Public Services Committee

28 October 2026

Public Services Committee Actual start House of Lords

Follow its sittings
22:48 - 23:23
Speaker 1
I'll formally welcome you again and ask each of you to introduce yourselves, please, to the committee.  I'm Keith, the chair of the committee.  And then if each of you could give a sort of introduction to your perspective on where we're up to in legislative, finance, and supply and demand within the care system to introduce the session before we go into formal questions.  Thank you very much. 
23:24 - 23:28
Speaker 2
So who would like to start? 
23:28 - 24:41
Speaker 3
I shall.  So good morning everyone.  I'm Rachael Wardell.  I'm the executive director for children families and lifelong learning at Surrey County Council and I'm here today representing the Association of Directors of Children's Services so speaking on behalf of the sector.  And I suppose the few words that I would say about the current position of reforms is that as you know there's a huge package of reforms going through children's services at the moment. 

The families first partnership program which is really important focus on children social care best start in life and the package of SEND reforms. 

So there's a huge amount of work currently underway in children's services.  The Families First reforms need to be fully implemented by the end of March, so that progress is underway at the moment.  And we're anticipating that that will have impact on the care sector, both in terms of the number of children who come into care and also potentially from the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill, the way that care is provided to those young people.  But at the moment, I would say that there's a real challenge in the sector, and I hope we can explore that in this committee today. 
24:41 - 25:58
Speaker 4
Shall I go next?  Okay.  My name's Lucy Butler, really pleased to be here today.  I'm the Chief Executive of Home and Future, which is the South East Regional Care Cooperative.  There's 19 local authorities that are in the region of the South East. 

We have 15 signed up to the Regional Care Cooperative and we're working with 18 of those 19 local authorities to implement the fostering reforms.  So from a where are we in terms of the reforms, I can speak particularly to sufficiency and the work around that, probably less so on the wider things.  Before that I was a director in the South East in two authorities, so I have that sort of background from a director's perspective.  Just two caveats I would say about Regional Care Cooperatives.  We were one of the pathfinders, the South East with Greater Manchester. 

We are very new and we are dealing with an issue that has been around for 30 to 40 years, so we're not quick fixes, so just to say that.  And secondly, you've just heard me say that we've got 15 of the 19 local authorities signed up to us.  We're not mandatory.  It's a choice whether local authorities join us or not.  And obviously we would be more powerful together. 

So, yeah.  That's my intro.  Thank you. 
25:58 - 25:59
Thank you, Lucy. 

25:59 - 28:39

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Hello, I'm Gerald Vernon-Jackson and I'm deputy chair of the Children and Young People's Committee at the LGA, and I'm here from the LGA. I am a, I was a social worker for a long time ago, but I worked both in residential and in field work. But I've then run Portsmouth Council for 15 years, so I've got both those bits of experience. I think the bits that I would want to highlight today is the financial pressure, which inevitably always happens and people know about.

But we're having to put in probably about an extra billion pounds a year across local authorities into children's social care, and that's not funded centrally. I was with a council earlier this week, their savings target that they have to hit is now over a hundred million pounds of cuts this year they need to find. I think the other things are the complexity of kids that we're looking after is growing. More and more young people with complex needs in mental health, substance abuse, exploitation. And the number of children we are looking after, it's fallen slightly last year, but overall it's growing, and that's a big problem.

We have issues of unregistered homes, which I'm sure we will come and talk about. And I'm really pleased Lucy's here from the care cooperative, regional care cooperative, because councils have withdrawn from providing direct services over the last 25 years, and now we're having to probably go back into re-providing them. And we need to think about how that happens. And I think my last thing is I think there's a real need for better coordination, particularly with the health service. We're getting the number of beds available for children and adolescents with mental health, severe mental health problems has fallen enormously, and we're the last, we're the end of the road.

The buck stops with us. And also with the criminal justice system, increasingly young people are being sent for us to look after, not into, not being locked up in prison, which is probably right for them, but it produces an enormous problem for us.

So I know in my council we've had one kid that we've been looking after, I think costing £25,000 a week. Now that's not unusual and it's becoming more and more common. So I thought those some of the things would be interesting to talk through today.

28:39 - 29:24

Speaker 1

Thank you all, those are very interesting opening remarks which we'll dig down into through our questioning. And I'll start with, if you Lucy particularly, but all of you to contribute around the new sort of care cooperative model that you're developing.

You've touched on some of the aspects of it that you think will be helpful. Could you elaborate a bit more on how it's being rolled out, what the funding arrangements are with local authorities, how it will tackle sufficiency of supply in the system, and the issue around boundaries that you are incorporating?

29:24 - 33:52

Lucy Butler

Yes, a lot there, so you might have to sort of prompt me if I forget some of those things. But so, as I said, we were one of the two pathfinders nationally, so ourselves and Greater Manchester. And they were chosen, I think, for various, because we're very different. So Greater Manchester is a combined authority, and they already had a relationship, those ten local authorities working together. In the South East, there was no real history of local authorities working together.

So I think one of the things that we were focused on is how do we best collaborate to get a better deal for children? And so the things that we have been focusing on, we've been looking at joint commissioning arrangements in the region. We have particularly been focused on working with partners, health partners in particular. And in the South East, we've got five ICBs, two provider collaboratives here, so it's not a simple picture. But we have established a memorandum of understanding with the ICBs and with the provider collaboratives to work together to get better homes for children.

So there's a really strong ethos, although that hasn't been replicated nationally, I think. We haven't seen that, you know, this kind of jointness together. So that's something we're particularly interested in working on. So we're working with health colleagues and our local authority colleagues to look at pathways of support for children, and joint pathways, integrated pathways, and also to look at joint provision.

So that's one of the big things that we're looking at. We've also been supporting the introduction of end-to-end fostering in the region. And South East, as I said, is a really big region. So to do that effectively, we've been working sub-regionally. So we're working with five sub-regions to, because it's really important that we stay close to local authorities and to place.

So we are looking at how we can bring the advantages of working in a more regional way to to better kind of have conversations with providers, to have a bit more control, to have a bit more say, and to do the things that work at a regional level. So we would say that local authorities are really good at commissioning services for children, but there's some things that you need local authorities to come together to tackle, and they're usually the more difficult issues like working together with health, really supporting children with more complex needs. So that's where we think the power of regional care cooperatives come in. We've also been doing a lot of work around workforce, of residential workforce in particular, because what we're hearing is that they might not have the skills that are needed to support children with multiple needs. So we're looking at how we enhance training and support for residential workers, and we are also looking at how we bring in the voice of children and young people into the work that we do.

So really wanting to hear from children that have experience of tier four provision, that have experience of unregistered.

We are really wanting to support local authorities to have the right homes for children at the right time. So, and I think it's really interesting, I think sufficiency is a really complex issue. So people often say there's not enough, there's not enough homes for children, but it's much more complex than that. And just a really simple example of that. So we have 2,220 children that are living outside the South East region.

And we also have 1,936 children outside of the South East that live in the region. So something for us to do to untangle that, it's just one example of how complex sufficiency is. How do we, how do we kind of unpick that? And I think one of the really good things about regional care cooperatives is that it will be a national initiative. So going back to that statistic I just shared with you, most of the children from the South East live in London.

So we are doing a piece of work with London. And likewise, most of the children coming in to the South East are from London. So we're doing a piece of work with London to look at how we might work together. So you can see how bringing local authorities together and some of these issues can be tackled regionally and some of these issues need to be tackled nationally. I hope that's answered your question and all of the things you asked me.

33:52 - 33:54

Speaker 1

Did you want to add to that, Rachael?

33:54 - 36:33

Rachael Wardell

I think I do, yes, and to sort of speak from the local authority perspective.

So the first thing that I would say is I think I agree very broadly with everything that Lucy has said about the advantages of regional care cooperatives and the benefit, I suppose, of working at scale and also collaborating across boundaries. So when Lucy refers to children with most complex needs, they are quite low in number, but they are usually the children for whom it's most difficult to find a placement, for whom we might be trying to find a placement in an emergency. Quite often what happens to these children, you know, is a form of crisis, and therefore we're trying to plan for them and find placements for them in an emergency. That often is what leads to them being located outside of their home local authority. So some of the things that Lucy was describing arise out of the conditions at the point at which a placement decision is made.

And once you have successfully found a home for a child in which they are doing well, moving them purely for geographic reasons doesn't make sense. You want them to stay somewhere where they are looked after and where they're thriving.

So there are lots of kind of complex moving parts. And the thing that we can do very well together as an RCC, I think, is to commission specialist provision at greater scale than any one local authority would need, but that is responsive to those kinds of particular needs. We've all, I think, referred to mental health as being a big issue. There are no longer the inpatient places that there used to be. Those children probably are better off outside hospital, but they do need specialist provision that meets their needs.

And they are often the children that we're the most worried about and the children who most need stability. They do also need to be close to home because their existing networks, maybe their existing education, which I'm sure we'll come back to later in this session, family members and friends are all important to them.

And so having a solution that is regional and close is really important. What I think I would say, and I don't think Lucy would disagree, is that RCCs aren't the answer to everything and we shouldn't try to get them to solve all of the challenges. So there are lots of things that local authorities definitely already do well. And certainly many local authorities now are growing their in-house capacity and capability, and we should encourage that because the local connection is vital. And wherever we can deliver something locally without needing to reach for that scale solution, that seems to me to be the most sensible and pragmatic way forward.

36:33 - 36:37

Speaker 6

And the RCCs offer that additionality for those complex placements.

36:37 - 36:53

Speaker 1

Just two very quick follow-up questions from me.

Are the resources from those 15 or however many local authorities pooled, and then they're still kept in separate silos? So you don't have a lever to pull to...

36:53 - 37:33

Lucy Butler

No. And I think there's, I mean, you might want to ask Rachel this as well, I think there's something about the confidence in RCCs. We are very new. And, you know, and the statutory duties all sit with the directors of children's services, as you know. So it's a bit of a leap of faith, I think, to give all of your commissioning budget.

And, you know, in the Southeast, it's something like 1.3 billion pounds, so it's a huge amount of money. Um, so I don't think that's going to happen quickly. But we are more of a strategic commissioning body to support the bits that local authorities are struggling to do by themselves. And I think you asked me originally how we were funded, so I will answer that. I remembered that.

So the local authorities fund us, so we have a funding formula and the local authorities fund us completely. And so in a sense we're like a member organisation working on behalf of our local authorities.

Um, so the local authorities fund us.

37:43 - 38:05

Speaker 1

Same quick question, could you remind me what the timetable is for assessment of the pathfinders with the view to rolling it out nationally? Because you did say unless it's done nationally as well, then there's still impediments in the revised system you're trying to put in place.

38:05 - 38:43

Lucy Butler

Yes, so there's a further five RCCs that have just been established in the last few months, so they're very new.

And they are doing the kind of groundwork that we did initially, which is kind of bringing together data, establishing relationships, having conversations with their local authorities about what their priorities are. So that doesn't cover the whole of England. That covers, I think, 150 out of 100, no, I think it's two-thirds, sorry, two-thirds of local authorities are now covered. It's 100 out of 150. Yeah.

But there are plans, I think, to roll it out further.

38:43 - 41:05

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Yes, thank you. Just a quick couple of things. I think I used to work in a secure unit in a regional, regionally provided place. And it was horrible, being blunt, where you lock kids in and they only exercise they had because of the place it was was in a yard, etc.

But I think the regional care cooperatives are going to be enormously helpful, but not quick. I wouldn't, I don't know where we're going, but I'd have thought I wouldn't expect a huge amount of change within five years because they're going to have to get up and running, etc. So don't expect things to happen too, too fast. I think we need to be absolutely clear about the scale of the problem. If we look between 2018 to 2022, the number of kids that we are looking after where we're spending more than £10,000 a week on a child rose from 120 to 1,500 in a four-year period.

And it's gone up from there. So I think we've had one recently where we're spending £25,000 a week looking after a child. But I think the bit that's important is the regional care cooperatives can really help at the high-end specialist end of the market.

I think we've got to be really careful about saying they're the answer to everything. Because it's really important when you're looking after a kid to try to make sure that you maintain links with family, with school, with friends. And moving people even 20 miles means that lots of those breakdown. And if you don't, the longer a kid is away from home, the more chance it is that that child will stay in care for a long time. So trying to work to keep those links of school and family going is best done at a local level because we know at a local level what the connections are and how we can try to make sure we can keep those.

So I think regional care cooperatives are enormously good for that high for the for the high end of the market. I'm not I wouldn't want them to be able to solve the local stuff about fostering ordinary fostering and and children's home places and things like that and kinship care.

41:05 - 41:38

Rachael Wardell

Is it right if I add something? It may be that your later questions will explore this further, but I wouldn't want to give the impression that when we're talking about placements that cost twenty-five thousand a week, that we're necessarily getting twenty-five thousand pounds a week value out of those placements. I wouldn't suggest that those necessarily better meet a child's needs than lower cost placements. So obviously children with complex needs, their placements are likely to be more expensive, they're likely to be more intensive, they will have specialist skills, but I don't think that we see value for money in those placements.

41:38 - 41:56

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

And if you if you're a social worker and you have to try to make sure that the kid is safe, that's what you will do.

And that's the prime, prime motivator. And what it costs will be because your choice is maybe zero. And that's a real problem we've got.

41:56 - 41:57

Baroness Watkins.

41:57 - 43:01

Baroness Watkins

I just wondered, there are two things that have come to me. One is for a tiny proportion of children you will deliberately send them a long way away because of county lines or whatever. And I just wonder what percentage that might be if you could give us an idea of it. And secondly, when we talk about twenty-five thousand pounds a week, I mean I did at one point work in an inpatient child and adolescent unit. I'm talking about thirty-five years ago as a nurse.

But I don't think at today's value that would be any more expensive. So I've got a kind of question: do you think health are taking their responsibility seriously in terms of treatment? Because for some children, given the right treatment at the right time, it might be more costly then, but if you look over a five-year period, it's cost-effective.

43:01 - 43:03

Speaker 8

Rachael, you'll know more than me.

43:03 - 43:50

Rachael Wardell

I can say a little bit. I'll take the health question first, I suppose, which is, I mean, I do think health colleagues take their responsibilities very seriously, but I think they're chronically under-resourced.

I think children's health funding takes second seat to adult health funding, and within that, mental health funding takes less. So they're not able, I think, to respond in the way that they would want to. But there are areas of conflict. And one obvious one is about children's behavioral issues, which may or may not be driven by a mental health condition. And where something is labeled as behavioral, it falls outside the purview of the health service to respond to it, and we might have a very strong view that it is actually a mental health condition.

43:50 - 43:52

Speaker 10

So we do see that kind of conflict, for sure.

43:52 - 43:54

Speaker 9

Thank you. Lord Faulkner.

43:54 - 44:33

Richard Faulkner

Morning. Thank you for coming to see us this morning. Very interesting answers so far, and I'm sure there'll be lots more to come. I want to ask you about the market management measures contained in the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act. Do you think it's likely to make any difference to the situation the DfE reported, that the children's social care market is fundamentally broken?

That's the first question. I mean, is it going to make a real difference? And will it manage to reshape the market in the way that the government wants? Perhaps Gerald, you'd like to take this one first.

44:33 - 46:03

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Um, so I think probably no. I would hope that it would do better than no, but I think the reality is no. Partly because of the huge pressure on placements. Secondly, these are increasingly run by large organisations who are funded by private equity whose demand is for profit, profit, profit and profit, and then some more profit.

And they are big enough to be able to do their accounts in a way that that big corporations do. And we have a rule in councils that any developer wanting to build, if they have if they have profits less than 10%, they don't have to contribute towards social housing. I don't think any or the very few developers declare that they've got more than 10% profit, and we don't have the resources they have to go through all of their accounts and look at them.

So, um, I think it's the right thing to be doing and I welcome the government's change of, the previous government's change of heart to say we're going to look at it, but I don't think it's going to make a huge difference and I think we're going to need much more, much more power to be able to regulate that market than is being proposed to be able to make a big, big change. Um, but Rachael will know, you have to sign the checks.

46:03 - 46:29

Rachael Wardell

I do. Um, I mean, I think you're right, probably isn't the answer as currently constructed. It's a last resort measure. Um, so there are very welcome measures there in the bill, but they're proposed as last resort, for example, the profit cap. I think probably as a sector we would like to see profit-making, or certainly profiteering providers where the profit margins are very high, ruled out of this very important area of work.

46:29 - 46:34

Speaker 12

How are you going to do that? Yeah. How are you going to do that?

46:34 - 47:05

Rachael Wardell

What, so the only way I think is going to be through legislation.

And so the profit cap, if it's used as a first resort rather than last resort, in other words, if we are active in the market straight away, I think that becomes really important. But if it's left as a last resort, I think that we will see continuing sort of movement in the market of organizations seeking to use this market to make high, unwarranted profits.

47:05 - 47:14

Richard Faulkner

Isn't there a risk that the clever people who run the accounts of the other companies will outwit the government officials?

47:14 - 47:29

Speaker 13

That's always a risk. And the only way that you could do that is by outlawing profit altogether. But that's not... Is there a future for voluntary and publicly run services?

47:31 - 47:41

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Because if we get to the position where it is only the private sector there, then they have a monopoly and we can be ripped off even more.

47:41 - 47:42

Lucy, did you want to...?

47:42 - 48:33

Lucy Butler

Just a couple of things. I think we have to be careful with these measures. I think they are welcome, but we have to be careful of adverse consequences and the impact if suddenly we see big swathes of the market disappearing. That's a real concern, I think. And I think there is something about what is it with some of our providers, the voluntary sector and local authorities, what is preventing them from entering into this area more and really understanding that and really supporting those providers?

And there's all sorts of issues that it takes a long time to register and set up a home, etc., all sorts of things that get in the way.

And I think we need to be as focused on the blockers as well as, you know, what is preventing people entering this, what, what is stopping them, what can we do to support the providers that we do want to support our children?

48:33 - 48:46

Richard Faulkner

And isn't there a real danger that the children with the most complex needs will be right at the end of the queue when it comes to future investment and so on?

48:46 - 49:23

Rachael Wardell

I don't think so, um, because they're currently costing the system so much for per individual placement. So really well-invested, um, funds into specialist placements would, I think, overall bring the costs down.

And it is why what we say about the RCCs and other measures are that they should focus on those young people first. So from our point of view, the resources that are currently in the system, if they were redirected into securing and developing specialist placements, that would be a very worthwhile investment. And they would be first in the queue for most DCSs, I think.

49:23 - 50:06

Speaker 14

Can I ask a supplementary just on this? Yes. I'm just thinking about this profit caps and the difficulty of doing that, but also I can absolutely see the importance of it. I wonder if there could be pressure on at least some of these providers to invest more in the skills and professional development of their staff, because that's another issue. And if you're making a lot of profit, even if you don't, if there's no profit cap, you could at least be investing in the quality of the staff you recruit, the way you train them, the way you develop them, all of that.

Because we need to build a whole ecosystem of qualified, talented, effective people in this field, don't we?

And it's not quite happening at the moment.

50:06 - 50:34

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

And the, it would seem to be the best ones will do that. The ones who aren't so good won't, because they're interested in the profit. I think one of the great things about having the regional care cooperatives here is that we are able to make sure that we're investing long-term in highly skilled staff who are well-trained and well-supported, and it's a really good thing to be doing. But I think rubbish providers will remain rubbish providers.

50:34 - 50:38

Speaker 14

And should be, if the market was working, they should be exited from the market then.

50:38 - 51:10

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

But the problem is that the market doesn't work because we're desperate for placements. We will, if you're a social worker and you're trying to find somewhere to keep that child safe, the money is irrelevant.

You will just try to take it and persuade Rachael that she has to write the checks. But we're in a system where there are not enough places and too many children, so there is an enormous pressure just to take something to keep a child safe.

51:10 - 51:13

Speaker 15

I do understand. Thank you.

51:13 - 52:01

Rachael Wardell

If I can add, one of the professional development routes for practitioners in children's residential is into social work. And although that is obviously an important professional development and to be welcomed because we need social workers, there's a lot to be said for staying in the residential sector. And these are often low-paid workers, but they are not low-skilled, and those skills aren't sufficiently valued in the kind of pay scales in their settings.

So in local authorities which are trying to grow their in-house workforce and provision, you can definitely see that kind of investment in workforce. And Lucy alluded to it in relation to the RCC, which is something that one can do at scale on a regional basis, is that professional development of children's residential workers. So you're right, it is an issue.

52:01 - 52:28

Lucy Butler

Just a couple of things. The government is reviewing the training and development of residential workers, and I think that's to be welcomed because we don't think we currently get it right. And secondly, I think there's something for us to learn from European countries. So the social pedagogy model and how much they invest in their residential workers and, you know, the value that those workers have is much higher than in this country. And you can really see the quality of that support.

52:28 - 52:39

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

And just, I left doing residential care because I got too many broken bones.

And eventually I thought, enough is enough.

52:39 - 53:21

Sheila Hollins

Baroness Hollins and Baroness Redfern. I was interested in what you said about learning from European countries. I visited Dresden and saw a public services apprenticeship model for a five-year program for school leavers where social residential support or support in the community was developed alongside other public service roles with equal salaries at the end of a five-year program. Very impressive as a way, and they didn't seem to have the same shortages of social care workers.

Because it's valued and the training was exceptional.

53:21 - 53:34

Lucy Butler

And they trained alongside other public service workers. And I think, you know, if we think about these are the workers that are working with the most vulnerable children in our society, I think they deserve some investment.

53:34 - 53:52

Speaker 19

Agreed. Baroness Swift. Thank you, Chair. I have to declare I am a Vice President of the Local Government Association. A quick question is, we're talking about, can I talk about agency staffing and skill mix within agency staffing?

53:52 - 53:56

Speaker 18

Do you mean social workers or care workers?

53:56 - 53:59

Speaker 17

Care workers.

53:59 - 54:53

Rachael Wardell

So, for the most part, the agency debate that rages in the children's sector is focused more on agency social workers than on residential workers.

Um, but, uh, there are agency residential care workers, and the challenge for residential care employers is certainly to have a, kind of, an established staff base and to reduce turnover. And the thing about a, uh, residential, uh, home is you absolutely have to have the staffing at the right number for the children that you're accommodating and responding to. Um, and so if you, uh, have any kind of staff turnover or sickness absence, then you definitely, um, will get agency, um, agency workers, um, in to cover those gaps. Um, so that creates... With the right skills.

With the right skills, if that's... So, so, uh, they won't always be as highly skilled as your permanent workforce, no.

54:53 - 54:56

Speaker 20

Because of short notice work, yes. Yes.

54:56 - 55:44

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

If you have to shut if you haven't got anybody there, the right skills, well, there will be a level, but the right skills might be a pulse at the absolute minimum.

But you need somebody because if you haven't got that second member of staff in a children's home to do the sleep-in, then those kids have to be found somewhere else to live. So the pressure on people is enormous. But Rachael is right. The area where we spend a lot of money on is agency social workers as opposed to residential stuff.

55:44 - 56:21

Rachael Wardell

Yes, partly. But also, I suppose it's because actually that's the workforce that we mostly have in-house. So there are some local authorities in the country that have no in-house residential provision of their own. They're commissioning it all.

It won't necessarily be visible to them when a provider has an agency member of staff or even several agency members of staff. For those of us who do have in-house provision, and that includes my own authority, we're much more acutely aware of when we've got agency staff in our own in-house settings. But it's just, I suppose it's one degree removed when you're commissioning the place and you don't see necessarily what they're having to do to maintain their staffing rotas on a day-by-day basis.

56:21 - 56:23

Speaker 22

Thank you. Thank you.

56:23 - 56:24

Baroness Watkins.

56:24 - 57:14

Baroness Watkins

Thank you very much. Um, you've kindly slightly touched on this, but we're very interested in trying to identify the main factors that contribute to the continued use of the unregistered homes and whether whether you feel the safeguards are really structured properly in such situations. I think we've all read, you know, somebody from Plymouth is sent to an unregistered home, let's say in Blackpool, and how is, you know, supervision maintained during that period? So why send them and how do you supervise what's happening?

57:14 - 59:41

Rachael Wardell

Yes, so I'll speak to that. I mean, it is it is a it is usually a choice of last resort.

We wouldn't send our children to a, you know, a great distance if we could avoid it, and we wouldn't use unregistered if we could avoid it. So I do think, I mean, I've been a DCS now for nearly 14 years, I do think there was probably a time when unregistered provision was cheaper, and it was also lawful at that time, and there may have been places that used it for preference on cost. That is absolutely no longer true. So obviously it's now unlawful to place in unregistered, but also the cost of placing in unregistered is very high indeed. So some of our highest cost placements across the sector will be unregistered placements, and they will have been created usually specifically in a premises and with a staff that are designed to wrap around a young person who cannot be accommodated anywhere else.

So the kind of choices that are being made are very different now from how they might have been done at, you know, a decade ago.

I can't obviously speak for the percentage of unregistered use right across all local authorities, but I can speak briefly from my own. So I have about 960 children in Surrey's care, which is a low per 10,000 rate because of course Surrey is so huge, of which one child is in unregulated in extremis and actually doing very well where they currently are. So that becomes another challenge, which is the read-across between a regulated setting and high-quality provision that meets a child's needs is not exact. Sometimes a child is doing better in an unregulated setting, even if we wouldn't have chosen to place them there originally.

But once they're settled and the right support is around them, moving them to a registered provision just because it's registered might not be the right choice. And almost every DCS will have a story they can tell you of a time when they have had to move a child into registered because that's obviously the right thing to do, but that ended up breaking down really quickly because the child had become stabilized in the other setting. So what we tend to be motivated to do is to support those providers to become registered. And that's why the speed of registration is really important. So I want to work with providers, get your setting registered, and then we can kind of maintain a registered provision around these children.

59:41 - 01:00:18

Baroness Watkins

So if I just take the one child that you've talked about, can you put pressure as a purchaser on CQC to go and visit that place quickly because you're actually telling me that they're providing good quality care to that child?

One of the things that we're kind of challenged by is how long registration takes. And we've had people that one believes are in it for the right reason but can't get the registration.

01:00:18 - 01:00:55

Rachael Wardell

So it will be Ofsted who visits and Ofsted who is the registering body. And what they will say, and we do see evidence of this, is that when they know that a provider, you know, that a local authority is seeking the registration of that provider, they will try to prioritize it. And they certainly do try to prioritize local authorities' in-house settings to be registered as well for the same reasons, obviously. But again, all of us will have experienced occasions where we think they're not as fast as they could be.

So it's still an area of concern for us.

01:00:55 - 01:01:03

Baroness Watkins

Right, that's very helpful to us because we don't know the answer, but we think maybe there is something that could be done around that.

01:01:03 - 01:01:23

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

I think I've heard of people having to wait a year for Ofsted to come and register them, which is ludicrous. And maybe one of the things we should be looking at is maximum times that Ofsted have to be able to do this piece of work and get somewhere registered.

01:01:23 - 01:01:46

Speaker 1

Just on that, is it a capacity issue within Ofsted? They haven't got enough people registering, or is it, as we've heard, sometimes a problem, say, with the local authority getting planning permission for any changes to the property that is required in advance of registration? Where's the balance in this?

01:01:46 - 01:01:50

Speaker 23

Where is the real blockage in the queue?

01:01:50 - 01:02:39

Rachael Wardell

It's not just in one place and I do think that's what makes it difficult. So one of the points of influence recently has been the change in the regulations that meant that supported accommodation now needs to be registered as well. That led to a flood of applications into Ofsted in relation to supported accommodation. So I think were they to have a representative here they would talk about the fact that they are processing very many more applications than they used to. So there is to a certain extent a capacity issue.

Some of the things that you've described are a problem. So sometimes it isn't easy to get planning consents on settings. Sometimes it's a delay in getting a registered manager because for a setting to be registered the manager also has to be registered. So those things do slow us down.

But sometimes it does just seem like things get stuck and we can't find a good reason. So it's a combination, I think.

01:02:39 - 01:02:47

Speaker 1

And is it right that if a manager who is registered in one home can't assume registration on another home?

01:02:47 - 01:03:06

Rachael Wardell

That's correct as it currently stands. If they move somewhere else. So there has been a change to the rules which mean that if there are two homes closely located to each other, one registered manager can cover two. But if a registered manager moves completely to another setting, they would have to be re-registered in the new setting.

01:03:06 - 01:03:24

Baroness Watkins

And is that partly because there isn't kind of a central register for registered managers?

I mean, in other professions, I mean, if you're a registered social worker, you can go and work in another place easily, can't you?

01:03:24 - 01:03:31

Rachael Wardell

So, well, they they are all recorded, their registration is recorded at Ofsted, but it's not portable.

01:03:31 - 01:03:34

Speaker 25

No, that's the issue. So would portability help with this?

01:03:35 - 01:03:37

Speaker 26

Thank you very much, Chair. Right.

01:03:37 - 01:03:56

Magid Magid

That's very good. Just staying on the subject of issues of delays of registration and the impact, so can I just probe a bit further about how that's impacting on your sufficiency planning, these kind of delays in registration, whatever the reasons are?

01:03:56 - 01:04:55

Rachael Wardell

Yeah. So, so obviously for local authorities that are developing their own settings, they will have forecast the occupancy as part of their sufficiency planning, and if there is a delay in registration, then they're not meeting their sort of forecast sufficiency plans.

To a certain extent, though, all local authorities rely on provision by other providers. And again, when we are looking at sufficiency plans, we look at the extent to which providers are trying to develop their provision in our local area. It is worth saying that in some areas there are more providers than are needed, particularly where property prices are low and there are some parts of the country which are net importers of children in care and they would probably not want as many settings as they have and would prefer to see them located somewhere else. So this is one of the things that I think that the RCCs can help with. I don't know if you want to come in, Lucy, on that.

01:04:55 - 01:06:14

Lucy Butler

Yeah, I mean, I just think in terms of, we know, particularly in the South East, we have some of our local authorities that have developed homes, have fully staffed homes, but they aren't registered.

And so that is a really big issue. And I think, and when we were talking, just to comment when we were talking about bringing in other providers, maybe from the voluntary sector, it costs a huge amount of money to invest in a staff, to staff a residential home and not to have children in those homes, which happens. It happens, it can happen for a year, six months to a year. So that's a, you know, that is a, you know, that will be off-putting to people without big equity behind them, for instance.

So, so that's something for us to consider. I do think that there is, we are, you know, looking at both what we can do in terms of upskilling residential staff, what we can do with putting influence on Ofsted and working with Ofsted to kind of, you know, address this issue, but also looking at the sufficiency nationally and what we can do to kind of make that more proportionate to where the children's needs are, because at the moment it doesn't match children's needs at all. And if you were to do a sort of, if you were to do a kind of chart of where children are being placed, it would look incredibly messy because children are going all over the country from different areas. Does that answer your question?

01:06:14 - 01:06:16

Speaker 28

Yeah, can I just come in, Chair?

01:06:17 - 01:06:47

Magid Magid

I mean, would it be possible, and maybe this is a question for Gerald actually, to get a, what's the cost of that delay? So if you're saying you've got a home, you've got staff trained up, but you're not able to take them young people, are we able to put a number to it so we can make the case to government and Ofsted or whoever to say the lack of action or delays is costing the social care sector, i.e. young people aren't being given the service and this is the amount of money that's, how can I put it, not being used well?

01:06:47 - 01:06:56

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

I'm sorry, I wouldn't have that number, but I'm sure we could see.

Could you get it for us please?

I'm sure my colleagues behind me who are busily writing things down will get that for us.

01:06:56 - 01:07:16

Magid Magid

And the other thing I would have asked from the LGA, sorry, I should have declared an interest, remiss of me, I'm also vice chair of the LGA, is it possible to find out where the biggest delays are in the local authority areas in terms of registration? You said sometimes it's a year. It'd be nice, be interesting to see where those delays are geographically.

01:07:16 - 01:07:21

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Geographically or by the sort of provision that they're being offered?

01:07:21 - 01:07:23

Speaker 30

I, both I would say.

01:07:23 - 01:08:42

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Okay, because I, I think one of the things that would be helpful out of this is if there was a, a time that said, okay, Ofsted, you need to have gone in and do an initial inspection and reg, and make an initial decision within a month so that people can get on and, and get provid, providing that provision. Because if you're a social worker and you're faced with a child who is in somewhere that is unsafe for them and you're offered the chance of somewhere that looks good, you know about, it's unregistered, but you think they're safe, or somewhere else that you're less confident of, then, then your push will always be to what is, what's going to be the safest for that child irrespective of whether they've got Ofsted tick or not. And, and I think we have to trust that the people in social work, that that's what they're desperately trying to do.

And when I did it and in doing fieldwork, your caseloads are so high that once you've got one kid in somewhere safe, you have to move on to the next one that is in somewhere that is unsafe. And and the pressure is enormous. So if there should be some push to get Ofsted to approve places quicker, I think everybody would be happy.

01:08:42 - 01:09:20

Speaker 1

Is there an an opportunity or are there too many flaws in having a temporary license when you've done that initial inspection and you say this looks okay, so we'll give you a temporary license to alleviate the problem that you're identifying, but then with a timeframe of complete registration to follow, so you're on the path and and Ofsted therefore would could prioritize the process from that point and get that up and running as as quickly as possible?

01:09:19 - 01:09:41

Rachael Wardell

Well, certainly that is something that the ADCS has explored with Ofsted, and we haven't yet found the right set of conditions that would make that something that they would feel that they could do, because they wouldn't necessarily want to grant a temporary registration to every setting. But I think if the right set of conditions could be found, then that would be helpful.

01:09:41 - 01:09:48

Speaker 1

I mean, the example you gave sounds to me, on the face of it, an ideal opportunity to say, okay, let's get on with it.

01:09:48 - 01:10:08

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

It's about analyzing risk because we're dealing with children who are at risk or maybe risks in themselves but nothing is zero risk and leaving places that could provide decent care unregistered is a risk.

01:10:08 - 01:10:11

Speaker 31

Yes, agreed.

01:10:11 - 01:10:56

Baroness Watkins

Can I just ask, I said CQC by mistake but we have discussed separately, you know, should some of these really high level placements have CQC inspection as well? So I'd just like to ask what your opinion is. And then we've also said to ourselves, which is not, you know, we haven't written the report yet, do we just need a different inspection agency to really only concentrate on this because Ofsted have schools and lots of other things to do? Would there be any advantage in that?

This is not being anti-Ofsted, it's just trying to say, what do you think?

01:10:56 - 01:11:43

Rachael Wardell

I genuinely haven't given that thought, so I'm not sure that I could kind of formulate an answer as to whether another agency... What's essential is the right kind of capacity and resources devoted to the registration. On the question of CQC, I mean, I think the answer is yes. Some of these are, you know, clearly need to be clinical facilities really. And also for young people at the kind of upper end of adolescence, so who are likely to transition into adult services, sometimes the best place that we can place them is actually a CQC-registered setting that is intended for adults.

And that of course isn't deemed to be an appropriate placement for a child, but it would help their transition. So something that brought together Ofsted and CQC registrations would be a helpful thing.

01:11:43 - 01:12:26

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

But the basis of what we do, going back to things like the Laming report, is looking at social services having been separated off from education and health. And what we've worked on consistently for the last few decades is to try to make sure that those things are really closely worked. We used to have a social services department that did adults and children. We don't anymore. We have children's services that try to work across both health, education, and social care because the problem that was identified is the lack of communication between health, social care, and others about the well-being of a child.

01:12:26 - 01:12:31

Speaker 35

And I would be worried if we worked away from that.

01:12:31 - 01:12:34

Speaker 34

I understand. Thank you.

01:12:34 - 01:12:35

Speaker 32

Lord Barber.

01:12:35 - 01:14:41

Speaker 14

I was going to ask a question about Ofsted, but we've got well into that, so I'll just ask a refinement of that and build on the debate that we've just had. There's a whole issue about the speed of the registration process. There's a real issue about a director of children's services allocating money to something that we all know is illegal. It just doesn't feel right under any way of looking at it. But I understand the pressures.

You talked about the pressures on you and you said it was a choice of last resort, and I totally, I do totally understand that. So I'm not challenging that, but it must be wrong to be allocating public money to an illegal, in an illegal way.

I wondered actually, just thinking aloud, Chair, and following the debate that my colleagues have, our colleagues have just raised, whether actually the problem is that Ofsted shouldn't be the registration agency. Ofsted should be an inspection agency. And that, and if you register something, how can you inspect it six months or a year later, because that's questioning your own decision. So I just wondered at least if it were possible to think through a local authority that is known to be a good local authority in this field being able to register homes itself, knowing that Ofsted will come in six months and a year, knowing that the Ofsted framework sets out what a good setting is meant to do.

So let's say West Sussex, you would be able to register a children's setting and Ofsted would say, well, sometime in the next six months or a year we'll inspect that, and you would know that when you made the registration, so you're not going to set it up if you think it will fail its inspection. And you might not give that power to local authorities that are of questionable quality. I just wonder if there's something there about increasing capacity by getting well-proven, good local authorities to be able to do their own registration, knowing that Ofsted will keep inspecting.

01:14:41 - 01:14:54

Rachael Wardell

I think you could formulate a way that that could work.

I do think the challenge would be around those local authorities who might be struggling and therefore wouldn't be allocated that power, but they might still have a problem with sufficiency.

01:14:54 - 01:15:14

Speaker 14

Yes, but if the good ones were doing it, that would leave more space for Ofsted. And if you took Ofsted out of it altogether, the regional care cooperatives could pick it up. Because Ofsted doesn't register schools. Ofsted inspects schools. DfE registers schools.

And that's a focused task. This is a muddle of registering and inspecting.

01:15:14 - 01:15:33

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

There was a policy around, a phrase around a while ago called earned autonomy. That if you could demonstrate that you were of sufficient quality, therefore you needed less people to look at things because you had earned that by how you operate.

01:15:33 - 01:15:37

Speaker 14

I think that was a phrase I wrote into the 1998 white paper.

01:15:37 - 01:15:41

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Excellent. And I'm old enough to remember it.

01:15:41 - 01:15:43

Speaker 36

And read it. I'm ready.

01:15:43 - 01:15:48

Speaker 38

No, Caroline, I won't have read it. You know me well enough, I don't read things. But I remember it.

01:15:48 - 01:15:51

Speaker 37

That's exactly what I'm talking about.

01:15:51 - 01:16:36

Lucy Butler

Can I make a slightly different point about unregistered provision?

Because I think it's often overlooked, but it is a really big issue. So most of the unregistered provision that is made, and it's exactly right, you know, it's a provision of last resort, is often one child in one home. And the rise of solo placements, for a better term, has risen exponentially over the last few years. And I think that's a real worrying trend. And I think that's partly fueled by matching, and when providers are judged to ill-match children, they will be penalized by Ofsted.

And that is a really big issue. And what are we doing to our children to kind of isolate them in this way? So I think, and it often gets lost in this debate, I think.

01:16:36 - 01:16:43

Speaker 1

Okay, that's a very helpful point. Thank you. Okay, Lord Maheed, is there anything else you want to ask?

01:16:43 - 01:16:45

Speaker 39

No, I think you've covered that.

01:16:45 - 01:16:49

Speaker 41

Okay, fine. So, Baroness Pigeon.

01:16:49 - 01:17:05

Caroline Pidgeon

Yes, I have to declare I'm Vice President of the Local Government Association. Just, actually, Lucy, on the point you made, what do you mean by solo placement? Can you just explain a bit more what sort of child would end up in that? The complexities, just to paint more of a picture for us.

01:17:05 - 01:17:49

Lucy Butler

I mean, it isn't just one sort of child, but it would usually be a child that needs support from more than one agency, so may have mental health needs, may have, you know, other needs that need that really intensive support. And or may present a risk to either themselves or others. And then that will be, you know, there'll be a kind of narrative that this child needs to be on their own, you know.

And we've seen that more and more, and I think it's a real worry. And I think there's something we've seen that as we've seen provision around children shift, so tier four beds decrease and etc, etc. So there's something about how do we as a system really support these children in a way that doesn't isolate them, in a way that enables them to really take part in their local community and live with their peers.

01:17:49 - 01:18:30

Caroline Pidgeon

I think I just wanted to get a picture, just so I could visualize the sort of circumstances and child. I wanted to pick up on fostering and foster care. And, you know, we know there's two thirds of children in care were fostered in 2024. So generally more children are fostered. What's your assessment of the recent announcement to recruit 10,000 new foster carers?

And what do you see, maybe we'll start with Gerald, what do you see front line, what are the barriers to recruiting and retaining as well, which we heard previously is really important, foster carers?

01:18:30 - 01:22:35

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

So I think it's important to remember we try to do things in levels. So if a, first of all, we try to make sure that kids stay at home. And when I was doing social work, parents and grandparents would come and say, look, can you look up, we can't cope with little Johnny, and we would say, no, I'm terribly sorry, they're your child. We'd try to give you help, but, but we're not taking them off you. So we try to keep kids at home.

And then we try to look at kinship care, other other members of the family who could who could look after. And then to fostering. And only after that do we try to residential. So fostering is enormously important, and I think every council in the country will have been doing recruitment drives for foster carers for the last 30 years without stopping. Because we always desperately need foster carers.

And it's a... and the foster carers provide a wonderful service. Places where we rely on the independent sector, it costs double what you'd pay pay if somebody is fostering directly through the council, so it costs a lot more.

But I think the bit that is most important is the support you give, because when I talk to foster carers who've stopped, it's that feeling, and because we're looking after children with higher and higher levels of need, who foster carers need more and more skills and more and more support. And sometimes councils are able to do that, or private agencies are able to do that, and sometimes they're not. It's very welcome to go and recruit and things to say we'll recruit 10,000 foster carers. We've been trying, we've had recruitment drives for decades, but if the government can put some welly behind it, great. I think the other thing is that the children who are fostered are different.

It used to be that you used to foster small kids. You don't very much anymore. It's teenagers, and as anybody knows, teenagers are at times stroppy and difficult. I'm thinking of myself, of course.

But it is more difficult, and they're bigger. So it is more difficult. But I think if we could crack the support levels we give to foster carers, I think that's great. There are ways in which councils are doing things differently. So councils investing through their budgets in extending people's homes is a really good way of trying to make sure that that works.

It doesn't always work. Sometimes you'll build someone an extra bedroom and then they'll stop being a foster carer a year later. But it all helps. So I think there are ways in which we can do it, but I doubt big bang is going to make a huge difference. I hope it does.

But I think overall our budgets are pushed and pushed and pushed. And the more and more of our budgets are being spent on the high end. So we spend less and less on preventative in comparison and more and more just in crisis management stuff. And I think we have to think about how foster carers operate. There have been some places that have thought of almost employing foster carers, and I'm not sure that's the right way to go because I think it changes the ethos a bit.

But if we can think of the support, that's really important.

But if we could do more to support and more to support kinship care, I think that could do an enormous amount of help to take some of the pressure off.

01:22:35 - 01:22:36

Speaker 43

Thank you, Rachael.

01:22:36 - 01:25:03

Rachael Wardell

Yeah, I mean, the barriers are interesting. So some of them are economic, and that varies obviously from part of the country to part of the country. So for some foster carers, there is an economic incentive to become a foster carer, but in other parts of the country, it's very challenging to think about giving up paid work to care. One of the things that we would say is you don't necessarily have to give up paid work to care. That can be a bit of a myth, but the teenagers that we're talking about often do need someone at home all day, as do very young children.

So that can be complex for families. There's some good news stories in there. One of the things that we have lost a lot of foster carers to over the years is staying put.

In other words, these are children who've grown up with their foster carers and have stayed with their foster carers into adulthood. It's a lovely outcome for that young person, but it does mean that that family isn't fostering anymore. So we've got to kind of really think hard about what the balance of sort of incentives and pragmatic offers is. Things that we can do to create more space in a family home are important. One of the economic impacts recently is that young adults, who are the birth children of potential foster carers, are staying home to much later in their lives.

And so the space that might have opened up that would have made fostering possible no longer does, because families have got, you know, 23-year-olds, 26-year-olds, maybe even 30-year-olds under their roof at home, and there isn't space for them. So all of these things form part of the mix.

There's also something about the type of fostering. So not just we're seeing more need in relation to adolescents, those young people are often in huge distress, you know, mental health issues. They may be a risk to themselves, which lots of people find very difficult to cope with. They are sometimes a risk to others and also that is very hard to deal with and respond to. So we need people with a very particular set of skills.

But also what we might need is something that is less permanent than fostering traditionally is and is more offered as a respite for for birth parents and for wider kinship networks, but just somewhere safe that young people can spend a bit of time which kind of relieves pressure in the family.

So I think, again, Lucy talked about overseas, you see more of those models in other countries, and it would be interesting to see what we can introduce within that sort of target of 10,000 that is more specialist.

01:25:03 - 01:25:09

Caroline Pidgeon

So Lucy, do you want to come on that and also I wrote down earlier you talked about end-to-end fostering, I don't know what that means.

01:25:09 - 01:25:54

Lucy Butler

Okay, okay. Okay, so just to add to what Rachael has said, so we are, we were lucky enough in the South East to attract some funding from the DfE to support foster carers to train therapeutically. So again, I think it should be rolled out nationally, actually, I think that all of our, it's a bit like what we were talking about residential care, what is the support and training that we offer foster carers? And I also think we could do more nationally to really celebrate foster carers, you know, like national exemption from council tax for instance, you know, are we doing enough really as a country to really say we really value you as a group of people and these are the things that we're going to absolutely guarantee for you to do. And sorry, I've just forgotten the extra question.

01:25:54 - 01:25:57

Speaker 44

Oh, end-to-end, sorry, I wrote it down because I thought it sounded like a...

01:25:57 - 01:26:21

Lucy Butler

Yes, so end-to-end is the new kind of policy for regional care cooperatives to support groups of local authorities to come together to do end-to-end foster care. It's a bit of a misnomer because it's pre-approval. It goes up to the pre-approval process, so from when a person might consider being a foster carer, makes contact with the local authority right through to when they get approved.

01:26:21 - 01:26:24

Caroline Pidgeon

Right, so it's the process for becoming.

01:26:24 - 01:26:25

Exactly right.

01:26:25 - 01:26:29

Speaker 46

It's not the process for the child. Sorry, I thought this was something, some other new thing that I'd missed.

01:26:29 - 01:26:34

Speaker 45

No, it is, that is the technical term that the government is using, but it doesn't quite describe what it says, I agree.

01:26:34 - 01:26:48

Caroline Pidgeon

Right, so it's about from getting an interest to becoming a foster carer, okay. And is there any other, I guess your work is far more, as we discussed earlier, that specialist residential than doing much in this fostering space?

01:26:48 - 01:27:16

Lucy Butler

No, we are doing things in fostering. So, you know, as I described, we're doing looking at what we need to do to support foster carers. For support for foster carers. And also to how we can support local authorities to work together more collaboratively. So we're overseeing things like quality assurance for local authorities, the kind of the media campaigns and things like that.

So and the data. So it's about what we're trying to do is lessen competition between local authorities and work together.

01:27:16 - 01:27:56

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Karen, one of the other things that's disappeared over time, not only have we lost placements for teenagers and children in mental health facilities, but councils used to, within their education things, often have residential places for maybe four nights a week for kids in special educational settings, so that they're only at home for three nights a week. And that kept youngsters out of the care system because they weren't at home all the time. But that's increasingly disappeared as well, so that those alternative provisions don't exist.

01:27:56 - 01:28:01

Speaker 48

Lovely, thank you.

01:28:01 - 01:28:03

Speaker 47

Okay, Baroness Redfern.

01:28:03 - 01:28:38

Speaker 19

I think that's me. We have talked about the social care workforce, the skill mix as such.

Can I just drill down to when I see we have 40% of 19 to 21 year olds not in education, training or employment? So I'm asking about the work, the social care workforce. Do they work with these children, helping them with their digital skills, etc., ready for leaving care?

01:28:38 - 01:28:41

Speaker 49

Rachel.

01:28:41 - 01:28:44

Rachael Wardell

Yes, I mean, the short answer to that is yes.

01:28:44 - 01:28:45

They are. Right.

01:28:45 - 01:29:39

Rachael Wardell

In as much as we've got a lot of duties to care leavers, to those young adults who are care experienced, and that does include supporting their education. And that may be at a number of different levels. So some of our care leavers are, you know, in university and being supported to kind of thrive in higher education.

But you're right, obviously they're overrepresented among young people not in education, employment, or training. And councils' wider workforce have dedicated roles that are looking at NEET prevention, so supporting young people into education, employment with training. And therefore there is a good focus on our care leaver population within that wider work around NEET. But you can see that the problem is that those numbers are growing, and so I don't think we've cracked the answer to that. There's more work to be done.

01:29:39 - 01:29:46

Speaker 19

When we see 40% NEETs compared to 15%, it's quite a large difference, isn't it?

01:29:46 - 01:31:18

Rachael Wardell

Yes, it is.

And it partly reflects the things that cause young people to be out of education or out of employment with training in the first place, which is to do with levels of educational engagement and achievement. So the more engaged a young person has stayed in education throughout their statutory education age, the more likely they are to go on to a good destination post-16. And so for some of these young people who may have had a very turbulent adolescence, they won't have stayed in school very much, they may not have achieved very high levels of qualifications, and therefore they've got an extra barrier to overcome. The capacity in local authorities to support those young people in that trajectory is in our virtual schools. So you'll hear talk of the virtual headteacher and the virtual school.

And that is where your population of children in the care of your local authority are treated as though they are a school population. And the virtual head and their team pay close attention to those young people's educational engagement and achievement.

Every child in care will have a PEP, a personal education plan. And that is focused on, you know, how they're doing currently and what will stretch them, what will support them. But that's a kind of journey that starts at a much younger age. And the work that we're doing is kind of trying to close that gap for them so they're less likely to be NEET when they arrive at adulthood.

01:31:18 - 01:31:23

Speaker 19

Will they be given their own laptops when they're older, you know, to help with the digital skills as such?

01:31:23 - 01:31:27

Rachael Wardell

Yes, I mean, it'll depend, every local authority will have its own scheme, but yes.

01:31:27 - 01:31:29

Speaker 50

Right, I see. Thank you, thank you, Chair.

01:31:29 - 01:31:35

Speaker 1

Does that plan include their future housing needs?

01:31:35 - 01:32:45

Rachael Wardell

So that's another challenging question.

So, obviously, care leavers in suitable accommodation is something that we are measured and assessed on. And I'd like to think even if we weren't being measured and assessed on it, we would care deeply about our young people leaving care and being in suitable accommodation. In unitary authorities, in metropolitan authorities, the housing function is part of the, part of the local authority. And so the good relations between the children's service and that housing authority, housing department, can help some young people find their feet easily. In two-tier local government, that's more difficult.

It's not impossible, but you have to kind of engage with all of the districts and boroughs in relation to their housing duties.

And it depends very much on the part of the country you're in and the access for all young people to affordable accommodation at that age. Anywhere where it's more challenging for young people generally to stand on their own two feet in independent living, it will be even harder for our care leavers. So it's a task that we take very seriously, but it's a struggle.

01:32:45 - 01:32:56

Speaker 1

It is a cliff edge as well, isn't it? Which, if you don't have that provision moving forward, it can be pretty disastrous for the individual.

01:32:56 - 01:34:56

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

And all of us have got huge pressure on our waiting lists from people. But actually just putting an 18-year-old into a flat on their own, you're setting people up to fail so often. So you've got to work it closely and sensibly. And I think the rule that says now we have a responsibility for care leavers up to the age of 25 is really good because it means that that cliff edge is less. And sometimes it works.

I have a care leaver who will be standing for the council. And because and she's really, really good. But then I've seen others and there are growing up in care and residential has different things and often unexpected things that mean it's less easy to get work.

So I talked to one young woman who's really articulate. She was chair of our children in care council. And when I was leader of the council, I met with them on a very regular basis because being a corporate parent is so important. Now, she'd lived in residential care for quite a while. And to try to make sure that young people didn't assault staff, there was a rule that if there's something that we would that that they would go to court.

So she's ended up having done something that in a family wouldn't have been great, but would have probably been survivable. She has a conviction for assault. She wanted to work in childcare, nobody would look at her. As an un and it wasn't a thought-through thing to say, oh, we're going to stop her prospects of being able to work in the area that she wants to do. But it's just a being in care, lots of different things collide in different ways and it's not easy.

01:34:56 - 01:35:08

Speaker 1

I mean, I absolutely agree. There's no point in having the housing without the support around it.

But also, if there isn't the home, you don't get the support anyway.

01:35:08 - 01:35:24

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

And you need to have home where your networks are, because these youngsters, their networks are often very fragile. And if anything we can do to make sure that those survive, that is really, really important.

01:35:24 - 01:36:19

Rachael Wardell

There's a couple of good projects that I could point to. So one is the House Project, and that is designed to support young people to be able to sustain a tenancy. So it works with an identified group of young people, really supports their independent skills. We've been running that in my local authority, and everyone who's been through that program has really, really benefited from the program and has sort of landed them safely in independence, you know, very well able to kind of to live independently at that point. So I would really flag that.

Another initiative that I've seen is group living. So it's not unusual obviously for young people to live in shared houses, but you can as a local authority commission that yourself, match your care leavers carefully with each other so they're not living in a shared house with strangers, but they're living in a shared house with other young care-experienced people and supported.

01:36:19 - 01:36:23

Speaker 51

I've just noted those. Thank you. Interesting.

01:36:23 - 01:36:52

Speaker 14

It's just a thought building on what Rachel's just said, which is over the last 10 or 15 years we've seen a massive expansion of businesses that provide student accommodation across cities like Guildford, I'm sure in Surrey and all over Exeter where I'm the Chancellor of the University, Unite and these companies. I wonder if there should be a dialogue with them about providing housing that isn't solo, that is for young people in a setting where there's lots of other young people.

01:36:52 - 01:37:15

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

So I, as I took the train from Portsmouth today, around the main train station are student halls of residence that will have rooms for 4, 5, 600 students at a time. What we need for people coming through the care process is really small.

01:37:15 - 01:37:22

Speaker 14

I'm thinking it could be designed in when they were being built, do you see what I mean, not thrown into the whole mix.

01:37:22 - 01:38:01

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

So I think it's easier just to buy a house, being blunt.

The people who, or people aren't building student accommodation anymore because they've probably built too much of it because there were tax breaks that made it easier for people to do that than building homes for families. So we've got a glut of it. I think they would be personally too big to build in. I think there are alternative ways of doing this that would work, which would work better.

01:38:01 - 01:38:17

Baroness Watkins

Could I just come in on this? We have asked another group whether within Section 108 there should be, you know, one three-bedroom with en suite that could be used in this way.

01:38:17 - 01:38:28

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Except so many developers don't do anything through section 106 because they say they're making less than 10% profit so they're not going to put anything in anyway.

01:38:28 - 01:38:34

Baroness Watkins

If we just take away the financial and political issues, would that be a good idea?

01:38:34 - 01:39:17

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Possibly. The bit that would really help local authorities would be for them to be able to say what sort of housing they wanted. So we don't all want masses of six-bedroom or five-bedroom places with three garages, but we're not allowed to do that. And I hope it's not me making noises. No, it's not.

That's all right.

So so that's so but the but the but the movement within planning regulation is to the exact opposite, to say that councils should be able to have less and less say over what is provided, not more and more.

01:39:17 - 01:39:48

Rachael Wardell

I'll hop in just to mention planning because I made a note to myself to mention it at some point. It's not easy to think of a recommendation in relation to planning for the reason that I alluded to earlier, which is in some places there are too many children's homes and so you wouldn't want a presumption that planning permission would be granted. But there are places where it is really difficult to get change of use agreed or to get planning permission to run a children's home, and in an area where there is a sufficiency issue, if the presumption were that that would be granted, that would be a huge help.

01:39:48 - 01:40:14

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Okay, having sat on a planning committee, I'm going to disagree. Having somebody come to our planning committee with a proposal for a children's home where we were not confident that the care given would be good, having a presumption in favor just gives people the ability... And the good ones will always get through. It's the rubbish ones that we have to be able to find ways of weeding out.

01:40:14 - 01:40:18

Speaker 52

Okay, we've noted your two positions on this. Thank you.

01:40:18 - 01:41:11

Magid Magid

Chair, can I just comment? I mean, there is this stigma attached as soon as you see a planning application and it's a care home. Straight away, it's seen as feral kids. They're going to... And I just have to say, Chair, from experience of being on the council for many, many years, you know, we've had people and, you know, we've, you know, Lord Scriven and myself had to fight in a ward that we both represented for the care home to reassure people.

And some of us actually had to be the corporate kind of parents attached to that home. And Lord behold, didn't get many issues, but it's the issue beforehand, the fears that people have or the perceptions, not the actual reality. But like I say, there is this problem that trying to convert it from a local authority point of view is a real challenge. Thank you. Baroness Hollins.

01:41:11 - 01:42:12

Sheila Hollins

Well, my question is about what you think the current priorities should be for Department for Education to improve outcomes for children in care. But first, there are a couple of interests I have which have come out of today's discussion. First, Rachael, you mentioned the Best Start program, so I should mention that my daughter works as a consultant to the local authority in Surrey, including on the Best Start program.

And secondly, my interests as a psychiatrist are kind of relevant because I chaired the oversight panel for young people and adults with learning disability and autism who were detained in long-term segregation. And so, knowing that care-experienced children are more likely to experience mental health difficulties and what you've been talking about in terms of children with complex needs, for myself, that is quite a large part of the context of the question.

01:42:12 - 01:43:52

Rachael Wardell

So, I mean, you've almost identified the priorities there for me because I think the single biggest issue probably would be getting the educational response right for children who are in care or who are on the edge of care.

So we see quite often that children who come into care, particularly in the adolescent years, have had fragmented or broken educational experience in the run-up to that. That's part of what made it impossible for them to stay at home. It can often disrupt foster care and even residential care. So if a child isn't in school when they enter care or doesn't have a school place quickly when they enter care, that drives further problems. Also, obviously, it impacts their educational outcomes and then you find them represented in the NEET figures, potentially unable to stay in employment or sustain employment into adulthood.

So all of those other negative outcomes are attached. So I think, I mean, there's very good kind of public health information that shows that the better education an individual has, the better it is for their life chances right across a spectrum of well-being outcomes.

So for our children in care, securing their education, I think, becomes the highest priority. And to just draw out the point that you made around autism and in parallel mental health issues, for a lot of our young people, it's kind of neurodivergence that kind of features in their personal history, and finding education that matches their neurodivergence is so important.

01:43:52 - 01:44:23

Sheila Hollins

And connected to that, a lot of the children in care may also have had a number of adverse childhood experiences, including exclusions from services, which complicates further their placement.

So again, I mean, in terms of priorities, you know, how does that work? I mean, I imagine that Lucy, the the work that you're doing might be kind of helpful in that respect.

01:44:23 - 01:44:48

Lucy Butler

I think I think we should incentivise whenever we can the joint working between health and social care to support children. I think that's essential for children children that we care for. And also the points that we were making earlier about training and development for the workers that are really supporting those children. I think we need to up our game to be honest and really think carefully about how we support this workforce.

01:44:48 - 01:46:36

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

So for me, I think I would say the ICBs were created to try to pull together health and social care.

And I think some of them are working, but a lot of them aren't. And coterminosity between social care and ICBs work well. I know in our area, because we've been pushed into a bigger ICB, the relationship between health and social care is much worse now, and cooperation is much worse. And actually having coterminosity would have been much better. I think the other bit, inevitably funding is going to is is an enormous issue.

And we are local authorities are will be facing bankruptcy in increasing numbers because of adults' and children's social care budgets. And there has to be an answer to that, and nobody is providing that that I can see.

And I think probably the last bit is is trying to work with work with schools about off-rolling where where increasing numbers of of children their parents are persuaded to remove them from schools. They're not permanently excluded but the parents are because persuaded that it's a good thing to take their child away. And that means that probably the most vulnerable children are losing out on education and ways in which it's possible for local authorities to have some influence over schools particularly secondary schools about things like off-rolling would be really helpful.

01:46:36 - 01:46:43

Speaker 53

That's really really helpful and and that's a growing issue.

01:46:42 - 01:46:48

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

Some people will say it isn't, but I think our experience is off-rolling is a big problem.

01:46:48 - 01:46:57

Speaker 1

But presumably that's exacerbated because local authorities have less influence over the strategic planning of their schools.

01:46:57 - 01:47:11

Gerald Vernon-Jackson

There is no strategic planning for education. It is completely atomized, and it would be quite nice if there was some strategic planning.

01:47:11 - 01:47:46

Speaker 1

Yes, absolutely. I take your point. On that note, are there any further questions? Can I thank all three of you for your very clear answers this morning and your forthright views, which are welcome.

And I hope we'll keep in touch as the inquiry unfolds and the information we've already asked, hopefully you'll be able to provide us with. And it's nice to see that your staff are getting younger. Yes.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.