House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Actual start House of Lords
Follow its sittingsThe Lord Ranger of Northwood
As well as for civil servants, the removal of DSIT has caused confusion in industry, and I declare my interest as a co-founder of the Business AI Alliance and an advisor to a number of AI businesses. All these businesses have said the same thing to me: where do they go now? Where are all these policy areas sitting? How can they navigate their way as they try to bring that key element of growth to the UK economy?
Speaker 2
As I said in my initial response to the noble Lord, Lord MP, we have a minister for AI at the cabinet table. We also have a new and renewed BIST, which has been created to signify the UK's global leadership in innovation and maximize the growth potential contributed by emerging strategic sectors.
This is part of our reindustrialization agenda. I am confident that BIST, which is now responsible for emerging and frontier technologies, that this will be part of their key work going forward.
Speaker 6
We have in recent weeks had yet more evidence of AI agents going rogue, including hacking websites and even sending a fake tip about a real crime to the US police. So can I ask not about overall headcount, but specifically what the impact of these changes will be on the headcount for AI regulation? Is that headcount going to go up, going to go down, or stay the same?
Speaker 2
The percentage of staff in digital and data roles is projected to increase to increase. We're clear that when we're looking at overall responsibilities and functions and roles within the civil service, we need to make sure that we're ready for the future opportunities, but as the noble Lord is clear, also the future threats. I had the pleasure of going to talk to AC last week, and I was really impressed by the caliber of civil servant there and the work they're doing to protect and us and to build a rigorous scientific understanding, both of the capabilities but also of the risks associated with AI.
Timothy Kirkhope
Although the minister's remarks seem perfectly reasonable although rather difficult to understand, can she perhaps indicate to the House precisely how many people and what categories of people will be working with the minister who now has cabinet position?
Speaker 2
So I'm unclear of exactly how I'm going to come up with an exact figure for somebody who covers across government function albeit he will have teams such as AC who are working specifically with him. I can't stress enough that this government sees AI as so crucial that we have a cabinet level minister who has responsibility for drawing all these threads together and for making sure that we are well equipped both to get the opportunities that are presented but also the well-documented risks associated with AI.
Daniel Moylan
A number of civil servants, paid as civil servants, are in fact working for trade unions. Has the government considered prioritizing replacing them with AI?
Speaker 11
My Lords, we're concentrating a lot on the impact of AI on outside industry. To what extent is the civil service looking at using AI in its own internal operations and particularly what impact will it have now on the increased headcount that we had post-COVID?
Speaker 2
We've got a huge amount of work going across government in terms of making sure that we use AI to its potential, from everything from the Department of Health looking at how they're going to use it in a cutting-edge AI trial to transform cancer care, albeit that that's within the health service. We're confident that AI is going to improve public services and boost productivity, everything from identifying fraud and potential fraud through to making sure that we've got automated policy analysts and AI tutoring tools. We're rolling out AI tools that are going to save time and money and get the most effective civil service for the public.
Speaker 12
My Lords, headcount is irrelevant. What the real issue is, is the outcomes and the outputs that the department delivers.
So could I ask, in closing the department down, what will now be able to be done more efficiently and for those in industry and for the country?
Speaker 2
So I'm going to repeat myself again with apologies to your lordship house. Honestly, the UK is such, I mean the whole world, it's not just the UK, is it? The whole world is at such a critical juncture in related to the rapid increase and rapid development in AI science and technology. I do, I do understand on one level why people think, well, we'll put it all in one department and one box.
But actually, putting it across government and making sure we've got somebody who is driving that progress across government is critical in our view to making sure that this is embedded and part of everybody's work across every department and rather than sitting in DSIT.
The Baroness Finn
Between 2010 and 2016, under the coalition and Conservative governments, the civil service headcount fell by 21%, while we simultaneously set up the award-winning Government Digital Service in 2011. Despite this government's repeated pledges to reduce headcounts, the numbers have risen by 2% since they took office in 2024. So can the noble Baroness the Minister say whether ministers at any point approved that increase?
Speaker 2
You'd have to ask the previous Conservative government, which saw an increase from 2016 to of 140,000 civil servants.
So we can have a discussion about the numbers, but actually while that might be true of the coalition government, it definitely wasn't true of the Conservative government that followed.
Speaker 15
Before the noble lady asks her question, can I just remind the house that the first supplementary question should take no more than 45 seconds, all remaining questions should be no more than 30 seconds, and responses should be also of similar length.
Speaker 17
I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name, and I deeply resent that I'm one of the shortest speakers in the house.
Sue Hayman
I don't think the I don't think the chief whip's comments were personally meant.
My Lords, reservoir operations must comply with water framework directive objectives. Water companies are required to follow the drinking water safety planning approach and must assess risks to drinking water from the water source it is taken from until it reaches consumers at the taps. The planned raw water sources to supply the Havant Thicket reservoir have been monitored and mitigations have been proposed where required, including for emerging substances.
Speaker 17
I thank the noble lady the minister for her answer. I'm deeply unsatisfied with it, however, because I assume that it's Southern Water itself that's actually monitored and checked the sewage effluent that it's going to be putting into Havant Thicket reservoir. We need a reservoir, we desperately need more water sources, but at the same time you can't trust Southern Water to audit its own discharges.
So please, could the government do what they're doing in other countries like Singapore and actually create an expert panel to audit exactly what's going into that water supply? Because these forever chemicals that I've referred to are highly poisonous and pernicious.
Sue Hayman
Well, the noble lady mentions Singapore, and I think it's important to say that water recycling is used widely around the world, not just in Singapore, but in Australia, the USA, and in Belgium. And Southern Water is just one of the companies that are developing water recycling plants for the future. But it's also important to say that the project's going to use highly treated recycled water that's been through a series of very strict treatment and quality checks before it would enter the Havant Thicket Reservoir. And water stored in the reservoir would then go through further treatment and testing before being supplied as drinking water.
And specific concerns around Southern Water, the noble lady is happy to raise with me out of this question.
Ilora Finlay
Following Michael Sheen's documentary showing that there are polychlorinated biphenyls dumped at 14 sites across the UK, some of which are near Newport and Cardiff, what action is the government taking to detect high levels of contamination both in drinking water and in farm produce?
Sue Hayman
Well, the Environment Agency does work closely of course with a range of UK and international bodies to understand the different sources, because it's really important we understand where PFAS is coming from so we can actually have a proper risk-based approach to assessing and managing risks.
And that work is helping to inform the design requirements for additional water treatment schemes, such as the one that we are discussing. But also, the Defra has made a commitment to protect public health and the environment while supporting innovation and economic growth. And this is part of how we're going to work together in order to manage PFAS contamination.
Anne McIntosh
clean, but also that ideally they should be full. Yorkshire last week on Friday officially entered a drought status due to low water levels in reservoirs and rivers. I know the noble lady believes that there should be more reservoirs, particularly more smaller reservoirs.
What can she and her department do to remove the barriers to creating more smaller reservoirs being built?
Sue Hayman
Well, the noble lady makes a really important point, and I think this year's drought has really demonstrated that we need better ways in which we can hold water, particularly on farm, so that we can manage resilience of food security going forward. And Defra is very, very cognizant of this. We are working hard and with the Farmers Union, for example, around what can we do to increase food security, and obviously holding water on farm is part of that.
Speaker 20
Does the minister accept that some of the underlying issues in this oral question are precisely why we need the long-promised Clean Water Bill, or whatever it's now going to be called, including urgent statutory protection for chalk streams? What immediate safeguards will apply before that legislation arrives, and she expressed a lot of urgency about that previously, and when, oh when, will the bill be published?
Sue Hayman
Well, I can't give the noble lady a date of when the bill's coming, but it is something that we are working on very hard at the moment because it's really important that we do bring it forward. We know there's a lot of anticipation around it, but also it's a very important bill. And again, the noble lady mentioned chalk streams. Building reservoirs is actually a really important part of how we protect chalk streams going forward.
We need to stop the amount of abstraction that's that's taking place and reservoir building is one of the reasons why it's important if we are to reduce the need to take water from very sensitive environments.
Speaker 21
My Lords, is it the case that the farmers and farmers and golfers are use a lot of water that's inefficiently used and don't we need to do more to encourage them to be more effective?
Sue Hayman
Well, I think one of the really difficult questions around around drought is who actually has access to water. Golf courses I think use an enormous amount of water and there were some issues with some water companies and golf courses earlier this year. It is really an issue for the water companies and industry to sort amongst themselves, but clearly if there is a particular issue then government will step in.
Chris Grayling
Accept that if our system for supporting agriculture was adjusted so that there was a proper biodiversity margin between agricultural land and rivers, we would significantly reduce the amount of effluent flowing from that land into rivers and improve river quality?
Sue Hayman
Well, I totally agree with the noble lord because that's actually something I've done myself through a catchment sensitive farming grant. And you can get grants like that. We actually fenced off our river to stop the cattle going down to it, to stop that kind of pollution going in, and have planted alongside again to stop that pollution. So you can get catchment sensitive grants to look at things like that. And I think it's important that we encourage people to apply for them.
Speaker 23
My lords, that is a sticking plaster for as long as we are mixing industrial waste into sewage waste so that the PFAS are still coming through into the water in the runoff from the fields.
What would the Minister say to that?
Sue Hayman
Well, clearly, we need to resolve as much as we can the pollution of PFAS into our waterways, into our streams. And, you know, the government has brought forward a strategy around PFAS. We have to look at how we tackle this. We're also looking at the best ways of monitoring and also looking at the sources of where it comes from, because if we don't fully understand where it's coming from, we can't fully tackle it. But we're absolutely working very hard in Defra to manage that.
Speaker 24
May I begin by stating that I have deep respect for the noble lady, Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb, for however long she speaks.
For about 40 years, she's campaigned dutifully for mainstream green and environmental issues, and sometimes I've often found myself in agreement with her. But I must say that I've got nothing but contempt for the current Green Party leader, who in my opinion is a despicable piece of work and not fit to have any role in public life in this country. Now, Minister, regulations. A simple one. Our current regulatory framework is too fragmented and our regulators too unaccountable to deal effectively with these issues raised today, as we've all seen with Environment Agency and its failure to stop massive rubbish dumps in protected landscapes.
So what is the government doing to review Defra's 34 arms-length bodies, as we're proposing, to bring infrastructure project delivery and nature recovery under more direct ministerial control?
Sue Hayman
Well, I'm sure the noble Lord is aware, as will many noble Lords be aware, that we carried out the Corry report, the review, in order to look at how the different arms-length bodies in DEFRA work, not just in the water industry, but right across the board. We need to work better, we need to stop things falling through the cracks, we need to make sure that regulators do what we want them to do, what they need to do. It shouldn't just always be focused around finances, environment should also be always taken into account, and we're working very hard to make things more efficient and work more effectively.
Speaker 17
First of all, I'd like Lord Benyon to withdraw half of his comments in Hansard. And I would like to say to the noble lady the Minister, I still haven't heard a way forward on this. These chemicals are highly dangerous and there is no regulation at the moment to actually cover them.
And we cannot, I repeat this, we cannot trust Southern Water. Its Budds Farm wastewater treatment works was found in research conducted by the Marine Conservation Society to be releasing forever chemicals into the environment via their treated effluent. You can't keep allowing this. You've got to put in regulation.
Sue Hayman
I think there's two things I would say to the noble lady. First of all, the scheme, as she said, is going to take treated wastewater from Budds Farm wastewater treatment works. It will purify it to a high standard at a new water recycling plant before it's transferred to the reservoir. The water stored in the reservoir, as I said before, would subsequently be abstracted and conveyed to the Otterbourne water supply works for treatment and supply to customers. And that would create a new drought-resilient source of water for the wider region, which is desperately needed.
I would also say, we get asked all the time, why is it taking you so long to build reservoirs? Why haven't you started one of the new nine reservoirs you want? When are you going to complete it? Why has it been delayed? Part of the reason we have a problem building new reservoirs in this country is when we try, nobody wants them.
Evans
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Jane Sharon Taylor
My Lords, devolution reforms will give mayors and strategic authorities greater powers to support housing delivery within a national framework, enabling them to direct housing investment to reflect their local housing needs.
Housing targets are an important tool to make sure that sufficient housing is delivered in the right places, and the government has no plans to amend the standard method for assessing housing need introduced in December 2024.
Evans
My Lords, I'm grateful to the Minister for her, for her helpful response there. Not all of us share her optimism, unfortunately. And I know as a former Deputy Mayor of London, I was disappointed to learn that Taylor Wimpey, a major housebuilding developer, have pulled out of any further projects in London recently. Their chief executive stated as an explanation, 'the reward for undertaking development in London has evaporated'.
Does the Minister share my concern and how does she expect the government that's promised affordable housing to buy and rent to be able to provide housing when they're making it unaffordable to build?
Jane Sharon Taylor
I don't think it's this government that's making housing unaffordable to build. There are a number of factors affecting that, but I accept the point that there is an urgent need for more housing, especially social and affordable housing, and particularly in London. And that's why we're acting to address this because in March, the government and the Greater London Authority confirmed a package of temporary emergency measures providing targeted support for house builders to improve the viability that the noble Lord spoke of and to get quicker approvals on new housing schemes.
And we're also making major longer-term investment, including that social and affordable homes program that I've spoken about many times in this chamber, with up to 11.7 billion pounds for London and 1.5 billion from the new low-interest loan scheme for social and affordable housing.
Speaker 25
My lords. My lords. Lord Campbell-Savours is taking part remotely. I invite Lord Campbell-Savours to speak.
Dale Campbell-Savours
My lords, under the Devolution Act, mayors have new powers to unlock land for housing. So can we go further by giving local authorities and mayors the ability to reach housing targets through the acquisition of land for housing at agricultural prices, as in the case of the Vinex-wijk in Holland and Hammarby in Sweden housing development zones? An issue I've repeatedly raised in the house. We need some new radical thinking.
Jane Sharon Taylor
My noble friend has indeed raised this issue of land supply many times. The English Devolution Community Empowerment Act does strengthen mayoral housing and planning powers, including powers relating to planning applications of potential strategic importance, mayoral development orders, and a mayoral community infrastructure levy. And alongside the Planning and Infrastructure Act, it also supports the new framework for spatial development strategies. And we continue to look at issues around land supply and creative and innovative ideas. We continue to look across Europe and elsewhere for ways that we might help our mayors and our leaders to develop on the land that they need to develop.
Speaker 29
My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, I welcome this shift to local government deciding what the housing needs are. I live in the area of Tower Hamlets where there's about 28,000 people on the social housing waiting list. Would noble lady the minister say how the government designated data centers critical national infrastructure will affect some of the housing decisions? And I hope the ministers will ensure that a data center in Brick Lane is not built because it's going to impact mass housing crisis and also the well-being of children and families.
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, it's very important across the planning system and the noble lady raises an important issue around how we balance the need for our economic infrastructure, of which data centers are an increasingly important part, and we just had a whole debate earlier around AI. We can't operate AI without data centers, but that has to be balanced, of course, with the need for housing. And this government is committed to the streamlined planning system that's plan-led, pro-growth, accessible and understandable to all, and does deliver as far as is possible that balance. And we work with our colleagues in DEFRA as well around the land use framework to make sure we are taking account of all of the needs for land.
Dorothy Thornhill
My Lords, currently Whitehall sets the targets, mayors determine the strategy, and planning officers at a very local level are taking even more decisions under delegated powers. So my question to the noble lady the minister is, could she explain exactly what's left for locally elected councillors to determine, and how is this felt to strengthen local democracy in the eyes of that local community, which is where I think the tension at the heart of the noble lord's original question originates?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, I think it was clear that the previous system of not having any housing targets was not delivering the housing that we need. We continue to think that the best way for councillors and communities to engage in the development process for their areas through the local plan process, which will be agreed by the council. We're not changing the consultation rules on planning applications.
Representations are considered by the decision maker, whether that's an officer taking the decision or a planning committee. And it's vital that in exercising that democratic oversight, planning committees operate as effectively as possible, focusing on those applications which require member input, while placing trust in skilled planning officers in local authorities, making sure they decide applications more quickly in the service of residents and businesses.
Speaker 31
If you take London as an example, the Mayor of London has failed to deliver housing over a 10-year period. So which powers would the government retain in order to make sure that local authorities and mayors actually build the homes we need?
Do not devolve this power and devolve the responsibility along with it.
Jane Sharon Taylor
I've already set out the steps the government's taking to work with colleagues in London to accelerate house building in London. There has been a significant increase in applications already and through the City Hall Developer Investment Fund and the New Homes Accelerator, we are providing support to accelerate stalled schemes and we are driving housing-led regeneration on nationally significant sites like Euston. And we continue to make sure that we work with the Mayor's office to deliver the housing that London needs.
Richard Stuart Best
My Lords, can I ask the noble Baroness the Minister about the devolution to mayors and combined authorities of the power to set up development corporations? These have huge potential as in the London Legacy Development Corporation. They're going to be really great, but they're going to need some seed corn, some setting up funding. Will government provide that so we can see more of these wonderful development corporations?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well, the noble lord will be aware I'm a big fan of development corporations. We've had many discussions about them. And he's quite right that there is some need for capacity. And in August this year, the Prime Minister announced measures to strengthen the capacity and capability of mayoral strategic authorities as part of the government's wider devolution agenda. So measures like civil service secondments to mayoral offices, a place-based fast stream pilot, support for digital and data capability, and expansion of leadership development opportunities between central and local government.
It's very important that we support areas like Liverpool, and I went to have a meeting with them recently about their mayoral development corporation. Very exciting work, delivering 17 and a half thousand homes and 5 million square feet of commercial space. We need to give them every support in the capacity to deliver that.
Speaker 34
The London Borough of Lewisham have estimated that these regulations increase build costs by 15%. What is the government doing to cut the costs of building and of buying a home?
Jane Sharon Taylor
Well we continue to work with people across the construction sector to look at the issues but it's very important we don't want to go through another Grenfell. We don't want to have issues around poor quality build in the future. So again this is an issue of balance. We must absolutely get the balance right so we introduce the regulation we need to make sure that people's homes are safe, that they're affordable, that they're warm and that people aren't going to, we're not going to have the sort of disasters we've seen in the past.
But, of course, affordable is very much part of that equation, and this is all about balance.
My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, does the government have any policy to counter the land banking by the large companies?
Well, we have, we have looked extensively at how we urge building to take place, and we have got our Homes Accelerator now, which is helping to move some of these sites forward where development has been stalled. So, I'm sure that will contribute to delivering the housing that we all want to see. I think there's a focus right across our department and the team to make sure that we've taken the steps on planning, we've taken the steps on regulation, and now we are moving into the delivery phase, and we've seen a 15% increase in starts already this year.
Jack McConnell
My Lords, I beg leave to ask the question standing in my name on the order paper.
Speaker 36
My Lords, the quickest way to get diesel back onto world markets is a full energy ceasefire with both sides, Ukraine and Russia, stopping attacks. We therefore welcome President Trump's call for a reciprocal energy ceasefire and President Zelenskyy's readiness to implement it once a start date is confirmed. The Prime Minister reiterated his complete solidarity with Ukraine and our determination to strengthen sanctions on Russia when he spoke to President Zelenskyy on Saturday ahead of further talks in London today.
Jack McConnell
I'd like to thank my noble friend the Minister and the Prime Minister for their strong words of solidarity with President Zelenskyy and the people of Ukraine. And I'm sure that members across your Lordships' House will today welcome President Zelenskyy to London and express full solidarity with him in this very difficult week for him and his people. The coalition of the willing was established to provide diplomatic and material support for the Ukrainian government and the people of Ukraine in this constant fight for their sovereignty. The coalition includes most European countries, but also of course Japan, Australia, New Zealand and Canada.
Can the minister say what the government is doing to look at expanding the coalition in these challenging circumstances to involve more countries in providing that material and diplomatic support, and what is being done at the moment to mobilize the coalition to support Ukraine through what is going to be a very difficult winter ahead?
Speaker 36
Well, I thank the noble friend for that question and I'd like to also reiterate what he said about how welcome President Zelenskyy is today. I had the privilege of greeting him in fact on his arrival in central London and he'll be having discussions with the Prime Minister later on. And my noble friend's also right that the coalition of the willing, I mean it serves a number of functions. It serves the primary function as a noble lord said, of my noble friend said, of providing military support. Pleased to say that under both Conservative and Labour governments in the last four and a half years, we've provided over twenty-five billion pounds of support.
The coalition also provides budgetary support for Ukraine's finances, which have been catastrophically affected by the conflict.
It provides constant diplomatic support. But it also thinks ahead to a world in which security guarantees will be needed and looks to think about arrangements for that. As for expanding the coalition of the willing, my noble friend is right. There is scarcely a meeting I or the Foreign Secretary have in which we do not talk about the help that existing members of the coalition and prospective members can provide, and that will continue to be a theme of our discussions.
Malcolm Bruce
This deal is outrageous and it's unnecessary because the President is actually lifting sanctions on Russia and threatening new sanctions on Ukraine.
So no wonder the United States Foreign Relations Committee in the Senate said the United States should not provide Putin with a financial lifeline while Russia continues to kill Ukrainian civilians. So will the British government meeting President Zelenskyy in London today not only repeat that we stand foursquare behind Ukraine but are angered and dismayed that the White House is acting for Putin?
Speaker 36
I thank the noble Lord for that question. We will certainly be reiterating and have reiterated already unquestioning and continuing support for Ukraine, military, budgetary, diplomatic and other kind of support. As my friend the Defence Secretary said on Sunday, this is a choice that we've made different choices.
We think that the approach to Russia has to be consistently, and I'm pleased to say across the coalition and the world more broadly, has to be consistently focused on exerting pressure through sanctions and other kinds of pressure in order to force Russia to the table that President Zelenskyy's already said he's prepared to go to to discuss a ceasefire and future arrangements.
Mark Harper
The Minister is right in saying there's cross-party support for supporting Ukraine and President Zelenskyy, and I'm happy to reiterate mine for that. Can I ask him a question? European Union, there are still European countries, I understand, that are purchasing gas from Russia. Does the Government have any plans at the summit that it's having in November with the European Union to raise this issue and see what and take steps to persuade those countries that purchasing gas from Russia is helping to fund its military campaign against Ukraine?
Speaker 36
Well, I thank the noble Lord for that question. He puts his finger on an extremely important point.
And again, it's something in my short time so far at the Foreign Office I've seen an extreme amount of attention focused on continuing economic relationships, not just in Europe but elsewhere in Central Asia and elsewhere. It's something that the Foreign Office and government more broadly takes very seriously. We have a variety of tools we try to use to put pressure on and encourage countries to reduce their economic relationship with Russia. The EU-UK summit in late November is primarily about the UK's relationship with the European Union in the light of the Brexit treaty and arrangements for that. But I can assure him that the issue he raises is something that's at the forefront of desks across the Foreign Office and their relationships with multiple countries.
Speaker 40
Does the noble Lord the Minister agree with me that the President of the United States, a country which prizes and fought for its own independence, could indeed leave a genuine positive legacy as a peacemaker if, instead of doing business deals with Russia's current regime, he sought a peace in Ukraine that does not involve simply handing over that country to a terrorist state bent on colonizing its neighbors? A one-word answer will suffice.
Speaker 36
Okay. Is that a word? It's inconceivable in my view that a peace which we all desperately want in this conflict will occur without the full engagement of the United States. And I think encouraging the United States to play that positive role and to continue many of the positive contributions they've made to securing that peace is an important thing for all parties in this conflict.
Martin Callanan
My Lords, across this House we have maintained an important consensus on the need for us all to stand fully behind Ukraine, and I agree with the noble Lord's comments and the Prime Minister's comments on the need for further sanctions against Russia. However, on the 26th of March, Keir Starmer announced that he had given approval for Russia's shadow fleet tankers to be seized if they transit through UK waters, and this was widely welcomed. Since then, we have intercepted a grand total of one from the dozens which have transited the English Channel. Can we expect some more robust action from this new government in halting these uninsured and dangerous vessels?
Speaker 36
Well, I thank the noble Lord for that question, and he's right to point to the importance of disrupting the shadow fleet. But I'm pleased to say the UK is playing a very leading role in doing precisely that. By some estimates, Putin has spent over 14 billion dollars in establishing the shadow fleet.
We have now specified over 640 vessels under the Russia sanctions regime, including over 600 oil tankers and 20 liquefied natural gas carriers. There is much more to be done, there is more that will be done, and there is more that will be done to encourage other nations to have the courage to do what we did. But this is at the center of the leading thinking about effective responses to Russia, and the UK is proud to be in the vanguard of that.
Speaker 42
My Lords, I serve on the Council of Europe Parliamentary Network on the situation of children in Ukraine. The Russians have deported 20,651 children from Ukraine, occupied Ukraine, to Russia. They're told they're now Russians, they're made to learn Russian, and they're being offered up for adoption by Russian families. Older teenagers are put into training camps in preparation for taking part in military action against Ukraine. So can I ask my noble friend for help?
Will the government remind our American friends of this before they make any deals like the one we're talking about today?
Speaker 36
Well, I'm very glad my noble friend has raised this issue. I was in Ukraine three weeks ago and visited an organisation that focuses on tracing and trying to bring about the judicial proceedings to bring back stolen children. The number is probably actually greater than 20,000. It's extraordinarily heartbreaking to see these stories and it's extraordinary work that these organisations and the Ukrainian President's office is doing. I was in Toronto last week at an international conference precisely on the issues of detained Ukrainian civilians and stolen children, because that's what they are, children that have been stolen from their families and forced into adoption throughout Russia.
There was a 60 or 70 countries that signed pledges and committed to further budgetary and other kinds of support, and we are going to continue to encourage all nations to put this at the forefront of their thinking about the Ukraine conflict.
Jeremy Purvis
The government put forward an open-ended exemption on its sanctions against refined oil products from Russia. This now could potentially include products imported via the United States under this deal from America. Under pressure from these benches, the government, Stephen Doughty wrote to me on the 11th of June saying that there was now a sunset clause on that extension for the 1st of January, and we welcomed that. Can the Minister be absolutely clear to the House that even if there's pressure from Trump's administration, that sunset clause will not be altered and we will ensure that there's a full and comprehensive ban of this Russian refined oil products in the UK?
Speaker 36
I thank the noble Lord for this, for the question.
It's something he's focused on before and he's right to focus on it. I'm not going to discuss the details of individual sanctions, obviously. Sanctions policy is an extremely complex, crucial but extremely complex area, partly complex because of reimportation, redesignation and relabeling, and partly complex because sanctions measures incentivize countries to get around those sanctions measures through further arrangements. So our sanctions policy has to remain vigilant to both the flows and also innovation in the ways in which countries get around sanctions. I can assure him, without mentioning specifics, that that will remain at the heart of how we approach this.
Speaker 44
My Lords, that concludes oral questions for today. Those who wish to leave the chamber might do so now quickly and quietly.
Speaker 45
My Lords, Courts and Tribunals Bill, I beg to move that this bill be now read a first time.
Speaker 46
The question is that this bill be now read a first time. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content, the contents have it. My Lords, we now come to some instruments previously debated in Grand Committee, Code of Practice on Access and Unfair Practices during the Recognition and Derecognition Process and one other motion, Lord Lyon.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, with leave of the House, I beg to move the motions standing in my name on the order paper en bloc.
Speaker 46
The question is that the two motions in the name of Lord Long be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. We now come to Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026 and two other motions, Lord Wilson of Sedgefield.
Wilson
My Lords, I beg to move that the motions standing in my name on the order paper, I beg to move that they be moved en bloc.
Speaker 46
The question is that the three motions in the name of Lord Wilson of Sedgefield be agreed to en bloc. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content.
The contents have it. We now come to questions on an answer to an urgent question asked in the House of Commons yesterday on the early release scheme, and we start with the front benches.
Richard Keen
My Lords, when discharging more and more criminals before completion of their prison sentence, one simple measure of public protection would be electronic tagging. We know that the government has failed to implement this measure, with many of these criminals leaving prison early without a tag.
Will the noble Lord the Minister advise how many of the latest cohort of 600 criminals were released without a tag, and will he undertake that any further criminals who are released early will be electronically tagged before they leave prison?
Speaker 45
My Lords, we inherited a failing tagging system with record backlogs, but since 2024 we've been working hard to fix this and the install rates are up nearly 50% since 2024. We're also investing 100 million in electronic monitoring, tagging offenders before release and strengthening victim protections via new alert systems. All of this helps us to cut the number of unmonitored offenders and protect victims, and we are confident that we have enough equipment and Serco field resource to deliver. The situation has improved. Our quarterly electronic monitoring statistics include figures for the number of prison leavers fitted with tags, and the next quarterly update will be published in October.
Speaker 50
My Lords, I think the party opposite... Oh, sorry, I'm sorry, I'm really sorry.
Sal Sarah Brinton
The noble Lord. I wanted to follow on from Lord Keen's question about tagging. Other countries quite often tag prisoners before they leave or actually at the prison gates. I wanted to raise one other global example which worked really well, which doesn't relate to prisoners, but Taiwan introduced tagging for people having to isolate at home during the COVID inquiry very, very quickly by using local resources, and it worked very successfully.
Will the government undertake to look at both the issue that Lord Keen raised about prisoners being tagged before they leave, but also looking at innovative ways of making this work across the country?
Speaker 45
Of course the government will, as the noble lady and the whole House knows from the discussions on the Sentencing Act, we've introduced a presumption that offenders released early will be tagged, and we have a range of tagging options at our disposal: curfew tags, alcohol tags, and GPS tags. I'm interested in what she said about Taiwan. I didn't know about it. But look, the situation is clear. I think we all understand it.
It wasn't a good situation with tagging. We are improving it, but it is clearly a central aspect of how we're going to manage the criminal justice system in the future.
George Foulkes
My Lords, can I clearly apologize to the noble lady for jumping the gun?
My Lords, I think the party opposite are proposing, if they were ever returned to power, to create 50,000 new prison places. As I understand it, in 14 years they only created 400, no, 500 new prison places and closed 23 prisons. Could, is the minister aware of what miracle solution Lord Keen and his colleagues have found?
Speaker 45
Well, I do believe in miracles, I'm a Catholic. But even I think 50,000 is a lot. But we are undertaking the largest prison build program since the Victorian era. And in December 2024, this government published our plan to create 14,000 additional places. And I want to say this, I don't think I've said this from the dispatch box before on this subject.
We've already delivered through new prisons, the expansion and refurbishment of the existing estate and temporary accommodation 3,300 places. So we have made a substantial impact on prison place supply. My noble friend is right that under the Conservative government, there was a net increase of only 500 places in 14 years. And indeed, they were responsible for closing 23 prisons. As for the 50,000 new places that the leader of the opposition has promised, seeing will be believing.
Speaker 53
So now, how many newly released prisoners have been tagged? And we also want to know how many have been returned to prison having committed an offense. We're not getting that information from the government at the moment.
Is the explanation for that failure either that they don't have the information or they choose not to give it? And if the latter, why?
Speaker 45
Neither of those are the explanation. As I've already said, we do quarterly release figures both on tagging and on reoffending, and we shall continue to do that. That is the government's position.
Speaker 54
My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, I think, my Lords. Have the government conducted any assessment of how many additional serious crimes are likely to be committed as a result of the early release scheme?
Speaker 45
It is very early days for the early release scheme, and I do want to make one thing clear.
There is a great deal of confusion in the public debate about early release schemes. There have been a succession of early release schemes under the previous government and indeed we in this government had two early release schemes because there were less than a hundred prison places. The early release scheme we are now engaged in is part of the earned progression model, which is a new approach to sentencing that came out of the Gove review, which we discussed at length in the proceedings of the Sentencing Act. This is not just early release to reduce prison numbers. This is a considered policy approach which we put through the Sentencing Act.
We've made lots of assessments and debated them, but it is very early days for this new model and I don't think the noble Lord would expect me to quote numbers after such a short period.
Speaker 56
My Lords, I declare my interest as a trustee of the Clink Charity. We work both inside and outside prisons, helping prisoners prepare for release. With prisoners being released now often at very short notice under these schemes, they're coming out very ill-prepared. I wonder if the government have made an assessment of what additional preparation needs to be made and how that can be done to allow prisoners to adjust to life outside without reoffending.
Speaker 45
I thank the right reverend prelate for that question and I know he has been deeply involved in this area of work.
I know it's not good to disagree with bishops, but I'm going to if I may. I wouldn't accept the characterization that people are ill-prepared. What we have done in this round of these early releases under the own progression model is do it in tranches over ten phases. What we did on the last early release scheme, which was so urgent, was release more people in only two tranches. So I think we are doing a great deal to prepare people for release and working with the probation service.
It is much better planned, it is much better delivered, and I expect that to have a considerable benefit.
Speaker 57
My Lords, these early releases, thank you, my Lords, these early releases are putting huge pressure on the probation services as we're already well aware, suffering badly after the last government's failings. The workloads are high and it's reflected in the resignations.
Doesn't the noble Lord the Minister agree that these outstanding public servants should be paid properly for the job that they do, and we should do everything we can to make sure that their ballot for strike action really doesn't have to take place? Thank you.
Speaker 45
The situation for probation, as I've discussed many times before on this, from this dispatch box, we are asking a lot of probation and we're asking more under our new model, particularly the second phase of the intensive supervision. We've invested 700 million. We are onboarding a number of new probation officers, 1,300 this year. But on the question that my noble friend raises, we certainly hope there won't be industrial action and we are working to reduce the workload of probation officers and we've committed to achieving that.
But you know, I don't want to be under any, I don't want to leave your Lordships under any illusions. Building a viable probation service which is bigger and better than the one we had before and indeed the one we inherited is a key priority in making our new approaches to sentencing effective.
Speaker 58
The prison crisis is that for the last 30 years, governments of all parties trying to prove they're tough on crime have encouraged ever more people being sentenced to prison sentences for longer and longer periods, so that I think we have now the highest incarceration rate in Europe. And I think the average sentence is about double what it was when I was Justice Secretary 30 years ago and probably more than that compared with the distant past when I practiced at the criminal bar.
Now the the government is now going to build more prisons. If it insists on doing that, could it actually use the space in the prisons to devote more time to rehabilitation because the public would be better served if we put more effort in, had more space in which to put the effort to reduce reoffending when they're released so that we have fewer victims of future crime. Meanwhile, despite our policy, the rate of serious crime in this country has never been lower and has been falling for the last 30 years as it also has in countries which have reduced their sentencing policies just like the Netherlands.
Speaker 45
And I entirely agree with what what the noble lord has said about the way in which sentence lengths have increased.
That is why we have made the changes we have in the Sentencing Act. But there is, and he's absolutely right to say, there is no evidence that that has either changed or has any direct correlation with the rates of crime or indeed, and importantly, on the public perception of crime. I have to say, as a sort of novice and amateur politician, assumptions that legislating for longer and longer sentences on the basis that it's going to change public opinion clearly hasn't worked. On the question of rehabilitation that the noble lord raises, we do know what works in relation to rehabilitation and we are doing more on drug treatment and so on. But we won't be able to do anything effective on rehabilitation or reducing reoffending if we have massively overcrowded prisons and massively overstretched staff.
Speaker 46
My Lords, I apologize to those noble Lords who wanted to come in with questions, but time is now up on this one. And we now come to questions on a statement made in the House of Commons on Monday the 12th of October on Drumcree.
Speaker 60
My Lords, I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss the events at Drumcree in Portadown over recent days and the decision of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to prohibit an Orange Order parade from Drumcree Church along the Garvaghy Road. At the outset, I would like to concur with what the government statement says about not returning to the standoffs that took place in the mid-1990s from the mid-1990s that resulted in widespread and large-scale disorder, awful violence and, most sadly of all, the loss of 21 lives. It was a particularly painful chapter in Northern Ireland's troubled history, one which left terrible scars on society and which I believe fostered the heightened community tensions that led to the death of Robert Hamill that we discussed on Monday. Any question of going back to those times is simply unimaginable. My Lords, I was special adviser to the then Secretary of State, the late Lord Mayhew of Twysden, for some of that period.
I was also at the Northern Ireland Office when disputes around the return parade through Ardoyne in North Belfast also led to serious disorder from 2012 until a resolution was found in 2016. So, my Lords, I speak with some small degree of experience on the issues with which the current Secretary of State, the noble Baroness the Minister, along with other colleagues and officials have grappled in recent days and the predicaments that they have faced. Ministers often face a choice between the least worst options, or as I believe Alec Douglas-Home once put it, between the unpalatable and the utterly catastrophic. The police are also placed in an near impossible position. We completely accept, therefore, the sincerity of the Secretary of State when he says that the decision on Friday to ban the parade was not one that was taken lightly.
I do believe, however, that the decision taken raises serious issues. The parade was permitted with severe restrictions: 35 people to walk the 10-minute route with no bands or supporters, by the Parades Commission, which is the lawfully constituted body under the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998. As their determinations carry the full weight of law, the parade was legal, and the lawfulness of the Parades Commission determination was upheld by the Court of Appeal, chaired by the Lady Chief Justice, on Monday. The parade was prevented, however, from taking place by an unlawful protest, as a result of which a number of people, including senior politicians, are being investigated over possible breaches of the law. My Lords, it cannot be excusable for any, but least of all lawmakers, to decide that they will only obey the law when it suits them.
Yet does the Minister agree that this is what appears to have happened on this occasion?
In his own statement, the Chief Constable said that for the march to proceed would have, quote, required a substantial public order intervention that was not assessed to be proportionate and which would have carried an unacceptable risk of serious injury, disorder and the wider contagion effects across Northern Ireland, end quote. Nobody doubts that these are serious matters and require full consideration, and we are clear that nothing can be gained by any actions that will further heighten tensions, just as nothing will be gained by heeding those voices that wish to pull down the institutions in Northern Ireland.
But is it not the consequence of banning the march that those who have broken the law and those whose actions have threatened serious injury, disorder and wider contagion have in fact triumphed? I totally accept that this is not remotely the intention of ministers and the government, but will not the perception in Northern Ireland be that those who bring sufficient numbers onto the streets and threaten violence and disorder will prevail? My Lords, throughout the duration of the standoff at Ardoyne, I attended countless meetings with nationalist politicians and residents adamant that Parades Commission determinations must always be upheld.
At the same time, unionist politicians and the Orange Order exhorted us to use the same process and section 9 powers employed by the Secretary of State on Friday to enable their parade at the time to take place. In 2013, we did give this serious consideration but drew back due to the implications for the authority of the Parades Commission, confidence in policing, and above all, upholding the rule of law. Again, I know that this is not the intention, but I am deeply concerned that the Secretary of State might have crossed a line from which it will in future be very difficult ever to retrieve. Finally, the pledge of office in schedule 4 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998 contains a commitment for ministers, including the First Minister, quote, "to support the rule of law unequivocally in word and deed and to support all efforts to uphold it", end quote. Does she believe, does the noble Baroness the Minister believe that there should be consequences for any minister of whatever political party who fails to abide by that pledge?
And in this respect, are there any plans to look at the powers of the Secretary of State under Section 38 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998? In his statement, the Chief Constable said that among the considerations in recommending the Secretary of State ban the parade were, quote, "the implications for the Northern Ireland Executive and for the peace process." Can the Noble Baroness tell the House what the Chief Constable actually meant by that? As I have said, I fully accept that there are no easy answers, but I do fear on this occasion that the government may have taken the wrong choice.
Susy De Martini
My Lords, I too am grateful to have the opportunity to discuss the statement that was made on Monday this week by the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland.
My Lords, these past few weeks have served as a stark reminder of just how fragile the peace process is and of how we must never take it for granted. These events also remind us of the power and importance of words. Words as well as deeds can inflame, cause hurt, and ultimately can turn people towards violence, a violence that has mercifully been so much less a part of people's lives in Northern Ireland since 1998. The Belfast Good Friday Agreement left many of those issues concerning reconciliation and dealing with the past unresolved, and that is perhaps one of the lessons learned from these recent events, events which have been further inflamed by social media and the highly personalized, unacceptable, and often offensive language used.
We need to find ways to bring about genuine reconciliation and move on from the past. From these benches, we welcome all efforts at de-escalation and dialogue, and therefore commend the intervention of the Secretary of State. An intervention that followed clear advice from the PSNI. That advice was clear: not to intervene risks a further increase in violence and a wider deterioration of the peace process. I would also like to pay a personal tribute to the Minister, who I know has dedicated so much time over the last few weeks in trying to find compromises and solutions to these very difficult and highly sensitive issues.
As a Scot from a small town where traditions are fiercely upheld, I do understand the importance placed on such traditions, but they should never, I believe, be at the expense of the security and safety of others. It is important that the rule of law is respected and upheld. We must put the community and their future first. People living side by side and getting on with their lives do not benefit from replaying the worst chapters of the past. A three-week standoff costing five million pounds in policing alone is money and resource that could have gone elsewhere.
Those choices will inevitably have consequences for real people.
Our job now is to support those who want to move forwards, to protect the institutions, respect the rule of law and ensure this dispute does not taint the hard-won progress of the last 30 years. Can the Minister say what practical support is being provided to the communities in Portadown who have now lived through three weeks of disruption and tension and how is she going about supporting that? The policing bill is now approaching, as I said, £5 million. Can the Minister confirm whether additional resource will be made available to the PSNI and whether that cost will fall on the Northern Ireland block grant? And finally, will the Minister commit to encouraging engagement with young people, a generation who have mostly grown up without this kind of division and violence, and to hear their perspective on how we can move forwards?
Speaker 62
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord Lord Kane and the noble Baroness Lady Sashi for their considered and thoughtful contributions to this deeply sensitive debate.
As noble Lords will be aware, during the Secretary of State's statement in the other place, he alerted members that the decision that he laid out in his statement is subject to legal challenge. We must respect the court's role and not anticipate its conclusions. Therefore, noble Lords will understand that this limits what I can say today. However, firstly, I want to thank many members of your Lordship's House, as well as members of the other place, who, like me, spent a great deal of what was meant to be a quiet recess, those famous last words, trying to manage a situation that was deeply troubling and for many heartbreaking.
I also want to thank the Portadown Loyal Orange Lodge Number 1 and the Garvaghy Road Residents Association for the time they genuinely took to come to Hillsborough and to engage in active negotiations. While we're about to talk about a range of issues and I will touch on the facts of where we currently stand, the one thing I would like to say to noble Lords is we talk a great deal about how fragile peace is. But what I have also learned is quite how resilient the communities in Northern Ireland are. And the one thing I think we should hold on to is that if this situation had happened 20 years ago, I am not sure that we would have seen the level of peace on the streets or relative calm on the streets that we have seen in spite of people trying to inflame. And for that, I can't tell you how grateful I am.
Let me set out the facts.
Portadown Loyal Orange Lodge Number 1 obtained a lawful determination permitting its procession. I want to thank the Lodge for the time that they gave me, as well as the Secretary of State, for their constructive engagement. Their commitment to upholding the law and their cooperation with the police has been vital in maintaining calm and order. The Parades Commission determination, as it was made at the time on the 25th of September, was upheld on the early hours of the 26th of September and then again at the Court of Appeal on Monday the 12th of October.
However, the Secretary of State received a formal application from the Chief Constable on Friday the 9th of October under section 9 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998, advising that facilitating the parade would carry an unacceptable risk of serious injury, widespread disorder and public safety threats. No responsible minister could disregard that clear operational assessment. Upholding the rule of law requires judiciously preventing serious disorder. As the Chief Constable has noted, upholding a determination does not come at any cost. Crucially, nobody is above the law or granted immunity from it.
The Police Service of Northern Ireland's operation regarding unlawful protesting is underway, and any individual who broke the law will face police investigation.
Noble Lords may also be aware that the first person has been, has gone to prison with a custodial sentence for six months yesterday. Noble Lords have also raised concerns about regarding sort of future parading, which is one of my personal concerns. The Secretary of State's exercise of powers under section 11, not section 9 of the Act, was specific to the circumstances on the ground at Drumcree. The use of section 9 powers under the Act is also specific to this particular situation and does not diminish the vital role of the Parades Commission, which remains the lawful body for regulating public processions in Northern Ireland. As I have stated, the courts have upheld the Parades Commission's determination, as did the Secretary of State via his section 9 power.
However, we do have to address concerns around public confidence in the Parades Commission from both sides of the community, which is why we have asked Justice O'Hara to carry out the independent judge-led review into the Commission's processes and procedures, and I am the Minister responsible for that review. The Secretary of State and his ministerial team, that would include me, spent two weeks, two weeks intensively engaging, intensively engaged on this issue, hosting successive rounds of negotiations at Hillsborough Castle with all affected parties to attempt to secure a compromise. During these discussions, we explored multiple options for ending the impasse. These included options such as Portadown Lodge completing one final march along the Garvaghy Road on the condition that it would not apply to march down the route again. Another option that would have seen Portadown Lodge accept that it had won the right to march but agree not to exercise that right.
Other options included the residents accepting that the Lodge had established the legal right and would not challenge other parts of the route.
My Lords, as we have seen in other parts of Northern Ireland, where a local agreement can be made, it is actually what sticks and helps us move on. In this instance, a local agreement could not be reached and there is a clear distinction between failing to secure an agreement on a deeply complex issue and failing to act. We tried. My Lords, on some of the specifics, I'm going to need to reflect on Hansard because obviously there are some things I can and can't say right now from the dispatch box. But I think one of the things that I am, that I just want to reflect on is one of the comments made by the noble Baroness, Lady Suttie, which is I was very aware and even I think noble Lords, members of your Lordships' House are aware of the extraordinary respect I have for the people that delivered the Belfast Good Friday Agreement, many of whom are members of our Lordships' House, of your Lordships' House.
I don't think I ever realized what the pressures were on those very people until I sat in the rooms that they had sat in to try and bring together two sides in a very, very difficult process. I am so grateful for what they had done that has got us to this point. The noble baroness also raised the question of practical support for the community in terms of next steps. Obviously we are now working with key partners and allies both on the ground and in terms of institutional stakeholders to see what has to be done. There needs to be some time.
There is genuine hurt on both sides about what has happened and obviously still ongoing court cases.
But we are aware of the ongoing impact that this is going to have on community tensions and community relations. Noble lady also raised the PSNI. I think there are current ongoing discussions but five million pounds is an accurate figure of how much this has cost. And while we're talking about that I genuinely want to put on record my thanks to the PSNI. We have seen officers not have any leave for weeks that are back to places which also for those that have served historically and I spoke to many officers who served during the very very dark days of Drumcree.
The memories that this brings back for them as well as for the direct members of the community are also real. And I think we need to be aware of that so I am very very grateful to the officers of the PSNI who did who did everything they could to hold the community together.
And I during the process went to Gold Command to thank them for the work they were doing during the process. I think there are other issues I'll need to reflect upon, but I will write to Noble Lord if I've missed anything substantial. My Lords, events over recent weeks have passed peacefully and without major disorder, which in itself represents a significant achievement. I appeal to all political and community leaders to exercise restraint in their language and assist in lowering tensions. We have seen some extraordinary leadership from our political leaders in Northern Ireland in recent days and weeks.
We have also seen the opposite from some.
We must grant the community in Portadown the breathing space needed to rebuild trust and uphold the spirit of mutual respect at the heart of the Belfast Good Friday Agreement. That has to be our priority and as we head towards 30 years, it will be 29 years next year, but 30 years as we get to such a significant milestone of the Belfast Good Friday Agreement, the responsibility on every single one of us to live up to the promises both of that and of the spirit of the Stormont House Agreement.
Speaker 63
My Lords, my Lords, my Lords, my Lords. The noble lady who has addressed us as the noble minister knows that she is held in the highest respect across Northern Ireland.
However, it must also be said that the Secretary of State has lost the confidence of a vast number of people within Northern Ireland because he and the Chief Constable, in spite of a lawful decision made by the Parades Commission, the court permitting 35 Orangemen to walk down Garvaghy Road, they bowed shamefully to Irish supporters, the First Minister Michelle O'Neill and a republican mob gathered from across not only Northern Ireland but also the Irish Republic to defy the law on Garvaghy Road and threaten violence. Can I ask the noble lady, how can she tell us how the government is going to restore the rule of law in Northern Ireland and stop what is now clear to everyone that there is a two-tier policing, one for republican agitators and lawbreakers and another for the law-abiding people of Northern Ireland?
Speaker 62
I want to thank the noble lord for his question.
I know how difficult this has been for many people who recognize who see parading as such an important part of their community and their culture and of the deep cultural significance. I just want there's two things I'd like to say. First of all, that 90% of parades take place without conditions and we have come so far from where we were. But in terms of the rule of law, my Lords, I stand at this dispatch box representing the British government. We spend the majority of our time legislating.
Of course I believe in upholding the rule of law. But we need to make sure that that is not at any cost. And I think noble Lords are aware because they were there and I wasn't of the sheer damage that was done and the number of lives that were taken throughout the troubles, but specifically related to Drumcree.
So this is the most heartbreaking, the most difficult of issues. Where the noble Lord is absolutely right is that where the law the rule of law needs to be upheld is where the PSNI need to make prosecutions and we're already seeing that police investigation continue and I hate to use civil service language but at pace given someone's already gone to prison.
Speaker 64
My Lords, we have plenty of time to get everybody everyone who wants to contribute in as long as questions are brief like the one we just heard. I suggest we go to the non-affiliated benches and then we and then we can take turns around the House.
Arlene Isobel Foster
My Lords, thank you. First of all, with the indulgence of the House, can I say as the wife of a police officer who was at Drumcree one, two and three, I want to pay tribute to the men and women who stood on that road.
And I say that because they are often stuck in the middle and they often don't have a voice. So I want to pay tribute to those men who stood there because if violence had have happened, they are the people it would have happened to. So I really do want to pay tribute to the ordinary members of the PSNI. My Lords, in his statement in the other place, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland said that the Orange Order was unable to complete the route due to an unlawful, unnotified protest by residents of the Garvaghy Road and their supporters who blocked the route.
He then said that he made the determination to amend the Parades Commission determination because the Chief Constable had advised him of the risk of serious injury, disorder, and wider contagion affecting the whole of Northern Ireland. My question is a simple one. Where was the risk of serious injury and disorder coming from? Because according to the Secretary of State, it wasn't coming from Portadown Lodge and its supporters. He said yesterday that their commitment to upholding the rule of law and their cooperation with the police had been absolutely vital in maintaining calm.
So where was the risk of disorder coming from?
Speaker 62
I'd like to align myself with the comments of the Secretary of State. I have met many times now the leadership of the Portadown Lodge and they have shown leadership.
These are normal men who have been thrust into the limelight in this, in this space and they have shown leadership within their own community and they have complied with the law at every point. Um, in terms of, um, the any intelligence, obviously we are currently subject to a judicial review and therefore I can't comment further. But what I would like to, um, but I would like to say to the noble lady is I'm very, very grateful for the leadership she also showed during this process and for the support that she has given to others. Um, when the noble lady raises a very, very important point about the PSNI, as I hope I did too.
I don't think we can reiterate what we put people through, even in the last fortnight, both because they have heard from their colleagues over decades about what Drumcree has meant and what the impact was during one, two, and three on the police officers who served then, but also because we were asking them to stand again between two communities, the communities from which they come from and what that means for them too. So this isn't—I was reminded when I was over that there can always be a perception that people like me can fly in and out, can go into one community and try and help, but I get to go home, and the police officers don't necessarily get to do that.
Margaret Ritchie
Could I thank my noble friend the Minister for the statement that was delivered by the Secretary of State in the other place on Monday. And as somebody who has been elected in Northern Ireland for a long period of time and witnessed the events of the last episodes of Drumcree and the impact that that can have on the loyal orders and also on the residents who live there all of their lives and we mustn't forget that. And I am coming as somebody who supports law and order. But we very clearly need pragmatism, a de-escalation of community tension, respect for political and community difference and that need for compromise that the Secretary of State referred to the other day.
And those words were also echoed by the former President of the United States, Barack Obama, when he was in Belfast last night at Queen's University. So would my noble friend the Minister outline the need for a return to Stormont, a return to the Executive, and a return to building work on developing the budget and also fixing public services and agreeing pay deals for public sector workers, as well as the unfinished business of reconciliation and the healing process, the very issues that those people and those MLAs are elected to do.
Speaker 62
The noble, my noble friend highlights the rest of my job outside of current events too, and trying to hold together the executive has been an incredibly important part of the last two weeks. I think it's, or three weeks. It's vitally important that the structures of the Belfast Good Friday Agreement hold. They are our best route through for making sure that we can actually deliver for the people of Northern Ireland on a normal visit when I am speaking to people in Northern Ireland in their communities about the issues they care about. It's, they care as much about how we fix the roads and how we look after our public services as any other part of the United Kingdom.
And I think that's vital, and the noble lady will be, my noble friend will be very aware of the ongoing conversations about the budget. Those conversations are ongoing. There is a deal on the table. We just need everyone else to agree it. But I feel like I have said those words many times in the last three weeks.
But as the Secretary of State says, it's time for everyone to double down on compromise.
Speaker 53
May I say to the Minister, would she agree that many of us in England who believe strongly in the Union would very much prefer the unionists in Northern Ireland not to honor their traditions in a way seen by others to be provocative?
Speaker 62
My Lords, I don't. I mean, genuinely, I think that every part of the United Kingdom has their own traditions and their own celebrations, and that includes whether it is our different faith communities or whether it is our different geographic locations.
We all have significant traditions that we respect and mark. And while it may be really easy for anyone in GB to say it would be easier if people didn't want to parade, if people didn't want to have, if people didn't want to march, because this isn't just unique to one side of the community. The Parades Commission makes determinations for both sides of the community. I think it is incredibly important that we live in a free and fair society that respects freedom of speech and expression, and that's exactly what this is. We just, and that's why the Parades Commission exists and was established in 1998 in order to facilitate that people could have their traditions.
I just very briefly want to highlight one of the most extraordinary experiences I had this summer, which was the Fleadh, which was the Irish music festival in Belfast. 1.6 million people came during three days, and at one point I found myself on the slips of, at the Titanic slip, listening to the Ulster-Scots bands play, sitting next to the Taoiseach. A, I was sitting in the middle of Belfast where 20 years ago that would have been a security threat in itself in terms of who was present, or 30 years ago it would have been something you couldn't have considered. But also I was sitting with the head of the Irish government as we celebrated the culture of Ulster-Scots. I think that we need to, that has to be the hope that we hold on to into this, that we can all respect each other's traditions.
My Lords.
Speaker 67
My Lords, as a unionist and Orangeman, I will continue to honor my traditions in a peaceful and wayful manner.
My Lords, the minister mentioned the Good Friday Agreement. In the years following the sign of the Belfast Agreement, pressure was placed on the Ulster Unionist negotiators to give more ground to Sinn Féin IRA, whilst republicans continued to issue threats and carry out shootings and maimings on the streets of Northern Ireland. Can the noble lady the minister tell the House what is to stop other rent-a-mobs, including known republican terrorists, from issuing similar threats in the months to come to get their way in the public highways of the United Kingdom?
Speaker 62
I thank the noble Lord for his question, I genuinely do. I think the one thing that we need to do is to ensure that we have confidence in the Parades Commission.
I do have confidence in the chair and the commissioners, but it's about making sure that there is public confidence. One of the things that came to light over that was my ignorance over the summer was that there hadn't been a review done of how the Parades Commission had been operating since 2007. It was Lord Ashdown who had previously undertaken such a review. 20 years later, it was easy to take some of these things for granted. We need to make sure that the Parades Commission is fit for purpose, that everyone has faith in it, but also that their determinations are respected by all sides.
Alfred Dubs
My Lords, I wonder if we can get the whole thing into perspective.
I congratulate the Secretary of State on having made a very difficult, difficult decision indeed. But I wonder if my noble friend the Minister could indicate how many Orange Order marches take place every year without any trouble at all, hundreds if not thousands, and indeed some of them even take place in Donegal. And I would use that fact as a way of urging the unionists to say, look, we're having a pretty fair crack of the whip with our marches, surely, surely we can now obey the, or we can listen to the Chief Constable, a very sensible and, and effective individual. When the Chief Constable gives particular advice to the Secretary of State, it'd be hard for the Secretary of State, Secretary of State to ignore it, and we should be grateful about that. And can I say finally, my Lords, the Good Friday Agreement, Belfast Agreement, is too important to be prejudiced on this particular issue.
Speaker 62
I've thought about my noble friend many times over the last few weeks, not least because of how much time I spent in Hillsborough and how much time I know that he spent there during the negotiations for the Belfast Good Friday Agreement, and for his service I am always grateful, but in this area more than most. The noble Lord is right in terms of the number of parades that happen, and in fact 90% of the parades now happen without contention, and for that I think the whole of Northern Ireland society is grateful and we can't walk back from that. I think we need to ensure that we hold onto that.
The only gentle thing I would say to the noble, to my noble friend, is that this was a legal determination through the processes that had been agreed and that is where, and that is where people, we sat in, we put processes in place. People were going to like some decisions and not like others, but when the, but when the decision has been made and it is viewed to be lawful, I think we do need to view everything through that prism.
Speaker 70
My Lords. I think it's been made clear that this was a small, legal parade. And I think we're unfortunately in a position where he who shouts loudest appears to get their way. My concern comes with the comments and the behavior of the First Minister, Michelle O'Neill, who is also of course Vice President of Sinn Féin.
Because one of the key points that has been raised is that there should be no interference from the politicians at the highest level. And there was no need for any interference because all the processes had been agreed. However, that appeared not to be the case, and therefore I do believe that it was a wrong decision by the police in Northern Ireland, and also it didn't help with her interference. And I'd just like to ask the noble Baroness the Minister to, with her colleague, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, remind the First Minister that she did say when she was asked that she was proud to stand with those in the neighborhood, but that the Orange march on the 27th of September was unwanted, sectarian, and triumphalist.
And these are her words. So perhaps the noble Minister would pass on the message to the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister perhaps that in future interference on this scale would not be welcome.
Speaker 62
My Lords, it's important that the rule of law be upheld. Everyone, no matter their position, should cooperate fully with the police. Holding public office brings responsibilities to the whole community we represent. Every political leader should uphold the law and consider how our conduct affects the confidence of all those we serve. In terms of the specific case the noble lady raises, there is an ongoing police investigation.
James Peter Weir
My Lords, can I first of all join with my colleague in indicating the level of personal regard to which the Minister is held in Northern Ireland. But the events of the last fortnight and the decisions of the last fortnight have been deeply damaging to both the political process and the rule of law, with a First Minister who seems to believe that she is above the law and can pick and choose which laws she abides by, by defying the law and indeed encouraging others onto the streets to also break the law.
And a situation in which a legal determination was overturned not on the basis of legal challenge, not on the basis of the merits of the decision itself, but on the basis of an illegal protest and the threat of violence, which sadly sends out the clear signal that the more unlawful you can be and the more that you can actually threaten violence, the better your chances of success are. That is deeply worrying to society as a whole. So can I ask the minister what actions does the government intend to take to try and restore public confidence in both the integrity of the political process and also the primacy of the rule of law?
Speaker 62
The noble lord raises two very, very important points, which is at the fundamentals of everything that has been tried to achieve during the 28 and a half years since the Belfast Good Friday Agreement was signed.
And I want us to ensure that we hold on to quite how far we have come. In terms of the decision that the Secretary of State made, he considered the Chief Constable's assessment that facilitating the procession would carry an unacceptable risk of serious injury and wider disorder. He could not responsibly disregard that advice. But the noble Lord is absolutely right. We now have a job of work to do to make sure that people respect both the rule of law and have an appreciation for why Stormont is so important.
Speaker 74
And we will continue working with all the political parties to try to deliver that.
Speaker 73
I welcome the Secretary of State's intervention.
I welcome the Secretary of State's intervention and I also thank my noble friend the Minister for her vision of the Belfast Flower, which I think is a vision of modern Belfast that many, many people sign up to. But this particular march, as we know, is associated with a history of violence and sectarian murders, including the Quinn children, and that explains why memories in the area amongst the residents are still so raw.
Would my noble friend the minister confirm that it's beholden on governments, courts and state agencies to uphold the European Convention on Human Rights, including freedom from sectarian violence, which is explicitly enshrined in the Good Friday Agreement that we all support?
Speaker 62
My Lords, of course we all have a responsibility to uphold every part of the Belfast Good Friday Agreement. Responsibility is on each and every one of us. I spent time with the residents association from the Garvaghy Road and especially in terms of the women, their genuine fear of what happened and of their memories of Drumcree one, two and three and what happened in terms and as we heard earlier this week in including what happened to Robert Hamill. That being said, and I don't want to diminish anyone's pain because there is always too much pain and heartbreak in Northern Ireland. We experience it nearly every day, especially in your Lordships' House when we discuss these matters.
But what I would say to the noble to my noble friend is that there is pain across the part the piece in in Drumcree and further afield and when we discuss anything about the troubles, there is no part of this where there is anything but hurt.
Speaker 46
My Lords, I'm afraid time is up so I apologize for those noble Lords who didn't manage to get their questions in. So we now come to the Sovereign Grant Bill, Lord Pitt-Watson.
David Pitt
My Lords, I beg to move that the bill be read a second time.
This bill relates to the sovereign grant, which Parliament has provided to support the official duties of the monarch and the work of the royal household. This bill implements the conclusions of a recent Royal Trustees' review of that sovereign grant. It does three things. First, it resets the grant level for the next financial year at 99.9 million pounds, with the anticipation that that will be the grant for the next five years. Currently, the grant is 137.9 million pounds.
This gives effect to the commitment of successive governments and the expectation of the Royal Household for a reduction in the level of funding following the completion of the Buckingham Palace reservicing program. The bill also aims to make two targeted improvements to the statutory framework for this funding, introducing limited flexibilities to ensure that funding levels remain appropriate both on an annual basis and within the year in response to exceptional circumstances. This will make it easier to respond where funding would become inappropriately low or inappropriately high.
The Sovereign Grant supports the monarch's official duties, so it funds the staff, the official travel, the property maintenance, the essential services required for the sovereign to fulfill their unique constitutional role. That role extends beyond ceremonial functions; it includes hosting heads of state, supporting diplomatic engagement, representing the United Kingdom overseas, and strengthening our relationships across the Commonwealth and the world. These activities support UK interests, including trade, investment, security, and diplomacy. At home, the grant supports the sovereign's significant role, from recognizing charitable and voluntary service to bringing communities together across the United Kingdom. I would also note that with a new and younger monarch, there have been more activities than in the immediate past.
Coming to the bill, since 2012, the level of the Sovereign Grant has been determined through a statutory framework established by Parliament in the 2011 Sovereign Grant Act. That framework requires the annual grant amount to be calculated by reference to the previous year's expenditure and a percentage of the profits of the Crown Estate, which is an independent corporation whose net revenue profits are returned to the Exchequer. To ensure that the funding levels remain appropriate, the 2011 Act also requires the Royal Trustees, that is the Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, the Keeper of the Privy Purse, to conduct regular reviews.
A key piece of context for this House today is that Parliament agreed a temporary uplift in the grant from 2017-18 to 2026-27 to fund the Buckingham Palace reservicing program. That program has been a major 10-year investment to modernize aging infrastructure, replace critical electrical and mechanical systems, and safeguard the long-term future of one of the nation's most important historic buildings. As that program nears completion, now is the time for the level of funding to be reassessed. Earlier this year, the then Royal Trustees completed the latest review and considered both the Royal Household's projected expenditure and the Crown Estate's projected revenues for the period 27 to 32.
The Trustees concluded that, with the Buckingham Palace reservicing program nearing completion, the exceptional funding required that justified the temporary uplift no longer existed. They therefore recommended that the level of the Sovereign Grant should fall from 137.9 million pounds in 2026-27 to 99.9 million pounds in 27-28. That represents a reduction of almost 38 million pounds, or more than a quarter compared to the current year. At the same time, the Trustees recognized that the Royal Household continues to face operational pressures.
The recommended level of funding will, for example, enable the household to address a maintenance backlog, one that was exacerbated by the pandemic, and replace the aging digital infrastructure, for example, to strengthen cybersecurity. The grant level provided for by this bill therefore ensures value for money for taxpayers and that the royal household can continue to discharge its functions effectively. In conclusion, then, I think this bill delivers a fair and proportionate funding settlement. It reduces the level of the sovereign grant following the completion of the major capital program. It improves the resilience and sustainability of the statutory framework while maintaining parliamentary oversight, and it ensures that the sovereign grant can continue to fulfill its core purpose, supporting the official duties of the monarch and maintaining the occupied palaces on behalf of the nation.
John Redwood
My Lords, I support the minister in his aims, and I'm very pleased the minister set out so well the important work that the Royal Family does on behalf of our country, promoting our diplomatic efforts, entertaining important guests of the nation, and supporting the government of the day in the work that the government is doing in trade, diplomacy, and wider world affairs.
And I accept fully the case the Minister has made out that this needed review. I was a supporter of extra money being made available to renovate and modernize Buckingham Palace. It's a most important national building and importantly it's a working building because so many people get the pleasure to go there and so many of our international guests have the privilege of a great dinner or a social event at the palace, which they normally much value because it's something many other countries in the world cannot match. So I broadly welcome this legislation and I quite agree that the amount should be adjusted downwards. But I also would just like to stress that I think the amount must be sufficient and the formula and the details for future years must be sufficiently well thought through so that we do accommodate without argument or unseemly exchanges legitimate increases in costs which are clearly going to take place as inflation still stalks our land and as modernization and the amount of service we expect probably increases.
So we should expect the amount of money to go up. I'm quite sure my noble friend on the front bench will have detailed issues which she will rightly raise, but I think it will be in the spirit that we fully support the monarchy in its work, we believe there should be a proper sovereign grant. But I would just like to leave this last thought with the minister so that he may be able to clarify a bit more at the end, that I do think it is good to have a formula which you can normally rely on, which gives a fairly predictable outcome to allow the royal household to plan rather having year by year to battle away over budgets in the way that others may have to do because I think that is a distraction and if it gets into the press, it is then damaging to the very diplomatic image we're trying to create.
George Foulkes
Lord, I have a great respect for the Minister, this Minister in particular, as a fellow Scot like me, he will make sure every bawbee gets value for money. And I understand he will have had a brief from down the corridor, in fact the words were quite familiar having read the Commons Hansard. But I hope that he will listen to the debate here in the House of Lords and transmit the views of the members here, because unfortunately this bill wasn't given the full scrutiny that it deserved on the floor of the House of Commons, and I think that was rather regrettable.
So the Lords needs to give it some scrutiny today. And although we're not in a position to move any amendments because the Speaker of the House of Commons has designated this, understandably, as a money bill, we still have a duty to shine a light on the inequality that is built into this mechanism and the lack of transparency and the lack of accountability. My Lords, the reality is simple. If the government genuinely wanted a needs-based system, the Royal Household would submit an annual budget request to the Treasury like any other public entity. Instead, we've now got a formula tied to Crown Estate profits.
That's a system designed as a heads-I-win, tails-you-lose proposition: frozen against losses when profits fall, yet fully open to the upside when they surge. My Lords, when we ask the public to fund an institution to the tune of about a hundred million pounds a year through the Sovereign Grant, at a time where sadly we know many of the people in this country face severe pressure on their household budget, we here have a duty to ask two fundamental questions. First of all, are we getting value for money? And secondly, do the actions of the institution match the value that it preaches?
I would argue that in both cases the answer is no. We hear various royal pronouncements on climate change. Yet official reports reveal hundreds of private jet and helicopter flights for short domestic trips, one recently to the races where the royal concerned could have easily gone by car. And the taxpayer has funded two new helicopters for the royal family, whereas mountain rescue for their helicopters have to raise money through charitable efforts. Now, is that right in the 21st century?
And then we see commendable statements on homelessness, Prince of Wales in particular. But the Crown maintains many, many empty or underutilized luxury estates across the country, in Scotland at Balmoral, in London, all over, not just Buckingham Palace, but all over the city of London, and at Sandringham, many, many unused, underutilized estates. So in terms of value for money also, our monarchy remains by a vast margin the most expensive state-funded royal family in Europe. Spain, in Spain, the public grant is only about 7 million pounds, in Sweden under 15 million pounds, and the Netherlands at 45 million.
So in European terms, we are one of the big spenders as far as royal family is concerned. And if we take a baseline of 2011, 31 million pounds, and adjust that for inflation, our sovereign grant, even allowing for these kind of expenditure, would be between 45 and 50 million, not the 99.9 million pounds proposed. And that figure doesn't even account for police security. I've had letters from local councils about the cost that they are required for security. And the tax advantages of the incomes from the duchies, not taken account of.
And I'm not challenging the role of the sovereign, the sovereign in particular.
But while European neighbors have streamlined their royal houses, we continue to fund a sprawling network of so-called working royals. Working royals, whose ribbon-cutting duties of pulling open a table, a tableau. That is not real work. Not like a teacher who works five days a week, or a nurse in a geriatric hospital who might be working a 12-hour shift. It's not real work that they do.
I mean, I might just say that Princess Anne is a notable exception, and it's interesting that all her offspring have given up their royal titles and work for a living. Perhaps that's an example that other members of the royal family might think about.
So the fundamental issue here is accountability. When George Osborne introduced the Sovereign Grant, he claimed removing parliamentary debate would depoliticise the monarchy. In reality, it stripped away democratic oversight, and the tightening of Freedom of Information rules means that transparency also is now virtually impossible, breaking the assurances that were given previously to Parliament. Shielding the institution behind FOI exemptions and blocking debate has enabled a runaway increase in public funding. So in order to achieve this, I think that there are three key actions that are necessary.
And I really sincerely ask the Minister to take account of the debate here today and to take these down to his fellow ministers in the Treasury and elsewhere and consider, first of all, a return to the annual parliamentary scrutiny through regular debates and votes, like other public bodies. Secondly, we should treat the Royal Household also like any other public body under the Freedom of Information Act. And thirdly, we should ask the Commons to task their Public Accounts Committee to conduct a full root-and-branch review of all royal funding and finances. Parliament is here to safeguard public money, and it is time we modernized, we streamlined, and properly brought transparency to this institution.
I hope the minister will genuinely, sincerely take account of this debate and, with colleagues, look again at this matter.
Prem Sikka
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Fox of Camnock. This bill comes at a time when many households are struggling to make ends meet. Under this bill, the core funding of the royal household, that is after ignoring the money allocated for refurbishment of Buckingham Palace, rises from 51.8 million for 2024-25 to 99.9 million for 2027-28. That is an increase of 97%. I'm not aware of any ordinary household that has secured an increase of this magnitude in its income to discharge its essential duties.
The average real wage of workers has barely changed since 2008.
25.3 million people live below the minimum income standard. Around 300,000 people a year are dying while waiting for NHS hospital appointment, but here we are giving away a large chunk of money. This massive increase is being given to a family, which according to Forbes magazine, could be worth 21 billion pounds. Anyone with lifetime savings of over 16,000 pound is generally disqualified or severely restricted from receiving universal credit, housing benefit or income support. But under this bill, a mega rich family would continue to receive public money.
Many people would not be happy with that arrangement at all, and clearly the government must notice that issue. Profits from the Crown Estate, which is essentially a property business owned by the monarch but run independently, go to the Treasury. Its profits are used as a benchmark to calculate the funding given by the government to the royal family in the form of sovereign grant. But then there are questions. Do the Crown Estate, the Crown Jewels, the Duchy of Cornwall, and the Duchy of Lancaster belong to the nation, or are they private property of the royal family?
If they are public property, then all revenues must go to the public purse.
If they are private property, then those assets and related income streams must be taxed in the same way as any other private property is, and the beneficiaries must pay income tax, capital gains tax, corporation tax, and inheritance tax. Perhaps the minister can clarify what makes something a public property or a private property and why they need to be treated differently in this case. What we have had for decades is what I call a medieval fudge. We distinguish good societies from the rest by appealing to the rule of law, but the laws don't apply equally to all. Some get privileged treatment.
The King is exempt from inheritance tax, ordinary mortals are not. The Duchies do not pay corporation tax or capital gains tax.
The King voluntarily pays income tax on his private income and a portion on the privy purse not used for official duties. Why should payment of income tax be voluntary for anyone? Don't we have a rule of law? I'm sure many people would like to pay taxes voluntarily, but they will never ever get that particular chance. Could the Minister explain why the King's exemptions from income tax, inheritance tax, and capital gains tax continue, and what revenues could be collected if these exemptions were to be abolished?
In June 2026, the King published data showing that he paid around 30 million pound in voluntary income and capital gains tax for the period 2022-23 to 2024-25, which continued the practice started during his time as the Prince of Wales. The current Prince of Wales also embraces similar disclosures. These selected snippets should not be confused with transparency. Anyone completing a tax return must disclose employment income, income from trade or profession, investment income, dividends from home and abroad, capital gains, business profits, inheritance, and more. But there are no such disclosures in the snippets which are put into the public domain.
There is no transparency about the wealth or income of the Royal Family, and this is in the early 21st century.
Nothing is known about the King's investments, how they are held, where they are held, and income therefrom. Various tax exemptions erode the UK's tax base as well. In the absence of meaningful data, it is hard to know what the correct amount of tax paid by the King or the Prince of Wales actually should be. The Sovereign Grant does not count for income tax purpose. But if normal individuals receive sums from the state to enable them to make ends meet, they are taxable.
For example, the state pension, carer's allowance, contribution-based jobseeker's allowance and the contribution-based employment and support allowances are all taxable.
One rule for the poor, one for somebody else. The King does not pay capital gains tax on capital of the Duchy of Lancaster and pays income tax on his private income only to the extent that it isn't used for official purposes. In the House of Commons debate on this bill, ministers referred to, and I quote the words, "personal" and another word they used was "official" expenses. But none offered any clear distinction between the two. Are support staff, palaces, various residences, servants, kitchens, chauffeurs, are they really for personal or official purposes?
Hopefully the minister can clarify. Presumably whatever is personal should not be funded by the public purse.
So it would be helpful to see details of that particular information. One of the most anomalous positions is that of the Duchy of Cornwall. Is it really a public organisation? Is it a crown body? Is it a corporation?
Or is it just a private fiefdom? A state within a state. If it is part of the crown, then all the checks, balances, scrutiny and accountability that apply to public assets should also apply to the Duchy and its custodian, which is the Prince of Wales.
Its records should be subjected to periodic scrutiny by the National Audit Office to determine whether the organisation is operating efficiently and effectively and lawfully, and whether the public is getting value for money. But none of this applies to the Duchy because we are told that it is a private estate. Well, is it really a private estate? The business of the Duchy extends far beyond Cornwall. It is one of the biggest landowners, spread across 20 counties in England and Wales.
Its operations include, or have recently included, manufacture and sale of biscuits, snacks, jam, marmalade, honey, chocolate, organic food, seeds, holiday cottages, farm produce. It owns warehouses, Dartmoor Prison, the Oval cricket ground and more.
Certainly does not easily fit with the word Cornwall here. It extends far beyond Cornwall and it is really a conglomerate. Its 2026 accounts show that it has assets of 1.3 billion and a financial surplus of 21.55 million pounds. It is a commercial entity and it competes with local, national and international businesses. But it does not pay corporation tax or capital gains tax because now we are told that it is actually a crown body.
So the Duchy claims exemption from taxes on the basis that it is a crown body. Inevitably these exemptions must lead to unfair competition.
The payment of taxes provides for education, pensions, and healthcare for workers and social infrastructure used by the Duchy to make profits. However, because of the tax exemptions, the Duchy does not bear any of the social costs of that infrastructure. It is effectively having a free ride on the back of ordinary taxpayers. That cannot be right at all. The Duchy complies with the UK employment and health and safety laws.
It collects PAYE, national insurance, it collects and pays VAT. This gives the appearance that it is actually a business subject to the laws applicable to all other businesses. But then at the same time we are told that it actually is not a commercial organisation and can't really be treated as a corporation.
Well, what is it? Hopefully the minister would be able to tell us what exactly it is and why on earth should it actually be exempt from the laws which apply to any other commercial entity. On page 92 of the Duchy's 2026 accounts, which you might want to have a look at if you're finding it hard to go to bed tonight. Page 92 of the Duchy's 2026 accounts contain interesting information. And I quote, so this is in quotation marks.
Certain Duchy properties are occupied by His Majesty the King and his staff for living accommodation or commercial activities. These were let at open market values, that the total value of annual rent charge amounted to £503,711, end of quote. So this actually is a rent the Duchy receives by renting out Highgrove House. So the King pays rent to the Duchy of Cornwall, presumably out of the Sovereign Grant, but the Duchy is owned by his son, the Duke of Cornwall. So one member of family is paying rent to another.
Money does not go to anybody outside at all, it is retained within the family. So can the Minister explain how this inter-family transaction affected the calculation of the Sovereign Grant?
Is it really a cost in any way whatsoever? So to sum up, major reforms are needed on transparency, accountability, calculation, and the grant of the sovereign grant. The royals frequently say that they wish to be treated as normal people. I urge the minister and the government to fulfill that particular wish.
Anthony Berkeley
My lords, it's a real honor to follow the speaker and my two colleagues before me who have given so much detailed information about what is wrong with the crown estates and the sovereign grant system. I do welcome my noble friend's, the minister's, clarification of what is in the bill.
I do welcome my noble friend the Minister's clarification of what is in the bill, and it is certainly an improvement on what we had before. But, my Lords, there's an awful lot more to do. I first of all feel I deprecate the lack of scrutiny that the other place has given this particular bill because it's the kind of thing which they could, with all the help that they can get, provide some really useful challenges to what is in the, what the trustees produce.
And of course the first thing is that any challenges need to be independent. And most people would think that the trustees, who are the Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer and the Keeper of the Privy Purse, which we can look upon as the Royal Family, they do appear to be marking their own homework, which is not a satisfactory way of providing an independent assessment.
The other point relating to that is that there's a continuing feeling from many people in this country and in both houses that the, I don't know what it is, but there's a sort of a lack of deference and it's important they seem to step back from being positively critical of some of the things that have happened for fear of upsetting members of the royal family. And you couple that with the feeling that many of the members, and I do exclude frankly the members that my noble friends have spoken about, have an expectation that people consider to be out of touch with a reduced monarchy and the financial situation that many people find themselves.
And it's very unclear to me which royals are on what apparently are called official duties and as my noble friend Lord Foulkes said, why do they need two helicopters? I'm probably seen as the black sheep of the royal family critical group because I have the honor of being quoted in a book a few years ago by then Prince Charles saying that don't worry about Lord Berkeley, he's a nutcase. I think that's a bit of an honor actually.
My Lords, one of the most important things which needs to be done in any future investigation is what expenditure is applicable to the Royal Family as head of state, call it official duties, and what ends up in their private use. Where does the revenue sit, private or public? For the most part, is the grant value for money? To give an example, my Lords, Buckingham Palace has been mentioned as a cost to the taxpayer and it seems as if a good job has been done and the costs are reasonable and it's now nearly finished and that's very much to be welcomed.
But not many noble lords will know that the income from visitors to Buckingham Palace goes into the pocket of the sovereign. You'd think if the taxpayer has paid all these millions to rebuild Buckingham Palace as an emblem of the state and everything else, surely the income from the visitors should go to the taxpayer in a little bit of a reimbursement of what they've paid. It's in passing, it's a rather good example of how a building can be refurbished to a high quality at a reasonable cost and maybe those who are in charge of trying to upgrade the Houses of Parliament should take some, get a few lessons from them, but that's a little bit, a little bit sideways.
So, my Lords, we have the taxpayer paying renovation costs and the King or the Duke of Cornwall, whoever it is, getting the income benefit. It is very odd. And it's not declared. A similar one is when royalty go on an official visit somewhere. As noble Lords will know, it's normal for the royalty to give a gift to the host and receive a gift in return.
Sometimes they're small gifts and sometimes they're large gifts. But again, it seems as if the noble, as if the gifts that go to the sovereign, or whoever it is, are retained by the sovereign, but of course it's the taxpayer who's paid for the gift that the sovereign gives to them. It should be one or the other. But again, and of course if you ask questions, it's much too, it's much too secret. My Lords, other noble Lords have mentioned the problem of property.
And I found it very interesting recently to read a book by Norman Baker, former Member of Parliament for Lewes in Sussex, called Royal Mint and National Debt, which lists 21 properties which are royal residences, as well as 13 other ones. Now, the royal residences, 21 properties, do the royals really need 21 properties to fulfill their royal duties? Because every time the whoever the incumbent changes, it rather seems as if the the new one insists on buying a new property without giving up the old one. Do they let it out?
And if they do let it out, where does the income go? My noble friend has mentioned the Duchy of Cornwall, which, as noble lords will know, made a profit of about 22 million last year. But it doesn't, of course, operate like other estates, as my noble friend said. It also gets income from people who die intestate in Cornwall, and it gets a nice cut from the mineral rights from the mining in Cornwall, of which there's quite a lot. But it doesn't actually mean that the profits, even some of the profits, go to housing in the Isles of Scilly or Cornwall, or maintaining the services and the transport.
And there's a big issue with air services to Scilly at the moment, as noble lords will know.
And a useful contribution would be a contribution to improve the flying to St Mary's to category three standard so that it didn't get closed for fog so often. But again, they've offered a very nice site on St Mary's for building an abattoir, which is really useful for the local farmers. It's taken a long time for that offer to be there.
But we'll be quite sure that having built the abattoir, which other people will be funding, and then any charge for the use of the abattoir will go straight into the pocket of the Duchy rather than those who've actually funded it. So my Lords, I welcome the National Audit Office's input so far, but it needs to be a much wider scope in addition to what the House of Commons should be doing in the future. But the first thing to look at is the need. Is there a need for this expenditure? And secondly, is it official or private, as some of my colleagues have said?
Or is it the usual thing that the Treasury pays the cost and the income goes as a profit to the private part? There needs to be a debate about affordability in this.
The value for money for taxpayer is not evident at the moment and it needs to be. But the most important thing for me is it must be seen to be undertaken by an organisation that is separate either from the government or from the Royal Family itself. Now whether that's a separate committee or whether it's the National Audit Office, I don't know, because something needs to be done to remove this kind of deferential attitude which seems to cover so much of this that we mustn't upset anybody. As my noble friend said, this is a business.
And if it's a business, then it should be treated on business terms and everybody's equal. And I hope that in the future we'll be able to have a longer debate, and I hope that the government, my noble friend, will actually take comments from many noble lords here this evening and consider with his colleagues how we can do to bring this into a really modern, affordable monarchy.
Susan Kramer
My lords, I will focus on this bill and not on the broader issues, and I also intend to be brief as my colleagues in the Commons spoke to the issues and we will support this bill.
But first may I say that with ten Prime Ministers in a decade in the UK and with a President in the US who feels free to make play with the traditional balance of power, I do feel very relieved that we have a stable non-political head of state, even if monarchy is a legacy of a very different past. Now that role as head of state must be properly funded, as must the heritage buildings, though why we go through the complex myth that the money is related to the Crown Estate is quite beyond me. Given that that mechanism remains, I do find it peculiar that future grants are set at a fixed percentage of Crown Estate revenues when these vary year on year.
I mean, how does that enable sensible planning and indeed not encourage overspend? My Lords, my colleagues in the Commons raised issues on the transparency of grant spending and also submitted an amendment that the NAO, the National Audit Office, should independently assess the submission upfront rather than just the Royal Trustees and rather than just waiting to review the spend in a retrospective audit. And that value for money assessment would be laid before both Houses and require the approval by resolution of the Commons, returning some democratic accountability and oversight. A process like this might, for example, have asked the obvious question when looking at the numbers that are in the briefing on the Sovereign Grant Bill of why the increase in core funding in the grant is well above inflation. That was true for the year 25-26 and it's true again for the year 26-27.
And if that work had been done, we would surely have more detail, we would have had a fleshed out answer from the minister in the other place who simply said costs have risen. And I do think that additional kind of transparency and oversight would give the public much more confidence in the use of the moneys that are given as the Sovereign Grant. Now my colleagues also sought assurances that neither these funds nor taxpayer funds generally would fund state honors for Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor. I'm not sure that the minister gave a direct response, but I interpreted what he said as an assurance that that would not happen. And I see that the minister here is nodding.
Susan Kramer
With the King choosing to live at Clarence House rather than return to Buckingham Palace, and the younger Royal Family generally choosing a more modest lifestyle, are there plans for what we're going to do with Buckingham Palace when the restoration is complete? Will it continue in its current roles, are there new roles being contemplated, and how does funding work through for all of that? My Lords, the Sovereign Grant process, I think, could benefit from significant simplification and from greater transparency, but given that we are where we are, we will support this bill.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My Lords, I'm grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for introducing this bill and the context for its passage so clearly.
The Sovereign Grant provides the public funding necessary to support the monarch in carrying out official duties and to meet the associated costs of the Royal Household, including the maintenance of the royal occupied royal palaces. Those tasks are vital and it is right that they are provided for. His Majesty's official opposition supports the bill. Like the Minister and my noble friend Lord Redwood, we recognize the considerable contribution made by His Majesty the King and other working members of the Royal Family in carrying out their constitutional and public duties, both at home and overseas. Most of this is admired around the world and the working members work hard and of course the profits from the Crown Estate go to the Treasury, as I remember when I sat in the Minister's seat and the receipts were rising.
Buckingham Palace alone attracts some 683 visitors a year, which is a big boost to the wider economy. It's not only a symbol of the monarchy and of the Royal Family, but one of the most recognizable symbols of the UK itself and of our national history, which we want people to understand both here and abroad. Buckingham Palace, Windsor Castle and the Mall provide the setting for some of the great occasions on which this country comes together: for royal weddings, state ceremonies, the award of honours, Remembrance Days and moments of national celebration. These sites are seen by millions at home and around the world and form an important part of how our country presents itself internationally.
The Sovereign Grant helps to ensure that the buildings and spaces for which it is responsible remain fit for purpose, properly maintained and worthy of the national institutions they represent, so that they can continue to be a source of national pride for generations to come. The Sovereign themselves plays a vital role in representing our country at home and abroad, and remains, I believe, a significant source of British soft power and of stability, as the noble lady Lady Kramer pointed out. So the central purpose of the bill is straightforward.
The sovereign grant was temporarily increased to meet the costs of the 10-year Buckingham Palace resurfacing program, and as that program reaches its conclusion, it's reasonable that the level of funding should be reconsidered and that those exceptional capital costs should no longer be reflected in the baseline grant. Indeed, the principle that the grant should be reset once the resurfacing program had concluded was established under the previous government. As we've heard, the bill accordingly sets the sovereign grant at 99.9 million for 2027-28, compared with 137.9 million in 2026-27. So that's a sensible objective. But this bill does rather more than reset the grant for a single financial year, and it's on the longer-term changes I'd be grateful for some further clarification.
As the noble Lord Lord Fox has come now and the noble Lord Lord Barkley said, it's our job to do the scrutiny that the House of Commons hasn't had time to give it.
Though I'm not in the same place, I have to say, as he is, nor today in the same place as the noble Lord Lord Sikka or the noble Lord Lord Berkeley, but I will leave the Minister to respond to their wider comments. So I turn to my questions on the bill itself and to clause two and the new reference percentage of 20.5%. The government have explained that this figure arises from the review undertaken by the Royal Trustees and that it reflects a bottom-up assessment of the expected requirements alongside forecasts for Crown Estate revenues. Ministers in the other place also explained that the assessment includes future expenditure on the occupied palaces, modernization of digital infrastructure and cybersecurity and other operating costs. That's helpful, but I hope the Minister can provide the House with a little more detail about the calculation.
20.5% is, after all, a very precise figure. Can the Minister explain more fully how the Royal Trustees translated their assessment of the future needs of the Royal Household into that particular reference percentage? And that leads to a wider question of whether the revised mechanism is sufficiently resilient to future changes in Crown Estate revenues. The attraction of a statutory formula is that it provides predictability and a degree of separation between the day-to-day decisions of ministers and the funding necessary for the discharge of the monarch's official functions. But any formula is only as effective as the assumptions on which it rests.
It would therefore be helpful if the minister could explain how the government expect the new arrangements to operate if the Crown Estate revenues depart significantly from current forecasts and how quickly the system will be capable of responding. And that brings me to clause 3, which is the most constitutionally interesting. This provides for an appropriate amount of the Sovereign Grant to be one which would leave the adjusted value of the reserve fund at no less than 10% and no more than 50% of annual expenditure. Where the normal formula produces a result outside that range and the Royal Trustees cannot correct it under the existing mechanism, they must identify an appropriate alternative amount and the Treasury must make regulations giving effect to it. And I'd be grateful if the minister would explain the basis for those two thresholds.
Why were 10% and 50% considered the appropriate lower and upper limits?
And what assessment has been made of the level of reserves genuinely required for financial resilience? More fundamentally, clause 3 slightly changes the balance of the existing framework. The 2011 system is principally formula-based. The bill retains that principle, but it also creates circumstances in which the Treasury will have a direct role in altering the amount of grant. Now, there may be perfectly good practical reasons for providing flexibility.
Nevertheless, where ministers are given powers to alter the level of public funding provided under a statutory framework, Parliament is entitled to understand precisely how those powers are intended to operate.
And that is particularly relevant to new section 6B, which allows the Treasury to increase the sovereign grant during the course of a financial year where ministers consider that there are exceptional circumstances requiring them to do so. The Treasury must consult the Royal Trustees and any such regulations require the approval of the House of Commons. Can the minister give the House some indication of what the government envisages falling within that definition? But finally, I return to the underlying purpose of the bill. There is a perfectly clear rationale for revisiting the sovereign grant as a substantial, time-limited programme of work at Buckingham Palace comes to an end.
There is equally a strong case for ensuring that the statutory framework is capable of responding where its normal operation would otherwise produce an obviously inappropriate level of funding.
So we support the bill, but I look forward to the minister's response to the questions I have raised.
David Pitt
My Lords, thank you. This has been an interesting discussion and rightly so. I will do my best to respond to those parts of the debate where I can, and if I fail so to do, please do contact me afterwards and a written response might be better. But it is right that we have this discussion because where public money is concerned, this House is entitled to expect clarity, discipline, and proper accountability. And where the constitutional arrangements supporting the official duties of the monarch are concerned, this House is also entitled to expect a framework that is stable and proportionate and fit for purpose.
I think that is what the bill provides. At its core, as it says, it does three things. It resets the level of the Sovereign Grant to reflect the fact that the exceptional funding requirement associated with Buckingham Palace's servicing program is coming to an end, therefore bringing down the Sovereign Grant, which would otherwise be rolling forward into the future with the existing formula. Secondly, it does establish a mechanism for calculating the grant in future years, where if the reserve was to fall below 10%, that might trigger a discussion of whether more was needed. If it went above 50%, that might trigger a discussion of whether less was needed.
And thirdly, it introduced powers to adjust the grant in exceptional circumstances. The noble Baroness Neville-Rolfe asked what those might be. If you imagined a catastrophic fire, for example, and one would want to respond to that should that take place. So, taken together, hopefully those changes amount to a measured and a sensible reform. Let me, however, just be clear about what the Sovereign Grant covers and it doesn't cover.
It simply, it does not provide any personal income to any member of the Royal Family.
It doesn't fund private properties, just confirming the question that the noble Baroness Kramer asked. Its purpose is to support the monarch's official duties as the head of state, to maintain the occupied palaces from which those duties are carried out. It supports staffing, official travel, upkeep of buildings used for state occasions, public engagements, constitutional functions. That is its purpose and that only is the purpose of this bill. Now I know Lord Sikka and others have wanted a wider debate about the Royal Family and the funding of the Royal Family.
And I recognize that they've raised questions about taxation, about the position of the Duchies of Lancaster, Lord Berkeley about the Duchy of Cornwall.
And I know these are matters on which the noble Lords hold strong views and considerable expertise. But this bill is targeted, is a targeted piece of legislation. Its purpose is to amend the statutory framework governing the Sovereign Grant so that it continues to operate effectively at the end of the reservicing program with appropriate funds being made available. And I'd like to turn my attention to those matters. We've had questions about adequacy or inadequacy from Lord Redwood and noble Baroness Neville-Rolfe.
Look, the completion of the capital program at Buckingham Palace does not mean that all capital programs have disappeared. There remains a large and complex historic estate that requires ongoing maintenance and long-term planning. That has been included in this budget. There's a need to address maintenance backlog, to address aging systems, to strengthen cyber resilience, which is something I mentioned in my opening speech, to improve energy efficiencies.
These funding requirements have been assessed through a detailed bottom-up assessment of the Royal Household's costs and an assessment of the expectation of the Crown Estate's expected profits over this period. But the key thing is the bottom-up assessment, which comes to 99.9 million, and then that is reflected across to the 20.5% of the Crown Estate. I'll come back to this issue in a little while. So while the bill does reduce the grant, it's done in a way that should reflect the Royal Household's genuine funding requirements for the years ahead, rather than setting the grant to an arbitrary figure. This is something that has gone via the Royal Trustees, including the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Exchequer.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer is my boss, and I think that any thought that money might have been spent where he was marking his own homework would be one to which he would not assent. I think this has been a process of some rigour and a bottom-up process, but it still raises the question, and I think this is a big question for some of the noble members on this side of the House, of is this value for money? And Lord Sikka raised a number of questions about we have poor and needy people in this country, how do you think about the expenditure of this on the Sovereign Grant relative to all the other ways that that money could be spent? And look, might I just be a wee bit challenging on this?
I tried myself to think my way through that, and what could I compare the sovereign grant to? I thought I could compare it to a similar budget for your Lordship's House. It would be two and a half times the size of the sovereign grant. And I wondered if we might reflect on how the people of Britain listening to this debate, who by the way pay both of those bills, how they would assess the value of each.
I don't know for sure what the answer to that question is, but I thought my noble friend Lord Fawkes of Cumnock would recognize the quote from Robert Burns: "Would some power the giftie gie us to see ourselves as others see us." And I don't know what the answer to that question is. By the way, I am a big supporter of your Lordships' House, but I have a sense that the people of Britain would give considerable support to the payment of a sovereign grant for our King to be able to carry out his duties.
George Foulkes
Of course. There's another quotation from Robert Burns: "Wee, sleekit, cow'rin, tim'rous beastie, O, what a panic's in thy breastie!"
And if we were not to stand up and raise questions, we would be accused of being wee, sleekit, cow'rin, tim'rous beasties. And I hope that the noble my noble friend will recognize that members of this House have a duty, a responsibility to raise these matters and we do so with honor and with seriousness.
David Pitt
Absolutely. And and look, I I I was not offering that in any way as a put-down of the debate. Rather, how could I find something that I could compare in government expenditure to the sovereign grant?
And I chose the House of Lords expenditure because I can't see how I compare it to nurses' pay. It's just entirely, it's just entirely different. Noble Baroness Neville-Rolfe asked about the 20.5%. Again, let me reassure Noble Lords that the way the trustees arrive at the relevant figure is a bottom-up assessment of what is required to enable the Royal Household to carry out its duties. It's not by guessing a percentage, and I think the anticipation is that the £99.9 million is something that will carry forward in future years, but with the ability to adjust that I have already discussed.
The Noble Baroness Kramer raised questions about transparency and scrutiny. And look, the government agree that these matters should be subject to proper parliamentary oversight, but it's also important to be accurate about the framework that does exist.
The Sovereign Grant, it is covered by statute. It is subject to reporting and audit requirements on a par with government departments. And the annual amount is authorized by Parliament through the usual supply processes, the relevant accounts laid before Parliament, audited by the National Audit Office. So this is not a case of public funding operating without scrutiny. The task before the House is to ensure that the underlying framework remains workable and proportionate and that the smaller amount that we are offering for the smaller grant in coming years is both adequate but not excessive.
So look, the question before us tonight is just a practical one. Do we leave in place a framework that no longer properly reflects the end of the exceptional servicing expenditure, or do we put in place a revised framework that resets the grant, improves flexibility, and preserves the ability of the grant to fulfill its core purpose? The government's view is that the right course is the latter. My Lords, I think these measures are targeted, proportionate, and fair.
I thank my noble Lords, all my noble Lords, for raising the questions that you have raised, but I think this bill delivers value for money for taxpayers. It improves the existing framework governing the Sovereign Grant so that it continues to operate as Parliament intended, and it ensures that the grant will fulfill its core purpose of supporting the official duties of the monarch and maintaining the occupied royal palaces. My Lords, I beg to move.
Speaker 84
The question is that this bill be now read a second time. As many as of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
Speaker 84
The question is that this bill be not committed. As many as of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
Speaker 84
The question is that this bill be now read a third time.
As many as of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
Speaker 84
The question is that this bill do now pass. As many as of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. My Lords, we now move on.
Protection Against Detriment (Industrial Action) Regulations 2026, Lord Leong.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, the three debates today covers measures that play an important part in the government's plan to make work pay, delivering on our commitments to modernize and improve employment rights for the 21st century. These measures will help us reset and modernize our industrial relations framework. My Lords, I am grateful for the opportunity to debate these important reforms and trust that the House will fully support this package of measures. My Lords, let me turn to our first debate. I beg to move that the House approves the Protection Against Detriment (Industrial Action) Regulations 2026.
I also note the regret amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral, and I'm glad of the opportunity to debate these important reforms, and I will address the concerns raised by the noble Lord in my remarks. This instrument was laid before the House on 24th of June 2026. This instrument relates to protection from detriments for workers taking protected industrial action under the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. This instrument is being introduced to provide essential protections for workers, ensuring they can take industrial action without being treated unfairly by their employer as a result. In 2019, Fiona Mercer was suspended by her employer for participating in and helping to organize lawful strike action.
She brought a claim against her employer under section 146 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations Consolidation Act 1992, or TULRCA. The 2024 Supreme Court Mercer judgment ruled that the current protections against detriment for trade union activity under this section of TULRCA do not extend to protected industrial action. As a result, the Supreme Court issued a declaration of incompatibility between UK legislation and Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to freedom of association.
This means there is a gap in the law that could enable bad faith employers to unfairly penalise workers taking industrial action. While it should always be treated as a last resort, this government believes that industrial action is an integral and vital part of workers' rights to express their collective voice. If a worker chooses to take industrial action, it is essential that employers treat them fairly and with respect, as the vast majority of employers have always done. This statutory instrument fills a legal gap, allowing workers to strike without risking detriment and aligning our law with the European Convention on Human Rights.
The Protection Against Detriment (Industrial Action) Regulations are made under section 236A of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025. These regulations and section 236A prohibit employer detriments aimed at penalising, preventing, or deterring protected industrial action. This government is committed to protecting workers who take industrial action while ensuring that employers are not unduly affected or unduly restricted. The vast majority of employers already act responsibly and do not penalise workers for taking industrial action. This legislation therefore targets the rare cases in which such treatment may occur, without disrupting the day-to-day running of responsible businesses.
That is why this legislation prohibits detriments only for the sole or main purpose of penalizing, preventing, or deterring industrial action. This means that during the period of industrial action, ordinary business practices will not be banned, provided they are not used for the sole or main purpose of penalizing, preventing, or deterring a worker from taking industrial action. For example, a disciplinary action may still be taken against a worker who has committed misconduct unrelated to strike action during an ongoing strike. Employers will still be able to manage industrial action in ways that don't involve imposing unlawful detriment. Examples of this include proactive negotiation before industrial action commences and contingency planning to mitigate the impact of the action.
My Lords, let me now address the matter of wage deductions in the context of industrial actions. An employer should not be obliged to pay a worker for work not done because that worker was on strike. Therefore, in common law, the principle of no work, no pay applies. This means that if a worker does not attend work for a day because of industrial action, the employer is under no obligation to pay them for the day. These regulations state that they do not affect this common law position.
The rules enabling the deduction of pay on account of a worker's participation in protected industrial action will remain as they are.
So this statutory instrument also adds section 236A to the list of claims in schedule A2 to the Trade Union and Labour Relations Consolidation Act. Detriments claims will be added to schedule A2 and an employment tribunal may adjust compensation by 25% based on compliance with the ACAS code of practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures. This promotes fairness, cooperation and prompt dispute resolution, helping employers resume normal business quickly. My Lords, let me turn directly to the regret motion tabled by the noble Lord Hunt.
This motion raises concerns about the timing of the regulations in the context of the government's reforms to industrial action notices and mandates. The noble Lord also expressed concern that there is a risk of increased litigation and administrative burdens resulting from the regulations, which the noble Lord believes will lead to employers delaying legitimate operational decisions and possibly affecting the delivery of critical public services. My Lords, let me address Lord Hunt's concern that regulations and reforms to industrial action notices and mandates will lead to more strikes. My Lords, this will not be the case. At present, employers very rarely impose detriments on workers for taking industrial action.
There have been very few significant cases brought. Therefore, we do not believe that banning all detriments will have a significant impact on the level of industrial action.
In the years 2019 to 2020 and 2020 to 2021, there were 24 and 15 tribunal hearings respectively related to detriments for trade union membership, the closest parallel to this legislation. We expect the number to be similarly low for detriments imposed for industrial action. The Employment Rights Act simplified industrial action notice requirements and extended the mandate length, reducing ballot frequency while ensuring employers get enough notice to prepare to prepare. Providing notice before balloting and action is still required for protection. In addition, employers can still withhold pay from workers taking industrial action and this has always been shown to be the effective deterrent to workers.
In response to the noble Lord's second concern, I do not agree that these reforms will increase litigation and administrative burdens on businesses or cause employers to delay their action. My Lords, in conclusion, this statutory instrument is crucial for protecting workers' rights to industrial action and aligning our law with the European Convention on Human Rights. It prevents bad faith employers from exploiting the legislative gap highlighted by the Supreme Court while allowing good faith employers to handle industrial action non-punitively and continue normal practices. I hope all noble Lords will support this instrument.
Speaker 84
Question is that this motion be agreed to.
Amendment, Lord Hunt of Wirral.
David Hunt
My Lords, I'm very grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument to which I have tabled a regret amendment. And I look forward to hearing the speeches of the noble Baroness Carberry of Muswell Hill and Lord Davies of Brixton, who bring considerable knowledge based on their long service in the trade union movement and in the field of employment relations. So they will probably understand my approach, which is that I believe these regulations risk taking this country back towards an industrial relations culture which most people thought had been left behind decades ago.
When I, of course, I served in the House of Commons and I go back 50 years, but I look in particular to 1979, mainly to the winter of discontent, when 29 and a half million working days were lost to industrial disputes. Public services were disrupted right across the country and the consequences for ordinary people, in particular my constituents in Merseyside, were severe. It remains one of only three years since 1926 in which more than 20 million working days were lost to industrial action. That history ought to make any government extremely cautious about legislation which further weakens the consequences of industrial action, and yet these regulations choose the broadest possible approach.
Now, the government's own consultation shows where the concerns lie. Of the 27 employer respondents, 22 were large employers with more than 250 staff. Employer respondents overall opposed prohibiting every detriment by 16 to 9. Among business representative organisations, 9 out of 11 opposed this blanket approach. These are the organisations responsible for managing workforces, maintaining operations, and delivering services during industrial disputes.
And the majority of them warned ministers that this approach goes too far and will likely harm industrial relations further.
The cost to the economy will be real and they could be very substantial indeed. An employer may still discipline genuine misconduct or take decisions for legitimate operational reasons. But if, however, a worker alleges that the real purpose was to penalise industrial action, the employer may find itself having to defend that decision before a tribunal.
The risk is that managers become more reluctant to take perfectly legitimate decisions on performance, discipline, staffing or business continuity for fear that these decisions will later be challenged as a detriment. And the government's own consultation confirms, and I quote, "any increase in strike activity could indirectly affect households through service disruptions, transport, education, creating externalities that raise household costs." Stating the obvious, perhaps, but where is the obvious conclusion that strike activity should continue to be the last resort? The impact of these regulations will hit the public sector and therefore taxpayers the hardest. Since 2022, around 70% of workers involved in labour disputes have been public sector workers and around 80% of stoppages have occurred in the public sector.
Around half of all working days lost over that period were in the public sector.
The increased costs that this legislation adumbrates are going to fall on passengers waiting for trains, parents whose children cannot get to school, and patients waiting for treatment. We don't have to speculate about what rogue industrial disruption looks like. Earlier this year, RMT industrial action on the London Underground caused significant disruption, with tube journeys falling sharply during strike days and some lines unable to operate normally. In the NHS, the consequences are even more serious.
During the BMA resident doctors' strikes in July 2025 alone, over 54,000 appointments and procedures were postponed. Now, taking the measures in the Employment Rights Act cumulatively, the direction of travel is always towards more power for the trade unions, more legal risks for the employers, and fewer protections for the public who depend on uninterrupted services. And the government can't even tell us how much all this is going to cost. Its own options assessment states that it has not been able to put a figure on the costs or benefits or the potential impact on businesses and the public sector. Yet ministers have chosen the widest possible option regardless.
And there is, of course, a broader question of public interest here. Industrial relations law must strike a balance, and these regulations tilt that balance too far. The lessons of the 1970s must not be forgotten.
Britain paid a heavy price when industrial relations became dominated by confrontation and disruption. We should not be taking steps that risk returning us towards that model. I beg to move.
Speaker 86
My Lords, the original question was that the regulations laid before the House on the 24th of June be approved, since when an amendment has been moved by Lord Hunt of Wirral at end to insert the words set out on the order paper.
The question I therefore have to put is that this amendment be agreed to.
Speaker 87
Lords, I am very sorry and disappointed that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, is seeking to reopen the principle, an important principle behind these regulations, a principle that has been endorsed in both Houses in the Employment Rights Act, and a principle that was well debated where the arguments were well aired as the bill was going through the House before it became the Employment Rights Act. As my noble friend the Minister has recalled, the principle we're talking about is that a worker should not suffer a detriment simply for exercising the lawful right to take protected industrial action, and I emphasize lawful.
The amendment before us regrets that the regulations prohibit all detriments for taking protected industrial action. And I was expecting that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, might have been arguing that he preferred a closed list, in which case I might have been able to express some sympathy with his arguments, although I would take him to task. But I think that I interpret the noble Lord's speech as preferring there to be no list at all, and therefore no limit at all on any punitive action that could be taken against a worker who is simply exercising a lawful right, and perhaps the noble Lord could clarify that.
As the noble lord Lord Hunt reminded us, the government consulted business and other stakeholders only on two options and that two options were a prescribed list or a complete ban. And the government set out their conclusions earlier this year and the minister in the other place further elaborated on this in a meeting of the delegated powers committee last month. And essentially the government concluded that a closed list might initially appear more certain, but they opted for a complete ban, which is what the noble lord very much regrets. In the consultation, there were credible arguments in favor of a prescribed list, but the arguments against were much stronger. And essentially, it's not possible to reduce industrial relations to a list of foreseeable forms of retaliation.
A prescribed list of detriments would not give workers the protections they need when they are acting on their lawful right to take industrial action. It's not possible to anticipate all employer potential actions in secondary legislation. An employer who wanted to get round the protection could simply do something that wasn't on the list simply because Parliament hadn't anticipated it. And also a list could become out of date, but again, I anticipate that the noble Lord doesn't want any list at all. And I do recognize the concerns expressed during consultation by some employers and business organizations, as Lord Hunt has set out.
And they are entitled to be assured that these regulations won't stop legitimate management decisions or expose employers to random claims.
And I contend that the government has provided that reassurance. The regulations don't provide workers with a general immunity from adverse treatment. They apply a statutory purpose test. The employer's act or deliberate failure to act must have the sole or main purpose of preventing, deterring, or penalizing the worker. And my lords, that is a significant threshold.
As my noble friend the minister said, these regulations don't make every management decision that might affect a person on strike unlawful.
The purpose test provides a safeguard. And Lord Hunt's amendment points to the risk of increasing litigation and burdens with adverse effects on employers' day-to-day business activities. No one wants more tribunal cases. Nobody wants to see more burdens on businesses. But there isn't any evidence that that is what is going to follow.
An employer will still be able to manage its business. It can make contingency arrangements, reorganise work, deal with genuine misconduct and take decisions for legitimate operational reasons. And to underline the point made by my noble friend the Minister, the regulations do not prevent the ordinary deduction of pay for time not worked because of a strike.
The regulations do not give workers immunity from management action. They address something much narrower: the use of management power to punish or deter the exercise of a statutory right. Nor does it seem likely that we'll see more tribunal cases for reasons my noble friend the Minister has set out. These regulations are preventative. They provide clarity.
There is no reason to believe that they will lead to more litigation. And I will underline the point: the right to take protected industrial action is a statutory right.
A right that can be deliberately frustrated through an employer's choice of sanction is not a particularly meaningful right. These regulations don't seek to tilt the balance of industrial relations in favor of one side. They establish a boundary around the exercise of managerial power. Legitimate management remains legitimate. Retaliation for exercising a lawful statutory right does not.
Bryn Davies
The noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral, has tabled a regret motion, but I'm going to explain why I think the House should not share his regrets. And I thank my noble friends, Baroness Carbury of Muswell Hill and Lord Lyon. But first I have to give my apologies because I'm not at now able to stay for the other two debates which I have my name down for this evening, although I think those in the House can probably understand my views on those by read-across from my views on this one. I shouldn't probably shouldn't be here for this one, but I feel so strongly on this and the other issues that are before the House this evening that I feel compelled to speak out.
The truth is, I know which side I'm on. I'm on the side of the worker and how we all gain, workers and employers alike, from good and effective industrial relations. And essentially, this is what these regulations are all about. Getting rid of oppressive anti-trade union legislation is a means to that end. Turning to these regulations, they deal with a gap in the law that the Supreme Court has already identified in the Mercer case.
Fiona Mercer, a care worker, was suspended as a result of taking part in lawful industrial action.
The court found that the existing framework gave workers no protection against detriment short of dismissal for taking part in industrial action. It held that this was incompatible with the right to freedom of association under Article 11 of the European Convention that was inserted by the Employment Rights Act last year, and under that act there is the power to close this gap. Now, this gap has real consequences, as Ms. Mercer's case is not an isolated one.
In the Communication Workers Union's dispute with Royal Mail in 22 and 23, the employer imposed disproportionate disciplinary sanctions, restricted sick pay, and reallocated overtime to agency workers. In the RMT's dispute with Southern Rail between 2016 and 2018, members lost their free travel passes, and so did their families and dependents. Their car parking permits were withdrawn, and all their pay was withheld until the passes and permits were returned. Their applications for rest day working were refused. None of this was dismissal, and none of it was unlawful under the law as it stood and stands, but each of these measures caused real and material harm.
Now the effect goes beyond the individuals involved.
When workers know they can be penalized in these ways, some of them will decide not to take part in action they are legally entitled to take. The rights exist in law, but in practice it is restricted. This matters for the way disputes are resolved. Industrial action, we all agree, should be the last resort, and most disputes are settled by negotiation, and many, most, settled before any strike takes place.
Negotiation works, the essential process of achieving agreement because both sides know the workers can in the end withdraw their labor. If using that right carries penalties, even though short of dismissal, the balance in negotiations moves towards the employer. Perhaps those on the other side of the debate could say whether they think employers should be able to dismiss employees for going on strike, because what's the difference? It's the pressure on the worker that makes the point. The TUC emphasizes that trade unions are essential to rebalance power in the labor market, and these regulations are consistent with that aim.
The noble Lord Lord Hunt of Wirral waves the spectre of a return to the 70s.
Well, I think we've moved on a long time there, and the legislation, much of the legislation post that time is already in force. Now, the government consulted, as my noble friend Baroness Carberry of Musselburgh has explained, the extensive consultation and the decision to go to not use the list has been explained. The test here, just to emphasize the point, is whether the sole or main purpose of the employer's action was to penalize workers for taking part in protected industrial action, for exercising their democratic rights, or to prevent or deter them from doing so. Tribunals have much practice in applying that test. It's not new.
So these regulations are essential to close in a measured way the gap that the Supreme Court has already identified.
Dave David Goddard
My Lords, I will be reasonably brief as we carry the scars from the original employment bill as it wended its way through many an hour past midnight today. And throughout the passage of that bill, we on these benches argued for a proportionate and reasonable approach, one that gives employees adequate rights without placing undue burdens on the business. These regulations should be judged by that test. At present, the law protects workers from being dismissed for taking part in lawful industrial action, but not from lesser penalties, such as cut shifts, a withheld bonus, or a missed promotion.
Whatever views one takes of the gap, employers and workers are entitled to know where the line falls. The law should provide clarity on this issue, not obscurity. The test is narrow, and that matters. The detriment must have the sole or main purpose of penalising, preventing, or deterring protected action. So I would be grateful if the Minister could confirm a couple of points to me on the record, since employers will read the decisions of this debate tonight.
That ordinary management decisions taken during a dispute remain lawful, that discipline for misconduct unrelated to disputes are still unaffected, and that employers still can deduct pay for days not worked. And I have three practical questions for the Minister. Firstly, guidance. The explanatory memorandum says guidance will be updated this month.
The regulations will take effect from the 30th of October. So what exactly will be published? And will ACAS be ready to answer the questions from small employers? Secondly, pay. The explanatory memorandum accepts the rules on how much pay may be deducted for strike days are complex, and an employer who gets that figure wrong could face a claim.
Will the guidance set out how proportional deductions should be calculated, and with worked examples? And finally, tribunals. The tribunal system, as we know, is already under strain. What assessment have the government made of the likely numbers of claims under these regulations, and will they monitor and report back to this House?
The noble Lord Hunt raises fair questions about litigation and public services, and I hope the Minister answers them tonight. Clear answers on guidance and monitoring will give employers and workers the clarity they really need, perhaps more than a regret motion does.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, let me thank all noble Lords for their contributions, and I'm very grateful to the support from my noble friends for support across the House for the Protection Against Detriment (Industrial Action) Regulations 2026. Let me address the several questions that noble Lord Hunt asked earlier in respect to strike days. Let me share some statistics with him.
Across 2024 and 2025, there was an annual average of 773,000 days lost to industrial action. This is a decrease from the highs of 2022 and 2023 under the previous government, where 2.5 million and 2.6 million days were lost to strike action, the most for over three decades, but a significant increase from the previous decade, which saw an average loss of 345,000 days per year between 2012 and 2019.
Let me remind him again, in the years 2019 to 20 and 2020 to 2021, there were respectively 24 and 15 tribunal hearings related to detriments for trade union membership, the closest parallel to this legislation. So we expect the number to be similarly low for detriments imposed for industrial action. The noble Lord also asked about protecting public services. My Lords, protecting patients, service users and public remains essential. Employers can take genuine measures to maintain critical operations and address health and safety risks.
These regulations do not require managers to ignore safeguarding concerns. Fair treatment of workers and responsible management of essential services must operate together. And then he did ask also about whether there was a full impact assessment.
I agree with the noble lord, employers' concerns deserve a substantive answer. We conducted a consultation, recorded concerns about litigation, administration, and operational flexibility, and we considered them. The department judged the expected impact fell below the threshold requiring a full impact assessment, reflecting the limited use of these detriments. However, we will monitor implementation through stakeholder feedback, and the published memorandum commits to a review in 2031. The memorandum also identifies the ten million annual equivalent net direct cost to business threshold and the planned non-statutory review.
The noble lord also asked about business burden on businesses. Responses to our consultation show that employers rarely, if ever, and I said this earlier, impose detriments for taking industrial action. These changes will have a very limited impact for the vast majority of employers. It is general good practice for employers to keep records of businesses and disciplinary discussions, decisions rather, relating to workers. These records will help to defer from any speculative claims.
And also the burden on recording employer decisions. I mean, there is no evidence to suggest workers will bring additional speculative claims as a result of this legislation.
Workers are already protected from detriments for their trade union membership and general activities. So our understanding is that few speculative claims are brought under those provisions, so we would not expect this to lead to any increase in such cases. My Lords, I think the noble Lord Goddard asked about the pay deduction and all that. The question of the precise amount of pay that can be deducted is subject to a complex case law and depends on the particular facts and circumstances, including the worker's contractual terms and ways of working. So it would therefore not be practical to codify this case law in these regulations.
That position is not made any more complex by these regulations.
So the majority of cases, the matter for pay deduction is simple and often corresponds to one day's pay withheld for one day's strike. My Lords, on the question about guidance, I would have to write to the noble Lord after speaking to officials on that. But I know we obviously this is going to take effect from the 30th of October this month. This statutory instrument addresses a simple issue which I am sure all members support, namely protecting workers from unfair treatment if they take industrial action. Many will have thought this basic protection already exists in legislation.
However, the 2024 Supreme Court judgment showed that this statutory instrument is necessary to ensure workers are properly protected. This legislation will close this gap and ensure workers are properly protected. My Lords, I beg to move that this statutory instrument be approved.
David Hunt
My Lords, I'm very grateful to all those who've participated in what has been a very important debate. I'd just say to the noble Baroness, Carbury of Muswell Hill, I do admire her great record. She rightly received recognition for her services to industrial relations, employment relations. But I do think several of the points she raised were answering a speech I hadn't made, but I could have made. And I'd just say to the noble Lord, Lord Davies of Brixton, I always admire him because he's a fellow of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries.
So his words are always, particularly on pensions, to be taken very carefully. But really, we just ask again, and I thought Lord Goddard of Stockport posed three key questions, and I don't think they have been properly answered. No doubt we'll await further responses. But I would just say to everyone, these regulations are moving in the wrong direction. I remember fighting the election towards the end of the nineties, when Tony Blair, who did win the election in 1997, actually promised faithfully that he would not reverse the legislation that had been enacted after the winter of discontent.
He was put on the spot, okay, but he promised that, and it was fulfilled during that period of Labour government, there was no attempt to do what the minister is now asking the House to approve. And I just say, don't let's forget history. It teaches us a great deal. Industrial relations has to strike a balance between the rights of workers to take lawful industrial action, the rights of employers to manage their organisations, and in particular the rights of the public who rely on essential services. And as I said before, these regulations tilt that balance too far.
For these reasons, I regret these regulations and I do urge the government to reconsider them, preferably before it is too late.
But in the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw the motion.
Speaker 86
Is it your pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn. The question therefore is that the original motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content.
The contents have it. We now come to questions on a statement made in the House of Commons on Monday the 12th of October, international update.
Howe
I'm grateful to the noble baroness, the leader of the House, for allowing time for questions on this statement.
In the other place, my right honourable friend, the Leader of the Opposition, set out some of the serious challenges we're facing as a country, many of which cannot be solved through international engagement without serious hard work at home. As an official opposition, we are willing to work with the government on defence, on welfare spending, and on support for our allies across the world, particularly Ukraine. The Prime Minister's statement was upbeat in its tone, but it was perhaps a pity that he couldn't have said more about the specific challenges that we are facing as a country. The Prime Minister spoke at some length about the opportunities of a new trade deal with the European Union that might cut through barriers faced by UK exporters.
It was encouraging to hear him express confidence that such a deal was attainable. Can the noble Baroness say what has led the Prime Minister to express that degree of confidence that a better deal with the EU is within reach? He said that there's a deal, quote, on the table, but what we didn't hear was what the EU could expect us to concede in return. Will there be any red lines in our position, and if so, what will they be? On this side of the House, we of course want to see stronger economic growth, but if we look at what's happening in the EU as regards growth, it's not encouraging.
This week, Chancellor Merz of Germany, the Italian Prime Minister Meloni, and the Belgian Prime Minister De Wever all called for an emergency brake mechanism to help boost the EU's flagging economic competitiveness. My Lords, that shows that EU leaders themselves recognize the economic risks of over-regulation. So can the noble Baroness explain why the Prime Minister feels that new agreements with the EU would unlock growth when EU leaders themselves are battling against over-regulation within the bloc? On a specific point included in this prospective trade deal, the Prime Minister referred to energy prices in Northern Ireland. He said, and I quote, "In Northern Ireland, the proposed energy deal could cut wholesale energy costs by 20%."
I emphasize the word wholesale. I was puzzled by that and would be glad if the noble Baroness could explain what precisely he meant.
My Lords, I was heartened to see the Prime Minister's unequivocal and steadfast support for Ukraine. That is a position on which we have had cross-party consensus since Putin's illegal invasion, and I welcome President Zelenskyy's visit today. As to that, on a specific point relating to sanctions, the energy minister, the noble Baroness Lady Curran, said yesterday in the House that the United Kingdom's ban on Russian oil, and I quote, "applies to all oil and oil products that originate in Russia, irrespective of the way that they enter the UK."
I need to ask, was that statement strictly accurate? Can the noble Baroness confirm that under the general trade license for sanctioned processed oil products, some Russian-derived oil products are in fact being imported into this country? Can she say when ministers intend to discontinue that license? The Prime Minister also made a point of committing the UK to meeting our NATO commitments in full. Yesterday, the Defence Secretary warned of the risk that our allies, if attacked, would prioritize the supply of defense equipment for their own defense over agreed supplies to the United Kingdom.
And he went on to emphasize the strategic importance of building our sovereign defense supply capabilities.
However, we understand from the Prime Minister that we will have to wait until the spending review, possibly as late as next autumn, for confirmation of when the United Kingdom will hit the interim 3% spending target. Now, if we want to build our sovereign defence capabilities, that is a long delay that leaves our own defence manufacturing sector in limbo. My Lords, does the noble Baroness agree with the Defence Secretary on the importance of homegrown defence?
And if she does agree, can she confirm that we're going to have to wait until next autumn before we know the date by which the government plan to hit the 3% interim target? The recent Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia have demonstrated how important our defense capability is. I know we've committed an RAF Voyager refueling aircraft to support Saudi Arabia, but in light of the most recent attacks, what further support will we provide? If the leader of the house can't answer that today, will she write to me on the point? We know that the Houthis have been emboldened by Iran, and it's very likely that the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps is behind the threat to RAF Fairford.
What reassessment of the threat have ministers made following the incident at RAF Fairford, and can the noble baroness say what, if any, practical steps to boost security at our airbases are planned? My lords, let me turn briefly to the threats posed to our overseas territories.
The Prime Minister is right to have announced a review of the 35 billion Chagos treaty with Mauritius, which has been overwhelmingly unpopular. Can the noble baroness say when this review of the policy is set to be completed? And finally, my lords, we've heard increasingly aggressive rhetoric from Javier Milei, the President of Argentina, on the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands. The Falklands are British. The islanders are clear on that.
It was reassuring to read in today's press of the amphibious assault exercise conducted in the Falklands by soldiers of the Parachute Regiment.
On the other hand, we hear that HMS Protector, which we rely on to patrol the Southern Atlantic, is out of action following engine failure. I'd be grateful if the noble Baroness could reassure us that His Majesty's Government will continue not only to defend our sovereignty over the Falkland Islands, but also ensure that we are prepared for any eventuality.
Jeremy Purvis
My Lords, these benches agree with the Prime Minister that the UK needs to be a consistent and stable partner on the international stage. We want to build and maintain relationships, and that is why it's been especially necessary for those for our emerging economies where our interests are developing, like in Africa. It is therefore a disappointment that this job is made harder for the UK by a constant shift of ministerial positions, for example, three ministers for Africa in just two years.
What is definitely not consistent or stable partnership is the Trump administration. The US decision to assist the Russian war effort is reprehensible. The UK must do what we can to ensure that the US cannot circumvent our sanctions. The Prime Minister's statement does reference the refined oil sanctions, and as the noble Lord Earl Howe had indicated, he referred to the sanctions that were introduced in the spring.
I might be able to help him on his question that he asked the leader because the open-ended exemption of the refined oil products in third countries has now got a sunset clause attached to it as a result of my discussions with Minister Stephen Doughty, who wrote to me on the 11th of June that this exemption will be sunsetted on January the 1st, and the government issued a statement on gov.uk. I hope the official opposition has access to the internet. Can the leader, however, confirm that this remains the case under the Burnham premiership? I very much hope so. I raised this with Lord Wood at questions and I hope the leader can confirm that that loophole will be coming to an end and be able to withstand any pressure from the Trump administration.
We also agree that the government needs to be resolute in our defense against any Iranian intervention in the UK, and we need a further assessment as to how the IRGC manages to communicate, coordinate, and potentially conduct activity here at home. I hope that the leader will update us on how we are closing all of those opportunities, but also ensuring that there are no legal means by the no means by which transnational repression by Iranian terrorist organizations, proscribed organizations, can target individuals here in the United Kingdom, including journalists. With regards to external influence, we welcome the Prime Minister's statement with regards to Russian interference in British politics, especially on that associated with the Brexit referendum. Now, the leader of the opposition has denied that there's been any Russian interference with regards to that.
So I went back to the Russia report, and it's interesting that paragraph 46 of the Russia report is less definitive than what the leader of the opposition suggests that it is. However, the difficulty we have in Parliament and indeed the public is the very last sentence when the ISC Russia report drew what it considered to be its conclusions, because after outlining all of the information that it presented, the last sentence of the last conclusion states, I quote, "However, we have found asterisk asterisk asterisk which suggests that asterisk asterisk asterisk dot asterisk asterisk asterisk." This is not helping us have full disclosure as to the extent of Russian interference.
So given the Prime Minister's statement on Monday and today, it is now time to publish much more material when it comes to the Russian interferences without three asterisks deleting critical information. We hope that the government's efforts for agreement on food safety, for energy and law enforcement will be successful with the European Union. The Leader of the Opposition said in reference to seeking improvements in our relationship with the EU compared to the Brexit deal, I can quote from Hansard, "he is not going to get a better deal." These benches thinks that the previous government would have found it hard to get a worse deal and proven to the fact that it's take took them years to mitigate problems with Northern Ireland and it's taken the current government to have agreement with Gibraltar.
And I does I do hope that the Noble Earl Howe when referencing the Falkland Islands and our our commitment to that territory, which I have been to. The previous government forgot to include the Falklands in the negotiating mandate on Brexit at all. So when I was there, they were furious that they had struggles with Brexit. So we welcome the government's efforts to have a better agreement. Now I was confused with the position that we've just heard because in the Commons, the leader of the opposition criticized the Prime Minister for outlining the objectives of these talks.
She said, I quote, "I will tell him as a former trade secretary, this is not how you conduct negotiations." Now we're being asked what the government's red lines are. So there's a lack of consistency, I think, from the position of the opposition.
But whilst we want the government to be successful in these negotiations, these are far too modest ambitions. The Prime Minister said that if the government is successful in achieving everything that it wants, it will be the equivalent of a 10 billion pound benefit a year after the 14th year. But we are losing close to 90 billion pounds a year now. And therefore the government really does need to remove the red lines. The statement, I'm afraid, as I draw to a close, the statement, I'm afraid, is silent on the world's worst humanitarian crisis on Sudan.
Absolutely silent. The UK is the penholder at the Security Council. And we've now had very credible information of the use of chemical weapons on civilians in this conflict. And the government does need to be clear as to what its intents are.
Are the government seeking a full investigation by the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons, which is desperately needed to ensure that there is no further scar on the humanity that we are now turning a blind eye to the use of chemical weapons in this conflict? Finally, I hope the leader can reassert the position on Sudan that we remain determined to see a civilian-led government. We will not open an embassy in Khartoum until we have a civilian-led government, and we will make sure that there are efforts to protect civilians in this ongoing humanitarian crisis.
Speaker 91
Well, first of all, can I thank both noble Lords for their comments and questions?
I'll do my best to answer as many as possible, and for the tone in which they expressed those. There's a lot in this statement, and it shows the extent of the Prime Minister's work since he took office just before the summer recess. And you know, it's like a tour around the world in some places, the different issues as well as the issues at home. Can I start, I think both noble Lords raised the issue of the annual threat update we've seen and the issue about Russian interference. And this is serious.
I don't know if members had the opportunity to read Sir Ken McCallum's speech and the questions and answers he took, which I thought was highly significant in the way that he expressed himself as well.
He did stress that there is an important difference between those attempts and the impact they can have. But it's also a matter of record that a lot of activity the Russians did against elections and during the Brexit campaign, though there's not the evidence that it had much impact, but inevitably they will try for a reason and they continue to try and that is escalating. And I found Sir Ken's speech both alarming and encouraging.
And I think the work that our agencies do to protect us, much of which we will never know about or the details of, is seriously impressive. The noble Lord asked about Ukraine, and he's right. Absolutely, I think the cross-party from both Houses' support for Ukraine, as we saw when President Zelenskyy visited here and he's been back in the UK, and he saw the King today and the Prime Minister. That support, it can't just be moral support and words, it has to be very practical support. And that was committed, and the Prime Minister said before the meeting he won't go away empty-handed today.
And it is ongoing, and I think it's important the House, both Houses, remain totally united and steadfast and robust in our support for Ukraine. Now, it's not, it's also about our own defense as well, and there's a self-interest in that, and it's really important that we carry on with that support.
The sanctions, as he know... we talked about, and the noble Lord asked about the dates when the current situation on oil and gas... currently, he's right, I think it's about 90% of all Russian oil is sanctioned, and that includes products that are refined outside Russia, even though they've originated from Russia as well. The noble Lord Howard also asked about the defense review and... sorry, not the defense review, the spending review, and about the commitment and NATO spending. And he sort of implied that because we've committed to reaching the NATO commitments and spending 3.5% by 2035, that nothing was happening in the meantime.
It's a process to get to that and the spending review will outline the process to that. But can I tell him the amount of money the previous government, when we left office in as a Labour government previously, we were spending over 2.5%. That went down under the Conservative government. And I don't think the Conservative government ever got to 2.5% of spending on defense. That has now increased and we've over 2.5%.
And the amount of investments being made in our defense industry is hugely significant. We're investing 300 billion pounds over the next four years. The Ministry of Defense budget will reach 74 billion pounds in 2027-28. And by 2029-30, we'll be 27% higher in real terms than in 2023-24.
So it's not a case of sit back, wait, we have the spending review and make an announcement. This is ongoing expenditure investment that's going on now and should continue to do so. And I think he's right to say we don't sit back and wait, we can't afford to do that. The security of the nation is a government's first responsibility. The, he also, there was also a question about the Iran and the IRGC.
Noble Lords will recall the state's threats legislation this House passed and they are now designated. And I think that is critical and that was also referenced I think in the speech that MI5 and comments from the Prime Minister. I think the issue of tying this in with Russia as well, the unwillingness of the last government to ask the questions about Russia are really important.
And I think as the Prime Minister said today, the leader of the opposition in a previous role said she hadn't even read the report. And I think it, you know, we do need to ensure that we are open with people. I think unless the public understand the nature of the threats and why the government wants to spend more money on defence, it's really hard to make the case. And so keeping people informed, understanding the nature of threats, understand the reality of what this means is going to be absolutely crucial. Sometimes though, asterisks are going to be really important because there is information that can't be provided in the public domain for national security reasons.
And I would trust the ISC to know when that is the case and when it isn't. The noble Lord Howe asked why is the Prime Minister confident he can get a better deal from the EU?
I think I'd say it's hard to get a worse one. If we look at what's been happening and I looked at some of the figures about the amount of produce that is being wasted at the moment because of red tape. The Conservative Party, I always believed in the past, was a party that wanted to reduce red tape and reduce bureaucracy for businesses. And yet it seems when it's Brexit that's caused it, it isn't the same problem. And yet there are so many producers that are seeing their products rotting at portside, being destroyed.
The amount of paperwork to export Scottish salmon, which is a major contributor to our economy, is absolutely shocking at present.
And it's actually costing millions of pounds to the economy every year. So I wouldn't say that we can be guaranteed there's a deal, but the work is going on to make sure we do get the deal. And the deal, you know, the agri-food and drinks of the SPS will add up to five billion pounds a year, which will help supermarkets, it'll give better prices. But also it's a respect to those that are producing our food that it doesn't go rotten on the quayside. So if the noble Lord wants to say to farmers we think the deal we've got is a good one, then I think he's on his own as far as I'm concerned.
I think it is a poor deal. And the, you know, we will do everything we can and engage with Europe to get a better deal for people of this country, as the Prime Minister has been very clear on this. Unless we do so, is the Chief Whip nodding? No.
I've run out of time. I'm being told I've run out of time. So for those questions I haven't answered, I will come back to during the course of other questions.
Speaker 15
My lords, we now come to up to 20 minutes of backbench questions and the first question will come from the Conservative benches.
Speaker 92
My lords, the noble lady the speaker said that we have a moral and practical obligation still to support Ukraine and I'm sure we all agree on that.
So can I ask why the government has reduced the money given to hosts who are hosting Ukrainian families from £350 to £100 a month? I declare an interest as someone hosting or has hosted a Ukrainian family and we have another one coming soon.
Speaker 91
I have to say to the noble lady, I'm not aware of that at all. Friends of mine are hosting a Ukrainian family and they haven't raised it with me at any point. So I'll have to write to her, go back and check on that. I've asked my colleagues here and we're not aware of that either. So I'll look into that for her and we'll write to her.
Sarah Ludford
My Lords, I thank the noble lady the leader of the house for repeating the statement. Just briefly, one word on Ukraine.
I think it's extremely important that we remain very solid, and I'm glad that the new Prime Minister is, and that there's such cross-party support. I think it is not only obviously crucial for Ukraine, but I think it's attracting international respect for this country, the degree of consistency and strength that we are showing to Ukraine. But my questions are about Europe, inevitably. I very much welcome the Prime Minister breaking the omertà that has prevailed for many years. But he talks, and I welcome this, about a serious dialogue about the different options for our relationship in the long term.
I think it's important that that dialogue encompasses issues not only of the economy, but also people's sense of identity, which I think was completely neglected in the Brexit referendum. So I think, I hope that will happen.
But you can't have a dialogue about different options unless the Prime Minister is willing to set out what those options are. And I hope that we will hear sooner rather than later about that. I mean, obviously my side is as put forward single market, customs union, and there's going to have to be some kind of stepped approach. So I hope we get some flesh on the bones about that. And just lastly, the noble lady talked about red tape of the Brexit deal, which the red tape-hating Conservatives managed to deliver.
I'm on the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee, and I feel so much for businesses in Northern Ireland which are suffering from the current situation. So solving that would help a great deal.
Speaker 91
I'm grateful to the noble lady. It's always the case when we discuss matters European that the official opposition say we're going too far and the Liberal Democrats say we're not going far enough. So for clarity, let's just be clear. The Prime Minister made very clear that we respect the result of the referendum. We are not removing our red lines.
They are clearly in place. And as he puts it, and I think he's right to do it in these terms, that yes, he's concerned about the damage Brexit's done to the economy and concerned about economic growth. But he's also concerned about trust in politics. And in our last manifesto, we were clear about the red lines. In fact, the Brexit referendum informed the manifesto when we said about the red lines.
But what he's also said, he wants to have all options on the table, so there's no predetermined outcome. And he'll come forward with more discussions on that.
And they should involve all parties and everyone should be able to contribute to those discussions. I think she's right on the issue on Northern Ireland. Somebody mentioned the Falkland Islands, that Falkland Islands wasn't considered during Brexit. I don't remember Northern Ireland being discussed during the Brexit debate. I do remember a former Prime Minister telling businesses in Northern Ireland, don't worry, there'll be no checks, no forms for you to fill in.
If they do, if you get any, send them to me. Now, I don't know if Boris Johnson has had all those forms that the Northern Ireland businesses have to complete sent to him. But it was, people did not understand the full implications. So if we can remove some of the export health certificates, product sampling costs, and if we can remove some of that red tape and bureaucracy in the discussions that are ongoing at the summit, that would be a good thing for businesses and for growth of this country.
But yes, there will be there's going to have to be a proper assessment. And I would have thought it is wrong for any government to not look at decisions that have been taken and make assessments of where it's been beneficial and where it's been damaging. And a proper assessment of any benefits and disbenefits and the impact on this country. And I think the Prime Minister's made his views clear on it, but that kind of assessment is needed to look at what action could be taken further in the future. But he's been clear that would have to be agreed by the public as he says the public are the boss.
Speaker 95
My Lords, would the noble lady agree that in the light of the increasing threats to Middle East bases used by American aircraft and the losses of aircraft on those bases, that their interest in the continuing availability of Diego Garcia as UK sovereign territory is now ever more important and explains why in President Trump's exchanges with the Prime Minister, the President emphasized once again the importance of Diego Garcia and its sovereignty to UK?
Speaker 91
The noble Lord makes a key point. We regard the Diego Garcia as a key strategic military asset for both the UK and the US and discussions are ongoing. It's our shared security that is important and we work together on this.
Now, maintaining the long-term operation of the base is really important and the Prime Minister will continue to discuss that. That's been driving the negotiations that we've had since I think about 2022 the negotiations started and they've as you're aware it's like sometimes been three steps forward and one step back or two steps back even. So as the Prime Minister's already said we continue to work, he will be discussing with the American administration and with the President these issues to see if we can reach a conclusion and an agreement.
Speaker 96
My Lords, I've been struck during my relatively short time in your Lordships' House by the increasing frequency in which AI contributes in discussions and questions in this chamber. And I'd therefore like to ask my noble friend the Leader of the House if she can confirm that it's the government's view and position that decisions about regulation of AI should be taken by democratically elected governments expressing sovereign intent on behalf of their citizens rather than by industry leaders alone. And if that's the case, this will require significant international collaboration through a variety of mechanisms. And is this therefore a position that the government is prepared to advocate in its international discussions and especially in the forthcoming G20 summit?
Speaker 91
Short answer is yes.
Slightly longer answer is government's already said that this will be a key focus for when we are chairing the, holding the chair of the G20 that's coming up. So it will be discussed at the summit no doubt, but the G20 meetings, there will be discussions around this. The issues I think we've got to look at are the security, the benefits that can accrue, where are the dangers, and how we work together internationally. This isn't something that any one country can do with on their own. It has to be a global effort, and it has to be governments looking at how they can benefit their citizens through AI, but also how they can protect their citizens from AI when essential.
So the work is going on. I think we're the first time the government has a dedicated AI minister that sits around the cabinet table. We also have across every single department, indeed we've discussed it at cabinet on more than one occasion already, every minister, every department has responsibilities around AI.
It's not something, as I think Noble Baroness Lady Tricross said today, you can't put it in a box and say it's in just one area. It's got to be across government and across nations, so it's going to be a key focus for our Prime Minister at the G20.
Speaker 97
I'm grateful to the Noble Lady, the Leader of the House, for allowing us to have this debate. Can I raise a particular matter? The Prime Minister mentioned Fairford, and he said, quote, "it's almost certainly directly the IRGC", and quite properly and correctly has sanctioned two Iranian individuals who the government believes were responsible, for which I congratulate him. But will she understand the revulsion, and I choose the word with care, that many of us felt at the photograph of our Foreign Secretary shaking hands with the Foreign Minister of Iran?
I honestly felt gut-wrenched to see that my Foreign Secretary should shake hands with a person who is a member of the government of Iran. And does he not accept that that sort of photograph and earlier messages that have been sent will lead to a result in the Israeli elections which he may not be happy with? And care should be taken at this very sensitive time to avoid making those sort of handshakes, comments that will lead to people taking a view in the Israeli elections which we might not be happy with.
And can I finally ask her, and I accept that she may not have a briefing on this point, for the government's response to the announcement yesterday that President Abbas, who is in the 21st year of his four-year period, has announced again the postponement of elections in November. When the government recognized the state of Palestine, we were told that this would lead to a democratic state. We were told that there would be a player in the region who could be respected, and yet they have cancelled their elections. And I have received messages from Palestinians, particularly in East Jerusalem, who are really upset with this, and I'd be interested to know the government's perspective and views on this announcement.
Speaker 91
I'm grateful to the noble Lord.
He will be aware, you know, where the Foreign Secretary will pull no punches in his discussions with ministers from Iran, and he's been very clear on that. Governments through many years have been having meetings, and we need to keep that engagement open. We do have British citizens that are in prison in Iran, and we want to do everything we can to support them. So it's a meeting, but I understand the point he makes. Can I say that on the Palestinian elections, I don't think he's yet seen the joint statement that's been issued by the Foreign Secretary with the foreign secretaries or foreign ministers of Australia, Canada, and France as well.
A joint statement's been issued. It says that they deeply regret the Palestinian President's decision to postpone the elections, as well as the presidential elections in 2027. Now, it's going to be nearly two decades now since there's been elections.
Now, we're deeply disappointed, whilst acknowledging the significant challenges and impediments that affect the ability to conduct elections in a manner fully consistent with international standards. But we commend the important work of the Central Elections Commission in advancing practical preparations to address these challenges and facilitate voter participation. We want to see fair, free and fair elections. And I can give him a copy of the statement if that's helpful to see it from all the Foreign Secretaries. But also to tell him it reiterates at the bottom, I think it's very important, our long-standing position that Hamas can have no role in the future government of Palestine.
Speaker 98
I recall that David Cameron shook hands with the Iranian Foreign Minister at the United Nations.
Diplomacy is about talking to foes as well as friends. My question's about stable, consistent, reliable partner, and about the absence in the statement on Monday of any reference to development aid. Is it, I'd like the leader to ask in her party, the party of Judith Hart and Clare Short, whether it's right that aid to Malawi, for example, 56 million this year, 5 million in 2028-29.
Massive cuts for all of Africa, but not with no softening for the poorest. Malawi is one of the poorest 10 countries in the world or Commonwealth countries. Do the cuts for Africa really have to be that big and do they have to be so heavily skewed against our friends? How does that fit with consistency and stable partnership?
Speaker 91
Yeah, I understand the point the noble lord makes and we remain committed to being able to increase ODA as and when circumstances allow. But he will be aware of the amount of money the government is spending around the world and direct aid through ODA is not the only way to support these countries. The more we can do in partnerships and development, creating and supporting economies, providing humanitarian aid, there's an additional 100 million pounds going in Yemen at the moment to support humanitarian aid there as well.
The needs around the world are greater than ever. Noble Lord Purvis mentioned Sudan as well and support there. So, I take the points back that he makes, but we should not think that the only way we can support our friends and those in need is through direct ODA.
William Wallace
My Lords, the noble lady in her statement today remarked that unless the public understand the nature of the threat, I quote her, they will not be able to help in making sure we resist it. And I'd like to pursue that question. It's quite clear that the previous government did underplay the nature of the threat.
It's equally clear, I've just checked back on some of the notes of this, that Boris Johnson, for example, prevented the Intelligence and Security Committee from publishing a fuller version of the Russia report, partly because it was deeply embarrassing to the Conservative Party. We had under the Conservatives a Defending Democracy Taskforce, but we all of us know very little about it. It does not report to Parliament, unlike its French, Canadian, or Australian equivalents. And the Prime Minister's statement on Monday talks about the new National Centre for Information Defence, about which we so far have almost no detailed information.
Can the noble lady take back to the government the argument that unless our public are educated about the nature of foreign interference in British politics from a range of hostile states, we will not be successful in combating them because the public will not understand when these hybrid threats arise?
Speaker 91
Um, it wasn't quite what I said, but it's the, the, um, it is sort of in that area. And I think he's absolutely right. The public need to understand, and we need an honesty and transparency as far as possible. He'll understand it's not always possible to be completely transparent because our information would put British citizens at risk, or our operations at risk. But if you, you don't have to read very far into the state of threats report from MI5 yesterday and the speech yesterday and the comments made by the Prime Minister, that the threats are many and varied.
And they're threats against individuals, it's threats against infrastructure and the nature of these. Whether we're talking about undersea cables, whether we're talking about cyber attacks, it's varied. And even this week we've seen commercial threats on commercial companies seeing cyber attacks and we don't know where they've come from and how they've been done, but it's a threat nevertheless. So he's right, the public do have to be made aware. I think we have a Prime Minister that is very keen to be as open as he possibly can and we've seen that from many of the things he's said and to look at things in a different way.
So I'm confident that we can have a more grown-up conversation about this. You don't want to alarm people unnecessarily, but we do want to let them know the nature of the threats and what is being done.
And as I mentioned before, the work that's being done by our security services, the counter-terrorism police and our police force in negating those threats and tackling them, many of which we will never hear of because of the fantastic work and the excellent work and the professional work that they are doing. But yes, we have to ensure the public are aware that when the government takes this action, there's a very strong reason for doing so.
Speaker 102
My Lords, despite my continuous requests, Brexit was undertaken with no, I repeat, no economic or social impact study of its effects on the North West region, a region of over six million people. Can my noble friend the Leader of the House undertake that new and improved relationships with the EU will be considered for their economic, social and cultural impacts for all of the regions of the UK?
Speaker 91
One is the kind, the breadth of issues to deal with, economic, social and cultural. We've had debates in this House on many occasions about the cultural impact for our creative industries. But he makes a wider point about all areas of the country being affected and how they, those issues can be addressed. And I think, you know, particularly where we've got Number 10 North looking at economic growth, there is a real determination with this government that we do have these impacts and growth and those kinds of issues looked at across the whole country, not just in a few areas.
And does the Leader of the House agree with the argument made by Sir Tony Blair in his very long essay published in May of this year, where he argued that until the European Union reverses its approach to technology regulation, which in his view is stifling innovation, it will continue to fall behind the United States and China?
Speaker 103
And he argues that until that changes, it would be a very big mistake for the United Kingdom to contemplate rejoining it. Indeed, he said he argued that rejoining the European Union is not the answer to Britain's situation in 2026.
Speaker 91
That's precisely why there has to be a full assessment of what all the options could be so that an assessment can be made of what the country wants to do.
To suggest that everything is right in Europe would be a fallacy and would not do justice to the debate. At the moment we have real concerns about the made in Europe laws and that's part of the negotiations we'll be having at the summit. So I think it's premature to get into the argument he's having because we've not decided on a way forward yet. But the kind of issues of what would be the benefits, what would be the detriments. But I do put to him that when we exited, when we Brexited, we lost the opportunity to influence regulations and laws within Europe.
And so we have this awful situation now where these things are happening and we're just not part of it and able to influence them in any way. But the whole discussion of what the route is forward will be looking at all of these issues because obviously they have to be taken into account.
Speaker 104
My Lords, before I call the next item of business, I'll allow a brief moment for the front bench to rearrange. ACAS Code of Practice on Time Off for Trade Union Duties and Activities, Lord Leong.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, I beg to move that the Committee considers the draft ACAS Code of Practice on Time Off for Trade Union Duties and Activities, which was laid before this House in draft on 6 July 2026. I note the regret motion tabled by the noble Lord Sharpe of Epsom. I'm grateful for the opportunity to debate this code and will address the concerns raised by the noble Lord in my remarks. My Lords, the government believes that strong trade unions are essential for tackling insecurity, inequality, discrimination, enforcement, and low pay. Trade union representatives play an important role, and this government is committed to ensuring that they have the capacity to represent employees and to negotiate with employers.
This government recognizes trade union equality representatives for raising awareness, promoting equal rights and developing policies that help organizations benefit from being equal opportunities employers. That is why through the Employment Rights Act 2025, we strengthened existing rights and introduced new rights for employees who are trade union representatives. The three key changes are: first, the existing right to reasonably paid facility time for trade union representatives to carry out their duties has been strengthened. The legislation now makes clear that where a trade union representative requests paid facility time, it should generally be treated as reasonable and it is for the employer to demonstrate otherwise if challenged in a tribunal.
Secondly, the Act introduces statutory provisions requiring that representatives be provided with reasonable access to facilities such as meeting spaces, communication tools, and appropriate workplace resources to enable them to carry out their duties or undertake relevant training. Thirdly, the Act introduces a new right to reasonably paid time off for trade union equality representatives for specified equality-related purposes. The ACAS Code of Practice on Time Off for Trade Union Duties and Activities, issued under section 199 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, offers practical guidance on the legislation. The code has been updated to reflect Employment Rights Act changes, ensuring effective implementation when new rights come into force in October. It offers clear guidance for employers, trade unions, and representatives on practical application.
During parliamentary scrutiny of the Employment Rights Act, this House sought clarity on how these rights would operate in practice, emphasizing the need to update this code. The revised ACAS code provides guidance, helping employers, trade unions, and representatives understand how the measures should be implemented in the workplace. It explains how these rights should be applied, including activities under statutory duties, factors determining request reasonableness, union-employer communication about time off, and how employer-union arrangements are agreed. Importantly, it supports constructive engagement between employers and unions, encouraging cooperation and clarity over rigid rules to benefit both parties.
My Lords, the code offers clear guidance to help employers confidently handle requests and assist representatives in exercising their rights properly. In that sense, the laying of this code is a necessary step to ensure that the changes made by the Act operate as intended from day one. My Lords, I will now turn to the regret motion tabled by the noble Lord Sharpe of Epsom. This motion raises concerns about the code expanding the right of trade union equality representatives to paid time off. However, it is important that we are clear about the purpose and scope of the code before us today.
This code neither introduces nor extends any new rights or obligations.
The Employment Rights Act established the statutory right for trade union equality representatives to take reasonable time off, recognizing their vital role in supporting members and engaging with employers on equality issues. Effective industrial relations save money by reducing tribunal cases, improving training, and lowering staff turnover. Trade union equality reps help foster constructive engagement on workplace equality. Importantly, the Act clearly sets out the specific equality-related purposes for which this right to be paid time off can be taken. My Lords, this code isn't introducing any new requirements but is narrow and necessary.
Its purpose is to guide the effective implementation of the Act's changes which come into force on 30th of October alongside this code. My Lords, I hope all noble Lords will be able to support this instrument.
Speaker 84
The question is that this motion be agreed to.
Amendment, Lord Sharpe of Epsom.
Andrew Sharpe
My Lords, I'm grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument to which, as he noted, I have tabled a regret amendment. As the noble Lord the Minister pointed out, under these regulations, if a dispute reaches an employment tribunal over the amount of time a union representative proposes to take off, it is for the employer to show that the amount requested was not reasonable. That applies not only to existing trade union representatives but to the new statutory equality representatives created by the Act. Now my Lords, how is that a fair starting point for an employer who is trying to run an organisation?
The employer is responsible for delivering the service, for meeting the order, for keeping the production line moving, for ensuring adequate staffing, serving customers and, in the public sector, ensuring that taxpayers receive the services for which they have paid. Yet when an employee asks to spend paid working time away from their ordinary duties undertaking trade union activity, the presumption now operates against the employer. If there is a challenge, it is the employer who must prove that the amount requested was unreasonable. Now, the government's own impact assessment acknowledges a possible consequence. It states explicitly that employment tribunal claims may increase because the bill places the burden of proof on the employer.
The code states explicitly that what is reasonable will depend on the circumstances in each case. My Lords, that is an invitation to test every case, and we can have little doubt that it will be exploited aggressively by the trade unions to cow employers into submission. The second issue, my Lords, is the creation of statutory rights for trade union equality representatives.
Let us be precise about what this means. The government are not creating a separate new job title in every workplace. They are giving existing employees who are appointed or elected as union equality representatives a statutory entitlement to spend reasonable paid working time carrying out equality-related union functions. But those functions are extraordinarily broad. They include promoting equality in the workplace, arranging equality-related training, consulting the employer on equality issues, obtaining and analysing workplace equality information, and preparing to carry out all those activities.
These regulations could encompass requiring businesses to do document reviews, data analysis, and meeting preparation. There could also be a serious data protection issue.
Equality and pay information may identify individuals, and much of it may constitute special category personal data. The draft code, it noted, was silent on whether employers might be expected to create new material rather than simply provide information which already exists. But I suppose we should be grateful that the code specifies that employer and union activities at least complement one another to avoid duplication. The government's own impact assessment says there is likely to be a cost to employers from representatives spending more paid working time on facility time. It also accepts that statutory equality representatives are likely to impose some additional paid facility time cost.
And the cost in particular in the public sector is already unsustainable. The Taxpayers' Alliance, analysing reported public sector facility time data for 2023 to 2024, calculated that at least 21,639 trade union representatives were costing £98.2 million in facility time across the public sector. It found 993 employers spending 100% of their working hours on facility time. At the same time, a report by the Institute of Economic Affairs found direct public sector equality, diversity and inclusion staffing and training costs of approximately £557 million annually.
Also note, the latest civil service facility time guidance removes the previous departmental mandatory cap, which was set at 0.1% of the pay bill, and it replaces it with a suggested guideline at the same number. Meanwhile, the Unemployment Act repeals a trade union facility time publications requirements. I wonder why. My Lords, the government cannot even get unemployment down, yet when people in work are in work, it is legislating to give them more paid time away from their actual jobs. The taxpayer is being asked to fund additional facility time without a quantified estimate of the recurring public sector cost.
The private employer faces additional paid absence facilities, administration, data protection questions and potential litigation. Public service managers face further pressure on staff time at a point when productivity remains below its pre-pandemic level.
My Lords, the government's paymasters really have bought some nice perks, and I say to them, enjoy them while they last. So for those reasons, I regret this code and ask the minister to explain why the government believes that this is a good use of business resources, public sector staff time and taxpayers' money.
Speaker 84
The original question was that the code of practice laid before the House on 6th July be approved. Since when, an amendment has been moved by Lord Sharpe of Epsom at end to insert the words set out on the order paper. The question I therefore have to put is that this amendment be agreed to.
Richard Balfe
My Lords, I rise to speak in the space reserved for Lord Davis, who sadly cannot be with us, but I don't think anyone will be surprised at what I have to say.
I was a member of a trade union before I was ever a member of any political party. And that union was in the civil service. What I have to say firstly about this proposal is that I haven't had a single representation asking me to oppose it. Not one. The second thing I'd like to say is that I have been involved in a trade union consistently since the age of 16.
I think I'm probably the only person in this house who's actually been the president of two TUC affiliated trade unions. And I'm probably also the only person in this house who has addressed the party conferences of both Labour, Conservative and the TUC Congress. So I've certainly been around the block, as they say. But my experience of trade union work was founded really in the welfare area. When I first became a trade union official, I was, believe it or not, 16 years old.
This is not because I demonstrated a great ability. It was because no one could agree who should have the job. So the Communist Party, the Socialist Party of Great Britain, the various bits of the Labour Party decided that it should be me because they thought I'd be the easiest one to push around.
Actually, they were wrong. But what I did learn in those very early days was that much of the work we did was welfare work. It wasn't industrial work at all. I haven't had a day on strike in my life, and I haven't had a day out of a trade union in my life. So what I learned first about TUs is that we looked after the members.
The first chairman I had, who was a Red Clydesider, he used to say, "All that matters, Richard, is are they in compliance?" That meant, have they paid their subs?
If they had, they were looked after. And we had many cases where we looked after members because they had problems. Simple as that. But also, and it's worth remembering, and this comes up in this debate, the employer often asked us to intervene.
Often the call went out, do you think you could have a word with him or her because you know what we're up against here? And people who went sailing in thinking they'd got cast-iron case to pursue discovered when they spoke to their union rep that they didn't have much of a case at all because the union rep would say, look Jim, we had this a couple of years ago and this is how it ended up and what you want is not going to work. So we were as much a part of management as we were part of any great plot to overthrow the state. So what I say in this is, firstly, there's no legal requirement in this for employers to get paid time off. It all boils down to goodwill and many things in the trade union movement do exactly that.
They boil down to goodwill.
People want a pleasant and happy workplace, and the job of a trade union is often to help to build that. But if they can't agree, there is a resort to an employment tribunal, which is provided here, and I would hope it doesn't have to be used very often. But if it does, complaints can be resolved by conciliation or by ACAS. So it's not as though this is trying to build up dispute. It is actually a way of trying to solve dispute.
The final point I want to make is this. Years ago, we had a Prime Minister who was never my favourite, she was called Mrs Thatcher. When she was the Prime Minister, when she was the leader of the Conservative Party, Central Office had three people devoted to trade unions. They used to look at the agendas, go to the conferences, and they knew what they were talking about. My good friend John Bowis was there as the leader of that little band.
I would ask that the present Conservative leadership looks again at deepening its relations with the TUs, because I'm afraid often they give the impression that they don't know what on earth's going on there or how to influence it.
It's quite easy to influence it. It's rather like my dog. Pat them on the head, give them a bit of love, you'd be surprised how far you can get.
Speaker 87
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, might not be surprised to hear that I don't agree with him that the code is disproportionate or that it represents an unjustifiable burden on employers or taxpayers. Just to get a bit technical to start with, the regret motion suggests that the draft ACAS code is itself expanding the statutory entitlement to paid facility time for equality reps, but of course, as the noble Lord knows, it's the act itself which has done that and the arguments were played out during the passage of the act.
So what ACAS is now doing is explaining how the statutory right is to operate in practice. And the key question is whether ACAS has produced a sensible set of guidance for implementing the law that Parliament has enacted, and I believe that it has. And to recall, the Act provides a right to reasonable time off for equality reps of a recognized trade union for a specified purpose. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, described the purposes as broad, but I would emphasize that they are specified, and I think that that is helpful. And the purposes are promoting equality in the workplace, arranging relevant learning and training, providing information, advice or support to qualifying union members, consulting with the employer, obtaining and analyzing information, and preparing for those activities.
And it also provides a right to again reasonable time off for relevant training. And the amount of time off, its purposes, occasions and conditions have to be reasonable in all the circumstances, including the employer's circumstances and the practical requirements of the workplace. The code doesn't turn that into an unlimited entitlement, so this is not some new open-ended commitment on employers.
The regret motion suggests there's insufficient evidence that equality representatives will improve workplace outcomes. And of course, we should always ask what evidence supports a new employment right, but no one can provide proof that every single instance of paid time off will produce a measurable improvement in a particular workplace. But what we can say is that there is long-standing evidence and experience that properly trained workplace representatives can contribute to better employment relations, and they do. The existing ACAS codes points to the positive benefits to employers, employees, and union members of effective workplace representation, including helping to resolve problems and conflicts at work.
And the updated codes adds that effective representation can help to build trust, improve communication and support early resolution of workplace disputes. And my Lords, these are not abstract benefits. A workplace dispute that's resolved at an early stage is less likely to become a formal grievance, a disciplinary dispute, an employment tribunal claim or a breakdown in the employment relationships. And I have spoken to many employers who recognize how union reps can be a valuable source of intelligence for management, helping the employer to deal with a problem before it becomes expensive, entrenched or legally contentious. And that matters very direct in equality matters.
Issues involving discrimination, harassment, victimization, or unequal treatment are precisely the sorts of matters where trained representatives can help both employees and employers and stop grievances getting out of hand. I fully share this regret motion's concern about value for money. Of course, every pound of taxpayers' money should be spent responsibly, but I don't accept that the costs related to time off for equality reps will be disproportionate. As always, costs need to be measured against benefits.
It's wrong to assume that the time spent by a trained representative is simply a cost with no corresponding benefit. The potential benefits of these measures are workplaces where disputes are dealt with efficiently, managers receive early warnings and accurate information about problems affecting their workforce, employees understand their rights and responsibilities, and problems are contained. Sometimes an hour spent identifying and resolving a problem is an hour that saves many more hours later. The motion speaks of taxpayers funding "additional staff time", and again, the legislation talks about reasonable time off, and there are conditions.
To get paid time off, the employee must be a member of an independent trade union recognized by the employer and must have been appointed or elected as equality representatives in accordance with the union's rules. My Lords, the motion is not keen on taxpayers' money being spent on equality, diversity and inclusion activity and bashing EDI has become a fashionable transatlantic sport, but leaving that aside, what does the code actually say?
The statutory definition of equality in this context is not an invitation to pursue every conceivable form of EDI activity. It's tied to established concepts in the Equality Act 2010: eliminating discrimination, harassment and victimisation, advancing equality of opportunity between people who share protected characteristics and those who do not, and fostering good relations.
Speaker 107
Excuse me. I ask that my noble friend could sit down because we do have to get on. Yes, we missed out on your previous contribution. But even so, every noble lord only has six minutes, I beg your pardon.
Speaker 87
The concepts of equality are not wildly new and good employers fully and already subscribe to them.
Speaker 107
I'd be grateful if my noble friend, the noble lady, would please conclude her remarks.
Speaker 87
To conclude, if we believe that public money should be used proportionately, we should welcome guidance that encourages employers and unions to agree clear, workable and reasonable arrangements. That's what the code provides and I hope the regret motion will be accordingly withdrawn.
James Stewart Jackson
My Lords, it's a pleasure to have the opportunity to take part in this debate and I warmly support the amendment, the regret motion by my noble friend on the front bench, Lord Sharpe of Epsom. One would expect that in a period of great difficulty and challenge for small businesses, this government would be giving businesses a break in a situation of increasing inflation, tax rises, supply chain blockages, consumer confidence dropping, national insurance payments going up, youth and graduate unemployment, low growth and poor productivity in the public sector.
90% of businesses that the FSB, the Federation for Small Businesses, surveyed in July were worried about this act and only 18% in that survey expected business to grow. And of course, people criticize the Labour Party for not having much knowledge or experience of business and investment, but you can't say the same of the trade unions. They've invested 142 million pound in the Labour Party in donations since 2010 and they've really bought and paid for this legislation in a way which is quite outrageous, especially when we are lectured on a regular basis by the Labour Party on ethics and the appropriateness of corporate donations.
But mustn't forget also it wasn't just the trade unions, they did receive four million pounds from Quadrature Capital hedge funds just before the 2024 general election. My Lords, this is problematic. And in fact, actually, I would say this is an obvious example of the idiom of gilding the lily, to add unnecessary decoration, detail, or embellishment to something that is already complete, beautiful, or perfect, often spoiling it in the process. Because actually the system works at the moment.
And this extra bureaucratic encumbrance for businesses will make it very difficult because it's all very well trooping through the lobbies to support this piece of legislation, but other people having to pick up the tab and mainly small business. There will be no limits and specifications around length of paid or unpaid time off. It could be open to abuse and could be extremely costly to employers. As raised by my noble friend, the provisions of paid facility time for DEI representatives are broad and fairly novel. The code of practice acknowledges that, quote, many employers have well-established ways of engaging their workforces on equality issues.
So it's all that work's already being done. And I have to ask the question, why is there a carve-out for DEI? Is it not the case that trade unions already have practices and policies which focus on equality of opportunity and DEI for all their workforce?
Why do we need a special de facto taxpayer-funded DEI carve-out? Reasonable in relation to time off is open to highly subjective interpretation and will likely arise in costly disputes, and we absolutely know this will happen. Where employees hold multiple union roles, their entitled time off may compound. The accommodation and facilities provision requirements could also be extremely costly and onerous. And I have to say in passing, I think the number of responses for this code of practice is extremely small, frankly, given that the ramifications through the years and the impact it will have on the efficiency of business is pretty profound.
So, my Lords, maybe I ask the Minister some specific questions from the explanatory memorandum about the code of practice. On paragraph 5.1, it rather blithely says, "This will lead to improved worker representation and industrial relations by giving trade union representatives the freedom to organize, represent and negotiate on behalf of their workers and increased cooperation between employers and workers, leading to beneficial outcomes." This is subjective. There's no evidence for this. How is this measured?
What's the source? What's the source that evidence suggests that representatives cannot always take sufficient time off or facilities to carry out their duties? This can limit effective worker representation. Where's the example of that?
Where is the actual documented empirical data that supports those assertions made in the explanatory memorandum that accompanies this code of practice that we're discussing today? It also says this approach supports clarity and consistency, enabling the framework to be applied by employers and union representatives in a way that reflects the needs of their workplace. Again, there isn't any specific evidence brought forward for that. And when we look at the impact on businesses, charities, and voluntary bodies, which is at page four of the explanatory memorandum, there's no real analysis of the impact it will have in terms of familiarisation and transition costs that the increased facility time will have.
And whilst I accept it will not affect small and micro businesses, it will still affect businesses which are smaller. I have to say also that this code of practice is unnecessary. The system at the moment works. The system is one that business is not pressing for. This is a payback for the trade unions for the money they've given to the Labour Party, and I deeply regret it because it will have huge consequences.
It will cost people's jobs, business opportunity, profit, and that will be bad for the wider economy.
Dave David Goddard
My Lords, this code updates the guidance last revised in 2010 and reflects the rights that Parliament granted to the Employment Rights Act. And on these benches, we will not oppose it. We have some practical questions that require answers. The new right for equality representatives applies only where an independent union is already recognized, and it carries the same notification and training conditions as those existing rights for union learning representatives. The code asks for equality representatives to work alongside existing staff networks rather than duplicate them.
And we think that's sensible. But much depends on the word reasonable, as Lord Sharpe of Epsom has outlined earlier. Time off must be reasonable.
Accommodation and facilities must be provided on request that are reasonable in all circumstances, including the size and resource of the employer. That gives the employers room to refuse requests that are not proportionate and reasonable, but also leaves a good deal to be done that could be settled case by case. So my questions are these. What estimates have the government made of the additional paid time off for equality representatives, particularly in the public sector where budgets are tight? How will the government and ACAS monitor whether the reasonable test is working as intended?
And will the code be reviewed once there's evidence over the first one or two years, rather than being left for 16 years? And finally, timing. Many employers, schools amongst them, will be reading this code alongside the access regulations and the new duties to tell workers of their rights to join a union, all coming into force on the same day.
Will ACAS publish short, practical guidance for line managers before the 30th of October? My Lords, during the passage of the Employment Rights Act, we on these benches argued for codes of practice that give businesses and employees alike clarity and fairness, and this is what we expect the government to do. This code goes some way towards delivering that. I hope the minister addresses my questions, but we on these benches will be content to support the government should Lord Sharpe wish to test the House.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, let me thank all noble Lords for their contribution, and I'm grateful for the support and constructive scrutiny across this House regarding the ACAS code of practice on time off for trade union duties and activities.
The points raised today have been helpful, and I will respond to them here. Now, let me start by saying this: supporting reps to carry out their roles can benefit employers, workers, and trade unions. It can help to lay the groundwork for early resolution of workplace disputes, build trust and boost good workplace relations, improve communications and encourage constructive dialogue between employers and trade unions, encourage a culture of mutual respect, and contribute to healthier and more productive organisations.
An effective industrial relations can save both business and taxpayer by reducing the number of employment tribunal cases, enhancing workers' training and reducing staff turnover. Now, my Lords, let me turn to the sort of the reasonable test that Lord Sharpe asked. Representatives at relevant employer asking for time off or facility should follow the ACAS code to help them make a reasonable request. What is considered reasonable will depend on the circumstances in each case, including where relevant the size, resources and organisational structure of the employer. Employers are required to comply with the legal entitlement to reasonable time off for trade union duties and activities.
My Lords, taxpayers are entitled to expect public money to be used responsibly, as my noble friend Baroness Carbury has stated. Equality representatives can help staff address discrimination, harassment and barriers to fair treatment at work. Those are practical workplace concerns. So, my Lords, I would question the suggestion that employees at an underperforming organisation should have less support in addressing them. Improving workplace relations can only contribute to improving services.
So, my Lords, the government's approach is to support effective representation while retaining the requirement that paid time off must be reasonable.
And I just want to also touch on the impact assessment. I mean, the impact assessment cites research suggesting equality representatives can improve workplace equality practices, particularly when they have sufficient time and meaningful engagement with employers. Our judgment is that effective representation can deliver worthwhile benefits, but implementation must be proportionate and its effectiveness assessed. Let me address the issue on small business, I think the noble Lord Jackson of Peterborough addressed earlier. My Lords, as Minister for Small Business, I take his concern very seriously.
Now, having run businesses myself for the best part of 45 years, I understand that when a small team loses even one person's working time, that requirement depends on what is reasonable, taking account of the employer's size and available facilities.
A small employer's circumstances therefore matter directly. There is no blanket exemption, but the framework allows for proportionate arrangements. Fair treatment at work and the practical ability to run a business must go together. And the issue on the code has, various noble Lords have actually mentioned about the code. The code has been updated to reflect the new rights added by the Employment Rights Act.
The code provides clarity on these new rights. Let me touch on the issue about whether employers have been properly consulted and whether they will work.
My Lords, ACAS consulted for eight weeks and received 47 responses, including from employers, unions, and professional bodies. That consultation led to changes clarifying roles, training requirements, and practical arrangements. The published approach also provides for a post-implementation review after five years. My Lords, good employers and effective trade unions share an interest in workplaces where concerns are heard, disputes are resolved, and people can do their jobs well. Parliament has established those rights.
This code gives employers and representatives practical guidance on applying them responsibly. My Lords, I ask the noble Lord to withdraw his amendment and invite the House to approve the code.
I beg to move.
Andrew Sharpe
Well, I'm, my Lords, I'm very grateful to all those who spoke, in particular my noble friend Lord Jackson of Peterborough, who I thought raised some very good questions about evidence and clarity, which I'm afraid the noble Lord the Minister hasn't really addressed. I'm also, of course, grateful to my noble friend Lord Balfe for his historical tour de force. And I would say to the noble lady Baroness Carberry, yes, they are specified, the statutory rights, but they can also be broad, and they are ridiculously broad. The point of this regret motion, my Lords, is that the burden is shifting, burden of proving reasonable is shifting to the employer. And the government's own impact assessment says that it will lead to an increase in tribunal claims.
The noble Lord Leong just said that it will reduce the number of tribunal cases, but that is not consistent with the government's own impact assessment, which I regret.
I hold the minister in very high regard, as he knows. I know he's a very successful businessman, and he always is very clear and admirable in his intentions. But on this occasion, I would like to test the opinion of the house.
Speaker 84
The question is that the amendment in the name of Lord Sharpe of Epsom be agreed to. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The question will be decided by a division. I will advise the house when voting is open.
Voting is now open.
Clear the bar.
George Young
Order! The question is that the amendment in the name of Lord Sharpe be agreed to. As many as that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content.
The contents will go to the right by the throne, the not contents to the left by the bar.
George Young
My Lords, there have voted contents 56, not contents 82, so the not contents have it. The question is that the original motion be agreed to. As many of that opinion will say content. To the contrary, not content. The contents have it.
Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026 debated with one other motion, Lord Young.
Speaker 113
My Lords, could I remind noble Lords of the speaking times of six minutes for this debate. Thank you.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, I beg to move that the committee approves the draft Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026 and the accompanying draft Code of Practice on the Right of Trade Unions to Access Workplaces. This statutory instrument and the code of practice were laid before Parliament on 6 July 2026. My Lords, I also note the regret motion by the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom. My Lords, this instrument and the draft code of practice put into effect a key measure contained in the Employment Rights Act 2025.
The importance of facilitating union access is recognized internationally, with rights enshrined in legislation. The 2025 Act framework allows trade unions to communicate with workers in person and digitally. The starting point in this framework is discussion and agreement. Employers and trade unions first negotiate a statutory access agreement. Where negotiations are unsuccessful, either party may refer the case to the Central Arbitration Committee, or CAC.
The CAC may then determine whether access should be granted and on what terms. The regulations before the House today provide the practical and procedural detail required for that framework to operate.
They outline the relevant time periods, matters for the CAC to consider for access and provisions on penalties for breach of a statutory access agreement. The accompanying code of practice offers practical guidance to employers and trade unions. My Lords, I wish to highlight certain specific features of the regulations. First, the CAC must refuse access where an employer has fewer than 21 workers. Secondly, access is not unrestricted.
Statutory access agreements will set out where, when and how access may be exercised. Access must also not unreasonably interfere with an employer's operations. Union officials will be expected to comply with relevant requirements on operations, health and safety, security and safeguarding.
These considerations ensure that an access agreement fits the circumstances of the particular workplace. The regulations also set out circumstances in which access must be refused. These include cases where refusal is necessary in the interest of national security. I know the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, expressed concerns about the measure's impact on employers and business operations. However, the framework is designed to ensure that access agreements reflect the individual workplaces while recognizing employers' legitimate operational requirements.
My Lords, let me now turn to the frequency of access. The regulations include weekly access as a model term. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, raises this point in his regret motion.
The government carefully considered the views expressed during consultation on this point. Access agreements should provide a genuine opportunity for trade unions to communicate with workers rather than being so infrequent that their practical value is diminished. The flexibility to negotiate the access arrangements is intended to ensure that meaningful access or engagement occurs. Access should also allow workers to engage with trade union officials considering workplace circumstances and avoiding unreasonable interference with the employer's business. An example of such a case of flexibility would be a business that operates a shift pattern.
In such a circumstances, the access agreement might be arranged so each access happens at different times, allowing workers to engage with the union if they wish.
My Lords, it is important that the framework have a robust and credible enforcement model. The maximum penalties are £75,000 for a first penalty order under an access agreement, £150,000 for a second, and £500,000 for subsequent penalty orders. The CAC must consider a range of factors, including the nature and gravity of the breach, before determining any penalty. This ensures that penalties remain proportionate while providing meaningful powers to address serious or repeated instances of non-compliance. Penalty fines can be issued to any party, any party to the access agreement.
This includes third parties.
The noble Lord Sharpe states in his regret motion that the enforcement regime has been implemented without sufficient evidence. The government has committed to reviewing the operation of the framework during its first six months following implementation. We will engage with stakeholders, including employers, trade unions, and the CAC in this review and publish our findings. The review will help ensure the framework remains effective, proportionate, and responsive to the on-ground experience. My Lords, concerns have been raised about the burden on employers, operational disruption, and the model term for weekly access and the proportionality of the enforcement regime.
Safeguards including exemptions for small employers, flexible access arrangements with trade unions, protections in regulations, and a proportionate enforcement regime. For those reasons, I respectfully disagree with the conclusions set out in the regret motions.
These are balanced and practical issues. My Lords, I therefore hope that noble Lords will support both the instrument and the accompanying code of practice. I beg to move.
George Young
The question is that this motion be agreed to. Amendment, Lord Sharpe.
Andrew Sharpe
Well, my Lords, I'm very grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument, to which I have tabled a regret amendment. But he won't be surprised to know that I take a very different view from the one that he has just explained. So let's begin with the government's own consultation. When respondents were asked whether weekly access should be a model term, just 4.6% agreed and 95.3% disagreed.
When they were asked whether two working days' notice should be the model for subsequent access visits, just 7.5% agreed and 92.4% disagreed. So, my Lords, rather than as the Minister, noble Lord the Minister has contended, this was carefully considered, I'm afraid it looks, or the conclusions at least look neither careful nor considered. On the two most controversial aspects of this SI, weekly access and two working days' notice, the government have proceeded despite overwhelming opposition among the business community. So could the noble Lord the Minister tell the House what evidence did the government receive which they considered sufficiently compelling to outweigh that response? My Lords, these regulations implement one of the most far-reaching changes to industrial relations contained in the government's Employment Act.
They create a statutory route by which an independent trade union can obtain physical access to a workplace, even where those workers are not union members. The union does not even have to be recognized by the employer, nor does it have to demonstrate that it already has members in that workplace. And such an intrusion is a complete violation of the property rights of business. The exemption in the regulations applies only below 21 workers, meaning businesses with no HR department, no in-house lawyer, and no industrial relations team or experience are going to have to deal with some of these intrusions. And it will guarantee that a large number of businesses will choose not to expand beyond 21 workers to avoid the hassle of all of this, my Lords.
During report on the Employment Rights Bill, the official opposition tried to protect SMEs from precisely this outcome. The Federation of Small Business explicitly supported that approach, warning that smaller employers simply do not have the HR infrastructure or the legal teams available to larger companies to navigate complex access procedures and negotiations. It is no surprise that the government opposed us, and unfortunately the Liberal Democrats also abandoned the small business argument. My Lords, in April this year, the British Chambers of Commerce, the CBI, the Federation of Small Business, the Institute of Directors, Make UK, the CIPD, and the Recruitment and Employment Confederation wrote jointly to the Employment Rights Minister, and yet they have been completely ignored.
Their conclusion was that the absence of a structured dialogue had produced an outcome which failed to address businesses' fundamental concerns over significant disruption from increased access rights. And these new burdens, my Lords, also come at a very peculiar moment, because the new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, has said, and I quote, "For too long, businesses have been carrying the burden of rising costs," end quote. And he has promised that his government will, quote again, "bring down costs," end of quote. So does the Prime Minister even support these regulations? And if he does, how does he reconcile potentially weekly union access, new statutory response negotiation processes, the Soviet-sounding Central Arbitration Committee proceedings, and potentially very substantial penalties, as we've just heard, with his stated ambition to reduce costs on British businesses?
And a reminder, those penalties can go up to 500,000 pounds. That is not proportionate. The government's own costing does little to reassure.
The explanatory note says that no full impact assessment has been produced for the regulations because no or no significant impact on the private, voluntary or public sector is foreseen. Well, how is that possible? Is the government being deliberately ignorant or are they just incompetent? The public sector raises an additional concern. The Local Government Association warned that arrangements should not interfere with operational priorities or the provision of vital public services, including schools, waste depots and other controlled environments.
The Home Care Association has said that no assessment of its cost to publicly funded care was published and that providers have received no additional funding to meet it.
For England's home care, supported living and extra care workforce, it estimates that if 25% of workers attended weekly one-hour meetings, the additional cost could be around 266 million pounds. Its extreme worst-case scenario of weekly attendance by the entire workforce exceeds 1 billion pounds a year. The association also points out that around 80% of home care is purchased by the state. So after all the talk from the Prime Minister about reforming care, the government's measures are going to divert scarce resources into paid attendance at union meetings, resources that ultimately come from providers, councils and taxpayers. My Lords, I want to finish with two very specific questions.
The first comes from a business organisation and they asked us this this morning. If this is what the government thinks a good business must do and how they will empower trade unions against employers who fail to meet this standard, what standards will be expected of how trade unions conduct themselves and how do we protect good employers against trade unions who don't?
Can the noble Lord the Minister address that very well concern? Well, judged concern. My second very specific question to the Minister is this: how is the CAC qualified to make judgements about national security? By definition, it can't be. My Lords, these regulations read less like the balanced and carefully calibrated framework promised to this House and more like a trade union wish list imposed on our job and wealth creators.
So like in the previous debate, I would say enjoy it while it lasts because we will repeal all the job-killing measures in the Employment Rights Act of 2025. I beg to move.
George Young
The original question was that the regulations laid before the House on July the 6th be approved. Since when an amendment has been moved by Lord Sharpe of Epsom at the end to insert the words set out on the order paper.
The question I therefore have to put is that this amendment be agreed to.
James Stewart Jackson
I'm pleased my Lords to support my noble friend on the front bench. And if the previous instrument was gilding the lily, this is overegging the pudding, I have to say. The burden placed on employers to demonstrate that access arrangements are do not reasonably interfere with their business and therefore and through referring the matter to the CAC are both onerous and time consuming.
And I have to ask the fundamental question: what right do trade unionists have to come into a business every week demanding to involve themselves in the technical granular activities of that business? Even Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs do not avail themselves of those opportunities. Why should this be part of primary legislation or secondary legislation? And why are the trade unions treated any differently to anyone else? Weekly access as a model is a burdensome expectation of the CAC which would significantly disrupt businesses and employers.
There are also potential privacy concerns around digital access inclusion as part of the union's right to access the workplace.
And I have to say, it's barely believable that this is not about going in and having regular access, which is completely laudable to people who are already trade union members, but this applies to people who are not trade union members. So on what basis, if you have one person that's a trade union member and nine that are not trade union members, should that trade union official have a right to go into that business, disrupt it, stop it from supporting the bottom line, jobs, prosperity and opportunity? The code, of course, we're told, is, does not impose, or the regulations do not impose legal obligations. But quote, its provisions are admissible in evidence and are to be taken into account in proceedings before any court, tribunal or the CAC where they consider them relevant. This arguably gives the code a quasi-legal status, which perhaps it shouldn't have outside of statutory or secondary legislation.
So let's be honest, let's not be naive. Trade unions are going to push the envelope on this. They're going to be as difficult as possible using this code in order to have as much access as they possibly can. And we're also looking of course at the development of quite a draconian enforcement scheme via the Central Arbitration Committee contained in in the code. My Lords, it's going to be time consuming.
It's going to be bureaucratic. But I'd like to ask some specific questions of the Minister.
The impact assessment has not been prepared for the instrument because apparently the department have concluded that annual costs to the business are expected to remain below the de minimis threshold. Are we really saying that there will not be very significant costs of these regulations and this code of practice? There's no evidence again to support that. In in respect of the of the costs and the benefits, the government says we expect the equivalent annual direct cost to business, charities and voluntary bodies to remain below the 10 million de minimis threshold. I don't believe that.
James Stewart Jackson
This is a government that says it's absolutely laser-like in its focus on growth, but it doesn't bother to monetise, doesn't even bother to avail itself of the opportunity to look at data to decide whether this will have a real benefit in terms of the economy. And I come back to the point that my noble friend has raised about the statutorily supported national bargaining frameworks for adult social care and school support staff. Do we really believe that hard-pressed school support staff and people in the social care sector, which under all governments are under enormous strain in terms of the recruitment and retention, in terms of getting to the next client, in terms of closing down another client to make sure they're fed properly or cleaned or washed, whatever? Do we really think that they've got time to be negotiating with trade unionists when they're some of them are micro-businesses in very restricted geographical areas with a small number of a workforce?
It's bonkers. And it's a complete, it's a completely fantastical approach to the real world. This government doesn't care about that. It was warned about this by His Majesty's opposition. The chickens will come home to roost, and in those particular areas of school support and social care, jobs will be lost, and that will be a very regrettable thing.
And I would ask the government to think again.
Richard Balfe
My Lords, it's a great pleasure to speak in this debate and to note, sir, on the opposition bench, on the other benches, my predecessor as president of BALPA, Lord Monks, and my successor, the Lord Barber. And sitting behind them, Baroness O'Grady, who probably still has that fate to befall her. But let us see. I notice the Federation of Small Businesses is getting a mention. Well, I seem to remember we recently introduced someone into this House on the Labour benches who claimed to be from the Federation of Small Businesses.
So maybe the Labour group will benefit from the wisdom of that particular person. The next point I'd like to make is a quite simple one. As far as the unions I've been concerned with, this is not a payback to the Labour Party. BALPA has never given a penny to the Labour Party.
The British Dietetic Association has never given a penny to the Labour Party. So they're hardly getting a reward for doing nothing at all, are they? What I would say, though, is that they are good, strong trade unions in their sector, doing a job to make the health service work for the dietitians and to make the aircraft industry work for BALPA. And, you know, you talk about access to companies.
Let me point out that if you look at the difficulties of rostering pilots, it's very difficult to get them in the same country at the same time, let alone in the same room. So, you know, this is one of the problems that has to be faced and has to be dealt with. But whenever we bring up anything regarding better rights for trade unions, we come up with a barrage of objections. Objections which frankly I think are spurious because they need to be overcome. We in the European Union have dozens of airlines.
They all have structures similar to this. And so there's nothing exceptional about giving access to businesses to trade unions.
The fact that I don't think there is an aircraft company with under 21 employees, but this has never been a great difficulty. The next point I'd quickly like to make is that the prospect of bringing this in fulfills a demand which has been around for at least the last 20 years. And it's about time it was done. The access of workplaces is a fundamental to trade unions. And people aren't going to be going down there every week saying, "Oh, it's Thursday, we've got to go down to Bristow's Aircraft and insist on getting through the door."
Richard Balfe
The way things do work, though, is that if you get an employer who is determined to cause problems, they can cause them. I always go back to the notion of Eddie Shah, remember him and Grunwick, who put all the objections he could find in the way of recognizing the TU movement. And I was delighted to be on the picket line at Grunwick with Shirley Williams of blessed memory, and not necessarily any party that I belong to. So, you know, let's get real about this.
I think that if you want to mess things up, you can. But there is no reason why a responsible trade union, which most of them are, at least 100% anyway, maybe a few more than that, if they want access, they have a right to put their claim before the workers. After all, it's the workers who sign up. It's their money that gets deducted from their pay packet. It's their money that gets paid over.
And one of the big problems in all the unions I've served on has always been to keep up the membership, to persuade people not to resign, to persuade people that you're providing something for them. Most of the time what you're providing for them are welfare services.
People join unions to be looked after, not to be campaigned against. So I end where I did my last speech, to ask the Conservative Party to have a fundamental rethink of the way it deals with the two million Conservative voters who hold trade union cards. These are not outsiders, these are our people, and they deserve a bit better than they sometimes hear.
Margaret Mary Sheila Lawlor
It's a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Balfe, and I have an answer to that, Lord Balfe. When I went to Cambridge first, I used to meet quite a lot of people.
I'd come from Ireland and I hadn't been familiar with the British trade union movement. Two people who I worked with in Cambridge told me, they weren't academics, they were doing another job, they told me that they wanted work, but they couldn't get work because they weren't in the trade union. And yet, when they applied to join a trade union and were admitted, they were taken out on strike. So they couldn't work. But they joined the union because they couldn't get work unless they joined it.
And perhaps they're still members of that union. I haven't kept in touch. Anyway, my Lords, it's, Lord Balfe is a very old and dear friend, and I think we'll disagree about this. He introduced me into your Lordships' House and I have great respect for him.
But I oppose the regulations here on this guidance on trade number 2026, 2026 Trade Unions, this one, because it detracts from the efficient and productive operation of businesses and factories. And I speak as an employer, a small employer, but an employer. I wouldn't be under these regulations, but heaven knows if I had a bigger organisation, I would be. It brings unknown costs to employers, and they are unknown. From what our noble, my noble friend has said, there's been no reliable costing, and they go against fairness and politicise the workplace.
There will be a serious impact on efficiency because of the need to facilitate perhaps weekly meetings by vacating a room for them and providing IT backup and keeping compliance records.
There will be a definite loss of productivity and profitability. Just think of small businesses which employ the threshold of 21 employees, or the much smaller business of maybe 10 members but is associated with other businesses owned by the same employer who have a much larger workforce. They will be included in these regulations. There will be overheads for costs for security, for IT and energy, and moreover, there will be disruption to working schedules, co-working, teamwork, and all the practices which make for good outcomes and successful productivity.
My noble friend Lord Sharpe has drawn attention to the fact of our not having any reliable assessment provided by the government of the costs and impact. It could be anything, judging by the code of practice stipulations for access in working hours, providing the rooms, digital liaison, and so on. And indeed, the model for reasonableness laid down here is a weekly meeting. If a weekly meeting takes place, that would be considered reasonable. No wonder, as Lord Sharpe has said, so many, so few employers support the weekly meeting arrangements.
Just say each meeting takes an hour or more of working time. How much working time is lost for an employer over the whole year with a payroll of 21 or 30 or 40 employees?
And you total it up for the total productivity in this country at a time when our productivity and growth is abysmal. Finally, the trade unions are essentially an arm of the Labour Party. I oppose the politicisation of the workplace and the labour movement. There are many, most, many affiliated unions. I take the noble baroness's point, not every union is affiliated to the Labour Party, but many of them support the Labour Party.
Lord Monks, I'd love to hear from you if you wish, but not now.
Finally, there are many working people to whose beliefs, and Lord Jackson has said this, who find their beliefs, some of their aims and practices and ideals inimical. How can it be fair to give them a dominant position under law to propagandize amongst the workforce and recruit? And this is quite apart from undermining property rights, which has been mentioned. The answer is not to give rights to organizations with other political views, but perhaps that is one answer. Rather, it is to avoid entirely the politicization of the workforce.
Speaker 117
My Lords, I declare an interest as an employee of a large multinational employer.
I wish to speak against these regulations, not because I oppose trade unions or worker representation, but because this government has chosen to ignore democratic consultation on an unprecedented scale, imposed a framework that will damage the small businesses they claim to champion, and crossed a line on employer autonomy from which we may not easily return. This government consulted on these proposals. Over 1,600 responses came in. As my noble friend Lord Sharpe has mentioned, but I believe worth repeating, on the central question of weekly access, the heart of this regime, 95.3% of respondents disagreed. On the two working day notice requirement, 92.4% disagreed.
Speaker 118
These are not marginal objections. They're not even 50-50, my Lords. They are landslide rejections, the kind of number a politician usually only sees in a province he's not expecting to lose.
Speaker 117
And the government has ignored them entirely. This is not how government should work. When a consultation returns a verdict this one-sided, there is a democratic obligation either to redesign the policy or to explain with rigour why you are overriding the people you consulted. The government has done neither. It has simply filed the responses away somewhere dark and plowed ahead regardless.
That should concern this House on principle alone. But the principle is not the only problem. The competence is appalling.
The 21-worker threshold catches businesses that never asked for this intrusion and barely have the paperwork to cope with it. The Institute of Directors surveyed 680 business leaders. Only 10% supported the 21-worker threshold. 74% wanted a higher bar. Yet here we are, imposing weekly union access on firms with modest HR capacity, minimal administrative resources, and no history of industrial relations complexity.
The regulations will create bureaucracy wildly out of proportion to the risk they address.
For retailers with multiple sites, for social care providers already stretched to breaking, for universities managing student safety and data protection, this framework is a sledgehammer looking rather pleased with itself over a nut it has yet to actually crack. And the costs assumptions are thin, in the way that a stage magician's assurances are thin. The impact assessment does not monetize every business burden. It does not fully capture management time, facilities, paid attendance at access meetings, or the opportunity cost of disrupted operations. For public services, social care, local government, these are unfunded costs landing on budgets already down to their last few pence down the back of the sofa.
The code recommends full pay for workers attending access meetings in work time. The Home Care Association estimates that this could be ruinous in publicly funded care.
The government has not told us how that cost is justified or who precisely is expected to foot the bill, beyond presumably hope. But here is what troubles me most. These regulations cross a constitutional line, and not quietly. For decades, we have expected workplace relations to reflect negotiation between employer and union, not a unilateral statutory entitlement handed down from on high. This regime says whether you recognize a union or not, the state will now let itself in.
That is not a tweak to employment law, it is a fundamental shift in the relationship between employer, worker, and state, dressed up in the modest clothing of a statutory instrument.
It erodes employer autonomy in ways that will not be undone merely by regretting them later, which is, I note, all this motion actually allows us to do. I do not oppose worker voice. I oppose this vehicle for it, one rejected by consultation, imposed without justification, misaligned with business reality and dangerous to the principle of voluntary engagement. This government has, in effect, asked the country a question, disliked the answer and gone ahead regardless. I support this regret motion and press the government to return to the drawing board and perhaps this time take on board what comes back.
Jonathan Patrick Moynihan
My Lords, some elements of these regulations are to a degree reasonable. The employer's response period, originally proposed at one week, is, following our representations earlier, now three. And access agreements are capped at two years. I acknowledge those things. And I also take comfort from the fact that apparently not a single Labour backbencher opposes my noble friend's motion, if I look at the speaker list.
But none of this changes the fact that the Act squats here as a major destroyer of growth, a gift from the former Prime Minister to the new one, helping fulfill his expressed desire to take our economy back to that decade of strife, the 1970s. Because non-unionized companies can thrive while unionized ones tend to go to the wall.
And because of that, now nine out of ten private sector employees are not unionized. So, or not union members, I should say. So for most private businesses, this will be their first dealing with unions in decades. And in a fiercely competitive global market, companies have to be flexible and agile. Unionization slows decisions, blocks rapid change of direction, and adds red tape.
Now, companies want harmony and cooperation with their workforce, as the noble Lord Balfour, my noble friend Lord Balfour, said. So balanced guidelines are crucial.
If they're unbalanced in favor of the union, the company has to continually cave into the union so as to avoid sanction by this Central Arbitration Committee. Onerous weekly union meetings, the potential for CAC complaints if managers even ask workers what took place. With these guidelines, your Lordships will be amazed at how many companies will stop growing at 20 workers, to the direct detriment of the economy. The CAC is being given enormous latitude with nebulous guidance permitting arbitrary decisions. Its three-person panels comprise a lawyer academic in the chair, a member from the trade union side, and an employer member, so-called, drawn in the government's own recruitment literature mainly from HR directors and employment relations leaders, not from people who have built businesses.
To an HR leader, a union is a normal part of the corporate landscape, so the introduction of a union will seem manageable in the guidelines' words. But to an entrepreneur, the person on whom our country's growth depends, a union is an obstacle to succeeding in a highly competitive world. So I ask the noble minister for assurances that in the promised spring consultation, the government will propose changes in three areas. First, lower the penalties. After consultation, the government, in an extraordinary decision, raised the maximum fine from 150,000 to 500,000.
Who consulted them to do that? How can a business with 21 workers, sorry, sorry, I've lost my place.
Fines should not be so large that they drive a company into financial distress or derail its growth, and these, even 75,000 for many businesses, will. Second, protect working time. The weekly visit presumption should go. I saw noble Lords on the Labour benches nodding when the noble Lord Balfe said weekly was unnecessary and wouldn't be wanted, so why is it here? How can a business with 21 workers cope with weekly visits?
Meetings should default to breaks or the end of shifts, and where they fall in paid time, they should be limited to say 30 or at best 45 minutes. Third, reform the digital access guidelines.
Companies should have a right of reply through the same channel and should not be obliged to disseminate unlawful material, which the guidelines do oblige them to do right now. Beyond meetings, union communications through company channels should also be limited to one a week. And companies must be free to log email delivery and link activity for security purposes, with the monitoring ban agreed to mean only scrutiny aimed at identifying workers' engagement with union material. Finally, every worker, member or not, should be allowed to unsubscribe.
My Lords, should the government lose the next election, much of this will matter less, apart from meantime further dramatic losses in economic growth, because an incoming Conservative government will largely repeal this damaging act. Until then, I ask the government, please limit the damage by improving these far too union-friendly guidelines.
Dave David Goddard
My Lords, I rise for the last time this evening. I obviously haven't got the same crystal ball the Conservatives have got at the moment, and I see no evidence of a Conservative government on the horizon as we speak, and I am completely supported by my group on that. The right of access was in the government's manifesto, and on these benches we accept the mandate for it. But we're more interested in how it works practically, and following on from Lord Moynihan of Chelsea, the first practical question I would ask is the frequency.
I mean, the regulation says the CAC treat weekly access as reasonable, although the unions may ask for less. What evidence does the government rely on in setting one weekly access, and what did the consultation responses say about it? Secondly, the practicalities of a visit. As I understand it, the code does not say how long a visit should last for, or whether an employer can keep part of the team working to maintain cover. For a care home, a hospital ward, or a small hotel, these are questions that matter.
And will the minister set out the government's expectations? And thirdly, the employer does not control all the sites. Many workers in security, cleaning, and facilities management are based on clients' premises. The regulations allow a complaint and ultimately a penalty against a site owner who prevents access.
So how does the minister square that particular circle and how will it work in practice for small contractors and their clients? And for timing, once again, these rules start on the 30th of October, barely a fortnight from now. 15 working days to respond to a request. And as has been said earlier, penalties of up to half a million pounds for repeated breaches. Will employers have practical guidance in hand before the date starts?
And so I'd like the minister to give me two commitments tonight. One, to publish data on access requests, CAC decisions, and penalties broken down by the size of the employer. And a first review within two years rather than five, so anything unworkable could be put right and quickly.
The questions raised by Lord Sharpe and others deserve answers, and I hope tonight the Minister can give them.
Sonny Liang
My Lords, firstly, let me thank all noble Lords for their contribution and grateful for some support across the House on the Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026 and a draft Code of Practice on Trade Union Right of Access. My Lords, before I answer some of the points raised, may I start by respectfully saying to the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, and some noble Lords on the opposite side. Now, this Employment Rights Act has sometimes been portrayed as if workers' and employers' interests sit on opposite sides of the ledger. I do not see it that way.
This Act is a small but important step in the right direction, establishing a stronger floor for the labour market and greater security for working people. Good employers should not fear a race to the top. Many already go well beyond the statutory minimum. Now, I've said earlier, I've spent 45 years in business. I know that the relationship between an employer and their staff is central to success.
People who feel valued and secure have a stronger stake in helping that business succeed. So, my Lords, I just want to put that on record. The whole point about a union representation and employers is in order for them to come together to address issues.
And let me also share some statistics here. Workplace conflict currently costs employers almost 30 billion pounds a year, equivalent to 20,000 pounds per employee. In 2022 and 2023, the UK lost more days in strike than any year since the 1980s, and the NHS strikes during 2023 alone cost the taxpayer more than 1 billion pounds. Access under a statutory access agreement cannot be used for the purposes of ongoing industrial action. Industrial action should and must always be the last resort.
The government believes that better communication between employers, workers, and trade unions can help support more stable workplace relations.
Now let me address the whole issue about SME. Let's look at the statistics here. 99% or 5.5 million businesses employ less than 21 workers, which means that this exemption, or rather these companies that employ less than 21 workers, will not have to provide access because that's what the regulation says. So the government has been clear that SME should not face disproportionate burdens under the statutory access framework. That is why the regulation provides the CAC must refuse access where the employer has fewer than 21 workers, which means it's 5.5 million businesses in this country.
The threshold aligns with existing statutory recognition framework, providing consistency across closely related areas of trade union law.
I think Lord the Noble Lord Sharpe mentioned about double standards. Let me be absolutely clear again, the enforcement regimes applies to trade unions and the CAC can find both trade unions as well as businesses. Businesses and trade unions are both subject to the same enforcement regime. And several noble lords have also asked about consultation. Concerns about proportionality, operational impact and the position of SMEs were among the most frequently raised issues throughout the consultation.
These concerns were considered carefully and we made a number of changes to improve clarity, workability and the practical applicability of the framework.
So the final code contains a stronger guidance as a result. Now, I think the noble Lord Sharpe also asked about how can the CAC assess national security? May I gently remind the noble Lord, the CAC is an independent statutory regulator comprising of 45 members acting independently and they will consider evidence including from employers and unions on national issues, security issues where relevant. Let me bring to address a point that Lord Jackson mentioned about school support and social care.
To ensure the statutory right of access frameworks operate efficiently and effectively alongside national bargaining frameworks, like for adult social care and school support staff, we intend to introduce a targeted assessment from 2027 so that the size-based threshold does not apply in these cases. Let me address the issue that Lord Ashcombe asked on the consultation responses. In terms of consultation responses, many more businesses are likely to respond to this consultation than trade unions because there are far more businesses than unions. Trade unions represent millions of workers when they represent to a consultation with a single response. My Lords, let me address the issue on access that I think Lord Goddard asked.
My Lords, look, access takes place under an agreed arrangement or an agreement determined by the CAC.
The framework sets out where, when and how access may be exercised. Union officials may be required to comply with reasonable workplace instructions, identification requirements, safeguarding arrangements and health and safety procedures. The framework contains safeguards to ensure that access is meaningful while taking account of operational requirements of the workplace. My Lords, look, these measures are intended to strike a fair and proportionate balance. They clarify how access should operate, encouraging employers and trade unions to resolve issues through discussions and regulation.
As we discussed earlier, the purpose of the framework is not, is not simply to facilitate access, it is to support constructive industrial relations. That is why we have committed to reviewing the framework following implementation.
My Lords, throughout today's debate, noble Lords have all reflected on the regret motion tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom. Those concerns centered on the framework's impact on employers, weekly access model, and enforcement proportionality. I hope I have showed that those issues were carefully considered in developing the framework and are reflected in the regulations and the code of practice. My Lords, I said earlier, as a minister for small business, I recognize the need to avoid disproportionately burdening the smallest employers. The CAC must refuse statutory access from employers with fewer than 21 workers, as I said earlier.
So, my Lords, I therefore hope the House will both support the regulation and the accompanying code of practice, and I beg to move.
Jonathan Patrick Moynihan
Before the Minister sits down, may I ask him, given that he didn't respond to any of my requests for a response, will he respond by writing to the various points that I asked him to respond to?
Sonny Liang
I will ask my officials to go through Hansard and definitely will write to him.
Andrew Sharpe
Well, my Lords, as ever, I'm very grateful to all who spoke in this relatively short but lively debate. I'm particularly grateful to the support for my motion from my colleagues, my noble friends, and I'm also grateful to the noble Lord Goddard for asking some very good and very specific questions. As ever, I'm very grateful to the noble Lord the Minister for his efforts.
I regret on his behalf the fact that he got no support at all from his own benches, which I think is rather a shame. I've got to say in response to one of my specific questions that I don't believe the fact that the Committee for Public Safety, or whatever it's called, is independent qualifies it to judge national security matters. That's not really a justification for that power at all. I think the noble Lord the Minister should have another think about that and perhaps come back to me in writing. My Lords, I think, and I've said it before, that these attempts to legislate the unions back into relevance in the private sector will ultimately fail.
Having said that, I will now withdraw my regret motion, but I will reserve the right to say I told you so at some point in the future. And I repeat, we will repeal all of the job-killing measures in the Employment Rights Act of 2025. But for now, I beg leave to withdraw.
George Young
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that this amendment be withdrawn? Amendment is by leave withdrawn.
The question is that the original motion be agreed to. As many as of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. Code of Practice on the Right of Trade Unions to Access Workplaces, Lord Lyong, move formally.
Formally.
George Young
The question is that the second motion in the name of Lord Lyong be agreed to. As many as of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
That the House do now adjourn.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.