House of Commons

1 September 2026

House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:21 - 00:51
Speaker 4
Order.  Order.  Will the member wishing to take his seat please come to the table. 
00:51 - 01:46
Speaker 3
I swear by Almighty God that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to His Majesty King Charles, his heirs, successors, according to law, so help me God. 
01:46 - 03:20
Spk Member of Parliament | Chorley
Member of Parliament | Chorley
Lindsay Hoyle
I wish to inform the House that I have received letters from the honourable member for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green informing me of her resignation as the chair of the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee, the honourable member for Hammersmith and Chiswick informing me of his resignation as chair of the Justice Committee, and the honourable member for Luton North informing me of her resignation as chair of the Women and Equalities Committee.  I therefore declare those chairs vacant.  Nominations for elections to those vacancies are now open and will close at 2:30 on Monday the 7th of September.  Nomination forms will be available from the Vote Office, the Table Office and the Public Bill Office.  Only members from the Labour Party may be candidates in these elections. 

If there is more than one candidate in any election, the ballot will take place on Monday the 14th of September between 3:00 p.m. and 6:00 p.m. in the Aye division lobby.  I remind colleagues that new rules in relation to campaigning for select committee chair elections, which were proposed by the Procedure Committee, were endorsed by the House on the 28th of April 2016.  A briefing note with more information will be available from the Vote Office and online.  We'll now come to questions to the Secretary of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs.  I start with question number one, Blair McDougall. 
03:20 - 03:23
Blair McDougall
Lab Member of Parliament | East Renfrewshire
Member of Parliament | East Renfrewshire
Blair McDougall
Question number one. 
03:23 - 04:08
Lab Member of Parliament | Cardiff South and Penarth
Member of Parliament | Cardiff South and Penarth
Stephen Doughty
Well Mr. Speaker, if I might, I wanted just to start by acknowledging the devastating floods in Nepal and I know many members are supporting constituents who've been affected by this tragedy and our support remains supporting British nationals and supporting the people of Nepal and we've engaged with authorities in Kathmandu and Beijing and we stand with them at this incredibly devastating and difficult time.  Mr. Speaker, we categorically do not support export of any bombs or ammunition for use in military operations in Gaza.  We suspended 29 licenses in September 24 and approximately 50 licenses have been refused since then.  All licenses are assessed in line with the strategic export licensing criteria and are kept under continual review. 
04:08 - 04:28
Speaker 24
Thank you Mr. Speaker.  Will the UK ban all trade with illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank, East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, sanction companies profiteering from this trade and enforce the ICJ ruling against illegal occupation?  Thank you. 
04:28 - 04:43
Lab Member of Parliament | Cardiff South and Penarth
Member of Parliament | Cardiff South and Penarth
Stephen Doughty
Well Mr. Speaker, the honorable gentleman will have heard the statements made by the Prime Minister and my right honorable friend the Foreign Secretary on this issue and he should expect further announcements in due course. 
04:43 - 05:06
Lab Member of Parliament | Leeds East
Member of Parliament | Leeds East
Richard Burgon
Thank you Mr. Speaker.  In September 2024, the government suspended some arms sales to Israel over its war on Gaza.  Given the escalating Israeli violence in the West Bank, will the government review its export licenses to ensure no British military equipment is supplied to Israel that could be used there? 
05:06 - 05:27
Lab Member of Parliament | Cardiff South and Penarth
Member of Parliament | Cardiff South and Penarth
Stephen Doughty
Well my honorable friend makes a very important point and as I assured the original questioner, we keep all of our licenses under review.  We only approve licenses that are consistent with our legal obligations and all of them are kept under careful and continual review as standard and we'll of course keep the House updated as the implications of any other announcements that we make. 

05:27 - 06:11

Speaker 31

Thank you Mr. Speaker. I'd like to welcome the Foreign Secretary and new ministers to their place in the House. As previous speakers have mentioned, the UK's trade relationship with Israel also includes the trade in goods from illegal settlements. And members across the House will have been shocked to see the violent scenes of settlers acting with apparent impunity and with overt support from Israeli ministers who set out their support for those settlements. So can I push the minister a little bit further to confirm to this House whether the government will introduce new sanctions to target those settlers involved in these attacks as well as the extremist ministers who are encouraging them, whether the government's reported progress towards a trade ban on illegal goods will extend to services and perhaps most importantly, whether the government will set out the consequences if those bans are breached?

06:11 - 06:52

Stephen Doughty

Well Mr. Speaker, can I share with him the horror at some of the things that we've seen going on in these illegal settlements and we have absolutely condemned the settler violence, the settler terrorism that we have seen. Absolutely our condemnation of the proposals for E1 and all illegal settlements and indeed we have joined other countries around the world in condemning this proposal and being very, very clear with the government of Israel that this must stop. The Prime Minister's been very clear that we need to do more including looking at further sanctions, both those involved in the violence in Gaza but also looking at measures to ban trade in goods with illegal settlements. And we've been very clear that British companies should not be financing, constructing or advertising new settlements.

06:52 - 07:01

Speaker 8

Number two Mr. Speaker.

07:01 - 07:28

Speaker 6

This government inherited a situation from the previous Conservative government where UK control over the vital UK-US military base in Diego Garcia was under threat. This is about the long-term safety and national security of the United Kingdom and the British people. Maintaining long-term operational control and security of the base remains a top priority and is the entire basis for the UK-Mauritius agreement. A financial element was a crucial part of that deal.

07:28 - 07:46

Luke Morgan Evans

Thank you Mr. Speaker and I think we've heard that line for the last two years. The question the public want to know and the one I placed at the Defense Secretary before the summer was where is this case now? He said he's looking at the details closely. We're six weeks on. Can she confirm this deal is now dead as it should be?

07:46 - 08:26

Speaker 6

Mr. Speaker, he asks about the payments when he knows this is about the long-term safety and national security of the United Kingdom and the British people. Diego Garcia is a key strategic military asset for both the United Kingdom and the United States, which has protected our shared security for nearly sixty years. At the time, the Conservative government held eleven rounds of negotiations with the Mauritians. At the time, Mr. Speaker, they argued that Britain's defence was best served by having legal certainty over the Chagos Islands. Funding for the treaty will be provided for within the existing spending review settlements for the FCDO and for the Ministry of Defence.

08:26 - 09:11

Anne Emily Thornberry

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Can I begin by welcoming the Foreign Secretary and his new team to their place? But can I in particular welcome my honourable friend? I am cross with her for leaving the Foreign Affairs Committee. We will miss her very much.

But she is a formidable member of our committee, and I'm very proud to see her take such a well-deserved place on the front bench. So now to the work. Mr. Speaker, on the issue of islands that the UK and now supposedly the United States take a great interest in, I wonder if the Minister might provide an official response to President Trump's latest nonsense that he might withdraw support for UK sovereignty over the Falklands.

09:11 - 09:44

Speaker 6

I thank the chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee for her warm words. Mr. Speaker, the UK has no doubt about its sovereignty over the Falkland Islands. They are and will always remain a British overseas territory in line with the wishes of the Falkland Islanders. The UK is steadfast in our support for Falkland Islanders' rights of self-determination. I have seen the comments that the Foreign Affairs Select Committee chair is referring to, however our position remains unchanged.

09:44 - 10:53

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. First may I welcome the new Foreign Secretary and his ministers to the team, and convey the apologies for the absence of my colleague, the Shadow Foreign Secretary, who is overseas at the moment. I'd also like to associate these benches with the government's condolences following the devastating floods in Nepal and Tibet, and our thoughts are with all those who have lost loved ones, those who are still missing, including British nationals, and the emergency workers undertaking extraordinarily difficult rescue operations. Now, in April, Mr. Speaker, ministers admitted that the Chagos treaty had become, and I quote, impossible to agree at political level after the US withdrew its support, yet the government now says it is again trying to push the deal forward with Washington. So what has changed?

Let me give the government another chance to answer the question. Has the US agreed to amend the 1966 UK-US agreement governing Diego Garcia, and why is the department budgeting for a deal that remains blocked by our closest security ally?

10:53 - 11:30

Speaker 6

Mr. Speaker, we worked in lockstep with the US in developing and testing the deal to ensure that it meets the UK and US security requirements. I'm not going to give a running commentary on this matter, but the US administration has repeatedly supported this agreement, and nothing in this treaty has changed since the US originally gave its endorsement to the deal. We've always been clear that the US government must be content with the agreement before we proceed in ratifying the treaty. We'll continue to work with the US and Mauritius to find a way forward that is in the UK's best interests and protects our national security.

11:30 - 11:32

Bellavia Ribeiro-Addy

Question three, Mr. Speaker.

11:32 - 11:33

Foreign Secretary.

11:33 - 12:11

David Lammy

With permission, Mr. Speaker, I'll answer questions three and 17 together. Israeli settlements are illegal under international law. Last month, we saw the issuing of tenders for the E1 settlement, long regarded as the crossing of a red line because it cuts through the heart of the West Bank and risks making a Palestinian state unviable. This action was rightly condemned by a whole range of countries in the international community, including the United Kingdom. Over recent weeks, we've also seen appalling settler terrorism and Palestinians driven from their homes.

Mr. Speaker, this government will not acquiesce in the destruction of the two-state solution. We will act, and I will set out a comprehensive set of measures in the coming weeks.

12:11 - 12:12

James Dash.

12:12 - 12:44

James William Naish

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The UK told the Security Council on the 29th of June, I believe, that over 6,000 settlement housing units had already been approved this year, alongside the declaration of a further 465 dunams of Palestinian land as state land on the 24th of June, as a violation of international law. The situation has only deteriorated since. So does the Foreign Secretary accept this pace of expansion shows that current UK measures are failing to change Israeli government behavior and that a trade ban is now the necessary next step?

12:44 - 13:18

David Lammy

My honorable friend speaks with great sense on this. I am deeply worried about the pace of what is happening, and let's just be honest, Mr. Speaker, about what is happening here, which is that the creation of the facts on the ground are seeking to destroy the prospect of a two-state solution, and we cannot simply stand by and let it happen. My honorable friend will know that the Prime Minister, shortly before he became Prime Minister, talked about doing more on measures to ban trading goods with illegal settlements. We are obviously working across government and with our allies on these measures, and if he is a little patient in the coming weeks, we will have more to say.

13:18 - 13:19

Bell Ribeiro-Addy.

13:19 - 13:47

Martin Rhodes

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank the Foreign Secretary for his answer and his condemnation of the Israeli government's policies in the West Bank. Does the Foreign Secretary agree that action against these illegal settlements must include banning the trade of services as well as goods with these settlements? Services such as mortgages and financial support and legal services from UK companies to illegal settlement buildings.

13:47 - 14:09

David Lammy

I think again, Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend makes an important point, which is we need to look, and we are looking indeed, at our wider economic relationship with the occupied territories and the different tools we have to tackle it. I want to be very clear, as my honorable friend said, we do not want British companies financing, constructing, or advertising new settlements. The work we are now undertaking is how we can stop that, and as I say, I'll have more to say soon.

14:09 - 14:11

Speaker 26

Kit Malthouse.

14:11 - 14:52

Kit Malthouse

Mr. Speaker, thank you. Does the Secretary of State recognize that the situation we find ourselves in in the West Bank and indeed in Palestine more widely represents an almost complete failure of British foreign policy in this particular regard? And that one of the really most distressing aspects as a British citizen of this whole conflict, aside for the death and destruction and the savagery, has been the sight of British ministers sent out like goldfish to mouth platitudinous condemnation, promise action, only being dragged to some pathetic ineffectual steps by pressure from their own backbenchers. So my question is this: is anything going to change?

14:52 - 15:21

David Lammy

Yes. And look, I associate myself pretty much entirely with the remarks that the honorable gentleman makes, right honorable gentleman. And look, I think we need to face facts on both sides of the House here, which is that it has been the policy of successive governments over a long period to be for the two-state solution. But if you are for the two-state solution and you see it being destroyed by the facts on the ground, you must act. And I can assure him, because I know he has a long-standing interest and expertise on these issues, we are going to.

15:21 - 15:23

Speaker 9

Brendan O'Hara.

15:23 - 16:05

Brendan O'Hara

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I welcome the Foreign Secretary to his new role.

He will be aware that none of his recent predecessors were ever short of an angry word or a condemnatory statement about Israel's action in Gaza or the West Bank. What they were woefully short of, of course, was in taking any meaningful action to back up their supposed outrage. What is happening in the West Bank is happening right now, and so time is of the essence. So when will he spell out exactly the consequences for the state of Israel and for any UK national or UK-based company who are found to be complicit in this illegal E1 expansion program?

16:05 - 16:36

David Lammy

Well, look, I do want to defend the record of my predecessors for a moment. I'll come to his question. Recognition of the Palestinian state was a historic decision made by this government. The action taken on arms licenses... But I say to the honorable gentleman, I think we on this side of the house, as the Prime Minister has said, recognize the need for a step change in our approach, given the urgency.

And as I say, he won't have to wait too long.

16:36 - 17:05

Speaker 19

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Secretary of State will no doubt be aware of the Israeli government's removal of Dutch representatives from positions monitoring the ceasefire in Gaza, following trade bans by the Dutch government recently. What reassurances can he give the house that in the event of any decision to impose new trade restrictions, the UK's ability to influence events in the Middle East won't be undercut further as a result?

17:05 - 17:32

David Lammy

I think my honorable friend raises a legitimate point here, but I just want to say this, which is we must listen to the voices across the piece on these questions, and including the Palestinian Authority. And I think it's very, very important when we think about, when we weigh our decisions, and people rightly worry about some of the impacts it can have, to listen to those who represent Palestinians who say the time to act is now. And that's what we're going to do.

17:32 - 18:16

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the new Foreign Secretary and his team to their places. He's the third Labour Foreign Secretary we've had in two-plus years. We have had so many hand-wringing statements. He himself has just said the time to act is now, but he's asking us to wait weeks more for a statement about banning settlement trade, something that is absolutely clear is essential now.

What is he waiting for? Will he ban trade in goods, services, investment in both directions immediately, because the facts on the ground are changing right now, at pace, faster than ever before? What is the UK government still waiting for?

18:16 - 18:54

David Lammy

Well, I can assure the honorable lady that we are working intensively on this, and she won't have to wait long, as I've said in earlier answers. And look, the reason I want to get this right is that we need a comprehensive reset of our policy across the piece. Look, many members of the house on both sides have made very, very important points, not just about trade, but a whole set of issues, including around the ICJ judgment on legality. I want a comprehensive reset of our approach on these issues, because for the reasons that the honorable gentleman opposite said, and indeed many honorable members have said, it is necessary, it is high time, and as I say, she won't have to wait long.

18:54 - 18:58

Speaker 10

Number four, Mr. Speaker.

18:58 - 19:23

David Lammy

With permission, Mr. Speaker, I will answer questions 4, 11, and 14 together. Keeping the British people safe is the first duty of government. This summer, we've seen the effects of the climate crisis in starker terms than ever. We're impacted here at home and also by what happens overseas. Showing leadership on this will be a core priority for me as Foreign Secretary, and I will bring a group of foreign ministers together at the United Nations later this month to discuss how to respond.

19:23 - 19:52

Speaker 41

My thoughts are with the victims of the flooding in Nepal and Tibet last week, a horrifying and pertinent reminder that climate change and its inevitable consequences are the biggest threat to our health, our homes, and our way of life. Already, drought and resource scarcity are actively fueling regional conflicts around the globe and driving mass displacement. What diplomatic initiatives is the Secretary of State leading to combat climate change and prevent resource-driven conflict?

19:52 - 20:36

David Lammy

I think my honorable friend makes a really, really important point about this. And I think this summer, I believe the Met Office have said, I'll correct it if I'm wrong, Mr. Speaker, this is the hottest summer on record just today. I think this brings home to us the sense that whatever one's views on net zero and associated issues, and I know there are various views on all sides of the house, this is a national security threat, one of the biggest national security threats we face. And so what I undertake to her and members across the house is in my role as Foreign Secretary, I will treat this with the seriousness it deserves in that context.

20:36 - 20:38

Speaker 15

Melanie Onn.

20:38 - 21:14

Melanie Onn

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Humber generates 20% of our electricity and is critical to delivering UK energy security. We have to work with our international allies to build a stronger framework of the friendly to protect all of our critical infrastructure. The Humber Marine and Renewables and Norwegian offshore wind MOU is a really good example of collaboration which will keep the turbines turning. Has he had any discussions with allied partners to protect and grow clean energy projects to improve collaboration to better support global energy security?

21:14 - 21:45

David Lammy

Well, if I may say, Mr. Speaker, my honorable friend, and I used to say this at DESNZ questions, is an absolutely brilliant advocate on these issues with somebody with huge expertise before she came into the house on these questions. And I can assure her that as part of the work that we are doing in alliance with my honorable friend the Energy Secretary, we will be working with other countries on these questions. What we have to do is we have to tackle the problem of emissions and we also have to help countries adapt and both are crucial.

21:45 - 21:47

Speaker 13

Perrin Moon.

21:47 - 22:24

Perran Moon

Merci, Mr. Speaker, and I'd like to associate myself to the comments of the Minister in relation to the appalling scenes in Nepal. The success of our action on climate change is dependent on working collaboratively with international allies to secure resilient supply chains and limit dependencies on states hostile to the national interest. As part of Cornwall Council's international strategy, they're working with the likes of the Breton government and the Quebec government to enhance resilience of renewable energy and critical minerals supply chains. What is the Foreign Office doing to support the national security through such outward-looking initiatives?

22:24 - 22:52

David Lammy

Speaker, we love Cornwall and we love my honorable friend for the brilliant advocacy he shows on behalf of his constituents and what Cornwall is doing. And I think he is right and I will look at his initiative because I think working with governments across the world, including state governments on these issues, is absolutely crucial. This is a collective action problem and we have to tackle it collectively.

22:52 - 22:53

Monica Harding.

22:53 - 23:38

Monica Harding

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I put on record my party's concern and thoughts with the people of Nepal and Tibet as this tragedy unfolds and urge the government to stay the distance with them. The UK spend on international aid and development aids our national security, not only in climate change, but in keeping extremism, pandemics and illegal immigration from our shores. But this government has slashed aid brutally and the true impact of the cuts were finally realized in the final hours before summer recess. The cuts are deep and worrying.

So will this administration reverse them and can the Secretary of State set out a timeline for when the UK aid will return to 0.7% of GNI, a commitment which we, this house, legislated for?

23:38 - 24:15

David Lammy

The honorable lady makes an important point, but I do say to her, we inherited an incredibly difficult fiscal position with extraordinary pressures on the public finances. We are absolutely committed to doing everything we can on development. And indeed, I associate myself with the remarks you made about Nepal and I'll say more about it later. That's why as soon as the tragedy happened, we were there, one of the first countries to show that we would actually provide financial assistance to the government of Nepal. So we take these issues incredibly seriously and have a proud record.

24:15 - 24:33

Joshua Peter Reynolds

Mr. Speaker, with the United States stepping back from its multilateral climate cooperation, can I ask the Secretary of State what specific coalitions the UK is convening to fill the gap the United States is leaving and so far which countries have signed up to it?

24:33 - 25:07

David Lammy

Mr. Speaker, I've met a wide range of foreign ministers in my six weeks or so in the job and have talked to many of them about these issues. And to put this just frankly, this hasn't been at the forefront of foreign ministers' agendas. And in a sense, I think this summer, and I know we've said this many times before on climate issues, this summer is a wake-up call about the fact that this cannot, important as energy ministers are, of course I was one recently, it's also got to be a matter across government. And you need an absolutely cross-government approach on these issues and I assure him that's what we'll do.

25:07 - 25:47

Danny Chambers

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We know that food security is part of national security and it's been another tough year for agriculture with a record wet winter and now a record hot summer. We also have bluetongue disease going through livestock, Mr. Speaker, which when I was at vet school was a disease of Northern Africa and Southern Europe and it has spread through Europe to the UK and now to Scotland because of climate change. Does the Foreign Secretary agree with me that it is hugely irresponsible and it is scientifically ignorant for the leader of the opposition to ban conservative candidates standing at the next general election if they believe in taking serious action to tackle climate change?

25:47 - 26:26

David Lammy

Well, look, the leader of the opposition will have to take her own responsibility for candidates. I was once leader of the opposition, it's a hard job, as I proved. But look, there is an interesting thing here, Mr. Speaker, which is a debate has now broken out in the pages of the Daily Telegraph, an organ I obviously read a lot, on climate change. And people saying, well hang on a minute, how can the Conservative Party that thinks it cares about preservation of our way of life ignore this issue? So I urge people across the House to take this issue seriously.

26:26 - 26:30

James Wild

Question number five, please.

26:30 - 27:20

David Lammy

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'll answer five and 19 together. This government is determined to follow the leadership of every British government since the Russian invasion and stand shoulder to shoulder with the people of Ukraine against Russian aggression, which has intensified in recent weeks with July the worst month for civilian casualties in Ukraine since 2022. My first foreign minister call was with my counterpart, Foreign Minister Sybiha, and I had the privilege to meet with President Zelenskyy alongside the Prime Minister in my second week in the role. On Russian sanctions, on helping Ukraine with its defense and helping ensure it can prevail in the conflict, we will be with the people of Ukraine and its government as long as it takes.

The government is rightly championing long-term support for Ukraine and deterrence against Russian aggression, but that diplomatic approach has to be backed up by credible pledges on military capability.

27:20 - 27:29

James Wild

spend 3% of GDP on defense by 2030, something the Chancellor said was essential to defend our country only a few weeks ago.

27:29 - 28:16

David Lammy

These are obviously matters for the Chancellor to determine as he will well know. But I do say this to him specifically on Ukraine, that we will do whatever is necessary to support the government of Ukraine. And look, it's clear to me that at so many different levels we have shown, and I pay tribute as I did in my opening answer to previous governments, including beginning with the government of Boris Johnson on this, which is our solidarity with the people of Ukraine, the British people's solidarity, but the government's solidarity, and not just solidarity, but action is absolutely crucial. This conflict matters in principle and it matters to our future security too.

28:16 - 28:52

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Dr. Neil Shastri-Hurst.

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. We know that the Kremlin uses disinformation and misinformation to thwart Ukraine's effort and that of its allies in terms of its fight against Russian aggression. However, in recent weeks, there has been evidence that Meta has permitted Russian state propaganda to be targeted at individuals, including threats that Britain should be punished for its assistance to Ukraine. What steps is the Foreign Office taking and the government more widely to keep Meta to account?

28:52 - 29:30

David Lammy

Well, just on the opening point, or rather the end point he made, Russia can make its threats, but we are not going to be deterred from our solidarity and support for Ukraine. And I want to put that on record and make that absolutely clear in the House. I think he raises, and I've been reading the sort of back catalog of FCDO questions, the kind of thing I do, Mr. Speaker, and I know this issue of disinformation and misinformation has come up a lot. And look, I think I will undertake to the honorable gentleman that this is something I will work on with my colleagues across government and specifically on the Meta issue that he raised.

29:30 - 29:32

Speaker 36

Nick Thomas-Symonds.

29:32 - 29:58

Nick Symonds

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I congratulate the Foreign Secretary and the ministerial team and wish them well. In recent months, Mr. Speaker, I've been proud alongside the former Prime Minister to negotiate the UK's participation in the EU's support loan for Ukraine. Does the Foreign Secretary agree with me that going forward there should now be no unnecessary delays in procurement, that the kit and the weapons need to get to the front line in Ukraine where they're needed as soon as possible?

29:58 - 30:29

David Lammy

Well, can I first take this opportunity, Mr. Speaker, to pay tribute to the excellent job my right honorable friend did in government on Europe and then those very, very difficult negotiations, and I pay tribute to him for the brilliance with which he undertook that. The answer to his substantive question, Mr. Speaker, is absolutely yes. And I do say to the House, this winter is absolutely crucial for this conflict. And we must do everything we can not just to support Ukraine, but to do so in a speedy way.

30:29 - 30:31

Speaker 23

Joanna Baxter.

30:31 - 31:11

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members across this House remain deeply concerned about the 20,610 Ukrainian children stolen by Russia since the start of their illegal war. The right honorable gentleman's predecessor established this country's proud record on this issue, committing £4 million to tracing efforts which have located more than 1,000 children, imposed over 130 sanctions, and supported Ukraine in establishing a special tribunal for the crime of aggression. Will the new Foreign Secretary commit to working with me to continue the government's vital work in this area?

31:11 - 31:27

David Lammy

Well, can I first, Mr. Speaker, pay tribute to the work of my honorable friend, but also members across this House on this incredibly important and profound issue? And I can say 100% yes, I commit to working with her and other members from all parties on this issue.

31:27 - 31:29

Speaker 18

Andrew Stephenson, Minister.

31:29 - 32:18

Andrew Snowden

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. We remain steadfast in our support for the Ukrainian people and in our determination that Putin must not prevail. Russia has responded to Britain's decision to share Storm Shadow technology with Ukraine by threatening British factories with attacks from so-called unknown sources. You, Mr. Speaker, as well as I, will know for workers and residents in places like Wharton and Samlesbury in Lancashire and across the country, the concern and worry this will have for people. So with Putin continuing to reject meaningful steps towards peace, what formal representations has the Foreign Secretary made to Moscow in response, and what diplomatic action is he coordinating with our NATO allies to increase international pressure on Russia?

32:18 - 32:42

David Lammy

Well, let me thank the honourable gentleman for his very, very important question, and I endorse absolutely the spirit and substance of his question. I just want to say this, Mr. Speaker, let's be clear where the aggression comes from. It comes from Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the wider threat to our allies. I say very clearly, we will stand shoulder to shoulder with the people of Ukraine, we will not be intimidated by Russian threats.

32:42 - 32:44

Speaker 44

Alison Taylor.

32:44 - 32:46

Alison Suzanne Taylor

Question number six, Mr. Speaker.

32:46 - 33:12

Stephen Doughty

Well, thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Strait of Hormuz should be open to safe, secure, and unimpeded transit in accordance with international law, and the Foreign Secretary and I, the United Kingdom, working closely with international partners to drive diplomatic efforts to restore navigational rights and freedoms. And we continue to make clear to Iran that it must cease its egregious attacks on shipping, on our partners and allies, and it must engage in negotiations to reopen the strait in good faith.

33:12 - 33:14

Speaker 43

Alison Taylor.

33:14 - 33:38

Speaker 49

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents in Paisley and Renfrewshire North are feeling the impact of higher energy and petrol prices and will appreciate the efforts his department is making. Would the minister agree with me that military action by the world's superpowers is risking a return to pricing instability, and all efforts must be made to cease military activities?

33:38 - 34:08

Stephen Doughty

Well, Mr. Speaker, I entirely understand the concerns of my honourable friend's constituents, particularly in an advanced manufacturing district such as Paisley and Renfrewshire North, and I know her constituency well, and I understand why she is speaking up for her constituents. Of course, the events there are affecting communities across the United Kingdom. The Prime Minister is taking action at home to support people with energy bills and the cost of living, but absolutely that is why we need to see a diplomatic solution, negotiations, and the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz and the standing up for the fundamental principles of trade and maritime security.

34:08 - 34:09

Bob Blackman.

34:09 - 34:29

Bob Blackman

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Clearly, the free flow of shipping through the Strait of Hormuz is vital to Western economies. But clearly the threat here is that Iran is going to seek to take control completely over shipping through those straits. What sanctions is the government proposing to take to prevent Iran from succeeding?

34:29 - 34:58

Stephen Doughty

Well, he's absolutely right that we need to see the straits reopened, we need to have that agreement between Iran and Oman, and also ensuring there isn't tolling, that there is a free flow of trade, and that of course those attacks on shipping cease immediately and on partners in the region. We have already imposed 240 sanctions on Iran, Mr. Speaker, and we will continue working with international partners to apply economic pressure, but a diplomatic settlement is the right way to restore right of passage in the Strait of Hormuz.

34:58 - 35:01

Speaker 46

Andrew Snowden, shadow minister.

35:01 - 35:45

Andrew Snowden

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Iranian regime is deliberately weaponising the Strait of Hormuz, using rockets, drones, and sea mines to menace international shipping and hold the global economy to ransom. Its aggression threatens British vessels, drives up fuel prices, and places our energy, aviation, and food supply chains at direct risk.

Following the latest American strikes and the Iranian retaliation, will the Minister set out what specific and concrete measures the Government is taking with our international partners to resolve this crisis, restore the safe and sustained passage of commercial shipping, and ensure that Tehran can no longer threaten Britain's energy security with impunity?

35:45 - 37:02

Stephen Doughty

Well, he's absolutely right to set out the situation and the threats and the impact on our economy. And I think we share across this House a desire to get the straits reopened. That's why the Foreign Secretary and I have been engaged in so much diplomatic action over recent weeks with our partners in the Gulf and of course making clear to Iran directly in conversations what we expect to see happen. Of course, I mentioned the sanctions have already taken place. We keep other measures under review.

And Iran of course cannot be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon and they cannot continue their destabilising activity in the region or indeed their threats to Jewish and Israeli communities around the world. So we need to see this as a whole package of activity and those are the things that we've been making absolutely clear to Iran and working closely with partners on. Thank you, Mr Speaker. This Government fully recognises that China poses a series of threats to UK national security, from cyber attacks, foreign interference and espionage targeting our domestic institutions to transnational repression of Hongkongers. Yet China presents the UK with opportunities as the world's second largest economy and the UK's third largest trading partner.

Not engaging is no choice at all. Our approach to China is consistent. We will cooperate where we can and challenge where we must.

37:02 - 37:23

Anthony Bradley Thomas

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Well, it's good to hear the Minister acknowledge that China is a threat. The directors of GCHQ and MI5 have been clear that China presents the most significant state-based threat to the UK. The Government has previously talked about its China audit. Will the Government commit to publishing this in full?

37:23 - 37:32

Anneliese Dodds

As the honourable gentleman knows, there's been a series of questions on this in recent times and I'm happy to update the honourable gentleman again in writing.

37:32 - 37:47

Adam Jogee

Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. We've all seen the corrosive impact of the Chinese government's policies in Africa and the South Pacific and throughout the Commonwealth. And this is important for our national interest as much as it is for the countries affected. So can I ask my honourable friend the Minister what we're doing about it?

37:47 - 38:03

Speaker 53

We continue to work internationally. The honourable my honourable friend will know that I'm also the Commonwealth Minister. And as part of this work, whether it's across Africa or the Caribbean, is showing that our relationship is the most important is between those countries and the United Kingdom.

38:03 - 38:32

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Nine weeks ago, the Government was told that the Chinese embassy guards were brandishing a threatening peaceful vigil holders with prohibited electroshock weapons. The Chinese Communist Party either breached articles 41 and 27 of the Vienna Convention or they procured these weapons illegally in the UK. The Chinese Communist Party won't waive diplomatic immunity. So when will Minister stop hiding behind a dead-end Metropolitan Police investigation and do something to deter future hostilities in the UK?

38:32 - 38:56

Anneliese Dodds

Can I thank her for her question, Mr Speaker? Can I be clear, any attempt by a foreign state to coerce, intimidate, harass or harm individuals on UK soil will never be tolerated. But she knows as well as I do, there is a live police investigation by the Metropolitan Police. And actually members of this House should respect the fact the Metropolitan Police are investigating. Frankly, Mr Speaker, she knows better and I hope that she will wait for the investigation and that's when we will listen to what they've got to say.

38:56 - 39:19

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I start by thanking the Minister for his comments about the terrible floods in Nepal. I know a number of residents in my constituency of Harlow who have family in the region that they have lost and they will be listening to what the Government has to say on that issue. Can I also ask the Minister what he is doing working alongside Cabinet colleagues to tackle the important issue of disinformation online? A lot of that disinformation we know comes from bad state actors.

39:19 - 39:38

Anneliese Dodds

Can I thank him for his question? He will know that we that we do work across Government to tackle disinformation. I can say within my own portfolio, Mr Speaker, that we've increased the funding for the BBC World Service, the most trusted newscaster across the world. And that is a way in which we do tackle disinformation across the Foreign Office.

39:38 - 40:23

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My right honourable friend, the new Shadow Foreign Secretary, is in Taipei today, where Taiwan's Defense Ministry has warned that an increasingly unpredictable China is intensifying preparations to blockade and encircle the island. That comes in the same week that the US exposed another extensive Chinese state-sponsored hacking operation against government institutions and critical networks. So with Beijing threatening Taiwan, targeting our allies, and conducting espionage against this country, will the Foreign Secretary finally state plainly that China poses a threat to British interests, and will he place China in the enhanced tier of the Foreign Influence Registration Scheme?

40:23 - 40:26

Anneliese Dodds

The honourable lady knows that we keep all these things under review, and I'm happy to write to her as ever.

40:26 - 40:28

Speaker 61

Douglas McAllister.

40:28 - 40:30

Douglas McAllister

Question number eight, please, Mr. Speaker.

40:30 - 41:05

Stephen Doughty

Mr. Speaker, can I pay tribute to our FCDO consular teams, particularly for their current work on the Nepal-China flooding crisis, but it is also important to pay tribute to the work that they do to support thousands of British nationals who are arrested or detained abroad each year. We are strengthening that support, including through the appointment of the first dedicated envoy for complex detentions, our former colleague, Right Honourable Alistair Burt, which I'm sure was welcomed across the House, and he is supporting British nationals and their families in the most difficult detention cases. I've met with him to discuss those cases, and I'm looking forward to his challenge and his review of all of those cases.

41:05 - 41:07

Speaker 55

Douglas McAllister.

41:07 - 41:39

Douglas McAllister

Mr. Speaker, today marks 3,224 days of my constituent Jagtar Singh Johal's arbitrary detention and torture in an Indian prison. Mr. Speaker, I welcome the Foreign Secretary to his place, the ninth Foreign Secretary in office since my constituent's detention. So what steps has he taken since his appointment to secure Jagtar's release? Will he do more than just raise his case? Will he use his authority and take decisive action to end this injustice, and will he agree to meet with Jagtar's family as a priority?

41:39 - 42:21

Stephen Doughty

Well, Mr. Speaker, I thank him for his sustained and continued advocacy on behalf of his constituent, which is deeply powerful, and I know it's a concern to many members across this House. And despite some progress in Mr. Johal's legal proceedings, eight of the cases against him remain outstanding. We continue to raise concerns about his detention with the Government of India at every appropriate opportunity, emphasizing the need for a prompt, full, and just resolution of his cases within India's independent legal system. The former Foreign Secretary raised the case on the 4th of June. The Foreign Secretary's envoy for complex consular detentions met with Mr. Johal's brother on the 7th of August, and we will meet with the family in due course.

I can confirm that, and consular officials most recently visited Mr. Johal on the 29th of July.

42:21 - 42:23

Speaker 57

Sir Iain Duncan Smith.

42:23 - 43:16

Speaker 63

Mr. Speaker, I raise the cases of Ryan Cornelius and Sebastian Lai, both United Kingdom citizens, and I raise this with the attention of the Foreign Secretary, who I welcome in his position, of course. But Ryan Cornelius has been incarcerated for 19 years, trumped-up charges by a corrupt regime that is supporting a war over in Sudan at the moment. Will the government, first of all, in his case, bring sanctions against that regime to persuade them or to force them to release this man as he should have been? And in the case of Jimmy Lai, would the Foreign Secretary also threaten clear sanctions? And I now know that Sebastian Lai wants to see the Prime Minister with the Foreign Secretary.

Please say to the Prime Minister he should see him, because this man, again, wrongly incarcerated by a despotic regime.

43:16 - 43:51

Stephen Doughty

Well, Mr. Speaker, he raises important cases, and I can assure him in the case of Ryan Cornelius and Charles Ridley, we continue to support their clemency applications and to raise their case with the UAE authorities. In fact, I did so recently, and the former Foreign Secretary did as well and has met with their family. And in relation to Jimmy Lai, as he knows, we condemn the politically motivated prosecution of Jimmy Lai in the strongest terms. And, you know, his sentence is tantamount to a life sentence at the age of 78, and we're deeply concerned for his health. We continue to call for his immediate release.

The Foreign Secretary has raised this with his Chinese counterpart and will, of course, meet with the family. We'll happily to meet the family.

43:51 - 43:51

Speaker 60

Sam Joseph.

43:51 - 44:29

Sojan Joseph

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have been in regular contact with my constituent Chloe Pepper, who has expressed serious concerns regarding the welfare of her brother Ryan. He has been detained in Dubai since the beginning of November. Ryan has reported that he has experienced mistreatment while in detention, which is a matter of significant concern. The UAE authorities have conducted an investigation into this and found no evidence of mistreatment.

So could I ask my honourable friend, what scope do consular officials have to seek information about UAE's investigation to ensure that Ryan's allegations were properly investigated?

44:29 - 44:40

Stephen Doughty

Well, Mr. Speaker, we raise all cases with authorities in line with the appropriate consular protocols. I'm very happy to speak with him about the case involving his constituent and see what we can do further.

44:40 - 44:42

Speaker 65

Dr. Andrew Murrison.

44:42 - 45:23

Andrew Murrison

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I congratulate the government on the hiring of Alistair Burt? He's a good hire and will do great things for some of these most complex of cases. But does the Minister agree with me that many of these cases are extremely difficult and exceptionally traumatic and it is far better to prevent them happening in the first place? What more can be done to advise discretionary travellers on the risks that they run when travelling to some of these exceptionally challenging locations and particularly advising them in advance of the finite nature of any consular support that may be forthcoming if they get into trouble?

45:23 - 46:03

Stephen Doughty

Um, well, Mr. Speaker, I'd absolutely concur with his praise for Alistair Burt. Um, you know, he sat he took my position in the past. He's somebody I think who commands immense respect across this House and it's certainly been a pleasure to work with him so far and I certainly will welcome his challenge and review of the most complex cases. As he said, some of these are incredibly incredibly difficult. He rightly says prevention is crucially important.

We provide advice via the FCDO travel advice and of course we provide tailored advice in some cases. But absolutely we want to make sure that British nationals are aware of the full range of risks with travelling to a number of locations and we attempt to make that very clear in advance.

46:03 - 46:04

Liz Twist.

46:04 - 46:06

Liz Twist

Question nine, Mr. Speaker.

46:06 - 46:07

Minister.

46:07 - 46:48

Speaker 71

With permission, Mr. Speaker, I'll answer questions nine and 25 together. Tackling the climate and nature crisis is an urgent priority for us all, as recent extreme wildfires and droughts have only served to reinforce. So the UK is working with international partners to drive progress, whether through our forest partnerships with countries such as Brazil and Indonesia or through our Global Clean Power Alliance to accelerate the worldwide transition to clean energy. The Foreign Secretary will act as the UK's governor to the World Bank, taking personal leadership of the UK's engagement on development and climate finance. And later this month, the Foreign Secretary will also convene foreign ministers at the UN to address climate security challenges.

46:48 - 46:49

Liz Twist.

46:49 - 47:11

Liz Twist

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now my constituents here in Blaydon and Consett suffered through a summer of extreme heat, seen trains cancelled, signal interruptions and experiencing wildfires. As climate change affects every single one of us, not only in the UK but globally as we've heard today, can I ask the Minister how climate change resilience is being embedded directly into our core diplomatic and security strategy?

47:11 - 47:43

Speaker 69

I thank the honourable lady very much for her question, my honourable friend for her question, and I sympathise very deeply with her constituents who have been subject to such appalling disruption over the summer. We are very committed to strengthening international cooperation to anticipate, prevent and respond to climate-related risks of all sorts, including extreme weather. And the French Minister for Foreign Affairs and the FCDO have recently reaffirmed our commitment to expand early warning initiatives, including through the Climate Risk and Early Warning Systems programme to strengthen protection for the most climate-vulnerable countries and populations as well as her constituents.

47:43 - 48:17

Speaker 66

The Minister will be aware that the world's peatlands play a critical role in tackling climate change, storing as they do twice as much carbon as all of the world's forests combined. Thanks to previous EU funding, work to restore the Bolton Moss Fell peatland in my constituency began in 2015. Can the Minister outline what international peatland restoration programs the UK government is currently engaged with, and will she press DEFRA colleagues to ensure that the UK continues to provide the long-term funding to restore Cumbria's upland bogs?

48:17 - 48:52

Speaker 69

Mr. Speaker, we are committed to peatland restoration, which is critical to tackling the climate and nature crisis and meeting our Environmental Act targets, as my honorable friend has laid out. The UK supports international peatland conservation through programs such as the Darwin Initiative. Darwin projects are, for example, helping communities in Peru and Indonesia to manage peatland ecosystems sustainably. Many tropical forests are also part of peatland ecosystems, and the UK has a long-standing portfolio of work supporting them. And of course, the department does continue to work closely with DEFRA to protect and restore important ecosystems.

48:52 - 49:27

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After a horrendous summer of wildfires and the catastrophe in Nepal and Tibet, it's clear that if we're going to solve these problems, we need to act globally, but we need to think locally. It's really important that the public trust the information that they receive on climate change if we are going to deal with this. So will the FCDO work with cabinet colleagues to make sure that the public are educated and consider funding a national program of public information, or perhaps the screening of the people's emergency briefing, so that we all understand more about the situation?

49:27 - 49:43

Speaker 74

Speaker, I couldn't agree with the honorable lady more. It's very important that people trust the information they receive. She will have noticed, of course, the alert that was sent out across England as a sign of just how seriously this government takes its commitment to communicate with the public responsibly.

49:43 - 50:02

Jim Shannon

Speaker, I thank the Minister for that answer. Minister, there are 67 wars across the world, countries in conflict with other countries. What can the Minister do to ensure that sworn enemies can come together to combat the tackling climate change, which is the real enemy of every country in this world?

50:02 - 50:16

Speaker 69

Mr. Speaker, I very much agree with the honorable gentleman. Climate change is a common enemy and we have to face it across this House, across this country and across the world. And we're committed to working with everybody who is taking climate action seriously.

50:16 - 50:58

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

Question number 10 please, Mr. Speaker.

Mr. Speaker, there is no British security without Europe, and no European security without Britain. The EU is one of our closest partners on foreign and security policy. That is why I was in Austria yesterday meeting a number of our European counterparts, and why the Foreign Secretary will travel to Ireland later to meet with EU foreign ministers. The ambitious security and defense partnership agreed with the EU is boosting cooperation, and as my excellent predecessor noted already, we recently struck a deal to join the EU's 90 billion dollar Ukraine loan initiative.

50:58 - 51:24

John Richard Foord

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Four EU member states have written to the European Commission asking that it explores new options to make use of Russian immobilized state assets by Ukraine for its self-defense. They propose that EU states spread the legal and financial risks of seizing those assets. Will, when the Foreign Secretary goes to Ireland this evening, he support that initiative?

51:24 - 51:39

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

The Foreign Secretary and I have discussed many of these questions. He will of course be discussing Ukraine. We have made a signal contribution to European security through our efforts in Ukraine. We will continue to do so. It'll be a top priority in our discussions in the weeks ahead.

51:39 - 52:11

Ben Coleman

Speaker, at the moment, the European Union is taking big decisions to address the challenges which are facing it, and we're not at the table, and this affects us too. And I'm thinking of Made in Europe, steel tariffs, the safe defense procurement program. Can the Minister reassure my constituents in Chelsea and Fulham that the government will press ahead with a summit this year, that it will get good deals for young people, the price of food, the price of energy, and also that it will seek to be more ambitious, more bold in getting us back a seat at the table so the decisions which affect us we are part of making?

52:11 - 52:43

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

I can reassure my honorable friend's constituents, we are getting back to the table after many years of neglect. I was at the table yesterday. The Foreign Secretary will be at the table this evening. We are pressing British interests in relation to steel, Made in Europe, a whole range of really important questions. We have made considerable pressure.

Young people, research and development institutions will have access to a closer relationship with Europe, and we will push ahead in the weeks and months ahead.

52:43 - 53:21

Speaker 31

Mr. Speaker, Labour's decision to recruit a new Prime Minister directly led to the cancellation of the UK-EU summit in July. But a month and a half later, we still have no date, leaving businesses in the dark about the future relationship. They also want to know whether the Prime Minister's truly committed to a bolder approach to our European relations or the pedestrian approach taken by his predecessor. So can the Minister today provide some certainty by telling the House when the UK-EU summit will take place, and can he confirm whether the government will heed Liberal Democrat calls to put the UK's entry into the single market on the table at those talks?

53:21 - 53:48

Hamish Nicholas Falconer

The honorable gentleman knows how diplomacy works. You don't announce a summit until you've agreed it with your partners. On his substantive question, are we ambitious to go further and faster? Yes, we are. I said that in Europe yesterday.

We have said it repeatedly, and we're taking every effort we can to ensure that there is a partnership that works both for the UK and the EU, and that we are advancing quickly towards it.

53:48 - 53:53

Speaker 79

To ask the Secretary of State if he'll make a statement on his ministerial responsibilities.

53:53 - 54:41

David Lammy

Mr. Speaker, I'm sure the whole House will want to join me in expressing our deep sorrow for the flooding on the Nepal-China border that has caused widespread death and devastation. There are 987 confirmed deaths and 3,916 people still missing, of whom 36 are British nationals. From the moment the tragedy unfolded, we have sought to provide all the help we can to the Nepalese authorities and support British nationals, including 5 million pounds in additional humanitarian assistance. Our humanitarian and consular specialists are on the ground in Nepal, and FCDO crisis teams are working round the clock to support relatives of those missing. Mr. Speaker, my deepest condolences go to all those who have lost loved ones in this tragedy, particularly British nationals and their families.

54:41 - 55:18

Speaker 63

Mr. Speaker, I ask the Secretary of State if he's been made aware of the case of Joshua Wong, Hong Kong resident who is now being prosecuted by the administration in Hong Kong using the National Security Law. He will know that Hong Kong has trashed the Sino-British agreement and decoupled the concept of common law from their rights and responsibilities. All Joshua Wong has done is to ask for the same rights and privileges that we hold dear here in this country. Will the Secretary of State now take up their case with the Chinese government and say to them, enough is enough, it's time to stop chasing peaceful protesters?

55:18 - 55:34

David Lammy

What I will say to him, I absolutely will take up that case, and I know he has taken a long-standing interest on a whole range of issues. And I do say to him, because of his long-standing interest, we will be forthright on human rights when it comes to China, and we will be strong in relation to foreign interference and espionage, any threats that we find to this country.

55:34 - 55:59

Speaker 80

Thank you Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Foreign Secretary's decision to show personal leadership in acting as the UK Governor to the World Bank and given the wildfires that we've seen in Europe across the summer and the flooding in the park can he tell us how he intends to use the UK's influence to make sure that adaptation and resilience finance is much more quickly accessible to those countries that need it most.

55:59 - 56:23

David Lammy

Yeah honorable friend Mr. Speaker raised a really important point and the reason I took up this role is I want the World Bank to do more to make adaptation and resilience further faster simpler and more accessible. We know from events around the world how vulnerable countries are on the front line of climate breakdown and I undertake to him and the House that I will make it a top priority.

56:23 - 56:52

Wendy Morton

Mr. Speaker the Foreign Secretary has declared that development and climate finance will be central to his tenure. Yet the aid watchdog has found that the system has too often focused on meeting a spending target rather than clear priorities or value for money. So before he embarks upon an expensive roadmap back to point seven percent will he commit to a full national interest review that includes considering value for money for the taxpayer.

56:52 - 57:16

David Lammy

I think the honorable lady right honorable lady makes a very important point actually which is that any aid spending that we do must be value for money but I do say and I think this is a very very important point that I hope both sides of the House can agree on that this is not just the right thing to do in principle to help support the world's poorest countries it's also the right thing from our point of view because if we don't deal with problems around the world they come to Britain.

57:16 - 57:55

Wendy Morton

Thank you Mr. Speaker. I'd just like to touch on Nepal and Tibet because it is a truly harrowing situation with hundreds of lives lost thousands still missing and British nationals among those unaccounted for. We welcome the deployment of the UK's rapid response team and the humanitarian package. But when it comes to British nationals can the Foreign Secretary reassure the House that our consular teams have secured the full access on both sides of the Nepal Tibet border and what specialist British search rescue and victim identification assistance is being offered and will continue to be.

57:55 - 58:20

David Lammy

What what the right honorable lady raises a very important and sensitive issue around families of British nationals who are missing. We're engaging with the authorities on both sides of the border I can assure her and we are also and I said this from the the morning after the disaster when I spoke to the to the Nepalese Foreign Minister we are making available all the resources we have at our disposal to help in this process.

58:20 - 58:32

Speaker 81

Thank you Mr. Speaker. Can the Minister update the House about the steps that the government is taking to tackle the Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

58:32 - 59:10

Speaker 69

Mr. Speaker we are working closely with international partners to support the African-led response. We acted early to allocate an initial 2.6 to twen 26.9 million pounds to fund the immediate response in DRC and Uganda to support the World Health Organization and Africa Centers for Disease Control in coordinating the regional response. I am today pleased to announce to the House a further 51.8 million taking our total funding to 78.7 million. We're also taking a leading role internationally. I met the head of Africa CDC Dr. Jean Kaseya in Addis Ababa last week and I'll be discussing this issue with ministerial counterparts ahead of the UN General Assembly later this month.

59:10 - 59:26

Speaker 83

Mr. Speaker last month 12 protesters were arrested in Tbilisi just for displaying a banner criticizing Georgian oligarch Bidzina Ivanishvili who controls the Georgian Dream government. The European Union and the United States have taken steps to sanction Mr. Ivanishvili.

When will the UK government follow suit?

59:26 - 59:39

Stephen Doughty

Mr. Speaker, he knows we don't comment on future designations, but we have sanctioned a number of individuals in Georgia in relation to actions. And we urge Georgia to respect rights and freedoms and inclusive and open democratic society.

59:39 - 01:00:01

Speaker 82

Mr. Speaker, the catastrophic events in Nepal last week have had a profound impact on the significant Nepalese community in my constituency. As well as underlining both the need for further sustained effort to tackle climate change internationally, don't they also underline the need for continuing aid to Nepal?

01:00:01 - 01:00:22

Stephen Doughty

Well, he powerfully speaks up on behalf of his constituents with connections to Nepal. And I can absolutely assure him that we're looking at what further support we can offer to Nepal. And I would emphasize that we had stuff pre-positioned and our work on disaster risk reduction over many years has enabled us to be in a strong position to respond. But we will stand by Nepal as they have always stood by us and also work closely with China.

01:00:22 - 01:00:39

David Reed

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As bond yields climb sharply and Middle East turmoil revives inflationary pressures, how is the Foreign Secretary reassuring international partners that Britain can pay its way? And more importantly, is he warning the new Prime Minister of fresh non-essential spending?

01:00:39 - 01:00:58

David Lammy

I think what I would say to the honorable gentleman is I take incredibly seriously my role in helping to tackle the cost of living crisis the British people are facing. And that is working tirelessly to get back to the Strait of Hormuz being reopened so that actually we can get oil and gas flowing, which is what we need to do.

01:00:58 - 01:01:28

Nadia Whittome

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Around the world, countries like Seychelles are leading the way on decriminalizing same-sex acts, while others like Ghana are passing appalling new laws that attack the LGBTQ+ community simply for being who they are. Could the Minister assure this House that the UK is doing all it can to work with like-minded countries around the world to advance equality and protect the fundamental rights of LGBTQ people?

01:01:28 - 01:01:46

Anneliese Dodds

She's absolutely right to raise this issue, Mr. Speaker. And I'm very pleased to confirm to the House that back in May, I announced a 21 million pound fund to advance LGBTQ rights internationally over three years. This government will always support international rights of LGBTQ people forevermore.

01:01:46 - 01:02:18

Brendan O'Hara

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's beyond doubt that Israeli settlements in Palestinian territories are illegal. And the Foreign Secretary stated sanctions for those who participate in illegal settlement expansion will be brought forward. But sadly, Labour MPs in this House are trying to prevent this on the basis it could result in retaliatory measures from the US. So can the Foreign Secretary assure this House the UK's adherence to international law will not be traded away, that the rights of Palestinian people are not bargaining chips, and that he will not be bullied by backbenchers or President Trump into allowing continued settler violence and the deliberate destruction of the two-state solution?

01:02:18 - 01:02:25

David Lammy

I can assure him, Mr. Speaker, Labour MPs are very keen that action is going to be taken and it's going to be.

01:02:25 - 01:02:45

Sarah Champion

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, globally, the rights of women and girls are being stripped away at alarming speed, particularly when it comes to education and sexual reproductive rights. So can I ask the Foreign Secretary if he plans to honor his predecessor's commitment to make sure that women's and girls' rights are embedded across FCDO programming?

01:02:45 - 01:02:58

David Lammy

Mr. Speaker, let me take this opportunity to pay tribute to my predecessor, the Health Secretary, for the excellent work she did leading the campaign globally on violence against women and girls. And 100% yes, I will continue her brilliant work.

01:02:58 - 01:03:21

Marie Goldman

Mr. Speaker, I've heard firsthand from many Palestinian business owners how illegal Israeli settlements ruin lives and disproportionately impact women and girls. I've received hundreds of emails from my Chelmsford constituents demanding comprehensive government action. So will the Foreign Secretary reassure my constituents and pledge that any trade ban will also include services and investments?

01:03:21 - 01:03:35

David Lammy

As I said earlier, Mr. Speaker, we're looking at all of the economic issues in relation to the occupied territories. And I think the honorable lady makes a really important point, which is what has happened in Gaza and the West Bank has pricked the conscience of a generation, and that's why we will act.

01:03:35 - 01:04:02

Brian William Leishman

Mr. Speaker, does the Foreign Secretary share my concern that a British company, Dana Petroleum, is involved in a consortium granted licenses for oil exploration in Palestinian waters off the coast of the occupied Gaza Strip? That this is illegal and amounts to a war crime of pillage, and can you say what he intends to do in terms of challenging this illegal action by a British-based company?

01:04:02 - 01:04:18

Stephen Doughty

Well, Mr. Speaker, he raises a very important issue. The United Kingdom recognizes Palestine as a state and therefore its entitlement to a territorial sea. And let me be clear, I would expect any UK company to abide by their obligations under international law.

01:04:18 - 01:05:13

Lindsay Hoyle

Complimentary questions. We now come to the statement from the Prime Minister. And I know there's been a lot of speculation over the recess. Just to say this is in accordance with the rules of government. The ministerial code is quite clear.

So that's why, for those who said why haven't I commented, because it is within the rules that I don't make, it is this House that abides by them. We now come to Prime Minister's statement, Andy Burnham.

01:05:13 - 01:25:27

Andy Burnham

With permission, Mr. Speaker, I wish to make a statement on the direction in which I will lead our country. I come before this House having visited each of the regions and nations of the UK over the last six weeks, and Ukraine on the occasion of the 35th anniversary of its independence. The UK's steadfast support has helped sustain Ukraine's resolve over the last four and a half years, particularly so in the last two. That was the achievement of my predecessor, and as he stands down from this place, I want to pay tribute to the right honorable member for Holborn and St Pancras. He has given this country a lifetime of public service, Mr. Speaker, particularly for those fighting for justice.

When my right honorable friend delivered in this House on his promise to the Hillsborough families and everyone involved in the Hillsborough Law campaign, it was a moment I will never forget. His leadership took our party from one of its worst defeats to its best victories and created a platform to change this country for the better. We will use it well, Mr. Speaker, and we wish his family the very best for the future. The position my right honorable friend took on Ukraine, building on the work of his predecessors as Prime Minister, is one which I will not change, whatever the threats we face. We do not seek escalation, but instead will stand firm in providing what help we can to enable Ukraine to defend itself from this illegal invasion.

Britain's defense starts in Ukraine, and the defense of our nation will always be my first priority. On public safety, Mr. Speaker, I know the whole House will wish to join me in expressing deepest condolences to the family, friends, and colleagues of PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough, who were killed in the line of duty on the A66. We will do our best to support the Middlesbrough community, which is hurting and grieving right now, and we hear the call from the members of this House representing it for a discussion about investment in policing and police numbers.

I know I also speak for the whole House in expressing my profound shock and horror at the devastating scenes on the Nepal-China border. My sympathies are with all those affected, including the families and loved ones of those missing in this appalling tragedy. The Foreign Secretary is doing everything he can to support the Nepalese government and British nationals in the region. This is what the climate crisis looks like, Mr. Speaker. We have just ourselves experienced what is likely to have been the hottest summer on record.

This government will meet the climate challenge, and I can confirm to the House that I will attend COP31 in Turkey in November. Mr. Speaker, I will build on the work of my predecessor in other areas. When I visited Dover in early August, staff from Border Force and HM Coastguard told me extra police numbers on French beaches are beginning to deliver real results. I can report to the House today that this has continued throughout the last month, with numbers arriving over the summer halved on last year, making this year to date the lowest for crossings since 2021. Tomorrow, when I welcome President Macron to the UK on the occasion of the opening of the exhibition of the Bayeux Tapestry, I will thank him for the cooperation that has enabled us to prevent over 48,000 people crossing.

Where it is right to do so, Mr. Speaker, I will build on what has been achieved. However, where necessary, I will not hesitate to make changes. One of the first things I did after taking office was to review the plans to relieve pressure on prison places with the Lord Chancellor, who will provide a full update to the House following my statement. We took an early decision to exempt rape, grooming and serious child sex offences, and fast-track work to see if we could go further, hearing calls from the family of PC Andrew Harper and many others. As a result, Mr. Speaker, we are now confirming that anyone convicted of manslaughter, death by dangerous driving or indecent assault will not now see any change to their prison term.

We will find additional prison places by deporting more foreign national offenders, and finally grasping the nettle on an issue this House has ignored for too long: indefinite IPP sentences, a now-abolished policy, but one which to this day keeps people behind bars despite already having served more than their sentence. None of this is easy, Mr. Speaker, but I did what I always do, and that is to apply my values to a challenging situation, and a care for people which I spoke about in Downing Street. I believe the public will support me in recognizing the clear difference between those who have served their time and more, and those who have not. We will bring forward legislation soon, but we can find a solution to end this injustice which balances public safety and basic fairness, and I urge colleagues on all sides of the House to help us do that. This is politics done differently: problem-solving over point-scoring.

It is what the country needs. It is what the public want more of. And it will characterize my time in office, Mr. Speaker. I was pleased to begin cross-party talks over social care in the summer. And I thank the leader of the Liberal Democrats and the right honorable member for Daventry for the spirit in which that endeavor began.

And I wish the latter well as he leaves the front bench. When it comes to the biggest issues facing the country, the economy and the cost of living crisis, people are looking for much more substantial change, as promised in our manifesto, and that is what I will bring. Britain is not where any of us would wish it to be. Things are not working as they should. Life is too expensive and too hard for too many.

This is why this government's first moves were to give businesses and people a little breathing space. On tax, in my first week in office, we cut VAT on electricity bills and cut business rates for pubs, social clubs, and live music venues. We reinstated the two pound cap on bus fares for the whole of 2027. These measures will provide some relief, Mr. Speaker. They were funded by reprioritizing within government, as the bedrock of our approach will be grounded in fiscal responsibility.

But in the long term, lifting growth and living standards will require much more. What I bring back to the house after ten years away is a clear diagnosis of what has gone wrong, and let me lay it out clearly, particularly for the right honorable gentleman since he asked. From the 1980s, this country took a series of wrong turns. Political power was centralized. Economic power privatized.

The country deindustrialized. Austerity followed, hollowing out councils and depriving them of the agency to act to reverse any of this. And then Brexit compounded the damage, ushering in a decade of low growth and stalled regeneration. Change begins with honesty, Mr. Speaker. Not hearing much of it this afternoon.

Unless we are blunt about what went wrong, we won't turn things around. Far from taking back control, the combination of these policies took control out of the hands of communities up and down Britain. For forty years, too many places have been drifting. Too many British high streets tell the story of this decline. People yearn to see them restored to what they once were, as the community secretary and I heard on our visit to Ilkeston in the summer.

But they see no hope if we continue on the same path, with a failed economic model which does not trickle down much to places like theirs and instead allows wealth to be extracted and siphoned out. Britain's water industry stands as a leaking monument to that approach. A country run in the private rather than public interest, and that is now abundantly clear to voters of all parties, including the party opposite. The government I lead will be relentless in giving people and places what they were promised ten years ago: ownership and control. And from that control over their destiny comes change and growth.

I do. Let me explain why. Because it is backed by a decade of personal experience turning around one of the UK's former industrial heartlands and turning it into the fastest growing city region in the country, bucking the low growth trend. It has given me, Mr. Speaker, a clear theory of growth, and I will apply it to all parts of the UK, learning from what has been achieved in Greater Manchester. For a long time, the country did not have ambitions for its regions outside of London.

I say this with confidence.

It even talked of the managed decline of Liverpool. It took the devolution of power out of this place to allow our big city regions the ability to set new ambitions for themselves. Now I want every single place across our regions and nations to be able to do the same, creating the conditions for good growth in every postcode. And in that spirit, I was glad to meet the Liberal Democrat leader of Cornwall Council with my honorable friend, the member for Truro and Falmouth, on my recent visit. I know like many rural economies across the UK, Cornwall lacks a basic level of infrastructure, which in turn harms growth and holds back living standards and life chances.

And I heard the cross-party call for a devolution deal. I understand concerns in this house about the potential emergence of a two-tier England between those with devolved power and those without, and I will not ignore them. So I have asked Number 10 North to begin work with Cornwall Council and its six MPs on a devolution deal, with or without an elected mayor. And Mr. Speaker, I today extend the same offer to all parts of England without devolved power. The First Secretary of State will today write to every member of this house setting out how they can engage Number 10 North in the service of the places they represent.

I extended the same offer to the First Ministers of Scotland and Wales and the First and Deputy First Ministers of Northern Ireland when I met them over the summer. As they rightly pointed out, their situations are different, but there is interest in what a local model of devolution could look like in each of the home nations, and we will discuss that with them at a special meeting of the National Economic Council next month. Mr. Speaker, this government will oversee the biggest redistribution of power this country has seen. In July, we published a statement on the next stage of English devolution, and it will include powers long requested by mayors, such as post-16 technical education, employment support, and fiscal devolution, starting with the ability to set an overnight visitor levy to commence towards the end of financial year 27-28. The driving force behind it all will be Number 10 North.

It will oversee the rewiring of the British state, the rebuilding of resilience in our communities, and the reindustrialization of our regions. Its creation was one of the first acts of this administration, and I believe that in time it will be seen as one of its most significant. It is a clear answer to the question with which this country has long wrestled: who in government drives growth? My theory of growth requires it to be driven with the full authority of the very center of government in close partnership with HM Treasury. Number 10 North has been set up with that full focus: the single front door on which regions can knock to get quicker joined-up decisions from Whitehall and through which power and resources will be passed to them.

Resources will include human resources. This is because a state which has grown too large at the national level now needs to redirect civil service capacity regionally and locally, repairing the damage of austerity and making the service of place the state's first priority. We can already see what is possible, Mr. Speaker. I'm glad Number 10 North was able to stand behind Mayor Richard Parker when he took urgent action in August to prevent the collapse of bus services across the West Midlands. And I want to congratulate Mayor Steve Rotheram who this weekend, after four decades of deregulation, will see the first buses return to public control in the Liverpool City Region.

Taking back control of essential services like transport is an enabler of a more productive economy because it allows local areas to grab hold of the levers of power for themselves. But driving growth demands we go further. It is taking far too long for businesses to get grid connections. And they are being quoted prohibitively expensive sums of money if they try to bring those dates forward, as I heard on my visit to a farm near Truro. Household energy bills are the highest in Europe and the cost of energy is impacting business and inward investment.

Too many areas have seen water supplies disrupted this summer due to a lack of reservoir capacity. Our tourism industry is damaged by too many sewage spills. Why they say opposite, it's a question they should ask themselves. This summer has shown us very clearly that water companies are failing to rise to the climate challenge. It can't go on.

Later in the year, our 10-year plan for Britain will set out plans for stronger public control over these essentials, making them work for people and places again. Alongside this, we will empower all areas to expand the public housing stock, building on the first allocations from the Social and Affordable Homes Programme announced by the Communities Secretary last week. Mr. Speaker, bringing forward the biggest council home building programme since the post-war period is the Labour way to get the welfare bill down. So is reforming our education system so that it balances academic and technical and offers a path in life for all young people. Michael Gove calls this bringing back stupid, when in fact, for too many young people written off by his reforms, it is bringing back hope.

Allowing mayors to shape technical pathways and provide work placements for young people, building back into colleges and schools from the needs of the regional economy is the way to support more young people into work. So is prioritising more accessible community-based mental health services as we announced in the summer. This will be a major part of our response to the forthcoming Milburn report, which will follow its publication in the autumn. For it to work, a more intentional approach to the reindustrialisation of Britain is required. We will support all parts of the country to take more public control over investment strategy, learning from the Greater Manchester model of a consolidated good growth fund drawn from their own funds, prudent loan borrowing and fragmented budgets held by government bodies.

We will back local industrial strategies, a policy of the Theresa May government I am happy to revive, by identifying priority sectors and developing the triple helix approach to economic development by entwining business, academia and government behind the plan. This is the way, Mr. Speaker, we will build a pro-business culture and an innovation-led economy in all parts of the UK, finally capturing the long-term benefits of the invention that is in the DNA of our nation, backing our startups and scale-ups to stay in the UK where they were founded. Mr. Speaker, when I stood outside Downing Street six weeks ago, I said Britain needs a circuit breaker after a decade of turbulence, negativity, point-scoring and divisive politics. This is what I have outlined today: a clear, coherent and credible approach to growth that can unlock a feeling of positivity and possibility in every postcode in Britain. Our job in here is to make it real by taking a place-first rather than party-first approach.

It starts with reasserting basic standards for Britain, that this is a country where no one sleeps rough and no community is blighted by an illegal waste tip. And from there, working together to build a new sense of optimism around the country. We can make this next decade better than the last. We can lift the prospects of all our people and places. We can put more power into every postcode.

We can let Britain believe again. We can bring back hope. Mr. Speaker, I commend this statement to the House.

01:25:27 - 01:25:35

Lindsay Hoyle

Now come to Leader of the Opposition, Kemi Badenoch.

01:25:35 - 01:36:22

Kemi Badenoch

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I welcome the Prime Minister to his place at the dispatch box and take this, my first opportunity, to congratulate him on becoming Prime Minister. He has been in office for 43 days, during which I have learned about how he puts the milk in his tea, I have found out exactly what he thinks about pork scratchings, but I have not had the pleasure of asking him any questions. So we are all grateful, we are all grateful, Mr. Speaker, that he has finally found time to come to Parliament to answer some. Mr. Speaker, Mr. Speaker, it is only fair, Mr. Speaker, it is only fair to be gentle with someone on their first day at work, so I'm only going to ask him a few very simple but very serious questions, and I hope that he can provide me with some simple and serious answers.

I genuinely wish him well as he seeks to live up to the dignity and importance of the role. And I was pleased to see him in Ukraine over the summer, continuing the Conservatives' world-leading support for Ukraine's fight against Russian aggression. That being said, I'm also very relieved to see that he has not brought his guitar with him today. His predecessor stood at that dispatch box two years ago, sounding very triumphant, having just won a landslide, just two years ago. What went wrong?

Where is he now? Gone. That job is not as easy as it looks from the outside, Mr. Speaker. Labour MPs have not explained why they got rid of him, they have not explained, they're laughing, but they haven't explained why they got rid of his predecessor, but on this side of the House, we understand that this country's problems will not be solved by lofty promises alone. In the end, the Prime Minister will be judged on what he actually delivers.

This is a very different job to being Mayor of Manchester, where he did not have to pick winners and losers and he did not have to make difficult trade-offs. He did not have to worry about our national security.

He does now. A government's first and most important duty is keeping the country safe. The last Prime Minister and his Chancellor left an enormous hole in Britain's defence budget. We know this because the current Chancellor quit as Defence Secretary over that black hole, saying it could put British troops at risk. He said that there could be an attack by Russia on NATO as soon as 2030 and that not funding the defence investment plan reduces the readiness of our forces.

So let me ask the Prime Minister very clearly: will he provide the funding which his own Chancellor said was necessary to keep British troops safe, and that means 3% by the end of this decade? Mr. Speaker, keeping this country safe also means defending our borders. The Prime Minister mentioned boat crossings, but we must be honest: boat crossings have not gone down because of anything that Labour has done. We have to be honest. They, Mr. Speaker, boat crossings are down across all of Europe and have been for much longer.

Let us be honest: the problem is still not solved. The Prime Minister will have seen the extraordinary scenes in Ceuta over the summer, where more than 70,000 people tried to cross into Europe. Many of those people would like to end up in the UK. This is not just a British problem, it is a growing global problem. Even Denmark is starting to send illegal migrants to other countries as a deterrent, exactly like the Rwanda scheme we put in place and Labour scrapped.

We now hear that the Home Secretary is thinking about reviving a Rwanda-style scheme. So can the Prime Minister tell me, yes or no, is that the plan? Next, he must keep British people safe from dangerous criminals. It was interesting to hear his comments in the statement about early release. Before the summer, I sat with women who had experienced some of the most horrific crimes imaginable, and the perpetrators of those crimes were about to be let out of prison early.

The Prime Minister told those women that it was too difficult to keep their perpetrators in jail. Then he changed his mind. The family of PC Andrew Harper appealed to the Prime Minister not to release his killers early, and again he told them it was a non-starter. Then he changed his mind. The Conservatives told the government to create new spaces on the existing prison estate and to get foreign-born criminals out of our jails.

The government said we were wrong, now they're doing both. He has had, Mr. Speaker, he has had five different positions on early release in six weeks, putting the victims through hell with his indecision. So will he now set out a timeline for his promise to get more foreign national prisoners out of British prisons? As well as keeping the country safe, his next big challenge will be making people in this country feel richer. The biggest mistake Labour have made in office so far, and there've been quite a few to choose from, is that they crushed our economy under the weight of nearly 70 billion pounds in new taxes.

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister wasn't here so I will give him the list: the jobs tax, the family farms tax, the family business tax, taxes on pensioners, taxes on workers, taxes on businesses. Three and a half thousand pounds a year for every working family.

He says he cares about the cost of living; Labour's taxes have made that worse. Those taxes, Mr. Speaker, have cost people their jobs: thousands of jobs in oil and gas, thousands of jobs in industry across our country. The recruitment market for new graduates is the worst it has ever been. There are 50% fewer vacancies than last year, which was already the worst on record. If he does not change course, he too, like every other Labour Prime Minister, will leave office with unemployment higher than when he came in.

So can he guarantee, here and now on the floor of the House, that there will be no more tax rises in the autumn budget?

Mr. Speaker, the year is 2026. The year is 2026. Yet the Prime Minister said in his statement that everything has gone wrong since the 1980s, still complaining about Margaret Thatcher. I am 46, Mr. Speaker, I'm 46 years old. He is talking about a woman who became Prime Minister before I was born.

He is living in the past and he wants to take us back to the 1970s. On this side of the House, we are for the future. We are for the future, Mr. Speaker, not the past. That is the difference between them and us. His ideas are all about more government control, more spending, more tax, more politicians.

Conservatives want people to keep more of their own money. We want businesses to grow, to invest, to expand, and to create more jobs. That is the difference between the Labour Party and the Conservative Party. His diagnosis is completely wrong. His theory of growth is completely wrong.

He thinks that if government spends more money, we will all get richer. That is not how this works. Companies are not leaving our shores because there isn't enough government. Another difference between us, Mr. Speaker, is dealing with the ballooning welfare bill. Up and down this country, hardworking people are fed up with going to work, fed up of paying for their neighbors to sit at home with mild health conditions which don't stop them from working.

They are fed up of hearing, as we did this summer, that working in Boots is not good for your mental health. Ridiculous. We are on the side of those hardworking, fed-up people, Mr. Speaker, we are on their side. So I ask him: will he stand up to his backbenchers in a way that his predecessor never could and cut the benefits bill?

It is a simple question, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister engineered it so he could have as long a summer holiday as possible, so he should be ready with some answers. And Mr. Speaker, I'm even hearing rumors, I'm even hearing rumors that he doesn't want to do PMQs next week. But it is my job to ask him serious questions and it is time for him to start answering. I know they don't like hearing the questions, Mr. Speaker, but they're going to hear them.

It is my job to speak on behalf of all of those people out there who want to know what he has planned, and it is time for him to start answering some serious questions. Governing is hard, but the country needs him to succeed. Where it is in the national interest, I will help him, and he may find Conservative votes come in handy when Labour MPs are too scared to do the right thing.

Britain faces many serious challenges to our national security and to our economic security. There are difficult decisions to make, and they will show whether the Prime Minister is serious about governing. On defense, his own Chancellor said 3% was needed to keep British troops safe. Now, apparently, he doesn't believe this. On illegal migration, Labour scrapped Rwanda.

Now they appear to be considering a Rwanda-style scheme of their own. On prisons, he said dangerous criminals could not be exempted from early release, then he changed his mind. This country cannot afford a government swerving all over the place. Labour have already tried government by U-turn. It doesn't work.

If he wants to be different from his predecessor, if he wants to live up to the optimistic vision he is painting, he's going to have to start taking this job seriously. That is not, that is not what we heard from the Prime Minister today, but that is what the Conservatives are offering.

01:36:22 - 01:43:52

Andy Burnham

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I thank the honorable lady for the welcome that she gave me and to her kind words. And can I appreciate the tone of some of what she had to say there. And I do want to try and work with her across the floor of this House where we can. She mentions my summer, Mr. Speaker.

I notice she spent hers traveling all the way to Rome to be told by the Italian Prime Minister not to do a deal with reform. Well, if she'd have called me, I'd have told her that and saved her the trip, Mr. Speaker. She was right, she was right to start on Ukraine as I did. And I did mention the work of previous Prime Ministers in setting the right tone. Boris Johnson, Liz Truss, Rishi Sunak, everybody played a role in setting that tone, and it has been carried on by the right honorable member for Holborn and St Pancras.

And it is a very challenging situation, but I was there to send a very clear message that with a change of Prime Minister, there does not come any change, Mr. Speaker, in Britain's approach. And I hope I speak for the vast majority of members of this House in making that completely plain. She said that the job of Prime Minister is different to the job of Mayor of Greater Manchester, and I can vouch that I know that now, Mr. Speaker, after six weeks in the role. She was wrong to say, though, that in that role I didn't have to worry about national security. I did have to worry about national security.

Within two weeks of taking office, I had to deal with the appalling terrorist attack at the Manchester Arena. And I send all my best wishes to those who gathered last night at the Heaton Park synagogue, Mr. Speaker, remembering our friends who lost their lives, the incredible efforts of Rabbi Daniel Walker and others to hold the attackers at the door. And we all send them our very best wishes and reaffirm again, hopefully from all sides of the House, that antisemitism is a scourge that we should work together to remove from our society. She mentions defense, Mr. Speaker, and she again is right to, because this is a changing and challenging world in which we live. But can I say to her very, very directly, I appointed this Chancellor of the Exchequer precisely because of his commitment to the defense of our realm and the arguments he has made.

And he will set out at the, he will set out at the spending review the path to honoring our international commitments in full, as I said we would when I was before the steps of Downing Street. Mr. Speaker, I think those listening at home will find it hard to accept what the right honorable lady said about the boat crossings that are significantly down, halved on last year, had nothing to do with anything this government has done.

That is plainly not the case. I heard an opposition spokesperson on the radio this morning trying to find any excuse to justify it, the weather and all kinds of things. Can they not just accept that the action that we're taking is making a progress? The cooperation with the French that I mentioned. And yes, we will continue to look at all measures, the Home Secretary and I.

We will be relentless in making sure we continue to make progress, but it would, I think, do the party opposite well to recognize that significant progress has indeed been made. On the early release of prisoners, I don't think there is any moral high ground here for any party in this House. The Justice Secretary will make a statement and lay out the timeline for foreign national offenders to be returned after mine. And I hope we can work together on that question of IPP sentences, because, Mr. Speaker, too often issues in this House just get left. I left ten years ago worried about this issue and I come back to find it's not resolved.

Social care was something I spoke about a lot when I left. I come back, it's not resolved. We have to do better, don't we? We have to find more ways of working across this House and not just leave issues unresolved and all the harm that that causes. On growth, Mr. Speaker, I cut tax twice in my first week.

And I can say to the honorable lady that I am committed to bringing down the welfare bill, but there's a way of doing that that isn't about crude cuts, but is about providing the right support for people, particularly young people, whom, in my view, the education system has let down. She mentions the 1980s. I have to say to her, that is the legacy that we are still struggling to reverse. It's the reason why... well, let's have this argument in this House. Why are people paying such high water bills and the infrastructure is crumbling before our eyes?

Why are energy bills in this country the highest in Europe? Why do members opposite represent constituencies where bus services year after year have been cut and the fares have gone up? And they know the truth of what I'm saying, Mr. Speaker. Let's have some honesty so that we can deal with these issues properly. And, Mr. Speaker, if I conclude by saying, you know, she raises an ideological point.

I noticed yesterday she appointed a new shadow cabinet. The new shadow chancellor, I welcome him to his position too, I believe the author of the mini budget. I think at least half of the shadow cabinet supported the Liz Truss government. The honorable lady said the fact that I had been in my position for 43 days. Well, can I turn that round and say, and that means in six days this government will have outlived the Truss government and will be here for a lot, a lot, a lot longer.

So, Mr. Speaker, I will work with the right honorable lady where we can and we should make that commitment to each other today, but I will still point out where she's wrong. We are not in a position, Mr. Speaker, to take lectures where this country is moving in the right direction. You can see that on the economy, you can see that on small boat crossings, you can see that on the cost of living, and that is what we will continue to do to turn this country around.

01:43:51 - 01:43:52

Dame Meg Hillier.

01:43:52 - 01:44:41

Margaret Olivia Hillier

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I welcome the Prime Minister to his office and to the dispatch box. And... sorry about this, people shouldn't leave when a member's on their feet. It's discourteous. Dame Meg Hillier. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I know with my fellow committee chairs, we look forward to welcoming him to the Liaison Committee very, very soon so we can drill into his agenda in more detail.

I was really pleased over the summer about the announcements on housing, where in London this is really holding people back. It's causing so many challenges. One of those is that it's hard to release public land that has previously been used for education or health, for example, for building on. Will he undertake to put a rocket under release of that land where it's appropriate and best to deliver housing?

01:44:41 - 01:45:33

Andy Burnham

Prime Minister. Well, can I thank my right honorable friend... no, well, my apologies, my honorable friend for Hackney South. And can I say I look forward to my first appearance before the Liaison Committee. On the question of public land, she raises something that I think is a really important issue because we've got to look at how do we build as many council and social homes as we can to bring the housing benefit bill down, to bring the temporary accommodation bill down, which is ruinous in London for London councils. And we have to find ways of doing that within the public purse.

And public land is one of the ways that we can achieve that. So I will be looking at a program of the release of public land to build council and social homes, and I look forward to working with her on that.

01:45:33 - 01:45:37

Lindsay Hoyle

Leader of the Liberal Democrats, Ed Davey.

01:45:37 - 01:48:49

Edward Jonathon Davey

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank the Prime Minister for advance sight of his statement, and can I welcome him to his place? And can I associate myself with the condolences he has sent to the family and friends of the police officers killed on the A66 and his comments on the disaster on the Nepal-China border. Mr. Speaker, I wished each of his predecessors well. But given how that went for them, perhaps he'd prefer I didn't bother this time.

But I do sincerely hope the Prime Minister can turn things around, and quickly, because we all know how fed up people are. We hear it all the time. Every year it gets harder to make ends meet. The waiting lists seem to go up. More and more things just seem broken.

And we know the populists and extremists are eager to keep things that way so they can profit from it. But everything the Prime Minister has just described in his statement would only be possible if we fundamentally change the way we do politics in our country. Growing the economy, cutting the cost of living, fixing our public services, restoring people's trust, these are things every new Prime Minister has talked about, but they failed because they stuck to a broken political system. A system that makes it impossible to really change things for the better. Now the reason so much is broken in our country and never gets fixed is partly that our political system concentrates too much power in the wrong hands: in Westminster, in Whitehall, in big multinational companies.

And I think he gets some of that, judging by what he's been saying. But there are so many more problems in our political system: too much power in the hands of social media barons who interfere in our politics, crypto-billionaires who use donations to buy influence, and too little power in the hands of our people.

Britain's political system too often rewards corruption and leaves everyone else feeling powerless. Our great country, Mr. Speaker, is being held back. And it will only be free to thrive again if we put real power in people's hands. We've been campaigning on this for decades. The Prime Minister himself has written about it.

And his decision over the summer to finally start cross-party talks on social care, talks I've been desperate to start for years and which Conservative and Labour Prime Ministers promised but failed to deliver, that is a welcome step in the right direction. But there is a lot more work to do and more fundamental changes needed to make our politics work for the people we serve. So will the Prime Minister start that work today and, listening to the calls of over 170 members on these benches and on his own, launch a national commission to change politics so we can fix our country?

01:48:49 - 01:51:58

Andy Burnham

Well, Mr. Speaker, can I thank the right honourable gentleman for his contribution just now? And there is plenty there that I can agree with and work with him on. Too much power in the wrong hands. It's what I was saying to the right honourable lady a moment or so ago. Can anyone in this House say that the water industry is sufficiently accountable to their constituents?

Can anyone in... Okay, Northern Ireland we will... Oh, Scotland, sorry, I... my apologies. And Scotland. There are models elsewhere which we can follow, Mr. Speaker.

Can anyone say with water in England that the money that is siphoned out in salaries and dividends is justifiable when the system can't provide a basic service to people this summer, when sewage spills out onto our beaches, into our lakes? Can anyone justify... I'm surprised that there isn't more recognition of that from the party opposite. 40 years, 30 years, I should say, of privatisation has not left it in a... in a good state. And changing some of these big things will require the different approach that the right honourable gentleman is... is calling for.

I was pleased that he came on his holiday to those cross-party talks on social care. I can give him a commitment that I will keep them going up until the point where Louise Casey reports next year with her options. And I hope even then we might be able to find a consensus option that we... we take forward. I do not want to leave this position, Mr. Speaker, without having put all of my political capital into solving this issue. I couldn't defend it as Health Secretary 16 years ago, that we were leaving people to lose everything that they'd worked for, but often only getting in return care that was substandard and not... not good enough.

And I know it from my own family experience that this can't carry on any longer. Nor can it be defended that people caring for other people's parents are on poverty pay and yet still giving them everything of themselves to those roles. We owe it to millions out there to fix this. And this is a test for this Parliament, what remains of it, to see if we can do that. And I will work with the honourable gentleman, right honourable gentleman, to do that.

On his suggestion of a national commission, I... there is a democracy taskforce working out of the Cabinet Office and I could certainly involve him in the work that that is doing.

I believe that this Parliament does need to be a circuit breaker for this country. I do not believe we can carry on as we are. We are losing the trust and faith of the public. We need to act together to turn it around and I look forward to working with him precisely on that theme.

01:51:58 - 01:52:02

Lindsay Hoyle

Dame Emily Thornberry.

01:52:02 - 01:52:53

Anne Emily Thornberry

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And the Prime Minister is absolutely right. We must free our politics and bring back trust. And it seems to me that we could start doing it tomorrow. We could take foreign influence out of our politics by banning foreign money from our politics.

I really welcome the fact that the government is going to amend the Representation of the People's Act and cap donations at 100,000. But given what's happened since the Rycroft review, I worry that the cap isn't strong enough and I think that the public agree with me. So given there is probably going to be our last chance to protect our democracy before the next general election, could the Prime Minister give serious consideration to supporting my amendment which bans all foreign donations? For reference, it's clause 85.

01:52:53 - 01:53:32

Andy Burnham

Prime Minister. Well, can I thank my right honorable friend the member for Islington South and agree with her very strongly that we need to restore trust, particularly when it comes to foreign donations that seek to influence our politics. And I'm pleased she recognizes the amendments that have been brought forward to the Representation of the People Act which will be debated in this House later this week, Mr. Speaker. I mentioned the Defending Democracy Taskforce which has been set up in the Cabinet Office. I think it needs to continue to look at these issues.

And this won't be the last chance, Mr. Speaker. I think we can come back to these issues in this Parliament, such is their importance.

01:53:32 - 01:53:36

Lindsay Hoyle

Father of the House, Sir Edward Leigh.

01:53:36 - 01:54:34

Edward Leigh

May I congratulate the Prime Minister on what he said in about Ukraine and how he conducted himself there. And our enemies should know that this House is completely and utterly united in standing behind the Ukrainian people. And that was the most powerful part of his statement precisely because we're working together. So can I encourage him in another in this direction? We all know that we're under mortal threat.

We all know that we have to increase the defense budget. We all know that the decisions to pare back the bloated welfare bill are extremely difficult. So why doesn't he take up the offer of the leader of the opposition to deal with this, to meet our international commitments, to reduce dependency, to make sure that we're living within our means, work together and do this now, action this day?

01:54:34 - 01:55:47

Andy Burnham

Prime Minister. Well, can I thank the Father of the House for what he said about Ukraine and I saw the sincerity with which he said it and I appreciate it. It was important for me to make the journey last week. I know it was appreciated by President Zelenskyy and he asked me to relay to this House and beyond how much he and the Ukrainian people appreciate the support that we have provided and we will continue to do so for as long as it takes. On the question of meeting our defense commitments, Mr. Speaker, and bringing down the welfare bill, I can't defend a position where too many people in their 20s are on benefits.

But what I do say is why is that the case? And I do not believe we have an education system that is setting all young people up for success. I think there is more we can do to give young people work-related opportunity at 16. I think there is more support we can provide them with mental health. Those are the approaches I think we can take, Mr. Speaker, hopefully with cross-party support, to set our young people up for life, to invest in their success and that way bring down the welfare bill in a sustainable way.

01:55:47 - 01:56:19

Barry Gardiner

Barry Gardiner.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister has spoken powerfully about the devolution of power and giving back control. So will he ensure that the proposals for commonhold and leasehold reform that five million leaseholders in this country are waiting for with bated breath do give that power and control back to those people through the right to enfranchise and through the right to manage?

01:56:19 - 01:56:56

Andy Burnham

Can I thank my good friend, the member for Brent West? And can I say to him that I'm looking at every facet of the cost of living crisis and where people face unfair charges that they can't avoid, and this area of leasehold is absolutely in that territory. So can I make a commitment directly to him today? It is my intention, the intention of the government, to bring forward that commonhold and leasehold bill so that finally we can reform this unfair system, and we will do that in this session.

01:56:56 - 01:57:36

Simon Hoare

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome the Prime Minister to his place and sincerely wish him well for the future? He will know the vital importance of livestock farming to this country, and it is pivotal to the North Dorset economy. He will also know that there have been 783 confirmed cases of bluetongue since just the 1st of July. The cost of vaccination is £3 per sheep and £6 for cattle.

What support can the government give to livestock farmers who are already hard pressed as a result of a very dry summer and a very wet winter?

01:57:36 - 01:58:57

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the member for North Dorset, I'm probably not renowned for spending much time on farms, I'm more likely to be found in the northern quarter of Manchester, but I was on a farm in Cornwall in the summer precisely to engage and understand the issues that they are facing. And I heard very clearly the issues that have been presented by this very difficult summer for farmers up and down the country. And can I say to him, I will focus on farming because for me farming and food production is part of the sovereign production and manufacturing capacity of this country that we'll need to strengthen in years to come. We will need to depend upon it and therefore we need to strengthen it more now. And that is a clear commitment to give him some sign that I mean what I say.

I did, I didn't go empty-handed to Colwin Farm. I took a commitment to allow more flexibility over Defra funding so that areas could be used for grazing that were previously not able to be used for that, also funding to build reservoir capacity on farms so that summer 27 hopefully will be less painful than summer 26. But that's my commitment, Mr. Speaker, and I look forward to working with him to improve measures for farming.

01:58:57 - 01:59:23

Bill Esterson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I very warmly welcome my right honourable friend's commitment to continuing Britain's global leadership on climate action, including going to COP31? Can I also welcome the breathing space that he's focused on for people and businesses? But as he said, it will take a lot more than that to deliver the growth and the re-industrialization I know he's so committed to.

01:59:23 - 01:59:38

Speaker 107

So can I encourage him to read the Select Committee's report on the cost of energy, where we have recommendations on how to bring down those disastrously high costs that are crippling in competitiveness for so much of British industry?

01:59:38 - 01:59:39

Prime Minister.

01:59:39 - 02:00:18

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my good friend, the chair of the Energy Committee, for that contribution? And in the words of the Chancellor, we need to focus on cost of living, but also cost of business. And it's those two things together that we need to address and bring the cost of energy down. It's ruinous for households, but also for business, as I was saying in my statement. The cost of grid connections can be huge.

The long wait that businesses can face is damaging for inward investment. We do need to bring serious reform, I believe, to deal with those issues, and I look forward to working with him on that.

02:00:18 - 02:00:20

Lindsay Hoyle

Mr. Carmichael.

02:00:20 - 02:01:01

Alexander Carmichael

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I welcome what the Prime Minister just said there about strengthening farming? And if he's serious about this, then one of the first things he can do is ensure that our farmers do not have to compete with imported food that is produced to lower standards than we expect. On Thursday, the European Union will ban the import of beef from Brazil because they are not satisfied that it is produced safely. The USA, China, and Norway are likely to do the same thing.

So will the Prime Minister offer to our consumers and our farmers the same protections that these governments offer theirs?

02:01:01 - 02:01:02

Prime Minister.

02:01:02 - 02:01:51

Andy Burnham

Well, I am listening carefully to what the honorable member for Orkney and Shetland is saying. And can I say to him that all of these issues are on the table at this moment in time? But particularly public procurement, I have been working with the First Secretary of State and the Chancellor to consider how we change British public procurement to support our own production and manufacturing base. I believe there's so much more we could do to make sure food grown on British farms is served in our schools, in our hospitals, in our prisons, and beyond. I do believe we can do a lot more through public procurement before we reach to protectionist measures, but I hear what he has had to say today.

02:01:51 - 02:03:07

Andy McDonald

Andy McDonald.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I congratulate the Prime Minister on taking office, and I thank him profoundly for his tribute to the Cleveland police officers, PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough, so tragically killed on the 22nd of August. My Middlesbrough and Thornaby East constituents, and indeed constituents across Teesside, welcome his remarks in the past week on support for Cleveland Police, and I look forward to the Home Secretary's statement later today. His remarks on greater public control of public service and public utility provision are most welcome, and I look forward to discussing the nature of that public control in more detail in the coming weeks and months. One core aspect of that is the continued waste of public funds through continued use of outsourcing to provide core public services.

I trust that he will engage with key stakeholders who have provided yet more evidence that it makes complete economic sense to insource provision of our services. And does he agree that we must make sure that the new public interest test does its job of economic transformation and delivers, as we promised, the biggest wave of insourcing in a generation?

02:03:07 - 02:04:24

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my friend for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East? I was really distressed by what I saw in his community following the tragic death of our two police officers, the seven lives lost in total, and I know it has sent shockwaves through the community.

From my previous role, I know about the unfairness in police funding, or that is how it is felt in some parts of the country, and I know he feels that and his colleagues do too. I think we do need to look at that question as part of the wider police reform programme that the Home Secretary has on. On the second part of his question, the manifesto does commit us to the largest wave of insourcing in a generation, and my right honourable friend is overseeing that work. If you take one example that I mentioned in my statement, employment support, often delivered through outsourced contracts. I believe if you bring that in and put it under the control of mayors and combined authorities, who can spend that funding through the community, voluntary, social enterprise sector, I personally believe that money would achieve far greater results than it currently does.

02:04:24 - 02:05:01

Esther McVey

Could the Prime Minister explain what was so particularly deserving about the Avanti train drivers that they warranted such a pay increase? Or was it done just to avoid the embarrassment of the Cabinet not being able to get back and forth to his Number 10 of the North vanity project? Or do we take it that this Prime Minister will cave into every trade union demand that comes across his desk?

02:05:01 - 02:05:41

Andy Burnham

Mr Speaker, the right honourable lady for Tatton knows as well as I do the misery that her constituents have suffered on the West Coast Main Line, particularly since her government handed it over to Avanti West Coast. It is not what they should be expected to put up with, Mr Speaker. Manchester lost its services under her government. We have to have a functioning railway line, and the agreement reached with the drivers will give that security of a good service to people in her constituency and across the North West.

02:05:41 - 02:06:14

Speaker 119

The Prime Minister has hit the road running and running into issues that are long overdue. For my six-year campaign to scrap aim to permit, I thank the Prime Minister for making that announcement over the summer. Local people will now have a say what their high street looks like, vibrancy. Local councils will now have a say. Will the Prime Minister work with me to reinvigorate our high streets and also implement a few more of my campaigns?

02:06:14 - 02:07:14

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my honourable friend for Brent East, who has been a doughty campaigner for improved services on our high streets and particularly pointing out the risks of the aim to permit regime, which has allowed the proliferation of adult gaming centres, for instance, Mr Speaker, in some of our more deprived communities. And my whole approach, Mr Speaker, will be to create an incentive regime that supports the businesses that are bringing good things to our high streets, hospitality, others that give people a place to go and bring the communities together, and take action against those who do harm. And we announced tougher action on vape shops in the summer alongside adult gaming centres and other gambling venues. So she deserves great credit, Mr Speaker, for the campaign that she's run, and I'm pleased that she feels now we can begin to turn our high streets around.

02:07:14 - 02:07:40

Lisa Smart

I was encouraged to hear the Prime Minister talk about his support for political reform and indeed looking at the voting system.

But can I push him to be just a tiny little bit more specific? He could if he wanted bring in a change to the voting system ahead of the next general election if he wanted to. We would strongly back him. But if he doesn't want to do that, will he at least commit to kicking off a commission, a national commission on electoral reform?

02:07:40 - 02:07:43

Lindsay Hoyle

Prime Minister.

02:07:43 - 02:08:32

Andy Burnham

Mr. Speaker, can I thank the honorable lady who I know well for that question. And I think she may have heard me speak before about leaving this place 10 years ago, standing for the first time under a proportional system and seeing how it changed the conversation on the doorstep where all of a sudden you had an incentive to look for a point of agreement rather than to score points as I've been saying. So that experience changed me. Where I will disagree with her is in saying that we do that ahead of any general election because I do believe that there needs to be a mandate to make that change. So from my point of view, there are different views in this House, but I believe we will need to get a consensus at the next election and if there is that consensus, then a change can be made in the next Parliament.

02:08:32 - 02:08:33

Catherine West.

02:08:33 - 02:08:57

Catherine West

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and could I thank my right honorable friend for the work that he's done to date on rough sleeping and tackling the scourge of rough sleeping so prevalent in many of our cities and towns and also outside of our cities and towns. And could I ask him what vision he has to include the voluntary sector in that crucial task of tackling rough sleeping?

02:08:57 - 02:10:13

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my honorable friend. I was going to say leadership rival, but I don't think she was ever fully in that category, Mr. Speaker. But she is absolutely right to point to the role of the voluntary sector in the mission that I've launched to end rough sleeping if we can by the end of this year. I don't think public funds alone will get us all the way, Mr. Speaker. We will need to rely on voluntary contributions, the work of our charities.

In the end, they are doing the work to tackle rough sleeping across the country. I believe it is incumbent on all members of the House to put their shoulder behind this. And I'm looking, I can't remember the honorable gentleman's constituency, but I remember Harrow East and I remember the work that he did in the private member's bill that he brought forward. It should be a cross-party matter. In my view, nobody should sleep rough on our streets.

We all have charities in our constituencies who are doing the most amazing work to support people. And any of us can find ourselves in that position such as life these days. We should all get behind this drive. We should thank those organizations for their work and let's see if we can give an offer to everyone in this country to come inside by Christmas.

02:10:13 - 02:10:16

Lindsay Hoyle

Stuart Andrew.

02:10:16 - 02:10:54

James Stuart Andrew

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In a volatile world, I think we can all agree that energy security is important, but so too is food security. I was interested in the answer he gave to my honorable friend a moment ago because in the eastern side of my constituency, there is an application for a huge solar farm on prime agricultural land when on the western side there are huge distribution warehouses with not a single solar panel on their roof. So will he commit to review this situation so we can have a policy that safeguards both our food and our energy?

02:10:54 - 02:11:12

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the right honorable gentleman, that was characteristically clear and a good suggestion and it's one I will take up. And I meant what I said when I thanked him for coming to those cross-party talks in the summer. I've always enjoyed working with him and I wish him well whatever comes next.

02:11:12 - 02:11:14

Lindsay Hoyle

Toby Perkins.

02:11:14 - 02:12:05

Toby Perkins

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome what the Prime Minister said and particularly welcome his commitment to go to COP31.

Um, what will be even more important than him going there is what he says when he gets there, and we look forward to him showing that the UK will continue and remain to be a really, really committed to fighting climate change here in the UK and doing our bit overseas. So can he say any more about whether he will be able when he goes to COP31 to commit to the Tropical Forests Forever facility that the government has been looking at, and whether he will also be saying that his fight on the on the cost of living will continue to encourage people to take those choices that support the environment, such as having an electric vehicle or having electric bringing down the cost of electric to support those heating choices?

02:12:05 - 02:12:06

Prime Minister.

02:12:06 - 02:12:58

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to to my honorable friend, I strongly support the last point that he that he made. I know from my experience in my previous role when we electrified bus depots and the bus fleet in Greater Manchester, the running cost of the system came right down, and it helped us sustain the two pound fare cap that had been removed elsewhere, and it's proof that action on climate can reduce the cost of living, and these two things should not be pitched as opposites, they can be causal, you can act on climate and you can bring down the cost of living. So I will be at COP31 as he said, I do recognize the importance of the of the rainforest and continuing to provide our support in the form of of loans to support work to conserve it. I look forward to working with him on these issues, and I hope to see him in Turkey.

02:12:59 - 02:13:46

Dave David Michael Doogan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister to his place and in so doing extend my best wishes to not only him but also his family as he takes up the manifold burdens of his new role. He was heard in his ascent to high office to report that the UK isn't working and Westminster isn't working. Well, I have 100% agreement with him on that, although my prognosis would be terminal rather than treatable. He he understands that energy bills are now 600 pounds higher than Labour promised they would be at the general election, and there's another large increase coming before Christmas.

He touched on energy in his statement, so will he give us a date between now and whenever the general election will be that energy bills will be 300 pounds lower, just in the way that Labour promised?

02:13:46 - 02:13:47

Prime Minister.

02:13:47 - 02:14:41

Andy Burnham

Can I thank the leader of the SNP, particularly for the very kind words that he he he used, and my family will appreciate those, so thank you for saying that. And Mr. Speaker, I could see things, I could relate more to what I used to hear from those benches when I left this place than when I used to be in here, when I was sometimes finding frustrations, let's say, with Westminster and the way it works. But it's precisely because we need to rewire it and get power out of here and into the country, in my view, we do that and we keep the United Kingdom together if we do that, because then all parts of it will feel that it's working for them in a way that perhaps they don't feel at this moment in time. When it comes to energy bills, I have acted already to bring in that cut on VAT on electricity bills. I recognize it's just a start, but I hope he sees that as a sign of intent.

02:14:41 - 02:14:42

Gareth Snell.

02:14:42 - 02:15:12

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and can I congratulate and welcome the Prime Minister to his place and welcome what he said about serving British food across the public estate in this country. And can I push him further and say that British food should be served on a British plate made in by British ceramics, and the houses that he wishes to build should be made with British brick. So can I encourage him to go as fast as he absolutely can on rewiring public procurement so that British jobs in this country can be benefited by the British taxpayer's pound?

02:15:12 - 02:15:13

Prime Minister.

02:15:13 - 02:16:02

Andy Burnham

Mr. Speaker, I will be a a staunch defender of the potteries in this in this house, if not its football clubs, and I don't know whether they are the North West or the West Midlands, but certainly I'm very fond, and I know the crucial importance of the ceramics industry to that part of the country. I do think there is much more we can do with public procurement in Britain to support crucial industries.

I don't think we've done enough in the past. Social value weighting can be applied to all public procurement, which makes it more likely that contracts will be awarded to British-based entities. I don't think we should allow the culture of sending everything outside of this country to continue. This will be a big change under this government.

02:16:02 - 02:16:41

Roger Gale

In welcoming the Prime Minister to his place, I noticed his criticism of the water companies, justified criticism in many cases of the water companies. Could I direct his attention to the predatory activities of another private company, National Grid, who are seeking to preempt the construction of a station on the Minster Marshes with no planning consent whatsoever and while the results of a planning inspectorate inquiry are still awaited. Would he be kind enough to intervene?

02:16:41 - 02:17:11

Andy Burnham

Well, Mr. Speaker, it's good to see the right honorable gentleman again. And I appreciate what he said endorsing what criticism I was making of the water industry. I do think we need to find a significant reform. If that can be done cross-party, so much the better. On the issue that he raised, I am not familiar with the planning situation that he mentioned, but I will look out for him and I will have a word with him and I will see if I can do something to look into it.

02:17:11 - 02:17:46

Jessica Morden

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and thank you Prime Minister for visiting Port Talbot steelworks last week and highlighting the importance of securing and protecting our sovereign steel industry, which I know as Prime Minister he will do. Steel communities have long faced unfair global trading practices, but our new safeguards will still leave some steel manufacturing unprotected, including galvanized steel made by Llanwern steelworks in Newport. Will the Prime Minister work with business, trade, Tata, and the trade unions to see what more can be done?

02:17:46 - 02:18:45

Andy Burnham

Well, Mr. Speaker, can I say to my honorable friend, I was really pleased to visit Port Talbot last week. And I know the importance of the steel industry in her part of the world, the history of it. And what I came away with was a clear sense of what is possible, carrying through an industrial transition that will set up steelmaking for the rest of this century. Now, this is another one of those things, one of those things I've spoken about today that this country hasn't done well. Industrial transition is definitely one of those things.

We allowed deindustrialization in the past before trying to help industry into a new era. We need to make it work this time in South Wales. I said it to the trade unions last week. I said it to the leadership of Tata. I will say it to the honorable lady in this House.

We will make that happen and we will guarantee steelmaking in South Wales for generations to come.

02:18:45 - 02:19:18

Richard Tice

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister's spoken a lot about the increase in the cost of living, and much of that is driven by the increase in the energy prices because of the rush towards net stupid zero and the multiple increase in renewables such as solar farms on our productive agricultural farmland. It's madness to import gas from overseas when we've got our own gas in the North Sea. So when will the Prime Minister do the right thing, approve the licenses at Rosebank and Jackdaw and elsewhere in the North Sea?

02:19:18 - 02:20:06

Andy Burnham

Well, Mr. Speaker, I don't know if the honorable gentleman was listening a moment ago when I was talking about how renewables can bring down the cost of living.

And I gave a very clear example in Greater Manchester. It costs thirty pounds to charge a bus with electric charge, two hundred plus to fill a tank of diesel. He really does need to look into the facts a little bit more before he makes statements like that in this house. Solar panels on people's homes can bring down the cost of their energy. And yes, Mr. Speaker, we need to be pragmatic.

We will still need to rely on oil and gas for some years to come. The mistake he is making is saying it's got to be one or the other for political purposes. The truth is it's going to have to be both.

02:20:06 - 02:20:51

Dawn Butler

Mr. Speaker, I was proud to support the Feltham Convening Partnership's Young Leaders Summer Program last month. And what struck me was their ambition for themselves and their community, and also their call for more work experience opportunities. When the Tories and the Lib Dems in coalition made work experience optional, placements fell by sixty thousand in the first year, a drop from which we never recovered. Does the Prime Minister agree with me that this government's work with employers like Sainsbury's is now bringing hope, but that we must go further and faster, and that we must not deny the next generation the promise of Britain?

02:20:51 - 02:22:06

Andy Burnham

Can I thank my honorable friend for her work on this matter, on apprenticeships particularly? And I do think what she's just said needs to be understood when we consider the Milburn report, because some of the decline in apprenticeships for young people lies behind some of the statistics that he has revealed. I will pay some credit to the party opposite, Mr. Speaker, because the work placements that came with T-levels in the experience that I had in Greater Manchester was a huge and positive innovation. Forty-five day work placements made a difference for young people. It was enough for them to feel that they could belong in the place where they were.

I would like to work with members across this house to see if we can turn the commitment of a forty-five day work placement as a guarantee to all young people as part of our response to the Milburn report. The evidence I have is that they are hugely successful. Alongside that, more apprenticeships at nineteen, more degree apprenticeships beyond that. That is the way we give strong, structured pathways to our young people. The technical route is not bringing back stupid, it's bringing back hope as I said before.

02:22:06 - 02:22:59

Bob Blackman

Mr. Speaker, and I share the Prime Minister's vision of ending rough sleeping for good. He was very kind to refer to my private member's bill, but there's two actions that he could take now he's now in office. The first, as he knows, that the various different attempts at progress on Housing First across the country could be brought across the country, because ending rough sleeping is one thing, but building that network of support around people is absolutely vital. The second aspect is ensuring that my second private member's bill that became law in 2023, which actually would regulate the use of supported housing, still has to be enacted. Will he act now to make sure that's introduced so that vulnerable people are protected from rogue landlords?

02:22:59 - 02:24:11

Andy Burnham

Well, I meant what I said, Mr. Speaker, earlier in praising my honorable friend. He has done a huge amount of work in this area, and I recognize it. He mentions Housing First. I think he was one of those who persuaded Sajid Javid when he was in the community secretary role to pilot Housing First in three big cities: West Midlands, Greater Manchester, and Liverpool. And it was exactly as he said, hugely successful.

It was about prevention rather than paying for for crisis. And what I've experienced in my career, Mr. Speaker, is it's actually more expensive to leave somebody sleeping rough than it is to give them simple accommodation every night because the cost of many visits to A&E, long stays in hospital, time in police custody, that adds up to being more expensive than the simple provision of of a room. I will look at the bill that he mentioned and I will speak to the community secretary about it, but this is something we can fix. When issues are fixable, we should work across this house to do it. We can end rough sleeping.

We did it in the pandemic. I see no reason why we can't do it again.

02:24:11 - 02:25:24

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you so much, Mr. Speaker. And can I welcome my right honorable friend to to his place and also thank him for his statement. I particularly agree with him in what he was saying around social security and tackling the drivers of the high rates, for example, of young people who are not in education, employment or training. And I perhaps I could direct him to a report from the select committee which came out just before the recess specifically on that point. But could I ask my question in relation to the Middle East?

I know he's made reference in in the past to the importance of of being able to hold hold Israel to account. What does he think is the appropriate action that we and our partners can do in relation to ensuring humanitarian aid and access, but also in relation to the unlawful settlements? These are unlawful, and so many occasions the law has has been broken, and there's a real danger that Palestine state will not be viable if we carry on in this way. Thank you.

02:25:24 - 02:26:28

Andy Burnham

Thank you. Look, but can I thank my my honorable friend, my dear friend, the member for Oldham East and Saddleworth, and certainly I will look up the select committee report. Can I say to her in in answer to the points about the Middle East, as before I became Prime Minister, I did issue a statement saying I thought we needed to look again at the approach that we'd taken and be very clear about our values and what what we believe is right. And obviously matters are changing quickly. We've seen the really quite worrying statement about the E1 extension and the settlements there and the fast-track tender process, which I think would lead to decisions being made before the Israeli election, which as I understand it could imperil if not end the two-state solution.

So these matters are urgent. They do need to be confronted, and I believe we will be updating the house soon on those matters.

02:26:28 - 02:27:10

Benedicta Wera Hobhouse

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Just across from Number 10 North in Manchester, but in many towns and cities across the country, women are secretly filmed on a night out, and the videos are posted online with vile, degrading, misogynistic contents and comments. And the women only find out once these videos have been shared a hundred thousand times and more, and they do not know what to do, and we need to change something. Will the Prime Minister support the campaign to end this vile practice, including looking at reform to make misogyny a hate crime?

02:27:10 - 02:28:30

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank the honorable lady for her question, and can I say that these issues are very much at the forefront of my of my mind.

As the father of two daughters, I think about them a lot and remember the change that we brought in in Greater Manchester following the appalling murder of Sarah Everard. It was a moment that I think created such a powerful change in the conversation, challenging men, lads, boys for their behavior and making it absolutely clear that violence against women and girls of any kind, everyday harassment, needs to be an issue that they must be confronted with and must address. I've also recently, in recent days, met Georgia Harrison, who is doing amazing work, Madam Deputy Speaker, campaigning to protect women online and asking for the very reasonable request of any non-consensual explicit video being taken down immediately rather than 48 hours, which is currently the totally unsatisfactory approach. So I can tell the honorable lady I will support her 100% in bringing through that change, but also will think about the other points that she raised.

02:28:30 - 02:29:03

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There are four and a half million unpaid carers in England, and I know from firsthand the impact this has on carers and their families, having been a carer for two members of my own family. But I know from millions of carers, the emotional and the financial toll is far greater than I faced. Can the Prime Minister assure the House that when the casey review is completed, funding will not be the reason for its recommendations not being implemented?

02:29:03 - 02:29:56

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, can I say to my honorable friend, and I know this matters to her personally as it does to me. The leader of the Liberal Democrats made the point in the cross-party talks and powerfully in the media that family carers are often just not seen and sink slowly as the situation gets more and more unbearable, unsustainable for them, and I know that from my own family experience. So I give her my word that social care will be a huge priority for me from this dispatch box. We do need to support family carers, as the right honorable gentleman said. We need to support paid carers much more, who as I say are working on poverty pay.

I will not leave this role until we've brought forward a social care system that we can be proud of.

02:29:56 - 02:30:46

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituents in Bognor Regis and Littlehampton will have been pleased to hear Sir John Cunliffe with his 88 recommendations that he produced last July. But his diagnosis is rather different to the Prime Minister's. He believes that governance and regulation are the key to better performance, not some ill-defined version of better public control, which by the government's own assessment comes to more than 100 million billion pounds. So will the Prime Minister promise to enact all 88 of Sir John Cunliffe's recommendations without delay?

02:30:46 - 02:32:02

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the honorable lady, I appreciate the Cunliffe report takes us forward, but it was to some degree limited in what it was able to consider. And I believe we need to look at all possible solutions for the water, for the water industry. I don't think we're in a position where we can say what is being proposed will solve everything. It's a very regrettable situation that the privatization of water has left us in a position where we're going to find it very difficult to reverse. What has happened, Madam Deputy Speaker, is funding has left through salaries and dividends, bills were kept low for a period of time, but it was the infrastructure that is suffering.

And when it comes to the point now when we're needing to put those infrastructure problems right, it's the bill payers who are being asked to pay 20% plus on their bills, not those who siphoned the money out in the first place. It's an unsatisfactory situation. It's an industry where the shareholders never lose and the bill payers never win. And I say to the honourable lady, it is simply wrong and unsustainable.

02:32:02 - 02:32:35

James Mark Sewards

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister's commitment to regulate the funeral industry was extremely welcome. It was especially welcomed by those families who've been victims of rogue funeral operators, and I commend him for it. They are now asking when regulation will be brought into effect. So can I ask the Prime Minister, is this still a priority for him, and if so, when will the funeral industry finally be regulated?

02:32:35 - 02:33:07

Andy Burnham

Can I say to my honourable friend, the Member for Leeds North West and Morley, that I was truly appalled when I heard about what happened, and I feel for any family who was a victim of that despicable crime. And can I offer to him today a meeting on behalf of those families to listen and to see how we can build a programme of change that will meet what has been exposed by this terrible crime.

02:33:07 - 02:33:43

John Whittingdale

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Within a few days of the Prime Minister taking office, he announced business rate relief for pubs, clubs, and live music venues. But I had spent the summer talking to other businesses like hair salons, like post offices, like booksellers, all of which are just as important in the high street as those that have already been given help. So will he now commit to give business rate relief to all high street businesses and get rid of this cost which is destroying jobs?

02:33:43 - 02:34:42

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my right honourable friend. He is making a point that I made myself in the Makerfield by-election. I do think there is more we need to do to support our high streets. I have made a start with pubs and live music venues, but I do believe we need to go further in exactly the way he describes. And I think it is a case of rebalancing the system so that some of the large entities, the warehouses who don't in a percentage terms pay the same amount on business rates, we rebalance it so that we can support those businesses on the high street that are doing public good, are able to get a reduction to enable them to survive.

That's something that I'm looking at, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think we need to get serious about our high streets. We need to take action on those that cause harm, and I've mentioned vape shops and adult gaming centres. We need to do more to support those that do good.

02:34:42 - 02:35:57

Speaker 131

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I welcome the Prime Minister back to this place, to that place, and the ambition he has brought to this country. He will know that he will need time to achieve the things he set out today, which is why I know he will share my concerns about what is happening in British politics. Reform has accepted nine million pounds in donations this year alone, just eight million of which from three UK-based donors. That is more than the government party and the opposition party combined.

Checkbooks are already circling the next general election. And if we wish to defend our democracy and make sure that all voices can be heard equally, we need to make sure it's not money that talks. I heard what he had to say to my colleagues about the Defending Democracy Review, and I welcome it and the legislation tomorrow about UK donors. But he will know there are people closer to home who wish to use their money to influence the process too.

So can he confirm that his democracy review will look at caps on UK individual and company donors, and it will legislate before the next general election so that we act?

02:35:57 - 02:36:28

Andy Burnham

So can I say to my honorable friend, I recognize the importance of the issues that she's raising for the reasons I gave earlier. The bill that we will debate later this week is a start, but I don't think anyone on the front bench is saying it's the end of this matter. We do need to go further. I would encourage her to engage with the Defending Democracy Taskforce, and certainly I have an open mind about what those further measures might be.

02:36:28 - 02:36:30

Eleanor Laing

Martin Vickers.

02:36:30 - 02:37:16

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We in Northern Lincolnshire, Prime Minister, look forward to your first visit in your new position. You will find that if you travel by train from Manchester, there is an hourly service, but if you travel from London, there is no direct service. My honorable friend, the Father of the House, and I have been campaigning for a restore to restore the direct service for 15 years. If he could give an early win, it'd be victory for me in 15 years, but he could deliver it in 15 weeks.

Could he have a word with the Transport Secretary to have yet another look at providing this service, which I know will be supported by his PPS behind him?

02:37:16 - 02:38:11

Andy Burnham

Yes, I've only been back in this House, Madam Deputy Speaker, and already my PPS is lobbying me from behind, which is obviously helpful. But he's right to do so, and he's right to raise it. I remember as chair of the Rail North Committee in my previous role, the concern of people in his part of the world. The rail connections to my part of the North are nowhere near what they should be. But can I say, I heard skepticism on the benches opposite.

If he's interested, I will fix a meeting for him with the team at Number 10 North so that he can put his case. And this is why we took public control of the railways so that we can start to put services back. There's no point in having public control if it doesn't deliver public benefit. And in my view, every area needs a basic level of connectivity if we're to connect people to opportunity and get growth going in every postcode.

02:38:11 - 02:38:13

Eleanor Laing

Dr. Zubir Ahmed.

02:38:13 - 02:38:43

Zubir Ahmed

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's a lamentable tale. My father started driving buses in the West of Scotland in 1964. Glasgow was better connected and cheaper to get around than it is now in 2026. With the centralizing forces of the SNP government in Holyrood and a lack of attention by the SNP council in Glasgow, could I ask my right honorable friend the Prime Minister to lend his moral clarity and expertise on this matter and get Glasgow's buses moving again?

02:38:43 - 02:40:01

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to my honorable friend, I have had a number of approaches from colleagues in Glasgow about seeing how we can support them to move the bus system forward. I was surprised to hear how expensive bus fares are in the city. And I do believe there have been moves to put them back under public control, but I am not aware that that's been supported by the Scottish government. And I hope the Scottish government will provide funding and support to enable the Greater Glasgow area to move in that direction. If I'm wrong, I'm happy to be corrected.

But I did have a lot of people coming to me saying, we're not getting any support, can you help us move things forward?

A great city like Glasgow should have public transport, Madam Deputy Speaker, under its own control. And from what I see in Scotland, there is something of the same problem as in England, where the capital city has a public transport system that is way beyond what anywhere else has. It's not that we're anti-London or anti-Edinburgh, it's great that they've got those public transport systems, but all parts of the UK need to have a level of infrastructure that is seen to be fair and, as I said before, connects all people to job and opportunities, and Glasgow deserves that too.

02:40:01 - 02:40:04

Eleanor Laing

Helen Morgan.

02:40:04 - 02:40:36

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

I welcome the Prime Minister to his place and I welcome his commitment to put power back into the heart of communities through a devolution program. But in places like Shropshire, where there's no immediate plan for a combined authority or a mayoral authority to be put in place, people are really worried that we're going to be left behind. I wonder if the Prime Minister could elaborate on his earlier comments and explain when authorities like Shropshire will get those devolved powers and crucially the resources to go with them so that they can start turning around life for people in places like North Shropshire.

02:40:36 - 02:41:22

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the honorable lady, it was a serious offer that I made at the dispatch box earlier today to say that there could be a devolution deal for every part of England with or without an elected mayor. I do believe it will only work if it's based on unitary local government. I don't think it will work with a two-tier system. But that's why I said to colleagues in Cornwall, I'm quite happy to see if a deal can be done for a single unitary authority. That is what I understand members of Parliament for Cornwall want, working with the leader of Cornwall Council.

If that is the settled view, I'm not going to try and impose something else, let's work with that, and the same could be true in Shropshire, but it needs to be effective and functional and be able to stand on its own two feet.

02:41:22 - 02:41:24

Eleanor Laing

Rachael Maskell.

02:41:24 - 02:42:07

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I welcome my right honorable friend to his role. Ten months ago, my constituents were promised a public inquiry into the mental health trust after ten years of campaigning for it. People have died in the interim. It's simply unacceptable. However, in writing about unaccountable power over the summer, I see the weaknesses not only in the decision-making processes but also in the lines of scrutiny to ensure we can deliver for our constituents.

Will he work with me and the work that I've been doing to ensure that we're not just talking about devolution of power but also of scrutiny to hold these bodies to account?

02:42:07 - 02:42:36

Andy Burnham

Well, I can say to my honorable friend, Madam Deputy Speaker, that is entirely what the Hillsborough Law was about, and it builds on a duty of candor that was already there in the NHS but now will go further to those running NHS organizations and all NHS bodies. I would be happy to meet with her to discuss this in more detail because I can see how much it matters to her, and I hope that's a helpful commitment.

02:42:36 - 02:42:38

Eleanor Laing

Chris Law.

02:42:38 - 02:43:16

Brendan O'Hara

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister's spoken of his desire for a written constitution, arguing a formal legal framework is necessary to the devolution agenda. Yet in his short notice in office, short time in office I should say, he has already attempted to unilaterally defy the legally binding Good Friday Agreement by declaring that a border poll is, and I quote, off the table. Does the Prime Minister recognize he's no mandate to defy the constitutional wishes of the people of Northern Ireland, the people of Scotland, or the people of Wales, and that any written constitution or devolution agenda must include a pathway for each of those nations to choose their own future?

02:43:16 - 02:44:53

Andy Burnham

Well, I think the honorable gentleman has misunderstood what I actually said. I answered a media question on a visit to Northern Ireland before meeting the various parties, and the question was that a proposal was being put to the meeting about a border poll. And my answer was that the purpose of the visit was to get functional government in Stormont because in my view that would most serve the people of Northern Ireland right now, and I wasn't there to distract onto other issues.

I'm very aware of every word in the Good Friday Agreement. I will stick to it 100% as Prime Minister. I, you know, care about Northern Ireland. I visit often. It was, how do I put it, it was a situation that preempted the meeting we were about to have.

I wasn't there to discuss that. The Good Friday Agreement, if he reads it, as I'm sure he has, is quite clear on the circumstances in which that issue arises. And I, as I said, honor the words of the Good Friday Agreement. But our common challenge right now is functional government in Stormont. And I believe everybody should work together to achieve that.

And I've asked the Northern Ireland Secretary to support that process. And I recognize the concerns people have about the budget in Northern Ireland. Those are the issues to be dealt with first and foremost. And that was the answer that I gave to the media.

02:44:53 - 02:44:55

Eleanor Laing

Katrina Murray.

02:44:55 - 02:45:26

Katrina Murray

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and welcome my right honorable friend to his place. During the summer recess, I spent time engaging with organizations who work with children and young people in my Cumbernauld and Kilsyth constituency. What struck me was the way that they talked about young people being unable to interact with anything except for their phones. Can I urge the Prime Minister to move forward at pace with the social media ban for under-16s?

02:45:26 - 02:45:31

Andy Burnham

I'm happy to give my honorable friend that commitment.

02:45:31 - 02:45:33

Eleanor Laing

Dr. Ellie Chowns.

02:45:33 - 02:46:28

Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The climate crisis is hitting hard already, and I was glad to hear the Prime Minister acknowledge that in his statement this afternoon. We've just had the hottest summer since records began. Farmers are facing the worst arable harvest since records began. And the Met Office tells us today that extreme summers like this have been made 130 times more likely by burning fossil fuels.

So in that context, will the Prime Minister remember his words of last year when he warned against the siren voices taking us down the path of dependence on fossil fuels? Will he stick to the manifesto promise not to drill any more oil and gas? Will he rule out Rosebank and Jackdaw because the climate damage that they would create hugely outweighed any possible benefit and will lead to more disasters like we've seen on the Nepal-Tibet border just last week?

02:46:28 - 02:47:21

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank the leader of the Greens in here, and I'm ready to work with her because I carry from my last role into this a very clear commitment to a carbon-neutral future. I don't resile from that in any way at all. I am proud of what I have done on that front. What I would say, and it's almost the opposite of the gentleman behind her a few moments ago, I think the wrong approach here is to be one or the other. We're going to have to find a way to make a transition from oil and gas to a renewable future.

And that doesn't mean it's all one or all the other. There has to be, there has to be a process where we can make a transition and do it as effectively and affordably as possible.

02:47:21 - 02:47:23

Eleanor Laing

Marsha de Cordova.

02:47:23 - 02:48:13

Marsha Cordova

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I welcome the Prime Minister back to this place and also thank him for his statement. We have rightly reset our relationship with the European Union, and now is the time to build on that progress and redouble our efforts to strengthen UK-EU cooperation. Now, with the upcoming summit next month, can the Prime Minister reassure me and my constituents in Battersea that he will be bold and ambitious in seizing this opportunity, going further and faster to boost economic growth, remove unnecessary trade barriers, and strengthen our economic relationship with Europe, and also creating opportunities for young people, not only in my Battersea constituency, but across the country.

02:48:13 - 02:49:11

Andy Burnham

Can I thank the my honourable friend the member for Battersea, and can I recognise the work of my right honourable friend, the former Prime Minister, who changed the conversation with Europe when he came into office. And I've had that played back to me from a number of European leaders, so there is something to build on. Good steps have been taken. The UK-EU summit is in front of us. It may be the month after next, but we're still waiting to finalise that.

But I hope we can make further progress there. There is no doubt that our growth has been hit in the last decade. There is no prospect, in my view, of getting what we want for our farmers if we are to take an isolationist approach to this. We do have to work more closely with Europe. That is the approach that I will take unapologetically, and I hope the honourable lady will have some success to celebrate soon.

02:49:11 - 02:49:13

Eleanor Laing

David Mundell.

02:49:13 - 02:50:12

David Mundell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I welcome the Prime Minister back to the House of Commons and genuinely wish him well in his endeavours. Although I would gently point out that Number 10 North is three hours south of my constituency. And I hope that his view of the north is a whole of the north approach. And one measure which would not cost him anything, which would be popular in the north and across the whole of the UK, is if he ruled out what appeared in the previous Prime Minister's green paper on the future of television, and that is that terrestrial free-to-view television could be switched off in 2034, meaning that everyone would have to pay to watch television, and that particularly affects elderly, vulnerable, and those who live in rural areas.

02:50:12 - 02:51:07

Andy Burnham

Well, can I assure my right honourable friend, I think I'm right in saying, that Number 10 North will be as much at the service of Scotland and his constituents as it will anywhere else. And I do think members of this House will get used to seeing what an improvement it might be in getting answers out of Whitehall on many issues, but including the one that he's just raised. I'll give him an honest answer, Madam Deputy Speaker. I am concerned about those plans too. I know some of my constituents in Makerfield rely on Freeview.

There is perhaps an opportunity to look at this as part of the BBC Charter renewal process. I can't give him a final answer today, but I recognise that it's a genuine issue that he's raised. I know it will be of concern to his constituents, and let me have a proper look at it.

02:51:08 - 02:51:52

Rupa Huq

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I heartily congratulate the Prime Minister for bringing a bit of optimism and hope back in here and on his summer tour. Now, had he made it round our way, he could have seen how Thames Water, despite a hosepipe ban, have been leaking 10,000 litres of water an hour into North Acton because of a leak. They could have also seen how at the same time fat cat bosses are getting pay rises and they are dumping sewage into our beloved River Brent.

So can I ask, I was pleased by his words on water today, when can we take this failing company back into public hands?

02:51:52 - 02:52:54

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my honorable friend for what she said. It is my intention to bring back a bit more optimism around the country, to give people the feeling that things can be fixed. That's my style to face things and fix things, and it's the approach I'll take to water too. I don't know whether the benches opposite were supporting the status quo. It sounded like it to a degree, but it isn't defensible in my view for precisely the reasons that she just gave.

So we are looking at options, Madam Deputy Speaker. I believe we do need a strengthened response, particularly when it comes to legislation. Happy to work with the honorable lady and plot out a path as to how we can make sure we repair our water infrastructure, bring down people's bills, and make sure it's not always the public that's expected to pay for everything.

02:52:54 - 02:54:01

Sammy Wilson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I first of all on behalf of the DUP wish the Prime Minister well in his job. Hopefully he does deliver on the promises on energy, the economy, etc., though I do note that it only took him about 30 seconds to break his promise on no point scoring in responding to the leader of the opposition, though a bit of point scoring's not a bad thing. He has pointed out that confidence in government is important. In Northern Ireland, the Parades Commission, a public body which has got a very significant role in curtailing people's freedoms, has recently been shown that it acted illegally, biasedly, it showed disdain for applications from the unionist community, and it failed abjectly in its duty.

And yet the arrogant members of the Parades Commission have refused to resign even though they know they don't have any public confidence. Will he have discussions with the Secretary of State to ensure that there's an immediate dismissal of this discredited body?

02:54:01 - 02:54:59

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank the honorable gentleman, it's good to see him again. And can I say to him that I am bringing a problem-solving approach. There will still be the odd point scored here and there. I mean, it would be a bit dull if I didn't do a little bit of that. But I'm serious, where we can find common ground, we should do.

The public expect it. Do not think they're fed up watching the television sometimes when things are broken and we're all still kind of playing politics with those things. Let's see where we can make progress and score the points where we can't. But on the very serious issue that he raised, Madam Deputy Speaker, I was, as I said a moment ago, in Northern Ireland last week. I met with his colleagues and other parties as well.

I know there has been a serious loss of trust in the Commission and I know it needs to be addressed. The Northern Ireland Secretary has taken some action, but I do believe more is to come.

02:54:59 - 02:55:46

Eleanor Laing

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I warmly welcome the Prime Minister to his place and commend him on his direction and the spirit of his statement. Small and independent businesses are the lifeblood of my constituency. I hear regularly from owners like Colin and Jack, who own two Feast coffee shops in Sheffield, that they are facing an onslaught of financial pressure.

This morning, on my way here, Jack told me how rising VAT and electricity prices have meant that there is very little left at the end of the month to pay himself. I know this is the case for many others and it goes beyond the normal ups and downs of businesses. So I welcome his decision to cut VAT off energy bills from October, but is he willing to explore how else we might be able to help small and independent businesses?

02:55:46 - 02:56:52

Andy Burnham

Well, as I said to the honourable gentleman for Maldon, Madam Deputy Speaker, I do believe there is more that we need to do to support the businesses that my honourable friend the member for Sheffield Central raises and there will be, there will be more, more to come. The cost of doing business is too high, as I've said in this House this afternoon, energy bills are too high for businesses as well as households and we need a determination to bring those bills down and lower the cost of business. So there will be more to come, Madam Deputy Speaker, this will be a pro-business government, it'll be a pro-small business government. Nobody should make any mistake of that. The approach I led in Manchester was all about the public taking control of what it needs to do to make a place functional so then it's functional for businesses as well as people as well and that's Manchesterism and that's what we'll bring nationally.

It's all about setting businesses up to succeed and I look forward to working with her to improve that business and her high streets too.

02:56:52 - 02:58:09

Julian Lewis

May I gently remind the Prime Minister, as someone who was politically active in the Thatcher decade, that that was the period that she did so well because the Labour Party was in a terrible state, embracing unilateral nuclear disarmament, for example, at the height of the Second Cold War, which is mercifully a position it has now left long behind. I welcome what the Prime Minister has said about wishing to work consensually and across party lines. In that spirit, will he look again at the shameless gerrymandering around the local government reorganization? The honourable gentleman for Oldham West at the beginning of the process promised us that there would be no unnecessary fragmentation or boundary changes without strong reason for it, yet my constituency is being torn apart with the Waterside that has looked towards the New Forest for centuries being taken over by Southampton. The same is happening elsewhere.

This is something that was not in his party's manifesto, it's a good opportunity for him to show that he means what he says about consensus.

02:58:09 - 02:59:05

Andy Burnham

Well, I would take on that challenge, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I will ask the Communities Secretary to, to consider what he said this afternoon. I think these changes do benefit from having the maximum consensus on. On the Thatcher government, we'll probably have to agree to, to disagree, Madam Deputy Speaker. One observation, we have a public housing stock that has one and a half million fewer homes than it did in the 80s and 90s and we now have one and a half million people on housing waiting lists up and down the country. Now, I would put it to him that that is a cause of further public cost in terms of people in a crisis situation.

I think we can do better. I've been prepared to criticize the government that I was in, maybe one day he might criticize the one he was in and then we'll be able to find some solutions.

02:59:05 - 02:59:42

Mark Maguire

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister to his place and associate myself with all of his comments about the two police officers sadly killed up in Clevedon. Now, I speak with first-hand experience when I say any police officer will start a shift but not expect to not be able to go home at the end of that shift. It's really important that we, we recognize that. And it's in that spirit that I ask the Prime Minister, does he commit and agree that the government will always have our police officers' backs and make sure that the police force is properly funded so that we can make sure my former colleagues can look after the communities up and down this country?

02:59:42 - 03:00:46

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, can I agree wholeheartedly with what the member for Forest of Dean has said? Can I point to my record as Mayor of Greater Manchester, where I had the back of all of the thousands of officers who were out serving and keeping Greater Manchester safe day after day? I do pay tribute to the families of those officers we lost in Middlesbrough and those individuals in the line of duty sacrificing themselves for the for the community. I also want to assure him that I did hear the voice of PC Andrew Harper's family in making my decisions on early release. Obviously, this House before I was here passed Harper's Law, and that did create a situation where the spirit of that legislation really should have been honored in that early release scheme.

It will now be honored in that early release scheme, and it always should be that this House gives the maximum recognition to those who put themselves at risk for the safety of us and everybody else.

03:00:46 - 03:00:50

Judith Cummins

Liz Saville Roberts.

03:00:50 - 03:01:25

Liz Roberts

The Prime Minister says he puts devolution at the heart of his agenda. And I believe him. We both know that decisions are best made closer to the people they affect. But Wales still lacks the powers already available to Scotland and even to Greater Manchester. That cannot be right.

So when he meets the First Minister next month, will he work with Plaid Cymru to make good that devolution gap on policing, on the Crown Estate, on rail, and the fiscal powers that Wales needs to build and prosper?

03:01:25 - 03:02:18

Andy Burnham

I'm ready to have a constructive conversation with the First Minister as I did when I met him in July in my first week in office. And what I believe from my own experience, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that a form of local devolution in Wales and Scotland might further strengthen the economy, public services. And that's the point I'm making in relation to buses in Glasgow, but but other services as well. Where power is too centralized and too remote, then sometimes poor decisions are made. My agenda is all about putting power in the hands of people at the community level so that they can drive changes that are right for them.

I think there's a model of local devolution that could be made to work in Scotland, in Wales, possibly in Northern Ireland, and I'm ready to support that if that's what she so wishes.

03:02:18 - 03:02:21

Judith Cummins

Fleur Anderson.

03:02:21 - 03:02:53

Fleur Kathleen Anderson

Social media and the harm it does to our young people is one of the biggest issues brought to my attention by my constituents in Putney, but also people across the country. I am really glad to hear the Prime Minister's affirmation that he will carry on with the raising of the ban on social media from 13 to 16. Can he comment further on that ban, that it won't be sort of watered down at all, but it will remain a full ban for all of the day for our young people to reduce the harm that's done to them?

03:02:53 - 03:03:48

Andy Burnham

Well, I think I'm right in saying, Madam Deputy Speaker, that the right honorable lady, the Leader of the Opposition, made strong statements early in this year, going back to January, on this very issue. And I indicated then that I supported the strongest action, recognizing the damage to children's mental health that social media has been doing. And that is an example of how I work and how I will work in this role. Where there is obviously something that is wrong, that is causing harm, particularly to children, it is incumbent on all of us to act. So from my point of view, Madam Deputy Speaker, there is no watering down.

We do need to take action. For those of us with children, we can see sometimes the damage that's being done. We shouldn't just accept it, and I will lead from the front on this particular issue.

03:03:48 - 03:03:50

Judith Cummins

Harriet Baldwin.

03:03:50 - 03:04:38

Harriet Baldwin

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. In welcoming the new Prime Minister to the dispatch box today, I note that in his statement he refers to the biggest issue facing the country being the economy and the cost of living crisis. Will he accept that one of the things that has damaged our economy and caused prices to be higher was the tax and spend budget in November 2024? He has cut taxes twice since he became Prime Minister, small tax cuts, so will he commit that in the budget there will be no further searching for new things to tax? The biggest message of hope he could send to this country today would be to rule out further tax rises.

03:04:38 - 03:05:43

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say very clearly to the honorable lady and to the country more broadly that I fully understand the pressure that businesses are under, and the cost of doing business is higher than it should be given the pressures of energy costs and other things as well. So I am not coming into this position in any way in denial about that, Madam Deputy Speaker. We do need to take further steps to reduce the cost of business, and I've indicated a direction of travel on that today. So these are matters that we need to give the utmost consideration to. We do need to get growth up, and she says, she tries to kind of make an analysis that it was all that.

We've had a decade of low growth, Madam Deputy Speaker. These issues go back much deeper, and it's why in my statement today I laid the issues out very clearly and put forward a plan for growth, but that plan does require us to be pro-business and provide what support we can.

03:05:43 - 03:05:55

Judith Cummins

And before I call for the next question, can I just remind members that I am trying to get as many people in as possible, so if the questions could be shorter, that will be really, really very helpful for everyone. Tahir Ali.

03:05:55 - 03:06:28

Tahir Ali

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'll follow your advice. Neighborhood police numbers are down, youth services have been cut to the bone. Is it any surprise that youth crime is rising? Will the Prime Minister, along with my constituents, agree with me, the constituents of Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley, that we need to commit to both, not as optional extras, but long-term ring-fenced funding so that we don't lose another generation to the streets?

03:06:28 - 03:06:50

Andy Burnham

Can I say to my honorable friend, if we are closing down digital space for young people, it is incumbent on us, all of us, to open up more physical space in communities and repair the damage to youth services that was done 15 or so years ago. We won't get crime down without that. That's the other side of the coin to increasing police officers. He has my commitment on that.

03:06:50 - 03:06:52

Judith Cummins

Tim Farron.

03:06:52 - 03:07:34

Timothy James Farron

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honorable member for North Dorset asked the Prime Minister earlier about bluetongue. He gave an answer about farming, but the Prime Minister will recall he didn't address the issue directly. He was elected in 2001 for the first time in this place, obviously I welcome him back. That was the election that was postponed because of the foot and mouth outbreak.

As things stand, there are 754 reported cases of bluetongue in Great Britain already. It takes three weeks after first dose for sheep to become immune, six weeks for cattle to become immune. This is animal welfare disaster, a human tragedy, and a farm business nightmare. Will he make the tackling of bluetongue and the delivery of vaccine an urgent priority for him and his government?

03:07:34 - 03:07:57

Andy Burnham

Well, when I did the visit in the summer, Madam Deputy Speaker, I did hear concerns about the availability of vaccine and the time it was taking for farms to access it, so I am aware of the issue. I will seek an update from the DEFRA Secretary on the issue, and if necessary, I'd be prepared to meet the honorable gentleman to discuss it.

03:07:58 - 03:08:27

James William Naish

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I particularly welcome the Prime Minister's visit to a farm in Cornwall over the summer where I believe the work of the Labour Rural Research Group was mentioned to him. One of the LRRGs campaigns is to end the rural penalty due to the cost of living in rural areas being higher and weaker access to transport, energy, food and digital services. Will the Prime Minister confirm that it's his intention to make rural areas a priority in his premiership?

03:08:27 - 03:09:20

Andy Burnham

Well, as I said before, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm pleased to give the honorable gentleman, honorable friend that assurance. I want to ensure that we don't have a two-tier England where rural and coastal areas feel in some way shut out or left behind. There is a devolution deal that can be done for everywhere. He has my commitment about that. I do encourage him to look at the letter from the first secretary about number 10 north.

It is about providing practical area, but I also would encourage members on all sides to start to be practical about agreeing a combined authority where that can be brought through because that in our experience is the best way to get a building block for economic growth, for sustaining important services and I want rural areas to benefit from exactly the same.

03:09:20 - 03:09:22

Judith Cummins

Wendy Morton.

03:09:22 - 03:09:57

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over the summer, the Prime Minister opposed development on green spaces in his constituency saying it offers no benefit to the local community and will place huge strain on local infrastructure. My constituents face the same pressure. So will he commit to new and meaningful green belt protections to protect those green spaces in both of our constituencies and make sure houses are only built when there's been meaningful consultation with communities, when communities are being listened to and when infrastructure is in place? And please scrap this ridiculous grey belt definition.

03:09:57 - 03:10:49

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the honorable lady, my constituency, my new constituency, and in fact, it does include a good chunk of my old Lee constituency, so I know it well, has been hugely developed over the years where we have brought through significant new housing. And anyone who visited the by-election will know that the infrastructure is struggling to cope with the number of houses that have been built in the constituency. So all I'm saying to the honorable lady is I do support taking a balanced approach where there has been significant development, but I don't think it's a sustainable approach to turn your back on all development completely. So it's about a balance and I'll work in this role to find that balance with the honorable lady.

03:10:49 - 03:10:51

Judith Cummins

Deirdre Costigan.

03:10:51 - 03:11:29

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I hugely welcome the Prime Minister's 422 million pound investment to end rough sleeping. But in Ealing Southall, many of those on the streets have no recourse to public funds, so it's illegal for the council to spend money helping them. Many would go home, but they face delays getting travel documents and from closed police cases left open. So would the Prime Minister ensure that the relevant Home Office and housing ministers meet with me so Ealing Southall is not left behind when it comes to his groundbreaking pledge to end street homelessness?

03:11:29 - 03:12:07

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my honorable friend and we absolutely will work in the way that she's described. The commitment is real. This is not a temporary commitment. The money that she mentions, as far as I'm concerned, is ongoing. Everyone in should be the permanent policy, or will be the permanent policy of the government that I lead.

I do not believe we should accept that anybody sleeps rough on a British street at any time. But I also know that if you are to help people on a journey away from the street, it requires a whole person approach, all departments working together. It can be done, and I look forward to working with the honorable lady on it.

03:12:07 - 03:12:09

Judith Cummins

Alberto Costa.

03:12:09 - 03:12:49

Alberto Costa

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Earlier today, members from across this House and indeed the other place, along with stakeholders from throughout the United Kingdom, met to discuss the scourge of microplastic pollution. I'm chair of the APPG on microplastics and today we launched our report, the second in 10 years. I've got an easy ask of the Prime Minister. Would he organize a meeting for myself and the stakeholders and members from across the House to meet with the relevant minister to discuss the recommendations in the report?

03:12:49 - 03:13:08

Andy Burnham

Um, I've given quite a few commitments to meetings today. So what I will say to the honorable gentleman, recognizing the seriousness of the issue, I will ensure the relevant minister meets him at his or her earliest convenience, given the seriousness of the issue and the report that he's done.

03:13:08 - 03:14:01

Josh Dean

Thank you very much. Over the bank holiday weekend, the treasured green space in Sawbridgeworth was decimated by building work without planning permission. Thanks to our community's exceptional response, East Herts Council was able to move quickly and secure an injunction. But across the country, this is sadly the exception and not the rule. Whilst this kind of unpermitted development is not a specific offense, residents in my community certainly felt that what started on Saturday was criminal.

The Prime Minister has made clear that he wants to tackle the thorny issues that make a real impact on people's lives in communities like mine. So would he agree to meet with me to discuss why we need to change the law to ensure that police and local authorities have the right powers so they can stop this kind of unpermitted development in its tracks?

03:14:01 - 03:14:55

Andy Burnham

Madam Deputy Speaker, it is a real commitment of mine to ensure the right powers are held at local level to take action on issues that matter to communities. And we've had similar issues with illegal waste tipping in constituencies that leave people feeling there is no accountability, almost a sense of lawlessness. And we cannot allow that to continue. So I absolutely will look out for him to discuss this further. I think we can do more to empower local authorities.

And if he heard something I said in my statement, it was a real commitment to taking resources from a national level and bringing them back down, particularly to support local councils who in recent times, I'm afraid, have seen themselves hollowed out and don't have that enforcement capability that they once did. We do need to find ways of putting it back so that people who do these things in communities can be held accountable and councils can enforce their own laws.

03:14:55 - 03:14:57

Judith Cummins

Munira Wilson.

03:14:57 - 03:15:35

Munira Wilson

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Our schools and colleges cannot be fueled by hope alone. At the start of the summer, the Prime Minister outlined an overhaul of 14 to 16 education. This comes on the back of far-reaching reforms to special educational needs provision and a new, as yet unresourced requirement to expand enrichment activities in our schools. So could the Prime Minister tell schools across the country and indeed parents across the country how he's going to find the people and the cash to deliver all this, because our schools are at breaking point and teachers are leaving in their droves already?

03:15:35 - 03:16:09

Andy Burnham

No, I do recognize, Madam Deputy Speaker, the need to fund education in exactly the way that she described.

And it's back to the point I made about investing in success rather than paying for failure. We do need to be serious about giving all young people a path to success and therefore reducing the number of young people dependent on benefits in their in their twenties. This is a shift that we need to make. The Milburn report hopefully will lay a way to do that and I look forward to working with her on that important issue.

03:16:09 - 03:16:37

Alistair Scott Carns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I may as well welcome the Prime Minister to his place. In this short time in government, you've done a fantastic job of changing the lives of young people. And I always say the next generation is our greatest legacy. People not in education, employment or training are now below a million for the first time.

So could the Prime Minister lay out what the strategy is moving forward for people neither in education, employment, training and make it a national mission to give them the opportunity that they deserve.

03:16:37 - 03:17:40

Andy Burnham

I think he is absolutely right to say it should be a national a national mission. And I talked earlier about a guarantee of a work placement at sixteen or between sixteen and eighteen of quality. I believe we could look at doing more around supporting young people with transport costs as we did in Greater Manchester. I think we do need more youth apprenticeships. They did go in decline and we need to to turn that around.

And degree apprenticeships is something that I think we need to see much more. The point I'm making is we need to lay out a technical path from fourteen for all of our young people so that we don't just have a situation where it seems to them that the university route is the be-all and end-all, important as that is for those who want to go on it. Too many young people hit their middle teenage years in year ten, year eleven and they can't see where the path is going and then they start to drop out. That is what I'm determined to fix. I look forward to working with him on it.

03:17:40 - 03:18:41

Sorcha Eastwood

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's hard to disagree with a lot of what the Prime Minister has set out, but I'm going to make sure my conscience is clear. I worry. I worry about our economy. And so whenever I hear the Chancellor refer to continuity Starmer administration, that's a red flag for me.

My constituents in Lagan Valley cannot pay their bills. They are struggling with life in a way that they have not known before. I believe that this Prime Minister is serious about wanting to reach those people. And let me tell you when we met in Northern Ireland last week, believe you me, rest assured I can guarantee this House is not interested in hearing about the stuff from our past. My constituents want to get on with life in the here and now.

Right here, right now. The VAT cut for electricity soon to be engulfed by rising prices. Did the Prime Minister not have it right the first time whenever he said that our people need a new economic model?

03:18:41 - 03:19:39

Andy Burnham

What I thank the honorable lady for her question and it was a good meeting that we had last week. And I don't disagree with what she's saying, nor do I disagree with the power with which she's saying it because there's many people watching this saying it's too hard now, we need we need help. The VAT cut on electricity did lead to a funding funding offer to the Northern Ireland government. But I would be the first to say it's only it's only a start. It's a small step for the reasons that she's giving.

There is more we can do to bring down the cost of transport. We are going to set out more plans in the budget to to help with the cost of living. I think she should keep that level of determination to support her constituents. I think we will make this country feel better, more contented, more united if we are dealing with these issues in a very meaningful way for for them. And I want that to be the hallmark of this government.

03:19:38 - 03:20:12

David William Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to warmly welcome the Prime Minister to his place and thank him for his recent visit to the North East where he committed to trying to tackle the systemic infrastructure issue of the North East, which is the dualling of the A1. And I just want to thank him for committing to find alternative ways to fund that. And this afternoon, myself and 12 other MPs, the mayor, and actually in the spirit of cross-party working, the local Conservative leader have written to him to ask what more we can do to work with him and his government to secure this generational change for infrastructure in the North East.

03:20:12 - 03:20:47

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, can I say to my honorable friend that I will ask the Transport Secretary to work also with colleagues at Number 10 North to see what can be done to bring forward a new way of delivering this much-needed infrastructure. I know how critical it is. I don't think any region of the country, possibly the South West or certainly the South West and the North East, do not have a level of infrastructure that is acceptable. And this is something that has been long promised, not delivered, but let's see if Number 10 North can make the breakthrough.

03:20:47 - 03:20:48

Sir Gavin Williamson.

03:20:48 - 03:22:11

Gavin Williamson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I thank the Prime Minister for articulating a desire to reach across the political divide on issues that are common among all of our constituents. Across all of our constituencies, we're seeing more and more people struggling to have a family, to have children. And this is increasingly a greater and greater issue all across the country, but in Staffordshire, for example, if you are a family that needs NHS IVF treatment, you are not even entitled to one round of IVF treatment, despite the National Institute of Clinical Excellence saying you should be entitled to three. The Prime Minister has a health bill coming to this house next week.

I have an amendment there to make sure that right across England, all of our constituents can make sure that they have a basic minimum that has been recommended by NICE so that they can have a family. Could I ask the Prime Minister to encourage his Health Secretary to look at this amendment to see if there is a way to work across party to have an impact on something that is so important to so many people?

03:22:11 - 03:22:50

Andy Burnham

Well, I know he'll be speaking for many people in his area and I can see the passion with which he does. I am not aware of the detail of the amendment at this point in time, but I certainly will ask the Health Secretary to take a close look. I don't like the idea of postcode lottery in the National Health Service. I do believe that there should be an expectation that services available anywhere should be available everywhere, particularly when it comes to an issue as important as this. I give him a commitment today to look at the issue, but I'd have to come back to him to let him know what we were able to do.

03:22:50 - 03:22:52

Judith Cummins

Rachel Blake.

03:22:52 - 03:23:40

Rachel Blake

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister to his place. In July, the Prime Minister pledged to end rough sleeping and that is warmly welcomed by me and my constituents in the cities of London and Westminster, which faces the highest levels of rough sleeping in the country. We've heard today already people raising this in the chamber. When I speak to people who have been sleeping rough, they talk to me about feeling passed from pillar to post and when they have been offered somewhere to stay in a hostel, they simply don't feel safe and secure within it.

The Prime Minister has made really important statements here in the chamber today. Will he work with me about the issue of local connection and the way in which local authorities are applying that and the condition of hostels in this country? It simply isn't good enough and I think we need to place real focus in there if we are to meet this ambitious pledge.

03:23:40 - 03:24:56

Andy Burnham

Well, I'll certainly work with my honorable friend on this issue, Madam Deputy Speaker.

And can I credit the Passage, which I believe is in her constituency, a wonderful charity supporting homeless people, which I was proud to support on the morning when I went into Downing Street? And it focused me on what I needed to be focused on before I did that. I agree with everything that she is saying. If people are passed from pillar to post, they will not settle enough to be able to begin their journey of recovery. And that's all of my experience on this issue in Greater Manchester.

We had it right in the pandemic, when people were given a settled place to stay. And when people are in the same place every night, that is when they begin to recover. And I don't believe it's beyond us to be able to provide now what we provided then. And that's why my commitment to everyone in is a permanent commitment. And that should give the body, the organisations like the Passage and others doing brilliant work in this area, to start planning for the long term and turn the tide around on the human tide around, sadly, on what is just a tide of misery for so many people.

We are wasting money on failure when we could be investing in recovery, and that's what we should do.

03:24:56 - 03:26:08

Thomas Gordon

I'd like to start by welcoming the Prime Minister to his place and thank him for his show of cross-party support for my campaign to scrap time restriction on disability bus passes. I really genuinely and sincerely appreciated the fact that he came to the parliamentary event and drop-in that we held last year with Whizz-Kidz, with the RNIB, with Bus Users UK and Transport for All, as well as many other charitable organisations, with the likes of Jackie Snape from Disability Action Yorkshire. The Prime Minister has shown what cross-party working can do when he delivered that change for Greater Manchester and is now rolling it out across England. I'm really grateful to him that come next year, disability bus passes won't start at 9:30 AM because disabilities don't either. With that in mind, he mentioned in answer to another question, he doesn't like postcode lotteries.

Another issue that will still exist is the issue of companion bus passes granted to disabled people who need someone to accompany them. This is an issue that will still see a postcode lottery, and the right honourable gentleman for New Forest East has been campaigning on this vigorously. I wondered if the Prime Minister might look at this issue too and deliver the same cross-party success to scrap those injustices too.

03:26:08 - 03:27:10

Andy Burnham

Well, I do pay tribute to the honourable gentleman for Harrogate and Knaresborough. He was kind enough to invite me to a meeting of the all-party group when he was campaigning on that issue. And we did work on it cross-party, and I was pleased to be able to make that change as Prime Minister. And it is something that will benefit a huge number of disabled people. But he is right that the job is not done, because many disabled people will say they can't go out and live their life without a companion, and sometimes they can't afford to pay for that.

So further work to be done, Madam Deputy Speaker. But let's celebrate the small wins, but I don't think it is a small win, because it means everything to somebody who now can get out whenever they need with that change, or will soon be able to. And I do pay credit to him. He ran a great campaign. I was something I did in Greater Manchester.

I was proud to support him, and that's the thing I'm saying today. Let's do more of that.

03:27:10 - 03:27:27

Judith Cummins

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the Prime Minister to his place. According to the ONS, manufacturing directly contributes 15% to the economy of Staffordshire, which is double the national average. So I really welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to reindustrialisation, which is vital to towns like Stafford.

03:27:27 - 03:27:49

Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner

Will the Prime Minister meet with me and other interested MPs, particularly those who are members of the Re-industrialization Research Group, so we can speak about this issue, but specifically speak to the issue related to towns? We know that towns have more manufacturing employment than cities. So to have growth in every postcode, having manufacturing booming again in towns is going to make such a difference.

03:27:49 - 03:28:38

Andy Burnham

Well, I couldn't agree more with my honorable friend, Madam Deputy Speaker. The agenda of re-industrialization goes hand in hand with lifting high streets, and I know she's campaigned on both of those things. I am serious in saying we need quite a change in British public procurement to support our industries. And as she will see as we go towards the budget, we will talk more about what can be done to support high streets. Too many tell a story of decline.

If you can turn them around, it can completely change the way people feel about the areas that they live. It can build that sense of optimism that can make then many more things possible. And that's what I intend to do in for her constituency and many others working with her.

03:28:38 - 03:29:49

Bernard Jeremy Corbyn

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Could I congratulate the right honorable member on becoming Prime Minister and on his stamina at taking questions for even longer than the longest World Cup match already? He's said some very helpful and useful things about housing, particularly on rough sleeping. Could I ask him to look seriously at the issue facing renters living in the private rented sector, where the local housing allowance in most cases comes nowhere near the level of rent that's being charged? In reality, it's less than 2% of private sector rents are within the local housing allowance.

Raising the local housing allowance often means chasing the market all the time, therefore costs more and more. So the obvious answer, surely, and he must know the numbers of people living in the private rented sector, is to actually bring in some kind of ceiling, a rent control of some sort within the private rented sector and immediately look at not postponing the raise in the local housing allowance, but to bring real relief to people who are desperately up against it and subsidizing their rent out of their benefits. It's not fair, it's not right, and I'm sure he would agree with me.

03:29:49 - 03:31:05

Andy Burnham

Well, can I thank my right honorable friend? And while I may have already outlasted the longest World Cup match, I'm sure he and I did a longer Q&A at a hustings in 2015, and so this is just a small one. I agree with what he is saying in terms of the change that we need to see to the housing market. He mentions local housing allowance. It's been repeatedly frozen in recent years, and that has meant the gap between benefits and rents has grown bigger and bigger.

And it is the biggest reason that explains why London councils have a huge temporary accommodation bill, which I think has gone over half a billion pounds now. So it doesn't save money because it just creates an unfunded pressure in council budgets. He may have seen that in our first allocations from the social and affordable homes program, which I mentioned in my statement, London is by some distance the biggest beneficiary, and particularly the building of council homes in London. So we've made a significant down payment there. I hear what he says about local housing allowance.

I think we need a package of measures to turn the housing market around, and hopefully some of what I've said today answers his concerns.

03:31:05 - 03:31:48

Sarah Russell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I would like to thank the Prime Minister for the words that he has said around cross-party working. I know my constituents believe in it very, very strongly. And on that basis, I would like to endorse comments made by colleagues on the opposite benches around farming, drought, and bluetongue, all of which are very important to my constituents.

But to move on to the matter most immediately at hand for my constituents, Jodrell Bank is in my constituency and is facing a significant problem in the medium term because of funding cuts. Would it be possible for him to work with me and Number 10 North, alongside my friend and colleague, the member for Macclesfield, to address this issue?

03:31:48 - 03:32:24

Andy Burnham

Everyone of my generation, Madam Deputy Speaker, went on a school trip to Jodrell Bank and there is no way that we can see its demise and it won't happen under my government. I know there's changes that have been made in relation to research funding, but Jodrell Bank is a heritage asset for the country as well as a research asset. I will indeed set up the meeting she requires. There must be a way to save Jodrell Bank and I give her a commitment today at this dispatch box, we will find it.

03:32:24 - 03:32:26

Judith Cummins

Vicky Slade.

03:32:26 - 03:33:09

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We have had the hottest summer on record and we've also had an exceptionally high number of tragic deaths in our rivers and seas around the country. At the same time, so many children are no longer able to learn to swim and there have been over 200 swimming pools closed since 2020, public and school swimming pools. So will the Prime Minister look at how we can better fund leisure centers and swimming pools to make sure that every child knows how to save themselves and to float, with the advice under the Royal National Life Saving Association, and make sure that we do not have such a terrible summer again?

03:33:09 - 03:33:27

Andy Burnham

There have been too many tragic deaths this summer, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the best way to prevent that is do exactly what she said. I think swimming should be an entitlement for young people on the curriculum and I look forward to seeing how we can deliver that working with her.

03:33:27 - 03:33:29

Judith Cummins

Douglas McAllister.

03:33:29 - 03:34:03

Douglas McAllister

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My West Dunbartonshire constituency includes the towns of Dumbarton and Clydebank, both share proud histories as industrial powerhouses, not least in shipbuilding. If we are to reindustrialize every part of our UK, every postcode, it must include West Dunbartonshire. We have two sites on the Clyde ready for investment, Carless in Old Kilpatrick and the former Exxon site in Bowling. Will the Prime Minister help me restore industry to these sites and will he visit my West Dunbartonshire constituency?

03:34:03 - 03:34:56

Andy Burnham

Well, I will at some point, as soon as I can, Madam Deputy Speaker. But can I say to him in relation to shipbuilding, I worked with the Mayor of Liverpool who was setting a contract for a new Mersey ferry and found there was pressure to have it built overseas. And using social value commissioning, he and I worked together to make sure that ferry was built at Cammell Laird's in Birkenhead and will soon come into service in Liverpool. And that's what we need to see more of, Madam Deputy Speaker. Too many buses are being bought from companies outside our shores.

Wrightbus in Northern Ireland, ADL in Scotland and Scarborough, we should be doing more to back British business and he can expect that fully from me as well as commitments to the shipbuilding industry.

03:34:56 - 03:34:58

Judith Cummins

Mark Pritchard.

03:34:58 - 03:35:49

Mark Pritchard

And can I say I'm flattered to be associated with the Prime Minister, mistaken identity, I'm not sure if he would be as flattered. But can I welcome him to the dispatch box, welcome him back to the House and welcome his commitment to Ukraine. But if I may, I'd like some clarity on the defense budget. It seems over the recess, of course there's been no scrutiny of the Prime Minister or the government over the recess, that there has been a talking up of the government's commitment to spending 2.5% of GDP on defense by 2035. There has not been as much talk about meeting the 3% target by 2030.

So would the Prime Minister like to inform the House and the country, given that his Chancellor in his previous role as Defense Secretary said this country should be prepared to be on a war footing?

03:35:49 - 03:36:00

Andy Burnham

It's a crucial issue he raises.

It matters greatly to myself and to the Chancellor. We will meet all of our international commitments and we'll set out how at the spending review.

03:36:00 - 03:36:44

Peter Lamb

The Prime Minister is right to pursue further devolution within the United Kingdom. But in my work in the Public Accounts Committee, I'm regularly struck by how little the different parts of the United Kingdom appear to learn from each other, even when tackling very similar challenges. Devolution allows different places to take different approaches, creating real opportunities to learn from what works and what doesn't. As we devolve more power within the United Kingdom, does the Prime Minister agree that we must also get much better at grasping these opportunities so that every part of the UK can learn from and benefit from the experience of others? And is he thinking about how we could bake this into further devolution in a way that it is not currently?

03:36:44 - 03:36:53

Andy Burnham

I think it's an excellent suggestion, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's exactly the thing Number 10 North was set up to do and I will pass his suggestion on to them.

03:36:53 - 03:37:54

Rebecca Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was pleased to hear the Prime Minister speak multiple times about his trip to Cornwall and I hope he enjoyed Exeter services on his way through Devon because it's disappointing he didn't spend more time in rural Devon in particular because the biggest issue I dealt over the summer was the government's local government reorganization announcement, which is going to see a huge rural Devon constituency of 2,200 square miles with just 103 councillors. This compares to three urban centers of about 600 square miles between them with 220 councillors. Now, I accept the Prime Minister's ambition for growth in every postcode, but quite frankly, he's already mentioned in an earlier question about the lack of infrastructure in the Southwest. How can that version of local government reorganization produce growth in every postcode?

And I urge him to revisit that decision with the minister responsible because quite frankly, constituents across rural Devon are devastated by what it might mean for them.

03:37:54 - 03:38:28

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to the honorable lady, I did intend to visit Devon at the same time, but I was diverted to Stourbridge and I hope she'll understand why because of the devastating fire in people's homes that we saw in the middle of the summer. But similar as I said before, I am prepared to look at local government reorganization or ask the community secretary to do that. Where possible, we need as much consensus as we can get. If she's telling me that we need to work harder to find that, then I'm always prepared to do what I can.

03:38:28 - 03:38:59

Elsie Blundell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank the Prime Minister for his statement today and welcome him to his place. The Prime Minister knows the Hooligan family from Middleton, who tragically lost their beloved Michael, the result of the callous actions of a violent reoffender who should have been recalled to custody far sooner if only the local probation service had been more rigorous in its monitoring. Will the Prime Minister commit to looking seriously at the probation service in terms of accountability and how it operates so that serious further offenders are given no opportunity to cause further harm to constituents like mine?

03:38:59 - 03:39:50

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to my honorable friend, I do know Gary and Leslie Hooligan well. I've met them many, many times and the murder of their son was something that sadly could have been prevented and it was in some ways caused by chaos in the probation system as she as she knows. When I was leaving this house in the middle part of the last decade, in my view, probation services were plummeting into chaos and only in recent times have we started to lift them back up again.

Personally, I think there does need to be accountability for what happened to probation services in that period. It was a disastrous reorganization. It had real human consequences. And I've always supported the call for work to give answers to the families who lost loved ones, truth and justice. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

03:39:50 - 03:40:38

Luke Morgan Evans

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And we know that Labour's NHS policy when it comes to mandatory advice and guidance and single point of access has led to deaths. Now, we warned about it on this side of the House. Doctors warned about it. Patients warned about it.

And we were told repeatedly it's total nonsense, misinformation, opportunism, and even conspiracy theories. Now HSIB, the government's watchdog, safety watchdog, has produced a report that says linking these this system to deaths. It's asked for a rapid review. I know he's been a health secretary before. Will he commit to commit that review to make sure there are no further delays in diagnosis and no further deaths as a result of that policy?

03:40:38 - 03:40:50

Andy Burnham

I haven't yet had chance to read that review, Madam Deputy Speaker. I will and I will then seek to speak to him on the back of that to see what we can do.

03:40:50 - 03:41:25

Nadia Whittome

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In my constituency of North Warwickshire and Bedworth, more than one in five people are employed in logistics and related industries and will welcome this government's focus on growth in every region. Given the impact that business costs have on consumer prices, what steps will he take to improve the operating environment for logistics businesses and help ease the cost of cost of living pressures for families? And will he commit to meeting with small family-owned logistics companies in my constituency?

03:41:25 - 03:41:43

Andy Burnham

Well, I thank my honourable friend for that question. And I will, again, can't give a time commitment, but I will at some point do exactly as she as she asked and and have that meeting. I recognize the cost of doing business is too high. We do need to show serious intent to bring it down and that is what we will do.

03:41:43 - 03:42:46

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With Chequers in my constituency, can I welcome the so-called King of the North to his new Buckinghamshire residence? But next time next time he's at Chequers and before he heads off to enjoy as I know he has the wonderful pubs in Wendover, could I persuade him to could I persuade him to take a drive to the Buckinghamshire villages on the Oxfordshire border, villages like Ludgershall, like Marsh Gibbon, like Oakley, Long Crendon, Boarstall, Brill, and see for himself just how inappropriate it is to put an asylum center just over that border at MOD Bicester? Then make an intervention with the Home Secretary to ensure a more suitable site is found for such a center. And while he's talking to the Home Secretary, could he ask her to respond to my letter with a series of very detailed questions about this site that my constituents have been asking that I sent to her over six weeks ago?

03:42:46 - 03:43:49

Andy Burnham

Well, I will certainly look carefully at what he is saying. He will have heard what I said in my statement that boat small boat crossings are down, the number of people coming over is down, but we still have a challenge in relation to accommodation. I will though look at the issue. I know I think the Piddington issue is is nearby but is is similar and I know there are concerns in in that community as well. The only thing I would say is it can't be the case that it's only the deprived, the most deprived parts of this country are asked to deal with the whole issue of asylum accommodation.

A balance has to be struck, but it has to be fair for everybody. And I of course recognize that large-scale institutions can then put pressure on nearby villages.

Let me look at the issues that he raises and see they're genuine, but this is an issue that has to be dealt with as a whole country, and that's what I would do.

03:43:49 - 03:44:27

Judith Cummins

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. September is Childhood Cancer Awareness Month, and I raised with the last Prime Minister the case of Max Hall. During our summer recess, Max passed away. He will forever be 14. Will the Prime Minister commit in his direction of government to prioritizing brain cancer, the biggest cancer killer of those under 40, and get his ministers to meet with Max's family and the organizations that support families, such as Brain Tumour Research and Brain Cancer Justice?

03:44:27 - 03:45:16

Andy Burnham

I will absolutely give him that commitment that I will ask the relevant minister to meet, and would he do me the favor of passing my sympathies to Max's family? It's devastating news that he's given the House today. There is so much more we need to do on brain cancer. You can be sure from me, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I will always do that in the name of my good friend Tessa Jowell, whose family still work on these issues. There is so much more that we can do, and I know that these issues have been in the media recently.

There is encouraging research being done. We need to see a breakthrough. I will keep a close eye on that meeting. I'm happy to work with him further on this.

03:45:16 - 03:46:33

Jim Allister

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Today the Prime Minister has spoken with great passion about empowering local people and allowing them to make decisions that affect their own lives. On that theme, could I ask the Prime Minister what action will he take to restore United Kingdom and people sovereignty to Northern Ireland when it comes to making the laws which currently in 300 areas of law are made by a foreign parliament, not made by this United Kingdom, laws we don't make, laws we can't change? And indeed the Prime Minister inadvertently put a focus upon it when he referred to the cut in VAT on electricity, a cut that couldn't apply to Northern Ireland because we are subject to foreign EU law that no one has voted for. So will the Prime Minister, in his crusade to empower local people, set about the fundamental task of restoring UK sovereignty, people sovereignty to the people of my constituency?

And speaking of my constituency, he mentioned Wrightbus. Could I invite him to come and visit it at an earliest opportunity?

03:46:33 - 03:47:04

Andy Burnham

Well, I always love visiting Northern Ireland, Madam Deputy Speaker, so who knows? But on his main point, I think I'm probably going to disappoint him. Obviously the arrangements put in place are about supporting the economy of Northern Ireland because Northern Ireland can get the benefits of access to both, and it's important that he sees the benefits of the arrangement that the Windsor Framework brought as well.

03:47:04 - 03:47:40

Jonathan Brash

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister has rightly described council tax as highly regressive, saying it's unfair that people in Greater Manchester often pay far more than people living in London. Does he therefore agree that that same injustice is even more stark in towns like Hartlepool, where a Band D household pays 2,556 pounds a year compared to 1,048 pounds in Westminster? He has rightly attacked this unfairness, so will he now commit to attacking the problem and replacing the hated council tax system that hammers towns like mine?

03:47:40 - 03:48:17

Andy Burnham

I don't think I can go all that way today, Madam Deputy Speaker, at the dispatch box, but I do understand the point that he is making. A council tax system based on 1991 valuations is is not going to deliver fairness across the country. The first steps at reform were taken in last year's budget, Madam Deputy Speaker. We need to proceed with consensus if we can on this issue. I understand what he's saying, but I think the the wholesale reform might have to wait for another day.

03:48:17 - 03:48:44

James Wild

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. At the weekend, the Prime Minister stepped in to ensure that his number 10 North railway service continued. So in that spirit of problem solving, will he use his office to ensure rapid action is taken to restore a reliable service from King's Lynn to King's Cross for my North West Norfolk constituents, who had 380 trains cancelled in July and 280 in August?

03:48:44 - 03:49:37

Andy Burnham

Can I say, Madam Deputy Speaker, I have said to the Transport Secretary and she agrees, the performance of the railways over the summer we've just had has been nowhere near good enough. We had passengers on a train from Edinburgh to London on a very hot day with no working toilets on the entire train. The train I was on coming back from Cornwall and Devon was abandoned at Taunton. I think we all have those those experiences. The railways need to improve and public ownership of them needs to drive that improvement.

I will be convening a rail summit soon to discuss the summer just gone. I will be happy if he wants to write to me to give me the details of the service that he mentioned, because we do need to see significant improvement on our railways.

03:49:37 - 03:50:08

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to grasp the nettle of social care reform. At Calderdale and Huddersfield Foundation Trust, which is a well-performing trust, about 20 percent of beds are filled with people who should be getting better at home. But with a 10 percent vacancy rate in social care, we can't fix this problem without having high-quality jobs and progression in social care. So will the Prime Minister please direct Louise Casey to look at that area of social care so we can build a national care service that people want to work in?

03:50:08 - 03:50:48

Andy Burnham

To my honorable friend, he's exactly right. I think the first stage of any social care reform should be workforce reform to create that foundation to build a new approach, a more preventative, higher quality service that actually keeps people out of hospital. I do think it starts there. It does start with people's pay, terms and conditions, their prospects for progression, their ability to move towards the NHS. I've always favored seeing this as a as a single approach across all all care.

Happy to work with him on that, but he's articulated perfectly today, from my point of view, the first stage of social care reform.

03:50:48 - 03:51:16

Lewis Cocking

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister has spent all summer trying to be all things to all people. My constituents in Broxbourne want government to cut wasteful spending, lower taxes, and get a grip on our immigration system. That all requires tough decisions to be made by the Prime Minister. So will the Prime Minister choose his left-wing backbenchers, or will he choose the British people?

03:51:16 - 03:52:02

Andy Burnham

Can I say to the honorable gentleman, there was nothing easy about reopening early release. And I was listening to the British people when I made changes to exclude rapists from the scheme, groomers from the scheme, those guilty of the most serious sexual offenses against children, and then going even further, excluding manslaughter and and other historic child sex offenses.

So I do take difficult decisions regardless of what he might read on social media. I've done that for 25 years as an elected politician. It's what I will carry on doing, and the proposals that the Justice Secretary will outline soon show that that is exactly the nettle that I've grasped.

03:52:02 - 03:52:45

Judith Cummins

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister to his place, and he is right to say that we need more power and more ownership back in the hands of our communities. My constituency of Aylesbury is in a relatively wealthy part of the country, but if you talk to the people at the Vineyard Foodbank or at the Youth Concern drop-in, you wouldn't know it, because that overall wealth masks really significant inequalities within Buckinghamshire. In fact, people in parts of Aylesbury live on average 11 years less than people in the wealthier parts of the south of the county. So can I ask the Prime Minister what more control and more ownership looks like for my residents, and particularly for those at the sharp end of the inequalities that I described?

03:52:45 - 03:53:32

Andy Burnham

I think it's so important, Madam Deputy Speaker, that rural communities don't feel shut out from the drive towards devolution, and that is why I've made that really clear commitment today. I do believe that rural communities can benefit, I would say, from public control of bus services, possibly more than an urban area, because bus services in rural areas are so fragile, so expensive, often very intermittent, and it's only moving to a regulated service that actually can put in place a decent, reliable bus service for people. And that is something that we should support rural areas working through Number 10 North to put into effect for our rural communities as much as our urban areas.

03:53:32 - 03:54:24

Andrew George

Good afternoon, Madam Deputy Speaker. On behalf of my Cornish parliamentary colleagues and myself, can I welcome the Prime Minister's recognition of Cornwall's special case, and indeed his visit to Cornwall and his kindness in communicating with me in advance of his meeting. But notwithstanding his experience in his previous job, would he please recognise that the metropolitan template isn't appropriate in all circumstances when one is dealing with devolution? That there are Celtic regions and nations like Cornwall that actually do require a bespoke settlement. And indeed, I know that we're going to be having a discussion in Number 10 North on this matter, and all I can say is that I welcome the opportunity and I hope that he'll engage in that with a very open mind.

03:54:24 - 03:55:56

Andy Burnham

Well, it's a very real offer, and I'm glad that it finds favour with my honourable friend, because we've worked together over a number of years. I do think, and I heard some groans from the other side when I mentioned overnight visitor levy, but if that was a power given to Cornwall, and bear in mind many of us will have been on summer holidays when we spend a few euros extra to recognise the benefit we get from using services in a local area, if that was extended as part of a devolution deal, I think it could be quite transformational for Cornwall, because it can open up a new revenue stream that can start to address that infrastructure. Now, that would be a choice for Cornwall, but I do want to consider a devolution deal that gives real levers that can help Cornwall and other rural areas start to improve their services. It might provide the revenue to sustain bus services, for instance. It's about fairness.

I don't think residents, we heard about the unfairness of council tax, it can't be right to make the residents pay for all of the services when visitors should make a fair contribution as well.

We pay it elsewhere as British tourists. I don't see why visitors to Cornwall shouldn't pay a little extra. But that's the type of discussion we need to have. So it's not a fluffy discussion, it's a real discussion about what can be done to move Cornwall forward and I am ready to do it and maybe make this a template for other rural areas across England.

03:55:56 - 03:55:57

Lloyd Hatton.

03:55:57 - 03:56:38

Lloyd Hatton

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and may I figuratively raise a glass to the Prime Minister's much needed 20% cut to business rates for pubs, clubs and live music venues. This really is a win for our high streets. But other hospitality businesses, namely the hundreds of hotels, cafes, restaurants, fish and chip shops, takeaways right across my constituency, they also need support with the cost of business rates. These are family owned businesses and they are the backbone of our high streets. So will the Prime Minister look closely ahead of the budget at widening this support so other hospitality businesses can benefit as well.

03:56:38 - 03:56:45

Andy Burnham

Can I assure my honorable friend I am giving close consideration to that very suggestion.

03:56:46 - 03:57:27

Lincoln Jopp

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and can I wish you many many happy returns of the day. Can I welcome the Prime Minister to his place and also his words when he said in answer to someone else, I will always demand the highest level of recognition for those who put themselves at risk for us to keep us safe. I'm sure after six weeks as Prime Minister he includes within that our amazing armed forces. And yet our Northern Ireland veterans face never ending process of prosecution absent any new evidence, new or compelling. And so does he think that our Northern Ireland veterans need more protection and if he does what's he going to do about it.

03:57:27 - 03:57:37

Judith Cummins

Before the Prime Minister responds, questions need to be super short and Prime Minister let's keep the responses tight as well. Thank you so much. Prime Minister.

03:57:37 - 03:58:12

Andy Burnham

I mentioned the Good Friday Agreement before and I do think it's important to deal properly and fully with all of the issues that are still there that need to be addressed. I don't think it's a case of leaving anything hanging over anybody. The commission proposed in the bill allows answers to be given for those who are still seeking answers. It is about having the right protections too for veterans, but those amendments will be brought forward soon and we can discuss them as a house then.

03:58:12 - 03:58:14

Judith Cummins

Lizzie Collinge.

03:58:14 - 03:58:41

Elizabeth Rachel Collinge

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm extremely proud over the last two years to have seen the huge expansion of clean energy, a key way that we're tackling the horrendous climate change that we've seen this summer. And in fact my constituency is the biggest clean energy generator of the whole country with Heysham 1 and 2 nuclear power stations. So can the Prime Minister confirm that the clean energy revolution will continue under his government and continue to be a top priority.

03:58:41 - 03:58:44

Andy Burnham

I can absolutely give the honorable lady that commitment.

03:58:44 - 03:58:45

Rosalind Turner.

03:58:45 - 03:59:15

Rosalind Turner

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister's read off a list of policies since coming into office. Interestingly he's failed to mention one major intervention that his government has continued his predecessor's policy of arming Israel, an apartheid state that has committed and continues to commit genocide in Gaza. So instead of deflection and the boring nice guy act, will he finally admit to the house that he has chosen to continue arming Israel and is therefore complicit in the genocide of the Palestinian people.

03:59:15 - 03:59:30

Andy Burnham

Can I say, I think the honorable lady wasn't in the house at the time, I did signal a change when I came into office as Prime Minister on Israel and Palestine and a further statement will be made to the house very shortly.

03:59:30 - 03:59:31

James Swallow.

03:59:31 - 04:00:09

Peter Swallow

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker, happy birthday. The Prime Minister will know that the commitment he has made on social and council housing will be very very welcome in a place like Bracknell with lots of families waiting for a home.

But it's undermined when social housing providers sell off their social homes through the disposals process. I know that we are taking steps to address this through the social housing bill, but I am concerned we're not going far enough and it's good to see the housing minister in his place. Will the Prime Minister work with him to address this issue and make sure we can stop disposals?

04:00:09 - 04:00:23

Andy Burnham

Can I say to my honorable friend, the housing minister has just assured me that we'll be looking at the very issue that he raises and perhaps he might want to pursue that conversation with my honorable friend.

04:00:23 - 04:00:54

Speaker 214

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister spoke earlier about deindustrialization and that is exactly what's happening in my constituency of Aberdeen South. But this deindustrialization is being caused directly by Labour's energy policies. The energy profits levy, the ban on new licenses and the delay on approving Jackdaw and Rosebank are all having a huge impact on thousands of jobs. So would the Prime Minister take a different approach from his predecessor and protect the jobs in the oil and gas sector?

04:00:54 - 04:01:00

Andy Burnham

I've been very clear Madam Deputy Speaker, I will take a pragmatic approach and you'll see that in action soon.

04:01:00 - 04:01:33

Scott Arthur

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker and I thank the Prime Minister for his statement. He mentioned the triple helix model. What's missing in Scotland from that model of course is that local authorities aren't empowered to play their part. On Friday Liz McAreavey from Edinburgh Chamber of Commerce and also the chief executive of Glasgow Chamber of Commerce wrote to the Prime Minister asking him to work with the First Minister in Scotland and city region leaders right across the Edinburgh Glasgow region to forge a devolution deal which enables these cities to meet their full potential. Will he take this offer seriously?

04:01:33 - 04:01:53

Andy Burnham

Well it's certainly on offer from me Madam Deputy Speaker to have a devolution deal that precisely does what he says, gets business, academia, local government all pulling together. That's on offer. Obviously it's a matter for the Scottish government, I'm not going to go round their back, but I hope we can agree something at the National Economic Council next month.

04:01:53 - 04:02:21

Jess Brown-Fuller

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. As the Prime Minister looks ahead to what is predicted to be one of the wettest winters on record, my constituents are expecting more of the same. Southern Water pumping sewage into our precious chalk stream, the River Lavant, which then feeds directly into Chichester Harbour. So can I ask the Prime Minister what he believes is an acceptable timescale to get to grips with the water industry and regulate them properly rather than a review that's delayed everything that was limited in scope?

04:02:21 - 04:02:45

Andy Burnham

No, I understand the last point, I've hinted at it today. The Cunliffe review I think was too limited, it should have looked at all options for the water industry. I don't want this to drag on, but I don't believe we have a water industry that's fit for the climate challenges of the future for the reasons that she's given. So it won't be too long Madam Deputy Speaker, we will come forward with our proposal soon.

04:02:45 - 04:03:07

John Slinger

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister's plans for the biggest redistribution of power this country has ever seen. But does he agree with me that in addition to redistributing power by geography, we also need to rebalance power between the generations and would he have a look at my ideas of a youth triple lock and also a dedicated minister for the younger and future generations?

04:03:07 - 04:03:24

Andy Burnham

I think this house will need to have a very profound debate when the Milburn report is published. We need to do, make a generational change in the way we support our young people and I will engage him fully in that discussion.

04:03:24 - 04:03:40

Ben Spencer

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Towns and villages across my constituency are often besieged by utility and engineering works. Would he look at and personally respond to my campaign for a statutory duty to coordinate these works to keep Runnymede and Weybridge moving?

04:03:40 - 04:03:49

Andy Burnham

Yes, this used to drive me mad as Mayor of Greater Manchester, Madam Deputy Speaker. Only the capital has had some of these powers. Everywhere should have them. I'm in full support of what he says.

04:03:49 - 04:03:50

Amanda Martin.

04:03:50 - 04:04:13

Amanda Martin

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It was a pleasure to welcome the Prime Minister to Portsmouth this summer when he visited His Majesty's Royal Naval Base. It was especially good to welcome a fellow North MP to Portsmouth North. He saw first-hand the dedication of our armed forces. So does he agree that supporting personnel and their families remains a priority, and like the police, they should include proper paternity leave for every serving father and ensure that our self-employed fathers are no longer left behind?

04:04:13 - 04:04:31

Andy Burnham

Well, I fully agree with my honorable friend, Madam Deputy Speaker. We do need to provide the very best support we can to those who serve in our armed forces. I know the Chancellor in his previous role did a lot to improve forces' accommodation. There is more we can do, and I look forward to working with her on that, and I enjoyed my visit.

04:04:31 - 04:04:33

Speaker 204

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

04:04:33 - 04:04:53

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

My mum and I survived domestic abuse when I was a child, but today there are many victims who are terrified about their own survival in light of the early release scheme. I know the Prime Minister has already excluded perpetrators of some offenses from that scheme and pulled out the stops there. But what stops will he pull out to further protect those victims of domestic abuse?

04:04:53 - 04:05:32

Andy Burnham

I don't want to steal the thunder of the Justice Secretary, but he will soon announce a much enhanced licensing and tagging regime where victims will be able to be given a say in the setting of the restrictions. And we are moving for the first time to a system of restrictions zones rather than exclusion zones. What that means is the victim being much more in control and not allowing people just to have places they can't go into, giving them a zone that's the only area that they can go into, and that completely alters the balance in favor of victims.

04:05:33 - 04:06:04

Alex Baker

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As the MP for Aldershot, I was really pleased to hear that the Prime Minister had held bilateral talks with Prime Ministers Carney and Freeland, who are leading the founding of the Defense Security and Resilience Bank. For the past 18 months, I have been pushing for the UK to join this multilateral bank because I believe we must work internationally to fund defense. Will the Prime Minister commit to the UK to stand with our allies and join this World Bank for defense, which can unlock millions in investment for our British defense industry?

04:06:04 - 04:06:24

Andy Burnham

Certainly, Madam Deputy Speaker, we will look at it, and indeed we are looking at it. And I've been in touch with the Canadian Prime Minister. There are other schemes as well in Europe. I think what we need to do to be pragmatic about our defense commitments is look at all ways of collaborating so that we can save the money as she suggests.

04:06:25 - 04:06:56

Speaker 223

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Prime Minister, Scotland is not a region and should not be treated as one. And those in Scotland are hurt and frustrated at the way that the Prime Minister has conducted the conversation around devolution and so arrogantly dismissed the mandate that the Scottish people gave of pro-independence. So I want to ask the Prime Minister why he thinks he can dismiss the democratically elected mandate of the Scottish people.

04:06:56 - 04:07:46

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I certainly haven't in any way disrespected Scotland. I came to Scotland to support the opening of the Commonwealth Games in my first week in office. I met the First Minister. He shared with me some of his concerns about the Council for the Nations and Regions that he felt didn't give due consideration to the nations. And I listened to that as well as putting the proposals on the table about more local devolution.

So I haven't done anything that she of the kind that she described. Similar to Northern Ireland, it's about where public support changes and the position changes.

And I don't follow all of the polls in Scotland, but I'm not aware that they are consistently showing a change and a need for another referendum.

04:07:46 - 04:08:13

Speaker 205

Madam Deputy Speaker, across the East Midlands persistently low apprenticeship start rates mean loads of our young children don't get the opportunities that they deserve. As the Prime Minister witnessed in Derby, there are some excellent examples of young people with good apprenticeships. Will the Prime Minister work across industry to make sure we increase the number of start-up apprenticeship rates so more young people can get a start in life?

04:08:13 - 04:08:35

Andy Burnham

It was brilliant to be at Alstom with him and to see all of the apprentices that they employ as well as their supply chain. It's a model for how we want to see others. I think we need to make a massive change in this area. It should be a big part of our response to the Milburn report and I can give him a commitment that is exactly what I'll be seeking to do.

04:08:35 - 04:09:02

John Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Prime Minister's warm words about rural coastal communities will be seen I'm afraid like the chocolate Freddo bar that he said he couldn't affect the price of, sweet but ultimately insubstantial. Similarly, his triple helix theory of growth is like the purple one in the Quality Street, largely nuts. We need much more detail, Prime Minister. Rural communities are crying out for help.

We need action. We cannot have Stone Roses' Fool's Gold.

04:09:02 - 04:09:31

Andy Burnham

He's worked hard on that question, Madam Deputy Speaker. Full marks for creativity. It must have looked great in front of the mirror, but it was still pretty good in here as well. Can I say the triple helix model, maybe he needs to speak to Baroness May down the corridor because that was her theory of the local industrial strategies that I mentioned and it's worked pretty well in Greater Manchester. I wouldn't dismiss it quite so quickly, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Greater Manchester average growth for a decade of over 3%. Maybe there's something worth looking at there.

04:09:31 - 04:10:16

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Prime Minister for his statement and also for the fact that his first visit after being elected as leader of the Labour Party back in July was to the North, North Kent in this instance. And would he agree with me that what his visit will have shown him is that we need to continue our investment in infrastructure, in our case the Lower Thames Crossing, but also fixing our crumbling roads such as Galley Hill Road in my constituency. We need to double down on infrastructure in order to have growth in every postcode, don't we, Prime Minister?

04:10:16 - 04:10:42

Andy Burnham

I completely agree and it was striking people pointing out the loss of the ferry service between his constituency and Tilbury, I think I'm right, Gravesend. Gravesend and Tilbury, have I got that right? That type of connectivity is crucial to local communities and I completely agree. Number 10 North is there to get that infrastructure back in and I hope he will work with them too.

04:10:42 - 04:11:06

Martin Wrigley

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Prime Minister to his place with his message of optimism and hope and change in terms of water, climate change and procurement. On procurement, may I be presumptive and give him a quick win? We can remove Palantir from the FDP in the NHS and replace it with a Greater Manchester model that works today and supplies more than Palantir does or ever can. That's an easy win to take.

04:11:06 - 04:11:17

Andy Burnham

Well, I've already got the other side of the House championing my achievements as Mayor of Greater Manchester, Madam Deputy Speaker, but he makes a good point.

04:11:17 - 04:12:02

Linsey Farnsworth

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and welcome to the Prime Minister in his post.

Madam Deputy Speaker, my constituency of Amber Valley is made up of three small manufacturing towns with surrounding villages, but it's been overlooked for far too long. So I'm pleased to hear the Prime Minister speak of growth in every postcode, and my constituents will be particularly pleased to hear about reindustrialization after our largest employer of Denby Pottery recently closed its doors for the last time after 217 years. Can the Prime Minister advise how we can prioritize constituencies like mine that are still experiencing the effects of deindustrialization?

04:12:02 - 04:12:29

Andy Burnham

Well, I was sad to hear about Denby Pottery, and I know her part of the world fairly, fairly well. We are serious about making sure where there are world-class sectors in our communities, we back them properly, we help them make transition to future, future technologies. We haven't done that well as a country in the past, we'll do it much better in the future.

04:12:29 - 04:13:11

Joe Robertson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm glad the Prime Minister had a nice tour of the UK over the summer. Had he come to the Isle of Wight, he would have heard about our number one cost of living issues, and that is the price of traveling to and from the Isle of Wight, astronomical, harming our tourism economy, restricting access to health and education. If he stands by his comments around people power and putting power back into communities, will he at least be open to creating regulatory powers so that we can control prices that are currently levied by private equity companies, put passengers first, and ensure that the Isle of Wight is treated fairly just like every other community in the UK?

04:13:11 - 04:13:47

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think he should, he sounds like he could be speaking from these benches because I got a lot of jeers when I talked about public control earlier this afternoon, but that's precisely what he's calling for, and he's right to do so. It enabled me to reduce bus fares in Greater Manchester, I don't see why it wouldn't enable him to reduce ferry fares. Bring me a proposal, that's what I would say to the honorable gentleman. Bring me a proposal, I will look seriously at it because I understand completely how critical that is to opportunity and growth both on the island and also on the mainland.

04:13:47 - 04:14:18

Speaker 229

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the Prime Minister to his place and thank him for the positive actions he is taking, particularly to end rough sleeping by Christmas. Will he join me in thanking the amazing charities and organizations in Southend who do so much good work in this area: HARP, St. Vincent de Paul, the One Love Project, YMCA, and Off the Streets? And can he give me an assurance that this off the streets is only the start of solving what can often be a complex set of individual circumstances?

04:14:18 - 04:14:48

Andy Burnham

Absolutely, Madam Deputy Speaker. When we think of rough sleeping and homelessness, the bricks and mortar is only part of it. In effect, what we're talking about is a journey of recovery, and that was the housing first philosophy that people talked about before. It's about giving people a firm base, but then giving them the support to move forward. Every person, in my view, is capable of recovery, we just need to give them the circumstances in which it can happen.

04:14:48 - 04:15:03

Speaker 228

The extremes of this summer can't simply be wished away by emollient phrases like not all one or another on new fossil fuel drilling. So can the Prime Minister tell us whether earlier he meant all our climate commitments are at risk from his government, or just this one?

04:15:03 - 04:15:42

Andy Burnham

The climate commitments in our manifesto are not at risk, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I've made it very clear today, I think we need to plan for a carbon-neutral future. I'm not one of those who will pander in a different direction. I was convinced as Mayor of Greater Manchester that our future lay in adopting renewables.

I am of the same view as Prime Minister. Where I differ from the Green Party is they take an ideological rather than a pragmatic approach to getting there, and that, I'm afraid, might delay the transition that she seeks.

04:15:42 - 04:15:44

Speaker 226

And how I've missed you, Chris Vince.

04:15:44 - 04:16:14

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and may I wish you a very happy birthday. And can I thank the Prime Minister for making one of his first visits as Prime Minister to Harlow, almost as if he knew I was going to mention Harlow quite regularly. However, I want to refer very seriously to an announcement made recently by the German government about an incident that happened at Leipzig Airport. Would he agree with me that we should be condemning this outrageous act of Russian aggression and also send our support to our German allies?

04:16:14 - 04:17:15

Andy Burnham

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a very serious matter indeed, and I believe news has broken about it as we've been gathering a statement from the German government in relation to the incidents at Leipzig. I want to leave the House in no doubt: the UK stands in full solidarity with Germany in the face of these egregious and unacceptable attacks. Russia's attempts to undermine our united resolve and our willingness to support Ukraine are futile and doomed to fail. We will be steadfast in the face of them. I am in touch with Chancellor Scholz and we are working closely with our allies to defend any threats to NATO and our allies and NATO territory.

And I'm glad he's raised it today. It's a very serious development and it requires the most intense European cooperation in response.

04:17:15 - 04:17:57

Iqbal Mohamed

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I wish the new Prime Minister the very best and welcome his commitment to a better kind of politics. Madam Deputy Speaker, nationally 4.4 million people are now in council tax debt, 1.2 million more than in the last year, and 1.7 million instructions were made for bailiffs in the last year. Bailiff use comes at a significant human and economic cost. So will the Prime Minister look at this issue, including revoking section 45 of the council tax regulations that allows councils to call in bailiffs, and introducing a new duty of care that puts harm reduction at the heart of council tax collection and helps write off unfair debt?

04:17:57 - 04:18:28

Andy Burnham

I happen to agree with what the honorable gentleman is saying, and I know there has been moves to improve the regulation of bailiffs. I also encourage the ten councils in Greater Manchester to take a different approach to debt, because there are many people in his constituency and mine who fear the noise of the letterbox going or a knock at the door. Personal debt can be completely destructive of people's mental health, and I think there is a different and better way as he describes.

04:18:28 - 04:19:12

Speaker 231

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When the Prime Minister travels up the West Coast Main Line through Milton Keynes and Bedfordshire, he'll be going through a bit of the country where there's a lot going on. We're building many new homes, we're building a new hospital, a new railway line, a new theme park, and expanding Luton Airport. But without a devolution deal, we can't make those projects a success for the local area, and there's a fear about us getting left behind. So will he work with local councils and local MPs to deliver a devolution deal as quickly as possible?

And on top of that, what would he say while I'm convinced and many of the local MPs are convinced, some local councillors still aren't convinced about the benefits of devolution? What would he say to them about the benefits that devolution would bring to Milton Keynes and Bedfordshire?

04:19:12 - 04:19:41

Andy Burnham

I think the evidence is undeniable when it comes to growth. I've mentioned Greater Manchester; the Liverpool City Region is now growing faster than the UK average. For most of our lives, that just wasn't the case. It's not in managed decline; it's actually flourishing.

And his area is too, but it can go even, it can go even further. The model of devolution in England is working. I want it to be available to all areas. If he wishes to lead a delegation to Number 10 North, I will ensure he gets the warmest possible welcome.

04:19:41 - 04:20:12

Luke Taylor

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know the Prime Minister is a huge advocate for the combined authority system of devolution. So I have good news for him. All of London's 32 boroughs called for exactly that in London in a rare cross-party call last year. So, in the spirit of cross-party working, and as he says to apply his experience from Manchester to the rest of the UK, will he reshape London's devolution settlement at last by giving London boroughs a seat at the table when making decisions with the Mayor?

04:20:12 - 04:20:42

Andy Burnham

I am aware of that change. Obviously, the GLA is created by statute and there are other voices in this mix as well, including London members of Parliament. I will always respond to a change when it is brought to me with a clear consensus, cross-party support. I'm not aware that that exists fully across London, but if such a proposal is brought, I would always look at it carefully.

04:20:42 - 04:21:11

Brian William Leishman

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, the previous Prime Minister announced a 200 million pound fund to create a green industrial revolution in Grangemouth. Now, my constituency needs reindustrialised, my communities need re-energised, and I know that the Prime Minister is as passionate about both of those things as I am. Will he make it a top priority to reindustrialise Grangemouth, get good, secure jobs into the town, and build the industrial future that Grangemouth and all of Scotland needs?

04:21:11 - 04:21:44

Andy Burnham

Well, can I say to my honourable friend, I understand that there is the possibility of sustainable aviation fuel production at Grangemouth, and I find that really interesting. And I keep coming back to it. If he wishes me to get Number 10 North to support him in developing that proposal, I know there's a financial commitment. But actually, if we do reindustrialise, the money we put forward to support that process can pay us back over many years to come through a bigger and flourishing economy in all parts of the UK.

04:21:44 - 04:22:17

Carla Lockhart

Madam Deputy Speaker, last week the High Court delivered a killer blow for the Parades Commission in Northern Ireland, uncovering unlawful decision-making. For 28 years, they've denied Portadown district the right to return home from their annual church parade. Every unionist and grassroots loyalist has said they have no confidence in the Parades Commission, yet staggeringly today, his government has said they have the full backing. The belligerence and arrogance of these commissioners is staggering. I would ask the Prime Minister to intervene and give them their P45.

04:22:17 - 04:22:51

Andy Burnham

Well, I don't know if the honourable lady's right about full backing, because I do believe there has been an independent review announced into the Parades Commission, the process that they undertook. So, the Northern Ireland Secretary has already taken some steps. The review into the process will go further, and we will work hard to ensure that the trust of all communities, but particularly the community she represents, is restored in the commission.

04:22:51 - 04:23:32

Charles David Robertson

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I commend the Prime Minister on his commitment to building good growth in every postcode? Across Lichfield, Burntwood, and the villages, my constituents will say that there is a real opportunity to look at HS2. Because despite nearly endless delays and disruption from roadworks and road closures on that stretch that would have linked Birmingham to Crewe and to Manchester, there has been nothing but pain and nothing but an anchor on our growth. But for all of that pain, we will see no gain. There is currently no station planned anywhere in Staffordshire and no new services anywhere in the county either.

Will the Prime Minister meet with me to discuss how we can make this project work for every postcode along the line?

04:23:32 - 04:23:57

Andy Burnham

I think there is a need for a resolution of what will happen from Handsacre to Manchester via Crewe and what the solution is for communities in between. It can't be left where it is indefinitely. I understand the points that he's making, but given my past role, I hope he will be assured that it is something I know a lot about.

04:23:57 - 04:24:31

Alison Bennett

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and happy birthday. There are teachers in West Sussex that are giving up running after-school clubs so they can take on a second job because the cost of living, particularly the cost of housing, is so high in West Sussex. And one of the issues is that West Sussex has the fifth lowest secondary unit of funding in schools. So will the Prime Minister review minimum per-student funding levels so that they truly reflect the cost of living in West Sussex?

04:24:31 - 04:24:36

Speaker 236

Well, I will ask the Education Secretary to look at precisely the issue she raises.

04:24:36 - 04:24:56

John Neil Duncan-Jordan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On social care, does the Prime Minister agree that there is a fundamental unfairness when care for dementia is means-tested while cancer care is funded by us all through general taxation? Isn't this unfairness the issue we need to address?

04:24:56 - 04:25:17

Andy Burnham

I have always said, Madam Deputy Speaker, that we won't have a health and care system fit for the 21st century until it supports people with dementia as well as it treats people with cancer. We are some way from that, but that is the goal we should be working towards.

04:25:17 - 04:26:01

Speaker 31

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. May I welcome the Prime Minister to his role? May I also welcome his commitment to restoring local ownership and control? Sadly, that's not been the experience of my residents in Bicester, Piddington, Blackthorn, Ambrosden and Arncott as they face the proposal for a huge asylum centre to be built costing millions of taxpayer pounds. 55 days ago, the government said that this was an urgent application and yet it remains veiled in secrecy and has not been published.

So will the Prime Minister honour that commitment to restore local agency, withdraw the urgent application and publish the details so they can be held to scrutiny by the people they should be, the local people and local representatives?

04:26:01 - 04:26:18

Andy Burnham

Well, I am aware of the concern and it's similar to the issue as raised by the honourable gentleman opposite as well. All I can say is I will give him a commitment that I will familiarize myself with all of the detail of the of the planning application and will happily report back at this dispatch box when I have done that.

04:26:18 - 04:26:55

Speaker 237

Madam Deputy Speaker, can I welcome the Prime Minister to his place and invite him to my place? There are beautiful flight connections from Manchester to the Western Isles where he will see we have the highest concentration of community-owned wind farms in the country. And if he really wants to fulfill the potential of the energy transition, then these communities should be given priority access to grid connections and he should use the muscle of GB Energy to give communities and local councils the ability to buy shares in renewable renewable schemes anywhere in their area. It's devolutionary, it's revolutionary, and the template for how to do it is in the Hebrides.

04:26:55 - 04:27:11

Andy Burnham

Well, it's put very well, Madam Deputy Speaker, and this is exactly the agenda that I've been talking about from this dispatch box today. All parts of the UK need to have that control over those basic services and I look forward to working with him to support what he's saying.

04:27:11 - 04:27:17

Speaker 233

For the final and 125th question, Gideon Amos.

04:27:17 - 04:27:49

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Over the summer, Madam Deputy Speaker, the national maternity review confirmed what we all feared in Taunton, which is Musgrove Park Hospital's maternity unit is the most challenging estate in the country. It cannot be right that mums are giving birth in 30-degree heat and staff are fainting while they're looking after them. If that's the most challenging estate in the country, they cannot wait until 2033. Will the Prime Minister please look at moving forward the new maternity unit at Musgrove Park as an urgent priority?

04:27:49 - 04:28:21

Andy Burnham

I remember well, Madam Deputy Speaker, visiting in my health minister days. I did some work shadowing at the hospital, so I know how much in need it is of renovation. I will look into the issue. I think across the NHS this summer staff have been working in unbearable conditions, same for patients as well. I know the Health Secretary has this high on her agenda and I will come back to the honourable gentleman when I've had a chance to look at the latest status of that issue.

04:28:21 - 04:28:55

Judith Cummins

That is the end of the Prime Minister's statement. I'll give the front benches a few moments to shuffle over. If colleagues can settle quickly, we're moving on to the statement on criminal justice reform, and I call the Justice Secretary and the Lord Chancellor, Alex Norris.

04:28:55 - 04:37:21

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and with your permission, I will make a statement on the implementation of the Sentencing Act. When this Labour government took office, we inherited a crisis in our prisons, regularly at 99% capacity, with fewer than 100 places available at one stage, one bad day away from running out of space, courts forced to suspend trials, police unable to make arrests, nowhere to put dangerous criminals, a total breakdown of law and order with victims bearing the brunt. My predecessors have acted swiftly to stabilise our prisons, committing to the most ambitious prison building programme since the Victorians, pledging 14,000 new prison places by 2031 with 3,200 already delivered, compared to the record of the party opposite, who added just 500 net places in 14 years. We've also deported nearly 12,000 foreign national offenders, but we had to ensure that we never returned to the shambolic emergency releases carried out with little scrutiny or warning by the previous government. So we passed the Sentencing Act, which introduced the earned progression model, where offenders on standard determinate sentences spend at least a third of their sentence behind bars and longer if they behave badly, with more serious offences requiring serving at least half, and with no upper limit for time spent inside for bad behaviour.

But release from prison is not the end of the story. We've overseen the largest ever expansion of tagging, and working closely with police, we are giving probation access to the largest and toughest range of measures to manage offenders. Every single offender leaving prison can now be tagged, and strict licence conditions can include curfews, bans from pubs, clubs, even football matches, exclusion zones where criminals cannot go, and for the most serious sexual and violent offenders, we are introducing world-first restriction zones, confining them to specific areas, sometimes a few miles wide, curtailing their liberty to give victims more freedom. And if conditions are breached, offenders can be recalled to prison. This clearly asks more of our brilliant probation service, so we're also investing 700 million pounds more on probation and community services by 28-29, hiring a further 1,300 trainee probation officers on top of the 2,300 recruited in the past two years.

But let me be clear about who this model applies to. The most dangerous offenders locked up for serious violent and sexual offences and on life, those on life sentences were never eligible. But the Prime Minister and I were determined to look again. So we moved quickly to exclude rape offences and many serious child sex offences and grooming offences. And we've gone further still, now excluding all unlawful killing offences, death by dangerous or drink driving, causing or allowing the death of a child, and of course manslaughter, as well as indecent assault, which has been used to prosecute historic child sex abuse.

This means hundreds more dangerous criminals staying behind bars for longer, including those who killed PC Andrew Harper in the line of duty. This is the right thing to do and I pay tribute to his wife Lizzie and mother Debbie who campaigned for this. We would like to have gone further, but due to the lack of investment of the previous government's 14 years, we are unable to do so. I want to reassure the House that victims in the victim contact scheme are being kept informed by dedicated victim liaison officers, and we are rightly giving victims the opportunity to have their say on license conditions for offenders in their case. And I've instructed my officials to attempt to trace all affected victims for whom we don't have the details.

And on top of this we are boosting victim support with an 18.9 million pound funding package, including a dedicated free helpline offering emotional support for anyone affected and specialist support for victims of violence against women and girls. And I've asked the Prisons Minister to work with victims groups to shape our response because victims must come first. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister and I have pushed the system to its limits, and at the same time my duty is to ensure that we always have the space to lock up offenders. So today I can announce a fast-track plan to create more headroom in our prison system by bringing forward more than 110 million pounds worth of funding, where I've identified where we can accelerate the delivery of more places, including converting space within prisons into cells. And we're pushing to deliver current building plans faster and will also invest in new land for prisons, building a credible pipeline of new sites to enable more prison building, because my top priority is to build a long-term sustainable future for our prison estate.

And we're also freeing up space in the shorter term. There are thousands of foreign national offenders in our prisons at vast expense to taxpayers. We've increased removals by 41% compared to the last two years of the previous Tory government, and we've changed the law to expand the early removal scheme and now we will go further. Next year we will begin removing foreign national offenders serving determinate sentences immediately after sentencing. But I want to reassure the House that the most dangerous, such as those already excluded from sentencing act changes, will be still required to serve prison time before being deported.

And I want to be clear that all removed offenders will be barred from returning to the UK for life, because deportation is at the anchor of that punishment. If you break our laws, if you abuse Britain's hospitality, we will permanently remove you. We will also act on a long-standing injustice. More than 2,000 people are still trapped by the indeterminate imprisonment for public protection or IPP sentence. They were abolished, rightly, a decade ago, but offenders are still locked up for far longer than envisaged, often for crimes which if sentenced today would have seen them spend much less time in jail.

Of those who've never been released, 99% are beyond the tariff imposed by the court, and 80% have served 10 years or more beyond it. And tragically with no end of their sentence in sight, some IPP prisoners have taken their own lives. Concerns about IPPs have been raised across the political spectrum including by former Justice Secretary Alex Chalk who called them a stain on our justice system. The number of IPP offenders has been reducing, but the Prime Minister and I want to go further. We will soon bring forward legislation to end the sentence once and for all by the end of this Parliament.

These are complex cases and some of these offenders have committed serious crimes. Public safety will be always my top priority and we must balance that with the fairness that I talked about with these sentences. It will take time to get this right, but the work will begin immediately and I offer to all parties and none in this place to do so on a cross-party basis. I will listen to experts inside and outside this House, including the former Justice Secretary Robert Buckland and former Home Secretary David Blunkett, committed advocates of IPP reform who I thank for agreeing to work with me. In the meantime we will do everything within the existing framework to support those in prison to move towards a safe and sustainable release.

I also intend to look at how we improve outcomes for offenders with complex needs. Women in prison often have high levels of trauma, abuse, mental ill health and addiction. Many are mothers and their children can be affected profoundly by them being in prison. So I want to reduce the number of women in custody where it is safe to do so, alongside a cross-government agenda to address the drivers of women's offending. For youth offenders, I'm announcing four and a half million pounds of investment for robust community alternatives to locking children up in expensive, ineffective and unsuitable prisons.

And to help solve the crisis in adult prisons, I've decided to temporarily hold some 18-year-olds in our youth estate for longer. Madam Deputy Speaker, my job is to balance the sustainability of our prisons with public protection, the rights of victims and public confidence in the justice system. The decisions that the Prime Minister and I have had to take are difficult ones. We would have liked to have gone further, but this government inherited a system on the brink of failure. I am clear that there must always be space for dangerous offenders, because protecting the public means fixing prisons for good, otherwise it is the victims who are let down and we will never let that happen.

This government will run towards problems, including the tough decisions needed to build a justice system that is firm, fair and protects the public. Those aims will guide me as I tackle its challenges, reform it for a sustainable future and ensure it commands the confidence of the British public. I commend this statement to the House.

04:37:21 - 04:41:05

Nick Timothy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the Justice Secretary to his place. This is the government's fifth early release policy in just six weeks since the Prime Minister took office. At every stage, we were told ministers had no choice but to include dangerous criminals because the alternative would be the collapse of the entire system. Now the plan is to stop one group of dangerous criminals leaving prison early by letting a different group of dangerous criminals out instead. The Justice Secretary and Prime Minister have justified the plan to release IPP prisoners as a matter of principle, but it's no such thing.

It's a fag-packet policy written to get them out of this crisis. Last year, a Justice Minister rejected it, saying it would put the public at risk. 1,415 IPP prisoners had to be recalled to prison after release. The Parole Board says the rest, 856 prisoners, are too dangerous to be freed. And despite the new exclusions, many violent criminals will still be released after one third of their sentence.

This includes domestic abusers and some paedophiles. The Justice Secretary says if a domestic abuser breaches the terms of their release, tagging means probation and the police will be alerted, and he said this morning these are really good systems. But most breaches result in no action at all. In fact, the Justice Secretary said this morning that early release is now, quote, "business as usual" and will go on for years to come. So with that in mind, the Sentencing Act provides no end date to SDS40.

So is this a permanent provision? If not, for how long does he think it should last? Can he rule out letting prisoners out even earlier with the use of home detention curfews, even earlier with home detention curfews? Will he publish detailed capacity projections and all relevant data? Will he give us a timeline and a target for his promise to get more foreign national prisoners out of the country?

What is his plan to overcome barriers to deportation caused by the ECHR and in particular unqualified rights like articles 2 and 3? How many cells will be established within the existing estate by the end of 2026, 27 and 28? Will he release every IPP prisoner by the end of the parliament as suggested in the MOJ statement on Sunday? Will prisoners who would have received a life sentence had IPP sentences not existed remain locked up? Will the Justice Secretary rule out watering down the criteria used by the Parole Board to assess IPP prisoners?

And can he confirm the changes to early release will come through secondary legislation, presenting MPs with a false binary choice and no chance to amend their plan? Madam Deputy Speaker, we've more than 700 fewer prison cells than last year, 1,600 fewer prison officers since the election, and no new prisons have been planned or approved by this government since the election. There are more than 4,000 operational available places and 4,000 more that are certified but out of use because of rules and regulations, officer shortages, and in the case of Dartmoor prison, levels of radon gas that local residents live with every day. Madam Deputy Speaker, describing the early release of criminals, a dangerous and irresponsible policy, as business as usual is an insult not just to victims, it's a dereliction of duty.

04:41:05 - 04:45:13

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm grateful for the Shadow Secretary of State's kind words in welcoming. I don't know him well, but I know that he like I shares a love for this country and everything he does is seen through that prism. And my commitment to him is to work with him. There'll be times, perhaps even including today, where we need to disagree in the best traditions of this place, but I know there'll be a lot that brings us together over the months and hopefully years to come for both of us. I mean, first of all, on the point of plans and changed plans.

You know, I make no apology, certainly not to the opposition, for being able to grab hold of a system that when we left in July wasn't going to exclude whether it was rape offences, child sex offences, and now those who've taken lives. That is, that is good. I do, I recognize and I would say to victims that I know that's created uncertainty and I do apologize to them, but I hope that they would understand that it was done with noble purpose and now we must use the time available to make sure victims are getting the right support, particularly around shaping restrictions on their offenders if they do come out. But he mentions plans. The reality is if we followed his plan, we would have a prison system that was bust before Christmas.

What would that mean for justice in this country? How could that be right? And he jumps on the point of business as usual. The point I'm trying to make here is this parliament has changed legislation. So the Sentencing Act is the basis on which the basis on which standard determinate sentences will be governed and that will be the case for the foreseeable future.

I mean, linked to that, linked to that, he talks about how the changes will come into force. That will be via varying the commencement order. He talks about home detention and I can say that I have no intention of going any further. You know, these the results the work that we've put in as a result of the Sentencing Act, that is our way of managing the pressure in the system. On capacity and he asks for for clarity.

Well, a little bit of clarity here. We should be clear that, you know, we've added 374 places in the adult male estate since the general election. Now, that is nowhere near, nowhere near where we want to get to as the end state. That's why our building program has 14,000 places in it.

But I would hope that it is a point of shared interest in wanting to do more. Of course things do come in and out of the estate, whether it's fire damage, you know, I wouldn't underestimate the importance of contamination either, but nevertheless, there will be, of course there will be significant places added in in this Parliament and in our program to 2031. He asks about data and the chance to scrutinize that. Well, he will know under the Sentencing Act that we are committed to publishing an annual report and that's what we'll do. And I'm sure he and I will get into it at that point.

I mean, on foreign national offenders, I mean, I would, if the honorable gentleman has doubt, I would state my record to him and to the House. You know, we have increased by 41% the removal of foreign offenders in this country. And I might gently say that was my role in the Home Office in doing so. So he should not doubt my vigor. There are changes he mentions, Article 3.

He will know the important work done at the Council of Europe. My honorable friend here has done a lot of important work in this space. Similarly, our work around Article 8 is also important. I hope he will support that when that's in front of Parliament too. So I don't think he should doubt our vigor.

As I say, we're already doing well better than his predecessors. They're sat next to him, he could talk to them about that. But indeed, I know we'll go further. But let me finish on this IPP point, Madam Deputy Speaker, because I'm really interested to see how this does and doesn't hold. Because I know the honorable gentleman is a champion of individual liberty.

I know the honorable gentleman is a skeptic of what he thinks is uneven justice. Now, he, you know, if I'm able to make this acknowledgment, I hope he will at least reflect on it, that there is a real dissatisfaction that as a result of the changes we've had to make, that some people will leave their, leave prison earlier than their sentence dictated, and there will be in many cases people who are still there 10 years after. Now, there is no easy solution to that. All I ask of him is to engage in a process to bring that to its resolution.

04:45:13 - 04:46:19

Speaker 244

Madam Deputy Speaker, the members opposite seem to need reminding that the early release program was devised by a Conservative government. We have been debating at great length in the media and amongst politicians about keeping people in prison for longer. And I do support what the government is, government policy is on this issue. But I would remind the House that the only thing ultimately that makes people safer is to give more support to prison officers, including their salary, to put money into improving the prison estate. Some of these prisons are Victorian buildings.

And finally, to put the effort and the money into rehabilitation of prisoners, not just keeping them in prison longer.

04:46:19 - 04:47:01

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful to the right honorable lady and I would agree wholeheartedly with the, with the value that she puts into the important work of our prison officers and our probation officers. I mean, she is exactly right. The thing that surely binds all of us is that we want to reduce reoffending. But we know that, and this is, you know, why what is, what I've presented to Parliament today is a, is a measure to get us through a crisis. We have to build a new criminal justice system.

And that can be done from this dispatch box, but actually has to be done much more widely, including work with our prison officers, our probation service, the police, and our communities to reduce reoffending. That's what we all want to see.

04:47:01 - 04:49:26

Jess Brown-Fuller

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Justice Secretary knows that the chaos and uncertainty on victims and their loved ones over the summer months by the handling of this scheme has been unforgivable. The government has changed course countless times, leaving those like PC Andrew Harper's family and countless others without the certainty that they deserve.

Now the reality that we all agree with is that in a properly functioning justice system, no victim or loved one should ever be told that their perpetrator is being released earlier than they were told when that sentence was handed down. But if tough decisions have to be made, then they have to be made carefully, sensitively, and preparedly, with the safety of victims, loved ones, and the public front of mind. So how therefore will the Justice Secretary be communicating these what I hope are final changes to those that received those generic letters, including those victims of grooming gangs and sexual abuse earlier this year, and will those letters be tailored to each victim? He mentioned in his statement those that are not on the victim contact scheme and an effort by the MOJ to contact them. Can he please provide an assessment of how many victims he thinks that is and how much resource he'll be giving to try and track down those victims?

The reality for the new Justice Secretary is that his inheritance is now a public safety crisis. If probation staff go ahead with strike action, as threatened last month, is the Justice Secretary confident the system can safely manage the risks of releasing thousands of extra offenders? This has all the hallmarks of a national emergency waiting to happen, yet where is the emergency response? Can he explain why the National Criminal Justice Board has not met all year, despite these changes being discussed last year as part of the Sentencing Act, and will he now convene COBRA to give the situation the gravitas that it deserves? The prison capacity crisis is one that this government inherited two years ago, but they now own the responsibility.

And as highlighted by the CEO of the Howard League, we are one major incident away from a disaster. Prisons such as Wandsworth have been operating 62% above their intended built capacity as the new normal, creating dangerous conditions that undermine any effort to rehabilitate offenders. So what can the Justice Secretary give in terms of confidence that he can deliver this increase in capacity on time, given past failings to do so, and then adequately staff them?

04:49:26 - 04:51:59

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm very grateful for the Lib Dem spokesperson for her contribution there. And I do accept, as I hope she heard me say, I do accept that the impact of us taking the summer to try to carve more offences out of this regime in a way that's safe and means we have a resilient prisoner state, I appreciate that that has an impact on victims, on survivors, and on their families as they wait with uncertainty. I hope that that's not unforgivable in the sense that I hope that it is understood that our aims for that were noble ones and have allowed us to go further, which I think is a good thing that all colleagues would share. But my mitigation of that and my attempt to seek to balance that is by what we do now. And that is my commitment from this dispatch box about the quality of engagement with victims and survivors.

Everyone is being written to immediately to have a contact sent to them, a trauma-informed engagement introducing a conversation that's going to come from a VLO specific to them, specific to the information about their offender's release date and whether it's changing, and then helping them tailor the controls on their perpetrator so they can live the fullest possible life. On the points on probation and capacity, well I would say, and I pay tribute to my predecessor colleagues as Lord Chancellor, the work that's been done to recruit more staff. That is not at its end state, but nevertheless that 700 million pound investment is starting to bear fruit, and I think that that gives us optimism for probation. But I am aware still of the challenges and have met with staff and will continue to engage, of course we want to avert strike action as she says. On the National Criminal Justice Board, I mean for me, that talks a little bit to the point that I made to my right honourable friend.

I want to reinvigorate that as a place that takes real ownership of a reform of our criminal justice system, which I think all of us would accept is not delivering, we're paying a lot for failure as well, and that's what I intend to do with that. I haven't had very long as I hope she would accept, but I certainly look forward to meeting with them.

On the point of convening COBRA, I have to say that that is not in my gift, that's in the Prime Minister's. But what I would say is that the changes that we've made are exactly to avert that scenario where we get to a crisis. So I'm, you know, I'm conscious in the spirit in which she says about some of the pressures that we have put on over the summer, they have been for good aims, but now we need to build a much better system out of this.

04:51:59 - 04:52:47

Speaker 245

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank my right honourable friend for today's statement, which will be welcomed by my constituents after a period of great anxiety. I thank him also for his engagement with me over the summer. When PC Andrew Harper was killed in my constituency, it devastated our community. But it also left a deep determination to stand by our brave police who every day run towards danger.

Andrew Harper was the absolute best of us, and I'd like to pay tribute to his family who have fought so bravely in his memory. I'd also like to thank everyone in my constituency and beyond who signed the petition and made their voice heard. Will the Secretary of State outline what steps he will now take to show our brave police that this government will always be on their side?

04:52:47 - 04:53:58

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful to my honourable friend for that question, and I would want to pay tribute to her campaigning, very direct campaigning to me over the summer about her expectations and her community's expectations. And I would associate and join in what she said with regards to PC Andrew Harper, who was the very best of us. And, you know, that is, I know, and I really respect what both Lissie Harper and Debbie Adlam, that they've never asked for special treatment. But I do think it is reflected in the actions of this Parliament that we changed the law subsequently, that we do think that it is different when our emergency service workers are killed in the line of their duty. It's right that we did that, but this did create this inequity that it is right that we've, that we have corrected it.

I again, I apologize to both of them about the time that it took to do so, but I'm glad that we have been able to do so. And on a final point, you know, the thing that I want to do for our brave police up and down the country is to have a system that isn't running as hot as this, that they're not having to chase around all those symptoms of failure. Now that is, you know, a long-term piece of work, but, you know, one that starts immediately, and my commitment to them is to have them in the room in the process of doing so.

04:53:58 - 04:54:47

Julian Lewis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know the government will be doing its best to protect potential future victims of early release offenders, particularly those who were in jail for domestic abuse or other fixated behavior. But it's not good enough simply to try and improve tagging measures. What one has to do is improve the ability of potential victims to summon help if attacked again. Can he confirm that the government will make a unified representation of how such potential future victims can protect themselves, for example, by emergency alarms being fitted as a matter of routine?

04:54:47 - 04:54:58

Judith Cummins

Before the Secretary of State responds, I can understand how sensitive this topic is, but we've been in the chamber a long time before we started other bits of business, so please keep questions short and answers just as short, please.

04:54:58 - 04:55:11

Alexander James Jordan Norris

The right honourable gentleman is right to raise that. That is part of the conversations that victim liaison officers are having so that every victim and survivor is able to shape the support around them to make sure that they're feeling safe and secure.

04:55:11 - 04:55:48

Mark Maguire

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's decision to end early release for certain serious offenders, including those responsible for the appalling killing of PC Harper, as we've heard. My former police colleagues and other emergency workers put themselves in harm's way every day to keep us safe, and they must be able to have confidence in our system. So does the Justice Secretary agree with me that this decision sends them and others a clear and unequivocal message that this government values their service, stands firmly with them and their families, and will ensure that those who commit the most serious crimes against them face the consequences of their actions?

04:55:48 - 04:56:17

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful for that question. I want to recognize my honorable friend's own service in the police service. And you know, I know it was made very clear to me by lots of colleagues and it was clear in the conversations I had that the policing family were looking very, very closely at our actions in this regard. I hope they've got that message both from law changes that have happened but also the changes we've been able to make now. And as I say, I hope they'll measure us by the work we will do with them to improve the criminal justice system going forwards.

04:56:17 - 04:56:41

Esther McVey

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Cheshire Police estimate the additional cost to manage more criminals back on the streets due to Labour's early release scheme will be 1.4 million pounds a year. So can the Minister reassure police forces up and down the country that these extra resources will be handed to them.

04:56:41 - 04:56:55

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Well, the right honorable lady will know of our significant increase in funding to our police already. Of course, through the National Police Chiefs' Council's representations have been made about police resourcing and support we can give to policing and we're still having those conversations with them.

04:56:55 - 04:57:35

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Lord Chancellor's statement. As a former criminal law barrister, I represented defendants who were actually given IPP sentences. They were required to complete courses, treatments and rehabilitation but before they could be considered for release. Yet many were never offered any of these things in time, leaving them to be unable to be reviewed by the Parole Board through no fault of their own.

Can the Lord Chancellor say what he's doing to ensure the prisons get the help and the courses they need in time for their parole eligibility.

04:57:35 - 04:58:02

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Well, I hope my honorable friend takes comfort from what both the Prime Minister and myself have said about making sure the right support is put in place for those who are paroled to stay out of prison and for those who aren't haven't yet passed that stage to get to that stage and to pass it. It has to be done with public safety in mind. But as I say, whether it's her insights or insights from colleagues across the chamber, we are very much up for that dialogue because we are resolute in our intention here.

04:58:02 - 04:58:28

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When the Justice Select Committee visited a young offenders institute earlier this year, we found that most of the young people were not able to access even the minimal amount of education or training, which means that they're more likely to go on to commit more offenses. So what is he doing to improve the access to education, training and financial preparedness to make sure that young offenders and their adult counterparts do not reoffend and therefore fill the prisons up again.

04:58:28 - 04:58:54

Alexander James Jordan Norris

The honorable lady hits on a very important point here. What are we using our facilities for if it's not to rehabilitate particularly our young people. That is a symptom of what happens when the estate runs as hot as it does. That is a big factor both for young people and all people frankly on reoffending. That's why we're taking pressure off so she's heard what I've said about investment to get to what we want, which is a system that properly prepares people for release.

04:58:54 - 04:59:36

Speaker 246

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I thank the Justice Secretary for engaging with me and other colleagues over the summer and taking action to bring forward when the victims' hotline will be up and running so it's available for victims next month who are worried about their offender's release. But could I ask about restriction zones because at present offenders can be banned from a victim's local area but it still leaves victims really worried about running into them when they leave their area. Restriction zones reverses that burden, confining offenders to specific areas. But will the Justice Secretary be more ambitious about the use of restriction zones so it is the freedom of perpetrators that are curtailed and not their victims.

04:59:36 - 05:00:14

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Thank you. First of all, I'd like to recognize my honorable friend's work herself in the department that we're building out from, particularly around the hotline and that's why we've brought it forward.

But this, I'm really pleased she's given me the chance to talk about restriction zones because these are world-leading. We are introducing them for the first time. The commitment that I've made to campaigners, indeed I had an email literally as I was about to stand up about how this could operate, is that we will bring those who are interested in making sure these work into the room to challenge us on what we're doing to make sure we're going as far as we can in a way to make these effective. You know, this is going to take time to build up. It has to be done in the right way, but these have really got really high potential and my commitment from this dispatch box is for that max engagement so people know what we're doing and can help us do this well.

05:00:14 - 05:00:47

Alexandra Alicia Martha Kearns

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Mark Saunders was a teacher who raped young girls. His sentence was nine years and nine months, yet in July, after serving just two years, he was moved to an open prison, free to come and go and have overnight stays. In July, I raised his case at Justice Questions with the member for Rother Valley and also wrote to the Minister. He promised to review the case, but I've still had no response.

I'm sure the Lord Chancellor recognizes for survivors this feels like a form of early release. He shouldn't be in our communities now, which he is, after serving only a quarter of his sentence.

05:00:47 - 05:00:55

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Well, the honorable lady will have heard what I've said about who we've taken out of scope of the progression model, but on the specific case, let me undertake to look at that and come back to her as soon as possible.

05:00:55 - 05:01:37

Kevin Foster

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Lord Chancellor may know that I've written to him about my constituent William Payne, whose girlfriend Abigail Eggleston was killed by Liam Bowes, who was sentenced to 12 years for causing death by dangerous driving. And I therefore welcome the government's decision to exclude that offense from the new release arrangements. I wonder if he's able to confirm that as a result, Mr. Bowes' custodial release point will remain at two-thirds of his sentence rather than being brought forward to one-half and ensure that my constituent receives formal confirmation of this.

05:01:37 - 05:01:57

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful for that question. As my honorable friend knows, we have taken death by dangerous driving out of scope of this progression model, so anybody under this model whose sentence was being reduced from two-thirds to a half and was in there for death by dangerous driving is now not in scope. I will get the full clarity on the release date for my honorable friend.

05:01:57 - 05:02:37

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The daughter of one of my constituents was the victim of a knife attack in her own home in 2014. Thankfully, the perpetrator was convicted. He is now charged with another offense of rape and is appearing in court next month. You can imagine the concern of my constituent's daughter when she received a letter from Victim Support to say that this individual was going to be released.

I have written to the Lord Chancellor about this. I appreciate he might not have seen the letter personally, but could he give an assurance that he will look at this and do all he can to ensure this individual is not released?

05:02:37 - 05:02:59

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Again, I would say to the honorable gentleman that rape has been excluded from the progression model, but I will look at that as again as a matter of urgency and come back to him. The most important I would think to say to all colleagues is that engagement for the victim survivor with their victim liaison officer so they can answer some of those questions too, and I will do anything I can to speed up that process.

05:02:59 - 05:03:20

Warinder Juss

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Does my right honorable friend agree that one way of increasing prison capacity is to reduce reoffending, with 80% of people in prison being reoffenders? Far too often, we have prisoners who leave prison with no home, no job, no family or social connections. Are we doing enough to address this?

05:03:20 - 05:03:42

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I mean, the answer to that question is no. You know, that's why the system is running as hot as it is, and then it becomes a self-defeating cycle of a system that runs hot and therefore doesn't do those things. I hope he will, as I certainly did, take a lot of comfort from what the Prime Minister said in the previous session around particularly addressing housing so that we know that people have that stable base from which to rebuild their lives.

05:03:41 - 05:04:11

Speaker 247

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want him to know how grateful I am for the phone call he placed with my constituent Rosie Shephard. Her sister Fenella Hawes was killed by a drunk driver four times over the limit, and the words he was able to speak to her were of great comfort to her family. Does he accept that the nature and timing of the communications that have gone out over the summer have been really, really devastating for families? And have lessons been learned in general in future situations which requires wholesale correspondence with victims?

05:04:11 - 05:04:30

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I mean, the honourable gentleman is right, and I hope he has heard me accept that. I hope there would be a degree of recognition that it's been done in a noble cause of wanting to go further, but I would still recognise everything he says in terms of correspondence, as you say, particularly correspondence that might be more general and go out wider. Our commitment is to make sure that that's trauma-informed.

05:04:30 - 05:05:06

Mary Creagh

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I welcome my right honourable friend to his place and congratulate him on the steps he's taken this summer to reduce prison populations whilst excluding the most dangerous offenders? We must never again be in a position of having more prisoners than prison places. But can I ask him to reassure the House that as he looks at the use of prison capacity and spare places, he will not remove the workshops and training areas in prisons which our brilliant prison staff do so much work in to reduce that cycle of reoffending?

05:05:06 - 05:05:25

Alexander James Jordan Norris

My right honourable friend's made a very important point there. I hope she's heard from what I've said about our enthusiasm for those things that do prevent reoffending. My honourable friend the Prisons Minister is looking closely at this in our estate plans because we do know that those areas really help us prepare people for release and keep them from reoffending.

05:05:25 - 05:05:47

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. There is no dispute that the IPP topic is a difficult challenge, but there's also no dispute that many of those IPP prisoners have been deemed as a high risk to society by the Parole Board. So is it the government's position that the Parole Board is incorrect, or is it the government's position that they're willing to lower the threshold of risk?

05:05:47 - 05:06:28

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I don't think, I don't think it has to be a binary choice between those two things. I would want to recognise the really good work that the Parole Board does. I think there is definitely a challenge, as he has heard me say, around support for those who have been in prison, as I say, if you've been in prison for a decade longer than perhaps you were sentenced for, you are going to struggle to adapt to life on the outside. So it's incumbent on us as a government, across government, because, you know, our probation service does so much, it's the other wrap-around things too that can help us go further. So, you know, I'd say to the honourable gentleman, I think he would accept as I do that these sentences have more than come, more than come to their time.

Let's work together to bring it to its end.

05:06:28 - 05:07:01

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for his statement. His colleague, the Policing and Crime Minister, wrote to me over the summer to confirm that from the 26th of October, police in Ealing Southall will have the power to use Labour's new respect orders, with persistent anti-social behaviour offenders facing up to two years in prison. Does he agree with me that the steps that this government is taking will help ensure that there is room in our prisons for those who are making life a misery right now for many of my constituents in Ealing Southall?

05:07:01 - 05:07:19

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I totally agree with that. There needs always needs to be, and it's sad that it needs this to be stated, places for people to go to prison when they've committed those serious offences, because the worst-case scenario would be either trials collapsing or people being re-bailed back to perhaps the situation from which they've been offending. So that's why we've made the changes we've made.

05:07:19 - 05:07:46

Speaker 228

Madam Deputy Speaker, the Secretary of State has spoken about sentenced prisoners, but not yet about the 15,000 prisoners who are being held on remand.

This includes one in four of all women in prison, particularly young women, those held for non-violent crimes including protesters and a higher proportion of minority groups. So when will we see real action on remand decisions, and especially on the relevant recommendations of the Women's Justice Board earlier this year?

05:07:46 - 05:08:07

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful for that question. The remand population is a very, very much a material part of this consideration. There is an important place for remand in public protection, but she will know that often a function of a remand population is of course court delays, and that is something that there's important legislation making its way through this House and we'll be, I've no doubt, having important exchanges on that to come shortly.

05:08:07 - 05:09:05

Speaker 254

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to echo the remarks of my colleague for Reading West and Forest of Dean, now no longer in the chamber, regarding Andrew Harper. What kind of message would it have sent to 140,000 police officers if those killers had been released? The important thing is those officers, when they open their locker at 6:00 AM in the morning for the early shift, for the 10:00 PM night shift, they need to know that this House has got their back. And I'm afraid to say, due to governments of all different stripes over a long period of time, police officers have not felt that. They're all used to politicians saying they support the police and so forth, and we're grateful for that.

But what the police officers really need is it to be borne out in the decision-making and in the actions. So can I just beg the Justice Secretary to bear that in mind in all the decisions he takes in what I hope is a very successful tenure as Justice Secretary?

05:09:05 - 05:09:37

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful to my honourable friend and again I would want to recognise his service. He knows of what he speaks in this area. I am well aware, as I said to my honourable friend, that the eyes of the policing family were on us, and indeed they remain on us. And I would say to them, as I would say to him, for them to judge us by our actions. We want to get to the same place that they want, which is a criminal justice system that isn't running so hot, that isn't meaning that they're having therefore to be dragged away in all sorts of places, particularly recourt.

So we've got lots of work to do, but my commitment is to do it with them.

05:09:37 - 05:10:07

Ashley Peter Fox

Madam Deputy Speaker, the Lord Chancellor will know that a substantial proportion of criminals released under Labour's previous early release scheme have reoffended and are now back in prison. Yet his department refuses to release the exact numbers. So will he commit to releasing this data and release data going forward on the new cohort of early release criminals who reoffend, so that in this House we can judge the success of his policies or otherwise?

05:10:07 - 05:10:24

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Well, I always enjoy fulsome debate on the statistics. He will know that the MOJ produces a wide range of statistics quarterly, will continue to do so. He's made an important suggestion there that I'll of course have a look at, but it's really important that the public has the fullest amount of information for the best public conversation.

05:10:24 - 05:11:01

Speaker 253

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I echo the Secretary of State's statement today, and I'm grateful that he's worked really hard to exempt more crimes such as rapists and child sex offenders. But the VAWG sector is clear, VAWG, that violence against women perpetrators should not be included in the early release scheme. And I know how difficult this is because the party opposite has left us a complete mess to clear up. And I know that Welsh Women's Aid are really grateful that the victims' fund has just been announced and that will help them look after victims. But could the Secretary of State reassure me that any survivor will not be harmed as a result of these releases?

05:11:01 - 05:11:53

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I recognise the vigour and the spirit with which my honourable friend asks that question and indeed with the voice that she gives to a sector that's very concerned about these changes. And I would want to recognise that we wanted to go further than this. So our commitment in being unable to do so, what we're doing to close that gap is as she says, bringing more support forward to make sure that there is that direct support, whether it's the victims' hotline or through the important work that the local sector does in a community level. But also the test it seems to me for us to pass and for us to prove to victims is that that process of engagement, getting quality information to people at the right time and then designing the controls on perpetrators is the best thing we can do to seek to close that gap.

And again, I appreciate there's a burden of proof on us to demonstrate that we do that.

05:11:53 - 05:12:01

Judith Cummins

To help me get every member in, questions must be just one sentence. Caroline Voaden.

05:12:01 - 05:12:28

Caroline Jane Voaden

Prison governors talk about the revolving door of prisoners. Almost half reoffend. I'm going to say this in one breath. Those who go through the Landworks rehabilitation project in South Devon reoffend at a rate of 5%. 90% of them go into employment, go back into the community.

It's proven, it's a success, it works. Please, will the new prisons minister come to South Devon and come and see Landworks? It's magic. See what they do. It's cheaper than prison, it works, and we need to roll this out across the country.

05:12:28 - 05:12:30

James Timpson

She's very much looking forward to doing so.

05:12:30 - 05:12:32

Judith Cummins

Philip Siddiq.

05:12:32 - 05:12:53

Speaker 258

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and happy birthday. I thank the Secretary of State for his statement. I believe officials would have told the Secretary of State a date or a timeline for when the current prison system will reach full capacity. Could I ask him how that compares to the previous assessment?

05:12:53 - 05:13:27

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Well, I know that as pretty much every Lord Chancellor for a number of years now, the first thing in my inbox on day one was a note saying, by the way, we're going to run out of prison places in November. What I'm pleased to say is that as a result of changes built by my immediate two predecessors, the Sentencing Act improves that saturation date into the future, comfortably into the future. And where we are on that will be set out when we publish our capacity report later this year. But my commitment is to go much further. The colleagues have heard the Prime Minister say that he wants us to take a 10-year arc of these things, and the same is true for prison capacity.

05:13:27 - 05:13:28

Liz Saville Roberts.

05:13:28 - 05:13:52

Liz Roberts

Diolch, Madam Llefarydd. The government tells us restriction zones will keep people safe, but victims need to see the small print to believe this, especially after the warnings in July's National Audit Office into tagging. So could you tell me, if an offender leaves a restriction zone, what guarantee can he give that the GPS system will warn police and probation officers so they can act to keep victims safe in real time?

05:13:52 - 05:14:22

Alexander James Jordan Norris

But tagging is exceptionally important and as, you know, the technology is improving as is the compliance with the contract. Similarly, there are changes that we are making as part of this process. The presumption of tagging eliminates a point of failure. Also tagging in prisons, a pilot that is developing, again reduces a point of failure. But I appreciate the substance of her point, that we have to demonstrate to those who are interested in this space that this big commitment is one that is impactful.

That's why I've made the commitment I have to have that challenge work with those who care about this to demonstrate what we're doing.

05:14:22 - 05:14:23

George Freeman.

05:14:23 - 05:14:57

Jonathan Brash

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Terry Rowley has received an IPP sentence on the 8th of February 2008 with a minimum tariff of one year and 126 days. That was 6,780 days ago, more than 18 and a half years, and he remains in prison. The government has rightly committed to end this injustice, but will the Justice Secretary ensure that as we do so, people like Terry have a fair, transparent, and genuinely rehabilitative route to release while continuing to protect the public?

05:14:57 - 05:15:27

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I totally agree with that. I mean, it is worth reflecting and pausing and reflecting on what the honourable gentleman's just said. Someone who went to prison for one and a half year sentence who is still there 18 and a half years later. There should be discomfort from all of us about that status. So it is right that for those who perhaps are on that journey and passing Parole Board processes that we put the best possible support in place for them to sustain their release from prison, and that we look at for those who are not, the way that we bring IPP to its close.

And I'm committed to working with colleagues to do so.

05:15:28 - 05:15:54

Ian Sollom

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I welcome the Lord Chancellor announcing investment into the probation service. But will he lay out specifically what the government's doing to fix the vetting delays and the staff attrition problems that have kept level broadly stable despite previous investment in funding?

And would he also commit to a date by which Cambridgeshire and Peterborough will exit prioritisation?

05:15:54 - 05:16:19

Alexander James Jordan Norris

The honourable gentleman makes a very important point around vetting, and you know, I heard from probation frontline leaders about cases where it's taken them the thick end of a year and the attrition that that has as people go and get other jobs. We don't want to see that happening. Vetting must be done properly, but my honourable friend, the Prisons Minister, and myself are working with the Cabinet Office to improve that. On the specific point around Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, I'll revert directly to him.

05:16:19 - 05:16:21

Judith Cummins

Rachel Maskell.

05:16:21 - 05:16:48

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's crucial that conditions are followed on release. However, automatic recall often means that people who miss a probation appointment then end up in prison, often for months on end. So will he look at the recall processes to make sure it's fair and equitable, and that if people do err on what their conditions are, that there is more work outside of prison to support that person rather than bring them back into custody?

05:16:48 - 05:17:30

Alexander James Jordan Norris

My honourable friend makes a really important point, and I think it would be a point of unanimity across this place that say if an individual out on licence went and contacted their victim, we would expect that that is a significant transgression that would have the most significant response. Similarly, breaching their conditions flagrantly and clearly deliberately. There is an element, you know, I have said I don't think this is happening widely, but I would want to recognise it in the spirit the honourable lady says around things that non-compliances that are more technical. Now, I would defend strongly people must turn up to the meetings they're expected to, but you know, she asks whether I will of course look at it, and of course we will, because we want it to be an effective recall system.

05:17:30 - 05:17:31

Jess Asquith.

05:17:31 - 05:18:02

Janet Jessica Daby

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I'm sure the Lord Chancellor is aware that it is estimated that 20% of the prison population is young people or adults that have previously been in care or indeed care leavers. So I just wish to ask the Lord Chancellor if he will take a leading role to work across government to make sure these preventative measures in place to stop and to prevent care-experienced people coming into the prison, but also where they are in prison, that they will make sure that they have the necessary support that they need to make sure they do not return. Thank you.

05:18:02 - 05:18:29

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I absolutely agree with that, and I've been having the conversation with my right honourable friend, the Secretary of State for Education, very recently on this point. I always took very seriously as a local councillor the role of corporate parent, and that those children in our care, we were their parents in law, but also in substance as well, and that we had to give them all of those opportunities to thrive. But as she says, when they are challenged, to help them get out of that and build a more positive path. I think she's exactly right to raise that.

05:18:29 - 05:18:30

Shaun Bailey.

05:18:30 - 05:18:56

Speaker 259

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and happy birthday, a fellow Virgo. I very much welcome the clarity in the Lord Chancellor's statement, but as he will know, on the issue of additional prison capacity, the Prison Officers Association has already raised extreme concerns about understaffing, under-resourcing, risk of extreme violence and overcrowding. What reassurances can he give today that additional resources will be provided to operate these extra spaces safely?

05:18:56 - 05:19:30

Alexander James Jordan Norris

The honourable lady makes an excellent point, and you know, I look forward to having these conversations with the leadership of the POA and the members who do, you know, such a great job. You know, I am really aware of the attrition particularly and the retention challenges of people working in our prison system because the estate runs hot. So what we're doing here is exactly in service of making it a better place to work, so they're not having to administer a system that is tense and is, you know, running on its margins all the time. By deflating it in the ways that I've talked about, that helps us build a more stable regime and I think a better place to work.

05:19:30 - 05:19:55

Joshua Fenton-Glynn

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We know these decisions aren't easy and they reflect the state that the system was left in. But I do have concerns, and charities have raised concerns, about domestic abuse survivors because perpetrators are going to be let out as early as next month. It's clear that we need to do more to support these victims. So can the Minister please tell me what services will be put in place to make sure that there is adequate support for victims of domestic abuse whose perpetrators are being released?

05:19:55 - 05:20:23

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful for that question and as I've said to other colleagues, I think that this is an important thing that we demonstrate. He'll have heard what I've said about bringing the helpline forward. He will have heard also about what I've said for support for local organisations to help support survivors through difficult periods. But also the critical thing is that really high-quality engagement with the victim liaison officer so those individuals have certainty about what's happening and can help design controls around their perpetrator.

05:20:23 - 05:20:46

Speaker 266

Probation officers and their trade unions have expressed concern about the proposed removal of the workforce measurement tool used to ensure staff caseloads are at safe levels, and no date has been set for a replacement. What assessment has the Secretary of State made of the capacity of the probation services to manage rising caseloads safely, and when will the new platform be delivered before the current one is decommissioned?

05:20:46 - 05:21:16

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm very grateful for the chance to kind of address this. That system's coming to an end because it's 15 years old. You know, it is right that we address that. I want across the probation service to have much better tech enablement. You know, I was meeting staff hearing about the importance that actually AI transcription is being able to have in terms of reducing their paperwork workload.

We of course want to have effective workload management tools in place and that's what myself and my honourable friend are working closely on as we move to the new model.

05:21:16 - 05:21:41

John Martin McDonnell

Can I thank my honourable friend for addressing the, well, grasping the nettle of IPP prisoners, and remind the House that it was Bob Neill, the Conservative chair of the Justice Select Committee, who built consensus on that committee, brought forward a report to urge the government to act and set up a number of proposals. I see Bob's name is not on the list of advisors that the Secretary of State has mentioned. It would be useful having him on board, I believe.

05:21:41 - 05:22:02

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I'm grateful to my right honourable friend. I will be in touch with Bob. I, you know, we do not intend for this to be a long, drawn-out process. We want to build from the best evidence that's available and from those who've been active in this space. And I certainly will make sure I contact Bob, I, you know, remember him very fondly from his time in this place to see how he can help us in this process.

05:22:02 - 05:22:37

Liz Twist

The Secretary of State will be aware of my constituents Gemma Tapple and Rachel Walls, the great-aunts of baby Mayor, who was, who died at the hands of her mother's partner. Can I thank him and the Prime Minister for reviewing the early release scheme so that Mayor's mother, who was scheduled for early release this month, will not now be included in this scheme? And can I commend him for his proposals explained today to increase accommodation? And can he say how victims will be supported in the future to ensure that they have a good outcome?

05:22:37 - 05:23:06

Alexander James Jordan Norris

The honourable lady raised directly with myself and colleagues that appalling case which, when it came into public attention, rightly sickened I think everybody who saw it. I'm pleased we've been able to make the change that we have, but again would recognise the impact of the uncertainty across the summer. On the point on victim support, it's about that, you know, really high-quality engagement through victim liaison officers as well as access to local support services that we are augmenting our funding for and also the victims' helpline.

05:23:06 - 05:23:29

Speaker 264

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Lord Chancellor for his focus on victims in today's statement. Some of the most harrowing conversations I've had as an MP have been with victims and survivors and the impact of the failures in the tagging system it's had on them, re-traumatising them again and again after.

Can he explain to my constituents what the impact of the new restriction zones will have on them and their experience of the criminal justice system going forward?

05:23:29 - 05:23:59

Alexander James Jordan Norris

It's a really significant change. You know, this and this isn't just about restriction zones about what I'm about to say, but it is really important I say, I think, what I'm about to say. Traditionally, victims and survivors have lived their life around the license conditions of their perpetrator. We need to flip that and restriction zones give us that chance. My right honorable friend the Home Secretary is here, which is very helpful because she built this system out and that is the change that we want to see to make sure victims are living full lives.

05:23:59 - 05:24:01

Judith Cummins

Sarah Russell.

05:24:01 - 05:24:45

Sarah Russell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Lord Chancellor, you have inherited an absolute mess in terms of the prisons and I feel heart sorry for you trying to balance the needs of victims with the needs for justice and the ability to actually manage the prison estate in a meaningful way. In terms of exclusion zones, they could be absolutely transformative in terms of the ability for victims to live their lives going forward. But that is contingent on the tagging service being effective. And at the moment, I think that people would assume, and particularly victims would assume, that if someone breaches their tag restriction zone, that their probation officer would at the very least be automatically informed of that point.

But the IT doesn't function in that way. So when will that be in place?

05:24:45 - 05:25:11

Alexander James Jordan Norris

Well, the technology is rapidly improving, as I say, as is compliance. There are other points of failure, such as people not getting tags. That's why I think that presumption helps, as does tagging at prison. You know, I was with staff on Friday. I indeed I was tagged, as colleagues may have seen.

And I have to say, it worked very effectively in that case. But we are absolutely resolute that it must work. And and that's why we're putting the effort and the investment in that we are.

05:25:11 - 05:25:13

Judith Cummins

Final question, Amanda Martin.

05:25:13 - 05:25:38

Amanda Martin

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Lord Chancellor's statement and the changes and I know victims have been at the heart and the forefront of his and the Prime Minister's mind. Families like Chloe Hollands and Skye Nichols have seen the devastating consequences of domestic abuse. So can I ask the Lord Chancellor how these and future change will better protect victims, ensure the psychological harm caused by domestic abuse and particularly coercive control is properly recognized?

05:25:38 - 05:26:08

Alexander James Jordan Norris

I mean, I I you know, I really recognize the importance of of that question. And indeed the anxiety caused by survivors caused for survivors of domestic abuse as a result of these changes. You know, we need that clearer earlier flagging. That's been something that's been lacking and that we're resolute in adding. But also, as I say, that importance of extra support brought sooner and more investment into it, but a really good engagement with victim liaison officers so they know exactly, the victim and survivor knows exactly what's going to happen with their perpetrator and can shape the controls on them.

05:26:08 - 05:27:26

Judith Cummins

End of the statement on the criminal justice reform. I'll give the front benches a moment or two to shuffle over. Minister, if you're ready. No, forgive me. I was just marvelous.

Before I call the Secretary of State, I have a statement to make. Before we come to the statement on Cleveland policing, I should inform the House that charges have been brought against a number of individuals in relation to the fatal collision on the A66 and the house fire in Grangetown. Those cases are now sub judice. Mr. Speaker is granting a full waiver for today and future proceedings to enable discussion on support for the victims and wider issues concern raised in the context of these incidents. However, I must urge members not to discuss the details of any individual case.

This includes not discussing any motive or the guilt or innocence of any individual. Members should avoid wider speculation that could be prejudicial in any future criminal trials.

I call the Secretary of State.

05:27:26 - 05:35:08

Yvette Cooper

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. With your permission, I will make a statement about the fatal crash near Middlesbrough on the 22nd of August and the death of two brave police officers that day, Police Constable Matthew Blades and Police Constable Tom Clough. It is a most humbling duty of any Home Secretary to oversee the work of our police forces and the thousands who serve in them. That is never more true than on a day like today, when we honour those who have fallen in the line of duty, those who lost their lives as they sought to protect us all. The detail of what happened will by now be well known to most in this House and beyond it, but it is right to begin by recounting the facts.

At 3:39 on the morning of Saturday the 22nd of August, a Volkswagen Passat containing five young men was travelling the wrong way down the A66. As it did so, it collided with a marked Cleveland Police armed response vehicle. This police car was, I should add, travelling on the correct side of the road. A significant emergency response was deployed, and I must pay tribute to all the first responders who attended the scene and worked in extremely difficult circumstances. Despite their best efforts, PC Blades and PC Clough both died as a result of the collision, as did the five individuals who were driving on the wrong side of the road.

Madam Deputy Speaker, following such an incident, it is mandatory that a referral is made to the Independent Office for Police Conduct. That has happened in this case, and the IOPC has begun an independent investigation. On the 23rd of August, they issued an update which I will now summarize. Prior to the crash, Cleveland Police received intelligence regarding numerous incidents linked to a Volkswagen Passat. The Passat was later sighted and an armed response vehicle began a pursuit.

The pursuit lasted just under seven minutes before the Passat crossed over to the wrong side of the A66. At that point, the pursuit was aborted by officers who continued to travel on the correct side of the carriageway. However, around 10 seconds later, the Passat collided with a police vehicle which was not involved in the pursuit but was in the area to assist in the search. That car contained Police Constables Blades and Clough. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is an ongoing investigation, so we must heed the request of those best placed to examine the circumstances of this awful incident by avoiding speculation and giving them the time and space they need to carry out their vital work.

Significant police activity has followed the crash. Some 27 arrests have been made as part of a wide-scale investigation into suspected serious and organized crime. There are limits on what can be said publicly at this stage, but both the IOPC and Cleveland Police have my full backing in their respective tasks. Members may be aware that Cleveland Police has also been investigating a house fire in Grangetown, in which two people died, including, tragically, a child. It should be noted that the force is not treating this as connected in any way to the A66 crash.

However, it has undoubtedly added to the sense of disquiet in a community already reeling from that earlier tragedy. Many in this House and across the country will also have been troubled by the scenes in County Durham, where a number of vehicles were set on fire at a memorial for one of the occupants of the Passat. I recognize how unnerving it will have been for law-abiding citizens, both in the affected areas and beyond, to see a spate of incidents in close proximity and in quick succession. Let me therefore assert once more: lawlessness of any kind will never be tolerated, and this government stands squarely behind the police as they face down criminality and disorder on our streets. Madam Deputy Speaker, this government is supporting the police in word and deed.

Cleveland Police, like all forces, is receiving a real-terms uplift this year, taking its total funding to 197.8 million pounds, an increase of 7 million pounds compared to 2025-26.

Clearly, the events of recent days have placed exceptional pressure on Cleveland Police, and I can confirm today that the force has received additional resource under mutual aid arrangements, which has seen officers deployed to Cleveland from around the region. I would like to thank those forces and personnel who have stepped up and taken on this additional work. I can also announce today that in light of the situation the force has faced, we will allocate an additional 2 million pounds to Cleveland Police to tackle serious crime in the area. This will build on existing operations, including the clear, hold, build approach, which is both tough on serious crime and on the causes of serious crime, and has been shown to work across the country. In addition, as I have said before, we are committed to a wider review of the police funding formula to ensure force funding is fair and keeps the public safe.

A new approach to allocating funding will be brought in as part of our reforms to police structures. In the meantime, the government will continue to work closely with Cleveland Police to ensure that they have all the support they need as they face these challenging circumstances and grieve the loss of two of their own. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me end by paying tribute to those two men, PC Blades and PC Clough, devoted their lives to the noblest form of public service, protecting their fellow citizens. In remembering them, we hold in our hearts those they leave behind, above all, their family and all those who love them. I think also of their colleagues in uniform, not just in Cleveland, but across policing, who have lost friends and colleagues and fellow members of the policing family.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this tragedy speaks to an enduring truth: policing is not just a profession, it is a calling, answered only by those who are willing to place themselves in harm's way to protect us all. PC Blades and PC Clough epitomised that courage. At 37 and 38, they were no age at all, but in their all too brief lives, they gave so much. An extraordinary number of tributes have poured in, but I think we must leave the final words to their families, who knew them best and loved them most. PC Blades' wife remembers a beloved husband and the most devoted father to their two young boys.

She said, and I quote, "He was loved beyond words by all his family and friends, and his loss has left a space that can never be filled. He gave his life in the line of duty, protecting and serving others with courage, dedication, and selflessness." PC Clough's family describe him as their hero. They remember his fantastic sense of humour and pay tribute to a man who jumped into action whenever needed, and who was always on public duty throughout his all too short life. Madam Deputy Speaker, a death in the line of duty is a moment of profound national sorrow, but our public loss is a fraction of the private and personal tragedy for these two families.

So across this House, let us offer them our love, support, and prayers. Let us never forget who those two brave men were and how much they meant to those who loved them. For all they did and all they gave, PC Blades and PC Clough were the very best of us, and today we remember them. And I commend this statement to the House.

05:35:08 - 05:39:16

Judith Cummins

I call the Shadow Secretary of State, Chris Philp.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Home Secretary for advance sight of her statement. I know the whole House will join the Home Secretary and I in paying tribute to those brave officers tragically killed in the crash on the A66 in the early hours of August the 22nd. Our thoughts are with the families of PCs Matthew Blades and Tom Clough, whose lives were cut short by a car recklessly driven on the wrong side of the road by criminals. Those brave officers made the ultimate sacrifice in the line of duty, and they will never be forgotten. Every day, police officers up and down the country risk their lives to keep us safe, and we owe them all a deep debt of gratitude.

This tragedy has sent shockwaves through Cleveland Police and the public more widely. The Home Secretary has set out some of the steps being taken to support local police, but can she confirm that every request for extra assistance made by Cleveland Police has now been met? In the aftermath of August 22nd, I was shocked to see so-called tributes staged for some of the men directly responsible for PC Blades and Clough's deaths. This included cars being driven dangerously and set on fire. Criminal activity of this kind is wrong in principle and deeply offensive in these circumstances.

Will the Home Secretary join me in condemning this activity and calling on the police to ensure it does not happen again? Madam Deputy Speaker, organised crime was allowed to take hold in whole parts of Middlesbrough. Criminal gangs ran rampant and engaged in retaliatory attacks on one another. Homes and properties were attacked with no consequence and it escalated even further in the days after August 22nd. While it is welcome that 27 people have finally been arrested, this lawless gang chaos should never have been allowed to take root in the first place.

And of course the police need proper resources to stop this. Many campaigners, including my honourable friend the member for Stockton West, a shadow policing minister who I can see in his place, have been raising concerns for some time that there is a multi-million pound shortfall in funding for Cleveland Police in this current financial year. Even the local Labour Police and Crime Commissioner, Matt Storey, said this government's financial settlement this year, and I quote, "completely fails to deliver the resources required to meet the demand faced by Cleveland Police and falls far short of what is needed." So does the Home Secretary accept her own Police and Crime Commissioner's assessment that the funding she put in place for Cleveland Police this year is inadequate? Lawless chaos followed that underfunding and I think the Home Secretary should apologise for that.

The two million pounds just referred to is only 0.5% of Cleveland's budget and is clearly wholly inadequate in the circumstances. Now I'm afraid this reflects a wider national trend that goes beyond just Cleveland. The last government left behind record ever police numbers, but there are now 1,800 fewer police officers under this government. As a result, crime has increased by 10% and ASB has gone up by 15% in just the last year. The Home Secretary must now accept that cutting overall police numbers was a mistake and will she take steps to reverse that decline?

The truth is that only zero tolerance of crime and disorder will ensure it's criminals who are the ones afraid, not the law-abiding public. We've seen the consequence of that with the rampant gangs going unchallenged in Middlesbrough and it's clear now that a zero tolerance approach is required to keep the public safe.

05:39:16 - 05:43:28

Yvette Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, let me first start by saying that at the beginning of his statement, I appreciate the fact that the Shadow Home Secretary paid tribute and gave his condolences to the families of PC Blades and PC Clough.

On that at least there is agreement across this House as to the enormity of their sacrifice and the need to support their family and their friends as they face this loss. Let me say to him on the wider matters that he raises. He has absolutely no credibility, Madam Deputy Speaker, when it comes to police numbers. It was his government that cut police numbers, not by a few thousand here and there, a few hundred, but by 20,000 police officers. They then decided to replace the 20,000 that they cut, but did so in a distortive way that meant that you have warranted police officers working in admin jobs and behind desks across police forces in this country.

The truth is the Tory government made an absolute mess of policing over their time in government. And I've said this many times to the Shadow Home Secretary, it falls on deaf ears, but it remains true and I will keep saying it. He'd have more credibility entering this debate if he fronted up what went wrong under the Tory government and apologized for it. I notice he's got the Shadow Justice Secretary sitting next to him, who was a special adviser to a former Tory Home Secretary. Until there is humility about the mess that the Tories made of our public services and our policing in particular, they have no credibility and I will take no lessons from them.

Especially given that on Cleveland specifically, it was his party who oversaw the loss of over 200 officers in Cleveland itself. It is this government that is righting those wrongs. We have increased funding to policing by 2 billion pounds since being elected, and all forces will receive a real-terms uplift in their funding this year as part of an overall 18.5 billion pound package. Funding to Cleveland has increased by 18.3 million since 2024, and that's a real-terms increase of 4.4% over two years. So that is the truth of what we have had to deal with as an incoming Labour government, and we will not stop until we have our police service functioning exactly as the public would expect.

Let me also say to him on the issue of criminal gangs and the efforts made by Cleveland Police. I don't think it's a fair characterization of that police force to suggest that they've done nothing for all this time and have only sprung into action since this horrifying incident took place. They are of course responding to this incident and those arrests have been made and they will continue, and this government will stand shoulder to shoulder with them as they get control of this matter and control of the streets in Cleveland. That is why we've announced the additional funding today, that is why there are mutual aid arrangements in place to assist them as well. Let me tell him that I do agree with him on the unlawful activity that has been taking place in relation to tributes and memorials for some of those who lost their lives in the crash.

I of course condemn all unlawful activity and all attempts to breed public disorder as a result of what's happened. And again, we stand foursquare behind the police as they respond to those incidents, and people should be in no doubt, any attempts at instigating public order, breaking our laws, will meet the full force of the law and the government will support the police as they carry out that incredibly important work. Madam Deputy Speaker, there will be questions about the ability of the police to respond effectively and to make sure that we are able to give confidence to all of our public about the sort of standard of service that they can expect from their policing. But people in this House should have absolute no doubt, this is a government that has increased funding to policing, is going to make sure that we reform policing so that they are capable of dealing with every type of challenge that a modern force faces, and to have a police service that we can all be absolutely proud of and can rely on in our time of need, and I hope that that is something that all members acting reasonably across this House can unite around.

05:43:28 - 05:43:29

Andy McDonald.

05:43:29 - 05:45:27

Andy McDonald

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I join the Home Secretary in paying tribute to PC Matthew Blaydes and PC Tom Clough. I also pay tribute to all the officers of Cleveland Police who, while grieving the loss of their two colleagues, have continued to serve with extraordinary professionalism, remaining visible in our communities, pursuing offenders and making arrests. My thoughts and those of my Middlesbrough and Thornaby East constituents and everyone across Teesside remain with the families of the officers, their friends and colleagues, as has been magnificently demonstrated by the overwhelming generosity shown in donations to the fund established to support the families of Matthew and Tom, and at the outpouring of love and solidarity at the Riverside Stadium on Saturday, which reflects the decency of the overwhelming majority of people in our communities. But we must confront the reality of crime honestly.

The latest figures show around 123 recorded crimes per 1,000 people across the Cleveland Police force area, the highest rate of any police force in England and Wales. Yet Cleveland has experienced the largest percentage reduction in full-time equivalent officers since 2010, losing around 13% of its officers. Police numbers are not the only factor, but a force facing the highest demand in the country needs the resources to respond. I am truly grateful to my right honourable friend for the financial assistance she's announced for Cleveland today, and that will address the mutual aid bill and some. But I ask that she meet with me and my colleagues to discuss how that deficit in resources can be urgently and permanently corrected.

05:45:27 - 05:46:41

Yvette Cooper

Well, I thank my honourable friend for his remarks. I know how deeply affected he and other parliamentarians who represent the local area have been by what has happened, and I pay tribute to their ability to give voice to what their communities are experiencing. And I particularly agree with him on thanking the officers who are still on duty, who've lost one of their own. They are showing incredible bravery in very difficult circumstances. I'd be very happy to meet with my honourable friend and with other colleagues from neighbouring constituencies to discuss these matters in more detail.

I hope he will take comfort from the additional resourcing that has been announced today. We believe that is important to get on top of the serious and organised crime issues in the area. But of course, we will want to make sure that the force has everything they need in order to respond. But more widely, I would like to discuss with him how this matter makes the case for wider police system reform so that we can make sure we have a service that can respond to local need, but that can also at regional level surge resources into areas that are experiencing particularly high levels of crime as well.

05:46:41 - 05:48:26

Max Wilkinson

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Max Wilkinson.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to join others in extending my sympathies and those of my party to the families and colleagues of PC Matthew Blaydes and PC Tom Clough. My thoughts are with their loved ones at this extremely difficult time. By virtue of my in-laws, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm from a policing family, so I know the shock and grief is being felt in the wider policing community too, and that should be acknowledged today in the chamber. At least one of those killed in the Middlesbrough crash is in multiple videos posted on TikTok depicting dangerous driving.

This is part of a concerning wider trend on social media platforms where lives are being risked in the pursuit of clicks. And we must ask who is benefiting from this? Well, it's some of the world's richest people. They're getting richer off the back of these platforms, which are currently under-regulated, while communities suffer the consequences.

So will the Home Secretary work with the Culture Secretary to strengthen the Online Safety Act so that the glorification of dangerous driving is brought into scope? It is, of course, as others have said, deeply worrying to see the scenes of unrest that have followed this incident. We know that there are national pressures on police resources. So can the Home Secretary tell the House how long mutual aid will continue? And can she say something about the support given to the other forces that are losing resource under mutual aid arrangements?

And given the apparent links, is she confident that her reforms will give police and the National Crime Agency the resources and powers they need to tackle the scourge of organised crime that impacts not only Middlesbrough, but so many communities across our country?

05:48:26 - 05:51:21

Yvette Cooper

Well, I thank the Lib Dem spokesman for his comments and questions. Let me assure him, I'm already discussing the wider issues on social media platforms and content that's posted on them with colleagues across government. He will know this government has been implementing various elements of the Online Safety Act, and from the middle of next year, the wider measures within the Online Safety Act come online, and that will mean that the largest social media platforms, including TikTok, will be under a legal duty to act against harmful content that breaches their terms of service, and that will include content of this nature. In the meantime, most of the platforms are taking this content down. It's a reactive process in the sense that they are responding to content being flagged, and then it has been, for the most part, been removed from their platforms.

But from the middle of next year, that will become a duty upon those platforms to act proactively, not just reactively. But of course, I think as I've said to him before, there are wider questions around the efficacy of the Online Safety Act and whether we need to revisit the measures in that act and go further, given the very unique pressures that some of the content on those platforms pose for law and order and criminal justice more broadly, and those are matters that the government is considering, and other colleagues in the government will come to the House to update in due course. But let me assure him I do work closely with colleagues on the specifics that are being raised by this case. Let me also say to him, on mutual aid, that will continue as long as it's needed by the Chief Constable in Cleveland. But I do think this case does show the need for wider police structural reform.

Cleveland is a relatively small force, and we can see the pressures on a small force that is having to do local neighbourhood policing as well as the sorts of much more specialist investigations that go with organised crime and public order related issues. As I've made clear before, moving to a three-tier system with local forces, regional forces, and then also the new National Police Service, I think puts us in the best possible position to be able to provide a policing service that is able to respond to local issues in the way that local people expect with a very visible local policing presence, give us the flexibility to respond to cases as we've seen in Cleveland across a larger area where you've got the capacity and the numbers that you need in order to deal with public order risk, for example, without having to rely on mutual aid to get through and to survive day by day, and then a National Police Service that can then take up the types of crime that we know are prevalent nationally and then also have an international dimension as well. We will bring forward our proposals on reform later this year, and I look forward to debating those with him and others across this House.

05:51:21 - 05:52:14

Luke Myer

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The whole of Teesside has been shaken by the tragic deaths of PC Tom Clough and PC Matthew Blades last week. And the real Teesside, the one not depicted in the media, is the one that filled out the Riverside with a standing ovation for those two brave officers on Saturday, and that has raised over a million pounds for their families, and that stands with our emergency services every single day. But they need their government to stand with them too. And I'm grateful for the two million pounds extra funding that has been announced today, and the 300 extra officers that have been deployed from across the country to keep our streets safe in the short term.

In the long term, what we need is funding formula reform. So will the Home Secretary bring that forward at pace and ensure that we get the fair funding settlement that Cleveland so desperately needs?

05:52:14 - 05:53:35

Yvette Cooper

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, let me pay tribute to my honourable friend for the way that he has responded to this incident on behalf of his constituents, who I know have been deeply affected, as has he himself. And the outpouring of support for the families of PC Blades and PC Clough, I think, is a real testament to the people that he represents. Let me assure him on ensuring that the government proceeds with its planned review on the funding formula. As we change police force structures, the necessity of changing the formula, the case for that is also made out.

You couldn't keep the same funding formula with a new policing system in any case. I say that to him to assure him that both reviewing and then reforming the police funding formula is absolutely critical to the program of police reform. We know that the previous government over 14 years on many occasions promised reform of the funding formula, but then also ducked that reform at every opportunity. The move to a new structure for policing in this country provides the best opportunity to also then re-look at funding. And let me really reassure him that is absolutely on the agenda, and we will be updating the House on the timetable for that once the independent review on police force structures has been completed and presented to the House.

05:53:35 - 05:53:37

Speaker 273

Matt Vickers.

05:53:37 - 05:54:24

Matt Vickers

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As a local member, may I pay tribute to PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough, and to every police officer who's worked tirelessly throughout these horrific and tragic events. Our thoughts remain with their family and colleagues. Despite having the highest crime rate in the country, Cleveland received the lowest increase in funding, with our local Labour PCC warning of a 2.4 million pound shortfall. I very much welcome the mutual aid and the funding announced, but will the Home Secretary guarantee that the new funding formula will properly reflect the pressures of serious and organised crime faced by Cleveland, so this funding does not prove merely a sticking plaster?

05:54:24 - 05:55:48

Yvette Cooper

Well, Madam Deputy Speaker, I know the honourable gentleman is also a local member and he is taking the opportunity to ask a question from the backbenches to reflect his local interest. I just want to pay tribute to him as well for his response to this incident and the wider pressures in his local area. Let me assure him that when we begin the work on reforming the funding formula, we will start with a first principles approach of what we are seeking to achieve, and that will include broader issues on demand for policing and reflect the reality of what policing different areas looks like. In the new police force structure, of course, a new regional force model that is big enough to be able to surge capacity to local areas when required will give the flexibility to make sure that forces are not condemned to permanently relying on mutual aid, which is to the credit of the policing system that people step up and do what is required to keep their areas safe. But nobody could argue that that is the right way to run policing in our country in the 21st century.

It does need, desperately does need reform. Most of the policing system leaders recognise that the structure needs reform, and funding reform will therefore flow as a result of that. I can assure him of that. And the first phase of consulting on funding reform will be on the first principles of what the funding is for and how to reflect the needs of different areas.

05:55:48 - 05:57:02

Jonathan Brash

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I join with the Home Secretary and indeed the whole House in paying tribute to PC Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough and sending our heartfelt condolences to their families and loved ones. Matthew was a coach at my son's football club, FC Hartlepool, as well as at Seaton Carew FC, and both teams played each other last Saturday where I was proud to join with so many other Poolies in paying tribute to a remarkable man so loved by everyone who knew him. And I would also pay tribute to our police and all emergency services who I know are getting up every single day grief-stricken at the loss of their two colleagues but still doing their job to an amazing extent. Madam Deputy Speaker, these tragic events did not materialize out of the blue. The lawlessness that we are seeing in certain parts of our communities did not happen overnight.

It is the consequence of systemic underfunding for our police and may I also say for our fire service. So I welcome the two million pounds announced by the Home Secretary today, but does she agree, and I join with my colleagues in saying this, we need a long-term solution to fix the funding formula both for our police and our fire service if we are to protect all of our communities, and I hope that she's sincere in ensuring that happens.

05:57:02 - 05:58:35

Yvette Cooper

Well, let me thank my honorable friend and also pay tribute to his work in providing reassurance to his local community. And I know it's particularly difficult when you have a personal connection to somebody who has lost their lives in these circumstances. And so I just want to pay tribute to my honorable friend for the work he's doing in what are obviously very difficult circumstances for local representatives and also obviously all members of our emergency services in the area. Let me just reassure him that the work that we are going to be doing on police funding is a very real part of the wider police reform program. And I hope that when we discuss these matters, as I know we will when I meet local members of Parliament for the area, we're able to see how this fits in with a wider program of police reform.

As I say, this incident in a very horrific way does show why we need to reform policing structures so that we have the right level of policing in each of our areas such that we can respond to everything from shop theft, anti-social behavior on our high streets, make sure that we can deal with localized organized and serious crime, and then also make sure that specialist investigation and public order are not things that are left to be looked after by mutual aid arrangements. So the case for reform I believe is made out, and as a necessary part of that reform we will of course be looking at the funding formula, and I look forward to discussing that with him very soon.

05:58:35 - 05:59:40

Lewis Atkinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The deaths of PCs Matthew Blades and PC Tom Clough have of course been felt acutely in Cleveland but also more widely across the whole of the North East and the policing family in it. And I can pay tribute to colleagues across the House and also the right honorable lady for Redcar who I think has spoken with dignity as a local representative in light of those terrible events. The officers, some of the officers stepping forward to provide mutual aid from neighboring forces the Home Secretary refers to, including Northumbria, Durham and others, and unfortunately the sad reality is of the four forces that had the highest fall in officer numbers from 2015, three of them are the North East's forces. So I think that makes the point that the Home Secretary is making about the need for fundamental change in the funding formula.

So as she does that, but those officers are despite the cuts putting themselves back into duty, providing mutual aid, whatever, at enormous personal cost to themselves.

So as she reviews the funding formula, will she also agree with me that officers need ongoing access to wellbeing and mental health support to help them respond to communities as they have been?

05:59:40 - 06:01:39

Yvette Cooper

My honorable friend makes an incredibly important point and let me assure him that the usual arrangements on the engagement of the National Police Wellbeing Service have been activated and support is being provided and we will obviously monitor that to make sure that that is adequate and can rise to the challenge of what we are seeing in Cleveland. It's an incredibly important point because, you know, police officers are human beings at the end of the day and they are still running towards danger, working very long hours, helping people in their local community, but they do need support. And when you've lost two of your own in such terrible, terrible circumstances, the case for that support is more than made out. It is being provided, but the Policing Minister will be making sure that she continues to talk to the Chief Constable and others to make sure that our officers are being supported and looked after. I absolutely agree with him on the need for fundamental change in the way that we do the funding formula for policing, but also that is tied to the fundamental change that we need on police force structures as well.

He will know Cleveland is a force of about 1500, even before the cuts under the Conservative government it was around 1700 officers. That is very different to a force such as mine in the West Midlands which is 6000 officers or Greater Manchester which is around 8000 officers. We have a system that is very lopsided in terms of police force sizes, but more importantly the size of officers that you have in each of those forces and that does limit what some of the smaller forces can sometimes do without needing mutual aid to support them. So there is a case here for structural reform, but done in a way that makes sure that the public can have absolute confidence that their local forces in future will be highly focused on local issues, regional forces able to handle the specialist investigations and public order issues that we're seeing made out in a case like this and then the National Police Service on top of that as well. And I look forward to discussing those issues with him as I know we will because he's a member of the Home Affairs Select Committee.

06:01:39 - 06:01:41

Speaker 274

Jim Dickson.

06:01:41 - 06:02:53

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I thank the Home Secretary for her statement and I want to echo her words about the two brave police officers who lost their lives in this incident in the collision on the A66. My constituency in Dartford has experienced very similar, deeply anti-social and incredibly dangerous experiences of racing and speeding on our roads, groups of predominantly young men gathering along our main roads, watching cars speeding down those busy roads as content is filmed to be posted on social media. We had a particularly bad spike and hotspot over this weekend in a stretch of road called Bob Dunn Way next to the Bridge Estate and I want to thank local people who have raised this with me and BBC South East who have highlighted the problem. This activity is clearly dangerous for other road users but really disruptive for local residents. So would the Home Secretary agree with me that we must do absolutely everything we can to tackle this lawlessness on our roads and the social media trends that appear to be driving it?

06:02:53 - 06:03:47

Yvette Cooper

Well, I thank my honorable friend for raising his constituency matter which has some of the same issues as we've seen in Cleveland. I see the same in parts of Birmingham as well. He's absolutely right that we have to do everything we can to clamp down on this emerging pattern of behavior that glorifies this type of activity that can lead to incredibly dangerous situations on our roads. As I said in response to an earlier question, in admittedly a reactive way, social media platforms are taking down the content that is being flagged with them and I would urge him to make sure he shares with those platforms directly but also through the Home Office any local examples that he has as well so that we can make sure that is taken down. And as the wider measures in the Online Safety Act are implemented, we can expect the platforms to take a much more proactive position on this so that we can stop this trend in its tracks.

06:03:47 - 06:04:17

Speaker 286

Can I thank the Home Secretary for her statement this evening? I will allow a couple of moments for the front bench to swap over. Brings us to presentation of bill, Mr. Richard Holden.

06:04:17 - 06:04:22

John Richard Holden

Vehicle Emissions Trading Schemes Order 2023 Revocation Bill.

06:04:22 - 06:04:24

Speaker 277

Second reading what day?

06:04:24 - 06:04:27

Speaker 284

Friday the 15th of January.

06:04:27 - 06:04:36

Speaker 278

Friday the 15th of January 2027. Presentation of bill, Lisa Smart.

06:04:36 - 06:04:39

Lisa Smart

Greyhound Racing Bill.

06:04:39 - 06:04:41

Speaker 283

Second reading what day?

06:04:41 - 06:04:44

Speaker 279

Friday the 19th of March 2027.

06:04:44 - 06:04:56

Speaker 278

Friday the 19th of March 2027. Which brings us to the ten minute rule motion, Adam Jogee.

06:04:56 - 06:13:48

Adam Jogee

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's good to be back. I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill that would require local authorities in England to prepare and publish a road safety plan in respect of each school in their area and for connected purposes. The reasons behind my road safety plans bill and my bringing it to the House this evening are due to the events of December 2025 in Madeley Heath in the northern part of my constituency. A local dad was walking his daughter to Meadows Primary School not far from their home and on this fateful day was struck down by a reckless and speeding driver. That's what this bill is about today, Madam Deputy Speaker.

We are here to demand action and to ensure that those responsible, in our case Staffordshire County Council, get on with actually doing something rather than more on occasion warm weasel words about understanding the problems. Newcastle-under-Lyme is home to many brilliant schools, from Meadows Primary School to St. Wulstan's in Wolstanton to Hassell Street Primary where I was outside yesterday with Labour's candidate in the town by-election scheduled for October the 8th, Andrew Fox-Hewitt, who went to that school back in the day, Madam Deputy Speaker, up to Churchfields in Chesterton, St. Mary's on Silverdale Road and of course May Bank Infants. All excellent schools, all returning to school this week and all would be safer if the provisions of my bill became law. This is important, Madam Deputy Speaker, because no child, no parent, no carer, nobody in Newcastle-under-Lyme or anywhere else in England should be at risk of injury, serious injury or indeed death when on the journey to school in the morning or from school in the afternoon. And whilst we will all agree that no one should be at risk of losing a loved one or should be pushed to or should be forced to push a child out of harm's way or indeed be at risk themselves, we've seen far too many close calls in Newcastle-under-Lyme.

And since my election to this place, I've heard countless reports from local people back home of serious incidents on our roads, whether that is the continuing speeding on Hambridge Avenue that's seen near misses for humans and family pets killed by reckless drivers, to concerns from a number of local people about speeding along Basford Park Road and Silverdale Road. Not to mention the disgraceful boy racers who wreak havoc up and down the A34 and in the car parks of neighboring hotels. Or indeed the junction at Bowsey Wood Road where there was a recent fatality and of course the incident at Meadows Primary School back in December 2025. Dangerous driving, boy racers and the associated impact are the very worst forms of anti-social behavior. My constituents have had enough of this anti-social behavior, Madam Deputy Speaker, and they want it sorted.

Just a few days ago I was copied into an email from a constituent of mine that was sent to Staffordshire County Council. I want to share a few of the sentences from that email with the House. The community, and I quote, has established a community speed watch group with volunteers dedicating their own time to conduct numerous monitoring sessions. More than 10,000 vehicles have been observed. Police presence was recommended by the council as the primary and short-term solution.

However, it has not proved to be a readily available option. Nevertheless, as previously stated, police presence cannot be considered a suitable substitute for a permanent solution, such as the provision of a pedestrian crossing. In light of the above, and I continue to quote, Madam Deputy Speaker, we would be grateful for a clear update from Staffordshire County Council on the current position and in particular whether any specific road safety measures have now been identified for the A525-A531 junction. The local community remains committed to working constructively with Staffordshire County Council and relevant partners to find a lasting solution. I couldn't put that better myself, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'm grateful to my constituent Susanna for her tenacity and to Carol, Rebecca, Louise and another of my constituents, Jill Whitmore, who has been a lollipop lady outside Meadows Primary School for many years and sits on the borough council.

These brilliant campaigners had me out on a cold, wet morning earlier this year. It was raining cats and dogs, Madam Deputy Speaker, although I think I at the time used other words, and it was clear from being with them that morning that the junction at Meadows Primary School is not safe nor is it fit for purpose. They have together in all weathers campaigned hard and demanded action from the county council and the police to do more to stop speeding drivers and to keep our community safe. That's why this bill is so important and so timely, not just in my community back in Newcastle-under-Lyme but right across England, Madam Deputy Speaker. I've repeatedly called out Staffordshire County Council for failing, or falling and failing, falling short and failing on their duty to get a grip of the situation and to finally install the necessary traffic calming measures.

And whilst we wait for the county council and its leadership to wake up, there continues to be what feels like near misses every day. This bill would mean the council has no excuses. Now I know that members of the county council like to watch my speeches, Madam Deputy Speaker, and so I hope they are watching this one and that they get up from their desks and get on with doing whatever's needed to make our roads safe. We can start at that by ensuring that journeys to and from school are made safe, but it doesn't stop at that. At my coffee morning, or one of my coffee mornings in the summer, I met a constituent of mine, Madam Deputy Speaker, a 97-year-old man in very, very good shape indeed, who came along to the church hall at St Werburgh's in Clayton.

And he noted the speeding along Dartmouth Avenue outside the library and the medical centre on Kingsbridge. Now my constituent told me he's almost been knocked down several times and has seen families with small children in similar situations. So whilst my bill starts with schools and making the school journey a better experience for all those concerned, let it be a catalyst for safer roads, Madam Deputy Speaker, in Newcastle-under-Lyme and right across the country. There were 160 casualties in Newcastle-under-Lyme alone last year, Madam Deputy Speaker, including two fatalities. The case for my bill is made by those statistics and the many, many families who are impacted by dangerous driving, by speeding and criminality, because this is a crime and we need to tackle it.

I'm proud that this Labour government has made some vital progress on road safety since the election of July 2024 and I welcome the publication of the first road safety strategy in over a decade earlier this year. And I'm particularly grateful to the excellent Minister for Road Safety, my honourable friend from Nottingham South, for her engagement with me on issues of road safety in Newcastle-under-Lyme and for speaking to me about my bill before the summer recess. Staffordshire County Council, if I may say, Madam Deputy Speaker, could learn a thing or two from the Minister, because I'm sick and tired of receiving responses that tell me the councillor for the division will look at my request for action, but to date no county councillor has properly stepped up to be counted. Reviews, investigations, empty words and broken promises are all well and good, but they're boring. We need action and we need a comprehensive approach, not a ward-by-ward attempt at a solution.

My bill will help make that so. It forces those who dither and delay to fix up and look sharp. I know that that applies to councils across the nation.

Now, whilst accidents outside our schools often result from small, careless mistakes, the very worst consequences are felt for the rest of the lives of those impacted. So as I bring this bill before the House today, my thoughts are with all those in Newcastle-under-Lyme and beyond who have lost a loved one or suffered an injury on one of our roads. By backing this bill, we can make our road networks, specifically those surrounding our schools, safer for pupils, parents, and teachers. School entrances should be amongst the safest crossing points for pedestrians in our communities. My bill is about ensuring that everyone in Newcastle-under-Lyme and across England feels safe on their journey to school and back home by mandating all local authorities to develop and implement a bespoke road safety plan for every school in England.

What a good idea, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like people in my community and across the country, I know exactly where the problems lie, as do those who walk these journeys every day. And listening to those who share those experiences is important if we want to ensure that every child can make that journey between their home and school safely. But we should not have to rely on the hard work of local campaigners to fight for change, or be waiting around for another serious accident before action is taken. As each and every school in England is nestled in different communities with different road networks, the existing macro approach to school road safety just hasn't worked.

It's missed the concerns and challenges that children, parents, and teachers face in different locations. One size clearly does not fit all, and that's why my bill will provide local authorities with a mandate to take action to address specific problem areas. Dangerous crossings, speeding vehicles, and blind spots all contribute to these near misses, and they need to be targeted on a case-by-case basis by proactive local authorities. My bill sets out a local-first approach, designing plans that respond to the concerns and experiences of local people who know their areas best. Every child and every parent and carer deserves to walk to school safely without living in fear that they may not make it to the school gates.

And the same goes for the end of the school day. Every teacher should also be able to expect their pupils to arrive safely for a full day of learning and to come back the next morning. And no member of this House should be forced to come to the House with a bill like this again. I hope the Road Safety Plans Bill and its aims find swift and productive support. I look forward to working with one and all to keep people safe on their way to and from school, Madam Deputy Speaker.

It isn't difficult or controversial, but it's vital. So let's get on with it, because our children and their families in Newcastle-under-Lyme and across England deserve nothing less.

06:13:48 - 06:14:03

Speaker 278

The question is that the honorable member have leave to bring in the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

Who will prepare and bring in the bill?

06:14:03 - 06:14:43

Adam Jogee

Anna Dixon, Callum Anderson, Dame Karen Bradley, Mrs. Elsie Blundell, Sarah Russell, Dr. Al Pinkerton, Lee Ingham, Simon Hall, Dr. Allison Gardner, Jacob Collier, Anna Gelderd, and myself, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Adam Jogee.

06:14:43 - 06:14:45

Speaker 288

Road Safety Plans Bill.

06:14:45 - 06:14:48

Speaker 287

Second reading what day?

06:14:48 - 06:14:50

Speaker 289

Friday the 16th of October.

06:14:50 - 06:15:03

Speaker 278

Friday the 16th of October. We now come to motion number two on business of the House. Minister to move.

06:15:04 - 06:15:24

Speaker 278

The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

We now come to the motion on the sovereign grant. I call the minister to move the motion.

06:15:24 - 06:18:30

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I beg to move the motion on the order paper in the name of the Chancellor of the Exchequer relating to the Sovereign Grant. If we approve the motion, the bill to establish the Sovereign Grant will be published later today, and the House will have an opportunity for a longer and more detailed debate, I'm sure, at second reading. The Sovereign Grant is the annual funding provided to support the Sovereign's official duties and the work of the Royal Household, including staffing, official travel, and the maintenance of the occupied Royal Palaces. Since 2012, the level of the grant has been determined through a statutory framework that links it to a specified percentage of the revenue of the Crown Estate, an independent public business whose net revenue profits are returned to the Exchequer. Additionally, in 2016, the previous government agreed a temporary 369 million pound uplift to the grant over 10 years from 2017-18 to 2026-27, specifically to fund the Buckingham Palace resurfacing programme, a major 10-year project to modernize and safeguard the palace's essential infrastructure.

Periodically, Madam Deputy Speaker, Parliament requires the Royal Trustees to review whether the arrangements for the Sovereign Grant remain appropriate. Earlier this year, the then Royal Trustees completed that review and made recommendations for the appropriate level of the Sovereign Grant funding from 2027 to 2032. The Trustees recognized that with the Buckingham Palace resurfacing programme nearing completion, the exceptional funding requirement for this scheme no longer exists. They therefore recommended that the overall level of funding provided through the Sovereign Grant should reduce from next year from 137.9 million to 99.9 million in 2027-28. This recommendation was made based on an assessment of the Royal Household's expected costs and the Crown Estate's expected revenues between 2027 and 2032.

The new level of the grant will ensure that the Royal Household can continue to deal with property maintenance backlogs following some years of constrained funding during the pandemic. It will also allow the Royal Household to replace aging systems to strengthen cybersecurity and to install energy-efficient heating systems. Given that we, with the consent of the House, will be debating the clauses in the bill in more detail, I'm sure, in second reading later this month, I'll bring my remarks to a close, Madam Deputy Speaker, by saying that overall, these measures ensure that the grant will continue to fulfill its core purpose of supporting the official duties of the monarch and maintaining the occupied Royal Palaces, and the clauses in the bill, I hope the House will agree, will improve the existing framework governing the Sovereign Grant so that it continues to operate just as Parliament intended.

06:18:30 - 06:18:36

Speaker 292

The question is as on the order paper. Shadow Minister James Wild.

06:18:36 - 06:27:26

James Wild

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and the background to this motion dates from 1760 when the agreement was reached with George III to surrender the Crown Estate revenues to the taxpayer in return for government support. But it wasn't until the 2011 Act that the financial support was delivered through the Sovereign Grant, and the purpose of that Act was to bring together what was a patchwork of funding streams and arrangements with a more transparent system with greater accountability to taxpayers. And the motion that the Minister's moved proposes three important changes to set the baseline for the Sovereign Grant for next year, to update the percentage, and finally it creates a mechanism to allow the Treasury to set the grant in future years in certain circumstances, which includes potentially reducing the amount in the Sovereign Grant.

And given the grant funds the duties of the monarch and the royal household, we support this approach and the motion. I think it's worth reflecting that in an era when many institutions struggle to find public support and respect, the monarchy continues to play a unique role in our life. Whether representing Britain overseas, supporting charitable organisations, strengthening diplomatic relationships, or bringing communities together at moments of celebration or national reflection, the royal family performs an indispensable public service. And we saw that in the response following the death of the late Queen and in the support that His Majesty the King has had as he's taken on the responsibilities of the crown. I should note that His Majesty is a constituent when he is resident at Sandringham in my North West Norfolk constituency, which, while a private residence, also hosts official events that are covered by the grant.

And the value of the royal family is not simply symbolic. Independent analysis has shown the substantial soft power and economic benefits flowing from the institution, whether trade, tourism, cultural influence, or indeed the prestige associated with royal warrants that many constituent firms are fortunate to benefit from. And the grant enables these benefits to be realised. For this financial year, the Sovereign Grant stands at 137.9 million pounds, with 97 of that in core funding and 40 million pounds as the final payment for the Buckingham Palace reservicing programme. And at a time when many construction projects, I could think of a number to mention, seem to miss their budget and targets, it's right to acknowledge the National Audit Office findings that the 10-year programme has managed to remain in budget despite challenges by making trade-offs, actively managing risk, and learning lessons.

But completion of that reservicing programme would mean that without these proposed changes, funding would remain at that 137.9 million level in 2027, which clearly could not be justified. And that's what lies behind the resetting of the baseline of 99.9 million and raising the reference percentage to 20.5% for the period 3 to 21-32. And at first glance, that looks like a significant reduction from the current level, but it does come across, come after the completion of the 10-year programme, and core funding has actually increased to 97.6 million this year from around 52 million in 2024-5. According to the House of Commons Library, if it had simply increased with inflation from 2016, it would now be 59.4 million pounds. So we have to ask what lies behind that growth.

And the jump from 52 to 72 million in 25-26 was largely driven by property maintenance, higher payroll, and other spending alongside a top-up to the reserve Sovereign Grant after a period of largely flat grants. And over half the total grant was allocated to the preservation of the occupied royal houses, which must be right. The further rise to 97.6 million appears to mainly relate to royal travel, digital services, housekeeping, and hospitality, although I'd welcome if the Minister can shed some more clarity on where the remaining costs come from. And as we move forward, there is a considerable backlog of maintenance at the occupied royal palaces, need to modernise ageing systems, improve cybersecurity, and invest in more energy-efficient infrastructure. And I'm grateful to the royal household and the Keeper of the Privy Purse for the constructive conversations I've had with him on behalf of His Majesty's opposition regarding the settlement, which does two things: to preserve the historic national buildings and run a modern, secure, fit-for-purpose operation.

I have a few points I'd like clarification from the Minister. First, ahead of the second reading of the bill, where obviously we'll be able to get far more into the detail than we will this evening, can the Minister commit to writing to me with a breakdown of the planned expenditure behind the new 99.9 million figure? For example, why is payroll expected to rise by 7 million between 26-27 and 31-32? Core property maintenance rises by 25%, and clearly the case for addressing maintenance, particularly in state-room areas, for example, is clear. Is the Minister confident that the broader program reflects value for money?

And can the Minister confirm that any capital expenditure above 6 million pounds, such as replacing the boilers at Windsor, would require Treasury approval of a business case? And encouragingly, income supplementing the grant is forecast to increase by a quarter over the period. How confident is the Minister in those projections? It's important there is also a focus on efficiency, and what external benchmarking of the Royal Household cost base has there been, which comparator organizations were used, and what specific efficiencies have resulted or are planned as a result? In terms of the reserve, as I've mentioned, this fell with the impact of COVID and now stands at 21 million pounds.

Is there a formal target reserve level the household is managing toward for resilience purposes, distinct from the statutory 50% reduction trigger threshold, and if so, over what timeframe is that expected to be reached? The motion provides for the reference percentage used to calculate the grant, and the government has set this out will rise from 12% to 20.5%. This is described as being calibrated to the household's expected costs for that five-year period. What specific cost forecast underpins that rate, and has it been independently tested or benchmarked, or is it effectively set simply by reference to the household's own submitted budget? And for those who may be concerned that this is a too-generous settlement, the reality that there will be a real-terms reduction as the grant remains flat in cash terms over the period.

One of the significant parts of this motion, which we will scrutinize carefully in the legislation, is a mechanism to allow the Sovereign Grant to decrease where circumstances warrant it. This reforms a long-standing feature of the existing system, the golden ratchet set out in section 6 of the 2011 Act, under which funding cannot decrease in cash terms. And the government's King's Speech briefing note, Madam Deputy Speaker, tells us that the proposed change means the grant can be reduced from one year to the next, preventing inappropriately high funding. Of course, it's important that all taxpayer money represents value for money, but can the Minister elaborate on the rationale for that, given the settlement is expected to be flat cash over the period? In what type of circumstances would a reduction be considered appropriate, and what would the role of Parliament be in scrutinizing any such decision?

To conclude, we support the motion and resetting the Sovereign Grant following the completion of the Buckingham Palace works. It's important that we establish a sustainable funding framework for the years ahead. However, there are important questions I've raised over the increases in the last year ahead of setting this new baseline, in what circumstances the government may look to reduce the funding, and these are asked in the spirit of supporting both the institution of the monarchy and the principle of responsible stewardship of public money. Thank you.

06:27:26 - 06:27:27

Neil Duncan-Jordan.

06:27:27 - 06:30:01

John Neil Duncan-Jordan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the government's decision to bring forward legislation to make it possible for the sovereign grant to be reduced. But there remain a number of issues surrounding the grant that I believe the government should also address. The first is the link between the grant and the profits of the Crown Estate. The Crown Estate is quite separate from the monarchy and operates to generate revenue for the Treasury.

This seems a very odd form of indexation and begs the question why the grant isn't based on the needs of the monarchy or its costs. This, I believe, needs to be reviewed. The fact that the grant could only ever go up until the government brought this motion forward was also described by the FT as an arrangement wherein a good year the monarchy would win and in a bad year the taxpayer would lose. It's right, therefore, that the government is addressing this anomaly. This also goes on to raise the question of how the grant should be set.

I believe the Treasury should have the power to specify the amount of grant on an annual basis. It's important that the funding of the monarchy is transparent and open to MPs for debate. Numerous times I have tried to table questions about these issues, only to be told this is not something for Parliament to discuss. This has to change. Finally, Madam Deputy Speaker, there are some anomalies when we look at the monarch's wider financial arrangements.

Why, for example, are they not subject to inheritance tax? Why is no account taken of the profits of the Duchy of Lancaster when setting the level of the sovereign grant? And why are the monarch's financial affairs exempt from freedom of information legislation? Whilst today's bill might be viewed as an administrative adjustment, it's important that we ask the question why the grant needs to be 322% higher than it was when it was first introduced in 2012. Even allowing for inflation, the proposed grant is well over twice the real value of its starting point.

So I would be grateful, Madam Deputy Speaker, if the minister would comment on these issues when he sums up.

06:30:01 - 06:30:03

Speaker 294

Spokesperson Lisa Smart.

06:30:03 - 06:33:17

Lisa Smart

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The sovereign grant does not provide personal income to the King, to the Queen, or to any member of the royal family. The grant funds the work of the institution, and the largest part of it funds buildings. Between 2025 and 2026, 67.5 million pounds went on property maintenance alone, including the Buckingham Palace reservicing program and the installation of more energy-efficient heating. These are heritage sites carrying a maintenance backlog that has built up over decades, and the reservicing work exists to stop a serious risk of fire and flood.

We should, of course, take the action needed to protect these national heritage assets. The grant is also funding green infrastructure across the estate and better cybersecurity, which in the current international climate is not an optional extra for any national institution. However, we should treat the increases as temporary in nature, and it is right that the sovereign grant is readjusted once these projects are complete. The government has already committed to legislate for exactly that once the reservicing work's finished. And that brings me to a key issue, which is transparency.

The taxpayer is funding this. Taxpayers are entitled to see where their money goes. And as the honorable member for the pool has already mentioned, Parliament is entitled to hold the government and the Treasury to account for it.

Now, some of that framework already exists and it works. Under the Sovereign Grant Act, the Royal Household's accounts are audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General and laid before this House, and the Royal Household sits within the National Audit Office's value for money remit. But that is not the whole picture. We have an institution spending over 130 million pounds of public money a year, where the published accounts are the beginning and the end of what the public can ask for. If one of my Hazel Grove constituents wanted to know how a figure in that report came to be, there is no route for them to find out.

So I wonder if I could encourage the minister to let us know whether he has any plans to review the reporting requirements attached to the grant so that Parliament and the public get spending detail at a level that allows genuine scrutiny. It is right that taxpayers will have questions about where and importantly who this money goes to. Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor holds no title, no office, and no public role. He is, as far as the state is concerned, a private citizen, and as such, not a penny of this grant should reach him, and nor should any other taxpayer funding. And that has to include what happens at the end of his life.

Frequently, members of the Royal Family have received publicly funded funerals, either having ceremonial funerals or state funerals. And for context of how much these can cost, the Queen Mother's ceremonial funeral in 2002 cost more than 5.4 million pounds, of which 4.3 million pounds was policing. So could the minister confirm that no public money from the Sovereign Grant or from any departmental budget would fund a ceremonial funeral, a lying in state, or state honors of any kind for Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor?

06:33:17 - 06:34:44

Jim Shannon

Madam Deputy Speaker, thank you very much. Can I thank the minister for his introduction and for his words for setting out the scene for what we're looking at tonight. The clarification is needed, the minister has done just that in a way which I think is transparent and that the nation needs to know as well. So does the minister and this House not agree with me that while we must always ensure absolute value for money for every single taxpayer in my constituency of Strangford and right across the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the monarchy provides an immeasurable service, stability, and global prestige that far outweighs these costs. When we look at the figures in the Sovereign Grant Bill, we see that the Treasury is rightly acting to reduce the overall grant to 99.9 million for the year 2027-2028 financial year.

But can the minister confirm and acknowledge that this demonstrates, I believe, a clear commitment from the Palace to be transparent, to tighten its belt alongside the public that everybody else is doing, and to ensure that the continuous maintenance of our historic national heritage can continue. Thank you very much.

06:34:44 - 06:41:17

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank members from across the House for their questions and their the beginning of the scrutiny that will take place should the House agree for the bill to be laid and for debate to proceed at second reading. Let me turn to some of the points that were raised. The shadow exchequer secretary, I hope he still has that title with the ongoing junior ministerial opposition junior ministerial reshuffle, raised a whole range of important questions and asked whether I would write to him on these matters.

And I would be very happy to make sure to write to him, and I'm sure that letter can be made available to others in this place, given that a whole range of questions were asked and I may not be able to cover them all just now in concluding. One of the key questions that has been asked by members on all sides in fact is around this increase in the value of the Sovereign Grant above inflation. This of course is an important question. It's one that the trustees went over in detail in making the decision to increase the grant relative to the pre-Buckingham Palace servicing costs up to 99.9 million. Of course it is reducing by a quarter from one year from the current year to the next year because of the Buckingham Palace refit finishing.

A large part of the increase in the expenditure has been about the refurbishment and the servicing costs of the occupied Royal Palaces themselves. That was 18 million in 2016-17 and it will be next year at 33.6 million. So that accounts for a large share of the above inflation increase. And then he mentions, and I believe the House of Commons Library and others have pointed to the other increases in expenditure that are facing the Royal Family, that the Royal Household is facing. Yes, on buildings and maintenance, but also on making sure that the palaces can take proactive steps to improve the energy efficiency of their heating in line with broader net zero goals that at least do have some level of consensus across the House.

And I hope one day we may be able to rebuild the consensus that seems to sadly have been lost in recent months on making sure we can reduce our domestic carbon emissions along with our international allies. Also investment in cybersecurity, which of course is growing, the need to do that in line with AI, and to make sure that we can target other long-term, long-term measures to make sure the Royal Household is more resilient. There are a whole range of other questions that were asked in terms of making sure, have the trustees ensured that there's a real focus on external benchmarking, on what work has been done to scrutinize these costs? I'm assured that that work has taken place and we can discuss it in more detail at second reading. And this touches on the point that my honorable friend the member for Poole and others have raised around the fact that the Sovereign Grant will now be set at close to 20% of the revenue rather than 12 and a half percent.

That reflects this bottom-up assessment that has taken place looking across the needs of the Royal Household and making sure that it is being funded adequately for the work, for the public duties that His Royal Highness the King and the Royal Family carry out. And it is worth pointing out that His Majesty the King, forgive me, the King and other members of the Royal Family are carrying out. And it is worth pointing out of course that those activities have increased significantly in recent years. Towards the end of her reign, the late Queen was not carrying out a large number of foreign engagements and also was hosting a smaller number of state visits. The King has increased the engagement that he is carrying out on our behalf as part of his public duties and that has involved more expenditure in terms of staff costs and making sure that those engagements and the benefits that the Shadow Exchequer Secretary talked of in terms of the representation of our country and supporting good causes here in the UK can get the funding and the support that they need.

It is worth noting in response to the question raised by the Liberal Democrat spokesperson that the Sovereign Grant is very clearly focused on the official duties that the Royal Family carry out on our behalf and isn't about supporting or funding their private activities or things that it wouldn't be appropriate for the Sovereign Grant to fund. The honourable member for Poole also raised the need for debate on these topics and of course we will all get plenty of time in second reading to debate the issues that he and others have raised around transparency and the clarity on where the Sovereign Grant is being spent. I've set out today some initial outlines of that, I'll respond in writing and I'm sure we'll have a thorough debate later in the month. I'll have to get back to the Shadow Exchequer Secretary on the business case threshold but we do of course as a Treasury make sure that every penny of money is well spent and that includes the 99.9 million that will be allocated here. Madam Deputy Speaker, I have I hope responded to many of the points that have been raised and I thank members for their contributions.

I look forward if we do proceed to debating this at second reading.

06:41:17 - 06:41:23

Speaker 295

A bill is to be brought in upon the resolution. Who will prepare and bring in the bill?

06:41:23 - 06:41:33

Daniel Mark Tomlinson

The Chairman of Ways and Means, the Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Secretary Alex Norris and myself.

06:41:33 - 06:42:02

Speaker 297

Dan Tomlinson. Sovereign Grant Bill. Second reading what day?

06:42:03 - 06:42:26

Speaker 278

Tomorrow. We now come to the debate if I have a minister. We now come to the debate on the impact of strategic lawsuits against public participation. I call Alex Sobel who will speak for up to 15 minutes.

06:42:26 - 06:49:23

Alex Sobel

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move the motion on the impact of strategic lawsuits against public participation also known as SLAPPs. It is custom to thank the Backbench Business Committee. This is the second attempt we're having on having this debate. Last time I agreed to pull the debate so we could have a longer debate on settlement goods.

But I want to thank the Backbench Business Committee for giving us 90 minutes protected time because otherwise we'd be only having 44 minutes of this debate so that is really why I'm thanking them this evening. So coming on to SLAPPs. A SLAPP is a litigation or commonly the threat of litigation designed primarily to silence criticism rather than vindicate a legitimate legal right. The objective is often not to win in court but to make speaking out so expensive, stressful and risky that journalists, campaigners, academics, whistleblowers and ordinary citizens decide that remaining silent is the safer option.

On the surface, SLAPPs might appear to be a niche media law issue. However, as we'll no doubt hear from examples from members today, by suppressing information that is in the public interest, they undermine our democracy, our public watchdogs, and the integrity of our justice system. Back in June, during justice questions, the then Secretary of State recognized the profound financial and psychological impact of SLAPPs and the threat that they represent to democracy and free speech. He also highlighted that SLAPPs extend beyond journalism and issues of free speech, including SLAPPs being used to silence sexual abuse survivors and tenants who complain to landlords. This is one of five reasons why today's debate is particularly important and timely.

Many think SLAPPs are confined to journalists being threatened by Russian oligarchs. In fact, the threat is more diverse than ever. The expanding scope of this abuse across all types of public interest activity is deeply concerning. There has been a significant spike in cases reported to the UK Anti-SLAPP Coalition over the last 18 months, a large portion of which are private citizens who have spoken out about concerns in their local area or services they've received. I've no doubt we'll all have constituents affected by SLAPPs.

Secondly, the tactics are also evolving. While defamation remains a common legal basis used, SLAPPs are also now being brought through claims like harassment, data protection, privacy, and trespass, demonstrating that any effective response must establish universal protections irrespective of the cause of action. Thirdly, the UK appears to be an attractive jurisdiction for this kind of legal abuse. Our expensive litigation and claimant-friendly reputation have made London a popular destination, while the European Union has moved ahead with an anti-SLAPP directive and 22 EU countries have now taken action to progress anti-SLAPP legislation at a national level. In the UK, broad protection is still absent.

We risk becoming an outlier. In recent months, the limits of the existing regulatory framework have been brought into sharp focus. The Solicitors Regulation Authority has faced challenges in progressing SLAPP complaints, particularly those that have reached tribunal stage, and recent Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal judgments have failed to address the fundamental issue of SLAPPs as an abusive tactic. Despite opening over 70 cases since 2022, only three so far have progressed to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal. Moreover, the SRA have not publicly released any data regarding the status of their SLAPP-related investigations since 2024.

While new legislation is urgently required, it must also be accompanied by strong regulatory guidance and enforcement action. Finally, Parliament now has an opportunity to act. Before the summer recess, two new private members' bills were introduced, one by the right honorable member opposite, and I'm sure we'll hear more from him on that, and also one in the other place by Baroness Stowell. These private members' bills aim to create broader anti-SLAPP protection. The issue before us is no longer whether the problem exists, it is whether we are prepared to legislate with the urgency the problem demands.

Many of Britain's biggest national scandals came only to light because determined journalists, courageous whistleblowers, and persistent campaigners refused to be intimidated, but SLAPPs have often been present. SLAPPs delayed reporting on the Horizon Post Office scandal, maternity scandals in teaching hospitals such as Oxford and my own in Leeds, and the Grenfell Tower tragedy. Think about the scandals we have never discovered because someone successfully silenced those asking the questions. That is why this issue is about far more than protecting journalists, it's about protecting the public's right to know. I should acknowledge that the previous government recognized the problem.

Following the Ministry of Justice's 2022 consultation, reforms were introduced through the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 23, creating protections against SLAPPs connected to economic crime, including an early dismissal mechanism and greater protections on legal costs.

Those were welcome reforms, but they are also flawed and limited. They only protect investigations into economic crime and depend on a complex and time-intensive process to determine the intentions or mindsets of the claimant. These limitations matter. Public interest speech is not confined to corruption, fraud, and money laundering. It also concerns patient safety, environmental harm, housing conditions, human rights abuses, sexual violence, animal welfare, and failures of public administration, amongst others.

People should not lose protection simply because the wrongdoing they expose does not fit within a narrow statutory category. This is why I'm calling the government to use the opportunity of these two private members' bills to introduce universal anti-SLAPP legislation. I want to keep my remarks short because we are short on time and I want to make sure everybody gets in, all of those who have come to this debate. But I would like to take the opportunity to thank all of those who have been working on this issue for the last five years to support the cases we will hear about today, including the Foreign Policy Centre, Index on Censorship, CLD, the News Media Association, the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, Reporters Without Borders, Spotlight on Corruption, Transparency International, and all the members of the UK Anti-SLAPP Coalition, as well as the Media Lawyers Association and the APPG on Anti-Corruption and Responsible Tax, who support their work. But I also want to thank the targets of SLAPPs who have bravely spoken out about the legal threats they have faced.

SLAPPs encourage silence to avoid increasing liability, but we only know about the scale of this issue because these brave people all across the country have spoken out, and we are indebted to them. Thank you.

06:49:23 - 06:49:28

Speaker 298

The question is as on the order paper. Sir John Whittingdale.

06:49:28 - 06:56:08

John Whittingdale

Um, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I begin by congratulating the honorable gentleman for Leeds Central on obtaining this debate. This is a subject that we have discussed here a number of times over the years, and the need for action becomes even greater. And indeed, the honorable gentleman, I think, picked up the baton from the honorable gentleman for Bolton West, who was going to initially hold this debate before he was elevated to high office. I speak in my capacity as chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Media Freedom and also, as the honorable gentleman said earlier, as the sponsor of a private member's bill which I shall be introducing in November.

The reason is that SLAPPs have been a stain on this country's reputation as defenders of media freedom for too long. We actually set up the Media Freedom Coalition in 2019, and I'm delighted that under the outgoing Foreign Secretary, the UK has taken back the co-chair position with Finland. And our position on media freedom is one we can be proud of. We have gone up in the ranking produced for the World Press Freedom Index. We're now at 18.

But in their commentary on the UK, RSF said, quote, "Lawsuits aimed at gagging journalists in the UK are one reason why we are not in a higher position." Now, SLAPPs are not new. They have been around for a long time, and I spent part of my summer in my deckchair reading an excellent book by David Hooper, which recounts the history of SLAPPs starting with James Goldsmith and his war on Private Eye, followed by Robert Maxwell, who took on Orum Press and the biographies written about him, and then perhaps most notoriously after that, Mohamed Al-Fayed, whose appalling actions in abuse of young employees at Harrods were known about and were reported but were then suppressed as a result of lawsuits which he liberally sprayed around using very expensive lawyers.

And it is the case that generally SLAPPs are used by rich people who are seeking to suppress information which is clearly in the public interest. And when I chaired the Select Committee now 15 years ago, we looked at that and the advent of libel tourism, the fact that the UK courts were specifically being used by people who had very little connection with the UK to bring libel suits because we were seen to be sympathetic to the idea of libel actions to suppress information. And since then, particularly Russian oligarchs have queued up to come and use the British courts. And we have talked to and met, as the honourable gentleman said, some of the brave people who have sought to expose their actions and been subjected to SLAPPs cases, people like Catherine Belton, the author of Putin's People, and Tom Burgis, the author of Kleptopia. And it continues today, and I'm not going to go into a number of cases, but we'll perhaps have more opportunity to do so when the private member's bill comes forward.

But I'm particularly grateful to the Anti-SLAPP Coalition for the help that they have given in taking forward this campaign. Progress has been made. The Defamation Act in 2013 sought to address some of the worst aspects of libel tourism. The Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act focused specifically on those who were alleging economic crime and put in place some protection. But the problem with that was that some of the worst cases, and I go back to both the work of Catherine Belton and Tom Burgis, they were not allegations of economic crime, they were more serious than that, and clearly the provisions in that bill would not have been sufficient.

And it was Wayne David who in the last Parliament then sought to extend the provisions of that act to cover a far wider range of actions, and sadly it did not complete its passage due to the general election. But my intention is to try and complete the work that Wayne David started with his bill. And the Minister will be very much aware that at the beginning of this year, 120 editors, including every major publication not just in the UK but across the world, wrote calling for the Government to act. And I know that the Government was committed to taking action, but unfortunately couldn't find a slot to do so. And I would like to say that I'm extremely grateful to the Minister for the discussions that we've already had about how we might work together in order to bring legislation onto the statute book.

The honourable gentleman is right, Baroness Stowell in the other place is introducing a private member's bill, hers has been published, and there is some debate as to the mechanism which is most effective. I think there were concerns that the attempt in the Wayne David bill to set out lengthy definitions might make it more complex, and there is an argument for trying to make the test of a SLAPP simpler. But those are details which I think we will want to continue to discuss with the Minister and her officials.

the objective we all share. I should say I'm not opposed to people having the right to bring defamation actions or other suits where they feel that they've been wrongly accused of something, that is a fundamental right. What I am opposed to is the abuse of lawsuits with the deliberate intent of suppressing information which is clearly in the public interest. And it is that definition which we will seek to explore how best to set out in legislation. So I look forward to further meetings with the Minister and I welcome this as perhaps the first opportunity to debate what I believe is a very important issue for the freedom of speech and journalism in this country.

06:56:08 - 06:56:10

Speaker 299

Jill Brookell.

06:56:10 - 07:01:49

Jill Mortimer

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Anti-Corruption and Responsible Tax, I would like to thank my friend, the honorable member for Leeds Central and Headingley, for working with me to secure today's debate. It's been about nine months since I initially presented the application to the Backbench Business Committee, but I'm pleased to say it has already been worth that wait. Could I also congratulate the Minister on her reappointment? It was a real pleasure to work with her in my role as a Ministry of Justice Parliamentary Private Secretary in the last government, and I've found her no less supportive, engaged, and collaborative when I've come to her with constituency issues, as I will speak to in more detail later on.

I'd like to take today's opportunity to share at least one particularly egregious example of vexatious litigation in the form of a SLAPP. Now, before I go any further, let me confirm that the cases I mention today are not subject to ongoing legal proceedings, Madam Deputy Speaker. Back in 2016, Jennifer McAdam invested the inheritance she received from her late father into a cryptocurrency called OneCoin. But OneCoin was a three billion pound lie. In reality, it was a global Ponzi scheme.

When it collapsed the following year, millions of people from 125 countries lost money. In order to raise awareness and protect other investors, in 2017, Jennifer organized a webinar for other victims and cryptocurrency experts to explore ways to hold the company to account. Three weeks later, she received a legal threat from OneCoin and its co-founder Ruja Ignatova, dubbed the Cryptoqueen in the viral podcast that followed. That threat, sent via law firm Carter-Ruck, claimed that Jennifer had defamed the so-called Cryptoqueen during the webinar. It went on to say that the only way to avoid a court case was to refrain from publishing similar allegations and to retract the webinar video.

Even as legal action was threatened against Jennifer, regulatory action against OneCoin was already underway in a number of countries. Jennifer should have been celebrated for trying to help other victims and prevent future ones, not threatened and harassed. In 2025, Claire Gill, a partner at Carter-Ruck instructed by OneCoin, was referred to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal by the Solicitors Regulation Authority on allegations that she sent a letter to McAdam which contained an improper threat of litigation. However, by the end of the year, the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal refused to dismiss the proceedings, stating that Gill had acted on explicit client instructions and had no reason at that stage to disbelieve them, and that the SRA's allegation was founded on hindsight rather than evidence of professional misconduct. The SRA has also been ordered to pay Gill's costs, which Carter-Ruck claim to be around one million pounds.

Naturally, such sizeable costs raise fears they may dampen the regulator's appetite to challenge similar SLAPP-related cases in the foreseeable future. Now, there are serious questions to be asked about the tribunal's approach in setting such a high bar of actual knowledge of wrongdoing, effectively requiring evidence of complicity before professional ethics really kick in.

Conveniently easy for lawyers to simply avoid asking questions they do not want to know the answers to. And if lawyers are allowed to blindly and ignorantly pursue their client's interests, even when that involves silencing the police and, to quote, in furtherance of fraud, to use the tribunal's wording before the case was thrown out, then we will never stop SLAPPs. But this isn't just about London lawyers and international scams. According to reporting by the Manchester Mill back in 2021, a solicitor named Andrew Milne acquired 67 residential freeholds at auction for around 130 pounds per property in Horwich, in my constituency. Milne then proceeded to demand thousands of pounds from my constituents in return for their freeholds, often citing spurious breaches of lease covenants.

And yet, when the Sheffield Tribune sought to report on Milne's equally outrageous behavior in Yorkshire, he sent them a message which included the following threat, and I quote: "We will definitely bring proceedings for defamation and malicious falsehood if you publish such complete and malicious lies." This is how it works: bullies, charlatans, and chancers like Milne using their privileged positions to seek to silence journalists and whistleblowers lifting the lid on their abhorrent actions. Now, on a general policy point, I have been encouraged by noises coming out of the SRA since the regulator's change in leadership. But as in the cases described, it strikes me that the regulatory framework as currently stands is not up to the job. That's why a universal anti-SLAPP law is needed to ensure those who speak out in the public interest are protected.

And so I welcome the recent comments about the government's commitment to introduce universal anti-SLAPP legislation and the opportunity the two private members' bills on SLAPPs presents, both in this house and in the other place. In particular, I know the right honorable member for Maldon is keen to work with the government in what I trust will be an exemplar of cross-party working. So I hope that across party lines, we can seize this opportunity to put to bed the spurious litigation put forward by individuals who seek to silence dissenting voices. To close, let me reiterate the ask from the UK Anti-SLAPP Coalition, namely that legislation must be accompanied by strong regulatory guidance and enforcement action to ensure lawyers are held to account for abusive legal tactics. I hope this government can deliver on that ask in the fullness of time.

07:01:49 - 07:01:50

John McDonnell.

07:01:50 - 07:06:11

John Martin McDonnell

Thank you, Madam Deputy Chair. I'm secretary of the NUJ parliamentary group, and I'd like to speak in that capacity. But I'm also a victim of the James Goldsmith Foundation, as the honorable gentleman for Maldon has referred to. And if members are unaware of what the Goldsmith Foundation was all about, it was basically an organization funded by James Goldsmith, which employed Carter-Ruck to identify people that James Goldsmith politically disagreed with and targeted them. And in my instance, as I was writing exposing the then MP for my constituency, a Conservative MP, who was being hosted on a series of trips by Saddam Hussein to Iraq and then coming back here to justify the gassing of the Kurds in Halabja, where 4,000 people were gassed to death.

What then happened, I was sued by Carter-Ruck. And it's the same issue over all: you just cannot afford to fight. In fact, I had to hand over the deeds of my property as a result of that action because we simply could not fund, even though there was some Labour Party support for funding, the general view was is that this was a sinking pit of funding that we could not match. That was just one example of how the Goldsmith Foundation operated, but it's one example of the operation of SLAPPs, as the honorable gentleman said, over a long period of time. This was way back in the nineties.

The reference has been made: this isn't just about journalists. It isn't. But the journalists have been mainly the target on all of this, and it has been devastating with regard to the consequences for some because of the legal costs that they've had to incur just to try and demonstrate that they've been writing truthful analysis of the events that they've been trying to report.

It does stifle free speech and it undermines that right to the general public to know information exactly as has been said. There's a deterrence effect, a form of intimidation against telling the truth. In the past, the the previous Prime Minister did give a commitment with regard to legislation. Unfortunately, it wasn't in the King's Speech, we unfortunately we felt that was unfortunate, but now's the time to pick up the pace of that. And I'm grateful for the Minister now offering briefings on how we can move forward and working on a cross-party basis as well.

The issue for us is that although everyone so far spoken welcomed the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act, again just to reiterate, it just applies to economic crime reportage. And therefore what has been happening is even though some journalists will be protected under that, the individual that who we've been reporting upon will then find another matter to take the action and as a result of that the journalist is not protected. And the the thresholds and criteria of judgments that are taking place where the court the the judge has to consider the intent of the SLAPP filer but also the intent of the defendant as well. It's a threshold far too high. And there's case after case that we can cite, but the most recent one I think that's caught the publicity was Dan Neidle's case where he exposed a firm operating a tax avoidance scam, won the case, but then was left with 146,000 pounds of costs of legal fees.

As has been said, there's been various various attempts by honourable members to try and tackle this issue. The Scottish Government has also said it's awaiting a legislative opportunity to bring forward legislation itself. The NUJ is part of the anti-SLAPP anti-SLAPP coalition and the proposals that have been put forward really is to make sure that there's a clear criteria to identify SLAPPs. There's a ten-point criteria that's been set forward, that we higher the merits threshold for likely success at at trial. And then also that there's a filter mechanism for a a swift disposal of what are actions that are clearly seeking to to gag individual journalists and others.

That's why we welcome the Government's engagement now with and including hopefully with the the NUJ over these coming weeks that we can get this legislation on the statute book as rapidly as possible so we can protect freedom of speech.

07:06:11 - 07:06:12

Rachel Blake.

07:06:12 - 07:12:45

Rachel Blake

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I congratulate my honourable friend, the Member for Leeds Central and Headingley for securing this important debate. It really is very welcome to be here with friends who are so committed to this issue and have been for such a long time. Because this debate is about much more than press freedom, although it is very much about that. It's about whether ordinary people can speak out in the public interest without fear of being silenced by those with deeper pockets, greater resources, and access to expensive legal representation. Strategic lawsuits against public participation, SLAPPs, so unattractively described, are designed not necessarily to win in court, but to intimidate, exhaust, and suppress scrutiny.

They're increasingly being deployed against journalists and campaigners, whistleblowers, survivors of abuse, community activists, and ordinary citizens. And anyone who raises legitimate concerns about matters of public interest can find themselves on the receiving end of aggressive legal threats, as we have heard. The consequence of this is a chilling effect that extends far beyond the individual target. When one person is punished for speaking out, countless others are forced to conclude that it might be safer for them to remain silent. And that should concern every member of this House.

One case that demonstrates this danger particularly clearly is that of my constituent, the investigative journalist Clare Rewcastle Brown, founder of the Sarawak Report. Ms Rewcastle Brown played a key role in exposing the 1MDB scandal in Malaysia, one of the largest corruption scandals in recent history. Her reporting helped bring international attention to allegations involving billions of dollars that had been diverted from a Malaysian state investment fund, allegations that subsequently became the subject of investigations and prosecutions across multiple jurisdictions. But instead of scrutiny being met simply with accountability, it was met with legal pressure. Between 2017 and 2019, she was pursued through the London courts in a libel action brought by Abdul Hadi Awang, the president of the Malaysian PAS party.

The claim was eventually withdrawn and settled in her favour before trial. The significance of that case lies not merely in its outcome, but in what it demonstrates about the power imbalance at the heart of SLAPPs. As Ms Rewcastle Brown has described, she understood that the objective was not simply to challenge particular words on a page, rather it was to place immense pressure on a journalist through prospect of years of costly litigation, with the hope that eventually that pressure would force a retraction, damage credibility and discourage further reporting. Even when defendants ultimately prevail, they cannot recover the years lost to litigation, the stress inflicted upon them or the time diverted away from public interest work. And that is why campaigners often say that in a SLAPP, the process becomes the punishment.

And let us consider what's at stake. Without investigative journalists such as Clare Rewcastle Brown, one of the world's most significant corruption scandals might never have received the scrutiny that it deserved. Important information might never have reached the public domain. Powerful individuals might never have been held accountable. Yet our legal system left the burden on the journalist to endure years of legal challenge before reaching that outcome.

The reality is that many people do not have the resilience, resources or support to do what Clare did. Many local journalists do not, many campaigners do not, many victims of wrongdoing do not, many ordinary citizens certainly do not. And increasingly, these tactics are evolving. They're no longer confined to traditional defamation claims. We now see claims framed through privacy law, data protection law, harassment claims and injunctions.

The legal mechanisms change, but the purpose remains the same: to drive up costs, create fear and suppress participation in public life. And that's why the existing protections are insufficient. The anti-SLAPP provisions, as we have heard, in the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act were an important first step. However, they are limited to economic crime reporting and leave many people vulnerable. A journalist investigating corruption may receive some protection, a survivor speaking about abuse may not, a local campaigner raising concerns about environmental damage may not, a resident exposing wrongdoing in their community may not.

And that cannot be the right approach. I'm also concerned about questions surrounding enforcement and regulation. The Solicitors Regulation Authority has made clear that solicitors must not pursue abusive litigation tactics, must not advance unmeritorious claims and must not use their professional position to intimidate those engaged in lawful public interest activity. And those principles are absolutely right. But principles alone are not enough if those subjected to abusive legal threats do not have confidence that the system is working.

And that is why legislation and regulation must go hand in hand in this scenario. We need a robust statutory framework that allows judges to dismiss abusive claims at the earliest possible stage. We need strong cost protections for defendants and we need effective professional regulation that ensures lawyers who facilitate abusive tactics are held to account.

And this shouldn't be a partisan issue. Members across this House depend on a free press. We depend on campaigners, researchers, whistleblowers, and engaged citizens bringing serious issues to public attention. Democracy itself depends on scrutiny. I therefore urge the government to work constructively with all colleagues from all parties to bring forward comprehensive anti-SLAPP legislation that protects public interest speech, upholds press freedom, and ensures that our courts cannot be used as instruments of intimidation by those seeking to escape scrutiny.

We should ask ourselves what is holding us back from tackling this, because ultimately, this debate is about a simple principle. In a democratic society, the law should protect those who speak truthfully in the public interest, not provide powerful individuals with the means to silence them.

07:12:45 - 07:12:47

Speaker 301

Marcus Campbell-Savours.

07:12:47 - 07:15:52

Markus Campbell-Savours

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When debating this issue, I crudely used to think of Greenpeace activists taking on multinationals or journalists writing books about oligarchs, Erin Brockovich-style figures exposing injustice. But as has already been raised, SLAPPs are far more relevant to ordinary people than these cases indicate. People like my constituent, Jeff Thompson. Jeff moved to Penrith to enjoy his retirement.

What he didn't expect was the Penrith pong, a foul odor that periodically hangs over the town. Many residents believe the smell is linked to the Omega Proteins rendering plant operated by Leo Group. The company dispute they are the only source of odor. So Jeff set up a Facebook group called Fresh Air for Penrith, a place for residents to moan about the pong, share information, and learn how to make complaints to the Environment Agency. And for running a Facebook page, Jeff received his first legal letter in February '23, finding himself living under the threat of a defamation claim, with all the stress and fear of legal costs that that brings, all because he spoke up on an issue he and his neighbors cared about.

When I was elected, I said publicly that I wanted to tackle the pong. I grew up in Cumbria, and people have talked about the smell for decades. So I was genuinely surprised by how many people warned me not to get involved. People said I might be sued, and until I learned about Jeff's case and the basis of the action against him, I dismissed those warnings as absurd. Now I'll be honest, when I was first elected, Jeff got right under my skin.

Every MP has someone in their inbox with legitimate concerns who is awkward, and some who are extremely awkward. Jeff's one of them. He's very demanding and good at irritating people. But over time, I've come to see Jeff in a different light. I now cast him in a tradition of awkward people, the people who pester, who prod, who refuse to let things go.

And the truth is, without people like Jeff, and there's at least one in every town in my patch, nothing changes. Communities rely on them to keep pushing until someone listens. Well, Jeff also had the courage to fight back. And in June '26, more than three years after the first legal letter, Omega Proteins and Leo Group finally issued a notice of discontinuance. They agreed to pay Jeff's legal costs, and he's now free to speak about what he describes as a living hell.

But for every Jeff, there'll be many out there now who are simply gagged. And their stories won't be told as part of this debate. That's why his story matters.

07:15:52 - 07:17:05

Speaker 303

His case shows exactly why we need an anti-SLAPP law. The Anti-SLAPP Coalition and Index on Censorship helped my constituent in ways I never could, but they need us to act now. They've set out one crucial step that would have protected Jeff: a simple early dismissal mechanism based on an objective signs of abuse. Not a subjective test about what was in the claimant's mind, not years of litigation, just a clear, fast filter that lets a judge say, "This is a public interest issue, this is a citizen speaking about their community, this case should not proceed." If that mechanism had existed, Jeff would not have spent three years under threat, he would have not have faced the stress, the cost, or the fear, and the company would not have been able to use litigation as a tool of intimidation.

Madam Deputy Speaker, no constituent should fear being sued simply for speaking about an issue that they believe is wrong. We must ensure that our legal system protects public participation rather than punishes it. Thank you.

07:17:05 - 07:23:11

Brian William Leishman

Madam Deputy Speaker, our society is grossly unequal. Local councils hollowed out by years of austerity, people needing food banks to survive, kids going to school hungry, people trapped in low-wage precarious employment, all while corporations make record profits and the super-rich become even wealthier. Inequality destroys society and ultimately reduces people, places, and systems to nothing more than commodities and assets, there to be used and exploited by the wealthy. This is clearly obvious in our legal system. Because with SLAPPs, then the law can be used as a weapon by the powerful and the wealthy, making a mockery of things we like to believe are the foundations of our justice system: fairness, equality, transparency, and the notion that money should have no bearing on someone receiving justice.

Madam Deputy Speaker, every debate that we have in this place comes down to the fundamental issue in British politics and society, the same that we have had for hundreds of years: class. And SLAPPs are the embodiment of capitalism and the inequality it creates. Because SLAPPs are used to intimidate people, to restrict activists and campaigners, to exhaust their time, their energy, their emotions, and crucially, as we've heard by so many honourable members, their finances, all to suffocate freedom of speech. Madam Deputy Speaker, I wish now to speak about Lucy and Verity Nevitt, who in 2018 reported allegations of sexual assault and rape to the police. Following an investigation at the end of January 2019, the police decided that they would take no further action due to insufficient evidence.

After Lucy and Verity's cases were dropped, the ladies decided to speak out online to warn others about him.

Specialist Metropolitan Police officers encouraged them to speak out online but told them not to name him, to say alleged and call it serious sexual assault instead of rape. But the sisters decided to say who he was and what he'd done. Their attacker responded by bringing a legal action against the sisters based on accusations of misuse of private information, harassment and defamation. As legal action continued, the sisters became aware of cease and desist letters being sent, firstly to CrowdJustice, where they were raising money for their defense, and also to support their MPs. In May 2020, the High Court decided on a number of applications made by Lucy and Verity and also the claimant.

The sisters were allowed to lift the anonymity order to allow themselves to be publicly identified, while the court allowed the claimant to remain anonymous. However, the court rejected his application for reporting restrictions. In its intervention to oppose this application, PA Media, then the Press Association, argued that the main thrust of the claimant's application for anonymity is to protect his reputation rather than his privacy. In her rejection, Justice Steyn stated that a reporting restriction order is a peremptory order affecting the right to freedom of expression of the press and the public. It is a form of censorship.

After numerous hearings and increasing, obviously hugely increasing legal costs, all parties agreed on a settlement, allowing Lucy and Verity to speak about what had happened to them as long as they did not name their abuser. Lucy said it was a really difficult decision. If we had the money, we would have gone the whole way. This wasn't just about us, but there are so many other victims out there. After founding the Gemini Project in 2018 and fighting back against their attacker's attempt to shut down the organization during the legal battle, the sisters' campaign in support of survivors against SLAPPs and other abusive tactics continues today.

Madam Deputy Speaker, to finish, as legislators, we in this chamber are not exempt from blame. We, the state, allow this practice to happen. Our inaction makes us complicit in this inequality. So, I say to the Minister tonight, we must stop wealth, both corporate and personal, from buying silence and evading both accountability and justice. We must do everything in our power to equalize the legal system and wider British society.

An end to SLAPPs would be a big step forward to achieving that.

07:23:11 - 07:23:15

Speaker 304

Which brings us to the front bench contributions, Jess Brown-Fuller.

07:23:15 - 07:30:38

Jess Brown-Fuller

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to begin by congratulating the member for Leeds Central and Headingley for leading today's important debate and for setting out comprehensively, but also succinctly, very grateful for that, why we are here debating SLAPPs, and the member for Bolton West for originally securing today's debate.

Our justice system was built around the principle of fair and equal treatment for all who go through it. It should not be a tool for the rich and powerful to systematically silence accusers and avoid accountability. But the growing use of SLAPPs makes it abundantly clear the system is in fact tilted towards those that harness power or wealth. Victims, journalists, academics, whistleblowers and many more, all attempting to speak truth to power, are being silenced by mechanisms within the justice system that are being weaponised and abused. These mechanisms are not intended to protect these rich and powerful individuals, but are doing just that and preventing access to justice.

Lawsuits and threats with immense financial implications and additional time constraints are being used to intimidate and coerce individuals into stepping out of the legal system and stopping their actions. They are keeping cases of immense importance and significance to the public out of the courts, undermining the fair and equitable justice system that we should all strive to achieve. I know many today have been supported by the work of the Anti-SLAPP Coalition, who have done so much to expose these cases and push for the legislative changes necessary. And they themselves have reported spikes in the number of cases sent to them in recent years, blaming an environment in the UK which is claimant-friendly and in favour of those suing. And it's not something that we should be proud of.

And of course there have been high-profile cases that have come to light and some have been alluded to today. Mohamed Al-Fayed, the Horizon scandal and Grenfell all provide serious regrets. And attempts to bring these scandals to light were continually blocked from the courts, elongating the pain of their victims and meaning many never saw justice served at all. One case provided by the Anti-SLAPP Coalition illustrates many of these issues. It's the case of Heidi, who having contracted a building firm to carry out an extension of her home, became concerned about the quality of the work carried out.

So she terminated the work, but having taken a six-figure loss, made a complaint to the Trading Standards Authority. She was informed she'd need other cases to take the case forward, which she then requested on social media. Having done this, Heidi was challenged by the building company's lawyers with a letter stating her actions amounted to harassment, defamation, malicious falsehood and falsely questioned her legal qualifications. Very similar to a case that a gentleman brought to me connected to the Anti-SLAPP Coalition, who spoke to me about the intense level of legal correspondence that he received from an estate management company that he had accused of poor service and mismanagement. He had created a Facebook group not just for that estate management company, but to find other cases of estate management companies that had been failing their residents.

And he was relentlessly pursued by the estate management company's legal team with letters insisting that he remove the group or he would face legal action. There's also the harrowing case study that was covered by BBC Woman's Hour of a clinic who performed plastic surgery. They, having encouraged customers to leave reviews on its website and on Trustpilot, had their lawyers pursue legal action against at least five individuals who dared to write negative reviews of their service. These reviews related to legitimate concerns about the quality of treatment provided by the clinic, yet the customers were pursued with vigour, with the legal action threatening to take individuals to court and defamation claims of thousands of pounds. And one woman commented that she hid the whole case from her husband for fear of losing their family home.

So she felt totally silenced by this plastic surgery company who were threatening to take away the home that she lived in.

It resulted in a number of the individuals removing their completely legitimate concerns about their treatment from the online forums. All of these cases highlight situations arising up and down the country, and that's the ones that we know about as many as many honorable members today have said, this is just the tip of the iceberg because the number of people that will have folded under immense pressure and immense amounts of money being thrown at them, we don't know how many cases we don't know about. The continued use of the legal system to intimidate and scare individuals from speaking out. But what we need now to combat this are universal statutory protections to counter SLAPPs in UK law, something eminently achievable as has been shown in the US and in Europe. Currently, well-meaning journalists, whistleblowers, campaigners and victims speaking out on matters of public interest unrelated to economic crime have no legal recourse and these gaps must be addressed.

New legislation should be introduced that ensures equal access to the justice system and doesn't allow those with vast amounts of money the opportunity to silence victims or or those undertaking legitimate scrutiny. And this must involve a filter mechanism that allows courts to swiftly dispose of SLAPPs, an extension of early dismissal procedures, cost protections for defendants in all SLAPP cases, not just those involving financial crime, and the empowerment of courts to impose financial penalties on those who bring forward abusive SLAPP claims or use SLAPPs relentlessly against multiple claimants. We must also strengthen the regulatory powers of professional standards bodies and ensure that robust enforcement against lawyers and law firms that engage in abusive SLAPP litigation. And at the same time, improve access to legal advice and support for those facing SLAPP threats. This is a position that the Liberal Democrats have consistently held, being the only party to support that legislation in our manifesto in 2024, but the point is clearly recognized across the house.

The last Conservative government's amendment to the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act provided protections in cases of economic crime, as has this government's public recognition of the issues in this area. And we've now seen two private members' bills this session which introduce anti-SLAPP provisions, including one due to be presented by the honorable member for Maldon in November. So will the minister confirm today the government's position on those two private members' bills and whether it's the government's intention to support those bills in their passage through the house? I'd ask the minister whether they could outline what conversations they are having or planning to have with the legal profession to stamp out these sorts of practices. The current context, the attention and the support across the house demonstrate the time is right to take steps, protect victims and protect the chance of equitable justice.

And this will only happen with legislation that stamps out malpractice as early as possible, avoiding extortionate costs for victims and allowing the truth to finally be heard. Thank you.

07:30:38 - 07:30:41

Speaker 305

Shadow Minister, Dr. Kieran Mullan.

07:30:41 - 07:37:22

John Kieran Mullan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's grateful to have the opportunity to speak in this debate and congratulate the member for Leeds Central and Headingley on securing it, and also the member for Bolton West for his previous efforts. I also want to thank the member for Maldon for his long work in this area and I think it was helpful for him to set out at the beginning of the speech of the debate the fact that this isn't new actually and these these similar attempts to use the law in that this manner go back quite some time. Free speech is not simply a nice to have, it is one of the foundations on which free society is built. It allows whistleblowers to come forward, it allows victims of abuse and misconduct to tell their stories and be heard and it allows journalists and campaigners to hold the powerful to account.

But free speech is not real if it can only be exercised by those wealthy enough to defend it. When people are frightened into silence, not because what they've said is false, but because of the cost of being right being too high, something is fundamentally wrong. And that's the danger posed by SLAPPs. At their worst, SLAPPs are not really about winning in court, but using the process itself as a punishment. They're designed to make the journey to court so expensive, so exhausting, that the journalist, the campaigner, the whistleblower, or the victim gives up before a judge ever considers its merits.

That chilling effect is not accidental, it's the point. Claims that go all the way to trial can cost an enormous amount in legal fees. Even a defendant who wins can be left with thousands in unrecovered legal bills. The threat being made is not always 'we will win', very often it is 'we can afford this for longer than you'. The asymmetry is the weapon.

We've seen this in some of the most high-profile cases involving British journalists and publishers. Catherine Belton and her publisher faced multiple legal actions after the publication of 'Putin's People'. Tom Burgis and HarperCollins faced litigation over 'Kleptopia'. Eliot Higgins and Bellingcat were pursued through the courts by Yevgeny Prigozhin. I want to pay tribute to those publishers and those businesses that resisted that pressure and were willing to pay those legal bills that enabled those publications to survive when we know others don't.

These cases show how wealthy and powerful overseas actors, including Russian oligarchs, Kremlin-linked figures, and large foreign corporations, have been able to use or threaten to use English courts to put pressure on British journalists investigating corruption, kleptocracy, and misconduct. And that should concern every member of this House. Because we have to have a situation in which journalists can continue to act without fear or favour. And we want charities to be able to raise concerns about wrongdoing and survivors of abuse to speak publicly about what happened to them. I've spoken in this House before about how the UK is the most frequent international origin of legal threats against journalists, accounting for 31% of all such cases.

There are lots of things that we can be proud of in our judicial system and its popularity around the world, but this is one that should give us pause for thought. Around 30% of SLAPPs in 2023 were used to prevent reporting of sexual misconduct. We cannot think of this as an intangible threat to freedom of speech alone. It's being used to silence victims of some of the most personal violations imaginable. The Shadow Justice Secretary put it plainly in a previous debate on this subject.

SLAPPs have been deployed by those with deep pockets against company employees, NGOs, campaign activists, survivors of abuse, and people from many walks of life. And he was right. This is experienced not only in Fleet Street, it's experienced by charity workers who've documented wrongdoing at care homes, by campaigners who've published evidence of environmental harm, and by the victims of sexual violence. So let's be clear about our position. We support the principle of regulating further to stop abusive SLAPP litigation.

It's not right that wealthy individuals, foreign oligarchs, or large corporations can use disproportionate spending power and the threat of financial ruin to silence legitimate public interest. Of course, any legislation must be well-drafted and carefully considered. People must still be able to defend their reputations in court. If a person's genuinely been defamed or false allegations have been made against them, they must have access to justice. I'm sure we've all had our own experience.

I can remember in a previous election campaign, a so-called journalist deciding that my record as a volunteer policeman was entirely fantastical and made up and I was a criminal, and I had to get a solicitor involved to get that taken down. We've all had similar experiences, I'm sure. But clearly the balance at the moment is wrong. The question is whether the courts should be used by those with the deepest pockets to intimidate critics, bury investigations, and frighten others into silence. And they should not.

I think it is important, as many have done, that we recognise the progress to date. The previous Conservative government introduced the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023, which provided the first statutory definition of a SLAPP and created a power to strike out abusive claims at an early stage in cases relating to economic crime. We recognise, as the motion notes, that those provisions were narrow, but they were a start.

And supported the private members bill from the then member for Caerphilly that would have extended those protections significantly. That bill fell before the election and it was not brought, a new version of it wasn't proposed by the new government. The current government's record on this has been underwhelming. The outgoing Prime Minister described the abuse of courts by the rich and powerful as intolerable in October 2024. The Justice Secretary promised legislation as soon as parliamentary time allows, it did not appear in the King's speech.

We then learned that plans had been drafted and were ready to go, but were reportedly shelved for fear of the backlash from some lawyers. 111 peers, including eight former cabinet ministers, signed a cross-party letter in April demanding action, and the UK Anti-SLAPP Coalition, whose 2022 model law set out a possible clear legislative framework, has been waiting for a response ever since. The co-chair of the UK Anti-SLAPP Coalition described action on SLAPPs as a relatively easy win, not only for a government, but for the protection of public interest speech and the overall health of our democratic society. I do also want to acknowledge the work done in the other place by, for example, the Baroness Stowell of Beeston. For some time, the Lords have been an important advocate of legislation in this area.

But the point I'd make to the government is simple: they don't need to start from scratch. They have years of cross-party debate, expert testimony, and the lived experience of victims. They have campaigners, journalists, lawyers, and members across both houses calling for action. The building blocks are there. The government has accepted the principle.

The outgoing Prime Minister called SLAPPs intolerable. The Justice Secretary said legislation would be brought forward. The King's speech has been and gone, so what's the government's plan? Because if the answer today is only warm words, then the 111 peers who signed the cross-party letter, the editors of the Times, the Sun, the Guardian, the NUJ itself, the UK Anti-SLAPP Coalition, and every member who's spoken in this debate are perhaps entitled to a little something more. People must be free to defend their reputations in court, but wealthy individuals and corporations mustn't be able to abuse that freedom and use disproportionate legal firepower to silence legitimate free speech.

07:37:22 - 07:45:57

Sarah Sackman

Minister, Sarah Sackman.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me start by echoing the thanks to the honorable member for Leeds Central and Headingley, and also to the member, my friend, the member for Bolton West, for securing time for this important debate. And to thank everybody across the house who's contributed so thoughtfully to it. Can I also thank the Backbench Business Committee for granting this debate and ensuring the time has been given to consider this vitally important subject. It's perhaps all too rare that cross-party consensus on an issue such as this breaks out, but clearly it has at this slightly ungodly hour, but it is still all the better for it.

Let's be clear: SLAPPs are an abuse of power, an abuse of the legal system, designed to shut down scrutiny, not to seek justice. They're brought, as we've heard, to harass, to intimidate, to wear down opponents through financial pressure and psychological strain. Often brought by wealthy individuals or corporations to silence journalists, authors, publishers, academics, but also, as we've heard particularly powerfully from the member for Penrith and Solway, to silence ordinary individuals and to seek to exploit the power balance imbalance that exists in our society. And in this David and Goliath, it's not just individuals that lose out. It's corrosive of the principle in our society which respects the rule of law, that everyone should be equal before the law.

This is a media freedom issue, of course it is, but it's not just that. It's one about access to justice. And when SLAPPs predominate, we all lose out. As we heard eloquently from the member for Cities and Westminster, it poses a threat to our democracy. Because the purpose of SLAPPs is intimidation, to silence critics through fear, to deter public interest reporting through the threat of costly litigation.

As the Minister for Courts, I say this and want to underline that the courts should always be a forum for justice, not a weapon of intimidation. So the government's position is clear: freedom of expression and investigative journalism must never be undermined by abusive litigation. And so the calls that we've heard tonight from across the House for universal anti-SLAPP legislation is a call that the government welcomes. As others have pointed out, we have begun to take the stepping stones towards that universal framework. I want to pay tribute to the previous government who put on the statute books the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023, which this government began to implement.

That was designed to stop wealthy elites from effectively silencing critics, journalists, and activists. But as a number of members have pointed out, that definition of SLAPPs, defined in statute for the first time to help courts identify abusive claims, was confined narrowly to economic crime. And as we've heard, SLAPPs are used in a far wider context. So whilst it is a vital stepping stone, it is just that. There is agreement that we've heard tonight that we need to go wider because many alleged SLAPPs fall outside the current framework, including cases involving sexual abuse allegations, medical negligence concerns, academic research, and consumer reviews, all sorts of things that are in the public interest.

So we need a wider definition of SLAPPs that goes beyond economic crime and one which too adopts an objective test of what is objectively reasonable behavior in the conduct of litigation. We recognize as a government that the test needs to be simplified to deploy that early dismissal mechanism, that cost protection that exists within the ECT framework, but deploy it in a more refined and effective way. An objective test is one which I find and which the government finds attractive, and a better definition of harassment, alarm, or distress is needed, and it's a definition that we will look to work on with those who bring forward the private members' bills. Other members have spoken not just about the need for legislative action, but also the need for a culture change in the legal profession and amongst our independent regulators. I want to be clear: the overwhelming majority of solicitors and legal professionals in this country and in this jurisdiction act with honesty, professionalism, and a deep commitment to the rule of law.

There is a reason why England and Wales is rightly regarded as world-leading when it comes to legal services and as a legal jurisdiction. Lawyers play a vital role in upholding justice and protecting rights. But that should not detract from the high standards that need to be demonstrated right across the profession because maintaining public confidence requires that recognizing both the profession's strengths but also those cases where legal processes are being misused and abused by legal professionals. Which is why I welcome the calls for further action and robustness from our independent regulator, the Solicitors Regulatory Authority. We need to look again at the SRA's enforcement powers and whether it has the tools it needs to bring both the fines and disciplinary sanctions at those lawyers who let down the reputation of the profession.

That culture change is important; it needs to be a cross-government initiative. Legislation's not worth the paper it's written on if it's not applied properly. And that's why the work led by the Department of Culture, Media and Sport, working with the National Committee for the Safety of Journalists, bringing together government, media, legal, and civil society to track the use of SLAPPs, to look at the ways in which journalists are being targeted, is also an important initiative.

The honorable member for Chichester posed the question, what work are we doing with the legal profession? And I can assure her that I meet regularly with the Solicitors Regulation Authority and that this is frequently a topic of discussion. She asked, quite rightly too, what is the government's position on the forthcoming private members' bill? And as the honorable member for Maldon acknowledged, he and I are in constant contact. We are working together because there is much common ground, and we see that there can be a good way forward that gets the sort of results we need to see on the statute book, striking a coherent balance between the right to access the courts, which must be maintained for people to protect their reputation and their right to privacy, but also, of course, the freedom of expression on the part of journalists and individuals to which many have spoken tonight.

Our conversations have been constructive. We are working closely with one another, as well as with Baroness Stowell in the other place. And I believe and I'm confident that a carefully balanced, proportionate approach, which government can support, is capable of coming forward. And I look forward to continuing that work with him. So to conclude, our focus is on tackling all SLAPPs, this form of abusive litigation used to intimidate and silence public participation.

That is necessary for the integrity of our legal system. It is necessary to protect freedom of expression, and it is necessary to protect democracy itself. So let me thank the honorable member for Leeds Central and Headingley once again for his championing of this critical issue, and to all of those, not just in this chamber, but all those ordinary individuals and brave investigative journalists who determinedly campaign against the abuse of our legal system and for freedom of speech for bringing these matters to the nation's attention.

07:45:57 - 07:46:02

Speaker 308

Alex Sobel to wind up briefly.

07:46:02 - 07:47:12

Alex Sobel

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I think that today's debate has really shone a light on the practice of SLAPPs. And I think that the whole House now really understands the urgency in which we need to move forward. And we have these two opportunities with these private members' bills. And I think that tonight's debate and all the contributions, and in particular actually the minister's winding up, shows the determination right across the House and across parties to once and for all ensure that those speaking up on these vital public interest issues can be heard and are not crushed by those with money and with sort of power which they can now utilize our legal system to ensure that these voices aren't heard.

So once and for all, we can end this terrible practice. Thank you.

07:47:12 - 07:47:15

Speaker 312

I beg to move that this House do now adjourn.

07:47:15 - 07:47:20

Speaker 311

The question is that this House do now adjourn. Greg Smith.

07:47:20 - 07:49:45

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This adjournment debate is on behalf of my late constituent and his family, a tragic case that raises serious questions about emergency response, clinical training, information sharing, and whether the systems meant to save young lives are fit for purpose. On the 31st of January 2024, Adam Ankers, aged just 17, collapsed whilst playing football for the Wycombe Wanderers Foundation under-19 development team. He was a much-loved son, brother, friend, and teammate. He dreamed of a career in professional football, and on the captain's armband he was wearing that day, he had written the words: strength, inspiration, leader, desire.

Despite first aid trained coaches being present, despite a defibrillator being brought straight to the pitch, and despite multiple calls to 999, no one recognized that Adam was in sudden cardiac arrest. No CPR was started. The coroner found that Adam's brain was starved of oxygen for around eight minutes because no one attempted CPR, and heard evidence that for every minute without CPR, the chances of survival decrease by 10%. South Central Ambulance's own serious incident review reached the same conclusion independently, acknowledging an eight-minute period in which CPR should have started and did not. The ambulance itself arrived within 11 minutes of the first 999 call at 14:31, but by then the critical window to act, having been led by telephone, had already been lost.

Very briefly.

07:49:45 - 07:50:12

Jim Shannon

Thank you for giving way, and he tells a very heartsome and very difficult case, and I congratulate him on that. The British Heart Foundation estimates that one person under the age of 35 dies every month in Northern Ireland from an undiagnosed heart condition. In light of this, does the honorable member not agree that more must be done to ensure that the public is equipped to perform effective CPR, to use a defibrillator, so that they are confident in performing bystander CPR?

07:50:12 - 07:59:24

Greg Gregory Smith

I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman for that intervention. I do agree with him, and I will come on to explore many of these issues later in my speech. When paramedics arrived, they found Adam cold, blue, not breathing, and without a pulse. They immediately started CPR and took him to Harefield Hospital with the support of Thames Valley Air Ambulance. Despite the best efforts of clinicians, Adam was declared brain stem dead on the 4th of February, in law the moment of his death, and his heart stopped for the final time on the 5th of February when life support was withdrawn.

His parents, Alistair Ankers and Naomi Wakefield, both work in healthcare. Through devastating experience, they came to the conclusion that Adam's death could have been prevented. Adam's parents fought for more than two years for a proper, in-depth inquest, rather than the four-hour online hearing first offered. They were represented by a single barrister, paid for by remortgaging their house, against an array of solicitors and counsel for the NHS bodies and the Football Association.

That is not a fair fight. The underlying condition was arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy, ARVC, a genetic heart disease whose first sign can be sudden cardiac arrest. This was a failure to identify a life-threatening emergency in real time, and it is why recognition, escalation, and response matter so much. The inquest raised serious concerns about the handling of 999 calls and the ability of call handlers to recognize abnormal breathing and cardiac arrest. Ambulance services in England use one of two systems: MPDS and NHS Pathways.

NHS Pathways is used by just over half of our 999 services and by all 111 services in England, and it was the system used on call that day. The inquest heard expert evidence from paramedic David Davis, not the one of this parish, who told the court: "I am unable to say that NHS Pathways, as is currently configured, can always properly support members of the public to identify ineffective breathing. I am also uncertain as to whether NHS Pathways can adequately identify potential out-of-hospital cardiac arrest where there is seizure-like activity at the outset." That, Madam Deputy Speaker, is about as serious a warning as an expert witness can give. If the system cannot reliably recognize the signs of cardiac arrest, people are being put in danger.

And if the public are left uncertain whether to follow the advice they are given or act on instinct, that is a public safety problem. The coroner issued a five-point prevention of future deaths report on the 16th of April this year, addressed to 13 bodies including NHS England, Department for Health and Social Care, the Football Association, South Central Ambulance Service, the UK National Screening Committee, and Cardiac Risk in the Young. Responses were due by the 11th of June. There is a pattern in those responses: every organization expressed sympathy and described some work underway, but almost none attached a date to anything. NHS England says a genetic service specification is "currently being revised", but with no timetable.

Resuscitation Council UK says responsibility sits with NHS England and the Department, not them. The Association of Ambulance Chief Executives says it is not constituted to mandate or instruct ambulance services. Everybody has pointed to somebody else. And there have been warnings for years about call handlers and cardiac arrest, sepsis, and other conditions, with no clear public evidence of improvement. Why?

I therefore ask the Minister to instruct the Care Quality Commission to urgently and regularly assess ambulance services on call handler skill in detecting and managing abnormal breathing and suspected cardiac arrest. A CQC inspection of South Central Ambulance Service before Adam's death had already found call handlers struggling to recognize abnormal breathing, with serious incidents leading to patient harm as a result, not new information to the trust. South Central Ambulance Service's own response to the coroner's report suggests the public should understand call handlers follow a fixed script and that callers may need to act independently of advice given. If that is genuinely the government's position, that people in the worst moment of their lives should second-guess the emergency services, the public deserve to hear that plainly, not discover it buried in a filing after a child has died.

Training alone, of course, will not be enough. NHS Pathways plays a central role in how millions of emergency and urgent care calls are handled every year. Yet there is strikingly little publicly available data on its safety and effectiveness. That is not good enough. So, will the minister commit to a fully independent review of the effectiveness and the culture of NHS Pathways, not simply a restatement that the National Clinical Assurance Group already provides oversight.

That body assures the clinical safety of dispositions. It does not examine culture, and in terms of reference are set by NHS England, and it reports to NHS England, who are the body who run NHS Pathways. I want to press further on one other point, as it goes to whether the government can even get the basic facts right responding to a dead child's inquest. NHS England's own prevention of future death response states that Adam was triaged through protocol 12, convulsions stroke fitting, an MPDS reference. But the coroner's own findings state that NHS Pathways, a different system owned and run by NHS England itself, was used as the script for that call.

Why did NHS England's response point to the wrong system entirely, rather than confront the failings of the system it actually runs? Did national leadership check its own response against the coroner's findings before sending it? Will it now formally correct the record and explain how that error ever happened? Moving on, there is the question of how genetic risk is communicated within families. Distant relatives in Scotland had known since 2018 that a genetic variant PKP2 associated with ARVC ran in the family.

But that was not passed to Adam's immediate family in full until after his death, and only then because Adam's parents themselves had to go back to that distant relative and ask directly whether there was a letter he had not shared. There was. Once the risk was confirmed, the genetic services' own answer for cascading that information further to the wider family was a brown paper envelope containing 10 photocopied letters, which the family were left to hand round themselves. A grieving family doing the NHS's job of tracing and warning their own relatives with no support offered. Adam's grandmother had in fact raised the family history with her cardiologist at Papworth Hospital, who accepted it was recorded in three places in her notes, but said he had not seen it.

A 2022 referral from the GP was read by this doctor, but never followed up due to an administrative error. Separately, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, which held the original genetic records, refused to disclose them to the English coroner's inquest as falling outside its jurisdiction, and the coroner considered, but decided against, applying to the Scottish High Court to compel cooperation as not a proportionate use of public funds. No family should be told that the truth about their son's death was not proportionate to pursue across a devolved border. So I ask the minister to raise this with his counterparts in the devolved health systems, so no hospital anywhere in this United Kingdom refuses to cooperate with an inquest into a child's death ever again.

07:59:23 - 07:59:24

Very briefly.

07:59:24 - 08:00:08

Peter Swallow

I thank him for giving way. He is making an incredibly powerful case and I know that the tragic death of Adam will be felt across the country, including by my constituents in Sandhurst, where we remember the tragic death of Lewis Marsh in not too dissimilar circumstances around, you know, taking part in sporting activities. He'll be aware that there is screening available for young people who might be at risk of cardiac death and I pay tribute to the work of the charity Cardiac Risk in the Young. Does he agree that we should see more of that rolled out so that young people, particularly those who might be at heightened risk, are made available screening so that they can know that they face this risk?

08:00:08 - 08:03:56

Greg Gregory Smith

I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman. I do agree with him on that point and I'm going to come on to screening in one or two moments. But on that last point, families should not be left to act as their own caseworkers in the aftermath of grief. We need to review how genetic findings are communicated to all of those relatives and how families can be properly supported in doing that work, not simply told, as NHS England and the British Society for Genetic Medicine have both said so far, that a service specification is under review with no date attached. The coroner also raised whether there is adequate sudden cardiac arrest training for coaches and referees at organized football matches.

If young people are taking part in organized sport, those supervising them must know how to respond when something goes wrong. I welcome that the Football Association is exploring improvements and that Adam's parents have engaged constructively with that work. But this should not depend on a grieving family campaigning after a tragedy. It should be standard for every club, not just the accredited ones. I'm also concerned that the English Institute of Sport, Sport England, and the Faculty of Sport and Exercise Medicine UK, all recipients of this prevention of future deaths report, all in receipt of public or National Lottery funding, did not respond to it at all.

Public funding should carry a basic obligation to engage when a coroner writes to them about a child's death. And finally, coming onto the honorable gentleman's point, screening. A specific, checkable gap. Cardiac Risk in the Young estimates 12 apparently fit and healthy young people die of undiagnosed cardiac conditions every week in this country, with no prior symptoms in around 80% of cases. Those are not abstract numbers.

They are lost sons and daughters. The UK National Screening Committee is currently consulting on the evidence and the government should be guided by that work. But I've checked directly what that evidence map actually contains and I want the House to hear this clearly. Its literature searches were conducted on the 10th of April 2025. On the 24th of February 2026, the Journal of the American College of Cardiology published the largest and most relevant UK study ever conducted on this exact question: outcomes from over 104,000 young people screened by Cardiac Risk in the Young over a 10-year period, led by St George's, the University of London.

With real-world data on what actually happened to people after a positive result, precisely the evidence the 2019 review said was missing. That study did not exist when the map's searches were run and I've confirmed directly against the published document that it is not in it. If anyone reaches tonight for the map's citation of an unrelated 2022 cricket screening paper by a different McGloughlin study, I want it on the record now that that is not the same study. So my question is direct. Will the government confirm the evidence map has not considered the February 26 JACC study and commit tonight to it being formally included in the deliberations of the committee when it meets in November, rather than being filed away for a further three-year wait as the map's own conclusion currently recommends?

And if the committee does not recommend population-wide screening, will the minister commit to implementing the FIFA 2025 consensus statement, which recommends screening young footballers aged 12 to 18 as best practice? This is football's home country and its national sport. We should be asking whether we do enough to protect the young people who play it.

08:03:56 - 08:04:44

Julian Lewis

Very briefly. I'm very grateful and my constituent Sue Carter lost her son Ryan aged 25 to sudden adult death syndrome and her friend Charlie Graddidge lost her brother Danny, who had been a friend of Ryan's at scouts together. Had they both been screened, both of those relatives believe that their lost ones would still be alive. And they now spend their time fundraising 7,000 pounds at a time, and they've done this three or four times to enable CRY to screen 100 youngsters and pick up people with irregularities. That's great work, but it oughtn't to be done by private individuals, ought it?

08:04:44 - 08:07:21

Greg Gregory Smith

I'm very grateful to my right honourable friend and entirely agree with him and commend his constituent's wonderful fundraising, but that master point that it shouldn't be left to individuals to have to fundraise for that is an absolutely correct and well-made point. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, to conclude, I have seven requests. First, that the CQC regularly assess call handlers' skill in recognising cardiac arrest and abnormal breathing. Second, a fully independent review of NHS pathways' effectiveness and culture. Third, a correction to the record on which triage system was used and how that error occurred in Adam's case.

Fourth, a dated review of how genetic findings are communicated to relatives, including funding currently dependent on British Heart Foundation charity money to embed genetic testing into coronial pathways. Fifth, proper consideration of the FIFA 2025 statement and the JACC study by the National Screening Committee before it reaches its conclusions in November. Sixth, a statutory duty requiring NHS hospitals in one devolved UK nation to cooperate with inquests in another, so that no hospital anywhere in this United Kingdom can again refuse to disclose records relevant to a child's death. Seventh, and simplest, a meeting between a Minister and Adam's parents. The Football Association has already met with this family.

I struggle to see why the Government cannot manage the same. Madam Deputy Speaker, Adam's family deserve answers and they deserve action. Every organisation that responded to the coroner has been sympathetic, and I believe that sympathy is sincere, but sympathy did not bring Adam home. And it will not stop the next 17-year-old collapsing on the next pitch this winter. What will stop it is somebody in Government saying, "This is mine to fix, and here is the date."

Adam's family have shown extraordinary patience through an inquest, a prevention of future deaths process, and now this debate. What they are asking for is not extraordinary: that the Government reads the evidence, tells the truth about what its own agencies have and have not done, and commits, with dates, to making sure that no other family buries a child because a system could not tell the difference between a boy fighting for breath and a boy breathing normally. I look forward to the Minister's response.

08:07:21 - 08:07:34

Speaker 313

Now, I am conscious there is another member risen and we have but 10 minutes left. She might prefer to confine her comments to an intervention on the minister in the interest of time. James Frith.

08:07:34 - 08:09:44

James Frith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm honored to be standing at the dispatch box as the new Minister for Health Innovation. Let me start by thanking NHS staff for their heroic shifts over the summer months. I also want to thank the honorable member for Mid Buckinghamshire for bringing this debate forward and for speaking with such deep conviction. I am humbled that this is the subject of my first outing in this new role, and I thank him and other members for their work on this important area.

I know the honorable gentleman, through his work and other members' work on the APPG, has already met with my honorable friend, the member for Washington and Gateshead South, in July. Madam Deputy Speaker, reading about it first and listening to the honorable member's account again here, we agree: Adam's death was an absolute tragedy. As a dad, I can't begin to imagine what Adam's mom and dad continue to go through, and I pay tribute to them. It goes without saying, of course, that I would be happy to meet with him and them to discuss what more we can do to change the system, to go through the seven requests in detail, to help save other parents from the same heartbreaking loss that they have endured. I'm determined, Madam Speaker, that the benefits of innovation are felt first and fastest by patients and families as quickly and as safely as possible.

That means accelerating the adoption of technology, digital services, the government's single patient record, and better integration between our national platforms so that relevant information about known conditions, family associations, and medical history can follow the person across services, professionals, and organizations.

08:09:44 - 08:10:11

Speaker 316

I'm very grateful to the minister for giving way. In January 2023, Mia Jennings died suddenly from a cardiac event, a swimming instructor, star apprentice, and by all accounts a wonderful young lady. Since her passing, her family have made incredible efforts to raise money for CRY, over fifty thousand pounds, bringing screening directly to the communities across Macclesfield. Will he join me in commending Mia's family for their extraordinary efforts in her memory?

08:10:11 - 08:12:27

James Frith

I am never failed to be impressed by the sheer determination of humans that have endured the worst of losses to turn such loss into such positive contribution, and of course without hesitation I pay tribute to Mia's family for such fundraising efforts. Sharing and, done properly, innovation can support more joined-up care, more personalized services, and faster sharing and implementation of new guidance and learning. Let me now come in turn to some of the specific points the honorable gentleman has raised. Madam Deputy Speaker, NHS England have made changes to the call script in response to new advice from the Resuscitation Council issued in November 2023. That advice was given just two months before Adam's death.

It is tragic that it had not yet come into force by the time that Adam stepped onto that pitch. As healthcare professionals, Adam's mom and dad will know that these changes would have given him a much better chance of survival, as callers now receive advice to begin life support as well as the certainty of using a defibrillator on a teenager.

The honorable gentleman raised a number of important points about the NHS pathways system. The challenge we face in improving the sensitivity of cardiac arrest identification is to do so in a way that does not generate false positives. Ongoing performance monitoring of NHS pathways finds that the system accepts over triage. This is an intentional safety feature of triage systems and as the honorable gentleman knows at a time when many ambulance services are under such significant strain the management of stretched resources is paramount. He is right in saying that NHS England works with the NHS pathways clinical team ambulance services specialist organizations including Resuscitation Council UK to review data and emerging evidence and to see where we can do better.

I will give way.

08:12:27 - 08:13:19

Speaker 317

Thank you. I'm grateful for the opportunity to intervene on this important debate. As well as being an issue I care about deeply because of the impact on young people in Barrow and Furness I have the privilege of serving as chair for the APPG on cardiac risk in the young. I came to be chair of the APPG after learning about the tragic loss of two Barrow and Furness residents Wilson Sheppard and Vicky Parker. Wilson and Vicky died only two weeks apart and a few miles away from each other in 2023 and both deaths should have been preventable and I pay tribute to their moms Leslie Meese and Donna Parker for their tireless campaigning.

Will the government commit to developing a national strategy for the prevention of young sudden cardiac death in places like Barrow and Furness and across the country bringing together screening expert cardiac pathology and inherited cardiac conditions and the identification and investigation of blackouts?

08:13:19 - 08:13:41

James Frith

Thank you. I thank my honorable friend for her intervention. I'd be very happy to discuss the requests in person and pay tribute also to the families of Wilson and Vicky. The impact of defibs more and more of defibs being available is incredibly important and very happy to speak in more detail on that issue. I'd give way.

08:13:41 - 08:14:12

Amanda Hack

I thank the minister for giving way. I went to see Glenfield Hospital in the summer to talk to them about their genetic testing that they do at Glenfield Hospital which is amazing. I think one of the things that actually strikes me through all of the conversations I've had as the former chair of the APPG is actually about how much work could be done in A and E to strengthen that pathway. So what could the minister tell us about looking at ECGs after some people have been tested in A and E that could go back to cardiologists?

08:14:12 - 08:17:35

James Frith

I hope I will cover thank you for the intervention thank her for her intervention. I hope I will cover and do justice to those points important points. NHS pathways Madam Deputy Speaker also give providers call level CPR data to support local reviews and improve quality as well as review data and emerging evidence to see where we must do better. They send quarterly reports to the National Clinical Assurance Group which is made up of senior clinicians drawn from Royal Colleges professional bodies and urgent and emergency care services. These professionals can and often do submit constructive feedback to the way that pathways are run.

Madam Deputy Speaker at present NHS clinical staff are trained in CPR but from April 2027 this will be extended to all NHS staff including those in A and E. The rollout of this training will take time but it will hugely increase the number of people in the country with valuable life saving knowledge. Finally when it comes to recognizing cardiac arrest I can confirm that the Quality Care Commission does assess call handlers skill as part of its inspections. We know that no human system is perfect and I am all too aware that a list or accounts as this can risk sounding defensive. So let me repeat my openness to sitting with him and Adam's parents and colleagues to ensure we see how and where we may or can do better and go further.

Turning to his points around genetics, I'm hugely optimistic about the potential of genomics and life sciences over the next 10 years. The NHS clinical genetics services delivers a comprehensive clinical genetics and genetic counseling service for individuals with a family history of genetic conditions including cardiac conditions. They provide a detailed review of family history that can direct the diagnosis, risk assessment and lifelong clinical management of patients of all ages and their families who have or at risk or are at risk of having a genomic condition. The current specification for clinical genetics services was published more than a decade ago under the previous government and is no longer fit for purpose, not least because this is one of the most innovative fields in healthcare. Today specialist clinical services simply do not have the capacity or infrastructure to contact family members proactively, except where there is a particularly high risk that has already been identified.

For me in my work, it's a clear example of why innovation must help connect our public services. So NHS England's genomics program working with the genomics clinical reference group has done a review of the 17 regional NHS clinical genetics services. This has shone a light on the challenges addressed to be addressed in the service to match the government's expectations. I am, I am coming to a close Madam Speaker. I am unable to confirm a specific date for the honorable gentleman, but suffice to say there is much more to be done before expectations are met by service.

On his point about UK National Screening Committee, it is true the draft recommendations have been consulted on and did not find that the current scientific evidence Order. The House stands adjourned.