European Affairs Committee

15 September 2026

European Affairs Committee Actual start House of Lords

Follow its sittings
19:57 - 21:33
Speaker 1
Good morning and welcome to this evidence session of the Select Committee in the House of Lords on European Affairs into the UK-EU Gibraltar agreement, which has come before us under the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act for consideration.  This is a public session.  We will be taking evidence and there will be a transcript which will be available for witnesses to correct for any errors that they might notice.  And of course, the whole session will be in public.  I'm delighted to welcome as our witness this morning Lord Wood of Anfield, who's Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, and with him Paul Hughes, who's the Deputy Head of the Southern Europe Department at the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office and was, of course, previously Joint Deputy Head of the FCDO's Gibraltar Negotiations Taskforce. 

We're hoping to conclude this in 60 minutes, so if we can keep the questions and the answers crisp, that would be very helpful.  And to get us going, if I may, I'd like to just ask a general question, which needn't take too long to answer, but just to sort of set the context for the evidence, which is, you know, why wasn't Gibraltar included in the Trade and Cooperation Agreement in 2020 in the first place?  We had bridging measures instead.  How successful were the bridging measures?  Why did we need something other than those? 

And since negotiations began in 2021, they seem to have taken an extraordinary long time.  Perhaps you could just set out why it's taken five years to reach this agreement.  Minister. 
21:33 - 25:09
Speaker 2
Well, thank you, Lord Chair.  It's a real pleasure to be here with amongst so many colleagues in the Lords. 

Let me just start with one minute on the purpose of this bespoke treaty, which is what it is.  As you know, Gibraltar was not included in the TCA, and I'll come back to why that might have been in a minute, which was negotiated obviously by a previous UK government.  And that meant that the people and businesses of Gibraltar had an uncertain future ahead of them.  And that's why the UK, the government of Gibraltar, Spain, and the European Commission agreed this practical and I think lasting solution, which cements Gibraltar's economy, cements Gibraltar's way of life, cements the principle of sovereignty.  And what it delivers is quite simple in one way. 

It is a fluid border between Gibraltar and Spain.  That was the prize that the people of Gibraltar were clear, you're speaking to the Chief Minister, I know, later on, that was absolutely clear from his point of view as well. 

It's stability, it's jobs, it's investment, not just for Gibraltar but for the whole region.  And crucially, a non-negotiated outcome would have, could have imposed huge economic costs, running to hundreds of millions of pounds, through disruption to cross-border workers, trade, and investment.  So that was the prize all the time, making sure that our maxim of "nothing about Gibraltar without Gibraltar" was kept to the fore.  And I'm pleased to say that has been done throughout by Paul and his colleagues and everyone who's worked on it.  On the question of why it was not included, an agreement was not included in the TCA in December 2020, I mean, in a way you should get Lord Frost in maybe and ask him that question. 

I think my best understanding is that Gibraltar was not included in the scope of the TCA because it was a position taken by the European Union at the time.  And this was probably because of Spain's view that Gibraltar should have separate arrangements with the EU to the rest of the UK.  Now, given that Gibraltar's requirements are so different, the government then, I think, then I understand, took the decision to agree to separate the discussions and pursue a bespoke agreement alongside the government of Gibraltar.  I mean, looking back, it's perhaps, this is me speculating, but it's probably difficult to conceive of how the Schengen arrangements that have been negotiated in this treaty could have been negotiated at the time of the TCA as well.  So even though it was difficult at the time, I think there is virtue in the fact that we've, after a long time, ended up with an agreement which secures that feature of the treaty agreement. 

On the bridging measures, the bridging measures were quite successful for their time.  They were informal agreements between UK, Gibraltar and Spain, primarily again focused on making sure the border was kept fluid.  And the core of them was an agreement to carry out immigration checks on EU and Gibraltar residents at the, sorry, the core of it was not to carry out full immigration checks at the land border.  But there were other bridging measures as well on things like reciprocal healthcare, data protection.  Why wasn't that enough? 

A variety of reasons.  Firstly, there were periodic and growing issues of concern with certain categories of people such as defense personnel who faced difficulty crossing the land border. 

25:00 - 27:11

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Secondly, and I think most crucially, as informal measures, they were just not sustainable in the long run. Businesses, people, and the Government of Gibraltar were severely hampered in their ability to do long-term, medium and long-term planning because they relied on informal agreements, goodwill, and we know that politics can turn things, informal understandings on their head quite quickly. So having security through a treaty was important. And the third thing about timing is the introduction of the Entry/Exit System in the European Union. It meant that Spain would have not been able to continue allowing people to cross the border.

The Spanish Foreign Minister Albares said, I think in late 2024, publicly, that the bridging measures could not continue after the introduction of the EES. So for all those reasons, there had to be a treaty solution. And the last part of your question, and apologize it's a long time, why did it take five years? I guess two reasons.

One is complexity. This is over a thousand pages long, as you will see. Poor Paul here is still recovering. It was a sort of multi-faceted negotiation across a number of different dossiers. Of course that's complex.

Cooperation was good, but Spain has views and UK has views and importantly Gibraltar has views, which meant that the conversations were long and complicated. There were particular complex arrangements that were required for things like checks on people in Gibraltar airport, which we're going to talk about I'm sure later, on customs arrangements. There was physical infrastructure that had to be constructed to make all these things possible, dimensions of military aspects. So complexity is the main reason.

I think the second reason is politics. If you look at the last five years, 2022 was a politically tumultuous year here in the UK, 2023 was election year in Spain, 2024 we had a change of government. I think the conversations, as far as I can understand, and the cooperation continued, but the pace of them probably was interrupted by those political events in the last few years. Sorry, that was a long answer.

27:11 - 27:13

Speaker 3

No, thank you very much. Lord Jackson.

27:13 - 27:44

James Stewart Jackson

Thank you, Lord Chairman. Congratulations on your appointment. I know it probably comes second to playing for Liverpool FC, but you know, take what you can get. Can I just press you, you raised the specific issue of the border.

Can you, and the term fluidity at the frontier, I think you used, or border. So what's the difference in practical terms between fluidity at the frontier, which I know the Government of Gibraltar and our government are using, and free movement?

27:44 - 28:22

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Fluidity at the frontier means that the 15,000 people who cross the border every day, that the economy of Gibraltar works on, the land border, can pass without checks. That's the key of fluidity at the border. As you know, for people arriving by air and sea, there's different arrangements, but that's the key definition of fluidity. The local economy, the people of Gibraltar and the First Minister prioritize the land border openness as the key to fluidity, but also key to the economic prosperity of the area. And so that's the, that's the key cardinal feature that the Gibraltarian people wanted and which was negotiated.

28:22 - 28:23

Lord Grantchester.

28:23 - 28:26

The Lord Elliott

Good morning, Lord Wood.

It's good to see you before the committee.

28:26 - 28:28

Speaker 6

It's nice to see you too.

28:28 - 28:59

The Lord Elliott

My question is that the agreement wishes to enshrine a mutually cooperative arrangement between the EU and the UK, but obviously its effects are going to be felt between Gibraltar and Spain more specifically. How does the government in the UK plan to navigate this complex arrangement, including as it does immediately going into dynamic alignment? Will it require additional diplomatic resources?

28:59 - 31:05

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Well, thank you, Lord Grange, for that question.

You're right that the dynamics are definitely complex. And that's why the treaty establishes joint governance bodies, including a ministerial-led cooperation council, three specialized committees, which are in the process of being set up with the EU, which is similar to the withdrawal agreement. And a range of dispute resolution mechanisms, which is standard in all international treaties, plus arrangements under that for working groups between the UK and Spain. So there's a complex web of supporting cooperative fora and institutions that will support this. I mean, just to give you a sense of the range of British engagement in this, that we have obviously the Gibraltar team in the Foreign Office, which is continuing to cooperate with the government of Gibraltar, particularly on implementation issues, which continues to liaise with the European Commission.

In Gibraltar, the Governor and his team in the Convent.

I had the pleasure, by the way, of going to Gibraltar last week for Gibraltar National Day. You can see pictures of me on the web wearing red trousers and a red tie, which is the national color for the Gibraltar National Day. It was an extremely enjoyable day. And the Governor and his team are excellent, who do excellent work in the Convent. We have the UK mission in Brussels, which engages with the EU on Gibraltar matters.

Our embassy in Madrid continue to engage with the Spanish MFA. And further, obviously, a lot of the issues to do with environmental issues engage officials from different government departments here in the UK. So not only is there the treaty set up, this network of interlocking cooperative institutions and groups, but there is also British diplomatic and other engagement throughout the system.

So, yes, it is a complex set of dynamics. We don't envisage that equipping ourselves with this challenge and meeting it in the implementation period is going to involve any significant increase in resources.

31:05 - 31:08

Speaker 7

Thank you. Thank you very much. Baroness Uddin.

31:08 - 31:27

Susy De Martini

Thank you, Lord Chair. I'd like to add my congratulations on your appointment. What are the main problems that Brexit caused for Gibraltar that this agreement is trying to solve, and what were the most delicate and sensitive of these?

31:27 - 32:40

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Well, again, not wanting to repeat myself, but you should probably ask someone else rather than me because I wasn't around.

But I mean, obviously there are lots of practical issues, teething issues both before and after the treaty, but teething issues now the treaty is in provisional force, which aren't really Brexit related. I guess the main Brexit related one that was the dominant problem was the potential for the introduction of full immigration checks at the land border. The Gibraltarian people made it clear, the Gibraltarian Chief Minister consistently made it clear that would have been a disaster for Gibraltar and for the surrounding region. And that is really what this agreement is designed to avoid first and foremost. And the bridging measures, as I said, had a temporary solution but had no long-term legal security.

So replacing those informal arrangements with something that guarantees the security and stability, that was really the big nut to crack as far as I understand it. And that's the really central feature of the treaty that's emerged.

So I guess that would be my overwhelming central problem that the treaty has hopefully resolved.

32:40 - 32:42

Speaker 9

Another session.

32:42 - 33:43

Catherine Margaret Ashton

Congratulations, it's fantastic to see you in this position. And as a fellow Liverpool supporter, always good to see the word Anfield in front of us. I live in an Arsenal household, so you know... There were lots of principles that were set out by I think Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab in 2021 to sort of say what we should and shouldn't do. And at the heart of that has been the issue of sovereignty.

And I pay tribute to Paul and his team because these are very complicated things.

It's an extraordinary document that you've achieved. Other areas where you feel that you kind of had to bump up against the principles, are there areas where you feel that there was a challenge to this question of getting the sovereignty right? And do you feel at the end of it comfortable that we've addressed all of the issues, or do you think there'll be a need to continue to address any of these bigger questions of principle later?

33:43 - 35:33

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Yeah, thank you for that question. I mean, I guess categorically, this treaty does not affect sovereignty at all. We're very clear about that. And not only did we not discuss passing sovereignty of Gibraltar without the people of Gibraltar being in consent, a long-standing principle, we didn't discuss sovereignty of Gibraltar at all in the course of this.

But just to make crystal clear, Article 2 of the treaty has a specific clause which explicitly makes clear that its contents do not impact the sovereignty position and cannot be used to challenge it. So sovereignty is not on the table, it wasn't impacted. This agreement is about the technical arrangements that apply and which govern Gibraltar's relationship with the EU. And as I said before, the outcomes of this treaty are very bespoke. They reflect the unique circumstances of Gibraltar.

It is a unique treaty. It doesn't have any wider consequences beyond that. That was foreseen in the original Foreign Secretary statement, the bespoke nature of these arrangements. And as I said earlier, that's part of the reason why the negotiations took as long as they did. Now, some of the outcomes set out in the statement are different to what was envisaged in an operational sense.

That's true. But the goals of border fluidity for people and goods in a way that's safe and manageable for customs and for the people of Gibraltar have been achieved. And the key thing is, this was an outcome chosen by the Government of Gibraltar, unanimously supported by the Parliament of Gibraltar, supported by the people of Gibraltar. It's their choices that were respected in the arrangements that have been designed. And I think that is, you will hear that message, I'm sure, from the Chief Minister.

That is the fundamental reason that this is politically secure, I think.

35:33 - 35:36

Speaker 13

Thank you. Lord Moinhan wanted to follow up.

35:36 - 35:45

The Lord Moynihan

Good morning, Lord Wood, and many congratulations on your appointment and also on your very competent handling last week of, I think, your first front bench debate in the chamber.

35:45 - 35:47

Speaker 12

Oh, thank you very much.

35:47 - 36:12

The Lord Moynihan

The question was about sovereignty. Surely it would be the case that this appears to remove the territory permanently from British trade policy, which surely must be a significant impingement upon our sovereignty. And, for example, would Gibraltar still be allowed to join CPTPP under this deal?

36:12 - 37:04

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Well, I don't think it is. I might ask Paul to answer the CPTPP question, but no, it doesn't touch on sovereignty at all. The customs arrangement, as with the border arrangements, were chosen by the Government of Gibraltar. The question of sovereignty is not touched by that. These were choices that were made in pursuit of the goal to have a land border that was open in a way that would support the Gibraltarian economy.

It's customary for governments, we do it as well, in order to satisfy treaty requirements in the name of a greater interest we have to observe certain rules. That is what the Gibraltarians are doing and that's what this treaty enables. So it doesn't touch on the question of sovereignty. It sets up operational arrangements which involve choices by the Government of Gibraltar that allow both on customs and the movement of people for fluidity to continue.

37:04 - 37:24

The Lord Moynihan

I'm confused as to whether you're saying no, Gibraltar is not removed from Britain's sovereign trade policy, or whether you're saying being removed from Britain's trade policy does not impinge on sovereignty. And I've still got the question about CPTPP.

37:24 - 37:29

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Yes, well I'm going to ask Paul to do the CPTPP question and I'll come back to you.

37:29 - 38:00

Paul Hughes

Yes, well so I mean in terms of general trade policy, this agreement is only about goods.

So it's only about goods trade. So Gibraltar has established a customs union with the EU with regard to trade in goods. Gibraltar's interest in international trade, as I'm sure the Chief Minister will tell you, is in trade in services. And the answer to your question is that yes, Gibraltar could accede to CPTPP to the trade in services chapter that were relevant to it.

38:00 - 38:02

Speaker 16

But not to goods.

38:03 - 38:08

Paul Hughes

Not goods, because they're in a customs union with the EU, but that's a decision that they've made.

38:08 - 38:32

The Lord Moynihan

Well, this is my case, Chairman. We have a policy in this country of not joining the EU customs union, which is, by the way, only in goods, you know, services isn't affected anyway. And we have said now we are, for Gibraltar, going to join Gibraltar into that customs union, which is an impingement on our trade policy.

38:32 - 38:46

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Lord Bonnar, I don't think that's true. Gibraltar is not joining the EU customs union. Gibraltar is, has a bespoke customs union for goods with the EU. That is not joining the EU customs union. That's a misrepresentation, if you don't mind.

38:46 - 38:51

The Lord Moynihan

Well, a customs union with the EU. Banana, banana, tomato, tomato.

38:51 - 38:54

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Bespoke customs union that they have chosen to go into, yes.

38:54 - 39:38

Tim Timothy Barrow

Could I ask a slightly different question on the sovereignty point, which I think might be of interest to some people? Sovereignty has not been ceded in this.

But there are certain arrangements that have been made under the treaty, for example, you know, the involvement of Spanish customs, police, etc., etc. And some people might say, well, okay, that sounds fine, there are strict limits to that. But is there scope for a sort of a creeping expansion of Spain's role within Gibraltar? And if there is, how is that to be controlled under the arrangements that you described earlier for monitoring the ongoing process of the agreement?

39:38 - 41:04

The Lord Wood of Anfield

I don't think so. I mean, I think creeping cooperation is what the Gibraltarians want. So setting up stronger forms, I saw myself when I saw the Commander British Forces, Tim Davey, in Gibraltar, and his excellent work that he and his team do. And he was talking very positively about the early stages of cooperation with military liaison officers in Spain, very positively.

I talked to the Gibraltar head of the Royal Gibraltar Police, Owain Richards, who's been there a few months, similarly. There are issues that need to be discussed with Spanish police, with the Guardia Civil and others, but he has good relations there. So first thing to say is that scope for more and more cooperation at this stage is what's going to make the implementation of the treaty work. My understanding, and Paul may want to jump in if this is a misrepresentation, my understanding is that in each area there is clearly and carefully delineated scope for the relevant Spanish authority. So for example, in military, we're going to maybe talk about military issues in a minute.

Spanish military officers are only involved in issues to do with assuring the application of derogation for military personnel and some very limited information sharing.

Apart from that, they have no scope in the treaty for more jurisdictional roles. And so I think in each area that principle seems to have been well applied to prevent the kind of concerns that you're worried about.

41:04 - 41:06

Speaker 17

Thank you very much, Lord Tugendhat.

41:06 - 41:14

Christopher Tugendhat

Mine is a rather different question. I'm very intrigued by the disputes arbitration procedure.

41:14 - 41:15

What, sorry?

41:15 - 42:19

Christopher Tugendhat

The disputes arbitration procedure. And I was also struck in your answer to Lord Moynihan by your distinction between joining the customs union and having a bespoke customs union, and I think that's a very important distinction.

Now, the British government is engaged in negotiations with the EU, as we all know, over a variety of things: the electricity and the carbon emissions and the phytosanitary and so forth. And in a sense, if these agreements, if these negotiations are successful, they will be bespoke agreements rather than joining the customs union. And I wondered, therefore, to what extent you consider that the arbitration procedure, which is a rather interesting one that applies in the case of Gibraltar, might provide a precedent in the case of the British government's negotiations.

42:21 - 42:56

The Lord Wood of Anfield

I can't pretend I'm an expert on the details of the arbitration procedure. You are right though to point to parallels in the, for example, in the choice to align on regulations between the Gibraltar approach on the customs union and some aspects of Schengen and the approach the UK government is currently engaged in with the EU. Of course that calculation is a relevant comparison. I may have to ask Paul to comment on specifically on the dispute mechanism. I'm sorry that the thing you're most passionate about is something I know perhaps little about, but Paul maybe can illustrate some of the themes you're talking about.

42:56 - 43:43

Paul Hughes

Yes, I mean, I think because the arbitration procedure in the agreement is largely quite standard apart from how it deals with matters of EU law, which is this referral potential to the ECJ to decide on interpretations of EU law.

That mechanism was actually taken from the withdrawal agreement, Lord Barrow will be familiar with, which in turn was taken from previous EU agreements. So I mean, you would, I think you'd have to ask Cabinet Office colleagues on the specifics of the current negotiations, but but yes, it makes sense that if that's how the EU has managed this in the Gibraltar deal and in the past, that it may it may serve as the basis for what we're doing with the EU at the moment, yes.

43:43 - 43:51

The Lord Wood of Anfield

And the ECJ role, let's be clear, is is clarifying aspects of EU law as and when necessary for those parts that Gibraltar has taken on board.

43:53 - 44:08

Christopher Tugendhat

I mean, one of the interesting features is the extent to which the European Court of Justice is in the background rather than the foreground, and I I thought that was very interesting. Lord Gadhia.

44:07 - 44:41

The Lord Gadhia

Thank you, Lord Chairman. I should declare my historic interests in Spain as detailed in the register. My question is about the military base, the naval base, naval and military base, and whether in any way this treaty will have an impact on military personnel coming and going and general access to and from the military base.

44:41 - 44:47

Tim Timothy Barrow

And sorry, could you also address operations as well, the conduct of operations?

44:47 - 47:05

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Sure. Sure. Well, thank you for that question. And it was made clear throughout the negotiations that safeguarding the operational autonomy of the UK's military facilities in Gibraltar was a total red line throughout the discussions.

And the treaty protects that autonomy, allows our facilities to continue their crucial contribution there to regional security and to prosperity. There is no Spanish role in approving, authorizing, or controlling UK military operations, UK personnel deployments, or military movements. And that's absolutely clear. There are specific arrangements the treaty provides for for military personnel and military goods to ensure the base can continue operating effectively following the removal of routine checks at the Gibraltar-Spain border. And military personnel, civilians traveling on defense business, and their immediate family members and close defense partners are not subject to routine Schengen entry and exit checks.

And likewise the treaty contains dedicated arrangements for military and dual-use goods which preserve our ability to supply and operate our military facilities. So these arrangements largely preserve the practical position that was that was in place. They were supported widely by Ministry of Defence and the Defence Secretary. And however on top of that, of course, we do have cooperation with the Spanish who are a NATO ally and it's important that that continues and deepens.

They're a trusted ally. And in light of the removal of the land border checks, we've agreed to limited information sharing, as I said earlier, with the Spanish military through the military liaison officers' nexus. The role of that relationship is to facilitate the operation of military derogations, as I said earlier on, and the smooth running of the treaty. So that's the structure of both protection of the autonomy of our military activities and the base, but also the limited cooperation which is essential for smooth functioning of the treaty.

47:05 - 47:18

The Lord Gadhia

And I assume that therefore the local commanders in the different branches of the military are entirely content, indeed may even think of this as an improvement on their current situation. Is that right?

47:18 - 47:39

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Absolutely right. And I was very struck talking to the commander of British forces there about his positivity about the early weeks of these arrangements and the relationships he's building. So yes, it's been two months since the treaty came into provisional force, but the relationship building is going well as far as I can tell.

47:39 - 47:40

Thank you.

47:39 - 47:40

Baroness Smith wanted to come in.

47:40 - 48:24

Julie Smith

Thank you. I don't quite have a declaration of interest, but I did visit Gibraltar last year at the invitation of the Gibraltar government. So it falls slightly outside the declaration period, but I thought I would mention it. Just wanted to ask quite a specific question about Schengen and in answer to your or follow up to your response, Minister, you said that service personnel and their families wouldn't be subject to routine Schengen checks. Right.

Will they have some sort of document that means that if they then visit other Schengen countries, they're not going to get caught up in the 90 days out of 180?

48:23 - 49:23

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Yes, so the UK retains complete control of who serves in Gibraltar and who travels there on defense business. And beneficiaries of these derogations are not subject to the Schengen entry and exit requirements, as I say. So personnel will are required to demonstrate eligibility for the derogations through having a standard document, like a valid identity document or movement order. And that's the way in which that that operates.

In terms of the Schengen the the Schengen 90 days rule, there is an arrangement now in place which enables the military personnel to clock in, clock out, so that the Schengen clock stops and starts in the right ways. That's that's a that's a good example of a an implementation improvement that's happened in the last couple of months in order to respond to your challenge. I hope I hope that makes sense.

49:23 - 49:25

Speaker 21

Thank you. Lord Brann.

49:25 - 50:02

The Lord Brennan

Thank you, Lord Chair, and welcome, Minister, and congratulations on your appointment. I know Lord Jackson and Baroness Ashton referred to your support of Liverpool Football Club, which you advertise in your title, but they may not be aware that you're also an avid musician, a very talented one as well. So we're hoping maybe you might be able to help us on that down the line in terms of cultural touring. But that's another another subject. How will the agreement's provisions dealing with the refusal of individual entry into Gibraltar, how will that work?

And who will take the final decision to exclude somebody and at what point in the process?

50:02 - 51:52

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Thanks, thanks for that, Lord Brand. I mean, the Government of Gibraltar has been in charge of these decisions for decades and it is in charge of entry into Gibraltar still under the under the treaty. Gibraltar residents, let's start with them. They cannot be refused entry to Gibraltar. The treaty's been the treaty's been designed so that all residents have the right to return to return home.

More generally, none of the parties wanted individuals who pose a genuine threat to security or safety to be able to enter Gibraltar or the wider Schengen area.

And so there was a strong, there is a strong shared interest in cooperation between Gibraltar, Spain, and the relevant law enforcement authorities. And so to unlock the benefits of a fluid border, the arrangement now is that everyone arriving into the airport will undergo, as I found out myself, Gibraltar immigration controls carried out by Gibraltar officers, followed by Schengen entry checks carried out by Spanish officials. And on completion of these checks, individuals are able to enter both Gibraltar and the Schengen area. So when an individual is the subject of an alert on the Schengen Information System, which of course we don't get access to elsewhere, and or they don't meet the requirements for entry into the Schengen area, then Spain may refuse them entry into Schengen.

In those circumstances, excuse the complexity of this, in those circumstances the Government of Gibraltar has taken a decision, their own decision, to mutually recognize decisions taken by Spain to refuse entry to the Schengen area where they're based on security or public safety concerns.

51:52 - 51:59

The Lord Brennan

So in effect the answer is that the Spanish authorities could refuse entry into Gibraltar.

51:59 - 52:12

The Lord Wood of Anfield

No, Spanish the Spanish authorities make a decision about entry into Schengen. The Government of Gibraltar uses that information to make to make has chosen to use that information to make decisions about entry into Gibraltar, of which they are still in complete control.

52:12 - 52:21

The Lord Brennan

They've chosen that they will under all circumstances they will they will respect and adhere to the decisions taken by the Spanish.

52:21 - 52:23

Speaker 23

They've chosen to mutually recognize.

52:23 - 52:26

Speaker 25

And they've done that obviously not voluntarily, but the fact is that that is what will happen in practice.

52:26 - 52:28

The Lord Wood of Anfield

They've chosen mutual recognition as the principle of it, yes.

52:28 - 52:31

Speaker 24

Okay. Sorry, and what happens the other way around?

52:31 - 52:36

Tim Timothy Barrow

What happens the other way around if Spain wants to allow them in but Gibraltar doesn't?

52:31 - 52:32

I'm sorry?

52:36 - 52:42

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Well, Gibraltar has the right to exclude anyone from Gibraltar, including UK nationals who are not Gibraltar residents.

52:42 - 52:54

Tim Timothy Barrow

If Gibraltar, if they go to Gibraltar first, the Gibraltar authorities first, if the Gibraltar authorities refuse them, do they still go on to the Spanish authorities or is that the end of it?

52:54 - 52:58

Speaker 26

Everybody apart from everyone goes through both.

52:58 - 53:13

The Lord Brennan

Under those circumstances, sorry, I've got the chairs again, under the circumstances that the Gibraltar authorities have decided they don't want to admit somebody, they then go on and talk to the Spanish border guards who say, oh, we think you're okay to admit, what happens to that person in those circumstances?

53:13 - 53:22

Speaker 27

The Gibraltar authorities are in charge of the decision to admit to Gibraltar, so they wouldn't be allowed into Spain via that route.

53:23 - 53:50

The Lord Brennan

We can't stop them going home. So the Spanish could admit them into Schengen, but Gibraltar could say, you're not coming into Gibraltar. And if they were not, does that apply to every EU citizen or citizens of other jurisdictions? How would it work? You're giving the particular example of Spain, but what if it was a citizen of another European Union country or indeed a non-EU country?

What would happen?

53:50 - 54:00

Paul Hughes

I would have to check that and come back to you. I think the same principle applies that they should be allowed to transit home, but I would have to check that.

54:00 - 54:04

The Lord Brennan

I think it would be useful if we could clarify that if we are going to have a debate in the House prior to...

54:04 - 54:47

Tim Timothy Barrow

We'll definitely clarify that.

No, I agree entirely because I have to admit this is one area, one of suppose many areas, when I plowed through all those hundreds of pages that I got a bit baffled by. I clearly understand the point about Gibraltar accepting the Spanish decision and accepting to abide by that, but I don't quite understand how it works the other way around. Because you say that Gibraltar can exclude who it likes, but has it agreed that it will never exclude a Spanish citizen? Has it agreed that it will never exclude an EU citizen? And you've said they go to both, so clearly the situation could arise where Gibraltar says you can't come into Gibraltar and Spain says you can come into Spain and the EU.

What happens?

54:47 - 54:56

The Lord Wood of Anfield

That may be possible. I mean, we will definitely get back to you on this, but also you have the Chief Minister coming up and I think he may be your shortcut way to getting a practical answer to the question.

54:56 - 55:10

The Lord Brennan

Before I finish, Minister, while while we've got you here, to the best of your knowledge, has anyone asked President Trump his opinion on Gibraltar, given how freely he's opined on other controversial jurisdictions like the Falkland Islands and Northern Ireland?

55:10 - 55:17

The Lord Wood of Anfield

I haven't done a trawl recently of President Trump's social media, but I don't I don't know the answer to that. I don't believe he has, but I don't know for sure.

55:17 - 55:18

Thank you.

55:18 - 55:19

Lord Jackson.

55:19 - 56:53

James Stewart Jackson

Thank you, Lord Chairman. Notwithstanding what you're saying, Minister, about the agreement of Gibraltar government, the agreement nevertheless contains 43 annexes of EU legal acquis that will apply on a dynamic basis to Gibraltar. You know, why is this necessary is the first question. You will know that in 2024, the Commons EU Committee argued that the UK concessions on the border alignment and the Schengen acquis and the airport represent a serious diminution of UK sovereignty.

And when one looks at the list of powers that this treaty conveys, Spain gets primacy in arrest, detention, search and seizure powers, coercive action. It can block new residency permits. It can force withdrawal of existing residence permits. It can retrospectively review pre-treaty permits. It can ban individual Gibraltar residents from leaving Gibraltar.

Gibraltar must provide quarterly risk assessments to Spain. Spain issues short-term visas for Gibraltar visitors. It can block emergency border visas.

I mean, the list of powers that have been vested in Spain and the EU is very, very significant. So, coming back to sovereignty, are you convinced that Article 2 does not diminish, is enough rather to address the argument that sovereignty has been seriously diminished by this treaty?

56:53 - 57:19

The Lord Wood of Anfield

The sovereignty has not been diminished by this treaty. That's just, that's just not true. Article 2 is reassurance. It's not, the rest of the treaty, as I said, is a technical treaty about the relationship between Gibraltar and the EU. It's just not true, it's out of the question that these agreements undermine sovereignty because this is areas where Gibraltar is choosing to align its rules with those of the EU in order to unlock benefits.

It's a choice that Gibraltar has made.

57:19 - 57:36

James Stewart Jackson

With respect, Minister, that's a separate issue where whether Gibraltar agrees with it or not.

We're talking about the sovereignty of a British sovereign territory, which is a separate issue as to the sanction or otherwise of the Gibraltar government.

57:36 - 59:04

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Sovereignty of British territory, yes, but we have a constant, consistent key principle that nothing about Gibraltar without Gibraltar. The Gibraltarian people have made decisions which we respect about the customs arrangements. Now, just to go back, it's not true also that there are 43 annexes about EU law. In fact, the majority of them don't have EU law. Many of them are about provisions in the main text to do with rules of procedure or simple lists of things such as relevant criminal offences.

We think roughly there are about eight of those annexes that contain references to EU law. And they are all measures where Gibraltar has committed to remain aligned with those in order to unlock the benefits of an open border. And this is a good thing for Gibraltar. It had to be a bespoke, as people in this room know who worked on this, it had to be a bespoke deal.

It had to be a deal involving the consent of the Gibraltarian people, of course. And this is a model that's proportionate to Gibraltar's circumstances. It avoids them having to incorporate extensive, lengthy, and frankly irrelevant EU law into their own domestic legislation. And it's something crucially they've decided to do. So that's why it's not 43 annexes of EU law, but it is Gibraltar opting in to certain limited provisions in the name of having a fluid land border and supporting the economy and the welfare of Gibraltar.

59:03 - 59:52

James Stewart Jackson

Okay, that's a helpful and comprehensive reply. My final question, if I may, Chairman, is would you concede that there has been some concern and disquiet in the employment market in that this treaty gives the power of the EU and Spain to de facto block the entrance of British nationals who hitherto would have worked in Spain, and that that's the power, not that they will necessarily exercise that power, but that there may therefore be a displacement of employment opportunities as between British nationals and local Spanish? And that that is something that has caused some concern. That is the power that the treaty gives to the Spanish and to the EU.

59:52 - 01:00:29

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Not quite sure I recognize that description of it, if I'm honest. I mean, yes, there is a thriving Gibraltar economy which relies on many Spanish workers.

That's why preserving the openness of the land border was so crucial. Gibraltar remains in charge of deciding whether nationals can come in. So I'm sure there are concerns as economic change happens, which happen in every part of the world. But nothing in the treaty has established a fundamentally new dynamic in those two respects. In fact, it's provided legal certainty for both of those features, which has been welcomed by Gibraltarians.

01:00:29 - 01:00:32

Speaker 28

Thank you. Thank you. Lord Ledden.

01:00:32 - 01:01:01

The Lord Lennie

Thank you, Lord Chairman, and welcome to the committee, Lord Wood. As you know, the public often analyze new treaties and agreements using cost and spending as a sort of measure and a metric, a shortcut if you like, for that. I'd like to explore that a bit. The agreement says that the Cooperation Council will establish a financial mechanism aimed at promoting cohesion in the region.

How much will Gibraltar pay for these arrangements, and will the UK be required to make a contribution?

01:01:01 - 01:02:14

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Well, thank you for the question. I know there's been some interest in this. I mean, the treaty's designed to obviously fundamentally create the conditions for prosperity in the region. That's a fundamental purpose of it, and the surrounding region, by removing barriers to the movement of goods and people. And under the financial mechanism you refer to, both parties will establish independent funds to benefit Gibraltar and the region around Gibraltar.

So the Government of Gibraltar will set up a fund which could, for example, provide employee training and employee development in Gibraltar for frontier workers.

But you have the Chief Minister coming, you can ask the Chief Minister about that proposal. There's no specific timelines for establishing this yet, but we expect it to be set up soon and we'll have more details, more details will be available in due course since the specifics have been agreed within the Cooperation Council. As agreed under the Concordat between Gibraltar and the UK, the political agreement, the UK contribution to the mechanism will come from Gibraltar and will not be met from UK taxpayer funding.

01:02:14 - 01:02:19

Speaker 30

That's very clear. Thank you. Lord Berry.

01:02:19 - 01:03:02

George Leonard Carey

Thank you very much, and I should recall my interests, not least having been alluded to, having worked on negotiations of related agreements and indeed in the early and unsuccessful years of this negotiation.

And welcome, Minister, and congratulations on your appointment. And I join others also in congratulating Paul, Lindsay Appleby, and others who did so much to get this agreement over the line. Minister, you've just referred to the Concordat, and I just wanted to ask you about that because the Gibraltar parliamentarians unanimously agreed to the agreement in March 2024 subject to that Concordat. And I wonder if you could tell us a bit about why the Concordat was necessary and what its impact is.

01:03:02 - 01:04:44

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Thank you. Just before I say that, to add to your list of thanks, my predecessor Stephen Doughty, who was the Minister for Europe, he did a lot of work to make sure that this got over the line. On the Concordat, the Concordat is a political agreement between the UK and Gibraltar.

Why is it needed? Because we wanted to provide clarity on how Gibraltar and the UK can work together to ensure the treaty is smooth and implementation happens. And that's the fundamental purpose of the Concordat. It sets out respective responsibilities for implementing the treaty, and it's an essential accompaniment. The Gibraltarians wanted it.

It provides clarity, which is helpful from a UK government point of view, while respecting our respective constitutional arrangements and the UK's international obligations.

As far as I understand, it was always the intention to have such a document alongside the treaty, a document with the Government of Gibraltar. A similar one was agreed as part of the Withdrawal Agreement, I'm sure you know about that. And we want this treaty and the arrangements it sets up to last in perpetuity, for a very, very, very long time. And the impact of the Concordat is to clarify how we envisage the treaty being implemented between us as a party to the treaty and Gibraltar, who, as I keep saying, are in charge of their own affairs. So that's the purpose of the Concordat.

01:04:44 - 01:04:58

Tim Timothy Barrow

Thank you. Could you just, I'm afraid I'm not quite clear on this, what is the legal status of the Concordat versus the treaty itself?

01:04:58 - 01:05:04

The Lord Wood of Anfield

It's an accompanying document. It doesn't have any, as I understand it, Paul, any legal standing?

01:05:03 - 01:05:11

Paul Hughes

It's a political instrument between us and the Government of Gibraltar.

01:05:11 - 01:05:31

Tim Timothy Barrow

Right, so it's a political agreement and so therefore it's open to amendment at any time by either side, you know, on, I was going to say political whim, that's probably not a very, but you know what I mean, driven by other political considerations.

01:05:31 - 01:05:49

The Lord Wood of Anfield

I think that whoever the UK government is, they will want, they have a vested interest in wanting a working, functioning cooperative relationship with the Government of Gibraltar. The Government of Gibraltar will always want clarity about the implementation of the treaty that they depend on.

So I'm very hopeful that it will continue to be in place.

01:05:49 - 01:06:13

Tim Timothy Barrow

Well, I'm not saying that the concordat's a bad thing, but I think we should be very clear about its status. And that, you know, a treaty is a treaty and has all sorts of enforcement mechanisms. The concordat as described by you is a political agreement which will require continued political work and engagement, if I can put it that way. Does that sound right? Tim's looking a bit puzzled.

01:06:13 - 01:06:21

George Leonard Carey

I'm not sure it requires continual political work, but there's a continuing conversation between us and the Gibraltarian authorities.

01:06:21 - 01:06:22

Way of working together.

01:06:22 - 01:06:28

Speaker 32

I would describe that as work. Good. Thank you very much. Right, Lord Moynihan.

01:06:28 - 01:08:09

The Lord Moynihan

Thank you, Chair. Thank you again. I'd like to turn to the topic of termination. Obviously something of considerably more interest to our side possibly than to the government.

It seems from a reading, and I could have got this wrong, it's quite complex, that there are three mutually inconsistent ways in which the treaty can be terminated. You've got Article 334 that says termination can take place on 12 months' notice plus Gibraltar's consent and a confirming referendum. So that's a nice solid, quite difficult to break or to happen process. But then you've got Article 19(5) that provides for termination within 90 days without further ado. And then you've got a provision, as I understand it, that Spain at will is allowed to unilaterally force the termination of the entire agreement.

Now, let's say Article 334 allows, you know, that's what we've got in mind, lock this thing in, very, very difficult to get out. Article 195, let's say that for some bizarre reason Gibraltar elects a Faragist government who wants to get out. Apparently, they can just give 90 days' notice and go. And then we were wanting to make Spain happy and produce something that wouldn't be changed. But apparently, Spain can continue to apply pressure, should they have some aggressive government, because they can say, "If you don't give us more concessions, we're going to terminate this whole thing at will."

Have I got this right?

01:08:09 - 01:09:28

The Lord Wood of Anfield

Well, let me answer the 195 point because I think the 334 point you've, that is the bone of contention that you're asking about, it's 195 and the third alleged exit option.

On 19.5, this is a provision that is precedented in the agreements the EU has with Norway, with Switzerland, with Iceland about Schengen arrangements with the EU. And the purpose of it is- is for a very specific scenario where if Gibraltar explicitly rejected or ignored an update to an EU act that they have committed to align to, it begins a 90-day period when there is- where an alternative to termination is examined by the parties, a sort of discussion period, in order to avoid it.

The purpose is to avoid that provision kicking in. And it's a pretty decent assumption, unlike your assumption that a Faragist government would take over in a country that had a 96% support for remain in the referendum, it is a reasonable assumption that the period of 90 days would be used pretty intensively by all parties to sort out an agreement. So that's on 19.5. I'm going to hand over to Paul on the Spain's unilateral mechanism allegation, which Paul knows more about than I do.

01:09:28 - 01:11:05

Paul Hughes

Yes, I think I know the article you're referring to, which is in the mobility of persons chapter, which comes after the review of the mobility of persons chapter at the end of four years. And I've not got it in front of me, but I think it says something along the lines of if Spain informs the EU that they are no longer content, then the EU will set in process the process of termination. So it's a Spanish request for the EU as the party to terminate the treaty.

I think you've identified that correctly. I mean, what I would say is it triggers the termination process, which is a 12-month, I think it might be nine months in that process, where alternatives can be found. But I would say that what that is is reflecting the reality that most of the treaty from the EU side is for Spain, affects Spain, and it's for Spain to implement.

And we've recognized that on our side through the Concordat and the very, very tight drafting of the termination provisions in the Concordat, setting out the process for how the UK would use the termination provisions of the treaty. So both those provisions are sort of acknowledgment of the reality that the treaty is fundamentally mainly about the relationship between Gibraltar and Spain.

01:11:05 - 01:11:48

The Lord Moynihan

Okay, I think you've confirmed that what I said was correct. And just in a friendly way, I would say we can't just say, "Oh well, Gibraltarians are 95% in agreement with this." Right now, we can't hardly say that in a month where Ceuta has been invaded by tens of thousands of Moroccans and we can immediately see that that whole situation is likely to collapse in a relatively short space of time. So we can't just say, "Oh, none of these will ever happen."

You're saying that in this treaty, this could happen, as I understand it. Spain or your far-rightist or the obvious first we all agree on.

01:11:48 - 01:12:31

Tim Timothy Barrow

Could I, because I'm just so clear in my own mind. What I understood, what I understand to be the case and what you've just said, is that the main withdrawal mechanism, the first one that Lord Myners set out, is the principal instrument. The second one would only kick in if Gibraltar refused to align with, in other words, to live up to its agreement, which is fine. But the third one is that Spain at any time can decide it doesn't like this arrangement and therefore can terminate it, or rather sort of insist that the EU terminate it because it's not a Spanish treaty. So have I got that right?

01:12:31 - 01:12:49

Paul Hughes

I think it's just important to be very clear, it's not at any time. It's in a specific process at the end of a review that happens at the end of four years in relation to the mobility provisions of the treaty. That's when the Spanish option is there. That's my understanding of it.

01:12:49 - 01:12:52

Speaker 33

So is that a one-off option at that moment in time?

01:12:52 - 01:12:57

Paul Hughes

I think I'm fairly certain that's correct, yes. The Chief Minister will definitely be able to give you more clarity.

01:12:57 - 01:13:00

Speaker 35

Because I think it's an important point. Thank you.

01:13:00 - 01:13:03

Speaker 34

Thank you. Lovely. Lord Tugendhat.

01:13:03 - 01:13:37

Christopher Tugendhat

I can't remember a time when there haven't been negotiations going on about Gibraltar, or envisaged, or broken down, or renewed, or whatever.

So let me just ask you, do we think that this agreement actually settles matters for Gibraltar for as far ahead as you can see, or do you think further agreements will be necessary? Of course Lord Moynihan's right that the unexpected can happen, but as of now, do you feel that this issue is now wrapped up?

01:13:37 - 01:14:51

The Lord Wood of Anfield

From a treaty point of view, yes. It's the last piece of the jigsaw after Brexit. And I think everyone involved in it, I can't claim any credit for myself, I've just arrived in my job, but everyone, all his colleagues, people of Gibraltar, the officials who worked in Spain as well, everyone should, I think, be applauded for arriving at a settlement that is now, the issue is now about implementation rather than about the fundamentals. And I think that's an extraordinary achievement. And one of the crystal clear things about the treaty is that sovereignty is protected.

So we've done all this, not we, but it has been achieved while sovereignty has been protected completely. Now, of course, we may agree in future that there are changes in arrangements that will be needed in the implementation and the operation of the different, different economic activities and different jurisdictional, different law enforcement operations. Of course there'll have to be adjustments to the way it's implemented. But as far as the treaty goes, this is a stable and lasting foundation for Gibraltar's relationship with the EU for many, many years to come.

01:14:51 - 01:15:00

Christopher Tugendhat

I think that's very encouraging and certainly speaking for myself, I would congratulate those who've been involved in negotiating this.

01:15:00 - 01:18:48

Tim Timothy Barrow

Exactly. Well, thank you very much indeed.

And we're just coming up to 12 o'clock, on time, which is good. So I'd like to thank our witnesses, Lord Wood of Anfield and Paul Hughes from the FCDO, very much indeed for giving evidence today. It's been a pleasure to see you in this role. And with that, I'll suspend the public session.

Well, good afternoon and welcome to this resumed session of the European Affairs Select Committee in the House of Lords, where we are conducting an evidence session on the UK-EU Gibraltar treaty. And I'm very grateful to our witness for the second session, the Honorable Fabian Picardo KC MP, who is the Chief Minister of Gibraltar. Thank you very much indeed for joining us. We look forward to your evidence, public evidence as I said earlier, and we hope to finish by 1:00. If you are content, we will get underway.

And I would like to start, if I may, just by asking a general question to enable you briefly to set the background before we get into more detail.

And I wonder if you could say from your perspective why you think the vote of the Gibraltarians was so overwhelmingly in favor of this treaty, 96%? How was the outcome of the 2016 referendum on the UK's membership of the EU greeted in Gibraltar, which I imagine has some sort of bearing on that? And why do you think that it's taken so long from the decision of the UK to leave the EU and the Trade and Cooperation Agreement to get to the position where we are now, where we have this treaty?

01:18:48 - 01:20:44

Fabian Picardo

So, my Lords, thank you for the opportunity to address you from Gibraltar. I'm sorry I cannot be in London with you.

2016 was a very difficult year for Gibraltar. The result of the UK referendum on membership of the European Union in effect upended our economy as it was, or had the prospect of upending our economy as it was. That was deeply understood by the people of Gibraltar, and it's for that reason that they voted overwhelmingly to remain in the European Union. Because of course it wasn't just our economy that would be upended. It would be the ability of many in Gibraltar to visit their closest family who might live in Spain, the ability to continue to live the lives that we live not just in the reduced geography of Gibraltar, but also with access to Southern Spain and Europe from Gibraltar.

All of that we could see would end in the way that it has ended for many of those who might have found it so easy to get from the United Kingdom to destinations in the European Union. And during the course of this summer, to name but one, have found that the application of new EU border rules, all of which were known about in 2016, have come home to roost. When you have 15,000 people who come into your territory every day, who would have to go through those new, more difficult border arrangements in and out of Gibraltar, you understood as a voter in Gibraltar without needing to have it explained to you that the result of the United Kingdom leaving the European Union would be a very, very bad thing for this very proud British territory.

01:20:44 - 01:20:48

Tim Timothy Barrow

Thank you very much indeed. That's helpfully sets the scene. Baroness Stroud.

01:20:48 - 01:21:07

Susy De Martini

Thank you, Lord Chair. Um, you've talked a little there about the, um, some of the practical problems that Brexit caused for Gibraltar, that this, um, agreement seeks to solve. Which of these were the most difficult and sensitive issues and do you believe that this agreement will help resolve them?

01:21:07 - 01:22:37

Fabian Picardo

Thank you, Baroness. Undoubtedly, the issue of fluidity at the frontier was the issue that we faced as the starkest and potentially the most dangerous.

I was indicating to you before that 15,000 cross-frontier workers come into Gibraltar every day. I mean, if you just imagine the volume of people that that represents when they need to come in between principally 7:00 a.m. and 10:00 a.m. And if you apply that entry checks or exit checks, if they went perfectly well, would take about, you know, 15 to 30 seconds per person, and that the ability of us to have a number of lanes would be restricted to perhaps two or three, you can see that fluidity of people was going to become a huge issue. And those people work in our public services, looking after our elderly, in our health service, looking after our ill and our children, and they work in the online gaming industry, they work in the insurance industry, they work in the public and private sector in equal measure.

And therefore the government's ability to offer the public services that we offer in Gibraltar, which are, if I may say so, at the highest European standard, and our ability to produce the public finances that fund them were at risk. And you can imagine that is not a risk that any Gibraltarian foot should be taking.

01:22:37 - 01:23:23

The Lord Gadhia

Thank you very much. My question, Chief Minister, and thank you so much for joining us this morning. My question is whether when there was a change of government in this country in 2024, whether that actually had any effect on the negotiations which I imagine had already begun before 2024, before the 2024 election.

Did that change of government affect the tone and the speed and the facility of those negotiations?

01:23:23 - 01:23:30

Speaker 37

I never expected to be facing the Duke of Wellington down the barrel of a camera. My Lord, I think the important thing to note is that throughout the negotiations, different political parties at Westminster have been equally supportive of the Government of Gibraltar in the negotiations that we have been involved in, both in the context of the Withdrawal Agreement, where I see my good friend Lord Barrow is among you and no doubt will have something to say about that, and then the negotiation of the New Year's Eve Framework Agreement, which was between the United Kingdom and Spain and Gibraltar, and then the commencement of the negotiation of this treaty, which started under a Conservative government.

01:24:11 - 01:25:29

Fabian Picardo

I was able to accompany Lord Cameron to Brussels on two occasions, and then David Lammy and Stephen Doughty on another occasion. So what I will say is that on the negotiation of these arrangements, both parties in the United Kingdom have been equally supportive. Of course, because there is a socialist government in Madrid, the election of a Labour government gave us a bit of an ideological frisson of excitement that we might be able to move more quickly.

But if I must be honest with you, as I always want to be in the evidence I give these committees, I think that the election of President Trump and the speech by Vice President Vance at the Munich Security Conference in February of that year, 2025, I think was what gave the biggest boost to the negotiations, as all of Europe and the United Kingdom realized that we needed to start working together and thinking together about geopolitical issues and geopolitical strategy, and that the United Kingdom and Spain and the United Kingdom and Europe couldn't be at loggerheads over two and a half square miles of geography on the southernmost flank of Europe. We need to be working together on those issues.

01:25:29 - 01:26:27

Julie Smith

Thank you.

I suspect President Trump and Vice President Vance would not be very enthusiastic to realize that they were helping the cause of European integration and cooperation. But in terms of the negotiations that we've seen across, as you say, two different governments of two different political persuasions in the UK, to what extent do you feel that the principles that you and the then Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab released in March 2021 have been adhered to? And in particular, the Foreign Secretary undertook not to agree arrangements that meant that the sovereignty over Gibraltar would pass to another state and with which you were not content. Do you feel these aims have been achieved or are there issues that remain on the table?

01:26:27 - 01:27:44

Fabian Picardo

Thank you, my lady. They were not his aims. They were my aims.

They were the aims of my negotiating team and the Government of Gibraltar to which the United Kingdom agreed. But what you've referred to um are not the terms of those negotiating guidelines for the United Kingdom. What you've referred to is what we call the double lock on the Gibraltar Constitution which dates from 2006. It's a sine qua non for any Government of Gibraltar that that should be the position and it has been the position of the United Kingdom since then. The key issue for us and the key issue for Mr. Raab and the key issue for all Foreign Secretaries that I've worked with of all political complexions has been that the sovereignty of Gibraltar, the exclusively British sovereignty of Gibraltar, should not be compromised by one iota in any arrangements that we entered into.

And they have not been. And I'm very happy to go through any outstanding threads that you may feel you might want to talk to me about after having taken the evidence of Lord Wood, given the questions I've heard from Lords Moynihan and others if you wish, because I can put my hand in the Gibraltarian political fire and tell you that not one iota of our sovereignty has been compromised at all.

01:27:44 - 01:27:57

Julie Smith

Thank you. I'm a Liberal Democrat who along with the two main parties has been very supportive of Gibraltar and I don't have any further questions. I suspect some other members of the committee might wish to come back though.

01:27:57 - 01:28:08

Fabian Picardo

I have the leader of the Gibraltar Liberals on my right, might be my left over there, who is the Deputy Chief Minister of Gibraltar, Joseph Garcia, who's been integral to our negotiating team.

01:28:08 - 01:28:10

Speaker 38

We have met him.

01:28:10 - 01:28:12

Speaker 39

Lord Jackson.

01:28:12 - 01:28:51

James Stewart Jackson

Liberals do tend to be on the left in this country. Chief Minister, can I ask you just picking up on what you say about sovereignty and we will come back to sovereignty in more substance a bit later, but something that the Minister you will have heard didn't really allude to that much but is important is the potential involvement of the European Court of Justice in interpretation of the legal acquis of the European Union. How do you see that in terms of dispute resolution being an issue that may infringe upon the sovereignty of Gibraltar in the future?

01:28:51 - 01:31:08

Fabian Picardo

Absolutely not. Let's be very clear. The people of Gibraltar voted 96% to remain in the European Union. That means with the full application of the European Court of Justice's jurisdiction as it was under the European Communities Act.

What Gibraltar is doing is akin to what the United Kingdom did in 1972. That is to say, it is agreeing to abide by rules of a club, and it is agreeing that the court, the dispute resolution mechanism of that club, which is the European Court of Justice, should be able to determine interpretations as to those rules as a price for membership. Membership which can be determined, and we'll go no doubt through the termination issues that you've touched upon already, which can be determined in a number of different ways should the people of Gibraltar in the exercise of their own sovereign will so determine should they wish to leave that club.

And therefore there's no question that the ECJ determining what the meaning of European provisions means, um, in any way impinges on sovereignty. Because that's all the ECJ can do. It can tell us what European text means. And there's a good reason for it too. Because that European text has a life in the European Union legal order and in our treaty.

And what you cannot have, and this makes a lot of jurisprudential sense, is different interpretation of exactly the same words in exactly the same circumstances.

So for example, a directive on matters of the environment which applies within the member states in the EU, which is interpreted in a particular way by the European Court of Justice if there's a dispute, cannot, because it might also be one of the instruments that we agree should apply under the treaty, be subject to a different interpretation as to its same words by the dispute resolution mechanism of the treaty without that dispute resolution mechanism under the treaty having regard to the interpretation of the European Court of Justice. This is not sovereignty. This is jurisprudential consistency.

01:31:08 - 01:31:10

Speaker 40

Thank you, Lord Brennan.

01:31:10 - 01:31:56

The Lord Brennan

Thank you very much, Lord Chair, and thank you for joining us, Chief Minister. Um, you may have heard, I think you did manage to hear some of the earlier exchanges with the Minister, Lord Wood, and the question I asked about how will the agreement's provisions deal with the refusal of individual entry into Gibraltar?

How would they work, and who takes the final decision to exclude somebody and when? And there was, in the answer from both the Minister and the official, I think some confusion over exactly how that would work, and they did agree to write with us to clarify that prior to any debate we might have in the House of Lords itself. Did you hear that exchange, and do you have any, can you shed any more light on that other than what the Minister and the official said?

01:31:56 - 01:34:26

Fabian Picardo

Yes, I did hear it. I heard what was said. I have to say that you are talking to one also of his footballing ideological complexion. When he left Gibraltar last week, we were very clear that neither of us would ever walk alone. Very good.

I don't think that there was confusion.

I think to be fair, these are extraordinarily complex arrangements. There is complexity. But I'm very happy to take you through the issue as we see it, because I think that might be more helpful. So the principle that we set out in the New Year's Eve framework agreement was a very simple one, which written down is actually very complex, which is namely that Gibraltar would continue to do the Gibraltar immigration check and would have the jurisdiction that it has today to accept or deny an individual having the right to come into Gibraltar. And Schengen would continue to do the same thing.

Of course, because we would do them as consequential checks, one after consecutive checks, one after the other, Gibraltar would make its decision. And if Gibraltar permits the individual to come in, then the individual goes to the Schengen check to be permitted also access to Schengen.

And that individual is permitted access to Schengen and has no problems. If we permit access to Gibraltar, but access to Schengen is not permitted, then the individual only has the right to visit Gibraltar, but not Schengen. And in those circumstances, there are circumstances where the individual can come only to Gibraltar and not to Schengen. If we say that the individual cannot have permission to enter Gibraltar, we nonetheless allow them to go to the Schengen check, and if they are permitted access to Schengen, they can then go into the Schengen space through a different exit at Gibraltar Airport, which will not allow them or not permit them access to Gibraltar.

But they can then have their run of Spain and the rest of the Schengen area, which of course logically makes sense because if they had landed in Jerez or Malaga, which are less than 100 kilometers away each of them, they would have been permitted access to Schengen without a problem. Now, of course, in those circumstances, the individual will be told that they are not permitted access to Gibraltar. We will put their faces on our facial recognition systems, which we have, and if they come into Gibraltar, they will be illegally in Gibraltar.

01:34:26 - 01:34:34

The Lord Brennan

Right, so it'll be sort of exit but not via the gift shop, as it were. You wouldn't be allowed that way through, essentially, in those circumstances.

01:34:34 - 01:34:38

Speaker 41

Spain no longer allows us the gift shop on the way in.

01:34:38 - 01:34:56

Tim Timothy Barrow

Could I just ask a point of clarification, Chief Minister? You said if you allow entry to Gibraltar but Spain does not allow entry to Schengen, they can then come into Gibraltar but not go into Schengen. How do you know if there's a fluid border?

01:34:55 - 01:35:47

Fabian Picardo

In certain circumstances they're permitted to come into Gibraltar. But of course if they then go into Spain, they would be illegally in Spain. So there are very restricted circumstances in which they would be able to come into Gibraltar. These are the circumstances which are very similar to the circumstances that apply, and I think I should have made this point earlier, thank you for taking me up on it. I should have said that these are very similar arrangements to the arrangements that apply when somebody arrives at any of the EU Schengen states and they have not been permitted a Schengen visa.

So there are circumstances, for example, where Germany would allow you into Germany but you would not have a Schengen visa and therefore you have no right to visit France or any of the other Schengen states.

And you would be illegally in France if you were to wander over the frontier there.

01:35:47 - 01:35:57

The Lord Brennan

Could I just ask, do you have any idea of how many people we might be talking about who are likely to fall under that sort of circumstance?

01:35:57 - 01:36:19

Fabian Picardo

So in the couple of months, literally two months to the day that we have been applying these arrangements, there have been no such instances. And what there have been are instances of people who are undocumented for the purposes of arrival in Gibraltar or Schengen, so double refusals, so to speak. No single refusals.

01:36:19 - 01:36:36

The Lord Brennan

Okay, I think that's very helpful.

And finally from me, I wasn't going to repeat this, but since you mentioned President Trump yourself, do you have any insight onto what his views are about Gibraltar's relationship with the UK?

01:36:36 - 01:37:01

Fabian Picardo

I don't have any insights on that. I mean, I think I don't want to make any comment on matters beyond my jurisdiction or competence, if you'll forgive me. I would only say that I was giving the view I was giving because it was a clear accelerant at the table, not because I'm making any comment on anybody else's leadership of their particular nations.

01:37:01 - 01:37:03

Speaker 43

Very deftly handled. Thank you.

01:37:03 - 01:37:48

The Lord Elliott

No, thank you. Good morning and welcome, Minister, to the committee. We come to the payment for services.

And while being of the same city as our UK Minister, nevertheless on our side of the park, we have the motto Nil Satis Nisi Optimum. So with that in mind, the parties have agreed to implement the principles of good governance in the area of taxation on the basis of transparency and exchange of information and fair tax competition under Article 211. How will this obligation actually work, and what are the implications for Gibraltar's tax policy?

01:37:48 - 01:39:11

Fabian Picardo

Well, Gibraltar's tax policy already completely aligns with the principles set out as best practice under the OECD. And when we were members of the European Union, we already fully complied with the European Union standards in respect of transparency, etc.

Let me give you a reason to be proud of this particular British Overseas Territory. We were the first jurisdiction in the European Union, that is to say ahead of the United Kingdom, ahead of Germany or France, to implement the fourth anti-money laundering directive's obligation to have an open register of beneficial ownership in respect of companies. We've maintained that. We have no difficulty abiding by the highest international standards in respect of transparency, good practice, and what a fair and objectively verifiable tax rate is. For those reasons, when the EU set that out as a requirement under the treaty, as it does in respect of all of the treaties that it enters into with third parties, we were very happy to sign up with absolutely no objection whatsoever.

It doesn't impede our ability to be a competitive, well-regulated, indeed very highly regulated financial services center for the world.

01:39:11 - 01:39:16

Speaker 44

Thank you. Okay. Good. Lord Jackson.

01:39:16 - 01:40:46

James Stewart Jackson

Thank you, Chairman. I'm going to ask a slightly different question than I'd originally intended because I think Mr. Picardo has adequately addressed the issue about the acquis and the treaty itself.

So can I ask you, given that the old UK visa route for travel to Gibraltar ended on the 8th of July and that exemptions based solely on UK residence or a UK visa no longer apply in terms of entry in respect of Schengen, is there any concern from local businesses in Gibraltar that it will be the default position to recruit young Spanish people in the service industry, hospitality and leisure, rather than the traditional route where you did have a not insignificant number of young British people coming to Gibraltar to train and take part in the employment market in leisure, tourism and those areas? Is that something that concerns you?

Um, and those areas, is that something that concerns you because the corollary of that is that there will over time be a displacement that practically everyone will be Spanish citizens and that young British people will not really any longer travel to Gibraltar to to take part in that in those employment opportunities?

01:40:46 - 01:40:54

Fabian Picardo

I'm sorry to say with the very greatest of respect, I can't imagine a more misconceived approach.

01:40:54 - 01:40:59

James Stewart Jackson

No, it's a question, it's not an approach, it's a question, so will you answer it directly, thank you.

01:40:59 - 01:41:48

Fabian Picardo

Of course I will, and I will preface my answer by saying that the position from which it comes is entirely misconceived for a simple reason. There are almost none of the people that you describe in the Gibraltar job market, young Brits who might wander down to Gibraltar who might form part of the Gibraltar employment market. The reality is that we have a resident population that is in the employment market and there are, last time I checked, seven people unemployed who are residents of Gibraltar.

Let's be very clear, I don't know whether the microphone might create some distortion. I didn't say 7%. I said seven people. Michael, Richard, Timothy, Dorothy, you know, people with seven names, right?

01:41:48 - 01:41:51

Speaker 45

I didn't ask you about the unemployment rate.

01:41:51 - 01:44:12

Fabian Picardo

If you don't let me answer, I can't give you the answer. 15,500 people who come through the frontier every day to work in Gibraltar. Half of them are Spanish. Half of the balance are British. And they will continue to be able to come to Gibraltar to work without impairment, in the same way as they've become residents of Spain before and come to Gibraltar to work.

They will be able to become residents of Spain before and come to Gibraltar to work.

There's absolutely no question of a British person who wants to work in Gibraltar, who has a job in Gibraltar, being able to come into Gibraltar as a result of this treaty. It's just not related to anything set out in the treaty. I think what you're trying to get at is that the government of Gibraltar of its own motion has set out new residence requirements for those who will be able to become resident in Gibraltar and to take employment in Gibraltar. The reason for that is because the treaty makes Gibraltar such an attractive jurisdiction to become resident in that we have to be more discerning than we may have been before about who becomes resident in Gibraltar.

We've set out a minimum wage that you need to be able to demonstrate your earning to maintain yourself in Gibraltar, which I think is in the region of £37,000, which is just shy of the average earnings in Gibraltar. And that might not be the sort of salary that a young British person of the sort that you described might be able to earn when they first take a job. But despite that, we want to be able to see people come to Gibraltar who are young, of any nationality, whether they are British or not British, who might be able to bring something to the emerging digital industries that we have. And we have exemptions for people who are particularly young. So I think that's what your question is getting at.

We've resolved the issue that some of our businesses identified with those new residence requirements, but those new residence requirements are not required by the treaty. They're our own sovereign in Gibraltar constitutional obligation of the and right of the Government of Gibraltar to fix for the reasons I've set out.

01:44:12 - 01:44:34

Speaker 46

Thank you for your comprehensive reply. I mean, that's... Sorry if that sounded a bit aggressive in the beginning, but I really didn't think that it was coming from a treaty source and therefore I wanted to scotch it dead. Yes, well, that was an interesting statistic that I was personally not aware of, that half of the people coming across the border every day to work in Gibraltar are British citizens resident in Spain.

01:44:34 - 01:44:53

Tim Timothy Barrow

No, half of the half was it? So what did I say? You said half. It's half of the half. Half of the remainder.

Yeah, a quarter. Half Spanish, half are British residents. The other half. So a quarter. Yes.

Excellent. Good. I'm glad I managed to clarify that. Thank you. Good.

Right, Lord Elliott.

01:44:52 - 01:44:59

The Lord Lennie

I'd like to explore the, one of the cost elements of the agreement. The agreement says that the Cooperation Council will establish a financial mechanism aimed at promoting cohesion in the region. How much will Gibraltar pay for these arrangements, and will the UK make a contribution as well?

Thanks for joining us, Chief Minister.

01:45:12 - 01:46:39

Fabian Picardo

Thanks, Lord, the, the Government of Gibraltar will be making the contribution respect of the, the financial mechanism. It won't be the UK taxpayer that is contributing to that.

The taxpayer that is contributing to that, the Government of Gibraltar will be raising the money for that financial mechanism through its own taxpayer resources and through contributions from some of the companies in the leading industries in Gibraltar who've indicated that they want to help us to populate the, what I might call the Gibraltar-UK side of the fund, which will be used exclusively for the purposes of training people in the Gibraltar job market or for the Gibraltar job market in Gibraltar or around Gibraltar. We think this is a good way of ensuring that we continue to have the, the people necessary for our job market to continue to flourish and grow. To give you another statistic, when I was first elected as Chief Minister, the number of cross-frontier workers was in the region of six or seven thousand, and the job market in Gibraltar has grown exponentially in the last 15 years. The more industries we have, the more people we need, the more public finance we receive as a result of that, not just in PAYE, social insurance contributions and corporate, corporate contributions.

Initially, the fund will be in the low millions of pounds and potentially that will grow in coming years.

01:46:39 - 01:46:43

Speaker 47

Thank you. Lord Barrow.

01:46:43 - 01:47:22

George Leonard Carey

Thank you very much, and it's a pleasure to see you, Chief Minister, and other colleagues. If I could just turn to the debate within Gibraltar, if I can call it that. So the agreement was unanimously endorsed in March this year by parliamentarians in Gibraltar. I wonder if you could tell us a little bit about what in particular was welcomed and if there were any concerns hidden within that vote, if I can call it that way.

And secondly, there was a concordat agreed with the UK government, and I'd be interested to know how you see that and whether you feel comfortable that it protects Gibraltar's position.

01:47:22 - 01:51:10

Fabian Picardo

Lord Barrow, it's a pleasure to see you, a veteran of the Gibraltar trenches in Brussels from 2018. Thank you for all your help in getting us here. If we hadn't had a withdrawal agreement clause on Gibraltar, we probably wouldn't have got on to a New Year's Eve agreement and this treaty. So, I think it would be unfair for me to set out the concerns of my fellow parliamentarians on the opposition benches in the Gibraltar Parliament, but the Hansard of the Gibraltar Parliament is published in respect of that debate, which set out both the concerns of parliamentary colleagues in the opposition and my response to those concerns. This is an international arrangement between the United Kingdom and the European Union where Gibraltar and Spain have been key to the negotiation.

You can imagine that it is the fruit of compromise. I mean, as I've said on a number of occasions in Gibraltar, I didn't turn up, I didn't pitch up in Brussels to negotiate the European Union's surrender to the people of Gibraltar. And so there are issues here which require compromise from the point of view of the key areas that the Commission is the guardian of the treaties of. There are key areas here which of course were Spanish concerns not related to sovereignty. There are key concerns of the United Kingdom and key concerns of Gibraltar, which have become this treaty.

So I've described the treaty as imperfect but exactly what we need to keep going forward as a community and with our sovereignty intact. I was very heartened to hear the leader of the opposition use the same description in the last week as he reflected during our Gibraltar Day events on our treaty. So I think there is wide agreement and wide consensus in Gibraltar on that. Of course there are some dissenting voices. Perish the thought that there were not, otherwise we wouldn't be the vibrant democracy that we are.

But to see a parliament united in Gibraltar, we don't often unite on issues other than in defense of British sovereignty, united around this treaty I think says a lot. Now the concordat, as you rightly say, was the condition that the motion put by the government and the opposition together made in order to ask the United Kingdom to start the process of ratification of the treaty.

Why was that relevant? Well, because as you'll know, you were involved in it, we had a concordat for the withdrawal agreement where there was a chapter on Gibraltar and the United Kingdom and Gibraltar needed to know in respect of that chapter, who does what, who's responsible for what, who's going to put their hand in their pocket for what. So, of course, there had to be in relation to a free-standing treaty just in relation to Gibraltar, of course, a concordat that also set out, you know, what was going to be the responsibility of each of the parties.

Because it's a treaty, these are UK international legal obligations, even though Gibraltar is going to discharge the lion's share of them at the coalface, at Gibraltar frontier and in the jurisdiction of Gibraltar, where constitutionally we are the only entity empowered to discharge those functions. And so the concordat was always going to be important. The terms of the concordat, there's also a letter which accompanies the final version of the concordat from Stephen Doughty, have been scrutinized in Gibraltar. They've been found to be satisfactory, if not perfect, back to the imperfect analogy in respect of the treaty. And that in politics, I think, is what we call success.

01:51:10 - 01:51:17

Tim Timothy Barrow

Okay. Pleasure. That's a very helpful clarification on the concordat, actually. Thank you very much indeed for that, Baroness Ashton.

01:51:17 - 01:52:04

Catherine Margaret Ashton

Chief Minister, it's great to see you, and I just want to just get a couple more clarifications, if I might, for the purposes of the committee reporting to the House.

And that's we note that obviously it's been provisionally applied from July the 15th. Can you just explain why you have to provisionally apply rather than fully apply? And you've said that this is satisfactory in terms of how it's working out and I agree with you in politics that's a very good result. But has anything emerged during this period of the provisional application that you'd like us to be aware of, any issues or problems that perhaps we just need to take note of?

01:52:04 - 01:57:31

Fabian Picardo

Thank you, Baroness Ashton, for your continued interest in Gibraltar. We had an opportunity to meet and discuss all things Gibraltar in Cordoba, I seem to recall, in the era before COVID and around Brexit. So thank you for your continued interest.

I really do appreciate it on behalf of those I represent. As you know, we've had a number of different deadlines for the application of the new European entry and exit rules, the EES, the now infamous EES. During the course of the negotiation, these were cliff edges that were constantly coming towards us because we had an entente cordiale between Spain and the United Kingdom and Gibraltar on how the frontier would continue to operate without the full application of the Schengen Border Code whilst we were negotiating, as perhaps should have been the case from our departure in 2020. But of course, once EES arrived, that was going to require people to give biometric data in order to enter the European space.

And the deadline for that was July this year, the most recent deadline. And 90 days on, even the discretion was to end, although we understand solely from journalistic reporting that that discretion of easing up on EES may have been extended in the past 24 hours by the Commission. So for Spain and for Gibraltar and for the United Kingdom and the European Union, what we all wanted to do was to avoid people having to cross the land frontier Gibraltar to have to go through the EES checks when those came in.

Because if you think of Dover, where you're going in a car onto a boat, here you have literally thousands of vehicles crossing every day, so you'd have to have iPad EES for many of them, which would cause a huge tailback, however efficiently and with goodwill you might be trying to do so. We would have had reciprocal checks. We would really have snarled the whole thing up. And our job as politicians is to make life easier for people, not harder. So we all were wanting to hit the date of before the application of EES.

We couldn't hit that date for ratification, so we included, I think at the suggestion of the Commission at the time in the negotiation, a provisional application clause in the arrangements. That is what has enabled us to see the treaty work its magic, if I may say so, on fluidity of people at the frontier from the 15th of July, with ratification due, I think, at the Strasbourg session of the Parliament on the 14th, 15th of December this year.

And in terms of what we have seen in that period of provisional application... Well, look, I think we're doing a very good job in terms of how we deal with people entering via the airport and the port. We have sometimes, when we have four or five aircraft arriving at once, some people who are experiencing a delay which is shorter than the delays that are being experienced at some other larger European airports.

European airports, but our airport is small and so as we look to make the arrangements for the final layout of what the airport will look like, I think we'll we'll hope to in liaison with Spanish colleagues add more EES booths so that when we have peak periods we'll be able to deal with more of EES enrollment by those who are not residents in Gibraltar or of the European area. And on customs issues, I think in the early days we found that there were first of all logistical traffic issues because, you know, never let something as complex as a treaty get in the way of a regional fair that is going to be set up just where the lorries have to do their turnaround and is going to cause a longer queue. But also the new procedures which are a little sticky and we need to ensure the best application of those new customs procedures is seen through and that we haven't got different officials taking a different view on the European side of how the new procedures apply.

We need a fixed procedure. I'm very pleased to hear Paul confirm, as we know, that the working groups are in the process of being established so that the EU-UK working groups, which will involve largely Spanish and Gibraltarian presence, will be able to resolve not just as we have at a practical level on the ground, but also perhaps in new protocols, which will be the work product of those committees, the way that we'll go forward in the bits that have been stickier. But I'll give you a statistic. In the first couple of days, we'd gone from about 250 to 300 trucks a day coming into Gibraltar to about 100 to 150 trucks coming into Gibraltar. A lot of that was the traffic problem we were having because of the fair and people getting used to the new systems.

We're back up now to 250 to 300 trucks a day. Things are working.

People are still getting used to the new systems. There are better ways of doing some things and we'll finesse those in the days, weeks and months ahead, but I think that we're getting there and the fluidity is where it needs to be.

01:57:31 - 01:57:33

Speaker 49

Chief Minister, thank you very much.

01:57:33 - 01:57:35

Speaker 51

Yes, Lord Jackson.

01:57:35 - 01:57:47

James Stewart Jackson

Just a technical question, First Minister. The new residency regulations, have you published guidance on that and how they'll be interpreted?

01:57:47 - 01:57:48

Yes, we have.

01:57:48 - 01:57:50

Speaker 48

When were they published?

01:57:50 - 01:57:55

Speaker 52

I can't tell you the date. I'm happy to write to you with the date and the regulations.

01:57:56 - 01:57:59

Speaker 50

Thank you very much. Lord Tugendhat.

01:57:59 - 01:58:59

Christopher Tugendhat

Before I ask the question I'm down to ask, I'd just like to come back to the point about people crossing the frontiers. In the past, my recollection is that there were many British people who lived on the Costas who had their banking facilities in Gibraltar, that their pensions were paid into an account at a British bank in Gibraltar, and their mortgages were with British banks in Gibraltar, and that indeed there were citizens of some other European countries who also used the facilities of British branches in Gibraltar. So I ask as a matter of interest, is that still the case to any great degree? And if it is, I imagine that in as much as it makes a difference, the treaty we're talking about facilitates the arrangements of those people as well.

01:58:59 - 02:00:51

Fabian Picardo

No, that is no longer a discernible part of the business of Gibraltar. For example, I don't think that there are any banking institutions in Gibraltar now that offer banking to non-residents. And so most of the people who have property in the Costas around Gibraltar will have banking arrangements and mortgages with lending institutions in Spain or perhaps in the United Kingdom. After Brexit, that became very, very, very difficult indeed. So there are few British institutions that now trade as British institutions in the European Union.

It would usually be a British name, but the European branch or the European corporation that holds that name that would be doing that banking business.

What we see coming across the frontier today are principally tourists who are arriving in the Spanish costas and come to Gibraltar for a day or longer. We're seeing people who live in the area who want to come to Gibraltar to shop for British products, in so far as that British product can still make it into the European Union after Brexit and before the SPS agreement that we sincerely hope the United Kingdom will do as part of the, I read today once again delayed, further reset negotiations. But none of the sort of demographic that you described now stand out.

There's a lot of what we call expats, British people who reside in the Costa, who will be coming to Gibraltar principally to shop, to see Gibraltar, to see a British bobby, and if they want, stand on a red phone box, but not to do their banking here. That's not the demographic anymore.

02:00:51 - 02:01:10

Christopher Tugendhat

Okay, thank you very much for that. Let me ask you, we've covered a lot of ground. Is it your expectation that this agreement settles matters for Gibraltar for as far ahead as one can see, or do you think further agreements are going to be necessary?

02:01:10 - 02:03:10

Fabian Picardo

I think that in relation to the question of fluidity and the relationship between Gibraltar and the European Union, indeed the United Kingdom and the European Union in relation to Gibraltar, the issue is settled and I think it should be regarded as settled even by the parties that are not presently in government. And what I detect is that there's going to be a lot of rhetoric in an election year in Spain, for example, on Gibraltar, etc., but whether that rhetoric, if there is a change of government, would lead to a change of approach, I think is a matter that we will have to see develop. Look, I'm never going to tell you that it's not impossible that the issue could come back for re-litigation in the future, but I think everybody is happy with the imperfect arrangements that have been done and that they should continue to apply because what they do is they give business efficacy to the requirement of all of the relevant governments and institutions to permit people to move fluidly from one territory to another for all of the commercial and personal reasons that we might have set out.

Look, the United Kingdom has reserved its position on sovereignty because it wanted to and we wanted to, we would have insisted that's the case. So has Spain. Nothing has changed on the sovereignty issue. But of course Gibraltar is not for one moment setting aside its continued fight for the recognition of our right to self-determination in Gibraltar, in the United Kingdom, and in New York, where we're still on the list of non-self-governing territories and we need to come off of that list, something which is hotly disputed by Spain in New York. So what I might say is that perhaps we've resolved the issue for Brussels, but we still have a lot to do in New York.

02:03:10 - 02:03:18

Christopher Tugendhat

Okay, thank you very much and I must say it's been a great pleasure to listen to the clarity of your responses. Thank you.

02:03:18 - 02:03:19

Good morning.

02:03:19 - 02:06:28

The Lord Moynihan

Thank you, Chair. And and thank you so much, Chief Minister, for taking some of your precious time to come and talk with us. It's been very enlightening. I I remember crossing La Línea in, I think, 1964 and at the time the the there there was a threat of the border closing suddenly and we managed to get into Gibraltar but were then unsure whether we'd be able to drive out of Gibraltar. And I think I think those problems that in 1964 were present have rumbled on a lot.

So let us hope that you are right in your thought that this is going to be a very good settlement.

And if I could offer a disclaimer to your rather earlier concerns about the things I said, I doubt that there's anybody in this room who isn't incredibly proud of Gibraltar's past and current achievements. And, and there is in this country, I, I obviously I can't speak for everybody, a real sense of bond and, and closeness to Gibraltar, and long may that continue. But, but the concerns that you were talking about earlier and reverted to just now were about sovereignty. And I think the UK has always been very anxious to give Gibraltar as much sovereignty, freedom as is absolutely possible within the context of its being a British Overseas Territory.

And you addressed that yourself just now. And you heard a previous witness tell us that actually this deal means that Gibraltar will no longer be allowed to join the CPTPP in goods. So either we are going to have to get a carve-out in our negotiation with CPTPP or we're going to have to exclude Gibraltar, it seems to me, in goods. So, and we all agree this deal is only about goods, it's not about services, and Gibraltar is a services economy.

But we in this country, our economy is only growing at the moment because of our ability to step outside a bunch of EU regulations that are throttling growth over there, but that because we're avoiding them, we're getting growth over here in AI and tech and other similar areas. So will you, as Gibraltar, be allowed to, or will you be controlled by the product parts of the product liability directive, of the AI Act as regards goods products, and of the Cyber Resilience Act, for example? There will probably be others. Because if so, getting back to the point of sovereignty, are you looking more like a British Overseas Territory or an EU Overseas Territory if you have to take all these laws?

02:06:27 - 02:10:32

Fabian Picardo

Well, thank you for your long-standing interest in Gibraltar. I wasn't around in 1969. I only popped out in 1972, by which time the gates had been closed. But I do recognize, we may come to an area of disagreement between us in a moment, but I do recognize that bond of friendship that unites us with all of the British people, however they might have voted in 2016. Our bonds go deeper than just membership or non-membership of the European Union.

That's the reality.

If you'll allow me a quick flourish, when the gates came down and I was asked by Spanish journalists what we were going to do with the gates, I suggested that they might be taken to the cemetery where the Spanish dictator now lies and laid on his coffin, given that he was so enamored of them, we might make sure he never comes out and does any damage again. But I want to be very clear about what we've done and I'm going to try and explain it philosophically for a moment and then come to the detail. What we have looked at is the reality that Gibraltar geographically and therefore physically is attached to Europe. And therefore the things that move physically, people and goods, need to be able to flow with Europe in a very fluid fashion. Note that I never used in the time I've addressed you the concept of free movement, because the freedom of movement concept for people permits people the right of establishment.

We haven't done that deal with the EU.

We've only done a deal of fluidity of people and fluidity of goods. And the things that move metaphysically, that is to say services, are outside of the scope of the UK-EU treaty in relation to Gibraltar. That brings me to your question on the CPTPP. We are able now to have all of the international trade agreements that the United Kingdom is doing extended to Gibraltar in services. We have very little interest in goods trade with the United States, with the Pacific region, etc.

Because first of all Gibraltar's a very small market. We've never been involved in the exportation of goods other than perhaps tobacco, but we didn't exactly cover ourselves in glory in that respect.

So, I mean, what we want to be able to do is to continue to be able to grow in the only thing you can grow in the geography of two and a half square miles, which is in services. And so we can have the CPTPP extended to us in services. We can have the Japan agreement extended to us in services. And all of the other agreements, Morocco agreement, which is more relevant because it's our neighbor, extended to us in services. We've never formed part of what you referred to earlier in questioning my colleague Lord Wood, of British trade policy, so to speak.

In fact, I might say that it might have made for a very different Gibraltar if we had been included in British trade policy. We were never considered. We were never consulted. We were never given a role in that respect, which is a pity. And I think, you know, it would be good if we could go back 50 years and change that, but we can't.

And so I hope that answers the question. On AI, for example, on cyber, there we are as free an agent as the United Kingdom, unless of course, and this is important and you rightly point to it, the interface between those two are goods. And what you might call the servification, I think is the servitization, I think is the concept in the WTO of how services can access goods. And there's a bit of a murky grey area there in between. But in pure services, which is where our business is, we're free, we're a free agent with the United Kingdom, and we can do more of what we do very successfully.

02:10:32 - 02:11:02

The Lord Moynihan

But I think you've just said therefore that for example you could not buy or trade any genetically modified food that comes from the UK, say one that had health benefits. You can't engage in any research or activity in that area. So you are precluded from all sorts of things that the UK can do.

02:11:02 - 02:12:07

Fabian Picardo

Well, let me put it this way. That glass half full presentation I would answer like this. We have chosen to continue to grow in the services area, making the compromise of not having in the future any of the research that we have never had in respect of genetically modified organisms because we have nowhere to grow anything in Gibraltar.

And we have chosen to make those compromises in order to be able to continue to grow in the areas that we can grow. We have not had since 2016 the ability to bring to Gibraltar any fresh produce that is not able to enter the EU under the current arrangements for the UK. But I do hope that the United Kingdom government's reset with the European Union reaches a safe harbor and that it includes an SPS agreement and that anything produced in the UK will be able to come into Gibraltar, although it's very likely that in reaching those SPS arrangements, the United Kingdom may also make the same compromises that we've made in the context of these treaty arrangements.

02:12:07 - 02:12:41

Tim Timothy Barrow

Yes, which would be tragic, tragic for our economy. Thank you. On that note, Chief Minister, thank you very much indeed for sparing us your time today.

It's been most helpful and it will be an important contribution to the House's consideration of the treaty, I don't doubt. I also pass my appreciation on to the team at your end for bearing with the various technological challenges we've had in setting up this link, but I'm delighted it's been successful. Thank you again for joining us, and with that I draw the public session to a close.

02:12:41 - 02:12:44

Speaker 54

May I say something before you do?

02:12:45 - 02:12:48

Speaker 55

May I say something before you before you close?

02:12:49 - 02:13:13

Fabian Picardo

Simply to say thank you for your interest in Gibraltar and this configuration of the committee and earlier configurations of the committee, and to say goodbye because I will be retiring from my office in coming months. I imagine, barring any last-minute urgency, that this is the last time I will appear before your committee. And so thank you for all your considerations at the time I've been appearing for the past decade and a half. Thank you and goodbye.

02:13:13 - 02:13:19

Tim Timothy Barrow

Well, we wish you a happy, productive, and busy retirement. Thank you very much.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.