House of Commons

29 October 2026

Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
34:07 - 35:22
Speaker 1
Colleagues, before we come to transport questions, I'd like to pay tribute to a long-standing member of the House administration.  Sue Holt, who passed away last week.  Sue had worked in the House administration for 39 years and was known to many members across both Houses for her work in the Inter-Parliamentary Relations Office supporting international delegations.  Sue was spirited, good-humoured, hard-working.  She will be very much missed and our thoughts are with her family, friends and the team that she worked with. 

It is the sad news I've had to bring to the House.  Colleagues, also it would be remiss of me not to mark the fact that this is the final day for Tom Goldsmith, our current Clerk of the House.  He'll sit at the table well Tom, I know the whole House will join me in thanking you for your service, wishing you all the very best in the future.  And for those who don't know, Tom knows every Carry On character, he knows every Carry On film.  So what I would say is, Carry On Clerk. 
35:22 - 35:25
Speaker 3
We now come to Transport Questions, Chris Berry. 
35:25 - 35:28
Speaker 2
Question number one, Mr Speaker. 
35:28 - 35:29
Minister. 
35:29 - 36:02
Speaker 4
Thank you, Mr Speaker, can I on behalf of the Government add our wishes to Tom on his final day. 

With your permission, Mr. Speaker, I would answer this question together with question 18.  The government recognizes the importance of promoting active travel.  On the 12th of June, we published the third cycling and walking investment strategy, which sets out our ambitious targets for active travel in England.  The strategy is supported by over 4.5 billion pounds of projected investment through to 2030, helping to make walking, wheeling, and cycling a safe and attractive choice for everyday trips. 
36:02 - 36:03
Chris Murray. 
36:03 - 36:42
Speaker 5
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.  The Tour de France starts in my constituency in July, and Portobello High School's Girls God Cycling project has already got over 70 girls onto bikes.  It's now being extended across Scotland. 

The Grand Départ trophy visited Portobello this month to mark the race's first start in Scotland and to recognise the girls' excellent work.  So can I ask what the government is doing to capture that energy and inspire the next generation of cyclists?  And can I invite ministers to Edinburgh in this Tour de France year to meet our impressive cyclists? 

36:42 - 37:28

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, can I first of all agree with my honourable friend that the Tour de France is an amazing opportunity to inspire more people to walk and cycle, and what a wonderful constituency for them to appear in. Active travel, of course, is a devolved matter, but officials from the Department for Transport and Transport Scotland do meet regularly to discuss active travel, most recently in September. And I want to pay tribute to the work of Portobello High School. Cycling is a fantastic way to get around whilst cutting emissions and keeping fit.

In England, we are investing 135 million pounds in schemes such as Bikeability cycle training, with over half a million children receiving training each year. Alongside this, we are supporting delivery of safer networks, enabling more children to walk, wheel and cycle to school. So I will look into seeing whether we can visit to enjoy some of the benefits of these schemes along with the honourable member.

37:28 - 38:07

Julie Minns

Thank you, Mr Speaker, and just to continue the theme of the Tour de France, after it leaves my honourable friend's constituency, it will finish its first leg in Carlisle. And indeed, I think we can all agree that cycling and e-bikes do play a very important role in active travel. However, so many members on this side of the House have become very concerned about illegal e-bikes that do not meet the definition of an electrically assisted pedal cycle, and it's doing great damage to the reputation of cycling.

So will the Minister meet with me and other members on this side of the House to discuss a ban on the sale of illegal e-bikes so that we can actually focus on the positives of cycling in the Tour de France?

38:07 - 39:05

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, can I first of all congratulate my honourable friend on the news that the Tour de France's opening stages will be finishing in Carlisle next year, and I hope that she will be claiming the yellow jersey at that point. But Mr. Speaker, she makes a very important point. I think honourable members on all sides of this House are concerned about illegal e-bikes, and they, to be clear, have no place on our roads. It is far too easy at the moment for retailers to put in the fine print that these vehicles are for use only on private land, and for consumers to buy them then before using them illegally on public roads without even realizing that they are doing so. So I'm keen to explore how we tackle this issue as a government, including through the newly established cross-government ministerial group on this issue.

In the meantime, I'll be writing to retailers and online marketplaces to remind them of their responsibilities on marketing these products responsibly. And of course, I am happy to meet my honorable friend and other interested members on this subject.

39:05 - 39:07

Lindsay Hoyle

Sir Roger Gale.

39:07 - 40:28

Roger Gale

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, may I first associate myself with your remarks relating to the sad loss of Sue Holt. During my time as the leader of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, I found Sue to be always there, always cheerful, always helpful, as did the whole of the delegation that I was privileged to lead. We shall miss her dreadfully. And while also supporting your remarks, Mr. Speaker, could I say that during my time as an acting Deputy Speaker, I leant very heavily on the wise advice of Tom Goldsmith.

And I wish him, I wish him every happiness in whatever he chooses to do next. Mr. Speaker, I'm sure the whole House will associate itself with the support for active travel in general and cycling in particular. But there is a downside. The growth in the number of cyclists has led to a clear growth in the number of cycling offences. Cyclists on pavements, cyclists crashing through red traffic lights, cyclists cycling at night without lights at all.

Does the Minister have any information about prosecution relating to these offences?

40:28 - 40:29

Minister.

40:29 - 41:12

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, I think the right honourable member raises some very important points. I think we've all seen irresponsible cycling, but let's be clear, cycling on pavements is an offence except where it's permitted and police can take action and do take action against careless or dangerous cycling. As he will know, the Crime and Policing Act 2024 introduced new offences covering death or serious injury caused by dangerous, careless or inconsiderate cycling. And we've also recently written to food delivery companies emphasizing the need for them to ensure that their riders are acting legally and responsibly when undertaking their duties. But I understand what the honourable member is saying and we'll certainly look into that further.

41:12 - 41:13

Ruth Edwards.

41:13 - 42:10

Marie Goldman

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I also associate myself with your remarks regarding the outgoing Clerk of the House, Tom Goldsmith, for whom I've spent many an hour sitting in various meetings together and I very much appreciate his wise words as well. Mr. Speaker, I'd like to follow on the theme about active travel.

E-bikes and e-scooters are an incredibly part of active travel. In my constituency of Chelmsford, we have a trial which has been going on actually for several years of e-scooters and that's fabulous. But unfortunately, it means it's also led to a rise in illegal e-scooters. The Essex Police, when I met with them recently, tell me that they are difficult to intercept, but when they do intercept them, it's difficult for them to be able to store them when they confiscate them because of the concerns about battery fires, for example. The problem is so many people when they buy e-bikes or e-scooters don't realise that they are illegal to ride.

And we really do need to do something about that because actually it's the people who buy them that end up paying the price if they don't understand that they can't use them and Essex Police have to pick up the pieces.

42:10 - 42:12

Speaker 10

Minister.

42:12 - 42:35

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

I think the honourable member makes a a very fair point. One of the purposes of the cross-departmental working group is to work with Home Office officials and ministers to understand what the limitations are on police action and see whether we can find new and novel methods of actually tackling this issue. So any information that she's got from her local constabulary we'd be very grateful to receive it.

42:35 - 42:36

Nick Smith shadow minister.

42:36 - 43:33

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you Mr Speaker and can I associate the thoughts of the official opposition with your comments in regard to the sad loss of Sue Holt and send our condolences to her family and friends. And likewise as many of the Carry On films were made in Buckinghamshire at Pinewood Studios wish the Clerk of the House a very happy retirement.

Now, Mr. Speaker, the government has been warned by over 290 organisations that its guidance on dangerous floating bus stops puts visually impaired people, deaf people, and people with mobility issues at risk. So will the Minister acknowledge that cycling and active travel infrastructure must not come at the expense of disabled people's safety, and that some proponents of active travel, including those within the Department for Transport itself, must stop compromising the safety of disabled people who simply want to use public transport?

43:33 - 44:15

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Well, can we be absolutely clear that this department does not compromise the safety of anyone when they're crossing the road. The department's actually published statutory guidance on the provision and design of floating bus stops with Active Travel England in January of this year. And all traffic authorities must have regard to this guidance. It does actually provide very clear advice on floating bus stops to design them in the mind of passengers, cyclists, and pedestrians. So actually, the most concerning and troublesome of these floating bus stops are actually no longer being built.

But we are continuing to work on this, and we absolutely understand the concerns, and we're absolutely determined to deal with this.

44:15 - 44:17

Lindsay Hoyle

Luke Glover, Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

44:17 - 44:48

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I join you in paying tribute to both Sue Holt and Mr. Goldsmith. There is growing interest in the issue of illegally modified e-bikes and their use, as shown by comments in this House, but also a Westminster Hall debate last week and new policy passed at last month's Liberal Democrat conference. So to ensure that e-bikes support rather than hinder the growth of active travel, can I ask the Minister, he's talked about this cross-government working group, but will he commit to creating an action plan based on that to tackle the issue with clear timescales and owners?

If he did, he would have our support.

44:48 - 45:17

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, I can assure the opposition spokesperson that there is already an action plan. There are a number of issues that we've identified, actually building on some of the work from the all-party group's recommendations, and that will be fed into this cross-departmental working group. So we absolutely hear what the honorable member, indeed all honorable members, are saying about this. We need to get our roads safe, we need to get this plague of illegal e-bikes sorted out once and for all, and this government is determined to do that.

45:17 - 45:20

Speaker 14

Question number two please, Mr. Speaker.

45:20 - 45:51

Simon Lightwood

Well, good morning, Mr. Speaker.

Last week, the government launched the Share the Carriage, Not the Noise campaign with rail operators across the country, reminding rail passengers to use headphones or potentially face fines of up to a thousand pounds. The Bus Services Act also gives local authorities new powers to crack down on nuisance behaviour on buses, including loud music, littering, vaping, and anti-social behaviour. Our new guidance will help authorities put these powers into practice and make journeys safer and more comfortable for passengers.

45:51 - 45:53

Speaker 16

Tom Rutland.

45:53 - 46:19

Thomas William Rutland

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There is nothing more irritating than being sat on a train or a bus and being subjected to someone scrolling through endless videos or blasting music out loud.

So can I welcome the department's action against these headphone dodgers? Can my right honorable friend or honorable friend set out how this will be enforced to ensure that we reclaim our public transport from nuisance passengers and restore some tranquility on our journeys?

46:19 - 46:52

Simon Lightwood

Absolutely. Our Share the Journey, Not the Noise campaign has started a national conversation about how the standards we should all expect on trains, reminding those few who fall short that there are fines in place. We expect that most passengers will comply with requests to watch videos on silent or use headphones, but there are clear routes for escalation if not, up to and including prosecution. Local authorities can introduce bus by-laws now, covering excessive noise with fixed on-the-spot penalties of up to 100 pounds.

46:52 - 47:15

Benedicta Wera Hobhouse

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Well, we Liberal Democrats are very pleased that the government has listened to our calls to tackle headphone dodgers. But can I ask again, because I haven't really heard an answer to the previous question, how is this going to be visibly enforced so in Bath my public transport users can actually be sure that something is happening?

47:14 - 47:56

Simon Lightwood

Anti-social behavior on buses is tackled through wider crime and policing laws. Transport safety officers, of which the department also funded trials, will also be used. It's about giving local transport authorities the powers to enforce these. That came with, obviously, Liberal Democrats working on the committee in the Bus Services Act as well. We introduced those bylaws to do that.

Of course.

We've been tackling nuisance behavior on public transport for a long time now. It's an ongoing priority. We invested 2.5 million pounds, actually, in those transport safety officer pilots into targeted action against nuisance behavior, publishing guidance so others can adopt that best practice. And of course, the Bus Services Act gives those powers to every local authority now to instigate those bylaws.

47:56 - 48:05

Catherine Fookes

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Over 1,500 local people... Oh, sorry, question three, please.

48:05 - 48:46

Speaker 20

With your permission, Mr. Speaker, I would like to answer this question along with question seven. For too many disabled people, the railway remains a system of barriers rather than connections. To improve disability at stations, we continue to deliver step-free access through the Access for All program. And since July of 2024, we have completed improvements at 31 stations across the country. A further 22 are in progress on site at the moment, and 36 are in design.

Last month, we also committed to making level boarding from train to platform a baseline expectation for all new GBR trains.

48:46 - 48:47

Catherine Fookes.

48:47 - 49:26

Catherine Fookes

Thank you. I thank the Secretary of State for her answer.

But over 1,500 people have signed my petition to make Chepstow station fully accessible. Currently disabled travellers need to go east into England, cross over a road, get back on a train and travel back through Chepstow to go west to Cardiff. So Chepstow residents were really incredibly disappointed that they missed out on the last round of Access for All funding, despite being near top of the priority list from Welsh Government to Westminster. So can the Secretary of State please confirm when the next Access for All round will begin and when Chepstow station will be fully accessible to residents?

49:26 - 50:02

Speaker 20

I'm grateful to my honourable friend for that question and she paints a very vivid picture of how critical accessible stations are, not just to her constituents but to people travelling across the country.

She will know that Chepstow was nominated for Access for All funding in 2022 but was not selected for funding by the previous government. Future funding beyond what I spoke about in my first answer will be considered at the next spending review and I'd be keen to work with her to understand how that case can be put forward at that time.

50:02 - 50:37

Josh Dean

Thank you very much Mr. Speaker. Disabled residents and anyone who relies on the lift at Bishop's Stortford train station have found it consistently out of service in recent months and it's making it harder for them to get to work, school and other activities. I understand that discussions regarding a long-term fix are ongoing, however our community still lacks clarity on what these works will involve and when they might take place. The Rail Minister kindly supported my campaign to get the platform one lift at Hertford North train station over the line.

I'd be grateful if Ministers could lend their support again by asking Network Rail and Greater Anglia to bring forward a clear plan for restoring reliable step-free access in Bishop's Stortford.

50:37 - 51:09

Speaker 20

I'm very sorry to hear about the problems that my honourable friend's constituents are experiencing at Bishop's Stortford station. I am aware of these problems and know that it was further impacted by the extreme temperatures this summer. A full lift replacement is planned for 2028, but I realise that this will sound like a long way off for his constituents. So in the short term, I will ask my officials to meet with Greater Anglia to explore how we can alleviate disruption for residents, and I'd be happy to keep him updated.

51:09 - 51:37

David Mundell

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I just put on the record that the Tour de France will be passing through my constituency twice?

Can I ask the Secretary of State if she will investigate the position in relation to Kirkconnel station in my constituency on the Nith Valley line? Kirkconnel is a former mining community with an older population, and many people are unable to use the station because of infirmity or poor mobility.

51:37 - 51:53

Speaker 20

Matters relating to the railways, as he will know, are a devolved matter, but I will look into the issues of accessibility at the station he refers and progress any necessary conversations with colleagues in the Scottish Government.

51:53 - 52:13

Paul William Forster

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One of the lifts at Woking station was out of service for 40 days in one year, and constituents in West Byfleet have complained the station's platform there is too high for them to use safely.

What is the Secretary of State doing to make sure stations on the South Western Railway line are accessible for all?

Minister.

52:13 - 52:41

Speaker 20

As I said in my earlier answer, we do have a programme of work that is happening across the country at the moment, whether it's further design work on stations or actually construction works underway at the moment. With reference to the two particular stations that he mentions, Woking and West Byfleet, I'd be happy to look at some of the more the detail about that and to discuss with him whether future improvements could come forward as part of the next spending review.

52:41 - 52:42

Shaun Hodgs.

52:42 - 52:44

Speaker 24

Question number four, Mr. Speaker.

52:44 - 52:45

Minister.

52:45 - 53:09

Victoria Collins

Good morning, Mr. Speaker. The Government recognizes that airport drop-off charges can be a source of real frustration for passengers, particularly where payment arrangements are unclear, signage is difficult to follow, or motorists face additional charges for late payment.

Recognizing concerns on the impact of drop-off charges on passengers, the government's committed to undertake a review to ensure that travel remains accessible and that passengers are treated fairly.

53:09 - 53:58

Sharon Hodgson

I thank the Minister for that answer, but I'm sure he recognizes that charges at UK airports for drop-offs have risen sharply in recent years, with Newcastle now charging six pound while London Stansted and Gatwick both charge ten pound, even though drop-offs are totally free at most major European airports, including eight of Europe's ten busiest. Now, the airports justify this as a much-needed income stream, but for many travelers, it just feels more like pinching the pockets of hardworking families. So is the Minister able to elaborate? He mentioned the review.

Can he elaborate on the promise to review these charges and will this review address the issues of affordability and accessibility for my constituents?

53:58 - 54:39

Victoria Collins

Well let me thank my honourable friend for a question and let me be clear we do expect airports to treat passengers fairly and to ensure that travel remains accessible. The review is going to look at the impacts of airport drop-off charges on users of airport services. The detailed scope is going to be developed as part of the review process but it could include affordability, accessibility, travel behaviour and the experiences of different groups of passengers.

More broadly, the Civil Aviation Bill, which has just been brought through committee, seeks to modernise the United Kingdom's aviation legislative framework, with one of its key objectives being to strengthen consumer rights and protections, particularly for those who travel with disabilities.

54:39 - 55:12

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much indeed, Mr Speaker. And I really do welcome the government's U-turn adopting Conservative policy and deciding to review airport drop-off charges. But in response to my written question, the Minister did not confirm that the government's own anti-car surface access targets, the 100% plus increase in business rates that many airports have faced, or the crippling increases in employment taxes would form part of that review. So will the Minister agree to ensure that all these important factors form part of the inquiry into what is leading to airport drop-off charges soaring under his government?

55:12 - 55:52

Victoria Collins

The Shadow Secretary of State for Transport seems to not want to face up to the fact that this government is taking decisive action to help our airports and airlines, whether that be signing off airport expansion across the country or modernising our airspace to both provide community benefit alongside those efficiencies.

I've already been clear that the review itself is going to look at questions around affordability, access to airports. That is the right way to ensure that we have a system that's both proportionate for consumers and airport users, whilst also reflecting the fact, as he mentioned in his question, that often planning considerations are built in with mode share targets linked to airport drop-off charges. This government will take a proportionate approach to that review and to the aviation sector as a whole.

55:52 - 55:54

Lindsay Hoyle

James Shannon.

55:54 - 56:06

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Two days running on the order paper, time to buy a lottery ticket. Question number five.

56:06 - 56:16

Speaker 20

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My department regularly discusses roadworks and other highways matters with the Northern Ireland Executive through the UK Roads Leadership Group.

56:16 - 56:18

Speaker 29

James Shannon.

56:18 - 56:58

Jim Shannon

Can I thank the Secretary very much for that? And I'm glad to hear that the Minister has discussions with the local Minister at the Northern Ireland Assembly.

One of the examples is the A25, the Castleward Road in Strangford. The issues are that local businesses are finding their trade reduced by some 90%. And there is a, I believe, a sensible solution, that is to work at nighttime. I suggested that to the department back home as a way of alleviating the impact upon local businesses. So can the Minister ensure that those discussions take place at a time when businesses are struggling to meet their basic staffing and operating costs?

This, I believe, is essential to protect our traders. Thanks so much.

56:58 - 57:33

Speaker 20

I completely understand why the honorable gentleman raises these matters, whether it's people traveling on the roads or businesses that are impacted by roadworks across the entirety of the UK, these impacts are felt. We have been discussing these matters through the UK Roads Leadership Group, and I can tell him that a code of practice was recently published which provides guidance for authorities on how to better coordinate roadworks with neighboring authorities and with utilities, considering overnight works, for example, to minimize disruption.

57:33 - 57:34

Deidre Costigan.

57:34 - 58:06

Deirdre Theresa Costigan

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Northern Ireland Street Works Order 2007 would allow the Northern Ireland Executive to bring in a lane rental scheme to charge contractors a daily rate for disruptive roadworks, but they've chosen not to take this position. Will the Minister extol the virtues of the lane rental scheme to the Northern Ireland Executive, and while she's at it, will she take the final steps to give the lane rental powers under the English Devolution Act to the Mayor of London to cut traffic in Ealing Southall too?

58:06 - 58:10

Lindsay Hoyle

I think we'll stick with Northern Ireland. You pick which account, Secretary of State.

58:10 - 58:37

Speaker 20

Mr. Speaker, I'll do my best to address both elements of those because I know from my experience as the Deputy Mayor for London what an important difference lane rental schemes can make to how the most disruptive impacts can be managed. And I will certainly pursue discussions with the Northern Ireland Executive about lane rental because I know it could make a real difference in that part of the UK as well.

58:37 - 58:44

Charles David Robertson

Dan Roberts. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and good morning. Question number six, please.

58:44 - 59:16

Speaker 20

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With your permission, I'd like to answer this question along with question 10.

For too long, our railways have not been run in the service of passengers. We are turning this around with six operators already brought into public ownership under this government and Great Western being renationalised on the 13th of December. Next year, the creation of Great British Railways will bring the management of track and train together, ending decades of fragmentation and delivering better and more reliable services for passengers.

59:16 - 59:40

Charles David Robertson

Dave Robertson. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents rely on the Cross City line to get them in and out of Birmingham. But of an evening, the last train back from Birmingham doesn't run as far as Lichfield, meaning we can't make the most of the nightlife there.

As Christmas approaches, will the Minister agree with me that it's time to change that and boost the evening service from New Street to Lichfield City so my constituents can make the best of Birmingham's Frankfurt Christmas market?

59:40 - 01:00:11

Speaker 20

I thank my honorable friend for his tireless campaigning on rail issues, and I know that these services would make a real difference for his constituents over the Christmas period. I do welcome the work done by West Midlands Trains and the local community on developing proposals for this trial. I think our publicly owned railways should work in the service of passengers, and I think these extra trains would be a great example of this, and I very much back my honorable friend's call for this trial to take place.

01:00:11 - 01:00:52

Speaker 35

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I thank my right honorable friend? My Cardiff East constituents were absolutely delighted yesterday with the announcement of 30 million pounds for Cardiff Parkway station. We're the only constituency in the capital city without a train station, and so it's going to be transformational for growth, for jobs, and for travel.

Now, before the Senedd election, the Welsh Labour government agreed to a funding contribution alongside private investors to ensure that this project is delivered. Can she confirm, please, whether in the five months since that election, the minority Plaid government has said it will honour that intergovernmental agreement?

01:00:52 - 01:01:32

Speaker 20

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It is now for the new Welsh government to confirm its own contribution to this project so that we can get on and deliver it as quickly as possible.

To my knowledge, no such confirmation has been provided to date. I'm really pleased that we confirmed our contribution yesterday as part of the budget. And I would like to congratulate my right honourable friend for her campaigning on this issue, not just for her constituents, but as an excellent former Welsh Secretary. It was an absolute delight to work alongside her and to be able to start to put right the historic wrongs of underinvestment in the Welsh railways.

01:01:32 - 01:02:15

Paul Stephen Barclay

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Could I constructively suggest a way that the Secretary of State could help three cabinet colleagues: the DEFRA Secretary, who's building a major reservoir in my constituency, the Housing Secretary, with big plans within Cambridge, and the Chancellor, who often talks about the Oxford-Cambridge Arc. Securing a light rail link to the reservoir will shape public response to it. The Department for Transport currently doesn't seem to be involved at all with the other departments of government.

I don't expect her to be familiar with the scheme, it's primarily for one of her colleagues, but could the department perhaps write to me setting out what the department could do to help those other departments deliver on their aims?

01:02:15 - 01:02:42

Speaker 20

Mr. Speaker, this government is investing considerably in improving rail services and public transport connections in Cambridgeshire. I'd be happy to follow up on the detail of his proposal, but I would just recognize in the East West Rail proposals linking Oxford to Cambridge, the opening of the new station at Cambridge South, there is significant investment going into this part of the country, but I will come back to him on the detail that he raises.

01:02:42 - 01:03:06

Thomas Gordon

Mr. Speaker, in yesterday's budget there was one mention of Northern Powerhouse Rail. One of the easiest ways to deliver benefit for passengers would be to unlock the indefinitely paused York area capacity scheme.

Will the Secretary of State commit to continuing to look at this and make sure that passengers in Harrogate and Knaresborough and across that line can get the trains when they need them with the service that they should expect?

Secretary of State.

01:03:06 - 01:03:39

Speaker 20

Mr. Speaker, as part of Northern Powerhouse Rail, we are prioritizing improvements in the Yorkshire region, services from York to Leeds, between Sheffield and Bradford and Leeds. Indeed, I was in Bradford just last week to make the announcement about a brand new station at Bradford, which is much needed. I know he continues to champion the case for the York area capacity study. We will continue to keep all of this under review because we do need to make sure that we're providing the right number of trains where people need them and when they need them.

01:03:39 - 01:03:41

Speaker 38

Marie Tidball.

01:03:41 - 01:04:28

Marie Tidball

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

The Penistone line, which runs through my constituency, serves over half a million people, eight constituencies, six hospitals, four universities, and a network of colleges, schools, and GP surgeries, but only has one train an hour. Our government is funding phase one of upgrading this line, but further funding is needed to deliver phase two to enable two trains an hour along our line, the spine which connects South and West Yorkshire. Does the Minister agree with me that delivering both phases of upgrades together most effectively secures two trains an hour, and will the Minister meet with me ahead of the next spending review to discuss delivering the full upgrade and two trains an hour to ensure growth in every postcode along the line?

01:04:28 - 01:04:49

Speaker 20

I know my honorable friend and I have met before on this issue, and she is right to say that the government is making that investment in phase one, and I remember discussing this with her when I was at Sheffield station as part of the Northern Powerhouse Rail announcements earlier this year.

I'd be happy to continue those conversations about phase two as we head into the next spending review.

01:04:49 - 01:04:51

Speaker 41

Leigh Wilson.

01:04:51 - 01:05:22

Munira Wilson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My London constituency doesn't have a tube service. My residents are entirely reliant on the South Western Railway services to get to work, to school and elsewhere. For stations like Hampton and Whitton, we've seen passenger footfall close to or exceed half a million in the last year, yet the services are infrequent and less reliable since nationalization. So will the Secretary of State back my calls, supported by thousands of local residents, with the timetable review underway, that we should get far more frequent and reliable services for stations like those?

01:05:22 - 01:05:23

Speaker 40

Secretary of State.

01:05:23 - 01:06:03

Speaker 20

The honourable lady is right to mention the timetable review that is underway, and I'd be happy to discuss with South Western what the options are with regard to Hampton and Whitton. I would just note one of the benefits of renationalising South Western Railways has been the rollout of the new Arterio fleet of trains, air-conditioned trains that are providing more capacity. I would also recognise the important work that South Western have done to reduce the number of cancellations that are coming about as a consequence of the unavailability of staff. We need to get the basics right on South Western in order to provide the service that she and her constituents deserve.

01:06:03 - 01:06:08

Speaker 43

Alison Griffiths, Shadow Minister.

01:06:08 - 01:06:56

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Labour promised that nationalisation would deliver a more reliable railway. Two years on, it is getting worse.

Between April and June, all government-run operators saw cancellations rise or punctuality fall. Ministers say that Great British Railways will turn this around when it launches next year. They promised its implementation timetable and draft license consultation this autumn. On this last sitting day of October, neither has yet appeared. So when will they?

And when will passengers see the improvements they were promised?

01:06:56 - 01:07:57

Speaker 20

Speaker, can I start by congratulating the lady on her appointment to the front bench?

I think this is the first opportunity that I've had chance to do so from the dispatch box. She is right in some respects. We do need to make more progress on improving punctuality and reliability, and I can't pretend that I'm happy with performance across the entirety of the rail network at the moment. But what I would gently point out to her is that at the last reporting period, cancellations across publicly owned operators were 3.9% compared with compared to 4.9% for operators yet to transfer and still in private ownership. And on punctuality, 82.6% of stops by publicly owned operators were were within three minutes of their scheduled arrival time, compared with just 73.8% for operators yet to transfer.

01:07:57 - 01:08:00

Speaker 45

I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

01:08:00 - 01:08:29

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A £1 billion order for 29 new five-car battery electric trains for TransPennine Express was recently announced. Whilst welcome, it has raised some eyebrows, with Modern Railways magazine estimating that the cost is nearly double that of conventional electric-only trains. It would cost a staggering £25.2 billion for similar deals to replace England's passenger trains which have diesel engines. Are we on the right value-for-money track with this approach to rolling stock specification and procurement?

01:08:29 - 01:09:00

Speaker 20

I was delighted to be in Derby a few weeks ago to announce the new fleet of battery electric trains for TransPennine Express. It is a £1.2 billion investment. Included in that is hundreds of millions of pounds of maintenance costs for the duration of that contract.

We are working on procurements for both Southeastern trains and Northern trains at the moment, and value for money and affordability will be central to the decisions we make on those procurements going forward.

Christopher Vince.

01:09:00 - 01:09:03

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Number eight.

01:09:04 - 01:09:26

Victoria Collins

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Through our Civil Aviation Bill, we're cutting down on the cost and the stress of flying for families across the country. Our changes mean that airlines on all UK flights will be required to seat children under the age of 14 with a parent free of charge, and that simple name errors on bookings can be fixed for free, ending unfair and irritating charges.

01:09:26 - 01:09:51

Christopher John Vince

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. If my Harlow constituency wasn't brilliant enough, we actually have an international airport on our doorstep, with Stansted Airport providing jobs for over a thousand people from Harlow and even more of those on apprenticeships.

With the planning application for the expansion of Stansted Airport approved, would the Minister put his backing behind this vital project and agree that he will work with local partners to ensure it really benefits my constituents of Harlow?

01:09:51 - 01:10:31

Victoria Collins

Well, let me thank my honorable friend for his question. This government welcomes the 1.1 billion pound investment into Stansted by Manchester Airports Group, which is going to transform the airport and provide wider benefits to the local area, including Harlow, of which I know my honorable friend is a determined champion. This investment is a great example of the conditions for growth in our aviation sector that this government has created. It's going to support jobs, local businesses and skills with the planned expansion of Stansted Airport College in collaboration with Harlow College, with 5 million pounds worth of funding by the Department for Education. This shows that the government has a strategy which is delivering both for the aviation sector more broadly and for communities like Harlow.

01:10:31 - 01:10:33

Speaker 48

Number nine, Mr. Speaker.

01:10:33 - 01:10:55

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In 2025-26 the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency issued 12.3 million driving licenses, processed over 100 million individual customer transactions and issued 18.5 million vehicle registration certificates. We recognize that improvement is needed on the time taken to process medical driving license applications and plans are in place to address this.

01:10:56 - 01:11:33

Luke Morgan Evans

I'm grateful to the Minister for his answer, but I've got an increasing number of constituents who are coming to me with problems getting their license. One such example was a lady who had dementia, passed all the tests and had months and months of delays trying to get her license, having to take her complaint to the Chief Executive to get an answer, only for it to be backdated and having to go through the whole rigmarole again in a few months' time. This isn't an isolated case.

I have diabetes patients, I have epilepsy constituents who are all suffering. So what is the Minister doing to make sure that we can speed this up so people can get back on the road as soon as they're medically fit?

01:11:33 - 01:12:13

Justin Piers Richard Madders

I recognize the concerns the honorable member has raised and I have asked for further information on some of the individual issues that he has raised. We are taking steps to tackle this issue. We've introduced a new digital casework system, we're recruiting additional staff, there are automation of routine processes happening. Things are moving in the right direction, Mr. Speaker. In 2022-23, the average number of working days to complete a medical licensing application was 89.

This time last year it was 76. It's now down to 66. We want to get this down to 45 by March of next year and I can assure the honorable gentleman that we will do everything in our power to make sure that happens.

01:12:13 - 01:13:21

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

I'm not certain the Minister is right when he says the DVLA is getting better. Their operating surplus is forecast to collapse by 54%. DVLA is spending £96 million a year on postage and printing, despite a plan to move 85% of transactions online. The DVLA is committed to delivering £5 million in efficiency savings, yet expenditure is forecast to increase by £59 million in the same year.

And as my honourable friend said, the position on medical licensing is just out of control, particularly when a written parliamentary question recently revealed that the average time for a bus and lorry driver to get a decision is still an unacceptably high 64.8 days from August. So can the minister come back with a very detailed plan on how his department is going to get a grip on what can only be described right now as a failing government agency?

01:13:21 - 01:13:44

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, if the agency was failing, that was the condition we found it in when his party left office. I'm not entirely sure what the opposition spokesperson is complaining about. He's saying we're spending more money on the agency, but that's actually to increase the number of staff, to improve the automation and digital services and take to actually make the service more efficient. There is a plan and it's working. I think he should actually support it.

01:13:44 - 01:13:45

Steve Darling.

01:13:45 - 01:13:47

Speaker 50

Question 11, Mr. Speaker.

01:13:48 - 01:14:13

Victoria Collins

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Regional airports are vital gateways for passengers and major sources of local employment. The UK aviation sector operates in a commercial market with airports attracting passengers and airlines responding to demand through route development. The UK government supports airport growth across the country and through the Aviation Council, which I co-chair, and its regional connectivity working group, we're examining the challenges and opportunities facing regional airports.

01:14:13 - 01:14:44

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Regional airports such as Exeter should be an engine for economic growth. However, one often sees that the airports' services gravitate towards larger regional airports.

Would the Minister give some further information on how the Minister is seeking to ensure that more peripheral airports such as Exeter are strongly supported to be the engine for economic change that they could be?

01:14:44 - 01:15:33

Victoria Collins

Well, let me thank my honourable friend for his question. In terms of regional airports like Exeter, but also Newquay Airport too, we need to ensure that they've got the connectivity they link they need into larger airports. And through our consultation on the Heathrow expansion National Policy Statement, we focused dedicatedly on how to increase via either PSO connections or routes into the airport through a regional fund, how we might better facilitate those connections. More broadly, whether it be through airspace modernisation so that we can facilitate better connectivity, or ensuring that regional airports are better protected against fluctuations in the price of jet fuel, the government is committed to taking comprehensive action to support this sector, recognising that it can serve as both a catalyst for economic growth, but also for economic connectivity for his constituents to which he so rightly points.

01:15:33 - 01:15:34

Speaker 52

No, please.

01:15:34 - 01:16:05

Charles Noah Law

Thank you, Speaker. Earlier this year, we saw an issue with Cornwall Council being unable to secure any eligible bids for its public service obligation service from Newquay Airport. And since then, the council has been scrabbling around trying to secure new commercial routes, which is very welcome and much needed. But what consideration has the Minister given to more flexible PSO arrangements that might allow, for instance, airports such as Newquay to say bid in with a more commercial outlook on how we get that support?

01:16:05 - 01:16:35

Victoria Collins

Well, PSO routes, Mr. Speaker, are crucial to connect areas of the country such as Cornwall, which serve as regional economic catalysts to the nation's capital. I'd note that since the end of the London-Newquay PSO in April, commercial connectivity has been retained, but I know my honorable friend is very eager to see this work go further. The Department remains open to continued engagement with Cornwall Council on options to maintain connectivity, and I'll of course bear in mind the points he makes around more flexibility in PSO arrangements as part of those discussions.

01:16:35 - 01:16:38

Speaker 54

Number 12, please, Mr. Speaker.

01:16:38 - 01:17:02

Speaker 20

Mr. Speaker, we're investing in the rail network in the Greater Manchester area, including the Bolton to Manchester line and services to Blackburn. These investments will improve reliability, which, combined with our funding for longer trains with more seats, will substantially boost capacity. We are also investing in key stations, including crucial upgrades at Salford and Manchester Victoria.

01:17:02 - 01:17:27

Speaker 55

Mr. Speaker, when I worked in Manchester, my train from Hall i' th' Wood station was regularly delayed, cancelled, or overcrowded thanks to Northern Rail's two-carriage service at rush hour. Ten years on, commuters at both Hall i' th' Wood and Bromley Cross station are still being failed by Northern Rail. And with no Metrolink access, it's no wonder Boltonians feel left behind. So what is our government doing to connect Bolton to the 21st century?

01:17:27 - 01:18:06

Speaker 20

I do understand how frustrating it is when services are delayed, cancelled, or overcrowded. The Rail Minister has been incredibly clear with Northern management that their level of performance, including in Bolton, has been unacceptable and they've been instructed to produce an improvement plan. Beyond that, Northern are talking to other train operators to see if they have additional trains which could increase capacity and reliability. And I mentioned earlier that there's early planning work underway to purchase up to 450 new trains for Northern, which could include the replacement of the ageing units on the Clitheroe to Bolton line.

01:18:06 - 01:18:08

Speaker 56

Question 13 please.

01:18:08 - 01:18:34

Victoria Collins

Minister. Thank you Mr Speaker. This government is proud to support the RNLI and the work of its volunteers to save lives at sea. The RNLI is a charity that is independent of government but is a crucial delivery partner of His Majesty's Coastguard's maritime and rescue service. I greatly value the contribution of the RNLI and all of its volunteers and staff for their life-saving efforts and wholeheartedly thank them for their service.

01:18:34 - 01:18:35

Matthew Patrick.

01:18:35 - 01:19:07

Matthew Patrick

And can I thank the minister for his answer and for his full-throated support of the RNLI. He'll be delighted to learn that five of the brilliant volunteers in my constituency at West Kirby and Hoylake RNLI stations have been awarded long service awards.

But they and the whole RNLI family are having to deal with a campaign of disinformation run frankly by cowards hiding behind a balaclava or a keyboard. And I'd like the Minister to tell me how he'll give them his support and whether he could show some of that Wirral spirit because Wirral is backing the RNLI every step of the way.

01:19:07 - 01:19:53

Victoria Collins

I couldn't agree more strongly with my honourable friend and let me pay tribute to the five volunteers recognised in his constituency and to RNLI volunteers across the country who provide a vital public service. I am clear that there is no space for the recent scenes of disgraceful abuse and intimidation directed at volunteers and staff. I've written to the RNLI to express my support to them to condemn this behaviour.

I'm also visiting an RNLI station in Bridlington later today and have hosted a cuppa for the crew in my own constituency, which I'd also encourage honourable members to do. I'd also just like to reassure the honourable member, Mr Speaker, that the police have confirmed that RNLI lifeguard crews are recognised as emergency workers under the Assaults on Emergency Workers Act, meaning anyone who assaults them could face up to two years' imprisonment, and rightly so.

01:19:53 - 01:20:26

Joshua Thomas Babarinde

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Saving lives at sea is not a political choice, it is a moral duty that we are all proud our RNLI has been undertaking for over 200 years. They are infinitely more patriotic than those who seek to abuse them.

Will the Minister share with us how he will better protect and afford the safety of those valiant RNLI volunteers in places like Eastbourne and across the country so that they can continue their life-saving work?

01:20:26 - 01:21:11

Victoria Collins

Well, let me reassure the honourable gentleman that in terms of the criminal penalties that apply to any abuse, discrimination, or assault on RNLI workers as a result of them being emergency workers, that is something that the government takes incredibly seriously in terms of enforcement and something that I will be certain to monitor extremely closely alongside my Home Office colleagues. Along with the Prime Minister and my colleagues in this House, I've written to the RNLI to express my support to them. He is absolutely right to say that they represent the best of British values, going out to save people at sea from ordinary backgrounds themselves, volunteering their time. They are the best of our society. They deserve our protection, our respect, and our support, and this government will stand behind them every step of the way.

01:21:11 - 01:21:14

Speaker 59

We come to topicals, Andy McDonald.

01:21:14 - 01:21:17

Speaker 60

Number one, Secretary of State.

01:21:17 - 01:22:34

Speaker 20

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

I'm sure I speak for the whole House when I say our thoughts are with those affected by yesterday's horrific train crash in Spain. I know our Rail Accident Investigation Branch has reached out to offer assistance, and I have written to my counterpart, Minister Puente, to formally offer my condolences. Mr. Speaker, yesterday's budget gave families the breathing space they need, and transport is no exception. By extending the 5p fuel duty cut to July next year and by lowering the cost of using local public EV chargers, we are putting money back in the pockets of Britain's drivers. The budget also confirmed 300 million pounds of total investment to upgrade Leeds station.

Breathing space today, backed by investment for the future. And this builds on the everyday fixes we're already making to improve people's journeys, whether it's the 7,000 miles of road resurfaced this year, ending unfair charges for air passengers, cracking down on anti-social behaviour on public transport, or the 2 pound bus fare cap coming back in January. These are just some of the ways we're making everyday journeys better, safer, and easier.

01:22:34 - 01:22:36

Speaker 61

Dan McDonald.

01:22:36 - 01:23:19

Andy McDonald

Mr Speaker, I associate myself with the Secretary of State's remarks concerning the Spanish rail disaster. Mr Speaker, Commonwealth's research estimates 129 billion pounds was spent on outsourcing public services in 2024-25, generating billions in private profits.

And I welcome the announcement of the First Secretary of State of a dedicated insourcing unit. So will the Secretary of State meet with recognized trade unions to develop a Department for Transport insourcing strategy, including across rail and other transport services, to improve value for money, rebuild public capacity, and protect workers?

01:23:19 - 01:23:52

Speaker 20

My honorable friend is entirely right to raise the opportunity presented by the work being led by the First Secretary of State. I meet with the leadership of the trade unions regularly, and I know this issue has already been raised at the Rail Engagement Group. I would say our lifting of the ban on new municipal bus companies in the Bus Services Act also presents opportunities, and where insourcing drives better outcomes for passengers and better value for the taxpayer, we should undoubtedly be looking at it.

01:23:52 - 01:24:21

John Richard Holden

Can I associate myself with the comments of the Secretary of State about this Spanish rail crash? Now, on the 18th of June, the Secretary of State told this House that Heathrow expansion was critical to national growth. However, on the 27th of September, the Prime Minister said it was principally a matter for London and Londoners. And last week, the honourable member for Selby, writing to a written parliamentary question, said the government will consider the Transport Select Committee's recommendations before deciding next steps. So, Mr. Speaker, does she agree with herself, the Prime Minister, or her junior minister?

01:24:21 - 01:24:22

Secretary of State.

01:24:22 - 01:25:01

Speaker 20

Mr. Speaker, the government's position on Heathrow expansion was set out in the draft Heathrow expansion national policy statement that we consulted on in the summer. We're working through those responses very carefully.

He will know that this is a very significant privately financed infrastructure project, and it's right that we look thoroughly at all the evidence, including the independent economic analysis, and looking at the evidence on the really strict tests on climate, noise, and air quality. It's entirely right that the Prime Minister wants to look closely at the detail of such a nationally significant project.

01:25:01 - 01:25:32

John Richard Holden

I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for that clarification. Last week, Chancellor Merz set out his plans to scrap the ban on petrol and diesel cars across the EU. He said, "We stand by drivers, we stand with our industry, we stand with open innovation in technology, the internal combustion ban is off the table." When will this Transport Secretary listen to British business, the unions, and British drivers and scrap the ZEV mandate that is costing British jobs and taxpayers?

01:25:32 - 01:26:11

Speaker 20

Mr. Speaker, I'd say gently to the right honorable gentleman that the ZEV mandate is actually the rarest of things. It's a policy brought in by his government that I actually agree with, but sadly after a good start even they managed to mess that up. And when we came into office, we had to reinstate the 2030 phase-out date for petrol and diesel cars. And it's important that we provide certainty to consumers and industry. I believe that approach is working with nearly a third of new cars sold now EVs, up from around a quarter a year ago.

01:26:11 - 01:26:31

Speaker 63

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The recent announcement that Severn Steel will be supplying Heathrow expansion with low-carbon steel production will be essential to both decarbonize our transport infrastructure and to protect Welsh workers.

So what steps are the government taking to ensure that lower-carbon Welsh steel is used in all major rail and transport infrastructure projects?

01:26:31 - 01:26:56

Victoria Collins

Let me thank my honourable friend for his question. Welsh steelmaking remains a key part of the UK government's steel strategy, with Wales expected to account for around half of future UK steelmaking capacity. We are committed to a sustainable UK steel sector and encourage the use of lower-carbon materials, recognising that electric arc furnace steel can provide a lower-carbon alternative in infrastructure projects across the country.

01:26:56 - 01:27:26

Gregory James Stafford

Constituents, Mr. Speaker, you are lucky enough not to have to suffer the weekly misery of Southwestern Railway, but my constituents, I surveyed them recently and asked them what they actually wanted from this first nationalised rail service now that we're paying for it. And their priorities were clear, sir.

They want more services from Liphook, more carriages at Haslemere, faster journeys from Farnham, and any access at all from Whitehill and Bordon. So will the Minister commit to meeting with me to getting those four rather simple things done soon?

01:27:26 - 01:27:49

Victoria Collins

Let me thank the honourable member for his question. As he has referenced, SWR is developing proposals for a refreshed timetable which focuses on improving reliability and the resilience of services. Plans are going to be shared through a public consultation with passengers and stakeholders later this year, which I would encourage his constituents to contribute to. In the meantime, I'll ensure that I facilitate that he has a meeting with the Rail Minister on this topic that he raises.

01:27:49 - 01:28:13

Speaker 65

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Department is aware of my increasing frustration at balaclava-clad yobs tearing up and down on dirt bikes in Darlington.

Indeed, the rest of the House is increasingly frustrated and we need action on this. Will the Minister and the Department commit to licensing at the point of sale or registration at the point of sale to aid the valiant efforts of our police forces in the North East?

01:28:13 - 01:28:33

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I commend my honorable friend for her work in this area? She is right that these yobbos are causing misery on many communities. We are determined for retailers to clean up their act and I'm keen to explore how we tackle this issue. So I will be happy to meet with her through my cross-departmental ministerial group to see how we can take that matter forward.

01:28:33 - 01:29:21

Victoria Collins

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Harpenden Thameslink services are facing Luton Airport expansion, Bedford Universal Studios and a local plan now 9,000 more houses coming down the line from this government, all while passengers like Emma are facing expensive, cramped and unreliable services.

So, what are the government doing to improve capacity, services, and pricing?

Well, thank you for her question. GTR is working with Network Rail and other local partners to explore potential timetable, rolling stock, and infrastructure improvements to increase capacity through Harpenden. This follows long-term demand forecasting which indicates continued passenger growth driven by planned housing developments and the expansion of Luton Airport to which she references. But I'd be very glad to continue working with her to make sure that we get the capacity improvements that we need over time to meet the needs of her constituents.

01:29:21 - 01:29:22

Catherine Fookes.

01:29:22 - 01:29:52

Catherine Fookes

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Most of us in Monmouthshire have to rely on our cars for every single journey. So I am absolutely over the moon that following meetings with National Express, next week they are bringing services back to the Monmouth area with coaches stopping at Raglan services so you can travel from Haverfordwest to Birmingham.

Will the Minister come with me on a journey on the coach so that he can see how important this route is for my constituents?

01:29:52 - 01:30:13

Simon Lightwood

I thank my honorable friend for her question. I'm delighted to join her in welcoming this new coach service to her constituency. Of course, this government is supporting operators by extending the 5p fuel duty cut until next July. I'll of course check my diary, but I'd encourage all honorable members to get on and book their way. Nine castles and some absolutely fantastic countryside to visit.

01:30:13 - 01:30:14

Alyn and Deeside.

01:30:14 - 01:30:43

Wendy Morton

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

On both sides of the House, I think it's fair to say there's disappointment following WSMR's open access application being rejected over capacity and reliability concerns on the West Coast Main Line. So is the Secretary of State confident that nationalising Avanti will deliver the punctuality improvements and extra pathways needed to accommodate new services, which I include hope WSMR stopping at Aldridge railway station?

01:30:43 - 01:31:24

Speaker 20

I do share the honourable lady's disappointment about the decision of the ORR. They can independently make that decision. My department had supported the application for that new direct service that would have also served cities like Shrewsbury. I will be working with Network Rail and train operators and GBR when it's established to consider all options for providing new direct services to London alongside that part of the route. Some of the investments that are coming in future years could enable that to happen because I know how important it is to her constituents and other travellers in the region.

01:31:24 - 01:31:24

Ruth Cadbury.

01:31:24 - 01:31:40

Speaker 69

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As the government prepare their taxi and private hire vehicles bill, will the minister ensure that local authorities like Sunderland have the enforcement powers and resources they need to regulate all vehicles operating in their areas, regardless of where they are registered?

01:31:40 - 01:32:05

Simon Lightwood

Mr. Speaker, I fully recognize my honorable friend's concerns. Taxis and private hire vehicles are regulated through an outdated and fragmented framework, and that's why this government intends to bring forward a draft bill to address this. My officials are also working hard to commence the powers from the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, which will let enforcement officers suspend any license used in their area where there are immediate safety concerns.

01:32:05 - 01:32:32

Charlotte Cane

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

My constituents of Ely and East Cambridgeshire have suffered delays, cancellations, and the trains meant to go from London to Ely or King's Lynn terminating early at Cambridge. Will the Secretary of State undertake to meet with me to discuss how we can take forward the Ely Junction improvements, which will increase capacity and make our railway more reliable?

01:32:32 - 01:32:55

Victoria Collins

Well, let me thank the honorable lady for her question. We of course recognize the strategic importance of the Ely Area Capacity Enhancement program and the significant benefits that it could deliver for passengers, freight, and economic growth, both in her constituency and across the wider region. We'll actively consider this scheme as further funding opportunities become available, and I'll do my level best to ensure that she is involved in those conversations as they progress.

01:32:55 - 01:33:19

Speaker 70

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. A second runway at Gatwick Airport will be a lightning rod for our economy.

It will bring a billion pounds in economic benefits and 14,000 new jobs, many of which will benefit the South Londoners that I serve. With this now having the green light and work about to begin, can I ask what support is the government giving this important infrastructure project?

01:33:19 - 01:33:41

Victoria Collins

Let me thank my honorable friend for her question. The government recognizes the importance of this project, which is why we approved the development consent order. It's now for Gatwick Airport to progress with this privately funded project. My officials continue to engage with the airport to understand how government can help in its delivery, and I would encourage my honorable friend to continue to work with me to think about how we can best support that process.

01:33:41 - 01:33:43

Speaker 71

Ben Maguire.

01:33:43 - 01:33:43

Ben Maguire

In May, the government announced 57 million pounds in nationwide funding for Wi-Fi on trains. Some other parts of the country have had many rail upgrades. But despite the South West's terrible rail lines and now delays due to the HS2 works at Old Oak Common, will the Minister commit to a minimum fair share of 12 million pounds for the South West, which would cover the entire GWR network of 93 Intercity Express trains?

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

01:34:15 - 01:34:36

Speaker 20

The fact that Great Western Railways is going to be coming into public ownership on the 13th of December, I think presents an opportunity. The honorable gentleman talks about the importance of things like Wi-Fi, and I hope to have more to say on that in the months ahead because I know how important good connectivity is for people who are using our railways.

01:34:36 - 01:34:37

Speaker 73

Lia Nici.

01:34:37 - 01:35:01

Melanie Onn

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The extension of the fuel duty cut to July 2027 will be welcomed by my Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes constituents, many of whom do rely on their cars for work purposes. What more is the government doing to help people reduce the cost of motoring when it comes to using their vehicles for work purposes?

01:35:01 - 01:35:32

Speaker 20

My honorable friend is completely right to raise the pressures that motorists and businesses are facing at the moment. In addition to the extension of the temporary 5p cut to fuel duty, we're also maintaining the road tax holiday for heavy goods vehicles until the summer of next year. We're making public charging cheaper for those who've already made the switch to an electric vehicle but don't have a driveway to charge at home, and we continue to offer money off the purchase price of over 60 models of electric cars.

01:35:32 - 01:35:56

James Stuart Andrew

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The village of Isham in my constituency is sandwiched between Wellingborough and Kettering and for 40 years has been battling to get a bypass. The situation has now got worse because of a huge development of warehousing, yet has been refused for funding. So can I give a very warm welcome to the Minister to come to Isham, because only seeing it for yourself can you understand how desperately we need this bypass.

01:35:57 - 01:36:12

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, I'm happy to do that. I think it would probably be on my way home one weekend. And yes, obviously we've invested a record amount of money into our networks and there's only a finite amount, but I'm happy to discuss the issue further with him.

01:36:12 - 01:36:13

Speaker 75

Peter Swallow.

01:36:13 - 01:36:35

Peter Swallow

Mr Speaker, this month has seen a series of quite serious road accidents in my constituency in Bracknell, Warfield and in Crowthorne. In one incident, very tragically, a young man, Shayan, lost his life at the scene. Will the Roads Minister meet with me to discuss these incidents and listen to Shayan's family's plea for more action on road safety?

01:36:35 - 01:36:57

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, can I first of all extend my sympathies to Shayan's family and of course I'm happy to meet. I would just at this point like to commend my predecessor, the honourable member for Nottingham South, for the excellent work she has done on the road safety strategy, which I am privileged to be able to build on, and part of that work will be engaging with bereaved families.

01:36:57 - 01:37:27

Joe Robertson

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Greedy corporate interests have stripped out over 200 million pounds from our Isle of Wight ferry services in the last 10 years.

I'm grateful to the Minister for setting up local round table meetings, but they are at risk of becoming a talking shop and the ferry companies don't appear to be taking them seriously. Can he give us an assurance locally that if the ferry companies don't take this opportunity to improve services and reduce prices, the government will consider taking steps to force their hand?

01:37:27 - 01:38:00

Victoria Collins

Well, the honourable member is determined to achieve better ferry services for his constituents. And I'm pleased that he reflects on the Cross-Solent Group and the work that it's done and the progress that it is making. I am keeping a close watch on its proceedings. I expect all members of it to contribute in meaningful ways to find practical local solutions to these challenges and of course keep options under advisement going forward. But I would say that in relation to ferry services, the government does believe that locally-led solutions are often the best approach to matters such as the one that he describes.

01:38:00 - 01:38:09

Speaker 79

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Cowbar Lane in my constituency is at serious risk of collapse into the sea. We have a plan in place for relocating it and making it safe.

Will ministers meet with me to discuss?

01:38:09 - 01:38:37

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Well, Mr. Speaker, we recognize the impact of coastal erosion affecting Cowbar Lane and are aware of the plans set out by Redcar and Cleveland Council to move the road further inland. The government has already provided over 300 million pounds of City Region Sustainable Transport Settlement funding to the Tees Valley. Ben Houchen's delivered on this, but it clearly is not actually seeing anything happening on the ground. So I'm happy to meet with the honorable member to see what more we can do to encourage him to deliver on this issue.

01:38:38 - 01:39:01

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Residents in Holton Heath and Sandford are being blighted every weekend by racing vehicles, motorcycles, and modified small cars, causing nuisance and really loud noise. What progress is being made on the acoustic devices that allow police to be able to act on these illegal vehicles?

01:39:01 - 01:39:20

Justin Piers Richard Madders

I'm very sorry to hear the honorable lady's constituents having to endure these issues. There have been a number of trials. It's not that straightforward to actually isolate the noise, we've found, but actually police forces do have powers to tackle this and I'm happy to write to her with further information about what they can do.

01:39:21 - 01:39:44

Christopher David Ward

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The A259 coast road runs the entire southern length of my constituency, but daily delays on it are a huge frustration, particularly for constituents in Rottingdean, Telscombe, and Saltdean. So what more can the Minister do to unlock promised, long-promised upgrades on this road and to finally get Reform-led East Sussex County Council to put the funding and focus needed to get it over the line?

01:39:44 - 01:39:45

Speaker 81

Minister.

01:39:45 - 01:40:03

Justin Piers Richard Madders

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Department recognizes the importance of the particular road that the honorable member has referred to, and we are ready to crack on with this. I would join him in encouraging the Tory Reform-led County Council to actually release the funding necessary to get on with the job.

01:40:03 - 01:40:46

Andrew George

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituents are not demanding a multi-billion pound HS answer to the five-and-a-half-hour journey time from Penzance to London, for example, but just a fraction of that to improve comfort, reliability, and punctuality of the service.

My honorable friend for North Cornwall mentioned the 57 million pounds which has been allocated, just a fraction of the money that's spent on HS policies, simply to get Wi-Fi services on this service. We understand that's held by the Treasury at the moment. When will this be rolled out, because it's desperately needed now?

01:40:46 - 01:41:02

Speaker 20

As I said to his honorable colleague in my reply, we are very keen to make progress on the issue of better Wi-Fi connectivity in Great Western services, and I hope to be saying more on that in the coming months.

01:41:02 - 01:41:55

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. First of all, may I associate myself with the condolences made by the Transport Secretary and others about the terrible tragedy in Spain yesterday.

Mr. Speaker, there are many bottlenecks on the national rail system that are holding back rail freight growth. And whilst I welcome the government's announcement of the interim rail freight growth strategy of 40% by 2040, without a clear and deliverable strategy, the government risks falling back on the on this expansion of rail freight, such an important sector for us all. So may I ask the government, when will we see a rail freight growth strategy, or will we have to wait for the overall rail enhancement strategy?

01:41:55 - 01:42:27

Speaker 20

The Chair of the Transport Select Committee is completely right to highlight the need for increasing the amount of freight that we transport by rail.

That's why we have set a target of growing rail freight by 75% by 2050, with that interim target of 40% by 2040. We aren't publishing a separate rail freight strategy, as I will put that target in the long-term rail strategy when it's published, and I will expect Great British Railways to set out in its first business plan how it will achieve it.

01:42:27 - 01:42:29

Speaker 85

Martin Vickers.

01:42:29 - 01:42:56

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Earlier this week, the All-Party Rail Group had received presentations from representatives for talking about access to both airports and seaports. In respect of seaports, they made the suggestion that modest electrification projects linking seaports such as Immingham to the main line would greatly improve rail freight distribution. Do the government have plans to do to such schemes?

01:42:56 - 01:43:21

Victoria Collins

Let me thank the honorable member for his question and it was a pleasure to visit the port of Immingham a few months ago. Rail connectivity to our ports, encouraging modal shift and electrification's role in increasing the efficiency of rail freight growth to our seaports is of real personal interest to me. I'll therefore happily take this conversation forward with him and think about how we can facilitate better connectivity to our ports through electrification of our railways.

01:43:21 - 01:43:54

Perran Moon

Mr. Speaker, and I declare an interest as the chair of the APPG on EVs. After more record EV sales, the government's consultation on the ZEV mandate closed last Friday. The mandate affects only 8% of all new car registrations manufactured in the UK. So can the minister set out if the consultation has considered the billions of pounds in private sector investment in domestic lithium extraction, battery manufacturing and charge point infrastructure?

01:43:54 - 01:44:22

Speaker 20

I can assure my honorable friend that we look at these issues in the round. He mentions charge point infrastructure.

Only this week, I had a roundtable with the main operators of chargepoint infrastructure, as well as a meeting with the car manufacturers. We have done a review of the ZEV mandate on which we consulted this summer. The Chancellor has set out our intention to respond to that as a government by Christmas, so that we can provide certainty to everyone that is contributing to the EV transition.

01:44:22 - 01:44:50

Alexander Carmichael

Thank you, Mr Speaker. The decision in July to abandon plans for the changes to remuneration of coastguards was very widely welcomed, but that was over three months ago now. Coastguards around the coastline tell me that there has been absolute radio silence within the MCA since then.

There are a number of whistleblowing complaints about the senior executive team which are simply not being addressed. So when are we going to hear what the government will do to fix our coastguards?

01:44:50 - 01:45:18

Victoria Collins

Let me thank the honorable member for his question and for his work to represent both the coastguard service in his constituency and also across the country. I can reassure him that over the summer work has been progressing both on questions relating to backdated liabilities and future workforce arrangements as it applies to His Majesty's Coastguard. I hope to have more to say in the future, but I will maintain my obligation to keep the honorable member and members across the House updated as closely as I can on developments as they unfold.

01:45:18 - 01:45:19

Jonathan Brash.

01:45:19 - 01:45:41

James Jonathan Hinder

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Not a single rail service has run from Clitheroe on Sundays for a very, very long time.

And I know the Secretary of State and her team of ministers have heard representations from me a lot on this issue, but can I just get reassurance that she and her team are doing everything they can to get those Sunday services back up and running?

01:45:41 - 01:45:57

Speaker 20

I agree with my honorable friend that his constituents are right to expect a good service every day of the week, including Sundays. I can assure him the management of Northern are around the table with the RMT to work together on a way forward, and I hope to be able to say more soon.

01:45:58 - 01:46:34

Tessa Munt

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Community transport minibuses, like Mendip Community Transport in my area, are a lifeline for rural communities, but the minibus driving test is costly, up to £2,000 per volunteer, hard to access, and pretty unrealistic for volunteers, while drivers who qualified before 1997 and have a D1 classification included on their driving licenses are retiring.

So will the Minister meet with me and representatives of the industry and recognize officially the sector's own safety training scheme, MiDAS, as a route for car drivers to gain a minibus license?

01:46:34 - 01:46:50

Simon Lightwood

The Government recognizes the vital role that community transport plays in connecting people with communities, enabling access to employment, education, and essential services such as healthcare. Of course, I'd be more than happy to meet with the honorable lady.

01:46:50 - 01:47:13

Markus Campbell-Savours

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The last train from London to Newcastle tonight is at 11:08 PM, but the last train from London to Carlisle is at 7:30 PM.

Now the experiment with train privatization is coming to an end, is it possibly time for a new experiment where the West Coast gets the same level of service as the East Coast?

01:47:13 - 01:47:37

Speaker 20

Mr. Speaker, Avanti West Coast is due to come into public ownership in March of next year. And over the course of the next few years, there is an opportunity to look again at the timetable because I recognize the importance of those later services leaving direct to his constituency as well as to the constituencies on the other side of the country.

01:47:37 - 01:48:05

Alison Bennett

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The derailment that happened in the summer between Haywards Heath and Lewes is of great concern to my constituents. It happened during a period of very hot, dry weather, which caused the ground to crack and dry. I understand that Network Rail are looking at ways to change how they maintain embankments and cuttings, but there was no money in the budget yesterday for Southeast Railway services.

Does the government have a plan to make sure our services are punctual and they are safe?

01:48:05 - 01:48:43

Speaker 20

I do completely understand why that incident will have been of huge concern to her constituents. We're spending over two and a half billion pounds in this control period on the railways to address issues to do with climate change mitigation and adaptation. We are awaiting the final report of the Rail Accident Investigation Branch as to the causes of that particular incident. Network Rail took immediate tests, immediate steps to increase inspections across the network to ensure safety. And I think the events in Spain yesterday serve as a reminder why safety must always be paramount when it comes to our railways.

01:48:43 - 01:49:05

Speaker 93

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Consideration of eastern access at Hitchin station has been stalled for far too long.

Working with ministers and our councils, I'm delighted we've been able to finally get this moving forward. And yesterday's announcement of five point six million in new growth funding for Hertfordshire is a fantastic opportunity to go further and finally make it happen. Will ministers meet with me to discuss coming to North Hertfordshire to make sure we make the most of this opportunity for my town?

01:49:05 - 01:49:11

Speaker 94

In the interest of speed, yes.

01:49:11 - 01:49:29

Euan Stainbank

Orromobility are a company in Falkirk that design assistive mobility products for disabled people. They and their customers need certainty that any reforms to light zero-emission vehicles regulation will protect access to pavements and roads, not reduce it. Six months after the consultation on powered mobility devices closed, when will the government provide that certainty and publish its response?

01:49:29 - 01:49:39

Justin Piers Richard Madders

I thank the honourable member for his question and grateful to Orromobility for engagement with the department on the consultation, which we will be responding to very shortly.

01:49:39 - 01:49:40

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

01:49:40 - 01:50:03

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

And I'm aware that the Secretary of State has already answered two questions about the fantastic pilot that Peninsula Rail did for Wi-Fi on GWR trains. But I would gently ask, if we are to go ahead with rolling that out for nationalization on the 13th of December, whether there's a way to give a nudge to Treasury to make that money available.

01:50:03 - 01:50:28

Speaker 20

My honorable friend has been an absolutely tireless campaigner on this issue, and I know she depends upon Great Western Railway services, as I do from my own constituency. I'm also absolutely clear that being able to have good mobile connectivity is something that people feel very strongly about and could improve satisfaction with journeys, and I will continue my discussions with colleagues across government to make it happen.

01:50:28 - 01:50:56

Speaker 99

Completes questions, let the front bench change over. Now come to business questions, Shadow Leader of the House.

01:50:56 - 01:51:02

Alexander Jesse Norman

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the Leader give the House the forthcoming business?

01:51:01 - 01:52:20

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The business for the week commencing the 2nd of November will include Monday the 2nd of November continuation of the budget debate, Tuesday the 3rd of November conclusion of the budget debate, Wednesday the 4th of November remaining stages of the Sporting Events Bill, followed by consideration of a carryover motion relating to the Railways Bill, followed by consideration of a carryover motion relating to the Cyber Security and Resilience Network and Information Systems Bill. The House will then rise for the November recess at the conclusion of business on Wednesday the 4th of November and return on Tuesday the 10th of November, when the business for the week commencing the 10th of November will be Tuesday the 10th of November second reading of the Financial Services and Markets Bill, Wednesday the 11th of November an opposition day debate on a motion in the name of the official opposition, subject yet to be announced, Thursday the 12th of November general debate on the 110th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme, followed by a general debate on the Nolan principles, the subject for these debates determined by the Backbench Business Committee, and Friday the 13th of November private members' bills.

And Friday the 13th of November, private members' bills.

01:52:20 - 01:57:02

Alexander Jesse Norman

I thank the leader very much for that update. Mr. Speaker, as the House will be aware, this is a day of very mixed feelings. We mourn the deaths and the injuries sustained in the Spanish high-speed rail disaster yesterday. But in a far happier vein, it's impossible not to celebrate the triumph of Harry Kane in the Ballon d'Or, the first British winner for 26 years, and of giant-killing Fleetwood Town in conquering Arsenal in the Carabao Cup.

Just in time for Halloween, Mr. Speaker, we learned that the SNP government in Scotland has assembled an army of nearly 800 ghost workers on the public payroll, costing taxpayers £27 million a year. The jobs have vanished, but the salaries remain. One of these people has been non-working in the NHS for 17 years. That's the SNP in a nutshell, Mr. Speaker. Needless to say, the Scottish government have no plans to change this state of affairs.

Hundreds of people being paid to pretend they have jobs, it's the perfect metaphor for this Labour government. And so to the Chancellor of the Exchequer, who spoke after the usual orgy of pre-briefings to the media yesterday and avoided, I have to say, to his credit, some of the more lunatic ideas of his colleagues.

He tried his best, Mr. Speaker, but frankly, Harry Kane, Fleetwood Town, hell, Fleetwood Mac would have done better with that budget. It was a budget for a May general election, not the future of Britain. As Helen Miller of the Institute of Fiscal Studies put it, there was, quote, "lots of fiddling, but no clear coherent vision." It means that disposable household incomes are falling, the tax burden is at historic peacetime highs, growth forecasts are falling, with not even the whiff of a strategy for growth yesterday. Worse still, as the noted economist Paul Johnson pointed out, the budget implied back-end loaded spending cuts in most areas of public service spending of 2.6% per year between 2028 to 9 and 2031 to 32.

His verdict was, quote, "This is not honest politics nor honest economics." His words, Mr. Speaker, not mine, and Mr. Johnson, I think is well known, is not a Conservative. But there's something even more troubling here. Britain is walking a fiscal, a monetary, and a security tightrope. And yet again, the government's response has been to postpone difficult decisions, spin the plates, ladle on the fudge, and hope that nothing goes wrong.

And now we have speculation, persistent speculation despite attempted rebuttals, that the Prime Minister may call a general election. What an extraordinary abdication of responsibility that would be. The message would be this: yes, Britain faces profound economic and international uncertainty, so let's add a little extra disruption to it with an entirely unnecessary election more than two years before one's required.

And while we're at it, let's reopen the constitutional turmoil of another EU referendum to boot. The British people would surely say, we gave you Labour people a majority of more than 170 to sort out the country's issues. You have replaced your own Prime Minister and your Chancellor, you have failed to deliver the change you promised, and now you want another election because you're simply too frit to make the decisions required. Britain needs growth, it needs stability, it needs financial strength, it needs national security. Instead, it's getting short-term fixes, deferred decisions, and political maneuvering.

This is not a strategy for governing Britain, it's an absolute failure of leadership. The Chancellor couldn't even meet his own test for defence spending, over which he supposedly resigned.

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister has talked endlessly of his desire to "rewire the state". The Chancellor said the same in terms yesterday. We've got a huge debt burden, stretched public services, rising interest rates, growing defense commitments. There is the escalating threat of external shocks: Ukraine, Iran, inflation, AI, trade wars, extreme weather, another pandemic. So will the leader now explain, in his usual candid way, without prevaricating or blaming others, why these two men have demonstrated absolute zero interest in actually taking any of the serious decisions required to address these issues?

01:57:02 - 02:04:13

Lucy Maria Powell

And first of all, can I join with the shadow leader in sending our deepest condolences to the people of Spain in the aftermath of the horrendous train crash which occurred yesterday, taking the lives of 68 people as well as injuring many others. And I'm sure, as she said, the thoughts of the whole House are with all those affected. Last week, Mr. Speaker, across the UK, we saw some very severe and stormy weather. And I want to send condolences to the families of those loved ones who lost their lives, but also to thank all the emergency service workers who've been working hard to mitigate the effects of the storms.

I'm also saddened to hear, Mr. Speaker, of the passing of Sue Holt. She was a much-respected member of the staff of this place in the Inter-Parliamentary Relations Office, and I know the whole House will want to send condolences to her family and friends at this time. Further to the tributes made last week, Mr. Speaker, and your words this morning, I'd also like to add my best wishes again to Tom Goldsmith, who after 30 years of outstanding service to the House is retiring from the office of Clerk of the House today. I'd also like to pay tribute, Mr. Speaker, to Kerry King, who after 43 years in the civil service and 19 years as Head of Secretariat and Deputy Clerk of the Privy Council is leaving her role this week. Kerry was appointed a Lieutenant in the Royal Victoria Order in the 2023 New Year's Honours in recognition of her services to the Privy Council, and I have greatly valued her advice and guidance in my role as Lord President of the Council, and I wish her well.

And as the Shadow Leader of the House has said, on entirely different matters, I want to congratulate Harry Kane, who this week became the first English player to win the Ballon d'Or since Michael Owen in 2001. And as she said, I'm sure members across the House will join with me in sending congratulations on this well-deserved win, and I'm sure, as I did, found his comments as he accepted the award very moving. And I think young people who are looking at Harry Kane will see someone entirely committed, not just to the sport, but to family and everything else, and that he really is a hero to many people, and I wish him well. Mr. Speaker, there will be no business questions next week, so I do want to mention Remembrance Sunday on the 8th of November, as we take pause to honour those who gave their lives in defence of our freedoms.

As we take pause to honor those who gave their lives in defense of our freedoms, let us remember the extraordinary debt that can never fully be repaid. Turning to the comments of the Shadow Leader of the House, the Chancellor set out a very clear plan yesterday in the budget, which gives families and businesses some breathing space from rising costs and supports Britain's economic growth, not least the 100 pounds payment to 20 million households in council tax bands A and D in England.

Also support for businesses, taking around 70,000 more retail, hospitality and leisure businesses out of business rates altogether. And at the same time, Mr Speaker, supporting the housing market with measures for first-time buyers, social housing and cutting unnecessary costs and delays for housebuilders. We've also, Mr Speaker, reaffirmed our commitment to end homelessness for good. I have to say on the other comment that he made, I found him uncharacteristically unfair, I think, about the events of yesterday. And on the question of pre-briefing, I was struck and pleased, in light of what we've said over a period of time, at how little pre-briefing there was about the budget.

...about the budget and how disciplined the Chancellor, his team, and indeed everybody else was in making sure that it was this House that heard for the first time the contents of that budget. He mentions the issue of household income, and the government is not complacent, Mr. Speaker, about the challenges that we face going forward. And I have, I listen very carefully to what has been said about the potential for household income going forward. But I just gently remind him and others opposite, Mr. Speaker, that 14 years of Conservative government and people were worse off at the end than they had been at the beginning. And that is the first time, Mr. Speaker, in history that that happened.

So we're not going to take any lessons from the right honorable gentleman or indeed anyone else. He will know, because it is true, that this government faces international pressures. There are headwinds that we need to face, and I think a little more understanding of that would be appreciated. And despite all of that, the projection still is that the economy will grow.

It won't grow as fast as we want it to grow. That is why the measures in the budget were there to try and make sure that in getting the foundations right, we then get on with growth as quickly as possible. We will be doing all we can, but I would also gently point out, without being complacent, that the predictions about growth in this year were lower than it has actually turned out is the case. But we will see what happens, not least in the Middle East. It is noticeable, Mr. Speaker, that when a number of very credible organisations talk about the state of the economy, not least the OBR, the IMF, and the IFS, that one of the things that they pick out is not a lack of political stability, but the fact that the government has a majority, it has a Prime Minister with a very clear vision of where he wants to take this country, not just, Mr. Speaker, in making sure that we in this place do everything that we can to boost the economy.

It has a Prime Minister with a very clear vision of where he wants to take this country, not just, not just, Mr Speaker, in making sure that we in this place do everything that we can to boost the economy, but to make sure that no regions and no towns and cities are left behind, which is why devolution is so important. He talks about defence. We're spending 14 billion pounds more on defence than the previous administration. They were spending during their time in office the lowest amount since the end of the Cold War. The Prime Minister set out a very clear timeline yesterday in which he committed again the government to a 3% spending 3% on defence and also that we will meet our NATO commitments.

So what happened yesterday was a recommitment to those things and we are on in line, on track to deliver all of them.

And my final point is this, Mr. Speaker. The right honorable gentleman talks about an election and the Prime Minister was very clear in what he said in the last few hours about how he sees the possibility of an election. And actually, I'd just say to the party opposite, if they are looking for a general election, be very careful what you ask for.

02:04:13 - 02:04:56

Douglas McAllister

Very much, Mr. Speaker. May I ask the Leader of the House to join me in congratulating my constituent, Connor McElwaine, who has completed an extraordinary 18,000 kilometer cycle ride from Canberra Avenue in Dalmure to Canberra, Australia over the course of nearly a year. Connor has biked through 23 countries and raised over £5,900 for Venture Scotland, which is a charity supporting young people to build confidence and realize their potential.

Connor's now embarking on the long journey home via New Zealand, the United States, and Europe. So will the Leader of the House join me in wishing Connor every success for the remainder of his remarkable adventure and a warm Clydebank welcome when he returns home next spring?

02:04:56 - 02:05:25

Lucy Maria Powell

Mr. Speaker, I'll not only join my honorable friend in congratulating Connor on completing such an extraordinary adventure, but of course to thank him for doing so for such a good cause. There will be many people who will benefit from what Connor has done that will never meet him, but nevertheless they will have met him and when they learn of his achievements, they will be hugely impressed, I'm sure. And I wish him every success for the remainder of his adventure and safe travels on his journey home.

02:05:25 - 02:05:28

Speaker 101

Liberal Democrat spokesperson Bobby Dean.

02:05:28 - 02:07:19

Bobby Dean

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I say at the start that we share our thoughts with the victims and families of those involved in the train crash in Spain?

And I also want to add to the congratulations to Harry Kane and say on behalf of all Tottenham Hotspur fans that he is one of our own. It is tempted to get into the budget, but I haven't spoken in the debate yet and I fear that if I start now I might run out of things to say. There were of course a record number of measures in the budget yesterday, but they had the lowest cumulative value that we've seen in decades. And I think that makes it the most extravagant display of looking busy for the boss in history. Moving on to other events, Mr. Speaker.

I'm sure the whole House will join me in wishing the Leader of the House a very happy birthday. I'm sure she's looking forward to celebrating with a nice cup of tea and a slice of cake later. I'm sure she'll be pleased to know that she's the longest-serving female Leader of the House in history. Moving on to other events, Mr. Speaker, this week on Monday we saw that the AI debate was bumped off of the agenda. And I'm afraid that I think this makes Parliament look slightly ridiculous.

This week on Monday we saw that the AI debate was bumped off of the agenda and I'm afraid that I think this makes Parliament look slightly ridiculous.

We last debated AI properly in this chamber back in 2023. And in terms of how the technology moves on, that is light years ago. Instead, on Monday, we debated the performance of Royal Mail, an important issue, but one that was only debated the week previously in Westminster Hall. And critics are now saying that this exposes how this House sometimes spends more time engaging on popular local issues than some of the complex challenges that our country faces. Now, my own view is that we must make time for both of these things.

We need to make sure that we tackle those important local issues in our constituency, but also rise to the challenges of our time. There are huge questions to answer on the growth opportunity presented by AI, how we get it adopted widely across the country, but also on the safety concerns and the threat of super-intelligent models to our society.

These are critical questions for this Parliament to engage with. And so I ask the Leader of the House, will he make time for a debate in government time as urgently as possible so that colleagues can engage with these big questions of our time?

02:07:19 - 02:09:18

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And can I say from the outset that I always find the honorable gentleman's comments both honest and brave, and admitting that he's a Tottenham Hotspur fan is characteristic of it. In terms of the postponement of the debate, I do understand his frustration and indeed the frustration of others, but as he said, the first debate attracted a huge amount of attention. There were two important debates in front of the House. I will make sure we try to make sure that the number of statements are balanced, but we've got to balance that with making sure that the House is kept updated.

I am committed to finding as much time as possible for the Backbench Business Committee, and I'm sure the chair of the committee, who is in his place, will have heard the desire of the honorable gentleman for a debate. And on a wider point, he does make some relevant points, Mr. Speaker, about the way that we use time here, and he will know that the Modernisation Committee is looking currently at how best we use time in this place. He raises the issue of AI safety, and the budget delivers the government's most ambitious AI package yet, investing 700 million pounds to tackle the risks of AI. And we will place AI at the center stage at the G20 presidency, when I expect that the House will be given ample time before that happens actually to debate those issues.

And we will be working towards at the summit a hopefully agreed single set of global principles and standards on AI, and the government is clear where there is further necessary work we will, we will do that. And in terms of making time for a debate, he makes a very important point about the link between AI and growth, and I've just announced a further three days of the budget debate, so with a bit of ingenuity I'm sure he or others can make those points during that debate.

02:09:18 - 02:10:11

James Mark Sewards

Paul Sibut. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I was shocked and appalled when a peaceful Hindu festival in Wakefield the weekend before last was attacked by masked individuals leaving two people injured. There were children and families present, including 50 of my constituents from Leeds South West and Morley. The honorable member for Ossett and Denby Dale has done sterling work in liaising with the police and the community, and there's more work to come.

It took place in her constituency. But in the meantime, will the Leader of the House join me in condemning this kind of violence, condemning the individuals that encourage it, and standing with the Leeds South West and Morley Indians that I represent? And will he also call for a debate in government time on the need to protect all of our communities from abhorrent attacks?

02:10:11 - 02:10:48

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I absolutely join my honorable friend in condemning this appalling incident in Wakefield and reaffirming that all forms of hatred and division have absolutely no place in our society. Attacks like these must never be tolerated, and we need to send that message out in a united way, but a very clear and a loud way from this place.

And I thank my honorable friend and the member for Ossett and Denby Dale for the support that they have provided for their constituents. The government takes this matter very seriously and if we can find time for a debate at some point in the future around social cohesion and what further can be done, because we're doing a lot, then we'll certainly try to find that time.

02:10:48 - 02:13:35

Bob Blackman

Bob Blackman, chair of the Backbench Business Committee. Mr Speaker, and if the Liberal Democrat spokesman is brave, I can tell you I've got a season ticket home and away watching Tottenham and I've watched virtually every goal that Harry Kane scored for us and I only wish he was still scoring for Tottenham rather than Bayern Munich. Can I start on a sad note and pay tribute to the late Sir John Hannam, who was the MP for Exeter from 1970 to 1997.

He was also the secretary of the 1922 Committee from 1987 to 1997. And indeed, he died at the ripe old age of 97. And I'm sure we will all join together in sending our condolences to his family. Now, the House won't have long to wait, provided the Leader of the House allocates us time, because the debate on the emerging risks of advanced AI, which of course had to be withdrawn because of the sheer number of speakers there were for both debates on Monday. If we are allocated the 19th of November, we will allocate that date for that important debate, and also a debate on International Men's Day, which actually coincides with the date as well.

In terms of the Westminster Hall business, on Tuesday the 3rd of November, there'll be a debate on the findings of the Milburn Review. On the 10th of November, when we come back, there'll be a debate on anti-social behaviour.

And I remind the House that that debate will start at 11:30 rather than 9:30. And on the 12th of November, there'll be a debate on fire and rescue services suicide prevention training, followed by a debate on VAT policy for the hospitality sector. Further debates obviously for Westminster Hall will be announced in due course. Now, Mr. Speaker, in addition to Remembrance Sunday, which we will commemorate during that recess period, it is also Diwali. And so I'm sure the whole House will join with me in wishing all Hindus, Sikhs and Jains Shubh Diwali for the event, and also a happy, peaceful, prosperous and above all else healthy Hindu New Year, which follows.

However, if you're a Hindu in Pakistan, you're in serious trouble at the moment. We as an All-Party Group for British Hindus, we received a report from Insight UK just last week on the plight of Hindus in Pakistan. This makes horrific reading. And I would ask the Leader to get a Foreign Office, either the Foreign Secretary or Foreign Office Minister, to come to the House and tell the House what the Government is doing to safeguard minority communities, not just in this country, quite rightly, but also in countries where they are a minority and severely oppressed.

02:13:35 - 02:15:09

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and let me thank the honorable gentleman as ever as chair of his committee for the hard work that he does and indeed the rest of the committee.

And I want to join him in paying tribute to Sir John Hannam, who was a distinguished member of this House, and we send our condolences to his friends and to his family. I thank him for what he said about backbench business going forward and the matter of the AI debate. So the honorable member for Carshalton and Wallington shouldn't underestimate the influence that he has in this place, because he's got half an answer, if not the whole answer, of exactly when it will be. But I will look at allocating time, as the chair will know, I will do my very best to do that. I also want to send my best wishes to the Hindu community for Diwali.

As ever, the honorable gentleman raises very important concerns about social cohesion and faith groups, not just in this country, but indeed abroad.

I want to thank the Hindu community for everything that they do in our local community, but in fact across the country, and put that on record. But I also will raise his concerns with the FCDO. He's raised these matters before. The government takes the treatment of minority communities and particular faith communities very seriously indeed. And I will raise it with FCDO colleagues and see at some point if we can get the statement that he seeks.

02:15:09 - 02:16:04

Julie Minns

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I also add my congratulations to Harry Kane? But could I also say just how proud we remain of the success of our Lionesses, not just on the field, but off the field in inspiring young girls to play?

However, I've become aware that a girls' coach in Carlisle is unable to access the UEFA A license because her role as a coach in the girls' emerging talent center is excluded from the FA's priority criteria, whereas a coach in the equivalent boys' pathway is not. I've written to the FA, but their response states that they do not intend to change this. Could the Leader of the House therefore advise me how we in this place can make the FA think again and ensure that opportunities available to female coaches in the women's game are not confined just to the large clubs and the top tier?

02:16:04 - 02:16:44

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I absolutely agree with my honorable friend that we should all take pride in the success of the Lionesses. We are committed to supporting every aspect of women's sport, with Sport England committing £60,000 to support the FA in developing a bespoke women's football workforce strategy.

Therefore, I'm very concerned to hear of the specific case and concern that my honorable friend has. I hope that the FA have heard what she has said here today. But she asks how best she might be able to take it forward. I'm happy to facilitate a meeting with the sports ministers to see if we can get the answer that my honorable friend wants and we can take this matter forward.

02:16:44 - 02:16:46

Speaker 105

Sir Roger Gale.

02:16:46 - 02:17:23

Roger Gale

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the figures underpinning the business case for National Grid's ludicrously environmentally damaging Sea Link project have been shown to have been fiddled together in cloud cuckoo land.

The Secretary of State for Energy is due to issue her determination on the Planning Inspector's inquiry into that scheme imminently. Mr Speaker, with his usual courtesy, would the Leader of the House seek to ensure that that announcement is made on the floor of the House and not slipped out in a written answer on a non-sitting Friday?

02:17:23 - 02:17:43

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I understand the right honourable gentleman's concerns about these matters and indeed the way that announcements are made. And I will do my very best, I will take what he said away and I will do my very best to try to get the route that he seeks to make sure that it is made in the appropriate way.

02:17:43 - 02:18:16

Euan Stainbank

Mr Speaker, this month 141 Student Loans staff, 120 based in Scotland, were told their jobs would transfer to Capgemini, the same company who incidentally helped design the Student Loans Company target operating model.

This transfer will come into effect from the 1st of March, one month before the government's public interest test will start compelling departments and non-departmental bodies like the Student Loans Company to evidence the long-term cost of outsourcing decisions. Would the Leader encourage the Cabinet Office to provide a statement on how they can prevent outsourcing decisions being accelerated before the public interest test comes into effect?

02:18:16 - 02:18:45

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and as ever my honorable friend raises an issue of great importance to his constituents and I pay tribute to him for doing so. I understand that he has a meeting, Mr. Speaker, with the my honorable friend the Parliamentary Secretary of the Cabinet Office in his diary and I hope that that meeting will address his concerns. If it doesn't, then I'm sure my honorable friend, who's a doughty fighter for his constituents, will raise it once again on the floor of the House and we'll have to see what else is necessary to move this forward.

02:18:45 - 02:18:45

Stephen Barclay.

02:18:45 - 02:19:21

Paul Stephen Barclay

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Would the Leader of the House raise with the Home Secretary the very real concerns of residents in Fenland at the proposed asylum center in Leverington, an area excluded by the previous Conservative government as unsuitable for such accommodation, on which the council, on the basis of legal advice, have raised a number of objections, and on which the Home Office has missed its own deadline to give a decision by the 16th of October? This site isn't suitable for the proposed asylum center, and I'd be grateful if he could raise that with the Home Secretary.

02:19:21 - 02:19:47

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The right honorable gentleman will know how difficult these decisions can be, and also I know the concern that it raises in constituencies such as his. So let's be absolutely clear and honest about that.

But I will raise his concerns here today with the Home Secretary, because even where there are difficult decisions, it's important that as far as we can, we take local communities with us and that we get the right outcome at the end.

02:19:47 - 02:20:26

Perran Moon

Moraz, Mr. Speaker. The athletics track at Carn Brea Leisure Centre is just one of two public access tracks in the whole of Cornwall, and the Duchy's only five-lane facility for a population of 600,000 people. It's in urgent need of restructuring at a cost of £600,000, but with EU and SPF funding no longer available and grants largely aimed at sports clubs, the Leisure Centre Trust is struggling to meet the costs. Will the Leader of the House help me secure a meeting with the Sports Minister to discuss how we can support this vital community asset at the heart of one of the UK's most deprived communities?

02:20:26 - 02:20:58

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My honourable friend is a strong advocate for his Cwmbran athletics track and for young people in his constituency, and he knows that grassroots sports clubs and facilities are at the heart of our local communities, which is why the government is backing them with £400 million investment in grassroots sports facilities across the UK. I am happy to help him to arrange a meeting with the sports minister, she's going to be quite busy after today's session, to help to facilitate the meeting so that he can discuss it with her.

02:20:58 - 02:21:35

Pippa Heylings

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Families across Cambridgeshire have been waiting years for the two new special schools in Gamlingay and March, and following meetings with two ministers, we finally got confirmation from the government to build them, and we were thankful for that. However, since then, there's been radio silence, and that's 270 special places in limbo.

In July, I wrote to the minister to ask for an update on the timeline for construction, and I've heard nothing. So will the Leader of the House please help me secure a further meeting, but swiftly confirmation, swift confirmation of the deadline for opening both of those schools so that our children, schools, and local authorities are no longer left in the dark?

02:21:35 - 02:21:58

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The honorable lady is right to raise these matters on the floor of the House on behalf of her constituents because they will be of concern, not just to the local educational community, but also obviously to the young people and their families. So I will take that matter up with the department and ensure that she will get an answer to her questions.

02:21:58 - 02:22:41

Speaker 107

I'm grateful, Mr. Speaker.

The Higher Education Mental Health Implementation Taskforce was convened in 2023 to improve mental health support for higher education students and ensure that universities were better equipped to support student wellbeing. This taskforce, chaired by Professor Sir Steve West as the Higher Education Student Support Champion, was expected to meet until May this year, but no minutes have been published since October 2025. So will the Leader of the House please ask the Department for Education to provide an update on the taskforce's status, confirm whether or not Professor West is still in post, and also set out when it expects to publish the final report and recommendations of the taskforce?

02:22:41 - 02:23:04

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I want to reassure my honourable friend that Sir Steve West remains in post as the student support champion and as chair of the taskforce and will continue to do so until at least the end of the current academic year. The minutes of the meeting held in the last meeting in August of this year will be published shortly and I hope hopefully will provide him with the update that he reasonably requests.

02:23:04 - 02:23:27

Speaker 109

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Now, in rural areas like South Northamptonshire, transport is a really pressing issue, and the closure of the Ability bus service earlier this year has left many of my residents isolated. We need to do so much more to support and provide for community transport. So could I ask for a meeting or a debate, actually, in government time on securing greater support for community transport?

02:23:27 - 02:23:45

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government is very committed to community transport, understands the importance of it for all sorts of communities, not least rural communities. And I think this is probably something that the honorable lady might want to take up as either a backbench business debate or an adjournment debate.

02:23:45 - 02:24:32

Dawn Butler

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, Middle Yard Apartments in my constituency, I have one constituent stuck on the fourth floor because the lifts are not working. 500 constituents without hot water or heating, and they've been told that could last for months. Harley Property Investment Developers and Union Development Limited are responsible for this. Will the Leader of the House ask ministers in the Department of Energy to help urgently reconnect the gas because we're entering into colder months, and also the Minister for Housing so that we can look at financial mismanagement of freeholders and management companies because they have form, Mr. Speaker.

02:24:32 - 02:24:38

Dawn Butler

They have an apartment in Hackney that's also without water. Thank you.

02:24:38 - 02:24:38

Lucy Maria Powell

And I completely agree with my honorable friend that this situation is unacceptable. It's appalling that residents are being forced to rely on temporary measures despite paying service charges and with no end in sight in some cases. She's absolutely right to champion her constituent's urgent demand for the immediate restoration of services and I do hope that her words have been heard today by the developers and the managers. We've got the Leasehold Bill coming down the track, Mr. Speaker, hopefully that will right some of these wrongs. But I also will take up the matter with the ministers most associated with this to see if my honorable friend can get the progress that she seeks.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

02:25:22 - 02:25:24

Speaker 111

Susan Murray.

02:25:24 - 02:26:03

Susan Murray

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

My constituent in Mid Dunbartonshire has spent eight years trying to recover child maintenance owed by their former partner. An investigation has identified undeclared income and a failure to pay, yet enforcement action hasn't happened. The case has also recently been found to have been left unassigned for seven months after being returned to the CMS by the Financial Investigation Unit. Will the Leader of the House help arrange a meeting with a minister to address this case and the wider failures in child maintenance service case handling?

02:26:03 - 02:26:29

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And we recognize that some parents' experiences of the child maintenance service don't meet the standards that are expected of them, which is why we're committed to reforming the system.

But I will assist the honorable lady in trying to get a meeting with the relevant ministers so that she can raise this case in light of, in the context of what we're trying to do generally with the Child Maintenance Service.

02:26:29 - 02:27:06

Nick Smith

Mr. Speaker, we had huge wildfires in the Welsh valleys last summer. So can I welcome last week's summit, which announced the UK's first permanent military firefighting capability. Now, when I met firefighters after the summit, I heard anecdotal reports that some fires were being started deliberately. So could we please have a ministerial update on further next steps after the summit? We need many more preventative ideas to address this dreadful issue.

02:27:06 - 02:27:32

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The anecdotal reports that my honourable friend raises are very concerning indeed. We are investing as a government £97 million upgrading national resilience assets, and we are developing England's first wildfire action plan covering prevention, preparedness, response, and recovery. And I'll ensure that my honourable friend receives an update from the relevant minister to give him the answer that he seeks.

02:27:32 - 02:27:34

Speaker 114

Martin Vickers.

02:27:34 - 02:28:14

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. St. Andrew's Hospice in Grimsby and Lindsey Lodge in Scunthorpe provide an excellent service to my constituents, as does the hospice movement across the country.

Hospice UK held a drop-in session earlier this week when they outlined that research had been taking place that modest additional funding to the movement could save the NHS considerable amounts in emergency treatments. Could the leader find time for a debate on this where we can explore how the hospice movement can actually save money for the NHS as well as providing excellent care for our constituents?

02:28:14 - 02:29:01

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The honorable gentleman is an assiduous campaigner for St. Andrew's Hospice and related issues, and I recall a particularly moving speech that he gave on hospice care during the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, and I pay tribute to him for that. We are supporting the hospice sector with a £125 million funding boost alongside £80 million for children's hospices over the next three years, but I do understand continuing concern in the sector. I will make sure that the relevant department hears his concerns, but I'd also remind him that we've got three days of budget debate.

I'm sure he's been long enough to be able to weave hospice funding into a contribution should he catch your eye.

02:29:01 - 02:29:37

Juliet Campbell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In my constituency of Broxtowe, residents have reported to me dangerous racing, speeding and other forms of anti-social behavior on the A52 near Bardills roundabout. I've continually raised this with the Highways Agency, Nottingham City Council, Nottingham County Council and with Nottinghamshire Police to no avail. Would the Leader of the House support me and assist me in bringing together the relevant ministers so we can get those agencies together to secure safety on that stretch of the road?

02:29:37 - 02:30:16

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The government recognizes the importance of preventing dangerous driving and ensuring the safety of all road users. And I pay tribute to my honorable friend for raising this on behalf of her constituents in the way that she does. We are taking steps through the road safety strategy to make our roads safer for everyone. But it does need everyone to step up, Mr. Speaker, including local councils and the local police.

I will do as she asks, and I will help to secure a meeting with the relevant ministers so that she can discuss these matters further to make sure that those who do play a part are working together to get the best outcome.

02:30:16 - 02:30:46

Paul William Forster

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yesterday's budget included an announcement that Surrey would get a mayor. In the Red Book budget papers, it had that we're in advanced talks to have a mayor in my county. That is contrary and that is news to MPs like me who have not been consulted.

There has been no vote on any local authorities in the county. So please could we have a debate in government time about the merits of introducing new mayors, including about the process that could result in my constituents of Woking and other areas having a mayor without having a say?

02:30:46 - 02:30:59

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I do understand the concern in some areas about the changes that we are proposing. But I'd just point out to him that we're expecting a local government statement next, in which case he might want to make the point directly to the minister.

02:30:59 - 02:31:01

Speaker 116

Anna Dixon.

02:31:01 - 02:31:34

Anna Dixon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week I attended the National Curry Awards here in Parliament, and I was delighted to present Sizzling Lounge from Bingley in my Shipley constituency with their award for best restaurant.

They're one of the highest-rated curry houses in Bradford and run by two inspiring brothers who came to the UK as child refugees from Myanmar. So would the Leader of the House join me in congratulating Sizzling Lounge and all the fantastic curry restaurants, particularly those in Bradford, who contribute so much to our high streets and towns?

02:31:34 - 02:32:01

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I absolutely join my honorable friend in congratulating Sizzling Lounge on their award, and I'd better be careful by commending all the curry houses in my constituency too for the fantastic contribution they make. I want to thank all of those who made this possible. They are an important part of our local community, not just hers but others too, and I congratulate and thank everyone concerned.

02:32:01 - 02:32:02

Speaker 118

Stuart Andrew.

02:32:02 - 02:32:44

James Stuart Andrew

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We are blessed in this country with charities up and down the country doing an amazing work. And I was pleased to host a dinner here launching a new one that's based in Northamptonshire in my constituency called Living Like Linda, which is inspired by the incredible Linda Williamson, who now helps other people going through chemotherapy, long-term chemotherapy, to enjoy days out and social experiences so that they can forget about their treatment for a few hours. So will the Leader of the House join me in paying tribute to both Linda and her husband Andy for the amazing work that they've done and all other charities up and down the country who help people who really need it most?

02:32:44 - 02:33:23

Lucy Maria Powell

Hear, hear. Mr. Speaker, charities are the very heart and the very best of our local communities.

Charities are the very heart and the very best of our local communities, and I'm happy to join the right honourable gentleman in thanking Linda and Andy for everything that they do, and wishing Living Like Linda well for the future, and all the volunteers across our country who do such a fantastic job on behalf of our local communities. Stephanie Peacock. Oh, thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've been going to Penistone Paramount in my constituency since I was a child. This 110-year-old Art Deco cinema is the jewel in the crown of our town.

02:33:23 - 02:34:13

Marie Tidball

Yet the Reform-led Barnsley Council has decided to shelve the 1.8 million Principal Towns funding that was going to be used to build a second screen, a new cafe and bar area, and make the cinema accessible throughout. Reform's decision is indefensible. This was ring-fenced funding with planning permission already granted and a procurement notice published.

My constituents agree, with over five and a half thousand of them signing my petition calling for the council to reverse its reprehensible decision. Will the Leader of the House advise me on how I can best work with the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport to ensure generations of local people can continue to enjoy our treasured community asset for another century to come?

02:34:13 - 02:34:47

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honourable friend is a fantastic advocate for her constituents and she's right to raise this important matter. I'm afraid it's just the latest example of Reform-led councils letting down the people that they are supposed to be representing. With ring-fenced funding secured, with planning permission in place and a procurement notice published, there really is no excuse for Reform on this matter. And I will raise this with colleagues at DCMS and ensure that she gets the meeting that she seeks.

02:34:47 - 02:35:22

Victoria Collins

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Just to declare an interest as a patron of St. Francis Hospice. The assisted dying debate provided a much-needed focus on cross-party commitment to improve palliative care, so all those who need it can get the support and solace just like Judith's husband John found at the Hospice of St. Francis. So, Mr. Speaker, will the Leader of the House join me first in thanking the charities and volunteers who drive that hospice care, but also ensure we keep up that momentum, secure a debate on palliative care, and consider the four-point plan from Hospice UK and secure the future and funding of hospice care?

02:35:22 - 02:36:03

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

I'm delighted to, pleased to join the honorable lady in paying tribute in her local example of hospice care, but hospice care across the country. And as I said in answer to a previous question, the government is committing more resources to that, but we are aware of the concerns and in some sense the demands of the hospice center across the country to make sure that they can go on providing the very best services that they can. And as I said to the previous speaker, I think that we have three days of debate on the budget and it seems to me the sort of thing that a constituency MP might want to raise during that.

02:36:03 - 02:36:38

Maureen Burke

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent recently contacted me after his three-year-old daughter was involved in a terrifying near miss with a recklessly ridden e-bike. The unsafe use of these vehicles is a growing threat to public safety.

In Scotland, enforcement is devolved and regulation is reserved. With this in mind, would the Leader of the House make time available for a debate on how the Scottish and UK governments can work together to protect our communities from dangerous e-bikes?

02:36:38 - 02:37:12

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend raises a very concerning matter. We have heard too many tragic stories involving the dangerous use of e-bikes, including in my own constituency. The Crime and Policing Act introduced new offenses and penalties for dangerous cycling, and I would encourage my honorable friend to apply for a Westminster Hall debate, or indeed an adjournment debate, to discuss further how we can work not just to tackle e-bikes, but also how best we can work cross-border.

02:37:12 - 02:37:55

David Mundell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I don't know whether you or the leader are cinema-goers, but this weekend you could visit the Lonsdale Cinema in Annan for its range of Halloween films, including a 30th anniversary screening of The Scream. But also, I commend Alan Towers, the proprietor of that cinema, on the fact that it has been nominated as Cinema of the Year in the British Independent Film Awards, and to commend further Alan and his team for keeping that cinema going through sometimes difficult times and providing a much-valued entertainment service for people across the south of Scotland and beyond.

02:37:55 - 02:38:35

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

I certainly join the honorable gentleman in congratulating Lonsdale Cinema for being shortlisted as one of the best cinemas in the UK and for Alan Towers himself for all the work that he has done. Independent cinema is very important and as I am a cinema-goer, I am something of a film buff. I'm sure it's very tempting, Mr. Speaker, to in one of these exchanges to have a week of cinema, I don't know. We'll see where we get to. But I want to pay tribute to all those who work to make this possible and who have provided entertainment for so many people in his area, but also I should say the Jam Jar Cinema in my constituency too.

02:38:36 - 02:39:12

Catherine Helen Atkinson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Derby built the engines that powered the Spitfire, and the Chancellor announced a 2.5 billion pound joint investment by government and Rolls-Royce in the budget to develop the next generation of aircraft engine, support thousands of jobs, and should create tens of thousands more jobs in the next decade. So does the Leader of the House agree with me that this is a brilliant example of our government rebuilding British industry, working alongside business to deliver skilled jobs, opportunities for young people, and strengthen our economy?

02:39:12 - 02:39:38

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And my honorable friend is absolutely right to celebrate the announcements made in the budget yesterday by my honorable friend the Chancellor. I do agree with her. This is an excellent example of the government's commitment to reindustrialization, which will ensure that our investment works twice for us, both keeping us safe, but also driving reindustrialization with skills here in the UK.

02:39:38 - 02:39:39

Andrew Rosindell.

02:39:39 - 02:40:27

Andrew Rosindell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the Leader of the House join me in celebrating on Monday this week Essex Day and to thank Mr. Speaker for flying the flag of the county of Essex from New Palace Yard here in the Houses of Parliament? But would he also accept that we have wonderful charities in Essex like the Collier Row and Romford Foodbank and the St. Francis Hospice? We didn't see very much in yesterday's budget that supports local vital charities that help local people and do the work that possibly takes away costs from government. So can we have a debate in government time about how we can support local charities like the ones I've mentioned to support local people in my borough, but across the country?

02:40:27 - 02:41:03

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

We've missed the honorable gentleman in the last few weeks and therefore flags have really got a mention, but we're back there. Look, I know why he does it. He does it very well on behalf of his constituents, I have to say that. There was a lot in yesterday's budget which he might want to go back and have a look at. But if he's, if there are some things there that he wants to go further on, like hospice funding or like food banks or whatever else and support for charities, then he's got an opportunity because we've got three days left on the budget debate.

02:41:03 - 02:41:38

Josh Dean

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Sandra Morphew is best known as the 82-year-old former landlady of the Rose and Crown in Bishop's Stortford and she's much loved by our community. But she's currently on life support in Turkey following a serious accident.

Due to a dispute with her medical insurance, Sandra's family now face spiralling medical costs and a potential £80,000 bill to bring her home, which they're now raising money to pay. So will the Leader of the House join me in encouraging residents in Bishop's Stortford to support this crowdfunder and sending best wishes to Sandra's family, and will he kindly use his good offices to help me to raise Sandra's case with the relevant minister?

02:41:38 - 02:42:05

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and first of all, I'm sure the whole House will join me in wishing Sandra a speedy recovery. And I join him in encouraging constituents to donate to the crowdfunder if they can, if that's appropriate and they can afford to do so. And thirdly, I'll be happy to facilitate a meeting with him for him with the relevant minister so he can put his case directly to them.

02:42:06 - 02:42:41

Charlie Dewhirst

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'm sure both yourself and the Leader of the House will share my delight at the news that the Seabirds pub in Bridlington has reopened following a £300,000 refurbishment.

This coincides with my Pub of the Year competition in Bridlington and the Wolds. I'm absolutely delighted to be home to 114 pubs across the constituency. So will the Leader of the House join me in thanking every landlord and every landlady across the country for all their hard work and everything they do for local communities? And after my competition has closed on Saturday, will the Leader of the House join me for a pint in the winning pub?

02:42:41 - 02:43:13

Lucy Maria Powell

It's extraordinarily tempting, Mr. Speaker. But seriously, I do congratulate everybody involved in the refurbishment of the pub. Pubs are at the heart of our local communities, and I congratulate everybody involved.

I can't guarantee that I will be there to celebrate with him, but I'm sure he will find a lot of local residents who will be very pleased that it's happened. And perhaps when he's there sharing a pint with them, he can talk about the support for hospitality which was in yesterday's budget.

02:43:13 - 02:43:46

Catherine Jane Smith

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I believe that you, like I, dropped into the Parkinson's UK drop-in for MPs yesterday, where it was highlighted that across the country we have a postcode lottery when it comes to access to blue badges for people that are suffering from Parkinson's. So I was wondering if I could ask the Leader of the House if we could have a debate in government time about this postcode lottery, because access to blue badges is a real enabler for people with disabilities to be able to get out, go to work, education, appointments. So can we have a debate in government time? Thank you.

02:43:46 - 02:44:21

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

My honorable friend raises important concerns and I understand that she successfully lobbied her local council to not go ahead with a proposal to scrap free blue badge parking on council car parks. And if that is the case, then I pay tribute to her and local campaigners for their hard work. Regarding her concerns on issues of people with Parkinson's accessing blue badges, I will make sure that she gets a response from the relevant minister to directly address her points. And should she wish to follow that up with a meeting with the minister, I'll help her to arrange that.

02:44:22 - 02:45:01

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent William lives in a beautiful, high-quality, recently built home in Wimborne, but the developer won't allow him or his neighbors to install solar panels on the front. Ben lives in a recently built, beautiful shared ownership house in Merley and his housing association won't allow him to install an EV charger.

So, the Secretary of State for Housing has talked extensively about dealing with the blockers. But can the Leader of the House arrange for a ministerial update on what we can do about the corporate blockers who are stopping people from improving their own homes and trying to decarbonize the nation?

02:45:01 - 02:45:16

Lucy Maria Powell

Mr. Speaker, I can get the honorable lady that update that she seeks, but it seems to me this is the sort of topic that an adjournment debate or a Westminster Hall debate is ideal for, because I'm sure other colleagues from across the House will share her concerns.

02:45:16 - 02:45:18

Speaker 126

Markus Campbell-Savours.

02:45:18 - 02:45:49

Markus Campbell-Savours

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Purchased for £51,000 in 2022, Cockermouth's Old Courthouse later collapsed and still partially sits in the River Cocker. However, in the owner Halal Group Limited's accounts, they state fixed assets of £248,000.

They have not responded to calls for transparency or action. Would the Leader agree to a debate on micro-company accounts, their use by property investment businesses, and the lack of transparency over asset valuations?

02:45:49 - 02:46:20

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'm sure this case will have made great concern to my honorable friend's constituents. He's absolutely right to raise it. I hope that the owners of the building concerned have heard what he's said today and take very urgent steps to address the situation because if they don't, I have a feeling that my honorable friend is going to be seeking an adjournment debate or a Westminster Hall debate in which he's going to give even further voice to this need. So I do hope that they listen and get on with it.

02:46:20 - 02:46:21

Robbie Moore.

02:46:21 - 02:46:21

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

02:46:21 - 02:47:04

Robbie Moore

Across Keighley and Ilkley, we are constantly seeing large numbers of those large nitrous oxide canisters being discarded, many of which are left at the side of roads. They are clearly being used illegally by drivers and others, which creates major concerns with road safety, but also littering, which is leaving it to organisations like Litter Free Ilkley to pick them up. There is a clear link to safety and a safety threat for driving with the influence of nitrous oxide, but the detection in the body is difficult still for the police to pick up.

So can we have a debate in government time to address this, but also looking at bringing out much stricter controls around purchase of these canisters?

02:47:04 - 02:47:33

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And we are doing a lot around fly-tipping and there are aspirations across government to do more about waste crime. So his concerns are not only concerning but distressing, but also timely. He might want to seek a debate, Mr. Speaker, an adjournment debate, because as he rightly suggests, it's not just the responsibility of one department. It's about departments working together to make sure that we can take this matter forward for his constituents and indeed constituents across the country.

02:47:33 - 02:47:35

Speaker 128

Ben Thompson.

02:47:35 - 02:48:08

Sharon Hodgson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This month marks OCD Awareness Month, and last week I had the privilege of meeting young Ellis at Lord Lawson of Beamish Academy in my constituency. Ellis was diagnosed with OCD at a young age and has raised over £2,000 for OCD UK.

Will the Leader of the House join me in congratulating Ellis on this incredible achievement and consider a debate in government time on improving awareness for OCD and access to support for young people?

02:48:08 - 02:48:47

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I join my honorable friend in congratulating Ellis on raising so much money for OCD awareness. It's right to celebrate young people making positive contributions to our society, and my honorable friend is right to do so. We are improving access to NHS mental health support for children and young people, including those with OCD, with over 40,000 more receiving support in this year to June compared with the previous year. But in order that we can make it clear to ministers the need to continue to make progress on this, I would encourage him to apply for a Westminster Hall debate.

02:48:47 - 02:49:13

Tessa Munt

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

My constituent, who's approaching retirement, has been quoted £2,710 for root canal treatment. With just 23% of adults in Somerset seeing an NHS dentist in the last two years, can the Leader of the House highlight the problems of access of NHS dentists and ask the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care to reform dental services and end the South West's status as a dental desert?

02:49:13 - 02:49:42

Lucy Maria Powell

Mr. Speaker, and we've heard about this issue because it's a serious issue on many occasions. And the government is doing all it can to get dental hubs out there to make sure that people do get access. But as she is aware, the question is wider than that. It's about reforming the dentistry contract. So I'll make sure that the relevant minister's heard what she said today.

I'll get her an update on what is intended, including in her own area.

And if she wants a meeting with the minister, I'll arrange that too.

02:49:42 - 02:50:14

Paul Davies

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last week I visited the Horizon Group in my constituency, which has developed Hero, a solar-powered safety warning device made for remote environments. The products currently provide an essential safety message for some regions of Network Rail on unmanned crossings and access points. Innovation such as this keeps people safe. So does the Leader of the House, like me, welcome the Chancellor's statement yesterday on the importance of supporting innovation by British industry?

02:50:14 - 02:50:41

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yes, I do, and my honorable friend is right to praise the work of the Horizon Group and their innovative work. We are committed to supporting innovations by SMEs, including 7.4 billion pounds through UK Research and Innovation to support innovative company growth.

There are a number of days in the budget debate, and I would encourage my honorable friend to make his remarks should he catch your eye in one of those.

02:50:41 - 02:51:21

Munira Wilson

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. As a result of the government's so-called fair funding formula, Richmond Council, my local authority, faces a devastating cut of over 100 million pounds of government funding over the next four years. That's almost 60% of its budget is about to be gutted. Our vulnerable children and adults are going to suffer the most as a result of this, these cuts. So could I ask the Leader of the House, given the Prime Minister's commitment to local leadership and empowering local communities, will he grant a debate in government time to revisit this damaging formula so we can find a sustainable solution?

02:51:20 - 02:51:21

Lucy Maria Powell

The budget announced 100 million pounds for local authorities to provide further support to households in greatest need. We are giving local leaders greater control over locally generated revenues. We're delivering 78 billion pounds in a multi-year finance settlement and 5.6 billion pounds boost for local services over the next three years. I understand that local authorities that are adversely in individual cases adversely affected by that will have concern and she's right to raise them. We've got a local government statement after this, she might find a way of getting that into that statement.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

02:51:57 - 02:52:31

Speaker 130

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last weekend the Alfred East Art Gallery in Kettering reopened after being shut for six years.

I have such fond memories of visiting there as a child, so I'm so pleased that the next generation of young people in Kettering will be able to experience the same. Would the Leader of the House join me in thanking Billy, Adam, all of the gallery team in Kettering for making this possible, and also join me in encouraging everyone in Kettering and the surrounding areas to visit the gallery? It's free and a really, really brilliant cultural experience.

02:52:31 - 02:52:51

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I absolutely join my honorable friend in congratulating the hard work of everyone involved in the reopening of the Alfred East Gallery. We are committed to funding the arts, with 130 cultural venues, museums, and libraries benefiting from the Arts Everywhere Fund, ensuring that galleries like the Alfred East are around for years to come.

02:52:52 - 02:53:35

Ben Maguire

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last month, South West Water were fined 8 million pounds for more than 500 sewage dumps.

Rather than going back to the Treasury, that money should reduce the bills of customers who actually paid for waste and sewage services. This fine followed 330 illegal dumps into the River Camel and 230 untreated dumps at Harlyn Beach, a world-class beach in Cornwall. My constituents are sick of a company that keeps breaking the law and treats fines as a cost of doing business. Will the Leader of the House commit to a debate on government time holding these failing water companies to account and introducing jail time for offending water bosses?

02:53:35 - 02:54:04

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We have introduced criminal liability for water bosses who cover up or hide sewage spills, indeed up to two years behind bars.

But the honorable gentleman speaks very powerfully because I understand the effect that it has in areas such as his. And I hope that the water company has heard what he's said here today. Should he seek an adjournment debate or a Westminster Hall debate, I'm sure he could go even further in what he clearly feels very, very strongly about.

02:54:04 - 02:54:05

Chris Stephens.

02:54:05 - 02:54:47

Chris Stephens

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My constituent Hazel McLeod brought generations in Winchburgh together with pupils from Winchburgh Academy, Sinclair Academy, and senior community group Good Companions, creating a book of residents' memories, "What Do You See When You Look At Me?" The book received the Highly Recommended Award at the Global Intergenerational Excellence Awards 2026, which recognized 13 projects worldwide.

Will the Leader join me in congratulating everyone involved and commend Hazel Sterling's efforts throughout the years and make a statement on the value of intergenerational projects to preserve local stories and strengthen community spirit?

02:54:47 - 02:55:11

Lucy Maria Powell

Yes, I do, Mr. Speaker, and I want to join my honorable friend in congratulating everyone involved with the making the "What do you see when you look at me?" book on receiving their very prestigious award. Projects like this play a vital role in preserving local stories, bridging generational divides, and strengthening community spirit. So I just want to say well done to everybody concerned.

02:55:11 - 02:55:51

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I ask the Leader of the House this question?

The report International Labour Law and International Human Rights Law: Analysing the Convergence and Divergence, recently launched in Parliament right here, highlights significant gaps in the implementation of international labour rights, particularly affecting women, children, and informal workers. So will the Leader of the House please ask the Secretary of State to make a statement, or better still, make time for a backbench business debate on the effectiveness of UK programs in promoting international labour rights and supporting the implementation of core ILO conventions? Thank you.

02:55:51 - 02:56:21

Lucy Maria Powell

Mr. Speaker, as ever, the honourable gentleman raises a serious matter. He's right to point out that it is often women and children who suffer most when international labour rights are undermined. The UK continues to work with the ILO to implement and uphold employment rights across the world.

I will raise his concern with ministers, but the chair of the Backbench Business Committee is still in his place, so I'm sure should the honourable gentleman seek such a debate, the committee will want to give it consideration.

02:56:21 - 02:56:59

Liz Twist

Mr Speaker, this month marks Glow Week, the Child Brain Injury Trust's annual campaign reminding children to be bright and be seen as the clocks go back. I recently joined Delves Lane School for a Glow Week event and was joined by County Durham Fire and Rescue, Consett Neighbourhood Police and Elddis Transport, who brought along vehicles to show pupils how to stay safe on the roads. Will the Leader of the House join me in thanking the trust and make government time for a debate on improving road safety education to protect young brains from injury?

02:56:59 - 02:57:29

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr Speaker. My honourable friend has been a distinguished campaigner on this issue and I pay tribute to her for that and for the work of the Child Brain Injury Trust.

We are taking steps through the road safety strategy to make our roads safer for everyone. These matters have been raised consistently with me in these sessions, and I would encourage my honorable friend to join with others, perhaps, in seeking a backbench business debate on these matters, because I think it would be a particularly well-attended debate.

02:57:29 - 02:57:32

Speaker 133

Sam Tebbett.

02:57:32 - 02:58:11

Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In South Derbyshire, an initiative developed by my constituent, Dan Mottley, my team, and me has been taken forward by South Derbyshire District Council to encourage businesses to publish clear accessibility information, helping disabled people, their families, and friends make informed choices on venues to visit while recognizing the economic value of the purple pound.

Ahead of Purple Pound Day on the 3rd of November next week, will the Leader of the House consider a debate on introducing mandatory accessibility information standards for businesses to ensure disabled consumers can access clear, consistent information and give more businesses the confidence and guidance to become accessible and inclusive?

02:58:11 - 02:58:31

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I pay tribute to my honorable friend and her constituent, Dan Mottley, for their local initiative. And I'll make sure that the relevant department has heard her question today. I'd encourage her to apply for a Westminster Hall debate, Mr. Speaker, so the matter can be discussed further, because I'm sure there are other honorable members who might want to join in on that.

02:58:31 - 02:59:04

Anna Gelderd

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last weekend saw the 65th anniversary of the building of the Tamar Bridge, and local people are still paying the price to cross what is clearly critical national infrastructure.

So I marked the occasion by talking to local people in Saltash and Torpoint about my petition to end the tolls, which are a barrier to growth and to accessing essential healthcare, schools, and jobs over the Tamar. So will the Leader of the House support me to secure a meeting with the Secretary of State for Transport to deliver a fairer toll system in the short term and a toll-free Tamar in the long term?

02:59:04 - 02:59:29

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank my honorable friend for this question because she's an insidious campaigner on this matter. She makes a powerful case about the financial burden that tolls place on residents and businesses who need to get to work and access essential services. I'll make sure that the Transport Secretary is made aware of her representations on the floor of the House today, and we'll see if we can arrange a meeting for her.

02:59:29 - 03:00:11

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, if you or the Leader of the House would like to visit my Gloucester constituency, first of all, you'd be very welcome, and secondly, you would see rather a rare sight: seagulls seemingly walking on water in Gloucester Docks.

Now, I'm not aware of any divine intervention, but we have had a very dry summer and an unprecedented silt build-up. Canal & River Trust have started a four million pound dredging program, but I'm concerned that in the long term, we're going to keep seeing this problem build up again and again as the dry summers continue. So will the Leader of the House give a debate in government time on how we can make water companies like Bristol Water, who pump water out of our canal system, pay their fair share to uphold and maintain the historic docks in Gloucester?

03:00:11 - 03:00:33

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I understand that the current water supply agreement between Bristol Water and the Canal & River Trust is due to be renewed in 2028 and that there are ongoing conversations regarding dredging and managing silt in Gloucester Docks.

I'll make sure that the relevant minister hears his concerns, but he may want to take that further and seek an adjournment debate.

03:00:33 - 03:01:05

Helena Dollimore

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Many local towns like Rye and Bexhill give free Saturday parking during the festive season to boost local high streets, but not Hastings. That's why last year I launched a campaign calling on the local council to roll this out in Hastings too. Does the Leader of the House agree with me that after the budget yesterday took decisive action to support local businesses and cut business rates, that Green-run Hastings Borough Council should get in the festive spirit early and support my campaign for Christmas parking in Hastings?

03:01:05 - 03:01:29

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honorable friend is a doughty campaigner for her constituents and I pay tribute to her for that, and what she says about the run-up to Christmas and parking will resonate around the country.

As she rightly points out, we have given Hastings Council record funding and I suggest that they spend it on the priorities of her constituents and listen to what my honorable friend has said.

03:01:29 - 03:02:10

Charles David Robertson

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Advantage Retirement Homes runs two care homes in my constituency, St Thomas Priory near Armitage and Chasewater Muse in Burntwood. Between these two properties, the company is currently owed a staggering sum by the local Integrated Care Board, almost £600,000. The board is failing to pay out funded nursing care payments, a weekly sum that the NHS should pay to cover the cost of registered nurses in care homes. This has been going on since 2023.

Does the Leader of the House agree with me that this is utterly unacceptable and will he ask the relevant minister to meet with me to discuss the penalties that are available for ICBs when they fail to make the payments that are owed to hardworking companies in my constituency?

03:02:10 - 03:02:33

Lucy Maria Powell

Mr. Speaker, the issue that my honorable friend raises is very concerning. He's right to raise it today.

The fact it goes back to 2023, I think adds greater urgency to it. We recognize the significant concern that unresolved payment issues can cause for providers, so I would be happy to try to facilitate a meeting with him and the relevant minister so that he can raise the case even further.

03:02:33 - 03:03:09

Christopher Murray

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Bonfire Night can be difficult in Edinburgh, and previous years have seen serious disruption and pretty terrifying anti-social behavior in Niddrie and Craigmillar.

I've been working closely with the police for months and with the Hays Community Hub, Sandy's Community Centre, and many other groups across Craigmillar and Niddrie to keep disruption this year to a minimum, backed by 20 million from the UK Government's Pride in Place funding. So will my right honourable friend support a debate on how we back community organisations to tackle anti-social behaviour around Bonfire Night?

03:03:09 - 03:03:45

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and my honourable friend is absolutely right to raise this matter because that will resonate again with members across this House, and it's often raised with me at this time of a year, and I commend him for the work that he's doing in his local community. The government is looking at the matters that he raises. The consultation on reforming fireworks and pyrotechnic legislation received a very high number of responses, not surprisingly, and the government is currently considering the evidence and will respond in due course, and at that point, I'm sure there'll be ample opportunity to discuss this matter further.

03:03:45 - 03:04:28

Jayne Susannah Kirkham

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After Storm Austin last week, with its echoes of Storm Garett, I wanted to recognize some of my Cornish parish councils who set up their emergency plans. Saltwind Catering for working with the National Grid providing some of that hot food that people needed. National Grid themselves and their teams for what they've done, particularly Jacob Wallace at National Grid. Cormac for sorting out the trees so quickly now and our farmers and Radio Cornwall.

I think a lot of their actions and what we did in Garett led to the Be Prepared scheme that the government rolled out last week. Could we have a debate in government time on support for resilience in communities in the face of the effects of climate change and some of these severe storms?

03:04:28 - 03:05:18

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My honourable friend is right to list all of the individuals and organisations that played an important part in clearing up the storms and I pay tribute to them and indeed everybody across the country for everything that they have done, including local radio, National Grid, in many cases farmers, absolutely crucial to the work that happens. As she's right to do that, the government understands the challenges of changing climate and the importance of resilience, and we will be bringing forward in the future an opportunity to debate these matters still further. But again, because it's about organisations making sure that they've got the resources that they need, we've got three days of budget debate left if my honourable friend wishes to raise, give time to raise these matters still further.

03:05:18 - 03:05:44

Speaker 93

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Local veteran support group The Muster Point do fantastic and vital work supporting veterans right across my community.

And this winter, they're teaming up with the inspirational Chicksands and Henlow Military Wives Choir to release a single, "We're Still Here", to raise funds to support their vital work. So would the Leader join me in thanking them for all they do for our community and urge members right across the House to dig deep and get behind their efforts and drive that single right up the charts this Christmas?

03:05:44 - 03:06:08

Lucy Maria Powell

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I'm sure the whole House will join me in thanking The Muster Point and the Chicksands and Henlow Military Wives Choir for their invaluable work in supporting veteran communities. And I would join my honorable friend in encouraging members to get behind and listen to the Christmas single, "We're Still Here", to make sure that it gets the notice and the credit that it deserves.

03:06:08 - 03:06:27

Speaker 99

May the front benches change over.

03:06:27 - 03:06:32

Speaker 139

If we're ready, Minister, Mr. McMahon.

03:06:32 - 03:07:06

Jim McMahon

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This government is committed to shifting power from Westminster and Whitehall to the places where people live and work. Yesterday's budget showed that we are committed to giving local leaders, local councils, and local communities the tools to shape their future. But our ambition to rewire the state and make sure the country is ready for devolution depends on strong, sustainable local government. And it's only through reorganization that we'll create those strong foundations.

03:07:06 - 03:07:09

Speaker 140

We know reorganization is difficult, but we also believe that it's worth it.

03:07:09 - 03:14:27

Jim McMahon

The decisions that we take now will be the building blocks for how this country is governed for generations to come. And our vision is clear: mayoral and strategic authorities underpinned by strong unitary councils with real powers to take decisions in the interests of their communities. On the 7th of September, the Secretary of State announced a review of the programme to ensure that it was robust and aligned with this government's priorities. Since then, we have listened to local leaders, sector partners, mayors and members of Parliament, and I want to place on record our thanks to them for the work that they have done and for engaging constructively. Consensus will not always be possible, but I know that all of us are putting forward arguments for what we believe are the best for the different areas of England.

I am committed to hearing all those views before coming to final decisions.

I also want to take a moment to recognise the impact on councils, on councillors, on their staff, and I appreciate their desire for clarity. Today I can provide some clarity on what comes next. I can announce to the House that the first phase of the review is now complete. I have tested the programme's framework, including whether the criteria set out in February last year continue to support the Government's priorities. I have concluded, on the basis of the programme, that it is robust.

And I've concluded that the existing criteria are correct both on their own terms and that they continue to support the Government's policy agenda. We are content that we can take forward local government reorganisation in line with existing criteria. In concluding this review, I have also considered the best way to bring clarity quickly, while making sure that each area receives the deep and thorough considerations that they all deserve.

So, we will inform councils of outcomes at the earliest possible opportunity. This means that some areas will get outcomes quicker than others. And so today, I am therefore able to give further clarity on some of the 14 areas who had decisions in July. The Secretary of State and I have carefully considered all the proposals and the evidence for these 14 areas. Following that initial consideration, we are minded to implement, subject to representations in a process and parliamentary approval, the following proposals in five areas.

Firstly, in East Sussex and Brighton and Hove, the two-unitary proposal including boundary changes requested by Brighton and Hove City Council, except for the parish of Farmer.

The one-unitary proposal in Gloucestershire, the three-unitary proposal in Oxfordshire, including boundary changes, and the two-unitary proposal in Warwickshire, alongside the two-unitary proposal in Worcestershire. These decisions are for the same council structures that were previously announced in July, but they are new decisions following full and thorough consideration. Before final decisions are taken, there will be a minimum of a three-week period during which those who are interested may make further representations to me. The start and end dates for this period will be confirmed very shortly, as well as further detail on how councils and other interested parties can make representations. Any final implementation decisions will be subject to the normal parliamentary approval.

In the remaining nine areas announced in July, we're going to take more time and we'll use the coming months to further consider proposals submitted before coming to a view. To give councils clarity on the legal status of the existing decisions, we are withdrawing the decisions announced in July for the following areas: for Derbyshire and Derby, for Devon, Plymouth and Torbay, for Hertfordshire, for Kent and Medway, for Lancashire, Blackburn with Darwen and Blackpool, for Leicestershire, Leicester and Rutland, for Lincolnshire, North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire, for Nottinghamshire and Nottingham, and for Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent. I want to be absolutely clear that this is not a reflection on the work underpinning those proposals. I can now set out the plan for the final phases of the review. The review will now focus on the 15 areas that are due to have mind-to decisions.

Those are, in no particular order, the nine areas I've just mentioned, the four areas with decisions withdrawn in September, Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, and West Sussex. To be clear, all options and proposals in these areas will remain under consideration and I'll approach all those with an open mind. As such, it should be not assumed that the same proposal will be automatically selected. It's important to allow the process to run its course and to allow full and proper consideration. We will move faster where we can, and some of the remaining areas may receive an outcome decision before others.

I commit to coming back to the House with updates for another set of areas by Christmas, and every area will have an outcome by early next year. Turning to local elections, as we set out in September, elections scheduled for May 27 will now go ahead to existing councils.

This means that elections to new councils will be May 2028, followed by a vesting day of April 2029. This is for all areas apart from Surrey. I've also heard concerns about the cost of uncertainty, and we appreciate that areas have incurred costs in good faith. All areas will receive half of that transition funding that they were previously due, and that equates to £450,000 per new unitary previously announced. These guaranteed payments will be made in the coming weeks regardless of the review's outcome.

Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and West Sussex will also receive £500,000 per area. After final decisions, we will pay any remaining balance depending on how many councils are chosen.

I've also heard from members across this House about the pride, about the history and identity sitting behind our cities and our counties. City status and ceremonial matters play a valuable role for local pride, and so we will work with areas to make sure that city status is preserved following reorganization. And subject to final decisions, we will continue to work with places to protect their city status by working through all the options, including bringing forward legislation where necessary. Apologies, I've been struggling with a cold for about a week. And usually when a minister kind of comes up in the morning with a croaky throat, it's a result of a long night of karaoke.

But I'm afraid this is the result, this is the result I'm afraid of LGR conversations back-to-back all morning, which doesn't carry quite the same fun or rhythm to it. But nevertheless, I want to continue to use this moment to build consensus and to deliver a program that we work together between central government and local government, because this program has to be a joint effort. It's the foundation of rewiring how our country works and getting the foundations in place to devolve new powers and functions in every area. This government will be an active and reliable partner and we stand ready to work with councils to support them to deliver these significant changes. And I promise to keep the House updated and I commend this statement to the House.

03:14:27 - 03:14:37

Speaker 142

Regardless of the croaky voice, I was paying attention because it covers my constituency of Wealden in East Sussex. Shadow Secretary of State, Katie Lam.

03:14:37 - 03:19:18

Katie Lam

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

It gives me no pleasure whatsoever to say that from start to finish, this government's approach to local government reorganization has been nothing short of a farce. The government first promised to publish its English devolution white paper in November 2024. That was delayed until December 24, with affected councils given three weeks over Christmas to decide whether or not to delay local elections. Last year, after the right honorable member for Ashton-under-Lyne was forced to resign from cabinet, her successor and, as it turns out, her predecessor, assured us that reorganization was not taking and would not take any longer than planned, and that elections scheduled for May 2026 would go ahead. The government confirmed this twice in November 2025.

Yet the very next month, they announced that elections in some parts of the country would be pushed back as far as 2028. Two weeks later, again in the run-up to Christmas, the then local government minister invited another wave of postponements.

In January of this year, despite having promised not to delay elections in November, the then Secretary of State announced legislation to postpone 29 elections. The next month, days before the department was due to answer for its behaviour in court, those postponements were withdrawn. Naturally, the taxpayer was left to pick up the tab for all of these delays, a bill which runs into the tens of millions of pounds. This U-turn was announced during recess so that members of Parliament had to wait to question ministers. In March, it was another set of announcements and another set of legal challenges.

In June, it was revealed in a pre-action letter issued by the department that ministers had ignored official advice over reorganization plans. In July, just days before the right honorable member for Maidenhead became Prime Minister, the previous Secretary of State announced a whole new set of reorganization plans, with many members given essentially no time to scrutinize the sweeping changes that were set to be imposed on their areas. We still haven't seen the advice which informed those decisions. Can the minister confirm today, in the interest of transparency, that this advice will be published? And in September, following updated and privileged legal advice, the current Secretary of State withdrew decisions for Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk, and Suffolk, and paused plans in most of the rest of the country.

What a complete joke, Madam Deputy Speaker. Today the minister talks of giving councils clarity, yet goes on immediately to say that all options and proposals remain under consideration and that he approaches all decisions with an open mind. He cannot be serious. We are two and a half years into this process, Madam Deputy Speaker, with years in opposition to plan it. Why have these decisions not yet been made?

And what clarity exactly have we gained from this statement? The vast majority of councils are none the wiser after what we have heard today. He talks of allowing the process to run its course and of giving full and proper consideration to each decision. But can he set out what will actually be taken into consideration? What role have party political objectives played in determining new local government boundaries?

How can we still be at the stage of keeping an open mind?

Has the government received at any point during the process legal advice which indicates that political considerations were given undue weight in deciding new council boundaries? And when can the councils which have been left in the dark by today's announcement expect some kind of verdict from the government? Which areas will hear by Christmas? What does early next year actually mean? Given this government's record on meeting its own deadlines, I'm sure the Minister will forgive me for my skepticism.

The real-world results of this endless delay are plain to see. People across the country are left without any sense of which council will be providing services in the year and years to come, while councillors and council officials have spent millions of pounds of taxpayers' money planning and preparing for new authorities which may never materialize. So, notwithstanding the announcement that the minister has made today on funding, can he provide an estimate today of the total cost of this government's shambolic local government reorganization? How much of that cost has been eaten by legal fees? The money spent on this farcical reorganization process should have been spent instead on resurfacing roads, collecting bins, and maintaining parks, core local government functions that people actually care about.

For all the Prime Minister's talk about local government, this whole approach to devolution has shown nothing but contempt for local democracy. Local voices have been ignored in the drawing of new council boundaries, overridden instead by party political considerations. Again and again, Labour's approach to local government has been about imposing more government, pushing up tax, and stacking the deck in a cynical effort to gain political advantage. They should be ashamed.

03:19:18 - 03:23:28

Jim McMahon

I think the first thing I'll say is that the concerns about the implications of the delay on councils and councillors and the officials that have been working on these schemes, we don't take for granted.

We know that the pause was disruptive and we know that people put a lot of work into the proposals that they did and in the transitional work that they did ahead of the new unitary councils. But equally, it would have been wrong for government not to have taken into account the legal status of those that were in court and not use that as an opportunity to review the programme overall, which was the decision that we announced in September. And that was the right thing to do, to give clarity to the programme, to move forward with confidence and to make sure that we are reviewing the criteria, the process, the decision-making, the evidence base and where needed to come to fresh decisions. Now, from my perspective, I play this absolutely with a straight bat. I want to do it with integrity and it's important to say that there are no government proposals on the table here.

The only proposals that a minister can consider are those that councils themselves have submitted during the process. Now, our job is to make sure that we test the evidence base, we test the assumptions, we take into account local opinion, we test the alignment with public service boundaries, we test the financial modelling, and through that work, we determine on balance, and by the way, there is no perfect solution for quite large parts of England that I have seen, but that doesn't mean we can't get it to be the best it can be. And so our job in making that decision is to do that in an objective way and with an open mind, which is why I can't understand the front bench on the other side criticising what is objectively the right thing to do. The idea that we pre-determine in a legal process what we believe to be the outcome that we most desire and railroad that through would be entirely the wrong thing to do.

And all of the vulnerabilities with LGR that she speaks about are features of previous rounds of LGR that the then Conservative government undertook on a fairly regular basis. There is no decision that government takes that isn't open to a legal challenge if somebody wants to move that challenge. And the government themselves on LGR found that they were in court defending previous decisions. Cumbria was a good example of that where the government were taken to court. That was heard by a judge and the government had to explain why it came to the view that it did.

So we should not pretend that somehow a legal challenge represents a fault in the system, but it is a pause for thought and that's the pause that we have taken to make sure that it is right going forward. On the questions about how this is going forward, so what there isn't in this approach is the previous kind of tranching up of areas. So there isn't like a tranche one, two or three quite deliberately. What we are going to do is to work through them as quickly as possible.

And the commitment that we've made is that rather than waiting, I don't know, for an artificial date at a particular point in time, if we can come forward earlier with a with a few, we should do that rather than waiting for the whole program to be confirmed a bit a bit later on in that process. And then finally on the point of costs and how much has been incurred. So there are different ways of looking at this. There are the costs of producing the proposals. Well, that isn't abortive because those proposals are real today and those proposals will be considered as part of the new process.

So those are not wasted costs at all and those are normal costs to be incurred in reorganization. There are costs then of transfers, how once a decision is made, actually preparing the ground to move to these new shadow unitaries. But that is required whatever decision is made in whatever county. So that is not abortive work either. What we do accept is that the decision to pause and ask areas to ask staff to stop working on these proposals has led to a cost incurred by those authorities that would not have been incurred had we not decided to pause that program.

And it's on that basis that we have decided to release the money that we have. And I think that's the right thing to do. You know, we believe strongly in central government and local government working in partnership together and us being respectful to each other. And if councils say that we've incurred costs that we would not otherwise have incurred, it's quite right that government say we're willing to meet you halfway.

03:23:28 - 03:23:30

Speaker 144

Cat Smith.

03:23:30 - 03:24:14

Catherine Jane Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Minister for his statement, but there remains some confusion in Lancashire and I hope the Minister is able to clarify a few things. The moving away from the different tranches suggests now that there is no timetable for what might happen in Lancashire.

My councillors are asking me for some clarity on a timetable for Lancashire. Can I also seek reassurance that this means that Lancaster will not lose its city status in any part of this reorganization, and that the building blocks for doing this reorganization doesn't have to be strictly on borough councils? For example, Wyre Borough Council, which was already an amalgamation of other councils, might want to stay looking in different directions.

03:24:14 - 03:24:15

Minister McMahon.

03:24:15 - 03:25:30

Jim McMahon

First of all, can I thank her for the representations that she's made over a long period of time on Lancashire reorganization and on devolution too. So the timetable that we set out, I accept it doesn't have the list-by-list, county-by-county of when exactly that's going to come. But we have said that we will conclude the considerations by the new year, or in the new year.

And so wherever the the counties find themselves in the program when it's advanced to develop in that sense, they will know one way or the other in that February-March period and we'll be working through them as and when. My point was more that if we're in a position to announce some earlier, we should do that rather than keeping areas waiting unnecessarily. And and that's the the idea of the approach that we're taking. On the the point correctly made about Lancaster and this impact cities actually across the the counties in scope, it would be absolutely wrong that just because the city status is aligned to the local authority that's being abolished rather than the geographical area, that they would potentially risk losing that status. And I can give an absolute assurance that whether we have to even move new legislation to preserve it, whatever we have to do, there will not be a current city that loses its status through reorganization.

03:25:30 - 03:25:33

Speaker 145

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Pippa Heylings.

03:25:33 - 03:27:18

Pippa Heylings

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Liberal Democrats support genuine devolution and shifting power out of Westminster. But we've been shocked by the government's botched handling of this process. Ministers promised that MPs and local leaders would be properly involved in decisions affecting their area, yet many have been left in the dark until announcements were effectively made for them. Can the Minister explain why MPs representing affected areas were not briefed before today's announcement? And even now, after months of confusion over local government reorganization, delayed elections, and significant abortive costs, councils and communities are still waiting for certainty.

Local authorities, many in dire financial positions following years of underinvestment, have spent time and money in good faith preparing these proposals according to the government's criteria and timetable, only for those timetables to shift repeatedly. And in my constituency of South Cambridgeshire, one of the fastest growing areas in the country, businesses need certainty to invest and plan. Councils need certainty to set budgets and deliver services, and council staff deserve clarity about their future. Yet today's statement leaves Cambridgeshire and Peterborough yet again waiting a decision while other areas move ahead. So when will the minister finally provide a clear and stable timetable for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and for other areas that are still awaiting decisions?

Finally, following the chaos of withdrawing decisions, pausing reorganization, and reviewing the program following updated legal advice, can the Secretary of State even guarantee that what she is announcing today is legally sound?

And will she now publish that legal advice to demonstrate that? Thank you.

03:27:18 - 03:29:37

Jim McMahon

So working backwards, the reason why we carried out the review was to make sure that we were satisfied as ministers who are making the decision that the decisions were being made in a rational way with the evidence base secured and that where there were questions outstanding that we tested that in the process. Because obviously we were not the ministers who made the July decisions and so coming back in we need to be absolutely sure that what we put our name to is correct and we're doing that in points. Now that may be in many areas that actually the same conclusion is reached, but importantly it'll be reached as a fresh decision.

So we are going to go through that, which is why it's taking time. And actually, had we have come here and said, you know what, we've completed the whole program review, the financial review, and we've done every single county in England outstanding in a few weeks, I think you would have cast doubt on just how much time we'd given to each of the counties and the proposals. So we are determined to make this robust, for it to be right, and to put the time needed to make sure that we fully go through the proposals, the consultation, the financial assessment, and where local areas have put forward an argument in support of their proposal, we are testing that line by line. And I'll give you an example. If a local authority is requesting a boundary change or to grow their boundaries, and it's predicated on matters like housing numbers or economic growth or travel to work areas, I want to see that.

I want to see the travel to work map, I want to see the urban development form in the way that it takes in that particular place, etc. So we are testing those to make sure that we are satisfied.

But I do return to the point I made. I haven't seen a single proposal that I consider to be the perfect proposal. But it's our job to make sure with that that we've received, that we try and get the best possible proposal. And that's the work that we are undertaking. On the point about Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, and obviously it applies to West Sussex as well, they essentially go into the same pool.

So I wouldn't assume necessarily that because they were at the end of the decision-making process on the previous round, that you're at the end of the process on the current round. We'll make a decision on which ones we're going to bring forward shortly. And on the point about legal advice, and it was mentioned by the opposition front bench as well, it's obviously long-standing government policy that we don't publish that legal advice.

03:29:37 - 03:29:42

Speaker 142

I need members to have much shorter questions and the ministers' answers to be on point as well. David Williams.

03:29:42 - 03:30:37

David Williams

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When I'm out listening to residents around Kidsgrove and surrounds, what they tell me is they want good public services delivered efficiently and to a high quality, but a two-tier system causes constant confusion. So if a resident wants to raise issues about their local park, they go and speak to the borough council. Have a question about your local library, go and speak to the county council. Need a pothole fixed, speak to your county council and not to your borough council, and that list goes on.

And at the same time, we're paying for managers and directors at two councils rather than one, which is a waste of public taxpayers' money. Would the minister agree with me that what matters most to the residents of Kidsgrove and surrounds is having good, high-quality services that work for them, and it also offers greater accountability because at the moment they're passed pillar to post?

But equally, residents in Stoke-on-Trent North and Kidsgrove do want clarity from the government, so can I please press the government to offer that clarity?

03:30:37 - 03:31:31

Jim McMahon

Well, I think he makes the case for reorganization well, really, which is it's less important how we perceive structures of government in this place. It's more important, in my view, that local people know who to hold to account for decisions that are made on in their name and with their taxes. And the truth is, in two-tier areas, there is confusion about which council you hold to account for delivery of services in those areas. And there is duplication of services.

The very fact that you have multiple chief executives and multiple finance directors and multiple HR directors, etc., means that in a period where all the pressures on adult social care and children's services and temporary accommodation and our desire to start rebuilding neighborhood services back up so people can see the improvement in their area, means that we have to do absolutely everything we can to direct money to the front line, to local services that people can see.

03:31:31 - 03:31:32

Bernard Jenkin.

03:31:32 - 03:32:05

Bernard Jenkin

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I don't think the Minister mentioned Essex in his statement, but on his point about funding, which I think is much appreciated, that areas have incurred costs in good faith, does that apply to Essex? Because on that basis of 450,000 per new unitary previously announced, we would be due 2.25 million pounds for the inconvenience and disruption to local government in Essex.

03:32:05 - 03:32:25

Jim McMahon

Minister.

Yes, all the local authorities that were engaged in LGR, whether they're part of the four that were subject to the court challenges or the one that we're withdrawing today, will receive a payment for the work that they have done. The reorganization program is going ahead, and so we are going to return to Hampshire, to Essex, to Norfolk and Suffolk to complete that work.

03:32:25 - 03:32:27

Speaker 150

Nadia Whittome.

03:32:27 - 03:33:02

Nadia Whittome

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Councils have spent considerable time and resources building the case for local government reorganization, including producing robust financial analysis, housing data, social care impact, and the impact on travel to work areas. Today's announcement raises serious questions for any future timetable. Can the Minister confirm, are councils expected now to go back to the drawing board and negotiate with surrounding councils on new boundaries?

And if so, how can they be expected to do this by January while meaningfully consulting their residents?

03:33:02 - 03:33:06

Speaker 153

Minister.

03:33:06 - 03:34:03

Jim McMahon

So as it stands, we are satisfied that there isn't a requirement for areas to develop new proposals. And so we will consider the proposals already submitted and the evidence base to it and also the consultation that then went alongside it. But these have to be fresh ministerial decisions that are objective and that we approach with an open mind. So there is no further requirement on councils to do that front work. However, we are going to introduce a minded-to process.

So when the decisions are made, they will be minded-to decisions.

And the idea of that is, I do think we need to rebuild good faith in local government, where if areas have concerns about the proposal that we believe ultimately is a minded-to decision, but it's not quite right for an area, or there are concerns about potential implementation or what it means to local communities, there's got to be something in the process where government is open to listen to that. And we believe that is best done through this minded-to process.

03:34:03 - 03:34:04

Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown.

03:34:04 - 03:34:32

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Yes, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I warmly welcome the Minister's statement today and his announcement that Gloucestershire will be one unitary authority? This will produce better administration and better value for money. However, can I ask him to explain to my constituents why we are having an election next May on the existing councils, which will gradually lose power as it moves towards the following election the next year? Why can't we simply have an election next May on the shadow unitary authority?

Minister.

03:34:32 - 03:35:53

Jim McMahon

So it's important that we have a program that is consistent across the country.

What we can't do is to say, well, because there seems to be a bit more local consensus in one place than the other, and maybe the legal risk is a bit less, we can suddenly kind of shortcut the process. And so that means that Gloucestershire, like everywhere else, will go through the minded-to process. So the letters that go to councils today will give around three weeks for interested parties to make representations. What that means in—and then obviously then we need to consider then our response to it and kind of do any more development from that. That will mean that the '27 election just won't be possible.

The other thing to I think have in mind is that even though we are doing our best to tie this down and for it to be robust, any decision of government can be challenged in court, including the one in Gloucestershire.

And I think the worst outcome actually is that we pretend that May 27 is an option where we're going to get to the end of the minded-to decision in January. It's going to take a couple of months then to look at it. That would be no time at all for a returning officer and political parties even to find candidates potentially for the new Cheshire unitary if there's a chance that that decision could be JR'd in that process. I think that would probably be the worst outcome. So it's, it will take a bit longer is the, is a fact.

But actually, having that does give more certainty to councils to prepare for it.

03:35:53 - 03:35:58

Speaker 155

Chris Webb, after which I will call Steve Darling. Chris Webb.

03:35:58 - 03:36:42

Christopher Paul Webb

The Minister knows my frustration with LGR and the original outcome.

And I know the member for Blackpool North and Fleetwood and the member for Fylde all agree that the outcome that came for Blackpool, Fylde and Wyre to merge as one authority was the worst outcome possible with the challenges that we face in a constituency in an authority like Blackpool. So does the minister agree or will look at with the mind to decisions that if local areas object to this that they're able to feed in other proposals that were on the table originally that may work better not just for our area but for across Lancashire? And on top of that, will he look at if they want to go back to the 500,000 size of authorities?

03:36:42 - 03:37:36

Jim McMahon

So I mean we've confirmed multiple times on the 500,000 population was a guiding figure. And we were very mindful during the course of reorganization that some councils were going above that, Gloucestershire being one example of that actually with mid-600s. But yeah, but actually there are others where they didn't believe for their local population for different reasons and sometimes actually it was the spread of or the difference of identity between a coastal community or an urban city or the rural shire that may have surrounded it where their view was actually the council should better represent that identity rather than you know being a single unit.

So that was always a guiding figure. There isn't in this process a window for new proposals, but what there will be is a minded-to process where when we confirm our preferred option, if there are proposals for tweaks that would make it better, then we'd be open to receiving that during that process.

03:37:36 - 03:37:38

Speaker 157

Steve Darling.

03:37:38 - 03:38:02

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. On the 7th of September, the Secretary of State made a commitment that Devon MPs would be able to hold a meeting with the appropriate minister to discuss local government reorganization in Devon. Sadly, that meeting has not occurred to date. What timescale will the minister give for such a meeting occurring? Thank you.

03:38:02 - 03:38:32

Jim McMahon

So, we did say that meetings would take place after the review, that we wanted the review to take its course. That's obviously now concluded and I've made a statement today. We do have a list of MPs that have requested meetings in debates and in writing, that is about 40 to 50 MPs. So we have a Monday evening surgery, 7:00 until 9:00, and we'll make sure that MPs, every two weeks, I should say, not every week. And we'll make sure that MPs are given a slot at the earliest possible opportunity.

03:38:32 - 03:39:08

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

The prize on offer for Gloucester residents from local government reorganization is the promise of devolution, so that we can share in the powers and the investment that the Prime Minister and the Chancellor have announced over the last previous few months. Will the Minister meet with me to discuss how we can make sure the local government reorganization and the model proposed for Gloucestershire will actually unlock devolution opportunities rather than block it, because the only credible option for Gloucestershire is a foundation status authority in the short term, with joining WECA in the long term? That's backed by six out of our seven local councils and all four constituent councils of the West of England Combined Authority.

03:39:08 - 03:39:43

Jim McMahon

Well, he makes an important point, and actually one of the criteria for reorganization is that it has to be compatible with devolution going forward. And hopefully members would have seen the announcement yesterday for ten new devolution agreements across England, significant investment that's going to come our way. But it's quite obvious, actually, when you look at the map of England, there is that belt around the Midlands where actually economies and communities say that they look in different directions, and we need to just work through in practice what a good settlement is for those areas. But I absolutely take on board his points. Thank you for all the work he does on this, and I'm very happy to meet.

03:39:43 - 03:39:43

Dame Karen Bradley.

03:39:43 - 03:40:26

Karen Bradley

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government is very good in imposing on people things they don't want. So in Staffordshire Moorlands the government wants to impose the end of Staffordshire Moorlands district and the end of Staffordshire police, reorganisations that will be at different timeframes and will lead to great confusion. So can I ask the minister if he will make sure he considers my proposal, which has been my proposal all along for local government reorganisation, which is leave our councils' local authorities in the state they are, leave them in the situation they are, give us a mayor if that's what the government wants to do, but we really don't need having any more distraction for our local government officials who need to get on and deliver services.

03:40:26 - 03:41:08

Jim McMahon

I just don't agree with the analysis that we can stay as we are. I don't think from a public service delivery point of view we can stay as we are. I don't think from a devolution point of view we can stay as we are.

And I don't think from a financial sustainability point of view we can stay as we are either. The world has changed and the demand now for people-led services in adults, children's, in temporary accommodation are overwhelming councils. So we have got to make sure that we free up the money from the system that is currently being used for executive pay and back office support and we direct that straight to neighborhoods and for people services. And that is not to decry the good work that district councils do at all. I respect those councils, but we have to take this in the 50-year period of what reorganization is.

03:41:08 - 03:41:56

Linsey Farnsworth

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister will know that I support local government reorganization and that I welcomed the original pause of the decision to split Amber Valley into two.

Now, I know the Minister is taking the time to carefully review the situation and I thank him for his thorough and thoughtful manner in which he's doing so. However, delay is bringing uncertainty for officers in the council in terms of their future, uncertainty of planning services, and uncertainty for delivery of projects for the people of Amber Valley going forward. So given that splitting Amber Valley is the only point of contention between the boroughs and districts of Derbyshire, will he commit, or can I urge him to commit, to a swift and firm timetable for Derbyshire? It can be sorted out quickly.

03:41:56 - 03:41:58

Speaker 161

Minister.

03:41:58 - 03:42:14

Jim McMahon

Yeah, I thank her for all her representations over a long period of time on this. I can definitely commit that we are going to move as quickly as possible. And all the points that she raised are definitely in our mind when we consider all the proposals about identity, about good public services, etc.

03:42:14 - 03:42:15

Nigel Farage.

03:42:15 - 03:42:37

Nigel Paul Farage

Thank you very much. I'm pleased that my party's legal challenge has bought us a stay in Essex and elsewhere, but to re-emphasize, district councils matter to remote, rural and coastal communities. In Clacton, planning decisions are taken in Clacton Town Hall. Big decisions that matter. Under your proposals, those decisions will be made by a large population center...

03:42:37 - 03:42:44

Speaker 163

Mr. Farage, just one moment please. Be seated on my feet, thank you. No you and yours because I'm not responding. Carry on.

03:42:44 - 03:43:03

Nigel Paul Farage

Big planning decisions are taken locally. They'll be taken miles away in a big population center with no understanding of the local ground.

Is that not against the devolution powers the Prime Minister, the Chancellor and you yourself have championed as being good for the country?

03:43:03 - 03:43:13

Speaker 163

Minister, for this response, I am not at the dispatch box. It's the Minister, not you and yours, backbench MPs are speaking through the chair. Minister.

03:43:13 - 03:44:08

Jim McMahon

Thank you, and I'm delighted the Member's managed to find a seat today. Looks quite comfortable there, and there's not a prayer card in sight that I can see. He actually makes an important point actually about how local politics matters. What we don't want to do through reorganisation is to take away the local. So the English Devolution Community Empowerment Act requires us to bring forward before Christmas neighbourhood governance arrangements.

And what we want to try and do is have a unit of government within a council so we hardwire it and mainstream it so that local councillors are given the respect of being frontline councillors with powers, resources to get things done in their area.

But that which we can do at a bigger level, that we do do that in a different way. Can I just say that, and I know he didn't mean this, but to be clear, the Reform Party is not taking the government to court. Local authorities have decided to issue claims and we need to make sure that we're not using local authorities for party political reasons.

03:44:09 - 03:44:52

Amanda Hack

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Minister for his statement and he will know I've been calling for a devolution settlement for Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland, which I was pleased was confirmed in the budget yesterday. However, we know that local government reorganization is going to be key to long-term strategic growth in our communities. So it is disappointing to hear of this withdrawal at this moment. But I have more concerns about how this uncertainty will impact our communities and our hard-working colleagues across local councils.

How will those local authorities be supported in Leicestershire and Rutland in light of this change to make sure this doesn't disrupt their long-term aim for excellent services to my residents?

03:44:52 - 03:45:25

Jim McMahon

She makes a very fair point about the impact of the of the pause and the delay and that has impacted a lot of council staff that have been working on this. It's definitely impacted on chief officers and legal officers and councillors, which is why we committed to returning back as soon as possible. I think we've honored that with the work that we've done so far, but we'll move at pace to make sure that we can move as quickly as possible. And obviously within her the counties of Leicestershire and Rutland, I think the prospect of securing devolution there and that investment could be transformational for the communities and the economy.

03:45:25 - 03:45:26

Steve Barclay.

03:45:26 - 03:46:07

Paul Stephen Barclay

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. After over two years, he's come to the chamber today to say all options are still on the table.

He can't say what the timeline is for Cambridgeshire. And yet he also said at the dispatch box his priority is getting resources to the front line. I'm not surprised the Secretary of State who is here has decided not to give this statement and ducked it and passed it to him. But could he answer the question the front bench asked a little earlier? What is the total cost to local authorities and the government of this process so far, given we arrive at a situation today where all options are on the table?

03:46:07 - 03:46:43

Jim McMahon

The cost of transitioning from the two-tier system to new unitaries is covered by councils in their proposals.

They tell us how they're going to finance the transitional arrangements that they themselves are asking government to consider. We have for the first time actually, for the first time because government haven't done this before, we have introduced a multi-million pound budget, that's 900,000 pound per new unitary to support the transitional arrangements on top of that. So I do believe actually the way that he frames it is not the reality because government is meeting councils halfway.

03:46:43 - 03:47:19

Adam Jogee

Thank you very much Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the announcement today in the statement that the Minister has scrapped the what I would call disgraceful and discourteous announcement made in July 2026. He's right to throw it out. But my constituents in Newcastle-under-Lyme want and deserve certainty and clarity Madam Deputy Speaker and I didn't hear much of it in this statement.

So can I ask him three very quick things? Can he confirm how MPs in Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent will feed into the review? How much money will our local authorities get to address all they've spent so far? And can I urge him to focus on the new mayoral authority announced yesterday, because that has the support needed for change of this scale?

03:47:19 - 03:47:27

Speaker 142

I appreciate how local this is for everybody, but please, one question each, because we need to get through this very quickly. Minister.

03:47:27 - 03:47:48

Jim McMahon

Um, well, obviously we were delighted to announce yesterday the devolution agreement, and that will definitely bring new resources and powers to that area. But it has to be built on a strong foundation of local government that can be sustained as well. In terms of how MPs can engage, the mind-to-process, when decisions are issued, gives us a three-week window where MPs and other interested parties can make representations.

03:47:49 - 03:48:09

Paul William Forster

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The two local authorities that serve my constituency of Woking are due to be abolished next year under the first phase of local government reorganization. Now we hear that Surrey is likely to have a mayor.

Will the Minister confirm that the government will let Surrey choose whether to have a mayor or not via a public consultation and a vote with councillors? Thank you.

03:48:09 - 03:48:45

Jim McMahon

So, as with LGR, devolution is locally led. And so it's for local areas to come to government to say that we have a broad agreement that we want to be in talks for devolution. We then bring that into a program. We speak to Treasury about the finances in that program, which is where we got to yesterday. So this is great news for the ten areas that are in scope.

The next stages are a consultation probably around December, and then local authorities will be taking local decisions to form the strategic authority probably in February, March. Once they do that, we then move the SIs legislation here in the House.

03:48:46 - 03:49:12

Samuel Carling

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. Councils across Cambridgeshire and Peterborough have worked collaboratively throughout the whole local government reorganization process, even where they have disagreed.

I've long advocated for our region to have three unitary councils, not just two, and I hope the government will agree. But there are of course questions about where boundaries should lie. So what avenues will be available and are available for councils to submit modifications to proposals if consensus can be built on improvements?

03:49:12 - 03:49:43

Jim McMahon

So at the moment we'll be going on the proposals that we have already. So if those proposals generally contain the type of outcome that he wants and we are minded to go with that proposal, there is that opportunity in the minded-to window to make a representation that says actually it could be improved if. Now if we're in a situation where we accept that as an argument and we want to make a modification order, that's then a separate process of consultation that we need to follow.

So it'd probably just take a bit longer to do that, but equally, if it's the right thing to do, we should be open-minded to do it.

Nigel Huddleston.

03:49:43 - 03:50:17

Nigel Huddleston

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister can't stand at the dispatch box and say that the government's not imposing local government reorganization and then stand at the dispatch box and say the status quo and staying as they are is not an option. Is he therefore fully aware of the chaos, cost, and uncertainty that this indecision is causing in Worcestershire, where, if I understand correctly, we've got local district council elections next year, a unitary election then the year after, and maybe a mayoralty election, but we don't know mayoralty for what? Does that make sense to him?

03:50:17 - 03:50:58

Jim McMahon

Well, it makes sense in terms of the pace of change here is quick. We know that. But also, we think that the economic and social requirements for that pace are vital.

If we do not move quickly, we will have no chance of making sure that growth can reach every postcode in the country, which is our promise. And we have no ability to make sure that those who need social care, those that need care in their local communities, and those vital neighbourhood services get the funding that they need. It's the right thing to do. But on his point about whether we're imposing this, to be clear, the English Devolution White Paper that was published in the December previous invited councils to be part of that programme. And every one of the 21 outstanding counties did apply.

It was voluntary for them to do that.

03:50:58 - 03:51:00

Speaker 170

Chris Ward.

03:51:00 - 03:51:28

Christopher David Ward

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister will know that there's still real concern in Peacehaven, Telscombe and East Saltdean in my constituency about the proposed merger into Brighton and Hove. And he will know that because of the many times I've raised it with him previously and the Secretary of State.

So given today's announcement and the minded-to decision, can he just explain a little more clearly about how my constituents can feed in now in what I think is a three or four week period, and how I can make sure their views continue to be heard?

03:51:28 - 03:51:51

Jim McMahon

So I thank him for the representations he's already made. At the moment, the proposal on the minded-to decision is to expand the boundary of Brighton and Hove City Council to include the communities of Saltdean and Peacehaven further down the coast. But that is a minded-to decision and so there is an opportunity for communities to make that representation alongside MPs, but I give credit for the representations he's made on this over quite a long period.

03:51:51 - 03:52:24

Ben Maguire

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

And can I commend the government for granting Cornwall, by exception, a single authority FSA devolution deal. I've been proud to work with all of Cornwall's MPs and the council leader on this. And Cornwall is very much relieved to see that it won't be merged with any other region. But would the Minister now meet with all of Cornwall's MPs to discuss how we can move to that mayoral suite of powers and funding without a mayor as new legislation comes before this House?

03:52:24 - 03:52:55

Jim McMahon

Well, I understand that there was a, all MPs were invited to the meeting at Number 10 North to talk about devolution, which is good news. And that shows you just how important we're taking this, where it's a single government priority. We're working across our different teams to make sure that it's landed. And I hope he recognizes as well that in Cornwall, we are working as hard as we can to recognize that different places are in different positions when it comes to devolution. But ultimately, we want to complete the map, either through a foundational authority or through an FSA.

03:52:55 - 03:53:31

Stephen Race

I welcome yesterday's announcement of a mayoral strategic authority for the geography of Devon. But as the Minister is aware, cities are currently district councils, but are also the drivers of economic and jobs growth, house building and much else in the area, currently locked out of sitting as full constituent members of mayoral strategic authorities. Can the Minister give some commitment to, as we're looking at legislation potentially around cities, can he look at whether we can have cities in advance of local government reorganization being able to sit as full constituent members of MSAs?

03:52:56 - 03:52:56

Stephen Race

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

03:53:31 - 03:54:08

Jim McMahon

First of all, thank you to the member for the representation he's made on behalf of Exeter over a long period of time on this, both in terms of reorganization and devolution.

He raises a very fair point really, which is that we were trying to align reorganization to be in place to then receive devolution. But the fact is that they are now going to run slightly at different time tables. It does raise a question about if this is about an economic project, which it is, the city economic driver, the travel to work areas ought to have a voice in that. So I can't make commitments today other than to say I acknowledge the point he makes and I'll take it away.

03:54:08 - 03:54:31

Desmond Swayne

Were he to consult a map, he would understand that the creator's purpose in placing the estuary of the Test was to prevent, for government purposes, the western part of the eastern part of the New Forest being treated as a suburb of Southampton.

03:54:31 - 03:54:34

Speaker 173

I'll certainly make a note of that.

03:54:34 - 03:54:36

Speaker 172

Andrew Pakes.

03:54:36 - 03:55:24

Andrew Elliot Pakes

Madam Deputy Speaker, Peterborough is ambitious for growth and to improve life for our residents. So anything which extends this process risks knocking back some of that ambitious growth.

So can I ask the Minister if we can do this as quickly as possible? Peterborough is also unique, I think, in this process in that we are already a unitary council being brought into a bigger process. We are consistently told that the decision hasn't been taken, but in July a review would already start. So can the Minister confirm, has any review actually happened since the last review was started in July? And will it take until a decision is made, which is minded, before MPs in Cambridgeshire and councillors and communities will actually get to have a say on the options which are being considered?

03:55:24 - 03:55:51

Jim McMahon

So with Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, and also with West Sussex, we are still in early in the process. So we'll confirm in writing just what that will be. But all decisions will be minded to.

And obviously he makes a very strong case about the economic benefits of Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and that being built on strong foundations. And can I just say, which I know is a slight advantage, but just to congratulate him on his appointment as the cooperative champion for government. He's always been my cooperative champion, but it's quite nice to see it being recognised.

03:55:51 - 03:55:52

Richard Tice.

03:55:52 - 03:56:22

Richard Tice

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The reason this shambolic local government reorganisation has been so appalling is because the government made political decisions as opposed to the right decisions. Reform Lincolnshire welcomes the decision to pause the wrong decision there. But does the Minister understand that Reform in Warwickshire is very, very concerned that the two unitary proposal that he has minded to accept today will lead to the bankruptcy of both unitaries within just a matter of years?

03:56:22 - 03:56:30

Jim McMahon

So the minded-to process will allow any representations in the area to make those points.

And if there's new information that we haven't considered, I'd be very happy to receive it.

03:56:31 - 03:57:03

Luke Murphy

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I thank the Minister for his statement. Can I urge him to make a minded-to decision as quickly as possible for Hampshire, and for that to include the creation of a North Hampshire unitary authority? It's right economically, it's right for the delivery of public services, and has a coalition of charities and businesses behind it. Can I also join with my honourable friend, the MP for Exeter, in urging representation for districts, not just cities, but large towns like Basingstoke, to have representation on the Hampshire and Solent Combined County Authority?

03:57:03 - 03:57:24

Jim McMahon

Obviously, Hampshire was one of the areas that were withdrawn earlier in the September decision. So, we are going to be reviewing that process.

I think I've said before not to assume that just because they were in previous batches before that that will be the order in which we take them going forward. We'll confirm just how we're going to batch those up in the in the coming weeks or not.

03:57:24 - 03:58:13

Speaker 178

Thank you very much. I didn't think that the minister could make things for people in Worcestershire even more confused than they were already. People in Worcestershire just want their bins taken out, the roads maintained, enough school places, adult social care provision and a say in planning. But now I understand that we're going to have to get councillors elected to district councils again next May, and then the May after that we're going to have to get councillors elected to a new shadow authority. And it's not until 2029 now that this new entity in the south of Worcestershire is going to be created.

And I just can't see how that is going to benefit my residents.

03:58:13 - 03:58:43

Jim McMahon

But the member makes the case as to why the district elections are important. We cannot have a situation where there's a democratic deficit where one part of the partnership in reorganization, the transfer of assets and workforce and liabilities and the rest of it doesn't have a say. And as she says, the vesting day on this timetable will be April '29. And I think the idea that you haven't got a democratic mandate reset to negotiate that transfer, I'm afraid just doesn't hold.

03:58:43 - 03:59:12

Josh Newbury

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

I'd first like to start by thanking the Minister for the part he played in getting the announcement of a strategic mayoral authority for Staffordshire over the line in time for yesterday's budget. However, despite the potential efficiency and simplicity gains of local government reorganization, the shifting goalposts and stop-start process has caused deep frustration in our county. So could the Minister confirm what the coming months will bring in terms of consultation with MPs, councillors, and most importantly, our constituents, so they're clear on how they can again have their say over the future of our councils?

03:59:12 - 03:59:28

Jim McMahon

So now the review has concluded, the list of MPs that have requested individual meetings will take place, and we'll make contact with MPs in the usual way for those Monday sessions. But notwithstanding that, as I said, the statutory process will allow formal representations even beyond that.

03:59:28 - 03:59:29

Alison Bennett.

03:59:29 - 04:00:05

Alison Bennett

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Still, West Sussex waits, and we badly need certainty on geography of the new authorities for my county.

I cannot overestimate or overstate just how cash-strapped and how fragile our public services are. £500,000 to offset the cost of more delay is of course welcome, but it's only the tip of the iceberg of the amount of money this department has spent in the last two years on LGR. Can I push the minister again: how much has that cost?

04:00:05 - 04:00:30

Jim McMahon

Well, as I say, all the localized costs for reorganizations include the financial profiles that councils send to government. So councils themselves determine what type of form they want to take and put forward for their area.

And alongside that boundary proposal, they've got to do a financial assessment of the councils that then will follow, the transitional arrangements, and what the cash implication of that is, and that's all set out in the proposal.

04:00:30 - 04:01:07

Speaker 180

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I advise the state today the new time, the new transitional funding and the minister's work on this so far. My understanding of this statement is now that Lancashire's case for reorganization is in fact stronger and more robust than it was just a few months ago, if a little delayed. Can the minister confirm to me today that this new window of engagement is an opportunity for Lancashire to remake its case for our future with our newly announced and very welcome mayor, and an opportunity for me to keep lobbying him for a smaller East Lancs unitary and perhaps new electoral boundaries, not using existing county divisions?

04:01:07 - 04:01:24

Jim McMahon

Well, I mean, I congratulate him for the representations. It's probably fair to say I can't get through the voting lobby without him making that representation. But I think for the right reasons, he cares about the place that he represents in Burnley and he wants devolution in Lancashire to be a success. And on that basis, we're entirely as one.

04:01:24 - 04:02:04

Gagan Mohindra

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Like others in this House, I think it's fair to say this whole process has been a shambles. Like many others in the House, I come from a local government background and I feel sorry for my councillors, my council and my residents for what they're having to go through. Having said all of that, I do think that the previous decision for Hertfordshire was wrong, so I appreciate that the Minister has taken the opportunity to reassess what Hertfordshire's going to be doing in the future.

But given that my own community is a collection of small towns and villages and we do not have a mayoralty, how will he ensure that my community is properly represented whatever the outcome for Hertfordshire?

04:02:04 - 04:02:38

Jim McMahon

So I'll be reviewing not only the proposals that came forward but also the consultation that was carried out at the time and I'll be testing the assumptions. And to be clear, on one end you've got big is beautiful, have a single unitary and save all the money and the rest of it, or on the other side you've got no local is better. And actually in this debate today we have heard there are very different views on some of that. I tend to find the truth is usually somewhere in the middle and trying to get a compromise that people accept as doing that is what we're going to try and endeavour. But clearly we can't preempt that because we are coming at this with an open mind.

04:02:38 - 04:03:23

James William Naish

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It is right that all options proposed by Nottinghamshire authorities are looked at fairly and properly. So I welcome this confirmation today. But today's update also reinforces that LGR is extremely complicated, should never have been a term one priority and is destabilising the very organisations that we rely to deliver so many services from this place.

Now having led a local authority, I cannot emphasise enough how big an impact this is having on our councillors and council officers. So I wonder if he could clarify, are there scenarios where minded to may mean that LGR does not go ahead? Are councils able to make representations to that effect? And who is being held accountable for the announcements on the 16th of July, which should never have happened?

04:03:23 - 04:03:55

Jim McMahon

Well, to be clear, the invitation that went out for areas to make submissions to the LGR process was entirely voluntary. There was no mandation. And so when councils make a submission and a proposal to that process, it's that bit that initiates LGR. So this is a government-wide programme, but to be clear, it's taking place because we've received proposals from local councils that we're now required to review.

But I do take on board his point around kind of being mindful of the impact it has on council officials and councillors.

04:03:55 - 04:04:31

Julian Lewis

The Minister is a genial sort of fellow, and I want to believe him when he says he wants to proceed by consensus. So will he accept that there is no consensus at all on splitting the New Forest, taking the Waterside, putting it under the control of Labour-dominated Southampton, when well over 30,000 people signed the petition to keep the Forest together that was handed in at Downing Street on the day, the very day that they rightly withdrew the plan for Hampshire?

04:04:31 - 04:04:49

Jim McMahon

So as with the decision in Hampshire, will be an area that we will take afresh. I haven't got any predetermination about what that might be.

I haven't got any predetermination about what that might be, but I think the point he raises about ensuring as much as we can do, and again this is quite an imperfect process in a sense, that it reflects community identity is definitely something that's at the back of my mind.

04:04:49 - 04:04:51

Speaker 184

Dr. Pinkerton.

04:04:51 - 04:05:29

Al Pinkerton

Thank you, Mr. Deputy Speaker. LGR and devolution are, as the Minister has said, intrinsically linked. So it came as a bit of a surprise to read on page 66 of the Red Book yesterday that Surrey is apparently in advanced talks with the Government over a new strategic multi. I say surprise because if those are advanced talks, they haven't involved any of the MPs and apparently only a 10-minute phone call with the new unitary authorities for Surrey on Monday evening. So can I just ask the Minister, in the spirit of consensus and correspondence, can we just make sure that before this goes any further forward, that those unitary authorities and the MPs are fully consulted?

04:05:29 - 04:05:31

Speaker 185

Thank you.

04:05:31 - 04:06:06

Jim McMahon

He makes a fair point about consultation. I will say that myself and the devolution minister here have done a lot to engage with local government, and also many of the drop-in sessions that we've had have been about devolution. So I push back on the idea that we haven't done that, but equally we could always do more. And if further talks are required, that's important. But let's not allow it to take away the positive benefit that this multi-billion pound investment will bring to our communities.

And what I would say to him as a local MP is surely the reason why we come here in the first place is to make sure that our areas get its fair share.

04:06:06 - 04:06:35

Mark Garnier

Like my honorable friend the member for North Cotswold, I agree that the idea of merging six district councils and one county council into one unitary authority for 650,000 people is a good idea.

It has a lot of efficiency. So in a county like Worcestershire, where we have 630,000 people, six district councils and one county council, how on earth did the minister come to the conclusion that it was a good idea to split the county council in two and have a north and a south divide in a county that's smaller than Gloucestershire?

04:06:35 - 04:07:12

Jim McMahon

Well, through the process, what we don't do is to align a entirely separately legal decision in a neighboring county with the one that's being made next door. All we can do is to receive it on the proposal basis that we receive. And now these are not always easy decisions and they're always a matter of balancing competing interests. And as I said before, there is no perfect proposal yet that I've seen. What we're trying to do is to get the best possible one.

And we've tried to do that both in Gloucestershire, we've tried to do that in Worcestershire and all the others that we've announced today.

But equally we are in a minded to process and if he wants to make representations in that time we're very happy to receive them.

Andrew Rosindell.

04:07:12 - 04:07:55

Andrew Rosindell

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. The Minister knows because we've discussed it many times that the historic counties and historic cities are very different from local government boundaries and I'm very pleased to say that he said today that city status is preserved and the same with ceremonial matters. So will he finally allow historic and ceremonial counties to be as one to avoid the confusion so that places like mine can have our Essex identity regardless of local government boundaries and will he give a cast-iron guarantee that there is no plan to merge the London Borough of Havering with other East London boroughs to create some sort of super East London council?

04:07:55 - 04:07:59

Speaker 189

I think I've got enough on my plate without taking that on.

04:07:59 - 04:08:01

Speaker 188

Ben Obese-Jecty.

04:08:01 - 04:08:36

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. There seems to be some confusion on both sides of the House with regards to the next steps for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough.

So I was wondering if the Minister would be able to clarify. He said earlier that the process is early on, so Cambridgeshire would still receive written confirmation of what the options are that are chosen. You also appear to confirm that despite the fact that the four options that were tabled would be selected, they could later be modified by councils if they saw fit and that would be taken forwards. So could you just clarify that that's the process going forwards? And could you also clarify what is the, what is the criteria under which that decision will be taken?

04:08:36 - 04:09:28

Jim McMahon

So we published the criteria at the start of the process and that criteria stands. It is an unweighted criteria and the idea there is it gives us the freedom to take into account that England is very diverse and what's right for one county might not be right for the other. But equally, these have got to be in the end as sustainable as possible.

They've got to take into account the balance of efficiency and identity in the same way. But these are not easy decisions. On the point he makes about the opportunity to have a modification proposal, we're now at the point where we've received the proposals so there's no additional window to do that and the consultation obviously in places has carried out. However, in all of these decisions there will be a minded-to process so he and others can make those representations. But I'm very happy in cases such as Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and also in West Sussex to confirm in a bit more detail in writing to members shortly.

04:09:28 - 04:10:15

Charlotte Cane

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. As many people have said, this process has been a shambles. But I do welcome that you're going to have the minded-to with time for people to come back and give their views.

Although I want this process sorted quickly, that timetable has to be enough for a real consultation. And bear in mind all local government has to give proper due notice of their meetings and what's going to be on the agendas so that the public can come and have their say as well. I'm not at all sure that three weeks is long enough. Will the Minister please look at making a timetable that makes it practical for local authorities and local people to properly make their representations?

04:10:15 - 04:10:46

Jim McMahon

So the way that we approach the minded-to decision is actually not to necessarily assume that the council itself will be the conduit for every view in an area.

Actually, in a single area, there might be very different views from different political groups or from local charity organisations or other public service providers. And so it's deliberately intended for councils and local residents or business community or whoever who have an interest to make a representation. And our view is that three weeks ought to be time to do that.

04:10:46 - 04:10:47

Sir John Whittingdale.

04:10:47 - 04:11:27

John Whittingdale

Um, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Six weeks ago, the government announced that it was scrapping the local government reform proposals for Essex and going back to the drawing board. As a result, that announcement created yet more uncertainty and further paralysed decision-making. And yet today, he hasn't even mentioned Essex and has provided no additional clarity whatsoever.

So how can he expect elections to go ahead in 2028 when we're not even going to know what the authorities that are going to be elected are going to be until next year?

04:11:27 - 04:12:12

Jim McMahon

I definitely accept his concern that having a, almost like an itinerary of areas with a clear date alongside them would do what he's asked. But that isn't where we are. We've taken the decision that the moment we're able to confirm an area, we ought to confirm it as soon as possible rather than waiting for them to be batched up in the way that might have been done previously. And on whether elections should or shouldn't go ahead, I made the point before, these district councils will be in place up until the vesting days of the new local authorities. And what we can't have are elections being cancelled that create that democratic deficit.

Councils have to have representation where the people around the table have the mandate given to them by the public.

04:12:12 - 04:12:13

Speaker 193

Final question, Martin Vickers.

04:12:13 - 04:12:37

Martin Vickers

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. North and North East Lincolnshire, the two unitaries that serve my constituency, are unanimous in wanting to maintain the status quo, as are the four MPs across the area. His predecessor announced that that would be the case. Could he enlighten us to why he is further delaying and continuing the uncertainty?

04:12:37 - 04:13:09

Jim McMahon

I mean, it's not further delaying in the way that he almost suggests, for the sake of delay. These are new decisions that have to be taken. So it's not the case that I'm just reviewing previous decisions and saying, well, we'll allow them to go. We are withdrawing the decisions entirely for those areas, and we're going to remake them from the point of proposal, consultation, and afresh based on the evidence. Now, as he says, this is a compelling proposal, and why wouldn't we agree otherwise?

That may well be the outcome, but it'd be wrong to predetermine it.

04:13:09 - 04:13:33

Speaker 195

That is the end of the statement on local government reorganization. I'll give the front benches a few moments to shuffle over. Before we begin, we have a personal statement from Tony Vaughan.

04:13:33 - 04:15:53

Tony Vaughan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. With your permission, I wish to make a personal statement. Following a complaint to Parliament's Independent Complaints and Grievance Scheme by a former member of my constituency staff, the Commissioner and the Independent Expert Panel have found that on three occasions in February 2025, I breached Parliament's bullying and harassment policy.

I accept those findings in full. At a small gathering to thank my former colleague for her work establishing the constituency office, I initiated a hug. I assumed that she was content to be hugged, but I did not ask, and the hug was unwelcome to her. Later that month, while out of the office, intending to join an online meeting that was not in my diary, I took my former colleague's phone from her hand without her consent to join that meeting. She immediately challenged me and took the phone back.

It was not mine to take. The next day, two calls with my former colleague and me were ended abruptly while I was trying to find the venue for a constituency appointment, one of them deliberately by me after entering a live church service. Regrettably, I never explained why these calls had ended, as I ought to have done.

As a result of these behaviors, my former colleague was upset and humiliated. My behavior had a real and continuing impact on her and her family, and I'm truly sorry for this. I was the employer of my former colleague. There was an imbalance of power between us, and I was not sufficiently alert to it as the behavior code requires. The responsibility for behaving in a way that was mindful of that imbalance was mine and not hers.

I also recognize that behavior like this could well impact on somebody who is vulnerable, whether or not that is known. That is why respect and courtesy must come first in every interaction I have with others. Since these events, my approach has changed. I am more alert to the need for sensitivity to those I work with.

I have undertaken further training, including one-to-one training. Going forwards, I will be mindful of the need for both courtesy in my dealings with staff, including in times of stress, and for my personal attention when staffing problems arise. I made mistakes and I breached the policy. I apologize unreservedly to my former colleague and to this House.

04:15:53 - 04:15:57

Speaker 196

The Clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.

04:15:57 - 04:16:01

Speaker 197

Ways and means, adjourned debate on question.

04:16:01 - 04:16:12

Speaker 163

Now, the question is as on the order paper, and I call the Shadow Chancellor, Andrew Griffith.

04:16:12 - 04:17:27

Andrew Griffith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget must be bewildering to members of the Prime Minister's party.

He promised them a circuit breaker, an end to 40 years of neoliberalism, a new political model, and instead it's all gherkins and aubergines. I can see the defense secretary sitting there. He's probably wondering the same as everyone else. Was that it? To be honest, he's probably thinking he would have done a better job.

He might be right. It's not too late. If he resigns again, he might get his chance to be the chancellor. But all the while, Madam Deputy Speaker, Britain has a debt problem. Britain has a defense problem.

Britain has a growth problem. And apparently, we learned yesterday, there is nothing the chancellor can do. On the big challenges, what has this budget actually done? It doesn't reduce borrowing. Total debt has gone up.

It doesn't properly fund defense.

They still haven't set out how 3% will be funded. And it doesn't cut taxes to get the economy growing. Instead, they're putting taxes up again. I'll give way.

04:17:27 - 04:17:54

Zubir Ahmed

Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm grateful to the right honourable gentleman for giving way. He spoke there about this country having a defence problem. I wonder if he could elaborate about the context of that defence problem, perhaps reflect upon the fact it might have been something to do with underinvestment that's left us with poor morale in the British Army, unprecedented levels of poor morale, and perhaps that underinvestment in terms of leaving the British soldiers unequipped to do the basic job of defending our country?

04:17:54 - 04:17:58

Speaker 199

Interventions should be short and sharp and to the point and a question. Andrew Griffith.

04:17:58 - 04:19:01

Andrew Griffith

Well thank you Madam Deputy Speaker, and if time allows I'm very happy to go into great detail about the record of defense on this house. We were proud once Russia invaded Ukraine to stand with the people of Ukraine, to reboot the funding, to reboot the funding for defense. And the test that the Chancellor failed wasn't my test. It was his own test. It was the Chancellor who resigned because his previous Chancellor and Prime Minister would not give our armed forces the proper funding that our defense.

Yesterday we needed decisive action and all they delivered was a budget of ducked decisions. The Chancellor's taken to heart the idea of why do today what you can put off to next year or the year after.

And as a result, let's be clear, Britain will be less secure, less fair, and poorer for it. Now I'd be remiss, I'll give way once.

04:19:01 - 04:19:13

Kevin Bonavia

The Shadow Chancellor says on the 14 years of Tory government, our armed forces were reduced to a size smaller than at any time since the Napoleonic Wars. How secure were we during his time in power?

04:19:13 - 04:25:08

Andrew Griffith

Madam Deputy Speaker, when I can make some progress and we've got plenty of time to talk about defense. No, in I've got a very good answer. In 2010, his party wanted to reduce and cut further our armed forces. We were the party, we were the party that will always stand behind our armed forces. Madam Deputy Speaker.

Madam Deputy Speaker, let me make some progress because this is a debate about the whole of the budget and there'll be plenty of opportunity to talk about defense.

Let me make some progress and we can come back to that. Let me... Let me be... Give the government some credit for some of the few positives in the budget. The Chancellor was right to U-turn on his party's manifesto commitment to equalize the youth rate of the minimum wage.

One in six young people under this government are looking for a job and can't find one. Shame on them. And equalizing the youth minimum wage would have made a desperately tough situation harder. He should have gone further and halved the jobs tax for young people as we would have done. He was also right to ignore those on his backbenches who wanted to raise capital gains tax.

In fact, it wasn't just the backbenches, it was the Defense Secretary. He was also calling for that.

So thank goodness the Chancellor didn't listen to him. It would have meant many more wealth creators joining the thousands who have fled our country under Labour. Madam Deputy Speaker, the public wasn't asking for much from this budget, and yet even their lowest expectations have not been met. Ordinary people wanted the government to get a grip on out-of-control welfare spending. They wanted a budget that properly funded defence.

They wanted the government to tackle the deficit. And they wanted tax cuts for their families to be better off. That would have been real breathing space. And against all and any of those tests, the budget has comprehensively failed.

It could have been a moment, Madam Deputy Speaker, when a Chancellor resolved to live within our means. Instead, this government will have added, do they know the number, more than 300 billion pounds worth of borrowing over the course of this Parliament. Borrowing is up in every single year of the forecast. The national debt now stands at the equivalent of 100,000 pounds for every household, and it's set to grow by a quarter in the next five years.

Britain is walking along a fiscal cliff edge, and the government has decided this is the moment to close their eyes. Yesterday, the OBR confirmed the government is spending 124 billion pounds a year on interest alone, up 14 billion, more than the government spends on defense, policing, and prisons combined. Money going straight out of the door to our creditors. It was so out of control that the Bank of England, in the run-up to this budget, was forced to make an extraordinary 200 billion pound intervention to try and reduce the cost, and still the 30-year gilt rates rose above 6%. It's not fair, Madam Deputy Speaker.

It's not fair to our children or to their children. We cannot continue to kick the can down the road to future generations of taxpayers.

And instead of getting a grip, the Chancellor doubled down. He repeated his predecessor's mistakes and cut the fiscal headroom to just £15 billion, the equivalent of just three and a half days of public spending. Is that recklessness why the Defence Secretary wants us all to have three days' worth of stockpiled food? The Chancellor said in his conference speech, the Chancellor said in his speech, the levels of debt are an assault on our common sense, an affront to our values. That was just a month ago.

So what's changed? He's now raising debt in every single year of the forecast. A month ago, it was an affront to his values. Now it's front and centre in his budget. The Prime Minister may not care about the debt we hand on to the next generation, but he really ought to.

As should Labour's faithful little helpers, the Liberal Democrats. So enraptured by Europhilia, so desperate to crawl back into the clutches of Brussels, that they haven't noticed a glaring problem. The nation's figures... tempting. The nation's figures are so poor, the nation's figures are so poor that we couldn't rejoin the EU even if we wanted to. EU rules say that a member country's national debt should be under 60% of GDP, yet the UK is approaching 100%.

The EU's deficit limit is 3%, yet the UK's is one and a half times that. And despite all that debt, the Chancellor still hasn't found the money to properly fund 3% of GDP on defence. And while we welcome that the government is finally funding its own defence investment plan, it's not good enough. No serious person disputes... Of course I will, of course I will.

04:25:08 - 04:25:36

Siobhain McDonagh

Is the honourable member aware that when defence spending when Labour left office in 2010 was 2.5%, it fell below 2% during the Conservative government and is now set to rise to 2.5%? Does he understand the correlation between Labour governments and increased defence spending?

04:25:36 - 04:26:06

Andrew Griffith

The Labour whips have clearly been doing their history lessons, but history lessons, Madam Deputy Speaker, are not going to defend our country. The threat is real. The Defense Secretary is running around telling us to put food under our beds, to store water. The issue is now, and that is why the Chancellor himself resigned saying it was inadequate that he didn't fund the three percent. Nobody challenges that.

Nobody challenges that. I'll give way one last time, Madam Deputy Speaker.

04:26:06 - 04:26:33

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

I thank the honorable gentleman for giving way, and actually there is an element of agreement because in our budget yesterday we agreed to get to three percent of GDP on defense by 2030, as did the honorable gentleman's mini-budget back in 2022.

But does he agree the difference between our budget and his budget is that we'll actually get to the spending review next year to be able to deliver it and it'll last longer than 47 days?

04:26:33 - 04:31:19

Andrew Griffith

Madam Deputy Speaker, I mean, they try so hard. The hole in their budget is gaping wide open. And the problem, Madam Deputy Speaker, is it's not just us on this side of the House that can see that hole, it's our adversaries around the world. Leaving ourselves open, not properly funding our armed forces isn't going to scare anyone in Moscow and it's not going to deter Tehran. The Defense Secretary's resigned once before.

We know he's not against resigning. Perhaps he could resign again on principle today.

We on this side of the House are used to Labour making their promises, but to break the promises that they made to our armed forces is a new low. And if the Chancellor had any dignity yesterday, he would have resigned. Despite their failure to fund defence, they've still raised the tax burden to the highest level on record, higher than in the aftermath of World War II, higher than even the Member for Leeds West and Pudsey raised it to. Who remembers how this government had no plans to put up taxes? How's that working?

For the third budget in a row, the tax burden is set to rise. All told, taxes are going up by a total of 75 billion pounds a year, higher next year, higher the following year, higher in every single year of the forecast.

Even the Prime Minister's former economic advisor, Andy Haldane, now says that Britain is taxed out. He also called the Chancellor penny wise, pound foolish. I'm not even sure about the penny wise bit, to be honest. And where will that money come from? Families, small businesses, the self-employed, farmers, the people who work hard, want to get ahead.

And why? To pay for those who don't, those who could work but choose not to. The damage doesn't just stop with the tax bill itself, it's the disincentives in the economy that do the most harm. Two years ago, the Chancellor stood at that dispatch box and raised taxes on jobs.

Now, we're in a jobs crisis. Over 170,000 jobs lost since July 2024, all because Labour don't understand that if you tax something, you get less of it. Now they're raising taxes on the banks, who provide mortgages, loans to small businesses and pay interest to savers. Chancellor might think it's just a bank tax. But we know, like every tax, it will end up being paid by ordinary working people.

People, higher mortgages, lower returns on savings and bank branch closures in every constituency and every high street and fewer jobs in this country. The budget also has a vindictive tax rise on people who've done the right thing, who've done what governments have always told them to do, what this government wants them to do, to save money. And yet for many, up to 49 pence in every pound of interest on hard-earned savings will now be taken by the Chancellor. It's the same story on landlords who've already been on attack under attack from this government. And the OBR says that rents will go up as a result.

Madam Deputy Speaker, of all that this budget was missing, the lack of welfare reform stands out the most. Or at least so we thought. Because this morning, the Chancellor told the BBC that there will be welfare cuts before the election. Perhaps a Treasury minister could come to the House and clean up the Chancellor's mess. His budget hasn't even survived 24 hours.

Last week, the Prime Minister called the benefits bill a moral outrage.

He was right then, but he's not doing anything about it now. Because those on the other side of the House are too afraid to say enough is enough. They don't have the courage to get a grip of welfare because they're worried it would cost them their jobs, Madam Deputy Speaker. Thanks to the TaxPayers' Alliance, we know that for more than half of all Labour MPs, the number of benefit claimants in their constituency is larger than their majority. It's true for the Chancellor.

It's certainly true for the Defence Secretary, and it's true for the right honourable Member for Northampton North. They won't get welfare under control because it would cost them their seats, their own interests before the country. I'm making progress, don't you worry, I'm doing very well, Madam Deputy Speaker.

04:31:19 - 04:31:28

Speaker 163

Order.

Fascinated as we all are, there are many people hoping to contribute this afternoon, so hopefully we'll be coming to a conclusion soon. Andrew Griffith.

04:31:28 - 04:35:18

Andrew Griffith

Madam Deputy Speaker, I read that this budget had some of the most measures in it of any budget, but also that they were the most inconsequential. I will try and crack through a few other things. I'll tell you who else is, they're all chuntering, I'll tell you who else's interest they're putting first: the trade unions. Because while they're raising taxes on everybody else, they're handing out over 40 million pounds over the next two years to a Union Learning Fund. I can't even begin to imagine what they'll be learning around: how to run rings around the Health Secretary, what to do with those extra days off from working a four-day week, how to keep public sector pay rises twice as high as in the private sector.

That's probably about right. He says how to keep the Conservatives out, that's probably exactly what they're doing.

It's a political bung to their political allies. It's ridiculous. It is ridiculous, Madam Deputy Speaker. While families face tough choices, we're in a cost of living crisis, this government uses its budget to tax people and hand money to the trade unions. Now, it wasn't just the budget we heard yesterday, Madam Deputy Speaker, it was also the Office of Budget Responsibility figures.

And they really do show us just how bad things are. The first time ever, the government is planning to spend over 45 pence in every pound in the economy. Government spending goes up every year of the forecast, and debt is up every year of the forecast.

And all the while, it's official that living standards are down. Real household disposable incomes are set to be lower next year than when Labour took office. 1,500 pound lower at the end of this Parliament than they were forecast to be under the Conservatives. And it's not hard to understand why. Inflation is up, interest rates are soaring, unemployment is up again.

And the one-off 100 pounds the government is putting in bank accounts won't touch the sides for most people given the cost of ingress, cost of increase and that. So the only thing that will put us on a path out of this decline and deficit is growth. We understand the value of growth.

The Prime Minister has got his history entirely wrong. The mistake this country made wasn't to choose markets over socialism in 1970. It was not electing Mrs. Thatcher. It was giving up all that we achieved in the 80s and 90s. In conclusion, in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker.

She's very firm, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget will go down as one of history's great missed opportunities. Not to undo 40 years of neoliberalism, but to undo the damage in the first two years of this government. The mistakes made by the member for Leeds West and Pudsey, who's now busy job hunting and discovering herself for the first time what it's like to receive rejection after rejection. Yesterday was a chance to put Britain back on the right track and the Chancellor blew it.

Higher taxes, higher spending, higher borrowing. Lower growth, lower living standards, fewer jobs.

I hope the Chancellor kept the receipt for this budget, because I think he's going to want to return it. The British people know this is not the budget we need. This is a great country whose potential is being held back. But we've got a Chancellor who ducks his choices and a Prime Minister who wants to take us back to the 1970s. You can't tax and regulate your way to growth.

National security really does matter more than social security, and only by tackling the deficit can we back away from the fiscal cliff edge and do the right thing by future generations.

04:35:18 - 04:35:23

Speaker 204

I call the Defence Secretary, Wes Streeting.

04:35:23 - 04:35:25

Speaker 203

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

04:35:25 - 04:39:02

Wes Streeting

I'm proud to open this budget debate on behalf of the government, proud of the leadership of the Prime Minister and the Chancellor, who is offering this country breathing space today and fresh hope for the future. Madam Deputy Speaker, before I turn to that, I do need to talk about the threat this country faces, one that sabotages our economy, that pushes out misinformation, that attempts to undermine people's trust in government. For once, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm not talking about the Russians, but the Trussians, not least the Shadow Chancellor opposite, who I fear is part of a Trussian sleeper cell operating in the shadows of the Conservative Party. He didn't say much about his plans today, but I don't think we need to look very far. In fact, there is a book out that tells us all about the secret plans he's no doubt saving up for the next manifesto.

Bank Job, it's called, written by one Liz Truss. He knows her well, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is the Liz Truss for whom he helped write the mini-budget, which crashed our economy and damaged Britain's reputation, and which he still says contained, and I quote, "lots of good things". Maybe, Madam Deputy Speaker, that's why when I tried to obtain a copy of the Bank Job this morning, I found there were no books available in bookshops for miles around. Presumably, the Shadow Chancellor has gone around and bought them all up, just in case someone might find out exactly what they stand for.

Because that is the danger, Madam Deputy Speaker. They walk among us, the Trussians hiding in plain sight. Deep cover sleeper agents masquerading as responsible fiscal conservatives. But we will not be fooled, Madam Deputy Speaker. We remember when the shadow chancellor cheered her on and we all know the consequences of their misjudgments.

And if we're not careful, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Trussians are coming and they're winding up to play their own band of roulette with our public finances once again. But all joking aside, Madam Deputy Speaker, I think it is genuinely appalling that the arsonists have the audacity to complain as the firefighters are clearing up their mess.

Never forgive, never forget, and never let the Tories do it again. In fact, in one of the low points of an otherwise dull and inaccurate contribution to this chamber, he had the audacity to level low-level blows against my right honourable friend, the member for Leeds West and Pudsey. Let me just point out that despite the shocks, the economic global shocks this country faces, the security threats of a kind we have not faced in generations, the IMF earlier this month upgraded their growth forecast for Britain for 2026. The IMF said, the IMF says, and I quote, that the UK stands out among G7 nations, and it credited the government's responsible approach to handling the public finances.

And I pay tribute to her leadership, her experience, and her hard-headed stewardship of our economy.

04:39:02 - 04:39:14

Speaker 142

Order. I can tell that the Defence Secretary's had his Weetabix because he is very loud at the dispatch box. And he has to be loud because there's so much heckling. Can everybody just calm down a little bit? Wes Streeting.

04:39:14 - 04:42:21

Wes Streeting

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. They can shout all they like, Madam Deputy Speaker, but the fact is that the former Shadow Chancellor restored the confidence of the markets after they trashed Britain's reputation with their catastrophic mini-budget. She created the platform for our Labour government to invest in public services, protect the most vulnerable, foster innovation, and navigate the headwinds of the last two years. And during her time as Chancellor of the Exchequer, she established a record that the Conservative front bench couldn't begin to touch.

Those are the facts. And nonetheless, against the backdrop of the enormous challenges this country faces, as the Chancellor set out yesterday, he is taking action to tackle the cost of living, to give households breathing space today, help for 20 million households to help heat their homes this winter, freezing fuel duty to keep down prices at the pump, helping with the everyday cost of the weekly shop so that people have more money in their pockets. Action on energy bills, the minimum wage, the national living wage, the state pension, all going up to help people out.

And no one, Madam Deputy Speaker, no one is suggesting that these measures solve everything for everyone, everywhere, all at once. But people can see that we are doing everything we can, as fast as we can, to give people breathing space today and fresh hope for the future. To show that this government and this Prime Minister has got their backs. To show that as a nation we can still do big things, that government can make a difference to people's lives, that Britain is a country we can still believe in. And that's important as we look beyond the optimism of the first hundred days of this new government and our new Prime Minister to the brighter future that lies ahead for our country if we make the right choices.

Because yes, we face great challenges, but the character of a nation isn't defined by the challenges it faces, but how it chooses to respond. And be in no doubt, it is a choice.

We choose not to be daunted by the scale of the challenge, but to be motivated by it. To face the future not with fear, but with confidence. To choose hope. We choose it because we know what hope can do. Look at what this Labour government has been delivering in the past two years.

Half a million children out of poverty. Waiting list down by a quarter of a million. The asylum backlog down 60% in a year. Small boat crossings at their lowest in six years. The fastest growing economy in the G7 in the first half of this year.

Free breakfast clubs feeding 680,000 children. Six train operators brought back into public ownership. And defence spending up by 14 billion pounds compared to the Conservatives' final year in office. Lots done, lots more still to do. But so many reasons to believe that our best days lie ahead.

I'll certainly give way.

04:42:21 - 04:43:11

Paul Stephen Barclay

I thank the Defense Secretary for giving way. As he's talking about defense spending, could I just take him to the Red Book, page 31, paragraphs 2.5 and 2.6? I'm sure one of his Treasury colleagues will have a copy. He will see there's 10.3 billion of reprioritization to fund that, alongside 4.7 billion, of which 3 billion is capital cuts elsewhere, 1.7 billion from the reserves. So of course he'll get the 1.7 from the reserves.

Has he been told by the Treasury where that 3 billion of capital savings is coming from?

How much of it, if any, is coming from his department? And can he assure the House that the government is on track on the over 10 billion of efficiencies, given that the Institute for Government and many others say that is highly unlikely to be delivered?

04:43:11 - 04:45:24

Wes Streeting

Madam Deputy Speaker, I can absolutely confirm that thanks to the responsible choices made by the Chancellor and his predecessor, we do have headroom to weather shocks. The Chancellor is drawing on that. But in terms of capital budget reprioritisation across government, it is absolutely true to say that across the cabinet, members have been willing to prioritise within their own capital programmes in order to fund defence. So we can be absolute clear, beyond any doubt, Madam Deputy Speaker, that this is a Chancellor, this is a Prime Minister, this is a team that chooses to prioritise defence.

I bet he wishes he made the same choices when he was Chief Secretary to the Treasury, leaving our armed forces hollowed out and underfunded. And Madam Deputy Speaker, it was another great Healey, my predecessor Denis Healey, who said that without strong defenses, we have no houses, we have no hospitals, we have no schools, we have a heap of cinders. The first duty of any government, to keep our country safe, is a greater and more urgent challenge than it has been for generations. The gravest dangers of the 20th century are returning, armed with the technologies of the 21st.

Britain faces growing threats from state-sponsored terrorism, sabotage and hostile acts designed to disrupt our lives, undermine our security and spread fear. And yesterday, the Chancellor gave his response to those threats at this despatch box, delivering more support to the frontline for freedom in Ukraine, plugging the 4.7 billion pound gap in the defence investment plan, confirming our unshakable commitment to NATO to spend 3.5% of GDP by 2035, but going even further with a new target reflecting Labour's commitment to fund defence spending at 3% of GDP by 2030. That is the commitment the Chancellor made at this despatch box yesterday. That is a record the Conservatives can't even begin to touch. But I look forward to him defending the indefensible.

04:45:24 - 04:45:38

Benjamin Obese-Jecty

I just wanted to bring the Defence Secretary back to his comments about the defence investment plan and it being fully funded. The Red Book says that there's a reallocation of capital spending that's 145 million this year, 2.1 billion next year.

Could you just outline where that reallocated capital spending will come from?

04:45:38 - 04:47:11

Wes Streeting

I've just set out, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's there in the budget. It is there. The Government have reallocated from capital programs across government to make sure defence is fully funded. And what is so disappointing, Madam Deputy Speaker, and this has become a running theme of the leadership of the Leader of the Opposition. It's a running theme.

When we sat on that side of the House in opposition, I remember Keir Starmer always making a virtue of standing with the Government on issues of national security and defence. Constructively challenging where we needed to, but standing with the Government. This lot can't help but try and score petty party political points at the expense of defence and national security.

And what is even more extraordinary is the enormous brass neck when you look at their record. Just look at it: the smallest army since the Napoleonic Wars, every single recruitment target missed, morale fell to a record low of 40%, almost every equipment programme over budget, behind schedule, often both, defence spending facing a real-terms cut between 2010 and 2024, fell from 2.5% of GDP to 2.3%, and in the words of their own Defence Secretary, the armed forces left hollowed out and underfunded. And now they have the audacity to turn up and criticise a Labour Government that is investing more, investing more quickly, and cleaning up their mess.

04:47:11 - 04:47:24

Speaker 142

Order. Mr Opperman, not good behaviour.

And Mr. Cartlidge, after yesterday, I thought you would have had a much quieter voice. I can't hear the Secretary of State. Can we just let him continue? Secretary of State.

04:47:24 - 04:48:52

Wes Streeting

I mean, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm trying to make my voice heard from the dispatch box. But as I've said from my first day as Defense Secretary, I trust this Chancellor to give us what we need to keep our country safe. Yesterday demonstrated why. And his budget proves why Labour can be trusted on defense. We are delivering the - it does say here because I wrote it - we are delivering the biggest sustained increase in defense spending since the end of the Cold War.

That was Labour's record before the budget.

This budget takes us even further and next year's spending review will take us further still. What a- what a contrast with the abysmal record of failure staring us in the face across the House of Commons today. I appealed in my first statement to this House for national unity on national security. I actually think it's important that our allies and our adversaries know that we agree far more than we disagree on. We all believe we should spend more on defence.

We all believe we should stand with Ukraine. We all believe we should invest in homeland security. What a pity then that the Leader of the Opposition and her ragtag band of political vandals choose to play politics with national security. To do that in the current environment is bad enough. To do so after their abysmal record in government takes some brass neck.

But maybe the honourable gentleman wants to defend it.

04:48:52 - 04:49:18

Graham Stuart

I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for giving way.

Um, but he's aware that there is no plan to ensure that that target in 2030 is met. And at a time when we've actually got short-term cuts in operational spending, the Secretary of State must feel a certain amount of disappointment that we don't have a firm plan in place. Because if the Treasury don't sign off the numbers, then nothing really happens. That's true, isn't it?

04:49:18 - 04:50:19

Wes Streeting

I just don't know what they've got to moan about, Madam Deputy Speaker. We came into government, we came into government with the abysmal inheritance we faced. We chose straight away to invest more in defence to clean up their mess.

We've now gone even further than the 2.5% NATO commitment by 2035 by choosing to set our own target of 3% in 2030. And that's not just about the future. It is built on our record in our first two years. Defence spending has gone from 2.3% of defence spending in the moment. But we have gone, we have gone, just so we're clear.

When we came into office, we've gone from spending 2.3% of our GDP on defence to 2.7% next year. So it is very clear we are on the right trajectory. That's not a record that they can speak to. I don't know how they've got the, I don't know how she can be so shameless. But let's find out.

04:50:19 - 04:50:53

Mark Francois

If it's true that he has a plan for 2030, why did the Labour chairman of the Defence Select Committee say yesterday in reaction to the budget, and I quote him, "Some of the key decisions on defence spending have lamentably been delayed until next year's spending review."

There is a cost to inaction. Investment in our nation's defence and security cannot be kicked into the long grass. Our adversaries are not bound by fiscal years and spending cycles." Why did the Labour chairman of the Defence Committee say that?

04:50:53 - 04:51:02

Speaker 142

Before the Secretary of State responds, can I just point out there are so many people wishing to contribute, so hopefully his speech will be coming to a close shortly. Defence Secretary.

04:51:02 - 04:55:19

Wes Streeting

Madam Deputy Speaker, I've been too generous with my interventions, but let me just take that point head-on. I think that is completely unfounded criticism, actually.

I don't care if he's the chair of the Defence Select Committee, and I'd say it directly to the chair of the committee, and I'm sure I'll get the chance to say it to the entire committee. It would be fair criticism if this government had not already made decisions that is leading to the fastest increase in defence spending since the end of the Cold War. Not in future years, already on the basis of our first two years. And I'm sure the chair of the select committee is a good friend, and I'm sure just as I can take his criticism on the chin, he will take mine. I will gladly accept criticism where I think it's fair, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I will robustly reject it where I think it is wrong.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, taking your advice on timing, let me just say, I've referred to the 14 years' record of the last Conservative government.

Let me contrast it with what I have presided over in the last 14 weeks. Armed forces recruitment showing its longest run of growth for half a decade. 400 contracts signed worth over £4 billion. £400 million for spy drones for the army. £135 million for Royal Navy torpedoes.

£700 million for next generation fighter jets. Over £8 billion for our nuclear submarine fleet. We've launched the UK's sixth attack submarine and the first ever space squadron. We've returned gun barrel manufacturing to the UK for the first time in decades.

We're backing British industry to build the docks for our nuclear subs. We've increased monitoring of Russian vessels in the English Channel, provided 50,000 apprenticeship opportunities for young people, welcomed record-breaking investment in Scotland, deployed our armed forces to help Saudi defend from Houthi attacks, bolstered support for Ukraine, signed a landmark AI deal to access cutting-edge battlefield data, strengthened our NATO alliances as I've visited Washington, Paris, Copenhagen, Warsaw, Reykjavik, and Kyiv, mobilized with our allies in the Ukraine Defense Contact Group, the E5, or the Joint Expeditionary Force, hosted our friends from Italy, Japan, Canada, Australia, Qatar, and Oman, as well as the NATO Secretary General. And in case the opposition missed it, as their leader seemed to yesterday, on top of the biggest sustained increase in defense spending since the end of the Cold War, we've set out our own target to spend 3% of GDP on defense by 2030. That is our record. That is a record the party opposite cannot begin to touch.

A government that actually puts its money where its mouth is. Strengthening our armed forces, strengthening our alliances, strengthening our industrial base, backing Britain by buying British.

That is how you defend this country, not with the gimmicks and grandstanding of the party opposite. By making this country ready with our allies to fight and win so that our adversaries think twice about launching an attack in the first place. Madam Deputy Speaker, the truth is that this is a more dangerous world and that makes greater investment essential. But delivering what the Chancellor announced yesterday requires choices and trade-offs. That's why we'll make sure that every pound that we invest is well spent to make sure it creates jobs and opportunities.

Not just the Ministry of Defense, but the Ministry of Growth and the Ministry of Opportunity. Helping to deliver the Prime Minister's domestic agenda. Stronger regional economies, a rebuilt industrial base, good jobs and better opportunities for the next generation.

A more resilient United Kingdom, built by the British people to keep Britain safe. Spending on our on defence is a measure of our commitment, but capability is a measure of our credibility. That's what this Labour budget, rooted in our values, does. It gives breathing space to working people, it gives us fresh hope for the future, and it strengthens the security upon which we all depend. Building a Britain ready to fight and building a country worth fighting for.

That is our record, that is our plan, and that's why I'm proud to stand at this despatch box and commend the budget to the House.

04:55:19 - 04:55:24

Speaker 142

I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson Joshua Reynolds.

04:55:24 - 04:55:58

Joshua Peter Reynolds

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. After years of government chaos and failure, we can only end the brutal cost of living crisis and fix our broken public services if we get the economy growing.

We need a real growth plan with Europe at its heart. So Labour must fix the Conservatives' botched Brexit deal by joining the single market and negotiating a new customs union, and using the billions of pounds that that raises to cut people's taxes and cut people's bills. Already, already, I'll give way to him.

04:55:58 - 04:56:10

Luke Morgan Evans

I'm very grateful to him giving way. Given the fact we heard from the shadow front bench that we don't meet the criteria to rejoin the EU, how does the Lib Dems suggest we get round that problem?

04:56:10 - 04:57:38

Joshua Peter Reynolds

I thank the honourable gentleman for his intervention. I would potentially suggest he needs to listen to what I said in the previous 30 seconds because what I said was we need to join the single market and negotiate a new customs union. I did not say we need to rejoin the European Union. First, the first thing that we would do was to fix the biggest brake on our economy and that is the botched Brexit deal. It put up barriers for every business that trades with our largest single market.

Small firms in Maidenhead tell me how they now spend more time filling in forms than they do filling in orders. Some have simply given up trading with Europe altogether. That is lost trade, lost jobs and lost revenue. We would rip up the government's red lines, build a new growth and defence partnership with Europe, including single market and a new customs union. And we would grow our economy.

According to independent research, those measures would bring in 27 billion pounds a year in extra tax revenue by the end of the parliament. And we would give those proceeds back to the people who earned it, by raising the tax-free personal allowance to 15,000 pounds and by raising the higher rate threshold to 56,000 pounds, taking two and a half million of the lowest paid out of income tax altogether and putting 650 pounds back in people's pockets. It was the Liberal Democrats that raised the personal allowance before, we can do it again. That is how you cut tax responsibly, you need to grow your way to get there. I'll give way.

04:57:38 - 04:57:53

Anna Dixon

Thank the honorable gentleman, would he wish to add his thanks to the Chancellor for the new low-income tax-free allowance for pensioners, ensuring that they can keep their state pension and their hard-earned pension?

04:57:53 - 04:59:47

Joshua Peter Reynolds

I think the honorable lady will find there is an anomaly within the Chancellor's proposals where there is going to be a 54% tax rate for certain pensioners on certain incomes.

Now, I don't believe necessarily that 54% tax rate for pensioners is the right thing to be doing. The second thing that we as Liberal Democrats would do would be to make fairer choices about who pays. This budget does go back once again to savers. Tax on savings on property incomes and savings incomes go up by another two points, that's on top of the two points that were announced last year. So the retired couple that have put money away all of their lives and the family that are saving for their deposit will be taxed more.

The government is giving savers a little bit with one hand, but is taking with another. There is a fairer option though. Because of the high interest rates and the way that Bank of England's quantitative easing program works, the Treasury is handing billions of pounds over to the big banks every year. This is a windfall that the banks did nothing to earn. And it's a windfall that the banks keep and businesses at our villages and our towns are paying the price.

Our plan to claw back some of that money would raise five billion pounds a year on average. And that has never been needed more because as UK Hospitality confirms, the hospitality sector pays 82 pence in business taxes for every pound that it makes, making it the highest in our economy and double that of the banks. In my constituency, we have felt that more than ever. Just last month, the Crown in Birches Green, that was ranked amongst the 50 best gastro pubs in the country, closed its doors. The owner, blaming staff costs, rent, business rates, and VAT, said enough was enough.

If a pub like this cannot make the numbers add up, what hope is there for cafes, restaurants, and pubs across the country? That is why we would use some of that bank windfall tax to cut VAT for the hospitality sector where it needs it most. The third thing we would do would take to take our security seriously. And I'm going to give way.

04:59:47 - 05:00:04

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

There's a slight irony what he's just said. He wants to cut the VAT on pubs, yet he wants to get closer to the European Union that would not allow us to cut VAT on our own individual country. Isn't there a slight contradiction there?

05:00:04 - 05:03:28

Joshua Peter Reynolds

Once again, the honourable gentleman is confusing single market and customs union with rejoining the European Union. I am glad that the Defence Secretary is in his place today because just days ago he did say that we need to be ready for war by 2030 within a thousand days. And I take that warning seriously and I hope that his colleagues do too. Because yesterday the Chancellor set the target for 3% of GDP on defence by 2030.

And the plan to pay for that will come in next year's spending review. So the money that is needed for the issues and the compromises that he describes will not be coming until next year. Madam Deputy Speaker, no government can meet a 1,000-day deadline on a funding plan that currently doesn't exist, which is why we Liberal Democrats have proposed defence bonds. Our plan would raise £20 billion over two years, ring-fenced to rebuild our armed forces, starting now, inside of the Defence Secretary's 1,000 days, not after them. Meanwhile, the Government is funding its defence investment plan by cutting budgets across Whitehall.

Earlier this year, departments were told to cut 1% from their capital budgets to pay for the first £10.3 billion of the dip. Now, the remaining £5 billion, they must find another 1% on top of that.

And as has already been mentioned, we do not know where these cuts will be coming from. So families right across the country want to know which capital projects are going to be cut. Will it be the rebuilding of our crumbling schools? Will it be our leaking hospitals? Where is that money going to come from?

So we are asked to choose between security and growth, but we need both. So the Government urgently needs to make the case for defence bonds so we have the money as soon as possible to rebuild our defences. And by building that capacity alongside our European partners, every pound would go further, supporting skilled jobs and British businesses within the supply chain. We've also set out how to keep that investment going for the long term, which is the Digital Services Tax.

We would raise the digital services tax from 2 to 10%, bringing in billions of pounds a year from the tech and social media giants by 2030. These are some of the most profitable companies in the world, and it is only fair that they pay their fair share. Our plan shows how, and it is fully costed. Defence bonds would provide the money up front, and the higher digital services tax would sustain it year after year. Together, they would pay to expand the British shipbuilding and build more frigates to protect our waters.

Our European neighbours are investing billions in their own defence industries, and Britain must be at the heart of that, not watching from the sidelines. That is why we need our new growth and defence partnership with Europe, buying together, building together, and defending our continent together, ensuring that it is British shipyards, engineers, and factories that win jobs and investments from European contracts, because if we are shut out, then those jobs go elsewhere. Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget is a holding pattern budget.

It is not the growth budget that we all needed. But there is a better way: growth with Europe, fairer taxes that ask the big banks rather than hard-pressed savers to pay their share, lower bills for every household, and a serious plan for our security. That is what fiscal responsibility looks like. We need to grow our economy, cut people's bills, and cut people's taxes.

05:03:28 - 05:03:31

Speaker 209

Ruth Edwards.

05:03:31 - 05:09:31

Margaret Ruth Cadbury

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget gives my constituents and people up and down the country much-needed breathing space and fresh hope for our long-term future. It tackles the big issues facing our country, from the cost-of-living pressures facing mine and all of our constituents to the need to bring growth back to our economy.

The Chancellor was honest about the impact that the war in Iran has had on our economy, on energy prices, and on our supply chains. I remind the House that we on this side of the House opposed this war, but the Conservatives opposite supported it. I will address the impacts of this budget first on my constituency and then from my perspective as Transport Committee Chair. I'm pleased the budget delivers on house building, more council and social housing, as too many families in Hounslow, Brentford, and Isleworth are living in temporary housing, and the new Your First Home scheme, which will support the many who are earning but don't have a deposit to get on the housing ladder.

And on this, the Treasury listened and have raised the sale price cap for the scheme in London. Thank you. Over the past year, I've met businesses across my constituency, restaurants such as Sam's Waterside, coffee shops such as Balucci's in Isleworth and Hounslow, to small specialist manufacturers, Ormiston Wire and Newmont Engineering. Their common message to me has been that costs, particularly energy and business rates, are too high. So I'm really pleased that the Chancellor has committed to taking more businesses out of paying business rates, 900 each in Hounslow and in Richmond boroughs, and frozen business rates for many more businesses.

Madam Deputy Speaker, I also know that to support businesses, we need to get more money into people's pockets. So increasing the national living wage and the minimum wage, addressing energy bills, keeping its commitments on tax and introducing the new pension tax allowance among many others in this budget are all very much welcomed by my constituents. And I welcome that London now has the fiscal devolution that our city has long deserved and brings London more into line with other world cities. It allows the mayor to kickstart projects across the capital, and one of which includes the West London Orbital, a much-needed rail line linking Hounslow to Hendon via Old Oak Common, opening up development and employment opportunities across a swathe of West to North London. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, as chair of Transport Select Committee, I want to mention several other transport-related elements in the budget that I welcome.

The Government's work to bring international rail services to Stratford, which will increase rail connectivity and choice. And the work to address the costs for EV drivers using public charging points. The decisions on fuel duty, which not only benefit car drivers, but save a light goods vehicle driver £472 on average and the average HGV driver nearly £4,000 per year. Given the impact that fuel prices are having on the critical logistics sector, we all end up benefiting from these changes. Building rail infrastructure costs far more to build per kilometre in the UK than in any equivalent economy, and I refer to my committee's February 26th report on rail investment pipelines, "Boom and Bust" we called it.

So I welcome the announcement of the review of rail infrastructure costs and to the publication of the more extensive infrastructure pipeline. The review's terms of reference responded to many of the issues discussed in our inquiry, how investment certainty with clarity about what point costs are fully understood and when funding will be committed. This drives efficiency, safeguards workforces and enables skills planning. Investment is certainly needed, investors certainly need to have their concerns allayed.

These come from the rail supply chain and their investors. Now, although this work is restricted to rail, the scope of the government review is otherwise very similar to the CMA review of road and rail procurement, so I would like to know from the government how will the two relate to each other. And additionally, in its response to our report, the government strangely denied there was such a thing as boom and bust in investment, so I do express a hope that the review will be more open-minded on that front. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm glad the Chancellor has heard the pleas from owners of airports and the private rail infrastructure such as St Pancras and HS1. They're concerned about the exceptional and unpredictable rateable value increases, and I hope that a rational and predictable system can replace the current mess that is holding back long-term investment in our rail and aviation infrastructure.

I welcome the work the Treasury is doing to enable the Prime Minister's drive for devolution and partnership with local leaders, Northern Powerhouse Rail, and a whole host of local transport projects that will deliver local growth across Britain. And finally, the Chancellor is also backing British bus manufacturers with a new look at bus procurement, very welcome indeed. I will conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, by thanking the Chancellor for tackling the big issues that face our economy and for delivering a budget that delivers both for constituents and the whole economy.

05:09:31 - 05:09:33

Speaker 210

Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown.

05:09:33 - 05:12:06

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Madam Deputy Speaker, thank you for allowing me to catch your eye in this important budget debate.

I listened to the Defense Secretary and I thought he absolutely embedded his comedic skills and some of what he was saying would have been better said on Have I Got News For You rather than in this chamber. So what we've got in this budget, it's a tragic opportunity. It's a tragic opportunity to fix the fundamentals of this economy. Our debt is at a record level. The tragedy about that is that we are paying more than Greece in the rate that we are paying on that debt, 5.31%.

And that will add an additional interest on servicing that debt, just the increase on the interest of 14 billion pounds alone. Now the debt, the amount we're paying to service that debt is the third largest if it had been a government department.

The Department of Work and Pensions budget is about 246 billion. Sorry, it's around 344 billion. And this doesn't even cover the amount of income tax that we are raising totally in this country, which is 330 billion. In other words, income tax doesn't pay all of our DWP bills. The second highest department is 226 billion pounds.

So I welcome the Chancellor saying he will meet his fiscal rules by the end of this Parliament. But that involves the national debt falling by the end of the Parliament. If I were a betting man, I doubt very much whether he will meet that rule. Now on one of the, one of the saddest things about our economy at the moment is inflation is going up.

And before they start to scoff at that, it's one of the most important measures of the lot because it affects everything. It affects all of our cost of living, everything from our fuel costs to our energy costs to our mortgage costs, all affected by inflation. So the one thing we ought to be doing is trying to get down the rate of inflation. And one of the saddest things about inflation is that my constituents, many who live off the gas grid, have to pay for heating oil, and heating oil has gone up by 75% in the last year. Imagine that if you're on benefits, and they're getting very little help out of this budget to meet that.

05:12:06 - 05:12:15

Speaker 211

Currently 13% of 16 to 24-year-olds... My honourable friend has made his point very well.

05:12:15 - 05:18:43

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Let's hope that's read into the record. Currently, 13% of 16 to 24-year-olds are neither in employment, education, or training. We should be focusing relentlessly on creating opportunities for young people and supporting businesses that employ them. Sadly, this budget, as I'll say in a minute, does not do that. When sickness benefits pay more than the minimum wage, what is the incentive to work?

Sectors such as tourism and hospitality, which provide opportunities in every part of the country, every constituency, but especially in rural areas, are facing significant economic pressures, and at least one pub a week nationally is closing.

The rates relief offered by the Chancellor in this budget may help a minuscule amount, but this is unfortunately offset by the increase in the minimum wage and particularly VAT costs that those businesses face. Now I want to turn to the kernel of what the Defence Secretary was saying and turn to defence. Solemnly promised by this Prime Minister and the previous Prime Minister that we would not only get to 2.7% quickly, we would actually have a path to 3%. Now there is no path to 3%. The only path that I can see is that departmental budgets will be cut, and it hasn't yet been tied down what will actually have to come out of those departments, what services will come out of those departments to pay for that 2.3% real cuts in those departments.

And there was no clarity on this in our budget yesterday. Surely, if the Labour Party and the Government keep both boasting about they're going to go to 3%, the least they owe the British people is a path of how we're going to get there. At least not only the 3%, but the 3.5% in the following Parliament, which is a great deal of money. Importantly, as General Sir Richard Barrons has said recently, we don't own the clock. In other words, we don't know when our adversaries are likely to launch some form of attack on us.

And we do know that the Ministry of Defence is not able to place the orders it needs, for example in some of the bigger equipment like F-35s. Well, when are the F-35s going to come?

The Defence Secretary shakes his head. They're still in the queue, they can't be manufactured for us because we haven't made the solid commitment as to when we want them. And that particularly, that delay in procurement particularly affects some of our smaller defence companies because they don't have the cash flow. I now want to turn to AI. Now AI is something that I raised in an intervention yesterday.

This is one of the most important things the Chancellor could have done for this country yesterday was to provide a proper path how the government in every single department was going to operate digital and AI more effectively so that it could increase productivity. And the machinery of government changes that the government has undertaken in the last year don't give the PAC, which I chair, any confidence that the government has a real policy on digital and AI and how they're going to produce these mechanisms, use this technology properly.

A year ago, digital policy was in the Cabinet Office. Then it was transferred to DSIT. DSIT was abolished. Now it's in DCMS, the department which historically has been used to dealing with sport and culture, not the important matter of AI. So without this priority, it's difficult to see how this government is really going to make this digital policy work.

Now, when my honourable friend, as I said in an intervention yesterday, the member for Godalming and Ash, started in his budget to give some significant sums to the Department of Health, the Defence Secretary's former department, of three billion to transform their digital equipment, that was the start of what we should have been doing for every single department.

And I don't know how the government are going to meet their efficiency targets unless they actually start to introduce proper AI, actually get rid of some of our legacy equipment, which as the Defence Secretary knows only too well is more vulnerable to cyberattacks. I now want to turn to local government reform, and I was very pleased to have the announcement this morning that Gloucestershire is going to be one unitary authority. That is good news. But we're only going to get any increase in finances for our local authority if we can come up with devolution. And it's, and there was no link to how Gloucestershire was going to move from local government reorganization into a strategic authority.

And we need to have that, because otherwise we're not going to be able to take advantage of some of those financial advantages. In the closing minutes of my speech, I just want to talk about the Civil Service Pension Scheme.

And here there is a good news story in which I'm going to praise the government. We have had five hearings on the Public Accounts Committee into the dreadful mess that Capita has left that scheme. Five hearings where every single deadline has been missed. And that is not good enough for those poor 1.7 million members of that scheme. So the government have done a really good thing.

Last week, I wrote to the pensions minister about the problem of if Capita did not pay out a lump sum within two years, they would be taxed on that sum at their highest rate. The minister met me fairly quickly. I raised it on the floor of the House on Monday. And bingo, I got a letter yesterday saying the law was going to be changed in the budget. Now I do pay tribute to the government and the pensions minister for that very quick action.

That was the just thing to do.

Those pension scheme members will not have to keep worrying about whether they're going to get their full lump sum or not. So in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a sadly wasted opportunity, and we look forward to future budgets actually giving us a path how we can have a better economic future. One of the economic measures that we had in the budget yesterday was the growth of 1.2%, which every, all the Government, the Chancellor's crowing about, but actually 1.2% historically is not enough to keep spending at the rate that the Government is. We need more measures to help business. We need a proper taxation policy, and then this country will start to grow.

05:18:43 - 05:18:45

Speaker 212

Madam Deputy Speaker, thank you.

05:18:45 - 05:18:50

Speaker 213

And with an immediate five-minute time limit, Chris Webb.

05:18:50 - 05:23:54

Christopher Paul Webb

Yesterday the Chancellor affirmed this government's commitment to good growth in every postcode, and as the MP for a town that has been neglected by previous governments, I welcome this investment in communities like mine because it's desperately needed. Through years of austerity and economic decline, places like Blackpool were asked to do more with less again and again until there was nothing left to cut. I believe with the right investment and with local people in the driving seat, no community needs to feel left behind again. Many of my constituents have already welcomed the cost of living measures this budget has set out.

A £100 household energy payment for eligible households in council tax bands A to D means 97% of households in my constituency will feel that benefit. Freezing fuel duty rates and extending the 5p cut to July 27, along with more generous mile rates for people who use their own vehicles for work, will make a real difference to the tradesmen and care worker alike in Blackpool. Taken together, along with a welcome increase in minimum wage, these are tangible changes that will have an impact on my constituents' pockets. But improving people's lives means improving their environment too. People want to walk out their front doors and be proud of where they live, not be met by boarded up buildings.

High streets are the beating heart of our communities and hardworking businesses should be able to thrive on them. The derelict buildings fund announced alongside the budget lets us bring prominent, long-term vacant buildings back into productive community or commercial use. After campaigning hard in this place for funding to tackle blight of derelict buildings in Blackpool, I'm delighted we've been allocated the £1.35 million from that fund.

This is the type of investment we have to make count. And I'll be leading on this work locally and I want local residents to tell me the buildings that matter most to them or what projects to back with the potential to transform the area. This is exactly what we mean when we talk about putting power back into every postcode and it's another step to building a better Blackpool. It's right that this Labour government has now committed over 40 billion to the biggest housebuilding program in a generation, with an extra 1.5 billion committed in the budget. At the end of last year, 11,844 people in Blackpool were waiting for social housing.

So I urge ministers not to overlook like their predecessors did to ensure we get a share of additional homes to meet the scale of our need.

And I welcome the Chancellor's additional 432 million pounds to ensure people sleeping rough have a route off the sleeps, off the streets. Figures from Blackpool Council show that applications from people seeking help with homelessness in 24-25 were running nearly three times the national average. But we must make sure that safer accommodation alongside the practical health, addiction and housing support people need to rebuild their lives and stay off the streets for good. We have fantastic homelessness and reach organisations across Blackpool, just like Streetlife, whose youth advisory group I welcomed in Parliament last week. They told me that they need wrap-around support for us to see the whole person.

Unfortunately, the odds have been stacked against our young people. We face serious concentrations of deprivation and poor health and a demand on services for children and families.

Blackpool currently supports nearly three times the national average of children in care compared nationally. Yet despite the immense pressure, Blackpool Council has significantly improved its children's services, where we were recently graded outstanding by Ofsted, thanks to the tireless work of frontline staff and dedicated leadership from councillors Jim Hobson and Kath Benson. Alongside the leader of Blackpool Council, Councillor Lynn Williams, we've joined, she's joined me in urging the government to commit to dedicated children and families transformational investment package for Blackpool, so that we can work together on the work that's already been done to bring down the numbers of children in care. We stand ready to work with the government to make our town a national example of prevention-led children's services reform.

I have told this House on numerous occasions that I truly believe when Blackpool succeeds, Britain succeeds. If we can fix the problem of a town at the sharp end of many statistics, we can fix them anywhere. We are now a town on the cusp of change. We have a wealth of creativity and culture and the ambition to be the City of Culture in 2029. That I believe could be the connective tissue between all the areas of the good work being done.

So in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, breathing room is needed and this budget provides some of that, but we must scale up the ambition and the speed of the projects. Blackpool's motto is progress. It's a town that's pioneered so much and has kept moving even through deep spending cuts. We're on the right path.

What we need now is a government that walks with us.

05:23:54 - 05:27:20

Seamus Logan

Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to begin by asking the House, when I heard the Chancellor's speech yesterday, is that it? Is this the government's best shot? If the Prime Minister's planning to go to the country on the back of this, I say bring it on. Yesterday, the Chancellor delivered the gravest betrayal of the just transition in my constituency and in Scotland. Grangemouth, Mossmorran, and now St Fergus.

This looks like Thatcherism on steroids. Anyone seeing a pattern here?

The Chancellor didn't even have the courage to spell it out in yesterday's budget, with loss of government support for Acorn in the weeds of the Red Book. While its so-called mature CCUS projects in England and Wales get the go-ahead, the Labour government's paltry offer to Scotland amounts to merely seeing how loan or equity investments can support the continued development of future CCUS, specifically mentioning the Acorn site. In other words, the project will no longer be considered for direct government money as part of the government-funded Track process. I'm not taking interventions, there's a lot of people wanting to... No, thank you.

With the Labour government prioritising 9.4 billion in England and Wales, and not even managing 200 million for the Acorn project in the Scottish cluster, rhetoric once again fails to match reality and instead reveals treachery in cold blood. I was promised a final investment decision by the previous Chancellor at the dispatch box.

Where's that promise gone? Today trust in this UK government from Scotland lies in tatters as they renege on their commitment to the green transition and reindustrialization in the northeast of Scotland. Task forces, reports, roadmaps, decisions to be made in the future, jam tomorrow. As one newspaper put it this morning, the sound we heard yesterday was the can being kicked down the road. The Chancellor calls it capital reprioritization, but his fancy phraseology hides the truth.

Existing capital remains prioritized in Teesside and Merseyside. Why not Acorn in Scotland? The Scottish cluster and the UK's net zero future and thousands of jobs in Scotland rely on this ability to cut industrial emissions, providing the country's only viable CO2 transport and storage solution.

Without it, key industries including energy, chemicals and manufacturing face mounting costs, a loss of competitiveness and a major risk of job losses. Meanwhile, as the cost of living, the cost of food, of fuel and energy spirals upwards, Scotland remains trapped in an economic doom loop under Westminster control. We estimate 650 million will be removed from our budget next year. Where is this breathing space for households? At a time when energy bills will soon be more than 1,000 pounds higher than promised, the Labour Party's gas price hike will disproportionately increase costs for people in Scotland.

And what about the many people who rely on home heating oil in my constituency and across Scotland, who won't benefit from changes on standing charges? Where is the help for these households facing enormous hikes in heating costs?

I know the members opposite don't like to hear it, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I'm still going to say it. Where are the transformative measures on child poverty?

05:27:20 - 05:27:28

Speaker 217

Order, I am struggling to hear the honourable gentleman. Please let us be able to hear the words that come out. Seamus Logan.

05:27:28 - 05:28:49

Seamus Logan

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Where are the transformative measures on child poverty? The UK government only has to look to Scotland for inspiration on innovative policies to combat child poverty, such as the no, such as the Scottish child payment. Where's West, where's Labour's equivalent? Where's the full windfall tax on the banks?

Three percent for fifteen months just won't cut it. Forty-six billion profit made in 2024. I've already said no interventions, thank you. Where's the help for the Scottish whisky industry? Why is there nothing on fiscal drag and tax thresholds?

Why is there nothing on VAT reduction for small hospitality businesses? Of course, the extent of the Barnett consequentials remain to be seen. Devolution is fine for mayors, Madam Deputy Speaker, but what we need in Scotland is a fresh start with independence. That's why we in the SNP choose Scotland, not this tepid version of a Chancellor's budget. A waste of opportunity, a betrayal of our energy workers, a hopeless stab in the back for struggling families, robbing Peter to pay Paul.

I'll conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, channeling the words of T.S. Eliot, words written more than a hundred years ago. This budget wasn't so much a bang, but a whimper.

05:28:49 - 05:29:02

Speaker 217

Before I call the next speaker, can I just remind people that are trying to heckle from the back benches at the same time as trying to catch my eye, they may want to be mindful. Dame Siobhain McDonagh.

05:29:02 - 05:33:25

Siobhain McDonagh

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Chancellor's budget, particularly the additional 1.5 billion for social and affordable housing, taking the government's investment to more than 40 billion. The only lasting solution to our housing crisis is to build more homes, particularly more council homes. But I want to address a crisis that cannot wait for those homes to be built. The almost 200,000 children across the country who will spend tonight homeless.

And in London, that figure is one in 30 children, or one in every school class. They are not sleeping on the streets.

They have a roof over their heads, but they are homeless. As chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for households in temporary accommodation, I see the national picture and the scale of the homeless crisis we face. But as the MP for Mitcham and Morden, I see the faces behind those statistics week in, week out at my constituency advice surgery. I see families living in a single room, parents desperately trying to keep their children at the same school, children without anywhere to do their homework, or cooking facilities where their parents can prepare a proper meal. And temporary accommodation is increasingly anything but temporary.

Earlier this year, my APPG published research into child mortality in temporary accommodation. Between 2019 and 2023, 104 children died in cases where temporary accommodation was identified as a possible contributing factor to their vulnerability, ill health or death. 76 of these children were babies under the age of one. And every one of those numbers is a child whose future has been taken away and a family who will never recover from that loss. We must never accept that as an inevitable consequence of homelessness.

But there is also a serious financial argument for tackling this crisis.

London councils are spending more than 5.5 million pounds every single day on temporary accommodation. Much of the money is spent securing accommodation from private providers, often at considerable expense, without creating the permanent housing assets that councils so desperately need. And the cost of unsuitable temporary accommodation does not end with the council's housing budget. It's felt in our schools, our NHS and other public services through disrupted education, worsening health and the additional support that families so often need. That is why we must consider the full cost of homelessness to the public purse, not simply the price of providing a roof over someone's head.

I welcome the Chancellor's additional 432 million to tackle rough sleeping, but homelessness is not confined to our streets. The budget recognizes this and confirms the government ongoing value for money review of homelessness funding will examine temporary accommodation. That review must consider how councils acquire more suitable accommodation locally, reducing their reliance on costly private placements. But we cannot wait until 2027 to improve conditions for children living in temporary accommodation today. Every child deserves somewhere safe to sleep, somewhere to do their homework, and somewhere their parents can prepare a proper meal.

These are not luxuries, but the most basic requirements of a home. The Chancellor's additional investment in social and affordable housing is a welcome commitment to tackling the root causes of homelessness.

But building the homes we need will take time. For the children growing up homeless tonight, time is something we cannot afford to waste. We must ensure that the government's ambition to end rough sleeping is matched by an ambition to end child homelessness.

05:33:25 - 05:33:27

Speaker 220

Charlie Dewhirst.

05:33:27 - 05:38:27

Charlie Dewhirst

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Fiscal responsibility means living within your means. Every household across East Yorkshire and up and down the country knows that you cannot spend more on the family credit card than you earn, racking up debt with little more than the hope of a future pay rise. Yet that is exactly what this government is doing with our country's credit card, a credit card taken out in my constituents' names.

After Labour crashed the economy in 2008, they left a deficit of 10%. They were spending 10%, Madam Deputy Speaker, 160 billion pounds more on the country's credit card each year than the country earned. Only the Conservatives' fiscal responsibility was able to fix Labour's mess and steadily wrestle that deficit down. And even after the exceptional need to support jobs and businesses through a global pandemic and the Ukraine war, that deficit rose to 4.4%, less than half of the legacy left by Labour in 2010. And here we are again, with Labour's fiscal irresponsibility and no plan to deal with the deficit.

Labour are borrowing 308 billion pounds more than the plan they inherited in 2024. Under this government, the national debt has surged through the 3 trillion pound mark for the first time ever.

This spending cannot go on. This government needs to get borrowing down, it needs to get public spending down, it needs to get welfare down. And it needs to get people's taxes down. Next year the tax burden will reach a historic high of 37.9% of GDP under this government and it is set to surge from there. So where is this money going, Madam Deputy Speaker?

Well, I'd like to address briefly some of the issues around the mismanagement of public money in the civil service. Now this government to their credit pledged to reduce the size of the civil service, but I've bad news because the headcount has risen by 11,000 people since they took office, but cutting the headcount is not their only broken promise.

Last year, they put out a press release promising they would instruct civil servants to stop what they themselves called wasteful spending, namely banning government-branded merchandise and away days in externally hired venues rather than using freely available government buildings. Yet DEFRA spent £20,000 on an away day at the Cumberland Hotel in March. The same month, DCMS spent £2,000 on an away day at the British Museum. The following month, April 2023, the Cabinet Office spent over £33,000 hiring the Hartwell House luxury hotel and spa and its swanky restaurant with a 20-page wine list for another retreat for its top tier of civil servants. I must confess, Madam Deputy Speaker, I was slightly confused that Cabinet Office minister admitted this in a written answer to my honourable friend the member for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire, because when I asked the question, I got the response: "In the calendar year, the Cabinet Office has not held any departmental senior civil service away days."

Moving on, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Crown Prosecution Service spent £37,000 on an away day at the four-star Manchester Marriott Hotel.

The Department for Transport managed to spend nine thousand pounds on an away day at the Foreign Office and fourteen thousand pounds on an away day at the HS2 offices. The Northern Ireland Office spent four thousand pounds meeting in a castle. Department for Education had an away day for twenty-seven thousand pounds at a Grade II listed building in Sheffield while the Ministry of Justice spent another thirty-four thousand pounds on an away day at a theatre. The Treasury, who we might hope would be holding the purse strings a little tighter Madam Deputy Speaker, held two away days, one at the British Museum and spent twenty-five thousand pounds excluding VAT. DESNZ held three off-site away days, two at four-star hotels costing a total of over fifty thousand pounds and the Department for Business also spent fifty thousand pounds on three including one at the Emirates Stadium citing that there was no alternative available then.

The MOD and Foreign Office couldn't tell me whether they had any away days as it would cost them too much to answer the question. So I dread to think how many away days they've had. And unfortunately, the Women and Equalities Office hasn't even bothered to reply to me, so I assume they've got lost on an away day at a nice spa hotel. I would go on, Madam Deputy Speaker, but really the, the list, the list goes on and on. And when we get to merchandise, the Cabinet Office alone, who actually banned all of this, spent £4,000 on T-shirts, stickers and commemorative coins.

Um, we could go on about, we could move on to Number 10 North, but I think as we know, Madam Deputy Speaker, it is nothing more than a vanity project. In conclusion, it is time to bring back common sense and fiscal responsibility. Taxes are at a record high, growth is down, borrowing is higher, debt is up and living standards are down. We cannot keep spending more on the country's credit card than we earn.

Wealth must be created before it can be distributed by our businesses, our entrepreneurs and those who go to work every day. There is no such thing as government money, it is taxpayers' money and Labour are addicted on spending other people's money, not creating it. We, the Conservatives, want to see Britain richer, more prosperous and thriving. And to paraphrase the excellent point made by the Leader of the Opposition yesterday, our country is overspent, over-borrowed, overtaxed and drowning in an out-of-control welfare system. What a pickle we are in, Madam Deputy Speaker.

05:38:27 - 05:38:28

Callum Anderson.

05:38:28 - 05:43:25

Callum Anderson

Madam Deputy Speaker, very happy to contribute to today's debate and it's a pleasure to particularly follow my honourable friends the members for Brentford and Isleworth, Blackpool South and Mitcham and Morden. I welcome this budget for three reasons.

First, it maintains the fiscal discipline that is a strategic imperative. And I think the fact that Sterling, the FTSE indexes and 10 and 30 year gilt yields have stayed stable over the last 24 hours is a significant signifier of that. And given the risks that the UK economy faces, be it barriers to trade, the imposition of tariffs, rising or volatile and rising energy costs and higher government borrowing costs everywhere, it is really important that this budget has remained within the fiscal rules. And second, it does provide families, households and businesses in the towns and villages and city that make up the Buckingham Bletchley constituency genuine breathing space as they manage ongoing cost of living pressures. 34,000 households in council tax bands A to D will receive the 100 pounds household energy payment.

Even more will feel the extension of the electricity VAT cut. Businesses on Queensway in Bletchley or in the high streets of Buckingham and Winslow will gain from the higher small business rate relief threshold rise. Agricultural businesses in North Buckinghamshire benefit from the extended red diesel duty cut. But while an absolute imperative, fiscal responsibility should never be an end of itself, which is why the third reason that I welcome this budget is because it does what my right honourable friend the Chancellor sought out to do, which is to back those bloody-minded entrepreneurs.

But it's not just me saying that. It is business groups such as Startup Coalition and UK Private Capital that are saying it too. Because fiscal responsibility enables government to help the people who are building Britain's next generation of national champions and globally consequential companies, be that in AI or in defense, clean energy, life sciences, or advanced manufacturing. They are driving the economic growth. They are driving the job and wealth creation.

And ultimately, they are also underpinning the sovereign capabilities of the UK. And growth in every postcode is absolutely the right objective. And that means we need entrepreneurs in every postcode too. And today is undoubtedly a better day and a better Britain to build and innovate a company than it was yesterday.

So when it comes to helping people start a business, raising the trading allowance from £1,000 to £3,000 is a strong signal that people, and in particular young people, can realise their dreams here in the United Kingdom. When it comes to scaling businesses, we have known for a long time that that is where Britain can do much more and needs to go further more quickly. And so expanding the capacity of the British Business Bank and National Wealth Fund, including deploying £5 billion over the next four years into defence, recognises the role that public capital has to play in acting as a cornerstone investor alongside our deep pools of private capital, all £3 trillion of it too. But after all the blood, sweat and tears that goes into building a business, we also have to give founders a genuine reason, a compelling reason beyond patriotism alone, to remain anchored here and stay here. And that's why the founders' relief is so welcome.

And I know that's what many business groups have been arguing for and advocating for across government and Westminster for some time. It's because it will be giving entrepreneurs more, greater levels of confidence that they can build and scale here and they will be rewarded. And just as importantly, it will strengthen them to reinvest their wealth and recycle their expertise and their experience into more ventures into the future. And growth and wealth creation and fiscal responsibility are intrinsically linked. Growth is the ultimate stabilizer of the public finances through stronger receipts that will help reduce the budget deficit and reduce our borrowing costs in the long run.

And that will help give us flexibility to let people keep more of what they earn and invest in things that are particularly important to us here, be it investing in our national security, our schools, and our police. This budget is a very welcome step in the right direction. There's much more to do and I look forward to the 10-year plan and the spending review in the long run, and I welcome this budget.

05:43:25 - 05:43:27

Speaker 223

I call Sarah Olney.

05:43:27 - 05:48:28

Sarah Olney

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. There are many elements of the Chancellor's budget which I welcome: his commitment to fiscal devolution, his promise to end rough sleeping, and the additional assistance for people to pay their energy bills. But there were many significant omissions and missed opportunities. Instead of freezing fuel duty, he should have listened to Liberal Democrat calls to cut it. Instead of promising reform to Carer's Allowance in four years' time, he should have delivered it now.

And instead of flirting with the EU, he should have committed to beginning negotiations to rejoin the single market and a new UK-EU customs union. For our young people, the Chancellor's moved away from Labour's manifesto commitment to equalize the minimum wage and living wage, while failing to address the student loan bubble, which is at bursting point, or to scrap his predecessor's damaging NICs rise, which is keeping young people out of work. For working people, he failed to address wage compression and follow Liberal Democrat calls to increase the personal allowance and to raise the higher rate income tax threshold. This reform is vital for the 110,000 Londoners who are being dragged into the higher tax bracket. So while there are measures which can be welcomed in this budget, there are many missed opportunities, and the Liberal Democrats will push the government to be more ambitious and to deliver on their promise of providing people with the help they need during the cost of living crisis and the unaffordably high cost of doing business.

Not enough is being done to support small businesses who are struggling, particularly regarding the cost of employment. In retail alone, employment costs have jumped by 6.5 billion since the 2024 budget. Unemployment levels are alarmingly high. 25% of young Londoners are not in employment, education or training. The government must start making it easier for businesses to provide opportunities, particularly to young people as they begin their working life.

Moving to decouple gas and electricity prices is a welcome step and we welcome the short-term relief which many households will receive to ease energy costs this winter, but the government has failed to address the issues facing many businesses, the cost of energy for our industrial sector. Our dependence on other countries for fuel makes us all vulnerable to international turmoil.

Household energy bills remain a third higher than before the war in Ukraine and the average UK resident and small business are being hit by these risings. The ongoing war in Iran reminds us yet again of the importance of secure and reliable energy sources. The best way to cut energy bills is to invest in homegrown renewable power. Make UK set out the ruinous effect which industrial electrical costs have on investment and they have highlighted the continuing lack of action to address the costs and the risks now associated with taking on workers. The manufacturing sector accounts for 2.6 million jobs and 42% of UK exports and the government must listen to their calls to reduce energy bills much more urgently than the 10-year schedule set out in the Chancellor's speech.

The British Chamber of Commerce and the Chief Executive of the Food and Drink Federation have echoed these calls, highlighting that the energy support which is available to certain manufacturing sectors does not apply to food and drink businesses. It's time for the UK to lead within Europe again on security, working closely with our democratic European allies so that we can support Ukraine and our European partners during peace and war. Our trade relationships must also be adjusted to reflect the geopolitical realities which we face. The government must remove their self-defeating red lines and be bolder by introducing a new EU-UK Customs Union. Ministers must take advantage of the upcoming UK-EU summit to maximize opportunities of closer trading with the European Union and mitigate the risks and damage caused by schemes such as Made in Europe.

The Liberal Democrats have always championed fiscal devolution, and I welcome that this budget will legislate for the Mayor of London to set up a successor to the Elizabeth Line business rate supplement.

Anyone who has used London's train network recently will acknowledge that it is in need of upgrades, whether it be persistent cancellations on the District Line or the discomfort of using the Central Line, commuters in London deserve better. That being said, the business rate supplement remains quite a limited way of raising funds. The government has seemingly constrained it to only apply to the West London Orbital and Bakerloo Line extension, so while I welcome this as a step in the right direction, I will continue to champion further fiscal devolution for the capital. I'm concerned to see that the Home Office and the Department for Transport are set to face funding cuts. While taking into account the caveat that figures are adjusted due to lower employer pension contributions, the Home Office faces 1.2 billion in cuts next year and then another 1.2 billion cut the following year, while the DfT will lose out on 100 million over two years.

And two of the most common issues I see in my inbox are concerns around policing and transport, so this is a huge concern to my constituents.

Lastly, on an issue which has been declared a matter for London and Londoners by the Prime Minister, I come to the question of Heathrow expansion. Still a question yet to be answered. The budget Red Book states on Heathrow, the Transport Secretary will provide an update as soon as possible. If the Prime Minister is true to his word, why does the decision on a third runway still seem to lie in the hands of the government? It is a white elephant project which does not have the support for the majority of Londoners and must be scrapped.

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

05:48:28 - 05:48:29

Alex McIntyre.

05:48:29 - 05:53:19

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Yesterday at the budget, the Chancellor's and this government's priorities were clear: delivering breathing space for families and businesses in Gloucester this winter in the middle of global headwinds from wars in Ukraine and the Middle East, and starting to tackle the big issues facing our country on defence, on social care, on energy bills, to build fresh hope and optimism for the future, a future that delivers real change for Gloucester residents.

The cost of living crisis remains the number one concern for families and businesses in my city. So I welcome the down payment made by the Prime Minister this summer, reintroducing the two pound bus fare cap, scrapping VAT on electricity bills, and cutting business rates for our pubs. And yesterday I was pleased that the Chancellor went further. The hundred pound household energy payment will be paid to fifty thousand households in Gloucester this January, providing much needed help in the coldest months. Freezing fuel duty and increasing the minimum wage above inflation will help.

Now, the Chancellor acknowledged these measures won't solve the cost of living crisis alone, but this is a vital first step, with the Prime Minister's ten-year plan coming later this year and the spending review next spring. And I ask the government throughout all of this to keep hardworking Gloucester families at the front of their minds when they're going through those processes. But breathing space is not just for families.

It is also needed for the small businesses that are the beating heart of our city. For too long our local high streets have been punished by an outdated business rate system. By freezing rates in real terms for retail, hospitality and leisure properties and providing that 20% cut for our pubs and live music venues, we are taking decisive action. And by increasing the small business relief, almost 60% of businesses on our Gate Streets will be taken out of business rates altogether. I also welcome the government's new Hope on the High Street strategy.

It aligns with the great work done by Andrew Hearn at Gloucester City Council on our city masterplan. It is an ambitious plan for our city and we must be ambitious. But I must draw the House's attention to the immediate roadblock that we face at home in Gloucester. Gloucester City Council is for all intents and purposes entirely broke.

Years of mismanagement have forced the council to rely on an emergency bailout from the government just to keep the lights on. And to make matters worse, following a recent vote of no confidence in the leader of the council, the entire Lib Dem cabinet of the council have walked away. And the council is now operating without any political leadership whatsoever. My constituents cannot afford for Gloucester's regeneration to be held hostage by local political chaos and bankruptcy. The city centre desperately needs investment, officers need political certainty, and the businesses of Gloucester need a reliable functioning partner to unlock the growth that this budget makes possible.

So I ask the government today, what support can the government provide to my constituents to get Gloucester back on track? How can we at a national level bypass this local vacuum of leadership to ensure that our city centre gets the investment it so desperately needs and that our national growth strategy is not blocked by local government failure? Turning to growth, I want to make sure that Gloucester businesses truly benefit from our national economic strategy.

Small businesses need a reliable place in the national supply chain. When we invest, we must buy local, build local, and grow local. Nowhere is that supply chain more crucial than in our national security. Gloucestershire has a proud, deep-rooted footprint in the defence, cybersecurity, and aerospace sectors, and I'm proud this government is fully funding the defence investment plan and putting ourselves on a firm path to reach 3% of GDP on defence spending by 2030. And I urge the government to ensure that this historic investment flows directly to innovative SMEs in Gloucester like Poeton, Avon Metals, Cherry & White, and Permali, the very businesses engineering the technologies that keep our country safe.

Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget fundamentally recognises that the people closest to problems should have the power to solve them. It promises greater control over local economic futures, and it is clear that devolution is the key to unlocking Gloucester's immense potential.

Sadly, due to a lack of consensus from local leaders, Gloucestershire is being left behind. There is only one option that makes long-term sense for Gloucester and that is for us to join the West of England Combined Authority. I am in complete cross-party agreement with Lisa Spivey, the Liberal Democrat leader of Gloucestershire County Council, on that. And in the meantime, we need a Gloucester Foundation Strategic Authority to unlock investment in my city. I ask the government to meet with me to deliver that.

In closing, every decision in this budget shows that we have shut the door on the reckless, unfunded promises of the Shadow Chancellor's past and that we reject the dangerous rhetoric of Reform, whose pledge to slash public funding in a hundred days without any detail would decimate our hospitals, our schools and our police, and they're not here again today. We are choosing a different path.

Gloucester has an incredible future ahead of it, provided that we get the devolution and investment that we deserve. We can build new council homes, we can rebuild our high street, and we can finally deliver the fresh hope that our great city deserves.

05:53:19 - 05:53:20

Steve Barclay.

05:53:20 - 05:57:01

Paul Stephen Barclay

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Defense Secretary opened today's debate by praising the former Prime Minister and the former Chancellor, which may come as a surprise to them both, given that earlier this year he resigned from government, saying in his resignation letter he couldn't serve alongside them because of the lack of direction and drift. And it's less than a year since the benches opposite cheered and waved their order papers at Rachel Reeves's budget.

And it's striking when you look at today how much continuity there is in measures that they cheered yesterday, despite being so unhappy with the previous Chancellor. And I thought by illustrating that, I would just highlight certain phrases and words that we hear from the benches opposite on a regular basis. Starting with perhaps the most frequent, which is the need to have no austerity and end to austerity, which is a constant refrain. I can see the front bench nodding, so they'll be surprised, Madam Deputy Speaker, to see that in the OBR, at page 21 and at page 114, it talks about the fact that there's an 11 billion pound shortfall from the year after next for departments other than protected departments, such as health. They've already said they want to commit to defense.

I don't think the party that stands saying 24 hours to save the NHS is going to cut the health service going into an election, but perhaps that's their policy. But if not, they're going to be cutting unprotected departments by, according to the OBR, 2.6% in those final three years. Now, there's also a paradox to that because it's only last week that the Defense Secretary came to the House to say there's urgency on national resilience. And yet the departments like MHCLG that would deliver that national resilience, well, they'll be the same ones that are facing unprotected cuts. And so the benches opposite are cheering a budget in which there is austerity baked in.

Now, it may be they shake their heads, so it may be that they've been told by the Labour whips, don't worry, because the spending review will fix that. But I know, having run a spending review, spending review allocates the funds, it doesn't decide on the quantum. Now, it may be that they say, well, don't worry, because there'll be an election.

And there may be, but the Prime Minister yesterday was saying the opposite. So either they believe a budget that has austerity baked in, or they think that the spending review is going to fix this, or they don't believe the Prime Minister and think an election will avoid the issue entirely. But it's an odd position for people that come to the chamber talking about an end to austerity, who are then cheering a budget where it is literally in the numbers in the Red Book. The second paradox is they talk about green space, and one of the areas of continuity with last year's budget, literally certain policies like a 2p on property income tax is a repeat of last year's 2p, 4p in all, both starting at the same time, April next year.

And the OBR makes clear that that will lead to fewer people entering the rental market, fewer landlords and prices going up. They have a bank tax, again repeating a trick of the former Chancellor who thought if I tax employers with national insurance it won't go through into a jobs tax. So we've got a bank tax on the basis that that will be more palatable. But don't take my word for it, the Times leader, I think it was the 16th of October, said it will be a tax on growth. And again one of their favorite advisors, Lord O'Neill, said, and I quote, it will hobble growth.

So you've got a budget which is premised on creating... of course I'll give way.

05:57:01 - 05:57:11

Samuel Carling

I'm grateful to my constituency neighbor for giving way. I just wonder in the context of his criticism of the tax change to banks, how he responds to I believe the chief executive of Barclays describing changes along the lines of what we've made as bearable.

05:57:11 - 05:59:14

Paul Stephen Barclay

Well, of course it will be bearable for him because he won't take it from his bonus. He will take it by adding it to the mortgage rates and the loan rates that he charges the honorable member's constituents. Does he honestly believe that the bankers are going to take it from their own bonuses, or does he think they're going to pass it on to constituents and to consumers? And indeed, that is exactly what The Times, that is exactly what Lord O'Neill and many others have commented. So it's a displaced cost that will add and constrain business.

This government talks about wanting growth in every postcode, but making it harder for businesses to access capital will make it harder for them to expand. So again, we have a measure which continues, as with landlords and approach taken by the previous government.

And then we have a lack of consistency even, Madam Deputy Speaker, with the Labour conference just last month. At last month's conference, as the front bench pointed out, the Chancellor talked about how he was aghast at the idea of debt. What the OBR document makes clear is it's adding, just from the budget measures, eight billion of debt this year alone. And that's not alone, that's on top of the 11 billion of additional debt that flows from interest rates and inflation. So again, a government that says it wants to reduce debt has a budget that is adding to debt and adding to it right there in a way that will further constrain the growth in every postcode that it says.

I'm out of time, unfortunately, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I suspect in a few months' time, as with the last budget they cheered, once the detail becomes more known, once they see how it goes against many of the equities that they say they stand for, we will find this budget disowned in exactly the same way that the last one was.

05:59:14 - 05:59:16

Speaker 227

Dr. Zubir Ahmed.

05:59:16 - 06:01:54

Zubir Ahmed

Madam Deputy Speaker, my apologies for my malfunctioning technological malfunctioning there.

Madam Deputy Speaker, when I was first elected to this place as the proud member for Glasgow South West, many of my constituents lived in a lot of financial uncertainty. Whether it was the financial uncertainty that was accompanied by having over 6,000 kids living in relative poverty, whether it was the financial uncertainty of many of my constituents not having had a decent wage rise for over 10 years, or whether it was the financial uncertainty borne by the proud shipyards of Govan being able to fill their order books. But very quickly, Madam Deputy Speaker, I was proud that I was part of a government and a friend of a Chancellor, the right honourable member for Leeds West and Pudsey, that helped to eliminate some of that uncertainty by giving the fastest wage growth in a year, much greater than had happened in the past previous 10 years, by lifting the two-child cap that took thousands of kids in my constituency out of poverty and probably benefited the local economy in my constituency to the tune of 4 million pounds, and also by securing the Type 26 frigate contract that will give certainty to Govan shipyard workers for generations to come.

But Madam Deputy Speaker, it is not only in the large policy areas that this Labour movement does its work. It is at its best when at the ground level it feels the pain of ordinary people trying to get by and not being able to live the lives that they were promised by their forefathers. And in that sense, therefore, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm very proud of the current budget and the current direction that my right honourable friend the Chancellor has taken, particularly in relation to energy bills.

We are committed through this budget to making sure that immediately 90% of my constituents will feel the benefit of £100 off their energy bills, that 100% of my constituents will now be absolved of the need to pay standing charges on their energy bills, and all of my constituents will also have VAT eliminated off their electricity bills. We cannot, no country, no government can insulate our citizens from the pressures of global markets and global conflict, but we can do as much as we can, and I believe we are doing as much as we can in regards to energy bills and making that space, creating that space for being able to live more comfortably.

06:01:54 - 06:01:56

Speaker 228

I'll happily give way.

06:01:56 - 06:02:15

Luke Morgan Evans

I thank the member for giving way, and talking about doing everything we can, the budget has gas and oil receipts as one of the ways of bringing in some of that funding. Page 93 of the ORB report explicitly says that Rosebank is banked in as being granted. Is he in support of Rosebank?

06:02:15 - 06:05:37

Zubir Ahmed

The honourable gentleman will know that this is a quasi-judicial process. It is, and it would be remiss of me to be making undertakings that my honourable friend the Secretary of State of Energy is responsible for. But I gently remind him, those calculations have been baked in for many, many years. It's not some kind of new reference to the assumptions in this year's OBR report. And the honourable gentleman knows this very, very well and is being a little bit mischievous, I think, in his questioning.

If I return to my principal point around giving breathing space, it is not only families and individuals that need breathing space, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's businesses, it's small businesses on the high street.

And I'm really proud that before this budget and during the course of this budget, we are lifting many, many more businesses on the high streets out of the need to pay business rates. Now in Scotland, honourable members may be aware that that saving will not be automatic. It is at the discretion of the Scottish Government. And I would in this chamber plead with them to make sure that the Barnett consequentials of that decision is translated into savings on business rates for ordinary high street businesses, including pubs, because the right honourable friend the Prime Minister made that undertaking during the summer to reduce business rates for music clubs and pubs. And that, as far as I know, as yet has not translated into a similar policy statement in Scotland.

And I know pubs in my constituency of Glasgow South West, which runs around many of the underground stations in Glasgow, and sometimes, you know, students and other people like to do what's called the Clockwork Orange pub crawl across these pubs, would crave and benefit from these savings. And I would urge the Scottish Government to pass them on with immediate effect. But Madam Deputy Speaker, these are all interventions that make life a little bit more bearable and easier. And I know for some members, choosing between social and personal economic security and the national security of our nation are somehow binary choices, but they are not. One very much is reliant on the other.

And that's why also we are committed to making sure that our defense spending hits the targets in 2030 and 35 that our NATO allies expect.

And again, my constituency, I'm proud is contributing to the defense of our nation, whether it's through the shipyards and building the Type 26 frigates that will be patrolling our seas to the more novel technologies and the drones that are being designed also in my constituency. And it is a moment, I think, to reflect upon the fact that we on this side of the house are proud of investing in defense. It is not taboo to invest in defense as sometimes has been espoused by the Scottish Green Party or the Scottish National Party. We should be proud that we are the forefront in Scotland of being defending our nation. And we will always invest in it.

And I'm grateful that finally the SNP has relented and also matched our funding to two defense technical colleges in Scotland to be able to defend our nation.

In closing, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would just say this, that this Prime Minister and this Chancellor, when I've spoken to them, understand Scotland. They feel the needs of Glasgow South West, and that's why the budget that they have delivered will give them breathing space for today, but also, more importantly, hope for tomorrow.

06:05:37 - 06:05:41

Speaker 229

Susan Murray.

06:05:41 - 06:09:42

Susan Murray

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a pleasure to follow the honorable member for Glasgow South West. The Chancellor has said his budget carries through the vision of the Prime Minister, with much still to come in his 10-year plan and the spending review next year. So there is still an opportunity to change the fiscal policy which could help to achieve the government's own housing targets and help councils, developers, and communities to revive town centers and bring back into use derelict and long-term empty buildings.

I'd like to start today by congratulating the Friends of Campsie High Kirk, the first group in Britain to take ownership of an A-listed heritage building through the King's and Lord Treasurer's Remembrancer ownerless property transfer scheme. It's their work that has led me to raise this issue today, and I'm incredibly proud to have them in Mid Dunbartonshire. The organization has taken a derelict A-listed church with plans to renovate it for community use. Yet nearly every piece of work they carry out on the site will be charged VAT at 20%. Until recently, Scotland's historic churches could claim back VAT on their repairs through the Listed Places of Worship Grant Scheme.

That scheme has now closed, and the fund that replaced it covers England only. The UK government says Scotland's share of the money has gone to the Scottish government, yet no fund has been set up to spend it.

So even the buildings that could once claim the 20% back are now caught. Will the Minister take up with the Scottish Government and press for a fund to be created? But it's not just community groups that face this hurdle in restoring our historic sites. Should a developer wish to restore a similar historic building as housing, they would pay VAT at 5% if the conversion qualifies, or the full 20% if it does not. Meanwhile, if they were to demolish the building and start anew, they would pay no VAT on the new homes.

The Government's explanation is that zero rate on new homes is there to stimulate the construction of new homes.

But I think the truth is that it shouldn't matter whether a home is new or not. If any building is lying long-term vacant or derelict, bringing it back to a habitable, eco-friendly condition gives us the same benefit as building a new house. On top of that, restoring a building preserves the character and heritage of an area, saves carbon by reusing existing materials rather than making and transporting new ones, and often meets less local opposition. We all know how difficult it can be to get permission to build a new home, and we all know the impact a derelict property can have on a street. HMRC has told my office that it doesn't hold figures on how much VAT it raises from building repair and restoration.

Before ruling anything out, the Treasury should be able to tell this House what the tax brings in.

So with that in mind, I have three asks of the Treasury. First, I urge the Minister to investigate and publish how much VAT is raised each year on the renovation and repair of historic buildings. Second, will the Treasury assess the case for treating renovation, repair and conversion in the same way as new build? And third, will the Treasury confirm that Scotland will benefit from its fair share of the derelict buildings fund? Our historic buildings help us make our communities what they are.

The tax system should help people save them and bring them back into use, not charge them more to repair than to build new. Thank you.

06:09:42 - 06:09:43

Speaker 231

Richard Baker.

06:09:43 - 06:14:36

Richard Baker

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, I hold the member for Aberdeenshire North and Moray East in high regard. I do. He's no longer in his place, but I thought it was very telling that he wouldn't take any intervention on his contribution because the Scottish National Party are desperate to paint the gloomiest possible picture of this budget, but their argument doesn't hold because the reality is, for Scotland and for my constituents, this budget is full of measures which are going to be very widely welcomed.

For my constituents in Glenrothes and Mid Fife, measures such as scrapping the standing charges for gas and extending the freeze on fuel duty are going to be extremely welcome. I am delighted that the budget also means pensioners will see their state pension rise by nearly five hundred pounds a year, and we've also acted to ensure pensioners only receiving that income won't have to pay income tax on it. I will obviously make the case again to ministers for the nearly eight hundred and fifty retired miners in my constituency who are members of miners' pension scheme. I do hope ministers will now act swiftly to ensure all the funds in the pension now go to retired miners. But we have to also remember that the context for every pensioner in my constituency is action to increase their pension and also action on rising energy prices, which have of course, as we approach another cold Scottish winter, been a subject of deep concern for my constituents.

And we are the £100 energy payment being introduced for households in council tax bands A to D is particularly welcome. And thank goodness the SNP actually have seen sense on one thing and are ensuring that this policy will be implemented from this government in Scotland. In my constituency, it means nine out of ten households will benefit. Vital relief in terms of the rising energy prices we face because of the global economic challenges we have.

This is the real practical support for families the Prime Minister promised and which this budget delivers. The budget not only provides breathing space in tough times, it also sets out investment which brings huge opportunities for the future of our communities in Glenrothes and Mid Fife, the prospect of skilled work and good jobs for our young people. Along with the Defence Secretary, who I thought gave an excellent speech at the start of this debate, the Chancellor has committed the funding for the defence investment plan. His decision that the contract to build the new dry docks for Faslane will be built not in a foreign shipyard but here in the UK is a wonderful opportunity for the Methil yard in my constituency, saved from closure by this government. If the new dry docks are built by the skilled workforce at Methil, this will secure the long-term future of the yard and drive their recruitment even higher.

Methil is a community with a proud industrial history but with high levels of social deprivation, and this is a wonderful opportunity for re-industrialisation in our part of Scotland.

And it's not only in defence where there's such potential to grow our local economy. We have thriving renewable energy businesses, and the decision to proceed with the Jackdaw project has been widely welcomed in the Scottish energy sector because it will provide employment in an industry whose workforce will be vital if we are to succeed in making the transition to renewables and sustain skills and employment in our energy sector.

Not only in energy, not only in defense, but the 18 million pound pledge to the University of Edinburgh to boost our national capacity to design and test our own semiconductor chips is a decision which will be warmly welcomed across the fourth in Fife, where industry leading companies such as Classic Wafer Fab and Semifab are based with highly expert staff exporting their products right across the globe. Another example how we are taking advantage of the revolution in AI to ensure it is secure and also providing the economic benefit which can be realized for many of our high-tech, high-skilled industries which are located in Scotland as well. This is a budget for breathing space, a budget to protect our economic stability, a budget for investment in the future of our communities, and I commend the Chancellor for recognizing not only the challenges we face as a country and offering families respite from them, but also the many opportunities we have to strengthen growth in our economy in the future.

06:14:36 - 06:14:38

Speaker 234

Sir John Whittingdale.

06:14:38 - 06:19:35

John Whittingdale

Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Before I turn to the budget I would just like to take this opportunity to pay tribute to Sue Holt whose death the Speaker announced to the House this morning. I'm a member of the OSCE Parliamentary Association delegation, a former leader and I've worked with Sue over quite a long period. She was always immensely cheerful and efficient and her death came as a real shock to us all and I send my condolences. Now turning to the budget at least for this one part of the budget I would like to welcome which is the continuing support being given by this government to Ukraine.

That is something which was initiated under the last government indeed over 10 years ago long before the full-scale invasion by Russia we have continued to maintain it it is a cross-party matter and therefore that support is very welcome.

But one of the reasons why it is so important that we support Ukraine is because Ukraine is our front line. And the threat to Ukraine is not just a threat to that country, it's a threat to all of us. And that is a reason why it is essential that we need to be increasing our defense expenditure now. Now, the Chancellor has recommitted to the 3% of GDP by 2030, but that is still some way off. And we've heard from the Secretary of State about the immediacy of the threat.

And it is a matter of some concern that whilst we're still debating how we are going to get to 3%, our allies like Denmark, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Norway, Poland are already exceeding that 3% and planning to spend more. And perhaps one of the reasons why we have not been able as yet to explain how we are going to meet that target is because the essential measures to fund it, in other words, addressing the welfare budget, again have been ducked by this, by this government. We await the outcome of the reviews by the Minister and by Sir Alan Milburn. But in the meantime, we are now reaching a position where 6.7 million people are now claiming out-of-work benefits. That is creating a situation which is not just unaffordable, it is actually immoral that so many of working age are out of work and instead are living on benefits.

And we have a situation in this country where all the economic signals for the long term are heading in the wrong direction. Borrowing going up, our national debt already standing at a trillion, three trillion dollars and scheduled to increase further. Tax levels are the highest in our history. And regulation, which the Chancellor claims he wants to bring down, we understand today that the Employment Rights Bill, according to the OBR, is going to result in unemployment of over 5% next year. That situation has the effect that it destroys incentives to work, it drives away investment, it causes entrepreneurs to leave the country.

It is an unsustainable situation, and yet nothing in this budget does anything to give confidence that those things are going to be reversed.

now I would quickly like to refer to a couple of measures. I raised with the Prime Minister in his first statement the situation in our high streets where so many businesses have been hit by not just the increase in business rates but the increase in national insurance contributions, in energy costs, in the minimum wage. and whilst the measure to increase the threshold for business relief is of some small help, it is nothing like sufficient to help those number those businesses which are struggling to survive. I I regret that there was no mention of VAT which was something that UK hospitality have identified as the critical measure which could help because they are having to compete with countries like France, Spain and Italy who levy rates half of those here.

I want very quickly to mention hair salons, which the Chancellor talked about. They are so often facing unfair competition by an exactly identical-looking salon next door where the chairs are rented out and actually staffed by people classing themselves as self-employed. That is actually depriving the Treasury of proper revenue whilst also creating unfair competition. I hope that's something that the Treasury will listen to. I'm sorry that yet again it is the gambling sector that is used as the sort of cash cow, and I refer the House to my entry in the members' register, but by increasing the tax on gambling yet again, the effect is going to actually hit our high streets even harder because a lot of betting shops are going to be driven out of business.

06:19:35 - 06:19:36

Will he give way?

06:19:36 - 06:19:57

Mark Francois

I'm grateful. He's been a staunch defender of Ukraine for many years in this House. So would he agree with what President Zelenskyy said yesterday, as reported in The Sun, when he advised this government to prioritise UK defence spending and to do so without further delay? Does Zelenskyy know something the government doesn't?

06:19:36 - 06:19:36

Yes, of course I'll give way.

06:19:57 - 06:21:06

John Whittingdale

I'm extremely grateful to my constituent neighbour for making an excellent point and giving me another minute. He is absolutely right that President Zelenskyy once again has spoken words that if only the government would listen. And it is absolutely right that we should increase our support and expenditure on defence. Finally, he and I both represent relatively rural constituencies.

Finally, he and I both represent relatively rural constituencies and again I regret the fact that the budget had no mention of the harm being done to the agricultural sector through the family farming tax, nor did it provide any help to those constituents and I have many, I know he does as well, who are off the grid and rely on heating oil. They will not benefit by the abolition of the standing charges and yet they have faced huge increases. Perhaps the only thing to celebrate in this budget really is the fact that the Chancellor didn't listen to those behind him who wanted to go even further with a wealth tax and a mansion tax and an increase in capital gains tax and long may that continue that he listens to us and not to them.

06:21:07 - 06:23:12

Liz Twist

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the opportunity to speak in today's debate on the budget and to talk about some of the things that will affect my constituents.

This budget does indeed bring a breathing space needed by families, workers, and small businesses across the country, built on the bedrock of fiscal discipline. And helping families to deal with high living costs. And most noticeably, of course, I look at energy costs. And across Blaydon and Consett constituency, over 92% of households will benefit from the household energy payment, delivering £100 directly to help with bills this winter for households, alongside the extension of 0% VAT on electricity. And many of these houses, Madam Deputy Speaker, are of course poor quality and poorly insulated, so it's particularly welcome.

For local motorists, tradespeople and commuters, extending the 5p fuel duty cut keeps daily costs down, and many constituents have written to me about this. Now, I recently heard when talking to the North East Chamber of Commerce that our local businesses were concerned about operating with the current system of taxes. For our high street businesses, the £1 billion business rates package ensures that over 52% of retail, hospitality and leisure properties across the North East will pay no business rates at all next year, giving independent traders room to plan and room to invest.

Now, alongside the 35% business rates relief for pubs, the new guest beer legislation gives local landlords the right to serve locally brewed beers on tap, supporting independent North East brewers like Firebrick Brewery in Blaydon and Thirsty Moose in Ryton, who have all spoken to me about these issues.

06:23:12 - 06:23:36

Anna Dixon

I thank my honourable friend for giving way, and like her, I have small breweries in my own constituency, including the Saltare Brewery, the Goose Eye Brewery and Salt. Does she agree with me that with rising energy costs, this £110 million annual alcohol duty relief for small brewers is very welcome from the Chancellor?

06:23:36 - 06:27:34

Liz Twist

And there are indeed welcome moves in this budget, and I know that the guest beer was one that was particularly wished for.

So turning to regional growth, I warmly welcome the new 1.5 billion borrowing facility for mayoral strategic authorities announced yesterday. In Gateshead, these devolved borrowing powers will allow us to move forward with the transformation of Gateshead Quays development. Backed by 24 million pounds in enabling funding from North East Mayor Kim McGuinness, essential site preparation and infrastructure work can now begin. Once these loans allow us to start investing in full, Gateshead will gain a world-class venue featuring a 12,500-seater arena and international conference centre. And the North East Combined Authority estimates that this ambitious development will attract over a million visitors every year, generate a 70 million pound annual boost to our local economy, and create 2,000 good local jobs.

Now, I want to set the record straight on the international investment summit. The budget announces that the next international investment summit in spring 2027 will take place in Newcastle. Madam Deputy Speaker, I must gently correct the record for the Treasury. As the Chancellor announced in his speech yesterday, that major summit will actually be hosted on the south side of the Tyne, right in Gateshead. I look forward to seeing Tyneside on the global stage, and as we prepare to welcome global investors, my firm hope is that the investments announced at the summit stay directly in Gateshead and the surrounding area, helping to further fund our local regeneration and economic growth, and benefiting my constituents on the Gateshead side and beyond, to opportunities in employment and other jobs.

So it will affect the whole of Gateshead, not just the Quayside. Now, there's a little-noticed measure in there about preventative P-D-O, I think it is, and so in the announcement, and I particularly welcome the creation of ring-fenced preventative expenditure, P-D-O, establishing a spending category for early intervention at spending review to make later stages. Now, we don't have much detail on this, but I'm going to get my bid in quite early, and what I want to see is that we see an investment in preventative measures which affects all departments for suicide prevention and for mental health.

This is a really important issue and one, Madam Deputy Speaker, that I come back to regularly. And I warn the Treasury bench that I will be referring to this many times in the future so that you don't lose the message. So if you could take a note now, that would be helpful. Now, extensive research conducted by Samaritans and Mind demonstrates that every single suicide prevented saves our economy roughly 1.46 million. We can't reduce lives to figures on a spreadsheet, but it shows that investment in preventative work on mental health and on suicide prevention is well worth the money.

Now, across County Durham, 878 local properties will benefit from the real terms business rates freeze, alongside 377 in Gateshead. And to help our young people gain high-quality skills and secure good careers, new apprenticeship brokerage funding and expanding oral apprenticeship services will support businesses and SMEs to hire and train the next generation. And the derelict buildings fund too will help us in both sides of my constituency to make a difference to our high streets.

06:27:34 - 06:27:35

Karen Bradley.

06:27:35 - 06:32:37

Karen Bradley

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's an honour to follow the honourable lady from Blaydon and Consett. And can I join my right honourable friend from Maldon in paying tribute to Sue Holt? I was in Strasbourg with her only a few weeks ago when she was taken ill, and it was a great shock to all of us to learn about what had happened to her.

I want to cover matters in the budget that relate to my constituency, the Home Affairs Committee, and also my constituency. But I realize I have limited time, so I will race ahead. And it's pretty quick, in fact, on the Home Affairs side of things, because there wasn't very much in the budget about the Home Affairs side of things. In fact, there was only one mention in the speech, which was £15 million over three years for a misogyny prevention fund, which we'll wait to see what that actually involves. But I do worry that priority is being given to perpetrators, and where is the money for victims?

Because actually, a victim-centered approach on violence against women and girls is essential. And the government has already said that a billion pounds needs to be spent on tackling violence against women and girls during the life of the strategy. So, in the Red Book, I think it says that the government is prioritizing £55 million of funding over two years to accelerate delivery of the violence against women and girls strategy.

55 million out of a billion again does not sound too much. The things that weren't mentioned but actually are related to home affairs, two inquiries that we're conducting at the moment, one on workplace-based immigration. I'm interested in the work that the government is doing on apprenticeships etc., but I would urge them to look at the work we did with Demos on a piece of deliberative democracy looking at the public's attitude to workplace-based immigration, because there they will find some really interesting insights around the need to prioritize upskilling UK workers to take job vacancies, not just looking to overseas to fill vacancies. And also we are doing a piece of work on the impact of serious and organized crime on local neighborhoods.

And it's really interesting what my right honourable friend from Maldon said about the high street, because what we've seen is the hollowing out of the high street as a result of some of the measures that the government has taken on national insurance and business rates, etc., has left a vacuum which is being filled by organised criminality. And they are filling our high street in a way that is inappropriate and we don't want it. So I would urge the government to deal with that. Moving to my constituency issues, I welcome the £100 for A to D council taxpayers. We have a disproportionately high number of bands A to D in Staffordshire Moorlands and so there will be more affected by that than perhaps other constituencies.

But there was nothing on those that rely on heating oil. And they won't benefit from the abolition of the standing charge for gas. They really do need help.

And as we come into winter, the numbers that are being quoted to me about the price to fill a tank for heating oil is astonishing. Again, I join my right honourable friend in commenting about there was nothing about hospitality and tourism. As the Member of Parliament for Alton Towers and other great local attractions, including the Peak Wildlife Park, I know how much they have - they've welcomed the reduction in VAT over the summer, but how much they want to see that made permanent. And also there was nothing for farmers. And it would have been very heartening if the government - if the Chancellor had mentioned something about the family farm tax to give farmers the respite that they need.

Turning to other matters, on local government reorganization, this is something that the government tells us we need to have in order that we can benefit from so many of the measures in the budget.

I would just say again, as I said in the statement, if we're going to have a mayor, we don't need to reorganize the structure of our local government as well. Let let that time and effort by officials and councillors be spent on delivering services and let the mayors have that strategic overview. That I think would be a much better approach. I also want to raise a project called the Peak Cluster, which is a proposal to enable the cement industry to continue in the Peak District by carbon capture and transporting the carbon from the Peak District to Morecambe Bay. This is of great concern.

Firstly, how much carbon is going to be emitted in building these pipelines that are going to go underneath the Peak District, Cheshire and others to get out to Morecambe Bay where the carbon can then be put into a empty gas field. It would surely just be better to allow the cement industry to continue in the United Kingdom producing cement in as clean a way as possible without the need to build this pipeline and all the environmental damage that's going to cause. My final point was to welcome the comments that were made around new battery storage and solar farms needing to be connected to the grid immediately. To start with, that will be very welcome for many of my constituents.

06:32:37 - 06:32:42

Speaker 217

I'm calling Sam Carling, after which I'll be calling Steve Darling. Sam.

06:32:42 - 06:37:42

Samuel Carling

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. High energy costs are one of the biggest issues facing my constituents, as well as the small businesses our economy needs to thrive.

So I'm delighted that in this budget, the Chancellor has announced that standing gas charges, which we all know just aren't fair, will be removed. That comes on top of cost of living policies already announced by the Prime Minister, such as removing VAT from electricity bills, a measure which the Chancellor has now extended, on top of a direct £100 household energy payment to eligible Band A to Band D households, and on top of the £150 taken off energy bills by measures at the last budget. These things add up. And focusing on energy costs is the progressive thing to do. The poorest 10% of households pay the greatest share of their money on energy, at over 12%.

And so these measures provide support to those most in need, the families and particularly the children in poverty in Northwest Cambridgeshire and across the country. Indeed, the whole budget reflects progressive principles. 80% of households, all bar the top 20%, will have more money in their pockets from this budget. The ninth decile breaks about even, and then it's only the top 10% that are being asked to pay that little more, and it really is only a little more, 0.1% of their income.

This is very much the Labour way. But all the support we are providing must of course be paid for, and a key part of that will come from delivering growth. And we are delivering growth. Our economy was the joint fastest growing in the G7 in the first half of this year. And that comes alongside the news that the IMF forecast that we are set to deliver a bigger reduction in borrowing over the next few years than any other G20 country.

And we're one of only two G7 countries to cut our deficit this year, despite all of the global headwinds that we face. And in many ways I feel sorry for the Conservatives here because they have a very difficult job of reading a red book full of good news and trying to make it sound bad. And I welcome the discussion in the budget about lowering business costs, both through business rates reliefs and freezes.

We've heard a lot of criticism that there's nothing in this budget for hospitality businesses, but about 50% of retail, hospitality and leisure businesses in the East of England won't be paying any business rates at all. And the reforms to regulation will be saving businesses up to 5.6 billion pounds a year if we hit the target that we have set out. Can I encourage the government to ensure that that also applies to our life sciences sector? I've spoken previously in this chamber about options for reforming clinical trial regulation such that we save business and NHS time and money and attract more investment, not by necessarily cutting regulation, but by streamlining it and reducing duplicated effort. There's an awful lot of different regulators that look after clinical trials at the moment, and I do think there's a lot of potential to streamline some of that down and really save a lot of money and just bring in more investment into that area.

I want to talk briefly now about one more area I would have liked to see more work on and which I hope the government might consider going forward in the spending review. And that is Gift Aid and the tax exemptions given to charities. There's very little scrutiny of that expenditure, which is sizeable, with over five billion pounds of reliefs for charities in the tax year to April 2026. And of course, the vast majority of charities spend that money well and on good causes, and that is to be commended. But due to fundamental problems in the law, it is far too easy for organisations that provide very little or no benefit to the public, or in some cases even active harm, to obtain charity status and in so doing claim public money through Gift Aid and tax exemptions.

And that damages the whole sector and those within it that do such good work.

For example, in July 2023, the Guardian reported that the Kasna Charitable Trust transferred 5.7 million pounds to support an illegal settlement in the occupied West Bank. In theory, therefore, the UK taxpayer could have funded an illegal settlement by over a million pounds in gift aid through that transaction alone. The fact that was permissible under our current system clearly shows that major reform is needed, including to Treasury rules, and that significant amounts of taxpayer money could be saved because that's not an isolated example. There are many similar organizations, taxpayer-funded charities, that are preaching horrendous misogyny, homophobia, and other hatred. That's a monumental waste of our constituents' money, which we could be redirecting both towards our public services and also to tackle violence against women and girls at the same time.

I know that's a priority for this government.

It's showing that through measures in this budget, like the 15 million pounds announced to create a misogyny prevention fund, which will have a real impact. But measures like that are hugely undermined when the chari-, the taxpayer is subsidising major organisations who, for example, as reported was earlier this week, um, there was a mosque in whom, in which preachers were advising husbands that they could hit their wives. I also became aware just yesterday of a church with awful posts on their website denying the existence of marital rape and all sorts of other horrendous misogyny. That one again had an income of 5 million pounds, a million of that could be taxpayer funding. So that has got to stop and I implore Treasury ministers to consider what options they have to ensure it does.

06:37:42 - 06:37:44

Speaker 235

Steve Darling.

06:37:44 - 06:41:46

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Torbay has one very sad accolade that it is the most deprived constituency that has a Liberal Democrat MP.

And so therefore the cost of living crisis is close to my heart. The fact that the government reduced fuel bills for some people is welcome, but it is a small step and there were other opportunities on the table that the Liberal Democrats highlighted that could have helped people with the fuel crisis that is set to bite really deep come the new year when those bills go up. Also, I'm only too aware of the challenges that people have getting out and about in a rural county such as Devon, and further support that the Liberal Democrats identified sadly were left on the table. As our spokesperson said earlier on in the debate, it is about growing the economy, unshackling ourselves by using what opportunities there are for us and not choosing to keep to those red lines is extremely important.

On the upside, I'd like to celebrate, use this opportunity to celebrate the fact that one of our, the oldest pub in Torquay is set to reopen tonight, the Hole in the Wall. And I'm and I'm delighted that my uncle Drew Millin will be performing there on a Thursday and a Sunday night, and I wish I was home in time to be joining them. But on a more negative note, I'm disappointed as I'm sure many others are within this chamber that the temporary cut to VAT that we campaigned for to help our hospitality industry and tourism was sadly not part of the budget.

That opportunity still sits there and it would give us a boost in a number of different ways. Again, as colleagues have already highlighted, the National Insurance hike has hit that industry. Even raising the levels where it kicks in would be helpful, particularly for NEETs and helping young people into those opportunities of their first job in the hospitality industry. Again, hospitality is in fear of the overnight levy. And this is the irony is that you look at the VAT rates that you're seeing in Italy, Spain or France and it's 10%.

Here it's 20%. So applying an overnight levy is quite perverse in those situations unless you have that VAT cut that then puts us more on a level playing field.

And I've even had scouting associations who run a campsite in Torbay concerned that scout groups and similar youth facilities could be hit by such a visitor levy. My number one priority as the MP for Torbay is Torbay Hospital and the rebuild of it. And so it's, Madam Chair, it's somewhat disturbing that only 190 million pounds was added in to the budget to support our NHS. That doesn't even cover the rebuild of Torbay Hospital that is desperately needed. So I would hope that the Chancellor would continue to push hard on supporting our NHS.

In conclusion, I would like to welcome the changes that have been made, the taper that's set, that is set to be applied to Carer's Allowance. That is a significant step in the right direction.

However, a four-year delay in this implementation is is a bit of an indictment on the DWP that it's going to take that long. And then finally, a one pound for pound approach of the taper of taking back earnings over this amount. Surely there's an opportunity to be more generous in the long term as this emerges. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:41:46 - 06:41:47

Dr Jeevun Sandher.

06:41:47 - 06:46:19

Jeevun Sandher

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm going to give a slightly different budget speech today because I think this budget we have here shows a very different, not just in material terms as to what this government is doing, but also a moral difference between our two sides. Because of us on this side of the chamber, it's always been clear, indeed our founding values are, that every single person in this country should be able to live a decent life. And out of that we build prosperity for all. And for others, that only some should be able to afford a decent life.

And for others, that only some should be able to afford a decent life, a vision that's not just left us materially poorer, but morally poorer as well. Now Madam Deputy Speaker, I've written budgets in the Treasury in Somaliland, I've seen really difficult budgets, and make no mistake, this was a difficult budget at an incredibly difficult time. We face existential challenges, an affordability crisis, a burning planet, war in Europe, all of it coming at the same time. And underneath it all, a question that underlies our politics: will we be able, will we stand together, stronger together to meet this moment, or will we fall apart, divided, weaker and poorer? And for us, we made our choice in this budget: that we will see every single person, every single family, and every single place do even better than before.

Of families, of workers, of business and yes, of government working in partnership to create prosperity. That is why in this budget we reduced energy bills so families could afford the basics, yes, but also because we know when families have more in their pockets, they spend more down the shops and that helps their local businesses. We help businesses as well, not just with the things that they require, the roads, the skills, the investment in energy, but on top of that as well, the rates cut, giving them a bit of breathing space as we go into what we all know will be an incredibly difficult winter ahead.

And of course, for government, being able to raise the funds that we need in the fairest way possible, yes, but also in the way that does not damage prosperity. And that is why we have a windfall tax, yes on the banks, who have made huge profits in the past few years, but also windfall tax on oil and gas giants. Because when they're making tens of billions of pounds from a war in Ukraine, we make the choice that says we will use some of that money to help get down bills for people in our constituencies, in our communities, and yes, across our country. We don't just know this works because it is working, because we are the fastest growing economy in the G7. We know it works because it's what our past tells us as well.

We know that it was Bevan's alliance of labour and capital that helped win the Second World War. We know that Attlee built common prosperity based upon common sacrifice, all of it from common endeavour. Blair and Brown who renewed a nation.

All of that built upon this fundamental ideal that we hold in our founding membership cards and indeed today, that we achieve more by standing together through our common endeavour. But, Madam Deputy Speaker, there are those who believe differently from us, who believe that we should be allowing oil and gas giants and banks to make huge record windfall profits and leave it there, and not try to help every single person in this country. We've also seen that Reform, who support racist thugs, masked people on our streets, will use those kind of tactics to distract from the fact that they want to give their crypto-billionaire mates tax cuts. That is who we stand against and that is the ideal that we stand against on these benches. Madam Deputy Speaker, we choose a different path.

The British people are better than that, better than the anger, the division, but also the penury that it leads to. We know on our side what we have always known and seen throughout our history, that we build prosperity for all, that we stand together when each of us can stand tall, that a nation is only strong as each of its people have a stake in it, and they have a stake in that nation if life is affordable for all. That is the choice we have made in our history, in our greatest moments. That was the choice that helped us win a war, rebuild it after, rebuild our nation after that war, and it was the same choice that's seen us build prosperity in our past, indeed prosperity in our present. That is what this budget represents, that's the choice that we make, and Madam Deputy Speaker, every single one of us is so proud of it.

06:46:19 - 06:46:22

Speaker 239

Thank you.

06:46:22 - 06:46:24

Speaker 238

Point of order, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:46:24 - 06:46:26

Speaker 237

Points of order, Sam Carling.

06:46:26 - 06:46:41

Samuel Carling

Thank you. It's just come to my attention that the member for Rayleigh and Wickford made a particularly nasty age-related comment during my speech. And I just wanted to see if perhaps, a, if that was in order, and b, if he might like to say that so that his young constituents can hear what he thinks of them.

06:46:41 - 06:46:45

Speaker 240

Further to that point of order, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:46:45 - 06:46:58

Speaker 217

I thank the honourable member for his point of order. I did not hear any comments in the chamber and it's really a matter not for the chair. I didn't hear it. Point of order, Mark Francois.

06:46:58 - 06:47:09

Mark Francois

If I've caused any offence, I'm sorry, but I was reacting to the fact that the honourable gentleman effectively said that the people on these benches couldn't read, which I would humbly suggest is not very polite.

06:47:09 - 06:47:30

Speaker 217

I thank the honourable member for his point of order, but that is clearly not a matter for the chair, it's a, it's a matter of debate. But I would just ask members yet again to treat each other with courtesy and respect that we expect in this chamber, that we expect in this chamber. I now call Bob Blackman.

06:47:30 - 06:52:35

Bob Blackman

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and a pleasure to, to follow the honourable colleague opposite. The overriding question after the Chancellor sat down yesterday was, is that it? And indeed, most budgets manage to survive 24 hours before they fall apart.

His budget yesterday lasted about 24 minutes before it fell apart, as the leader of the opposition literally eviscerated it, quite rightly. And indeed, the verdict this morning suggests that living standards are going to fall during the duration of this government. And indeed, that over the 2010-2020 period, household income increased by 12%. In this decade, it's likely to only increase by 2%. That demonstrates that this government and this Chancellor is making Britain poorer.

We have to remember as well that there are baked-in tax increases from the previous Chancellor that are kicking in now. And I want to look at four particular areas of the budget where there are missed opportunities. First, for young people, as my honourable friend the member for North Cotswolds pointed out, there's nothing in this budget for young people. There's a million young people not in education, training, or education or work.

There could have been an opportunity to reduce national insurance contributions for those aged who are recent graduates under 25. No action. As a result, graduate unemployment is dramatically up. There could have been action on reducing the amount of interest that ex-students pay on their student loans. That was promised but not delivered.

And the energy costs, for example, a lot of young people in London will share houses in bands E to F. Those young people will get no relief from the hundred pound drop in the ocean energy costs that's dished out. What there are are clearly taxes on savers, taxes on banks, taxes on landlords.

That means that rents will go up, which means that young people will end up paying the price. So indeed for most landlords there is a problem because they can't sell their properties because of the inflated stamp duty that applies, and therefore the amount of supply will reduce. I also note that the issues around smoking or cessation of smoking were not mentioned once in the budget. But unbelievably, smoking cessation in the National Health Service is being cut. And there are still 4.9 million smokers out there who desperately want to quit, but they will not get the support under this government that they desperately need.

That costs the economy 53.2 billion pounds every year through lost productivity, healthcare, social care, and smoking-related fires. So ladies and gentlemen, Madam Deputy Speaker, it is a big issue here that young people are being hit, older people are being hit.

I welcome the extra money on enabling every rough sleeper to have a roof over their head. The commitment was, of course, that they'd be taken off the streets before Christmas. It's now watered down. They'll be given an offer of somewhere to sleep, but at the same time, the number of people who are homeless or rough sleeping is actually increasing. So, far from dealing with the problem, the government is not actually addressing it properly.

It's good news that the Vagrancy Act has been scratched and we celebrated that two days ago, and there's much more we can do to help people who are in this extremely vulnerable position.

As I mentioned earlier this week, we still await the implementation of the Supported Housing Regulatory Oversight Act that I implemented three years ago that would help vulnerable people from being prevented from being exploited. There are concerns straight away on one of the government's moves to bring empty buildings back into use. Now the key there is who's going to pay the cost? Where's the money coming from when councils have already got overstretched budgets? And when dealing with the local authorities, the £100 council tax rebate doesn't fix the core spending issues.

For those of us that follow these things, the average increase at council tax last year at Band D was £111. So the £100 that some people are going to get back will disappear when the council tax increases come in this year.

So indeed the problem now at local authority level is that the demand-led services, which of course are not in control of local authorities, continue to spiral. I welcome the fact that the government has given a three-year settlement, but it's still not going to be sufficient and in many cases it's going to lead to huge council tax increases and cuts in services. So all in all, Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget is a series of missed opportunities that could have been so easy to solve.

06:52:35 - 06:52:41

Speaker 217

I call Adam George, after which I'll be reducing the time limit to three minutes. Adam George.

06:52:41 - 06:56:24

Adam Jogee

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, very grateful to you. Despite me having edited lots out, but I will try and now read through my scribbles. In this budget, His Majesty's government is taking the necessary steps to make everyday life that little bit easier for people back home in Newcastle-under-Lyme, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank goodness.

And those steps and that determination stand in stark contrast to the chaos, instability and nonsense that we see at Staffordshire County Council. This week we received news that Staffordshire County Council is onto its fourth leader at County Hall since the county council elections in May 2025. It's an uninspiring and unfunny game of musical chairs, and my constituents in Newcastle-under-Lyme deserve much better, Madam Deputy Speaker. Our community is a great place and is home to good, hardworking, decent people. They deserve every little bit of help announced yesterday to make life that little bit more manageable, and there is much to welcome.

I'm pleased that more than 40,000 homes in my community will receive the £100 payment that we've heard from colleagues across the House to help with their energy bills, extended the 0% rate of VAT on electricity bills until July 2027, finally acting on gas standing charges, and there was more good news on fuel duty too.

We're taking more businesses out of paying business rates by increasing the small business rates relief threshold, important, too, for retail, hospitality, and leisure businesses in my community. In fact, these changes, Madam Deputy Speaker, will mean that around 52% of all retail, hospitality, and leisure properties in the West Midlands will now no longer pay business rates at all. This will go some way to helping the much-loved and much-used pubs and restaurants in our town centre and communities, as well as boosting our local economy and keeping local people in work. We saw action on paternity leave, which will make the system fairer, that's excellent, and I welcome the £55 million worth of funding that's available, that will be made available to accelerate the delivery of the violence against women and girls strategy, that's really important stuff.

And I look forward to working with the Chancellor and colleagues from coalfield communities to finally deliver the justice that our coal miners deserve. And whilst I will never shy away, Madam Deputy Speaker, from my concerns with local government reform and the impact that it would have in my community, I am delighted that the government has announced that a new mayoral strategic authority for Stoke-on-Trent and Staffordshire is on its way. This will bring power, it'll bring investment and decision-making closer to those of us who live, learn and work in Newcastle-under-Lyme, and that's to be welcomed. And just seeing I've got a bit more time, Madam Deputy Speaker. Since I was elected, I've seen, I've seen up close, it would, it would, it would do a disservice to my constituents not to use the time, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Since I, since I was elected, I have seen up close how our local authorities have passed the buck at every stage, and my constituents have suffered because of it.

And these changes now mean, with a mayoral strategic authority, that we have the opportunity to fix a broken transport system, to invest in our young people, and to boost the resilience of our region, all with our local communities at the heart of that process. Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget is one part of helping communities like mine recover from years of delay, dither, and deindustrialization. We owe it to the hardworking, skilled people who built our town, and the young people who will move it forward, to keep pushing for better. We have a proud history, a strong identity, and huge potential. And with this budget, we have begun the journey of reinvesting power and control into communities like mine.

And I'll continue to do everything I can as a Newcastle-under-Lyme voice here to make sure that their voice is heard as loudly and proudly too. And there's a minute and 23 seconds back to you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

06:56:24 - 06:56:26

Speaker 241

On a three-minute time limit, Dr. Luke Evans.

06:56:26 - 06:59:22

Luke Morgan Evans

Oh, thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I had to check that the Chancellor had said what I thought he had, and it was referred to again today by the Defence Secretary, for saying this is the first 100 days of a government and a new 10-year plan. Well, by my calculation, the government has been in for 847 days, with the third budget being delivered yesterday and over a quarter of the way through the last 10-year plan. So rather than this being a baby budget and a fledgling government, it's more an adolescent government. And this really is a bumfluff budget.

It's got wispy bits, it's got patchy bits, but actually no one really knows what it is, where it's going, and even if it should be there. And you can see that by the fact that we've had 98 announcements within it, one of the records, but also per value for those projects, it's also the lowest on record. Now I was pleased when I saw the budget that there were some bits that I've been working on that are finally coming into fruition. First of all, pensioners being taken out of paying tax on their state pension. Also, the freeze in fuel duty.

But these are the kind of things that were already warned about and put in by a Labour government, a hole dug by a Labour government that they've had to half fill. And this is exactly what we see with the NEETs situation. Young people in record unemployment, especially when we compare it to the EU average, over a million people not being able to get through into their jobs.

And what does the government do? Well, it put on that toxic concoction of tax increases, red tape, and now it turns around and says we'll give you £3,000 to take someone on. Well, get out the way. It'd be far simpler to let businesses take on and grow as they need. And the same applies for the hospitality industry, the leisure industry.

It's welcome that the government has made some changes here on their rates. But of course, remember they took away the support in the first place and put up the rates and added the toxic concoction in on top. So this is the hole that's been half filled.

And we see it time and time again. We often hear about the money that went into the NHS, but also remember it was taken away on the jobs tax that hit the likes of hospices, care homes, GPs, pharmacies, all feeling it. And even with the energy aspect, a hundred pounds has been given, but we know that Ofgem say the cap is going to be up over four hundred pounds increase. And remember, Labour promised three hundred pounds lower bills when they came into office. So I hope we do see this beard grow into some full bushy shape.

Now whether it's Keir Starmer's continuation or Andy Burnham's new direction...

06:59:22 - 06:59:28

Speaker 245

The honourable gentleman knows better than to refer to the Prime Minister by name. Dr Luke Evans.

06:59:28 - 06:59:36

Luke Morgan Evans

Forgive me. The member for Macclesfield and his new direction with a lovely new moustache.

06:59:36 - 06:59:38

Speaker 243

Nadia Whittome.

06:59:38 - 07:02:32

Nadia Whittome

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome many of the measures in the budget, policies to lower energy bills and the food shop, support for our high streets, that every penny of the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme surplus will go to former miners, and our continued commitment to support Ukraine's defenses. The government is absolutely right to double the fund to end rough sleeping, and the extra 1.5 billion for 10,000 social affordable homes is very welcome. I'm glad that the government is tackling this issue with such ambition. However, if we are to reverse 40 years of neoliberalism, we must apply that same ambition to every area where people are struggling.

We've got the deepest poverty levels in 30 years. Rents and mortgages, food prices and bills are spiraling and wages simply are not keeping pace.

Despite the increase in funding in the in recent years, public services are still under severe pressure. We cannot expect people to endure this fall in living standards to keep going without while the super-rich get richer. Now, I recognise that the government's in a difficult position as a result of the global economy, but it's the government's job to shield people from those shocks and to build stronger protections for the future. And that is why we must be bolder in taxing wealth. We could fairly raise billions of pounds to fund our public services, to strengthen social security and to renationalise essentials like water and energy.

Now, I welcome measures to tax banks and to raise property income tax, but we must go further, including impactful measures like reforming capital gains tax. The current system encourages people to convert labour income into capital gains, hoard wealth, and leave the UK without paying their fair share. This could raise 20 billion pounds a year, enough to fund a national care service. We could expand national insurance contributions to cover investment income and partnerships, that could raise 6 billion pounds a year, funding local housing allowance rates increasing. And we could replace council tax and stamp duty with a proportional property tax, that could raise 5.6 billion pounds a year, leaving most people better off.

And of course an annual wealth tax at 2% for individuals who have wealth over 10 million pounds, that could raise 24 billion pounds a year. As the Chancellor said, we need fresh hope for the future, but hope cannot come from words alone.

We cannot paper over the cracks in a rigged economic system. And it's this Labour government's duty to fundamentally transform our economy so that it's just, resilient, and shifts wealth and power back to working class people.

07:02:32 - 07:02:35

Speaker 246

Christine Jardine.

07:02:35 - 07:05:28

Christine Jardine

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a pleasure to follow the honourable member from Nottingham East. It's fair to say that all budgets are keenly awaited, speculated upon, and then scrutinized in great detail. Some herald landmark decisions like the initial COVID response package in March 2020.

Others live in infamy, like the mini-budget which crashed the market in 2022. But this one, this one is more difficult, because to categorize it, coming as it does at a time when the unpredictability of the White House and Trump's provocation of foreign wars creates an instability both in the international markets and for families here in the UK, and massive uncertainty, which is why the 15 billion for Ukraine is so important for theirs, for ours, and for Europe's defenses. But there's also much more I welcome in this budget, and partly because this is not the time for disagreeing for disagreeing's sake or point scoring. The people of this country have massive problems facing them with energy prices and the cost of living, and it is down to us to work together to fix them.

So any measures to bring down the crippling cost of energy bills and remove the unfairness of gas standing charges and give families a little headroom in the cost of living crisis should be endorsed. And we must remember that while supermarket shelves are filling with luxuries for too many people, this winter will be about keeping warm and keeping the children fed. And for businesses, they will also struggle. So I was delighted to see funding from gambling and vape shops to support other high street businesses, and to ask the banks that the British taxpayer who bailed them out two decades ago can now expect the favour to be returned. And it'll be no surprise to anyone in this place that the impetus to create a better working relationship with the EU is one that I heartily endorse.

As I do the 18 million pounds for advanced chip development led by Edinburgh University and the 6 million for Glasgow's Scottish Events Campus. But I worry, as most Scots do here, that many of the measures in this budget, for which there will be 600 million pounds of consequentials for Scotland, will disappear into that black hole created by the Scottish Government and the 5 billion pound shortfall the budget now faces. But the Chancellor said yesterday that this was a Labour budget for the worker, the sole trader, the parent at the school gate, the young person desperate to start their first job or business. Those are the people who will decide which category this budget falls into. They are the ones who will decide whether their lives are better.

And when we come out of this storm that the Chancellor talked about, we will see whether this tanker, which will take a long time to turn around, whether it is facing in a direction that the families in this country will welcome. Thank you.

07:05:28 - 07:05:29

Chris Hinchliff.

07:05:29 - 07:08:22

Chris Hinchliff

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In our era of perma-meta-polycrisis, the decisions the Chancellor has taken to provide our country with a little breathing space will be welcome news to many of my constituents. The longer-term question that remains is what we mean by good growth, because looking back over the last two decades, it's proven perfectly possible for GDP growth to happen and yet for almost everyone's lives to simultaneously get harder. Our country will drift until politicians are able to give a meaningful definition of good growth that the whole country can strive for and mobilize around. Fortunately, Madam Deputy Speaker, we don't have to reinvent this wholly anew for ourselves.

The greatest economic mind our country has ever produced, John Maynard Keynes, has left us many of the answers that we have been fumbling for.

Nearly 100 years ago, he warned that a focus on the wrong priorities would keep us forever in a pit of want. In other words, chasing the chimera of infinite and exponential increases in consumption completely misses the point of what economic policy should achieve. From Keynes's time to today, there has been nearly a six-fold increase in UK GDP per capita. We have more than enough wealth to ensure everyone of our constituents is meaningfully employed, can afford decent food, is well housed, and yet hardship, reliance on food banks and the housing crisis don't just persist, but in many ways continue to worsen. Madam Deputy Speaker, when Keynes wrote about the economic possibilities for his generation's grandchildren, I don't think this is what he had in mind.

We may have a growing surplus of AI slop, we have all the poisonous social media one could possibly want to consume, and we have the jolly good fun of casino capitalism that doesn't actually produce anything.

But what we lack is safe, comfortable, and genuinely affordable homes for millions of people. What we lack is food that is both affordable and nutritious for all, and what we lack almost everywhere outside London is a public transport network that can reliably get you from where you are to where you need to be. And the reason for this economic failure is straightforward. We have not had the self-confidence and determination to mobilize our enormous resources to actually meet our fundamental problems. Keynes was absolutely right when he argued that we already have all the resources and technical means to erase economic need in our country.

What we have lacked is the organization to use them. There are literally trillions of pounds managed by UK pension funds and asset management schemes. If we directed just a fraction of this to investing in our actual priorities, our country could finally hop off the nauseating merry-go-round chasing growth that endlessly forces us to make trade-offs which have brought our natural world to the brink of collapse.

And I will end on this, Madam Deputy Speaker. The fundamental fact about all our lives is that they are transient. The promise of consuming more every year than the last is irrelevant to making the most of the time we are each allotted.

07:08:22 - 07:08:23

Sir Julian Lewis.

07:08:23 - 07:11:24

Julian Lewis

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And the Defence Secretary who started off the debate today is undoubtedly a versatile and an entertaining politician. But I think he did himself a little less than full justice in being so casually dismissive of the remarks made by the Labour Chairman of the Defence Select Committee.

For the record, I have found the honorable gentleman for Slough to be both thoughtful, knowledgeable, and patriotic, and he deserves to be listened to, just as his predecessors in the role, including me, were listened to, with, I believe, respect by Conservative governments, even when we were criticizing them. And criticize them we did. As long ago as June 2018, the Defense Committee published a report entitled "Beyond 2%", HC 818 for those nerds who are interested in looking it up. And this called for a level of defense expenditure approaching the figure of 3% of GDP, which the United Kingdom still maintained as late as the mid-1990s.

Now, the mid-1990s were six years or so after the fall of the Berlin Wall. And when the government keeps saying, as the Chancellor said yesterday and as the Defence Secretary repeatedly said today, though not taking interventions on it, that he was so proud to be part of a government that had, um, was behind the biggest increase in defence spending since the end of the Cold War, the question you have to ask them is how much do they think this country spent on defence during the Cold War? Because when the Cold War was over, the threat diminished. The threat is now high.

It's as high as it ever was during the Cold War. And during, for example, the 1980s, as I've said many times, we spent between four and a half and five percent of GDP, calculated by today's method of calculation, on defense. Now, in June 2025, the Hague Summit Declaration actually called for NATO members to spend five percent by 2035, consisting of three and a half percent on core expenditure and one and a half percent on wider defense-related items. We are already beginning to hear how the three and a half percent, or even the three percent, are going to be made up by creative accounting.

Let us bear in mind the three and a half percent are core defense and the creating accounting elements if they're lucky deserve to be included in the five percent, but that's it.

07:11:24 - 07:11:26

Speaker 251

Chris Murray.

07:11:26 - 07:14:17

Christopher Murray

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I am so pleased to support a Labour budget that is backing Scotland and backing Edinburgh, despite the best efforts of the SNP to talk down its benefits and talk down my city. I welcome in particular the announcement of importance to my constituency, 18 million pounds for a UK advanced chip design academy at Edinburgh University. This is how you build hope for the future. Modern iPhones contain at least a dozen chips designed in Edinburgh, and Edinburgh researchers helped design a crucial sensor used in iPhone cameras, billions of which are now produced worldwide.

Consider this remarkable statistic from the historian Chris Miller.

Last year, in a single year, the semiconductor industry manufactured more chips than humanity produced of all other manufactured products combined throughout human history. Artificial intelligence may appear digital, but it depends on something profoundly physical: chips, semiconductors, and the infrastructure that powers them. We can't afford to watch from the sidelines while the United States, Taiwan, and others lead the field. Thanks to this budget, Edinburgh will join them in the future. I have argued for years that Edinburgh can be one of the great powerhouses of the British economy, provided we have a government willing to back its potential.

But for too long, we have had an SNP government letting us down at every turn. Edinburgh is the lowest-funded per head local authority in Scotland. There are more homeless children in Edinburgh than in the whole of Wales. They hoard money in Holyrood and starve Scotland's capital city.

Yesterday, we heard a Labour Chancellor reject that, make the decisions that will help Edinburgh thrive. Support for entrepreneurs, for startups, scale-ups and founders will mean the innovation of Edinburgh researchers pushes us into the future. Yet the SNP's position on Labour's investment in Scotland is absurd in the extreme. We heard the member for Arbroath and Perthshire Glens attack the renewal of standing charges on bills, despite having advocated that policy in this chamber only months earlier. The Scottish Government's budget is 12.4% higher, even setting aside new responsibilities.

Since Labour came to office, we have delivered £8 billion extra for Scotland's budget. Where has that money gone?

Why are my constituents still facing waiting lists, homelessness and potholes? It is because the SNP are so keen to look for grievance, they can't even work out they've been given more money. Labour is delivering for Edinburgh. What's holding us back is an SNP government with no plan, no conception of what Scotland's capital city can do, and no notion of how to use government to improve people's lives. Thank you.

07:14:17 - 07:14:18

Dr. Neil Shastri-Hurst.

07:14:18 - 07:17:16

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's a pleasure to follow the honourable gentleman, although I suspect we will have slightly different assessments of this particular budget. Because in my view, this budget is a thin gruel of a budget, with its 98 measures which are tinkering at tax and spending. It's not un-reminiscent of the Emperor Nero in Rome, fiddling as it burned. Because this is ultimately a budget of delay.

It has kicked the big decisions into the long grass. It's anemic in terms of its assessment and forecast for growth, and it is quite simply not setting out a compelling vision for our economic future. And there is a cost, Madam Deputy Speaker, of that inertia. And there are two areas where I think that is very, very obvious. The first, of course, is in defense, and we are living in an increasingly unstable world.

It is negligent, it is a failure of duty of government not to properly fund our armed forces. And a consequence of having a plan for a roadmap for 3% is that you actually have no strategy whatsoever. And I'm afraid the absence of that plan from this particular Chancellor especially does nothing to enhance his credibility in front of the British public and the markets.

The second area that I'll touch on very briefly is welfare. And I'll touch on it briefly because there was barely any mention of it in yesterday's budget. And yet, welfare spending is predicted to go up by 19 billion this year. And by 2031-32, the total welfare spend is anticipated to be 431 billion pounds, Madam Deputy Speaker. That is utterly unsustainable.

There is however one area that I want to concentrate on and that is a particular hidden tax measure within this budget. And it's buried at section 6.147 of the Red Book, but it does have enormous implications for those who are self-employed and pay their tax under self-assessment.

I'm one of those individuals from my historic earnings at the bar and my age debt. But what this new proposal will end up doing is that individuals will be paying their taxes perhaps on a monthly, perhaps on a quarterly basis, it's unclear as of yet. But it will almost certainly draw into that measure 50% tax returns being brought forward in terms of when they are paid. Now there is an obvious effect for the Treasury in year one of this measure, it will increase more than 1.3 billion pounds in terms of receipts. By year three it will be 1.8 billion.

But it will be ruinous for the individuals concerned because they will end up paying tax on issues that they have not yet received.

It doesn't reflect the seasonality of payments, and it is quite frankly a rather silly policy that has been cooked up by those that have no understanding of business at all.

07:17:16 - 07:20:17

Anna Dixon

Thank you, Deputy Speaker. In yesterday's budget, we saw the Chancellor putting in place measures that will put money back into the pockets of my constituents in Shipley, support our brilliant independent businesses, and deliver for carers and families across Bingley, Shipley, Baildon and the surrounding villages. Now this budget does so without endangering the strong economic foundations that were laid by the previous Chancellor, my right honourable friend the member for Leeds West and Pudsey, and I'd like to echo the Defence Secretary's tributes to her for her action to restore economic stability after the Tory economic chaos.

Against a global backdrop of uncertainty, it's a tricky balancing act for the new Chancellor, rebuilding our public services and maintaining fiscal discipline. But this Chancellor and this budget got that balance right, delivering security at home with better public services and security from threats abroad. So, Madam Deputy Speaker, I echo with others and welcome the new energy bills breathing space, which will give 36,500 households in Shipley a £100 payment this winter. I'm also incredibly proud that after years of campaigning, the carers allowance cliff edge will be abolished and replaced with a taper, so carers who earn just a little over the earnings limit will no longer lose their entire allowance. Carers should never be penalised for working an extra shift.

That unfairness ends under a Labour government. I share our new Prime Minister's ambition to reform adult social care, to ensure that disabled adults and older people get the care they need, and so I look forward to the spending review and hope that his ambition will be matched by the Chancellor's in the spending review. And briefly, I would like to echo the member for Blaydon and Consett's enjoyment about the P-DEL, the new protective prevention spend. It may seem a little geeky, Madam Deputy Speaker, but this could prove transformative. Let's stop paying for failure and crisis and instead invest in early intervention.

And just one example where this could make a huge difference is in hospice and end-of-life care. If we funded our local hospices like Marie Curie and Sue Ryder, who are currently reliant on charitable funding, they could expand community support.

This would deliver reductions in inappropriate and unnecessary hospital admissions at end of life, saving money in the NHS and ensuring more people die at home and in the community. And finally, I welcome the defense spending and hope that some of the fantastic innovative defense SMEs in Shipley, like Radio Design and Slipstream Engineering, can use it to grow high-skilled jobs in my area. This is a fantastic budget. It shows that the Labour government is listening to people in places like Shipley, backing workers, carers, and our local businesses. Thank you.

07:20:17 - 07:22:54

Speaker 109

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. So the Chancellor started his remarks by praising the previous Chancellor yesterday. He said, I quote, "She brought fiscal discipline to this country and she took the decisions required to boost investment." Apparently. But what he omitted is actually more telling.

That is that she increased tax on business, she crippled farmers with taxes, the ballooning welfare bill, and the ballooning borrowing. If this fiscal discipline was as good and so great, perhaps she still herself might have been delivering that budget yesterday. He also talked too of giving Britain some breathing space on the cost of living and the cost of business. If this is breathing space, then I think he needs to be very careful of misrepresentation. That budget was a faulty inhaler at best.

I am concerned particularly on some of the measures within the budget. On devolution, there was a lot of discussion, Madam Deputy Speaker, about devolution. However, for an area like Northamptonshire, we are not being considered at the moment on battling for any provisions around mayors.

So we're battling at the moment to be able to be considered as a unit of six. It is currently looking at BLMK and it's such a—and it's so important when so many decisions are apparently going to be devolved to these authorities that Northamptonshire has its right place within these discussions. So I do hope that we can continue to make the case for Northamptonshire to be part of that. I also want to briefly just touch on some of the comments that were made around defence. Now, defence of this realm is absolutely essential and we all know how vital it is that we get to 3% of our GDP by 2030.

Now, I think it is incredibly shocking some of the comments that was made by the Secretary of State for Defence earlier on. These benches asking for detailed questions about how we will achieve that spending should not be dismissed and joked about. It is absolutely right that this is the chamber and this is the place where those questions are answered. So I would ask that the Secretary of State reconsiders his approach the next time the opposition asks these questions.

And especially because the Chancellor, when he was Secretary of State for Defence, resigned on exactly the reason that we couldn't necessarily reach 3%. A target is all that was mentioned yesterday. And I'd like to just remind everyone of the definition of a target is something you aim for. What we actually need is a full-on commitment here and now. The budget was given the title which said about a fresh hope for the future.

This is not about hope for the future. This is about this government delivering. Hope is a little bit, as they say, like a rocking chair. It gives you something to do, but it gets you absolutely nowhere. So I would just say action speaks much louder than words.

07:22:54 - 07:22:55

Mark Sewards.

07:22:55 - 07:25:54

James Mark Sewards

Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker.

In the short time available to me, I'll just go through a few things in this budget that I think will genuinely help my constituents, and also a few areas that I think the government should go further. Starting with household bills, I certainly won't be alone in this House in finding that most of my constituents are genuinely worried about the pressure of household bills. It's definitely welcome that standing charges are being scrapped from gas bills, that the VAT on energy bills has been suspended for longer, and the new 100 pound household energy payment is being introduced. That's going to benefit 40,000 properties in my constituency alone.

And it is welcome breathing space, but it cannot be the summit of our ambitions on energy bills, or indeed on bills more generally. That's why I did welcome the long-term direction set out on energy by the Chancellor yesterday, but I do want to assure my constituents and give fair warning to the front bench that I will be asking for more support if bills do not come down quickly enough in the short and medium term. It's also welcome as well to see the support given to businesses, nearly half of all businesses in Yorkshire and the Humber will not pay business rates following the announcements yesterday. But alongside that immediate support for families and businesses, the budget did make some investments in my home city of Leeds, not least the 200 pounds, 200 million pounds extra to transform Leeds train station. Now there's lots in that, there's a new bridge over the platforms, there's three new entrances, there's bigger and better concourses.

But when I went through this with my wife Alice yesterday, she was very quick to remind me, she's absolutely right, the improvements to the lifts are incredibly overdue.

They are so painfully slow that you have to factor 15 or 20 minutes extra into your journey if you have a pram or if you have a wheelchair. And I have to say, as somebody who has a five-year-old, a two-year-old, and another one arriving in a few weeks' time, I welcome that investment into our lifts and I can't wait to spend the money to make them just that little bit faster for anybody with a pram. I do also welcome the 50 million pounds being given to Leeds College of Building for their new campus on the South Bank. That is going to be used by my constituents, it's going to give them benefits, it's going to give them a chance to start a new career in an area where we have skill shortages already. And in the very short time available to me, I will also say that as chair of the Yorkshire North Lincolnshire APPG, we were about to put out a report calling on the government to give fiscal devolution to the regions to allow mayors to keep more of the tax revenue that we raise centrally.

Very pleased to see that the Chancellor has beaten us to the punch and announced that. And I do know that the Prime Minister considers Lord Blunkett to be a personal mentor and hero to him, and he has also been a mentor and hero to our APPG. So I'll just say that he took what was in our report, gave it to the Prime Minister, and that's how it ended up in the budget statement. And that's my story and I'm sticking to it.

07:25:54 - 07:25:55

Kevin Bonavia.

07:25:55 - 07:28:59

Kevin Bonavia

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget comes at a time when conflict in Europe and in the Middle East, not of our choosing, not of our making, has hit cost of living here at home hard, while the threats facing our country make investment in defence and national security more important than ever. And as today's debate opened on our side with the Defence Secretary, I want to make a further point.

Economic security and national security go hand in hand. And this is particularly important in my constituency of Stevenage, where the aerospace and space sectors are a vital part of our local economy. Indeed, as I've said many times in this place, over a quarter of satellites in space have components made in my town of Stevenage. But to have that security in the long term, we have to make sure people get through the attack on our cost of living now. And that is why this budget has so much for that breathing space.

To help with soaring energy bills, we have the hundred pound household energy payment that will help thirty-six thousand homes in Stevenage and our villages.

We have the extension of the electricity VAT cut. Pensioners, the lowest income pensioners, will not be paying income tax as a result of this budget. And our businesses, our retail, hospitality and leisure businesses in Stevenage, will benefit from the real terms increase in the next two years. These taken together all help, and it's no good the opposition belittling any of those. And when it comes to security, as the opposition have accepted, the defense investment plan is fully funded.

That means our defense industry can now get on and provide the equipment and the support that our armed forces need.

We are united in this house in supporting Ukraine and I'm glad we all welcome the extra support for Ukraine. But the opposition had 10 years in government, sorry, 14 years in government, and they lecture us about defense now. In that time, I've already said our armed forces were belittled. The member for New Forest East talked about looking at the last government increasing defense spending then, never did it. You never did it.

And now they say they will cut welfare. Welfare ballooned under the last government. Now and they say they're going to cut 30 billion. No plans. They ask us for a plan.

They ask us for a plan, nothing from them. So why should we believe a word from them?

Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a time to think about that breathing space for our constituents, and I commend this budget to the House.

07:28:59 - 07:29:04

Speaker 256

Which brings us to the front bench contributions. Shadow Minister, Mark Francois.

07:29:04 - 07:29:36

Mark Francois

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. It's a pleasure to sum up for His Majesty's Opposition this afternoon. Perhaps I can begin on a consensual point by pointing out that yet again, as we are debating these important economic matters, including the defense of the realm, there is no Member of Parliament from the Reform Party present. They have taken no part in this debate at all. We know they don't do Thursday afternoons, and they certainly don't do defense either.

07:29:36 - 07:29:42

Speaker 255

Very quickly. Does he believe it's because their prayer cards were taken out of place and that's why they can't be here?

07:29:42 - 07:39:29

Mark Francois

No, I think it's because they're desperately trying to find someone, anyone, to go to one of their press conferences. Now, according to the Red Book, working-age welfare spending will increase to 221 and a half billion in 2031-32. That's almost a quarter of a trillion pounds and an increase of over 57 billion since 24-25. The Prime Minister famously said at the dispatch box just a few weeks ago that national security can't come at the expense of social security. And that really is a segue to what I principally want to say this afternoon.

What the Chancellor announced yesterday was not a detailed programme for how to spend 3% of GDP on defence, but just a plan to have a plan, which is not really a plan at all.

He promised to begin work, his words, on how this would be achieved by the time of the spending review next year. The Labour government has already had two years to answer this question. So why do they need a further year now? When Labour published the Strategic Defense Review, the SDR in June 2025, all three authors of the report, led by Lord Robertson, a respected former Secretary General of NATO, were absolutely adamant that the bill for implementing their recommendations was a minimum of 3% of GDP on defense.

So unless and until the government definitively commit to spending this money, it's very difficult for our armed forces to realistically deter a war with any aggressor, in particularly the Russians, not the Trussians. At the time of SDR, we were told this level of detail would be provided in the subsequent defense investment plan. The House was promised this in the autumn, then by Christmas, then by the new year, then in the spring, and it was only finally published in late June 2026. Nevertheless, when the DIP was eventually published, the government then kicked the can down the road for a second time and still failed to provide a definitive date of when and crucially how this country would spend 3% of GDP on defense. Indeed, the then Defense Secretary, now the Chancellor, famously resigned, seemingly on a point of honor because the government had failed to give a date for 3%.

I have here, Madam Deputy Speaker, his resignation letter, dated the 11th of June, and I quote from it directly. After explaining to you that I would not be able to accept a DIP settlement that does not give our forces the resources they need, I'm now left with no other option than to submit my resignation as your Defence Secretary. It's also worth recording that the then Veterans Minister, the member, the honourable and gallant member for Birmingham Selly Oak, resigned in company with him, partly over this, and also because of his very severe reservations over the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, a wicked bill, which he famously described as not fit for purpose. Now miraculously, having resigned as Defence Secretary, when the Prime Minister then fell, the right honourable gentleman for Wycombe was immediately reincarnated as the Chancellor of the Exchequer.

However, he then found himself with the boot very much on the other foot. Now given his understanding of defence and the solemn terms in which he wrote his letter, it was not unreasonable to assume that having now seized control of the bridge at the Treasury, he'd be ideally placed in order to meet his own request to name the date for 3% and how to finance it. Otherwise, why did he resign? So I'm genuinely deeply saddened to see that yesterday he failed his own test. All we were offered was an offer to produce a plan for 3% in the government spending review which will take place next year.

So in other words, a man who seemingly resigned on a point of honour, when he had the perfect chance to put that problem right, completely ducked it.

All that Labour have done is kick the can down the road for a third time. So our armed forces cannot realistically plan because they do not know how much money they will really have to spend in this nation's defence, and they're now going to have to wait at least another year before they do. But the House didn't take it from me. Chris Evans, the political editor of the BBC, in summarising the budget on the 6 o'clock news last night said, "The biggest questions this government still faces, such as the long-term funding of defence, this budget didn't answer."

Well, in fact, Madam Deputy Speaker, it's even worse than that, because when the defense secretary agreed the SDR, he also signed up with the Treasury for almost 11 billion pounds of efficiency savings. This was a Labour deal, a Faustian pact between two warring government departments, but the effect of those in-year efficiency savings, or spending cuts in pub English, is now proving debilitating for our armed forces. The in-year cuts were some two and a half billion in the previous financial year, and they're now three and a half billion in this year, 26-27. For instance, one of the reasons it took nearly a month to get HMS Dragon to sea was because of maintenance cuts that occurred under this efficiency savings program. We now see the vast bulk of the Royal Navy tied up alongside the quayside, partly because of maintenance issues, but also to save money.

For many months, we had a period when not a single one of our nuclear attack submarines was at sea.

And before the Minister intervenes and chides me for discussing submarine movements on the floor of the House, I'm not. I'm discussing the absence of submarine movements on the floor of the House. We've also seen army exercises cancelled on Salisbury Plain and flying hours reduced for some of our RAF pilots. These are exactly the wrong things to be doing if we're trying to send messages to Vladimir Putin, a former KGB colonel, to deter him from further adventurism, for instance, in the Baltic states. Yesterday, and I'm afraid, Defence Secretary, I'm going to quote him again, the Labour Chairman of the Defence Committee excellently summed it all up by saying, "Some of the key decisions on defence spending have lamentably been delayed until next year's spending review.

There is a cost to inaction. Investment in our nation's defence and security cannot be kicked into the long grass.

Our adversaries are not bound by fiscal years and spending cycles." He should know. Again yesterday, we even learned from the depths of the budget Red Book that the Chancellor has effectively cut the overall MOD budget by a billion pounds in each of the next two years by pocketing reduced spending estimates on MOD pensions for the Treasury, rather than allowing the MOD to retain the cash and spend it on bolstering our defences. The Treasury has described these two one billion pound cuts in the defence budget as an accounting adjustment. Well, it's Enron accounting.

It's smoke and mirrors, and it only helps our adversaries and not our armed forces. On defense housing, there's a similar story. I served for some five months on the Armed Forces Bill Committee, when we were told repeatedly that the money for this purpose would not be raided for short-term efficiency savings. In fact, the honorable and gallant member for Birmingham Selly Oak told us on the 18th of March during committee, I quote, "The nine billion has been ring-fenced." "It has absolutely been secured for defense housing."

"Nothing in the DIP process will stop us getting on with the job of making these improvements and getting the job done." "We have made that commitment not just to the armed forces community but the nation." "We have said it in the House and we will see it through."

That's completely unambiguous. So imagine our anger when we then saw a letter from the Permanent Under-Secretary to the Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee dated the 25th of September, who says not only will some 850 million of that money now be deferred to the next Parliament, but also an additional 1 billion of upgrades to single living accommodation for soldiers would now be deferred as well. So what the government have done is they've cut nearly 2 pounds of that investment in this Parliament in a desperate attempt to meet exactly the Treasury-imposed efficiency saving targets that they swore blind to us for five months they would not do. So in summary, Ma'am, the Defence Secretary who opened this debate neglected to mention the MOD's 3 and a half billion efficiency savings target for this year. He talks about being ready for war within a thousand days, whilst at the same time imposing crippling cuts on the operations and training of our armed forces who are there to deter war in the first place.

Si vis pacem, para bellum. The budget totally failed to answer the question of how the government will actually spend 3% of GDP on defence. And they're listening in Moscow, in Beijing, in Tehran and in Pyongyang. This is a dereliction of duty by a government who will the ends but don't will the means, who talk tough but act weak, who let down the people of this country, who won't defend them properly and who must be held to account at the ballot box for their abject failure in defence of the realm.

07:39:29 - 07:42:33

Speaker 258

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I'd like to thank all right and right honourable members for their contributions to this budget debate and it's an honour to respond on behalf of the government.

Yesterday the Chancellor delivered a budget which will steer Britain through a period of global volatility and through the economic storm which has increased pressures on families and firms across this country. It was a budget that doubles down, Madam Deputy Speaker, on our fiscal discipline. It's one that strengthens our economic resilience and our national security, making responsible choices in an uncertain world. It's a budget that offers households and businesses breathing space from cost pressures in the here and now and a budget which makes critical structural changes that will drive our future prosperity. And Madam Deputy Speaker, over the course of today, one moment, the Defense Secretary and right honorable members on this side of the house, including the honorable members for Buckingham and Bletchley and for Blaydon and Consett, have rightly emphasized the importance of our commitment to fiscal responsibility.

Fiscal responsibility, Madam Deputy Speaker, underwrites every promise this government makes to the British people. And as was made clear yesterday, in this budget, the Chancellor has met his fiscal rules, and for the first time this government is meeting them in the third year of the forecast. The headroom against the stability rule is 15 billion pounds, rising to 22 billion pounds in 2030-31. Last year, we cut borrowing to its lowest level in six years, and the OBR's EFO confirms that borrowing will fall over the forecast.

And Madam Deputy Speaker, you'll forgive me, Madam Deputy Speaker, and you'll forgive us on this side of the House for taking the advice of the Shadow Chancellor with not so much a pinch of salt, but a whole bucket. Because not only is he the architect of the mini-budget, but he maintained just a few weeks ago that the mini-budget, as the Defence Secretary said, contained lots of good things. So maybe he would like to tell us what those good things were. Were they the sky-high mortgages for millions of people right across this country, including in my constituency? Was it the disastrous market impact?

Was it the cratering of our international reputation? Which, what were, what were the good things? Madam Deputy Speaker, Britain's economic reputation was so badly damaged under the party opposite that the IMF publicly warned them to change course.

And I know you can tell, Madam Deputy Speaker, they don't like they don't like being reminded of that, of course. And look, the shadow Chancellor doesn't like that either because he was the one of the mini-budget's chief architects and indeed the most ardent fans. The reality is that the contrast between their approach and ours could not be clearer. I will give way.

07:42:33 - 07:42:48

Luke Morgan Evans

Talking about structural problems and difficulties, we've just had a press release come out from the Labour party which says, "Exclusive: Chancellor tells Christian Guru-Murthy Labour will not bring welfare bills down in this Parliament." Does she stand by that?

07:42:48 - 07:43:52

Speaker 258

Madam Deputy Speaker, we are reforming welfare and the Prime Minister has made clear today the welfare budget ballooned under the party opposite. The Prime Minister has been very clear today that the welfare bill will come down. The welfare bill will come down.

So, as I said, Madam Deputy Speaker, the contrast between our approach and theirs could not be clearer. The IMF forecast earlier this month that our deficit would be the lowest in the G7 by 2029. And Madam Deputy Speaker, fiscal strength matters because our economic security and our national security are inseparable. That's why this budget strengthens Britain's capacity to withstand global volatility. It funds the defense investment plan right by reprioritizing capital budget so that Britain can respond in a more to a more dangerous world.

It strengthens our defense industrial base and it supports skilled jobs across the country. And it also, as has been pointed out by the right honorable member for Malden and the honorable member for Edinburgh West...

07:43:52 - 07:43:53

Speaker 259

Point of order, Steve Barclay.

07:43:53 - 07:44:22

Paul Stephen Barclay

The Chief Secretary's just said at the dispatch box that the welfare bill will come down. The BBC has been reporting following the Chancellor saying the same thing this morning that Number 10 and the Treasury have informed the media that that is not the case and the welfare bill won't be coming down. So how do we ensure that the House gets the true position, because it's rather hard trying to keep up with the fact that it keeps changing.

07:44:22 - 07:44:32

Speaker 260

Can I thank the right honorable member for his point of order. He will of course know full well that that is not a matter for the chair, but I'm sure the Treasury bench has heard the point he made. Minister.

07:44:32 - 07:45:11

Speaker 258

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, let me turn now about energy security, because it's part of our national security too.

We're reforming our energy system so that Britain is less exposed to volatility. We'll freeze new policy costs on bills pending a comprehensive cost control framework. We're accelerating investment in the grid and we're procuring clean power only where it lowers bills and can connect properly. And Madam Deputy Speaker, when it comes to our public services, this government has stabilized spending after years of underinvestment by the party opposite. And spending will continue.

07:45:12 - 07:45:28

Mark Francois

Grateful. I'm sure she can confirm to the House that she is a Treasury minister. Because I have here the press release issued by the Treasury, which says, for immediate release, exclusive, Chancellor John Healey tells Krishnan Guru-Murthy Labour will not bring welfare bills...

07:45:28 - 07:45:35

Speaker 261

Order, order.

Mr. Francois, we refer to him as the Chancellor, not by his name. Mark Francois.

07:45:35 - 07:45:58

Mark Francois

I apologize, Ma'am, I was reading the press release, but I accept your admonition. Anyway, it says that the bloke who's in charge of the Treasury has told Krishnan Guru-Murthy that Labour will not bring welfare bills down in the Parliament, and the Economic Secretary to the Treasury, to give her her correct title, just said that they will. So who's right? Is it the honorable lady or her boss? Because they can't both be, can they?

07:45:58 - 07:47:37

Speaker 258

Madam Deputy Speaker, the Prime Minister confirmed earlier today that we will bring the welfare bill down as soon as possible. And I'm very happy, I'm very happy, I'm very happy to confirm that. And as the, look, as the Chancellor said yesterday, Madam Deputy Speaker, when it comes to public services, we will insist on reform, on prioritization, and on value for money as well.

Because that is what resilience looks like. It looks like sound public finances, secure energy, strong defense, and a state which is able to act when the country needs it to. And Madam Deputy Speaker, as honorable members have made clear, including the honorable members for Gloucester, for Shipley, and for Leeds South West and Morley, the measures in this budget will provide breathing room for families and businesses now, whilst also helping to bring bills down over the long term. And Madam Deputy Speaker, we know that the pressures when it comes to energy are not just felt by families, but they're felt by businesses too. And that's exactly why we're increasing the small business rate relief threshold for retail, hospitality, and leisure properties, taking around 70,000 more businesses out of business rates altogether.

And for other businesses in the sector, rates will be frozen in real time for two years.

We're supporting, Madam Deputy Speaker, high streets and the businesses that give them life. We're backing pubs, clubs, and music venues. We're reducing the supply-side barriers that firms repeatedly tell us hold them back: energy costs, slow infrastructure decisions, red tape, and access to finance. And because of our commitment to fiscal responsibility, all of these measures are fully funded. I will give way.

07:47:37 - 07:47:55

Anna Dixon

I very much thank my honourable friend for her closing remarks and responding to the points raised during the debate. I would ask that she just confirm that business rate relief will not apply to the vape shops that are popping up on our high streets and blighting our high streets.

07:47:55 - 07:50:27

Speaker 258

Madam Deputy Speaker, I can.

And Madam Speaker, let me move now because upon that commitment to sound finances is our plan to double down on the conditions that will allow for the growth that is going to drive this country's future prosperity. We are determined that Britain will be an even better place to start a business, to scale it, and then to stay. And a new founders' relief will offer a 10% capital gains tax rate on eligible lifetime gains of up to £10 million for founders of high-growth companies. We're doubling the SEIS limit and we're tripling the trading allowance too.

And recognizing that artificial intelligence is the defining technology of our time, which is already turbocharging productivity, we're putting more than 700 million pounds behind making it safer, more secure, and easier to adapt. And I'm pleased to confirm to the honorable member for North Cotswold that we will continue to safely adopt AI within the public sector, improving public services and productivity whilst securing better value for taxpayers. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, the Chancellor also talked yesterday about significant change to our energy policy, because we know that affordable, secure energy is a platform for growth. So by accelerating grid connection, controlling costs, and lowering electricity bills, we will strengthen industrial competitiveness and unlock investment across the country. And then, Madam Deputy Speaker, we're also putting our public finance institutions at the heart of Britain's growth mission, with an additional 20.4 billion pounds of capital for the National Wealth Fund and the British Business Bank.

Madam Deputy Speaker, let me conclude by saying in the first half of this year, our economy was the joint fastest growing in the G7 alongside the United States.

The OBR has raised its forecast for growth this year to 1.2%. Whole economy investment, business investment, and productivity are all up. Now, that progress is being tested by global pressures, we know, and that is exactly why the Chancellor has delivered a budget that will steer us through the storm. It's a budget underpinned by fiscal discipline. It provides support to families and firms now.

It will strengthen our resilience and it will put this country on the better, more secure, and more prosperous course that the British people deserve. I beg to move that the debate be now adjourned.

07:50:27 - 07:50:37

Speaker 262

The question is that the debate be now adjourned. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No. I think the Ayes have it.

07:50:37 - 07:50:42

Speaker 264

The Ayes have it. Debate to be resumed what day?

07:50:42 - 07:50:44

Speaker 263

Monday 2nd of November.

07:50:44 - 07:51:17

Speaker 265

Monday the 2nd of November. The front benches if they wish to can shuffle out. Petition, Vicky Slade.

07:51:17 - 07:52:04

Vikki Slade

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.

Hairdressing and barber businesses are a core component of our high streets. They bring millions of repeat visits every year. They provide local jobs, improve our emotional well-being, and cannot be replaced by AI or moved online. Yet they are in crisis, with apprentice starts reduced by 84% since 2015, employment likely to fall by 93% by the end of this Parliament, and salon owners seeing the VAT rate as a penalty for employment and growth. So the 2,000-plus signatories of this petition request that the House of Commons urge the Government to introduce a permanently lower rate of 10% of VAT for professional hairdressing, barbering, beauty, spa, and aesthetics services.

07:52:04 - 07:52:18

Speaker 266

And the petitioners remain, etcetera.

07:52:18 - 07:52:27

Speaker 269

Petition, hair and beauty sector.

07:52:27 - 07:52:32

Speaker 267

I beg to move that this House do now adjourn.

07:52:32 - 07:52:36

Speaker 268

The question is that this House do now adjourn. Cat Smith.

07:52:36 - 07:55:38

Catherine Jane Smith

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And as you are aware, it's not the first time that I've had an adjournment debate on the issue of sodium valproate in my 11 and a bit years as a Member of Parliament here.

This continues to be an issue which affects so many and for which justice still feels so far away. I don't intend to spend much time, given the history of this House debating the topic, of going through the history of the drug, which has been used to treat epilepsy and bipolar disorder since the early 1970s, but I will briefly, for the benefit of anyone who's perhaps tuning in for the first time, go over the brief facts of what happened. The drug is a teratogenic, which was known to be teratogenic from the time it was first licensed. And despite this, doctors were initially advised that the risk did not justify, and I quote, "did not justify discouraging a woman who needs anticonvulsant treatment from having a child or changing a satisfactory drug regime when the epilepsy is well controlled."

And the result of that has been playing catch-up ever since, with the valproate pregnancy prevention program only being launched following tireless campaigning from women affected, such as my constituent Janet Williams, who is in the gallery tonight, along with her friend and colleague Emma Murphy, in 2018, securing that pregnancy prevention plan. It's difficult to calculate the number of children that have been exposed to valproate in utero since its 1973 licensing. The Patient Safety Commissioner has made an estimate of around 14,000 for the period from 1972 to 2017 in England.

Diagnosis often gets picked up when clinicians or perhaps in some cases parents recognize facial dysmorphic features. And children born with fetal valproate spectrum disorder can have a wide range of physical and mental health symptoms including but not limited to weak muscles, visual problems, hearing difficulties, difficulties with balance, social anxiety, low energy, heightened sensitivity to noise and difficulties in regulating emotions. But one of the biggest health conditions facing people with fetal valproate spectrum disorder is autism, but also a significant number will also have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, ADHD, dyspraxia, sensory processing disorder and epilepsy. It can affect children in very different ways. In some of the most severe cases, and I know the honorable gentleman's got a constituent who's very severely affected, the individual can end up bedbound and very severely disabled.

For some children it may be more of an issue with the autism and sensory processing.

Does the gentleman want to... I'll give way.

07:55:38 - 07:56:42

Bob Blackman

I thank the honorable member for giving way and thank her for introducing this long-awaited debate. My constituent, Karen Buck, whose daughter Bridget Doyle was born paralyzed, is bedbound, she suffers from autism and the reality is that there are many victims out there that suffer from a variety of conditions, as she quite rightly points out. Not least, of course, is spina bifida as well, which she hasn't just mentioned.

And I think the problem here is that the court case which was established to try and get recompense for those victims had legal aid withdrawn back some 20 years ago. Unfortunately, although commitments have been made time and time again to help those people, these mothers are now coming to the advanced end of their lives and the children they've supported will desperately need support when their lives end. Does she think there's a need for now a proper compensation scheme?

07:56:42 - 07:58:25

Catherine Jane Smith

I thank the honorable gentleman for raising his constituent Karen's case with her daughter Bridget. And I would entirely agree with him that the time is now. I think that he raises an important point, Madam Deputy Speaker, about the fact that because this scandal has been going on for so long, the drug first licensed in the 1970s inevitably means that the babies that were harmed are no longer babies.

They're not even children. They're adults with, you know, disabilities, and their parents are, you know, getting older every year. And the reality is for many of those parents, and when I speak to them, one of the biggest anxieties is around the fact that who's going to look after their children when they no longer can? And that's why we need to see compensation paid out, I believe, sooner rather than later, because it's already frankly been too long. Turning to the case for compensation, if I may, I think the case for redress from the government for the families affected by this maladministration has been conclusively made.

You know, this is not the first debate we've had in this chamber about this, but nor was it even the first review.

In 2020, the Cumberlege review, which was established by the previous Prime Minister Theresa May, she found that the state and manufacturers have an ethical responsibility to provide ex gratia payments to those who have experienced avoidable damage. These payments should be made to cover costs such as travel to medical appointments, respite breaks, or emergency payments where a parent has to stop working to cover care. And I pay tribute to the former Prime Minister for her work on this issue because she really was a doughty campaigner on this. And I give way to my honorable friend.

07:58:25 - 07:58:57

Liz Twist

I thank the honorable member for giving way. And I have constituents also affected by the sodium valproate issue. And does she agree with me that it's a double injustice?

First of all, that the parents, Emma and Janet, had to fight to get recognition and change in the prescription of sodium valproate, and then have had to fight again to get compensation for the very real damage caused.

07:58:57 - 08:05:32

Catherine Jane Smith

I would totally agree with my honorable friend, but it goes further still. You know, when you have a child with additional needs, the last thing you need is to be fighting a national campaign for justice. You already have enough on your plate trying to cope with your child and make sure your child's accessing the support that they need without having to run a national campaign. But that's been the reality for many of these parents, primarily mothers, who have children that have been harmed by valproate. That is exactly what they've had to go on and do.

Um, so to go back to my points around the the history of the reviews that have been done into this scandal, the um in back in 2022 the then Conservative government initially rejected the recommendation that I've just set out. Um, however, um in 2022 it did have a change of heart by the then health minister, I remember Maria Caulfield, uh she was tasked the patient safety commissioner to provide options for financial redress. And that felt like a real step forward for the campaign at that point. And the commissioner produced the Hughes report in February 2024. And it reiterated what we already know, which is that the government has a responsibility to create an ex gratia redress scheme providing financial and non-financial redress for those harmed by valproate.

The Hughes report recommended that the government should create a two-stage financial redress scheme comprising of interim scheme and main scheme with the interim payments commencing in 2025. And for those that are paying attention will realize that that's somewhat late now. She further recommended that these payments should be made by an independent body which commands the confidence of patients. And I think that point is particularly important to make to the minister for the patients that have been harmed have lost so much confidence that the importance of the independence of the body that would administer this would be able to give those patients confidence that it was being done properly. So where are we today?

So we've had both the Cumberlege review and the Hughes report stressing the need for speed when responding to this issue. And that is to a large extent, as my hon. Friend set out, due to the time and nature of the scandal. We now have a cohort of adults with fetal valproate spectrum disorder whose parents are increasingly finding it difficult to support their needs due to their own health and care requirements. And sadly, we're now over two years on from the latter and the Government has yet to formally respond to it. And this is despite the clear recommendation that interim payments should have commenced last year.

The previous Secretary of State for Health, the Member for Ilford North, did do a television interview with ITV Granada's Lucy Meacock in February of this year, in which he indicated that he wanted to commence compensation payments before the end of this Parliament.

So it's therefore troubling that in answers to parliamentary questions from myself and colleagues, that the government's line today remains, and I quote, "a decision to provide compensation has not yet been made." And I just want to say, Madam Deputy Speaker, in response to the written parliamentary questions that myself and colleagues have been putting, it is feeling increasingly frustrating that it feels like when ministers see a written parliamentary question come in and see the word valproate, there's almost a stock answer that gets lifted off the shelf and that gets given to us as members. And speaking to some of the victims recently, they've told me they feel quite gaslit by some of the answers to written parliamentary questions, and written parliamentary questions which just keep referring back to the same answer again and again.

We really do need to make progress with this issue. So does the minister understand the considerable distress such uncertainty and inconsistency causes? So will she today make unequivocally make clear that the government accepts the case for financial redress for the victims of sodium valproate and put in place a clear timetable for delivering that financial redress?

And if the minister needs any more persuasion, and I know that she is a good minister and I know that she'll want to do the right thing here, but if she needs any more persuasion, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to say that by tuning into BBC Two at 9 o'clock on the 9th of November, she'll be able to see the screening of Mums v Big Pharma, which is produced by the same makers as the Post Office scandal, and it really does show the human side and the human cost to this scandal for so many families, some of whom are in the gallery here tonight. And it's really just sort of the perspective of basically two Lancashire mums that have absolutely had enough and are fighting for justice. And if I know one thing about Lancashire women is that when we've got our teeth into something, we do tend to stick at it and we will persevere.

But particularly for Janet Williams, who's been campaigning for justice since 1996, it really is time that justice was brought forward for these victims. In addition to the conversations I've had with victims of the scandal, I've also heard concerns raised by those living in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. And the government, they feel that the government hasn't necessarily engaged as well with victims in the devolved nations. And part of that will be the nature of the health being devolved to those nations. But the reality is, as well as health is a devolved matter, the regulations of human medicines and medical products does remain reserved.

And those victims in the devolved nations too deserve to be taken seriously and brought with English victims on that journey towards redress, both financial and non-financial redress. The government has previously put in place UK-wide schemes for redress, such as on infected blood, and I know the minister is well aware of that.

Will the Government therefore commit to working closely with victims from Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, as well as the devolved administrations on this matter?

08:05:32 - 08:06:13

Anna Dixon

I have to give way. I very much thank the honorable lady for giving way and for her campaigning on behalf of the victims of this particular scandal. I wondered if she was aware of the report from the Public Accounts Committee making recommendations about Government compensation schemes. We looked at schemes including the infected blood scandal, and they suggested that these schemes needed to be designed with the victims and that there should be independence in the way there is for infected blood. And I hope that the Minister in responding to you will also take note of that report and how such a compensation scheme could be set up so that it provides quick redress for victims in the way she hopes.

08:06:13 - 08:06:53

Catherine Jane Smith

I thank the honorable lady for her intervention there and commend her for the work that she does along with others on the PAC committee. And that report is absolutely right to stress the independence in order to give confidence to the victims, but also a scheme designed with victims because these are families that have already had so much done to them that it's important that when it comes to redress they are part of the solution and designing that solution. And that's part of the process of redress. That's part of the justice is that they're no longer having things done to them but are part of designing the solution to resolve things. It'd be a pleasure to give way to my honorable friend.

08:06:53 - 08:07:42

Sharon Hodgson

Thank you and apologies Madam Deputy Speaker for being late to the debate. It caught me somewhat by surprise the early start.

But as she's aware, and the honorable lady may have touched on this already, the Hughes report is an excellent report and that gave a blueprint for how a redress model could be, you know, put in place, right down to the amounts and how that could, you know, be facilitated. Does my honorable friend agree with me that it's been over two years since the Hughes report? I know there's been a change of government, but this government's been in for a good over two years now. Does she agree with me it's about time that the government came forward and accepted the recommendations of the Hughes report?

08:07:42 - 08:10:58

Catherine Jane Smith

I thank my honorable friend for her intervention. And thank her as well for all the work she's done over a number of years on this issue. And she's been a doughty campaigner on sodium valproate and has the confidence of many of the victims and is very well thought of. I would say that I would entirely agree with what she says about the Hughes report. It is a very good report that should have been enacted already.

And it's frustrating that we've been waiting as long as we have on this. There was many things as well as the redress, but also about the non-financial redress in that report. And as part of that, of course, now we've got the pilot clinics that are taking place in Manchester and in Newcastle. We have pilot clinics supporting children and adults that have been affected by valproate. But these are pilots, unlike some of the other clinics.

So with mesh, for example, those clinics are permanent clinics and they're able to provide psychological support as well. For those that are victims of valproate, the clinics are still, still in trial. And we don't have clinics outside of the north of England.

And obviously as a north of England MP, I'm very glad that the clinics are sort of local to me. But the reality is that victims of valproate live right across the United Kingdom, and it shouldn't become a postcode lottery of where people can access support. So can the government update the House perhaps about whether or not these are going to be made permanent and perhaps expanded to cover a wider geography rather than just the north of England? And finally, I suppose, would the Minister commit to meeting with me and victims, especially those from the campaign organisation INFACT, to discuss in detail the government's long-term intentions in this area? Because many of these victims feel like they've been in the dark for an awful long time about what's happening.

Labour, we've been in government here since 2024, and I think the time has come when feet can no longer be dragged and justice needs to be done. Redress needs to be put in place, and the families that have been affected are owed no less than that. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm so glad you're in the chair tonight because you too have been a doughty supporter of these victims, and I know you too are very fondly thought of, especially by those in the public gallery tonight, for your support on this. And I'm really grateful that there has been interventions from both sides, because this truly is an issue which cuts across party politics, because regardless of what colour rosette one wears, you cannot fail to see the injustice that has been done to these families. And I personally would like to see it be a Labour government that delivered this redress to these victims.

You know, this scandal's been going on since the 1970s. The time has passed for just talking about this.

We need to start acting and doing things. The families that have been affected are frankly owed nothing less. And I hope that in the Minister's reply, she will give them some hope tonight because I'm told that hope is back. So let's make sure that means something by having some hope from the dispatch box tonight. Thank you.

08:10:58 - 08:11:02

Speaker 271

Minister, Dame Diana Johnson.

08:11:02 - 08:14:23

Diana Ruth Johnson

Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And can I also say how nice it is to see the Clerk of the House in his place? And I want to pay tribute to his very long service in this place and wish him the very best for the next chapter.

I also, of course, want to start by congratulating my honorable friend the Member for Lancaster and Wyre on securing this important debate and thank all the honorable members who have contributed to this sensitive and important topic. We've had the Member for Blaydon and Consett, my honorable friend for Shipley, my honorable friend for Washington and Gateshead South, and the honorable gentleman for Harrow East, all making very important contributions. And again, I would also like to reference, Madam Deputy Speaker, I know that you're a long-standing supporter of this issue as well.

And I know that my honourable friend has been working tirelessly for many, many years on behalf of her constituent Janet Williams and all the campaigners and the families, including Emma Murphy, who my honourable friend referred to, and to make sure that women's and families' voices are heard and that they are at the heart really of the discussions and the debates that we have. And I also agree with my honourable friend about the perseverance of women. And there's clear perseverance here indeed. And I have been very moved by the stories that I've heard, both before I came into office and the more I look into this matter, I think the more tragic it appears to be. And I will be watching that television programme on the 9th of November, which my honourable friend referred to.

Now, as my honorable friend would expect, since becoming the Minister for Public Health and Patient Safety, I have been briefed by officials on the Hughes report and the progress that we've made so far. Of course, I am very pleased to meet with my honorable friend and the families affected. Of course, I'm happy to do that. I'm also very determined to make progress on the government's response to the Hughes report, and I will, of course, work closely with devolved governments in doing that. Because as has been said in the contributions today, this affects all parts of the United Kingdom, so we need to work together.

Now, my predecessor, the honorable friend, the member for Glasgow South West, established a direct line with the Patient Safety Commissioner to start to drive this work forward.

And I think that was the right approach and I look forward to meeting Professor Hughes shortly. I am conscious that it has been more than two years since Professor Hughes published her report and more than five years since the Independent Medicines and Medical Devices Safety Review was issued by Baroness Cumberlege. And we know the lives of women, children and their families have been profoundly changed. Their voice must be heard as we address the issues with I think the urgency that is demanded. We must also...

08:14:23 - 08:15:03

James William Naish

I thank her very much for giving way and thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. My constituent Matthew Cox has Fetal Valproate Syndrome and this time last year he wrote to the Prime Minister. It took several months to get a response. He wrote again to Number 10 in March this year. I wrote to the Health Secretary in July this year.

There's been no responses, and the response that Matthew did receive, for someone with learning difficulties, was not an appropriate response. I wonder if she'd take Matthew's case away specifically and make sure that he does get the response that he's been looking for. He and his mum welcomed the hope that a new Labour government brought on this issue. It is really essential that we deliver for them.

08:15:03 - 08:16:53

Diana Ruth Johnson

Of course, I will take that away. And can I just say, as a Minister, I've made it very clear that we should respond in a timely way to, obviously, to Members of Parliament, but in other correspondence as well, and in a way that people can understand what is being said to them.

So I absolutely take that point. So just moving on I think I just want to make it clear that we are determined to build a system that listens that hears and that will act and we need to do that with speed compassion and proportionality. Madam Deputy Speaker as someone who has fought hard for the compensation that was due to the victims of the infected blood scandal I fully understand the strength of feeling on this matter and I can also appreciate the frustrations of the families and the campaigners. This is a complex and sensitive issue and it does require careful coordination across government. The support we offer to those who have suffered profound harm must be meaningful and responsive to their needs.

The government is clear that those affected have already waited far too long for answers. On the issue of financial redress. While a decision has not yet been taken to provide financial redress, my priority is to drive these discussions forward with greater urgency, while ensuring that any decisions we take are underpinned by a thorough assessment of the available options and continue to engage across government. Our discussions so far have considered the scope, the affordability, and the practical challenges of a redress scheme. I do want to just say a few words about non-financial redress.

08:16:53 - 08:17:15

Catherine Jane Smith

Yes, happy to. If with the minister's permission, I'd like to see some clarity because she's said that the decision has not yet been made and yet the previous Secretary of State for Health told ITV that the financial redress would be, he was expecting it to be by the end of this parliament.

So could you just clarify, that seems inconsistent to me.

08:17:15 - 08:17:43

Diana Ruth Johnson

My understanding of what the previous Secretary of State said was that he wanted to see progress within this Parliament. I'm very mindful of the recommendations of the Hughes report, which set out clear recommendations around redress, and I've just tried to set out that's the avenue I'm pursuing with some speed to look at what the options are. So I hope that answers the my honourable friend.

08:17:43 - 08:17:45

Speaker 273

Will she give way?

08:17:45 - 08:17:47

Speaker 274

Yes, I will do, yes.

08:17:47 - 08:18:28

Liz Twist

I thank the Minister for giving way, and I know from her work in the past that she would be very conscious of the issues here.

But can I just say, two years on from the Hughes report, which was very clear, we need to be acting. This is an important issue and it feels like a group of women, primarily, are being left to one side to wait their turn or wait their time. Can the minister assure me that she will be in the department making sure that we get a real answer on financial and other redress? I'm sure that she will be doing that, but we need to see some action.

08:18:28 - 08:19:01

Diana Ruth Johnson

I can fully understand and appreciate the frustration because it has been two years since the report was published. I will do my very best. I know that my predecessor, who's in her place, was also looking at what more we could do to speed matters up.

And I will give my undertaking to this House that I will do my very best to make sure that we make progress on this and all the recommendations in the Hughes report are, I can see, I can see my honourable friend wants me to give way and I'm very happy to.

08:19:01 - 08:19:53

Sharon Hodgson

Thank you, one last brief intervention if I may. I know my honourable friend is best placed with her experience of leading the contaminated infected blood campaign to be now in this position to deliver for all of these victims from mesh, valproate and maybe Primodos as well, although that wasn't in the Hughes report. One other thing if I may add to her list is around payments from big pharma to the health sector. They really do have to be disclosed.

At the moment they're ambiguous, misleading, there's lump sum payments that hide a multitude of payments. And does my honourable friend agree with me that to prevent these injustices in the future going forward, it is really time for the government to enact a statutory approach to payment transparency in the health sector?

08:19:53 - 08:22:02

Diana Ruth Johnson

Well, I'm very happy to discuss that with my honourable friend and see what we can do, but I'm very happy to take that away. Can I just deal with this non-financial redress point, because I think it's important this is also recognised, that people do need support now. And the department is working with the NHS to put in place a range of measures to support the women and the families alongside action to strengthen the safe prescribing of sodium valproate.

In February, on that second anniversary of the Hughes report, my honourable friend the Minister of State for Health set out how the department is addressing their needs by improving the clinical services and treatment that patients receive, commissioning further research and initiating long-term preventative measures. So I just wanted to update colleagues on those initiatives. First of all, on the improvements to services and treatment. Since 2018, the number of women that have been prescribed sodium valproate has gone down, although there is a cohort who have already been affected and require specific treatment. We must ensure that our healthcare system is shaped around their needs and their experiences.

Shortly after the government came into office, NHS England began operating the fetal exposure to medicines pilot service in hospitals in Manchester and Newcastle, which my honourable friend referred to.

This project is providing a multidisciplinary assessment, diagnosis, and treatment planning, and its findings will inform the way we do this at a national level. The proposed extension of the pilot project includes setting up a third site and an independent evaluation of the pilot, because we shouldn't be marking our own homework. This should give us the evidence we need to determine whether a nationally commissioned service could be implemented across England. This approach balances the need to improve support for affected individuals and families with the requirement to ensure that any future national service is evidence-based, clinically effective, and financially sustainable.

08:22:02 - 08:22:27

Bob Blackman

I thank the minister for giving way, and it's good news that she's considering a national proposal.

Will she undertake to have a meeting with the long-serving victims of this scandal who've been caring for their children for many years without support, to show her commitment and what needs to be done for those long-serving mothers who've been in such desperate times? I think she will learn quite a lot from such a meeting.

08:22:27 - 08:23:48

Diana Ruth Johnson

Of course I would. Of course, that would be something I would be very interested in doing and learning more. So yes, absolutely, and I'm sure my office will be in touch with the honourable gentleman about that. I just now want to just deal with the other two points I was talking about.

So on the second update on research and development, we are working with clinicians from the pilot and other experts to see how we can improve the services available to affected patients. And finally on prevention, NHS England and the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency have introduced strict measures to minimize valproate exposure during pregnancy, including pregnancy prevention programs and prescribing controls and specialist counseling for women who may become pregnant while taking the medication. So Madam Deputy Speaker, let me close by again paying tribute to all those families whose lives have been changed forever by sodium valproate and also the other measures, the other issues that were set out in the Hughes report around pelvic mesh too. I hope I've made clear this afternoon how determined we are to respond to the Hughes report with the urgency and the compassion that those families absolutely deserve.

08:23:49 - 08:24:19

Speaker 275

Now, before I put the question, I was travelling overseas when the tributes to the Clerk of the House were made earlier in the week. So I would just like to correct the Minister. The Clerk of the House cannot be very long-serving because he's clearly an incredibly young man and far too young to retire. But can I add my thanks to him for all the support and help he's given me in this role? And with that, the question is that this House do now adjourn.

As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. The ayes have it. Order, order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.