House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsLauren Edwards
It is a broader principle that we must consider as a House today. Who ultimately decides the laws that govern our nation?
Many members would no doubt prefer to be working in their constituencies today. They are not because a small number of peers in the other place chose to prevent any votes taking place on the substance of that bill. I will, once I've concluded my opening remarks. That decision means that one of the most significant national conversations that we have been having as legislators was brought to an abrupt halt. And who suffers detriment as a result?
Clearly the terminally ill and their families, who had a fair assumption that the will of the people they elected to represent them in this chamber would be respected.
But also those who must navigate our current unclear laws. Laws that do not protect or guide those who work in our health system. Laws that do not contain safeguards against the risks of coercion. And laws that criminalise and traumatise families who simply want to be with their loved ones at the moment of their death. Laws that four directors of public prosecutions have urged need to change.
If we do not vote today to allow this bill to continue its passage through Parliament, then we accept those outcomes as the cost of maintaining the status quo.
And who knows how long it will be before we get the opportunity to consider the introduction of assisted dying laws again, despite consistent polling showing that it receives majority public support.
Jim Shannon
I thank the honorable lady for what the bill hopes to achieve. She cannot, the honorable lady cannot ignore the overwhelming 68% of the public believe that the assisted dying bill must be paused. The 73% of people say the bill should be rejected outright. The public sees the danger. This House must halt the process, pause the bill, and instead focus on properly funding world-class palliative care.
Lauren Edwards
I thank the honorable member for his intervention. I think we do need to be very careful when we're quoting polling, certainly in the last few weeks, when we know that, for instance, a Whitestone Insight has been criticized heavily by the British Polling Organization in recent weeks about failing to meet their standards in terms of disclosing who has been funding their research.
So the reference that I'm making here is to those very robust independent polls, such as the British Attitude Survey, which in 2024 found 73% of the British public supported assisted dying and has done so over the last 20 years. I'm sorry, I'll keep going. I'll make some progress. I'll give way.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honorable lady talks about who makes our laws and has talked in articles she's written about the primacy of this place. So if this bill were to go forward, is she willing to accept amendments to this bill? Because she has brought forward an exact same bill despite the sponsor in the House of Lords saying himself that there needed to be 77 amendments to make this bill safer.
Lauren Edwards
Thank you, I think for that intervention. It's not quite the exact same bill, it does incorporate two amendments that were agreed without a vote in the House of Lords last time. What I will be asking members to do is to, we have had our conversation in this chamber about this bill in 2025. We have had an interrupted conversation as a nation, and I will be asking the members of this House to send the bill back to the House of Lords so that they can continue their important work of amending and scrutinising legislation.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Does she agree with me that unless this House makes it absolutely clear that it's outrageous and unacceptable for a very small number of unelected peers to block legislation supported by the elected chamber, the same tactic could be used again with any private member's bill that comes forward in this House?
Lauren Edwards
Absolutely, it would be setting a dangerous precedent. And for those members who want to come in on specifics of the Parliament Act, there will be ample opportunity later in my speech, and I'll be willing to take interventions on that. I'll make some progress. I pay tribute to my honourable friend, the member for Spen Valley, and the courage, courtesy, and openness she showed during the passage of her bill. Her engagement with those from all sides of the debate, particularly during the committee stage, delivered a stronger bill which this House voted for at report stage and third reading.
And one strengthening was the introduction of a requirement for the Health Secretary to report regularly on the availability, quality, and distribution of palliative care. And in asking parliamentarians to consider assisted dying, my honourable friend also prompted a national conversation about how we improve and fund palliative care. And we saw more funding for hospices and government action to develop a new framework to improve palliative care and end-of-life care.
Anna Dixon
I thank my honourable friend, and as the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Hospices and End of Life Care, I wonder whether my honourable friend shares the concern that given there are an estimated 170,000 people who die in this country each year without access to palliative and end-of-life care, there can be no choice until hospice and end-of-life care are properly funded.
Lauren Edwards
I thank her for her intervention and I think it's absolutely right that for instance the Prime Minister and the government have said that improving palliative care must be a priority for him and his government and I think that's something that we can all support. I think everybody should have access to good quality palliative and hospice end-of-life care at their final moments. No, I'll make some progress. But as acknowledged by organizations that provide that care, their services cannot address pain and suffering in all circumstances and during the passage of the bill in the last parliamentary session, we heard examples of the limits of palliative care from members with medical expertise themselves. No, I'll make some progress.
We heard difficult stories about patients with bile duct cancer facing the prospect of fecal vomiting as their illness progressed. We listened as they recounted memories of watching patients bleed to death while conscious, I will in a moment, cancer having eaten away at their carotid artery. We felt their frustration when the maximum dose of sedatives could not alleviate the choking and suffocation of someone with peritoneal cancer. These people deserved choice and a dignified end.
Zubir Ahmed
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I reassure my honourable friend as a practicing surgeon that deals with bowel cancer that there is almost never a reason why someone should be in that state with faeculent vomiting if they were treated appropriately and all of the relevant palliative care measures were in place?
Lauren Edwards
So I, the position that I take is that we can and we must improve both palliative care and supported assisted dying. Thank you. We must grasp that opportunity in front of us to create a holistic end-of-life care system that will deliver choice and dignity for every single one of our constituents.
Wendy Morton
Grateful to the honourable lady for giving way because on this very specific point of hospices, I absolutely understand what she's saying. I've visited our local hospices. I've sat beside my father when he was dying, but not in a hospice. This absolutely matters, the point of palliative care. But the government doesn't recognise the funding that the sector needs.
There is a postcode lottery and the ministers aren't even answering WPQs.
So until that is fixed, we shouldn't be having this debate. Does she agree?
Lauren Edwards
I thank her for her intervention and I would point out that the four-year implementation period at the end of this bill, if it received royal assent, would give us the opportunity to work together to improve palliative care and assisted dying, create that holistic end-of-life care system that I referred to. The four-year implementation period means that nobody would be receiving assisted dying until 2031 at the earliest. That would be too late for many people, but it would be plenty of time to make improvements in palliative care, have them go hand in hand with providing the choice of an assisted death for those who still need it.
Simon Hoare
I'm very grateful to the honourable lady for giving way and she's making a principled argument which the House must listen to and respect. But she has spoken about choice and dignity. The one thing I have never understood about this bill is the importance of it being six months. If there is to be choice and dignity, and if people are in pain and the condition is terminal, what is the sanctity of six months? If the principle of choice and dignity underpin the bill, surely six months is way too narrow.
Lauren Edwards
Thank him for his intervention.
So obviously members have previously raised concerns around doctors getting the prognosis wrong in terms of how long someone is able to live. My understanding is that six months, having looked at the international evidence, was a reasonable point to draw because as it gets closer to the time of death, the accuracy of the diagnosis is increased. I would like now, no, I'm sorry, I won't give way. I would like to thank all those who took part in the debate on this bill in the chamber in the last parliamentary session. We showed politics at its best through our robust but courteous debates.
We did our job and we did it well. And now it is time for us to send this assisted bill dying back to the House of Lords so they can finish what they started.
Whatever our respective views on the form and composition of the second chamber, I hope that we can agree that peers play an important role in scrutinising, refining and strengthening the legislation that we send them.
Alec Edward Shelbrooke
I am extremely grateful to the honourable lady and she's outlined the will of this house. But at the last bill she may recall at Prime Minister's questions I asked the then Prime Minister to do what's happened with similar bills in the past on homosexuality, abortion, the death penalty, and that was to give committee time to the whole house on the floor of the house. That would massively strengthen amendments that are made by using the whole of the house to go up. Now that is a choice of the government front bench. So may I ask the honourable lady, is she going to lobby her own government to give proper scrutiny to everybody in this house for committee stage?
Lauren Edwards
I thank him for his intervention. The government has been clear, as the previous government of the previous Prime Minister was clear, that it remains neutral on assisted dying, but has responsibilities to make sure that the legislation that we bring forward is workable. And certainly that's the assurances that we have received at third reading when we voted in favor of it as a chamber. No. I am asking you today to start the process of sending this bill back to them so that they can continue their important function of fulfilling their important constitutional role.
Joseph Simon Opher
Can I thank the honorable lady for giving way and giving an incredibly strong speech as well. What I would say is as part of the core committee, we gave about 200 hours of assessment to this bill, much more than most government bills, and indeed the Lords have had an enormous amount of time to consider it as well.
So saying there hasn't been enough scrutiny is simply wrong.
Lauren Edwards
I thank him for his intervention and I would also point out and tell members to be in no doubt that the bill we sent them last year was robust. It was expertly drafted by the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel and developed with comprehensive technical advice from officials in both the Department of Health and Social Care and the Ministry of Justice. I'll make a little bit more progress please. Although neutral on the issue of assisted dying, then as now, as I mentioned, the government has a duty to ensure that any legislation that Parliament passes is effective, legally robust and is workable. And I am confident saying to this House that the bill before us today is a well-designed, safe piece of legislation.
Marsha Cordova
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
And the honorable lady is making a good case for this bill. But she will know, when the bill was introduced in 2024, there was no equality impact assessment carried out. Recently the government have published it and it really does highlight the disproportionate impact that this bill will have on black and ethnic minority communities and disabled people. There is nothing in this bill to address that.
Lauren Edwards
So I would start by saying this bill is explicit that it does not apply to people with a disability.
Richard Burgon
On that point, on that very point, will you please give way? I thank my honorable friend for giving way.
Of course, what we're considering today is not the general principle of do we or do we not agree with assisted dying, it's this bill, because we are not a debating society, we are a parliament. So therefore, can I ask the honorable member why it's the case that there isn't virtually a single disabled people's organization in this country which supports the bill? Disabled people often feel voiceless. I think it's important that their voices are heard today. They're outside parliament, so I would like my honorable friend to address that in her speech.
Lauren Edwards
I would be very happy to address that, and I would say there is not a uniform view amongst disabled people on the issue of assisted dying. No, there, within, like with anything, within organizations, there are people who arrive at different views. And I think it's important that we are giving disabled people the same rights as other people. And it is very clear in the bill that it is for adults aged over 18 who have a terminal illness and who only have six months to live. And it specifically makes clear that this does not apply to people that have a disability.
Speaker 20
The member has made it clear she's not taking interventions at this point. Lauren Edwards.
Lauren Edwards
Thank you. So as has been mentioned, the bill has been subject to hundreds of hours of scrutiny and amendments made to strengthen its safeguards. But that doesn't mean it can't be strengthened further. As with any bill, it will benefit from additional scrutiny.
The bill before us today already includes an important clarification on eating disorders that was agreed without a vote in the House of Lords last time. And together with the co-sponsor of the bill in the House of Lords, Lord Falconer, who's in the gallery today, I've recently met representatives from medical bodies and hospice organisations to discuss further amendments that could be made in the other place.
Gavin Robinson
I'm very grateful to the honourable lady for allowing me to intervene. And she mentions that the government have a responsibility to ensure this legislation is lawful and it is workable. Yet she is the bill sponsor. That responsibility rests on her too. And yet despite knowing that the bill sponsor in the previous session brought forward over 30 amendments of her own and eight new clauses, and the bill sponsor in the Lords brought forward 77, a recognition that this bill is manifestly unworkable, she has chosen not to amend her bill.
Lauren Edwards
I would disagree with the position that any time we amend a bill in this place, it means that the bill is ultimately deficient and unworkable. That's not how it works. All I am asking the chamber to do today is to send the bill back to the House of Lords so that they can continue their work, which was interrupted, scrutinising the bill.
Sam Rushworth
Quick question on that point. I do thank the good member, she's being very generous with interventions. I wonder if she would be willing to share with the House what, if any, amendments that the Lords made besides the two that she's mentioned, that she personally thinks should have been added to the bill, and if she does feel they should be, why they weren't.
Lauren Edwards
There are a number of amendments around points of clarification that I think are quite important where people feel that the words, although they seem robust to me, some external organisations would like them to be made a little bit clearer. So those points of clarification are ones that certainly I believe can be made in the House of Lords. No, I'll make some progress. Taking the approach that I have outlined respects both the will of this House, as already expressed in June 2025, and allows the usual parliamentary processes to continue. No, by giving way on that point.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
Erskine May gives this House a way to send what is called suggested amendments to the Lords as a separate motion alongside this bill when it goes to the other place. Now, it has not been used since 2004, but does the honourable member recognise that if some members of this House wish to send suggested amendments that they think are crucial for this bill at the same time, they can do so?
Lauren Edwards
Yes, that is a part of our usual parliamentary process and she's right to raise that. But by sending the bill back to the Lords as it stands, we will prevent that same small group of peers who talked it out last time from doing the same thing again. And it is my fervent wish that the peers, all peers, no, I'm sorry, I'll make some progress. It is my fervent wish that all the peers in the House of Lords will accept that important distinction between their chamber and ours and fulfill their role in the usual way. In doing so, they can consider and send an amended bill back to us for a final vote before Royal Assent.
No, I'll make some progress.
If at that point, members of this House decide to vote the bill down, I and many others in this chamber and outside this chamber would be upset and disappointed. But I would accept the result because it would have been as a result of the proper democratic processes being followed. What I cannot accept, and what many people both inside and outside of this chamber cannot accept, is the current situation. A situation in which a small number of unelected peers filibustered legislation that was supported by this chamber. This is not how our democracy is supposed to function.
John Hayes
Extremely grateful to the honorable lady whose speech is a series of oxymorons. She doesn't like polling that's against the bill, but likes it if it's in favor.
She feels the bill should be amended in the House of Lords, but not with amendments that would improve safeguards. And on the subject of safeguards, will she explain to the House why the previous bill, which once had legal safeguards in order to assuage doubts about its efficacy, were entirely dropped?
Lauren Edwards
They were dropped in favor of a stronger safeguard, which was a multidisciplinary panel of people with different perspectives who were trained in spotting coercion, psychiatrists, a legal expert, bringing us... So yeah, bringing other people in, a social worker, different perspectives to ensure that the person taking the assisted death decision was doing so in an informed and settled way, free from coercion. That was dropped because it was a strengthening of the bill, not a weakening. I'm going to make some progress. I'm going to make some progress.
Members took the best part of a year to grapple with this issue. You spoke to your constituents, you engaged with the organisations that would be affected, you read your materials, you thought deeply and you consulted your conscience. And you arrived at a decision, whatever that decision was in terms of how you voted, or indeed even if you didn't vote at all. But it was a difficult process. And it is not acceptable that the outcome of those deliberations has not been respected.
We owe it to the, no, we owe it to the people that we represent to find a resolution on this issue one way or another within this Parliament.
Simon Hoare
I'm very grateful to the honorable lady for giving way a second time. On that basis, and this is the democratically accountable House, I think we'll all agree on that point, is she prepared to accept in committee and at report, if this bill secures a second reading this afternoon, is she prepared to accept amendments authored, debated, and voted upon by members of Parliament?
Lauren Edwards
We have been through that process. There was a committee that had hundreds of hours of scrutiny that properly kicked the tires on the robustness of this legislation. What we need to do as a House is to send a bill back to the House of Lords so they can finish their job. We did ours. As important as the democratic point of principle is to the argument that I make today, we must not lose sight of the people who are most relying on us, the terminally ill and their families.
And the gallery today is filled with inspirational people campaigning for this much-needed change in the law. People who themselves are terminally ill and who, due to the passage of time, may never get the opportunity to choose a dignified death surrounded by their loved ones, but who nevertheless spend the time they have left campaigning so that others in future may have that choice. No, I'm sorry, I won't. People like Christie Arnsten, who has lived with incurable metastatic breast cancer for more than a decade. And this has sadly returned for the fifth time, and she is undergoing what may be her final treatment of chemotherapy.
Christy speaks eloquently about the way her fear of a difficult death has weighed on her mind since her diagnosis and affected her life. She says, "For me, the scariest part of having the diagnosis was that I had no control over the last few weeks of my life. If I had known that assisted dying was an option, a weight would have been lifted from my mind for the last 10 years." And this is the cost of accepting the status quo: the fear and worry for those who know that palliative care may not be enough to avoid a difficult and painful death. I'll make a little bit more progress.
It snatches away their final moments, and moments that I know from speaking to friends and family in Australia can be much better spent when there is a safe, voluntary assisted dying system in place.
Speaker 29
I thank the honorable lady for being so generous with her time. I wonder, though, if she is aware of the sheer number of palliative care consultants that are not prepared to take part in assisted dying and the impact that that will have on the palliative care system. In my constituency, all three palliative care doctors who work in Plymouth's Derriford Hospital are against assisted dying and are saying that they will leave the profession. So how can we offer palliative care at the same time as assisted dying?
Lauren Edwards
Thank you for the intervention. I would point out there are a range of views amongst the palliative care community, and that is specifically why the bill allows them not to be involved in the process if they don't wish to. It's specifically for that reason. No, I'll... no.
I would like to end with the words of Elise Burns, who like me called Kent home, and who sadly died in July with secondary cancer of the lungs, liver and bones. And she said, "I would love peers to look me in the eye and tell me why me and my friends and anyone with terminal illness doesn't deserve to die with dignity and to have the choice to die without pain." We owe it to terminally ill people like Elise, who are relying on us and who were so filled with hope when we voted in favor last time. Quite rightly, they cannot understand how, having secured the support of the people they elected to represent them, the issue that is so important to them has been frustrated by a small group of people with no democratic mandate.
The important conversation that we have been having on assisted dying as legislators and as a society has been interrupted. To leave it so would have a profoundly negative impact on people's trust in our political system. If we fail to support the bill at second reading today, are we not saying that it's fine for a minority of unelected peers to defy the will of the House of Commons? Are we really prepared to concede that point and accept the consequences, not only for this vital legislation, but for future legislation too? So I ask honourable members to join me today in sending a clear message that the will of this chamber should be respected on behalf of all the people that we represent.
And I ask you today to support giving this bill a second reading.
Speaker 1
The question is that the bill be now read a second time and I now turn to Dame Karen Bradley.
Karen Bradley
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a very difficult day. No one could be failed to be moved by the grief of campaigners, by deeply personal stories, whether born of their own experience or of the experience of those they have lost. And those voices deserve to be heard. And it is important in this place that we respect all views, whether we agree or disagree.
But as we deliberate today, I go back to the words of the honourable member for Bradford, who spoke in the previous time we debated this. And she asked us to remember the quiet ones, those who may be less organised or not as powerful, but who are nonetheless equally, if not more, important: the voiceless. Now, those words resonated particularly strongly with me because I had the privilege of serving ten years ago as the minister for preventing abuse, exploitation and crime, the first time that that safeguarding brief had been brought under one minister. It was so often the quiet voices that needed to be heard. It was the time I spent with victims that persuaded me that modern slavery was something we needed to legislate for.
It was the time I spent with the victims of domestic violence, some of whom didn't even want to admit that they were victims, that persuaded me we needed to do more, we needed to legislate in this area. And when I took the coercive control offence through Parliament, it was incredibly important. A very difficult offence.
Coercive control is not easy to prove, it's not easy to find the evidence for, but it was so important that we did this. And I remember speaking at an event not long after the legislation had gone through, and I explained the coercive control offence and what we were trying to do in Parliament. And afterwards, a woman came up to me privately, and she was in tears. She told me that what I described had been her life some 30 years earlier. She had recognized eventually that she was a victim, and so often victims don't recognize they are, but she did recognize she was a victim.
She'd gone to the police. But because the offences weren't violent, they weren't physical, the police said there was nothing they could do. They even said, lock the door and hope that he beats the door down because then we could arrest him on criminal violence. That was all they had. There was nothing they could do to help this woman.
And that encounter stayed with me and it reminds me time and again that abuse is not always a single act. It becomes can be the gradual erosion of somebody's confidence, independence and sense of what choices are really theirs. And coercion to end one's life may not come as an explicit threat. It may be the repeated suggestion that someone is becoming a burden. It may be...
I will I will not be giving away much because I am at Madam Deputy Speaker's, but I will give way to the honourable lady.
Speaker 31
I I thank her very much for giving way and and for sharing that really difficult story, but would she not agree with me that the current system has absolutely no safeguards at all against coercion and that's exactly why we need this bill?
Karen Bradley
So coercion is something that we absolutely need to tackle and we need to understand as a society. I don't think this bill has the safeguards that it's needed because... I will give way there and then I'll give way to the previous sponsor and then I will make some progress.
Jim Shannon
Can I thank the honorable lady for giving way? And I quote the story of one of my constituents, an MND sufferer. He said if he had the option two years ago for this, he probably would have taken it. But instead, in his words, I would have missed out on the most fulfilling two years of my life in the knowledge that I can have more moments like this ahead of me. His words is please don't do this, life is worth living.
Does she agree?
Speaker 32
I thank the honorable gentleman, makes a very important point. I now give way to the previous sponsor.
Kim Leadbeater
I thank her for giving way. Would she agree with me, and she's making a very important point and I've considered this at length obviously during the last two years, and that's why so many amendments were made to the bill around coercive control to ensure that all professionals involved have to have training. There are multiple checks for coercion throughout which don't exist now.
We now check for coercion when someone is dead.
Karen Bradley
But I accept what the honorable lady says and I know she speaks with great sincerity. But it is still the case that under this bill somebody could be seen remotely without a face-to-face appointment, without them being alone, where the coercive perpetrator may be forcing them. And yes, final intervention.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
I thank the honorable lady. What she is describing, suicide currently outstrips homicide of women in our country as the reason for the deaths in cases of domestic abuse and coercive control that she is talking about.
So what she outlines is currently happening today. So arguing for the status quo is not something that I feel comfortable with and I feel considerably stronger about the safeguards which I have worked with my honorable friend to make sure are in the bill.
Karen Bradley
I have enormous respect for the previous minister and we have worked closely together, but the point she's making around suicide of women who are victims of domestic abuse etcetera is a separate matter. We need to tackle that absolutely and we need to make sure that those women in particular who feel that they have nowhere else to go other than to commit suicide, I mean that is just the most outrageous and horrendous situation and we absolutely have to tackle it and we have to work on this, but this bill is not the solution to that problem. And as I referenced, I'd better have...
Speaker 35
I thank the honorable member for giving way, she's been very generous with her time.
As a survivor of domestic violence, as a survivor of an attempted suicide many years ago whilst campaigning about domestic violence. Would she agree with me that coercion is not always external? Coercion can also be internal. Am I a burden on my family? Can they afford to look after me?
Coercion, that coercion isn't picked up in training because it comes from deep inside when you are vulnerable and at your at your worst ebb.
Karen Bradley
The honorable lady makes the case so powerfully and I'm going to disappoint now there won't be any further interventions for some time. Because my fear as hers is is not principally for those who are confident, articulate and able to insist upon what they want. It's for that person who doesn't want to make a fuss. The person accustomed to putting everybody else's needs before their own.
The person who internalizes that coercion. The person who feels guilty about the care they require or have simply been deprived of it. Recognizing abuse is a really difficult thing. I'm struck there's those of who have the misfortune of watching daytime TV might have noticed that there are currently adverts around no-frills cremation services and I'm particularly struck by one that is a woman, a woman of late middle age, slightly slightly small quivering voice saying she doesn't want to be a burden, she doesn't want to cause a fuss, she doesn't want her family to have an awful time at the point of her death so she's investing in a no-frills cremation to make sure her family like the big thing back there. That that person exists because the advertising agency isn't bothering making that advertisement if that person isn't there.
So I say that we have to think about the most vulnerable. These are the people whom Parliament, this House, has a particular duty to remember when we legislate and today in deciding whether this bill without further changes is safe to become law. So the question before us today is what decision is this House making? Now, I recognize the sponsor, the honorable member for Rochester and Strood, is keen to focus on the other place, and there is an appealing simplicity in saying send it back there and let them do their work. But this is not really about the other place anymore.
That House has actually made itself irrelevant. It is about this House and this House alone. Because if we seek to engage the Parliament Act, we are in effect taking a unicameral decision. And we should understand what it means.
We would be declaring that the bill before us is in a fit state to become law whether or not the other place completes its work. There is no separate process by which this house later authorises the Parliament Acts. Our approval of the bill is the decision. And the sponsor and her co-sponsors, I, I, I won't, I really do need to make progress. The sponsor and her co-sponsors have been clear, and including in her answers now, that there won't be amendments made in this place.
A deliberate decision has been taken to introduce a near-identical bill, not incorporate the 77 amendments from the Lords sponsor, including changes which addressed issues he himself accepted required attention. No, I really can't, I'm so sorry to my honourable friend. This is something that could have been dealt with. We have had a summer, we could have had time to work on it. We could have had, for example, a clause that would have given an equal right to palliative care, a simple assessment of unmet need, something, anything to allow there to be a genuine choice.
But that opportunity has now gone. So let me be absolutely clear about what today's vote is and what it is not. It is not another vote on the principle of assisted dying as at an ordinary second reading debate, and the honorable lady said that herself. It is not a vote to allow this House to improve the bill. It is not even a vote to allow the other place to improve it, because that is not in this House's hands.
If this bill is sent to the other place and falls for whatever reason, even if that's because Parliament prorogues early, for instance, or receives not a single further hour of debate, it can be forced into law as it is. And the Hansard Society put it plainly, and I quote: "Bills proceeding under the Parliament Act have been subject to only minimal amendment."
This House needs to understand that the proposed approach requires, in their words, "preserving an unchanged bill with defects." That is a very different decision. And I know there'll be members in this House saying to themselves, "Nothing has changed since I voted for this before, why should I change my vote now?" My answer is simple: a great deal has changed, though not, unfortunately, in the bill itself. We know more now than we did then, and changing one's conclusion when the evidence changes is what Parliament is supposed to do.
We now have revised estimates from the government showing that many more people may seek an assisted death than members previously understood. Up to 4,610 may apply in the first year, and up to 10,428 in year 10. That is more than 1,000 times the number going to Dignitas each year.
This is not a slow run-up during which we can watch the system develop, identify mistakes and quietly correct them. I really must make progress, I'm so sorry. We could have thousands of people entering this system immediately. If the safeguards are not right on day one, vulnerable people will be exposed on day one. And we also have the updated equality impact assessment which the honorable lady from Bradford references.
And its conclusion should give every member pause. It recognizes that disabled people may feel subtle pressures due to attitudinal barriers or lack of alternative appropriate services and support. It says that this may include structural pressures such as neglect, poverty and difficult living conditions.
And it recognizes that we may see disproportionate numbers of ethnic minority people choosing to have an assisted death to avoid financial hardship or escape abuse. I believe that this bill isn't finished, but we are effectively voting today for a completed and finished bill. And that worries me enormously. There has been much that has been said and talked about in the debate previously and I won't repeat the point, but we are giving powers to a future government to implement this bill. We're not giving the powers to the front bench today, to the ministers sitting there.
We're not giving powers necessarily to the front bench on my side. We're giving them to a future government of any political persuasion. And I remember when I was a government minister, always asking myself, would I be happy if this was something that another government took forward, that they had the power to do this?
So I would ask members to apply a test we too rarely apply when legislating. Do not ask whether you trust the people who will administer these powers today. Ask whether you would be content for the political party you trust least to possess them tomorrow. Because there is simply not enough detail in this bill to constrain how many of these decisions are made. And the National Down Syndrome Policy Group put it best.
This bill hopes for the best rather than prepares for the worst. I, I do, I do feel sorry for my honourable friend from the select committee, but I really must make progress because Madam Deputy Speaker's been clear to me that I must. So I say particularly to colleagues who supported the bill before and have wrestled sincerely with this issue since. You do not have to repudiate the vote you cast last time in order to vote differently today.
You do not have to decide that assisted dying can never be right. You do not have to abandon the compassion that led you to support the principle. You need only ask whether this bill, in this form, on the evidence before us now today, is safe enough for Parliament to force into law. That is today's test. And there is no shame whatsoever in concluding that the answer to a different question is different.
Indeed, there would be something profoundly wrong with a Parliament in which members felt bound by an earlier vote, regardless of everything they'd learned since. Success is very rare for private members' bills. It is an amazing route where legislation is simple and consensus easily achieved, and the whole House came together last Friday to do something quite remarkable for babies.
But it is a terrible route for something where the risks of getting it wrong are very great, there is great complexity and such emotion. Before a government bill is introduced, departments will normally spend months or years developing the policy, sometimes too slow, but they do. They consult experts and those affected, testing its legal and practical implications, producing impact assessments, securing cross-government agreement, and having the legislation professionally drafted and scrutinized by parliamentary counsel and finally going through the PBL committee where ministers have to prove to the rest of government that the bill is fit for purpose. And that's what we needed here when dealing with one of the most profound changes Parliament could make to the relationship between the citizen, medicine and the state. Some say they want to amend it.
Have there been any reassurances those amendments will be supported?
For a public bill committee, the sponsor controls the make-up of the committee and will have a majority. At report, if we are fortunate, members may have the opportunity to vote on only a handful of issues and those supporting the bill will be asked to reject each one. We are being asked to support the bill as it stands alongside a commitment to force it into law regardless of what safeguards are forgotten or what gaps remain through which vulnerable people may fall. And there is no one else to whom we can pass responsibility. We cannot say the other place will sort it out.
We cannot say we will fix it later. If this bill becomes law, Parliament may not get another opportunity simply to reopen it and put right what we discover we got wrong. The consequences will instead be worked out in practice, in hospitals, in homes and ultimately in the courts where judges will make decisions based on the law before us today.
And for the people affected by a mistake, we will sort it out later is no safeguard at all. So my appeal today, particularly to those who voted for the bill before, look at what we know now. Look at the people who will depend upon us having got every safeguard right. Remember the quiet ones. Are you prepared today to say that this bill, in this form, is safe to be forced into law?
Thank you.
Speaker 1
Over 90 members are trying to catch my eye. I can only maximize contributions if colleagues now keep their speeches to around six, seven minutes. And I call Claire Hazelgrove.
Claire Hazelgrove
Deputy Speaker, today I'm going to share the most personal of stories publicly for the first time.
And I'd ask for the kindness of colleagues in not intervening so that I can. Last October, my mum, Ruth Hazelgrove, chose to bring her late-stage terminal illness to an end on her terms at home, with dignity and with a strength I can only try to imagine. Mum had just turned 61. She had endured significant health challenges for almost half her life. When mum was 32, she was diagnosed with a rare blood cancer, polycythemia vera.
Thankfully, she was able to see us grow up and meet her grandchildren. Mum loved life and laughter, and our family will remember her this way. In early 2024, she was told her condition had taken a significant turn.
That autumn, while we debated the initial version of this bill, Mum's pain was excruciating. She had access to good palliative care, but what we learned the hardest of ways is that not all pain can be palliated. I will never forget seeing her writhing and screaming in pain at points for weeks. None of us will. And I know of no deity that would want that.
Eventually, some medication helped her leave hospital, which then became less effective over time. For Mum, it wasn't a choice of life or death. It was a question of what kind of death she would have. She was clear that she didn't want a painful or undignified death. She wanted peace.
For us, it will always be a tremendous personal sadness that the current law meant that she couldn't tell us her plan and we couldn't say goodbye to her. But more importantly than that, that she couldn't say goodbye at the end of her life or be surrounded by her loved ones, which is what she would have wanted for her death. Instead, the harmful status quo meant that Mum died alone, with photos of us around her. This was either 11 months ago today or tomorrow. We won't ever know whether it was late one evening or early the next morning that she died, or if we're ever marking the anniversary on the right day.
This is the status quo. This needs to change.
This is why our vote today and our work on this is so important now. People with terminal illnesses and those who are diagnosed with them soon matter greatly. If we were to leave it once again to another Parliament, it would be too late for other people with terminal illnesses who want this provision too, but instead face the same impossible bind as my mum well into the 2030s at best. An excruciating death or dying alone is simply not an acceptable bind on any human being. To allow choice does not impose an outcome, but to continue to restrict it does.
In part of mum's last note to us, which is why I'm speaking today, she wrote:
"I wish the Assisted Dying Bill would have come into force in my lifetime. Maybe there will be hope for others in the future." Ultimately, isn't what Parliament's for, to provide safeguards and freedom? I don't believe that we're here to dictate how people live their lives and their deaths, but to enable safe individual choice. Today's vote is on whether we should continue to work on this or not at all.
I ask right honorable and honorable members to ask themselves if they feel this impact of the status quo is right, is just. My hope, and I know my mum's hope, is that her story can help us choose to end this harmful status quo and see terminally ill adults finally have true choice over their lives and their deaths.
Edward Leigh
The honorable lady has spoken most movingly, and we know that many of us are very conflicted on this issue, and we have to respect each other and show compassion. We know what this debate is all about. No one side has a monopoly of compassion. And I'm going to say in a moment why I believe in being assisted to die in a dignified way.
But will the House forgive me if I start with an essential legal point? We know that what this is all about is ensuring that the bill that we are debating today leaves the House unamended so that the Parliament Act can be imposed. Now, the Isle of Man had an assisted dying bill which, like this bill, left a lot to delegated powers. The Ministry of Justice concluded that this meant that their bill was not compatible with the ECHR. When the result of the private members' ballot was published, three former attorney generals of both parties, Baroness Scotland, Dominic Grieve, and Baroness Prentice, wrote to the sponsor to urge her not to present the same bill as it would run into the same legal and constitutional difficulties.
Now let me give my own personal views as briefly as possible. I'm going to surprise the House in saying that I'm in favour of assisted dying. I'm in favour that when I or when all of us approach our last moments, we go into a hospice and we are assisted to die. And that's what doctors and nurses do all the time. And I've been very impressed by what the Prime Minister, our Prime Minister, said on this issue, and he hasn't been mentioned yet.
It is unfortunate that that offer has not been taken up, and we have to ask why.
And this is about ensuring that everybody receives excellent palliative care as we see in our hospices, like our own hospice in Lincoln, St Barnabas Hospice. So we're agreed on that.
Well, will he forgive me because I've been told to be brief. So I'm in favour of us being assisted to die as painlessly as possible. And every palliative care nurse and doctor I've ever talked to has made clear that in the overwhelming majority of cases, that is possible. And of course we can be, as we all are when we have operations, we are anaesthetised. So I hear the argument, but I believe that we need to improve palliative care.
So what worries me about this bill, and this is my point, is I don't believe that this will just be an assisted dying bill. I think in time it will become an assisted suicide bill. Now I've mentioned the ECHR.
I mean, what is the logic of this bill? We all know it's terrible if you've got a terminal cancer prognosis, but what if you are clinically depressed? What if you are quadriplegic? What if you are sentenced to a lifetime where you cannot move your arms or your legs? What if you know, what if you know, like a member of our family in Canada, that you have got, going to get more and more dementia and therefore you take the assisted dying route?
The truth is you cannot differentiate between these conditions which make unbearable life for many people. So I give this prediction that if this bill goes through, if the Parliament Act is ensures it happens, I believe that in 10 years' time we will be in a situation like Canada and very large numbers, very large numbers of people will be choosing assisted dying. Now we hear a lot about, I think it's rubbish myself, that this country is broken, that the elite is ruining the country. This country isn't broken. The reason why we're under pressure is that there are too many of us, too many old people, too many people with multiple health conditions.
And there is tremendous pressure on the NHS, on older people. We know that, and we've heard a lot from my friend about coercion. And we've heard also that coercion is not necessarily external, it can be internal. So I believe that if we move to a society where assisted suicide is the norm, vast numbers of people will take it up. Is that really the sort of society that we want?
Now we will, I agree, no, no, no, I agree that we will have more prosperity, a richer country. I agree that we'll have more choice and more freedom. But will it really be a happier country? And my point is this, and what I stand for and what I believe in so passionately is respect for all human life. Life of old people who are suffering so much from dementia they don't even, can't even recognize their own children.
People who have these appalling long-term conditions.
But I believe that there's a greater thing than choice or prosperity. It's love. Love of life. And if all of us in every country in the last hundred years had said that whatever happens we should respect life, but not take it. So yes, this is going to be difficult for many people and we've heard moving stories.
But I urge you with the NHS, do you want this conversation to start? At the moment we know that when you go to the hospital you know that you will be dealt with by a doctor and a nurse in a compassionate way and the argument is all about relieving your symptoms, trying to save your life.
Do you want the conversation to perhaps start with the fact that your life is unbearable? So I believe that this bill, and I know the passion on either side and we treat each other with respect, but I urge you, before you vote for this bill at 2:30, remember what sort of society you will be creating. Not a society which loves life.
Zubir Ahmed
Madam Deputy Speaker, I speak on this matter as someone who is an active medical practitioner, as a transplant surgeon, as a cancer surgeon. Much of my clinical practice for the last 20 years has revolved around caring for unwell, complex patients, many of whom flicker between a label of terminal illness and a life-limiting illness. It is some of that experience I wish to bring to bear on this debate today.
Madam Deputy Speaker, let me first of all start off by acknowledging the varied experiences people have at the end of their life and at the end of the life of their loved ones. I've cared and operated on thousands of such patients. I've helped many, but I also know I have often fallen short. Some of those stories have played vividly in my mind over the last few days. And when they have, I have reflected upon the fact that more often when things have not gone right, it is because of an absence rather than a failure of good quality palliative and psychological care not being available universally.
But today, Madam Deputy Speaker, as a member of this place and as a surgeon, my job is to help move this discussion beyond the emotive and the case study to level-headed analysis that serve that will serve our society well not only today, but for the decades to come. Having read this bill again, and now with the hindsight of ministerial experience in the Department of Health and Social Care, I am more convinced now than ever that our social and palliative care system simply is not ready, at least not ready in an equitable sense, to meet the demands of this bill. I won't at the moment if that's okay. The bill itself will, when taken from the laboratory of this legislative text and dispatched to the bedside and to the clinical frontier, will not serve its laudable aims of bringing choice and control for the preemptive quick death that I know many desire and expect as a result of this legislation.
And while it will not fulfill those aims, it will expose millions, the quietly vulnerable, the constituents and patients of mine, more often than not women in Glasgow Southwest, who quietly concede to me in the sanctity of a clinic room, usually, that they do not wish to be a burden, who have at many occasions asked me to end their life because they have suffered multi-generational financial strains and do not want their illness to hold their children and their grandchildren back. Madam Deputy Speaker, when you visit places like Govan and Pollok as a parliamentarian as well as a doctor, you understand that as a society we are only scratching the surface in understanding the full extent of coercive control in this country. I will give way.
Speaker 38
I thank the honorable member for giving way.
It pierces my heart whenever cancer is repeatedly mentioned in this conversation, and I'm grateful for the member for West Lancashire and for her advocacy. You may have cancer, you may have a terminal diagnosis, but you still want to live, and we should support those people to live first before we contemplate their death.
Zubir Ahmed
Can I commend my honourable friend for her powerful testimony? I know she has personal experience on this matter as well. When you visit those places, you know what vulnerability looks like. People who can't send their voices down here via the mic, the TV studio, or a billboard in Westminster tube station. But people we need to make sure do not feel the burden of what some call an option, a choice, becoming their obligation or their duty.
Not at the moment. But it is on the foundational principles of this bill I want to concentrate primarily today.
The first is this idea that we have around the six month to live label. Terminal illness, Madam Deputy Speaker, is a medical diagnosis fast changing in the modern medical world and becoming an increasingly meaningless term. Only yesterday evening I was in the company of a professor of respiratory medicine who in rightful satisfaction told me that many of his stage four lung cancer patients designated with six months to live in 2023 are being managed as a chronic disease in 2026.
In my own practice, the stage four colon cancer that spreads to the liver when the patient comes to see me, in the advent of immunotherapy, means I have an equal chance of telling them they have six months to live or six years to live. Under this law, when I meet that kind of patient, it is unclear to me, with some Supreme Court precedents around consent, whether I should be offering them immunotherapy and assisted death at the same sitting. The six months prognosis, Madam Deputy Speaker, will take a new and unhealthy salience in every clinical conversation, a label some will desire and others will want to avoid at all costs being placed in their clinical record. It will fundamentally change, I believe, and undermine the candid nature and the sanctity of the patient-doctor conversation and relationship. Madam Deputy Speaker, I must be honest with you.
Torcuil Crichton
Thank you, the right honourable friend is making a very informed speech on how the medical landscape has changed.
But while the arguments we make today are the same, the political landscape has changed as well. Doesn't he agree with the Father of the House that we now have a Prime Minister committed to solving social care and palliative care? And that in Scotland, where he comes from himself, we saw the political landscape change in front of our eyes when MSPs voted initially for similar legislation, but in the end voted against. People can change their minds, and I hope they do.
Zubir Ahmed
I'm grateful to my honourable friend for mentioning the Scottish context where we did vote down this legislation at the third, at the third reading when we understood the impacts and the wider societal ramifications. Madam Deputy Speaker, I have to be honest with you. When I am asked to prognosticate as to whether someone has six months to live or not, I am as often wrong as I am right.
It is not a good enough marker, for instance, for the DWP anymore to discharge benefits for life-limiting conditions, and I do not see why it should be a good enough marker for prescribing death. In another paradox of this legislation, someone like me could write a prescription to induce death with less regulatory oversight than I currently need to remove a kidney to give life in transplantation. I of course sympathize and endorse the desire many colleagues have who support this bill to relieve suffering. To be clear, we have many tools to do this, and we must bust some myths today. Clinical discretion, for instance, means there is no maximum dose of morphine.
I can give my patient whatever they need in the setting that they need it. But this bill is less about relieving suffering and more about bypassing its possibility. And I understand that. It is in many ways advocating for death as prophylaxis. Death must be by definition of this bill induced by medical prescription.
It will be the only medical prescription that I'll be able to write as a doctor, but not administer. Because the burden of administration falls to the patient. The weight of expectation falls on the patient. And we must discuss the insights and the mechanism by which death will occur. Muscle paralysis, slowing of the heart rate, sedation, and the possibility that paralysis may take hold before sedation does.
Death will not be an event, it will still be a process.
It will be in 15% of cases subject to some form of complication, such as vomiting, seizures, and will not always achieve its goal. The complication profile, Madam Deputy Speaker, I wish I could give you more information on, but despite it being prevalent in other jurisdictions across the world, the data continues to be woefully lacking. And alongside this, the 14-day cooling-off period means that the patient must remain lucid in that time, and there have been cases elsewhere in the world where patients have denied themselves palliative care and pain relief to remain lucid to consent for their death. I am therefore of the opinion, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the foundational elements of this bill will create the allure of choice and control, but not the agency to pursue either. And now the safeguards: much is made of two doctors who will assess eligibility.
The trouble is, neither have to know the patient well or go to any great lengths to exclude the likelihood of coercion. Doctors, Madam Deputy Speaker, are trained to do many things. Assessing and picking up coercion is not one of them. In fact, consultant psychiatrists with PhDs in coercion, like my honorable friend the member for Weybridge, who I hope we will hear from soon, have written testimony in court that they would find it difficult to exclude coercive, controlling behavior. Madam Deputy Speaker, I came into medicine and into Parliament to act with compassion and to provide dignity to those we serve.
I believe that is why we are all here. Compassion and kindness is not the preserve of one side or the other. But for me, compassion and kindness also calls to courage. The courage to be honest with patient and constituent alike. The compassion and the honesty to say the bill will not fulfill its aims.
It will disappoint many who will crave the total agency and control that they want. But it will expose and disenfranchise further the vulnerable in our society. The compassion and honesty to say our NHS is a great institution, but in its current form and state, it is not ready. It is not safe for this conversation, for this bill, in this moment.
Speaker 1
In case I didn't make myself clear, looking around the room, there are many people wishing to contribute. I urge colleagues to keep their contributions to five minutes or less, otherwise I'll be forced to put in a speaking limit. Kit Malthouse.
Kit Malthouse
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
As co-sponsor of the bill once again, I'm acutely conscious that there is more at stake today than merely the fate of those who are facing their end, because the conduct of the other place means that our democracy is also on trial today. I sat in the chamber on a number of occasions, watched more on television with unfolding horror at the game that was being played at the other end of this building, a game that was marked in homes across the country with dismay and misery and agony, as I contemplated Lords effectively putting up the pretence of scrutiny, but at the same time putting down a thousand amendments. I won't. Putting down a thousand amendments, many of which were cruel or absurd, effectively designed to be kind of sand in the engine of slowing up what should have been a proper parliamentary process, and a process that the dying deserve to see operate correctly.
We have to be aware in this House that expectations are high that people who send us here can rely on decisions made in this House proceeding into law. And I'm afraid that what's at stake today is our democracy. And if this bill falls today, one of the biggest losers will be the standing of this House and this institution as a whole.
Jeremy Paul Wright
I'm extremely grateful to my right honourable friend for giving way and I applaud his passion and his clarity on this issue.
But on the subject of democratic accountability, he knows that if, as the honourable member for Rochester and Strood has made clear, no amendments can be accepted from this House to this bill as it stands, then the authority to decide whether the bill changes passes to the other place. And there must be a problem, must there not, in his argument with this House saying, if we are worried about the content of this bill at the moment, we can do nothing about it, and we rely on the other place to do so instead.
Kit Malthouse
Well, I respect my right honourable friend's expertise in this matter, but as he's already heard on the floor of the House, it is perfectly possible for this House to suggest amendments, for them to be negotiated with the sponsors and placed against the legislation in the House of Lords and then come back to this House for approval. And we would much rather that that is what would have happened in the first place. But this House now faces an invidious choice.
If we pass the bill, if we amend it in this House, then it will just be talked out again. And I'm afraid I have no faith that the small group that dedicated themselves to holding up the bill, to denying dying people what they seek because of their own personal— some of those, I won't— some of those members who had just a few months before been specifically rejected by the electorate and replaced in this House by others, that they cannot, I'm afraid, be trusted not to do the same again. Now, this is a less than ideal situation, I will grant him. However, the sponsor has said, and I know the sponsor in the House of Lords is willing to entertain amendments being put down in the Lords, which will come back to the House for conclusion. But there are a couple of other issues that I just wanted to deal with, Madam Deputy Speaker, before I get there.
The first is this notion of palliative care, and we discussed this at second reading extensively.
And I'm pleased that this debate has stimulated a strong debate about palliative care. The Health and Social Care Committee of the House of Lords found that in territories that have assisted dying, palliative care generally improves because people become less afraid of talking about death. But we must be careful. We must be careful not to say that perfection is something is a precondition for those who are dying. Perfection has to be an objective for those of us who will carry on living.
We can't delay and indulge them, the dying, in their agony because we're not satisfied with the state of palliative care. We have to deal with the choice that those people are facing at the point of their death and give them the choice that so many of them are seeking.
The second is about coercion and as the Father of the House said about love. One of the most affecting people I've met over the last 11 years of campaigning on this issue was Warwick Jackson, who came to our party conference a couple of years ago. Warwick's wife Anne was diagnosed with terminal peritoneal cancer. She knew basically she was going to die a slow, suffocating death at the end. And as he watched her dying, heard her begging her palliative nurse to end it all for her, he contemplated smothering her with a pillow.
And the only thing that stopped him was because he didn't want her dying thought to be her loving husband having brought her life to an end.
And that is the conflict of love that we pose to people by perpetuating this appalling status quo. We've heard time and time again that the situation millions, thousands of our constituents live with every single day is so horrific, so appalling that even the best palliative care cannot alleviate their pain. And so I urge you, colleagues, to consider what your vote may mean today because as we said at second reading, a vote against this bill is not a passive act. It's not something neutral. It is a vote for a status quo that is a status quo of misery and degradation and cruelty for so many.
We know that the British people support this measure. We know that there are lots of territories around the world that we respect and admire who have assisted dying operating for many years successfully. It's not beyond us to get our democracy operating as it should do and to design something that will work for the British people.
We can't give dying people more time, but we can give them mercy and love. I urge you to vote for the bill.
Ashley Dalton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The last time this House considered this bill at second reading, I was keeping a secret. Whilst honourable and right honourable members were debating the issue, I was grappling with my own terminal diagnosis. I was told I have stage four incurable metastatic breast cancer. I was overwhelmed with grief, fear, and anxiety.
I was scared of what was to come, and I was fearful of how it would impact my family and my loved ones. I was scared that I was going to get really poorly and thinking how will I cope? How will my family cope? How will I be cared for? How will I afford it?
How badly will it hurt?
How long will it last? When you hear those words, depression, anxiety, grief, fear, shame, and guilt come in bounds. Suicide risk is highest immediately after diagnosis, and it usually falls quickly within three to six months. I would be lying if I said that when thinking about all that was to come, I didn't consider that it might just be fairer and easier on everyone if I just got the dying over with as soon as possible. Having treatable depression, however, will not exclude anyone from an assisted death within this bill.
And depression is common among people with terminal illness, but it is often treatable.
Clinicians are trained to prevent suicide in people suffering from depression. But where would the line be drawn? This bill makes no provision to support this difficult transition or to create safeguards around it. A person can also be suicidal and have unmet mental health needs prior to developing a terminal illness, and then ask the state to kill them without any assessment of their psychological health, just their mental capacity, because mental capacity and mental health are not the same thing. The Royal College of Psychiatrists recommends a holistic, multidisciplinary assessment of every applicant.
The three-person panel at the end of the assessment process in this bill is not what most NHS clinicians recognise as a multidisciplinary team.
It certainly does not allow for meaningful multidisciplinary decision-making. The assessment needs to happen at the beginning of the process, not the end, and each team member should be independently assessing the patient in person. This is not what has been included in this bill. Now, I don't know how long I will live. I will be on treatment for life, however long or short that may be.
I at the moment live between scans in nine to twelve week blocks of time. The last scan may show the disease is stable, but the next scan might show that it is growing again. If the disease is stable, the drug's working and we can carry on. Eventually the drug will stop working, the cancer will grow, and we'll have to try another drug and see if that works.
At some point, we'll either run out of drugs to try or I'll be too poorly to tolerate them. Then I die. It could be months, it could be years. No one really knows. Prognosis is notoriously difficult to predict.
Palliative care professionals and oncologists tell me that whilst they can more or less give me an indication of when I'll die when I'm a few days or weeks off, anything beyond that is the flip of a coin. The six month prognosis in this bill is something no one can ever be really sure of. But what the palliative care professionals have told me is that palliative care can help me when I die.
But in the campaign around this bill, it seems to me that it's being implied that without, that a person with a terminal illness will have a dreadful, painful death unless they have access to assisted dying. And it's simply not true. Palliative care in the UK is excellent. Far too many people do not have access to palliative care that they need, but the idea that it is not possible to alleviate pain and discomfort is false. People, I, have been terrorized with tales of people vomiting up their own feces as though this is commonplace during death.
It is vanishingly rare. And, you know, bowel obstructions are more common, but they are treatable. I know, I've had one.
It's nothing short of irresponsible to scaremonger people like me into believing our deaths will be horrific, when all the evidence suggests that with access to good palliative care, deaths are on the whole gentle. The answer is not to terrify people and their families. It's to sort out palliative care and social care first. Because none of this takes place in a vacuum. Until we can say that everyone that needs it has access to high-quality palliative care, then we're offering nobody a choice.
A terrible death or an assisted death is not a choice. It's a threat. Whilst I speak today from the position of someone with a terminal illness, I am acutely aware that this is not about me. This debate is also not about an abstract concept or a position of principle.
The question that will be put at the end of this debate will not be that this House has considered the question of assisted dying. It won't even be that this House agrees with the principle of assisted dying. The question will be that this House agree that this bill be read for a second time. This bill. Not the bill it might have been, not the bill members might have hoped it would be, not the bill it could be.
This bill. It is the only thing before us today. And incidentally, it says absolutely nothing about the House of Lords. That is not the question that we are being asked.
And whatever honourable or right honourable members think about the principle of assisted dying, surely our first and foremost responsibility is to write law that is safe and workable. Not one of the professional bodies that would be tasked with delivering the Bill are willing to attest that as it stands, it is either safe or workable. Not one. The Royal College of Psychiatrists, the Association of Palliative Medicine, the Royal College of Physicians, all say the Bill is seriously inadequate. They aren't opposed to assisted dying in principle, but they cannot support this Bill.
And instead of bringing a Bill identical to the last, so that the Parliament Acts could be used and it can be forced unamended onto the statute books, why didn't the proposers spend the summer working with the Royal Medical Colleges, professional bodies and organisations to build a Bill that they could all support? If they had done that, it would have been very difficult for anyone opposed to the principle to argue against the Bill.
But they didn't. But this is not about sides. This House is not a debating society. It's about making the law. Whilst we may be campaigners out there, in here we are all legislators.
It is our responsibility not to pick a side and dig in, but to work together to build the best laws that we can, and that is never truer than with a private members' bill on a matter of conscience. This bill does... no I won't. This bill does not protect the most vulnerable. It does not protect the poor, the old, people with disabilities or black and minority ethnic people being disproportionately affected. It does not protect people who are mentally ill.
It does not recognise that not everyone has the same level of agency, control or influence over their decision making.
And what the clinicians we would ask to deliver this bill are saying is that it isn't even workable. That there is every expectation it wouldn't even work for the terminally ill people that want an assisted death either. And there's no stopping it. Auto-commencement in the bill means if it's passed by the Commons, pushed through the Parliament Act, and even if the government or the NHS is not ready, it has to happen on the strike of four years from it being passed. Even if there's no funding.
Even if palliative care is still broken. Even if it is known to be dangerous, flawed, or unworkable. It is happening, ready or not. This is not a last chance saloon. This debate has been going on for years.
It's not a once-in-a-generation opportunity. It could come back again at the next Parliament. My days may be numbered. But that doesn't mean that I want this chamber to rush through bad law just so I might have a chance to see it or use it.
It's of huge importance. If honorable and right honorable members have any doubt that the exact bill before us today is not the best it could be, is anything less than excellent, well-thought-out, and robustly drafted legislation that protects the vulnerable and recognizes the expertise of our world-class clinicians, and a bill that I and other terminally ill people deserve, then I vote, I urge them to vote no or vote abstain.
Pippa Heylings
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I begin by thanking the honorable member for Rochester and Strood for her courage and compassion in bringing this bill back before Parliament. The debate in this House, the other House, and across the country is profoundly important.
We need to get better at talking more openly about death and what dying well means. These were the words of the end-of-life care clinical lead during my last week's visit to the new dedicated palliative and end-of-life care ward at Addenbrooke's Hospital in my constituency of South Cambridgeshire. It's something my own father said to me many, many times over 40 years ago. He was a family doctor in Hull, in the deprived communities, witnessing family births and deaths of many patients at home and in hospital. Love life, live life as much as possible, and have a good death.
The last time this bill came before the House, it encouraged that conversation.
There was respectful debate, evidence was examined, safeguards were strengthened. The Commons voted in favor and the bill was sent to the House of Lords for further scrutiny. What we are doing today is allowing due process to continue by sending the bill back to the Lords so it can complete its passage. I am grateful to the many constituents who've written to me on all sides of this debate, sharing deeply personal experiences that have shaped their views and informed my own thinking. Having listened carefully over all of our debates, the bill committee, the witnesses, the evidence, I continue to support this bill.
There is a need to change the status quo. Receiving a terminal diagnosis, as we have heard, is devastating. It brings a loss of control of the future that many people find deeply frightening.
One of those people is my constituent Jody, who is living with a terminal grade four astrocytoma brain tumor. Following life-saving surgery, she continues treatment aimed at preserving the best quality of life possible. Fiercely independent, she is living every single day. Yet in her own words, the prospect of the disease eventually taking over her brain, leaving her unable to think clearly, communicate, or make decisions, frightens her more than she can express. She said, none of us know what the future holds, but knowing that the option of assisted death would be available should I ever reach that point would provide me with enormous comfort and reassurance.
As we've heard today, what we don't talk enough about is the current status quo.
It's almost as if there's a taboo. And that for some terminally ill people is an unsafe and cruel status quo, with hundreds of people already taking matters into their own hands. And I want to share the story of my constituent, Kath Sheppard. Her sister, Emma Windred, was a keen and active outdoors woman who loved life. Facing the end of that life, she chose the only legally defensible and medically supported route available to her: voluntarily stopping eating and drinking.
We know that many medical practitioners feel that this is a grey area and much more guidance is needed in this area.
That should not be the only option. Emma felt robbed of the death she wanted, and she campaigned for the law to change until her end came. After Emma's death, Cath has continued that campaign so that others might have the option of the gentle and dignified death her sister believed she was denied. Now, again as we've heard today, too often assisted dying and palliative care are presented as competing alternatives. They are not.
Both are rooted in the same aim: ensuring that people approaching the end of life are treated with dignity, compassion, and respect. I'm fortunate that Arthur Rank Hospice serves my constituency and the wider region. It provides outstanding care and support to patients and families at some of the most difficult moments in their lives.
Its staff and volunteers do extraordinary work. Yet like many hospices around the country, it faces huge cuts, the loss of beds, something that many and I and others have campaigned to stop happening. We all know there is a disgraceful crisis in adult social care. Hospices, hospital-at-home services, district nursing, community palliative care are all desperately underfunded. Therefore I welcome, as we all do as Liberal Democrats, welcome the Prime Minister's call for cross-party talks on social care.
But Madam Deputy Speaker, I do not share the premise that assisted dying legislation must wait until palliative care is fully funded and available everywhere. This is not an either-or. This is not a before-until. These are not and should not be competing priorities.
My support for this bill is matched by my belief that we must equally strengthen palliative end-of-life care. Dying with dignity means access both to outstanding palliative care, compassion at every stage of life, and the ability to have choice, agency, and dignity for those very final days. And this bill will not make choice for anyone. It will simply allow terminally ill people to make choice for themselves, safely, challenging the status quo, and with their loved ones around them if they so wish.
Joshua Fenton-Glynn
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I've struggled with this vote perhaps more than any other in Parliament because if you'd asked me at any time in my life if I was for or against assisted dying, I'd say I'm in favour. I believe people have autonomy over their own bodies as a fundamental liberal principle. But we do not vote on principles here. We vote on legislation. And this bill at this time is not one I can support.
I don't believe it's safe. I don't believe it addresses very legitimate concerns of disabled voices, and I do not believe it's come at the right time. In my speech, I'm going to cover the state of palliative care and fears of coercion. But first, I'd like to thank my constituents for the role that they've played in this, coming to meetings, speaking to me at surgeries, writing me emails in a respectful way, the way that we should conduct our politics in all things, but particularly things this serious.
I bring professional and personal experience to this. I've been a council cabinet member for social care sitting on a safeguarding board. I've worked for the General Medical Council and for the past two years I've sat on the Health and Social Care Select Committee. And like many people, I've sat with a loved one as they've died. Ultimately my experience means that I don't for one minute believe that this is simple.
I know that if we don't pass this bill then some number of people will die in preventable pain and a painful death. I also know that if we do pass any bill there will be some number of people who are coerced into taking their own lives.
If you have moral certainty, not just now thank you, if you have moral certainty on this, I honestly envy you. But on the state of palliative care, we are told that this bill is about giving our constituents more options, the choice between good palliative care or an assisted death. But in a world where there are such gaping holes in our health, social care and palliative care system, that is simply not the case. Not just now. My committee asked our independent expert panel to look into the quality and availability of palliative care, and the results should give everyone in this room a pause for thought, because we do not have a universal offer of palliative care in this country.
The report points to a postcode lottery of provision. Hospices are largely funded through charitable donations, which means in better-off areas there is better care.
On my committee, we constantly hear about the social determinants of health. Let's not have one of them be that those in wealthier areas have the choice of a comfortable death, while the poor must choose an early one. Furthermore, there is a workforce crisis in palliative care. There are 700 palliative care doctor posts, but 70 vacancies. Add to that 130 doctors expected to leave the profession in the next five years, and to make matters worse, training bottlenecks mean there won't be specialist doctors trained to replace them.
This is in a landscape where in the current decade we expect demand for palliative care to increase by 55%. I want a safe bill, and taking all of these things into account, a safe bill would give some discretion to the Health Secretary as to when they implement it.
This bill does not, I'm sorry I won't just now. It has an auto-commencement clause, which means that within four years of the passage of this bill, whatever the state of our health service, whatever the state of our social care, whatever the state of our palliative care, even if there's been another pandemic, this bill will come into force. And that brings me to our safeguards. I cannot vote for a bill that does not sufficiently guard against coercion. That is what my constituents with disabilities say they fear the most.
And having been in charge of social care, I know what that looks like. And let me be clear, the safeguards in this bill are not enough. If the bill in its current form passes, a patient would be subject to more scrutiny to give up a kidney than to give up their life.
The ultimate weakness of this bill is that the question being asked when a patient goes to the panel is a medical and legal one, not a social and psychological one. The main judgment will be an assessment of whether they're likely to die in the next six months, not why they've chosen to die or whether there is a risk of coercion. And coercion isn't always committed by the traditional villain, it's not who wants money. It is often committed by a loved one at the end of their tether. As support falls away and money drains, options narrow and people's sense of what choices they have narrow too.
Without improving palliative care, we will put far too many people in this heartbreaking position. Now, as MPs, we are used to being forthright in our opinions, we are used to advocating for ourselves and our constituents. Madam Deputy Speaker, I am coming to the end.
But on our select committee, I am constantly hearing from vulnerable patients who say that they are frequently ignored, talked about, or talked over by medical professionals. They feel talked at, not talked to. And when considering this legislation, I do not ask whether it will work for people like me. I ask whether it will work for the most vulnerable, those whose voices are rarely heard, those whose voices are most dependent on the state for protection. They rely on us to be their voice.
This bill comes from a place of compassion. But it could lead to a place where a disabled person feels they are less. It could lead to a place where poor social care means people don't feel they have a choice between a comfortable life and an early death. So that is why I say, with a heavy heart, not this bill and not at this time. Thank you.
Sir Bernard Jenkin.
Bernard Jenkin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I welcome the honourable member for Calder Valley's speech because he is an example of what we have seen throughout this whole debate, which actually goes back to the early 2000s, that people have been peeling off from supporting assisted dying in principle and certainly peeling off supporting this bill. And I am a case in point. I came into the chamber to listen to the Falconer Bill, the Lords bill, I think it was in 2014, absolutely determined I was going to vote for assisted dying. And I sat through the debate and ended up voting against because I thought the arguments were not made in favour of this bill, of any bill.
And the second reason I think we should throw this out today is the bill keeps changing. Even now this bill is not settled.
Even now the advocates of this bill want changes to this bill. And they are stuck with the reality that if the Parliament Act is invoked, they will only be able to invoke the bill as it stands today. They will not be able to have their changes. So if in doubt today, the House must vote no. Third point I want to make, this is a far bigger question, it turns out, than just a matter of conscience or a matter to be decided that is isolated.
It's a massive question that affects public policy and with major public expenditure consequences. And that has convinced me that we really shouldn't see another bill like this one until we have a government bill that has been through the process of proper scrutiny within government, with all the consequences laid out and dealt with, so that a responsible and accountable Secretary of State presents a bill that is not a backbench bill. And maybe there should perhaps be a citizens' assembly on this question. It is a subject that would lend itself to a citizens' assembly. Well, it doesn't take away any power from this House.
This House would still be able to decide, but it would inform the debate in a way that the debate is still not informed. Finally, I would just say, my mother and my father passed away in recent years.
I'm so grateful that my mother never had to confront this question. She often said, "Oh, I just want to die, I'm just a burden on the family." And though she would have never qualified for this bill, I'm so grateful there were never any circumstances possible that would have confronted her with this question. And I just also advert to another conversation. A very dear friend, someone who's become a mentor, a very, very interesting, clever, intellectual, determined, courageous lady, and she has scoliosis of the spine.
And the last time I went to see her, there she was, hardly able to sit up, in constant pain. And I asked her, because we have open conversations, "If assisted dying was available to you, would you take it?" And without hesitation, she said, "Oh yes." And I said, "Why?"
"Because I'm a burden to my family." And I said, "Well, I've been voting against assisted dying, I'm going to have to rethink my position." And she said, without hesitation, "Oh, I don't advocate it." Because she understands the complexity of this, and she knows that it opens a can of worms that we really haven't understood fully. So I do urge colleagues in this House today to vote against this bill.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I want to start my remarks by paying real tribute to my honourable friend from Filton and Bradley Stoke. Mainly because I'm a bit lazy, I very rarely prepare to speak in debates, don't have copious notes ever, and her remarks have led me to where my remarks will go. And that is, I will cover the issue of coercion that people have mentioned today, but like her, I will talk about my mother, who also died when she was 61 years old. And unfortunately, it was much, much nearer in my honourable friend's life. My mother died when I was 28 years old, and so many years ago now.
And she had leiomyosarcoma and suffered with it for around three years. The prognosis did change, so I hear those arguments that are being made in this House. But towards the end of her life, my she she felt she was going to die at one particular point. She it was coming to the end. She was in a wheelchair.
She was completely paralyzed. She was doubly incontinent by this point. And just to give you an idea of the kind of woman my mother was, my mother was an absolute titan. She was like Erin Brockovich but with a bad perm in the 1980s.
She can claim now to giving a job and being able to spot talent because she gave a job to the current Prime Minister who worked for her for some time and is often teary-eyed whenever I talk to him about her. And when she got to this stage, my brothers live in different parts of the world and country. I live 20 minutes from where I was born and where she lived. And we all went back to be with her because we believed this was it, that she was going to be taken, that she was going to die. And she didn't die on that occasion.
And so my brother who lives in France went back home. And then when it came to the point where a doctor gives you the call and says your mom is about to die, my brother couldn't come back. It was about four weeks later.
And so it was me who was with my mom when she died, not all of her children, not all of her grandchildren. And I am eternally grateful for that. But she definitely, this was a woman who had written every part of her funeral. She knew exactly what she wanted us to feel. She had planned within an nth degree what would happen after she was gone.
I found the other day a recipe for Christmas puddings and the pin number for her credit card in an old, in an old book, because she was like, your dad might not be able to get money. She had thought about everything.
She wasn't gifted with the ability to think about this. She would have, when my brothers were surrounding her, she would have taken the choice on that day. And I feel that it, she didn't die in terrible pain and I recognize what the honorable lady is saying and we shouldn't, we shouldn't, she wasn't writhing, it wasn't awful. However, she should have been able to choose to have her family with her. Now, I will, and so I will vote for this bill.
She raised me to believe, she was, I went to women's liberation playgroup which she set up with a load of women. She raised me to believe in a right to choose, my gosh, more so than anything else in life.
And so she would tell me what to do today. But I just to the point of coercion that many people have mentioned, I am a scholar of coercion and I want to just say it to everybody today, don't rest on the laurels that if we do nothing, people today won't be coerced to death. That will happen today. That will literally happen today. And so the idea that if we just do nothing, I'm not going to because the Madam Deputy Speaker is, is clear.
But the idea that we are going to walk out of here if we do not pass this today and women in our country are any safer is an absolute, is an absolute myth. Doing nothing, doing nothing is not the same as acting.
Layla Moran
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I start by paying tribute to all the members who have shared their story and the member for Birmingham Yardley? I feel like we've learned a bit more about how she became how she is today. And we've heard so many heartbreaking stories, I'm sure, from our own constituents. I want to thank all of them who have contacted me, whether or not we agree or not, because sharing these stories are profoundly difficult for people.
Layla Moran.
Layla Moran
One constituent with incurable cancer contacted me asking for the freedom to choose when to give up their battle.
Her own brother had incurable melanoma spreading down his neck, which left him barely able to speak to his loved ones. He went out at 2:00 a.m. in his dressing gown. He climbed onto a bridge and he jumped onto a motorway below. But this was witnessed by two girls who were walking home from a party. My constituent asks, how many more need to take their own lives in horrific ways because they simply cannot bear the pain, discomfort and hopelessness anymore?
And she wants the right to decide when is enough is enough for herself. And then there is Joelle, whose sister went abroad to access assisted dying. 84-year-old Joelle sang to her sister as she ended her life peacefully with her family around her.
She said, it was a painless, peaceful and dignified death at a time of her own choosing. Together with giving birth to my own children, it was one of the most beautiful experiences of my long life. I don't believe that only families with means should be able to have this experience. It should be open to everyone. Now let me turn to the issue of palliative care.
I pay tribute to my colleague from Calder Valley, while we share the committee and we both wrote the reports together, I come to a different conclusion and with great respect.
It is true, and frankly is a stain on successive governments, the state that palliative care is in. Our investigations and our findings were stark. Commissioning variation and postcode lotteries, bereavement support frequently inaccessible, services are fragmented, workforce and skill shortages are widespread, and systemic inequalities persist. It's also worth note, no I shan't. It's also worth noting that the NHS hasn't been meeting its own standards on palliative care for decades.
The then minister appeared before us in the spring, and he mentioned the importance of workforce. I say again, and I will say it again I hope, where is that workforce plan? We need it. But that won't be the whole answer. We also need better data, early identification, clearer guidance, and joined-up working with adult social care and local authorities.
Now the government have said that they are going to publish a modern standard framework, and I think it is very positive that the interim MSF is now published.
But let me tell you where I see it as chair of this committee. I genuinely do not believe that palliative care would have been included in the early batches of MSF if it wasn't for this bill forcing it to. And I further don't believe that the NHS, with all of its issues and competing priorities, let alone the competing political priorities that this government has and any other government that may come after it in the next four years, that palliative care, without the pressure of a bill like this, is going to improve as fast as we want it to. And so I say to members this: I do not believe that this is an either-or proposition. I want palliative care to improve, therefore I will be voting for this bill.
And I will have to end with one more constituent story. And that's the story of Robert. His two parents actually had different views on this. His father didn't agree with assisted dying, but his mother did. We are lucky in Oxfordshire that we have some of the best palliative care in the country.
And he described how her care was absolutely exemplary.
She died in a way where she was without pain and well looked after. But she, he felt that her wishes were not respected while his father's were, and there were consequences to her not being able to access assisted dying, which was that her brother couldn't be there at her bedside when she passed. So for those constituents who want a real choice at the end of life, I will tirelessly continue to want to improve palliative care, but I will also be supporting this bill today.
Speaker 54
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I mean that sincerely on a day when so many colleagues want to speak. I promise you my remarks will be brief. Our debate today is about who has choice and agency in our society, in respect of the authority of this elected House of Commons and what limits should exist on the role of the other place.
And more fundamentally, the right of a terminally ill person to exercise choice at the end of their life, or whether the state should be able to override it. We are back here today for a second reading of the Terminally Ill Adults Bill, not because the question before us has changed since November 2024, but due to the actions of a very small number of members of the other place.
Madeleine Sarah Smith
I'll happily give way.
Would he confirm to the House how many amendments were accepted in the House of Lords, and that it was about 90 peers who were involved in supporting the amendments that were laid down?
Speaker 54
Grateful for honorable friend's intervention. I don't have the number of amendments that were approved. What I do have is the number that were proposed: 1,286 wrecking amendments.
Now, there are, Madam Deputy Speaker, there are many thoughtful and compassionate critics of this bill who I respect deeply. And I want to put on record my... I won't at this moment... my admiration for the member for West Lancashire for her astonishingly brave speech this afternoon. But what I can't condone are the actions of members of the other place whose motivation in the last session of Parliament appeared to be to block the democratic process.
Will the honourable member give way?
Ben Spencer
I will give way.
Is it not important to ask someone why they want to have opposition to assisted suicide a wrecking amendment?
Speaker 54
The point I was making, Madam Deputy Speaker, which I believe many colleagues will recognize, that in over 100 hours of debate, more than a thousand amendments was not conducive to the idea that people wanted to seriously make progress with this bill. And it was to all intents and purposes a filibuster. Our role today extends beyond debating the Terminally Ill Adults Bill. It is also, in my view, to reaffirm the will and the primacy of the House of Commons. Madam Deputy Speaker, it is the first time...
I will.
Andrew Murrison
Thank you very much for giving way. If the primacy of this place is the most important point, why has the bill sponsor said that she will not allow amendments here by this House at this stage to take place?
Speaker 54
The point was made very well by the member for Northwest Hampshire, who made clear that because of the actions of a very small number of peers, he has no faith, and neither do I, that that process won't be repeated this time around.
I'm going to make some progress. It is the first time that I've spoken on this subject, and I want to briefly set out why I've consistently supported choice at the end of life. The first is the simple principle that, faced with a terminal diagnosis, I believe it should be the right of the individual to choose how they leave this world. If we offer the choice of an assisted death in the circumstances detailed in this bill, it will be, as my honorable friend the member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket said in 2024. He said, "We are shortening death, not life."
This is not life or death, this is death or death. Our choice is to say whether we want to choose, we want people to have the choice of a dignified death or to force some people to endure painful and traumatic last moments, as so, as my honorable friend, the member for Filton and Bradley Stoke set out in an astonishing speech earlier today. The second is that I won't at this moment. The second is the medical reality that there are some conditions that are beyond good palliative care. Driving improvements in palliative care should be a moral imperative for all of us in this place, but it does not resolve the question before us today.
Another doctor, the honorable member for Hinckley and Bosworth, again speaking in November 2024. He said, some conditions we cannot provide good palliative care for, the likes of the inoperable neck cancer eroding away in the carotid artery, there is no alternative to a terrifying death.
If we fail to pass this bill, we do so in the knowledge that we are making an active choice to allow people to continue to die in this way when we know that an alternative is possible. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, I cannot support a status quo where the state decrees it knows better than the wishes of a terminally ill person. That is the reality today. People who are dying are denied their wish to end their time on this earth on their terms. I am voting for this bill today because I believe in the primacy of the elected House of Commons.
And I am voting for this bill today because above all, I believe that someone who is terminally ill should not have their last moments dictated to them by the state.
That just as in life, it is the individual who deserves the choice to choose their own path in death.
Andrew Murrison
Thank you very much indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I start by congratulating the sponsor of this bill. This is a remarkable feat of political endurance, both on her part and on the part of the honorable lady the member for Spen Valley. I do pay tribute to that. Can I also start by declaring my interest as a registered medical practitioner, active doctor.
But more than that, and probably far more important than that, as somebody who has sat by relatives in their final hours and minutes, like many in this chamber. That really has an impact and is certainly germane to the sort of material that we're discussing today.
Now, although he's apparently not voting today, the new Prime Minister has said that he wants to improve palliative care, and he wants that to be available before we weigh up this extremely difficult matter that will affect a relatively small number of people at the end of their life. Now, I don't agree with the Prime Minister on much, but I do agree with him on that. And happily, the honourable member, the member for Glasgow South West, who's no longer in his place, agrees with it too. And if I may paraphrase the Prime Minister, I want good palliative care to be available in every postcode. I think the criticism we have of it in this country right now is it is not universally available to all.
I believe that if it is, then many of the considerations we are deliberating on today would be profoundly altered. And that is one of the reasons that I will not be supporting this bill today. I will give very briefly.
Rachael Maskell
I'm grateful because I undertook the independent commission on palliative care. And we know that the data now shows a worsening of palliative care, 170,000 people not having access to the care they need, but also specialist techniques like neuromodulation, palliative radiotherapy, and nerve blocks not available to those even able to access palliative care. Does he not recognize we need to look at the skills available as well as the access points?
Andrew Murrison
I certainly do, and I suspect those sort of things were on the mind of the Prime Minister when he made his remarks recently. But the first reason I will not be supporting this bill today is I seriously do not want to live in the kind of society in which we see the frail, elderly and vulnerable feel coerced into doing the right thing. Hear, hear. We can set up panels and judges in chambers and social workers and all the rest of it, but we as humans know how humans work. We know the light side and we know the dark.
Often the currency that passes between vulnerable adults and their influencers are things that are not said. And some of the contributions today have touched upon that, and none of it is captured in clause 34.
We know that certain groups particularly like to please, to acquiesce, to oblige. We all know constituents like that, and we also know that they are often among the most vulnerable. People with Down syndrome, for example, people like the lady that was cited by my right honorable friend, the member for Staffordshire Moorlands, who featured in the Simply Crem advert. People like that, quiet people, if you like. They are among the vulnerable, and they are among the people that I do not believe are adequately protected by this bill.
Can we genuinely say that there would be a level playing field for them? Our first mission in this place must be to protect the most vulnerable.
And on the vulnerable, Canada has seen the most appalling mission creep, particularly into mental health. And that's probably why the Royal College of Psychiatrists, in company with the most impressive array of medical, disability, and charity groups, is so wary of this bill. Count them off. Do not turn a tin ear to them. Now, I do not want the tone and texture of my profession, or of any other, to be changed irrevocably by its involvement in termination.
Nor do I want others in the NHS or elsewhere in our care system unprotected by codes of ethics and opt-outs and explicitly protected in this bill to feel obliged to be involved in it. Clause 31 is all very well, but if this bill passes, the pressure on those in the palliative care sector particularly to facilitate assisted dying will be substantial. Earlier in my career, I considered being an obstetrician, and I was very attracted to it. And one of the reasons I didn't do it because I did not feel comfortable being involved with a very large part of that practice, which is termination of pregnancy. I feel this will irrevocably change the nature of palliative services in this country.
The previous health secretary pointed out the tedious business of opportunity costs. Five percent of deaths in Canada, where the law we are now debating has been in place for a decade, are now assisted. I won't because of time, I'll get the evil from Madam Deputy Speaker. Assisted cough.
That is one in 20, Madam Deputy Speaker. Translated to this country, that would mean a huge extra cost that would have to be found from other frontline services. Which services? Likely to be found from government support for hospices already reeling from national insurance increases that have yet to be fully offset. In my view, the moral, ethical, legal, practical issues that we are discussing today, complex as they are, are well beyond the scope of a private member's bill.
The only way to achieve a halfway safe and competent act is to make it a government bill, contained in a manifesto. And so far, no major political party has wanted to engage with that.
It is true that each day lives are shortened by interventions aimed at easing pain or suffering. That's what the caring professions do. That is quite different from a deliberate and systematic state-sanctioned and delivered program to end the lives of people approaching death. At the end of the day, we can rationalize the pros and cons of assisted dying, but most of us will go with what we feel in our guts. My instincts tell me that giving the state or its agents leave to end life in this way is wrong.
They tell me that however well-intentioned, it'll lead in one direction that will over time leave a grizzly trail of unintended and unforeseen consequences, and that's why I oppose this bill.
Sarah Champion
Madam Deputy Speaker, I've watched the assisted dying debate for many years since it started in Oregon. Many countries across the world now have it in place, including some of our crown dependencies. And I am pleased that this legislation in front of us is building on the good of that and rejecting the bad that it has seen. I'm also assured that there has been hundreds of hours of debate and scrutiny which has built on the bill which is in front of us now, and so I am very comfortable supporting it. I know that people have extremely strong views on that, on this bill, and I respect them for that.
I wanted to really speak to the people who are undecided because there are a lot of myths that have attracted themselves to this bill and I hope to knock some of them out.
I'm not sure if members are aware, but before I came to this place, I ran a children's hospice. And I can tell you the palliative care system is amazing. The end-of-life care that is given is absolutely incredible. But everything everybody has said about it being a postcode lottery, if it's in your area, if they have space, if it has the funding, is true. And we need more funding, and we need universal palliative care.
But that's not what this debate is about. I was also deeply shocked when the debate was first raised about the number of disability groups and disabled people who thought that this was targeted at them.
And I was shocked because I hadn't realized how vulnerable they felt in our society and that they could believe that this bill might be an attack on them. I'm not going to because we're really pushed for time. What I want to say to them is this bill is tightly drafted. It is specific. It is for people of sound mind who have a terminal diagnosis of six months or less.
That has to be verified by two clinicians and then there is a panel to make sure that you... I'm still not giving way, I'm sorry... that you are of sound mind and this is something that you want to do. Because a lot of debate has been taken up about coercive control.
And I have to defer to the powerful speech given by my very amazing honourable friend from Birmingham Yardley, whose entire career has been spent fighting against coercive control. As she said, there are not robust measures in place for those, generally women, who are suffering domestic violence, coercive control. But in this bill, there is some measure to try and make sure that coercion is not applied to people taking forward this measure. What is this debate about? It's about choice.
It's about giving adults of sound mind the choice in the last six months of their life. Currently, the only choice available is if you have a lot of money and you're physically able to go to Dignitas, or as so powerfully and emotionally outlined by my honourable friend from Tipton and Bradley Stoke, to take your own life. Neither of those are an acceptable position for us to continue with. And it's not just about pain. But let me say from my experience that there is some pain that is unmanageable and not everybody gets the dignified death that they want.
So for adults who are able to make an informed choice, I would like them to have that responsibility. I would like them to choose the time. But let's also look at what's happened internationally. Many people who go through the process, who get the certification, don't actually use it. It is a comfort blanket to them.
It is an insurance policy for them. So let us not have this illusion that as soon as, you know, you get the certification, that's it, you're marched off.
That's absolute nonsense. The choice is there all the way through. So when I say to you in a couple of hours when you walk through one chamber or the other, please think about your constituents, think about their ability to have an informed choice, and I genuinely believe this legislation does that.
Speaker 64
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As members of this House, our fundamental obligation above all political considerations is to protect those who are most exposed, most vulnerable, and least able to advocate for themselves. I acknowledge that colleagues from all sides view this bill as a measure of compassion.
But if compassion is to truly serve the public interest, then it must be paired with rigorous scrutiny and an examination of all consequences of the intended legislation. Madam Deputy Speaker, I voted against this bill both at its second reading in 2024 and its third reading in 2025. And I intend to do so again today. I believe the government should assist people to live, not to die. Our focus should be on providing hope and support to all those who feel death is the only way out of a dark situation.
That is the purpose of humanity: to preserve life. We should prioritize the improvement of palliative care and end-of-life care as opposed to directing taxpayer money away from these services into assisted suicide.
Around 60% of the public agree that we should first fix our NHS before even considering whether to introduce assisted suicide into law. I note also the right honorable member for Ilford North, during his tenure as Health Secretary, concurred with this majority in June 25, describing how it would take time and money that is already in short supply. And in addition, our new Prime Minister has outlined his commitment to a new National Care Service and to implementing reforms to strengthen our existing services. I welcome the fact that this Prime Minister is acting to protect the function of our health and care networks to support our constituents in life. Because ultimately, the NHS should be saving lives, not taking lives.
Our palliative and end-of-life care services are an essential part of our NHS and wider healthcare system across the country. I want to pay tribute specifically to LOROS Hospice, who provide free and high-quality care to terminally ill and adult patients across Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland. They care for around two and a half thousand people and play an important role in our community in Leicester East, not only in their direct support of patients, but also through their provisions to wider families and friends that are affected by such situations. In their evidence to the Public Bill Committee, they highlighted that there should be one specialist palliative care bed for every 12,000 people. But with just 22 beds, they had one for every 55,000.
How can I turn around to my constituents and say they'll have a choice other than assisted death against that backdrop? I am de- um respectfully I will not be taking interventions, many colleagues wish to speak and I am mindful of time, so please forgive me. I am disappointed and concerned that the honourable member for Rochester and Strood has reintroduced this identical bill to the House, ignoring all of the issues revealed, even the ones admitted by the noble and learned Lord Falconer in the other place. This bill's failure is not just a sign of how inadequate the private members' bill process is for a bill of this magnitude, but also the alarm over the lack of safeguards for vulnerable people, the very demographic that we in this House are supposed to protect and support. Madam Deputy Speaker, the purpose of this House is to legislate well.
We are here to advocate for our constituents, to share our differing opinions, and to use our privileged positions of influence to impact the outcome of legislation. But the methods and attitude of the member for Rochester and Strood completely discounts the hours of debate that took place on the assisted suicide legislation in the last session. The amendments tabled in the other place were not unreasonable, but were legitimate safeguards to protect those who are vulnerable in our society. Many from external organisations and 26 from the Law Society alone. Amendments that would ensure the safety of those with eating disorders and Down syndrome.
Amendments to increase the chance of catching abusive situations where the individual is being pressured to end their life.
Amendments from trade unions to protect the compensation rights of families of workers suffering from occupational or industrial diseases who seek an assisted death. The Leader of the House told MPs before summer that lessons needed to be learned about how you take the public with you, how you build consensus, not to just keep ploughing on, and that they should consider if the PMB route is really appropriate. His words fell on deaf ears, it seems. We stand here in the Mother of Parliaments as representatives of the millions of British citizens throughout our constituencies, and we have the right to debate issues because generations before us fought tirelessly to secure it. The threat of the use of the Parliament Acts to drive through this legislation completely disregards safeguards for vulnerable people.
It requires us not to care if no further changes are made to this bill.
I am well aware that this subject of debate is not one that is easy and straightforward, but is painful for a lot of our constituents and distressing for members across this House. Madam Deputy Speaker, if I can just come to my last point, one of my many concerns with the concept of assisted suicide relates to coercion. This can come in many forms, as we've heard in the House. Members across this House will know that my constituency of Leicester East has one of the highest concentrations of non-white British and multi-ethnic populations in the country. And I will say again and again, I'm enormously proud of that, but I will not support any bill that leaves them vulnerable to coercion.
Legal experts gave evidence to the Bill Committee during the previous Parliament stating that in some cultures, and I quote, "decision-making is a collective process involving family and community members."
We cannot allow the fear and distress of people experiencing palliative care, end of life care, or simply struggling with the prospect of living another day to be taken advantage of. It is dangerous that this house would consider creating legislation that would allow space for people to be encouraged, and in some instances forced, to take a decision at their most vulnerable to end their life. Madam Deputy Speaker, allow me to conclude on this point by reminding the honorable member for Rochester and Strood that 59% of voters in her very own constituency agree that this bill should not be the priority for this government. I ask her now whether she sits here today to truly represent her constituents. And if she does, and if she takes into account the situations of those within her constituency who are vulnerable, she will acknowledge that it would be morally void to support this bill any further.
Charles Noah Law
Members could help each other by keeping their speeches to five minutes. Noah Law.
I've long said that my support for this private member's bill is contingent on a commitment to improving, not sidelining, the palliative care system. And may I start by paying tribute to the courageous and dedicated palliative care workers of our country, including in my constituency at Mount Edgcumbe Hospice. And despite being seen as charitable organisations working alongside the NHS, hospices provide a vital line of support and reduce, in fact, the cost of care in our NHS itself, which is something I think should be considered. And each year these independent hospices... I will very briefly give way.
Joseph Simon Opher
I'd like to thank the honourable member for giving way. Does he acknowledge that actually, even with excellent palliative care, there's very similar rates of people demanding assisted dying?
And in fact, even in 2010, when we had probably the best palliative care in the world, still people went to Dignitas or took their own lives.
Charles Noah Law
Yes, a very important point raised by my honorable friend. And each year these independent hospices help around 220,000 people spend their final days outside of hospital settings. And this saves the NHS an estimated one and a half million bed days and more than 800 million pounds annually. Our Prime Minister is right, we must fix palliative care. And I greatly welcome that commitment to work cross-party to end the decades of political drift on social care too.
Ballooning budgets that have hit not just the NHS, but local authorities too, and particularly those in Cornwall. They've hit us really hard.
We need to fix that system so that it gives people dignity. I will keep going so that everyone has a chance to speak. We must give people dignity, security, and support when they need it the most. And at present, palliative care remains lovingly, but to an embarrassing degree, funded by the donations of those supporters who run the marathons, the charity shops, and fundraising events for hospice charities across the UK. The National Audit Office concluded that in 2023 to 24, around two-thirds of independent adult hospice sector's total income was generated from those charitable sources, and whilst around 29% of total income was government funded, primarily through ICBs.
Now, I'm all for social enterprise and charities using their assets to generating income, but the reliance on this model has to stop. So why not have a system where government provides consistent central centralized support frameworks for hospices, reflecting the consistent and vital services that they provide to our NHS and people at the end of life? It is in our government's gift to fix this. If we believe that high quality palliative care is a fundamental service at the end of life, and that system currently depends on commissioning decisions from integrated care boards, ad hoc grants, and the fundraising of local hospices, is that really fit for purpose?
We must ensure a consistent national minimum standard of provision to be delivered by every integrated care board to end the end-of-life postcode lottery.
Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Palliative and social care need fixing, and that is a concern that unites us as a House, because it is a scandal that how well you die depends on where you live. But to suggest that this bill should wait until palliative care is improved is a fallacy for two reasons. Firstly, this bill gives us an opportunity to improve palliative care. It places a statutory duty on the Secretary of State to tell this House what the state of palliative care in this country is, whether people can even access it.
No government has ever been required to answer that question, and under this bill, it would be.
Now, I would go further and say that this assessment should come into place before the Act comes into force and should be an annual update to Parliament. But that amendment cannot be made to a bill that does not exist. So if we vote down this bill today, we delay and deny the possibility of mandating a genuine assessment of the state of palliative care in this country. The second reason is that it is a fallacy is that Hospice UK has told us repeatedly that it would be inappropriate to even imply that hospice and palliative care can address pain in all circumstances. We know it does not, and honestly, it cannot.
So when we say we will fix palliative care first, we are promising something that no palliative care system has ever delivered or will ever be able to deliver, and we are asking for people to die in pain waiting for something that cannot be given.
Vote this down and we are no closer to understanding the state of palliative care. I would also add that we already have in this country do not resuscitate orders. Doctors suggest them, families agree, and a person who could have been revived dies, often without their voice featuring in any way. I have had this in my own personal circumstances where I had to run across to Guy's and St Thomas's and tell them to lift a do not resuscitate that they had put in place without consulting me. So let's not pretend that this line is sacred because no one in this place seems to be saying, well while we're at it let's scrap do not resuscitates, and it is on the same continuum.
Let me turn to the other place and to procedure. A great many peers were doing precisely their job. Others were laying siege to the bill.
And if anyone does not want to accept that both of those are true, I ask you to look at your own bias. And on some issues they were right. On treatment of depression, on eating disorders, on whether a hospice can decline to take part. When this House passed the bill, we expected it to be debated and come back to us with amendments in the ordinary way. Erskine May provides that where a bill proceeds under the Parliament Act, that this House may suggest amendments to the other House without inserting them into the bill.
That power does not sit with the bill's sponsor. It sits with anyone sat in this chamber. And if the Lords agree to that amendment, they are treated as Lords amendments already accepted by the Commons. They don't even need to come back to us. There is precedent from the Hunting Bill in 2004 and the Trade Union and Labour Relations Bill 1976.
So the choice before us is not between an unamended bill and no bill. So I'm not asking the House to accept the bill as it stands and I will press amendments myself through that process, particularly around the audit of palliative care and treatment of depression. So to members, this process can be improved. As a Conservative, individual freedom, choice and personal responsibility shape my decision making, until those freedoms cause harm to others. For years I have listened to debates on this issue waiting for the harm in the principle of giving us autonomy over our own bodies and our own destiny to materialize.
There is no harm in the principle of assisted dying, and I'm yet to hear an argument that exposes it. This bill applies to those who have six months left to live, no one else. And I'm arguing for a freedom that harms no third party, but will relieve a great deal of suffering. In our last debate, I told the House my mother's last words were, "I cannot go on like this." And she died a few days later, and that was a great kindness to her, even if it was a great cruelty to me and my children.
But too many in this country, this great compassionate country, go to sleep at night desperate for the pain to end, and wake the next morning knowing they must endure another day of it. A body that betrays them or racks them, where no medication will soothe it. And another day where this House has denied them to bring an end with their families on their own terms. I'm going to keep going. Members have spoken often about unexpected recoveries and how this has brought them to oppose the legislation.
This is the news we wish for every person we love and for every loved person you have. Last year, I was told twice that I would die, almost likely, potentially with complications I have that I will not speak at the moment of. So I know what it is to want to survive. I know what it is to fight.
But for many that day is not coming. There is no reprieve in that way. And we cannot write laws around the dying for a hope of a miracle that will not come for most. So I will vote for this bill because living in a perpetual state of torture cannot be right and we cannot allow people to wait for longer. If you are undecided, vote for the bill.
Do not end the argument. Continue it and I will stand with you in laying suggested amendments to the other place.
Julie Minns
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The last time this matter was debated in this House, I was sitting at the hospital bedside of my dying mother.
Consequently, I was unable to speak in that debate and unable to cast a vote. I am therefore grateful for the opportunity to speak and vote today, and I urge colleagues and the sponsor of this bill to ensure that this House has the opportunity to scrutinise, amend and make it safe. Accompanying someone you love through the final days of their life is one of the most profound experiences any of us can have. It confronts us with suffering, vulnerability, fear, and also with the importance of care, compassion and human dignity. That experience did not make me indifferent to the arguments for this bill, quite the opposite.
It made me determined that before we offer people assistance to end their lives, we as individuals and especially as legislators have a responsibility, a duty to ensure they have access to every possible form of support to live their remaining days well. As the friend to a mother whose child was failed time and time again by the inadequacy of our mental health service, whose child by some miracle survived the swallowing of razor blades, anorexia, overdoses and self-harm, I know that access to every form of support was not there for them. As the relative who saw the inadequacy of social care eat away at the self-respect of a once fiercely independent woman, leaving her to conclude she was a burden and we'd be better off dead, I know that that access to every possible form of support was not there for them.
And as the daughter who sat at a hospital bedside having agreed to the withdrawal of invasive treatment, only to watch my semi-conscious mother scream for water that was wrongly withheld and writhe in agony because specialist palliative care was only available nine to five, Monday to Friday, I know that access to every form of support was not there for her. So I ask colleagues, why, when we know that every possible form of support is not there for our constituents, when we know that mental health care is inadequate, when we know that social care is threadbare, when we know that palliative care is an unfunded lottery, when we know that there is no going back when we vote for this, how, how can we prioritize and fund the resource, the care, and the support for those choosing an assisted death, but deny it?
When we know that there is no going back when we vote for this. How? How can we prioritize and fund the resource, the care, and the support for those choosing an assisted death, but deny it to the mentally ill, deny it to the elderly, and deny it to those who wish a pain-free natural death? We hear much of choice in the context of this debate. But choice is only meaningful when people have genuine alternatives.
And in too many parts of our country, those alternatives simply do not exist. Therefore, before, before, not after, not over the next four years, but before we vote to facilitate death, we have a duty as legislators to ensure that the resource, the funding, and the support is there so that we can know, know today, know before we take this vote, that every possible effort has been made to treat suffering. This bill does not do that. Madam Deputy Speaker, once we are over the edge, there is no going back. We know that in every country that has introduced assisted dying, its scope has subsequently expanded, sometimes without further legislative approval.
And yet, I will not give way. And yet, despite knowing this, we stand once more on the edge.
We stand on the edge knowing all of this bill's flaws. So I ask colleagues to pause, not step over the edge, and instead ask ourselves: are we certain that this bill definitively safeguards against coercion, including self-coercion? Are we certain about mental capacity assessments? Are we certain about terminal prognosis? Are we certain that the safeguards and review mechanisms will be in place?
Are we certain that we have ensured our constituents have access to every possible form of support to live their remaining days well? Because if the answer to just one of those questions is no, then we should not, we must not step over the edge.
Madam Deputy Speaker, let me conclude with the words of the friend I spoke of whose child was failed by our mental health service. She said, "My daughter had a history of serious mental health problems from the age of 13. At 22, she went to university and quickly realized she needed more support to manage the change. Despite her history, referrals from her GP, multiple self-harm instances that required A&E admission, community services kept saying she did not meet their thresholds. It ultimately led to total deterioration and two years as an inpatient on a secure ward.
During this time, she repeatedly said her life was not worth living and that she was in so much pain she wanted to die. After much fighting with inadequate and unsafe services, she is now living in the community, back at university, and has plans for the future. But in countries such as the Netherlands, her wish to die would have been granted under their assisted dying rules. She says, "I have my daughter today because we don't have assisted dying here." Please, please don't change that.
Monica Harding
Speaker, this bill is not safe. And as of today, the responsibility for this bill falls on us and only us.
If we vote yes today, then unless the movers, who accepted no critical amendments at the committee stage last time, unless they have a 180-degree change of heart, then we can expect this bill to become law as it stands. And despite honorable members saying that they will press their own amendments, we have no assurance from the government that government time will be allocated to that. So the only question we are left with is not whether we are in favor of the principle of assisted dying, it is are we 100% content with this bill? Because we no longer have the prospect of the second chamber making it any safer. And as somebody who is against an unelected second chamber, then that is a responsibility that I am determined to accept.
But it is a daunting prospect, far more daunting than when we debated this the last time, because the responsibility is now ours and ours alone. We cannot ignore the fact that none of the expert witnesses at the Lords Select Committee could confirm that the bill was safe. None. And of the warnings, the one that resonated most for me from the Royal College of Psychiatrists when they stated, currently needs can be identified, but not necessarily met. Somebody could proceed to an assisted death where they may have made a different decision had those needs been met.
During the passage of this bill, two of my siblings who suffered with poor mental health throughout their lives have died.
I witnessed their struggle, the terrible fear and pain of cancer while their mental health worsened. In both cases, the medical staff couldn't get their mental health medication right because of poor handover between practitioners, a service design issue, because of the difficulties in assessing the mental health of patients in a palliative state, a clinical issue, and because the psychiatry resource was not available, a resource issue. None of these issues will have been resolved when this bill becomes law.
This bill is not contingent on making palliative care provision better or mental health provision better. And there is no provision in this bill to assess unmet psychological medical needs at any stage, nor consult others involved in the patient's care historically or involved through their life. Family members like me, who had seen them failed by systems and processes throughout their life and was desperately concerned that those systems and processes might also fail them at the end of their life. It is our duty to design the systems and processes which are safe for people like my brother and sister. And on this occasion, I don't think that we have done so.
Many professional bodies are clearly warning us that we haven't. There will be no amendments to protect people like my brother and sister. I would have wanted them protected. It's down to us now. The other place can't help us or hinder us.
The responsibility sits squarely on our shoulders. And this is no longer about the principle.
We have had that debate. It is about the practice of this bill, which the movers have shown time and time again that they will not permit to be amended. The experts, the clinicians, the groups asking for the most vulnerable in our society are overwhelmingly telling us that this bill is not safe. The offer of assisted dying to people in the position of my siblings is the very opposite of autonomy. Today we must accept our responsibility as MPs, grave responsibilities to those most at risk.
Today this is not about the principle. This is about the practice and the bill is not safe.
Today we must vote no.
Sadik Al-Hassan.
Sadik Al-Hassan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And may I pay tribute to the my honourable colleagues from Filton and Bradley Stoke, Birmingham Yardley and Rutland and Stamford for sharing really heartfelt stories and showing the strength that I wouldn't be able to show. My mom passed away in November last year and their stories and what they shared with us today are inspiring. And like many across this House, I've spent a great deal of time thinking about this debate, reading constituent stories, many of them heartbreaking, and reflecting on what this bill means to me personally, as well as what it means to the people of North Somerset who sent me here.
At the heart of this debate is autonomy, dignity and humanity. The question of whether someone who is terminally ill can choose the manner of their death is fundamentally a question about agency. These people did not choose their illness. They did not choose the suffering that came with it. They did not choose the impact it has on those who love them.
But they might be able to have some say in how their story ends. And that I believe restores some measure of dignity and control that illness has taken from them. Many of you will know that I practiced as a pharmacist for nearly 20 years before my election. That means I've seen the faces behind this debate. I've watched people collect prescriptions that offer nothing more than a sticking plaster over terminal illness.
Pain managed, but suffering not ended.
A safe and legal route at the end of life would not replace good palliative care. It would sit alongside it, offering the small mercy of choice to those who want it. And another element of this debate I had to consider is as a Muslim, this question sat alongside my faith in a way I had to think through carefully. And I've concluded that while I personally may not choose to make use of this provision, my faith guides my own life, it is not my place to let it dictate someone else's final chapter. This debate is at its core about whether people have the right to choose.
And it's worth remembering that choice is itself central to faith. Belief only has meaning because it is freely chosen. If I were to use religion as a basis for stripping others of their choice, it would turn faith against one of its own foundations. My faith guides me to live my life and make my choices. That right to choose, I believe, should not be denied by any one of our beliefs, however sincerely held.
Like so many North Somerset residents who have written to me on this issue, I believe that those who are suffering, often for long, unimaginable stretches of time, deserve to be offered a choice.
Mims Davies
Mims Davies.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for calling me. There is no conscience issue more capable of dividing constituents, family, or indeed this House, than that of assisted dying. And we can all agree, no one wants to suffer unnecessarily at the end of their life, and no one wants to witness their loved ones suffering.
We are all here in this place doing what we believe is best to achieve that end. This debate means the subject of death as a process again is out of the shadows. Where we as a society have thrust it over the many years, unwilling to confront our own mortality, avoiding difficult discussions even with our own families until reality finally hits us, as it does, we just don't know how. It is a truth that the death of a loved one and our own inevitable decline can sometimes arrive with real fear, real pain, and sadly with too much unnecessary and unsupported suffering. But it does come to us all and it would be wiser for us to be ready to face it, to prepare for it and to be able to live with it as individuals, as family, as society.
And for those of us here today as lawmakers, in reality, a change can happen in all our lives, whether a bolt from the blue, accident, incident, tragedy, a violent attack, a diagnosis, or simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time can mean life changes in an instant, and who you are and what you are capable of and what your life is now and onwards comes into focus. And my dad and our lives changed in an instant. He was attacked at work, punches thrown, fell and hit his head on the curb, saved by a passing man on his lunch break with first aid training. I was 11, he didn't recognize us for several months, and as a result, the financial impact, we eventually lost our home, our family business, and the surety that his hard work had given us. So disablement can begin at birth, it can be acquired, it can come as a health condition, all depicting what happens next.
Yet we are legislating and potentially fundamentally changing every person in this country's relationship today with the state, with their doctor, with the NHS, depending on their health, their preparedness for what is next, and the support they may not have. Over the past two years, I've listened too carefully to my colleagues on all sides of the House who've made personal arguments for and against. I've read the many briefings sent to me by charities, organizations, and groups and representatives from right across our society. And I've heard too from a thousand or so of my constituents, who I deeply thank for sharing their own stories and thoughts.
And I've reflected back on my own experience, my father's and other friends and loved ones, as it does when you witness accident, incident, or health condition, or eventually that death of a loved one. And we know that many people are fighting and come to this place for better lives, for better treatment, for updated drugs and better knowledge and empathy, often living and pushing for living longer after an initial prognosis they have been given. And my father lived a longer life than in fact my mum, who became his main carer.
She previously worked with disabled young adults, helping them into work and helping them to thrive. And as someone who was previously having the honour of being the Minister for Disabled People, Health and Work, I roundly appreciate that some of our most vulnerable often do feel under-acknowledged, undervalued, unheard and screened out of life and work and wider society. And in this role, I had to learn and be ready not to base policy making on my own thoughts and my own family experience, but to put good lawmaking at the heart of what I did. People must not feel pressured, worthless or subject to coercion, defined solely about what they can't do. My dad too often felt worthless.
Long term, he felt less of a man, no longer a provider, a business owner, and went back to his farming roots, but a head and neck injury meant this wasn't sustainable. An unseen disability saw him succumbing to early onset dementia with trauma-induced epilepsy and diabetes.
He far too often felt he was worth more to us dead than he was alive. This was long before the realm of social media and the additional pressures that all of that entails. So I do believe this process is completely wrong, sadly, for a vehicle of this bill to bring forward such societal consequence and change, to change the relationship between a patient and doctor, individual and state, and change significantly all of our connections with the NHS. I will do.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
I thank the honorable lady for giving way.
Is she not like me then puzzled that the sponsor brought back the same bill despite there being many amendments that the sponsor in the Lords agreed needed to be made and as the sponsor today acknowledged needed to be to included?
Mims Davies
Absolutely. We are here to make good laws and today's vote as we've heard is not simply on the principle of the bill but on the detail or frankly the lack of detail. Good intentions are not good enough. We are voting not for what we want to happen because of this bill, we are voting for what will happen. And we cannot continue to divorce this from reality.
It will impact right across government, our communities and intertwine us swiftly into new challenges. Too often in this place we have had good intentions but no delivery plan. We cannot continue with that. The bill's own sponsor in the other place felt his own need to bring forward 70 new amendments. Let me just make some progress.
I have four main concerns: funding, assessment process, lack of institutional opt-outs, and crucially, the auto-commencement clause. Can we all look at our local NHS teams and know that we are ultimately taking more resources from them? The impact, the equality impact assessment explicitly acknowledges disabled people and those from ethnic minorities, often who we speak about in this place with prevalence because we can do it for them. This puts this at odds with this bill. There is much more I'd like to say, but I need to conclude.
This bill, although well-intentioned, is simply a mixture of naivety, idealism, and wishful thinking.
No delivery plan, and it greatly raises the hopes, the great hopes in the hour of need for care and good support and understanding of our constituents. We are being asked to send this bill back to the other place and perhaps use the Parliament Act to force it through regardless of fitness for purpose, with all knowledge of its flaws and its lack of workability, to just get it done. But that means that we are not listening even to the doctors who have spoken in this place today. I cannot subscribe to this type of lawmaking, Madam Deputy Speaker, no matter how well-intentioned. I am grateful we are talking about life and death and end-of-life care and what value we put on people and loved ones.
We are fighting for better palliative care and we are doing what we can for people to give them all they need as death approaches, but I cannot in good faith support an unsafe private members' bill and support this process we today are undertaking.
Hilary James Benn
Hilary Benn.
Thank you indeed, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a very difficult moral and practical question, but for me it is fundamentally about whether we can act to relieve human suffering. Now, we've heard a number of really profoundly moving speeches in the debate today. I would highlight in particular the speech of my honourable friend for West Lancashire and my honourable friend the member for Filton and Bradley Stoke, because we are talking here about people who fear or face unbearable pain, choking or gasping for breath or loss of control at the end of their lives.
Are they not vulnerable too? It's a really, I think for me, a really important point. And the question is, can we really look them in the eye at that moment and say, "I'm very sorry, but I am not prepared to vote to support you being given the means to remove that fear"? Not everyone will take advantage of it, but it for them is an assurance. Or to relieve that suffering, even though that is what you wish.
And are we going to say, "I'm sorry, but I will not give you the means of determining the manner of your passing from this world, surrounded by those whom you love"? I am not going to give way because of the constraints of time. And I don't think we can any longer justify the contradiction that is at the heart of this debate.
We know people with terminal illnesses are already killing themselves. That happens, not at all covered by the protections that are contained in the bill that my honourable friend has moved. And you know, the biggest contradiction of all for me is the fact that there are those who travel abroad. We know this is happening, and I think it's a very uncomfortable fact for those who oppose the bill for this reason. I think it's a gaping hole in the argument against the bill, because the truth is that the Crown Prosecution Service was faced with a terrible dilemma.
They could see the number of people going to Switzerland and they had to ask themselves, are we actually going to prosecute mums, dads, spouses, lovers, friends, brothers and sisters for going with those that they love to be with them at the end? And that is how they came to draw up their guidelines. And if you read them, for me, they're full of common sense. Because they say in these circumstances, it's not in the public interest to prosecute someone. And if you look at the figures, the vast majority of family members who've accompanied their loved ones to Switzerland have not, quite rightly in my view, been prosecuted for what I would regard as a final act of love.
Indeed, it would be an outrage to prosecute them. But you know, despite those guidelines, some people are fearful because they get questioned when they come back.
And some have not gone to Switzerland with their loved ones to hold their hands at the last for fear of what might happen to them. So the question I put to the House is this: if we have in effect legalized assisted dying for British citizens who have the money and the means to do it abroad, and we have, and I've heard no one in the debate so far criticize that, then why are we not prepared to provide the same means to people to bring their lives to an end who are terminally ill here in the United Kingdom? And Madam Deputy Speaker, coming to terms with our own mortality is about the final journey that we will make. We talk about awe and wonder.
I never fully understood what awe and wonder meant until I was present at the death of those I loved most dearly. And you know, when the bill was given its second reading, when the result was declared, there was this extraordinary moment because there was complete silence in the House. Complete silence. And why do I think that was the case? Because we understood the significance of what we had just done and the consequence of the bill that we had voted to eventually send to the other place.
And today we're called upon to make once again our choice.
I have made mine, and I will cast my vote to enable those who are terminally ill, who want to take control of the moment of their death, who want to be able to relieve their suffering, who want to feel that they do not have to fear what is coming, to take that decision if that is their choice. And I would urge the House not to deny those people that choice.
Rosie Duffield
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Rarely do we debate legislation that represents quite such a seismic shift in the relationships between individuals, the state, health providers and civic society, and there is so much at stake. When members believe strongly that a bill is flawed and could be abused, resulting in serious harm, we have an absolute duty to implore others not to simply let it pass and hope for the best, but to consider it fully, deeply, and to accept that our duty is first and foremost to protect lives.
The potential consequences of poorly drafted legislation without robust safeguards are ultimately the responsibility of every single member in this room. I come to this debate wearing several hats. As the representative for Canterbury, the home of this country's Christian faith, rather than removing that aspect in this debate as others may have chosen to do, I must consider the views of the church, and the Archbishop has made her view very clear again this week, as well as representations from our sizeable mosque and that community.
As a daughter who this week last year was sitting at my father's bedside as he was dying from the early onset Alzheimer's that so cruelly began when he wasn't very much older than I am now, and as the partner of a filmmaker who directed the BBC's documentary Better Off Dead, led by Liz Carr and based on her decades of disability rights activism, I was already aware of Liz's work through her Not Dead Yet campaign, but the opportunity to learn much, much more by discussing this subject at home in depth for so many months was invaluable. Lifelong campaigner Baroness Jane Campbell has seen off so many attempts to pass assisted suicide legislation in the other place that she likens it to Groundhog Day. In the documentary, she says, "People are decent, kind. They think they're doing us a great favour by giving us this choice, but what they don't realise is how deadly this choice can be." And it is worth repeating that not a single disabled rights organisation or professional body supports this legislation.
And if this place were truly representative of the UK's population, there would be almost a hundred physically disabled members of Parliament, but we are nowhere near that. Sorry, oh, um, sorry. Oh, go on then.
Marsha Cordova
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to thank my honorable friend for what is a very powerful speech that she is giving. And she truly sets the tone when she talks about disabled people. Will she agree with me, there was a poll that was out this morning, that polled thousands of disabled people, where many of them said, and rightly said, they need assistance to live.
In fact, we have to get our palliative care and also social care right, with the right investment, before we could even begin to engage in a discussion or a debate around assisted death and assisted suicide. So does she agree with me that these are the priorities that we should be taking, not trying to push through legislation that is flawed and not fit for purpose?
Rosie Duffield
Absolutely, and I thank my friend for her contribution and her considerable experience in this area. We hear a lot about coercion. Those with learning disabilities are surely the most extremely vulnerable to that. The elderly, people with dementia. I know before my dad lost the ability to speak, he could absolutely have presented even to medical professionals who didn't know him like the family did, as capable of signing on the dotted line.
In reality, he would have forgotten almost immediately what had just taken place, but he retained an ability to mask his confusion, to be jovial, and to mask his memory issues for quite some time. And as for the slippery slope, every single example in every other nation proves without a doubt that assisted dying legislation may start off with the intention that it will only apply to terminal illness, and dementia and Alzheimer's are of course terminal. Yet that has expanded alarmingly in Canada and the Netherlands, so much closer to home. Briefly.
Elizabeth Rachel Collinge
The honourable lady for giving way. I'm sure she's aware that the law in Canada was brought in after a Supreme Court judgment, whereas our Supreme Court and of course the European Court of Human Rights have repeatedly refused to rule on this, saying quite rightly that it is a matter for Parliament.
So does she not agree that this jurisdiction is different and does she not accept that this is a matter for Parliament and can only be changed like that?
Rosie Duffield
We talk a lot about Canada, but the Netherlands is practically next door to my constituency and that is a democracy that is very similar to ours. And we see people in their 20s who've been allowed to take this path, which I think is absolutely shocking. Mental health and even solvable social temporary problems have entered the fray in those other nations. Depression, homelessness, young people opting to end their lives. Those in favor of this bill may dismiss that as being scaremongering, but it happens in one of our neighboring democracies.
One of our most powerful speakers here, the member for Bradford West, this week hosted Alicia Duncan, whose story featured in Better Off Dead.
Her mother was put on the Canadian MAID system's track one. That's for those who have a terminal health diagnosis, despite not having one. Alicia's family believe that she was essentially coerced through an abusive relationship and her children were not able to prevent her death. These horrifying cases may seem isolated, but there are many, many more, stories that didn't make the final cut of the documentary, trust me, stories not told to anyone. But we make laws based on the worst-case scenarios every single week.
So why is this bill so almost uniquely optimistic? If we have any doubt, we must vote against this bill again today.
It doesn't mean that we believe the principles of it are entirely wrong. But please, I would urge colleagues to listen to disabled activists like Liz Carr, Tanni Grey-Thompson, Jane Campbell, and experts in palliative care in this place such as Ilora Finlay and Professor Katherine Sleeman, and please vote against this bill if you have any doubt.
Sarah Smith.
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am sure that I am not the only member who came to this place because I felt that too often the voices of those people who I wanted to represent are seldom heard, and I felt a duty to ensure that they were heard in decision-making at the highest level.
And while I am the Member of Parliament for everyone in Highburn and Haslingdon, and while I recognize many people in my constituency might support the principle of an assisted death, today I must vote considering the perspective of those many hundreds of people who have written to me for whom this specific bill is a terrifying prospect. Many of those have written are disabled themselves or caring for severely disabled children or family members, people getting older and worried that they would become a burden, people who know because of the color of their skin that they will face different treatment in our NHS and worry what that would mean for themselves or their elderly parents. We must all consider the privilege that we hold in this place.
The confidence to challenge a doctor's assessment, to turn down the suggestion of assisted death, the belief that we might be able to afford the care that we need when we are older and make a true choice about how we might die. But we must remember that this is not the experience of most people, and certainly not the experience of those with lower levels of education, from ethnic minority backgrounds, those with disabilities or struggling to make ends meet. For them, the suggestion made by a doctor may easily sound like a decision for what is best for them. For them, the likelihood of having their mental capacity accurately assessed is far less than it would be for many of us. For them, and indeed for most of us, the assessment around how long they have left to live is often hugely inaccurate.
John Hayes
I will take the intervention, and she's absolutely right.
And what this debate is illustrating is a difference across this House. It's the difference between those who feel that individual agency is always supreme and those who, like her and me and many others, believe in social solidarity, believe in our responsibility, indeed our mission, to protect the very people that she describes who would be at risk. There is no doubt they would be at risk from this bill.
Madeleine Sarah Smith
I could not agree with the honourable gentleman more. They cannot escape the often unintended prejudices they face every single day in their engagement with our health services.
And that is why they know this bill will treat them unequally and they are begging us not to pass this bill into law. Disability rights groups also have shared with us that introducing assisted dying devalues the life of disabled individuals by framing dependence as an intolerable condition and one not intrinsic to all our lives. Relying on each other is what makes our society strong and we must not tolerate a situation where individuals make decisions from which they cannot return on the basis that they perceive themselves to be a burden. This law, if passed, will almost certainly further increase the gap in life expectancy between the richest and poorest people. Given that people living in more deprived areas are likely to acquire complex multi-morbidity seven years younger than those in the richest areas and are far more likely to feel that they are a financial burden to their families, it is reasonable to anticipate that this will lead to people with less money dying younger.
Madam Deputy Speaker, is that the legacy that those voting for this bill today want? In Hyndburn and Haslingden, I have seen how systemic failures in social and palliative care have added to the suffering and challenges many in my community have faced. And like many of us, I have sat with loved ones as they were dying without the palliative care that they needed. According to Marie Curie, currently one in three people die without good palliative care, and during these debates we have heard so many horrific stories of death, which of course we must do all we can to avoid. I spoke with one of the most highly regarded palliative care nurses in the world, who has spent most of her career in South Africa with children who have AIDS and who've died far too young.
She told me in her decades of practice and thousands of patients, there were only two patients she could bring to mind when she was unable to offer them a good death with the right treatment and care. Assisted dying is not a choice if palliative care is not provided as an alternative. As it stands, the costs of assisted dying are supposed to come within the existing health budget. Research carried out by Sue Ryder found that to offer consistent palliative care to every patient who needed it, we would need to double the levels of funding from the NHS, costing around an extra 300 million pounds a year. We have to be clear about the priorities and honest about what is possible.
This bill intends to force the NHS to implement assisted dying within four years.
It is just not realistic to say with budget constraints and capacity limitations that both palliative care can be improved and assisted dying can be introduced simultaneously. We are taking 10 years to implement the SEND reforms that we are proposing, and yet we expect to do this within four? What this law should do is provide that assisted dying is not introduced until palliative care is fixed first, and this bill fails to do this. Furthermore, the evidence from other countries is overwhelming: introducing assisted dying leads to a decrease in the investment in palliative care. I will close to say that a Labour government, it was a Labour government that introduced the National Health Service with the aim, and I quote, "to secure improvement in the physical and mental health of the people in England and in the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of physical and mental illness."
And it is this mission that staff in the NHS have signed up to deliver. Let this Labour government not be the one that brings in a bill that effectively entirely undermines and changes this forming part of the NHS and let's instead vote today to kill this bill.
Thomas Gordon
Tom Gordon.
I'd like to start by paying tribute to the member for Rochester and Strood and also to the member for Spen Valley for their hard work, not just on this bill, but the one in the last Parliament that I sat on the bill committee and tabled many amendments, sometimes much to the frustration of the honourable member for Spen Valley in the last Parliament. I want to talk about a number of people who died without dignity and without choice today. The first one of which was a story I remember as a teenager my mum told me about her uncle. He was terminally ill and she cared for him during the end of his life. She went round to his house to check on him, knowing that the end was getting near and tragically stumbled upon him, he'd collapsed on the floor and died.
That was something that stuck with her to this day and informs her views and my views on assisted dying. The reason I say he stumbled and collapsed on the floor is my mum was led to believe he was making his way in his final moments across the room to pick up the shotgun on the back of the door to end his life. That is the reality for people like my mum and her uncle and many other people. A number of years ago, I also ended up dealing with a situation not too dissimilar myself. I was living back home at my mum's and nipped next door to where my gran lives and heard a loud bang.
I ran across the road with my gran and we found the neighbour John, a pig farmer, who was suffering unbearably with a chronic life-ending condition, who'd decided to take matters into his own hands. That is the status quo.
That is the reality for people today who are in pain, who have unbearable suffering, who are terminally ill and we do nothing to protect them. That is why I am in favour of a change in the law and it is one of the things that drives me to this place with the conviction that something, a law like this, has to be better than what we currently have which offers no safeguards and no protections for people in those final moments. No one wants to die. It is not a choice they make, but we can give people that choice about their end of life and how they may see the end. And it's not just a choice for terminally ill people, but also for people who are in remission like my mum.
A number of years ago my mum had breast cancer. She had a stage one and a stage three breast tumour, both independent, in the same breast.
In my mid-twenties, I faced having to have a conversation with my mum about what would happen if she, a single parent, was to pass away and leave me with my then five or six-year-old sister. That is not a conversation that I ever forget, and it's one of the things that motivates me to talk about this issue as prominently and as much as I do. For my mum, she's made clear that if she was to end up with secondary breast cancer and it coming back, she wouldn't want to go through the ordeal and the trauma of the surgery and chemotherapy that she faced. She's got lasting nerve damage and a quality of life that is poorer and reduced as a result of that original cancer. It is something that causes her great concern every single day.
And every time I've come to this chamber, or to the chambers where we had the conversations for the Bill Committee, I ring her first and ask for her advice. She has routinely said that when she goes to her breast cancer support meetings with other friends who are in remission, time and again, they say that having that choice, even if they seek not to use it, would bring them great comfort.
That is why I come to this place with such clarity on this issue. It is those people who are living in those circumstances or those people who didn't have a choice that guide my views on this situation. I think for me, if we were in that situation, I would fight tooth and nail for my mum to go through with having surgery and having chemotherapy or radiotherapy or whatever it may be. But I respect it would be her decision, even if I would not like the consequences of it. And today, that is why when we're revisiting this conversation, when we're revisiting this piece of legislation, I don't see this as a final say on this bill.
It is restarting that process which was abruptly ended by members in the other place. We've heard a lot of information today about oh amendments wouldn't be accepted and with the greatest respect to the member for Rochester and Strood and the member for Spen Valley, in the last parliament, despite being a supporter of this bill, I consistently put down amendments to make it a bill which I thought better reflected the realities for people, people who might have neurodegenerative diseases and other criteria. We know that when we look across the globe that this bill is the most restrictive, the most narrow. To suggest that this is a bill that would somehow be a new frontier that has never been delved into before is simply untrue. We are lagging behind international comparators.
We are lagging behind giving people that choice. We know people who have the means or the money can have that right right now by travelling abroad.
We know that all too often people who don't have the money have to take those circumstances and actions tragically into their own hands and are robbed of a good death. So today I would encourage all members and those who are genuinely undecided or wavering as we sit in this place that a vote at second reading will continue this debate. It will allow a continuation and it will allow for members to table amendments at report stage. And importantly one of the things that people keep ignoring in this debate is if the Lords operate in good faith and they send us sensible suggestions we will end in ping-pong. We will be able to pick up amendments that would further allay those fears that would strengthen this bill and the idea that that's something that can't happen is one that is simply untrue.
So I would encourage all members today to make sure that they continue this debate and give opportunity and choice to people at end of life.
Margaret Ruth Cadbury
Ruth Cadbury.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I supported this bill in 2015 and I will again as this bill goes through its processes. I am truly grateful for all of the work that so many members here and in the other house have done to work on the detail of this bill. And I am confident that we have, it has been improved significantly and learned from the experiences of jurisdictions across the world, many of whom have had assisted dying for many years. And let's remember, in most of those jurisdictions, only about a third of people who choose the option of assisted dying actually go ahead and need to use it.
My resolve has been strengthened, Madam Deputy Speaker, by those I've heard from with direct experience. And I will mention just two experiences told to me by people I know well. One is a constituent who asked me to support the change in the legislation. His brother was diagnosed with cancer and after an operation that proved unsuccessful, was admitted to a hospice for end-of-life care. He said about his brother, he was very philosophical about what was going to happen.
His one request and hope was that his death was not going to be prolonged and painful. He received excellent care from an amazing team at the hospice. But sadly, when the time came, he suffered in a way no human should have to. We don't allow, my constituent went on, we don't allow our pets to suffer the way he did.
His acute suffering and pain lasted four days. When he was able to, he pleaded for help for the pain to stop. The hospice did everything possible to help, but there are legal limits to what they can do. If he could only have received a life-ending intervention five days before he died, as he wanted, he would not have had to suffer the indignity and agony of a painful and long-drawn-out horrific death.
The second experience is that described in several occasions in this House by Paul Blomfield, former MP for Sheffield Central, about his father's death. And Paul continues to be a powerful advocate for the right to choose, and his full speeches are preserved in Hansard, so I'm just going to quote a small part about the experience after Paul received a phone call that his father had been found dead in his garage after receiving a terminal diagnosis of inoperable lung cancer. From Paul's words: "He had faced various health problems positively until the diagnosis clearly led to his decision to take his life. He could not talk to me or his partner about it because he would have made us complicit. The current law forced my father into a lonely decision and a lonely death.
And he died prematurely, because I'm sure that what drove him to end his life at that point was the fear that if he did not act when he was still able, he would lose the opportunity to act at all. Madam Deputy Speaker, those potentially facing unimaginable pain or suffering after their terminal diagnosis, despite the best palliative care, have options now that are invariably lonely, like Paul's father, or involve an arduous and costly journey by going to Switzerland, or they have no choice, such as that of my constituent's brother. The many people who've shared their experiences of facing death soon have told us they want to die on their own terms. And we also know, through various credible polls, that the majority of people in this country want that choice for themselves. I don't want to deny them the right to be able to make that choice.
Martin Vickers.
Martin Vickers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for giving me the opportunity to speak in this so important debate. Understandably, we have heard some passionate contributions and courageous ones, such as the from the honorable lady for West Lancashire, who's no longer in her place, but she gave a remarkable contribution to the debate. In the House, we discuss a whole range of issues week in, week out, many of them rather mundane, but nothing, of course, is more important than these issues that affect life and death. I would have thought, to be honest, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the mountain of briefings, reports, individual letters, particularly from a number of clinicians, would have been sufficient to persuade most people that this is an unsafe bill.
But my conclusion is that I want to speak about the the wider implications. Other members have mentioned the impact on society. I claim no particular insight. Indeed, I see through a glass darkly. Some of us will believe that life is God-given, others not.
But what I'm sure we can all agree is that it is uniquely precious and that we should do all we can to preserve it. I do not in any way question the motives of those members or the members of the public who take a different view. Many will have reached those conclusions, as we've heard today, having witnessed the slow and sometimes painful death of a loved one. I've a firm view that if assisted dying is legalized, we will be poorer as a society.
We will have crossed a line. We will have accepted that, to adapt the phrase I used earlier, life is not uniquely precious, and importantly, we will have changed the relationship between doctor and patient. That relationship is crucial and it could be compromised if the patient was anything other than 100% certain that the doctor or clinician was striving to maintain life. When we are old, weak and seriously ill, we need compassion and support, not the nagging doubt that the treatment that we are receiving is not entirely... No, I can't give... there's no time for interventions.
As societies have evolved and civilization has advanced, care of the vulnerable, those who are sick and those who need comfort nearing the end of their lives has become a higher priority, and rightly so.
In preparation for this debate, I reread an article that the former Supreme Court judge Lord Sumption had published in the Sunday Times in November 2024. We cannot produce legislation that meets every circumstance. Lord Sumption has stated that the decision to allow doctors to help bring about the death of a human being crosses a major moral threshold. I think that is sufficient warning that we should be very, very confident that this bill safeguards that. I don't believe it does.
As I say, we can't produce legislation for every individual circumstance, so we are left with the alternative of including sufficient safeguards.
Even if you support the bill in principle, this does not have those safeguards. If one is old, frail, weak, and seriously ill, one needs help, support, and compassion, not the added worry and the nagging doubt over whether everything possible is being done to preserve one's life. Both my parents died of cancer and suffered in their final months. I well remember the telephone call from the consultant after the tests on my father when he said, "We must hope that God is merciful and does not allow him to suffer for too long." Although he did suffer, he lived for a further six months after I received that fateful call, and in that six months I saw him enjoying life, sharing time with his then four-year-old granddaughter.
In his final weeks, he spent time in St Andrew's Hospice in Grimsby. I saw then what comfort could be offered through palliative care.
No longer did he suffer the periods of pain that he had in earlier weeks. And that happened as long ago as 1988. Things have improved dramatically since that time.
Neil Hudson
I'm very grateful to my honourable friend for giving way. Quite rightly, when we enter this life, the NHS, the state supports us through obstetrics, gynaecology, maternal health, neonatology and paediatrics. But at the other end of our life, when we leave this world, the charitable sector picks it up. The majority is delivered outside the NHS. Surely that can't be right as a society.
Surely we have to fix that and sort palliative care before we go anywhere near this bill.
Martin Vickers
I thank my honorable friend for that intervention and he makes a, an important point. Going back to St Andrew's Hospice in Grimsby, my mother actually died in hospital on the day that she was due to be moved into that hospice. And how I wish that only a day or two earlier she had been able to do that and receive the care that I know from subsequent visits that they have provided. We all have to cope with the loss of loved ones and such experience raise in the mind of any right-thinking person the question of how we minimize suffering. If someone has previously indicated their wish to hasten their death, I acknowledge it's extremely difficult to say, "Sorry, that's not possible."
However, I believe moves to legislate for assisted dying would be yet another step that lessened the value of human life that we as a society place on it. I suggest to the House that though that of the expert opinions and personal stories we've all received must, even if you in principle favor assisted dying, make you think seriously about whether or not this bill is the right vehicle to introduce it. In my view, it is not. There are too many safeguards that are lacking. It must be rejected.
Life is precious and we should recognize that.
Abena Oppong-Asare.
Abena Asare
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Before I begin, I'd like to declare an interest as patron of my local hospice in my constituency, Community Hospice. I want to be clear from the outset that I'm not opposed to assisted dying in principle, and I understand why many people support a change in law, and I recognize compassion that motivates those views.
However, today I want to set out why I remain unable to support this particular bill. This debate evokes deeply held views across the House, and I respect my colleagues who have reached a different conclusion. But the question that has troubled me throughout this debate remains the same. Can a choice ever be truly free if the support, care, and dignity people deserve are not equally available to all? Through my work with my local hospice, I've seen firsthand what excellent end-of-life care can achieve.
I've seen dignity, comfort, and compassion, and I've seen how much those final months, weeks, and days can mean to individuals and families. That experience leaves me convinced of one thing: dignity at the end of life is possible, and it's our challenge to make it available to everyone.
I've also listened carefully to constituents on all sides of this debate. One constituent wrote to me about caring for both her husband and her former partner after they were diagnosed with terminal cancer. Both were told they had no more than six months to live. Both lived for more than a year beyond that prediction. During that time, they were able to reconnect with family, spend precious time with loved ones, and continue living meaningful lives.
Her message was simple: prognosis is not certainty, and diagnosis is not the end of the journey.
That does not mean doctors are wrong, but it does mean that when Parliament is considering legislation built around predictions of life expectancy, we must take that uncertainty seriously. That's why I believe the concerns raised by organisations such as the Royal College of Physicians and the British Geriatrics Society about the end of life's uncertainty, safeguarding and the definition of terminal illness deserve careful consideration. Madam Deputy Speaker, I cannot separate this debate from my own experiences either. Members of my family have experienced discrimination within the healthcare system. These experiences leave a lasting impression.
They remind you that trust, access and outcomes in healthcare are not always experienced equally by everyone.
And those inequalities, in a moment, in those inequalities, they do not disappear when people seriously become ill.
John Hayes
I'm grateful to the honorable lady for giving way. And what we're now saying to those clinicians is we want you to do much, much more. We want you to gauge whether people have been coerced. We want you to make a definitive judgment about how long someone has to live. This is an unbearable pressure on those whose mission is to save lives, not to take lives.
Abena Asare
I thank my honorable friend for his intervention. I also want to talk about data from the King's Fund, which shows that in 2023-24, local authorities received over 2 million requests for social care support from new clients. But only 859,000 of those received publicly funded long-term social care, nearly two-thirds of them older people.
That means 58% received no support. Furthermore, the government's equality impact assessment gives me pause. It acknowledges concerns that people from ethnic minority backgrounds may face higher risks because of poorer access to healthcare, poverty, lower quality of care, and higher levels of abuse. Disabled people and disability organisations have also spoken powerfully throughout this debate about their concerns and the risks they believe this legislation could pose.
We should listen carefully to those voices because for many people, the question is not simply whether someone has been coerced, it is whether they are making this choice in circumstances none of us would want for ourselves.
Daniel Francis
Thank you, and I thank my honourable friend and my constituency neighbour for giving way. This week, we've seen evidence from Kingston University which reinforces the experience of people with learning disabilities, that they see advice from a doctor not as advice, but as a recommendation. And we know from their experience in COVID, they were five times more likely to have a do not resuscitate order placed on them. So does she share my views that those issues in the equality impact assessment reinforce the view that for people with learning disabilities, this legislation would remain unsafe?
Abena Asare
I'd like to thank my honourable friend from Bexley and Crayford.
I do share those concerns. I've met with constituents who have also been impacted and I've seen it in the equality impact assessment. So I want to go back to the point: it is whether we are making this choice in circumstances none of us would want for ourselves. So the person unable to access the social care they need, the person worried about the financial consequences of their illness, the person who feels like a burden to those they love, and the person feeling loneliness and dependency or abuse. Where evidence identifies greater risk for particular groups and where respected voices continue to raise concerns about whether existing safeguards are sufficient, I believe Parliament has a duty to take those concerns seriously and test whether more can be done.
Because access to death should never be easier than access to dignity in life. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want every person approaching the end of life to receive the dignity, support, and compassion that I've seen provided by our hospices across the country. But having considered the evidence before us, I am not persuaded that these serious concerns around inequality, disability, safeguarding, and end-of-life uncertainty have been adequately resolved. Until I can feel confident that these safeguards are strong enough to protect the most vulnerable, I do not believe Parliament should create a legal route to an assisted death.
Christine Jardine
Christine Jardine.
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the honorable member for bringing this back and giving us another chance to debate this, although part of me regrets, and I'll explain why, that we're having that other chance. And I respect everyone who has taken the responsibility of coming here today to do this again, and I particularly respect those who've shared their very moving personal stories with us all. But most of all, I respect and I would like to apologize to those who are going through the trauma again of waiting to find out if they will have the choice. I have huge sympathy for them because they believed when we originally passed this bill and sent it to the other place that if they needed it in four years' time, they would have the choice. It would be in their hands.
But that has been snatched away from them.
That hope has been taken away, not by us. We fulfilled our responsibility to the electorate. We spent hundreds of hours in committee, in private discussions, in debates, in the report stage, going over this bill in minute detail until we could in confidence send to the other place the best bill we thought possible. Of course, we thought they'll amend it, they'll bring things back, but we have fulfilled our role and respected the will of the British public. Unfortunately, when it went to the other place, that's not what happened.
A handful of peers blocked it.
They did not show, I'm sorry I won't take interventions, I'm sorry. They did not show the same respect for the repeatedly expressed will of those who face the end of their lives.
Sam Rushworth
Would she acknowledge that the handful of peers that she refers to includes two the former presidents of the BMA, Royal College of Psychiatrists, a leading professor of palliative medicine, a former chief executive of NHS England, two former attorney generals, and the former president of the family division of the High Court?
Christine Jardine
I do, but they are each one individual, and each of the professional organizations is neutral, and believe me I envy them on that. They are neutral on that. We have the responsibility to make the decision.
Now after today, if we do as we did before because we have already said the majority of us that this is the best bill that we can produce. We have made that decision once already. The majority of us did. And we sent it to the other place. And if we do that again today, I hope that they listen, that they take that on board and that handful of peers who blocked it.
Yes, okay, certainly.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Thank the honourable lady for for giving way and she speaks with with great passion.
Does she agree with me that members in the other place bringing forward amendments the like of suggesting that women who'd been through the menopause or men needed to have a pregnancy test before they could be eligible for an assisted death was a deliberate attempt to wreck the bill as opposed to undertaking their important role of scrutiny?
Christine Jardine
I completely agree and I think it did the other place no credit at all that they did that. But the other thing I think that is interesting and noticeable about all of our experiences that we have today, I have personal experience which I admit influences my view. I saw my mother go through a very painful death and wish she'd had the choice. I don't know what she would have done, but I wish she'd had the choice. But I think what is interesting is that we've all taken different things from those experiences.
Some of us have said we can't do it because of that experience and others have said we must do it because of that experience because we have all made decisions.
We all have the right to make decisions for ourselves. And that can surely be no more important than when we face the final decision that we will face. And it's for that reason, to respect that choice, to respect the decision which has already been made in this place, to respect the will of the British people, that I would ask the House to send this bill back to the Lords again for approval.
Liz Kendall.
John Kieran Mullan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is the first time during this Parliament that I've been able to speak publicly about assisted dying and why I support a change in the law and indeed this bill. A decision, you know, I voted for 11 years ago when the then MP for Wolverhampton South West, Rob Marris, put his assisted dying bill to Parliament.
And I do think of all of the people who have suffered unbearable pain and loneliness since that first debate took place. Now, I'm going to make three brief points and forgive me if I don't take interventions, I know there's so many people who want to speak. The first is why I support a change in the law in principle. I have always believed that so long as it does no harm to others, people should have as much control, say, and choice over their lives and the decisions that matter to them as possible, no matter what their background or situation. That power should be in people's hands to live or die as they choose, not as anybody else thinks they should or tells them they should.
And that this shouldn't only be the privilege of those with money, knowledge, or resources. For me, this applies as much to the end of your life as it does throughout the rest of your life, and arguably more so, to choose as best we can how we leave this mortal coil, on our own terms, in as little pain as possible, with grace, humanity, and dignity, surrounded by the people we love and who love we in return. And that is not the case at present, as my honourable friend for the member for Filton and Bradley Stoke so bravely and movingly set out.
The principle of choice is deeply important to the people and families who have suffered unbearable deaths and who are worried about unbearable deaths, whether or not they use that choice. Many have talked about having that option as a kind of insurance policy or as a comfort for them when they're going through those difficult times. And that principle of choice and how important that is leads me to my second point, which is about the argument that we need better palliative care and social care before any change in the law. The truth is, if you genuinely believe in choice, it's not either better care, palliative care or social care or the option of assisted dying. It is both.
Because even with the best quality universal palliative care, it will not alleviate unbearable suffering for some people.
We know that from respected research institutions, from hospices and from patients themselves, and we should listen to their voices. Now back in 2000, the year 2000, the then editor of the British Medical Journal, Richard Smith, wrote a powerful article entitled "A Good Death". And I remember reading it and how, how amazing I thought this, this article was at the time. And in it he argued that medicine in particular, but also society as a whole, does not give the attention we should to helping people die a good death.
But our ageing population and the increase in long-term chronic conditions, so sudden death is no longer the norm, means we need a new approach to look across the broad spectrum of support that is needed to provide a good death, based on clear principles, including being able to retain control of what happens, to be afforded dignity and privacy, to have control over pain relief and other symptom control, to have choice and control over where death occurs, who is present, who shares the end, and to be able to leave when it is time to go and not to have life prolonged pointlessly. I see today's debate very much within that context on what makes for a good death. So alongside a change in the law on assisted dying, we must also improve palliative care and social care for families. I have campaigned for that for years, for more beds in my local hospice, Loros, for for free social care and choice at the end of life.
And so that, as Richard Smith argued all those years ago, we as a country and society bring death more into life. And that is entirely within the power of this government and this House. And I know my honorable and very dear friend on the front bench will care passionately about those issues. My third and final point is about trust in our democratic process. And I want to pay tribute to the right honorable member for Northwest Hampshire for the very powerful speech he gave earlier on this point.
I have the greatest respect for many knowledgeable, experienced, highly principled members of the House of Lords.
But it is not right and it is not acceptable that a tiny minority should be able to talk the bill out with hundreds and hundreds of amendments for the sole purpose of scuppering this bill. A bill that, may I say to honorable members, has been far more highly scrutinized than many government bills, the most scrutinized in my 16 years in Parliament, and a bill that was passed by this House of elected members. The Lords should vote on this bill, amend it if they see fit, send it back to us, just like we do with all other bills. We have done our job. Now the House of Lords needs to do theirs, to give people the dignity, respect, choice and control over how, where and when they die that so many hundreds of people have not had in the decade since we last faced this issue.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome the opportunity to now be able to give my personal views on this bill as colleagues in health have taken over responsibility for it. I spent most of my life as someone that was highly sympathetic to the cause of assisted dying and imagined that I would support it if I ever was an MP. But that changed in 2018. That changed when I read the Gosport Memorial Hospital Independent Panel report published in that year. That is a report that should be more widely read and I often wonder why it didn't get the attention it deserved because it found between 1987 and 2001 more than 450 NHS patients had their lives prematurely shortened by healthcare staff.
Dr. Kieran Mullan.
John Kieran Mullan
They were mainly elderly, the average age of 81 but as young as 61 and more than 70% of them were admitted to hospital not needing palliative care or at the end of their lives. And the report describes what happened to some of them. One patient was admitted for respite care but deteriorated and became confused during his stay.
Staff asked permission to give him diamorphine, but his daughter refused as he was not in pain. However, his wife later agreed and he was started on diamorphine by syringe driver. He died the same day. A man admitted for dementia was started on diamorphine syringe driver. Staff asked his son for permission and he gave it, but he felt there was no explanation of what it meant to be given diamorphine.
The dose was doubled and his father died five days later. His son felt that the diamorphine had effectively killed him. Why did that happen? That happened because the staff in that hospital and that ward had developed a culture of prioritizing the convenience of looking after patients over the value of their lives. And it speaks to something we often don't like to talk about and that we might feel guilty about, and that is that looking after people is not only just challenging, it can sometimes be deeply unpleasant.
As a doctor, I've helped look after people that when you approach them to give them care, they'd scratch at you or hit out at you.
I've helped look after patients who refuse to stay in bed, even though it's in their best interests, and continually wander the wards and need to be monitored all of the time. And perhaps in what might seem banal, but is actually very challenging sometimes, patients who continually call out for help again and again and again and again, perhaps asking for a medicine they've already been given or a meal they've already been given and refuse to be consoled. And that brings out perhaps what we would want most of the time, the best in us, the best in our nature, to be kind and caring and compassionate. But it can also sometimes bring out the worst of our nature, our impatience, our intolerance, and even our cruelty.
And whilst I've seen that happen in hospitals, I know that goes on in private homes up and down the country every day. And whilst I don't seek to say that this bill will be used in that same way to deliberately bring about the ends of the lives of confused or elderly patients, my worry is how it inserts itself in that battle in our country between the best and worst of our nature, in families and in conversations and settings where people, as much as we don't like to believe it, actually actively for selfish reasons wish their relatives were dead, and that those relatives know that their family wish that they were dead. I don't want a bill or a message from this Parliament to go out to the wider country to say that actually not just Parliament, but through the mechanisms of the NHS, a wing of the state, we will sometimes support and help you to end your lives.
I remain deeply sympathetic to the scenarios and circumstances that people have described, and I can personally foresee a situation where I would want to make use of this bill and feel it would benefit me. But we shouldn't legislate for what we might want. We have to legislate for what is in the broader interest of our constituents and our country. Not least because, as many have articulated, this bill in itself has some serious flaws. Particularly the arbitrary decision to implement it in four years' time, regardless of what might be happening to the situation in our palliative care services, when we've seen even recently them facing very new and real challenges when it comes to funding.
So while I understand why people will see this will bring benefit for some people, and I acknowledge that it will, I think the price we're asking some of the most vulnerable in-need people in our society, the risk that we're asking them to face, the price we might be asking them to pay, is simply too high.
Mary Foy
Mary Kelly Foy.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
We've heard much today about the legal and the medical and ethical questions being raised by this bill. And for me to ignore the warnings of the medical professions is absolutely baffling. But my remarks today will focus on poverty, inequality and what dignity really means at the end of life. And my daughter Maria has been in my mind throughout my considerations. Maria lived with severe cerebral palsy, she was non-verbal and required round-the-clock care.
And from the day she was born, we were told that she might just have six months to live. But she defied this and lived for 27 years, bringing immense joy to our family. And it's because of Maria that I approach this debate with concern.
I fear for non-verbal or vulnerable people, and I worry for those who don't have a trusted person to protect them or speak out for them. Now, I'm sure we all want to see dignity for those at the end of life. But we must ask ourselves what dignity really is. Dignity in these circumstances means being well cared for, supported, receiving the best possible treatment, and knowing that your life is valued. It isn't dignified to feel pressured towards death because of burdens of cost or social and economic pressures that accompany serious and terminal illness.
And when we talk about coercion, we often think of pressure from individuals.
But the greater risk may be social coercion driven by inequalities that exist in our society. And under the current proposals, briefly, because you have done a few.
Joseph Simon Opher
All right. Can I just say there hasn't been one confirmed case of coercion anywhere in the world under any of these jurisdictions.
Mary Foy
Thank you for that intervention. You will find that there is, there are statistics that 8% of those, 8% in America have been, who've been deemed having a choice, have been facing huge difficulties around their financial issues, their financial situation. No, I won't, I've already given.
Daniel Francis
Does my honourable friend and the Kingston University research which I referred to earlier shows that in the Netherlands, people with learning disabilities actually cited they were coerced into an assisted death? So would my honourable friend have the same concerns I have about that matter?
Mary Foy
Thank you for that intervention and I couldn't agree more. Couldn't agree more and we've seen things happening around the world in similar jurisdictions where where these issues have bore light. And under the so we have seen that we do know that there is a greater risk of social coercion driven by the inequalities that people face. And under the current proposals, will the panel of experts be able to adequately assess the impact of the wider pressures of life? The truth is, when we talk of choice, the reality of making such a choice is very different for the wealthy than it is for others.
Inequality shapes health outcomes throughout our lives, as well as the options available to people at the end of their life. The choices facing someone who is financially secure are very different from those facing someone on a low income, relying on benefits or struggling to make ends meet. And as evidence from other countries starkly highlights that such social and economic factors, including inequality in the provision of healthcare, are significant for those who are deemed to have chosen to end their lives, and we should not ignore this.
Now, for more than a decade, we've seen public services come under strain, disability support reduced, and rising hardship for many families. During COVID, we witnessed the immense pressures on our health system. And what I worry is that we risk telling people we cannot always guarantee the support needed to live well, but we can offer greater choice in death. Real choice can only come with high-quality care, strong support services, and access to excellent palliative care. That would provide dignity, and it's our job and a challenge for society to deliver the chance of real dignity for those facing terminal illness.
And the people most exposed to the risks within this bill are often those already facing disadvantage: older people, women, those living in poverty, and those with poor mental health. And we live in a very unequal society. The wealthy are better protected from hardship, while others face pressures that can profoundly influence their decision.
And I so I cannot be clearer enough, clearer enough, poverty should never be the reason for someone to choose to die. And to conclude, I return to Maria. While she won't be able to hear my remarks today, I know she'd be pleased that I finally got to make my case. And I urge colleagues to bear in mind people like Maria when they're casting their votes. If we are serious about dignity and choice, then our first duty should be to improve care, strengthen support and tackle the inequalities that shape people's lives.
Carla Lockhart
Can I please encourage members to think of colleagues when it comes to their contributions and not to speak for too long, obviously I can't put a time limit. Carla Lockhart.
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and can I commend the honourable member for West Lancashire, one of the most powerful speeches I believe we've heard in this place today.
The words we use in this debate matter. And if I've learned anything in my 20 years of politics, it's to be honest with people and the public that we represent. And the soft language of assisted dying is misleading the public because it obscures the stark and very, very dark reality of what is actually being proposed. We should have always had the courage to call things for what they are. Of course, we all want assistance when we are dying, but that's not what this bill does.
It's not an extra shot of morphine to ease someone on their way. It is a bill that allows doctors to provide lethal drugs for a patient to end their life.
Let the reality of that sink in. Our great NHS, the principles of which are to protect and save life, will be responsible for state-sponsored suicide. And that's what it is. And Madam Deputy Speaker, yesterday was World Suicide Prevention Day, and the irony should not be lost on any member of this House. Healthcare professionals and charities work tirelessly to prevent suicide.
They seek to reassure people in despair that their life has value, that help is available and that hope remains. But what does this bill do? It weakens the principles that underpin our suicide prevention strategies.
So I ask supporters of this bill, what message does a system of state-sanctioned death send to those already wrestling with suicidal thoughts? How can we genuinely regard suicide as a tragedy to be prevented while at the same time allowing it to become a medical intervention to be facilitated by the state? One of the deepest concerns is that this bill does not require proper exploration of why a patient wishes to end their life. What if it is driven by financial worries or poor access to care or fear of being a burden on family members?
Sometimes a desire to die is actually a cry for help, yet under this legislation, death will be presented as an acceptable response to hardship. The lines get particularly blurred when it comes to certain manageable conditions such as type 1 diabetes. If a person decides to refuse treatment, these conditions could end up meeting the bill's definition of terminal illness. When the definition is this broad, it is easy to see how the law will expand over time. And I know the opposite to my view will hate the word slippery slope, but that's the reality in every country where this legislation has been approved.
Oregon, similar to our bill, now diabetes and arthritis. Belgium, children, people with autism. Spain, a lady who was gang raped ultimately went on to end her own life. I also have really grave concerns about those who may be quietly pressured into choosing assisted suicide.
This bill allows doctors to discuss assisted suicide with patients, but it makes no exception for those who may be especially vulnerable. These people include... I will give way.
Janet Jessica Daby
The honorable lady for giving way. The very definition of coercive control is it's insidious and we don't find out about it until years later. Maybe the victim themselves wasn't aware of it until years later. A victim of coercive control in assisted dying, there would be no years later, would there?
Carla Lockhart
I couldn't agree more with my honorable friend. These include people with learning difficulties, those with a history of suicidal feelings, or those detained for their own safety under the Mental Health Act. To give just one example, people with Down syndrome rely heavily on parents and carers to help navigate complex decisions.
They are deserving of every possible safeguard, and this bill does not provide it. Instead, according to the National Down Syndrome Policy Group, the bill presumes the best rather than legislates for the worst. That's not good legislation. As one member of the group said, "I worry that I and others with Down syndrome and our families and supporters might be pressured to consider ending our lives when we face the effects of aging." "Haven't we enough stigma to deal with already?"
The bill will also, no, I'll not give way. This bill will also fundamentally alter the patient-doctor relationship. For generations, people have looked to healthcare professionals for treatment and care. That trust is precious.
It should never be diluted, and this Bill drives a coach and horses through that relationship. The role of our health service should be to do no harm and to stand alongside patients in their darkest moments. And I'm not standing here with rose-tinted glasses on. I know that too many people struggle to access end-of-life care they deserve. But the answer to that failure cannot be to make death more available; the answer is to make care more available instead.
We should be focusing our energy and resources on strengthening palliative care services and ensuring that nobody faces their final days without proper support. Madam Deputy Speaker, my opposition to this Bill is not only practical, but moral.
Life is precious and it deserves protection from its beginning to its natural end. That is what my Christian faith teaches me, and that belief is shared by many of my constituents and by countless people across this great United Kingdom. This House was founded on Christian principles; this legislation is so far removed from those Christian principles. The true measure of a compassionate society is not how easily it facilitates death, but how faithfully it cares for those who are suffering. As I watched my dad take his last breath on this earth, tears rolled down his face, his pain had often been unbearable, but our NHS stepped up.
His consultants, pain nurse, and those caring for him rallied around him because he wanted and deserved to live. He did not need help to die; he needed help to live. And when death came naturally, he needed care, compassion, and dignity. That is what every vulnerable person deserves.
I cannot support a law that would allow the state to be involved in ending human life. And that's why I and my colleagues on this bench will be voting against this bill today.
Janet Daby.
Janet Jessica Daby
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And surprisingly, I'm not trying to persuade honorable members how to vote one way or the other during this assisted dying debate. And this is because I think honorable members know by now how they're going to vote and why they are going to vote the way that they do. However, I feel I need to share my thoughts and my views with my constituents of Lewisham East why I'm voting the way I am today. And I say this because there is a significant change as to how I voted previously.
Now, if honorable members are influenced by my contribution, then indeed so be it. Madam Deputy Speaker, I will get right to the point.
I previously voted for assisted dying. I recognised then, as I do now, the deep turmoil that family members experience when they know or indeed see their loved ones dying. That agonizing distress or pain they experience is something no one wants for themselves or indeed their loved ones. However, I cannot shake from my mind a conversation I had with someone some time ago about assisted dying. They'd been diagnosed with HIV and AIDS, and this was before the time of advanced medication for this illness.
Their body was breaking down and they had been informed their prognosis was bleak.
They said had assisted dying been an option for them then, they would have taken it. However, it wasn't an option and after some time they have since been stabilized on medication. They're in full-time work and although they do have side effects and they do feel tired, they are living a meaningful life. And they are no longer, as you can imagine, an advocate for assisted dying. When I previously voted for assisted dying and my voting on the different amendments at that time was varied as I was trying to navigate my way through this issue ensuring I was considered in my approach.
But on my mind was always the questions of inequalities, how this would impact poor communities, isolated individuals, people with mental and physical disability as well as those in controlling, as we've already heard and discussed, coercive relationships. And how this system would work in our society now and how it will change in years to come.
And also, of course, how this would impact Black and minority ethnic communities who already experience deep inequalities within health services, as shown by years of impact assessments and reports on this issue. As chair of the Sickle Cell and Thalassaemia APPG, I'm constantly reminded of the health inequalities and suffering that people with this disorder continue to experience. They are constantly undermined, ignored, and their disorder is grossly lacking in research funding. Part of this new evidence has also been the government's own impact assessment on the effective, on the effectiveness of assisted dying on the health service.
This recent report suggests that people from ethnic minority backgrounds may be more susceptible to coercion, to coercion due to structural pressures such as poverty, lower care quality or domestic abuse. As a result of these pressures, the impact assessment states that ethnic minority people could disproportionately choose to have an assisted death to avoid financial hardship or escape abuse. This relates to broader concerns regarding the availability and quality of social and palliative care, particularly for already disadvantaged communities. Earlier this year, up to 60% of hospices, hospices reported that they were having to make cuts to frontline services as a result of financial pressures. And while the government has increased funding for the sector, it is clear that far more work is needed before those in need of support at the end of life receive the dignified care and choice of treatment they deserve.
Alongside this, there is the additional pressures on the broader health service and the legal sector resulting from this bill, which reinforces my decision to vote against it. Now I implore the government to invest in hospices and palliative care across the country to make it the best it can be for all postcodes. Now following my vote in favour of assisted dying, for the following two nights I had nightmares about dying and death. I had to wrestle with myself knowing that I was not entirely comfortable with the decision I had made, and my conscience was not at peace. And I cannot again in good conscience vote for the bill.
In fact, I wish there was a bill before this chamber that we could have all gotten behind, as there is so much that needs to be done in our society. I decided that if the opportunity should arise again, I'd be voting against assisted dying.
Now, I do not judge the conclusions that others, my honourable members and honourable friends from across this chamber reach, but I ask that we respect each other and we do that in a respectful way.
Andrew George
Andrew George.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's an honour to be asked to speak in this debate. Indeed, this is the first time that I have, and indeed I'm a sponsor of the bill and a member of the Health Select Committee. I congratulate the honourable member for Rochester and Strood in the way that she introduced this debate and the outstanding work of the honourable member for Spen Valley in the way that she has championed this over all this time.
If this bill is defeated today, it will leave us with a significantly unsatisfactory and dangerous status quo where all of the legitimate concerns raised by those who oppose the bill in respect of safeguards and coercion will simply continue, but probably be increasingly driven behind closed doors as things, I fear, will only get worse. And also, it will reward the worst and most reprehensible behaviour by those in another place to block this bill last time. If the purpose of the shocking behaviour of a small minority of peers towards this bill earlier this year was simply to make a powerful case for their own abolition, then they've certainly hit the jackpot on this occasion.
And if we reward them with victory today, we weaken the relationship between the two Houses and cede more power and influence over our democracy than is healthy or indeed wise. There is a concern, a theme which has been running through the debate today, that implies that the bill is insufficiently perfect, that indeed perfect being the enemy of the good syndrome that runs through this and indeed a lot of other debates and other legislation. The concept that there is a 100%, as I think my honourable friend for Esher described it, 100% perfect bill is simply in the minds of those who believe that it is possible to get to that point. When have we ever had a perfect piece of legislation? If the honourable member wants, I'm sorry, because of time, I don't think they can answer this one with a postcard to me rather than an intervention.
When we when when have we ever had a perfect piece of legislation? We we end up perpetually restrained we would end up being perpetually restrained from making progress because we only produce compromises and not the utopian perfection which we all want. If we were all sent off at the beginning of this process two years ago in terms of terms of how best to handle end of life considerations and everyone was given a pen and paper and go off into a darkened room without their mobile phones to draft a piece of legislation we'd have 650 perfect bills all written according to the opinions of everyone in this chamber. All bills are are inevitably a compromise a compromise I can't because because of the of the time constraints.
All bills are necessarily a compromise and that doesn't mean to say that we simply have to make do with bad legislation. And indeed, this is the bill that was sent down to the other place was in fact a very, very good compromise, an excellent compromise which actually achieved all of the matters which... I'm sorry to be stirring people up at this stage in the debate, particularly as time is indeed very short.
The other theme which runs through this is that somehow people believe that the issue of palliative care is one as if there were a binary choice available to us. So that indeed either we have 100% palliative care or we can go down the route of backing this bill, or that we shouldn't support a bill like this until we have 100% perfect wrap-around universal palliative care around the country. I mean, being a member of the Health Select Committee, we produced a report on this and it's quite clear that it is possible, indeed it will actually help the case for improvements in palliative care if this option is also available, as a number of other members have made the point. In relation to the limitations of palliative care, I think that point has been made very strongly by others, and indeed the point around coercion and safeguarding, because after all the current situation is that both in terms of coercion and safeguarding, the environment at the moment is certainly not satisfactory.
The bill provides safeguards where presently there are none. It is irresponsible and scandalous that some people promote scare stories about risks to disabled people, to anorexic children, to Down's syndrome children, to the vulnerable, when in fact actually those risks currently exist and indeed this bill actually provides the safeguards which I think many people want. So last time we had a vote on this issue at third reading, I thought it was this chamber at its very best. There was no choreographing of the response.
You could hear a pin drop when the result was announced. It was the a very good debate followed by followed by MPs coming together in silence following that debate and indeed people from both sides of that of the debate embraced behind the chair in tears because they understood the gravity of the decision before them. And that I don't think was respected by the way in which the Lords have treated this bill. And that's why I think it's vitally important that we send this bill back to the Lords and don't allow them to have the victory that they seek. Thank you.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Dr. Peter Prinsley.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have cared for patients with advanced cancers of the head and neck, and I've seen patients at the end of their lives, and it is this experience above all that convinces me that we must introduce this humane and dignified option to assist those who are dying in peace at a time of their choosing and to avoid the loss of autonomy and dignity that so many people fear. I fear it. Perhaps other honorable members also fear it, for none of us can know when we will die, not until we are dying ourselves. For this is not a measure that chooses between life and death, only between death and death, between dying and dying.
And that is the truth of the matter. Now, I did not always think like this, but I've seen the limits of even the most skillful palliative care, and I have seen the look in the eyes of the patient reconciled with the end of their days and the pleading expression of the poor soul to put an end to suffering.
For that is what we are debating: suffering. Assisted dying is complementary to palliative care; it is not an alternative. Now, others will say that this is unconscionable, and I respect that. I am asking the House to vote to support choice. That is all I am asking.
We voted for it before, and honourable members in the other place sought to prevent the passage of the bill. But we are not misled or deceived by such a parliamentary device, neither the public, who will not forget this moment. So I urge members across the House to support choice. That is all I am asking.
Siân Berry
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm here because we do need to change the law so that dying people have a choice for a better death than too many horrible, progressive, terminal diseases allow for now. I'm here because of my own conscience. I'm a humanist and a patron of Humanists UK. And I'm also here with the support of so many of our citizens who desperately want to see a change in the law, and of very many of my own constituents who've written to me to tell me their own personal stories of losing people under the worst circumstances because the status quo did not allow them another choice.
Siân Berry.
Siân Berry
Two weeks ago I heard from my constituent Julia, who told me about her mother Jane and asked me to speak about her case. Faced with a progressive terminal neurological diagnosis at 92 and unable to travel alone for help, Julia's mother decided in secret to end her life in a very distressing way I cannot bring myself to describe today. Julia says, "I had no idea that she was going to act on her oft-stated desire, although in retrospect I realize that a phone call we had in the morning of that day she said goodbye in her own way." "And she also made sure that it would be her friend and carer who would find her, this instead of Julia herself the next morning."
Julia says, "While I miss her terribly, I'm proud of her for her determination and grateful that the manner of her death apart, she has left me with positive memories of her, rather than the gradual eroding of herself that she, and I to be honest, were both dreading." She adds, "Now that I'm coming out of the weeds of my grief at her loss, I am determined to make her legacy the right for people in her situation, when they are faced with losing all agency, to have the choice to take the ultimate act of agency over their life." That is what we're here for. We're here to make something more humane than that situation that Julia and her mum Jane faced. Examples like these are real people, brave for telling us their stories, who have demonstrably been harmed by the law as it stands.
People are raising concern about potential harms if we change things. We have debated this so many times and now in the bill for every concern I've heard expressed at this new law being used by someone ineligible or by someone who is not choosing freely the way their terminal illness will play out. I believe we can see real safeguards in the bill before us. They are very, very strict. For some dying people, these requirements on them will be too much in fact.
So some people will be denied the service in this bill today, but people will benefit and there is a clear moral case and duty for Parliament as a whole to act to progress this issue. But now, Madam Deputy Speaker, there is not just the moral case for this bill we have debated before, there is a democratic case too.
The serious, careful work we started here must be completed in the normal way in our upper house too, for the democratic process to be completed. Last year, we voted and voted again on the principle, in the bill committee, at report stage. The earlier proposer of the bill listened and proposed over a hundred of her own amendments and accepted more than thirty from opponents who wanted to go maybe further than she or I would have liked. She worked with civil servants to make its workability crystal clear, and the minister reported back to us previously that the bill was workable. Other amendments were voted on here in this house.
At third reading we debated what we had designed and voted again. We passed on a sound piece of legislation last year.
I believe we sent the Lords a good bill, a safe bill, a compassionate and workable change in the law for the Lords to refine if they wished. And we must now say to the Lords they must collectively now do as MPs did, consider the bill with the seriousness it deserves, vote just as we did our duty in putting our vote on the record and bring it to a conclusion in that place. Honourable, I say to my honourable friends, Madam Deputy Speaker, please vote for this bill to continue so its progress and all the work we've done so far to build something better than the status quo for dying people does not end today.
Marie Tidball
Dr. Marie Tidball. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This week death has felt rather too close to home for me.
My dad, John, my constituent, my great political hero and indeed hero in life, had surgery for lung cancer, followed by a cardiac arrest the next day. Thanks to our wonderful NHS and its outstanding care, CPR and treatment performed on him was successful and he is now in the process of recovery. To such an extent that I was able to have a detailed conversation with him at his bedside, where he insisted that I come here to this place to speak and vote in this debate. My dad is determined to live.
Nevertheless, he told me that if circumstances were different, where his condition was terminal with six months left to live and had capacity to make that choice, he would want to have the option to choose an assisted death to give him dignity. Access to the choice of assisted dying, as tightly drawn in the bill today, enables the terminally ill adult who chooses it to live a good death. In the second reading of this bill, previously brought by the member for Spen Valley, I said my support was conditional on further safeguards being embedded in it, because too often control is taken away from disabled people.
And for clarity, I wanted to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, that clause 2, subsection 4 of the bill before us today says, for the avoidance of doubt, a person is not to be considered to be terminally ill only because they are a person with a disability or mental disorder or indeed both. Further, Madam Deputy Speaker, as a member of the bill committee, I worked for over 90 hours to ensure all those changes that I requested were made, and they are now on the face of the bill brought by the member for Rochester and Strood. My amendments, including to introduce two new clauses, were unanimously supported by that committee.
The first, clause 48, establishes a disability advisory board made up of disabled people and our organizations to embed a long-term and iterative structure in law to report on the bill's implementation and impact upon disabled people. The second, clause 22, sets out provisions to put in place independent advocates for people with autism and mental health conditions, enabling them to effectively understand their options around end-of-life care. Further, Madam Deputy Speaker, I also ensured the bill provides for specific up-to-date training for registered practitioners on reasonable adjustments and safeguards for autistic people and people with learning disabilities in clause 8.
Further, I secured an expanded duty in clause 28 to collect additional information about whether immediately before death the person seeking assistance had a disability as defined under section 6 of the Equality Act other than a disability amounting to terminal illness as defined in this bill. Together, all these measures create a solid foundation to enable disabled people to have a strong voice when advocating for themselves about their choices on end-of-life care and, importantly, a seat at the table scrutinising and monitoring the implementation of this bill.
Spending nearly two years thinking about death in relation to this bill has been life-changing for me, because the thing about considering choice in death, understanding what dignity in dying involves, and what living a good death really means, is that it makes you think deeply about the meaning of living a good life too. To love ferociously, to live passionately, experiencing every single moment as if suspended like a vignette woven from Charlotte's Web. After all, what's a life anyway? We're born. We live a little while.
We die.
As E.B. Webb's eponymous character points out, each of these stages of human life requires us to treat ourselves and fellow humans with dignity, to value ourselves, to enable us to feel and perceive our own worth. This bill not only anchors that dignity at this final stage, but in doing so, compels us to embed dignity at each and every other stage of our lives as well. This bill lays a counterweight alongside the government's plans to raise the quality of and access to palliative care, and to drive urgent reform on social care, to build a new system that gives people the dignity, security and support they deserve. Driving quality in these areas together can and must be done contemporaneously. My friend and incredible assisted dying campaigner, Nathaniel Dye, passed away this year.
He squeezed every single drop of joy out of life and taught me so much about why living a good death matters. For setting the bar high for dignity in death, we set the bar even higher for dignity in life.
Ben Spencer
Madam Deputy Speaker, as a former mental health doctor and someone who's done research in decision-making capacity, today in my brief time I have, I want to talk about stigma. I've looked after many hundreds, perhaps thousands of people who've self-harmed or attempted suicide. And of course, the desire for one's life to end can be an entirely reasonable and understandable wish. But it's often a manifestation of a treatable mental disorder. A treatable mental disorder.
With the right intervention, care, and support, people get better.
With a person looking back and saying, "What was that about?" "I'm so thankful I didn't succeed and I got the care and treatment I needed." But the bill refuses to acknowledge this, framing the debate, the intervention as shortening the death process or some form of assisted dying rather than what it is: physician-assisted suicide. It is designed to take at face value an expression of a wish to die as an absolute fact, an expression of autonomy, not a possible manifestation of mental illness. This is its blind spot.
This is its most tragic flaw, where I believe all problems from the bill derive from. Mental disorder can be very tricky to detect. There is nothing stigmatizing about mental disorder.
If someone in hospital expressed a wish to die. If someone in a care home or outpatient clinic expressed a wish to die. If someone here in this chamber expressed a wish to die. If a loved one expressed a wish to die. The first person I want them to see is a psychiatrist, not an assisted dying practitioner.
Joseph Simon Opher
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I just praise the House all round for some fantastic speeches, the member for West Lancashire, the member for Filton and Bradley Stoke, and indeed just now from Penistone and Stocksbridge.
So I'm very proud of our House and the way we've debated this. I've been involved in delivering palliative care and end-of-life care, and these are actually quite different, for over 34 years. I continue to do so as a GP. I will cut this speech short, but this is really about choice. Choice exists for people in France, in Spain, in the Netherlands, in Belgium, in Australia, US, in Canada, and indeed in Jersey and the Isle of Man.
And it also exists for people in this country if you've got 15 grand. However, we haven't got access to this at the moment. And what I would say is to all those doubters, this is the safest assisted dying bill in the world. Full stop. That is a fact because it's got so many safeguards, many more safeguards than the ones in Australia or in any other place.
Now I will just carry on if that's okay.
So it's a good thing to offer, it's a great thing to offer end-of-life care and palliative care. And in 2010, the UK system of palliative care was leveled as the best in the world, and yet still people went to Dignitas. Still 600 people who were suffering from terminal diagnosis killed themselves. And indeed, in Oregon, 92% of patients who opted for assisted dying were receiving good palliative care. They are different.
So I'm just going to carry on and be very brief. The one other thing I would say, there's been a lot of concern quite rightly about disabled people and people from the black and Asian minorities about whether they'll be harshly dealt with. In fact, the evidence is from other jurisdictions is that these people do not go for assisted dying. It's actually a white middle-class able-bodied thing that tends to go.
And in a way, we have the opposite problem that we need to deal with. Can I also say, can I also say, can I also say that in some studies, just to answer your question, there's some studies in California where they treated depression in people with terminal illness and it made no difference to their choice around assisted dying. Assisted dying is different because as my friend, the member for Norfolk, no, I can't remember where you're from, I'm afraid. But what he said, it's not a choice between life and death. It's death from natural causes or death under your control.
And all I would say to all these people, all of us here, is that we have a choice. We have a choice right now in about five, ten minutes. And then, but we must give other people that choice.
And is it our right to deny those people that choice? So I will now sit down because the Speaker is giving me some black looks. Thank you very much.
Damian George Patrick Hinds
Which brings us to the front bench contributions. Damian Hinds.
Madam Deputy Speaker, today is once again a day of heavy responsibility for all of us. On what we in this House call conscience issues, many of the people we represent hold strong and immutable views, and we hear from them. There are also many others who we represent who hold much more nuanced views. We are less likely to hear from them, the ones who say, "Yes, but," or, "Well, it depends," or, "I'm just not sure." Others evolve their views over time, and most can do so privately.
There is no such option for Members of Parliament, for our names are publicly recorded in a column marked "Aye" or "No." And with issues like this, members across the House cast that vote after very serious consideration, personal reflection, and sometimes deep turmoil. And members who support this bill should not have their motives questioned. Members who oppose the bill should not have their motives questioned. And members who have reached a different conclusion from one they reached at an earlier stage should not have their judgment questioned either.
At the previous second reading, we were voting on the principle of the bill, as is usual at a second reading.
Colleagues knew that amendments could be made in committee and indeed, as has been discussed, a number were. At third reading, many MPs voted in the expectation that further changes would be made in the other place. Today, we vote on the bill as it is today, which is almost, almost exactly the same as it was at that previous third reading. Now, if there is the prospect of the Parliament Acts being used, that would of course increase the importance, the salience of the text as it is now. And it is reasonable, of course, Madam Deputy Speaker, entirely in order for honourable members to consider today information that is available today, which was not available in those previous parliamentary events in the colleagues and colleagues have alluded to a number of these things.
We now have the evidence that went to the Lords Select Committee on safeguards and procedures, the updated impact and equalities impact assessments, the reports from the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform and the Constitution Committees covering the extent of delegated powers. And we've heard from Royal Colleges and other professional bodies who have a neutral stance, many of them, on the principle, but raise significant questions about particular aspects. And we know from ministers that there would need to be some reprioritization of NHS resources, but we do not know the extent. Now, none of these things decide the question for Parliament, but they may help inform us.
If any provision in the bill has not been fully brought into effect within four years, they come into force automatically. Now, different views will exist among us as to whether that can confidently be said to be time enough in considering workforce, training, operational readiness and the design and implementation of safeguards. The government has said rightly that the time taken to implement other schemes is not directly comparable because none are as in this bill. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a free vote on a matter of conscience. There is no party line on either side of the chamber.
No one, I suggest, finds this issue easy.
I, like all of us, have received countless representations from constituents, often informed by the most heartbreaking family circumstances. Their arguments are sincere and earnest and deeply moving, and in equal measure on both sides of this issue. And we can say the same, Madam Deputy Speaker, for the heartfelt speeches we have heard once again today on both sides in this House. There are moments in debates like we have had today that are difficult to sit through and listen to, but also it is the most immense privilege to be a Member of Parliament and to hear some of these testimonies.
Today we have had, again, a good and respectful debate in the very best traditions of our Parliament. And whatever the vote a little later today, that respect must endure, for this is why we are put here: to take difficult decisions about the law, decisions that somebody has to take, not because it is obvious to everyone what to do, but precisely because these issues are hard to resolve. Madam Deputy Speaker, that also involves recognizing that good people with the best intentions can and do reach different conclusions on the same question. Each of us now can only make our own judgment in good faith. Each of us bears that responsibility that can only fall to us as parliamentarians to consider the arguments, the evidence, and crucially, the legislation that is actually before us today as we cast our votes.
Alison McGovern
Minister, Alison McGovern.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Not for the first time this week, I find myself wholeheartedly agreeing with the right honorable member who spoke on behalf of the opposition just then. Of course, we will all act according to our conscience, and we respect others if they come to a different conclusion, and he and I agree wholeheartedly on that point. I would like to thank members across this house on both sides of the debate for their consideration of this legislation and their thoughtful contributions to the debate today. By my count, Madam Deputy Speaker, 40 members have spoken in the debate, and I have listened to all they've said with great interest, and I thank each and every one of them.
This is a difficult debate to speak in at times.
We heard of people's own family and private experiences. That is hard to bring to this House, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I really thank all colleagues right across every corner of this House for doing so. The issue of assisted dying has been subject to extensive and detailed consideration over a number of years, most recently in this House and the other place in the previous session, as well as outside Parliament. And we think today, Madam Deputy Speaker, of all of those who feel strongly on both sides of this debate and what they're thinking about as they listen to our discussions. And we send our care to all of those who are struggling with grief.
Let me start by first reiterating that the government is neutral on the question of assisted dying and on the passage of the bill. As the Prime Minister has said, this is an incredibly important and personal debate, and it is right that it is a matter for Parliament and not government to decide whether this bill should become law. The government does, however, have a duty to the statute books, and it's on that basis that I'm speaking at the dispatch box today as the minister responsible for helping to ensure the bill, if passed, is workable and effective. Now, I must explain to members, if I may, that in the interests of time, I'm going to keep my remarks purposefully brief and I won't be taking any interventions. And I do apologize to members wholeheartedly for that.
I would normally do so, but if I could say to members, I'm happy to discuss any issues that they have with them.
I've listened to the entire debate today. I've heard members' views and questions and many interventions. And I just want to turn very briefly to a couple of important issues. On procedure, like any private member's bill, this bill will proceed through the usual parliamentary stages, subject to Parliament's will. And with respect to questions to the government on the Parliament Acts, I would just refer members to the acts themselves, which set out conditions under which legislation may pass without requiring consent of the House of Lords.
That's a matter for Parliament and it's not for the government to decide whether to pass this bill.
And as usual with any constitutional questions, members may approach the clerks for further advice, as I'm sure you would agree, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've said I'm not taking any interventions and I'm sorry to be discourteous to the member, but I'm going to stick to that. Now, I did just want to make a few comments on the matter of social care and palliative care, having recently taken over responsibility for these most important issues. In my opinion, Madam Deputy Speaker, social care has been ignored for far too long, both the 1.5 million people, mainly women, who work in it, and the families who need it, and we heard that across the House today.
The Prime Minister has made social care a personal priority and I am working with my right honourable friend the Secretary of State to deliver changes now alongside the work being done by the Casey Commission, which we have expedited by a year. Building a National Care Service will mean people know where to turn when they need help and where care workers are given the status and the respect they deserve. We're pushing ahead with workforce changes, including career progression, training and job security. And we've made 4.6 billion of additional funding available for adult social care by the end of this Parliament, including 500 million pounds for the first fair pay agreement for care workers. And we will strengthen social care now, not just waiting for the Casey Commission, providing greater choice and independence as we do so.
Let me turn to palliative care, Madam Deputy Speaker, that many, many members have raised.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I have huge respect for the Minister. And as she said today, she's not taking any interventions. She's a very good Minister. And I trust that she will be answering in detail the points that have been raised in the House today, because having discussions with her and the government after the debate is too late for today's vote.
Now, I know she's a thorough and assiduous Minister. I'm sure she'll do her best to do that. But I think it is important to make the point to the House, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Speaker 114
As the right honorable and very experienced member will know, that was not a point of order and not a matter for the chair. But I'm sure the Minister has heard her. Minister.
Alison McGovern
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I also respect my honorable friend. And though it was not a point of order, the House will have heard what she said.
I am attempting to address the points that have been raised in the debate, particularly on procedural matters, on social care, and I'll turn now to palliative care, which I think is extremely important and has been raised very many times within the debate. Now, on palliative care, we're developing, as the chair of the select committee set out, we're developing a modern service framework for palliative care and end-of-life care. This framework is clinically led and evidence-based to support sustained improvements in outcomes for patients and carers, including by systematically identifying, measuring, and reducing health inequalities and reducing unwarranted variation in access, in experience, and outcomes.
And as part of this work, we expect all integrated care boards to complete a needs assessment to get a detailed understanding of their current and future population, including people of all ages with palliative care and end-of-life needs. And I think that this is vital in order to commission services that best meet the need whilst providing value for money. Many members raised how important this is, particularly reducing unwanted variation, and I want to acknowledge that and say that I will be working with members across this House to deliver this modern service framework. Members mentioned the hospice sector quite rightly. We provided a 125 million capital boost funding for adult and children and young people's hospices.
But I just want to say to members, I've heard the points that they've made and I know we have more to do. And many members and friends will know that in July, I lost my own mum. So I had a very practical education in this topic, and that experience will shape how I take this work forward. Sorry, Madam Deputy Speaker. To conclude, I would just like to thank all honourable members once again for all they have said.
Members will understand how difficult it is when we're sharing personal experience, and many of them have done today, and I'm really proud of everybody who has done so, difficult and challenging though this issue is. Thank you. I'd just like to also thank all members who've given me their sympathy over recent months and weeks.
It has been so appreciated. The government remains neutral on whether this bill becomes a law. But it is our serious responsibility, should Parliament pass this legislation, to ensure effective implementation within the framework provided by the legislation. And on that basis, we would provide technical support to the sponsor if Parliament chooses to progress the bill. That said, I would just repeat again the comments that the right honourable member made from the opposition dispatch box, which I will now say on behalf of the government.
This is a deeply challenging issue for us all and for the public and for our constituents that we represent. In discussing this issue, we must model the best behavior of this house: respectful, thoughtful, careful debate, listening to each other and understanding those very different perspectives that we come from. I think that we've done that today, and I hope, Madam Deputy Speaker, that whatever happens in the division, that we will be able to continue to show those behaviors and give this serious subject the deep respect it deserves.
Speaker 116
The question is that the question be now put. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. Division, clear the lobby.
The question is that the question be now put. As many as of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The tellers for the ayes are Jeff Smith and Bambos Charalambous, the tellers for the noes, Katrina Murray and Ruth Jones.
Speaker 116
The Ayes to the right were 293, the Noes to the left 218, so the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Unlock. The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary No.
Division, clear the lobby.
The question is that the bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. The tellers for the ayes are Jeff Smith and Bambos Charalambous, the tellers for the noes, Katrina Murray and Ruth Jones.
Speaker 116
To the right were 270, the Noes to the left 286, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. Can I ask members leaving the chamber to do so quickly and quietly please, we do have further motions to dispose of.
Speaker 122
Hospitality Services (Value Added Tax Exemption) Bill, second reading.
Speaker 122
Sporting and Physical Education Services (Value Added Tax Exemption) Bill, second reading.
Speaker 122
European Convention on Human Rights, notification of withdrawal bill, second reading.
Objection taken.
Speaker 147
Friday the 5th of February 2027. Controlled Drugs (Procedure for Specification) Bill, second reading.
Speaker 148
Friday the 16th of October. In-person Booking Services Bill, second reading.
Object.
Object.
Speaker 122
Northern Ireland Troubles (Criminal Investigations etc) Bill, adjourned debate on second reading.
Object.
Madam Deputy Speaker, I beg to move.
Object.
I beg to move.
Object.
Speaker 157
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. 25 years ago today, on a clear Tuesday morning, 19 terrorists hijacked four passenger planes. Two were flown into the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center in New York. A third struck the Pentagon, and the fourth, United Airlines Flight 93, crashed in a field near Shanksville, Pennsylvania, after passengers and crew resisted their hijackers. In a period of less than two hours, the Twin Towers fell and 2,977 innocent people from more than 90 countries were murdered.
Of those killed, 67 were British citizens, more than any other country apart from the United States. Thousands more were injured, and many survivors, emergency workers, and people who took part in the recovery operation have lived with the physical and psychological consequences ever since. Shall I just give way, please? I'll give way.
Jim Shannon
Madam Deputy Speaker, first of all, can I commend the honourable gentleman for bringing this forward? It's only right on this day that we do remember all of those who lost their lives, and particularly the 67 British citizens. As someone who represents a constituency in Northern Ireland and knows all too well the cruel, devastating scourge of terrorism, the effect on loved ones and also the first responders, I know that grief is indeed the price we pay for love.
And does the honourable gentleman agree with me that this House stands resolutely shoulder to shoulder with our American allies in the ongoing fight against global terrorism wherever it may be in this world?
Speaker 157
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I thank the honourable gentleman for his apt intervention and I absolutely agree with him. The United Kingdom stands shoulder to shoulder with the United States of America, our strongest and longest-standing ally. Madam Deputy Speaker, although the attacks— I will give way.
Scott Arthur
I do thank him for giving way. And I think before the last intervention he mentioned the loss of emergency workers in that brutal attack. And of course we do celebrate and salute their courage. But since the attack, we now know that more firefighters have actually died as a result of their work on the site than actually died on the day of the attack itself. So when we remember those who died that day, we also have to think about the legacy of the attack, including those firefighters who have been lost.
Speaker 157
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention and he is absolutely right. And it's a point that I'll come to later in my speech.
I think he's absolutely right to raise it now. I was just saying to the honourable gentleman from Northern Ireland, I think he's absolutely right. We stand shoulder to shoulder with our friends and colleagues from the United States because although the attack took place on American soil, it was a global tragedy, Madam Deputy Speaker. Its victims came from across the world. Its grief crossed borders and its consequences shaped the quarter of a century that followed.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the work of the 9/11 Memorial and Museum in New York is guided by three simple principles: to honor, to educate, and to inspire. Those principles should also guide us in terms of how we mark this anniversary here in Britain: honoring those who were lost, educating those too young to remember, and drawing inspiration from the courage shown in the face of terror. For those of us old enough to remember that day, the events are seared into our memory. We remember where we were when we heard the news. We remember watching the images from New York and struggling to understand what we were seeing.
We remember the shock of the second plane striking the second tower when it became clear that this was not an accident. And we remember the towers falling, knowing that thousands of people were still trapped inside. But the passage of 25 years creates a new responsibility. Every child now at school was born after the attacks. Many young adults have no personal memory of 9/11.
Indeed, one current member of this House was not yet born when the attacks took place.
In fact, across the United Kingdom, around 20 million people, close to three in 10, have been born since the attacks. For a growing number of our population, 9/11 is not a memory. It is something they encounter only in textbooks, on online videos, or in brief references during foreign policy discussions. For them, it is history. That change is inevitable, but forgetting is not.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we must ensure that future generations understand what happened, who was lost, and why the attacks still matter. Young people should understand that Al-Qaeda's terrorism was driven by a murderous ideology. They should also understand the extraordinary courage shown in response. I'll give way.
Speaker 159
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the honorable member for giving way.
And of course, we must remember the families of those killed, as well as those killed on this tragic day 25 years ago. I was working as a in the BBC press office at the time of this, and the shocking scenes playing out as everybody was literally standing around watching the scenes unfolding on television was horrific, unseen until perhaps COVID and the COVID pandemic. Does he agree with me that the international efforts to promote tolerance and understanding to avoid another such incident of this type are absolutely vital?
Speaker 157
I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention, and I do absolutely agree with him.
We should use this opportunity in the 25th anniversary year to look forward and to educate young people. I talked about educating young people in terms of Al-Qaeda's terrorism and their murderous ideology, but it's also an opportunity to teach young people in particular about the extraordinary courage shown in response to that ideology, from the firefighters climbing the stairs as others came down, from police officers, paramedics and office workers helping strangers to safety, and from the passengers and crew of United Airlines Flight 93, whose resistance prevented many more deaths. 9/11 must never be reduced to footage of aircraft and collapsing buildings, but the numbers 2,977 were 2,977 individual lives: parents, children, husbands, wives, siblings, friends and colleagues, all of whom expected to return home that evening. That includes the 67 British victims which were mentioned by me and by the honorable gentleman earlier.
9/11 was an attack on the United States, but its grief crossed borders immediately. British families received the same unbearable phone calls, waited for the same news, and experienced the same permanent empty place at family gatherings. I particularly want to recognise those British families today. Their loss did not end when the cameras moved on. Anniversaries can bring public attention, but bereavement is lived privately day after day and year after year.
Madam Deputy Speaker, earlier this year, His Majesty the King and Her Majesty the Queen visited the memorial in New York. They laid flowers beside the South Pool, met bereaved families, survivors and first responders, and left a message honouring those who had lost their lives.
They expressed Britain's enduring solidarity with the American people, and their visit was a fitting expression of the special relationship between our countries and a reminder that Britain continues to share in this remembrance. That loss also reaches into my Havant constituency too. My constituent Sally Taber lost her godson Ollie Bennett in the attacks. Ollie was 29 years old and a successful financial journalist. On 9/11, he was at the World Trade Center to report on a conference.
Sally told me that when she saw the TV footage, she knew her godson had died. Ollie's family, his godmother and his school friends were determined that his life would be remembered not for the terrible way it ended, but for the values he had lived. They established the Ollie Bennett Charitable Trust in his memory, offering grants to aspiring entrepreneurs.
Over nearly 25 years, the trust has helped 169 young people begin their dream of starting a business. The trust is now drawing to a close, but its closure doesn't bring Ollie's legacy to an end. It leaves behind scores of young people who were given an opportunity because his family and friends responded to an act of destruction by helping others create something new. Sally's story reminds us that an atrocity committed thousands of miles away can leave an absence in a home and a community right here in Britain. It also reminds us why names, photographs, voices, and personal memories still matter.
We must therefore continue to recognize that the human cost did not cease on September the 11th. The destruction of the World Trade Center released a vast toxic dust cloud and over 400,000 first responders, recovery workers, survivors, residents and others were exposed during the attacks and the nine-month recovery operation that followed, as the honorable gentleman opposite rightly said, and this House pays tribute to all of them, as he so rightly said. So it is right as well that this year, for the first time, the ceremony at Ground Zero will include a seventh moment of silence dedicated to those who died from 9/11-related illnesses. This is an important recognition that the victims of 9/11 were not only those whose lives were taken on the day itself, but also those whose sacrifice shortened their lives in the years afterwards. Madam Deputy Speaker, that brings me to the role of technology in remembrance.
9/11 was one of the first great tragedies of the digital age.
Millions watched it unfold live on television, and much of what survives was recorded by ordinary people using the technology available to them at the time. Voicemails, telephone calls, photographs, emails, webcam recordings, and amateur video, they all captured fragments of individual experience. Today, technology allows those fragments to be preserved, connected, and shared on a scale that would once have been impossible. A pupil in the Havant constituency who has never visited New York can examine a digital timeline of the morning, study primary source material, and hear directly from a survivor, a bereaved relative, or a first responder. That work of preservation is increasingly urgent as people with first-hand memories of 9/11 are growing older.
The children who lost parents are now adults.
Many of the firefighters, police officers, medics, and recovery workers have passed away. We cannot assume that first-hand testimony will always be available, so we must record it while we can, so it remains accessible in the decades ahead. No institution has done more to provide that access than the National September the 11th Memorial and Museum in New York. Built on the site of the World Trade Center, it combines the physical power of place with the evidence needed to understand what happened. Its collections preserve objects, images, recordings, and personal accounts, and its educational work helps teachers introduce pupils to an event that took place before they were born.
Anyone that has visited the Memorial and Museum, as I've had the privilege of doing with my wife, will understand the scale of its reach.
It is not only an American place of remembrance. Around 37 million people have visited the memorial, and nearly 28 million have entered the museum. Visitors have come from more than 170 countries, travelling to the place where history happened, to pay their respects, understand the attacks, and remember those who were murdered. Thank you to everyone at the memorial and museum for the care and seriousness with which you have preserved this history, supported families, and helped a generation understand the attacks. I also want to thank the survivors, relatives, first responders and witnesses who've entrusted the museum with their memories.
Sharing those experiences can carry a considerable personal cost, but it gives future generations something no summary can ever provide: a direct connection with another person's experience.
The museum's work should prompt us to consider our responsibilities here in the United Kingdom. 9/11 is not a mandatory topic in England's national curriculum, and while some schools do teach it, not every pupil will learn about it. I recognize that education policy does not fall within the minister's department, but nevertheless, 9/11 was an international event which profoundly shaped Britain's relationship with our closest ally. I would therefore be grateful if the minister addressed three questions when responding. Firstly, will she work with the Prime Minister and Education Secretary to examine how 9/11 is taught in schools and how resources from the museum can be made more readily available to teachers and pupils?
Secondly, will she ask the British Embassy in Washington and the Consulate General in New York to support closer educational and commemorative links between the museum, British cultural institutions, and victims' families? And thirdly, how can the government support British families to preserve their memories so they're not lost? Madam Deputy Speaker, today's anniversary is an opportunity to reaffirm our faith in democracy and decency, and I give way to the honourable gentleman.
Christopher Chope
I'm grateful to my honourable friend and congratulate him very much on bringing this debate to the House. And I think what he's said is symptomatic of the importance of the special relationship, which he does so much to support in his role as a member of the executive of the British-American Parliamentary Group.
Would he agree that one an additional point that could be added to the the list he wants the government to respond to would be to promote the special relationship and ensure that generations of children coming up realize that we are really close allies and should remain close allies with our friends in the United States irrespective of who happens to be holding elected office at any one time.
Speaker 157
I thank my honorable friend for his very positive intervention and also thank him for his work as an officer of the British-American Parliamentary Group. I'm proud to serve on its executive and I know the minister who is in her place will have heard his request which I certainly agree with. And I agree with my honorable friends that today's anniversary is an opportunity to reaffirm our relationship with the United States and our wider faith in democracy and decency. The terrorists sought not only to murder innocent people on 9/11 but to destroy open societies, the relationships that he talks about and the values that sustain them. They failed.
The response to hatred was courage. The response to destruction was rescue and rebuilding.
The response to human lives being lost is the determination to keep speaking their names. Madam Deputy Speaker, remembrance is not passive. Instead, it requires active choices to teach, to preserve, and to tell the stories of individuals rather than allowing them to disappear into history. Those who remember that morning must now pass on its story to those who do not. We owe it to the people who were murdered, including the 67 British victims.
We owe it to families such as Sally's who have carried their loss for a quarter of a century. And we owe it to future generations who must understand both the hatred displayed that day and the courage that came in response. Madam Deputy Speaker, inscribed in the 9/11 Museum's Memorial Hall are words from Virgil's Aeneid.
No day shall erase you from the memory of time. Inspired by Virgil's poetry, we must ensure the victims of history's deadliest terrorist attack are never lost to time. That is a responsibility carried by each generation, including our generation, and one we must always honor.
Kirsty McNeill
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm very grateful to the honorable member for having for securing this important debate and he's spoken very movingly and given the House an opportunity to mark the 25th anniversary of the deadly terrorist attacks of the 11th September 2001. And 25 years on it can be tempting to think of 9/11 as a moment in history, an event perhaps for a textbook, a museum or a documentary, and those of course are important and will come to them later. But I begin by saying that for thousands of families 9/11 is not history at all. It's a memory deeply felt of someone who left home that morning and never returned.
So today we begin with them. We remember the nearly 3,000 people killed in New York, at the Pentagon and in Pennsylvania. We remember the victims from more than 90 countries. We remember the 67 British citizens who lost their lives. We stand with those who have lost people they loved and those who have carried that loss for now a quarter of a century.
The honourable member for Havant spoke very movingly about his constituent Sally Tabor and the loss of her godson Ollie Bennett. And I want to pay tribute to Ollie and offer my deepest sympathies to Sally, to Ollie's family and to all those who knew and loved him.
The charitable work established in his memory is a truly powerful example of how a life can continue to inspire hope and opportunity for others. And we should also remember and honor the extraordinary courage that was shown that day by the firefighters who climbed the stairs of the World Trade Center while thousands of people were trying to escape, from the police officers, the paramedics, and ordinary members of the public who did extraordinary things, putting the safety of others before their own. Passengers aboard Flight 93 acted with remarkable bravery. And as my honorable friend, the member for Edinburgh South West, has told us, many first responders lost their lives, but others have lived with the physical and mental effects of what they experienced. So their courage deserves more than our admiration.
It deserves our lasting remembrance. The courage we remember today was individual, but the response that followed was truly collective, as the honorable gentleman from Christchurch has told us and the honorable gentleman, the member from Strangford.
For 25 years, the United Kingdom and United States have indeed stood together in remembrance, and we do so again as we mark this anniversary. The honourable member for Havant has also asked about closer educational and commemorative links with the National September the 11th Memorial and Museum. Our diplomatic network in the United States has worked closely with American partners and other stakeholders in support of this anniversary and will continue to look for opportunities to deepen US-UK cooperation in this regard. My honourable friend, the Minister for the Americas, represents His Majesty's Government at commemorative events in New York today, including the National September the 11th Memorial at Ground Zero and a special memorial at the Queen Elizabeth II September the 11th Gardens. There he'll join victims' families, survivors, first responders, American representatives and international partners.
While here in the United Kingdom, the anniversary was this morning marked with a special changing of the guard ceremony at Buckingham Palace.
It echoed the special program of music played there on the 13th of September 2001, when the British and American national anthems were played as a clear signal of our unity and our support. Their Royal Highnesses the Duke and Duchess of Gloucester and my right honourable friend the Foreign Secretary stood alongside the United States Ambassador to the United Kingdom, Warren Stephens, to remember. They were joined by representatives of victims' families and UK emergency services. Now these events cannot undo the pain of the past, but they are a way of us saying that all lives that were lost still matter, their sacrifices still matter, and that we will never forget what happened. The honourable member for Havant has rightly focused on our responsibility to pass the memory of 9/11 on to a new generation.
Many of us remember where we were when we heard the news, and the honourable, my honourable friend from Watford has reflected on that powerfully. But many young people, as has been mentioned, have got no memory of that day. Many were not yet born. Future generations should understand what happened and why it mattered.
Education should explain clearly the harm caused by terrorism. It should tell the stories of the victims and it should recognise the courage of the first responders. The National September the 11th Memorial and Museum plays a vital role in preserving such stories and helping new generations understand both the scale of the attacks and the individual lives affected. Wider digital archives allow people around the world to hear testimony, see photographs and explore historical records. And the UK is playing its part too.
Through institutions such as the National Archives, records connected to September the 11th are being preserved so that future generations can continue to learn from them. The honourable member from Havant has asked about how 9/11 is taught and remembered in schools, and I will make sure that his points are drawn to the attention of my right honourable friend the Education Secretary and the Minister for the Americas.
The attacks of September the 11th of course demonstrated with truly tragic clarity why our collective security matters. Following 9/11, NATO invoked Article 5 for the first time in its history, because our allies recognized that an attack on one was an attack on all. In the years that followed, British and American service personnel would stand side by side once again in Afghanistan. Many never returned home, and we remember them today too, and recognize the lasting impact on veterans and on military families. So today this House has come together to remember those who lost their lives, to honor the courage shown that day, and to stand with the families and communities whose lives were changed forever.
As we mark this 25th anniversary, let us remember that behind every single statistic was a person. Behind every headline was a family, and behind every act of remembrance is a promise.
Speaker 116
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.