. We now come to motion number 76 on rates of alcohol duty. The question is that the motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion, say "aye".

Of the contrary, "no".

No.

08:41:08 - 08:41:57

Speaker 304

Division, clear the lobby. Colleagues observing the chamber should note that I'm on my feet and should be seated. Sir John Hayes, Graham Stuart, that's not really a seat, that's kind of a curious perch. Marvelous, and the question is, as on the order paper, as many as that opinion say "aye".

08:41:57 - 08:41:58

Of the contrary, "no".

08:41:59 - 08:42:01

Speaker 314

Tellers for the Ayes are Emma Foody and Laurence Turner. Tellers for the Noes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas.

08:52:16 - 08:52:20

Speaker 315

Order.

08:52:20 - 08:52:30

Speaker 316

The ayes to the right, 331, the noes to the left, 181.

08:52:30 - 08:53:13

Speaker 293

The ayes to the right, 331, the noes to the left, 181. So the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Unlock. With leave of the House, I will put the questions on motions 77 to 85 together. The question is that motions 77 to 85 be agreed to.

As many that opinion say aye. Contrary, no.

The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. We now come to motion number 86 on high value council tax surcharge. The question is that the motion be agreed to. As many that are of that opinion say, "Aye". To the contrary, "No".

08:53:13 - 08:53:45

Speaker 304

Division, clear the lobby. Entering the Chamber will know that I'm on my feet and should be seated, Ms Rachel Gilmour? Marvellous.

08:53:45 - 08:53:49

Speaker 317

The question is as on the Order Paper. As many of that opinion say aye.

08:53:50 - 08:53:51

Of the contrary, no.

08:53:52 - 08:53:54

Speaker 318

Tellers for the ayes are Emma Foody and Laurence Turner. Tellers for the noes are David Simmonds and Bradley Thomas.

09:03:59 - 09:04:05

Speaker 320

Order.

09:04:05 - 09:04:15

Speaker 316

The Ayes to the right, 327.

The noes to the left, 161.

09:04:15 - 09:05:01

Speaker 293

The ayes to the right, 327. The noes to the left, 161. So the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Unlock. With the leave of the House, I will put the question on the remaining Ways and Means motions together.

The question is that motions 87 to 108 be agreed to. As many as that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. The question is that the motion relating to finance money be agreed to.

As many as that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. The ayes have it, the ayes have it. Bill ordered to be brought in upon the foregoing resolutions.

09:05:01 - 09:05:05

Speaker 321

Who will prepare and bring in the bill?

09:05:05 - 09:05:41

Speaker 60

The Chairman of Ways and Means, the Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Emma Reynolds, Lucy Rigby, Dan Tomlinson, Torsten Bell, and myself.

09:05:41 - 09:05:44

Speaker 322

Finance Bill.

09:05:44 - 09:05:46

Speaker 323

Second reading what day?

09:05:47 - 09:05:49

Speaker 326

Tomorrow.

09:05:49 - 09:05:54

Speaker 324

Hear.

09:05:54 - 09:06:03

Speaker 293

Right, that is the end of that piece of business today and we're moving on. Point of order, Daisy Cooper.

09:06:03 - 09:06:46

Daisy Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The right honorable member for Fareham and Waterlooville claimed twice during today's debate that 27 young non-EU migrants have been hired for every young Brit since 2020. But the reality is very different. The report the honorable member was referring to has been debunked. And the actual numbers of employed young people, not the increases in the number of payrolled young people are used, then 10 UK under-25s are employed for every one non-EU national.

So Madam Deputy Speaker, could I please ask for your advice on how members of this House can be asked to correct the record?

09:06:46 - 09:07:33

Speaker 293

I'm grateful to the honorable member for giving notice of a point of order. I take it that she has informed the right honorable member for Wareham and Woburn, but I can see she's nodding that she has, before she referred to it. The chair is not responsible for the accuracy of honorable members' speeches, and any member who wants to correct the record should contact Hansard, as she's most definitely got her point on the record today. Now, I'll let the front benches shuffle over. With the leave of the House, I will group the next SIs together.

Motion number three on transport, motion number four on electricity, motion number five on housing,

09:07:33 - 09:07:36

Speaker 329

No.

09:07:36 - 09:07:39

Speaker 327

Off to do, oh so sorry, forgive me.

09:07:39 - 09:07:42

Speaker 330

I'll be taking these individually.

09:07:42 - 09:07:46

Speaker 331

Motion number three on transport, Minister to move?

09:07:46 - 09:07:47

I beg to move.

09:07:47 - 09:07:56

Speaker 293

The question is as on the Order Paper, as many of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No"? The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number four on electricity, Minister to move?

09:07:56 - 09:07:57

I beg to move.

09:07:57 - 09:08:08

Speaker 332

The question is as on the Order Paper, as many of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary? The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Motion number five on housing, Minister to move?

09:08:08 - 09:08:09

I beg to move.

09:08:09 - 09:08:22

Speaker 333

The question is as on the Order Paper, as many of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No"? Division. The division is deferred until tomorrow. Motion number six on housing, Minister to move?

09:08:22 - 09:08:23

I beg to move.

09:08:23 - 09:08:27

Speaker 328

The question is as on the Order Paper, as many of that opinion say, "Aye".

Of the contrary No?

09:08:27 - 09:08:29

Speaker 334

No.

09:08:29 - 09:08:35

Speaker 293

The division is deferred until tomorrow. Motion number seven on sanctions, minister to move?

09:08:35 - 09:08:36

I beg to move.

09:08:36 - 09:08:39

Speaker 336

The question is as on the order paper, as many of that opinion say Aye.

09:08:40 - 09:08:46

Speaker 337

Of the contrary No? The Ayes have it. The Ayes have it.

09:08:46 - 09:08:48

Speaker 335

I beg to move that this House do now adjourn.

09:08:48 - 09:09:00

Speaker 293

The question is that this House do now adjourn, and I call Freddie van Mierlo on the future of minibus drivers for community transport services. Freddie van Mierlo.

09:09:00 - 09:11:43

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to start, if I may, by talking about FISH, but not, Madam Deputy Speaker, the aquatic kind you'll be pleased to know given the topic of this debate.

FISH stands for Friendship in Sickness and Health, and it's a wonderful charity in the village of Sonning Common in my constituency of Henley and Thame. Its volunteers, among other things, run a minibus service for older residents and residents with disabilities to get about the villages in my area. Their minibus Their minibuses are perfect for providing a people who otherwise would really struggle to leave the house with a trip out to the shops or to the market. Morrisons, I'm told, remains ever popular, and the extra space on the bus is vital for bringing back all the shopping. FISH are not alone either in my constituency.

Henley Handybus, supported by Henley Town Council, operate daily, and the Woodcote Volunteers host events provided providing transport to their monthly tea parties. But it was Sonning Common's FISH group that brought to my attention the issue of D1 licenses when they met with me in October here in Westminster.

The Minister is likely to be familiar with the issue, but I'll briefly describe it in the words used to explain it to me. A category D1 license gives a driver permission to drive a minibus with up to 16 passengers up to 7.5 tonnes. Prior to 1997, all new licenses were issued with this category as standard. In 1997, that changed and now in now D1 minibus driving licenses require an additional test. This happened for very understandable reasons to enhance safety and it also brought us in line with other similar countries.

But it also created a problem.

Community transport services have become dependent on an ever decreasing pool of drivers who qualified prior to 1997. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am confident that means neither yourself, the Minister or I have D1 licences. The reality today is that more than half of community transport operators report insufficient D1 drivers to meet demand. According to the Community Transport Association, 81% of community transport operators are not confident they will have enough D1 drivers to sustain their services in as little as three years' time. What's even worse, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that once a driver gets to the age of 70, they automatically lose their D1 category licence unless they apply to retain it.

They must do that every three years. Again, this is for very understandable reasons and sensible safety precautions. But the upshot is that 99% of all D1 licences in Great Britain are held by drivers in a narrow age band of 47 to 69.

I'll happily give way.

09:11:43 - 09:12:19

Jim Shannon

Madam Deputy Speaker, first of all, can I commend the honorable gentleman for Henley and Thame for bringing this forward. He's brought up an incredibly important issue. Certainly, in my constituency of Strangford, local independent bus companies provide an absolute lifeline for the vulnerable, for the elderly, for the school children. Yet these operators are facing incredible pressures from rising fuel costs, regulatory burdens, and an acute shortage of qualified D1 licensed drivers. If we are to prevent rural communities from being cut off, does the honorable member agree the government must step in with targeted support to assist our local operators with driver recruitment, training, and operational funding UK-wide?

09:12:19 - 09:12:31

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Well, I thank the honorable member for his intervention. He mentions D1 licenses and also a wider range of issues that face community transport organizations, and I'm sure the minister will have heard him. Yes.

09:12:31 - 09:13:09

Manuela Perteghella

I thank my honorable friend for giving way. Recently, I hosted a roundtable of community transport organizations chaired by VASA, which operates in my constituency and is supported by Stratford-on-Avon District Council. And they are a lifeline for residents, often elderly residents, who otherwise struggle to reach medical appointments and other services. Does my honorable friend agree that community transport should be recognized as a core part of our transport network, as essential infrastructure, especially in rural areas, and should be embedded in future national and local transport policies?

09:13:09 - 09:13:48

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

I thank my honorable friend for her very sensible intervention, and my own local authority in Oxfordshire also heavily supports community transport organizations, and I am sure her proposals were also heard by the minister.

Over the next five years, more than 3 million D1 licences are likely to be lost as drivers reach 70, equivalent to one in five of all D1 licences. We are therefore facing a ticking time bomb as qualified drivers age out at the top, and there are not enough replenished from below. Without action from the Government, there are serious consequences for the future viability of community transport. Yes, I give way.

09:13:48 - 09:14:22

Tessa Munt

I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way.

I'm a massive supporter of Mendip Community Transport, and in fact my village has a community transport minibus, which is absolutely essential lifeline, particularly in a rural area where we have no buses. I'm sure the honourable gentleman is aware, and I wonder what he thinks about the fact that if you want to undertake a driving test, a minibus driving test in my area, you have to travel some long distance and it can cost you up to £2,000 for that test, which seems extraordinarily expensive.

09:14:22 - 09:15:56

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

I thank my honourable friend for that addition to the debate. I was aware of the cost, which I will come on to, but I hadn't been made aware previously of the distance that some drivers may need to travel to carry out a test and that will be an additional barrier to enabling volunteers to do what they love doing most. Now if you might reasonably ask, Madam Deputy Speaker, why don't people just take the test? So, test is a perfectly reasonable thing to ask someone driving 7.5 tonnes of fast-moving metal to pass. I think we all accept that.

No one is disputing it. But it's how difficult that test is and how costly it is that matters.

How proportionate is the test to the social benefits of community transport? How easy are we making it for people who want to do good in their community, who want to give up their time for others to do so? Because if we make it too difficult, they'll just say what's the point, and move on to something else. At the moment, drivers must pass an additional theory test, a practical test, and a medical assessment, all to the tune of up to £2,000. Setting a cost of up to £2,000 might make sense in terms of passing on the administrative costs of the testing regime to the customer.

Rationally, I can see how we might have got to this point. Though the Minister may be able to confirm if a profit is made on the testing regime, or not. And certainly, if it is the case, I would ask if he looks into it. But I would argue the social and economic bene- benefit of having more minibus drivers able to run local community services should be taken into account. Rural

Yes, I will.

09:15:56 - 09:16:34

John Slinger

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way, and I commend him for bringing this really important debate to the chamber. And I'm listening intently to what he's saying, and I will be listening intently to what the minister says, because I've seen firsthand in my constituency, the Volunteer Friends charity, who actually run a MediCar transport service and supported shopping service. And the issues that he's raising show that there are problems in this sector, and we need to do everything we possibly can to facilitate people to volunteer to help the community. And I've seen with my own eyes just how important this is.

09:16:34 - 09:19:21

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

Well, can I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention?

And his intervention highlights just how widespread this issue is and how keenly it's felt in all corners of the country. Rural constituencies like mine rely on volunteer transport to plug the gap between private motor vehicle usage and commercial for-profit bus companies. Many rural routes are not profit-making and have no hope of doing so. The alternative is clear. If we let community transport die a slow death, we will see more social isolation with all the health and social care costs associated with that.

We will see councils come under pressure to step in with tax-payer funded schemes and subsidies at a time when the Government has cut my own local authority's funding, it's hard to see how that can happen.

And why should it, when we have a pool of people willing to volunteer? And for the volunteers, it's rewarding work that gives meaning to people's lives, it provides an opportunity to give back and be part of something really special. And I'd like to put on the record, therefore, that I'm sincerely grateful for all the hard work that volunteers put in everyday and the contribution they make. Two of these wonderful volunteers are John Pearman, FISH transport coordinator, and David Whitehead, the chair of FISH Volunteer Centre.

The pair do excellent work to coordinate half a dozen drivers and look out for opportunities to recruit new volunteers. John told me about how he found three potential new drivers, but once they had understood the cost and time needed to update their license to D1 status, all withdrew their interest. This is even with the offer from Sonning Common Health Centre for free medical testing to volunteer minibus drivers. And so, David and John completely rely on the 47 to 69 age band. That band becomes ever narrower each year.

When thinking about how to move forwards, the Government doesn't have to start from scratch. In 2022, a call for evidence on driving licensing

took views on the minibus licensing regime from over 2,000 respondents. Although most respondents supported a change in current licensing arrangements, no substantial actions have been taken to improve the status since then. The Government has pointed concerned parties towards exemptions that already exist for D1 licences. However, the CTA note that these exemptions make no meaningful change in availability of drivers. The exemptions allow those with a standard driving licence post 1997 to drive a lighter minibus of up to 3.5 tonnes.

However, nearly three quarters of all vehicles in the UK's community transport fleet are minibuses with between nine and 16 seats, often with weighty accessibility features.

Larger vehicles give local charities, community groups and social enterprises the flexibility they need to operate effectively with more affordable costs.

Will the honourable gentleman give way again?

09:19:22 - 09:19:47

Tessa Munt

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way a second time. I would just like to point out also that there are a number of community minibuses that are now run on they're electric vehicles, and of course the batteries are very much heavier, and that takes them automatically along with a lot of the accessibility equipment, like wheelchair lifts, takes their weight way over the three-and-a-half-tonne limit.

09:19:47 - 09:21:46

Frederick Isaac Van Mierlo

I thank my honourable friend for that intervention, and of course, we want to be encouraging a shift to more sustainable, greener forms of travel, and that should be enabled within the while still maintaining a good cohort of drivers.

I won't take any more interventions because I know we have to move on. More than one in 10 organisations have changed their service delivery model, often replacing conventional minibuses with cars or lightweight minibuses, resulting in lower capacity, increased costs and operational complexity. However, drivers of these lighter vehicles are not eligible to be paid, unlike the standard D1 licence, adding further to the burden. So how can we help community transport? The CTA has put forward a proposal.

It's not a blanket minibus licence for all drivers, and not a return to 1997. They propose a targeted intervention to allow drivers to acquire a D1 licence to drive a minibus for non-profit organisations. The licence would draw on minibus learning programs that already exist, and require the driver to complete a DVSA-accredited, training-based upgrade similar to the Minibus Driver Awareness Scheme, MiDAS.

MIDAS is a national programme of quality-assured education and training for the community transport sector. This approach was supported by resident by respondents to the government's 2022 call for evidence. The CTA proposal requires an online theory test, a short practical session, on-road assessment and medical assessments, but crucially with a cost of just under £300. The proposal allows numbers of drivers to be increased in a safe way using an established information and learning assessment. Perhaps the minister, in his remarks, can therefore say if he has considered the CTA proposals.

And of course, I would caveat that with I'm not a road expert, and the CTA's pro- proposals may not be 100% the answer, but surely the government can come up with a regime that achieves both aims: safe roads and a thriving community transport sector. I look forward to the minister's remarks and addressing the points raised.

09:21:46 - 09:21:50

Speaker 344

Minister, if you're ready, Minister Simon Lightwood.

09:21:50 - 09:28:20

Simon Lightwood

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I begin by congratulating the honorable gentleman, the member for Henley and Thame, on securing this debate and on raising this important subject. I'm grateful for him giving the House the opportunity to reflect on the enormously valuable contribution that community transport makes to communities across the country. And I want to begin by putting on record this Government's strong support for the community transport sector and our appreciation for the staff and volunteers who make those services possible. Can I also pay tribute to Fish in this place for doing a fin-tastic job.

They really do make a splash for all the right reasons. They are efficiently doing a great job in this community. He did give me a heads up that he'd be mentioning them. I couldn't resist it.

Look, on a more serious matter, the community transport can provide a real lifeline, particularly for older and disabled people, those who are vulnerable or isolated, and people living in rural areas where other public transport options are limited. It helps people get to work, in education, to health care, and other essential services. And just as importantly, it allows people to see friends and family, to take part in community life, and maintain their independence. The scale of that contribution should not be underestimated.

Community transport operators provide around 13.8 million passenger journeys each year. This is ultimately not just a debate about driving license categories or regulations, it's about people's ability to get where they need to go and to remain connected to the communities in which they live. That's why the government provides practical support to the sector. The department provides the Community Transport Association with an annual grant to support its work with its members and the wider sector. We also make available up to £3.8 million each year to eligible community transport operators through the bus service operators grant, helping operators with their running costs.

A 60% uplift has been added to community transport claims until the 31st of March 2027 with further support during the current period of increased fuel costs. But our support is not simply about direct financial assistance.

We want community transport to be properly recognized as part of the wider transport network. We encourage local authorities to consider community transport within their local transport planning and to look at how those services can complement conventional fixed route bus services and improve connectivity. That is particularly important in places where community transport fills gaps that other transport services cannot easily fill. I turn to the specific issue that the honourable member has raised today: the rules governing the driving of minibuses. I recognise very clearly the concern within the community transport sector about the availability of drivers with category D1 entitlement.

Prior to 1997, Madam Deputy Speaker, someone obtaining a car licence was automatically granted the restricted category D1 entitlement commonly known as D1 101, allowing them to drive a minibus where it was not being driven for hire or reward. The automatic entitlement ceased for people passing their car test from the 1st of January 1997. Since then, drivers have generally needed to pass an additional test to obtain a category D1 entitlement, although there are limited circumstances in which a holder of a category B car licence may drive a minibus without a full D1 licence. The practical consequences are that drivers who retain a category D1 through those so-called grandfather rights are gradually getting older and the number of drivers with D1 is gradually reducing.

And I understand the concern that this creates for community transport operators that have traditionally relied upon this cohort of drivers. The CTA has made the case strongly that a diminishing pool of D1 drivers is making recruitment more difficult and imposes additional costs on organisations which need to train new drivers. I want to acknowledge the constructive work with the Association that has been done in bringing this issue to government and to Parliament during Community Transport Week in October. The CTA held an event here in Parliament and launched its white paper setting out its case for changes to licensing arrangements. The department is aware of that proposal and we're actively reviewing it.

I recognise both the seriousness of the concern behind that work and the effort that the CTA has made to develop a practical proposal. At the same time, however, the government must consider any proposed change to driver licensing arrangements very carefully.

This consideration also takes place within the wider framework of the Government's Road Safety Strategy, which will be published earlier this year. The strategy reiterates the Government's commitment to reducing those killed and seriously injured on our roads and to ensuring that road safety impacts are properly considered when developing transport policy. Any changes to driver licensing arrangements therefore need to be assessed not only in terms of accessibility, workforce availability and operational benefits, but also in terms of their implications on road safety outcomes. And I had a look before coming here tonight.

The last full year of pass rates for D1 in 2025,

there were 3,069 tests taken, 2,511 were passed, but 552 failed that D1 test. So, those without this D1 qualification would potentially be driving minibuses. So, you can see how important safety is when considering the implications of any changes. And of course, minibuses can carry up to 16 passengers. In addition to the driver, they can weigh up to 5 tonnes and be driven at speeds of up to 70 mph.

The responsibility placed on the person driving such a vehicle is therefore different from that involved in driving a private car. And for many of the passengers who depend upon community transport are themselves older, disabled or otherwise vulnerable.

So, whilst I absolutely recognise the pressures facing operators, road and passenger safety must remain at the heart of our consideration of any changes to the licensing regime. I will indeed.

09:28:20 - 09:28:36

Tessa Munt

I'm grateful for giving way. Can I ask him how many accidents there've been involving community minibuses in the last two, three years, please? And if he doesn't, might he be able to write to me with that information? I realize it's a very serious matter. I just wondered how many incidences there were.

09:28:36 - 09:28:37

Minister Lightwood.

09:28:37 - 09:31:15

Simon Lightwood

I will commit to write to the honourable lady on that matter, I don't have that information to hand. But of course what I've said doesn't mean that the government should close its mind to reform, quite the contrary. But it does mean that we must be satisfied that changes designed to make it easy to obtain the necessary entitlement don't introduce unacceptable risks for minibus passengers or for other road users. That balance between flexibility and safety, Madam Deputy Speaker, is not a new question. In 2022, the previous government held a substantial call for evidence looking at potential reforms to driver licensing regimes.

One of the questions it considered was specifically whether people holding a category B car licence should be granted entitlement to drive category D1 minibuses. The review ran between August and October 2022 and deliberately sought evidence about whether reforms could widen the pool of minibus drivers while maintaining the safe use of our roads. The response demonstrated significant support for the change, but that is not by itself the same thing as evidence that the change can be made safely. The Department's assessment of that exercise was that, while there was strong support for extending driving licence entitlements, the evidence presented was not sufficient to allow us to fully understand and assess the associated road safety risks. Now, I understand that the Community Transport Association does not agree that the evidence currently available justifies maintaining the existing position.

That evidence gap is, however, important. It is why the department's continued to say that any potential relaxation of the D1 requirements need to be considered alongside the implications for road safety. But I do not want the honorable member to take from what I've said that the Government is insensitive to the problem that he's described, far from it. We recognise the demographic issue affecting holders of D1 grandfather rights. We recognise what community transport operators are telling us about recruiting drivers, and we recognise the arguments that the costs and the practicalities with obtaining a D1 entitlement maybe particularly challenging for small, community-based and not-for-profit organisations.

Through its proposal for reform, the Community Transport Association believes it can address those pressures while providing appropriate safeguards. We will consider that contribution seriously.

But we will also continue to place passenger and road safety at the centre of our consideration. I hope Members from across the House will agree that those two objectives of supporting the sustainability of community transport and ensuring that people can travel safely should not be regarded as opposing ambitions. Our task now is to determine how best to secure both. Thank you.

09:31:15 - 09:31:21

Speaker 293

The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as that opinion, say "aye". The "ayes" have it. The "ayes" have it. Order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.