Fourth Delegated Legislation Committee

28 October 2026

Fourth Delegated Legislation Committee Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
15:30 - 15:38
Speaker 1
The draft Private Rented Sector Database Regulations 2026.  I call the Minister to move the motion. 
15:38 - 19:25
Speaker 2
Thank you, Mr. Wishart.  It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair.  I beg to move that the committee has considered the Private Rented Sector Database Regulations 2026.  In our manifesto, Mr. Wishart, we promised to overhaul the regulation of an insecure and unjust private rented sector.  Our transformative Renters' Rights Act 2025, which received Royal Assent on the 27th of October last year, delivered on that commitment. 

On the 13th of November, we published an implementation roadmap setting out our intention to switch on the provisions of the Act in three distinct phases.  The first phase, which entailed the introduction of the new tenancy regime, was implemented on the 1st of May this year.  We are now progressing with the second phase of our reforms.  This entails establishing a landlord ombudsman for the PRS to improve dispute resolution, settling issues between tenants and landlords without costly court proceedings, and introducing our innovative database of PRS properties to bring together key information for landlords, tenants, and councils.  These regulations concern the latter. 

They set out the registration framework for the database and are essential to enabling its rollout, which will commence regionally from the 15th of December.  The database will record information about private landlords and privately let properties in England. 

It will help landlords understand their obligations, give tenants better information before entering into a tenancy, and support local authorities with enforcement.  The service will be known publicly as Register Your Rental Property Service, but I'll refer to it as the database for the purposes of this debate.  The regulations before us determine how registering for the database will work in practice.  They cover who can make entries, what information must be provided, and how the database can be kept accurate over time and up to date.  Landlords will be required to make a landlord entry, which will include their name and contact information. 

Entries for organisational landlords will include information about the organisation and its management.  Joint landlords will share the dwelling entry for the property, but each will need their own landlord entry.  Landlords will be required to make a dwelling entry for each property, which contains information including its address, ownership, property type, rent level, and relevant management details. 

Once occupied, this must include tenancy and health and safety information, including uploaded certificates and information relating to gas, electrical, and energy performance information.  Landlords will be legally responsible for registration, payment, renewal, and compliance.  Under regulations, they may, however, delegate the supply of certain information to an agent or property manager to reduce administrative burden.  The regulations also allow entries to be made, updated, or renewed by certain third parties in discrete circumstances.  For example, where a landlord lacks capacity, or where a possession restriction is in place when a mortgage provider requires court order possession of an unregistered property. 

Entries will need to be kept up to date for an entry to be deemed active.  Recorded information will be treated as out of date where details no longer reflect the landlord, property, tenancy, or relevant compliance position.  They must generally be updated within 28 days.  Regulations give the database operator the ability to correct errors and remove entries that do not meet the requirements for inclusion. 

We will issue guidance on operational detail, including on verification of entries by local authorities.  Regulations require landlords to pay a fee to make or renew a dwelling entry.  The instrument does not set the fee, but does delegate this to the database operator.  The operator is required to set the fee by reference to the relevant costs as specified in the Act.  We've separately announced the fee as 65 pounds per property per year, pro-rated during initial rollout to ensure costs remain fair and those registering first aren't paying more. 

This is the first of two statutory instruments needed to implement the database.  Following parliamentary approval of this first instrument, rollout of the database will commence, as I've made clear, on the 15th of December this year.  Each region will be rolled out in one-month intervals.  When a region's registration window goes live, landlords will have three months to register properties in the region.  We've issued guidance showing the order and timings for this. 

19:25 - 20:08

Matthew Pennycook

All relevant entries are required to be made by the end of the 14th of November 2027. A second statutory instrument will cover the public-facing side of the database, the addition of specified breaches and offences committed by landlords, and further data sharing. We will commence this as soon as possible following completion of the initial rollout. This will concern what information is made visible to the public and wider data sharing arrangements. Those matters are therefore not in the scope of this regulation.

To conclude, Mr. Wishart, these regulations put in place the operational requirements needed to begin the rollout of the PRS database. They are a critical step toward a more transparent and enforceable PRS system, supporting compliance while giving tenants better information about the homes they rent, and I commend these regulations to the committee.

20:08 - 20:18

Peter Wishart

The question is that the committee has considered the draft Private Rented Sector Database Regulations 2026. I call the Conservative spokesperson, Gareth Bacon.

20:18 - 27:29

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Mr. Wishart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. In this case, I think it's my first time. I welcome the opportunity to sit opposite the Minister again and appreciate the remarks he has made in this debate. I also welcome this opportunity on behalf of His Majesty's Opposition to address this set of regulations.

Mr. Wishart, a fair, honest, and accountable private rented sector is important for landlords, agents, and tenants alike. I think there is no dispute in that. Indeed, any system concerning people's homes and property must be transparent. And from what I've heard, the providers in the private rented sector are broadly united in agreement on that point.

The National Residential Landlords Association have said, and I quote, "If designed well, the database should make it easier for landlords to demonstrate compliance with their obligations whilst empowering tenants to distinguish between responsible majority and the rogue and criminal minority of landlords." The Large Agents Representative Group said, and I quote, "With the correct design, it would make compliance easier to demonstrate for landlords and their agents, give tenants greater confidence about the homes that they rent, and provide local authorities with better information to target enforcement against those who fail to meet the required standards." However, with these regulations before us, the NRLA have described them as a costly mess. The idea of a national register is in itself not a disagreeable one. But the proposed implementation and structure of this database is alien to any common sense approach.

First and most strikingly, the government have designed the database with barely a fifth of the providers in mind. Landlords with a single property are responsible for just 21% of tenancies in England according to the 2024 English Private Landlord Survey. The other roughly four-fifths of tenancies are managed by landlords with more than one property, including some with thousands. Indeed, around one in five landlords hold nearly half of all tenancies. Mr Wishart, it's 2026, there is very advanced technology available, yet the government's proposals envisage manual uploading of each individual property.

These regulations as they stand here and now make no provision for bulk upload, forcing landlords into uploading properties one by one. Mr Wishart, Noah processed more animals onto the ark at a time than that. Each property requires circa 70 data points.

That's an awful lot of admin and a huge time implication, when much of the information required is already submitted to councils through the existing licensing schemes. The Large Agents Representative Group, representing some of the largest portfolios in the country through clients such as Chestertons, Hamptons, Knight Frank, Savills, and Foxtons, estimate that if it takes 10 minutes to register an individual property, as the government estimates apparently show, that means over 1,600 staff hours for a 10,000 property portfolio, and about 3,300 hours for the 20 minutes it actually expects it to take. But on that point, larger providers disagree with the government's estimate of the time to upload data, and the associated costs of uploading per property could be even longer. Assuming it takes 30 minutes per property, and that there are seven productive working hours a day, that amounts to 214 working days for a 3,000 home property portfolio, and 714 days for a 10,000 property portfolio.

And this is a long way from being the only problem with the proposed database. The regulations stipulate that landlords must start and end the registration themselves and agents can only supply certain information. This directly contradicts the government's own impact assessment which assumed agents would register on the landlord's behalf. Then there is the lack of an audit trail. Because of the system favored by the government, landlords have no ability to verify and validate data on a portfolio basis.

They have no access controls nor audit trail for data uploads, changes or deletions. The consequence of this is obvious: a heightened risk of exposure to administrative errors, consequent fines, which can range from £7,000 to £40,000, and a host of compliance and audit risks. Then we come to the crux of the subject of cost.

The Renters' Rights Act 2025 included in its impact assessment an estimated data registration fee of 28 pounds 85 per property every three years. Now the government have confirmed a fee of 65 pounds per property every single year, while the draft regulations require entries to be renewed every 12 months. For the 80% of landlords in the market that care for more than one property, this represents a significant and unplanned recurring cost. And no one in the sector knows where the figure of 65 pounds came from, nor how it can be justified, and perhaps the Minister in his closing remarks can provide a clear explanation of how that 65 pounds has been calculated. While the providers in the private rented sector are in broad agreement with the concept of a database, they are also united in viewing the approach of this government as a total disaster.

And none of the concerns I've outlined today should come as news to the government because they've all been raised directly with government officials by industry representatives. Many of those I've spoken to thought the government had heard their concerns and were making adjustments, only to discover later that they'd been ignored entirely. How does the government expect to earn or maintain the trust of the whole sector when they ignore the sector's concerns and blindside them with extra financial and labour costs? The Large Agents Representative Group have summed up the government's proposals by stating, and again I quote, "Instead of making best use of data already held across government and other established systems, the proposed approach requires landlords and agents to manually and repeatedly input and maintain information that in most cases is already available elsewhere, creating unnecessary duplication, administrative burden and risk of inaccuracy for all stakeholders."

The decisions being made now about its underlying architecture risk embedding unnecessary bureaucracy and practical problems from the outset. This is concerning when significant fees are being imposed and non-compliance carries substantial and lasting penalties. Mr Wishart, the significant additional costs and administrative burdens imposed by this approach are likely to have damaging repercussions. Voices in the build-to-rent sector, a sector vital to assisting in the delivery of new homes, have said, and I quote, "This will inevitably deter much-needed investment in new homes, particularly at this time of viability crisis." In conclusion, Mr Wishart, these are just a few of the significant issues shared with me by industry.

The database as proposed by the government is not fit for purpose. It is not good enough to impose something that everyone knows is not going to work just so that the government can claim that it is taking action.

These regulations represent the very worst of the government, hell-bent on regulating first and worrying about the consequences later. Empty promises of continuing improvements don't cut the mustard. A sector already saddled by over-regulation and tax hikes needs efficiencies, not even more constraints. So I implore the minister to pause the impending rollout of these regulations, which are due for implementation in just a couple of weeks' time, scrap the current proposals, and produce new ones after proper consultation with industry. Mr. Wishart, I say that more in hope than expectation, so the opposition will seek to divide and vote against these measures today.

27:29 - 27:32

Speaker 5

I now call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Gideon Amos.

27:32 - 31:19

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Mr. Wishart, and it's a pleasure to serve the committee with you in the chair.

I firstly will declare an interest as a registered social landlord. And we come at this from the Liberal Democrats from I think a different, somewhat different starting point than the official opposition in that we supported the Renters' Rights Bill Act and we also strongly supported the database of landlords as really important information, basic information that tenants should be able to have. So we've been consistent in supporting the concept of what's in front of us.

But, Mr. Wishart, the system that's been devised is nothing short of a fiasco and will undermine the whole purpose of the database and will, as well as being harmful in terms of, or at least challenging to say the very least, to landlords and damaging to their business operations, it will also frustrate tenants. Because if landlords need to spend this time, amount of time, updating a register one property at a time, imagine if you're an institutional landlord and you have 4,000 dwellings, one at a time can only be entered. This can take weeks and months, by which time the database will be completely out of date for tenants to look at it. So this, the problems of this database will not only affect landlords but will affect tenants as well. We desperately need build-to-rent landlords and more build-to-rent landlords to build more rented accommodation.

And a debate, there is a debate going on about the Renters' Rights Act and whether or not landlords have withdrawn from the market. And I don't intend to get into that debate in detail.

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation take a different view and say that there's, there's a certain amount of churn. But one thing is absolutely clear. The Renters' Rights Act is challenging the sector to a huge degree and causing a great deal of change and churn. The last thing that's needed right now is a database that for our biggest landlords is completely impossible to complete in any economic or efficient kind of way. And I'm grateful to the, to Real Estate UK for their briefing.

I make no apologies for reading out parts of what they have told me. For example, a single employee working through a 5,000-home portfolio would need 2,500 hours or around 312 and a half working days to upload. That has to be done every year, Mr. Wishart.

And then without any fee discount or integrative information provision process, then a build-to-rent landlord with a 5,000 unit portfolio can expect to spend around £378,000 a year on registering their properties. And furthermore, to comply both with selective licensing and the service, a build-to-rent landlord can expect to pay over £4 million across a 5,000 home portfolio. As the opposition spokesperson has pointed out, that the costs are above what was expected in at the time of the passing of the bill. It surely is not beyond the wit of government to produce a database where you can have multiple uploads and don't need to upload one at a time and a database more efficient than one we have at the moment where you cannot even copy across data from one property to the next. Even if you had 250 exactly the same, you have to enter each one individually without copying across any of the data.

So if the official opposition hadn't proposed to vote against, which it clearly is, we in the Liberal Democrats will be voting against. This is bad for the Renters' Rights Act, it's bad for tenants, it's bad for landlords, and it's bad for the build-to-rent sector that we need to support our housing market.

31:19 - 32:50

John Whittingdale

Oh, thank you, Mr. Wishart, and I won't detain the committee for long. However, I just want to say my honorable friend has made some excellent points, drawing on some of the information as has the Liberal Democrat spokesman supplied by the organizations representing those who are landlords with multiple premises. I would like to declare that I am a single landlord of a small one-bedroom flat in Westminster.

It already falls within the Westminster City Council selective property licensing scheme, which costs in the order of a thousand pounds and requires me to upload a great deal of information, all of which, as I understand it, is now going to be duplicated in this system. And I would like the Minister to explain how it is that this is going to provide additional information to tenants in those areas where it is already available through the local authority. And I have to say that the Liberal Democrat spokesman referred to the effect of the Renters' Rights Act, which I think has already increased the disincentives on landlords from going into the private rented sector.

And I've just listened to the Chancellor at some length explain to us why he is going to bring in better regulation and at the same time is going to commit to getting rid of homelessness. Both of which are admirable objectives which I share, but I'm not sure that this particular measure is going to help deliver either of them.

32:50 - 32:52

Speaker 8

Minister Matthew Pennycook.

32:52 - 38:11

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you very much, Mr. Wishart. I note, and I think it's the first time I've seen in this Parliament, the Liberal Democrats and Conservative Party in unison. But if you'll let me finish, given the Her Majesty's Opposition opposed the Act outright, I would not be surprised by their opposition to this measure. I am somewhat surprised by the Liberal Democrat Party's opposition to this particular measure, but I take the challenges on the various points in good faith.

Let me try and reassure honorable members about what we are trying to achieve here. Firstly, on how the data is uploaded, and just to make clear, it is not the case that each landlord needs to log on and upload the same information each year, starting from scratch. You only need to update the information if the information you have already entered has changed. Once the initial information has been uploaded, as I say, if it remains unchanged, you don't need to change it. We have explored options for enabling bulk uploads, something I pushed officials on.

I started from the same position that honorable members opposite did: can't we just allow bulk uploads? We have concluded, after looking into the issue in some detail with quite a significant amount of sector engagement, that due to significant challenges with data validation and error handling, traditional solutions such as uploading Excel files, which was one of the options that were put to us, would only add complexity for the user.

We are designing the service to be as straightforward as possible for landlords, including those with larger portfolios. To meet their needs, we'll be enabling organizations to add multiple employees to their accounts, enabling easier administration. And we are looking at how to make it easier for landlords, particularly those managing large portfolios, to connect their existing property management systems directly with the service and to create some efficiencies in that respect. And we'll look to provide a digital, a secure digital connection that landlords and their technology providers can choose to integrate with, reducing the need to enter the information manually to register their properties. And we will continue to explore opportunities to improve functionality and reduce burdens as the service develops.

I hope that that has answered some of the points raised to me about bulk data entry. Well, we are going to look to integrate the management systems of large portfolio holders in ways that will, specifically to the point put to me, does each large portfolio have to sit there and add in each entry once each every year? That is not the case. I'm trying to clarify some of the misconceptions that have been put to me in the interventions that followed. On selective licensing, and we debated this at length through the passage of the Act, selective licensing and the database have different purposes.

The database will not duplicate or replace selective licensing. We do recognize the important role that licensing can continue to play where it is used appropriately. The national database will provide consistent information about private landlords and rental properties across England, as I say, supporting transparency, compliance, and local authority enforcement.

We will, however, continue to review how licensing and the national service interact as implementation progresses, with a specific view to reduce duplication. I very much agree that in terms of the amount of information that's currently held when a selective licensing scheme is put in place, there are ways, I think, we can reduce the amount of information required for that once the database is in place. The shadow minister asked me why can't letting agents register on behalf of landlords. One of the key goals of the database is to improve landlord awareness and capability. Responsibility for ensuring that registration requirements are met will remain with the landlord throughout.

Letting and property agents will not have a mandatory role in registration and will not be separately registered through the service.

Requiring landlords to initiate registration ensures they engage with their legal responsibilities from the outset. We do, however, recognize that letting and property agents play an important role in supporting landlords to meet these responsibilities. And to reflect this, agents will be able to support landlords by providing certain information once the landlord has started the registration process. Again, come back to the point, the importance of the initial registration in this first phase of the rollout. Where an agent agrees, the landlord will be able to delegate the provision of specific tenancy health and safety information to them.

A series of points were put to me about the fee. The fee is set at £65 to fund a national service. It's fair, sustainable, and capable of supporting effective enforcement. I think the shadow minister has put to me on several occasions, as has the Liberal Democrat spokesman, the need to properly fund local authority enforcement in the private rented sector. Here we are with the means to do so.

Every landlord is required to pay the annual £65 fee for each property they register on the database.

As the fee is charged per property, landlords must pay each time they register a different property. As I say, the fee has been set in this way to balance fairness and sustainability for landlords with the cost of operating the service and tackling non-compliance in the private rented sector. And the shadow minister is absolutely right, the NRLA, other organisations are supportive of the database in principle because it will allow us to bear down on the unscrupulous landlords in the market that do much to colour the reputation of the good landlords that are out there. I'll give way. We'll give way to Mr. Ashworth.

38:11 - 38:47

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you, Mr. Wishart, and I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. In my constituency in Bridgwater in Somerset, there is a chronic shortage of rented accommodation. And I'm concerned that this expensive and cumbersome system will deter further private landlords renting their properties.

And if the Minister doesn't have a system that can have bulk uploads, he should tell his officials to think again, to go out into the private market and get a system that works. So he should scrap these regulations and tell his civil servants to think again.

38:47 - 39:16

Matthew Pennycook

I thank the honorable gentleman for that point. I don't think we need to think again because we are thinking about this issue, and I say to him again, we are exploring how we can make it easier for landlords, particularly those with managing large portfolios, to connect their existing management systems directly with the service and integrate them. So if they have a way—he shakes his head at me—but if they have a way of integrating their service in a way that provides for that faster upload, that is precisely what we are trying to look at already.

39:16 - 39:18

Speaker 10

I thank the Minister for giving way.

39:18 - 39:43

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Would it not be a better thing to do than to pause these regulations now then, explore that fully, and then come back once you've, sorry, once he has adapted the system so that can be incorporated? This comes back to the point I was making about regulate now and try and fiddle it later. It's not going to work and the large landlords are telling you, sorry, are telling the Minister, that it's not going to work. Why not just pause and work it out and then come back?

39:43 - 40:05

Matthew Pennycook

We're not going to pause, I say to the Shadow Minister, quite plainly, because we want the database in place. It has benefits for landlords in understanding their legal responsibility, it has benefits for tenants. This is the first of two statutory instruments as I've made clear. We think we can do that work and working with the sector to understand how we might integrate their management systems, we can do that with, and I'll give way and then I'm going to make some progress because the same point's continuing.

40:05 - 40:56

Speaker 11

I think, no, I think the Minister, I thank the Minister for giving way.

I formerly was a commercial property lawyer and I just want to bring a practical point about the enforcement. The ambition behind this I'm sure is very positive in terms of making sure that everyone has the information that they need and that tenants have that information. But there will be a practical reality because if these come in and these can't be enforced properly, it will actually then start to cause delays in the rental sector itself because it will cause problems. So I really do advocate that a pause would be very essential here because actually if you cannot gather that information, upload it in the time, if we're talking about potentially up to 10,000 properties, extremely large examples, that's going to take possibly nearly a year or more to get the information up. Have we thought through the knock-on impacts of this?

And I really do exercise caution from the practical reality of being on the other side as a lawyer back in the day.

40:56 - 41:37

Matthew Pennycook

We have thought through the implementation and we are confident we can proceed as we intend to do. No, I won't give way. I'm going to make some progress. On the fee, because I do want to come onto this point. Fees will support activity which identifies and acts on non-compliance with the Renters' Rights Act reforms.

The funding will support councils ensuring they have the staff and skills required to identify and tackle non-compliance and drive landlords who persist in breaking the law out of the sector. Fees will be pro-rated during the initial roll-out and this will ensure that landlords in regions required to register early are treated fairly. And I go back to my opening remarks, we are rolling this out on a regional basis from December this year. I think I've answered all the points put to me. Happy to give way to the honorable gentleman.

41:37 - 42:17

Gideon Amos

The Minister is very generous with his time as always. And he has indeed answered a number of the points and I give him that. But the point about the fees is that if millions of pounds are being paid by institutional landlords for this, then they should at least be able to expect a database that works.

Now, I welcome the fact the Minister said he's continuing to look at this. Could he go a smidgen further and commit now on the record that the government will ensure that bulk uploads can be achieved? Because that is the huge failure of this system.

42:17 - 43:31

Matthew Pennycook

I can't give him that commitment because we have looked into the practicality of bulk uploads, and we don't, in the way, in the terms he's put it to me, think that that is a workable solution. As I've tried to make clear at several points now, we are looking at how we can integrate the management systems of larger landlords into the database in such a way that does not require them to manually input each of their properties in the way that has been put to me in that debate. So we are looking for those efficiencies.

Why would we not look for those efficiencies? And just on his point about fees, I just really want to make clear it's not the government's intention to use the fees to fund wider costs that are not connected to the private rented sector, but some of the fees will be going on local authority enforcement. As we've debated on previous occasions, it is incredibly important that local authorities have the resources to properly enforce the act. But to conclude, Mr. Wishart, this instrument sets out practical steps required to deliver the PRS database. It sets the registration framework that landlords, local authorities, and database operator will follow.

In commencing rollout of the database, these regulations will support landlord compliance, strengthen local authority enforcement, and give tenants better information about the homes they rent, and I therefore commend them to the committee.

43:31 - 43:42

Peter Wishart

The question is that the committee has considered the draft Private Rented Sector Database Regulations 2026. As many as are of that opinion say aye.

43:43 - 43:44

On the contrary, no.

43:44 - 43:48

Speaker 13

No.

43:48 - 44:15

Speaker 15

Division. Lock the doors.

44:15 - 44:16

Gideon Amos.

44:17 - 44:19

Speaker 14

Jess Asato.

44:20 - 44:21

Gareth Bacon.

44:22 - 44:23

Sarah Bool.

44:24 - 44:53

Speaker 17

Mr Luke Charters? Aye. Mary Creagh? Aye. Samantha Dixon?

Aye. Sir Ashley Fox? No. Mrs Sarah Hodgson? Sharon.

Sorry, Sharon Hodgson. Aye. Alex Mayer? Aye. Tessa Munt?

No. Darren Paffey? Aye. Matthew Pennycook? Aye.

Nick Thomas-Symonds? Aye. Henry Tufnell? Aye. Laurence Turner?

44:53 - 45:14

Speaker 16

Aye. Sir John Whittingdale? No. The Ayes were 11 and the Noes 6. The Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.

Unlock. Order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.