Social Housing Bill

29 October 2026

Social Housing Bill House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:01 - 00:18
Speaker 5
Shall we commence today's proceedings with the consideration of the Bill with group 24, new clause 1, with which it will be convenient to take new clause 34 and new clause 4.  Gideon Amos to move new clause 1. 
00:18 - 00:44
Speaker 8
Thank you, Sir Roger.  It's a pleasure to serve on the committee with you in the chair.  I have pleasure in moving new clause 1, which would be a strategy for the provision of 150,000 new social homes a year in England.  That is our Liberal Democrat target.  We believe that we welcome the government's commitments so far to funding and supporting the delivery of social homes. 
00:44 - 01:17
Speaker 6
It's of key importance.  In fact, we welcome those proposals a lot more than we welcome some of the proposals for the planning system on private housing development.  But in terms of social homes, which is the focus of this amendment, we need a significant target.  And so far, the government has not put a statutory target, or indeed a clear target at all, for the delivery of social homes.  The National Housing Federation and Shelter say that at least 90,000 more social homes per year are needed. 
01:17 - 01:29
Speaker 2
Why do we go to 150,000?  Because social homes should not just be for the most excluded, the most desperate, the most challenged in our society.  They should be for working people who are in low-paid jobs who cannot afford... 
01:29 - 01:30
Will he give way? 
01:30 - 01:31
Of course I'll give way. 
01:31 - 02:12
Speaker 15
I thank the honorable member for giving way.  And I hesitate to ask him perhaps a slightly difficult question.  So earlier in the proceedings, and he is a very nice man and does a very good job, but I note that he has previously said that national housing targets should not be dictated by Whitehall and that the government's actual housing targets are over the top and that a targeted approach to housing is unreasonable.  Wouldn't he agree that what the government is doing is in line with his previous comments and will actually achieve more social and affordable housing by overhauling the funding mechanisms for housing and also by breaking down the planning barriers, and that that's a better approach, as he would have previously agreed himself? 
02:12 - 03:26
Speaker 7
I very much welcome the honorable lady's question about the details of Liberal Democrat policy, which I shall be delighted to expound upon.  Frankly, the challenge I was making there was to the government's overall target for homes, which are mainly market homes, mainly private homes.  So we have situations in Taunton where thousands of homes will be imposed on a community that won't be able to afford them, won't have any access to them, and won't be for local people.  Those targets are causing, alongside the planning reforms, which seem to celebrate a confrontational, I think the Labour Party called it a blockers versus builders approach.  The idea that that will somehow lead to more community acceptance of housing development is a wrong-headed notion. 

And that is why we believe the overall housing target needs to be based...  I'll finish my remarks on this point.  The overall housing target needs to be based on household projections as it was once, rather than the current standard method.  However, we would stick rigidly to our target for 150,000 social homes.  And that's the target we would be absolutely sticking to and imposing. 

Did the honorable gentleman over here have a question? 

03:26 - 04:13

Speaker 4

I thank the honorable gentleman.

I appreciate his point around housing targets. I would remind the committee we are interrogating this bill. One of the criticisms I've had of this bill is that actually the forecast for new additional houses, certainly in the impact statement, doesn't, is, is to some extent inaccurate, I would say. Can he speak to his own interrogation of this bill, his own disappointment that this bill doesn't create new houses that clearly he and his party want to see?

04:13 - 05:56

Gideon Amos

To be fair to the Conservative members, which is something I don't often say, I think they have raised the point in earlier sessions on this, in this committee, that too little, there's too little in this bill to secure the actual delivery of social homes, the really affordable homes that we need to see, which is why our new clause one, the very first amendment we were submitting, would insert such a target into this bill. And if I can just return to the objective of delivery of social homes, the budget gave an extra one and a half billion to the program, which is incredibly welcome, and I almost share in the hear-hears on that, even if it, even if on social homes that would struggle to add about a thousand per year to the current 18,000, which is the closest to a target we can divine from the government's policy announcements, about 18,000, 19,000, maybe 20,000 a year. We need a whole lot more than that. As I said, the National Housing Federation believe we need at least 90,000 per year. So that current level of ambition really is not high enough, and I'd encourage the government to focus its attention less on issuing thousands more planning permissions, although we need, of course we do need the planning permissions to keep coming through, but issuing thousands more planning permissions where we have a million plots with planning permission already not built for private housing, and focus more attention instead on the delivery of social housing and having a target, if not this one, then having a target of some sort.

Of course I'll give way.

05:56 - 06:35

John Slinger

I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way. Perhaps he's going to come on to address the point I'm about to make, which is what practical steps is he going to give his local government colleagues, Liberal Democrat local government colleagues, who I think it's fair to say don't necessarily have the greatest of reputations for approving housing developments in the areas they represent? So he's admittedly said that he's more in favor of social home building rather than private dwellings, but what practical steps is he going to do to perhaps encourage his colleagues in local government as regards his target?

06:35 - 10:55

Gideon Amos

Well, I welcome the question from the honorable gentleman, obviously anticipating a position when we're in government and able to ensure that this sort of delivery takes place. But I point him to Eastleigh Council that set up a unit, for example, taking over a 2,000 home development not being delivered by the developer and actually making that a local authority development and driving it through. I went down to Cornwall, Liberal Democrat Cornwall Council recently, under the previous Liberal Democrat administration they set up a housing company which is building 180, I wish it was 180,000, Sir Roger, 180 homes per year and using the benefits from that, the profits from that to build social rent homes. I could take him to, I'd invite him to join me in Taunton and come with me on the North Taunton estate where we're building 400 council houses and we have retained our council housing stock. Sadly due to right to buy it's not the 30,000 units it used to be, it's now only 6,000 homes we have, but we are doing what we can and my colleagues in Somerset Council are bringing new council houses to parts of Somerset for the first time in a generation.

So I'd encourage him to look at the activity on the ground of Liberal Democrat authorities. The amendment as I say would set a target of 150,000 social homes per year, something for the government to aspire to, and if not that target what is the target the government would set itself and when will it set itself a target? It doesn't require this many to be built, it's not a money resolution, it simply requires the government to publish a strategy for what would be required to get there. If the government is serious about the housing crisis it should have no objection to setting a target of this kind. In our manifesto we set an allocation of 6 billion pounds per year towards that achievement.

It would take a number of years to reach 150,000, I appreciate that. With your permission Sir Roger and in the interest of time I will move on to the other amendment in this group in my name which is the local authorities borrowing restrictions. Another which is new clause 4. Another significant area where I will give some hear hears to the government is the words that the Prime Minister has spoken about reviving council housing and delivering a lot more council housing, but I fear there are more words than there are pounds in the Prime Minister's pronouncements. Shelter have commissioned research from Savills examining the impact of the housing revenue account debt on council's ability to build new social homes.

Research found that writing off HRA debt could unlock between 190,000 and 284,000 dwellings. Shelter also recently published research with Pragmatix Advisory that assesses the economic and financial case for cancelling HRA debt and investing in social housing. The central conclusion is that the policy would be compliant with the government's fiscal rules by generating substantial long-term economic and fiscal benefits, generating a benefit of 140 billion over a 60-year timeframe. Somerset Council, my colleagues there, told me if it were not for the government's self-financing debt rules they could build out another 630 council houses on top of the ones that I was outlining to the honourable gentleman opposite. Appreciate that the cost of writing off that debt is significant, I'm sure the minister has previously come back on that point, but if not write off all of that debt would the government write off some of that debt?

For example we put in an extra 2 billion pounds per year in our manifesto to this area, would the government put in 2 billion pounds to write off some housing revenue account debt? It's important to get councils building again and those that have their housing revenue account maxed out have the political will to do it, they have the experience in many cases to do it, but they lack the financial headroom to do it. And if we want to get councils building we need to look seriously at the HRA debt. Thank you Sir Roger.

10:55 - 11:16

Speaker 14

The question is that new clause 1 strategy for the provision of 150,000 new social housing dwellings a year in England. Getting ahead of myself. The question is that new clause 1 be read a second time. I beg your pardon. On my new clause.

I beg your pardon. New clause 1 in the group. Not new clause 1. New clause 34. Any in the group.

11:16 - 12:19

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Any in the group. Okay. Thank you so much Sir Roger. In which case I rise, firstly it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I rise to move new clause 34 which stands in my name. I regret that my pointing out that this bill doesn't create a single new social home appeared to get under the minister's skin on Tuesday, but the fact of the matter is that this bill doesn't create any extra housing and that is not a surprise really coming from a government that's built just 26% of their target in nearly 50% of their time in this parliament.

Nonetheless it's simply not good enough.

Moreover, the few and far between places where the government have tried to get Britain building have nearly always come at the cost of green belt protections. And this is despite the fact that research from the Campaign for the Protection of Rural England shows that a large proportion of the government's lofty housing target could be swiftly met using brownfield land that already has planning permission. The CPRE estimates that up to 1.41 million homes could be built on existing brownfield land in England, based on data from local planning authorities' brownfield land registers up to 2022.

12:19 - 12:21

Speaker 12

Will the honorable member give way on that point?

12:22 - 12:54

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the honorable member for giving way, and he's talking about the importance of building on brownfield land first, and certainly that is the policy of this government. But would he agree that while the previous government professed to want to focus on developing brownfield land, in fact they did absolutely nothing to make that viable, whereas this government is putting money into the Brownfield Land Release Fund, which will help clean up that land, and those are steps that the previous Conservative government absolutely failed to take.

12:54 - 13:44

Andrew Gareth Bacon

I would like to point out to the honorable lady, I mean, it's a reasonable point she makes, but we are looking forward, not backward. And the thing that has to be said, the honorable lady says that she's making brownfield land development more viable, where is the sign of that? There is no development happening. Development in this country is grinding to an absolute standstill under this government. Now, that malaise did not start under this government, and I will accept that point, I will accept that criticism.

But it is most certainly being exacerbated by this government. They are doing nothing to turn back the tide, they in fact are pushing it further and further out to sea. 1.41 million starts amounts to 93% of the government's manifesto pledge, and that is why I have tabled new clause 34, which seeks to require the government to publish a strategy for prioritizing brownfield land for social housing development.

13:44 - 14:33

Lewis Cocking

Thank you, Sir Roger. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I'd like to speak in support of particularly new clause 34 about prioritizing brownfield development first. We always hear from the government that they want to protect the green belt, which I often laugh at when they say that, because there is nothing in legislation, they never want to put anything in the face of the bill, they never want to issue anything about protecting the green belt. And on brownfield sites, Sir Roger, Labour's favorite think tank, the Institute for Policy Research, has found that there are 1.4 million homes that have been left unbuilt since 2007. I mean, that is particularly rather close, as I said in the chamber in my second reading speech, to the government's commitment to build 1.5 million homes, which they've all but admitted that they won't meet.

I will give way.

14:33 - 15:31

Danny Beales

Thank you. I'm worried to say it, but I agree with the member opposite about the frustrations that there are many homes with permission, often on brownfield sites, that haven't been built. I see it in my own constituency in Uxbridge and South Ruislip. My experience, however, is speaking to those landowners and developers, the reason they haven't been built is the Liz Truss mini-budget crashed the financial models of those schemes, the regulation, the Building Safety Regulator, the rollout of new regulations, second staircase rules from the last government, stymied and slowed down development and changed viability. And fundamentally, his patch and my patch, Conservative councils are taking far too long, if ever, to approve development on brownfield sites that again are pushing against viability.

This government has taken measures on all of those things I've mentioned. Does he not agree it's slightly rich for the party opposite to claim that it's somehow this government's responsibility for those homes not being built out quickly?

15:31 - 16:40

Lewis Cocking

I mean, I'm slightly bewildered, and I've got great respect for the honorable gentleman, who did invite me in a debate in the chamber to visit one of his pubs in his constituency, and I didn't take him up on the offer, and maybe I should have done, because maybe I could have corrected him on lots of things that he's just said.

I mean, I'm slightly bewildered as I said about the nonsense that's just been spoken. I mean, look, I was a council leader. It's not the planning system why these houses don't get built. When I speak to developers in my constituency, lots of them talk to me about it's difficult now to employ people with the day one rights employment rights that this government has brought in. Lots of businesses speak to me about the increase in national insurance contributions.

We've got a plan to take fifty thousand pounds off the cost of building a new home, which will include social homes, which will increase the supply. This government has done nothing to increase supply. All it's done is attack local councils for giving out planning permission. And local councils get punished when they don't have a five-year land supply, which they have very little control over. The government needs to be doing much more to bring forward brownfield sites because usually brownfield sites, as he mentioned, I've got loads of them in my constituency.

I will give way.

16:40 - 17:32

John Slinger

I thank the honorable gentleman who I like very much and respect. But regarding brownfield sites, which invariably are in towns, would he agree with me that the resources, be they educational or health, within towns are often relatively busy or full up and facing real challenges and pressure? And that actually what we need in our wider planning system is that other conurbations, admittedly that don't have all of the transport links etcetera that mean that town brownfield sites are most prominent in the planning system and they are prioritized by this government, let's not forget, but that other conurbations, villages and so on, also need additional housing, additional social housing, because quite often when I'm talking to those people in those villages, their pubs, their schools are struggling because they don't have sufficient people wanting to use them.

17:32 - 19:00

Lewis Cocking

I thank him for his intervention and I thank him for his kind words and I have great respect for the honorable member too. I mean, he makes an interesting point, but the point goes wider than that. It's about the appropriate development in the right place followed up by infrastructure. Where I do agree with him, it is usually in the center of towns where we have brownfield sites. And as I said in my second reading debate, we're all fed up of driving past sites with all of the hoarding on where the site has got planning permission, they've gone through the planning committee at the local council, the local council has said yes we will give permission based on these circumstances, or they haven't and they've won on appeal unfortunately.

And it gives that feel for the town center. So when you go down the town center and you see all of the hoarding up on the brownfield sites, I mean I've got some in my constituency, in the heart of my constituency in Cheshunt, where we've got a care home waiting to be built, a facility that is long overdue in the local community that we really want to see be built, but it's left empty for years and years. And you just see hoarding up and it gives a real sense of loss of pride in a place when you go down the town center and you see site after site. I mean, we've got sites now in Hoddesdon which got planning permission in 2014, which have only just started moving forward through this process. There's lots of things that I think affect the building and the house build-out rates.

But this government could be doing much more to give powers to local councils to get these brownfield sites off the ground because as I said, there are thousands of unbuilt planning permissions in the country. I will give way.

19:00 - 19:06

Matthew Pennycook

Can he give us an example of the type of powers he has in mind that he thinks councils don't enjoy currently but should?

19:06 - 19:36

Lewis Cocking

I thank the minister for giving way and I know he's got a lot of expertise in this area. I mean, for example, one of the things, when you issue a standard planning permission, you get say three years to build. But as we've seen in my local area, that doesn't necessarily mean something gets built, that just means they've started on site. So it could be digging a hole, building a first wall, that's not actually producing anything at the end of that. What I would like to see local councils have is use it or lose it, right?

Just because someone has started digging on site doesn't mean that they've got those types of powers to bring that forward. I'll give way again.

19:36 - 19:45

Matthew Pennycook

That's a very interesting line of argument. Is the Conservative Party's official position now that use it or lose it powers should be introduced on brownfield sites?

19:45 - 20:23

Lewis Cocking

I think we've got to explore all options, right? Oh, hang on one second. I want to protect as much of the green belt as possible. I want to protect as much of the green belt as possible. There is lots of sites, and we've all got sites in our constituency that are brownfield sites that we want to see come forward, that would help meet the social housing targets that we've all got in our local constituencies, that would bring down waiting lists.

Unfortunately, this bill talks about the right to buy, and I just put on record now, stopping the right to buy, those same people that bought those houses would still be in those houses now. They don't magically disappear and the waiting list disappear if we got all of these houses back under right to buy. I will give way.

20:23 - 20:55

Gideon Amos

Gillian Ames. The honorable gentleman's very generous in his time, as he always is. I welcome the Conservatives' move towards use it or lose it permissions. And would they therefore, to give that effect, as we argued in the passage of the Planning Infrastructure Bill, would they, by lose it, I assume they agree with us that that should mean the compulsory acquisition of sites that have not been built out over a reasonable period of time? Otherwise, what does lose it mean?

How does it have effect?

20:55 - 21:52

Lewis Cocking

Well, I would, as I said, I think we need to explore all options, and I would like to see brownfield sites built out first. I want to protect as much of the green belt as possible. That means looking at how we can utilize the areas that have got planning permission, the areas that have already gone through that planning process, the areas in our town centers that we can see and that residents drive past all of the time. I think that's where the government need to be looking at, because there are loads of unbuilt planning applications that we've all had the consultation on, that we've all gone and spoken to our residents about. So I think all options must be on the table to look at how we can... and we do, just let me make this point, we do that in our constituencies all the time.

I have people coming to see me at my local surgery to ask me why a site hasn't been built out. As I said, I've got a care home on a brownfield site in the middle of my town center in Chesham that we desperately want to see built, and it would be good if the government could bring forward tools for local councils to enable those sites to get built out quicker.

21:52 - 22:33

Speaker 4

I thank the honorable member. I thought it would be appropriate again just to remind the committee the purpose of the clause is to force the government to bring forward a strategy that looks at utilizing brownfield sites, not bouncing opposition parties into making policies on the hoof. We give it to you, the government, to come up with these ideas. But yes, I wondered if my honorable friend from Broxbourne could just reaffirm that is the point he's making, that the government should bring forward a strategy to indicate their intent.

22:33 - 23:15

Lewis Cocking

I thank my honorable friend for that intervention. And absolutely, this clause is about the government must bring forward a strategy for brownfield sites. Now, that could include a multitude of options. And when the government do bring forward that strategy, we as the opposition will look at the benefits of all of the items in that strategy. And as I said, it could include use it or lose it powers.

That was one example that the government could look at and review to see what could happen. But as I said, this clause is about bringing forward brownfield first sites. I don't think anyone disagrees with that. So it would be good that the government could accept this to form part of the bill, because then the bill might actually become about building more social housing than at the moment what's in the bill does nothing of the sort.

23:15 - 26:26

Edward John Argar

Anybody else? Thank you very much, Sir Roger. And I rise in support of new clause 34 moved by my honorable friend, the shadow minister.

And I've listened very carefully to the exchanges across the committee chamber today. I have to say, I don't see what is particularly contentious about what my honorable friend is proposing. It is not unreasonable to seek to build on the focus on brownfield land being developed first that the previous government did so much to do. And therefore a strategy to draw those different strands together as we look towards the future and however many more years of this government we have, the power is in their hands to do this. I don't see what is contentious about doing what my honorable friend's amendment proposes.

And to the honorable gentleman, the member for Rugby, I think who I listened to carefully, I'd put a counterpoint to the point he made about development on brownfield sites because the reality is in my constituency, which has a couple of towns in it and is right on the edge of Leicester but goes way up into rural northeast Leicestershire. The reality is that it is the developments on the edges of the towns or nearer the city that often work most effectively because you do have the bus routes, do have access to more schools, you have access to shops, to businesses, to employment opportunities. And the challenge we face locally is that in Leicester city and under the Labour mayor of Leicester, we're seeing, I go through it, I go from the station to my constituency, I see undeveloped brownfield sites or commercial sites that have fallen into disuse sitting in the city, undeveloped, unmodernized, unutilized. And yet the mayor says he cannot meet his housing target there and therefore has farmed them out to the rural areas in the county, meaning significant amounts of development on the edges of villages, often without a bus route or with a very sparse bus route, with a full village primary school, with a GP practice serving a whole range of rural communities and unable to meet the needs of the additional development. So you do see a real challenge in those circumstances in terms of pressure on local services.

I've been pushing for a long time when these applications are brought forward to see if there is a way of having I before E, infrastructure before expansion, so that at least you know the services are there. And one of the big challenges, and it's one that the previous government in which I served didn't solve, I suspect this government will struggle to solve it because it comes down to the viability of development, is you can ask developers, and we do, and local authorities do, for capital contributions for those services. Often the problem is the ongoing revenue cost of running them. So you can get an extra surgery room in a surgery, but will the local NHS ICB be willing to fund the salary costs and commission extra GP practice services?

26:26 - 27:20

Danny Beales

Yeah, of course I will. I'm kind of perhaps in trouble by saying I agree with the member opposite again. I'm finding a lot of agreement in some of the things said. It is a frustration that the future benefits of infrastructure have not often been realized because of the funding models we have in place. And local leaders, local mayors have said the case is clear for this infrastructure, it will unleash housing and growth, but they have to go to the Treasury to make the business case with a begging bowl in their hand to get that capital and it takes too long.

This government is changing that. The budget just yesterday gave significant new powers to mayors in London, in my patch, the TIF in and around Euston, the Bakerloo extension, a number of projects and looking to give mayors more share of business rates and taxation to do exactly that, invest upfront in infrastructure on the benefits of growth to come. So isn't the government doing exactly what the member opposite is saying should happen?

27:20 - 30:39

Edward John Argar

Well, I hesitate to disagree with the honorable gentleman who I have a lot of time for. But certainly in my constituency, no they're not, because there isn't a mayor in Leicestershire. There is a mayor of Leicester, but there isn't a mayor in Leicestershire. So we don't get any of the benefits of this. Now I may find in about 20 minutes that the minister's colleague says something in the chamber that may be about to change that, I don't know yet.

But so we don't have those benefits. And actually a lot of it, a lot of the challenges around service provision are not addressed by what the Chancellor set out yesterday. Take the NHS, take the funding model there. We've got an ICB in Leicestershire, Leicester and Rutland, that is having to make in-year savings to try to live within its financial envelope. So we have GP practices which are full and got to a point, I've got one practice in Melton Mowbray, which single practice has 37,000 patients on its books.

They don't have and the ICB has said it sees no reason to expand because the development hasn't happened yet in Melton, so it won't expand beforehand to meet that need until the need is demonstrable there, by which time there are a whole range of people who will have moved into that new development and won't have been able to get on the list for that surgery or be waiting for a very long time. Now I'm not saying that is something that suddenly appeared in July 2024, it's a challenge governments of all political complexions have grappled with. I've got a lot of time for this minister. I hope that it is something that is on his radar and it's something he'll be thinking about. But just turning to brownfield sites and why I think what my honorable friend's put forward shouldn't be contentious.

It's a sensible approach to draw together all the different strands and all the work that the previous government did to push the development of brownfield sites. I'll just give a few examples of that. The NPPF had a clear focus on it. We required local authorities to publish reports and registers of available brownfield sites for development. We reviewed permitted development rights and changes and changes in use class rules to make it easier for commercial sites to be repurposed for development into housing.

And alongside that, 4.3 billion pounds into the housing infrastructure fund, 550 million pounds into the brownfield housing fund. This is tangible investment to persuade and support local authorities to prioritize brownfield first. The problem I find locally in my patch is that the Labour mayor of Leicester simply didn't do it and we see the brownfield sites everywhere and we now see that development pushed out into the county because the city has failed to do what it needs to do. What my honorable friend's amendment would do would be, and I think it is a modest amendment, would be to compel the government to bring forward a strategy to draw those strands of all the work the previous government did, the work this government is doing, into a clear and coherent strategy that would see that prioritization of brownfield sites much, much more with much more focus upon it and giving the local authorities and others the means, the support, the policy backup to be able to really genuinely make that a reality on the ground. So Sir Roger, I will finish there but simply by emphasizing my support for my honorable friend.

30:39 - 33:59

Speaker 4

Thank you Sir Roger. It's a reality when you serve with such an august group of gentlemen that your speech is slowly whittled down by their speeches preceding them. But if it's okay, these are pet projects of mine actually because, and I said this earlier I think, I'm one of those people here who represents a rural community. And we have seen in Suffolk the reality of building houses in areas that just it's not suited. I, we have had a number of kind of major weather events over the last 10, 15 years.

I have not read a single section 17 flood report that doesn't identify urban sprawl and house building in rural areas and on floodplains and on low-lying land as a major contributor to massive flooding risks in rural England.

And that's on top of the fact that my honorable friend from Melton and Syston has raised, which is many homes that are built in rural areas are not near schools, not near transport infrastructure, not near high streets. These are not houses that young people want to move into. You know, I use this anecdote all the time, but in my village, which is, you know, in the middle of nowhere, we have 30 units have been built on the side of the town. We don't have any, not only are they too expensive, but we don't have any of the utilities that the young people who we are trying to solve the housing crisis for want. And at the same time, I have Ipswich in my constituency, a mine of brownfield sites.

And so my point in this speech is this bill, this new clause could be a huge opportunity for the government to align a policy on social housing with its broader economic agenda of empowering regions, because our economic future is going to be in towns and cities. That is an inevitability. That is where the jobs are going to be made. That is where the growth is going to be. That's where education institutions, those anchor institutions that are so important for the long-term economic viability of these towns are based.

This shouldn't come as a surprise to many of you. We represent Rugby and Wolverhampton and Durham in here. All of these places, the members would say, we want jobs, we want young people, we want institutions that embed economic growth. Let me just make this point, and critically, affordable homes to sit alongside them. What is the point of a thriving town without affordable housing?

I give way to the honorable gentleman from Rugby.

33:59 - 34:31

John Slinger

I thank the honorable gentleman. Does he agree with me that the need for social homes, and indeed affordable homes, but since we're talking about social homes here, that need exists also in our villages? It doesn't exist only in our towns. And if we are to deal with the long-standing problems with the very high cost of homes on the private market, we need social homes across the range of conurbations in our country.

34:31 - 36:35

Speaker 4

Listen, I don't think we would be arguing against that statement in one bit. I'm not trying to expunge social tenants from rural England. And I represent actually some very, Suffolk is not just a load of farms and tractor driving. You know, we've got a lot of working-class towns. We need social housing.

But we're talking about the future of social housing. We're talking about the future of our economy. And we're talking about the future of our dynamism. We have always moaned jealously about the French and the Germans and the Americans for having this dynamic economy with engines of prosperity outside the capital city, while we're stuck with this unimodal economy that's so rooted in London.

It's crazy, isn't it, that we're sitting here, I'm sitting here on this side of the House, sort of making the Prime Minister's arguments for him. But anyway, I reach the point where this is an opportunity, surely, in this bill to say, if we are going to build 50 to 100, 150, we're going to tackle the 1.3 million people who are stuck on the waiting list for social houses, why don't we make sure that that is aligned with our responsibility on economic growth? That, I mean, and I'll end with this. We, all of us, are bored of hearing from experts and friends and family members about the lack of joined-up policy making across government. Well, this is a really good example of how we can make sure that this bill, not an inconsequential bill, but one bill in a wide patchwork of legislation brought forward by this government, can align with a wider economic agenda that we can all get behind.

36:35 - 36:37

Roger Gale

Thank you very much.

36:37 - 36:39

Speaker 21

Minister.

36:39 - 39:51

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Roger. It's a pleasure to continue our proceedings with you in the chair. And I welcome after what I will put candidly as a sort of languid approach of the opposition in previous sessions, that they have clearly woken up, Sir Roger, and are now fully participating in the debate, and I very much welcome that. We had a remarkably, partly for this reason, Sir Roger, we had a remarkably productive first day of committee on Tuesday, and while our debates on many clauses and amendments were predictably spirited, they nevertheless did remain civil and in the main constructive, and I hope we can proceed in that vein today. I will make a just a general point before I respond to the individual amendments.

And it's a point that the shadow minister is clearly struggling to grasp. Our ambitions in terms of delivering the biggest increase in social and affordable house building in a generation will benefit from this legislation. They are not entirely dependent on this one piece of legislation. And the supply statistics speak for themselves. These are the statistics, Sir Roger, from 2024-25.

Overall social and affordable house building, 64,921. That's the highest level since 2014-15. Social housing on its own, 12,267. That's the highest level since 2012-13. Council delivered homes, 10,600.

That is the highest level since 1991-92. This government's record on social and affordable, and this is all, by the way, prior to the initial allocations from our social and affordable housing program going out the door, which they now have. So we have increased supply. We will increase it further. This bill will make a material impact to doing so.

I'll turn now to the three amendments that have been spoken to, starting with new clause one. As the honorable gentleman is fully aware, as I've just said, in line with our commitments that we made in our manifesto, we're committed to delivering the biggest increase in social and affordable house building in a generation, to prioritizing the building of new social rented homes, and to supporting councils and housing associations to make a greater contribution to affordable supply. In the 27 months we've been in office, we've faithfully sought to honor those commitments. We've made the biggest long-term investment in social and affordable housing in recent memory, an investment which as he rightly recognized was topped up in yesterday's budget by a further one and a half billion pounds. We are vigorously prioritizing social rented housing.

And I understand, indeed I welcome, I embrace his encouragement, his support for us to raise our ambition further. However, given the nature of our inheritance from the party opposite, with social housing supply averaging a historical low of under 8,000 units per year from 2013 to 2024, following the purposeful, deliberate pivot to affordable rented tenures, a target of 150,000 new social homes per year is not currently realistic, and a statutory requirement to produce a strategy for delivering such volumes within 12 months of Royal Assent is not a proposition we can support. And I also once again say gently to the member for Taunton and Wellington that his party continues to wildly underestimate the cost of social housing supply on the scale he is proposing. The government's estimate of the grant funding required to support the delivery of 150,000 social homes is in excess of 20 billion pounds per year. Now, for obvious reasons, his party has escaped the kind of scrutiny to which the government and the official opposition are subject, but if his party wants that 150,000 figure to be taken seriously, it will have to set out a credible funding strategy of the kind that it has not done so to date.

We are rebuilding the capacity of councils and housing associations to borrow and invest in new and existing homes, and we are reinvigorating council house building. Now, in his more generous moments, the Liberal Democrat spokesman acknowledges the transformative impact of what this government has done in respect of social housing supply.

40:42 - 41:06

Gideon Amos

Which we'll certainly be setting out prior to going into government. Could I ask the minister if he makes an extensive argument that 150,000 is not the right target? Shelter and the National Housing Federation say 90,000 are needed per year minimum. What is the government's target?

41:06 - 44:56

Matthew Pennycook

Well, as he knows, and we've had this debate many times, we have not set to date a national social and affordable housing target. And that is because, and I've explained this on numerous occasions, and he will know this, social and affordable homes come through grant funding, they also come through section 106. It's for local areas to set out the needs for their particular authority areas as part of local plans. And we've strengthened, as he knows, through the NPPF, some of the expectations in that area. I'll turn now to new clause 4, also tabled by the honourable gentleman.

As I've said, the government has already taken a number of steps to rebuild the capacity of councils to borrow and invest in new and existing homes, including the fundamental reform of the Right to Buy scheme at the heart of this bill, as well as a 10-year social housing rent settlement and social rent convergence. At the budget yesterday, it was confirmed that the preferential borrowing rate for council housing will remain in place until at least March 2028 to support councils to borrow more cheaply for house building. There are no current restrictions exercised by central government over the amount that councils can borrow via their housing revenue accounts for house building purposes. Councils are now free to borrow in line with the prudential code, which requires them to demonstrate that any borrowing is affordable, prudent, sustainable, and proportionate. As envisaged by the honourable member's amendment, these are precisely the types of tests that are essential to ensure that local authority finances are managed sensibly and sustainably whilst ensuring sufficient flexibility to meet local housing targets.

And as such, in our view, it is not necessary to accept this amendment as there are no restrictions to remove. And finally, new clause 34, Sir Roger, tabled by the honourable member for Orpington. The government is strongly committed to a brownfield-first approach, as was the previous government. Several members have made that point, it is a fair one, including for the development of social housing. And we do expect, let me just be very clear about this, I say it on every occasion I can, once permissions are granted, we expect to see them built out as quickly as possible.

And honourable members on the benches opposite won't have to wait long for the build-out transparency package that we consulted on some time ago to be brought forward. On the 17th of August, the government published a new National Planning Policy Framework. This makes clear that authorities should plan to meet as much of their development needs as possible on brownfield land. To strengthen support for the development of brownfield land, the new NPPF encourages higher densities in sustainable locations and greater intensification of urban and suburban sites. It also introduces a presumption that development in-site settlement should be approved unless any adverse effects would substantially outweigh the benefits of doing so.

Furthermore, Sir Roger, through the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act this year, the government committed to making regulations requiring strategic planning authorities to have regard to the desirability of prioritising development on previously developed land. That arose out of a challenge we received from the opposite benches in the passage of that act.

Taken together, these measures demonstrate the government's strong and continued support for brownfield development in national policy. On social housing in particular, national planning policy reflects our commitment to the delivery of social rent homes. It requires local plans to set out minimum proportions of social rent to be required on new development. Now, as everyone knows, the NPPF is a material consideration of critical importance in planning decisions and local plans are required to be prepared with regard to it. As such, it is the right place in which to set clear expectations for how and where development should come forward.

Therefore, a requirement to produce a separate brownfield land social housing development strategy is, in our view, unnecessary. It's duplicative as existing policy and relevant development plans already sufficiently achieve the same. So, to the point made by the honourable gentleman, the member for Central Suffolk and North Ipswich, policy in this area is already aligned. We do not need a separate brownfield land strategy. As I've previously dubbed such strategies, they are the last refuge of an opposition scrambling around for meaningful policy amendments to a bill.

44:56 - 45:05

Speaker 30

And for those reasons, and with those assurances, Sir Roger, we cannot accept these amendments.

45:05 - 45:17

Speaker 29

Only to say, Sir Roger, I... this is starting to become quite fun, but I don't accept the minister's comments and we will seek to divide at the appropriate moment on this on any clause.

45:17 - 45:49

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger. And I simply rise to state that a target for 150,000 homes per year is not a meaningless tribute. It's actually setting in place a target that the government has so far not done. And I know the minister welcomes our encouragement to challenge them to go further on social housing. And therefore we will do so by pushing this matter to a vote and encouraging the government to come up with a target for the number of social homes it's going to produce.

45:49 - 45:53

Speaker 27

Thank you, Sir Roger.

45:53 - 46:26

Roger Gale

Thank you. I'm not entirely clear whether the honourable gentleman wishes to press... you wish to press it to a division. New clause 1 proposed as on the order paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye.

Aye. Contrary no. No. Division. Lock the doors.

Sagal Abdi-Wali.

46:26 - 46:28

Speaker 24

No.

46:28 - 46:29

Gideon Amos.

46:30 - 46:31

Edward Argar.

46:32 - 46:33

Gareth Bacon.

46:34 - 46:35

Danny Beales.

46:36 - 46:41

Speaker 23

Rachel Blake. Sian Berry. Hazel Caliskan.

46:41 - 46:43

Speaker 26

No.

46:43 - 46:44

Lewis Cocking.

46:45 - 46:46

Deirdre Costigan.

46:46 - 46:48

Speaker 22

No.

46:48 - 46:54

Speaker 28

Lee Dillon. Mary Kelly Foy. Matthew Pennycook.

46:55 - 46:56

John Slinger.

46:57 - 46:59

Speaker 25

John... Patrick Spencer.

47:00 - 47:01

Laurence Turner.

47:02 - 47:47

Roger Gale

Steve Yemm. The ayes were 1 and the noes were 7, so the noes have it. Unlock. For the benefit of those who are unfamiliar with this arcane process, the honourable gentleman has indicated that he wishes to move new clause 24.

That doesn't happen now, although it's grouped. It happens later on in the bill when we reach it. It will not have been forgotten. New clause 2, which has been debated with group 6. Gideon Amos wishes to move formally or withdraw?

47:47 - 47:49

Speaker 35

Move formally.

47:49 - 48:04

Speaker 39

The question is that new clause 2 be read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

48:05 - 48:06

Contrary no.

48:06 - 48:10

Speaker 40

No.

48:10 - 48:12

Speaker 41

I think the noes have it.

48:12 - 48:21

Speaker 43

Aye. No. Aye. Division.

48:21 - 48:26

Speaker 36

Lock the doors. Soheila Abadi?

48:27 - 48:28

Gideon Amos?

48:29 - 48:30

Edward Argar?

48:31 - 48:32

Gareth Bacon?

48:33 - 48:34

Danny Beales?

48:35 - 48:38

Speaker 34

Rachel Blake? Sarah Brackenridge? Nesil Caliskan?

48:39 - 48:40

Lewis Cocking?

48:41 - 48:42

Deirdre Costigan?

48:42 - 48:47

Speaker 37

No.

48:47 - 48:48

Luthfur Rahman?

48:48 - 48:51

Speaker 38

No.

48:51 - 48:52

John Slinger?

48:53 - 48:54

Patrick Spencer?

48:55 - 48:56

Laurence Turner?

48:56 - 49:05

David Laurence Russell Turner

No.

49:05 - 49:20

Roger Gale

The ayes were 1, the noes were 7, so the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 25 and new clause 3, which it would be convenient to consider with new clause 53. Gideon Amos to move new clause 3.

49:20 - 50:21

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger. I'm grateful for the opportunity to move new clause 3, which stands in my name and that of my Liberal Democrat colleagues. Regulatory inspections of housing associations, particularly where there's been bad practice or poor responses to tenants, and I want to acknowledge that of course most housing associations, registered providers, do an excellent job and fulfill an absolutely vital role in delivering the social homes that we need. However, in cases where they fail and they fail to deliver an adequate level of service and repairs to tenants, in those instances where they're particularly bad, eventually the regulator of social housing may carry out an inspection. That is only after years in which tenants have been disadvantaged, not served.

50:21 - 50:24

Speaker 32

Of course I will.

50:24 - 51:21

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

I thank the honorable member for giving way, and his amendment is very similar, I think, to the official opposition's amendment in this same group. But the official opposition, I believe, are saying that theirs is a probing amendment. So to ask a kind of probing question of the honorable member, how does he see this moving beyond the changes the government has already brought in, in fact on a cross-party basis, with Awaab's Law, which will allow now tenants to be able to report problems with repairs and have them dealt with by their housing provider within a very short timescale and will give them ability to sue for breaches or to go to the ombudsman? And on top of that, of course, the new right to manage right that is within this bill that we're discussing today, which will allow tenants to actually get rid of their repair provider completely and have their own brought in. How does he see his amendment today moving beyond that?

51:21 - 51:23

Speaker 31

What is the gap?

51:23 - 53:42

Gideon Amos

Well, the honorable member for Ealing Southall makes some excellent points about measures that we have supported, and Awaab's Law is one of them and the Renters' Rights Act. And we certainly welcome those new standards that tenants will have access to. The import of this new clause is that it will cover a much wider range of poor practice across a whole estate, for example, rather than individual dwellings, or indeed across a whole registered provider of social housing. We already have inspections of registered providers by the regulator, but as I say, they tend to come after the scandal is all over, after things have been running for years, tenants have been complaining, there have been recourse to complaints mechanisms and so on. So our new clause would ensure, give tenants, where a reasonable percentage of them have signed up to trigger an inspection by the regulator at an earlier stage, rather than making it a proactive power and a proactive inspection by the regulator rather than waiting to the end of the process and expecting the regulator to look into it at a later date.

Of course, there are details to be worked out in terms of, you know, what do we mean by an estate and so on, which is why we've made provision in the new clause for regulations to be approved in this place to make those more detailed arrangements in relation to that. But this is fundamentally giving social housing tenants an extra lever, a power to bring in the regulator where that's justified to carry out an inspection in a proactive way. It's a constructive amendment and it's submitted for that purpose. I'm delighted the Conservatives have followed suit with something similar and could be persuaded to even vote for it in the unlikely event that this new clause doesn't get voted through the committee today. But I think on that basis, Sir Roger, it stands on its own merits.

It would give an extra lever, an extra power to social housing tenants, some of whom are really badly served by their housing associations. With that, I move new clause three.

53:42 - 53:50

Roger Gale

Ability of tenants to trigger a regulatory inspection. Question is that new clause three be read a second time. Gareth Bacon.

53:50 - 54:49

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you very much, Sir Roger. I rise to move new clause 53, which stands in my name. Many people in social housing have come into their new home from a past marred by hardship and a lack of safety. When tenants finally come to have a roof over their heads and a place to call home, they must not be left to face unsanitary or unsafe living conditions as a result of the property owner or manager. And that is why we've tabled, the honorable lady is completely correct, a probing clause, new clause 53.

This would add an extra layer of protection for tenants and a fresh route for direct accountability for registered providers. The clause would enable tenants of a registered provider to request an inspection by the Regulator of Social Housing, giving tenants new powers to ensure their home is not just four walls but a sanctuary. It's vital that social housing tenants have the ability to make the most of the regulator's functions and that the regulator is not just a bureaucratic machine but a voice for the vulnerable.

54:49 - 54:52

Speaker 44

Anymore? Minister.

54:52 - 56:03

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Roger. Can I thank the honorable gentlemen for tabling and moving the two new clauses that they just have. This government is determined to ensure that social housing tenants live in safe and decent homes, are listened to, and have access to redress when things go wrong. However, I'm not persuaded these amendments are necessary. The current framework, Sir Roger, the current regulatory framework, which, and again to in a spirit of generosity cross-party, was introduced, the powers which were taken under the Social Housing Regulation Bill under the previous government, didn't do all bad things, there were some good things the previous government did and we should acknowledge them where they did.

But the Social Housing Regulation Bill provided the powers for that regulatory framework and that provides strong mechanisms for tenant voice and regulatory oversight. In 2024, the regulator introduced a new proactive regulation regime and has since begun inspecting all large landlords at least once every four years. The regulator issues a consumer grading after these inspections so that it is clear to tenants and the public how well the landlords are performing. In addition, the regulator retains the ability to engage with landlords outside these routine inspections if concerns are raised.

56:03 - 56:18

Lewis Cocking

I thank the Minister for his response. I just want to ask a general question. Does he believe that the social housing regulator has enough powers to deal with the issues that he's describing? And this is just off the good spirit of me asking a genuine question about how he thinks it is operating.

56:18 - 58:19

Matthew Pennycook

I'm always open to evidence that it doesn't have sufficient powers. My judgment is that it does and that its consumer ratings that are being handed out, we're getting a steady stream of them now, do really have an impact in driving improvements in landlord behavior. Central to the regime, Sir Roger, is the regulator's independent and risk-based approach to regulation. This allows the regulator to target its engagement and interventions to areas where there is the greatest risk of harm to tenants. Now it is worth clarifying, tenants and other members of the public can refer matters to the regulator where they believe a registered provider may not be meeting the outcomes of the standards and the regulator may take those concerns into account as part of its wider regulatory activity, including inspections.

But in our view, introducing tenant-triggered inspections risks cutting across this approach by potentially diverting regulatory resource away from higher risk providers or issues while also undermining the regulator's ability to act independently. It's our view that the existing framework already ensures that tenants' concerns can inform regulatory action while allowing the regulator to determine where intervention is most needed. With regard to new clause 53, which I accept the shadow minister's made clear is a probing amendment, I would have particular concerns about introducing a mechanism whereby the regulator would inspect individual tenants' dwellings. While individual tenants can escalate issues to the regulator as I've made clear, it considers performance against the regulatory standards at a landlord level, seeking assurance that the landlord is delivering the outcomes set out in the regulatory standards. The regulator directly inspecting individual homes would move away from its co-regulatory approach and would require significant additional resource.

In addition, tenant views already play an important role as I've said in the existing regime. The regulator draws on a range of sources as part of its inspections, including through the landlord's complaints process, the housing ombudsman, and direct referrals. The existing framework ensures that tenants already play an important role in the system without the need for a statutory mechanism to trigger inspections. For these reasons, I respectfully ask that the honorable members withdraw their amendments.

58:19 - 58:43

Speaker 52

Thanks very much. I wish to press to a vote, Sir Roger, new clause 3.

58:43 - 58:50

Roger Gale

New clause 3 proposed as on the order paper. The question is that the clause be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye.

58:51 - 58:52

Contrary no.

58:54 - 59:03

Roger Gale

Division. Clear the lobby. Lock the doors. Lock the doors. There's nobody else waiting.

Siobhan Baillie.

59:04 - 59:05

Gideon Amos.

59:06 - 59:07

Edward Argar.

59:08 - 59:09

Gareth Bacon.

59:10 - 59:11

Danny Beales.

59:11 - 59:13

Speaker 47

No.

59:13 - 59:14

Nesil Caliskan.

59:15 - 59:16

Lewis Cocking.

59:17 - 59:18

Deirdre Costigan.

59:18 - 59:22

Speaker 48

No.

59:22 - 59:23

Matthew Pennycook.

59:24 - 59:25

John Slinger.

59:26 - 59:27

Patrick Spencer.

59:28 - 59:29

Laurence Turner.

59:29 - 59:35

David Laurence Russell Turner

No.

59:35 - 59:50

Roger Gale

The ayes were one and the noes were seven. So the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to new clause 4 which has been debated already with new group 24.

Mr. Amos, move formally?

59:50 - 59:51

Formally.

59:51 - 01:00:04

Roger Gale

Local authorities' borrowing restrictions. Question is that new clause four be read a second time. As many of that opinion say Aye. Aye. Contrary No.

No. Division. Lock the doors.

01:00:04 - 01:00:36

Speaker 58

Sagal Abdi-Wali? No. Gideon Amos? Aye. David Agall?

Abstain. Gareth Bacon? Abstain. Danny Beales? No.

Hazel Caluscan? No. Lewis Cocking? Abstain. Deirdre Costigan?

No. Matthew Pennycook? No. John Slinger? No.

Patrick Spencer? Abstain. Lawrence Turner? No.

01:00:36 - 01:00:52

Roger Gale

The Ayes were one and the Noes were seven, so the Noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 26 and new clause five, with which it would be convenient to take new clause 12. Gideon Amos to move new clause five.

01:00:52 - 01:03:49

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger, and it is a pleasure to move new clause five, which stands in my name and that of Liberal Democrat colleagues, on review of access to social housing for former service personnel. This is an appropriate time, as we run into Remembrance Sunday and Armistice Day, to consider and to take account of the needs of service personnel and veterans in this bill, this important bill on social housing. Around 3% of rough sleepers are veterans, according to the No Homeless Veterans campaign. Government research found that 2,180 veteran households are assessed as at risk of experiencing homelessness. One of the most significant reasons for that is PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder, which unexpectedly obviously affects many veterans.

One in three veterans are also disabled. This new clause would require the Secretary of State to review and report to Parliament on the provision of social housing for former members of the armed services. And to anticipate the point that this is simply a review, surely there can be no more important group to review the performance of social housing for than our veterans and those who have put their lives at risk for our country, Sir Roger. It will no doubt be convenient to committee that I move on to move new clause 12 in the same group that also stands in my name, Sir Roger, if I may, rather than sitting down and standing up again, which is a great tradition of this House. New clause 12 in this group also stands in my name and that of my Liberal Democrat colleagues, on review of access to social housing for rehabilitated offenders.

There's been a staggering 26% year-on-year increase in the number of households requiring homelessness support due to leaving care, custody, or hospital. When it comes to rehabilitated offenders, the last thing we want are offenders whose rehabilitation does not, is not sustained and is not supported due to not having anywhere to live. One in ten sleeping rough were recently discharged from an institution. That's a massive number, Sir Roger. We need to do better by those who need that support.

One in six prison leavers had no fixed abode on their first night, one in six in 2025-26. About a thousand a month are released to rough sleeping in 2024-25, up about 40% in a year.

I respectfully submit both these new clauses to the committee for consideration.

01:03:49 - 01:04:01

Roger Gale

Review of access to social housing for former service personnel. Question is that new clause 5 be read a second time. Minister.

01:04:01 - 01:05:48

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Roger. As the honorable member has just set out, new clauses 5 and 12 would require the Secretary of State to publish reports on access to social housing for former members of the armed forces and former offenders respectively. We of course, Sir Roger, want to make sure that social housing allocation system works fairly and effectively. Current and former members of the armed forces community benefit from strong protections within the allocations framework, including receiving the highest preference where they have a housing need. Where local connection or residency tests apply to determine who qualifies for an allocation of social housing, legislation exempts the armed forces community regardless of when they last served.

This ensures that they are not disadvantaged when applying for social housing due to the mobility required by service life. And the new clause to the bill that we debated on Tuesday, Sir Roger, will also ensure that veterans will not face local connection barriers when seeking homelessness assistance. There is statutory guidance in place on improving access to social housing for members of the armed forces. There are not specific protections in the system for former offenders. They will have their housing need considered in the same way as other groups.

They may fall within existing statutory reasonable preference categories where, for example, they are homeless, need to move on welfare grounds, or need to move because of medical or other relevant needs. Work is already underway to update statutory guidance on social housing allocations to ensure that allocations reflect local need and effectively support vulnerable households. Our call for evidence on this recently closed and we're now working with partners to prepare updated guidance and we plan to consult on this updated guidance next year. With this comprehensive review already underway, Sir Roger, we do not consider there is a need to conduct separate reviews for specific groups such as former members of the armed forces or former offenders. I hope on that basis the honorable gentleman, member for Taunton and Wellington, is sufficiently reassured and may consider withdrawing his amendment.

01:05:48 - 01:05:51

Roger Gale

Mr. Amos.

01:05:51 - 01:06:16

Gideon Amos

The amendment is not a burdensome one, Sir Roger. It's a review of access to social housing for former service personnel. And whilst I hear what the minister said, that the government keeps these matters under review, surely a social housing bill should commit to supporting the veterans and armed service community in this way. And therefore I will move this to a vote.

01:06:16 - 01:06:22

Roger Gale

Question is that the new clause as on the order paper be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:06:25 - 01:06:31

Speaker 54

Division. Lock the doors.

01:06:31 - 01:06:32

Ms. Gaby Abadi.

01:06:35 - 01:06:35

Edward Argar.

01:06:36 - 01:06:37

Gareth Bacon.

01:06:37 - 01:06:38

Danny Beales.

01:06:38 - 01:06:41

Speaker 57

No.

01:06:41 - 01:06:42

Nesil Caliskan.

01:06:43 - 01:06:44

Lewis Cocking.

01:06:45 - 01:06:46

Deirdre Costigan.

01:06:46 - 01:06:48

Speaker 56

No.

01:06:48 - 01:06:49

Matthew Pennycook.

01:06:49 - 01:06:51

Speaker 55

No.

01:06:51 - 01:06:52

John Slinger.

01:06:53 - 01:06:54

Patrick Spencer.

01:06:55 - 01:06:56

Laurence Turner.

01:06:56 - 01:07:02

David Laurence Russell Turner

No.

01:07:02 - 01:07:13

Roger Gale

The ayes were one and the noes were seven, so the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 27 and new clause 6. Mr. Amos to move new clause 6.

01:07:13 - 01:08:59

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger. And it's a pleasure to move this new clause in relation to requirements for wheelchair accessible social housing.

Social tenants are worse served now than they were in terms of wheelchair accessible housing. 2022-23, a third of wheelchair users in the social sector were placed in homes that were neither accessible nor adapted, according to Age UK. The planning system is also something of a postcode lottery. Only 170 out of 311 local plans set targets for wheelchair user homes. Nationally, one wheelchair home, wheelchair accessible home is planned per 538 people.

The South West plans one per 810 people. London plans one per 210, the North West one per 2006 people. The NPPF doesn't require any M4(3), so that is wheelchair accessible under the building regulation standards, it leaves to local plans to assess need. We've already seen how this is something of a lottery, Sir Roger. London already has 10% requirement in its local plan, which proves a 10% level is achievable and can be done.

But the Minister might say this is a matter of devolution, let local communities decide rather than central government, and that councils are free to follow that example. But we say that a minimum floor of 10% is reasonable, it's been considered by government in the past, and we respectfully submit that 10% of new social housing should be wheelchair accessible, Sir Roger.

01:08:59 - 01:09:10

Roger Gale

Requirement for wheelchair accessible social housing. Question is that new clause 6 be read a second time. Minister.

01:09:10 - 01:11:13

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Roger. New clause 6 tabled by the honourable gentleman seeks to ensure that at least, as he's just argued for, at least 10% of new social housing dwellings meet M4(3) wheelchair accessible standards of the building regulations. I very much commend where he's coming from with this amendment. The government does recognise the importance of increasing the supply of housing for older people and those with disabilities. He's also right that for many years it has been something of a postcode lottery.

That's why the new National Planning Policy Framework recognised the need through planning policy to drive up rates of M4(2) requirements, we've set that minimum floor of 40%, and why when it comes to M4(3), the new NPPF requires plans to set out the proportion that should be delivered to that standard in order to meet or exceed identified need. In our view that's a significant step forward in ensuring more wheelchair accessible housing is delivered. However, we recognise that M4(3) is a specialised product for wheelchair users with levels of need differing considerably between local areas. Our approach, Sir Roger, acknowledges that local authorities are best placed to assess accessible housing needs in their areas and set out appropriate exemptions. A blanket 10% M4(3) requirement would risk undermining these policies set at a local level.

To support this locally-led approach, we've also committed to producing guidance to assist local authorities in assessing the housing needs of disabled people to ensure that assessments of need are robust and consistent. Social Affordable Homes Programme funding can also be used to support the delivery of much-needed new supported housing, including new accessible homes. In our view, national policy remains the most effective route through which planning reform should be pursued. Imposing such a requirement in legislation rather than in policy, as this amendment seeks to do, would be unduly rigid, could limit an authority's ability to respond to local circumstances and constrain growth. We therefore think it's right to continue addressing these matters through planning policy and guidance.

01:11:13 - 01:11:16

Speaker 60

For those reasons, Sir Roger, I kindly ask the honourable gentleman to withdraw the amendment.

01:11:16 - 01:11:32

Gideon Amos

I hear that the Minister has said that we've had these expressions in guidance before and in policy before, and we are still a very long way from having suitable provision for wheelchair accessible homes, and therefore I intend to press this to a vote with leave of the committee, Sir Roger.

01:11:32 - 01:11:35

Roger Gale

Is it your pleasure that the new clause be withdrawn?

01:11:35 - 01:11:37

Gideon Amos

No, I intend to press this to a vote.

01:11:37 - 01:11:40

Speaker 62

You're pressing it to a vote, I'm terribly sorry, I'm finding it quite difficult to hear.

01:11:40 - 01:11:41

I'll speak up a bit louder.

01:11:41 - 01:11:53

Roger Gale

If you would, that would be helpful for me, I'm deaf. The question is that new clause six be read a second time as is indicated on the amendment paper. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:11:55 - 01:11:57

Speaker 65

No.

01:11:57 - 01:12:03

Roger Gale

Division, lock the doors.

01:12:03 - 01:12:32

Speaker 58

Scott Benton. No. Gideon Amos. Aye. Edward Argar.

Abstain. Gareth Bacon. Abstain. Danny Beales. Aye.

Nesil Caliskan. No. Lewis Cocking. Abstain. Deirdre Costigan.

No. Matthew Pennycook. No. John Slinger. No.

Patrick Spencer. Abstain. Laurence Turner. No.

01:12:32 - 01:12:48

Roger Gale

The ayes were one and the noes were seven. The noes have it, unlock. We now come to group 28 and new clause seven, with which it would be convenient to consider new clause nine. Gideon Amos to move new clause seven.

01:12:48 - 01:19:46

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger. I appreciate we're in the meat of the main amendments that I and the Liberal Democrats have tabled, but this is a particularly important amendment given the experience we've had in the recent summer, mitigation of overheating and cooling standards, the cool rule as we would term it. What this amendment would achieve is that new homes, new social homes would achieve where passive measures are not sufficient enough to achieve a reasonable level of cooling, it would require active cooling to supplement the passive cooling sufficient to achieve a temperature of around 21 degrees during periods of high external temperature. We have had an extraordinary summer, have we not, Sir Roger? We witnessed five heatwaves, COBRA was convened, people died in overheated homes.

We passed the Hazards and Social Housing Regulations were passed just last week, adding excess heat as a prescribed hazard that social landlords must address, but the bill has an opportunity to ensure that new homes do not end up in the same state. There are of course the initial I think responses to requiring active cooling are energy considerations and perhaps considerations of urban heat island effect. But when one examines both of those, Sir Roger, it becomes absolutely apparent that we need active cooling in our homes given the change in climate that we have. If one considers the energy consumption, let's remember that we paid, I think it was 260 million pounds to generators of solar and wind energy this year to turn off that generation of electricity and to stop using it. We have surplus electricity being generated, particularly in the summer in the hotter months, which we are not using and we cannot use.

In fact, there is an argument for electrification in a whole range of other fields as well as this so that that demand can be used and the renewables industry can be recompensed for that generation. We are not using taxpayers' money to turn off such generation, so there is no shortage of electricity for active cooling which we desperately need in our homes.

The urban heat island effect is something which of course concerns me, as I'm sure it does many others who are concerned with our changing climate. But interestingly, research from the University of Manchester has studied the impact and the additional loading of air conditioning on buildings on the urban heat island effect. And what it's concluded is that it accounts for approximately one degree Celsius of heating, compared to the amount of cooling that can be provided simply by shading the exterior of a building with trees or other shading, which is about 12 degrees of 12 degrees Celsius. So it's the contribution made by air conditioning and other cooling systems is negligible to the heat urban heat island effect. So without either of those objections, and with the focus remaining on passive cooling first in new buildings, we need to move to a position where we are making our new homes cool enough, not just warm enough, obviously in the winter.

And we discussed that, do we not, and the warm homes grant was a I won't go into in great detail, but it should perhaps become a better homes grant so that we can use those grants to provide cooling in homes that desperately need existing homes that desperately need it as well. But in this bill we are considering new social homes, and surely we must ensure that new housing stock is not going to overheat in the way we've seen this summer, given that by some experts, the recent summer we've had, although incredibly hot, will be the coolest we ever have. So we need to enter a new era of thinking about our homes, about social homes in particular, and how they are cooled. And it's on that basis that we've put forward this amendment in new clause whatever it was, Sir Roger. And because I know the committee likes me to keep things moving along and keep proceedings running fast and smooth, I will, with your leave, Sir Roger, I'll also cover new clause nine, which stands in my name in this group, which is zero carbon standards for new social housing.

We recognize that the new building regulations and I will I'm happy to present this as a probing amendment, Sir Roger. We recognize that the a welcome nods from the other side of the committee chamber. We welcome the changes that have been made to building regulations in terms of the future home standard being embedded in the regulations in the recent regulations which come into force in April. I was interested in listening to the Chancellor in the chamber yesterday. I was interested in his statement that there will be effectively a moratorium on new building regulations changes for the next for this Parliament, which the rationale for which I understand.

But can I can I genuinely ask the Minister to clarify whether the regulations that have been passed, which come into force in April, will remain in force? Including within that package, of course, was my honorable friend the Member for Cheltenham's private member's sunshine bill, which would require solar photovoltaic panels on all new homes as standard, which is very important and something that knocking on doors people often raise with me, as why can't all these new homes have solar panels? So could we have an assurance that the I've almost finished. I want to say that the those regulations, despite what the Chancellor said yesterday, will continue to come into force in April and are not affected by the moratorium. Just reverting to new clause seven on the cool roof, we will be pushing new clause seven to a vote, indeed I on this occasion will be pushing new clause seven to a vote, but not the other clause.

Thank you, Sir Roger.

01:19:46 - 01:19:55

Roger Gale

Mitigation of overheating and cooling standards, the core rule. Question is that new clause 7 be read a second time. Minister.

01:19:55 - 01:21:45

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Roger. Can I thank the honorable member for Taunton and Wellington for tabling new clause 7, which I will start with. He's absolutely right to draw attention to overheating, and I can assure him that the government recognizes the scale of the challenge it presents. Overheating in homes is already a severe public health issue. It will obviously, for the reasons he's rightly stated, only grow more acute in the years ahead.

We know there are health risks and implications for excess deaths for particularly vulnerable populations. Sir Roger, we take it extremely seriously, and we agree that new homes should protect everyone from the risk of overheating. That is why Part O of Schedule 1 to the Building Regulations requires that new residential buildings in England are built to mitigate the risk of overheating. The government continues to keep these requirements under review, and a full technical review of Part O is currently underway to ensure that the framework remains effective and proportionate. These requirements already apply to newly built social housing, ensuring residents benefit from the same standards of overheating mitigation regardless of their tenure type.

The accompanying statutory guidance, Approved Document O, sets out how these requirements can be met. This amendment would require active cooling, such as air conditioning, to be installed wherever an indoor temperature of 21 degrees Celsius cannot be maintained. Conversely, Part O assesses the risk to health posed by overheating through an evidence-based methodology and does not rely on a single prescribed temperature threshold. Part O also, Sir Roger, prioritizes passive measures, such as shading and natural ventilation, which help prevent homes from becoming too hot in the first place. In many cases, overheating can be effectively mitigated through passive measures alone, so Part O helps create homes that are resilient to hot weather while limiting energy use, carbon emissions, and energy bills for residents.

I will give way.

01:21:45 - 01:22:04

Gideon Amos

Apologies for interrupting the minister in his flow, and grateful for allowing the intervention. It's just to clarify that the amendment is sets out that only where it cannot be achieved otherwise is active cooling proposed. So the priority for passive measures in this amendment would continue.

01:22:04 - 01:24:55

Matthew Pennycook

I welcome that clarification from the honorable gentleman. What I was going to come on to say is that Part O doesn't prohibit any form of active cooling where designers can demonstrate that it is appropriate. Part O, as I've said, encourages passive design measures before relying on mechanical systems. And as I've said, in many cases, overheating can be effectively mitigated through passive measures, but mechanical cooling, such as air conditioning, can be used to mitigate overheating where all reasonable, reasonably practical steps have been taken to minimize overheating through passive means. And for those reasons, we think this amendment would likely increase the unnecessary use of mechanical cooling with associated costs for developers and residents.

For these reasons, I'd kindly ask the honorable member to withdraw new clause 7. Turning to new clause 9, which concerns zero-carbon standards for new social housing. The government fully recognizes the importance of ensuring that new homes, including social housing, support our legally binding net-zero target. We share the honorable member's ambition to deliver homes that are energy-efficient, low-carbon, and fit for the future. That is exactly what the Future Homes Standard will achieve.

The reassurance I was going to give him in not intervening was that that is not affected by the Chancellor's announcement yesterday of an effective moratorium on major new regulations, setting aside the qualifications he set out at the dispatch box in regard to building safety issues. But the government, Sir Roger, legislated for the Future Homes Standard in March of this year.

It will come into force for non-higher-risk buildings from the 24th of March next year, and from the 24th of September 2027 for higher-risk buildings. It will apply to all new homes, including social housing. Homes built to this standard will have high levels of energy efficiency, use low-carbon heating, and in most cases generate renewable electricity on site. These homes will also be zero-carbon ready, meaning they will produce very little carbon and become zero-carbon once the national grid is fully decarbonised without requiring further retrofit. And that is the really important point.

We are retrofitting homes that have been built over recent years because of the decision of a previous government to remove the required standards that were in place, at great cost. We could go into that, it's outside the scope of the bill, we could go into the cost that that entails. But we are ensuring that these new homes that come forward once the standard is in place are zero-carbon ready, they don't require further retrofit. And the government has also worked carefully to set a standard that delivers substantial carbon savings while remaining proportionate, technically feasible, and deliverable at scale. Introducing, in our view, further new standards risks creating a separate and potentially inconsistent regulatory regime for social housing, as well as additional costs and delivery pressures for the sector.

So while I agree with the objective behind this new clause, in our view, the Future Homes Standard already provides the appropriate means of achieving it. And for those reasons, I again respectfully ask the honourable gentleman to withdraw new clause 9.

01:24:55 - 01:24:57

Speaker 69

Mr Amos.

01:24:57 - 01:25:49

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger. With respect to new clause 7, the cooling rule, I appreciate that the minister points out that there is no prohibition on active cooling being used in new homes. But the fact is that we need to actually secure cooling. We can't just leave it to, you know, the most luxury, the most luxury accommodation that has cooling in these extremely hot summers that we're having. We need to have a requirement, just as we have requirements for other, for other habitable standards of space, of daylight, of heating.

So we also need a statutory standard of cooling. And if it doesn't come today, Sir Roger, I believe it will come. I do wish to push this new clause to a vote. Thank you, Sir Roger.

01:25:49 - 01:25:58

Roger Gale

New clause 7 proposed as on the order paper. The question is that new clause 7 be read a second time. Many of that opinion say aye.

01:26:01 - 01:26:03

Speaker 70

Division. Lock the doors.

01:26:03 - 01:26:06

Speaker 76

Division 11. Segal Abdiwali.

01:26:09 - 01:26:10

Edward Argar.

01:26:11 - 01:26:12

Gareth Bacon.

01:26:13 - 01:26:14

Danny Beales.

01:26:14 - 01:26:16

Speaker 73

No.

01:26:16 - 01:26:17

Hazel Cheeseman.

01:26:18 - 01:26:19

Lewis Cocking.

01:26:19 - 01:26:21

Speaker 72

Abstain.

01:26:21 - 01:26:22

Deirdre Costigan.

01:26:23 - 01:26:24

Matthew Pennycook.

01:26:25 - 01:26:26

John Slinger.

01:26:27 - 01:26:28

Patrick Spencer.

01:26:29 - 01:26:30

Laurence Turner.

01:26:30 - 01:26:34

Speaker 75

No.

01:26:34 - 01:26:49

Roger Gale

The ayes were one, the noes were seven, so the noes have it. Keep the doors locked just for the moment. New clause 8 has already been debated in group 12. Mr Amos, do you wish to move new clause 8 formally?

01:26:49 - 01:26:51

Speaker 74

Withdraw.

01:26:51 - 01:26:54

Roger Gale

Is it your pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn?

01:26:55 - 01:27:04

Roger Gale

Amendment by leave withdrawn. We now come to new clause 9, which has already been debated in group 28, and Mr Amos, I think you indicated that was a probing amendment.

01:27:04 - 01:27:06

Speaker 71

Yes, withdraw.

01:27:06 - 01:27:09

Roger Gale

Is it your pleasure that the, that new clause 9 be withdrawn?

01:27:10 - 01:27:57

Roger Gale

Did somebody say yes? Amendment by leave withdrawn. We now come to group 29 and new clause 10. Um, sorry, just before we do, in the light of one or two things that have been said this morning, where a lead amendment is grouped with others, you don't need to seek permission to speak to those other amendments. Only the lead amendment is moved at that time, but you can speak to any of the others that I call as a group with the others.

If they are reached and if a division is required, that will take place later in the procedure. I said it was arcane, it is.

Group 29, new clause 10. Mr. Amos to move new clause 10.

01:27:57 - 01:30:46

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger. And I'm incredibly heartened by your experience of Parliament and your statement that you find it arcane. If you find it arcane, Sir, I can only imagine how those of us who only came into the chamber recently find it. But appreciate your clarification on that, Sir Roger. I will be very brief in this new clause, really to highlight the frustration that many feel when they see social housing quotas reduced having gone through the planning system, having been negotiated, having been promised a certain level of genuinely affordable housing that local people can access, only then to find that the applicant has renegotiated that consent, has argued viability, and therefore has in frequent occasions removed all affordable housing.

In fact, there's an example my honorable friend the member for St. Ives and the Isles of Scilly brought to me where an exception site included around 40% social housing as an exception on an exception site, and that permission was in place. But since the government's new standard method renders nearly all authorities unable to meet their five-year housing supply, it's created a free-for-all in which the inspector had no alternative, the government's inspector had no alternative but to conclude that because the five-year housing supply cannot be met, as it can't be met in nearly all authorities given the new methodology, the appeal removed all the social housing from that permission, leaving so an existing permission on an exception site had social housing and private housing, but by appeal due to the new standard method, the inspector concluded he had no alternative, no option but to remove all the social housing from that permission and revert it all to private housing. So an exception site that was originally only granted permission because it was an exception, because it would deliver social housing, is now entirely private market housing, which people in Cornwall who live locally will not be able to access and not have any advantage from. So the frustration of communities, I think, is strong in terms of seeing how these consents are undermined at later stages. And this amendment seeks to rectify that by preventing the arguing down of those numbers.

And I submit it on that basis respectfully to the committee.

01:30:46 - 01:30:56

Roger Gale

No reduction in social housing secured through planning permissions or obligations. Question is that new clause 10 be read a second time. Minister.

01:30:56 - 01:33:10

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Roger. New clause 10 seeks to prevent local planning authorities from agreeing to any reduction in the number or proportion of social homes required through a planning obligation or planning condition. Sir Roger, the government is committed to strengthening the system of developer contributions to ensure that new developments provide necessary affordable homes and infrastructure, and we've already taken a number of steps to that end. The new NPPF published on the 17th of August seeks to promote greater clarity on expected contributions at the plan-making stage and reduce cases of unnecessary site-specific viability assessment by clarifying when it may be appropriate at the decision-making stage.

This certainty will help to minimize lengthy negotiations over developer contributions, including of affordable housing, when it comes to specific sites. At the same time, the framework will retain flexibility for those cases where negotiation is genuinely needed to enable sites to come forward. We're also acting, Sir Roger, to minimize friction and reduce the complexity involved in the negotiation of section 106 agreements, which are and will remain an essential mechanism for delivering social and affordable housing, but in recent years have become synonymous with inefficiency and delay. The new NPPF formally introduces the category of medium development sites of up to two and a half hectares in an area and between 10 and 49 units. It also provides the basis for the use of model obligations, as policy DM6 subsection 4 states that where model obligations are relevant to a development, they should be used unless there is a strong reason for using a different obligation.

And following this, Sir Roger, we launched a consultation on four standardized planning agreements for medium-sized sites, which will be expected to become the default for relevant applications in the future. The consultation closed on the 20th of October 2026, and we are considering the responses received. Sir Roger, the proper process for modifying or discharging planning obligations is set out in section 106A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. I know the honorable gentleman knows this, he's got great experience in this area from his experience before he came to the House. As set out in my letter to the Planning Inspectorate earlier this year, attempts to revisit fundamental issues of viability or planning obligations through section 73 applications should be carefully scrutinized and supported by robust justification, with due weight given to the impact of any reduction in affordable housing delivery and the wider merits of the scheme.

01:33:10 - 01:33:12

Speaker 80

I hope that helps.

01:33:12 - 01:33:50

Gideon Amos

Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Sir Roger, and I'm grateful to the Minister, and I'm grateful to him for engaging on all of these amendments, including this one. I do think there is a really important, my question is whether he and the government recognize that the example that I cited, that because of the standard method, many, many, in fact most authorities in Southern England cannot meet the five-year housing supply, and because of that, social housing, affordable housing is being removed from planning permissions. And has the government, is the government concerned about that? Is it doing any assessment of how much this is happening?

01:33:50 - 01:38:11

Matthew Pennycook

Minister. I'm going to be careful because the honorable gentleman will be fully aware, given the role of MHCLG ministers in the planning system, I obviously can't comment on any particular local plans or particular applications. I don't know the specific circumstances in that case that he cites. I think I'd make the general point, and it picks up on something that the shadow minister, I think, mentioned earlier. When we arrived in office, housebuilders across the country were telling us that in the main, the planning system was probably the biggest barrier to housebuilding that they faced.

Following the reforms we have made to national planning policy, they no longer say that. Viability, as the honorable gentleman has rightly highlights, viability is the chief concern at the moment. Viability pressures across the country are acute. In certain parts of the country, they are particularly severe. London is a good example.

So viability is bearing on schemes and what they can bring forward. I struggle, if I'm honest, to see the direct link between the standard method, five-year housing land supply. We could have a wider discussion here and I outside the chamber on that and the HDT concerns that I know he's raised in the past. I'm trying, Sir Roger, to remain focused on the intent behind the clause, which is around planning obligations and conditions. I've just set out the government's position on section 73, alongside ongoing work relating to the implementation of section 73B of the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act.

The government intends to undertake a wider review of the statutory framework for modifying or discharging existing planning obligations and will provide further details about this in due course. But I am clear, and I hope this will reassure the honorable gentleman in respect of section 73B, our intention in reviewing this matter is not to allow developers to more easily reduce planning obligations already entered into, including for affordable housing.

Sir Roger, the government has also acted to deal with the detrimental consequences of a declining market for section 106 affordable homes. We've already taken a number of steps to support demand for section 106 units, not least spending review measures designed to rebuild the capacity of registered providers. As a result, we are seeing tentative signs of improvement in appetite for acquiring section 106 homes. However, despite this positive shift in sentiment post-spending review, we know there are still housing schemes where developers remain unable to secure an RP buyer for the affordable homes set out in an original section 106 agreement, and where local planning authorities and developers have not discussed or reached agreement on variations to planning obligations, with the result that many of these sites are stalling. It's for that reason that we made clear in a written ministerial statement on the 28th of January that we expect all local planning authorities to take advantage of existing planning flexibilities to renegotiate section 106 agreements and allow the tenure of homes to be varied in order to secure a buyer where affordable homes secured in section 106 agreements remain uncontracted or unsold.

As he will know, this can be effected by a deed of variation making amendments, revisions to existing section 106 agreements, either by agreement of the parties to the 106 or by formal application under section 106A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. Our concern, to directly pick up on his amendment, our concern about new clause 10 is that it could create unintended consequences. It may be contrary to our shared objective to boost the supply of social and affordable housing. It is important, notwithstanding his concerns, which I do recognise, that the system retains sufficient flexibility for local planning authorities to respond to significant changes in site or economic circumstances after planning permission has been granted, such as a recession or similar significant economic change. And we are concerned that new clause 10 could unduly restrict that flexibility, which could, and this is the ultimate point, could cause sites to stall and subsequently reduce overall housing delivery, including overall social and affordable housing delivery.

I suspect that I won't have convinced the honourable gentleman entirely, but I hope he can agree that where we are in terms of the system as it stands carefully balances the need for that flexibility. We're trying to ensure that we maximise the amount of social and affordable housing supply that can be secured, but we should avoid legislation which imposes, in our view, an unreasonable degree of rigidity, while obviously continuing our efforts to increase affordable housing delivery overall. I hope on that basis he might be content, persuaded to withdraw on this occasion.

01:38:11 - 01:38:13

Roger Gale

Mr. Amos.

01:38:13 - 01:39:18

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Roger. I appreciate the minister's correct analysis that there is a balance here to be struck with individual sites. I accept that. The direct link between the standard method and the loss of social housing is that the standard method, having come in, means that local plans are now, most of them, no longer able to meet five-year housing supply, which means most local plans are no longer effective. And therefore, an inspector presented by a developer with a site with social housing and private housing in it is forced to conclude on appeal on that, on a section 73 application to amend it, is forced to conclude that there is no longer an exception which should justify social housing because all sites have to come forward and they all have to be market housing.

And that's the effect of imposing the standard method and rendering so many local plans no longer effective.

01:39:18 - 01:39:39

Matthew Pennycook

Can I, not responding to his point, but just make this offer to him because I'm genuine interested. He will know that we have tried to strengthen national policy when it comes to rural exception sites through the new NPPF. I'm very interested if he thinks that there are particular reasons why that strengthening won't have the desired effect or other barriers to bringing forward those sites.

We want more of those sites to be brought forward precisely for the reasons he's setting out.

01:39:39 - 01:40:11

Gideon Amos

It's very generous of the Minister and I will take up the offer writing to him with the appeal decision, which is a completed decision now, so it's not, it wouldn't involve Ministers in interfering in any, in any decision. You're able to see the effect and I think we need to understand how much that is happening across the country if we're losing social homes all over. With that, I'll, I'll come to a conclusion, Sir Roger, and I would aim to push this to a vote, yes please.

01:40:11 - 01:40:17

Roger Gale

New clause 10 proposed as on the order paper. The question is that new clause 10 be read a second time. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:40:19 - 01:40:21

Roger Gale

Division. Lock the doors.

01:40:21 - 01:40:25

Speaker 84

Division in 11. Sagal Abdi-Wali.

01:40:28 - 01:40:29

Edward Argar.

01:40:30 - 01:40:30

Gareth Bacon.

01:40:31 - 01:40:32

Danny Beales.

01:40:33 - 01:40:34

Hazel Borland-Boyce.

01:40:35 - 01:40:36

Lewis Cocking.

01:40:37 - 01:40:38

Deirdre Costigan.

01:40:39 - 01:40:40

Anthony Higginbotham.

01:40:41 - 01:40:42

John Slinger.

01:40:43 - 01:40:44

Patrick Spencer.

01:40:45 - 01:40:46

Laurence Turner.

01:40:46 - 01:40:54

Speaker 86

No.

01:40:54 - 01:41:04

Roger Gale

The ayes are one, the noes are seven, so the noes have it. Unlock. We now come to group 13 and new clause 11. Gideon Amos to move new clause 11.

01:41:04 - 01:41:09

Speaker 83

Sir Roger, I beg to move that the debate be now adjourned.

01:41:09 - 01:41:15

Roger Gale

Ah, that's what the note says. Thank you very much. Question is that the sitting be now adjourned. As many of that opinion say aye.

01:41:16 - 01:41:22

Roger Gale

Contrary no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it. The doors will be locked. If members wish to leave papers in here, they may do so.